THE
WONDER OF UFF
By
J. ARTHUR THOMSON, M.A, LL.D
Regiu.- ; \atural History in the University -.f A he* ice-
fSiJ .5 .bBoT .
KEW YO;*SJ
H !'0i,'l AVi> COMPANY
* vn^rw MELROSE LU;
FiG. 1 .The Drama of Life. (After Roesel.) 1. Stork with frog.
2. Tadpoles on weed. 3. Salamander. 4. Frog's Spawn.
5. Toad. 6. Lizard
THE
WONDER OF LIFE
B 7
J. ARTHUR THOMSON, M.A., LL.D
Regius Professor of Natural History in the University of Aberdeen.
Author of 'The Biology of the Seasons,' 'Darwinism and
Human Life,' 'Heredity,' 'The Study of Animal
Life,' 'Introduction to Science,' etc., etc
NEW YORK
HENRY HOLT AND COMPANY
LONDON: ANDREW MELROSE LTD
PREFACE
THE aim of this book is to illustrate the ever-growing
wonder of animated Nature with especial reference
to animal life. It is an unconventional introduction to
Natural History and Biology, taking broad views of the
actual lives of living creatures and working inwards. It
is therefore complementary to other books which begin
with the minute analysis of the individual. The author
hopes that it may be found useful in ' Nature- Study '
as a continuation of his Biology of the Seasons, and
that teachers of Zoology may recommend it to their students
as an introduction to the study of some of the problems
for the discussion of which our crowded curricula leave
little time.
Recent years have brought us a great increase of know-
ledge in regard to the haunts of life, such as the Deep Sea ;
periodic movements such as the Migration of Birds ;
adaptations and inter-relations ; animal behaviour, both
instinctive and intelligent ; the intricacy of life- histories
and the drama of organic evolution. It has been possible,
therefore, in this book to use many fresh facts and fresh
lights to illustrate and illumine old problems. The result
in the author's mind has been a strengthening of the con-
viction that the facts of life cannot, for biological purposes,
be adequately re- described in mechanical formulae. It
is hoped, however, that dogmatism has been successfully
avoided. The Wonder of Life must speak for itself.
Perhaps everything that lives would appear equally
wonderful if we knew enough about it ' the leaf of grass
no less than the journey work of the stars . . . the pis-
mire equally perfect the egg of the wren the tree-toad,
2054328
vi PREFACE
a chef tfoffuvre for the highest the narrowest hinge in my
hand and the mouse that is miracle enough to stagger
sextillions of infidels.' The author of a recently-published
admirable introduction to Zoology has used the motto
'Ev Traai yap rot? (frvaiKOis eveaTi ri Qav^a^TOv and
we could wish for no better, being equally persuaded of the
cosmic magic. ' Prais'd be the fathomless universe, for
life and joy, and for objects and knowledge curious.' It
is indeed altogether wonderful, but to different minds
different things appeal to one the way of the eagle in
the air, to another the meanest flower that blows. So we
have taken a wide sweep in our survey.
It is also true that science and age are ever changing
the focus of our wonder, for as Keats lamented, the rainbow
has never been quite the same since Newton looked at it,
and the sunbeam that used to steal through the shutters
and dance to our half -awed delight many years ago is
not quite such a wonder now. But new wonders have
taken the place of the sunbeams of our childhood, and so
it must always be for those who keep their eyes young,
that is to say, scientific. If the half-wonders go, the
wonder remains, and this the fundamental mysterious-
ness of Nature is what we meant our book in per-
formance so far short of our ambition to illustrate.
My thanks are due to Miss Shinnie for her skilful
illustrations, to the publishers for the considerate patience
with which they have borne delays enforced by profes-
sional duties, and to Messrs. Macmillan for their kind per-
mission to use Huxley's translation of Goethe's Aphorisms.
J. ARTHUR THOMSON.
MARISCHAL COLLEGE,
THE UNIVERSITY, ABERDEEN.
1914.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PAGE
PREFACE ......... v
INSTANCES OF THE WONDER OF LIFE . . . . ix
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS ...... xix
CHAPTER I
THE DRAMA OF LIFE ; OR, VITAL MOTIVES ... 1
CHAPTER II
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE ; OR, THE EXPLOITATION OF THE
EARTH ........ 54
CHAPTER III
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE ; OR, THE CIRCUMVENTION OF
SPACE AND THE CONQUEST OF TIME . . . .127
CHAPTER IV
THE WAYS OF LIFE ; OR, MODES OF ANIMAL BEHAVIOUR . 186
rii
viii CONTENTS
CHAPTER V PAGE
TH* WEB OF LIFE; OB, THE INTRICACY OP INTER-
RELATIONS ........ 263
CHAPTER VI
THE CYCLE OF LIFE ; OR, FROM BIRTH THROUGH LOVE TO
DEATH 371
CHAPTER VII
THE WONDER OF LIFE ; OR, THE CHARACTERISTICS OF LIVING
CREATURES 471
INDEX ........ 651
INSTANCES OF THE WONDER OF
LIFE
In Illustration of the Wonder of Life, the book tells of
PAGE
millions of insects on a glacier .... 7
the bustle of life on the heather .... 8
a cataract of birds and a great draught of fishes . 9
the floating meadows of the open sea ... 10
the animal census . . . . . . .11
twenty flowering plants on a patch of turf . . 11
the vultures gathering to the carcass . . . .14
a spider's web ........ 14
a fish that spits at insects . . . . .15
a spider binding a grasshopper hand and foot . . 15
the skua forcing herring gulls to disgorge their fish . 16
the land -leeches falling from the branches . . .16
a mosquito milking an ant ..... 16
a python's extraordinary meals . . . . .17
a fish swallowing a fish larger than itself . . .17
frigate-birds exploiting boobies ..... 20
birds of prey thinning bats ..... 22
cannibal Rotifers 23
sea -cucumber entangling lobster. .... 25
a fish that fishes 25
butterflies with protective repulsive odours . . 25
the garment of invisibility in flat-fishes ... 30
the chamseleon's colour-change ..... 30
the leaf -butterfly effacing itself 31
the two kinds of mimicry . . . . 32, 33
young mantises like ants ...... 34
a crab masking itself with a sponge . . . .35
a lobster masked with seaweed ..... 36
x INSTANCES OF THE WONDER OF LIFE
PAGE
the pistol crab as a tailor 36
self-advertisement among animals 36
the chamaeleon's ruse 39
the soap-bubbles of cuckoo spit ..... 41
experiments in bipedal progression ..... 43
a jet of blood from the horned toad's eyes ... 47
the fire-fly's courtship ....... 49
the male Rhinoderma with eggs hi his croaking-sacs . . 50
paternal care in hornbills . . . . . .51
beetle -pets kept by ants ....... 52
the shifts for a living on the sea -shore 62
sea slugs secreting dilute oil of vitriol .... 62
a fight between starfish and sea-urchin . . 63
cannibalism in a molluscan cradle ..... 65
paternal care among shore animals ..... 70
the male stickleback's nest ...... 70
the male lumpsucker's care of the eggs .... 70
the multiplication of palolo-worms ..... 71
how Ctenophores escape the storms ..... 74
open-sea insects ........ 76
transparent animals ........ 78
animal life in the great ' deeps ' 83, 87
a strange, dark, cold, calm, silent, monotonous world . 87
trawling at a depth of over three miles .... 87
the ceaseless rain of small organisms from the surface to
the abysses *'..',.'. 88
the absence of microbes in the deep sea . . . .88
long stalks and long limbs in deep-sea animals . .90
abyssal fishes ' tumbling upwards ' . . . .91
an extraordinary blind cuttlefish from the abysses . . 92
bright colours in a world of darkness .... 94
iridescence seen on lakes ....... 102
three million Rotifers to the square yard .... 104
the linkage between mussels and minnows . ' . . 106
the linkage between bitterlings and mussels . ' '. ' . 106
water-fleas surviving desiccation for nine years . . . 107
a leech surviving two days' imprisonment in ice . . 109
organisms of the dwarf-plankton which pass through the
finest pilk gauze. . . ; . . . . 110
the circulation of matter: how the world goes round. . 110
INSTANCES OF THE WONDER OF LIFE xi
PAGE
the strange deep-water fishes of Lake Baikal . . .113
eighty seeds from a clodlet on a bird's foot . . .114
water animals which do not get wet . . . .115
the water -spider's sub-aquatic nest . . . . .116
fishes out of water . . . . . . .118
the golden age of earthworms ...... 122
caves as refuges for weaklings ...... 123
various solutions of the problem of flight .... 124
many different kinds of ' swooping ' Vertebrates . .124
the flights of gossamer spiders ..... 126
productivity of fishes, rats, rabbits, etc. .... 130
a starfish with 200 million eggs 133
fourteen species on one stone . . . . . .135
red snow ......... 135
spider living in a pitcher-plant ..... 137
nets made by caddis -worms 138
the Penelope spider . . . . . . . .141
the Antarctic fauna ....... 142
desert vegetation ........ 144
rock-boring animals ....... 145
climbing fishes ........ 145
adaptations of aquatic insects ...... 147
frogs in salt water . . . . . . . .148
nesting of the White Tern 149
remarkable nest of a tree-frog 150
a mouthless carp 150
extraordinary tenacity of life 152
life of tissues and organs excised from the body . . 153
stinging by a decapitated wasp ..... 153
the Big Trees, over 2,000 years old 154
the habits of the land-crab 157
skates in fresh water ....... 158
the summer sleep of mud -fishes . . . . .160
turning white in winter ....... 162
the Ruffed Grouse beneath the snow . . . .162
the migration of birds . . . . . . .163
the Arctic Tern in the Antarctic circle . . . .165
the return of a swallow to its birth-placo . . . 171
flying at the rate of 100 miles per hour .... 174
the power of way-finding in birds ..... 180
xii INSTANCES OF THE WONDER OF LIFE
PAOI
the migration of the Pacific Golden Plover . . .182
the behaviour of newly hatched turtles .... 192
movements keeping time with the tides .... 196
the behaviour of young chicks 207
lapwing's call-note heard from within the egg . . . 209
instinctive behaviour of larval Sphex-wasp . . . 209
sucking instinct of newly-born pig ..... 209
effective first flights of young swallows . . . .210
first webs of young spiders . . . . . .211
Calicurgus wasp disabling a spider . . . . .212
Ammophila wasp bruising caterpillar's head . . . 212
Fabre's experiments with Sphex wasp . . . .213
foraging and warfare among Black Termites . . . 218
unique tactics of Black Termite soldiers .... 222
young moorhen's instinctive diving ..... 224
young buzzards excited by first sight of adder . . . 225
wild traits in tame animals ...... 226
remarkable limitations of instinct ..... 227
procession caterpillars going in a circle .... 228
shortness of memory in caterpillars ..... 228
instinct of lemmings to go straight on .... 229
feigning death, at various levels ..... 230
bluffing enemies, as it seems to us . . . . .231
homing in ants and bees 233
evidence of a sense of direction in bees .... 234
local memory in limpets ....... 235
crabs masking themselves with seaweed .... 236
association of sensations in dogs and fishes . . . 242
association in hermit-crabs ...... 245
the trial and error method 246
behaviour of the dancing mouse 247
plasticity of instinct 253
thinking horses of Elberfeld 255
birds essential to the habitability of the earth . . . 266
Nature as a vast system of linkages .... 267
connexion between sea -gooseberries and fisheries . . 268
connexion between fishes and malaria .... 269
consequences of introducing mongoose into Jamaica . . 269
fauna and flora of birds' feet 272
distribution of seeds by ants 272
INSTANCES OF THE WONDER OF LIFE xiii
PAGB
inter-relations of mussels and minnows .... 273
inter-relations of bees and flowers 275
pollination of the fig 280
ambrosia 282
inter-relations of a pitcher -plant 283
inter-relations of ants and plants ..... 285
shelter-associations among animals ..... 290
relations between fierasfers and sea-cucumbers . . . 290
partnership between painted fish and sea-anemone . . 293
commensalism of hermit-crabs and sea-anemones . . 294
symbiosis of Algse in animals ...... 295
the double nature of lichens ...... 297
partner microbes ........ 299
the adaptations of parasites ...... 302
grouse-disease 303
the extraordinary life-history of the liver-fluke . . . 307
the story of Sacculina 309
the story of ox-warbles ....... 310
the production of galls 312
the formation of pearls 313
habits of the cuckoo ....... 315
the gregariousness of fiddler-crabs 324
division of labour among ants 326
tailor-ants using larvae as needle and thread . . . 328
a primitive form of ant-society 331
division of labour among Termites ..... 333
reserve ' kings and queens ' among Termites . . . 334
signalling among Termites ...... 336
economy of the bee-hive ....... 339
hive-bees nesting in a tree 340
evolution of social bees 341
year's life of humble-bee 343
nest of a wasp ........ 345
animal societies 345
viscacha villages ........ 350
domestication of aphides by ants ..... 351
guests and pets of ants ....... 352
slave-making among ants ...... 354
the relations of birds and insects ..... 359
house-flies as distributors of disease . . 359
xiv INSTANCES OF THE WONDER OF LIFE
PAGE
rats, rat-fleas, and plague Bacilli 364
yellow fever and the Stegomyia mosquito .... 365
the importance of the white heron ..... 366
the fate of the passenger pigeon ..... 366
the correlation of organisms in the web of life . . 368
the various curves of life ...... 373
the development of the egg ...... 375
development of a fraction of an egg .... 378
many embryos from one egg ...... 379
the ripening of the egg 381
the fertilization of the egg 382
artificial parthenogenesis ....... 383
a remarkable case of hybridization ..... 389
the development of nerve-fibres ..... 390
the distinctiveness of organic growth .... 398
internal secretions in relation to growth .... 399
organisms of unlimited growth ...... 401
structural registration of growth ..... 402
regulation of growth ....... 404
the meaning of youth ....... 408
the play of animals . . . ' . . . .408
courtship among animals ....... 410
combats of males ........ 412
significance of courtship-behaviour ..... 415
habits of sea-lions 416
fragrance of butterflies . . . . . . .416
audible signalling on the part of a male moth . . .417
post-matrimonial cannibalism ...... 419
parental care 420
paternal care ......... 422
the remarkable behaviour of the bee-hunter . . . 425
habits of dung -rolling beetles 426
brooding insects ........ 427
over two thousand feathers from the nest of the long-tailed tit 427
the tabula rasa of the young bird's brain . . . 430
the chain of parental instincts .- . . . . 431
the prevalence of other-regarding activities . . . 433
longevity of animals ....... 435
a centenarian tortoise ....... 436
the different kinds of death . 439
INSTANCES OF THE WONDER OF LIFE xv
PAGE
the immortality of the Protozoa ..... 440
rarity of microbic death among wild animals . . . 441
the general occurrence of violent death in Nature . . 441
alternation of generations in hydroids .... 444
life-history of a jelly-fish ...... 445
remarkable larvae of Echinoderms ..... 446
story of horse-hair worms ...... 447
life -history of barnacles ....... 448
life-history of the shore-crab ...... 451
life-histories of May-flies, gnats, moths .... 452
a glimpse of a Parthenopeia ...... 457
the degeneration of Ascidians ...... 458
the story of the salmon . ...... 459
the development of the frog ...... 460
different forms of life-curve ...... 464
the story of niners . ....... 464
the efficiency of the living creature as an engine . . 473
the insignia of life ........ 474
an amoeba's pursuit of its prey ..... 477
paste-eels surviving desiccation for fourteen years . . 483
seeds germinating after eighty-seven years . . . 483
white blood corpuscles remaining alive outside of the body for
four and a half months ...... 486
the puzzling phenomena of luminescence .... 487
the physiology and psychology of sleep .... 494
the remarkable phenomenon of anaphylaxis . . . 501
the chemical individuality of the organism . . . 507
the specificity of the blood ...... 509
the living creature as a bundle of adaptations . . . 510
the adaptations of the mole 518
Venus's Fly-Trap and its 'memory' .... 520
snow shoes of the Ruffed Grouse ..... 521
an extraordinary egg-carrying adaptation in a male fish . 522
an egg-eating snake, Dasypeltis ..... 523
Aristotle's lantern ........ 524
eyes that shine at night ....... 525
adaptations before birth ....... 527
the remarkable eyes of Anableps ..... 528
warm-bloodedness in birds and mammals .... 530
the ptarmigan's heart, adapted to the mountains . . 532
xvi INSTANCES OF THE WONDER OF LIFE
PAGE
the immunity of hedgehog and some other mammals to
snake poison ........ 532
the wealth of colouring in the animal kingdom . . . 534
the partnership between Convoluta and an Alga . . 535
pigments as waste-products, reserve-products, and by-products 536
the ripple-marks of growth 536
the internal uses of pigmentation ..... 538
the protective value of coloration ..... 539
an insect protected by its meals ..... 542
the plasticity of the Msop Prawn 545
coloration expressing nervous rhythm .... 546
warning colours among animals ..... 548
recognition-marks and guide-marks 549
the significance of the rabbit's white tail .... 549
the decorations of the mouth in some nestlings . . . 549
the peacock's tail 550
a starfish regrown from a single arm .... 555
portions of minced sponge regrowing a whole . . . 557
regeneration of a stork's bill ...... 562
regeneration of a newt's lens ..... 363, 570
an antenna regrown instead of an eye .... 569
the same result reached by different paths . . . 569
the regrowth of a snail's horn, including the eye . . 571
great steps in evolution . ' . . . . . 575
the first making of a ' body ' . . . . . . 576
the beginning of bilateral symmetry .... 576
the gradual emergence of nobler forms of life . . . 577
the first finding of a Vertebrate voice .... 578
the steps of progress made by Amphibians . . . 578
the fitness of the environment to be a home of life . . 579
the method of organic evolution, trial and error . . 582
the mystery of variations ...... 584
the tactics of Nature 586
new things made out of very old things .... 586
altering the ' time ' of a vital tune 588
the optimism of pathology 589
trading with Time 591
registration without memory ...... 592
blindness following imprisonment in darkness . . . 593
a remarkable experiment with water-fleas ., . " . . 597
INSTANCES OF THE WONDER OF LIFE xvii
PAGE
development considered as akin to recollection . . . 602
peach-trees becoming evergreen. ..... 602
remarkable experiments with nurse-toads .... 604
the possibility of germinal experiment .... 606
the living past 606
man's body as a museum of relics 607
the vestigial hind-limbs of whales 608
the pineal body, sometimes an eye 609
a two-toed horse . . . . . . . .611
the stability of the germ-plasm ..... 612
a persistent relic in shrews ...... 613
the third eyelid in man ....... 614
the egg-tooth of young birds ...... 616
the hairs of whales ........ 618
living fossils, such as Sphenodon ..... 620
a quadrupedal young bird, Opisthocomus . . . 620
conservatism in evolution ...... 621
the amoeboid growth of nerve-cells ..... 622
the distinctiveness of vital activity ..... 624
the regulation of bodily functions ..... 626
the complexity of everyday life ..... 627
various examples of animal behaviour, all requiring historical
explanation ........ 628
the migration of eels 630
development transcending mechanical categories . . 635
the continuity of evolution ...... 631
the achievements of man's reason ..... 649
Liesegang's rings ........ 643
the fundamental mysteriousness of Nature. . . . 648
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
(BY ELIZABETH L. SHINNIE)
FIG. PAGE
1. The Drama of Life. After Roesel . . Frontispiece.
2. Extinct bipedal Reptile, Iguanodon. After Dollo . 4
3. Scorpion holding a fly. After Lankester . . .13
4. Web of Garden Spider 14
5. Garden Spider 15
G. Deep-sea Fish, Chiasmodon. After Giinther . . 17
7. Spectacled Cobra striking. After Fayrer . . .19
8. Noctules on an old tree . . . . . .21
9. Figwort with pupa-cases of a beetle ... 29
10 and 10A. Protective coloration of Flatfish. After
Sumner Plate 30
11. Leaf Butterfly, Kallima Plate 32
12. Spider like an ant. After Peckham ... 34
13. Lobster masked with seaweed. After Williamson . 36
14. Rattle of rattlesnake 37
15. Starfish regenerating lost parts. After Mclntosh . 39
16. Frilled Lizard running like a biped. After Saville Kent 43
17. Frilled Lizard at bay. After Saville Kent ... 44
18. Horned Lizard or Phrynosome. . . . Plate 46
19. Shore scene in the Mediterranean . . Plate 58
20. Egg-capsules of dog-whelk 65
21. Free-swimming larva of a starfish, Luidia. After
Mclntosh 67
22. Starfish, Leptoptychaster, with young ones. After
Challenger Report 68
23. Nest of stickleback 69
24. Animals on sea-grass. After Issel . . . Plate 72
25. Open-Sea Insect, Halobates. After Buchanan White 76
26. Jellyfish, Dactylometra. After Agassiz and Mayer Plate 76
27. Deep-sea Crinoid, Metacrinus . . . Plate 82
28. Abyssal Pycnogonid or Sea-Spider. After Loman . 84
29. Three long-stalked Pennatulids .... 89
30. Deep-sea Brittle Star. After Koehler ... 90
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
PIG. PAGE
31. Deep-sea Cuttlefish, Cirrothauma. After Chun . Plate 92
32. Two Deep-sea Fishes 95
33. Three species of water-flea, Cyclops. After Neubaur
Plate 104
34. A piece of gauze used in tow-netting. After Lohmann 108
35. Organisms of the Dwarf -Plankton. After Lohmann 110
36. Nets made by larval caddis-flies. After Wesenberg-
Lund Plate 138
37. Section through a land-crab. After Semper . . 157
38. Mudfish, Protopterus, in its summer-sleep. After W. N.
Parker 160
39. Young spiders moving around the nest. AfterHoesel . 211
40. Worker Termite. After Bugnion .... 216
41. Worker Termite. After Bugnion and Popoff . . 218
42. Soldier Termite. After Bugnion and Popoff. . . 220
43. Insect in cataleptic state. After Schmidt. . . 231
44. Bird-catching spider catching a humming-bird Plate 242
45. Ctenophore or Sea-Gooseberry. After Mayer . . 268
46. Acacia twig tenanted by ants. After Schimper . . 286
47. Association of Hydractinia, whelk, and hermit-crab . 288
48. Fierasfers entering and leaving Holothurians. After
Emery Plate 290
49. Colonial Radiolarian with partner Algae. After Brandt 295
50. Green Hydra expanded and contracted . . . 296
51. Stages in life-history of Liver-Fluke. After Thomas 308
52. Section of a pearl. After Rubbell. . . . Plate 312
53. Shell of Freshwater Mussel with pearls. After Rubbell
Plate 314
54. Leaf-cutting ants at work. After Moeller . . 326
55. Section of nest of Humble-Bee. After Wagner. . 343
56. Nest of wasp. After Janet 345
57. Mosquito, Anopheles. After Nuttall . . . 363
58. Egg of Ascidian. After Duesberg .... 375
58 A. Segmentation of the Egg of a Frog. AfterBles . . 376
59. Chain of Embryos from one Ovum. After Marchal 379
60. A dividing Cell, showing chromosomes. After Haecker 380
61. Diagram of a Cell 387
62. Male spiders fighting. After Peckham . . . 412
63. Male spider dancing. After Peckham . . . 413
64. Female spider with cocoon. After Blackwall . . 421
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS xxi
FIG. PAGE
65. Sea-Horscs, Hippocampus. After Anthony . . 422
66. Lumpsucker, Cyclopterus ..... 424
67. Emperor Penguin and Young. After Wilson . . 428
68. Life-history of a Hydrozoon. After Allman . Plate 444
69. Free-swimming Larva of a Sea-Cucumber . . 446
70. Free-swimming Larva of a Sea-Cucumber . . 446
71. Life-history of an acorn-shell, Balanus . . . 449
72. Life-history of a Jellyfish, Aurelia. After Bronn . 450
73. Larva and Pupa of a Gnat. After Hurst . . 453
74. Life-history of Death's Head Moth . . . Plate 454
75. Metamorphosis of the Eel. After Schmid. . Plate 456
76. Male Edible Frog 462
77. Marine Lampreys making a Nest in a River . Plate 466
78. Diagram of a Phosphorescent Cell. After Watase. . 488
79. Remarkable Deep Water Fish, Lamprotoxus. After
Holt and Byrne 493
80. Flounder with pigmented under-side. After Cunningham 513
81. Leaf-insects. Phyllium. . . . Plate 518
82. Head of Male Kurtus, carrying eggs. After Weber . 522
83. Mermaid's Purse of Dogfish 527
84. Head of Cassowary. After Rothschild and Keulemans
Plate 536
85. Two Spiders with Protective Resemblance. After
Vinson and Pickard- Cambridge 540
88. Umbronia, Insect like a Prickle . . . .541
87. Chromatophore from a Prawn. After Degner . . 544
88. Bright Colours of Littoral Animals . . . Plate 550
89. Hydra with eight heads. After Roesel von Rosenhof . 552
90. Regeneration of pieces of Stentor. After Gruber . 554
91. Comet Form of Starfish. After Richters . . .560
92. Wing and Wing-Bones of Penguin. ^4/terPycraft . 587
93. Vestigial hip-girdle and hind-limb of Whale. After
Struthers 608
94. Pineal Eye of Slow-Worm. After Hanitsch . . 609
95. Pineal Eye of Embryo Spheriodon. After Dendy . 610
96. King Crab, Limulus 619
97. Peripatus. After Balfour 620
98. New Zealand Lizard, Sphenodon . . . .621
99. Neat of Hornet. After Janet . . . Plate 628
100. Liesegang's Rings. After Liesegang . . . 643
CHAPTER I
THE DRAMA OF LIFE
(VITAL MOTIVES)
'Sbe performs a plag; we fcnow notwbetber sbe sees it
berself, ano yet she acts for us, tbe lookers-on. . . /
4 1ber mecbanism baa few springs but tbeg never wear
out, are always active ano manffolo. . . .'
'Gbe spectacle of IRature is always new, for sbe is always
renewing tbe spectators. 5Life is ber most ejquisite inven*
tion ; ano oeatb is ber expert contrivance to get plenty of
life/
Goethe's Aphorisms, translated by Huxley.
Succession of Players Progress of the Drama Primal Impulses
One Great Problem Abundance of Individuals Number of
Species Variety of Form Variety of Bread-Winning The
Struggle for Existence Thrust and Parry Many Inventions
Intricate Situations In Illustration : Cuckoo Spit The Case
of Horned Lizards Love-Scenes Family Life Complications
Retrospect.
? I ^0 many observers of living creatures it has seemed
JL as though they were being allowed to see just a little
of a complex and long-drawn-out drama. All the world
is the stage, on which, without any fall of curtain, scene has
succeeded scene since life began. The stage is crowded,
in spite of its spaciousness, and everywhere we see repeti-
tions of the same episodes and situations on different scales.
Here there is a scene among birds, and there the insects
2 THE WONDER OF LIFE
show the same as if in miniature. What the mammals
are acting is being caricatured by the amphibians ; and so
it appears all round, as if one were in a multiplying-mirror
show. It is like a world of echoes.
Succession of Players. The stage is crowded with
actors and actresses who always appear to be artistic in
their proper setting or scenery. Some are on the boards
as individuals for minutes, like some of the microbes ; some
for hours, like some midges ; some for days, like the adult
and aerial phases of May-flies or Ephemerids ; some for
weeks, like the house-flies ; some for months, like the
humble-bees ; some for years, like the eagle ; some for
centuries, like the Californian Big Trees ; but all in turn
yield to Time's tooth. So automatic, however, is the suc-
cession among the short-lived creatures which it is permitted
to any one of us to observe, that no gap is ever apparent.
There is always an understudy ready to fill the vacant place.
When we lengthen out our vision scientifically we see,
however, that in spite of the apparent sameness there is
continual change, and that one cast succeeds another
as age follows age. Many great actors of superlative
merit, like the Sea-Scorpions, the Giant Saurians and
the Flying Dragons, have altogether ceased to be, and
have left no direct successors at all. Nor has their
mantle fallen on any. The play goes on, but the players
change.
Progress of the Drama. The age-long drama, whose
progress, or, it may be, merely changeful sequence, is called
Evolution, was aptly likened by Samuel Butler to the
development of a fugue, ' where, when the subject and
counter-subject have been announced, there must thence-
forth be nothing new, and yet all must be new. So through-
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 3
out organic nature which is a fugue developed to great
length from a very simple subject everything is linked on
to and grows out of that which comes next to it in order
errors and omissions excepted '. ' And yet all must be
new ', for it would not be a drama if it did not develop, and
it would not be life if it were not creative. The Aristotelian
maxim that there is nothing in the end which was not also in
the beginning, is true if we believe that in the beginning was
the Logos. Otherwise it requires safeguarding. For while
individual development is the expression or realization of
the given inheritance, it is a self-expression that can only
come about by trafficking with the environment, and may
greatly enrich itself in so doing. And similarly, through
the ages, the evolving organisms have been trading with
Time, and thus ' all must be new '.
Beyond doubt the most impressive fact about animate
nature is the ascent of life. It has gone on, reaching from
step to step in a manner for which we have no word but
progress. Its historic movement, as Lotze finely said, is like
that of an onward-advancing melody. It is a fact that
nobler and finer forms of life have appeared on the world's
stage as one geological period has succeeded another.
The bodies of animals have become more complex and
more controlled, that is to say in technical terms, more
differentiated and more integrated. The life of the creature
has escaped more and more from the thraldom of the
environment. We instinctively think of a bird as the
emblem of freedom. There has been an increasing ampli-
tude in life, as is evident when we compare birds and
mammals with amphibians and fishes, or insects and
spiders with sea-urchins and medusae. There has been, it
appears to us, an increasing liberation of the Psyche ;
4 THE WONDER OF LIFE
there is more and more behaviour as we ascend, and we
may even discern the springs of conduct.
It must not be supposed, however, that the history
discloses any straightforward progress, for it is full of
retrogressions and of strange culs-de-sac. The tapeworm
FIG. 2. Extinct bipedal Reptile, Iguanodon mantelli, about 12 feet
high. The genus is restricted to the Wealden (Cretaceous). (After
Dollo.)
is as much a product of evolution as the bird, and is as
well adapted to its inglorious lot as the lark to heaven's
gate. There have been extraordinary failures, too, in the
sense that many extinct types of great perfection have
left no direct descendants. We do not know that their
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 5
particular excellences have in any way passed into those
who continue the march, except in the very indirect sense,
perhaps, that Man, for instance, is the stronger because of
his early antagonists like the Cave Lion and the Cave Bear,
who have long since ceased to be.
In the history of life we may recognize, with Bergson,
three main lines of evolution. (I) There is the vegetative
line, followed by plants, and in great measure by such
animals as hydroids and corals. (II) There is the in-
stinctive line, followed especially by the chitin-clad small-
brained Arthropods (Crustaceans, Insects, Spiders, and the
like). (Ill) There is the intelligent line, followed more
especially by the Vertebrates, where an internal skeleton
of bone usually takes the place of the Arthropod's external
skeleton of chitin, and where the cerebral part of the
nervous system attains high development. A Calif ornian
Big Tree, two thousand years old, may represent the
climax of I ; an ant the climax of II ; and a man the
climax of III.
Primal Impulses. What in this world-fugue is the
subject and what the counter-subject ? There can be
little doubt that the answer must be Hunger and Love.
These are the two primal impulses.
Warum strebt sich das Volk so, und schreiet ?
Es will sich nahren, Kinder zeugen, und sie ernahren so gut
es vermag.
These words ' hunger ' and ' love ' must not indeed be
used woodenly ; they correspond to self-preservation and
race-continuance, to self-regarding and other-regarding,
to nutrition and reproduction, to self-increase and self-
multiplication, to feeding and flowering, and so on. It is
6 THE WONDER OF LIFE
well understood that while Charles Darwin's grandfather
wrote a book about The Loves of the Plants, it is not
particularly useful for us to employ such a phrase. Never-
theless, it is entirely sound science to emphasize the
fact that rich as plants are in adaptations which secure
food, they are not less rich in adaptations which secure
the nurture and dispersal and development of their off-
spring.
One is tempted sometimes to say that the primal impulse
of organisms even before hunger and love is self-
assertion, self-expression, and insurgence. But these big
words are all covered by the little word ' life '. For life
is activity, effective activity, regulated activity, self-asser-
tive activity. If we start with this postulate, we may
then say that the mainsprings of an organism's activity
may be summed up in the words ' hunger ' and ' love ',
the imperious motive forces of life.
One Great Problem. As we contemplate the drama,
both as we can see it with our eyes, and as we can see it
with the help of telephotic apparatus (such as a palaeonto-
logical museum !), we may discern that, in spite of all the
variety, there is one perennial problem and endeavour,
namely, to adjust relations between the active, self-asser-
tive, insistent, insurgent organism and the inert, indifferent,
heavy-handed environment. Living has often been de-
scribed as action and reaction between the organism and
the environment, but this is not quite adequate. The facts
of the case have been better stated by Prof. Patrick Geddes.
On the one hand, the Enviroment acts upon the organism,
burning it and stoking it, heating it and cooling it, quicken-
ing it and slowing it, moistening it and drying it, exciting
it and quieting it, and so on. The organism being acted
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 7
upon, the relation may be formulated as E-*>f -* o (the first
letters of the words Environment, function, and organism).
On the other hand, the Organism (to which we may now
give the capital letter) not only reacts, it acts. It hits
back ; it thrusts ; it operates upon its environment. The
environment being acted upon, the relation may be formu-
lated as 0->f->e. The real business of life is an adjustment
0^-f^e
of the twofold relation : = f ; and that is what we see
E^f-o
continually going on in the drama of life.
Abundance of Individuals. We have spoken of the
crowded stage, and the prodigality of life is certainly
one of its characteristics. Antarctic explorers have told
us that in one haul of the dredge in those icy waters
it was quite a usual thing to get from ten thousand
to thirty thousand specimens of a certain Crustacean.
On the surface of the small pools of water on the
melting ice of the mer de glace at Chamonix, M. Vallot
found in 1912 an extraordinary multitude of a rather
rare wingless insect, the ' glacier flea ', Desoria nivalis.
These minute and primitive forms occurred over a
stretch of glacier twenty metres broad by two thousand
metres long, and there must have been forty millions of
them !
The heather on the moor, with its firm leaves and appar-
ently clean twigs, does not suggest itself as a crowded home
of life, but that is just what it is, as Dr. Shipley found in
searching for grouse-parasites. He adopted the method
of soaking the heather in water and then centrifuging the
infusion, with the result that an extraordinary wealth of
little creatures was discovered. He gives a striking picture
of what would appear if we could see a square yard of
8 THE WONDER OF LIFE
the moor through a gigantic lens, magnifying a hundred
times :
' The heather plants would be as tall as lofty elms, their
flowers as big as cabbages, the grouse would be six or seven
times the size of ' Chantecler ' at the Porte St. Martin ;
creeping and wriggling up the stem and over the leaves,
and gradually yet surely making their way towards the
flowers, would be seen hundreds and thousands of silvery
white worms about the size of young earthworms. Lying
on the leaves and on the plant generally would be seen
thousands of spherical bodies the size of grains of wheat, the
cysts of coccidium [a minutely microscopic Protozoon
parasite] ; and on the ground and on the plants, as large as
split peas, would be seen the tapeworm eggs patiently
awaiting the advent of their second host. It is perhaps a
picture that will not appeal to all, yet it represents what,
unseen and unsuspected, is always going on upon a grouse
moor.' [The Grouse in Health and Disease, 1911.]
It may be said that the naturalist has beyond all others
a discipline in the fine art that Blake spoke of as grasping
infinity in the palm of the hand. Even about the dry
twigs of the heather, there is a bustle of life.
Sometimes we get an impression of the prodigal wealth
of life with overwhelming convincingness. Describing a
visit to a Lapland bird-berg, the nesting- place of guillemots,
razor-bills, and puffins, the naturalist Brehm wrote :
* The whole hill was alive. Hundreds of thousands of
eyes looked upon us as we intruded. From every hole and
corner, from every peak and ledge, out of every cleft,
burrow, or opening, they hurried forth, right, left, above,
beneath; the air, like the ground, teemed with birds.
From the sides and from the summit of the berg thousands
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 9
threw themselves like a continuous cataract into the sea
in a throng so dense that they seemed to the eye to form
an almost solid mass. Thousands came, thousands went,
hundreds of thousands swam and dived, and yet other
hundreds of thousands awaited the footsteps which should
rouse them also. There was such a swarming, whirring,
rustling, fluttering, flying, and creeping all about us that we
almost lost our senses. . . . The cloud of birds around us
at the summit was so thick that we only saw the sea dimly
and indefinitely as in twilight. . . . The millions of which
I had been told were really there.'
Speaking of the dense swarms of haddocks and the like
which throng at the spawning time into the Norwegian
fjords, the same naturalist says :
' Animated, almost maddened, by one impulse, the fish
swim so thickly that the boat has literally to force a way
among them, that the overweighted net baffles the com-
bined strength of the fishermen or breaks under its catch,
that an oar placed upright among the densely packed crowd
of swimmers remains for a few moments in its position be-
fore falling to one side.'
Perhaps this final touch is exaggerated, but the general
impression has been verified many times in the lochs in the
West of Scotland.
The prodigal abundance of larger forms of life implies
the still greater abundance of small fry, for all are linked
by nutritive chains. It is in the open-water of lake and
sea that we get our best impressions of multitudinousness.
At the spring maximum of the Rotifer or Wheel- Animalcule
called Synchceta, there may be about three millions to a
square yard of lake ; at the summer maximum of the slimy
io THE WONDER OF LIFE
Alga, Clathrocystis ceruginosa, there may be 500 millions
to the square yard ; at the autumn maximum of a well-
known Diatom Melosira varians, which has a summer
maximum as well, there are about 7,000 millions to the
square yard, so that the waters of the lake form a veritable
living soup. Perhaps, outside of Bacteria, this is near the
climax of productivity.
The same exuberant productivity is equally characteristic
of many tracts of the open sea, where a vessel may steam
for days through floating meadows, several feet deep, of
simple vegetation mostly consisting of unicellular Algae.
Thus clusters of threads, called Trichodesmium, may collect
on the surface in calm weather, like unmelting yellowish-
brown snowflakes, and extend over many acres. In an
ordinary sample from a warm part of the Atlantic and
from a depth of 50 metres (which is the most densely
peopled zone as far as plants go), there are likely to be
about 5,000 plant-cells in a litre ; but there may be as
many as a quarter of a million, which is a prodigious
exuberance of life.
Number of Species. There might be great abundance
of life and yet no conspicuous variety, but every one
knows that the number of different kinds of animals and
plants is far beyond what we can readily conceive. Aris-
totle recorded about 500 animals, but a single expedition
nowadays may still discover more than a thousand new
species most of them rather small deer we must admit.
We are amazed at the number of stars which we can see
definitely on a clear night, perhaps four thousand alto-
gether, but there may be more species in one family of
insects.
In the small island of Britain there is a record of the
THE DRAMA OF LIFE n
occurrence of about 462 different kinds of birds, and the
total number of living species of birds may be safely
estimated at not less than ten thousand.
Dr. Gadow, writing in 1898, estimated the number of
recent species of Vertebrate animals at 24,241. He put
Mammals at 2,702, Birds at 9,818, Reptiles at 3,441, Amphi-
bians at 925, Fishes at 7,328, and primitive Vertebrates
at 27. But it is when we pass to the Invertebrates that
the numbers of species mount up so enormously. Thus an
authority on Diptera has put the probable number of
species at a hundred thousand, and there is no doubt that
there are many times more species of insects than of all
other animals put together. Dr. Sharp remarks that
though the largest insects scarcely exceed in bulk a mouse
or a wren, ' yet the larger part of the animal matter existing
on the lands of the globe is in all probability locked up in
the forms of Insects '.
The same authority estimates the number of named
species of insects at 250,000 ; and suggests that this is only
about a tenth of the total. It has been estimated that
there are about 200,000 plants, of which about a half are
Dicotyledonous Flowering Plants. But even more im-
pressive is Darwin's record of finding twenty species of
Flowering Plants in a patch of turf four feet by three ;
or the finding of four hundred in a square mile.
Variety of Form. There are not very many main styles
of architecture among animals, but there is endless variety
in detail. All the Vertebrates are obviously reducible to
one style of architecture, but what contrasts there are be-
tween eagle and whale, between tortoise and snake, between
eel and skate, between frog and newt, between swift and
penguin, between weasel and giraffe, between minnow and
12 THE WONDER OF LIFE
man, and so one might continue for a long time. Among
Invertebrates, the unicellulars or Protozoa form a sub-
kingdom by themselves ; the Sponges and Stinging Animals
ring the changes on the possibilities of radial symmetry ;
Worms present a bewildering variety of types with little in
common save the general tendency to be ' worm-like ' ;
Echinoderms, though a very well- defined series, show aston-
ishing contrasts, between brittle-star and sea-urchin,
between the sausage-like sea-cucumber and the graceful sea-
lily. The two other great series are the Arthropods and the
Molluscs, sharply contrasted at almost every point. Among
Molluscs we may compare oyster with cuttlefish, slug with
nautilus, land-snail with ' sea-butterfly ' ; it is difficult
for the ordinary observer to understand on what grounds
such dissimilar forms can be united under one title. Simi-
larly, the exceedingly successful Arthropod series, rivalled
only by the Vertebrates, includes Crustaceans, Centipedes,
Insects, Spiders, Scorpions, Mites and many other very
divergent types. If we consider Crustaceans, we get the
same impression, water-fleas and lobsters, fish- lice and
land-crabs, sand- hoppers and barnacles what a variety of
form ! The crowning illustration is surely among Insects,
where within a relatively narrow range we find an astonish-
ing wealth of style, the squat bug and the lank walking-
stick insect, the heavy beetle and the dainty midge, the
butterfly and the flea, the mosquito and the cockroach. It
has also to be remembered that there are many less familiar
types of animal life which represent quite distinct lines of
their own, such as Rotifers, Polyzoa, and Brachiopods,
which greatly increase the range of diversity of forms.
Variety of Bread -Winning. In illustration of variety
of habit, let us recall for a moment the variety of food-
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 13
getting among birds the blackbird gobbling the belated
worm in the early morning, the thrush making a ' kitchen-
midden ' of snail shells, the humming-bird sipping nectar
from the flowers, the oyster-catcher jerking the limpets
off the sea-shore rocks, the woodcock probing for earth-
FIG. 3. A Scorpion, Euscorpius, holding a fly in one of its claws, or
pedipalps, and piercing it with its sting. (After Lankester.)
worms among the mould, the stately heron fishing by the
side of the stream, the eagle in low flight searching the
mountain-side for grouse, the secretary-bird striking the
snakes in the South African karoo, the cross-bill deftly
tearing up the cones on the fir trees.
It seems certain that vultures and the like discover their
prey by sight and not by smell. Sometimes they seem to
keep definite ' preserves ' in the sky, and when one sees the
carcass and descends upon it, his neighbour in the next
' preserve ' follows suit, and another and another as the
news passes through the heavens. A fine picture of this is
given in Hiawatha
' Never stoops the soaring vulture
On his quarry in the desert
On the sick or wounded bison,
THE WONDER OF LIFE
But another vul-
ture, watching
From his high
aerial look-out,
Sees the down-
ward plunge
and follows,
And a third pur-
sues the second,
Coming from the
invisible ether,
First a speck and
then a vulture
Till the air is dark
with pinions '.
And then
it, comes the
blinding poetic
R flash-
'So disasters
come not
55
FL
singly '.
There are
humdrum ways
of getting food,
which the
grazing herds
illustrate. But
FIG. 4. Web of Garden Spider. The spinner how often this
makes first the strong foundation-lines (FL).
Then the rays (B) are made. Third, a non-
viscid primary spiral (PS) is formed, as a
scaffolding, from the centre outwards. . , , .
Fourthly, this is replaced by the viscid dramatically!
secondary spiral (ss), which is the genuine JjJverV one has
web, made from the outside inwards. '
heard of the
Archer or Spitting Fish (Toxotes) of Malay, which shoots
s e l
is solved
THE DRAMA OF LIFE
from its mouth a long jet of water and with accurate aim
secures a coveted insect which was sunning itself on the
plants overhanging the stream. The larva of the ant-lion
digs a funnel-like pit in the sand and lurks at the foot to
seize small insects that roll down ; and the larval Cicindela
makes a vertical tube, ' in which he props himself like
a chimney sweep climbing up a chimney ', so that his
head forms a lid on the level of the ground. M. Henri
Coupin describes the procedure :
' When a little creature is about
to pass over this veritable living
trap the larva sinks down, at
the same time dragging with
him his victim, which he hastens
to seize between his claws and
to devour '. Spiders' webs and
snares illustrate another method
which has often its detailed
subtleties. Thus M. Coupin
refers to Vinson's discovery of
the use of a strong silken string
bent in zigzag in the middle of the
web of a Madagascar spider, which makes a construction
very much like that of the common Epeira diadema of our
gardens. The cable must be of use, for if it be removed it
is at once replaced by another, but what can its use be ?
The answer was forthcoming one day when Vinson saw a
large grasshopper jump into the web, and saw the spider
hastily seize the cable and wind it round the unusual
victim, who was too big to be held by the usual fine threads !
There is such an embarrassing number of strange ways of
getting food that it is difficult to pick and choose, some
FIG. 5. Garden Spider,
Epeira diadema, female.
16 THE WONDER OF LIFE
lurk like the crocodiles, some act burglar like the ant-eater
bursting into the termitary, some hunt in packs and some
alone, some utilize what others have won. Thus in the
North of Scotland it is not an uncommon sight to see a
Skua gull (Stercorarius) chivying herring gulls in the air
until they disgorge their last caught fish. It is an astonish-
ing fact that this should be sometimes re-caught by the
skua before it reaches the water. What a long gamut
there is between the behaviour of these skuas and the land
leeches in the tropical forest ! ' Only too frequently ', says
M. Coupin, ' one hears a sudden noise like hail falling on the
branches. It is not falling hail, but leeches, which hasten
to attach themselves to beasts of burden and to men, from
whom they proceed to suck the blood. They were watching
[sic] their chance, perched on the branches an odd
dwelling-place, by the way, for creatures that are generally
considered aquatic '.
We have referred in " The Biology of the Seasons " to
Jacobson's extraordinary story of a mosquito milking an
ant. For that is what it comes to. The mosquito frequents
certain trees in Java on which the ants (Cremastogaster
diformis) go to and fro. It hails a passing ant and strokes
her head with quick movements of fore-legs and antenna.
Perhaps it tickles, perhaps it massages the ant who can
tell ? It seems to please her anyhow, for she emits a drop
of juice which the mosquito sucks up. The mosquito
has been named Harpagomyia splendens by de Meijere,
who points out that the creature cannot bite. But to
beg it is not ashamed. Jacobson found two other
Dipterous insects in Java which seem also to have learned
how to tap ants. These extraordinary inter-relations
recall the well-known but very remarkable fact that
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 17
several species of ants keep Aphides or green flies as their
cows (vacccB formicantm as Linnaeus said), utilizing the
sweet fluid which they exude when they are stroked.
The ants take some care of the Aphides and resent inter-
ference with their property.
Milking ant or aphis is dainty feeding ; contrast it with a
python's meals. A specimen of Python reticulata, about
25 feet long, which was observed in Hagenbeck's zoological
garden, swallowed a swan of 18 Ib. and two days later a
roebuck of 67 Ib. Another swallowed within two days
two roebuck of 28 Ib. and 39 Ib., and soon thereafter a
chamois of 71 Ib. In another case a goat of 84 Ib. in
weight was engulfed, and took about nine days to digest.
The pharynx can be dilated to a width of over a yard.
After a meal the pythons remain inert, and it should be
>noted that although they often eat much, they do not need
to eat often ! Two of them remained in good condition
from spring to November without eating at all.
The voracity of some of the Deep- Sea Fishes goes beyond
FIG 6. A Deep-Sea Fish (Chiasmodon r.iger), whose distended stomach
contains a larger fish. (After Giinther.)
C
i8 THE WONDER OF LIFE
bounds. Thus it is recorded that the first specimen of
Melanocetus johnsonii, obtained from off Madeira, had
engorged another fish about twice its own length. Dr. Gill
writes : ' The extensibility of the jaws and connected
parts as well as the dilatability of the cesophagus, stomach
and integuments enabled the captor fish to accomplish
this feat ' after which it took a bait and was caught.
Another curious fish, Linophryne lucifer, from the same
locality, came to be known by coming up to surface, hoist
on its own petard, having swallowed another fish longer
than itself.
The Struggle for Existence. As we watch the drama
from year to year we see ever-recurrent situations. The
dramatis personae may be different, but the situation is
the same. Among the most familiar of these situations
are the various forms of ' the struggle for existence ',
which we use as a formula to include all the ways in which
living creatures react to limitations : Animals get hungry,
they seek their food, they endeavour to catch what often
endeavours not to be caught, they compete with others
who endeavour to catch the same elusive prey, they have
also to keep an eye on those who are seeking to catch them
while they are trying to catch something else ; and mean-
while they have to struggle to keep their foothold amid the
storm of the careless physical environment. There are
also struggles for mates and for the safety of offspring.
Which of these endeavours is the struggle for existence ?
Each and all. For the real meaning of the phrase is to be
found, not in picturing this or that kind of struggle or
endeavour, but rather in the general idea of living organisms
asserting themselves against limitations and difficulties,
partly no doubt due to their immediate competitors of the
THE DRAMA OF LIFE
same kin or even family, but by no means restricted to this.
It is important to realize the variety of ' struggle '-
from a life and death competition around the platter of
subsistence to a persistent and peaceful endeavour after
well-being. It may be for foothold, for food, for mates,
or on behalf of the
family. It may be
(1) between fellows
of the same kind,
(2) between foes of
quite different
kinds, or (3) be-
tween organisms
and their physical
surroundings, i.e.
between Life and
Fate. In insisting
on this multiplicity
of ' struggle ', or
reaction against
limitations and
FIG. 7. Spectacled Cobra, Naja tripudians,
in the act of striking. The animal
grows to a length of 5 feet. (After
Fayrer.)
difficulties, we are
keeping close to
Darwin's own meaning, for he wrote :
' I should premise that I use this term [' struggle for
existence '] in a large and metaphorical sense, including
dependence of one being on another, and including (which
is more important) not only the life of the individual, but
success in leaving progeny.'
Let us take a few illustrations to show the variety of
' struggle '. The competition between antagonistic species
20 THE WONDER OF LIFE
and indirectly between members of the same species is
vividly pictured in an account which Mr. Dean C. Worcester
gives of a recent visit to Cavilli Island, one of the Philip-
pines. The actors were the red-legged boobies (Sula
piscator), related to the British gannet, and the frigate-
birds (Fregata aquila).
' Just before dusk, as we were leaving for the steamer,
we witnessed an extraordinary scene. Large numbers of
red-legged boobies which had apparently been fishing all
day, began to return, bringing fish to their nesting mates
and to their young. The frigate-birds promptly formed a
skirmishing line, and, singly or in pairs, attacked all comers,
compelling them to give up their fish. Some of the boobies,
possibly sophisticated individuals which had learned wis-
dom by experience, actually handed their fish over to the
frigate-birds and so escaped without much drubbing, but
less experienced or more obstinate individuals, which at
first refused to disgorge, were vigorously punished until
they changed their minds and threw up their fish which
were most adroitly caught in the air by their piratical
enemies. In one instance, two frigate-birds set upon a
booby, one of them attacking him from above, and the other
flying below to catch the fish which he dropped, and getting
five out of seven. Soon the incoming boobies began to
arrive in flocks, and the frigate birds were not able to set
upon them all, so that many individuals got through to
the island. Once among the trees they were left in peace.'
Captain A. R. S. Anderson has given us a dramatic picture
of an extraordinarily keen, though somewhat one-sided,
struggle between birds and bats. The scene is in the Far East
by the banks of the river Salween, where lime-stone rocks
rise for some 250 feet, and are bored by caves and orna-
mented by Buddhistic sculpture. The human tenants are
JT IG . 8. Large Bats, Noctules, Vesperugo noctula, clustering on an old tree.
21
22 THE WONDER OF LIFE
long since sped, and the caves are the home of legions of
bats. As the sun is setting a couple of falcons come over
the hill and fly restlessly to and fro over the river, keeping
a watchful eye on the mouths of the caves. Then kites
and jungle crows gather together till there are about a
hundred. The dramatic moment is at hand. Out comes
a single bat, then a pair, in puzzling jerky flight, eluding
the birds of prey, who are too experienced to be led off on a
profitless pursuit. There is a pause for a minute or two,
then a sudden rush of wings is heard, and the nightly sortie
begins. Like smoke from a dirty chimney on a stormy
day, the bats issue in a dense column, ten feet wide by ten
feet deep, in hundreds and thousands, so closely packed
that many are jostled into the river below. The falcons,
kites, and jungle crows have now their innings ; they fall
upon the sortie and, striking right and left, soon obtain all
they want. But the enormous majority of the bats escape
safely into the after-glow. It seems likely that the cease-
less sifting process is automatically regulated, else the
relatively weak and slowly reproducing race of bats would
long since have come to an end. Bats have such an unpre-
dictable kind of flight that they are very difficult to catch ;
when the birds reduce their numbers so that the crowd is
no longer closely packed, the nightly percentage of victims
will fall. It will no longer pay the birds to hunt them,
and there will be a close time till the numbers rise again.
A New Jersey naturalist describes a great host of mos-
quitoes, which were pursued and thinned by a large army
of dragon-flies, which were being in turn destroyed by a
big flock of birds. Similarly in mankind, while one tribe
is destroying another a more civilized power often bears
down upon the conquerors. We have referred elsewhere to
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 23
Mr. Hudson's very instructive picture of a wave of life in
South America. Fine weather and many blossoms ; many
flowers and many bees ; many bee-grubs and many mice ;
multitudes of mice and a thronging host of birds of prey.
Diets are changed, habits are changed, numerical propor-
tions are changed ; and then the season suddenly changes,
and everything collapses with terrific mortality into a new
position of equilibrium.
Rotifers, or Wheel-animalcules, are microscopic, but the
struggle for existence is as keen as among rats. Most eat
single- celled plants and animals ; some pierce the cells of
Algee and suck out the living matter ; and some swallow
other Rotifers whole. Mr. C. F. Rousselet, whose beautiful
microscopic preparations of Rotifers are deservedly famous
both in Europe and America, has told us of the cannibalistic
voracity of Ploesoma hudsoni, which seems actually to
have a predilection for its own kith and kin. ' Of all
Rotifers this is the most vigorous swimmer ; it rushes
through the water at great speed, snapping at any other
Rotifer that conies in its way, carrying it in its mouth
and devouring it without a moment's pause '. ' The
attacking individual snaps at and holds on to its victim like
a bull- dog ', it pierces the skin and sucks up the soft parts.
One of Mr. Rousselet's slides showed three of these ' atro-
cious cannibals ' : ' the anterior individual is being carried
in the jaws of its captor, whilst the latter has been caught
a moment later by a third Ploesoma, intent on devouring
both '. We have here a good instance of the frequent
intensity of the struggle for existence.
Thrust and Parry. We get a side-light on the struggle
for existence when we observe the prevalence of armour
and weapons, and all manner of defensive and offensive
24 THE WONDER OF LIFE
devices. We say ' armour ', and we see armadillos in their
bony mail, giant sloths with shields an inch in thickness,
tortoises almost invulnerable, scale-clad fishes, molluscs
in their shells, crustaceans and insects within their strong
chitinous cuticles, sea-urchins bristling with heavy spines
like hedgehogs, the stage is full of men at arms.
We think of ' weapons ', and what a collection rises into
view, from the microscopic stinging threads of the jelly-
fish and the Portuguese man of war to the tusk of the male
narwhal, ten feet long, from the forceps of crabs to the
antlers of stags, from the stings of bees to the fangs of the
cobra, from the lashing tail of the sting-ray to the sword
of the sword-fish, from the strangling arms of the octopus
to the talons of the eagle !
But stopping an endless catalogue, let us take three or
four instances of the quaintness of methods of offence and
defence.
In the case of the common nettle, the sting is effected by
specialized hairs, each of which shows a bulbous base with
glandular cells, a slender stalk with a duct running up it,
and a sharp-pointed ' cap ' at the end of the brittle tip. The
sharp tip pierces the skin, and in breaking off there effects
an injection of the poisonous secretion. In the hair of
the Chilian nettle (Loasa) there is no cap to the hair, the
tip is sharp-pointed and like a curved needle.
A very curious means of defence is seen in a number of
Holothurians, or sea-cucumbers, which discharge long
glutinous threads, or ' Cuvierian organs ' from the posterior
end of the body. In Holoihuria nigra, the Cuvierian organs
are white conical bodies which are protruded posteriorly,
when the creature is irritated. They remain attached by
their bases to the animal, but elongate into long glutinous
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 25
tubes which become disconnected. The elongation is due
to internal fluid pressure and is always preceded and accom-
panied by a rise of pressure in the fluid of the body-cavity.
A lobster of considerable size may be bound hand and foot
with these threads of the ' cotton spinners ', as some
of the Holothurians are called, a quaint instance of an
animal with a highly developed nervous system being
ensnared by the retaliations of a creature which has not
a ganglion or nerve-centre in its whole body. How dim
its awareness of the situation must be !
As Dr. Theodore Gill observes, the capture of fishes by
a lure began long before man acquired that art, it was
evolved among fishes themselves. The angler (Lophius
piscatorius] has a dorsal fin- ray turned into a rod and line
and dangling bait. ' It needs no hook, for the bait
attracts a victim sufficiently near to be seized upon by the
sudden leap of the angler '. The dangling of the bait is
quite automatic, and the device probably began fortuitously,
but the angler is very alert. In some Deep-Sea anglers there
is, in addition to wormlike baits, a phosphorescent bulb
or lantern which is perhaps seductive.
Many butterflies, especially from warm countries, have
the power of exhaling a repulsive odour. Dr. P. A. Dixey
mentions Acraea, Euploea, and Papilio as genera among
which this property is common. ' Musty straw, stable
litter, rabbit-hutches, acetylene, bilge-water, these are some
of the substances to which the odours of these unsavoury
butterflies have been compared '. The odour may be
distributed from patches of specialized scales or hairs, or
from the general wing surface, but never from plume-scales
such as distribute the delicate flower-like perfumes. More-
over the scents occur in both sexes and may be stronger
26 THE WONDER OF LIFE
in the female. There is much actual evidence that the
repulsive odour protects the butterflies from insect-eating
enemies. Dr. F. A. Dixey notices that many of them are
conspicuous, slowly-flying forms, given to courting obser-
vation rather than to avoiding it. They trust to their
repulsiveness.
' Moreover since it is well recognized that the preservation
of the life of the female is more important than that of the
male for the welfare of the species, we should expect that
if there is a difference between the sexes in the intensity of
the odour, that difference would be in favour of the female.
This, again, is borne out by observation in a number of
cases. Where both sexes are repulsive, the female, as a
rule, is the more repulsive of the two, and therefore (as a
consolation) the safer from attack.'
Many Inventions. In the higher reaches of the animal
kingdom we find examples of deliberate device the cat
watches for the mouse, or the fox for the rabbit, the ele-
phant bides his time and has his revenge after many days,
the wolves encircle their victim and close in upon him ;
wits are pitted against wits in the battle of life. At lower
reaches we find instinctive inventions which work extra-
ordinarily well, but which do not seem to require any
deliberate control. It is possible that they are suffused
with awareness, but their efficient performance depends
on the inherited organization of the nervous system. The
insect ' feigning death ' is certainly not consciously trying
to efface itself ; the crab that covers itself with a disguise
of foreign objects is not clear as to its own device (we
shall discuss the case later on), for it has been known to
put on a transparent cloak with which the experimenter
provided it. In many cases, doubtless, intellectual pro-
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 27
cesses which have their seat in the higher centres of the
brain may come to the aid of the inborn instinctive pro-
cesses which are localized in lower centres. And apart
altogether from intelligence and instinct there are many
striking cases of what may be metaphorically called suc-
cessful inventions or ' shifts for a living ', which depend on
structural peculiarities of the organism gradually perfected
through the ages. Without seeking to analyse at this
stage, we wish to notice some of these life-saving and life
furthering adaptations of structure and behaviour, which
it is one of the charms of Natural History to discover. Just
as in the human drama we see disguise and mask, imitation
and bluff, underhand devices and clever escapes, so it is
in the animal world, though the psychology of the matter
is in most cases entirely different.
Over and over again in the history of animal life the
situation has been saved by some thorough change (which
doubtless took time to effect) in habitat or habit. The
earthworms, springing probably from an aquatit stock,
discovered the subterranean world, and must have enjoyed
a prolonged golden age beneath the ground, until centipedes,
burrowing beetles, and eventually moles came to trouble
them in their deep retreats. A temporary prosperity must
have likewise rewarded the invasion of the air by insects,
until flying reptiles, birds, and bats discovered the secret
as well ; or the adoption of a marine habit by the ancestors
of our modern Cetaceans, Pinnipeds, sea-turtles, and sea-
snakes. What success must have rewarded the birds'
discovery of migration, or the hibernating mammals' very
different device of evading the hardships of winter ! In
hundreds of different ways, at point after point, life has
saved the situation by a change of tactics.
28 THE WONDER OF LIFE
A general resemblance to surroundings is often life-
saving, and one must not be in haste to exclude the possi-
bility that some animals actively seek out the surroundings
with which they best harmonize. With certain backgrounds
a woodcock or a curlew upon its nest fades into its sur-
roundings and becomes practically invisible, just as does
the brown lizard on the sand, the green snake among the
branches, the transparent arrowworm in the sea, the
mountain hare among the snow, the hare on the ploughed
land, and one might fill a page with good examples.
It has been noticed that a grey donkey in a field at night
may be quite invisible at a distance of a few yards, though
the noise of its cropping is very distinct. On a night with
diffused ground light, when cows were visible at a distance
of eighty yards, a donkey was quite invisibla at eight. It
is probable that his lighter under-surface served to diffuse
what light there was. A careful observer writes :
' On his starboard quarter at four yards distance, his dark
head appeared as a moving blur, but " stern on " at that
distance he was completely invisible an " airy nothing "
though, like Polonius, " at supper ". It was most extra-
ordinary to hear the animal feeding and to be unable to see
a vestige of him.'
There is an interesting moth, the Golden-Eight moth
(Plusia nwneta), which during the last half-century has been
spreading westward and southward from its Russian head-
quarters. Its first appearance in Britain was in 1857 ; a
great invasion occurred in 1890 ; since then it has diffused
itself over England. It is called ' Golden Eight ' because
of the markings on its golden-grey wings. When it is at
rest, however, it puts on the mantle of invisibility and
THE DRAMA OF LIFE
29
strongly resembles a dead
and dry leaf still attached
to the stem. Mr. Charles
Nicholson writes :
c
' The front legs are
stretched out straight in
front of the head at a right
angle to the axis of the
body, the second pair of legs
being pressed close to the
body, while the last pair
just hold to the support,
almost, or quite, covered
by the tips of the fore
wings which just touch
beyond the body, the FlG - 9. Piece of Figwprt, Scro-
moth appearing to be
clinging to its support by
the front legs and wings
only. It falls to the
ground when touched.'
phularia nodosoa, with pupa-
cases (c) of a beetle, Oionus
scrophularice, with a marked
superficial resemblance to the
fruits (F).
The value of the protective coloration may be enhanced
when it is associated with a power of colour- change, when
the animal, within certain limits, can adjust itself to the
particular hue or even pattern of its surroundings. This
is extraordinarily well illustrated by many of the flat-fishes,
of the plaice, flounder, sole series, which can adjust the
shade and the pattern of their upturned surface so that
they become practically part and parcel of the sand or
gravel on which they are resting. It appears that the
colour of the surroundings first affects the eye, then the
brain, then the sympathetic nervous system, then the
30 THE WONDER OF LIFE
spinal nerves to the skin, and finally the state of con-
traction of the pigment cells just below the surface. Any
one may see a lemon-sole, for instance, putting on its gar-
ment of invisibility. Until one catches sight of its eyes,
it seems to be completely lost in its background. The
invisibility is sometimes further ensured by a dusting of
sand, but it is remarkably complete without that.
It may be explained that the outer skin or epidermis
of fishes is delicate and transparent. All the colour is in
the dermis, and it usually occurs in remarkable pigment-
cells or chromatophores. These typically show numerous
radiating processes, and the pigment can be spread out
to the periphery or concentrated in the centre, according
to the expansion or contraction of the mobile protoplasm
of the pigment-cell. According to the pigment which
they contain black, yellow, red, and so on the pigment-
cells are called melanophores, xanthophores, erythrophores,
and so forth. Then there are other cells containing spangles
of the waste-product guanin, which are called iridocytes or
guanophores. They cause the silvery, metallic, or iridescent
appearance familiar on many fishes. Professor Ballowitz
has recently discovered, in the Weaver and some other
Bony Fishes, a new kind of chromatophore, consisting of a
group of cells a cluster of iridocytes with an encapsuled
central melanophore which sends its ramifying process
through the capsule in complicated courses.
The story goes that a chameleon, whose power of
colour-change is famous, reached the limit of its capacity for
* sympathetic coloration ' when it was placed in a tartan-
lined box. It soon died, with a pained expression of baffled
adaptability, but some of the achievements of flat-fishes
in the way of harmonizing with their surroundings do not
FIG. 10. Flat Fish, Rhomboidichthys podas. After resting for two
or three days on fine gravel. (After Sumner.)
FIG. 10A. Flat Fish, Rhomboidichthys podas. After resting for
three days on the spotted background. (After Sumner.)
.9**ft*1
ti ***** jrf con-
ta* fturiiww, Any
tvfetancr. putting on its gar-
'; catebvtf agiit of it eyes,
; -*r ite background. The
; *urt4*r easored by a dufliiug of
ow} iol gniJ
ft no 8yb
t^. - ..r,t All the colour is in
ha -f-rr(arkablc pigment-
-iily show numerous
' can be spread out
j> thr centre, according
\r,- ..f
the pigment which
-r i. *ttBw. ri. andao oo the pigment-
- > -j -^bi?na, xAtir-hoplivres, crythrophores,
.-M are other c-el is .-;.:
u. which au> ca!'
ii.;- . j iivet-y. u
T- many fishes.
in the Weaver and some other
;if chroinatophore, consisting of a
.'fiboq
$e power of
.
: an-
vements of fiat-fisheg
.urroundings d<>
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 31
fall far short of the tartan standard. We have inserted
two illustrations which show how extraordinarily close the
approximation may be.
The protective value of a colour-resemblance between an
animal and its surroundings is probably increased when the
form and pose of the creature is like something else. We
do not, however, know very much in regard to the degree
of attention which the enemies of these protected animals
pay to form. As many animals appear to be alert in de-
tecting movements of their prey, there will be an advantage
if the latter are shaped like other things. A walking-stick
insect that is creeping or swaying about on a twig, will be
less likely to be seen as a moving object because of its
strong form-resemblance to a group of twigs.
Here we have the well-known cases of butterflies like
leaves, of caterpillars like little twigs, of spiders like lichens,
and so on. It is interesting to notice that the perfection
of the resemblance is often due to combination of items.
Thus in the famous case of Kallima, which is like a pendent
withered leaf when it settles down, usually head down-
wards, on a branch, there is similarity in colouring, there is
resemblance in shape, the mid-rib and veins of the leaf are
counterfeited by the nervures of the wings, the likeness
is heightened by marks on the wings which look like
fungus marks on the leaves, and so on. Moreover, in
Kallima there is much individual variation in the markings
on the under surfaces of the wings, ' simulating all degrees
of decay and discoloration and fungus attack '. It seems
reasonable to suppose that this variability of pattern is
even more effective than if the Kallima were tied down to
resembling only one kind of withered leaf.
Subtlest of all these misleading resemblances to other
32 THE WONDER OF LIFE
things is mimicry in the strict sense, where there is a striking
external resemblance between two unrelated animals which
frequent the same haunts. As examples we may cite the re-
semblance between the drone-fly (Eristalis) and a bee ;
between the European grass-snake, Tropidonotus viperinus,
quite innocent in character, and a viper ; between the Lepi-
dopteron Trochilium apiforme and the hornet ; between a
spider (e.g. Myrmarachne formicaria] and the dreaded ant.
It is usual to refuse the title of true mimicry unless it
can be shown (or unless it has been shown in analogous
cases) that the mimicker lives along with the mimicked
to a considerable extent, that the mimickers are in the
minority, that the mimickers are like the mimicked in
superficial characters only, and that the mimicked are
more or less markedly safe and usually more or less con-
spicuous. It goes without saying that the use of the terms
mimicker and mimicked is entirely metaphorical, for the
mimetic resemblance is not deliberate.
Students of mimicry are accustomed to distinguish several
types. Thus in ' Batesian Mimicry ', first clearly defined by
the naturalist-traveller Bates, we have a palatable animal
escaping in virtue of its superficial resemblance to unpalat-
able forms, with striking features, which are rarely attacked
and are greatly in the majority over the mimickers. The
bad reputation of ants gives a vicarious safety to several
ant-like spiders ; the disagreeable taste of the mimicked
butterfly helps the survival of its palatable Doppel-
Ganger.
Mr. Guy A. K. Marshall observed a Dipterous fly, Ceria
gambiana, visiting flowers in company with a formidable
wasp, Polistes marginalis, and it seems reasonable to infer
that the fly profits by its likeness to the dangerous creature
1 1 . A. A butterfly (Kallima inachis), with outspread wings
showing the upper surface. B. The same on a branch, head
downwards, with the wmgs folded together, showing the under
surface. C. A withered leaf hanging downwards.
THE WONDER OF UF
ifry ia the strict senae, ^ & a
:rri>U*\X' between two it--.
tw kaonts. As MMm:*w w- i ! i* re-
t^wwn fche drojte-rl > bee ;
K^^ipyan grass-sruikf. ' :inu,9,
st i character, and A vipwr ; i^xween the Lepi-
o^4lfm api/orww *nJ th bomot ; between a,
Ifftnwrockne formicaria } *IM! the dreaded ant.
to refuse the title oi t.r Biimicry unless it
Ho^tt for ujiless it ha w n in analogous
-.!! .01
r fess marketUy safe and usviaUv more or less con-
j.oa.'*. It goes without saying that the use of the terms
ienefeor and mimicked is entirety nv , for the
?:?Sf^At resemblance is not deliberate,
.. ft - of mimicry are accustomed to disti
t ypivp 1 hs in ' Batesian Mimicry ', fi rat cl'-.
ik* 1 tiataraEst-traveller Bates, we have a palatable animal
raping in virtue of its superficial rew unpalat-
able forma, with striking features, winch are rarely attacked
and are gr**tly in the nmj . the niiinickers. The
bad reputation < . ; i >us safety to several
ant-like spiders ; the dirag*nbk.' taste of the mimicked
butterfly helps datable Doppel-
anger,
Mr. Guy ' pte i
yambiana, viairmg flowers i
wasp. "rgmalis, a\
that t' ; s by its lik ,
B
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 33
with a bad reputation that it has come to associate with.
In all such cases single observations are unconvincing, but
when similar cases accumulate the argument gathers force.
Thus it is very interesting that J. Bourgeois should have
noticed Ceria conopsoides visiting the wounds on the trunk
of a horse-chestnut in company with a wasp, Odynerus
crassicornis, a formidable insect. Both were visiting the
tree with the same end to lick the exudation ; the fly
was probably protected from certain enemies by its ' Bate-
sian mimicry ' of the wasp.
Another type of mimicry is called Miillerian, after the
naturalist Fritz Miiller, and here we have a resemblance
between several immune species living in the same country.
This is well illustrated among South American Lepidoptera,
e.g. Danaids, Heliconids, and Acrseids, and it seems to
work like a sort of mutual assurance. None are palatable,
but by being like one another they spread the risk of being
experimented on by inexperienced birds. Birds have to
learn discretion in their youth ; they take many an unpleas-
ant bite of unpalatable victims before they become pro-
ficient ; they remember the marks of bad taste, and the
more similar these marks are the more likely their possessors
are to escape. The more in the ring, the less the waste of life.
There are many difficulties in connexion with mimicry
especially perhaps the question of its evolution but it is
difficult to see the remarkable illustrations collected by
Professor Poulton and to consider the facts he adduces
as to its efficacy in certain cases, without being ready to
admit that it plays a considerable and curious part in the
drama of animal life.
Sometimes the mimicry is very exact as regards colouring
and pattern ; sometimes it is rather in pose and movement,
D
34 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Let us take an instance. From a pale emerald-green nest,
sent from the Gold Coast to the Zoological Society in London,
there emerged a crowd of young Mantids, about four milli-
metres in length, which exhibited a curious mimicry.
' When crawling about the case they looked exactly like
a crowd of busy ants, their rapid darts and pauses recalling
irresistibly the busy method of progression so characteristic
of these Hymenoptera '. Now, there is nothing more pro-
fitable for an innocent little insect than to be like an ant,
for ants have a very bad reputation, or what corresponds
in the animal world to a reputation. But the interesting
point which was noticed by Mr. R. I. Pocock, the Superin-
tendent of the Gardens, was this, that it was only when they
were moving about that they resembled ants. When they
settled down they were seen in their true colours as
Mantises, ' raising the fore part of the body and head, folding
up their fore-legs, and every now and then swaying gently
from side to side as if rocked by
the wind. While thus employed
they were seen to be procrypti-
cally coloured '. That is to say,
they were inconspicuous. This is
obviously a very interesting case ;
when the little creatures were
resting they were hidden, and
when they were poking about
they were like ants ! Without
observations and experiments in
their natural surroundings no
naturalist could assert that the
FIG. 12. Spider, Synemo- young Mantises are saved from
syna formica, like an ...
ant. (After Peckham.) elimination by being inconspicu-
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 35
ous or by being like ants. But as we have experimental
proof in a few analogous cases, it seems quite sound Biology
to say that these little Mantises probably get on very
much better because they have added to the usual incon-
spicuousness of their kind, the additional advantage of
being like ants when they are young. For by the time
they had attained a length of seven millimetres, they had
lost their ant-like look.
Another ' device ' is that of masking, where the creature
disguises its real nature by covering itself with foreign
bodies. It is difficult to draw the line between extrinsic
armour and disguise. Thus the larval caddis-insects in
the streams cover themselves with minute pebbles or with
pieces of plant-stem and the like ; and this is probably in
the main a protection, not a mask. When we pass to
crabs covering themselves with sea- weed, or with sponge,
or with hydroids, or with part of a sea-squirt's tunic, we
have to do with something nearer masking.
Zoologists are well aware that the little crabs of the
genus Cryptodromia are in the habit of masking themselves
with pieces of sponge or ascidian or the like. R. P. Cowles
has recently watched the whole process of sponge-cutting.
The naked crab (Cryptodromia tuberculata, in the Philip-
pines) cuts a groove on an encrusting grayish sponge,
works its way under it, and dislodges it. In a short time
the ragged edges of the sponge shield grow smooth and
neat. The cutting is done with the forceps, but the dis-
lodged piece is caught hold of and carried by the last pair
of legs.
' It is a surprise to the collector when, on turning over a
rock covered with large and small patches, he sees some of
36 THE WONDER OF LIFE
the smaller patches suddenly become animated and crawl
away. Another surprise is in store for him when he picks
up one of these small patches and finds it to be the cover
of a crab carefully hollowed out so as to fit the outline of the
carapace, and tightly held in place by the last pair of
legs, whose dactyli [terminal joints] are hooked into the
inturned rim.'
Mr. Cowles also describes the way in which the Pistol
Crab (Alpheus pachychirus) of the Philippines makes its
tube of matted Alga-threads. The tubes, which are rather
shelters than masks, are often 25 to 30 centimetres long and
2 centimetres in diameter, and one end is fixed to the rock.
A male crab placed on a piece of matted Alga turned itself
on its back, and using the slender chelate limbs imme-
diately behind the forceps, drew the sides of a furrow to-
gether and sewed them by a simple stitching. Threads of
Alga were drawn from each side into the opposite side.
On another occasion a tube was torn into shreds and given
to a pair of crabs, who made a coherent tube by next morn-
ing. Filaments were entangled on the edges of a sheltering
piece of rock and then drawn together.
' When the Alpheus found a hole in the rapidly forming
tube, the slender legs came through, caught hold of the
filaments of the Alga, and manipulated them in much the
same manner as a man might the thread with which he
darns a hole in his sock ; that is, by drawing the edges of
the hole together and fastening them.'
Self-Advertisement. In great contrast to those
animals that walk delicately, or lie low, or fade into their
surroundings, or put on disguise, there are those that are
noisy and bold, fussy and conspicuous the self -advertisers.
36 r
the smatt* >* *-.* | *te*fttasi wsd crawl
away. *r * ^ * fe*J3* wto i picks
up on*" ? a" ^ be' t?tt! cover
of a cr*fc &i L ** to fct *fae outhne of the
cftrsp/. -wiS 8T y the last pair of
Itjw 'Lf,;4 i are hooked into the
$ -ay in which the Pistol
== 5 vines makes its
3 ,tbes, which are rather
1 of - centimetres long and
71 d is fixed to the rock,
trotted Alga turned itself
~ j- chelate limbs imme-
5 sides of a furrow to-
f stitching. Threads of
g* S- ''to the opposite side.
tub*}aV^ft-torn ; riven
who mad M Inherent t.i o >m-
^. j re entai'.*" ring
8" o
59
s. ^ aing
. '!_ .-at hold of the
;n in much the
1 with which he
ing the edges of
tj ,orn.'
j their
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 37
The theory is that those in the second set can afford to call
attention to themselves, being unpalatable or in some
other way safe. To prove a theory of this sort is impossible,
but it becomes cogent and convincing in proportion to the
number and variety of cases to which it can be applied.
Mr. Pocock, of the Zoological Society's Gardens in London,
has applied the theory to various Mammals, and it seems
to work out well. Taking the common shrew (Sorex vulgaris),
for instance, he points out that it is fearless and careless,
Fio. 14. The rattle of the rattlesnake (Crotalus), composed of a number
of horny bells, added to at successive moults. It is agitated
when the snake is excited and produces a shrill noise. Thus large
animals, on whom the snake would simply waste its poison, are
warned off.
and that it makes a frequent squeaking as it hunts. It
can afford to be a self-advertising animal because of a
strong musky scent, which makes it unpalatable. A cat
will never eat a shrew. The odoriferous glands are situated
in a long line on each side of the body. Similarly, the large
Indian musk-shrew (Crocidura ccerulea) is conspicuous even
at dusk, quite fearless in its habits, and goes about making
a peculiar noise like the jingling of money. But it is safe in
its unpleasant musky odour.
The common hedgehog is comparatively easy to see at
night ; it is easy to catch, because it stops to roll itself up,
on very slight provocation sometimes ; it rustles about in
3 8 THE WONDER OF LIFE
the herbage and ' sniffs furiously ' as it goes ; it often calls
to its mate ; it is at no pains to keep quiet. Nor need it,
for although a few enemies manage to eat it, the spines are
in most cases quite effective prevention. Moreover, it
can give rise when irritated to a most horrible stench. The
porcupine is another good instance of a self-advertiser,
and so is the crab-eating mungoose (Mungos cancrivora).
In a few cases we have some definite knowledge in regard
to the actual process of adaptive colour-change. The spotted
salamander (Salamandra maculosa], with its conspicuous
livery of bright yellow and dark brown, is a case in point.
It is well known to become almost black when the soil of
its vivarium is dark and relatively dry. Two things
happen : the yellow areas become gradually smaller, re-
treating towards the centre till they disappear ; and the
dark areas become darker. Experiments following the
ordinary method of exclusion are very instructive, e.g.,
using a black-paper ground with the normal humidity.
The shrinkage of the yellow spots is induced by the colour
of the ground, while the darkening is brought on by
increasing drought. An experimenter, Alois Gaisch,
relates that he put a salamander into a vivarium with
black peaty soil (which remained moist), and found it
almost unrecognizable after three months. The yellow
spots had shrunk, there were many black dots about their
margins, and microscopic examination showed that the
black pigment had abundantly invaded the yellow areas.
Two other salamanders put in about the same time showed
no change of colour, which seems to show that there are
differences in individual susceptibility. If that be so, and
if it had not to do with age or the like, we have an illustra-
tion of how a selective process might work. For if it were
THE DRAMA OF LIFE
39
a matter of great advantage that yellow and black salaman-
ders should lose their yellowness in a black-soiled coun-
try, it is plain that the non- susceptible types would be
eliminated, while the susceptible types would survive and
multiply after their kind.
We are accustomed to think of the chameleon's colour-
change in connexion with protection, but it seems also
to have a distinctly repellent value. Mr. Cyril Crossland
has given an animated
account of a chameleon
frightening off a fox
terrier which attacked
it. At first the reptile
tried to run away, but
that is not its strong
point ! ' In a few
seconds the impossi-
bility of escape seemed
to reach the animal's
brain, when it at once
turned round and
opened its great pink
mouth in the face of
the advancing foe, at
the same time rapidly
changing colour, be-
coming almost black.
This ruse succeeded ,
FIG. 15. Common Starfish (Astenas
every time, the dog rubens) regenerating lost parts. It
tnrnincr off af OTIPP ' shows at the top two arms which are
irmng ott at once . just beginning to be regrown . T he
Mr. Crossland points largest of the five arms has been
. . , previously regrown double. (After
out that m natural Mclntosh.)
40 THE WONDER OF LIFE
leafy conditions the startling effect would be enhanced
a sudden throwing off of the mantle of invisibility and the
exposure of a conspicuous black body with a large red
mouth.
There is no end to these effective adaptations, and all
that we are concerned with here is the illustration of a very
remarkable aspect of the drama of life. We know how
cuttlefishes throw dust (or ink) in the eyes of their pursuers ;
how the skunks repel by their loathsome stench ; how the
starfish escapes by surrendering an arm, the crab by giving
up its claw, and the lizard by parting with its tail ; how
the puss-moth caterpillar puts on ' a terrifying attitude ',
and the cat effectively ' bluffs ' the dog. Of a truth it
may be said of Life that it has sought out many inventions.
Intricate Situations. Other illustrations of the dra-
matic element in Animate Nature may be found in the
frequent occurrence of intricate situations. Many of
these arise from the complex inter-relations which have
in the course of time been established. As we propose
to give many examples of these inter-relations in a subse-
quent chapter, it may suffice here to recall the general
Darwinian conception of the ' Web of Life ', that Nature
is a vibrating system most surely and subtly inter-
connected. No organism lives or dies quite to itself,
each being in some way correlated with some other.
In Illustration : Cuckoo- Spit. The impression of the
subtlety and intricacy of life, which we wish to convey,
might be illustrated by taking rare and quaint instances,
but the commonest things, curiously enough, are always
the most striking. In early summer in temperate countries
nothing is commoner on the herbage than the splashes of
white froth which are often called ' cuckoo-spit '. The
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 41
old idea was that the mother- cuckoo spat them out as she
flew around looking for a suitable nest in which to place
her egg, and it was also supposed by some that they gave
rise spontaneously to singing Cicadas. They have, of
course, nothing to do with cuckoos, but they have, in a
sense, something to do with cicadas, for they are produced
by the larvae of insects, e.g. Aphrophom spumaria, which
are related thereto. They are popularly known as frog-
hoppers, in allusion to the highly developed jumping
powers of the adults.
The eggs are laid the previous autumn by the mother
' froghopper ' in deep crevices in the bark of willow-bushes
or the like ; they hatch in spring, and there emerge small
squat larvae with a piercing beak and firmly gripping legs.
These probe the leaves and stems of plants and suck up the
sugary sap, much as their relatives the green-flies or Aphides
do. And just as ' honey- dew ', as it is called, passes out
of the food-canal of the green-flies in large quantities and
smears the leaves and even falls like drops of rain to the
ground, so the surplus sap passes through the frog-hoppers
and forms the familiar foam-like ' spit '. The food is very
abundant, the larva grows and moults, and grows and
moults again, and finally passes into a resting or pupa
stage ; its wings grow and other changes of structure are
brought about ; it leaves the froth and moults for the last
time ; it becomes a full-grown winged insect, and there is
no more foam to be seen on the herbage. All the frog-
hoppers have grown up.
The making of the foam which envelops and conceals the
larval frog-hopper is of much interest. In the first place,
the material is watery sap, slightly changed by passing
through the food-canal ; it is exuded at the hind end and
42 THE WONDER OF LIFE
spreads over the body and limbs. In the second place,
there is an external air-canal, a sort of closeable gutter on
the under surface of the body posteriorly, in which the
insect collects air from the outer world and from which it
can expel it into the surrounding clear fluid. If we watch
carefully we can see the larva raising the end of its body
to the surface of the froth and allowing the air- canal to fill ;
thereafter the canal is used like a pair of bellows and air
is blown into the fluid. Some of the air is of course utilized
for the insect's breathing. In the third place, there are
minute wax glands on two of the segments of the hind
part of the body, which produce small quantities of wax.
This is acted on by a ferment in the exuded fluid and a
sort of soap is formed ! If it were not for this soap-pro-
duction the bubbles would not last so long as they do.
It is a very remarkable device, living under water and
yet in the open air, conspicuous and yet concealed, in the
sunshine and yet cool ! Though the frog-hoppers are some-
times picked out from their frothy shelter by audacious
wasps and the like, there can be no doubt that they are
saved from many enemies and many risks by having
acquired the art of blowing soap-bubbles. For that is
precisely what happens.
The Case of Horned Lizards. Among terrestrial
animals, the lizards stand easily first in the exhibition of
quaint and bizarre forms. It seems as if Nature had, so to
speak, let herself go among lizards in quips and cranks.
How like a joke the chameleon and many another quaint
lizard seems till we see them in their appropriate environ-
ment and at their daily work. We are thinking of forms
like the little dragon (Draco volans), with its skin webbed
between enormously extended ribs ; or the Australian
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 43
moloch, with its curiously hygroscopic skin, pimpled all
over with sharp tubercles ; or the frilled lizard which
Saville Kent describes, that runs totteringly about on its
hind legs like a baby just before it falls ; or the basilisk,
with erectile crests on its back ; or our own British slow-
Fia. 16. Frilled Lizard (Chlamydosaurus) running like a biped, with its
collar folded round its head. (After Saville Kent.)
worm, which has put on the guise of a snake, and is famous
for the ease with which it can surrender its tail to save its
life.
In the show of quaint lizards the chameleon must always
be awarded the first prize ; but many will agree with us
in thinking that the horned lizards of Mexico, California,
and Nevada come a good second. They have been known
for a long time, but they have been made the subject of
a recent monograph by Mr. Harold C. Bryant, of the
University of California. To this fine piece of work one
envies the author his subject we are indebted for some
44
THE WONDER OF LIFE
FIG. 17. Frilled Lizard of Australia (Chlamydosaurus kingi) with a great
erectile frill on the neck, folded when the creature runs, expanded
when it stands at bay. The animal grows to nearly 3 feet. (After
Saville Kent.)
new and interesting material. The creatures in question
are often spoken of as ' horned toads ', the false classifica-
tion being probably suggested by their squat shape, their
sluggish ways, and their habit of catching insects on a
sticky tongue. True lizards they undoubtedly are, and
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 45
among the Iguanids ; but they differ from all other mem-
bers of the order in their flat bodies covered with keeled,
spiny scales, and in the circlet of horns upon the head.
There are eighteen different species belonging to the genus
Phrynosoma, and there is one other known, a unique creature
from the deserts of the Gila and Colorado Rivers, which
requires a genus (Anota) all to itself, and has the honour,
indeed, of differing from every other living lacertilian in the
closing up of a small gap on the roof of the skull known
as the supratemporal foramen. One needs, however, to
know a good deal about skulls before one can appreciate
the importance of this unique feature.
What is the significance of the Phrynosome's peculiarities?
In the first place, what is the meaning of that circlet
of sharp horns on the head, which recall (as if in miniature)
the projecting horns of some of the extinct Dinosaurs ?
The curious shape of head that results reminds one also of
the quaint fruits of the water-chestnut which the peasants
round Florence string into most decorative rosaries. But
what are the horns for ? They serve to ward off blows
and bites, for the creature lowers its head and raises the
scales of its back when it is on the defensive, and we can
well believe that if an enemy bit the head of a Phrynosome
once, it would never do so again. The Indians say that
if a snake swallows one whole, the indomitable lizard
proceeds to work its way by a short cut from the stomach
outwards which for the aggressor must be an extremely
disagreeable process, bringing repentance to the snake.
Mr. Bryant says that there is some foundation for this
story, and it has its analogues at any rate in records of
box-fishes biting their way out of sharks.
A second distinctive feature in the homed lizards is their
46 THE WONDER OF LIFE
power of adaptive colour- change. They have the secret of
the Gyges ring, and putting on the garment of invisibility
is for them as easy as winking. ' Wherever its home ', says
the monographer, * the horned lizard resembles the colour
of the substratum so closely that it is practically invisible
except when in motion. Specimens from the white sand
of the desert are very light in colour, those from the
black lava belt are almost black, whereas those from the
vari- coloured mountain districts show red and even
bluish markings. How quickly a change of environment
would bring about a change in colour is not definitely
known, although Coues states that the change takes place
in from twenty-four to forty- eight hours '.
Given horns and scales and the mantle of invisibility,
the horned lizards are safe, and we are not surprised to learn
that most of the species are represented by large numbers
of individuals. We can understand now why they have
such a wide geographical range from Canada to southern
Mexico, and from the Mississippi to the Pacific coast ;
why they rarely bite ; why they can afford to take things
easily, basking in the sun and moving with leisurely deliber-
ation. When an enemy comes they ' play 'possum ' ;
when they are thoroughly scared they seek refuge in a bush
or burrow in the sand.
Even in their burrowing they are unlike most other
creatures, for they work their way beneath the ground
head-foremost. As Mr. Bryant says, ' The chisel-shaped
head is the principal tool, the legs being used almost
solely for forcing the head forward. A wriggling motion
of the head and body serves to drive the head beneath the
sand and soon covers the body completely with earth.
A little shake of the tail flings the dirt over that appendage,
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 47
and the lizard becomes entirely hidden. The nostrils are
kept either at the surface of the ground or near enough to
the surface so that breathing is possible '. Sometimes the
spines are left protruding above the ground like dry thorns.
Stranger even than the circlet of horns and the wonder-
fully perfect power of colour-change is the habit of ' shed-
ding tears of blood '. It was for this that the Mexicans
called the Phrynosome the ' sacred toad ' ; it is to this
that the boys of San Diego refer when they say they saw
the creature ' spit blood '. As there are the best of physio -
logical reasons why it can neither ' weep blood ' nor ' spit
blood ', what is it that happens ? The eyes are tightly
shut, the eyelids swell to twice or thrice their normal size,
and a fine jet of blood shoots out for several inches from
beneath the upper eyelid. The whole phenomenon is
startling and quite worthy of the strange creature. Some
say that the haemorrhage is associated with the excite-
ment of the breeding season, but this lacks proof. So far
as experiments go, they seem to indicate that the rush of
blood is associated with shock and fright. The eyelids are
rich in blood-vessels, and what happens is first a congestion
and then probably the rupture of a blood-vessel. It may
be compared to bleeding at the nose, but the point is that
it has been regularized. One physiologist has suggested
that the flooding of the head sinuses, the elevation of the
blood pressure, and the jet of blood, while associated with
panic and excitement, may also have a frightening effect
deterrent to enemies.
The horned lizards are for the most part insectivorous,
catching living ants, beetles, and flies on the end of the
viscid tongue. ' Why the animal is never bothered by
being stung internally by the ants it swallows alive seems
48 THE WONDER OF LIFE
hard to explain.' It is sensitive enough externally ; can
it be that it is immune internally ? When insects become
scarce, and the cold weather sets in, the horned lizards
burrow into the ground and pass into the coma of hiberna-
tion. Dr. Gadow makes the interesting note that if cap-
tive specimens are not allowed to hibernate, ' they will keep
on feeding through the winter, but in that case are sure to
die in the following spring '.
We may leave the horned lizards in their winter sleep,
though without nearly exhausting their peculiarities. One
more may be mentioned, which, like the haemorrhage, well
deserves further study. Mr. Bryant has found that they
are very amenable to what looks like hypnosis. When a
specimen is rubbed on the top of the head and between the
eyes, it turns its head down, closes its eyes, and passes
into a stupor, in which it may remain for five or ten minutes.
But the observer was not quite sure whether what happened
was a faint, or a feint, or neither. It presents one of those
unsolved problems with which every study in Natural
History should begin and also end.
Love -Scenes. The interest of many a human drama
is in its love-affairs two men and a maid, two maids
with their hearts set on one man such are the apparently
simple data from which a plot is evolved. And it is so
among animals also. We need not quibble about words ;
the love of the Argus pheasant showing off his hundred
eyes before his desired mate is doubtless very different
from the love of the stickleback coaxing and driving his
bride to the nest among the weeds, and both are very
different from our loves, but there is undoubtedly a com-
mon element. We must avoid the amiable error of
generosity reading the man into the beast but we must
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 49
avoid the opposite error of excessive stinginess which
reduces the animal to the level of an automatic machine.
The true view is between these extremes.
Among the loves of animals, we may find what is common-
place (when there is not the slightest hint of preferential
mating), but we also find the extraordinary, as when a she-
spider puts an abrupt full stop to a courtship by devouring
her suitor. We find what provokes us to mirth, as when a
male spider waltzes over a hundred times around his
desired mate at a respectful radius ; we find also what
seems pathetic, as in the familiar nuptial flights of the
ants, where the apparent waste of masculinity is so enor-
mous worse than the worst of wars.
Let us travel to the meadows around Bologna. It is
late on a summer night, when the darkness is short. It is
very quiet, for even the frogs have ceased for weeks to utter
their cheerful brek-a-brek whose interrogativeness expresses
the essence of conversation. There seem to be living sparks
in the air and lesser lights among the grass. It is the
courtship of Luciola the Italian fire-fly. The lady-
Luciolas are sedentary ; the males fly about. When a
female catches sight of the flashes of an approaching male
she allows her splendour to shine forth. He sees the
signal, and is forthwith beside her, circling round like a
dancing elf. But one suitor is not enough, and the lady-
Luciola soon attracts a levee. In apparently courteous
rivalry her devotees form a respectful circle, flashes of light
come and go, and eventually in the dead of night the
coquette's choice is made. In the two sexes, Prof. Emery
says, the colour and intensity of the light is much the same,
but the luminous rhythm of the male is more rapid, with
briefer flashes ; while that of the female is more prolonged,
50 THE WONDER OF LIFE
with longer intervals, and more tremulous suggestive
indeed of the contrasts among higher non-luminous
creatures. The picture is dramatic.
Family Life. Why do the people thus strive and cry ?
the poet asked, and the wise answer came : ' They will
have food, and they will have children, and they will
bring up the children as well as they can.' This is true
for us ; it is also true for animals, and there often is a
dramatic element in nurture. The mind fills with all sorts
of illustrations of parental care the kangaroo placing her
newborn babe unable even to suck into her skin-pocket ;
the mother crocodile who digs up the buried eggs when she
hears the restless young piping their slender signal from
within the egg it would not be well to be born buried
alive ; the father frog (Rhinoderma) who carries the eggs
and even the froglets in his croaking sacs, yet does not
swallow them and so on ; down and down to the skate -
sucker that mounts guard for months over its egg-clusters
laid in a shell, or the little brook-leech that bears about its
young hanging on to the body. But there are instances in
which the dramatic element is more apparent than in these.
Let us spread the wings of our imagination again and
travel to some warmer clime Africa, Australia, but pre-
ferably India to some place where hornbills are at home.
These birds, well known for the helmet on their head, are
tree-lovers, except when feeding ; though their bones are
more pneumatic than those of most birds, they fly heavily
and slowly, most of them with a sound like that of a
steam-engine in the distance ; their characteristic note is
between the bray of an ass and the shriek of a railway
engine ; they are somewhat indiscriminating feeders,
in many ways, in short, not very attractive. But in
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 51
one respect their behaviour excites our admiration the
behaviour of the male bird to his mate and offspring.
When nesting-time comes, a hole in a tree is found, and
the wife goes in and shuts the door. From material which
she has gathered or which her husband brings she walls
herself in literally ' barring the door weel '. Only a small
opening like the grille in the convent door is left ;
perhaps it helps to keep snakes and other enemies out.
Through the window, however, the father feeds her, knock-
ing with his bill if she is not on the outlook ; as he clings
to the bark he is (if nature be not a mirage) obviously
anxious about his charge ; she sits safe minding her own
business, he works hard bringing succulent fruit, or tender
mouse, or juicy frog ; curiously enough he sometimes casts
up the lining of his gizzard with all its contents enclosed
a strange votive offering on the family altar. We are
not surprised to learn that by the time the young bird
is ready to emerge the devoted father and husband ' is
worn to a skeleton '. The story is dramatic.
Complications. There is a novel by Turgemef called
A Friend of the Family in which are depicted some of the
disadvantages attendant on the guest out-staying his
welcome. But there are far more complicated problems
involved in the habit many ants have of being hosts to
beetles. To make the matter clear, a brief introductory
statement must be made. Just as we have or may have
in or about our houses five sets of living creatures parasites
like the homceopathist's leech whose name of flea it is
impolite to mention, really inimical intruders like rats,
more or less indifferent fellow-inmates like the death-
watch, useful domestic animals like the cow, and pets like
the cat, so ants may have in their nests parasites in the
52 THE WONDER OF LIFE
form of mites, unfriendly intruders, indifferent fellow-
tenants, occasional ' cows ' (as Linnaeus called the
Aphides), and pets. These pets are usually Staphylinid
beetles belonging to the family well-represented in
Britain by the devil's coach-horse (Ocypus olens}. Some
of the Staphylinids are downright robbers and others are
merely tolerated by the ants, but there is a third set
(represented by the genera Atemeles and Lomechusa) to
which the name of pet may be applied. These beetles
are never found outside or at any rate very far from the
ants' nests ; they have patches of yellow hairs which
seem to secrete some substance which the ants like to lick ;
they seem to be on very friendly relations with the ants, for
they stroke them and get drops of honey from their mouths,
and they will in turn disgorge some of their repast for the
benefit of a hungry host. On the other hand, these friends
of the family are not so innocent as they appear, for while
with bended knee they will solicit a bonne bouche from
their hosts, and while they like to sit among a crowd of
ants as if exchanging the compliments of the season, they
are on the sly eating up a good many of the ants' children
and that when their own are receiving food from the ants.
And now we come to our precise point. Looking down
through Father Wasmann's eyes on this quaint association
of hosts and guests, we feel safe in saying that the presence
of the beetles adds to the ants' sum-total of happiness, and
yet we cannot avoid doubting whether the amiable hospital-
ity of the ' little people, exceeding wise ' has not in it elements
of danger. What if the guests became too numerous ?
As a fine example of wheels within wheels, let us face
this question and inquire what actually happens. The
beetles are not unlike ants in their ways, and the larvae of
THE DRAMA OF LIFE 53
Lomechusa, as described by Wasmann, are very like ant
larvae. At any rate, the ants make little distinction
between the ant- larvae and those of their guests ; they treat
them both alike. Now it is the habit of the worker-ants
to dig up the ant-larvae and to clean them during the pupal
metamorphosis ; and they do this likewise for their guests'
larvae. But while it is a good procedure for the ant-
larvae, it is disastrous to the beetle- larvae ; the great
majority perish under the treatment and perhaps only
those which have been overlooked survive. Two naturalists
at least have referred to this as an unfortunate circum-
stance, as an illustration of the well-known fact that ' the
best-laid plans of mice and men gang aft agley ', but in
reality the apparent failure is an unconscious success ;
the result of the wheels- within- wheels complication is that
the friends of the family do not become too embarrass-
ingly numerous.
Karl Jordan has made an interesting study of the glands
of Lomechusa and Atemeles and other related beetles which
live as guests in ants' nests. Numerous unicellular glands
on the sides of the abdomen produce the secretion that the
ants lick with evident gusto. But there are also numerous
offensive glands, common to other beetles of the same
sub-family Aleocharinae which are not myrmecophilous.
The secretion of these offensive glands has an odour like
that of amyl-acetate or methyl- heptenon, and it has,
like these substances, a stupefying effect on the ants. It
is used against stranger ants or against the hosts them-
selves when they are troublesome. The possession of the
offensive glands gives the beetles a certain standing, so to
speak, but it is on the possession of the palatable secretion
that the myrmecophilous partnership depends.
CHAPTER 11
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE
(THE EXPLOITATION OF THE EARTH)
'Sbe bas oivioeo berself tbat sbe mas be ber own oelfgbt.
Sbe causes an enoless succession of new capacities for
enjoyment to spring up, tbat ber insatiable sgrnpatbg mag
be assuageD. . . .'
'Sbe tosses ber creatures out of notbfngness, ano tells
tbem not wbence tbeg came, nor wbitber tbeg go. 5t is
tbeir business to run, sbe fcnows tbe roao. . . .'
Ooethe's Aphorisms, translated by Huxley.
The Shore Fauna The Pelagic Fauna The Abyssal Fauna
The Freshwater Fauna The Terrestrial Fauna The Aerial
Fauna.
THERE are six great haunts of life : the shore of
the sea, the open sea, the deep sea, the freshwater,
the dry land, and the air. And these have their distinctive
tenants. For while some types may be represented by
very similar forms in more than one haunt, and while some
animals pass from one haunt to another, yet on the whole
there is distinctiveness in the faunas of the various regions.
So we may speak of littoral, pelagic, abyssal, freshwater,
terrestrial, and aerial faunas. Besides the great haunts
there are minor haunts of much interest such as caves,
and brackish water, and underneath the ground. It must
be granted, too, that parasitic animals have explored and
54
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 55
exploited a great variety of haunts in or on other creatures.
In strictness, as we shall recognize later on, the freshwater
haunt should be subdivided into several distinct haunts.
I. THE SHORE FAUNA
We must think of the shore-area as much more than
that stretch of sand and gravel and rock-pool and mud
which many of us know so well the happy hunting-ground
of child and naturalist alike. The shore-area is much
more than the stretch between tide-marks. It includes
the whole of the shallow shelf around continents and con-
tinental islands, down to a depth of, say, 100 fathoms. It
is the area where seaweeds grow. Geographers tell us
that, without including the imperfectly known polar areas,
the shore-area stretches for over 150,000 miles and has a
superficial extent of perhaps nine million square miles.
It is therefore an immense area, though it only occupies
between 6 and 7 per cent, of the entire sea-surface. It
makes up for its relative smallness by the density and
variety of its population.
What strikes us first about the littoral area is that it is
the meeting-place of the terrestrial, the freshwater, the
pelagic, and the abyssal faunas. Over the marshy ground
overflowed at high tides, or over the firm-turfed links, or
abruptly up the cliffs, or tediously over the seemingly
interminable sand-dunes, we pass from the littoral to the
terrestrial. Up the long estuary there is often a gradual
passage from salt water to fresh, and we notice some ani-
mals like flounders that don't seem to care which they live
in. If we take a boat and sail out, or if we swim out in
some places, we pass from the littoral to the pelagic area.
If, on the other hand, we could walk down the gently
56 THE WONDER OF LIFE
sloping shelf that often occurs, we should find the light
becoming gradually fainter and the seaweeds becoming
gradually scarcer, and if we could continue to a depth of
about 100 fathoms, we should come to the ' mud-line '
where wave-action ceases and the mud sinks quietly to
rest. This is near the edge of the continental shelf, and
beyond this is the steep slope leading down to the deep
sea.
The shore-area has been divided by Forbes and others
into zones : (a) the strictly Littoral or tidal zone, between
the tide-marks, with limpets and acorn-shells, periwinkles
and dog-whelks, cockles and mussels, sea-anemones and
crumb-of-bread sponge ; (6) the Laminarian zone, where
the long pennon-like brown seaweeds grow in profusion
with sea-urchins and starfishes and nudibranchs ; and (c)
the Coralline zone, with abundance of calcareous Algse, and
such animals as ' buckies ' and ' sea- mice'. But shores
differ so enormously that these zones are not of general
occurrence ; a great deal depends on the gradient, for the
shelf may extend out for many miles, or there may be deep
water up to the sides of the cliffs and no shore at all, as in
the Scandinavian fjords. A noteworthy point that can be
readily verified concerns the seaweeds. The dominant
colour changes as we proceed outwards. Most of the
green Alga3, such as the sea-lettuce (Ulva lactuca), are in
the shallowest water ; the brown ones, such as the huge
Laminarians, are most predominant further out ; the
red Algse, such as Delesseria sanguined, are especially char-
acteristic of the lowest zone of seaweeds. In the brown
forms the chlorophyll is masked with a brown pigment
(phycophaein), in the red forms with a red pigment (phyco-
erythrin), and the point of greatest interest is simply that
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 57
the red seaweeds are able to continue the work of assimila-
tion in relatively faint light, though they do not form the
ordinary kind of starch. It may be noted in passing that
the pelagic Sargasso weed consists of pieces of littoral sea-
weeds (e.g. Sargassum) which have been torn by storms
from the shore and floated outwards.
It is usually believed that the green Algse came first
historically, but it is interesting to notice Brunnthaler's
heresy that the red ones are most primitive. His idea is
that the red Algse were physiologically best suited for the
dim light of very ancient days when the Earth was enveloped
in a dense cloud canopy, just as they are nowadays best
suited for the deeper waters of the littoral area. Those
with brown pigment came next and they were well suited
to absorb rays from a somewhat lighter but still very misty
atmosphere. The green Algae came last in the series, when
our present-day conditions were established. They proved
very successful and spread from the sea to the estuaries and
thence into the freshwaters.
Physical Conditions. The character of the shore -
fauna depends in part on the chemical composition of the
water, which shows considerable diversity. This depends
on the nature of the rocks and sea-bottom, on what the
rivers bring down, and on what the currents sweep along.
The nature of the rocks, whether volcanic or calcareous,
granitic or sandstone, and so on, is also of much importance ,
determining, for instance, the nature of the rock-pools
and the opportunities for attachment. On the nature of
the rocks and sea-floor the vegetation of seaweeds in part
depends, and the ' flora ' reacts on the fauna.
It is part of the definition of the shore-area that it is
illumined (hence its rich vegetation), but it is subject of
58 THE WONDER OF LIFE
course to the vicissitudes of day and night (unknown in
the Deep Sea) and of the seasons (there is eternal winter
in the Deep Sea). The vicissitudes of temperature are
much more marked than in the Open Sea. With its tides
and storms and floods, the shore-area is on the whole very
difficult and ' trying '. Its tenants must be familiar with
what has been called ' the discipline of dislodgment'.
We may refer to the wreckage of life seen in the jetsam
after a heavy storm, to the effects of a very hard winter
on the shore population the following summer, and to the
long-lasting effects of the last eruption of Vesuvius on the
fine littoral fauna of the Bay of Naples.
There are, it is true, circumstances in which the life of
the shore is sheltered from much of the mercilessness of
the physical forces we are thinking of the deep holes whose
sides are unsecured except by the severest storms, the
sunny shallows on the inner side of the breakwater formed
by a barrier coral-reef, the stretches of lagoon protected
by a mangrove belt a mile broad, and the great mud-line
itself where wave-action has ceased. These are instances
of conditions where delicate organisms may live a sheltered
life even within the littoral area, but in most cases the
reverse is much nearer the truth. The shore is a hard
school where lessons are driven home with blows and where
risks are continuous. It furnishes many illustrations con-
firming Tennyson's conclusion in regard to one aspect of
organic Nature :
That life is not as idle ore
But iron dug from central gloom
And heated hot with burning fears
And dipped in baths of hissing tears
And battered by the shocks of doom
To shape and use.
FlG. 19. Shore scene in the Mediterranean, showing sea-horses,
the red coral of commerce in the left upper corner, a branching
red Alcyonarian, and a tube-inhabiting worm.
58 >W. WONDER OF
coare* fc* ** 11 in
fchf I?- nter
u: tl- are
r-i-K-b "-R;" u<: *&flt must be familiar with
*' ecu' i scipline of dislodgment'.
fTeckngy tjf life seen in the jetsam
tb effects of a very hard winter
the folJowiog sximmer, and to the
the last eruption of Vesuvius on the
the Bay of Naples.
.c, oircum:- ivhich the life of
sniwoiis .nfi^nfiiwiibgM sHl ni anaoa . 9ioH8 . I .Oil
B .ismoo isqqu rial aHl ni soiammoD lo Ifiioo bai srli
.nnow sniiidBfini-sduJ B bns .nBriBnoyoIA bai
side of th< T formed
> stretches of la;. td
broad, and
' n has ceased. These are instances
organisms may
:. J8Hnm] area, but in most cases the
truth. The shore is a hard
t h blows and where
; .uy illustrations con-
.rd to one aspect of
'>ars
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 59
A Representative Fauna. The shore-fauna is cer-
tainly the most representative of all faunas. What pic-
tures rise in the mind ! Swiftly moving Infusorians lash-
ing their way through the water ; Foraminifera with
beautiful shells of lime slowly gliding on the fronds of sea-
weed ; calcareous sponges like little vases and more irregular
flinty- and- horny sponges, sometimes coating the rocks like
the common crumb-of-bread sponge, sometimes growing
in beds like the plants they were once supposed to be ;
hydroid zoophytes like miniature trees on rock or sea-
weed ; sea-anemones and corals often like beds of flowers,
living an easy-going life, waiting for food to drop into
their mouths, or stinging small passers-by ; unsegmented
worms such as the ' living films ' which glide on the sea-
weeds or stones like mysteriously moving leaves, and the
Nemertines or ribbon-worms, also covered with cilia, but
provided with a remarkable protrusible proboscis, some-
times ejected so violently as a weapon that it breaks off
altogether and wriggles like a worm itself ; the higher
ringed worms or Annelids in extraordinary numbers, like
Nereis, Phyllodoce, and Aphrodite itself, so beautiful in
themselves and in their names that we can understand
the enthusiasm of the expert who is said to have named
his seven daughters after seven favourite Polychaets ; the
starfish creeping up the rocks with their strange hydraulic
locomotor system, the brittle- stars using their lithe arms
like gymnasts, the sea-urchins tumbling along on the tips
of their teeth, and the sluggish sea-cucumbers plunging
their tentacles into the mud and then into their mouths ;
the beautiful colonies of ' Moss-animals ' or Bryozoa,
crusting stone and weed as if with lace, or forming leaf-like
fronds like the sea-mat (Flustra), which was one of the
60 THE WONDER OF LIFE
first animals Charles Darwin worked at, or growing into
calcareous tufts as if in mimicry of corals ; myriads of
Crustaceans, such as water-fleas, acorn-shells, beach-
fleas, sandhoppers, no-body crabs, sea-slaters, shrimps,
hermit-crabs, and shore-crabs proper ; strange sea-spiders,
neither crustaceans nor spiders, like Pycnogonum littorale,
clambering among the seaweeds and hydroids ; an occa-
sional insect and even myriopod about high tide mark ;
spiders in the caves and among the dry rocks ; bivalves
innumerable, such as cockles and mussels, oysters and
razor-fish ; herbivorous gasteropods like periwinkles, and
voracious carnivores like the dog- whelks and buckies ;
sedentary limpets with a slight range of movement and a
slight memory for locality, since beyond a narrow radius
they fail to find their way home ; an occasional cuttle-
fish caught in a shore-pool and many more further out ;
a large representation of ascidians or sea-squirts, both
simple and compound, which lie at the base of the Verte-
brate series ; thelancelets (Amphioxus) buried all but their
mouth in the fine sand ; true shore-fishes Like sand-eels
and gunnels and shannies ; an occasional reptile like the
lizard Amblyrhynchus which swims out among the rocks,
or a poisonous sea-snake, or a turtle coming ashore to lay
her eggs ; numerous shore-birds like oyster- catcher and
rock pipit, gull and cormorant ; and an occasional mammal
like otter and seal on the whole a more representative
fauna than in any other life-area.
We must not, of course, include among the shore animals
strayed pelagic forms, such as jellyfishes, which are often
stranded in enormous numbers. Millions of inwafted
" Night-Light " Infusorians, Noctiluca, sometimes form a
reddish brown ridge on the beach, but one might as well
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 61
include a stranded whale in the littoral fauna. As we shall
see later on, many of the distinctive littoral animals pass
through a pelagic phase, but that again is a different matter.
Our point at present is the simple one, that there is much
in the jetsam which does not belong to the shore.
Keen Struggle for Existence. It is evident that the
shore-area must be characterized by a keen struggle for
existence. In the open sea there is practically no limit to
the floating room and swimming room, but the shore is
narrow and crowded. In a rock pool there is often no
vacant niche. There is competition even for foothold. It is
important for instance that the limpet which makes little
journeys in search of seaweed to nibble should not go too
far, else it will not find its way back, and will have lost
the spot which its shell has grown to fit. It is curious, too,
to see the American slipper-limpet one growing on the
top of another to the number of four or five suggestive
of the root-idea of a sky-scraper.
There is abundant food in the shore-area, for there is
a great crop of seaweeds to start with, but there is nothing
to compare with the pelagic sea-meadows an inexhaustible
supply of microscopic Algae extending for square mile after
square mile, and for many feet in depth. Thus on the
shore there is much more struggle for food competition
around the platter. It is lessened by the fact that there
is considerable variety in the dietary, some being carnivor-
ous, others vegetarian, others feeding on microscopic ani-
mals, and others on debris, but one must remember that
even the crumbs of organic matter, formed on the shore or
brought down by rivers, are always being swept away by
the undercurrent to greater depths. The most must be
made of them before they are lost.
62 THE WONDER OF LIFE
We often see ' nutritive chains ' the worm feeding on
debris, the crab feeding on the worm, the shore-fish swallow-
ing the crab, the herring gull with a swoop lifting the fish
from near the surface of the water, the skua gull chivying
the herring gull and forcing it to relinquish its booty.
There are hundreds of similar concatenations.
There is struggle for foothold, struggle for food, and
struggle against dislodgment ; and it takes every form
from a literal struggle for subsistence to a competition
for luxuries, from a life and death combat to a rivalry
of wits. The oyster-catcher tries to knock the limpet off
the rock with a dexterous stroke of its strong bill, the limpet
tries to hold fast ; the carnivorous sea-slug sometimes
secreting dilute sulphuric acid from its mouth tries to
bore through the back of a starfish which may succeed in
dislodging its enemy by creeping under a low shelf of rock ;
the hermit-crab seizes a worm, the worm breaks into two,
and the hermit-crab falls in among the tentacles of a large
sea-anemone. In a thousand forms there is that reacting
against difficulties and limitations which is the essence of
the struggle for existence.
In illustration of weapons in more detail, let us take the
case of the sea-urchin. Among the large spines on its
test there are minute ones (pedicellarise) with three snap-
ping blades. They suggest three-bladed shears on the end of
a long flexible stalk. Some of them help to grapple food-
particles, some keep the test clean, and others, as Prouho
and von Uexkiill showed, give poisonous bites. On the
dorsal surface of the beautiful golden-yellow heart-urchin,
Echinocardium ftavescens, there are many of these poisonous
' gemmiform pedicellariae ' which have been observed to
work very effectively. G-andolfi Horny old put a small
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 63
Annelid worm on the back of the heart-urchin and watched
the spines snap at it. A reddish fluid flowed out from
their tips and the worm was dead after a few minutes of
violent wriggling. The minute pedicellarise then separated
themselves off from the test and remained imbedded in
the worm. They all broke at the same place, just at the
joint between the base of the spine and the test, and some
of them were re-grown in about a month. The re-growth
of these weapons is interesting, and it may be recalled that
the common sea-urchin (Echinus) has also the power of
regenerating its spines and these only. Because of the
globular nature of its body it is not exposed to the risk of
losing parts, and we can thus understand why it does not
exhibit autotomy and re-growth on the scale illustrated
by the starfish and the brittle-star.
In connexion with the pedicellariae, it is interesting to
notice that a starfish will get the better of a small sea-
urchin by applying first one and then another of its arms,
to the spiny surface, getting it well nipped by pedicellarise,
and then wrenching off a whole crowd. It does this per-
sistently over and over again until the sea-urchin is robbed
of all its weapons.
As an illustration of armour the sea-urchin might also
serve, but let us turn to Molluscs. Every one who knows
the molluscs of the shore, or has enjoyed a ' beauty-feast '
looking over the cases of shells in a museum, must have
been struck with the solidity of many of these encasements
and with the frequently elaborate outgrowths from the
surface knobs, shelves, roughnesses, peaks, undulations,
and what not. There is a suggestion of sheer exuberance
about many of them, and it looks as if there were a waste
of shell-making material and energy. The explanation is
64 THE WONDER OF LIFE
probably in part physiological though as yet beyond
statement for instance that the deposition of conchin and
carbonate of lime by the skin or mantle may be an organized
way of dealing with the waste products of the animal's
body, and perhaps also with by-products of digestion.
This must remain vague in the meantime, and therefore we
turn with pleasure to a secondary or oacological explanation
which has been suggested by Mr. Cyril Crossland that the
thickness of the shell and the outgrowths on it must be
credited with protective value. The shell-eating fish
Balistes prefers the bivalves with weaker shells. Another
enemy, the boring gastropod Murex, kills more of those
with smoother shells. It kills large numbers of Margariti-
fera mauritii, which has small and weak outgrowths on its
shell ; it kills few of another species, Margaritifera mar-
garitifera, which has large strong processes remaining for
at least six years. It seems that the strong processes on
the surface of the shell prevent the Murex from readily
getting a firm hold with its foot, and without this it cannot
work the drill in its mouth that it uses to bore through
the bivalve's defences. In some species of bivalve the
outgrowths of tli3 shell are larger in the young forms, and
they are of the greater value therefore during the relatively
more active period when the young pearl oyster, or hammer-
shell (Avicula), or Tridacna, is crawling about and seeking
a suitable place for settling down on. Mr. Crossland' s
suggestion may require modification, but he backs it up
with definite facts showing the actual life-saving value
not of the armour merely, but also of the decorations which
it bears.
When the Murex gets a good grip on a relatively smooth
shell it drills a hole through, and allows some paralysing
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 65
mucus to enter ; but there is a quicker method. ' It finds
the flexible edge of the shell, then by contractions of its
foot breaks a piece away. The mucus of the foot is then
poured out in quantities, and this has some poisonous effect,
as the bivalve, while still untouched, ceases to respond to
the stimuli which ordinarily cause a smart closure of the
shell '. If the shell is covered with rough decoration the
Murex finds the burglary more difficult.
Infantile Mortality. The shore is a ' congested dis-
trict ' ; the birth-rate is high ; the infantile mortality is
enormous. Under the ledges of the rocks and in the crevices
we find in abundance the neat little
vase-like cases, we may almost say
cocoons, which the dog-whelk (Pur-
pur a lapillus) forms for its eggs.
They change from a light pink to FIG. 20. Three egg-
a straw colour. Each is the scene
of a tragedy. If we examine a freshly Purpura
. fastened to the
formed vase we find that it contains roc k.
scores of eggs. Later on, we find only
about half a dozen embryos. What has become of the
majority ? Careful examination at intervals shows that
some of the eggs get the start of others in their development,
and that the leaders devour the laggards, and continue to
lead because they do so. The same is true in the egg-
capsules of the great whelk or ' Buckie ' (Buccinum
undatum) cases reminding one of the fruits of hops,
cemented together into balls often the size of an orange,
or much larger. Inside each capsule there is the same
grim elimination the survivors use their fellows as other
embryos use the yolk of the egg. There is no lack of
brutal frankness in some of Nature's ways, ' so careful
F
66 THE WONDER OF LIFE
of the type she seems, so careless of the single life ' ; for
here we have cannibalism in the cradle, the straggle for
existence at the very threshold of life.
In the pool where we gathered the Purpura capsules, we
may see the beautiful Tubularians, e.g. Tubularia indivisa,
waving their tentacles, and it is interesting to remember that
in the ovary of Tubularia, as in that of the freshwater
Hydra, there is a struggle for existence among the numer-
ous possible eggs. A few survive in Tubularia, one sur-
vives in Hydra ; it is a case of engulfing the other ova.
Thus we see how wide the conception of the struggle for
existence really is that it applies even to the germ-cells ;
and our thoughts pass on to Weismann's daring speculation
that there may be a struggle between the ancestral con-
tributions which make up the inheritance within the egg.
Speaking of ' infantile mortality ' leads us naturally
to think of the various ways in which it is lessened. These
show an interesting parallelism with rational methods in
operation in mankind. The first method is to transport the
delicate young lives from the rough-and-tumble life of the
seashore to the open water. Starfishes, sea-urchins, and
their allies, many worms of diverse kinds, many crustaceans
and molluscs have delicate larvaB, altogether unsuited to
stand the hard conditions of the shore, but admirably
suited for a period of pelagic swimming or drifting. It is
true enough that Death often finds them there also, but
they are certainly much safer than near the shore.
It is an interesting question whether the pelagic habit
of the larvae of some shore animals is an indication that
the cradle of the stock to which they belong was the open
sea, just as the littoral habit of the robber-crab's young
is an indication of the original shore home of this terrestrial
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 67
FIG. 21. Free-swimming pelagic larval starfish the Bipinnaria of
Luidia enormously enlarged, showing transparent larval body (A)
with curious processes, and the young starfish (B) being formed.
(After Mclntosh.)
animal. Or is it a quite secondary new departure on the
part of what one may call autochthonous shore animals,
this getting their young into a relatively safer area ? Is
it similar to the case of the aquatic habit of the larvae of
many insects, such as gnats and mayflies, which is believed
to be quite secondary ? There is most to be said for the
view that the pelagic phase of some shore-animals is
secondary. The larvae are often highly specialized in
relation to open-sea life, and not the least like ancestral
forms. In certain cases the first view may be enter-
tained.
Parental Care. Keturning to the avoidance of infantile
mortality, another method of life-saving is to increase
parental care and nurture ; and the shore is rich in illus-
68
THE WONDER OF LIFE
trations of that. One of the British starfishes, Asterias
mulleri, seems to skip the usual free-swimming larval stage,
for a specimen has been seen on the shore with the
miniature young ones crawling about on their mother's
body, as shown in the subjoined figure of one of the Chal-
lenger starfishes. The marine leech, or skate-sucker, lays
FIG. 22. A starfish, Leptoptychaster kerguelensis, with the young ones
(Y), clambering about on the mother, the free -swimming larval stage
having been suppressed. (After the Challenger Report.)
its eggs in the empty shell of a bivalve mollusc, and mounts
guard over them week after week, carefully removing any
mud or debris that might smother them. In a number
of shore crustaceans the young are carried about by the
mother, and may move about on her body in a very quaint
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE
69
way, now
hanging on
to her an-
tennae and
again to her
tail. It is
the male sea-
spider or
Pycn o g o d
that gets hold
of the eggs
and carries
them about
attached to a
pair of ap-
pendages, and
it is likewise
the male sea-
horse (Hippo-
campus) who
stows away
the eggs in a
c apacious
breast pocket
and carries
them there
till they are
hatched.
We cannot
exhaust our
admiration
for the male
V
FIG. 23. Nest of the fifteen-spined Stickleback,
Gasterosteus spinachia, among the seaweed!
E. A bunch of eggs. (From a specimen.)
70 THE WONDER OF LIFE
stickleback, which makes a nest among the seaweeds, and
watches over his offspring with a remarkable devotion. At
the breeding season he is gorgeously coloured in red, orange
and green, and is like a fragment of rainbow in the pool.
With strange glutinous threads, which come from his
kidneys, he ties fronds of seaweed together into a nest
with an entrance and an exit and a little room in the middle.
Thither he manages to lead his mate, who lays her eggs
in the nest and returns to everyday pursuits. The male
it is who mounts guard and drives off intruders, often much
larger than himself a fine example of a big soul in a little
body. When the young are hatched, like animated com-
mas in the water, his labours do not cease, for he seems
to spend his day in tending them driving them in at
one door, only to see them reappear forthwith by the other.
Another striking case is that of the lumpsucker or cock-
paidle (Cycloptems lumens], a quaint sea-shore fish which
has its pelvic fins shunted forwards and transformed into
an adhesive sucker which takes a firm grip of the rocks.
The female lays a large mass of reddish eggs in a recess
of a deep rock-pool about the low tide-mark, and the male
mounts guard over them. He becomes greatly excited
at the approach of an intruder, but what is even more
interesting is the way in which he every now and then
lashes his tail vigorously from side to side close by the
mass of eggs. The result of this performance is that the
eggs are washed free of the mud or debris that settles on
them, and it is difficult not to believe that the lumpsucker
is aware of what he is about. He has been known to guard
the eggs so anxiously that even meals were neglected.
The infantile mortality may be lessened, as we have
seen, by a migration to open water, or by an increase of
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 71
nurture. It may be counteracted, though not lessened,
by enormous multiplication ; and that expedient is also
familiar on the shore. A single oyster may have sixty
million eggs which leaves a considerable margin for
deaths. We may recall also the famous case of the palolo-
worms (Eunice viridis) of the coral-reefs of Samoa and
elsewhere. Once a year, with striking regularity, myriads
of these worms crawl out tail foremost from the crevices
they inhabit, and agitate themselves so violently that
while the head end remains in the rock the posterior ends
drop off and make the water ' like vermicelli soup'. These
headless worm-bodies are laden with egg-cells and sperm-
cells, and these are shed in countless millions in the water,
so that the fertilization is quite secure. The swarming
begins shortly before sunrise, and it is mostly over in half
an hour. Everything is extraordinary the sharp punc-
tuation of the time of reproduction (different in Pacific
and Atlantic), the subtle stimulus of the moonlight and
the sunrise, the discharge of the multitudinous writhing
bodies, the profuse sowing of the seed ; but perhaps the
most extraordinary thing is the evasion of the death -
penalty which reproduction, especially exuberant repro-
duction, often involves for the parent. For the heads
remain in the reefs and grow new bodies at their leisure.
Given stimulating and hazardous conditions of life,
and keen competition among organisms, we expect to
find special adaptations, and the shore is full of them.
We have already referred to effective armour, such as
we see in crab and whelk. These have also their weapons
and so have many of the unarmoured, such as sea-anemones
and ribbon- worms (Nemerteans). Starfishes and brittle-
stars and many others illustrate the adaptation of ' auto-
72 THE WONDER OF LIFE
tomy ' or self -mutilation, losing a member or part, but
saving the whole life, and able at leisure to regrow what
they have lost. Protective colour-resemblance is frequent,
as we may see in young shore-crabs (Carcinus mcenas)
which show many different colours and patterns, and
are often most effectively like the substratum of the rock-
pool on which they rest. We shall discuss later on the
extraordinary power of protective colour-change in some
prawns (Hippolyte varians), and that of young flat-fishes,
as they assimilate themselves to the sand or gravel, is not
less perfect, though within a narrower radius. The sand-
crab (Hyas araneus) and others mask their carapace with
seaweed, so that they move about under an innocent
disguise, anticipating on their own line such human tricks
as ' the walking wood of Birnam'. And this is only the
beginning of a list of life-saving adaptations in the shore-
area.
We cannot pass from this brief study of the littoral
fauna without recalling the probability that it was on
the sea-shore that many of the most valuable of vital
acquisitions were made. Many of the great types of
animal life have been to school on the shore, and who
shall say what lessons they did not learn amid that rough-
and-tumble life, where changes come often, where competi-
tion is keen, where the discipline of dislodgment is ever
recurrent, where a premium is put on alertness and per-
sistence and adaptability ? The shore has been a great
school of life. Yet in saying this we do not wish to imply
that the wisdom of any animal race whatsoever has been
due to the premiums which individuals have paid to
experience. For this theory of entailment does not seem
to us to describe Nature's method.
FIG. 24. Animals associated with Posidonia Oceania, a sea-grass.
Three pieces of leaf are shown. (After Issel.) A. 1 . A Hydroid,
Plumularia (Monotheca) obliqua. 2. An Isopod, Idothea
hectica, protectively coloured. 3. A Bryozoon, Membranipora
pilosa, and small patches of another, Microporella malusii. B.
4. A small fish, Lepadogaster bimaculatus, protectively coloured.
5. Growth of coralline, a calcareous Alga. C. 6. Membrani-
pora. 7. A Hydroid, Sertularia mediterranea.
72
THF
tomy' or self-
saving the wh
they have lost
as we may 'JH
which sho
are often i
pool on w.
extra--- 1
but
it Insure vhat
'Qt,
>dnus mcsnas)
re and patterns, and
:(>stratum of the rock-
'.' >::all discuss later on the
olour-change in some
that of young flat-fishes,
gravel, is not
. rrowei s >e sand-
.r- mask their caraace with
,boqoal nA .S
rS .noo^a
.a ii 8 uI E m Blb.oqor.iM
BpHdo ^rliono
A . ,*
.Wiohs ^o
-
,
an iti .
shall -
and-tiunc
tion is k^'
recurrent, v
sistence an"
school of life. ;
that the wisdou
experience. For this
A
"3 of
aQ d wn o
. ai dd that rough-
- where competi-
islodgment is ever
'"rtness and per-
a been a great
-t wish to imply
- een
1 to
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 73
Peculiar Conditions. There are many peculiar haunts
of life which must be regarded as subdivisions of the main
haunts, though they have come to have very little in com-
mon with any one of them. Thus we find a peculiar set
of animals in the salt marshes which occur here and there
along the coasts ; in continental salt lakes which have
no connexion with any present sea ; in hot springs where
animals may sometimes be found flourishing at a tem-
perature of 45C.
II. THE PELAGIC FAUNA
The conditions of life for open-sea or pelagic animals
must be regarded as on the whole very favourable. For
there is plenty of room and there are no boundaries to
be dashed against till a shore is reached. A storm can
be avoided by sinking for several fathoms. There is sun-
shine without any risk of drought, and more uniformity
throughout the day and throughout the year than is to
be found elsewhere except in the monotonous abysses of
the deep sea. The extraordinary abundance of micro-
scopic Algae at the surface and down for many fathoms
ensures an inexhaustible food supply for the animals.
There is unlimited ' sea-soup '. It is not surprising, there-
fore, to find that the open sea has been peopled from the
earliest times of which the fossil-bearing rocks give us
any record.
Dr. J. Y. Buchanan, who has given much attention
to the study of the colour of the sea, points out that a
deep olive-green, common in polar latitudes, but not
confined to them, is due to an abundance of diatoms and
to the excretions of animals that live on diatoms. From
the polar ice to beyond the fortieth parallel, the surface
74 THE WONDER OF LIFE
water is a pronounced indigo colour. From the equator
to beyond the thirtieth parallel, the colour of the surface
water is a pure and brilliant ultramarine. The olive-
green, the indigo and the ultramarine are the three great
colour-types of the sea.
Open Sea. One must be careful to notice that pelagic
does not mean at the surface ; it means ' open sea ' and
as far down as clear light reaches. Many small organisms
have their maximum at a depth of 50 fathoms below the
surface, and a great advantage of being several fathoms
down is that a measure of calm is enjoyed. Dr. A. G.
Mayer brings this out very vividly in his memoir on the
Ctenophores or ' sea-gooseberries ' of the Atlantic coasts
of North America fascinatingly beautiful animals of
the Ccelenterate series, distantly related to Medusoids.
' In the extreme tenuity of their bodily substance and
their diaphanous delicacy of coloration, the ctenophores
stand apart from other marine animals. Their presence
in the water is commonly denoted only by the brilliant
flash of rainbow colours, which play along the lines of
their ciliary combs as they move languidly beneath the
unrippled surface of the sea. Yet these creatures are
no more wonderful in their complex organization than
in their remarkable adjustment to their habitat : for so
delicate are most of them that a current such as that of
an oar suffices to tear them into misshapen shreds a fate
which they escape in time of storm by sinking far into
the depths. This fact accounts for the extreme rarity
of many of these forms, for the ocean's surface must have
remained flat as a mirror for many hours before they can
be lured upward from the calm of their deep retreat.'
We must distinguish between the surface plankton
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 75
and the sub-surface plankton, both within the light- limit,
and the bathy-plankton which extends below that limit,
and consists necessarily of animals only.
Swimmers and Drifters. The open- water animals
(Plankton, in the wide sense) are conveniently divided
into the active swimmers, such as fishes, which make up
the Nekton, and the more passive drifters, with relatively
feeble organs of locomotion or none at all, that are swept
about at the mercy of tides and currents. Another general
distinction should be borne in mind, that between the
permanent and the temporary planktonic animals, for
while there are many creatures that spend their whole
existence in the open sea, such as Ctenophores and Portu-
guese Men of War, there are others, which are only there
as larvae, e.g. the swimming bells of littoral zoophytes, and
the young stages of many worms, echinoderms and molluscs.
Representative Pelagic Animals. The pelagic fauna
is made up of a great variety of types, from the pin-head-
like Noctiluca, whose intense luminescence sets the waves
aflame in the short summer darkness, to the great whales
the giants of the present age. The list includes many
Foraminifera (especially the Globigerinids), thousands
of different kinds of Radiolarians (so successful perhaps
because they have partner Algse living inside them), the
active Dinoflagellates (much sought after by small crus-
taceans and even by fishes), many other Infusorians, jelly
fishes or Medusae, often in great fleets, and the swimming-
bells or Medusoids, many of which are the liberated repro-
ductive buds of sedentary zoophytes, strange colonies
known as Siphonophores such as the Portuguese Man of
War and Velella, the delicate Ctenophores which never
come to the surface unless it is very calm, not a few free-
7 6
THE WONDER OF LIFE
swimming ' worms', such as Sagitta like a glass arrow
in the water, a few Holothurians or sea-cucumbers which
have departed widely from the prevalent habit of their
class, a legion of Crustaceans often of surpassing beauty
of colour and form, a few insects
(Halobatidse) the last creatures
one would expect, such molluscs
as the sea-butterflies (Pteropods)
dainties which the whalebone
whale captures in countless
myriads in the great sieve which
hangs down from the yawning
cavern of its mouth, the similarly
light-shelled or shell-less Hetero-
pods and many actively swimming
cuttlefishes, such as the Argonaut,
some Tunicates like the Salps
(often swimming gently in long
transparent chains) and the
' fire-flame ' (Pyrosoma) famous
for its luminescence, numerous
fishes such as flying fishes, a few
turtles and venomous sea-snakes,
such birds as Mother Carey's
Chickens and the flightless pen-
guins, and among mammals the cetaceans large and small.
This abbreviated roll may serve to suggest the representative
character of the pelagic fauna. Within the pelagic fauna it
seems right to include the petrels, since they are distinc-
tively ocean-wanderers, and very seldom come ashore
except for breeding. An ancient race, marked by their
protruding tubular nostrils and their compound bill of
FIG. 25. Halobates, a
pelagic insect, one
of the Hemiptera.
(After Buchanan
White.)
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 77
several horny plates separated by deep grooves, the petrels
appear to have been very successful, for they are to be
found in all the oceans including the Arctic and Antarctic
and they are represented by a great variety of types from
the tiny storm petrel to the gigantic albatross which may
have a spread of wing twice the height of a man. As we
have already said, there are many larval forms of shore
animals which pass through a pelagic phase. They cannot
be counted in except for the time being, and the same
must be said of the Leptocephali or transparent young
stages of various eels. Nor can we include such fishes
as salmon and sea-trout, which really belong to the fresh
waters, though so much of their energy is acquired during
their visits to the sea. There are some pelagic animals,
such as the arrow- worms (Sagitta and the like), which we
can think of as having always lived in the open sea, but
most seem to bear the impress of lessons which the open
sea could never have taught them. In such a case as
the Halobatidse (pelagic insects) it is obvious that the
open sea is a secondary home.
Adaptations. Among the adaptations to pelagic life,
the following seem most important. In several ways the
floating capacity is increased : by the formation of gas
reservoirs, such as the great float like a glorified cock's-
comb of the Portuguese Man of War ; by the development
of light and buoyant tissue, as in the jelly of Medusae ;
and by the enormous development of delicate outgrowths
which give the creature a wide surface of contact with
the water, as we see, for instance, in many of the pelagic
Crustaceans. We cannot glance at them without feeling
that architecture of this sort could not survive the sea-
shore conditions for a day.
78 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Many open-sea animals are transparent ; many of those
that live near the surface have beautiful blue and violet
colours, well seen in the Siphonophore Velella and in the
Gasteropod lanthina. It is possible that there is occasion-
ally some adaptiveness in the transparency, though this
quality follows for the most part from the lightness of
build. It must in some cases make the swimmers or
drifters practically invisible. Even in a small bowl of
sea- water it is very difficult to see an arrow-worm (Sagitta)
or the like, and it is very interesting to watch in a large
aquarium how the quite unique Venus's girdle (Cestus
veneris), which is at once transparent and iridescent, is
conspicuous at one moment a creature of positively daz-
zling beauty and invisible the next. Some pelagic
fishes, such as a quaint little sea-horse, which live among
the Sargasso weed, have the body reddish brown, but the
fins, which are spread out in the open water, are a beautiful
transparent blue. It is no argument against the theory
that transparency is advantageous to point out that it
is often of no avail, e.g. when the great Cetacean catches
thousands of sea-butterflies in its net.
There is evidently a considerable intensity of life in
some of the Plankton animals, for their movements are
practically ceaseless, and their sensory equipment, especi-
ally in the way of eyes and balancing organs, is often very
remarkable. Many are ' phosphorescent ', such as Nocti-
luca, Ctenophores, Pyrosoma, but the vital significance
of this remains a riddle. Many move about in shoals,
which indicate prolific reproduction and great abundance
of food. The numbers are greatest in the colder seas,
which is probably due to the fact that at low temperatures
growth and development are slowed, the life is drawn out,
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 79
and more generations are living at the same time. In
some cases the large number of different species, within
a relatively narrow radius, is very characteristic. Thus
there are over 5,000 species of Radiolarians. This, per-
haps, means that the conditions of life are relatively easy
and Natural Selection not very stringent.
There is much still to learn in regard to the vital economy
of the sea, for instance as to the food supply. It has
been calculated by Putter and Dakin that the ' producers '
(the plant-plankton) are often insufficient for the ' con-
sumers ' (the animal plankton), and Dr. Dakin has also
maintained that, even if there were enough of food, it
would be ' an altogether unthinkable piece of work ' for
the animal to catch enough to cover its physiological
expenditure. Dr. Dakin calculates that a sponge sixty
grammes in weight would require to filter several thousand
times its own volume of water per hour in order to obtain
sufficient food, which sounds a somewhat formidable
task. A big jellyfish, he calculates, would require over
seven millions of nauplius larvae per day, which is literally
a large order. ' It is quite impossible for such large quanti-
ties to be caught, and equally strange that remains of the
creatures are so rarely found, if they have been captured
as food '. Perhaps it is too soon, however, to be very
confident in regard to the amount of organic material that
a creature like a sponge or jellyfish requires to cover the
loss due to its metabolism.
Prof. Piitter's view is that many marine animals are
in a way saprophytic feeding on the organic compounds
contained in solution in the water. He regards the sea
as a great reservoir of dissolved foodstuffs (compounds
of carbon other than carbonates, and compounds of nitrogen
8o THE WONDER OF LIFE
other than ammonia, nitrates and nitrites). The question
is, how much of this foodstuff there really is; and here
the doctors differ. It is quite possible that organs with a
large surface, notably gills, have a directly nutritive value.
Prof. Putter's strongest argument is simply that the solid
food-supplies taken in by various types e.g. sponge and
crustacean are not sufficient to account for the chemical
changes that are known to go on. But the comparative
physiology of marine invertebrates is still very young. In
any case we must not too hurriedly dismiss the idea that
there may be, especially in crowded zones, a sort of perma-
nent ' stock ' to the sea-soup. Every one who has examined,
even with the fingers, the foam that is blown ashore from
a rich littoral region after a storm, will agree that
there may be much dissolved organic matter in the water.
But this is no matter for opinion. It remains to be seen,
by careful analysis and after elimination of all the plankton,
how far it is true that there is bread in the waters.
Recent investigations at Port Erin Biological Station,
by Prof. Benjamin Moore and others, have not in the least
confirmed Putter's view. Of great importance beyond
doubt in the economy of the sea are the extremely minute
organisms of the ' dwarf plankton,' so small that they
pass through the interstices of fine silk cloth (see
Fig. 34).
There are very interesting seasonal variations in the
amount of the Plankton, the two maxima being in spring
and autumn. Waves of abundance follow one another
in a regular order ; thus there is usually to begin with
a great multiplication of Diatoms, then of Dinoflagellata,
and then of Copepods. The reasons for the seasonal varia-
tions are still being investigated, but there is indication
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 81
that the spring exuberance depends largely on the sun-
light, and partly on the temperature of the water and
vertical currents in the sea which aid in the circulation
of food materials.
III. THE ABYSSAL FAUNA
Every one has seen more or less of the other haunts of
life, but no one has had any vision of the Deep Sea the
abyssal region beyond the light limit and the plant limit.
Many have been within a stone's throw, or drop rather,
of it ; a few have had the rare experience of dredging
from its distant floor ; many have examined Deep-Sea
animals in museums ; but no one has ever seen its secrets
in their natural setting.
The study of the Deep Sea is relatively modern, but
its progress has been strikingly rapid. In 1818 Sir John
Ross dredged a brittle-star (Astrophyton) from 800-1,000
fathoms, but this discovery appears to have supplied no
stimulus. In 1841 Edward Forbes dredged without
result in deep water in the Mediterranean, and Sir James
Ross's similar attempts in 1847 were not more successful.
Naturalists of the middle of the nineteenth century spoke
of the Deep Sea as an abyss where life is either extinct, or
exhibits but a few sparks to mark its lingering presence.
In 1860, however, when the cable from Sardinia to Algiers
was lifted for repair from a depth of 1,000 fathoms, fifteen
animals were found attached to it a discovery which fired
enthusiasm. Surgeon-General Wallich should be remem-
bered, we think, as one of the early pioneers, along with
W. B. Carpenter, Huxley and Wyville Thomson. The
cruises of the Lightning (1868) and the Porcupine (1870)
G
82 THE WONDER OF LIFE
showed that most of the invertebrate types were represented
at depths of 600 fathoms or more. These preliminary
samplings led on to the famous voyage of the Challenger
(1872-76), which, like Darwin's voyage on the Beagle,
may be ranked as a Columbus voyage in the history of
biology. Darwin's voyage led to the discovery of a new
world for the evolution idea made everything new ; the
Challenger voyage led practically to the discovery of the
new world of the Deep Sea. Under Wyville Thomson's
leadership the explorers cruised for three and a half years
over the wide oceans, crossing the Atlantic rive times,
covering 68,900 nautical miles, reaching down with the
long arm of the dredge to depths equal to reversed Hima-
layas, raising treasures of animal life from over five hundred
stations, and bringing home spoils which have taken forty
huge volumes to describe. The results, under Sir John
Murray's editorship, have supplied a broad foundation
for the science of oceanography, and given a powerful and
lasting impulse to zoology in general.
Without dwelling on historical facts, we venture to call
attention to three points. (1) It was out of a practical
task that the stimulus to Deep-Sea exploration arose,
and there has been on the part of science some repayment
of this debt. (2) What happened is a warning against
dogmatism. It is not very long since an authority spoke
of the floor of the Deep Sea as ' an area regarding which
nothing was known, nor could be known ' ; and now there
is a large library of descriptive reports. (3) What the
Challenger began has been followed up by expeditions
from most of the countries of Europe and by the magnifi-
cent work of the late Professor Alexander Agassiz in
America.
FIG. 27. Deep-sea Crinoid (Metacrinus), showing the attaching * roots ' (R), the
stalk (ST) g 1 vmg oft cirri ' (ci), and the calyx (CA) with ten feathered arms (A).
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 83
Physical Conditions
(1) Depth. The average depth of the sea is about 2|
miles, and over 80 per cent, of the sea-floor lies at a depth
of over a thousand fathoms. Thus the greater part of the
Deep Sea is very deep. It is, indeed, a remarkable fact
that the great abyssal plain, deeper than 1,700 fathoms,
extends over about 100 millions of square miles, which is
more than a half of the entire superficial area of the earth
(197 million square miles, of which 57 millions, say 30 per
cent., are terrestrial, and 140 millions, say 70 per cent.,
are marine).
Here and there in the Deep Sea there are tremendous
depths, technically called ' deeps', of over 3,000 fathoms ;
and eight soundings of over 5,000 fathoms have now been
taken. Among these is the famous ' Challenger deep '
in the North- West Pacific, of 5,269 fathoms, nearly six
miles, in which Mount Everest would be more than en-
gulfed. In fact, its summit would be 2,600 feet below the
surface. Another instance is the ' Swire deep ', off Min-
danoa, of 5,348 fathoms, over six miles, in which Mount
Everest might be submerged with 3,087 feet to spare. It
is easy to calculate the vertical distance between the top
of Mount Everest and the foot of the Swire deep.
(2) Pressure. From the weight of water, which great
depth implies, it follows that there must be enormous
pressure in the Deep Sea. At 2,500 fathoms it is 2| tons on
the square inch, perhaps twenty-five times as much as the
pressure in the cylinder of an engine that drives an average
railway engine. Even the water is compressed and bodies
into which the water cannot penetrate quickly enough are
squeezed almost beyond recognition when they are sunk
84 THE WONDER OF LIFE
to great depths. The Challenger explorers found that a
piece of wood sunk to the abysses was so heavy when
pulled up again that it sank in water. The muscles of a
dead animal, such as a whale, must undergo a tremendous
compression if the carcass sinks.
FIG. 28. Deep-Sea Pycnogonid or " Sea Spider," Pipetta, with extra-
ordinary length of limb in proportion to the size of the body. The
males carry the eggs. (After Loman .)
When a whale fills its lungs and ' sounds ', remaining
below the surface for ten minutes at a time (as the Prince of
Monaco proved), its body may be subjected to a consider-
able increase of pressure, which the ribs in particular have
to withstand. Mr. J. Y. Buchanan suggests that the
occurrence of a number of broken and repaired ribs on one
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 85
side of a whalebone whale's skeleton preserved in the
Museum of Monaco may be a record of the animal's having
gone beyond the limit of safety. He recalls Paul Bert's
experiment, in which the pressure of the air in the lungs of
a dog was reduced by a not very large fraction of an atmo-
sphere, with the result that the thorax collapsed with
every rib broken.
(3) Temperature. The sun's heat is lost at about 150
fathoms, and the Deep Sea is therefore intensely cold.
With relatively little variation (2 or 3 Fahr.) in the year,
the temperature remains near the freezing point of fresh-
water (32 Fahr.). The bottom temperature may be below
30 Fahr. in Polar waters, and over 90 per cent, of the whole
sea-floor it may be said that an eternal winter reigns.
What a contrast this is to the surface conditions, which
may show an annual variation of 50 in one area, and which
show such extremes as 26 Fahr. off Nova Scotia and 96 in
the Persian Gulf ! The variations and extremes on land
are still more marked.
The coldness of the deep water seems to be mainly due
to a flow of cold bottom-water from the Southern and
Antarctic oceans towards the equator, and in a less degree
to a similar flow from the sub- Arctic region. The causes
of this flow are complex, but the oceanographers refer to
the great intertropical evaporation, to the action of extra-
tropical winds which blow the surface-waters polewards,
to ' the head of water ' which is accumulated in high lati-
tudes by the action of the prevailing winds, and to the
greater density of the water in high latitudes. As temper-
ature affects the solubility of gases in water, cold water
being able to absorb more than warm water, the polar
waters contain more oxygen than elsewhere, and the
86 THE WONDER OF LIFE
equatorial movement of bottom- water rich in oxygen must
be of considerable biological importance for the animals of
the Deep Sea.
(4) Darkness. There is but little penetration of light
beyond 250 fathoms, so that the world of the Deep Sea is
in utter darkness, save only in so far as that is relieved by
gleams of ' phosphorescent ' light. In some places where
there is much of this luminescence, it may be that the
scene is like the ill-lighted suburbs of a town on a very dark
night, or like a moorland with no light save from the stars.
In his 1911 cruise on the Michael Sars, the late Sir John
Murray found that the light limit had been under-esti-
mated. By using more delicate apparatus, notably the
Helland-Hansen photometer, he was able to show that
there is a clear effect at 300 fathoms, and some effect at
500 fathoms, which is about half a mile down. At 900
fathoms no effect of light was detectable. These were
very sensitive tests, however, and for practical purpose
we may still say that there is very little light below 250
fathoms.
(5) Calm and Silent. Another physical feature is the
pervading calm, for the severest storms are shallow in
their grip, and though the cold polar water is ever creeping
along the bottom towards the equator, this is a relatively
slow movement. Only in a few places is there evidence of
what may be called a current. If there were rapid move-
ment the deep ooze which covers vast areas of the sea-floor
would be raised in whirling clouds. Thus we must think
of the deep sea as extraordinarily still and quiet, for there
can be no noise to break the abiding silence of the abysses.
(6) Monotony. There is some variety in the composi-
tion of the sea-floor, for the remains of calcareous organisms
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 87
predominate in some places and of siliceous organisms in
others, and the debris called ' red clay ' is found in the
deepest parts of all. But otherwise monotony prevails.
There is no scenery, except that here and there a ridge
stretches like a watershed, or a volcanic cone rises abruptly
to the surface, or a great depression leads into one of the
' deeps'. Otherwise there are great stretches of undulating
plain, like very flat sand-dunes, or like a great desert.
There is no sound and echo, no day and night, no summer
and winter in the monotonous Deep Sea. It is all silence,
all night, all winter. Apart from the animals altogether,
what a remarkable picture rises in the mind a picture of
the forever unseen a strange, dark, cold, calm, silent,
monotonous world!
Biological Conditions
(a) The first big fact, the establishment of which we owe
to the Challenger expedition, is that there is practically no
depth-limit to the distribution of animal life. Wherever
the long arm of the dredge has been able to reach, there
are organisms and plenty of them. It is astonishing to
read of Sir John Murray and Dr. Hjort using an otter
trawl, with fifty feet of spread, at a depth of 2,820 fathoms
(over three miles), and using it very successfully. It
should be noticed that there are some thinly peopled
areas sea-floor deserts, so to speak ; that there is a richer
population at the more moderate depths; that there are
more animals on the calcareous ooze than elsewhere; and
that there are probably thinly-peopled zones between the
bottom and the light-limit. But the big fact is that there
is no ' deep ' too deep for life.
88 THE WONDER OF LIFE
(6) Plantless. The second big fact is that, beyond the
sunk resting stages of some simple Algse, there are no plants
in the Deep Sea. This follows from the absence of light,
and it involves as a consequence that all the Deep-Sea
animals must be either carnivorous or devourers of debris.
There are the usual ' nutritive chains ' abyssal fish eating
abyssal crustacean, and that eating worm, and that eating
still smaller fry ; but since they cannot all be eating one
another there must be some extraneous food-supply. That
is afforded by the gentle and ceaseless rain of small organ-
isms, killed by vicissitudes in the pelagic meadows over-
head, and sinking through the miles of water like snow-
flakes falling on a very still day. Investigation all goes to
show that while big corpses like those of fishes are doubt-
less all to the good if they reach the bottom undevoured,
what counts for the Deep-Sea basal food-supply is the rain
of microscopic atomies.
(c) No Bacteria. There are abundant bacteria in the
sea, in the economy of which they play a very important
role, but there seem to be none in the great abysses. It is
interesting to know of one place in the wide world where
there are no microbes. From their absence it follows that
there is no rottenness ; everything is devoured in the great
clearing-house. The whale's carcass is picked bare, by
crustaceans in particular ; the skeleton is dissolved
away till only the stone-like ear-bones are left. Of the
great shark everything soon disappears save the teeth.
(d) Representative Fauna. The animal population of the
abysses includes representatives of most of the classes of
animals from Protozoa to Fishes. Let us run through the
list. There are many kinds of Foraminifera and a few
Radiolarians (not including, of course, the sunk shells of
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE
surface forms
of both these
types) ; there
are many
siliceous
sponges, but
no calcareous
ones ; there
are sea-ane-
mones and
some related
corals and
very decora-
tive Alcyona-
rians ; Anne-
lids and some
other ' worms '
burrow in the
ooze ; Echi-
n o d e r m s
abound
starfishes,
brittle - stars,
sea - urchins,
sea -cucum-
bers, and
sea-lil i e s
swaying on
their stalks
like daffodils FIG 29 ._ Three Pennatulidg
with very long stalks.
I. Chunella ; II. Funicu-
lina; III. Urabellula.
by the lake-
side ; Crusta-
THE WONDER OF LIFE
ceans have a rich representation at many levels of com-
plexity, and there are quaint Sea-Spiders or Pycnogonids
which are neither spiders nor crustaceans ; most of the
molluscan types are in abundant evidence ; and finally
there is a weird army of voracious abyssal fishes.
Adaptations. A common feature in the sedentary
Deep-Sea animals is the possession of long stalks on which
the more essential parts of the body are raised high out
of the treacherous ooze. We
see this useful adaptation in
the surpassingly beautiful
Crinoids which grow some-
times in great beds, in
Alcyonarians such as Umbel-
lulas and Funiculinas, and in
some of the sponges like the
Glass-Rope-Sponge. In some
of the Alcyonarians the sup-
porting stalk which bears the
colony of polyps on its sum-
mit may be over a yard in
length.
A similar adaptation is seen
in the extraordinarily long
limbs which many of the
Crustaceans and Sea-Spiders
exhibit. They illustrate an
FIG. 30. Deep-Sea Brittle extreme of lankiness and they
Star or Ophiuroid, Astro- J
charis virgo, showing the may be thought of as walking
onstilte. In many cases the
liable to breakage and limbs are several times longer
the very small central
disc. (4/terKoehler.) than the body. There can
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 91
be little doubt that these elongated limbs are suitable for
moving delicately on the soft surface. Some of the Deep-
Sea Brittle-stars show a great reduction of the central disc
and a great elongation of the arms as compared with shallow
water forms. It may be noted that the extraordinary
elongation of limbs and the like is quite incompatible with
any conditions except those of perfect calm.
Many Deep-Sea animals are very delicately built, with
bodies thoroughly permeable by water. A delicate struc-
ture like Venus's Flower Basket (Euplectella) which is
shivered in a child's fingers, is admirably suited to great
depths where there are tons of pressure on the square inch.
The whole body is open to the water and the pressure is not
felt. For while a hermetically sealed glass vessel is crushed
in when it is lowered into deep water, an open glass vessel,
no matter how delicate, is not affected. On the Challenger
expedition, Mr. J. Y. Buchanan made an instructive experi-
ment which has been often cited. He took a hermetically-
sealed empty glass cylinder, wrapped it up in flannel, en-
closed it in a copper cylinder with perforated ends, and
lowered it to 2,000 fathoms. At a certain depth the glass
cylinder was shivered into snowy powder, for its walls could
not withstand the increasing outside pressure of the water.
The shivering took place so suddenly that before water
could rush in to fill the vacant space, one side of the
copper cylinder caved in. As Prof. Wy ville Thomson said,
an ' implosion ', not an explosion, occurred.
When an abyssal fish rising suddenly gets into a zone of
much reduced pressure, the gas in its swim-bladder, which
had its pressure adjusted to the greater depth, expands,
and the fish, in spite of itself, is hurried to the surface,
' tumbling upwards', as Professor Hickson puts it. The
92 THE WONDER OF LIFE
transition is too rapid for a readjustment to be effected.
It is well known that Deep-Sea fishes brought up in the
dredge are apt to suffer explosion and distortion in the
ascent.
Another adaptation that leaps to the eye is the specializa-
tion of tactile appliances, as is natural enough in a world of
darkness. There may be antennae longer than the whole
body, groping a long distance ahead, so that the animal
can feel its way as a blind man does with his stick. Many
of the long legs of crustaceans bear tactile bristles and many
of the fishes have long slender barbules stretching back-
wards from the chin or from the fins. They are often well-
innervated and their suitability for the conditions is evident
enough.
An Extraordinary Deep -Sea Cuttlefish. As an
example of an extraordinary abyssal type, we may take
Cirrothauma murrayi, one of the captures of the Michael
Sars North Atlantic Deep-Sea Expedition of 1910, which
was carried out under the auspices of the Norwegian Govern-
ment and the superintendence of the late Sir John Murray
and Dr. Johan Hjort. Three thousand metres of wire were
out when this new cuttlefish, which has been carefully de-
scribed by Prof. Chun, was captured, and it is a wonder
that it came up in a condition to be examined. For its
fragility recalled that of a Ctenophore, which is saying a
good deal ; the body was gelatinous and semi-transparent ;
a delicate web united the arms, through the whole length of
which the nerves could be seen shining. The gelatinous
body had an exceedingly faint violet colour, while the parts
round the mouth and the basal portions of the arms showed
the purple chocolate colour which occurs in many Deep-Sea
animals. While most cuttlefishes are covered with chroma-
FIG. 31. Deep-sea Cuttlefish, Cirrothauma murrayi. (After Chun.)
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 93
tophores, this denizen of the great depths had only one,
' a rhombic chromatophore between the two fins '. The
arms bore some normal suckers, but each had thirty-six
others of minute size, flattened and without sucking disc,
and showing in each case in the long spindle-shaped and
clumsy stalk a curious structure which may be a lumines-
cent organ and reflector.
The eyes are of interest, in illustration of the subtlety
of life. There are Deep-Sea cuttlefishes with small eyes,
as one might expect, but this is the only case, recorded
as yet (1914), in which the actual structure of the eye is
involved. For this cuttlefish is blind ! The eye is minute,
without a lens, with a very degenerate retina and optic
nerve. Nature is economical, as we say in metaphor ;
but here she seems to have been parsimonious to a degree
almost hazardous. The degeneration of thisCephalopod's
eye has gone further than in many blind vertebrates. It
is adaptive, apparently, to conditions of abyssal darkness ;
but surely it remains sensitive to the luminescent sparkles
of its own arms and the prey they grope for.
Problems of Deep -Sea Fauna.
There are many unsolved problems in the Deep Sea,
and one of the most obvious of these is the frequent occur-
rence of 'phosphorescence'. It is seen in animals of high and
low degree ; it is exhibited by sedentary animals and by
free swimmers ; it is associated with a great variety of
highly specialized organs ; and these are occasionally
situated on most extraordinary places near the end of the
tail, on the tip of a long flexible rod, inside the mantle-
cavity of a cuttlefish, or inside the gill-chamber of a crusta-
94 THE WONDER OF LIFE
cean. It is so common that it surely has some significance.
Perhaps it has different meanings in different animals,
and there is no lack of suggestions. May it be sometimes
a lure, attracting victims, who come like moths to the
candle ? Is it sometimes an advertisement on the part of
unpalatable creatures, warning off intruders and molesters,
as the rattlesnake does with its rattle ? Does it some-
times serve as a lantern, guiding the active animal to its
prey ? Of course that would not apply to cases where
the light is at the hind end ! Does it serve in some cases
as a ' recognition mark ', enabling those of the same kin
to know one another ? In some fishes the disposition of
the luminescent organs on the body is different in the two
sexes. But phosphorescence, as it is called, remains an
unsolved problem.
Another difficulty is raised by the fact that there is so
much colour in Deep-Sea animals. What can be the use of
that in an abode of darkness ? There are many reds, e.g.
in Crustaceans and Anemones ; there are shades of orange
and yellow ; there are some instances of beautiful blue ;
there is almost no green. It is noteworthy that there is
very little in the way of spots or stripes, most of the animals
being all one colour. It is probable enough that there is
no utilitarian interpretation of these Deep -Sea colours,
which may be simple by-effects of useful structures and
functions. It may be that the Deep-Sea colours are like
those in withering leaves without utility in themselves.
The autumn colouring of withering leaves is largely due
to the ebbing vitality, just as floral colouring is largely due
to intense vitality. Decomposition products in the former,
waste products in the latter may not be chemically far
apart. But while the pigmentation of the flowers is turned
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE
95
to good account as a means of attracting insects, no one
has ever suggested any utility in the gorgeous colours of
the autumn woods. They are the outcome of very im-
portant physiological processes, but they are not them-
selves of use ; and the same is probably true of the reds
and other bright hues of many abyssal animals.
Another general problem the most general of all is
raised by the fact that many Deep-Sea animals are quite
closely related to shore animals, with essentially the
FIG. 32. Two Deep-Sea Fishes.
L, Luminous organ.
same functions discharged by essentially the same organs,
and yet under such different conditions of temperature and
pressure. Processes of digestive fermentation, for in-
stance, which go on in shore animals in the warmth of
the Tropics, are also going on on the floor of the Deep Sea
at a temperature near the freezing-point of fresh water.
We know that warmth up to a certain limit hastens growth ;
we should like to have facts in regard to the rate of
growth in the eternal winter of the Deep Sea.
96 THE WONDER OF LIFE
In reporting on the free- living marine Nematodes
collected at Cape Royds on the Shackleton Expedition,
Mr. N. A. Cobb refers to the same problem of vigorous life
in extraordinary conditions. Hundreds of specimens,
males, females, and young, were taken from a mere thimble-
ful of the dredgings. They seem to be rather smaller
than species in warmer seas, but they do not seem to be
less prolific. ' It is hardly conceivable that the body
temperature of the marine polar species is higher than that
of the water in which they live, namely, near the freezing
point of fresh water, and yet, in spite of the freezing tem-
perature, and the long polar night, nematode protoplasm
seems to glide on through its mitosis dance to much the
same purpose as if bathed in equatorial light and ensconced
in the warm pools of tropical reefs.'
Of detailed problems there is a long list, but we must
be content with one illustration. It concerns the eyes
of fishes. When we take a series of fishes from various
depths, starting with the shore, we find that some of those
from moderate depths (300-600 fathoms) have very large
eyes, and it seems reasonable to interpret this as an adapta-
tion to the failing light. We also find that some of those
from great depths, of over 1,000 fathoms, have very small
eyes, and it seems reasonable to associate this with the
darkness. A useless eye will tend to dwindle, for the
individuals with least of it will get on best. But the difficulty
is that, along with the abyssal fishes with very small eyes,
there are others which have very large ones. It is difficult
to see how both conditions can be adaptive. Two sugges-
tions have been made : that those abyssal fishes with
large eyes are relatively newcomers, in which the
dwindling process has not begun, or that they are
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 97
adapted to make use of the gleams of phosphorescent
light.
The Question of Origin. As to the origin of the
Deep-Sea fauna, the evidence points to the conclusion that
the abysses have been persistently colonized age after age
by migrants from the shore and from the ' Mud-Line'.
There is a marked resemblance between certain representa-
tives of the Deep-Sea fauna in a given region and representa-
tives of an adjacent shore fauna. Quite a number of Deep-
Sea animals have affinities with Polar animals. It is un-
likely that the Deep-Sea fauna was established long before
the Cretaceous times, and perhaps the cooling of the Poles
and the setting up of a bottom-movement equatorwards
of cold water rich in oxygen was one of the conditions of
the abysses becoming a home of life. The rarity of primi-
tive types in the Deep Sea shows that we cannot regard
the fauna as made up of relics of very ancient days.
Professor Johannes Walther calls attention to the signifi-
cant fact that no Palaeozoic types occur in the present Deep-
Sea fauna. Archaic forms like Lingula (lamp-shell), Limu-
lus (king-crab), Nautilus, Pleurotomaria, Mytilus, Serpula,
and Astropecten are littoral, not abyssal. The present-day
Deep-Sea animals do not date back further than the
Triassic period, and some of them are closely related to
Cretaceous types. Walther works on to the interesting
suggestion that the enormous elevation-movements which
led to the Hercynian range in Europe, the Appalachians in
America, and Sudanese mountains in Africa were associ-
ated with complementary depressions which formed the
great abysses of the ocean.
The Wonder of the Deep Sea. In one of his last
writings Herbert Spencer complained of the unreflective
9 8 THE WONDER OF LIFE
mood among cultured and uncultured alike, ' which does
not perceive with what mysteries we are surrounded'.
' By those who know much', he said, ' more than by those
who know little, is there felt the need for explanation'.
' What ', for instance, ' must one say of the life, minute,
multitudinous, degraded, which, covering the ocean floor,
occupies by far the larger part of the earth's area ; and
which yet, growing and decaying in utter darkness, pre-
sents hundreds of species of a single type ' ? This raises
the question of the deeper significance of the abyssal fauna.
In the first place, it seems useful to remind ourselves
that a knowledge of the Deep Sea has cut into human life ;
it has been of value to mankind, practically, in connexion
with laying cables (and that has meant much) ; intellectu-
ally, for it has been an exercise-ground for the scientific
investigator ; emotionally, for there is perhaps no more
striking modern gift to the imagination than the picture
which explorers have given of the eerie, cold, dark, calm,
silent, plantless, monotonous, but thickly peopled world of
the Deep Sea.
Yet this cannot be its full meaning. So perhaps we get
nearer the heart of the problem when we recognize the
simple fact that the Deep Sea is an integral part of the
whole. Just as the making of the great ' deeps ' was corre-
lated with the raising of great mountains, so the abyssal
fauna is wrapped up with the whole vital economy of the
Earth. For it is the overflow basin of the great fountain of
life whose arch is sunlit. It is necessary to the wholesome-
ness of the ocean. It is the universal clearing-house.
And perhaps we may go a little deeper still, for when we
recognize that insurgent life which will not be gainsaid has
conquered the abyssal desert, that this by-way is full of
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 99
beauty not surpassed elsewhere, and especially that there
is here the same order and rationality and pervasive pur-
posiveness that we find elsewhere, then we begin to perceive
that the life of the Deep Sea is part of the embodiment of
what appears to us as a great thought. To the question
of significance, which forces us far beyond Science, William
Watson has given us the poet's answer :
Nay, what is nature's
Self, but an endless
Strife towards music,
Euphony, rhyme ?
Trees in their blooming,
Tides in their flowing,
Stars in their circling,
Tremble with song.
God on His throne is
Eldest of poets,
Unto His measures
Moveth the whole.
IV. THE FRESHWATER FAUNA
The systematic study of the freshwater fauna began
before that of the shore or of the deep sea, for men like
Reaumur (1683-1757), Rosel von Rosenhof (1705-1759),
and Trembley (1700-1784), who had the joy of discovering
and naming some of the commonest inhabitants of our
lakes and ponds, laid broad and deep foundations before
there was much in the way of marine zoology. But when
the fauna of the sea began to be systematically studied,
attention was in great measure charmed away from the
freshwaters, and it is only in the last quarter of a century
or so that this haunt of life has begun again to receive its
due share of investigation.
ioo THE WONDER OF LIFE
It is said that the freshwaters occupy about 1,800,000
square miles, but that is a small fraction of the total of
about 197,000,000 for the earth's surface. In some
countries, however, the freshwater area is very considerable;
thus in Finland it is estimated at about 13 per cent. The
relative smallness of the freshwaters is made up for in a way
by the scattered distribution and the correlated great
diversity in character. How many different forms there
are, with no unity except in the word fresh the large
deep lake with storms like those at sea, the mountain tarn
with its dark mysterious surface, the shallow pond with a
population in many respects different from that of the
lake, the ephemeral pool, the permanent well, the swamp,
the ditch, the brook and the river. Nor do these exhaust
the list; thus in a detailed German classification we find
a special subdivision for water-pipe fauna. It is recorded
that before the improvement of the filtering in connexion
with the water-supply of a large town on the Continent,
no fewer than sixty-one animals were obtained from the
pipes including eels, sticklebacks, water-snails, insect
larvae, worms, and the freshwater sponge. For practical
purposes, it may be noted, large intruders are often unim-
portant. The serious thing is when some fungus, like
Crenothrix, takes up its abode in the pipes.
Of the various forms which accumulations of fresh water
may assume, the lake or loch is most important. It is
distinguished from the pond not so much by its size as by
depth, which reaches a maximum in Lake Baikal, with its
760 fathoms. In typical lakes we can readily distinguish
(1) the relatively shallow shore-area, (2) the open water,
and (3) the dark quiet dreary plain at the foot of the steep
slope or talus which runs from the shore-shelf downwards.
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 101
Thus in true lakes, as in the sea, we have to distinguish
a littoral, a pelagic, and an abyssal fauna.
Physical Conditions. The physical conditions of
freshwater basins are of course very diverse, and they
determine noteworthy differences in the fauna and flora.
Thus it is well known that certain organisms, such as
the stonewort Chara, and the freshwater crayfish, Astacus,
require that there be a relatively large percentage of
carbonate of lime in the water, while others, like the fresh-
water mussels, do not thrive if there is.
Concerning temperature, it is obvious that in summer
that of the surface is higher, while in winter, especially
when there is ice, that of the bottom is higher. Averages
on the surface for the four seasons read like this : Spring
6-7 C., Summer 17-8 C., Autumn 11-9 C., Winter 3'9 C.
In summer, or indeed for about 280 days in the year, when
the warmer water is at the top, there is a decrease down
to 4 C., the temperature of water at its greatest density,
but the decrease downwards is not uniform there being
a strange leap between 5 and 10 fathoms. In winter, for
about 85 days in the year, when the colder water is at the
top, there is an increase downwards until 4 C. is reached.
For a short time twice a year, the temperature is practically
uniform throughout. It should also be remembered
that for each 5 fathoms there is almost an additional
atmosphere of pressure.
The degree of illumination is of vital importance as
regards the distribution of both plants and animals, and
the depth to which light can penetrate varies considerably,
especially with the purity and colour of the water. The
red rays are lost first, the violet rays go deepest. A
common average result with a white plate is that it ceases
102 THE WONDER OF LIFE
to be visible at about 3 fathoms, but we have to multiply
this by two since the light has to travel up again from the
plate, so that a common average for light-penetration is 6
fathoms. In very clear water, as in the Lake of Constance
in winter, the figure may rise to over 12 fathoms. And
this must be further extended if we take the chemical rays
into account, for silver chloride paper is affected at 55
fathoms and silver bromide paper at over 90 fathoms.
The diverse coloration of freshwater basins raises a
number of interesting and difficult questions. Chemically
pure water is said to have an azure blue colour. The
addition of numberless impalpable dust particles pro-
duces a yellowish tint, which along with the primitive blue
gives green. Thus we have to thank the dust for the
colour of the lake as well as of the clouds overhead. But
the green is often in part due to millions of unicellular
Algae. A tawny yellow, familiar in the rivers of the Scottish
Highlands, may be produced by abundance of dissolved
organic matter humic acid and the like. A most remark-
able iridescence of water is sometimes seen when the sur-
face is covered with millions of the translucent moulted
cuticles of water-fleas, but the splendour of this has to be
seen to be believed. The practical importance of the colour
of the water is in connexion with its penetrability by light ;
the blue water is most penetrable, the green less, the yellow
still less.
Various Lacustrine Regions. The littoral or shore
area of the lake may be broad or narrow according to the
configuration of the lake. Like the corresponding sea-
shore area, it is subject to great vicissitudes diurnal and
seasonal, it is often full of movement, it is strongly illumined,
it has a rich vegetation, and it is often crowded with
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 103
animals. It is marked by such plants as the stonewort
(Cham), mare's tail (Hippuris), pond- weeds (Potamogeton),
duckweed (Lemna), water-lilies, Ranunculus lingua, Alisma
pkmtago, bog-bean, and so forth. Some show interesting
adaptations of mobility and elasticity suited to the turbu-
lence of the shore.
As to the animal life, it is varied. By the shore there
may be nests of gulls and wild duck, of coot and moorhen.
The shallows are the home of frogs and sticklebacks, of carp
and miller's thumb (Cottus gobio). The freshwater mussels
plough their leisurely way along the mud ; the water-snails
glide back downwards along the surface-film. The water-
spider weaves her diving-bell nest, and beautifully coloured
water-mites rush to and fro. There are countless Crus-
taceans, like Daphnia and Sida, Diaptomus and Cyclops ;
fixed Rotifers like Floscularia and Melicerta miracles of
beauty ; some equally fascinating freshwater Polyzoa ;
simple Planarian worms wafting themselves along the water
weed by their unseen cilia ; besides Hydra and freshwater
sponges and many Protozoa. We have given samples
enough to show that the shore of the lake has a very
representative fauna.
The second great region in lakes is the open water,
tenanted by a pelagic or limnial fauna and flora. The
vegetation is represented by numerous Alga3, by duck-
weed and Ceratophyllum, by the beautiful rootless Bladder-
wort (Utricularia) with its neat traps for water-fleas.
Some show gas vesicles which ensure floating. As to
animals, there are Infusorians (e.g. species of Ceratium
and Peridinium), numerous Rotifers, legions of water-
fleas, not a few water-mites (such as Atax crassipes and
Curvipes rotundus), a few insect larvae, e.g. of Corethra
104 THE WONDER OF LIFE
plumicornis, and also the larval stages of some shore forms,
e.g. of the bivalve Dreissensia. In the transparency, the
delicacy of build, and the occasional presence of long pro-
cesses believed to be useful in drifting we see adaptations
to the open water life.
The success of a lake depends to a large extent upon
the open water population, and waxes and wanes with its
vicissitudes. A few forms are almost uniformly abundant
all the year round, but the majority show a marked periodi-
city. Thus the Rotifer Synchceta has its climax in spring,
and there may be about three millions to the square yard
in April. The well-known Diatom, Melosira varians, has
two maxima in the year, one in July and one in October,
and may attain in the last-named month to the astonishing
abundance of about 7,000 millions to the square yard.
The slimy Alga, Clathrocystis aeruginosa, has its climax
about August, with about 500 millions to the square yard.
Others, again, have their maximum in winter, such as the
Copepod Crustacean, Diaptomus gracilis, whose propor-
tionate representation for the four seasons is indicated by
the figures 760 for April, 7,900 for August, 31,160 for
September, and 121,290 for January. The broad fact to
be realized is that the upper layers of the open water are
the chief productive areas, where the Algae utilize the
energy of the sunlight to build up the carbon-compounds
which form the fundamental food supply of all the lacustrine
population.
The third great region is that of the greater depths of
the lake, a region of uniformity, where there is neither
day nor night, where the temperature is low and relatively
uniform, where the pressure is very great, where there are
no movements apart from life, and where there is usually
FIG. 33. Three closely related species of Cyclops. A. Cyclops
distinctus. B. Cyclops fuscus. C. Cyclops albidus, probably
a hybrid between the other two. All the specimens shown
are females. The median eye is well seen. (After Neubaur.)
1. Antenna. 2. Antennule. 3. Egg-sac. 4. Caudal filaments.
104
Tttfe WONDER OF LIFE
plumicomts, ai
e.g. of the biv
delicacy <>i *;>**
ceases bali***
to the >. w
The >.'^--a*
the or* -
t&*r Urvi *<*g*s *rf some shore forms,
rcMtewi*, In fcbc transparency. the
:&? :*'-** ;<**.< presence of long pro-
aptations
to a large extent upon
axes and wanes with its
ost uniformly abundant
show a marked periodi-
has its climax in spring,
hons to the square yard
i. Mdosira varians, has
.A .2qoby3 ^o sabsqa
.aubidb gqoIoyD -D
nworfe ansmbsqe aHl IIA .owl
ia\\K) .nase Haw ai
Oopep
the figures-- -'&> ,
be re*.l!3*Ji
TJM ; ,- ;
energy uf it>> wtak^'
which f onii
population.
The third great n$.
the lake, a region f vfli
day nor night, where cfcc
uniform, where the pnaeu
no movements apart
- ,a ,8yl?ndaib
isHlo sHj.nMvd^ g n ^
ys niiibani arfT .limpf STB
.s^nnaJriA .S .finnainA ' : .1
Lrd.
t, eh as the
--'-^c prupor-
' iicated by
ut, 31,160 for
broan fact to
- 'ien water are
?.ie Algae utilize the
? ca : n compounds
- y of all the lacustrine
le greater depths of
y, where there is neither
ture is low and relatively
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 105
much mud. It is the least populous region. Since it is
dark, there are practically no plants except Bacteria and
the like. The animal population includes Amoebae and
their relatives (e.g. species of Difflugia and Arcella),
Infusorians like Stentor and Vorticella, a deep-water reddish
Hydra, simple Turbellarian and Nematode worms, others
of higher degree like Nais, some species of Fredericella
and Paludicella among Polyzoa, a number of Crustaceans
(e.g. blind species of Cyclops and Asellus), some insect
larvae, e.g. of the harlequin fly, a few water-mites like
Hygrobates, a few molluscs like the bivalve Pisidium
Jioferi and the Gastropod Limncea abyssicola, and finally
a few fishes like the giant Silurus and its small counterpart,
the burbot (Lota vulgaris), which is one of the hosts of the
young stages of the formidable human tapeworm (Bothrio-
cephalus lotus), thus linking up the dark depths of the lake
into connexion with human life.
In regard to other freshwaters, such as ponds and rivers,
it must suffice to say that each has its distinctive fauna,
and that the population in rivers is much less abundant
than elsewhere. In the actual current of the Rhine,
Lauterborn found only twenty Rotifers, two Crustaceans,
nine Protozoa, and two Diatoms ; but of course this number
is greatly increased when we take account of the creatures
e.g. larval insects that creep about on the stones and
among the weed. Wherever there is stagnancy, e.g. in
the pools of the overflow bed, we find much the same
fauna as in ponds. As to ponds, while there are a few
forms, e.g. Leptodora hyalina, which occur both in ponds
and lakes, the fauna of the shallow pond is usually quite
different from that of a true lake. Thus no one expects to
find a Crustacean like Byotrephes longimanus in a pond.
io6 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Inter -Relations. There are many good instances
among freshwater animals of the way in which the life of
one creature becomes wrapped up with that of another.
We shall afterwards refer to the extraordinary fact that
the continuance of the race of freshwater mussels depends
on the presence of minnows and other small fishes, while
on the other hand, the continuance of the freshwater fish
known as the bitterling (Rhodeus amarus) depends on the
presence of freshwater mussels. The young stages of the
liver-fluke of the sheep are spent within the small fresh-
water snail (Lymnceus truncatulus), and the larvae of the
formidable guinea-worm of man are found inside certain
species of water-flea or Cyclops. Some tropical freshwater
fishes feed greedily on the aquatic larvae of mosquitoes and
thus help to lessen malaria which is due to a microscopic
animal temporarily parasitic in the insects. There are
endless nutritive chains of great practical importance.
Thus the voracious cormorants so often shot down on the
shores of the estuary, where they certainly engulf many
fishes, are not to be dismissed so summarily, for in certain
localities they keep down the eels and crabs which destroy
the fry of valuable species. Some freshwater fishes feed
on crustaceans and insect-larvae, which feed on minute
organisms, which, again, depend on decaying organic
matter. The insectivorous bladderwort (Utricularia)
catches small animals in its neat traps and these are said
to be utilized by the water-spider. As we shall see, some
caddis- worms spread nets for the ' dwarf -plankton,' and
the green freshwater Hydra owes its colour and its success
to having entered into partnership with very minute
Algae which live within the cells of its inner or endodermic
layer.
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 107
Adaptations. Many freshwater animals run the risk
of being periodically dried up, and there is a series of
remarkable adaptations to meet this vicissitude. Many
are able to survive prolonged desiccation. They are
masters of the art of ' lying low and saying nothing ', as
Brer Rabbit phrased it. The capacity is illustrated by
some Protozoa, Nematodes, Rotifers, Bear-Animalcules,
Entomostracan Crustaceans, and Mites, but in some cases
what survives is not the animal itself but an enclosed egg
or germ.
Writing in the Annals and Magazine of Natural History
in 1898, Mr. Atkinson noted that forty years before he had
taken some samples of mud from the ancient pool of Gihon,
outside the Jaffa Gate of Jerusalem, which at that time
contained water for only two months of the year. The
dry mud was sent to England and moistened, with the
result that Dr. Baird found in the culture six new species
of living Entomostraca or water-fleas. For eight years in
succession, at the Leeds Philosophical Society's Museum,
the mud was dried up in summer and moistened again in
spring, and its tenants still persisted. Not that any one
individual was known to persist, but multiplication in
summer always provided individuals or resting eggs to
carry on the torch for another period. In one case, a small
sample was left dry in a pill box for nine years, and then
moistened, with the result that in a fortnight a single
specimen of Estheria gihoni made its appearance. Here
the torch was kept burning, either by an individual or more
probably by a resting egg, throughout the desiccation of
nine years. In another case, the alternation of drought
and moisture was kept up artificially for twenty-four years,
with unvarying success as regarded persistence of vitality.
io8 THE WONDER OF LIFE
It is well known that specimens of the brine-shrimp
(Artemia) can often be got by keeping a solution of Tidman's
Sea-Salt for some days till the desiccated germs hatch out.
Belonging to another series are the adaptations which
enable freshwater animals to meet the winter, which in
northern countries sets a spell on many forms of life. It
sends many to sleep, like the frog in the mud by the pond
side mouth shut, nostrils shut, eyes shut, breathing by
its skin like a worm, and with its heart beating ever so
feebly. It sends others to the deeper sleep of death, for
just as winter prunes the trees, so it sifts the fauna of the
pond. There is severe elimination, and it is therefore
very interesting to notice the ' winter- eggs ' of water-fleas
and Rotifers which are able to withstand great severities
of temperature, and the strange ' statoblasts ' or resistent
germs of Polyzoa, and similar adaptations for surviving
difficulties by a Fabian policy of waiting. A good example
is the freshwater sponge, which spreads exuberantly over
stones and submerged roots in the summer, but soon feels
the pinch in autumn. The body of the sponge dies away,
and rots away, but in the skeletal framework, which
cannot rot, clumps of cells are formed, buttressed round
by capstan-like flinty spicules, and these gemmuks, as they
are called, persist as foci of life while the parental corpse
disintegrates. When the spring comes and the rivers are
in flood after the melting of the snow, the sponge skeleton
is broken and the gemmules are carried hither and thither,
many, perhaps most, to destruction, a few to find a harbour
in suitable crevices where they may proceed to develop
into early summer sponges.
In times of severe frost many animals seek safety in the
mud a refuge from being imprisoned in the ice. There
FIG. 34. Magnification of a piece of fine ' Miiller's gauze ' used in tow-netting, showing
the organisms of the dwarf plankton or ' Nannoplankton,' which are minute enough
to pass through the invisible pores of the cloth. (After Lohmann.)
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 109
is undoubtedly severe elimination, but there are some
tough creatures which do not necessarily die even when
encased in ice. Provided that they can form small cavities
around themselves, they may last till the thaw comes ;
thus a leech has been known to survive forty- eight hours
in a block of ice. The worst case is when the ice is thick
on a shallow pond, for then there is risk of suffocation ;
oxygen becomes scarce ; sulphuretted hydrogen and
ammonia accumulate ; the fishes come eagerly to holes in
the ice ; and there is often great mortality. We are
impressed, however, by life's toughness as well as by its
fragility ; thus the water-snail, Limnceus stagnalis, may
be seen creeping quite actively on the under surface of the
ice. Leeches and eels are also notable for their powers
of resistance. We are familiar with the contrast between
the crowded and busy life of the pond and loch in summer
and the clear deserted appearance in winter, but the fact is
that the water is seldom so empty as it looks. There is
plentiful life in some of the Alpine lakes which are frozen
most of the year ; and in the depth of winter in Britain
and similar countries there may be abundant representa-
tion of ' water-fleas', rotifers, bear-animalcules, infusorians,
amoebae, and other small animals.
Vital Economy of the Freshwaters. The population
of a freshwater basin may be divided into producers,
consumers, and middlemen. The raw materials consist of
air, water, and salts, which the producers, the green plants,
work up, with the help of the sunlight, into complex
carbon compounds. These are utilized by the consumers,
the animals, who dissipate the stores of energy which the
plants have accumulated. The middlemen are in great
part the Bacteria, which often make vegetable products
no THE WONDER OF LIFE
more available for animal use, and also break up the
dead bodies of animals into material that can be used by
plants as food.
Besides Bacteria there are other extremely minute
forms of life which play an important part in the vital
economy of the freshwaters. Such are the Desmids,
Diatoms, Phyto-flagellates, and Zoo-flagellates which
Prof. Lohmann of Kiel sums up in the word Nannoplankton
(or Dwarf-plankton). They are so minute that they pass
easily through the meshes of the finest silk gauze, and
they are best collected by centrifuging samples of the
water at a high rate of speed. Their importance lies in
their extremely rapid multiplication and in the fact that
some of them are producers of the organic out of the inor-
ganic, while others are middlemen between the dead and
the living.
The securely established general idea of fundamental
importance is that which Liebig did much to promulgate
the idea of the circulation of matter. Apart from a
few permanent products like the Travertine of Tivoli,
the oolitic material on the shores of the Great Salt Lake,
and deposits of siliceous diatom-earth, everything about
the lake is in a state of flux. Place a box with water,
some mud, and some animal manure beside the fish pond,
and arrange it so that there may be a periodic discharge
from near the surface. Bacteria multiply and work their
way with the manure ; Infusorians multiply and form food
for Daphnids and other ' water-fleas ' ; these trickle in a
living cascade into the pond ; the fishes are fed, and the
fisherman's table is served. The chain may be longer or
shorter ; Diatoms, Rotifers, Worms and so on may share in
the ceaseless reincarnation of material that goes on. If the
FIG. 35. Microscopic organisms of the dwarf plankton or ' Nannoplankton.' (After
Lohmann.) 1. Halteria rubra, a ciliated Infusorian, with a symbiotic Alga
inside it. 2. Meringosphaera mediterranea, a unicellular Alga, with long pro-
jecting processes. 3. A Chrysomonad with projecting rods on its shell. 4. A
Monad. 5. Cladopyxis setifera, a Peridinid Infusorian. 6. A Coccolith,
Rhabdosphsra claviger. 7. A unicellular Alga, Chaetoceras gracile. 8.
Phytoflagellate, Eutreptia.
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE in
fisherman should have the bad luck to capsize his basket,
he might get the contents back again after many days.
The Bacteria reduce the dead fish to debris which Infu-
sorians devour, and to simple substances which plants
reintroduce into the circle of life. What was part of
the dead fish becomes part of Infusorian and Diatom ; it
enters into a new incarnation in the Crustacean ; it be-
comes again part and parcel of a fish. For it is thus
that the world goes round, and we have a curious bio-
logical commentary on casting bread upon the waters.
An extraordinary outburst of vegetative life is sometimes
seen in canals, extending for many miles, and making
the water like green soup. The phenomenon is due to
various kinds of green Algae, but often it is one kind that
predominates. When this is Oscillator ia, the sight is
especially remarkable, for this type of filamentous blue-
green Alga has the habit of slowly bending backwards and
forwards in the water as if it were trying to break its
vegetative chains.
Origin. When we ask in regard to a freshwater basin,
where its tenants came from, we are led to three answers.
(1) It seems quite clear that a certain number have come
from the sea, either by active migration, as we see the
elvers doing to-day, or by passive transport as in the case
of the freshwater sponges. When we find one family of
sponges (Spongillidse) in freshwater, and a large number
of families in the sea, we may safely conclude that the
freshwater forms had a marine ancestry. Hydra and half
a dozen other Hydrozoa live in freshwater ; all the other
Co3lentera or stinging animals are marine ; we need have
no hesitation in regarding the freshwater forms as derived
from marine ancestors.
H2 THE WONDER OF LIFE
It seems very likely that not a few of the freshwater
animals have migrated gradually from the sea and the sea-
shore, through estuaries and brackish water, to rivers
and lakes. As the possibility of making this transition
depends on the physiological constitution of the animal,
we can understand that similar forms would succeed in
different areas. And this is part of the explanation of
the high degree of uniformity seen in the freshwater faunas
of widely separated areas. The process of migration may
be seen going on at present in the invasion of the Kiel
Canal and in some similar cases. Various shrimps and
the like go far up certain rivers ; the flounder is found
many miles from the sea ; sticklebacks seem to be quite
capable of thriving well in either fresh water or salt ; and
there are hundreds of similar facts.
(2) It has been suggested by Credner, Sollas and others
that some present-day lakes are dwindling remnants of
ancient seas relict- seas in short. Part of an old sea
may become land-locked and be converted in course of
time into a freshwater basin. Or it may be that a present-
day lake which never was as such part of a sea, may be-
come connected with a relict-sea by alterations of land-
level and owe part of its fauna to that circumstance.
There may have been a somewhat uniform pelagic fauna
in the remote past, and that may be part of the explanation
of the uniformity of the fauna in freshwater basins widely
separated from one another. If the land-locked portion
of sea was gradually converted into a freshwater basin,
there would be a stern elimination of non-plastic types,
and since the conditions of elimination would be much
the same everywhere, the result would be uniformity in
the survivors. Mr. J. E. S. Moore has brought forward
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 113
strong evidence to show that the fauna of Lake Tanganyika
includes many molluscs, for instance, which were inhabi-
tants of Jurassic seas. It is very striking to find in Lake
Tanganyika a Gasteropod like Typhobia horei whose
kinship is certainly with marine types.
Several different kinds of freshwater Medusoids (Limno-
codium, Limnocnida) are known from various parts of
the world, and are probably to be interpreted as relicts of
a marine stock. The same may be said of the very simple
freshwater polyp, Microhydra ryderi, reported from North
America and also from Germany. Like numerous marine
hydroids, but unlike the common freshwater Hydra, it
liberates a minute swimming-bell or Medusoid.
It is necessary to distinguish between relict marine
faunas and relict seas. Thus the remarkable population
of Lake Baikal seems to be in part a relict marine fauna,
but there is no evidence in the surrounding deposits to
show that the Lake was ever anything but a freshwater
basin. We must therefore suppose that the marine types
in the lake the seals, for instance migrated from an
ancient sea, along paths now hidden.
Thirty-four fishes are known from Lake Baikal, and
L. S. Berg divides them into those which are general in
Siberian freshwaters (17) and those (also 17) which are
endemic. Of the latter some are related to Siberian forms,
while others (Abyssocotini, Cottocomephoridse and Come-
phoridse) seem quite unique. There are no forms in the
Siberian waters, nor in the Arctic Ocean, nor in the Pacific
which come near these puzzling forms which Berg regards
as very ancient, and perhaps native (autochthonous) to
the Lake. They live at greater depths than any other
freshwater fishes, descending to 1,600 metres.
i
ii4 THE WONDER OF LIFE
(3) Of many of the smaller animals in a freshwater basin,
it is safe to say that they have been transported from some
similar haunt. The same or similar species occur in basins
separated by half the circumference of the globe. And
just as there are distinctive species of mammals and birds
in islands e.g. the Orkney Vole and the St. Kilda Wren
so there are distinctive species of crustaceans and fishes
in lakes, the explanation being in both cases the same, that
local variations have been helped by isolation to become
stable species. A very striking instance may be found in
the large number of different species of char in British lochs.
To explain the widespread faunistic uniformity in fresh-
water basins, Darwin referred to the agency of birds in
carrying organisms or germs of organisms from one fresh-
water basin to another, from one watershed to another ;
to the wafting powers of the wind ; and to changes of land
level which may bring different river beds into communica-
tion. The capture of one river- valley by another running
in a different direction has often occurred, and may have
helped to distribute lacustrine types. It is probable,
however, that birds have been the chief agents in transport.
The startled duck that rises in a hurry from the water
often carries some entangled aquatic plants with it, and
animals on the plants. Thus another pond may be peopled.
In the clodlets of mud on the feet of birds many minute
animals have been found Ostracods, Phyllopods and
Copepods (all sorts of ' water-fleas ' in short), Polyzoa and
Rotifers, and Nematode worms. No fewer than 537
plants were found represented in 6| ounces of mud, and
Darwin got eighty seeds to germinate from one clodlet
from one bird's foot. The role of birds as distributing
agents is well known to be very important for seeds, but
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 115
it is also very important for small animals. A diagrammatic
instance may be found in the occurrence of a freshwater
sponge in a pond in the middle of the sandy Sable Island
which lies out in the Atlantic, a hundred miles from Nova
Scotia.
From Land or Air back to Water. There is a
certain contingent of the freshwater fauna that has arisen
by a sort of turning back of terrestrial and aerial forms.
Just as whales and dolphins are in all probability the
descendants of terrestrial mammals which took secondarily
to the sea, so some freshwater animals, such as aquatic
insects, the water-shrew and the water-vole, the otter and
the beaver, are doubtless the descendants of terrestrial forms.
In this connexion it may be noted that many water
animals are not so much wetted as one might think. In
some water-beetles, such as the whirligig (Gyrinus] and the
water boatman (Notonecta), the body is very partially
wetted. In the water-spider (Argyroneta) considerable
areas of the hairy body refuse to become wet. In the family
of Hydrophilid beetles, some hardly wet at all, some keep
considerable parts of the body dry, and some become wholly
wet. The wetting or not wetting depends on capillary
phenomena, which depend on the structure of the surface
of the body and its hairs or setae. There can be little
doubt that the differences are finely adaptive to slight
differences in habit.
The Water- Spider. In illustration of the interesting
habits of freshwater animals we may take the case of
the water-spider, Argyroneta natans, of which Dr. Wagner
has made a fine study. It is remarkable as an air-breather
which spends most of its life under water, and it is remark-
able among spiders inasmuch as the male is much larger
n6 THE WONDER OF LIFE
than the female. The length of the male's body is about
15 mm. and that of the female about 8 mm. The colour
is reddish-brown to olive-brown, but it has when swimming
a silvery appearance due to bubbles of air which are
entangled among the velvety hairs and shreds of silk which
cover the body. It is in quiet pools where there are abun-
dant water- weeds that this member of a thoroughly terres-
trial race makes itself at home. There are a few other
spiders, e.g. species of Dolomedes and Pirata, which creep
down plants right into the water when danger threatens, and
there are a few others which walk daintily on the surface-
film, but Argyroneta is the only thoroughly sub-aquatic type.
It makes, as every one knows, a dome-shaped web, usually
attached by silk threads, like a tent by its ropes, to water-
weeds and stones, but occasionally fashioned inside a water-
snail's empty shell, or in a hole in a piece of wood. In all
cases it fills its dome with air brought down from the sur-
face, till the result is something between a diving-bell and
a submerged balloon. It has anticipated at least one of
man's many inventions, though it is probably but dimly
aware of its inherited or instinctive skilfulness. There
is no hint of prentice- work in the web that is made in such
peculiar conditions, and it is interesting to notice that the
architecture bears a close resemblance to that of the webs
made by terrestrial members of the same family. For some
reason or other, the pattern worked out in winter is different
from that of the summer web. The webs require frequent
renewal, for inquisitive Gammarids and the like are con-
tinually breaking the moorings. The supply of air has
also to be continually renewed. With this work and with
the pursuit of the water-insects on which it feeds, the
spider is kept busy, but it is able to spare a good deal of
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 117
time for its toilet not exactly in combing its hair, as its
movements suggest, but in arranging its lace, for it carries
little tags of silk disposed over its body.
Unlike most spiders, Argyroneta is very peaceful, as if
its residence in water had cooled its passions. When two
meet they go quietly on, unless they are worried by cap-
tivity or happen to be very hungry when, like creatures
of higher degree, they are apt to be quarrelsome. The
females are patterns of placidity, and are quite free from
the reproach of devouring their mates or would-be mates,
as their terrestrial cousins often do. It has to be remem-
bered in this connexion that they are only about half the
size of the males, the reverse of the usual relative propor-
tions of the sexes among spiders. Within the silken bell
the mother spider carefully disposes the cocoon containing
the eggs, but when these hatch and the young spiders begin
to fend for themselves, she ceases to show any interest
in their movements. Wagner insists that she cares more
about the cocoon than its contents, but it is very difficult
to get mentally near these children of instinct, and it may
be that the impression is as erroneous as that which might
be made by a casual observer of mankind who, looking
down from a great height, maintained that mothers
seemed to give more attention to the cradle or the peram-
bulator than to the content of baby.
V. THE TERRESTRIAL FAUNA
The transition from water to dry land has been many
times effected in the course of animal evolution. Among
backboneless animals, it was negotiated by some of the
Protozoa (Amoebae and Infusorians) that passed from water
to damp earth ; by some of the simpler worm- types (various
n8 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Planarians and Nematodes) ; by the earthworms and land-
leeches ; by a few Crustaceans, such as wood-lice and land-
crabs ; by the archaic Peripatus and its allies widespread
connecting-links between segmented worms and types
like Centipedes ; by the Centipedes themselves and their
allies, such as Millipedes ; by many Insects ; by Spiders,
Scorpions and many Mites ; and by the Pulmonate Gastro-
pods, namely land-snails and land-slugs.
While fishes are, of course, confined to the water, there
are some interesting curiosities. Thus the eel may make
short excursions over the moist grass of the meadow,
and some tropical fishes burrow deep into the mud in
the dry season. In the common Periophthalmus of
tropical shores we have one of those extraordinary excep-
tional cases a fish that can remain for many hours out
of water. The same is true of the interesting double-
breathing mud-fishes (Dipnoi), which have their swim-
bladder turned into a sort of lung, and can live long out
of water. Among backboned animals, the transition from
aquatic to terrestrial life was made in the Carboniferous
Period by the Amphibians, many of which still recapitulate
every year the historically important step passing from
a larval or tadpole gill-breathing life in the water to an
adult lung-breathing life on land. In a few cases, e.g.
the black salamander (Salamandra atra) of the Alps, which
lives above the level of water-pools, and some tree-frogs
which never come to earth, the aquatic gill-breathing stage
is skipped altogether.
In Reptiles, Birds, and Mammals, as every one knows,
there is no trace of gills left in early life (though the tell-
tale gill-clefts remain in the embryo), and the young are
lung-breathers from the time they are born or hatched. A
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 119
secondary return to the water is illustrated by some Reptiles
water-snakes, turtles, crocodilians and a single marine
lizard (Amblyrhynchus) ; by some birds like the flightless
penguins and the pelagic petrels ; by some mammals like
Cetaceans and Sirenians, seals and sea-lions.
Origin. Some terrestrial animals probably passed
from the freshwaters, through the mediation of marsh
and bog. The earthworms form a large cosmopolitan
group, now thoroughly terrestrial and indeed avoiding
very wet places, but the occurrence of three or four aberrant
types (like Alma and Dero) with gills tells the tale of their
historical origin. No one can doubt that the land-leeches
were derived from a freshwater stock, for the great majority
of leeches (Hirudinea) are tenants of the freshwaters. It
is probable that the snails and slugs of dry land originated
from a freshwater stock and there is, of course, no dubiety
in cases like frogs and toads where the larval life is still
spent in the ponds and ditches. The interesting land-crab,
Birgus latro, which goes far up the mountains and even
climbs trees, returns every year to the sea-shore to breed,
and its marine larvae well illustrate the general conclusion
that the habitat of the young forms is the ancestral habitat.
It is possible that the terrestrial Isopods were also derived
from a littoral stock.
If a land-animal has not originated from a freshwater
stock or from a littoral stock, how else could it arise ?
The third mode of origin is from some pre-existing terres-
trial stock. Thus Mammals probably evolved from a
terrestrial Reptile stock, and Reptiles from a terrestrial
Amphibian stock. Thus, again, it is probable that Insects
and Spiders sprang from pre-existing terrestrial stocks of
Arthropods.
I2o THE WONDER OF LIFE
Fundamental Adaptations. Prof. Cuenot has noted
that there are four adaptations essential to thoroughly
terrestrial life. (1) The animal must be able to breathe
dry air, either by the skin (as in earthworms), or by some
special apparatus, such as the air-tubes of insects, the
lung-books of scorpions, the pulmonary chamber of snails,
and the true lungs of Amphibians, Reptiles, Birds and
Mammals. (2) The animal must be able to resist a con-
siderable range of variation in temperature and humidity,
and thus we find in terrestrial animals all sorts of cuticular
and integumentary structures, such as feathers and hairs,
and all sorts of detailed devices for meeting the notable
changes in vital conditions that the succession of the
seasons involves. Thus hibernation and warm-blooded-
ness find their place here as exceedingly effective adapta-
tions to terrestrial life. (3) A terrestrial animal will tend
to have an abbreviated life-history, or in other words a
direct development, for the conditions of life on land are
not suited for larval stages. The notable exception is in
the case of insects, many of which must be called terres-
trial, and many of which have intricate life-histories with
a great variety of larvse. It will be noted, however,
that many insect larvse are very carefully hidden away,
that many are specially adapted to be inconspicuous, and
that many are peculiarly protected from possible enemies,
e.g. by being unpalatable, by being covered with irrita-
ting hairs, by exuding repulsive fluids. On the whole,
it is safe to say that it is characteristic of terrestrial
animals that the young are born or hatched at a very
advanced state. What comes out of the egg of a spider
or a snail is a miniature of the adult, fully formed. Some
species of Peripatus and many insects are viviparous. In
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 121
many birds that nest on the ground, the young, known
as Praecoces, are able to run about within a short period
after hatching ; and every one knows how quickly a
lamb or a foal gets on to its legs.
In this connexion it is very interesting to notice that in
Amphibians which represent the transition-class between
aquatic and terrestrial life, there are not a few exceptions
in which the larval period, normally passed through in the
water, tends to be abbreviated by some peculiar device.
Thus the eggs of the South American Nototrema ovifera
are pushed by the male, after they are laid, into a pocket
on the female's back ; those of the Chilian Rhinoderma
are carried by the male in his resonating sacs ; those
of the Surinam Toad develop in a multitude of little skin-
pits on the female's back.
(4) The fourth adaptation is one that might not naturally
occur to the non-zoological student. A thorough-going
terrestrial animal usually shows internal fertilization of the
eggs. In many fishes the eggs are deposited in the water
and the fertilizing fluid or milt is deposited upon them or
near them. But this is incompatible with the conditions
of terrestrial life. There are exceptional cases, it Is true,
but they tend to prove the rule. Thus one earthworm
fertilizes another, but the sperms are extruded again
in packets which project as tiny tags on the skin ; these
spermatophores are included in a barrel of mucus that
slips over the earthworm's head and forms the cocoon when
the eggs are liberated. What is laid in the ground is a
cocoon containing several eggs and numerous sperms.
The terrestrial area has to be divided up into more sub-
divisions than any other haunt of life : it is so extraordinarily
diverse. We think, for instance, of mountains and islands,
122 THE WONDER OF LIFE
of woods and forests, of moors and meadows, of links and
dunes each with its characteristic fauna and flora. There
are peculiar regions like steppes and prairies, tundra and
desert, and the circum- polar areas so far as these can be
called terrestrial.
Under Ground. It is interesting to think of the large
number of animals that have taken to a subterranean
mode of life as burrowers in the ground. There must have
been long ago a golden age for the race of earthworms
when they discovered the possibility of colonizing a new
world below the surface. Ages probably passed before
they were followed by the Centipedes who are their invet-
erate enemies, by some of the burrowing beetles, and by
carnivorous slugs (Testacella). Long ages passed before
the moles followed the earthworms into the recesses of
the soil, and became equally well adapted to the peculiar
conditions of that strange mode of life.
Over and over again the same story has been re-enacted,
e.g. by burrowing amphibians (Csecilians), burrowing
lizards (Amphisbsenids), and burrowing snakes (Typhlops,
etc.) : a temporary safety has been secured by a change
of habitat, and then new enemies and difficulties have been
encountered.
Cave Animals. Caves and grottos have come to be
tenanted by a diverse array of animals, more or less adapted
to the conditions of life darkness and constant temperature,
absence of green plants, and a humid atmosphere, for
thoroughly dry caves have never more than casual tenants.
The cave-fauna includes many bats, a few peculiar mice,
the Amphibian Proteus of the great caves of Carniola and
Dalmatia, and three American salamanders, a good many
small fishes, numerous beetles and a few other kinds of
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 123
insects, many spiders and crustaceans, various snails, and
so on. They tend to be somewhat dwarfed types, with
more or less degenerate eyes (except in the bats and mice),
with highly developed tactility, and with reduced pigmenta-
tion. In those cavernicolous animals in which the develop-
ment of the eye has been worked out, e.g. Proteus, Ambly-
opsis (a fish), and Cambarus (a crayfish), it has been shown
that the eye of the young form is relatively less degenerate
than that of the adult.
Racovitza, who has made a special study of cave-animals,
gives an interesting account of an Isopod or wood-louse,
Spela3oniscus, from an Algerian cavern. It is colourless,
blind, and covered with tactile setse ; it has no longer any
near relatives living in the light of day ; it is an archaic
representative of a fauna which has disappeared. It was
in a sense a failure, Kacovitza thinks, for whereas it can
roll itself up in a ball like many other Isopods, such as
the widely distributed Armadillidium vulgare, its antennae
are left sticking out and exposed to danger. So it had
to become a Troglodyte. Eacovitza suggests that it is
not the only failure who has taken refuge in a cave, ' cet
asile que dame nature installa a peu de frais pour ses veil-
lards, ses impotents et ses rates'.
VI. THE AERIAL FAUNA
The last haunt of life to be tenanted was the air, and
it is interesting to notice how many attempts have been
made to possess it. Among backboneless animals the
insects alone have attained to the power of true flight, but
among backboned animals there are three instances of
success the extinct Pterodactyls, the Flying Birds, and
the Bats. Thus in each of the three great classes of air-
124 THE WONDER OF LIFE
breathing Vertebrates Reptiles, Birds and Mammals
the problem of flight has been solved, each time in a
different way.
The power of taking ' soaring ' leaps has been acquired
many times over in the history of Vertebrates. R. S.
Lull gives ten cases Rhacophorus, Ptychozoon (a lizard
with a long fringed tail), Draco (a lizard with the skin
extended on greatly prolonged ribs), and seven Mammals,
Petauroides, Petaurus, Aerobates, Anomalurus, Pteromys,
Galeopithecus and Propithecus. Except in Petauroides,
there is in these swooping mammals a fold of skin along
the animal's flanks, which may be supplemented by
folds in front of the fore-limbs, between the hind limbs,
or along the tail. In the much-debated movements
of the Flying Fishes (Thoracopterus, Gigantopterus,
Exocoetus, and Dactylopterus), there is at most an
approximation to true flight.
It is not surprising that many of the attempts to possess
the air should have proved quite unsuccessful, for man's
own experience of aviation has taught him that success
depends on numerous fine adjustments, and is not to be
attained except at great cost of life. In the case of birds
there is a remarkable correlation of numerous adaptations
the somewhat boat-like shape of the body, the ballasting
of the body with heavy organs below, the lightly built
skeleton with bones of the hollow girder type, the arrange-
ment by which the flying helps the breathing, the enormous
development of the pectoral muscles sometimes attaining to
half the whole weight of the bird, the turning of an arm into
a wing, the possession of feathers with inter-linked barbs,
the fusion of dorsal vertebrao to form a steady basis against
which the wings can work, and so on through a long list.
THE HAUNTS OF LIFE 125
From the evolutionist point of view it is interesting
to notice that in Bird, Bat and Pterodactyl the flying
organ is in each case the arm, and yet the details of the
transformation are very different in the three cases. With
precisely the same fundamental material to work with,
three entirely different types of wing have been evolved.
In insects the wings appear to be entirely novel struc-
tures hollow, flattened sacs growing out from the upper
parts of the two posterior divisions of the thorax ; but it
is possible that they were, to begin with, rather respiratory
than locomotor organs. Indeed, in some cases they still
have considerable respiratory function containing blood-
channels and extensions of the air-tubes or tracheae. As
illustrations of analogy it is interesting to compare Birds
and Insects, for they are as far apart from one another
anatomically as they could well be, and yet they have
much in common lightly built bodies, highly specialized
musculature, very elaborate respiratory system with active
expiratory movements, and so on. These are convergent
adaptations towards the same end in entirely different
types.
It is probable that the Vertebrate animals which have
attained to the power of true flight have sprung from
arboreal stocks. It is likely that the oldest known bird
the extinct Archaeopteryx which had teeth on both
jaws, a long lizard- like tail, and claws on each of the three
digits of the half-made wing, was definitely arboreal. The
same conclusion is suggested by the Hoatzin (Opistho
comus), one of the most primitive of living birds, whose
young ones clamber about on the branches. It is probable
that the Bats sprang from a stock of arboreal Insectivores.
Most of the insects which are aerial as adults spend the
126 THE WONDER OF LIFE
early part of their life on the ground, or on herbs and
bushes, or in the water, for the possession of the air is,
of course, a secondary victory. It is interesting to notice,
however, how very independent of the earth many of
the birds have become, with even their nests far off the
ground. How thoroughly aerial a bird may be is well
illustrated by the common swift, which throughout the
long summer daylight never alights or pauses, except for
brief moments at the nest.
Gossamer. In illustration of successful adventure into
the air, the flights of gossamer- spiders may be noticed. At
various times throughout the year, but especially in the
autumn, large numbers of small spiders congregate on the
tops of palings and bridge-rails and herbage, and standing
on tiptoe with their head to the breeze, allow long threads
of silk to pass from their spinnerets. When the parachute
is long enough and the wind begins to pull on it, the spiders
let go their hold of their support, and are borne on the
wings of the wind from one parish to another. If the
wind should fall, the spiders can * spread more sail ' by
lengthening their silken threads. If the wind should rise,
the spider can ' furl their sails ' by winding in part of their
parachute. When tens of thousands of small spiders
migrate simultaneously some fine morning, there may
be, as they sink to earth, a shower of gossamer, covering
the fields for acres. In many cases we see and feel threads
of gossamer floating in the air without any attached spiders ;
these are usually broken-off parts of parachutes. They
recall to us the failures of the days before achievement.
CHAPTER III
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE
(THE CIRCUMVENTION OF SPACE AND THE CONQUEST
or TIME)
' Sbe is tbe onlg artist ; worfcing=up tbe most uniform
material into utter opposites ; arriving, without a trace of
effort, at perfection, at tbe most ejact precision, tbougb
always veileo unDer a certain softness. . . .'
'Sbe is all tbings. . . . sbe is rougb ano tenoer, lovely
ano bateful, powerless ano omnipotent. . . /
'Sbe is cunning, but for gooo enos; ano it is best not to
notice ber trtcfcs. . . /
4 &be one tbing sbe seems to aim at is 5noi\>tDualitg ; vet
sbe cares notbing for inDfviouals. Sbe is always builofng
up ano Destroying; but ber worfcsbop is inaccessible.'
Goethe's Aphorisms, translated by Huxley.
Productivity Filling every niche Difficult Conditions Tenacity
of Life Plasticity The Biology of the Seasons Migration
as an Instance of Insurgence.
IN many of its familiar expressions life seems to be an
extraordinarily delicate form of activity easily
disturbed and spoilt and ended. A little quickening of the
rate of metabolism, and life's fitful fever is over. A slight
lack of harmony in the internal laboratory, and the happy
child becomes a cretin. A pin-prick below the thumb-
nail when he was planting seedlings and the robust
gardener dies of lockjaw. An unusually cold night and two
127
128 THE WONDER OF LIFE
hundred birds are gathered in the morning in one stackyard.
This does not sound much like the insurgence of life !
It must be pointed out, however, that the impression
we often get of the brittleness of living creatures is apt to be
fallacious. Truly the more intricate of them have ex-
quisitely balanced organizations, with machinery that is
easily put out of gear, for the more parts there are, the
greater is the likelihood of something going wrong, and
chemical complexity often involves chemical instability.
But the big fact is that life is tough.
A boy whirling a stick, a pigeon strutting on the ground, a
fortuitous contact between boy's stick and pigeon's skull,
and it is all over with the favourite bird. This is a trivial
instance of what in the course of life we have far too
many occasions to deplore, namely casualties. Socially, a
casualty means an accident for which no one in particular
is to blame ; it is put down to ' the hand of God '. Bio-
logically expressed, a casualty is a fortuitous and fatal
incidence, on a living creature, of forces to which it cannot
in any effective way respond. It is plain enough that if
the pigeon had only had the skull of an elephant, or a ram
for that matter, it would not have died from a slight ' con-
cussion of the brain ' induced by the schoolboy's carelessly-
handled stick. But then it would not have been a
pigeon, and could not have been a pigeon, for the real
answer to the apparent difficulty is that complex organisms
cannot be adapted to casual dangers, that they would be
unthinkably handicapped if they were. Therefore, when
we think of the terrible destruction in the fauna of the
Gulf of Naples after an eruption of Vesuvius, or the decima-
tion both on the shore and inland that follows an unusually
hard winter, we are forced to admit that we cannot expect
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 129
organisms to be adapted to resist other than normal con-
ditions. Our expectations are often, however, agreeably
disappointed.
We admit, then, that organisms are often tender plants,
frail edifices, delicate pieces of vital machinery, adapted
for a relatively constant, or at any rate regular environ-
ment, and not for casualties. But the much bigger fact
is the toughness of life, which we wish to illustrate in this
chapter. It is difficult to get a fitting word for the quality
that impresses us all the self-assertiveness of life, its power
of persistence against difficulties, its habit of attempting
the apparently impossible and leading forlorn hopes. We
have called it the insurgence of life.
Perhaps the primary illustration of the quality is to be
found in the fundamental fact about life, that although the
organism is always changing, it yet remains approximately
the same. It is always burning away, but it is not con-
sumed. It is continually arising like a Phoenix from its
own combustion. Ceaseless metabolism in all ordinary
cases, and yet a retention of integrity or intactness that
is the fundamental wonder of life. To this we shall have
to return in our final chapter.
PRODUCTIVITY
In illustration of what we venture to call the insurgence
of life, we may begin by recalling a few instances of pro-
ductivity. Life is like a stream that is continually tending
to overflow its banks. A little one is always becoming a
thousand, and a small one a great nation. Some of us
on an ocean voyage may have watched the sun set in the
water, lingering for a minute or two like a ball of fire
balanced on the tight string of the horizon, and may have
K
130 THE WONDER OF LIFE
waited till it became quite dark except for the stars and the
steamer lights, and then enjoyed the splendour of oceanic
' phosphorescence '. There is a cascade of sparks at the
prow, a stream of sparks all along the water level, a welter
of sparks in the wake, and even where the waves break
there is fire. So it goes on for miles and hours a lumin-
escence due to the rapid vital combustion of pinhead-like
creatures (Noctiluca and others), so numerous that a
bucketful contains more of them than there are people in
London. We are filled with amazement at the prodigal
abundance of life.
Taking the slowest breeder among mammals, Darwin
calculated that a pair of elephants, living for over a century
and rearing one offspring every ten years, would have in
750 years, barring accidents, nineteen millions of descen-
dants. Wallace quotes Kerner's statement that a common
weed, Sisymbrium sophia, often has three-quarters of a
million of seeds, and that if these all grew to maturity and
seeded, the whole of the land-surface of the globe would be
covered with the result within three years.
The very general absence of parental care of any sort
among fishes is a familiar fact, partly explicable because
fishes are creatures of low degree in the Vertebrate alliance,
and partly because of the prolific reproduction. With egg-
laying in the open water in the great majority of cases,
parental care would be difficult, and survival is secured by
great reproductivity. It is sometimes extraordinary. A
ling weighing 54 pounds had 28,000,000 eggs, a turbot of
17 pounds 9,000,000 eggs, a cod of 21 pounds 6,000,000
eggs. In four herrings the number of eggs varied from
20,000 to 47,000.
In many of the less differentiated animals there is not
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 131
only great fertility, but rapid coming to maturity. Mr.
Newton Miller has supplied precise data as to the fertility
of the brown rat in captivity, and these are of serious human
interest because of the importance of this animal as a
destroyer of food-supplies and a disseminator of disease.
The creature breeds all the year round, and five or six
litters may be actually reared by a pair in the course of a
year. If the young are destroyed or removed at birth,
there may probably be a litter every month. In one case
seven litters were produced in seven months by one female.
The young are carried from 23|-25 days before birth.
The number in a litter varies from six to nineteen, with an
average between ten and eleven. They are not full grown
before eighteen months, but both sexes are ready for
reproduction not later than the end of the fourth month.
The rabbit may have six young ones in a litter, and four
litters in a year ; and the young may begin to breed when
they are six months old. This rate is far surpassed by
some of the mice, and when we descend to the level of
insects and the like we find an extraordinarily rapid suc-
cession of generations. In the time required for the pro-
duction of one generation of a larger higher animal, the
lower type has had many generations and has produced
an enormously greater weight of living matter. It was
this that led Linnaeus to say that three flies consume the
carcass of a horse as quickly as a lion (' Tres muscse con-
sumunt cadaver equi, seque cito ac leo ').
Huxley calculated that if the descendants of a single
green-fly all survived and multiplied, they would at the end
of one summer weigh down the population of China. The
descendants of a common house-fly would in the same time
six generations of about three weeks each occupy a
132 THE WONDER OF LIFE
space of something like a quarter of a million cubic feet,
allowing 200,000 flies to a cubic foot. An oyster may have
sixty million eggs, and the average American yield is
sixteen millions. If all the progeny of one oyster survived
and multiplied, and so on till there were great-great-grand-
children, these would number sixty-six with thirty-three
noughts after it, and the heap of shells would be eight times
the size of the earth! Of course none of these things
happen, because of the checks imposed by the struggle for
existence. Yet every now and then, as man knows to his
cost, a removal or diminution of the natural checks allows
the potential productivity to assert itself for a short time
or within a limited area. The river of life sometimes does
overflow its banks, as it always tends to do, and the result-
ing flood is called a plague. But one plague brings another
in its train, as in Egypt long ago, and things right them-
selves, usually with considerable loss in the process.
The large African land-snail Achatina fulica was intro-
duced about 1900 into central Ceylon, but was shortly after-
wards practically exterminated. A couple that escaped
destruction were carried down some years afterwards to the
low country. ' Here they increased to such an amazing
extent, over an area of about five square miles, that
their numbers were to be reckoned by millions, no fewer
than 227 being counted in a cluster on the stem of a
cocoa-nut palm in a length of about 6 feet '. Luckily little
or no damage has been done, as the snail acts as a scavenger.
The adults are attacked by a terrapin of the genus Nicoria,
the young stages have many enemies, and the early
exuberance of multiplication is now being checked.
On the night before the new or full moon in the middle
or latter half of December there occurs the remarkable
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 133
swarming of the Japanese Palolo worm. It invariably
takes place about midnight just after flood-tide. At 1 a.m.,
Akira Izuka relates, the worms ' covered the whole
water as with a sheet ' and were thick down to a depth of
a fathom. By 2.15 a.m. there was not a single worm to
be seen ; the reproductive orgasm was over. The pheno-
menon appears to us to be a dramatic instance of the
abundance of life, of the crisis-nature of reproduction, and
of the precise way in which internal rhythms may be
related to external periodicities.
Dr. Th. Mortensen has called attention to the extra-
ordinary fecundity of the starfish Luidia ciliaris, which is
well known in British seas. The beautiful red ovaries are
arranged in a double series in each arm or ray 300 in an
arm 30 cm. long. As the species is seven-armed a complete
female of that size, which is nearly the average, has 2,100
ovaries. In one ovary there are at least 300,000 eggs,
probably nearer half a million. As the ovaries are smaller
towards the tip of the arm, it may be just to take the mean
number of eggs per ovary at 100,000, and the number of
ovaries may be reduced to 2,000 ; this gives the number
of eggs in a grown female at no less than 200 millions.
Yet the larvae are relatively rare and the adults are far
from common. ' What a waste of eggs must here take
place ! '
Professor Lorande Loss Woodruff, of Yale, who has
devoted many years to the experimental study of the
slipper animalcule (Paramoecium), gives a very interesting
account of a five-year pedigreed race. On May 1, 1907, he
started with a ' wild ' Paramoecium aurelia, isolated from
an aquarium. When it had produced four individuals
by division, these were isolated to form the ancestors of
134 THE WONDER OF LIFE
four lines. The pedigreed culture was maintained by
taking a specimen practically every day from each of these
lines up to May 1, 1912. This facilitated an accurate
record of the number of generations attained, and it
also precluded the possibility of conjugation taking place,
for this process of incipient sexual union does not occur
between forms which are all descended from one by
repeated asexual fission.
In the five years there were three thousand and twenty-
nine generations, four hundred and fifty-two in the first,
six hundred and ninety in the second, six hundred and
thirteen in the third, six hundred and twelve in the fourth,
and six hundred and sixty-two in the fifth. The mean
rate of division was over three divisions in forty-eight
hours.
The slipper-animalcules were as healthy in 1912 as in
1907. They had given evidence of the potentiality of
producing a volume of protoplasm approximately equal to
10,000 times the volume of the earth ! The experiments
illustrate admirably the extraordinary self-reproducing
capacity of living matter. They also seem to show that
given an ideally favourable environment there is no
need for the occurrence of conjugation and no reason for
senescence. The slipper-animalcules preserve the secret
of eternal youth.
FILLING EVERY NICHE
Fauna of a Stone. No one who has made the experi-
ment will forget the lesson learned by making a census
of the population of a single creviced stone brought up by
the dredge. Molluscs, Crustaceans, Worms, Echinoderms,
Zoophytes, Sponges, Protozoa, and other groups may be
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 135
all represented. In a report on the Bryozoa collected on
the Clare Island Survey, Mr. A. R. Nicholls notices that
from one stone no fewer than fourteen different species
of these colonial ' moss-animals ' were obtained. A small
stone bore eleven species of the same class ! We see the
same filling of every corner all the world over.
Red Snow. The striking phenomenon of Red Snow
was known to the ancients and is mentioned by Aristotle.
It occurs all the world over and affords a good illustration
of what we call insurgence. It seems to be most abundant
in the Far North and Sir John Ross described the ' Crim-
son Cliffs ' of Greenland as extending for miles ! The ordin-
ary ' red snow ' is due to swarms of a Flagellate Infusorian,
Sphcerella (or Protococcus) nivalis, sometimes claimed by
the botanists, but there are sometimes red animals of higher
degree, namely Rotifers, Water-Bears, Mites, associated
with it forming a ' Red Snow ' fauna. The facts have
been recently summed up by Mr. James Murray, who was
zoologist on Sir Ernest Shackle ton's Antarctic Expedition.
He found abundance of a red Rotifer, which he named
Philodina gregaria, forming conspicuous blood-red stains
on stones at the margins of lakes, and increasing with
prodigious rapidity. It lives frozen in ice for years, and
resumes activity whenever the ice melts. Vogt found a
related species (Philodina roseola] on the Alps along with
the Flagellate ' red snow ' ; Langerheim found the same
association in Ecuador. The red colour of both Alpine and
Polar Rotifers is confined to the stomach, which looks
as if the colour were due to the Rotifers making meals of
the Flagellates. Mr. Murray notices in addition that M.
Gain of the Charcot Antarctic Expedition found red mites
along with the red snow, and that Ehrenberg long ago
136 THE WONDER OF LIFE
found a red water-bear and a red Eotifer (Callidina scar-
latina] among snow on Monte Rosa at a height of 11,138
feet, which is another good instance of the insurgence of life.
Brine Shrimps. The pretty little brine-shrimp
(Artemia salina) that used to occur in British salterns, and
has a widespread distribution from the Great Salt Lake
of Utah to Central Asia, is famous in several ways, and
notably because it can live in water with as much as 27
per cent, of dissolved salts, yet occurs, though rarely, in fresh
water. It is usually about half an inch long and has a pale
reddish colour, due, as Sir Ray Lankester first showed, to
the presence in the body fluids of haemoglobin the char-
acteristic vertebrate blood pigment which is somewhat
rare in Invertebrates. In some places the colonies seem
to be altogether female, and parthenogenesis obtains, the
eggs developing without being fertilized. In other localities
males are common and reproduction takes place by means
of fertilized eggs. Sometimes the Brine Shrimp is vivi-
parous, the eggs hatching within the mother's brood-sac and
giving rise to microscopic larvae (Nauplii) with three pairs of
limbs and an unpaired eye. Variable in its reproduction,
the Brine- Shrimp is variable also in its form, especially as
regards the end-lobes of the tail and the bristles they bear.
Perhaps this is correlated with the chemical diversity of
the habitats frequented. The eggs can survive being dried
and may be blown about by the wind or carried on the feet
of birds from one salt pond to another. We have already
referred to their occurrence In Tidman's Sea-Salt.
A Hazardous Home. One knows the narrow shelves
high up on the Alps, which, for part of the year at least,
are the homes of men, women, and children ; one knows
the narrow ledges on the precipitous Bird-bergs where
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 137
kittiwakes and guillemots and many other sea-birds have
their summer quarters and bring up their family ; one has
seen the water-snails browsing nonchalantly on the minute
vegetation on the stones of the Niagara River within a few
yards of the Falls ; but are any of these habitats so remark-
able as that of a spider that lives inside one of the Pitcher-
plants ? In that notorious lure for insects, with its very
slippery internal surface, and noxious dungeon full of
rottenness, the spider lives and thrives. Forestalling the
plant, it catches some of the insect victims as they slip
down the facilis descensus Averni and sucks their juices,
letting the dry corpses tumble into the pit. This is certainly
one of the strangest of habitats. They say, moreover, that
when an insectivorous bird aware of the plant's device
arrives on the scene and proceeds to break down the
prison-walls, the spider plunges into the foul fluid in the
foot of the pitcher, is able to survive suffocation for a
time, and eventually escapes as the tearing-up is accom-
plished.
Larvae of Flies. There is no parallel in the rest of the
animal kingdom to the variety of habit and habitat that
is illustrated by the larvae of Dipterous insects. Mr. J. C.
Hamon found larval Stratiomyidse in a hot spring in
Wyoming, where he could not keep his hand immersed, and
others occur in brine. Some are found in the rushing
torrent, and others in the rain-water barrel. Some are
found in the midst of filth, and others cannot endure the
least contamination. Some are parasitic, and others have
an extremely active free life. Let us take as an instance
in more detail the larva of Simulium reptans, a British
representative of the buffalo-gnats. The adult fly bites
hard and is irritating to man, but it is not to be compared
138 THE WONDER OF LIFE
with other species which do serious damage among herds
of cattle in the valley of the Danube and in the United
States.
The larva of Simulium reptans lives in rushing water,
holding on to water-buttercup and the like by a clawed
sucker at the posterior end of the body. It has a similar
sucker on the thorax, and it seems to use this one when it
moves about on the weed. Another safeguard is to be
found in its ability to exude an attaching thread from its
salivary glands. It is about 12 mm. long, of a greenish-
black colour, and it is continually wafting food into its
mouth by the action of two pairs of beautiful sweepers.
The larva pupates in a silken pouch or cocoon fixed to the
weed, and showing a pair of projecting respiratory processes.
Professor Miall describes the emergence of the winged fly
from the sub-aquatic cradle, and how it is wafted up to
its appropriate element as If inside a large water-bubble
an ingeniously simple device !
Nets of Caddis Larvae. C. Wesenberg-Lund has
given a very interesting account of the peculiar nets made
by the larvae of some of the Caddis-flies of lakes and
streams. They serve for the capture of the drifting plank-
ton. Some are trumpet- shaped, up to four inches in
length, with the mouth always upstream. They are bluish-
green in summer because of the Algae on the threads,
and brownish in winter because of the diatoms. Other
nets are flat, with an aperture in the centre leading down
into a tunnel beneath a stone ; others are like swallows'
nests and are fastened in large numbers to the vertical
banks ; others are funnel-shaped and fixed to the pond-
weed leaves ; others make chains of baskets out of duck
weed leaves and spin a web on the front of each. The
FIG. 36 Nets of larval Caddis-Flies. (After Wesenberg-Lund.) I. Larva of Holocentropus
dubius. III. Its snare-nest. II. Snare-nest of Neureclipsis bimaculata.
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 139
spinning larvae are campodeiform in type, that is, not so
worm-like as ordinary caddis-worms, and they differ also
in being very sedentary and practically carnivorous. The
author writes (in 1911) : 'It seems strange that until now
we have hardly had any idea at all as to the spinning powers
of these animals ; as the spider spins its web above ground,
and lies in wait for the winged insects and the flying plank-
ton of the air, so the campodeoid larva constructs its net,
lurking for the small animals and floating plankton of
lakes and water- courses.'
Strange Habitats. In hunting for earthworms one does
not naturally look up a tree, but Dr. Robert Stager has
shown that it is a useful plan to search in unlikely places.
In exploring on the Alps he investigated the mossy cushions
which often flourish on the stem and branches of the
sycamore and bear ferns and various flowering plants. In
that strange habitat he found four different species of
earthworm. Others occurred in the familiar cushions
formed on almost bare rock by plants like Dryas octopetala,
Silene acaulis, and Gypsophila repens. Again we have illustra-
tion of the way life insinuates itself into every vacant niche.
Another strange habitat is that of an ' unsalamander-like
salamander ' (Autodax lugubris) which lives up trees
(Quercus agrifolia). W. E. Ritter found them in holes at
a height of 30 feet, sometimes as many as a dozen in one
hole, representing perhaps a family. Most of the cavities
occupied had very narrow openings. The eggs are hung
in clusters from an overhanging surface, each egg on a little
string of its own, and both sexes look after them. Most
Amphibians are gentle creatures, but these Salamanders
are very ready to show fight in defence of their eggs or
themselves, and they have very large teeth.
140 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Another series of strange habitats has been found in the
burrows made by moles and hamsters and other mammals
of similar habit. There are, of course, accidental co-
tenants ; and there are others which though often found in
burrows occur elsewhere as well ; and there are parasites
belonging to the burrowing mammals. But after these
are taken account of there remains a distinct burrow- fauna,
just as there is a distinct cavern-fauna. Thus L. Falcoz
mentions the Staphylinid beetles, Heterops prcevia,
Oxypoda longipes, and Aleochara spadicea as good illus-
trations of the fauna of moles' nests.
Many beetles visit nests casually for pickings ; others
are frequenters of nests but of other suitable places as
well ; there is a third lot of exclusively ' nidicolous '
Coleoptera, and the list of these drawn up by Bickhardt
in 1911 came to twenty-eight. Eighteen of these are
confined to the homes of mammals, such as mole, hamster,
mouse, and rabbit ; seven are confined to the nests of
birds, such as dove, sand-martin, owl, and woodpecker ;
three are found associated with both birds and mammals.
A curious refuge is that of the rare sea-otter on the
great beds of kelp seaweed (Macrocystis] which fringe the
rocky coast of the North Pacific, among the Aleutian and
Kurile Islands. We read that ' these great kelp beds
make calm water, though the surf be roaring and breaking
just outside, and are dense enough for the otters to lie
upon.' In the middle of the nineteenth century the sea-
otter was still comparatively plentiful all round the North
Pacific coast, now it is hardly to be seen even by the
exploring naturalist. It is interesting in its adaptations
for aquatic life the hind feet being suited only for swim-
ming ; in the adaptation of its back teeth for crunching crabs,
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 141
molluscs, and sea-urchins the crowns being smooth and
rounded ; and in the care for the pup which the mother
shows, dandling it, and diving with it.
The Penelope Spider. Not only do living creatures
fill every cranny in the rock-pool, every nook in the
grassy bank, they take advantage of every niche of
opportunity. The illustrations are world- wide. Professor
Goeldi gives us one from a garden near Para. The time is
long before dawn and the chief actor is a spider, spinning
in the dim light. Before the sun rises her web is finished,
and it serves to catch the winged male scale-insects in
their early morning nutter. But as the sun rises, the
spinner grows restless ; she dislikes the light of day, just
as does the poacher who has by night spread in the field
his net for birds. So, at the dawning, the spider draws
her net together with its quivering delicate captives, and
retires into the shade to investigate the catch. It was only
by staying up all night in the garden that Professor Goeldi's
son discovered the secret of this light-avoiding spider whose
web disappears with the morning dew. It is a mode of
bread-winning that fills a curious niche of opportunity.
Penelope-like, the spinner makes and unmakes her web
each day, but not without effective results to man (by
destroying the injurious scale- insects) as well as to herself.
Successive Waves of Life. The pressing insurgence
of life which is illustrated by the way in which organisms
fill every niche even the least inviting is illustrated in
quite another way when we observe a sequence of possessors
passing like waves over a particular environment. When
one horde has made an area uninhabitable for itself by
exhausting the food-supply, there may come another able
to cut even closer to the bone. We see this in a very
142 THE WONDER OF LIFE
striking way in the sequence of animal and plant life in a
' hay infusion ' one form after another rising into domin-
ance and then disappearing. In this connexion Professor
L. L. Woodruff of Yale has shown that the slipper-animal-
cule (Paramoecium), excretes substances which are poisonous
to itself when they accumulate in a limited environment.
Thus when Paramcecium reaches its maximum, the be-
ginning of the end is not far off.
DIFFICULT CONDITIONS
Who has not been impressed by the way in which living
creatures triumph over the most unpromising circum-
stances ? We went up the other day to a well-known minor
pass in the Alps where we were getting near the lasting
snows and the bare inhospitable rocks. It seemed ill-suited
to be a home, but what impressed us most, after the view of
the mountains, was the abundant insurgent life ; we felt
what Bergson calls the elan, the spring, the impetus that is
characteristic of life. Not only were there many beautiful
flowers coming up even at the thinned edges of the snow
mantle, but there was quite a rich insect life. Conspicuous,
too, were the large, white-bellied Alpine swifts, perhaps the
most rapid of birds, continually swirling about, all in silence,
in the cold air : emblems of insurgent life. Shy marmots
whistled from among the rocks. Flocks of white moths
floated up in the mist, rising like the souls of animals that
had died far below. We felt the insurgent indomitable
quality of life.
Antarctic Shores. On Sir Ernest Shackleton's Antarctic
Expedition several collections were made at Cape Royds
(77 32' S.), at first sight a most unpromising locality.
On the shore there was no vestige of life ; nothing but
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 143
funereal black sand when the ' foot-ice ' was gone. Inshore
there was black lava, showing no vegetation higher than
mosses, and very little of them. Even the lichenous tripe
de roche, familiar in books of Arctic exploration for its
role in staving off starvation, was scarcely so abundant
as to fulfil the same life-saving role in the Antarctic.
Ice covered the sea ; ice fifteen feet of it covered the
little lakes. Could any faunistic outlook have been more
unprepossessing ?
But the reality was very different from the appearance.
Mr. James Murray and the other workers under his guid-
ance wasted no time in bemoaning the absence of faunistic
amenities. They made holes in the ice, which the Weddell
seals helped to keep open, and set traps which yielded
molluscs, crustaceans, and worms. They managed to haul
a dredge from one hole to another, and got sponges, sea-
anemones, alcyonarians, starfishes, crustaceans, and
molluscs. They cut down through fifteen feet of ice in the
small inland lakes, and reached a floor of ' foliaceous vege-
tation ', and a rich micro-fauna and micro-flora. There
were abundant Rotifers, especially of two new viviparous
species, which subsequent experiment showed to be able
to withstand all sorts of changes of temperature. There
were ' water-bears,' or Tardigrades, and water-mites, and
two species of ' water-fleas ', besides thread- worms, In-
fusorians, and two kinds of Rhizopods. Here then in the
collecting at Cape Royds we get another illustration of the
insurgence of life. We see life persistent and intrusive
spreading everywhere, insinuating itself, adapting itself ;
resisting everything, defying everything, surviving every-
thing.
Desert-Plants. A well-known adaptation to difficult
144 THE WONDER OF LIFE
conditions is exhibited by desert plants which store water.
They have a relatively large root-system which enables
them to make the most of any available supply. F. V.
Coville found in the Mohave Desert, California, a branching
cactus (Opuntia echinocarpa), 19 inches high, which had a
network of roots extending over an area 18 feet in diameter.
These roots were 2 to 4 inches below the surface, suited
therefore for utilizing a downpour. Some desert plants send
their roots deep, and Professor R. H. Forbes has described
an acacia of Arizona which has a double root-system, one
for absorption near the surface, and the other for searching
deeply.
The collecting surface is great, and the losing green surface
is small ; the whole plant, as in many cactuses, may be
like a ball or barrel and without leaves. The structure of
the cuticle and even of the transpiration pores is adapted
to lose as little as possible, and the interior of the plant
consists chiefly of water-storage cells, so that as much as
96 per cent, of water can be collected. The plant becomes a
tank and the water is often quite drinkable. A Barrel-
Cactus or Bisnago (Echinocactus emoryi) studied by Coville
yielded 3 quarts of water from about 8 inches of a plant
about a yard high and 20 inches in diameter. It may be
further noted that the Bisnago is effectively protected
against grazing animals by the impenetrable armour of
hooked and rigid spines, and another notable feature is the
fluted surface which allows it to expand and contract
without cracking. When we think of the root-system,
the leaflessness, the barrel-shape, the skin, the water-cells,
the spines, the fluting we realize what a bundle of adapta-
tions this desert plant is, and many other slightly different
examples might be given. Although the Barrel-Cactus
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 145
seems to be peculiarly safe (except from man, who some-
times taps it), there are many desert plants whose stores
form the only water supply of not a few of the desert
animals.
Rock -Borers. Life's characteristic filling of every
niche leads to extraordinary modes of life. Instead of
seeking a life of ease, many animals attempt what
seems impossible, and achieve it. Take the simple case
of boring bivalves, like the Pholads, which work their way
into hard rock. According to one theory, the boring is at
least partly due to an acid secretion ; according to another
view it is mainly accomplished by mechanical means. Miss
B. Lindsay made a very careful study of Zirphcea (Pholas)
crispata and Saxicava rugosa at St. Andrews, and came to
the conclusion that the boring is in these cases entirely
mechanical. The Pholas works in two ways sucking and
scraping. ' It might be described as a combination of a
nutmeg-grater and a vacuum- cleaner '. The foot is
extruded ; a wide gap appears between the foot and the
mantle ; the mantle becomes fully extruded, and then
rotatory movements begin. An interesting detail is that
the shells consist of aragonite, which is harder than the
usual calcite, and this must help a little in the process of
boring, which remains, however, when all is said, a very
remarkable performance.
Climbing Fishes. There is a well-known tropical fish,
Periophthalmus, which, like its relative Boleophthalmus,
spends hour after hour out of water, squatting on the mud
by the sides of the estuaries, or even climbing up on the
roots of the mangrove trees. But such climbing powers as
Periophthalmus possesses are far surpassed by those of a
catfish, Arges marmomtus, which lives in the torrential
146 THE WONDER OF LIFE
rivers of the Andes, where there is a rapid succession of
falls, cascades, and potholes. Under usual conditions
Arges is a clumsy and awkward swimmer, but for creeping
and climbing in the torrents it is wonderfully adapted. It
anchors itself by its suctorial mouth, and works itself up-
stream with the help of a ventral bony plate bearing the
ventral fins and equipped with strong muscles which move
it backwards and forwards. The plate is studded with
small sharp teeth pointing backwards. These catfishes
climb up the smooth water- worn surfaces of deep potholes,
and have been known to ascend eighteen feet without a slip
or fall.
Terrestrial Animals Under Water. On the Mediter-
ranean shore among the calcareous Algae, Racovitza found
a marine spider, which Louis Fage has described under the
title Desidiopsis racovitzai. It lives in crevices, in burrows
(of Lithodomus), in empty shells (of Vermetus), and keeps
the water out more or less by spinning threads across the
entrance to its retreat. There is no tide to contend with,
but it is a strange abode for a terrestrial animal. Unlike
the freshwater spider, it cannot swim. It can remain
for a long time under water, but has to return to dry
land periodically to get a supply of air, which is entangled
about the posterior body. What the creature feeds on is
uncertain.
A species of mite, Eryihrceus passerinii, belonging to a
terrestrial stock, is known to live in the crevices of the sea-
shore rocks, and to be able to withstand prolonged immer-
sion. It utilizes the air imprisoned in the capillary passages
in the cracks of the rocks. A primitive wingless insect,
Anurida maritime/,, which has been carefully studied by
Imms, lives habitually among the sea-shore rocks. When
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 147
the tide rises it retreats far into crevices or into the
sand. The whitish hairs on its body hold a supply of air,
which may last for 4 days. There are also two British
parasitic gall-flies that occur at high-water mark among the
sea-weed of the jetsam.
Aquatic Insects. The adaptations of aquatic insects
form a well-nigh inexhaustible theme. Let us take a
couple of instances from Dr. Boring's account of the larvae
of the Donaciinae, a sub-family of the Chrysomelids, or leaf-
beetles. The larvae puncture the roots of water-plants,
such as pond- weed and Sparganum, and feed on the exu-
ding sap. In making the hole, by means of the cutting
mandibles, the neatest possible contrivance comes into
operation. The first segment of the thorax slips forward
against the plant and within the water-tight compartment
thus formed, the head works freely and the sap is kept
from adulteration with water and debris.
The adaptation for breathing is not less striking, for the
larvae manage to tap the stores of air in the intercellular
spaces of water plants. A hooked breathing pore or
spiracle at the end of the abdomen is plunged into the
tissue of the plant and the air finds its way (in a somewhat
intricate fashion) into the breathing-tubes or trachese of
the insect. Similarly, after the larva has enveloped itself
in a secreted cocoon, it actually bites a hole, or more
than one, at the bottom and establishes connexion with
the air spaces of the root to which it is attached. In this
way it secures a supply of air during its pupal period !
Against the Grain. It seems to be part of the
Amphibian constitution to have an antipathy to salt
a small quantity being often fatal. Referring to the absence
of Amphibians from strictly oceanic islands Darwin pointed
148 THE WONDER OF LIFE
out that they throve particularly well when artificially
introduced, as into Madeira, the Azores, and Mauritius,
' but as these animals and their spawn are immediately
killed (with the exception, as far as known, of one Indian
species) by sea- water, there would be great difficulty in
their transportal across the sea, and therefore we can see
why they do not exist on strictly oceanic islands '. They
could not be transported on trees and the like, as some
animals have been, without fatal drenching. Darwin
makes mention of an exception, and we have recently
(1911) had a circumstantial account by Mr. A. S. Pearse
of sea-shore frogs at Manila. He quotes Dr. Gadow's
words, ' Common salt is poison to the Amphibia ; even
a solution of 1 per cent, prevents the development of the
larvae ', and then reports that he saw little frogs of the
genus Eana hopping about on the flats of an estero, or tidal
creek, opening into Manila Bay. Two holes made by the
crab Sesarma bidens were seen to be full of wriggling tad-
poles newly hatched. Samples of water from a pool with
tadpoles on the edge of the creek were analysed, and it was
found that the tadpoles were developing in slightly diluted
sea-water, containing as much as 2 per cent, of sodium
chloride. It seems, then, that both tadpoles and frogs can
stand much more than a grain of salt.
Audacity. There is sometimes what we may venture
to call sheer audacity in the things animals do and succeed
in doing. Taking such a serious matter as the disposal of
the eggs in birds, we find, of course, all manner of careful
nests and secure hiding-places and safe sites, but we also
find sheer audacity. We do not refer to the often reported
cases of birds nesting inside a hat, or up the sleeve of a
coat, or inside an unlit station-lamp ; for while a few of
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 149
these are interesting, the majority are not, since we are apt
to forget that the bird does not know what hats and sleeves
and lamps are. In many cases, moreover, these divergences
prove dismal failures. We refer rather to cases like the
nesting of the White Tern (Gygis alba], one of the most
interesting and beautiful birds of Norfolk Island in the
Western Pacific, about nine hundred and fifty miles north-
east from Sydney. The bird breeds in densely wooded gullies,
and it lays its single egg in a knot-hole or any slight depres-
sion on a more or less horizontal branch. It is difficult to
think of any more hazardous situation. Mr. A. F. Basset
Hull tells us that ' the sitting bird puffs out its breast-
feathers so as to completely hide the egg, depressing its
forked tail so as to obtain as secure a hold as possible, and
sits with its beak pointing into the eye of the wind, so as
to offer the least resistance '. Both parents share in the
task of incubation, and we are not surprised to learn that
they show great caution in rising and settling. It is the
place chosen for the egg that chiefly concerns us, but we
may finish Mr. Hull's interesting story.
' I saw the young bird, a ball of black down, squatting
unconcernedly on the bare limb while its parents were away
searching for food. A week later it was still there, and had
then grown nearly as large as its mother, but it was still
covered with the black down. Its mother flew up, and
straddled over it, vainly endeavouring to cover it. There it
sat blinking down at us, like a black piccaninny in the
arms of a white nurse.'
Tadpoles of a Tree Frog. To illustrate a cluster of
adaptations, let us take Dr. W. E. Agar's account of the
nest made by one of the tree-frogs, Phyllomedusa sauvagii.
The adults are arboreal in their habits, and yet the tadpoles
150 THE WONDER OF LIFE
develop in the water. This is, so to speak, arranged for
by making a nest among the leaves of bushes overhanging
the pools, and this nest breaks down at the appropriate
time, allowing the newly hatched tadpoles to drop into the
water. A number of leaves are held together by a deposit
of empty gelatinous egg-capsules, such as we sometimes see
in ordinary frog spawn spheres of jelly without an egg
inside. It appears that the gelatinous envelope characteristic
of Amphibian eggs is adhesive when it is not in contact
with water. Thus the leaves are more effectively held
together. The cavity thus formed is filled up with a mix-
ture of full and empty egg-capsules, and then there is a
lid of empty ones on the top. It seems that the empty
capsules not only keep the leaves together until the tadpoles
are ready to drop out, but they form a protective shield
lessening the risk of drying up. Dr. Agar observed that
there was least mortality in the more perfect nests, so that
the peculiarity of producing empty egg- capsules and the
habit of using them is just such a peculiarity as would be
fostered and fixed by Natural Selection.
Defiance of Handicaps. There is in many creatures
an extraordinary defiance of circumstances a refusal to
admit handicaps. There is an order of jellyfishes, well
represented by the widely distributed green and blue
Rhizostoma pulmo, in which the mouth is normally closed
up by the lips so that only minute apertures are left along
the lines of suture. This is intelligible, for the food is
microscopic and the peculiarity is long established. But
what are we to make of a case like the mouthless carp
described by J. W. Fehlmann, which lived and throve,
though its food-canal was mouthless and blind. That
was severe handicapping, but the fish refused to die. It
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 151
lived for at least four years, feeding as well as breathing
through its gill-clefts. It is possible that the carp was in
part sustained by nutritive material in solution in the
water, but there were numerous mayfly larvae, crustaceans,
pieces of plants and the like in the food-canal which must
have passed in by the breathing apertures. It may be
recalled that according to some speculative anatomists the
present-day mouth of backboned animals arose from the
fusion of two gill-clefts.
In any case, though the mouthless carp naturally enough
showed no trace of fat, it lived for at least four years,
and that is the sort of defiance of handicapping which we
wish to illustrate.
TENACITY OP LIFE
The toughness of some animals is extraordinary, and is
often of considerable practical importance to man, for
instance, when he is trying to rid his farm or garden of
injurious insects. They are so difficult to kill. The
explanation is in part no doubt that the chitinous cuticle
is very impervious and resistant, and that larvae in parti-
cular are able to close their mouth and breathing-pores.
But there is a good deal left to explain. A very careful
worker, L. Bordas, notes that he immersed potato cater-
pillars (Phtorimcea opercuklla) in 70 per cent, alcohol for
six to eight hours, and found them still able to contract
the body, and to move the head and limbs and jaws !
The larva of the cheese-fly, Piophila, can pass right
through the alimentary canal of man and dog without being
the worse for it, though the canal may be worse for them, as
they scratch the delicate mucous membrane with their
oval hooks. Alessandri put some for sixteen hours in
152 THE WONDER OF LIFE
70 per cent, alcohol and others for thirty hours in petroleum,
but they survived it all. Such is the toughness of some
living creatures.
Some of the statements that have been made in regard
to the survival of complex animals after prolonged and
severe desiccation require to be revised. In some cases, at
least, the creatures themselves die, but eggs with specially
resistant envelopes (' winter- eggs ') live on and rapidly
develop when there is a restoration of favourable conditions.
Thus D. D. Whitney (1908) found that out of forty-five
different species of Rotifers, belonging to seventeen families,
only two, Philodina roseola and P. citrina, could success-
fully withstand desiccation. It seems probable that the
revival of adult Rotifers after desiccation is not so common
as has sometimes been supposed.
An almost whimsical instance of vital resistance is
vouched for by G-. Tornier. He found two eggs of the
common lizard, Lacerta agilis, through which the rhizome
of a sedge had grown, dissolving away the shell at the
entrance and exit. Each of the eggs contained a normal
embryo ! In the uppermost of the two eggs, which was
perforated centrally by the rhizome, there were actually
three rootlets penetrating the embryonic membranes and
entering the yolk-sac. In one case a delicate rootlet had
passed into the embryo's mouth. Yet the embryos were
normal, illustrating quaintly but strikingly what we may
call developmental resistance.
An eel about a foot long has been known to live for seventy-
two hours without water, and a day's drought can be
readily withstood. This tenacity of life makes it easier
to admit the possibility of the overland journeys which
eels are alleged to take when occasion requires.
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 153
Some interesting illustrations of tenacity of life have been
afforded by recent experiments on the surviving- power of
tissues cut off from the living body. In suitable culture-
media they can be kept alive for many days and may even
grow. At a variable point, differing for different tissues
and media, growth becomes slow and stops and the living
fragment dies. In this connexion Alexis Carrel has de-
monstrated a very instructive fact, showing that the
death may be due to an accumulation of waste products
and is not inevitable. If the dying fragment is lifted on a
cataract- knife and bathed and fed, and bathed and fed
again, it may get a new lease of life. It rejuvenesces.
After nine washings a fragment of connective tissue grew
with great activity on the thirty-fourth day after its
excision from the organism. Thus, within limits, senescence
and death are contingent, not necessary phenomena.
The automatism of part of a body is often gruesome. A
turtle's heart will live for many days after its quondam
possessor has been made into soup. A fractional part of a
silk moth was observed by Professor V. L. Kellogg to ' live '
for more than a day, responding to stimulus, and actually
extruding the ovipositor and laying a few eggs. The
separated anterior half of a wasp will go on sucking
syrup, and the posterior half will sting. We are impressed
on the one hand by the delicacy, on the other hand by
the toughness of life.
The 'Big Trees '.In the 'Big Tree' (Sequoia
gigantea) of the western slopes of the Sierra Nevada
range and in the ' Redwood ' (Sequoia sempervirens)
of the Coast Ranges, we have the impressive surviving
representatives of an ancient genus (dating from the
Cretaceous) that once spread over the Northern
154 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Hemisphere, but was brought near to extinction by the
severe conditions of the Great Ice Age. In size, majesty,
vigour, recuperative power, age and antiquity these
' Big Trees ' command our admiration. They have the
distinction of having had a longer life than any other
living creatures they make centenarians and the like
appear youngsters.
The late Prof. W. R. Dudley recorded some precise data
on a subject which tempts to exaggeration. * Of the vari-
ous trunks of Sequoia gigantea examined ranging from 900
years upward, the oldest possessed 2,425 rings, or had begun
its existence 525 years before the Christian era '. A tree
near a perennial stream was over 80 feet in circumference,
ten feet from the ground, but was only 1,510 years old ;
another growing on a hillside not near a stream, had suffered
from fire and from privations (fifty rings of scarce years
not covering an inch), and it was only 39 feet in circum-
ference, ten feet from the ground, but it had attained the
age of 2,171 years and a height approaching 300 feet.
Professor Dudley showed the extraordinary vitality of the
Big Tree by tracing out the way in which many of them had
been able to ' heal ' or cover over great wounds made by
fire. What a tree does is not to revitalize what has been
killed that is impossible but to extend or fold its living
tissue over the wound. ' There is no organic union
between the new wood of the folds and the wood of the
charred surface underneath them, no healing at this point
of contact, in the ordinary sense of the word; but
there is effectual covering, or healing in the rarer sense,
according to the tree trunk's way.' The process may take
scores of years.
The tree already referred to which began its existence in
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 155
271 B.C. was about twelve feet in circumference just above
the base at the beginning of the Christian era. When it
was 516 years old (A.D. 245) it suffered a burn three feet
wide, and 105 years were occupied in healing this wound.
When it was 1,712 years old (A.D. 1441) it suffered two bad
burns. One hundred and thirty-nine years of growth
followed, including the time occupied by the covering of
the two wounds. When it was 1 ,851 years old (A.D. 1580) it
suffered from a burn two feet wide which took 56 years to
heal. When it was 2,068 years old (A.D. 1797) a tremendous
fire burned a great scar 18 feet wide with a height estimated
at 30 feet. In the 103 years that were vouchsafed to it before
it was killed, the tree had reduced the wound to fourteen
feet in width, and it might have finished it in A.D. 2250,
or thereabouts. * Sequoia gigantea stands practically alone,
sublime among living objects in its ability to withstand an
injury of this magnitude, and to endure a sufficient length
of time for its complete recovery '. The resistance to
insect, fungus, and microbe is hardly less remarkable.
' There is something in the sap of the Big Tree that is an
elixir of life, something deposited in the lignified cells
of the normally formed layers of wood that resists in an
unexampled way the dreadful ' tooth of time '.
One does not envy the man who can look at even a sec-
tion of great Sequoia without a thrill at the sight. * We
have, deep in their annual rings, records which extend far
beyond the beginnings of Anglo-Saxon peoples, beyond
even the earliest struggles for liberty and democracy
among the Greeks', . . . ' records of forest conflagrations, of
the vicissitudes of seasons, of periods of drought and periods
of abundant and favouring rains '. It is to be hoped that
everything feasible will be done to protect these triumphs
156 THE WONDER OF LIFE
of life these sublime instances of its power and endurance
which are certainly among the most remarkable products
of the globe.
The recuperative power of races varies within wide limits,
and it is often difficult to suggest why one type should have
so little and another so much of it. The story of the tile-
fish (Lophobatilus chamceleonticeps) is interesting in this con-
nexion. It used to frequent the north-east coast of North
America, in water about 50 Fahr., and was much fished
between 1879 and 1882. In 1882, however, there was
a very hard winter, culminating in a great storm which in
one night almost put a full stop to the tile-fish. Over a
sea-area of some 5,000 square miles the dead fishes were
found on the surface in thousands suddenly killed ofE
by a fall of temperature below the limit of viability. No
tile-fish was seen for ten years. But in 1902 the small
remnant that must have escaped began to manifest itself,
and the recuperation gradually set in.
PLASTICITY
Change of Habits. The well-known robber-crab
(Birgus latro) is a good instance of adaptability to a thor-
oughgoing change of habit. Birgus should be a seashore
animal, and it has to return to the shore to spawn, illus-
trating the rule that the young have to be cradled in the
ancestral headquarters, but it has become a terrestrial
animal. It goes high up the mountains, and Dr. Andrews
has photographed it climbing trees. It simply walks up,
clinging by the sharp points of the walking-legs, hardly
using the large claws at all. Of the robber-crabs at Christ-
mas Island, Dr. Andrews writes that they are easily fright-
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 157
FIG. 37. Cross section through a land-crab (Birgus latro). (After
Semper. ) 1 . The over-lap of the cephalothorax shield. 2. The respir-
atory tufts. 3. Two small gills. 4. The base of a leg. 5. The ventral
nerve-cord. 6. The food-canal. 7. The pericardium around the
heart.
ened and scuttle off backwards, propelling themselves with
their long anterior legs in a series of ungainly jerks. They
seem quite conscious of the comparative defencelessness
of the abdomen, which they endeavour to thrust under
logs or into holes among the roots of trees. But they
never carry any protective covering. Their dietary must
also have changed greatly, for they eat fruits of various
kinds (such as sago-palm and screw-pine) and carrion of
all sorts. As their name suggests, they are incorrigible
thieves, stealing from the camp not only what is or
even looks edible, but apparently anything that has been
handled, cooking utensils, bottles, and clothes. Dr.
Andrews complains that he had a geological hammer
practically ruined by having its handle splintered in the
powerful claws of one of the robbers !
The case of the land-crab suggests another good instance
of adaptation to change of habit. It is to be found in a
Philippine crustacean, Thalassina anomala, which is in
some respects like a link between the long-tailed prawn
type and the hermit-crab type. It is a common burrower
158 THE WONDER OF LIFE
by the shore of the estuaries and makes holes not only in the
softer ground, but in the hard clay of the grassy meadows.
In the latter the holes go down till they are below the
water-level. The animal seems able to live in poorly
aerated water, as Bate surmised long ago from his study of
preserved specimens. Its habits have been recently studied
by Mr. A. S. Pearse, who points out that the ability to
breathe in poorly aerated water would be a distinct advan-
tage, and seems to have been secured by a simple contri-
vance. The gill-covers or side-flaps of the shield that covers
the front of the body are movable on the dorsal portion
of the carapace by a sort of flexible hinge joint. ' An
individual placed in a dish will often move the sides of the
carapace in such a manner that it resembles a Vertebrate
gasping for breath '. Such bellows-like movements must
serve to hasten the current of water that is drawn in over the
gills and thus facilitate respiration.
As a good instance of the possession of a new home we
may refer to the freshwater sting-rays of the Ganges. No
fishes are more characteristically marine than rays and
skates, yet it is certain that there are several members of
this (Batoid) family in the Ganges. Two species, Trygon
fluviatilis and Hypolothus sephen, have established them-
selves far up the great river. Even one thousand miles
above tidal influence, they thrive and breed freely.
While some creatures are sensitive specialists as
regards environment, others are tough cosmopolitans.
In illustration of the latter we may refer to Dr. Alcock's
account of the freshwater crabs (Potamonidse) of
India. They are typically freshwater animals, but some
can live both in brackish water and in damp jungle. ' They
are found in ponds, lakes, streams, rivers, and marshes ;
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 159
and though they flourish most at low or inconsiderable
levels in the tropics they extend into the warmer temperate
regions, and are also quite common at considerable eleva-
tions in the torrid zone.' As a particular example, he
takes Paratelphusa spinigera, which is very common in the
swamps of Lower Bengal.
' In the rainy season it can be seen in any Calcutta tank,
often reposing on the bank, half immersed in the water :
in the cold season it may be found in the j heels in swarms,
half-buried in the mud : in the hot season, where the sur-
face waters dry up, it digs deep burrows to get down to the
ground water. The same species, P. spinigera, on the one
hand, ascends the Ganges and Jumna as far as Hardwar
and Saharanpur, and the Jhelum valley to an elevation of
two thousand feet, and, on the other hand, does not object
to the brackish water of the Gangetic delta.'
THE BIOLOGY OF THE SEASONS
We have given some examples of what might be called
the conquest of space the exploitation of the earth, the
making the best of difficult conditions, the circumventing
of obstacles ; but there are other instances of the same
quality of life which might be grouped under the title
the conquest of time the victory over temporal vicissitudes.
This is in great part the theme of a previous study J and
we shall confine ourselves here to a few illustrations.
The general problem is how living creatures suit them-
selves to the external periodicities of the seasons, or of
day and night, or of oscillations of climate. In diverse
ways the internal rhythms of life have come to be adjusted
to the external periodicities. It is said that the tropical
1 The Biology of the Seasons, 1911.
160 THE WONDER OF LIFE
African mudfish (Protopterus) taken to North Europe,
and kept with abundant water, tends to become dormant
at what corresponds to the African dry season, when it
normally goes to sleep for half the year. It is said
(precise facts would be very valuable) that migrant birds
in cages become restless in autumn at the proper time
for southward flight although they are living in conditions
of apparent comfort. It is certain that many birds begin
their autumnal migration with notable punctuality at a
'time when the external changes have not yet begun to
be in any sense compelling.
The point may be further illustrated by reference to
Professor Semon's suggestive experiments with young
Acacias (Albizzia lophantha). They had never been
exposed to the normal alternation of day and night, to
which acacias are wont to respond by expanding or closing
the leaves. Semon exposed them to artificial days and
nights of six hours' or twenty-four hours' duration, but the
young plants exhibited the twelve-hours' cycle quite
unmistakably though just a little altered. After this
experiment, Semon exposed his plants to continuous dark-
ness or to continuous illumination, and he had the satis-
faction of seeing the twelve-hours' cycle still manifesting
itself for a little. It gradually became indistinct, as the
plants gave up asserting themselves against ' times out
of joint '. At first, however, the experiments showed very
beautifully how the ingrained hereditary periodicity may
struggle against inappropriate external conditions.
It is interesting to consider the diversity of ways in
which animals meet the difficulties involved in the winter-
conditions in North Temperate countries. Many birds,
' intelligent of the seasons ', as Milton has it, escape the
FlG. 38. Protopterus. A. Capsule cut into, showing the coiled-up fish with its
nostril at foot of the pipe (P). B. Capsule intact, showing lid (L). (/4/fcrW.
N. Parker.)
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 161
spell by flight, a solution which we shall presently discuss
in detail. Other creatures, unequal to the long and adven-
turous journeys of the birds, retire into winter-quarters,
in which they he low, awaiting happier days. Thus the
earthworms burrow more deeply than ever below the reach
of the frost ; the lemmings tunnel their winding ways be-
neath the icy crust of the Tundra ; all manner of insects
in their pupa-stages lie inert within cocoons or other pro-
tective envelopes in sheltered corners ; the frogs bury
themselves deeply in the mud of the pond, and lie there
mouth shut, nose shut, eyes shut, with the heart beating
feebly, and breathing through their skin ; and the slow-
worms coil themselves up together in the penetralia of their
retreats all trying to get below the deadly grip of the
frost's fingers, and usually succeeding. Let us take, as a
diagrammatic detail, Professor Arnold Lang's observa-
tion, that the heart of the snail beats more and more slowly
as the temperature falls and the animal sinks more deeply
into hibernation. A heart that can beat fifty times a
minute in summer may only beat 2-36 times a minute at
a temperature of 2-65C. in February.
Very effective, too, is the deep hibernation of such mam-
mals as hedgehog, hamster, and marmot. The normal
power of ' warmbloodedness ', that is, of keeping an
approximately constant body-temperature, is in abeyance
for a time ; the body cools to a degree which in ordinary
life would be fatal ; the fat accumulated in days of plenty
is slowly burnt away ; irritability wanes to a minimum
and the ordinary reflexes are faint ; the heart beats feebly ;
the breathing movements may be scarcely perceptible ;
the creature steadily loses weight. But it keeps alive !
Others, again, such as the Arctic fox, the mountain hare,
M
i6s THE WONDER OF LIFE
the ermine, the Hudson's Bay lemming, and the ptarmigan,
face the dread enchantment of Winter, but turn paler
and paler under the spell, until they are as white as the
snow itself a safety-giving pallor. They have a consti-
tutional tendency to change their colour, and the external
cold pulls the trigger that sets the process at work. The
white suit is of service for concealment or in the chase,
and it is also physiologically the most economical and
comfortable dress for a warm-blooded animal when the
external temperature is very low.
An interesting and unusual adaptation to the severity
of winter is exhibited by the Canadian Ruffed Grouse
(Bonasa umbellatus), which often takes refuge among the
dry soft snow of drifts, having discovered its value as a
non-conductor. It sometimes tunnels in, but it usually
gets a start by diving from a branch or off the wing. It
makes a passage about two feet long with an enlargement
at the end, and may lie there for several days. Mr. Charles
MacNamara observes that ' except for the one mark where
the tunnel begins, the surface of the snow is quite undis-
turbed, and no one would ever suspect that a live warm
bird was concealed in the drift '.
MIGRATION AS AN INSTANCE x
From ancient days the migration of birds has excited
the wonder of all thoughtful observers. The author of
the Book of Job took note of the hawk that stretcheth
her wings towards the south ; the Hebrew prophet in his
message to Israel recalled the fact that ' the stork in the
1 In taking this instance we have almost inevitably repeated part of
the discussion of Migration to be found in several chapters of The
Biology of the Seasons,
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 163
heavens knoweth her appointed time, and the turtle and
the crane and the swallow observe the time of their coming ' ;
and Homer made telling use of the familiar picture of the
migrating cranes. We know much more about migration
than did these early observers, but it can hardly be said
that the wonder is less.
Sometimes the migratory movement is seen with almost
startling vividness, so that even the careless are impressed ;
at other times the annual tide flows and ebbs without
calling for much remark. On an island like Heligoland,
which lies on a favourite migratory route and is without
any resident birds of its own (save sparrows), it is very
impressive to see wave after wave of migrants strike the
rocky shore in the autumnal westward and south-westward
movement. The birds used to light in thousands on the
small fields now given over to batteries, and rest for a
few hours before continuing their journey. Observers
on the Isles of Scilly sometimes see hundreds of thousands
of birds of the same kind flying from the English coast ;
and taking many hours to pass. And many who have
travelled on a steam-ship up the West Coast of Africa in
autumn have had the good fortune to see enormous numbers
of birds making their way south, looking from a distance
like dense clouds of smoke swirling rapidly close to the
water. Some of the migrants often rest on the ship for
a while, until they feel that they are being carried the
wrong way. Then they rise into the air and make for the
south again.
Not less interesting is it to watch the actual arrival of
the summer visitors, especially when they come in after a
long sea- voyage, and sink to the ground as if welcoming
a rest. When one sees swallows and the like arriving on
164 THE WONDER OF LIFE
the coast of Cornwall, for instance, one recalls Tennyson's
picture
Faint as a climate-changing bird that flies
All night across the darkness, and at dawn
Falls on the threshold of her native land,
And can no more.
But whether the migration be seen in a striking or in an
inconspicuous form, it can never fail to produce the thrill
of wonder in the reflective observer.
Lines of Inquiry. It may be said broadly that there
are three main lines of inquiry, each reasonable and promise-
ful. Each has indeed already led to important results.
First, there is the method of registering the arrivals and
departures, the changes and movements, in a small area
like Heligoland or Fair Island, which can be thoroughly
explored. We cannot mention these two islands without
thinking at once of Gatke and Eagle Clarke. Second,
there is the method of collecting data, year after year, from
observers scattered over a wide area, both inland and on
lighthouses and lightships, who record times of arrival
and departure, great wave-like incursions, marked increase
and decrease in numbers, and the like. This is the method,
painstaking and laborious, and sure to yield generalizations
in the long run, which has been followed for eight years
now (1914) by the British Ornithologists' Club. Third,
there is the method, which we may particularly associate
with the name of Dr. Thienemann of Rossitten, of marking
large numbers of migrants with indexed aluminium rings,
in the hope of hearing again of the whereabouts of a small
percentage in their winter-quarters or summer- quarters
or en route between the two. This method has already led
to the mapping out of a more than provisional migrational
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 165
route for the White Stork in its southward or south-east-
ward autumnal flight.
Some Fundamental Facts. Migration is not to be
confused with the invasion of a new territory in search of
food and under pressure of increasing population though
it may have originated in some cases in this way. It is a
regularly recurrent seasonal movement, an oscillation
between summer- quarters and winter- quarters, between
a breeding and nesting place and a feeding and
resting place. And one of the fundamental facts is that
birds always nest in the colder area of their migratory range.
For the Northern Hemisphere it must be admitted that
bird- migration is a general phenomenon, though it differs
greatly in its range and conspicuousness. In many parts
of Scotland the curlews pass at the beginning of winter
from the exposed moorland to the neighbourhood of the
sea-shore, where it is easier to procure food ; and flocks
of sixty or more of these shy birds are often seen at work
among the jetsam. This is migration within a short radius.
It may be contrasted with that of the Arctic tern which
the Scotia explorers found ' wintering ' in the Antarctic
summer in 74 S. lat. ' the greatest latitudinal range of
any vertebrate animal '.
It is said that many of the godwits which nest in eastern
Siberia winter in New Zealand, but the ' ringing method '
should be used to test these generalizations. It is certain,
of course, that many godwits leave the north of New
Zealand in spring, that many godwits nest in Eastern Siberia,
and that many godwits return to New Zealand in October.
It is necessary, however, to prove that the birds that spent
some summer months in Siberia were the birds that enjoyed
in the same year a second summer in New Zealand.
166 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Referring to the general occurrence of migration, Professor
Newton said
' I cannot point out any species which I believe to be, as a
species, entirely non-migratory. No doubt many persons
would at first be inclined to name half a dozen or more which
are unquestionably resident with us during the whole year,
and even inhabit the same very limited spot. But I think
that more careful observation of the birds which are about
us, to say nothing of an examination of the writings of
foreign observers, will show that none of them are entirely
free from the migratory impulse.'
He instanced the Hedge Sparrow which seems so station-
ary on Britain, and yet is well known as a migrant on the
Continent.
Our knowledge of bird- movements in the Southern
Hemisphere is very scanty, and must be left out of account
at present ; but for the Northern Hemisphere it is a very
familiar fact that the birds of any country can be classified,
from the migration point of view, into five sets :
(1) There are the summer- visitors, such as swallow,
swift, cuckoo, nightingale, and so on through the long list
(mostly insectivorous, one should note), who arrive from
the South in Spring, nest and breed within our bounds,
and return in late summer or autumn ' to warmer lands
and coasts that keep the sun '.
(2) Against these we have to place the winter- visitors,
such as fieldfare and redwing, both first cousins of the
thrush, the snow bunting, and many of the northern ducks
and divers, who nest in the far North, but come South in
winter.
(3) In a set by themselves we may rank the birds-
of-passage in the stricter sense, like some of the sand-
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 167
pipers, the great snipe, and the little stint. They rest
for a short time only in a country like Britain, on their
way further south or further north.
(4) Then there are the ' partial migrants ', who are
always represented in the country or area in question,
but not always by the same individuals. That is to say,
some individuals leave the country and others do not ;
and the place of those who go is often taken by other
individuals from elsewhere. Thus in many parts of Scot-
land one may see lapwings every month of the year,
and yet there is a regular autumnal migration of lapwings
from Scotland to Ireland. There are always goldfinches
to be found in the South of England, but there is a regular
migration southwards in October and a corresponding
return in April. Recent research has shown that the list
of ' partial migrants ' is a long one, longer than used to
be thought.
(5) There remain the strictly resident birds such as,
in Britain, the red grouse and the house sparrow (to take
a sacred and a profane example). The rook and the robin
may serve as two other instances. But the list has been
greatly reduced by the discovery that many of the reputed
residents are really partial migrants. It is obvious that
no hard and fast line can be drawn ; and it goes without
saying that species which are resident in one country
may be migratory in another, just as the summer-visitors
of one country are of course the winter- visitors of another.
Perhaps another division should be made for the inter-
esting ' casual vagrants ' who occasionally turn up in a
country, far of! their normal line of movement. The
American Kildeer Plover shot in Aberdeenshire in 1867
is a good instance.
i68 THE WONDER OF LIFE
The migration of birds is a seasonal phenomenon, and
it seems legitimate to rank among the fundamental facts
the contrast that obtains between the autumnal and the
vernal movements. There is some uncertainty in regard
to various features of the contrast, but that it is marked
must be admitted. The autumnal migration, on the
whole southwards, is less intense than the return migration
in spring. One often observes a good deal of preliminary
fuss and not a little dallying before the autumnal migrants
get fairly under way. They make trial journeys and may
begin their pilgrimage with short stages. The young
birds are said to get restless first ; the old males are said to
linger longest. It may be that the adults are kept back
by the need of recuperation after their family cares, and
also by a moult after which the feathers damaged by the
summer's wear and tear are replaced. Every one knows
the exceptional case of the cuckoo, whose offspring, carefully
fostered by other birds, do not leave Britain for six weeks
or so after all their real parents have gone.
In spring, on the other hand, the movement is much
more intense, impetuous, and urgent. The adult males
seem usually to take the lead, ' love-prompted ' ; then
follow the adult females ; the immature birds, who will
not breed for a season or two, bring up the rear. Thus
the vernal order is the reverse of the autumnal order.
There is some evidence, also, that the spring journey is
more direct than the autumn journey. Shortcuts are found
and impelling haste is the characteristic feature. Where
the sexes fly separately, it may be that this is because they
naturally fly at different rates.
As a striking illustration of the contrast between the
vernal and the autumnal migration movement, we may
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 169
recall Audubon's observation in reference to the Rice
Bird, Dolichonyx oryzivora, that it flies in Spring by night,
and in Autumn by day.
Another general fact that impresses us in regard to
migration is its regularity and success. When weather
conditions are very unpropitious, there is often great
mortality. The streets of towns are sometimes strewn
with the corpses of thousands of birds that have gone
astray and succumbed to the cold. As many as five
hundred nightingales have been gathered in a single day
from one small town. Large numbers of migrants perish
every year by dashing themselves against the windows of
lighthouses. But, on the whole, the striking fact is not
the number of failures but the large proportion of successes.
This is the more striking when the difficulties of a long
migration- journey are borne in mind. What we are made
to feel is that migrating is an old-established business ;
it has been going for so many hundreds of thousands of
years that it has acquired a certain smoothness. A thrush
born in the North of Scotland was found at the end of its
first summer near Lisbon a long journey for an inex-
perienced traveller who is hardly counted as a migrant
at all. And there are many similar instances.
The feature of regularity is also illustrated by the re-
markable punctuality of arrival and departure which is
usually exhibited, except, indeed, when the meteorological
conditions are unusual. Fog and head-winds may delay
arrival ; a summer that has favoured the increase of insect
life may induce birds to postpone their departure ; but,
on the whole, there is a remarkable temporal regularity
in the comings and goings.
While there is great regularity in many cases, it must
170 THE WONDER OF LIFE
also be borne in mind that certain of our summer visitors
in Britain keep on arriving for a long time different
contingents probably coming from different winter-quar-
ters. Thus in the sixth Keport of the Migration Com-
mittee of the British Ornithological Club it is recorded that
' the immigration of the wheatear (including both races)
extended over a longer period than that taken by any
other species, the first arrivals (in 1910) being observed
on March 6, the last on May 19. Other species occupying
a prolonged period were the willow- warbler (March 19
to May 19) and the whin-chat (March 26 to May 23),
while the shortest time seems to have been taken by the
wood- warbler (April 11 to May 6). The average length of
the arrival period for 1910 was about five or six weeks '.
For the same year the first bird to return was the chiff-chaff
on March 5, but except for a few species the immigration
did not really set in till April 2. Most of it was over by
the end of the third week in May. The largest movement
occurred on May 2, when no fewer than twenty-five
different species arrived simultaneously on the British
coasts.
On the whole, however, the regularity of the migratory
movement is impressive, and Professor Alfred Newton
wrote thus about it long ago
' Foul weather or fair, heat or cold, the puffins repair to
some of their stations as regularly on a given day as if
their movements were timed by clock-work. Whether they
have come from far or from near we know not, but other
birds certainly come from a great distance, and yet they
make their appearance with scarcely less exactness. Nor
is the regularity with which certain species disappear much
inferior ; every observer knows how abundant the swift
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 171
is up to the time of its leaving its summer home, and how
rarely it is seen after that time is past.'
Still more remarkable is the fact of spatial regularity.
For in a few cases (doubtless to be increased) we have
conclusive proof of a bird's return to its birthplace.
A swallow marked as a youngster with an aluminium
ring has been known to return the following year, not
merely to the same county or parish, but to the same farm-
yard a striking instance of precision in the sense of
locality, and of a constitutional home-sickness bringing
the bird back from its winter-quarters (probably in Africa)
to its birthplace in England. The same return to the
original homestead has been proved in the case of the
house-martin and the stork, and is certainly one of the
most wonderful facts about migration.
Concrete Problems of Migration. One of the im-
portant questions which patient investigations, like those
of Mr. Eagle Clarke, are in process of answering, concerns
the routes which birds follow in their migratory flight.
On the basis of observations made at lighthouses and
lightships and at strategic inland stations, it has been
possible to map out certain favourite routes. Equally
useful results have rewarded ' the ringing method ' pursued
by Dr. Thienemann at Rossitten, Dr. Mortensen in Holland,
Aberdeen University and the editor of British Birds, in
Britain, and by others on the Continent and in the United
States.
The localities where any particular kind of bird was
originally ringed and was subsequently captured, are
registered on a map (a different one for each kind of bird),
and as the records of rings accumulate in the course of years
the distribution of dots or crosses on the map begins to
172 THE WONDER OF LIFE
show the nature of the migratory movement with an
accuracy proportionate to the number of data. The marks
may show an irregular diffusion over a wide area, which
would indicate the absence of well- defined paths ; or they
may show a definite strand or curve, which would indicate
one of the favourite paths. Thus Dr. Thienemann has been
able to trace the migration of the stork with considerable
precision. There is an autumnal movement from the north
to the south-east as far as South Africa ; and a vernal return
to the natal district, sometimes within a few miles of the
birthplace, was proved in some cases. The rings were
returned from Damascus, Alexandria, the Blue Nile, Rhode-
sia, and further south. One of the birds recorded from
the Kalahari desert, 8,600 kilometres from its northern
home, had been killed for food by a native, who threw it
away, as uncanny, when he caught sight of the ring. Two
young storks, nine months old, were found in Basutoland,
9,600 kilometres from home.
In the same way it has been made clear that there is
among hooded crows, for instance, a great westward move-
ment in autumn, e.g. from Finland along the shores of
the Baltic, and that there is a subsequent curve towards
the South. This westward and then southward curve
seems to be true of many birds in North Europe. Certain
contingents seem to swerve southwards by the valleys
of the Rhine and the Rhone, and then across the Mediter-
ranean to North Africa. Other contingents seem to go
further westwards, crossing, it may be, by way of Heligoland
to the South of England, and thence across to France,
Spain, and Portugal, finally landing like the others in
North Africa. For some other birds, like the swallow
and the Red-Spotted Bluethroat, there is considerable
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 173
evidence of a more direct north to south movement in
autumn. Large numbers of swallows are seen in autumn
making their way down the west coast of Africa, perhaps
reaching the Cape ; those from Eastern Europe are said
to work their way southwards by the Nile Valley. Cor-
responding species or varieties in North America seem to
fly to Brazil, and in North Asia to Burmah.
It is not merely in regard to the routes followed by
migratory birds that we are in ignorance ; we are in most
cases quite unable to say where our summer visitors pass
the winter. We know that they leave us for the south,
and we know that birds of that kind become numerous in
the late autumn in some other area the shores of
the Mediterranean, Arabia, West Africa, South Africa
and so on, but what we wish to be able to do is to make
a precise statement to the effect that certain summer
visitors of the Midlands of England spend their winter on
the Gold Coast or elsewhere. Perhaps this will eventually
become possible if the bird-marking method is prosecuted
for a long stretch of years. Another question of great
interest, which must wait for its answer until many more
data accumulate, is whether the re turn- journey in spring
is by a route different from that of the autumnal journey.
Other matters for investigation, which must be patiently
continued without hurrying towards an answer, are the
altitude and the velocity of the migratory flight, and its
relation to weather-conditions. While enormous armies of
larks, starlings, thrushes, and some other birds have been
seen flying very low across the sea, it is probable that
most migrants fly at a considerable height. Careful
observations made by von Lucanus lead to the conclusion
that it is very unusual for birds to migrate at altitudes above
174 THE WONDER OF LIFE
3,000 feet. Some astronomers, however, report seeing
birds at elevations of 10,000 feet.
Gatke estimated the speed of migrating plovers, curlews,
and godwits, crossing Heligoland, at nearly four miles a
minute, and he calculated the speed of Hooded Crows,
crossing the North Sea, at 108 geographical miles per hour.
He credited the little Northern Bluethroat with a
velocity of 180 geographical miles per hour. It seems
to be the general opinion of experts that these figures
are far too high. Dr. J. Thienemann's observations at
Rossitten in 1909 led to such averages as the following :
Sparrow-Hawk, 25 miles per hour; Hooded Crow, 31 J;
Rook, 32| ; Chaffinch, 32|; Linnet, 34f; Peregrine Falcon,
37; Jackdaw, 38J ; Starling, 46. Some other careful
observers have estimated the migratory rate of many birds
at about a hundred miles an hour. It is reported that a
marked swallow flew from Compiegne to Antwerp, about
145 miles, in 1 hour 8 minutes !
It is certain that many a bird may attain in its everyday
life to a velocity of fifty miles an hour, and it is probable
that twice as fast is a safe estimate for the rate of many a
migratory flight, when the whole life is raised to a higher
pitch.
And as to meteorological conditions it becomes increas-
ingly clear that birds in their migrations are somewhat
strikingly indifferent to the weather, unless,indeed, it reaches
a high degree of storminess or f ogginess or unpropitiousness
generally. It seems that the weather- conditions which
obtain when and where a mass-movement begins are of
much more moment than those into which the birds pass
in the course of their flight.
Deeper Problems of Migration. It is interesting to
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 175
inquire where we should rank migration on the inclined
plane of animal activities, but no secure answer can be
given in the present state of science. It seems to partake
very largely of the nature of instinct, that is to say, birds
have a specific hereditary preparedness or disposition for
their migratory movements, which enables them to go
through with them without education or experience. But
this does not exclude the view that birds have their wits
about them as they fly, for many instinctive activities
show a spice of intelligence. Nor does it exclude the view
that birds migrate more successfully as they grow older,
for instinctive routine may be intelligently perfected by
practice. That the migratory activity has an instinctive
basis is suggested by its regularity and orderliness, without
much individuality and with little hint of caprice ; by the
preparations made before there is any real need ; more-
over it must be remembered that none of our summer
visitors have any personal experience of wintry conditions,
literally knowing no winter in their year ; by the success
with which many young birds carry it through, apparently
unguided and untutored ; by a few observations of the
restlessness shown at the proper time by comfortably caged
migrants ; and by the sporadic occurrence of other true
migrations in widely separated divisions of the animal
kingdom.
Periodic movements occur in many other creatures besides
birds in landcrabs, in fishes like salmon and eel, herring
and mackerel, in turtles, in lemmings and field mice, in
some deer, in eared seals and in most cetaceans, such as
the bottle-nose whale, the right whale, and the white-
beaked dolphin. The term migration should not be used,
however, without qualification, unless the movement is really
176 THE WONDER OF LIFE
periodic a recurrent seasonal movement. Thus we regard
the turtles' voyage to the egg-laying beach as migratory,
while the lemmings' march is not. Similarly the move-
ments of the salmon and the eel are much more worthy of
being ranked as migratory than are those of the mackerel
and herring.
The movements of whales are believed to depend in great
part on the distribution of the organisms on which they
feed, and perhaps in part on ocean currents. But accord-
ing to Guldberg, there is also a reproductive factor. Gravid
females seek calm and shallow waters. It must be remem-
bered, however, that distance does not count much with
these powerful swimmers, and just as a gull may cross the
Atlantic (Germany to Barbadoes) without the fact mean-
ing very much, so a whale's movements may be much
less significant than those of a salmon.
If it be granted that the migratory activity has an inborn
instinctive basis, we look none the less for the immediate
causes or stimuli which pull the trigger twice a year at the
proper time. In the case of the autumnal movement, we
think of the increasing cold and the decreasing shelter, of
stormy weather and the shortening of the daylight hours
available for food-collecting, and of the dwindling supply
of insects and slugs, fruits and seeds, and so on. But
we shall probably go wrong if we regard these unpropitious
conditions as more than liberating stimuli, which act on a
prepared state of mind.
The stimuli that prompt the northward journey in spring
are more difficult to state, especially when we take into
account the great diversity of the winter- quarters and
the fact that a large proportion of the returning migrants
are immature. Probably the conditions of temperature,
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 177
humidity, and food supply are such as to exclude, for
many kinds of birds, the possibility of nesting in the south.
Perhaps in some cases the bird's constitution is such that it
cannot become reproductive without the subtle stimulus
implied in a return to the conditions of the original birth-
place. Perhaps too there are lingering memories of the
abundant and pleasant food whether berries or mos-
quitoes to be had in the North. Both on the repro-
ductive and on the nutritive side there may be a sort of
constitutional home-sickness.
It is difficult to get beyond mere speculation in regard
to the origin of the migratory activity. The living organ-
ism is not merely a responsive plastic system which the
environment subjects to various experiences ; it is a crea-
ture that experiments. Migration was an experiment, an
' inborn inspiration ', probably to begin with of germinal
origin in the face of untoward conditions. The new line
of solution, peculiarly natural to a flying creature, was to
evade the difficulties, instead of facing them. Thus, instead
of hibernating or laying on fat or making a great store of
food, birds migrated before the approach of winter. It
was a stroke of genius to discover that the prison doors
were open.
Our view, then, is this, that an original instinctive
mutation must be postulated, which amounted to ' a new
idea ', but was not an idea, which found expression in a
timeous restlessness, in sensory alertness, in adventurous
experiment, and in a power of flying more or less in one
direction. Perhaps we see something like the beginning of
it to-day in animals which seem to be sensitive to remote
warnings of an impending storm, and take refuge accord-
ingly. Given a beginning, we can understand the diffusion,
178 THE WONDER OF LIFE
augmentation and specialization of the migratory instinct
on ordinary Darwinian lines. Discriminate elimination
of the dull, the sluggish, the wilful, the inexpert would
gradually raise the standard of migratory capacity mil-
lennium after millennium.
As to the actual historical conditions that justified the
migration experiment and sustained the discriminate
elimination of the inexpert, there are two theories, both
of which may be true. On one theory, our present-day sum-
mer visitors were once at home over a great part of the
Northern Hemisphere which once had a much warmer and
more equable climate than it now enjoys. Then there
was no need for much migration, though most of the
birds would probably seek to get away from the warmer
areas at the breeding and brooding time, and away from
the more exposed northern outposts when winter came.
But if the climate changed and became steadily more
severe, if the winters lengthened and the snowline crept
lower and lower down on the mountains, if great glaciers
spread southwards, and so on, then very gradually birds
had to migrate further and further south in winter and were
able to penetrate less and less far into the north in spring.
When the climate changed again for the better, and the
ice retreated pole-wards, there came about a re-coloniza-
tion of the North Temperate zone as a breeding area. There
was a return to the old racial haunts which the Ice Ages had
rendered temporarily uninhabitable.
In general terms, then, the present-day spring migration
northwards implies an organic reminiscence of the original
headquarters before the Ice Ages ; and the present-day
autumn migration southwards implies an organic remini-
scence of the second home which was discovered under the
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 179
stress of the glacial intrusion. But too much must not
be made of the Ice Age, since we know that there is migra-
tion in the Southern Hemisphere as well as in the Northern.
The other theory, for which there is perhaps most to be
said, lays the emphasis on the food-supply. Many birds
are prolific, and overcrowding is apt to occur. Instead of
crowding in one area all the year round, and involving
themselves in want, birds learned, like the Swiss peasants,
to exploit two areas, each for about half of the year. They
tended to push further and further northward in spring,
exploring and exploiting new grounds, staying as long as
they could, and retreating before the breath of winter
to their old home in the south, or, in many cases, far
beyond that. It was probably most effective to go as far
north as possible before settling down to family life. A
noteworthy fact is that the more prolific birds tend to have
the wider migratory range.
The importance of natural selection in connexion with
migration was clearly pointed out by Alfred Russel Wallace
in 1874 :
' It appears to me probable that here, as in so many other
cases, " survival of the fittest " will be found to have had a
powerful influence. Let us suppose that in any species of
migratory bird, breeding can as a rule be only safely accom-
plished in a given area ; and further, that during a great
part of the rest of the year sufficient food cannot be obtained
in that area. It will follow that those birds which do not
leave the breeding area at the proper season will suffer,
and ultimately become extinct ; which will also be the fate
of those which do not leave the feeding area at the proper
time. Now, if we suppose that the two areas were (for
some remote ancestor of the existing species) coincident, but
i8o THE WONDER OF LIFE
by geological and climatic changes gradually diverged from
each other, we can easily understand how the habit of
incipient and partial migration at the proper seasons would
at last become hereditary, and so fixed as to be what we
term an instinct. It will probably be found that every
gradation still exists in various parts of the world, from a
complete coincidence to a complete separation of the breed-
ing and subsistence areas ; and when the natural history of
a sufficient number of species in all parts of the world is
thoroughly worked out, we may find every link between
species which never leave a restricted area in which they
breed and live the whole year round, and those other cases
in which the two areas are absolutely separated ' (Nature,
October 8, 1874, p. 459).
Way -Finding. The most fascinating question in
regard to migration is the one whose solution is probably
most remote, How do the birds find their way ? It is in
agreement with scientific method that instead of giving too
much time to speculation on this theme, we should devote
years of patient investigation to the much humbler question,
What way do they find ? After years of devotion to the less
ambitious question, we shall probably be able to ask the
more fascinating question in some more hopeful form.
No doubt the wonder is great that birds return from the
south to their birthplace in the north ; that inexperienced
young birds make a long journey, often over-sea, to suit-
able winter-quarters, with success in a large proportion
of cases ; that they keep their direction in the dark and at
great heights, and while flying over the pathless sea. It
is true that there are many failures, a crop of tragedies
every year, a never-ceasing process of discriminate and
indiscriminate elimination, but the marvel is the relative
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 181
success of one of the most daring of life's experiments.
Let us glance very briefly at the various suggestions that
have been made in regard to the way-finding. (1) It has
been suggested that success in way-finding may be due to
inherited experience, slowly cumulative from generation
to generation, enriched and specialized by individually
minute contributions. There is probably very little sound-
ness in this suggestion, for we have no secure evidence of
the direct entailment of the results of experience, and we
find it difficult to state what content the experience could
have in the case of birds flying by night, and often at great
heights, and across the sea, as so many do.
(2) An attractive theory is that of social tradition, and
in this there may be some truth. The idea is that those
lead well one year who followed well for several years
before. Ornithologists are not quite omniscient ; there
may be some old experienced hands amongst that rushing
troup of youngsters. But the difficulties are great.
How could the old hand become experienced in the matter
of a night journey across the Mediterranean ? In the case
of the cuckoo there does not seem to be a single adult left
in Britain when the youngsters begin to migrate. But
there is no evidence that cuckoos are less successful migrants
than other birds. It has been said that they may migrate
with their foster-parents, but this, if true, cannot be the
whole truth, since a number of the species who act as
foster-parents are non-migratory birds.
(3) A third theory, that has a great deal to be said for it,
lays all the emphasis on sensory acuteness. Birds have
very keen senses of sight and hearing ; the migrants
sometimes follow coast-lines, river-valleys, lines of islands,
and so on. But it is quite plain that this cannot be the
182 THE WONDER OF LIFE
whole answer, since many birds migrate by night and at
considerable altitudes. Nor are there any landmarks in
the open sea.
(4) The fourth suggestion has almost certainly a high
degree of soundness, that birds have in a sublime degree
' a sense of direction ', which is expressed in two forms
as a capacity for flying continuously in a definite direction,
and as a capacity for ' homing '. In regard to the second
form we have some data, for the ' homing ' powers of cats
and dogs, cattle and horses, are well known. Even when
the cat is put in a basket, and taken in a cab, and then hi
a tram, it may find its way back. It is true that we do
not hear very much of the cats who left their second home
and did not return to their first home, but the positive
cases are very interesting. There are some striking facts
to which we shall refer in the chapter on Animal
Behaviour, which go to show that if a hive-bee, issuing
from the hive, be caught and imprisoned in a box and
put into a pocket, and be thus transported for an
intricate half-mile, and then released, it ascends into
the air, and makes a ' bee-line ' for home. The ' homing '
of pigeons is also a familiarly established fact, and
the value of it is not lessened by knowing that the
power can be greatly increased by training. In fact, it
seems legitimate to suppose that birds have in a sublime
degree the sense of direction and the homing faculty. But
all that we can say is, that this not unwarranted assump-
tion makes the problem of way-finding less of an isolated
riddle.
A Particular Case. A story that may well excite
admiration is that of the Pacific Golden Plover (Charadrius
dominicus fulvus), large numbers of which winter in the
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 183
Hawaiian Islands, which are about 2,000 miles away from
any continental area. Mr. H. W. Henshaw suggests that the
islands were accidentally discovered by storm-driven waifs
who were blown out to sea when following their usual
southward migration route along the Asiatic coast in
autumn. In any case the islands have become favourite
wintering grounds, and the migration to and fro has come to
be a regular recurrence. The birds leave the islands in spring
in very good condition and probably fly straight on across the
ocean, without feeding or resting, till they reach, it may be,
the Aleutians. There is good reason to believe that many
of the Golden Plover breeding in Alaska are from Hawaii,
and that many of those that arrive in Hawaii in autumn
have been in Alaska. ' It thus appears ', Mr. Henshaw
says, ' that thousands of birds, large and small, make a
2,000-mile flight from Alaska to Hawaii in fall and return
in spring '. The flights are hazardous and many are lost,
but the marvel is that so many are successful.
' What at first might appear a physical impossibility
the 2,000-mile flight of small birds across an ocean highway
without a single landmark and with only the friendly winds
to guide them, if indeed they utilize these as guides is
not only possible, but the feat is accomplished annually
by many thousands of individuals, and apparently with no
stops for rest or food. The wonder of it is increased when
we realize that these annual flights are undertaken solely
for the purpose of making a sojourn of a few brief weeks in
Alaska to nest and rear their young.'
Mr. Henshaw falls back on the hypothesis of ' a sense of
direction tantamount to a sixth sense '. The confidence
with which the migrants launch out from Hawaii into the
trackless waste certainly gives us pause.
1 84 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Even if we postulate that they know how to make a
journey that they have made before, and that young birds
serve some apprenticeship, there rises the further ques-
tion, Why do they launch forth at all ? The departure
from Alaska in autumn is obviously intelligible, they must
flit or starve ; but why do they leave Hawaii ? There is
plenty of room and plenty of food, and some American
birds a stilt, a night heron, a gallinule, a goose, a short-
eared owl, and a buzzard which probably came as waifs,
like the Golden Plover, have become resident Hawaiian
birds. Why does not the Golden Plover become a resident ?
The probable answer is a purely biological one, that, as Mr.
Henshaw suggests, the Golden Plovers were originally
Arctic birds, and that they have a homing impulse, a
constitutional desire to return to their cradle- country, the
Northern paradise from which the ice once expelled them.
We agree with this observer in adopting the hypothesis of
an organic home-sickness which prompts a return at the
breeding season to the original headquarters or somewhere
in that direction.
Retrospect. A few examples may be as effective as
many thousands to illustrate that quality of living creatures
which every one in some instance or other has had occasion
to admire. When we watch the literal legions of starlings
circling over their resting-place on Cramond Island in the
Firth of Forth, or the living cataract of guillemots, razor-
bills, and puffins that descends from one of the great bird-
bergs of the North when we rattle the oars in the boat, or
a swarm of locusts in South Africa darkening the sky with
a thick curtain of wings, we feel the insurgence of life.
When we watch the flying-fishes rise in hundreds before the
prow of the steamer, like grasshoppers in a meadow ; or
THE INSURGENCE OF LIFE 185
the storm-petrels flying over the waves with dangling feet,
never touching land except to nest ; or the salmon leaping
the falls ; or the elvers on their journey up-stream, we feel
again the insurgence of life. When we gaze at the cut
stem of the Sequoia, which was a sapling a few years after
the Fall of Rome, we are in presence of another form of the
Will to Live. When we consider, as we have been doing,
the fascinating wonder of bird-migration one of the great
adventures of life we have a fine expression of the same
quality. But, most of all, when we come to reckon with the
history of organisms, when we see life slowly creeping
upwards through the ages, adapting itself to every niche
of opportunity, expressing itself progressively with in-
creasing freedom and fullness, do we realize what is meant
by insurgence.
CHAPTER IV
THE WAYS OF LIFE
(MODES OF ANIMAL BEHAVIOUR)
'Bacb of bet works bas an essence of its own ; eacb of ber
pbenomena a special characterisation; and set tbeic diver*
sitg is in units. . . .'
'Sbe bas alwap.8 tbougbt and always tbtnfcs ; tbougb not
as a man, but as "Mature. Sbe broods over an allscompre*
bending idea, wbicb no searching can find out. . . .'
Sbe creates needs because sbe loves action. Wondrous !
tbat sbe produces all tbis action so easily. JEverp. need is a
benefit, swiftly satisfied, swiftly, renewed. jEverg fresb
want is a new source of pleasure, but sbe soon reacbes an
equilibrium/
4 Sbe bas neither language nor discourse; but sbe creates
tongues and bearts, bp. wbtcb sbe feels and speaks.'
Goethe's Aphorisms, translated by Huxley.
What is Animal Behaviour ? Behaviour of the Lower Animals :
Tropisms and more than Tropisms The Study of Animal
Instinct Instances of Instinctive Behaviour The Tale of
the Black White AmW-Specialized Character of Many Instincts
Limitations of Instinct Some Difficult Phenomena : ' Feign-
ing Death ', ' Bluffing ', ' Homing ', ' Masking ' Intelligent
Behaviour Instinct and Intelligence Educated Animals.
THERE can be no doubt that investigators of animal
behaviour during the last quarter of a century have
been much less generous than their predecessors, and that
they have in their parsimony greatly advanced our under-
standing. For it is an important rule in science to make the
186
THE WAYS OF LIFE 187
most of the simpler factors before calling in the aid of the
more recondite. The danger lies in going too far in this
direction, trying to force upon facts a simplicity which
does not fit them.
The older naturalists were inclined to be too anthropo-
morphic in their view of the lower animals, reading the man
into the beast without scruple, and accepting anecdotes
of animal intelligence on their face value without criticism.
It was often very pleasing, this interpretation of animals
as homunculi of the ' Brer Rabbit ' type, with all the
human faculties in miniature, except perhaps reason ; but
it was not good science. The reaction came inevitably,
and about 1900 we find investigators like Bethe, Beer, and
Uexkiill declaring that it was time for biologists to give
psychology a rest and to tackle the problems of animal
behaviour biologically. And some have been so satisfied
with their biological interpretations in terms of nerve and
muscle, protoplasm and its metabolism that they have
put ' the animal mind ' entirely on the shelf, for certain
sections of the animal kingdom at least.
WHAT is ANIMAL BEHAVIOUR ?
Metabolism. The living creature is always undergoing
change, even when it rests ; for life is essentially activity.
Only in states of ' latent life ' and the like does the ceaseless
combustion and stoking, waste and repair, running- down
and winding-up, come to an approximate standstill
from which it is easy to pass into death. But the ceaseless
metabolism is not what is meant by behaviour.
Everyday Functions. In every animal there are
five everyday functions or activities. There are what Sir
Michael Foster called the two ' master-activities ' of
i88 THE WONDER OF LIFE
movement and feeling, or contractility and irritability,
connected with the muscular and nervous systems respec-
tively, if these are differentiated. These two master-
activities make life worth living. To keep them a-going
there are the auxiliary functions of (a) nutrition including
the ingestion, digestion, and absorption or final incorpora-
tion of nutritive material ; (6) respiration, including the
absorption of oxygen, which may almost be called a
gaseous food, to keep the vital combustion a-going, and
the elimination of carbon dioxide, which is a gaseous waste ;
and (c) excretion, or the filtering out of the nitrogenous
waste. Now these five everyday functions are the condi-
tions of behaviour ; yet behaviour means something more.
In the same way, the periodic functions of growth and
reproduction may be said to condition behaviour, but they
do not necessarily involve it.
The beating of the heart is a very vigorous activity,
going on, as we say, ' automatically '. It is in reality, of
course, very subtly controlled by the nervous system, and
can adjust itself to varying conditions within the body.
We may take it, however, as a good type of automatic
internal activities, such as the respiratory movements
and the quiet work of liver and kidneys also illustrate.
Reflex Actions of Parts of the Body. When we
quickly draw away our finger from a hot surface, or close
our eye against an approaching ball, or cough when a crumb
of bread threatens to go the wrong way, we are illustrating
relatively simple reflex actions of parts of the body. A
stimulus from the outer world affects a sensory nerve, a
message passes to the central nervous system, and a
response quickly passes down a motor nerve, commanding
a muscle or several muscles to move. In essence, reflex
THE WAYS OF LIFE 189
actions involve (1) a receptor of a stimulus a sensory
or perceptory nerve-cell from which impulses pass in to
the central nervous system, (2) a ' motor ' nerve- cell which
connects the central nervous system with a muscle or
a gland, and (3) between these two a ' communicating '
nerve- cell connecting them within the nervous system. The
three structural units taken together constitute a reflex arc,
but in actual fact reflex actions are always more complex
than this diagrammatic analysis suggests and cannot be
isolated, except in theory, from other reflexes to which they
are linked.
When a single-celled organism contracts itself or draws
away from a stimulus the simplest sort of response that a
living creature can make it seems most convenient to use
the term reaction, keeping the term reflex action for multi-
cellular animals in which there are differentiated elements
forming a reflex arc. From simple reflex actions, such as
drawing the finger away from a hot object, there is a
graduated series leading on to such complicated reflex
actions as coughing and sneezing and sucking.
Reflex actions require no attention, no will, no con-
sciousness, no brain ; they are invariable reactions of parts
of the body to a particular stimulus, and depend upon pre-
established structural arrangements and functional sensi-
bilities. It seems convenient to admit that they hardly
rise to the level of behaviour, for that term implies
that the organism as a whole is an agent and that it
exhibits a concatenated series of actions. In behaviour
there is a more or less effective succession of adjust-
ments of the whole creature. That the links of the
chain may be reflexes, is a view held by many investi-
gators.
190 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Above reflex actions of parts of the body may be ranked
a series of movements often called tropisms such as
movements towards the light or away from it, towards
warmth or away from it, towards one chemical substance
and away from another.
Then comes the great range of instinctive behaviour,
differing in a broad way from reflexes and tropisms in its
greater complexity of concatenation, differing in a broad
way from intelligence in its fixedness and in its indepen-
dence of experience. That it is very frequently influenced
by intelligence is generally admitted.
The higher grade of behaviour which we call intelligent
is marked by conscious control, by learning, by profiting
from experience, by ' perceptual inference ', and often by
experimenting. In the individual life-time a piece of
behaviour which required intelligent control to start with
may by dint of repetition cease to require this and become
habitual.
In some human actions there is a control of behaviour
in reference to general ideas, there is ' conceptual ' instead
of ' perceptual ' inference, and to this the term rational
conduct should be restricted.
Behaviour looked at without Analysis. Before going
further, it may be useful to look at the general business of
animals, without raising any of the very difficult problems
regarding the relative status or significance of different
kinds of behaviour. What is it, on the whole, that animals
busy themselves with ? We must answer, with Prof.
M. F. Guyer, that ' Animals, from their own point of view,
have two, and only two, occupations in the world. These
are (1) to care for themselves, and (2) to care for their
offspring. Consequently, every important thing to be
THE WAYS OF LIFE 191
seen about an animal has to do with one or the other of
these pursuits '.
Thus we see animals seeking for food, storing it, making
shelters and homes, adjusting themselves to the inanimate
world, e.g. in migration and concealment ; adjusting them-
selves to other creatures, e.g. in combat and flight ; seeking
and finding mates, preparing for the young, feeding and
otherwise caring for the young, and so on. There may
also be play during the early part of life, courtship at
adolescence, division of labour within a community, and
co-operation in societary enterprises, such as building a
dam or going on a slave-making raid.
BEHAVIOUR OF THE LOWER ANIMALS : TROPISMS AND
MORE THAN TROPISMS
Tropisms. In the lower animals, according to Loeb,
Bohn, and others, we must recognize the general occurrence
of ' tropisms ' and allied reactions. Every one knows
that plants growing in a window bend towards the light,
and this is said to come about automatically, simply
because the side away from the light grows more quickly.
We do not need to suppose that the plant longs for the
light. In the same way animals may move towards the
light without ' willing ' to do so. Prof. Jacques Loeb
has explained what happens. When the light comes from
one direction and strikes one eye, it sets up chemical pro-
cesses in one eye which are different (e.g. quicker) than those
in the other. But this affects the nerves and muscles of
the illumined side and the creature moves towards the
light. For it is usually a bilaterally symmetrical animal, and
192 THE WONDER OF LIFE
it is more comfortable for it to have its chemical processes
in equilibrium, and its two eyes equally illumined.
Tropisms, then, are obligatory movements which result
from a difference in the role of chemical processes on the
two sides of the plane of symmetry. Thus we have
phototropisms, or obligatory reactions in relation to a
light stimulus, the creatures sometimes moving towards it,
like some moths, caterpillars, and fishes, which are said
to be positively heliotropic ; and sometimes away from
it, like earthworms, maggots, and freshwater Planarians,
which are said to be negatively heliotropic. In the case of
fixed animals, like sedentary worms, the reaction may be
simply a bending towards or away from the light.
Similarly, there are tropisms in relation to gravity
(geotropism), in relation to currents or pressures (rheo-
tropism), in relation to diffusing chemical substances and
odours (chemotropism), in relation to contact with surfaces
(thigmotropism), and so on. In all cases the reaction is
obligatory and the tendency of the reaction is to secure
physiological equilibrium. As we ascend the scale of
being, tropisms are often caught up along with more complex
activities, but in many of the lower animals they can be
studied more or less by themselves.
Some observations by Davenport Hooker on newly-
hatched Loggerhead Turtles illustrate what is meant by
an inborn tropism. The babies move away from red,
orange, and green, but move towards transparent or
opaque blue. It is probable, at any rate, that this helps
them to reach the sea, which is their home, though they
are born ashore. After entering the water they swim out
to sea, perhaps attracted by the darker blue of the deeper
water. In a large sand-pit, from which the ocean was
THE WAYS OF LIFE 193
invisible, they did not move in any definite direction,
and the control experiments showed that their behaviour
was not affected by the sound or smell of the sea.
DIFFERENTIAL SENSITIVENESS. Associated with tro-
pism, is the phenomenon of ' differential sensitiveness ', to
which Loeb and Bohn have attached great importance.
An animal which is moving towards the light comes to a
shadow ; it may cross it, it may come to a standstill, it
may recoil, but usually it tends to rotate through 180 and
to proceed for a time in the opposite direction. The same
phenomenon is observed in relation to gravity and
chemicals diffusing in the water.
It is remarkable to see a tube- inhabiting worm in an
aquarium instantaneously draw in its head and tentacles
when one simply puts one's hand between it and the light.
In the cells of these beautifully expanded filaments chemical
processes were going on briskly and at a certain rate ; by
making a sudden shadow one makes a sudden change in the
rate. The disturbance stimulates the sensory nerves, and
a message travelling outwards again commands the muscles
to contract. But it all happens so quickly before one
has time to say, ' Look at that ! '
Differentia] sensitiveness is often mixed up in actual
life with a tropism-reaction. Thus Bohn's experiments on
starfishes led him to conclude that these brainless creatures
are the slaves of diverse impulses, whose combination may
be recognized in their behaviour. There is the impulse
due to the immediately preceding state, there is the
trop ism-impulse, and there is the rotatory or oscillatory
impulse. The result is an organic (not a deliberate)
compromise, which Bohn says may be almost certainly
predicted in given conditions. It cannot, however, be
O
194 THE WONDER OF LIFE
compared to the composition of forces this organic
compromise because so much depends on the physiological
state of the creature at the time being.
Changes of Reaction dependent on Internal Condi-
tions. Modern experimenting has made clear that a crea-
ture's activity at a given time is, in part, dependent on
the general physiological state of its body, apart from the
activity of the central nervous system. And the physiolog-
ical state of the body alters with functioning and environ-
ment. A well-known instance observed by Loeb is very
striking. The caterpillars of Porthesia chrysorrhcBa, which
emerge from hibernation in spring, have a very pronounced
attraction to light (positive phototropism). But when they
have eaten, this disappears entirely, and does not reappear.
The physiological state of the body has been thoroughly
changed, and the behaviour likewise. Loeb also notes that
when the male and female ants are approaching sexual
maturity, they exhibit an intense and increasing attraction
to the light, which the workers do not show. The physio-
logical state of the body has been altered by the onset of
reproductive maturity, and the behaviour is correspondingly
changed.
After an animal has reacted many times in rapid succes-
sion to the same stimulus, it ceases to do so. Some active
substance in the sensory cells, or in the nerve cells, or in the
muscles, has been used up for the time being. The weak
reactions before the substance was quite used up and
before it has been properly restored have been put down
to the creature remembering that it had been fooled these
many times. But it is almost certain that this is quite
wrong, and that there is no memory involved at all.
Cellular memory begins when there is some more or less
THE WAYS OF LIFE 195
lasting change or registration in the protoplasmic organiza-
tion.
Changes of Reaction dependent on External
Changes. A small crustacean called Gammarus, very
common in fresh water, where it plays the part of a cleaner-
up, has the habit of avoiding the light. It frequents
shaded corners and gets under things. To avoid using
question- begging terms, we say that it is negatively
heliotropic. Its habitual reaction or tropism is to move
away from the light. But add the least trace of acid to
the water, so that the solution is no stronger than T^^ of
one per cent., and Gammarus moves towards the light.
It seems almost like magic, changing the creature's
ingrained habit by a tiny drop not of some potent philtre
but of commonplace acid !
This case would be extremely puzzling if it stood alone,
but there are related facts which throw some light on it.
Loeb has experimented with some smaller Crustaceans,
Copepods, which do not seem in ordinary circumstances
to be much affected by the light. When they are put
into an aquarium lighted from one side only, they do not
behave in any special way. But if some water rich in
carbonic acid be poured slowly into the aquarium, the
scene is changed. The Copepods become positively and
strongly heliotropic ; they form a group in the brightest
part of the aquarium and dispose themselves, as best they
can, in the direction of the light. Loeb suggests that the
acid, acting as a catalyzer, increases the amount of the
material affected by the light in the animal's eye from a
previously minimal and negligible quantity to a quantity
that cannot be disregarded. The difference between the
more illumined and the less illumined side of the animal
196 THE WONDER OF LIFE
becomes appreciable, and the animal arranges itself so
as to secure chemical equilibrium, which doubtless spells
comfort. In short, the addition of the acid has quantita-
tively increased the chemical effects of the light, so that
it ceases to be negligible.
Rhythmic Movements. The story of the little green
Planarian worm, Convoluta, illustrates the combined effect
of periodic external changes on the one hand and the
internal rhythms of the body on the other. On the flat,
sandy beach of some parts of Brittany, the small worms
come up in crowds when the tide is out, and form green
splashes on the surface. When the tide comes in they
retire into the shelter of the sand. Their movements are
synchronous with those of the tide. But Bohn has shown
that the Convolutas in a quiet aquarium or in a glass tube
behave in the same way ; they ascend when the tide goes
down, they descend when the tide comes in though they
are, of course, quite away from all influence of the tides.
What is still more remarkable is that they keep time with the
irregularities of the tide. Bohn believes that the alteration
of the geotropism from plus to minus may be associated
with the alternation of relative desiccation and relative
hydration during the periods of low tide and high tide.
In the case of hermit-crabs, however, Anna Drzewina
observed that there was a rhythmic change from going
towards the light at high tide and from the light at low tide,
and that this occurred in an aquarium where they were
covered with water all the time. It is very interesting
to find that a rhythm established in relation to external
periodicities persists in an aquarium where there is uni-
formity of conditions. A beautiful corroboration of the
original dependence of the rhythm on the tides is found in the
THE WAYS OF LIFE 197
fact that hermit-crabs from the Mediterranean, where there
are no tides, did not show the change of tropism as regards
light, but were always positively attracted to it. According
to Bohn, a night and day rhythm has been to some extent
established in the constitution of some sea-anemones, which
go on for several days shutting during the day and opening
at night, although they are kept in continued darkness.
There are internal rhythms in the body whose origin is
obscure, e.g. in the secretory activity of the kidney, which
is at its minimum at about 9 p.m. and at its maximum
in the early hours of the day. Now, as Bohn says, we do
not need to use psychical terms in referring to this, and
why should we in connexion with the rhythms exhibited by
shore animals in relation to the tides?
Establishment of Tropisms. In many cases it is
plain that animals improve by practice ; the nerves and
muscles become fitter by exercise ; the creature finds
itself. We see this in the individual ; apart from any
learning in the strict sense (by association, imitation, and
inference), there is an apprenticeship of cells, tissues and
organs, and a reward of increased efficiency. This is a
matter of observed fact. What remains a subject of
debate is whether the reward of individually increased
efficiency is in any way entailed, or whether racial progress is
wholly due to the selection of the fitter germinal variations.
As the data stand at present, the verdict must, we think,
be given in favour of the second interpretation.
Tropisms are hereditary compulsions to certain kinds of
movement, and it is a thinkable theory that the particular
combinations of them that occur in any particular animal
express the result of a long process of selection. It is
quite true that the tropisms often lead the animals to
198 THE WONDER OF LIFE
their death, e.g. the moths to the candle, and that some
(e.g. galvanotropism) are not known to be of use to their
possessors, but there seems much evidence that the com-
bination of tropisms normally exhibited by any particular
living creature is well adapted to the ordinary conditions
of its life. The particular combination is reasonably
referred to the work of selection.
Beyond Tropism. The question which one would
like to be able to answer is, how far the conception of
tropisms and the like suffices to cover what is observed of
the ways of the lower animals. Is tropism all, or is there
a gradual emergence of something more, which requires
other formulae ? Is there the beginning of genuine
behaviour ? When a monkey's bonne-bouche is hidden
in a vessel of a particular shape and colour, which is then
placed among other vessels of other shapes and colour,
the creature proceeds to look for it at random. But as the
experiment is repeated and repeated, with due precautions,
the monkey's tentative searches become fewer, till finally
it goes straight for the proper vessel. In this method of
trial and error the monkey doubtless uses its brains ; is it
possible that the same sort of method may be exhibited
by animals which are very far from having any brains at
all?
The experiments of Jennings are in favour of an affirma-
tive answer. They go to show that some Infusorians
practise in a simple way this method of trial and error,
and thus make a step beyond tropisms. The Infusorian
Oxytricha fallax was observed advancing towards a warm
region of the water ; it recoiled, turned slightly on itself,
and advanced again. It met the warmth again and
repeated the same reaction, altering the direction a little.
THE WAYS OF LIFE 199
This happened four times without escape from the warmth.
Eventually, however, after these trials, a way of escape was
found. There are some who do not accept the interpreta-
tion that Jennings puts upon his facts ; but every one
admits that his facts are very important and that his
interpretation must be given a fair hearing.
Professor Jennings has shown that the Protozoon
Stentor, a relatively large Infusorian, reacts to a precipita-
tion of powder in the water (1) by turning aside ; or if that
fails, by (2) reversing ; or if that fails, by (3) contracting
into its tube ; or if the precipitation continues, by (4) shift-
ing its quarters altogether. So far, trial of different
reactions, three of which were ineffective, though in other
circumstances any one might have been a perfectly good
answer. But the point is that when Professor Jennings,
after a short interval, repeated the fall of powder, the
Stentor began with the fourth answer. It had learned
something from its experience.
It remains, in part, a matter of opinion, but to us it
seems impossible to describe the behaviour of Protozoa
as merely due to tropisms. What they do is not always
predictable, they seem to try different reactions, they seem
to learn from experience, they show discrimination or selec-
tion in what they pursue and in what they avoid. Professor
Jennings goes the length of saying : ' In no other group
of organisms does the method of trial and error so com-
pletely dominate behaviour, perhaps, as in the Infusoria '.
THE STUDY or ANIMAL INSTINCT
There are few problems that have been more discussed
than that presented by the instinctive behaviour of animals,
200 THE WONDER OF LIFE
and it remains in process of solution. Almost every
modern observer admits that many of the activities of
animals, say of bees and wasps, do not conform well with
what we know as ordinary intelligent activities. The
observed fact is that there is a different ' tang ' about
them. The problem is to define this difference, and it
may be that one of the reasons why we find this so difficult
is, that we are ourselves, predominantly, creatures of
intelligence.
In early days the problem was not clearly focussed.
The whole of animal behaviour was slumped, and the whole
of human behaviour was slumped two quite unscientific
assumptions, and the problem was to find the difference
between them. Of course, the man always got the best
of it.
Thus, many of the Greek philosophers, such as Plato,
fixed a great gulf betwixt the thinking man and the impulse-
driven beast. Man had reason and intelligence, they said ;
the animal had sensations and impulses only an anima
sensitiva. It is very interesting to observe, however,
that Aristotle, while ranking animal behaviour at a much
lower level than man's, recognized clearly that it was
purposive.
The conception of instinct, as Nature-implanted impulse,
became a little more definite among the Stoics. They
compared animals to little children who have not begun
to think. Animals have sensations, perceptions, repre-
sentations and impulses, they said, but no power of reason-
ing. They instanced the case of ducklings hatched and
reared by a hen, which show an inborn, Nature-implanted
impulse or instinct to make for the water. This was quite
sound in its way, but we cannot help wondering what
THE WAYS OF LIFE 201
they would have made of the case of a hen which, after
several successive experiences of fostering ducklings,
involving inter alia an anxious flight on to a stone in the
middle of the pond, tried to lead her own chicks at a later
date to the water !
In the Middle Ages and later, all animal activities were
slumped together and ascribed to the ' faculty of instinct ',
and all human activities were, with equal futility, slumped,
and referred to the ' faculty of reason '. Instinct was
widely regarded as a divinely implanted capacity of doing
purposelike things without understanding or even intending
them. This vicious parenthesis of ' faculty psychology '
led on to the extreme position of Descartes, who regarded
animals as automatic machines, in whose workings the
psychical substance plays no part. One must recognize
that in this extraordinary view he had a clear perception
of the strangely unplastic and stereotyped character of
instinctive behaviour. But he did not realize at all that
many animals are, apart from instinct altogether, very
actively and acutely intelligent.
Through a number of notable men, and in different ways,
a strong reaction set in against the Church view and the
Schoolmen's view of animal instinct. It was pointed out
that human activities could not be defined off in bulk
as different in kind from animal activities. It was shown
that some forms of animal behaviour could not be described
except as intelligent, but that there was another kind of
animal behaviour on somewhat different lines, which might
be called instinctive. The reaction gradually led to the posi-
tion of men like Biichner, who maintained that instinct
was a term for the hereditary mental predispositions
towards particular sequences of behaviour predispositions
202 THE WONDER OF LIFE
which were, of course, embodied in the particular inborn
brain- pattern characteristic of the organism in question.
He made the further step, which seems nowadays so
obvious, of recognizing that in many animals instinctive
behaviour predominates, while in others, as in Man,
intelligent behaviour predominates. Thus it came to be
no longer a question of animal behaviour in contrast to
human behaviour, but of two different modes of behaviour,
both of which may be illustrated in one creature, to wit,
instinctive and intelligent.
Darwin's contribution comes next. With his charac-
teristic common sense, he was quite clear that in animal
behaviour we have often to do with individual experiment-
ing and inference in other words, with the exercise of
intelligence, and often, also, with another kind of capacity
instinct ' implying some inherited modification of
the brain '.
In the second place, taking cases like the instinct of the
young cuckoo to tumble its foster-parents' offspring out
of the nest, the instinct of the Ichneumon-fly larvae to
devour the soft body of the caterpillar in which they find
themselves hatched, the instinct of the cat to play with the
mouse, Darwin argued that they were not mysterious
implantations, but growths, accumulated and perfected
by Natural Selection. As to their origin, he agreed, on
the one hand, with the Lamarckian school, that some of
them might have arisen through the transmission of intelli-
gently acquired habits ; but, on the other hand, he laid
most emphasis on Nature's sifting of the inborn variations
which are continually cropping up. Variations in structure
are of frequent occurrence, and so are variations in the
responses that animals make to external stimuli. New
THE WAYS OF LIFE 203
answers of a profitable kind variations in reflex actions,
for instance become the beginnings of new instincts.
After Darwin came a period of critical discussion. The
two chief theories of the origin of instincts were specialized
and pitted against one another. Spencer, Haeckel, Preyer,
and Wundt were prominent among the supporters of the
Lamarckian interpretation that instincts represent the
inherited results of experience. A young pointer points
because its ancestors were taught to point. An intelli-
gently acquired familiarity with a certain sequence of
actions ingrains itself, first, in the individual as a habit,
and, second, on the race as an instinct, the intelligence
lapsing. But other instincts, it was suggested, may have
arisen from a lower level, namely from reflex actions, such
as closing the eye on the approach of a missile, or the
sucking of the babe when it is put to its mother's breast.
If a series of reflexes occur often in a certain routine,
they may become interlocked with a certain inevitableness,
and the entailment of the results of the frequent
repetition of such a sequence may give rise, so the theory
ran, to an instinct. Both forms of the theory postulate
the transmission of the results of experience, but on the
first supposition the experience is intelligent, on the second
it is simply reflex.
For many years the first form of the theory that
instinct represents lapsed intelligence held the field, and
it is certainly a very attractive interpretation. Intelligent
activities, such as playing the piano, become by long
practice habitual. They cease to require concentrated
intelligent control ; they suffer what is badly called
mechanization ; and the brain is left freer for something else.
The intricate routine is somehow ingrained in the individual
204 THE WONDER OF LIFE
memory ; the theory is that in the course of generations
the capacity of going through the routine is somehow
ingrained in the germ-plasm, becoming part and parcel
of the inheritance. On this attractive view, heredity is
the racial analogue of memory, and development is a kind
of recollection.
The next important step in the history was Weismann's
critique of the transmission of acquired characters or
modifications. These may be defined as individually
acquired changes of bodily structure, which are directly
due to changes or peculiarities either in function or in
environment, and which so transcend the limits of organic
elasticity that they persist after the inducing conditions
have ceased to operate. That these are of common occur-
rence is a matter of everyday observation; that they
are ever transmitted as such or in any representative
degree has not yet been securely proved in a single instance.
It is likely that biologists will return on a higher turn of
the spiral to a recognition of the importance of ' Nurture '
in evolution, but there cannot be any return to the crude
belief in the transmission of individually acquired charac-
ters that was general before Weismann's criticism. It is
very difficult to see, in connexion with habit for instance,
how the establishment of a definite brain- track can repre-
sentatively affect the germ-plasm, and unless it does that
it cannot be transmitted. Thus, if Weismann's critique
be sound, it forbids the assumption which is fundamental
to the Lamarckian theory, that instincts are due to the
inherited results of experience. Intellectual ability may
be transmitted, for it is primarily due to a germinal varia-
tion in the direction of increased sagacity ; but intellectual
agility due to practice is not transmitted. Thus, Weismann
THE WAYS OF LIFE 205
concluded that instincts owe their origin not at all to
experience or practice, either at the intelligent or the reflex
level, but wholly and solely to the sifting of germinal
variations. The pointing quality in pointers probably
started with a constitutional variation in this direction
(there are analogous cases among wild hunting animals).
Man took advantage of this and strengthened it by vigorous
selection, which still continues. Moreover, there is some
individual apprenticeship still.
Many of Weismann's detailed criticisms must be kept
in mind whatever conclusion is arrived at in regard to
the nature of instinct. He referred, for instance, to the
difficulty raised by those instinctive actions which occur
only once in a lifetime, e.g. the young bird breaking its
way out of the imprisoning egg-shell, the moth escaping
out of an elaborate cocoon, the nuptial flight of the queen-
bee, the gall- wasp laying its egg with such precision in
the very heart of the bud of the wild rose, and so on through
a long list. What is done only once in a life- time cannot
become a habit !
Origin from Reflexes and Tropisms. The result
of Weismann's criticism was to concentrate attention on
the idea of the origin of instincts as germinal variations.
As this view presents difficulties to many minds, let us
offer some illustration. Every now and then, though far
too rarely, we hear some one say of a child, ' he has. such
peculiar ways of his own ', or ' she is not like other girls '.
That means a certain originality or idiosyncrasy, a new
pattern ; it is biologically regarded as the expression of
a germinal variation. It really represents, we make bold
to say, an experiment in self-expression on the part of
the creative germ- plasm.
206 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Now these germinal variations, whose origin is another
story, find expression at all levels. A person may be
born with a chemical variation of such a sort that even
a small quantity of egg in his food acts like a poison.
Another may be born with some variation in the eye which
leads to short-sightedness, colour-blindness, night-blind-
ness, or the like. Another has a quite unusual sense of
locality or direction. Another is a musical genius. In
short, organisms may be born with all manner of constitu-
tional variations which lead them to respond in an unusual
manner to external stimuli. The theory of instinct to
which Weismannism, for instance, leads, is that instincts
arise from within as germinal variations, that those which
are profitable survive, while those that- are very disadvanta-
geous (like some reversionary instincts in man) lead to
the death of their possessor. Instincts, as M. Marquet
has well said, are ' inborn inspirations '. Their origin is
confessedly obscure from within the creative germ-
plasm but not any more obscure than that of many other
inborn variations, such as any form of genius, or any novel
departure in detailed structure.
Experiments on Instinct. The next step was the
establishment of the experimental study of instinctive be-
haviour, which we may associate in particular with the name
of Lloyd Morgan. Spalding had indeed followed the same
method many years before, but his observations were
somewhat lacking in exactness. What Lloyd Morgan did
was to incubate the eggs of fowls and some other birds
in the laboratory, so that he could study the behaviour
of the young away from any influence of parental education.
He was in this way able to demonstrate the instinctive
character of some capacities, such as uttering a character-
THE WAYS OF LIFE 207
istic call-note or swimming deftly a short time after birth
(in the case of coots). In the case of the young water-
hen he showed that the capacity of diving and swimming
under water was also thoroughly instinctive, but might
be deferred in its expression for a long time until the
appropriate liberating stimulus pulled the trigger. Very
instructive was his demonstration of the striking absence
of instincts that one might have expected to be present.
Thus, the young chicks to whom he was foster- parent showed
no recognition of water as drinkable material, though they
would take drops eagerly from a finger touching their bill.
They only became aware of water as water after they
happened to wet their bills by pecking their toes when
standing in a dish. Then they immediately drank in
the usual fashion. The chicks had never seen their mother,
of course ; but it was perhaps a little surprising that they
paid no special attention to her clucking outside the door.
For one might expect innate awareness of the significance
of a particularly important sound, since we know that the
capacity of producing a certain call-note is in some cases
innate or instinctive. Professor Lloyd Morgan also found
that his chicks were sometimes innocent enough to stuff
their crops with worms of red worsted, but they soon knew
better. For, the important outcome of the investiga-
tions was that the chicks make up for their paucity of
instincts by their quick intelligence by their extremely
rapid educability.
Lloyd Morgan worked out an admirable definition :
' Instincts are congenital, adaptive and co-ordinated
activities of relative complexity, and involving the
behaviour of the organism as a whole. They are similarly
performed by all like members of the same more or less
208 THE WONDER OF LIFE
restricted group, under circumstances which are either
of frequeDt recurrence or are vitally essential to the con-
tinuance of the race. They are to be distinguished from
habits which owe their defmiteness to individual acquisition
and the repetition of individual performance '.
Lloyd Morgan's work marks a distinct stage in the study
of instinct. The experimental method, as usual, makes
a new beginning. His work has been continued, but only
continued by other investigators. And, leaving aside
entirely some important experiments on animal intelligence,
we may say, as regards the history of the investigation of
instinct, that the two new steps of importance are concerned
with (a) the endeavour of Loeb, Bohn and others to analyse
particular cases of instinctive behaviour into combinations
of tropisms and the like, and (6) the suggestion of Bergson
that instinct expresses a particular mo,de of knowledge,
differing from intelligence rather in kind than in degree.
INSTANCES or INSTINCTIVE BEHAVIOUR
When we pass in the Animal Kingdom from brainless
types, like polyps and starfishes, to creatures of higher
degree, like crabs and ants and spiders, we find ourselves
in a new world. There are tropisms still, and there is differ-
ential sensitiveness, but there is a new kind of behaviour
much more complicated, which is called instinctive.
When a shore-crab is carried over the beach and then
laid down, it makes for the sea in its own peculiar sideways
fashion. Light and wind and slope seem to have no effect ;
it makes for the moisture of the sea. This is probably a
tropism, perhaps complicated by some higher capacity.
When a worker-bee, coming out of the hive for the first
THE WAYS OF LIFE 209
time, flies to a flower which it has never seen before, and
tackles it deftly, collecting pollen and nectar, it illustrates
instinctive behaviour. We say that it does its work ' as
if to the manner born ' ; and it is characteristic of instinc-
tive capacity that it is hereditarily entailed.
An unhatched lapwing may be heard saying ' pee- wit '
from within the egg. This is its distinctive call-note, and
its utterance appears to be instinctive quite independent
of instruction or imitation. Chicks reared in an incubator
have the usual vocabulary. This, again, is characteristic
of instinctive behaviour, that it does not require education
or example or practice, though it may be improved thereby.
As Dr. Hans Driesch has said, instinctive behaviour is ' a
complicated reaction that is perfect the very first time. '
The mother Sphex-wasp, whose behaviour we shall
afterwards discuss, stocks each of the cells in her nest with
three or four paralysed crickets. On the under side of one
of these (turned on its back) she fixes an egg, out of which
in three or four days a delicate worm-like larva is hatched.
This tiny creature bores a hole through the cricket's cuticle,
makes its way into the paralysed body, and proceeds to
devour the tissues. In a week or so, having attained a
length of twelve millimetres, it goes out by the aperture by
which it entered, and proceeds to enjoy another cricket.
In about twelve days it has eaten all its larder. Its
behaviour is strikingly instinctive.
The way in which some new-born mammals immediately
proceed to suck their mother illustrates an instinctive
endowment. ' Each little pig the moment that he is outside
hurries over the sow's hind legs, and, in the second second
of his outdoor life, has a teat in his mouth '. Newly -born
pigs also show instinctive knowledge of the significance
f
210 THE WONDER OF LIFE
of the sow's grunting. Spalding put a young pig into
a bag the moment it was born, kept it in the dark for seven
hours, and then placed it near the sty, ten feet from where
the sow lay concealed.
' The pig soon recognized the low grunting of its mother,
went along outside the sty, struggling to get under or over
the lower bar. At the end of five minutes it succeeded
in forcing itself through under the bar at one of the few
places where that was possible. No sooner in, than it
went without a pause into the pig-house to its mother,
and was at once like the others in its behaviour '.
A blind-folded youngster found its mother almost as
well as one with its eyes free. After two days blindfolding
it required only ten minutes' practice to make it ' scarcely
distinguishable from one that had had sight all along '.
In the strict sense, birds do not learn to fly, though their
inborn capacity of flying is improved by exercise. Spalding
put five unfledged swallows in a small box with a wire
front, and hung it near the nest. The parents fed the
offspring through the wires, and the young birds throve as
usual, though one was found dead just as it became fully
fledged. The others were set free one after another. Two
of them were perceptibly wavering and unsteady, and
two were more effective from the first. But even the
less endowed flew ninety yards right away, and none of
them knocked against anything. In a subsequent experi-
ment one of the newly-fledged, newly -liberated birds per-
formed almost at once magnificent evolutions over the
beech trees. All this was performance without practice,
for the swallows had not been able even to extend their
wings in their narrow prison.
In the familiar case of the spider's web, there is no
THE WAYS OF LIFE
211
evidence
that the
spinner im-
proves by
practice.
T h e fi r s t
web made
by the
spiderling
has all the
parts seen
in the web made
by the adult.
Montgomery has
shown, in species
of Epeira, that
as the spiders
grow older the
thread becomes
thicker and the
web larger ; there
are a few more
radial rays and a
few more loops
in the spiral, but
these differences
are correlated
with the in-
creased weight
of the spider and
the increased
size of the spin-
FIG. 39. Young garden
spiders, moving
around their nest,
rising and sinking
on threads of silk,
and congregating
in a central mass.
(After Koesel.)
212 THE WONDER OF LIFE
ning organs. There is more material to work with, and
the web is a little more substantial, but there is no real
change, or need for any.
We shall take two or three instances from the veteran
entomologist, Fabre, whom Darwin called ' that inimitable
observer ', who has perhaps got nearer the intimate life
of insects than any one has done since the days of Reaumur.
Fabre sees Instinct in the insect world looming as a big,
underivable fact, which must be taken as given, which
cannot be explained in terms of anything else, either
intelligence or reflex action.
Picture the ringed Calicurgus wasp, which first stings
its captured spider near the mouth, thereby paralysing
the poison claws, and then, safe from being bitten, drives
in its poisoned needle with perfect precision at the thinnest
part of the spider's cuticle between the fourth pair of legs.
Looking in another direction, what can we say of the
mother of the Halictus bee family, who, after prolonged
maternal labours, becomes in her old age the portress of
the establishment, shutting the door with her bald head
when intrusive strangers appear, opening it, by drawing
aside, when any member of the household arrives on
the scene?
The solitary digger wasp, Ammophila, is wont to drag
caterpillars to the living larder which she accumulates
for her young. The victim must be made inert, but it
must not be killed. The Ammophila first and quickly
stings the caterpillar in the three nerve-centres of the
thorax ; she does the same less hurriedly for the abdomen ;
and then she squeezes in the head, producing a paralysis
which cannot be recovered from ! This ghastly but wonder-
ful manifestation of instinct requires no noviciate, it is
THE WAYS OF LIFE 213
perfect from the first, it expresses an irresistible inborn im-
pulsion, at once untaught and unteachable. The insect's
achievements are due to ' inborn inspirations '. They look
like intelligence ; but disturb the routine, and the difference
becomes at once apparent. To instinct everything within
the routine is easy ; but the least step outside is difficult.
It is many years since Fabre described the behaviour
of the Sphex wasp (S. flavipennis or S. maxillosus) in
stocking a larder for its young. It makes burrows, each
consisting of a horizontal porch, a sloping main shaft,
and off this three or four horizontal cells. In each cell,
the wasp places an egg and three or four paralysed crickets
or related insects. Each cell is closed when it is filled,
and the shaft is closed when the storing is completed.
Another shaft is then sunk.
When the Sphex catches its cricket it stings it, usually
three times, in three different strategic points in the nervous
system, the result being that the cricket is incapable of
movement, but remains alive until the larvss of the Sphex
are ready to devour it. When the Sphex has stung the
cricket, it grips it by an antenna and drags it or flies with
it to the mouth of the burrow. There it lays it down,
and proceeds to inspect the burrow to see that everything
is as it should be. If everything is in order, it comes
up again, and drags the cricket with it, going in backwards.
The interesting experiment that Fabre made was to remove
the cricket while the Sphex was making its inspection of the
burrow. He placed it at a short distance. The Sphex,
coming up again, was apparently agitated by the disappear-
ance of its captive and sought for it energetically. Having
found it, the Sphex drew it a second time to the mouth
of the burrow, laid it down again, and proceeded to inspect
214 THE WONDER OF LIFE
afresh ! This routine was repeated no fewer than forty
times in succession, and the apparent compulsion to do
things always in a given order is evidently strong.
Although the burrow had been so often inspected, the
Sphex had to do it again, when it brought its captive
cricket once more to the entrance.
In regard to a nearly-related East Indian wasp, Eothney
made a similar experiment, which is summarized by Dr.
Sharp (Cambridge Natural History, vol. 6, p. % 110).
' He discovered a nest in process of construction, and
during the absence of the mother-wasp abstracted from
the burrow a large field-cricket that she had placed in
it ; he then deposited the Orthopteron near the cell. The
parent Sphex, on returning to work, entered the tunnel
and found the provision placed therein had disappeared.
She came out in a state of excitement, looked for the miss-
ing cricket, soon discovered it, submitted it to the process
of malaxation or kneading, and again placed it in the nest,
after having cleared it from some ants that had commenced
to infest it. She then disappeared, and Eothney repeated
the experiment. In due course the same series of operations
was performed, and was repeated many times, the Sphex
evidently acting in each case as if either the cricket had
disappeared owing to its being incompletely stunned or
to its having been stolen by ants. Finally, the observer
placed the cricket at a greater distance from the nest,
when it recovered from the ill-treatment it had received
sufficiently to make its escape. The points of interest
in this account are the fact that the cricket was only tem-
porarily paralysed, and that the wasp was quite able to
cope with the two special difficulties that must frequently
occur to the species in its usual round of occupations '.
Fabre's experiment certainly shows how thoroughly
THE WAYS OF LIFE 215
an instinctive animal may become the slave of routine.
On the other hand, there are details in the story which
suggest that the routine is no blind automatism. There
was the energetic searching for the stolen cricket a
variation from the usual routine. It seems pushing the
law of parsimony too far to suggest that the search was
simply the fussing about of a perplexed wasp. There
was, moreover, an incidental experiment made by Fabre.
On one occasion he substituted for the paralysed cricket
another specimen which had not been stung. When the
Sphex came to drag it in, the cricket naturally resisted, and
there was a keen struggle. It did not last long, however,
for the Sphex soon leaped on its victim and stung it thrice.
It is possible that intelligence took the reins at the critical
moment. In any case, there was no automatism.
Fabre has led many to marvel at the effective way in
which the Sphex wasp stings the cricket in its ganglia,
and drags the paralysed victim to the burrow, and this
marvel does not stand alone. But Marchal points out that
the instinct is not so fixed or perfect as Fabre represented.
Mistakes are sometimes made ; the precision of the fatal
thrust is sometimes at fault ; many blows are often given.
The spots where the Cerceris strikes the Halictus are those
most conveniently reached by the sting ; the squeezing of
the brain is because the Cerceris likes the juice ; and the
idea that the mother Bee-hunter empties the dead bee of
its honey because that would give the carnivorous larvae
pains in their stomach is altogether too anthropomorphic
(see p. 426).
THE TALE OF THE BLACK ' WHITE ANT '
Among quaint and wonderful insects a unique place
must be ceded to the so-called ' white ants ' or Termites.
216
THE WONDER OF LIFE
They are not related to the true ants, differing widely
from them in structure, in life-history, and in their
social economy, but they resemble them in their achieve-
ments and in compelling our admiration. They are
unique among insects in often contributing to the scenery
of the lands which they inhabit, for the hills or termitaries
many of them construct out of masticated earth are often
twice a man's height and are often as thick as mole-hills
on a badly infested field. Indeed there are many parts of
South Africa where the hard
domes of the termitaries form
perhaps the most prominent
feature in a monotonous land-
scape. Like the true ants, they
are ' lords of the sub-soil ', but
their appetite for woody stuffs
gives them a wider grip of things,
and their influence on human life
is very considerable. Telegraph
posts and the like have to be
made of iron to resist their
jaws ; the legs of the table have
to be insulated on earthenware
cups ; and, as the late Pro-
fessor Henry Drummond said, there are many places
where it is dangerous for a man with a wooden leg to
go to sleep without taking special precautions, else his
artificial member will be a heap of sawdust in the morning.
We must not even begin to discuss the work they do in
pruning forest trees of their decaying branches, and in
aiding the earthworms in the circulation of the soil liter-
ally making the world go round. For as they greatly
FIG. 40. Worker Termite,
Termes ceylonicus;
enlarged. (After
Bugnion.)
THE WAYS OF LIFE 217
dislike the light, almost without exception, they build
earthen tunnels as they go, and the substance of these is
sooner or later weathered down, and is carried by the rain
to the streams and thence to swell the alluvium of the
distant valley.
Another introductory note is necessary before we pass
to consider, as a particular illustration of instinctive
behaviour, the ways of the Black Termite. A little
must be said of the Termites' social economy. There
is a striking division of labour. Besides the males and
' queens ', that is to say, the parental members of the
community, there are, in many cases, supplementary
' kings and queens ', kept in reserve and ready to replace
the others in the event of emergency. Then there is the
great body of ' workers ', who are really permanent children
of both sexes, non-reproductive individuals who do not
grow up. They differ therefore from the ' workers ' in the
bee-hive or the ant-hill, who are all females, though they
remain in normal circumstances non-parental. Finally,
besides the workers in the Termite community there are
often big- jawed soldiers, likewise non-parental, and the
intricate division of labour does not end here. But let us
turn to the tale of the black Termite of Ceylon, the Black
' White Ant ' as who should say a tale which we owe
especially to the patient observations of Professor Escherich
of Tharandt and Professor Bugnion of Lausanne.
The Black Termite, so abundant in Ceylon, is certainly
peculiar. It is more like a true ant than a Termite. It
resembles the black wood-ant (Lasius fuliginosus) in colour,
in many of its ways, in its nest, and even in its smell.
The nest is usually in a hollow stem a labyrinth of pas-
sages hollowed out in a brown or black wood-paper. When
218
THE WONDER OF LIFE
the observer opens a nest, ' there streams out a very flood
of black creatures, soldiers and workers, covering his
hands, but doing him no harm.' Some of the workers
are trying to save the babies who are not of course theirs
by carrying them in their mouths. Sometimes a white
baby is seen sticking on to the big head of a soldier.
Familiarity can surely
never breed contempt at the
spectacle of a Black Termite
army on the march through
the jungle, moving quickly
in a twisting file, it may
be several hundred yards
long, or four inches across,
pressing through and round
and over a multitude oi
obstacles, hurrying on hour
after hour, at the rate of
about a yard in a minute,
FIG. 41. Worker Termite, Termes making tortuously for a
definite end a tree covered
with lichens where they
find their food supply. We speak of an ' army ', but
most of the marching Termites are ' workers ', the soldiers
are posted on each side of the file and often move very
little. The wonder of the spectacle increases when it is
discovered that through the whole army among soldiers
and workers alike there is no vision at all. The effective
march of the blind army depends wholly on exquisite
senses of touch and smell, which appear to be located in
the antennae or feelers.
Professor Bugnion found a convenient small colony of
convulsionarius ; enlarged.
(After Bugnion and Popoff.)
THE WAYS OF LIFE 219
the Black Termite in the hollow stem of a Pandanus, and
was able to transport it intact to his hut, where it was
placed on a table. The very first night the black army
made a sortie, descending a table-leg, and visiting a cocoa-
tree about three yards off. They returned in the morning,
and some of them carried a little greyish yellow lichen in
their mouths. The next event was an invasion of the Ter-
mite nest by a band of true ants (Pheidologeton) whose
soldiers have particularly big heads. These proceeded to
carry ofi the Termite larvae, and in spite of valiant resistance
would have succeeded had not M. Bugnion played the part
of providence. He drove away the intruders and put the
Termite nest in a more secure place. When night fell the
blind army made another sortie, the details of which were
interesting. The workers came out tentatively, guarded
by lines of soldiers ; after going a little way some turned
back again, as if to instruct the main body ; they got on
to the track of the night before, which was marked by traces
visible to M. Bugnion and probably smellable to the
Termites. But after all, the sortie was a failure ; they did
not find the cocoa-trees.
The observer formed a little bridge over a deterrent
difficulty, and next day the cocoa-tree with its lichens
was covered by innumerable workers. They went about
their business in groups, five or six grated off the lichen
and passed it to a carrier, who continued to collect till he
had as big a packet as his mouth would hold. But the
return was concerted and orderly, not individual or hap-
hazard. It did not begin until the soldiers, who had been
standing all the while at attention, gave a signal. After
a little moving to and fro, the workers formed into line,
descended the tree, and made for home in two great bands.
220 THE WONDER OF LIFE
The so-called ' soldiers ' play a very important role as
guides and scouts. When Escherich broke a march by
making a little gully with his finger, there was general
disorganization in the ranks be-
hind the interruption, and the
spectacle was seen of the soldiers
exerting themselves to the utmost
to restore order and the broken
connexion. They are also scouts,
searching out new lines for forag-
ing. ' Very carefully, step by
step, just like cats, they slink
forwards, one behind the other,
and if the foremost detects any-
thing the least suspicious, he
draws nervously back, pulling
FIG. 42.-Soldier Termite, his " brave " comrades after
Termes convulsion- him.'
arius ; enlarged. (After
Bugnion and Popoff.) Professor Bugmon acted as
war-correspondent to the black
army from December 18 till March 8, and the story of
the goings out and comings in is of great interest to the
serious student of animal behaviour. We cannot do more
than refer to a few of the observations. The importation
of a second colony led to a war which lasted for three days,
after which a peace was concluded, and the first colony
(which had no queen and only a few children) joined the
second. An excursion was made every day ; fifteen cocoa-
trees were visited, some at a distance of 15-20 yards ; five
roads were established, which were carefully adhered to.
Occasionally, however, the whole army got lost, failing to
find the track after they left the tree, and long detours
THE WAYS OF LIFE 221
were sometimes made before they got right again. The
sortie usually began about sun-down (6 p.m.), but earlier
if it was a dull afternoon ; there seemed always to be
hesitation and caution at first ; a number of soldiers acted
as scouts, discovering the best tree ; and there was always
that turning back of certain individuals who kept the
main body in touch with the advance guard. The orders
seemed to be given through the antennae or by a quivering
of the whole body. The retreat usually began at dawn
and lasted for four or five hours. Escherich notes that
most of the return journeys ended about nine or ten o'clock
in the morning. Photographs of the sortie (taken by
magnesium flashlight) and of the retreat (taken in daylight)
showed that the long troop of workers marched between
two lines of soldiers who kept their heads turned outwards.
As to numbers, Escherich computed that a vigorous
band, crowding past at the rate of about 600 in a minute,
would comprise about 200,000 individuals. Professor
Bugnion counted about a thousand to a yard, and as the
army took five hours to file past at the rate of a yard per
minute, there must have been about 300,000 individuals.
There were over two hundred soldiers to every thousand
workers. Professor Escherich has shown that the number
of soldiers guarding a march varies greatly with the danger.
When the risks are great the soldiers stand within an
antenna-length of one another so that they are always in
touch. One morning the returning troop was harassed
by the little true ant previously mentioned. Professor
Bugnion counted two hundred soldiers on a length of four
feet forming at a critical point a living wall covering the
retreat of the black workers. It may be noted that
the species here dealt with does not eat wood, but subsists
222 THE WONDER OF LIFE
almost wholly on lichens, occasionally adding particles
of rotting leaf and something out of the damp black soil.
Professor Escherich watched them grazing like so many
cows on a meadow of green unicellular Algae growing, as
we often see in this country, on damp stones. Occasion-
ally the same observer saw a few workers eating up every
shred of a deceased comrade.
Escherich was greatly impressed by the cleanliness of the
Black Termites. Like cats, they spend a good deal of
time over their toilet, and they lick one another all over,
washing every crevice of their many -hinged bodies. Their
mutual aid in this direction reminded him often of mon-
keys. Care is taken to keep the nests very clean, and the
refuse is disposed of in a scrupulously tidy way. The
keen-eyed observer goes the length of suggesting that there
are special sanitary inspectors. It certainly looks very
like it.
Some of the trees visited by the Black Termites bear the
nests of a well-known tailor-ant, Oecophylla, which is three
times bigger than our Termite and much more agile.
When the Termites arrived there was of course a bitter
battle, in which the true ants almost always got the worst
of it. Escherich occasionally saw the soldiers lose their
presence of mind and fall back on the workers, among
whom a temporary panic resulted. The soldiers have big
heads, but very small jaws, and the puzzle is how they
can fight at all. Their tactics are nothing short of extra-
ordinary. When the Oecophyllas draw near, the Termites
squirt full in their face drops of a viscous secretion which
appears to drive the true ants almost crazy. They drop to
the ground and continue for a long time rubbing their faces
against stones and debris. The Termite soldiers resume
THE WAYS OF LIFE 223
their attitude of detached immobility and the workers
go on with their lichen-gathering.
It may be safely said that the recent observations on the
Black Termite have given the student of animal behaviour
some material of unsurpassed interest and have raised
some deep problems. Perhaps their chief general interest
is in their illustration of somewhat complex social life on
an instinctive basis, and in their corroboration of the view
that instinct and intelligence are expressions of life on quite
divergent tacks of evolution, differing rather in kind than
in degree. But on any interpretation the Black ' White
Ant ' is passing wonderful.
SPECIALIZED CHARACTER OF MANY INSTINCTS
One of the striking facts in regard to instincts is that
they are often highly specialized, and that their value
depends on their precision. Let us give two or three
examples. It is well known that the young cuckoo, while
still blind and naked, will eject the rightful tenants of the
nest with great effectiveness, just as if it understood all
about it. It is helped to get rid of the eggs by a hollow
on its back, which persists for eleven days or so. A careful
observer of the ejection of a partly-fledged young pipit
from a nest below a heather-bush on the declivity of a
low, abrupt bank has called attention to the purpose-
like way in which ' the blind little monster made for the
open side of the nest, the only part where it could throw
its burthen down the bank '.
The specific character of instinct is finely illustrated by
the solitary wasps, which store food in their nests for the
future grubs. In most cases each species of wasp has her
224 THE WONDER OF LIFE
own particular kind of prey, which she knows instinctively ;
in most cases she handles her prey in a quite distinctive
way ; in most cases she has a particular routine when she
arrives at her nest. The behaviour is complex, adaptive,
specific and constant. There is hereditary awareness of
certain things (a cognitive disposition), and there is linked
to that a hereditary impulsion to a certain routine (a cona-
tive disposition). As Dr. McDougall puts it :
' The structure of the mind of such an animal must be
conceived as consisting of a limited number of innate cog-
nitive dispositions, each linked with a conative disposition ;
and the maintenance of the single cycle of activities, which
compose the life history of the adult creature, depends
on the fact that the exercise of each conative disposition
produces a situation which excites another cognitive dis-
position, which in turn sets to work another conative
disposition, and so on, until the cycle is completed '.
Professor Lloyd Morgan relates his instructive experience
with a young moorhen which he had hatched in an incu-
bator. It swam well, but it would not dive. One day,
however, when it was swimming in a pool it was suddenly
frightened by a boisterous puppy. ' In a moment the
moorhen dived, disappeared from view, and soon partially
reappeared, his head just peeping above the water beneath
the overhanging bank '. Suddenly, and without warning,
it had exhibited a characteristic piece of behaviour, and
its dive was absolutely true to type. The diving perform-
ance was obviously something novel and specific ; it did
not grow out of the swimming on the surface.
The method of self-delivery practised by the unhatched
chick within the egg used to be regarded as a sort of appren-
THE WAYS OF LIFE 225
ticeship to the future pecking. But it is quite different.
As Spalding observed :
' Instead of striking forward and downward (a move-
ment impossible on the part of a bird packed in shell with
its head under its wing), it breaks its way out by vigorously
jerking its head upward, while it turns round within the
shell, which is cut in two chipped round in a perfect
circle some distance from the great end '.
At the time of hatching there is an exaggeration of a
special muscle which afterwards ceases to be conspicuous !
Some of the cases of so-called instinctive reaction are
so strikingly specific, so definitely related to particular
circumstances, that one is certainly prejudiced, at first sight,
in favour of the view that the lessons of experience are in
some way entailed. Professor Semon cites such a case
from Lenz's Schlangen und Schlangenfeinde (Gotha, 1870)
a very reliable work. Lenz took two young buzzards
from the nest and reared them. They killed slow-worms
and ringed snakes carelessly, but they were in a most
striking way excited when they first had to deal with an
adder. They had previously devoured pieces of adder's
flesh quite greedily, so it could not be smell that pulled the
trigger of the instinctive excitement. Moreover, buzzards
work by sight. The question then is, What was it that
made the buzzards treat the adder in a way entirely different
from that in which they dealt with grass snakes? The
same kind of fact was brought out by the experiments
made in the London ' Zoo ', of confronting various types
of mammals with venomous snakes. None paid any
attention to the apparition except monkeys, who showed
unmistakable symptoms of great fear. It is probable
226 THE WONDER OF LIFE
enough that these inborn antipathies of higher Vertebrates
are ingrained at a higher level of the brain than instincts
are.
An exceedingly interesting inquiry has been well begun
by Dr. Louis Robinson in his Wild Traits in Tame Animals
(1897) an inquiry into those modes of behaviour which
seem to be survivals of the original wild life. It was in
the pack that the dog organically learned to signal by its
tail, to guard its bone, to obey orders, to watch, and so on.
As Darwin suggested, the turning round and round on
the hearthrug may be connected with the primitive roving
of the pack, which moved from place to place and found
temporary resting-places for the night among the long grass.
The crime of sheep- worrying is a recrudescence of old ways.
Shying in horses may be in part a relic of a valuable ances-
tral instinct to swerve suddenly from suspicious movements
of snake or wild boar or crouching tiger among the bushes
and reeds. Wild foals run with their mothers, and unto
this day they do not gorge themselves with milk, as calves
do. Scotch cattle, taken to a large American ranch, hid
their calves among the thick herbage, true to the old ways,
for the wild cows hide their young in the thickets while
they go to graze in the open. The angry ewe still stamps
her foot the old signalling of danger on the mountain
side. We laugh at the sheep as they go in file and jump
in succession over an imaginary obstacle simply because
one of them did it by mistake, but they are acting in
accordance with one of their oldest and most useful instincts.
The pigs squeal now because their wild ancestors squealed
to summon their neighbours to help them against a bear ;
they grunt now because it was by grunting that their
ancestors kept together in the jungle or among the high
THE WAYS OF LIFE 227
bracken. This and that interpretation may be fallacious,
but there is no doubt as to the profitable nature of the
inquiry.
LIMITATIONS OF INSTINCT
Wonderful as instinctive achievements are, they are
much more limited than those of intelligence. They are
tied down to particular forms and sequences, and even a
slight change or dislocation makes them futile. A good
example of this limitation of instinct is given by Fabre, who
states that when the nest of the common wasp is covered
with a bell glass, the imprisoned insects never dig a passage
out, though they could if they tried, but remain cooped up
till they die. Moreover, although stragglers which had
been left outside will actually dig their way in, they have
not wit enough to show their fellows the way out, nor
even to make their own escape again. Instinct is always
fatalistic.
The mason bee makes a mortar nest with a lid, through
which, at the proper time, the grub cuts its way. Put
on a little paper cap in actual contact with the lid, and the
grub has no difficulty in cutting through the extra layer.
But if the covering cap be fixed on just a little way above
the natural lid, not in contact with it, the grub emerging
into the closed interval between the lid it has cut through
and the artificial covering cap, can do no more, and dies.
It could cut its way through with the greatest of ease, but it
cannot. For when it has emerged through the first lid
it has done all its cutting, and it cannot repeat it. So, the
routine having been disturbed, it dies in its paper prison,
for lack of the least glimmer of intelligence.
228 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Similarly, when Fabre wickedly joined the front end of a
file of procession caterpillars to the hind end, they went
on circling round and round the stone curb of a big vase
in the garden, day after day for a week, covering persist-
ently many futile metres. As Fabre said : ' Us ne savent
rien de rien '.
Alfred G. Mayer and Caroline G. Soule made some inter-
esting experiments on the caterpillars of the milk-weed
butterfly (Danais plexippus). Thus they observed that
once the caterpillars have started eating, they may be
induced to eat substances which they would never have
begun with. Although they are not receiving the proper
stimulus, they cannot stop. This tendency to continue
activity ' in the face of a non-stimulus ' is called ' the
momentum of the reaction '. Another interesting point is
the shortness of their associative memory. If a ' distasteful '
leaf is presented at intervals of one and a half minutes, the
caterpillar tries it every time and takes about the same
number of tentative bites. But if the leaf be presented at
intervals of about thirty seconds, the caterpillar takes fewer
and fewer bites, and then refuses. But it cannot remember
for a minute and a half.
The limitations of instincts are very interesting, especially
in showing how different instinctive behaviour is from
intelligent behaviour, but it must be emphasized that it is
part of the conception of an instinct that it shall be service-
able from the start. To a greater or less extent it must be
serviceable for survival in the widest sense, and serviceable
also ' as affording the congenital foundations for an im-
proved superstructure of behaviour '. Even though it is far
from perfect, even though it is afterwards greatly improved,
even though it is only a play instinct (which is far
THE WAYS OF LIFE 229
from being a mere luxury) an instinct is always service-
able.
That animals are sometimes led astray by ' following
their instincts ', is well known ; the birds who act as a
cuckoo's foster-parents illustrate this. That the hereditary
endowment is often insufficient for every emergency, is
also well known ; thus cattle will sometimes eat poisonous
herbs. But there is no difficulty here, since, on the whole,
creatures are well served by their instincts. It is impos-
sible that all instincts should be perfect in animals whose
environment is changeful or who change their environment.
The Norwegian lemmings, when they form migratory
bands, often head westwards, and continue on their way
with great persistence and considerable pugnacity. They
swim across lakes, but are apt to lose their bearings in the
water and drown. As they march, their ranks are thinned
by birds of prey and small carnivores ; even the reindeer
trample them underfoot. It is often but a small percentage
that reach the shores of the North Sea a select band of
survivors deserving a better fate. For, true to their instinct
to go on, they swim into the sea and are drowned. In a
case vouched for by Collett, a vessel sailed for fifteen
minutes through a swarm, the water being alive with
them as far as the eye could reach. What must be noted
in a case like this, is, that the go-ahead instinct is often
serviceable, though it cannot avail against a famine or the
occurrence of seas on the earth's surface.
The instinct to go on is very strong in eels, and its general
effectiveness is manifest. It carries them over difficulties
and unfavourable conditions if these are not too long
drawn out. It can hardly be urged as an imperfection that
these persistent creatures, both as elvers and afterwards,
230 THE WONDER OF LIFE
work their way into fatal culs- de-sac. Mr. W. L. Bishop
reports that in the water- works of Dartmouth, Nova
Scotia, eels caused considerable trouble by continually
getting into the water-mains, and blocking the service-
pipes.
SOME DIFFICULT PHENOMENA
' Feigning Death '. It is well known that many
Crustaceans and Insects become absolutely motionless
when suddenly disturbed. There they lie, without moving
a feeler or a limb, as if they were dead. This may be very
useful when they are being hunted by enemies who only
snap at moving things, who perhaps do not see them
unless they move. The phenomenon is very familiar and
very puzzling. Whether it is a physiological faint or an
instinctive feint, who can tell us. But it is admitted by all
that in the lower animals it is not a deliberate ' playing
' possum ' and that it is not a * fear paralysis '.
Bohn deals with the so-called 'feigning death' by
pointing out that it comes into line with ' differential
sensitiveness ', which is exhibited by some of the lower
animals in face of a sudden change in the environment.
Single-celled animals and tube- inhabiting worms show it
equally well ; they retract and remain quiet ; the duration
of their passivity varies with the light and temperature ;
after several experiences in succession the reaction dwindles
away. There is a strong suggestion here of the so-called
' death- feigning ' in insects and crustaceans, which follows
aD sorts of stimuli, which varies in its duration with the tem-
perature and the illumination, which wanes after it has been
brought on repeatedly. The creature passes into a strange
THE WAYS OF LIFE
231
state ; one limb may be cut off after another, and it gives
not the slightest reaction. As Darwin noted, the attitude
is often not at all like the death- attitude. The phenomenon
may be exhibited by a decapitated insect. There seems
reason, then, to agree with Bohn that in Crustaceans and
Insects the so-called death-
feigning is an exaggeration of
the ' differential sensitiveness '
of simpler animals.
In the water-insect known
as the water- scori* ion (Rana-
tra), there is a marked ' death-
feigning ', but it is exhibited
only in the air, which the
American species, at any rate,
rarely visits. It is so pro-
nounced, both in young and
adult forms, that the creature
can be cut in two without
any response, but it is dim-
cult to see that it can be of
any value. Mr. S. J. Holmes
writes :
FIG. 43. An insect Carassiua
standing on its head
in the ' cataleptic ' or
' death-feigning ' state.
A little less than natural
size. (After Schmidt.)
' One is strongly inclined to
believe that the death-feint, which is manifested only
when the insect is in the air, is rather an incidental
result of certain physiological peculiarities of the organism
than an instinct which has been built up by Natural
Selection for the benefit of the species '.
'Bluffing'. Every one knows how the cat that is
chased by an impudent dog suddenly turns and 'stands
232 THE WONDER OF LIFE
at bay ', a very picture of wrath, with its teeth showing
and its fur all on end. Some have supposed that the cat
makes itself look bigger and that the dog is abashed by
the sudden change of dimensions. But the idea that there
is deliberate 'bluffing' cannot be considered, even with
a creature as clever as a cat. The cat is angry, and some-
times a little afraid; the raising of the fur is a reflex.
What makes the dog slink off is partly the abruptness of
the change of tactics and partly the awareness that this
little spitfire ' means business '.
Now, if ' bluffing ' does not take place in the cat, it is
still less likely to occur among the lower animals. There-
fore, when we observe the ' terrifying attitude ' of the
puss-moth caterpillar, or the Eyed Blenny (Blennius
ocellaris], raising and waving its dorsal fin with its curious
black ' eye-mark ' when it is attacked, or the Russian
tarantula taking a pose which makes it look biggest and
most impressive, we must not too hastily conclude that the
creatures know what they are doing. What we see is
probably an inherited reflex, and is probably of real
utility in the struggle for existence, for it does appear to
have a disconcerting effect on enemies.
' Homing '. It is well known that ants can find their
way home from a distance. The present-day interpreta-
tion does not postulate any special 'homing instinct',
but regards the phenomenon as due to a combination of
factors. There seems no doubt that use may be made of
odoriferous substances left on the track, and Bethe
started the hypothesis that there is a quantitative or
qualitative difference between the scent on the way from
the nest and that on the way to the nest.
The results of Turner's experiments (1907), led him to
THE WAYS OF LIFE 233
conclude that the ants learn to find their way. They make
many mistakes at first, but gradually improve. They
associate different impressions (olfactory, tactile, visual,
etc.), and remember certain finger-posts. According to
some, there is a ' muscular memory ' of the movements
effected and of the amount of work done. But the general
view is that the homing of ants is the result of the practised
combination of a number of hints. According to Pieron,
the way- finding of ants is most frequently due to the
combination of diverse sets of impressions. These are often
predominantly visual, as in Formica fusca and F. rufibarbis ;
they may be mainly olfactory, as in Lasius flavus and
L. fuliginosus ; in the very blind Aphcsnogaster barbara
they are mainly muscular.
The homing of bees and digger-wasps is even more
striking than that of ants so striking that Fabre felt
compelled to postulate a capacity more subtle than ordinary
memory, ' une sorte d'intuition des lieux '. He caught
ten specimens of Cerceris, marked them, put them in a box,
took them three kilometres away, and liberated them
next morning. Of the ten, five returned to the home.
Some specimens of Chalicodoma were taken over hill and
dale to a distance of four kilometres, and twenty per cent,
returned. Bethe liberated some bees in the middle of
Strasburg and others at the same distance from the hive,
but in the country ; those from the streets were home (in
the suburbs) before those from the country. Professor
Yung, of Geneva, made a very interesting experiment. He
took twenty bees from a hive near the lake, put them in a
box, and took them six kilometres into the country, where
they were liberated. Seventeen returned, some in an hour.
Next day the seventeen were put back in the box and
234 THE WONDER OF LIFE
taken on a boat to a distance of three kilometres on the
lake. When liberated, they flew off in all directions, but
none returned. This suggests that the bees build up a
knowledge of the country round about them.
Bouvier concealed the entrance to the nest of a Bembex
with a stone. This appeared to disturb the insect a little,
but it lighted on the stone. When the stone was shifted,
during the insect's absence, for about eight inches, the
creature returned to the stone. It appeared to have fixed
the stone in its memory. Further experiments go to
show that bees and similar insects serve an apprenticeship,
that they have a remarkable topographical memory, and
that they begin by, so to speak, feeling their way from
finger-post to finger-post. The Peckhams speak of the
' systematic study of the surroundings,' and others have
described the trial flight of bees when they first leave the
hive. Buttel-Reepen has shown that bees removed from the
hive before they have had this ' orientation flight ' do not
return, and that if the hive be taken some miles off, a new
apprenticeship has to be served.
There are other data, however, that go to support
Fabre's assumption of an ' intuition des lieux '. Thus
Gaston Bonnier observed that bees returned straight to
the hive making a bee-line, in fact from a distance
of as much as three kilometres. When they were carried
afield in a box and then liberated, they made for the hive,
which was quite invisible behind a wood. When their
eyes were obscured with blackened collodion, they still
found their way, which shows that vision is not necessary.
The removal of the antennae, which bear the so-called
olfactory organs, did not prevent their return. These
facts support the view that bees have a ' sense of direc-
THE WAYS OF LIFE 235
tion ', more or less comparable to that of carrier pigeons,
and located In the cerebral ganglia.
The Peckhams made some fine experiments on ' homing '
in social wasps. For instance, they captured a number of
wasps leaving the nest in the morning, and, having stopped
up the nest, took them to some distance off. The first lot
was liberated a furlong out on a lake ; the second in a barn
with a window at each end one towards, the other away
from the nest ; the third, three hundred yards away in
the country. From fifty to seventy per cent, returned to
the nest. It seemed to the observers that the wasps rose
high in the air and flew about in circles until they saw
something they remembered.
Some careful observations have been made on the
' homing ' habit in limpets. In many cases, it has been
shown that particular limpets have particular sites on the
rock, and that they return to these after they have been
on a short excursion. They appear to have a topographical
memory, which fixes impressions not only of the particular
site but of its surroundings. The reason why it matters
that the limpet should ' go home ', is that the margin of
their shell grows so as to fit the little inequalities on the
surface of the rock, and a small amount of water is thus
retained during the period when they are left dry by the
retreating tide. Lloyd Morgan found that of twenty-one
limpets moved for eighteen inches, eighteen found their
way back ; of thirty-six moved for twenty-four inches,
only five got home again.
'Masking'. Various crabs, such as the common
Hyas araneus, fasten seaweed on to their carapace, and
thus cover themselves with effective disguise. When they
put on an inconveniently large piece, they take it off again
236 THE WONDER OF LIFE
and trim it. Some crabs use the tests of sea-squirts or
pieces of sponge and zoophyte. In a number of higher
crustaceans (crabs, lobsters, etc.), a salivated cement of
sand is plastered over the carapace, making it very like
the substratum. In species of the somewhat primitive
type known as Dorippe, the posterior limbs are turned
upwards and they hold the disguise which may be almost
anything, even a piece of glass in position over the back.
Most remarkable are the cases where crabs take seaweed
of the colour that suits their usual background.
The process of masking in one of the spider-crabs (Maja)
has been very carefully studied by Minkiewiez. The crab
seizes a piece of seaweed in its forceps, puts it into its
mouth and cuts off a piece, and then fixes this by means of
its forceps on the back or on the walking legs. It moves the
forceps backwards and forwards till the alga fixes on some
of the recurved and barbed hooks borne on the carapace
or legs. The same is done with sponge, hydroid and com-
pound Ascidian, and Minkiewiez got his crabs to dress
themselves up in pieces of silk paper. Professor Fol
once made a similar experiment, giving the crab pieces of
hay and white paper and depriving them of seaweeds.
Unsatisfactory as the dress material was, it was duly
utilized.
Minkiewiez made the interesting experiment of placing
two or three thoroughly cleaned crabs in an aquarium
and giving them pieces of silk paper of two colours
one the same as the environment and the other different,
with the result that the crabs chose the pieces with the same
colour as the surroundings. * If the walls are white, they
will be covered with white only; they will take neither
green, nor yellow, nor black ; if the walls are green, they
THE WAYS OF LIFE 237
will be clothed in green '. In an aquarium divided into two
with different colours (red and green), he placed crabs
which had in a preparatory aquarium clothed themselves
with red and green. The red crabs went towards the red
end, the green crabs towards the green end. In an aquarium
divided into three equal parts, the middle one white, the
other two black, the white crabs went to the white part
and remained there. In a control experiment in another
aquarium, with black in the middle and white on both sides,
the black crabs went for the black.
That the facts are suggestive of active masking and of
deliberate choice must be granted, but Minkiewiez pointed
out the danger of hurrying to a generous conclusion. He
refers to Fol's observation that crabs could be got to put
on a dress of white paper, which made them more, not less,
conspicuous. He points out that clothed crabs transferred
to an aquarium of a very discordant colour make no
attempt to remove their old costume, though they hang
on new papers beside the old ones. Furthermore, he found
that crabs put into a black aquarium never took black
paper if they could find any other colour. ' They cover
themselves with green, red, or white, making a bright
patch on the black floor of the aquarium, instead of con-
cealing themselves '. The apparent contradiction between
these exceptional facts and those which suggest deliberate
self-disguise is very striking, and it led Minkiewiez to
inquire carefully into its significance.
He found that blinded crabs disguised themselves at
once, though without any reference to the colour of the
surroundings. Whenever their claws touch suitable things
the routine of reflex movements begins, their mouth-
appendages are next touched, and then the dorsal hooks.
238 THE WONDER OF LIFE
The brain is not required at all, which corroborates the
observation of Bethe, that a crab in which the connexion
between the brain and the ventral nerve cord has been cut,
can walk and select its food and take its meals, and defend
itself very much as usual. So, after the complete severance
of the brain, one of Minkiewiez's spider-crabs was often
seen to disguise itself, executing the whole series of move-
ments in the proper order.
The power of discriminating between different rays of
light is well seen in many animals. Minkiewiez has shown
that the newly- hatched larvae (Zoaeee) of the spider-crab
(Maja squinado) are strongly attracted to the light, and
under a spectrum make for the rays of the shortest wave-
length the violet and blue. The red Nemertean worm,
Linens ruber, is negative with respect to diffused light,
but when it is illumined by coloured light it makes for
red and yellow rays and is repelled by the blue and green.
In diffused light in an aquarium with a floor of two colours
(say red and violet), it comes to rest on the red and avoids
the violet. If the colour be other than red and violet, it
always seeks out the background nearest red.
Hermit-crabs seem to be very suitable animals for experi-
mentation, as they do not get excited and can be shifted
about and placed here and there in an aquarium while
within the shelter of their shell. They show a strong
preference for a white background, and next to that for
a green one. Apart from green, the attractive value of a
colour corresponds to its position in the solar spectrum.
In an aquarium with a floor half green, and half any other
colour but white, the hermit crabs make for the green
side whenever they get their eyes out of their sheltering
shell, and Minkiewiez found that during the day they never
THE WAYS OF LIFE 239
crossed the boundary line ! The same applies to an
aquarium half white, half black. The order of their prefer-
ences is thus :
Black -> red -> yellow -* blue -> violet -> green -> white +
The next result reached by Minkiewiez was very remark-
able, that a change in the nature of the medium brings
about a reversion of the attractions to the various rays.
When distilled water was added to the sea water (25-80
cubic centimetres to 100 cubic centimetres), the Nemertean
worm, Linens ruber, turned towards the most refrangible
rays of the spectrum as decidedly as it had previously
avoided them ! The change in the medium disturbed the
physiological condition of the animal, but on the fourth
day the original attractions manifested themselves again.
When a worm which had got accustomed to the diluted
water and showed its normal preference for red was put back
again, after two or three weeks, into ordinary sea water,
it Avas again disturbed, and made for the violet.
Hermit-crabs left in a basin without change of water
become gradually intoxicated with their own waste pro-
ducts, and all their preferences are inverted. The scale
of values remains in the same sequence, but the direction
of movement has changed to the opposite, as in the follow-
ing line :
+ Black <- red <- yellow <- blue <- violet <- green <- white
Professors Keeble and Gamble have shown that young
prawns (Hippolyte varians), almost colourless to start
with, rapidly assume the coloration of the seaweed on
which they are placed. What is more, the adults that have
put on some definite colour, are able to change this and
assume a new one in harmony with a new environment.
Minkiewiez got similar results : any colour can be changed
2 4 o THE WONDER OF LIFE
into any other, though some prawns are more susceptible
than others. ' Once changed, the colour of the Hippolyte,
even in the most obstinate, becomes plastic, and can be
changed with astonishing rapidity, sometimes in ten
minutes '.
According to Minkiewiez, what it seems to come to is
this. In a green environment, the spider-crab becomes
positively susceptible to green, and negative in relation
to other colours. It will disguise itself in such green as it
can find growing on the green surfaces. It does not choose
its disguise. When it is transferred to an aquarium half
red and half green, it goes to the green half, not because its
disguise is green, but because it is itself attracted by green.
It does not choose its environment. In a dark aquarium
the crab may make itself conspicuous by putting on pieces
of light-coloured paper instead of black paper, for any
colour is more attractive than black, which has no influence
at all.
The behaviour of the spider-crab in its self -concealment
is composed of two parts. In the first place, it is drawn or
driven towards certain coloured surfaces, according to the
sum of the given conditions. Once there, and in touch
with material usually seaweed it begins, in the second
place, to cover itself, one set of tactile impressions provoking
certain movements of the claws, which lead to tactile impres-
sions of the mouth parts and further movements and so
on, until the whole routine is accomplished. We have
given this case in some detail because it illustrates the work
of the modern school, who rightly believe in pushing physio-
logical interpretations as far as they will go before invoking
an ' efficient consciousness ' or the like.
In Summary. As regards the theory of instinct, there
THE WAYS OF LIFE 241
are three main views : (a) Instinctive actions are re-
garded by some as concatenated reflexes, as non- cognitive
hereditary dispositions to follow a certain routine Avhen the
trigger is pulled. (6) Instinctive actions are regarded by
some as quite inseparable from intelligence, (c) Instinct and
intelligence are regarded by Bergson and others as two
radically different, though complementary, kinds of
knowing, which have evolved along divergent lines. It is
too soon to come to a decision in regard to these rival
theories. The fact remains that there is a big area of
animal behaviour of a peculiarly fascinating type which is
conveniently called instinctive.
INTELLIGENT BEHAVIOUR
When we pass from the Invertebrates to the Vertebrates,
we find ourselves in a new atmosphere. Instinct begins
to count for less and intelligence for more. There are,
indeed, many illustrations of intelligence among Inverte-
brates and of instinct among Vertebrates, but on the whole
the big-brained type, which reaches its climax in Birds
and Mammals, is one which is relatively poor in ready-
made predispositions to certain lines of behaviour and
relatively rich in its power of learning by experience. As
Sir Ray Lankester has said, the big brain type is eminently
educable.
After naturalists condescended to credit animals with
intelligence analogous to their own, and ceased to bundle
all animal behaviour together and label it ' instinctive ',
there was a generous reaction. It was the fashion to see a
Brer Rabbit everywhere, and to read the man into the
beast without let or hindrance. All sorts of delightful
242 THE WONDER OF LIFE
anecdotes of animal sagacity were collected with more
zeal than discretion.
We may associate with the name of Romanes in particu-
lar the beginning of a more critical period. Though he was
not always sufficiently stern himself, he did important
work in sifting the data, and in trying to separate out
precise observation from the more or less unconscious
inferences with which the recorder so often interpenetrates
it. He drew the useful distinction between perceptual
inference (intelligence), where a conclusion is drawn from
concrete representations, and conceptual inference (reason),
where the syllogism involves general concepts ; and showed
that there was no evidence compelling us to credit animals
with more than the former. Considerable progress has
also rewarded the work of the experimental school, who
have studied the process of ' learning ', of forming associa-
tions, of profiting by experience, of experimenting in novel
situations, and so on.
Association. It was a great step in evolution when
animals began to associate sensations together. We mean
by a sensation, physiologically, an impression made on the
nervous system by external stimulus, and psychologically,
an awareness (to some degree) of the external stimulus.
Let us refer briefly to some of the experimental work which
has been done in the study of the association of sensations.
There is, for instance, the work of Pavlov and his school
on the establishment of associations in the dog. It is well
known that a dog's mouth may water when it sees food ;
there is a reflex stimulation of the salivary glands, not
by direct contact with food, but circuitously by a visual
impression. When the food is put in the dog's mouth,
the salivation must follow ; when the stimulation is cir-
FIG. 44. Bird-catching spider (Mygale avicularia) catching a
humming-bird. From a specimen.
242
anecdot
zeal tha
We m
lar the
not .
THE WONDER OF LIFE
aa***fei sagacity were collected with more
r
tii the name of Romanes in particu-
nore critical period. Though he was
'>. stern himself, . he did important
.= ?**< Ut&, and in trying to separate out
-A**;-.^ ffron the more or less unconscious
-. !.(. l-h* recorder so often interpenetrates
n**fn\ distinction between perceptual
where a conclusion is drawn from
and conceptual inference (reason),
n-*e general concepts ; and showed
IT us to credit animals^
U,t 5,-.s n '
has been
There is,
on the esr.
known that &
there is a refl.
by direct OOUM
impression. When
the
lution when
We mean
ir.ade on the
psychologically,
xternal stimulus.
. : : 'Otimental work which
xaation of sensations.
Pavlov and his school
in the dog. It is well
ter when it sees food ;
' the salivary glands, not
cuitously by a visual
- in the dog's mouth,
-he stimulation is cir-
!
THE WAYS OF LIFE 243
cuitous the result is inconstant. Pavlov showed that if
a whistle is always sounded when a dog gets something
to eat, then by and by the sound of the whistle will make
the dog salivate. An association between the sound and
the gustatory excitation has been established.
The stimulus that ' suggests ' the salivation may be
almost anything if the dog has the association estab-
lished it may be, besides sight and sound, an odour, a
movement, a change of temperature or illumination, a
scratching of the skin, and so on. The method is useful
in definitely proving the animal's sensitiveness to various
stimuli some of them well known to all who know dogs,
and others a little surprising but its chief value is in
showing the establishment of cerebral associations, and in
discovering their laws. The experiments leave in the mind
a vivid impression of the remarkable plasticity of the dog's
brain in forming associations. Thus, Orbeli succeeded in
establishing a reflex between the salivation and the shape
of the letter T (as distinguished from other shapes) thrown
on a screen.
Bohn gives some other instructive illustrations. Many
fishes show no sign of hearing sounds, and yet they some-
times hear them. For Meyer taught some fishes in a couple
of months that whenever a certain sound was made they
would find some food in a dark chamber in their aquarium.
They acquired an interest in the sound and they came
gradually to associate it with their memory of food.
There is a special interest in experiments with fishes,
since their brain, especially in bony fishes, or Teleosts, has
stopped at a low level. Some observers, like Edinger, deny
them even memory. M. Oxner has recently made some
instructive observations at the Oceanographical Museum
244 THE WONDER OF LIFE
at Monaco with a fish called Coris julis, whose intelligence
is at an interesting incipient stage. To begin with, he
showed that when he disguised the hook very cleverly, he
could catch the same fish as often as he pleased. But this
only proved that the disguising of the hook was practically
perfect, and that the fish was appetized. If there was
no hint of the hook, there was nothing which an unreflecting
creature could learn. A certain sensory impression raised
a recollection of a pleasant experience, and action followed
almost like a reflex.
Oxner's experiments with the sea-perch (Serranus scriba)
are very instructive. In an aquarium he hung a red and
a green cylinder by silk threads of a similar colour, and
put food in the red one only. For the first two days the
wary fish did not approach the cylinders at all. On the
third day, after fifteen minutes' ' deliberation ', it entered
the cylinder and ate the food ; on the fourth day it did
this after five minutes ; on the fifth day after half a minute ;
from the sixth to the tenth day it rushed in at once. On
the eleventh day it entered a fresh red cylinder that had
no food in it, and waited there for three minutes. So that
one may reasonably conclude that an association had been
established between the red colour and the food.
On each of the succeeding six days the fish rushed into
the empty red cylinder, and when Oxner dropped in some
food, a little was taken. On the eighteenth, nineteenth and
twentieth days, the fish was unappetized and would not
eat the food. But the interesting fact was, that even in
the absence of appetite, the fish seemed unable to resist
rushing into the red cylinder. The association worked
almost like a reflex. It may be noted that there is no
particular attraction in the red colour, for the same general
THE WAYS OF LIFE 245
results were obtained when the food was put in a cylinder
of another colour.
Bouvier was able to prove that wasps of the genus Bembex
associated a certain stone, for instance, with the way to
their burrow. It has been shown that the American
crawfish, the crab, and the hermit-crab can be taught to
take the more advantageous or the easier of two alternative
paths. Anna Drzewina gave hermit-crabs which had been
deprived of their shells a number of top-shells (Trochus)
with the openings closed. The hermit-crabs spent futile
days and nights trying to use the closed shells, but after
six to eight days gave it up. Even when a shell with a
paper lid was given them, they would not so much as try.
They associated the form of the shell with failure. But
when other closed shells of a different shape were given to
them, they began eagerly again their futile attempts to
win a way in.
Trial and Error. In illustration of another experi-
mental method, we may refer to Professor Thorndike's
investigation of the learning powers of cats and dogs.
He contrived cages with doors which could be opened by
the manipulation of more or less intricate combinations of
bolts and levers. Hungry cats and dogs were shut in
and were tempted, by food placed just outside, to solve
the problem of their prison-doors. In similar circumstances,
we should probably do a little thinking, make one trial,
and be free. But this was not what the cats and dogs did.
They got out by the ' trial and error ' method ; that is to
say, they made one experiment after another until they
hit upon the fit and proper way of working the mechanism.
The experiment was repeated over and over again, and
the curves recording the times taken to escape showed a
246 THE WONDER OF LIFE
gradual descent. If the animals had ideas on the subject,
they did not seem to use them. They learned by ' trial
and error,' as we often do ourselves. But Professor Thorn-
dike made an important step in suggesting that the pleasure
of the meal that rewarded escape served to ' stamp
in ' the immediately antecedent association between the
picture of the interior of the cage and the successful impulse
that led to the succession of muscular movements effecting
release. This is Professor Thorndike's ' sense-impulse '
theory of learning.
When Thorndike's cats were shut up in boxes which
could be easily opened in a particular way, they seemed
to get out by accident. On subsequent occasions they
did not take quite so long, and they gradually learned the
trick. Dogs were quicker, and monkeys quicker still.
In most cases the method seems to be the same a chance
discovery, and subsequently a gradual elimination of the
ineffective attempts. But there appear to be some cases
where it looks as if the animal had an intuition of the line
of effective trial, as if it ' had a notion ' of the best thing
to do.
Experiments, especially in getting out of labyrinths, have
been made with rats and guinea-pigs, chickens and sparrows,
and some other creatures. The story is in most cases
essentially the same. The animals learn more or less
quickly to profit by their mistakes and to conquer the
difficulties of the situation. In some cases (Watson's
white rats) the learning appears to depend in great part on
a muscular memory of the effective sequence of movements,
for the elimination of sight, hearing and smell and a good
deal of tactility did not seem to make much difference
to the education in the maze.
THE WAYS OF LIFE 247
Of great interest are the experiments made by Yerkes
on ' dancing mice '. These fascinating creatures represent
a peculiar variety, of unknown origin, which has been the
subject of artificial selection. They are characterized by
the inability to move far in a straight line without whirling
or circling about with extreme rapidity. They are quite
deaf, except sometimes during the third week of life.
Their power of discriminating differences in brightness is
acute, but their colour- vision, in the strict sense, is poor.
They are quick to perceive movements, but make little
of form. They have considerable powers of learning and
can remember an acquired habit for 2-8 weeks after disuse.
What has been forgotten is more quickly re-learned.
Dr. Yerkes arranged in their cage two passages, with doors
which bore movable cards differing in colour or in surface.
One passage led to food, the other to a slight electric shock.
The food was sometimes to the right and sometimes to the
left, but the door which led to it was marked with the
same kind of card. When there were many changes the
mice hesitated a good deal, going from one to another
and touching the cards.
This point is of great interest, and must be emphasized.
When the mouse found the right-hand door to be the path
to food and freedom several times in succession, it tried
the plan of keeping to that door. When it found that
the cards were being alternated, it learned also to alternate.
When it found that this did not work when the changes
were irregular then it brought all its powers of discrimina-
tion to bear on the problem. The learning how to ' choose '
aright was quickest when the difference in the illumination
of the two cards was most marked (colour in itself does
not seem to count), and it was also noteworthy that when
248 THE WONDER OF LIFE
fine discrimination was necessary, a strong electrical stimu-
lation the punishment of error seemed to hinder, not to
help, progress.
The case of the dancing mouse, so carefully studied
by Dr. Yerkes, seems peculiarly interesting because of
what one may call its nonchalance and inattentiveness.
' Most Mammals which have been experimentally studied
have proved their eagerness and ability to learn the shortest,
quickest and simplest route to the food without the addi-
tional spur of punishment for wandering. With the dancer
it is different. It is content to be moving whether the
movement carries it directly to the food-box is of secondary
importance. On its way to the food-box, no matter
whether the box be slightly or strikingly different from
its companion box, the dancer may go by way of the
wrong box, may take a few turns, cut some figure eights,
or even spin like a top for a few seconds almost within
vibrissa-reach of the food-box, and all this though it be
very hungry '.
But in spite of this lack of concentration, it learns to
discriminate successfully.
It is difficult to know how much imitation counts for in
animal behaviour. A monkey which has learned to work
a piece of mechanism is sometimes able to teach others to
imitate all the required movements, but often it meets
with the variety of futile imitations that other teachers are
familiar with. In one case, the simple trick of reaching a
fruit with a stick was learned by one, yet never imitated
by his companions. It is probable that in the natural
life of the creature, and in the play period, imitation counts
for much more than experiment has as yet indicated.
THE WAYS OF LIFE 249
It is not even certain that a cat can catch a mouse without
having been shown the way !
In regard to instinctive, as well as intelligent behaviour,
it is probable that the influence of others counts for much
probably for more than is generally allowed. Taken
singly, the ant, the bee or the termite has not a great deal
to say for itself ; but ' the co-operative work of the hive or
nest is amongst the greatest wonders of nature '. ' This ',
says Professor Carveth Read, ' perhaps may be best ex-
plained by the incessant trying of all the operative ants, or
bees, or termites, at their several tasks, in which individuals
often fail, but have their work made good by the trying of
others '. As Turner points out in his study of ' homing '
in ants, the appearance of concerted division of labour
may be deceptive, they supplement one another because all
are trying. Thus, flurried ants carrying pupae may hide
these under a stone, and others who know the way may
rescue the pupae if they discover them.
As every one knows, a piece of behaviour which was
* thought out ' to begin with, or required intelligent control
at every turn, may be repeated so often that the brain
is modified by its performance, and the need for attention
and control ceases. In a word, it becomes habitual. ' A
habit is a more or less definite mode of procedure or kind
of behaviour which has been acquired by the individual and
has become, so to speak, stereotyped through repetition '.
INSTINCT AND INTELLIGENCE
When a newly-hatched coot or blackheaded gull is
tumbled into water, it swims well instinctively ; when the
hens come running when the hen-wife calls ' Tuck- Tuck ',
250 THE WONDER OF LIFE
they are putting two and two together in a simple way.
When a dog turns round and round and smooths the herb-
age of the hearthrug into a bed for the night, it is obeying
an ancient instinct ; when it tries various ways of getting a
stick with a crooked handle through a fence of close-set
uprights, it is using its intelligence. When a horse shies
at an unexplained rustling in the hedgerow, it does so
instinctively ; when it takes the market-cart safely home
with the driver asleep, it does so intelligently. When
inexperienced bees deal successfully with flowers, the per-
formance is instinctive ; when they set up house in a tree
or mend a broken comb in an economical and effective way,
intelligence is probably at work. When a bird utters its
call-note before it is hatched, that is instinctive ; when
a parrot tells its mistress that it is dinner-time, that is
more or less intelligent.
In these instances we have contrasted, in a simple way,
instinctive and intelligent behaviour. It seems clear
that whether the difference between them be of degree or
of kind, there is a difference of sufficient importance to
warrant the use of two different words. But it seems neces-
sary to admit that it is not easy to discover either kind of
behaviour in a perfectly pure form. Instinctive behaviour
has often a spice of intelligence along with it, or is modified
by intelligent ' learning '. Intelligent behaviour often
utilizes instinctive dispositions as a basis.
That the distinctive call-note of a bird is sometimes
instinctive is satisfactorily proved by cases where the
characteristic sound is uttered before the young bird
is hatched. Mr. Hudson cites the case of a young
Rhynchotus rufescens, isolated when it was getting out of
the egg-shell and reared beyond reach of education, which
THE WAYS OF LIFE 251
was nevertheless accustomed, long before it was full-grown,
to retire to a dark corner of the room and give forth its
characteristic evening song. Young coots hatched in an
incubator utter the same note as their fellows in natural
conditions.
But this cannot be the whole story, for there is no reason
to doubt the experiments made by the Hon. Daines Barring-
ton, one of Gilbert White's correspondents. He reared linnets
under skylarks, woodlarks, and titlarks, and found that
they learned the song of their foster- parent in each case.
This points to the conclusion that imitation counts for a
great deal. It is likely that many young birds learn their
song from their parents. Mr. Hudson reports that in the
case of the oven-bird the parents sing a sort of duet together,
which the young birds, when only partially fledged, prac-
tise inside the nest in the intervals when the parents are
absent. Mr. G. W. Bulman, a careful observer, gives a cir-
cumstantial account of the yellow-hammer's singing lessons.
The whole subject requires more attention and, above all,
some careful experimenting.
The intrusion of intelligence upon an instinctive routine
is probably seen when a bee that is unable to get at the
nectar of a flower in the ordinary legitimate manner,
proceeds to cut a hole through the base of the tube. Many
years ago Hermann Miiller pointed out that Bombus
terrestris, which has a shorter proboscis than some other
species of the genus, often tries in vain to suck the flowers
of the oxlip (Primula elatior), and that it does not seek the
short cut until it has convinced itself by experience that
the other method will not work.
In many cases, however, bees which could suck the flower
in the ordinary way, may also bite a hole through. Hermann
252 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Miiller found that this practice was especially common
when flowers grow in masses and are very much visited.
Gnawing the hole means losing time in the first instance,
but it saves much time afterwards. The bees are able to
discover more rapidly what blossoms are worth anything.
The more minutely such facts are inquired into the more
significant they become. Thus Professor Francis Darwin
noted in regard to the wood- vetch (Lathyms sylvestris)
that the bee bites the hole just at the best place. The
honey is secreted within a nectary enclosed by the united
filaments of nine stamens ; there are two ' nectar-holes ' at
the base ; and the bees gnaw a hole exactly over the left
nectar-hole, which is larger than the right.
' It is difficult to say how the bees have acquired this
habit. Whether they have discovered the inequality in
the size of the nectar-holes in sucking the flowers in the
proper way, and have then utilized this knowledge in deter-
mining where to gnaw the hole ; or whether they have
found out the best situation by biting through the vexillum
at various points, and have afterwards remembered its
situation in visiting other flowers. But in either case
they show a remarkable power of making use of what they
have learned by experience '.
In other words, there is distinct intrusion of intelligence
into the domain of instinct.
In further illustration of the subtle admixture of intelli-
gence with instinct, one of Fritz Miiller's observations
may be cited. In a hive of Brazilian stingless bees (Trigona
mirim), the workers had completed and filled forty-seven
cells, eight on a nearly finished comb, thirty-seven on the
following, and four around the first cell of a new comb.
THE WAYS OF LIFE 253
' When the queen had laid eggs in all the cells of the
two older combs, she went several times round their circum-
ference (as she always does, in order to ascertain whether
she has not forgotten any cell), and then prepared to
retreat into the lower part of the breeding room. But
as she had overlooked the four cells of the new comb, the
workers ran impatiently from this part to the queen, pushing
her, in an odd manner, with their heads, as they did also
other workers they met with. In consequence, the queen
began again to go around on the two older combs, but
as she did not find any cell wanting an egg, she tried to
descend ; but everywhere she was pushed back by the
workers. This contest lasted for a rather long while,
till at last the queen escaped without having completed
her work. Thus, the workers knew how to advise the
queen that something was as yet to be done, but they
knew not how to show her where it had to be done '.
What is called ' the plasticity of instinct ' illustrates the
modifying influence of intelligence. One of Romanes's
examples may be cited. He took three orphaned ferrets
and gave them to a young Brahma hen which was sitting
on dummy eggs. She had never reared a brood of chickens,
so she was quite unprejudiced. On the other hand, it is
interesting to note that she had been nearly killed by an old
ferret a few months before, so she should not have shown
any partiality for that tribe. As a matter of fact, she took
to them immediately, and she sat on them for rather more
than a fortnight, nearly up to the time when their eyes
were open. The ferrets were at first taken from the nest
to be fed with milk, but as this procedure caused the foster-
mother much uneasiness, they were afterwards fed in the
nest an arrangement with which the hen was perfectly
satisfied. She seemed to be puzzled at the lethargy of her
254 THE WONDER OF LIFE
' offspring ', who could not, of course, follow her when she
occasionally flew off the nest and summoned them. After
one day she was quite aware of the meaning of the ferrets'
hoarse cries, so different from a chick's piping note, and
she would run in an agitated manner to any near place
where Mr. Romanes hid them. There was no evidence,
however, of a reciprocal understanding, for the ferrets
showed no responsiveness to the hen's clucking.
During the whole fortnight the hen sat almost con-
tinuously.
' She used to comb out their hair with her bill, in the
same way as hens in general comb out the feathers of their
chickens. While engaged in this process, however, she
used frequently to stop and look with one eye at the
wriggling nest-full with an inquiring gaze expressive of
astonishment. At other times, also, her family gave her
good reason to be surprised ; for she used often to fly off
the nest suddenly with a loud scream an action which
was doubtless due to the unaccustomed sensation of being
nipped by the young ferrets in their search for the teats '
This interesting case has many parallels, and the series
of them afford astonishing illustrations of the plasticity
of instinct.
EDUCATED ANIMALS
When we study horses, elephants, dogs, cats, monkeys,
and other ' clever ' Mammals, it seems necessary to admit
that they have good memories, that they have a power of
rapidly forming associations, that they profit by experience,
that they can adapt old means to new ends, that they can
' put two and two together '. They must be granted the
power of perceptual inference, and there are some facts con-
THE WAYS OF LIFE 255
nected with the education of higher animals which suggest
that we have swung to the extreme of crediting animals
with too little mental capacity.
Every one knows that much can be achieved by the
patient training and persuasion of big-brained higher
animals, such as those which we have named, but no
one yet knows how much. Elephants make very clever
workers and the educability of army horses or of shepherds'
dogs is astonishing. When the late Lord Avebury asked
his dog Van if it wanted to go for a walk, it used to run to
its box of printed cards and fetch the one with OUT on
it. It would bring other cards, such as BONE or TEA, when
it was invited to enjoy these luxuries. The same sort of
associative power was even more developed in Dr. Romanes's
chimpanzee, ' Sally ', who would hand you three straws,
or four straws, and so on, as you asked her. To save time,
she used sometimes to double one of the straws and present
the two ends between her fingers and thumb, making
three straws do duty for four. And it was an interesting
fact that when she was refused a reward in such cases,
she used to straighten out the bent straw and make the
number right by picking up another. This appreciation of
numbers is very interesting, but it is mere child's play
compared with the arithmetical powers that many hard-
headed naturalists have recently felt compelled to recognize
in the ' thinking horses ' of Elberfeld.
The story of the so-called ' thinking horses ' begins
with ' Clever Hans ', who was taught by Herr Von Osten
to give, by stamping, the answers to a long and varied list
of arithmetical questions. The case was carefully investi-
gated in the Psychological Laboratory of the University of
Berlin, and the general verdict was that the horse observed
256 THE WONDER OF LIFE
its questioner very attentively and took note of ordinarily
imperceptible and unconscious movements of the head and
body which indicated when he should stop stamping. It
was very clever of the horse to utilize the unconscious signals,
but it was not arithmetic. Pfungst declared that ' Clever
Hans ' could not read figures or words, as was alleged, that
he could not spell, or count, or perform arithmetical
operations, and that even his memory was poor. It only
remained to say that he was a very well-meaning and an
uncommonly attentive horse. ' Clever Hans ', rather shorn
of his glory, passed into the hands of Herr Krall, a well-to-do
merchant in Elberfeld, who took precautions (e.g. by
using blinders) to keep him from receiving any visual
signals during the experiments, and was still able to get
correct answers. With increasing age, however, ' Hans '
became tired of ' arithmetic ', and would obstinately
refuse to do any more of whatever it was that he had
done. Convinced that the critics were missing part
of the truth, Krall started afresh with two young Arab
horses Muhamed and Zarif of two and two and a half
years respectively, which previous experience with ' Hans '
enabled him to train in a more effective way.
Krall accustomed his horses to the appearance of letters,
figures, words, and the like, which were hung up in their
* schoolroom ' ; he taught them for one to two hours a
day ; he carefully avoided routine ; he used ' blinders ' to
eliminate unconscious visual hints, and made an improved
sounding-board for stamping the answers on. He taught his
pupils to indicate units with the right foot, tens with the
left, hundreds with the right, so that 126, which meant 126
stamps for Hans, involved only 9 for Muhamed and Zarif.
' Nothing ', ' no ', ' not ' and ' none ' were indicated by
THE WAYS OF LIFE 257
one movement of the head from left to right. Gently and
good-humouredly he taught them to associate a certain
sound or sight with a certain number, a certain sound or
sight with a certain object, or even operation. His educa-
tion was run on association lines. Very gradually he got
them, he thinks, to ' understand ' addition, subtraction,
multiplication and division. In the course of time they
were able to deal with fractions and to extract square
roots and cube roots. Dr. Hartmann, of Koln, got a friend
to extract three cube roots and put the questions and
answers in separate envelopes. In the stable he opened
the first envelope and dictated, ' Cube root of 13,824 '.
In a few seconds came the answer, 24, which Hartmann
confirmed by opening the relevant envelope. The cube
root of 29,791 was stated to be 31. The cube root of
103,823 was given first as 57 and then, rightly, as 47.
Professor Buttell-Reepen got a friend to put a number
of arithmetical questions in separate envelopes and the
answers in others. Neither he nor Krall knew what they
were. One was the square root of 3,364, and \/ 3,364 was
written on the board. Muhamed stamped 32 (wrong),
44 (wrong), then twice wrong, and then 58, which is right.
Professor H. von. Buttel-Reepen relates a very interesting
experience. In September of last year he went one day,
with Professor Ziegler, to KralPs stables half an hour earlier
than had been arranged. In the yard they fell in with the
Shetland Pony ' Hanschen ', and resolved to make some
experiments in the owner's absence. They got out the
blackboard and the stamping-board, and without a word
33
Professor Ziegler wrote down the sum n. Hanschen
stood waiting before the stamping-board and at once
s
258
THE WONDER OF LIFE
rapped out the correct answer. This is a very instructive
instance. The pony had been taught at intervals for
about six months ; it had never been previously questioned
in the yard, nor by strangers. A short distance off there
was a groom brushing the yard, and another, Albert, was
brushing Zarif, but they took no part in the proceedings ;
and before a second trial, Albert went into the stable.
Another sum was written on the board, JJ, and the words
were said, ' Now, Hanschen, add the two figures and you
will get some carrots '. The right answer, which chanced
to be the same as before, was at once rapped out. At
this stage the owner and teacher appeared on the scene,
but remained at a distance of five or six yards. The pony
did two more sums, both wrong at the first trial, and then
right. When the answer is wrong, and no reward or
recognition is given, the pony begins to paw again, some-
times giving the right answer, sometimes persisting in
the wrong one.
Just a little need be said about the spelling and reading
lessons, which were not nearly so striking. A board was
hung up, arranged on the plan indicated below :
1
2
3
4 etc.
3
~
.0
e
n
1
20
a
h
1
30
i
d
g
w etc.
40
etc.
THE WAYS OF LIFE 259
Each letter is denoted by two figures, units in the upper
horizontal row and tens in the left vertical row. Thus
e is represented by 11, which involved two stamps one
stamp with the right foot and one with the left ; and n by
12, which involved two stamps with the right foot and
one with the left. The horses insisted on spelling phonet-
ically and in omitting the vowels ; thus ' Pferd ' was
' Ferd ' and ' Essen ' was ' S N ' to them. It may be noted
that Krall taught the alphabet and spelling on the old-
fashioned lines. Pointing to ' k ', he told the horses,
' this is ka ' ; pointing to ' p ', ' this is pe '. It is hardly
surprising that, even after six months' learning, the horses
were very shaky about the spelling of a word like brod
(bread), though they had strong practical reasons for
making sure of a word with such pleasant associations.
Let us note, however, one of the spelling tests. Krall
asked Muhamed if he wished a carrot, and got the usual
emphatically affirmative nod. ' Well ', said Krall, ' pay
close attention ; this gentleman's name is B-u-t-t-e-l
(spelling it), spell that '. Muhamed began with an ' h ',
presumably for Herr, being a well-bred horse, and then
wandered. Krall repeated with slow emphasis, Buttel,
and the horse answered, ' bdul '. To the question, Where
does the ' u ' come in ? Muhamed answered by stamping
twice. ' Good ', said Krall, ' then in the second place ', and
the horse answered, ' budl '.
The verdict of several competent observers, such as
Professors H. Kraemer, P. Sarasin, H. E. Ziegler, Claparede,
Buttel-Reepen, is to the effect that the horses do in some
measure understand what they are being trained to
do, that they do in some mysterious way calculate.
Several general arguments may be used in support of
260 THE WONDER OF LIFE
this view. (1) The horse is a very intelligent creature ; it
has a remarkably fine brain. Perhaps KralFs pupils are
being led by him to cultivate fallow areas in their
unusually rich cerebral estate. (2) The analogy of calcu-
lating boys is suggestive, for some of these have been very
backward in other respects, unable to read or write,
unaware of conventional methods of arithmetic, and so on.
Professor von Buttel-Reepen cites the case of the Italian
peasant-boy who extracted the cube-root of 3,796,416
in 30 seconds, and many instances are well known. (3)
There may be some useful hint in the observation which
several visitors have made, that the answers which are
stamped out quickly and energetically are usually right.
(4) Numerous mistakes are made, especially when the
pupil is cross or distracted. It is of interest to notice,
what Professor Plate and others have pointed out, that
the number of mistakes increases with the difficulty of the
sums. There was often a curious intelligibility in the
mistakes, though an expert arithmetician has pointed
out that the nature of the mistakes tells against the theory
that real calculation is going on. That the horses are able
to correct their mistakes is also of interest. Similarly,
it is interesting that different experts who visited the
horses got very unequal exhibitions of skill, or whatever
it may be, and that the horses have refractory periods
when they won't learn or won't show off. The fact that
' Clever Hans ' has lost all interest in figures, finds its
analogy in the case of Richard Whately, whose gifts as a
calculating boy were quite replaced by others by the time
he became Archbishop of Dublin.
What is to be said on the other side ? Many have pro-
claimed their opinion that there must be some trickery some-
THE WAYS OF LIFE 261
where, but this remains, on the whole, a vague innuendo.
There is no evidence whatever that Herr Krall is other
than a perfectly honourable and absolutely disinterested
inquirer, anxious to get at the facts. Turning to concrete
objections, we find that unbelieving critics have referred
to the darkness of the stable ; to the mesmeric influence
of Krall; to the fact that the horses concentrate their
attention on their master, the groom, and their carrots,
and pay little heed to the problem on the board ; to the
continuous flow of remarks addressed to the horses by Krall
in varied tones, from pianissimo to fortissimo ; to the all
too constant presence of the groom, Albert, who sometimes
(according to Wigge) touches the horses suggestively !
Each and all of these objections must be fully met by
further investigation, but it is interesting to note that
many of them have been already met by particular
experiments, to some of which we have referred.
We have stated the two interpretations each beset
with difficulties. On the extreme sceptical view, the horses
stamp out an answer which is somehow communicated
to them by some practical joker who can compute rapidly,
and who must be having the time of his life reading the
literature on the subject. On this view, which is beset
with great difficulties, the horses are showing remarkable
sensitiveness to minute signals and extraordinary docility
in their innocent complicity. It is plainly the task of
further investigation to answer, one after another, all the
objections which unfriendly critics have urged.
On the other view, which finds no evidence of trickery,
the results seem indeed like the beginning of a new chapter
in Animal Psychology. The horses have shown not only
extraordinary powers of precise attention, concentration,
262 THE WONDER OF LIFE
association, memory, but an unsuspected genius for dealing
with numbers. Those who take this view need not, of
course, accept KralPs generous conclusion that his horses
think as men do, but they must give him credit as an
educator who has been rewarded by the discovery of
remarkable mental powers which at present elude analysis.
In any case, it is for Comparative Psychology to continue
the investigation on the strictest scientific lines and with-
out prejudice.
A lady in Mannheim taught her Airedale terrier on KralPs
methods. The dog learned to count and spell like Krall's
horses. Professor H. E. Ziegler reports that he visited
the dog, and drew on a piece of paper a mouse (Maus), a
flower (Blume), and an elephant (Elefant). The dog
spelled out ' Maus ' ; then Bliml, which is said to be the
local dialect for Blume ; and, finally, Kma Krai Brdo.
The last was very puzzling, but it seems that the dog had
seen several days before a postcard of Krall's young
elephant, which is called Kama. Therefore, when shown
Professor Ziegler's drawing, it spelled out Kma Krai. It
may be that Brdo referred by some association of ideas
to Krall's blind horse, Berto. As no one knew beforehand
what was to be drawn, it is difficult to suggest that the
dog was coached up, and we have Professor Ziegler's word
for it that unconscious hints and trickery cannot be thought
of for a moment.
CHAPTER V
THE WEB OF LIFE
(INTRICACY OF INTER-KELATIONS)
'Sbe 10 all tbings. Sbe rewards berself anD punisbes
berself; fs ber own jog anD ber own misery. . . .'
4 1bcr cbiiDren are numberless. Co none is sbe altogether
miserly ; but sbe bas ber favourites, on wbom sbe squan&ers
mucb, anD for wbom sbe makes great sacrifices.'
Ooethe's Aphorisms, translated by Huxley.
The Balance of Nature Linkages The Living Earth Mutual
Dependence for the Continuance of Life Ants and Seeds
Mussels and Minnows Bees and Flowers Other Illustrations
Inter-Relations of a Pitcher-plant Ants and Plants
Epizoic Associations Shelter Associations Commensalism
Symbiosis Parasitism Domestic Complications The Cuc-
koo's Habit^Animal Societies The Ant Hill The Bee Hive
The Termitary Other Illustrations Domestication Guests
and Pets Slave- making Man and the Web of Life.
ONE of Darwin's master-ideas has during the last
half -century passed into general intellectual cur-
rency the idea of the web of life. Nothing is unimportant,
nothing is isolated, nature is a vast system of inter-relations
and linkages. Earthworms have made most of the fertile
soil of the Earth ; cats have to do with next year's clover-
crop ; eighty seeds may germinate from one clodlet on one
bird's foot. These are Darwinian instances and we are
263
264 THE WONDER OF LIFE
constantly discovering new ones to-day. Every move on
Nature's chessboard has consequences which may have a
very long- lasting influence on the game. We know that the
housefly puts an appreciable drag on the wheel of civiliza-
tion, that squirrels affect the harvest, that wagtails have
to do with the success of sheep-farming, and that cats may
play a not unimportant role in determining the welfare of
India.
As a corollary to Darwin's central conception came
Pasteur's the idea of the controllability of life. Silk-
worm disease and Phylloxera among the vines are not dis-
pensations of Providence to be submitted to, they are
handicaps to be got rid of. Olive pests in Italy and Vole
plagues in Thessaly do not arise without good reason,
and it is within our powers to alter these reasons. Tollitur
causa, ablatus effectus.
THE BALANCE OF NATURE
This phrase may serve to indicate the broadest kind of
inter-relation, where two sets of living creatures, having
evolved together, are dependent on one another, and on
the persistence of an approximate equilibrium between
them. It is possible to construct a closed- off aquarium
in which the plants and animals balance one another per-
fectly for a period varying with the degree of uniformity
in external conditions, and the carefulness of adjustment
between the diverse constituents of the population. The
oxygen required by the animals is produced in sunlight
by the green plants, and the carbonic acid gas produced
by the animals is utilized by the plants. The closed-off
microcosm usually comes to an end by an over-production
THE WEB OF LIFE 265
of minute plants or by the accumulation of poisonous waste-
products.
Taking a less artificial instance, we recognize the depend-
ence of vegetarian animals on the plants of the given area.
When the lemmings of a Scandinavian valley or the voles
further south multiply exceedingly in times of plenty,
they tend to check their own increase by eating up
every green thing. Then the lemmings go on the march
and the voles spread from parish to parish.
There is a necessary proportion to be sustained between
herbivorous animals and plants, between carnivorous
animals and herbivores, and one of the reasons of the
ceaseless struggle for existence is just the clashing of the
requirements of different kinds of creatures. The struggle
goes on in a more or less inconspicuous sort of way until
some environmental cause, such as peculiar weather,
brings about a marked disproportion on one side or the
other, and then there is a crisis.
Attention has often been directed to the 'beneficent
provision of Nature ' that animals which are preyed upon
are, on the whole, more prolific than those which prey upon
them. Thus, small Rodents tend to be much more prolific
than Carnivores. The primary reason for this is probably
that less individuated types tend to be more prolific. In
a relatively stupid stock the variants in the direction of
increased reproductivity will tend to survive. Great
reproductivity will become the survival-securing quality
of the feeble-minded types.
Birds keep down insects and small mammals, and they
also distribute seeds. It is plain that any sudden reduc-
tion in their numbers will bring about disharmony in the
order of Nature. Those who make such calculations
266 THE WONDER OF LIFE
tell us that in the absence of birds the earth would be
quite uninhabitable in six years. Certain it is that, as
things are at present, the vegetation of the earth depends
on birds. The grass of the meadow would soon be gone
if birds did not thin the grubs in the winter and the spring.
The trees of the woods would not long remain if the birds
did not clean off the injurious insects. The small rodents,
such as mice, popularly called vermin, are in many places
bad enough as it is, but the hawks and owls save us from
plagues. No one can deny that bullfinches destroy fruit-
buds, that wood-pigeons devour large quantities of grain,
that sparrow-hawks destroy many useful birds, that
sparrows introduced into the States have been a national
curse, and so on ; but these are quite exceptional instances.
Even if we adhere to a somewhat narrow anthropocentric
position, the balance of beneficence in favour of all but a
few birds is overwhelmingly great. And it is absurd to
suppose that Man, like a spoiled child of the Universe,
should have everything made smooth for him, and should
have no taxes to pay for his continual interference with the
established order of things.
Prof. Alfred Newton once drew a vivid picture of the
desolation likely to be wrought by man's carelessness in
disturbing the balance of Nature alike by introduction
and extermination.
' What if a future Challenger shall report of some island,
now known to possess a rich and varied animal population,
that its present fauna had disappeared, that its only mam-
mals were feral pigs, goats, rats and rabbits with an infusion
of ferrets, introduced by a zealous " acclimatizer " to check
the abundance of the rodents last named, but contenting
themselves with the colonists' chickens, that sparrows
THE WEB OF LIFE 267
and starlings, brought from Europe, were its only land-
birds, that the former had propagated to such an extent
that the cultivation of cereals had ceased to pay the
prohibition of bird-keeping boys by the local school-
master contributing to the same effect and that the
latter (the starlings), having put an end to the indigenous
insectivorous birds by consuming their food, had turned
their attention to the settlers' orchards so that a crop
of fruit was only to be looked for about once in five years
when the great periodical cyclones had reduced the
numbers of the depredators, that the goats had destroyed
one-half of the original flora, and the rabbits the rest,
that the pigs devastated the potato-gardens and yam-
grounds.'
The destruction of small bats seems to be entirely wanton
and foolish, for they help birds in thinning the hosts of
fecund insects. It has been recently stated by Dr. C. A. R.
Campbell, of San Antonio, Texas, that there is an apparent
relation between mosquitoes and bats, that the former
increase as the latter decrease. He suggests the estab-
lishment of shelters for the bats so that they may increase
and multiply.
Linkages. At every turn the naturalist finds proof that
Nature is a vast system of linkages, and that it is quite
unscientific to think of any organism as trivial or detached.
The arc of its life may not enter the human field, but it is
sure to enter many others, and one or other of its inter-
sections may at any moment acquire significance for Man.
One would not be inclined at first sight to attach much
practical importance to the sea-gooseberries or Ctenophores,
pelagic animals of the greatest delicacy and beauty. They
descend into quiet water when there is any sea on ; they
re-ascend when there has been a lasting calm. Their
268
THE WONDER OF LIFE
importance lies in the fact that they destroy large
numbers of floating fish eggs and young fry. Dr. A. G.
Mayer writes :
' Tender as they are
to the touch, passing
jelly-like between the
fingers of the hand
that attempts to seize
them, their food con-
sists largely of young
fishes, which they en-
gulf in great numbers,
seizing their prey by
means of their pecu-
liar adhesive cells.
Thus, in the cold
northern waters where
ctenophores occur in
vast swarms, they
constitute a serious
menace to the cod
fisheries by devouring
pelagic eggs and
young fish.'
In almost all cases
the ordinary stinging
cells characteristic of
jelly-fishes and other
Coelenterates are ab-
Fio. 45. Ctenophore showing (T) retractile , f__ m nf PT vnn>irrpfl
tentacles bearing adhesive cells; (M) sent from Ltenopnores,
position of the mouth ; (c) line of font their place Is taken
ciliated combs ; (AS) apical spot with , .. ,
a sensory organ. (After Mayer.) by equally Character-
THE WEB OF LIFE 269
istic adhesive cells which grapple with small animals pass-
ing by.
Another good instance of linkage, which is not obvious
at first glance, is the connexion between fishes and malaria.
But it is not a hard riddle to read. The parasite which
causes malaria is disseminated by the mosquito, and the
larval mosquitoes are devoured by many fishes. Captain
R. B. Seymour Sewell and B. L. Chaudhuri have described
eleven Indian fishes which are of proved value as mosquito
destroyers. They conclude that ' fishes may be a very
important agent in regulating and diminishing the degree
of malarial infection in any given district '. It has also
been suggested that the reason why the Barbadoes are
remarkably free from malaria, is that the mosquito larvse
are devoured in large numbers by a small fish, popularly
known as ' millions', which is very abundant in all the
streams and pools.
The practical lesson to Man is the obvious one that he
cannot be too careful lest he disturb the balance of things,
by extermination on the one hand, or by transplantation
on the other. We have elsewhere referred to important
instances, such as the introduction of rabbits into Australia
and of house-sparrows into the United States. We may
refer again to the story of the rats of Jamaica. Rats
brought by ships became a plague in Jamaica. To cope
with them the mongoose (Herpestes griseus) was imported,
and it made short work both of the Old World rats and the
Jamaican cane-rats. But when these were gone, the
appetite of the mongoose remained, and the poultry and
various ground birds began to suffer. Useful insect-eating
lizards were also eaten, and another cloud rose on the sky
there was a multiplication of injurious insects and ticks,
270 THE WONDER OF LIFE
so that plants and animals began to be afiected through
an ever-widening circle.
Mr. Thomas Barb our has followed up the chain of con-
sequences as regards reptiles :
' The introduction of the mongoose has caused the almost
complete extinction of many species which were once
abundant, and has in some ways radically changed the
facies of the fauna. In the back country, lizards are rarely
met with, and it is only in the vicinities of villages and
towns, where they are more or less protected, that one
may obtain satisfactory series of many species. The
true ground-inhabiting forms have, of course, suffered
most, so that lizards of the genera Ameiva, Mabuia and
Celestus are now scarce and difficult to obtain. Snakes
have suffered perhaps more than lizards.'
An additional linkage in the case of the sparrow intro-
duced into the United States has recently come to light,
but it requires further investigation. The swarms of
sparrows drive away other birds, but they also appear to
exert an inimical influence on poultry in the wide sense
(fowls, turkeys, ducks, geese, etc.). In the sparrow's
intestine there are parasitic Protozoa, known as Coccidia,
which occur in great abundance. The sparrow is accus-
tomed to them, but when they pass to new hosts, such as
poultry, they cause serious diseases, known as ' blackhead '
or coccidiosis. The parasites also occur in the American
' robin ' (Merula migraloria), the quail, and the Ruffed
Grouse ; and perhaps there is a risk of making the sparrow
a scapegoat.
The Living Earth. As an instance of subtle inter-
relations, we may refer to some recent investigations at the
Rothamsted laboratory. Drs. Russell and Hutchinson
THE WEB OF LIFE 271
found that when soils were heated or when they were dosed
with certain volatile antiseptics, and afterwards brought
into conditions favourable for plant growth, they showed a
great increase in fertility. Further inquiry showed that the
soil Bacteria are first reduced in numbers by the heating
or sterilizing, and that after a while they increase enor-
mously. To this increase is due a greater production of
ammonia in the soil, and to this, of course, the greater
fertility. But the puzzle is why the decrease after heating
or sterilizing should be followed by a great increase.
The suggested solution of the puzzle is very interesting,
and it is instructive even though it may require subsequent
modification. There are many Protozoa in the soil, some
of which feed on Bacteria and thus limit their increase.
The Protozoa are more sensitive than the Bacteria to the
heating or sterilizing. There is a killing off in both camps,
but the Protozoa suffer most. In the period of recovery
the surviving Bacteria multiply enormously in the relative
absence of their enemies. This solution requires verifica-
tion, and our knowledge of the soil Protozoa is still too
scanty and vague. A great reward certainly awaits the
investigator of the Protozoa of the soil. Mr. T. Goodey
has listed about thirty already, but eighteen of these are
ciliated Infusorians which exist in the soil in an encysted,
not in an active state, and cannot therefore function as
Bactericides.
MUTUAL DEPENDENCE FOB THE CONTINUANCE OF LIFE
Two organisms inhabiting the same area may become
linked together in such a way that the continuance of the
life of one of the two is dependent on the presence of the
272 THE WONDER OF LIFE
other. Thus many flowers depend for their pollination
on the visits of quite definite insects, who, in minding their
own business of collecting pollen and nectar, unconsciously
transfer the fertilizing dust from blossom to blossom. We
shall return to this particular case after we have noted a
few other illustrations.
Fruit-eating birds, such as thrushes, are responsible for
the distribution of many seeds. Many water-birds carry
minute animals from one watershed to another, and
there is indeed quite a fauna and flora of birds' feet.
Earthworms sometimes plant trees and the squirrel's
forgotten stores may serve to start a coppice. The world
is full of such linkages. We may refer to the role of
ants as a less familiar illustration.
Ants and Seeds. It has been known for a long time
that ants carry to their nests the seeds of the cow-wheat
(Melampyrum), and it has been suggested that in doing so
they labour under a ' misapprehension ', as one might say,
confusing them with pupae. There are some details which
support this view, which may have something in it.
Probably, however, the ants know better, and the
theory does them injustice. For further research has
shown that ants have a very marked predilection for
certain seeds and fruits, and carry them about for great
distances.
Experiment has shown that ants are particularly fond of
seeds which have ' food-bodies ' or ' oil-bodies ' in their
coats, such as violet, bluebell, mignonette, and fumitory.
In many cases the ants carry the seeds to the nests, but eat
only the external food-bodies, so that the thrown-out seeds
may still germinate. Moreover, in many cases the seeds
are lost by the ants on their journeyings. Prof, F, E,
THE WEB OF LIFE 273
Weiss took the seeds of the gorse, which have a bright
orange, fleshy food-body, and placed them on ant-tracks.
He found that they were rapidly picked up by the ants,
while seeds of various other plants were left alone. The
seeds of the broom, which have a food-body like that of the
gorse, were treated in the same way. It seems legitimate,
then, to conclude that ants assist in the distribution of gorse
and broom.
Mussels and Minnows. The freshwater Mussels (Unio
and Anodon) are bound up in the bundle of life with fishes,
such as minnow and stickleback. The mussel keeps its
larvae in a capacious cradle within the outer gill-plate, and
does not allow them to escape until a minnow or the like
comes into the immediate vicinity. When the crowd of
free-swimming bivalve larvae find themselves in the water
near the fish they show manifest excitement and move
towards it, snapping their valves, which bear minute attach-
ing hooks. Fine anchoring threads of a glutinous character
are also exuded, and attachment is effected to the minnow's
skin. For a considerable time the larvae remain fixed to
the fish, pass through a kind of metamorphosis, and eventu-
ally fall off into the mud perhaps far from the place where
their parents lived. There are many interesting points
here the hereditary attraction of the mussel larvae to the
fish (in the laboratory they are excited by even a piece of
fish), the special adaptations which secure attachment,
the metamorphosis, the distribution ; but what we wish to
emphasize is the broad fact that two creatures as different
as possible the mussel and the minnow have got linked
up together. The minnow is quite passive in this linkage,
but it is an extremely interesting fact that a continental
fish, the bitterling (Rhodeus amarus}, should spend part of
274 THE WONDER OF LIFE
its early life as a semi-parasite inside the gill-cavity of the
freshwater mussel.
Bees and Flowers. The inter-relations between bees
and flowers have formed the subject of many studies and of
many controversies. For the matter is not so clear and
simple as is sometimes represented. Bees visit the flowers
for the pollen and the nectar. The cane-sugar of the nectar
is transformed into glucose and is consumed as food by its
collector, or is stored in cells. The pollen serves as food
directly, or it is mixed with honey to form a nutritive
paste or jelly for the young. In hive-bees there is often a
good deal of method in the collecting ; Aristotle noted
rightly that they often keep to one kind of flower at a time.
There is often division of labour among the workers, for
some collect nectar and others collect pollen. The adapta-
tions on the bees' part are many, but the most important
are the suctorial mouth-parts and the pollen-collecting
hairs on the legs.
The egg-cell of a flowering plant hidden away within
the ovule within the ovary does not usually develop into
an embryo unless it be fertilized by a male element (nucleus)
within the pollen grain. The pollen grains are dusted on
to the stigma of the pistil in various ways usually by
insects or by the wind or by shaking and from a pollen
grain a pollen-tube grows down in search of the egg-c3ll.
It is a nucleus within the pollen-tube that effects the fertili-
zation proper and sets development agoing. Unless this
happens, the ovules or possible seeds do not become real
seeds containing embryos.
Now it is well-known that although self-fertilization
occurs (e.g. in peas), cross-fertilization is predominant.
That is to say, fertilization is usually effected by pollen
THE WEB OF LIFE 275
from another plant, and sometimes that is the only possible
mode. It was one of Darwin's great services that he showed
by experiment the advantages of cross-fertilization as
against self-fertilization where that is possible. The plants
that grow from cross-fertilized seeds are more robust, tend
to flower earlier, and have more numerous and better seeds.
In Mexico the vanilla is cross-pollinated by bees ; in other
regions the stamen is rubbed against the pistil artificially ;
there is said to be no doubt as to the superiority of the
Mexican vanilla. Darwin also pointed out the interesting
fact that if there be placed on a stigma a pollen grain from
the same flower and a pollen grain from another plant of the
same species,the pollen-tube of the latter grows more rapidly
and usually wins the race for the ovum. If the conclusion
be accepted that cross-fertilization is the advantageous
mode, then the importance of bees and other flower- visiting
insects is plain, for it is they who unconsciously effect the
pollination. On their visits to flowers various parts of their
bodies are dusted with pollen from the stamens, and when
they pass on to other flowers of the same species they
mechanically and inevitably transfer the pollen to the
stigmas.
If the bees are useful to the races of flowering plants
which they visit, as experiment proves, and if the flowers
are useful to the bees, as is evident, then we should on
general grounds expect to find a variety of adaptations
fitting the bees to make the most of the flowers and fitting
the flowers to make the most of the bees. That is what is
found, and it is very instructive to notice that there is, so
to speak, a long inclined plane of adaptiveness, some bees
being much fitter flower-visitors than others, and some
flowers making much more of the bees than do others.
276 THE WONDER OF LIFE
The climax of bee evolution is exhibited by the hive-bees
(Apis mellifica), which we mention in the plural because
there are a good many varieties which again differ in their
degrees of fitness. The especial fitness of the hive-bee is
to be found in the perfection of the arrangements for col-
lecting and carrying the pollen and for sucking the nectar.
It is interesting to find that apiarists have for years prac-
tised some measure of selection with the hive-bee, just as
the breeder with his horses and cattle, paying special
attention to such points as the length of the tongue (which
they measure with a glossometer !) the desire being to
control its length.
The controversy really begins when we inquire into the
adaptiveness of the flowers to their visitors, for there is one
school of naturalists who insist in interpreting floral char-
acters as the outcome of a selective process in which insacts
have played the leading role, while according to another the
selective role of insects is of quite subsidiary importance.
The extreme position in regard to the role of insects was
long since expressed by the late Lord Avebury, then Sir
John Lubbock.
' Not only have the form and the colours, the bright
tints, the sweet odours and the nectar been gradually
developed by force of an unconscious selection exercised
by the insects, but even the arrangement of the colours,
the shape, the size and the position of the petals, the rela-
tive position of the stamens and pistil, are all determined
by the visits of the insects, and in such a way as to assure
the great object (fertilization) that these visits are intended
to effect.'
The famous French botanist, Gaston Bonnier, has been
foremost in maintaining that the plant secretes nectar for
THE WEB OF LIFE 277
its own use, and would secrete nectar were there no bees.
The nectaries are manufactories where cane-sugar (due to
the starch made in the leaves) is worked up and stored
usually for the fruits and seeds. The drops that are sweated
out, as night falls, from the nectaries never contain more
than a small part of the sugar of the nectaries ; they cor-
respond to water-drops elsewhere, except that they are more
or less rich in sugar ; if insects do not suck them up they
are re-absorbed in due course. This appears to be a very
effective objection up to a certain point. It shows that
the primary significance of the nectaries is for the plant
itself. We wish to point out, however, a rule in scientific
method which has its application here, namely, that one
must be careful not to mix up problems of origin with
problems of subsequent evolution. Bonnier's evidence that
the primary significance of nectaries is for the plant itself,
is not inconsistent with the view that bees and other
insects may have had something to do with the evolution of
these organs, e.g. in determining their precise position.
It remains a fact that bees tap them, and it is probable
that these visits of bees have, in the course of ages, had
some selective influence on the plants.
In regard to the fragrance of flowers the case is just a
little different. It cannot be said that the fragrance as
such is of direct use to the flowers. It may be a quite
incidental property of chemical substances which are
important in the metabolism of the plant. But in the
same way it may be argued that the sweetness of nectar is
not as sweetness of direct use to the plant. The sugar need
not have been sweet, and the chemical substances referred
to need not have been aromatic. As it appears to us, clear-
ness comes when we separate the two problems of origin
278 THE WONDER OF LIFE
and of subsequent evolution. The answer to the question
of the origin of substances of sweet odour is to be found
in the physiological study of the plant. But the
subsequent success of flowering plants with particular
odours may have been due to the fact that these odours
attracted useful insect visitors and repelled intruders.
There is no doubt that bees are attracted by the fragrance
of honey and of certain flowers. Bouvier quotes the
pretty observation of Perez that bees frequenting the
willow catkins in the early Spring are always to be seen
coming from the side toward which the wind blows the
fragrance.
Thirdly, there is the question in regard to colour, which
is the most difficult of the three. For while it is certain
that bees like sweetness, and that bees like certain odours,
it does not seem so certain as was once supposed, that bees
like particular colours. There are some difficulties. Bon-
nier put a row of painted blocks red, green, white or
yellow on the turf near some hives and baited each with
honey. They were visited impartially by the bees, but
with a slight preference for green. It is said, however,
that when bees are preoccupied with flower- visiting they
do not pay much heed to other things. It must also be
remembered that the flower is to the bee a complex of
sensations appealing to sight and smell and taste ; and
that in trying to get at the truth by analysis one may land
in fallacy.
Forel put coloured artificial flowers in a basket of dahlias
and baited them with honey. The bees kept to the dahlia
till an inquisitive or blundering individual discovered the
treasure in the artificial flowers. These were then thor-
oughly explored, except the green ones. Even after the
THE WEB OF LIFE 279
honey had been removed the visits continued perhaps
because of pleasant memories.
Some interesting experiments made by J. Wery go to
show that colour and form of the flowers count for much.
He removed the corollas from a number of flowers and left
others uninjured. The position of the flowers was changed
from time to time. In the one experiment, in the month of
June, the uninjured flowers were visited by 107 insects, of
which 72 were bees ; the flowers without corollas, but still
conspicuous, were visited by 79 insects, of which 28 were
bees. He also found that artificial flowers were freely
visited and that a glass vessel with honey was left alone.
In all these experiments there is the defect that they deal
with bees who have already established associations.
Crucial experiments should be made with inexperienced
bees.
In regard to colour, our conclusion is as before. The
origin of the coloured substances is a physiological secret
of the plant, but in so far as the colour has formed an im-
portant part (how important remains to be proved) of
the complex of attractions which draw the useful insect-
visitors, in so far it will tend to persist and perhaps increase
in the course of selection. But there can be little hesita-
tion in accepting Claude Bernard's general conclusion :
' The law of the physiological finality is in each individual
being and not outside it ; the living organism is made
for itself ; it has its own intrinsic laws. It works for itself
and not for others.'
Spoiling an Adaptation. It is well known that the
common Bombus terrestris is very much given to biting a
hole through the base of the flower of the red clover, and
280 THE WONDER OF LIFE
is therefore of little or no use in pollination. The other
species of humble-bees enter by the mouth of the flowers,
and it is their visits that really count. Mr. Thomas Belt
made the interesting observation that in the beginning of
the season some individuals of Bombus terrestris visit the
flowers of the scarlet-runner in a legitimate manner, but
soon discover that there is a shorter way by biting a hole.
They burgle unopened buds in the same way, and the
hive-bee has learned to utilize the humble-bee's perfora-
tions. Large gaping flowers such as those of Foxglove
and Nasturtium are pollinated by Bombus terrestris, but
the narrower ones are cut through and despoiled without
benefit.
The Case of the Fig. Of all the mutual relationships
that are involved in pollination, those concerned with the
fig are perhaps the most remarkable. The whole story
has not yet been cleared up, and it is too complex for full
discussion here. Utilizing a luminous article by Prof. F.
Cavers, we shall simply seek to explain the intricate part
which certain minute wasps play in the fertilization. As
is well known, the flowers of the fig are formed within a
hollow, pear-shaped receptacle with a narrow mouth. Just
below the mouth are the male flowers ; the rest of the cavity
is lined by the female flowers ; all are very minute. Early
in Spring a female wasp (usually Blastophaga grossorum)
enters the cup of the early inedible inflorescences of the
wild fig before the male flowers are open, and lays her eggs
in the female flowers. These eggs hatch into wingless
males who never escape and winged females who fly away
after they have been fertilized by the males. As they creep
out they get dusted with pollen from the male flowers
which have meantime opened. They visit a later crop of
THE WEB OF LIFE 281
figs, and the female flowers, saved by long styles from
having eggs laid in them, are pollinated and produce normal
seeds. The female wasps go in and out till the swelling of
the juicy inflorescence nearly closes the opening. They
then migrate in autumn into small late inedible figs, where
they lay eggs. These eggs hatch into wingless males and
winged females, which remain inside the small figs through
the winter. The females escape in Spring before the dry
figs fall off, and then the story begins again. We must not
pursue the matter further : it is complicated by the exist-
ence of two cultivated varieties of the wild fig the inedible
caprificus with male flowers only, and the ordinary edible
domestica with female flowers only. Both are visited by
the Blastophaga wasp.
OTHER RELATIONS BETWEEN PLANTS AND ANIMALS
Many animals feed on plants ; many animals have their
home on or in plants (see Parasitism) ; many animals secure
the pollination of flowers and the distribution of seeds ;
a few animals hide themselves with a disguise of plants (see
Masking) ; a few animals have entered into an internal
partnership with plants ; but this list does not by any
means suffice to cover the extraordinary diversity of inter-
relations. Let us refer to a few of the many other kinds
of linkage.
Alga on Sloth's Hair. A quaint association seems to
have become established between a unicellular Alga, like
the Pkurococcus which makes tree-stems green in wet
weather, and the shaggy hairs of the South American sloth
(Bradypus), which lives an altogether arboreal life. The
sloth has almost exactly the same greyish-green colour as
282 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Tillandsia usneoides, the so-called ' vegetable horse-hair ',
which is common on trees, and it is almost certain that this
colour-resemblance has protective value.
Ambrosia. In the tunnels made by various beetles
(e.g. species of Xyloterus and the like) in the bark and
wood of trees there is a lining of Fungus, which produces
special spherical ' ambrosia ' cells, serving as food for the
insects. This association appears to be useful to both
organisms : the insects are fond of the ' ambrosia ' , and
its growth makes up for the frequently poor nutritive
quality of the wood ; the fungi profit because the larvae
carry them in their borings into the sapwood, where they
get the best food and have at the same time a good supply
of air. The association has been carefully studied by Prof.
Neger, who regards it as a genuine symbiosis. It is much
commoner in warm and tropical zones, where the boring
insects often do much harm both by their own operations
and by introducing the fungi, most of which seem to be
related to the Ascomycete genus Endomyces. The matter
may become more complicated wheels within wheels
again when weeds begin to grow in the fungus garden
in the form of yeasts and Bacteria and the like which further
infect the wood, but are not of any use to the beetles.
Neger found the same ' ambrosia- cells ' inside the galls
made by certain mites (Asphondylia). The cavity of the
gall is lined by a layer of fungus threads, among which are
the special ' ambrosia cells ' which the developing mites
eat. After the mites have departed, the spores of the
fungus are produced on the outer surface of the gall.
Here, then, there is a triple combination of flowering-plant,
mite, and fungus.
Plants Turning the Tables. Even the worm will
THE WEB OF LIFE 283
turn and even the plant may retaliate. Many plants are
full of deadly poison ; many are densely infiltrated with
crystals from which even snails turn aside ; many have
thorns and spines which though primarily expressions of
peculiarities of constitution are often secondarily protec-
tive ; many have moats and railings which entrap or ward
off unwelcome insect visitors ; and so on through a long
list.
More actively retaliatory are the carnivorous plants, like
the butterwort (Pinguicula), which attracts insects to its
glistening glandular leaf and there digests them, like the
bladderworts (Utricularia) with their neat traps for water-
fleas, like the sundews (Drosera) with their finger-like
tentacles, like the pitcher-plants (Nepenthes and Sarracenia),
catching very passively, and Venus' s Fly-Trap (Dionced),
capturing very actively, and so forth. Here there is a
definite turning of the tables.
A hint of the retaliatory power of the plant is familiar
in the stinging nettle (Urtica dioica), with its hairs contain-
ing formic acid, but the capacity reaches its climax in a
large member of the order Urticaceae, the ' stinging-tree '
(Laportea), species of which occur in Japan, Eastern India
and Queensland. A light touch of a leaf produces a viru-
lent effect lasting for days or even months. The pain is
described by men who have been stung as maddening and
agonizing, and the effect on horses and dogs is also very
severe. The Australian species may attain a height of
10-15 feet and is said to emit a disagreeable odour.
Inter -Relations of a Pitcher Plant. Let us take one
case in more detail. In studying one of the insectivorous
plants, the Spotted Trumpet-Leaf, Sarracenia variolaris,
whose long tube forms a very effective trap, Prof. C. V.
284 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Riley discovered that there were two common insect
visitors, that came and went and were not destroyed. One
of these is a flesh-fly (Sarcophaga sarracenice), which is
attracted by the odour of putrescence and deposits its
maggots (it is viviparous) in the rotting material, with
remains of ants, flies, moths, beetles, katydids, crickets,
and the like, at the bottom of the pitcher.
The whitish maggots riot in the putrid insect remains,
but, of the dozen or so that there are to start with, ' usually
but one matures, even when there appears macerated food
enough for several '. A fratricidal warfare is waged which
reduces the numbers in this remarkable way. When the
survivor has attained its full larval size it bores through the
leaf and burrows in the ground. After a few days' pupation
it issues as a large two-winged fly. Two questions natur-
ally present themselves, Why the adult escapes the fate of
all but one of the other insects that enter or tumble into
the tube ? and Why the maggot is not killed in the noxious
fluid in which it revels ?
The fly is probably safe because it has strong, spreading
legs with large adhesive surfaces and strong claws, which
enable it to get a grip of the cellular tissue of the pitcher
surface in spite of the slippery downward-projecting hairs.
When it is disturbed within the pitcher it buzzes about
violently and emerges in most cases successfully. It is
more difficult to explain the survival of the maggots, ex-
cept by simply pointing to other cases where dipterous
larvae live in what seem to be hazardous situations, e.g.
inside the food-canal of a higher animal or inside decaying
matter.
The other intruder, who successfully braves the dangers
of the trap, is a little glossy moth, marked with grey-black
THE WEB OF LIFE 285
and straw-yellow. This Sarracenia moth (Xantkoptera
semicrocea) walks with impunity on the treacherous inner
surface of the pitcher and the female lays her eggs singly
near the mouth. The young larva spins for itself a carpet
of silk and draws the rim of the pitcher together with
a web which shuts out all other insects. It works its way
down the wall of the pitcher, devouring the cellular tissue,
and dropping large quantities of undigested food into the
cavity. It is a half-looper caterpillar, with beautiful cross
bands of white and purple or lake red, and prominent rows
of tubercles. ' It keeps up, in travelling, a constant, rest-
less, waving motion of the head and thoracic joints, recall-
ing paralysis agitans. The chrysalis is formed in a slight
cocoon, usually just above or within the packed ex-
crementitious material. There are two broods in the
year '.
Here we have two good examples of strange habitat
and strange mode of life. The flesh-fly is ' a mere intruder,
the larva sponging on and sharing the food obtained by the
plant '. The moth is an active enemy spoiling the Sarra-
cenia trap.
Ants and Plants. The associations between ants and
plants show various degrees of intimacy. Ridley distin-
guishes three groups : (1) The ants may be sheltered within
the leaves or flowers, within hollow stems or thorns, and so
on, without deriving any food from the plant or conferring
any benefit on it. (2) In the case of some epiphytic ferns
and orchids, the ants that shelter about the base of the
plant bring up considerable quantities of soil. (3) Much
more intimate, however, are those cases where the ants live
in hollow stems, branches, or spines, and while feeding on
secretions exuded by glands of the plant, give this benefit in
THE WONDER OF LIFE
FIG. 46. Acacia Twig (Acacia sphaerocephala),
about two-thirds natural size. (After Schimper.)
1. The large hollow thorns which are tenanted
by ants. 2. An entrance bored through a
thorn. 3. Small inflorescence. 4. A compound
leaf in resting position. The bodyguard of
ants which live in the shelter of the acacia do it
no harm. On the contrary they ward off the
attacks of the formidable leaf-cutter ants.
return that
they form
a body-
guard,
warding off
the attacks
of other
insects.
An as-
soci a t i o n
that still
requires a
good deal
of clearing
up is that
between
ants and
the laby-
rinthine
stem-
tubers of
My r me-
codia tuber-
o s a , a
famous
Java^n e s e
epiphyte.
The tuber
has many
passages
and cav-
erns, which
THE WEB OF LIFE 287
are tenanted by ants (Iridomyrmex myrmecodius}. Beccari
thought that the ants were responsible for making the laby-
rinth, but Forbes and Treub proved that there could be
typical labyrinths in the entire absence of ants. It seems
certain, indeed, that the tuber is a water-absorbing and
water-storing organ, very useful to a plant which lives quite
off the ground. At the same time the association with ants
is very general. Miehe points out that some of the walls of
the maze are smooth and light brown, while others are
warty and dark brown. A dark fungus grows on the rough
surfaces, not on the smooth. The ants deposit their
excrement on the rough surfaces ; they use the smooth-
walled chambers as nurseries. It is probable, Miehe thinks,
that the excrement of the ants is utilized by the plants ;
and this, if the case, may be a very useful arrangement for
an epiphyte living off the ground. The ants get a conveni-
ent shelter. They do not seem to eat anything that be-
longs to the plant, though what they eat is unknown.
Nor do we know whether they can get along without their
maze.
Epizoic Associations. Many plants, such as Lichens
and Orchids, grow upon other plants, and are known as
epiphytic, and the term may be also applied to animals
which are practically confined to certain plants, e.g. various
Hydrozoa and Polyzoa on seaweeds, not in any real para-
sitism, but because the situation suits them well. Similarly,
we have epizoic plants and animals. The green Alga on
the Sloth's hair is epizoic. The seaweed on the limpet's
back is epizoic. We do not know that there is any value
in the last association, though with some slight change of
conditions it might readily become invested with such
value. In the same way there are many examples of
288 THE WONDER OF LIFE
FIG. 47. Epizoic growth of hydroid polyps Hydractinia (A), on shell of
whelk Buccinum (B), which is tenanted by a hermit-crab. For-
ceps of hermit-crab (c). The hydroid colony shows division of
labour; it includes nutritive, reproductive, and other types of
individual.
epizoic animals : acorn-shells on bivalves and crabs,
Serpulid worms on shells, Hydrozoa and Polyzoa on many
kinds of marine animals, one sponge on another and so on.
Weber refers to the fact that the muddy floor of the Banda
Sea is covered for miles with a dense network of a large
Foraminifer, Rhizammina algceformis, and that this serves
as a suitable substratum for a large number of sedentary
animals, which could not otherwise find a foothold in the
soft mud.
Of many of these epizoic marine animals it must simply
be said that they grow upon other marine animals just as
they might grow on any other object. The young stages
happened to land there and found the substratum suitable.
This must be true of the acorn-shells (Balanns), false-oysters
(Anomia), serpulid worms, Polyzoa, zoophytes, and the
like often found on crabs, which do not seem to illus-
trate more than fortuitous epizoic association. But some
THE WEB OF LIFE 289
of the cases are difficult. Thus Dr. W. T. Caiman describes
a crab from Christmas Island which had a hydroid polyp,
allied to Stylactis, attached like a tassel at the ' knee '
of each of its legs. All but two of the polyps were symme-
trically disposed and the rootwork (or hydrorhiza) followed
the grooves on the carapace. Moreover, the type speci-
mens of the species of crab (Medceus haswelli), although
coming from another and distant locality, were found to
bear similar or identical hydroids.
Prof. Alcock has described the curious association
between a Hydroid (Stylactis minoi) and a small rock perch
(Minous inermis) ; but even more remarkable is Prof.
Willey's case of barnacles growing on a sea-snake. His
figure, almost mediaeval at first glance, shows a bunch of two
kinds of barnacles (Lepas anserifera and Conchoderma
hunteri) attached to the end of an Indian Ocean sea-snake
(Hydrus platurus). The barnacles are not in any way para-
sitic, they are simply epizoic ; the free-swimming young
forms happened to fix themselves to the snake instead of
to a drifting spar. But it is interesting to notice that their
occurrence on snakes has been repeatedly recorded. To
the snake, one would think, they must prove themselves
a troublesome incubus, seriously impeding its movements.
Some of the epizoic associations certainly become dan-
gerous to the bearer. Prof. Charles Chilton describes such
a case in the crab Paramithrax longipes, which seems to be
almost invariably accompanied by specimens of the acorn-
shell Balanus decorus, growing on its carapace and some-
times becoming so large and numerous that they exceed in
size the body of the crab itself. The association was prob-
ably quite unimportant in its initial stages, but gradually,
as the cirripedes grew, they must have become inimical
y
2 go THE WONDER OF LIFE
to the crab's welfare. It is understood, of course, that as
long as the crab is growing, it moults periodically and gets
rid of its associates in casting its shell. It is after growth
has stopped that the burden tends to become too heavy to
be borne.
The sucking fish Echeneis illustrates the difficulty of
classification. It fastens itself temporarily to other fishes,
to turtles, and even Cetaceans, but uses them simply as a
means of transport. It is no more a parasite than a man
on horseback.
Shelter Associations. No hard and fast lines can be
drawn, but it seems useful to group together as ' shelter
associations ' a number of interesting cases in which one
animal finds shelter in or about another, without itself
conferring any benefit in return.
Fierasfer is one of the best examples of shelter-associa-
tion. It goes in and out of sea-cucumbers, starfishes,
and big bivalves, but it feeds independently like any other
fish. The fact is that it belongs to a family (Ophidiidae)
of light-avoiding fishes, such as the sand-eel Ammodytes,
and yet is very dependent on the freshness of the water.
Thus it occurs in the shelter of animals in which there are
active currents of water.
The entrance of Fierasfer into its sea-cucumber host
has been described by Linton. Apparently by accident
the fish touches the body of the sea-cucumber (in this case
Stichopus moebii), with its snout ; it at once feels its way
backward to the posterior end without any pause, as if it
was following a scent ; vision does not seem to count for
much. When it touches the cloacal opening it brings its
slender tail sharply round with a rapid whip-like movement
and thrusts the tip in. Up to this point the fish is excited ;
FIG. 48 Fierasfer acus, entering and leaving Holothurians. (/l//er Emery.)
THE WEB OF LIFE 291
it now insinuates its body into its host in a quiet leisurely
way. When the Holothurian is placed in water with
insufficient aeration, the fish comes out, and rises to the
surface, taking in gulps of air.
Numerous small horse-mackerels (Carangldse) swim
about under the shelter of the umbrella of large jelly-
fishes, and other small fishes find safety among the very long
and hair-like spines of the dark-coloured rock-urchin
(Diadema saxatile). Prof. Weber notes that as many as
ten specimens of a pelagic fish (Nomeus gronovii) may be
found in the shelter of the tentacles of the Portuguese
Man-of-War (Physalia). There is a fish called Amphiprion
bicinctus, which lives inside a large sea-anemone (Crambactis
arabica), and Prof. Plate has described Apogonichthys
strombi, from the Bahamas, which spends at least part
of its time in the mantle cavity of large specimens of
Strombus gigas.
It must be confessed that the hermit-crab does not seem
to be always happy in its choice of a shelter. Prof. Chilton
tells how Eupagurus stewarti, which has a straight abdo-
men, inhabits tubular cavities within a Millepore or a
calcareous Polyzoon. The cavities may be due, as Prof.
Benham suggests, to the decay of a branch of seaweed
around which the Millepore or the Polyzoon grew. But
the point is that the calcareous shelter may be much larger
than the hermit-crab, and must be very heavy, if not too
heavy, to carry about.
An intermediate state of affairs is illustrated when two
animals share the same dwelling without sharing food.
Thus the prairie-owl lives with the ' prairie-dog ' in North
America, and another species of owl with the Viscachas
in South America. Perhaps in the same category may be
292 THE WONDER OF LIFE
ranked the ' Inquiline ' gall-insects, which are not them-
selves gall-producers, but utilize what others make.
Another half -and-bet ween case is that of a moth, Galleria
melonella, whose caterpillars feed entirely on beeswax.
The female lays her eggs on pieces of wax or wood within
the hive ; the minute grub-like caterpillars emerge in
about eight days and make themselves a shelter of silk
which protects them from the stings of the bees. They
feed chiefly on old honeycomb. As they grow they en-
large their shelter into a gallery which opens on the surface
of a comb. When they reach their limit of growth they
make cocoons on the wall of the hive near the entrance,
and pass out as moths in a fortnight or so.
Commensalism. This term, which is just the same
as companionship, ' eating at the same table ', may be use-
fully restricted to external associations which are beneficial
on one side at least. When the benefit is two-sided, the
term ' mutualism ' or ' commensal mutualism ' may be used.
Many associations remind one of the beggar at the rich
man's gate a small creature living on the crumbs from
its larger host's table. But it is difficult to draw the line
between cases where the benefit is all on one side and those
where some degree of reciprocity obtains. Thus Miss
Winifred Coward has described a peculiar little hydroid,
Ptilocodium repens, which grows among the polyps of a
Pennatulid, Ptilosarcus, from the Timor Sea. The two
kinds of animals live literally ' cheek by jowl ', and as the
hydroid has numerous defensive polyps, out-numbering
the nutritive ones (which, it is interesting to notice, have
degenerate tentacles), it may be that it confers some pro-
tective advantage on the Pennatulid on whose food-supply
it levies toll.
THE WEB OF LIFE 293
A vivid description of the partnership between the giant
sea-anemone and the ' painted fish ' (Amphiprion) is
given by E. J. Banfield in his delightful book My Tropic
Isle (1910). The dainty fish, only an inch and a half long,
is ' resplendent in carmine, with a broad collar and waist-
band of silvery lavender (or rather silver shot with laven-
der) and outlined with purple '. On the least alarm the
fish ' retires within the many folds of its host, entirely
disappearing, presently to peep out again shyly at the
intruder. It is almost as elusive as a sunbeam, and most
difficult to catch, for if the anemone is disturbed it contracts
its folds and shrinks away, offering inviolable sanctuary.
If the fish be dissociated from its host, it soon dies. It
cannot live apart, though the anemone, as far as can be
judged from outward appearances, endures the separa-
tion without a pang '. What the fish does for the anemone
is uncertain perhaps it attracts small food. But other
anemones greedily seize inquisitive fishes.
Many crabs and hermit-crabs form an external partner-
ship with sea-anemones, which grow on the carapace, or
sometimes on the forceps, or, in the case of some hermit-
crabs, on the borrowed Gasteropod shell. The benefit is
clearly two-sided, and a Crustacean bereft of its partner
anemone has been known to search for it diligently. A
hermit-crab shifting from its Gasteropod shell to a larger
one has been seen trying to flit its partner as well. To
the Crustacean the benefit is that the sea-anemone can
sting, and that it also serves as a marking cloak. To the
anemone there is the advantage of transport and of crumbs
from its companion's table. Prof. Weber refers to cases
like the crabs Polydectus and Melia, where the anemone
is carried about on the forceps in a highly aggressive
294 THE WONDER OF LIFE
way the one animal literally making a tool of the
other !
One of the most extraordinary cases of commensalism
is that described by Colonel Alcock as established between
an Indian Ocean hermit-crab, Paguristes typica, and a sea-
anemone of the genus Mamillifera. The sea-anemone
settles down on the hinder part of the young hermit-crab's
tail, and the two animals grow up together in a most inti-
mate manner, the spreading anemone forming ' a blanket
which the hermit- crab can either draw completely forward
over its head or throw half-back as it pleases '.
A very well-known association is that between a hermit-
crab and a bright orange sponge, Suberites domunculd;
which spreads over the Gasteropod shell which the hermit-
crab has borrowed. The sponge is unpalatable to many
animals ; it is packed with strong needles of flint ; and
it has a pungent odour. For these reasons it must be of
advantage to its bearer, which it also very effectively
masks. It seems to dissolve away the Gasteropod shell,
but this is probably no disadvantage, since it lightens the
burden the hermit-crab has to carry. When the sponge
settles down on the shell inhabited by a hermit-crab which
has not reached its limit of growth, it will of course be
left behind when the Crustacean flits. It is quite possible
that the vacated shell with its associated sponge may be
picked up by a smaller hermit-crab in search of a new shel-
ter. The same sponge also grows on the back of Dromia
vulgaris, a common crab, and some experiments made at
the Naples Zoological Station by Signor Polimanti brought
out two very interesting facts, first, that the crab takes the
initiative in getting the sponge on to its back, planting it
there itself, and second, that the sponge really affords its
THE WEB OF LIFE
295
partner an effective protection against the appetite of
cuttlefishes. It is a fine case of diamond cut diamond,
the thrust and parry between crab and cuttle.
A number of animals which clean up others without utiliz-
ing any living material should be
ranked with the commensals, not with
the parasites. This is true of many of
the so-called fish-lice (Argulidse), which
are scavengers of the skin of carp and
other fishes, and of various insects and
mites (e.g. Trichodectes, Philopterus),
which do the same for mammals and
birds. Another example is the plover,
which Herodotus accurately described
as cleaning the mouth of the crocodile,
removing leeches and other parasites
from the huge gape.
Symbiosis. It seems to us justi-
fiable and useful to restrict this term
to the mutually beneficial internal
partnership of two organisms of differ-
ent kinds.
In most Eadiolarians pelagic Pro-
tozoa usually with siliceous skeletons
there are symbiotic Algae which
used to be known as ' yellow cells '.
They are unicellular plants embedded
in the transparent living matter of
the Radiolarians, and a very profitable
partnership has been established.
Being possessed of chlorophyll, the Algse
can utilize the carbonic acid formed
FIG. 49. A colonial
Radiolarian, Col-
lozoum inerme.
(After Brandt.)
The small spheres
are the units
composing the
colony ; each is
accompanied by
partner Algae ; all
are imbedded in
a transparent
matrix. Greatly
enlarged.
296
THE WONDER OF LIFE
by the Radiolarian, and are able to build up carbon-
compounds, such as starch. They give off oxygen,
which is of course profitable for the animal, and they
doubtless utilize nitrogenous waste products made by
the animal. If
things are not going
well, it is always
open to the Radio-
larian to digest its
partners ! The huge
numbers of Radio-
larians alike of in-
dividuals and of
specie s seem to
indicate that the
symbiosis is very
profitable.
The symbiotic
Algae are known as
Zooxanthellae, and
their occurrence has
FIG. 50. The Green Hydra, expanded and been recorded in a
contracted. The expanded form shows
the male organs or testes as swellings
near the base of the tentacles and the
ovary as a swelling near the attached
base. The transparent ectoderm is
seen as a layer surrounding the endoderm they are very abun-
which contains the green elements, " .
usually regarded as symbiotic Algse. dant and quite in-
dispensable. Prof.
Keeble has shown that the larvae do not develop unless
they are infected, and that an adult which has been
driven by straitened circumstances to absorb its partners
can be re-infected and given a new lease of life.
variety of an i ma ls.
J
In the Planarian
n ,
worm tonvoluta,
THE WEB OF LIFE 297
Besides the Zooxanthellae there are other symbiotic
forms, e.g. the green Zoochlorellse. Their occurrence is
known in Amoebae (a colony of Amoeba viridis nour-
ished for ten years without food), in the green Hydra, in
the green freshwater sponge, in some sea-anemones, and
in many Alcyonarians. They are usually referred to
the family Palmellacese, but are not certainly known to
live apart from symbiosis.
Lichens. One of the most striking instances of partner-
ship is that illustrated by lichens, which Schwendener,
Bornet and other botanists proved to be compound
plants. Each consists of the branching and interlacing
threads of a Fungus, enclosing partner Alga cells. The
Fungus fixes the plant, absorbs air, water and salts, pro-
tects the Alga from drought and injury, and forms spores
which are wafted away by wind and water, and may start
new lichens if they find their proper partners. The Alga
uses the sunlight to build up carbon compounds, and it
joins with the Fungus in forming sexual reproductive
bodies. By taking proper precautions the Alga can be
got to live in water without the Fungus, and the latter
can live on sugary media or the like without the Alga.
The life of many a lichen is rather more complicated
than we have indicated. Thus in many of those that
grow on trees the Fungoid elements absorb decaying
organic matter ; and some tropical forms are actually
parasitic, absorbing food from the living tissues of leaf
and stem. In some cases the Fungus seems to kill its
partners and absorb them. The Algae are sometimes so
much shut in from light and air that it is difficult to believe
that they can do much in the way of photo-synthesis,
and there is strong evidence that in such cases the Algae
298 THE WONDER OF LIFE
are able to feed upon oxalic acid, and perhaps other organic
acids, produced by the Fungus. But after we allow for
these and other complications, there remains no doubt
that many lichens illustrate a very effective symbiosis
or mutually beneficial partnership of a Fungus and an
Alga.
A very interesting three-fold association has been in-
vestigated by Prof. Bottomley. Nitrogen-fixing Bacteria
(Azotobacter and Pseudomonas) are found along with Blue-
Green Algae (Nostoc and Anabcena) in the thallus of the
liverwort Anthoceros and in the leaves of Azolla, the Water
Fern. The same combination of Bacteria and Algae is
found in the roots of Cycas. It may be that the Alga
supplies the necessary carbohydrate for the Bacteria,
and that the host-plant profits by the nitrogen-fixing
powers of the Bacteria.
It is usual to find numerous Bacteria living in close
association with animals in the food-canal, in the mouth,
in the lungs, in the tissues, and some experts have raised
the question whether a higher animal could live a normal
life without its internal flora. By ingenious carefulness
M. Michel Cohendy, working at the Pasteur Institute,
has been able to rear chicks to an age of forty-five days
without their showing any trace of microbes. At that
date they became too big for their antiseptic cage and had
to be let out quite healthy and vigorous. In about
twenty-four hours those that were tested had the usual
stock of microbes. As they stood the sudden infection
quite well, it is plain that the power of resistance to ordinary
microbes is inborn or constitutional, not an individual
acquisition.
Just as there are friendly Bacteria in many animals,
THE WEB OF LIFE 299
which seem to help to oil the wheels, so yeasts may also
be co-operative. An instance is given by Dr. Karel Sulc,
who found various yeasts of the Saccharomyces (ordinary
yeast) type living inside the accumulated reserve material
of Aphides, Scale-insects, Cochineal insects, and the like.
There is evidence that they are not passive inclusions, but
that they work out changes in the stores.
In the interesting caterpillar of Nonagria typhce, which
feeds inside the stem of bulrushes, the digestive area is very
restricted, and Portier could find no evidence of a ferment
able to digest cellulose. But there were present in great
abundance very minute organisms, which he calls ' pseudo-
bacteria ', probably of the nature of moulds, which work
at the vegetable tissue and break it down. They pass
through the wall of the intestine and are engulfed by the
caterpillar's amoeboid blood corpuscles. The case is a
very extraordinary one and must be re-investigated, but
it looks like a genuine partnership, as if the ' pseudo-
bacteria ' were middle-men between the animal and its
food. We are reminded of the beautiful Infusorians which
seem to be always present in the horse's intestine, helping
in the breaking down of the hay and other foodstuffs.
The microbe (Pseudomonas radicicola) of the root-nodules
of Leguminous plants occurs also in some members of
other orders. Prof. Bottomley has found it forming
nodules in the lateral roots of the bog-myrtle (Myrica
gale), and has shown that young plants, grown in sterilized
soil poor in nitrogen, do not flourish unless they have the
root-nodules, and that root-nodules are produced on unin-
fected plants after they are treated with a culture of the
microbe. Miss Spratt has also found the same form in
an alder (Alnus incana) and in two buckthorns (Elceagnus
300 THE WONDER OF LIFE
edulis and Elceagnus rhamnoides), and has proved its bene-
ficial nitrogen-fixing role. It appears that the microbes
are polymorphic, rod-like (bacillus) forms and spherical
(coccus) forms being found in the same plant.
Parasitism. When one organism lives in or on another
its host, gets its food from it, is inextricably bound up
with it or with related forms, and is not beneficial but rather
injurious in its influence, we speak of parasitism. But,
as in other cases, the facts are too subtle for absolutely
precise definition. There are beautiful Infusorians in the
stomach of the horse, which are not found anywhere else ;
they apparently help rather than hinder the process of
digestion : Are they symbions or parasites ? Many small
Crustaceans are found on the skin of fishes, where they
clean up mucus and the like ; it is hard to draw the line
between some of them and the barnacles on a whale's
skin, which are merely epizoic. Not a few of the skin
parasites, e.g. mites, are doing their best to clean their
host. Many parasites seem to do no harm to their hosts
unless these get out of condition ; this is probably the case
with many of the threadworms and tapeworms found in
the food-canal of animals. Some parasites are quite
unimportant unless they get shifted into peculiar situations,
such as the vermiform appendix in man, within which
Nematode worms often provoke inflammation, or unless
they become suddenly very numerous. It need hardly
be said that the definition of parasitism must be such as to
exclude the antenatal life of the young mammal within
its mother, for here the two creatures are of the same
flesh and blood, and though the benefit is onesided and a
drain on the mother, she is adapted to her offspring as no
host ever is to its parasite.
THE WEB OF LIFE 301
Looked at broadly, parasitism is a way out of the struggle
for existence. Just as some animals have betaken them-
selves underground or into caves or down to the great
abysses, so others have become parasitic. It implies an
abandonment of direct competition, and its occurrence at
almost every level among backboneless animals shows that
it has been frequently resorted to, and with great success,
in many cases, as regards self-preservation and increase
in numbers. It should be noted that in many parasitic
types, e.g. among Crustaceans and Insects, only the females
have adopted the habit, doubtless in relation to egg-laying
and the protection of the offspring.
A thoroughgoing parasite, such as a tapeworm, is very
effectively adapted to the conditions of its life. It is
safe from all enemies (unless perhaps the practitioner with
his vermifuge) ; it floats in a plethora of food, which it
can absorb by the whole surface of its tape-like body ; it
can live and thrive with a minimum of oxygen, and it has a
mysterious ' anti-body ' which preserves it from being
digested by its host ; it has muscular adhesive suckers
and, it may be, attaching hooks, so that it is safely fixed
to the wall of the intestine ; it lives in warmth and comfort
without any expensive sense-organs to keep, with a low type
of nervous system a life of dull sentience. It has
attained to what economists have called ' complete
material well-being '.
The other side of it is, of course, degeneration. The
tapeworm has a lowly developed nervous system, no sense-
organs, slowly contracting smooth muscles, and so on.
Only its reproductive system is highly developed, and even
there a hint of degeneracy may be found in the self-
fertilization that often occurs. For some of the tape-
302 THE WONDER OF LIFE
worms and flukes are known to fertilize their own eggs.
External parasites are naturally much less degenerate than
internal parasites ; the retrogression is proportionate to
the thoroughness of the parasitism.
It is characteristic of parasites to be prolific. Some of
the tapeworms are said to produce eight millions of eggs ;
the female Trichina gives birth viviparously to fifteen
hundred young ones ; a liver-fluke is said to produce some
fifty thousand eggs. There are two ways of looking at this
prolific productivity. On the one hand, as regards the
individual organism, it is living without much exertion,
with abundance of stimulating food at its disposal. It is
physiologically in a position to be prolific. On the other
hand, as regards the race, there can be no doubt that the
prolificness is adaptive, that is to say, those types of parasite
have survived which were constitutionally prolific. The
risks in the life of a parasite are very slight when it is en-
sconced within its host, but they are often enormous in the
juvenile stages, or when there is transference from one host
to another. The life-history of the liver-fluke and the ox-
warble, subsequently referred to, may be taken as good
instances of these risks, but they are very general.
It must not be supposed that the prolific reproduction was
evolved as a reponse to these great risks ; it is rather to be
believed that those parasites which were constitutionally
prolific have become the surviving parasites. There are
good reasons for supposing that the parasitic alternative
is always being attempted and has always been attempted,
but that many of those organisms admitted to the available
asylums have died out within them. The dog is known
to have about forty different parasites ; both man and
the pig have more. The Scoter duck (CEdemia nigra)
THE WEB OF LIFE 303
harbours sixteen different species of flukes. Omnivorous
animals in particular are peculiarly liable to become hosts
of alimentary parasites. It is well known that oaks are
used as hosts by many different kinds of gall-flies. In
Europe, Quercus pedunculata harbours no fewer than ninety-
nine different kinds of gall-flies, Q. pubescens seventy-nine,
and Q. sessiliflora ninety-six.
Grouse Disease. Writing in 1911 on Grouse Disease,
Dr. Arthur Shipley said :
' Five years ago we knew two internal parasites (endo-
parasites) and two or three parasites which live outside the
skin (ectoparasites). At the present time we know that
grouse, like other animals, have a considerable fauna living
both in and on them. They are, in fact, not only birds, but
in a small way aviating Zoological Gardens. The scientific
members of the Grouse Disease Inquiry have recorded eight
different species of insect or mite living either amongst
the feathers or on the skin of the bird or in other ways closely
associated with the grouse, and no fewer than fifteen animal
parasites living in the blood, the alimentary canal, the lungs,
or other organs. Some of these are negligible. They
either exist in too small numbers or infest but a very small
percentage of the birds ; others, however, are found in
about 95 per cent, of the cases investigated, and two
at least are associated with grave disorders which often
terminate in death '.
One of these is a Nematode worm (Trichostrongylus
pergracilis), of which there may be 10,000 in one grouse,
about equally divided between the two intestinal caeca,
and a microscopic Protozoon, Eimeria (Coccidium) avium,
which lives in countless numbers in the delicate lining
membrane of the food canal in young grouse.
3 04 THE WONDER OF LIFE
The almost transparent threadworm (Trichostrongylus
pergracilis) of the grouse spends its early life on the heather.
' The eggs give rise to larvae in about two days. The
larvae surround themselves about the eighth day with a
capsule or cyst and undergo a " rest cure." After a period
of quiescence they quickly change into second and active
larval forms, which are minute, transparent, and quite
invisible. These lead a perfectly free life, and in wet weather
gradually squirm and crawl up among the leaves and
flowers of the heather, where they remain until swallowed
by the grouse. When once inside the bird, the larvae make
their way along the alimentary track, and enter the caeca,
where they rapidly develop into adults '.
There are some parasites, such as the Liver Fluke and
Trichina, which occur in numerous hosts, but this is the
exception. The rule is that a particular parasite occurs
only in a few, usually related, forms ; and there are many
parasites which occur only in one host, or only in two
one for the young asexual stage, and the other for the adult
sexual stage. The reason for this restriction to particular
hosts is that one and the same animal is not likely to be
adapted to a variety of somewhat subtle environments.
Moreover, where there are two hosts, the adult parasite
can only occur in a host that comes into very close vital
relations with the host of the young stages of the said
parasite. Thus the bladderworm of the rabbit becomes
a tapeworm in the dog that eats the rabbit ; the bladder-
worm of pig's flesh becomes a tapeworm in man. A vivid
instance of the narrow range of adaptability in some cases
may be inferred from the fact that the larva of the liver-
fluke cannot continue its life in Britain except within the
particular species of water- snail called Lymnceus trun-<
THE WEB OF LIFE 305
catulus or minutus ; if it enters another species it is un-
successful. Yet the same larva in some other countries
is able to continue its life in other species of water- snail !
When an examination is made of the food- canal of a
bird or mammal or other Vertebrate, which has not been
previously studied, some new species of parasite is very
generally found. There is a remarkable individuality in
the parasitic infection of distinct types. This probably
illustrates the role of isolation in assisting the formation of
species. Just as there is an Orkney vole and a St. Kilda
wren, and a distinct species of snail in each valley in Hawaii,
so there are different tapeworms, flukes and threadworms
in diverse hosts. In some cases, where the species of host
are nearly related, the species of parasites seem also closely
akin, and it should be asked in such cases whether the
observed differences in the parasites are really fixed hered-
itary characters, and not individually acquired features
induced by the slight peculiarities of environment.
There are curious little Crustaceans, called Lamippids,
of the order of Copepods, which occur, for instance, in
burrows among the spicules of Alcyonarian corals. They
are very distinctive little creatures, characteristic in their
buccal armature at one end and in their caudal fork at
the other. They have been studied systematically by
A. de Zulueta, who finds that each species of Lamippe
has its particular host. Some hosts may harbour two or
three species, but no species occurs on two hosts. It would
be interesting to transfer some young Lamippids from their
proper host to another, to see whether some of the alleged
specific differences are not directly due to the immediate
environment. Some of the species may be what we venture
to call ' modification species '.
x
306 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Parasites affect their hosts in a great variety of ways.
Their injurious influence may be trivial or serious, direct
or indirect. Skin parasites which are unimportant may
prepare the way for the entrance of very injurious microbes.
Intestinal parasites may become so numerous that they
interfere with the host's nutrition ; several hundreds of
large threadworms have been taken out of a horse's stomach.
They may cause very serious perforations of the wall of
the intestine. In the well-known sturdie-worm of the
sheep, the large bladderworm is found in the brain or in
the spinal cord, and causes disastrous locomotor disorders,
and often death. On the whole, however, the relation
between parasite and host is remarkably unimportant,
partly because of the adaptability of the organism, and
partly because the very aggressive parasites have probably
eliminated themselves from time to time by killing their
hosts. Such a case as Ichneumon larvae and caterpillars,
referred to elsewhere, is only possible because the insect
larvse pass into a new phase of life after they have killed
their hosts. The disastrous effects of parasites are usually
the results of the infection of new hosts who have not become
adapted to withstand the toxic and other deleterious
influences of the intruders.
Of great interest are those cases first rightly interpreted
by Professor Giard, where the parasite destroys the repro-
ductive organs of its host, effecting ' parasitic castration '.
Thus male crabs infected with the peculiar crustacean
parasite called Sacculina have their whole constitution
profoundly altered. The reproductive organ may be
destroyed and a small ovary producing ova may take
its place ; the shape of the abdomen approximates to
that of the female ; and the protruding parasite is actually
THE WEB OF LIFE 307
guarded by its bearer as if it were a bunch of eggs. But
we cannot do more than give a glimpse of this wonder of
parasitism.
IN ILLUSTRATION
Liver -Fluke. The well-known life-history of the liver-
fluke (Distomum hepaticum) affords vivid illustration of the
vicissitudes that are so common especially, it may be
noticed, in the case of parasitic animals. The adult lies,
like a flat leaf, in the tributaries of the bile-duct of the
sheep (and some other mammals), causing the disease
known as liver-rot, which often does much damage among
sheep. Like most internal parasites, it is very prolific,
and it is peculiar inasmuch as it fertilizes its own eggs.
The developing eggs pass down the bile-duct, down the
intestine, and on to the ground. If they are deposited on
quite dry ground, they soon die ; if they come to rest on
damp soil or among wet grass, they may remain in a state
of latent life for a couple of weeks ; if they fall into a
pool of water, they continue developing. In a short time
there emerges out of the egg-envelope a microscopic, some-
what pear-shaped, ciliated larva, which swims freely in the
water. It has energy to continue swimming for about
eight hours, but has no mouth or means of feeding. In
the course of its swimming it comes into contact with
many things, such as stick and stone, water-weeds and
small animals, but it pays no heed to any until it happens
to touch the little water-snail (Lymnceus truncatulus or
minutus) into which it immediately enters, finding the
breathing aperture a convenient door. If we could
understand the memory of the living matter which enables
this tiny brainless larva to respond effectively to the touch
30 8
THE WONDER OF LIFE
of the only creature by which its development can be con-
tinued, we should have read a great part of the riddle of
life. Inside the water-snail, the larva loses its cilia and
two eye-spots which it had ; it becomes a sporocyst which
falls victim to precocious asexual reproduction and forms
redise ; the rediae, which are larvae of a second type with
a food-canal and other complications, usually give rise
FIG. 51. Three stages in the life-history of the liver-fluke (Distomum
hepaticum). I. The ciliated free-swimming larva, with cilia (c),
and eye-spots (E). II. The sporocyst stage, showing the internal
asexual production of another kind of larva the redia (R). III.
The last larval stage, the cercaria, or young fluke, showing tail (T),
cyst-making cells (cc), and the mouth (M). (After Thomas.)
to more redise ; these in their turn produce again
asexually a third type of larva, known as the cercaria,
which has a bilobed food-canal, the beginnings of suckers
and gonads, and a locomotor tail. The cercarise leave
THE WEB OF LIFE 309
the moribund snail, leave the water, wriggle up blades of
grass, and encyst themselves, losing their tails in the process.
If a sheep pass that way and eat the blade of grass on
which the cercaria is encysted, the life- history is continued,
and it cannot be continued in any other way ! From the
food-canal of the sheep the cercaria, now a young fluke,
migrates up the bile-duct to the liver, and there, in the
course of a few weeks, becomes mature. In some cases the
adult liver-flukes die in the liver after they have repro-
duced ; in other cases they migrate out of the liver, are
passed down the gut, and die on the ground. It will be
noted that in this extraordinary life-history there is point
after point at which the process may come to an end. The
eggs may light on dry ground ; they may develop in a pool
without water-snails ; they may exhaust themselves before
they come across the water- snail ; the water-snail con-
taining them may be swallowed by a water- wagtail ; the
sun may dry up the encysted cercaria ; or it may be that
no sheep comes that way to eat the infected grass. The
whole life-history is a passage over a Mirza-bridge with an
exaggerated number of possibilities of failure. Had it
not been for their prolific multiplication, the race of liver-
flukes would long since have come to an end.
Sacculina. The adult parasite which protrudes on
the under surface of the abdomen of crabs, is a somewhat
bean-shaped sac, consisting very largely of a brood-chamber
distended with eggs. The central mass includes a nerve-
ganglion, a cement gland which secretes the egg- cases,
and the hermaphrodite reproductive organs. There is no
trace of digestive or circulatory organs, but the stalk of
the parasite is continued into the crab and divides into
numerous ' roots ', by which food is absorbed and waste
3io THE WONDER OF LIFE
excreted. The animal is at the nadir of parasitic degener-
ation. But what of the life- history ? Out of the brood-
chamber there emerge Nauplius-larvse, with three pairs
of appendages, a food-canal, and a median eye. They feed
and grow and moult, and pass into a second the Cyprid
larval stage. These fix themselves, just like barnacles and
acorn-shells (see page 448), by means of their first pair of
feelers, to the back or limbs of young crabs, finding a soft
place at the base of the large bristles or setae. All but
the head region is cast off ; the structures within the head
contract ; eyes, tendons, pigment, and the remains of the
shell are all lost, and a tiny sac sinks into the interior of
the crab. Eventually it reaches the ventral surface of
the abdomen, and, as it approaches maturity, the cuticle
of the crab softens beneath it, so that the sac-like body
protrudes. It seems to live for three years, during which
the growth of the crab is arrested. The reproductive
organs of both male and female crabs are destroyed.
Ox- Warbles. What an extraordinary story is that of
the ox- warble fly (Hypoderma bovis) I The eggs are laid
on the skin and are licked off into the mouth. According
to Jost, they hatch at the foot of the gullet, and the larvaa
bore into its wall and wander about in it for months (July-
November). They go on the march through the body,
through midriff, connective-tissue, kidneys, and what not
and come to rest beside the vertebrae (December-May).
Subsequently they pass upwards by way of the connective-
tissue of the back muscle to a position just below the skin
of the back the last chief place of their assembling. They
occur here from January till July, when they emerge and
fall on to the ground. They pass into the pupa stage on
the ground and the winged fly emerges in a few weeks.
THE WEB OF LIFE 311
Some of the tales of parasites are grim, almost like
nightmare imaginings. Roubaud has told us, for instance, of
two species of fly (he called the genus Chceromyia) which live
in the burrows of the Cape Ant- Eater and the Wart-hog.
The adults live on dung and love darkness. The larvae
lie in the damp ground, able to endure prolonged fasting,
biding their time. They are attracted to the warmth of
their hosts ; they emerge from the earth and fix themselves
to the skin, piercing it and drawing blood. They can
ingest three times their weight of blood. Roubaud reared
one on himself, which reminds us that there is another
fly of somewhat similar habit, Auchmeromyia luteola,
whose larvae pierce the human skin and suck blood.
Fabre tells us of a pigmy black Chalcid fly which follows
the giant Cigale, like a Nemesis, as she lays her eggs in the
twigs. As soon as the Cigale has filled one chamber and
passed on to the next, the anonymous Chalcid deliberately
inserts her alien egg, which effectively undoes the larger
mother's labours. For out of the egg comes a grub which
devours the Cigale's eggs. ' A small, quick- hatching grub,
richly nourished on a dozen eggs, will replace the family
of the Cigale '.
How curious, too, are the facts of hyper-parasitism, where
one parasite preys on another. The gall-fly Charips
victrix seems to destroy a beneficial Braconid that preys
upon plant-lice ; another gall-fly, Coihonaspis zig-zag,
destroys Phora aeletice, which is a parasite of the injurious
cut-worm of the cotton.
A complication in regard to the theory of galls has arisen
through the growth of scepticism as to the part which the
so-called gall-making animals play. Most galls are believed
to represent the plant's reaction to the secretions of the
312 THE WONDER OF LIFE
larva which hatches from the egg deposited by the gall-
making animal, and there can be little doubt that this is
a true interpretation in many cases. But there are other
galls which arise apart from insects and mites altogether,
namely fungus-made galls, and it is a suspicious fact that
there is often a striking structural resemblance between
the animal-made gall and the plant-made gall. Therefore,
Jules Cotte and others have suggested the theory that many
so-called animal-made galls are due to moulds or bacteria
or other fungi introduced by the animal. The insect or
mite would thus be important not so much in itself, but
because it carried a vegetable infection, and, as a matter
of fact, many so-called animal galls are demonstrably
associated with fungoid growths. Besides the frequent
resemblance in structure between animal-made galls and
fungus-made galls, there are other notable facts which
Cotte utilizes in his argument. Animals far apart from
one another are sometimes able to make very similar galls ;
the same animal may produce very diverse galls ; an
animal which causes galls at one place or at one season
may be inoffensive at another ; there is sometimes a
puzzling disproportion between the dimensions of the gall
and the number of its alleged producers ; some galls con-
tinue to grow after the animal parasites have disappeared,
and others are formed before the egg of the parasites
hatches. In any case, we have another illustration of
complex interlinking of organism with organism.
Pearls and Parasites. It is well known that if a
foreign body, such as a grain of sand, gets in between the
shell of a mollusc and the underlying skin (or mantle)
which lines it and makes it, fine layers of nacre may be
deposited around the intrusion and a sort of pearl formed.
FlG. 52. A section of a reddish-brown pearl, showing the nucleus
of organic matter (periostracum), and the concentric layers of
lime in prisms, with delicate intervening layers of periostracum.
(After Rubbell.)
312
TH1 WONDER OF LIFE
larva which hfttvtw*.
making anima*
a true interpre
galls which
namely fur
there is ^"-
the anim<
Jules i - *
euabun
}o *e important not so much in itself, but
r.*& a, vegetable infection, and, as a matter
-wvcalled animal galls are demonstrably
-'i ( l gBWrtfc* Besides the frequent
jtriif . 'iij.de galls and
gniworis ,nsaq nwoid-naibbai io noilDsz A ,S ^Ol
brus ,(mi}oe,iizonsq) isUsm oinBgio }o
o ^aysf gninaviaJni alBoifsb rffiw .zmshq ni ami!
.'.{ i;;uv '.iffvivHT vi - ; an
'. w. 1 -^ g-kilK at tn>* t>iaK!* *M at one season
may bo mofioBv<. r aooUiM ; t)Mt M sometimes a
puzzliug dpn>|v,"aoi* S?fw*HB cite ctimcMions of the gall
and the number of ;u *H<*d p*dcr8 ; some galls con-
tin tie to grow *ft*r the ajtimtU parasites have disappeared,
, ,, < t before the egg of the parasites
hatches. . > another illustration of
complex } anina with organism.
Pearls and . 1 il known that if a
foreign body, such aw a grain of swmd, gets in between the
shell of a mollusc and ih ng skin (or mantle)
whicl. ' rs ^ nacro may be
deposited arouc ] . nd a sort of pearl formed.
THE WEB OF LIFE 313
But these are not ' fine pearls '. The experiment has
often been made of boring a hole through the shell and
inserting a minute fragment of mother-of-pearl between the
shell and the mantle ; this makes a centre for pearl-form-
ation, and a more valuable semi-artificial pearl results.
Gradually it began to be suspected that the really fine
clear pearls, with translucent centres, were formed around
minute intruding parasites, which the skin of the mollusc
imprisoned, somewhat in the same way as the oak imprisons
the larva of a gall- wasp within an ' oak-apple '.
In 1902 H. Lyster Jameson showed that the agent in
forming the pearls in the common Edible Mussel (Mytilus
edulis) is the larva of a parasitic Trematode, which, instead
of secreting a cyst of its own, as is usual with such larvae,
stimulates the mussel to form around it a sac of epidermal
cells. These cells possess the same physiological properties
as the outer shell- secreting epidermis, and eventually, on
the death of the Trematode larva, secrete conchiolin and
calcareous salts, which, deposited in concentric layers around
the remains of the worm, become the pearl. But the life-
history remains obscure. It is possible that the early stages
of the Mytilus parasites live in the cockle (Cardium
edule), where closely related forms certainly occur. It is
possible that the adult form of the Mytilus parasite is to be
found in the Scoter Duck, but the experiments made to
test this have not yielded any conclusive result.
It has been suggested that the fine pearls of the Ceylon
pearl-oyster are due to the larvse of a tapeworm, Tetra-
rhynchus unionifactor, but the searching work of Lyster
Jameson does not confirm this conclusion. There is no
doubt that the young stages of this tapeworm occur in
the pearl-oyster, along with pearls, but it does not follow
314 THE WONDER OF LIFE
that the larvae cause the pearls. It may be a case of two
parallel diseases, comparable to the case of a dog infected
simultaneously with tapeworms and mange. Mr. Jameson
maintains that pearls arise round nuclei of some variety
of shell- substance formed when the normal rhythm of
secretion is disturbed.
A very careful study of the formation of pearls has been
made by A. Rubbell in the case of a freshwater mussel
Margaritana margaritifera, which is common, for instance,
in some of the mountain streams of Bavaria. His obser-
vations are quite against the theory that pearls are sepulchres
of flukes or any other parasites. He finds that they arise
around minute particles of a yellowish substance, which
resembles the outermost layer of the shell (the periostracum).
The pearls are formed in closed, single-layered sacs of
epithelium, which are constricted off from the external
epithelium of the mantle, that is to say, the fold of skin
which hangs down like a flap on each side of the bivalve,
lining and making the shell. Growth takes place by the
deposition of layer after layer around the yellowish centre.
The coalescence of several pearl sacs may give rise to
curious compound pearls. What are called ' shell-pearls '
begin in the mantle and become secondarily attached to
the shell ; they are to be distinguished from shell-concre-
tions which are formed around intruded bodies, and do not
show any concentric layering. According to Rubbell, the
innermost, or mother-of-pearl layer of the shell, is divided,
at certain places at least, into an inner and an outer stratum
by a clear intermediate layer, which is also seen inside
the pearls.
It appears, then, that there are pearls and pearls.
Keeping to those which are formed in ' pearl-sacs ' of the
FlG. 53. Shell of Freshwater Mussel (Margaritana margaritifera),
showing two pearls near the margin. (After Rubbell.)
314 THE WONDER OF LIFE
that tht- larvije cause tt pearls. It may be a case of two
parallel diseases, r<->, E, F, e.g.
certain carnivorous and insectivorous birds, reptiles, and
amphibians ; some parasitic and predaceous insects.
THE WEB OF LIFE 359
That the web of inter-relations includes human interests
may be illustrated by reference to the role of birds in
preserving the balance of Nature. All other life depends on
plant life ; but the great check on plant life is that of
insect life overwhelming in numbers, overmastering in
devices, and appalling in voracity ; and the great check
on insect life is bird life and, luckily for us, this again is
abundant, alert, and well appetized. It is very interesting
that the two great classes of successful fliers should be
thus, in the wide economics of Nature, pitted against one
another, wings against wings, freeman against freeman,
Invertebrate against Vertebrate, ' little brain ' against
' big brain,' ' instinct ' against ' intelligence.' Practically
this is the most important conflict of classes that the
world knows.
There is a biological suggestiveness in the old saying
about the dead flies which spoil the ointment of the apothe-
cary, but it was not till quite recently that the important
role of flies as disease- disseminators was discovered.
Perhaps it was at the time of the Spanish- American war
that it began to be clearly recognized that the house-fly
was a carrier of enteric fever and therefore full of menace.
It is now generally recognized that the house-fly can scatter
the germs not only of enteric, but of typhoid fever and of
cholera, and perhaps of other diseases as well, such as
infantile diarrhoea. It is also known to carry the tubercle
bacillus. Wherever there is a breeding ground, e.g.
about a heap of stable manure, and the possibility of
contamination with disease-germs, the house-fly becomes
a most serious danger as a disseminator. What is true for
Britain is not less true for the United States, as Dr. L. 0.
Howard has proved up to the hilt.
360 THE WONDER OF LIFE
The carrying is twofold, external and internal. After
it has been feeding on highly infective substances, the fly
must have many germs about its legs and mouth-parts and
body, and it may readily implant these in human food,
But its food-canal is also charged with concentrated
infective material, which may be dropped on food, on
dishes anywhere. Professor Nuttall remarks that " in
potential possibilities the droppings of one fly may, in
certain circumstances, weigh in the balance as against
buckets of water or of milk '.
Dr. Gordon Hewitt cites some important experiments
made by Giissow, who allowed a house-fly (Musca domestica),
caught in the room of a house, to walk over a culture plate
of agar-agar. He obtained thirty colonies comprising
six species of bacteria and six colonies comprising four
species of fungi. From another, caught in the open, he
obtained forty- six colonies comprising eight species of
bacteria and seven colonies comprising four species of
fungi. " The tracks of a house-fly caught in a household
dustbin yielded 116 colonies of bacteria comprising eleven
species, and including such species as Bacillus coli, B.
lactis acidi, and Sarcina ventriculi, and ten colonies com-
prising six species of fungi'. A very important fact,
proved by Faichne, is that if the maggot stage be de-
veloped in infected typhoid material, then the fly has also
typhoid bacilli in its alimentary canal.
It might seem to the uninitiated a sad waste of time to
inquire into the House Fly's flying capacities. But it is
a very important practical question, for the range of flight
determines the fly's range of mischief. Dr. Hindle finds that
house-flies tend to travel either against or across the wind.
This direction may be directly determined by the action of
THE WEB OF LIFE 361
the wind, or indirectly, owing to the flies being attracted
by odours borne by the wind. Fine weather and warmth
favour dispersal, and flies travel further in the open country
than in towns, probably because the houses offer food and
shelter. In thickly housed localities the usual maximum
flight is about a quarter of a mile, but in one case a single fly
was recovered at a distance of 770 yards (partly over open
fen land). When set free in the afternoon, flies do not
scatter so well as in the morning. Liberated flies often
mount almost vertically to a height of forty-five feet or
more. Every detail of this is important because flies are
disease-distributors.
Besides carrying the germs of diseases that affect animals,
flies may do something in the way of spreading the diseases
of plants. Thus L. Mercier has noticed that a common
summer fly, Sciara thomce, carries about the spores of
the fungus (Claviceps) which causes ergot on rye-grass.
The spores were abundant in the food- canal of the fly and
did not seem to be digested ; they also occurred on the
setse of the body. Although it has not been experimentally
proved that the flies infect healthy plants with Claviceps,
there is no doubt that they carry the germs and that they
frequent rye-grass.
Not a few insects are subject to fatal attacks of fungoid
parasites, and use is now being made of this to further the
destruction of injurious pests. By artificially favouring
the dissemination of the fungus it has been found possible
to cause a useful plague among the insects. Much good
has been done in this way in checking the scale insects
which attack the limes in Dominica and Montserrat and
similar islands. It has been recently suggested that an
artificial diffusion of a fungus, Empusa muscce, which is
362 THE WONDER OF LIFE
a specific parasite of house-flies and their relatives, may
be useful as a check to the multiplication of these
disease-distributors. One cannot help feeling that such
measures should be backed up by more evolved
cleanliness.
Man has in great measure freed himself from the disgrace
of gaol-fever or typhus fever, the germs of which used to
be transmitted from man to man by the clothes-louse,
and he is in process of conquering other plagues, a
step in the conquest being, in every case, an investigation
of linkages. Every one knows how the minute animals
which cause malaria (Plasmodium) and sleeping-sickness
(Trypanosomes) are disseminated respectively by the
mosquito (Anopheles maculipennis) and the tse-tse fly
(Glossina palpalis), and the human importance of these
four animals is beyond all estimation.
A curious though perhaps unimportant fact concerning
a near relative of the Trypanosomes has been recently
reported, and may serve to illustrate possible complica-
tions. A species of Leptomonas was discovered by Lafont
in the latex of Euphorbia pilulifera in Mauritius, and this has
been confirmed by G-. Bouet and E. Roubaud in regard to
other Euphorbias. They regard the infection as local
and temporary and without obvious pathological effects.
There seems little doubt that the plant is infected through
the agency of a bug.
That rats have to do with plague was perhaps referred
to in the Bible in the account of an epidemic among the
Philistines, which they connected apparently with ' the
mice that marred the land '. In more recent times, the
association of rat-mortality and human-mortality seems
to have been often remarked, and regarded as more than a
THE WEB OF LIFE
363
FIG. 57. A common mosquito, Anopheles maculipennis (female),
which carries the Protozoon causing malaria. (After Nuttall.)
coincidence. Avicenna refers to it in connexion with a
plague in Mesopotamia about A.D. 1000. But the identity
of the diseases in rat and man was not established till
1894, when the Bacillus pestis was discovered by Yersin and
Kitasato. This bacillus is a minute rod-like body with
rounded ends, about ^WQ-Q of an inch in length. It is fatal
not only to man, but to rats, mice, guinea-pigs, rabbits,
hares, ferrets, cats, monkeys, and American ground
364 THE WONDER OF LIFE
squirrels. It causes an acute fever associated with swellings
of the lymphatic glands (bubonic type), or it may primarily
attack the lungs (pneumonic type), or it may primarily
poison the blood (septicsemic type). The ' black death '
which destroyed about a fourth of the population of
Europe in the fourteenth century was apparently of the
pneumonic type and highly infectious.
The microbe of plague (in its ordinary modern form)
is not effectively transported by wind or in water or in
food. In rare cases it might be swallowed by man, but it
cannot make an effective entrance through the food canal.
It enters man through the bite of one of the Indian
rat fleas (Pulex cheopis). An outbreak of plague among
human beings in India is preceded by an outbreak of
plague among the black rats (Mus rattus) which frequent the
houses in great numbers. A flea bearing the plague bacilli
from the rat's blood bites man and thus infects him. There
are other kinds of fleas on rats, but Pulex cheopis is the only
one which will readily bite man.
A plague is known to occur in the marmots or ' tarba-
gans ' of Manchuria and an analogous disease in those who
hunt the animal for the sake of its skin. There are very
large fleas on the marmot, and it is possible that in the
epidemics of plague in Manchuria the marmot-flea may
play the same part as the rat- flea in India.
There have been many hints lately that mites have a
more complicated inter-relation with man and his domestic
animals than that which is implied in their being a
punishment for lack of cleanliness. (For mites are always
trying to clean things up.) It is probable that they have,
like ticks, a role in the spreading of disease. It has been
suggested that the very common follicle-mite (Demodex
THE WEB OF LIFE 365
folliculorum), generally regarded as a trivial parasite of the
human skin, may pave the way for some skin diseases.
One of the hints we have alluded to is Dr. Dahl's announce-
ment of a new mite, Tarsonemus hominis, found by Dr.
Saul in two cases in a human tumour. Was it simply a
parasite in the tumour, or had it a share in causing the
growth? It is well known that some of the species of
Tarsonemus cause gall- like cell-proliferation in plants.
Yellow fever, or ' yellow Jack ' as it used to be called, is
a dread disease that used to break out on ships sailing to
West Africa, the West Indies, and the like. It has occa-
sionally occurred in English and French ports, and at times
severely in New York and Philadelphia, but it is practically
confined to between latitude 40 N. and S. and longitude 20
E. and 100 W. The fell disease is transmitted by a
kind of mosquito, Stegomyia fasciata, which is almost
world-wide between the parallels of latitude 40 north
and south, a fact of incalculable human importance. For
if the disease should be introduced into the East, for in-
stance by the opening of the Panama Canal, Stegomyia
fasciata is there to spread it disastrously. Fortunately,
however, to be forewarned is to be forearmed, and the
forearming is now feasible enough. Since the American
Commission in 1899 proved up to the hilt what had been
previously suggested, that Stegomyia fasciata is the carrier of
the disease, the prevention of yellow fever has become
possible. The mosquito in question is a ' house-haunting '
insect, and it always breeds near dwellings. The larvae
develop in artificial collections of stagnant water, for
instance in old pots and pans. If these breeding-places
are destroyed, if the mosquito nets and screens are used,
and if patients are screened and segregated, so that fresh
366 THE WONDER OF LIFE
mosquitos be not infected, then Yellow Jack is conquered.
As a matter of fact, the disease has been quite stamped out
in Havanna.
It comes to this, then, that the great practical lesson of
Natural History is to recognize the complexity of inter-
relations, ' the wheels within wheels '. In a report of a
lecture by Mr. James Buckland, we read : ' The destruc-
tion of the white heron for its scapular plumes has robbed
half the world of a bird which is most useful to man. Its
loss to India and to China is most serious. It never touches
grain, but feeds solely near water and over damp ground,
the breeding-places of innumerable batrachians, small
crustaceans, and pestiferous insects, all of which directly
or indirectly injuriously affect crops in the neighbourhood.
The presence of the white heron in the rice-fields, for in-
stance, is distinctly beneficial to the farmer, and rice is
one of the most extensively grown crops of India and of
China.'
In this connexion it may be useful to point out that
many eliminations consequent on Man's intrusion cannot
be directly brought home to him as the results of any
ruthlessness. Thus one of the most extraordinary of
recent disappearances is that of the Passenger Pigeon
(Ectopistes migratorius) which used to breed, within the
memory of living man, in huge numbers in the North
American forests. Wilson, the American ornithologist,
estimated a flock at 2,230 millions, and in 1912 there was
said to be only one individual left, a female bird, about
nineteen years old, belonging to the Zoological Society of
Cincinnati. It is difficult to believe that there are not
survivors in the woods, but persistent efforts to find them
have not been rewarded with any success.
THE WEB OF LIFE 367
A second point of importance is that very strong en-
couragement has rewarded many of the endeavours to
conserve life endeavours now happily on the increase.
Thus the three herds of bison maintained by the Govern-
ment of the United States comprised in 1910 over 150 head,
and the total of pure-bred bisons living in North America
was a little over 2,000 a satisfactory result of careful
protection. Equally full of promise are the records of
reserve-areas and bird-sanctuaries (like those of the Sel-
borne Society in Britain and the Audubon Society in the
United States), and of individual efforts (we think, for
instance, of Mr. Ford, the well-known motor-car manu-
facturer) to conserve what may be fairly called vital assets.
In Conclusion. These few instances must serve to illus-
trate the fact that animated Nature is a vast system of link-
ages and inter-relations. No creature lives or dies to itself.
The threads of one lif e get caught up and intertwined with
those of another. The liver-fluke of the sheep cannot get
on without the water- snail, nor the bitterling without the
freshwater mussel, nor the mussel without the minnow,
or some such fish, nor the clover without the bee. We find
these inter-relations in all degrees of perfection, some old
established and working smoothly, others in the making or
on trial, and others again apparently making for the ex-
tinction of one at least of the associates. But in whatever
stage of evolution they are, their interest is great, the
web of life is a great fact in Nature, and it is one of the
naturalist's delights and tasks to discern the threads.
The general idea we have been expounding was tersely
put in an address by Dr. T. Muir. ' The specialist must
aim a little more at width of outlook and knowledge of men
and affairs, must seek to moderate his exaggerated estimate
368 THE WONDER OF LIFE
of the importance of his own little domain, and must try
to see good in the labours of other specialists in fields far
distant from his own, never forgetting that all fields are
but perfectly fitted portions of a cosmic whole, and that,
as the botanist and the astronomer in particular must
come to know
' Thou canst not stir a flower,
Without troubling a star '.
When we think quietly over the extraordinary series
of facts brought together in this chapter which is but
one of a possible thousand and one nights of tales we
confess to a feeling of wonder. Life overwhelms us with
its subtlety of linkage.
' We recognize, of course, that many haunts of life are
densely crowded, and commoner rubs elbow with patrician
in the throng of the streets, but the wonder is the intimate
interlinking of life with life. Contact is nothing, it is the
correlation that impresses us. Flowers and their visitors
fit one another as glove and hand ; cats influence the clover
crop and the incidence of the plague in Indian villages ;
water- wagtails have to do with the success of sheep-farming,
and mosquitoes with the decadence of Greece.
This is one of the big facts of life, the correlation of
organisms; and, to our thinking, its deep significance
is twofold. On the one hand, it seems congruent with the
deep-seated tendency of Nature to complexity. It looks
as if a story were being told. For there is reason to believe
that in the course of time atoms became molecules, and
molecules larger molecules, and these colloidal masses. It
is conceivable that these incorporated partner molecules
and became protoplasm ; and that, by and by, viable units
of -protoplasm, to wit, living creatures, emerged, and a world
THE WEB OF LIFE 369
of life began. Our hypothesis, based on many facts, is
that in this new world of life the complexifying tendency
continued, and we call that the self-differentiation of
protoplasm. Living creatures traded with time and found
fuller and fuller self-expression. No one doubts that many
kinds of ' flesh ' originated, one kind of fishes, another of
birds, another of beasts, another of man, as was said in
olden time.
But we must add to this or superimpose on it another
idea, that the living creature is associative. We do not
wish to multiply formulse or mysterious tendencies, but
there seems to be a touch of protoplasm that makes diverse
creatures kin. A quaint instance may serve as a diagram.
In recently examining at Roscoff a large collection of the
little green worms known as Convoluta roscoffensis, Marcel
A. Herubel found among them about forty specimens of
Convoluta flavibacillum, a species which is not green, which
had not been previously noticed in this locality. The
peculiar fact was observed, that on the ventral surface of
each of them there was a young C. roscoffensis, clinging
on by its dorsal surface. When they w r ere separated
in the aquarium, they were re-united in half an hour !
The meaning of the peculiar association remains quite
obscure, but, whatever it may be, the case may serve to
illustrate our idea, that many organisms go about with,
as it were, tendrils Unking themselves on to other organisms.
We have no great faith in the multiplication of ' tropisms ',
or inherent predispositions of organisms to move on certain
ways in answer to precise stimuli, but we would suggest
an addition to the list, viz. ' biotropism ' the attraction
of organism to organism. To rank this beside ' geotropism ',
' heliotropism ', ' thigmotropism ', ' chemotropism ', and
BB
370 THE WONDER OF LIFE
the like will not indeed make occurrences any clearer,
but it may serve as a useful labelled string for a large series
of facts the linking of one organism to another, at points
where their lines of life intersect, although we often cannot
see any obvious reason why they should do so. After
the event, we say, * It pays ' ; but who could have pre-
dicted its success. In any case, the correlation of organ-
isms in the web of life is a large fact. Nature continues
to complexify her system.
CHAPTER VI
THE CYCLE OF LIFE
(FROM BIRTH THROUGH LOVE TO DEATH)
instant sbe commences an immense journey, ano
everg instant sbe bas reacbeo bee goal '. '1foer life is in ber
cbfloren' .... "Iber cbiloren are numberless'. . . . *1ber
crown is love '. . . . ^ver greatness sbe spreads ber
sbfelo'. . . . * 2>eatb is ber expert Device to get plenty of life'.
Goethe's Aphorisms, translated by Huxley.
The Curve of Life The Continuance of Life The Wonder of
Development Growth Young Animals Adolescence Court-
ship among Animals Parental Care and the Family Ageing
and Senescence Death Illustrations of Life-histories The
Story of Niners.
THE living creature is always changing in its material
composition, yet it has a remarkable power of
retaining its integrity. This is one of its secrets. It burns,
but is not consumed. Besides this, however, it has the
power of passing from form to form, from phase to phase
the power of ' cyclical development ', as Huxley called it.
This is our main theme in this chapter.
The Curve of Life. From a microscopic egg-cell,
hidden within the ovule, fertilized by a pollen-nucleus,
an embryo plant develops ; the seed is sown and a seedling
develops ; the seedling becomes a sapling ; this grows into
a tree which bears flowers and seeds year after year, it
371
372 THE WONDER OF LIFE
may be for centuries, but finally becomes old, decays and
dies, falling to the ground, ' dry, bald and sere '.
Speaking of the beanstalk developing from the bean,
Huxley wrote :
' By insensible steps, the plant builds itself up into a
large and various fabric of root, stem, leaves, flowers,
and fruit, every one moulded within and without in accord-
ance with an extremely complex, but, at the same time,
minutely denned pattern. In each of these complicated
structures, as in their smallest constituents, there is an
immanent energy, which, in harmony with that resident
in all the others, incessantly works toward the maintenance
of the whole and the efficient performance of the part it
has to play in the economy of nature. But no sooner has
the edifice, reared with such exact elaboration, attained
completeness, than it begins to crumble. By degrees, the
plant withers and disappears from view, leaving behind
more or few apparently inert and simple bodies, just like
the bean from which it sprang ; and like it endowed with
the potentiality of giving rise to a similar cycle of mani-
festations '. . . . It is a ' Sisyphsean process, in the course
of which the living and growing plant passes from the
relative simplicity and latent potentiality of the seed to
the full epiphany of a highly differentiated type, thence
to fall back to simplicity and potentiality ' (Evolution
and Ethics, 1893).
The life-cycle is even more striking among animals.
The fertilized egg-cell divides and redivides ; the segmen-
tation-cells are arranged and differentiated ; an embryo
is formed, which goes on developing, directly or circuitously,
until the result is a reproduction of the parent organism.
But when the ascent from a vita minima at the start has
reached the vita maxima of maturity, there begins to be a
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 373
reversal of the process. There is a quick or slow descent
to the vita minima of senescence, ending in natural death,
if violent death has not previously intervened. Varied
as the life-histories are, there is always the same general
phenomenon of cyclical development.
The shape of the curve differs greatly in different types.
Some have a short youth, e.g. Aphides , which are almost
like adults at birth and set to work at once ; while others
have a long youth, e.g. frogs, which spend about three
months in the larval state. Some have a prolonged
maturity, e.g. most birds and mammals ; while others have
it soon cut short, e.g. May-flies, which are sometimes
literally insects of a day. There may be prolonged adoles-
cence, as in an eel, or a precocious maturity, as in a rat.
Two general ideas should be borne in mind (a) that life-
histories differ from one another in the lengthening out
or shortening down (sometimes even telescoping) of parti-
cular periods ; and (6) that they differ much more inti-
mately in the details of the curve in the minor ups and
downs which mark the vicissitudes of days and seasons,
and the often correlated internal periodicities.
The Continuance of Life. A chronometer well- wound
can keep agoing for a long time, but it eventually comes
to a standstill, and so does the organism. An intricate
device like the famous Strassburg clock may go through
a complicated performance, with processions of figures
and the like, but eventually the mechanism runs down
and the show is over. So is it with the organism. But
there are several big differences between an organism and
a mechanism, and one is that the organism normally
gives origin to other organisms like itself or shares in so
doing. It multiplies or reproduces itself.
374 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Thus the life of the organism is very different from the
path of a rocket in the air, which spends itself wholly in
its brilliant career, for normally the organism has offspring.
The vital trajectory is different from the course of the
drops of water in a fountain, which rise to the summit,
sparkle a moment in the sunlight, and sink again to earth.
The organism secures the continuance of its kind.
The Wonder of Development. There are some
beautifully transparent eggs which we can watch as they
develop, actually witnessing the divisions and displace-
ments of cells. The egg of one of the moths, Botys
hiemalis, is a good illustration, and there are few pro-
cesses that go on in the world more impressive than this
development the emergence of the obviously complex
from the apparently simple. In the case of the hen's
egg, that we are so familiar with, a small drop of
transparent living matter lies like an inverted watch-
glass on the top of the ball of yolk. From that drop, in
the course of three weeks, the chick is built up the most
familiar fact in the world and surely wonderful. In his
forty-ninth Exercitation on ' the efficient cause of the
chicken,' Harvey quaintly expressed his sense of the
wonder :
' Although it be a known thing subscribed by all, that
the foetus assumes its original and birth from the male
and female, and consequently that the egge is produced
by the cock and henne, and the chicken out of the egge, yet
neither the school of physicians nor Aristotle's discerning
brain have disclosed the manner how the cock and its seed
doth mint and coine the chicken out of the egge.'
Development is the ' becoming ' of the individual
organism. It is the attainment of a specific form and
THE CYCLE OF LIFE
375
structure, and
of the not less
characteristic
associated
faculties or
activities.
Often we can-
not tell one
kind of egg
from another,
but the one
will develop
FIG. 58. Egg of Ascidian, Ciona intestinalis, after
Duesberg, to show distribution of organ-
forming substances in the egg, which is
about to divide into two. At the lower
pole there is a distinct crescent with very
crowded small granules (plastochondria) ;
around the division-spindle in the centre
there is a clear zone ; the upper portion of
the egg has numerous yolk granules and
few plastochondria.
into a star-
fish and the
other into a
sea-urchin,
one will be-
come a rep-
tile and the
other a bird. Development is the expression or realization
of an inheritance.
The starting-point of an individual life is usually a
fertilized egg-cell a new unity formed by the intimate
and orderly union of paternal and maternal inheritances,
conveyed we know not how in the often microscopic egg-
cell and the extremely microscopic sperm- cell. There
may be development from a bud or from a fragment of a
parent organism this is the expensive process of asexual
reproduction. There are also many cases of partheno-
genesis, where the egg-cell develops without being ferti-
lized. Thus a drone-bee has a mother but no father, but
these modes of asexual reproduction and parthenogenetic
376 THE WONDER OF LIFE
development are relatively exceptional, and the individual's
start in life is usually the fertilized egg- cell.
The fertilized ovum divides and redivides, and we may
see this going on in the frog's spawn in the ditch. In that
case a groove appears dividing the ovum into a right and
left cell ; then another, at right angles to the first, dividing
each of these into an anterior and a posterior half ; then a
third cleavage in a horizontal plane cuts the four cells across
the equator, forming an upper hemisphere with four
smaller, and a lower hemisphere with four larger cells. In
some cases the process of cleavage suggests the operation
of an invisible magical knife.
For a time the process of division continues without
there being any growth, and a ball of cells (or blastomeres)
is formed which is still no larger than the original unseg-
mented ovum. But growth soon begins, and the cells
are arranged in germinal layers, or are variously localized
by processes of infolding and overlap. Sooner or later
the cells begin to show differentiation, some laying the
foundations of the nervous system, others of the muscular
system, others of the digestive system, and so on. And
besides differentiation there is the process of integration
the unification and co-ordination of the developing
organism. In short, there is a process of embryonic
development condensing into a few days or weeks the
achievements of ages of evolution.
At a certain stage, differing greatly in the different types,
the egg is ' hatched ', and there emerges from the egg-
envelope a young creature which is a delightful miniature
of the adult, as in the familiar case of a chick, or a larva
very different from the adult, as in the case of caterpillar
and tadpole. The embryo is the quiescent stage within
O
FIG. 58A. Segmentation of the egg of African Clawed Toad, Xenopus laevis. I.
The unfertilized egg with pigment and the nucleus in its upper hemisphere.
II. The 8-cell stage, seen from below. III. The early blastula or ' ball of cells '
stage. (After E. J. Bles.)
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 377
the egg-membrane ; the larva is free-living and able to feed
for itself ; but the larval stage may be suppressed, and
then we say that out of the egg-envelope there emerges a
young creature. Thus in one type the embryonic develop-
ment is succeeded by a long larval period, while in another
type the embryonic development eventuates in a young
creature like a miniature of the parent.
It is very difficult to discover a quite satisfactory punctu-
ation of life to say for instance when development stops.
As long as the expression of the inheritance goes on, as
long as differentiation and integration continue, we may
certainly speak of development, but mere increase in size
is not development, and it is very difficult to know when
to put in the stop. Some would say that there is no stop
at all until death, and that development includes all the
normal changes of form and structure that occur through-
out life, the breaking down in old age being on this view
just as much part of development as the building-up of
youth. This usage seems more logical than useful, for
the changes of senescence are for the most part of the
nature of ' involution ' rather than of evolution.
Others would put in the stop when the limit of growth
is reached, but the brain may go on developing long after
that, though in mammals there seems to be no increase
in the actual number of brain-cells after birth. Moreover,
as we have seen, there are many fishes and reptiles that
show no limit of growth.
Others would put in the stop when the specific characters
are well-defined, when the creature has put on the dress
that is its own and no other's. There seems a great deal
to be said for this punctuation, but it is open to the ob-
jection of excluding much that can be justly called develop-
378 THE WONDER OF LIFE
ment, e.g. the changes associated with sexual maturity.
The fact is that, in studying development, we are considering
the living creature in its time-relations, and definition
is a matter of convenience.
The first wonder of development is the minuteness of the
starting-point. Even when we use the comfortable word
potentiality, we find it difficult to deny the wonder of con-
densing a complex inheritance into a microscopic germ-cell.
An ovum the size of a pin's head is a large ovum, as ova go.
Many are microscopic, and a spermatozoon may be only
fwoooth f * ne ovum's size. Can there be room in these
minute vehicles for the complexity of organization which
an inheritance implies ?
The wonder grows when we consider some of the facts
of modern embryological research. Prof. Delage cut the
very minute egg of a sea-urchin into three parts, and reared
a larva from each of them. In another case he reared an
embryo from sVth of a sea-urchin's egg. Twin animals
may often be obtained from one ovum by producing a
separation of the first two cleavage-cells. Professor E.
B. Wilson produced quadruplets by shaking apart the
four-cell stage in the development of the lancelet.
The second wonder is germinal continuity. These
germ-cells are not ordinary cells ; they are like the fertilized
ovum which gave rise to the parent. All the cells of the
body are continuous with the original fertilized ovum by a
succession of cell-divisions, but in the case of the germ-cells
the lineage is undifTerentiated. In many cases, scattered
throughout the animal kingdom, from worms to fishes,
the beginning of the lineage of germ-cells is demonstrable
very early, before the division of labour implied in building
up the body has more than begun. Even when this early
THE CYCLE OF LIFE
379
FIG. 59. Chain of embryos (E,) of Encyrtus fuscicollis, all arising from
one ovum, bound together by a chain of mucus (s. ) After Marchal.
segregation of the germ-cells is not demonstrable, we know
that the germ-cells do not arise from differentiated
body-cells. They are cells which retain intact the
qualities of the fertilized ovum which gave rise to the
parent. Similar material to start with, similar conditions
in which to develop therefore, like tends to beget like.
Two famous quotations may make this fundamental fact
of germinal continuity quite clear. There is a sense, Galton
said, in which the child is as old as the parent, for when
the parent's body is developing from the fertilized ovum,
a residue of unaltered germinal material is kept apart to
form the reproductive cells, one of which may become the
starting-point of a child. To use Weismann's words : ' In
development a part of the germ-plasm (i.e., the essential
germinal material) contained in the parent egg-cell is not
used up in the construction of the body of the offspring,
but is reserved unchanged for the formation of the germ-
3 8
THE WONDER OF LIFE
cells of the following generation '. Thus the parent is
rather the trustee of the germ-plasm than the producer of
the child. In a new sense, the child is a ' chip of the old
block '.
A third wonder is the extraordinary process of matur-
ation or ' reducing division '. The details are diverse and
difficult, but the net result of the process may be simply
FIG. 60. Part of a dividing cell, a Radiolarian, showing the chromo-
somes in two groups. A, the cytoplasm ; c, the chromosomes ;
B,D, differentiations in the cytoplasm. (After Haecker.)
stated. In each cell in the body of an organism there is
normally a nucleus or kernel, and within the nucleus a
definite number of readily stainable rods, or loops, or
granules, called chromosomes. Each kind of living creature
has a particular number, thus there are twenty- four in man,
mouse, and lily ; sixteen in ox, guinea-pig, and onion ;
twelve in the grasshopper ; two in one of the threadworms,
and so on. There is no doubt that these chromosomes are
very important, and most biologists regard them as the
O
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 381
bearers or vehicles of the hereditary qualities. It is quite
safe to say that the chromosomes, along with other germ-
cell constituents, stand in some definite causal relation
to the adult characters. Now the remarkable fact is that,
while the quite immature germ-cells have the same number
(n) of chromosomes as the body-cells of the species under
consideration, the mature germ-cells have half that number
( - ) . By a kind of cell-division (meiosis), which is normally
restricted to this one point in the entire life- history, the
number of chromosomes is reduced to one half the normal
number. It follows that when the ripe spermatozoon
and the ripe ovum each with^ chromosomes unite in
fertilization, the normal number n is restored. If there
were not some reduction of this sort, the number of chromo-
somes would be doubled at each fertilization, which is
absurd. Moreover, in the reduction, which, in the case
of the egg, means the absolute rejection of half of the
chromosomes (which are usually carried off by the first
' polar body ' and come to nothing), we see an opportunity
for permutations and combinations among the items of
the inheritance, e.g. for the dropping out of a character
altogether. If we compare the inheritance so far as it
is borne by the chromosomes to a pack of cards, there
is a remarkable throwing away of half of the pack and
their replacement by half of another pack at the beginning
of each individual life.
The fourth wonder is fertilization the intimate and
orderly union of the reduced nuclei of the two sex- cells.
There are several processes involved which may be analysed
apart. There is the mingling of two inheritances,
382 THE WONDER OF LIFE
which usually come from two different parents, and it
is important to understand that the spermatozoon from
the one parent and the ovum from the other contribute
the same number of chromosomes, except in certain very
interesting cases where half the spermatozoa have an extra
chromosome. Furthermore, anticipating a little, we may
notice the ocular demonstration of the fact that when
the fertilized ovum divides, each daughter-cell or blastomere
receives the normal number of chromosomes, half of which
are of maternal and half of paternal origin. This has been
followed for several divisions, so that, if the chromosomes
are (even in some measure) inheritance-bearers we have a
remarkable confirmation of the truth of the prophetic
statement which Huxley made in 1878 :
' It is conceivable, and indeed probable, that every part
of the adult contains molecules derived both from the male
and from the female parent ; and that, regarded as a mass
of molecules, the entire organism may be compared to a
web of which the warp is derived from the female and
the woof from the male '.
In the animal kingdom it is usual for cells to have in their
cytoplasm, outside their nucleus, a minute body known
as the centrosome, which becomes two when the cell is
going to divide, and seems to play an important part in
the process of division. In the animal ovum the centrosome
disappears, and it is part of the process of fertilization that
the spermatozoon introduces a centrosome. This divides
into two, and these have their role when the egg divides.
One passes into each daughter-cell or blastomere.
Another aspect of fertilization is that the entrance of the
spermatozoon, or the reproductive nucleus of the pollen-
grain in the case of the flowering plant, does in some way
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 383
stimulate the ovum to divide, or remove some embargo
which hinders the ovum from starting on its course of
development. It is possible that some ferment may be
introduced in ordinary fertilization, but the remarkable
experimental work of recent years shows that a great
variety of stimuli may serve to set the egg dividing. It
is difficult to discern what is the common feature in these
diverse trigger-pulling stimuli.
Artificial Parthenogenesis. Our knowledge of the
very interesting phenomena commonly referred to as
artificial parthenogenesis is in great part due to two
experimenters of the first rank, Professor Jacques
Loeb and Professor Yves Delage. Loeb began by
showing that the action of the male element could be
facilitated or its range of possible action increased by
altering the conditions. In sea-water rendered faintly
alkaline the eggs of the sea-urchin could be fertilized
by the sperms of many different kinds of starfish, though
this did not occur in ordinary sea-water. But this was
but the beginning of his remarkable series of researches.
He put the eggs of the sea-urchin into sea-water to which
had been added a little formic, acetic, or butyric acid,
and then after a minute or two replaced them in normal
sea-water. They began to show the initial stages of nuclear
division. But when he transferred ova from the acidified
sea- water to more concentrated sea- water, to which common
salt had been added, they developed normally and at the
usual rate, and formed free-swimming larvae. Similar
experiments have been successfully made with several
kinds of worms and molluscs.
Loeb, Delage, and others have shown in a considerable
variety of cases that artificial parthenogenesis can be
384 THE WONDER OF LIFE
induced by many different kinds of stimulus. To set
the egg dividing a mechanical stimulus such as gentle
brushing or a pin-prick may suffice ; or a slight disturbance
of the chemical composition of the sea- water may serve ;
or some alteration of the osmotic conditions by adding
something to the water ; or exposure of the eggs to certain
vapours or to electric discharges. The puzzling feature
is the diversity of effective stimulus. In many cases the
artificially stimulated egg divides and re- divides, but
eventually comes to naught. In a few cases, viable young
animals develop. Thus Professor Delage reared a miniature
sea-urchin from an unfertilized ovum, and Fritz Levy
reared young frogs.
Without attempting any survey of the very striking
series of experiments, we may refer to two or three which
are particularly instructive. Winkler made an extract
of sea-urchin spermatozoa and put some of it in water
containing sea-urchin eggs. The eggs developed, and it
was inferred that the extract had ' fertilized ' the eggs.
The observation was right, the inference was wrong. For
Gies and Pichon showed that Winkler's results were due
to osmotic influence. The same results can be obtained
by using reagents that have nothing to do with sperm-
extract. Kupelwieser made the very interesting experi-
ment of bringing the spermatozoa of the mussel (Mytilus)
into contact with eggs of sea-urchins (Strongylocentrotus
and Echinus), with the result that the eggs developed into
larvae. Microscopic analysis showed that the chromo-
somes of the mussel spermatozoon played no part in the
fertilization, but that the centrosome introduced by the
spermatozoon took part in the cleavage process. The
larvae showed only maternal characters.
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 385
Very striking experiments have been made by M. Bataillon
on frogs' eggs, and confirmed by M. Henneguy. Under
proper precautions the eggs were taken from a frog, placed
in a flat dish, pricked with a needle of platinum or glass,
and then covered with a layer of water which had been
sterilized by heat. In about four hours the eggs began to
segment, and about a fifth of them did it normally. Out
of a thousand eggs, a hundred and twenty hatched into
tadpoles, and one of these lived till it was about three months
old and almost a perfect frog. As it has been remarked,
' in the hands of these physiologists, the little needle was as
potent (or almost as potent) as Aaron's rod '.
In one of his experiments, Bataillon took a piece of a
string of toad's spawn with as little jelly as possible, put it
in a dry dish, bathed it with a little blood, and made little
punctures in the eggs. They segmented ' magnificently ',
and the frog's blood works as well as the toad's, and better
than the spermatozoa of the frog ! According to Bataillon,
pricking the eggs, or exposing them to vapour of chloroform,
or subjecting them to electric discharges, and the like,
may be sufficient to activate the eggs and induce some
cleavage. But if embryos and larvae are to be developed,
there must be something more ; there must be an intro-
duction of some organic, apparently nuclear, matter, which
probably exerts a catalytic influence. Thus frogs' eggs
moistened with blood and then pricked will develop into
larvae. The pin-prick plus the introduced blood corpuscle
take the place of the spermatozoon in normal fertiliza-
tion.
Fritz Levy followed the method of pricking the frogs'
eggs with a platinum needle, which was sometimes first
dipped in salt or in the blood of the mother. He repeatedly
c c
386 THE WONDER OF LIFE
reared tadpoles by this aspermic development, and he was
thrice successful in reaching the stage of miniature frogs.
It is interesting to find that the nuclei were smaller than
the normal, and Levy believes that they had only half the
normal number of chromosomes.
The experiments in question illustrate very clearly that,
as we have indicated, several quite distinct things take
place in ordinary fertilization. The entrance of the sper-
matozoon implies some degree of mingling of the paternal
with the maternal inheritance, and it also implies some
stimulus to cleavage or the removal of some hindrance.
In the artificial parthenogenesis effected by MM . Bataillon
and Henneguy the role of sperm- stimulus was discharged
by a needle, and the inheritance remained, of course, purely
maternal, for there cannot be a hybrid between a needle
and a frog. As a French writer puts it : ' il ne peut etre
question d'heredite du cote du pere, car on ne voit pas
tres bien les jeunes grenouilles heritant des proprietes de
leur epingle paternelle '. While some incline to think
that the spermatozoon introduces a stimulus, perhaps of
the nature of a ferment, Loeb has suggested that
the spermatozoon may remove ' a negative catalyser or
condition ', the presence of which somehow keeps the
ovum from developing. The stimulus may be the removal
of an inhibitory influence. Further experiments are re-
quired before this question can be securely answered.
We have seen that a quite ripe ovum has in its nucleus
half the normal number of chromosomes ; if this ovum be
artificially stimulated to development, the cells of the
young animal should also contain only half the normal
number. According to Dehorne, this was the case
in an eight days' old frog-tadpole, reared from an
THE CYCLE OF LIFE
387
unfertilized egg ; the cells of the body had only half
the normal number of chromosomes. In some cases
the number seems to be normal, which may be due
to the fact that the ova began to develop under arti-
ficial stimulus before the ordinary reduction process
had occurred; or to a subsequent restoration of the
reduced number ' by a process of auto-regulation ', as
is said to be the case in Delage's parthenogenetic sea-
urchin larvae.
The general opinion of experts is thus summed up by
Professor E. B. Wilson. As
the ovum is much the
larger, it is believed to
furnish the initial capital
including in some cases
a legacy of food-yolk for
the early development of
the embryo. From both
parents alike comes the
inheritedorganizationwhich
has its seat (in part at least)
in the readily stainable
chromatin rods or chromo-
somes of the nucleus. From
the father comes a little body, the centrosome, which
organizes the machinery of division by which the egg
splits up, and distributes the dual inheritance equally
between the daughter-cells. Besides bearing the paternal
inheritance, restoring the number of chromosomes to
the normal, introducing the centrosome (which serves as
'the weaver of the loom'), and acting as the normal
trigger- puller which sets the egg a-going on the path-
or readily stainable bodies in
the nucleus ; 3, the cell sub-
stance or cytoplasm showing
a reticular structure ; 4, the
cell-wall.
388 THE WONDER OF LIFE
way of development, the spermatozoon may do yet
another thing. In some insects and other types, half of
the spermatozoa have the same number of chromosomes as
the ripe egg ( - ), while half of them have one fewerf 1 ),
\2' \2 '
and there seems to be good evidence that when two equal
numbers come together f--j J the result is a female,
while an ovum fertilized by a spermatozoon with - 1
2
chromosomes develops into a male.
We see, then, how much is involved when a spermatozoon
fertilizes an ovum. There is a mingling of the paternal
and maternal inheritances ; there is a restoration of the
normal number of chromosomes ; there is the introduction
of the minute centrosome which plays an important role in
cleavage ; there is an activation of the egg and a stimulus
to embryo-forming ; and there is a rapid change effected
in the periphery of the ovum, so that it becomes non-
receptive to other spermatozoa.
A glimpse into the subtleties that lie beyond may per-
haps be given by taking a particular item of fact. Giinther
Hertwig finds that the eggs of the Edible Frog (Rana
esculenta) and the Common Toad (Bufo vulgaris) may be
fertilized by sperms of the Brown Frog (Rana fusca). They
segment normally, but they die before they reach the
gastrula stage of development. But if the spermatozoa
of Rana fusca be first exposed to intense Radium rays,
and then used for fertilization, the eggs develop into larvae
which survive for several weeks. The explanation sug-
gested of this curious paradox may be wrong, but it is
illustrative. It is this, that the spermatozoa of R. fusca
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 389
contain some nuclear element which is not in harmony
with the particular protoplasmic composition of the eggs
of the Edible Frog and the Common Toad. But if this
disharmonious element be destroyed by the Radium in-
fluence, the spermatozoon may act as a stimulus to develop-
ment which is, in a sense, parthenogenetic. In various
organs, it was noted that the surface or volume of the
nuclei was half the normal.
Another side-light may be illuminating. In many cases
it is possible to effect artificial hybridisation, even between
types which are very far apart. A very striking instance
is that effected by Professor E. W. MacBride between the
eggs of the common heart-urchin (Echinocardium cordatum)
and the sperms of the common regular sea-urchin (Echinus
esculentus). The hybrid larvse, which showed both pater-
nal and maternal characters, lived for only eight or nine
days, but all Echinoderm larvse are delicate and difficult
to rear. The interest of the case is that the two parent
genera are so far apart. Professor MacBride points out that
Echinus and Echinocardium have been distinct since the
beginning of the Secondary epoch, and that their common
ancestor could not have lived later than a period which a
moderate estimate would place at twenty million years ago ;
yet the germ-cells of the two types will commingle so as
to produce a hybrid in which both paternal and maternal
characters are represented.
No one can dream of dealing in a facile way with
development, which is one of the central mysteries of
life, but we wish to try to state two general ideas.
The first is that development is an active process of
self-expression. This may be illustrated by reference to
a very important event in development, namely, the out-
3QO THE WONDER OF LIFE
growth of nerve-fibres and the establishment of specific
nervous connections on which the effectiveness of sub-
sequent activity depends. In 1890 Kamon y Cajal dis-
covered at the end of the embryonic nerve fibres, at a very
early stage in their development, what he called a cone
of growth, which he compared to the finger-like outgrowth
or pseudopodium which the Amoeba protrudes when
it is gliding over the mud of the pond.
In very vivid words he wrote (1899) :
' From the functional point of view, the cone of growth
may be regarded as a sort of club or battering ram,
endowed with exquisite chemical sensitiveness, with rapid
amoeboid movements, and with a certain impulsive force,
thanks to which it is able to press forward and overcome
obstacles met in its way, forcing cellular interstices until
it arrives at its destination '.
This was in great part a prophetic interpretation, and
many have vigorously opposed the conclusion that the
development of nerve paths is really due to the protoplas-
mic movement on the part of the nerve-cells. But brilliant
confirmation of Kamon y CajaPs view has been recently
afforded by Professor Ross Granville Harrison, to whose
work we wish briefly to refer.
Harrison's experiments show that two elementary
phenomena are involved in nerve development : (a) the
formation of the primitive nerve fibre by an outflowing
movement of the protoplasm of a nerve-cell, and (6) the
formation of neurofibrils within this filament a process
of tissue differentiation.
' It is through the former that the specific nerve paths
of the body are first laid down '. ' The energy of outgrowth
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 391
is immanent in the nerve-cell, and the initial direction of
outgrowth is already determined within the cell before
the outgrowth actually begins. The formation of the
fibre is therefore an act of self-differentiation within Roux's
definition '.
The second general impression that we get from the
study of development is that of a continuous action and
reaction between an implicit organization and the environ-
ing conditions. We include in the environing conditions
not only the external medium and its energies, and the
maternal environment where such exists, but also the
intra-embryonic environment, the influence of surrounding
cells and of the whole on any particular developing unit
or area. The developing organism is continually trafficking
with its environment, and the result is a function of the
intrinsic hereditary nature, on the one hand, and of the
appropriate environmental nurture, on the other.
In thinking of such a difficult problem as embryonic
development, it is always profitable to look at it in the
light of the development of which we are most immediately
aware the development of our own mind and character.
Of a truth they are both born and made. Our mind is in
great part a social product ; our character has to be wrought
out in conduct. What we are aware of is ' the expliciting
of the implicit ', the actualizing of something potential,
action and reaction between our hereditary nature and a
complex environing nurture. Reading back, we feel sure
that the same general idea applies to embryonic develop-
ment. The general idea is that of the seed which will
not germinate except in suitable soil, and duly favoured
with sunshine and rain ; but we wish to push the idea back
till we see in each cell of the embryo, in each ' organ-forming
392 THE WONDER OF LIFE
substance ' or plastosome, a seed to which the surrounding
cells supply the appropriate environment and the necessary
liberating stimuli. Above all, we must not think of the
matter too simply, too mechanically. That mechanical
factors operate directly on the developing embryo will
be admitted by all. There are bound to be pressures and
tensions and the like, which make themselves felt. But it
has to be borne in mind that the essential process is the
active expression of an inconceivably intricate organiza-
tion, which has been gradually wrought out through tens
of thousands of years. When Professor His maintained that
the large eyes of the young chick are the direct cause, by
compression, of the sharp beak of the bird, he was taking
too simple a view of the problem, and mistaking the cart
for the horse.
To take a concrete illustration of the absolutely essential
influence of the environment. It is well known that the
absence of the appropriate temperature at a critical period
may have a profound effect. It may arrest cell-divisions in
one part of the embryo more than in another, and strange
aberrations may result. Or it may operate by hindering
the operation of certain ferments. Thus Dr. J. Dewitz
placed the nests of a wasp (Polistes) in a refrigerator for
forty-eight hours, and found that this had the effect of
hindering the development of the wings in the pupae.
Similar experiments with the pupae of the blow-fly (Calli-
phdra) also resulted in defective wings. Again we are made
to feel that each stage in development has its appropriate
external nurture.
Environment affords or denies stimulus, and according
to the liberality or parsimony will be, in many cases, the
degree of development attained by the animal. A diagram-
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 393
matic illustration may be found in the story of Neptune's
Cup. This huge cup-like sponge (Poterion neptuni or
Cliona patera) may grow to an immense size a cup that
only a god could drain. It may be a couple of feet in
height. Now Vosmaer discovered what Topsent has con-
firmed, that this huge cup is the free form of a small boring
sponge which is found making gimlet-like holes in shells.
There are also free and prisoner forms of the common
Cliona celata.
Growth. The power of growth is one of the insignia of
life. It is characteristic of all living creatures, and every one
knows in a practical way what it means, though a precise
definition is not easy. One may say that growth is increase
in the size or volume of an organism, and usually implies
increase in mass or weight. But there is evidently no
small difference between an increase of size due to a sub-
cutaneous deposit of fat, such as we see in prize pigs and
prize fat cattle, and the slow continuous growth of a lean
fish like a haddock. There is a marked difference between
an enlargement due to the accumulation of watery fluid
and the fine growth of an embryo's brain. It is not growth
that we see when a parched turnip or the like is surrounded
with water and expands, or when a frog, leaving its winter-
quarters in the mud, plunges into the pond, and, absorbing
water through its skin, may be watched ' swelling visibly '.
It seems, indeed, that more than one word is required
to cover the various phenomena which may be quite
reasonably referred to as growth.
We cannot speak of growth as one of the characteristics
of living organisms without remembering that the power
of growth under suitable conditions is also the fundamental
property of crystals. Since Professor Lehmarm published
394 THE WONDER OF LIFE
his important work on Fluid Crystals in 1904, the conception
of crystals has had to be profoundly altered. For he
introduced us to what he called the ' new world ' of crystals
that are mobile and liquid, yet not separable by any break
from those that are rigid and solid. The fundamen-
tal character is the power of growing, and Professor
Lehmann thinks that this may be, as it were, utilized in the
growth of organisms. He figures the beautiful growths
of purely inorganic ' silicate- vegetation '. But what must
be definitely borne in mind is that the crystal can only
grow larger at the expense of material the same as itself.
Organic growth is essentially a regulated increase in
the amount of living matter (protoplasm) and intimately
associated substances. It is much more than accretion,
it is an active process of self-increase. Unlike a crystal's
growth, it comes about at the expense of materials different
from the growing substance often very different, as in
the case of plants, which feed on air, water, and salts.
Unlike mere expansion, it is regulated in relation to the
organism, or organ, or cell that is growing. In all multi-
cellular organisms growth is associated with cell-division,
for when the individual cell reaches its limit of growth it
divides into two.
As to the conditions of growth, the first is Nutrition.
Living involves continual wear and tear and not less
continual recuperation ; growth depends on there being
a surplus in the process of self -renewal. In other words,
it is a fundamental condition of growth that income
should be greater than outlay. Thus the enormous bulk
of many plants like the Big Trees of California is in part
dependent on the fundamental fact that the income of the
plant is always high above its expenditure. Animal giants
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 395
are rare, and one of the reasons for this is that animals live
much more nearly up to their income than plants do.
It sometimes happens, one must admit, that an organism
grows larger for a time without taking in any food we can
see that in the growth of salmon-fry before they begin to
eat but what happens in such cases is a change of con-
densed stored substances into more dilute and bulkier form.
The embryo is cashing and re-investing its legacy of yolk.
The same is true of the shoots of a potato, sprouting in a
dark cellar ; they show true growth though the organism
as a whole is actually losing water in transpiration, and,
as its respiration shows, breaking down carbon-compounds.
What was stored in the tuber is being transformed.
More difficult, perhaps, is the case of a young tadpole,
for careful measurements and weighings show that during
the period of most rapid growth, the weight of dry sub-
stance does not increase at all. During this period, it
seems, the imbibition of water is more important than the
assimilation of food-material.
Plenty of assimilated food is the sine qua non of growth,
but the conditions imply appropriate environment along
other lines. Growth, like development, has its optimum
environment, but this differs so much for different organisms,
that it is difficult to make general statements in regard
to the agencies that favour and those that hinder growing.
What is one organism's meat is another organism's poison.
In a general way, it might be said, light is essential for the
growth of plants, for the assimilatory process of building
up carbon compounds is a photo-synthesis dependent on
the sunlight. But when we look into the matter more
carefully we find that, other things being equal, plants
grow more rapidly during the night than during the day.
396 THE WONDER OF LIFE
The strongly refractive, so-called chemical rays, which
have little or no effect on assimilation, have an inhibiting
effect on growth. The growth of plants is also dependent
on humidity, the amount of oxygen, temperature, electrical
conditions, and other influences. The optimum tempera-
ture usually lies between 22 and 37 C., and there is a
complete cessation of growth in plants at a temperature
less than C. or higher than 40-50 C.
For animals the general statement may be made that
lowering the temperature puts a brake on growth. It does
so, in part, by retarding the process of cell-division, and
it does this, in part, by retarding the up-building of nuclein
compounds in the cells. Growth is much slower in polar
than in tropical seas, and the life-span is more drawn out.
For a developing chick, the temperature above which death
occurs is 43 C., the minimum at which growth stops is
about 28 C., the normal limits are between 35 and 39 C.
Some light on the difficult question of the limit of growth
may be obtained from a simple consideration in regard
to cell-growth, which seems to have been made independ-
ently by Herbert Spencer, Kudolf Leuckart, and Alex-
ander James. Cells may be defined as unit areas or cor-
puscles of living matter, and, as we have already noted,
the growth of multicellular organisms depends on the
growth and division of the component cells. A cell may
grow by taking up water, and by accumulation of the by-
products of metabolism, but essentially by having a surplus
in the continual recuperation of the living matter. Now,
if we start with a spherical cell and suppose it to grow
until it has quadrupled its original volume, it has by no
means quadrupled its surface, for the volume increases
as the cube of the radius, and the surface only as the square.
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 397
But as it is through its surface that the cell is fed, aerated,
and purified, functional difficulties are bound to set in as
the increase of surface lags behind the increase of volume.
There is four times as much material to be kept alive, but
there is not four times the surface by which to effect this.
A free-living cell, like an Amoeba, evades the functional
dilemma by flowing out into irregular processes, which
greatly increase the surface, making the cell like a country
with a much-indented coast-line. But what ordinarily
happens is that when the cell has reached its limit of growth,
the maximum safe size, it divides into two, halving its
volume and gaining new surface. As a general rationale,
applicable mutatis mutandis to organs and organisms as
well as to cells, the suggestion thus briefly outlined certainly
helps towards an understanding of the limit of growth.
Another important suggestion has been advanced by
Boveri and Richard Hertwig, that the limit of growth is
in part determined by the ratio of the amount of nuclear
material to the amount of cell- substance or cytoplasm.
When an animal grows larger this usually means that
its cells are multiplying, but it has been suggested (by
Plenk) that in lower animals of small size, such as Rotifers
and some Nematodes, an increase in the dimensions of the
cells plays an important part in growth. In the cells of
some animals with small eggs, such as lampreys and sala-
manders, there is some increase in the size of the elements,
and the same is true of very large cells in higher animals,
and of permanent elements like ganglion-cells, muscle-cells,
and lens-fibres, which lose their power of division at a very
early stage. On the whole, however, cell-multiplication
is the main factor in growth. The most characteristic
feature of a growing organism is that it is normally self-
398 THE WONDER OF LIFE
regulated. In the beautiful growth of a crystal in the
midst of its solution, there is some degree of regulation
in relation to the already existing architecture. Although
we may not understand much about it, we see that the
growth of the crystal is not higgledy-piggledy addition,
but an orderly and proportioned crystallization. But this
is far more deeply true of organic growth, which implies a
regulated series of phenomena, occurring in a certain
sequence and within certain limits. If the sequence be
disturbed or the limits be crossed, then there is something
abnormal. The regulation is comparable to that which
we see in the erection of a properly-designed building
there is a style and a plan to be adhered to, there are laws
of proportion to be respected, there is even a normal rate
which must not be disregarded. In the same way, the
regulation of organic growth has reference to the specific
constitution of the organism (its structural organization
on the one hand and its characteristic metabolism on the
other), and that means that it has reference to the past
history or evolution of the organism. This subtle quality
of regulatedness is one of the criteria of organic growth,
and it seems to many biologists to remove it far from the
mere multiplication of chemical substances, or from the
continued action of a ferment as long as material to ferment
is supplied.
One of the ways in which the regulation of growth is
brought about within the organism is by means of inter-
nal secretions or ' hormones '. These are produced by
glands or glandular tissues in various parts of the body,
and are passed into the blood. They are transported hither
and thither and, when they come into close quarters with
susceptible parts, they stimulate or hinder growth. Thus
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 399
it is well known that the internal secretions of the thyroid
gland which lies on each side of the larynx (or ' Adam's
apple'), and of the pituitary body (a remarkable organ
which is appended to the floor of the brain) have a specific
regulatory effect on the growth of the brain, the subcu-
taneous tissue, and the bones. It is said that a youth who
had been a successful candidate for a military post, but was
debarred because of inadequate height, was able by a
judicious use of pituitary extract (obtained from ox and
sheep) to add in a few months the peremptorily required
cubit to his stature. It has been shown that the internal
secretions of the reproductive organs in vertebrate animals
have a specific effect on the growth of various parts of the
body, both of important organs, like the milk-glands in
mammals, and trivial decorative structures, like the comb
in poultry. It seems certain that some, if not all, human
giants are the result of the exaggerated secretion of the
pituitary body, and it is possible that some kinds of dwarfs
are due to a deficiency of the same stimulus.
Even when we cannot at present suggest a physiological
interpretation, such as the influence of a specific secretion,
the fact of the regulation of growth must be recognized.
Different parts grow at very different rates, yet the normal
result is proportionate growth. In cases of under-feeding,
there is great diversity in the effect on different organs ;
they do not suffer alike. This points to a remarkable
internal regulation of growth. More familiar, and perhaps
simpler illustrations of the internal correlation may be
found in cases where an organ, such as the heart, responds
by increased growth to increased demands upon it.
Galls are often formed by plants in response to some
external stimulus, such as the salivary secretion of the larval
400 THE WONDER OF LIFE
gall-insect which has emerged from its egg-envelope de-
posited within the tissue of the leaf or stem. In these cases
we have very striking instances of specific secretions induc-
ing specific kinds of growth. These are extraneous
secretions introduced into the plant by an animal, but
we have also evidence of intrinsic secretions within the
plant which help to regulate growth. Thus it is said that
in the growth of the roots of some plants, specific chemical
substances are formed which inhibit further growth. In
short, facts are accumulating which show that particular
parts of an organism have their growth regulated by specific
internal secretions.
In his Principles of Biology Herbert Spencer devoted
much attention to the conditions of growth. He sought
to show that growth varies other things equal (1 ) directly
as nutrition, (2) directly as the surplus of nutritive income
over expenditure, (3) directly as the rate at which this
surplus increases or decreases, (4) directly (in organisms
of large expenditure) as the initial bulk, and (5) directly
as the degree of organization. This kind of analysis is
valuable, but what is more needed at present is an
extensive series of measurements of growth under diverse
conditions and in different kinds of organisms.
It is interesting to inquire into the periods and rates
of growth in different organisms. After an egg-cell has
been fertilized it divides and re-divides, but for a time,
though there is increase in the number of cells, there is
no increase in size. We see development, but no growth.
Soon, however, development and growth proceed hand in
hand, both very rapidly. Later on, when development is
proceeding slowly all the chief steps having been taken
growth may still continue very vigorously, Thus in the
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 401
pre-natal life of man, great strides in development are
taken in the first three months, along with very rapid
growth. Thereafter, when the developmental steps are
much less striking, the growth is for a time very rapid.
From the third to the fourth ante-natal month, the increase
is 600 per cent. After this it drops quickly and is barely
25 per cent, in the last month before birth.
In some organisms the growing period is very sharply
punctuated ; thus in insects with complete metamorphosis
all the growing is done in the larval period. After
the fully-formed winged insect emerges from the pupa-
stage, there is no increase in size. This holds good in all
butterflies and moths ; ants, bees, and wasps ; beetles;
and two-winged flies. In many cases the adult does not
feed at all, and there is the sharpest contrast between
the larva which feeds, grows, stores, and moults,
and the adult or imago which does not grow or moult,
but is especially concerned with the continuance of the race.
In other cases growth appears to have no limit but
the length of the life-tether. As long as the organism lives
and feeds it may go on growing. Thus we may distinguish
the indefinite or indeterminate growth of fishes and reptiles
from the definite or determinate growth of birds and
mammals. A sacred crocodile may continue slowly growing
year after year, and, it is said, decade after decade. It is
not uncommon to get huge haddocks as large as good-sized
cod-fish, but there is very little variation in the size of a
sparrow or of a squirrel. In other words, some organisms
show a very definite limit of growth the physiological
optimum while others do not.
An interesting feature about growth is the occurrence
of minor periodicities. Partly no doubt because of its
DD
4 02 THE WONDER OF LIFE
dependence on nutrition and on external agencies, growth
is often punctuated in some detail. Every one is familiar
with the annual rings of growth seen on the cross-section
of a tree seen so clearly because there is an alternation
of summer wood and autumn wood differing in texture.
The more prominent lines on the shell of the freshwater
mussel indicate years and the weaker lines between these
indicate minor periodicities. But the finest registering
is seen on the scales, in the ear-stones, and even in some
of the bones of many fishes.
Besides the periodicities of growth which can be reason-
ably correlated with external periodicities, such as those of
the seasons, there are others of a more recondite nature,
such as phases of quick growth and slow growth, that alter-
nate in the development of some animals, as Fischel has
shown, for instance, in the development of the duck. It is
probable that these differences of rate are connected with
the periodic liberation of internal secretions within the
growing organism.
The rate of growth has been carefully studied in a few
cases, e.g. in guinea-pigs by Minot, and the facts are
striking. In guinea-pigs there is in both sexes a decline
in the growth-rate almost from the moment of birth. The
decline of rate is rapid from about the fifth day to about
the fiftieth ; from the fiftieth day onwards the decline
is slower, until the growth stops altogether. Of course the
animal is growing a great deal, and very quickly too, in its
early days, but the rate of growth gets less and less. More-
over, the post-natal decline in the growth-rate appears to
be a continuation of an ante-natal decline. As Dr. Jenkin-
son puts it, ' The younger the animal, the faster it grows ;
the more developed it is, the more slowly it grows. The
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 403
rate of growth, in fact, varies inversely with the degree of
differentiation '.
In Man there are three maxima of rate of growth. The
first is before birth, but its precise occurrence is uncertain.
As we have already mentioned, the increment from the
third to the fourth month is 600 per cent. It then falls
with great rapidity between the fourth and sixth months,
and thereafter more slowly till birth. The second maxi-
mum is in the first year of infancy, when the increase of
weight is (according to Minot) about 200 per cent., and
the length (according to Schwerz) increases from 50 centi-
metres to about 75 centimetres. In the following five
or six years the rate of growth becomes slower and slower.
The third maximum is towards the time of puberty, at
about the age of twelve to thirteen for girls, of fourteen to
sixteen for boys. In the early years the length of the
body increases more rapidly than the weight ; later on,
after puberty, increase in weight takes the lead.
An interesting point in regard to growth is, that it
may differ markedly in the two sexes. The male is
often a pigmy compared with the female, though the egg-
cells from which they developed may have been identical
in size. The growth of women is quite different from
the growth of men, and as this has been observed in all
sorts and conditions, in many countries and races, it cannot
be referred to differences in habits. It is a constitutional
difference. It is not merely that the growth of women is
7 per cent, less than that of men ; the growth is on a different
scheme, with the parts in different proportions.
When we say that growth is a regulated increase in the
amount of living matter, we mean that it is not a steady
continuous increase in proportion to the available nutritive
404 THE WONDER OF LIFE
income, but a periodic controlled increase, differing in its
rate in different species and at different times, and proceeding
in such a way that what we call proportion is secured.
Professor Kellicott, in an important contribution to the
theory of growth, has emphasized the same idea by calling
attention to the diversity in the rate of growth of different
parts of the body.
In the smooth dogfish (Mustelus canis) the various organs,
or perhaps tissues, seem to grow characteristically, each
having an individual form of growth curve. The rates
of growth of the brain, the heart, the pancreas, the spleen,
and so on, are different from the rate of increase in total
weight. Indeed, it seems to Professor Kellicott that in
fishes, which are organisms of indeterminate growth, the
brain, heart, digestive glands, and fins do not always keep
pace with general increase of trunk musculature and connec-
tive tissue, and a loss of functional equilibrium results. The
fish may grow too large for its heart or for its brain. It
cannot be doubted that the determinate growth of birds
and mammals is an improvement on the more primitive
unlimited growth of fishes, which is less perfectly regulated.
When we consider growth in its entirety as a regulated
self -increase of the whole organism and of its parts, we
see how far it lies beyond the present limits of physico-
chemical interpretation. The analogous phenomena of
chemical polymerization and of the increase of crystals
in a solution are certainly interesting, but they do not
seem to have brought us more than a little way nearer
understanding organic growth. That an organism should
keep its own diary, entering therein its tradings with
time, is just a particular case of what is either a wonder or a
commonplace, that a living creature is characterized by this
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 405
capacity of enregistering within itself its experiences. In
many cases we do not know enough to read the diary ; in
many cases the creature destroys its own records in the
continuous process of self-repair or of replacement of old
cells by new. Here we feel the extraordinary importance
of the fact that in higher animals there is no replacement
of nerve-cells. We cannot add to them after we are born.
Young Animals. In his remarkable book on The
Childhood of Animals, which can hardly be over-praised,
Dr. Chalmers Mitchell suggests a threefold classification.
There are young animals which are in a general way like
miniature editions of the parents, or which, at any rate,
very soon become like their parents, as is the case with
reptiles, birds and mammals, and with a great variety of
backboneless animals, such as cuttlefishes, snails, spiders,
and earwigs. There is a distinct youthful period, with
interesting growth-changes, but young and old are of the
same type.
In the second place, there are animals whose young stages
are very unlike the parents, with a different kind of bodily
structure sometimes on a quite different plan and with
well-finished adaptations to a mode of life very different
from that of the adults. Tadpoles are very different from
frogs, and caterpillars from butterflies. The young of the
sedentary water-bag-like sea-squirts are free-swimming
creatures like miniature transparent tadpoles, and no one
who did not know could guess that the ' Glass-crab '
larva would become a rock-lobster. These larval forms
are of great biological interest, and their marked
unlikeness to their parents reaches a climax in most of the
Echinoderms (starfishes, brittle-stars, sea-urchins, sea-
cucumbers, and feather-stars), where the free-swimming
406 THE WONDER OF LIFE
pelagic stage is utterly different from the adult type.
After developing for a while on a line of its own, suited to
pelagic life, it begins again, as it were, on a new tack, and
the development is strikingly circuitous (Figs. 69, 70).
Many a young animal received a name of its own, before
zoologists recognized its beginning or its end. Thus the
knife-blade-like stage in the life-history of eels was called
Leptocephalus.
The third group, according to Chalmers Mitchell, includes
those animals which have no youth, and these he illustrates
by simple creatures like Amosbse. In such cases the unit
which starts on an individual life of its own is already
perfect ; it does not differ in protoplasmic organization
from the parent cell from which it was derived. We are
inclined to think that it would be equally accurate to
say that these simple creatures never grow up, remaining
eternally young. Ageing began when a body began.
When we think over our experiences of young animals,
a number of lasting impressions assert themselves. There
is the extraordinary abundance of life, the multitudes of
' water-babies ', like gnats and fish fry and tadpoles, and of
terrestrial forms, like grubs and caterpillars and mice ;
there is the correlated impression of the abundance of death,
out of a million oyster-embryos but one survives ; there
is the plasticity or modifiability of young things, the
experimental tricks that can be played with tadpoles, for
instance, being notorious. Another impression we get is,
that the young creature does often in some measure climb
up its own genealogical tree, for there is a great truth in the
seductive and much-abused doctrine of recapitulation.
Many reservations must be made, e.g. that the living
creature is specific, itself and nothing else from first to
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 407
last ; but especially in the making of organs do we see a
succession of individual stages which seem to correspond
to racial steps. The doctrine requires careful handling,
but we think that the facts still warrant us in upholding a
cautious statement of the 'Recapitulation Doctrine '-
that the individual development of an organism is in some
respects like a recapitulation, often much condensed and
telescoped, of the historical evolution of the race.
In our Biology of the Seasons we have referred to another
general impression which arises from the study of young
animals we are face to face with organic inertia on the
one hand and organic divergence on the other. On the
one hand, like tends to beget like ; ' the child is as old as
its parents, a chip of the old block, a pendant from a con-
tinuous chain of germ-cells '. On the other hand, we see
' the tendency to vary, to be something new, to be cre-
ative. The living creature is a Proteus. In a deep sense,
the little child leads the race '.
The old-fashionedness of young animals is often well
illustrated by their colour and markings. They tend to
show the primitive kind of colouration that results from
general physiological conditions, and the markings that
result from the rhythms of growth. This colouration
may be quite useful to the young animals, it often
seems to give them a garment of invisibility ; but it is
primarily a result of constitution, and no more utilitarian
than ripple-marks on the shore. Chalmers Mitchell shows
that if there are changes in subsequent development they
are usually of two kinds (1) there is a blurring of the
original pattern and a toning down of the youthful spotti-
ness and emphasis, for in the adult struggle for existence
there are few things safer than the monotony of ' self '-
408 THE WONDER OF LIFE
colour ; or (2) there is an overlaying of the old colouring
and pattern by something distinctively new, ' ruptive ', as
he calls it. The new types of colouration are increasingly
utilitarian and are proportionately defined by Natural
Selection. We say ' new ', but what occurs is probably
an analysis of the ' old ' ; certain factors come to the front
and others recede. Chalmers Mitchell uses the very
instructive analogy perhaps, as he hints, much more
of the dull coal-tar residues from which have been analysed-
out the ail-too vivid aniline dyes. In various passages,
somewhat neutralized (we think) by others, Darwin suggests
the view which many of his disciples hold (sometimes as if it
were their own), that the colours and patterns of animals
are outcrops of the dynamic constitution of the creature,
or by-products, it may be, of its activity ; but that what
happens and has happened in Nature's sifting may be
described as an elimination of the fatally exuberant or
conspicuous.
The Purpose of Youth. As we ascend the scale of
animal evolution, we find that one of the tendencies, most
notable in Mammals, is to lengthen out the duration of
youth. All sorts of devices and precautions conspire to
secure that the young animals remain longer young fed,
protected, freed from care and responsibilities, dowered
with energy, and given opportunity to play. We owe
to Groos, in particular, the idea that the play-period is the
educative period in the truest sense, and of fundamental
importance to the subsequent life.
We have discussed the matter recently in our Biology
of the Seasons.
' There are many play-instincts among animals ; they
have been wrought out in the course of ages, partly
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 409
as safety-valves for overflowing energy, partly as the
muscular correlates of emotion, partly as opportunities
for the emergence of variations before too rigorous selection
begins, but mainly as periods for educating powers which
are essential in after-life. Animals, Groos says, do not
simply play because they are young ; they continue young
in order that they may play. For play is the young form
of work, and the animals who played best when young,
worked best, lived best, perhaps loved best, when they
grew up '.
In his Childhood of Animals Dr. Chalmers Mitchell has
worked out the important thesis that the purpose of youth
is to give time for the breaking down of rigid instincts, and
their replacement by actions controlled by experience and
memory, by remembered results of experiment. We would
suggest that youth is the time when co-ordinations are
established between the instinctive processes of the lower
brain-centres and the intelligent processes of the cerebral
cortex.
It is plain that youth is a perilous time ; why should there
be this tendency to lengthen it out ? The answer is that
it is the time for self-expression. The number of brain-cells
does not increase, but their interlmkmgs are complexified,
which means a growth of intelligence and a deepening of
feeling. Thus has youth been justified in the past ; so it is
justified every day.
If Natural History is asked to give hints to the human
educationist and stranger things have happened one of
them will be this, as Chalmers Mitchell puts it :
' Youth should be spent in blunting [a term apt to be
misunderstood ?] every instinct, in awakening and stimu-
lating every curiosity, in the gayest roving, in the wildest
410 THE WONDER OF LIFE
experiment. The supreme duty of youth is to try all
things '.
Finally youth passes into adolescence. This is an arc
on the up-grade, when juvenile characters are shed and
adult characters put on. There is a final acceleration of
growth (with correlated rest and play, and plenty of food) ;
there is internal rearrangement and readjustment ; there
is a sifting of idiosyncrasies, to wit variations ; there is a
criticism of that acquired veneer which we call modifications
or individually acquired characters ; and there is more
than a beginning of sex-impulses.
Courtship among Animals. In the lower reaches
of the animal kingdom the process of reproduction is often
extraordinarily wasteful. Myriads of eggs are sown broad-
cast upon the waters, and millions of sperms are shed
fortuitously. Many fishes produce several millions of eggs,
and there is no counting spermatozoa. Mr. Oswald H.
Latter has given a vivid description of the discharge of
spermatozoa from the male freshwater mussel. It may
serve to illustrate the prodigal wealth of reproductive
material. A specimen of Unio pictorum emitted from the
exhalant aperture between the shell- valves a fine double
cloud of milky substance, which rose nearly to the surface
of the water, and then fell as a diffused cloud. The
whole of the water in the aquarium became cloudy
and the emission continued for some hours. It appeared
to be under some control, for a slight shaking of the floor
was followed by a cessation of the streams of spermatozoa,
though the ordinary exhalant current of water appeared
to continue without interruption. The liberated material
consisted of myriads of sperm-balls, revolving and swimming
like Vol vox-colonies, and finally breaking up into the
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 411
component spermatozoa. These exhibited astonishing
activity, and some kept it up below a cover-slip for seven
hours after liberation.
Many of the lower animals feed easily and have much
to spare, so that they can afford to be prolific. Moreover,
until the nervous system reaches a certain degree of integra-
tion, the sexes cannot be definitely aware of one another.
In Echinoderms, for instance, the absence of ganglia puts
definite sex-awareness out of the question. At many
different points, however, in the ascent of life we find
economization of reproductive material. An incipient case
is familiar in the salmon. The female fish makes a furrow
in the gravelly bed of the river and lays her eggs there.
The attendant male is stimulated by the presence of the
mature female and her eggs, and liberates the sperms or
milt along the furrow. There is still great loss, but it is
the beginning of an improvement upon the primitive and
wasteful broadcast semination of the waters.
Along various lines of animal evolution we find that the
males and females have become very definitely aware of
one another and are excited by one another. There is a
by-play of amatory behaviour preliminary to pairing, and
probably rendering the pairing more effective. A pervasive
excitement may change the creature's character and appear-
ance ; the whole being is sometimes, as it were, transfigured.
There is often a seeking out of the females by the ardent
males, and occasionally there is an appeal made to the
males by the females. The excited males fight with one
another, sometimes with almost maniacal ferocity, some-
times in a half-playful, bloodless jousting. Again, in a
fascinating variety of ways, the males make displays of
agility, of mettlesomeness, of beauty, of fragrance, of
4 i2 THE WONDER OF LIFE
musical talent, and so forth before the senses of their
desired mates.
Mr. W. P. Pycraft's recently published charming
volume on The Courtship of Animals gives an admirable
discussion of the whole subject, with a wealth of fresh in-
stances, and we shall not do more than recall a few pictures.
Stag fights with stag till they drip with blood ; the rival
FIG. 62. Male Spiders (Zygoballus) fighting. (After Prof, and Mrs.
Peckham.)
sea-lions slash with their great canines at one another's
necks, making long wounds, as the scars show for many a
day ; the cock capercailzies fight in the early spring and
the snow is spotted with their blood ; the blackcock's
tournaments at dawn are revelations of mingled passion
and pride ; the polygamous ruffs fight hour after hour with-
out wounds, and mingle their pugnacity with an extra-
ordinary self-abandonment ; male spiders have similarly
bloodless battles. When there is actual elimination of the
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 413
weak, the cowardly, the clumsy, the dull, and so on, so
that they are definitely unsuccessful or less successful in
reproduction, the combats of the males will probably have
some direct evolutionary influence, as Darwin confidently
believed. But there is great need for a stern sifting of the
data and an accumulation of more.
On the other side, there is the great variety of peaceful
FIG. 63. Male spider (Icius mitratus) dancing. (After Peckham.)
ways in which male animals give expression to their emotions
in the presence or proximity of their desired mates. Many
male spiders have a characteristic love-dance, differing
for different species, in which they appear to our eyes as
if they were showing off their good points. Some insects
have luminous love-signals, many offer up fragrant incense,
many give themselves up to energetic serenading if we
may so call it in our almost complete absence of knowledge
in regard to the sense of hearing in insects. Many birds
make elaborate displays, bending and bowing, strutting
and saluting, circling and fluttering ; and even a few of the
414 THE WONDER OF LIFE
cold-blooded fishes and newts have their love-play. Finest
and most familiar is the musical appeal of many birds.
Thousands of interesting facts are known as to visible
behaviour, but it is difficult to judge of the inward spirit.
We must not be recklessly generous, nor materialistically
sceptical. The whole life is one, and while we know that
internal secretions or hormones, liberated at the breeding
season and pervading the whole body, influence the brain
and the whole nervous system, and the circulation of the
blood and its composition, we are not on that account tc
suppose that the bird on the bough is emotionless, like a
musical box. We must not read too much into the displays,
for the suitors are, as it were, sex-intoxicated, expressing
their ardour instinctively and with abandon, rather than
with deliberation or strategy, but we must not think of
them too cheaply, as if they expressed lust only, and no
love.
As to the evolutionary importance of the courtship
behaviour, there is need at present for a critical revision of
the data. The late Alfred Russel Wallace always insisted,
thus differing from Darwin, that there was little convincing
evidence that the female bird chooses her partner, or chooses
him because of any particular excellence in colour or
plumage, agility or musical talent ; but some good ornithol-
ogists bring forward circumstantial cases of unattractive
male birds being left unmated. More facts are needed.
While Darwin seemed sometimes to credit the females with
a high degree of taste or aesthetic fastidiousness, he was
probably on safer ground when he wrote : ' It is not probable
that she consciously deliberates ; but she is most excited
or attracted by the most beautiful or melodious or gallant
males '. The probability is that the female surrenders
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 415
herself, not to a male selected because of some particular
excellence, but to the fortunate fellow whose ensemble most
successfully excites her sexual interest. Now, if this be so,
and if a number of uninteresting males are definitely
unsuccessful or less successful in reproduction, there will be,
in some measure, a denning of the path of evolution. There
will be not only a toleration, but a favouring of beauty ;
there will be at least a handicapping of dullness.
Looking over a treasury of illustrations, such as Mr.
Pycraft's Courtship of Animals contains, we cannot but
ask what the deep significance of the whole elaborate system
of behaviour may be, for it is not enough to say that it is
simply an overflow of vital energy and joie de vivre. The
persistence of a race depends on the success with which it
continues its kind, and the sex-impulse with its urge has
made reproduction a certainty. The instinctive behaviour
of courtship has added to the force and subtlety of the
overmastering internal sex-impulse. Indeed, as Emerson
said, the sex-impulse is imperious so that reproduction
may be ensured. As a matter of fact, we should turn the
idea round a little, and say that those types have survived
in which the sex-impulse was strong ; but it comes to the
same thing. Groos has pointed out that coyness on the
female's part is a character of considerable racial value,
and the courtship allows of coyness because the fittest males
succeed in overcoming it. Our general conclusion is that
the deep significance of courtship-behaviour is that it
makes pairing more effective.
IN ILLUSTRATION.
Sea Lions. In Spring a few old male sea-lions make
their appearance at the Pribylov Islands and swim about
416 THE WONDER OF LIFE
for several days, prospecting. They examine the ' rookery '
and go off to sea again, returning in reinforced numbers.
Each male chooses a spot some thirty yards square for
his future harem, and jealously guards it against intruders.
About two months later the females, who are not nearly so
large as the males, appear on the scene, and there is great
competition for them, each ' polygamous sultan ' trying
to secure from fifteen to twenty wives. Accounts differ a
good deal as to the degree of ' give and take ' among rival
males. The cubs are born a few days after the arrival of the
mothers, and seem to require a good deal of education.
Soon after the birth of the young, Professor D'Arcy
Thompson tells us, ' the comparative quiet of the rookery
is exchanged for a babel of noise and incessant quarrelling.'
The old males try to add to the score or so of wives they
have apiece ; the wifeless younger males try to secure
mates ; there are great fights among rival bullies. ' So
all day long the noise of battle rolls along the beaches
by the wintry sea, and the growling and the snarling,
the confusion and the din, are for some weeks together
indescribable '. The younger males, or bachelors, herd apart
from the others, and both they and the married females
go down to the sea to feed. It is noteworthy, on the
other hand, that ' the old males starve rather than leave
their posts ; they come fat and vigorous in springtime,
and are gaunt, emaciated, and scarred with the scars of
many battles before they leave again in autumn '.
Fragrance. In many butterflies, such as the green-
veined white (Ganoris napi), the males have a distinct
flowery perfume, which is associated with remarkable
' plume scales ' on the upper surface of the wings. It is
readily perceptible if we rub the wings with a camel-hair
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 417
brush. Similar perfumes, almost always flower-like, are
well known in relatives of the common whites, and they are
almost invariably confined to the males and to the upper
surface of the wings. The cells that produce the scent
which may be of the nature of a volatile oil seem to lie
in the skin (or hypodermis) below the surface-membrane
of the wing, and the ' plume scales ' are only distributors.
There can be little doubt that Fritz Miiller's suggestion
is correct, that the pleasant flower-like scents are useful to
the males in their courtship of the females, as auxiliary
means of attraction. It may also be that they help mem-
bers of the same species to recognize one another, for the
perfumes are often exceedingly distinctive or specific.
As to the repulsive scents, there is definite evidence that
they help to protect their possessors from insect-eating
enemies.
Fire -Flies. We have already referred to the court-
ship of the Italian Fire-fly. The female, sitting among
the grass, signals to passing males, who respond and
settle down around her in a devoted circle. Flashes
of light pass from the suitors to the object of their desire,
and from her to them, till the fire is sufficiently fanned,
a pairing takes place, and the party breaks up. Not less
refined is the approach that some male spiders make to
their somewhat explosive mates vibrating with one of
their appendages one of the threads of the web on which
the exquisitely sensitive spinner sits.
Audible Signals. Dr. Karl Peters has given us a very
interesting picture of love-signalling on the part of an
Alpine moth (Endrosa or Setina aurita, var. ramosa), which
he studied at Arolla. The males fly about actively, but
the females are sluggish and rest for the most part on
418 THE WONDER OF LIFE
tussocks of grass, where they are very inconspicuous. The
males are able to produce a crackling or snapping sound,
and it seems as if the females responded to this signal by
vibrations of their body and wings. When the males
fly overhead or settle down in the vicinity, the females
make themselves more conspicuous by their tremulous
movements, which appear to attract the male's attention.
When the sound stops, the answering movement stops.
Even when the female cannot see the male, she answers
back when the sound begins. It seems, then, as if the male's
signal appealed to a hearing organ and the female's signal
to sight. Dr. Peters's observations are of great interest,
because the experiments that have been made to test the
auditory powers of insects have been very unsatisfactory.
It is difficult to believe that the instrumental music of
Cicadas and crickets falls on deaf ears, but the experiments
testing this are inconclusive. Insects that have been
credited with the power of hearing remain quite indifferent
to a great variety of sounds, but it is possible that the
experiments fail because the sounds used as tests have
been meaningless and therefore quite uninteresting to the
insects. More observations like those of Dr. Peters are
much to be desired.
Puzzles of Behaviour. The Praying Mantis, or Prego-
Dieu of the Proven9als, is a ferocious Carnivore in a vege-
tarian order (Orthoptera), and feeds exclusively on living
victims, such as crickets, which it seizes by the back of the
neck. Fabre has shown that in comfortable captivity,
with abundant food, the mature females fight fiercely
and devour one another. The males likewise, smaller
and more delicate than the females, are often devoured
by their mates, after having had their addresses accepted.
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 419
' In the course of two weeks,' Fabre writes, ' I have seen
the same Mantis treat seven husbands in this fashion.
She admitted all to her embraces, and all paid for the
nuptial ecstasy with their lives '. But we must remember
that these same female Mantises make a beautiful and
elaborate cradle for the eggs, beating up a somewhat silken
secretion into a spongy foam which hardens in the
air.
The same mysterious ' post-matrimonial cannibalism ' is
illustrated by some scorpions and spiders, by some crickets,
and by the so-called ' golden ' Scarabee beetle. It must
be remembered, however, that most of the records relate
to creatures in captivity. Fabre relates in regard to the
' golden Scarabaeus,' which does such good work in destroy-
ing caterpillars that creep on the ground, such as the pro-
cession caterpillar, that between the middle of June and
the first of August, twenty-five comfortably- cased Scarabees
were reduced to five all females. He saw one of the
females devouring a male, and he found that all the corpses
of the males had been eviscerated. The fact that the
males did not seem to resist, suggests that they may be
naturally moribund after mating.
Parental Care and the Family. In many animals,
from worm to frog, the mother discharges a large number
of eggs, and leaves them to develop. Sometimes,
indeed, as in some marine worms and in many butterflies
and moths, she dies soon after reproduction. Even in
strong animals like lampreys and eels, death seems to
follow like a nemesis close on the heels of reproduction.
It must be admitted that the liberation of huge numbers
of ova sown broadcast in the waters is a wasteful pro-
cess. There is great mortality and many of the eggs are
420 THE WONDER OF LIFE
not even fertilized. The race is continued because there
are so many.
One must never think of Nature as deliberating and
deciding to replace a wasteful process by a more economical
one, nor yet as simply drawing her bow at a venture and
in the course of time hitting a mark. What goes on is
a ceaseless experimenting in different modes of self-
expression. Less prolific forms arose, and those that in-
stinctively took some care of eggs or offspring tended to
define the direction of evolution. Sometimes, on the other
hand, more careful types arose resting exhausted beside
their mass of eggs, and by and by incubating them and
those that were more economical in productivity would
tend to define the direction of evolution. The process
may have worked either way.
A number of suggestions may be offered. (1) The
passage from aquatic to terrestrial life is associated with
internal fertilization and with the suppression of larval
stages (see Chapter II), and it follows that the mother
animals would come to have a longer organic acquaintance
with their ova. The bird laying her eggs is much more
aware of what she is doing than the fish in the sea. (2)
In certain conditions, such as the low temperature of the
abysses or of polar seas, growth processes are slowed. This
might lead to a longer retention of the ova within the body,
and to viviparity. It is very significant that in Antarctic
Echinoderms, for instance, there is a general, though not
complete suppression of free-swimming larval stages, and
many cases are known of parental care, differing curiously
in details. (3) As is usual, when we face such problems,
we find that there are many approaches to parental care
and family life. The goal was probably reached very
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 421
gradually and by various routes. Thus we see a beginning
in those cases in which the mother lays her eggs, instead
of merely liberating them. The female salmon lays eggs
in a furrow which she makes in the gravelly bed of the
stream. We see a beginning in those cases in which the
mother carries her eggs about with her after she has liberated
FIG. 64. Female Spider Dolomedes mirabilis carrying underneath
her body, attached by silk threads, the silken cocoon containing
the eggs and eventually the young spiders. (After Blackwall.)
them. Many a spider has a silken cocoon which she bears
about with her until the spiderlings hatch. We see a
beginning in the retention of the eggs, not only until they
become larvae, but until particular circumstances arise.
Thus the freshwater mussel, which we have discussed,
keeps its Grlochidia in its gill-cradle until a minnow or
the like comes conveniently into the vicinity. We see
a beginning in the way many an animal mother allows her
young ones to clamber about her body, holding on to her
and being protected by her. The generalization may be
422
THE WONDER OF LIFE
ventured, that the maternal care is in certain respects like
an external continuation of the internal organic linkage.
Paternal Care. Some of the backboneless animals
which show parental care are hermaphrodites. This is
true of the brook-leech (Clepsine), which carries about its
young ones on the under surface of its body. In other
cases, both of high and low degree, the parental care is
FIG. 65. Sea Horses, Hippocampus. The upper row shows the success-
ive positions of the body in swimming. The body bends forwards
and straightens again. The lower row shows the fishes at rest. ( After
Anthony and Chevroton.)
exhibited by the males. We find this among those inter-
esting animals, of uncertain zoological position, known as
sea-spiders or Pycnogonids, where the males carry the eggs
attached to two of their legs. We find it in several fishes,
such as the stickleback, who makes and guards the nest
among the sea- weed, or the sea-horse (Hippocampus), who
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 423
carries the eggs about in his breast-pocket. The same
is true of some pipe-fishes (Syngnathus).
Somewhat like the stickleback's nest, but made by the
female, is that of the kelp-fish (Heterotrichus rostrata) of
the South Carolina kelp-beds. Mr. C. H. Holder observed a
female in captivity, and saw her push her way through and
round a bunch of seaweed, depositing a white viscid cord,
which clung to the fronds, and bore numerous minute white
eggs. The male, who is brilliantly coloured at the breeding-
season, like the kelp and like his mate at other seasons,
mounted guard over the ' nest ', while the female rested.
The whole process took a couple of hours, and the result
was a globular white mass about the size of a hen's egg.
Of the sculpin (Myoxocephalus scorpius), a common shore-
fish of northern seas, Dr. Theodore Gill relates that the
male may make a rough nest of seaweeds and pebbles for
the reception of the spawn, and that he mounts guard over
the mass of eggs, clasping it with its fins for a long time.
In the case of Arius fissus, a shore fish from French Guiana,
about twenty eggs ripen at one time. When these are laid,
the male takes them into his mouth, where they remain
until after hatching, until, in fact, the yolk sac is absorbed.
During the whole of this incubation period the father fish
is condemned to fast, so that we have a somewhat whimsical
instance of that antithesis between nutrition and repro-
duction which echoes through life.
Among Amphibians there are many cases parallel to
those which occur among fishes. Thus the male nurse-
frog (Alytes), not uncommon in some parts of the Continent,
carries the strings of ova on his back and about his hind
legs, buries himself in the damp earth until the development
of the embryos is approaching completion, then plunges
424
THE WONDER OF LIFE
into a pool, where he is freed from his living burden. In
the case of the Surinam toad (Pipa), the male is said to
help the female in placing the eggs upon her back, where
each sinks into a little skin pocket, in which it develops
without passing through a tadpole stage. In Nototrema
the female has a dorsal pouch opening backwards, and into
this the male pushes the eggs with his hind legs. In a
little South American frog, Darwin's Rhinoderma, the
male carries the (5-15) ova in his croaking-sacs, which
become enormously enlarged in the course of their develop-
ment. Eventually miniature frogs jump out of the father's
mouth ! In a number of birds the incubation is shared
by both sexes ; in the American ostrich (Rhea) it is said
to be wholly discharged by the male.
When we see the male lumpsucker or cock-pa idle
(Cyclopterus) mounting guard over the mass of eggs in
the rock-pool, and keeping them clean and aerated by
frequent agitations of the water, and continuing at this
FIG. 66.'
The Lumpsucker (Cydopterua lumpus). From a specimen.
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 425
task for many days, we are undoubtedly face to face with
parental care, and we are surprised that it should be pater-
nal. Two suggestions may be offered: (1) that just as
maternal care, in certain of its expressions, may be thought
of as a sort of prolongation of viviparity, so paternal care
may be organically associated with sex-instincts ; and
(2) that just as we find a female reindeer always with
antlers and the female Red-necked Phalarope with mascu-
line colouring and ways, so parental instincts which usually
develop only in the females may, to suit particular needs,
be grafted on to the males.
There is not much parental care among Gasteropods,
but there are often very remarkable egg-cases in which the
early stages of development are passed. We may refer in
illustration to the American Slipper Limpet (Crepidula
fornicata), which has spread rapidly since 1880 on British
oyster grounds. It takes special care of its spawn, as
Mr. Orton has told us.
' It constructs about fifty to sixty membranous bags,
into each of which it passes about two hundred and fifty
eggs, and as the bags are made and filled with eggs, they
are closed and fastened together by short cords. These
cords are finally all stuck on to the surface on which the
slipper-limpet happens to be sitting, so that when by taking
away the spawning individual the spawn is uncovered, it
looks like a bundle of balloons, each containing a number
of
Fabre has described in his inimitable manner the be-
haviour of a Hymenopterous insect, the Bee-hunter
(Philanthus apivorus), which pursues the hive-bee. It
always stings the bee on a minute soft patch in the
throat, which leads the sting into the cervical ganglia,
426 THE WONDER OF LIFE
' abolishing life at a single blow '. There is a much larger
soft area further back, but that is not utilized. It is a
knock-out blow under the chin that is delivered. Clasping
its dead victim firmly, the Philanthus squeezes out the
honey from the stomach, and does so repeatedly till every
drop is enjoyed. The fresh corpse of the bee is then given
by the Philanthus to her grubs, to whom the honey is
noxious !
In many insects the mothers exert themselves unsparingly
to provide stores of food for the young, but participation
on the father's part is very rare. Among the dung-rolling
beetles there are exceptions such as the Sisyphus, the
males and females of which work together in kneading a
pill of dung and transporting it, over great difficulties, to
the underground burrow where the eggs are laid. In the
case of the scarabee, Fabre tells us that while the sexes
co-operate in rolling balls of dung for their own consumption,
the female is left to do all the work of moulding the ball
and transporting it when it is for the use of the future
brood.
In non-social as well as social insects, parental care is
sometimes exhibited. The quaint mole-crickets (Gryllo-
talpa) move their eggs in their underground nests according
to the weather, and guard them sedulously against black-
beetles and the like. The earwig sits on her eggs, and older
writers have described what some who have recently
watched earwigs carefully have failed to confirm, that the
mother-insect gathers her young under her as a hen her
chickens. In spite of Fabre's criticism, it seems likely
that De Geer was accurate in his description of the mother
birch-bug brooding over her eggs and young.
F. P. Dodd describes the brooding habits of one of the
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 427
bugs, Tectocoris lineola, var. banksi. The mother sits in a
brooding attitude over her eggs for three weeks, until the
young are hatched out. She does not have anything to
eat during these weeks. When the young begin to break
through the egg-shells, the mother backs away for an
inch or so from off the egg-mass, and remains there for
some hours, long after the last egg is hatched. She then
departs, leaving the young bugs, whom she has perhaps
saved from Ichneumon flies, to fend for themselves.
It is among birds and insects that we find the highest
development of parental care, but what a contrast there is
between the two expressions. Among insects the prepara-
tions that are made for the young are for the most part
instinctive, and the mother is often without the satisfaction
of even seeing her offspring for she is dead before her eggs
are hatched. Among birds, while instinctive behaviour
continues, it is associated with much more intelligence,
and the preparation of nest-making is followed up by the
patience of brooding, and that again by often prolonged
nurture, and even education. Many birds are careful in
turning their eggs and in keeping the nest clean after the
young ones are hatched. Of the nests of birds, what shall
we say? so many of them express a climax of art (both
intelligent and instinctive) on the one hand and of instinc-
tive altruism on the other. For artistic quality, take the
nest of the wren, of the thrush, of the chaffinch, of the
house-martin, of the bottle titmouse, of the tailor-birds,
and of the weaver-birds. Or consider the single case of
the sea-swift, which achieves the impossible by fashioning
a firm nest out of the juice of its mouth. For altruistic
quality, take MacGillivray's fact that he got 2,379 feathers
out of the nest of the long-tailed tit, or the burrowing of
428
THE WONDER OF LIFE
the sand-martin an activity so alien to a bird's nature
or the labour of several months that is spent in building,
pellet by pellet, the strong two-chambered mud-nest of
the S. American oven-bird an architectural masterpiece
that may be as big as a child's head.
The brooding must imply
a good deal of a quality
allied to patience, and in
many cases not a little of
a quality allied to courage
when an enemy comes
nosing all round about the
nest. The shy curlew has
been known to allow a
photographer to bring a
large camera within ten
feet of her nest without
betraying herself by the
slightest movement. In
some cases, e.g. of great
heat, the brooding bird
. appears to suffer consider-
ably, and perhaps this has
FIG. 67. An Emperor Penguin,
Aptenodytes forsteri, with
the young one on her feet.
(After Wilson.)
something to do with the
fact that birds almost always
nest in the coldest part of
their migratory range. The
bird has to do all this, but the same may be said of much
of the parental care which all the world admires in the
human mother it is instinctive. In Man there is
probably greater possibility of disobedience and there is
a fuller awareness of what it all means.
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 429
After brooding there is the labour of feeding the young,
which often taxes to the utmost the energies of both parents.
Miles away from the Bird-Berg, where tens of thousands of
guillemots lay their eggs on the ledges of the cliffs, there
is a ' bank ' where sand-eels abound, and it is interesting
to lie in a boat and see the constant double stream of birds
passing overhead, all those returning to the cliffs having
a glistening fish in their mouth. We do not know which
most to wonder at, the appetite of the youngsters, the
indefatigableness of the parents, or the supply of sand-
eels.
We have already referred to the story of the hornbill.
The mother-bird nests in a hole in a tree, and is
imprisoned by a doorway of resinous material, big
enough to let the male bird's bill in , but small enough
to keep enemies out. On the male devolves the task
of procuring food for his immured mate, and afterwards
for his offspring also. After three weeks of it, he is often
worn quite thin, and sometimes he actually succumbs to
his other-regarding exertions before he is rejoined by
the female bird. He has to do it and it is said that an
unrelated male will attend to a widowed bird so
that we may not be warranted in using big words like
altruism in appreciating his behaviour. But no amount
of scrupulosity can disguise the fact that his expenditure
of energy is not for himself.
After the labour of feeding, comes the fine art of
education, for the young bird has always a great deal
to learn. Experiments in artificial incubation have shown
conclusively that the young bird is not rich in inborn
knowledge. The chick artificially hatched, with the aid of
an inanimate foster-mother, has no instinctive recognition
430 THE WONDER OF LIFE
of its actual mother's cluck. Even when thirsty it does
not recognize water as drinkable stuff, not even when it
walks through it. So unprejudiced is its tabula rasa of a
brain, that it will stuff its crop with worms of red worsted.
But the point is that it makes up for its paucity of instincts
by an extraordinarily rapid educability. And that is
what the parent-birds work with in educating their young
in the ordinary conditions of wild nature.
As all Mammals except the primitive Monotremes are
viviparous, their exhibition of parental care is perhaps not
so striking as in the nest-building and brooding birds, but
it often reaches a high level. We have to remember the
often prolonged gestation the mother carrying, as it were,
a huge parasite within herself, the suckling of the young,
and it may be carrying them about, as in Marsupials and
Bats, the defence of the family, and their initiation into
the business of life. Some Mammals, such as monkeys,
have a prolonged infancy and a long gastric education on
milk ; others are quickly able to look after themselves.
We read that a giraffe is able to stand up in about twenty
minutes after birth, to run freely in a day or two, and to
nibble grass in three weeks.
Chain of Parental Instincts. There are many unsolved
problems connected with parental care, but we think that
Professor F. H. Herrick has made many points clearer by his
conception of a chain or cycle of parental instincts, to
which we have already referred in connection with the
cuckoo (p. 320). The events in the cycle follow one
another with almost clock-like precision, but are always
liable to be influenced by intelligence. Normally they
form a harmonious series, and, what is very important,
there is an attunement a time-keeping between the
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 431
instincts of the parents and those of the offspring. In-
dividual disturbances of the harmony or attunement are
continually occurring, and are often misinterpreted as
insoluble puzzles. In the cuckoos and cow-birds a remark-
able change in instincts has been evolved as a modus
vivendi to meet a disturbance of the time-keeping.
We give a shortened statement of Herrick's analysis of
the reproductive cycle.
1. The spring migration to the breeding area or birth-
place.
2. Courtship and mating, often attended by song and
dance, especially in the male.
3. Nest-building : (a) selecting a site or using an old
one ; (6) building the nest or adapting an old one.
4. Egg-laying, usually at daily intervals in the completed
nest. As in (3), this is often attended by instincts of
guarding, fighting and concealment.
5. Incubation or brooding instinct ; attended as before
by instincts of guarding, fighting and concealment ; often,
as it proceeds, allaying all fear ; including a variety of
instinctive acts, sometimes recurrent, as removal of eggs
in bill, inspection of eggs, stirring of eggs with bill or feet,
cleaning nest by removal of broken eggs or shells, shielding
eggs from heat or cold, and sometimes hiding them with
covering of wings.
PAKENT. YOUNG.
6. Care of the young Initial responses at and
collecting food ; feeding the after hatching ; swallowing
young ; inspecting the nest reflexes ; call notes, and
and nestlings ; cleaning later alarm notes ; burrow-
both etc. ing under old bird; etc.
432 THE WONDER OF LIFE
7. Care and ' education ' Flight, fear, seeking prey,
of young, guarding, fighting giving call and alarm notes ;
for, feeding, encouraging, following, crouching, hiding ;
teaching, etc. imitating.
8. Autumn migration to Migration with adults or
winter quarters singly, or independently.
in company with individuals
of the same or of different
species.
Retrospect. In the lower reaches of the animal king-
dom there is prolific multiplication and great mortality ;
or, from another point of view, a life full of hazards and
high reproductivity to cope with these. It has been one
of the great steps in evolution to economize life, and one of
the most successful ways of doing this has been by parental
care, of which affection is a consequence. As Chalmers
Mitchell expresses it : ' The mere toleration of the young
by the mother is a new beginning in life, and is the foun-
dation of many of the highest qualities displayed by the
highest animals and by man himself '. . . . The relations
of the young to the mother ' are a continuation of the
organic relation by which the young are born of the body
of their mother, and they exist and become, so to speak,
a habit, before the individuality, the physical powers, and
the senses and aptitudes of the young are really awakened '.
. . . Later on we have, of course, affection as well as
care ; and families lead on to societies.
The Individual and the Race. When we study the
modes of multiplication, or the instinctive provision made
for the young, or the more deliberate parental care of higher
animals, we cannot but be struck by the fact that what is
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 433
done is often very far from advantageous to the individual.
It is advantageous, indeed essential, for the species, but
it is exhausting, sometimes fatal, to the single life. As
Goethe said, Nature ' cares nothing for individuals '.
Animals do not indeed foresee that their reproduction
is going to be fatal to them ; the instinctive mother-insect
does not know that she will never see her offspring emerge
from the eggs around which she places a store of laboriously
collected food ; we have no reason to believe that she has
any picture of offspring ; when animals are fatigued,
as their brain-cells show them to be, they probably suffer
no weariness, and they are doubtless unquestioning ; they
are borne on by impulses and instincts which are as com-
pelling as hunger and thirst. But the point is that these
strong instincts bear them to expenditures of energy which
are not self-preservative, but objectively other-regarding.
In some cases, it is true, there is the reward of reproductive
gratification, and Emerson was, we believe, profoundly
right when he suggested that the imperiousness of sex
desire was necessary in order to make organisms (especially
the higher animals) face reproduction. But the reward
of sex- gratification only applies to a limited set of cases,
and even for it many animals have to pay heavily. As
Goethe said : ' She holds a couple of draughts from the cup
of love to be fair payment for the pains of a lifetime '.
We are brought, then, to face the great fact of Organic
Nature, that those forms of life tend to survive in which
the individual has been more or less subordinated to the
welfare of the species. Metaphorically, that is part of
Nature's strategy. Literally, the prolific species-preserving
types have survived.
Reproduction is physiologically expensive. The sturgeon ,
FF
434 THE WONDER OF LIFE
whose unlaid eggs form the delicacy known as caviare,
liberates more than a million. There may be 100,000 sperma-
tozoa in a cubic millimetre. Many female butterflies die
after oviposition, and the same is true even of robust
animals like lampreys. The drone who succeeds in fertilizing
the queen hive-bee dies as he succeeds ; all the others, who
are unsuccessful, also die. A male spider often lays his life
on the altar of sex, and the same is true of some scorpions.
Viviparity is costly to the female, especially in Mammals ;
parturition is often exhausting ; feeding the young is a
drain on the mother's resources.
In a very interesting essay, ISEspece el son serviteur
(Paris, 1913), Professor Cresson has illustrated the degree
to which the individual is subordinated to the welfare of
the species. Apart from the physiological sacrifice alluded
to, there is the energy expended in securing the safety of
the eggs, and in providing nourishment for the young.
In many insects, such as sand-wasps and scarabees, the
amount of work done for the welfare of the progeny is very
great. The non-existent offspring act, Cresson somewhat
fancifully suggests, as ' moral parasites ' on their parents.
There is fatigue in nest-making, risk in incubation,
and both in attending to the nourishment, health, and
education of the young. Especially the mothers are, so to
speak, exploited, Nature taking advantage of their capacity
for self-forgetfulness. Less metaphorically, it is their
meat and drink to spend themselves for the race. In the
case of social insects, the subordination of the single life
is extraordinary, sometimes almost pathological. Cresson,
indeed, suggests the formula, ' Everything for the species ;
everything by the individual ; nothing for the individual '.
Ageing and Senescence. In most animals, as we
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 435
have seen, there is a definite limit of growth, which we
regard as the fittest size for the given organization and
the given conditions of life. Departures from the norm
have been persistently pruned off in the course of Natural
Selection. Similarly in many animals there is a normal
length of life (a potential duration of life) which is rarely
exceeded, though it may be seldom attained. Many of the
facts in regard to unusual length of life refer to animals
in captivity, and it is quite likely that a creature may
survive longer in a sheltered life than when it is subject to
the struggle for existence. On the other hand, the dura-
tion of life in captivity can hardly lead us to over-estimate
the potential duration of life in nature, since the artificial
conditions are bound to be less wholesome. The facts in
regard to captive animals tell us that the creatures can
live to such and such an age ; but this may be far above
their average length of lif e. It is very unlikely that many
wild parrots approach the century which is their potential
longevity. In the case of domestic animals, few fowls are
allowed to survive for five years, though they might live
for a score ; few cattle are allowed to reach the end of
their tether, which is about thirty; and just the same
applies to the average length of life in Nature, since most
wild animals come to a violent end.
Dr. Chalmers Mitchell's critical revision of the data
available in regard to the duration of life in mammals
and birds goes to show that most of the previous estimates
have been too high. Though a hundred years may be the
probable limit for the elephant, twenty to thirty years is a
fair average duration. A polar bear lived to thirty -three
years in the Zoo. The potential longevity of lions is between
thirty and forty years ; that of some of the largest Ungu-
436 THE WONDER OF LIFE
lates about fifty. It is rather interesting that human
longevity is probably greatest of all among mammals,
with the possible exception of the large whales.
As regards birds, more than one centenarian parrot has
been recorded, and the same age is credited to some birds
of prey. A raven of sixty-nine is authenticated, and an
eagle of sixty-eight. Herons, swans, and geese have a high
potential longevity, and an ostrich is said to be capable of
occasionally surviving for a term of thirty-five years.
A giant tortoise (Testudo gigantea) that was living near
Colombo in 1796, when Ceylon was first occupied by the
British, survived until 1894, so that it must have been more
than a centenarian.
In the case of Man, we must clearly distinguish between
the average specific longevity, about thirty-four years in
Europe but happily raisable with decreasing infantile
mortality, improved sanitation, decreasing warfare, increas-
ing temperance and carefulness and the potential specific
longevity, which for the present race is normally between
seventy and one hundred years. There is no warrant for fix-
ing an ultimate limit, either for the past or the future. All
that we can scientifically say, is that there are few well-
established instances of a greater human longevity than
104 years. Sir George Cornewall Lewis did good service
(1862) in destructively criticizing numerous alleged cases of
centenarianism, the occurrence of which he at first regarded
as quite unproved, but even he finally admitted that men
do sometimes reach a hundred years, and that some have
reached one hundred and three or four. The famous
cases of Thomas Parr, Henry Jenkins, and the Countess
of Desmond, said to be 152, 169, and 140 respectively, were
ruled out of court by Mr. Thorns, who edited Notes and
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 437
Queries at the time when Sir G. C. Lewis's wholesome
scepticism created much stir. As man is a slowly varying
organism, as regards physical characters at least, it is
extremely unlikely that his longevity was ever much greater
than it is now. Monsters in age and monsters in size are
alike incredible.
A fact of much interest is the statistical evidence
that such a subtle character as ' longevity ', that is to
say, a tendency to a certain lease of life, be it long or short,
is heritable like other inborn characters, though it rests
of course to some extent with the individual or his environ-
ment to determine whether the inherited tendency is
realized or not. Just as stature is a heritable quality, so is
potential longevity, but the degree of expression is in part
determined by ' nurture ' in the widest sense.
Professor E. MetchnikofE is one of the few modern biolo-
gists who would deal generously with biblical and other old
records of great human longevity. He apparently thinks
there has been some misunderstanding in regard to Methu-
saleh's 969 years or Noah's 595, but he accepts the great
ages of 175, 180, and 147 years ascribed to Abraham, Isaac,
and Jacob. Similarly, he accepts the 185 years with which
St. Mungo of Glasgow has been credited. And as he is
generous in regard to the past, he is hopeful in regard to the
future, believing that a more careful and temperate life,
as well as an enlightened recognition of the disharmonies of
our bodily frame, may bring about a time when man will
no longer, as Buffon said, die of disappointment, but
attain everywhere a hundred years. ' Humanity ',
Metchnikoff says, ' would make a great stride towards
longevity could it put an end to syphilis, which is the cause
of one-fifth of the cases of arterial sclerosis. The sup-
438 THE WONDER OF LIFE
pression of alcoholism, the second great factor in the pro-
duction of senile degeneration of the arteries, will produce
a still more marked extension of the term of life. Scien-
tific study of old age and of the means of modifying its
pathological character will make life longer and happier '.
He also quotes the theoretically simple conclusion of Pfliiger 's
essay on The Art of Prolonging Human Life ' Avoid the
things that are haimful and be moderate in all things '.
Attempts have often been made to correlate the duration
of an animal's life with its structural or functional character-
istics, and up to a certain point this way of looking at it is
useful. For the living creature is a consistent unity, and
its length of life must be correlated with its whole being.
It is evident that a very large animal will not be a very
short-lived animal, but the difficulty is that animals equal
in size are often very far from equal in length of life. It is
natural that a relatively easy-going animal like a sea-anemone
should be able to survive very much longer than an intensely
living insect, but the difficulty is that equally active insects
may differ greatly in their length of life. In his famous
essay On the Duration of Life (1881) Weismann considered
the various attempts to correlate length of life with size,
with intensity of life, with the duration of the growing
period, and so on, but found that none of the correlations
could be generalized. He was led to the conclusion that
length of life, like size, is an adaptive character gradually
defined in relation to the conditions of life of the species.
If a species is endangered in the struggle for existence,
and shows a decline of population too high a death-rate
in proportion to its birth-rate then, seeing that length
of life is a very variable quality, the species may be saved
by the Natural Selection of the longer-lived variants, who
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 439
in virtue of some constitutional toughness survive longer
and have more offspring. As Dr. Chalmers Mitchell
points out, however, the process might work the other
way round by a selection of those variants showing
increased reproductivity. If the specific duration of life
happened to be a very fixed character, and the fertility
very variable, the line of solution might be as Dr. Chalmers
Mitchell indicates. Both theories may be right. Unfortun-
ately, neither admits of verification as regards the past.
Death. In spite of criticisms, we find no good reason
against accepting Weismann's doctrine of the immor-
tality of the Protozoa. Truly, these simple organisms
do not live a charmed life ; they are continually being
killed in countless millions ; they are sometimes consumed
by parasites, and so on ; but the point is that some of
them at least are not subject to natural death in the same
degree as higher animals are ; that some of them, indeed,
may be exempt from natural death altogether. To be
devoured by other creatures, to be dried up by the sun,
to be killed by a sudden change of temperature, that is the
fate of many ; but that is violent death. Others are
occasionally destroyed by internal parasites smaller and
simpler than themselves, but that is microbic death. To
the natural death which ensues from the physiological
insolvency of the body they are immune. The reasons
are to be found in their relative simplicity of structure ;
they can continuously make good their wear and tear ;
and in their relatively simple modes of multiplication,
which do not involve the nemesis so familiar in higher
animals. It is well known that a family of Infusorians all
descended from one individual isolated in a basin will often
come to an end, one of the reasons being the absence of
440 THE WONDER OF LIFE
any conjugation or primitive pairing ; another reason being
that the medium is or becomes in some way abnormal.
But Weismann's doctrine postulates natural conditions,
which would, of course, include the possibility of conjuga-
tion, and an ever fresh medium. A recent worker, Mr.
G. T. Baitsell, reports that he has discovered an optimum
medium in which one of the Infusorians will thrive and
multiply indefinitely without conjugation and without
introduced tonics.
It is a familiar fact that in the history of a hay infusion,
one kind of Protozoon succeeds another, which disappears
before it. But this disappearance is sometimes due to
violent death, and is sometimes not more than passing into
a latent state, as the result of deficient food or accumulated
waste-products. And again, it may be admitted that
when a Protozoon divides into two or many individuals, there
is, in a sense, a disappearance of a particular individuality
which went through a particular sequence of experiences ;
yet we cannot speak of death when one creature directly
turns into two or into many, and when there is nothing
left to bury.
It is not improbable that very simple multicellular
animals, such as the freshwater Hydra, may go on living
indefinitely if the natural conditions are altogether pro-
pitious. The structure and the multiplication of Hydra
are alike so simple, that there seems no good reason why
it should die a natural death. But as the body became
more complex, death was instituted as a tax on progress.
In discussing senescence we have mentioned some of the
facts which more or less certainly involve natural death,
but they are mostly reducible to two : (1 ) That the effects of
wear and tear in the body are not readily made good with
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 441
anything like thoroughness, and (2) that the process of
reproduction tends to become physiologically exhausting,
especially to the female sex. It is a noteworthy fact,
however, that in wild nature, the usual termination of life
is violent. Most animals die before their time, devoured
by their fellows, killed off by some environmental vicissi-
tude, or starved by a seasonal disappearance of their food.
Very few cases of microbic death are known among wild
animals, and it is possible that all such cases are due to
some human interference. Sir Ray Lankester cites the
case of a sandhopper which suffers from a bacterial
epidemic, but admits that this may be quite ' unnatural '.
In regard to the legions of parasites with which animals
are infested, it has to be recognized that these are rarely
fatal. It would be almost a contradiction in terms that
they should be, for it is not advantageous to a parasite
to kill its host. Parasites are destructive when they are
transported into hosts which are not physiologically accus-
tomed to them, which have altered their geographical
distribution, and thus become susceptible to novel intruders.
Then we hear of plagues and decimation, but in most cases
parasitism is an old-established, going concern. There
rise in the mind cases like those of Ichneumon-flies, which
lay their eggs in caterpillars and the like, and there the
fatality is well known. The Ichneumon-grubs hatched
in the caterpillar, proceed to devour their temporary host.
But this is not an ordinary type of parasitism.
On the whole, therefore, we are led to agree with the
general conclusion, which many naturalists have reached,
that in a state of Nature, most animals die a violent death
before they have nearly reached the end of their tether.
And this is one of the reasons why life in Nature is so
442 THE WONDER OF LIFE
vigorous and wholesome. As Goethe said, ' Death is her
expert device to get plenty of life.'
Summary. There is, as we have hinted, reason to
believe that natural death is not to be regarded simply as
an intrinsic necessity the fate of all life ; we can carry
the analysis further, and say that it is incident on the com-
plexity of the bodily machinery, which makes complete
recuperation wellnigh impossible, and almost forces the
organism to accumulate arrears, to go into debt to itself ;
that it is incident on the limits which are set to the multi-
plication and renewal of cells within the body, thus nerve-
cells in higher animals cannot be added to after an early
stage in development ; that it is incident on the occurrence
of organically expensive modes of reproduction, for repro-
duction is often the beginning of death. At the same time,
it seems difficult to rest satisfied with these and other
physiological reasons, and we fall back on the selectionist
view that the duration of life has been, in part at least,
punctuated from without and in reference to large issues ;
it has been gradually regulated in adaptation to the welfare
of the species.
As we have suggested in The Biology of the Seasons,
several groups should be distinguished. (1 ) The first is that
of the immortal unicellular animals which never grow old,
which seem exempt from natural death. (2) The second
is that of many animals which reach the length of their
life's tether without any hint of ageing and pass off the
scene or are shoved off victims of violent death. In
many fishes and reptiles, for instance, which are old in years,
there is not in their organs or tissues the least hint of age-
degeneration. (3) The third is that of the majority of
civilized human beings, some domesticated and some wild
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 443
animals, in which the decline of life is marked by normal
senescence. (4) The fourth is that of many human beings,
not a few domesticated animals, e.g. horse, dog, cat, and
some semi-domesticated animals, notably bees, in which
the close of life is marked by distinctively pathological
senility. It seems certain that wild animals rarely exhibit
more than a slight senescence, while man often exhibits
a bathos of senility. What is the reason of this ?
The majority of wild animals seem to die a violent death,
before there is time for senescence, much less senility.
The character of old age depends upon the nature of the
physiological bad debts, some of which are more unnatural
than others, much more unnatural in tamed than in wild
animals, much more unnatural in man than in animals.
Furthermore, civilized Man, sheltered from the extreme
physical forms of the struggle for existence, can live for a
long time with a very defective hereditary constitution,
which may end in a period of very undesirable senility.
Man is very deficient in the resting instinct, and seldom
takes much thought about resting habits. In many cases,
too, there has come about in human societies a system of
protective agencies which allow the weak to survive through
a period of prolonged senility. We cannot, perhaps, do
otherwise ; but it is plain that to heighten the standard
of vitality is an ideal more justifiable biologically than
that of merely prolonging existence. For if old age be
then permitted, it is more likely to be without senility.
Those whom the gods love die young.
IN ILLUSTRATION
Freshwater Sponge. Some of the simplest animals
or Protozoa have very complex life-histories, especially
444 THE WONDER OF LIFE
in some of the parasitic forms ; but they are too difficult
for discussion here. As a first illustration, therefore, we
take a multicellular animal, the freshwater sponge. In
some of the freshwater sponges which form the family
Spongillidse, aberrant in having left the sea an interesting
alternation of generations has been described by W. Mar-
shall and others. In autumn the sponge, which grows
on sticks and stones in the river or lake, suffers from the
cold and from a scarcity of food. It begins to die.
Throughout the moribund body, however, little companies
of cells group themselves together and become surrounded
by a protective capsule of tightly -fitting, somewhat capstan-
like, flinty spicules. Each group is called a gemmule,
and while the parent dies, the gemmules survive the winter.
In April or May they float away from the debris of the old
body, and develop into new sponges. Some become short-
lived males, others more stable females. The ova produced
by the latter and fertilized by spermatozoa from the former,
develop into a summer generation of asexual sponges,
which, in turn, die away in autumn, and give rise to gem-
mules. The formation of gemmules is an asexual mode
of multiplication, and it also secures dispersal, for the gem-
mules can be swept about by currents without being
damaged, until eventually they effect lodgment in some
crevice and begin to develop.
Zoophytes and Swimming Bells. Many of the
graceful colonies of Hydroid polyps, often called Zoophytes,
liberate in the summer months transparent reproductive
buds specialized for free-swimming. These Medusoids,
which are in a very general way like miniature jelly-fishes
or Medusae, swim in the open water by contractions and
expansions of their bells. They are sexual stages in the
FIG. 68. Life History of a Hydrozoon, Bougainvillia fruticosa. A. The zoophyte
colony, natural size. B. A portion enlarged, showing PE , protective perisarc
L. 1 he hvmg connexion between the polyps ; NP. a nutritive polyp, MB. a medu-
soid bud, M. a medusoid about to be liberated. C. A free-swimming sexual
medusoid. (After Allman.)
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 445
life-history, and produce ova and spermatozoa. The
fertilized ova develop into free-swimming embryos, which
soon settle down and become polyps. Each polyp is the
beginning of a hydroid colony which is formed by repeated
budding. Thus there is a remarkable alternation between
a fixed, plant-like, vegetative, asexual hydroid colony or
zoophyte, and a free, active, sexual medusoid or swimming
bell. A similar separation of the life-history into two very
markedly contrasted chapters is common among Ccelentera
or Stinging Animals ; we find it again in many Trematodes
like the liver-fluke ; in some insects, like the gall- wasps ;
and in remarkable expression in the free-swimming Tuni-
cates known as Salps. It is also characteristic of ferns
and mosses and the like, and it occurs in disguised form
in flowering plants. It may be defined as the alternate
occurrence in one life-history of two or more different
forms differently produced.
The Common Jelly-fish. Every one who knows the
sea at all is familiar with swimming or drifting shoals
of the common jelly-fish, Aurelia aurita, one of the most
cosmopolitan of animals. The glassy disc, with a shimmer
of light violet, is usually about four inches in diameter ;
it is surrounded by minute circumference tentacles, and
eight sense-organs symmetrically arranged in niches ; four
frilled lips hang down from the central mouth on the under
side ; eight branched and eight unbranched canals radiate
out from the central stomach to a peripheral canal ; and
there are four conspicuously coloured male or female
reproductive organs. The fertilized eggs develop into
minute free-swimming oval larvae, which after a short
period of activity settle down on a stone or seaweed.
They develop into little polyp-like forms, known as ' Hydra
446
THE WONDER OF LIFE
FIG. 69. Minute trans-
parent free-swimming
larva of a sea-cucum-
ber or Holothurian,
showing transverse
bands of cilia (c)
and peculiar protrud-
ing ' arms ' (A).
tubae,' about an eighth of an inch in height, with a mouth,
gullet, and tentacles. In ordinary conditions this sedentary
stage grows larger, and displays a
series of transverse annular con-
strictions, becoming like a minia-
ture pile of saucers the strobila
stage. Each disc or saucer is
separated off in turn as a free-
swimming young jelly-fish (or
Ephyra), which feeds on micro-
scopic organisms, grows rapidly,
undergoes certain structural
changes, and becomes a sexual
jelly-fish. Thus we find that a
characteristically free and active
animal, the jelly-fish, includes in its life-history a fixed
and vegetative polyp-stage alternation of generations
again (see Fig. 72).
Echinoderms. The newly-
hatched larvae of sea-urchins, sea-
cucumbers, starfishes, and brittle
stars are diffusely ciliated two-
layered thimble-like sacs in fact,
not very remarkable gastrulae.
But they soon become quaintly
transformed by the outgrowth of
processes and the formation of
special bands of cilia into extra-
ordinarily shaped larvae, adapted
for open sea life. In sea-urchins,
for instance, the quaint larva,
known as a Pluteus, is often
FIG. 70. Minute trans-
parent free-swimming
larva of a sea-cucum-
ber or Holothurian,
showing peculiar pro-
truding ' arms ' (A)
and calcareous plates
(CP).
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 447
compared to a microscopic six-legged easel, and the
same type occurs in Brittle-stars. Those of starfishes
and sea-cucumbers baffle brief description. Those of
feather-stars or Crinoids are not so divergent.
But even more remarkable than the shape of the larvae
is the fact that they do not develop directly into the adult,
in the way in which a tadpole develops into a frog. The
development is circuitous. Within the larva a new forma-
tion begins, on a fresh architectural plan, utilizing some
parts and rejecting others, and the result is the adult
form (Fig. 21). The curious arms or processes characteristic
of the larva are in part absorbed and in part thrown off.
The wandering amoeboid cells which play so diverse and
important a role in the animal kingdom are very active,
at once as sappers and miners in breaking down, and as
builders in the re-construction.
Mermis and Horse -hair Worms. A curious sight is
sometimes seen in gardens, especially after heavy rains
in summer a thin thread of a worm raising itself into the
air from the top of a cabbage plant and writhing as if in
search of something. That is a female Mermis, and it is
supposed to be seeking out a place for egg-laying more
suitable than the very damp earth. This is an episode in a
curious life-history. The mature Mermithidse live in the
earth or in fresh water, and so do the first larval stages.
From the earth or water, the young larvae migrate and
bore actively into beetles, caterpillars, millipedes, slugs,
and so on. When they become mature, the worms leave
their hosts. Now it is noteworthy that no food is taken
either by the adults or by the young larvae. All the
feeding is done by the second larval forms during the
parasitic period. Many adult insects are non-nutritive
448 THE WONDER OF LIFE
and wholly reproductive, using the energy accumulated
in the larval period ; but in the Meimithidse the state of
affairs is even more striking, for the energy accumulated
in the second larval stage serves not only for mature life
and for reproduction, but also for the first chapter in the
life of the next generation ! The black horse-hair worms,
hundreds of which are sometimes seen in a little wayside
pool, each about the thickness of a hair from a horse's tail,
have a somewhat similar life-history. The minute larvae
enter water-beetles and other insects and grow large within
them, to a length of four inches or so, much longer indeed
than their hosts. When they become mature they work
their way out of the insects and sometimes suddenly appear
in large numbers in the pools. We have seen a pool a
couple of feet across, so crowded with them that over a
hundred could be lifted in a handful, just like a bunch of
vitalized hairs, as the mediaeval naturalists believed them
to be.
Barnacles and Acorn-Shells. The barnacles (Lepas,
etc.) on floating timber and the acorn-shells (Balanus)
encrusting the shore rocks are much alike in their life-
history, and a very remarkable one it is. Out of the egg
of the barnacle there emerges a minute free-swimming
larva a Nauplius with three pairs of appendages, an
unpaired eye and a delicate dorsal shield. After moulting
several times, it fixes itself by means of its first pair of
feelers, which have become suctorial, to some floating
object, and secures its adhesion by a secretion of gluey
material. The anterior end by which it has fixed itself
is drawn out into a long flexible stalk, and a thorough-
going change occurs in the bodily structure, until the final
form is reached. During this metamorphosis the animal
THE CYCLE OF LIFE
449
fasts, living on its stores. Out of the egg of the Balanus
a nauplius larva likewise emerges. It feeds and grows
and moults, and acquires a firmer dorsal shield, a longer
FIG. 71. I. An acorn-shell (Balanus), showing : 1, the external rampart
of calcareous plates ; 2, the valves which shut in over the retracted
body; 3, some of the thoracic appendages protruded. II.
The free-swimming larva of the same, known as a nauplius : 1,2,3,
first three pairs of limbs, corresponding to the antennules, antennae,
and mandibles of the adult. It is almost microscopic.
spined tail, and stronger appendages. It then changes
into a somewhat * water-flea '-like form the Cyprid
stage with two lateral eyes, six pairs of swimming append-
ages, a bivalve shell, and so on. It is very active, but it
GG
450
THE WONDER OF LIFE
does not feed, so that not unnaturally it soon comes to
rest as if in fatigue. It fixes itself head downwards on the
rock or shell by means of its first pair of feelers and some
glutinous cement. It loses its bivalve shell and makes
Fia. 72. Life-history of the common jelly-fish, Aurelia aurita. (After
Bronn.) 1, the free-swimming ciliated planula ; 2, the same fixed ;
3, the hydra-tuba, with four tentacles ; 4 and 5, the strobila or pile-of-
saucers stage ; 6, a later stage after most of the discs have been
separated off ; 7, a separated off disc or ephyra, showing 8 bifid
processes each with a sense-organ ; 8-9, the ephyra seen from the
side and from beneath. The mouth is shown in the centre.
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 451
another of a different pattern ; it undergoes a metamor-
phosis, fasting all the time, and becomes a miniature
adult with its beautifully waving curl-like appendages
comparable, as Huxley said, to a shrimp fixed head down-
wards and back downwards to a rock, and kicking its
food into its mouth with its legs.
Shore Crab. No one could suspect from an obser-
vation of a common shore-crab, such as Carcinus mcenas,
that its early youth was spent in open waters. The larva
is a minute transparent free-swimming creature, known
as a zosea, with its tail sticking out in a line with the rest
of the body, with eight pairs of limbs instead of the adult's
total of at least twice as many, and with a curved spine
arising from the middle of the cephalothorax shield. This
little animal feeds and grows and moults its cuticle, and
feeds and grows and moults again, becoming eventually
a second larval form, known as the Megalops. This has
lost the spine and gained a broader body and also additional
limbs, namely those corresponding to the forceps and
walking legs of the adult crab. But its tail is still sticking
out in a line with the rest of the body. The Megalops feeds
and grows and moults, gets its tail tucked forwards under
the cephalothorax, and becomes a miniature crab about
the size of a quarter of one's little finger nail a creature no
longer suited for free swimming, but for the floor of the
sea in shallow water, whence it creeps up on to the
shore.
Freshwater Insects. There is something peculiarly
fascinating in the life-histories of freshwater insects, partly
because of the sharp contrast between the aquatic and
the aerial chapters, partly because of the subtlety of the
adaptations to life in the water. Every one has enjoyed
452 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Tennyson's picture, which is only one out of a possible
score equally dramatic.
To-day I saw the dragon-fly
Come from the wells where he did lie.
An inner impulse rent the veil
Of his old husk : from head to tail
Came out clear plates of sapphire mail.
He dried his wings; like gauze they grew;
Thro' crofts and pastures wet with dew
A living flash of light he flew.
May -Flies. Not unfamiliar in May or June is the emer-
gence of a crowd of May-Flies or Ephemerides from the
pond or from a backwater of the river. In our Biology
of the Seasons we have described the long larval life in
the water, sometimes lasting for two or three years ; the
growth and the moultings ; the final moult, the unfolding
of the filmy wings, and the transient aerial dance some-
times lasting only for a day. The long-drawn-out nutritive
and growing period stands in remarkable contrast to the
hurried reproductive chapter. They rise like a living
mist from the pond ; they dance in the pleasant light of
the summer evening ; they dimple the smooth water into
smiling with a touch, chasing, embracing, separating. . . .
' They never pause to eat they could not an they would ;
hunger is past, love is present, and in the near future is
death. The evening shadows grow longer shadows of
death to the day-flies. The trout jump at them, a few
rain-drops help to thin the throng, the stream bears others
away. The mothers lay their eggs in the water and wearily
die forthwith, cradle and tomb are side by side ; and the
males also pass from the climax of love to the other crisis
of dying. But after all, the eggs are in the water, the
THE CYCLE OF LIFE
453
promise of the future ; the individuals perish, but the
race lives on.'
Gnats. Early in spring we may find the gnats' boat
of 300 eggs moored to the water-weed. Early in May
the larvse abound in the pools, quaint, dark-coloured
creatures, about half an inch long, with slender biistly
bodies, and mouth-parts which waft in food-particles.
FIG. 73. I, Larva. II. Pupa of the Gnat (Culex pipiens). (After Hurst.)
BT, respiratory tubes. T, tail end of larva.
They seem to spend their day between the bottom of the
pool and the surface-film, which they perforate with a
terminal valved breathing organ at the end of the tail.
Hanging head downwards, they accumulate air enough
to serve during prolonged submergence. They grow apace
and moult three times without changing much in their
character. But at the fourth moult a pupa emerges, light-
454 THE WONDER OF LIFE
brown in colour, with a large head and a small body, with
anterior breathing tubes, and no open mouth. After a
few days the pupa husk splits and the winged gnat escapes.
Other Insects. No life-history is more marvellous
than that of a moth or butterfly. Out of the egg, after a
very remarkable development, there emerges a minute
worm-like caterpillar, usually active, voracious, and of
rapid growth. Typically, it shows a hard head with biting
mouth-parts, with very minute antennae, and with several
pairs of simple eyes in every respect as different as possible
from the full-grown insect's head. The body consists of
thirteen or so segments, of which the first three bear jointed
clawed legs, corresponding to, though they do not become,
the three pairs of thoracic legs in the adult. Posteriorly
there are four or five pairs of unjointed, unclawed, leg-like
structures the so-called ' pro-legs ' which are not repre-
sented in the winged insect. As it eats it grows, and
growth involves moulting the thoroughgoing casting of
the cuticle. There may be five of these moults, each marked
by respiratory and other difficulties, and followed by rapid
growth. Finally, having reached its limit of growth,
the caterpillar becomes quiescent ; it often surrounds itself
with a cocoon, sometimes silken, and passes into the
chrysalis or pupa state. Serious respiratory and other
difficulties beset the pupa ; a process analogous to inflam-
mation pervades it ; the old structure is broken down and
groups of formative cells of an embryonic character proceed
to build up the adult body on a new architectural plan.
Everything is changed mouth-parts, antennae, food-canal,
muscles, everything. New structures, such as wings and
compound eyes, make their appearance. By and by there
struggles painfully out of the imprisoning husk an
FIG. 74. Life History of Death's Head Moth (Acherontia atropos).
From a specimen. I. The caterpillar. II. The pupa. III.
The pupa with the moth emerging. IV. The moth at rest.
V. The moth flying
454 THE WONDER OF LIFE
brown in colour; -**ik a. large head and a small body, with
anterior breathing tubes, and no open mouth. After a
few days the ]>'*;* S'?k splits and the winged gnat escapes.
Other Jnaevi*, No life-history is more marvellous
than that of * nth or butterfly. Out of the egg, after a
very renvt kv4* development, there emerges a minute
won.!:-lik ^v^^fciittr, usually active, voracious, and of
rapid Typical!} ~, it shows a hard head with biting
*,;;.rtTO insect's head. The body consists of
**giuents, of which the first three bear jointed
(, i*Tesponding to, though they do not become,
.(eoqoilB fiiJrumHoA) HloM b^H a'Hjcad \o v'toialM ail J .^ .oil
.III .squq aHT .11 .ifiKiqistBO 9flT .1 .namioaqs B moil
}83i IB Hloni 9fiT .VI ,sni]R-i3fn9 Htom oH* rftiw'Bquq
rrmvVi ?r -....- ,-,( ng of
ii ! :' ? iJMSfr r- arked
by u-apirnU.ry and other diiljt-uiu^s. -d by rapid
growth. Finally, having reached its limit of growth,
the caterpillar becomes quiescent ; it often surrounds itself
with a cocoon, sometimes silken, and passes into the
chrysalis or pupa state. Serious respiratory and other
difficulties beset the pupa ; a process analogous to inflam-
mation pervades it ; the old structure is broken down and
groups of formative cells of an embryonic character proceed
to build up the adult body on a new architectural plan.
Everything is changed mouth-parts, antennae, food-
muscles, everything. ~. wad
compound eyes, make ih< - there
struggles painfully out husk an
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 455
entirely new creature, the fully -formed moth or butterfly.
Two big facts stand out. The first is that the life-history
is divided into a feeding growing period and a fasting
reproductive period. For the amount that adult Lepidop-
tera eat is trivial, and some have mouths that do not open.
In no case among the higher insects is there any growth
after the adult form is attained. The other big fact is
the zig-zagness of the development. It proceeds for a
time along a certain path ; it comes to a standstill ; it
turns back on itself ; and then it goes ahead once more
on a quite different line.
Fabre has told us many stories in regard to the life
and habits of the large plant-bug, called Cigale, famous
for its instrumental music and infamous for the Parthian
shot of noxious stuff which it delivers on our face as it flies
away. The old legend had it that the Cigale who sang
in the summer was forced to borrow from the ant when the
scarcity of winter came, but the facts are the other way
round. When all the world is thirsty in the midsummer
drought, the Cigale with its delicate auger broaches the
cask of a suitable shrub. 'Plunging her proboscis into
the bung-hole, she drinks deliciously, motionless, and wrapt
in meditation, abandoned to the charms of syrup and of
song '. Many thirsty insects draw to the well, and the
aggressive ants, by sheer force of numbers and impudence,
succeed in hustling the Cigale away. They then make the
most of what is left of sweet sap.
The eggs of the Cigale are laid about July, in batches
in dry twigs, ten or so in each of thirty to forty chambers.
In autumn a remarkable primary larva emerges, which
Fabre compared to a very minute fish with one fin
the first two legs being joined to form the only movable
456 THE WONDER OF LIFE
appendage. This quaint form moults and there comes
forth a migratory larva, no bigger than a flea, which hangs
by its tail for an hour or a day at the end of a thread, waving
its antennae and bending its legs. It falls to the ground
and seeks for a spot of pervious soil into which to burrow.
It becomes a deep burrower and taps the roots of plants,
probably remaining, Fabre thinks, for four years under-
ground. We venture to quote from his Social Life in the
Insect World, the summing up of this extraordinary life-
history.
' Four years of hard labour underground, and a month
of feasting in the sun ; such is the life of the Cigale. Do
not let us again reproach the adult insect with his trium-
phant delirium. For four years, in the darkness, he has
worn a dirty parchment overall ; for four years he has mined
the soil with his talons, and now the mud-stained sapper
is suddenly clad in the finest raiment, and provided with
wings that rival the bird's ; moreover, he is drunken with
heat and flooded with light, the supreme terrestrial joy.
His cymbals will never suffice to celebrate such felicity,
so well earned although so ephemeral '.
The common house-fly (Musca domestica) can pass through
the whole of its intricate development with three larval
stages and a pupal stage in eight days, if the temperature
is steady and high (35 C.), but the same process may be
lengthened out over several weeks. According to Hewitt,
the flies become sexually mature in 10-14 days after their
emergence from the pupa-stage. Each fly lays from 120-150
eggs in a single batch, and may lay as many as six batches
during its short life. Except in warm stables and the like,
where reproduction may go on practically without stopping,
the breeding period is usually from June to October.
FIG. 75. Metamorphosis of the common eel (Anguilla vulgaris)
from the knife-blade-like Leptocephalus (1) to the shorter
cylindrical elver (5). (After Schmid.)
456 THE WOXDER OF LIFE
appendage. This qu&iut form moults and there comes
forth a migratory !&"<*, no bigger than a flea, which hangs
by its tail for an hot . .; *& a day at the end of a thread, waving
its antennae and K^ding its legs. It falls to the ground
and seeks for a si- < of pervious soil into which to burrow.
It becomes a fk- %.- Imrrower and taps the roots of plants,
probably reins* wig, Fabre thinks, for four years under-
ground. We ^.tiMire to quote from his Social Life in the
Insect Wc-r*>,i'._ i'te summing up of this extraordinary life-
history.
<* of hard labour underground, and a month
' .- *- -, * the sun ; such is the life of the Cigale. Do
>**in reproach the adult insect with his trium-
filluigfiA) fe nomrnoo aril to auoHqionjBisM XV .oil
Mil ol (I) auififiqaaoJqaJ Mlil-abald-afcijpl aril rnoit
/ (.bimibS \\N) (C)y[ 3 ,l !3 gp|g
wings that rival * with
heat and flooded < joy.
Hia cyn.h,:-.- ?. ; ;; y., - ch felicity,
so well earned althi' il\
The common house-fly (Mttsco domestica) can pass through
the whole of its intricate development with three larval
stages and a pupal stage in eight days, if the temperature
is steady and high (35 C.), but the same process may be
lengthened out over several weeks. According to Hewitt,
the flies become sexually mature in 10-14 days after their
emergence from the pupa-stage. Each fly lays from 120-150
eggs in a single batch, and may lay as many as six batches
during its short life. Except in warm stables and the like,
where reproduction may go on practically wi
the breeding period is usually from h
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 457
There is a rather famous Aphis Schlechtendalia chinensis
which makes galls on Rhus semi-alata in Japan and
China. The galls are used in dyeing and tanning they
are rich in tannin, and in former times they served the
Japanese women as a tooth-powder for blackening their
teeth. Sasaki has almost cleared up its complicated life-
history. There is a succession of wingless females, partheno-
genetic and viviparous, and after a time winged females
appear which lay eggs containing well-advanced embryos.
These develop into wingless females again. No males
have been found, and we have a glimpse of a possible
continuous Parthenopeia.
Sometimes the life-cycle is long drawn out, as in the case
of the seventeen-year cicadas (Tibicina septendecim), well
known in the United States, where they are often called
' locusts '. (A small British relative, Cicadetta montana, is
sometimes found in the New Forest.) The peculiarity
of the Cicada is that it is specially abundant every seven-
teenth year in the northern States, or every thirteenth
year in the southern States. The eggs are laid on the
twigs of trees ; the larvae drop to the ground and cluster
on the roots, sucking the sap ; after a prolonged larval
period, there is short pupation, and a broad, black insect,
with reddish nervures on its wings, emerges. The loud
instrumental music or stridulation made by the males is
very familiar.
Tunicates. The majority of Tunicates, belonging to
the Ascidian type, are somewhat nondescript marine
animals, of sedentary habit, often compared to wine-skins
or leather water-bottles. Until their development was
made known, no one suspected that their relationships
were with backboned animals. The egg develops into a
458 THE WONDER OF LIFE
minute transparent free-swimming larva, suggestive of a
tadpole. For some hours it enjoys a free-swimming life,
propelling itself by means of its tail. At this stage it has a
brain and a delicate dorsal nerve-cord, a supporting dorsal
axis (or notochord) in its tail, a brain-eye, a ventral tubular
heart, and two or more pharyngeal gill-slits all of them
distinctively vertebrate characters. But it does not fulfil
the promise of its youth ! It soon gives up its active life,
fastens itself by its head to seaweed or stone, and almost
immediately falls victim to rapid degeneration. The
nerve-cord is lost and the brain-eye ; the tail shrinks and
disappears, devoured by its own phagocytes ; the posterior
part of the body becomes twisted dorsally through 180
and within a few hours the creature begins to look like a
miniature Ascidian one of the most signal instances of
individual degeneration in the whole animal kingdom.
Eels. There is a fascination in the life- history of
the freshwater eel, though the mystery has been in part
removed. From inland ponds and quiet stretches of rivers
the full-grown eels migrate on autumn nights seawards ;
they pass out to sea into deep water, and probably die after
reproduction, for they never return. Obscurity still hangs
over the deposition and fertilization of the eggs and over
the early stages of development. The transparent Lepto-
cephalus larvae are found near the surface, and are for a
year or more pelagic. From the open sea, the young eels,
when they have become cylindrical in shape, migrate
shorewards and pass up the streams in a marvellous
procession or eel-fare.
On the Michael Sars (1910) expedition, the larvae of the
common eel were found not only on the Continental slopes,
but also in mid-ocean over the greatest depths, both over
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 459
the deep eastern and western basins and over the Azores
ridge separating them. The larger larvae were all got
north of the Azores, and the younger stages were all found
south of the Azores, which led Dr. Hjort to suggest that
the spawning area is probably in the southern central part
of the North Atlantic. No transformation-stages were
found in mid-ocean, and it may be that the change
only occurs on the Continental slope. But it must
always be remembered that the developing eggs have not
yet been discovered.
The Salmon. In British rivers, the time of salmon
spawning is in the late autumn or winter. The eggs are
laid in the gravelly bed of the stream, and they develop
very slowly. After three or four months the egg-envelope
bursts and the larva is set free, still encumbered with a
large yolk-sac, on the contents of which it subsists for about
seven weeks. About the eighth week after hatching, the
supply of yolk is exhausted, and the * fry ' about an inch
long begin to fend for themselves and to move energetic-
ally. They grow by the end of the year to be somewhat
trout-like ' parr ', about four inches long. In their second
year, usually, the young salmon change in coloration,
donning a beautiful ' sea-jacket,' and are known as ' smolts '
six or seven inches in length. These go down to the sea,
feed voraciously, grow rapidly, accumulate stores, and
become grilse. After a variable period of feeding and
growing, which may last a year or two years or more, they
are ready to spawn, and return to the place of their birth
in the fresh waters. Such in outline is the typical life-
history of the salmon, but there are many variations on
this theme. We have described in our Biology of the Seasons
the journey up the rivers, the struggle against the stream
460 THE WONDER OF LIFE
and the leaping of the falls all implying efforts which are
the more remarkable since there seems to be no evidence
that the adult salmon ever feeds in fresh water. Few salmon
seem to spawn more than once, and some die of spawning.
It is of interest to contrast the eel and the salmon, for the
former is a marine fish which has taken secondarily to a
life in the rivers and ponds, while the latter is primarily a
freshwater fish which has taken to the exploitation of
the sea.
In the case of the Pacific salmon (Oncorhynchus) the
general facts are the same, but a simplification is implied
in the fact that the adults die after spawning once. They
do not return to the sea. The run up the rivers to the
spawning grounds several hundred miles off is very
remarkable ; it may occupy two or three months ; after
tidal waters are passed the fish continues, according to Pro-
fessor C. W. Greene's ' marking ' experiments, at an average
speed of not less than 7 miles a day ; all the work is done
on an empty stomach, for feeding stops absolutely in fresh
water ; the work often includes jumping six or seven feet
in height and then continuing against a swift rush of water ;
and all the time the reproductive organs are growing rapidly
at the expense of other parts of the body. It is a remarkable
performance.
Frogs. Out of the frog's egg, in the midst of its
enveloping sphere of jelly, there emerges a ciliated larva,
which has already had an embryonic development of about
a fortnight. It is mouthless and limbless ; the eyes growing
out from the brain have not yet reached the surface ; there
are the beginnings of external gills ; and there is a glandular
cement organ on the under surface of the head, by means
of which the larva attaches itself to water -weed and other
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 461
objects. The gills become branched ; the mouth opens ;
the food-canal lengthens till it is like a watch-spring ;
four gill-clefts open from the pharynx to the exterior ;
the larvae feed greedily on vegetable matter, and grow
rapidly ; as their power of locomotion increases, the cement
organs dwindle.
The true tadpole stage then begins. A skin-fold covers
the gills, which are absorbed, only, however, to be replaced
by a second very similar set. Both sets are comparable to
the external gills of the double-breathing lung-fishes (or
Dipnoi) rather than to the gills of ordinary fishes. The
mouth acquires horny jaws and the fleshy lips bear horny
papillae. A gill-chamber is formed on each side, with one
exhalant opening, however, to the left. The circulation
is like that of a fish, and the heart is two-chambered ;
the tadpole is about a month old. The third period is
marked by the appearance of the limbs and by the
development of the lungs. The tadpoles come to the sur-
face to take gulps of air ; the circulation ceases to be
piscine ; the heart becomes three-chambered ; the tadpole
is two months old.
The tadpole reaches its full size, and the metamorphosis
is close at hand. It seems to fast, but the tail, which under-
goes internal dissolution, furnishes, through the medium
of the amoeboid phagocytes, some nourishment to other
parts of the body. The horny jaws are lost ; the frilled
lips shrink ; the hitherto rounded mouth becomes frog-
like ; the tongue enlarges and gains mobility ; the eyes are
exposed ; the fore-limbs, which have been kept back by the
gill-cover, become free. The animal recovers its appetite,
becomes thoroughly carnivorous, gets a relatively shorter
intestine, has its hind legs relatively lengthened, and, having
462 THE WONDER OF LIFE
lost all trace of its tail, hops ashore a little frog about
three months old.
It is very interesting to observe that in this single life-
history there is first of all nutritive dependence on the
legacy of yolk, then a period of vegetarian diet, then a
somewhat omnivorous period, then a fast, then a carnivor-
ous time, and finally an insectivorous adult lif e. Similarly,
as regards respiration, there is great variety. The newly-
FIG. 76. Male Edible Frog, Rana esculenta, showing the resonating
, sacs protruded from the corners of the mouth. From a specimen.
hatched larva breathes through its skin ; it has a first set
of gills ; it develops gill-clefts ; a second set of gills arising
under the gill-covering replaces the first set ; when it is
two months old it breathes by both gills and lungs ; the
gills disappear and the frogling is a lung-breather ; but
all through the winter the frog harks back to the
primitive cutaneous respiration.
As regards recapitulation, it goes without saying that
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 463
the larval frog is never like a young fish. It has no scales,
for instance, nor fin-rays supporting the tail- fin, and there
are much more fundamental differences. It is an Amphib-
ian from first to last. And yet, if we fix our attention on
the development of the heart or the circulation, we must
admit that the tadpole passes through stages which are
permanent in fishes. In other parts of its organogenesis
it climbs up its own genealogical tree, and to this extent
at least confirms the ' Recapitulation Doctrine '.
It is very instructive to compare the long drawn out life-
history of the common frog with that of some of its relatives.
In the Surinam toad (Pipa) and in some Tree- Frogs, the
tadpole stage is skipped altogether, while in the Paradoxical
Frog (Pseudis pamdoxa) the tadpole stage is much more
impressive, at any rate, than the adult. In his delightful
Infancy of Animals, Mr. W. P. Pycraft tells us that the
tadpole is nearly a foot long, nine inches going to the enor-
mous tail, and three inches to the head and trunk. During
a prolonged fast, and after no little re-modelling, this huge
larva is shaped into an adult frog, only two and a half inches
in length.
Retrospect. The general idea which these life- histories
suggest, is that the various chapters of a typical life-
history are capable of being lengthened out or shortened
down according to the conditions of life ; and to some
extent, also, that particular conditions of life, may have
been sought out to suit particular forms of the life-curve.
The various arcs on the span of life are, so to speak, elastic.
The line of life is like a telescope with many joints ; it can
be drawn out to its full length ; it can be pushed in to a
minimum ; or one part can be lengthened and another
shortened. Just as some flowers remain, as it were, per-
464 THE WONDER OF LIFE
manent buds, so some animals remain always young.
In what is called paedogenesis, sometimes illustrated by
the Axolotl, even the reproduction is shunted back into
larval life, so that adult life is reduced to nil. In other
cases, the conditions of adult life are extremely riskful,
and its duration is contracted to a few weeks or days or
even hours ! In other cases, it is the larval life that is
condensed ; thus in the freshwater crayfish, what comes
out of the egg is practically a miniature adult ; all the
usual larval stages, so characteristic of higher crustaceans,
have been telescoped into the embryonic development with-
in the egg. Or it may be that the larval life is drawn out
for years. The idea should be linked on to what has been
noted in regard to the successive chapters in the routine of
parental behaviour (see p. 430). It is, in a word, the idea of
temporal variations, that the life-histories of animals are
like tunes, which may be much altered by playing one part
out of all proportion slowly, and another part very quickly.
We may even go further, and recognize that there are
youthful types of organisms and others which are born old.
But this is the beginning of another story.
The Story of Niners. A score of miles, as the crow
flies, from the sea, there is a stretch of slowly -flowing river,
from which a mill-race has borrowed most of the water.
There are many pools with sand or mud, and if this be
stirred, we get a glimpse of curious, sluggish, eel-like crea-
tures, variously known as niners, or prides, or larval
lampreys. Some four to six inches long at the end of their
fluviatile life, with a polished dark skin, with a horse-shoe
lip around a toothless mouth, they are jawless, limbless,
and scaleless, and therefore cannot be ranked as fishes.
Although they are called ' niners ' ? i.e. nine-eyes (German,
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 465
Neunaugen], they are blind ; for their eyes, growing out from
the brain as vertebrate eyes always do, have not yet reached
the surface. There are seven gill-slits on each side, and
these have been popularly counted in as eyes. These
curious old-world creatures are often regarded as the young
of eels, but, as a matter of fact, they are far below the level
of fishes on the genealogical tree of animals. Whence have
they come and what future is before them ?
The Sea Lamprey (Petromyzon marinus), whose larvae
the niners are, is a strong muscular animal, sometimes a
yard long, abundant in the Mediterranean and the North
Atlantic. It also occurs in the American lakes, having in
this case dispensed with its normal journey to the sea.
The colour is greyish green with darker spots. The struc-
tural peculiarities are numerous. For apart from the
absence of jaws, limbs, and scales, which we have already
mentioned, there is a circular adhesive disc around the
mouth and lined with rows of horny teeth, there is a very
muscular protrusible ' tongue ' bearing horny plates for
rasping with, there is an unpaired nostril far back on
the top of the head, like a porpoise's blow-hole, and there
are curious gill-purses. Their habits are not less remark-
able. They attach themselves to living fishes and rasp
the flesh and suck the blood. They take a very firm hold
of their victims and make deep holes, and they are some-
times carried for long distances by large fishes, such as
salmon. They migrate in spring or early summer from
the sea (or the lakes of the State of New York) to the rivers,
usually changing to a more yellowish colour ; they make
nests of stones, and they die after spawning. *
It is a very general fact of Natural History that when
the habitats of adult and young are different, the cradle-
H H
466 THE WONDER OF LIFE
area represents the old home. The salmon is essentially
a freshwater fish, though its nutritive periods are mostly
spent in the sea. Its spawning in the rivers is indicative
of its original home. The common eel, on the other hand,
which has its nutritive period in the fresh waters, goes
down to the Deep Sea to spawn, and is probably to be
regarded as essentially a marine fish with its old home
in the greater depths. A similar argument leads to the
view that the Sea-Lamprey is primarily a freshwater fish
which has secondarily taken to spending a nutritive period
in the sea. We have already spoken of the forms of
Petromyzon marinus in lakes of the State of New York,
which do not leave the fresh water at all, though they
migrate from lake to river to spawn. In the case of the
River Lampern (Lampetra fluviatilis), whose young are
also called ' niners ', some remain all their lives in fresh
water, while others go down to the sea. This is paralleled
by the Trout (Salmo trutta), some forms of which remain
in lakes and rivers, while others (distinguished nominally
as Sea-trout) go down to the sea. It must also be noted
that a number of species of lamprey, such as the Brook
Lamprey, never leave the fresh water, and this may be
taken as another argument in support of the view that
the Sea Lamprey is secondarily marine. Let us follow
them now on their return journey to their cradle-area.
The spawning of the Sea Lamprey has been well described
by Dr. L. Hussakof . A circular depression is made, two to
three feet in diameter, in the river-bed. Large numbers of
pebbles and stones are carried out of the chosen area until
a shallow basin is formed, naturally with a floor of sand
and fine gravel. The adhesive disc around the mouth
acts like a vacuum-sucker, and it can be made to ' work '
JFlG. 77. Marine Lampreys (Petromyzon mannus), making a nest
in a stream, removing the larger stones from a selected spot and
piling them around the circumference.
BONDER OF LIFE
area represent* fce- M home. The salmon is essentially
a freshwater n*t iJtoagh its nutritive periods are mostly
spent in the >"?- H, spawning in the rivers is indicative
of its origin^ >w The common eel, on the other hand,
which has fc&tive period in the fresh waters, goes
down to > $?& to *ipawn, and is probably to be
regarded - have air* fc--*v spoken of the forms of
* fcfcfce v ' :- -i-AWf; In the case of the
B gnblem feuaiiBm nos^moDa^) 8/aiqm
bns Joqa balosba moil eanote ISBIB! aril ^nr/omai
.sonaialmuDiio artl bnuoie mal
remain
.-} nominally
-ri r- ,!>) , ...st fclso be noted
-liAt. * nrbr of sp^es of lamprey, such as the Brook
Lamprey, rwvr leave the fresh water, and this may be
taken as a-K'tht/r argument in support of the view that
the Sea Liimfsrey is secondarily marine. Let us follow
them now on their return journey to their cradle-area.
The spawning of the Sea Lamprey has been well described
by Dr. L. Hussakof . A circular depression is made, two to
three feet in diameter, in t \\* river-bed. Large numbers of
pebbles and stones a^ at of the chosen area until
A *feaUow basin is in. y with a fr
HM-. . avel. ' ;
:-:;;i n ' : >VOrk '
X^cT^ ,
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 467
after the animal is dead. Both sexes work at the nest-
making, and the males sometimes make considerable
preparations before the females arrive on the scene.
Sometimes two lampreys will unite their energies in lifting a
heavy stone.
When the nest is ready, or while it is being prepared,
the female lamprey lays her eggs within the circle, clinging
as she does so to a large stone. At the same time the male
seizes her by the top of the head, and the two bodies are
very rapidly vibrated for two or three seconds, during which
the milt or seminal fluid is shed upon the eggs. Fertiliza-
tion is external. The same remarks might be made in
regard to the brook-lampreys Lampetra planeri in Europe
and Lampetra wilderi in North America. ' The females/
according to Forbes and Kichardson, ' spawn in shallow
water, and, as a rule, where there is some current over
pebbly or stony bottom near the headwaters of a stream.
During the spawning process the females cling with their
oval mouths to pebbles or stones, and are clasped at the
nape by the suctorial discs of the males '. In the case
of the river lamprey, a good many couples combine to make
the nest and use it in common. The surface of the eggs
is covered with an adhesive stuff, to which sand grains
adhere, so that the eggs sink. Moreover, they say that
the two parents proceed at once to loosen some stones at
the upstream side of the nest, so that the loosened sand
buries the eggs. There may be several spawnings at short
intervals, and then the parents pass down stream to die.
For that is the most remarkable fact in the story of the
lampreys, that the one generation comes to an end in giving
the next generation a beginning. Reproduction is often
the beginning of death, but here the end comes quickly.
468 THE WONDER OF LIFE
We are familiar with this in some lower animals, such as
May-flies and butterflies, and in some still lower animals,
such as some of the worms, but it is rather startling to find
a big muscular sea lamprey a yard long and as thick as a
lady's wrist dead and stranded in the shallow water of
the river not far below the spawning-place. What does
it all mean ? Uprooting and transporting the stones has
involved no small expenditure of energy, no little wear and
tear ; the skin is often bruised and cut (and there are
wounds of combat and of mating besides) ; Bacteria and
Fungi begin to settle down (to which the skin of the larva
seems to be immune because of a ferment it possesses) ;
the creatures become blind and emaciated, and are often
attacked by other lampreys. But all the external causes
added up will not account for the wiping out of the adult
lampreys after spawning. Every one agrees that these
are contributory or accessory, but not the essential causes
of death.
A deeper answer is to be found in the fundamental
antithesis between nutrition and reproduction. These
sexually mature lampreys have not been feeding at all :
their hunger has been devoured by love. Profound bodily
changes have been associated with the reproductive func-
tion, similar to those more familiar in the case of the salmon.
The intestine, for instance, is quite out of gear. Deeper still,
perhaps, it is possible to go, for it seems legitimate to
suppose that the length of life's tether is, in many cases at
least, adaptive. Where reproduction takes such a grip
of the constitution, it would not be well for the race that
there should be survival. In other words, those of a type
that tended to live longer, but with enfeebled energies,
have been eliminated in the course of Natural Selection.
THE CYCLE OF LIFE 469
But let us return to the fertilized eggs. They develop
quickly and hatch in about a fortnight. About a month
later, when about half an inch long, the larvae leave the
nest and seek out quiet stretches of the river. They differ
from the adults in the horseshoe shape of the lips, in having
a sieve of barbels guarding the true mouth, in the details
of their respiratory system, in having much less developed
unpaired fins, and in being blind. They form burrows
in the sand or mud, and feed on small aquatic animals.
It is very difficult for ordinary eyes to see any difference
between the larvae of the various species, and the technical
name Ammoccetes branchialis is applied to them all.
After three or four years of a somewhat monotonous
juvenile life, the larvae begin to grow up. They put
away their larval characters and pass through a metamor-
phosis, just as a tadpole does in turning into a frog. This
is accomplished in the autumn months between the end of
August and mid-October. The horseshoe lips are changed
into a circle, the barbels into papillae, the suctorial disc is
formed, the teeth develop, internal adjustments are effected,
the creatures become more active, and pass down the rivers
to the sea or the great lake, where they become strictly
fish-eaters. After two or three years of vigorous life and
rapid growth the young lampreys have quite grown up,
and they return up the streams to their old cradle-area,
which is also the place of their death.
A Strasburg fisherman called Baldner is said to have
convinced himself more than two hundred years ago that
* niners ' grew into lampreys, but his correct conclusion
was not accepted till 1826, when A. Miiller observed the
whole life-history of the brook lamprey the eggs develop-
ing into niners, and these changing into the adult forms.
470 THE WONDER OF LIFE
The lampreys have many primitive features, e.g. in
their vertebral axis, their skull, their nasal passage, and
they are without doubt very old-fashioned types. They
probably diverged from the vertebrate stock before the
evolution of definite jaws, but it is possible that they long
ago lost the jaws which their remote ancestors had. Con-
sistent with their old-fashioned character is the poorly-
developed brain, and the low order of intelligence that
they exhibit. Bashford Dean and R B. Sumner have
noticed that many of the movements of brook lampreys
are not very * purposelike ', and Hussakof remarks the
same defect in the sea-lamprey. ' Thus a lamprey will
sometimes pick up a stone outside the nest, carry and
drop it into the nest ; or while carrying out a stone will
drop it half-way up the side of the nest. It will tug at a
large stone which it cannot possibly dislodge, or at a log,
in an effort to drag it out of the nest, and will repeat this
again and again, without profiting in the least by previous
failures. On the whole, one has a feeling that the lamprey
possesses a very low mentality, even as compared with
fishes '. They seem to be guided greatly by touch, and
they exhibit a curious preoccupation with their work,
paying no heed, for instance, to onlookers or to the noise of
automobiles clattering over a wooden bridge above the
nest-building. But whether this apparent absorption in
their work may be due to sensory dullness, we do not at
present know. In any case, stupid or not, these old-world
creatures do not choose the path of least resistance ; alike
in their migrations and in their nest-buildings they afford
us abundant food for wonder.
CHAPTER VII
THE WOKDEK OF LIFE
(CHARACTERISTICS OF LIVING CREATURES)
' past ano future are unknown to ber. be present is ber
eternity. Sbe is beneficent. . . ,'
4 Sbe is complete, but never finfsbeo. Bs sbe works now,
so can sbe always work. . . /
' Sbe is ever sbaping new forms ; wbat is, bas never p.et
been ; wbat bas been, comes not again. 3verp.tbin0 is new,
ano set naugbt but tbe olo.'
Goethe's Aphorisms, translated by Huxley.
The Creature Itself Organisms and Mechanisms The Insignia
of Life Down-breaking and Up-building The Power of
Growing Capacity for Behaviour Power of Reproducing
Development Variability Simulacra Vitse Difficult Pheno-
mena The Powers of Life Correlation The Subtlety of Life
Adaptation Regeneration The Crowning Wonder of Evolu-
tion Vitalism.
WE have considered organisms as actors in a drama,
living in haunts, conquering space, trading
with time, and passing from phase to phase in their indivi-
dual life-histories. Let us now change our point of view
and think of the living creature itself. What are the great
facts in regard to it and its living that stand out when we
get to a little distance, and are not embarrassed by the
details of anatomy, physiology, embryology and the like ?
THE CREATURE ITSELF
Were it not for the difficulty of seeing things clearly,
thoroughly, and imaginatively, all educated men, with
471
472 THE WONDER OF LIFE
opportunities of enjoying the observation of life as it is
lived in Nature, would be unanimous in admiration of
every living creature. The normal outlook, admittedly
difficult to attain to, is expressed in Walt Whitman's well-
known creed :
4 1 believe a leaf of grass is no less than the journey- work of the
stars,
And the pismire is equally perfect, and the grain of sand, and the
egg of the wren,
And the tree-toad is a chef-d'oeuvre for the highest,
And the running blackberry would adorn the parlours of heaven,
And the narrowest hinge in my hand puts to scorn all machinery,
And the cow crunching with depressed head surpasses any statue,
And a mouse is miracle enough to stagger sextillions of infidels.'
Organisms and Mechanisms. Both in teaching and
in investigation it is very useful to compare living creatures
to engines. Both are material systems for the transforma-
tion of matter and energy. But the analogy is most
useful when it breaks down, for then the insignia of life
stand out in relief. Professor Joly long ago pointed out one
of the deep differences between an inanimate material
system and a living organism :
' While the transfer of energy into any inanimate material
system is attended by effects retardative to the transfer
and conducive to dissipation, the transfer of energy into
any animate material system is attended by effects con-
ducive to the transfer and retardative of dissipation '.
Charging a Leyden jar or heating a bar of iron is attended
by effects very different from those which attend the
feeding of an animal.
But without dwelling on this technical difference, though
it seems to us far-reaching, we may emphasize the fact that
the efficiency of the living creature considered as an engine
THE WONDER OF LIFE 473
is surprisingly greater than that of our best engines. A
steam-engine, for the most part made of iron, is a material
system for transforming the potential energy of coal into
heat and work. A living organism, in great part built up
of proteids, carbohydrates, and other carbon- compounds,
is also a material system for transforming the potential
energy of food into heat and work. But the living organism,
considered as an engine, is much more effective than the
locomotive. For while the best steam-engine turns only
about twelve per cent, of its income of potential energy
into work ; the animal can give back as much as twenty-
five per cent. Moreover, the actual waste of heat in the
steam-engine is much greater than in the animal.
We need not elaborate the contrast between living
creatures and engines. To any one bent on maintaining
that organisms are engines, we would point out that they
are self -stoking, self -repairing, self -regulating, self-adjust-
ing, self-resting, self-increasing, and self-reproducing
engines !
In his interesting book, The Cell as the Unit of Life,
Dr. Allen Macfadyen wrote :
' A great part of physiological inquiry has consisted
in the examination and explanation, not of life but of the
mechanism of life, and so far as this mechanism is con-
cerned, adequate and satisfactory explanations have been
found in the ordinary laws of physics. It is when we come
to cellular activities that our real difficulties begin as regards
the essentially vital problems '.
It is interesting to look up the works of Professor W.
Koux, a hard-headed anatomist and embryologist, the
pioneer in the modern study of ' developmental mechanics ',
to notice how constantly, in spite of that word ' mechanics,'
474 THE WONDER OF LIFE
which he uses in a wide sense, he refers to ' self-preserva-
tion ', ' self-increase ', ' self-adjustment ', ' self -differentia-
tion ', ' self-regulation ', and so on.
Another note may be useful at this stage, that an engine
or a machine is not exactly a fair example of the inanimate
world. It is a sort of non- protoplasmic extension of man's
hand. It is a human invention. One of the famous
automata had a clever dwarf shut up inside, and in a way
there is a human idea inside every machine. This makes
a difference.
The Insignia of Life. What are the radical differences
between a bird and the stone that kills it, between a tree
and the snow- crystals that transfigure it ? What does
livingness really mean ? As the innermost secret of life
eludes us, this section of the chapter might end with
the mark of interrogation. On the other hand, while we
do not understand what the essence of life is, it may not
be unprofitable to treat living creatures descriptively,
asking ourselves how they differ from not-living things.
Many have tried to state in a few words the characteristics
of living organisms, but no formulation has won general
acceptance. The best we know is given by Roux, who
recognizes five ' elementary functions ' :
I. Self-disassimilation.
II. Self-preservation, including assimilation, growth,
movement, feeding, etc.
III. Self-multiplication.
IV. Self-development.
V. Self-regulation in the exercise of all functions, in-
cluding self-differentiation, self-adjustment, self-
adaptation, and in many organisms distinctly
recognizable psychical functions.
THE WONDER OF LIFE 475
Altogether, according to Roux, there are thirteen general
characters of living creatures, and we do not know of any
that he has omitted. Yet we venture to arrange the char-
acteristics somewhat differently.
Down-breaking and Up-building. Every normal
organism is like a whirlpool in the river, always changing
and yet more or less remaining the same. It is like the
sunlit top of a fountain rising in the air ; its component
elements are restlessly changing on their way up or on
their way down. Like a clock it is always running down
and always needing to be wound up ; but unlike a clock
it can wind itself up. Not indefinitely, indeed, but some
of the Calif ornian Big Trees (Sequoia gigantea) did it, as we
have seen, for two thousand years genuine Methuselahs !
The constructive, synthetic, up-building or winding-
up processes are summed up in the term Andbolism;
the destructive, analytic, down-breaking, running-down
processes are summed up in the term Katabolism, and both
are included in a term that covers both, Metabolism, for
which we have, unfortunately, no English equivalent no
word like the fine German word ' Stoffwechsel ', change of
stuff. Chemical change is universal, of course, but the
peculiarity in the case of organisms is the balancing of
accounts, the correlation of up-building with down-break-
ing, of the winding-up with the running-down. That is
the criterion of vital processes, biologically considered,
that they go on of themselves, that they form part of a
concatenated series of chemical processes somehow bound
into unity, a series in which the pluses balance the minuses,
and the thing goes on. It is idle to try to express it in
terms of what goes on in the sterilized chemical laboratory,
for, taken as a whole, it is something more. Isolate any
476 THE WONDER OF LIFE
particular reaction, and it is the same in the eagle as in the
test-tube ; but the riddle of life is that of the burning
bush nee tamen consumebatur.
The Power of Growing. Given a material system
that could balance accounts, that did not simply run down
brilliantly and fizzle out, like the flaring pill of potassium
thrown on the basin of water, the logically second criterion
is growth or self-increase. A surplus of income over
expenditure, that is the primal condition of organic growth
(for crystal growth and osmotic growth is not relevant at
all) ; the essential criterion is that out of material quite
different from itself the living creature is able to meet not
only current expenditure, but to lay by something for
growth. That income should exceed expenditure is the
obvious condition of organic growth.
The Capacity for Behaviour. The growth of an
organism implies an active assimilation, not a passive
accretion, but it makes more venturesome activity possible.
Having some reserves in hand is one of the conditions of
agency. In some of the simplest organisms it has been
observed that movement stops when certain substances
included in the living matter are used up, and does not begin
again until they are replaced. They are among the con-
ditions of behaviour, just as food and water are among the
conditions of the continued progress of a band of explorers.
But the life is more than meat.
When we study the activities of the very simplest
organisms we do not find that they are simple. The move-
ments of advance and retreat and re-advance exhibited
by some of the mysterious slime-fungi (Myxomycetes) are
beyond any re-description in terms of present-day chemis-
try and physics. They exhibit the rudiments of behaviour.
THE WONDER OF LIFE 477
The flowing movements of an amoeba cannot be inter-
preted as a result of local changes in surface tension, or the
like. Though surface tension phenomena are involved,
the movement is self-determined. Professor Jennings has
described the behaviour of an amoeba which pursued a
spherical cyst of Euglena for fifteen minutes. One amoeba
pursued another for a long time, finally capturing and
ingesting it. But after being carried for a short distance,
the prey partly escaped and was recaptured. It again
escaped, this time completely, but was pursued, overtaken,
recaptured, and again carried away. After five minutes
it escaped again, this time completely and successfully,
so that the hunter amoeba did not have its meal after all.
But this is more than surface tension.
It seems to be one of the insignia of life that the organism
registers within itself the results of its experiences. As
Professor W. K. Clifford said : ' It is the peculiarity of
living things not merely that they change under the
influence of surrounding circumstances, but that any change
which takes place in them is not lost, but retained, and
as it were built into the organism to serve as the foundation
for future actions '. As Professor Henri Bergson puts it :
* Its past, in its entirety, is prolonged into its present, and
abides there, actual and acting '.
To begin with, there must be a viable balance of up-
building and down-breaking the essential modus vivendi ;
then there must be addition to the specific structure, so
that some rest is possible in one part while another is
working hard ; along with that will go the accumulation
of some capital, so that the organism is not always living
from hand to mouth ; this makes more energetic action
possible, and more thorough re-creation of the specific
478 THE WONDER OF LIFE
structure. Thus we may begin to think of the conditions
of agency, of experimenting, of trafficking with time, and
of multiplying.
Power of Reproducing. Growth is self -increase, and
it leads on to reproduction which is self-multiplication.
In a simple organism a nucleated corpuscle of living
matter growth proceeds up to a certain point which
we call the limit of growth. Beyond that it is dangerous
for the corpuscle to grow, unless indeed it secures at the
same time great increase of surface. We have already
referred (p. 396) to what was pointed out by Herbert
Spencer and others, that if the corpuscle be a sphere, as it
often is, the volume (whose contents have to be kept alive)
increases as the cube of the radius, whereas the surface
(through which the keeping alive is effected) increases
only as the square. Thus if it grow beyond a certain size,
the corpuscle gets into difficulties. There is also an
optimum ratio between the nucleus and the rest of the
cell-substance.
Development. We are trying to see the essential
criteria of life in a logical order. The power of sustained
metabolism of balancing accounts makes activity and
growth possible ; growth naturally leads on to multiplica-
tion ; and the power of development that an isolated frag-
ment, or sample, or, it may be, germ-cell possesses of re-
expressing the whole is surely a continuation of the restitu-
tion and regrowth which goes on to make good the body's
wear and tear, and of the regeneration which is exhibited
when a lost part is replaced. Development is the making
visible of the latent manifoldness of the liberated fragment,
or sample, or cell. It is the expression of latent possi-
bilities it is, subjectively regarded, a kind of self-expres-
THE WONDER OF LIFE 479
sion. Out of the apparently simple there arises the obvi-
ously complex, as the chicken is ' coined and minted out
of the egg '. There are the two great processes : differen-
tiation (which is the structural side of division of labour),
and integration (which means the unification and har-
monization and controlling of all the parts). The develop-
ing creature becomes more visibly complex ; it also becomes
knit together as a unity. Development always implies
these two processes.
Variability. It is well known that some of the simplest
organisms which remain single cells occur in different
forms and with different qualities in different circumstances.
Thus the same Bacterium may be virulent or relatively
attenuated in its poisoning capacity, and ' polymorphic '
Protozoa, e.g. some Trypanosomes, are described. It does
not seem that these diversities are simply individually
acquired peculiarities, due to some peculiarity in the parti-
cular environment. They may have arisen in some such
way, but they often appear to have taken grip of the con-
stitution ; they are not individual, but racial peculiarities,
and will persist for a while even when the environment is
altered.
This variability of the living organism is characteristic
and fundamental. It has to be accepted, at present, as a
primary fact of life, but some suggestions may be considered
which tend to leave it less apart. In the inanimate world
there is a tendency in matter to complexify, for atoms to
build up molecules, and molecules larger molecules, and so
on. There is also a certain variability in the crystallization
of one and the same chemical substance, which may appear
in several different forms. Every one has looked at the
beautiful diversity among snow-flakes. Now it may be
480 THE WONDER OF LIFE
that the tendency to complexify that is seen in things
inanimate is carried on into organisms, and finds expression
in variation.
There are many peculiarities in the bodies of higher
animals which are certainly not the direct results of some
peculiarity in the environment, but are, we believe, the
expression of variations in the germinal substance. Yet it
has to be remembered in regard to these variations that the
environmental peculiarities may have served to prompt
the germ- cells to some internal re-arrangement of their
organization.
Weismann has laid emphasis on the fact that the ger-
minal substance in the germ-cells is subjected to the changes
and fluctuations in the nutritive stream, and it is possible
that these may serve to prompt germinal variations. He
has also suggested that there may be within the germ-cell
a literal struggle among the hereditary items or factors,
just as there is a struggle among the different parts of the
body.
Another consideration is this, that in the ripening of the
egg-cell there appears to be an opportunity for the dropping
out of hereditary items, and as a matter of fact we know
that items are very often dropped out. In albinos a pig-
ment-producing or pigment-completing factor is dropped
out. Moreover, in fertilization, as we have seen, there are
opportunities for new permutations and combinations,
when the paternal and maternal contributions enter into
intimate and orderly union. Two sex-cells become one
a unified individual, not merely an inheritance-packed cell.
In the compromise effected between similar items, in the
unified organization arrived at, there is probably many an
opportunity for something new.
THE WONDER OF LIFE 481
Simulacra Vitae. Biitschli, following Quincke, showed
how mimic cells might be produced by putting drops of
fine emulsions in suitable media. Some old olive oil beaten
up with a little powdered potassium carbonate forms a
very fine emulsion an acid in the oil attacking the salt
and liberating microscopic vacuoles of carbon dioxide.
The resulting emulsion is a microscopic foam, and micro-
photographs of drops of it look like micro-photographs
of some kinds of cells. For a time this resemblance gave
corroboration to the view that the minute structure of
cell-substance or cytoplasm was of the nature of a very
fine foam or emulsion, though of course made of very much
more complex materials than olive oil. It cannot be said,
however, that recent histological research has given support
to this interpretation.
It is doubtful whether these simulacra vitse throw much
light on the structure and activity of living cells, though
it is quite probable that they may have a bearing on the
formation of non-living bodies made by organisms, such
as shells and pearls, spicules and calcareous corpuscles.
If a weak solution of gelatine is spread on a slide and tiny
drops of ferrocyanide of potassium are put on at intervals
of five millimetres or so, the result is the production of
rather striking simulacra of nucleated cells. But do these
simulacra in relatively simple material throw much light
on the structure of vital units ? They are as remote as
concentrically laminated agates are from tree-stems, as
remote as the beautiful dendritic growths of manganese
dioxide are from zoophytes.
Professor Stephane Leduc has given much time to the
study of wonderful inorganic growths which he is able to
induce, and they certainly show what complex and beauti-
J l
482 THE WONDER OF LIFE
ful structures may arise in relatively simple media. Thus if
fragments of calcium chloride be dropped into a litre of dis-
tilled water containing sixty grains of silicate of potassium,
sixty grains of saturated solution of carbonate of soda,
and thirty grains of saturated dibasic phosphate of soda,
then beautiful phantasms arise ' osmotic growths ' like
mushrooms and moulds and corals and shells. They
show us the possibilities of inorganic growth, and perhaps
they may be of service in bringing into stronger relief what
is distinctive in organic growth. They may be of use
for comparison with osmotic phenomena in organisms,
but we are unable to see that they throw much light on the
essential nature of growth in organisms. It appears to us
to be giving an entirely false simplicity to the facts to
suggest that Biology is a subdivision of the physico-
chemistry of fluids. This is a survival of the uncritical
materialistic superstition, and to credit the artificial
osmotic growths with nutrition, assimilation, irritability,
and a power of development is a bad instance of an asser-
tion that outstrips its evidence.
Difficult Phenomena. However much more it may
be, living certainly is the correlation of a series of physical
and chemical processes that go on within the organism. But
it is impossible to ignore a thicket of difficulties. Even after
the organization has been fatally shattered, parts of the body
may continue active. A wasp, indeed, may continue sucking
syrup though some tough friend of the public comfort has
cut right through its waist. On the other hand, it is not
easy to find evidence of activity in the hibernating snail,
or in the resting pupae of some insects, and yet life has not
sped. There is nothing in either case by which we could
very readily prove to the sceptical that death had not
THE WONDER OF LIFE 483
occurred, though microscopic examination would show
that some of the cells were alive. But how much more
difficult the question becomes when we pass to dried up
paste-eels, small thread- worms or Nematodes of the family
Anguillulidse, which can remain dry and brittle for as
long as fourteen years, and yet become lively again when
restored to water ! What is life in these inert threads,
which exhibit no sign of living ? What has happened in
the fifteenth year, when although no visible change has
occurred, the threads are no longer susceptible to the
reviving influence of water ? They are dead ; but what
has happened ?
Latent Life. The familiar sight of bags of dry seeds
in the seedsman's shop raises many questions. In what
state is the life of these seeds for it is to be hoped that
most of them are still alive ? Can they remain alive
without actually living ? Vital processes involve chemical
change (metabolism) : has metabolism come to a stand-
still or is it going on very slowly ? It is not so easy to test
this as might be imagined, for the fire of life may be kept
burning so very, very low that no change is detectable in
the surrounding medium. Some plants can respire without
taking in oxygen from outside, and some others, e.g.
succulents, can respire without giving out any carbon
dioxide. Of course if the protoplasm is actually living it
is transforming energy, and if it has no income it must be
living on its own resources, therefore the life of seeds must
be limited. We know securely from Becquerel's careful
testing that seeds may germinate after resting for eighty-
seven years in a herbarium a hortus siccus indeed.
Becquerel has made important experiments on the
latent life of dry seeds. He showed, for instance, that the
484 THE WONDER OF LIFE
dry seed-coats of peas and beans, and of many others which
can germinate after prolonged desiccation, are air-proof.
When detached pieces were fitted on to the top of a tube
of mercury, above a Torricellian vacuum, no air was
drawn through even in months. Thus a dry seed is
peculiarly isolated. When the coats are wet, the absorp-
tion of water changes the situation, and gaseous exchange
begins.
Becquerel's later experiments are very striking. He took
seeds of wheat, mustard, and lucerne, and perforated their
coats ; dried them in a vacuum at 40 C. for six months ;
sealed them up in an almost exhausted tube for a year ;
submitted them to the temperature of liquid air ( 190)
for three weeks, and of liquid hydrogen (250) for three
days ; and then put them on moist cotton wool and they
germinated as usual ! In a review, Prof. Cavers gives
a terse statement of Becquerel's conclusion. ' Bec-
querel finds it impossible to conceive of " life " under the
conditions to which these seeds were subjected, and holds
that life can be interrupted completely not merely slowed
down with no prejudice to its resumption '.
Various fungoid organisms have been known to survive
twenty- two years' desiccation; various bacteria have
remained alive without air but with moisture for ten to
twenty years ; sediments containing various Protozoa
have shown re-vivification after five to six years. J. Noc
relates that some tubes with a little water and various
Protozoa were hermetically sealed in 1908, and were
recently examined. There was no trace of the Infusorians
which were there to start with, but there were encysted
Amoebae, some of which revived after ten days or so.
Some Protozoa dried on Tonkin commercial paper were
THE WONDER OF LIFE 485
revived after five years. One of these was a small Flagel-
late, Oikomonas termo.
Local Life. The phenomena of local life demand care-
ful consideration. On the one hand, we have many cases
of fragments which grow into wholes. On the other hand,
we have curious examples of parts which can live on for a
long time after the whole has been destroyed, though they
show little or no power of regeneration. Let us illustrate
the first set of cases first. Every one knows that a piece
of a branch or a piece of a potato will remain alive for a con-
siderable time after being cut off, and will in appropriate
conditions grow into a complete plant. Posts of wood,
believed toJbe dead, sometimes burst into leaf after they have
been driven into the ground. A small fragment of many a
plant, from Liverwort to Begonia, will grow into a complete
plant. And similarly, a fragment of sponge, of hydroid, of
sea-anemone, of certain worms, and so forth, can regrow the
whole. There is need of precise experiment to determine
the limits and conditions of these regenerations of wholes
from parts. In the case of Hydra, it has been found that
the regenerating fragment must not be too small a quanti-
tative limit, and that it must contain samples of the
different kinds of cells in the body a qualitative limit.
A tentacle will not regrow a polyp, though a polyp soon
regrows a tentacle. Very extraordinary are the recent
experiments of Professor H. V. Wilson which show that
some sponges may be minced up and strained through a
cloth strainer and yet the debris poured out in an appro-
priate place will develop into a proper sponge. It is a
verification of one of the old myths of Zagreon, who
was cut into pieces and yet survived.
As to the second set of cases, where parts live on though
486 THE WONDER OF LIFE
without regenerative power or only a little of it, we may
recall the familiar case of the turtle's heart, which, in
appropriate conditions, will continue beating for several
days after the bulk of the animal has been made into soup,
and has passed into a new incarnation. There it goes on
beating in its warm and humid glass case a fine illustra-
tion of local life.
Of recent years very remarkable experiments have been
made in keeping pieces of tissue alive in suitable media
outside the body. What happens in most cases is that they
live on for a time, grow a little, and die. Perhaps we should
know a good deal if we understood why they die. It has
been suggested that the death may be contingent rather
than necessary, that it may be due, for instance, to the
accumulation of waste products. With this idea in mind,
Alexis Carrel has devised a system of artificial rejuven-
escence, washing the piece of tissue from time to time in
' Ringer's solution ', and placing it in a medium of plasma
and distilled water. A piece of connective tissue revived
nine times after this bathing treatment staving off senes-
cence and death for more than a month after its removal
from the body.
Every one knows that egg-cells can remain for a long
time alive but without developing. Much more remarkable
is the fact that spermatozoa can be kept alive in a salt
solution for a week. Very much more remarkable is the
fact that isolated red blood corpuscles, of the newt for
instance, can be kept alive for a fortnight. Jolly took a
small quantity of blood directly from the newt's heart,
put it in a tube placed in ice, and found the white blood
corpuscles alive after 4| months. Verily the tenacity of
life is great.
THE WONDER OF LIFE 487
Powers of Life. Life is a powerful kind of activity.
We see this in many ways in the power of self-increase
that is so characteristic of living matter, one Infusorian
becoming a million in a week ; in the associated power
of transforming matter, the green plant changing air,
water, and salts into bread, the animal changing the plant
into flesh ; in the economical transformations of energy,
for as we have already mentioned, an organism considered
as an engine gives more return for the potential energy
supplied to it (the food or fuel) than any engine of man's
device ; in the capacity for storing potential energy without
much leakage, as we see so convincingly in the trees of
the forest ; in the manifoldness of the energy-transform-
ations that are accomplished, for we find one and the same
creature doing work, giving off heat, giving off light, and
exhibiting electrical changes ; in the exquisite responsive-
ness, for a sundew tentacle will detect the presence of a
minute drop of ammonium carbonate added to a large jar
of water, and the earthworm, though without ears, is aware
of the light tread of a thrush's foot. As it is impossible
to discuss all the powers of life, our method must be, as
throughout, only illustrative. We shall discuss two
powers or capacities as different as possible the power of
giving forth light, and the power of taking a rest in sleep.
Luminescence. In illustration of the powers of life,
let us take the phenomenon of luminescence, or, as it has
been erroneously called, phosphorescence. From the
chemico-physical point of view, the organism is a material
system which effects the transformation of matter and
energy. It is the seat of continuous chemical changes
oxidations and reductions, hydrations and fermentations
which we sum up in the term metabolism. There is no
488
THE WONDER OF LIFE
doubt that the production of light is one of the results of
this metabolism. Just as heat is produced by the vital
activity of the muscles (their characteristic ' thermogenic '
function) and by all the combustions that go on in the
body, so light is produced in connexion with other chemical
processes involved in living. Many facts point to the con-
CHB-
FIG. 78. Phosphorescent cell. (After Watase.) c, Cytoplasm of the
cell ; CHB, Chromosomes of the nucleus living constituents.
A, Food ; PH, Photogenic Granules not living constituents.
Oxygen acts on the photogenic granules, and Light emanates
from the cell as the result of oxidation.
elusion that the luminescence need not be in itself of any
biological importance, any more than the heat produced
in the active brain is normally of any importance, any
more than the beautiful colour of some organic waste
products is in itself of any importance. But just as the
production of heat or of pigment may be turned to good
THE WONDER OF LIFE 489
account and made vitally important, so it may be with
the production of light.
The facts in regard to luminescence in organisms raise
many unanswered questions and demand further investiga-
tion, but there is no particular difficulty about the bare
fact that light is produced in laboratories which give off
heat, as we all experience, and generate electricity, as we
may experience on close acquaintance with the Electric
Eel or the Torpedo.
A noteworthy fact in regard to luminescence is its wide
distribution in the sea. When the oars drip sparks on a
summer night we see the luminescence of Noctiluca ; and
there are many pelagic animals some Radiolarians, some
Medusae, most Ctenophores, some ' worms ', many crus-
taceans, a few molluscs, Tunicates like the splendid Pyro-
soma, and various surface fishes which are luminescent.
In the shore area there are luminescent Echinoderms,
especially Brittle-stars ; the boring Pholads with their
miners' lamps ; and various members of the great alliance
of Stinging Animals or Ccelenterates. In the great abysses,
as we have noticed, luminescence is common, e.g. among
Alcyonarians, Medusae, Echinoderms, Crustaceans, Cuttle-
fishes, and true fishes. On land we know it best in glow-
worms, fire-flies, and other insects, but it also occurs in
some Myriopods (e.g. Geophilus electricus), and in some
earthworms (e.g. Photodrilus). It is usually said to be
quite absent in freshwater animals, but we have some
suspicions as to the accuracy of this generalization, bearing
in mind Nelson Annandale's freshwater Lampyrid and
allegations of luminescent Chironomid larvae. That there
are phosphorescent Bacteria is well known every one can
see them on fish hung up to dry and it is probable that
490 THE WONDER OF LIFE
reports of luminous birds are due to luminescent fungi
on the plumage.
In a case like trie luminescence of Bacteria, no one even
looks for a utilitarian explanation. The luminescence is a
by-play of vitality ; it is one of the residual powers of the
organism ; and it is probably exhibited in many cases in
which we do not and cannot see it. What we need to know
is (1) the internal physiology of luminescence, and (2)
what its use may be in certain cases where it bears the marks
of specialization.
The luminescence is in some cases indissolubly connected
with the cellular metabolism as in Noctiluca, Brittle-stars,
and some fishes. When they die their light goes out.
In other cases the luminescent material is not luminescent
until it is exuded from its producer into the water, as in
many Copepods. The light does not require contact with
life to keep it shining. The trail of the luminous Myriopod
is luminous, and in some cases (Copepods, Lampyrids,
and Pholads) the luminous secretion can be dried and
yet retain its capacity of giving forth light when it is put
into water after several days, weeks, or months.
In the American Lampyrid beetles, popularly called fire-
flies, the light-producing organ, as described by McDermott
and Crane, consists of two layers. The inner one, white
and opaque, seems to serve as a reflector, and perhaps
protects the insect from its own brightness. The outer
one, yellowish and translucent, is the seat of the actual
photogenic process. It is interesting to know that innu-
merable air-tubes or tracheae penetrate the organ, for
this bears out the conclusion otherwise arrived at, that
the luminescence is due to an oxidation.
In the American fire-fly both sexes are luminescent, the
THE WONDER OF LIFE 491
flightless female less so than her active partner. The
luminescent organs of the male consist of a pair of plates,
lying beneath the skin on the ventral surface of the fourth
and fifth abdominal segments. Each plate has two layers,
and the lower is built up of polygonal cells filled with
coarse granules. In this lower layer there is probably a
rapid oxidation of some unstable substance, perhaps of a
fatty nature. It is possible that the decomposition may
be accelerated by some ferment. Mrs. A. B. Howard has
called attention to the fact that the light is unaccompanied
by perceptible heat. It is therefore produced at the least
possible expenditure of energy, as Professor Langley long
ago pointed out.
In fire-flies of the genus Luciola the light given off
has a beautiful green fluorescence, and is able, like X-rays,
to affect a photographic plate through opaque media, such
as layers of wood or leather. The light cannot be taken
as phosphorescent, but includes rays which are, at least,
' similar to X-rays and ultra-violet light in so far as they
render certain opaque media transparent, and are inter-
cepted by glass '.
In an interesting study on the luminous organs of cuttle-
fishes, Dr. W. E. Hoyle calls attention to their occurrence
in so many and such scattered families, that repeated and
independent origination seems probable. They are almost
always on the ventral surface of the Cephalopod, but they
occur there in nine different situations. Sometimes they are
concealed beneath the mantle or beneath the skin, but
they may be effective even then, since the living tissues
of cuttlefishes are very transparent. It is plausible to
suppose that they serve as recognition marks, and that
they act as searchlights, playing over the floor of the sea.
492 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Some of them are simple, but others have a complicated
optical apparatus with some or all of the following structures
pigment layer, reflector, lens, and diaphragm. While
we may say that the production of light is parallel to the
production of heat in a muscle or of electric discharges in
Torpedo, there must be some definite utility when the organs
have a complicated apparatus. Very noteworthy is the
remarkable economy of the illuminant ; a quite infinites-
imal proportion of the energy is wasted on the production
of heat.
In two surface fishes of the Malay Archipelago,
Anomalops katoptron a,nd.Photoblepharon palpebralis, studied
by 0. Steche (1909), there are very large luminous organs
about the head, which seem to give out a constant light
without requiring any particular stimulus. The lumin-
escence has its seat in material secreted by glandular cells,
and occurs outside the cells in the cavity of the gland which
they form. In the fishes we have mentioned, the lumin-
escent organ can be, so to speak, extinguished by a down-
ward movement, which possibly takes place when an enemy
appears on the scene.
Messrs. Holt and Byrne describe a remarkable deep-water
fish, Lamprotoxus, from the south-west coast of Ireland.
It bore a filamentous barbule many times longer than the
body. The colour of the scaleless skin was velvety-
black and the barbule was grey. A purplish-grey cord-like
band of luminous tissue, partially embedded in the skin,
formed a closed loop on the anterior part of the body.
There was also a large photophore behind and slightly
below the eye, occluded by skin save for a narrow slit ;
and there were numerous very small photophores.
There is little direct evidence as to the use of luminescence,
THE WONDER OF LIFE
493
and, as we have said, there are probably many cases where
it is of no use. But this cannot be the case when it is
associated with highly specialized organs. And when we
see a female glow-worm with luminescent organs on the
under side of the body turning herself back downwards
with the result, at any rate, that her light is visible, we
find it difficult to believe that the light is not attractive to
FIG. 79. A remarkable fish, Lamprotoxus flagellibarba, from deep
water off S.W. of Ireland. The small spots and the ' looped
band ' seem to be luminous organs. The barbel is many times
longer than the body, which is about seven inches in length. (After
Holt and Byrne.)
the male. Many animals move towards a light, and it is a
very probable view that the luminescence of many marine
animals helps to bring food to them. Professor Max Weber
mentions the very interesting fact that the fishermen of
Banda cut out the luminous organ of Anomalops and similar
fishes, and use it as a bait, for it keeps on shining for hours.
A sudden illumination of a luminous organ, or a sudden
discharge of a luminous secretion may have a protective
494 THE WONDER OF LIFE
value. In the darkness of the great abysses some animals
may possibly use their luminous organs as lanterns. Where
the luminous organs are arranged on a definite pattern
which is sometimes different in the two sexes it is quite
likely that they serve as recognition marks. But for our
present purpose it is enough to indicate that this peculiar
transformation of energy not in itself necessarily useful
may be seized upon, utilized, and specialized towards diverse
ends by different types.
Sleep. It appears to us to be characteristic of the life
or activity of organisms that it can be slowed down and
quickened again. We may hunt out analogies, such as
that of a fire which, after vigorous burning, smoulders,
and then breaks out again ; but no mere mechanisms have
the organism's power of taking a rest, and one of the many
forms of rest is ordinary sleep that familiar but puzzling
state in which we spend about a third part of our existence.
Analogous but quite different vital adjustments are to be
seen in the hibernation of such animals as snail and dor-
mouse, and in the so-called ' sleep ' of plants which often
makes itself plain in the altered position of the leaves and
the closing of the flowers.
Normally, there can be no doubt, the sleeping habit was
established in relation to sunset, but every one knows that
we can adjust our capacity for going to sleep so as to suit
our particular circumstances. The important point is,
that once the habit is established, say of going to sleep at
11 p.m., it asserts itself with some insistence unless the
attention is strongly diverted. In the course of a short
time, varying with the individual, the rhythm can be
changed and the man sleeps as soundly (other things equal)
by day as he formerly did by night.
THE WONDER OF LIFE 495
Animals accustomed to sleep will die in a few days if
they are deprived of it ; in some cases, much .sooner, as
has been shown experimentally, than if they are deprived
of food. What, then, is it that goes on during sleep that
makes it necessary ? What is the physiological condition
during sleep ?
In a recent lecture, Legendre summed up the state of
affairs : Digestion goes on, and this may lessen the blood-
supply to the brain ; perspiration and excretion go on ;
the respiratory movements are altered, being usually
slower, deeper, and more regular ; relatively less carbonic
acid is given off ; the body temperature falls ; the action
of the heart is slowed and the arterial blood pressure
diminishes ; there is a relative angemia of the brain ; the
working of the sense-organs is altered ; the muscles are
generally relaxed and the reflexes tend to disappear ;
and there are other differences of a subtler sort. But it
cannot be said that there is in this narration anything
that in particular gives us the clue to the significance of
sleep.
There is a superabundance of theories in regard to the
cause of sleep, but, until recently, it was the delight of
physiologists to show that none of them was adequate.
It has been suggested that a relative anaemia of the brain
left the nerve-cells without enough of food or encumbered
with imperfectly removed waste. It has been suggested
that changes in the condition of the blood produced sleep.
It has been suggested that wearied nerve-cells contracted
and lost that touch with one another that they have during
waking hours. It has been suggested that the creature
becomes irresponsive and indifferent to the outside stimuli
that keep it agog in its waking hours. But, as Claparede
496 THE WONDER OF LIFE
points out, these suggestions cannot be solutions ; they
simply shunt the problem. For why this periodic change
in the now of blood to the brain, why the retraction of the
nerve cells, why the unresponsiveness to outside stimu-
lation ?
In a luminous lecture on sleep, Professor Fraser Harris
distinguishes four types chemical, vascular, sensory, and
psychic. (1) Sleep may be due to fatigue- toxins, the
poisonous waste-products of exertion, just as it may be
induced by drugs. The nerve- cells in the brain no longer
exhibit their normal interlinking (or synapsis) ; there is
resistance to incoming sensory messages. Men fall asleep
in the saddle or on forced marches, and Holbein fell asleep
when swimming the Channel. (2) Sleep may be due to
diminution of the velocity of the cerebral blood flow, just
as may occur abnormally in some kinds of fainting. It has
been shown that the sleeping brain is paler, there is less
blood and a lower blood pressure. Mosso devised an ex-
periment of balancing a wide-awake man accurately on a
table, and showed that when he fell asleep the foot end
of the table sunk the dip indicating the depth of sleep.
When the heart is excited we cannot sleep. (3) Sleep
may be due to sensory changes, to an increase of the
' resistance ' at the interlinking (or synapsis) of the cells
in the sensory centres of the fore-brain, or a diminution
of conductivity at these interlinkings. When sensations
force their way in we cannot sleep. (4) Sleep may be due
to the absence of emotions and ideas ; thus stupid people
fall asleep easily. As Bergson has said, we do not go to
sleep if we are more interested in anything else than going
to sleep. When we are worried we cannot sleep.
Another approach to the problem of sleep is in the light
THE WONDER OF LIFE 497
of general biological facts. All activity implies a using
up of material, a using up of oxygen, and the formation
of waste-products. The nerve cells are in no way exempted,
and it has been demonstrated visually that the brain- cells
of a bee that has been working hard all day are in a different
condition from those in a brain that has been resting.
In a case of prolonged insomnia there was said to be a
disappearance of a readily stainable (chromatophilous)
substance located in what are called ' Nissl's granules '
in most nerve-cells. Moreover, the nerve-cells require to
keep up a store of intra- molecular oxygen. And besides
carbonic- acid gas, which is always being removed by the
blood, there are subtler wastes, ' fatigue toxins ', about
which we do not know very much. The general biological
view is therefore this, that persistent activity involves
using up of material and oxygen and an accumulation of
waste-products, such that the ' machinery ' has to go more
slowly, so that re- stoking and cleaning may be thoroughly
effected. It is conceivable, indeed, that it might have been
arranged that repair always kept pace with waste, and that
the organism never got into any physiological arrears at
all. It is probable that very simple organisms, such as the
' immortal ' Amoeba are in this happy state. But with
increasing complexity this ceased to be possible, and sleep
was invented. ' Blessed be the man ', said Sancho Panza,
' who invented sleep ', but we do not know at what precise
level of organization the invention was discovered. Prob-
ably not until the cerebral cortex was well differentiated.
The general biological theory is consistent with many
familiar facts : The greatly fatigued organism falls asleep ;
it awakens from sleep refreshed. And it is remarkably
confirmed by Legendre's delicate experiment of injecting
K K
498 THE WONDER OF LIFE
into a normal animal the serum, or, better, the cerebro-
spinal fluid of an animal exhausted by loss of sleep. In
about half an hour there is induced an imperative need for
' The animal so injected is benumbed little by little, its
eyelids blink, its limbs relax, its eyes close, it loses all
attention, and it responds but feebly to strong stimulation.
Its brain presents the characteristic lesions of insomnia.
The injections, under the same conditions, of liquids from
a normal animal have no effect at all '.
It seems evident, then, that in some form or other, the
injection from the exhausted animals acts like a sleeping
draught.
It seems to us very probable that there are many cases
where this general biological theory of sleep is quite suffi-
cient. The successful long-lived animals are those that
can take rests. There has been an age-long selection of
the methodical, who work when they work, and rest when
they rest. An established rhythm of alternate working
and resting pays best, and it has become conveniently
hitched on to the great external periodicity of day and
night. The works have to be slowed down to permit of
re-stoking and thorough cleaning, and these functions are
effected most readily when their recurrence is rhythmic.
It is very interesting, however, to find Legendre, physiolo-
gist as he is, declaring that although physiology has im-
portant and fundamental contributions to offer towards
a theory of sleep, ' physiology alone cannot dream of solving
the problem '. We understand that his view has particular
reference to Man and the higher vertebrates, where it seems
that psychological factors must also be taken into account.
THE WONDER OF LIFE 499
It appears to us probable, as we have hinted, that there are
levels in the animal kingdom at which the purely physio-
logical theory of sleep is adequate to cover all the facts. All
sleep is not the same sleep, any more than all flesh is the
same flesh.
Claparede objects to the purely physiological view on
various grounds. One can sleep without being fatigued,
and one may be too tired to sleep. If sleep were enforced
by the accumulation of fatigue-poisons, how is it that
many a man is so lively just a few minutes before he goes
to bed ? Could an auto-intoxication of the severity sug-
gested be endured night after night for threescore years and
ten ? One of the Siamese twins could sleep while the other
suffered from insomnia, yet their blood-vessels communi-
cated ! Perhaps there are answers to these objections,
but we shall not go into that. Our point is simply to show
that there are great difficulties in the way of the purely
physiological theory. Claparede maintains that an adequate
theory must be psychological as well.
Experiments made by Legendre and Pieron confirm
the theory that specific waste-products or fatigue-toxins
are formed during periods of prolonged wakefulness, that
these permeate the organism, and particularly affect the
frontal lobes of the brain. They prevented dogs from
sleeping, while tiring them as little as possible, and found
that about ten days was the limit of resistance.
' The temperature of the body remains normal, the res-
piration undergoes no variation, and the amount of carbon
dioxide in the blood does not increase, which enables us
to exclude the theories of the impoverishment of the blood
in oxygen and its enrichment in carbon dioxide as the actual
causes of sleep. Neither the blood nor the brain lose their
500 THE WONDER OF LIFE
proportion of water, and this fact combats the theories
that explain sleep by dehydration '.
When the animal can no longer keep its eyes open, and
has become almost quite unresponsive, the frontal lobe
shows cellular disturbances. If it is no longer kept awake,
it plunges into deep sleep, from which it awakens com-
pletely refreshed. It is quite normal again, and the alter-
ations in the brain have disappeared. It may be that
these experiments are on the way to the discovery of an
alleviation of one of the most terrible of human ills
insomnia.
Claparede's view is that sleep is more than a passive
obedience to internal physiological necessities, it is an
active defensive instinct. Just as the bird migrates in
autumn before there is external coercion, so we go to sleep
before there is an overpowering need. The physiological
conditions, such as the fatigue-producing substances, pull
the trigger of an old-established sleep-instinct. They
serve to make us take for the time being a great interest
in sleep. If a greater interest should be aroused, sleepiness
disappears like magic ; the child who could hardly keep its
eyes open, does not want to go to bed at all when there is
sudden news of a great fire to be seen. When our interest
for the moment is greater in sleep than in anything else,
and that implies inducing external and internal conditions
to which we have become habituated, then we are asleep
before we know it.
It comes to this, that long ago, those animals got on best
which established a rhythm of work and rest, corresponding
on the whole to the periodicity of day and night, and later
on that some of their successors got on best which developed
THE WONDER OF LIFE 501
a sleep-instinct or hereditary predisposition to sleep,
obedient rather to trigger-pulling physiological conditions
than to coercive auto-intoxication or the like.
We cannot conclude this section on sleep without sug-
gesting the desirability of trying to bring numerous dis-
tantly or nearly related phenomena into line. A great
reward awaits the successful investigator. Perhaps it
is impossible to put the numerous analogous phenomena
into any one series, but it would be progress to know why
this could not be. If we start with normal diurnal sleep,
we have many associated phenomena, such as (a) very
prolonged slumbers, (6) trance, (c) coma, (d) hibernation,
(e) prolonged latent life. If we go back again to normal
diurnal sleep, we have in another direction, or perhaps in
other directions, such phenomena as fainting, catalepsy,
the so-called sleep of insects, ' feigning death ', paralysis.
And then there are the various forms of artificial ansesthesia,
such as chloroforming (which has, of course, been very
thoroughly studied), to ' the shortest way out of Slum-
town ', (which has been very thoroughly practised).
THE SUBTLETY OF LIFE
One of the most striking biological discoveries of the
twentieth century is that of anaphylaxis a difficult term
for a very remarkable phenomenon which illustrates ex-
ceedingly well what we venture to call the subtlety of life.
To understand what the phenomenon is, some introductory
exposition is necessary.
It is well known that certain common infectious diseases,
such as scarlet fever, produce a poison within the body,
and that if the patient recovers he is for the future (in most
502 THE WONDER OF LIFE
cases) invulnerable or ' immune ' so far as that particular
poison is concerned. In conquering the poison of the
disease the body produces anti-toxins, which remain as a
chemical body-guard, preventing the same disease from
getting in again. In a similar way the anti-toxin
produced as a reaction to the mild poison introduced in
vaccination is a preventive or an immunization against
subsequent poisoning from small-pox. This is the first
point to be apprehended.
It is also very well known that there are many poisons,
such as the nicotine of tobacco, which render the individual
increasingly tolerant of them if their use is persisted in.
Thus, the confirmed ' opium-eater ' can imbibe or inject
a dose which would immediately kill a normal individual,
and which would have been fatal to himself if he had not
accustomed himself to gradually increased quantities. De
Quincey, in his Confessions, tells us that he gave to a
wandering Malay who came to his door, a piece of opium
large enough to kill six dragoons and their horses if they
were not used to it ! The Malay received it with delight,
broke it into three pieces, and immediately swallowed
them all. De Quincey's own allowance at one period of
his life was said to be eight thousand drops of laudanum a
day. In any case, it is certain that the body becomes
increasingly tolerant of certain poisons.
Anaphylaxis. The new fact which has been discovered
by the eminent French physiologist, Professor Charles
Bichet, is that certain poisons when introduced into the
system enormously increase the susceptibility of the organ-
ism to the toxic action of that particular substance. This fact
was apparently not unknown to some of the earlier
physiologists, but it was not clearly recognized as other
THE WONDER OF LIFE 503
than an obscure anomaly (always a clue to be followed
up), till Kichet tackled it in 1902, and coined for it the
name Anaphylaxis a companion word to prophylaxis,
which means protection against a disease. (See Richet's
V AnapTiylaxie, Paris, 1912.)
Let us follow Professor Richet's work. One of his early
experiments was with the poison in the stinging cells
of the sea-anemone's tentacles a poison which we can feel
if we have the courage to put the tip of our tongue to the
sea-anemone's mouth. Our finger will not suffice, for the
poison- bathed lassoes of the stinging cells are not suffi-
ciently strong to penetrate the skin of our hands. Richet
made an extract by soaking the tentacles of Actinia in
glycerine, and he injected the poison thus obtained
into the veins of a dog. He found that a rather large dose
was required to cause death, but what came to him as a
surprise was the discovery that a dog which had fully
recovered from treatment and was subjected to a fresh injec-
tion a month afterwards, succumbed to a dose of about one-
twentieth the original strength. It might be suggested
that the poison was cumulative, and that the second dose
was the last straw that broke the camel's back, but the
improbability of this was evidenced by the time that had
elapsed since the previous injection and by the smallness
of the second dose. The only possible conclusion from
this and other experiments was, that the first dose brings
about a peculiar physiological condition which makes the
organism hyper-sensitive to subsequent doses.
A further step, was taken in 1903, when M. Arthus
showed that the anaphylactic condition could be induced
by a substance, such as blood-serum, which is not in itself
toxic. A rabbit, which had been injected with a dose of
5o 4 THE WONDER OF LIFE
horse-serum without showing any signs of disturbance,
a month later succumbed at once on receiving an injection
of one-twentieth the quantity of the original amount.
Anaphylaxis is invariably specific. That is to say, an
animal which has been rendered hyper-sensitive to one
particular substance, is not affected in any peculiar way by
a subsequent injection of another substance, not even by
a different kind of blood-serum. This has a curious appli-
cation in the practice of medical jurisprudence. It supplies
a new and conclusive method of determining the source of
a quantity of blood, for instance whether it is human or
not. Suppose there be in readiness a set of guinea-pigs
which have been treated, a month or so before, with large
doses of the serum of different creatures man, dog, horse,
and so on ; a solution of the blood to be identified is
injected into each of them ; one reacts and the others
remain unaffected ; the blood to be identified came from
the kind of organism whose serum had been injected
into the guinea-pig which reacted.
Another remarkable experiment was made with guinea-
pigs for here, as in other cases, this stupid rodent justifies
its existence by proving a remarkably fine subject for
experiment. Its sensitiveness to a given substance may
be increased five thousand times, which makes very delicate
testing possible. The experiment was that of injecting
into a set of guinea-pigs an extract of the muscle of a human
mummy, and after an interval other muscle extracts from
various organisms. But the guinea-pigs proved the
specific nature of anaphylaxis, they reacted only to extract
of human muscle, ' thus proving, if proof were needed, that
the chemical constitution of the human body has not
notably varied in the last three or four thousand years '.
THE WONDER OF LIFE 505
The medical aspects of anaphylaxis do not concern us
here, but we may note that Professor Richet regards the
phenomenon as throwing light on the diagnostic value of
tuberculin, and probably also on the occasional terrible
accidents which for a time almost discredited it as a thera-
peutic agent. This latter point is still under investigation.
The ' serum disease ', too, which sometimes follows the
use of anti- toxin and inoculation for plague is probably
to be explained in the same way. Cases are described
which seem to show that a substance may be prophylactic
against a particular disease, bringing about a condition of
immunity, and, at the same time, anaphylactic against
itself, inducing hyper-sensitiveness to even small doses.
The simultaneous development of immunity and anaphy-
laxis may serve to illustrate what we mean by the
subtlety of life. From a practical point of view it is
comforting to learn that the physiologists have already
devised an ' anti-anaphy lactic method of procedure '.
No crystallizable substance is known to produce anaphy-
laxis, but almost any colloid substance (i.e. an albuminoid
unable or hardly able to pass through organic membranes)
may do so under certain conditions. Among these con-
ditions are, that a certain time an incubation period
must elapse between the doses, and that the substance
serum, egg, milk, muscle-extract, vegetable extract,
sea-anemone extract, or whatever it may be must be
introduced into the circulation. ' Alimentary anaphy-
laxis ', i.e. through eating the substance in question, seems
to come about very rarely, and the reason for this is obvious,
since it is not the substance itself, but the result of the
digestion of the substance, that passes from the food-canal
into the circulation. But the rare exceptions are of great
506 THE WONDER OF LIFE
interest, since they are the people known to us all, to whom
' eggs are poison ', who cannot digest milk in any form,
or who cannot eat a particular kind of shellfish without
more or less serious symptoms, such as nettlerash and
fever. Instances are known of people becoming very
seriously ill through having unconsciously partaken of some
disguised form of the substance to which they have such
a violent constitutional antipathy. A scientific light is
thrown on the adage, ' what is one man's food is another
man's poison '. In this connection, again, the phenomenon
of anaphylaxis is absolutely specific, and Dr. Bichet cites
the case of a man who always showed violent symptoms
after eating even a perfectly fresh shrimp, yet who could
indulge freely in lobster without inconvenience. He
strained at a gnat, but could swallow a camel with ease.
Another complexity is what is called ' passive anaphy-
laxis '. That is to say, if the blood of an animal which
has been anaphylactized in regard to a particular sub-
stance be injected into another animal, that also becomes
anaphylactic to the same substance. A little seems to
go a long way in producing a remarkable change. Inter-
esting also is the fact that anaphylaxis in a mother, acquired
either before or after conception, may be acquired by her
offspring, so that they are born anaphylactic. Diffusion
of a substance from the mother's blood to the offspring's
must have occurred during the ante-natal life. But the
condition of congenital anaphylaxis is not of long duration.
In guinea-pigs it was noted on the forty-fourth day, but
had disappeared by the seventieth.
Professor Kichet's theory of anaphylaxis, that is of the
precise way in which the condition is brought about, is
too technical for our present purpose. Suffice it to say
THE WONDER OF LIFE 507
that he regards the first introduction of the albuminoid
substance as modifying the blood by producing in it,
during the so-called incubation period, a chemical sub-
stance, which is not in itself toxic, but which is capable of
becoming immediately and violently toxic in the presence
of the original albuminoid.
Chemical Individuality. One of the general ideas
that rises in the mind after a consideration of some of the
facts of anaphylaxis, is that of the chemical individuality
of an organism. It is characteristic fundamentally
characteristic of an organism that it carries its past into
its present, that ' time bites into it ' as Bergson puts it,
and there is often very considerable variety in individual
experience. Many different kinds of substances enter into
the organism, and some of them may bring about modifica-
tion, either in the direction of anaphylactization or immuni-
zation, and thus each individual of a species may differ
from every other in chemical composition. We know
indeed experimentally that there are these individual
differences, some of them probably germinal or innate,
some of them modificational or extrinsic, in origin. An
individual is an individual not only to his finger-prints,
but to his chemical molecules. And it seems to us that
the anaphylaxis experiments clearly show that the vague
' idiosyncrasy ' of the past must give place to a more
definite conception of a chemical individuality which not
only expresses the new unity which is established in every
fertilized egg-cell, but embodies the results of the indivi-
dual's physiological history, just as his psychological
personality is ever registering his mental experiences.
But while there are minor idiosyncrasies (distinguishing
between the individual members of a species, distinguish-
508 THE WONDER OF LIFE
ing sometimes between the two sexes), there is also a
typical specific chemical constitution which cannot be
widely departed from if the species is to persist. The
muscle extract of a modern man pulled the anaphylactic
trigger in the guinea-pig which had been treated a month
before with extract of mummified muscle. We know in
other connections that there is a demonstrable specific differ-
ence between the blood of a horse and the blood of an ass.
There is a specific chemical constitution which is on the
whole the best for the species in question, being stamped
with survival-merit after thousands of disadvantageous
aberrations have been sifted away through thousands of
years. Thus we come back from anaphylaxis to what was
said of old : ' All flesh is not the same flesh : but there is
one kind of flesh of men, another flesh of beasts, another of
fishes, and another of birds '. We are here close to the
idea of a chemical definition of a species, which will not
be other than complementary to a psychological one. And
it is here that Professor Bichet makes a notable contribution,
pointing out the specific or racial value of this curious pro-
perty of anaphylaxis.
' I am more and more convinced ', he writes, ' that every
detail of the organism has a protective role, and is useful
and even necessary to life, and that, therefore, a great
general biological function like anaphylaxis must play
an essential part in the defence of organisms. So that
anaphylaxis appears to us an efficacious and energetic
method of maintaining the chemical stability of our bodies
by provoking an immediate and violent reactional response
to the introduction of any substance which might change
it. This is not the defence of the individual ; it is the
defence of the species at the cost of the individual '.
THE WONDER OF LIFE 509
Individuality of the Blood. What is called the serum
test for blood is a good illustration of the subtle individu-
ality of different creatures. If the serum of human blood
is injected into a rabbit, it produces a change in the rabbit's
blood of a very specific kind. As de Nobele showed in
1902, the serum of that rabbit will give a precipitate with
human blood, but not with the blood of other Mammals.
Thus if a murderer asserts that the bloodstains on his
clothes are due to his having killed a rabbit, not a man,
his statement can be tested ; and the method has passed
into the ordinary practice of medical jurisprudence. The
serum for testing with can be kept for months in a dry state
(after evaporation in a vacuum) without losing its relia-
bility, and bloodstains that are several months old may
be accurately identified. Of course the method has been
tested and re-tested hundreds of times, and little improve-
ments in detail have been introduced. It should be
noticed that the principle of the method was discovered
in relation to milk, and that it was applied in the identifica-
tion of different kinds of milk and different kinds of flesh
before it was applied to blood.
ADAPTATION
Wherever we look throughout the wide world of animate
nature, we find illustrations of particular fitness to parti-
cular conditions. The size, the shape, the colour of an
organism, the structure of parts in relation to their use
and in their relation to other parts all are adaptive. In
the same way the characteristic behaviour of the creature
in its everyday life, and the internal activities within the
body all are adaptive. And what is true of everyday
5io THE WONDER OF LIFE
activities, where one might attribute some of the effective-
ness to practice, is equally true of activities which are only
occasional, e.g. those connected with animal courtship
and parenthood. Almost every detail of specific structure
and specific behaviour may be interpreted as adaptive.
This term might simply mean that the structure or function
in question is fit, effective, well adjusted, making for the
preservation or well-being of the individual or of the species ;
but in biological usage it has also a theoretical implication
that the detail in question, if it be part of the hereditary
constitution or some expression of it, is the result of a
process of evolution. It was not always as it is now, it has
a history behind it, it is a product of the factors of evolu-
tion, whatever these may be.
There can be no doubt that no small part of the pleasure
we have in the contemplation of living creatures is related
to their effective fitness. As Sir J. Burdon Sanderson once
said in a lecture, ' the delight and interest with which the
forms, colours, and structure of animals and plants fill us is
derived from the conscious or unconscious perception by
our minds of their adaptation their fitness for the place
they are intended to occupy '. He even went so far as to
declare his belief that our artistic perception of beauty
in nature is in great measure derived from the same source.
In working towards a clear idea of one of the fundamental
facts of biology the adaptiveness of structure and func-
tion it may be useful to consider three other facts
(1) Effectiveness of response; (2) plasticity; and
(3) modifiability.
(1) Effectiveness of response. As we have already
seen, effectiveness of response is one of the distinctive pecu-
liarities of living creatures. Many inanimate things
THE WONDER OF LIFE 511
respond to stimuli, but often self-destructively, whereas
the living creature's responses tend to self-preservation
or to species-preservation. Not that the organism can
respond successfully to all stimuli, for instance to a strong
current of electricity, for it is not able to live anywhere or
anyhow, but only within certain environmental limits.
We cannot account for this primary and fundamental
power of effective response ; it is part of our conception
of life. There could have been no organisms at all unless
they had possessed something of this power of answering
back and yet retaining their integrity. In some degree it
must have been part and parcel of the first and
simplest organisms, and it has been improved upon ever
since.
(2) Plasticity. Another important fact is that living
creatures are in different degrees plastic. That is to say,
they can adjust their reactions to novel conditions, they
are not rigidly stereotyped in their responses. In many
cases, even among the simplest organisms, the animal that
is up against a difficulty, ' tries ' one mode of reaction
after another, and may eventually find one which is effective.
Professor Jennings reports that the behaviour of certain
Infusorians may be compared to a pursuance of ' the
method of trial and error '. There are not a few cases of
marine animals showing sufficient plasticity to adjust
themselves in their own individual lifetime to the very
different conditions of fresh water. We see plasticity
too when animals are transported from one habitat to
another where different habits are required. It is convenient
to use the term ' accommodation ' for the frequently occur-
ring functional adjustments which organisms are able to
make to new conditions. Thus there may be an interest-
512 THE WONDER OF LIFE
ing multiplication of red blood corpuscles in the case of
successful human migrants to a lofty plateau, in South
Africa, for instance.
Many unicellular animals are very plastic, and it seems
reasonable to suppose that there was a considerable prim-
ary plasticity in the early organisms, and that restrictions
were placed on this as differentiation progressed. As the
body became more and more complex the range of primary
plasticity was lessened, but a more specialized secondary
plasticity was gained in many cases where organisms lived
in environments liable to frequent vicissitudes.
(3) Modifiability. Taking a third step we recognize
as a fact of life that organisms often exhibit great modifia-
bility. They can change for their lifetime in response to
changes in surroundings or habits. Thus a man's skin
may be so thoroughly tanned by exposure to the sun during
half a lifetime in the tropics, that it never becomes pale
again, even after migration to a far from sunny clime. This
change in the skin is a modification : it differs from a
temporary adjustment in being permanent, and from a
constitutional swarthiness inasmuch as it was impressed
from without rather than expressed from within. It is
exogenous, not endogenous.
' Modifications ' may be defined as changes in the body
acquired during an individual lifetime as the direct result
of changes in function or in environment, and so transcend-
ing the limit of organic elasticity that they persist after
the inducing conditions have ceased to operate. Lack of
nutrition at a particular stage in development may directly
induce an arrest or a dwarfing, with consequences from
which there is no possibility of recovery. A particular
occupation, such as shoemaking or the old-fashioned weav-
THE WONDER OF LIFE
513
ing, may induce functional changes even in the skeleton,
which are there for life.
These modifications are sometimes indifferent, so far as
we can judge, as regards the welfare of the organism ; and
though they are almost always attempts at effectiveness
on the part of the structure affected, they may be pre-
judicial to the organism as a whole. In the case of a goldfish
FIG. 80. Underside of a young flounder, showing pigmentation after
exposure to light from beneath. (After J. T. Cunningham.)
shut up for years in total darkness, there is degeneration
of the eye, which is no doubt a modification on the minus
side. Yet the degeneration considered by itself may be
regarded as a quite effective response to the abnormal
conditions involved. The inflammation that follows an
invasion of microbes into the body may lead on to death,
but it is none the less an effective response on the part of
L L
514 THE WONDER OF LIFE
the body-guard of phagocytes, and it is often a life-saving
one.
In many cases the modifications are markedly beneficial.
When a mammal is taken to a colder climate it often
acquires a thicker coat of hair, which is obviously advan-
tageous. When a plant is moved from the plain to the
plateau it often acquires a thicker epidermis, and Professor
MacDougal has furnished numerous illustrations of useful
modifications exhibited by plants when transferred to
desert conditions. Every one knows that an area of skin
much pressed upon becomes hard and callous, and that this
is often of protective value. Many other instances might
be given of functionally and environmentally induced
modifications which are useful, effective, fit, and may even
make for the preservation of the individual, when the
struggle for existence is keen. These are adaptive modifica-
tions.
Nature of Adaptations. It tends to clearness of think-
ing to keep the term adaptations (used to denote the results
of an evolutionary process) for features and qualities and
arrangements which are inborn, not individually acquired.
An accommodation is the transient expression of plasticity ;
a modification is permanent but individually acquired ;
an adaptation is racial, the expression of the natural inherit-
ance, not an individual gain or loss. It goes without saying
that though these adaptations are potentially implicit in the
germinal material in the fertilized ovum they cannot be
expressed without the appropriate nurture. But this does
not bring them in the least within the category of ' acquired
characters ' or modifications, which result from changes
in the ordinary nurture. In the same way, it is mere
word-splitting to find any difficulty in the fact that ac-
THE WONDER OF LIFE 515
quired adaptive modifications, which are the direct results
of changes in the ordinary nurture, could not occur unless
the potentiality of them were part of the heritable ' nature '.
That goes without saying, but it does not affect the clear
distinction between the exogenously induced modification,
wrought from without inwards, and the endogenously
originating variation which works from within outwards.
Origin of Adaptations. Like the correlated but larger
problem of the origin of species, this is one of the funda-
mental still imperfectly answered questions which the
interpreter of animate nature has to face. There are only
two main theories in the field the theory of the direct,
and the theory of the indirect origin of adaptations.
(a) According to the Lamarckian theory racial adapta-
tions owe their origin to the cumulative inheritance of
individual adaptive modifications. But there is as yet a
lack of positive evidence in support of this interpretation,
plausible as it seems to be. Unless we have experimental
evidence of the transmissibility of presently occurring
adaptive modifications, we are not justified in using this as
an interpretation of results which occurred in the distant
past. Too much may be made of the argument that
many cases are known where transmission of modifica-
tions certainly does not occur, but it must be admitted
that it is difficult in our present state of knowledge to
conceive of any way by which a change acquired by a
part of the body can affect the germinal material in a
manner so precise and representative that the offspring
show a corresponding change in the same direction.
(6) The Darwinian theory is that adaptations are due
to the selection of those inborn and heritable variations
which, by making their possessors better adapted to the
5ib THE WONDER OF LIFE
conditions of their life, have some survival value. It is a
fact of observation that in many groups of organisms the
individuals fluctuate continually in various directions. It is
also a fact of observation that some of these variations
increase the survival value of their possessors. It is
inferred that the cumulative inheritance of these favour-
able variations, fostered by selection in any of its numerous
forms, and helped by the elimination gradual or sudden
of forms lacking the variations in the fit direction, or
having others relatively unfit, may lead to the establish-
ment of new adaptations. The greatest difficulty in this
argument is to account for the origin of the fit variations,
and this has to be met by the accumulation of observational
and experimental data bearing on the origin and nature
of variations. It is also necessary to accumulate more
facts showing that selective processes acting directively
on fluctuating variations do really bring about the results
ascribed to them.
(c) The work of recent years notably that of Bateson
and De Vries has made it plain that besides the con-
tinually occurring ' fluctuating variations,' there are ' dis-
continuous variations ' or ' mutations,' where a new char-
acter or group of characters not only appears suddenly,
but may come to stay from generation to generation. It
cannot be said that we understand the origin of these
mutations, in some of which the organism in many of its
parts seems suddenly to pass from one position of organic
equilibrium to another ; but that they do occur is indubit-
able, and their marked heritability is also certain. Mendel
has given at once a demonstration and a rationale of the
fact that certain mutations, when once they have arisen,
are not likely to be swamped, but are likely to persist,
THE WONDER OF LIFE 517
unless, of course, selection is against them. In horticulture,
in particular, artificial selection has operated in great part
on mutations. If this interpretation be confirmed and
extended, it will not be necessary to lay such a heavy burden
on the shoulders of selection. But more facts are urgently
needed ; and how and under what conditions mutations
whether adaptive or non-adaptive occur, remains an
unsolved problem.
(d) In his theory of Germinal Selection, Weismann has
elaborated an attractive subsidiary hypothesis. Supposing
that the germinal material consists of a complex a multi-
plicate of organ- determining particles (the determinants),
he postulates a struggle going on within the arcana of the
germ-plasm. Supposing limitations of nutrition within
the germ, he pictures an intra-germinal struggle in which
the weaker determinants corresponding to any given part
will get less food and will become weaker, while the stronger
determinants corresponding to the same part will feed
better and become stronger. While the external selection
of individuals goes on, and is all important, it is being
continually backed up by the germinal selection. Thus
nothing succeeds like success.
(e) Various evolutionists Profs. Mark Baldwin, H. F.
Osborn, and C. Lloyd Morgan have suggested that al-
though individual adaptive modifications may not be
transmissible, they may have indirect importance in
evolution, by serving as life-preserving screens until coin-
cident inborn or germinal variations in the same direction
have time to develop. As Groos expresses it, in reference
to some instinctive activities Imitation may keep a
species afloat until Natural Selection can substitute the
life-boat heredity for the life-belt of tradition.
518 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Finally, in thinking over this difficult problem of adapta-
tions, we must remember the importance of the active
organism itself. As Professor James Ward has well pointed
out, it may seek out and even in part make its environment ;
it is not only selected, it selects ; it acts as well as reacts.
And although the details and finesse of this may have been
elaborated in the course of selection, the primary poten-
tiality of it is an essential part of the secret of that kind
of activity which we call Life.
Illustrations of Adaptations. The structure of a long
bone in a mammal is adapted to give the utmost firmness
with the minimum expenditure of material ; the unique
pollen-basket on the hind legs of worker-bees is adapted
to stow away the pollen ; the colours and patterns on the
wings of leaf-insects are adapted to harmonize with the
foliage on which they settle ; the parts of flowers are often
adapted to ensure that the insect- visitors are dusted with
pollen, and thus to secure cross-fertilization ; the peacock
is adapted to captivate the pea-hen ; the mother mammal
is adapted for the prolonged pre-natal life of the young ;
the so-called ' egg-tooth ' at the end of a young bird's bill
is adapted to the single operation of breaking the egg-shell
and so on throughout the whole of the animate world. It
is indeed a mistake to dwell upon signal instances of adapta-
tions, since (apart from degenerative changes in old age,
morbid processes, perverted instincts, rudimentary or
vestigial structures, and certain 'indifferent' characters
which are not known to have any vital significance) almost
every detail of structure and function may be regarded as
adaptive.
The Mole. In illustration of adaptive characters let
us consider a common animal like the mole, ' the little
Pr
FIG. 81. Leaf-insects (Phyllium) From a specimen. A, the green
form on green leaves ; B, the brown form on brown leaves ;
anH C, the young stage.
5i8 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Finally, in thinking over this difficult problem of adapta-
tions, we must remember the importance of the active
organism itself. As Professor James Ward has well pointed
out, it may swk ont and even in part make its environment ;
it is not onlv sekw-t*d, it selects ; it acts as well as reacts.
And although tk* details and finesse of this may have been
elaborated ID ibfc course of selection, the primary poten-
tial itv of ;? i *ri essential part of the secret of that kind
of aeuviiv \vfma we call Life.
IUustr*tta* of Adaptations. The structure of a long
I,*,?, .i.. > ! S; it*nt inquiries into the physiological
signifies? , ; -.4 v:$ir\-.^.-Ar> which is a very difficult problem;
but it, ;,-*.*r h* amid that some pigmented substances
rti't t-.f ?Ko. 'kiittii* of waste-products, like the green guanin
: H toii**Vi' kidney, or the sulphur-yellow in the wings
^s* buttrfbs, r the sepia of the cuttlefish ; that
art- of ihe nature >f resent products, like the carmine
run accumulates ifl the bod of the female cochineal
c5T .W .nbH 9 Hl rri zitomtin'A yd
<>f tnaj*\ Thus the gonads
' ,...- ^ ; :.' 'iflt.
Primary Si Coloration.
The cross bars, the concentric lines, the zoned structure.
and the super jK>siuon of very thin lamellae produce inter-
ference colours, but what is their primary significance ?
The answer must be, that they are the ripple-marks ot
growth ; they are expressions of the fact that growth j*
rhythmic, not continuous. The familiar concentric li-
the stem of a tree express the difference between tit*
summer and the winter wood ; the lines on the sur
a shell are indices of periods of growth pum.
times of rest.
As- ustration of the idea towards whi
structural features are just
THE WONDER OF LIFE 537
the ripple-marks of internal tides (periodic or rhythmical
changes in metabolism and growth), we may refer to the
suggestive observations of Eiddle (1908) on fault-bars
in feathers. Fault-bars are weak areas interrupting the
fundamental barring of the feather, and they appear to be
due to malnutrition or to defective nutrition. They may
be produced by feeding the birds with Sudan III, by
unwholesome conditions, or by using amyl nitrite to reduce *>"
blood-pressure. They are usually laid down at night,
when the blood- pressure is normally lower than during the
day. The structurally weakened areas tend to be less
pigmented, and it has been shown that the production
of the dark (melanin) pigment in feathers may show
quantitative fluctuations corresponding to changes in the
available food supply.
' The reduced nutrition, brought about daily by the
minimum blood-pressure ; the disadvantageous position,
in relation to the blood, of the pigment and barbule elements
of the feather ; together with the very rapid rate at which
feathers grow, furnish the complex of conditions which
bring unfailingly into existence a fault-bar, and to a more
or less appreciable extent a light fundamental bar, at
perfectly regular intervals in the entire length of every
feather formation.'
This is of very great importance, for we are here be-
ginning to see how an alternation in the rhythm of internal
processes may have far-reaching external results which
afford much more than raw material for Selection to
work on.
Physiologically useful Pigments. Having recognized
that pigments occur in an organism as waste- products,
reserve-products, or by-products, and that there need not
538 THE WONDER OF LIFE
be primarily any virtue in their colour, we hasten to point
out that they are often of very great physiological value,
and that their colour, as well as their chemical composition,
may be of vital importance. Speaking metaphorically,
we may say that this has been one of the methods of evolu-
tion to catch up some quality which is present for some
deep constitutional reason, and give it a novel secondary
value often life-saving, (a) The whole world of life
depends on the green pigment, chlorophyll, which is
characteristic of plants, for it is a condition of the photo-
synthesis or upbuilding of sugar and other organic com-
pounds in the leaves that the sunlight should reach the
living matter through the screen of chlorophyll. (6) The
red pigment, haemoglobin, which made its first appearance
(as far as we can judge) in some Ribbon- worms or Nemer-
teans, was also a physiological discovery of the highest
importance, for its capacity of entering into a loose union
with oxygen, and thus becoming an oxygen-carrier, must
have greatly facilitated and improved the function of res-
piration. Along with haemoglobin, which occurs in all Verte-
brates and in some Invertebrates (such as some Nemerteans
and Annelids), there have to be ranked a number of other
respiratory pigments. One of the commonest of these
among Invertebrate animals is haemocyanin, of a faint
bluish colour. In addition to transporting oxygen, some
pigments are of great value in storing it within the body.
} e.g. in the muscles, (c) Another use of pigment is in
S/ connexion with vision, for the dark pigments of the retina
}are continually undergoing chemical change, and they
often show remarkable alterations in position. In the
peculiar condition known as night-blindness there appears
to be a lack of the normal ' visual purple ' in the retina.
THE WONDER OF LIFE 539
(d) Another direct utility may be recognized in the pigmen-\
tation of the skin in various animals. Thus the dark/
skin of some animals from very warm countries and '
the whiteness of some animals from very cold countries
may have a direct physiological value to its possessor.
It appears that the dark insoluble melanin pigments, as
in the crow and negro, are protective against the ultra-
violet rays of sunlight.' A remarkable fact was observed
by Engelmann in regard to the peculiar restless Algae
known as Oscillatoria. He found that in red light they ,
had a green colour, and in green light a red colour in '
both cases the physiologically best colour.
Protective Value of Coloration. Some of the finest
instances of adaptation are seen in the way animals resemble
their habitual environment. Shape and pose sometimes
conspire with coloration to give the animal a mantle of
invisibility. Referring for details to books on animal color-
ation by Professor E. B. Poulton and Mr. F. E. Beddard,
we wish to give a few representative illustrations. Many
desert animals have an isabelline or sandy coloration that
renders them very inconspicuous ; the fennec fox and the
gerbille, the sand-grouse and the horned viper are good
examples. Green snakes are difficult to detect on the
trees and the common shore-crab, whose colour is variable,
often harmonizes to a nicety with the background of the
rock-pool. In many birds and mammals, as Thayer has
well shown, a very perfect garment of invisibility is attained
in a very simple way by having the under surface of the \
body rather lighter than the upper surface.
The protectiveness is heightened when the animal is
like something else, not in colour merely, but in form ;
and there is no better example than the Javanese butterfly
540
THE WONDER OF LIFE
Kallima, which is conspicuously coloured on the upper
surface, but becomes like a withered leaf when it folds
its wings together and exposes the brown under surface
(Fig. 11). As we have noted, the nervures on the wings look
like the veins on a
leaf, and the sug-
gestion of a mid-
rib increases the
resemblance.
Spots on the
wings look like
holes on the leaf,
and so on. In
fact, perfection is
attained by the
combination of a
number of items.
Even the fact
that the colora-
tion of the under
surface and the
position of spots
may vary a little
PIG. 85. Two spiders : I. Cserostris mitralis 1S P erna P s ad '
like a knot on a twig; and II, Ornitho- vantag6OUS,since
scatoides decipiens, like a bird's dropping. , , , . , * i
(After Vinson and Pickard-Cambridge.) tne butterfly has
thus a general
resemblance to different kinds and states of withered leaves.
Protective colour- resemblance is seen at its best in cases
where the animal can adjust itself to the coloration of the
surface on which it is resting ; and there is no better illus-
tration than that of plaice and other flat-fishes, which are
THE WONDER OF LIFE
able in a short time to alter the
disposition of their pigment cells
so as to become part and parcel of
their background. The figures we
have given show the nicety of the
harmonious adjustment (Fig. 10).
Great care must be exercised
in ascribing protective value to
the colour- resemblance between
an animal and something else,
and each case must be judged on
its own merits. It must be made
clear, for instance, that the re-
semblance which conceals the
creature from us is equally effec-
tive in concealing it from its
natural enemies. The desert in-
sect does not escape the desert
lizard, and the green insect on
the twig is unhesitatingly picked
off by the sharp-eyed bird who
has made that its business. Some
creatures, like sea-slugs, which
are often very harmonious with
their surroundings, are seldom
eaten by anything.
It is satisfactory, then, that
there are some definite observa-
tions proving the protective FIG.
value in particular cases. With
silk threads Cesnola tethered
forty-five green praying mantises
UM
86. A Venezuelan insect,
Umbronia spinosa, with
a marked resemblance to
a prickle on the twig on
which it (UM) is
From a specimen^
542 THE WONDER OF LIFE
to green herbage, and sixty-five of the brown variety
to withered herbage, and found that the birds had
not noticed any of them within the seventeen days of
the experiment. But it was quite another story when
he reversed the arrangement. When he put twenty-
five green ones among brown herbage, all were killed by
birds in eleven days, while of forty-five brown ones on
green grass, only ten survived at the end of seventeen days.
Here we have definite proof of a selective death-rate,
definite proof of the protective value of the colour-resem-
blance. And happily the case does not stand alone.
In some cases the colour- resemblance between the animal
and its immediate environment has a very simple explan-
ation. The sea-lemon Archidoris tuberculata is yellow when
it is eating the yellow sponge Dendoryx incrustans and red
when it is eating the red Esperella cegagrophila. It is
thus coloured like the sponge it is browsing on ; the
sponge's colour has directly affected it. This is an individ-
ually acquired character a modification, and not to be
confused with inborn colour- changes which we call
variations. Whether the sea-slug is protected or not by
its modification, we do not know, but the point is that, if it
should turn out to be protected, the origin of the protec-
tion is obvious.
Dr. A. Ch. Hollande, of Nancy, reports a very interesting
case of an insect apparently protected by its meals. The
flower-buds of one of the mountain-mulleins (Verbascum
nigrum) are pierced in autumn by the larva of a Curculionid
beetle called Cionus olens, which feeds on the violet hairs of
the stamens. The violet vegetable pigment (anthocyan)
eaten by the grub passes down the food-canal, and, in
the usual way, into the blood, where, however, it has an
THE WONDER OF LIFE 543
uncoloured form. It is carried to the fatty bodies and
accumulates there in numberless granulations, re-assuming
the violet colour, which shines through the brownish
integment and makes the grub effectively harmonious
with the colour of the stamens amid which it works.
In the case of the Tree-Sloth, the green colour of the
hair is due to Algse which might grow elsewhere, and as
there are other instances of plants of low degree growing
on living hairs, the Sloth's case is no particular puzzle.
In Baron Albert von Sack's Voyage to Surinam (1810)
there is a surprisingly early reference to this peculiar case
of protective resemblance.
' The colour and even the shape of the hair are much in
appearance like withered moss, and serve to hide the animal
in the trees, but particularly when it gets that orange-
coloured spot between the shoulders, and lies close to the
tree ; it looks then exactly like a piece of branch where
the rest has been broken off, by which the hunters are often
deceived '.
Account must also be taken of cases where the particular \ /
colour depends physiologically on that of the surroundings. T
Some caterpillars have a sensitive period during which
their colour or that of the pupae is influenced, within certain
limits, by the surrounding colour. This has been proved
experimentally by Professor Poulton, Schroder, and others.
How the colour of the reflected light affects the pigmen-
tation of the animal is obscure, but the fact is certain in a
few cases, and it is to be associated with the fact, also
proved in a few cases, that the mortality among pupae is
in part dependent on the degree of their inconspicuousness
against certain backgrounds. It is stated that the colour
544
THE WONDER OF LIFE
of a shore-crab is directly influenced, while the shell is
being formed after a moult, by the dominant colour of the
immediate environment.
There can be no doubt that certain colour-reactions
which follow reflexly and necessarily often look as if they
FIG. 87. Much branched chromatophore of a prawn, Praunus flexuoxua.
(After Degner.) The pigment flows out along the root-like branches
or contracts centripetally. The chromatophore)[seems to arise
from a combination of cells a syncytium.
should be advantageous, but it is difficult to give direct
proof of this. One of the prawns, Palcemon treillianus
studied byFrohlich (1910) is blue or green by day^when
its red chromatophores are strongly contracted, and reddish-
brown by night, when the red chromatophores expand.
When one is put into a white porcelain vessel it becomes
THE WONDER OF LIFE 545
milky and translucent ; the chromatophores contract
greatly, and there is an unexplained turbidity in the cara-
pace. When it is put into a glass vessel and that placed
on a mirror, it becomes transparent, the maximum con-
traction of chromatophores occurs. It is easy to imagine
conditions where this milkiness or this transparency would
be very useful. On the other hand, we read that an
individual forced to jump loses its transparency, which
does not sound so adaptive.
Professors Gamble and Keeble have demonstrated a
remarkable plasticity in the coloration of the vEsop-prawn
(Hippolyte varians), which may be red, yellow, blue, orange,
olive, violet, brown, green, and other colours. It is born
without a bias, and it takes on the hue of its environment,
both when young and adult. If it is put in an aquarium
the sides and floor of which are lined with coloured paper,
it takes on the colour ; and it will change from one colour
to another. It seems to have more plasticity in its color-
ation than it can possibly need, but it can make itself
invisible among the bright colours of seaweed.
In the ^Esop- prawn the colour changes periodically
with the nervous state of the animal, according as it is
sleepy or wakeful. We venture to quote Professor Gamble's
fine description (The Animal World, p. 140) :
' The wakeful hours of Hippolyte are hours of expansion.
The red and yellow pigments flow out in myriads of stars
or pigment-cells ; and according to the nature of the back-
ground, so is the mixture of the pigments compounded to
form a close reproduction both of its colour and its pattern :
brown on brown weed, green on Ulva or sea-grass, red on
the red Algae, speckled on the filmy ones. A sweep of a
shrimp net detaches a battalion of these sleeping prawns,
N N
546 THE WONDER OF LIFE
and if we turn the motley into a dish and give a choice of
seaweed, each variety after its kind will select the one
with which it agrees in colour, and vanish. At nightfall,
Hippolyte, of whatever colour, changes to a transparent
azure blue ; its stolidity gives place to a nervous restless-
ness ; at the least tremor it leaps violently and often
swims actively from one food-plant to another. This blue
fit lasts till daybreak, and is then succeeded by the prawn's
diurnal tint. Thus the colour of an animal may express
a nervous rhythm '.
In many cases, both among plants and animals, the
range of colour exhibited by one and the same organism
is very striking, but it has sometimes a very simple ex-
, .^planation. There is a colourless ' chromogen ' substance,
j or ' mother of pigment ', which takes on different colours
according to the amount of oxidation to which it is sub-
jected under the action of a ferment. One of the common
colour- evoking ferments is called tyrosinase. The different
colours in cases of this sort simply correspond to different
rates or rhythms ; and it is easy to understand how this
or that punctuation might be fixed by Natural Selection.
The common sea-slater, Lygia oceanica, has numerous
much-branched black or dark brown chromatophores in
its epidermis, which make it inconspicuous against a dark
background of rock. Tait has shown (1910) that if the
creature is exposed to light in a black-painted dish, it
remains dark, but that if it is exposed in a white dish it
becomes lighter in colour and more transparent, so that
eventually the heart can be seen beating through the skin.
This change is due to a retraction of the black chroma-
tophores, which also leaves certain white chromatophores
more in evidence. When the eyes are painted over with
THE WONDER OF LIFE 547
lampblack, no change follows the transference to a white
surface, which shows that the external colour first affects
the eyes, then the central nervous system, and then the
pigment-cells in the skin.
It is very instructive to compare the juvenile and the
adult coloration. In many young mammals and birds,
as Dr. Chalmers Mitchell has well shown in his Childhood
of Animals, the coloration requires little more than a
physiological interpretation. The pigments are by-
products of the metabolism ; they are laid down in agree-
ment with the particulate character of the skin, or they
may express the rhythms of growth being laid down, for
instance, in concentric lines and cross-bars. If this primi-
tive coloration is not disadvantageous, it will, of course
be tolerated, but the point is, that it does not require any
special utilitarian explanation. It may, indeed, be quite
useful thus the spottiness of some young mammals
makes them very inconspicuous. As the young creature
grows its coloration changes. The spots may unite into
stripes or bands, or they may be blurred into a monotone.
Or it may be that a new pattern replaces the primitive one ;
sometimes of ruptive vividness, so that the natural outlines
of the animal are broken up protectively ; sometimes of
startling and impressive brilliance, such as we see in certain
sex-decorations. It is when we pass to the secondary
coloration, analysed out of the primary as aniline dyes
from the coal-tar residue, that we feel the need of special
utilitarian or selectionist interpretations. And they are
not lacking !
Warning Coloration. A third use of coloration,
first expounded by Alfred Eussel Wallace, is as an advertise-
ment on the part of animals that are unpalatable or offensive
548 THE WONDER OF LIFE
or in some way safe. ' They require ', as Wallace said,
' some signal or danger flag, which shall serve as a warning
to would-be enemies not to attack them, and they have
usually obtained this in the form of conspicuous or brilliant
coloration, very distinct from the protective tints of the
defenceless animals allied to them '. It is satisfactory that
this interpretation has been justified by a number of
experiments, which go to show that hungry animals, once or
twice duped by having conspicuous unpalatable caterpillars
and the like given to them to eat, soon learn by experience
and are aided in this by the impressiveness of the colouring.
Even in fishes, whose cerebrum remains at a very low level,
an association between colour and a gustatory experience
may be established and retained. It has to be admitted,
however, that in many cases the experiment of offering
conspicuous unpalatable caterpillars and the like to hungry
animals has failed to confirm the theory of warning color-
ation, so that each case has to be judged on its own merits.
In some cases there appears to be truth in the interesting
suggestion of Eisig, that very abundant deposition of a
waste-matter pigment may render an animal at once
unpalatable and conspicuous.
This much seems certain, that numerous noxious or
aggressive types, such as wasps, coral snakes, and skunks,
are conspicuously coloured. A familiar and plausible
illustration may be found in the common salamander
(Salamandra maculosa), which is conspicuous in its black
and yellow livery and has a very glandular skin the
secretion of which is perhaps noxious.
Recognition -Marks and Guide-Marks. A fourth
use of coloration is to aid animals in the rapid recog-
nition of their kith and kin, and in the rapid execution of
THE WONDER OF LIFE 549
precise movements, such as placing food in the nestling's
mouth. It was Alfred Russel Wallace who first expounded
the theory of recognition colours, bringing forward in-
stances, especially from among deer, antelopes, birds, and
insects, of striking patches of colour which may be plausibly
interpreted as facilitating rapid recognition. One of the
best instances is also the most familiar the rabbit's
upturned white tail. When they are feeding in the twilight
and are suddenly alarmed, safety may depend on the
rapidity with which they reach the burrows. Hesitation
may be quite fatal, and it does not seem far-fetched to
suppose that ' the white, upturned tails of those in front
serve as guides and signals to those more remote from
home, to the young and the feeble '. The white stripe
above the springbok's tail, which is nearly concealed when
the animal is at rest, but very prominent when it starts to
run, is probably another good instance.
In Mr. W. P. Pycraft's fine History of Birds, which is a
rich treasure-house for students of adaptations, attention
is called to the bright colours sometimes seen around or
in the mouth of nestlings ; and the interpretation is offered
that they serve as a guide to the parents when feeding the
young. The inside of the mouth is diversely coloured, e.g.
bright yellow, as in the thrush, and purplish-red, as in the
chaffinch, while in the Bearded Titmouse it is of ' a bright
cornelian red, surrounded by a band of yellow, and relieved
by a double row of white, glistening, tooth-like conical
processes '. It seems that the most elaborate oral decor-
ations, as in the Gouldian Weaver-finch (Poephila gouldii),
are found in young birds which are hatched in places where
there is but little light. Chun has noted that in this bird
the brilliant bodies at the angles of the mouth of the nestling
550 THE WONDER OF LIFE
reflect the light like mirrors and are effective guide-marks.
Attractive Coloration. A fifth use of coloration
is to add to the ensemble of attractiveness which one sex
has for the other, and which, by stimulating sexual interest
and increasing sexual excitement, makes pairing more effec-
tive. It is usually the male who is the more decorative and
brilliant, but there are exceptional cases of the reverse.
The tail of the peacock is a masterpiece in this kind of
coloration, and the decorativeness of male Birds of Para-
dise and Lyre-Birds and Pheasants is hardly less transcen-
dent. The habits of Bower-birds and some other birds
which collect brightly-coloured or shining objects, suggest
that an appreciation of colour, as colour, is not wanting,
but in thinking of courtship coloration it is probably safer
not to be too analytic, crediting the female bird with too
much in the way of particulate aesthetic discernment. It is
probably the total impression of agility, beauty, vigour and
other qualities which kindles or fans the fire of sexual
excitement in the coy female.
The brilliant coloration of the males is in some measure
latent in the females, as is shown in cases where an old
female bird, or one with an abnormal ovary, begins to put
on a masculine dress. The masculine characteristics are,
as it were, seeds which will not normally develop except
in male soil. They are parts of the inheritance, but they
do not start developing except in appropriate soil and in
response to appropriate stimulus. It has been shown
experimentally that the stimulus, in some cases at least,
is furnished by the ' hormones ' or internal secretions of the
reproductive organs which are diffused by the blood through-
out the body when the organism becomes adolescent or
when the breeding season sets in. It is interesting to find
FIG. 88. Shallow- water marine animals with bright colours. 1.
Elephant's Tusk Shell, Dentalium. 2. Chiton. 3. Starfish.
Echinaster sepositus, (After Ludwig.). 4. Sea Cucumber. 5.
Sea Anemone, Actinia mesembryanthemum. (After Andres.)
6. Cluster of Ascidians. 7. Small Cuttlefish, Sepiola. (After
Jatta.)
550 THE WONDER OF LIFE
reflect the light like mirrors and are effective guide-marks.
Attractive Coloration. A fifth use of coloration
is to add to the cn&mble of attractiveness which one sex
has for the other, and which, by stimulating sexual interest
and increasing sexual excitement, makes pairing more effec-
tive. It is usually the male who is the more decorative and
brilliant, but there are exceptional cases of the reverse.
The tail of the peacock is a masterpiece in this kind of
coloration, and the decora tiven ess of male Birds of Para-
dise- and Lyre-Birds and Pheasants is hardly less transcen-
dent. The habits of Bower-birds and some other birds
.1 .siuolco fcighd Hriw slsopifl^, afifiMft , J
./ieihalS . . nolirO .muilBinsQ JlaHS jJeuT
. r j. i mi
disc regenerating the other itself likely to be fatal. This
four arms. M, the mouth ; theory, which is really Dar-
BA, a regenerating arm ; OA,
the original arm ; AG, the wiman, has been re-stated
by Weismann in the words:
' the power of regeneration
possessed by an animal or by a part of an animal is regu-
lated by adaptation to the frequency of loss, and to the
extent of the damage caused by the loss '.
It is evident, at once, that the lank and slender bodies
THE WONDER OF LIFE 561
of worms, the long arms of starfishes and brittle-stars, the
sprawling limbs of newts, the long tails of lizards, and
so on, are naturally liable to injury, and that a re-
generative capacity is one which natural selection would
foster.
It is also evident that internal organs are much less likely
to be cut out than external organs are to be cut off. It is
also certain that visceral wounds are much more likely to
be fatal in Vertebrates than in Invertebrates, so that a
regenerative capacity in the former would be, so to speak,
a quality wasted, whereas in the less sensitive Invertebrates,
where it often occurs, it is very much in demand. If the
retention and specialization of the regenerative capacity
has been evolved as an adaptive character, it must obvi-
ously be restricted to cases where the injury is of a kind not
likely to be fatal.
It will be observed that Lessona's law does not touch the
question of the origin of the regenerative capacity, nor the
question of how the capacity resides in the lizard's tail or
in the snail's horn, nor the process of re-growing a complex
structure from a stump. It is a theory of the distribution
of the regenerative capacity why is it here and not there,
why is it strong in some animals and weak in others, why
it is well marked in regard to some parts and not at all
marked in regard to others. The question is whether it is
a sufficient formula to cover the known facts in regard to
the distribution of the regenerative capacity.
Testing the Theory. One way of testing the theory
is to inquire whether there are any or many well-authenti-
cated cases of the regeneration of parts which would not
be likely to be injured or lost in the natural conditions of
the animal's life. A number of difficult cases have been
o o
562 THE WONDER OF LIFE
brought forward, and we may consider a few which may
be called typical.
There is the well-known case of the stork's bill, which
Weismann admitted to be difficult. The upper half was
accidentally broken off, the lower jaw was amputated to the
same length, in the course of time both were regenerated
a very remarkable achievement.
Now is there any evidence that such a serious injury
might occur in ordinary life ? If it is not a loss that is at all
likely to occur, then it is not easy to understand why any
organic provision should be made for its compensation.
The difficulty was lessened by the report of Bordage, that
in cock-fights similar injuries were frequent and were often
followed by very remarkable regeneration. In one case
the premaxillae and part of the mandible were torn off a
large fraction of the entire beak yet both bones and horny
coverings were regenerated. Now cock-fighting, though
elaborated by men of more or less evil device, is a natural
phenomenon. Cocks are given to fighting furiously, inj uries
are frequent, and it is just the sort of ever-recurrent injury
for the reparation of which provision might be made.
When we discover, furthermore, that male storks also fight
furiously, sometimes fatally, the difficulty of the stork's
bill seems, as Weismann says, to become an exception
proving the rule.
Another difficult case which Weismann discusses is that
the eye of the newt (Triton) may be regenerated, as Bonnet
and Blumenbach showed long ago, after serious injury.
We now know that if the lens alone be carefully taken
out, it will be replaced. These are very remarkable
instances of regeneration, but the question immediately
arises, What chance is there that in natural conditions a
THE WONDER OF LIFE 563
newt should have its eye gouged out ? To this Weismann
answers that newts fight furiously, at any rate at the
breeding season, and often injure one another ; and that
the larvae of the large water-beetle (Dytiscus marginalia)
often attack newts just behind the head. Moreover the
water-snail Limnsea, though usually vegetarian, is some-
times found killing a newt, getting upon its back and
filing the skin with its radula. It is probable that
a more complete knowledge of the life of Amphibians
would show that serious injury to the eye is not a rare
casualty.
A very interesting case is given by Bordage. In locusts
and related insects, the loss of one of the first two pairs of
legs is followed by regeneration. On the other hand, the
posterior or third pair of legs, which are of great importance
in jumping, are not regenerated. Now why should this
be, that the less important may be re-grown, while the more
important are not ? This seems quite inconsistent with
Lessona's law. But Bordage points out that the loss of
the posterior legs almost prevents moulting, leaves the
locusts exposed to great danger, and, furthermore, prevents
breeding. Perhaps therefore the case is covered by the
corollary to Lessona's law ' provided the injury be not
fatal '. Nor can one conceive how organic provision
could be made for an injury which prevents breeding. The
prevention of breeding is a full-stop to the evolution of an
adaptive feature of any kind.
Some of the cases of regeneration are very remarkable.
Kammerer has found that in the common house-fly (Musca
domestica) and in the blow-fly (Calliphora vomitoria)
amputation of a wing is not followed by any result, yet
tearing off a wing from a newly pupated fly is sometimes
564 THE WONDER OF LIFE
followed by re-growth. The new wing is at first homogene-
ous and transparent, it subsequently gets veins which
seem to be after the normal pattern. The regeneration of
a wing has also been observed in the meal-beetle (Tenebrio).
In Nature an insect bereft of wing would be likely to die,
nor is the accident very likely to happen often unless in
Lepidoptera, where the removal of a wing is followed by no
result. It seems difficult therefore to suppose that the
regenerative capacity is always adaptive.
An interesting peculiarity in connection with regenera-
tion in the starfish may also be used as a test case. Miss
Helen D. King points out that in Aster ias vulgaris it is
quite usual for an isolated arm to regenerate the whole if
it has a fraction of the central disc left. ' Comet-forms '
are not infrequent, which consist of a fully- developed arm,
a partially formed disc, and four beginnings of the arms
which are missing. One of these forms is figured (Fig. 91),
and every shore-naturalist is familiar with every possible
transition between the single arm and the intact starfish.
All this is well known, but what Miss King's experiments
brought out was the fact that while the ventral part of
an arm may regenerate the dorsal surface, the converse
does not occur. It may be said, of course, that this is
simply because of the complexity of the ventral surface,
with its tube-feet, water-vessel, nerve-strand, and so on.
But it is just possible that the reason may be different, and
connected with the obvious fact that the dorsal surface is,
in natural conditions, much more open to attack and injury
than the ventral surface which adheres to the rock. Again,
perhaps, the exception proves the rule.
Another apparent difficulty which turns out to be a
corroboration is expounded by Bordage. The lower or
THE WONDER OF LIFE 565
tarsal joints of the legs of locusts and the like are readily
dislocated, and in the two front pairs they are readily
regenerated. It requires great force to break the leg near
the top between joints 1 and 2 (coxa and trochanter),
or still more between parts 2 and 3 (trochanter and
femur). The injury is often fatal. But the remark-
able point is that if the insect survives and is young,
regeneration may be effected, especially if the dislocation
is between joints 2 and 3, ivhere it is most difficult. This
seems to be an extremely difficult case, for after making
all allowances for the various and violent ways in which
locusts may be pulled about by one another, or by birds
and other enemies, it is difficult to see how in natural con-
ditions sufficient force would be exerted to break the
leg, and still more difficult to understand why regenera-
tion should most frequently follow when the breakage
occurs at the most difficult place.
Yet the difficulty is not insurmountable, for observation
of the frequent moultings shows that when the locust is
struggling out of its old clothes or cuticle, breakage at
the joints is very apt to occur, particularly at the trochanter-
femur articulation, which afterwards becomes so strong.
The difficulty disappears and becomes an argument in
favour of the view that the distribution of the regenerative
capacity is adaptive.
Similarly, Bordage has shown in regard to Walking-
Stick Insects, or Phasmids, where the assaults of birds and
lizards seemed to afford insufficient reason for the pre-
valent habit of breaking off a leg at a particular line and
re-growing it thence, that the breakages during emergence
from the egg or from the cast moults have probably fur-
nished sufficient reason for the evolution of the restorative
566 THE WONDER OF LIFE
provision. On a point like this it is interesting to get
precise facts, and Bordage notes that out of a hundred
Phasmids, nine died during moulting, twenty-two tore
themselves free with the loss of one or more legs, and only
sixty- two survived without any loss. In short, breakage
during moulting is a frequently recurrent casualty, pro-
vision for which would certainly be favoured by natural
selection.
Another difficulty is presented by the regeneration of the
abdominal limbs of hermit-crabs, which are normally pro-
tected by the Gastropod shell which the Crustacean borrows.
There are five of these the first very rudimentary in the
males, but used for carrying the eggs in the females ; the
fourth and fifth used to fix the hermit-crab to the central
pillar of the borrowed shell. It is evident that there is
little likelihood of these limbs being nipped off extremely
little in the case of the two hindmost pairs. But Professor
T. H. Morgan has shown that all the limbs of hermit-crabs
are capable of regeneration, though they do not all grow
again equally often, the anterior abdominal appendages
being less frequently renewed than the more exposed
thoracic limbs, for even these are not always restored after
loss. He therefore argues that there is here no relation
between frequency of loss and regenerative capacity a
thesis quite counter to the idea of Lessona's law. Weis-
mann's general answer is that the regenerative capacity
shown by the hermit-crab's abdominal limbs may be a
persistent inheritance from ancestral forms which must
have had exposed tails. Moreover, one would like to
inquire particularly into the life of hermit-crabs to find
out whether there are not now in the combats, in the
flitting from one house to another, and particularly in the
THE WONDER OF LIFE 567
moultings some very good present reasons for the retention
of the regenerative capacity in the abdominal appendages.
Imperfect Regenerations. Another objection to the
theory which interprets the distribution or occurrence of
the regenerative capacity as adaptive is found in those
strange and highly interesting cases where the re-growth
takes place, but not according to pattern. As Spallanzani
showed in 1768 and T. H. Morgan in 1899, a decapitated
earthworm may grow a second tail (as shown by the dis-
position of the excretory tubules or nephridia) instead of
replacing its lost head. But this only serves to show that
the regenerative process is liable to go wrong at times just
as the embryonic development does. The fact that a
headless creature is sometimes born does not affect the
general conclusion that development is a regulated and
harmonious process.
Werner points out that when a lizard re-grows its tail, it
does not always adhere to the pattern. When the scales
are comparatively simple, the regeneration is almost perfect,
but when the scales are complex and there is much orna-
mentation, the regenerated tail is simpler than the one
that was lost ; it tends to be an ancestor's type of tail. Hence
the wit has suggested that to find out a lizard's pedigree,
you have only to pull off its tail. Perhaps a truer way of
stating the case, however, is that the regenerated tail is
nearer the embryonic type, which is not surprising if
regeneration be due to a local persistence and re-awakening
of embryonic growing powers.
There seems to be a widespread tendency towards the
reproduction of a simpler or ancestral form, or, in some cases,
of a simpler and more embryonic form. Thus in cock-
roaches and walking-stick insects (Phasmids), which have
568 THE WONDER OF LIFE
normally five tarsal joints at the end of the leg, the regener-
ated limb has only four tarsal joints, which is believed to
be the ancestral number. Weismann cites the observation
of Fritz Miiller, that in a Brazilian shrimp, Atyoida poti-
morim, the long clawed forceps are replaced in regeneration
by the older short-fingered type of forceps, seen in the
allied genus Caridina. In both these cases it might be
said that the regeneration was economical and that not
more than a workable substitute for the lost part was
re-grown. But this cannot be the explanation, for we know
that regeneration will take place perfectly in half-starved
animals. Furthermore, there are cases where the regener-
ated part, though more ancestral, is not more economical
of material. Thus Barfurth calls attention to the very
suggestive fact that the four-fingered hand of the Axolotl
is replaced after amputation by a more typical five-fingered
hand.
Weismann has suggested a speculative theory of these
cases. He supposes that there are regeneration-germs
which come to reside in areas particularly liable to injury
(like the cambium- cells in various parts of plants), and he
further supposes that these have, in their developmental
power, lagged a little behind the level of the part to which
they correspond. They are able to replace it, but not quite
up to the contemporary grade of evolution. It must be
remembered that the regeneration tends to be rapid com-
pared with the original development, and that the con-
ditions are different. Perhaps some stimulus is awanting
to incite the regeneration to go a step further.
It must be admitted that in many cases the substitute
that replaces the lost part is not quite correct, not quite
up to the mark. In place of a lost leg an insect may grow
THE WONDER OF LIFE 569
an antenna ; in place of an antenna a leg. Instead of a
lost abdominal limb the edible crab may grow a walking
leg, which is very much out of place, and instead of a lost
stalked-eye the lobster may grow an antenna. Many cases,
indeed, are known where a Crustacean does not get an eye
for an eye, but something simpler. Most of these cases
of imperfect regeneration concern animals whose limbs
normally pass from one form to another with successive
moultings, and, as Przibram suggests, it is worth asking
whether the antenna instead of an eye was really the final
result of the regenerative process. The animals should be
kept alive when possible, and the observation continued
until after the next moult. In his experiments on the
common water-flea, Daphnia, and on the Isopod, Asellus,
he found that the regenerated limb was not at first perfect,
but became normal after repeated moultings.
Regeneration and Embryonic Development. In
many cases the process by which regeneration is effected
is very like the normal process of typical development,
which is perhaps what one should expect on a priori grounds.
The ectoderm or outer layer of the cut surface furnishes
the ectoderm of the re-growth, and the mesoderm the
mesoderm. But in some cases the regenerative growth
is very different from that which occurs in embryonic
development, and we have to face the puzzle that the same
result may be reached by two different paths.
When the anterior end of a Naiad a freshwater worm
is cut off, an ectodermic cap is formed, according to Hepke,
over the wound ; in the concave interior of this cap there
gradually appear all the organs to be replaced ; muscles,
which are normally mesodermic, are formed by cells mig-
rating from the ectoderm, and a piece of food- canal, which
570 THE WONDER OF LIFE
ought by rights to be endodermic, is formed by the ectoderm.
There are not a few cases of this sort, and it is plain that
regenerative growth does not necessarily follow the path
of embryonic development. The same sort of difficulty
arises in connection with the buds of Tunicates and
Polyzoa which reach the same general result as a fertilized
ovum, but by quite different paths. Perhaps we have
here a hint that we may create unnecessary difficulties by
making too much of the distinctiveness of the germinal
layers.
Another much- discussed case must be cited. Calucci,
Wolff, and Miiller have made the experiment of extracting
the lens of Triton, with the result that it was normally
regenerated. From what, however ? Not from remnants
of the lens, for there were none, but from the iris, with
which the lens (a product of the ectoderm in front of the
optic cup) has no genetic connection. That an iris should
be able to regenerate an iris would be consonant with the
general facts of regeneration, but it seems to be able to
re-make a lens, in whose original making it plays no part.
It may be pointed out that the posterior epithelium of the
iris is ectodermic like the lens, and furthermore that the
newt is an animal with great regenerative power in many
parts, and may be contrasted with an animal like the rabbit,
where regeneration of the lens does not occur unless some
portion of the lens be left. Perhaps, however, the case of
the newt's lens points to the conclusion that the residual
germinal capacity, localized here and there in animals, is
more general and less specific than is sometimes supposed,
and that what occurs in any particular instance is under
some sort of regulation, so that what is most needed tends
to be done.
THE WONDER OF LIFE 571
The Wonder of Regeneration. It is striking to see
how from within its cuticular sheath there suddenly bursts
forth a beautifully formed lobster-limb, replacing one that
has been lost. It is liberated at a moult, and stretches
itself out like a Jack-in-the-Box. The occurrence seems
almost magical, but we must not be misled. The abrupt-
ness of the phenomenon is wholly superficial, there has been
a long period of gradual differentiation within the husk
of the limb-bud. There are not many Jack-in-the-Box
phenomena in organic Nature. Her magic is quiet.
Therefore one of the things to be borne in mind is that
in regenerative growth, just as in embryonic development,
one phase naturally and gradually leads on to the next. The
stump of a snail's horn will re-grow the whole horn, with
the eye at the tip included, and will re-grow it not once but
many times. But there is nothing sudden, the horn is
fashioned with a gradually increasing perfection, reminding
one of the growth of, let us say, a coronet in the craftsman's
hands. The words gradual differentiation and integration
do not solve any mystery, but they may save us from a
false impression.
We are probably unable in the present state of science
to utilize to proper advantage the analogies between cry-
stallization and growth ; but it is interesting to remember
that a minute fragment of alum fashioned artificially
into a sphere, or a cylinder, or a lens, will, when dropped
into a solution of alum, develop into a perfect octahedron,
through what Rauber has called an imperfect embryonic
stage. A sphere of saltpetre will similarly regenerate a
rhombic prism, and any mutilation of a crystal will be
followed by a restoration of the normal form. Now the
gap between the little spherule of alum and the perfect
572 THE WONDER OF LIFE
octahedron is remotely comparable to the gap between the
regenerative hood that forms at the anterior end of a
decapitated freshwater worm and the perfectly re-grown
head. In both cases there is a gradual series of differentia-
tions and integrations connecting the beginning and the
end.
Again, without detracting from the genuine wonder of
the facts of regeneration, we may reasonably seek to bring
them into line with analogous phenomena, and we have
already referred to asexual multiplication, tissue replace-
ment, and the like. Let us recall also what occurs inside
the pupa case of a fly, where the larval body is literally
disintegrated, and certain minute groups of cells (the
imaginal discs) act among the debris as the centres of a
reconstruction on an entirely new plan.
When we think of the earthworm growing a new head,
or the lizard a new tail, or the newt a new lens all, as it
were, at command we must try to allow for the influence
of environing stimuli. The residual germinal power in the
animal counts for much, but this operates under the influ-
ence of a particular environment, which also counts for
much, though not for so much. Perhaps this point may
be best understood by reference to what is technically called
heteromorphosis, which means that in certain conditions
the re-growth departs from its ordinary mode of procedure.
If an inch or two be cut from the cylindrical stalk of
the common zoophyte Tubularia, and one end be stuck in
the sand, a head may be re-grown at the free end whether
that was originally turned towards the head or towards
the base. But if both ends be left free, the piece re-
generates a head at each end. Evidently the environ-
mental influences count for something here. There are
THE WONDER OF LIFE 573
many similar cases which suggest that the result is, as it
were, a compromise between the inherent growth-tendencies
of the organism and the environmental stimuli operative in
each case.
Theoretical Considerations. In what way is it
possible for us to imagine the regenerative capacity of
organisms? A crocodile loses a tooth, but beneath its
hollow base there lay another which now fills the gap.
Not far off there is a rudiment of another, and so on. The
adder casts a fang, but there is another ready to slip into
its place, and to re-establish in a very interesting way the
connection with the poison duct. Not far off there is a
rudiment of another fang, and so on. But when a crab
loses a claw there is no under-study lying ready at the area
of rupture. There is no rudiment of a visible nature, and
yet the regeneration is duly effected. How can we con-
ceive of this ?
In certain cases, as in plants, there is visible evidence
of persisting embryonic tissue the cambium which
has retained the formative capacity of the original fertilized
egg-cell. In many of the lower animals, such as polyps,
division of labour has not gone very far, and there are
visible ' interstitial cells ' which have remained undifferen-
tiated and might be compared to the cambium cells of
plants. But in most of the cases which we have discussed
in this chapter regeneration takes place from amid a
stump of differentiated cells. In some instances there is
an apparent undoing of the differentiation, a return to a
simpler type, and a multiplication at a embryonic level.
Sometimes considerable assistance appears to be afforded
by migrant amoeboid cells of the body the phagocytes
which appear on the scene of the accident and are very
574 THE WONDER OF LIFE
active in various ways. But they are by no means indis-
pensable. On the whole, in the present state of our know-
ledge, it seems that the best working hypothesis is Weis-
mann's. He supposes that the germ-plasm includes special
' regeneration-determinants ' which are distributed appro-
priately through the body and lie quietly like garrisons in
strategic places, awaiting a possible awakening stimulus.
Perhaps, however, it is at present wiser to leave our
conception of the arrangements for regeneration somewhat
vague, and to concentrate attention on the case for Les-
sona's law that regenerative capacity tends to occur in
those animals and in those parts of animals which are in
the natural conditions of their life particularly liable to
injury, always provided that the part lost be of real import-
ance, and that the injury be not fatal. All of which comes
to this, that the distribution of the regenerative capacity
is adaptive, and can be accounted for on the theory of
Natural Selection.
THE CROWNING WONDER OF EVOLUTION.
We have become so familiar with the general idea of
organic evolution that we have ceased to wonder enough.
It should be a thought to thrill us, that we and the multi-
tudinous, varied, intricate, and always beautiful world of
life around us have grown by infinitely slow gradations
from an apparently simple beginning. Through unreckon-
able ages Life has been slowly creeping upwards, possessing
and conquering the earth ever more thoroughly, unfolding
new and unsuspected potentialities seon after aeon, and
affording us in fact no small part of the material that has
gone to build up our conception of Progress.
THE WONDER OF LIFE 575
It is a grand piece of history beyond doubt the pre-
historic history of the organic world. If our conception
is right at all, there once was a time when the living creatures
of the Earth were very minute corpuscles of living matter
very simple but individuated, able to feed, grow, and
multiply, able to enregister their experiences. We must
try to think of them as simpler than any of the Protists
that are visible to-day. Perhaps the ultra- microscopic
Chlamydozoa may be nearest to them.
Great Steps in Evolution. Looking backwards we
see a great succession of achievements. Within the realm
of the unicellulars we find every grade of structural differen-
tiation some relatively simple, some extraordinarily
complex like many of the Radiolarians. We can still
trace the gradual specialization of functions, the establish-
ment of the great types of cell life, the beginnings of repro-
duction and of death. One of the earliest steps was the
dichotomy which separated plants and animals the most
momentous cleavage in evolution.
A simple instance may serve to bring out the point that
functions have become more specialized as evolution pro-
ceeded. W. Staniewiez has called attention to the interest-
ing fact that Protozoa have never learned to digest fat.
All multicellular animals have this power, but the Protozoa
have not. Experiments with Paramcecium, Stentor,
and some other common Infusorians show that fat may
be ingested, but it is not digested. It is not a natural
part of a Protozoon's food, and the fat that is occasionally
found in natural conditions within the Protozoon cell
seems to be due to the transformation of proteids or carbo-
hydrates. If the facts are correct, the power of digesting
fat was added on to the digestive function when the transi-
576 THE WONDER OF LIFE
tion was made from unicellular to multicellular animals.
When certain simple organisms, unable fully to complete
that division into two or more separate units which normally
occurs at the limit of growth, began to form multicellular
'bodies' one of the greatest steps in evolution was
taken. It was perhaps with the acquisition of a
body that natural death began. It was certainly with
the acquisition of a body that there began the very advan-
tageous division of labour between body-cells and germ-
cells. Among the Protozoa there are often dimorphic
units which combine in fertilization or conjugation, and
they are the analogues of the ova and spermatozoa of higher
animals ; but it was only after the establishment of the
multicellular body that the sexes, in the strict sense, were
differentiated as sperm-producers and ovum-producers
males and females respectively.
Another step with far-reaching consequences was the
replacement of the radial symmetry of polyp and jellyfish
by bilateral symmetry. It was some ' worm ' types which
began the useful habit of moving with one end of the
body always in front, and with this was associated the
acquisition of head-brains, the beginning of the process
which has led to our being able to tell our right hand from
our left.
We think of what was implied in the discovery of an
oxygen-capturing respiratory pigment like haemoglobin,
or of an armouring substance like chitin which is char-
acteristic of the highly successful Arthropod alliance of
Crustaceans, Insects, Spiders and the like. The early
differentiations of striped muscle and specialized sense-
organs were other great events, and much was gained by
such a simple step as having a food-canal open posteriorly
THE WONDER OF LIFE 577
and not blind, as it was to begin with. Another great
invention was the blood itself, a fluid tissue, transporting
digested food, carrying oxygen and carbon dioxide, drain-
ing away the nitrogenous waste, and distributing the
regulative hormones produced by organs of internal
secretion.
Looking backwards we see that there has been a wonder-
ful twofold progress in differentiation and in integration.
On the one hand, bodies have become more complicated ;
on the other hand, more unified and controlled. In parti-
cular, we see that life has become richer and freer as the
nervous system became more complex and more unified.
A fresh start was doubtless made when backboned animals
emerged, it is difficult to say whence or how, for with them
the possibilities of a distinctly higher life began, with more
intelligence and less instinct, with more mastery of the
medium. We think of birds, of mammals, and of man ;
of the detailed colonization of the earth and the exploitation
of its resources ; and of the consummate adaptations
seen at every turn.
One of the big impressions is the gradual emergence of
nobler forms of life. Millions of years passed before any
backboned animals appeared. The earliest fossil fishes
are obtained from Silurian strata ; the first Amphibians
are much later in the Carboniferous ; the Reptiles
probably began in the Permian ; the oldest known bird,
Archseopteryx, is Jurassic. Some races reach their climax
and begin to wane, but if we take the Vertebrate series,
we may say in general terms that the rock-record reveals
a slowly increasing perfection.
To refer to a concrete detail, it is strange to think of
the fact that it was not till millions after millions of years
PP
578 THE WONDER OF LIFE
had passed that living creatures found a voice. Apart
from the instrumental noises of some insects, it was
not until the advent of Amphibians in the Carboniferous
age that the silence of nature was broken by any voice of
life. It is useful to fix attention on one race and to note
what they achieved, and no one surely can look at the
fossil remains of the Carboniferous Amphibians without
a thrill. They are the remains of pioneers the first back-
boned animals to begin the possession of the dry land,
the first to have finger and toes and thus the power
of feeling things in three dimensions, the first to have a
voice and a mobile tongue, and the first to have true lungs.
How many acquisitions these early Amphibians made !
Mr. W. D. Matthew, of the American Museum of Natural
History, has written appreciatively concerning Eryops,
a primitive Amphibian which lived about the close of the
Carboniferous Period ' five times as old as Eohippus (an
early ancestor of the modern horse), a hundred times as
old as the mammoth or mastodon or the earliest known
remains of man'. It was 'a sort of gigantic tadpole or
mud-puppy, with wide flat head, no neck, a thick heavy
body, short legs and paddle-like feet and a heavy flattened
tail '. Heavy and clumsy, small- brained and slow, but
it was near the top of the genealogical tree in its day, and
it was rich in promise ! ' The giant dragon-fly that darted
over the head of the slow- crawling Eryops might seem,
except in size, a far superior type of being, a far more
promising candidate for the position of ancestor to the
intelligent life which was to appear in the dim future '.
But the facts were far otherwise. The giant dragon-fly
had already reached the limit of great organizational
change, while ' the amphibian was but beginning the
THE WONDER OF LIFE 579
adaptation of the vertebrate structure to a terrestrial life '.
It had not circumscribed its possibilities, and perhaps
there is something in Professor Shaler's suggestion, that
the possession of an internal instead of an external skeleton
was a factor in giving free play to the evolutionary potency
which lay concealed in these unpromising amphibians of
the Carboniferous forest-swamps.
The Fitness of the Environment. A favourite idea
of olden times was expressed in the phrase the harmony of
nature, the theory being that the physical conditions, for
instance, were suitable for life. The universe was regarded
as distinctly friendly. This idea has been rehabilitated
in Professor Lawrence J. Henderson's recent essay on
The Fitness of the Environment (1913), to which we wish
briefly to refer. When a crust forms on a heavenly body,
like our earth, the normal envelope is an atmosphere
containing water and carbonic acid gas, which are necessarily
and automatically formed in vast amounts by the cosmic
process. They are very fit things in themselves, and fitted
to play an important role in inorganic evolution, but the
point is that they also exhibit extraordinarily great and
detailed fitness in relation to the upbuilding and susten-
ance of living creatures. Their exceptional properties
have contributed to the success of life. There are no other
compounds which share more than a small part of the
qualities of fitness which water and carbonic acid possess ;
and no other elements which share those of carbon, hydro-
gen and oxygen. Living means trafficking with the environ-
ment ; to do this effectively organisms must be complex and
yet coherent, plastic and yet durable ; and they were able
to gain these qualities because of the fundamental pro-
perties of the primary constituents of the inanimate environ-
580 THE WONDER OF LIFE
ment. In the same manner, the oceans which were formed
automatically in the course of the cosmic process have in
certain respects a maximal fitness in relation to life. Even
our own blood, which is such an effective internal medium,
seems to owe some of its virtue to Father Neptune.
' The fitness of the environment results from character-
istics which constitute a series of maxima unique, or
nearly unique properties of water, carbonic acid, the
compounds of carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen and the
ocean so numerous, so varied, so nearly complete among
all things which are concerned in the problem, that together
they form certainly the greatest possible fitness. No
other environment consisting of primary constituents
made up of other known elements or lacking water and
carbonic acid, could possess a like number of fit char-
acteristics or such highly fit characteristics, or in any
manner such great fitness to promote complexity, durability
and active metabolism in the organic mechanism which
we call life '....' In fundamental characteristics the
actual environment is the fittest possible abode of life '.
It seems to come to this that ours is the best of worlds.
It is certain that the earth could not have become the home
of the living creatures that we know unless it had gone
through stages of chemical and physical preparation.
It is certain that the physical basis of life as we know it
could not have been formed unless there had been in
matter a tendency to complexify to form atoms, molecules,
enormous molecules, and those unstable aggregates of
molecules which we know in colloids. It is also certain
that the compounds of carbon, with their large molecules,
and power of colloidal union, are such as to favour the
increase of structural complexity, e.g., as we see it in the
THE WONDER OF LIFE 581
physical basis of life. And so on, for, as Prof. Henderson
has well shown, the evidence is cumulative that living
creatures, as material systems, are in no wise foreign to
the earth but are in the deepest sense congruent with it.
This is a very important and sound conclusion.
Yet we cannot follow Prof. Henderson to his conclusion
that ' in fundamental characteristics the actual environ-
ment is the fittest possible abode of life '. It may be so,
but the assertion outstrips the evidence. That we cannot
suggest another plan of evolution, another kind of make-
up for the physical basis of life, does not by any means
prove that there could be no other, no better. Who can
tell that there may not elsewhere be other and fairer faunas
and floras which biologists of another and of wiser sort
rejoice to study?
While it is a notable and valuable service to have shown
what we may call the solidarity of organisms and their
environment, is there not a risk of arguing in a circle, and
making a problem where none exists ? We must remem-
ber the old lady's fallacy regarding rivers and towns. If
we grant, as Meldola says, that the elements have not been
launched haphazard into existence as independent entities ;
if we admit a tendency in matter to complexify when it
gets a chance (a tendency no more explicable than gravi-
tation) ; if we suppose, as the author does, that ' the whole
evolutionary process, both cosmic and organic, is one ',
why should we be surprised at the ' two complementary fit-
nesses ' ? The characteristic properties of water and
carbonic acid, of carbon compounds and colloid states, are
peculiarly fitted for the life of organisms, because organisms
as mechanisms (and our author does not consider them
otherwise) are such as could arise and survive and evolve
582 THE WONDER OF LIFE
under the given environmental conditions. The earth is
friendly to living creatures because in their physical
nature they are bone of her bone, and flesh of her flesh
her very children.
But it is an important piece of work to have shown that
organisms cannot be thought of as episodically or contin-
gently fitted to their environment, that the ' natural char-
acteristics of the environment promote and favour com-
plexity, regulation, atid metabolism, the three fundamental
characteristics of life '. The characteristics that make
them fit have contributed to the fitness of organisms.
It is no small service to have so clearly and circumstantially
suggested that Nature is Nature for a certain purpose.
The Method of Evolution. So far as we know as
yet, the method of organic evolution has been the method
of trial and error : ceaseless experimenting on the part of
the germ-cells, and the submission of these tentative new
departures to that criticism by the environment, which
we call Natural Selection. The experiments are called
' variations ', and there is a growing body of evidence
to show that we must distinguish the minor fluctuations
from the major mutations. (It does not seem likely that
' modifications ', or the direct results of peculiarities of
nurture in the wide sense, are of any direct importance
in evolution, since we have no secure evidence that they
are ever transmitted, as such or in any representative
degree. ) The facts in regard to ' mutations ', which we owe
to De Vries, Bateson, and others, point to the occurrence
of sudden and discontinuous variation ; ' the existence,
that is to say, of new forms having from their first beginning
more or less of the kind of 'perfection that we associate with
normality'. The general idea is that novel characters
THE WONDER OF LIFE 583
may suddenly appear, as it were, full-fledged, with con-
siderable perfection from the moment of their emergence,
and without intergrades linking them to the parents.
Furthermore, the novel character of the mutant, if we
may use the word, is independently heritable and does not
blend ; it can be grafted intactly on to another stock, or it
can be dropped out as such. Again, mutations are on the
whole qualitative, as contrasted with the quantitative
fluctuations. It comes to this, then, that the elusive
Proteus, which is the essence of every living creature, is
ever changeful, sometimes leaping (' mutations ', we call
the movements), sometimes taking short tentative steps
(' fluctuations ', we call them).
As to the origin of fluctuations and mutations we must
still confess with Darwin that our ignorance is profound.
Is it a fundamental characteristic of organisms, that they
tend to vary and often to vary creatively ? So much must
be allowed for the effect that fluctuations in the nutritive
stream of the body may have in evoking responsive changes
in the complex germ-cells. So much must be allowed for
the effect that searching environmental changes may have
in acting as liberating stimuli to the germ- cells pulling
the trigger of their potentiality. So much must be allowed
for the opportunities afforded in maturation and fertiliza-
tion for shuffling the chromosome cards, producing new
combinations or dropping out an item altogether.
Perhaps we can go a step further, recalling, for
instance, what Herbert Spencer emphasized, and what
the progress of chemistry since his day has made even more
vivid, the tendency in matter to complexify corpuscles
forming atoms, atoms molecules, molecules larger molecules,
and so on. Perhaps the living unit, which we know as the
584 THE WONDER OF LIFE
germ-cell, utilises this complexifying tendency in a pro-
gressive differentiation of its own. Just as the same
chemical substance may crystallize in more than one way,
so, but more subtly, the germ-cell may experiment with
its architecture. The germ-cell is no ordinary cell, it is
a gamete, a condensed individuality ; and just as an
intact organism, from Amoeba to Elephant, tries experi-
ments, so it may be that the implicit organism of the
germ-cell tries experiments which we call variations.
Such at least is our view of a great mystery.
It seems, then, if we are reading the story of Evolution
aright, that a genius may be born like Minerva from the
brain of Jove. There is brusquely a new pattern, ' some-
thing quite original ', a mutation. It used to be a dogma :
Natura non facit saltus, but evidences of Natura saltatrix
are rapidly accumulating. They spoke of life ' slowly
creeping upwards ' but the Proteus leaps as well as creeps.
There is doubtless some progress by thrift, by adding one
to one to make a thousand, but it is beginning to be clear
that Nature gambles. The great steps in evolution were
probably made by grands coups, not by savings. Many
of them express new ideas, and it is difficult to see how a
new principle in organization could originate gradually.
While modern biology lays more emphasis on what may
be called the ofganismal factor in evolution what is
attainable by the creative experiments of the organism,
especially in the germinal part of its life this is in no way
inconsistent with the Darwinian theory of Natural Selec-
tion, or Nature's sifting. The raw materials are the inborn
variations; the internal condition of progress is their
heritability and their consistency with the rest of the
organism ; the external condition is the struggle for existence
THE WONDER OF LIFE 585
in its manifold forms ; the process is discriminate elimina-
tion ; and the result is the survival of the variants fittest
to the given conditions.
Eeferring, for discussion, to our ' Darwinism and Human
Life,' we wish to emphasize what seems to us of the greatest
importance, that Nature's sifting is extraordinarily mani-
fold and subtle, as Darwin always insisted. The struggle
for existence is much wider than is suggested by the words
taken literally. It expresses the sum total of the reactions
which living creatures make to their limitations and diffi-
culties. We see the struggle for existence wherever living
creatures press up against limiting conditions ; wherever
living creatures, with their powers of growing and multiply-
ing, thrusting and parrying, changing and being changed,
competing and combining, working for self and working
for others, do in any way say, ' We will live '.
In the same way the Natural Selection which Darwin
spoke of metaphorically as ' daily and hourly scrutinizing
throughout the world the slightest variations ', is only
thought of truly when it is thought of subtly. For it
comprises all the forms of discriminate criticism which meet
the experiments or variations of organisms, now working
with dramatic swiftness in killing off unfit variants even
before they are born, again working with imperceptible
slowness giving to some a slightly longer life or a slightly
larger family, now singling the full-grown, and again the
young, and again the germ-cells themselves. As Goethe
said, ' Nature's children are numberless. To none is she
altogether miserly ; but she has her favourites, on whom
she squanders much, and for whom she makes great
sacrifices. Over greatness she spreads her shield'.
Summary. Our view is that the organism is the
586 THE WONDER OF LIFE
product the creation-result of the germ-plasm with its
great uniformity and yet ever-newness, and the environ-
ment with its great uniformity and yet ever-newness.
The germ-plasm is variable, that is to say it makes experi-
ments, some futile, like every artist's, some successful.
Those that are successful are so because their urgent fingers
fit into the environmental glove. But this metaphor is on
one side too static. For the germinal experiments that
succeed are those to which the environment offers, as it
were, encouraging opportunity for expression.
Tactics of Nature. What we have said in regard to
the method of organic evolution refers only to the general
formula, and we cannot here do more than illustrate the
answers to the interesting further question that arises as
to the detailed tactics in particular cases. The production
of such geniuses as ants and bees, wasps and spiders, rooks
and cranes, elephants and horses, remains more or less
of a mystery. Though in some cases, such as elephants and
horses, we have considerable information as to the historical
stages of evolution, we have little light in regard to the
organic urge which may have accounted for the successive
uplifts. As has been said, we understand the survival
but not the arrival of mutations. It is different, however,
when we turn to Nature's method of making extraordinarily
new things out of very old things. For this is what has
happened in a great number of cases where something
apparently novel has emerged. The old is, as it were, re-
crystallized. The mineral becomes a jewel. Let us give
a few illustrations.
The spinnerets of a spider are very novel contrivances,
but they apparently represent transformed limbs. The
butterfly's spiral proboscis is a coiled jaw and the bee's
THE WONDER OF LIFE 587
sting an elaborated ovipositor. The serpent's fangs are
folded or channelled teeth, and the reservoirs of venom are
but specialized salivary glands. The milk-glands of mam-
mals seem to have arisen from clusters of sebaceous skin-
glands, common to both sexes. Every schoolboy knows
that the elephant's trunk an extraordinary novelty in
FIG. 92. Wing of Adelie Penguin, Pygoscelis adelise, illustrating the
fact that a very novel structure, a nipper, may arise by a not very
great transformation of an older structure a whig. (After Pycraft. )
A, the entire wing covered with small flat feathers ; B, the bones of
the wing ; H, humerus ; R, radius ; u, ulna ; R, radiale, one of the
two free wrist bones ; u, ulnare, the other free wrist bone ; CMC,
carpometacarpus, part of wrist and palm fused ; I, thumb bone
fused ; II, second digit with two joints or phalanges ; III, third
digit with one joint (PH. i.).
its day is just the creature's nose, and every student of
comparative anatomy can tell us how the hammer and
anvil that form part of the delicate apparatus for conveying
vibrations to the inner ear were once part and parcel of the
rougher and more commonplace mechanism of the jaws.
There is no doubt that to make an apparently very new
thing out of a really very old thing is part of Nature's magic
588 THE WONDER OF LIFE
The idea which we have illustrated was clearly expressed
by Dr. Anton Dohrn, the founder of the famous Zoological
Station at Naples. He called it ' the principle of function-
change ', and showed, for instance, that the unimportant
bladder which grows out from the hind end of the gut in
frogs, becomes an all-important birth- robe, the allantois
in reptiles and birds, and part of the placenta, which
binds the unborn young to the mother, in mammals.
New things out of old, that is the law. For what could
have been newer in its day than a feather, and what is a
feather but a glorified scale ? In regard to this homology,
which Aristotle discerned so long ago, there is still a little
difficulty, for the development of a feather is very distinc-
tive and in several respects unlike that of a scale. And
there are no transitional types between scale and feather,
the minute flat structures on a penguin's flippers being no
nearer scales than are the plumes of an eagle. Recent
investigations, such as Frieda Bornstein's study of the
foot of the capercaillie, where feathers and scales occur in
close association, point to the conclusion that a feather
corresponds not to a whole scale, but to part of a scale,
another part being suppressed. But none the less the
feather illustrates the evolution of the new from the old.
As another illustration of tactics we would briefly refer
to the idea of temporal variations which has been expounded
by Professor Patrick Geddes. In the chapter on ' The
Cycle of Life ' we have spoken of the changes which may
come about by lengthening out one chapter of the life- history
and compressing another, by altering, as it were, ' the time '
of the tune at different periods. It seems that we can
interpret not a few evolutionary changes in the light
of this idea. For some types are all youth, and others
THE WONDER OF LIFE 589
are born old ; some telescope adolescence and others draw
it out for many years. It is plausible, and, as we say,
suggestive, to regard certain types as arrested juveniles
and others as precociously senile, just as we have plants
which remain as great buds and others which are all flower.
The idea is the more valuable because we know of an
agency in higher animals by which the rate of development
of particular parts can be altered. It has been shown
that internal secretions have a regulating action on the
growth of parts of the body. Some act as accelerants,
others as inhibitors. It is said that ' infundibular extract
(from the pituitary body) has been employed with success
in recent years in order to add in a short time a few desirable
inches to a young man's height. So that it seems, after
all, as if one may, by taking sufficient thought, add a cubit
to one's stature. In other cases, it is the absence of a
specific secretion that causes some particular part to grow
abnormally large, as if some brake were removed. Prof.
Arthur Dendy has suggested that this internal regulation
of growth may account for cases where animals or parts
of animals seem to have acquired some sort of momentum,
growing far beyond the limit of utility. A disappearance
of certain glands, or some change in the secretion of certain
glands, may remove the normal brake, with the result
that a part which was wont to be controlled as to its
growth by a specific secretion or ' hormone ', may grow
far beyond its optimum, and may indeed become fatal to
its possessor.
Another theory, deserving of more than brief illustration ,
is suggested by Virchow's idea of an optimism of pathology.
Certain organic diseases are due to constitutional variations
which tend to the wrong side of viability, but those germi-
5go THE WONDER OF LIFE
nal variations that miss are not far removed from those
that hit, and what misses in one type may hit the mark in
another. Constitutional disease is metabolism which
has got out of time, out of place, and out of proportion.
What is disease in one organism may be normalized in
another. Let us give examples.
The strange process by which the bone at the base of
the stag's antlers dies away every year would be a patho-
logical necrosis in other animals, but it has been normalized
in deer and allows the antlers to fall off. The remarkable
changes that occur in Ascidian larvae or in tadpoles'
tails at the time of metamorphosis would certainly be
classed as pathological degenerative processes in other
types, but they have been normalized. Similarly, the
metamorphosis from the larval to the adult type of archi-
tecture is, in many insects, accompanied by inflammatory
crises in which phagocytes play an important role. The
viscid threads by means of which the male stickleback
binds together the leaves of plants to make a nest are pro-
duced, according to Mobius, by the enlarged testes affect-
ing the kidneys in a semi- pathological manner. There
are parallel pathological products in higher animals, but in
the stickleback the process has been normalized, and
turned to good account. Do not the sea-swifts, which
make snow-white nests of the copious secretions of the
mouth, suffer from super-salivation, and what shall we say
of the ' pigeon's milk ' which is formed from a curious
degeneration and disruption of the cells lining the crop ?
In further illustration of this normalizing of the patho-
logical, we may refer to Poyarkoff's description of the
gill-plate sacs in which the embryos of the common fresh-
water bivalve, Cyclas, are incubated. The embryos
THE WONDER OF LIFE 591
develop in the shelter of the inner gill-plate within little
sacs, and the point is that these are in the main due to the
activity of leucocytes. In other words, they arise by a
process analogous to inflammation. After the embryos
are liberated the gill- plate requires considerable patching
up, especially as regards its epithelial covering.
TRADING WITH TIME
In a preceding chapter we gave illustrations of life's
victory over difficulties. The most uninviting corners of
the earth and sea are explored and exploited ; the most
unpromising habitats become comfortable homes ; a
table is spread in the wilderness ; there is sometimes, as
we have seen, an amazingly successful recklessness, and
in cases like the migratory birds who literally ' know no
winter in their year ', we are face to face with an achieve-
ment which seems not far short of getting the better of
Time.
(A) Registering Experience. The beginning of the
organism's business of trading with time was not far from
the beginning of living organisms themselves. We are not
sure that a living creature was worthy of the name until
it became able to register its experience, until it was
able to profit by what happened to it. They say that the
bar of iron once struck remembers the blow, which seems
to us rather an abuse of metaphor, but, as we believe in
the value of metaphor as a scientific instrument, we do
not press our objection. We would ask, however, whether
the smitten bar of iron, or the jarred crystal, or the jewel
whose sanctity was violated, remembers the experience
to its own advantage, for that is what the organism does.
Its premiums paid to experience are its own best treasures.
592 THE WONDER OF LIFE
This capacity of registering experience and of utilizing
that registration in subsequent activities, appears to us
to be of the very essence of life. To take an instance that
seems simple, though it is probably very difficult, they say
that Venus's Fly Trap (Dioncea muscipula) when it has been
tricked several times in succession by stimuli which bring
it no satisfaction (or which do not lead on to the normal
sequences to which the plant has been habituated in Nature),
will cease to respond to the provocative stimuli. It passes
into a state of ' physiological sulks ' ; it becomes callous
to stimuli ; and this is the very best thing it could do,
short of catching hold of the tantalizing experimenter.
It almost remembers.
It must be recognized that among the simpler animals,
such as Protozoa, Sponges, Zoophytes, Sea-Anemones,
Corals, Jellyfishes, Sea-Urchins, Starfishes, and simple
Worms, with not very much in the way of what are popu-
larly called ' habits ', there is great sensitiveness to stimulus
and a remarkable power of somehow registering experiences.
A starfish has no nerve-centres or ganglia at all ; that is to
say, the nerve cells of its nervous system are not concen-
trated, and indeed they have not sunk beneath the level
of the skin ; but the starfish has a remarkable power of
registering experiences and acting differently because it
does so. It has got far above the level of simply ' answering
back '. One reaches a higher level, of course, when there
is real and effective memory, for we cannot believe in more
than vague memory in creatures that have not nerve-
centres. For real and effective memory there must be
repositories or treasure-houses, such as nerve-centres
afford.
(B) Individual Modifications, We see then that the
THE WONDER OF LIFE 593
organism has a characteristic power of registering experi-
ences, and the next step in our argument is that these
experiences may have lasting effects. Let us take one
illustration from the results of imprisonment in darkness.
Light, as every one knows, has many effects on the living
creature : it is used by the green leaf in building up organic
substances ; it makes our pulse beat more quickly ; it
serves as a liberating stimulus for the development of pig-
ment. These are only three of the many relations between
light and life. We inquire therefore with interest into the
negative side the influence of darkness, and we shall
refer to Ogneff's very interesting experiments on gold-fishes.
He kept them in a roomy tank and with plenty to eat
earthworms and ' blood- worms ' (larvae of Chironomus,
the harlequin fly) but in absolute darkness. He kept
this up for over three years, and observed the modifications
that occurred in the fish.
The colour first became black, but in the second year
it became golden again, and the reason for this is interest-
ing. To begin with, the dark pigment-cells (melanophores)
spread out and covered up the subjacent layer of waste-
crystals (iridocytes) which give the gold fish its golden
sheen. But subsequently the wandering amoeboid cells
or phagocytes devoured the dark pigment- cells and thus
re- exposed the golden layer.
The changes in the eye were even more interesting.
A complete alteration occurred in the structure of the
pigment- epithelium of the eye, and there was a complete
disappearance of the rods and cones, and of some other
characteristic features of the eye. Profound atrophy
of the eye occurred in the absence of any functioning, and
the fish became totally blind. This experiment is of great
Q Q
594 THE WONDER OF LIFE
interest, and it should be repeated by some other investi-
gator on some other type. It shows us how much may
happen in an individual lifetime. It suggests that an
individual fish imprisoned in a perfectly dark cave would
become blind. In the next generation the atrophy of the
eye would probably be greater, since the offspring would
experience the darkness from birth while their parents
experienced it only from the date of imprisonment. It is
likely that the absence of light-stimulus would inhibit the
development of the eye. Thus blind fishes in caves might
be accounted for in terms of individual loss through disuse.
If the degeneration of the eye continued to increase after
the second generation, that would prove the hereditary
accumulation of an acquired character. On another
theory, blindness might arise in caves as a germinal
variation and, being possibly advantageous, become
a racial character. A constitutionally blind race would
not show any power of getting back its well- developed
eyes on re- exposure to light, but a modificationally blind
race would.
A drastic change in the surroundings often makes the
organism quiver in its inmost parts, and curious modifi-
cations, that we do not as yet know the meaning of, are
brought about. Thus Ogneff has shown that Axolotls
kept in darkness and starved at the same time become
blanched an experiment which may throw some light
on the whiteness of some cave animals, such as the Proteus
of the Carinthian caves. In the Axolotls the black pig-
ment cells atrophied and were destroyed by the ever- ready
body-guard of phagocytes, which carried off the pigment.
This goes on not only in the skin, but in some of the internal
organs, which also lose their black pigment- cells.
THE WONDER OF LIFE 595
(C) Habituation. What is true of the results of environ-
mental influence holds good in regard to function. A
sequence of activities often performed leads to the estab-
lishment of a habit, which is associated with a structural
change in the nervous system. As we say, paths are
established along which nervous messages pass swiftly
and smoothly. Experiments, such as some of those alluded
to in the chapter on " The Ways of Life," show clearly that
the individual organism can in various degrees become
habituated, and it is plainly advantageous to it to have
engrained reactions, tropisms, rhythms and instincts.
Ready-made effective answers to frequently recurring
questions save time and energy, and often the life of the
creature. In many cases there is no time for experiment-
ing or deliberating, the answer must be instantaneous if
it is to be any good at all. But this brings us to the difficult
fact that it is often with more than individual habituation
that the organism gives its ready-made answer such as
passing into hibernation on the approach of winter, or
flying south in the autumn. Antecedent to its individual
experience, it exhibits the effective reaction.
(D) Transmissibility of Acquired Characters.
In the case of a Protozoon, such as an Amoeba or a Slipper
Animalcule, the problem is simple. The unicellular creature
gathers experience ; its organization is definitely affected ;
it has learned a lesson. This is not for itself alone but for
its race, for it multiplies by dividing into two, and each
of the daughter- cells shares in the organization which has,
so to speak, learned a lesson. Each new unit can then go
on to learn the lesson a little better, and so we have the
rudiments of behaviour in these relatively simple living
creatures. There is no doubt here that the race profits
596 THE WONDER OF LIFE
by the premiums which the individuals pay to experience.
But when we pass from the unicellulars to the multicellu-
lars the problem changes. There is a differentiation be-
tween body-cells and germ-cells, and although the germ-
cells do not live a charmed life within the body it is difficult
to suppose that experiences registered in the body can
affect the germ-cells in such a specific and representative
way that the offspring will profit by the experiences of its
parent's body. It is possible that deeply saturating
environmental influences may affect both body and repro-
ductive organs somewhat similarly. It is possible that
very important and frequently recurrent alterations of the
ordinary metabolism, which are registered as structural
modifications of the body, may sometimes be associated
with the formation of characteristic cellular substances
which saturate through the body and pass into the germ-
cells. Through the germ-cell when it comes to develop,
these hypothetical substances may affect the body of the
offspring. In point of fact, however, we do not at present
know that a structural modification of the body of the
parent, impressed from without by some peculiarity of
the environment, or brought about through some peculiarity
of functioning, can affect the offspring in such a specific
or representative way that the parent's modification is
transmitted. We do not know that this ever occurs.
Many thoughtful people find it impossible to believe
that somatic experiences do not specifically or representa-
tively affect the offspring. How can there be any trading
with time worth talking about if the individual gains are
not handed on as a legacy to the offspring ? But the
confidence with which this question is asked sometimes
disappears when we ask another ' And the losses too ? *
THE WONDER OF LIFE 597
For that would be obviously very disadvantageous, and yet
we cannot have the one without the other, the pluses
without the minuses.
All biologists are agreed that starving a mother may
prejudice the development of the offspring, and that the
accumulation of toxins in the body of either parent may
have the same effect, but that is not the point of the long-
continued and still unended controversy regarding the
transmission of somatic modifications (badly called ' the
inheritance of acquired characters '). The precise point
at issue is this : Does a structural change in a part of the
body, directly induced by use or disuse, or by some change in
surroundings and nurture generally, ever affect the germ-
plasm in the reproductive organs in such a specific or repre-
sentative way that the offspring will thereby exhibit the same
modification that the parent acquired, or even a tendency
towards it ?
We have discussed this question carefully in our Hered-
ity and Darwinism and Human Life , and we shall
not attempt to summarize the pros and cons. It may be of
interest, however, to give a short account of what appears
to us to be the most careful experimental contribution
that has yet been made towards the solution of this crucial
biological problem. We refer to Dr. W. E. Agar's experi-
ments on one of the small Crustacea, a Daphnid or
water-flea. The condensed narrative is necessarily a
little difficult, but it will reward the serious student, not
only in its interesting conclusion, but also as a fine
example of scientific method.
(E) A Test Case. Dr. W. E. Agar studied a curious
abnormality reflexion of the valves of the carapace in
the water-flea or Daphnid, called Simocephalus vetulus.
598 THE WONDER OF LIFE
The abnormality seems to be induced by the nature of
the food ingested. Affected animals appear quite healthy
and reproduce freely. He found that although individuals
were removed to control conditions (of relative normality)
before the eggs were laid, the young developing from these
eggs exhibit the same abnormality as that which their
parents had acquired during their lifetime, as a direct
result of their environment. This result has been con-
firmed over and over again. Females with ripe eggs were
also removed from control conditions and put into the
particular culture which induces reflexion of the valves.
The young developed from these eggs were fully normal,
showing the persistence of the effects of normal environ-
ment. Subsequent broods of these females in the culture
became successively more and more reflexed, i.e. the
normality wore off just as the abnormality also does.
In a second set of experiments by raising the temperature
(to 28-5 31-5C.) the size of the young Daphnids was
greatly reduced in their first, and indeed in all stages. The
rate of the life- cycle was also enormously increased, the
period from the birth of the parent to the birth of the
young being fourteen days at 16 and six days at 30.
The number of young per brood was diminished. The im-
portant results of the experiment were the following. The
specimens developing from eggs laid by parents a few hours
after removal from the higher to the lower temperature
were almost as small as those born at the higher temperature.
The subsequent eggs laid by the same parents, still under
control conditions, still remained affected by the smalhiess-
producing conditions, though to a rapidly diminishing
extent.
In a third set of experiments a reduction of length was
THE WONDER OF LIFE 599
caused by living in a particular kind of solution. The
reduction was found to persist for a short time, and was
followed by a reaction.
The experiments illustrate ' parallel induction.' In the
first and second sets of experiments, at any rate, individuals
placed in abnormal environments in their first stage
acquired the definite abnormal features in their own bodies
in later stages. Simultaneously, the eggs in their ovaries
were influenced in such a way that the young developed
from them presented at birth the same abnormality as
that which their parents had acquired in their lifetime.
It made little difference whether the young developed
from eggs laid after removal of the parents to control
conditions, or were bom in the abnormal environment,
so long as the eggs underwent their ovarian growth while
the parents were under the influence of the environment.
In the subsequent broods of those parents which had been
removed to control conditions the effect of the abnormal
conditions appeared in rapidly diminishing intensity. In
the second generation in control conditions the abnormal
effect still persisted (in the first two sets of experiments),
but to a very slight degree. In all three sets of experiments
a very decided reaction appeared in the third generation.
Mutations, giving rise to new types, are due to a change
in the composition in the living unit. ' The other cause
of variation a change in the environment while the living
units remain the same is probably far commoner. Such
a change, if effective, will probably result in the formation
of unusual metabolic products included in the living proto-
plasm, and thus the visible external variation produced
may have as its immediate cause either the changed environ-
ment itself, or the altered protoplasmic inclusions. In
6oo THE WONDER OF LIFE
the case of parallel induction, it seems that the environ*
ment works indirectly, through the mediation of these
(not living) products, which when once formed are not
immediately got rid of, but are passed on passively included
in the protoplasm of the gamete '. Some (not living)
product is included in the egg, passes passively into the
body which develops from the egg, and thus produces on
the body the same effect as it produced on the body of the
parent which acquired the character in question.
Dr. Agar sums up the question of transmissible environ-
mental effects as follows: (1) A changed environment
(in its widest sense) may produce a visible modification in
the body indirectly by altering the nature of the metabolic
products included in the living protoplasm. These in
turn react with the protoplasm, and therefore effect changes
in its product, the body. (2) Whenever the environment
acts simultaneously on body and gonad a similar alteration
in metabolic inclusions of somato- and germ-plasm takes
place. (3) These metabolic substances included in the
germ-cell naturally pass into the developing body, which,
therefore, shows the same modification as its parent did,
even though removed from the environment in question.
(4) These substances may produce a powerful effect, though
present only in minimal quantities. (5) They may be of
such a nature as to stimulate the formation of antibodies,
thus causing a reaction in later generations.
It is probable that many biologists of to-day would be
relieved to find that there is much more truth in Lamarckism
than Charles Darwin thought there was when he said ' Hea-
ven forfend us from such Lamarck nonsense '. We have
taken the most scientific investigation we know of that
bears on this question, and it does not seem to strengthen
THE WONDER OF LIFE 601
the Lamarckian position. It is easy to interpret results
as due to the hereditary accumulation of individual gains
and losses, which have been acquired under conditions
of changed function or changed environment ; but when
it comes to experimental testing the case breaks down.
(F) Does Experience count for the Race ? Let us
turn back to our study of instincts, with this extremely
important question in our minds. It is certain that many
animals have an inborn capacity of reacting in a definite
and adaptive way to particular stimuli, and a succession
of these reactions may be linked together in a very effective
piece of behaviour. In some cases at least, as we sought
to show, it is possible to give a reasonable interpretation of
these instinctive capacities. We can think of them be-
ginning as germinal variations ; we can think of them
progressing as germinal variations ; we can think of them
being most subtly perfected in the course of Natural Selec-
tion. All this is outside of the hypothesis that the tutelage
of experience counts for anything except in the individual
lifetime. That individual experience may give a finishing
touch to instinctive capacity may be admitted without
accepting the view that these individual gains are in any
representative way transmissible.
What we have stated is the ordinary Darwinian view,
but we must in fairness give a statement of the Mnemic
interpretation, according to which the offspring are sup-
posed to benefit directly by the premiums paid to experi-
ence on the part of their parents and ancestors.
(G) Mnemic Theories. The term ' mnemic ', which
recalls the more familiar word mnemonic, is applied to the
theories of heredity suggested by Ewald Hering, Samuel
Butler, Richard Semon and others, according to which
602 THE WONDER OF LIFE
the germ-cells are supposed to treasure up some of the
results of the organism's experience, as it were, by uncon-
scious memory, so that when they come to develop they
reproduce in some measure the traits which their parents
or their ancestors acquired as the result of experience.
The idea is that the germ-cells become stored with the
latent ' memories ' of past generations, or less metaphoric-
ally that the germ- cells are changed or impressed in a
^definite and specific way by the organism's experiences.
Development is in part the ' recollection ' of these germinally
treasured * memories '.
Samuel Butler's view was that an inheritance implies
; a store of memories and that development is akin to recol-
lection. A newly hatched chick pecks at once and with
good effect, because certain cells in the chick remember
having superintended pecking before. Part of every in-
dividual existed before in the parents and the molecules
have a memory of previous experiences.
Let us take as a very interesting illustration E.
Bordage's observations on European peach trees trans-
ported to Reunion. As has been noticed in similar cases,
they dropped their deciduous habit and became it took
some twenty years evergreen. The individual constitu-
tion was altered. But the still more interesting point
is that when seeds of these pseudo-evergreens were sown
in certain mountainous districts with a considerable
amount of frost, they produced young peach trees which
were also evergreen. European seeds sown in similar
places produced ordinary deciduous trees.
It must not be hastily concluded that an interesting
case like this compels us to return to the old belief in the
transmission of acquired characters in the form that
THE WONDER OF LIFE 603
belief took before Weismann's scepticism. The change
to evergreenness was physiological rather than structural
a change in the rhythm of metabolism"perhaps. More-
over it is quite likely that the climatic change operating
for many years influenced the germ-cells of the peach along
with the whole tree. This is a legitimate theoretical dis-
tinction, though it is not, perhaps, of much practical im-
portance.
Let us try to state Semon's central position without
using his somewhat bewildering terminology. Every one
admits that an organism reacts to many different kinds
of external change. It registers within itself its novel
experiences. Some of these produce changes in what
Semon calls the ' energetic sJtuajilQi} ' of the whole organism, \^
and these are supposed to impress themselves in a lasting
way on the germ-cells. The impressed effects on the germ- -1
cells are conveniently called ' engrams '. Just as our mind )
becomes rich in memories of experiences, so the germ- plasm ..
becomes stored with many ' engrams '.
The second general idea in Semon's theory concerns de-
velopment. When the germ- cell which has been impressed
with ' engrams ' comes to develop, a partial recurrence
of the ' energetic situation ', which previously acted ' en-
graphically ', will call forth the latent engrams into expres-
sion. Given appropriate stimuli the ' memories ' will stir,
and they will influence what is going on, namely the
development of the individual.
Let us recapitulate. Year after year a complex influ-
ence plays upon the organism and modifies its constitution.
The internal ' energetic situation ' is changed and result-
ing stimuli are supposed to pass to the germ- cells. The
corresponding changes in the germ-cells are called en-
604 THE WONDER OF LIFE
grams. When the germ cells come to develop into
offspring, these engrains may have an influence a specific
influence. Appropriate liberating stimuli of the nature
of the original change in the energetic situation will call
forth the latent engrams. This is called ' ekphory '.
In support of his nrnemic theory of heredity Semon
cites, among other facts, Kammerer's experiments on the
Nurse-Toad (Alytes obstetricans}. Unlike ordinary toads,
the female lays her eggs on land, and the male who assists
in the process gets them glued on his hind legs. Moreover,
the eggs are larger than usual, with more yolk, and fewer
in number.
Kammerer kept the toads at a relatively high temperature
(25-30 C.) and thus induced them to seek the water,
where the egg-laying and fertilization took place. The
gelatinous envelopes of the eggs which had remained sticky
and unswollen on land, now swelled up as usual, and as they
would not adhere to the male's legs, the eggs developed
in the water. After several breeding periods the toads
became accustomed to the water ; they also laid more
numerous and smaller eggs.
But the more important fact is this, that the offspring
of the toads showed a change of habits like that of their
parents. When they became sexually mature they sought
the water, even when kept at the normal temperature,
and laid their eggs there. The fourth generation showed
a re- appearance of the doubtless ancestral swollen pad on
the forefinger of the male, which was absent in the race of
nurse-toads with which Kammerer experimented. In
Semon's phrase the appropriate stimuli called forth the
latent ancestral engrams.
Provisional Conclusion. It may be that there is
THE WONDER OF LIFE 605
more truth in the Mnemic interpretations than we are
personally able at present to recognize, and we have no
desire to be dogmatic. But we do not feel that the evi-
dence is convincing.
What then is the state of the case? The individual
profits by experience, profits in his protoplasm and cells,
in his joints and marrow, in his mind and character. There
is no secure evidence, however, that his gains are in any
way entailed, or that his losses are minuses to his offspring.
Yet the progress of a race or stock looks as if these profitable
lessons learnt by the individual did somehow count. Now
it is possible that the germinal primordia of various char-
acters, embodied we cannot conceive how in the germ- cells,
respond, as flames to tuning-forks, to the lessons which the
corresponding actualized characters in the body of the
individual are learning. We keep an open mind on this
question, but it must be admitted that the present-day
facts are mainly, though not exclusively, against this view
that particular modifications of the parentage do specific-
ally affect the progeny in the same direction. If this
be so, what then remains but a retreat to the original Dar-
winian position of copious germinal variations sufficiently
copious to ensure a certain number of (selectable) hits
amid a multitude of misses ?
The question ever returns : What is trading with time
good for, if the bodily experiences of the individual do not
count for the race ? For that is what it comes to. We
would suggest that the question requires some re-setting.
Our biology is at times too anthropomorphic and at times
not anthropomorphic enough. In human affairs we con-
tinually think of ourselves as experimenting, trying this
and trying that, and finally doing something. We transfer
606 THE WONDER OF LIFE
this idea to the non-rational animals, and we think of
them, probably aright, as trying this and trying that, and
finally doing something. We carry this idea down and
down, and probably it is much truer than many naturalists
think, but we doubt whether it is by thinking of adult
organisms that we shall understand what trading with
time really means.
The suggestion we wish to make is this. No one will
dispute the statement that an Amoeba may profit by its
experiences and may make experiments ' in the light of '
these experiences. Now it must be remembered that the
germ- cells or gametes are not ordinary cells ; they are indi-
vidualities, organisms, creatures, who live and multiply,
who struggle and combine, who are repositories of multi-
plicate inheritances adjusting themselves inter se in the
most momentous of organic compromises. Now it may be
that these gametes neither simple cells nor portmanteaus
of hereditary items, but unified ' creatures ', experiment
not fortuitously, but artistically, not at random, but with
a purpose.
The Living Past. In any case, one of the strongest
impressions that we get from the study of organic evolution
is that of the persistence of the past in the present. In a
manner inconceivable to us, save through the analogy of
memory, the germ- cell garners the long results of time.
To some extent in the development of organs in the indivi-
dual there is a recapitulation of stages which correspond
to long chapters in the evolution of the race. And just
as we recognize traits of their wild lineage in our domesti-
cated animals, so in a wider field we see the individual's
organic reminiscence of primeval days and a recrudescence
of ancestral wounds. In ourselves we are only too well
THE WONDER OF LIFE 607
aware of these ' palaeo- atavistic ' qualities. There is a
terrible truth in Walt Whitman's picture of man emerging
' stuccoed all over with reptiles and quadrupeds ', and in
Tennyson's picture of ' Reversion ever dragging Evolution
in the mud '. As Prof. Stanley Hall says :
' We are influenced in our deeper, more temperamental,
dispositions by the life-habits and codes of conduct of
we know not what unnumbered hosts of ancestors, which
like a cloud of witnesses are present throughout our lives,
and our souls are echo- chambers in which their whispers
reverberate '.
The idea of the living past is familiar in connexion with
those vestigial structures, like the teeth in whalebone
whales, which persist in many animals as tell-tale evidences
of remote ancestry like the unsounded letters in words
or the superfluous flaps and buttons in our clothing which
once had a functional significance. Our own body is a
veritable museum of relics some (like the notochord)
disappearing in embryonic life, others (like the Eustachian
tube) persisting in greatly disguised form, others (like the
third eyelid) remaining as dwindling vestiges, and others
(like the vermiform appendix) not merely outliving their
usefulness, but proving themselves dangerous anachronisms.
It goes without saying that the mere persistence of
dwindling organs and of habits that have become anachron-
isms, is not evidence of misadaptation. The useless teeth
of the baleen whale, the unseeing eyes of many cave-animals,
and the now meaningless relics of wild habits which many
domesticated animals exhibit, present no particular diffi-
culty. They are the vanishing vestiges of characters
that were once effective and adaptive. This remains a
satisfactory answer except to those who expect a perfect
6o8
THE WONDER OF LIFE
cosmos even when it is pointed out that vestigial organs
are often very variable and apt to be seats of diseases
(witness appendicitis),
and that anachronistic
habits form part of
what men call crimes.
None but the un-
imaginative can fail to
be impressed by the
sight of the pelvic
bones of a large whale.
Dwindling relics they
are of originally huge
hip-girdles. They may
be connected with ad-
jacent muscles a tail
muscle, the genital
muscles, and a trunk
muscle, but they are
practically of no mo-
ment. Eontgen ray
photographs show that
they still retain, how-
FIG. 93.-Vestigialhip-girdleandhind.limb 6Ver > the Characteristic
of a whale. 1, Vestige of pelvis or internal architecture of
hip-girdle; 2, Vestige of thigh-bone or , Q ,.
femur ; 3, Cartilage corresponding to bone - bometimeS, as
the tibia. The closely dotted parts tne fig^e g^ows, there
are cartilage. I he dotted line crossing J .
2 shows the contour of the pelvis ; are vestiges not Only
M, muscles attached to these pieces of e .1 hn
skeleton. (After Struthers.) ot tne P elV1S
only by the ischiac portion), but of femur and tibia
as well. Careful measurement made by Willy Augustin.
THE WONDER OF LIFE 609
of the pelvic vestiges of the Finner (Balcenoptera physalus),
the Blue Whale (B. sibbaldi), Rudolphi's Rorqual (B.
borealis) and the Humpback (Megaptera boops) show
that the bones, like many vestigial structures, are in a state
of considerable variability.
We have given two figures of a very interesting and
puzzling structure connected with the roof of the brain
in Vertebrates. From the region known as the 'tween-brain
or optic thalami there is a dorsal up-growth, usually con-
FIG. 94. Vertical section showing the pineal eye of the adult slow-
worm, Anguis fragilis. (After Hanitsch.) 1 , Cuticle ; 2, Epidermis ;
3, Connective tissue ; 4, Parietal bone of the skull ; [5, Lens of pineal
eye ; 6, Wall of pineal eye ; 7, Epiphysis or upgrowth from the
brain. It is here continuous with the stalk of the pineal eye.
According to Hanitsch, the pineal eye in the slowiworm is
sensitive to changes of temperature.
sisting of two parts, a pineal organ or epiphysis proper,
and a parietal organ, which generally springs from the
epiphysis, but may have an independent origin in front of
it. Perhaps they were originally the right and left mem-
bers of a pair. The parietal organ is often atrophied,
but in some cases, especially in Reptiles, it is terminally
differentiated into a little ' pineal body.' In the New
Zealand ' lizard ' (Sphenodon) and in the slow- worm
(Anguis) it shows distinct traces of eye-like structure.
R R
6io THE WONDER OF LIFE
In the lamprey, both the epiphysis and the parietal organ
show this. Above Reptiles the pineal stalk is short and
its terminal portion is glandular. The epiphysis is occa-
sionally absent in Mammals (e.g. some Cetaceans), and
the pineal body is absent in the dolphin and Dasypus.
According to some authorities, the pineal body was primi-
tively an unpaired median, upward-looking eye ; according
to others, the optic function is a secondary transformation.
,3
FIG. 95. Section showing developing pineal eye of Sphenodon. (After
Dendy.) 1, Epidermis; 2, Dermis ; 3, Lens; 4, Wall of pineal
eye ; 5, Choroid plexus of dorsal sac, on the roof of the third ven-
tricle of the brain ; 6, Nerve of pineal eye ; 7, Pineal sac.
For it not infrequently happens that a dwindling structure,
tending to become vestigial, may become secondarily
specialized. Thus the vestigial hairs on the lips of some
whales have a quite extraordinarily rich innervation.
It must be frankly admitted that many of the examples
that used to be given of the re-assertion of long-lost an-
cestral characters were insufficiently criticized, and the
list of so-called reversions has been remorselessly thinned
by the more modern students of inheritance. Sometimes,
THE WONDER OF LIFE 611
however, it does seem as if the return to an old-fashioned
condition was best explained by the hypothesis of the
re-awakening of an ancestral trait which had lain latent
for many generations.
In other cases it seems more likely that some derange-
ment of development has resulted in a suggestion of an an-
cient condition without there being any re- awakening of
any particular ancestral item in the inheritance. Probably
this is the case with most of the two- toed horses that crop
up. But some of them are strongly suggestive of more
than this. Thus Prof. K. Skoda, of the Veterinary College
in Vienna, describes a case where each fore-leg bore beside
the normal single digit (No. Ill) a second. This second
(No. II) had three joints, but did not reach the ground.
There was a metacarpal (or palm-bone) for this extra
digit, but it was largely fused with the ordinary meta-
carpal of No. III. The usual No. IV. free splint or meta-
carpal was present, and there seemed to be actually hints
of a minute metacarpal No. I. Especially when we look
into the details of a case like this does it seem difficult to
dissociate what occurred from all relation to the ancient
polydactyl.
To some minds it seems very inconsistent to credit the
germ-plasm at one time with great stability, and at another
time with great power of change. But there is really no
paradox here, for every thinker with a lively intelligence
shows the same combination of qu.'-ilities holding by
fundamental principles, yet restlessly experimenting with an
open mind. So the germ- plasm in its own fashion proves all
things and holds fast that which is good. Moreover, it is
quite likely that the varying or mutatir\g occurs periodically.
Just as we have an alternation between speculation and
612 THE WONDER OF LIFE
dogmatism, between liberal and conservative moods, so
the germ-plasm may have what correspond to originative
and fixative moods.
As an instance of the stability of the germ-plasm, even
when violently treated, we may take Dr. D. D. Whitney's
investigation of the effect of alcohol on generations of
Rotifers. He studied four strains of parthenogenetic
Rotifers, originally descended from one female, for twenty-
eight successive generations. One strain was kept as a
control, and the other three strains were kept in a quarter
per cent., a half per cent., and one per cent, of alcohol. The
rate of reproduction was lessened in the alcoholic strains
and the resistance power was lowered. In the eleventh to
fifteenth generations of the one per cent, alcohol strain, the
individuals showed a decidedly lower resistance power. They
exhibited a markedly increased susceptibility to copper
sulphate which was used as a test of resistance. The result
showed, then, the evil effects of alcohol. But whether it
showed the hereditary evil effects or not remained to be
seen.
When the alcohol was removed in generations eleven to
twenty-two, the rate of reproduction increased noticeably in
the very first generation, and in the second equalled that
of the control strain. Individuals of the second generation
after the alcohol had been removed were no more susceptible
to copper sulphate than those which had never been alco-
holized. The general conclusion is that the grandchildren
possess none of the defects caused by alcohol in the grand-
parents. The alcohol, in the small percentages used,
affected only the body-tissues of the Rotifers, which is not,
of course, to be interpreted as meaning that chronic alcohol-
ism in man may not affect the germ- cells. Dr. Whitney
THE WONDER OF LIFE 613
also points out that if the Rotifers were subjected to the
alcohol solution indefinitely, generation after generation, the
race would probably become extinct. The alcohol lessens
the rate of reproduction and it may, in the course of time,
progressively weaken the germ-cells. What was proved,
however, was that ' if the alcohol is removed it is possible
for the race to recover and to regain its normal condition
in two generations, thus showing that the germ- substance
is not permanently affected by the alcohol ' so far as the
experiments went. In any case we have a good instance
of the stability of the germ- plasm.
It is only fair, however, to cite a case on the other side,
indicating susceptibility. Dr. Charles R. Stockard made
experiments for three years in intoxicating male guinea-
pigs by inhalation of alcohol (which does not spoil their
stomach), and reached the important conclusion that an
alcoholized male guinea-pig almost invariably begets
defective offspring even when mated with a vigorous
normal female. The effects were manifest in the second
generation animals as well. ' The poison injures the cells
and tissues of the body, the germ-cells as well as other
cells, and the offspring derived from the weakened or
affected germ- cells have all of the cells of their bodies
defective.'
Dentition of Shrews. Let us take a somewhat un-
familiar illustration of a persistent relic. It is well known
that in ordinary placental mammals with various kinds
of teeth (heterodont as it is called), there are never
more than three pairs of incisors. There is thus a gap
between all ordinary mammals and the old-fashioned
Polyprotodont Marsupials, such as the Tasmanian Wolf
or Thylacine, which has four upper incisors, and the Bandi-
614 THE WONDER OF LIFE
coot (Perameles) which has five. Now a study of the
development of the teeth in shrews led Augusta Arnback-
Christie-Linde to the very interesting discovery, that
there are more than three incisor germs in both jaws of
Sorex araneus, and probably also in the upper jaw of
Neomys. These extra incisor germs in the Shrew are
apparently useless relics vestigial structures without
any function. They come and they go without attaining
full development. ' They are ', the discoverer says,
' undoubtedly inherited from distant ancestors, which
consequently were to be found among polyprotodont (and
heterodont) mammals '. As regards the number of
incisor teeth it seems as if the Shrews bridged the gap to
which we alluded above. In any case, these extra incisor
germs seem to illustrate our present point of the long
lingering of structural relics which have outlived their use.
In the inner upper corner of our eye there is a minute
half -moon- shaped fold, the plica semilunaris, a most
interesting item in the museum of relics which we carry
about with us in our body. For it corresponds to the
third eyelid (in whole or in part) which is well- developed
in most mammals and helps to clean the eye. It is vestigial
not only in Man, but in Monkeys and in Cetaceans. Its
practical absence in the Cetaceans is compensated for by
the continuous washing of the eye with water. In the
other cases the frequent movements of the upper eyelid
must make up for the vestigial state of the third eyelid. It
is a very old structure, a venerable relic, for it is the ' nicti-
tating membrane ' that is flicked across the eyes of Birds
and it is also represented in most Reptiles.
It may be profitable to pursue the matter a little further.
The plica semilunaris sometimes includes in man a minute
THE WONDER OF LIFE 615
cartilage a tell-tale cartilage. In white races it is a great
rarity, occurring in less than one per cent. Giacomini
found it in four cases out of five hundred and forty- eight
whites. But he found it twelve times in sixteen coloured
people, and Adachi found it five times in twenty-five
Japanese. More recently Dr. Paul Bartels examined twenty-
five South African natives (eight Hereros and seventeen
Hottentots) and found the tell-tale cartilage in twelve.
The cartilage is found in all Apes and Monkeys, and although
no living Ape or Monkey is ancestral to Man, the cartilage
is a Simian feature, persisting in Man since the remote
period when the human stock diverged from the Simian.
The facts show that some races are in this instance as in
others, more theromorphic than others more conser-
vative of their historical relics.
One has, of course, to be careful in using this interpre-
tation of peculiarities as atavisms. It is probable that in
some cases all that we are justified in saying is that a varia-
tion occurs which happens to be along very antique lines.
To take an example, the teeth of mammals begin as in-
growths of the (ectodermic) epithelium into the (meso-
dermic) connective tissue of the gum, whereas the teeth
of sharks and skates and other Selachian fishes begin as
papillae of the mesoderm which grow up into the epidermis.
The teeth of Selachians are just transformed scales, turned
to a new use. But it is a remarkable fact that the Sela-
chian or placoid mode of tooth development does occur
in Bony Fishes, tailed Amphibians, and in the crocodile.
Rose has seen hints of it in the human embryo, and not
long ago (1911) Adloff found in a human embryo, of about
nine weeks, a freely projecting epithelial papilla lying
beside a normal tooth-germ. He regarded it as an atavistic
616 THE WONDER OF LIFE
rehabilitation of the oldest mode of tooth- development.
Amphibian Scales. Sometimes it seems quite legiti-
mate to recognize a structure as a relic although we are
not aware of the precise affiliation. Every one knows
that almost all amphibians are naked-skinned or scaleless
in great contrast to the scaly Reptiles. It is also well
known that some of the ancient extinct Amphibians, the
Labyrinthodonts or Stegocephali, were armoured. There-
fore it is interesting to find in the most old-fashioned stocks
of living Amphibians, namely the burrowing Csecilians,
that there are transverse rows of thin calcined scales
imbedded in the dermis or under-skin. Moreover, in a few
rare cases among tailless Amphibians, there are bony scales
in the skin. Thus in Ceratophrys dorsata there is a bony
shield on the back which arises from the confluence of a
large number of small ossifications in the dermis. It is
very unlikely that this can mean anything but a retention
of the ancestral armour. Not less interesting, though less
secure, is Margarethe Kressmann's interpretation of
numerous papillae that occur all over the lower layer of
the dermis in Siren lacertina, the American mud- eel.
Each consists of firm connective tissue and is usually tipped
with a mantle of pigment. They project into the more
superficial looser layer of the dermis and are quite hidden
from the outside. It seems reasonable to interpret them
as dwindling vestiges of the ancestral armature.
The Egg Tooth. At the tip of the bill of many un-
hatched young birds there is a horny knob which is called
the egg- tooth. It has nothing whatever to do with teeth,
of which, as separate structures, no living bird is known
to show any hint (the alleged cases of tern, etc., having
broken down) ; but it is interesting in several ways. If it
THE WONDER OF LIFE 617
is of use in breaking through the egg-shell to liberate the
young bird, which seems, in some cases at least, to be
very doubtful, then it is one of those structures which are
used only once. As every one knows, it usually falls off
soon after hatching.
This fact suggests that it may not be a special structure
that has evolved on a line of its own, but the last relic of
an old set of structures, retained because of its utility
while all the others have gone. Some recent observations
by B. Rosenstadt suggest that the egg-tooth of the upper
jaw and its corresponding vestige on the lower jaw, maybe
relics of an ancient armature, older than the horny sheaths
we are familiar with on the bird's jaws. In the first place
they become horny in the embryo before there is any other
cornification on the jaws. In the second place, the process
of horn-making in the egg tooth is different from that
elsewhere. Each of the skin cells concerned turns wholly
into horn, nucleus and all, whereas in ordinary cases, as
in the horny sheaths that make the bill, only the mantle
of each cell is turned into horn. This is a technical point,
but it is of interest in suggesting that the egg-tooth is a ,>
very ancient relic indeed.
Whales' Hairs. Let us look at the fact of whales'
hairs. If we could understand these, we should have a
master-key in our hand. The points are three. (1) The
ancestry of Cetaceans is unknown, but they are quadrupeds
and mammals none the less that the remains of the hind-
limbs are buried, and that their hairs are reduced to a
minimum. It is possible that whales were evolved from
scale- covered Mammals, which took to aquatic life. The
slight resemblance of the whale's flipper to that of the
extinct Ichthyosaurian reptiles cannot mean much; for
618 THE WONDER OF LIFE
the flipper-type must have arisen de novo in the Cetaceans.
It is a specialized transformation of a typical mammalian
limb, just as the skull is a specialization of a typical mam-
malian skull.
(2) Although the divergence of Cetaceans from a terres-
trial stock must have taken place very long ago, the loss
of hair may have been very gradual, or it may have occurred
brusquely, by a mutation such as we see in ' Chinese dogs '.
It is a remarkable fact that they seem never to disappear
altogether. Although the inexperienced eye may see none,
there is probably no species entirely without them. Dr.
Arnold Japhen recently examined five kinds of baleen
whales and six kinds of toothed whales, and found hairs
about the lips of them all. Therefore we must admit that
the capacity of forming hairs remains still in the Cetacean
skin, that, in some way or other, the potentiality of hairs
persists as a dwindling relic as part of the inheritance. It
is very interesting to find that apart from their great reduc-
tion in number, the hairs show distinct signs of retrogression.
The hair-muscles and the sebaceous glands have gone,
the hair shaft is greatly reduced, what is called the root-
sheath is simpler than usual, and there is no hair casting.
(3) On the other hand, we find in regard to whales'
hair an illustration of what has often occurred in the
course of evolution that vestigial structures may be
utilized, indeed specialized, even when they are very
much reduced. It seems, metaphorically speaking, as
if the organism sometimes saved its historical relics just
as they were disappearing by discovering some utilitarian
vindication of them. For these small retrogressed hairs
on the whales' lips exhibit at the same time a remarkable
specialization, namely in their rich supply of nerve-fibres
THE WONDER OF LIFE
619
and in the way these end in the hair-follicle. There may
be four hundred nerve-fibres to a single hair, so that if
there are twenty-five hairs on the chin region, there are
FIG. 96. King Crab, Limulus, seen from above. It is an archaic
type, a veritable ' living fossil,' the sole survivor' of the ancient
race of Palaeostraca. The figure shows the horseshoe-shaped
cephalothorax shield, bearing lateral and median eyes ; the ab-
dominal shield ; and a spear or telson projecting behind. (From
a specimen.)
ten thousand nerve fibres. The vestigial hairs seem like
specializations of the tactile hairs or vibrissse which every
one knows in a cat's whiskers. In the toothless Cetaceans
620
THE WONDER OF LIFE
at least, it seems highly probable that these richly inner-
vated, though much reduced structures, play some role
in connexion with food-getting.
Living Fossils. Of great in-
terest in this connexion are those
old-world types such as Peripatus
and Limulus, Polypterus and the
Dipnoi, Sphenodon and the Mono-
tremes survivors of ancient races.
One of these living fossils is
the hoatzin (Opisthocomus), an
extremely ancient and isolated
type, frequenting the lower
Amazon and surrounding terri-
tory. One of its primitive
features is the quadrupedal
character of the young, which
use their fore-limbs for creeping
about with on the branches.
They also dive and swim well.
There are external claws on the
first and second fingers and a
vestigial claw on the third. The
hand- like use of the wing is
present in the adults as well, who
never fly if they can help it. Mr.
Beebe notes that ' their method
of arboreal locomotion is to push
and flop from branch to branch '.
Their weakness of flight is doubt-
less in part due to a curious
specialization, that the crop has
i
FIG. 97. Peripatus, an
ancient type, in some re-
spects linking segmented
worms to Insects. The
figure shows antennae,
simple eyes, simple
clawed appendages, and
an unsegmented some-
what cater pillar-like
body. (After Balfour.)
THE WONDER OF LIFE 621
become like a gizzard, with thick and muscular walls.
This is associated with a unique reduction of the front
of the breast-bone, and a consequent lessening of the
area for the attachment of the muscles of flight.
FIG. 98. New Zealand Lizard, Sphenodon or Hatteria, an archaic
reptilian type, sole survivor of the ancient race of Rhynchocephalia.
(From a specimen.)
Conservation in Evolution. We wish to expand the
idea of the living past into a general conception of the
conservative tendency in evolution. There is, it seems to
us, a very literal sense in which we may think of the higher
animals as heirs of all the ages. Particularly effective
modes of vital behaviour, some of which made a fortune
in their day, yet did not save their possessors from utter
ruin, have been caught up by collateral relatives and
handed on as a legacy from by-gone ages to the higher
animals. Where, for instance, would a higher animal
be what possibility of such a life would there be without
a persistence of that most primitive manifestation of life
which we call amoeboid movement the ebb and flow
of a protoplasmic tide so familiar to students of biology
in amoebae and white blood corpuscles ? How long would
a higher animal survive without its body-guard of phago-
cytes ? Nor could it have become what it is, had not its
embryonic nerve-cells flowed out into nerve- fibres ; just like
exploring Amoebae !
622 THE WONDER OF LIFE
One of Harrison's devices was to excise a small portion
of nerve cord from an embryo frog, and to replace this by a
cylindrical clot of blood or lymph of the proper length and
calibre. After two or three days the embryo was killed
and sectioned. It was found that fibres from the brain
and anterior part of the cord had grown, or flowed, for a
considerable distance into the cord, forming naked threads.
But the general point with which we are here concerned
is that the development of nerve-fibres is brought about
by one of the very primitive properties of protoplasm,
namely amoeboid movement.
It is very interesting that the only animal types
without wandering phagocytes are the Nematodes
(some of which at least have stationary phagocytes) and
the Lancelets. The Nematode worms do not lead on
to anything else ; and the Lancelets, though near the
base of the Vertebrate branch, are specialized types
on a cul-de-sac of their own ! It appears to us profoundly
significant that Man himself in the development of his
nervous system, in the repair of an injury to the front of
his eye, in the everyday resistance to intruding Bacteria,
and in every inflammation, serious or trivial, harks back
in his cellular activities to the Amoebae gliding along on the
mud of the pond.
VITALISM
The Purely Physical. Among the facts with which the
student of science has to deal there are many which he
calls purely physical the movements of the earth and the
heavenly bodies, the seasons and tides, the sun and the
wind and the rain, the weathering of the mountains, the
making of the fruitful land, and so forth. The reality
THE WONDER OF LIFE 623
which these facts represent may not be exhausted by
formulae in terms of matter and motion, but for the theore-
tical purposes of description, and for the practical purposes
of anticipation and mastery these formulae suffice. The
facts may be treated as parts of a mechanism, on the view
that all are ' merely complicated cases of change of con-
figuration in a system of mass particles '. The processes of
the physical order are marked, as every one knows, by their
rigid uniformity of routine, their monotonous sequences,
which are like chains of iron. They can be described with
extraordinary precision on which we stake our lives
every day by means of formulae which have only a few
factors in them. At present, these factors seem to be not
more than five the ether, the electron, the atom, the
molecule, and the mass, energy being ' involved in the
construction of any of these out of any other '. The
question with which vitalists are chiefly concerned is
whether these concepts are adequate for a useful descrip-
tion of the activities of organisms for a description which
will make the facts of life more intelligible, by showing
them to be particular cases of something more general.
For that is what ' making a thing intelligible ' usually
means. It must be quite clearly understood that as
material systems in space, organisms ' conform to the laws
of the physical universe ' : gravity affects a bird just as
it affects a stone, the properties of a hydrogen atom are
the same whether it forms part of a scholar or of his mid-
night oil, capillarity is as inexorable in a blood vessel as in
a glass tube ; but what the vitalist says is that all the
available knowledge of chemical and physical happenings
within the organism does not begin to answer the distinc-
tively biological questions.
624 THE WONDER OF LIFE
The Animate. That the animate order of facts trans-
cends in some way the purely physical seems to some minds,
and to certain moods of other minds, almost self-evident.
The world of life is full of individuality, of spontaneity, and
apparent purposiveness. Living creatures often make
fatal mistakes when the environment is too much for them,
but in their normal surroundings what is characteristic
is their effectiveness of response, making for self-preserva-
tion and betterment. They are genuine agents, trying, or
seeming to try, one reaction after another until they find
the one which is most effective ; they profit by experience.
It is necessary, however, to face the objection that these
qualitative criteria of livingness are manifest only in the
higher reaches of the animal kingdom, and illustrate the
compounding and elaborating that goes on in evolution.
The plant seems less animate than the animal, the coral less
animate than the bird. And we have already referred to
such difficulties as are presented by latent life and local
life, by the survival and development of a minute fragment
of an egg, and by the fertilization of a frog's egg by a pin's
prick. We must not take selected instances of life's apart-
ness ; we must consider vital phenomena all along the line.
Argument from everyday Functions. When we
take counsel with the physiologists and inquire into the
contraction of muscles, the irritation of nerves, the diges-
tion and absorption of food, the process of respiration, and
the filtering of blood by the kidneys, we find that many
chemical and physical processes are involved, but that it
has not yet been found possible to give a continuous
physico-chemical description of any total vital function.
We can isolate off portions of a function and watch them
occurring in a test-tube away from the living body alto-
THE WONDER OF LIFE 625
gether, but we cannot re-combine our analyses so as to
account for the whole.
It is not merely what happens, but the way in which it
happens, that we have to consider. If we inquire into the
passage of digested food from the alimentary canal into the
blood, or the interchange of gases in the lungs, or the filter-
ing that goes on in the kidney, we certainly find that
these involve physico-chemical processes, and we detect
in their occurrence nothing that contradicts the principles
of physics and chemistry ; and yet the physico-chemical
formulae do not suffice for a complete description of the
vital function. They do not quite fit ; the living cells
make a difference a difference which we have at present
to accept as a fact.
Every year we know more about the physical and
chemical processes that occur in living bodies, but it does
not seem as if the physico-chemical explanation of vital
functions was coming any nearer. We do not know what
the future may have in store ; but we must take things
as they are, and there is surely significance in the fact
that increased knowledge of physiological chemistry and
physiological physics has brought the distinctively vital
into stronger relief. It has not made the distinctively
vital more intelligible ; that is, it has not shown it to be a
particular instance of something more general.
Treating the organism as a machine has led to great
clearness in regard to the big transformations of energy
that go on in the body. Without Chemistry and Physics
applied to the living body, what would be our understand-
ing of respiration, of animal heat, of muscular work, or of
the significance of the various kinds of waste ? And yet
what works well as an engine of research, does not suffice
S 8
626 THE WONDER OF LIFE
for a formulation of the facts of the way in which the
great workshop of the body is regulated, of the way in
which the different functions are adjusted to every varying
need, of the way in which they work into one another's
hands, so that a unified effective life results. To take one
instance, it is no longer a difficult physico-chemical problem
to account for the ' animal heat ' of the living body (or
for a large fraction of it, at any rate), but this does not
help us much to account for ' warm-bloodedness ' ; that is
to say, for the regulation of heat-production and heat-loss,
so that the temperature of the body of the bird or the
mammal remains approximately constant whatever the
outside temperature may be. Much is known in regard
to the so-called ' thermotaxic mechanism ', but the more we
know the further off it seems from mechanical explanation.
If no everyday function of the body has found complete
re- description in physico-chemical terms, it follows a
fortiori that we are not within sight of an explanation of
such fundamental vital processes as growth and repro-
duction. As we have already seen, organic growth is no
process of passive accretion, it is selective and integrative.
The new material is incorporated and unified ; what is
added on is related essentially, far more than topographic-
ally, to what is already present. The growth is a repro-
duction of the specific organization and of no other.
It may seem strange to assert that even if we had a
complete record of all the transformations of matter and
energy that go on within the body in all its everyday
functions, we should not be answering the biological ques-
tions as to the activity of the creature as a whole : What
is the ' go ' of this animal, how does it keep agoing, how
do the various functions work in a variable way into one
THE WONDER OF LIFE 627
another's hands, how are they co-ordinated in a harmoni-
ous result, how are they adjustable to changeful external
conditions ? Even a complete ledger of the osmotic and
capillary processes, the oxidations and reductions, the
solutions and fermentations, would not furnish the kind of
description the biologist wants.
We must bear in mind the extraordinary complexity
of the problem of the everyday life of any common animal.
For what is a creature but a huge army with battalions
which we call organs, brigades which we call systems ?
It advances insurgently from day to day always into new
territory often inhospitable or actively unfriendly ; it
holds itself together, it forages, it makes good its own losses,
it even recruits itself, it pitches a camp and strikes it again,
it goes into winter-quarters, it retreats, it recovers itself,
it has a forced march, it conquers. What the biologist
wishes is a description of the organism's daily march which
will not ignore the reality of the tactics the intra-organis-
mal tactics.
In addressing the Physiological Section of the British
Association in 1909, Professor E. H. Starling said :
' In his study of living beings the physiologist has one
guiding principle which plays but little part in the sciences
of the chemist and physicist, namely, the principle of
adaptation. Adaptation or purposiveness is the leading
characteristic of every one of the functions to which we
devote in^ our textbooks the chapters dealing with assimila-
tion, respiration, movement, growth, reproduction, and
even death itself '.
Now adaptation or purposiveness requires a historical
explanation ; it is a supra-mechanical concept. It is true
628 THE WONDER OF LIFE
that it applies, in a measure, to a machine, but a machine
is the embodiment of a human purpose. It is an elabor-
ated tool, an extended hand, and has inside of it a human
thought.
The Argument from Animal Behaviour. The
inadequacy of a physico-chemical account of vital activity
becomes even more obvious when we pass from the every-
day activities of the body to a connected series of animal
activities to animal behaviour.
Let us return, for instance, to the newly hatched micro-
scopic larva of the liver-fluke, of so much practical import-
ance to sheep-farmers (see p. 307). It has no organs in the
strict sense ; it has only a few cells altogether ; it has no
hint of a nervous system. It is covered with cilia, and
has energy enough to swim about for a day in the water-
pools by the pasture. It comes in contact with many
things, but it responds to none, until haply it touches the
little freshwater snail (Lymnceus truncatulus) the only
contact that will enable it to continue its life. To this it
responds by working its way in at the breathing aperture,
and within the snail it goes through a complex series of
multiplications and metamorphoses, the upshot of which
may be that a sheep becomes infected with a young liver-
fluke. The life-history is dramatic, the risks of failure
are enormous ; our point is the delicate adaptation of a
brainless organism to the one stimulus which will enable
it to continue its life. This seems to us to be far beyond
all possibility of mechanical description ; it requires a
historical explanation.
What we have just alluded to is no rare curiosity ; it is
a frequent and characteristic feature in animal behaviour
that the organism is historically tuned to be a receptor
FlG. 99. Nest of hornet, Vespa crabro, in vertical section. It was suspended from a slate
roof, AR. The top of the primary central support is seen at T. There are six tiers of
combs (1-6). Round the central comb of the sixth tier, there are four combs, the
structure of which is shown at the side, B c D E. V, the entrance. P, the road to the
nest, along the beam F, is marked by the dotted line. A short cut has been formed at
L, which represents two triangular paper screens. M, part of the gable wall. As the
situation was a very warm one, the wall of the nest had only one thin envelope (ENV).
W/fcr?Janet.)
THE WONDER OF LIFE 629
to particular but absolutely indispensable stimuli which
may not occur more than once in the life-history. The
freshwater mussel, as we have already mentioned, carries
her young ones in her outer gill- plate, and does not set
them free unless a stickleback or a minnow or some other
such fish is in the immediate vicinity. When the fish comes
near, the mother mussel, whom it is no libel to call ' acepha-
lous ', liberates a crowd of pinhead-like larval mussels or
Glochidia, who rush out into the water like boys from the
opened school door. They snap their minute valves ; they
make for the fish ; they fasten on its skin and enter upon
a new chapter of their life-history. Even in the laboratory,
when they have been removed from the mother, they be-
come excitedly active if a morsel of stickleback be dropped
into the dish in which they are. It is this organic memory
of the essential stimulus that seems to us to be character-
istic and supra -mechanical of a higher order than the
responsiveness of wires or photographic plates to particular
kinds of rays. It is a sensitiveness gained or invented by
the creature in the course of its racial evolution and regis-
tered in the constitution. Though simpler, it is as well
marked in the absolutely brainless larva of the liver-fluke
as in the larval mussel which has the beginnings of a nervous
system ; in a small-brained, predominantly instinctive
creature like a bee as much as in a big-brained, predomin-
ably intelligent creature like a bird. We find analogous
kinds of behaviour at all levels of nervous organization.
The worker-bee leaving the hive for the first time enters
a new world with confidence and proceeds to gather
honey from difficult flowers, being ' to the manner born '.
We have referred to the definite proof that a young
swallow which leaves Britain for the South at the end of
630 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Summer may return the following Spring to the farm-
steading which was its birthplace. The question is :
Does the return of the swallow differ from the return of a
thrown boomerang in kind or only in degree ; that is to
say, Does it require different fundamental concepts for its
interpretation ?
We wish to emphasize the fact that the same sort of
behaviour requiring historical explanation occurs at
all levels of organization, even when there is no question
of brains at all. It is distinct from the ' soul and body '
problem. Dr. Driesch, who stands as the foremost pro-
tagonist of modern vitalism, got to his strong convictions
by experiments on egg-cells, where there are no data as to
mental processes. The problem of the autonomy of life
would confront us even if to make an impossible assump-
tion there were no animals in the world at all, only plants
and us Jack and his bean-stalk, in fact.
Migration of Eels. As an illustration of the problem
of vitalism let us take the migration of eels, which has been
recently discussed in this connection in a masterly article by
Mr. E. S. Russell (' Vitalism ', Rivista di Scienza, April,
1911). It is a very useful case, because the eel has a brain
of a very low order, and we are not warranted in using
in regard to it the psychological terms which are indis-
pensable in the case of the more intelligent birds and
mammals (see p. 458).
The eels of the whole of Northern Europe probably begin
their life below the 500-f athom line on the verge of the deep
sea away to the west of the Hebrides and Ireland, and
southwards to the Canaries. The early chapters of the
life-history remain obscure, but the young larva rises to
the upper sunlit waters as a transparent, sideways-flattened,
THE WONDER OF LIFE 631
knife-blade-like creature, about three inches in length,
with no spot of colour save in its eyes. It lives for many
months in this state known as a Leptocephalus expend-
ing energy in gentle swimming, but taking no food. It
subsists on itself, and becomes shorter and lighter, and
cylindrical instead of blade-like. It is transformed into a
glass-eel, about two and a half inches long, like a knitting
needle in girth. It begins to move towards the distant
shores and rivers. In some cases it may take more than
a year to reach the feeding ground those that ascend the
rivers of the Eastern Baltic having journeyed over three
thousand miles. Their ranks are thinned, but large num-
bers succeed in finding the estuaries, and the passage of
millions of elvers up our rivers is one of the most remark-
able sights of Spring. There is a long period of feeding and
growing in the slow-flowing reaches of the rivers and in the
fish-stocked ponds. But there is never any breeding in
fresh water, and after some years a restlessness seizes the
adults as it seized the larvae a restlessness due, however,
to a reproductive, not to a nutritive motive or impulse.
There is an excited return journey to the sea they don
wedding garments of silver as they go and become large
of eye. They appear to migrate hundreds of miles, often
at least out into the Atlantic to the verge of the deep sea,
where, as far as we know, the individual life ends in giving
rise to new lives. In no case is there any return.
Let us consider in particular the penultimate chapter, the
migration from the rivers to the distant spawning grounds.
Like many other fishes, the eel requires for spawning very
definite conditions of depth, salinity, and temperature.
The North Sea will not serve, for it is too shallow ; nor the
Arctic Ocean, for it is too cold. What can the Machine
632 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Theory of Life make of a story like this ? What can the
physiology that is only applied physics and chemistry tell
us ? It can tell us, for instance, a most useful thing to know,
how the energy for the journey is obtained from chemical
explosions of oxidizable material in the muscles of the eel's
body. It can tell us some of the steps in the making of this
fuel out of the eel's food. It can tell us that the muscles
are kept rhythmically contracting by nervous stimuli ;
that the advent of sex-maturity often alters an animal's
reactions to external stimuli ; and so on for a whole volume.
It is all interesting and indispensable, but it does not really
help us much in trying to understand the migration of the
eels to the distant spawning grounds. Even if an omnis-
cient chemist and physicist could give an account in his
own language of all the physical and chemical happenings
that occur in the eel's body from the time it left the pond
to the day of its death, that would not make more intelli-
gible to the biologist the concatenation of all these into the
unified adventure of migration.
' To the chemist ', Kussell says, ' confronted with this
problem, there is no fact of migration at all ; there is only
an intricate enravelment of chemical reaction. To the
biologist the fact of migration to a particular region for a
particular purpose is cardinal '.
If it be said that one can picture, in dreams at least, a
torpedo so delicately adjusted, that it descended rivers,
went out to sea, kept off the rocks, turned corners, and did
not explode until it could do so effectively in an area of
appropriate stimulation, the answer must be that this
mechanism is still a very hypothetical construction, and
that if it were constructed it would not be a fair sample of
THE WONDER OF LIFE 633
the inorganic world. For obviously it would have a human
idea and a human purpose inside of it the very essence
of its construction. But more than that, the eel has made
itself what it is in the course of ages ; it has traded with
time ; it has evolved. And again, the hypothetical
torpedo does not, in its final explosion, start a crowd of
potential torpedoes, which is what the eels do before they
die.
But if the mechanistic account of the eel's migration is
unsatisfactory, is the vitalistic one or, as we prefer to say,
the biological one any better ? What light has biology
to throw on the remarkable story ? Only this, that we
can relate the particular case of the eel to what we know of
organisms in general, that they are historical beings, deter-
mined by their past their own past and that of their race.
The eel's inheritance is a treasure-store of the ages, a
registration of many inventions. Non-living things have
no history in this sense ; we cannot say that they have
profited by experience. In the organism, as Bergson
says, the past is prolonged into the present. Thus we pass
on to a new level of explanation or interpretation, which is
historical in a sense different from that implied when we
give a so-called historical interpretation of the present
state of the Alps. As Professor W. K. Clifford put it :
* It is the peculiarity of living things not merely that
they change under the influence of surrounding circum-
stances, but that any change that takes place in them is
not lost but retained, and as it were built into the organism
to serve as the foundation for future actions. . . . No
one can tell by examining a piece of gold how often it has
been melted and cooled in geologic ages. . . . Any one
who cuts down an oak can tell by the rings in its trunk
634 THE WONDER OF LIFE
how many times winter has frozen it. ... A living being
must always contain within itself the history, not merely
of its own existence, but of all its ancestors.'
As Bergson maintains, it is distinctive of the organism,
as of ourselves, that :
' Its past, in its entirety, is prolonged into its present,
and abides there, actual and acting '. ' Continuity of
change, preservation of the past in the present, real dura-
tion the living organism seems to share these attributes
with consciousness '.
Argument from Development. When we observe
the development of an animal actually going on, in almost
perfect transparency, as in the moth Botys hyalinalis, we
get an impression of something very unlike anything else in
the world. From a minute clear drop of living matter
lying on the top of the yolk we see in the course of twenty-
one days the development of the chick the gradual emer-
gence of the obviously complex from the apparently simple.
It seems far away from mere machinery ; it is more like
an artist painting a picture. We get the same impression
when we look into details, such as the making of the silk-
like threads that compose the familiar skeleton of the bath
sponge. Large numbers of secretory cells called spongo-
blasts group themselves in double file in the middle
stratum of the sponge, as if some unseen captain mar-
shalled them. Up the middle of the double file spongin
is secreted, made at the expense of the contributors, and
the many individual contributions coalesce in a sponge-
fibre. By combining the images that we get from sections
at various stages we can, in a sense, see the replacement
of a piece of cartilage by bone the sappers and miners
THE WONDER OF LIFE 635
called osteoclasts who clear the ground, and the builders
called osteoblasts who build up the new construction all
working like busy ants. We feel that this transcends
mechanical categories. Eeference has already been made
to the quite extraordinary series of events that is witnessed
when a larval insect, such as a fly, goes through its meta-
morphosis the larval body breaking down into debris, the
new body being built up out of the ruins on a very different
architectural plan. The central wonder of development
is the general process of differentiation, the realization
of the inheritance, but this is enhanced by many accessory
facts : there is the remarkable power the embryo often
shows of righting itself when the building materials of its
edifice have been artificially disarranged ; there are interest-
ing ' regulation phenomena ' by which it adjusts itself after
disproportions have been artificially induced ; there are
the strangely circuitous paths, reminiscent of ancient his-
tory, by which it reaches its goal ; there are the widely
different ways of securing the same results.
The vitalistic argument from the facts of development
has found its finest expression in the work of Dr. Hans
Driesch,who was led to the conclusions of his Science and
Philosophy of the Organism by a brilliant series of embryo-
logical experiments. His arguments based on the study
of morphogenesis, or the development of form and structure,
are too technical for our present discussion (we have given
a resume of them in The Hibbert Journal, January, 1912,
in an article from which we have borrowed freely) ; we
cannot do more than indicate his main thesis.
' Life, at least morphogenesis, is not a specialized
arrangement of inorganic events ; biology, therefore, is
not applied physics and chemistry : life is something apart,
636 THE WONDER OF LIFE
and biology is an independent science '....' There is
something in the organism's behaviour in the widest
sense of the word which is opposed to an inorganic resolu-
tion of the same, and which shows that the living organism
is more than a sum or an aggregate of its parts. . . . This
something we call " Entelechy ".'
Driesch conceives of ' Entelechy ' as ' an agent at work
in nature ', 'of a non-spatial nature ', without a seat or
localization ; it is unmaterial, and it is not energy ; it is
not inconsistent in its agency with the laws of energetics ;
its function is to suspend and set free, in a regulatory man-
ner, pre-existing potentials, i.e. pre-existing faculties of
inorganic interaction.
Argument from Organic Evolution. It is con-
venient to speak of ' cosmic evolution ', ' inorganic evolu-
tion ', ' the evolution of the solar system ', ' the evolution
of the earth ', ' the evolution of scenery ', and so on ; but
there is a risk of identifying processes which are really
very different.
In biology it is usual to draw a distinction between the
two terms development and evolution. Development
(Haeckel's ontogeny) is the becoming of the individual ;
Evolution (Haeckel's phylogeny) is the becoming of the
race. How do these agree and differ ? In both there is
a succession of stages, and the scientific assumption is that
each stage is conditioned by the preceding stages. In
development the continuity between successive stages is
one of personal identity ; it is the same organism from
start to finish, though, as we have seen in the chapter on
' The Cycle of Life ', there are some apparent contradic-
tions. In racial evolution, however, the stages are physic-
ally discontinuous. Although we speak of the continuity
THE WONDER OF LIFE 637
of the germ-plasm, we must admit that one generation
is not personally identical with preceding or succeeding
generations.
But the radical difference is surely this, that in any stage
in racial evolution there are numerous individuals that do
not figure in the final result ; they are outside the pale of
success ; they die before their time or they have small
families ; in any case they and theirs are eliminated in
Nature's sifting. They do not count. They are ' cast as
nothing to the void '. It is easy enough to find in some in-
dividual life-histories, complicated by metamorphosis and
the like, instances of the suppression or elimination of parts,
but there is nothing in development comparable to the
staking of individual lives and losing of them that has
gone on throughout the whole of that sublime and romantic
adventure which we call organic evolution.
It seems to us therefore that it would be more accurate
to speak of the development of the earth, the development
of the solar system, and so on, keeping the term evolution
for the organic and the super- organic. Better still would
it be to find another term for the sequence of changes in an
inorganic system ; and some distinguished men of science
have recognized this in speaking of ' the story of the
heavens ', ' the story of the earth ', and so forth.
This question of words matters a good deal. As Hobbes
finely said, words are only intellectual counters with which
the wise do reckon, but they are the money of fools ;
yet words make fools of us all. The fundamentally im-
portant thing is to avoid verbally identifying processes
which are really very different. In the succession of inor-
ganic changes, there are no alternatives ; every stage is the
necessary outcome of its antecedents ; all is mechanically
638 THE WONDER OF LIFE
determined ; the chains are of iron. In the succession
of organic changes there are alternatives, as a species may
show in splitting into two or more equally successful
species ; the creatures are genuine agents in a fashion
quite different from that of streams of water or ice which
diverge and combine ; in short, the mechanical categories
are transcended. We are not unaware of the analogies
between the inorganic sequence of changes and the evolu-
tion of organisms that have often been indicated, and that
Herbert Spencer made much of ; they are fascinating
but unconvincing. It is said, for instance, that ' the
process by which worlds emerge from the primal nebula
depends upon the conflict of attractive and repulsive
forces ', just as the process by which species emerge from a
primal stock depends upon the struggle for existence. But
' the conflict of attractive and repulsive forces ' is a phrase
which must be used in a large and metaphorical sense
which is what Darwin said in reference to the phrase
' struggle for existence '.
What we have in the realm of organisms is a continual
creation and experimenting on the one hand, and a con-
tinual sifting on the other, but the sifting is often a very
gentle process. At the best, in comparing inorganic and
organic ' evolution ', we do not get beyond formal re-
semblances.
The reasons why many biologists cannot accept as
adequate any mechanical description of organic evolution
centre in the nature of the organism. The organism plays
such an active part. It is active in its variations, which are
experiments in self-expression, though some environmental
stimulus may pull the trigger which liberates them. It is
in some measure active even in the process of natural
THE WONDER OF LIFE 639
selection, for it does not simply submit to the apparently
inevitable. It often evades its fate by a change of policy
or of environment ; it compromises, it experiments ; it
is full of device and endeavour. It is certainly much more
than a pawn in the hands of Fate or Environment ; it
plays its own game. Besides the variability or inventive-
ness, which, from the germ-cells outwards, offers solutions
to life's problems, there is the organism's utilisation of these
assets, and there is the equally fundamental entailment or
hereditary registration of the successful new departures
without which evolution were impossible.
The Continuity of Evolution. Immense gaps in our
knowledge are immediately apparent when we inquire
into the origin of living organisms upon the earth, the
beginnings of intelligent behaviour, the origin of Verte-
brates, the emergence of Man, and so on. We know very
little as yet in regard to the way in which any of the ' big
lifts ' in evolution have come about, and yet we believe
in the continuity of the process. That is implied in our
ideal concept of evolution, which we accept as a working
hypothesis. It is not very easy to say what it is that is
continuous, but we mean in part that there is at no stage
any intrusion of extraneous factors. But this continues
to raise in the minds of many the difficulty that the results
seem much too large for their antecedents. Can we believe
that the world of life, with its climax in Man, has been
evolved from a nebulous mass ?
Let us recall Huxley's famous statement of his radical
mechanism :
' If the fundamental proposition of evolution is true,
namely, that the entire world, animate and inanimate, is
the result of the mutual interaction, according to definite
640 THE WONDER OF LIFE
laws, of forces possessed by the primitive nebulosity of the
universe, then it is no less certain that the present actual
world reposed potentially in the cosmic vapour, and that
an intelligence, if great enough, could, from his knowledge
of the properties of the molecules of that vapour, have
predicted the state of the fauna in Great Britain in 1888
with as much certitude as we say what will happen to
the vapour of our breath on a cold day in winter'.
This strong and confident statement includes several
assumptions regarding which one may fairly argue. Thus
Professor Bergson calls attention to its practical denial
that time really counts. ' In such a doctrine, time is still
spoken of ; one pronounces the word, but one does not
think of the thing. For time is here deprived of efficacy,
and if it does nothing, it is nothing '. Huxley practically
denies the creative individuality of organisms which trade
with time in a spontaneous and unpredictable way all their
own.
The ' fundamental proposition of evolution ' (which
Huxley invoked) is of Man's own making, and we are not
inclined to be coerced by it into believing that the state
of the British fauna either in 1888 or in 1914 could have
been predicted by any intelligence however great from a
* knowledge of the properties of the molecules ' of the
cosmic vapour. Not only because we believe that time
counts with living creatures, but because molecules and
the like are concepts of physical science used for the de-
scription of certain abstracted aspects of reality used to
describe things for a particular purpose or from a certain
point of view. It is true that they correspond to that
aspect of reality so accurately that we risk lives and
fortunes on them, but to say that they exhaust the reality
THE WONDER OF LIFE 641
appears to us not only an unwarrantable assumption, but
a contradiction in terms.
The ' primitive nebulosity of the universe ', or of our
solar system at any rate, has probably its analogues in the
heavens of to-day, where worlds can be seen a-making.
As far as its movements and condensations and such
like went, it might have been physically described, and
it could not have been described in any other way.
But if within that whirling sea of molecules there ' re-
posed potentially the present actual world', then the
physical description would not have been the whole truth
about it. Yet we do not know how the physicist could
have indicated that his description was not exhaustive.
Whenever we think of facts like intelligent behaviour
among animals or the reasoned discourse of Man, who has
harnessed electricity to his chariot, has made the ether carry
his messages, has annihilated distance, has coined wealth
out of the thin air, and has begun to control heredity
itself, we feel that if these qualities reposed potentially in
the nebula's whirling sea, the physical description which
might have been given could not have been exhaustive.
Rather would we fall back on the fundamental proposition
of evolution which Aristotle discerned, That there is no-
thing in the End, which was not also, in its quality,
in the Beginning. Our philosophical position is briefly,
That in the Beginning was the Logos.
Bergson's View. The two modern thinkers who have
most appreciated the wonder of life that is to say, the
relation of theory of life and theory of knowledge are
Professors Henri Bergson and Hans Driesch. We have
already referred, in a necessarily inadequate way, to
Driesch's rehabilitation of the Aristotelian conception of
T T
642 THE WONDER OF LIFE
Entelechy ; we venture to refer it must be very inade-
quately again to Bergson's conception of the origin and
nature of life. Bergson's metaphysical theory is that a
broad current of consciousness penetrated matter, carrying
matter along to organization. He does not keep us in
doubt as to what he means by life. Life is conscious-
ness launched into matter ' availing itself of a slight
elasticity in matter ', ' using matter for its own purposes '.
Consciousness, or rather supra-consciousness, is at the
origin of life, and consciousness appears as the motive
power in evolution. ' Consciousness, or supra-conscious-
ness, is the name for the rocket whose extinguished frag-
ments fall back as matter ; consciousness, again, is the
name for that which subsists of the rocket itself, passing
through the fragments and lighting them up into organisms.
But this consciousness, which is a need of creation, is made
manifest to itself only where creation is possible. It lies
dormant when lif e is condemned to automatism ; it wakens
as soon as the possibility of choice is restored '. In fact
an organism is conscious in proportion to its power to move
freely a quaint metaphysical apology for athletics. In
the course of evolution it becomes more and more free as
the sensori-motor system becomes more perfect. ' But,
everywhere except in man, consciousness has let itself be
caught in the net whose meshes it tried to pass through :
it has remained the captive of the mechanisms it has set
up '. With man, however, a new freedom began. Con-
sciousness is breaking its chains. How free it may become,
who shall say ?
A Suggestion. Under the sway of his evolution-idea,
the biologist finds it difficult to entertain the hypothesis of
consciousness being launched into matter as a bolt from
THE WONDER OF LIFE 643
the blue. May it not have been that the anima animans
has been with creation through and through, and from
first to last ? We think of the majestic order of the heavens
and the perfection of the dew-drop, of the extraordinary
surge of our whole solar system towards some unknown
goal, and of the internal ' life ' of crystals. We wonder
FIG. 100. Rings formed by placing a drop of 80 per cent, silver
nitrate on a thin layer of 510 per cent . gelatine, which contains
about O'l percent, of potassium bichromate. The gelatine under
the drop is coloured red-brown, silver chromate being precipitated.
Outside that a dull, white margin is formed which spreads slowly
outwards. As the diffusion goes on the rings of similar precipitation
of silver chromate are formed at a little distance beyond the area of
uniform precipitation. (After Liesegang.)
if Time has, after all, simply flowed over the opal and the
agate, and whether the beryl has garnered no fruits of
experience. A photograph of a zoophyte e.g. Sertularia
cupressina is extraordinarily like the beautiful dendritic
frescoes which imprisoned Manganese makes on the wall of
its cell ! To take another example, we admire the intricate
zonal structure of Liesegang's rings formed, for instance,
644 THE WONDER OF LIFE
when a big drop of silver nitrate is placed on a film of
gelatine in which there is a trace of potassium bichromate.
There we see, as the diffusion and precipitation proceed,
the rings of growth on a salmon's scale and the zones of the
otolith in his ear. There we see, as the diffusion and pre-
cipitation continue, the zones of growth in the stem of an
oak, in the recesses of a pearl, in the vertebra of a fish, on
the scale of a tortoise, and on the barred feather of the
hawk. No doubt a wide gulf is fixed, but the phenomena
are extraordinarily similar as well as very different, and
our point is simply that too much must not be made of the
quality of ' inertness ' in non-living material.
May it not be that an aspect of reality continuous with
the clear consciousness in the higher reaches of life has
always been present, though it is negligible for the practical
purposes of science until the confines of the inorganic are
passed ? May it not be allowing us glimpses of its presence
in the architecture of the crystal, in the hidden ' life ' of
jewels, and in radio-activity ? May it not be expressing
itself in the tendency that matter has to complexify pass-
ing from atom to molecule, from simple molecule to com-
plex molecule, and from molecule to colloid masses ? May
it not lie behind the inorganic evolution which we are
beginning to discover ? May it not have been resident
in the nebula of our solar system, and be contemporaneous
with the primeval Order of Nature.
IN CONCLUSION
A consideration of the everyday functions of organisms,
of their behaviour, of their development, and of their
evolution, leads us away from Kant's view that there is
one science of nature, and leads us to follow Driesch and
THE WONDER OF LIFE 645
others in maintaining that Biology must be ranked beside
Physics as a fundamental and autonomous science. An-
other line of argument would, we believe, lead us, even
from the naturalist's point of view, to recognize the auto-
nomy of Psychology.
We recognize, then, three orders of facts : the physical
order, where mechanism reigns, where mechanical formulae
suffice for the description of what goes on ; the animate
order, where mechanism is transcended ; and the psychical
order, where mechanism is irrelevant. It is plain that the
physical order overlaps the animate order, for organisms
are material systems, and their life includes a concatena-
tion of chemico-physical processes. At the same time, as
we have seen, we cannot explain the fundamental pro-
perties of the organism, which we start with in biology, in
chemico-physical terms, nor would a complete chemico-
physical description of what goes on in the life of the
organism be the kind of description which a biologist seeks.
The same applies to the psychical order, which is overlapped
by the biological. In short, the sciences are differentiated
not only by their subject matter, but by their characteristic
questions and methods and concepts.
Perhaps we may be allowed to refer to three remarks
which are often made in regard to this sort of discussion
by the plain man in the street, from whom most of us, after
all, are not far removed. He is surprised, in the first
place, at the longevity of the problem of vitalism and the
oscillations of human judgment from one side to another.
An old question indeed, for Aristotle was a thorough-going
vitalist, and his biology was in conscious opposition to the
school of Democritus. And from that time we have had
periodic oscillations between vitalistic and mechanistic
646 THE WONDER OF LIFE
interpretations. Now the organism is a machine, and
again it is a spirit ; now it is a free agent, and again it is
only an automaton ; now engine and again entelechy.
There are several reasons for this continual see-saw, the
chief one being that there is truth on both sides. For the
purposes of chemistry and physics the organism may
be adequately considered as a material system ; for the
purposes of biology another aspect of its reality has to be
recognized.
But another reason is given by Bergson in his theory
of the limitation of our intellect. ' The intellect, so skilful
in dealing with the inert, is awkward the moment it touches
the living '. ' It is characterized by a natural inability
to comprehend life '. ' Created by life, in definite circum-
stances, to act on definite things, how can it embrace life,
of which it is only an emanation or an aspect ? Deposited
by the evolutionary movement, in the course of its way,
how can it be applied to the evolutionary movement it-
self ? ' 'In vain we force the living into this or that one
of our intellectual moulds. All the moulds crack.'
What then can be done ? Some would say, ' Nothing !
Let us cultivate our garden '. Bergson's suggestion is,
that our method of pure intellectualism is wrong. The
line of evolution that ends in human intelligence is not
the only one. Other forms of consciousness, such as
instinct, ' express something that is immanent and essential
in the evolutionary movement. Have we not powers
complementary to the understanding by which we may
get a vision a fleeting vision of what life essentially is ' ?
We have a fringe of instinct.
Some of the tough-minded, or we ourselves in tough-
minded moods, are apt to depreciate that ' fringe of vague
THE WONDER OF LIFE 647
intuition that surrounds our distinct that is, intellectual
representation '. According to Bergson it is an invalu-
able organon.
In sympathy, in artistic and poetic feeling, we come near
instinct. We speak of the intuitive insight of the ' born
doctor ' and the divining sympathy of the mother. Berg-
son says that we do well so to speak. ' Instinct is sym-
pathy ; if it could extend its object and also reflect upon
itself, it would give us the key to vital operations just as
intelligence guides us into matter '. 'By intuition ', he
says, ' I mean instinct that has become disinterested, self-
conscious, capable of reflecting upon its object, and of
enlarging it indefinitely '. It brings us sympathetically
into life's own domain, and makes us feel sure once more
that Wordsworth, Emerson, Meredith, and other nature-
poets are truest, because deepest, biologists of us all.
In the second place, the plain man wonders why we should
worry over such an academic question as the number of
the sciences. Vitalist or mechanist a plague o' both your
houses ! will either view make any difference to this life
of mine ? This raises large questions, but one answer must
suffice. If the mechanistic theory of the organism be
erroneous a false simplicity or materialism it behoves
us in the love of truth to fight, all the more that those
who maintain that biology is only applied chemistry and
physics are of the company of those who say that psycho-
logy is a branch of physiology and sociology a pseudo-
science. This position may be held with conviction in the
name of scientific method and interpretation by men who
are as much impressed as any with the fundamental
mysteriousness of nature, but it tends with the careless
to strengthen the hands of the unpoetic, the unromantic,
648 THE WONDER OF LIFE
and the wonderless, who darken the eyes of their under-
standing.
In the third place, the plain man says : * This big talk
about the autonomy of the organism, and so forth, is all very
well, but do you mean that there is in the living creature
more than meets the eye ? Is there more than matter and
energy, or not ? ' The disappointing scientific answer must
be that the question is not rightly put. We do not know
what matter really is, nor what all the energies of matter
may be. What we do know is that present-day physico-
chemical formulae do not suffice for the biological descrip-
tions of organisms, and that we require to use historical
explanations which are beyond the limits of physics and
chemistry. And we find no warrant for asserting that the
physical concepts of ' matter ' and ' energy ', abstracted
off for particular scientific purposes, exhaust the reality of
Nature. Very much the reverse.
We see before us an ascending series of individualized
activities correlated with an increasing complexity of
material organization the two aspects are inseparable :
the worm is a higher synthesis than the mineral, and the
bird than the worm, but we cannot explain the fundamental
properties of these successive syntheses in terms of anything
else. We feel sure, however, that organisms reveal or
express a deeper aspect of reality than crystals do (deeper,
because it is nearer to what is most real to ourselves, our
own conscious experience), and that in this sense there
is more in the plant than in the crystal, more in the animal
than in the plant, more in the bird than in the worm, and
more in man than in them all,
FINIS
[From Huxley's translation of Goethe's Aphorisms.]
IHature ! "Ode are surrounDeD anD embraced bg ber :
powerless to separate ourselves trom ber, anD powerless
to penetrate begonb ber. . . .
TUfle live in ber miDst ano know ber not. Sbe ts incess*
antlg speaking to us, but betrays not ber secret. . . .
Sbe rejoices in illusion. Idboso Destroys it in bimself
ano otbers, bim sbe punisbes witb tbe sternest tgrannp..
Wboso follows ber in faitb, bim sbe takes as a cbilD to ber
bosom.
Sbe wraps man in Darkness, ano makes bim for ever
long for ligbt. Sbe creates bim DepenDent upon tbe eartb,
Dull ano beavg ; ano set is always sbaking bim until be
attempts to soar above it. ...
$ praise ber ano all ber works.
Sbe bas brougbt me bere anD will also leaD me awap..
5 trust ber. Sbe mag scolo me, but sbe will not bate ber
work. 5t was not 5 wbo spoke of ber. IRo ! trabat is false
anD wbat is true, sbe bas spoken it all. Gbe fault, tbe merit,
is all bers. . . .
Bverp. one sees ber in bis own fasbion. Sbe bioes unoer
a tbousano names anD pbrases, anD ts always tbe same.
5 praise ber anD all ber works. Sbe is silent anD wise. 5
trust ber.
649
INDEX
Abundance of individuals, 7 ;
of life, 104
Abyssal fauna, 81
Acacias, experiments with, 160
Acorn-shells, 448
Acquired characters, transmissi-
bility of, 595
Adaptations, 509 ; Darwinian
theory of, 515 ; Lamarckian
theory of, 515 ; in deep sea, 90 ;
of freshwater animals, 107 ;
functional, 530 ; illustrations
of, 518 ; limitations of, 128 ;
nature of, 514 ; origin of, 515 ;
spoiling, 279-280 ; of terrestrial
animals, 120
Aerial fauna, 123
Agar, Dr. W. E., 149, 596-601
Agassiz, Alexander, 82
Alcock, Prof., 158, 289
Alpine swifts, 142
Ambrosia, 282
Amphibians, importance of, 118
Anableps, 528
Anaphylaxis, 502
Anderson, Capt. A. R. S., 20
Andrews, Dr., 156
Animal behaviour, 187, 628
Animal society, criteria of, 345
Animate, the, 624
Antarctic nematodes, 96 ; shore
fauna, 142
Ant-hill, 326
Ants and Aphides, 1 7 ; and plants,
285-287 ; and seeds, 272 ; har-
vesting, 349
Aquatic insects, 451
Arboreal animals, 125
Archer or spitting fish, 14
Arctic tern, 165
Argyroneta, 115
' Aristotle's Lantern,' 524
Arthus, M., 503
Association, 242
Audacity of Life, 148
Avebury, Lord, 255, 276
Bacteria, 87, 109, 111 ; soil, 271 ;
luminescence of, 490
Baitsell, G. T., 446
Balance of Nature, 264
Baldner, 469
Baldwin, Prof. J. Mark, 517
Ballowitz, Prof., 30
Barbour, Thomas, 270
Barnacles, 448
Bataillon, 385
Batesian mimicry, 32
Bateson, 516, 582
Bats and birds, struggle between,
20
Becquerel, 483
Beddard, F. E., 532
Beebe, 620
Bee-hive, 339
Bee -hunter, 425
Bees and flowers, 274
Beetles in ants' nests, 52
Behaviour, capacity for, 476 ;
intelligent, 241
Berg, L. S., 113
Bergson, 5, 208, 241, 477, 507,
634, 641, 646
Bernard, Claude, 279
Bert, Paul, 85
Bethe, 238
' Big Trees,' 153
Birds, adaptations of, 124 ; and
bats, 20 ; distributing animals,
114
Bird-bergs of Lapland, 8, 9
Birgus, 119
651
652
INDEX
Bishop, W. L., 230
Bitterling, 273
Blind cuttlefish, 92
Blood, individuality of, 509
Bluffing, 231
Bohn, 193, 208, 243
Bombus, nest of, 343
Bonnier, Gaston, 234, 276
Boobies and frigate birds, 20
Bordage, E., 563, 602
Bordas, L., 151
Boring, Dr., 147
Boring gastropod, 64
Bottomley, Prof., 298
Bourgeois, J., 33
Bouvier, 234, 245
Bread-winning, variety of, 12
Brehm, 8, 9
Brine shrimps, 108, 136
Brooding, 428
Bryant, H. C., 43-48
Buchanan, J. Y., 73, 84, 91
Biichner, 201
Buckland, J., 366
Bugnion, Prof., 217, 218, 219,
336, 337, 525
Bulman, G. W., 251
Butler, Samuel, 60
Biitschli, 481
Buttel-Reepen, 234, 257
Butterflies, odours of, 25
Caddis larvae, nets of, 137
Cajal, Ramon y, 390
Caiman, Dr. W. T., 289
Carnivorous plants, 283
Casualties, 128
Cave animals, 122
Cavers, Prof. F., 280
Challenger, 82
Cheese-fly larv, 151
Chilton, Prof. Charles, 289
Chromosomes, 380-381
Chun, 92
Cigale, 455
Circulation of matter, 110
Claparede, 499-500
Clarke, W. Eagle, 164, 171
Clark, Dr. A. H., 521
Clark, Dr. H. L., 555
' Clever Hans,' 255
Clifford, Prof. W. K., 477, 633
Climbing fishes, 145
Clods on birds' feet, 114
Cobb, N. A., 96
Cohendy, Michel, 298
Collett, 229
Coloration, protective, 29, 539;
attractive, 550
Colour adaptations,29, 30, 534
Colour-change, in fishes, 29 ; in
horned lizards, 46 ; in prawns,
72 ; in winter, 162
Colour of deep-sea animals, 94 ;
of sea, 73
Commensalism, 292
Continuity of germ-plas .r>, 378
Continuance of life, 372
Controllability of life, 264
Convergent adaptations, 124
Convoluta, 196, 369, 534
Co-operation, 327
Copepods, 104
Coralline zone, 56
Cormorants, 106
Cotte, Jules, 312
Coupin, Henri, 15, 16
Courtship among animals, 410
Cowles, R. P., 35, 36
Crabs, masking of, 236
Credner, 112
Cresson, Prof., 434
Grassland, 39, 40, 64
Ctenophores, 74
Cuckoo, 223; habits of, 315
Cuckoo-spit, 40-42
Cuenot, 120
Cunningham, 528
Dakin, Prof., 79
Dancing mice, 247
Darwin, 114, 130, 202, 203, 275
Darwin, Francis, 252
Dean, Prof. Bashford, 470
Death, 439 ; feigning, 230
Deep-sea animals, 88 ; colour of,
94
Deep-sea, darkness of, 86 ; depth
of, 83 ; fauna of, 81 ; pressure,
83 ; temperature, 85 ; signifi-
cance of, 98
Deep-sea fishes, eyes of, 96;
voracity of, 17
INDEX
653
Deep water of lakes, 104
Delage, 378, 383
Dendy, Prof. A., 589
Dependence, mutual, 271
Desiccation of Entomostraca, 107
Development, 374, 478
Dewitz, Dr. J., 392
Differentia,! sensitiveness, 193
Dixey, Dr. F. A., 25, 26
Dodd, F. P., 426
Dogwhelk, 65
Domestication by ants, 350
Downbreaking and upbuilding,
475
Dragon-flies and mosquitoes, 22
Drama of life, 1-53
Driesch, Dr. Hans, 209, 635, 641
Drzewina, Anna, 245
Dublin, Dr., 356-357
Dudley, Prof. W. R., 154-155
Dwarf Plankton, 109
Earth, the living, 270
Earthworms, 119, 121
Echinoderms, 446
Edible birds' nests, 530
Edinger, 243
Educated animals, 254
Eels, 229, 458 ; migration of, 630
Egg-carrying by male fish, 522
Egg-case of skate, 527
Egg-eating snake, 523
Egg-tooth, 616 ; of chick, 525
Emery, Prof., 49
Entelechy, 634
Environment, organism and, 6, 7 ;
the fitness of, 579
Epizoic associations, 287
Escherich, Prof., 217, 220
Evolution, conservation in, 621 ;
continuity of, 639 ; great steps
in, 575 ; main lines of, 5 ;
method of, 582
Existence, struggle for, 18
Eyelid, the third in man, 614
Eyes, of cave-animals, 123 ; of
deep-sea fishes, 96 ; that shine
at night, 525
Fabre, 212, 228, 233, 418, 419,455
Fair Isle, 164
Family life among animals, 50
Feigning death, 26, 230
Fertilization, 381 ; internal, 121
Fever, 531
Fiddler crabs, 324
Fierasfer, 290
Fig, pollination, 280
Fireflies, 417
Fishes, deep-sea, 95 ; of Lake
Baikal, 113 ; out of water, 118
Flight, power of, 123
Flowers, bees and, 274 ; colour,
278 ; fragrance of, 277
Fly-trap, Venus, 520
Fol, Prof., 236
Food of marine animals, 79
Forbes, Edward, 56, 81
Form, variety of, 11
Fossils, living, 620
Fragrance, 416
Freshwater, colour of, 102 ; con-
ditions, 101 ; illumination of,
101; temperature of, 101
Freshwater animals, 103
Freshwater faunas, 92 ; origin of,
111 ; uniformity of, 112
Freshwater insects, 451 ; medu-
soids, 113 ; sponge, 108
Frogs, 460 ; experiments on eggs
of, 385
Functions, every -day, 187
Gadow, Dr., 11, 48
Gain, M., 155
Gaisch, A., 38
Galls, 311, 399
Gamble, Prof., 239, 545
Giitke, 164, 174
Geddes, Prof. P., 6, 588
Gemmill, Dr. J. F., 524
Generations, alternation of, 444
Germinal selection, 517
Giard, Prof., 306
Gill, Dr. Theodore, 18, 25, 423
Gilpin -Brown, L. G., 328
Gnats, 453
Goeldi, Prof., 141
Goethe, 433
' Golden-eight ' moth, 28
Goodey, T., 271
Gossamer, 126
Greene, Prof. C. W., 460
t>54
INDEX
Green-fly, fertility of, 131
Groos, 415, 517
Grouse, Canadian, Ruffed, 162
Grouse disease, 303
Growing period, 401
Growing, power of, 476
Growth, 393 ; conditions of, 394 ;
in man, 403 ; regulation of, 399
Guests, and hosts, 51-53 ; and
pets among ants, 352
Guide-marks, 548
Guyer, Prof. M. T., 190
Habitats, strange, 139
Habits, change of, 27, 156
Habituation, 595
Haddocks, swarms of, 9
Hamon, J. C., 137
Harris, Prof. Fraser, 496, 530
Harrison, Prof. Ross Granville, 390
Haunts of Life, 54-126
Heather, crowded with life, 7, 8
Heligoland, 164
Henderson, Prof. L. J., 579
Henshaw, H. W., 183-184
Herrick, F. H., 316-321
Herubel, Marcel, 369
Hewitt, Dr. Gordon, 360
Hibernation, 108, 161
Hickson, 91
Hippolyte, 545
His, Prof., 392
Hjort, J., 87, 92
Hoatzin, 125, 620
Holder, Dr. C. H., 423
Hollande, Dr. A. Ch., 542
Holmes, S. J., 231
Homing, 232
Hooker, Davenport, 192
Hormones, 398
Hornbills, family life of, 50
Horned lizards, 42-48
Horse, a two-toed, 611
Horses, thinking, 255
Horsehair worms, 447
House-fly, 360, 456
Howard, Mrs. A. B., 491
Howard, Dr. L. 0., 359
Hoyle, W. E., 491
Hudson, W. H., 250-251. 350
Hull, A. F. Basset, 149
Hunger and Love, 5
Hussakoff, Dr. L., 466
Huxley, 131, 372, 639-640
Huxley, Julian S., 557
Implosion, 91
Impulses, primary, 5
Individuality, chemical, 507
' Infantile mortality ' on the
sea-shore, 64
Inference, conceptual and per-
ceptual, 242
Insects, wings of, 125
Instinct and intelligence, 249
Instinct, animal, 199 ; limitations
of, 227 ; origin of, 205
Instinctive behaviour, instances
of, 208
Insurgence of life, 127, 129
Intelligent behaviour, 241
Inter-relations, intricacies of, 263 ;
among freshwater animals, 106
Isolation, 114
Izuka, Akira, 133
Jacobson, 16
Jameson, H. Lyster, 313
Japhen, Dr. A., 618
Jellyfish, 445
Jenkinson, Dr., 402
Jennings, Prof., 477
Joly, Prof., 472
Jordan, K., 53
Kammerer, 563, 604
Keeble, Prof., 239, 545
Keibel, Prof. F., 526
Kellogg, Prof. V. L., 153
Kelpfish, 423
Kent, Saville, 43
King, Miss H. D., 564
Krall, 256
Lacustrine regions, 102
Lake Baikal, 100, 113
Lakes, fauna of, 103
Laminarian Zone, 56
Land crab, 11 9, 156
Land snail, African, 132
Lang, Prof. Arnold, 161
Langerheim, 135
INDEX
655
Lankester, Sir Ray, 136, 241, 358,
441
Larvae of flies, 136
Latent life, 483
Latter, Oswald H., 410
Leduc, Prof. Stephan, 481
Legendre, 499
Lemmings, 229
Lentz, 225
' Lerot,' 532
Lessona's law, 560
Lichens, 297
Liesegang's rings, 643
Life, continuance of, 372 ; the
cycle of, 371 ; curve of, 371 ;
drama of, 1-53 ; insignia of,
474; insurgence of , 127; powers
of, 487 ; subtlety of, 501 ;
toughness of, 128
Light-limit in sea, 86
Limit of growth, 401
Lindsay, Miss B., 145
Linkages, 267
Littoral zone, 56
Liver-fluke, 307
Lizards, horned, 42-48
Local life, 488
Loeb, J., 191, 194-195, 208, 383
Lohmann, 109
Longevity, 436
Lotze, 3
Love, hunger and, 5
Loves of animals, 48
Luciola, the Italian fire-fly, 49
Lull, R. S., 124
Luminescence, 94, 487
Lumpsucker, 70
MacBride, Prof. E. W., 389
McDougall, Dr., 224
Macfadyen, Dr. A., 472
Mclntosh, Prof. W. C., 39, 67
Malaria, 269
Mantis, 34, 418
Marquet, M., 206
Marshall, G. A. K., 32
Masking, 35, 235; in crabs, 72
Mason bee, 227
Matthew, W. D., 578
Maturation, 380
Maximum productivity, summer
and autumn, 10
Mayer, A. G., 74, 228, 268
Mayflies, 2, 452
Mechanisms, organisms and, 472
Mercier, L., 361
Mermis, 447
Metabolism, 475 ; animal, 187
Metchnikoff, Prof., 437
Meyer, 243
Miall, Prof., 137
Migration, 162-184 ; concrete pro-
blems of, 171 ; deeper pro-
blems of, 174 ; fundamental
facts of, 165
Miller, Newton, 131
Mimicry, 32
Minkiewiez, 236, 237, 238, 239
Mitchell, Dr. P. Chalmers, 405,
409, 432, 547
Mnemic theories, 601
Modifiability, 511
Modifications, individual, 592
Mole, 518
Moles' nests, fauna of, 140
Monaco, Prince of, 84
Mongoose in Jamaica, 270
Montgomery, 211
Moore, Prof. B., 80
Morgan, Prof. Lloyd, 206-208,
224,517
Morgan, Prof. T. H., 567
Mortensen, Th., 133, 171
Mosquitoes, and ants, 16 ; and
dragon -flies, 22
Mouthless carp, 150
Movements, periodic, 175
Muir, Dr. T., 367
Miillerian mimicry, 33
Muller, Fritz, 252
Miiller, Hermann, 251
Multiplication of freshwater
animals, 104
Murray, James, 135, 143
Murray, Sir John, 82, 86, 92
Mussels and minnows, 273
Nannoplankton, 80, 110
Nature, tactics of, 586
Neger, Prof., 282
Nekton, 75
Nematodes, 96
Nerve-development, 390
Newton, Alfred, 166, 170, 266
656
INDEX
' Nidicolous ' Coleoptera, 140
' Niners,' 464
Noctiluca, 130
Nototrema, 121
Nutrition, 394
Nutritive chains, 62, 110
Ogneff, 593
Opisthocomus, 125
Organism and environment, 6, 7
Organisms and mechanisms, 472
Origin of deep-sea fauna, 97
Orton, 425
Osborn, H. F., 517
Oscillatoria, 111
Osmotic growths, 482
Oxner, 243-244
Ox-warbles, 310
Oyster, fertility of, 132
Painted fish,' 293
Palolo-worm, 71 ; swarming of,
133
Parasitism, 300
Parental care, 419
Parental instincts, chain of, 430-
432
Parthenogenesis, artificial, 383
' Partial ' migrants, 167
Past, the living, 606
Paternal care, 69, 422
Pathology, the optimism of, 589
Pavlov, 242
Pearls, 312
Pearse, A. S., 148, 158, 324-325
Peckham, Mr. and Mrs., 234, 235
Pelagic algse, 73 ; fauna, 73 ;
insects, 76 ; larvae, 66
Penelope spider, 141
Peri-embryonic fluid, 528
Periodicities, 401
Periophthalmus, 118
Peters, Dr. Karl, 417
Phosphorescence, 86
Photosynthesis, 394
Physical conditions of shore area,
57
Pieron, 330
Pigeon, passenger, 366
Pigment in animals, 535 ; sig-
nificance of, 536
Pineal body, 609
Pitcher plant, inter-relations of,
283
Plankton, 75
Plants and animals, relations
between, 281
Plasticity of life, 156, 511
Play of animals, 408
Plover, Pacific Golden, 183, 184
Pocock, R. I., 34, 37
Polar body, 381
Poulton, Prof. E. B., 33, 34, 539
Primal impulses, 5
Productivity, 129 ; in the open
sea, 10
Protective coloration of crab, 72
Protozoa, immortality of, 440
Przibram, Prof. H., 569
Putter, Prof., 79
Pycraft, W. P., 412, 463, 549
Python, meals of, 17
Race, the individual and the, 432
Racovitza, 123, 146
Rat, fertility of, 131
Reaction, changes of, 194-195
Read, Prof. Carveth, 249
Red snow, 135
' Reducing division,' 380
Reflex actions, 188
Regeneration, 571
Regeneration and embryonic
development, 569
Regeneration, imperfect, 567
Regeneration of lost parts, in-
stances of, 543, 552
Regenerative capacity, unequal
distribution of, 558
Registering experience, 591
Relict seas, 112
Reproducing, power of, 478
Resemblance to surroundings, 28
Response, effectiveness of, 510
Revivification of water-fleas, 107
Rhinoderma, 121
Rhythmic movements, 196
Richet, 503
Ritter, W. E., 139
Ritzema-Bos, Dr., 519
Robinson, Louis, 226
Rock-borers, 145
Romanes, 241, 253, 255
Ross, Sir John, 81
INDEX
657
Rothney, 214
Rotifers, 104
Rousselet, C. F., 23
Roux, 473-475
Rubbell, A., 314
Russell, Dr ,and Hutchinson, Dr.,
270
Sable Island, 115
Sacculina, 309
Sack, Albert von, 543
Salamander, colour change in,
38 ; in trees, 139
' Sally,' 255
Salmon, 459
Salt, amphibians and, 148
Sanderson, Sir J. B., 510
Scales, amphibian, 616,
Sea-cucumber's defence, 24
Sea-horse, 69, 422
Sea-lamprey, 465
Sea-lions, 415
Sea-otter on kelp beds, 140
Seasonal changes in freshwaters,
104
Seasons, Biology of the, 159
Sea-spider, 69
Sea-urchin eggs, experiments with,
378, 383 ; weapons of, 62
Seeds, ants and, 272
Self-advertisement, 36
Semon, Prof., 160, 603
Senescence, 443
Senility, 443
Sequoia, 153
Shackleton, 96
Shaler, Prof., 579
Shells of Molluscs, 63
Shelter associations, 290
Shipley, Dr. A. E., 7, 8, 303
Shore area, 55 ; physical condi-
tions of, 57 ; struggle in, 61
Shore crab, 451
Shore, evolutionary significance
of, 72 ; fauna, 55
Shrews, dentition of, 613
Signalling among Termites, 336
Signals between sexes, 417
Simulacra vitae, 481
Simulium larva, 136
Skua and herring-gull, 16
Slave-making among ants, 354
Sleep, 494
Slipper animalcule, 133-134
Slipper-limpet, 425
Sloth's hair, alga on, 281
' Snowshoes' of grouse, 521
Social bees, evolution of, 341
Societies, animal, 323
Sollas, 1 12
Soule, Caroline G., 228
Southwell, T., 526
Spalding, 225
Sparrows in United States, 270
Species, number of, 10
Spelajoniscus, 123
Spencer, Herbert, 97, 400
Sphex-wasp, 20y, 213
Spider crabs, masking of, 236
Spiders, ballooning, 126
Spider's web, 210
Sponge, freshwater, 443
Stager, Dr. R., 139
Starfish, fecundity of, 133
Starfish with young, 68
Starling, Prof. E. H., 627
Stickleback's nest, 69
Stockard, Dr. C. R., 613
Stone, fauna of a, 134
Structural coloration, 536
Struggle among ova, 66
Struggle for existence, 18, 66 ;
Darwinian view of, 19-20 ; in
shore area, 61
Subterranean animals, 122
Sumner, F. B., 470
Surinam toad, 121, 424
Surroundings, resemblance to, 28,
31
Swooping animals, 124
Symbiosis, 295
Tactile organs, 92
Tanganyika, 113
Temperature and growth, 396
Temperature, influence of, 95
Tenacity of life, 151
Termites, 333 ; black, 215
Tern, nest of White, 149
Terrestrial animals, adaptations
of, 120 ; origin of, 119 ; under
water, 146
Terrestrial fauna, 117
Thienemann, Dr., 165
u u
658
INDEX
Thompson, Prof. D'Arcy, 416
Thomson, Dr. Stuart, 552
Thomson, Sir Wyville, 81, 91
Thorndike, Prof., 245-246
Thrust and parry, 23
Tidman's sea-salt, 108, 136
Tile fish, 156
Time, trading with, 591
Tissue regeneration, 555
Tornier, G., 152
Transparent animals, 78
Tree-frogs, tadpoles of, 149
Trial and error, 245
Triton, lens of, 570
Tropisms, 191 ; establishment of,
197
Tubularia, 66
Tunicates, 45-47
Turner, 232
Typhobia, 113
Variability, 479
Venus' Flower Basket, 91
Venus girdle, 78
Vest gial structures, 607
Vinson, 15
Viscachas, 350
Vitalism, 622
Vogt, 135
Vries, de, 516, 582
Vultures 13, 14
Wagner, 115
Wallace, A. R., 179, 414, 547-549
Wallich, 81
Walther, J., 97
Warm-bloodedness, 530
Warning coloration, 547
Wasmann, 52
Wasp, nest of, 344
Wasp, solitary, 224
Water -fleas, 107
Water-spider, 115
Watson, William, 99
Waves of Life, successive, 141
Way-finding of birds, 180
Ways of Life, 186
Weapons, 24
Weber, Prof. Max, 493
Web of Life, Man and, 357
Web of Life, 243
Darwinian conception of, 40
Weismann, 205,438,480,517,562,
568
Wery, J., 279
Wesenberg-Lund C., 137
Wetting of water animals, 115
Whales' hair, 617
Whelk, 65
Whitney, Dr. D. D., 612
Willey, Prof., 289
Wilson, Prof. E. B., 378
Wilson, Prof. H. V., 485
Wings, 125
Winter conditions in freshwater,
108
Winter eggs, 108
Wintrebert, 28
Woodruffe, Prof. L. L., 133, 142
Worcester, Dean C., 20
Yellow-fever, 365
Yerkes, 247
Young animals, 405
Youth, the purpose of, 408
Yung, Prof. E., 233
Ziegler, H. E., 262
Zoophytes, 444
Zulueta, A. de, 305
Butler & Tanner Frame and London
A 000029433 o