tt.'-ju-kr.y's'r D 4 5 2 7 •}■•! #1 lZS^'-I ^> R N P R > O R'^ V. THE LIBRARY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LOS ANGELES 4, A DISSERTATION ANTIQUITIES PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN, WORCESTERSHIRE. BY THE REV. H. CARD, D.D. F.A.S. &c. kc. &c. VICAU OF fillEAT MALVERN. And O, yc swelling liills, ami spacious pluins! BcRpront from shore to sliore with steeple towei-s. And Hpircs wiiosc " silent tin^'er points to heaven ;" Nor wanting at wide intervals the bulk Of ancient Min?ter, lifted ahove the cloud Of the dense air which town or city hrecvis To intercept the sun's glad heams, — may ne*er That true succession fail of Knglish hearts. Who with ancestral feeling, can perceive What in those holy structures ye possess Of ornamental interest, and the charm Of pious sentiment diffused afar, Ami human charity, and social love. — Wordsworth. Nor rough, nor hancn, are the winding ways Of hoar antiquity, but strewn with tlowei-s. — Warton. LONDON: PRINTED roll J. <;. \ F. lUVlXGTON, ST. Paul's ciiikiii vaud, and Waterloo place, i'vi.i. mai.l; S: SOI, It nv uincK, woucrsTF.it. ISM. LONDON : GILBERT AND RIVINGTON, PRINTERS, ST. JOHN'S-SQI'ARE. (S90 DEDICATION. TO HER ROYAL HIGHNESS THE DUCHESS OF KENT. Madam, My pleasing labour is now finished; for pleasing I can truly call it, since it was undertaken at the desire of your Royal Highness, graciously communicated to me on a recent occasion. I am far from thinking my performance ])erfect, but do not imagine any thing I can add of sufficient value to require longer delay in placing it before your Royal Highness, with every sentiment of profovuid respect. I have the honor to remain, Madam, Your Royal Highness' most obliged, and most dutiful Servant, HENRY CARD. THE VICARAGE, September 8, 1834. (i3;a2i^i'i PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN, WORCESTERSHIRE. If antiquity impart additional dignity to the temple as well as to the palace — and what acute observer of the human mind will dispute this fact ? — then must those Christian edifices reared by the pious muni- ficence of our forefathers excite our deepest reverence, and call forth our most fervent aspirations for their preservation. Unquestionably ]ni who has perused the frightful accounts unfolded at the Visitations of the Abbeys — the detestable crimes practised in those cloisters of iniquity and impurity', — cannot but acknowledge that Henry VIH., ' " 1 know not by what right," observes Mr. Ilallam, " we should disbelieve the reports of the visitation under Henry VIII. entering, as they do, into a multitude of specific charges, both probable in their nature, and consonant to the unanimous opinion of the world." Middle Ages, vol. iii. p. 352, 353. For additional coniinuation of these assertions, see Fosbrooke's British Monachism, vol. i. p. 127, where that writer has thoroughly exposed the delinqiicncies of the Monks. But nothing can be more indis- putable than the fact, that the monasteries were the chief or sole preservers of the historical Memorials of their times, however just may be the remark of Gibbon, " that of such manuscripts, the casualty of fire, or the slow progress of damp and worms, would often endanger their limited and precarious existence." See his Miscellnneous Works, vol. ii. p. 709. We learn from Spelman, that some sympathy for the fate of the B 2 PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. in their suppression, rendered an essential service to the cause of true religion. Glorious as the era of the Reformation was, still it will l)e ever matter of regret to the real lovers of the fine arts, whether Roman Catholic or Protestant, tliat so many stately Abbeys, monu- ments of tlie skill as well as the piety of our ancestors, should have been demolished or dilapidated. Among, however, those national ornaments which escaped the hand of destruction, the conventual church of Great Malvern still retains most of its original perfection. Occupying a spot as lovely as the eye ever rested upon, and built after the customary form of a cross, this venerable structure, in its magnitude, proportions, and decorations, with its dark grey tower so full of impression and effect, — with its pierced battlements and graceful pinnacles, — presents a most beautiful specimen of that florid style of English architecture which prevailed in the reign of Henry VII. The whole length of this majestic and picturesque fabric, as given by Mr. Chambers in his History of Great Malvern ', is an hundred and seventy-one feet, its breadth sixty-three feet. The height of the nave is sixty-three feet ; and that of the tower a hundred and twenty-four feet. Congreve must have had a building Monks and Nuns was felt on the part of the Commons, as Henry was obliged to send for them, and to declare, in his usual bluff manner, that if the Bill were not passed, which put him and his heirs in possession of all monastic establishments, with the property belonging to them, both real and personal, he would cause some of their heads to be struck off. History of Sacrilege, p. 183. ' P. 53. Before the demolition of the South Transept Aisle, and of the Lady Chapel, at the east end of the church, which Cole the antiquary states to have been about fifty feet in length, (see MSS. Brit. Mus. vol. x. folio 119), the building must have been quite cathedral-like in appearance. Well, indeed, may Cole style it, " a most noble structure." The old parish church was dedicated to St. Thomas the Apostle, and stood near the present church, at the north-west corner of the church-yard. Its length was ninety feet, its breadth tliirty-six, and it had one small chapel to the south. See Thomas. Antiq. Priorat. Majoris Malveme, p. xci. PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. 3 of this sort in his mind, wlien, iu that noble passage of his Tragedy, he exclaims, — " How reverend is the face of this tall pile, Whose ancient pillars rear their marble heads To bear aloft its arched and ponderous roof, By its own weight made stedfast and immoveable, Looking tranquillity '." In the middle ages^ art commenced with sacred subjects. Indeed, ecclesiastical architecture was the chief boast of those dark times. Churches, therefore, independently of early religious associations, must always be objects of great interest, as they illustrate our history, and the state of the arts at the time in which they were erected. It is painful then to remark, that, after such a lavish prodigality of ex- penditure, we have so few beautiful new Churches to compensate for the loss and decay of the proud fanes of olden times. AA'hile these fill the beholder with awe, admiration, and delight, there is nothing in those to raise the mind to a loftier state of thought and feeling ; the latter — sublime structures, and therefore awakening sublime emo- tions, — are as distinguished for their vastness, grandeur and science, as the former are devoid of such qualities or attributes. Unfortunately, our present system of education pays little or no attention to art ; or that great desideratum in our Universities, a Professorship of Ecclesiastical Architecture from the era of the Norman Conquest to that of the Reformation, — a period in which is exhibited such boundless variety in all the diflercnt gradations of style, — would long ago have contributed not only to form the national taste upon ' Mourning Bride, Act ii. Scene 1. * According to the authority of Mr. Ilallnm, and no higher can be produced on the subject, tlie Middle Ages comprise about one tlious.-ind years, from the invasion of France by Clovis, to that of Naples by Charles VIIL Vol. iii. p. .^OS. U 2 4 I'RIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. purer principles, but might have drawn the notice of the Government to the better preservation of those highly interesting edifices which have not sunk under the ruthless fury of the fanatic, or the more silent operations of Time. Formerly, upon this subject, there was an intensity of religious feeling, instead of that obtusity which has been for so many years past but too apparent on the part of those who have directed the movements of the State. No stronger proof of this assertion can be afforded, than that Sir Reginald Bray, the restorer of the Priory, a brief history of which we are about to give, was, to use the parlia- mentary phrase of this day, the Premier of Henry VII. His memory is immortalized by the unrivalled skill and taste displayed by him in the construction of Henry's Chapel at Westminster, " that glorious work of fine intelligence V' and in the completion of that of St. George's in Windsor Castle. The other points in his character entitle him to an honourable renown. It was the complaint of a great states- man and historian^, " that we are often declaiming about the wisdom of our ancestors, without knowing what they mean, or hardly ever citing any particulars of their conduct or of their dicta." That we may not commit the error here censured, we will show in what a brilliant light Sir Reginald's character is set by an ancient writer. ' The pretensions of Alcock, Bishop of Ely, have been advanced as a participator with Sir Reginald, on this memorable occasion. But this is pure assumption with many. We believe, that the evidence of Sir Reginald being the architect of this wonder of the norld, as it has been styled, will stand the strictest examination. There is just cause for regret, that we are still without any certain or accurate knowledge upon the subject of the other edifices constructed by him. " It is surprising," observes Jfr. Britton, " that more particulars of this truly eminent man, and of the public buildings he is said to have designed, have not been satisfactorily developed." Architectural Antiquities, vol. iii. p. 34, .35. ' See Correspondence of the late Gilbert Wakefield, B.A. with the late Right Honour- able Charles Fox, p. 86. PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. 5 " After the death of this noble Princess Elizabeth, departed Sir Reginalde Brayc, Knight of the Garter, a very ffuther of his country, a sage and grave person, and a fervent lover of justice. Insomuch that if any things had been done against good law or equitie, he would, after an humble fashyon, reprehende the Kinge, and gyve him good advertysement how to reform that offence, and to be more cir- cumspect in another like case. Of the same vertue and honest plainness was John Moreton, Archbyshop of Canterbury, which died two years before. So these two persons were over restrayned of the Kinge's wilful scope and unbridled liberties : whereas the rude and ignoraunt people say and affirm that theyr counsaile infected and cor- rupted the Kinges clean and immaculate conscience contrary to his princely disposition and naturall inclination. Such is ever the errour of the common people : but surely as longe as the Kinge would heare and obeye such as warned him of his office royall and kingly duetie, he could in no wise erre or swarve aside '." In thus recoi'ding the courageous wisdom and public virtue of this pillar of the state — for Sir Reginald shone as a soldier as well as a counsellor — we shall so far testify our respect for the observation just quoted, as to give a few more particulars respecting this most liberal benefactor, or to speak more correctlj', second founder of the Priory. The place of his nativity was St. John's Bcdwardine', in Worcester- shire, and he entered into public life wiiji manj' of the external advantages of birth and fortune. His ancestors came to Enjiland with William the Concpu-ror. Sir Richard, the father of Sir Reginald, ' Sec MS. LansJowiic, JIus. Brit. No. 'J7S; IJishop Kennel's Collections, fol. L'(>2. l5o;j. ' Some writers represent him to have been a native of Great Malvern ; but others, who are better informed on the subject, aj^rec with Nash, that he was born in the parish above mentioned, in 1st Richard 111, 1 183. 6 PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERX. and, according to some, physician to Henry VI. was of Eaton Bray, in the county of Bedford, and endeared himself so much to the King, as to be sworn of the Privy Council. Sir Reginald early gained the good opinion of Margaret, Countess of Richmond and Derb}', and ultimately became a chief instrument in assisting her son, Henry, to mount the English throne. Great undertakings require great quali- fications and abilities. And when that master-stroke of policy — the union of the two Houses of York and Lancaster, by the marriage of Henry with Elizabeth, daughter of Edward IV. was projected by the Duke of Buckingham, and Moreton, Bishop of Ely, they fixed on Sir Reginald as the person to carry it into execution. In these words did Moreton specify his merits to the Duke. " He is sober, secret, and well-witted, and his prudent policy is known to encompass things of great importance." The firmness, temper, and address of Sir Reginald, in an enterprise where so many discordant feelings and embroiled interests were concerned, led finally to complete success: for he drew over to the cause of his mistress. Sir Giles D'Aubeny, Sir John Cheyney, and other persons of great weight in the kingdom. As a reward for having acted so prominent a part in this transac- tion, Henry, at his accession, loaded him with estates and offices of large profit. In 1494, he was elected High Steward of Oxford; and he did not disappoint the hopes of that learned body in maintaining their rights and privileges. Henry, in his letters-patent to his said Steward, knight of his body, recognising, no doubt at Sir Reginald's urgent solicitation, the franchises of the University, as including, besides other matters, the right of hearing the criminal causes of scholars and other privileged persons, accepted the nomination, and allowed him and his other assessors (named in the patent) or any two of them, to proceed in the common form against offenders. On the PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. 7 marriage of Prince Arthur, the dowry of the Princess was guaranteed to her by the Duke of York, the two Archbishops, the Bishops of Winchester and Lincoln, and Sir Reginald Bray. The eminent ser- vices which he had rendered to Henry procured him also the dignities of Knight of the Garter, and Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster. Bred a soldier as well as a politician, his skill and gallantry were con- spicuously displayed in the decisive battle of Bosworth Field, and in that of Blackheath, where the Cornish insurgents were completely routed. In short, placed in employments which he executed with equal ability and integrit}', it was his rare good fortune to enjoy uninterruptedly the favour of one of the most sagacious and sternest Monarchs that ever held the British sceptre. Sir Reginald died on the 5th of August, 1502-3, and was buried in the middle of a Chapel at Windsor, which was founded by him, and still bears his name : and Churton, summing up his character, says, " that he received from the Crown innumerable patents, marks of favour, grants of emolument, which, as they did not corrupt, served only to display the integrity of the senator and the statesman : while his counsel carried so great a sway witli the court, that, liail he not died before Henry, the acts of rapacity and opjjrcssion with which that Monarch's later annals are disgraced, would no doubt have been less numerous and less flagrant, if not entirely prevented '." According to Bishop Tanner and Dr. Nash, the Priory of Great Malvern first rises into notice from a very remote period. The former says, " here in the great wild forest was an hermitage, or some kind of religious house for seculars, before the Conquest, with some en- ' The most authentic information of Sir Roginatd Uray will be found in Dugdalc's Baronage; Kippis's Edit, of the Biog. Brit. art. Bray; Churton's Lives of the Founders of Brazen-nose College ; and Manning's Suney. 8 PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. dowment by the gift of King Edward the Confessor;" and the latter, speaking of Malvern in his Collections for the History of Worcester- shire, observes, "Before the Conquest it was a wilderness thick set with trees, in the midst of which some monks, who aspired to greater perfection, retired from the Priory of Worcester, and became hermits. The enthusiasm spread so fast that the number soon increased to three hundred, when, forming themselves into a society, they agreed to live according to the order of St. Benedict, and elected Aldwin, one of their number, to be superior. Thus was the monastery founded about the year 1083, with the consent and approbation of St. Wolstan, Bishop of Worcester." It was dedicated to the Virgin Mary and also to St. Michael, as we learn from an original charter pre- served in the British Museum '. In the Annales Wigornienses, we are expressly told that Aldwin was the founder of the Malvern Monaster)', a.d. 1085. William of Malmesbury has furnished us with a somewhat detailed account of the circumstances which induced him to commence the undertaking. What person at the present day does not feel a peculiar pleasure, especially if he have an archaic' tone of mind, M'hen satiated with our profitless philosophizing, he turns to the simple but graphic tales ' See Dugdale's Monast. Angl. N.E. Part xxii. p. 440. ' Whether an}' of our readers be possessed with the feelings and sentiments we are now about to speak of, would puzzle us as much to determine as a dubious case of law : but we have known those who entirely participate in them ; to whom the study of the dusty record and the mildewed charter has the same inexpressible charms as the sweet chirpings of birds in woods and fields, the soft rippling of streams, and the rude whistling of the winds, have for others. " I have heard one of the greatest geniuses this age has produced, who had been trained up in all the polite studies of antiquity, assure me, upon his being obliged to search into several rolls and records, that, notwithstanding such an employment was at first very dry and irksome to him, he at last took an incredible pleasure in it, and preferred it even to the reading of Virgil or Cicero." Spectator, No. 447. PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. 9 of the good old gossiping chroniclers. For, in that pictorial age, of which we are discoursing, when the manners and opinions of con- temporaries were so naturally represented, there was no wide gulf fixed between fancy's regions and those of sober reality ; between the dim and tremulous twilight of uncertainty, and the steady effulgence of convictidM, but annalists and their readers — rari nantes in gurgite vasto', — were alike content to wander on in " the palpable obscure" of the time, yielding unhesitating confidence to its delusions and its dreams. Whenever the writer is firmly assured of what he relates, his narrations generally bear an impress of truth to others. Indeed he demands, and expects their faith in all that he propounds, as if what he had ascertained to his own conviction was equally clear to them. Such a national Chronicler was William, the Monk of Malmes- bury ; for in his day the literary man was only to be found in the monastery. None then handled the pen to any useful or edifying purpose, but the member of a chapter or of a convent ^ The following ' " The gross mass of tlie laity, from the baron to the mechanic, were then more addicted to the exercises of the body than to tliose of the mind. Few among them could read, still fewer could write : none were acquainted with the Latin tongue ; and if they sometimes listened to a tale of past times, their puerile love of the marvellous would prefer the romance of Sir Launcclot, or Sir Tristram, to the authentic narratives most honourable to theu- country and their ancestors." See Gibbon's Address upon the Study of the History and Antiquities of Great Britain; Memoirs, vol. ii. p. 709. But even at the end of the sixteenth century, the ignorance and barbarism of the times were such, that Marlow, " he of mighty line," makes one of the clowns, in his tragedy of Faustus, say to another, " Snail, what hast thou got there, a book ? why thou can'st not tell ne'er a word on't." ' And not many there either. Parchment was an article of great expense, from its scarcity, in those days, which was another obstacle to the spread of knowledge, and an excuse to so many of the Monks for being content to sit lazily and proudly in (heir ignorance, Mr. Ilallam quotes Warton for the fact, that no parchment could be procured about 1120, for preparing an illuminated copy of the Bible. Middle Ages, vol. iii. p. .'J.'JS. We shall offer no apology to the curious reader for presenting to him our researches upon C 10 , PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. legend, connected with the history of the Priory, may aptly serve as an illustration of the foregoing remarks. Our translation, it will be seen by the learned reader, is almost a literal one. There was one Aldwin, a monk, wlio, witli a single companion named Guido, lived as a recluse in that very densely wooded chase, which is called Malvern. After long struggles of conscience, Guido considered it absolutely necessary, as the shortest path to glory, to visit Jerusalem, and see the Lord's sepulchre, or meet a blessed death by the hand of the Saracens. Aldwin was disposed to follow his example, but first consulted his spiritual adviser Wolstan. The prelate dissuaded him, and cooled his ardour by saying, " Do not, I beseech thee, Aldwin, go any where, but remain in your place : believe me, you would wonder if you knew what I know ; how much God is about to perform through you in that place." The monk having heard this departed, and now remained firm in purpose, and soothed every sorrow by the hope of the prophecy. Nor was it long after that the prophecy hastened to its fulfilment. One after the other successively came, to the number of thirty. Abundant were the stores of provision which flowed in upon them from the neighbouring inhabitants, who judged themselves happy in being permitted to minister aught to God's ser- tbis subject. Many entries occur in the Wardrobe Accounts of various kings' reigns, and in the Pipe Rolls, duplicates of which are now in the British Museum, of the sums paid for parchment. One of these entries, in the printed Wardrobe Account of the 28th Edward I. p. 51, is Juliane atte Flode, de Wyntonia, pro pcrgamens empt' de eadem per Johem de Langeford pro expens' garde robe Regis, videlt pro 40 duodenis pergamen' precio duodene 12d. — 21. Os. Od. — et pro 15 duodenis precio duodene 18d. — 1/. 2^. Gd. per manus predicte. I. ibidem 15 die Marcii Siimnia. 3/. 2s. 6d." From this entry it would appear, that 40 dozen skins, at 12f/. per dozen, cost 21. ; and 15 dozen of, perhaps, a superior quality, or larger size,' cosf 1/. 2s. 6d. ; so that parchment must have been sold, in Edward's reign, after the rate of Id. and lid. per skin. In another part of the same Wardrobe Account, (28 Edward I.) GO dozen skins of parchment, with carriage of same from Lincoln to Westminster, including cordage for packing them, cost 71. 12s. PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. H vants ; or if there chanced to be need of any thing, they supplied the want by faitli, deeming it a little matter to be without carnal food, seeing that they grew fat upon spiritual joys '. It would appear, by the following story, that the same Bishop (Wolstau) did not want just vision to discern that the spirits of men must become pure from their errors and vices by first suffering for them, and that without continual training and tutoring, spiritual growth would not proceed in that way so as to be conducive to any permanently good purpose. One Swclf, a merchant, had been accustomed to visit him once a year to receive his advice in the healing of his spiritual ailments. Once on a time, after giving the absolution, he observed, " You often repeat the sins which you have confessed; because, as the proverb goes, opportunity makes the thief. Wherefore I advise you to become a monk, which, if you do, you will not long have the opportunity for those sins." Upon this, the other rejoined, that he could not possibly become a monk, because he found it so difficult to bring: his mind to it. " Go your ways," said the Bishop, in somewhat of a passion ; " a monk you will become, whether you choose it or not, but only when the appliances and means of vice have wa.\en old in you." Which fact we afterwards witnessed, because, when now broken down by old age, and warned by disease, he betook himself to our monastery : but though he had many times repented, yet, nevertheless, as often as any one reminded him of the Bishop's saying, he still laboured to check his temper, and to soften his disposition '. In another respect, also, the prediction of this eminent saint ^ of the ' Sec Note A, Appciulix. ' See Note B, Appendix. * " WilsU'inus in sanctitate nostro sxculo nomatissimus." Vide (Jul. Malm. De Vilis Pontificum, fol. 159. After this quotation we must suppose the mitred priest's pretensions to canonization indisputable : but popular fame is not always to be taken as the best criterion for the honours of saintship. Had some of tliosc worthies, who have been so c2 12 PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. monastic calendar (Wolstan) was verified. After Aldwin had procured letters-patent from Pope Gregory VII. and William the Conqueror, Urso d'Abitot, or D'Abtot, a Norman baron, whose property was con- siderable in this county, as well as other magnates, became a great benefactor to the Priory. It was honoured also in a particular man- ner by acts of liberality on the part of Henry I., who, besides confirming all former grants, by his Charter, dated 1271, annexed various lands to it. In No. IX. of the Charters and Instruments, in the new edition of Dugdale's Monasticon Anglicanum, are enumerated the possessions, temporal and spiritual, of the Priory, at the period of its taxation by Pope Nicholas IV. 1291. It was fortunate for the prosperity of this establishment, that Walkerius, or Walcher, its second prior, trod in the steps of the first, in all benevolence to man, and in all humility to God. The zeal of the faithful may well be supposed to have been eager to heap bounty on him, who was so much an object of reverence, that to disbelieve the words of Walcher, was, according to William of Malmesbury, doing an injury to religion'. An epitaph is but au imperfect test of merit, but, as an opinion on the worth of individual character, it dignified, lived in the present day, we should naturally conclude that the police officer, or the cachipoUis, as he is styled in Wiclif's New Testament, {Dcdis of ApostoUs, c. xvi.) would have failed in his duty, if he had not provided his thief-catching apparatus as a means for preventing them from further tainting the community by the badness of their characters. In exemplification of this remark, take the following story of what occurred to St. Martin, as given on the authority of Bellarmine, by Bishop Philpotts. " He had long entertained some pretty strong doubts of the propriety of the devotions offered by the people in his neighbourhood to a supposed saint ; because, in truth, there was nothing very certain or satisfactory in the traditions concerning him. One day, when St. Martin was at his prayers, the ghost of this personage appeared to him, and frankly confessed that he was a damned spirit; that when alive, he had been a robber, and that he suffered death for his crimes by the hand of the public executioner." Letters to Butler, p. 35. ' " cujus verbis qui non credit injuriam religioni facit." De Regibus, &c. &-c. PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. 13 is at least deserving of equal regard with an eulogy on the living. He then must be an epitaph-hater, who would deny that some grains of truth may not lie witliiu the monkish lines inscribed on a stone of coffin-like form in memory of Prior Walcher, which was dug up in May, 1711, in a garden adjoining the church-wall, on the south side of the nave, on which the Priory cloisters were supposed to have stood ; a circumstance, be it observed, which gives a sort of warrant to the conjecture that he was buried in them. Philosophvs dignvs bonvs Astrologvs, Lotheringvs, Vir pivs ac hvmilis, monachvs, Prior hvivs ovilis, Hie jacet in cista, Geometricvs ac Abacista, Doctor Walchervs ; flet pltbs, dolet vndiqve clervs ; Hvic Ivx prima mori dcdit Octobris seniori ; Vivat vt in coelis exoret qvis qve fidelis. mcxxxv '. ' " Here lies entombed Walcherus of Lorraine, Prior of this Convent, noted for his piety and humilitj', a distinguished Philosopher, a good Astronomer, Geometrician, and Arithmetician; universally lamented by Laity and Clergy. He died on the first day of October, advanced in years. Let every true Christian fervently pray, that he may live in Heaven." — It is a debateable point among the critics, at what period these Latin rhymes made their appearance in the world : and that verses of this kind should be designated Leonine, has puzzled the learned Canulcn himself. " Riming verses, which are called Versus Leoni, / know not wherefore (for a lyons taile doth not answer to the middle parts as these verses do), began in the time of Carolus Magnus, and wore onlv in request then and in many ages following, which dclighteth in nothing more than in this minstrelsie of meeters." Remains, 1G14, p. 337. Might not this name have been given to them after Leo the Great. The whole ancient Roman Liturgy was generally known by the name of tlie Leonine Sacramentarj', though it is believed to have been equally put together by Gclasius I. and by St. Gregory. Tiie monks, in honour of Leo, may likewise have distinguislied these verses by liis name. Heame, in the Preface to his History of Glastonbury, p. xivi. asserts, that a brass plate was found on the inscription of Walchcr's tomb in Great Malvern Church : but, as tlie lively Walpole says, iu his letter to Cole on this subject, " Tom Hearne must have here mistaken brass for stone." Cole's MSS. vol. XXV. fol. 194. We presume that no objection, which will be deemed valid, can he made to the assertion of Cole, " that the use of brass plates lor monumental inscriptions was not introduced so early as the lime of Henry I." 14 PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. " My soul deligliteth," exclaims the author of Vatliek, " in a legendary tale of the monastic sort;" and old Grose, no inconsiderable name among those who are skilled in legendary lore, was used to say to his boon companions, " that he loved a good ghost story, as much as the clown did wrestling and single-stick." Perhaps some of our readers may have the same bent of mind for the marvellous, " for those bodyless creations that ecstacy is very cunning in," and there- fore it would be uncourteous in us not to indulge their taste in this respect ; especially, as it is incumbent upon us, in our capacity of his- toriographer to the Priory, not to abbreviate or slur over any circum- stance or event, which may revive the long-forgotten reputation of its Superiors. The following story, related to William of Malmesbury by him wliose epitaph we have just transcribed, must show in what high estimation he stood with his contemporaries, when this chronicler can invest fancy's air-drawn pictures with all the characters of a real transaction ; can consider them as having sufficient warrant to be entitled to a respectful belief, merely because they emanated from the brain of Prior Walcher. " Read not to believe and take for granted," was a piece of advice from Lord Bacon, that would have been thus answered with contumelious scorn in the words of Spenser, by the lovers of the preternatural and visionary. " Why then should witless man so much miswecn That nothing is but that which he hath seen." " Not more than fifteen years have elapsed," said Walcher, "since a contagious disease attacked the Prior of that place, and afterwards destroyed many of the monks. The survivors at first began each to fear for himself, and to pray and to give alms more abundantly than usual : in process of time, however, for such is the nature of man, PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. 15 their fear gradually subsiding, they began to omit them. The cellarer more especially, who publicly and laughingly exclaimed, that the stock of j)rovisions was not adequate to such a consumption as was going on ; that he had lately hoped for some reduction of expense, considering there had been so many funerals, but that his hopes were at an end, if the dead consumed what the living could not. It hap- pened on a certain night, when from some urgent business he had deferred going to rest for a long time, that having at length got rid of the difficulties which delayed him, he went towards his dormitory. Singular is the circumstance now to be related. He saw in the Chapter-house the Prior and all who had died that year sitting in the order they had dt'parttd, whereat he was affrighted and endeavoured to escape ; but was detained by force. Being reproved and corrected after the monastic manner with the scourge, he heard the Prior speak precisely to the following effect : — That it was foolish to be ravenously seeking profit by another's death, seeing that all men were subject to one common fate. That it was impious for a monk who had passed his whole life in the service of the church to be grudged his pittance of pay for a single year alter his death : that he himself should die very shortly ; but that whatever others might do inr liiui, should rcdountl only to the advantage of those whom he had defrauded : that he mitilit now <'o, and endeavour to correct bv his example those whom he had corrupted l)v Ids language. lie departed, and demonstrated that he had seen nothing imaginary, as well by the recent marks of the scourging, as by his death, which shortly followed '." Before parting with Malmesbury, we cannot forbear adst riing to his, apparently earnest desire to taki' the monastery of Malvern under his especial protection. lie is anxious to hold it up to universal ' Sec Note C, Appendix. 16 PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. respect; thou<>h he shows himself not to be the blind and indiscrimi- nate eulogist of it, whon he closes his general remarks by saying, in the way of brotherly counsel, that " he hands down this place to immortal hope, while the penury of mortal things distracts and stimu- lates the monks'." The mitred Abbots of Westminster, ever since the period when Gislibertus Crispinus, one of their number, bestowed several manors and estates upon the Priory, had claimed pre-eminence of power over it. In the reign of Henry II. a violent dispute arose between Richard Ware, Abbot of Westminster, and Godfrey Giffard, Bishop of Wor- cester, respecting the subordination of Great Malvern. Being both men of inflexible spirit, and of equal energy, the litigation was long protracted ; at last Edward I. in the plenary exercise of his royal authority, brought this great cause of contention to an amicable settlement : the Priory being made a grateful offering to the ambition of the Abbot, and the Manor of Knightwick, in this county, given to the Bishop and his successors ^ But although placed in this instance under the jurisdiction of Westminster, the Prior and Convent appear to have always acted as an independent corporation ^ with respect to the mass of property they had accumulated in the counties of Worcester, Hereford, Gloucester, and Warwick : for the Priors, like 1 " Ad iramortalem spem commemoro, dum mortalium rerum pemiria monachos trahit et animat." De Monasteriis, fol. 1C2. ' For evidence upon these points, vide Rcgist. chart, et privileg. Abbatiae Westmonast. MS. Cotton. Mus. Brit. Faustina. A. 111. Malvern, fol. 276. Carta Godefridi Wygnrn epT qd in cella maiori Malvemie nullam habeat jurisdictione. C. Ixxxv. fol. '276^ Composico int. Westm. & Malverne capit Ixxxvj. fol. 277"^. Rex Edwardu5 confirmat forraam pacis factam in V. Driiii. G. AVygom. Epm. & Westm. sup. cell. Malvern, cap. Ixxxvij. fol. 279. Assensus Prioris & Convent Malvern sup ordinaciSn Dm Edwardi Reg. cap. Ixxxix. ' See Tanner's Notitia Monastica. PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. 17 many otliers of tlicir order, were desirous of procuring real property by purchase, as well as by charters of donation, tliough sometimes they alienated their lands in favor of their relations and friends'. In 1151, 5 Henry II. William Burdet assigned to Roger, then Prior of Malvern, Avercote or Aucote Monastery, in Warwickshire, as a cell to that Prior)'. There was also another cell at Brockbury, in the parish of Colwall, Herefordshire. Yet over these, the Abbots of Westminster exercised no sort of control in the disposal of their reve- nues or appointments. The occasion which led to the foundation of the little monastery of Avecote is quite dramatic as to incident, but, as an atonement for bloodshed, not uncommon in those ferocious times. We shall give this tale to the reader in the direct and simple narrative of Dugdale. " William Burdet being both ii valiant and devout man, made a journey to the Holy Land for subduing of the infidels in those parts, and his steward, whilst he was thus absent, solicited the chastity of his lady, who resisted those his uncivil attempts with much scorn ; whereupon he grew so full of envy towards her, that so soon as he had advertisement of his master's arrival in England, he wont to meet him ; and to shadow his own foul crime, complained to him of her looseness with others : which false accusation so enraged her husband, that wlien lie came home, and siu- approaelud to receive him with joyful embraces, he forthwith mortally stabbed her; and to e.xpiate the same unhappy act, after he understood the truth, he built this monastery '." ' llanc terrain tenuit Sirof de Episcopo, tempore Rcf;is Eilwardi, quo mortuo dcdit Kpiscopus filiam ejus euru liac terra, cuidam suo milili, qui et matrein pascerct, et Episcopo inde servirct. See Proofs and Illustrations, Part II. p. ccclxvi. in Sir Francis Palgravc's Rise and Progress of tlie English Coinmonwcalth. ' Monas. Aiigl. p. •l.'iS. 18 PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. At the time of the dissolutiou of religious houses, the Priory was valued, according to Dugdale, at £308. Is. 5^d., and according to Speed, at £375. Os. 6^d., Tanner's M. T. Valor and Stevens's Supple- ment give £307. Is. 4|(/. as the summa clara. i. e. the net amount. Among its possessions are the manors of Wortefield, Newland, and Powyke, in the county of Worcester, Northwode, in Shropshire, the town of Hatfield, and lauds in Baldenhale Malvern, Branncsford and Lye, tithes at Archcsfonte, in the diocese of Salisbury, of the yearly value of 40s. Tlie Priory of Malvern had likewise the appropriate churches of Longeney Powyke and Malvern, the patronage of the churches of Hanleye, in the deanry of Powyke, of Upton Snodbury, in the deanry of Pershore, and of Eastleach, in the deanry of Fayrford, in the county of Gloucester'. - " From the age of Charles Martel," emphatically asks a writer as eloquent as he is profoundly learned, " down to tlie reigns of Henry, or Joseph, or Napoleon, when could the Pontiff or the Priest retain any possessions which the King and the soldier were determined to acquire^?" We are not, therefore, to be surprised, that the domains of this Priory should have shared the fate which befell ecclesiastical possessions more or less in every country in Europe. The level of the ocean changes. Field after field, as wave follows wave, has the Priory been stripped of, by that great innovator Time, to use the often-quoted words of Lord Bacon ; so that if one of its monks, who lived in the twelfth or fourteenth century, could now revisit Malvern, he would find all its fair acres alienated or sold'; and if he awoke from his ' Nash, vol. ii. p. 122, 123. ^ See the Rise and Progress of the English Commonwealth, by Sir Francis Palgrave, Part I. p. 169. ' We learn, upon distinct authority, that Philip and Mary confirmed a purchase made by Henry Fayrefeld, of the manor of Woodfelde, in the county of Worcester, of part of PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. 19 long slumber with his recollective faculties strong about him, after gazing intently upon tliat church and well known cross ', he would, the lands of the dissolved monastery of Malvern. See Dugdale, Jlonast. Angl. N. E. p. 441, but into whose hands the other portions of the domain fell, we cannot discover with any certainty. ' Crosses, we are told by a writer to whom every student of ecclesiastical architecture is highly indebted, were erected at the entrance of churches, to throw the mind into an attitude of solemn thought and reverence. See Britton on Stone Crosses. May I avail myself of this opportunity (for want of a better) of saying a few words upon some animadversions which have been passed upon me for not removing a cross in the interior of this church. To tlie prattle of the ignorant, and the sneers of the superficial, 1 will not throw out a sentence in my defence : but I would endeavour to propitiate those of sounder and more impartial understandings, by addressing them in these lines and note of our great philosophic Poet : " Yet will we not conceal the precious cross. Like men asliamed. " The Lutherans have retained the cross within their churches : it is to be regretted that we have not done the same." Wordsworth's Ecclesiastical Sketches, p. 123. Similar sentiments were once expressed to me by the late Mr. Davison^^7io;HCH meniorahile — a name never to be pronounced by low as well as high Churchmen, without a pause of admiration. If moral and intellectual excellences — if orthodoxy without any species of bigotry — if an ardent desire to advance the great cause of Christianity in every quarter of the globe — if a firm attachment to our ecclesiastical establishments, without any hunting after professional honours — if singleness of purpose — if inflexible integrity and extensive charity, without ostentation — be among the best recommendations for a bishopric — as sure they arc, or ought to be — then should not this man have died without a mitre on his head. Alas! how many eminent pastors, patterns to believers, " in faith, in purity, and in conversation," have been removed in the midst of their days and usefulness ; " perhaps to tell us," says one, distinguished alike for his piety and talents, " that the Lord's cause does not depend on any instruments, however necessary as well as desirable they seem to us — but upon Himself, who has the residue of the Spirit." — In the last number of the Uritish Critic, p. 242, the epithet illiislrioits is aflixcd to the name of Davison. Now those, who were not thoroughly acquainted with his great intellectual superiority — with his vast reach and comprehension of view — especially those who know his work on Prophecy only by hearsay, in every chapter of which there are marks of deep thouglit and a most powerful mind, may not perh.ips consider tlie foregoing terra as truly applicable to the subject of these hasty observations. The number, however, of his important christian virtues — and the variety of his attainments, which mark the highest order of intellect, fully sanction an epithet appropriated only to those who are d2 20 PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. turning his ej'es towards the monastic refectory", have as much diffi- culty in recognizing it, as tlie way-faring man in discovering a safe tread between shifting sands and mirages; so different an aspect has it assumed under the lapse of ages. That hall, where he held high festivals with his Prior and brethren, is now converted into a barn ; and the oaken board on which he partook of his meals, changed into mangers for horses and oxen. In the Gate-house, however, of the Priory, disfigured and deterior- ated as it is, he would still discern some of the features remaining as he left them. This genuine and interesting piece of antiquity is of the perpendicular style of architecture, being erected about the same period as the greater part of the church. The front is composed of two divisions ; the arch has a square head, and the spandrils are filled with quatrefoils enclosed in circular ribs ; on each side arc five pannels witli cinquefoil heads, and pannels charged with shields : over all is a boldly projecting cornice, which runs along the front of the structure, and forms the base of the upper division. Springing from the apex of the arch, on a moulded corbel, is a highly enriched oriel window, having its angular mullions relieved with delicately carved pinnacles. On each side are eight transom-headed pannels, two of which are perforated as windows. At each angle of tlie front of the building is a buttress of two stages, the face of the lower one being gifted wath the rarest mental endowments. Indeed the appointment of such a character even to a i'rebendal Stall, will throw a moral splendour over the administration of Lord Livei-pool, whenever the disposal of his church patronage shall be discussed. But, ere long, I hope to have a fitter opportunity of paying my unbiassed tribute of respect to this most distinguished Minister of the Gospel, than is presented in the corner of a note. ' Refectories, or Fratries, were large wainscoted halls, with a crucifixion above the boards, a dresser, almories or cupboards, windows opening unto the kitchen, through which the meat was served, and desk with a bible for reading during the dinner. See Fosbrooke's Encyclopaedia of Antiquities, Vol. I. p. 108. PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN'. 21 pannelled : while at the west side we find a number of painted tiles fixed on the wall near the roof, similarly ornamented to some of those in the church. There are good reasons for believing that this Gate- house is now not more than half of its original size, for the roof is without its corresponding parts, and the back is cased with nothing but common brick. Here, perhaps, was a chronicle composed, and the original deposited among other muniments kept under the triple keys of the Superior of the House ; while some of the rooms were aj)propriated for the distribution of eleemosynary gifts ; for it will be reckoned among the chief merits of the monastic establishments, next to their successful promotion of agriculture', and the estimation which is due to them as conservatories of mental treasures, that a great portion of their wealth was employed in the daily' exercise of acts of charity and benevolence. ' If their inmates did not deeply cultivate the study of divinity, we may conclude that they did well in the useful philosophy of the spade; for we are told hy Mr. Turner, " that Domesday Survey gives us some indication that the cidtivation of the church lands was much superior to that of anj' other order of society : they had much less wood upon them, and less common of pasture: and wliat they had appears often in small irregular pieces : while their meadow was more ahundant, and in more numerous distri- butions." See his valuable History of the Anglo-Saxons, Vol. II. p. 1C7. ' According to that close observer of human nature, Piers Ploughman, or Robert Langland, or John Malvernc, for so the author of the Vision of William has been variously styled, the dole was not dealt out so liberally to the beadsman at the gate of the abbey and priory as some of those who would wish to get rid of the system of tythes assume it to have been. " Little had lordes to do to give lands from tiieir heirs To religious that have no ruthe though it rain on their aultrcs. In many places there the parsons be themselves at ease. Of the poor they have no pitie, and that is their poor charilie." But whoever was the writer of these Visions, tiiere is uncommon tact evinced in his 22 PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. One more observation respecting the Gate-house, before we take leave of this part of our subject. It lias been remarked by Dr. Johnson, in his life of Milton, that " every house in which this great man resided is historically mentioned, as if it were an injury to neglect naming any place that he honoured by his presence." In like manner may we say that this Gate-house ' is honoured, as there is a tradition, description of manners and character, while he has delivered what has been boldly called " prophecies of the history of the Reformation." The vehicle of allegory serves to shelter the satirist; but satirist as he was, he has imparted to many of his lines that rural and touchingly simple air which must ever continue to please. Even to the unpoetical reader, the musings on Malvern Hills, with which he opens the poem, will not be dis- tasteful ; there are many passages also full of the facetious humour of his great contem- porary, Chaucer. " The Vision," remarks the great Selden, " is WTitten in a kind of English metre which for the discovery of the infecting corruptions of those times, I prefer before many of the more seemingly serious invectives, as well for invention as for judgment." Note in Polyolbion, fol. p. 109. Hollinshed, Stow, and Wood, thus allude to this writer, who has studied so thoroughly the characters and manners of his fellow countrymen and contemporaries. " Among the learned men of that age, (Edward 111.) was Robert Langland, a secular priest, born in Salopshire, in Mortimer's Clebury." llolinshed, ed. I. Vol. II. p. 1003. — " This year, John Malverne, fellow of Oriel college, in Oxford, made and finished his book entitled the Visions of Piers Plowman." Stow"s Ann. p. 238.—" Robertus Langland Johannes Malverne nonnullis appellatur : fertur autem inter sui steculi poetas maxime facetos exeelluise." Wood, Hist, and Antiq. Univ. Oxon. 1. ii. p. 10. 7. — And Spenser assigns to him a high poetical rank, when he says, " Go but a lowly gate among the meaner sort. Dare not to match thy pipe with Tityms his style. Nor with the Pilgrim that the Plowman plaid awhile." Epilogue to ShejihercCs Calendar. ' The following is a description of part of the Gate-house of the Priory of Bridlington, in Yorkshire, as surveyed by one of Henry the Eighth's general surveyors, and the remains of the Malvern Gate-house would encourage the opinion, that it had not been without similar accommodations ; so that the King, during his temporary sejour there, would not have been without what may be called the salu7i and boudoir of those days. " At the cummyng yn of the said Priory is a Gate-house foure square of Towre facyon, buylded Ffrestone, and well covered with leade. And one the South Syde of the same Gate-house ys a Porter's lodge w' a Chymnej', a rounde Stayre leding up to a hye Chamber wherein the thre Weks Courte ys always kepte in w' a Chymney in the same, and betweene the Stayre PRIORY OF GREAT MALVERN. 23 which, according- to Cole, represents with much probability, that Henry VII. took up his abode there — the sovereign upon whom Bacon has pronounced this noble eulogy. "His laws (whoso marks them well) were deep and not vulgar; not made on the spur of a particular occasion for the present, but out of providence for the future ; to make the estate of his people still more and more happy, after the manner of the legislators in ancient and heroic times '." The readers of our popular histories are imbued with the notion that the patrician class were the chief instigators with Henry to com- mence his work of spoliation on the ancient Church. True it is, that they shared in the division of the bounty, and many of them most larg(!ly, but those, whose knowledge is not merely superficial, are well aware that the sole suggestor and prime agent and director of this doubtful and dangerous experiment was the Secretary Cromwell. "^e," says the accurate Strype, "had the great stroke in all this. All these counsels and methods were struck out of his head; for which, as he received the curse, and brought upon himself the hatred of many, 80 many more, well affected to a reformation of superstitions in the Church, extolled him highly*;"' although we question much whether these very persons would have been so desirous of pushing matters to extremity, could they have anticipated that the secularization of the monastic estates, however defensible enough in itself N THE I'KlNCIl'Al, WHITINGS OF BI.SHuP BURNETT. .\ Quarto Volume, in preparation. UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LIBRARY Los Angeles This book is DUE on the last date stamped below. 1:he Library ♦DA Card - 690 A dissertation oe iiZCZ the antiquities of the priory of Great Malvern. *DA 690 U3C2 D 000 452 753 idm