LIBRARY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA. Cla&s THEATRE FIRES AND PANICS: THEIR CAUSES AND PREVENTION. BY WILLIAM PAUL GERHARD, C.E., Consulting Engineer $1? Sanitary Works, FIRST EDITION. FIRST THOUSAND. NEW YORK : JOHN WILEY & SONS. LONDON: CHAPMAN & HALL, LIMITED. 1896, Copyright, 1896, BY WM. PAUL GERHARD. ROBERT DRUMMOND, ELECTROTYPER AND PRINTER, NEW YORK. PREFACE. THIS little book is not intended to be a general treatise on " Theatre Planning and Construction." It is simply, as its title implies, a discussion of the causes and the prevention of fires and panics in theatres. A few years ago the writer prepared several essays on the subject, which are herewith reproduced substantially as originally given. The writer has added at the end of the book a list of the literature (works, pamphlets, and articles in technical journals) bearing upon the sub- ject, which he has found of value in studying the whole question, and which he hopes will be helpful to others. May the book prove of practical utility and of in- terest generally to architects, engineers, theatre man- agers, and fire underwriters, and fulfil its mission of securing greater safety in theatres ! THE AUTHOR, NEW YORK CITY, 36 UNION SQUARE, July, 1896. iii 127676 CONTENTS. I. THEATRE-FIRE CATASTROPHES AND THEIR PREVEN- TION. PAGE Introduction I Theatre-fire Statistics 3 List of Twelve Prominent Theatre-fire Calamities of this Cen- tury 12 Causes of Theatre Fires 20 Causes of Panics 25 Dangers to Human Life 27 The Prevention of Theatre-fire Catastrophes. 29 (a) Measures to prevent outbreak of fire 29 (b) Measures to localize fires , 29 (c) Measures to insure the safety of the spectators and of the stage people 30 (d) Measures to put out fires 30 Theatre Inspections 40 Theatre Management 44 Conclusion 45 II. THE ESSENTIAL CONDITIONS OF SAFETY IN THEATRES. Introduction 47 Causes of Theatre Fires 49 Statistics of Theatre Fires 51 General Considerations , 52 Location and Site 57 Plan of Building 59 Construction of Building 65 Staircases, Entrances and Exits, and Fire-escapes 69 v vi CONTENTS. PAGE Aisles and Chairs 73 Fire-proof Curtain 75 Stage Ventilator 77 Fire-proof Treatment of Stage Scenery 79 Stage Construction and Stage Machinery 80 Heating 83 Lighting 85 Lightning-rods -89 Ventilation and Sanitation 90 Fire-service and Fire-extinguishing Appliances 92 Life-saving Appliances 97 Fire-alarms 98 Questions of Management 99 Periodical Inspection .... 103 III. THE WATER-SERVICE AND FIRE PROTECTION OF THEATRES. Introduction 105 GENERAL REQUIREMENTS OF SAFETY IN THEATRES. 1. As regards the Location 105 2. As regards the Plan 106 3. As regards the Construction 106 4. As regards the Interior Arrangement and Equipment 107 5. As regards the Management 109 6. As regards Inspection in FIRE-EXTINGUISHING APPLIANCES. 1. Water supply and Water-mains 114 2. Water-meter and By-pass 116 3. Shut offs and Gate-valves 117 4. Fire-pumps 118 Details of Underwriter Fire-pump 121 Fire-pump for Theatres 124 5. Suction -reservoir 127 6. Fire Stand-pipes 128 7. Fire-valves 130 8. Fire-hose.. 132 9 Fire Nozzles and Couplings 135 CONTENTS. Vll PAGE 10. Monitor Nozzles 136 11. Hose-racks 137 12. Hose-spanners 138 13. Automatic-sprinkler System 139 14. Perforated- pipe System , 153 15. Fire- pails 155 16. Casks 159 1 7. Portable Fire-extinguishing Apparatus 159 18. Steam- jets 161 19. Sand 161 20. Fire-axes and Fire-hooks 161 21. Minor Fire-extinguishing Devices 162 22. Life-saving Appliances 162 23. Fire-alarm and Watchman's Clock 163 24. Water-supply for House Service 163 IV. LITERATURE ON THEATRES. 1. Books English 165 " German , 165 " French 168 " Italian , 168 2. Pamphlets 168 3. Articles in Journals and Magazines 171 4. Rules and Regulations 175 5. Official Reports 175 THEATRE FIRES AND PANICS: THEIR CAUSES AND PREVENTION. I. THEATRE-FIRE CATASTROPHES AND THEIR PREVENTION.* THE prevention of fire and incidental panic in halls of audience requires that in the planning, construction, interior arrangement and equipment of such buildings certain rules should be followed, and certain pre- cautions observed by the architects and engineers of such structures. Of the greatest importance in respect * This paper was prepared by the author for the annual meeting of the International Association of Fire Engineers, held in Montreal, Canada, in August, 1894. It was introduced with the following words: " Gentlemen of the International Association of Fire Engineers : Yours is an organization which has for its chief object ' the intelligent pro- tection of human life and the saving of property.' Your annual meet ings are held largely with the view of learning of improved methods of fire-fighting. Your principal business is to fight and put out fires, yet I believe I do not err in stating thatyfov prevention is a subject in which you are likewise interested. Indeed, the law in my own city, to quote an example, declares that ' the fire department shall be charged with the duty of preventing and of extinguishing fire and of protecting property.' You will observe that preventing fire comes first in the 2 THEATRE FIRES AND PANICS: to the enactment of strict building laws are all build- ings where a multitude of people are congregated, by day or at night, for worship, education, or amusement, such as churches and synagogues, schools and colleges, concert- and lecture-halls, circuses and theatres. I shall restrict my remarks to theatres, although much of what I will say applies equally to the other classes of buildings named. The prevention of theatre-fire calamities is a subject in which not only firemen but the general public are, or ought to be, interested. In the planning and construction of theatre build- ings, even more than in other buildings, the combined skill, knowledge, and talent of both the architect and the engineer are necessary to create a model and safe structure. While the architect works out the best plan on the available site, determines the general arrange- ment of the divisions of the building, decides the mode of construction, designs the elevation, and selects the decorative treatment of the interior, he is assisted by the engineer or by specialists in the vari- ous engineering branches in the solution of intricate enumeration of the duties of firemen. As in medicine there are two views, the one being the cure of disease, and the other one, which I consider the higher aim, the prevention of disease; just so, I hold, are fire departments and firemen concerned not only with the extinguish- ment of fires and with the saving of life and property, but likewise, and to even a higher degree, with the prevention of fires. " About fire-fighting it would be presumptuous on my part to speak to you, for that is not in my line, and I would not be qualified to speak on the subject to you, many of whom have spent the best part of an active life in the battle with fire and smoke. The subject which I have chosen for my paper concerns the prevention of fire and calami- ties incidental thereto in a class of public buildings where large crowds gather nightly for amusement's sake." THEIR CAUSES AND PREVENTION. 3 problems requiring special expert knowledge, such as the construction of difficult foundations, the calculation and the working out of details of all iron construc- tions, the design of the mechanical or power plant, comprising steam-boilers, engines, dynamos, hoist- ing and general stage machinery, the heating and ventilation of the building, the gas-lighting and the electric-lighting system, the plumbing, drainage, and water-supply, the arrangement of the toilet-rooms, the general sanitation, and finally the fire protection of the theatre. It is because I have had the good fortune of being associated in my own branch of engineering with architects of the highest standing in the construction and equipment of * some recent theatre buildings, and also because, by inclination, I have, for years, made the question of the safety of theatres a special study, that I venture to publish the following remarks about theatre-fire catastrophes and their prevention, in the hope that they will be helpful in preventing the re- currence of disasters similar to those related herein. Theatre-Fire Statistics. It may be well to begin by giving briefly a few statistics regarding theatre fires and their causes. Here we at once encounter much difficulty in gathering and presenting accurate and reliable figures and facts. There are numerous cases in which a fire breaking out in a theatre, on the stage, in the auditorium, or elsewhere, is at once extinguished by the stage hands, or by the firemen on duty in the building. Many 4 THEATRE FIRES AND PANICS: cases of this kind never become known to the public or to the press, and no accurate record is kept of them. In other instances, again, blind fire-alarms are followed by a panic and often by loss of life. When a fire in a theatre breaks out during the night and destroys the building the cause of the same often forever afterwards remains a mystery. Distinction must be made between occasional outbreaks of fire which are subdued before it can spread, and such fires which completely destroy the building. The data given below refer only to theatres which are entirely burnt down. Those fires which break out during a performance, when the building is crowded with people, are nat- urally the ones of greatest interest to us. If accom- panied, as they unfortunately often are, with loss of life, the number of persons killed and wounded is diffi- cult to ascertain with absolute accuracy, as many perish in the building who are not missed by friends or relatives. The tendency in these cases is usually for the press to exaggerate the number of victims, whereas on the other hand the theatre officials or the municipality often try to keep the figures below the actual number. The curious mistake is sometimes made of counting both the dead and the wounded in the same figure of victims, obtaining thereby largely increased and incorrect figures. We are principally indebted for theatre-fire statis- tics to the works of Herr August Foelsch, a German civil engineer, recently deceased; of Herr Franz Gilar- done, a retired German fireman; of Capt. Shaw, of the London Fire Brigade; to Dr. Choquet, physi- THEIR CAUSES AND PREVENTION. 5 cian to a French life-insurance company, and to the labors and reports of John C. Hexamer, Esq., a civil engineer and insurance surveyor, of Philadelphia. Their figures and statistics do not by any means agree, and it is difficult to account for the discrepancies. Taking the work of Herr Foelsch as, on the whole, the most complete and reliable guide, although it is not brought quite up to date, being published in 1878, with a supplement issued in 1882, shortly after the Vienna Ring Theatre fire, we find a list of 516 theatres enumerated, which up to and including the year 1877 were completely destroyed by fire.* Out of these, 460 theatres were burnt in 100 years. The list contains of theatres in the principal cities the following: London 31 Boston II Venice 6 Paris 29 Glasgow n Baltimore 6 New Yorkf 26 Cincinnati.. ... 9 Cologne 5 San Francisco.. .. 21 New Orleans. .. 8 Edinburgh 4 Philadelphia.... 17 Bordeaux 7 Among the 5 16 theatres we find 37 theatres which were burnt twice. 8 " " " " three times. 4 " " " " four times. i theatre (the Bowery Theatre in New York) which was burnt fi^r times; also one theatre in Spain, which burnt down seven times. * This figure in the supplemental edition to the work of 1882 was corrected to 523. f Since 1821 up to the present time 29 theatres have burnt down in New York City. 6 THEATRE FIRES AND PANICS: Regarding the average life of theatres, the records are confined to 252 theatres, and show that 5 theatres burnt down before the opening; 70 " " in the first 5 years after opening; 38 " " " between 6-10 " " " 45 " " " 11-20 " 27 " " " " 21-30 " 12 " " " " 31-40 " 20 " " " " 41-50 " " " 17 " " " 51-60 " 7 " " " " 61-80 " 8 " " " " 81-100 " 3 " " " after over ico years' existence. Total 252 Out of a total of 252 theatres, 70, or more than one fourth of them, are destroyed before they reach an age of 5 years. Theatres, therefore, as a rule, do not attain an old age, and Herr Foelsch figures the average ageof these252 theatres as 22f years. For the United States the average life of a theatre is said to be only from II to 13 years, but it should be remarked that these figures were reached some years ago, before the stricter theatre laws of some of our large cities (New York and Boston, and quite recently Brooklyn and Philadelphia) were enacted. Recent analytical studies of the question have elicited the fact that there are two periods in the life of a theatre building, when it is most endangered or subject to destruction by fire, namely, one from the time of its construction up to .and including the first five years, and the second period, after the theatre has been opened from 40 to 50 years. This- may be ex- plained, first, by the fact that in a new theatre the safety appliances, the arrangements for lighting, the THEIR CAUSES AND PREVENTION. ? scene-hoisting devices, the fire-protection appliances, are rarely in perfect working order, and the theatre employes have not as yet become accustomed to hand- ling them, and are likewise unfamiliar with the rules of management. The second period of renewed danger is explained by the fact that after the number of years quoted above much of the apparatus in a theatre has become worn out or useless, and is not always kept in repair or replaced by new apparatus, and it may also be attributed to the fact that after the lapse of many years the theatre management and inspection are apt to be less strict, and that often interior alterations are made which unfavorably affect the safety of the build- ing. From the middle of the last century to our present day nineteen theatres on the average have been de- stroyed annually by fire. For those who are interested in more detailed figures, I quote the statistics gathered by Herr Foelsch and Dr. Choquet, the latter's figures being placed in brackets. In the years 1751-1760 there were 4 theatre fires in all countries. 1761-1770 8 i77 I ~ I 78o 9 (ii) 1781-1790 " ii (13) 1791-1800 13 (15) 1801-1810 17 1811-1820 16 (18) 1821-1830 30 (32) 1831-1840 25 (30) 1841-1850 43 (54) 1851-1860 " 69 (76) 1861-1870 99 (!03) 1871-1880 " 181 (169) 1881-1885 (174) 8 THEATRE FIRES AND PANICS: Taking each year from 1871 we have the following numbers : In 1871 there were 20 theatres destroyed. " 1874 " 15 " 1875 " 14 " 1876 " 19 " 1877 " 17 " " " 1878 " 20 " " " 1879 " 25 " 1880 " 23 " 1881 " 28 " 1882 " 25 (37) " " " 1883 " 22 " " " 1884 " 9 (40) " 1885 " 9 " 1886 " 7 (8) " 1887 " 12 (18) " 1888 " 15 " "(up to Nov.) The fire loss represented by these figures reaches many millions of dollars' worth of property. The hour of the day in which the above theatre fires started is of considerable interest. Out of 289 fires^ 56 theatres burnt during the day between 7 a.m. and the afternoon, or ....... 19.4 per cent. 15 " " one hour before beginning of performance, or ........... 5.2 " " 36 " " during performance, or ....... 12.4 " " 66 " " within two hours after close of performance, or ............ 23.9 " " 113 " " during the night and before 7 a.m. next morning, or ...... 39.1 " " Later on, when the records of 373 theatre fires were available, Herr Foelsch found this percentage to THEIR CAUSES AND PREVENTION. $ remain nearly the same, viz.: 19.9, 5.6, n.6, 22.6, and 40.3 per cent, respectively. It will be seen from these figures that the greatest danger from fire to a theatre is during the two hours following a perform- ance, and not during the performance, as would naturally be supposed. The reason for this is partly, that during the performance greater watchfulness exists as regards open lights, the sources of heat, and the other usual causes of fire, and partly because many fires while actually started during a performance, for instance, by carelessness in the use of fireworks, or by the use of firearms, do not break out at once, but smoulder for a while in the inflammable scenery and woodwork of the stage, and break out during the hours following the performance. The risk from fire immediately before the performance and while the audience is admitted is found to be three times as great as during other hours of the day, which is ex- plained by the fact that at this time the gas flames are lit which illuminate the scenery. Theatres are, therefore, safest in the day-time; the danger is increased threefold during preparations before the performance, because of lighting up, etc. ; it is reduced during the performance on account of the careful inspection and greater watchfulness on the stage, but is still two times as large as during the day ; the danger reaches a maximum (7 times the day risk) during the two hours after the close of the perform- ance, and it remains during the night nearly 3^ times as great as during the day (sparks from fireworks or pistol wads may remain glowing for hours after the performance). 10 THEATRE FIRES AND PANICS: The theatre fires which break out during the per- formance are often accompanied with loss of life of both spectators and actors, and are therefore of par- ticular though sad interest to us. The life of firemen is often greatly endangered at theatre fires at all hours, and the list of instances where firemen have been killed while engaged in their duty in trying to save burning theatres is quite large. Herr Foelsch describes in detail 36 theatre fires between 1770 and 1877 which began during the per- formance, and out of this number not less than six were accompanied by appalling loss of life. From 1877 to 1889 six other deplorable theatre calamities have taken place. In the twelve years from 1876 to 1888 not less than 1600 people were killed in the six well-known theatre disasters of Brooklyn, Nice, Vienna, Paris, Exeter, and Oporto, nearly all of the victims being dead within ten minutes from the time when the flames and the smoke from the stage reached the auditorium and the galleries. Dr. Choquet, in his statistics, enumerates a total of 732 theatres destroyed by fire from 1751 to 1885, with a total number of victims, i.e., both killed and wounded, of 6573. This list includes fires where fire- men lost their lives in the performance of their duty. Since the beginning of this century 536 theatre fires occurred, and from 4500 to 5000 persons were killed or wounded. Here are in detail, in periods of ten years, some of the figures of victims of theatre-fire calamities given by Dr. Choquet: THEIR CAUSES AND PREVENTION. II In the years 1751-1760, 10 victims. " " 1761-1770, 4 " " 1771-1780, 154 " 1781-1790, 21 " tt " 1791-1800, IOIO " " " 1801-1810, 37 " " 1811-1820, 85 " ' " 1821-1830, 105 " " " 1831-1840, 813 " " 1841-1850, 2114 " M " 1851-1860, 241 " " 1861-1870, 104 " M " 1871-1880, 1217 " 1881-1885, 628 In the year 1887, " " 1888, " 1887, " 1892, (Amsterdam, 1772, 25 d.; Saragossa, 1778, 77 d., 52 w.) (Capo d'Istria, 1794, 1000 v.) (Richmond, Va., 1811, 72 v.) (Philadelphia, 1829, 97 v.) (St. Petersburg, 1836, 800 v.) (Canton, 1845, 1670 v.; Carlsruhe, 1847, 63 d., 203 w. ; Quebec, 1846, 200 v.) (Livorno, 1857, 43 d., 134 w.) (Ahmednuggur, 1878, 40 v. ; Brooklyn, 1876, 283 v. ; Shanghai, 1871, I2OV.; Sacramento, 1876, no v.) (Nice, 1881, 70 v.; Richmond, (State?) 1885, ioov.; Vienna, 1881, 450 v.) Paris, 150 " Oporto, 140 " Exeter, 200 " Philadelphia, Central wounded. Theatre, several dead and Before proceeding to study the causes of theatre fires, I will give a brief list of twelve prominent theatre- fire calamities of this century, the horrors of many of which are probably fresh in the minds of some of my readers. 12 THEATRE FIRES AND PANICS: List of Twelve Prominent Theatre Fire Calamities of this Century. I. Theatre in Richmond, Va. Date: December 26, 1811. Time of fire: During the last act of the evening performance. Number of people in audience: About 600. Cause of fire : Careless hoisting of a stage chandelier with lighted candles, whereby a border became ignited. Panic, jam at exits. Number of victims: Seventy persons killed, many injured. No data available as to location, plan, construction, and equipment. 2. Lehmann Theatre and Circus at St. Petersburg, Russia. Date: February 14, 1836. Time of fire: During the afternoon performance, at 4 o'clock. Number of people in audience unknown. Cause of fire: Stage-lamp, hung too high, ignited the stage roof. Panic, jam at exits. Number of victims: About 800 persons killed. Location : In an open square. Construction : Temporary wooden structure. Exits obstructed by the panic-stricken crowd. j. Royal Theatre at Quebec, Canada. Date: June 12, 1846. Time of fire not stated. THEIR CAUSES AND PREVENTION. 13 Number of people in audience unknown. Cause of fire : The upsetting of a lamp on the stage ignited a wing. Number of persons killed: About 100. Construction: Of combustible material. Chief defects: Insufficient exits, narrow stairs; one wooden staircase broke from over-weight of the crowd, and thereby obstructed one of the exit doors. 4.. Grand Ducal Theatre, at Carlsruhe, Baden, Ger- many. Date: February 28, 1847. Time of fire: Just before beginning of evening per- formance. Number of people in audience: About 2000. Cause of fire: The careless lighting up of the gas lights in the Grand Ducal box ignited the draperies. Number of victims: 63 persons dead and 200 in- jured. Location : Entirely free on an open square. Construction: Wooden interior; the four exits or- dinarily effected the emptying of the house in six minutes. Chief defects: The main entrance to the theatre was bricked up (!). Of the four exits mentioned only ONE was open; the other three were locked and barricaded. The gas was turned off in the street after the fire broke out, but the oil-lamps in corridors were kept burning. The occupants of the parquet and of the balconies escaped. Most of the victims were gallery spectators, who became suffocated by smoke. Many were saved by breaking in the locked exit doors. 14 THEATRE FIRES AND PANICS: 5. Teatro degli Aquidotti, Leghorn, Italy. Date: June 7, 1857. Time of fire: About 8 o'clock in the evening. Number of people in the audience: About 3000. Cause of fire: A rocket, part of fireworks on the stage, ignited the scenic decorations. Number of victims: From 43 to 100 killed, and 134 to 200 injured. No details. 6. Conway ' s Theatre, Brooklyn, N. Y. Date: Decembers, 1876. Time of fire: During the last act of the performance of " The Two Orphans." Number of people in audience: About 1000, viz., 250 in parquet, 350 in balcony, 405 in the gallery. Cause of fire : A border caught fire from the border- lights, perhaps owing to a sudden draft, caused by opening a window. The fire was increased by the opening of a large door at the back of the stage. Number of persons killed: 283, all from the upper gallery. Location : Building stood detached on three sides. Construction: Ordinary, but with well-arranged exits, permitting the emptying of the theatre in from 5 to 6 minutes. Plan of theatre: Considered comparatively good at the time. Chief defects: No fire-proof curtain, no water avail- able for fire purposes. No fire-hose at the fire-hy- drants, nor any other fire-extinguishing appliances available. Auxiliary exit doors for the gallery kept closed. Only one staircase for the gallery. Stage THEIR CAUSES AND PREVENTION. I