Original inutea of the Gov- 
 ernor 'Generql *nd Council of Port 
 in Bengal
 
 
 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA 
 AT LOS ANGELES

 
 ORIGINAL 
 
 MINUTES 
 
 OF THE 
 
 ^GOVERNOR GENERAL AND COUNCIL 
 
 O F 
 
 FORT WILLIAM 
 
 1 K 
 
 [BENGAL, 
 
 ON THE APPOINTMENT, RECOMMENDED AND CARRIED 
 BY. MR. HASTINGS, IN OCTOBER, 1780, 
 
 OF SIR ELIJAH I M P E Y; 
 
 to BE JUDGE OF THE SUDDER DUAUNY ADAWLET, 
 
 With a Salary of Five Thoufand Six Hundred Sicca 
 Rupees a Month, or, Seven Thoufand Seven Hundied 
 and Ninety-five Pounds Four Shillings per Annum. 
 
 LONDON: 
 
 Printed for J. DI BRETT (Succeflbr to Mr. Altnon) oppofite Burlington 
 Houfe, Pkcadilly. 1781.
 
 \
 
 v I 
 
 MEMORANDUM. 
 
 AS it does not appear, that the com- 
 mittee of the honourable houfe of 
 commons, when they clofed their laft re- 
 port on the adminiftration of juftice in 
 Bengal, had feen the lateft and moft mate- 
 - rial part of the proceedings of the governor 
 c - general and council on that fubject, their 
 report of courfe is fo far defective. To fup- 
 ply that defect, and to compleat the infor- 
 mation already given to the public, the fol- 
 t lowing minutes are now publimed, and for 
 no other purpofe. The Eaft India com- 
 pany and the nation mould alfo be ap- 
 prized of the following facts. 
 
 i ft. 
 
 354735
 
 ift. Tbit Sir Eyre Coote did not deliver 
 his opinion jirft on Mr. Haftings's propofition, 
 as is uiual with the youngeft member of the 
 council, but after he had careful >y perilled 
 and confidered the minutes of the other 
 gentlemen. 
 
 That on the 24th, of October, 
 1780, Sir Elijah Impey, tormally accepted 
 of the office ot judge of the Sudder Duauny 
 Adavvlet, by a letter addreffed to the board. 
 
 3dly. That, on the fame day, Mr. Haft- 
 ings recommended an allowance of five 
 thoufand fix hundred Sicca rupees a month, 
 for Sir Elijah Impey, which, reckoning the 
 current rupee at two millings, as it is 
 ufually rated in Bengal, is equal to leven 
 thoufand, feven hundred, ninety five pounds, 
 four {hillings a year. But, as that queftion 
 could not be carried againft Mr. Wheler, 
 and Mr. Francis, without the affiftance of 
 Sir Eyre Coote, who had left Calcutta,' the 
 decifion of it, at the governor general's defire, 
 was poftponed, 
 
 The
 
 The following extracts from the ad of 
 parliament, and his majefty's charter of 
 juftice, are inferted in this place, as a proper 
 and neceflary introduction of the fubject. 
 
 Claufe in the regulation bill of the 13th, 
 of his prefent majefty's reign. 
 
 " And that all fuch Claries to fuch go- 
 
 " vernor general and council, and of fuch 
 
 " chief juftice and judges (hall be in lieu 
 
 <c of all fees of office, perquifites, emolu- 
 
 <c ments and advantages, whatfoever: and 
 
 <* that no fees of office, perquifites, emo- 
 
 " luments, or advantages whatfoever {hall 
 
 " be accepted, received, or taken, by fuch 
 
 <e governor general and council, or by fuch 
 
 " chief juftice and judges, as aforefaid, 
 
 or any of them in any manner, or 
 
 <c on any account or pretence whatfoever, 
 
 other than fuch falaries and allowances, 
 
 as are in and by this aft, directed to be 
 
 * c paid to them refpeclively. 
 
 Extraft
 
 tf from the Charter of Juflice, grant- 
 ed by His Majejly, the 26*6, Day of 
 1774. 
 
 " TT^HE court of directors of the faid 
 JL united company (hall, and they are 
 *' hereby required to direct, and caufe to be 
 11 paid, certain and eftablifhed falaries, to 
 <c the faid chief juftice, and each of the 
 " judges of fuch fupreme court of judicature, 
 " at Fort William in Bengal, as mall be by 
 Cc the faid new charter eftablifhed, that is to 
 <c fay, to the chief juftice, eight thoufand 
 " pounds by the year, and to each of the 
 "judges of the faid fupreme court of judica- 
 " ture, at Fort William in Bengal, fix thou- 
 <c fand pounds by the year, and that fuch 
 " falaries fhall be paid, and payable to each 
 " and every of them refpedively, for the 
 " time being, out of the faid territorial acqui- 
 * c fitions, in the kingdoms of Bengal, Bahar, 
 
 <f and
 
 " and Oriffa ; fuch falaries to take place and 
 <c commence, in refpect of all fuch perfons, 
 " who mall be refident in Great Britain at the 
 " time of their appointment, from the day 
 " on which fuch perfons (hall embark from 
 " Great Britain ; and fuch falaries to be in lieu 
 " of all fees of office, perquifites, emoluments y 
 ' and advantages ivhatfoever, as by the laid 
 ** act may more plainly and largely appear. 
 
 AUTHENTIC
 
 AUTHENTIC COPY 
 
 O F T H E 
 
 P R O C E E D I N G S, &c. 
 
 Revenue Department. 2gth Sept. 1780. 
 
 GOVERNOR GENERAL, 
 
 THE inftitution of the new courts of 
 Dewannee Adawlut has already given 
 occafion to very troublefome and alarming 
 competitions between them and the provincial 
 councils, and to much wafte of time at this 
 board. 1 hefe, however, manifeft the neceffity 
 of giving a more than ordinary attention to 
 thefe courts in the infancy of their eftablifh* 
 mem, that they may neither prevent the pur- 
 pofes nor exceed the limits of their jurifdidlion, 
 nor fuffer encroachments upon it. 
 
 To effect thefe points would require fuch a 
 laborious and alrnoft unremitted application, 
 that, however urgent or important they may 
 appear, I ihould dread to bring them before 
 the confutation of the board, unlefs I could 
 propofe fome expedient for that end, that 
 fliould not add to the weight of bufmefs with 
 which it is already overcharged. 
 
 B That
 
 / 
 
 That which I have to offer, will I hope prove 
 rather a dimunition of it. 
 
 By the conftitution of the Dewannee courts, 
 they are all made amenable to a fuperior court 
 called the Sudder Dewannee Adawlut, which 
 has been commonly but erroneoufly underftood 
 to be (imply a court of appeals it's province 
 is and neceffarily mud be much more extenfive. 
 . It is not only to receive appeals from the decrees 
 of the inferior courts in all caufes exceeding a 
 certain amount, but to receive and revife all the 
 proceedings of the inferior courts ; to attend to 
 their conduct j to remedy their defecls, and 
 generally to form fuch new regulations and 
 checks as experience {hall prove to be neceflary 
 to the purpofes of their inftitution. 
 
 Hitherto the board has referved this office to 
 itfelf, but hath not yet entered in the execution 
 of it, nor, I will venture to pronounce, willi$ 
 ever with effect, though half of it's time were de- 
 yoted to this imgle depart orient. 
 
 Yet without both the fupport and controul 
 of fume powerful authority held over them, it 
 is impoflible for the courts to fubfift, but they 
 muft either fink into contempt, or be perverted 
 into the inftruments of opprefiion. 
 
 This
 
 t 3 ) 
 
 This authority I repeat the board is incapable 
 of exercifing, and if delegated to any body of 
 men, or to any individual agent* not pofleffing 
 in themfelves feme weight independent of mere 
 official power, it will prove little more effectual; 
 The only mode which I can clevife to fubftirute 
 for it, is included in the following morions, 
 which I now fubrnit, on the reafons premifedj 
 to the confideration of the board. 
 
 That the chief juftice be requefted to accept 
 of the charge and fuperintendency of the office 
 of Sudder Dewannee Adawlut under it's prefent 
 regulations, and fuch other as the board fhall 
 think proper to add to them, or to fubftitute 
 in their ftead, and that on his acceptance of it, 
 he be appointed to it, and ftiled the judge of 
 the Sudder Dewannee Adawlut; 
 
 I fhall beg leave to add a few words in fup-* 
 port of this propofnion on different grounds. 
 
 I am well aware that the choice which I have 
 made for fo important an office, and one which 
 will minutely and narrowly over'ook every rank 
 of the civil fervice, will fubject me to much, 
 popular prejudice, as it's real tendency will be 
 mifunderftood by many, mifreprefented by more, 
 and perhaps dreaded by a few. I ihall patiently 
 B 2 fubmic
 
 ( 4 ) 
 
 fubmit to this confequence, becaufe I am eon- 
 fcious of the rectitude of my intentions, and cer- 
 tain that the event will juftify me, and prove 
 in that whatever light it may be fuperficially 
 received, 1 (hall be found to have ftudied the true 
 intereft of the fervice, and contributed the moft 
 effectually to its credit. 
 
 The want of legal powers except fuch as are 
 implied in very doubtful conftructions of the 
 act of parliament; and the hazards to which the 
 fuperiors of the Dewanny courts are expofed in 
 their own p'erfons, from the exercife of their 
 functions, has been the principal caufe of 
 their remifsnefs, and equally of the difregard 
 which has been in many inftances (hewn to 
 their authority. They will be enabled to act 
 with confidence, nor will any man dare to conteft 
 their right of a&ing when their proceedings are 
 held under the fanction and immediate patronage 
 of the firft member of the lupreme court, and 
 with his participation in the inftances of fuch as 
 are brought in appeal before him, and regulated 
 by his inductions. They very much require 
 an intlructor, and no one will doubt the fuperior 
 qualifications of the chief juftice for fuch a 
 duty. 
 
 It will be a means of leflening the diftance 
 between the board and the fupreme court, which 
 
 has
 
 ( $ ) 
 
 has perhaps been, more than the undefined 
 powers afTumed ro each, the caufe of the want of 
 that accommodating temper, which ought to 
 have influenced their intercourfe with each other. 
 The contefts in which we have been unfortuna- 
 tily engaged with the court bore at one time fo 
 alarming a tendency, that I believe every mem- 
 ber of the board foreboded the mod dangerous 
 confcquences to the peace and reiburces of 
 this government from them. They are at prefent 
 Compofed, but we cannot be certain that the 
 calm will lad beyond the actual vacation, fmce 
 the fame grounds and materials of difunion 
 fubfift 5 and the revival of it at a time like this 
 added to our other troubles might, if carried to 
 extremities, prove fatal. 
 
 The propofition which I have fubmitted to 
 the board, may, nor have I a doubt that it will, 
 prove an inftrument of conciliation with the 
 court, and it will preclude the necefllty of its 
 afiuming a jurifdiction over perfons exempted 
 by our construction of the act of parliament from 
 it. It will facilitate and give vigour to the 
 courfe of jullice j it will leffen the cares of the 
 board and add to their leifure for occupations 
 more urgent and better fuited to the genius antf 
 principles of government : nor will it be any 
 
 scceffion
 
 ( 6 ) 
 
 acceffion of power to the court, where that 
 portion of authority which is pr pofed to be 
 given, is given only to a fingle man of the court, 
 and may be revoked whenever the board (hall 
 think it proper to refume it. 
 
 Revenue Department, Oftober, 1780. 
 
 NO one can be more fincerely defirous 
 than I am of the due adminiftration of 
 juftice in this country. By the late act of 
 parliament, this branch is divided between the 
 fupreme court and the government : what the 
 aft hath not committed to the former, it confirms 
 to the latter ; and wherever the extent of the 
 refpective jurifdictions is not clearly defined, or 
 is oppofitely viewed, there mutual Candour and 
 regard to the publick good fhould influence; 
 Through thefe channels only can juftice flaw 
 here. 
 
 This board, in the late inftitution of Dewan- 
 nee courts of Adawlut, hath thought itfelf acting 
 within the province left to it by the legifiature ; 
 and making an effective regulation for the 
 
 benefit
 
 ( 7 ) 
 
 benefit of the country. I am forry to find 
 the govenor general's minute, that he now fees 
 the inftitution in a different light in both thefe 
 refpedls. He conceives that '* the fuperiors of 
 * c the Adawiets have no legal powers, txccpj 
 *' fuch as are implied in very doubtful conftruc, 
 " tions of the act of parliament " and that the 
 court of appeals eftablimed to controiil their 
 proceedings, and fupport their authority, can 
 never prove effectual for thefe purpofes. If the ^ 
 inftitution has really thefe evils in it, I am will- 
 ing to deliberate upon proper remedies for them ; 
 to reduce it if it has exceeded the due limit, or 
 if it is found to be eflentially defective, to agr\.e 
 to an eflf. ntial change in it. But at prefent I *. 
 onuft confefs thefe pofrtions are not evident to 
 me, and fuppofmg them to be cftablifhed, in /\ 
 the application of remedies, we can have no 
 ftandard but the lines marked out by the aA of 
 parliament, which affigns a feparate juriidiction 
 to each of the two departments, or implies the 
 duty of a co-operation of both. 
 
 Altho* I entertain all due deference for the 
 chief juftice, and feel myfelf embarrafled by the 
 perfonality which mixes in the qutftion before 
 us, yet I muft beg leave to fay, that the expedient 
 propofed by the governor general feems not to 
 fall in with any of the intentions of the act, 
 
 but
 
 C 8 ) , 
 
 but to be oppofed by difficulties, as well as to 
 threaten confequences, which unlefs obv.Jted 
 muft determine me to withhold my afltrnr to if. 
 
 Some of the prefent difficulties are thefe. 
 Firft. If rhe governor general and council have 
 no other legal power to appoint fuperimendams 
 of the Adawlet than what is implied from a 
 doubtful coxftruffion of the act of parliament, 
 then they fhouid not have proceeded to an 
 eftrfblifh.oent of fuch importance, nor fhould 
 they now per lift in it, -their bufinffs in fuch 
 cafe is to act in concert with the court, 
 
 2'dly. If they have not in themfelves com- 
 petent power for this eft a bli foment, then in like 
 manner they are not competent to confer upon 
 any individual that authority, with which it is 
 now propofcd to inveft the perfon of the chief 
 juftice, 
 
 jdly. Unlefs the chief juftice acknowledges 
 the validity of the board's inftitution (which 
 will be a great authority againft the governor 
 general's argument) he cannot confidently 
 accept of the office propofed for him. And the 
 fame remark may be extended to the opinions 
 of the other judges. His acceptance of an 
 office cannot eftablifh the legality of the power 
 that confers it.
 
 ( 9 ) 
 
 4thly, The union of different powers in the 
 perfbn of the chief juftice can be no reguhr 
 conciliation of the two departments. The in- 
 terpofition of his perfori may indeed prevent 
 their clafhing for a time, but this effects no real 
 adjuftment of principles between them. And 
 it does not feem allowable for us to conclude 
 that a particular diftinction (hewn to the chief 
 juftice will fupprefs all oppofition of fentiment 
 from the other judges, nor does this mode of 
 procuring peace, if it fhould fucceed, appear 
 the rnoft honourable or fafe for ourfelves -, for, 
 after delegating fo much power, both depart- 
 ments are ft ill left expofed, at the pleafure of the 
 chief juftice, to the future eruption of their un- 
 extinguiflbed differences. 
 
 5thly, If for the purpofes of conciliating the 
 court, and giving efficacy to the Adawluts, 
 fuch an authority is to be beftowecl, it would 
 feem that thefe purpofes would be better an- 
 fwered, and all danger of infringing the act of 
 parliament avoided, by delegating the power of 
 hearing appeals to all the judges of the fupreme 
 court, or aflbciating them with ourfelves, and 
 holding fuch power in conjunction with them, 
 which falls in with one part of the bill tranfmic- ^ 
 ted to the court of directors in the year 1776. * 
 
 C 6:hly,
 
 (10 ) 
 
 6thly, By an appointment of this nature, 
 the indrpcnJcncy of both departments may b? 
 endangered. By leparating the members from 
 their departments, a fyftem of mutual influence, 
 which may occafionaily operate too powerfully 
 upon each, is at once founded. 
 
 7thly, Such an union of different powers is 
 Beyond the icope of the act of parliament; and 
 foreign to the conttitution of the company's 
 government. A great falary, high rank, and 
 confideration are annexed to the office of chief 
 jjuitice, moft probably upon the fuppofition that 
 th^ perfon advanced to it, could here receive no 
 augmentation in any of thefe things; and it 
 feems inconfiftent with his appointment from 
 the king, which makes him independant, to 
 accept of another appointment during the 
 pleafureof this board. 
 
 Sthly, In the office propofed to be given to 
 the chief juftice, it doth not appear how he can 
 be held under either controul or refponfibility. 
 He cannot be feparated from the privileges of his 
 original office ; yet the exercife of them in all 
 that relates to the new appointment muft be 
 quite dilcretionary with him.-r-The apprehen- 
 fions, which I entertain and have alluded to in, 
 tr^e former part of the minute^ are thefe. 
 
 Firft,
 
 ( it ) 
 
 Firft, That it will be thought requifite, if 
 this appointment takes place, to annex a large 
 falary to it, and an ample eilablifhment. In 
 our prefent ftate, when we can hardly raife 
 money for our neceffary occafions, I fhould 
 think fuch an expence utterly inadmifiible. 
 
 adly, Decifions might probably go upofi 
 the principles of Englilh law. The introduction 
 of this practice mould, in my humble opinion, 
 be previoufly and maturely confidered* 
 
 3dly, If attorneys and folicitors ftiould be 
 admitted to practice in the court of appeals, a v / 
 new and wide door of litigation would be open- 
 ed. The company have no controul over 
 attornies and folicitors. 
 
 4thly, The bufinefs of the court of appeals 
 muft give opportunity fora thorough infpectiori y 
 of all the affairs of the revenue proceedings of 
 the provincial councils : of courfe a very power- 
 ful influence over both Europeans and natives* 
 
 5thly, Such an influence poflefled by the 
 chief juftice of the fupreme court might too y 
 much hide the government from the eyes of the 
 natives* 
 
 Waving
 
 -; 
 
 ( 12 ) 
 
 Waving further objections, I now repeat my 
 \vifh to fee thefe obviated j and whatever may 
 be wanting for an effectual controul over the 
 country courts fupplied. If the fervice, indeed, 
 Ihould require an extraneous check, delicate 
 and importent as this point is, I would by no 
 means have it underftood that I would oppofe it ; 
 but before this is applied, I think feveral other 
 expedients might be tried* ift, The company's 
 chief Jaw officer here feerns to be the perfon to 
 whom recourfe Ihould firft be had, his ftation 
 being fimilar to that of the company's in 
 England, who attends on all queftions of law, 
 and gives his opinion and advice. I think that 
 by introducing in the fame manner the advocate 
 general into the court of appeals, the bufmefs 
 of that court might be made eafy to the mem- 
 bers of the board : and I mnft think alfo that 
 if fuch an officer, as judge of the court of ap- 
 peals, mould be created, be has the moft natural 
 right to it, 
 
 adly, The fuprente court and the governor 
 general and council might fit together as a 
 court of appeals according to the principles of 
 the bill already mentioned. 
 
 3dly, The objections againft the chief juftice 
 lie with lefs force, againft either of the inferior 
 
 judges :
 
 ( .3 ) 
 
 judges : and 4thly, leaft of all againft the pre* 
 fidence of all the judges in rotation. 
 
 Revenue Department, 3d, O&ober, 17869 
 
 Mr. FR4NCIS, 
 
 I HAVE not had time to give to this impor- 
 tant propofition all the confideration it de- 
 ferves. The reflections, which it fuggefls, 
 mull be ftated hallily as they occur. 
 
 That it is a frefh innovation, fucceeding. 
 many others, in the adminiftration of juftice to 
 the natives of this country, is of itfelf a weighty 
 objection. All innovations of this nature arc 
 dangerous, efpecially in a country, whole 
 government cannot divide, or furrender any of 
 its powers, without lefTening the refpect, and 
 hazarding the obedience of its fubjedts. On this 
 principle, we contended for the exclufive jurif- 
 diclion of the governor general and council, as 
 Dewan, over the Zemindars, landholders, and 
 landed property of this country. In my judg- 
 ment, the propofition amounts to a direct con- 
 tradiclion, or defertion of every thing we faid, 
 or did, in the cafe of the Rajah of Coffeejurah : 
 
 as
 
 ( U ) 
 
 as fuch it will be naturally received and undef- 
 ftood by the natives. They cannot diftinguifh 
 between the chief juftice and the fupreme 
 courts ; or if the distinction could pofiibly be 
 explained to them, and if they could be fatisfied 
 that in fad it was not intended to reinftate the 
 court in the exercife of the jurifdiclion which it 
 had claimed, and which we had refilled, it is 
 probable they would think that fomc greater 
 evil was to befall them. 
 
 I hope it is unnecefiary for me to fay, that 
 no idea of perfonal difrefpec~l to the chief juftice 
 can be intended in any thing I (hall offer on the 
 public queftion before me. If any expreflion, 
 that may appear to have fuch a tendency Ihould 
 efcape me, I difclaim it. I mean to examine 
 the propofed inftitution on its own merits, and 
 the difficulties it may be fubject to, as a public 
 meafure, without reference to the perfonal 
 character, or qualifications of any individual. 
 I mail follow the reafoning of the governor 
 general's minute in the order in which he has 
 placed it. 
 
 i ft. If the inftitution of the new courts has 
 already given occafion to competitions between 
 the provincial councils and the Duanny Adaw- 
 luts, it is our bufmefs and duty to put an end 
 
 to
 
 ( '5 ) 
 
 to them by our authority, which is direct and 
 fufficiently coercive over both parties. We 
 ought to draw the line between them, and infift 
 on their refpe&ive fubmifllon to the limitation 
 defcribed by it. I do not think that, to effect 
 this point, would require any very laborious 
 application on our part. Our adminiftration 
 wants vigour, not time, to execute all its duties, / j 
 One punifhment would have more effect than a 
 thoufand regulations. But, if the argument 
 were well founded, how is the difficulty re^ 
 moved by transferring this laborious fervice to 
 the chief juftice, who is already fo overloaded 
 with the bufinefs of the fupreme court, that he 
 finds it impoflible to affift his brethren, as 
 acting juftices of Calcutta, and therefore is 
 very juftly excufed from (baring with them in 
 the toij of that troublefome office. 
 
 adly, The Sudder Dewannee Adawlut I know 
 has been commonly, but I do not think it is 
 erroneously, underftood to be fimply a court of v 
 appeals. The 6th article of the plan for the 
 adminiftration of juftice provides, that the De- 
 wanny Sudder Adawlut Jhall receive and determine 
 appeals from the provincial Dewanny Adawluts ; 
 and it fays no more. If its province be and 
 neceffarily muft be tpuch more extenfive, the ex- 
 tent of it (hould be accurately defcribed and 
 
 defined.
 
 C 16 ) 
 
 defined. For my own part, I know not where 
 to look for this necefiary definition ; but I know- 
 that a jurifdiction, not fo defined, either has no 
 power at all, or it is defpotic. A court of ap- 
 peal, as fuch, can do nothing but receive ap- 
 peals from the decrees of inferior courts : if it 
 ^ is to receive and revife all the proceedings of 
 fuch courts, it muft itfelf ceafe to be a court of 
 .appeal; for what fuitor will appeal to a fupe- 
 rior court, which has already revifed, approved, 
 and confirmed the very proceedings by which 
 he thinks himfelf injured. If a court of appeal 
 adheres to the true principle of its inftitution, 
 it fhould know nothing of the proceedings of 
 the inferior court, until an appeal from the de- 
 cree of that court comes regularly before it. If 
 k has already approved of the proceedings be- 
 low, it is inftanter a party, and cannot be judge. 
 As to the other duties propofed <c of attending 
 * to their conduct, of remedying their defects, 
 < and forming new regulations, &c. " thefe are 
 objects for the legiflative power of the country, 
 which I underftand, qu&. ad hoc at lead, is ex- 
 clufively and unalienably veiled in the governor 
 general and council. 
 
 gdly, I am of opinion that the office might 
 be exercifed by the board, or by any two mem- 
 bers of it, and that two or three fpecific days, 
 
 allowed
 
 c 17 ) 
 
 allotted in a month to this duty, would be fuf* 
 ficient to perform it* 
 
 4thly, I muft object to the requeft pfopofed 
 to be made to the chief juftice, for the follow- 
 ing reafons : The governor general and coun- >/ 
 cil cannot, without departing from the princU 
 pies on which they have unanimoufly acted, ef- 
 tablifh the Sudder Adawleton any plan^ which 
 commits the company's rights, or ours, in qua- 
 lity of Duan of the provinces, to the cuftody 
 of all, or any of the judges. The fupreme j\ 
 court and council differ widely in their ideas of 
 the jurifdiction of the court* The chief juftice 
 cannot be fuppofed to have changed the opini- 
 ons which he has at all times fo fteadily main- 
 tained ; and thofe opinions would lead him to 
 fubmit to the jurifdiction of the court in many 
 inftances, in which the council, upon tbeir 
 principles, would refill them. Thus the coun- 
 cil, by making the chief juftice judge of the 
 Sudder Dewannee Adawlut, would put it into 
 the power of the very man, with whom they 
 have been contending, to give up what they 
 have hitherto infifted on as their eficntial rights. 
 
 The great object of this plan is to give au- 
 thority to the Dewannee Adawluts ; but I can- 
 not admit that the means are likely to anfwer 
 D the
 
 ( i8 ) 
 
 the end. The arguments drawn from the ele- 
 vated ftation of the chief juftice have no weight. 
 He can carry none of the powers of the fupreme 
 court into the Sudder Adawlut. When he ads 
 under the appointment of the council as fuper- 
 intendant, he will poflefs no part of the autho- 
 rity which he derives from the king*s appoint- 
 ment of chief juftice. It will not prove an in- 
 ftrument of conciliation, nor prevent the revi- 
 val of difputes, which it is faid might prove, 
 fatal. It is admitted by the governor that the 
 grounds of difunion ftill fubfift ; and it is cer- 
 tain that the appointment of the chief juftice 
 to the Sudder Adawlut will make no alteration 
 in the authority and powers of the fupreme 
 court. The remaining judges^ will have the 
 fame powers that they all now poflefs, becaufe 
 the council cannot, by new modelling the 
 Adawlut?, abridge, or in any way affect the 
 powers of the court. If the chief juftice car- 
 ries his late opinions into the Sudder Adawlut, 
 V the fupreme court will obtain ftrength from this 
 appointment : if he acts on new principles 
 more conformable to thofe of the council, that 
 will rtife freih difficulties, It will tend to make 
 a breach between him and the other judges, but 
 can never repair the breach already fubfifting 
 A between the' court and council. 1 uie the lan- 
 guage which has already been applied by us to 
 
 the
 
 ( 19 ) 
 
 the judges, when I fay that there is a je 
 which all men feel far their own power and con- 
 fequence. T-he two pui (he judges cannot but 
 fed themfelves wounded by this partial fclection. 
 of the chief juftice, and the preference given 
 to his fuperior qualifications. We ought not 
 to offer them fuch caufe of offence, nor ought 
 we to be carelefs of the effects it may pro- 
 duce. -r-I conceive that the appointment of the 
 chief juftice to this office would clam arid be 
 inconfiitent with the duties of his preient fla- 
 tion. It would be an iniuperable bar to his 
 acting in many cafes, in whicn his duty, as 
 chief juflice, would call on him to act. Sup- 
 pofe a fuitor in the Adawlut fliould think the 
 judge had acted illegally : he might bring his 
 action againft him in the fupreme court ; and 
 then, upon the principles on which the court 
 and the chief juftice have particularly infifted 
 and acted, he would be obliged to come as a 
 party into the court, in which he ought to pre- 
 fide as chief juftice, to plead in the ufual form, 
 and to defend himfelf in the ufual way j and 
 he might be compelled to pay damages for 
 what he had done as fuperintendant, in the 
 fame manner that the council of Patna were 
 for their proceedings againft Nauderah Begum : 
 Thus his proceedings in the Adawlut would 
 
 D 2 bnng
 
 ( 20 ) 
 
 bring him a party into his own court, and pre- 
 clude him from acting in his capacity of chief 
 jullice. Again, fuppofe a perfon, committed 
 by any of the inferior Adawluts, or by the 
 chief juftice himfelf as judge of the Sudder 
 Ada-vlut, mould apply to him for a writ of 
 Habeas Corpus :> Shall he refufe the writ, 
 becaufe the grounds of the commitment are 
 already known to him ? Or foall he grant it, 
 tho* pofiefled of fuch knowledge, and where he 
 himfelf has prejudged the queftion, by order- 
 ing or approving the commitment ? I can- 
 not prefume to fay how far it would be his duty 
 to grant the writ at all events ; but it is evident 
 that the prifoner would gain nothing by obtain- 
 ing it.-! It may be faid the perfon, fo com- 
 mitted, may apply for a writ of habeas corpus 
 to one of the puifne judges. If he fucceeds 
 (as v he certainly would, if in the opinion of the 
 judge there mould be reafon to fuppofe the 
 commitment might be illegal) it would follow, 
 that the act of the fuperintendant would be can- 
 vafled, and perhaps fet afide by an inferior 
 judge of another court, in which the fuper- 
 intendant himfelf prefides. This cafe might 
 frequently occur; and if it fhould ever occur, 
 it would tend to create new differences between 
 the fupreme court on the one fide, and the Sud- 
 der
 
 der Dewannee Adawlut, fupported by the chief 
 juftice of the fupreme court, on the other. 
 
 On the whole, I think it would be improper 
 in the council to requeft the chief juftice to 
 take upon himfelf, and perhaps illegal in him 
 to accept an office, which is fo inconfiftent with 
 the duties of his prefent ftation, and which 
 would preclude him from exercifing the truft 
 repofed in him by the King in many cafes of 
 the greateft importance , particularly thofe, in 
 which the limits of the jurifdiction of the, 
 court, and the extent of the powers vetted in 
 the council, might come in queftion. 
 
 One of the obfervations with which the go- 
 vernor general concludes his argument in favor 
 of his plan, viz. " That the portion of au- 
 ** thority, which is propofed to be given, is 
 * given only to a lingle man of the court," 
 appears to me a ftrong objection againft it. 
 The Englifh government has very fparingly 
 delegated judicial authority to fingle perfons ; 
 final appeals in particular are never permitted to 
 be tried by a fingle judge, either in England, 
 or any of its provinces, or dependencies. The 
 King is, I believe, the only fingle perfon 'to 
 whom fuch an appellate jurifdiction is even 
 nominally given j and he cannot try an appeal 
 
 without
 
 v < 22 
 
 without the afliftance of his privy council. Ap- 
 peals to him therefore are called appeals to the 
 King in council^ 
 
 This policy has nothing to do with trials by 
 jury, or principles of Englilh liberty, which 
 may be thought in-applicable to Bengal , but 
 is founded on that juftice to which the natives 
 of Bengal are entitled, as well as other men. 
 But juftice requires that, in the conftitution of 
 a court, corruption be above all things guarded 
 againft ; and no magistrate is more liable to 
 corruption, than a judge in whom is verted a 
 power of determining appeals, without being 
 either checked by aflbciates, or controlled by 
 any further appeal to fuperior judges. The 
 IcgiQature, in eftabhftiing the fupreme court 
 of judicature here, though it be not a court 
 of appeal, and though an appeal may be made 
 from its decifions to the King in council, 
 thought a plurality of judges necefiary ; and 
 therefore created fo many, that it is not likely 
 they mould be reduced by chance to one. Mr. 
 Haftings and his council, when they erected 
 the court of Sudder Dewannee Adawlut, would 
 not leave fuch reduction in the power of 
 chance , but made the prefence of three mem- 
 bers eflcntially nrce0ary to a decifion. If I 
 could believe it lawful and proper for us to 
 
 delegate
 
 ( 23 ) 
 
 delegate our judicial authority to judges of 
 the fuprerne court, I mould think it ought ra- 
 ther to be given to all than to one. 
 
 If all the powers of the Sud^er Dewannee 
 Adavvlut be vefted in one man, yet fo vetted 
 " that they may be revoked whenever this board 
 " mall think it proper to refume them," fuch a 
 judge may become in the hands of corrupt council 
 an inftrument of oppreflion. The council will 
 not be anfwerable for his decrees , and he will 
 be in a great meafure protected by his judicial 
 capacity. 
 
 The authority given may undoubtedly be re- 
 voked, whenever the board mall think proper 
 to refume it. The prefent board cannot bind 
 their fucceflbrs, nor even themfelves, againit a 
 change of opinion. But will the chief jufticc ' 
 accept of fuch an office on fo precarious a foot- N 
 ing ? or would it be refpectful in us to offer it 
 to him, with the information, which ought to 
 accompany it, viz* That he is removable at J 
 any time by areiolution of the board. 
 
 Revenue
 
 Revenue Department, Oftober 8th, 1780. 
 
 t 
 
 Sir EYRE COOTE, 
 
 AS the determining upon points relative to 
 law proceedings has fallen fo little within 
 the limits of my profeflion, I acknowledge my- 
 felf inadequate to the forming a thorough 
 judgment concerning the plan propofed by the 
 governor general : but trufling to his full 
 knowledge of that branch of government, 
 which he now means to bring under the con- 
 troul of infpection, and from a real fenfe of the 
 abilities of the chief juftice, to render any depart- 
 ment of fuperintendance, which fhould be en- 
 trufted to his charge, no lefs ufeful and 
 beneficial in effect, than in idea, I give my 
 aflent to the meafure, obferving at the fame time, 
 however, that this aflent is for the trial of an 
 expedient which may be attended with favorable 
 confequences, and not for its abfolute eftablilh- 
 ment, and I therefore referve to myfelf full 
 liberty to vote for the repeal of the p relent re- 
 folution, mould I find it prove hereafter in any 
 refpect detrimental either to the great lines of 
 government, or to the community. 
 
 . C. 
 THE END.
 
 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LIBRARY 
 
 Los Angeles 
 This book is DUE on the last date stamped below. 
 
 Form L9-32m-8,'58(5876s4)444 
 
 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA 
 
 AT
 
 1158010453073 
 
 UC SOUTHERN REGIONAL 
 
 A 000017699 o