LIBRARY UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA. Class THE STEAM TURBINE AS APPLIED TO MARINE PURPOSES. NET BOOK.-Thi8 book is supplied to the Trade on terms which will not allow of Discount to the Public. CHARLES GRIFFIN & CO., LTD. CHARLES GRIFFIN & CO.'S STANDARD PUBLICATIONS In Large 8vo. Handsome Cloth. With 252 Illustrations and 3 Plates. 15s. net. THE THEORY OF THE STEAM TURBINE. A Treatise on the Principles of Construction of the Steam Turbine, with Historical Notes on its Development. BY ALEXANDER JUDE. CONTENTS : Fundamental. Historical Notes. Velocity of Steam. Types of Steam Turbines. Practical Turbines. Efficiency of Compound Turbines. Tra- jectory of Steam. Efficiency of Turbines, Types 2 and 3. Type 4. Turbine Vanes. Disc and Vane Friction. Specific Heat of Superheated Steam. Strength of Rotating Discs Governing Steam Turbines. Steam Consumption. Whirling of Shafts. Speed of Turbines. Index. MANUAL OF MARINE ENGINEERING. Comprising the Designing, Con- struction, and Making of Marine Machinery. By A. E. SEATON, M.Inst. C.E., M.I.Mech.E., M.I.N.A. FIFTEENTH EDITION, Revised and Enlarged. 21s. net. " The most valuable handbook of reference." Marine Engineer. ENGINE ROOM PRACTICE. A Handbook for Engineers and Officers in the Royal Navy and Mercantile Marine. By JOHN G. LIVERSIDGE, A.M.Inst.C.E. FIFTH EDITION. In large 8vo. Fully Illustrated. 6s. net. " The contents cannot fail to be appreciated." Steamship. POCKET-BOOK OF MARINE ENGINEERING RULES AND TABLES. For the use of Marine Engineers, Naval Architects, Designers, Draughtsmen, and others. By A. E. SEATON, M.Inst.C.E., and H. M. ROUNTHWAITE, M.I.Mech.E. NINTH EDITION, Revised. Pocket Size, Leather. 8s. 6d. " Admirably fulfils its purpose." Marine Engineer. BOILERS: LAND AND MARINE. Their Construction and Strength. A Hand- book of Rules, Tables, and Formula; relative to Materials, Scantlings, Pressures, Valves, Springs, etc. By T. W. TRAILL, M.Inst.C.E., F.E.R.N. FOURTH EDITION, Revised and Enlarged. Leather. 12s. Gd. " The most valuable work on boilers published in England." Shipping World. OIL FUEL: ITS SUPPLY, COMPOSITION, AND APPLICATION. By SIDNEY H. NORTH. Late Edition "Petroleum Review." In large Crown 8vo. Fully Illustrated. 5s. net. " Everyone interested in this important question will welcome Mr North's excellent text-book." Nature. STEEL SHIPS: THEIR CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE. A Mauual for Shipbuilders, Ships Superintendents, Students, and Marine Engineers. By THOMAS WALTON, Naval Architect. THIRD EDITION. Profusely Illus- trated. 18s. net. "The book throughout is characterised by thoroughness." Mariner. THE STABILITY OF SHIPS. By SIR EDWARD J. REED, K.C.B., F.R.S., M.P. In Royal 8vo. Handsome Cloth. Very fully Illustrated. 25s. " Sir Edward Reed's ' Stability of Ships ' is invaluable." Steamship. KNOW YOUR OWN SHIP. By THOMAS WALTON, Naval Architect. NINTH EDITION, Revised and Enlarged. Fully Illustrated. 7s. 6d. " Will obtain lasting success because of its unique fitness for those for whom it is written." Shipping World. DOCK ENGINEERING. The Principles and Practice of. By BRYSSON CUN- NINGHAM, B.E.. A.M.Inst.C.E. In. Large 8vo. With 34 Folding Plates and 4 a $& ^ e tne positions of the moving blade during the time in which a particle of steam is passing through the blades. If we assume that its velocity along the blades is uniform, and divide the length of the path into equal parts, we get the path of the steam as shown. At any point such as p the true velocity will be along the path of the steam, and if we assume an imposed reversed velocity u t a triangle such as is shown in the middle of the diagram will give a value and direction for w, the relative velocity, in terms of position in the passage of the steam through the blade. The direction of w should always be parallel to the tangent to the blade at the corresponding point. It will be seen that the turning of the line of flow of the steam from its initial direction 56 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. to its final direction through the blades is what causes the blades to revolve. A force has to be exerted to deflect the steam stream, and that force turns the turbine blades. If the steam passes through a series of blades of the same section and the same height, its velocity will gradually increase under the action of the pressure of the steam ; and if this were continued far enough, we should get a very much higher velocity than would be efficient in relation to the peripheral speed. It becomes necessary, therefore, at a certain stage, to increase the peripheral velocity, and this is first done by lengthening the blades. This is equivalent to an increase of area of section of flow, and must necessarily be associated with a reduction of velocity of steam. This reduced velocity in its turn is gradu- ally increased if the area of flow, that is, the height of the blades, is unchanged, and a point will again be reached in the velocity of the steam where the relation of the steam speed to the peripheral speed will be too great, and a further increase of length of blade must be made. It would be theoretically better to make a gradual increase in the length of the blade, but the practical difficulty of construction due to having a curved surface would be considerable, and if the steps in increase of length of blade are sufficiently frequent, there is little loss of efficiency in adhering to a uniform height through the group, provided that the number in the group is not too great. This process of increase of velocity associated with the increase of length of blade reaches a limit when the length of blade be- comes too great for strength, for the increase of length must be associated with an increase of thickness which involves (1) reduction of area, and (2) losses, that, in the process of continued increase of velocity, will become serious. There comes then a stage where the peripheral velocity must be in- creased more than the small amount which it can be increased by lengthening the blades. In marine turbines it is usual to make this change of peripheral velocity by passing the steam DIMENSIONS. 57 into a larger turbine, and most frequently into two larger tur- bines, so that a very considerable increase in the ratio of peripheral speed to steam speed can be secured. The division into two turbines and the increase of diameter of drum reduces the height of the blades at the beginning of the L.P. turbines to about the same as that at the beginning of the H.P. That is to say, the diameter of the L.P. drums is fixed to admit of this height of blade. The same process of increase of velocity goes on through the L.P. turbine, and has to be met by increased blade length at definite stages, until finally the pressure has so far fallen and the volume so far increased that most of the kinetic energy is taken out of the steam. The blades at the end of the L.P. turbine may be much longer than those at the end of the H.P., because the pressure which the steam exerts on these blades per unit of area is much less. DIMENSIONS. A description of the considerations which govern the details of dimensions may here be given. We have already seen that the shape and height of the blades depend on the relation between the steam speed and the peripheral speed. The steam enters the guide blade with velocity v , and has its velocity increased by steam pressure to v r The amount of work done on each pound of the steam in the first guide blades (calling them a) is v, :=W! which can be converted into heat units given off, or heat-drop, as it is technically called, by dividing by 778. In its passage through the blades the energy given off by the steam can be measured by the gain in velocity relatively to the blades. This relative velocity increases in passing through the wheel because 58 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. it is the actual work, or the work which would be done on the steam (if we bring the wheel to rest by giving it and the steam a velocity u opposite to that which the wheel really has, then this actual work is the difference in relative work at the be- ginning and end of the steam passage through the wheel). Actually the work is done on the wheel, but the hypothetical reversion which keeps the wheel fixed in our view is only hypothetical. Hence the work done on the moving wheel a can be measured by the expression Fig. 73. Curve of Velocities. The steam enters the next guide blades with the velocity c 2 in fig. 73, the third leg of the velocity triangle, of which u and w 2 are the other sides. As before, the velocity passing through the guide blades is increased, and the same series of changes takes place in it and in the moving blades. It should be noted that the starting torque is much greater than the torque at full speed and well under way by an amount which can be deter- mined from the base of the velocity triangle. The relation between c , c v w v w 2 , c 2 . . . depends on the form of the blades and the angles of entrance and exit. The determination of the values of the heat-drop in each set of guide DIMENSIONS. 59 and moving blades is simplified by assuming that the angle of exit of the guide and moving blades is the same, and that the exit velocity of steam from the guide blades c x is the same as the relative terminal velocity w 2 in the moving blades of the same set, and that the exit steam velocity of the moving blades c 2 is the same as the relative entering velocity w v This is expressed as w 2 = C 1 ; C 2 = w v The relations between these can be determined from a diagram of velocities such as in fig. 73. Fig. 74. Diagram of Heat- Drops. c i, c?, <, c? . are the velocities of the steam at the exits to the guide blades a t b t c t d . . . and they must be determined from an arbitrarily chosen curve. The first ordinate is usually fixed at about 100 feet. Cases of actual velocities of periphery u have been already given, and c is usually taken about twice that of u. The terminal velocity is also usually determined from the results of observations of the final pressure at the exit of the last vane. A hyperbolic curve is drawn between these 60 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. points as in fig. 74. 1 With this curve we can determine the value of c", c?, cj, c*. From these values the corresponding values of c 2 can be determined, and, as by hypothesis c 1 = w z and c 2 = w v we have all the velocities. The series of drops will be as follows : fM _ 02 for guide blades a, * w a -w c-^ - - l - 2 - for moving blades a, & *s 6> 6 2 _ c 2 1 ' 2 for guide blades b, .2 .2 ,2 .2 w5 trf c? c2 , , , j 7 J for moving blades &, fy fy and so on. From these a series of heat-drops can be calculated and put into the form of a curve. In fig. 74 the assumption is that the blades are in four sets of gradually increasing length. Where the length changes there will be a sudden increase in the heat-drop, the amount of which will depend on the increase of length of the blade. To find the actual value of the total heat-drop throughout the turbine we must know the total H.R required. The area at entrance can be determined from the consumption of water in Ibs. per I. EL P. per hour and the volume of 1 Ib. of steam at the initial pressure. The actual area is not the annular space between the drum and casing, because the area of entrance is through the guide blades, and if we take the steam velocity v t at the a guide-blade exits, we see (fig. 72) that the area in all the guide blades will be the annular space multiplied by the sine of the angle of exit of the guide blades. This angle in the actual case taken is about 30. These considerations fix the length of 1 Stodola's Steam Turbines. DIMENSIONS. 61 the blades. Take the case of the channel steamer whose periph- eral velocity is 98 feet per second and whose angle of entrance is 30, H..P. is 7400, and revolutions 630. If we assume initial pressure to be 125 Ibs., we find the volume of 1 Ib. of steam at this pressure will be 3'17 cubic feet. The length of blade is '8 inch, and, allowing for clearance, we may take disc area available for steam entrance as "82 inch. Assume water consumption to be 15^ Ibs. per H.P. per hour. From these data we get velocity of steam 7400x15-5x3-17x144 30*x-82x-5tX7rx3600 The general formula is n = PwPp 25D/7rsin 1 = length of blades in inches-}- clearance. a = angle of exit from guide blades. P = I.H.P. w = water per H.P. per hour. v p = volume of 1 Ib. steam at pressure p per square inch. D diameter of drum in inches. Knowing c\ for a successful turbine, we may assume it for a new design, and from this deduce the length of the blade Having obtained the heat-drops from the velocity curves through the stages of equal diameters, we come to an increase in length of blade and a small increase in diameter. Passing from the blade of length l : to blade of length Z 2 , we should have a sudden decrease in velocity in the ratio of -i, and this will *2 cause a sudden enlargement in the drop-curve. This can be * Diameter of drum. t Sin 30. 62 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. easily estimated by taking the velocity immediately before the drop and reducing it in the ratio - 1 . Then the difference of squares divided by 2g will give the enlarged drop at this point. There is a constant fall in pressure in the steam which can be obtained when we have fixed the drop-curve. From this pressure curve, which is shown in fig. 75, 1 we can get the volume per Ib. of steam, and knowing the velocity, we can see if the blade length is sufficient. If we start with a continuous drop- heat un'ts 150 atm. absolute T2 11 Fig. 75. Specific Volume and Weight. curve based on an assumed velocity of steam at exit of the guide blades, which is also a continuous curve, we can get a continu- ous pressure and a continuous volume per Ib. of steam curve. From this we can get the necessary length of blade for a given angle of exit. It will be generally found that the later blades are too long, and it will be necessary to increase the diameter of drum to increase the peripheral speed, and also to increase the angle of 1 Stodola's Steam Turbines. DIMENSIONS. 63 exit to widen the area of flow. These changes will introduce a discontinuity into the curve unless it could be possible to continuously increase the drum diameter or the angle of exit. This is not practicable, so that these changes have to be made in steps, and, obviously, the effect of the steps can only be determined by working out pressures, weights per Ik, and Fig. 76. velocities to suit the chosen steps. If the results are harmoni- ous, the design may be considered satisfactory, and if not it must be changed and new calculations made, so that to arrive at a satisfactory result a process of trial and error must be adopted. No doubt experience enables designers to approximate very closely to satisfactory results without making many steps in the process. Figs. 75 and 76 1 show the result of such a set of calculations. 1 Stodola's Steam Turbines. CHAPTEE IV. SCREW PROPELLERS IN TURBINE VESSELS. THE screw propellers, turned by the turbine, drive the ship. If the efficiency of the propeller and the turbines followed exactly the same relation to speed of revolution, the most efficient turbine would give the most efficient result in pro- pulsion. It is necessary to consider what makes for efficiency in the screw propeller and the turbine separately. Take the screw first. The pictures of the screws on the stern of a vessel show what kind of an instrument a screw is. Each blade is a piece of a surface which is swept out by a straight line revolv- ing uniformly about a fixed axis and moving at a uniform speed along that axis. The part of the surface appropriated for the form of a propeller blade is frequently elliptic in form, so that it is practically an elliptic plane slightly twisted and placed obliquely to the shaft axis. Every square inch of the blade in rotating meets with resistance due to the inertia of the water. This is usually considered as being of two separate kinds one due to . rubbing the particles of water out of the way, the other due to pushing them. We generally call these two kinds of resistance frictional and normal pressure re- spectively. For a given speed of blade through the water the more oblique the blade is the more will be the normal pressure, and the less oblique, the greater will be the frictional resist- ance. Also, the greater the area of the part of the blade moving at the given speed, the greater will be these resistances. 64 SCREW PROPELLERS. 65 If the plane of the blade be at right angles to the axis of the shaft, there will be no push in it. It will be all rubbing re- sistance. If it be in the line of the shaft, it will be all push and no rub. But in both these cases we shall have no reaction in the direction of motion, and there will be no force to cause propulsion. For positions of the blade between these two there will be both rubbing and pushing resistances, and there will be a resultant reactional push in the direction of motion which will vary from zero to a maximum and back again to zero between the two extreme positions of blade considered. What we have to find out is, where is this maximum and what is it. We will first try to see what goes on in the vicinity of a propeller when a ship is being driven by it. Fig. 77 l shows the results of observations upon the direction of the flow of Fig. 77. Showing the positions taken up by the stream lines at the stern of a moving vessel. water as a ship passes through it. The thick lines represent floating thin radial feathers which indicate the line of motion of the water relatively to the ship. This kind of change of relative motion is called stream-line motion, and its effect may be seen in actual forms round which flows a coloured fluid, as can be seen in Professor Hele-Shaw's apparatus. This shows 1 Trans. T.N.A., 1893. 5 66 MAKTNE STEAM TURBINES. the same kind of view which one would have in looking over the stern or bow of a ship if the water were particoloured in a similar way. Suppose in this stream at the stern we put a revolving screw propeller. There will be a disturbance of these stream lines. The rubbing and pushing action of the propeller sends the water in many directions, and the action of rubbing and pushing will react on the propeller, and tend to resist the rotation of the propeller, and will push the ship ahead. The more push the reaction gives to the ship for a given turning effort of the propeller, the more efficient will be the result. We have seen that there is a zero of push ahead in two directions of the blade relatively to the shaft, and a maximum somewhere between. This will be so in the case of the pro- peller acting under the stern of the ship, but inasmuch as the direction of the water to the axis of the shaft and to the line of motion of the ship is itself varying and slightly oblique, the position of zero push will not necessarily be either at right angles to each other or at the positions square to and along the shaft as in the simpler case already dealt with. Let us consider the simpler case first. Suppose a propeller to be carried by a phantom ship having no form, but only a capability of (1) delivering a turning effort to a propeller, and (2) receiving a push from the propeller. Suppose the turning effort on the shaft to be always the same, and such as might be delivered by the steady pull of a rope on a drum attached to the shaft. If the blade of the propeller is placed in a plane square to the line of shaft, the resistance which the turning effort will meet with will be a rubbing or frictional resistance, and there will be no forward push given to the propeller by the reaction of the water. The shaft will run very fast, and its limit of speed will only be reached when the total rubbing resistances balance the turning effort due to the rope on the drum. A large amount of work will be done by the force in SCREW PROPELLERS. 67 the rope moving at a great speed. But the useful effect in propelling the vessel will be zero. If for a rope we were to substitute a turbine, we might have a very efficient turbine so far as work delivered in relation to weight of machine or in relation to steam used, but the whole combination of screw and turbine would be a useless machine. If we place the propeller blade in a plane along the shaft, we should get a large push resistance to the propeller, but it would all be in a direction square to the shaft, and no forward push due to the reaction of the water would be caused. As before the limit of speed would be reached when the resistance to pushing the blade through the water balanced the pull in the rope. This would be at a much lower speed than in the former case, and the work done would be less in proportion to the lowering speed. If the work were done by the same turbine as before, it would not be so efficient a turbine either in relation to its weight or to mass of steam used. We might be able to make it as efficient in relation to steam used by making it larger and heavier, but this would still more sacrifice its efficiency in relation to its weight. Whatever was done to improve the efficiency of the turbine in one respect or the other would not make the propeller drive the ship, and, as before, the efficiency of the apparatus would be zero. If, however, we put the propeller blade in some oblique intermediate position, we shall get less rubbing and pushing resistances than in the respective first and second cases, but we shall get some effective push or thrust in the pro- peller. Suppose by a process of trial we can get the exact obliquity which will give a maximum push forward for a given pull on the rope at a given speed, that is, for a given amount of work done per unit of time (usually called a given amount of H. P.), we should then have the best propeller result as far as the obliquity of the particular blades of the propeller are concerned. But we should only then have one best result. 68 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. Consider how many things have been given or assumed for the whole installation. First we assume a certain work done per unit of time called horse-power. Next we assume a given speed of the rope and a given force. These two multiplied together give the H.P., but it is evident that one-half the speed and twice the force would give the same H. P. In fact there is a great variety of speeds and forces whose product is the H. P. , and each one of these will have a different effect on the pro- peller. It will also probably reduce the efficiency of both weight and steam consumption if the H. P. be got in a turbine instead of a rope and drum. Increase of speed will increase forward push, but the obliquity of the blades may not be the best for this increased speed. The turbine would probably be increased in efficiency by the increased speed. But even with this set of conditions it may not be that this particular propeller, even if at its best obliquity, would be the best pro- peller for that particular speed of turning. Its blade area may be capable of improvement. It may be that the in- creased speed would cause too much to be done in rubbing and not enough in push, so that it will be seen that though a propeller may be the best for a given set of conditions, it may be that it is not the best best, but that a change of conditions may make a better best. Thus it is seen that for the highest efficiency not only is the best best propeller the best for its own turbine, but it must also have the best turbine. Some- times it is possible to combine these excellencies, but generally it is not, and the sacrifice of one or other bests has to be made. It is certain that we must study the turbine efficiency in terms of speed of rotation and H. P. , and the propeller in the same terms, and also in that of speed of ship. The subject is too wide and too difficult to deal with here in mathematical detail, but it may be sufficient to say that the whole subject has been treated experimentally by model pro- pellers as large as 16 inches in diameter, having varying areas SCREW PROPELLERS. 69 of blades, diameters, obliquities, usually called pitch, revolu- tions, and speed of ship. These five variables all cause varying efficiencies, so that, treating efficiency as the result of any of those five variables, we have six in all. It is to be noticed that efficiency of propeller is the ratio of push forward to turning effort, and these are capable of varying independently. It will therefore be necessary to cross-stratify all these combina- tions by finding how some vary while others remain fixed. For instance, for a given speed of ship and a given H. P. and given propeller we may trace the change of efficiency in -SCALE OF SUP ff/mO Fig. 78. Single Efficiency and Turning Effort Curve. terms of revolutions. This is shown in such a curve as the figure 78, 1 where A is efficiency and B turning effort. The best way to show this is to represent the revolutions in term of slip ratio. The pitch of a propeller is the amount it would advance in one revolution if it were moving in immov- able material. When moving in water it pushes the water back, and so does not advance so much. The difference between the advance of the ship in movable material, such as water, and in an immovable material in relation to the total movement in the latter case, is called the slip ratio. If we make a series of experiments of this kind on the same 1 Trans. I.N.A., 1886. 70 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. propeller we should get for each speed of ship a curve of forward push called thrust and a curve of turning effort usually Rrrolutions of Jcrew pv S I? 16 20 24 28 32 Slip per Cenr Fig. 92. Model Propeller Experiments. S Blades. -200 Width ratio. " E," Curves of efficiency for constant value of " S." " P," Curves of pitch ratio for constant value of " S." 36 slip ratio. For example in fig. 91, which gives the E and P curves for two-bladed propellers of *2 width ratio, the S values chosen range from *2 to 2 '0. The following table gives the maximum efficiencies and the corresponding pitch ratios and slip ratios for each selected value of S : 90 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. Value of S. Maximum Efficiency. Pitch Ratio. Slip per cent. 2-0 65 625 28'2 1-5 677 705 26-0 1-25 69-5 76 24-5 1-0 71-6 825 22'9 75 74-9 92 20-3 6 77-0 99 18-5 5 78-8 1-06 16-8 4 80-6 1-14 15-0 3 82-2 1-25 13-0 25 83-2 1-35 11-3 2 84-0 1-465 10-0 The figures in the above table have been plotted on a base of S value. The curves are shown in diagram 98. For each of the figs. 91 to 97 a similar table was made, and the results plotted. Fig. 99 gives the results for all the three-bladed propellers, and fig. 100 shows the curves for all the four- bladed propellers. These figures, 98, 99, and 100, are final diagrams, and can be made use of directly to determine the maximum efficiency, the pitch ratio, and the slip ratio corresponding to maximum efficiency for any given value of S. Suppose that for any given value of S we have determined E, P, and s (slip ratio) from the final diagram. Let the diameter which has been selected to give S be D. Then the pitch p = P x D and pR(l-s) = V(101'33); Y(101-33) We can thus obtain the revolution corresponding to maximum efficiency for any given value of S. CF SCREW PROPELLERS. 91 It will be seen from the figures that the very best three- bladed propeller may have an efficiency as high as about 80 per cent., while the very best four-bladed only reaches about 75 per cent. The pitch and area ratios of this three-bladed pro- peller are about 1/6 and '28 (of disc area), while in the four- bladed these values are 1-1 and '24 respectively. 12 16 20 24- Slip per cent 23 36 4-0 Fig. 93. Model Propeller Experiments. 3 Blades. -275 Width ratio. " E," Curves of efficiency for constant value of "8." " P," Curves of pitch ratio for constant value of " S." It will also be seen that in both the three- and four- bladed propellers maximum efficiency is consistent with a very large range of pitch ratio, and corresponds in the three-bladed to about 12 per cent, slip ratio and in the four-bladed to 13 per cent, slip ratio. Of course the value of the maximum efficiency will vary very much with pitch 92 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. ratio, but the position of it in relation to slip will not alter. It may be interesting to notice that as between the three- and four-bladed propellers, while maximum efficiency occurs at about the same slip ratio, i.e. at about the same revolu- tions in the same diameter propellers, that the corresponding 8 // 16 20 Slip per Cent Fig. 94. Model Propeller Experiments. 3 Blades. -35 Width ratio. " E," Curves of efficiency for constant value of " S." " P," Curves of pitch ratio for constant value of " S." area ratios are "27 and '36, the excess of the latter over the former being simply that due to the extra blade, viz. about one- third. The effect of this extra blade only seems to be to detract from efficiency, as it lowers the maximum possible from 80 per cent, in the three-bladed to 75 per cent, in the four-bladed. SCREW PROPELLERS. 93 It has been shown that the values of S increase with decrease in pitch ratio, i.e. increase of diameter ratio, ranging in four-bladed propellers having jnarrow blades (of, say, area ratio -17) from 'I at pitch ratio of 1'Q to I'O at pitch ratio of -4, and in broad blades (say, of area ratio of *65) from so 70 16 20 51 ip per Cent Fig. 95. Model Propeller Experiments. 4 Blades. '125 Width ratio. " E," Curves of efficiency for constant value of "S." " P," Curves of pitch ratio for constant value of " S." 1 to 2'0. These are very significant figures, and show the wide range of power absorption of different propellers. The value of S, except for small areas, increases with increase of area ratio for the same pitch ratio, the rate of increase being much greater for small pitch ratios than for large. Taking these two statements together, it is seen that to get 94 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. a large value of S small pitch- ratios and large area ratios are necessary. Having described these curves we may now, by concrete examples, see their application to screw propellers. Let us take the case of a vessel having three screws driven by three 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 ?--^~~ P,-- "P-- 16 8 12 16 20 24 28 32 36 Slip per Cent Fig. 96. Model Propeller Experiments. 4 Blades. "2 Width ratio. " E," Curves of efficiency for constant value of " S. " " P," Curves of pitch ratio for constant value of " S." turbines or other motors, each capable of giving off 3000 H.P. to each screw shaft and collectively driving the vessel at 23 knots. From the formula G = '00312rcSD 2 V 3 we get 3000 = -00312 x 3 x S x D 2 x 23 3 : SCREW PROPELLERS. 95 This is a similar expression to the value D 2 obtained earlier in this paper. From this value, if we choose D, we can find a value for S. It is better to select different values for D and to draw curves of efficiency, pitch, slip, and revolution in terms of D. The A? 16 20 24 28 31 ip per Cent- Fig. 97. Model Propeller Experiments. 4 Blades. -275 Width ratio. " E," Curves of efficiency for constant value of " S." " P," Curves of pitch ratio for constant value of " S." 31 36 most favourable propeller to the given set of conditions can therefore be obtained. Selecting values of D from 4 to 10 feet we obtain values of S at which we can set up ordinates in the final curves. The following table shows how the results are obtained : 96 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. Kevo. D. S. E. Slip. P. Pitch p(l-s). R VxlOl'33 p. p(l-s) 4 1-65 60'5 37'2 92 3-68 2-32 1008 5 1-05 65-0 33-0 1-06 5'30 3-55 655 6 73 69-0 29-6 1-185 7-11 5-00 466 7 536 71-4 267 1-275 8'92 6-55 356 8 411 73-5 24'2 1-340 10'72 8-10 288 9 325 75-0 21-8 1-380 12-42 9-72 240 10 263 76-0 19'5 1-410 14-10 11-38 205 80 70 60 50 40 JO 20 10 1 / -/ /* 13 12 / / 1-1 / / I'D 6 32 ^ 90 -9 ^^. **2^ __ ' 80 _7 28^ . -_^ ---' ""* : ^~~~ 6*"?# ^==^ ~~~ _ ETFjcj. ~~ ^' * / /j eJlJL~ ' ___ - Z5 24 70 ? 60 6 5 20 " 26 "^^ 20 50 5 4 16 ^^ \ 16 9-0 '4 3 12 \ 2 30 -3 2 6 8 20 2 'I 4- 4 10 7 'ZSiTf. ill i o &-8-S ^yfn t]a;$ 20 15 1-25 10 Value of'S" 75 6 '5 4- 'J 252 Fig. 98. Model Propeller Experiments. ( maximum efficiency) Curves of -I pitch ratio } for two-bladed propellers. '200 Width ratio, (slip ) " S " obtained from formula G= '00312nSD2V3. SCREW PROPELLERS. The first column gives the diameters that have been selected. The corresponding values of S are put in the next column. We are now left to choose width ratio. In this case the width ratio -275 has been chosen. We therefore get our results from diagram 99, and the series of '275 curves. Setting up ordinates 2-0 1-25 10 Value of"S" 75 -6 5 -4 3-252 /5 Fig. 99. Model Propeller Experiments. (200 Width ratio. (maximum efficiency) ('200 Curves of -4 pitch ratio > for three-bladed propellers. -('275 ,, (slip ) (-350 " S " obtained from formula G = -00312nSD2V3. at the values of S given in the second column, we can read off the results for E the maximum efficiency, s the slip, and P the pitch ratio. These results have been tabulated in the next three columns. Multiplying P by D, we get the pitch in feet p. The sixth column gives the values of the pitch. 7 98 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. t CQ CO SCREW PROPELLERS. 99 5 6 7 8 9 10 II 12 13 14- Diameter in Feet Fig. 102. 4500 I.H.P. in each Propeller having three Blades. Selected width ratio = -275. Selected area ratio = -4427. Speed = 23 knots. 10 12 /4- 16 Diameters in Feet Fig. 103. 8000 T.H.P. in each Propeller having three Blades. Selected width ratio = '275. Selected area ratio = '4427. Speed = 19 knots. 100 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. SCREW PROPELLERS. 101 In the seventh column the values of p (1 s) have been put, and the last column is the revolutions which are calculated i'rom fl . , D 101-33xV the formula K= - These results have been plotted in curves in terms of D, and are shown in diagram 101. Other examples are given. Fig. 102 shows the curves for the propellers of the same 12 13 14 IS 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24- 25 26 Diameters in Feet. Fig. 105. 12,000 I.H.P. to each Propeller having three Blades. Selected width ratio = '275. Selected area ratio = '4427. Speed = 19 knots. vessel, only in this case there are two screws ; the I.H.P. per screw is therefore 4500. The speed being the same, we get in this case an SD 2 value of 39*6. Fig. 103 shows the curves for the case of a vessel of 24,000 I.H.P. There are three propellers, each three-bladed. Fig. 104 shows the curves for two different cases of large vessels, each with four screws. Fig. 105 shows the curves for the propellers of the same vessel as in fig. 103, only in this case there are two screws ; I.H.P. per screw therefore is 12,000. The speed is the same as before. CHAPTEE V. COMBINATION OF TURBINE AND PROPELLER. HAVING shown the relation between revolutions, efficiency, and diameter in a propeller, we may consider the effect of combining the various sizes of propellers with suitable turbines. We may first consider the general effect of revolutions upon turbine efficiency. The losses in a turbine may be classed under the following heads : Friction. Steam shock. Leakage by clearance at ends of blades. The first loss depends on velocity of steam through the blades and the surface of blades. Assuming the same internal con- dition, viz. the shape and spacing of blades, variation of revolutions has no effect on friction. We have seen that increase of diameter and reduction of revolutions decrease the length of blade but increase the number in the same propor- tion, so that with the same speed of steam and periphery there is no difference in blade friction. Whatever loss may be due to friction on the surface of the casing or drum, will increase with the diameter. The loss due to friction is not the energy necessary to overcome the resistance, because some of the energy comes back in the form of heat. Hence the difference of this loss between the large and small diameters, and the consequent small and large number of revolutions, is small. 102 TURBINE AND PROPELLER. 103 The difference of loss due to steam shock, with same internal conditions, may be neglected. The difference of loss due to leakage by clearance at the ends may be considered as varying with the ratio of the annular area of clearance to the remaining annular area. We have seen that the annular area for a given H. P. and steam speed is constant for varying revolutions and diameter. The clearances may be expected to vary as the diameters, as it is only on account of possible variations in the actual amount of these clearances that they exist at all. If there could be such per- fection in the relation between the ends of the blades and the adjacent surfaces of drum or casing that the clearance would always be a known definite amount, that amount could be made practically nil. But this is impossible for practical reasons, since the larger the diameter of drum and casing, the greater ought the clearance to be, as the causes which tend to make the ends of the blades change their position relatively to the drum or casing, will be intensified with increase of diameter. But the loss will be in proportion to the ratio of the clearance to length of blade. Hence as length of blade decreases, and clearance increases with increase of diameter, the ratio of loss increases as the square of the increase of diameter. Assuming the actual loss to vary as the ratio of clearance to length of blade, it is easy to calculate the loss of efficiency in terms of revolutions and so get a combined efficiency of turbine and propeller as shown below. The results for a channel steamer are : Propeller, . Per cent, clearance loss in turbine, Diameter in feet. Revolutions. Efficiency. 4 6 8 10 982 480 300 203 61 68'5 4-8 72'8 12-0 75-5 1-1 26-5 Nett efficiency, 59-9 637 60-8 49-0 104 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. With reference to the matter of economy of the turbine as applied to marine purposes, there is still a great deal of conflict of evidence. Taking the few cases in which ships of similar form, having boilers the same, have been tested for water consumption, I may state the following : ' ' King Edward " : Mr James Denny, in comparing the "King Edward" with a twin-screw triple-expansion engine, said the best that could possibly have been done was 19*7 knots in the latter, against 20 '5 actually got from the "King Edward. " Of this j%ths of a knot, T%ths is due to the lighter machinery and y^-ths to the turbine, and that, while the gross gain due to the adoption of the turbine was 20 per cent. , the relative efficiency of turbines and reciprocating engines with their accompanying propellers is 15 per cent. No statement of speed on service in relation to speed on the mile and its relative consumption has been published. The Midland Eailway boats, designed by the author's firm, were four in number. Three of these were exactly identical in form and construction, and with the fourth there was so little difference as not to interfere with the comparison. Two of these were fitted with turbines and two with reciprocating engines. One of the vessels with turbines and the two vessels with recipro- cating engines were the three that were identical in every other respect, except that the boilers of the turbine were 150 Ibs. against 200 Ibs. in the reciprocating engines. They were all tried on the measured mile at Skelmorlie, at draughts corresponding to the same load. They were also each tried continuously for six hours, and during both trials the number of strokes of the feed pumps was recorded. These feed pumps were exactly the same in construction, and gave reliable com- parative results. In a paper read by the author before the British Association in 1905, the following statement was made: TURBINE AND PROPELLER. 105 " The ' Londonderry ' has turbine power sufficient to obtain the same speed as the vessel with reciprocating engines. The weight of machinery is less, and the saving in the weight reduces the displacement and the resistance of the vessel so that the power required for the desired speed is less. This ad- vantage to the turbine shows in its first cost as well as in the cost of running, and it leaves the comparison with the recipro- cating engine as one which includes in favour of the turbine the incidental advantage due to its light weight. One of the savings in weight in the ' Londonderry ' was in the boilers, which, though of the same size and number as the other vessels, had a reduced pressure of 150 Ibs. instead of 200 Ibs. In the case of the other turbine vessel, the * Manxman,' the same saving in weight was not made, but a more powerful turbine was put in, and the boiler pressure was not reduced as in the "Londonderry." By this arrangement the greatest power which the boilers could give was obtained, regardless of the weight of the turbine, instead of, as in the other case, the smallest weight for a given power. The net result was a maximum gain in speed of three-quarters of a knot, which, if the efficiency in the other two ships were the same, is the equivalent of a gain of 14 per cent, of power when the extra resistance due to the extra weight is allowed for. It is difficult to determine how much of this gain is due to the turbines, as the propellers were different in the three ships, and probably had different efficiencies. But from the result of steam-con- sumption observations, it appears that at about the maximum speed of 22 knots of the ' Londonderry,' the slower vessel, the extra power required was more, while the resistance was less, the net difference in efficiency of turbine and propeller being at least 12 per cent, in favour of the 'Manxman,' the faster vessel." Taking the results without any qualifications, and at the speed for which the vessel was designed, the mean of the 106 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. turbine compares with the mean of the reciprocating engine with an advantage of 15 per cent, for the former. The next case in which results of exhaustive experiments were published were those of the ' ' Amethyst ' ' and ' ' Topaz, ' ' both of the same displacement, form, boiler installation, etc. , the comparison of the results being in favour of the turbine vessel. At 22 knots (the maximum speed for which water consumption is given in the reciprocating engine vessel) the figures are 22 against 14. Inasmuch as these figures repre- sent Ibs. per I. H. P. , the horse-power being that of the " Topaz," it seems as if there is something radically extravagant in the "Topaz," as the Boiler Committee reported that the total consumption per I. H. P. in the ' ' Hyacinth " and ' c Minerva " averages about 17 '5 Ibs. , while in the ' ' Saxonia " it was 14 '5 Ibs. It cannot therefore be said that the comparative results obtained in the "Amethyst" are of much value. Curves of I.H.P., coal and water consumed in Ibs. per I. H. P. per hour, are given in fig. 106. Other results have been published, Mr Speakman giving a comparison between T.B.D.'s to 25 knots, showing a gain in favour of the turbine of 6 per cent. Mr Grade of Fairfield has furnished comparative information of the coal consumption of two steam yachts, one with turbines and the other with recipro- cating engines. He gives the maximum coal consumption at full power in the case of the turbines as being about 1*83 Ibs., and in the ordinary vessel 2 '18 Ibs., which is an advantage of about 17 per cent, in favour of the turbine. When we come to service conditions, however, it is a little difficult to confirm the trial advantages. The table appended shows some results in the form of tons of coal per knot, and also tons of coal per knot in proportion to the power required for driving the vessel. The following results were given in the author's paper for the British Association : TURBINE AND PROPELLER. 107 jnot/ Jac/^H'l Jdd-sqi ut -idu/nsuoj /eoj JQJ aieos i 108 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. Per passenger certified to be carried. Dimensions. Coal per H.P. Speed in knots. Coal No. of EP Oil Cost of coal burnt. . Jx. staff. used. E.R. staff. "Queen" 323' x 43' 1-00 i-oo 1-00 1-00 I'OO 21-00 B. 324' x 35' 1-43 1-74 2-03 2-97 1-8 18'00 C. 280' x 35' 1'25 1-25 1-47 2-47 1-34 18-50 D. 313' x 36' 1-9 2-07 1-73 2'69 2-06 17-50 The figures given, except in the case of speed, are not absolute but only comparative. Mr R. J. Walker of the Parsons Company has given the following table, somewhat on the same lines for vessels on the same route. The " Viking " is a turbine steamer. The others are reciprocating. "Viking." B. C. D. Length, .... 350 feet 360 feet 330 feet 265 feet Breadth, .... 42 42 ,, 39 34 ,, Draught, . 11 ,, 13 10 ft. 6 in. 10 ft. 6 in. Displacement tons, 2400 2940 1520 Gross tonnage, . 1990 2140 1657 937 No. of passengers certified to carry, 1950 1994 1546 901 Total mileage per season knots, . . . ' . 8880 7870 9577 12,072 Coal per season tons, 4206 4833 4208 3833 Average speed of service knots, .... 22'2 20 19 17 No. of engineers, includ- ) ing greasers, . . ) 4 engineers 3 greasers 5 engineers 5 greasers 1 fanman 4 engineers 2 greasers 3 engineers 3 greasers Type of machinery, . turbines -{ 3-cylinder compound 2-cylinder compound twin-screw triple ex- ( paddle paddle pansion Tons of coal per knot, 472 614 439 317 RECIPROCATING ENGINE VERSUS TURBINE. 109 A comparison was given in the author's British Association paper of 1905, in the form of the following table, but the actual figures now given are for a comparison extending over the whole time during 1905 on which the vessels were running together. R reciprocating. Antrim. Lon. Lon. Don. Don. Man. Man. Antrim. T turbine. R. T. T. R. R. T. T. R. No. of trips, . . 72 72 78 78 26 26 21 21 Average coal per trip (tons), . 38-9 39-4 39-2 39-6 40'1 40'9 39-0 38-3 Average speed in knots, . . 20-0 197 19-9 19-3 19'3 20-5 20 4 19-6 Speed 2 . . .1 10-3 9-8 10-1 9-4 9-0 10'2 10-6 10-0 Coal consumed j Coal consumed per cent, in favour of, . . 4'8 ... 6-9 ... 117 6-0 Mean per cent, in favour of tur- Londonderry, 1 *0 Manxman, S'8 bines, . . . From these latter figures it will be seen that the economy of 15 per cent, shown on trial has not been borne out in practice, and the important question is what is the cause of this differ- ence. As far as one can determine from the examination of the turbines, they seem to be in exactly the same condition as they were when new. The average speed for the year's running is: reciprocating vesse! 1 = 20'0 knots, turbine vessel = 19*8, reciprocating vesse! 2 = 19'3, but the consumption of coal was not quite the same. The average for the year's running for speeds reduced to the same coal consumption are : reciprocating! 20*0, turbine 197, and reciprocating 2 19*2 knots. On trial the results for same consumption were : reciprocating! 20'0, turbine 20*5, reciprocat- 110 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. ing 2 19*2 knots. The averages at sea as compared with trial remain the same in the two reciprocating engine vessels, but have fallen off very much in the turbine. The author believes that he has put his finger on one principal cause of this inefficiency, and bases his belief on the application of the results of observation on revolutions of propellers at sea to find the extra resistance met with compared with that on trial. It is generally known that slip is the cause of thrust in a propeller. An increase of resistance can only be overcome by an increase of thrust if speed is to remain constant. Thrust can only be increased in the same propeller by increased slip, and is measured by it. It was found that in one of the recipro- cating engine vessels on the voyages in which she was at the same time on service with the other, the average thrust was increased to 1'29 times that necessary on trial to produce the average sea speed of 19*85 knots as against an increase of 1*4 in the other reciprocating engine vessel at 19 '24 knots. When the first reciprocating vessel was on service with the turbine vessel, the ratio of increase of thrust of the former was T23 at 20-12 knots against 2 '43 in the latter at 19'8 knots. The second reciprocating vessel's increase when on service with the turbine was 1"37 at 19'37 knots against 2 -45 in the turbine at 19-86 knots. It should be noticed that at different times the increase in resistance in the various cases is nearly identical for individual ships; 1'29 and 1'23 for the first reciprocating vessel, 1-4 and T37 for the second reciprocating, and 2'43 and 2 -45 for the turbine vessel in the two cases. The number of runs in each case was from 50 to 70, a sufficient number to form a reliable average. The extra resistance of ship must really be the same in all the cases. The increased amount of the thrust may not all be real in the reciprocating vessels, but it . shows a striking difference between these and the turbine, substantially 1^ to 2J, which is an increase of 33 per cent, as against 150 per cent. Naturally the first suggestion is that the 5 feet RECIPROCATING ENGINE VERSUS TURBINE. Ill propellers of the turbine are much less efficient than the 11 feet propellers of the other vessels, when the extra resist- ance of service, whatever it may be, is operative; but it is easy to calculate the difference of efficiency, and it is negli- gible compared with the difference of 1J and 2J, and some other cause must be found for this result. If the pressures per unit of turbine propeller area on trial be estimated, it is found that on the official trial at 2T6 knots it is represented by 13'25, while at 20 knots on trial it is ll'O. If we increase the figure 11 in the same ratio that the service resistance of the recipro- cating vessels is increased, viz. 1J, it becomes 14*6, which is in excess of that reached on trial. This points to the extreme probability of cavitation as the cause of the enormous increase of slip on service. Some confirmation of this is given by the fact that during the trials a speed of 22*3 knots was ob- tained with evidence of cavitation, and at a pressure represented by about 14'2. It seems therefore extremely probable that on service the pressures are much greater than on trial, and that at times cavitation takes place. The failure to reproduce on service, in the turbine vessel, the advantage of 15 per cent, obtained on trial, seems to be adequately explained by ineffi- ciency of propeller without any suspicion of defect on the part of the turbine itself. This is to some extent confirmed by the fact that in another turbine vessel on the same trade the inefficiency of the propeller is evident, but in a less marked degree, as the pressures on trial were much lower. It should be noted that the average extra thrust must be made up of many results in which the individual thrust must be much higher, in some cases, than the average, and in which cavitation must be very marked. In other turbine vessels which have been successfully running they have had no similar reciprocating vessels on exactly the same service, or if they have, the results are not available for comparison. There seems good reason to conclude that the 112 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. turbine vessels would have been more efficient 'performers at sea if they had been less efficient on trial, and the desire to obtain high-speed results on the measured mile has caused loss of efficiency on service. There is also reason to believe that this can be avoided in future and corrected in existing vessels. It may be of use and interest to give some idea of the relative weight of turbine and reciprocating machinery in different types of vessels. Table A gives this for channel steamers in terms of tons per I. H. P. ; Atlantic liners are also included. It TABLE A. MACHINERY WEIGHTS OF CHANNEL STEAMERS. Knots. I.H.P. Tons per I.H.P. Engines. Total. Turbines, 21 to 23 5000 to 10,000 021 075 Reciprocating, 20 to 22 5000 to 8000 04 115 ATLANTIC LINERS. Turbines, 19 to 20 25,000 09 19 Reciprocating, 18 to 19 22,000 10 20 will be noticed that the weight of turbine machinery per I. H.P. in channel steamers is about y^h of a ton, while with recipro- cating engines it is about double, namely, j^o^ n - Table B gives corresponding particulars for warships. These figures are much less than those of channel steamers. There will be a gain in efficiency in the latter class at sea by making larger turbines of lighter construction. The stresses in the revolving drum due to the centrifugal force do not generally exceed one ton per square inch. The outside casings are at present of cast iron, and probably could be made much lighter. The cost of upkeep is inappreciable in a turbine. The owners of the " King Edward " state that the actual repairs since she started running have RECIPROCATING ENGINE VERSUS TURBINE. 113 been nil. The only expense is due to the opening up for inspection every winter to satisfy the Board of Trade. The amount of oil used to make up the supply for the main bearings is about one gallon per month. The total cost of oil for engine- room and auxiliary machinery does not exceed 1 per month. TABLE B AVEIGHTS OF MACHINERY. Vessel. Trial speed (knots). I.H.P. (approx.) Weight in tons per I.H.P. (a) Engines, shafts, and propellers. ( & ) As in (a), plus boilers and water. Reciprocating T.B.D., . 30-00 5,800 0104 0218 55 >> 31-50 7,700 0113 0233 Turbine 37-00 12,000 0060 0157 55 55 32-00 10,500 0073 0169 cruiser, 23*63 14,500 0178 0339 Reciprocating 22-103 9,900 0261 0538 Turbine scout, 24-00 16,000 022 0475 Table C gives data for several turbine steamers. A description of a few of the different types of turbine vessels is given below. The first turbine steamer to be run commercially was the "King Edward" (fig. 107). She plys on the Firth of Clyde, and her average sea speed is about 19 knots, with an average coal consumption, including lighting up, etc., of 18 tons per day. 8 114 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. TABLE C DATA FOR Vessel. Type. L. ft. B. D. Draught. A about. C B. Trial speed. Revolu- tions. ft. ft. ins. ft. ' ' Princesse Elizabeth,' Channel steamer 344 40 23 3 9 2,000 565 24-00 500 " Viking," . " 350 42 25 3 11 2,400 519 23-53 430 "Manxman," . 330 43 25 6 11-66 2,270 480 23-00 542 "Londonderry," " 330 42 25 6 11-5 2,150 472 22-29 664 "Queen Alexandra," Pleasure steamer 270 32 11 6-5 800 499 21-63 750 "King Ed ward," 250 30 10 6 6'0 643 500 20-48 505 "Bingera," Cargo and pass. 300 40-5 19 1 14-5 2,680 534 17-45 590 "Victorian," Atlantic liner 540 60 42 C Trial 13,000 19'5 325 "Dieppe,". Channel steamer 280 34-6 14 6 9-25 1,360 530 21-75 626 "Loongana," . Cargo and pass. 300 43-1 23 12-5 2,500 541 20-00 700 "Carmania," . Atlantic liner 678 72 52 30-0 27,500 64 20-19 185 "Brighton," Channel steamer 280 34 22 9-25 1,260 5 21-00 495 "Queen," . " 310 40 25 9-88 1,750 5 21-26 480 "Onward," 310 40 25 9-88 1,750 5 22-8 440 " Invicta," ' 310 40 25 9-88 1,750 5 23-94 440 TURBINE VESSELS. 115 TURBINE STEAMERS. Equiv. I.H.P. approx. No. of shafts. Screws shaft. Diam. of pro- peller. Aver, service speed. Coal con- sumpt. per knot (tons). Length of service run. Astern speed. Boilers. W.P. No. D. L. ft. ins. ft. ins. ft. ins 10,000 3 1 21-75 357 68 16-2 150 8S.E. 15 11 9,500 3 1 6 6 22-2 472 55 160 4D.E. 15 19 6 9,000 3 >{ 6 2C. 5 7W. | 21-0 325 57 200 /2D.E.) \IS.E.; 15 7 /22 2 \11 5 7,200 3 1 5 19-8 357 110 150 J2D.E.) \IS.E.; 15 6 /22 2 \11 5 4,400 3 1 114 80 150 1D.E. 3,500 3 '{ 4 9C. 3 4W. J19-0 112 80 150 1D.E. 4,500 6 1 160 12,000 3 1 8 8 17-0 180 9S.E. 17 12 6,500 6,000 24,000 6,000 3 3 3 3 1 1 1 1 5 3 5 3 14 63 150 4S.E. 14 9 11 3 195 /8D.E.) \5S.E.f 8,500 3 H 6 2C. 5 8W. } 13-0 150 (2D.E. \ (2S.E. j 14 J 20 6 (10 6 9,000 3 i 6 6 16-0 150 (2D.E.\ 12S.E. / 14 (20 6 (10 6 9,000 3 i 6 6 16-0 150 /2D.E.\ 12S.E. / 14 /20 6 \10 6 116 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. Fig. 108 shows the cross-channel steamer "Queen," which runs between Calais and Dover. She attained a speed of Fig. 107. "King Edward." 21 '76 knots on trial, and she can go astern at 13 knots. In comparison with this we have a sister ship (the ' ' Onward "), built last year, with a trial speed of 22'94 knots and a backing Fig. 108. "Queen." speed due to a lengthened astern turbine of 16 knots. It is worthy of note that the boilers in both these vessels are identical, so it is evident that the gain in speed is due to a better knowledge of turbine construction and design than TURBINE VESSELS. 117 was obtainable when the machinery and propellers of the "Queen" were designed. Fig. 109. " Princess Maud." The next photograph (fig. 109) is the "Princess Maud," built for the Stranraer and Larne service. Fig. 110 shows the "Londonderry," one of the Midland Company's steamers, and Fig. 110. "Londonderry." the one with which the reciprocating engine ships were compared. She attained a speed on trial of 2 2 '3 knots. Fig. Ill shows the second and more powerful of the Midland Company's turbine vessels, the "Manxman." Her trial speed 118 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. bio TURBINE VESSELS. 119 was 23 knots. In fig. 112 is shown a photograph of the model of the same vessel. This gives a good idea of the under - water portion of the ship. The next photograph (fig. 113) shows the channel steamers " Invicta " and "Onward," of which mention has already been made. Fig. 114 is the " Brighton," which runs on the Newhaven and Dieppe route. Fig. 115 shows the stern and propellers of the turbine yacht " Lorena. " This shows very clearly the shape of the propeller blades. Figs. 116 and 117 show the Allan liners " Virginian " and " Victorian." The turbine steamer " Turbinia" Fig. 115. "Lorena," (260 feet x 33 feet x 20 feet 9 inches), fig. 118, is a pleasure steamer built to run on Lake Ontario. She has a draught of 9 feet 6 inches and a displacement Fig. 116. "Virginian." of about 1100 tons, is driven with three shafts, one propeller (4J feet diameter) on each shaft, and has a speed of 19 knots. 120 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. TURBINE VESSELS. 121 She was built to Board of Trade scantlings for channel service, but has made a satisfactory trip across the Atlantic, and was Fig. 121. " Dieppe." the first turbine steamer to trade in America. Her summer service is from Hamilton to Toronto, on Lake Ontario, and her winter service from the mainland to the West Indies. Figs. Fig. 122. "Princesse Elizabeth." 119 and 120 are two turbine vessels for the British India Steam Navigation Company, built to trade between India and the East. The next photograph is that of the " Dieppe" (fig. 121), built for the same service as the " Brighton." Fig. 122 shows the Belgian- 122 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. built steamer " Princesse Elizabeth," which attained a speed on trial of 24 knots, and has astern power to give 16*2 knots. Fig. 123. "Maheno." Figs. 123, 124, and 125 give a very good idea of the " Maheno," belonging to the Union Steamship Company of New Zealand. As an example of the reliability of turbine-running, this vessel, immediately after her trial on the Clyde, left for Dur- ban, 7000 miles, which she reached without a stop, and from there she went direct to Melbourne, a further dis- tance of 5500 miles. A re- sult surely worthy of com- mendation. H.M.S. "Amethyst" (fig. 126) is a third-class cruiser, Fig. 124. Stern of " Maheno." 360 feet x 40 feet x 14 feet 6 inches draught, displace- ment about 3000 tons. Maximum speed 23 '63 knots at 490 revolutions, the equivalent I.H.P. being about 14,000. The propellers are about 6 feet 6 inches diameter. TURBINE VESSELS. 123 < - 124 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. Figs. 127 and 128 are views of the T.B.D. "Viper," which attained a speed of 37'11 knots on trial, but was wrecked during the Fleet manoeuvres on the French coast. A similar vessel is the " Velox" (fig. 129), only she is of 32 '0 knots on trial. Fig. 129. T.B.D. "Velox." The T.B.D. "Eden" (fig. 130) represents another class of torpedo destroyer which originated after the scare produced by Fig. 130. T.B.D. "Eden." the " Cobra " breaking her back at sea. The speed of this class, due to the extra weight for strengthening, has been reduced considerably, the designed speed being 25 knots, but the trial speed was from 1 to 2 knots more. TURBINE VESSELS. 125 With reference to the largest Atlantic liners at present running, fitted with turbine machinery, fig. 131 shows a view of the "Carmania" under easy stearn. She is being tried on service with her sister ship the " Caronia, " whose only difference is that she is fitted with reciprocating machinery. So far no reliable data has been obtained, but it is hoped that these particulars will soon be available. As the German nation had so long held the " blue ribbon " Fig. 131. " Carmania." of the Atlantic for speed and shortest passage, it was thought necessary to take some steps to give back to Britain her old supremacy. After much thought, investigation, and many trials, it was decided by the Cunard Company, aided by Government, to build two large express liners, both to be fitted with Parsons turbines. These vessels, when finished, will be the largest in the world, and will have a speed of 25 knots (fig. 40). The power required for these immense vessels to drive them at this speed will be equivalent to about 70,000 I.H.P. Thus we 126 MARINE STEAM TURBINES. have in the course of nine short years a development in Parsons' marine turbine of from 2000 I.H.P. in the " Turbinia " to the gigantic power required for these leviathans. Surely this is a testimony to the amount of confidence and reliance which is placed in this method of propulsion, and is a worthy tribute to the indomitable perseverance with which Parsons carried on, under so many difficulties, the first experiments which were to give to marine engineering an impetus greater than the world had ever seen. PRINTED BY NKILL AND CO., LTD., EDINBURGH. A SELECTION FROM CHARLES GRIFFIN & CO.'S PUBLICATIONS OF SCIENTIFIC AND TECHNICAL WORKS. MESSES. CHARLES GKIFFIN & COMPANY'S PUBLICATIONS may be obtained through any Bookseller in the United Kingdom, or will be sent Post-free on receipt of a remittance to cover published price. To prevent delay, Orders should be accompanied by a Cheque or Postal Order crossed "UNION OF LONDON AND SMITH'S BANK, Chancery Lane Branch." COMPLETE TECHNICAL, MEDICAL, and GENERAL CATALOGUES forwarded Post-free on Application. LON DON : EXETER STREET, STRAND. 112107. C. 33. 20 CHARLES GRIFFIN & CO. '8 PUBLICATIONS. THIRD EDITION, Revised and Enlarged. Large Crown 8vo, with numerous Illustrations. 33. 6d. THE FLOWERING PLANT, WITH A SUPPLEMENTARY CHAPTER ON FERNS AND MOSSES, As Illustrating the First Principles of Botany. BY J. R. AINSWORTH DAVIS, M.A., F.Z.S., Prof, of Bioloey, University College, Aberystwyth ; Examiner in Zoology, University of Aberdeen. " It would be hard to find a Text-book which would better guide the student to an accurate knowledge of modern discoveries in Botany. . . . The SCIENTIFIC ACCURACY of statement, and the concise exposition of FIRST PRINCIPLES make it valuable for educational purposes. In the chapter on the Physiology of Flowers, an admirable resume, drawn from Darwin, Hermann Mtiller, Kerner, and Lubbock, of what is known of the Fertilization of Flowers, is given."- Joumal of Botany. POPULAR WORKS ON BOTANY BY MRS. HUGHES-GIBB, With Illustrations. Crown 8vo. Cloth. 2s. 6d. HOW PLANTS LIVE AND WORK: A Simple Introduction to Real Life in the Plant-world, Based on Lessons originally given to Country Children. By ELEANOR HUGHES-GIBB. ** The attention of all interested in the Scientific Training of the Young is requested to this DELIGHTFULLY FKESH and CHARMING LITTLE BOOK. It ought to be in the hands of every Mother and Teacher throughout the land. " The child's attention is first secured, and then, in language SIMPLE, YET SCIENTIFICALLY ACCDBATB.the first lessons in plant-life are set before it." Natural Science. " In every way well calculated to make the study of Botany ATTRACTIVE to the young." Scotsman With Illustrations. Crown 8vo. Gilt, 2s. 6d. THE MAKING OF A DAISY j "WHEAT OUT OF LILIES;" And other Studies from the Plant World. A Popular Introduction to Botany. BY ELEANOR HUGHES-GIBB, Author of How Plants Live and Work. " A BRIGHT little introduction to the study of Flowers." Journal of Botany. " The book will afford real assistance to those who can derive pleasure from the study of Nature in the open. . . . The literary style is commendable." Knowledge, LONDON: CHARLES GRIFFIN & CO., LIMITED, EXETER STREET, STRAND, Griffin's Standard Publications Applied Mechanics, . RANKINE, BROWNE, JAMIESON, 35 46*34 Civil Engineering, . . PROP. RANKINE, 35 Design of Structures, . S. ANGLIN, . Bridge-Construction, . PROF. FIDLER, , Design of Beams, . . . W. H. ATHERTON, Dock Engineering, . B. CUNNINGHAM, Engineering Drawing, . S. H. WELLS, . Thermo-Dynamic Prinei- ) T u pies of Engine Design, / L ' HOBBS > Constructional Steelwork, A. W. EARNSWORTH, Central Electrical Stations, C. H. WORDINGHAM, Electricity Control, . L. ANDREWS, ,, Meters, . H. G. SOLOMON, Light Railways, . . W. H. COLE, Sanitary Engineering,. F. WOOD, . Traverse Tables, . . R. L. GURDEN, Locomotive Engineering, W. F. PETTIGREW, Locomotive Compounding, J. F. GAIRNS, Valves and Valve-Gearing, OHAS. HURST, Hints on Design, . . CHAS. HURST, Marine Engineering, . A. E. SEATON, The Steam Turbine, . ALEXANDER JUDE, Marine Steam Turbine, PROF. BILES, Engine-Room Practice, J. G. LIVERSIDGE, Pocket- Book, . . . SEATON AND ROUNTHWAITE, 44 Present Day Shipbuilding, T. WALTON, Design Of Ships, . . PROF. HARVARD BILES Steel Vessels, . . T. WALTON, Stability of Ships, . SIR E. J. REED, The Steam-Engine, . . RANKINE, JAMIESON, Gas, Oil, and Air-Engines, BRYAN DONKIN, Boilers : Land and Marine, T. W. TRAILL, . Steam, . . R. D. MUNRO, . ,, Kitchen, . . R. D. MUNRO, . ,, Heat Efficiency of, BRYAN DONKIN, . Oil Fuel, . . . SIDNEY H. NORTH, Machinery and Millwork, PROF. RANKINE, Pumping Machinery, . H. DAVEY, . Hydraulic Machinery, . PROF. ROBINSON, 38 38 38 38 35,34 28 29 32 32 28 29 35 37 37 Grinding Machinery, . R. B. HODGSON, . 33 Lubrication and Lubricants, ARCHBUTT & DEELEY, 32 Rules and Tables, . RANKINE AND JAMIESON, 36 Bonus Tables, H. A. GOLDING, . . 31 Electrical Poeket-Book, MUNRO AND JAMIESON, 48 The Calculus for Engineers, PROF. ROBT. H. SMITH, 45 Measurement Conversions, PROF. ROBT. H. SMITH, 45 tONDON : CHARLES GRIFFIN & CO., LIMITED, EXETER STREET, STRAND. 26 26 26 27 27 27 26 48 48 49 30 78 31 30 30 31 31 44 28 29 29 26 CHARLES GRIFFIN & CO.'S PUBLICATIONS. FOURTH EDITION, Revised, with Numerous Diagrams, Examples, and Tables, and a Chapter on Foundations. In Large &vo. Cloth. i6s. THE DESIGN OF STRUCTURES: A Practical Treatise on the Building of Bridges, Roofs, &c. BY S. ANGLIN, C.E., Master of Engineering, Royal University of Ireland, late Whitworth Scholar, &c. "We can unhesitatingly recommend this work not only to the Student, as the BEST TBXT-BOOK on the subject, but also to the professional engineer as an EXCEEDINGLY VALUABLE book of reference." Mechanical World. In Large Crown Svo. Handsome Cloth. With 201 Illustrations. 6s. net. AN INTRODUCTION TO THE DESIGN OF BEAMS, GIRDERS, AND COLUMNS IN MACHINES AND STRUCTURES. - With Examples in Graphic Statics. BY WILLIAM H. ATHERTON, M.Sc., M.I.MECH.E. "A very useful source of information. ... A work which we commend very highly." Nature. THIRD EDITION, Thoroughly Revised. Royal %vo. With numerous Illustrations and 13 Lithographic Plates. Handsome Cloth. Price 30$. A PRACTICAL TREATISE ON BRIDGE-CONSTRUCTION: Being a Text-Book on the Construction of Bridges in Iron and Steel. FOR THE USE OF STUDENTS, DRAUGHTSMEN, AND ENGINEERS. BY T. CLAXTON FIDLER, M. INST. C. K, Prof, of Engineering, University College, Dundee "The new edition of Mr. Fidler's work will again occupy the same CONSPICUOUS POSITION among professional text-books and treatises as has been accorded to its pre- decessors. SOUND, SIMPLE, AND FULL." The Engineer. In Meditim Svo. Pp. i-xv + 248, fully Illustrated. Price IDS. 6d. net. CONSTRUCTIONAL STEELWORK : Being Notes on the Practical Aspect and the Principles of Design, together with an Account of the Present Methods and Tools of Manufacture. BY A. W. FARNSWORTH, Associate Member of the Institute of Mechanical Engineers. "A worthy volume, which will be found of much assistance. ... A book of particular value." Practical Engineer. IONDON: CHARLES GRIFFIN & CO,, LIMITED, EXETER STREET. STRAND ENGINEERING AND MECHANICS. 27 In Large 8vo. Handsome Cloth, Gilt, Uniform with Stability of Ships and Steel Ships (p. 38). With 34 Folding Plates and 468 Illustrations in the Text. 30s. net. The Principles and Practice of DOCK ENGINEERING. BY BRYSSON CUNNINGHAM, B.E., Assoc.M.lNST.C.E., Of the Engineers' Department, Mersey Docks and Harbour Board. GENERAL CONTENTS. Historical and Discursive. Dock Design. Constructive Appliances. Materials. Dock and Quay Walls. Entrance Passages and Locks. Jetties, Wharves, and Piers. Dock Gates and Caissons. Transit Sheds and Warehouses. Dock Bridges. Graving and Repairing Docks. Working Equipment of Docks. INDEX. " We have never seen a more profusely-illustrated treatise. It is a most important standard work, and should be in the hands of all dock and harbour engineers." Steamship. "Will be of the greatest service to the expert as a book of reference." Engineer. FOURTH EDITION. In Two Parts, Published Separately. A TEXT-BOOK OF Engineering Drawing and Design. VOL. I. PRACTICAL GEOMETRY, PLANE, AND SOLID. 4s. 6d. VOL. II. MACHINE AND ENGINE DRAWING AND DESIGN. 4s. 6d. BY SIDNEY H. WELLS, Wn.Sc., A.M.I.C.E., A.M.I.MECH.E., Principal of the Battersea Polytechnic Institute, &c. With many Illustrations, specially prepared for the Work, and numerous Examples, for the Use of Students in Technical Schools and Colleges. " A CAPITAL TEXT-BOOK, arranged on an EXCELLENT SYSTEM, calculated to give an intelligent grasp of the subject, and not the mere faculty of mechanical copying. . . . Mr. Wells showa how to make COMPLETE WOEKING-DSAWINGS, discussing fully each step in the design." Electrical Review In Large Crown 8vo. Handsome Cloth. 4s. 6d. net. THE THERMO-DYNAMIC PRINCIPLES OF ENGINE DESIGN. BY LIONEL M. HOBBS, Engineer-Lieutenant, R.N. ; Instructor in Applied Mechanics and Marine Engine Design at the Royal Naval College, Greenwich. CONTENTS. Laws and Principles of Thermo-Dynamics. Hot-Air Engines. Gas and Oil Engines. Refrigerating Machines. Transmission of Power by Compressed Air. The Steam Engine. Unresisted Expansion and Flow through Orifices. Flow of Gases along Pipes. Steam Injectors and Ejectors. Steam Turbines. APPENDICES. INDEX. LONDON: CHARLES GRIFFIN & CO,, LIMITED, EXETER STREET, STRAND- 28 CHARLES GJtlFFIN & CO.'S PUBLICATIONS. In Handsome Cloth. With 252 Illustrations. 155. net. THE THEORY OF THE STEAM TURBINE. MTreatise on the Principles of Construction of the Steam Turbine, with Historical Notes on its Development. BY ALEXANDER JUDE. CONTENTS Fundamental. Historical Notes on Turbines. The Velocity of Steam. Types of Steam Turbines. Practical Turbines. The Efficiency of Turbines, Type I. Trajectory of the Steam. Efficiency of Turbines, Types II., III. and IV. Turbine Vanes. Disc and Vane Friction in Turbines. Specific Heat of Superheated Steam. Strength of Rotating Discs. Governing Steam Turbines. Steam Consumption of Turbines. The Whirling of Shafts. Speed of Turbines. INDEX. " One of the latest books . . . also one of the best . . . there is absolutely no 1 padding ' cannot fail to secure a prominent and permanent position in the literature of the subject." Sir William White in the Times Engineering Supplement. Works by BRYAN DONKIN, M.Inst.C.E., M.Inst.Meeh.E., &c. Now READY. FOURTH EDITION, Revised and Enlarged. With additional Illustrations. Large 8vo, Handsome Cloth. 255. net. A TREATISE ON GAS, OIL, AND AIR ENGINES. BY BRYAN DONKIN, M.INST.C.E., M.INST.MECH.E. CONTENTS. PART I. Gas Engines : General Description of Action and Parts. Heat Cycles and Classification of Gas Engines. History of the Gas Engine. The Atkinson, Griffin, and Stockport Engines. The Otto Gas Engine. Modern British Gas Engines. Modern French Gas Engines. German Gas Engines. Gas Production for Motive Power. Utilisation of Blast-furnace and Coke-oven Gases for Power. The Theory of the Gas Engine. Chemical Composition of Gas in an Engine Cylinder. Utilisation of Heat in a Gas Engine. Explosion and Combustion in a Gas Engine. PART II. Petrpleum Engines : The Discovery, Utilisation, and Properties of Oil. Method of Treating Oil. Carburators. Early Oil Engines. Practical Application of Gas and Oil Engines. PART III. Air Engines. APPBNDICHS. INDEX. ''The best book now published on Gas, Oil, and Air Engines." Engineer. In Quarto, Handsome Cloth. With Numerous Plates. 255. THE HEAT EFFICIENCY OF STEAM BOILERS (LAND, MARINE, AND LOCOMOTIVE). With many Tests and Experiments on different Types of Boilers, as to the Heating Value of Fuels, &e., with Analyses of Gases and Amount of Evaporation, and Suggestions for the Testing of Boilers. BY BRYAN DONKIN, M.INST.C.E. GENERAL CONTENTS. Classification of Different Types of Boilers. 425 Experiments on English and Foreign Boilers with their Heat Efficiencies shown in Fifty Tables. Fire Grates of Various Types. Mechanical Stokers. Combustion of Fuel in Boilers. Trans- mission of Heat through Boiler Plates, and their Temperature. Feed Water Heaters, Superheaters, Feed Pumps, &c. Smoke and its Prevention. Instruments used in Testing Boilers. Marine and Locomotive Boilers. Fuel Testing Stations. Discussion of the Trials and Conclusions. On the Choice of a Boiler, and Testing of Land, Marine, and Locomotive Boilers. Appendices. Bibliography. INDEX. With Plates illustrating Progress made dtiring recent years> and the best Modem Practice. "Probably the MOST EXHAUSTIVE resume' that has ever been collected. A PRACTICAL BOOK by a thoroughly practical man." Iron and Coal Trades Review. LONDON; CHARLES GRIFFIN & CO.. LIMITED, EXETER STREET, STRAND, ENGINEERING AND MEGHANWi*. 29 In Large Crown 8vo. Handsome Cloth. With 131 Illustrations. 6s. net. LECTURES ON THE MARINE STEAM TURBINE, BY PROF. J. HARVARD BILES, Professor of Naval Architecture in the University of Glasgow. *' Thoroughly up to date and contains all the latest information." Steamship. FOURTH EDITION, Revised. Pocket-Size, Leather, 12s. 6d. BOILERS, MARINE AND LAND: THEIR CONSTRUCTION AND STRENGTH, A HANDBOOK OF RULES, FORMULAE, TABLES, &c., RELATIVE TO MATERIAL, SCANTLINGS, AND PRESSURES, SAFETY VALVES, SPRINGS, FITTINGS AND MOUNTINGS, &o. FOR THE USE OF ENGINEERS, SURVEYORS, BOILER -MAKERS, AND STEAM USERS. BY T. W. TRAILL, M. INST. 0. E., F. E. K N. f Late Engineer Surveyor-in-Chief to the Board of Trade. S" Contains an ENORMOUS QUANTITY OF INFORMATION arrranged in a very convenient form. . . . A MOST USEFUL VOLUME . . . supplying information to be had nowhere else." ZVie Engineer. FIFTH EDITION. Large Crown 8vo. With numerous Illustrations. 6s. net. ENGINE-ROOM PRACTICE: A Handbook for Engineers and Officers in the Royal Navy and Mercantile Marine, Including 1 the Management of the Main and Auxiliary Engines on Board Ship. BY JOHN G. LIVERSIDGE, E.N., A.M.I.C.E. Contents. General Description of Marine Machinery. The Conditions of Service and Duties of Engineers of the Royal Navy Entry and Conditions of Service of Engineers of the Leading 8.S. Companies. Raising Steam Duties of a Steaming Watch on Engines nd Boilers. Shutting off Steam, Harbour Duties and Watches. Adjustments and Repairs of Engines. Preservation and Repairs of "Tank" Boilers. The Hull and ita Fittings. Cleaning and Painting Machinery. Reciprocating Pumps, Feed Heaters, and Automatic Feed - Water Regulators. Evaporators. Steam Boats. Electric Light Machinery. Hydraulic Machinery. Air-Compressing Pumps. Refrigerating Machines, Machinery of Destroyers. The Management of Water-Tube Boilers. Regulations for Entry of Assistant Engineers, R.N. Questions given in Examinations for Promotion of Jfingineers, R.N. Regulations respecting Board of Trade Examinations for Engineers. &c. " This VERY USKFUL BOOK. . . . ILLUSTRATIONS are Of GREAT IMPORTANCE in a WOfk of this kind, and it is satisfactory to find that SPECIAL ATTENTION has been given in this respect." Engineers' Gazette. In Large Crown Svo, Cloth. Fully Illustrated. 5s. net. OIL FUEL: ITS SUPPLY, COMPOSITION, AND APPLICATION. BY SIDNEY H. NORTH, LATE EDITOR OF THE "PETROLEUM REVIEW.' CONTENTS. The Sources of Supply. Economic Aspect of Liquid Fuel. Chemical Composition of Fuel Oils. Conditions of Combustion in Oil Fuel Furnaces. Early Methods and Experiments. Modern Burners and Methods. Oil Fuel for Marine Pur- poses. For Naval Purposes. On Locomotives. For Metallurgical and other Purposes. Appendices. -INDEX. " Everyone interested in this important question will welcome Mr. North's excellent text-book." Nature. LONDON: CHARLES GRIFFIN & CO., LIMITED, EXETER STREET, STRAND, 30 CHARLES GRIFFIN