A Al = ^ ^^S 33 i ^^S 33 4 = GION 1 6 = == r — 4 = 3) 1 = ==^ 33 7 ^ :^=^= -n 7 ^ = 5 U.S. Architect of Public Biiildings Report 1651/52 THE LIBRARY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LOS ANGELES aBONia laiHdwvd if'' ■^ REPORT OF THE ARCHITECT OF PUBLIC BUILDINGS, ACCOMPANYING THE PRESIDENT'S MESSAGE AT THE SECOND SESSION OF THE THIRTY-SECOND, CONGRESS. WASiriNCiTON: ROBERT ARMSTRONG, PRINTER. UBL REPORT OF THE ARCHITECT OF PUBLIC BUILDIXGS. Architect's Office, United States Capitol, Washington, D. C, December 1, 1852. Sir : In conformit}'' to a resolution of the Senate of the United States, passed August 26, 1852, I have the honor to lay before you the i'oUowing "nbstract or compendium" of my annual report, which is herewith submitted : Extension of the Capitol. The appropriation for continuing the w-ork not having been made until the 3 4th of April last, the buildings are not as far advanced as I inticipated at the date of my last annual report. The contracts all being limited to existing appropriations, the contractors were not at liberty to make preparations for supplying materials until after the passage of the bill. As soon as the appro])riation was made, the contractors promptly commenced operations, and the work has since been prosecuted as rapidly as a proper regard for its permanency, durability, and beauty would warrant. The cellars of both wings are completed, the arches to support the basement floors ai'e finished, and the outside marble work is })rogrcss- ing raj)idly. All the foundations are permanently laid on the natural, undisturbed earth ; some of them are 40 f^'t deep, and none less than 15 feet below the ground line of the building.* The character of the earth un- der all the walls is the sameythroughout, being a stratum of compact gravel of several feet in tliickness* The walls are all built widi great care, and the entire sub-structure is massive and solid;* The stones of which these foundations are constructed were tested, at the recjuest of a speci;il committee ol" th cubic fix-t, bciug an average of 1,487 cubic li^et per week. Jiefore this marble was adoj)led, it was tested by a commission ap[)ointed for the purpose, and their report is hereto annexed. in coriformitv to the proviso contained in the first section f>f the art of Congress approved August iJl, 1852, I appoint(ul Mr. John C. Harkness as measurer of all the work and materials of the ext(Mision of the Ca[)itf)l, and Mr. Cornelius .Jiieobs receiver of materials f()r the north wing, and Mr. Willi;ini J. Smith on the south wing; all of whoui were duly sworn into oiliee. All the work done, and materials fnrnished by contract, have since been measured by Mr. Harkness, and no further payments were madev until the measurement was reported to this office, in conformity to tb«- aforesaid act of Congress. 4 Tlio whdlc amount nppropriatod, thus far, for the exten- sion of the Cai)itol is $000,000 00 And tlio total amount cxpondt-d to this date (December 1, 185:2) is 495,799 97 Leaving an unexpended balance of. 104,200 03 There \vill be recjuired to carry on the work during the })resent fiscal vear, ending June 30, 1S53, the addi- tional sum of. '. $400,000 00 And during the ensuing fiscal j'ear, ending June 30, 1S54, 600,000 00 Making 1,000,000 00 Library of Congress. On the 27th of January last I submitted designs for reconstructing the main library room, with arrangements for future extension, which were adopted, and on the 19th of March an appropriation of $72,500 was made to carry out the plans. Tlie work was immediately com- menced, and every possible exertion has been made to complete it before the assembling of Congress ; it will, however, be ouf of our power to finish it entirely for several weeks to come, notwithstanding the workmen have been constantly and cn(Tgetically employed, night and day. The entire room is fitted up with iron, and the ceiling is composed of the same material, so that nothing combustible enters in any way into its construction. The damage done by the fire to the western front has all been re- paired. The hot water furnaces, for warming the library and the adjacent rooms are completed and in operation. The appropriation made for " the repairs .jf the Congres- sional Library,'' by the act of Congress a})proved March 19, 1S52, amounted to $72,500 00 Of which there have been exj)cnded to the present date (December 1, 1S52) 51,703 24 Leaving an unexpended balance of. 20,790 76 The Patent Office Buildings. The interior of the eastern wing is nearly completed ; the basement and principal stories are now ready for occupancy. The hot water furnaces are completed and ready to be put in oj)eration. The eastern portico is far advanced to completion, and may be finished in a few weeks. The work has been resumed on the western wing, and the granite sub-basement is now being constructed. THOMAS U. WALTER, Architect of FuOlic Buildings. Hon. Alex. H. H. Stuart, Secretary of the Interior. Architect's Office, United States Capitol, Washington, D. C, December 1, 1S52. Sir : I have the honor to lay before you the following report of the state of the public works under my charge, and their progress during the past year ; Extension of the Capitol. The appropriation for continuing the work on the Capitol not having been made until the 14th of April last, the buildings are not in the state of forwardness I anticipated at the date of my last annual report. The contractors for furnishing materials were not at liberty, during the pen- dency of the bill, to make any arrangements for prosecuting the work, as the contracts all contain an express stipulation that " in case Congress should, at any time, ffiil to make the appropriations necessary to carry on the work, the said contracts shall be suspended, without thereby creating any claim on the United States." No preparations were, therefore, made for quarrying building- stone for the foundations, granite for the sub-basement, or marble for the su- perstructure, until after the passage of the bill, so that we can scarcely be said to have been in full operation until the middle of the season. Immediately after Congress had made the appropriation, the contract- ors promptly commenced the execution of their several contracts, and the most energetic means were used throughout the remainder of the season to accelerate the work as rapidly as was consistent with a proper execution of its several parts, and a due regard for its perma- nency, durability, and beauty. The cellar walls of both wings are completed, tlic arches to support the floors of the basement story are finished, and the outside marble work is progressing rapidly and satisfactorily ; the setting of the marble has been commenced, and the walls are raised, in some places, to the height of twelve feet above the granite sub-basement. Provision is made throughout the entire sub-structure for the system of warming the buildings, described in my last annual report, and all the necessary flues are commenced in accordance tlicrewith. All the foundations have permanent footings on the natural, undis- turbed earth; ni;my of tlicm are laid at the depth of ^/V;/ tl-ct, and none of tln;rii less \.\v,n\ fifteen feet Ix-low the ground line of the buildings. This inequality of depth was rendered necessary by the slope of the original hill on which the Caj)ilol is built. In descending from the eastern frf)nt, where the foundations are drej)c(?t, the declivity was made in steps, so as to preserve, in every part, a horizontal bearing. The character of the earth under all the walls is the same throughout the work, being a stratum of hard and com[)act gravel of several feet in thickness. In all cases the footings arc at least two feet broader than the walls they support, and in order to insure the [xrmanency o( tlie western fronts of both buiUlings, where the foundations were of such extraordi- nary depths, the front walls and the portico walls were united at the base, thus making a solid foundation o\' twenty feet in width, which was 6 carried up ri^ht foot from llio footings before the walls were set off to tlieir roqnirccT thii'kness. In t]iiiL:;inG: lor llie wostorn foundations of tho soulli wing, we found, at a ilepth of thiyly tcet below the level of the ground on the eastern front, architectural fragments, charred timber, and other debris, from the burning of the Capitol in the year 1814, which indicates the great amount of tiUing up that lias been done since that time. After passing through tliese masses of rubinsh, the natural earth was reached at the deptli o'i thnty-cight feet below the ground line, and at two feet below this undisturbed surface the walls were founded, as before stated. The stones of which these foundations have been constructed were tested, at the request of a special committee of the House of Represen- taties, bv the late Professor Walter R. Jc^hnson, whose report is hereto appended. The contractors for furnishing the marble commenced operations at their quairies in Lee, Massachusetts, immediately after the passage of tlie ap|)ropriation l)ill, and their first cargo arrived on the 5th of July last, since which time they have delivered (ivcnty cargoes, containing in the aggregate 35,236 cubic ieet, making an average of 1,4S7 cubic feet per week, which is quite as fast as we now require it. Before this marble was adopted for the extension of the Capitol, it was deemed proper to test the several specimens offered for the work, tor the purpose of obtaining reliable data on which to make the selec- tion. A commission was accordingly appointed to make the neces- sary' experiments, and on their report, together with the sanction of the Committees on Public Buihlings and Grounds of b(jth Houses of Con- gress, the marl)le we are now using was adopted. The report of the commission is hereto annexed. In conformity to the proviso contained in the first section of the act of Congress approved August 31, 1852, I appointed Mr. John C. Hark- ness as measurer of all the work and materials of the extension of the Capitol, and Mr. Cornelius Jacobs as receiver ot" materials on the north wing and Mr. WiUiam J. Smith on the south wing, all of whom were duly sworn into office. Mr. Harkness has since measured all the work done and materials furnished by contract from the commencement of" the work, and re- jKDrted the same to this ofhce, in conformity to tlie aforesaid act of Con- gress, and no further payments were made until the said measurement was received, and the accounts presented in accordance therewith. By an act of Congress approved September 30, 1850, there was ap[)roj)riated for the extension of the Capitol the sum of 8100,000 00 And by an act approved April 14, 1852, the further sum of 500,000 00 Making ihe whole amount appropriated for this work to the present date 600,000 00 The amount expendf;d at the date of my last annual report, (December 23, 1851,) was ' $88,082 86 7 Since which time have been expended, to the present date, (December 1, lS-52,) $407,717 11 Making 495,799 97 Which leaves an unexpended balance of. 104,200 03 600,000 00 A detailed account of the expenditures up to the 31st of the present month inclusive, will be transmitted to you on the 1st of January en- sumg. There will be required to carry on the work during the present fiscal year, ending June 30, 1853, the additional sum of. $400,000 00 And during the ensuing fiscal year, ending June 30, 1854 600,000 00 Making 1,000,000 00 Library of Congress. Immediately after the destruction of this portion of the Capitol by fire, which occurred on the 24t}i of December last, I was requested by the Commissioner of Pulilic Buildings to make an examination in refer- ence to the extent of the injury, to report thereon, and to prepare plans and estimates for repairing the damage. On the 27lh of J;muary I submitted a design flir reconstructing the principal apartment of tlie library wiiliin its original hmits, witli such an arrangement as would admit of its luturc enlargement, together with a report and an estimate, all of which were subsequently transmitted to the Senate Committee on Public Buildings and Grounds, and on the 19th of ^^arch last, an act was passed by Congress appropriating the sum of 872,500 for carrying out the design. As the plans contemplnted the execution of the entire work of iron, proposals were invited horn several establishments which were sup- posed to possess undoubted rir;iliti(\s l()r working in that material with expeditif)!) and aceuraev, ;ind the cf)iitraet w;is finally ;i\v;n'ded to Messrs. Junes, lieebe & Co., of N(nv York, they being the lowest bid- ders. Articles of agreement were entered into by the p.irties on the 21st of June last, .uid the work was commenced as soon as the j)atterns could be prepared. The gre.'it inconvenience occasioned by the lossof tin? il)rnier liijr.'uy rendered it highly important to have the room fniished, if possible, be- fore the asseml)ling of Congress, and to efii'ct this oiyect every possible exertion has been used. The eontrncrtnrs li;ive kept as mnny men con- stantly emplovefl, day and nifjht, ris the nriture of the work would ad- mit, and have left no means unemployed to bring it to a speedy con- clusion. Several weeks were lost by unforeseen difficulties, which occurred in preparing the room for the contractors; and considerable time was consumed in waiting for the patterns fi)r the f)inamental work, which the pattern-makers found it impossible to prepare as rap- 8 idlv as ihcy wero rr(iuire(l. But not\vitli.or?. Tlie hot water furnaces are completed and ready to be put into operation. Tlio eastern portico is nearly finished, and the steps and cheek Mocks are all wrought and ready to be set; it will, therefore, recjuire but a lew weeks to complete this part of the building also. The work was resumed on the western wing in the monlli of Sep- tember, according to the plans which were laid before you with my last annual report, and the granite sub-basement is now being con- structed. THOMAS U. WALTER, Architect of Public Buildings. Hon. Alkx. H. H. Stuakt, Stcrctanj oj the Interior. Report of the Commission appointed hj the Department of the Literior ^^to test the sevfral specimens (f marble offered for the extension of the United States Capitol.'''' November 3, 1851. Washington, D. C, December 22, 1851. Sir: The commission to which has been referred the examination of the marbles oflered for the extension of the Capitol, have been informed that vou are tlesirous of obtaining, as soon as j)ossible, such information as will enable the government to determine which of the several marbles to adopt. Though the questions proposed to the commission appear to ])e simple and easy of solution, yet they have been attended with many difficulties; and, notwithstanding the commission have pressed on the experiments as rapidly as the nature of the investigations would per- mit, and have devoted more time to the subject than they could well spare from their official duties, they are not yet able to present as many definite results as they could desire. In view, howrver, of the [)ressing demands for lnf()rmation, they have concluded to make the fJjUowing re[Mjrt of progress, which will be suf- ficient for the innnediatc action of government; and they would respect- fully ask for permission to continue their investigations, and to embrace in thrrn a greater varifty of the building mnterials of tliis country. Though the art of building has been practised from the earliest times, and constant demanrls have been nifide, in every age, for the means of determining the best materials, yet the process of ascertaining the strength and durability of stone appears to have received but little defi- nite scientific atteiuion, anrl the commission, who have never before made this subject a special object of study, liave been surpris(.'d with unforeseen difficulties at every step of their progress, and have cr)me to the conclusion that the processes usually employed for solving these questions are still in a veiy unsatisfactory state. It should be recollected that the stone in the building is to be exposed for centuries, and that the conclusions desired are to be drawn from results produced in the course of a few weeks. Besides this, in the present state of science, we do not know all the 11 actions to which the materials are subjected in nature, nor can we fully estimate the amount of those which are known. The solvent power of water, which even attacks glass, must in time produce an appreciable effect on the most solid material, particularly where it contains, as the water of the atmosphere always does, car- bonic acid in solution. The attrition of siliceous dusts, when blown against a building, or washed down its sides by rain, is evidently ope- rative in wearing away the surface, though the evanescent portion re- moved at each time may not be indicated by the nicest balance. An examination of the basin which formerly received the water' from the fountain at the western entrance of the capitol, now deposited in the Patent Office, will convince any one of the great amount of action pro- duced principally by water charged with carbonic acid. Again, every flash of lightning not onlv generates nitric acid — which, in solution in the rain, acts on the marble — but also by its inductive effects at a dis- tance produces chemical changes along the moist wall, which are at the present time beyond our means of estimating. Also, the constant vari- ations of temperature from day to day, and even from hour to hour, give rise to molecular motions which must aflect the durabihty of the mate- rial of a building. Recent observations on the pendulum have shown that the Bunker Hill monument is scarcely for a moment in a state of rest, but is constantly warping and bending under the influence of the var3-ing temperature of its ditterent sides. INIoreover, as soon as the pohshed surface of a building is made rough from an)'' of the causes aforementioned, the seeds of minute lichens and mosses, which are constantly floating in the atmosphere, make it a place of repose, and from the growth and decay of the nicroseopic plants whicli spring from these discoloration is produced, and disintegration assisted. But perhaps the greatest source of the wearing away in a diniMte like ours, is that of" the alternations of freezing and thawing which take pkice during the winter season; and though this elU'ct must be com- parativ(;ly j)o\verful, y(;t, in good marble, it requires the accumulated efl[ect of a nunil)er (jf years in order delinil(.'ly to estimate its amount. From all these causes, the commission are convinced that the only en- tirely reliable means of ascertaining the comparalive capability of mar- ble to resist the weather is to study the actual ( lli'c-ts of the ainiosphere upon it, as exhibited in buildings which f()r years ha\'e been exposed to these influences. Unf()rtunately, liowevcr, in this couniiy, bm lew oj)- portunilies for apj)lying this test are to be loimd. Ii is line sonic ;iii;il- agous itilormatioii iiiav be derived from the exainination ol the e.\])ose(i surfiices f)f" marble in their out-crops at the (jiiarry ; liiit in this case the length fit" time they liave been exposiMl, and the changes of actions to which tiiey may have l)een subjected dining, j)erhaps, long geological periods, are miknown; and since diflircnt (juarries may not have been exposed to the same action, they do not always afli^rd dclinite d.ita for reliable comparative estimates of durability, except wh< r<^ dilierenl specimens occur in the same (juarry. As we have said before, tlic art of testing the finality of stone for buihlirii; pnrposes is at present in a very imperti'ct slate; the object is to imitate the operations of nature, and at the same time to hasten the 12 effect by incrcnsiinG; the energy of the action, and, after all, the result may be doenied but as approximative, or, to a considerable degree, merely ]iroiiable. Ai)()ul twenty years ago an ingenious process \\as devised by M. Brard, which consists in saturating thestoiieto be tested with a solution of the sulphate of soda. In drying this salt crystallizes and expands, thus )>r()dneing an exfoliation of surfice which is supposed to imitate the eHect of frost. Though this process has been much relied on, and generally employed, recent investigations made by Dr. Owen lead u& to douT^t its perfect analog}'^ with that of the operations of nature. He found that the results produced by the actual exposure to freezing and thawing in the air, during a ])orti()n of winter, in the case of the more porous stones, produced vcr}' diilerent results from those obtained by the drying of the salt. It appears from his experiments that the action of the latter is chemical as well as mt^hanical. The commission in consideration of this have attempted to produce results on the stone by freezing and thawing by means of artilicial cold and heat. This process is, however, laborious; each specimen must be enclosed in a separate box fitted with a cover, and the amount of exfoliation produced is so slight that in good marble the operation requires to l)c repeated many times before reliable comparative results can be obtained. In prosecuting this part of the inquiries unforseen difficulties have occurred in ascertaining precisely the amount of the disintegration, and it has been found that the results are liable to be vitiated by circumstances which were not foreseen at the counnence- ment of the inquires. This part of the investigation, ihcrelbre, will require a long series of experiments in order to obtain results entirely reliable. It would seem at first sight, and the commission when they under- took the investigation were of the same opinion, that but little difficulty Would be found in ascertaining the strength of the various specimens of marbles. In this, however, they were in error. The first difficulty wliich occurred was to procure the j)roper instrument for the purpose. On examining the account of that used by Rennie, and described in the Transactions of the ]{o3'al .Society of London, the commission fi>und that its construction involved too much friction to allow of" definite comparative results. Friction itself has to be overcome as well as the resistance to compression, and, since it increases in proportion to the pressure, tlie stronger stones would appear relatively to withstand too great a comj)ressing force. The commission first examined an instrument — a hydraulic press — vrhich had jireviously been used for experiments of this kind, but found that it was liable to the same objection as that of the machine of Rennie. They were, however, extremely fortunate subsecjuently in obtaining, thrrjugh the p(jliteness of" Comniodore Ijallard, commandant of the navy-yard, the use of an admirable instrument devised by Major "Wade, late of the United States arrny, and constructed under his di- rectirm for the purposf; of testing the strength of gun metals. This instrument consists of a compound lever, the several fulcra of which are knife edges, opposed to hardened steel surfaces. The commission verified the delicacy and accuracy of the indications of this instrument 13 by actual weighing, and found, in accordance with the description of Major Wade, the equihi^rium was produced b}' one pound in opposition to tico hundred. In the use ol this instrumejit the commission were much indebted to the experience and scientific knowledge of Lieutenant Dahlgreen, of the navy-3'ard, and to the Hberahty with which all the apphances of that important public estabhshment were put at their disposal. Specimens of the different samples of marble were prepared in the form of cubes of one inch and a half in dimension, and consequently exhibiting a base of two and a quarter square inches. These were dressed by ordinary workmen with the use of a square, and the oppo- site sides made as nearly parallel as possible by grinding by hand on a flat surface. They were then placed between two thick steel plates, and in order to insure an equahty of pressure, independent of any want of perfect parallelism and flatness on the two opposite surfaces, a thin plate of lead was interposed above and below between the stone and the plates of steel. This was in accordance with a plan adopted by Rennic, and that which appears to have been used by most, if not all, of the subsequent experimenters in researches of this kind. Some doubt, however, was expressed as to the action of interposed lead, which induced a series of experiments to settle this question, wlien the remarkable fact was discovered that the yielding and aj)proximatcIy equable pressure of the lead caused the stone to give way at about halt the pressure it would sustain without such an interposition. For example, one of the cubes precisely similar to another, which witli- stood a pressure of upwards of 60,000 pounds when placed in imme- diate contact with the steel plates, gave wa}^ at about 30,000 with lead interposed. This remarkable fact was verified in a series of experi- ments, embracing samples of nearly all the marl)lcs under trial, and in no case difl a single exception occur to vary the result. Tlic exj)lnna- tion of lliis remarkable phenomenon, now that it is known, is not dilii- cult. Tlie stone tends to give way by Ijulging out in the centre of PAch of its four perpendicular faces, and to l()riri two pyramidal figures with their apicf!S opposed to each other at the centre of the cube and tlieir bases against the steel plates. In the case where rigid C(juabl(! pressure is employed, as in tliat of the thick steel plate, all parts must give way together. I'.ut in iliat of a ycilding equable pressure, as in the case of interposed lead, the stone first gives way along the lines of least resistance, nnd the remaining pressure must be sustained by the central portions luound the vertical axis of the cube. After this important fnct was clearly determined, lend and all oiher interposed substances were discarded, and a method devised by which the ut)per and lower surfacr-s of the cube could be ground info j)er(i'Ct parelleli.-ni. This consist:* in the use of a rectangular iron frame, into which a row of six of the specimens could be fastencfl by a screw at the end. The upper and lower snrfices (»f this iron frame were wrought into perfect parallc-lism by the operalif)n of a j)laning machine. The stones being fastened into this, with a small [xution of the njjjxr and lower parts projecting, the whole were ground down to n flat surface, until the iron and the face of the cubes were thus brought into a conlinu- u ous iihuu". The frame was then turned over, and the opposite surfaces frrouiid in hkc manner. Care was of course taken that the surfaces llius reduced to perfect parallehsm, in order to receive the action of the machine, were jiarallcl t(» the natural beds of the stone. All the specimens testetl were subjected to Uiis process, and in their exposure to pressure were found to give concordant results. The crushing force exhibited in the sul)j()ined table is much greater than that heretofore given for the same material. Tlic commission have also determined the specific gravities of the dirterent samples submitted to their examination, and also the quantity of water which each absorbs. The}'^ consider these determinations, and particularly that of the re- sistance to crushing, tests of much importance, as indicating the cohe- sive force of the particles of the stone, and its capacity to resist most of the intluences before mentioned. The amount of water absorbed may be regarded as a measure of the antagonistic force to cohesion, which tends, in the expansion of freezing, to disintegrate the surface. In considering, however, the indication of this test, care must be taken to make the comparison between marbles of nearly the same texture, because a coarsely crystallized stone may apparently absorb a small quantity of water, while in reality the cement which unites the crystals of the same stone may absorb a much larger quantitv. That this may be so was clearly estabhshed in the experi- ments with the coarsely crystalized marbles exaniined by the commis- sion. When these were submitted to a liquid which slightly tinged the stone, the coloration was more intense around the margin of each crys- tal, indicating a greater amount of absorption in these portions of the surface. The following table exhibits the average of the results which have been obtained, and, although they do not give the data for estimating with absolute certainty precise relative values, yet they enable the com- mission to pronounce, with consideraide confidence, that the first four mur/jlf.i (ire of a superior (jmilidj, and, it is believed, will 2)rove sufficiently durable firr the work proposed. Column No. 1 gives the relative resistance to crushing per square inch, in pf)unds avoirdupois, deduced from the average of five specimens of each s.imple. Cohnnn No. 2 gives the specific gravity of each specimen in its natu- ral condition, without allowing for thr water absorbed. An allowance on this account would slighlly cluinge the numljers presented. Column No. 3 gives the wriglit per cubic f()ot in {)f)nnds avoirdupois. Column No. 4 gives the (iu;intity of water ab.«orl)ed under a pressure of about fourteen pounds to ihe square inch, produced by placing the stone under water in the vacuum of an air-pump, and afterwards let- ting on the pressure of the atmosphere. Column No. 5 gives the relative amount of material thrown off in freezing and thawing twenty-eight times in succession. The quantities in the last two columns are expressed in weights of which the unit is the ten-thousandth part of an ounce. These of the last column are so small that the commission would prefer to repeat the experiments with a larger number of specimens, subjected to a greater 15 number of alternations of freezing and thawing. It will be seen, how- ever, that the results coincide in a considerable degree with the cohe- sive force, as exhibited in the resistance to crusliing, and also with the specific gravity. By running the eye down the column, it will be seen that the several stones may be divided into two classes; the Hist four specimens of the table exhibit a high power of resistance to crushing, and a high spe- cific gravity. In the remaining eight specimens, there is a sudden diminution in the resistance to crushing, and also in the specific gravi ty. The same change exists, though in a less marked degree, and with some exceptions, in the last column ; and when we take into consider- ation the facts which we have stated in regard to absorption by a fine- grained marble, in comparison with one of a coarsely cr3^stalline struc- ture, the results in the fourth column are also not discordant. It must be understood that the results given by the commission re- late exclusively to the particular specimens which were placed in their hands as the samples whicli accompanied the bids. From these spe- cimens the cubes experimented on were cut under the direction of the commission, and the remainder of the blocks deposited in the Smithso- nian l)uilding, where they may be examined by those who are inter- ested in the investigation. It should, moreover, be stated, that the commission, as a body, have had no opportunity of examining the stones in masses in the quarries, or of ascertaining whether they could bo obtained in sufficient quanti- ties, and of the same qualities as the specimens which have been tested. Also, whether they exhibit the presence of sulphuret of iron, or other contaminating substances, or show evidence of cracks or other unsoundness, all of which are observations of importance in dctermLn- ing the above. IG The following is a table of the mnrblcs submitted to trial by the commission, iirraiigcd in the order of resistance to a crushing force: TABLE. Origmal Nos. of samples. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Localities of quarries. Ciiisliing force on a square inch, in pounds avoirdu- pois. Specific gravity. Weight per cubic foot, in pounds avoirdupois. Absoqnion of water, in ten-thousauths of an ounce. LoFS by freezing, in ten-thousauths of an ouuce. East Chester, New York 1 3 9 7 4 6 2 12 11 10 5 8 23. 917 22. 702 IH. 941 18.061 10. 382 9. 625 9.544 9.071 8.950 8.812 8. 0.57 7. 153 2. 8579 2. 8620 2.8613 2. 8605 2.7143 2. 7086 2.7129 2.7131 2.7115 2. 7129 2.7128 2.7089 178. 62 178. 87 178. 83 178. 78 169. 64 169. 29 169. 56 169. 57 169.47 169. 56 169. ,55 169. 31 39J 103 66 52J 68 55 92 70,i «!•* 87 43J 119§ 6.2 9.9 11.8 Baltimore, small crystal West Stockbridge, Mass Baltimore, medium crystal "^^■(•Tnniit ^fnss ...... ...... 8.1 8.8 13.6 15.7 West Stockbridge, Mass Montgomery county. Pa Stockbriilgc, Mass Baltimore, large crystal T jpnoT Af iiss ... ............. (*) 8.8 25.7 21.9 24.1 Respectfully subnii •Ree ttod, ult lost by a ccident. Hon. Alex. H. H Stuaut, Secretary of the Interior. JOS. G. TOTTEN. JOSEPH HENRY. THOMAS EWHANK. A. J. DOWNING. TllOiLVS U. WALTER. Report of rrrtfcxsor TVtiltcr R. Johnson on the hiildhig stone vsed in con- structing the foundutions of the extension r tcsrini,' the iiiiirltlcH; (ini|ily Pn»fc8»or .ffihnwm in (■••iidiirting thedc I'xjiiTiujt'iitd, oh will be seen by tbcir rt'imrt whirh ina- mwliaU'ly precedes tbin document. -l • U. \V. 18 \v;is tlius npccrtnincd Aviili considcrnble exactness. Tliis modulus vari(\>i considerably in dilioicnt san)j)I(\'^, and oven in different cubes iVoni the sanii! saui])le. In order to obtain a standard of comparison ot ilie different specimens of the stone ojicrated on, I tested a sample of a rock, largely used in this country, and to some extent by government, l()r building rnd other purposes. This was the Quiney sienite, -svhich, as will be observed by reference to the table, sustained a very high pressure before crushing. In testing the action of the atmosphere on the different samples, I may remark that, for the particular purpose of the foundations of the Capitol, I do not consider that ihe trials of the eff(>et of frost are very important, as it is understood tliat these Ibundations will, when the building is comple- ted, be embanked in such a manner that frost will never reach them. For other uses to which this stone may be applied these trials may be of much importance. To some extent an exemption from water pin-- colating the soil will also apply to the foundations, since the water iall- ing upon the building will be mostl}' carried away by pipes and drains, and the shielding of the surface by pavements or flaggings will tend to keep dry the foundation walls. I have selected for the chemical trials such of the samples as ap- peared to represent the exactness of strength to resist crushing, and have subjected them to such re-agents as are likely to be most efficient in nature in causing disintegration or dissolution. The two samples taken for chemical analysis were those numbered one and seven of the accoinpanying table, and for a mechanical separa- tion of certain mineral constituents No 5, of the same table, was chosen, being one of those which appeared to have been freed from the action of atmospheric influences prior to its removal from the quarries. For some of the other samples, likewise, the effect of heating was noted by way of comparison. Having visited the quarries from wliieh tlje stone is stated to have been derived, 1 am enabled to state that the one from which the stone for the south wing was taken is known as the Smith quarry, and those from which that of the north wing is taken are the O'Neill (|uarries. One of the O'Neill quarries is immediately ad- jiininc' that of iSmith, and these two appear hi furnish stone of essen- tially the same character. The other (juarries of O'Neill are a few hundred feet lower down the canal. At all these quarries I judge that stone may be found, rc- prcs( nting every variety embraced in the scries of specimens selected lijr trial from the foundati(jns of the Capitol. At all of them there is a covering of greater or less depth, from one or two to ten or twelve feet of soil, sand, gravel, and clayey matter, with some roffed pebbles, all of which repose in beds, more or less regular, upon the upper edges of the micaceous rock, worked in the quarrifs. This rock lies inclined southwestwardly, in angle of about oO degrees ; and the natural beds and fissures of the stone afford ]:)assage to the surface water to pene- trate to a considerable distance below the upper edges. This penetra- tirm has caused, in some parts, a discoloration, accompanie-d by a greater oi less alteratifjii fif the consistency of the rock, the natural bluish or greenish color being changed to a yellowish brown, or drab 19 color ; and for about 20 or 25 feet from the top, the rock has been so affected by these surface influences as to be unfit for use in building. Below that level, varying, however, in the different strata, the work- able stone is found. In some of the softer portions it appenrs that the decomposition has extended further down than in adjoining firmer beds. In breaking the blocks the depth to which atmospheric influences have penetrated is in general sufficiently indicated by the color. A careful inspection enables the quarryman to reject those parts which have been materially affected by the influences above referred to; and the large heaps of rejected matter near the quarries, evince the. neces- sity and the exercise of a discrimination in the selection of such parts as are fit for building purposes. The discoloration of the stone is sometimes only superhcial, or extends to the depth of but a few lines. The upper edges of the rock next to the covering of sand, gravel, &c., aflbrd little more than a mass of micaceous sand, with barely cohesion enough to bear handlino;. The rock in its normal, or solid state, appears to occupy an interme- diate place between tnoe mica slate, of which flag-stones are made, and gneiss, whicli has the mineral composition of granite. This rock has quartz and mica in large proportions as compared with feldspar. It exhibits many nodules of quartz, nearly pure, and small garnets, toge- ther with iron p3'rlte3, and m:ignetic oxide of iron. I submit a table, exhibiting, yi/-6Y, the numl)er of samples tested; sec- ond, the part of the foundation walls from which they were severally taken; i/uV(/, the numbers of the several specimens taken from each sample; fourth, the external characters of each specimen; fif(k, the S[)eci!ic gi-avity; sixth, the weight of each sam])le per cubic f)ot, (kv rived from the average specific gravity; .«c«c/i^/t, the height of each 6pfc;-imen crushed ; c/^A//t, the observed compression; yt/'/i^/i, the force producing the observed compression; tenth, the n\\\x of the bas^j of each sp -cimfni opt-rated on; eleventh, the modules ot" resistance V) com- pression ytf each specimen; twelfth, the avenige modulus for each sam- ple; thiribk^nth, the average crushing force per scjuare inch, in pounls; fourteenth, t)ie absorption of water for c;ich smnple; and, Jiftccnlh, the OSS oi' cu/ii sample by the cflc'ct of heat. 20 •mTu9 B.jo 0011 "1 '•s.>nni (){; aiii/j.iJi HI ■>qn.i II. 'Ill ''i 1 11 i(\ s^dT •.u>Jl suiiua ut ipiii JCl .!'• .'ilu-> r. Aq Joiu.u j« uoihIjoshv -suxlii)) -jioATi spiinoil HI i|>)ii! •bs j,h1 .i.).fri| 3iin|sii.i,) •OIlIuiBS 1|,1B3 JOJ U0I3 -sojdiiiuo o) 3jin:i!ii!iii(i.) ut oouujsisjj JO oinpuj^ •soqa -in ajiinbif iii kuoiii -lO.lds lO OSINI lO 1MJV 8 00 o o in go o o ■=9 2 oo'crsT-H" •C^ TJ< I- 1^ i- O I* I- t- t' OJ t- n ^ i ci si CO 00 CO o> ■">• u> ^ i^ Q i^ O Ol 00 00 OB I- I- t- ci (Ti ej c« ■5 o e a : : o a : ; a. . . a. t-. ■ ■ o D. t.^ . . o o • ■ o a • • a. b •■a Z 3 • o « C ■ -r "= 6 ?: • > = a! a £25 o 3 •a o s •a S2 s -b N 2 1' J. "O en s 3 ° C (A ^ ^ >. li s _ .Id c^ rt — " 3 S3 ■=■ -.s •- .2 3 Of ^' tC o <_ J< Ol " o S'o 3i F o = 5 " E o .^ a '" ^ ^ c4 a> bo tJ •3 (- vt O at i> i; o H ci I -u.iiui.jnds oqi |o X."'1V .2 a. « 3 = 3 = o -I <_ S . C _ 3 » =^ o IBS I 3 CO bs .£■5 o o o ^ _— g-.- o o 3 T '7 , '" 3 - 1- - i- i o •3 ei S -3 ■— bi-« ba tS ~ .a: S •/. = .a: = ^ e; C 3 3 3 -y. ;5 w H 5 ^ 3 t: •- ~ ^^ ■'' ^ C 3 O g 3 3. O =-.-3 O 0°0C3^-0'*'-0 o o >?■ o o •g Pi"- o. »i 3! •J' o .2 -Slot O Ci.-— o til ..^ 3 r^ o .^ £ if <-"== 3" &s ° = fe ^ = t^ ^ ' 'r 2 a* s 3 « 5 ^ o •- a> o. o O &. O . .= § -S? o '*- 5n a* IIP _^ ^ *.» br' 5 o p - = = S ■1 « « o -H « n ut « S r: "^ 3 " " > t- ■5 bir > H> ^ — . '■5-^ "S 5^ — ^ H.'-.c 3 § 3 r>-3 E 2 a i o <5 S :';S a. 1: i V =f 1 - £ 1 1 c 3 § a 5 3 . f — .a " -5 i 3 n 37 is "5 £ 3 5 F S O ~ "3f5 O 3 " _ V. c- 3 3 c 3 S ii 1; " 3! '«. i a-" 3 t: .3 •— ■didUlISi 310 J« '0\ i 21 a o CO OS 00 o O o o o o o ■* *^ «>, ■ o Q O o o oo o a o OO o oo o o o 2 o o o o o o o C) o ITJ O O) n «o Cl ^ (O o ■^ l€ t~ m t^ o o 00 P5 o *»? Ci r) r^ ■^ 1^ CC CI Oi T r* I'- ?:c=3 o <- o o o rr (^ •^ — ilioi) of plants, have nr) doubt ro-operatcd nioic or less powerfully with the atmosphere in i)nKlucing the alterations visiblr at tin; (juarrifs at the uj)pcr part of the strata, and pcrcejjiibli; on the cxti.'rior or interior of some sam|)]es at the Capitol. 'J'hc pow(,-r of tlu" stone, when laid in buildinir, to n;- sist the further ucUou of acids, may be less imporlani, in n-fficnce to the organic products of the soil, than win u exposed in llio (junrriea to their influence beiieaili llic natural surface; Imi oiln r acids, and ihcir compounds, may and do |)ro{luce on the materials ol buildinu's ctlf els which, in the course of time, becouK! suiruiently marked. Had tune permitted, it would jjave been desirable- to trace distinctly the inllu- encc of the several causes just alludr-d to, and note the jtrccise effects. But the trials would be long, minute, and labr)rious. The followini,' trials have reference to tin; total amount ol matt(!i which acids, even in their concentrated f(»rm, are capable ol dissolving. Tliirty grains in powder of sample iNo 1, .after thf)roui;li drying, (where- by it lost 0.1 of a grain,) were treated with strong chhjrhydric witii a 26 little nitric acid, and the treatment repeated with fresli portions of acid, until everything soluble appeared to be removed. The ignited residue was observed to contain a few black particles, which were found to be magnetic oxide of iron removabU' ijy the magnet. The residue weighed 25. Go grains, or S2.17 per cent, of the original assay. Show- ing that of moisture, combined water, and mineral water, there had been removed 17.83 per cent. On sample No. 7 (altered rock) 30 grains lost of moisture O.OG grain, and these, by long boiling in chlorhydric with nitric acid, wasliing, separating, drying, and igniting, left a residue of 2G.23 grains, of which 0.03 grain was magnetic oxide of iron. The insoluble part is, conse- quently, 87.43 per cent, of the original weight, and the part dissolved is 12.57 per cent., showing a marked diflerence between this partly decomposed sample and the unaltered stone No. 1. The insoluble sili- cates are, of course, left in the rock altered by natural causes, and be- come a larger portion of the whole weight than in the unaltered state. Of the matter in sample 1, it appears there were of insoluble percent. silicates, with a little mametic oxide of iron 82.17 Hygrometric moisture 0.33 Combined water 0.87 Insoluble matter (silica) left in drying the solution 0.60 Peroxide of iron 6.30 Lime 0.34 ^lagnesia 0.20 Alumina 3.04 Protoxide of manganese 5.09 Potash 70 99.64 The above is the result of but a single analysis, which I should de- sire to repeat and vary, did time permit, in order to assure myself of the entire accuracy of the results. In order to arrive at some estimate of the adecjuacy of the founda- tion walls to support the structure which it is intended to place upon them, I have taken from the working drawings of the architect the di- mensions of the main walls already laid. These walls are, in general, six feet nine inches thick, but at those parts where the walls are high- est, the base resting directly on the ground, it is widened to nine feet. I find that the entire circuit of each wall (not including the porticoes) will be equal to a single wall 728 feet long. This wall is to support a superstructure 34 feet high and 4J feet thick, composed, in part, of marble weiuhing about 179 pounds per cubit foot, and in part of other materials, brick, mortar, &c., which will probably weigh considerably less; but I have assumed, for the sake of giving their full weight, that the entire wall will weigh 175 pounds [)cr cubit foot. Conse(|uenlly, one lineal foot of superstructure will weigh 20,775 pounds. This weight, when transmitted to the base of the foundation walls, where they are 6f feet thick, will load each square foot with a weight of 3,966 pounds; but where the foundation walls are 9 feet thick, the load at the base due to superstructure will be but 2,975 pounds per square foot. The highest part of the foundation walls themselves is stated by Mr. 27 "Walter to be 40 feet, and by the accompanying table it appears that the stone weighs 173 pounds per cubic foot, from wliich it follows, that a vertical wall (not widened at the base) would press that base with a force of 6,920 pounds per square foot, which, iiddcd to the pressure of 3,966 pounds, due to the superstructure, would give a total of 10,SS6 pounds, which would have been the load at the bottom of the founda- tion wall at its deepest part, if it had not been made thicker thnn the rest. If this deepest part of the foundation be gradually thickened from 6f feet at the top to 9 feet at bottom, the weight of it distributed over the base will be equivalent to a load of 6,05-5 pounds per square foot, to which adding the weight of the superstructure, as above com- puted, for the same 9 feet base, viz: 2,97-5 pounds, we obtain 9,030 pounds on one scjuare foot. By a reference to the table of results of experiments on crusliing, it will be found in column thirteen that of the blue micaceous stones No. 7 gave the lowest mean strength, viz: 8,156 pounds per square inch. No. 1 gave the highest result, viz: 20,715 pounds; and the average of seven samples of that kind of stone is 15,603 pounds per square inch. 8,156 lbs. per square inch is at the rate of 1,174,464 lbs. per sq. foot. 20,715 do do 2,980,960 do 15,603 do do 2,246,832 do 1,174,464 contains 10,886 one hundred and eight times. 2,980,960 do two hundred and seventy-three times. 2,246,832 do two hundred and six times. If the highest part of the foundation had been built only 6? feet thick at bottom, as well as at top, and wholly of the w(Nd(piir(vl Strength. 11 constructed of stone having the avtragr sfn/ig/h of tlio seven specimens of the quartz mica slate, the wall of iV^ i\'c\ thick would have a strength ten and thrcc-tmtlix times as great ;i.s tin; above- mentioned rule would r<(piire; and if it had a nine feet base, as be- fbrf!, it would be- twelv(j and two-fifths times as strong as the rc(|nire- ment of its load. The architectural rule to which I have just r(;ferred maybe li»und in Weisbacli's " Principles of the Mechanics (»f Ma( liineiy and Engineer- ing," American edition, vol. 1, |)age 215. in a slalenieiit of the |)rae- tical application of" the ascertained strength of" materials to resist crush- ing, it is there s;iid that "ten times iIk; absolute strength is given to WfX)d and stones, to iron only one of live times, and to walls of rough stones twenty times. Though these foundations are not wholly <>f rough stones, yet as they are so in ])art, 1 have elK)sen to assume that basis of computation as entirely within th(; limits of safety, whatever may be the size of the; specimens composing the masonry. 1 have thus far spoken of the force pressing on the bottom of thn founrlation walls at their dee[)est part. It may, j)erlia|)S, be said that the superstructure does not rest on a continuous wall, but on a fbundu- THE LIBRARY IIWyERSJTY OF CALIFORNIA LOS ANGELES r- mmmm Y , ^ 1158 00392 c UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LIBRARY Los Angeles This book is DUE on the last date stamped below. 1 ^'■■^r. I/' II '.'■ ■- <..■ : Drj-lT^^Rl-m