EX LIBRIS THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA FROM THE FUND ESTABLISHED AT YALE IN 1927 BY WILLIAM H. CROCKER OF THE CLASS OF 1882 SHEFFIELD SCIENTIFIC SCHOOL YALE UNIVERSITY i UNIVERSITY SERMONS Other Books by the Same Author THE creed of JESUS and OTHER SERMONS SOCIAL ASPECTS OF THE CROSS HYMNS OF THE KINGDOM OF GOD Edited by H. S. Coffin and A. W. Vernon The Same for Use in Baptist Churches Rev. Charles W. Gilkey, Co-editor SOME CHRISTIAN CONVICTIONS THE TEN COMMANDMENTS WITH A CHRIS- TIAN APPLICATION TO PRESENT CONDITIONS UNIVERSITY SERMONS By HENRY SLOANE COFFIN Minister in the Madison Avenue Presbyterian Church and Associate Professor in the Union Theologi- cal Seminary, New York City New Haven: Yale Univeksity Press London: Humphrey Milford Oxford University Press MDCCCCXIV coftright, 1914 By Yale University Press First published, April, 1914 Second printing, March, 1918 To My Father EDMUND COFFIN Yale *66 646532 1 PREFACE These sermons have been preached in the chapels of Yale, Harvard, Princeton, Columbia, Brown, New York and Chicago Universities, and of Williams, Dartmouth, Wellesley, Vassar, Mt. Holyoke and Bryn Mawr Colleges. Some of them have been dehvered at the Conferences of the Young Men's and Young Women's Christian Associations at Northfield and Silver Bay. They are published as they were spoken; and they are necessarily colloquial. They were preached to congregations of students having similar needs; and the same ideas recur in them frequently. The only reason for their publication is the desire that has been expressed to possess them in printed form, and to be able to pass them on to others, whose religious wants they may possibly help to bring to the only Source of supply. December, 1913. CONTENTS PAGE I. Three Stages in Religious Experience 1 II. Religious Prepossessions 19 III. The Finality of Jesus 36 IV. Abilities Suicidally Used . 57 V. The Claims of the Church upon Christians 76 VI. Fools for a Purpose 90 VII. Revelation by Concealment 108 VIII. The Religious Faculty 126 IX. Unexpected Sympathy 142 X. The Christian Thought of God . 160 XI. Faith and Growing Knowledge . 176 XII. The Fallacy of Origins . 192 XIII. The Reality of God . 211 XIV. Religion— a Load or a Lift? 227 XV. The Old, Old Story . 243 THREE STAGES IN RELIGIOUS EXPERIENCE Ezekiel 1 : 6, 28. The likeness of four living creatures. The likeness of a man. The likeness of the glory of Jehovah. In Ezekiel's somewhat fantastic vision there seems to be a mingling of three ele- ments which successively attract attention. We see first the subhmnan element; the stormy wind, great cloud, flashing flame, the living creatures with their strange forms, wings and wheels, and with move- ments comparable to a streak of lightning. Next, intermixed with all this and becoming more and more prominent, we see a human element; the living creatures have the like- ness of a man, the hands of a man under their wings, the face of a man. Then, mingling with all and at length occupying our entire thought, is a divine element. "The Spirit of life" controls the movements of the wheels, the noise of the wings of the 2 UNIVERSITY SERMONS creatures is like the voice of the Almighty, and, as we scan the human figure, there is "brightness round about him." "As the appearance of the bow that is in the cloud in the day of rain, so was the appearance of the brightness round about. This was the appearance of the likeness of the glory of Jehovah. And when I saw it, I fell upon my face." The successive elements in Ezekiel's vision suggest stages through which many of us pass in our religious experiences. God, as we conceive of Him in childhood, and perhaps in later life if our rehgious ideas remain childish, is a mysterious and magical creature not unlike Ezekiel's com- pound of wind, cloud, flame, wings, wheels, lightning. His face is the face of a man, but His movements and methods are like those of a benevolent but capricious fairy; and it is the unmanlike in Him, that in which He is utterly different from us, which attracts our notice and commands our admiration. We were told that the Bible was God's Book. That meant to us its unlikeness to all other books, its freedom from any imper- RELIGIOUS EXPERIENCE 3 f ection or mistake, its accounts of wonderful happenings such as never take place now- adays — angels talking with men, dreams like Jacob's or Joseph's or King Pharaoh's, the parting waters of the Red Sea before Moses and of the Jordan before Joshua, Elijah carried to heaven in a chariot of fire, the three brave Israelites unharmed in the burning furnace and Daniel untouched in the lions' den, animals entering into the affairs of men like Balaam's ass and Jonah's whale. Its miraculous stories offered no difficulty to us ; they were what we expected in God's Book; without them the Book would not have had its fascination for us, nor would it have impressed us as sufficiently wonderful to be divine. We were told that Jesus was God's Son. Our minds naturally dwelt on His bright home in heaven, unlike anything in the world. His great love in coming down to our earth and sharing human life, and on the extraordinary events in the Gospel story — the carolling angels at His birth, the Voice that spoke to Him out of heaven, the attacks of the tempter instantly repelled, the water changed to wine, the winds and 4 UNIVERSITY SERMONS waves stilled by a word, the thousands fed with one little boy's supper, the walking on the sea, the raising of the dead, His own rising from the grave and ascent into the sky. These incidents not only did not trouble us, they were the most interesting and helpful parts of the narrative. They fitted in exactly with our thought of what God's Son would be and do. God was a big fairy and naturally His Son would be fairylike. It was far less entertaining for us to hear and much harder to believe pas- sages where Jesus appears to be tired out, or unable to perform a mighty work, or ignorant of some future event. We were told to pray, and we asked God for anything it came into our heads to think we wanted. The notion of a law-abiding universe, the idea that we must cooperate with God to answer prayer, never occurred to us. Augustine speaks of himself in childhood as praying "though small^ yet with no small earnestness that I might not be beaten at school," but it never entered his mind that the avoiding of the beating was a matter in which he could materially assist the Almighty. RELIGIOUS EXPERIENCE 5 Our religious life was on the creature level in that it was predominantly selfish. The world exists for children, not they for the world. All the world I saw or knew Seemed a complex Chinese toy. Fashioned for a barefoot boy. It was frankly more blessed for us to receive than to give, and our petitions were personal pleas like the little Augustine's, or if our Now I lay me down to sleep, I pray the Lord my soul to keep, concluded with pleas for blessings on others, they were those whose lives meant much to us — parents, brother, sister, nurse, friends. When Dr. Thomas Arnold went to Rugby he wrote: "My object will be if possible to form Christian men, for Christian boys I can scarcely hope to make; I mean that from the natural imperfect state of boy- hood, they are not susceptible of Christian principles in their full development, and I suspect that a low standard of morals in many respects must be tolerated amongst 6 UNIVERSITY SERMONS ^ them." He lived to modify this opinion; but he was correct in recognizing that much of Jesus' teaching finds nothing to take hold on in children. They can revere and adore the winged creature, they cannot appreciate the man. Inasmuch as our imaginations were keen, God seemed very real to us. Many children have shared the experience Faber describes in "The God of My Childhood": God, who wert my childhood's love. My boyhood's pure delight, A presence felt the livelong day, A welcome fear at night, — At school Thou wert a kindly Face Which I could almost see; But home and holyday appeared Somehow more full of Thee. 1 could not sleep unless Thy Hand Were underneath my head, That I might kiss it, if I lay Wakeful upon my bed. And quite alone I never felt — I knew that Thou wert near, A silence tingling in the room, A strangely pleasant fear. RELIGIOUS EXPERIENCE 7 But the years which immediately follow childhood are a disillusionizing period. We discover beneath the wings of all our fairy creatures the hands of a man. Santa Claus gives place to affectionate people, and Christmas loses its mysterious delight. Prayer proves to be but the preliminary to effort, a program we must carry out with God, and almost inevitably we pray less. Our studies as we advance give us a world of law, and we are likely to lose the sense of personal touch with the Lawgiver. The Bible becomes a book of human experience. Its science, history, morals, religious ideas impress us often as very crude. We are struck with the resemblance of Israel's religion at many points to the religions of other peoples. And as for the miraculous stories, we class them with the legends we have learned to expect in all early literature. Instead of being unlike all other books, the Bible seems to us so entirely like many others, that we lose sight altogether of its uniqueness. Jesus becomes for us frankly a man. We admire His heroism. His broad-mindedness. His loyalty to truth. His glorious self- 8 UNIVERSITY SERMONS sacrifice; but we also recognize what we consider His limitations, the extent to which He shared the world-view of His contem- poraries, believing in to us such unbeliev- able beings as demons, and attributing diseases and insanity to their sinister activity. The miraculous tales about Him we either explain as instances of the power of a superior mind over others, or regard as poetic expressions of spiritual truths. Contact with fact has sobered and perhaps dulled our imagination, so that we have lost the sense we once possessed of God's nearness. I remember, I remember The fir trees, dark and high; I used to think their slender tops Were close against the sky is followed by the regretful Now 'tis little joy To know I'm farther off from heaven Than when I was a boy. Thomas Hood was really sighing for a passed fancy, not a passed faith; but since faith must picture Him in whom it believes. RELIGIOUS EXPERIENCE 9 the change in the picture may seriously shake the faith. There are some manifest gains in this complete humanizing of our religion. We appreciate and try to practice much of the teaching of the Bible, particularly the words of Jesus, that meant nothing to us before. We enter with enthusiasm into Jesus' hope of the Kingdom of Heaven on earth, the social order in which men deal justly, kindly and faithfully with one another, and love is supreme. We discover for ourselves that it is more blessed to give than to receive, and all the earnestness we used to put into our prayers to God goes into our service of men. We form strong friendships that were quite impossible to childhood, and begin to explore the height, breadth, depth and length of love. Devo- tion to duty, honesty in dealing with truth, consecration to humanity make up our religion. We are content to accept the statement of ^ir Edward Burne- Jones: "There is only one religion ; *Make the most of your best for the sake of others' is the Catholic Faith, which except a man believe faithfully he cannot be saved." 10 UNIVERSITY SERMONS In a very real sense Jesus means more to us than He ever did. We have exchanged a good fairy for a human brother, tempted in all points like as we are. We draw from the biography of this limited Man, as we now consider Him, a sympathy and an inspiration we never found there before. We prefer to think that He was born as all men have been, had to acquire His force of will by struggle, had to hold His hopes in the face of discouragement and apparent defeat, had to battle to keep His faith in God. But just there, perhaps, we part company with Him; we are not sure that we have faith in God. At all events, we have lost that feeling of God's actual comradeship. His personal interest in and presence with us, which was so strong in childhood. If there is something we think should be done, we rely on planning and not on praying. If we are tempted, we do not think of Him who can send a guardian angel to defend us, or stand Himself at our side with flaming sword, but smnmon up our self-reliance and resolve to keep our self-respect. If we are saddened and disappointed, if life goes RELIGIOUS EXPERIENCE 11 against us and our heart aches, we do not run to a mother-like Deity to be soothed and comforted, but rather say, with Henley: Out of the night that covers me, Black as the pit from pole to pole, I thank whatever gods may be For my unconquerable soul. In the fell clutch of circumstance I have not winced nor cried aloud; Under the bludgeonings of chance My head is bloody, but unbowed. But have we lost nothing? We used to be genuinely frightened as children when we were naughty: "Thou, God, seest me." Now, provided nobody finds out, we are not much troubled by secret iniquities. If we had something difficult to do, it was strengthening to feel that an Almighty Partner helped us do it. There was infinite comfort in thinking that a great, kind Heart was touched by aU our pains, that a Hand reached down and held us up when we stumbled, that an Ear was always open to receive the confidences we were too shy to give anyone else, and a Father up yonder 12 UNIVERSITY SERMONS understood us as nobody else could. When we walked through a dark place it took the lump out of our throat to hear a Voice whispering, "Fear not ; I am with thee." Perhaps we find ourselves in circum- stances where we cannot help praying; and when we actually pray, it does not seem so utterly unreasonable. It is not that we get the things we pray for without effort, but we have a sense of getting Someone who shares the effort with us. And if we keep reading this Book which we regard as a collection of human literature, we discover that there is something in it that inspires us as no other literature. It seems to appeal to us at more points of our complex beings, to fit into every conceivable situation in which we happen to be, to meet us at deeper levels and to raise us to greater heights. Whatever our theory of its inspiration, we feel that this collection of writings inspires us with stronger, wiser, better impulses, principles, purposes than any other book. If we think often enough of the entirely human Jesus, our admiration grows to adoration. We find ourselves not applaud- ing Him; we bow our heads in reverence. RELIGIOUS EXPERIENCE 13 If we do more than think of Him, if we honestly try to follow Him merely as a man, using His methods in our dealings with men, facing perplexities, suffering, defeat, with His courage and hope, we find ourselves receiving from Him quite ines- timable inspiration. We are amazed at the fullness of love, of patience, of bravery, there is in Him. We wonder if His expla- nation of its source may not after all be correct. Was there really a God, the Father whom He trusted so implicitly as Lord of heaven and earth, in fellowship with Him? If there was, is there such a God still? Is not this the most reasonable explanation of the sense of companionship which we find when we are driven to pray? And if there be such a Father, must He not have wished to speak with His chil- dren — must He not have spoken? And are not these inspirations which come to us from the Bible His word through those who best understood Him? To be sure, that word came through entirely human experiences, through men who were often imperfect and mistaken, but however it came it does inspire us now. "As the appearance of the bow 14 UNIVERSITY SERMONS that is in the cloud in the day of rain," so is the appearance round about the Bible. Light streams from it — a completely human book with all the defects inevitable in what men do, but through the human the divine, the word of God. And if there be such a Father, must He not have wished to give His children a cor- rect likeness of Himself? When we feel constrained to adore Jesus, are we idolaters, or is He the expression of God in a human life? When we draw on His fullness and discover unsearchable riches, is it not because in Him we find the embodiment of God's character? Is it not because He, like God, is love? We are not looking for divinity now in the extraordinary and unhuman things about Him, we are finding His humanity divine. His complete manhood, in which He is bone of our bone and flesh of our flesh. His very Godhood. Taking Him as a man, and nothing more than a man, we are constrained to place Him upon the throne of our lives as our ideal, the Master we cannot but obey. And as we obey the Man, there is "a brightness round about Him." We say: "If I ever worship a God, I I RELIGIOUS EXPERIENCE 15 He must be the duplicate of this Man. A God unlike Him I refuse to worship, because I know a diviner than He." If we accept Jesus' own thought of His Father we find that Father's character reproduced in Jesus. This man is "the appearance of the likeness of the glory of Jehovah"; and when we see Him we fall upon our faces. In humanizing our religion we have not lost our God. We exchanged a good fairy for a brother, and in the brother we have discovered our Lord. So I beheld my God, in childhood's morn, A mist, a darkness, great and far apart. Moveless and dim — I scarce could say. Thou art. My manhood came, of joy and sadness born — Full soon the misty dark, asunder torn, Revealed man's glory, God's great human heart. There is a childhood to be outgrown and a childhood to be grown up to. When once we have become not orphans, however self- reliant, but trusting children, seeing God in the human, in Jesus, and in aU that is Jesus-like in any man, we are not quite so eager to label childish all the extraordinary elements in the Bible and about Jesus that 16 UNIVERSITY SERMONS fascinated our childhood's imagination. We lay no emphasis on them. We do not say- to any man, "You must believe them"; we say, "You may." We resent the literalist on the one hand, and the rationalist on the other, who would reduce all the poetry of religion to bald prose. The heart of a little child demands that his faith shall have scope for fancy. Of course we do not see in unusual occurrences past or present any- thing peculiarly Godhke, for the regular and ordinary are equally divine ; nor can the unhuman be diviner than the human, for our God has been most fully disclosed in a Man. But we discover that "human" is a much more expansive adjective than we had thought. We come to know men and women who do more and better things than the best fairy we ever heard of. We live with human beings who are as angels of light. We are not troubled with the marvellous in the past ; our present is too full of startling surprises ; even if these events of long ago are not all to be taken as literal history, they may con- tain elements of prophecy; they are symbols of faith and hope. We are working and waiting for a day when even Jesus shall be I RELIGIOUS EXPERIENCE 17 no longer unique, but when "God shall be aU in aU." Meantime we see our God in Jesus. We cannot prove His deity to anybody who does not make Him God by giving Him his entire devotion. And whoever does, needs no proofs. We accord this human Brother all our reverence, all our trust, all our ser- vice, and we do not rob His and our Father; for He and the Father are one in purpose. We draw upon Him for what God only can supply, and we are not disappointed. He does all for us God can do, for the Father touches us personally through Him and opens up His unsearchable riches in Him. We live to make Him Lord over all, assured that the loyalty yielded to Him is yielded to the Father to whom He gives back the Kingdom, and that in Him all men, as we, will find the fullness of the God- head bodily. We do not dehumanize Him; He is first of all and entirely Man ; but that does not mean that He is not also the com- plete revelation of God. When we survey the wondrous cross we see Man at his highest ; and that for us is God at His best. "This is the appearance of the likeness of 18 UNIVERSITY SERMONS the glory of Jehovah. And when I saw it, I fell upon my face." Love so amazing, so divine, Demands my soul, my life, my all. II RELIGIOUS PREPOSSESSIONS Hebrews 11:6. He that cometh to God must believe that He is. This remark seems on the one hand a truism. How can a man approach a God who has no real existence for him? Would anyone think of coining to God unless he thought there were such a Being? What a platitude to tell us that he that cometh to God must believe that He is! And on the other hand it sounds harsh and forbidding. The most earnest believers have their moments of uncertainty. Ours is an odd world, and there are some ugly facts that make God, or at all events the Christian God, appear highly incredible. Even so staunch a man of faith as Luther confessed, "At times I believe and at times I doubt"; and there is a letter of Hugh Latimer to his fellow-martyr Ridley, in which he pleads : "Pardon me and pray for me; pray for me, I say. For I am sometimes so fearful, that 20 UNIVERSITY SERMONS I would creep into a mouse-hole; sometimes God doth visit me again with His comfort. So He Cometh and goeth." And in the hour when God is gone, when the mind oscillates between believing that He still exists somewhere and believing that He has never come at all, is there no chance for the heart to go in search of Him through clouds and darkness, if haply there be a God to feel after and find? Is there no place in religion for the prayer, "O God, if there be a God, save my soul, if I have a soul" ? There is a rigid exclusiveness in the sentence, "He that cometh to God must believe that He is." Has not our author been too dogmatic? Let us see what he means. He does not say, "He that cometh to God must feel that He is a real Being." We know what it is to feel the presence of some- one in the room. We know the sensation of loneliness when we are by ourselves; we have a different feeling when we are aware of the other's presence, even if the room be so dark that we cannot see him and he never utters a syllable to us. Many, perhaps all, religious people have times when they sense God's presence exactly as they sense the RELIGIOUS PREPOSSESSIONS 21 presence of a man of flesh and blood. But this vivid realization of the Unseen requires the use of the imagination. Imaginative- ness varies in different temperaments, and in the same person at different ages. Santa Claus and fairies are entirely real to some children; they can hear the former up the chimney and fancy the latter in a park on a spring day. If in coming to God we must feel His reality and fancy Him actually present, it is much harder for an adult to come to Him than for a child, and as we grow up we grow away from God. Further, such feelings, like all feelings, fluctuate. They seldom move on a level plain; their course is over mountains and valleys. The weather, our health, circum- stances take them up or down, and lift us to heights where God seems entirely clear and near, or drop us to abysmal depths whence He appears to be utterly excluded. And even when we feel ourselves in touch with God may it not be merely an imagi- nation? And without consciousness of His existence, may we not be firmly in His hand, living and moving and having our being in Him? Smugly self-righteous people fancy 22 UNIVERSITY SERMONS themselves God's intimates and speak of blessed interviews with Him which are entirely real to them; while their acquaint- ances are certain that, if there be a God, He has singularly little influence for good upon His chosen, if these be His chosen. And on the other hand, there are some into whose thoughts God never comes, who impress us as the sort of people to whom a good God, if He exists, must be most close. Faith and feeling, faith and fancy, are not the same thing. Imagination is a vast help to faith. Ruskin said that "an unim- aginative person can neither be reverent nor kind." He cannot be kind because it requires imagination to place oneself in another's place and feel what he feels. He cannot be reverent because only he to whom God is vividly actual walks humbly before Him. Let faith fancy, but let us not confuse the two. Again our author does not say, "He that Cometh to God must understand what He is." There are a few exceptional people who reach God headfirst. A leading American theologian of the last generation, Henry B. Smith, said: "My determination RELIGIOUS PREPOSSESSIONS 23 to seek religion was formed solely in conse- quence of my complete persuasion of its reasonableness. I did not feel any need of it." But there are far more who "stand at the temple door heart in, head out." They may have moods when the sense of an Eternal Beauty, of which all lovely sights are passing gleams, entrances them; or when the consciousness of a mighty and inscru- table Force, back of all the energies active in the universe, awes them; or when a wisdom that baffles their search, an Ultimate Truth behind all the broken fragments of our unrelated notions, tantalizes their minds to go out and explore the unknown for it; ir when a Love, controlling all things for good and holding their lives in its gentle embrace, comes upon them as a thought so good they cannot help wishing it true; but as soon as they begin to use their intellects, and explain their mood to themselves, and I try to form some image of this Somewhat |Dr Someone Beautiful, Mighty, Wise, Loving, they can gain no clear conception; the mood itself passes, and they find them- selves in a world alone with things and people. 24 UNIVERSITY SERMONS It is certainly important that believing people should use their brains, and the clearer the conception we form of the God to whom we are coming the closer will we get to Him, and the more intelligent will be our fellowship. It was a true saying of George Eliot's that "the few may find them- selves in the religious life simply by an elevation of feeling; but for us who have to struggle for our wisdom, the higher life must be a region in which the affections are clad with knowledge." It is not enough for us to have a feeling of trust in a Somebody altogether good, so that at times a mood steals over us in which we are uplifted and soothed and inspired; we have to connect that Somebody with the great universe, with human history, with all that is happen- ing about us and with what goes on in our own hearts. And it is in thinking out, or in failing to think out, these connections that God becomes unreal to us. But let us not make the mistake of trying first to understand what God is and only afterwards coming to Him. We must first touch the shore and land, before we can explore the continent and chart out the RELIGIOUS PREPOSSESSIONS 26 mountains and rivers and plains. We must believe that He is, before we can understand what He is. Faith is the John Baptist that prepares the way for knowledge. We shall always have to be satisfied with a knowledge of God that allows for a huge ignorance about Him. The interior of that Continent it will take us all eternity to chart. But it is quite possible for Him to be inescapably actual to us, an abiding Reality, while we confess, "Verily, Thou art a God that hidest Thyself, O God of Israel, the Saviour." What then does our author mean by faith when he tells us so dogmatically, "He that Cometh to God must beheve that He is"? He begins this chapter with a definition: "Now faith is the giving substance to things hoped for, a conviction of things not seen." Herbert Spencer was right when he said that "prepossession is nine points of belief." Religion starts in us as a hope, a wish. Many men are not infidels who ought to be ; they do not really wish for a Christian God. If this were actually His world; if success be attainable only by doing His will, and if the only success attainable be the kind He Himself seeks, they would be very dis- ii^ UNnxRsnr sekmoks ami. aahiffy. The jor of Ji dKsortaf G<4aeG