M::k .;^^'-#^ r... ■^%*f- ^«r-%. ■#^^ffc? s VJ^ ^i THE LIBRARY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LOS ANGELES KATHA VATTHU. |0ali Cert ^octetp. KATHAVATTHU. EDITED BY ARNOLD C. TAYLOR, B.A. VOL. I, LONDON : PUBLISHED FOll THE PALI TEXT SOCIETY, BY HENRY FEOWDE, OXFOED UNIVERSITY PEESS WAEEHOUSE, AMEN COENEE, E.G. 1894. Ube (Brcsbam press, UNWIN BROTHERS, WOKING AND LONDON. PEOPESSOEI T. W. EHYS DAVIDS HANC KEDACTIONEM DEDICO, PALICAKUM LITTERARUM VETERANO INEXEKCITATUS, AMICUS AMICO. irnor„____ PKEFACE. In the preparation of this edition I have used the following MSS. :— I. In Sinhalese character : (a) A paper MS. from the collection of Professor Rhys Davids = P. (b) A palm-leaf MS. also belonging to Professor Ehys Davids = S. (c) A palm-leaf MS. from the collection of the late Dr. Morris, belonging to the Boyal Asiatic Society = S2. II. In Burmese character : Mandalay palm-leaf MS. from the India Office collection =^ M. III.- I have also made use of the edition of the Katha Vatthu recently published in Siamese character, and pre- sented by the King of Siam to the Library of the India Office. I have occasionally noted its readings, and have distinguished it as K. It may be of interest to Pali scholars to know^ that this edition — at any rate as far as may be inferred from the Katha Vatthu — approximates much more closely to the Burmese tradition than to the Sinhalese, in spelling as well as in textual readings. Broadly speaking, there is little difference between it and the Mandalay MS., a fact Vlll PREFACE. which would seem to point to the derivation of the hterary side at least of Siamese Buddhism from Burmese rather than Sinhalese sources. It is, however, perhaps premature to generalise from a single instance, and it would be interesting to know the opinion of scholars who have examined any other of the Pitaka texts in this edition. The three Sinhalese MSS. are exceedingly corrupt, and it would have been impossible to have produced an edition of the text without the help of the Mandalay MS. The Sinhalese MSS. are all based on a single archetype, as may be inferred from the fact that they agree in making the same omissions and mistakes (see notes on pp. 209, 227, 344, 380, 393, &c.). They are evidently the work of scribes who did not understand what they were writing, and a complete collation of their blunders would require a separate issue of the Pali Text Society. It is interesting to notice that in all the MSS. I have used, the form vy° never occurs, even in the Sinhalese MSS,, but always by°. Trenckner has pointed out in the preface to his edition of the Milindapahho that his oldest Sinhalese MSS. (as well as the Burmese) have by°, whereas by Childers in his Dictionary and by most of the editors of Pitaka Texts the form vy° has been employed. It is a curious coincidence that the two texts in which the by° form seems to predominate — the Katha Vatthu and the Milindapahho — are rather later than the bulk of the Pitakas themselves, as we know that the Katha Vatthu dates from the reign of Asoka, while the Milin- dapahho is of still later date. It is, perhaps, then, an admissible conjecture that the form vy° is the older, and was used in the earlier portions of the Canonical Texts, but was gradually superseded by the by° form, which finally, e.g. in the Katha Vatthu, supplanted the original spelling of the word. But a far more accurate knowledge of our MSS. than we possess at present is needed to decide the question, which is still further complicated by PEEFACE. IX the uncertainty of the date at which the Pitakas were committed to writing. In conclusion, my thanks are due to Professor C. H. Tawney, Librarian of the India Office, for the loan of the Mandalay MS. and the Siamese edition, and above all to Professor Rhys Davids, for his ever ready help and encouragement. AENOLD C. TAYLOE. London, August, 1897. [The issiie of this volume has been delayed by the fire which unfortunately took place at the printers' works in Surrey, on Nov. 23rd, 1895.1 INDEX OF QUESTIONS DISCUSSED IN THE KATHAVATTHU. CONTENTS OF VOL. I. Pathamo Vaggo. No. PAGE 1. Puggalo upalabbhati sacchikatthaparamatthe- nati? ... ... ... ... ... ... 1 2. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? ... ... ... 69 3. N'atthi devesu brahmacariyavaso ti ? ... ... 93 4. Odhisodhiso kilese jahatiti ? ... ... ... 103 _5^ Jahati puthujjano kamaragabyapadan ti ? ... 109 6. Sabbam atthiti'? ... ... ... ... ... 115 7 . Atltain khandha ti ? 143 8. Atltam atthiti ? 151 9. Sabbe dhamma satipatthana ti V ... ... ... 155 10. Atltam atthiti ? 159 Dutiyo Vaggo. 1. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisatthiti '? ... ... 163 2. Atthi Arahato aniianan ti ? ... ... ... 173 3. Atthi Arahato kahkiia ti '? 180 4. Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti ? ... ... ... 187 5. Samapannassa atthi vaclbhedo ti ? ... ... 195 6. Dukkhaharo maggangam maggapariyapannan ti ? 203 Xll INDEX TO QUESTIONS DISCUSSED No. - PAGE 7. Ekam cittam divasam titthatiti ? . . . ... ... 204 8. Sabbe samkhara anodhikatva kukkula ti ? ... 208 9. Annpnbbabhisamayo ti ? ... ... ... ... 212 10. Buddhassa bhagavato voharo lokuttaro ti ? ... 221 11. Dve nirodha ti? 225 Tatiyo Vaggo, 1. Tathagatabalam savakasadharanan ti ? ... ... 228 2. Thanathane yathabhutani iianam Tathagataba- lam ariyan ti ? ... ... ... ... ... 232 3. Saragam cittam vimuccatlti ■? ... ... ... 238 4. Vimnttam vimuccamanan ti ? ... ... ... 241 5. Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthipariyutthanam pahinan ti '? ... ... ... • . . . ... 243 6. Atthamakassa puggalassa n'atthi saddhindriyan tiV ". 247 7. Mamsacakkhmn dhammupatthaddham dibbacak- khmnhotlti? 251 8. Mamsasotam dhammupatthaddham dibbasotam hotiti? ' ' 254 9. Yathakammupagatam hanam dibbacakkhun ti ? 256 10. Atthi devesu sanivaro ti '? ... ... ... ... 258 11. Asahiiasattesu saiiha atthiti ? ... ... ... 260 12. NevasaiihanasaMayatane na vattabbam sahha atthiti? 263 Catuttho Vaggo. 1. Gihl'ssa Araha ti ? 267 2. Saha uppattiya Araha ti '? ... ... ... ... 268 3. Arahato sabbe dhamma anasava ti ? ... ... 271 4. Araha catuhi phalehi samannagato ti ? ... ... 274 5. Araha chahi upekkhahi samannagato ti ? ... 280 6. Bodhiya Buddho ti •? 281 7. Lakkhanasamannagato Bodhisatto ti ? ... IN THE KATHAVATTHU. Xlll No. PAGE 8. Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pavacane okkantaniyamo caritabrahmacariyo ti ? ... 286 9. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo tlhi phalehi samannagato ti? ... ... ... 290 10. Sabbasannojananam pahanam arahattan ti ? ... 298 Paiicanio Vaggo 1. Vimuttinanam viniuttan ti ? ... ... ... 301 2. Sekhassa asekhananaip atthiti ? ... ... ... H03 3. Pathavikasinasamapattim samapannassa viparlte iianan ti ? . . . ... ... ... ... ... 305 4. Aniyatassa niyamagamanaya attlii iianan ti ? ... 307 5. Sabbam nanam patisambhida ti '?... ... ... 309 6. Na vattabbam " Sammiitifianam saccarammanan iieva na aiinaranimanan ti " '? ... ... ... 310 7. Cetopariya5'e iianain cittarammanena aiinaram- niananti?... ... ... ... ... ... 311 8. Anagate nanani atthiti ? ... ... ... ... 313 9. Paccuppanne nanam atthiti ? ... ... ... 314 10. Savakassa phale hanani atthiti ? ... ... ... 315 / Kathavatthu. NAMO TASSA BHAGAVATO ARAHATO SAMMASAMBUDDHASSA. I. 1. 1. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi niggahain : hahci puggalo upalabbhati sacci- katthaparainatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Yo sacci- kattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthenati . ' ' Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthenati,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati," no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthenati." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthenati,' " miccha. Anuloma-paiicakain . 2. Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. ^ saccikatthaparamatthenati, P.S^; sacchikatthu. S. 2 2 KATHAVATTHU. Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi patikammam : hanci puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'puggalo n'upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' yo sacci- kattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthenati,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati," no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'puggalo n'upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' yo sacci- kattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthenati,' " miccha. Patikamma-catukkam . 3. Tvan ce pana mahhasi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe * yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati,'" tena tava ^ tattha h'etaya- patinfiaya h'evam patijanantam 3 h'evam niggahetabbe ; atha tarn nigganhama, suniggahlto ca hosi.4 Haiici pug- galo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, tena vata re vattabbe "-Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati. " Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'puggalo n'upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati,' " miccha. 1 tvam, K. ; tava all MSS. ^ go taya, P.S.Sg. 3 patijananam, P.S2. ; patijanam, S. 4 hoti, P.S.S2. KATHAVATTHU. 6 No ce pana vattabbe " Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikattliaparamatthenati," no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikattlia- paramatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'puggalo n'upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' yo sacci- kattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalabbhati sacci- kattliaparamatthenati,' " idaii ^ te micclia. Niggaha-catukkam. 4. Ese ~ ce dunniggahlte, h'evameva 3 tattha dakklia ; Vattabbe kho " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthena," no ca vattabbe " Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikattliaparamatthenati," no ca mayam taya tattha h'etaya patihhaya li'evam pati- jananta 4 h'evani niggahetabba ; atha main nigganhasi duiiniggahlta ca homa. Hahci puggalo upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Yo sacci- kattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikat- thaparamatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikattliapara- matthenati,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikattliaparamatthenati," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikattlia- paramatthenati . ' ' Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikattliapara- matthenati,' " idan 5 te miccha. Upanayana ^-catukkam. I idani, M. ^ go P.g.Sa. 3 Evamevam, M. 4 patijananto, S. 5 idani, S.M. 6 upanaya, S.S2. ; upanhaya, P. 4 KATHAYATTHU. 5. Na h'evam niggahetabbe, tena hi yain nigganhasi — Haiici puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparainatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so pug- galo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparainatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthenati,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo apalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati," no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthapara- inatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparainatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' yo saccikattho paramattho tato so i)uggalo upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthenati,' " idan te miccha — tena hi ye kate niggahe se^ niggahe dukkate, sukate - patikamme, sukata patipadana ti. Niggamana-catukkam. P a t h a m o N i g g a h o. Pathamasaccikattho . 6. Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati? Amanta. Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Na h'evani vattabbe. Ajanahi niggaham : hanci puggalo n'upalabbhati sacci- katthaparainatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Yo sacci- kattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthenati.' ' Yain tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'puggalo n'upalab- bhati saccikatthaparainatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' yo I so, P. So. 2 sukkate, P.S.So. KATHAVATTHU. 5 saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenilti,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati," no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthenati . ' ' Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo n'upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' yo sacci- kattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthenati,' " miccha. Paccanlka-pahcakani. I 7. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati? Amanta. Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi patikammain : haiici puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthenati . ' ' Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthenati,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati," no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthenati." Yain tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthenati,' " miccha. Patikamma-catukkam. ^ P.S.S2. omit Paccanika-paficakani. 6' KATHAVATTHU. 8. Tvan ce pana mannasi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparainatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati,' " tena tava tattha h'etaya ^ patiiinaya h'evam patijanantam - li'evam niggahetabbe ; atha tain nigganhania suniggahlto ca hosi. Haiici pug- galo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthenati,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati," no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthenati." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho 'puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthenati,' " idan te miccha. Niggaha-catukkain. 9. Ese 3 ce dunniggahlte, h'evameva tattha dakkha ; Vattabbe kho " Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthena," no ca vattabbe " yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati," no ca mayam taya4 tattha h'etaya patihhaya h'evaiu patijananta h'evam niggahetabba ; atha mam nigganhasi dunniggahlta ca homa. Hahci puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabe kho ' puggalo n'upalal)- I hota, S. - parijanantam, P. 3 eso, P.S.Sa. " 4 P.S.Sa. omit taya,. KATHAVATTHU. 7 bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe 'yo sacci- kattho paramattho tato so piiggalo n'upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthenati,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthenati . ' ' Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho* puggalo n'upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati,' " idan te miccha. Upanayana-catukkani . 10. Na h'evam niggahetabbe, tena hi yam nigganhasi — Hahci puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho ' puggalo n'upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' yo sacci- kattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthenati,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati,'" no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo n'upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe 'yo saccikattho paramattho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati.' " idan te miccha — tena hi ye kate niggahe se ^ niggahe dukkate, sukate patikamme, sukata patipadana ti. Niggamana-catukkam . Dutiyo Niggaho. I so, P.S.Ss. 8 KATHAVATTHU. 11. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Sabbattha puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthe- nati '? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi niggaham ; hafici puggalo upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Sabbattha puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe * sabbattha puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Sabbattha puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati," no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe 'sabbattha puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati,' " miccha — Pe— Tatiyo Niggaho. 12. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikat^hafparamatthenati '? Amanta. Sabbada puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthe- nati? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi niggahaija ; hahci puggalo upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Sabbada puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho 'puggalo upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' sab- bada puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Sabbada puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati," no ca vata re vattabbe " Pug- galo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." Yarn tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'puggalo upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' sab- KATHAVATTHU. 9 bada puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati,' " miccha. Catuttho Niggaho. 13. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Sabbesu puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthe- nati '? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi niggaham ; hahci puggalo upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Sabbesu puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' sabbesu puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Sabbesu puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati," no ca vata re vattabbe " Pug- galo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'puggalo upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' sabbesu puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati,' " miccha. P a n c a m o Niggaho. 14. Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Sabbattha puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamat- thenati ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi niggaham ; hanci puggalo n'upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Sabbattha puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo n'upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe 'sabbattlia puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati,' " mic- cha. . 10 KATHAVATTHU. No ce pana vattabbe " Sabbattha puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo n'upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' sabbattha puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati,' " miccha — pe — C h a 1 1 h o N i g g a h . 15. Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Sabbada puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthe- nati ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi niggahain ; haiici puggalo n'upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Sabbada puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo n'upa- labbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' sabbada puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthe- nati,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Sabbada puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati," no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati.' " Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'puggalo n'upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' sabbada puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparanatthenati,' " mic- cha. Sattamo Niggaho. 10. Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Sabbesu puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthe- nati ? Na h'evam vattabbe. KATHAVATTHU. 11 Ajanahi niggaham ; hanci puggalo n'upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamattliena, tena vata re vattabbe " Sabbesii pnggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati.' " Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'puggalo n'upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' sabbesu puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati,' " mic- ella. No ce pana vattabbe " Sabbesu puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati," no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi ' ' Vattabbe kho ' puggalo n'upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' sabbesu puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati,' " mic- ella. Atthako Niggaho. 17. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, ru- pan ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Aiiham rupain afiho puggalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi niggaham : hahci puggalo upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena, rupafi ca upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Ahham rupam aiino puggalo ti." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena riipah ca upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' ahham rupain ahfio puggalo ti,' " micella. No ce pana vattabbe "Ahham rupam anno puggalo ti," no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo upalal)bhati saccikattha- paramatthena, rupah ca upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthenati." Yarn tattha vadesi ' ' Vattabbe kho ' puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena rupafi ca upalabbhati sacci- 12 KATHAVATTHU. katthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' annaiii rupaiii anno puggalo ti,' " miccha — pe — 18. = 17. reading vedana for rupam. 19. = 17. reading saiiiia for rupani. 20. = 17. reading samkhara for rupain. 21. = 17. reading viiiiianam for rupam. 22. = 17. reading cakkhayatanam for rupani. 23. = 17. reading sotayatanam for rupam. 24. = 17. reading ghanayatanam for rupam. 25. =: 17. reading jivhayatanam for rupani. 26. =: 17. reading kayayatanam for rupain. 27. = 17. reading riipayatanam for rupani. 28. = 17. reading saddayatanam for riipain. 29. = 17. reading gandhayatanain for rupain. 30. = 17. reading rasayatanam for rupani. 31. = 17. reading photthabbayatanaiii for rupain. 32. = 17. reading manayatanain for rupam. 33. = 17. reading dhammayatanain for rupain. 34. = 17. reading cakkhudhatu for rupain. 35. = 17. reading sotadhatu for rupam. 36. = 17. reading ghanadhatu for rupain. 37. = 17. reading jivhadhatu for rilpani. 38. = 17. reading kayadhatu for rupain. 39. = 17. reading rupadhatu for rupam. 40. = 17. reading saddadhatu for rupam.. 41. = 17. reading gandhadhatu for rupain. 42. ^17. reading rasadhatu for rupain. 43. =: 17. reading photthabbadliatu for rupain. 44. = 17. reading cakkhuviniianadhatu for rupani. 45. = 17. reading sotaviiinanadhatu for rupam. 46. = 17. reading ghanavinnanadhatu for rupain. 47. = 17. reading jivhavinnanadhatu for rupam. 48. = 17. reading kayaviiifianadhatu for ruj)ani. 49. = 17. reading manodhatu for rupani. 50. = 17. reading manoviniianadhatu ^ for rupain. 51. = 17. reading dhammadhatu for rupani. I P.S.S2. omit. KATHAVATTHU. 13 52. = 17. reading- cakkhundriyam for rupam. 53. = 17. reading sotindriyam for rupain. 54. = 17. reading ghanindriyam for rupam. 55. = 17. reading jivhindriyam for rupam. 56. = 17. reading kayindriyam for rupaiii. 57. = 17. reading manindriyam for rupam. 58. = 17. reading itthindriyam for rupam. 59. = 17. reading purisindriyam for rujDam. 60. = 17. reading jlvitindriyam for rupam. 61. = 87. reading sukhindriyain for rupam. 62. = 17. reading dukkhindriyam for rupain. ''63. = 17. reading somanassindriyam for rupam. 64. = 17. reading domanassindriyam for rupani. 65. = 17. reading upekkhindriyain for rupam. 66. = 17. reading saddhindriyain for rupam. 67. = 17. reading viriyindriyam for riipam. 68. = 17. reading satindriyam for rupam. 69. = 17. reading samadhindriyam for rupain. 70. = 17. reading paniiindriyam for rupain. 71. = 17. reading anannatannassamitindriyani for rupam. 72. = 17. reading annindriyain for rupain. 73. = 17. reading aiinatavindriyam for rupain. 74. Puggalo n'upakibbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Vuttam Bhagavata — Atthi puggalo attahitaya pati- panno, rupan ca upakabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Afinam rupain aiiiio puggalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi patikammam : hafici vuttam Bhagavata — Atthi puggalo attahitaya patipanno, rupan ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenJlti, tena vata re vattabbe "Afinam rupam afino puggalo ti." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' vuttani Bhagavata — Atthi puggalo attahitaya patipanno, rupan ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' ahnani rupani anfio puggalo ti,' " miccha. 14 KATHAVATTHU. No ce pana vattabbe " Afmam rilpam anno puggalo ti," no ca vata re vattabbe ' ' Vuttam Bhagavata — Atthi puggalo attahitaya patipanno, rupan ca upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthenati . ' ' Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' vuttam Bhagavata — Atthi puggalo attahitaya patipanno, rupaii ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati,' no ca vattabbe ' aiiiiam rupam aniio puggalo ti,' " miccha. 75. = 74. reading vedana for rupain. 76. = 74. reading sahha for rupam. 77. = 74. reading samkhara for rupam. 78. = 74. reading vimianam for rupam. 79. = 74. reading cakkhayatanam for rupam — pe — . 129. = 74. reading ariiiatavindriyam for rupam. S u d d h i k a - s a m s a n d a n a. 130. Bupam upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, vedana ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, afiham rupam afiha vedana ti ? Amanta. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, rupah ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Ahham rupam anno puggalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi niggaham ; haiici rupam upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena, vedana ca upalabbhati saccikat- thaparamatthena, ahham rupam ahha vedana, puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, rupah ca upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Anham rupam anno puggalo ti." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' rupam upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, vedana ca upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena, ahham rupam ahha vedana, pug- galo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, rupah ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' ahham rupam anno puggalo ti,' " miccha. KATHAVATTHU. 15 No ce pana vattabbe " Annam rupam anno puggalo ti," no ca vata re vattabbe '• Rupain upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthena, vedana ca upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthena, annam rupam aniia vedana, puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, rupaii ca upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthenati. " Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' rupam upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, vedana ca upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena, aiinam rupam ahha vedana, puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthahaparamatthena, rupah ca upalab- bhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' aiiharn rupam anno puggalo ti,' " miccha. 131. ^ 130. reading sahha for vedana. 132. = 130. reading samkhara for vedana. 133. = 130. reading vifmanam for vedana. 134. Vedana upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, sahha ca upalabbhati — pe — samkhara ca upalabbhanti — pe — vihhanah ca upalabbhati — pe— rupah ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena — pe ; Sahha upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, samkhara ca upalabbhanti — pe — vihhanah ca upalabbhati — pe — rupah ca upalabbhati — pe — vedana ca upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena — pe ; Samkhara upalabbhanti saccikatthaparamatthena, vih- hanah ca upalabbhati — pe — rupah ca upalabbhati — pe — vedana ca upalabbhati — pe — sahha ca upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena — pe ; Vihhanam upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, rupah ca upalabbhati — pe — vedana ca upalabbhati — pe — sahha ca upalabbhati— pe — samkhara ca upalabbhanti sacci- katthaparamatthena, ahham vihhanam ahhe samkhara ti?* Amanta. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, vih- hanah ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Ahham vihhanani ahho puggalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. IG KATHAVATTHU. Ajanahi niggaham ; haiici vinnanam upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena, samkhara ca upalabbhanti sacci- katthaparamatthena, aniiam vinnanam anne sainkhara, piiggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena vinfianan ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Aniiam vinnanam afiho puggalo ti." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kno ' vihhanain upa- labbhati — pe — sainkhara ca upalabbhanti saccikattha- paramatthena, aiihain vinnanam aiihe samkhara, puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, vihhanaii ca upa- labbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' ahnam vihhanain ahiio puggalo ti,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Ahham vihhanain anno puggalo ti," no ca vata re vattabbe " vihhanain upalabbhati — pe — samkhara ca upalabbhanti saccikatthaparamatthena, ahham vinnanam ahhe samkhara, puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, vihhanah ca upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthenati . ' ' Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'vinnanam upa- labbhati — pe — sainkhara ca upalabbhanti saccikattha- paramatthena, ahham vihhanain ahhe samkhara, puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, vihhanah ca upa- labbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' ahham vihhanain anno puggalo ti,' " miccha. 135. Cakkhayatanam upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthena, sotayatanah ca upalabbhati — pe — , dhammaya- tanah ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena — pe — sotayatanam upalabbhati — pe — dhammayatanam upa- labbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, cakkhayatanah ca upalabbhati — pe — manayatanah ca upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena — pe — , Cakkhudhatu upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, sotadhatu ca upalabbhati — -pe — dhammadhatu ca upa- labbhati saccikatthaparamatthena — pe — sotadhatu upa- labbhati — pe — dhammadhatu upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthena, cakkhudhatu ca upalabbhati— pe — mano- vihhanadhatu ca upalabbhati sacchikatthaparamatthena — pe— , KATHAVATTHU. 17 Cakkhundri3'aiu upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena sotindriyan ca upalabbhati — pe — -annatavindriyan ca upa- labbhati saccikatthaparamatthena — pe — sotindriyam upa- labbhati — pe — ahfiatavindnyam upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthena, cakkhundriyan ca upalabbhati — pe — annindriyan ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, afinam aiinatavindriyaiu. annam aiihindriyah ti "? Amanta. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, anfui- tavindriyaii ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati V Amanta. Annam ahiiatavindriyam anno puggalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. iVjanahi niggahain ; hahci ahhatavindriyam upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, ahhindriyaii ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, aiiiiam ahiiatavindriyam aiiiiain ahhindriyam, puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamat- thena, afiiiatavindriyafi ca upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Ahhaiu ahiiatavindriyani anno puggalo ti." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho ' amiatavindriyain upalabbhati — pe — (saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vat- tabbe ' annam aiiiiatavindriyam anno puggalo ti,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Ahiiani ahhatavindriyam anno puggalo ti," no ca vata re vattabbe " Annatavindriyain upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, ahiiindriyah ca upalabbhati, ahham annatavindriyain ahham ahhindriyam, puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, annata- vindriyan ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' ahiiatavindriyani upalabbhati — pe — saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vat- tabbe ' ahhaiu ahhatavindriyam anno puggalo ti,' miccha. 136. Rupain upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena ve- dana ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, ahhain riipam ahha vedana ti ? Amanta. 3 18 KATHAVATTHU. Vuttam Bhagavata — Atthi puggalo attahitaya pati- panno, rupafi ca upalabbhati saccihatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Afinam rupam anno puggalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi patikammam : hanci rupam upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena vedana ca upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthena, anfiam rupam anna vedana, vuttain Bha- gavata — Atthi puggalo attahitaya patipanno, rupaii ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, tena vata re vat- tabbe " Afinam rupam aMo puggalo ti." Yarn tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'rupam upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena vedana ca upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena, aniiam rupam aniia vedana, vuttam Bhagavata — Atthi puggalo attahitaya patipanno rupaii ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe •' anfiam rupam ahfio puggalo ti,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Afifiam rupam afiho puggalo ti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Rupam upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthena vedana ca upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthena, aiiiiam rupam afiiia vedana, vuttam Bhagavata — Atthi puggalo attahitaya patipanno, rupafi ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati . ' ' Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' rupam upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena vedana ca upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena, afifiam riipam aiina vedana, vuttam Bhagavata — Atthi puggalo attahitaya patipanno riipan ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' Afifiam rupam afifio puggalo ti,' " miccha. 137. Rupam upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, safifia ca upalabbhati — pe — samkhara ca upalabbhanti — pe — viiifianafi ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena — Vedana upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, saMa ca upalabbhati — pe — samkhara ca upalabbhanti — pe^ viiifianafi ca upalabbhati — pe — rupaii ca upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena — pe — . Safifia upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, samkhara KATHAVATTHU. 19 ca upalabbhanti — pe — vinfianan ca upalabbhati — pe — rupafi ca upalabbhati — pe — vedana ca upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena — pe — . Samkhara upalabbhanti saccikatthaparamatthena, vifi- fianan ca upalabbhati — pe — rupah ca upalabbhati — pe — vedana ca upalabbhati — pe — sahna ca upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena — pe — . Vihiianam upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, rupah ca upalabbhati — pe — -vedana ca upalabbhati — pe — sahha ca upalabbhati — pe — samkhara ca upalabbhanti sacci- katthaparamatthena — pe — . Cakkhayatanam upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, sotayatanah ca upalabbhati — pe — dhammayatanaii ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena — pe — sotayatanani upalabbhati — pe — dhammayatanam upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena, cakkhayatanah ca upalabbhati — pe — manayatanah ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena — pe — . Cakkhudhatu upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, sota- dhatu ca upalabbhati — pe — dhammadhatu ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena — pe — sotadhatu upalabbhati — pe — dhammadhatu upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, cakkhudhatu ca upalabbhati — pe — manovihiianadhatu ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena — pe — . Cakkhundriyam upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, sotindriyafi ca upalabbhati — pe — afiiiatavindriyah ca upa- labbhati saccikatthaparamatthena — pe — sotindriyam upa- labbhati — pe — ahiiatavindriyam upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthena, cakkhundriyah ca upalabbhati — pe^ — ahhindriyaii ca upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena ahham ahhatavindriyam ahhain ahhindriyan ti '? Amanta. Vuttam Bhagavata — Atthi puggalo attahitaya pati- panno, ahhatavindriyaii ca upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthenati ? Amanta. Ahham ahhatavindriyam anno puggalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 20 KATHAVATTHU. Ajanahi niggahaiu ; lianci annatavinclriyain upalabbhati — pe — annam afinindriyain, vuttam Bhagavata — pe — saccikatthaparaniatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Annam annatavindriyam anno puggalo ti." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'annatavindriyam upalabbhati — pe — aiiiiain aniiindriyain, vuttaip Bhaga- vata — pe — saccikatthaparaniatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' annam annatavindriyam amio puggalo ti,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Ahhain annatavindriyam anno puggalo ti," no ca vata re vattabbe " Afiiiatavindriyam upalabbhati — pe — aiiham ahiiindriyain, vuttam Bhaga- vata — pe — saccikatthaparamatthenati . ' ' Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' annatavindriyam upalabbhati saccikatthaparaniatthena — pe- — aniiam ahhih- driyam, vuttam Bhagavata — pe — saccikatthaparaniat- thena,' no ca vattabbe ' aiiiiain ahiiatavindriyam anno puggalo ti,' " miccha. p a m 111 a - s a in s a 11 d a 11 a iii . 138. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati '^ Amanta. Eupam puggalo ti ? Na h'evaiii vattabbe. Ajanahi niggaham ; hahci puggalo upalabbhati sacci- katthaparaniatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Eupam pug- galo ti." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparaniatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' rupain puggalo ti,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Eupain puggalo ti," no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamat- thenati." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparaniatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' rupain puggalo ti,' " miccha. 189. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati? Amanta. Eupasmiin puggalo — pe — anfuitra rupii puggalo — pe — puggalasmiin rupaii ti ? KATHAVATTHU. 21 Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi niggahani ; hanci puggalo upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Piiggalasmim rupan ti." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' puggalasmim rupan ti,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Puggalasmim rupan ti," no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamat- thenati." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe 'puggalasmim rupan ti,' " miccha. 140. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati '? Amanta. Vedana puggalo — pe — vedanaya puggalo — pe — ahnatra vedanaya puggalo — pe — puggalasmim vedana — pe — Sahha puggalo — pe — sahiiaya puggalo — pe — ahnatra sahhaya puggalo — pe — puggalasmim sahha — pe — Samkhara puggalo — pe — samkharesu puggalo — pe — ahnatra samkharehi puggalo — pe— puggalasmim samkhara — pe — Vihhanam puggalo — pe — vihhanasmim puggalo — pe — ahnatra vihhana puggalo — pe — puggalasmim vihhanan ti"? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi niggahani ; hahci puggalo upalabl)hati sacci- katthaparamatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Puggalasmini vihhanan ti." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe 'puggalasmim vihhanan ti,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Puggalasmini vihhanan ti," no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthenati." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe * puggalasmini vihhanan ti,' " miccha. 141. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati? Amanta. Cakkhayatanam puggalo — pe — cakkhayataiiasmiiu pug- galo — pe — ahnatra cakkhayatana puggalo — pe — puggalas- mini cakkhayatanain — pe— 22 KATHAVATTHU. Anfiatavindriyam puggalo — pe — annatavindriyasmim puggalo — pe — afiiiatra annatavindriya puggalo — pe — pug- galasmim annatavindriyan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi niggaham ; hanci puggalo upalabbhati sacci- katthaparamatthena, tenavata re vattabbe " Puggalasmim annatavindriyan ti." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho ' P^^gg'^'*^ upalabbhati saccikatthaparaniatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' puggalasmim afinatavindriyan ti,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe "Puggalasmim afinatavindriyan ti," no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthenati." Yain tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparaniatthena," no ca vattabbe puggalasmim ahiiatavindriyan ti," miccha. 142. Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati? Amanta. Kilpam puggalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi patikammam ; hahci puggalo n'upalabbhati sac- cikatthaparaniatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Eupani puggalo ti." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparaniatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' rupam puggalo ti,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Eiipam puggalo ti," no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamat- thenati." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparaniatthena," no ca vattabbe ' rupain puggalo ti,' " miccha. 143. Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati? Amanta. Eupasmim puggalo — pe — ahhatra rupa puggalo — pe — puggalasmim rupan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi patikammam ; hanci puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, tena vata re vattabbe "Pugga- lasmim rupan ti." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho ' puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparaniatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' puggalasmim rupan ti,' " miccha. KATHAVATTHU. 23 No ce pana vattabbe " Puggalasmim rupan ti," no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamat- thenati." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho ' puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe 'puggalasmim rupan ti,' " miccha. 144. Puggalo n'upalabhati saccikatthaparamatthenati? Amanta. Vedana puggalo — pe — vedanaya puggalo — pe — anfiatra vedanaya puggalo — pe — puggalasmim vedana — pe — Sanfia puggalo — pe — saMaya puggalo — pe — anfiatra sannaya puggalo — pe — puggalasmim safifia — pe — Samkhara puggalo — pe — samkharesu puggalo — pe — aririatra samkharehi puggalo — pe — puggalasmim samkhara — pe— Viniianani puggalo — pe — viiinanasmiin puggalo — pe — aiifiatra vinfiana puggalo — pe— puggalasmim viiiiianan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi patikammam ; hanci puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena, tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalas- mim vinnanan ti." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho • • • ' puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe puggalasmim vinnanan ti," miccha. No ce pana vattabbe puggalasmim vinnanan ti, no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthenati." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho ' puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe puggalasmim viniianan ti," miccha. 145. Puggalo n'upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati? Amanta. Cakkhayatanam puggalo — pe — cakkhayatanasmim pug- galo — pe — anfiatra cakkhayatana puggalo — pe— puggalas- miin cakkhayatanam — pe — Afinatavindriy am puggalo — pe — aiinatavindriyasmim puggalo — pe — anfiatra annatavindriya puggalo — pe — pug- gal asmiin afinatavindriy an ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi patikammam ; hanci puggalo n'upalabbhati sac- cikattha])aramatthena, tena vata re vattabbe " Puggalas- 24 KATHAVATTHU. mim annatavindriyan ti. Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' puggalo n'upalabbliati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' piiggalasmim annatavindriyan ti," "' miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Puggalasmim aiinatavindriyan ti," no ca vata re vattabbe " Puggalo n'upalabbbati sacci- katthaparamatthenati." Yam tattba vadesi "Vattabbe kho ' puggalo n'upalabbliati saccikatthaparamatthena,' no ca vattabbe ' puggalasmim annatavindriyan ti,' " miccha. C a t u k k a n a y a — s a m s a n d a n a m. 146. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Puggalo sappaccayo — pe — puggalo appaccayo, puggalo sainkhato puggalo asamkhato, puggalo sassato, puggalo asassato, puggalo sanimitto puggalo animitto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 147. Puggalo n'upalabbliati saccikatthaparamatthenati? Amanta. Vuttam Bhagavata " Atthi puggalo attaliitaya pati- panno ti " '? Amanta. Puggalo sappaccayo — pe — puggalo appaccayo, puggalo sahkhato puggalo asankhato, puggalo sassato, puggalo asassato, puggalo sanimitto puggalo animitto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Lakkhanavuttikatlia. 148. Puggalo upalabbhati, upalabbhati puggalo ti? Puggalo upalabbhati, upalabbhati keliici puggalo, kehici na puggalo ti. Puggalo kehici upalabbhati, kehici na upalabbhatlti ? Na h evam vattabbe — pe — 149. Puggalo saccikattho saccikattho puggalo ti ? Puggalo saccikattho, saccikattho kehici puggalo, kehici na puggalo ti. EATHAVATTHU. '2o Pnggalo kehici saccikattho, kehici na saccikattho ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 150. PuggEilo vijjamano vijjamano pnggalo ti '? Pnggalo vijjamano, vijjamano kehici pnggalo, kehici na pnggalo ti ■? Pnggalo kehici vijjamano, kehici na vijjamano ti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — 151. Pnggalo sam vijjamano sam vijjamano pnggalo ti ? Pnggalo samvijjamano, sam vijjamano kehici pnggalo. kehici na pnggalo ti. Pnggalo kehici samvijjamano, kehici na samvijjamano ti? ^ Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 152. Pnggalo atthi atthi pnggalo ti ? Pnggalo atthi, atthi kehici pnggalo, kehici na pnggalo ti. Pnggalo kehici atthi, kehici n'anhiti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — 153. Pnggalo atthi, atthi na sabbo ^ pnggalo ti ? Amanta. Pnggalo natthi, n'atthi na sabbo pnggalo ti? Xa h"evam vattabbe — pe — Yacanasodhanam. 154. Enpadhatuya riipi ^ pnggalo ti '? Amanta. Kamadhatnya kami pnggalo ti '? Xa h'evain vattabbe — pe — Eupadhatuya rupino satta 3 ti ? Amanta. Kamadliatnya kamino satta ti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arnpadhatuya arupl pnggalo ti ? Amanta. ^ sabbe, S.P. = j^-^^^p^^ ^,l 3 sattha, S. 26 KATHAVATTHU. Kamadhatuya kami puggalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arupadhatuya arupino satta ti ? Amanta. Kamadhatuya kamino satta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 155. Eupadhatuya rupi puggalo arupadhatuya arupi puggalo, atthi ca koci ' rupadhatuya cuto arupadhatum 2 upapajjatiti ? Amanta. Eupi puggalo upacchinno 3 arupi puggalo jato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Eupadhatuya rupino satta, arupadhatuya arupino satta, atthi ca koci rupadhatuya cuto arupadhatum upapajja- titi ? Amanta. Eupl satto upacchinno arupi satto jato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 156. Kayo ti va sariran ti va 4 sariran ti va kayo ti va kayam 5 appiyam karitva, esese clfiatthe same samabhage ^ tajjate ti ? ' ^^ " Amanta. Puggalo ti va jivo ti va jivo ti va puggalo ti va pug- galam appiyam karitva esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate ti ? Amanta. Anno kayo anno puggalo ti ? Amanta. Ahham jivam aimam sariran ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi niggaham : haiici kayo ti va sariran ti va sariran ti va kayo ti va kayani appiyam karitva esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate, puggalo ti va jivo ti va jivo ti va puggalo ti va puggalam appiyam karitva esese I keci, S. 2 S. °tuya ; P. ^tu. 3 ucchinno, S.P. 4 va omit S. 5 ayam, P. 6 sabhage, P. KATHAVATTHU. 27 ekatthe same samabhage tajjate, aiino kayo aiino puggalo, tena vata re vattabbe " Aniiam iivam aniiani sariran ti." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' kayo ti va sariran ti va sariran ti va kayo ti va kayam appiyam karitva esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate, puggalo ti va jivo ti vS jivo ti va puggalo ti va puggalam appiyam karitva esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate, aniiokayo anno puggalo,' no ca vattabbe ' aiiiiam ilvam aiiiiam sariran ti,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Aniiam jivam aniiam sariran ti," no ca vata re vattabbe " Kayo ti va sariran ti va sariran ti va kayo ti va kayam appiyam karitva esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate, puggalo ti va jivo ti va jivo ti va puggalo ti va puggalam appiyam karitva esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate, ahiio kayo anno puggalo ti." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho ' kayo ti va sariran ti va sariran ti va kayo ti va kayam appiyam karitva esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate, puggalo ti va jivo ti va jivo ti va puggalo ti va puggalam appiyam karitva esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate, aiiiio kayo ahiio puggalo,' no ca vattabbe ' aiiham jIvam afiham sariran ti,' " miccha. 157. Kayo ti va sariran ti va sariran ti va kayo ti va kayam appiyam karitva esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate ti ? Amanta. Vuttam Bhagavata " Atthi puggalo attahitaya pati- panno ti " ? Amanta. Aiiiio kayo aiiiio puggalo ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe. Ajanahi patikammam : liaiici kayo ti va sariran ti va sariran ti va kayo ti va kayam appiyam karitva esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate, vuttani Bhagavata " Atthi puggalo attahitaya patipanno," tena vata re vattabbe " Afiho kayo ahiio puggalo ti." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' kayo ti va sariran ti va sariran ti va kayo ti va kayani appiyani karitva esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate, vuttam Bhagavata — ZO KATHAVATTHU. Atthi puggalo attahitaya patipanno ' no ca vattabbe ' anno kayo aiino puggalo ti,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Aiiiio kayo anno puggalo ti," no ca vata re vattabbe ' ' Kayo ti va, sarlran ti va saiiran ti va kayo ti va kayaiii appiyain karitva esese ekatthe same samabliage tajjate, vuttani Bhagavata Atthi puggalo attahitaya patipanno ti." Yam tattha vadesi " Vattabbe kho ' kayo ti va saiiran ti va sariran ti va kayo ti va kayain appiyam karitva esese ekatthe same samabliage tajjate, vuttani Bhagavata - Atthi puggalo attahitaya patipanno ' no ca vattabbe ' anno kayo amio puggalo ti,' " miccha. Paiiiiattanuyogo. 158. Puggalo sandhavati asma loka parani lokam parasma loka imam lokan ti ? Amanta. So puggalo sandhavati asma loka parain lokam parasma loka imam lokan ti ? Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — Puggalo sandhavati asma loka parani lokam parasma loka imain lokan ti ? Amanta. Anno puggalo sandhavati asma loka parani lokam parasma loka imam lokan ti ? Na li'evam vattabbe— pe. Puggalo sandhavati asma loka parani lokaiii parasma loka imam lokan ti '? Amanta. So ca ahiio ca sandhavati asma loka parain lokam parasma loka imam lokan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Puggalo sandhavati asma loka parain lokani parasma loka imain lokan ti '? Amanta. N'eva so sandhavati na aniio sandhavati asma loka param lokam parasma loka imam lokan ti ? KATHAVATTHU. 29 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Puggalo sandhavati asma loka paraiu lokam parasma loka imain lokan ti ? Ainanta. So puggalo sandhavati, aniio puggalo sandhavati, so ca anno ca sandhavati, n'eva so sandhavati na anno sandha- vati asma loka param lokam parasma loka imain lokan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe. 159. Na vattabbam " Puggalo sandhavati asma loka param lokam parasma loka imam lokan ti " ? x\manta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Sa^ sattakkhattuparamam sandhavitvana puggalo Dukkhassantakaro hoti sabbasahiiojanakkhaya ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti '? Amanta. Tena hi puggalo sandhavati asma loka parani lokain parasma loka imam lokan ti. Na vattabbam " Puggalo sandhavati asma loka param lokam parasma loka imam lokan ti "? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Anamataggayani Bhik- khave sainsaro, pubba - koti na pahiiayati avijjamvarana- nam sattanam tanhasahiiojananam sandhavatain samsa- ratansti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi puggalo sandhavati asma loka param lokam parasma loka imam lokan ti. 1(50. Puggalo sandhavati asma loka param lokam parasma loka imam lokan ti ? Amanta. Sv'eva puggalo sandhavati asma loka parani lokam parasma loka imani lokan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sv'eva. puggalo sandhavati asma loka param lokam parasma loka imain lokan ti ? Amanta. Atthi koci manusso hutva devo hotiti ? x\manta. Sv'eva manusso so devo ti '? ^ Sa omitted in MSS. but cf. Itivuttaka III. 4. (Windisch). - °bba, M. 3 osaran, ti S. 30 KATHAVATTHU. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sv'eva manusso so devo ti ? Amanta. Manusso hutva devo hoti, devo hutva manusso ^ hoti manussabhuto, anno devo anno manussabhuto, sv'evayam sandhavatiti, miccha — pe — Sace hi sandhavati sv'eva puggalo ito cuto param lokam ^ ananno,^ h'evam maranam na hehiti ^ panatipato n'upalab- bhati, kammam atthi, kammavipako atthi, katanam kam- manam vipako atthi, kusalakusale vipaccamane sv'evayam sandhavatiti, miccha. 161. Sv'eva puggalo sandhavati asma loka param lokam parasma loka imam lokan ti '? Amanta. Atthi koci manusso hutva yakkho hoti, peto hoti, nerayiko hoti, tiracchanagato hoti, ottho hoti, gono hoti, gadrabbho hoti, sukaro hoti, mahiso 3 hotiti? Amanta. Sv'eva manusso so mahiso ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sv'eva manusso so mahiso ti '? Amanta. Manusso hutva mahiso hoti, mahiso hutva manusso hoti manussabhuto, anno mahiso ahfio manussabhiito, sv' evayam sandhavatiti, miccha — pe — Sace hi sandhavati sv'eva puggalo ito cuto param lokam anahho, h'evam maranani na hehiti panatipato n'upalabbhati, kammam atthi, kammavipako atthi, kata- nam kammanam vipako atthi, kusalakusale vipaccamane .sv'evayam sandhavatiti, miccha. 162. Sv'eva puggalo sandhavati asma loka param lokani parasma loka imam lokan ti ? ^ K. omits manusso. 2 paraloka, P. ; ahfio, P.S. ; hehiti, M., hotiti, P.S. ; in next section P. has paralokain, anahho, hehiti. 3 mahimso, M. KATHAVATTHU. 31 Amanta. Atthi koci Khattiyo hutva Brahmano hotiti ? Amanta. Sv'eva Khattiyo so Brahmano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi koci Khattiyo hutva Vesso hoti, Suddo hotiti ? Amanta. Sv'eva Khattiyo so Suddo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi koci Brahmano hutva Vesso hoti Suddo hoti Khattiyo hotiti ? Amanta. Sv'eva Brahmano so Khattiyo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi koci Vesso hutva Suddo hoti Khattiyo hoti Brahmano hotiti ? Amanta. Sv'eva Vesso so Brahmano ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi koci Suddo hutva Khattiyo hoti Brahmano hoti Vesso hotiti ? Amanta. Sv'eva Suddo so Vesso ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 163. Sv'eva puggalo sandhavati asma loka param lokam parasma loka imam lokan ti ? Amanta. Hatthacchinno hatthacchinno va hoti, padacchinno padacchinno va hoti, hatthapadacchinno hatthapadac- chinno va hoti, kannacchinno nasacchinno kannanasac- chinno, ahguhcchinno alacchinno kandaracchinno, kuni- hatthako phanahatthako kutthiyo gandhiyo kilasiyo sosiyo apamariyo ottho gono gadrabho sukaro mahiso mahiso va hotiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 164. Na vattabbam " Sv'eva puggalo sandhavati asma loka param lokam parasma loka imam lokan ti " ? Amanta. 32 KATHAVATTHU. Nanu sotapanno puggalo manussaloka cuto devalokam upapanno tattha pi sotapanno va hotiti ? Amanta. Hanoi sotapanno puggalo manussaloka cuto devalokam upapanno tattha pi sotapanno va hoti, tena vata re vattabbe " Sv'eva puggalo sandhavati asma loka parain lokam parasma loka imam lokan ti." Sotapanno puggalo manussaloka cuto devalokam upa- panno tattha pi sotapanno va hotiti katva tena ca kara- iiena sv'eva puggalo sandhavati asma loka param lokain parasma loka imam lokan ti V Amanta. Sotapanno puggalo manussaloka cuto devalokam upa- panno tattha pi manusso hotiti ? ' Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 165. Sv'eva puggalo sandhavati — pe — imam lokan ti? Amanta. Anahho avigato sandhavatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ananho avigato sandhavatiti ? Amanta. Hatthacchinno hatthacchinno va hoti mahiso va hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 166. Sv'eva puggalo sandhavati — pe — imam lokan ti ? Amanta. Sarupo sandhavatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sarupo sandhavatiti ? Amanta. Tain jlvain tain saiiran ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Savedano — pe — sasanho — pe — sasainkharo — pe — savin- nano sandhavatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Savihnano sandhavatiti ? ^ M. has katva after hotiti. KATHAVATTHU. 33 Amanta. Tarn jivam tarn sarlran ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 167. Sv'eva pnggalo sandhavati asma loka — pe — imrun lokan ti ? Amanta. Arupo sandhavatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arupo sandhavatiti "? Amanta. Ahham jIvam ahham sarlran ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Avedano — pe — asaiino — pe — asamkharo — pe — avifihano sandhavatiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe— Avihhano sandhavatiti '? Amanta. Ahham ilvam ahham sarlran ti ? • el « • Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 168. Sv'eva pnggalo sandhavati asma loka — pe — imam lokan ti '? Amanta. Riipam sandhavatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Bupam sandhavatiti ? Amanta. Tam ilvam tam sarlran ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vedana — pe — sahha — pe — samkhara — pe — vihhanain sandhavatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Vihhanain sandhavatiti ? Amanta. Tam jivaiii tam sarlran ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 169. Sv'eva pnggalo sandhavati — pe — imam lokan ti ? Amanta. Rhpani na sandhavatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Eupaiii na sandhavatiti ? Amanta. 4 34 KATHAVATTHU. Annam iivam annaiu sarlran ti *? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Vedana — pe — saiina — pe — samkhara — pe — viniianam na sandhavatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vifinanam na sandhavatiti ? Amanta. Aiiham iivani ahnam sariran ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 170. Khandhesu bhijjamanesu ^ so ce bhijjati puggalo Uccheda bhavati - ditthi ya Buddhena vivajjita. Khandhesu bhijjamanesu no ce bhijjati puggalo Puggalo sassato hoti nibbanena samasamo 3 ti. 171. Rupam upadaya puggalassa paniiattiti ? Amanta. Rupam aniccam samkhatain paticcasamuppannam kha- yadhammam vayadhammam viragadhammam nirodha- dhammam viparinamadhamman ti '? Amanta. Puggalo pi anicco samkhato paticcasamuppanno khaya- dhammo vayadhammo viragadhammo nirodhadhammo viparinamadhannno ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 172. Vedanam upadaya — pe — sahhaiii upadaya — pe — samkhare upadaya — pe — vinhanam upadaya puggalassa pahhattiti '? Amanta. Vinhanam aniccam — pe — viparinamadhamman ti ? Amanta. Puggalo pi anicco — pe — viparinamadhammo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 173. Riipam upadaya puggalassa pahhattiti ? Amanta. Nilam riipam upadaya nllakassa puggalassa pahhattiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — vijj°, P. 2 tava, P. 3 samasama, P. KATHAVATTHU. 35 Pitam rupain upadaya, Lohitam rupain upadaya, Odataiu rupam upadaya, Sanidassanam rupam upadaya, Anidassanam rupam upadaya, Sappatigham rupam upadaya, Appatigham rupam upadaya appatighassa pugalassa pannatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 174. Vedanain upadaya puggalassa pannattiti? Amanta. Kusalam vedanam upadaya kusalassa puggalassa pan- nattiti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kusalam vedanam upadaya kusalassa puggalassa pan- nattiti '? Amanta. Kusala vedana saphala savipaka itthaphala kantaphala manufiiiapliala asecanakaphala ^ sukhudraya^ sukhavipaka ti? Amanta. Kusalo pi puggalo saphalo savipako ittliaphalo kanta- phalo manuiliiaphalo asecanakaphalo sukhudrayo sukhavi- pako ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe^ 175. Vedanam upadaya puggalassa pannattiti ? Amanta. Akusalam vedanam upadaya akusalassa puggalassa pannattiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Akusalam vedanam upadaya akusalassa puggalassa paiihattiti ? Amanta. Akusala vedana saphala savipaka anitthaphala akanta- ^ asecanaphala, P.S. 2 sukhindriya, P.S. Sa always. 3G KATHAVATTHU. phala amanunnaphala secanakaphala dukkhndraya duk- khavipaka ti ? Amanta. Akusalo pi puggalo saphalo savipako anitthaphalo akantaphalo amanimnaphalo secanakaphalo dnkkhudrayo diikkliavipako ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 176. Vedanam upadaya puggalassa pamiattiti? Amanta. Abyakatam vedanam upadaya abyakatassa puggalassa pannattiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Abyakatain vedanam upadaya abyakatassa puggalassa paiinattiti ? Amanta. Abyakata vedana anicca samkhata paticcasamuppanna khaj^adhamma vayadhamma viragadhammanirodha- dhamma viparinamadhannna ti ? Amanta . Abyakato pi puggalo anicco samkhato — pe — viparina- madhammo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 177. Sannam upadaya, samkhare upadaya, viiinanam upadaya puggalassa paniiattiti ? Amanta. Kusalain vinhanam upadaya kusalassa puggalassa paii- nattiti '? Na h'evani vattabbe. Kusalain vifinanain saplialani savipakam itthaphalani, kantaphalani manufifiaphalam asecanakaphalani sukhu- drayam sukhavipakan ti ? Amanta. Kusalo pi puggalo saphalo savipako itthaphalo kanta- phalo manuniiaphalo asecanakaphalo sukhudrayo sukhavi- pako ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 178. Viiihanam upadaya puggalassa paniiattiti ? Amanta. KATHAVATTHU. 37 Akusalam vifinanam upadaya akusalassa puggalassa pannattiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Akusalam viiinanam iipadaya akusalassa puggalassa pannattiti '? Amanta. Akusalam vinnanam saphalam savipakam anitthaphalam akantaplialam amanunnaphalain secanakaphalam dukkhu- drayam dukkhavipakan ti ? Amanta. Akusalo pi puggalo saphalo savipako anitthaphalo akantaphalo amanunnaphalo secanakaphalo dukkhudrayo dukkliavipako ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 179. Vinfianam upadaya puggalassa paiiilattlti '? Amanta. Abyakatam viniianam upadaya abyakatassa puggalassa paniiattiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Abyakatam vinnanam upadaya abyakatassa puggalassa paiifiattiti ? Amanta. Abyakatain vinnanam aniccain sainkhatani paticcasamup- pannain khayadhammam vayadhammam viragadhamma- nirodhadhammam viparinamadhamman ti ? Amanta. Abyakato pi puggalo anicco sainkhato — pe — viparina- madhammo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe--- 180. Cakkhuiu upadaya cakkhuma puggalo ti vattabbo ti '?_ Amanta. Cakkhumhi niruddhe cakkhuma puggalo niruddho ti vattabbo ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Hotain upadaya ghanam upadaya jivham upadaya 38 KATHAVATTHU. kayam upadaya iiianam upadaya manava puggalo ti vattabbo ti ? Amanta. Manamhi niriiddhe manava puggalo niruddho ti vat- tabbo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 181. Micchaditthiin upadaya micchaditthiyo puggalo ti vattabbo ti ? Amanta. Micchaditthiya niruddhaya micchaditthiyo puggalo niruddho ti vattabbo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Micchasahkappam upadaya, Micchavacam upadaya, Micchakammantam upadaya, Miccha-ajivam upadaya, Micchavayamam upadaya, Micchasatim upadaya, Micchasamadhim upadaya micchasamadhiyo puggalo ti vattabbo ti ? Amanta. Micchasamadhimhi niruddhe micchasamadhiyo puggalo niruddho ti vattabbo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 182. Sammaditthim upadaya sammaditthiyo puggalo ti vattabbo ti ? Amanta. Sammaditthiya niruddhaya sammaditthiyo puggalo niruddho ti vattabbo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sammasahkappam upadaya, Sammavacam upadaya, Sammakammantam upadaya, Samma-ajlvam upadaya, Sammavayamam upadaya, Sammasatim upadaj^a, Sammasamadhim upadaya sammasamadhiyo puggalo ti vattabbo ti? Amanta. KATHAVATTHU. 39 Sammasamadhiinhi niruddhe sammasamadhiyo puggalo niruddho ti vattabbo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 183. Rilpani upadaya vedanam upadaya puggalassa pannattlti ? Amanta. Dvinnain khandanam upadaya dvinnam puggalanam pannattlti ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Eupam upadaya, vedanam upadaya, saiiiiam upadaya, samkliare upadaya, vinnanam upadaya puggalassa pannattlti ? Amanta. Pancannam khandanam upadaya pahcannam pug- galanam pannattlti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 184. Cakkhayatanam upadaya, sotayatanam upadaya puggalassa paiihatlti ? Amanta. Dvinnam ayatananam upadaya dvinnam puggalanam pahhattiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkhayatanam upadaya, sotayatanam upadaya — pe — dhammayatanam upadaya puggalassa pahhattiti ? Amanta. Dvadasannam ayatananam upadaya dvadasannam pug- galanam pahhattiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 185. Cakkhudhatum upadaya sotadhatum upadaya puggalassa pahhattiti ? Amanta. Dvinnain dhatunani upadaya dvinnam puggalanam pahhattiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Cakkhudhatuin upadaya sotadhatuin upadaya — pe — dhammadhatuin upadaya puggalassa pahhattiti ? 40 KATHAVATTHU. Amanta. Attharasannam dhatunam upadaya attharasannam puggalanain panfiattlti *? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 186. Cakkhundriyam upadaya sotindriyam upadaya puggalassa pannattiti ? Amanta. Dvinnam indriyanam upadaya dvinuam puggalanam pannattiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkhundriyam upadaya sotindriyam upadaya — pe — ahhatavindriyam upadaya puggalassa pahiiattlti ? Amanta. Bavlsatlnam indriyanam upadaya bavlsatlnain pugga- lanam pannattiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 187. Ekavokarabhavam upadaya ekassa puggalassa pannattiti ? Amanta. Catuvokarabhavam upadaya catunnam puggalanam pannattiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ekavokarabhavam upadaya ekassa puggalassa pan- nattiti ? Amanta. Paiicavokarabhavani upadaya pancannam puggalanain pannattiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 188. Ekavokarabhave eko va puggalo ti ? Amanta. Catuvokarabhave cattaro va puggala ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ekavokarabhave eko va puggalo ti ? Amanta. Pahcavokarabhave pahc'eva puggala ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — KATHAVATTHU. 41 189. Yatha rukkhain upadaya chayaya paiinatti , evanieNa rupam upadaya puggalassa pannattlti, yatha riikkhani iipadaya chayaya pahnatti, rukkho pi anicco chaya pi anicca, evameva rupam upadaya puggalassa pahnatti rupam aniccam puggalo pi anicco ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Yatha rukkhani upadaya chayaya pahnatti anno rukkho ahha chaya, evaineva rupam upadaya puggalassa pan- nattlti, ahhani rilpam anno puggalo ti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 190. Yatha gamain upadaya gamikassa pahiiatti, evain eva rupam upadaya puggalassa pahhattiti, yatha gamam upadaya gamikassa pahnatti, anno gamo anno gamiko, evameva rupam upadaya puggalassa pahnatti, ahham rupam anno puggalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— 191. Yatha ratthain upadaya rahho pahnatti, evain- eva rupa upiidaya puggalassa pahhattiti, yatha ratthain upadaya rahho pahnatti, anno rattho anno raja, evaineva rupam upadaya puggalassa pahnatti, ahhain rupain anno puggalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 192. Yatha na nigalo negaliko, yassa nigalo so negaliko, evameva na rupain rupava, yassa rupam so rupava ti, yatha na nigalo negaliko yassa nigalo so negaliko, anno nigalo anno negaliko, evam evam na riipam riipava yassa rupam so rupava, ahham rupam anno rupava ti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 193. Citte citte puggalassa pahhattiti? Amanta. Citte citte puggalo jayati jiyyati ^ miyyati ~ cavati uppajjatiti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe— 194. Dutiye citte uppanne na vattabbain " So ti va anno ti va ti " ? jiy°, P. 2 p_ and S. omit. 42 KATHAVATTHU. Amanta. Dutiye citte uppanne na vattabbam " Kumarako ti va kumarika ti va ti " ? Vattabbam. Ajanahi niggahain : haiici dutiye citte uppanne na vattabbam "So ti va anno ti va," tena vata re vattabbe "Dutiye citte uppanne na vattabl^am kumarako ti va kumarika ti va ti." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'dutiye citte uppanne na vattabbani so ti va aiino ti va,' ' dutiye citte uppanne vattabbam kumarako ti va kumarika ti va ti,' " miccha. Hanci va pana dutiye citte uppanne vattabbam ' ' Kuma- rako ti va kumarika ti va," tena vata re vattabbe "Dutiye citte uppanne na vattabbam so ti va aiiiio ti va ti." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho "dutiye citte uppanne na vattabbam so ti va anno ti va,' ' dutiye citte uppanne vattabbam kumarako ti va kumarika ti va ti,' " miccha. 195. Dutiye citte uppanne na vattabbam "So ti va aiiiio ti va ti " V Amanta. Dutiye citte uppanne na vattabbain " Itthiti va puriso ti va, gahattho ti va pabbajito ti va, devo ti va manusso ti va ti V " Vattabbam. Ajanahi niggaham : hailci dutiye citte uppanne na vattabbani " So ti va anno ti va," tena vata re vattabbe " Dutiye citte uppanne na vattabbani devo ti va manusso ti va ti." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'dutiye citte uppanne na vattabbain so ti va anno ti va,' ' dutiye citte uppanne vattabbam kumarako ti va kumarika ti va ti," " miccha. Hahci va pana dutiye citte uppanne vattabbain " Devo ti va manusso ti va ti," tena vata re vattabbe " Dutiye citte uppanne na vattabbani so ti va afiho ti va ti." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'dutiye citte uppanne na vattabbam so ti va anno ti va.' ' dutiye citte uppanne vattabbam devo ti va manusso ti va ti,' " miccha. 190. Xa vattabbain " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthenati " ? Amanta. KATHAVATTHU. 43 Nanu yo passati yam passati yena passati, so passati tarn passati tena passatiti? Aiiianta. Hanoi yo passati yam passati yena passati, so passati tarn passati tena passati, tena vata re vattabbe "Pnggalo npalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati . ' ' Na vattabbam " Pnggalo npalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthenati " ? Amanta. Nanu yo snnati, yo ghayati, yo sayati, yo phnsati,'^ yo vijanati, yam vijanati, yena vijanati, so vijanati, tarn vijanati, tena vijanatiti "? Amanta. Hanoi yo vijanati, yam vijanati, yena vijanati, so vijanati, tarn vijanati, tena vijanattiti, tena vata re vattabbe, "Pnggalo npalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthena- ti." 197. Pnggalo npalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati? Amanta. Nanu yo na passati, yam na passati, yena na passati, so na passati, tarn na passati, tena na passatiti ? Amanta. Haiici yo na passati, yam na passati, yena na passati, so na passati, tarn na passati, tena na passati, no oa vata re vattabbe "Pnggalo npalabbhati saccikatthaparamat- thenati." Pnggalo npalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Nanu yo na snnati yo na ghayati yo na sayati yo na phusati yo na vijanati, yam na vijanati, yena na vijanati so na vijanati, tain na vijanati, tena na vijanatiti '? Amanta. Haiici yo na vijanati, yaiji na vijanati, yena na vijanati, so na vijanati tain na vijanati tena na vijanati, no ca vata phussati, M. 44 KATHAVATTHU. re vattabbe " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamat- thenati." 198. Ka vattabbain " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikattlia- l^aramatthenati " '? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Passam' aham Bhikkave (libbena cakkhuna visuddhena atikkantamanusakena satte cavaniaiie uppajjamane hlne panlte suvanne dubbanne sugate duggate yathakammupage satte pajaiiainiti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamattheua,- ti. 199. Vuttam Bhagavata "Passam' ahain Bhikkave dibbena cakkhuna visuddhena atikkantamanusakena satte cavamane uppajjamane hlne panlte suvanne dubbanne sugate duggate yathakammupage satte paja- namlti " katva, ten'eva karanena puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Bhagava dibbena cakkhuna visuddhena atikkantama- nusakena rupam passati puggalani passatiti, rupam passati, rupani puggalo, rupain cavati, rupain uppaj- jati, rupain yathakammupagan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Bhagava dibbena cakkhuna visuddhena atikkantama- nusakena rupain passati puggalain passatiti, puggalam passati, puggalo rupaiii riipayatanain rilpadhatu nllain pltakain lohitakain odatain cakkhuviMeyyam cakkhus- miin I patihahhati cakkhussa apatham ^ agacchatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Bhagava dibbena cakkhuna, visuddhena atikkantama- nusakena rupain passati puggalain passatiti, ubho passati, ubho rupain rupayatanam rilpadhatu, ubho nlla, ubho pitaka, ubho lohitaka, ubho odata, ubho cakkhuvihheyya, ^ cakkhumhi, S.Sa. 2 abadham, S. ; apatain, M. KATHAVATTHU. 45 ubho cakkhusmim patihaiinanti, ubho cakkhussa apathain agacchanti, ubho cavanti, ubho uppajjanti, iibho yatha- kanunupaga ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. U p a d a p a n ii a 1 1 a n 11 y o y o . •200.' Kalyanapapakani kamniani npalabbhantiti ? Anianta. Kalyanapapakanam kammanain katta kareta npalab- l)hatlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 201. Kalyanapapakani kammani npalabbhantiti kalya- napapakanam kammanain katta kareta upalabbhatiti ? Amanta. Tassa katta kareta upalabbhatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tassa katta kareta upalabbhatiti ? Amanta. Tassa tass'eva n'atthi dukkhassa antakiriya n'atthi vattupacchedo n'atthi anupadaparinibbanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kalyanapapakani kammani upalabbhanti kalyanapapa- kanam kammanain katta kareta upalabbhatiti V Amanta. Puggalo upalabbhatiti, puggalassa katta kareta upalab- bhatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kalyanapapakani kammani upalabbhanti kalyanapapa- kanam kammanam katta kareta upalabbhatiti ? Amanta. Nibbanam upalabbhatiti, nibbanassa katta kareta upa- labbhatiti ? I P. and S. omit sec. 200. 46 KATHAVATTHU. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kalyanapapakani kammani — pe — kareta upalabbhatiti '? Amanta. Mahapathavl upalabbhatiti, mahapathaviya katta kareta upalabbhatiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe— pe — Kalyanapapakani kammani — pe — kareta upalabbhatiti '? Amanta. Mahasamuddo upalabbhatiti, mahasamuddassa katta kareta upalabbhatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kalyanapapakani kammani — pe — kareta upalabbhatiti '? Amanta. Sineru pabbataraja upalabbhatiti, Sinerussa pabbata- ranfio katta kareta upalabbhatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kalyanapapakani kammani — pe — kareta upalabbhatiti ? Amanta. Apo upalabbhatiti, apassa katta kareta upalabbhatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kalyanapapakani kammani — pe — kareta upalabbhatiti ? Amanta. Tejo upalabbhatiti, tejassa katta kareta upalabbhatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Kalyanapapakani kammani — pe — kareta upalabbhatiti ? Amanta. Vayo upalabbhatiti vayassa katta kareta upalabbhatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kalyanapapakani kammani — kareta upalabbhatiti ? Amanta. Tinakatthavanappatiyo upalabbhanti, tinakatthavanap- patlnam katta kareta upalabbhatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kalyanapapakani kammani — pe — kareta upalabbhatiti ? Amanta. Anna kalyanapapakani kammani anno kalyanapapa- kanain kammanam katta kareta ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — KATHAVATTHU. 47 202. Kalyanapapakclnam kammanani vipako npalal^bha- titi? Amanta. Kalyanapapakanain kammanam vipakapatisamvedi ' iipalabbhatlti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 208. Kalyanapapakanain kammanam vipako iipalabbha- tlti, kalyanapapakanain kammanam vipakapatisamvedi Iipalabbhatlti ? Amanta. Tassa patisamvedl iipalabbhatlti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tassa patisamvedl iipalabbhatlti ? Amanta. Tassa tass'eva n'atthi diikkhassa antakiriya n'atthi vattiipacchedo n'atthi aniipadaparinibbanan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kalyanapapakanain kammanam vipako — pe — vipakapa- tisamvedi upalabbhatiti "? Amanta. Puggalo upalabbhatiti piiggalassa patisamvedl iipalab- bhatlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kalyanapapakanain kammanam vipako upalabbhatiti, kalyanapapakanain kammanam vipakapatisamvedi upalab- bhatiti ? Amanta. Nibbanain upalabbhatiti nibbanassa patisamvedl upalab- bhatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kalyanapapakanain kammanam — pe — vipakapatisam- vedi upalabbhatiti? Amanta. Mahapathavl upalabbhatiti, mahasamuddo upalabbha- titi, Sineru pabbataraja upalabbhatiti, apo upalabbhatiti, 1 vedi, P.S.S, 48 KATHAVATTHU. tejo upalabbhatiti, vayo npalabbhatiti, tinakatthavanappa- tiyo upalabbhantiti, tinakatthavanappatmam patisamvedT upalabbhatiti ? Na h'evaip vattabbe — pe — Kalyanapapakanam kanimanani — pe — vipakapatisani- vedl upaLabbhatiti '? Anianta. Anno kalj^anapapakanani kanimanam vipako, aiino kalyanapapakanaiii kamnianam vipakapatisamvediti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — • 204. Dibbain sukhain upalabbhatiti ? Amanta. Dibbassa sukhassa patisamvedl upalabbhatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 205. Dibbani sukham upalabbhatiti dibbassa sukhassa patisamvedl upalabbhatiti V Amanta. Tassa patisanivedl upalabbhatiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe. Tassa patisamvedl upalabbhatiti "? Amanta. Tassa tass'eva n'atthi dukkhassa antakiriya n'atthi vattupacchedo n'atthi anupadaparinibbanan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe— pe — Dibbam sukhain upalabbhatiti, dibbassa sukhassa pati- samvedl upalabbhatiti ? Amanta. Puggalo upalabbhatiti puggalassa patisamvedl upalab- ])hatlti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — • Dibbain sukhain upalabbhatiti, dibbassa sukhassa pati- samvedl upalabbhatiti ? Amanta. Nibbanam upalabbhatiti nibbanassa patisamvedl upalab- bhatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe. Dibbam sukhain upalabbhatiti, dibbassa sukhassa pati- samvedl upalabbhatiti ? KATHAVATTHU. 49 Ainanta. Mahapathavl upalabbhatlti, niahasainuddo upalabbha- titi, Sineru pabbataraja upalabbhatlti, apo upalabbhatlti, tejo upalabbhatlti, vayo upalabbhatlti, tinakatthavanappa- tiyo upalabbhantiti, tinakatthavanappatlnam patisamvedT upalabbhatlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dibbam sukham upalabbhatlti, dibbassa sukhassa pati- samvedl upalabbhatlti '? Amaiita. Aiiham dibbain sukham afiho dibbassa sukhassa pati- samvedlti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 206. Manusakain sukhaui upalabbhatlti ? Amanta. Manusakassa sukhassa patisamvedl upalabbhatlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 207. Manusakam sukhani upalabbhatlti manusakassa sukhassa patisamvedl upalabbhatlti ? Amanta. Tassa patisaiuvedl upalabbhatlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Tassa patisamvedl upalabbhatlti '? Amanta. Tassa tass'eva n'atthi dukkhassa antakiriya n'atthi vattupacchedo n'atthi anupadaparinibbanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — - Manusakain sukhani upalabbhatlti, manusakassa su- khassa patisamvedl upalabbhatlti ? Amanta. Puggalo upalabbhatlti puggalassa patisamvedl upalab- bhatlti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Manusakain sukham upalabbhatlti, manusakassa su- khassa patisainvedl upalab})hatlti ? Amanta. Nibbanani upalabbhatlti nibbanassa patisamvedl upalab- bhatlti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe. 5 60 KATHAVATTHA. Manusakam sukham upalabbhatiti, manusakassa sii- khassa patisamvedl upalabbhatiti ? Anianta. Mahapathavl upalabbhatiti, mahasamuddo upalabbha- titi, Sineru pabbataraja upalabbhatiti, aj)© upalabbhatiti, tejo upalabbhatiti, vayo upalabbhatiti, tinakatthavanappa- tiyo upalabbhantiti, tinakatthavanappatlnam patisamvedl upalabbhatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Manusakam sukham upalabbhatiti, manusakassa su- khassa patisamvedl upalabbhatiti '? Amanta. Ahiiam manusakam sukham ahho manusakassa sukhassa patisamvediti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 208. Apayikam dukkham upalabbhatiti ? Amanta. Apayikassa dukkhassa patisamvedl upalabbhatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 209. Apayikam dukkham upalabbhatiti apayikassa duk- khassa patisamvedl upalabbhatiti '? Amanta. Tassa patisamvedl upalabbhatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Tassa patisamvedl upalabbhatiti '? Amanta. Tassa tass'eva n'atthi dukkhassa antakiriya n'atthi vattupacchedo n'atthi anupadaparinibbanan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Apayikam dukkhani upalabbhatiti, apayikassa dukkhassa patisamvedl upalabbhatiti '? Amanta. Puggalo upalabbhatiti pugglassa patisainvedl upalab- bhatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Apayikam dukkham upalabbhatiti, apayikassa dukkhassa patisamvedl upalabbhatiti ? Amanta, Nibbanam upalabbhatiti nibbanassa patisamvedl upalab- bhatiti ? KATHAVATTHA. 51 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe. Apayikam dukkhain iipalabbhatiti, apayikassa dukkhassa patisamvedl upalabbhatlti ? Amanta. Mahapathavl upalabbhatlti, mahasainuddo upalabbha- tlti, Sineru pabbataraja upalabbhatlti, apo upalabbhatlti, tejo upalabbhatlti, vayo upalabbhatlti, tinakatthavanappa- tiyo upalabbhantiti, tinakatthavanappatinam patisamvedl upalabbhatlti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Apayikam dukkham upalabbhatlti, apayikassa dukkhassa patisamvedl upalabbhatlti ? Amanta. Ahiiam apayikam dukkham ahho apayikassa dukkhassa patisamvediti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 210. Nerayikani dukkham upalabbhatlti? Amanta. Nerayikassa dukkhassa patisamvedl upalabbhatlti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 211. Nerayikaiii dukkhain upalabbhatlti nerayikassa dukkhassa patisamvedl upalabbhatlti ? Amanta. Tassa patisamvedl upalabbhatlti '? Na h'evam vattabbe. Tassa patisamvedl upalabbhatlti '? Amanta. Tassa tass'eva n'atthi dukkhassa antakiriya n'atthi vattupacchedo n'atthi anupadaparinibbanan ti "? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Nerayikani dukkhain upalabbhatlti, nerayikassa duk- khassa patisamvedl upalabbhatlti ? Amanta. Puggalo upalabbhatlti puggalassa patisamvedl upalab- bhatlti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nerayikani dukkhain upalabbhatlti, nerayikassa duk- khassa patisamvedl upalabbhatlti ? Amanta. 'J2 kathavatthu. Nibbanam upalabbhatiti nibbanassa patisamvedl upalab- ])hatiti? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe. Nerayikaiii dukkhain iipalabl)hatlti, nerayikassa duk- khassa patisamvedl upalabbhatiti ? Amanta. Mahapathavl upalabbhatiti, mahasamuddo upalabbha- titi, Sineru pabbataraja upalabbhatiti, apo upalabbhatiti, tejo upalabbhatiti, vayo upalabbhatiti, tinakatthavanappa- tiyo upalabbhantiti, tinakatthavanappatlnam patisamvedl upalabbhatiti ? Na h'evaiii vattabbe — pe — Nerayikam dukkhain upalabbhatiti, nerayikassa duk- khassa patisamvedl upalabbhatiti '> Amanta. Ahiiam nerayikam dukkham aiino nera3dkassa duk- khassa patisaiiivediti 'r* Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 212. Kalyaiiapapakani kammani upalabbhantiti, kalya- napapakanain kammanam katta kareta vipakapatisainvedi upalabbhatiti V Amanta. So karoti so patisamvedetiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — So karoti so patisamvedetiti '^ Amanta. Sayani katani sukhadukkhan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kalyanaj)apakani kammani — pe — vipakapatisainvedi upalabbhatiti ? Amanta. Anno karoti anno patisaiuvedetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ahiio karoti anno patisaiuvedetiti ? Amanta. Paraiii katain sukhadukkhan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kalyaiiapapakani kammani — pe — vipakapatisainvedi upalabl)hatlti ? KATHAVATTHU. 53 Amanta. So ca anno ca karonti, so ca anfio ca patisamvedentiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — So ca anno ca karonti, so ca anno ca patisamvedentiti ? Amanta. Sayam kataii ca parani katan ca snkhadiikkhan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe. Kalyanapapakani kammani — pe — vipakapatisamvedl upalabbhatiti ? Amanta. N'eva so karoti na so patisamvedeti, na anno karoti na anno patisainvedetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N'eva so karoti na so patisamvedeti, na aniio karoti na anfio patisamvedetiti ? Amanta. Asayam karam aparam karam adhiccasamuppannam sukhadukkhan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kalyanapapakani kammani — pe — vipakapatisamvedl upalabbhatiti ? Amanta. So karoti so patisamvedeti, aiifio karoti afiiio patisain- vedeti, so ca aiiho ca karonti, so ca anno ca patisamvedenti, n'eva so karoti na so patisamvedeti, na aiino karoti na anno patisainvedetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — So karoti so patisamvedeti, aiino karoti aniio patisain- vedeti, so ca anno ca karonti, so ca anfio capatisainvedenti, n'eva so karoti na so patisanivedeti, na anfio karoti na aiifio patisainvedetiti ? Amanta. Sayam katam sukhadukkhain, parani katam siikhadiik- kham, sayam katan ca param katan ca siikhadiikkham, asayam karain aparain karam adhiccasamiippannaiu sukhadukkhan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 218. Kammam atthiti ? 54 KATHAVATTHU. Amanta. Kainmakarako atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 214. Kammain atthiti kammakarako atthiti ? Amanta. Tassa karako atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tassa karako atthiti ? Amanta. Tassa tass'eva n'atthi dukkhassa antakiriya n'atthi vattupacchedo n'atthi anupadaparinibbanan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kammarn atthiti kammakarako atthiti ? Amanta. Puggalo atthiti, puggalassa karako atthiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kammam atthiti kammakarako atthiti '? Amanta. . Nibbanam atthiti, nibbanassa karako atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kammam atthiti kammakarako atthiti ? Amanta. Mahapathavl atthiti — pe — mahasamiiddo atthiti — Sinern pabbataraja atthiti — pe — apo atthiti — tejo atthiti — pe — vayo atthiti — tinakatthavanappatiyo atthiti, tina- katthavanappatlnam karako atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kammam atthiti kammakarako atthiti ? Amanta, Ahham kammam ahho kammakarako ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 215. Vipako atthiti ? Amanta. Vipakapatisamvedl atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 216. Vipako atthiti vipakapatisainvedl atthiti? Amanta. Tassa patisamvedl atthiti ? KATHAVATTHU. 55 Na h'evam vattabbe. Tassa patisamvedl atthiti ? Amanta. Tassa tass'eva n'atthi dukkhassa antakiriya n'atthi vattupacchedo n'atthi anupadaparinibbanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vipako atthiti vipakapatisamvedi atthiti ? Amanta. Puggalo atthiti paggalassa patisamvedl atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vipako atthiti vipakapatisamvedi atthiti '? Amanta. Nibbanam atthiti nibbanassa patisamvedl atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vipako atthiti vipakapatisamvedi atthiti ? Amanta. Mahapathavi atthiti — pe — mahasamaddo atthiti — pe — Sineru pabbataraja atthiti — pe — apo atthiti — pe — tejo atthiti — pe — vayo atthiti — pe — tinakatthavanappatiyo atthiti, tinakatthavanappatlnam patisamvedl atthiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vipako atthiti vipakapatisanivedl atthiti ? Amanta. Anno vipako aniio vipakapatisainvediti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — K a 1 y a n a V a g g o p a t h a m o. 217. Na vattabbam " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikat- thaparamatthenati ? " Amanta. Nanu atthi koci iddhivikubbatiti ? ^ Amanta. Hanoi atthi koci iddhivikubbati, tena vata re vattabbe " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." iddhiiu vikuppati, M. ; iddhini vikubbati, K. 66 KATHAVATTHU. Na vattabbam " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthenati ? " Amanta. Nanu atthi koci dibbaya sotadhatiiya saddain sunati — pe^ — paracittam janati, pubbenivasam anussarati, dibbena cakkhuna rupam passati, asavanam khayam saccikarotiti ? Amanta. Hanoi atthi koci asavanam khayam saccikaroti, tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamat- thenati." 218. Atthi koci iddhivikubbatiti katva tena ca karanena puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati '? Amanta. Yo iddhivikubbati sv'eva puggalo, yo iddhim ^ na vikubbati na so puggalo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Yo dibbaya sotadhatuya saddam sunati — pe — yo para- cittam janati, yo pubbenivasam anussarati, yo dibbena cakkhuna rupam passati, yo asavanain khayain sacci- karoti sv'eva puggalo, yo asavanam khayain na sacci- karoti na so puggalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — A b h i ii h a n u y o g o. 219. Na vattabbam "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthenati ? " Amanta. Nanu mata atthiti ? Amanta. Hahci mata atthi, tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." Na vattabbam " Puggalo upalabbhati sac/'ikatthapara- matthenati? " Amanta. ^ iddhi, P.S2. KATHAVATTHU. 57 Naniipitaatthi — pe — bhata atthi.bhagini atthi, Khattiyo atthi, Brahmano atthi, Vesso atthi, Siiddo atthi, gahatth(3 atthi, pabbajito atthi, devo atthi, niannsso atthlti '? Amanta. Hahci inanusso atthi, tena vata re vattabbe " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati . ' ' 220. Mata atthlti katva tena ca karanena puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Atthi koci na mata hutva mata hotiti ? Amanta. Atthi koci na puggalo hutva puggalo h(3tlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi koci na pita hutva — pe — na bhata hutva — na bhaginl hutva, na Khattiyo hutva, na Brahmano hutva, na Vesso hutva, na Suddo hutva, na gahattho hutva, na pabbajito hutva, na devo hutva, na manusso hutva manusso hotiti ? Amanta. Atthi koci na puggalo hutva puggalo hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Mata atthlti katva tena ca karanena puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati? Amanta. Atthi koci mata hutva na mata hotiti ? Amanta. Atthi koci puggalo hutva na puggalo hotiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi koci pita hutva, bhata hutva, bhaginl hutva, Khattiyo hutva, Brahmano hutva, Vesso hutva, Suddo hutva, gahattho hutva, pabbajito hutva, devo hutva, ma- nusso hutva na manusso hotiti ? Amanta. Atthi koci puggalo hutva na puggalo hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 58 KATHAVATTHU. 221. Na vattabbam " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthenati " ? Amanta. Nann sotapanno atthiti ? Amanta. Hanci sotapanno atthi, tena vata re vattabbe " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati . " ' Na vattabbam " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthenati " ? Amanta. Nanu sakadagamT atthi, anagami atthi, Araha atthi, ubhatobhagavimutto atthi, pahhavimutto atthi, kayasakkhl atthi, ditthippatto atthi, saddhavinmtto atthi, dhamma- nusarl atthi, saddhanusarl atthiti ? Amanta. Hahci saddhanusarl atthi tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." 222. Sotapanno atthiti katva tena ca karanena puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Atthi koci na sotapanno hutva sotapanno hotiti '? Amanta. Atthi koci na puggalo hutva puggalo hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi koci na sakadagami hutva — pe — na anagami hutva, na Araha hutva, na ubhatobhagavimutto hutva, na pahiiavimutto hutva, na kayasakkhl hutva, na ditthippatto hutva, na saddhavimutto hutva, na dhammanusarl hutva, na saddhanusarl hutva saddhanusarl hotiti ? Amanta. Atthi koci na puggalo hutva puggalo hotiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sotapanno atthiti katva tena ca karanena puggalo upa- labbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Atthi koci sotapanno hutva na sotapanno hotiti ? Amanta. Atthi koci puggalo hutva na puggalo hotiti ? KATHAVATTHU. 59 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi koci sakadagami hutva anagami hutva na anagaiiii hotiti ? Aiiianta. Atthi koci puggalo hutva na puggalo hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabl)e — pe — 228. Ka vattabbam " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikattha- paraniatthenati " ? Anianta. Nanu cattaro purisayuga attha purisapuggala atthiti ? Anianta. Hahci uattaro purisayuga attha purisapuggala atthi, tena vata re vattabbe " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthenati . " ' 224. Cattaro purisayuga attha purisapuggala atthiti katva tena ca karanena puggalo upalabbhati saccikattha- paraniatthenati ? Amanta. Cattaro purisayuga attha purisapuggala Buddhapatu- bhava patubhavantiti ? Anianta. Puggalo Buddhapatubhava patubhavatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Puggalo Buddhapatubhava patubhavatiti ? Amanta. Buddhassa Bhagavato parinibbute ucchinno puggalo, n' atthi puggalo ti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 225. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Puggalo sainkhato ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Puggalo asamkhato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Puggalo n'eva samkhato nasamkhato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Puggalo n'eva samkhato nasamkhato ti '? 60 KATHAVATTHU. Amanta. Samkhatafi ca asamkhatan ca thapetva atth'aiina tatiya kotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samkhataii ca asanikhatan ca thapetva atth'anna tatiya kotiti ■? Amanta. Nanu vuttaiii Bhagavata — " Dve'ma Bhikkave dhatnyo, katama dve? Sainkhata ca dhatii asamkhata ca dhatii. Ima kho Bhikkave dve dhatuyo ti. " Atth' eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Sainkhatan ca asanikhatan ca thapetva atth' aiiiia tatiya kotiti.' '22(3. Puggalo n'eva sainkhato nasanikhato ti ? Amanta. Annani samkhatam aMam asamkhatam aniio puggalo tiV Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Khandha samkhata nibbanaiu asamkhatam puggalo n'eva sainkhato nasamkhato ti ? Amanta. x\niie khandha aiiiiam nibbanaiii anno puggalo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Rupaiii sainkhatam nibbanaiu asamkhatani puggalo n'eva sainkhato nasamkhato ti ? Amanta. Anfiam mpam aniiam nibbanam aiiiio puggalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Vedaiia sanfia samkhara vinnanamsamkhataninibbanani asamkhatam puggalo n'eva samkhato nasanikhato ti ? Amanta. Afinam vifiiianam aniiam nibbanam anno puggalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 227. Puggalassa uppado pannayati vayo pannayati thitassa aiiiiathattain ' paniiayatiti ? Amanta. Puggalo samkhato ti ? ^ aiiii attain 8. KATHAVATTHU. 61 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Vuttam Bhagavata — " Tin'imani Bhikkave sauikhatassa samkhatalakkhanani ; samkhatanam Bhikkave dhanima- naiii uppado paiinayati vayo paiinayati thitaiiain anna- thattain pannayatltl," puggalassa uppado pannayati vayo paiinayati thitassa aiiiiath attain paiinayati, teiia hi piig- galo sanikhato ti. Puggalassa iia uppado paiiiiayati iia vayo pannayati na thitassa ahnathattaiii paiiiiayatiti ? Aiiianta. Puggalo asaiiikhato ti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — V'uttain Bhagavata — " Tin'imani Bhikkave asamkha- tassa asainkhatalakkhanani, asamkhatanain Bhikkave dhammanani na uppado pannayati na vayo pahria3^ati na thitanani aiiiiathattain paiiiiayatiti," puggalassa na uppado pannayati na vayo pannayati na thitassa ahhathattam pannayati, teiia hi puggalo asanikhato ti. '2'2y. Parinibbuto puggalo atthatthanihi natthatthain- lilti ? AithatiliaJULiJbit i . *^j^2f;2ZL ' ^ ' *^' ' "' ■" '^* Parinibbuto puggalo sassato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Natthatthamhlti parinibbuto puggalo ucchinno ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Puggalo kim nissaya titthatiti ? Bhavain nissaya titthatlti. Bhavo aiiicco sanikhato paticcasamuppaniio kliaya- dliammo vayadhammo viragadhaiiimo nirodhadhammo viparinamadhammo ti ? Amanta. Puggalo pi aiiicco sanikhato paticcasamuppanno khaya- dhanimo vayadhammo viragadhaiiimo nirodhadhanimo- viparinamadhammo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 229. Na vattabbani " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthenati " ? Amanta. Nanu atthi koci sukhani vedanani vediyaniano sukhaiu vedanani vediyamlti pajantititi ? 62 KATHAVATTHU. Amanta. Hanci atthi koci sukhain vedanam vediyaniano sukhain vedaiiaiu vediyamiti pajanati, tena vata re vattabbe " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati." Na vattabbaiu " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthenati " ? Amantil. Nann atthi koci diikkhain vedanaiii vediyaiiirino — pe — adiikkhainasiikhani vedanain vediyamano adukkhamasu- kham vedanaiu vediyamiti pajiinatlti ? Amanta. Hahci atthi koci adukkhamasiikhain vedanain vediya- mano adukkhamasukhain vedanam vedyamiti pajanati, tena vata re vattabbe " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthenati . ' ' 280. Atthi koci sukham vedanam vediyamano sukhain vedanain vediyamiti pajanatiti katva, tena ca karanena puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Yo sukhain vedanam vediyaniano sukhain vedanain vediyamiti pajanati sv'eva puggalo, yo sukhain vedanain vediyamano sukham vedanain vediyamiti na pajanati na so puggalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Yo dukkhani vedanain vediyamano — pe — yo adukkha- masukhain vedanain vediyamano adukkhamasukhain vedanam vediyamiti pajanati sv'eva puggalo, yo adukkham- asukhain vedanain vediyamano adukkhamasukhain veda- nain vediyamiti na pajanati, na so puggalo ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Atthi koci sukhain vedanain vediyamano sukhain veda- nain vediyamiti pajanatiti katva tena ca karanena puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Anna sukha vedana, aiino sukham vedanain vediyamano sukhain vedanain vediyamano sukham vedanam vediyamiti pajanatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — KATHAVATTHU. 63 Anna dukklia vedana — pe — anna adukkhamasukha vedana, aniio adnkkhamasukham vedanam vediyamano adukkhamasukham vedanam vediyamiti pajanatiti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 231. Na vattabbam " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthenati " ? Anianta. Nanu atthi koci kaye kayanupassi viharatiti ? Anianta. Hanoi atthi koci kaye kayanupassi viharati, tena vata re vattabbe " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthe- nati." Na vattabbam ' ' Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthapara- matthenati " ? Anianta. Nanu atthi koci vedanasu — pe — citte — pe — dhainmesu dhammanupassT viharatiti "? Amanta. Hanoi atthi koci dhammesu dhammanupassi viharati, tena vata re vattabbe " Puggalo upalabbhati sacohikat- thaparamatthanati. ' ' 232. Atthi koci kaye kayanupassi viharatiti katva tena ca karanena puggalo upalabbhati saoohikatthaparamat- thenati ? Amanta. Yo kaye kayanupassi viharati sv'eva puggalo, yo nu kaye kayanupassi viharati na so puggalo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Yo vedanasu — pe — citte — pe — dhammesu dhammanu- passi viharati sv'eva puggalo, yo na dhammesu dhamma- nupassi viharati na so puggalo ti ? Na h' evam vattabbe — pe — 233. Atthi koci kaye kayanupassi viharatiti katva tena ca karanena puggalo upalabbhati sacchikatthaparamat- thenati ? Amanta. Anno kayo aiifio kaye kayanupassi viharatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 64 KATHAVArrUU. Anna vedanfi anruuu cittaiu anno dhaninia anno ^ dluim- mesu dhannnanupassi viharatiti ? Na li'evani vattabbe — pe — 284. Puggalo npalabbhati sacchikatthaparaniatthenati ? Aniantii. Nann vuttaiii Bhagavata — " Sunnato lokain avekkhassu Moghamja sada - sato Attiinuddittliiin fihacca 3 Evain maccntaro siya. Evani k^kani avekkhantan.i Maccuvaja na passatlti."' Atth' eva snttanto ti? Aniantri. Tena hi na vattabbam '* Puggab npalabbhati sacchikat- thaparamatthenjlti." 285. PnggaU> avekkhatlti ? Ainanta. Saba riipena avekkbati vina rfipena avekkhatlti ? Saba vnpena avekkhatlti. Tain jTvani tain sarlran ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe— Vina rfipena avekkhatlti, anhani jivam ahhain sarlran ti :' Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Pnggalo avekkhatlti ? Ainanta. Abbhantaragato avekkbati bahiddha nikkhamitva avek- khatlti? Abbhantaragato avekkhatlti. Tain iivain tarn sarlran ti "/ Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Bahiddha nikkhamitva avekkhatlti annani jivain ahnain sarlran ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — I aiiiiesu, P.S. " saddha, So. P. 3 uhacca, M. ; ahicca, S. ; ohacca, K. KATHAVATTHU. 65 236. Na vattabbam " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthenati " V Amanta. Nanu Bhagava saccavadi kalavadi bhutavadl tathavadi avitathavadi anannathavaditi ? ' Amanta. Vuttam Bhagavata " Atthi puggalo attahitaya patipanno ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthe- nati. 237. Na vattabbam " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthenati " ? Amanta. Kanu Bhagava saccavadi kalavadi bhutavadl tathavadi avitathavadi anaiihathavadlti ? Amanta. Vuttam Bhagavata — " Ekapuggalo Bhikkhave loke uppajjamano uppajjati bahujanahitaya bahujanasukhaya lokanukampaya atthaya hitaj^a sukhaya devamanussanan ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthe- nati. 238. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati V Amanta. Nanu Bhagava saccavadi — -pe — anannathavaditi ? Amanta. Vuttam Bhagavata " Sabbe dhamma anatta ti " ; atth' eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikattha- paramatthenati . ' ' 239. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. ^ ananiiatathavadi, P. 6 66 KATHAVATTHU. Nanii Bhagava saccavadi — pe — anafinathavaditi ? Amanta. Vuttam Bhagavata " Diikkham eva iippajjamanani •uppajjati, dukkham eva nirujjhamanam nirujjhatiti na kankhati na vicikicchati, aparappaccayaiianam ev'assa ettha hoti, ettavata kho Kaccana sammaditthi hotiti ; " atth'eva suttanto ti '? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbain *' Puggalo upalabbliati saccikat- thaparamatthenati. ' ' 240. Puggalo npalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Nanu Vajira Bhikkhmii Maram papimantani etad avoca — " Kin nil satto ti ^ paccesi Mara ditthigatam nu te suddbasamkharapimjo ^ yam 3 nayidha sattupalabbhati.4 Yatha pi angasambhara 5 hoti saddo ^ ratho 7 iti, evam khandhesu santesu hoti satto ti sammuti. Dukkham eva hi sambhoti dukkham titthati veti ca nahhatra ^ dukkha sambhoti nahham9 dukkha nirujjhatiti." Atth' eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikat- thaparamatthenati . ' ' 241. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati? Amanta. Nanu ayasma Anando Bhagavantam etad avoca — I Kan na sapposi, S. ; kan nu, P. ^ puhho, S. 3 sam, P.S.S2. 4 satthupalabl)hati, M. ; tattha, P.S2. s obharo, S. 6 ^atto, P.S.S^. 7 rato, S^. ^ afinatra, S. 9 anno, S. ; na ahha, P. : na ahhani. So. KATHAVATTHU. 07 " Sunno loko siinno loko ti bhante vnccati. Kittavata " ^ ^ nil kho bhante sunno loko ti vuccatiti '? " " Yasma kho Ananda Surinam attena va attaniyena va, tasma suiifio loko ^^ ti vuccati. Kiii c' Ananda sunfiam attena va attaniyena J Ijy . va ? Cakkhu kho Ananda suiinam attena va attaniyena va, rupa suiifia — pe — cakkhuvinfianam sunfiam, cakkhu- samphasso suMo yam p' idam cakkhusamphassapaccaya uppajjati vedayitam sukham va dukkham va adukkhama- sukham va, tarn pi sunfiam attena va attaniyena va, sotani sunfiam — pe — sadda sufiiia, ghanam suiifiain, gandlia suiiiia, jivha sufifia, rasa sunfia, kayo suiifio, photthabba sumia, mano sunno, dhamma sunna, manovififianam sunfiam, manosamphasso sunno, yam p' idain manosam- phassapaccaya uppajjati vedayitani sukham va dukkhani va adukkhamasukham va, tain pi suiifiam attena va attani- yena va ; yasma kho Ananda sufinam attena va attaniyena va, tasma suhiio loko ti vuccatiti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikat- thaparamatthenati. ' ' 242. Puggalo upalabbhati saecikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Nanu Bhagava saccavadi kalavadi bhiitavadi tathavadi avitathavadi anafifiathavaditi ? Amanta. Vuttam Bhagavata — " Attani va Bhikkave sati attani- yam me ti assati." "E vain bhante." "Attaniyeva Bhikkave i // sati atta me ti assati." " Evam bhante." "Attani ca Bhik- kave attaniye ca saccato thetato anupalabbhiyamane yain p' idam ditthithanam so loko so atta so pecca bhavissami, nicco dhuvo sassato aviparinamadhammo sassati samani tath' eva thassamlti. Nanvayam Bhikkave kevalo pari- piiro baladhammo ti." " Kifici no siya bhante kevalo hi bhante paripuro baladhammo ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Puggalo upalabbhati saecikat- thaparamatthenati." 68 KATHAVATTHU. 248. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati '? Amanta. Naiiu Bhagava saccavadi kalavadi bhutavadi tathavadi avitathavadi anafinathavaditi ? Amanta. Vuttam Bhagavata " Tayo' me Seniya sattharo santo samvijjamana lokasmim. Katame tayo? Idha Seniya ekacco sattha ditth' eva dhamme attanam saccato thetato pannapeti, abhisamparayaii ca attanam saccato thetato pannapeti ; idha pana Seniya ekacco sattha ditth' eva hi kho dhamme attanam saccato thetato paniiapeti, no ca kho abhisamparayam attanam saccato thetato pannapeti ; idha pana Seniya ekacco sattha ditthe c'eva dhamme atta- nam saccato thetato na pannapeti, abhisamparayan ca attanam saccato thetato na pannapeti. Tatra Seniya yvayam sattha ditthe c'eva dhamme attanam saccato the- tato pafiiiapeti, abhisamparayaii ca attanam saccato thetato paiinapeti, ayain vuccati Seniya sattha sassatavado. Tatra Seniya yvayam ditth' eva hi kho dhamme attanam saccato thetato pannapeti, no ca kho abhisamparayam attanam saccato thetato paiinapeti, ayain vuccati Seniya sattha ucchedavado. Tatra Seniya yvayam sattha ditthe c'eva dhanmie attanam saccato thetato na paiinapeti, abhisam- parayaii ca attanam saccato thetato na pannapeti, ayain vuccati Seniya sattha sammasambuddho. Ime kho Seniya tayo sattharo santo samvijjamana lokasmin ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbani " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikat- th aparamatthenati . ' ' 244. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikatthaparamatthenati > Amanta. Nanu Bhagava saccavadi kalavadi bhutavadi tatha- vadi avitathavadi anaiiiiathavaditi ? Amanta. Vuttam Bhagavata " Sappikumbho ti " ? ^ Sabbi, M. KATHAVATTHU. 09 Amanta. Atthi koci sappissa kumbham karotiti '? Na h' evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi na vattabbam " Puggalo iipalabbhati saccikat- thaparamatthenati." 245. Puggalo iipalal^bhati saccikatthaparamatthenati ? Amanta. Nanu Bhagava saccavadi kalavadi bhutavadi tathavadi avitathavadi anannathavaditi '? Amanta. Vuttam Bhagavata " Telakmubho, madhukmnbho, pha- nitakmiibho, khirakmnbho.udakakmnbho, paniyathalakam, paniyakosakam, paniyasaravakam, niccabhattain, dhiiva- yaguti " '? Amanta. Atthi koci yagu nicca dhuva sassata aviparinamadham- mati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi na vattabbam " Puggalo upalabbhati saccikat- thaparamatthenati." Sainkhittain. Atthakaniggahapeyyala.i Sandhavanlya upadaya, cit- tena pahcamam kalyanam, iddhi. Suttaharena atthamain. P u g g a 1 a k a t h a. I. 2. 1. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti '? Amanta. Sabbattha Ai'aha arahatta parihayatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sabbattha Araha arahatta parihayatiti ? Amanta. Sabbattha Arahato parihaniti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti V I peyyala, M.K. ; ta, M. 70 KATHAVATTHU. Amanta. Sabbada Araha arahatta parihayatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sabbada Araha arahatta parihayatiti ? Amanta. Sabbada Arahato parihanlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti? Amanta. Sabbe 'va Arahanto arahatta parihayantiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sabbe 'va Arahanto arahatta parihaj'antiti ? Amanta. Sabbesah iieva Arahantanam parihanlti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti? Amanta. Araha arahatta parihayamano catuhi phalehi pariha- yatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Catuhi satasahassehi setthi setthittam karento satasa- hasse parihme ^ setthitta parihmo hotiti '? Amanta. Sabbasapateyya parihino hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Catuhi satasahassehi setthi setthittam karento sata- sahasse parihlne bhabbo^ sabbasapateyya 3 parihayitun ti '? . ' Amanta. Araha arahatta parihayamano bhabbo catuhi phalehi parihayitun ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti '? ^ P.S.So. omit the next 5 Hnes. 2 anibho, S. ; catabbo, P.S2. 3 pateyo, P.S2. KATHAVATTHU. 71 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amaiita. Parihayati sakadagami sakadagamiphala ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Parihayati anagami aiiagamiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Parihayati anagami aiiagamiphala ti ? Amanta. Parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Parihayati anagami anagamiphala ti "? Amanta. Parihayati sakarlagami sakadagamiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Parihayati sakadagami sakadagamiphala ti ? Amanta. Parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Na h'evarn vattabbe— pe — Na parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Amanta. Na parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Na parihayati sakadagami sakadagamiphala ti ? Amanta. Na parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Na parihayati anagami anagamiphala ti ? Amanta. Na parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Na parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Amanta. Na parihayati anagami anagamiphala ti ? Na h'evarn vattabbe— pe — Na parihayati sakadagrmil sakadagamiphala ti ? 72 KATHAVATTHU. Amanta. Na parihayati anagami anagamiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Na parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Amanta. Na parihayati sakadagami sakadagamiphala ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti*? Amanta. Araha arahatta parihayamano kattha santhatiti ? ^ Anagamiphale ti. Anagami anagamiphala parihayamano kattha santha- titi •? Sakadagamiphale ti. Sakadagami sakadagamiphale parihayamano kattha santhatiti ? Sotapattiphale ti. Sotapanno sotapattiphale parihayamano puthujjanabhu- miyam santhatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Ajanahi niggaham : hahci Araha arahatta parihayamano anagamiphale santhati, anagami anagamiphala parihaya- mano sakadagamiphale santhati, sakadagami sakadagami- phala parihayamano sotapattiphale santhati, tena vata re vattabbe " Sotapanno sotapattiphala parihayamano pu- thujjanabhumiyam santhatiti." Araha arahatta parihayamano sotapattiphale santhati ti? Amanta. Sotapattiphalassa anantara arahattah iieva saccikaroti ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Parihayati sotapattiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. I santhahatiti, P.S2. KATHAVATTHU. 73 Kassa baliutara kilesa pahlna Arahato va sotapannassa va ti ? Arahato. Hanci Arahato bahutara kilesa pahina parihayati Araha arahatta, tena vata re vattabbe "Parihayati sotapaniio sotapattiphala ti." 9. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti '? Anianta. Parihayati sakadagainT sakadagamiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kassa bahutara kilesa pahina Arahato va sakadagamissa va ti '? Arahato. Hahci Arahato bahutara kilesa pahina, parihayati Araha arahatta, tena vata re vattabbe "Parihayati sakadaganii sakadagamiphala ti." 10. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Parihayati anaganil anaganiiphala ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Kassa bahutara kilesa pahina Arahato va anagamissa va ti ■? Arahato. Hanci Arahato bahutara kilesa pahina, parihayati Araha arahatta, tena vata re vattabbe " Parihayati anagami ana- ganiiphala ti." 11. Parihayati anagami anaganiiphala ti? Amanta. Parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Kassa bahutara kilesa pahina anagamissa va sotapan- nassa va ti ? Anagamissa. Haiici anagamissa bahutara kilesa pahina parihayati anagami anaganiiphala, tena vata re vattabbe " Parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti." 12. Parihayati anagami anaganiiphala ti ? Amanta. 74 KATHAVATTHU. Parihayati sakadagaml sakadagamiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kassa bahiitara kilesa pahlna anaganiissa va sakadaga- missa va ti ? Anagamissa. Hanoi anagamissa bahutara kilesa pahlna parihayati anagami anagamiphala, tena vata re vattabbe " Parihayati sakadagaml sakadagamiphala ti." 18. Parihayati sakadagaml sakadagamiphala ti ? Amanta. Parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kassa bahutara kilesa pahlna sakadagamissa va sota- pannassa va ti ? Sakadagamissa. Haiici sakadagamissa bahutara kilesa pahlna parihayati sakadagaml sakadagamiphalfi, tena vata re vattabbe " Pa- rihayati sotapanno sotapattijihala ti." 14. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Ka h'evam vattabbe. Kassa adhimatta maggabhavana Arahato va sotapan- nassa va ti ? Arahato. Hahci Arahato adhimatta maggabhavana parihayati Araha arahatta, tena vata re vattabbe " Parihayati sota- panno sotapattiphala ti." 15. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Ka h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kassa adhimatta satipatthanabhavana, sammappadha- nabhavana, iddhipadabhavana, indriyabhavana, balabha- vana, bojjhahgabhavana Arahato va sotapannassa va ti? Arahato. Hahci Arahato adhimatta bojjhahgabhavana parihayati Araha arahatta, tena vata re vattabbe '" Parihayati sota- panno sotapattiphala ti." KATHAVATTHU. 75 16. Pariliayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Parihayati sakadagami sakadagamiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Kassa adhiiuatta niaggabhavana — pe — bojjhangabha- vana Arahato va sakadagainissa va ti ? Arahato. Hanoi Arahato adhimatta bojjhangabhavana parihayati Araha arahatta, tena vata re vattabbe "Parihayati saka- dagami sakadagamiphala ti." 17. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Parihayati anagam! anagamiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Kassa adhimatta niaggabhavana — pe — bojjhahgabha- vana Arahato va anagamissa va ti ? Arahato. Haiici Arahato adhimatta bojjhangabhavana parihayati Araha arahatta, tena vata re vattabbe "Parihayati ana- gaml anagamiphala ti." 18. Parihayati anagami anagamiphala ti ? Amanta. Parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Kassa adhimatta niaggabhavana — pe — bojjliahgabha- vana anagamissa va sotapannassa va ti ? Anagamissa. Hanoi anagamissa adhimatta bojjhahgabhavana pariha- yati anagami anagamiphala, tena vata re vattabbe " Pari- hayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti." 19. Parihayati anagami anagamiphala ti ? Amanta. Parihayati sakadagami sakadagamiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kassa adhimatta maggabhavana — pe — bojjhangabha- vana anagamissa va sakadagainissa va ti ? Anagamissa. Hanoi anagamissa adhimatta l)ojjhahgabhavana parihii- 76 KATHAVATTHU. yati anagami anagamiphala, tena vata re vattabbe " Pari- hayati sakadaganil sakadagamiphala ti." 20. Parihayati sakadagami sakadagamiphala ti '? Anianta. Parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Na h'evaiii vattabbe. Kassa adhimatta maggabhavana- — pe — bojjhahgabha- vana sakadagamissa va sotapannassa va ti ? Sakadagamissa. Hanoi sakadagamissa adhimatta bojjhangabhavana pari- hayati sakadagami sakadagamiphala, tena vata re vattabbe ■' Parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti." 21. Arahata dukkham dittham parihayati Araha ara- hatta ti ? Amanta. Sotapannena dukkham dittham parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Na h'evarn vattabbe — pe — Arahata samudayo dittho parihayati Araha Arahatta ti '? Amanta. Sotapannena samudayo dittho parihayati sotapaimo sotapattiphala ti? Na h'evarn vattabbe — pe — Arahata nirodho dittho parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Sotapannena nirodho dittho parihayati sotapanno sota- pattiphala ti *? Na h'evarn vattabbe — pe — Arahata maggo dittho parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Sotapannena maggo dittho parihayati sotapanno sota- pattiphala ti ? Na h'evarn vattabbe — pe — Arahata cattari saccani ditthani parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Sotapannena cattari saccani ditthani parihayati sota- panno sotapattiphala ti ? KATHAVATTHU. 77 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 22. Arahata dukkham dittham parihayati Araha ara- hatta ti ? Amaiita. Sakadagamina dukkham ditthaiii parihayati sakadagami sakadagainiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahata samudayo dittho, nirodho dittho, maggo dittho, cattari saccani ditthani parihayati Araha arahatta ti '? Amanta. Sakadagamina cattari saccani ditthani parihayati saka- dagami sakadagamiphala ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 28. Arahata dukkham dittham parihayati Araha ara- hatta ti y Amanta. Anagamina dukkham ditthain parihayati anagami ana- gamiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahata samudayo dittho, nirodho dittho, maggo dittho, cattari saccani ditthani parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Anagamina cattari saccani ditthani parihayati anagami anagamiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 24. Anagamina dukkhain dittham parihayati anagami anagamiphala ti '? Amanta. Sotapannena dukkham dittham parihayati sotapanno S( )tapattiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagamina samudayo dittho, nirodho dittho, maggo dittho, cattari saccani ditthani parihayati anagami anaga- miphala ti ? Amanta. Sotapannena cattari saccani ditthani parihayati sota- panno sotapattiphala ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 78 KATHAVATTHU. 25. Anagamina diikkham dittham parihayati anagami anaganiiphala ti ? Amanta. Sakadagamina dukkham dittham parihayati sakadagaml sakadagamiphala ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagamina samudayo dittho, nirodho dittho, maggo dittho, cattari saccani ditthani parihayati anagami ana- gamiphala ti ? Amanta. Sakadagamina cattari saccani ditthani parihayati saka- dagaml sakadagamiphala ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 26. Sakadagamina dukkhain ditthani pariliayati saka- dagaml sakadagamiphala ti ? Amanta. Sotapannena dukkham dittham parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sakadagamina samudayo dittho, nirodho dittho, maggo dittho, cattari saccani ditthani parihayati sakadagaml sakadagamiphala ti ? Amanta. Sotapannena cattari saccani ditthani parihayati sota- panno sotapattiphala ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 27. Sotapannena dukkhani dittham na parihayati sota- panno sotapattiphala ti ? Amanta. Arahata dukkham dittham na parihayati Araha arahatta ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sotapannena samudayo dittho, nirodho dittho, maggo dittho, cattari saccani ditthani na parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Amanta. Arahata cattari saccani ditthani na parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? KATHAVATTHU. 79 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 28. Sakadagamina dukkhain ditthani — pe — cattari sac- cani ditthani na parihayati sakadagami sakadagamiphala ti? Amanta. Arahata cattari saccani ditthani na parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 29. Anagamina dukkhain dittham — pe — cattari saccani ditthani na parihayati anaganii anagamiphala ti ? Amanta. Arahata cattari saccani ditthani na parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 30. Sotapannena dukkham dittham — pe — cattari sac- cani ditthani na parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti '? Amanta. Anasamina dukkham dittham — pe — cattari saccani dit- thani na parihayati anagami anagamiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 31. Sakadagamina dukkhain dittham — pe — cattari sac- cani ditthani na parihayati sakadagami sakadagamiphala ti? " Amanta. Anagamina dukkham dittham — pe — cattari saccani ditthani na parihayati anagami anagamiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 32. Sotapannena dukkham ditthain — pe — cattari sac- cani ditthani na parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti '? Amanta. Sakadagamina dukkhain dittham— pe — cattari saccani ditthani na parihayati sakadagami sakadagamiphala ti ? Na h'evarn vattabbe— pe — 33. Arahato rago pahino parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Sotapannassa sakkayaditthi pahlna parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — L 80 KATHAVATTHU. Arahato rago pahino parihayati Araha arahatta ti '? Amanta. Sotapannassa vicikiccha pahina — pe — sllabbatapara- maso pahino — pe — apayagamanlyo ^ rago pahino — pe — apayagamanlyo doso pahino — -pe — apayagamanlyo moho pahino parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahato doso pahino — pe — moho pahino — pe — mano pahino — pe — ditthi pahina, vicikiccha pahina, thlnain pahl- nani, uddhaccam pahlnam, ahirikam pahlnain, anottap- pam pahlnam parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Sotapannassa sakkayaditthi pahina parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahato anottappam pahlnam parihayati Araha arahatta tiV Amanta. Sotapannassa vicikiccha pahina — pe — sUabbataparamaso pahino — pe — apayagamanlyo rago pahino — pe — apayaga- manlyo doso pahino — apayagamanlyo moho pahino pari- hayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 84. Arahato rago pahino parihayati Araha arahatta ti? Amanta. Sakadagamissa sakkayaditthi pahina parihayati sakada- gaml sakadagamiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahato rago pahino parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Sakadagamissa vicikiccha pahina — pe — sUabbatapara- maso pahino — pe — olariko kamarago pahino, olariko byapado pahino, parihayati sakadagami sakadagamiphala tiV Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — niyo, M. I. 2. J KATHAVATTHU. 81 Arahato doso pahino — pe — anottappaiii pahiiiaiii pariha- yati Araha arahatta ti V Amanta. Sakadagamissa sakkayaditthi pahiiia — pe — olarika byapado pahino parihayati sakadaganil sakadagaiiiiphala ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 35. Arahato rago pahino parihayati Araha arahatta ti? Amanta. Anagamissa sakkayaditthi pahlna parihayati anagami anagaiiiiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahato rago pahino parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Anagamissa vicikiccha pahlna — -pe — sllabbataparamaso pahino, anusahagato kamarago pahino, anusahagato byapado pahino parihayati anagami anagamiphala ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe. Arahato doso pahino — pe — anottappam pahlnani pari- hayati Araha arahatta tiV Amanta. Anagamissa sakkayaditthi pahlna — pe — anusahagato byapado pahino parihayati anagami anagamiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 86. Anagamissa sakkayaditthi pahlna parihayati ana- gami anagamiphala ti ? Amanta. Sotapannassa sakkayaditthi pahlna parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Na h'evaiii vattabbe. Anagamissa sakkayaditthi pahlna parihayati anagami anagamiphala ti ? Amanta. Sotapannassa vicikiccha pahlna — pe — apayagamanlyo moho pahino parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Anagamissa vicikiccha pahlna — pe — anusahagato bya- pado pahino parihayati anagami anagamipliala ti ? 7 82 KATHAVATTHU. [I. '2. Aniaiita. Sotapannassa sakkayaditthi pahliia — pe — apayagaina- niyo moho pahino parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 87. Anagamissa sakkayaditthi pahlna parihayati ana- gaml anagainiphala ti ? Ainanta. Sakadagamissa sakkayaditthi pahlna parihayati sakada- gainl sakadaganiiphala ti ? Na h'evaiii vattabbe. Anagamissa sakkayaditthi pahlna parihayati anagami anagamiphala ti ? Amanta. Sakadagamissa vicikiccha pahlna — -pe — sTlabbatapanl- maso pahino — pe — olariko kamarago pahino — pe — olariko byapado pahino parihayati sakadagami sakadaganiiphala ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe. Anagamissa viccikiccha pahina — pe — anusahagato bya- pado pahino parihayati anagami anagamiphahl ti ? Amanta. Sakadagamissa sakkayaditthi pahina — pe — olariko bya- pado pahino parihayati sakadagami sakadaganiiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 38. Sakadagamissa sakkayaditthi pahina parihayati sakadagami sakadaganiiphala ti ? Amanta. Sotapannassa sakkayaditthi pahina parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti '? Xa h'evani vattabbe. Sakadagamissa sakkayaditthi pahina parihayati sakada- gami sakadaganiiphala ti '? Amanta. Sotapannassa vicikiccha pahina — pe — apayagamaniyo ni(jho pahino parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Sakadagamissa vicikiccha pahina — pe — olariko kania rago pahino olariko byapado pahino parihayati sakada- gami sakadaganiiphala ti ? I. 2.] KATHAVA'JTHU. 83 Aiuanta. Sotapaniiassa sakkayadittbi pahlna — pe — apayagama- niyo moho pahino parihayati sotapaiino sotapattipliala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. . 39. Sotapaniiassa sakkayadittbi pahlna na paribayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Amanta. Arahato rago pabliKj na pariliayati Araha arabatta ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe. Sotapaniiassa sakkayadittbi pahlna na parihayati sota- panno sotapattiphala ti ? Amanta. Arahato doso pahino — pe — anottappam pahlnam na parihayati Araha arabatta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Sotapaniiassa vicikiccha pahlna- — -pe — apayagamanlyo moho pahino na parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti V Amanta. Arahato rago paliino — pe — anottappaiii pahinani na parihayati Araha arabatta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 40. Sakadagamissa sakkayadittbi pahlna na parihayati sakadagami sakadagamipbala ti ? Amanta. Arahato rago pahino — pe — anottappaiii pahinani na parihayati Araha arabatta ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe. Sakadagamissa vicikiccha pahlna — pe — olariko byapado pahino na parihayati sakadagami sakadagamipbala ti ? • Amanta. Araliato rago pahino — pe — anottappaiii pablnain na parihayati Araha arabatta ti V Na h'evain vattabbe. 41. Anagamissa sakkayadittbi paliliia na paribayati anagaml anagamiphahl ti '} Amanta. Arahato rago pahino — pe — antjttappam pahliiain na parihayati Araha arabatta ti ? 84 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 2. Na h'evam vattabbe. Anaganiissa vicikiccha pahliia — pe — anusaliagato bya- pado pahlno na parihayati anagami anagamiphala ti? Anianta. Arahato rago pahiiio — pe — anottappain pahinaiii na parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe. 42. Sotapannassa sakkayaditthi pahina na parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Anianta. Anagamissa sakkayaditthi pahina anusahagato byapado pahlno na parihayati anagami anagamiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Sotapannassa vicikiccha pahina — pe — apayagamanlyo moho pahlno na parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti ? Amanta. Anagamissa sakkayaditthi pahina aniisahagato byapado pahlno na parihayati anagami anagamiphala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 48. Sakadagamissa sakkayaditthi pahina na parihayati sakadagami sakadagamiphala ti ? Amanta. Anagamissa sakkayaditthi pahina — pe — anusahagato byapado pahlno na parihayati anagami anagamiphala ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe. Sakadagamissa vicikiccha pahina — pe — olariko byapado pahlno na parihayati sakadagami sakadagamiphala ti ? Amanta. Anagamissa sakkayaditthi pahina — pe — anusahagato byapado pahlno na parihayati anagami anagamiphala ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe. 44. Sotapannassa sakkayaditthi pahina na parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti V Amanta. Sakadagamissa sakkayaditthi pahina — pe — olariko bya- pado pahlno na parihayati sakadagami sakadagamiphala ti? Na h'evain vattabbe. Sotapannassa vicikiccha pahina — pe — apayagamanlya I. 2.] KATHAVATTHU. 85 moho pahino na parihayati sotapanno sotapattiphala ti? Amanta. Sakadagamissa sakkayaditthi pahiiia — pe — olariko bya- pado pahino na parihayati sakadagaml sakadagamiphala ti? Na h'evam vattabbe. 45. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Nanu Arahato rago pahino ucchinnamulo talavatthukato anabhavamkato ayatiin anuppadadhanimo ti '? Amanta. Haiici Arahato rago pahino ucchinnamulo talavatthukato anabhavamkato ayatini anuppadadhammo, no vata re vattabbe " Parihayati Araha arahatta ti." Parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Nanu Arahato doso pahino — pe — moho pahino, mano pahino, ditthi pahlna, vicikiccha pahlna, thlnain pahlnam uddhaccam pahlnain, ahirikam pahlnam, anottappam pahlnain ucchinnamulaiu talavatthukatain anabhavam- katam ayatim anuppadadhamman ti "? Amanta. Hanci Arahato anottappam pahlnain ucchinnamulam talavatthukatain anabhavamkatam ayatim anuppada- dhammam, no vata re vattabbe " Parihayati Araha arahatta ti." 46. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Nanu Arahato ragappahanaya maggo bhavito ti ? Amanta. Hahci Arahato ragappahanaya maggo bhavito, no vata re vattabbe " Parihayati Araha arahatta ti." Parihayati Araha arahatta ti '? Amanta. Nanu Arahato ragappahanaya satipatthana bhilvita — pe — sammappadhana bhavita iddhipada bhavita indriya bhavita bala bhavita bojjhanga bhavita ti ? Amanta. .SC) KATHAVATTHl'. [1. 2. Hanci Arahato lagappahanaya bojjhaiiga bhavita, no vata re vattabbe "Parihayati Araha arahatta ti." Parihayati Araha arabatta ti ? Ainanta. Naiiu Arahato dosappalianaya — pe — anottappappaha- naya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhaiiga bhavita ti? Amanta. Hafici Arahato anottappappahanaya bojjhaiiga bhavita, no vata re vattabbe " Parihayati Araha arahatta ti." 47. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Naiiu Araha vltarago vltadoso vltanioho katakaramyo ohitabharo anuppattasadattho ^ parikkhlnabhavasahnojano saininadanfia viniutto ukkliittapahgho sainkinnaparikho ^ abbulhesiko 3 niraggalo ariyo pannaddhajo pannabharo visanfiutto suvijitavijayo, dukkham tassa parinhataiii, samudayo pahino, iiirodho sacchikato, maggo bhavito, abhihheyyaiii abliirihataiii, parihheyyani parihnatam, pahatabbain pahlnani, bhavetabbani bhavitaip, sacchika- tabbam sacchikataii ti? Amanta. Hanci Araha vltarago vltadoso — pe — sacchikatabbam sacchikatani, no vata re vattabbe "Parihayati Araha arahatta ti." 48. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Samayavimutto Araha arahatta parihayati, asamaya- vimutto Araha arahatta na parihayatiti. Samayavimutto Araha arahatta parihayatiti ? Amanta. Asamayavimutto Araha arahatta parihayatiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe. Asamayavimutto Araha arahatta na parihayatiti ? Amanta. Samayavimutto Araha arahatta na parihayatiti ? Na h'evani vattabbe. I osadatto, M. - ^kkho, P.S. 3 abyulhesiko, 1*. ; abbulesiko, M.S. T. 2.] KATHAVATTHU. 87 49. Samayavimuttassa Arahato rago pahino, parihayati samayavimutto Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Asamayavimuttassa Arahato rago pahino, parihayati asamayavimutto Araha arahatta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Saniayavimuttassa Arahato doso pahino — pe — anottap- pam pahinam, parihayati samayavimutto Araha arahatta ti? Amanta. Asamayavimuttassa Arahato doso pahino — pe — anottap- parn pahinam, parihayati asamayavimutto Araha arahatta ti'/ Na h'evam vattabbe. 50. Samayavimuttassa Arahato ragappahanaya maggo bliavito, parihayati samayavimutto Araha arahatta ti '^ Amanta. Asamayavimuttassa Arahato ragappahanaya maggo bhavito, parihayati asamayavimutto Araha arahatta ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe. Samayavimuttassa Arahato ragappahjlnaya satipatthana bhavita — pe — sammappadhana bhavita iddhipada bhavita indriya bhavita bala bhavita bojjhahga bhavita, parihayati samayavimutto Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Asamayavimuttassa Arahato ragappahanaya satipat- thana bhavita — pe: — bojjhahga bhavita, parihayati asama- yavimutto Araha arahatta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Samayavimuttassa Arahato dosappahanay a- -pe — anot- tappappahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhahga bhavita parihayati samayavimutto Araha arahatta ti V Amanta. Asamayavimuttassa Arahato anottappappahanaya, maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhahga bhavita, parihayati asama- yavimutto Araha arahatta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 51. Samayavimutto Araha vltarago vltadoso vltamolio katakaraniyo ()hitaI)haro anuppattasadattho j)arikkbTna- 88 KATHAVATTHU. [I. '2. bhavasaniiojano saiiiniadanna vimutto ukkhittapali^ho sainkinnaparikho abbulhesiko niraggalo aiiyo pannaddhajo pannabharo visaiinutto suvijitavijayo, dnkkhaiu tassa pariiifiatam, samudayo pahino, nirodho sacchikato, iiiaggo bbavito, abhinfieyyam abhinnatam, parinneyyam parinna- tam, pahatabbain pabinaui, bhavetabbaiii bhavitam, sac- chikatabbam sacchikatani, parihayati samay a vimutto Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Asamay a vimutto Araha vltarago vltadoso — pe — sacchi- katabbam sacchikatani, parihayati asamayavimutto Araha arahatta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 52. Asamayavimuttassa Arahato rago pahmo, na pari- hayati asamayavimutto Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Samayavimuttassa Arahato rago pahino, na parihayati samayavimutto Araha arahatta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Asamayavimuttassa Arahato doso pahino — pe — anottap- pam pahinain, na parihayati asamayavimutto Araha arahatta ti V Amanta. Samay avimuttassa Arahato anottappam pahinain, na parihayati samayavimutto Araha arahatta ti *? Na h'evain vattabbe. 53. Asamayavimuttassa Arahato ragappahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhahga bhavita, na parihayati asamaya- vimutto Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Samayavimuttassa Arahato ragappahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhahga bhavita, na parihayati samayavi- mutto Araha arahatta ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe. Asamayavimuttassa Arahato dosappahilnaya — pe — anot- tappappahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhahga bhavita, na parihayati asamayavimutto Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. I. 2.] KATHAVATTHU. 89 Samayaviiuuttassa Arahato anottappappahanaya maggo bhavito — pe— bojjhanga bhavita, na parihayati samayavi- miitto Araha arahatta ti '? Na h'evaiii vattabbe. 54. Asainayaviiiiutto Araha vltarago vitad(3so vltaiiioho — pe — sacchikatabbam sacchikatam, na parihayati asania- yavimutto Araha arahatta ti '? Amanta. Samayavimutto Aralia vltarago, vltadoso— pe — sacchi- katabbam sacchikataiii, na parihayati samayavimutto Araha arahatta ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 55. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti? Amanta. Saripiitto thero ^ parihayittha Arahatta ti ? Na h'evaiu vattabbe. Maha Moggallano thero, Maha Kassapo thero, Maha Kaccayano thero, Maha Kotthiko thero, Maha Panthako thero parihayittha arahatta ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe. Saripiitto thero na parihayittha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Haiici Sariputto thero na pariliayittha arahatta, no vata re vattabbe " Parihayati Araha arahatta ti.'" Maha Moggallano thero, Maha Kassapo thero, Maha Kaccayano thero, Maha Kotthiko thero, Maha Panthako thero na parihayittha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Haiici Maha Moggallano thero — pe — Maha Panthako thero na parihayittha arahatta, no vata re vattabbe " Parihayati Araha arahatta ti." 56. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Amanta. Nanu vnttam Bhagavata — " Uccavaca hi patipada samanena pakasita Na param digunam ^ yanti nayidain ekagunain nnitan ti." I thero, P. 2 paradignnain, P.Sa- 90 KATHAVATTHL . [I. 2. Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Aiiianta. Tena hi iia vattabbain. " Parihayati Araha arahatta ti." 57. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Aiiianta. Atthi chinnassa chediyan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atthi chinnassa chediyan ti ? Anianta. Nanii vuttam Bhagavata — " Vltatanho anadano kiccam yassa na vijjati Chinnassa chediyam n'atthi oghapaso' samuhato ti." Atth'eva suttanto tiV Ainanta. Tena hi na vattabbain " Atthi chinnassa chediyan ti." 58. Pai'ihayati Araha arahatta ti ? Anianta. Atthi katassa paticayo- ti ? Na h'evarn vattabbe. Atthi katassa paticayo3 ti? Anianta. Kami vuttam Bhagavata — " Tassa sammavimuttassa santacittassa bhikkhimo Katassa paticayo3 n'atthi karaniyain na vijjati. 8el() yatha ekaghano^ vatena na samirati Evam riipa rasa sadda gandha phassa ca kevala Ittha dhamma anittha ca n'appavedhentis tadino Thitam cittain vippamuttani vayain c '^ assamipassatlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Anianta. " ogha°, M. ; oghavaso, 8. ^ paricayo, P.S. 3 pati'^, P.y. 4 oghano, P. 5 vadenti, 1'. ; vedenti, 8. ^ p'ass, P. So. I. 2.] KATHAVATTHU. 91 Teiia hi na vattabbam " Atthi katassa paticayo ti." 59. Na vattabbam " Parihayati Araha arahatta ti " '? Amanta. Nana vuttam Bhagavata — "Pane' ime Bhikkliave dhamma sainayavimuttassa bhikkhuno parihanaya sam- vattanti. Katanie panca ? Kaiiiiiiaramata bhassaramata niddaraiuata saingaiiikaraiuata yatha vimuttam cittaui na paccavekkhati. Ime kho Bhikkhave panca dhamma samayavimuttassa bhikkhmio parihanaya saiiivattantiti." Atth'eva suttanto ti '? Amanta. Tena hi parihayati Arahil arahatta ti. 60. Atthi Arahato kammaramata ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atthi Arahato kammaramata ti ? Amanta. Atthi Arahato ra.i^o kamarago kamaragapariyutthanaiu kamaragasannojanam kamogho kamayogo kamacchanda- nivaranan ti ? Na h'evaiii vattabbe. Atthi Arahato bhassaramata atthi Arahato niddar-imata atthi Arahato samgaiiikaramata ti V Na h'evaiii vattabbe. Atthi Arahato saiiiganikaramata ti '? Amanta. Atthi Arahato ra.^o kamarago kamaragapariyutthanam kamaragasanhojanain kamogho kamayogo kamacchanda- nlvaranan ti ? Na h'evani vattal)be. 61. Parihayati Aiaha arahatta ti? Amanta. Araha arahatta parihayamano kiinpariyutthico pari hayatiti ? Ragapariyutthito parihayatiti. Pariyntthanani kiiii paticca iippajjatiti ? Annsayani paticca uppajjatlti. Atthi Arahato anusaya ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 92 KATHAVAT'I'HU. [I. 2. Atthi Anihato anusaya ti ? Anianta. Atthi Arahato kamaraganusayo patighannsayo mananu- sayo ditthanusayo vicikicchaniisayo bhavaraganusayo avij- janusayo ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe. Dosapariyutthito parihayatiti — pe — mohapariyutthito parihayatlti. Pariyutthanam kim paticca uppajjatiti '? Anusayain paticca uppajjatiti. Atthi Arahato anusaya ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi Arahato anusaya ti ? Anianta. Atthi Arahato kamaraganusayo — pe — avijjanusayo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe. 62. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti *? Amanta. Arahato arahatta parihayamanassa khn upacayam gacchatiti ? Rago upacayam gacchatiti. Sakkayaditthi upacayam gacchatiti, viccikiccha upaca- yani gacchatiti, silabbataparamaso upacayam gacchatiti? Na h'evani vattabbe. Doso upacayam gacchatiti — pe — moho upacayam gac- chatiti, sakkayaditthi upacayarn gacchatiti, vicikiccha upa- cayain gacchatiti, silabbataparamaso upacayani gacchatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 61. Parihayati Araha arahatta ti? Amanta. Araha acinatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Araha apacinatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Araha pajahatiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe. Araha upadiyatiti ? ' I udapadayati, P. I. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 93 Na h'evaiu vattabbe. Araha visiiietiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe. Araha ussinetlti"? ^ Na h'evam vattabbe. Araha vidhupetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Araha sandhupetlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Nanu Araha n'ev' acinati, na apacinati apacinitva thito ti? Amanta. Hanoi Araha n'ev' acinati na apacinati apacinitva thito, no vata re vattabbe " Parihayati Araha arahatta ti." Nanu Araha n'eva pajahati na upadiyati pajahitva thito ti? Amanta. Hahci Araha n'eva pajahati na upadiyati pajahitva thito, no vata re vattabbe " Parihayati Araha arahatta ti." Nanu Araha n'eva visineti na ussineti visinitva thito ti'? Amanta. Hahci Araha n'eva visineti na ussineti visinitva thito, no vata re vattabbe "Parihayati Araha arahatta ti." Nanu Araha n'eva vidhupeti na sandhupeti vidhupetva thito ti ? Amanta. Hahci Araha n'eva vidhupeti na sandhupeti vidhupetva thito, no vata re vattabbe "Parihayati Araha arahatta ti.'^ P a r i h a n i k a t h a I. 3. 1. N'attbi devesu brahmacariyavaso ti? Amanta. I usineti, P. 94 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 3. Sabbe deva jala' elamiiga avinfiii hattliasamvacika iia patibala siibhasitadiibbhasitanam atthani annatum, sabbe 2 deva na Buddhe pasanna na Dhamme pasanna na Sanighe pasanna, na Biiddhain Bhagavantam payirupa- santi, na Buddham Bhagavantam panham pucchanti, na Biiddhena Bhagavata paiihe vissajjite attamana, sabbe deva kamniavaranena saniannagata kilesavaranena saman- nagata vipakavaranena saniannagata assaddha acchandika duppanfia abhabba niyamani okkamitum kusalesii dham- mesu sammattain, sabbe deva niatughataka pitughataka arabantaghataka ruhiruppadaka 3 sanighabhedaka, sabbe deva panatipatino adinnadayino kamesn niicchacarino niusavadino pisunavaca pharusavaca sanipliappalapino abhijjhahino 4 byapannacitta micchaditthika ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Nann atthi deva ajala anelamuga viniin na hattlia- samvacika patibala subhasitadubbhasitanani attham aniia- turn, atthi 5 deva Biiddhe pasanna Dhamme pasanna Samghe pasanna, Buddham Bhagavantain payirupasanti, Buddham Bhagavantain paiihani pucchanti, Buddhena Bhagavata paiihe vissajjite attamana honti, atthi deva na kamniavaranena samannagata na kilesavaranena saman- nagata na vipakavaranena saniannagata saddha chandika paniiavanto bhabba niyamain okkamitum kusalesu dliani- mesu sammattain, atthi deva na niatughataka na pitu- ghataka na arabantaghataka na ruhiruppadaka na saingha- bhedaka, atthi deva na panatipatino na adinnadayino na kamesu niicchacarino na musavadino na pisunavaca na pharusavaca na sanipliappalapino na abhijjhaluno abya- pannacitta sammaditthikati '? Amanta. Haiici atthi deva ajala anelamuga vihhu na hattlia- 1 jala, P.S. 2 P.S.S2. omit from sablje to visajjite attamana. 3 ruhiruppataka, S. ; ruhituppadaka, M. 4 abhijjhalano, P.S. ; abhijjhalano, S2. 5 P.S.8.,- do not omit from atthi to attamana. I. 8.] KATHAVATTHU. 95 samvacika patibala subhasitadubbhasitanain atthain aiiiia- tuiii — pe — abyapannacitta sammaditthika, no vata re vattabbe " N'atthi devesu brahmacariyavaso ti." 8. Atthi devesu brahmacariyavaso ti? Amanta. Atthi tattha pabbajja mundiyani kasavadharana patta- dharana, devesu sammasanibuddha uppajjanti, pacceka- sambuddha uppajjanti, savakayugain uppajjatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Devesu pabbajja n'atthiti, n'atthi devesu ])rahnia- cariyavaso ti '? Amanta. Yattha atthi pabbajja tatth'eva brahmacariyavaso, yattha n'atthi pabbajja n'atthi tattha brahmacariyavaso ti? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Yattha atthi pabbajja tatth'eva brahmacariyavaso, yattha n'atthi pabbajja n'atthi tattha brahmacariyavaso ti? Amanta. Yo pabbajjati tass'eva ' l)rahmacariyavaso, yo na pabbajjati n'atthi tassa brahmacariyavaso ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Devesu mundiyain n'atthiti, n'atthi devesu brahma- cariyavaso ti ? Amanta. Yattha atthi mundiyani tatth'eva brahmacariyavaso, yattha n'atthi mundiyain, n'atthi tattha brahmacariya- vaso ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Yattha atthi mundiyani tatth'eva brahmacariyavaso, yattha n'atthi mundiyani n'atthi tattha brahmacariya- vaso ti ? Amanta. Yo mundo hoti tass'eva brahmacariyavaso, yo mundo na hoti n'atthi tassa brahmacariyavaso ti ? I tatth'eva, P. 96 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 3. Na h'evaiii vattabbe — pe — G. Devesu kasavadharana n'atthiti, n'atthi devesu brahmacariyavaso ti ? Aniaiita. Yattha atthi kasavadharana tatth'eva brahmacariyavaso, yattba n'atthi kasavadharana n'atthi tattha brahmacariya- vaso ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Yattha atthi kasavadharana tatth'eva brahmacariyavaso, yattha n'atthi kasavadharana n'atthi tattha brahmacariya- vaso ti ? Amanta. Yo kasavaiii dhareti tass'eva brahmacariyavaso, yo kasa- vain na dliareti n'atthi tassa brahmacariyavaso ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Devesu pattadharana n'atthiti, n'atthi devesu brah- macariyavaso ti ? Amanta. Yattha atthi pattadharana tatth'eva brahmacariyavaso, yattha n'atthi pattadharana n'atthi tattha brahmacariya- vaso ti V Na h'evaiu vattabbe — pe — Yattha atthi pattadharana tatth'eva brahmacariyavaso, yattha n'atthi pattadharana n'atthi tattha brahmacariya- vaso ti ? Amanta. Yo pattani dhareti tass'eva brahmacariyavaso, yopattam na dhareti n'atthi tassa brahmacariyavaso ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe - 8. Devesu sammasambuddha n'uppajjantiti, n'atthi devesu brahmacariyavaso ti ? Amanta. Yattha sammasambuddha uppajjanti tatth'eva brah- macariyavaso, yattha sammasambuddha n'uppajjanti n'atthi tattha brahmacariyavaso ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Yattha sammasambuddha uppajjanti tatth'eva brah- macariyavaso, yattha sammasambuddha n'uppajjanti n'atthi tattha brahmacariyavaso ti? I. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 97 Am ant a. Lumbiniya^ Bhagava jatoBodhiyamule abhisambuddho Baranasiyam Bhagavata dhammacakkam pavattitam tatth'eva brahmacariyavaso, n'atth' anfiatra brahmacariya- vaso ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 9. Devesu Paccekasambuddha n'uppajjantiti, n'atthi devesu brahmacariyavaso ti ? Amanta. Yattha Paccekasambuddha uppajjanti tatth'eva brahma- cariyavaso, yattha Paccekasambuddha n'uppajjanti n'atthi tattha brahmacariyavaso ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Yattha Paccekasambuddha uppajjanti tatth'eva brahma- cariyavaso, yattha Paccekasambuddha n'uppajjanti n'atthi tattha brahmacariyavaso ti '? Amanta. Majjhimesu janapadesu^ Paccekasambuddha uppajjanti tatth'eva brahmacariyavaso, n'atth' ahhatra brahmacariya- vaso ti ■? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 10. Devesu savakayugam n'uppajjatiti, n'atthi devesu brahmacariyavaso ti ? Amanta. Yattha savakayugam uppajjati tatth'eva brahmacariya- vaso, yattha savakayugam n'uppajjati n'atthi tattha brah- macariyavaso ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Y'attha savakayugam uppajjati tatth'eva brahmacariya- vaso, yattha savakayugam n'uppajjati n'atthi tattha brah- macariyavaso ti ? Amanta. Magadhesu savakayugam uppannam tatth'eva brahma- cariyavaso, n'atth' ahhatra brahmacariyavaso ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 11. Atthi devesu brahmacariyavaso ti ? I Lambiniya, P.S. - janappadesu, M. 8 98 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 3. Amanta. Sabbadevesu atthi brahmacariyavaso ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi manussesu brahmacariyavaso ti '? Amanta. Sabbamanussesu atthi brahmacariyavaso ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi devesu brahmacariyavaso ti '? Amanta. Asahhasattesu devesu atthi brahmacariyavaso ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi manussesu brahmacariyavaso ti ? Amanta. Paccantimesu janapadesu atthi brahmacariyavaso milak- khiisu ^ avinhataresu, yattha n'atthi gati bhikkhiinam bhikkhunlnam upasakanaiii upasikanan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe. 12. Atthi devesu brahmacariyavaso ti ? Atthi yattha atthi, ^ atthi yattha n'atthlti. Asaiihasattesu devesu atthi yattha atthi, atthi yattha n'atthi brahmacariyavaso, sahhasattesu 3 devesu atthi yattha atthi, atthi yattha n'atthi brahmacariyavaso ti? Na h'evam vattabbe. Devesu atthi yattha atthi, atthi yattha n'atthi brahma- cariyavaso ti '? Amanta. Kattha atthi kattha n'atthlti ? Asannasattesu devesu n'atthi brahmacariyavaso, san- nasattesu devesu atthi brahmacariyavaso ti. Asafifiasattesu devesu n'atthi brahmacariyavaso ti ? Amanta. Baiihasattesu devesu n'atthi brahmacariyavaso ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Sannasattesu devesu atthi brahmacariyavaso ti ? Amanta. ^ milakkhesu, P. ^ p g omit atthi. 3 saMasattesu, K. ; asaiinasattesu all MSS. I. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 99 Asaiinasattesu devesu atthi bralimacariyavaso ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe. 13. Atthi manussesu brahinacariyavaso ti '? Atthi yattha atthi atthi yattha n'atthlti. Paccantimesu janapadesu atthi yattha atthi, atthi yattha n'atthi brahinacariyavaso milakkhusu aviMataresn, yattha n'atthi gati bhikkhunain bhikkhuninain iipasakanani upa- sikanain, majjhimesu janapadesu atthi yattha atthi, atthi yattha n'atthi brahmacariyavaso ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Manussesu atthi yattha atthi, atthi yattha n'attlii brah- macariyavaso ti ? Amanta. Kattha atthi kattha n'atthlti '? Paccantimesu janapadesu n'atthi brahmacariyavaso milakkhusu avihiiataresu, yattha n'atthi gati bhikkhunain bhikkhuninain upasakanam upasikanam, majjhimesu jana- padesu atthi brahmacariyavaso ti. Paccantimesu janapadesu n'atthi brahinacariyavaso milakkhusu aviiiiiataresu, yattha n'atthi gati bhikkhunain bhikkhuninain upasakanain upasikanan ti ? Amanta. Majjhimesu janapadesu n'atthi brahmacariyavaso ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Majjhimesu janapadesu atthi brahmacariyavaso ti '? Amanta. Paccantimesu janapadesu atthi brahmacariyavaso milakkhusu aviiiiiataresu, yattha n'atthi gati bhikkhunain bhikkhuninain upasakanain upasikanan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe. 14. Atthi devesu brahmacariyavaso ti '? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata. " Tlhi Bhikkhave thanehi Jambudlpaka manussa Uttarakuruke ca manusse adhigan- hanti deve ca Tavatimse. Katamehi tlhi ? Sura sati- manto idha brahmacariyavaso ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti '■* Amanta. 100 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 3. Tena hi n'atthi devesu brahmacariyavaso ti. Savatthiyaiii vuttaip Bhagavata " Idha brahmacari- yavaso ti " ? Amanta. Savatthiyan neva brahmacariyavaso, n'atthi afiiiatra brahmacariyavaso ti V Na h'evani vattabbe. 15. Anagamissa puggalassa pahc' orambhagiyani san- hojanani pahlnani pahc' nddhambhagiyani sahhojanani appahlnani, ito ciitassa tattha uppannassa kiihim phahippattiti V ^ Tatth'eva. Hanci anagamissa puggalassa paiic'orambhagiyani sah- hojanani pahlnani pane' nddhambhagiyani sahhojanani appahlnani, ito cutassa tattha uppannassa tahim phahip- patti, no vata re vatabbe "N'atthi devesu brahmacariya- vaso ti." 16. Anagamissa puggalassa pane' orambhagiyani sah- hojanani pahmani pane' nddhambhagiyani sahhojanani appahlnani ito cutassa tattha uppannassa kuhim bharo- haranam kuhim dukkhaparihhatain kuhim kilesappahanam kuhim nirodhasacchikiriya kuhim akuppapativedho ti ? Tatth'eva. Hahci anagamissa puggalassa pane' orambhagiyani sahhojanani pahhiani pane' nddhambhagiyani sahhojanani appahmani ito cutassa tattha uppannassa tahim akuppa- pativedho, no vata re vattabbe "N'a,tthi devesu brahma- cariyavaso ti." Anagamissa puggalassa pane' orambhagiyani sahhoja- nani pahmani pane' nddhambhagiyani sahhojanani appa- hlnani ito cutassa tattha uppannassa tahim phaluppatti tahini bharoharanam tahim dukkhaparihhatain tahiiii kilesappahanam tahim nirodhasacchikiriya tahim akuppa- pativedho ; ken' atthena vadesi "n'atthi devesu brahma- cariyavaso ti ? " Handa hi anagami puggalo idha bhavitena maggena tattha phalain sacchikaroti. ^ phalappatti, P.S. I. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 101 17. Anagami puggalo idha bhavitena maggena tattha phalam sacchikarotiti V Amanta. Sotapanno piiggalo tattha bhavitena maggena idha phalain sacchikarotiti V Na h'evam vattabbe. Anagami puggalo idha bhavitena maggena tattha phalain sacchikarotiti ? Amanta. SakadagamI puggalo idha parinibbayl puggalo tattha bhavitena maggena idha phalam sacchikarotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Sotapanno puggalo idha bhavitena maggena idha phalain sacchikarotiti '? Amanta. Anagami puggalo tattha bhavitena maggena tattha phalam sacchikarotiti V Na h'evam vattabbe. SakadagamI puggalo idha parinibbayl puggalo idha bhavitena maggena idha phalam sacchikarotiti ? Amanta. Anagami puggalo tattha bhavitena maggena tattha phalain sacchikarotiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe. 18. Idha vihayanitthassa ^ puggalassa maggo ca bhavl- yati na ca kllesa pahlyantiti '? Amanta. Sotapattiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa puggalassa maggo ca bhavlyati na ca kilesa pahlyantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Idha vihayanitthassa puggalassa maggo ca bhavlyati na ca kilesa pahlyantiti V Amanta. Sakadagainiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa pugga- lassa — pe — arahattasacchikiriyaya patipannassa pugga- lassa maggo ca bhavlyati, na ca kilesa pahlyantiti ? I oditthassa, P.S.S^ 102 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 3. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sotapattiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa puggalassa apubbaui acarimam maggo ca bhavlyati kilesa ca pahiyan- titi? Aiiianta. Idha vihayanltthassa puggalassa apubbam acarimam maggo ca bhavlyati kilesa ca pahlyantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa puggalassa — pe — arahattasacchikiriyaya patipannassa puggalassa apubbam acarimain maggo ca bhavlyati kilesa ca pahlyantiti ? Amanta. Idha vihayanltthassa puggalassa apubbam acarimam maggo ca bhavlyati kilesa ca pahlyantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 19. AnagamI puggalo katakaraniyo bhavitabhavano tattha uppajjatlti ? Amanta. Araha uppajjatlti? Na h'evam vattabbe. Araha uppajjatlti ? Amanta. Atthi Arahato punabbhavo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atthi Arahato punabbhavo ti ? Amanta. Araha bhavena bhavain gacchati gatiya gatim gacchati samsarena samsarain gacchati uppattiya uppattiin gac- chatlti ? Na h'evani vattabbe. AnagamI puggalo katakaraniyo bhavitabhavano anohi- tabharo ^ tattha uppajjatlti ? Amanta. Bharoharanaya puna maggam bhavetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. ^ anohatabharo, M. ; anohatabharo, S.K. I. 4.] ICATHAVATTHU. 103 20. Anagaml puggalo katakaraniyo bhavitabhavano apariniiatadukkho appahlnakileso asacchikatanirodho appatividdhakuppo tattha uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Akuppapativedhaya puna maggaip bhavetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Anagami puggak^ katakaraniyo bhavitabhavano anohita- bharo tattha uppajjati, na ca bharoharanaya puna maggam bhavetiti ? Amanta. Anohitabharo ca tattha parinibbayatiti V Na h'evam vattabbe. Anagaml puggalo katakaraniyo bhavitabhavano aparifi- hatadukkho appahlnakileso asacchikatanirodho appati- vidhakuppo tattha uppajjati, na ca akuppapativedhaya puna maggam bhavetiti ? Amanta. Apatividdhakuppo ca tattha parinibbayatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 21. Yathamigo sallena viddho ^ duram pi gantva kalam- karoti evaiii evam anagaml puggalo idha bhavitena mag- gena tattha phalain sacchikarotlti. Yatha niigo sallena viddho duram pi gantva sasallo - va kalam karoti, evam evam anagaml puggalo idha bhavitena maggena tattha sasallo va parinibbayatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — B r a h m a c a r i y a k a t h a. I. 4. 1. Odhisodhiso 3 kilese 4 jahatiti ? AmanTa! Sotapattiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo duk- khadassanena kiin jahatiti ? I sallaviddho, P. - asallo, S. 3 odhiso, 1'. ■* kilesam, P.Sa. 10-4 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 4. Sakkayaditthiiii vicikicchaiu silabbataparamasam tade- katthe ca kilese ekadese jahatlti. Ekadesam sotapanno, ekadesam na sotapanno, eka- desam sotapattiphalappatto patiladdho adliigato sacchi- kato upasampajja viharati, kayena phusitva ^ viharati, ekadesam na kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesam sattak- khattuparamo, kolamkolo, ekabljl, Buddheaveccappasadena samannagato, Dhamme — pe — , Sainghe — pe — , ariyakan- tehi sTlehi samannagato, ekadesain ariyakantehi silehi na samannagato ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — 2. Samudayadassanena kim jahatlti ? Sakkayaditthim jahati, vicikicchain silabbataparamasain tadekatthe ca kilese ekadese jahatlti. Ekadesam sotapanno, ekadesam na sotapanno — pe — ekadesain ariyakantehi silehi na samannagato ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 3. Nirodhadassanena kim jahatlti? Vicikicchain jahati, silabbataparamasam tadekatthe ca kilese ekadese jahitlti. Ekadesain sotapanno, ekadesain na sotapanno — pe — ekadesam ariyakantehi silehi na samannagato ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — • 4. Maggadassanena kim jahatlti? Silabbataparamasain tadekatthe ca kilese ekadese jaha- tlti. Ekadesam sotapanno, ekadesam na sotapanno — pe — ekadesam ariyakantehi silehi na samannagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo dukkhadassanena kim jahatlti ? Olarikam kamaragam jahati, olarikain byapadain tade- katthe ca kilese ekadese jahatlti. Ekadesain sakadagaml, ekadesam na sakadagami, eka- desam sakadagamiphalappatto patiladdho adhigato sacchi- kato upasampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, eka- desam na kayena phusitva viharatiti ? I phussitva, P.Sa- I. 4.] KATHAVATTHU. 105 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Samudayadassanena kim jahatiti ? Olarikaiu kainaragain jahati, olarikam byapadain tade- katthe ca kilese ekadese jahatiti. Ekadesam sakadagami ekadesain na sakadagainT eka- desam sakadagamiphalappatto patihiddho adhigato sacchi- kato upasampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, eka- desam na kayena phusitva viharatiti '? Na h'evain vuttabbe — pe — . 7. Nirodhadassanena kim jahatiti? Olarikam byapadam jahati, tad ekatthe ca kilese eka- dese jahatiti. Ekadesam sakada^fami ekadesam na sakadagami eka- desam sakadagamiphalappatto patiladdho adhigato sacchi- kato upasampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesam na kayena phusitva viharatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Maggadassanena kiin jahatiti ? Tadekatthe kilese jahatiti. Ekadesain sakadagami ekadesain na sakadagami eka- desam sakadagamiphalappatto patiladdho adhigato sacchi- kato upasampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, eka- desam na kayena phusitva viharatiti '? Na h'evain vattabbe— pe— 9. Anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo duk- khadassanena kim jahatiti ? Anusahagatam kamaragain jahati, anusahagatam bya- padam tadekatthe ca kilese ekadese jahatiti. Ekadesain anagami, ekadesam na anagami, ekadesain anagamiphalappatto patiladdho adhigato sacchikato upa- sampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesain na kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesam antai-aparinibbayl, upahaccaparinibbayl, asainkharaparinibbayl, sasamkhara- parinibbayl, uddhainsoto akanitthagami, ekadesain na uddhamsoto akanitthaframlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 10. Samudayadassanena kiin jahatiti ? 106 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 4. Anusahagatam kamaragam jahati, anusahagatam bya- padain tadekatthe ca kilese ekadese jahatlti. Ekadesaiu anagami, ekadesam na anagainl, ekadesam anagaiiiiphalappatto patiladdho adhigato sacchikato upa- sampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesam na kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesam antaraparinibbayi, upahaccaparinibbayT, asainkharaparinibbayl, sasamkhara- parinibbayl, uddhamsoto akanitthagaml, ekadesam na uddhamsoto akanitthagamiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 11. Nirodhadassanena kiin jahatlti? Anusahagatani byapadam jahati, tadekatthe ca kilese ekadese jahatlti. Ekadesam anagami, ekadesain na anagami, ekadesam anagamiphalappatto patiladdlio adhigato sacchikato upa- sampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesain na kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesain antaraparinibbayi, upahaccaparinibbayl, asainkharaparinibbayl, sasainkhara- parinibbayl, uddhainsoto akanitthagaml, ekadesain na uddhamsoto akanitthagamiti ? • • • o Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 12. Maggadassanena kiin jahatlti? Tadekatthe kilese jahatlti. Ekadesain anagami, ekadesain na anagami, ekadesam anagamiphalappatto patiladdho adhigato sacchikato upa- sampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesam na kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesain antaraparinibbayi, upahaccaparinibbayl, asainkharaparinibbayl, sasamkhara- parinibbayl, uddhainsoto akanitthagaml, ekadesain na uddhamsoto akanitthagamiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 18. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo dukkha- dassanena kiiu jahatlti ? liiiparagam aruparagain manani uddhaccain avijjain tadekatthe ca kilese ekadese jahatlti. Ekadesain Araha, ekadesain na Araha, ekadesain arahat- tappatto, patiladdho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesain na kayena I. 4.] KATHAVATTHU. 107 phusitva viharati, ekadesam vitarago vltadoso vltamoho, katakaranlyo ohitabharo anuppattasadattho, parikkhlna- bhavasannojano saiumadanna vimutto nkkhittapaligho samkinnaparikho abbiUhesiko niraggalo ariyo paniiad- dhajo pannabharo visannutto suvijitavijayo, dukkhaiii tassa pariniiatam, saiiiudayo pahino, nirodho sacchikato, maggo bhavito, abhinneyyaip abhifmatam, parinneyyain parinnatam, pahatabbam pahlnaiii, bhavetabbain bhavi- tam, sacchikatabbam sacchikatain, ekadesani sacchika- tabbani sacchikatam, ekadesam sacchikatabbam na sacchi- katan ti '> Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 14. Samudayadassanena kim jahatiti ? Euparagaiu aruparagaiii manam iiddhaccam avijjani tadekatthe ca kilese ekadese jahatiti. Ekadesam Araha, ekadesani na Araha, ekadesani arahat- tappatto, patiladdho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesaiii na kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesam vitarago vltadoso vltamoho, katakaranlyo ohitabharo anuppattasadattho, parikkhlna- bhavasahhojano samniadahha vimutto ukkliittapahgho sainkinnaparikho abbulhesiko niraggalo ariyo pannaddhajo pannabharo visannutto suvijitavijayo, dukkham tassa parinnatam, samudayo pahino, nirodho sacchikato, maggo bhavito, abhihiieyyam abhihhatam, parihiieyyam pariii- hatani, pahatabbani pahlnani, bhavetabbain bhavitam, sacchikatabbani sacchikatain, ekadesani. sacchikatabbam sacchikatain, ekadesain sacchikatabbani na sacchikatan ti? * Na h'evani vattabbe. 15. Nirodhadassanena kim jahatiti ? Manaiu jahati, uddhaccani avijjani tadekatthe ca kilese ekadese jahatiti. Ekadesani Araha, ekadesani na Araha, ekadesani arahat- tappatto, patiladdho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesani na kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesani vltanigo vltadoso vltamoho, katakaranlyo ohitabharo anuppattasadattho, parikkhlna- 108 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 4. bhavasaiiiiojano sammadaiina vimutto ukkhittapaligho samkinnaparikho abbulhesiko niraggalo ariyo pannaddhajo pannabharo visaniiutto suvijitavijayo, dukkham tassa parinnatam, sainudayo pahiiio, nirodho sacchikato, maggo bhavito, abhiniieyyain abhinnatam, pariniieyyam parin- natani, pahatabbam pahinam, bhavetabbam bhavitam, sacchikatabbam sacchikatam, ekadesam sacchikatabbam sacchikatam, ekadesam sacchikatabbam na sacchikatan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 16. Maggadassanena kim jahatiti ? Uddhaccam jahati, avijjaiu tadekatthe ca kilese ekadese jahatiti. Ekadesam Araha, ekadesamnaAraha, ekadesam arahat- tappatto, patiladdho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesam na kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesain vltarago vltadoso vltamoho, katakaranlyo ohitabharo aimppattasadattho, parikkhlna- bhavasahiiojano sammadahiia vimutto nkkhittapahgho samkinnaparikho abbulhesiko niraggalo ariyo pannaddhajo pannabharo visaiiiiutto suvijitavijayo, dukkhaiu tassa parinnatam, samudayo pahlno, nirodho sacchikato, maggo bhavito, abhiiiheyyam abhinnatam, pariiiheyyani parin- natam, pahatabbani pahlnaip, bhavetabbani bhavitam, sacchikatabbain sacchikatani, ekadesam sacchikatabbam sacchikatam, ekadesain sacchikatabbam na sacchikatan ti? ' Na h'evam vattabbe. 17. Na vattabbam — ■" Odhisodhiso kilese jahatiti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata. " Anupubbena medhavl thokam thokam khane khane Kammaro rajatass' ' eva niddhame malam attano ti." x^tth' eva suttanto ti '? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam — " Odhisodhiso kilese jahatiti." I rajakass'., P.S2. I. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 109 18. Odhisodhiso kilesei jahaliti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Saha v'assa ^ dassanasampadaya Tayas su dhamma jahita bhavanti Sakkayaditthi vicikicchitaii ca Sllabbatam va pi yad atthi kinci, C ^ « . Catuh' apayehi ca vippamutto, ~ A. i Cha cabhithanani abhabbo katmi ^ ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam — " Odhisodhiso kilese jahatiti." 19. Odhisodhiso kilese jahatiti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttain Bhagavata — " Yasmim Bhikkhave samaye ariyasavakassa virajam vitamalam dhammacakkhum udapadi ' yam kiiici samudayadhammaip, sabban tain nirodhadhamman ti,' saha dassanuppada 3 Bhikkhave ariyasavakassa tlni saiiiiojanani pahlyanti, sakkayaditthi vicikiccha sllabbataparamaso ti." Atth' eva suttanto tiV Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam — " Odhisodhiso kilese jahatiti." d h i s o k a t h a. I. 0. 1. Jahati puthujjano kamaragabyapadan ti V Amanta. Accantani jahati, anavasesam jahati, appatisandhiyani jahati, samulam jahati, satanhani jahati, sanusayaiii jahati, ariyena hanena jahati, ariyena maggena jahati, I Saha vasaddassana, M. ^ abhabbakatun, M. 3 sahassanupada, H. ; sahassanupava, P. 110 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 5. akuppam pativijjhanto jahati, anagamiphalam sacchi- karonto jahatiti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 2. Vikkhambheti puthujjano kamaragabyapadan ti '? Aiuanta. Accantam vikkhambheti, anavasesam vikkhambheti, appatisandhiyam vikkhambheti, samulaiii vikkhambheti, satanham vikkhambheti, sanusayaiii vikkhambheti, ariyena fianena vikkhambheti, ariyena maggena vikkhambheti, akuppam pativijjhanto vikkhambheti, anagamiphalam sac- chikaronto jahatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Jahati anagamiphahisacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo kamaragabyapadani, so ca accantain jahati, anavasesam jahati, appatisandhiyam jahati, samulam jahati, satanham jahati, sanusayam jahati, ariyena iianena jahati, ariyena maggena jahati, akuppam pativijjhanto jahati, anagami- phalam sacchikaronto jahatiti ? Amanta. Jahati puthujjano kamaragabyapadam, so ca accan- tam jahati, anavasesam jahati, appatisandhiyain jahati, samulam jahati, satanhani jahati, sanusayam jahati, ariyena hanena jahati, ariyena maggena jahati, akuppam pativijjhanto jahati, anagamiphalam sacchikaronto jahatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Vikkhambheti anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo kamaragabyapadam, so ca accantam vikkham- l)heti,anavasesam vikkhambheti, appatisandhiyam vikkham- bheti, samidain vikkhambheti, satanham vikkhambheti, sanusayam vikkhambheti, ariyena iianena vikkhambheti, ariyena maggena vikkhambheti, akuppain pativijjhanto vikkhambheti, anagamiphalani sacchikaronto jahatiti? Amanta. Vikkhambheti puthujjano kamaragabyapadani, so ca accantam vikkhambheti, anavasesani vikkhambheti, appatisandhiyam vikkhambheti, samulani vikkhambheti, satanham vikkhambheti, sanusayani vikkhambheti, ariyena I. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. Ill nanena vikkhambheti, ariyena maggena vikkhambheti, akuppam pativijjhanto vikkhambheti, anagamiphalam sacchikaronto jahatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 5. Jahati puthujjano kamaragabyapadam, so ca na accantam jahati, na anavasesam jahati — pe — na anagami- phalam sacchikaronto jahatiti ? Amanta. Jahati anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo kamaragabyapadam, so ca na accantain jahati — pe — na anagamiphalam sacchikaronto jahatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe. 6. Vikkhambheti puthujjano kamaragabyapadain, so ca na accantam vikkhambheti, na anavasesam vikkhambheti — pe — na anagamiphalam sacchikaronto jahatiti '? Amanta. Vikkhambheti anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo kamaragabyapadam, so ca na accantam vikkham- bheti, na anavasesam vikkhambheti, — pe — na anagami- phalam sacchikaronto vikkhambhetiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe. 7. Jahati puthujjano kamaragabyapadan ti? Amanta. Katamena maggenati '? Eupavacarena ^ maggenati. Rupavacaro maggo niyyaniko khayagami bodhagami apacayagami anasavo asahhojanlyo aganthanlyo ano- ghanlyo ayoganlyo anivaranlyo aparamattho anupadaniyo asainkilesiyo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe. 8. Nanu rupavacaro maggo aniyyaniko na khayagami na bodhagami na apacayagami sasavo sanhojaulyo — pe — samkilesiyo ti ? Amanta. Hanci rupavacaro magg(j aniyyaniko na khayagami — pe — samkilesiyo, no vata re vattabbe " Jahati puthuj- jano rfipavacarena maggena, kamaragabyapadan ti." I °vacare, P.S2. 112 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 5. 9. Jahati anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno pug- galo anagamiinaggena kamaragabyapadam, so ca maggo niyyaniko khayagainl bodhagami apacayagami anasavo — pe — asainkilesiyo ti ? Ainanta. Jalmti pnthujjano rupavacarena maggena kamaraga- byapadani, so ca maggo niyyaniko khayagami bodhagami apacayagami anasavo — pe — asainkilesiyo ti ? Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — . 10. Jahati pnthujjano rupavacarena maggena kamaraga- byapadam, so ca maggo aniyyaniko na khayagami na bodhagami na apacayagami sasavo — pe — samkilesiyo ti ? Amanta. Jahati anagamisacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo ana- gamimaggena kamaragabyapadam — pe — so ca maggo aniyyaniko na khayagami na bodhagami na apacaya- gami sasavo — pe — sainkilesiyo ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe. 11. Pnthujjano kamesu vltarago saha dhainmabhisa- maya anagamiphale santhatiti '? Amanta. Arahatte santhatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Pnthujjano kamesu vltarago saha dhammabhisamaya anagamiphali' santhatiti ? Amanta. Apubbain acarimaiii tayo magge bhavetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Apubbani acarimain tayo magge bhavetiti ? Amanta. Apubbani acarimain tlni samaiihaphakiiii sacchikaro- tlti ? Na h'evani vattabbe. Apubbani acarimam tlni samaiiiiaphalaiii sacchikaro- tlti? Amanta. Tinnain phassanani tinnani vedananam tinnam safina- nam tinnam cetananam tinnam cittanam tinnam saddha- I. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 113 nam tinnam viriyanam tinnam satinam tinnam sainadhl- nam tinnam pannanam samodhanam hotiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe. 12. Piithujjano kamesn vltarago saha dhammabhisa- maya anagamiphale santhatiti '? Amanta. Sotapattimaggenati ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Sakadagamimaggenati ? Na li'evam vattabbe. Katamena maggenati '? Anagamimaggenati. Anagamimaggena sakkayaditthim vicikiccliam silab- bataparamasam jahatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe. Anagamimaggena sakkayaditthim vicikiccham sllab- bataparamasam jahatiti ? Amanta. Nanu tinnam sahhojananam pahana sotapattiphalam vuttam Bhagavata ti ? Amanta. Haiici tinnam saniiojananam pahana sotapattiphalam vuttam Bhagavata, no vata re vattabbe "Anagamimag- gena sakkayaditthim vicikiccham silabbataparamasain jahatiti." 13. Anagamimaggena olarikam kamaragam olarikam byapadam jahatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagamimaggena olarikam kamaragam olarikam bya- padam jahatiti ? Amanta. Nann kamaragabyapadanam taniibhava ^ sakadagami- phalam viittani Bhagavata ti '? Amanta. Hafici kamaragabyapadanam tanubhava sakadagami- phalam viittani Bhagavata, no vata re vattabbe "Anaga- patanu°, P.S.S2. 9 114 KATHAVATTHU. [I, 5. mimaggena olarikain kamaragam olarikaiP byapadam jahatlti." Pnthnjjano kamesu vltarago saha dhammabhisamaya anagamiphale santhatiti '? Am ant a. Ye ^ keci dhaiomam abhisamenti sabbe te saha dham- mabhisamaya anagamiphale santhahantiti ? ^ Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 14. Na vattabbam " Jahati puthujjano kamaragabyapa- danti'"? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhaeavata — "in"- " Ahesmn te atltamse Cha Sattharo 3 yasassino,4 Niramagandha 5 karuna ^ Vimutta 7 kamasahhojana ti. Kamaragam virajetva ^ Brahinalokupaga ahu. Ahesum savaka tesain Anekani satani pi, Niramagandha 9 karuna ^° Vimutta kamasahhojana ti. Kamaragam virajetva " Brahmalokupaga ahuti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi jahati puthujjano kamaragabyapadan ti. 15. Jahati puthujjano kamaragabyapadan ti ? Amanta. ^ Ye om. P.S. - santhapentiti, P.Sa. 3 jasakkaro, P. 4 yassasino, S. 5 niggamma, P.Sa.; nigama, S. ^ ^aruno, P.S2. 7 vimuttam, P.S2. ^ vibhajitva, P.S2. ; vibbhajjitva, S. 9 P.S.S2., have niramagandha here. ^° karuno, P.S. " viharitva, S2. I. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 115 Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " So hi nama Bhikkhave sunetto sattha ' evam dighayuko samano evam ciratthi- tiko aparimutto ahosi jatiya jaraya maranena sokehi paridevehi dukkhehi domanassehi upayasehi ' ' apari- mutto dukkhasma 2 ti " vadaini. Tarn kissa hetu ? Catunnam dhammanam ananubodha appativedha. Kata- mesam catunnam '? Ariyassa sllassa ananubodha appati- vedha, ariyassa samadhissa, ariyaya pahhaya, ariyaya vimuttiya ananubodha appativedha, tayidam Bhikkhave ariyain sllam anubuddham patividdham, ariyo samadhi anubuddho patividdho, ariya panha anubuddha patividdha, ariya vimutti anubuddha patividdha, ucchinna bhavatanha khina bhavanetti n'atth'idani punabbhavo ti. Silam samadhi pahha ca Vimutti ca anuttara, Anubuddha ime dhamma Gotamena yasassina. Iti Buddho abhihhaya Dhammam akkhasi bhikkhtinam Dukkhass' antakaro Sattha Cakkhuma parinibbuto ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Jahati puthujjano kamaragabya- padan ti." J a h a t i k a t h a . I. 6. 1. Sabbam atthiti? Amanta. Sabbattha sabbam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Sabbam atthiti ? Amanta. Sabbada sabbam atthiti '? ^ satta, P.S. 2 dukkhamha, P. 116 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 6. Na h'evam vattabbe. Sabbam atthiti ? Amanta. Sabbena sabbam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Sabbam atthiti ? Amanta. Sabbesu sabbam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Sabbam atthiti ? Amanta. Ayogan ti katva sabbam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Sabbam atthiti ? Amanta. Yam pi n'atthi tarn ^ p'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Sabbam atthiti '? Amanta. Sabbam atthiti ya ditthi sa ditthi micchaditthiti, ya ditthi 2 sa ditthi sammaditthiti h'evam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Atltam atthiti '? Amanta. 'Nanu atltam niruddham vigatam viparinatain atthaii- gatam 3 abbhatthahgatan 4 ti ? Amanta. Hahci atltain niruddham vigatani viparinatain atthahga- tam abbhatthahgatam, no vata re vattabbe "Atltam atthiti." Anagatam atthiti '? Amanta. Nanu anagatam ajatam abhtitam asahjatain 5 anib- 1 tarn atthiti, P.S.S2. 2 From ya to end S. has, Ya ditthiti yo ca m'atthi ; P.S2., so ca m'atthi. 3 atthagatam, P.S.S2. 4 abbhatthakatanti, P.S2. -5 asaiihatam, S. I. 6. J KATHAVATTHU. 117 battam anabhinibattam apatubhiitan ti ? Aiuanta. Hanci anagatam ajatam abhntam asanjatam anib- battam anabhinibattam apatubhutam, no vata re vat- tabbe " Anagatam atthlti." Paccuppannam atthi, paccuppannam aniruddhain aviga- tam aviparinatam na atthangatam na abbhatthangatan ti ? Amanta. Atltam atthi ,;^atltam anirnddham avigatam aviparinatam na atthangatam na abbhatthangatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paccuppannam atthi, paccuppannam jatam bhutain saiijatain nibbattam abhinibbattam patubhutan ti ? Amanta. Anagatam atthi, anagatam jatam bhutam saiijatam nibbattam abhinibbattam patubhutan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atltain atthi, atitam niruddham vigatam viparinatam atthangatam abbhatthangatan ti ? Amanta. Paccuppannam atthi, paccuppannam niruddham viga- tam viparinatam atthangatam abbhatthangatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatam atthi 1; anagatam ajatam abhutam asanjatam anibbattam anabhinibbattam apatubhutan ti V Amanta. Paccuppannam atthi, paccuppannam ajatam abhutam asanjatam anibbattain anabhinibbattam apatubhiitan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 3. Atltam rupam atthiti? Amanta. Nanu atltam rupam niruddham vigatam viparinatam atthahgatani abbhatthangatan ti ? Amanta. Hahci atitani rupani niruddham — pe — abbhatthahga- tam, no vata re vattabbe " Atitam rupani atthlti." Anagataui rupani atthiti '? Amanta. 118 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 6. Nanu anagatam rtipam ajatam abhutam asanjatam anibbattaiii anabhinibbattam apatiibhutan ti ? Amanta. Hanoi anagatam rupam ajatam — pe — apatiibhutam, no vata re vattabbe " Anagatam rupam atthlti." Paccuppannam rupam atthi, paccuppannam rupam aniruddham avigatam aviparinatam na atthangatam na abbhatthangatan ti "? Amanta. Atitaiu rupam atthi, atltam rupam aniruddham — pe — na abbhatthangatan ti'? Na h'evani vattabbe. Paccuppannam rupam atthi, paccuppannam rupam jatam bhutain sahjatam nibbattam abhinibbattam patu- bhutan ti '? Amanta. . Anagatam rupam atthi, anagatarn rupam jatam — pe — patubhutan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atltam rupani atthi, atltam rupam niruddham vigatam viparinatam atthahgatain abbhatthangatan ti ? Amanta. Paccuppannam rupam atthi, paccuppannam rupam niruddham vigatam viparinatani atthangatam abbhat- thangatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatam rupam atthi, anagatam rupain ajatani abhu- tam asahjatain anibbattam anabhinibbattam apatubhu- tan ti ? ' Amanta. Paccuppannani rupam atthi, paccuppannam rupam ajatam abhutam asaiijatain anibbattam anabhinibbattam apatubhutan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Atita vedana^ atthi, sanha atthi, samkhara atthi, viiahanam atthlti ? Amanta. Nanu atltain vihhanain niruddham vigatam viparinatam atthahgatain abbhatthangatan ti ? I. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 119 Amanta. Haiici atitam vinnanam niruddham — pe — abbhatthaii- gatam, no vata re vattabbe " Atitam vinnanam atthiti." Anagatam vinnanam atthiti ? O • • • Amanta. Nanu anagatam viimanani ajatam abhiitam asanjatain anibbattam anabhinibbattam apatubhutan ti '? Amanta. Hanci anagatain viniianain ajatain — pe — apatubhutain, no vata re vattabbe " Anagatam viiiiianam atthiti." Paccuppannam viiiiianam atthi, paccuppannam viiiiia- nam aniruddhani — pe — na abbhatthangatan ti ? Amanta. Atitam viiiiianam atthi, atitam viiiiianain aniruddhain — pe — na abbhatthangatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Paccuppannam vinnanam atthi, paccuppannam vinna- nam jatam — pe — -patubhutan ti ? Amanta. Anagatam vinnanam atthi, anagatam viiiiianam jatain — pe — patubhutan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atitam viiiiianam atthi, atitam vinnanam niruddham — pe — abbhattharigatan ti ? Amanta. Paccuppannani vihhanain atthi, paccuppannam viiiha- nam niruddham — pe — abbhatthangatan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe— pe — Anagatain viiiiianam atthi, anagatam vihiianam ajatam — pe — apatubhutan ti? Amanta. Paccuppannam viiiiianam atthi, paccuppannam viiina- narn ajataiii — pe — apatubhiitan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — i , 5. Paccuppannan ti va rupaii ti va rupan ti va paccup- pannan ti va paccuppannam riipam appiyain karitva , esese ekatthe same samabhage '■ tajjate ti ? ^^' . ^ ^ Amanta. / sabhage, P. and S. 120 KATHAYATTHT. [I. 6. Paccuppannam rupam nirujjhamanam paccuppanna- bhaTam jahatiti ? Ainanta. Eupabhavam jahatiti ? Ka h'evam vattabbe. Paccuppannan ti va rupan ti va rupan ti va paccup- pannan ti va paccuppannam rupam appiyam karitva esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate ti '? Amanta. Paccuppannam rupam nirujjhamanam rupabhavam na jahatiti '? Amanta. Paccuppannabhavarn na jahatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Odatan ti va vatthan ti va vatthan ti va odatan ti va odatam vattham appij'am karitva esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate ti ? Amanta. Odatarn vattham rajamanam odatabhavaui jahatiti ? Amanta. Vatthabhavam jahatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Odatan ti va vatthan ti va vatthan ti va odatan ti va odatam vattham appiyam karitva esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate ti ? Amanta. Odatam vattham rajamanam vatthabhavam na jahatiti? Amanta. Odatabhavaiii na jahatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Eupam rupal:)havarn na jahatiti ? Amanta. liupani niccam dhuvam sassatam aviparinamadham- man ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu ruparn aniccani adhuvam asassatam viparinama- dhamman ti? Amanta. I. 6.] IvATHAVATTHU. 121 Hanci rupam aniccam — pe — viparinaiuadhauiiiuuu, iio vata re vattabbe "Eupain rupabhavam iia jahatiti." 8. Nibbanam nibbanabhavaiu ua jahatiti, nibbanam niccain dlinvam sassatam aviparinaniadliamman ti ? Amanta. Eiipam rCipabhavain na jahatiti, rupam niccam dhiivam sassatam aviparinamadhammaii ti '.' Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Eupaiii rupabhavam na jahatiti, rupam aniccain acUiu- vam asassatam viparinamadhamman ti? Amanta. Nibbanam nibbanabhavam na jahatiti, mbbanaiii anic- cam adhuvam asassatam viparinaniadhannnan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 9. Atltani atthi, atltam atltabhavam na jahatiti '? Amanta. Anagatani atthi, anagatam anagatabhavam na jahatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atltani atthi, atltam atltabhavani na jahatiti? Amanta. Paccuppannam atthi, paccuppannam paccuppanna- bhavain na jahatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 10. Anagatam attlii, anagatam anagatabhilvain na jahatiti V Amanta. Atltam atthi, atltani atltabhavani na jahatiti? Na h'evain vattabbe. Paccnppamiani atthi, paccuppannam paccuppanna- bhavani na jahatiti ? Amanta. Atltani atthi, atltani atltabhavani na jahatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe. 11. Atltani atthi, atltani atltabhavani na jahatiti? Amanta. Atltani niccain dliuvain sassatani aviparinamadhainman ti? ' Na h'evain vattabbe. 122 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 6. Nanu atitam aniccam adhuvain asassatam viparinama- Qhamman ti '? Amanta. Hanci atitam aniccam adhiivam asassatam viparinama- dhammam, no vata re vattabbe "Atitam atthi, atitam atitabhavam na jahatiti." 12. Nibbanam atthi, nibbanam nibbanabhavani na jahatiti, nibbanam niccam dhuvam sassatam aviparinama- dhamman ti ? Amanta. Atitain atthi, atitam atitabhavam na jahatiti, atitam niccam dhuvam sassatain aviparinamadhamman ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atitain atthi, atitain atitabhavam na jahatiti atitam aniccam adhuvam asassatain viparinamadhamman ti ? Amanta. Nibbanam atthi, nibbanam nibbanabhavam na jahatiti, nibbanam aniccam adhuvain asassatain viparinamadham- man ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe. 13. Atitam rupam atthi, atitain rupam atitabhavani na jahatiti? Amanta. Anagatam rupain atthi, anagatam rupam anagatabha- vam na jahatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atitam riipain atthi, atitam riipam atitabhavani na jahatiti ? Amanta. Paccuppanam riipam atthi, paccuppannam rupain pac- cuppannabhavam na jahatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 14. Anagatam rupam atthi, anagatam rupain anagata- bhavam na jahatiti '? Amanta. Atitam rupam atthi, atitain riipain atitabhavam na jahatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — I. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 123 Paccuppannam rupam atthi, paccuppannam rupam paccuppannabhavam na jahatiti ? Am ant a. Atltam riipani atthi, atltam rupam atltabhavain na jahatiti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 15. Atltam rupam atthi, atltam rupam atitabhavam na jahatiti? Amanta. Atltam rupam niccam dhuvam sassatam aviparinama- dhamman ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu atltam rupam aniccam adhuvam asassatam vipa- rinamadhamman ti '? Amanta. Haiici atitain rupain aniccam — pe — viparinamadham- mam, no vata re vattabbe " Atltam rupain atthi, atltain rupain atitabhavam na jahatiti." 16. Nibbanam atthi, nibbanam nibbanabhavam na jahati, nibbanam niccam dhuvam sassatam aviparinama- dhamman ti '? Amanta. Atitain rupain atthi, atitain rupain atitabhavam na jahati, atitain rupam niccam dhuvam sassatam aviparina- madhamman ti '? ' Na h'evam vattabbe. Atitain riipam atthi, atitam rupain atitabhavam na jahati, atitain rupain aniccam adhuvain asassatam vipa- rinamadhamman ti ? Amanta. Nibbanam atthi, nibbanam nibbanabhavam na jahati, nibbanam aniccam adhuvam asassatam viparinamadham- man ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 17. Atita vedana atthi, atita saiiha atthi, atita samkhara atthi, atitam vihiianam atthi, atitain vihiianam atitabha- varn na jahatiti ? Amanta. 124 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 6. Anao'atam viiifianani atthi, anas^atam vinnanam anaga- tabliavam na jahatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atltam vinnanam atthi, atltam viiiiianam atltabhavain na jahatiti '? Amanta. Paccuppannain vinnanam atthi, paccuppannam viniia- nam paccuppannabhavam na jahatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe. 18. Anagatam viniianam atthi, anagatam vinnanam O • • • ' O • • • anagatabhavam na jahatiti ? Amanta. Atltam vihiianain atthi, atltam vinnanam atltabhavam na jahatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paccuppannam viiihanam atthi, paccuppannam vinna- nam paccuppannabhavam na jahatiti ? Amanta. Atltam viiiiianam atthi, atltain viiiiianam atltabhavam na jahatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— 19. Atltam viiihanam atthi, atltam viiihanani atltabha- vam na jahatiti? Amanta. Atltam vinnanam niccam dhuvam sassatam avlparina- madhamman ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu atltam viiiiianam aniccam adhuvam asassatam viparinamadhamman ti ? Amanta. Hahci atltain viiiiianam aniccam — pe — viparinama- dhammam, no vata re vattabbe " Atltain vihiianam atthi, atltam viiiiianam atltabhavam na jahatiti." 20. Nibbanani atthi nibbanam nibbanabhavam na jahati, nibbanam iiiccani dhuvam sassatam aviparinaina- dhamman ti ? Amanta. Atltain vinnanam atthi, atltain viiiiianani viiihana- I. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 125 bliavam na jahati, atltam vifinanam niccam dhuvam sassatam aviparinamadhamman ti "? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atltam vinnanain atthi, atltam vinnanam atitabhavain na jahati, atitam vinnanam aniccam adhuvam asassatam viparinamadhamman ti '? Amanta. Nibbanam atthi, nibbanam nibbanabhavam na jahati, nibbanam aniccain ad]:invain asassatam viparinamadham- man ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 21. Atltam ny 'atthlt i '? ^ Amanta. Hahci atitam nv' atthi,- atltam atthiti miccha, hahci va pana atthi nvatitam,3 atthi atltan ti miccha. Anagatain nv' atthiti '? Amanta. Hahci anagatam nv'atthi, anagatam atthiti miccha, hahci va pana atthi nvanagatam,4 atthi anagatan ti miccha. 22. Anagatam hutva paccuppannam hotiti ? Amanta. Tan heva anagatam tarn paccuppannan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tan heva anagatam tarn paccuppannan ti '? Amanta. Hutva hoti hutva hotiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Hutva hoti hutva hotiti ? Amanta. Na hutva na hoti na hutva na hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paccuppannam hutva atitam hotiti ? Amanta. Tan heva paccuppannani tain atitan ti '? NaJb'evam vattabbe. Tan heva paccuppannam tarn atitan ti '.* I n'atthiti, P.S. ^ n'atthi, P. 3 natthitan, P. ■+ nanagatam, P. 126 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 6. Amanta. Hutva hoti hutva hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Hutva hoti hutva hotiti ? Amanta. Na hutva na hoti na hutva na hotiti ? Na h'evaiu vattabbe. Anagatam hutva paccuppannam hoti, paccuppannam hutva atltam hotiti ? Amanta. Tan fieva anagatam tarn paccuppannam tarn atltan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Tan fieva anagatam tarn paccuppannam tarn atltan ti ? Amanta. Hutva hoti hutva hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Hutva hoti hutva hotiti ? Amanta. Na hutva na hoti na hutva na hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2H. Atltam cakkhum atthi rupa^ atthi cakkhuvinnanani atthi aloko atthi manasikaro atthiti ? Amanta. Atltena cakkhuna atltam rupam passatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atltam sotam atthi sadda ^ attlii sotaviniianam atthi akaso atthi manasikaro atthiti ? Amanta. Atltena sotena atltam saddam sunotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atltam ghanam atthi gandha atthi ghanaviiihanam atthi vayo atthi manasikaro atthiti ? Amanta. Atltena ghanena atltam gandham ghayatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atlta jivha atthi rasa atthi jivhavihiianam atthi apo atthi manasikaro atthiti ? I rupam, P. ^ saddo, P. I. 6.] I'CATHAVATTHU. 127 Amanta. Atltaya jivhaya atitam rasam sayatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atlto kayo atthi photthabba atthi kayavimianam atthi pathavl atthi manasikaro atthiti ? Amanta. Atltena kayena atitam photthabbam phusatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atlto mano atthi clhamma atthi manovihhanam atthi vatthmii atthi manasikaro atthiti '? Amanta. Atltena manena atltain dhammam vijanatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. (^^^ Anagatam cakkhmn atthi riipa atthi cakkhuviii- nanam atthi aloko atthi manasikaro atthiti ? Amanta. Anagatena cakkhiina anagatam rupam passatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Anagatam sotam atthi sadda atthi sotaviiiiianam atthi akaso atthi manasikaro atthiti '? Amanta. Anagatena sotena anagatam saddam simotlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Anagatam ghanam atthi gandha atthi ghanavihfianain atthi vayo atthi manasikaro atthiti ? Amanta. Anagatena ghanena anagatam gandhain ghayatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atlta jivha atthi rasa atthi jivhavihhanam atthi apo atthi manasikaro atthiti ? Amanta. Anagataya jivhaya anagatam rasam sayatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. AnagatO kayo atthi photthabba atthi kayavihiianam atthi pathavl atthi manasikaro atthiti ? Amanta. Anagatena kayena anagatam photthabbam phusatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 128 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 6. Anagato iiiano atthi dhamma atthi manovinnanam atthi vatthum atthi manasikaro atthiti '? Amanta. Anagatena manena anagatam dhammam vijanatiti ? Na li'evam vattabl)e. 25. Paccuppannam cakkhuin atthi rupa atthi cakkhu- vinhanam atthi aloko atthi manasikaro atthi, paccuppa- iiena cakkhuna paccuppannam rupam passatiti ? Amanta. Atltain cakkhuin atthi rupa atthi cakkhuvihfianam atthi aloko atthi manasikaro atthi, atltena cakkhuna atltam rupaiii passatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe. Paccuppannam sotam atthi ghanam atthi jivha atthi kayo atthi mano atthi dhamma atthi manovinnanam atthi vatthum atthi manasikaro atthi, paccuppannena manena paccuppannam dhammam vijanatiti? Amanta. Atito mano atthi dhamma atthi manovinnanam atthi vatthum atthi manasikaro atthi, atTtena manena atltam dhammam vijanatiti"? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— 26. Paccuppannain cakkhum atthi rupa atthi cakkhu- vihiianani atthi aloko atthi manasikaro atthi, paccuppa- nena cakkhuna paccuppannam rupam passatiti ? Amanta. Anagatain cakkhuin atthi rupa atthi cakkhuviiifianam atthi aloko atthi manasikaro atthi, anagatena cakkhuna anagatain rupam passatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Paccuppannain sotam atthi ghanam atthi jivha atthi kayo atthi mano atthi dhamma atthi manovinnanam atthi vatthum atthi manasikaro atthi, paccuppannena manena paccuppannani dhammam vijanatiti ? Amanta. Atlto mano atthi dhamma atthi manoviiihanam atthi vatthum atthi manasikaro atthi, anagatena manena anagatain dhammain vijanatiti '? I. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 129 Na h'evam vattabbe — ^pe — 27. Atitain cakkhum atthi rupa atthi cakkhuviniianaiii atthi aloko atthi manasikaro atthi, na ca atltena cakkhuna atltam riipam passatiti '? Aiuanta. Paccuppannain cakkhum atthi rupa atthi cakkhuvihna- nam atthi aloko atthi manasikaro atthi, na ca paccuppan- nena cakkhuna paccuppannain rupam passatiti ? Na h'evani vattabbe. Atltam sotam atthi ghanam atthi jivha atthi kayo atthi mano atthi dhannna atthi manovihfianain atthi vatthum atthi manasikaro atthi, na ca atltena manena atltam dhammain vijaniitlti '? Amanta. Paccuppanno mano atthi dliamma atthi manovififuinaiii atthi vatthum atthi manasikaro atthi, na ca paccuppa- nena manena paccuppannain dhammam vijanatiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 28. Anagatam cakkhum atthi rupa atthi cakkhuvihha- nam atthi aloko atthi manasikaro atthi, na ca anagatena cakkhuna anagatam rupani passatiti ? Amanta. Paccuppannain cakkhum atthi riipa atthi cakkhuvinna- nam atthi aloko atthi manasikaro atthi, na ca paccuppan- nena cakkhuna paccuppannain rupam passatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Anagatam sotam atthi ghanain atthi jivliJi atthi kayo atthi mano atthi dhamma atthi manovihhanain atthi vatthum atthi manasikaro atthi, na ca anagatena manena anagatam dhammain vijanatiti ? Amanta. Paccuppanno mano atthi dhamma atthi manovihhanam atthi vatthum atthi manasikaro atthi, na ca paccuppanena manena paccuppannain dhammain vijanatiti? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 29. Atitain nanaiii atthiti? Amanta. Tena hanena nanakaraniyaiii karotiti '? ' " 10 130 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 6. Na h'evam vattabbe. Tena nanena nanakaranlyam karotiti ? Ainanta. Tena naiiena dukkham parijanati samudayam pajahati nirodham sacchikaroti maggam bhavetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 30. Anagatam fianam atthiti '? o • • • Amanta. Tena nanena iianakaraniyam karotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Tena nanena nanakaranlyam karotiti ? Amanta. Tena nanena dukkham parijanati samudayam pajahati nirodham sacchikaroti maggam bhavetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 31. Paccuppannam hanam atthi, tena nanena hanaka- raniyam karotiti '? Ainanta. Atitam iianam atthi, tena nanena iianakaranlyain karotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paccuppannam fianam atthi, tena nanena dukkham parijanati samudayam pajahati nirodham sacchikaroti maggam bhavetiti ? Amanta. Atitam iianam atthi, tena nanena dukkham parijanati samudayain pajahati nirodham sacchikaroti maggam bhavetiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 32. Paccuppannam hanam atthi, tena nanena nanaka- ranlyam karotiti ? Ainanta. Anagatam hanam atthi, tena nanena hanakaranlvam karotiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paccuppannam hanam atthi, tena nanena dukkhani parijanati samudayam pajahati nirodham sacchikaroti maggam bhavetiti ? I. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 131 Amanta. Anagatam nanam atthi, tena iianena dukkhani parija- nati saiuudayam pajahati nirodham sacchikaroti maggam bhavetlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 38. Atltam nanam atthi, na ca tena iianena nanakara- nlyam karotiti ? Amanta. Paccuppannam nanam atthi, na ca tena fianena riana- karanlyain karotiti "? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Atitam rianam atthi, na ca tena iianena dukkliam pari- janati samudayam pajahati nirodham sacchikaroti maggam bhavetlti '? Amanta. Paccuppannam iianam atthi, na ca tena fianena dnk- khain parijanati samudayam pajahati nirodham sacchika- roti maggam bhavetlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 34. Anagatam nanam atthi, na ca tena fianena iianaka- raniyam karotiti '? Amanta. Paccuppannam iianam atthi, na ca tena hanena iianaka- ranlyam karotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatam fianam atthi, na ca tena iianena dukkham parijanati samudayam pajahati nirodham sacchikaroti maggam bhavetlti ? Amanta. Paccuppannam iianam atthi, na ca tena fianena duk- khain parijanati samudayam pajahati nirodham sacchika- roti maggam bhavetlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe- — pe — ^35.) Arahato atlto rago atthiti ? Amanta. Araha tena ragena sarago ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahato atlto doso atthiti ? 13'2 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 6. Amanta. Araha tena dosena sadoso ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahata atito moho atthiti '? Amanta. Araha tena niohena samoho ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahato atito mano atthiti '? Amanta. Araha tena manena samano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahato atita ditthi atthiti ? Amanta. Araha taya ditthiya saditthiko ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Arahato atita vicikiccha atthiti ? Amanta. Araha taya vicikicchaya savicchikiccha ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Arahato atitam thinain atthiti ? Amanta. Araha tena thinena sathino ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahato atitam nddliaccam atthiti ? Amanta. Araha tena uddhaccena sa-uddhaccako ^ ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahato atitam ahirikani atthiti ? Am ant a . "" ^ Araha tena ahirikena sa-ahiriko ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Arahato atitam anottappam atthiti ? Amanta. Araha tena anottappena sa-anottapi ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 36. Anagamissa atita sakkayaditthi atthiti ? I S. has Arahato tena uddhaccena uddhaccam hoti. J. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 133 Amanta. AnagamI taya ditthiya saditthiko ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Anagamissa atlta vicikiccha atthi, atlto sllabbatapara- maso atthi, atito anusahagato kamarago atthi, atito anusahagato byapado atthiti ? Amanta. Anaganii tena byapadena byapannacitto ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 37. Sakadagamissa atita sakkayaditthi atthiti"? Amanta. SakadagamI taya ditthiya saditthiko ti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sakadagamissa atita vicikiccha atthi, atito silabbatapa- ramaao-atthi, atito olariko kamarago atthi, atito olariko byapado atthiti ? Amanta. Sakadagami tena byapadena byapannacitto ti '? Na h'evaiu vattabbe — pe — 38. Sotapannassa atita sakkayaditthi atthiti ? Amanta. Sotapanno taya ditthiya saditthiko ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sotapannassa atita vicikiccha atthi, atito silabbatapa- ramaso atthi atito apayagamaniyo rago atthi, atito apaya- gamaniyo doso atthi, atito apayagamaniyo moho atthiti ? Amanta. Sotapanno tena mohena samoho ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 39. Puthujjanassa atito rago atthi, puthujjano tena ragena sarago ti ? Amanta. Arahato atito rago atthi Araha tena ragena sarago ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Puthujjanassa atito doso atthi — pe — atitam anottappam atthi, puthujjano tena anottappena anottapi ti ? Amanta. Arahato atitain anottappam atthi, Araha tena anot- tappena anottapi ti ? 134 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 6. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 40. Puthujjanassa atlta sakkayaditthi atthi, puthujjano taya ditthiya saditthiko ti ? Amanta. Anagamissa atlta sakkayaditthi atthi, anagami taya ditthiya saditthiko ti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Puthujjanassa atlta vicikiccha atthi — pe — atito anusa- hagato byapado atthi, puthujjano tena byapadena bya- pannacitto ti ? Amanta. Anagamissa atito anusahagato byapado atthi, anagami tena byapadena byapannacitto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 41. Puthujjanassa atlta sakkayaditthi atthi, puthujjano taya ditthiya saditthiko ti ? Amanta. Sakadagamissa atlta sakkayaditthi atthi, sakadagami taya ditthiya saditthiko ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — -pe — Puthujjanassa atlta vicikiccha atthi — pe — atito olariko byapado atthi, puthujjano tena byapadena byapannacitto ti? Amanta. Sakadagamissa atito olariko byapado atthi, sakadagami tena byapadena byapannacitto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe- — pe — 42. Puthujjanassa atita sakkayaditthi atthi, puthujjano taya ditthiya saditthiko ti ? Amanta. Sotapannassa atita sakkayaditthi atthi, sotapanno taya ditthiya saditthiko ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Puthujjanassa atita vicikiccha atthi — pe — atito apaya- gamaniyo moho atthi, puthujjano tena mohena samoho ti? Amanta. Sotapannassa atito apayagamaniyo moho atthi, sota- panno tena mohena samoho ti ? I. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 135 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 43. Arahato atito rago atthi, na ca Araha tena ragena sarago ti "? Amanta. Puthujjaiiassa atito rago atthi, na ca puthujjano tena ragena sarago ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahato atito doso atthi — pe — atitam anottappam atthi, na ca Araha tena anottappena anottapi ti ? Amanta. Puthujjanassa atitam anottappam atthi, na ca puthuj- jano tena anottappena anottapi ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 44. Anagamissa atita sakkayaditthi atthi, na ca anagami taya ditthiya saditthiko ti ? Amanta. Puthujjanassa atita sakkayaditthi atthi, na ca puthujjano taya ditthiya saditthiko ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagamissa atita vicikiccha atthi — pe — atito anusaha- gato byapado atthi, na ca anagami tena byapadena bya- pannacitto ti ? Amanta. Puthujjanassa atito anusahagato byapado atthi, na ca puthujjano tena byapadena byapannacitto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 45. Sakadagamissa atita sakkayaditthi atthi, na ca saka- dagami taya ditthiya saditthiko ti ? Amanta. Puthujjanassk atita sakkayaditthi atthi, na ca puthujjano taya ditthiya saditthiko ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sakadagamissa atita vicikiccha atthi — pe — atito olariko byapado atthi, na ca sakadagami tena byapadena bya- pannacitto ti ? Amanta. Puthujjanassa atito olariko byapado atthi, na ca puthuj- jano tena byapadena byapannacitto ti ? 136 KATHAVATTHU. [1. 6. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 46. Sotapannassa atlta sakkayaditthi atthi, na ca sota- panno taya ditthiya saditthiko ti ? Amanta. Puthujjanassa atlta sakkayaditthi atthi, na caputhujjano taya ditthiya saditthiko ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sotapannassa atlta vicikiccha atthi — pe — atlto apayaga- manlyo moho atthi, na ca sotapanno tena niohena sanioho ti? Amanta. Puthujjanassa atlto apayagamamyo moho atthi, na ca puthujjano tena mohena samoho ti ? ^Nja h'evam vattabbe — pe — (47y Atlta hattha atthiti ? ' Amanta. Atltesu hatthesu sati adananikkhepanam ^ pahhayatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atlta pada atthiti ? Amanta. Atitesu padesu sati abhikkamapatikkamo paniiayatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atlta pabba atthiti ? Amanta. Atitesu pabbesu sati samihjanapasaranam panhayatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Atito kucchi atthiti '? Amanta. Atitasmim kucchismim sati jighacchapipasa pahhayatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 48. Atito kayo atthiti ? Amanta. Atito kayo paggahaniggahupago ^ chedanabhedaniipago kakehi gijjhehi kulalehi sadharano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 1 adinam P. and S. ; nikkhamanam (P. only). 2 pagganha°, P. I. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 137 Atlte kaye visam kameyya, sattham kameyya, aggi kameyyati ? Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — - ... 7/? Labbha atlto kayo aniibandhanena ^ bandhitum rajju- -- ''^ bandhanena bandhitum samkhalikabandhanena bandhitmu - • •■-' gamabandhanena bandhitum nigamabandhanena bandhi- tum nagarabandhanena bandhitum janapadabandhanena bandhitum kanthapancamehi ^ bandanehi bandhitun ti '? ,] Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 49. Atlto apo atthlti? Amanta. Tena apena apakaranlyam karotiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atito tejo atthiti ? Amanta. Tena tejena tejakaranlyam karotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atlto vayo atthiti ? Amanta. Tena vayena vayakaranlyam karotiti '? Na h'evain vattabbe— pe — 50. Atlto rupakkhando atthi, anagato rupakkhando atthi, paccuppanno rupakkhando atthiti"? Amanta. Tayo rupakkhanda ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atlta pancakkhanda atthi, anagata paiicakkhanda atthi, paccuppanna pancakkhanda atthiti '? Amanta. Pannarasakkhanda ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 51. Atitam cakkhayatanain atthi, anagatain cakkhaya- tanam atthi, paccuppannam cakkhayatanain atthiti ? Amanta. Tini cakkhayatananiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— ^ addubandho, M. K. ^ kanda, M. ; kanha, P.S. 138 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 6. Atltani dvjidas'ayatanani atthi, anagatani dvadas'aya- tanani atthi, paccuppannani dvadas'ayatanani atthiti? Amanta. Chattims'ayatananiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — -pe — 52. Atlta cakkhudhatu atthi, anagata cakkhndhatu atthi, paccuppanna cakkhudhatu atthiti? Amanta. Tisso cakkhudhatuyo ti ? ^ Na h'avain vattabbe — pe — Atlta attharasa dhatuyo atthi, anagata attharasa dhatuyo atthi, paccuppanna attharasa dhatuyo atthiti? Amanta. Catupahhasa dhatuyo ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe— 53. Atltani cakkhundriyam atthi, anagatam cakkhun- driyain atthi, paccuppannaiii cakkhundriyam atthiti? Amanta. Tini cakkhundriyanlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atltani bavlsat' indriyani atthi, anagatani bavlsat' indriyani atthi, paccuppannani bavlsat' indriyani atthiti? Amanta. Chasatth' indriyaniti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — C-. " r54/ Atlto raja cakkavatti atthi, anagato raja cakkavatti atthi, paccuppanno raja cakkavatti atthiti ? Amanta. Tinnannam raianam cakkavattlnam sammukhlbhavo hotiti? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Atlto Sammasambuddho atthi, anagato Sammasam- buddho atthi, paccuppanno Sammasambuddho atthiti ? Amanta. Tinnannam Sammasainbuddhanam sammukkhlbhavo hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 55. Atltam atthiti ? I. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 139 Amanta. Atthi atltan ti ? Atthi siya atltam siya nvatltan ti. Ajaiiahiniggaham — hanci atitaiii atthi, atthi siya atltam siya nvatltam, tenatitam nvatltam nvatltani atitan ti. Yam tattha vadesi, " Vattabbe kho — Atltani atthi, atthi siya atltam siya nvatltan ti, tenatitam nvatltain nvatltam atltan ti," miccha. No ce pana atltam nvatltam nvatltam atltan ti,'''no vata re vattabbe "Atltam atthi, atthi siya atltam siya nvatltan ti." Yam tattha vadesi, "Vattabbe kho — Atltam atthi, atthi siya atltam siya nvatltam, tena- titam nvatltam nvatltam atitan ti," miccha. 56. Anagatam atthiti ? Amanta. Atthi anagatan ti ? Atthi siya anagatam siya nvanagatan ti. Ajanahi niggaham — haiici anagatam atthi, atthi siya anagatain siya nvanagatam, ten anagatam nvanagatam nvanagatam anagatan ti. Yam tattha vadesi, "Vattabbe kho — Anagatam atthi, atthi siya anagatam siya nvanagatan ti, tenanagatam nvanagatani nvanagatam anagatan ti," miccha. No ce pana anagatam nvanagatam nvanagatam anagatan ti, no vata re vattabbe "Anagatam atthi, atthi siya anagatam siya nvanagatan ti." Yam tattha vadesi, "Vattabbe kho — Anagatam atthi, atthi siya anagatam siya nvanagatam, tenanagatam nvanagatain nvanagatam anagatan ti," miccha. 57. Paccuppannam atthiti ? Amanta. Atthi paccnppannan ti '? Atthi siya paccuppannam siya no paccnppannan ti. ^ Ajanahi niggaham — hanci paccuppannam atthi, atthi siya paccuppannain siya no paccuppannain, tena paccup- pannam no paccuppannaiu no paccuppannain paccnppan- nan ti. Yaiii tattha vadesi, "Vattabbe kho — Paccuppan- nam atthi, atthi siya paccuppannani siya no paccuppannan ti, tena paccuppannain no paccuppannam no paccuppan- nam paccuppannan ti," miccha. No ce pana paccuppan- 140 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 6. nain no paccuppannani no paccuppannain paccuppannan ti, no vata re vattabbe " Paccuppannani atthi, atthi siya paccuppannain siy a no paccuppannan ti . " Yam tattlia vadesi, "Vattabbe kho— Paccuppannain atthi, atthi siya paccuppannain siya no paccuppannam, tena paccuppannani no paccuppannam no paccuppannam paccuppannan ti," miccha. 58. Nibbanam atthiti ? Anianta. Atthi atltaii ti '? Atthi siya nibbanam siya no niljbanan ti. Ajanahi niggaham — haiici nibbanam atthi, atthi siya nibbanain siya no nibbanam, tena nibbanam no nibbaiiain no nibbanam nibbanan ti. Yam tattha vadesi, " Vattabbe kho — Nibbanam atthi, atthi siya nibbanain siya no nib- banan ti, tena nibbanam no nibbanam no nibbanain nib- banan ti," miccha. No ce pana nibbanam no nibbanam no nibljanam nibbanan ti, no vata re vattabbe " Nib- banam atthi, atthi siya nibbanam siya no nibbanan ti." Yam tattha vadesi, " Vattabbe kho — Nibbanam atthi, atthi siya nibbanam sij^a no nibbanan ti, tena nibbanam no nibbanam no nibbanam nibbanan ti," miccha.' 59. Na vattabbam " Atitain atthi anagatani atthiti? " Anianta. Nanu vuttani Bhagavafa — "Yam kiiici Bhikkhave rdpain atltanagatapaccuppannam ajjhattam va bahiddha va olarikam va sukhumam va hinani va panltam va yam dure santike va, ayain vuccati rupakkhandho, ya kaci vedana, ya kaci saiiha, ye keci samkhara, yain kiiici viiiiia- nain atltanagatapaccuppannam ajjhattam va bahiddha va olarikam va sukhumam va hinaiii va panitain va yain dure santike va, ayam vuccati vihhanakkhandho ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti"? >-/ Anianta. Tena hi atitain atthi anagatani atthiti. 60. Atltam atthi anagatani atthiti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Tayo'me Bhikkhave nirut- J I. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 141 tipatha adhivacanapatha paiinattipatha asamkinna asam- kinnapubba na samkiyanti na sainklyissanti appatikuttha ^ e^ samanehi brahnianehi viiinuhi. Katanie tayo ? Yam / Bhikkhave rupain atltain niruddham vigatam viparinatam, ahositi tassa saiiklia, ahositi tassa samaniia, ahositi tassa pannatti, na tassa sankha atthiti na tassa saiikha bhavissa- tlti, ya vedana — pe, ya saniia — pe — ye samkhara — pe — yam vinnanam atltain niruddham vigatam viparinatam, ahositi tassa sankha, ahositi tassa samaniia, ahositi tassa pannatti, na tassa sankha atthiti na tassa sankha ahositi. *^ Yam Bhikkhave riipam ajatam apatHbhiitain, bhavissatiti tassa sankha, bhavissatiti tassa samahha, bhavissatiti tassa paiinatti, na tassa sankha atthiti na tassa saiikha ahositi, ya vedana — pe — ya saiiha — ye samkhara — pe — yam vihiianam ajatam apatubhUtam, bhavissatiti tassa saiikha, bhavissatiti tassa samahha, bhavissatiti tassa pan- natti, na tassa saiikha atthiti na tassa saiikha ahositi. Yam Bhikkhave rupam jatam patubhiitam, atthiti tassa sankha, atthiti tassa samahha, atthiti tassa pannatti, na tassa saiikha ahositi na tassa saiikha bhavissatiti, ya vedana — pe — ya sahha — pe — ye samkhara — pe — yain vih- haiiam jatam patubhiitam, atthiti tassa saiikha, atthiti tassa samahha, atthiti tassa pannatti, na tassa saiikha ahositi na tassa saiikha bhavissatiti. '" line kho Bhikkhave tayo niruttipatha adhivacanapatha pahhattipatha asamkinna asanikinnapubba na samkiyanti na sainklyissanti appati- kuttha samanehi brahnianehi vihhiihi. Ye pi te Bhik- • • • • X. kliave ahesum u kkalavass abhahha ^ ahetukavada akiriya- ^^ j vada n'atthikavada te pi me tayo niruttipathe adhivaca- napathepahiiattipathenagarahitabbamnapatikkositabbam amahhimsu. Tam kissa hetu ? Nindabyarosana-uparam- bhabhaya3 ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Atltain atthi anagatam atthiti." 1 appatikuto, P. 2 ukkana°, P ; ukkanavassabhahha, S.S2. 3 unarabblia°, M. . i ,i 142 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 6. 61. Atltam atthlti? Amanta. Nann a3'asnia Phagguno ^ Bhagavantam etad avoca ; " Atthi nil kho tarn bhante cakkhuin yena cakkhuna atlte Buddhe parinibbnte chinnapapaiice chinnavatmiie ^ pariyadinnavatte sabbadukkhavltivatte pafinapayamano paiinapeyyati, atthi nu kho sa bhante jivha — pe — atthi nil kho so bhante mano yena manena atlte Buddhe parinibbnte chinnapapaiice chinnavatume pariyadinna- vatte sabbadukkhavltivatte pahhapayainano pahhapey- yati '? ' ' "N'atthi kho tam Phagguna cakkhiim yena cakkhuna atlte Buddhe parinibbnte chinnapapaiice chinnavatume pariyadinnavatte sabbadukkhavltivatte pahhapayamano paiinapeyyati, n'atthi kho sa Phagguna jivha — pe — n'atthi kho so Phagguna mano yena manena atlte Buddhe pari- nibbnte chinnapapahce chinnavatume pariyadinnavatte sabbadukkhavltivatte pahiiapayamano paiiiiapeyyati." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbain " Atitam atthlti." 62. Atitam atthlti? Amanta. Nanu ayasma Nandako etad avoca " Ahu pubbe lobho tad ahu akusalam so etarahi n'atthi icc'etam kusalam, ahu pubbe doso, ahu pubbe moho tad ahu akusalam so etaralii n'atthi icc'etaiii kusalanti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbain " Atitain atthlti." 63. Na vattabbain " Anagatani atthlti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Kabahmkare 3 ce Bhikkhave ahare atthi rago atthi nandi atthi tanha, i3atitthitain tattha viiiiianam virulham, yattha patitthitam vihhanam virul- harn, atthi tattha namarupassa avakkanti, yattha atthi ^ Anafio, S. ^ vathume, P. ; vattame, S. 3 Kabahkao, M. nr I. 7.] KATHAVATTHU. 143 naniarupassa avakkanti atthi tattha samkharanam buddhi, y, yattha atthi samkharanam buddhi atthi tattha ayatim punabbhavabhinibbatti, yattha atthi ayatiiii punabbhava- bhinibbatti atthi tattha ayatim jatijaramaranam, yattha atthi ayatim jatijaramaranam sasokan ti Bhikkhavesarajam sa-upayasan ti vadami, phasse ce Bhikkhave ahare, mano- sahcetanaya ce Bhikkhave ahare, viniiane ce Bhikkhave ahare atthi rago atthi nandi — pe — sarajain sa-upayasan ti vadamlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? v* y' Amanta. "^ Tena hi na vattabbam " Anagfatam atthlti." ^i~,^ 64. Anagatam atthlti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttani Bhagavata — " Kabahmkare ce Bhikkhave ahare n'atthi rago n'atthi nandi n'atthi tanha appatitthi- tam tattha vihhanam avirulham, yattha appatitthitam vifinanam avirulham n'atthi tattha naniarupassa avakkanti, yattha n'atthi naniarupassa avakkanti n'atthi tattha sam- kharanam buddhi, yattha n'atthi samkharanam buddhi \j n'atthi tattha ayatim punabbhavabhinibbatti, j-attha n'atthi ayatim punabbhavabhinibbatti n'atthi tattha ayatim jatijaramaranam, yattha n'atthi ayatim jatija- ramaranam asokanti Bhikkhave arajaiu anupayasan ti vadami, phasse ce Bhikkhave ''ahare, manosahcetanaya ce Bhikkhave ahare, vihhane ce Bhikkhave ahare n'atthi rago n'atthi nandi — pe — arajam anupayasan ti vadamlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Anagatam atthlti." Sabbamatthitikatha. I. 7. 1 . Atltam khandha ti ? Amanta. Atltam atthlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 144 KATHAVATTHU. [1. 7. Atltam ayatanan ti ? Amaiita. Atltam atthiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Atltam dhatuti? Amanta. Atltam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atltam khandhadhatuayatanan ti ? Amanta. Atitain atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Anagatam khandha ti ? Amanta. Anagatam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatam ayatanan ti ? Amanta. Anagatam atthiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatam dhatuti ? Amanta. Anagatam atthiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatam khandhadhatuayatanan ti ? Amanta. Anagatam atthiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 3. Paccuppannam khandha paccuppannam atthiti ? Amanta. Atltain khandha atltam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paccuppannam ayatanam paccuppannam atthiti ? Amanta. Atltam ayatanam atltam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paccuppannam dhatu paccuppannam atthiti ? Amanta. I. 7.] KATHAVATTHU. 145 Atltam clhatu atltam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paccuppannam khandhadhatuayatanam paccuppan- nam atthiti ? Amanta. Atltam khandhadhatuayatanam atitam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Paccuppannam khandha paccuppannam atthiti ? Amanta. Anagatam khandha anagatam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Paccuppannam ayatanam paccuppannam atthiti ? Amanta. Anagatam ayatanam anagatam atthiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paccuppannam dhatu paccuppannam atthiti ? Amanta. Anagatam dhatu anagatam atthiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paccuppannam khandhadhatuayatanam paccuppannam atthiti ? Amanta. Anagatam khandhadhatuayatanaiii anagatain atthiti? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe^ — 5. Atltam khandha atltam n'atthiti? Amanta. Paccuppannam khandha paccuppannam n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atltam ayatanam atltam n'atthiti ? Amanta. Paccuppannam ayatanam paccuppannam n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atltam dhatu atltam n'atthiti ? Amanta. Paccuppannam dhatu paccuppannam n'atthiti ? Amanta. Atltam khandhadhatuayatanam atltam n'atthiti ? Amanta. 11 146 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 7. Paccuppannam khandhadhatuayatanam paccuppaiinam n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Anagatam khandha anagatam n'atthiti? Amanta. Paccuppannam khandha paccuppannam n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Anagatam ayatanam anagatam n'atthiti ? Amanta. Paccuppannam ayatanam paccuppannani n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Anagatam dhatu anagatain n'atthiti '? Amanta. Paccuppannam dhatu paccuppannam n'atthiti? Amanta. Anagatam khandhadhatuayatanam anagatam n'atthiti ? Amanta. Paccuppannam khandhadhatuayatanam paccuppannam n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Atitam rupam khandho ti ? Amanta. Atitam riipam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atitam riipam ayatanan ti ? Amanta. Atitam rupam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atitam rupain dhatiiti ? Amanta. Atitam riipam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atitain riipam khandhadhatuayatanan ti ? Amanta. Atitain riipani atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Anagatain rupain khandho ti ? Amanta. I. 7.] KATHAVATTHU. 147 Anagatam rupain atthiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatam rupam ayatanan ti '? Ainanta. Anagatam rupam atthiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatam rupam dhatuti ? Amanta. Anagatam rupam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatam rupam khandhadhatuayatanan ti '? Amanta. Anagatam rupam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 9. Paccuppannani rupain khandho, paccuppannam rupam atthiti ? Amanta. Atltam rupain khandho, atltam rupam atthiti "? Na h'evam vattabbe. Paccuppannam rupam ayatanam — pe — paccuppannani rupain dhatu — pe — paccuppannam rupam khandhadhatu- ayatanam, paccuppannam rupam atthiti '? Amanta. / Atltam rupain khandhadhatuayatanam, atltam ruparn atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 10. Paccuppannam rupam khandho, paccuppannam rupain atthiti ? Amanta. Anagatam riipain khandho, anagatam rupam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Paccuppannam rupam ayatanam — pe — paccuppannam rupam dhatu — pe — paccuppannam rupam khandhadhatu- ayatanam, paccuppannam rupain atthiti '? Amanta. Anagatam rupain khandhadhatuayatanam, anagatam rupam atthiti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — 1'18 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 7. 11. Atltam rtipam khandho, atltam rupam n'atthiti? Amanta. Paccuppannam rnpain khandho, paccuppannam rupam n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atitaiu rupam ayatanaiu — pe — atltam rupam dhatu — pe— atltarn rupam khandhadhatuayatanani, atitain rupam n'atthiti ? Amanta. Paccuppannam rupam khandhadhatuayatanani, paccup- pannam rupam n'atthiti'? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— 12. Anagatani rupam khandho, anagatain rupam n'atthiti ? Amanta. Paccuppannam rupam khandho, paccuppannam riipam n'atthiti '? Na li'evarn vattabbe — pe — Anagatam rupam ayatanam — pe — anagatam rupam dhatu — pe — anagatam rupam kliandhadhatuayatanam, anagatam rupam n'atthiti '? Amanta. Paccuppannam rupani khandhadhatuayatanani, paccup- pannam riipam n'atthiti"? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 13. Atita vedana, atita sahha, atita samkhara, atitam vihiianam khandho ti "? Amanta. Atitam vifiiianain atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atitam vihhanan ayatanam — pe — atitam vihiianam dhatu— pe — atitam vihhanaiii khandhadhatuayatanan ti ? Amanta. Atitain viiiiianaiii atthiti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 14. Anagata vedana, anagata saiiha, anagata samkhara, anagatam vihiianam khandho ti "? Amanta. I. 7.] KATHAVATTHU. 149 Anagatam viiinanam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatam viiinanam ayatanani — pe — anagatam viiiiia- nam dhatu — pe — anagatam viiinanam khandhadhatuayata- nan ti "? Amanta. Anagatam viiinanam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 15. Paccuppannam vifnianam khandho paccuppannam vihhanam atthiti ? Amanta. Atitam vihhanam khandho atltam vihhanani atthiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paccuppannain vihhanam ayatanam — pe — paccuppan- nam vihhanam dhatu — pe — paccuppannain vihhanam khandhadhatuayatanam paccuppannain vihhanaiu atthiti ? Amanta. Atltam vihhanam khandhadhatuayatanam atltani vih- hanam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 16. Paccuppannain vihhanam khandho, paccuppannam vihhanam atthiti ? * Amanta. Anagatam vihhanam khandho, anagatam vihhanam atthiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paccuppannam vihhanam ayatanam — pe — paccuppan- nam vihhanam dhatu — pe — paccuppannam vihhanam khandhadhatuayatanam, paccuppannain vihhanain atthiti? Amanta. Anagatam vihhanam kliandhadhatuayatanain, anagatam vihhanain atthiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 17. Atltam vihhanam khandho, atltam vihhanam n'at- thiti? Amanta. Paccuppannain vihhanam khandho, paccuppannam vihhanain n' atthiti ? 150 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 7. Na li'evain vattabbe — pe — Atltain viniianaiu ayatanam — pe — atitam viniianam dhatu — pe — atitam viiinanam khandhadhatuayatanam, atitam vinnanam n'atthiti ? Amanta. Paccuppannam vinnanam khandhadhatuayatanam, pac- cuppannam vinnanam n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 18. Anas^atam vinnanam khandho, anagatam viiihanam n'atthiti ? Amanta. Paccuppannam vinnanam khandho, paccuppannam viii- hanam n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatam vihiianam ayatanam — pe — anagatam vinna- nam dhatu — pe— anas^atam viiihanam khandhadhatua- yatanain, anagatam vinnanam n'atthiti ? Amanta. Paccuppannam viiihanam khandhadhatuayatanam, pac- cuppannam vihhanam n'atthiti? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — 19. Na vattabbam " Atltanagata khandhadhatuayata- nam n'atthi c'ete ti " '? Amanta. Nanu vuttain Bhagavata "Tayo'me Bhikkhave nirutti- patha adhivacanapatha pahhattipatha — pe — vihhuhlti. " Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Atltanagata khandhadhatua- yatanam n'atthi c'ete ti." 20. Atltanagata khandhadhatuayatanam n'atthi c'ete ti? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata— " Yam kihci Bhikkhave rupam atltanagatapaccuppannam ajjhattam va bahiddha va olarikam va sukhumam va hinam va panltam va yam dure santike va, ayam vuccati rupakkhandho, ya kaci vedana, ya kaci sahiia, ye keci samkhara, yam kihci vihhanain atltanagatapaccuppannam ajjhattam va I. 8.] KATHAVATTHU. 151 bahiddha va olarikam va sukhiimam va hinam va panT- tam va yam dure santike va, ayam vuccati vinnanak- khandho ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Atltanagata khandhadhatu- ayatanain ii'atthi c'ete ti." A 1 1 1 a m k h a n d li a t i k a t h a, I. 8. 1. A tit am atthiti? Ekaccam atthi ekaccam n'atthlti. Ekaccam niruddham ekaccam na niruddhain, ekac- cam vigatam ekaccam na vigatam, ekaccam atthanga- tam ekaccam na atthaiigatam, ekaccam abbhattliangatam ekaccam na abbhatthangatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Atitam ekaccam atthi ekaccam n'atthlti ? Amanta. Atita avipakkavipaka dhamma ekacce atthi ekacce n'atthlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atitam ekaccam atthi ekaccain n'atthlti ? Amanta. Atlta vipakkavipaka dhamma ekacce atthi ekacce n'atthlti? Na h'evam vattabbe^pe — Atitam ekaccam atthi ekaccam n'atthlti ? Amanta. Atlta avipaka dhannna ekacce atthi ekacce n'atthlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — ^pe — 3. Atltani ekaccam atthi ekaccam n'atthlti ? Amanta. Kim atthi kini n'atthlti ? Atlta avipakkavipaka dhamma te atthi, atlta vipakkavi- paka dhamma te n' atthiti. Atlta avipakkavipaka dhamma te atthiti ? 152 KATHAVATTHA. [I. 8. Amanta. Atlta vipakkavipaka dhamma te atthlti ? Na li'evam vattabbe. Atita avipakkavipaka dhamma te atthlti '? Amanta. Atlta avipaka dhamma te atthlti '? Na h'evain vattabbe. Atlta vipakkavipaka dhamma te n' atthlti ? Amanta. Atlta avipakkavipaka dhamma te n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atlta vipakkavipaka dhamma te n'atthiti ? Amanta. Atita avipaka dhamma te n'atthiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe. , Atita avipakkavipaka dhamma te atthiti '? Amanta. Nann atita avipakkavipaka dhamma niruddha ti '? Amanta. Hanoi atita avipakkavipaka dhamma niruddha, no vata re vattabbe "Atita avipakkavipaka dhamma te atthiti." 4. Atita avipakkavipaka dhamma niruddha te atthiti ? Amanta. Atita vipakkavipaka dhamma niruddha te atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atita avipakkavipaka dhamma niruddha te atthiti '? Amanta. Atita avipaka dhamma niruddha te atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atita vipakkavipaka dhamma niruddha te n'atthiti ? Amanta. Atita avipakkavipaka dhamma niruddha te n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atita vipakkavipaka dhamma niruddha te n'atthiti ? Amanta. Atita avipaka dhamma niruddha te n'atthiti? Na h'evam vattabbe. Atita avipakkavipaka dhamma niruddha te atthiti ? I. 8.] KATHAVATTHU. 153 Amanta. Atlta vipakkavipaka clhamma nirudclha te n'atthlti ? Amanta. Atlta ekadesam vipakkavipaka dhamma ekadesam a vipakkavipaka dhamma niruddha te ekacce atthi ekacce n'atthlti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — -pe — 5. Na vattabbam "Atlta avipakkavipaka dhamma te atthiti " •? Amanta. Nanu atlta avipakkavipaka dhamma vipaccissantiti ? Amanta. Hahci atlta avipakkavipaka dhamma vipaccissanti, tena vata re vattabbe " Atlta avipakkavipaka dhamma te atthiti." Atita avipakkavipaka dhamma vipaccissantiti katva te atthiti ■? • Amanta. Vipaccissantiti katva paccuppanna ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vipaccissantiti katva paccuppanna ti ? Amanta. Paccuppanna dhamma nirujjhissantlti katva te n'atthlti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Anagatam atthiti ? Ekaccam atthi ekaccam n'atthlti. Ekaccam jatam ekaccam ajatam, ekaccam sahjatam ekaccam asahjatain, ekaccam nibbattam ekaccam anib- battam, ekaccam patubhutain ekaccam apatubhutan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatam ekaccam atthi ekaccam n'atthlti ? Amanta. « Anagata uppadino dhamma ekacce atthi ekacce n'atthlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatam ekaccam atthi ekaccam n'atthlti ? Amanta. Anagata anuppadino dhamma ekacce atthi ekacce n'atthlti ? 154 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 8. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Anagatam ekaccam atthi ekaccam n'atthiti? _ O • • • Ainanta. Kim atthi kini n'atthiti ? Anagata uppadino dhainma te atthi, anagata anuppadino dhanima te n'atthiti. Anagata uppadino dhamma te atthiti ? Am ant a. Anagata anuppadino dhamma te atthiti V Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Anagata anuppadino dhamma te n'atthiti ? Amanta. Anagata uppadino dhamma te n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. Anagata uppadino dhamma te atthiti "? Amanta. Nanu anagata uppadino dhamma ajata ti ? Amanta. Haiici anagata uppadino dhainma ajata, no vata re vattabbe " Anagata uppadino dhamma te atthiti." 8. Anagata uppadino dhannna ajata te atthiti ? Amanta. Anagata anuppadino dhamma ajata te atthiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Anagata anuppadino dhainma ajata te n'atthiti ? Amanta. Anagata uppadino dhamma ajata te n'atthiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 9. Na vattabbam "Anagata uppadino dhamma te atthiti"? Amanta. Nanu anagata uppadino dhamma uppajjissantlti ? Amanta. Hanoi anagata uppadino dhamma uppajjissanti, tena vata re vattabbe " Anagata uppadino dhamma te atthiti." 10. Anagata uppadino dhamma uppajjissantlti katva te atthiti ? Amanta. I. 9.] KATHAVATTHU. 155 Uppajjissantiti katva paccuppanna ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Uppajjissantiti katva paccuppanna ti ? Amanta. Paccuppanna dhamma nirujjhissantiti katva te n'atthiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ekaccani atthltikatha. I. 9. 1. Sabbe dhamma satipatthana ^ ti '> Amanta. Sabbe dhamma sati satindriyam satibalam sammasati satibojjhaiigo, ekayanamaggo khayagami l^odhagami apacayagami, anasava asahiiojaniya aganthanlya ano- ghanlya ayoganlya amvaranlya aparamattha anuppadaniya asamkilesika," sabbe dhamma buddhanussati dhamma- nussati samghanussati silanussati caganussati devata- nussati anapanasati - marananussati kayagatasati 3 upasamanussatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe. 2. Sabbe dhamma satipatthana ti ? Amanta. Cakkhayatanam satipatthanan ti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — • Cakkhayatanam satipatthanan ti ? Amanta. Cakkhayatanam sati satindriyam satibalam sammasati satibojjhaiigo ekayanamaggo khayagami bodhagainl apacayagami, anasavam asafiiiojanlyam aganthanlyam anoghanlyam ayoganlyam anlvaranlyain aparamatthain anupadaniyain asamkilesikam, cakkhayatanam buddha- nussati dhammanussati samghanussati silanussati caganussati devatanussati anapanasati marananussati kayagatasati upasamanussatiti "? I opathana, M. always. ^ anapananussati, P. and S. 3 kayagatanussati, P. and S. 156 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 9. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Sotayatanam ghanayatanam jivhayatanain kayaya- tanam rupayatanam saddayatanain gandhayatanam rasayatanam photthabbayatanam, rago doso moho mano ditthi vicikiccha thinam uddhaccain ahirikam anottappam satipatthanan ti *? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Anottappain satipatthanan ti ? Amanta. Anottappain sati satindriyam satibalam sammasati satibojjhango ekayanamaggo khayaganii bodhagaml apacayagami anasavam asannojanlyam aganthaniyam anoghaniyam ayoganlyain amvaraniyam aparaniattham anupadaniyani asamkilesikam, anottappain buddhanussati dhamniannssati samghanussati sllanussati caganussati devatanussati anapanasati marananussati kayagatasati npasamanussatlti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 4. Sati satipatthana sa ca satiti ? ' Amanta. Cakkhayatanam satipatthanam tan ca satiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Sati satipatthana sa ca satiti ? Ainanta. Sotayatanam ghanayatanam jivhayatanam kayayatanam riipayatanain saddayatanain gandhayatanam rasayatanam photthabbayatanam, rago doso moho mano ditthi vicikiccha thlnain uddhaccain ahirikam anottappain satipatthanani tan ca satiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Cakkhayatanam satipatthanam tan ca na satiti ? Ainanta. Sati satipatthana sa ca na satiti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sotayatanam ghanayatanain — pe — anottappam sati- patthanani tan ca na satiti ? ' P.S., Sa omit sec. 4. I. 9.] KATHAVATTHU. 157 Amanta. Sati satipatthana sa ca na satiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Na vattabbam " Sabbe dhamma satipatthana ti? " Amanta. Nanu sabbe dhamme arabbha sati santitthatiti '? Amanta. Haiici sabbe dhamme arabbha sati santitthati,^ tena vata re vattabbe " Sabbe dhamma satipatthana ti." Sabbam dhammain arabbha sati santitthatiti, sabbe dhamma satipatthana ti ? Amanta. Sabbam dhammam arabbha phasso santitthatiti, sabbe dhamma phassapatthana ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sabbam dhammain arabbha sati santitthatiti, sabbe dhamma satipatthana ti '? Amanta. Sabbani dhammam arabbha vedana santitthati, sahha santitthati, cetana santitthati, cittam santitthatiti, sabbe dhamma cittapatthaiia ti ? Na h'evam vattabl)e — pe — • 6. Sabbe dhamma satipatthana ti ? Amanta. Sabbe satta upatthitasatino satiya samannagata satiya samohita sabbesam sattanain sati pacciipatthita ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sabbe dhamma satipatthana ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata ' ' Amatan te Bhikkhave na paribhimjanti ye kayagatam satim na paribhm~ijanti, amatan te Bhikkhave paribhuhjanti ye kayagatam satiiii paribhuhjantiti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Sabbe satta kayagatam satim paribhufijanti patilabhanti asevanti bhaventi bahuhkarontiti ? santitthatiti, M. 158 KATHAVATTHU. I. 9.] Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Sabbe dhamma satipatthana ti? Aiuauta. Nanii viittaip Bhagavata — " Ekayano ayam Bbikkbave maggo sattanam visuddhiya sokaparidevanam samatik- kamaya diikkbadomanassanam atthangamaya nayassa adhigamaya nibbanassa sacchikiriyaya yadidam cattaro satipatthana ti." i\.tth'eva suttanto ti? Ainanta. Sabbe dhaiuma ekayanamaggo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— 8. Sabbe dhamma satipatthana ti '? Amanta. Nanii vuttam Bhagavata " Rahho Bhikkhave Cakka- vattissa patubhava ^ sattannam ratananam patubhavo hoti. Katamesam sattannam? Cakkaratanassa patubhavo hoti, hatthiratanassa patubhavo hoti, assaratanassa, maniratanassa, itthiratanassa, gahapatiratanassa, pari- nayakaratanassa patubhavo hoti, rahho Bhikkhave Cakkavattissa patubhava imesam sattannam ratananam patubhavo hoti. Tathagatassa Bhikkhave patubhava Arahato Sammasambuddhassa sattannam bojjhahgara- tananam patubhavo hoti. Katamesam sattannam? Satisambojjhahgaratanassa patubhavo hoti, dhamma- vicayasambojjhangaratanassa patubhavo hoti, viriya- sambojjhangaratanassa patubhavo hoti, pltisamboj- jhangaratanassa patubhavo hoti, passaddhisamboj- jhahgaratanassa patubhavo hoti, samadhisambojjhaii- garatanassa patubhavo hoti, upekkhasambojjhahgarata- nassa patubhavo hoti, Tathagatassa Bhikkhave Arahato Sammasambuddhassa imesam sattannam bojjhahgarata- nanam patubhavo hotlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tathagatassa patubhava sammasambuddhassa sabbe dhamma satisambojjhangaratana va hontiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — I bhavaya (but va afterwards) P. [I. 10. KATHAVATTHU. 159 9. Sabbe dhamma satipatthana ti? Amanta. Sabbe dhaiunia sammappadhana, iddhipada, indriya, bala, bojjhaiiga ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — S a t i p a 1 1 h a n a k a th a. I. 10. 1. Atltam atthiti ? H'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthlti. S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti ? Amanta. Atthattho n'atthattho n'atthattho atthattho, atthibhavo n'atthibhavo n' atthibhavo atthibhavo, atthiti va n'atthiti va n'atthiti va atthiti va, esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Anagatam atthiti '? H'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthiti. S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti ? Amanta. Atthattho n'atthattho n'atthattho atthattho, atthibhavo n'atthibhavo n'atthibhavo atthibhavo, atthiti va n'atthiti va n'atthiti va atthiti va, esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate ti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Paccuppannam atthiti ? H'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthiti. S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — ^pe — S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti ? 160 KATHAVATTHU. I. 10.] Amanta. Atthattho n'atthattho n'atthattho atthattho, atthibhavo n'atthibhavo n'atthibhavo atthibhavo, atthiti va n'atthiti va n'atthiti va atthiti va, esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate ti? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — 4. Atltam h'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthiti ? Amanta. Kint'atthi kinti n'atthiti ? Atltam atltan ti h'ev'atthi, atltain anagatan ti h'eva n'atthi, atltam paccuppannan ti h'eva n'atthiti. S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti ? Amanta. Atthattho n'atthattho n'atthattho atthattho, atthibhavo n'atthibhavo n'atthibhavo atthibhavo, atthiti va n'atthiti va n'atthiti va atthiti va, esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate ti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Anagatam h'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthiti? Amanta. Kint'atthi kinti n'atthiti ? Anagatam anagatan ti h'ev'atthi, anagatam atltan ti h'eva n'atthi, anagatam paccuppannan ti h'eva n'atthiti. S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti ? Amanta. Atthattho n'atthattho n'atthattho atthattho, atthibhavo n'atthibhavo n'atthibhavo atthibhavo, atthiti va n'atthiti va n'atthiti va atthiti va, esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Paccuppannan! h'ev' atthi h'eva n'atthiti ? Amanta. Kint'atthi kinti n'atthiti ? Paccuppannam paccuppannan ti h'ev'atthi, paccuppan- I. 10.] KATHAVATTHU. 161 nam atltan ti h'eva n'atthi, paccuppannam anagatan ti h'eva n'atthiti. S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti '? Anianta. Atthattho n'atthattho n'atthattho atthattho, atthibhavo n'atthibhavo n'atthibhavo atthibhavo, atthiti va n'atthiti va n'atthiti va atthiti va, esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Na vattabbam " Atltam h'ev' ^ atthi h'eva n'atthi, anagatam h'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthi, paccuppannam h'ev' atthi h'eva n'atthiti " ? Amanta. Atltam anagatan ti h'ev'atthi, atltam paccuppannan ti h'ev'atthi, anagatam atltan ti h'ev'atthi, anagatam pac- cuppannan ti h'ev'atthi/paccuppannam atltan ti h'ev'atthi, paccuppannam anagatan ti h'ev' atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi atltam h'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthi, anagatam h'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthi, paccuppannam h'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthiti. 8. Rtipam atthiti ? H'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthiti. S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti ? Amanta. Atthattho n'atthattho n'atthattho atthattho, atthibhavo n'atthibhavo n'atthibhavo atthibhavo, atthiti va n'atthiti va n'atthiti va atthiti va, esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 9. Vedana, safina, samkhara, vihiianam atthiti '> H'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthiti. I So'va, P. 12 162 KATHAVATTHU. [I. 10. S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti? Ainanta. Atthattho n'atthattho n'atthattho atthattho, atthibhavo n'atthibhavo n'atthibhavo atthibhavo, atthiti va n'atthiti va n'atthiti va atthiti va, esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 10. Kupam h'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthiti? Amanta. Kint'atthi kinti n'atthiti ? Rupam rupan ti h'ev'atthi, rupam vedana ti h'eva n'atthi — pe — rupam saiina ti h'eva n'atthi — pe — rupam sarnkhara ti h'eva n'atthi, rupani vihiianan ti h'eva n'atthiti. S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti ? Amanta. Atthattho n'atthattho n'atthattho atthattho, atthibhavo n'atthibhavo n'atthibhavo atthibhavo, atthiti va n'atthiti va n'atthiti va atthiti va, esese ekatthe same samabhage tajjate ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 11. Vedana, sahha, sarnkhara, viiiiianam h'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthiti? Amanta. Kint'atthi kinti n'atthiti ? Vihiianam vihfianan ti h'ev'atthi, vihhanani rupan ti h'eva n'atthi — pe — viiirianam vedana ti h'eva n'atthi — pe — vihhanam saiiiia ti h'eva n'atthi — pe — vihhanam sarnkhara ti h'eva n'atthiti. S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — S'ev'atthi s'eva n'atthiti ? Amanta. Atthattho n'atthattho — pe — tajjate ti ? II. 1.] KATHAVATTHU. 163 Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — 12. Na vattabbam " Kupam h'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthlti, vedancl h'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthlti, saniia h'ev' atthi h'eva n'atthlti, sanikhara h'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthlti, viniianam h'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthlti '? " Amanta. Rupam vedana ti h'ev'atthi — pe — rupam sahna ti h'ev' atthi — pe — rupam samkhara ti h'ev' atthi — pe — rupam viiiiianan ti h'ev'atthi — pe — vedana, saiiha, samkhara, viiihanam rupan ti h'ev'atthi — pe — viniianam vedana ti h'ev'atthi — pe — viniianam saiiha ti h'ev'atthi — pe — vifiiiaiiam samkhara ti h'ev'atthiti "? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Tena hi riipam h'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthi, vedana h'ev' atthi h'eva n'atthi, saiiha h'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthi, sam- khara h'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthi, vihhanam h'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthlti. H'ev'atthikatha. T a s s a u d d a n a m Upalabbho, Parihanain, Brahmacariyavaso, dhiso , P a r i h h a k a m a r a g a p p a h a n a m , S a b b a 1 1 h i - vado, Ayatanam, Atltanagatesu bhago,^ Sabbe dhamma sati- patthana, H'ev'atthi h'eva n'atthlti. Mahavaggo. II. 1. 1. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisatthiti ? Amanta. I anagatesu rago, P.S2. 164 KATHAVATTHU. [II. 1. Atthi Arahato rago kamarago kamaragapariyntthanam kamaragasannojanam kamogho kamayogo kamacchan- danivaranan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N'atthi Arahato rago kamarago kamaragapariyutthanam kamaragasannojanain kamogho kamayogo kamacchan- danlvaranan ti ? Amanta. Hahci n'atthi Arahato rago kamarago kamaragapari- yutthanam kamaragasannojanam kamogho kamayogo kamacchandanivaranam, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi Arahato asucisnkkavisatthlti . ' ' 2. Atthi puthiijjanassa asucisukkavisatthi, atthi tassa rago kamarago kamaragapariyutthanam kamaragasaiiho- janam kamogho kamayogo kamacchandanivaranan ti ? Amanta. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisatthi, atthi tassa rago kamarago kamaragapariyutthanam — pe — kamacchandani- varanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisatthi, n'atthi tassa rago kamarago kamaragapariyutthanain — pe — kamacchandani- varanan ti ? Amanta. Atthi puthujjanassa asucisukkavisatthi, n'atthi tassa rago kamarago kamaragapariyutthanam — pe — kamacchan- danivaranan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisatthiti ? Amanta. Ken'atthenati ? ^ Handa hi Marakayika devata Arahato asucisukkavisatthim ^ upasamharantlti. Marakayika devata Arahato asucisukkavisatthim upa- samharantlti ? Amanta. Atthi Marakayikanam devatanam asucisukkavisatthiti ? I attho, P.Ss. 2 asucini, M. II. 1.] KATHAVATTHU. 165 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N'atthi Marakayikanam devatanam asiicisiikkavisatthi- ti? Amanta. Hanci n'atthi Marakayikanam devatanam asucisuk- kavisatthi, no vata re vattabbe " Marakayikanam devata- nam Arahato asucisukkavisattliiin upasamharantiti." 4. Marakayika devata Arahato asucisukkavisatthim upasamharantiti ? Amanta. Marakayika devata attano asucisukkavisatthim upa- samharanti, aiihesam asucisukkavisatthim upasamharanti, tassa asucisukkavisatthim upasamharantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Marakayika devata n'ev'attano na aMesam na tassa asucisukkavisatthim upasamharantiti ? Amanta. Hahci Marakayika devata n'ev' ^ attano na ahhesam na tassa asucisukkavisatthim upasamharanti, no vata re vattabbe " Marakayika devata Arahato asucisukkavisat- thim upasamharantiti . ' ' 5. Marakayika devata Arahato asucisukkavisatthim upasainharantiti "? Amanta. Lomakupehi upasainharantiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Marakayika devata Arahato asucisukkavisatthim upa- samharantiti ? Amanta. Kimkarana ti ? Handa hi vimatim gahayissamati.'^ Atthi Arahato vimatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi Arahato vimatiti ? Amanta. Atthi Arahato Satthari vimati, Dhamme vimati, Samghe vimati, sikkhaya vimati, pubbante vimati, aparante n'eva attano, P. ^ vimatigahissamati, r.S2. ll\6 K A lUAVATTIlU. [II. 1. Y imati . pubbant iipanmte viinati . idappneoayat ilpat icca- samupaunesu dhaminesu Yimatlti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — K'atthi Amhato Satthari vimati. Phanmio viinati, Sanigho vimati. sikkhaya viinati. pubbanto viinati, aparante vimati. pubbantaparante vimati. idappaocayatil- paticcasaiimppaimesu dbammesn vimatiti '? Amantii. Hanoi ii'atthi Arahato Satthari viinati — pe — idappacca- yatapaticcasamuppannesu dhammesu vimati, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi Arahato vimatiti." 6. Atthi pnthnjjanassa viinati. atthi tassa Satthari vimati — ^pe — idappaccayatapaticcasamnppaimesu dliam- mesu vimatiti ? Amanta. Atthi Arahato viinati. atthi tassa Satthari viinati — pe — idappaccayatapaticcasamuppaniiesu dhammesu vima- titi •? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Atthi Ai-ahato vimati, n"atthi tassa Satthari viinati — pe — idappaccayatapaticcasamuppannesn dhammesu ximatlti ? Amanta. Atthi puthujjanassa N'imati, n'atthi tassa Satthari vimati — pe — idappaccayatapaticcasamuppannesu dham- mesu vimatiti ? Ka h'evain vattabbe — pe — 7. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisattlilti ? Amanta. Arahato asncisukkavisatthi kissa nissando ti? Asita- pitakhayitasaptassa nissando ti. Ai-ahato asncisukkavisatthi asitapitakliayitasayitassa ^ nissando ti '? Amanta. Ye keci asanti. pivanti. khayanti, sayaiui, sabbesafi ueva atthi asucisnkkavisatthiti ? I asltapita°, P.S.S2. 11. 1.] KATHAVATTHC'. 167 Na h'evara vattabbe — ^pe — Ye keci asant:. r/'v-r*- khayanti, sayanti, -;abbfr-:an neva atthi asar,. Iti'? Amanta, Daraka asanti, pivanti, khayanti, sayanti, atthi d^ra- kanarrx asncisakka-. Na h'evain vattabbe — ^pe — Pandaka asanti, pivanti, khayanti, sayanti, atthi par.':>.- kanara asacisakkavLsatthTti '? Na hVrvarn vattabbe — ^pe — Dev> ri, pivanti, khayanti, sayanti, atthi dfevat&r • asudsu.'./.i . .-atthiti '? Na h'evarn v^.'^'^ -' ' ': — ^pe — ^' Arahato a- . .^a^isatthi asitapitakhavitasa^itassa )o ti ? Amanta. Atthi tassa asayo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — ^pe- Arahato nccarapassavo asitai>itakhayitasayitassa nis- gando, atthi tassa asayo ti'? Amanta. Arahato asucisnkkavisatthi asitanitakha'^itasavitassa nLssando, atthi tassa a-sayo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahato asncistikkavisatthi asitapitakhayitasayitassa nissando. n'atthi tassa asavo ti '? ^ uc'Carapassavo asitapitakhayitasaptassa nis- sando, n'atthi tassa asayo ti '? Na h'evam vattabb[iappaha- naya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhahga bhavita ti ? 176 KATHAVATTHU. [II. 2. Amanta. Haiici anottappappahanaya bojjhaiiga bhavita, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi Arahato annanan ti." 10. Atthi Arahato ahhanan ti '? Amanta. Nanu Araha vltarago vltadoso vltamoho — ])e — sacchi- katabbam sacchikatan ti? Amanta. Haiici Araha vltarago — pe — sacchikatabbam sacchika- tam, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi Arahato ahhanan ti." 11. Atthi Arahato ahhanan ti ? Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi ahhanam, paradhammakusalassa Arahato n'atthi ahhanan ti. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi ahhanan ti ? Amanta. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato atthi ahhanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paradhammakusalassa Arahato n'atthi ahhanan ti? Amanta. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato n'atthi ahhanan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 12. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rago pahhio, atthi tassa ahhanan ti ? Amanta. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rago pahlno, atthi tassa ahhanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pahlno, moho pahlno — pe — anottappam pahlnain, atthi tassa ahhanan ti ? Amanta. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappam pahmam, atthi tassa ahhanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 13. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato ragappahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhahga bhavita, atthi tassa ahhanan ti ? Amanta. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato ragappahanaya maggo bhavito — ])e — bojjhahga bhavita, atthi tassa ahhanan ti ? II. 2.] KATHAVATTHU. 177 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sadhammakusalassa xVrahato dosappahanaya — pe — anottappappahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhanga bha- vita, atthi tassa annanan ti ? Amanta. Paradhammakiisalassa Arahato anottappappahanaya bojjhanga bhavita, atthi tassa ahhanan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 14. Sadhammakusalo Araha vltarago vltadoso vltamoho — pe — sacchikatabbam sacchikatam, atthi tassa ahiianan ti? Amanta. Paradhammakusalo Araha vltarago — pe — sacchika- tabbam sacchikatam, atthi tassa ahhanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 15. Paradhammakiisalassa Arahato rago pahino, n'atthi tassa ahhanan ti ? Amanta. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rago pahmo, n'atthi tassa ahhanan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paradhammakiisalassa Arahato doso pahmo — pe — anottappam pahlnam, n'atthi tassa ahhanan ti? Amanta. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pahmo — pe — anot- tappam pahhiam, n'atthi tassa ahhanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 16. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato ragappahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — ^bojjhahga bhavita— pe — anottappa- ppahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhanga bhavita, n'atthi tassa ahhanan ti ? Amanta. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahanaya boj- jhanga bhavita, n'atthi tassa ahhanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paradhammakusalo Araha vltarago vltadoso vltamoho — pe — sacchikatabbam sacchikatam, n'atthi tassa ahhanan ti? 13 178 KATHAVATTHU. [II. 2. Anianta. Sadhammakusalo Araha vltarago — pe — sacchikatabbam sacchikatam, n'atthi tassa afifiaiian ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 17. Atthi Arahato annanan ti ? Anianta. Nanu vuttam Bliagavata — " Janatvaham ^ Bhikkhave passato asavanam khayam vadanii, no ajanato no apassato. Kin ca- Bhikkhave janato kiin passato asavanam khayo hoti? Iti rupam, iti rupassa samudayo, iti rupassa atthahgamo 3 ; iti vedana — ^pe — iti saiina — pe — iti samkhara — pe — iti vihfianam, iti vihhanassa samudayo, iti viiihanassa atthahgamo ti. Evam kho Bhikkhave janato evam passato asavanam khayo hotlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbain "Atthi Arahato ahiianan ti." 18. Atthi Arahato aiiiianan ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttanx Bhagavata— " Janatvaham Bhikkhave passato asavanam khayam vadami, no ajanato no apassato. Kin ca Bhikkhave janato kiin passato asavanam khayo hoti '? Idain dnkkhan ti Bhikkhave janato passato asa- vanam khayo hoti, ay am dukkhasamudayo ti janato passato asavanam khayo hoti, ayam dukkhanirodho ti janato passato asavanam khayo hoti, ayam dukkhanirodha- gaminlpatipada ti janato passato asavanam khayo hoti. Evam kho Bhikkhave janato evam passato asavanam khayo hotlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbain " Atthi Arahato ahhanan ti." 19. Atthi Arahato ahhanan ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Sabbain Bhikkhave ana- bhijanam aparijanani avirajayam appajahani abhabbo dukkhakkhayaya. Sabbah ca kho Bhikkhave abhijanam Janataham, M. ~ ci, P. 3 atthagamo, P.S. II. 2.j KATHAVATTHU. 179 parijanam virajayam pajaham bhabbo diikkhakkhayayati." Atth'eva snttanto ti ? Anianta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Atthi Arahato annanan ti." 20. Atthi Arahato aiihanan ti '? Amanta. Nann vuttam Bhagavata — " Saha v'assa dassanasampadaya ^ Tayas su^ dhanima jahita bhavanti Sakkayaditthi vicikicchitah ca Silabbatam vapi yad atthi kihci, ^ . Catiih' apayehi ca vippamutto f^ Cha cabhithanani 3 abhabbo katun ti." Atth'eva snttanto ti ? Anianta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Atthi Arahato ahhanan ti." 21. Atthi Arahato aiihanan ti ^ Anianta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Yasmini Bhikkhave samaye ariyasavakassa virajam vltamalam dhammacakkhum udapadi, ' yam kiiici samudayadhammam sabban tarn niro- dhadhamman ti,' saha dassanuppada Bhikkhave ariyasa- vakassa tlni saiiiiojanani pahiyanti, sakkayaditthi vicikiccha sllabbataparamaso ti." Atth'eva snttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Atthi Arahato annanan ti." 22. Na vattabbam " Atthi Arahato ahhanan ti " '? Amanta. Nanu Araha itthipurisanam -+ namagottam na janeyya, maggamaggam na janeyya, tiiiakatthavanappatlnamS namani na janeyyati '? Amanta. Hahci Araha itthipurisanam namagottam na janeyya, ^ Sahava saddassana, M. ; Sahavassa dassana, P. ; Saha yassa, Ss. ^ Tassa su, P. 3 Chaccabbio, M.; chachabi°, Ss- + itthi°, P.S.Sa. ^ °pahinam, P. 180 KATHAVATTHU. [11. 3. maggamaggam na janeyya, tinakatthavanappatlnam namam na janeyya, tena vata re vattabbe " Atthi Arahato aiinanan ti." 23. Araha itthipnrisanam naniagottam na janeyya, mag- gamaggam na janeyya, tinakatthavanappatlnam namam na janeyyati, atthi Arahato ahhanan ti'? Amanta. Araha sotapattiphalam va sakadagamiphalam va ana- gamiphalam va arahattam va na janeyyati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — . Anfianakatha. II. 3. 1. Atthi Arahato kahkha ti ? Amanta. Atthi Arahato vicikiccha vicikicchapariyutthanam vici- kicchasahhojanam vicikicchanlvaranan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N'atthi Arahato vicikiccha vicikicchapariyutthanam vicikicchasahhojanam vicikicchanlvaranan ti ? Amanta. Hahci n'atthi Arahato vicikiccha vicikicchapariyuttha- nain vicikicchasahiiojanam vicikicchanlvaranam, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi Arahato kahkha ti." 2. Atthi puthujjanassa kahkha, atthi tassa vicikiccha vicikicchapariyutthanam vicikicchasaiihojanam vicikiccha- nlvaranan ti ? Amanta. Atthi Arahato kahkha, atthi tassa vicikiccha vicikiccha- pariyutthanam vicikicchasaiiiiojanam vicikicclianlvaranan ti? '" ' Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Atthi Arahato kahkha, n'atthi tassa vicikiccha vici- kicchapariyutthanam vicikicchasahhojanani vicikicchanl- varanan ti '? II. 3. J KATHAVATTHU. 181 Amanta. Atthi putliujjanassa kankha, n'atthi tassa vicikiccha vicikicchapariyutthanam vicikicchasannojanam vicikiccha- nivaranan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 4. Atthi Arahato kankha ti ? Amanta. Atthi Arahato Satthari kankha, Dhamme kankha, Samghe kankha, sikkhaya kankha, pubbante kankha, aparante kankha, pnbbantaparante kankha, idappaccaya- tapaticcasamuppannesu dhamniesn kankha ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N'atthi Arahato Satthari kankha, Dhamme kankha, Samghe kankha, sikkhaya kankha, pubbante kankha, aparante kankha, pnbbantaparante kankha, idappac- cayatapaticcasamuppannesu dhammesn kankha ti ? Amanta. Hahci n'atthi Arahato Satthari kankha, Dhamme kankha Samghe kankha — pe — idappaccayatapaticcasamiippannesu dhammesu kankha, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato kankha ti." 5. Atthi puthujjanassa kankha, atthi tassa Satthari kankha, Dhamme kankha, Sarnghe kankha — pe — idappac- cayatapaticcasamuppannesu dhammesu kankha ti ? Amanta. Atthi Arahato kankha, atthi tassa Satthari kankha, Dhamme kankha, Samghe kankha — pe — idappaccayata- paticcasamuppannesu dhammesu kankha ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi Arahato kankha, n'atthi tassa Satthari kankha, Dhamme kankha, Samghe kankha — pe — idappaccayata- paticcasamuppannesu dhammesu kankha ti '? Amanta. Atthi puthujjanassa kankha, n'atthi tassa Satthari kankha, Dhamme kankha, Samghe kankha — pe— idappac- cayatapaticcasamuppannesu dhammesu kankha ti ? Na h'evam vatta])be — pe — 6. Atthi Arahato kankha ti ? 182 liATHAVATTHU. [II. 3. Amanta. Nanu Arahato rago pahlno ucchinnamulo talavatthukato anabhavamkato ayatim anuppadadhammo ti ? Amanta. Hanci Arahato rago pahino ucchinnamulo talavatthukato anabhavamkato ayatim anuppadadhammo, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi Arahato kahkha ti." Nanu Arahato doso pahino — pe — moho pahlno — pe — anottappam pahlnam ucchinnamulam talavatthukatam anabhavamkatam ayatiin anuppadadhamman ti ? Amanta. Hahci Arahato anottappam pahinaiu ucchinnamulam talavatthukatam anabhavamkatam ayatim anuppada- dhammam, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato kankha ti." 7. Atthi Arahato kankha ti ? Amanta. Nanu Arahato ragappahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — boj- jhahga bhavita ti '? Amanta. Hahci Arahato ragappahanaya bojjhahga bhavita, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi Arahato kankha ti." Atthi Arahato kahkha ti ? Amanta. Nanu Arahato dosappahanaya — pe — anottappappaha- naya maggo bhavito— pe — bojjhahga bhavita ti? Amanta. Hahci anottappappahanaya bojjhahga bhavita, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi Arahato kahkha ti." 8. Atthi Arahato kahkha ti ? Amanta. Nanu Araha vltarago vitadoso vltamoho — pe — sacchi- katabbain sacchikatan ti ? Amanta. Hahci Araha vltarago — pe — sacchikatabbam sacchi- katarn, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi Arahato kahkha ti." 9. Atthi Arahato kahkha ti ? Sadhammakusalassa II. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 183 Arahato atthi kankha, paradhammakusalassa iirahato n'atthi kankha ti. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi kankha ti ? Amanta. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato atthi kankha ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Paradhammakusalassa x-^-rahato n'atthi kankha ti ? Amanta. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato n'atthi kankha ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 10. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rago pahino, atthi tassa kankha ti ? Amanta. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rago pahino, atthi tassa kankha ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pahino, moho pahino — pe — anottappam pahinam, atthi tassa kankha ti ? Amanta. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappam pahinam atthi tassa kankha ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 11. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato ragappahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhahga bhavita, atthi tassa kankha ti? Amanta. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato ragappahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhahga bhavita, atthi tassa kankha ti-? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sadhammakusalassa Arahato dosappahanaya — pe — anottappappahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhahga bhavita, atthi tassa kankha ti ? Amanta. Paradhanmiakusalassa Arahato anottappappahanaya bojjhahga bhavita, atthi tassa kankha ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 12. Sadhammakusalo Araha vitarago vitadoso vltainoho 184 KATHAVATTHU, [II. 3. — pe — sacchikatabbam sacchikatam, atthi tassa kaiikha ti '? Amanta. Paradhammakusalo Araha vltarago — pe — sacchikatab- bam sacchikatam, atthi tassa kankha ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 13. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rago pahlno, n'atthi tassa kankha ti "? Amanta. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rago pahlno, n'atthi tassa kankha ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paradhammakusalassa Arahato doso pahlno — pe — anot- tappam pahinam, n'atthi tassa kankha ti ? Amanta. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pahlno — pe^anot- tappam pahinain, n'atthi tassa kankha ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 14. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato ragappahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhahga bhavita — pe — anottap- pappahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhahga bhavita, n'atthi tassa kankha ti ? Amanta. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahanaya boj- jhahga bhavita, n'atthi tassa kankha ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paradhammakusalo Araha vltarago vltadoso vltamoho — ^pe — sacchikatabbain sacchikatam, n'atthi tassa kankha ti ? Amanta. Sadhammakusalo Araha vltarago — pe — sacchikatabbam sacchikatain, n'atthi tassa kankha ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 15. Atthi Arahato kankha ti? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Janatvaham Bhikkhave passato asavanam khayam vadami, no ajanato no apassato. Kin ca Bhikkhave janato kim passato asavlnam khayo II. 3. I KATHAVATTHU. 185 hoti ? Iti rupam, iti rupassa samudayo, iti rupassa atthaiigamo ; iti vedana — pe — iti saiiiia — pe — iti sam- khara — pe — iti vinfianam, iti viniianassa samudayo, iti vinnanassa atthangaino ti. Evam kho Bhikkhave janato evam passato asavanam khayo hotlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? * Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Atthi Arahato kaiikha ti." 16. Atthi Arahato kankha ti ? Amanta. Naiin vuttam Bhagavata — " Janatvaham Bhikkhave passato asavanam khayamvadami, no ajanato no apassato. Kin ca Bhikkhave janato kim passato asavanain khayo hotI ? Idam dukkhan ti Bhikkhave janato passato asa- vanam khayo hoti, ay am dukkhasamndayo ti janato passato asavanam khayo hoti, ayain dnkkhanirodho ti janato passato asavanam khayo hoti, ayam dukkhanirodha- gaminipatipada ti janato passato asavanam khayo hoti. Evam kho Bhikkhave janato evani passato asavanain khayo hotlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Atthi Arahato kankha ti." 17. Atthi Arahato kankha ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttani Bhagavata — " Sabbam Bhikkhave ana- bhijanam aparijanam avirajayani appajahain abhabbo dukkhakkhayaya. Sabbah ca kho Bhikkhave abhijanam parijanam virajayam pajaham bhabbo dukkhakkhayayati.' Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam "Atthi Arahato kaiikha ti." 18. Atthi Arahato kankha ti '? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata— Saha v'assa dassanasampadaya Tayas su dhamma jahita bhavanti Sakkayaditthi vicikicchitah ca Silabbatam vapi yad attln kihci, 186 KATHAVATTHU. [II. 3. Catnh'apayehi ca vippamutto Cha cabhithanani abhabbo katun " ti. Atth'eva suttanto ti '? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Atthi Arahato kaiikha ti." 19. Atthi Arahato kahkha ti? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — ■" Yasmim Bhikkhave samaye ariyasavakassa virajam vitamalam dhaininacakkhum uda- padi, ' yam kihci samudayadhammain sabban taiu nirodha- dhammantij'saha dassanuppada Bhikkhave ariyasavakassa tlni sahhojanani pahlyanti, sakkayaditthi vicikiccha sllab- bataparamaso ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti '? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam "Atthi Arahato kahkha ti." 20. Atthi Arahato kahkha ti '? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — c " Yada have patubhavanti dhamma Atapino jhayato brahmanassa, Ath'assa kahkha vapayant i sabba Yato pajanati sojhetudhamman ti. Yada have patubhavanti dhamma Atapino jhayato brahmanassa, Ath'assa kahkha vapayanti sabba Yato khayam paccayanam avediti. Yada have patubhavanti dhamma Atapino jhayato brahmanassa Vidhupayani ' titthati Marasenain Suriyo^ va obhasayam antahkkhan ti. Ya kaci kahkha idha va hurain vfi Sakavediya 3 va paravediya va, Jhayino 4 ta pajahanti 5 sabba I avidhupayam, S. ^ Suriyo, M. 3 veriya, P.S.Sj 4 jayain no, S. 5 pajahatanti, P. II. 4.] KATHAVATTHU. 187 Atapino brahmacariyam caranta ti." " Ye kankha samatikkanta ^ kankhabliutesu panisu Asamsaya visamyutta ^ tesu dinnam mahapphalan ti." " Etadisi 3 dliammapakasanettha 4 Kin nil tattha 5 kankhati koci savako, Nitinna-oghani ^ vicikicchachinnani 7 Buddham namassama^ jinam janinda ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Anianta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Atthi Arahato kankha ti." 21. Na vattabbam " Atthi Arahato kankha ti " ? Amanta. Nanu Araha itthipiirisanam namagotte kankheyya, magganiagge kankheyya, tinakatthavanappatlnain name kankheyyati ? Amanta. Hanoi Araha itthipurisanain namagotte — pe — tinakat- thavanappatlnain name kankheyya, tena vata re vattabbe " Atthi Arahato kankha ti." 22. Araha itthipiirisanam namagotte — pe — tinakattha- vanappatlnain name kankheyya, atthi Arahato kankha ti ? Amanta. Araha sotapattiphale va sakadagamiphale va anagami- phale va arahatte va kankheyyati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — K a h k h a k a t h a. II. 4. 1. Atthi Arahato paravitarana 9 ti ? I sahao, S. ^ oyi^^tto, S. 3 ekadisi, P.Sa- ; kocisi, S. -+ pakiisanetta, S. 5 na tattha kiiii, M. ; kini kaiikhati, P.S.S2. 6 titiiina°, P. ; nattinna°, S. 7 vicikicchanani, P. s passama, S. 9 pari^, P. 188 KATHAVATTHU. [II. 4. Amanta. Araha paraneyyo parapattiyo parapaccayo parapatib- baddhabhu I na janati, na passati, saiiimulho ^ asaiiipa- jano ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Nann Araha na paraneyyo, na parapattiyo, na para- paccayo, na parapatibaddhabhu janati, passati, asam- mulho sampajano ti ? Amanta. Hanci Araha na paraneyyo, na parapattiyo, na para- paccayo, na parapatibaddhabhu janati, passati, asam- niulho sampajano, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti." 2. Atthi puthujjanassa paravitarana, so ca paraneyyo parapattiyo parapaccayo parapatibaddhabhu na janati, na passati, asammulho sampajano ti"? Amanta. Atthi Arahato paravitarana, so ca paraneyyo parapattiyo parapaccayo parapatibaddhabhu na janati, na passati, asammulho sampajano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Atthi Arahato paravitarana, so ca na paraneyyo na parapattiyo na parapaccayo na parapatibaddhabhu janati, passati, asammulho sampajano ti ? Amanta. Atthi puthujjanassa paravitarana, so ca na paraneyyo na parapattiyo na parapaccayo na parapatibaddhabhu janati, passati, asammulho sampajano ti ? I^a h'evarn vattabbe— pe — 4. Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti ? Amanta. Atthi Arahato Satthari paravitarana, Dhamme paravi- tarana, Samghe paravitarana, sikkhaya paravitarana, pubbante paravitarana, aparante paravitarana, pubbanta- parante paravitarana, idappaccayatapaticcasamuppannesu dhammesu paravitaran a ti ? I paraparibuddhabu, P. ^ samulho, P.S. II. 4.] KATHAVATTHU. 189 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N'atthi Arabato Satthari paravitarana, Dhamme para- vitarana, Samghe paravitarana, sikkbaya paravitarana, pubbante paravitarana, aparante paravitarana, pnbbanta- parante paravitarana, idappaccayatapaticcasamuppannesn dhammesu paravitarana ti "? Amanta. Hanoi n'attbi Arabato Sattbari paravitarana, Dbamme paravitarana, Samgbe paravitarana — pe — idappaccayata- paticcasamuppannesn dhammesu paravitarana, no vata re vattabbe " Attbi x\rahato paravitarana ti." 5. Attbi putbujjanassa paravitarana, attbi tassa Sat- tbari paravitarana, Dbamme paravitarana, Samgbe para- vitarana— pe — idappaccayatapaticcasamuppannesu dham- mesu paravitarana ti ? Amanta. Attbi Arabato paravitarana, attbi tassa Satthari paravi- tarana, Dhamme paravitarana, Samghe paravitarana — pe — idappaccayatapaticcasamuppannesu dhammesu para- vitarana ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Attbi Arabato paravitarana, n'attbi tassa Satthari paravitarana, Dbamme paravitarana, Samghe paravita- rana — pe — idappaccayatapaticcasamuppannesu dham- mesu paravitarana ti '? Amanta. Attbi putbujjanassa paravitarana, n'attbi tassa Satthari paravitarana, Dhamme paravitarana, Samghe paravita- rana — pe — idappaccayatapaticcasamuppannesu dham- mesu paravitarana ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Attbi Arabato paravitarana ti ? Amanta. Nanu Arabato rago pabino ucchinnamulo talavatthu- kato anabbavainkato ayatiin anuppadadbammo ti ? Amanta. Hahci Arabato rago pabino ucchinnamulo tJilavattbu- kato anabbavainkato ayatiin anuppadadbammo, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi Arabato paravitarana ti." 190 KATHAVATTHU. [II. 4. Nanu Arahato closo pahlno — pe— moho pahlno — pe — anottappam pahlnain ucchinnaniulam talavatthukatam anabhavamkatam ayatiin anuppadadhamman ti '? Aiiianta. Hanoi Arahato anottappain pahmam uccliinnamnlam talavatthukatain aiiabliavaiukatam ayatim anuppada- dhammam, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi Arahato parivita- rana ti." 7. Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti ? Amanta. Nanu Arahato ragappahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — boj- jhahga bhavita ti ? Amanta. Haiici Arahato ragappahanaya bojjhahga bhavita, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti." Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti ? Amanta. Nanu Arahato dosappahanaya — pe — anottappappaha - naya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhahga bhavita ti ? Amanta. Hahci anottappappahanaya bojjhahga bhavita, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti." 8. Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti ? Amanta. Nanu Araha vltarago vltadoso vltamoho — pe — sacchi- katabbam sacchikatan ti ? Amanta. Hahci Araha vltarago — pe — sacchikatabbain sacchika- tam, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti." 9. Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti ? Sadhammakusa- lassa Arahato atthi paravitarana, paradhammakusalassa Arahato n'atthi paravitarana ti. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi paravitarana ti ? Amanta. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato atthi paravitarana ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paradhammakusalassa Arahato n'atthi paravitarana ti ? II. 4. J KATHAVATTHU. 191 Amanta. Sadhainmakusalassa Arahato n'atthi paravitarana ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — 10. Saclhammakusalassa Arahato rago pahino, atthi tassa paravitarana ti ? Amanta. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rago pahino, atthi tassa paravitarana ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sadhamniakusalassa Arahato doso pahino, moho pahino — -pe — anottappam pahlnam, atthi tassa paravitarana ti? Amanta. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappain pahlnam, atthi tassa paravitarana ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 11. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato ragappahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhahga bhavita, atthi tassa paravitarana ti? Amanta. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato ragappahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhanga bhavita, atthi tassa paravitarana ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — ^pe — Sadhammakusalassa Arahato dosappahanaya — pe — anottappappahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhanga bha- vita, atthi tassa paravitarana ti ? Amanta. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahanaya bojjhahga bhavita, atthi tassa paravitarana ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 12. Sadhammakusalo Araha vitarago vltadoso vlta- moho — pe- — sacchikatabbam sacchikatam, atthi tassa para- vitarana ti ? Amanta. Paradhammakusalo Araha vitarago — pe — sacchikiltal)- bam sacchikatain, attlii tassa paravitarana ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 192 KATHAVATTHU. [II. 4. 13. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rago pahlno, n'atthi tassa paravitarana ti '? Amanta. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rago pahlno, n'atthi tassa paravitarana ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paradhammakusalassa Arahato doso pahlno — pe — anottappam pahlnam, n'atthi tassa paravitarana ti '? Amanta. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pahlno — pe — anot- tappain pahlnam, n'atthi tassa paravitarana ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 14. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato ragappahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhahga bhavita — pe — anottappap- pahanaya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhahga bhavita, n'atthi tassa paravitarana ti ? Amanta. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahanaya boj- jhahga bhavita, n'atthi tassa paravitarana ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paradhammakusalo Araha vltarago vltadoso vltamoho — pe — sacchikiltabbam sacchikatam, n'atthi tassa paravi- tarana ti ? Amanta. Sadhammakusalo Araha vltarago — pe — sacchikatabbam sacchikatam, n'atthi tassa paravitarana ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 15. Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata— " Janatvaham Bhikkhave passato asavanam khayam vadami, no ajanato no apas- sato. Kill ca Bhikkhave janato kim passato asavanam khayo hoti? Iti rupam, iti rupassa samudayo, iti rupassa atthahgamo ; iti vedana— pe — iti sahha — pe — iti sam- khara — pe — iti vihhanani, iti vihhanassa samudayo, iti vihhanassa atthahgamo ti. Evani kho Bhikkhave janato €vam passato asavanain khayo hotlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? ' II. 4.] KATHAVATTHU. 193 Aiiianta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti." 16. Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti. Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Janatvaham Bhikkhave passato asavanam khayain vadaini, no ajanato no apassato. Kill ca Bhikkhave janato kim passato asavanani khayo hoti ? Idain dukkhan ti Bhikkhave janato passato asa- vanam khayo hoti, ayain dukkhasamiidayo ti janato passato asavanam khayo hoti, ayaip dukkhanirodho ti janato passato asavanam khayo hoti, ayain dukkhanirodha- gaininipatipada ti janato passato asavanani khayo hoti. Evam kho Bhikkhave janato evain passato asavanam khayo hotlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti." 17. Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttain Bhagavata — " Sabbani Bhikkhave ana- bhijanam aparijanam avirajayain appajahain abhabbo duk- khakkhayaya. Babbaii ca kho Bhikkhave abhijanam parijanani virajayam pajaham bhabbo dukkhakkhayayati." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbaiu '* Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti." 18. Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttain Bhagavata — Saha v'assa dassanasampadaya Tayas su dhamma jahita bhavanti Sakkayaditthi vicikicchitan ca Sllabbatam vapi yad atthi kinci, Catuh' apayehi ca vippamutto Cha cabhithanani abhabbo kiltun ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti V Amanta. 14 194 KATHAVATTHU. [II. 4. Tena hi na vattabbam " Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti." 19. Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Yasmim Bhikkhave sama- ye ariyasavakassa virajam vitamalam dhammacakkhum udapadi, 'yam kinci samudayadhammam sabban tarn niro- dhadhamman ti,' saha dassanuppada Bhikkhave ariyasa- vakassa tlni saiinoj'anani pahlyanti, sakkayaditthi vicikic- cha silabbataparamaso ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti." '20. Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Naham ^ gamissami pamocanaya^ Kathamkathim Dhotaka kanci 3 Joke, Dhammaii ca settham abhijanamano Evam tuvam4 ogham imam tareslti."-. Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti." 21. Na vattabbam " Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti " ? Amanta. Nanu Arahato itthipurisanam namagottam pare vita- reyyum, maggamaggam pare vitareyyum, tinakattliava- nappatlnain namam pare vitareyyun ti ? Amanta. Haiici Arahato itthipurisanain namagottam pare vita- reyyum, maggamaggam pare vitareyyum, tinakatthava- I na param, P.S.S2. ' ^ pamojanaya, P.S2. 3 Katham kathi kenaka kinci, M. 4 duvam, S2 ; dhuvam, P. II. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 195 nappatinam namaiii pare vitareyyum, tena vata re vattabbe " Atthi Arahato paravitarana ti." 22. Arahato itthipurisanam namagottam pare vitarey- yum, maggamaggam pare vitareyyum, tinakatthavanappa- tmam namam pare vitareyyum, atthi Arahato paravita- rana ti ? Amanta. Arahato sotapattiphalaiu va sakadagamiphalam va ana- gamiphalam va arahattam va pare vitareyyuii ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Paravitaranakatha II. 5. 1. Samapamiassa atthi vacTbhedo ti ■? Amanta. Sabbattha ^ samapannanam atthi vacibhedo ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe- Samapannassa atthi vacibhedo ti ? Amanta. 8abbada samapannanani atthi vacibhedo ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Samapanassa atthi vacibhedo ti ? Amanta. Sabbesain samapannanani atthi vacibhedo ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Samapannassa atthi vacIl)hedo ti ? Amanta. 8al)basainapattlsu attlii vacibhedo ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 2. Samapannassa atthi vacibhedo ti ? Amanta. Samapannassa atthi kJiyabhedo ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Sabbatta, P. 19G KATHAVATTHU. [II. 5, Saiiiapannassa n'atthi kayabhedo ti ? Anianta. Samapannassa n'atthi vaclbhedo ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 3. Samapannassa atthi vaca, atthi vaclbhedo ti ? Amanta. Samapannassa atthi kayo, atthi kayabhedo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samapannassa atthi kayo, n'atthi kayabhedo ti V Amanta. Samapannassa atthi vaca, n'atthi vaclbhedo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — •4. Dukkhan ti jananto dukkhan ti vacain bhasatiti ? Amanta. Samudayo ti jananto samndayo ti vacani bhasatiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Dukkhan ti jananto dukkhan ti vacani bhilsatiti V Amanta. Nirodho ti jananto nirodho ti vacain bhasatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dukkhan ti jananto dukkhan ti vacani bhasatiti ? Amanta. Maggo ti jananto maggo ti vacani bhasatiti ? Na h'evain /attabbe — pe — 5. Samudayo ti jananto na ca samudayo ti vacain bhasatiti ? Amanta. Dukkhan ti jananto na ca dukkhan ti vacani bhasatiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Nirodho ti jananto na ca nirodho ti vacain bhasatiti ? Amanta. Dukkhan ti jananto na ca dukkhan ti vacani bhasatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Maggo ti jananto na ca maggo ti vacain bhJisatlti V Amanta. Dukkhan ti jananto na ca didckhan ti vacain bhasatiti "> Na h'evain vattal^be — pe — ('). Samapannassa atthi vaclbhedo ti? II. 5. J KATHAVATTHU. 197 Amanta. Nanani kimgocaran ti ? Nanain saccagocaran ti. Sotain saccagocaran ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Sainapannassa atthi vaclbbedo ti ? Amanta. Sotain kinigocaran ti ? Sotam saddagocaran ti. Nanain saddagocaran ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Sainapannassa atthi vaclbhedo, iianain saccagocarain, sotain saddagocaran ti '? Amanta. Hanci nanam saccagocarain, sotam saddagocaram, no vata re vattabbe " Sainapannassa atthi vaclbhedo ti." Sainapannassa atthi vaclbhedo, iianain saccagocarain, sotam saddag^ocaran ti '? Amanta. Dvinnam phassanam dvinnam vedananam dvinnam J~ • • • • saiinanam dvinnam cetananaiji dvinnam cittanam samodhanain hotiti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — : 8. Sainapannassa atthi vaclbhedo ti ? Amanta. Pathavlkasinam samapattim ^ sainapannassa atthi vaclbhedo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sainapannassa atthi vaclbhedo ti? Amanta. Apokasinam — pe — tejokasinain, vayokasinam, nllakasi- nani, pitakasinam, lohitakasinam, odatakasinam sama- pattiin — pe — akasanancayatanain, viiiiianahcayatanani, akiiicaiinayatanam — pe — - nevasaiihanasaiiiiayatanain sainapannassa attlii vaclbhedo ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — I Pathavikasinasamapatti°, P.S2. 198 KATHAVATTHU. !^II. 5, 9. Pathavlkasinam samapattim samapannassa n'atthi vacTbhedo ti ? Amanta. Haiici pathavikasinain samapattim samapannassa n'atthi vacibhedo, no vata re vattabbe " Samapannassa atthi vacibhedo ti." Apokasinain — pe — odatakasinain samapattim — pe — akasanaiicayatanam, viiinanaiicayatanam, akincafiiiaya- tanam — pe — nevasafiiianasaiinayatanam samapannassa n'atthi vacTbhedo ti ? Amanta. Haiici nevasaniianasannayatanam samapannassa n'atthi vacTbhedo, no vata re vattabbe " Samapannassa atthi vacTbhedo ti." 10. Samapannassa atthi vacTbhedo ti ? Amanta. Loki}' am samapattiin samapannassa atthi vacTbhedo ti V Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Samapannassa atthi vacTbhedo ti V Amanta. Lokiyam pathamain jhanam samapannassa atthi vacTbhedo ti ? Na h'evaiii vattabbe — pe — Samapannassa atthi vacTbhedo ti ? - Amanta. Lokiyani dutiyam jhanam — pe — tatij'ain jhanain — pe — catutthain jhanam samapannassa atthi vacTbhedo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 11. Lokiyam samapattiin samapannassa n'atthi vacT- bhedo ti ? Amanta. Hanci lokiyani samapattim samapannassa n'atthi vacTbhedo, no vata re vattabbe " Samapannassa atthi vacTbhedo ti." Lokiyam pathamain jhanain ^ samapannassa n'atthi vacTbhedo ti ? ' pathamajjhanain, P.S.Ss. II. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 199 Amanta. Hanci lokiyam pathamam jhanam samapannassa n'atthi vaclbhedo, no vata re vattabbe " Samapannassa atthi vacibhedo ti." Lokiyam dutiyam — pe — catiitthaiu jhanam samapan- nassa n'atthi vaclbhedo ti ? Amanta. Hanoi lokiyam dutiyain — pe — catuttham jhanam samapannassa n'atthi vacibhedo, no vata re vattabbe " Samapannassa atthi vacibhedo ti." 12. Lokuttarain pathamam jhanam samapannassa atthi vacibhedo ti ? Amanta. • Lokiyam pathamain jhanam samapannassa atthi vacibhedo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Lokuttarain. pathamam jhanam samapannassa atthi vacibhedo ti ? Amanta. Lokiyam dutiyam — pe — tatiyam — pe — catuttham jhanam samapannassa atthi vacibhedo ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Lokiyam pathamani jhanam samapannassa n'atthi vacibhedo ti ? Amanta. Lokuttarain pathamam jhanam samapannassa n'atthi vacibhedo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Lokiyam dutiyain — pe— catuttham jhanain samapan- nassa n'atthi vacibhedo ti ? Amanta. Lokuttarain pathamain jhanam samapannassa n'atthi vacibhedo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 13. Lokuttarain pathamain jhanain samapannassa atthi vacibhedo ti ? Amanta. Lokuttarain dutiyam jhanain samapannassa atthi vacibhedo ti ? 200 KATHAVATTHU. [II. 5. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Lokuttaram pathamam jhanam sainapannassa atthi vaclbliedo ti ? Amanta. Lokuttaram tatiyam — pe— catuttham jhanaui saina- pannassa atthi vaclbhedo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Lokuttarain dntiyam jhanam samapannassa n'atthi vaclbhedo ti '? Amanta. Lokuttarain pathamam jhanam samapannassa n'atthi vaclbhedo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Lokuttarain tatiyain — pe — catutthani jhanain sama- pannassa n'atthi vaclbhedo ti ? Amanta. Lokuttarain pathamam jhanam samapannassa n'atthi vaclbhedo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 14. Na vattabbain " Samapannassa attlii vaclbhedo ti"? Amanta. Nanu vitakkavicara vaclsamkhara vutta Bhagavata, pathamain jhanain samapannassa atthi vitakkavicara ti? Amanta. Haiici vitakkavicara vaclsainkhara vutta Bhagavata, pathamain jhanain samapannassa atthi vitakkavicara, tena vata re vattabbe "Sainapannassa atthi vaclbhedo ti." 15. Vitakkavicara vaclsainkhara vutta Bhagavata, pathamam jhanain samapannassa atthi vitakkavicara, atthi tassa vaclbhedo ti ? Amanta. Pathavikasinam pathamain jhanain sainapannassa atthi vitakkavicara, atthi tassa vaclbhedo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vitakkavicara vaclsainkhara vutta Bhagavata, pathamam jhanain samapannassa atthi vitakkavicara, atthi tassa vaclbhedo ti ? II. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 201 Amanta. Apokasinam— pe— tejokasinam, vayokasinam, nila- kasinam, pltakasinaiu, lohitakasinain — pe— odatakasinani pathamam jhanain sainapannassa attlii vitakkavicara, atthi tassa vaclbhedo ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 16. Na vattabbam " Samapannassa atthi vaclbhedo ti " '? Amanta. Nanii vitakkasaniutthana ^ vaca vutta Bhagavata, pathamam jhanam samapannassa atthi vitakkavicara ti '? Amanta. Haiici vitakkasamutthana vaca vutta Bhagavata, pathamani jhanam samapannassa atthi vitakkavicara, tena vata re vattabbe " Samapannassa atthi vaclbhedo ti." 17. Vitakkasamutthana vaca vutta Bhagavata, patha- mam jhanam samapannassa attlii vitakkavicara, atthi tassa vaclbhedo ti ? Amanta. Sahhasamutthana vaca vutta Bhagavata, dutiyam jhanam samapannassa atthi sahha, atthi tassa vitakkavi- cara ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vitakkasamutthana vaca vutta Bhagavata, pathamam jhanain samapannassa atthi vitakkavicara, atthi tassa vaclbhedo ti ? Amanta. Saiiiiasamutthana vaca vutta Bhagavata, tatiyain jhanain — pe — catuttham jhanam, akasanahcayatanam, viiiiianahcayatanain, akiiicaiiiiayatanam samapannassa atthi sahha, atthi tassa vitakkavicara ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 18. Samapannassa atthi vaclbhedo ti ? Amanta. Nanu " pathamani jlianani samapannassa vaca niruddha hotiti," atth'eva suttanto ti '? ' °samutthana, P.S. 202 KATHAVATTHU. :il. 5. Ainaiita. Hanoi " pathaniam jhanam samapannassa vaca niruddha liotiti," atth'eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe " Sama- pannassa atthi vaclbhedo ti." 19. " Pathamam jhanam samapannassa vaca niruddha hotiti," atth'eva suttanto ti, atthi tassa vaclbhedo ti ? Amanta. " Dutiyain jhanain samapannassa vitakkavicara ni- ruddha hontiti," atth'eva suttanto ti, atthi tassa vitak- kavicara ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — " Pathamain jhanam samapannassa vaca niruddha hotiti," atth'eva suttanto ti, atthi tassa vaclbhedo ti? Amanta. " Tatiyain jhanam samapannassa piti ^ niruddha hoti — pe — catuttham jhanam samapannassa assasapassasa niruddha honti, akasanaiicayatanam samapannassa rupa- sahiia niruddha hoti, viiihanahcayatanam samapannassa akasanahcayatanasaiiha niruddha hoti, akihcahhayatanam samapannassa viiihanahcayatanasahha niruddha hoti — pe — nevasaniianasahhayatanam samapannassa akihcahhaya- tanasahiia niruddha hoti, sahhavedayitamrodham sama- pannassa sahha ca vedana ca niruddha hontiti," atth'eva suttanto ti, atthi tassa sahha ca vedana cati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 20. Na vattabbain " Samapannassa atthi vaclbhedo ti "'? Amanta. Nanu pathamassa jhanassa saddo kanthako- vutto Bhagavata ti '? Amanta. Hahci pathamassa jhanassa saddo kanthako vutto Bhagavata, tena vata re vattabbe " Samapannassa atthi vaclbhedo ti." 21. Pathamassa jhanassa saddo kanthako vutto Bhasa- vata ti, samapannassa atthi vaclbhedo ti ? Amanta. I piti, M. 2 kantako, P. ; kandako, Sa. II. 6.] .KATHAVATTHU. 203 Dutiyassa jhanassa vitakkavicara kanthako vutta Bhaga- vata — pe — tatiyassa jhanassa piti kanthako vutta Bhaga- vata — pe — catiitthassa jhanassa assasapassasa kanthako vutta Bhagavata, akasanahcayatanam samapannassa rupasaiiha kanthako vutta Bhagavata, vinhanancayatanam samapannassa akasanahcayatanasanna kanthako vutta Bhagavata, akiiicanhayatanain samapannassa vinnanah- cayatanasahha kanthako vutta Bhagavata, nevasahha- nasannayatanam samapannassa akincannayatanasahna kanthako vutta Bhagavata — pe — sahhavedayitanirodhani samapannassa sahha ca vedana ca kanthako vutta Bhaga- vata, atthi tassa saiina ca vedana cati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 22. Na vattabbani " Samapannassa atthi vaclbhedo ti"? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — •" Sikhissa Ananda Bhao^a- vato Arahato Sammasambuddhassa abhibhu nama savako l)rahmaloke thito sahassilokadhatuni ^ sarena vinhapesi. Arabbhatha nikkamatha Yuhjatha - Buddhasasane, Dhunatha maccuno senam Nalagarain3 va kuhjaro. Yo imasmim dhammavinaye Appamatto viharissati, Pahaya ^ jatisamsarani Dukkhass'antani karissatlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti '■ Amanta. Tena hi samapannassa atthi vaclbhedo ti. Y a c I b h e d a k a t h a. II. G. 1. Dukkhaharo maggahgam 5 maggapariyapannan ti ? • dasasahassi°, M. ^ yuncatha, P. 3 nalagaram, P.S... -^ pahilti, P.S. 5 maggaiu, P. 204 KATHAVATTHTJ. [II. 7. AinantJl. Ye keci " dukkhan ti " vacam bhasanti, sabbe te maggain bhaventiti *? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Ye keci "dukkhan ti " vacam bhasanti, sabbe te maggam bhaventiti '? Amanta. Balaputhiijjana " dukkhan ti " vacam bhasanti, bala- puthujjana maggam bhaventiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Matughataka — pe — pitughataka, arahantaghataka, ruhiruppadaka ^ — pe — sainghabhedaka " dukkhan ti " vacam bhasanti, sainghabhedaka maggain l^haventiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dukkhaharakatha. II. 7. 1. Ekam cittain divasam titthatiti ? Amanta. Upaddhadivaso uppadakkhano,^ upaddhadivaso vayak- khano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ekam cittam dve divase titthatiti ? Amanta. Divaso uppadakkhano, divaso vayakkhano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ekam cittam cattaro divase titthati — pe — attha divase • • • • J- • • titthati, dasa divase titthati, visati divase titthati, masam titthati, dve mase titthati, cattaro mase titthati, attha mase titthati, dasa mase titthati, samvaccharam titthati, dve vassani titthati, cattari vassani titthati, attha vassani titthati, dasa vassani titthati, visati vassani titthati, tiiiisa vassani .titthati, cattaiisa vassani titthati, pafinasa vassani titthati, vassasatani titthati, dve vassa- I lohituppadaka, M. ^ okhane, P. II. 7. J KATHAVATTHU. 205 satani titthati, cattari vassasatani titthati, paiica vassasa- tani titthati, vassasahassain titthati, clve vassasahassani titthati, cattari vassasahassani titthati, attha vassasa- hassani titthati, solasa vassasahassani titthati, kappaiii titthati, dve kappe titthati, attha kappe titthati, solasa kappe titthati, battiinsa kappe titthati, catiisatthl kappe titthati, pahca kappasatani titthati, kappasahassaiii titthati, dve kappasahassani titthati, attha kappa- sahassani titthati, solasa kappasahassani titthati, visati kappasahassani titthati, cattarTsa kappasahassani titthati, satthikappasahassani titthati, — pe — ^caturasiti vassaahas- ahassani titthatlti ? Anianta. Dve cattarisa kappasahassani uppadakkhano, dve catta- lisa kappasahassani vayakkhano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Ekain cittani divasam titthatlti ? Amanta. Atth'ahne dhamma ekahain bahu pi ^ nppajjitva niruj- jhantiti ? Amanta. Te dhamma cittena lahuparivatta ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Te dhamma cittena lahuparivatta ti V Amanta. Nanu vuttani Bhagavata — " Naham Bhikkhave ahhaiu ekam dhannnain pi samanupassami evani lahuparivattain yathayidain- cittam. Yavah c'idain Bhikkhave upama pi na sukara yava lahuparivattain cittan ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Te dhamma cittena lahupari- vatta ti." 3. Te dhannna cittena lahuparivatta ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttani Bhagavata — " Seyyathapi Bhikkhave I bahuppi, M. ~ M. inserts bhikkhave after yathayidaiiu 206 KATHAVATTHU. [II. 7. inakkato ' aranfic pavane caraniano sakhain gaiihati, taiii muncitva aniiam ganhati, tarn muncitva aiinam ganhati, evameva kho Bhikkhave yadidain vuccati " cittain iti pi," "mano iti pi," " viiinanam iti pi," tarn rattiya ca divasassa ca annad eva uppajjati, annam nirujjhatlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbain " Te dhamma cittena lahiipari- vatta ti." 4. Ekain cittam divasaiu tittbatiti ? Amanta. Cakkhuvinnaiiam divasam tittbatiti ? Na h'evaiu vattabbe — pe — Sotaviiinanam — pe — ghanaviniianani, jivbaviniianam, kayavifnianaiii, akusalam cittaiii, ragasahagatam dosasa- hagatam inobasahagatam manasabagatam ditthisahaga-" tarn vicikicchasabagatam tblnasabagatam nddbaccasa- hagatain abirikasabagatani anottappasahagatam cittam divasam tittbatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Ekam cittain divasam tittbatiti ? Amanta. Yen'eva cittena cakkbuna rupain passati, ten'eva cittena sotena saddam sunati — pe — gbanena gandbam gbayati, jivbaya rasain sayati, kayena pbottbabbam pbusati — pe — manasa dbammam vijanati — pe — yen'eva cittena manasa dbammam vijanati, ten'eva cittena cakkbmia rupain passati — pe — sotena saddain sunati, gbanena gandbain gbayati, jivbaya rasain sayati, kayena pbottbab]:)ain pbusatiti ? Na b'evain vattabbe — pe — 6. Ekain cittain divasani tittbatiti ? Amanta. Yen'eva cittena abbikkamati ten'eva cittena patikka- mati, yen'eva cittena patikkamati ten'eva cittena abbikka- mati, yen'eva cittena aloketi ten'eva cittena viloketi. maggato, P.S. II. 7.] KATHAVATTHU. '207 yen'eva cittena viloketi ten'eva cittena aloketi, yen'eva cittena samminjeti ^ ten'eva cittena pasareti, yen'eva cittena pasareti ten'eva cittena samminjetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Akasanaiicayatanupaganam devanam ekaiii cittam yavatayukain titthatiti ? Anianta. Manussanam ekam cittam yavatayukain titthatiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Akasanancayatanupaganain devanain ekain cittam yavatayukam titthatiti ? Amanta. Catummaharajikanani devanain — pe — Tavatimsanam devanam, Yamanam devanain, Tusitanam devanam, Nimmanaratlnain devanam, Paranimmitavasavattlnam devanam, Brahmaparisajjanam devanain, Brahmaparo- i^ hitanam devanain, Mahabrahmanam devanain, Paritta- bhanain devanam, Appamanabhanam devanam, Abhassa- ranain devanam, Parittasubhanani devanain, Appamana- siibhanam, devanam, Subhakinnanam devanain, Vehap- phalanam devanain, Avihanam devanain, Atappanam devanam, Sudassanam devanam, Sndasslnam devanam — pe — Akanitthanam devanain ekaui cittain yavatayukain tittliatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Akasanaiicayatannpaganain devanam visati kappasa- hassani ayuppamanain, akasanancayatanupaganain deva- nam ekam cittain visati kappasahassani titthatiti ? Amanta. Manussanam vassasatain ayuppamanain, manussanam ekain cittain vassasatain titthatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Akasanaiicayatanupaganam devanain visati kappasa- hassani ayuppamanain, akasanancayatanupagrinain de- vanam ekain cittain visati kappasahassani titthatiti ? Amanta. 1 asamihjeti, P. 208 KATHAYATTHU. [II. 8. Catumiuaharajikanani devanam panca vassasatani ayup- panianam, catuniiiiaharajikanaiii devanain ekaiii cittam panca vassasatani titthati — pe — vassasahassain titthati, dve vassasahassani titthati, cattari vassasahassani titthati, attha vassasahassani titthati, solasa vassasahassani tit- thati, kappassa tatiyabhagani titthati, upaddhakappani titthati, ekaiii kappani titthati, dve kappe titthati, cattaro kappe titthati, attha kappe titthati, solasa kappe titthati, battimsa kappe titthati, catusatthi kappe titthati, panca kappasatani titthati, kappasahassam titthati, dve kappa- sahassani titthati, cattari kappasahassani titthati, attha kappasahassani titthati — pe — Akanitthaganain devanam solasa kappasahassani ayuppamanam, Akanitthaganain devanain ekani cittam solasa kappasahassani titthatiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 9. Akasanahcayatanupaganani devanain cittani muhut- tain muhuttain uppajjati, muhuttam muhnttain nirujjha- tlti? Amanta. Akasanahcayatanupaga deva muhuttain muhuttain cavanti, muhuttam muhuttain uppajjantiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 10. Akasanahcayatanupaganani devanain okain cittam yavatayukani titthatiti ? Amanta. Akasanahcayatanupaga deva yen'eva cittena uppajjanti, ten'eva cittena cavantiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — C i 1 1 a 1 1 h i k a t h a. II. 8. 1. Sabbe sainkhara anodhikatva ' kukkula ti V Amanta. Nanu atthi sukha vedana, kayikain sukhain, cetasikam I anodhim katva, M. II. 1'2> KATHAVATTHU. [Jl. 9. 110 vata re vattabbe " Sabbe saiiikhara anodhikatva knk- kula ti." Naiiu sllaiii — pe — uposatlio — pe — bhavana — pe — brah- macarij'aiii itthaphalaiii kantaphalam niannnfiaphalam asecaiiakaphalaip snkhiiidriyam siikhavipakan ti '•* Amanta. Hanci brahinacariyain itthaphalain kantaphalain iiia- iiumiaphalani asecanakaphalam sukhindrij^aiu sukha- vipakain, no vata re vattabbe " Sabbe samkhara anodhi- katva kukkula ti." 8. Sabbe sainkhara anodhikatva kukkula ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttain JBhagavata — " Bukho viveko ^ tutthassa Sutadhanimassa passato Abj'apajjhani sukhain loke Panabhiitesu sahhaiiio. Siikha viragata loke /-, Kamanam samatikkamo V/O ' Asmiinanassa yo vinayo Etain ve paramain sukhain. Tain sukhena sukhain pattain Accantani sukhain eva tain • • • Tisso vijja anuppatta Etam ve2 paramain sukhaii ti.' Atth'eva suttaiito ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbaui " Sal)l:)e sainkhara anodhikatva kukkula ti." K u kk u 1 aka t h a. II, 9. 1. Anupubbabhisama5^o ti ? Amantri. I vipako, P. ~ ce, P. II. y.J KATHAVATTHI-. 213 Aniipubbena sotapattiinaggani bhavetiti ? Ka h'evam vattabbe — pe — Aniipubbena sotapattimaggani bhavetiti ? Amanta. Aniipubbena sotapattiphalain sacchikarotlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Anupubbabhisaniayo ti ? Amanta. Aniipubbena sakadagamimaggain bhavetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — -pe — Aniipubbena sakadagamimaggain bhavetiti ? Amanta. Aniipubbena sakadagamiphalain sacchikarotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Aniipiibbabhisamayo ti ? Amanta. Aniipubbena anagamimaggain bhavetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Aniipubbena anagamimaggain bhavetiti ? Amanta. Anupiibbena anagamiphalain saccliikarotiti V Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — 4. Aniipiibbabhisamayo ti ? Amanta. Aniipubbena arahattamaggani bhavetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Aniipubbena arahattamaggani bhavetiti ? Amanta. Aniipubbena arahattaphalani sacchikarotiti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — 5. Sotapattiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggulo duk- khadassanena kini jahatiti ? Hakkayaditthini vicikicchain silabbataparamasani tade- katthe ca kilese catubhagani jabatiti. Catubhagam sotapanno, catubhaga];! na sotapanno ; catiibhagaii) sotapattiphalappatto patiladdbo adhigato ' I avikato, J\S2. 214 KATHAVATTHU. [11. .9. sacchikato upasampajja viharati, ka^^ena phiisitva ' vi- harati, catubhagam iia kayena phusitva viharati ; catubhagam sattakkhattuparaiiio, kolamkolo, ekabljl,- Buddhe aveccappasadena sainannagato, Dhamme — ^pe — Sainghe — pe — ariyakantehi silehi sainannagato, catii- bhagain na ariyakantehi silehi samannagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe pe — 6. Saniiidayadassanena — pe - nirodhadassanena — pe — maggadassanena kini jahatiti '? Sakkayaditthiin vicikicchain sllabbataparaniasain tade- katthe ca kilese catubhagani jahatiti. Catubhagam sotapanno, catubhagani na sotapaiino ; catubhagam sotapattiphalappatto patiladdho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viha- rati, catubhagani na kayena phusitva viharati ; catu- bhagam sattakkhattuparamo, kohinikolo, ekabljl, Buddhe aveccappasadena samannagato, Dhamme — pe— Samghe — pe — ariyakantehi silehi samannagato, catubhagani na ariyakantehi silehi samannagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo dukkhadassanena kim jahatiti ? Olarikam kamarjigam o|arikaiii byapadani tadekatthe ca kilese catubhagam jahatiti. Catubhagam sakadagaml, catubhagam na sakadagami ; catubhagam sakadagamiphalappatto patiladdho adhi- gato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, catubhagani na kayena phusitva viharatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samudayadassanena — pe — nirodhadassanena — pe — maggadassanena kim jahatiti ? 0}arikain kamaragain ojarikani l)yapadam tad ekattlie ca kilese catubhagam jahatiti. Catubhagani sakadagaml, catubhagain na sakadagaml ; catubhagam sakadagamiphala])patto patiladdho adhigato phussitva, P.B.82. - ekabiji, P. 82- II. 9.] KATHAVATTHU. 215 sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kayeiia phusitva viha- rati, catubha^^am na kayena phusitva viliaratlti ? Na h'evaiii vattabbe — pe- - 8. Anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipaiino puggalo duk- khadassanena kini jahatlti ? Anusahagatam kamaragaia anusahagatain byapadani tadekatthe ca kilese catubhagaiii jahatlti. Catubhagam aiiagami, catubhagam na anagaini ; catii- bhagani anaganiiphalappatto patiladdho adhigato sac- chikato upasampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, catubhagain na kayena phusitva viharati ; catubhagam antaraparinibbayl ^ — pe — upahaccaparinibbayi — pe — asamkharaparinibbayl — pe — sasamkharaparinibbayl — pe uddhamsoto akanitthagami, catubhagain na uddhamsoto na akanitthagami ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Samudayadassanena — pe — nirodhadassanena — pe — maggadassanena kim jahatlti ? Anusahagatain kamaragain anusahagatain b^'apadain tadekatthe ca kilese catubhagain jahatlti. Catubhagain anagami, catubhagain na anagaml ; catu- bhagam anagamiphahippatto patiladdho adhigato sac- chikato upasampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, catubhagam na kayena phusitva viharati ; catubhagam antaraparinibbayl — pe — upahaccaparinibbayi — pe — asanikharaparinibbayl — pe — sasamkharaparinibbayl — pe — uddhamsoto akanitthagami, catubhafram na uddhamsoto na akanitthao^aml ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — 9. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipaniio puggalo dukkha- dassanena kim jahatlti ? Ruparagam ariiparagain inanain uddhaccain avijjain tadekatthe ca kilese catubhagain jahatlti. Catubhagam Araha, catubhagain na Araha ; catubhagain arahattappatto patiladdho adhigato sacchikato upasam- pajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, catubhagain na °parinibbayi, P.S.Sa. 216 KATHAVATTHU. [II. 9. kayena phusitva viharati ; catiibh again vltarago vitadoso vltamoho katakaraniyo ohitabharo anuppattasadattho parikkhlnabhavasanfiojano sainniadanna vimutto ukkhit- tapaligho samkinnaparikho abbulhesiko niraggalo ariyo pannaddhajo pannabharo visanfintto suvijitavijayo, duk- khan tassa parinnatam, samudayo pabino, nirodho sacchikato, maggo bhavito, abbinneyyam abhinnatam, parinfieyyam parinnatam, pahatabbam pablnam, bhave- tabbam bhavitain — pe — sacchikatabbani sacchikatam, catubbagam sacchikatabbam na saccbikatan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samudayadassanena — pe — nirodbadassanena — pe — niaggadassanena kim jahatiti '? Ruparagam aruparagam nianani uddhaccam avijjain tadekatthe ca kilese catubbagam jabatiti. Catubbagam Araha, catubbagam na Araha ; catubhagaiii arahattappatto patiladdho adhigato sacchikato upasam- pajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, catubhagaiii na kayena phusitva viharati ; catubbagam vltarago vitadoso vltamoho katakaraniyo ohitabharo anuppattasadattho parikkhinabhavasaiihojano sammadaiina vimutto ukkhit- tapahgho samkinnaparikho abbulhesiko niraggalo ariyo pannaddhajo pannabharo visahhutto suvijitavijayo, duk- khan tassa parinnatam, samudayo pahino, nirodho sacchikato, maggo bhavito, abhihiieyyam abhiiiiiatam, parihheyyani parinnatam, pahatabbam pahinam, bhave- tabbam bhavitam — pe — sacchikatabbam sacchikatain, catubbagam sacchikatabbani na sacchikatan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 10. Sotapattiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo dukkham dakkhanto " patipannako ti " vattabbo ti ^ '? Amanta. Dukkhe ditthe " phale thito ti " vattabbo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samudayam dakkhanto — pe — nirodhani dakkhanto " patipannako ti " vattabbo ti ? vattabbako ti, P. II. 9. J KATHAVATTHU. iil7 Amanta. Nirodhe ditthe " phale thito ti " vattabbo ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — • 11. Sotapattiphalasacchikirij^aya patipanno piiggalo maggam dakkhanto " patipannako ti " vattabbo, magge ditthe " phale thito ti " vattabbo ti ? Amanta. Dukkham dakkhanto "patipannako ti " vattabbo, dukkhe ditthe " phale thito ti " vattabbo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Maggam dakkhanto " patipannako ti " vattabbo, magge ditthe " phale thito ti " vattabbo ti'? Amanta. Samiidayam dakkhanto ^ — -pe — nirodhani dakkhanto ■"patipannako ti " vattabbo, nirodhe ditthe "phale thito ti" vattabbo ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 12. Sotapattiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo dukkham dakkhanto "patipannako ti " vattabbo, dnkkhe ditthe na vattabbam " phale thito ti " vattabbo ti ? Amanta. Maggam dakkhanto "patipannako ti " vattabbo, magge ditthe na vattabbain " phale thito ti "' vattabbo ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samudayam dakkhanto — pe — nirodhain dakkhanto ""patipannako ti " vattabbo, nirodhe ditthe na vattabbain "" phale thito ti " vattabbo ti ? Amanta. Maggam dakkhanto " patipannako ti " vattabbo, magge ditthe na vattabbain " phale thito ti " vattabbo ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 13. Sotapattiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo dukkhain dakkhanto "patipannako ti '' vattablio dukkhe ditthe na vattabbain " phale thito ti " vattabbo ti? Amanta. Niratthiyani ^ dukkhadassanan ti ? nidattiyam, M. ; niratthiyani, P. So. 218 KATHAVATTHI'. [II. 9.. Na h'evaiii vattabbe — pe — Sainudaj'ani dakkhanto — pe — nirodhain dakkhanta " patipannako ti " vattabbo iiirodhe ditthe na vattabbaiii " phale thito ti " vattabbo ti? Amanta. Niratthiyain nirodhadassanaii ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 14. Dukkhe ditthe cattari saccaiii ditthani hontiti ? Amanta. Dukkhasaccani cattari saccaniti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Rtipakkhandhe aniccato ditthe paiicakkhandha aniccato dittha hontiti ? Amanta. Rupakkhandho paiicakkhandha ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 15. Cakkhayatane aniccato ditthe dvadasayatanani aniccato ditthani hontiti ? Amanta. Cakkhayatanaiu dvadasayatananiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkhudhatnya aniccato ditthaya attliarasa dhatuyo aniccato dittha hontiti '? Amanta. Cakkhudhatii attharasa dhatuyo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkhundriye aniccato ditthe bavlsatindriyani aniccato ditthani hontiti ? Amanta. Cakkhundriyam bavlsatindriyaniti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 16. Catuhi iianehi ^ sotapattiphalain sacchikarotiti ? Amanta. Cattari sotapattiphalaniti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthahi hiinelii sotapattiphalain sacchikarotiti? ' vihiianahi, P. II. 9.] KATHAVATTHU. 219 Amaiita. Attha sotapattiphalaniti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe^ Dvadasahi nanehi sotapattiphalain sacchikarotiti ? Amanta. Dvadasa sotapattiphalaniti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Catucattaiisaya nanehi sotapattiphalain sacchikarotiti ? Amanta. Catucattarlsa sotapattiphalaniti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Sattasattatiya nanehi sotapattiphalain sacchikarotiti ? Amanta. Sattasattati sotapattiphalaniti ? Na h'evain vattal^be — pe — 17. Na vattabbain "Anupubbabhisamayo ti " ? Amanta. Nana vuttain Bhagavata — " Seyyathapi Bhikkhave mahasamuddo anupubbaninno anupubbapono anupubba- pabbharo na ^ ayataken' eva papato, ^ evameva kho Bhik- khave imasmiin Dhammavinaye anupubbasikkhii anu- pubbakiriya annpubbapatipada na ayataken' eva ahhapati- vedho ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena lii anupubbabhisamayo ti. 18. Na vattabbain " Anupubbabhisamayo ti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Anupubbena medhavl Thokain thokain 3 khane khane Kammaro rajatass" ■+ eva Niddhame inalain attano ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi anupubbabhisamayo ti. I P. omits na. ^ pato, P. 3 thokathokam, P.S.Sa. •+ rajakass'eva, P.S^. 220 KATHAVATTHU. [11. \). 1\). Anupiibbabliisaniayo ^ ti ? Amanta. Nanvayasma Gavampati thero bhikklm- etad avoca — - *' 8animnkha me tarn avuso Bhagavato sutaiii, saininukha patiggahltam — ' Yo Bhikkhave dukkham passati, dukkha- samudayani pi so passati, diikkhanirodham pi passati, dukkhanirodhagaminipatipadain pi passati. Yo dukkha- samudayani passati, dukkham pi so passati, dukkhaniro- dhaiii pi passati, dukkhanirodhagamiiiipatipadam pi passati. Yo diikkhanirodhain passati, dukkham pi so passati, diikkhasamudayam pi passati, dukklianirodhaga- miiiipatipadain pi passati. Yo dukkhanirodhagamiiiipa- tipadam passati, dukkham pi so passati, dukkhasamuda- yain pi passati, dukkhanirodhain pi passatiti.' " Atth'eva suttanto ti '? Amanta. Teiia lii ua vattabbam, " Anupubbabhisamayo ti." 20. Anupubbabhisamayo ti '? Amanta. Nanu vuttani Bhagavata — " Balia v'assa dassanasampadaya — pe — cha cabhitha- naiii abhabbo katun ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi iia vattabbani " Aiiupul>])abhisaniaYO ti." 21. Anupubbabhisamayo ti V Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Yasmini Bhikkhave sam- aye arij'asavakassa virajani vitamalani dliammacakkhuiii udapadi, ' yam kihci samudayadhammani, sabban tain nirodhadhammaii ti,' salia dassanuppadcl Bhikkhave ariyasavakassa thii sahhojanani pahlyanti, sakkayaditthi, vicikiccha, sllabbataparamaso ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena lii na vattabbani " Anupubbabliisamayo ti." A 11 u p u b b a b h i s a m a }" a k a t li a . ' M. K. insert na vattabbani. - IjliiJ^I^:!!!!, P. II. 10.] KATHAVATTHU. '221 II. 10. 1. Baddhassa bhagavato voharo lokuttaro ti ? Amanta. Lokuttare sote patihaiiiiati no lokiye, lokuttareua vifi- lianena pativijaiianti no lokiyena, savaka pativijananti no puthujjana ti '.^ Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu Buddhas.sa bhagavato voharo lokiye sote pati- hahhatlti ? Amanta. Hafici Biiddhassa bhagavato voharo lokiye sote pati- haiihati, no vata re vattabbe " Buddhassa bhagavato voharo lokuttaro ti." Nanu Buddhassa bhagavato voharam lokiyena viiiiia- nena pativijanantiti ? Amanta. Haiici Buddhassa bhagavato voharam lokiyena vinfia- nena pativijananti, no vata re vattabbe " Buddhassa bhagavato voharo lokuttaro ti." Nanu Buddhassa bhagavato voharain puthujjana pativi- janantiti ? Amanta. Haiici Buddhassa bhagavato voharam puthujjana pativi- jananti, no vata re vattabbe " Buddhassa bhagavato voharo lokuttaro ti." 2. Buddhassa bhagavato voharo lokuttaro ti ? Amanta. Maggo, phalam, nibbanain, sotapattimaggo, sotapatti- phalam, sakadagamimaggo, sakadagamiphalain, anaganii- maggo, anagamiphalain, arahattamaggo, arahattaplialaiu, satipatthanam, sammappadhanain, iddhipadfi, indriyaiu, balam, bojjhahgo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Buddhassa bhagavato voharo lokuttaro ti ? Amanta. Atthi keci Buddhassa bhagavato voharam sunantiti ? Amanta. 22'2 Kjvthavatthu. [II. 10 Lokuttaro dhammo sotaviniieyyo, sotasmiiii patihan- nati, sotassa apatham ' agacchatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu lokuttaro dbammo na sotaviniiej'yo, na sotasmini patihannati, na sotassa apathani agacchatiti '? Amanta. Hanoi lokuttaro dhaninio na sotaviniieyyo, na sotasmiin patihaniiati, na sotassa apathani agacchati, no vata re vattabbe " Buddhassa bhagavato voharo lokuttaro ti." 4. Buddhassa bhagavato voharo lokuttaro ti ? Amanta. Atthi keci Buddhassa bhagavato vohare rajjeyyun^ ti? Amanta. Lokuttaro dhammo ragatthanlyo, rajanlyo, kamanlyo, madanlyo, bandhanlyo, mucchanlyo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — • Nanu lokuttaro dhammo na ragatthanlyo, na rajamyo, na kamanlyo, na madanlyo, na bandhanlyo, na muc- chanlyo ti '? Amanta. Haiici lokuttaro dhannno na ragatthanlyo, na rajanlyo, na kamanlyo, na madanlyo, na bandhanlyo, na muccha- nlyo, no vata re vattabbe " Buddhassa bhagavato voharo lokuttaro ti." 5. Buddhassa bhagavato voharo lokuttaro ti? Amanta. Atthi keci Buddhassa l)hagavato voharain dusseyyun ti? Amanta. Lokuttaro dhammo dosatthanlyo, kopatthanlyo, pati- ghatthanlyo ti? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Nanu lokuttaro dhannno na dosatthanlyo, na kopattha- nlyo, na patighatthanlyo ti ? Amanta. Hahci lokuttaro dhammo na dosatthanlyo, na kopattha- 1 abadham, P.Sa. ^ dajjo, P. II. 10.] KATHAVATTHU. '2'23 nlyo, na patighatthaniyo, no vata re vattabbe " Buddhassa bhagavato voharo lokuttaro ti." 6. Buddhassa bhagavato voharo lokuttaro ti? Amanta. Atthi keci Buddhassa bhagavato vohare muyheyyun ^ ti? Amanta. Lokuttaro dhamnio mohatthaniyo, annanakarano, acak- khukarano, paniianirodhiko, vighatapakkhiko, anibbana- samvattaniko ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu lokuttaro dhanimo na mohatthaniyo, na aiihana- karano, na acakkhukarano, paiihavuddhiko,- avighata- pakkhiko, nibbanasamvattaniko ti? Amanta. Haiici lokuttaro dhammo na moliatthanlyo, na ahfiana- karano, na acakkhukarano, paiihavuddhiko, avighatapak- khiko, nibbanasamvattaniko, no vata re vattabbe " Bud- dhassa bhagavato voharo lokuttaro ti." 7. Buddhassa bhagavato voharo lokuttaro ti? Amanta. Ye keci Buddhassa bhagavato voharani sunanti, sabbe te maggam bhaventiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ye keci Buddhassa bhagavato voharain sunanti, sabbe te maggam bhaventiti ? Amanta. Balaputhujjana Buddhassa bhagavato voharam sunanti, balaputhujjana maggam bhaventiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Matughataka — pe — pitughataka, arahantaghataka, ruhiruppadaka 3 — pe — samghabhedaka Buddhassa bhaga- vato voharam sunanti, samghabhedaka maggam bhaven- titi? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — muyhantlti, P. 8. 82. ^ buddhiko, P. 82- 3 lohituppiidaka, P. 82. 224 KATHAVATTHU. [II. 10. 8. Labbha sovannayaya^ latthiya dhaniiapunjo pi suvan- napunjo pi acikkhitun ti '? Aiiianta. Evameva Bhagava lokuttarena voharena lokiyam pi lokuttaram pi dhammam voharatiti. Labbha elandiyaya- latthiya dhaniiapunjo pi suvanna- pnhjo pi acikkhitun ti? Am ant a. Evameva Bhagava lokiyena voharena lokiyam pi lokut- taram pi dhammam voharatiti. 9. Buddhassa bhagavato voharo lokiyam voharantassa lokiyo hoti, lokuttarain voharantassa lokuttaro hotiti ? Amanta. Lokiyam voharantassa so lokiye sote patihaiihati, lokut- taram voharantassa lokuttare sote patihaiiiiati ; lokiyam voharantassa lokiyena vihhanena pativijananti, lokuttarain voharantassa lokuttarena viiihanena pativijananti ; lokiyam voharantassa puthujjana pativijananti lokuttaram voharan- tassa savaka pativijanantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 10. Na vattabbam "Buddhassa bhagavato voharo loki- yam voharantassa lokiyo hoti, lokuttaram voharantassa lokuttaro hotiti " ? Amanta. Nanu Bhagava lokiyam pi lokuttaram pi dhammani voharatiti ? Amanta. Haiici Bhagava lokiyain pi lokuttaram pi dhammain voharati, tena vata re vattabbe "Buddhassa bhagavato voharo lokiyam voharantassa lokiyo hoti, lokuttarain voharantassa lokuttaro hotiti." 11. Buddhassa bhagavato voharo lokiyam voharantassa lokiyo hoti, lokuttarain voharantassa lokuttaro hotiti ? Amanta. Maggani voharantassa maggo hoti, amaggam voharan- I sovannamayaya, M.K. = ("landhatiyaya, P. ; elandhayaya, S2. II. 11.] KATHAVATTHTJ. 225 tassa amaggo hoti ; phalam voharantassa phalam hoti, aphalam voharantassa aphalam hoti ; nibbanam voharan- tassa nibbanam hoti, anibbanam voharantassa anibbanain hoti ; samkhatam voharantassa samkhatam hoti, asam- khatam voharantassa asainkhatam hoti ; rupam voharan- tassa rupam hoti, arupain voharantassa arupam hoti ; vedanam voharantassa vedana hoti, avedanam voharan- tassa avedana hoti ; saiihain voharantassa sahna hoti, asahham voharantassa asahha hoti ; samkhare voharan- tassa samkhara honti, asainkhare voharantassa asamkhara honti ; viiihanani voharantassa viiihanam hoti, aviiliianain voharantassa avihhanain hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — V o li a r a hatha. II. 11. 1. Dve nirodha ti ? Amanta. Dve ' dukkhanirodha ti '.* Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve dukkhanirodha ti ? Amanta. Dve nirodhasaccaniti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve nirodhasaccaniti ? Amanta. Dve dukkhasaccanlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve nirodhasaccaniti ? Amanta. Dve samudayasaccaniti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve nirodhasaccaniti ? Amanta. I P.S.So. omit dve, ir, 226 KATHAVATTHU. [II. 11. Dve maggasaccanlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve nirodhasaccaniti ? Amanta. Dve tanani ^ — pe — dve lenaiii, dve saranani, dve paraya- nani, dve accutani,= dve amatani — pe — , dve nibbanaiuti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve nibbananiti ? Anianta. Atthi dvinnam nibbananain iiccanlcata hlnapanltata ukkamsavakamso sTma va bhedo va rajl va antaiika 3 va ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Dve nirodha ti? Amanta. Nanu appatisamkhaniruddhe 4 samkhare patisamkha nirodhentiti '? Amanta. Hanci appatisamkhaniruddhe samkhaje patisamkha nirodhenti, no vata re vattabbe " Dve nirodha ti." 3. Na vattabbam " Dve nirodha ti " ? Amanta. Nanu appatisainkhaniruddha sainkhara accantabhagga, patisamkhaniruddha samkhara accantabhagga ti ? Amanta. Hahci appatisainkhaniruddha samkhara accantabhagga, patisainkhaniruddha samkhara accantabhagga, tena vata re vattabbe "Dve nirodha ti." 4. Dve nirodha ti ? Amanta. Patisamkhaniruddha samkhara ariyamaggam agamma 5 niruddha ti ? Amanta. I tanani, P. - accuttani, P. 3 anantarlka, P. ; anantarika, S2. ^ oddha, P. 5 aramma, P.S2. II. 11.] KATHAVATTHU. 227 Appatisamkhauiruddha samkhara ariyamaggam agamma niruddha ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Dve nirodha ti ? Amanta. Patisamkhaniruddha samkhara na puna uppajjantlti ? Amanta. Appatisamkhaniruddha samkhara na puna uppajjantlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi na vattabbani " Dve nirodha ti." N i r o d h a k a t h a Tassa uddanam Parupaharo, Ahnanam, Kainkha, Paravitarana, Vaclbhedo, Dukkhaharo, Thiti, Kukkula, Samkhara, Eko abhisamayo, Eko voharo, Eko nirodho ti. Dutiyo Vaggo. •228 KATHAVATTHU. [HI. 1. III. 1. 1. Tathagatabalam savakasadharanan ti? Amanta. .Tathagatabalam savakabalain, savakabalam Tathagata- balan ^ ti ? Na b'evam vattabbe — pe — Tathagatabalain savakasadharanan ti ? Amanta. Tail iieva Tathagatabalain tarn savakabalam, tarn savakabalam tam Tathagatabalan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tathagatabalam savakasadharanan ti ? Amanta. Yadisam Tathagatabalam, tadisam savakabalam ; yadisam savakabalam, tadisam Tathagatabalan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tathagatabalam savakasadharanan ti ? Amanta. Yadiso Tathagatassa pubbayogo pubbacariyfi, dham- makkhanam dhammadesana, tadiso savakassa pubbayogo pubbacariya, dhammakkhanain dhammadesana ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Tathagatabalain savakasadharanan ti ? Amanta. Tathagato Jino Sattha Sammasambuddho Sabbahiiu Sabbadassavl ^ DhammasamI Dhammapatisarano ti ? Amanta. Savako Jino Sattha Sammasambuddho Sabbahhu Sabbadassavl DhammasamI Dhammapatisarano ti '^ Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tathagatabalam savakasadharanan ti '? Amanta. Tathagato anuppannassa maggassa uppadeta asaiijatassa ^ P.S.S.2 omit Tathagatabalan ti. 2 odayavi, P. III. 1.] KATHAVATTHU. 229 maggassa saiijaneta anakkhatassa maggassa akkhata maggariiiu maggavidu maggakovido ^ ti ? Amanta. Savako anuppanuassa maggassa uppadeta asafijatassa maggassa safijaneta anakkhatassa maggassa akkhata maggahnu maggavidu maggakovido ti '> Na h'evarn vattabbe — pe — 8. Indriyaparopariyattam yathabhutam hanain Tatha- gatabalam savakasadharaiian ti ? Amanta. Savako sabbanhu sabbadassavl ti ? Na h'evarn vattabbe — pe — 4. Savako thanathanam janatiti ? Amanta. Hanoi savako thanathanam janati, tena vata re vattabbe "Thanathanam yathabhiitam iianam Tathagatabalam savakasadharaiian ti." 5. Savako atltaiiagatapaccuppannanam kammasama- dananam thanaso hetuso vipakam janatiti ? Amanta. Hanoi savako atltaiiagatapaccuppannanam kamma- samadananam thanaso hetuso vipakam janati, tena vata re vattabbe " Atltanagatapaccuppamianam kammasama- dananam thanaso hetuso vipakam yathabhutam fianam Tathagatabalam savakasadharaiian ti." 6. Savako sabbatthagaminipatipadam janatiti "? Amanta. Hanoi savako sabbatthagaminipatipadam janati, tena vata re vattabbe " Sabbatthagaminipatipadam yatha- bhiitam iianam Tathagatabalam savakasadharaiian ti." 7. Savako anekadhatum nanadhatum lokam janatiti? Amanta. Hanoi savako anekadhatuni nanadhatum lokain janati, tena vata re vattabbe " Anekadhatuni nanadhatum lokaiu yathabhutam fianam Tathagatabalam savakasadharaiian ti." kovidho, P.S, 230 KATHAVATTHU. [III. 1. 8. Savako sattanam nanadhimuttikatarn janatiti '? Amanta. Hanci savako sattanain nanadhimuttikatam janati, tena vata re vattabbe " Sattanam nanadhimuttikatam yatha- bhutam rianam Tathagatabalam savakasadharanan ti." 9. Savako jhanavimokkhasamadhisamapattinain ' sam- kilesam vohanam vutthanam ianatlti'? • • • • • ti Amanta. Hanoi savako jhanavimokkhasamadhisamapattinain samkilesaiu vohanam vutthanam janati, tena vata re vattabbe " Jhanavimokkhasamadhisamapattinam saiii- kilesam vohanam vutthanam yathabhutani nanaiii Tathagatabalam savakasadharanan ti." 10. Savako pubbenivasanussatini janatiti ? Amanta. Hanoi savako pubbenivasanussatini janati, tena vata re vattabbe " Pubbenivasanussatini yathabhutani iianani Tathagatabalam savakasadharanan ti." 11. Savako sattanam cutupapatani janatiti ? Amanta. Hanoi savako sattanaiu cutupapatani janati, tena vata re vattabbe " Sattanam outupapatain yathabhutani iianani Tathagatabalam savakasadharanan ti." 1'2. Nanu Tathagatassapi ~ asava khina, savakassapi asava khina ti '? Amanta. Atthi kifici nanakaraiiam Tathagatassa va savakassa va asavakkhayena va asavakkhayain vimuttiya va vimiittiti ? N'atthi. Hanoi n'atthi kihci nanakaranani Tathagatassa vil savakassa va asavakkhayena va asavakkhayain vimuttiya va vimutti, tena vata re vattabbe " Asavanani khaye yatlifi- l)hutam nanam Tathagatabalam savakasadharanan ti." 13. Asavanam khaye yathabhutani nanain Tathagata- balam savakasadharanan ti '? 1 viniokha°, P.S2. 2 Tathagatassati, P.S2. III. 1.] KATHAVATTHU. 231 Amanta. Thanatbane yathabhutain nanain Tathagatabalam savakasadharanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Asavanain khaye yathabhutaiii fianam Tathagatabalam savakasadharanan ti ? Amanta. Sattanam cutvipapate yathabhutam hanani Tathagata- balam savakasadharanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 14. Thanathane yathabhutam iianani Tathagatabalam savaka-asadharanan ti ? Amanta. Asavanam khaye yathabhutam hanain Tathagatabalam savaka-asadharanan ti *? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Sattanam cutupapate yathabhutam iianam Tathagata- balaru savaka-asadharanan ti ? Amanta. Asavanain khaye yathabhutam hanam Tathagatabalam savaka-asadharanan ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — 15. Indriyaparopariyattam yathabhutam hanam Tatha- gatabalani savaka-asadharanan ti '? Amanta. Thanathane yathabhutam hanam Tathagatabalam savaka-asadharanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Indriyaparopariyattain yathabhiitani iianani Tatha- gatabalam savaka-asadharanan ti ? Amanta. Asavanam khaye yathjibhiitain hanani Tathagatabalani savaka-asadharanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 16. Thanathane yathabhutam iianam Tathagatabalam savakasadharanan ti ? Amanta. Indriyaparopariyattam yathabhutain iianam Tathagata- balam savakasadharanan ti ? 232 KATHAVATTHU. [HI. 2. Na h'evain vattabbe — pe- — Asavanam khaye yathabhutam fianaiu Tathagatabalaiu savakasadharanan ti ? Amanta. Indriyaparopariyattaiii yathclbhutam iiauam Tathagata- balam savakasadharanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — B a 1 a k a t h fi . ITT. 2. 1. Thanathane yathril)hutani nauain Tathagatabalam ariyan ti ? Amanta. Maggo phalam nibbanaiu sotapattiniaggo sotapat- tiphalam sakadaganiimaggo sakadagamiphalain anagami- maggo anagamiphalaiii arahattamaggo arahattaphalain satipatthanam sanimappadhanain iddhipada indriyani l)alam bojjhango ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Thanathane yathabhutam hanani Tathagatabalam ariyan ti ? Amanta. Suhhatarammanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Suhhatarammanan ti ? Amanta. Thanathanah ca manasikaroti, suhhatah ca manasi- karotlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Thanathanah ca manasikaroti, suhhatah ca manasi- karotlti ? Amanta. Dvinnam phassanain dvinnam cittfmain samodhanain hotiti ? III. 2.] KATHAVATTHU. 2813 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Thanathane yathabhutam iianam Tathagatabalam arij^an ti? Amanta. Animittarammanam — pe — appanihitarammanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Appanihitarammanan ti ? Amanta. Thanathanah ca manasikaroti, appanihitan ca manasi- karotlti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Thanathanaii ca manasikaroti, appanihitan ca manasi- karotiti ? Amanta. Dvinnam phassanain dvinnam cittanam samodhcinam liotiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Satipatthana ariya sm~ihatarammana ti ? Amanta. Thanathane yathabhutam hanam Tathagatabalam ariyam snfihatarammanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Satipatthana ariya animittarammana— pe— appanihita- rammana ti ? Amanta. Thanathane yathabhutam hanam Tathagatabalam ariyam appanihitarammanan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Sammappadhana, iddhipada/ indriya, bala, bojjhai'iga ariya suhhatarammana ti ? Amanta. Thanathane yathabhutam hanam Tathagatabalam ariyam suhhatarammanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Bojjhahga ariya animittarammana — pe — appanihita- rammana ti ? I iddbippada, P.H. 234 KATHAVATTHU. [III. I. Ainanta. Thanathane yathabhiitam nanam Tathagatabalaiii ariyain appanihitaranimanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Thanathane yathabhiitam nanam Tathagatabalaiii ariyani, na vattabbam " smmatarammanan ti " '? Amanta. Satipatthana ariya, na vattabba " smmatarammana ti"? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tlianathane yathabhiitam nanam Tathagatabalaiii ariyani, na vattabbam " animittarammanain — pe — appaniliitarammanan ti " ? Amanta. Satipatthana ariya, na vattabba " appanihitarammana ti"? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Thanathane yathabhutani iianara Tathagatabalaiii ariyani, na vattabbani " siihiiatarammaiiam — pe — animittarammanain — pe — aj)panihitarammaiian ti " '? Amanta. Sammappadhana — pe — -boijliahga ariya, na vattabbfi ■" appanihitarammana ti " ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Sattanam cutiipapate yathabhutani nanam Tatha- gatabalaiii ariyan ti V Amanta. Maggo phalam nibbanam sotapattimaggo sotapatti- phalaiii sakadagamimaggo sakadagamiphalam anagami- maggo anagamiphalain arahattamaggo arahattaphalaiii satipatthanam sammappadhanam iddhipada indriyaiii balam bojjhango ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — 8. Sattanaiii cutupapate yathabhutam hanaiii Tatha- gatabalaiii ariyan ti? Amanta. Sufifiatarammaiian ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — III. 2.] KATHAVATTHU. 235 Sunnatarammanan ti ? Amanta. Sattanam ciitupapatan ca manasikaroti, sunnatan ca manasikarotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sattanam cutupapatafi ca manasikaroti, sunnatan ca manasikarotiti ? Amanta. Dvinnam phassanam dvinnam cittanam samodhanain hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 9. Sattanam cutupapate yathabhutam nanam Tatha- gatabalam ariyan ti? Amanta. Animittarammanam — pe — appanihitarammanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Appanihitarammanan ti ? Amanta. Sattanarn ciitupapatan ca manasikaroti, appanihitan ca manasikarotiti '? Na h'evarn vattabbe — pe — Sattanam cutupapatafi ca manasikaroti, appanihitan ca manasikarotiti '? Amanta, Dvinnani phassanam dvinnam cittanam samodlianain hotiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 10. Satipatthana ariya suhfiatarammana ti '? Amanta. Sattanam cutupapate yathabhutam hanam Tathagata- balam ariyam sunnatarammanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Satipatthana ariya animittarammana — pe — appanihita- rammana ti ? Amanta. Sattanani cutupapate yathabhutam hanam Tathagata- balam ariyam appanihitarammanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 236 KATHAVATTHU. [III. 2. 11. Sammappadhana, iddhipada, indriya, bala, boj- jhaiiga ariya sunnatarammana ti? Amanta. Sattaiiam cutupapate yathabhutam nanam Tathagata- balaiii ariyam sunnatarammanan ti? Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — Bojjhaiiga ariya animittaramniana — pe — appanihita- rammana ti ? Amanta. Sattaiiaiu cutupapate yathabhutam fianam Tathagata- balam ariyam appanihitarammanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 12. Sattanam cutupapate yathabhutam nanam Tatha- gatabalam ariyam, na vattabbam "sunnatarammanan ti"? ' Amanta. Satipatthana ariya, na vattabba " sunnatarammana ti " ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sattanam cutupapate yathabhutam nanam Tathagata- balam ariyam, na vattabbani " animittarammanam — pe — - appanihitarammanan ti " ? Amanta. Satipatthana ariya, na vattabba " appanihitarammana ti"? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sattanam cutupapate yathabhutam nanam Tathagata- balani ariyam, na vattabbam " suhnatarammanam — pe — animittarammanam — pe — appanihitarammanan ti " ? Amanta. Sammappadhana — pe — bojjhaiiga ariya, na vattabba ''appanihitarammana ti " ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 18. Asavanam khaye yathabhutam hanaui Tathagata- balain ariyan ti ? Amanta. Thanathane yathabhutam nanam Tathagatabalam ariyan ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — III. 2. J KATHAVATTHU. '237 Asavanam khaye yathabhutam iianam Tathagatabalara ariyan ti? Amanta. Sattanam cutupapate yathabhutam nanam Tathagata- balam ariyan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 14. Thanathane yathabhutam nanam Tathagatabalam na vattabbam " ariyan ti " ? Amanta. Asavanam khaye yathabhutam nanam Tathagata])alaiii na vattabbam " ariyan ti " ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sattanam cutupapate yathabhutam nanam Tathagata- balam na vattabbam " ariyan ti " ? Amanta. Asavanain khaye yathabhutam iianain Tathagatabalani na vattabbam " ariyan ti " '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 15. Asavanam khaye yathabhutam nanam Tathagata- balain ariyam suhhatarammanan ti ? Amanta. Thanathane yathabhutam nanam Tathagatabalani ariyam sunhatarammanan ti '? Amanta. Asavanam khaye yathabhutani nanam Tathagatabalam ariyarn animittarammanam — pe — appanihitarammanan ti ? Amanta. Thanathane yathabhutam hanain Tathagata])a]ani ari- yam appanihitarammanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Asavanain khaye yathabhutani nanam Tathagatabalani ariyam suhfiatarammanam — pe — animittarammanain — pe — appanihitarammanan ti '> Amanta. Sattanam cutupapate yathabhutam nanam Tatliagata- balain ariyain appanihitarammanan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe -■ 288 KATHAVATTHU. [III. 3. IG. Tliiinathane yathabhutam nanam Tathagatabalam ariyam na vattabbam " sunnatarammanan ti " ? Amanta. Asavanam khaye yathabhutam nanam Tathagatabalam ariyam na vattabbam " siihhatarammanan ti " ? N a h'evam vattabbe — pe — Thanathane yathabhutam nanam Tathagatabalam ari- yam na vattabbam " animittarammanam — pe — appani- hitarammanan ti " ? Amanta. Asavanam khaye yathabhutain nanam Tathagatabalam ariyam na vattabbam " appanihitarammanan ti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sattanam cutupapate yathabhutam hanaiii Tathagata- balam ariyam na vattabbaiii " suhhatarammanam — pe — animittarammanam — pe — appanihitarammanan ti " ? Amanta. Asavanam khaye yathabhutam nanam Tathagatabalam ariyam na vattabbam " appanihitarammanan ti " ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — A r i y a n t i k a t h a . III. 3. 1. Saragam cittam vimuccatiti? Amanta. Eagasahagatam ragasahajatam ragasamsattham raga- sampayuttam ragasahabhu raganuparivatti akusalam ^ lokiyam sasavam sahhojanlyam ganthanlyam oghanlyam yoganlyain nlvaranlyain paramatthain upadaniyain sam- kilesikam - cittam vimuccatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Saphassani cittam vimuccati, phasso ca cittan ca ubho vimuccantiti ? Amanta. ^ kusalam, P. 2 samkilesiyam, P.S2. III. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 239 Saragain cittam vimuccati, rago ca cittan ca ubho vimuccantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Savedanam — ^pe — sasaniiain — pe — sacetanam — pe — sa- paniiam cittam vimuccati, paniia ca cittan ca iibho vimuccantiti ? Amanta. Saragam cittam vimuccati, rago ca cittan ca ubho vimuccantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — . 3. Saphassain saragam cittani vimuccati, phasso ca. cittan ca ubho vimuccantiti ? Amanta. Eago ca cittan ca ubho vimuccantiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Savedanam saragam — pe — sasanham saragam — pe — sacetanam saragam — pe — sapanhain saragam cittam vimuccati, panfia ca cittan ca ubho vimuccantiti ? Amanta. Eago ca cittan ca ubho vimuccantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Sadosam cittam vimuccatiti ? Amanta. Dosasahagatam dosasahajatam dosasamsatthani dosa- sampayuttam dosasahabhu dosanuparivatti akusalani lokiyani sasavain sahhojanlj^am ganthanlyaiu oghanlyain yoganlyam nlvaranlyain paramattham upadaniyain sam- kilesikam cittam vimuccatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Saphassam cittam vimuccati, phasso ca cittan ca ublio vimuccantiti ? Amanta. Sadosam cittam vimuccati, doso ca cittan ca ubho vimuccantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Savedanam — pe — sasahiiam — pe — sacetanam — pe — sa- pahham cittain vimuccati, panna ca cittan ca ubho vimuccantiti? *240 KATHAVATTHU. [III. 8. Amanta. Sadosam cittam vimuccati, doso ca cittaii ca uhho vimuccantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Saphassam sadosam cittain vimuccati, phasso ca cittan ca ubho vimuccantiti ? Amanta. Doso ca cittaii ca ubho vimuccantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Savedanam sadosam — pe — sasahhain sadosam -pe — sacetanam sadosam — pe — sapaniiam sadosam cittam vimuccati, pahna ca cittan ca ubho vimuccantiti? Amanta. Doso ca cittaii ca ubho vimuccantiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Samoham cittam vimuccatiti ? Amanta, Mohasahagatain mohasahajatani mohasamsatthain mo- hasampayuttam mohasahabhu mohanuparivatti akusalain lokiyam sasavam sahhojanlyain ganthanlyam oghaniyam yoganlyam nivaranlyam paramatthain upadaniyam saniki- lesikam cittam vimuccatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Saphassam cittam vimuccati, phasso ca cittaii ca ubho vimuccantiti ? Amanta. Samoham cittain vimuccati, moho ca cittaii ca ubho vimuccantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Savedanam — pe — sasaiifiaiu — pe — sacetanam — pe — sa- paririam cittam vimuccati, pahha ca cittaii ca ubho vimuccantiti ? Amanta. Samoham cittam vimuccati, moho ca cittaii ca ubho vimuccantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 9. Saphassam samoham cittam vimuccati, phasso ca cittan ca ubho vimuccantiti ? III. 4.] KATHAVATTHU. 241 Amanta. Moho ca cittan ca ubho vimiiccantlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Savedanam samoham— pe — sasannam samoham — pe — sacetanam samoham — pe — sapaiinam samoham cittam vimnccati, pahha ca cittan ca ubho vimuccantiti ? Amanta. Moho ca cittan ca ubho vimuccantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 10. Na vattabbam " Saraoam sadosam samoham cittam • o • • • • vimuccatiti " ? Amanta. Vltaragam vltadosam vitamoham nikkilesam cittam O • • • • • vimuccatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi saragam sadosam samoham cittain vimuccatiti. V i m u 1 1 i k a t h a . III. 4. 1. Vimuttain vimuccamanan ti? Amanta. Ekadesam vimuttam, ekadesam avimuttan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ekadesain vimuttam, ekadesam avimuttan ti ? Amanta. Ekadesain sotapanno, ekadesain na sotapanno ; eka- desam sotapattiphakippatto patiladdho adhigato sacchi- kato upasampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesam na kayena phusitva viharati ; ekadesain sattak- khattuparamo, kolamkolo, ekablji ; Buddhe aveccappasa- dena samannagato, Dhamme — pe — Sainghe — pe — ariya- kantehi sllehi samannagato, ekadesain ariyakantehi sllehi na samannagato ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Ekadesam vimuttam, ekadesam avimuttan ti ? 17 242 KATHAVATTHU. [III. 4. Aiiianta. Ekadesain sakadagami, ekadesaiii na sakadaganil ; ekadesaip sakadagamiphalappatto patiladdho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kayeiia pliusitva viliarati, ekadesam na kayena phusitva viharatiti ? Na li'evain vattabbe — pe — 3. Ekadesain vimuttam, ekadesam avimuttan ti ? Amanta. Ekadesam anagami, ekadesain na anagami ; ekadesam anagamiphalappatto patiladdho adhigato sacchikato upa- sampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesain na kayena phusitva viharati ; ekadesain antaraparinibbayi, upahaccaparinibbayl, asamkharaparinibbayl, sasainkha- raparinibbayl, uddhainsoto akanitthagaml, ekadesam na uddhamsoto na akanitthagaml ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 4. Ekadesam vimuttain, ekadesam avimuttan ti ? Amanta. Ekadesam Araha, ekadesain na Araha ; ekadesain ara- hattappatto patiladdho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharati, ekadesain kayena na phusitva viharati ; ekadesain vltarago vltadoso vltamoho — pe — ekadesain sacchikatabbain sacchikatain, ekadesain sacchikatabbain na sacchikatan ti "? Na h'evain vattabbe — ^pe — 5. Vimuttain vimuccamanan ti ? Amanta. Uppadakkhane vimuttam, vayakkhane ^ vimuccamanan ti? Na h'evain vattab])e — pe — 6. Na vattabbain " Vimuttain vimuccamanan ti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttain Bhagavata — " Tassa evam janato evain passato kamasava pi cittaiii vimuccati, bhavasava pi cittam vimuccati, avijjasava pi cittain vimuccatlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? 1 bhahgakkhane, M. III. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 243 Amanta. Tena hi vimuttam vimuccamanan ti. 7. Vimuttam vimuccamanan ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttain Bhagavata — " So evam samahite citte parisuddhe pariyodate anaiigane vigatupakkilese mudu- bhute kammanlye thite anenjappatte asavanaiu kliaya- nanaya cittam abhininnametlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbaiii " Vimuttam vimuccamanan ti." 8. Atthi cittam vimuccamanan ti "? xALinanta. Atthi cittam rajjamanam dussamanam muyhamanam kilissamanan ti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu rattan c'eva arattan ca, dutthaii c'eva adutthaii ca, mulhaii c'eva amulhan ca, chinnan c'eva achinnaii ca, bhinnan c'eva abhinnaii ca, kataii c'eva akataii cati ? Amanta. Haiici rattan c'eva arattan ca, dutthaii c'eva adutthaii ca, mulhafi c'eva amulhan ca, chinnafi c'eva achinnah ca, bhinnan c'eva abhinnaii ca, kataii c'eva akataii ca, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi cittam vimuccamanan ti." V i m u c c a m a n a k a t h a . III. 5. 1. Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthipariyutthanam pahl- nan ti ? Amanta. Atthamako puggalo sotapanno sotapattiphalappatto patiladdho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthamakassa puggalassa vicikicchapariyutthanam pahinan ti ? Amanta. 244 KATHAVATTHU. [III. 5. Atthamako piiggalo sotapanno sotapattiphalappatto — pe — kayena phusitva viharatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthipariyutthanam pahl- nan ti ? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthanusayo pahino ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthipariyutthanam pahlnan ti? " Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa vicikicchanusayo — pe — sllab- bataparamaso pahino ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Atthamakassa puggalassa vicikicchapariyutthanam pahlnan ti ? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa vicikicchanusayo pahino ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthamakassa puggalassa vicikicchapariyutthanam pahlnan ti ? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthanusayo — pe — sllabbata- paramaso pahino ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthanusayo appahino ti? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthipariyutthanani appahl- nan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthanusayo appahino ti ? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa vicikicchapariyatthanam appahlnan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthamakassa puggalassa vicikicchanusayo — pe — sllab- bataparamaso appaliino ti ? Amanta. III. 5.j KATHAVATTHU. 245 Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthipariyutthanam appahi- nan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthamakassa puggalassa sTlabbataparamaso appahmo ti?" Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa vicikicchapariyiitthanam appahlnan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthipariyutthanam pahl- nan ti '? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthipariyutthanappahanaya maggo bhavito ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthipariyutthanam pahlnan ti? " Amanta, Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthipariyutthanappahanaya satipatthana bhavita — pe — sammappadhana — pe — boj- jhanga bhavita ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthamakassa puggalassa vicikicchapariyutthanam pahT- nan ti ? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa vicikicchapariyutthanappa- hanaya maggo bhavito — pe — bojjhaiiga bhavita ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthipariyutthanappa- hanaya maggo abhavito ti ? Amanta. Amaggena pahinain lokiyena sasavena — pe — samkilesi- kenati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — - Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthipariyutthanappahanaya satipatthana — pe — bojjhaiiga abhavita ti ? Amanta. Amaggena pahinain lokiyena sasavena — pe — samkilesi- kenati ? 246 KATHAVATTHU. [III. 5. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthamakassa piiggalassa vicikicchapariyutthanap- pahanaya maggo abhavito — pe — bojjhanga abhavita ti? Amanta. Amaggena pahlnam lokiyena sasavena — pe — sainkilesi- kenati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Na vattabbam " Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthipa- riyutthanani pahlnan ti " ? Amanta. Uppajjissatiti '? N'nppajjissatiti. Hanoi n'uppajjissati, tena vata re vattabbe " Atthama- kassa puggalassa clitthipariyiitthanam pahinan ti." 8. Na vattabbam " Atthamakassa puggalassa vicikicclia- pariyutthanam pahinan ti " *? Amanta. Uppajjissatiti ? N'nppajjissatiti. Hanoi n'uppajjissati, tena vata re vattabbe " Attha- makassa puggalassa vioikiochapaiiyutthanam pahinan ti." 9. Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthipariyutthanaiu n'np- pajjissatiti katva, pahinan ti ? . Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthanusayo n'nppajjissatiti katva, pahino ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthipariyutthanam n'nppaj- jissatiti katva, pahinan ti ? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa vicikicohanusayo — pe — silab- bataparamaso n'nppajjissatiti katva, pahino ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 10. Atthamakassa puggalassa vicikioohapariyutthrmaiu n'nppajjissatiti katva, pahinan ti ? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa vicikioohanusayo — pe — silab bataparamaso n'nppajjissatiti katva, pahino ti ? III. 6. J KATHAVATTHU. 247 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 11. Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthipariyutthanam n'lippajjissatiti katva, pahlnan ti? Amanta. Gotrabhuno puggalassa ditthipariyutthanaiii n'uppajjis- satlti katva, pahlnan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthamakassa puggalassa vicikicchapariyutthanam n'uppajjjissatiti katva, pahlnan ti '? Amanta. Gotrabhuno puggalassa vicikicchapariyutthanani n'up- pajjissatiti katva, pahlnan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — A 1 1 h a m a k a k a t h a . III. 6. 1. Atthamakassa puggalassa n'atthi saddhindriyan ti ? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa n'atthi saddha ti? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Atthamakassa puggalassa n'atthi viriyindriyam — pe — n'atthi satindriyain — pe — n 'atthi samadhindriyain — pe — n'atthi paiinindriyan ti ? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa n'atthi pahiia ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi saddha ti ? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi saddhindriyan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi viriyani — pe — atthi sati, Jitthi samadhi, atthi paniia ti '? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa Jitthi pannindriyan ti '^ 2-4:8 KATHAVATTHU. [III. 6. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi mano, atthi manin- driyan ti? Am ant a. Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi saddha, atthi saddhiii- driyan ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi mano, atthi manin- driyan ti V Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi panha, atthi paniiin- driyan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi somanassain, atthi somanassindriyam — pe — atthi jlvitam, atthi jivitindriyan ti? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi saddha, atthi saddhin- driyan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi jlvitam, atthi jivitin- driyan ti ? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi viriyam — pe — atthi paniia, atthi pahhindrij^an ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi saddha, n'atthi saddhindriyan ti ? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi mano, n'atthi manin- driyan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi saddha, n'atthi saddhin- driyan ti ■? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi somanassam, n'atthi somanassindriyain — pe — atthi jlvitam, n'atthi jivitin- driyan ti ? III. G.] KATHAVATTHU. 249 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi pafina, n'atthi pannindriyan ti ? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi maiio, n'atthi maiiin- driyam — pe — atthi somanassain n'atthi somanassindriyaip. — pe — atthi jivitam, n'atthi jivitindriyan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — 7. Atthamakassa puggalassa n'atthi saddhindriyan ti ? Amanta. Atthamako puggalo asaddho ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Atthamakassa puggalassa n'atthi viriyindriyan ti? Amanta. x\tthamako puggalo kuslto hlnaviriyo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — ^pe— Atthamakassa puggalassa n'atthi satindriyan ti ? Amanta. Atthamako puggalo mutthassati asampajano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe^pe — Atthamakassa puggalassa n'atthi samadhindriyan ti "/ Amanta. Atthamako puggalo asamahito vibbhantacitto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthamakassa puggalassa n'atthi pannindriyan ti ?" Amanta. Atthamako puggalo duppaiiho elamugo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi saddha, sa ca saddha niyyanika ti? Amanta. Hanci atthamakassa puggalassa atthi saddha, sa ca saddha niyyanika, no vata re vattabbe "Atthamakassa puggalassa n'atthi saddhindriyan ti." Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi viriyani, tail ca viriyam niyyanikam — pe— atthi sati, sa ca sati niyyanika — pe — atthi samadhi, so ca samadhi niyyjiniko — pe — atthi paiifia, sa ca paiifia niyyanika ti ? 250 KATHAVATTHU. [III. 6. Amanta. Hafiei attlianiakassa puggalassa atthi panna, sa ca panfia niyyanika, no vata re vattabbe " Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi pafinindriyan ti." 9. Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa pugga- lassa atthi saddha, atthi saddhiiidriyan ti? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi saddha, atthi saddhin- driyan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa pugga- lassa atthi panfia, atthi pannindriyan ti ? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi panhil, atthi pannin- driyan ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 10. Anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa pugga- lassa — pe — arahattasacchikiriyjiya patipannassa pugga- lassa atthi saddha, atthi saddhindriyani — pe — atthi pahha, atthi pafihindrij'an ti '? Amanta. Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi panfia, atthi panfiin- driyan ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — 11. Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi saddha, n'atthi saddhindriyan ti ? Amanta. Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa pugga- lassa atthi saddha, n'atthi saddhindriyan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi pahha, n'atthi pannin- driyan ti ? Amanta. Sakadcigamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa pugga- lassa atthi pahha, n'atthi pahhindri3'an ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 12. Atthamakassa puggalassa atthi saddha, n'atthi eaddhindriyam — pe — atthi pahha, n'atthi pannindriyan ti V III. 7.] KATHAVATTHU. 251 Amanta. Anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa puggalassa — pe — arahattasacchikiriyaya patipannassa puggalassa attlii panna, n'atthi panfiindriyan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 18. Atthamakassa puggalassa n'atthi panc'indriyaniti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Paiic'iniani Bhikkhave indriyani. Katamani pafica? Saddhindriyain, viriyin- driyam, satindriyam, samadhindriyain, paniiindriyaiu. Iniani kho Bhikkhave pahc'indriyani. Imesam kho Bhikkhave pahcannam indriyanam samatta paripuratta ^ Araha hoti. Tato mudutarehi arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno hoti ; tato mudutarehi anagaml hoti ; tato mudutarehi anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno hoti ; tato mudutarehi sakadagamT hoti ; tato mudutarehi saka- dagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno hoti ; tato mudu- tarehi sotapanno hoti ; tato mudutarehi sotapattiphala- sacchikiriyaya patipanno hoti. Yassa kho Bhikkhave imani paiic'indriyani sabbena sabbaiii sabbatha sabbain n'atthi, tarn aham ' bahiro puthujjanapakkhe ^ thito ti' vadamlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Atthamako puggalo bahiro puthujjanapakkhe thito ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi atthamakassapuggalassa atthi paiic'indriy°ilnlti. Atthamakassa in d r i y a k a t h a . III. 7. 1. Mainsacakkhum dhammuputthaddhani dibbacak- khuni hotiti? " " AmantJi. Manisacakkhuin dibbacakkhuju, dibbacakkhuiu niani- «acakkhun ti ? paripurato, P.Sz. ^ ])iikkli(), P.S, 252 KATHAVATTHU. [III. 7. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Mamsacakkhum dhaminupatthaddhain dibbacakkhum hotiti '? Ainanta. Yadisam mamsacakkhum, tadisam dibbacakkhum; yadisam dibbacakkhum, tadisam mamsacakkhun ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Mamsacakkhum dhammupatthaddham dibbacakkhum hotiti ? Amanta. Tail heva mamsacakkhum tam ^ dibbacakkhum, tarn dibbacakkhum tam mamsacakkhun ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Mamsacakkhuiu dhammupatthaddham dibbacakkhum hotiti? Amanta. Yadiso manisacakkhussa visayo anubhavo gocaro, tadiso dibbassa cakkhussa visayo anubhavo gocaro ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — 2. Mamsacakkhum dhammupatthaddham dibbacakkhum hotiti ? Amanta. Upadinnam hutva anupadinnam hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Upadinnam hutva anupadinnam hotiti ? Amanta. Kamavacaram hutva iTipavacaram hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamavacarani hutva rupavacaraiii hotiti ? Amanta. Rupavacaraiii hutva arupavacaraiu hotiti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Rupavacaraiii hutva arupavacaram hotiti ? Amanta. Pariyapannaiii hutva apariyapannam hotiti V Na h'evam vattabbe — ^pe — T tam om. P.S.S.. III. 7.] KATHAVATTHU. 253 3. Mamsacakkhuin dhaminiipatthaddham dibbacak- khum hotiti ? Amanta. Dibbacakkhum dhaininupatthaddbain mamsacakkhiini hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Mamsacakkhum dhammupatthaddham dibbacakkhum hotiti ? Amanta. Dibbacakkhum dhammupatthaddham pannacakkhuui hotiti ■? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Mamsacakkhum dhammupatthaddham dibbacakkhum hotiti ? Amanta. Dibbacakkhuin dhammupatthaddhani mainsacakkhum hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Mamsacakkhum dhammupatthaddham dibbacak- khum hotiti ? Amanta. Dve'va cakkhuniti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve'va cakkhuniti? Amanta. Nanu tini cakkhimi vuttani Bhagavata, mamsacak- khum, dibbacakkhum, pailhacakkhun ti ? Amanta. Haiici tIni cakkhuni vuttani Bhagavata, mamsacak- khum, dibbacakkhum, pahhacakkhuiii, no vatare vattabbe " Dve'va cakkhuniti " '? Dve'va cakkhuniti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata " Tin'imani Bhikkhave cakkhuni. Katamani tIni ? Mainsacakkhuin, dibba- cakkhuni, pahfuicakkhuni. Imani kho Bhikkliave tIni cakkhuniti." 254 KATHAVATTHU. [III. 8. " Mamsacakkhum dibbacakkhum Pannacakkhum anuttaraiu, Etani tini cakkhuni Akkhasi purisattamo. Mamsacakkhussa uppado Maggo dibbassa cakkhuno, Yatha ca fianam udapadi Paniiacakkhiiip anuttaram . Tassa cakkhussa patilabha Sabbadukkha pamuccatlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi iia vattabbaiii " Dve'va cakkhunlti." Dibbacakkhukatha. III. 8. 1. Maipsasotain dhammupatthaddham dibbasotam hotiti ? Amanta. Mamsasotam dibbasotam, dibbasotam mamsasotan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Mamsasotani dhammupatthaddham dibbasotam hotiti? Amanta. Yadisam mamsasotaiu, tadisam dibbasotam : yadisam dibbasotam, tadisam mamsasotan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Mamsasotani dhammupatthaddham dibbasotam hotiti ? Amanta. Tan heva mamsasotam tain dibbasotam, tarn dibba- sotam tarn mamsasotan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Mamsasotam dhammupatthaddham dibbasotam hotiti ? Amanta. Yadiso mamsacakkhussa visayo anubhavo gocaro, tadiso dibbassa cakkhussa visayo anubhavo gocaro ti? III. 8.] KATHAVATTHU. 255 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Maiiisasotain dbamnmpatthaddham dibbasotaui hotiti ? Am ant a. Upadinnam hutva aiiupadinnain botiti ? Na h'evaui vattabbe — pe — Upadinnam butva aniipadinnani botiti ? Amanta. Kamavacarain butva rupavacarani botiti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamavacaram butvil rupavacarani hotiti ? Amanta. Kupavacaram butva arupavacarani hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Rupavacaram hutva arupavacarani botiti ■' Amanta. Pariyapannam hutva ax^ariyapannaip hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Mamsasotain dhammupatthaddbaiu dibbasotam hotiti ? Amanta. Dibbasotain dhammupatthaddham manisasotaiu hotiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Marasasotam dliammupatthaddham dibbasotain botiti ? Amanta. Ekah heva ^ sotan ti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ekah heva sotan ti '^ Amanta. Nanu dve sotani vuttani Bhagavata, mamsasotam dibbasotan ti ? Amanta. Hahci dvc sotani vuttani Bbagavata, mainsasotaiu dibbasotain, no vata re vattabbe " Ekiifi heva sotan ti." 1) i b b a s o t a k a t b a . ' I'ikiuii yeva, I'.S.So. •256 KATHAVATTHU. [III. 9. III. 0. 1. Yathakammiipafjatani nanam dibbacakkhun ti? Amanta. Yathakaminfipagatan ca nianasikaroti, dibbena cakkhuna rupam passatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Yathakammnpaf^atan ca nianasikaroti, dibbena cakkhnna rupam passatiti ? Amanta. Dvinnam phassanam dvinnam cittanam samodhanam hotiti ? Na h'evarn vattabbe — pe — 2. Yathakammnpagatam nanam dibbacakkhun ti ? Amanta. Ime vata ^ bhonto satta ti ca nianasikaroti, kayaduc- caritena^ samannagata ti ca nianasikaroti, vacTduc- caritena samannagata ti ca nianasikaroti, manoduccari- tena samannagata ti ca nianasikaroti, ariyanam upava- daka ti ca nianasikaroti, micchaditthika ti ca nianasi- karoti, micchaditthikammasamadana ti ca nianasikaroti, te kayassa bheda parani marana apayam duggatim vini- patam nirayam upapanna ti ca nianasikaroti, ime va pana bhonto satta ti ca nianasikaroti, kayasucaritena 3 saman- nagata ti ca nianasikaroti, vacTsucaritena samannagata ti ca nianasikaroti, manosucaritena samannagata ti ca manasikaroti, ariyanam anupavadaka ti ca nianasikaroti, sammaditthika ti ca nianasikaroti, sammaditthikamma- samadana ti ca nianasikaroti, te kayassa bheda param marana sugatim saggani lokam upapanna ti ca manasi- karoti, dibbena cakkhuna rupam passatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Yathakammiipagataiii nanam dibbacakkhun ti ? Amanta. Ime vata bhonto satta ti ca nianasikaroti, — pe — , te ^ tam, P. 2 °carite, P.S. 3 oduccaritena, P. III. 9.] KATHAVATTHU. 257 kayassa bheda param marana sugatim saggam lokaui upa- panna ti ca manasikaroti, dibbena cakkhuna rupam pas- satiti ? Amanta. Dvinnam phassanam dvinnam cittanam saiiiodhanam hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Yathakammupagatam nanam dibbacakkhun ti ? Amanta. Atthi koci adibbacakkhuko dibbacakkhum appatiladdho ^ anadhigato asacchikato yathakammupagatam janatiti ? Amanta. Hanoi atthi koci adibbacakkhuko dibbacakkhuni appati- laddho anadhigato asacchikato yathakammupagatam janati, no vata re vattabbe " Yathakammupagatam hanam dibbacakkhun ti." 4. Yathakammupagatam hanam dibbacakkhun ti ? Amanta. Ayasma Sariputto yathakammupagatam janatiti ? Amanta. Hahci ayasma Sariputto yathakammupagatam janati, no vata re vattabbe " Yathakammupagatam hanam dibba- cakkhun ti." 5. Ayasma Sariputto yathakammupagatam janatiti? Amanta. Atth'ayasmato Sariputtassa dibbacakkhun ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atth'ayasmato Sariputtassa dibbacakkhun ti ? Amanta. Nanu ayasma Sariputto etad avoca — " N'eva pubbenivasaya Napi dibbassa cakkhuno Cetopariyaya iddhiya Sotadhatuvisuddhiya Cutiya upapattiya PanidhI me na vijjatlti." I patio, p.s^. "l8 258 KATHAVATTHU. [III. U). Atth'eva suttanio ti '? Anianta. Tena hi na vattabbain " Yathakammnpagatam nanaia dibbacakkhun ti." Y a t h a k a m in u p a g a t a fi a n a k a t h a . III. 10. 1. Atthi clevesu sainvaro ti? Amanta. Atthi devesii asamvaro ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N' atthi devesii asanivaro ti ? Amanta. N' atthi devesu samvaro ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Nanu asamvara samvaro silam, atthi devesu samvaro ti'? Amanta. Atthi devesu asainvaro, yamha asainvara ^ samvaro silan ti? Na h'evain vattabbe. Ajanahi niggahani : hanci asainvara sainvaro silam, atthi devesu sanivaro, tena vata re vattabbe " Atthi devesu asainvaro, yamha asamvara sainvaro silan ti." Yam tattha vadesi ' ' Vattabl^e kho ' asainvara sain- varo silam, atthi devesu samvaro,' iio ca vattabbe * atthi devesu asainvaro yamha asainvara samvaro silan ti,' " miccha. No ce pana vattabbe " Atthi devesu asainvaro yamha asamvara samvaro silan ti," no vata re vattabbe " Asam- vara samvaro silam, atthi devesu sainvaro ti." Yam tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho 'asainvara samvaro silam, atthi devesu samvaro,' no ca vattabbe ' atthi devesu asamvaro yamha asamvara samvaro silan ti,' " miccha. " asamvaro, P. III. 10.] KATHAVATTHU. 259 • 3. Atthi manussesu samvaro, atthi tattha asaravaro ti ? Amanta. Atthi devesu samvaro, atthi tattha asamvaro ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi devesu samvaro, n'atthi tattha asamvaro ti ? Amanta. Atthi manussesu samvaro, n'attlii tattha asamvaro ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Atthi devesu panatipata veramaniti ? Amanta. Atthi devesu panatipato ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi devesu suramerayamajjapamadatthana verama- niti ? Amanta. Atthi devesu suramerayamajjapamadatthanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. N'atthi devesu panatipato ti ? Amanta. N'atthi devesu panatipata veramaniti ? Na h'evarn vattabbe — pe — N'atthi devesu suramerayamajjapamadatthanan ti '? Amanta. N'atthi devesu suramerayamajjapamadatthana verama- niti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Atthi manussesu panatipata veramani, attlii tattha panatipato ti '? Amanta. Atthi devesu panatipata veramani, atthi tattha panati- pato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Atthi manussesu suramerayamajjapamadatthana vera- mani, atthi tattha suramerayamajjapamadatthanan ti ? Amanta. Atthi devesu suramerayamajjapamadatthana veramani, atthi tattha suramerayamajjapainadatthanan ti ? Na li'evarn vattabbe — pe — 2G0 KATHAVATTHU. [III. 11. 7. Atthi devesu panatipata veramanl, ii'atthi tattha paiiatipato ti '? Amaiita. Atthi manussesu panatipata veramanl, n'atthi tattha panatipato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi devesu suramerayamajjapamadatthana veramanl, n'atthi tattha suramerayamajjapamadatthanan ti ? Amanta. Atthi manussesu suramerayamajjapamadatthana vera- manl, n'atthi tattha suramerayamajjapamadatthanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. N'atthi devesu samvaro ti ? Amanta. Sabbe deva panatipatino adiimadayino kiimesu miccha- carino musavadino suramerayamajjapamadatthayino ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi atthi devesu samvaro ti. S a m V a r a k a t h a . III. 11. 1. Asahhasattesu saiiha atthiti? Amanta. Sahhabhavo ^ sahhagati sanhasattavaso sanfiasanisaro sannayoni sannattabhavapatilabho - ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Nanu asaiiiiabhavo asanhagati asahiiasattavaso asafma- sainsaro asannayoni asanhattabhavapatilabho ti ? Amanta. Hahci asahnabhavo asahnagati asahnasattavaso asanna- sainsaro asannayoni asaiinattabhavapatilabho, no vata re vattabbe " Asahnasattesu sanna atthiti." 2. Asannasattesu saima atthiti ? I saiinasavo, P. = "attatavapatilabho, P.Sa. III. 11.] KATHAVATTHU. 261 Amanta. Pancavokarabhavo gati sattavaso samsaro yoni atta- bhavapatilabho ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Nanu ekavokarabhavo gati sattavaso samsaro yoni atta- bhavapatilabho ti '? Amanta. Hand ekavokarabhavo gati sattavaso samsaro yoni attabhavapatilabho, no vata re vattabbe " Asaniiasattesu saiina atthlti." 3. Asaiiiiasattesii saniia attliTti '? Amanta. Taya safiiiaya sannakaranlyani karotiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Manussesu saniia atthi, so ca saniiabhavo sanfiagati saiiiiasattavaso safmasamsaro saniiayoni saiiiiattabhava- patilabho ti ? Amanta. Asaiinasattesu safina atthi, so ca sahnabhavo sahhagati saiifiasattavaso saiinasamsaro sannayoni saiiiiattabhava- patilabho ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Manussesu sanha atthi, so ca paiicavokarabhavo gati sattavaso samsaro yoni attabhavapatilabho ti ? Amanta. Asaiihasattesu sahha atthi, so ca paiicavokarabhavo gati sattavaso sainsaro yoni attabhavapatilabho ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Manussesu sahna atthi, taya sannaya sahhakaranlyani karotiti '? An:ianta. Asaiihasattesu sahha atthi, taya saiihaya sahhiikarani- yani karotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Asahhasattesu saniia atthi, so ca asahhabhavo asah- nagati asahfiasattavaso asaiiiiasainsaro asahhayoni asah- nattabhavapatilabho ti ? Amanta. 262 KATHAVATTHU. [III. H. Maimssesu sanna atthi, so ca asamiabhavo — pe — asafi- nattabhavapatilabho ti ? Na h'evaiii vattabbe — pe — Asannasattesu sauna atthi, so ca ekavokarabhavo gati — pe — attabhavapatilabho ti '? Amanta. Manussesu sanna atthi, so ca ekavokarabhavo gati — pe — attabhavapatilabho ti ? Na h'evaiu vattabbe— pe — Asaimasattesii sanna atthi, na ca taya sahhaya sanna- karanlyam karotiti ? Amanta. Manussesu saiiha atthi, na ca taya safihaya sanhakara- nlyam karotiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 5. Na vattabbain " Asahhasattesu sahfia atthiti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Santi Bhikkhave Asahiia- satta nama deva, sahiiuppada ca pana te deva tamha kaya cavantlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi Asahhasattesu sahha atthiti. G. Asahhasattesu sahha atthiti ? Kahci kale atthi kahci kale n'atthlti. Kahci kale sahhasatta, kahci kale asahhasatta ; kahci kale sahhabhavo, kahci kale asahhabhavo ; kahci kale pahcavokarabhavo, kahci kale ekavokarabhavo ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe - 7. Asahhasattesu sahhii kahci kale atthi, kahci kale n'atthlti ? Amanta. Kam kalam atthi, kam kalam n'atthlti? Cutikale uppattikale atthi, thitikale n'atthlti. Cutikale ca uppattikale sahhasatta, thitikale asahha- satta ; cutikale uppattikale sahhabhavo, thitikale asah- habhavo ; cutikale uppattikale pahcavokarabhavo, thiti- kale ekavokarabhavo ti ? II T. 12.] KATHAVATTHU. 263 Na h'evaiu vattabbe — pe — A s a fi ii a k a t h a . III. 12. 1. Nevasanfianasarifiayatane na vattabbain " Saniia atthiti"? Amanta. Asaiinabhavo asannagati asaiiiiasattavaso asannasamsaro asanfiayoni asaniiattabhavapatilabho ti ? Amanta. Haiici asannabhavo asannagati — pe — asannattabhava- patilabho, no vata re vattabbe " Nevasannanasannayatane na vattabbam ' Sanna atthiti.' " 2. Nevasannanasannayatane na vattabbain " Sanna atthiti " '? Amanta. Ekavokarabhavo gati — pe -attabhavapatilabho ti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu catuvokarabhavo gati — pe — attabhavapatila])ho ti? Amanta. Hahci catuvokaral^havo gati — pe — attabhavapatilabho, no vata re vattabbe " Nevasaiihanasahhayatane na vat- tabbain ' Sahha athlti.' " 3. Asaiihasattesa na vattabbain " Sahhii atthi," so ca asaMabhavo asannagati asahhasattavaso asahhasainsaro asaiiiiayoni asaiihattabhavapatilabho ti '! Amanta. Nevasahiianasahhayatane na vattabbain " Sahha, atthi," so ca asannabhavo asannagati asahhasattavaso asahhasaiii- saro asahhayoni asahhattabhavapatilabho ti '^ Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Asahhasattesu na vattabbain " Sahha atthi," so ca ekavo- karabhavo gati — ^pe— attal)havapatilabho ti / Amanta. 264 KATHAVATTHU. [III. 12. Nevasannanasannayatane na vattabbam " Sannaatthi," so ca ekavokarabhavo gati — pe — attabhavapatilabho ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Nevasannanasannayatane na vattabbam " Sanna at- thi," so ca sannabhavo sannagati — pe — safinattabhava- patilabho ti ? Amanta. Asannasattesu na vattabbam " Sanna atthi," so ca san- nabhavo sannagati — pe — safinattabbavapatilabho ti? Na, h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nevasannanasannayatane na vattabbam " SaMa at- thi," so ca catuvokarabhavo gati — pe — attabhavapatilabho ti? Amanta. Asahiiasattesu na vattabbam " Saiina atthi," so ca catuvokarabhavo gati — pe — attabhavapatilabho ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Nevasaimanasaiinayatane na vattabbam " Sanna at- thlti ? " Amanta. . Nann nevasanhanasaiifiayatanam catuvokarabhavo ti ? Amanta. Haiici nevasaiinanasafinaj^atanam catuvokarabhavo, no vata re vattabbe " Nevasaiinanasaiiiiayatane na vattabbam ' Sanna atthlti.' " 6. Nevasahnanasahiiayatanam catuvokarabhavo, neva- sannanasannayatane na vattabbam " Sanna atthlti? " Amanta. Akasanancayatanam catuvokarabhavo, akasanaiicaya- tane na vattabbam " Samia atthlti"? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nevasannanasaniiayatanain catuvokarabhavo, nevasaii- nanasaiinayatane na vattabbani "Sanna atthlti"? Amanta. Vinilanaiicayatanam — pe — akincahhayatanam catuvoka- rabhavo, akihcahhayatane na vattabbam " Sahha atthlti " ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — III. 12."] KATHAVATTHU. 265 7. Akasanancayatanam catuvokarabhavo, atthi tattha sanna ti ? Amanta. Nevasannanasaniiayatanam catuvokarabhavo, atthi tat- tha samia ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Viiiiianancayatanam — pe — akincaniiay atanam catuvo- karabhavo, atthi tattha saiina ti ? Amanta. Nevasamianasahhayatanam catuvokarabhavo, atthi tat- tha sahiia ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Nevasahnanasaniiayatane na vattabban^i " Sahha at- thlti va n'atthiti va ti '"? Amanta. Nanu nevasailnanasahhayatanam catuvokarabhavo ti ? Amanta. Haiici nevasaiinanasannayatanam catuvokarabhavo, no vata re vattabbe " Nevasannanasaniiayatane na vattabbani ' Sanna atthiti va n'atthiti va ti.' " 9. Nevasaiiiianasahfiayatanam catuvokarabhavo, neva- saiinanasaiinayatane na vattabbam '" Saiina atthiti va n'atthiti va ti " '? Amanta. Akasanahcayatanam — pe — vihiianaricayatanam — pe — akihcaiinayatanam catuvokarabhavo, akincahiiayatane na vattabbam " Samia atthiti va n'atthiti va ti." 10. Akasanancayatanain catuvokarabhavo, atthi tattha samia ti ? Amanta. Nevasanhanasanfiayatanani catuvoka]"abhavo, atthi tat- tlia sanna ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vifihanaficayatanam — pe — akincaiihayatanani catuvoka- rabhavo, atthi tattha saiiiia ti ? Amanta. Nevasaniianjlsannayatanaui catuvokara])havo, attlii tat- tlia saiina ti ? 266 KATHAVATTHU. [III. 12. Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 11. Nevasanfianasanfiayatane na vattabbaiii " Sanaa atthiti va n'atthiti va ti " ? Anianta. Nanu nevasafifianasannayatanan ti ? Amanta. Haiici nevasannanasannayatanam, tena vata re vattabbe " Nevasannanasanfiavatane na vattabbain ' Safina atthiti va n'atthiti va ti.' " 12. Nevasanhanasahhaj^atanan ti katva, nevasahhana- sannayatane na vattabbam " Sahha atthiti va n'atthiti vati"? Amanta. Adukkhamasukha vedana ti katva, adukkhamasukhaya ' vedanaya^ na vattabbain "Vedana ti va, avedana ti vil ti"? Na h'evam vattabl^e — pe — N e V a s a n f I a n a s a n h a y a t a n a k a t h a . T [I t i y o V a g g o . Balani sadharanaiu, Ariyani, Saragam cittam vinmccafci,. Vimuttam vimuccamanani, Atthi cittam vimuccama- nam, Atthamakassa puggalassa ditthipariyutthanaiu pahi- nam, Atthamakassa puggalassa n'atthi pahcindriyani, Cakkhum, Botain dhammupatthaddhain, Yathakammu- pagatahanani, Devesu sanis'aro, Asafinasattesu sahna, evameva bha- vaggan ti. ' .sukha, r.K. ^ vedana, P.S. IV. l.J KATHAVATTHU. 267 IV. 1. 1. Gihi^'ssa Araha tiV Amanta. Atthi Arahato gihisafinojanaii ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N'atthi Arahato gihisannojanan ti '? Amanta. Haiici n'atthi Arahato gihisanhojanam no vata re. vat- tabbe " Gihi'ssa Araha ti." 2. Gihi'ssa Araha ti ? Amanta. Nanu Arahato oihisahhojanam pahlnani ucchinnamu- 1am talavatthiikatam anabhavam katam ayatiiji aniippa- dadhamman ti ? Amanta. Hahci Arahato gihisanhojanam pahlnam ucchinnamu- 1am talavatthukatam anabhavam katam ayatini anuppa- dadhammam, no vata re vattabl^e " Gihi'ssa Araha ti." 3. Gihi'ssa Araha ti ? Amanta. Atthi koci gihl gihisahhojanam appahaya ditth'eva dhamme dnkkhass'antaiu karotiti ? N'atthi. Hahci n'atthi koci gihl gihisahhojanam appahaya dit- th'eva dhamme dukkhass'antam karoti, no vata re vattabbe " Gihi'ssa Araha ti." 4. Gihi'ssa Araha ti ? Amanta. Nanu Vacchagotto paribbajako Bhagavantam etad avoca — " Atthi nu kho ])ho Gotama koci gihi gihisahhoja- nam appahaya kayassa bheda dukkhass'antam karotiti"? " N'atthi kho Vaccha koci gihl gihisahhojanain appahaya kayassa bheda dukkhass'antain karotiti." Attli'eva sut- tanto ti ? I Gihi, P.S,. 268 KATHAVATTHU. [IV. 2. Amanta. Tena hi iia vattabbam " Gihi'ssa Araha ti." 5. Gihi'ssa Araha ti '? Amanta. Araha methunani dhammain patiseveyya, methunam dhammam uppadeyya, puttasambadhasayanain ajjhava- seyya, kasikacandanain paccanubhaveyya, malagandha- vilepanam dhareyya, jataruparajatain sadiyeyya, aje|akam patiganheyya, knkkiitasnkaram patiganheyya, hatthigavas- savalavam patiganheyya, tittiravattakamorakapiiijalam ^ patiganheyya, pitavantavalamoHkam ~ dhareyya, odatani vatthani dlghadasani dhareyya, yavajlvam agariyabhuto assati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Na vattabbam " Gihi'ssa Araha ti " '> Amanta. Nanu Yaso kiilaputto, Uttiyo gahapati, Setu manavo gihissa bj^aiijanena arahattaiii patta ti '? Amanta. Hanoi Yaso kulaputto, Uttiyo gahapati, Setu manavo gihissa byahjanena arahattam patta, tena vata re vattabbe " Gihi'ssa Araha ti." G i li T ' s s a A r a h a t i k a t h a . IV. 2. 1. 8aha uppattiya ArahJl ti ? Amanta. Saha uppattiya sotapaimo hotiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Saha uppattiya Araha ti ? ^ pihjarani, M. ' cittavattandhavalamoH, P ; cittavandavalamohm, M. IV. 2.] KATHAVATTHU. 269 Aiuanta. Salia uppattiya sakadagami hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Saha uppattiya Araha ti ? Aiuanta. Saha uppattiya anagainl hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — . 2. Saha uppattiya sotapaniio na hotiti ? Amanta. Hahci saha uppattiya sotapanno na hoti, no vata re vattabbe " Saha uppattiya Araha ti." Saha uppattiya sakadagami na hotiti '? Amanta. Haiici saha uppattiya sakadagami na hoti, no vata re vattabbe " Saha uppattiya Araha ti." Saha uppattiya anagami na hotiti '? Amanta. Haiici saha uppattiya anagami na hoti, no vata re vattabbe " Saha uppattiya Araha ti." 8. Saha uppattiya Araha ti '? Amanta. Sariputto thero saha uppattiyii xA.raha ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Maha Moggallano thero — pe — Maha Kassapo thero — pe — ^Maha Kaccayano thero — pe — Maha Kotthiko thero — • pe— Maha Panthako '■ thero saha upjiattiya Araha ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Sariputto thero na saha uppattiya Araha ti? Amanta. Haiici Sariputto thero na saha uppattiya Araha, no vata re vattabbe " Saha uppattiya Araha ti." Maha Moggallano thero — pe — Maha Kassapo thero, Maha Kaccayano thero, Maha Kotthiko thero — pe — Maha Panthako thero na saha uppatti^^a Araha ti ? Amanta. I Mahabandhiko, V. '270 KATHAVATTHU. [IV. 2. Hanoi Maha Panthako there na saba upapattiya Araha, no vata re vattabbe " Saba uppattiya Araba ti." 5. Saba uppattiya Araba ti ? Amanta. Uppattesiyena cittena arabattani saccbikaroti lokiyena •sasavena — pe — samkilesikenati '? Na b'evam vattabbe — pe — Saba uppattiya Araba ti *? Amanta. U ppattesiyam cittam niyyanikain khayagam! bodbagami apacayagami anasavani — pe — asamkilesikan ti ? Na b'evam vattabbe — pe^ — Nanu uppattesiyam cittam aniyyanikam, na kbaya- gami, na bodbagami, na apacayagami, sasavam — pe — samkilesikan ti ? Amanta. Hanci uppattesiyam cittam aniyyanikam, na khaya- gaml, na bodbagami, na apacayagami, sasavain — pe — sanikilesikain, no vata re vattabbe " Saba uppattiya Araba ti." 6. Saba uppattiya Araba ti ? Amanta. Uppattesiyena cittena ragani pajabati, dosam pajabati, mobam pajabati, — pe — anottappam pajabatiti ? Na b'evam vattabbe — pe — Saba uppattiya Araba ti"? Amanta. Uppattesiyani cittam maggo — pe — satipattbanam sam- mappadbanam iddbipado indriyam balam — pe — bojjbango ti? Na b'evam vattabbe — pe — Saba uppattiya Araba ti ? Amanta. Uppattesiyena cittena dukkbam parijanati, samudayani pajabati, nirodham saccbikaroti, maggam bbavetiti? Na b'evam vattabbe — pe — Salia uppattiya Araba ti ? Amanta. IV. 3. J KATHAVATTHU. 271 Cuticittam, maggacittam, uppattesiyam ciltaui, phala- cittan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — U p p a 1 1 i k a t h a . IV. 3. 1. Arabato sabbe dbamma anasava ti? Amanta. Maggo phalam nibbanam sotapattimaggo sotapattipha- 1am sakadagamimaggo sakadagamiphalam anagamimaggo anagamiphalam arahattamaggo arahataplialaiu satipattha- nam sammappadhanam iddhipado indriyam balam boj- jhango ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Arahato sabbe dbamma anasava ti ? Amanta. Arahato cakkhum anasavan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahato cakkhum anasavan ti ? Amanta. Maggo phalaiu nibbanam — pe — bojjhango ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahato sotain — pe — Arahato ghanani — pe — Arahato jivha — pe — Arahato kayo anasavo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahato kavo anasavo ti? Amanta. Maggo phalaiu — pe — bojjhango ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Arahato kayo anasavo ti ? Amanta. Arahato kayo paggahaniggahupago ^ chedanal)hedanu- pago kakehi gijjhchi kulalehi sadharano ti ? Amanta. oQpako, P. 272 KATHAVATTHU. [IV. 3. Anasavo dhammo paggahaniggahupago chedanabhe- daiiupago kakehi gijjhehi knlalehi sadharano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Arahato kaye visam kameyya, sattham kameyya aggi kameyyati ? Amanta. Anasave dhamme visam kameyya, sattham kameyya, aggi kameyyati '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Labbha ' Arahato kayo addubandhanena bandhitmn, rajjiibandhanena bandhitum, samkhalikabandhanena ban- dhitum, gamabandhanena bandhitmn, nigamabandhan- ena bandhitmn, nagarabandhanena bandhitmn, janapada- bandhanena bandhitum, kanhapaficamehi- l^andhanehi bandhitnn ti ? Amanta. Labbha anasavo dhammo addubandhanena bandhitmn, rajjubandhanena bandhitmn, samkhahkabandhanena ban- dhitum, gamabandhanena bandhitum, nigamabandhanena bandhitum, nagarabandhanena bandhitum, janapadaban- dhanena bandhitum, kanhapahcamehi bandhanehi bandhi- tun ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Yadi Araha puthujjanassa civaram deti, anasavam hutva sasavam hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anasavam hutva sasavam hotiti ? Amanta. Tan heva anasavam, tarn sasavan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tafi heva anasavam, tam sasavan ti ? Amanta. Maggo anasavo hutva sasavo hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Phalam, satipatthanam, sammappadhanam, iddhipado, indriyani, balain, bojjhahgo anasavo hutva sasavo hotiti? ^ Laddho, P. ^ kanthapahcamehi, K. IV. 3. 1 KATHAVATTHU. 273 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Yadi Araha piithnjjanassa pindapatain deti, sena- sanam deti, gilanapaccayabhesajjaparikkharam deti, ana- savo hutva sasavo hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anasavo hutva sasavo hotiti '? Amanta. Tan neva anasavam, tarn sasavan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tan heva anasavam, tarn sasavan ti ? Amanta. Maggo anasavo hutva sasavo hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Phalam, sattipatthanam, sammappadhanam, iddhipado, indriyam, balam, bojjhango anasavo hutva sasavo hotiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Yadi ^ puthujjano Arahato clvarain deti, sasavani hutva anasavam hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sasavam hutva anasavam hotiti ? Amanta. Tan heva sasavam, tarn anasavan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tan heva sasavam, tarn anasavan ti ? Amanta. Rago sasavo hutva anasavo hotiti ? Na' h'evam vattabbe — pe — Doso — pe — moho — pe — anottappain sasavam hutva ana- savam hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Yadi puthujjano Arahato pindapatam deti, senasa- naiii deti, gilanapaccayabhesajjaparikkharam deti, sasavo hutva anasavo hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sasavo hutva anasavo hotiti ? Amanta. I Nanu, P.Sa. 19 274 KATHAVATTHU. [IV. 4. Tan neva sasavam, tarn anasavan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Tan neva sasavam, tain anasavan ti ? Amanta. Rago sasavo hutva anasavo botiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Doso — pe — moho — pe — anottappain sasavam hutva ana- savam hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 9. Na vattabbam " Arahato sabbe dhamma anasava ti"? Amanta. Nanu Araha anasavo ti '? Amanta. Hanoi Araha anasavo, tena vata re vattabbe " Arahato sabbe dhamma anasava ti." A n a s a V a k a t h a. IV. 4. 1. Araha catuhi phalehi samannagato ti? Amanta. Araha catuhi phassehi catuhi vedanahi catuhi safmahi catiihi cetanahi catuhi cittehi catuhi saddhahi catuhi viriyehi catuhi satlhi catuhi samadlnhi catuhi pahhahi samannagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Anagami tlhi phalehi samannagato ti ? Amanta. Anagami tlhi phassehi — pe — tlhi pahhahi samannagato ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — SakadagamI dvlhi phalehi samannagato ti ? Amanta. SakadagamI dvlhi phassehi — pe— dvlhi pahhalii saman- nagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — IV. 4. J KATHAVATTHU. '275 3. Araha sotapattiphalena samannagato ti ? Anianta. Ai'aha sotapanno sattakkhattuparamo, kolaiuk(jlo, ckn- biji ti'? Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — Araha sakadagamiphale samannagato ti ? Anianta, Araha sakadaganiT ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Araha anaganiiphalena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Araha anagami antaraparinibbayl, upahaccaparinib- bayl, asamkharaparinibbayi, sasamkharaparinibbayl, u->^ L a k k li a n a k a t h a IV. 8. 1. Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pavacane okkanta- niyanio caritabrahniacariyo ti '? Anianta. Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato savako ti ? Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato savako ti V* Anianta. Savako hutva biiddho hotiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Savako hutva buddho hotiti '? Anianta. Anussaviyo ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — 1 na aiiha, M. - janapadatthavariyiippatto, P. 3 adaddhena, P. IV. 8.] KATHAVATTHU. 287 Anussaviyo ti ? Amanta. Nanu Bhagava sayambhu ti ? Amanta. Haiici Bhagava sayambhu, no vata re vattabbe " Anussaviyo ti." 2. Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pavacane okkanta- niyamo caritabrahmacariyo ti ? Amanta. Bhagavata Bodhiya mule tin'eva samaiiiiaphalani abhi- sambuddhaniti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu Bhagavata^Bodhiya mule cattari samanhaphalani abhisambuddhaniti ? Amanta. Hanci Bhagavata Bodhiya mule cattari samahfiaphalani abhisambuddhani, no vata re vattabbe " Bodhisatto Kassa- passa bhagavato pavacane okkantaniyamo caritabrahma- cariyo ti." 3. Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pavacane okkanta- niyamo caritabrahmacariyo ti ? Amanta. Bodhisatto dukkarakarikam akasiti '? Amanta. Dassanasampannopuggalo dukkaram kariyainkareyyati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Bodhisatto aparantapaiu akasi, annani sattharaiii addisiti ? Amanta. Dassanasampanno puggalo ahiiam sattharam uddiseyya- ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 4. Ayasma Anando bhagavato pavacane okkantaniyamo caritabrahmacariyo, ayasma Anando bhagavato savako ti ? Amanta. Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pavacane okkantani- yamo caritabrahmacariyo, Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhaga- vato savako ti ? 288 KATHAVATTHU. [IV. 8. Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — Citto gahapati, Hatthako alavako Bhagavato pavacane okkantaniyamo caritabrahiuacariyo, Citto gahapati Hat- thako alavako bhagavato savako ti ? Amanta. Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pavacane okkantani- yamo caritabrahmacariyo, Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhaga- vato savako ti ? Na h'evaiu vattabbe — pe — 5. Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pavacane okkanta- niyamo caritabrahmacariyo, na ca Kassapassa bhagavato savako ti ? Amanta. Ayasma Anando bhagavato pavacane okkantaniyamo caritabrahmacariyo, na ca bhagavato savako ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pavacane okkantani- yamo caritabrahmacariyo, na ca Kassapassa bhagavato savako ti ? Amanta. Citto gahapati, Hatthako alavako bhagavato pavacane okkantaniyamo caritabrahmacariyo, na ca bhagavato savako ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pavacane okkantani- yamo caritabrahmacariyo, na ca Kassapassa bhagavato savako ti ? Amanta. Savako jativTtivatto asavako hotiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Na vattabbam " Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pavacane okkantaniyamo caritabrahmacariyo ti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttani Bhagavata — " Kassape aham Ananda bha- gavati brahmacariyam acarini '^ ayatim sambodhayati." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? I acari, P.M. IV. 8 KATHAVATTHU. 289 Amanta. Tena hi Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pavacane okkantaniyaino caritabrahmacariyo ti. 7. Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pavacane okkanta- niyaino caritabrahmacariyo ti '? Amanta. Nann vnttain Bhagavata — " Sabbabhibhu sabbavidu'ham asmi Sabbesu dhammesu anupahtto Sabbahjaho tanhakkhaye ^ vimutto, Sayain abhihhaya kam uddiseyyam. Na me acariyo atthi, Sadiso me na vijjati, Sadevakasmim lokasmiin N'atthi me patipuggalo. Ahafi hi ^ araha loke, Aham sattha anuttaro, Eko'mhi sammasambuddho, Sitibhuto'smi nibbuto. Dhammacakkain pavattetum Gacchami kasinain puram Andhabhutasmim 3 lokasmim Ahaii hi amatadndrabhin 4 ti." " Yatha kho tvain avnso patijanasi araha'sis anantajino^ ti." " Madisa 7 ve jina ^ honti Ye patta asavakkhayain, Jita me papaka dhamma Tasma'ham Upaka jino ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. I tanhakkhayo, P.Sz. ^ ahaii ci, P. 3 antabhiltasmi, P. 4 ahaniiiin amatadundubhin ti, K. ; ahafici amantadu- drubhin ti, Sa ; ahafiji amatadundubhin ti, S. 5 arahasi, P.S2; araha, S. ^ Ananda jino, P. 7 madiso, P. ; madissa, S. ^ vedajina, 8. P. 20 290 KATHAVATTHU. [TV. 9. Tena hi na vattabbam " Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhaga- vato pavacane okkantaniyamo caritabrahmacariyo ti." 8. Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pavacane okkanta-* niyamo caritabrahmacariyo ti ? Anianta. Nann vuttam Bhagavata — " Idam dukkham ariyasaccan ti me Bhikkhave pubbe ananussutesu dhammesu cakkhum ndapadi, lianam udapadi, panna udapadi, vijja udapadi, aloko udapadi ; tarn kho pan'idam dukkham ariyasaccam pariiiiieyyan ti me Bhikkhave — pe — pariiihatan ti me Bhikkhave pubbe ananussutesu dhammesu cakkhuin uda- padi— pe — aloko udapadi; idaiu dukkhasamudayam ariya- saccan ti me Bhikkhave — pe — tarn kho pan'idam dukkha- samudayam ariyasaccam pahatabban ti me pjhikkhave — pe — pahinan ti me Bhikkhave — pe — : idam dukkhaniro- dhain ariyasaccan ti me Bhikkhave — pe — tain kho pan' idam dukkhanirodham ariyasaccam sacchikatabban ti me Bhikkhave — pe — sacchikatan ti me Bhikkhave — pe — idam dukkhanirodhagamini patipada ariyasaccan ti me Bhik- khave — pe — tarn kho pan'idain dukkhanirodhagamini patipada ariyasaccam bhavetabban ti me Bhikkhave — pe — bhavitan ti me Bhikkhave pubbe ananussutesu dham- mesu cakkhuin udapadi, iianam udapadi, pahha udapadi, vijja udapadi, aloko udapadlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Ainanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhaga- vato pavacane okkantaniyamo caritabrahmacariyo ti." N i y a m o k k a n t i k a t h a. IV. 9. 1. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo tihi pha- lehi samannagato ti ? Amanta. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo catvihi phas- IV. 9.] KATHAVATTHU. 291 sehi catuhi vedanahi catnhi saiiiiahi catuhi cetanahi catuhi cittehi catnhi saddhahi catuhi viriyehi catnhi satihi catnhi samadhlhi catnhi paiihahi samannagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Anaganiiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno pnggalo dvlhi phalehi samannagato ti '? Amanta. Anaganiiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno pnggalo tlhi phassehi tlhi vedanahi — pe — tihi paiihahi samannagato ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno pnggalo sota- pattiphalena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno pnggalo dvihi phassehi — pe — dvilii pahhahi samannagato ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 3. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno pnggalo sotapatti- phalena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno pnggalo sotapanno sattakkhattuparamo, kolamkolo, ekabiji ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno pnggalo sakadagami- phalena samannagato ti ? x\manta. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno pnggalo sakadaga- mi ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno pnggalo anagami- phalena samannagato ti '? Amanta, Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno pnggalo anagami antaraparinibbayl, npahaccaparinibbayi, asamkharapari- nibbayl, sasanikharaparinibbayl, nddhainsoto akanittha- gaml ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Anaganiiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno pnggalo sota- pattiphalena samannagato ti ? 292 KATHAVATTHU. [IV. 9. Amanta. Anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sota- panno sattakkhattuparamo, kolamkolo, ekabljl ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sakada- gamiphalena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sakada- gaml ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sota- pattiphalena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sota- panno sattakkhattuparamo, kolamkolo, ekabiji ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Sotapattiphalena samannagato " sotapanno ti " vat- tabbo ti ? Amanta. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sotapatti- phalena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Sv'eva arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno, so sotapanno ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sakadagamiphalena samannagato " sakadagami ti " vat- tabbo ti ? Amanta. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sakadagami- phalena samannagato ti '? Amanta. Sv'eva arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno, so sakadaga- mi ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagamiphalena samannagato "anagamlti" vattabbo ti? Amanta. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo anagami- phalena samannagato ti ? IV. 9.] KATHAVATTHU. 293 Amanta, Sv'eva arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno, so anagami ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Sotapattiphalena samannagato " sotapanno ti " vat- tabbo ti '? Amanta. Anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sota- pattiphalena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Sv'eva anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno, so sota- panno ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sakadagamiphalena samannagato " sakadagami ti" vat- tabbo ti ? Amanta. Anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sakada- gamiphalena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Sv'eva anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno, so saka- dagami ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sotapattiphalena samannagato " sotapanno ti " vattabbo ti? Amanta. Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sota- pattiphalena samannagato ti '? Amanta. Sv'eva sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno, so sotapanno ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sotapatti- phalena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Nanu arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sota- pattiphalam vltivatto ti ? Amanta. Hahci arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sota- pattiphalani vltivatto, no vata re vattabbe, " Arahatta- 294 KATHAVATTHU. [IV. 9. sacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sotapattiplialena sam- annagato ti." 8. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sotapatti- phalam vltivatto, tena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sotapatti- phalam vltivatto, sakkayaditthiin vicikiccham sllabbata- paramasam ap ay again aniyain ragain apayagamanlyam dosam apayagamanlyam moliain vltivatto, tena saman- nagato ti ■? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 9. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sakada- gamiphalena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Nanu arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sakada- gamiphalam vltivatto ti ? Amanta. Hahci arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo saka- dagamiphalam vltivatto, no vata re vattabbe "Arahatta- sacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sakadagamiphalena samannagato ti." 10. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sakada- gamiphalam vltivatto, tena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sakadagami- phalam vTtivatto, olarikam kamaragain olarikain byapa- dam vltivatto, tena samannagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 11. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo anagami- phalena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Nanu arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo anaga- miphalam vltivatto ti ? Amanta. Hahci arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo anaga- miphalam vltivatto, no vata re vattabbe "Arahattasacchi- kiriyaya patipanno puggalo anagamiphalena samannagato ti." IV. 9. J KATHAVATTHU. 295 1'2. Arahattasaccliikiriyaya patipaniio puggalo anagaini- plialam vitivatto, tena samannagato ti ? Ainanta. Arahattasaccliikiriyaya patipanno puggalo anagami- phalam vitivatto, aniisahagatam kainaragain anusahaga- tani byapadain vitivatto, tena samannagato ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 13. Anagamiplialasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sotapattiphalena samannagato ti? Amanta. Naiiu anagamiplialasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sotapattiphalam vitivatto ti ? x\nianta. Hahci anagamiphalasaccliikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sotapattiphalam vitivatto, no vata re vattabbe, "Anagami- phalasaccliikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sotapattiphalena samannagato ti." 14. Anagamiplialasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sotapattiphalam vitivatto, tena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Anagamiplialasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sota- pattiphalam vitivatto, sakkayaditthiin vicikicchain sllab- bataparamasain apayagamanlyam ragain apayagamanlyam dosam apayagamaiilyani mohaiii vitivatto, tena saman- nagato ti '? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — 15. Anagamiplialasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sakadagamiphalena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Nanu anagamiplialasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sakadagamiphalani vitivatto ti '? Amanta. Hahci anagamiplialasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sakadagamiphalarn vitivatto, no vata re vattabbe " Anaga- miplialasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sakadagami- phalena samannagato ti." IG. Anagamiplialasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sakadagamiphalani vitivatto, tena samannagato ti? •296 KATHAVATTHU. [IV. 9. Amanta. Anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sakada- gamiphalam vltivatto, olarikam kamaragam olarikam byapadam vitivatto, tena samannagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 17. Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sotapattiphalena samannagato ti '? Amanta. Nann sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sotapattiphalam vitivatto ti ? Amanta. Haiici sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sotapattiphalam vitivatto, no vata re vattabbe " Sakadaga- miphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sotapattiphalena samannagato ti." 18. Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sotapattiphalam vitivatto, tena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sota- pattiphalam vitivatto, sakkayaditthim vicikiccham sllab- bataparamasam apayagamanlyam ragam apayagamanlyam dosam apayagamanlyam moham vitivatto, tena samanna- gato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 19. Na vattabbam " Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo tlhi phalehi samannagato ti " '? Amanta. Nanu arahattasacchikiriyaya patipannena puggalena tini phalani patiladdhani, tehi ca aparihino ti? Amanta. Hahci arahattasacchikiriyaya patipannena puggalena tIni phalani patiladdhani, tehi ca aparihino, tena vata re vattabbe ' ' Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo tlhi phalehi samannagato ti." 20. Na vattabbam "Anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya pati- panno puggalo dvlhi phalehi samannagato ti " ? Amanta. Nanu anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannena pug- IV. 9.] KATHAYATTHU. 297 galena dve phalani patiladdhani, tehi ca aparihlno ti? Amanta. Hanoi anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannena pugga- lena dve phalani patiladdhani, tehi ca aparihlno, tena vata re vattabbe "Anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo dvlhi phalehi samannagato ti." 21. Na vattabbam " Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sotapattiphalena samannagato ti " ? Amanta. Nanu sotapattiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannena pugga- lena sotapattiphalam patiladdhani, tena ca aparihlno ti ? Amanta. Hanoi sotapattiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannena pugga- lena sotapattiphalam patiladdham, tena ca aparihlno, tena vata re vattabbe " Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo sotapattiphalena samannagato ti." 22. Ai'ahattasacchikiriyaya patipannena puggalena tini phalani patiladdhani, tehi ca aparihlno ti ; arahattasacchi- kiriyaya patipanno puggalo tihi phalehi samannagato ti ? Amanta. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipannena puggalena cattaro magga patiladdha, tehi ca aparihlno ti ; arahattasacchi- kiriyaya patipanno puggalo catuhi maggehi samannagato ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe^ 23. Anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannena puggalena dve phalani patiladdhani, tehi ca aparihlno ti ; anagami- phalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo dvlhi phalehi samannagato ti ? Amanta. Anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannena puggalena tayo magga patiladdha, tehi ca aparihlno ti; anagami- phalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo tihi maggehi samannagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 24. Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannena pugga- lena sotapattiphalam patiladdham, tena ca aparihlno ti ; 298 KATHAVATTHU. [IV. 10. sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipaniio puggalo sota- pattiphalena saniannagato ti ? Amanta. Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannena puggalena dve magga patiladdha, tehi ca aparihino ti ; sakadagami- phalasacchikiriyaya patipanno puggalo dvlhi maggehi samannagato ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — A p a r a p i s a m a n n a g a t a k a t h a . IV. 10. 1. Sabbasafihojananam pahanam arahattaii ti ? Amanta. Arahattamaggena sabbe sahfiojana pahlyantlti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Arahattamaggena sabbe sahhojana pahlyantiti ? Amanta. Arahattamaggena sakkayaditthiin vicikiccham sllabbata- paramasaiii pajahatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahattamaggena sakkayaditthiin vicikiccham sllabbata- paramasam pajahatiti ? Amanta. Nanu tinnam sahhojaiianaiii pahanain sotapattiphalain vuttaiii Bhagavata ti ? Amanta. Hahci tinnain safihojananam pahanam sotapattiphalain vuttam Bhagavata, no vata re vattabbe "Arahattamag- gena sabbe sahhojana pahlyantiti." 2. Arahattamaggena sabbe sahhojana pahlyantiti? Amanta. Arahattamaggena olarikain kamaragam olarikam byapa- dam pajahatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — IV. 10.] KATHAVATTHU. 299 Arahattamaggena olarikam kamaragam olarikam byapa- dam pajahatiti ? Amanta. Nanii kamaragabyapadanam tanubhavam ^ sakadagami- phalam vuttam Bhagavata ti? Amanta. Hanoi kaniaragabyapadanain tanubhavam sakadagami- phalain vuttam Bhagavata, no vata re vattabbe " xVrahat- tamaggena sabbe sahhojana pahlyantlti." 3. Arahattamaggena sabbe sahhojana pahlyantlti ? Amanta. Arahattamao-gena anusahaoatam kamaragam anusaha- gatam byapadam pajahatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahattamaggena anusahagatain kamaragani anusaha- gatam byapadam pajahatiti? Amanta. Nanu kamaragabyapadanam anavasesappahanam anaga- miphalani vuttain Bhagavata ti '? Amanta. Hahci kamaragabyapadanain anavasesappahanani ana- gamiphalam vuttam Bhagavata, no vata re vattabbe "Arahattamaggena sabbe sahhojana pahlyantlti." 4. Arahattamaggena sabbe sahhojana pahlyantlti ? Amanta. Nanu ruparaga-aruparaga-mana-uddhacca-avij j ay a ana- vasesappahanain arahattam vuttam Bhagavata ti ? Amanta. Hahci ruparaga-aruparaga-mana-uddhacca-avijjaya ana- vasesappahanam arahattani vuttain Bhagavata, no vata re vattabbe "Arahattamaggena sabbe sahhojana pahlyan- tlti." 5. Na vattabbain " Sabbasahhojananani pahruiani ara- hattan ti " ? Amanta. Nanu Arahato sabbe sahhojana pahhia ti ? patanubhavain, P. 300 KATHAVATTHU. [IV. 10. Amanta. Haiici Arahato sabbe sannojana pahlna, tena vata re vattabbe " Sabbasannojananam pahanam arahattan ti." Saniiojanappahanakatha. GihT'ssa Araha, Salia uppattiya Araha, Arahato sabbe dhamma anasava, Araha catuhi phalehi samannagato, evameva chahi upekkhahi, Bodhiya buddho, Lakkha- nasamannagato Bodhisatto, Bodhisatto okkantaniyamo caritabrahmacariyo, Patipannako phalena samannagato, Sabbasannojananam pahanam Arahattan ti. Catuttho Vaggo. V. 1.] KATHAVATTHU. 301 V. 1. 1. Vimuttiiianam vimuttan ti ? Amanta. Yam kinci vimuttinanam sabban tarn ^ vimuttan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vimuttiiianam vimuttan ti '? Amanta. Paccavekkhanananam vimuttan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vimuttiiianam vimuttan ti ? Amanta. Gotrabhuno puggalassa vimuttiiianam vimuttan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Sotapattiphalasacchikiriyayapatipannassa puggalassa vimuttiiianam vimuttan ti ? Amanta. Sotapannassa fianam sotapattiphalam pattassa patilad- dhassa adhigatassa sacchikatassa iianan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa pugga- lassa vimuttiiianam vimuttan ti ? Amanta. Sakadagamissa iianam sakadagamiphalani pattassa patiladdhassa adhigatassa sacchikatassa iianan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa puggalassa vimuttiiianam vimuttan ti ? Amanta. Anagamissa iianam anagamiphalam pattassa patilad- dhassa adhigatassa sacchikatassa hanan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipannassa puggalassa vimutti- iianam vimuttan ti ? Amanta. I sabbanta, P. 302 KATHAVATTHU. [V. 1. Araliato nanam arahattam pattassa patiladdhassa adhigatassa sacchikatassa nanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Sotapattiphalasamangissa puggalassa vimuttiiianam vimuttan ti ? Amanta. Sotapattiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa puggalassa vimuttinanain vimuttan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sakadagamisamaiigissa puggalassa vimuttiiianam vimut- tan ti ? Amanta. Sakadagamiplialasacchikiriyaya patipannassa puggalassa vimuttiiianam vimuttan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagamiphalasamaiigissa puggalassa vimuttinanain vi- muttan ti ? Amanta. Anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa puggalassa vimuttiiianam vimuttan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahattaphalasamahgissa puggalassa vimuttiiianam vi- muttan ti ? Amanta. Arahattasacchikiriyaya patipannassa puggalassa vimut- tinanain vimuttan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — • 4. Sotapattiphalasamangissa puggalassa vimuttihanani vimuttani, tan ca ^ phalain pattassa haiiaii ti ? Amanta. Sotapattiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa puggalassa vimuttiiianam vimuttam, taii ca phalain pattassa iianan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Sakadagamiphalasamahgissa puggalassa vimuttiiianam vimuttam, tan ca phalam pattassa hanan ti '? I vimuttantam ca, M. ; vimuttan ca, P. ; vimuttam ca, S.S2. V. 2.] KATHAVATTHU. 303 Am ant a. Sakadagainiphalasacchikiriyayapatipannassapuggalassa vimuttifianam vimuttam, tan ca plialam pattassa nanan ti? ' ' Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Anagamiphalasamangissa puggalassa vimuttinanam vimuttam, tan ca phalam pattassa nanan ti ? Amanta. Anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa puggalassa vimuttinanam vimuttam, tafi ca phalam pattassa nanan ti ? Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahattaphalasamangissa puggalassa vimuttinanam vimuttam, tafi ca phalam pattassa nanan ti ? Amanta. Arahattasacchikiriyay a patipannassa puggalassa vimutti- nanam vimuttam, tail ca phalam pattassa nanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — V i m u 1 1 i k a t h a V. 2. 1. Sekhassa asekham ' hanam atthiti'? Amanta. Sekho asekhani dhammani janati passati, ditthani viditam sacchikatain upasampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu sekho asekham dhammam na janati, na passati, adittham aviditain asacchikatain na upasampajja viharati^ na kayena phusitva viliaratiti ? Amanta. Hahci sekho asekham dhammam na janati, na passati^ adittham aviditani asacchikatain na upasampajja viharati, na kayena phusitva viharati, no vata re vattabbe " Sekhassa asekhan] hanam atthiti." I asekliahanani, P. 304 KATHAVATTHU. [V. 2. 2. Asekhassa asekham fianam atthi, asekho asekham dhanimam janati passati, ditthain viditain sacchikatam upasampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharatlti? Amanta. Sekhassa asekham iianam atthi, sekho asekham dhammam janati passati, dittham viditam sacchikatam upasampajja viharati, kayena phusitva viharatlti ? Amanta. Sekhassa asekham hanam atthi, sekho asekham dhammam na janati na passati, adittham aviditam asacchikatam na upasampajja viharati, na kayena phusitva viharatlti ? Amanta. Asekhassa asekhain nan am atthi, asekho asekham dhammam na janati na passati, adittham aviditam asacchikatam na upasampajja viharati, na kayena phusitva viharatlti '? Amanta. 8. Sekhassa ^ asekhain hanam atthiti '? Amanta. Gotrabhuno puggalassa sotapattimagge hanam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sotapattiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa puggalassa sotapattiphale hanani atthiti ? Amanta. Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya — pe — anagamiphala- sacchikiriyay a — pe — arahattasacchikiriyay a patipannassa puggalassa arahatte hanam atthiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Na vattabbam " Sekhassa asekham hanam atthiti " ? Amanta. Nanu ayasma Anando sekho " Bhagava ularo ti " janati, " Sariputto thero, Maha Moggallano thero ularo ti " janatiti ? Amanta. Hahci ayasma Anando sekho " Bhagava ularo ti " janati. I Asekhassa, P.K. V. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 305 " Sariputto thero, Maha Moggallano thero ularo ti " janati, tena vata re vattabbe " Sekhassa asekham nanam atthiti." A s e k h a n a n a k a t h a V. 3. 1. Pathavlkasinasaniapattiin sainapannassa vipaiite nanan ti ? Amanta. Anicce niccan ti vipariyeso ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dukkhe sukhan ti — -pe— aiiattani atta ti — pe — asubhe subhan ti vipariyeso ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Pathavlkasinasainapattim samapannassa viparite iianan ti '? Amanta. Akusalan ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Nanu kusalan ti ? Amanta. Hanoi kusalam, no vata re vattabbe " Pathavlkasinasania- pattiin samapannassa viparite iianan ti." 3. Anicce niccan ti vipariyeso, so ca akusalo ti ? Amanta. Pathavlkasinasaniapattiin samapannassa vipaiite hanaiii, tan ca akusalan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dukkhe sukhan ti — pe — anattani atta ti^ — -pe — asubhe subhan ti vipariyeso, so ca akusalo ti ? Amanta. Pathavlkasinasainapattim samapannassa viparite hanam, tan ca akusalan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 21 306 KATHAVATTHU. [V. 8. 4. Pathavlkasinasamapattim samapannassa viparlte fianam, tan ca kusalan ti '? Anianta. Anicce niccan ti vipariyeso, so ca kusalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Pathavlkasinasamapattim samapannassa viparlte fianam, tail ca kusalan ti ? Amanta. Dukkhe sukhan ti — pe — anattani atta ti — pe — asubhe subhan ti vipariyeso, so ca kusalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Pathavlkasinasamapattiin samapannassa viparlte nanan ti ? Amanta. Araha pathavlkasinasamapattim samapajjeyyati '? Amanta. Hafici Araha pathavlkasinasamapattim samapajjeyya, no vata re vattabbe " Pathavlkasinasamapattim sama- pannassa viparTte iianan ti." 6. Pathavlkasinasamapattiin samapannassa viparTte hanam, Araha pathavlkasinasamapattim samapajjeyyati '? Amanta. Atthi Arahato vipariyeso ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi Arahato vipariyeso ti '? Amanta. Atthi Arahato saiihavipariyeso, cittavipariyeso, ditthi- vipariyeso ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe^ — ^pe — N'atthi Arahato saiihavipariyeso, cittavipariyeso, ditthi- vipariyeso ti ? Amanta. Hahci n'atthi Arahato saiihavipariyeso, cittavipariyeso, ditthivipariyeso, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato vipariyeso ti." 7. Na vattabbam "Pathavlkasinasamapattim sama- pannassa viparlte hanan ti ? Amanta. V. 4.] KATHAVATTHU. 307 Pathaviti samapajjantassa ^ sabb'eva pathavi hotiti ? - Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi patbavlkasinasamapattim samapannassa vipaiite fianan ti. 8. Pathavlkasinasamapattiin samapannassa viparlte nanan ti ? Amanta. Nanu pathavT atthi, atthi ca koci pathavim pathavito samapajjatiti ? Amanta. Haiici pathavi atthi, atthi ca koci pathavim pathavito samapajjati,novata re vattabbe" Pathavlkasinasamapattiin samapannassa viparTte hanan ti." Pathavi atthi, pathaviin pathavito samapajjantassa viparltain hotiti ? Amanta. Nibbanam atthi, nibbanam nibbanato samapajjantassa viparltain hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi na vattabbam " Pathavlkasinasamapattiin samapannassa viparlte hanan ti." V i p a r 1 1 a k a t h a . V. 4. 1 . Aniyatassa niyamagamanaya atthi hanan ti '? Amanta. Niyatassa aniyamagamanaya atthi fianan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Niyatassa aniyamagamanaya n'atthi hanan ti '? Amanta. Aniyatassa niyamagamanaya n'atthi hanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Aniyatassa niyamagamanaya atthi hanan ti ? samapannassa, P. ^ pathaviti, P.S.M. 308 KATHAVATTHU. fV. 4. Aiiianta. Niyatassa niyamagamanaya atthi nanan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe— Niyatassa niyamagamanaya n'atthi iianan ti V Amanta. Aniyatassa niyamagamanaya n'atthi iianan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Aniyatassa niyamagamanaya atthi hanan ti V Amanta. Aniyatassa aniyamagamanaya atthi iianan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Aniyatassa aniyamagamanaya n'atthi hanan ti ? Amanta. Aniyatassa niyamagamanaya n'atthi hanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe- — 4. Aniyatassa niyamagamanaya atthi hanan ti ? Amanta. Aniyatassa niyamagamanaya atthi niyamo ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Aniyatassa niyamagamanaya atthi hanan ti? Amanta. Aniyatassa niyamagamanaya atthi satipatthana — pe — sainmappadhana, iddhipada, indriya, bala, bojjhahga ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — •'^. Aniyatassa niyamagamanaya n'atthi niyamo ti ? Amanta. Hanoi aniyatassa niyamagamanaya n'atthi niyaimo, no vata re vattabbe " Aniyatassa niyamagamanaya atthi hanan ti." Aniyatassa niyamagamanaya n'atthi satipatthana — pe — bojjhahga ti ? Amanta. Haiici aniyatassa niyamagamanaya n'atthi bojjhahga, no vata re vattabbe "Aniyatassa niyamagamanaya atthi hanan ti." 6. Aniyatassa niyamagamanaya atthi hanan ti ? Amanta. V. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 309 Gotrabhuiio puggalassa sotapattimagge nanain atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sotapattiphalasaccliikiriyaya patipaiinassa puggalassa sotapattiphale iianam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya — pe — anagainiphala- sacchikiriyaya — pe — -arahattasacchikiriyaya patipaiinassa puggalassa arahatte hanam atthiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Na vattabbam " Aniyatassa niyamagamanaya atthi nanan ti " ? Nanu Bhagava jaiiati " Ayam puggalo sammattaiii- yamam okkamissati, bhabbo ayam puggalo dhammaiu abhisametun ti " ? Amaiita. Hahci Bhagava janati "Ayam puggalo sammattani- yamam okkamissati, bhabbo ayain puggalo dhammam abhisametum," tena vata re vattabbe " Aniyatassa niyamagamanaya atthi hanan ti." N i y a 111 a k a t h a . V. 5. 1. Sabbain hanaiii patisambhida ti? Amanta. Sammutihanam patisambhida ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sammutihanam patisambhida ti '? Amanta. Ye keci sammutim jananti, sabbe te patisambhidap- patta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sabbam lianaiii patisaml)hida ti ? Amanta. Cetopariyaye hanam patisambhida ti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 810 KATHAVATTHU. [V. 6, Cetopariyaye nanaiii patisaiiibhida ti '? Amanta. Ye keci paracittam jananti, sabbe te patisambhidap- patta ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 2. Sabbam iianam patisaiiibhida ti ? Amanta. - Sabba panna patisaiiibhida ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Sabba paiiha patisaiiibhida ti ? Amanta. Pathavlkasinasamapattim samapannassa atthi pahha, sa pahha patisaiiibhida ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Apokasinaiii — pe— tejokasinam — pe — vayokasinain — pe — nllakasinam — pe — pltakasinam — pe — lohitakasinain — pe — odatakasinam — pe — akasanaiicayatanam — pe — vihna- nahcayatanam — pe — akihcahhayatanam — pe — nevasaiiha- nasahhayatanain samapannassa — pe — danam dadantassa — pe — clvarain dadantassa — pe — pindapataiii dadantassa — pe — senasanaiii dadantassa — pe — gilanapaccayabhesaj- japarikkharain dadantassa atthi pahha, sa pahha patisaiii- bhida ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 3. Na vattabbam " Sabbam hanam patisaiiibhida ti " ? Amanta. Atthi lokuttara pahha, sa na patisaiiibhida ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi sabbam hanam patisaiiibhida ti. P a t i s a ill b h i d a k a t h a . V. 6. 1. Na vattabbain " Sanimutihanam saccaranimanah heva na ahharammanan ti " ? Amanta. V. 7.] KATHAVATTHU. 311 Nann pathavikasinasaniapattim samapannassa atthi nanam, pathavlkasinan ca sammutisaccamhlti ? Anianta. Haiici pathavikasinasamapattim samapannassa atthi nanam, pathavlkasinan ca sammutisaccamhi, tena vata re vattabbe " Sammutifianam saccarammanaii heva na aiinarammanan ti." 2. Na vattabbam " Sammutihanam saccarammanaii iieva na afifiarammanan ti " "? Amanta. Nanu apokasinam — pe — tejokasinam — pe — gilanapac- cayabhesajjaparikkharain dadantassa atthi iianam, gilana- paccayabhesajjaparikkharo ca sammutisaccamhlti ? Amanta. Hanci gilanapaccayabhesajjaparikkharam dadantassa atthi iianam, gilanapaccayabhesajjaparikkharo ca sammu- tisaccamhi, tena vata re vattabbe " Sammutifianam sacca- rammanaii heva na ahharammanan ti." 3. Sammutifianam saccarammanaii iieva na ahfiaram- manan ti ? Amanta. Tena hanena dukkham parijanati, samudayam pajahati^ nirodharn sacchikaroti, maggam bhavetiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — S a m m u t i h a n a k a t h a . V. 7. 1. Cetopariyaye nanam cittarammanah iieva na ahha- rammanan ti ? Amanta, Nanu atthi koci saragam cittam " saraf^am cittan ti " pajanatiti ? Amanta. Hahci atthi koci saragam cittam " saragam cittan ti " pajanati, no vata re vattabbe " Cetopariyaye nanam citta- rammanah heva na ahharammanan ti." 312 KATHAVATTHU. [Y. 7. Nanu atthi koci vitaragam cittaiii " vitaragam cittan ti " — pe — sadosain cittam — pe-^vitadosam cittam — pe — samohain cittam — pe — vltamoham cittam, samkhittam cittain, vikkhittam cittam, mahaggatam cittam, amahagga- tam cittam, sa-uttaram cittam, anuttaram cittam, samahi- tam cittam, asamahitam cittam, vimuttam cittam — pe — avimuttam cittam " avimuttain cittan ti " pajanatiti '? Amanta. Hanci atthi koci avimuttam cittam " avimuttain cittan ti " pajanati, no vata re vattabbe " Cetopariyaye hanam cittarammanaii iieva na aniiarammanan ti." 2. Phassarammane hanam vattabbam cetopariyaye hanan ti ? Amanta. Hahci phassarammane hanam vattabbam cetopariyaye hanam, no vata re vattabbe " Cetopariyaye hanam citta- rammanah heva na ahharammanan ti." Vedanarammane hanam, sahharammane hanam, cetana- rammane hanam, cittarammane hanam, saddharammane hanam, viriyarammane hanam, satarammane hanam, samadharammane hanain, pahharammane hanam — pe — ragarammane hanam — pe — dosarammane hanain — pe — anottapparammane hanam vattabbain cetopariyaye hanan ti? Amanta. Hahci anottapparammane hanam vattabbain cetopari- yaye hanain, no vata re vattabbe " Cetopariyaye hanam cittarammanaii heva na ahharammanan ti." 3. Phassarammane hanani na vattabbain cetopariyaye hanan ti ? Amanta. Phassapariyaye hanan ti ? Na h'evam vattablje — pe — Vedanarammane hanani — pe — sahharammane hanam — pe — anottapparammane hanam na vattabbain cetopari- -yaye hanan ti '? Amanta. Anottappapariyaye hanan ti ? V. 8. J KATHAVATTHU. 313 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Na vattabbam " Cetopariyaye nanam cittarainmanan fieva na annarammanan ti " '? Amanta. Nanu cetopariyaye fianan ti ? Amanta. Hanoi cetopariyaye nanam, tena vata re vattabbe " Ceto- pariyaye nanain cittarammanaii neva na aiiiiarammanan ti." C i 1 1 a r a m m a n a k a t h a . V. 8. 1. Anagate nanain atthiti ? Amanta. Anagatain mnlato janati, hetuto ^ janati, nidanato janati, sambhavato janati, pabhavato janati, samutthanato janati, aharato janati, arammanato janati, paccayato janati, samudayato janatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Anagate nanam atthiti V Amanta. Anagatam hetiipaccayatam janati, arammanapaccaya- tam janati, adhipatipaccayatam janati, anantarapaccaya- tam janati, samanantarapaccayatain janatiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — - 3. Anagate iianam atthiti ? Amanta. Gotrabhuno puggalassa sotapattimagge hanani atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sotapattiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa puggalassa sotapattiphale nanam hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sakadagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa pugga- lassa — pe — anagamiphalasacchikiriyaya patipannassa pug- I hetuno, I'.S. 314 KATHAVATTHU. [V. 9. galassa — pe — arahattasacchikiriyaya patipannassa pugga- lassa arahatte fianam atthiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Na vattabbam " Anagate iianam atthiti " ? Anianta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Pataliputtassa kho Ananda tayo antaraya bhavissanti, aggito va udakato va mithu- bheda va ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti '? Ainanta. Tena hi anagate iianain atthiti. A n a g a t a h a 11 a k a t h a . V. 9. 1. Paccuppanne fianam atthiti ? Amanta. Tena nanena tarn nanam janatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena iianena tarn iianam janatiti ? Amanta. Tena iianena tam iianam iianan ti ianatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena iianena tam nanam iianan ti janatiti ? Amanta. Tam iianam tassa hanassa arammanan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tain nanam tassa iianassa arammanan ti ? Amanta. Tena phassena tain phassam phusati, taya vedanaya tam vedanam vedeti, taya sahiiaya tam saiiham saiijanati, taya cetanaya tain cetanain ceteti, tena cittena tam cittam cinteti, tena vitakkena tain vitakkam vitakketi, tena vica- rena tam vicaram vicareti, taya pitiya tam pltiin plyayati, taya satiya tam satini sarati, taya pahhaya tam pafniam pajanati, tena khaggena tam khaggani chindati, tena pha- V. 10.] KATHAVATTHU. 315 rasuna tarn pharusam tacchati, taya kuthariya ^ tain kutharim tacchati, taya vasiya tarn vasim tacchati, taya suciya tarn siicim sibbeti, tena aiigulaggena tarn ahgulag- gam paramasati, tena nasikaggena tarn nasikaggaiu para- masati, tena matthakena tarn matthakam paramasati, tena guthena tarn gutham dhovati, tena muttena tain muttaiu dhovati, tena khelena tarn khelam dhovati, tena pubbena tarn pubbam dhovati, tena lohitena tarn lohitam dhovatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Na vattabbam " Paccuppanne iianam atthiti " ? Amanta. Nanu sabbe samkhare aniccato ditthe tarn pi iianam aniccato dittham hotiti ? Amanta. Hanci sabbe samkhare aniccato ditthe tam pi nanam aniccato dittham hoti, tena vata re vattabbe " Paccup- panne iianam atthiti." P a c c u p p a n n a 11 a n a k a t h a . V. 10. 1. Savakassa phale haiiam atthiti ? Amanta. Savako phalassa katam pahhapetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Savakassa phale hanam paiihapetlti ? Amanta. Atthi savakassa phalaparopariyatti,^ indriyaparopari- yatti, puggalaparopariyattiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Savakassa phale iianani atthiti ? Amanta. Atthi savakassa khandhapanhatti, ayatanapafihatti, 1 kutthariya. P., kudhariya, M.K., kutariya, S. 2 pariyattam, P. » • 316 KATHAVATTHU. [V. 10. dhatupaiinatti, saccapannatti, iiidriyapannatti, puggala- pannattTti ? Na»h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Savakassa phale nanam atthiti ? Amanta. Savako jino sattha sammasambuddho sabbannn sabba- dassavi dhammasami dhainmapatisarano ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Savakassa phale nanam atthiti '? Amanta. Savako anuppannassa magoassa uppadeta asanjatassa maggassa sahjaneta anakkhatassa maggassa akkhata niag- gahhu niaggavidu maggakovido ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Na vattabbam " Savakassa phale nanam atthiti " "? Amanta. Savako ahhani ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi savakassa phale nanam atthiti. P h a 1 a n a n a k a t h a . Vimuttnianam vimuttam, Sekhassa asekham nanain, Viparlteiianam, Aniyatassa niyamagamanaya atthi nanam, Sabbain hanain patisambhida ti, Sammutihanain, Cetopariyaye iianani, Anagate hanain, Paccnppanne hanani, Savakassa phale hanan ti. Pahcamo Vaggo. M a h a p a n n a s a k o . KATHAVATTHU. I^ali Cert ^ocietp. KATHAVATTHU. EDITED BY AENOLD C. TAYLOE, B.A. VOL. II. LONDON : PUBLISHED FOR THE PALI TEXT SOCIETY, BY HENEY FEOWDE, OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS W.AilEHOUSE, AMEN CORNER, E.C- 1897. INDEX OF QUESTIO_NS DISCUSSED IN THE KATHAVATTHU. CONTENTS OF VOL. II. Chattho Vaggo. No. 1. Niyamo asamkhato ti '? '2. Paticcasamuppado asamkhato ti V ... 8. Cattari saccani asanikliataniti ? 4. Akasanancayatanam asamkhatan ti ? 5. Nirodhasamapatti asamkliata ti ? ... 6. Akaso samkhato ti ■? ... 7. Akaso sanidassano ti ? S. Pathavidhatu sanidassana ti ? PAGE 817 819 822 825 827 828 880 881 S a 1 1 a m o V a g g o . 1. N'atthi keci dhamma kehici dhammehi samga- hita ti? 885 2. N'atthi keci dhamma kehici dhammehi sampa- yutta ti? 887 8. N'atthi cetasiko dhamnio ti? ... ... ... 888 4. Cetasiko dhammo danan ti ? ... ... ... 889 5. Paribhogamayam pmiiiam samvaddhatiti ? ... 843 VI INDEX TO QUESTIONS DISCUSSED No. 6. Ito dinnena tattha yapentlti ? 7. Pathavl kammavipako ti? ... 8. Jaramaranam vipako ti ? ... 9. N'attbi ariyadhammavipako ti? ... 10. Yipako vipakadhammadhammo ti ? PAGK 847 849 858 855 857 A 1 1 h a 111 V a g" g o . 1. Cha gatiyo ti ? ... ... ... ... ... 860 2. Atthi antarabhavo ti '? ... ... ... ... 861 8. Paiic'eva kaiiiaguna kamadhatuti ? ... ... 866 4. Pafic'ev' ayatana kama ti ? ... ... ... 869 5. Eupino dliaiiinia rupadhatuti? ... ... ... 870 6. Arnpino dhamma arupadhatiiti ? ... ... ... 872 7. Halayataniko attabhavo riipadhatuya ti'?... ... 874 8. Atthi mpam arupesnti ? ... ... ... ... 878 9. Kusaleiia cittena samutthitam kayakammam rupaip kusalaii ti? ... ... ... ... 880 10. N'atthi rupajlvitindriyan ti? ... ... ... 894 11. Kammahetu Araba arahatta parihayatiti ? ... 898 N a V a m o V a <;■ a' o 1. Aiiisainsadassavissa sannojananam pahanan ti 2. Aniatarammanam saMojanaii ti ?... 8. Kiipani sararnnianan ti ? 4. Anusaya anarainiiiana ti ? ... 5. Nanam aiiarammanan ti ? . . . 6. Atitaramiiianain cittaiii aiiaramiiiaiiaii ti ? 7. Habbam cittam vitakkanupatitan ti ? 8. Sabbaso vitakkayato viciirayato vitakkavipphar saddo ti ? . . . o 400 401 404 405 409 410 411 418 IN THE KATHAVATTHU. Vll No. 9. Na yatha cittassa vaca ti ?... 10. Na yatha cittassa kayakamman ti ? 11. Atitena samannagato ti ? ... PAGE 414 416 417 "iDC?"- D a s a 111 o V a g g o . Uppattesiye paucakkhandlie aniruddhe kiriya paiica khandha nppajjantiti ? ... ... ... 421 Maggasamangissa riipam maggo ti ? ... ... 422 Paficaviiihaiiasaiiianoissa atthi maggabhavana ti ? 424 427 429 481 483 487 439 440 441 2. 3. 4. Pafica viniiana kusala pi akusala piti ? ... 5. Paiica viiiiiana sabhoga ti ? 6. Maggasamangl dvlhi silehi saiiiannagato ti ? 7. Silain acetasikaii ti '? 8. Sllam na cittanuparivattiti '? 9. Sainadanahetukam sllain vaddhatiti ? 10. Vimiatti silaii ti ? ... 11. jiviiinatti dussilyan ti ? E k a d a s a ill o V a g g o. 1. Anusaya abyakata ahetulva cittavippayutta ti V ... 444 2. Annaiie vigate nanavippayutte citte vattamane na vattabbam nam ti ? ... ... ... ... 450 3. Nanaiii cittavippayuttan ti ? ... ... ... 451 4. Idaiii dukkhaii ti vacam bliasato idam dukkhan ti nanam pavattatiti ? ... ... ... ... 453 5. Iddhibalena samannagato kappam tittheyyati ? ... 456 6. Cittasantati samadhiti ? ... ... ... ... 458 7. Dhammatthitata parinipphanna ti ? ... ... 459 8. Aniccata parinippbamia ti ? ... ... ... 460 Vlll INDEX TO QUESTIONS DISCUSSED D V a d a s a in o V a g g o. No. PAGE 1 . Samvaro kamman ti '? ... ... ... ... 463 2. Sabbaiii kaniniam savipakan ti ? ... ... ... 464 3. Saddo vipako ti ? ... ... ... ... ... 466 4. Salayatanam vipako ti '? ... ... ... ... 467 5. Sattakkliattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattupara- inata niyato ti ? ... ... ... ... ... 469 6. Na vattabbam " Kolamkolo puggalo kolainkolata niyato ti"? 471 Na vattabbam " EkabijI puggalo ekabljita niyato ti"?... " 471 7. Ditthisampanno puggalo saiicicca panain jlvita voropeyyati ? ... ... ... ... ... 471 8. Ditthisampannassa pugalassa pahina duggatiti? ... 473 9. Na vattabbam " Sattamabhavikassa puggalassa pahina duggatiti " ? ... ... ... ... 475 T e r a s a m o V a g g o 1. Kappattho kappain tittheyyati ? ... ... ... 476 2. Kappattho kusalam cittam na patilabheyyati ? ... 477 3. Anantarapayutto puggalo sammattaniyamam ok- kammeyyati ? ... ... ... ... ... 478 4. Niyato niyamain okkamatiti ? ... ... ... 480 5. Nivuto nivaranam jahatiti ? ... ... ... 480 6. Sammukhlbhiito samiojanam jaliatiti? ... ... 482 7. Samapanno assadeti, jhananikanti jlianarammana ti? 483 8. Atthi asatarago ti ? . . . ... ... ... ... 485 9. Dhammatanha abyakata ti ? ... ... ... 486 10. Dhammatanha na dukldiasamudayo ti? ... ... 488 IN THE KATHAVATTHU. IX Cuddasmo Vaggo. . No. PAGE 1. Akusalamulam patisandahati knsalamulan ti ? ... 491 2. Salayatanam apubbam acarimam niatu kucchis- mim santhatiti ? ... ... ... ... ... 493 3. Cakkhuviniianassa anantara sotavinnanam uppaj- jatlti? 495 4. Ariyarupam mababhutanam upadayati ? ... ... 498 5. Anno kamaraganusayo, aniiam kaniaragapariyut- thananti? 499 6. Pariyuttbanam cittavippayuttan ti ? ... ... 501 7. Euparago rupadhatum anuseti, rupadbatupariya- panno ti ? . . . ... ... ... ... ... 502 8. Dittbigataip abyakatan ti ? . . . ... ... ... 504 9. Dittbigatam apariyapannan ti ? ... ... ... 507 P a n n a r a s a m o Vaggo. 1. Paccayata vavattbita ti ? ... ... ... ... 508 2. Avijjapaccaya samkbara, navattabbam "samkba- rapaccaya pi avij ja ti " ? . . . ... ... ... 510 3. Addha parinippbanno ti V ... ... ... ... 511 4. Kbano parinippbanno, layo parinippbanno, niii- buttam parinippbannan ti '? ... ... ... 514 5. Cattaro asava anasava ti ? ... ... ... ... 514 6. Lokuttaranam dbanimanam jaraniaranam lokut- taran ti '? ... ... ... ... ... ... 515 7. Sannavedayitanirodbasamapatti lokuttara ti '? ... 516 8. Saiiiiavedayitanirodbasainapatti lokiya ti ? ... 516 9. Saiinavedayitanirodbam samapanno kalam kare}'- yatiV 517 10. Sannavedayitanirodbasamapatti asannasattupika t\? 518 11. Afinani IvannniLiii, anno Ivamninpacayo ti ■? ... 520 X INDEX TO QUESTIONS DISCUSSED Solasamo Vaggo. No. PAGE 1. Pare parassa cittam nigganhatiti '? ... ... 524 2. Paro parassa cittam pagganhatiti '? ... ... 525 3. Paro parassa sukhaiu anuppadetiti '? ... ... 527 4. Adhigayha manasikarotiti ? ... ... ... 528 5. Eupamhetuti? ... ... ... ... ... 532 6. Rupam sahetukan ti ? ... ... ... ... 533 7. Rtipam kusalan ti ? . . . ... ... ... ... 534 8. Eupam vipako ti ? . . . ... ... ... ... 536 9. Atthi rupam rupavacaran ti ? ... ... ... 538 10. Euparago rupadliatnpariyapanno ti ■? ... ... 539 S a 1 1 a r a s a m o V a g g o. 1. Atthi Arahato piinMpacayo ti ? ... ... ... 542 2. N 'atthi Arahato akalamaccuti? ... ... ... 543 3. Sabbani idam kamniato ti '? ... ... ... 545 4. Indriyabaddhan heva dukkhan ti y ... ... 546 5. Thapetva ariyaniaggam avasesa samkhara dukkha ti? ' '. 548 6. Na vattabbam " Samgho dakkhinam patigganha- titi"? "... '... ... "..." *... ' ... 549 7. Na vattabbam " Samgho dakkhinam visodhe- tlti"? ..". ..." 551 8. Na vattabbam " Samgho bhmijati, pivati, khadati, sayatiti"? 552 9. Na vattabbam " Samghassa dinnam mahappha- lan ti "? .' 553 10. Na vattabbam " Buddhassa dinnain mahappha- lanti"? ." " 555 11. Dayakato va danam visujjhati, na patiggahakato ti? ' 556 IN THE ICATHAVATTHU. ' XI Attharasamo Vaggo. No. PAGE 1. Na vattabbam " Bucldlio Bhagava manussaloke atthasiti"? 559 2. Na vattabbam " Buddhena Bhagavata dhammo desito ti "? 560 3. N'atthi Biiddhassa Bhagavato karima ti ? ... 561 4. Bnddhassa Bhagavato nccarapassavo ativiya anne gandhajate adhigganhatiti ? ... ... ... 563 5. Ekena ariyamaggena cattari samaiinaphalani sac- chikarotlti '? 563 6. Jhana jhanam samkamatiti '? ... ... ... 565 7. Atthi jhanantarika ti ? ... ... ... ... 569 8. Samapanno saddam sunatiti ? ... ... ... 572 9. Cakkhuna rupam passatiti ■? ... ... ... 573 E k n n a V I s a t i m o Vaggo. 1. Atlte kilese jahatiti '?... ... ... ... ... 576 2. Sunfiata samkharakkhandhapariyapanna ti ■? ... 578 3. Samafmaphalam asamkhatan ti ? ... ... ... 579 4. Patti asamkhata ti '? . . . ... ... ... ... 581 5. Sabbadhaminanam tathata asamkhata ti ? ... 583 6. Nibbanadhatu kusala ti '? ... ... ... ... 585 7. Atthi puthujjanassa accantaniyamata ti'? ... ... 586 8. N'atthi lokiyam saddhindriyan ti '?... ... ... 589 V I s a t i m o V a g g o. 1. Asaiicicca mataram jivita voropetva anantariko hotiti? .593 2. N'atthi putbiujjanassa hanan ti '? ... ... ... 585 3. N'atthi niraj^esu nirayapala ti ? ... ... ... 596 4. Atthi devesu tiracchanagata ti ? ... ... ... 598 5. Paiicaiigiko maggo ti '? ... ... ... ... 599 6. Dvadasavatthukam hanam lokuttaran ti ? ... (302 Xll INDEX TO QUESTIONS DISCUSSED Ekavisatimo Vaggo. No. PAGE 1. Sasanam navakatan ti ? ... ... ... ... 604 2. Puthujjano tedhatukehi clhammehi avivitto ti ? ... 605 3. Attlii kiiici safinojanam appahaya arahattappat- tlti? 606 4. Atthi adhippaya-iddhi Buddhanam va savakanam va ti? 606 5. Atthi Buddhanam Buddhehi hlnatirekata ti ? ... 608 6. Sabba disa Buddha ti '? ... ... ... ... 608 7. Sabbe dhainiiia niyata ti '? ... ... ... ... 609 8. Sabl:)e kamma niyata ti ? ... ... ... ... 611 Bavlsatinio Vaggo. 1. Atthi kihci sahhojanam appahaya parinibbanan ti? 613 2. Araha kusalacitto parinibbayatiti ?... ... ... 613 3. Araha aneiije thito parinibbayatiti ? ... ... 615 4. Atthi gabbhaseyyaya dhaniniabhisamayo ti ? ..: 616 5. Atthi. gabbhaseyy aya arahattappattiti ? ... ... 616 6. Sabbain supinagatassa cittam abyakatan ti ? ... 617 7. N ' atthi kaci asevanapaccayata ti ? ... ... ... 618 8. Ekacittakkhanika sabbe dhamma ti ? ... ... 620 T e V T s a t i m o Vaggo 1. Ekadhippayena methuno dhammo patisevitabbo ti? * 622 2. Arahantanam vannena amanussa methunani dhani- niam patisevantiti ? ... ... ... ... 622 3. Bodhisatto issariyakamakarikahetu vinipatain gac- chatlti? ... 623 IN THE IvATHAVATTHU. Xlll No. PAGE 4. Atthi na rago ragapatirupako ti ? ... ... ... 625 5. Rupam aparinipphannan ti ? ... ... ... 626 INDICES. I. Index of Proper Names ... ... ... ... 631 II. Index of Passages from the Sutta Pitaka quoted in the Kathavatthu ... ... ... ... 633 VI. ].] KATHAVATTHU. 317 VI. 1. 1. Niyamo asamkhato ti "? Amanta. Nibbanam tanain lenam saranain parayanam accutam ^ amatan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Niyamo asamkhato, nibbanam asamkhatan ti ? Amanta. Dve asamkhataniti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve asamkhataniti '? Amanta. Dve tanani, dve lenani, dve saranani, dve parayanani, dve accutani, dve amatani, dve nibbananiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve nibbananiti ? Amanta. Atthi dvinnam nibbananani uccanTcata, hlnappanitata, ukkamsavakamso, slnia va bhedo va rajl va antarika va ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Niyamo asainkhato ti ? Amanta. Atthi keci niy amain okkamanti patihibhanti, uppadenti samuppadenti, utthapenti samutthapenti, nibbattenti abhinibbattenti, janenti sahjanentiti ? Amanta. Atthi keci asamkhatain okkamanti patikibhanti, uppa- denti samuppadenti, utthapenti samutthapenti, nibbat- tenti abhinibbattenti, janenti sahjanentlti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Niyamo asainkhato ti ? Amanta. Maggo asamkhato ti ? abbhutaiu, P. 318 KATHAVATTHU. [VI. 1. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Maggo samkhato ti '? Amanta. Niyamo samkhato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sotapattiniyamo asamkhato ti ? Amanta. Sotapattimaggo asamkhato ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Sotapattimaggo samkhato ti ? Amanta. Sotapattiniyamo samkhato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — ])e — Sakadagaminiyamo — pe — anagaminiyamo — pe — ara- hattaniyamo asamkhato ti '? Amanta. Arahattamaggo asamkhato ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahattamaggo sainkhato ti ? Amanta. . Arahattaniyamo sainkhato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Sotapattiniyamo asanikhato — pe — arahattaniyamo asainkhato, nibbanam asamkhatan ti '? Amanta. Pahca asamkhataniti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Panca asamkhataniti V Amanta. Pahca tanani — pe — antarlka va ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Niyamo asamkhato ti ? Amanta. Micchattaniyamo asainkhato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Micchattaniyamo sainkhato ti ? Amanta. Sammattaniyamo sainkhato ti ? VI. 2.] KATHAVATTHU. 319 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Na vattabbam " Niyamo asamkhato ti " ? Amanta. Niyame uppajja niruddhe aniyato hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi niyanio asamkhato ti. Micchattaniyame uppajja niruddhe aniyato hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi micchattaniyamo asamkhato ti. N i y a m a k a t h a . VI. '2. 1. Paticcasamuppado asamkhato ti '? Amanta. Nibbanam tanam lenam saranam parayanam accutam ^ amatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paticcasamuppado asamkhato, nibbanam asamkhatan ti? Amanta. Dve asamkhataniti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve asainkhataniti '? Amanta. Dve tanani, dve lenani, dve saranani, dve parayanani, dve accutani, dve amatani, dve nibbananiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve nibbananiti ? Amanta. Atthi dvinnam nibbananam uccanlcata, hlnappanitata, ukkamsavakamso, sima va bhedo va rfijl va antaiika va ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — abbhutam, P. 320 KATHAVATTHU. [VI. 2. 2. Paticcasamuppado asamkhato ti ? Anianta. Avijja asamkhata ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Avijja samkhata ti ? Amanta. Paticcasamuppado samkbato ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe— pe — Paticcasamuppado asamkhato ti '? Amanta. Avijjapaccaya samkhara asamkhata ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Avijjapaccaya samkhara samkhata ti ? Amianta. Paticcasamuppado samkhato ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Paticcasamuppado asamkhato ti ? Amanta. Sainkharapaccaya viniianani asamkhatan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sainkharapaccaya viiihanam sainkhatan ti '? Amanta. Paticcasamuppado sainkhato ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — , Paticcasamuppado asainkhato ti ? Amanta. Vihnanapaccaya namarupain asamkhatan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vihnanapaccaya namarupain samkhatan ti ? Amanta. Paticcasamuppado sainkhato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Paticcasamuppado asainkhato ti ? Amanta. Jatipaccaya jaramaranam asamkhatan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Jatipaccaya jaramaranam sainkhatan ti ? Amanta. VI. 2.] KATHAVATTHU. 321 Paticcasamuppado samkhato ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Na vattabbam " Paticcasamuppado asamkhato ti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — •" Jatipaccaya Bhikkhave jaramaranam, uppada va Tathagatanam aniippada va Tathagatanam thita'va ^ sa dhatu dhammatthitata dham- maniyamata idappaccayata ; tain Tathagato abhisambuj- jhati, abhisameti ; abhisambujjhitva abhisametva acikkhati deseti, pannapeti patthapeti, vivarati vibhajati uttaiukaroti ; passathati c'aha jatipaccaya Bhikkhave jaramaranam, bhavapaccaya Bhikkhave jati — pe — avijjapaccaya Bhik- khave samkhara uppada va Tathagatanam anuppada va Tathagatanani thita'va sa dhatu — pe — passathati c'aha avijjapaccaya Bhikkhave samkhara, iti kho Bhikkhave ya tatra tathata ^ avitathata anahnathata 3 idappac- cayata, ayam vuccati Bhikkhave paticcasamuppado ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi paticcasamuppado asamkhato ti. 5. "Avijjapaccaya sanikhara ti" ya tattha dhammatthi- tata dhammaniyamata asamkhata, nibbanain asamkhatan ti? Amanta. Dve asamkhataniti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve asamkhataniti ? Amanta. Dve tanani — pe — antarlka va ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. "Avijjapaccaya samkhara ti " ya tattha dhammat- thitata dhammaniyamata asamkhat;!, " sanikharapaccaya vihhanan ti" ya tattha dhammatthitata dhammaniyamata asamkhata, nibbanam asanikhatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tini asamkhataniti '? I P. omits va. ^ tathagata, P. 3 annatatha, P. 22 322 KATHAVATTHU. [Yl. 3. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tini asaiiikhataniti ? Amanta. Tini tanani — pe — antaiika va ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— 7. " Avijjapaccaya sanikhara ti" ya tattha dhanimatthi- tata dhammaniyamata asainkhata, " samkharapaccaya vinnanan ti" va tattha dhaniinatthitata dhammaniyamata asainkhata — pe — , "jatipaccaya jaramaranan ti " ya tattha dhammatthitata dhammaniyamata asainkhata, nib- banam asamkliatan ti ? Amanta. Dvadasa asainkhataniti ? * Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dvadasa asainkhataniti '? Amanta. Dvadasa tanani — pe — dvadasa lenani — pe — antaiika va ti ? ' Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — P a t i c c a s a m u p p a d a k a t h a . VI. 3. 1. Cattari saccani asainkhataniti ? Amanta. Cattari tanani, cattari lenani, cattari saranani, cattari parayanani, cattari accutani, cattari amatani, cattari nibljananiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Cattari nibbananlti ? Amanta. Atthi cattunnain nibbananam uccanlcata, hinappanltata, ukkamsavakainso, sima va bhedo va rajl va antaiika va ti '? " Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Dukkhasaccam asamkhatan ti ? VI. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 3'J3 Amauta. Dukkham asamkhatan ti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dukkhasaccam asamkhatan ti '? Anianta. Kayikaiii dukkhain, cetasikam dukkham, sokaparideva- dukkhadomanassupayasa asamkhata ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samudayasaccam asamkhatan ti ? Amanta. Samudayo asamkhato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samudayasaccam asanikhatan ti ? Amanta. Kamatanha bhavatanha vibhavatanha asanikhata ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Maggasaccam asamkhatan ti ? Amanta. Maggo asamkhato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Maggasaccam asamkhatan ti '? Amanta. Sammadittlii — pe — sammasamadhi asamkhato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Dukkham samkhatan ti ? Amanta. Dukkhasaccam samkhatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kayikain dukkham, cetasikam dukkham, sokaparideva- •dukkhadomanassiipayasa samkhata ti ? Amanta. Dukkhasaccam asamkhatan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Samudayo sainkhato ti "? Anianta. Samudayasaccam samkhatan ti .'' Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamatanha bhavatanha vibhavatanha sand^hata ti ? 824 KATHAVATTHU. [VI. 8. Aiuanta. Samudayasaccam samkhatan ti ? Na h'evaiu vattabbe — pe — Maggo samkhato ti ? Anianta. Maggasaccam samkhatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sammaditthi — ^pe — saniinasaniadhi samkhato ti ? Amanta. Maggasaccam sainkhatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Nirodhasaccain asainkhatain, nirodho asamkhato ti? Amanta. Dukkhasaccain asainkhatain, dukkham asainkhatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nirodhasaccain asainkhatain, nirodho asamkhato ti V Amanta. Samudayasaccam asainkhatain, samiidayo asauikhato ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Nirodhasaccain asainkhatain, nirodho asainkhato ti V Amanta. Maggasaccain asainkhatain, maggo asainkhato ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Dukkhasaccain asainkhatain, dukkham sainkhatan ti ■' Amanta. Nirodhasaccain asainkhatain, nirodho samkhato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Samudayasaccam asainkhatain, samudayo sainkhato ti? Amanta. Nirodhasaccain asainkhatain, nirodho samkhato ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Maggasaccam asamkhatam, maggo samkhato ti ? Amanta. Nirodhasaccain asainkhatain, nirodho sainkhato ti ? Na h'evam vattab])e — pe — (■). Na vattabam " Cattari saccani asamkhataniti " ? YI. 4.j KATHAVATTHU. 325 Aiiianta. Nanu vuttain Bhagavata — " Cattar'iiiiani Bhikkhave tathani avitathani anannathani. Katamani cattari "/ Idam dvikkhan ti Bhikkhave tatham etain avitatham etam anahhatham etam- -pe — ayain dukkhasamiidayo ti — pe — ayam dukkhanirodho ti — pe — ayam dukkhanii'odha- gaminl patipada ti tatham etain avitathaiii etam anahiiathani etam : imani kho Bhikkhave cattari tathani avitathani anahhathanlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi cattari saccani asainkhatanlti. Saccakatha. VI. 4. 1. Akasanahcayatanani asamkhatan ti ? Amanta. Nibhanam tanain lenain saranam parayanain accutani amatan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Akasanahcayatanani asamkhatam, nibbanam asam- khatan ti '? Amanta. Dve asamkhatanlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — ])e — Dve asainkhatanlti ? Amanta. Dve tanani — pe — antarlka va ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Akasanahcayatanain asanikhatan ti ? Amanta. Akasanahcayatanani ])liavo gati sattavaso sainsaro yoiii vifiiianatthiti attabhavapatiliibho ti ? Amanta. 3'26 KATHAVATTHU. 'VI. 4. Asamkhatani bhavo gati sattavaso samsaro j'oni vinnanatthiti attabhavapatilabho ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi akasanancayatannpagani kamman ti ? Amanta. x\.tthi asainkhatupagain kanmian ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi akasanaiicayatanupaga satta ti ? Amanta. Atthi asainkhatupaga satta ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 8. Akasanaiicaj^atane satta jayanti ]"Iyanti miyanti cavanti uppajjantiti ? Amanta. Asainkhate satta jayanti jiyanti miyanti cavanti uppajjantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Akasanahcayatane atthi vedana saiiha samkhanl vihiianan ti '? Amanta. Asamkhate atthi vedana sahiia samkhara viiihanan ti "? Na h'evaiii vattabbe — pe — Akasanaiicayatanam catuvokarabhavo ti ? Amanta. Asamkhatain catuvokarabhavo ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 4. Na vattabbain " Cattaro aruppa asamkhata ti " '? Amanta. Nanu cattaro aruppa aneja ^ vutta Bhagavata ti? Amanta. Hahci cattaro aruppa aneja vutta Bhagavata, tena vata re vattabbe " Cattaro aruppa asamkhata ti." A r u p p a k a t h a . ^ anehja, K. VI. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 327 VI. 5. 1. Nirodhasamapatti asamkhata ti? Ainanta. Nibbanam tanam lenam saranam parayanam accutam amatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe-^— pe — Nirodhasamapatti asamkhata, nibbanam asamkhatan Amanta. Dve asamkhataniti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve asamkhataniti ? Amanta. Dve tanani — pe — antarlka va ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Atthi keci nirodham samapajjanti patilabhanti, uppadenti samuppadenti, utthapenti samutthapenti, nibbattenti abhinibbattenti, janenti sahjanentiti ? Amanta. Atthi keci asamkhatam samapajjanti patilabhanti, uppadenti samuppadenti, utthapenti samutthapenti, nibbattenti abhinibbattenti, janenti sanjanentiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Nirodha vodanam vutthanam pahnayatiti ? Amanta. Asamkhata vodanam vutthanam paMayatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nirodham samapajjantassa pathamain nirujjhati vacisamkharo, tato kayasamkharo, tato cittasamkharo ti? Amanta. Asamkhatam samapajjantassa pathamam nirujjhati vacisamkharo, tato kayasainkharo, tato cittasanikharo ti ? ' Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nirodha vutthahantassa pathamam uppajjati cittasam- kharo, tato kayasamkharo, tato vacisamkharo ti? 328 , KATHAVATTHU. [VI. 6. Anianta. Asamkhata vutthahantassa pathaniain uppajjati citta- samkharo, tato kayasamkharo, tato vaclsamkharo ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 4. Nirodha vutthitam tayo phassa phusanti, suniiato phasso, animitto phasso, appanihito phasso ti? Amanta. Asamkhata vutthitain tayo phassa phusanti, suiinato phasso, animitto phasso, appanihito phasso ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Nirodha vutthitassa vivekaninnain cittam hoti vivekaponain vivekapabbharan ti ? Amanta. Asamkhata vutthitassa vivekaninnain cittam hoti vivekoponain vivekapabbharan ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe— pe — 5. Na vattabbani " Nirodhasamapatti asamkhata ti " ? Amanta. Sainkhata ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Tena hi nirodhasamapatti asainkhata ti. N i r o d h a s a m a p a 1 1 i k a t h a . VI. 6. 1 . Akaso asamkhato ti ? Amanta. Nibbanain tanain lenam saranam parayanain accutam amatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — • Akaso asamkhato, nibbanain asamkhatan ti ? Amanta. Dve asamkhataniti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve asamkhataniti ? VI. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 329 Amanta. Dve tanani — pe — antaiika va ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Akaso asamkhato ti ? Amanta. Atthi keci anakasam akasam karontiti ? Amanta. Atthi keci sainkhatam asamkhatam karontiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi keci akasam anakasain karontiti ? Amanta. Atthi keci asamkhataiu samkhatani karontiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Akase pakkhiyo gacchanti, candimasuriya gacchanti, tarakarupani gacchanti, iddhim vikubbanti, bahuni calenti, panim calenti, leddum khipanti, lagulam khipanti, iddhini khipanti, usmn khipantiti '? Amanta. Asamkhate pakkhiyo gacchanti, candimasuriya gac- chanti, tarakarupani gacchanti, iddhini vikubbanti, bahum calenti, panim calenti, leddum khipanti, lagulam khipanti, iddhiin khipanti, usum khipantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Akasain parivaretva gharani karonti, kotthani karon- tlti_? Amanta. Asamkhatam parivaretva gharani karonti, kotthani karontiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Udapane khahiiamane ^ anakaso akaso hotiti ? Amanta. Samkhatam asamkhatani hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tuccha-udapane puriyamane, tucchakotthe puriyamane, tucchakumbhiya puriyamanaya, fikaso antaradhayatiti ? Amanta. > khajamane, P. 330 KATHAVATTHU. [A^I. 7. Asainkhatam antaradhayatiti ? Na h'evaiu vattabbe— pe — 5. Na vattabbam " Akaso asamkhato ti " ? Amanta. Akaso sainkhato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi akaso asamkhato ti. Akasakatha. VI. 7. 1. Akaso sanidassano ti ? Amanta. Rupam rupayatanam rupadhatii nllam pitakam lohita- kam odatam cakkhuvihneyyam cakkhusmim patihannati cakkhussa apathain ^ agacchatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Akaso sanidassano ti? Amanta. Cakkhun ca paticca akasan ca uppajjati cakkhuviiina- nan ti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkhnfi ca paticca akasan ca uppajjati cakkhuviiifia- nan ti ? Amanta. " Cakkhufi ca paticca akasan ca uppajjati cakkhuvihna- nan ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? N'atthi. "Cakkhun ca paticca rupe ca uppajjati cakkhuvihfianan ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Hahci " Cakkhufi ca paticca rupe ca uppajjati cakkuvih- nanan ti," atth'eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe I apataiu, M. ; abadhain, S.So. VI. 8.] KATHAVATTHU. 331 " Cakkhun ca paticca akasan ca uppajjati cakkhuvinfianan ti." 3. Na vattabbam " Akaso sanidassano ti " ? Amanta. Nanu passati dvinnain rukkhanaiii antaraiu, dvinnam thambhanam ^ antaraiu, talacchiddain, vatapanacchiddan ti? Amanta. Hanci passati dvinnam rukkhanam antaram, dvinnam thambhanam antaram, talacchiddam, vatapanacchiddam, tena vata re vattabbe " Akaso sanidassano ti." Akaso sanidassano ti katha. VI. 8. 1. Pathavidhatu sanidassana ti'? Amanta. Rtipam rupayatanain rupadhatu nllain pitakam lohita- kam odatam cakkhuviiiiieyyain cakkhusmim patihaiinati cakkhussa apathain agacchatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Pathavidhatu sanidassana ti ? Amanta. Cakkhmi ca paticca pathavldhatuh ca uppajjati cakkhu- vihhanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkhun ca paticca pathavldhatuh ca uppajjati cakkhu- vihiianan ti ? Amanta. " Cakkhun ca paticca pathavldhatuh ca uppajjati cak- khuvihhanan ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? N'atthi. " Cakkhun ca paticca rupe ca uppajjati cakkhuvihhanan ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti V Amanta. ^ dhammanam, P. 88'2 KATHAVATTHU. ! VI. 8. Hanci " Cakkhun ca paticca iTipe ca uppajjati cakkuvin- nanan ti," atth'eva siittanto, no vata re vattabbe " Cak- khun ca paticca pathavldhatun ca uppajjati cakkhuvin- nanan ti ? 3. Na vattabbam " Pathavldhatu sanidassana ti" ? Amanta. Nanu passati bhuniini pasanani pabbatan ti ? Amanta. Hanci passati bhumini pasanan_i pabbatani, tena vata re vattabbe " Pathavldhatu sanidassana ti." Na vattabbam " Apodhatu sanidassana ti " '? Amanta. Nanu passati udakan ti ? Amanta. Hanci passati udakam, tena vata re vattabbe " Apodhatu sanidassana ti." Na vattabbain " Tejodhatu sanidassana ti " '? Amanta. Nanu passati aggini jalantan ti ? Amanta. Hanci passati aggiin jalantain. tena vata re vattabbe " Tejodhatu sanidassana ti." Na vattabbain " Vayodhatu sanidassana ti " ? Amanta. Nanu passati vatena rukkhe sancaliyamane ti ? Amanta. Hanci passati vatena rukkhe sancahyamane, tena vata re vattabbe " Vavodhatu sanidassana ti." 4. Cakkhundriyam sanidassanan ti ? Amanta. Bupam rupayatanam rupadhatu nilain pltakain lohita- kam odatain cakkhuviiiheyyani cakkhusmiin patihahnati cakkhussa apathain agacchatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Cakkhundriyani sanidassanan ti ? Amanta. Cakkhun ca paticca cakkliundj-iyah ca uppajjati cakkhu- vihhanan ti ? VI. 8.] KATHAVATTHU. 333 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkhun ca paticca cakkhundriyanca uppajjati cakkhii- vinnanan ti ? Anianta. " Cakkhun ca paticca cakkhundriyan ca uppajjati cak- khuviiihanan ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? N'atthi. " Cakkhun ca paticca rupe ca uppajjati cakkhuviiihanan ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Hanci " Cakkhun ca paticca rupe ca uppajjati cakkhu- viiihanan ti," atth'eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe " Cakkhun ca paticca cakkhundriyah ca uppajjati cakkhu- viiihanan ti." 6. Na vattabbam " Pahc'indriyani sanidassananlti "? Amanta. Nanu passati cakkhuin sotam ghanam jivham kayan ti ? Anianta. Hahci passati cakkhuin sotain ghanain jivham kayam, tena vata re vattabbe " Pahc'indriyani sanidassana- nlti." 7. Kayakanimani sanidassanaii ti? Amanta. Riipam rupayatanam rupadhatu nliani pltakain lohita- kain odatain cakkhuvihheyyain cakkhusmini patihahhati cakkhussa apathain agacchatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Kayakammam sanidassanaii ti ? Amanta. Cakkhun ca paticca kayakammah ca uppajjati cakkhu- vihhanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe- pe — Cakkhun ca paticca kayakammah ca uppajjati cakkhu- vihhanan ti ? Amanta. " Cakkhun ca paticca kayakammah ca uppajjati cakkhu- viiihanan ti." Atth'eva, suttanto ti ? N'atthi. 334 KATHAVATTHU. [VI. 8. " Cakkhun ca paticca rupe ca uppajjati cakkhuvifinanan ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti '? Amanta. Haiici " Cakkhun ca paticca rupe ca uppajjati cakkhu- vinnanan ti," atth'eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe " Cakkun ca paticca kayakamman ca uppajjati cakkhuvin- iianan ti." 0. Na vattabbam " Kayakammam sanidassanan ti " ? Amanta. Nanu passati abhikkamantam i patikkamantam aloken- tam vik:)kentam saniihjeiitam pasarentan ti ? Amanta. Haiici passati abhikkamantain patikkamantam aloken- tam vilokentam saminjentain pasarentam, tena vata re vattabbe " Kayakammam sanidassanan ti." P a t h a V ! d h a t u s a n i d a s s a n a t i a d i k a t h a , k a y a k a m m a in sanidassanan t i p a r i y o- s an a k at h a-. C li a 1 1 h o V a g g o . Niyamo asanikhato, Paticcasamuppado asamkhato, Cattari saccani asanikhatani, Cattaro aruppa asamkhata, Nirodhasaniapatti asamkhata, Akaso asamkhato, Akaso sanidassano, Cattaro niahal)huta, Pahc'indriyani, tatth'eva Kayakam- man ti. 1 atikkamantam, P. VII. 1.] KATHAVATTHU. 885 VII. 1. 1. N'atthi keci dhamma kehici dhammehi samgahlta ti ? Amanta. Nanu atthi keci dh annua kehici dhammehi f^ananam gacchanti, uddesam gacchanti, pariyapanna ti ? Amanta. Hahci atthi keci dhamma kehici dhammehi gananam gacchanti, uddesam gacchanti, pariyapanna, no vata re vattabbe " N'atthi keci dhamma kehici dhammehi samga- hlta ti." 2. Cakkhayatanam katamam khandagananam gaccha- tlti •? Rupakkhandhagananam gacchatlti. Hanci rupakkhandhagananam gacchati, tena vata re vattabbe" Cakkhayatanam rupakkhandhenasamgahitanti." Sotayatanam — pe — ghanayatanam — pe — jivhayatanam — pe — kayayatanam katamam khandhagananam gaccha- tlti •? Eupakkhandhagananam gacchatlti. Haiici kayayatanani nipakkhandhagananam gacchati, tena vata re vattabbe " Kayayatanam rupakkhandhena saingahitan ti." 8. Eupayatanam — pe. — saddayatanam — pe — gandhaya- tanam — pe — rasayatanam — pe — photthabbayatanain kata- maiu khandhagananam gacchatlti '? Eupakkhandhagananam gacchatlti. Hahci photthabbayatanain rupakkhandhagananam gac- chati, tena vata re vattabbe " Photthabbayatanain rupak- khandhena saingahitan ti." 4. Sukha vedana katamain khandhagananam gacchatlti ? Vedanakkhandhagananani gacchatlti. Hahci sukha vedana vedanakkhandhagananani gacchati, tena vata re vattabbe " Sukha vedana vedanakkhandhena samgahlta ti." Dukkha vedana — pe — adukkhamasuklia vedana kata.- main khandhagananain gacchatlti ? 336 KATHAVATTHU. [VII. 1. Vedanakkhandhagaiianam gacchatiti . Hanoi adukkhaniasukha vedana vedanakkandhaefananain gacchati, tena vata re vattabbe " Adukkhaniasukha vedana vedanakkhandhena samgahlta ti." 5. Cakkhusamphassaja sahiia katamam khandhaga- nanani gacchatiti ? Saiifiakkhandhagananani gacchatiti. Hahci cakkhusamphassaja sahha sahhakkhandhagana- nam gacchati, tena vata re vattabbe " Cakkhusamphassaja sahha sahhakkhandhena samgahlta ti." Sotasamphassaja sahha — pe— manosamphassaja sahha katamain khandhagananam gacchatiti '? Sahhakkhandhagananam gacchatiti. Hahci manosamphassaja sahha sahhakkhandhagana- nam gacchati, tena vata re vattabbe " Manosamphassaja sahha sahhakkhandhena samgahlta ti." 6. Cakkhusamphassaja cetana — -pe — manosamphassaja cetana katamain khandhagananain gacchatiti "? Samkharakkhandhagananam gacchatiti. Hahci manosampliassaja cetana samkharakkhandhaga- nanain gacchati, tena vata re vattabbe "Manosamphassaja cetana sainkharakkhandhena saingahita ti." 7 . Cakkhuvihhanam — pe — manovihhanam katamam khandhagananain gacchatiti ? Vihhanakkhandhagananam gacchatiti . Hahci manovihhanam vihhanakkhandhagananam gac- chati, tena vata re vattabbe " Manovihhanam vihhanak- khandhena samgahltan ti." 8. Yatha dainena va yottena va dve bahbadda ^ samga- hlta, sikkaya pindapato samgahlto, sa gaddulena ^ sam- gahlto ; evameva te dhamma tehi dhammehi samgahlta ti? Amanta. Hahci damena va yottena va dve bahbadda saingahita, pahbatha, P. S2. ; bahbada, S. gamalena, S. ; katulena, P. S2. VII. 2. J KATHAVATTHU. 337 sikkaya pindapato saingahlto, sa gaddulena samgahlto, tena vata re vattabbe " Atthi keci dhamma kehici dhani- mehi saingahlta ti." "&' Saingahitakatha VII. 2. 1. N' atthi keci dhamma kehici dhammehi sampayiitta ti? Amanta. Nanu atthi keci dhamma kehici dhammehi sahagata sahajata samsattha ekuppada ekanirodha ekavatthuka ^ ekarammana ti ? Amanta. Hahci atthi keci dhamma kehici dhammehi sahagata sahajata samsattha ekuppada ekanirodha ekavatthuka ekarammana, no vata re vattabbe " N'atthi keci dhamma kehici dhammehi sampayutta ti." 2. Vedanakkhandho saiiiiakkhandhena sahajato ti ? Amanta. Hahci vedanakkhandho saiiiiakkhandhena sahajato, tena vata re vattabbe "Vedanakkhandho saiiiiakkhandhena sampayutto ti." Vedanakkhandho sanikharakkhandhena vihhanakkhan- dhena sahajato ti ? Amanta. Haiici vedanakkhandho viiiiianakkhandhena sahajato, tena vata re vattabbe "Vedanakkhandho vihhanakkhan- dhena sampayutto ti." Sahhakkhandho, sanikharakkhandho, viiiiianakkhandho vedanakkhandhena, saiinakkhandhena, sanikharakkhan- dhena sahajato ti ? Amanta. Haiici vihfianakkhaudho sanikharakkhandhena salia- I ekavattuka, P. 23 338 KATHAVATTHU. [VII. 3. jato, tena vata re vattabbe " Vinnanakkhandho sam- kharakkhandhena sampayutto ti." Yatha tilamhi ^ telam anugatam anupavittham, uc- chumhi raso anugato anupavittho, evameva te dhamma tehi dhammehi anugata anupavittha ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sampayuttakatha. VII. 3. 1. N'atthi cetasiko dhammo ti? Amanta. Nanu atthi keci dhamma cittena sahagata sahajata samsattha sampayutta ekuppada ekanirodha ekavatthuka ekarammana ti ? Amanta. Hanci atthi keci dhamma cittena sahagata sahajata samsattha sampayutta ekuppada ekanirodha ekavatthuka ekarammana, no vata re vattabbe "N'atthi cetasiko dhammo ti." 2. Phasso cittena sahajato ti ? Amanta. Hahci phasso cittena sahajato, tena vata re vattabbe *' Phasso cetasiko ti." Vedana — pe — sahfia, cetana — pe — saddha viriyam sati samadhi paiiiia rago doso moho — pe — anottappam cittena sahajatan ti ? Amanta. Hahci anottappam cittena sahajatam, tena vata re vat- tabl^e "Anottappam cetasikan ti." 3. Cittena sahajata ti katva cetasika ti ? Amanta. Phassena sahajata ti katva phassika ti ? Amanta. Cittena sahajata ti katva cetasika ti ? I sllamhi, P.S2. VII. 4.] KATHAVATTHU. 889 Amanta. Vedanaya — pe — sannaya cetanaya saddhaya viriyena satiya samadhiya pannaya ragena dosena mohena — pe — anottappena sahajata ti katva anottappasika ^ ti? Amanta. 4. N'atthi cetasiko dhammo ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttain Bhagavata — " Cittan h'idam cetasika ca dhamma Anattato samviditassa honti. Hinappanltain tadubbaye viditva Sammaddaso ^ vedi 3 palokadbamman 4 ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena bi attbi cetasiko dbammo ti. 5. N'attbi cetasiko dhammo ti '? Amanta. Nanu vuttani Bbagavata — " Idba Kevattas bbikkbu parasattanani parapuggalanam cittain pi adisati, ceta- sikam pi adisati, vitakkitam pi adisati, vicaritam pi adi- sati ' Evani pi te mano, itthain ^ pi te mano, iti pi te cittan ti,' " Attb'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena bi attbi cetasiko dbammo ti. Cetasikakatba. VII. 4. 1. Cetasiko dbammo dajian ti ? Amanta. 1 anottappain siya ti, P.8.S2. 2 sampbattaso, P.; sampayuttaso, S. 3 veri, P.8.S2 4 phaloka°, P. 5 Kevatta all MSS. See Digba xi., note i2, p. 211. 6 ittam, P. 840 KATHAVATTHU. [VIT. 4. Labbha cetasiko dhammo paresain datun ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Labbha cetasiko dhammo paresam datuii ti ? Amanta. Labbha phasso paresam datun ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Labbha vedana — pe — sahiia cetana saddha viriyain sati samadhi — pe — panfia paresani datun ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe- — pe — 2. Na vattabbain " Cetasiko dhammo danan ti " ? Amanta. Danam anitthaphalain akantaphalam amanuiihaphalain secanakaphalam dukkhindriyain '- dukkhavipakan ti V Nanu danam itthaphalain kantaphalam manuhfiaphalam asecanakaplialain sukhindriyam sukhavipakan ti ? Amanta. Hahci danain itthaphalain kantaphalam manuhha- phalam asecanakaplialain sukhindriyain sukhavipakani, ten a vata re vattabbe " Cetasiko dhammo danan ti." 8. Danam itthaphalain vuttam Bhagavata, clvarain danan ti V Amanta. Civarain itthaphalain kantaphalain manuhnaphalain asecanakaplialain sukhindriyain sukhavipakan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Danain itthaphalain vuttani Bhagavata, pindapato, senasanam, gilanapaccayabhesajjaparikkharo danan ti V Amanta. Gilanapaccayabhesajjaparikkharo itthaphalo kantaphalo manumiaphalo asecanakaphalo sukhindriyo sukhavipako ti? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 4. Na vattabbain " Cetasiko dhammo danan ti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttani Bhagavata— dukkhudrayain, M.K. VII. 4.] KATHAVATTHU. Ml " Saddha hiriyam '^ kusalan ca danam Dhamma ete sappurisanuyata Etam hi maggam diviyam vadanti ^ Etena hi gacchati devalokan ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi cetasiko dhammo danan ti. 5. Na vattabbam " Cetasiko dhammo danan ti " '? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Panc'imani Bhikkhave •danani inahadanani aggahhani rattahhani vainsahnani poranani asamkinnani asamkinnapubbani na samklyanti, na saniklyissanti, appatikutthani samanehi brahmanehi vinhuhi. Katamani pahca ? Idha Bhikkhave ariyasavako j)anatipatam pahaya panatipata pativirato hoti, panatipata pativirato Bhikkhave ariyasavako aparimananam sattanani abhayam deti, averam deti, abyapajjhain deti, aparima- nanam sattanani abhayani datva, averaiii datva, abyapaj- jhain datva aparimanassa abhayassa averassa abyapaj- jhassa bhagi hoti : idam Bhikkhave pathamain danani inahadanani aggahhani rattahhain vamsahhaiii poranaiii asainkinnain asamkinnapubbam na saniklyati, na saiii- kiyissati, appatikutthani samanelii brahmanehi viiihuhi. Puna ca param Bhikkhave ariyasavako adinnadayam pahaya — pe — kamesu micchacaram pahaya — pe — musa- vadani pahaya — pe — suramerayamajjapamadatthanam pahaya suramerayamajjapamadatthana pativirato hoti, suramerayamajjapamadatthana pativirato Bhikldiave ari- yasavako aparimananain sattanani abhayaiii deti, averam deti, abyapajjhain deti, aparimananain sattanani abhayain datva, averam datva, abyapajjhain datva aparimanassa abhayassa averassa abyapajjhassa bhagI hoti : idani Bhik- 1 viriyam, P.S2. - dibbam caranti, P.S.S2. ; dibbani c'ayain vadanti, M. ; diviyani vadanti, K. ^/v/ 342 KATHAVATTHU. [VII. 4. khave pancainaiii danaiii mahadanam aggannam rattan- nam vamsaiinam poranain asamkinnam asamkinnapubbam na saniklyati, na samklyissati, appatikuttham sainanehi brahmanehi viiinuhi. Iiiiani kho Bhikkhave panca danani mahadanani aggaiinani rattannani vamsannani poranani asainkinnani asainkinnapiibbani na samklyanti, na samklyissanti, appatikutthani samanehi brahmanehi vihhuhlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Am ant a. Tena hi cetasiko dhammo danan ti. 6. Na vattabbaiii " Deyyadhammo danan ti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttani Bhagavata- — " Idh'ekacco annani deti, panam deti, vattham deti, yanam deti, malam deti, gan- dham deti, vilepanam deti, seyyam deti, avasatham deti, padipeyyani detiti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi deyyadhammo danan ti. 7. Deyyadhammo danan ti ? Amanta. Deyyadhammo itthaphalo kantaphalo manuhhaphalo asecanakaphalo sukhindriyo siikhavipako ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Danain itthaphalain vuttani Bhagavata, civaram danan tiV_ Amanta. Civaram itthaphalain kantaphalain manuhiiaphalam asecanakaphalain sukhindriyani sukhavipakan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Danain itthaphahim vuttam Bhagavata, pindapato danain, senasanain danam, gilanapaccayabhesajjaparik- kharo danan ti ? Amanta. Gilanapaccayabhesajjaparikkharo itthaphalo kantaphalo manuhhaphalo asecanakaphalo sukhindriyo sukhavipako ti? VII. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 343 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi na vattabbain " Dej-yadhammo danan ti." Danakatha. VII. 5. 1. Paribhogamayaiu punnam vaddhatiti ^ ? Amanta. Paribhogamayo phasso vaddhati, vedana vaddhati, sanna vaddhati, cetana vaddhati, cittam vaddhati, saddha vaddhati, viriyam vaddhati, sati vaddhati, saniadhi vad- dhati, pahiia vaddhatiti ? . Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paribhogamayain puhiiam vaddhatiti ? Amanta. Lata viya vaddhati, maluva viya vaddhati, rukkho viya vaddhati, tinain viya vaddhati, pmijapmijo viya vaddha- titi ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Paribhogamayain puhham vaddhatiti ? Amanta. Dayako danam datva na samannaharati, hoti pmliian ti? Amanta. Anavattantassa ^ hoti, anabhogassa hoti, asamanna- harantassa hoti, amanasikarontassa hoti, acetayantassa. hoti, apatthayantassa hoti, apanidahantassa hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Nanu avattantassa hoti, abhogassa hoti, samanna- harantassa hoti, manasikarontassa hoti, cetayantassa hoti, patthayantassa hoti, panidahantassa hotiti ? Amanta. 1 samvaddhati, P.S. 2 anavajjantassa, K. ; Atthakatha gives both va]]° and vatto. 344 KATHAVATTHU. [VII. 5. Haiici avattantassa hoti, abhogassa hoti, samanna- harantassa hoti, manasikarontassa hoti, cetayantassa hoti, patthayantassa hoti, panidahantassa hoti, no vata re vattabbe " Paribhogamayam pmiham vacldhatlti." 8. Paribhogamayani puhnaiii vaddhatiti '? Amanta. Dayako danaiii datva kamavitakkain vitakketi, byapa- davitakkam vitakketi, vihimsavitakkam vitakketi, hoti puhhan ti ? Amanta. Dvinnain phassanain ^ — pe — dvinnam cittanain samo- dhanain hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dvinnam phassanam — pe — dvinnain cittanam samo- dhanani hotiti ? Amanta. Kusalakusala savajjanavajja hlnappamta kanhasukka- sappatibhaga dhamma sammukhibhavam agacchantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kusalakusala - savajjanavajja hlnappamta kanhasukka- sappatibhaga dhamma sammukhibhavam agacchantiti '? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Cattar'imani Bhikkhave suvidiiravidiirani. Katamani cattari ? Nabhah ca Bhik- khave pathavi ca idani pathamam suviduravidiiram ; orimah ca Bhikkhave tiram samuddassa parimah ca tiram idam dutiyam suvidiiravidiiram ; yato ca Bhikkhave vero- cano abbhudeti yattha ca atthameti, idam tatiyain suvi- diiraviduram, satah ca Bhikkhave dhammos asatah ca dhammo, idam catuttham suvidiiravidrirain : imani kho Bhikkhave cattari suviddraviduranlti. Nabhah ca dure pathavi ca diire, Param samuddassa tadahu dure, ' phalanam, P.S.82. ; P.S.S2. omit the next two lines down to hinappanita. 2 P.S.S2 omit this question. . 3 dhamma, K, VII. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 845 Yato ca verocano abbhudeti Pabhankaro yattha ca atthameti, Tato li'eva durataram vadanti Satan ca dhammam asatan ca dhainmain ; Abyayiko lioti satain saniaganio Yavam pi tittheyya tath'eva hoti Khippam haveti ^ asatain sainagamo Tasma satam dhainmo asabbhi araka ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Ainanta. Tena hi iia vattabbam " Kusalakusala savajjanavajja hlnappanlta kanhasukkasappatibhaga dhamma sainmu- khlbhavam agacchantlti." 4. Na vattabbam " Paribhogamayam puiinam vaddha- tlti"? Amanta. Naiiu vuttaiii Bhagavata — " x-Vrainaropa vanaropa Ye jana setiikaraka Papan ca udapanan ca Ye dadanti npassayam,^ N^ 'y ^ '^> Tesam diva ca ratto ca '^^ Sada pminam pavaddhati, Dhainmattha sllasampanna Te jana saggagamino ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi paribhogamayain pmiiiam vaddhatiti. 5. Na vattabbam "Paribhogamayain pmihain vaddha- titi"? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Cattaro'me Bhikkhave 1 haveti, M.K. ; hi veti, Morris, Ang. iv. 47. 2 upasayain, P. 346 KATHAVATTHU, [VII. 5. pufinabhisanda kusalabhisanda sukhass'ahara sovaggika sukhavipaka saggasaiuvatttanika itthaya kantaya niana- paya hitaya sukhaya samvattanti. Katame cattaro? Yassa Bhikkhave bhikkhu clvarain paribhuiijaniano appa- manam cetosaniadhim iipasampajja viharati, appamano tassa punnabhisando kusalabhisando sukhass'aharo sovag- giko siikhavipako saggasamvattaniko itthaya kantaya manapaya hitaya sukhaya saiuvattati ; yassa Bhikkhave bhikkhu pindapatam paribhuhjainano — pe — senasanam paribhuhjamano — pe — gilanapaccayabhesajjaparikkharam paribhuiijaniano appanianam cetosaniadhim upasainpajja viharati, appamano tassa puiinabhisando kusalabhisando sukhass'aharo sovaggiko sukhavipako saggasamvattaniko itthaya kantaya manapaya hitaya sukhaya sanivattati. Ime kho Bhikkhave cattaro pufinabhisanda kusalabhi- sanda sukhass'ahara sovaggika sukhavipaka saggasam- vattanika itthaya kantaya manapaya hitaya sukhaya samvattantlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi paribhogamayani puhiiam vaddhatlti. 6. Paribhogamayani puhiiam vaddhatlti ? Amanta. Dayako danam deti, patiggahako patiggahetva na pari- bhuhjati chaddeti vissajjeti, hoti puhhan ti ? Amanta. Hahci dayako daiiani deti, patiggahako patiggahetva na paribhuhjati chaddeti vissajjeti, hoti puiiiiam, no vata re vattabbe " Paribhogamayani puhhani vaddhatlti." 7. Paribhogamayam puiiham vaddhatlti ? Amanta. Dayako danani deti, patiggahake patiggahite rajano va haranti, cora va haranti, aggi va dahati, udakam va vahati, appiya va dayada haranti, hoti puhhan ti ? Amanta. Hahci dayako danani deti, patiggahake patiggahite rajano va haranti, cora va haranti, aggi va dahati, udakam va vahati, appiya va dayada haranti, hoti puhham, no VII. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 347 vata re vattabbe ' ' Paribhogamayam punnain vaddhati- ti." Paribhogamayapunnakatha. VII. 6. 1. Ito dinnena tattha yapentiti ? Amanta. Ito civaram denti, tarn civaram tattha paribhunjantlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ito pindapatam denti, ito senasanam denti, ito gilana- paccayabhesajjaparikkharam denti, ito khadanlyam denti, ito bhojaniyam denti, ito panlyam denti, tattha paribhun- jantlti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ito dinnena tattha yapentiti ? Amanta. Anno aiihassa karako, parakatain sukhadukkham aiino karoti, anno patisamvedetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Na vattabbam " Ito dinnena tattha yapentiti " ? Amanta. Nanu peta attano atthaya danani dentam anmnodenti, cittam pasadenti, pitim uppadenti, somanassam patilab- bhantlti ? Amanta. Haiici peta attano atthaya danam dentam anmnodenti, cittam pasadenti, pItim uppadenti, somanassam patilab- bhanti, tena vata re vattabbe " Ito dmnena tattha yapen- titi." 3. Na vattabbain " Ito dinnena tattha yapentiti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Unname " udakain vuttham Yatha ninnam pavattati, I unnate, K. 348 KATHAVATTHU. [VII. 6. Evameva ito dinnain Petanam upakappati. Yatha varivaha pura Paripurenti sagarain, Evameva ito diiinaiii Petanam upakappati. Na hi tattha kasi atthi Gorakkh'ettha^ na vijjati, Vanijja^ tadisi n'atthi Hirannena kayakkayani, Ito dinnena yapenti Peta kalakata tahin ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi ito dinnena tattha yapentlti. 4. Na vattabbam " Ito dinnena tattha yapentlti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Pahc'imani Bhikkhave thanani sampassanta matapitaro puttam icchanti kule jayamanam. Ivatamani pahca ? Bhato va no bharissati,3 kiccam va no karissati, kulavaiiiso4 cirain thassati, dayajjam patipajjati,5 atha va pana petanam kakikatanam dakkhi- nam anuppadassati ^ : imani kho Bhikkhave paiica thanani sampassanta matapitaro puttam icchanti kule jayamanan ti. Paiica thanani sampassam Puttam icchanti pandita Bhato va no bharissati, Eiccain va no karissati, Kulavamso ciram7 titthe Dayajjam patipajjati,^ ^ ettam, P. ; etta, M. ^ vanija, M. skirissati, P. ; karissati, 8. 4 kusalam va so, P. 5 me patipajjissati, M. ^ aimpatissa, P.Sg. 7 civare, S. ; cire, P. . ^patipajjinati, M. VII. 7.] KATHAVATTHU. 349 Atha va paiia petaiiam Dakkhinam anuppadassati,^ Thanan'etani sampassam Puttam icchanti pandita. Tasma santo sappurisa Katannu katavedino Bharanti ^ matapitaro Pubbe katam anussarain, Karonti tesam kiccani Yatha tarn pnbbakarinam,3 Ovadakarl bhataposi 4 Kulavamsani ahapayam Saddho sllena sampanno Putto hoti pasamsiyos ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti '? Anianta. Tena hi ito dinnena tattha yapentiti. 1 1 o d i n n a k a t h a . VII. 7. 1. Pathavl kanimavipako ti ? Amanta. Sukhavedanlya dakkliavedaniya adiikkhainasukhave- danlya sukhaya vedanaya saiiipayutta dukkhaya vedanaya sampayutta adukkhamasukhaya vedanaya sampayutta phassena sampayutta vedanaya sampayutta saiinaya sampa- yutta cetanaya sampayutta cittena sampayutta sarannnana, atthi taya avattana^ abhogo samannaharo manasikaro cetana patthana panidhiti? I anupatissati, P.S2; anupatipassati, S. = a^.^nti, S. 3pubbatadinain, P.S.S2. 4 athaposi, S. Ssamphassiyo, P. ; sampassibho, S. ; sampassiyo, Sg. ^ avajjana, K. 350 KATHAVATTHU. [VII. 7. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu na sukhavedamya na dukkhavedaniya na aduk- khaiuasukhavedanlya na sukhaya vedanaya sanipayutta na dukkhaya vedanaya sampayutta na adukkhamasukhaya vedanaya sampayutta na phassena sampayutta na vedanaya sampayutta na sannaya sampayutta na cetanaya sampa- yutta na cittena sampayutta, anarannnana, n'atthi taya avattana abhogo samannaharo manasikaro cetana patthana panidhiti ? Amanta. Haiici na sukhavedamya — pe — anarammana, n'atthi taya avattana abhogo samannaharo manasikaro cetana patthana panidhi, no vata re vattabbe " Pathavl kammavi- pako ti." 2. Phasso kammavipako phasso sukhavedamyo dukkha- vedanlyo adukkhamasukhavedanlyo, sukhaya vedanaya sampayutto, dukkhaya — pe — adukkhamasukhaya vedanaya sampayutto, phassena sampayutto, vedanaya sampayutto, sahhaya sampayutto, cetanaya sampayutto, cittena sampa- yutto, sarammana, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Pathavl kammavipako pathavl sukhavedamya dukkha- vedaniya adukkhamasukhavedanlya, sukhaya vedanaya sampayutta, dukkhaya — pe — adukkhamasukhaya vedanaya sampayutta, phassena sampayutta, vedanaya sampayutta, sahhaya sampayutta, cetanaya sampayutta, cittena sampa- yutta, sarammana, atthi taya avattana — pe — panidhiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Pathavl kammavipako, pathavl iia sukhavedanlya, na dukkhavedaniya — pe — anarammana, n'atthi taya avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Phasso kammavipako, phasso na sukhavedamyo, na dukkhavedanlyo — pe — anarammano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? 8. Pathavl kammavipako ti ? Amanta. Pathavl paggahaniggahupaga chcdanabhedanupaga ti ? VII. 7.] KATHAVATTHU. 351 Amanta. Kammavipako paggahaniggahiipago chedanabhedanu- pago ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Labbha pathav! ketum viketum ^ athapetum ocinitum vicinitun ti ? Amanta. Labbha kammavipako ketuin viketum athapetum ocini- tum vicinitun ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — ^pe — Pathavi paresam sadharana ti ? Amanta. Kammavipako paresam sadharano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kammavipako paresam sadharano ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Asadharanam aiinesani Acoraharano 2 nidhi, Kayiratha macco 3 puiinani Sace sucaritam careti." Atth'eva suttanto ti '? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Kammavipako paresam sadha- rano ti." 4. Pathavi kammavipako ti ? Amanta. Pathamani pathavi santhati,4 paccha satta uppajjantiti? Amanta. Pathamani vipako uppajjati, paccha vipakapatilabhaya kammam karontiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — 5. Pathavi sabbasattanam kammavipako ti ? ' vikketum, M, 2 ^tha coraharano, P. 3 kayirathammacco, P. 4sandhati, P. 352 KATHAVATTHU. [VII. 7. Ainanta. Sabbe satta patbavim paribbunjantlti ? Na b'evam vattabbe — pe — Sabbe satta patbavim paribbunjantlti '? Amanta. Atthi keci patbavim aparibbmljitva ^ parinibbayantiti ?2 Amanta. Attbi keci kammavipakam akbepetva parinibbayantiti? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — 6. Patbavl Cakkavattisattassa kammavipako ti ? Amanta. Aiine satta patbavim paribbunjantlti ? Amanta. Cakkavattisattassa kammavipakam anne satta pari- bbuiijantlti ? Na b'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkavattisattassa kammavipakain anne satta pari- bbunjantlti ? Amanta. Cakkavattisattassa phassam vedanam saiinam cetanam cittam saddbain viriyam satim samadbiin paniiain aiine satta paribbunjantlti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 7. Na vattabbani " Patbavl kammavipako ti "? Amanta. Nanu attbi issariyasamvattanikani 3 kammam, adhipac- casamvattanikani kamman ti. Amanta. Hanoi attbi issariyasainvattanikam kammam, adbipacca- sainvattanikain kammain, tena vata re vattabbe "Patbavl kammavipako ti." Patbavl k a m m a v i p a k a k a t b a. pari°, K. ^ apari°, P. 3 oyam, M.K. VII. 8.j KATHAVATTHU. 353 VII. 8. 1. Jaramaranam vipako ti ? Am ant a. Sukhaveclanlyani dukkhavedanlyam adukkhamasukha- vedanlyam sukhaya vedanaya sampayuttam dukkhaya vedanaya sampayuttam adukkhamasukliaya vedanaya sampayuttam phassena sampayuttam vedanaya sampa- yuttam safinaya sampayuttam cetanaya sampayuttain cittena sampayuttam sarammanain, atthi tassa avattana abhogo samannaharo manasikaro cetana patthana pani- dhlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu na sukhavedanlyam — pe — anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Haiici na sukhavedanlyain— pe — anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Jara- maranam vipako ti." 2. Phasso vipako, phasso sukhavedanlyo — pe — saram- mano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Jaramaranam vipako, jaramaranam sukhavedanlyain — pe — sarammanain, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Jaramaranam vipako, jaramaranam na sukhavedanlyam — pe — anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — pani- dhiti ? Amanta. Phasso vipako, phasso na sukhavedanlyo — pe — anaram- mano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Akusalanam dhammanam jaramaranam akusalanain dhammanam vipako ti '? Amanta. Kusalanam dhammanain jaramaranain kusalaiiam dhammanain vipako ti ? 24 354 KATHAVATTHU. [VII. 8. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kusalanam dhammanam jaramaranam na vattabbain " Kusalanam dhammanam vipako ti " ? Amanta. Akusalanam dhammanam jaramaranam na vattabbam " Akusalanam dhammanam vipako ti " ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Kusalanam dhammanam jaramaranam akusalanam dhammanam vipako ti ? Amanta. Akusalanam dhammanam jaramaranam kusalanam dhammanam vipako ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Akusalanam dhammanam jaramaranam na vattabbam " Kusalanam dhammanain vipako ti " ? Amanta. Kusalanam dhammanam jaramaranam na vattabbam • (I • • • " Akusalanam dhammanam vipako ti " ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Kusalanah ca akusalanaii ca dhammanam jaramara- nam akusalanam dhammanam vipako ti ? Amanta. Kusalanan ca akusalanah ca dhammanam jaramaranam kusalanam dhammanam vipako ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kusalanah ca akusalanafi ca dhammanam jaramaranam na vattabbam " Kusalanam dhammanam vipako ti " *? Amanta. Kusalanah ca akusalanah ca dhammanam jaramara- nam na vattabbam " Akusalanam dhammanam vipako ti"? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — (). Na vattabbain " Jaramaranam vipako ti " ? Amanta. Nanu atthi dubbannasamvattanikain kammam, appa- yukasamvattanikam kamman ti ? Amanta. Hahci atthi dubbannasamvattanikain kammam, appayu- VII. 9.] KATHAVATTHU. 355 kasamvattanikam kamniam, tena vata re vattabbe " Jara- maranam vipako ti." J a r a in a r a n a m v i p a ko t i k a t h a. VII. 9. 1. N'atthi ariyaclhaminavipako ti ? Amanta. Nann mahapphalam samaiinam, mahapphalain brah- mannan ti ? Amanta. Hanci mahapphalam samanham, mahapphalam brah- mahham, no vata re vattabbe " N'atthi ariyadhammavi- pako ti." 2. N'atthi ariyadhammavipako ti ? Amanta. Nanu atthi sotapattiphalan ti ? Amanta. Haiici atthi sotapattiphalam, no vata re vattabbe " N'atthi ariyadhammavipako ti." Nanu atthi sakadagamiphalam — pe — anagamiphalain — pe — arahattaphalan ti? Amanta. Hafici atthi arahattaphalam, no vata re vattabbe " N'atthi ariyadhammavipako ti." 8. Sotapattiphalam na vipako ti ? Amanta. Danaphalam na vipako ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe— pe — Sotapattiphalain na vipako ti ? Amanta. Sllaphalani — pe — bhavanaphalam na vipako ti '? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Sakadagainiphalain — pe — anagamiphalain — pe — arahat- taphalaiii na vipako ti ? Amanta. 356 KATHAVATTHU. [VII. 9. Danaphalam na vipako ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahattaphalam na vipako ti ? Ainanta. Sllaphalam — pe — bliavanaphalaiii na vipako ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 4. Danaphalam vipako ti ? Anianta. Sotapattiphalam vipako ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Danaphalam vipako ti ? Amanta. Sakadagamiphalani — pe — anagamiphalani — pe — arahat- taphalam vipako ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Silaphalam — pe — bhavanaphalain vipako ti ? Amanta. Sotapattiphalain vipako ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Bhavanaphalain vipako ti ? Amanta. Sakadagamiphalani — pe — anagamiphalani — pe — araliat- taxihalam vipako ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Kamavacaram kusalam savipakan ti V Anianta. Lokuttaram kusalam savipakan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — linpavacarain kusalam — pe — arupavacarain kusalam savipakan ti? Ainanta. Lokuttarain kusalam savipakan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe^pe — Lokuttarain kusalain avipakan ti ? Amanta. Kamavacaram kusalam avipakan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Lokuttarain kusalam avipakan ti ? VII. 10.] KATHAVATTHU. 357 Amanta. Eupavacaraiii kusalani — pe — arupavacaram kusalam avipakan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — 6. Kamavacarain kusalam savipakam acayagamiti ? ' Amanta. Lokuttaram kusalain savipakam acayagamiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Rupavacarain kusalain — pe — • arupavacarain kusalain savipakam acayagamiti ? Amanta. Lokuttarain kusalain savipakain acayagamiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe— Lokuttarain kusalain savipakain apacayagamiti ? Amanta. Kamavacarain kusalain savipakain apacayagamiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Lokuttarain kusalani savipakain apacayagamiti ? Amanta. Rupavacarain kusalam — pe — arupavacarain kusalain savipakain apacayagamiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — A r i y a d h a in m a V i p a k a k a t h a. VII. 10. 1. Vipako vipakaclhammadhamino ti ? Amanta. Tassa vipako vipakadhammadhammo ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Tassa vipako vipakadhammadhammo ti ? Amanta. Tassa tass'eva n'atthi dukkhassa antakiriya, n'atthi vattupacchedo, n'atthi anupadaparinibbanan ti ? I °gamin ti, M. 358 KATHAVATTHU. [VII. 10. Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 2. Vipako vipakadhammadhammo ti V Ainanta. Vipako ti va vipakadhammadhammo ti va, vipakadham- madhammo ti va, vipako ti va, esese ekatthe same sabhage tajjjite ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Vipako vipakadhammadhammo ti ? Amanta. Vipako ca vipakadhammadhammo ca, vipakadhamma- dhammo ca vipako ca sahagata sahajata samsattha sam- payutta ekuppada ekanirodha ekavatthnka ekarammana ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Vipako vipakadhammadhammo ti "? Amanta. Tail iieva akusalain so akiisalassa vipako, tail neva kusaiam so kusalassa vipako ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vipako vipakadhammadhammo ti ? Amanta. Yen'eva cittena panani haiiati, ten'eva citteiia niraye paccati : yen'eva cittena daiiani deti, ten'eva cittena sagge modatiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 5. Na vattabbain " Vipako vipakadhammadhammo ti " ? Amanta. Nanu vipaka cattaro khandha arupino ^ ahiiamaniia- paccaya ti ? Amanta. Hanoi vipaka cattaro khandha arupino afihamahiiapac- caya, tena vata re vattabbe " Vipako vipakadhamma- dhammo ti." Vipaka d h a m m a d h a in mo t i k a t h a. arupa no, P. VII. 10.] KATHAVATTHU. 359 Sattamo Vaggo. Samgaho, Sampayutto, Cetasiko dhammo, Cetasikam danam, Paribhogamayam piiniiam vaddhati, Ito dinnena tattha yapeiititi, Pathavi kammavipako, Jaramaranam vipako, N'atthi ariyadhammavipako ti, Vipako vipakadhammadhammo ti. 360 KATHAVATTHU. [VIII. 1. VIII. 1. 1. Cha gatiyo ti? Amanta. Nanu panca gatiyo vutta Bhagavata, Nirayo, Tiraccha- nayoni, Pettivisayo, Manussa, Deva ti ? Amanta. Hanoi panca gatiyo vutta Bhagavata, Nirayo, Tiraccha- nayoni, Pettivisayo, Manussa, Deva, no vata re vattabbe '' Cha gatiyo ti." 2. Cha gatiyo ti ? Amanta. Nanu Kalakanjaka ^ Asura petanam samanavanna samanabhoga samanahara samanayuka petehi saha ava- havivaham gacchantiti '? Amanta. Hahci Kalakaiijaka Asura petanam samanavanna sama- nabhoga samanahara samanayuka petehi saha avahaviva- ham gacchanti, no vata re vattabbe " Cha gatiyo ti." 8. Cha gatiyo ti ? Amanta. Nanu Vepacittiparisa Devanain samanavanna samana- bhoga samanahara samanayuka Devehi saha avahaviva- hain gacchantiti ? Amanta. Haiici Vepacittiparisa Devanain samanavanna samana- bhoga samanahara samanayuka Devehi saha avahaviva- ham gacchanti, no vata re vattabbe " Cha gatiyo ti." 4. Cha gatiyo ti ? Amanta. Nanu Vepacittiparisa pubbadeva ti ? Amanta. Hahci Vepacittiparisa pubbadeva, no vata re vattabbe " Cha gatiyo ti." 5. Na vattabbam " Cha gatiyo ti " ? Amanta. I kalakata, P. - VIII. 2. J KATHAVATTHU. 861 Nanu atthi asurakayo ti '? Am ant a. Hanoi atthi asurakayo, tena vata re vattabbe " Cha gatiyo ti." (jT a t i k a t h a. VIII. ± 1. Atthi antarabhavo ti'? Anianta. Kamabhavo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi antarabhavo ti ? Amanta. Bupabhavo ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe— Atthi antarabhavo ti ? Anianta. Arupabhavo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Atthi antarabhavo ti '? Amanta. Kamabhavassa ca rupabhavassa ca antare atthi antara- bhavo ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe— pe — Atthi antarabhavo ti ? Amanta. Rupabhavassa ca ariipabhavassa ca antare atthi antara- bhavo ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 3. Kamabhavassa ca rilpabliavassa ca antare n'atthi antarabhavo ti ? Amanta. Hanci kamabhavassa ca rupabhavassa ca antare n'atthi antarabhavo, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi antarabhavo ti." Rupabhavassa ca ariipabhavassa ca antare n'atthi antarabhavo ti ? 362 KATHAVATTHU. |VIII. 2. Amanta. Hanoi rupabhavassa ca arupabhavassa ca antare n'atthi antarabhavo, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi antarabhavo ti." 4. Atthi antarabhavo ti '? Amanta. PahcamI sa yoni, chatthami sa gati, atthanii sa vinhana- tthiti, dasamo so sattavaso ti? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Atthi antarabhavo ti ? Amanta. Antarabhavo bhavo gati sattavaso samsaro yoni vihha- natthiti attabhavapatilabho ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Atthi antarabhavupagam kamman ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi antarabhavupaga satta ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Antarabhave satta jayanti, jlyanti, miyanti, cavanti, iippajjantlti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Antarabhave atthi rupani vedana saiiha sainkhara vinhanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Antarabhavo pahcavokarabhavo ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 5. Atthi kamabhavo, kamabhavo bhavo gati sattavaso samsaro yoni vihhanatthiti attabhavapatilabho ti ? Amanta. Atthi antarabhavo, antarabhavo bhavo gati sattavaso samsaro yoni vihhanatthiti attabhavapatilabho ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Atthi kamabhavupagain kamman ti ? Amanta. Atthi antarabhavupagam kamman ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Atthi kamabhavupaga satta ti ? Amanta, VIII. 2.] KATHAVATTHU. , 363 Atthi antarabhavupaga satta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamabhave satta jayanti jiyanti miyanti cavanti uppajjantiti '? Amanta. Antarabhave satta jayanti jiyanti miyanti cavanti uppajjantiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamabhave atthi rupain vedana sanfia samkhara viiinanan ti '? Amanta. Antarabhave atthi rupam vedana saiiiia samkhara vihhanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamabhavo pahcavokarabhavo ti ? Amanta. Antarabhave pancavokarabhavo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Atthi rupabhavo, rupabhavo bhavo gati sattavaso samsaro yoni vihhanatthiti attabhavapatilabho ti '? Amanta. Atthi antarabhave, antarabhave bhavo gati sattavaso samsaro yoni viiiiianatthiti attabhavapatilabho ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi rilpabhavupagain kamman ti ? Amanta. Atthi antarabhavupagam kamman ti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi riipabhavupaga satta ti ? Amanta. Atthi antarabhavupaga satta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Enpabhave satta jayanti jiyanti miyanti cavanti uppajjantiti ? Amanta. Antarabhave satta jayanti jiyanti miyanti cavanti uppajjantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 364 KATHAVATTHU. .' [VIII. 2. Rupabhave atthi rupam vedana sanna sainkhara viiinanan ti ? Amanta. Antarabhave atthi rupain vedana saniia sainkhara vihiianan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Rupabhavo pancavokarabhavo ti '? Amanta. Antarabhavo pancavokarabhavo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Atthi arnpabhavo, arupabhavo bhavo gati sattavaso samsaro yoni vihhanatthiti attabhavapatiiabho ti ? Amanta. Atthi antarabhavo, antarabhavo bhavo gati sattavaso samsaro yoni vihhanatthiti attabhavapatiiabho ti ? Amanta. Atthi arnpabhaviipagam kamman ti ? Amanta. Atthi antarabhavupagain kamman ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi arupabhavupaga satta ti ? Amanta. Atthi antarabhavupaga satta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arupabhave satta jayanti jTyanti mlyanti cavanti uppajjantiti ? Amanta. Antarabhave satta jayanti jiyanti miyanti cavanti uppajjantiti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arupabhave atthi vedana saiiha sainkhara vihhanan ti? Amanta. Antarabhave atthi vedana sahha sainkhara vihhanan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Arupabhavo catuvokarabhavo ti ? Amanta. VIII. 2.j KATHAVATTHU. 865 Antarabhavo catuvokarabhavo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Atthi antarabhavo ti ? Aiuanta. Sabbesaii neva sattanam atthi antarabhavo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sabbesah heva sattanain n'atthi antarabhavo ti ? Anianta. Haiici sabbesah heva sattanain n'atthi antarabhavo, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi antarabhavo ti." 9. Atthi antarabhavo ti ? Amanta. Anantarikassa ^ puggalassa atthi antarabhavo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anantarikassa puggalassa n'atthi antarabhavo ti '? Amanta. Hahci anantarikassa puggalassa n'atthi antarabhavo, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi antarabhavo ti." 10. Na-anantarikassa puggalassa atthi antaral)havo ti ? Amanta. Anantarikassa puggalassa atthi antarabhavo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anantarikassa puggalassa n'atthi antarabhavo ti ? Amanta. Na-anantarikassa puggalassa n'atthi antarabhavo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nirayupagassa puggalassa — pe — asahhasattupagassa puggalassa — pe — arupupagassa puggalassa atthi antara- bhavo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Arupupagassa puggalassa n'atthi antarabhavo ti ? Amanta. Hahci arupupagassa puggalassa n'atthi antarabhavo, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi antarabhavo ti." 11. Na-arupupagassa puggalassa atthi antarabhavo ti '> Amanta. ' anantarikassa, P. 8. ; anantariyassa, M.K. 366 KATHAVATTHU. [VIII. 3. Arupiipagassa pnggalassa atthi antarabhavo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arupiipagassa puggalassa n' atthi antarabhavo ti ? Amanta. Na-arupupagassa puggalassa n'atthi antarabhavo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 12. Na vattabbam " Atthi antarabhavo ti " "? Amanta. Nanu antaraparinibbayl puggalo atthiti ? Amanta. Hanoi antaraparinibbayl puggalo atthi, tena vata re vattabbe "Atthi antarabhavo ti." 13. Antaraparinibbayl puggalo atthiti katva atthi anta- rabhavo ti ? Amanta. Upahaccaparinibbayl puggalo atthiti katva atthi upahac- cabhavo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Antaraparinibbayl puggalo atthiti katva atthi antara- bhavo ti? Amanta. Asainkharaparinibbayl puggalo — pe — sasamkharapari- nibbayl puggalo atthiti katva atthi sasamkharabhavo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Antarabhavakatha. VIII. 3. 1. Pafic'eva kamaguna kamadhatu ti ? Amanta. Nanu atthi tappatisahhutto ^ chando ti '? Amanta. Hahci atthi tappatisaiiiiutto chando, no vata re vattabbe Panc'eva kamaguna kamadhatu ti." Nanu atthi tappatisahhutto rago, tappatisaiihutto I tappamtisah°, P. VIII. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 367 chandarago, tappatisaniiiitto samkappo, tappatisaiinutto rago, tappatisannutto sainkapparago, tappatisannutta piti, tappatisannuttam somanassaip, tappatisannuttaiii pltiso- manassan ti ? Amanta. Haiici atthi tappatisannuttam pltisomanassani, no vata re vattabbe " Panc'eva kamaguna kamadhatu ti." 2 Paiic'eva kamaguna kamadhatu ti '? Amanta. Manussanain cakkhum na kamadhatiiti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Manussanain sotam — pe — manussanain ghanain — pe — manussanain jivha — pe — manussanain kaj^o — pe — manus- sanain mano na kamadhatuti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Manussanain mano na kamadhatuti '? Amanta. Nanu vuttain Bhagavata — " Paiica kamaguna loke Mano chattha pavedita, Ettha chandam virajetva Evaiii dukkha pamuccatiti." Atth'eva suttanto ti '? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Manussanain mano na kamadhatuti." 8. Panc'eva kamaguna kamadhatu ti ? Amanta. Kamaguna bhavo gati sattavaso samsaro yoni vihnana- tthiti attabhavapatilabho ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Atthi kamagunupagain kamman ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Atthi kamaguniipaga satta ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamagune satta jayanti jTyanti mlyanti cavanti uppajjantiti ? 3G8 KATHAVATTHl'. jVIII. 3. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — jKamagnne atthi rupam vedana sanfia samkhara viiifianan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamaouna paiicavokarabhavo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamat^une Sammasambuddha uppajjaiiti, Paccekasam- buddha uppajjanti, savakayugam uppajjatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Kamadhatn bhavo gati sattavaso samsaro yoni viniianatthiti attabhavapatilabho ti ? Amanta. "■ Kamagnna bhavo gati sattavaso sainsaro yoni vinnanat- thiti attabhavapatilabho ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi kamadhatiipagam kamman ti ? Amanta. Atthi kamagnnupagam kamman ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Atthi kamadhatupaga satta ti ? Amanta. Atthi kamagunupaga satta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamadhatiiya satta jayanti jiyanti miyanti cavanti iippajjantiti ? Amanta. Kamagnna satta jayanti jtyanti miyanti cavanti uppajjantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamadhatiiya atthi rtipam vedana sahha samkhara vihiianan ti ? Amanta. Kamagnna atthi rupain vedana sahha sainkhara vihhanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamadhatn pahcavokarabhavo ti ? Amanta. Kamagnna pahcavokarabhavo ti ? VIII. 4.] KATHAVATTHU. 869 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamadhatuya Samniasanibuddha uppajjanti, Pacceka- sambuddha uppajjanti, savakayugam uppajjatiti? Amanta. Kamaguna Sammasambuddha uppajjanti, Pacceka- sambuddha uppajjanti, savakayugam uppajjatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Na vattabbam " Paiic'eva kamaguna kamadhatuti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Panc'ime Bhikkhave kamaguna. Katame paiica ? Cakkhuvinneyya rupa ittha kanta nianapa piyarupa kamupasamhita rajanlya, sotaviiiiieyya sadda — pe — ghanavinneyya gandha — pe — jivhavinneyya rasa — pe — kayaviiiiieyya photthabba ittha kanta manapa piyarupa kamupasamhita rajanlya ; ime kho Bhikkhave pahca kamaguna ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi panc'eva kamaguna kamadhatuti. Kamagunakatha VIII. 4. 1. Paiic'ev'ayatana kama ti ? Amanta. Nanu atthi tappatisaiihutto chando ti ? Amanta. Hanoi atthi tappatisaMutto chando, no vata re vattabbe " Paiic'ev'ayatana kama ti." Nanu atthi tappatisahiiutto rago, tappatisanhutto chandarago, tappatisahiiutto sainkappo, tappatisahiiutto rago, tappatisanhutto samkapparago, tappatisahiiutta piti, tappatisahhuttam somanassain, tappatisahiiuttam pltiso- manassan ti ? Amanta. Hahci atthi tappatisaiihuttam pltisomanassam, no vata re vattabbe " Pahc'ev'ayatana kama ti." 25 870 KATHAVATTHU. [VIII. 5. 2. Na vatfcabbam " Panc'ev'ayatana kama ti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Panc'imeBhikkhave kama- gima. Katame panca ? Cakkhuvinneyya rupa ittha kanta manapa j)iyarnpa kaniiipasamhita rajanlya, sotavinneyya sadda — pe — ghanaviiineyya gandha - — pe — jivhavinneyya rasa — pe — kayaviniieyya photthabba ittha kanta manapa piyarupa kamupasamhita rajanlya ; inie kho Bhikkhave panca kamaguna ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi paiic'ev'ayatana kama ti. 3. Panc'ev'ayatana kama ti '? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Panc'ime Bhikkhave kama- guna. Katame panca ? Cakkhnviiiheyya rupa — pe — kaya- viiiheyya photthabba ittha kanta manapa piyariapa kamu- pasamhita rajanlya ; ime kho Bhikkhave panca kamaguna. Api ca Bhikkhave nete kamaguna nania.^ Te ariyassa vinaye vuccanti Samkapparago purissassa kamo. Na te kama yani citrani loke Samkapparago purisassa kamo. Titthanti citrani tath'eva loke, Ath'ettha^ dhira vinayan ti chandan ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Panc'ev'ayatana kama ti." K a m a k a t h a . VIII. 5. 1. Hupino dhamma rupadhatiiti ? Amanta. I nam' ete, P.M. ^ ath'etta, P.S., atth'ettha, M. VIII. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 371 Rupam bhavo gati sattavaso samsaro yoni vinnanatthiti attabhavapatilabho ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi rupupagam kaininan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi rupupaga satta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Rupe satta jayanti jlyanti miyanti cavanti uppajjantl- ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Rupe atthi rupam vedana saiiha samkhara viniianan ti'r> Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Riipam pahcavokarabhavo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Rupadhatu bhavo gati — pe — attabhavapatilabho ti ? Amanta. Riipani bhavo gati — pe — attabhavapatilabho ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Atthi rupadhatupagain kamman ti '? Amanta. Atthi rupupagain kamman ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Atthi riipadhatvipaga satta ti ? Amanta. Atthi rupupaga satta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Rupadhatnya satta jayanti jlyanti miyanti cavanti uppajjantiti? Amanta. Rupe satta jayanti jlyanti miyanti cavanti uppajjan- titi ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Rupadhatuya atthi rupani vedana safiiia samkhara vihhanan ti '? Amanta. Rupe atthi rupam vedana sahna samkhara viniianan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 872 KATHAVATTHU. [VIII. 6. Kupadhatu pancavokarabhavo tiV Ainantii. Kupaiii pancavokarabhavo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Riipinc) dhainina rupadhatii, kamadhatiiya atthi rupan ti? Amanta. Sa va kamadhatu, sa rupadhatuti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sa va kamadhatu, sa rupadhatuti V Amanta. Kamabhavena samannagato puggalo dvlhi bhavehi sa- mannagato hoti kamabhavena ca rupabhavena cati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — R u p a d It a t u k a t h a . VIII. 6. 1. Arupino dhamma arupadhatuti V Amanta. Vedana bhavo gati sattavaso sainsaro yoni viniianatthiti attabhavapatilabho ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi vedanupagam kamman ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi vedanupaga satta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vedanaya satta jayanti jlyanti miyanti cavanti up- pajjantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vedanaya atthi vedana sahfia samkhara vifihanan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Vedana catuvokarabhavo ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — 2. Arupadhatu bhavo gati — pe — attabhavapatilabho ti ? Amanta. VIII. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 373 Vedana bhavo gati — pe — attabhavapatilabho ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi ariipadhatupagain kaniman ti ? Amanta. Atthi vedanupagain kaininan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi arupadhatupaga satta ti '? Amanta. Atthi vedanupaga satta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arupadhatuya satta jayanti jiyanti miyanti cavanti uppajjantlti? Amanta. Vedanaya satta jayanti jiyanti miyanti cavanti up- pajjantlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arupadhatuya atthi vedana sanna samkhara vinnanan ti? Amanta. Vedanaya atthi vedana saiiiia samkhara vinnanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ariipadhatu catuvokarabhavo ti ? Amanta. Vedana catuvokarabhavo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ariipino dhamma arupadhatu, kamadhatuya atthi vedana saiina samkhara viiihanan ti ? Amanta. Sa va kamadhatu, sa arupadhatuti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sa va kamadhatu, sa arupadhatuti ? Amanta. Kamabhavena samannagato puggalo dvlhi bhavehi sa- mannagato hoti kamabhavena ca arfipabhavena cati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Rupino dhamma riipadhatu, arupino dhamma arupa- dhatu, kamadhatuya atthi rupam vedana sahna sainkhjira vihiianan ti ? 374 KATHAVATTHU. [VIII. 7. Amanta. Sa va kamadhatu, sa rupadhatu, sa arupadhatuti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sa va kamadhatu, sa rupadhatu, sa arupadhatuti ? Amanta. Kamabhavena samannagato puggalo tlhi bhavehi sa- mannagato hoti kamabhavena ca rupabhavena ca arupa- bhavena cati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arupadhatukatha. VIII. 7. 1. Salayataniko attabhavo rupadhatuya ti '> Amanta. Atthi tattha ghanayatanan ti ? Amanta. Atthi tattha gandhayatanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Atthi tattha jivhayatanan ti ? Amanta. Atthi tattha rasayatanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi tattha kayayatanan ti ? Amanta. Atthi tattha photthabbayatanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — • '2. N'atthi tattha gandhayatanan ti ? Amanta. N'atthi tattha ghanayatanan ti V Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — N'atthi tattha rasayatanan ti ? Amanta. N'atthi tattha jivhayatanan ti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N'atthi tattha photthabbayatanan ti ? VIII. 7."] KATHAVATTHU. 375 Amanta. N'atthi tattha kayayatanan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Atthi tattha cakkhayatanam, atthi rnpayatanan ti ? Amanta. Atthi tattha ghanayatanam, atthi gandhayatanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi tattha cakkhayatanain, atthi rnpayatanan ti ? Amanta. Atthi tattha jivhayatanaiu, atthi rasayatanam — pe — atthi tattha kayayatanam, atthi photthabbayatanan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Atthi tattha sotayatanam, atthi saddayatanam — pe — atthi tattha manayatanam, atthi dhammayatanan ti ? Amanta. Atthi tattha ghanayatanani, atthi gandhayatanan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi tattha manayatanam, atthi dhammayatanan ti ? Amanta. Atthi tattha jivhayatanam, atthi rasayatanam — pe — atthi tattha kayayatanam, atthi photthabbayatanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Atthi tattha ghanayatanam, n'atthi gandhayatanan ti? Amanta. Atthi tattha cakkhayatanam, n'atthi rnpayatanan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Atthi tattha ghanayatanani, n'atthi gandhayatanan ti? Amanta. Atthi tattha sotayatanani, n'atthi saddayatanam — pe' — atthi tattha manayatanani, n'atthi dhammayatanan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe~- 6. Atthi tattha jivhayatanam, n'atthi rasayatanam — pe — atthi tattha kayayatanam, n'atthi photthabbayatanan ti? Amanta. Atthi tattha cakkhayatanani, n'atthi rnpayatanan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 376 KATHAVATTHU. [VIII. 7. Atthi tattha kayayatanam, n'atthi photthabbayatanan ti? Amanta. Atthi tattha sotayatanam, n'atthi saddayatanam — pe — atthi tattha nianayatanam, n'atthi dhaniniayatanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— 7. Atthi tattha cakkhayatanani, atthi rupayatanam, tena cakkhuna tain rupain passatiti ? Amanta. Atthi tattha ghanayatanam, atthi gandhayatanain, tena ghanena tarn gandham ghayatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi tattha cakkhayatanani, atthi rupayatanam, tena cakkhuna tarn rupam passatiti ? Amanta. Atthi tattha jivhayatanam, atthi rasayatanam, taya jivhaya tarn rasam sayati — pe — atthi tattha kayayatanam, atthi photthabbayatanam, tena kayena tarn photthabbani phusatiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 8. Atthi tattha sotayatanani, atthi saddayatanain — pe — atthi tattha manayatanam, atthi dhammayatanani, tena manena tarn dhammam vijanatiti V Amanta. Atthi tattha ghanayatanam, atthi gandhayatanain, tena ghanena tain gandham ghayatiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Atthi tattha manayatanam, atthi dhammayatanam, tena manena tarn dhamman vijanatiti ? Amanta. Atthi tattha jivhayatanam, atthi rasayatanam — pe — - atthi tattha kayayatanain, atthi photthabbayatanam, tena kayena tarn photthabbani phusatiti V Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 9. Atthi tattha ghanayatanain, atthi gandhayatanain, na ca tena ghanena tarn gandhani ghayatiti ? Amanta. Atthi tattha cakkhayatanani, atthi rupayatanam, na ca tena cakkhuna tarn riipam passatiti ? VIII. 7.] KATHAVATTHU. 377 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi tattha ghanayatanam, atthi gandhayatanam, na ca tena ghanena tarn gandham ghayatiti ? Amanta. Atthi tattha sotayatanam, atthi saddayatanam — pe — atthi tattha manayatanain, atthi dhammayatanam, na ca tena manena taiii dhaniniani vijanatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 10. Atthi tattha jivhayatanam, atthi rasayatanam — pe — atthi tattha kayayatanaiii, atthi photthabbayatanam, na ca tena kayena tarn photthabbam phusatiti ? Amanta. Atthi tattha cakkhayatanam, atthi rupayatanain, na ca tena cakkhnna tarn rupani passatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi tattha kayayatanam, atthi photthabbayatanam, na ca tena kayena tani photthabbam phusatiti ? Amanta. Atthi tattha sotayatanam, atthi saddayatanain — pe — atthi tattha manayatanam, atthi dhammayatanain, na ca tena manena tain dhammani vijanatiti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 11. Atthi tattha ghanayatanam, atthi gandhayatanani, tena ghanena tani gandhain ghayatiti ? Amanta. Atthi tattha mulagandho saragandho tacagandho patta- gandho pupphagandho phalagandho amagandho visa- gandho ^ sugandho duggandho ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 12. Atthi tattha jivhayatanain, atthi rasayatanain, taya jivhaya tani rasam sayatiti '? Amanta. Atthi tattha nmlaraso khandharaso ^ tacaraso pattaraso puppharaso phalaraso ambilani madhuraiii tittakam katu- kam loniyam khariyain lambilam 3 kasavo sadu asaduti ? 1 vissagandho, P.S.S2. ^ gandharaso, P. 3 lavanain, P.8.S2. 878 KATHAVATTHU. [VIII. 8. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 13. Atthi tattha kayayatanaiii, atthi photthabbaya- tanaiii, tena kayena tarn photthabbam phusatiti '^ Anianta. Atthi tattha kakkhalam niudiikaiu sanham pharusaiii • • • • • J. • sukhasamphassam dukkhasamphassam garukam lahukan ti? Na h'evaiu vattabbe — ^pe — 14. Na vattabbam " Salayataniko attabhavo rupadha- tuya ti " ? Anianta. Nann atthi tattha ghananimittaiu jivhanimittam kaya- niniittan ti ? Anianta. Haiici atthi tattha ghananiniittain jivhanimittam kaya- nimittam, tena vata re vattabbe " Salayataniko attabhavo rtipadhatuya ti." R u p a d h a tu y a a y a t a n a k a t h a. YIII 8. 1. Atthi rupain arupesuti ? Anianta. Rupabhavo rupagati rupasattavaso rupasainsaro rupa- yoni rupattabhavapatilabho ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu arupabhavo arupagati arupasattavaso arupasam- saro arupayoni arupattabhavapatilabho ti ? Amaiita. Haiici arupabhavo arupagati arupasattavaso arupasani- saro arupayoni arupattabhavapatilabho, no vata re vat- tabbe " Atthi rupani arupesuti." 2. Atthi riipam arupesuti ? Anianta. Pancavokarabhavo gati sattavaso sainsaro yoiii vihha- natthiti attabhavapatilabho ti ? VIII. 8.] KATHAVATTHU. 379 Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Nanu catuvokarabhavo— pe — attabhavapatilabho ti ? Amanta. Hanci catuvokarabhavo — -pe — attabhavapatilabho, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi rupain arupesuti." 3. Atthi rnpam rupadhatuya, so ca rupabhavo rupagati — pe — rupattabhavapatilabho ti ? Amanta. Atthi rilpam arripesu, so ca rupabhavo riipagati — pe — rupattabhavapatilabho ti ? Na h"evaiu vattabbe — pe — Atthi riipam rupadhatuya, so ca pahcavokarabhavo gati — pe — attabhavapatilabho ti ? Amanta. Atthi riipam arupesu, so ca pahcavokarabhavo gati — pe — attabhavapatilabho ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Atthi rupain arupesu, so ca arupabhavo arupagati — — pe — arupattabhavapatilabho ti ? Amanta. Atthi riipam arupadhatuya, so ca arupabhavo arupagati — pe — arupattabhavapatilabho ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — • Atthi rfipam arripesu, so ca catuvokarabhavo gati — pe — attabhavapatilabho ti ? Amanta. Atthi rupam arupadhatuya, so ca catuvokarabhavo gati — pe — attabhavapatilabho ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 5. Atthi rupain ariipesuti ? Amanta. Nanu rupanam nissaranain arupain vuttain Bhagavata ti? Amanta. Hahci rupanain nissaranain arupain vuttain Bhagavata, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi rupain arupesuti." (). Kupanam nissaranain arupain vuttain Bhagavata, atthi rupain arupesuti '^ 380 KATHAVATTHU. [VIII. 9. Amanta. Kamanam nissaranain nekkhammam vuttam Bhagavata, atthi nekkhammesu kama, atthi anasavesu asava,^ atthi apariyapannesu pariyapanna ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — A r u p p e r u p a k a t h a. VIII. 9. 1. Kusalena cittena samutthitam kayakainniam rnpam knsalan ti '? Amanta. Sarammanain, atthi tassa avattana abhogo saniannaharo nianasikaro cetana patthana panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana abhogo saniannaharo nianasikaro cetana patthana panidhiti ? Amanta. Hanoi anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana abhogo samannaharo nianasikaro cetana patthana panidhi, no vata re vattabbe " Kusalena cittena samutthitam kaya- kammam rupam kusalan ti." 2. Kusalena cittena samutthito phasso kusalo saram- mano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti? Amanta. Kusalena cittena samutthitain kayakammani rupam kusalam sarammanain, atthi tassa avattana — pe — pani- dhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kusalena cittena samutthita vedana — pe — sahiia, cetana, saddha, viriyam, sati, samadhi — pe — pafifia kusala saram- mana, atthi taya avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. ^ P.S.S2 omit "atthi anasavesu asava." VIII. 9.] KATHAVATTHU. 381 Kusalena cittena saniutthitain kayakammani rupain kusalam sarammanam, atthi tassa avattaiia — pe — pani- dhlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Kusalena cittena samutthitam kayakannnam rupain kusalam anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — i^e — panidhiti ? Amanta. Kusalena cittena samutthito phasso kusalo anarani- mano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kusalena cittena samutthitam kayakammani rupain kusalam anarammanani, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti '? Amanta. Kusalena cittena samutthita vedana — pe — sahiia, cetana, saddha, viriyam, sati, samadhi — pe — pahiia kusala ana- rammana, n'atthi taya avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Kusalena cittena samutthitam kayakammam rupain kusalan ti ? Amanta. Yam kinci kusalena cittena samutthitam rupam, sabban tam^ kusalan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kusalena cittena saniutthitain kayakammani rupain kusalan ti ? Amanta. Kusalena cittena samutthitam rupayatanam kusalan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kusalena cittena samutthitam kayakammani rupain kusalan ti ? Amanta. Kusalena cittena samutthitam saddayatanain — pe — • gandhayatanam, rasayatanani, photthabbayatanam — pe — • I santani, P.; samantam, S. 382 KATHAVATTHU. [VIII. 9. pathavTdhatu, apodhatu, tejodhatn — pe — vayodhatu kusala ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Kiisalena cittena saniutthitani rnpayatanain abya- katan ti ? Anianta. Kusalena cittena samutthitain kayakainmain rupain abyakatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kusalena cittena samutthitain saddayatanam — pe — gandhayatanam, rasayatanam, photthabbayatanam — pe — pathavldhatu, apodhatu, tejodhatu — pe — vayodhatu abya- kata ti ? Am ant a. Kusalena cittena samutthitain kayakammain rupain abyakatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 0. Kusalena cittena samutthitain kayakammam rupam anarammanam kusalan ti ? Amanta. Kusalena cittena samutthitain rupayatanam anaram- manam kusalan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Kusalena cittena samutthitain kayakammain rupain anarammanam kusalan ti ? Amanta. Kusalena cittena samutthitain saddayatanam — pe — gandhayatanain, rasayatanam, photthabbayatanam — pe — pathavldhatu, apodhatu, tejodhatu — pe — vayodhatu ana- rammana kusala ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 7. Kusalena cittena samutthitain rupayatanani ana- rammanani abyakatan ti ? Amanta. Kusalena cittena samutthitain kayakammain rupam anarammanain abyakatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — j)e— Kusalena cittena samutthitain saddayatanain — pe — VIII. y.] KATHAVATTHU. 383 »andhayatanain, rasayatanani, photthabbayatanaiii — pe — pathavTdhatu, apcxlhatu, tejodhatn — pe — vayodhatu ana- rammana abyakata ti V Amanta. Kusalena cittena samutthitain kayakammain rupain anaraininanam abyakatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Kusalena cittena saniiitthitam kayakammain riipam phassavippayuttain kusalan ti ? Amanta. Kusalena cittena sanmtthitam rupayatanain phassavip- payuttam kusalan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe pe — Kusalena cittena samutthitain kayakammain rupain phassavippayuttain kusalan ti '? Amanta. Kusalena cittena samutthitain saddayatanain — pe — - gandhayatanain, rasayatanani, phutthabbayatanain — pe — pathavldhatu, apodhatu, tejodhatu — pe — vayodhatu phassavippayutta kusala ti '.' Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 9. Kusalena cittena samutthitain rupayatanain phass- avippayuttain abyakatan ti ? Amanta. Kusalena cittena samutthitain kayakammain rupain phassavippayuttain abyakatan ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Kusalena cittena samutthitain saddayatanain — pe— gandhayatanain, rasayatanani, photthabbayatanam — pe — pathavldhatu, apodhatu, tejodhatu — pe — vayodhatu phassavippayutta abyakata ti ? Amanta. Kusalena cittena samutthitain kayakammain rupain phassavippayuttain abyakatan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 10. Kusalena cittena samutthitain kayakammain rupam anarammanain phassavipayuttain kusalan ti ? Amanta. 884 KATHAVATTHU. [VIII. 9. Kusalena cittena saniutthitam riipayatanain anaram- iiianaiii phassavippayuttain knsalan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kusalena cittena samutthitani kayakammain rupam anarammanam phassavippayuttain kusalan ti V Anianta. Kusalena cittena saniutthitain saddayatanain — pe — t^andhayatanam, rasayatanani, photthabbayatanain — pe — pathavldhatu, apodhatu, tejodhatu — pe — vayodhatu ana- rannnana phassavippayutta kusala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 11. Kusalena cittena samutthitani rupayatanam ana- rammanain phassavippayuttain abyakatan ti V Amanta. Kusalena cittena samutthitani kayakammam rupam anarammanam phassavippayuttain abyakatan ti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kusalena cittena samutthitani saddayatanain — pe — gandhayatanain, rasayatanain, photthabbayatanain — pe — pathavldhatu, apodhatu, tejodhatu — pe — vayodhatu ana- rammana phassavippayutta abyakata ti ? Amanta. Kusalena cittena samutthitani kayakammain rupam anarammanam phassavippayuttain abyakatan ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 12. Kusalena cittena saniutthitain vacTkammam rupam kusalan ti ? Amanta. Sarammanam, atthi tassa avattana abhogo samannaharo manasikaro cetana patthana panidhiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Nanu anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana abhogo samannaharo manasikaro cetana patthana panidhiti V Amanta. Haiici anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana abhogo samannaharo manasikaro cetana patthana panidhi, no vata re vattabbe " Kusalena cittena saniutthitam vaci- kammani rupam kusalan ti." VIII. 9. J KATHAVATTHU. 385 13. Kusalena cittena samiitthito phasso knsalo sarani- mano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti '? Amanta. Kusalena cittena saniutthitani vaclkammam rupaiu kusalam saraninianain, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? ' Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Kusalena cittena saniutthita vedana — pe — saiina, cetana, saddha, viriyain, sati, samadhi — pe — pahha kusala sarammana, atthi taya avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Kusalena cittena saniutthitani vaclkamniani rupani ku- salam sarammanam, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 14. Kusalena cittena samutthitam vaclkamniani rupain kusalam anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti V Amanta. , Kusalena cittena samutthito phasso kusalo anaram- mano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Kusalena cittena saniutthitani vacikammani iTipain kusalam aiiarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana^ — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Kusalena cittena samutthita vedana — pe — saiiha, cetana, saddha, viriyain, sati, samadhi — pe — pahha kusala anarammana, n'atthi taya avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — 15. Kusalena cittena saniutthitani vacikammani rupam kusalan ti ? Amanta. Yain kihci kusalena cittena saniutthitani rupani, sabban tani kusalan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — — Yatha kayakammani, tatha vacikamnian ti. — 16. Akusalena cittena saniutthitani kayakammam rupani akusalan ti ? 26 886 KATHAVATTHU. [VIII. 9. Anianta. Sarammanaiii, atthi tassa avattana abhogo samannaharo manasikaro cetana patthana panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu anaramnianam, n'atthi tassa avattana abhogo samannaharo manasikaro cetana patthana panidhiti ? Amanta. Hanci anaramnianam, n'atthi tassa avattana abhogo samannaharo manasikaro cetana patthana panidhi, no vata re vattabbe " Akusalena cittena samiitthitam kaya- kammam rupam akusalan ti." 17. Akusalena cittena samutthito [phasso akusalo sarammano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Akusalena cittena samutthitam kayakammam rupam akusalam sarammanani, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Akusalena cittena samutthita vedana — ^pe — sahiia, cetana, rago, doso, moho, mano, ditthi, vicikiccha, thlnam, uddhaccani, ahirikain — pe — anottappani akusalam saram- manain, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Akusalena cittena sanmtthitani kayakammam rupam akusalain sarammanam, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 18. Akusalena cittena samutthitani kayakammam rupam akusalam anarammanain, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Akusalena cittena samutthito phasso akusalo ana- rammano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Akusalena cittena samutthitani kayakammam nlpam akusalarii anarammanani, n'atthi tassa avattana —pc — panidhiti ? Amanta. VIII. 9.] KATHAVATTHU. 387 Aknsalena cittena saniutthita vedana — -pe — saiina, cetana, rago, doso, moho, iiiano, ditthi, vicikiccha, thinam, uddhaccam, ahirikam — pe — anottappam akusalain ana- ramnianam, n'atthi tassa avattaiia — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 19. Akusalena cittena samutthitaiii kayakanimam rfipam akusalan ti ? Anianta. Yam kinci aknsalena cittena samutthitam rnpam, sabban tarn akusalan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 20. Akusalena cittena samutthitam vaclkammain rilpam akusalan ti ? Amanta. Sarammanam, atthi tassa avattana abhogo saman- naharo manasikaro cetana patthana panidhiti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu anarammanain, n'atthi tassa avattana abhogo samannaharo manasikaro cetana patthana panidhiti ? Amanta. Hahci anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana abhogo samannaharo manasikaro cetana patthana panidhi, no vata re vattabbe " Akusalena cittena samutthitam vacl- kammam rupam akusalan ti." 21. Akusalena cittena samutthito phasso akusalo sarammano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti '? Amanta. Akusalena cittena samutthitain vaclkammam rupam akusalam sarammanain, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Akusalena cittena saniutthita vedana — pe — sahha, cetana, rago, doso, moho, mano, ditthi, vicikiccha, thinam. uddhaccam, ahirikani — pe — anottappain akusalain saram- manain, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Akusalena cittena samutthitain vaclkammain rupain aku- salain sarammanain, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? 388 KATHAVATTHU. [VIII. 9. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — - 22. Akusalena cittena samutthitam vacTkammani rupaip akasalam anaraninianam, n'atthi tassa avattana - -pe — panidhiti ? Aiiianta. Akusalena cittena samntthito phasso akusalo anaram- mano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Akusalena cittena samutthitain vaclkanimam rupain akusalain anaranimanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Anianta. Akusalena cittena saniutthita vedana — pe — saiina, cetana, rago, doso, nioho, mano, ditthi, vicikiccha, thlnani, "uddhaccam, ahirikam — pe — anottappam akusalam ana- ramnianam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 28. Akusalena cittena samutthitam vaclkammam • • • • rupani akusalan ti ? Amanta. Yam kihci akusalena cittena samutthitain rupaiu, sabban tain akusalan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 24. Akusalena cittena samutthitam vaclkanimam rupam akusalan ti ? Amanta. Akusalena cittena samutthitain rupayatanam akusalan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Akusalena cittena samutthitam vaclkammam riipam akusalan ti ? Amanta. Akusalena cittena samutthitain saddayatanam — pe — gandhayatanam, rasayatanain, photthabbayatanam, path- avldhatu, apodhatu, tejodhatu, vayodhatu, asuci, assu, lohitam — pe — sedo akusalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 25. Akusalena cittena samutthitain rupayatanam abyakatan ti? VIII. 9.] IvATHAVATTHU. 389 Anianta. Akusalena cittena samutthitam vaclkammam rupair? abyakatan ti ? Na h'eVam vattabbe — pe — Akusalena cittena samutthitam saddayatanam — pe — gandhayatanam, rasayatanam, photthabbayatanain — pe- — pathavldhatu, apodhatu, tejodhatu, vayodhatu, asuci, assu, lohitam — -pe — sedo abyakato ti ? Am ant a. Akusalena cittena samutthitain vaclkammam rupam abyakatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 26. Akusalena cittena samutthitam vaclkammam rupaiii anarammanam akusalan ti ? Amanta. Akusalena cittena samutthitain rupayatanam ana- rammanam akusalan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Akusalena cittena samutthitam vaclkammain riipaiii anarammanam akusalan ti V Anianta. Akusalena cittena samutthitain saddayatanam — pe — gandhayatanain, rasayatanain, photthabbayatanain, pathavldhatu, apodhatu, tejodhatu, vayodhatu, asuci. assu, lohitain — pe — sedo anarammano akusalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 27. Akusalena cittena samutthitam rupayatanain ana- rainmanain abyakatan ti ? Ainanta. Akusalena cittena samutthitam vaclkammam rupain anarammanam abyakatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Akusalena cittena samutthitam saddayatanam — pe — gandhayatanain, rasayatanain, photthabbayatanain — pe — pathavldhatu, apodhatu, tejodhatu, vayodhatu, asuci, assu, lohitain — pe — sedo anarammano abyakato ti ? Amanta. Akusalena cittena samutthitam vaclkammain rupain anarammanam abyakatan ti ? 390 KATHAVATTHU. [VIII. 9. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 28. Akusalena cittena samutthitain vaclkammam rupani phassavippayuttam akusalan ti ? Anianta. Akusalena cittena saniutthitam rupayatanam phassa- vippayuttam akusalan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — -pe — Akusalena cittena samutthitam vaclkammam rupam phassavippayuttam akusalan ti ? Amanta. Akusalena cittena samutthitam saddayatanam — pe — gandhayatanain, rasayatanam, photthabbayatanain, path- avldhatu, apodhatu, tejodhatu, vayodhatu, asuci, assu, lohitam — pe — sedo phassavippayutto akusalo ti ? Na h'evaiii vattabbe — pe — 29. Akusalena cittena samutthitain rupayatanam phas- savippayuttam abyakatan ti ? Amanta. Akusalena cittena samutthitam vaclkammam rupam phassavippayuttam abyakatan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Akusalena cittena samutthitain saddayatanam — pe — • gandhayatanain, rasayatanam, photthabbayatanain — pe — pathavldhatu, apodhatu, tejodhatu, vayodhatu, asuci, assu, lohitain — pe — sedo phassavippayutto abyakato ti ? Amanta. Akusalena cittena samutthitain vaclkammam rupain phassavippayuttam abyakatan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 80. Akusalena cittena samutthitam vaclkammam rupam anarammanam phassavippayuttam akusalan ti '? Amanta. Akusalena cittena samutthitam rupayatanam anaram- manain phassavippayuttain akusalan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Akusalena cittena samutthitam vaclkammam rupam anarammanain phassavippayuttain akusalan ti ? Amanta. YIII. 9.] KATHAVATTHU. 891 Akusalena cittena sainutthitam saddayatanam-^pe — gandhayatanain, rasayatanaiii, photthabbayatanain, patha- vldhatu, apodhatu, tejodhatu, vayodhatu, asuci, assu, lohitain — pe — sedo anarammano phassavippayiitto akusalo ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — 31. Akusalena cittena saniiitthitam rupayatanani ana- rammanani phassavippayuttain abyakatan ti ? Amanta. Akusalena cittena sainutthitam vaclkannnam riipain anaraninianain phassavippayuttain abyakatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Akusalena cittena samutthitain saddayatanam — pe — gandhayatanain, rasayatanain, photthabbayatanain — pe — pathavldhatu, apodhatu, tejodhatu, vayodhatu, asuci, assu, lohitam — pe — sedo anarainmano phassavippayutto abya- kato ti ? Amanta. Akusalena cittena samutthitain vaclkammam riipani anarammanain phassavippayuttain abyakatan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 32. Na vattabbain " Kupam kusalam pi akusalain piti"? Amanta. Nanu kayakammain vaclkammam kusalam pi akusalam piti ? Amanta. Hahci kayakammain vacikammam kusalain pi akusalain pi, tena vata re vattabbe " Kupain kusalain pi akusalain piti." 33. Rupam kusalain pi akusalam piti ? Amanta. Cakkhayatanam kusalain pi akusalain piti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Kupani kusalain pi akusalain piti ? Amanta. Sotayatanani — pe — ghanayatanain, jivhayatanain, kay- ayatanam, rupayatanani, saddayatanam, gandhayatanain, 392 KATHAVATTHU. [VIII. 9. rasayatanam, pliotthabbayatanaiii, pathavidhatu, apodhatu^ tejodhatu, vayodhatu, asnci, assu, lohitam — pe — sedo kusalo pi akusalo piti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 34. Kayo rupaiii, kayakammaiu rupan ti ? Ainanta. Mano rupaiii, nianokanimaiii rupan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Mano arnpani, manokainmam arupan ti '? Anianta. Kayo arupam, kayakammaiu arupan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kayo rupain, kayakammaiu arupan ti ? Aiuanta. Mano rupani, manokammaiu arupan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Mano arupam, manokainmam arupan ti ? Amanta. Kayo arupam, kayokammain arupan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 35. Kayo rupan ti, kayakammaiu rupan ti ? Amanta. Cakkhayatanaiu rupan ti, cakkhuvihhanaiu rupan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kayo riipan ti, kayakammaiu rupan ti ? Amanta. Sotayatanaiu rupan ti, sotavihnanaiu rupan ti ? Na h'evaiu vattabbe — pe — Kayo rupan ti, kayakaiuiuani rupan ti ? Amanta. Ghanayatanam rupan ti, glianavihhanam rupan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kayo rupan ti, kayakammaiu rupan ti ? Amanta. Jivhayatanam rupan ti, jivhavihhanaiii rupan ti? Na h'evaiu vattabbe — pe — Kayo rupan ti kayakammaiu rupan ti ? Amanta. VIII. 9. J KATHAVATTHU. 39<^ Kayayatanam rupan ti, kayavinnanam rupan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 36. Rupam kamman ti ? Amanta. Nanu vnttain Bhagavata — " Cetanaham Bhikkhave kainmam vadami, cetayitva kaniinam karoti kayeiia vacaya manasa ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbain " Kupam kamman ti." 37. Eupam kamman ti ? ' Amanta. Nanu vnttam Bhagavata — " Kaye va Ananda sati kayasahcetanahetu iippajjati ajjhattam sukhadukkham, vacaya va Ananda sati vacisahcetanahetu uppajjati ajjhattain sukhadukkhani, mane va Ananda sati mano- sahcetanahetn uppajjati ajjhattain sukhadukkhan ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Kupam kamman ti." 38. Rupain kamman ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — '* Tividha Bhikkhave kaya- sahcetana akusalam kayakammam dukkhindriyam ^ dukkhavipakam, catubbidha Bhikkhave vaclsahcetana akusalain vaclkanimani dukkhindriyam dukkhavipakam, tividha Bhikkhave manosahcetana akusakini manokam- maiii dukkhindriyain dukkhavipakam ; tividha Bliikkhave kayasahcetana kusahim kayakammani sukhindriyam sukhavipilkani, catubbidha Bhikkhave vaclsahcetana kusalain vacikammain sukhindriyain sukhavipakain, tividha Bhikkhave manosahcetana kusalam manokammain sukhindriyam sukhavipakan ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ".'' Amanta. ' Sec. 37 is repeated in P.S.Ss. - diil IX. 4.] KATHAVATTHU. 407 4. Kainaraganusayo samkharakkhanclhapariyapanno anarammauo, kamarago sainkharakkhandhapariyapanno sarammano ti ? Anianta. Samkharakkhandho ekadeso sarammano, ekadeso ana- rammano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samkharakkhandho ekadeso sarammano, ekadeso ana- rammano ti ? Amanta. Vedanakkhandho, sahhakkhandho, vihhanakkhandho ekadeso sarammano, ekadeso anarammano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Patighanusayo, mananusayo, ditthanusayo, vicikic- chaniisayo, bhavaragannsayo, avijjanusayo anarammano tiV Amanta. Avijja avijjogho avijjayogo avijjapariyutthanam avijja- sahiiojanam avijjanivaranaip anarammanan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe^ Avijja avijjogho — pe — avijjanivaranam sarammanan ti? Amanta. Avijjanusayo sarammano ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Avijjanusayo anarammano ti ? Amanta. Katamakkhandhapariyapanno ti ? Sainkharakkhandha- pariyapanno ti. Samkharakkhandho anarammano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samkharakkhandho anarammano ti ? Amanta. Vedanakkhandho, sahnakkhandho, vinhanakkhandho anarammano ti ? Na h'evarn vattabbe — pe — 7. Avijjanusayo sainkharakkhandhapariyapanno ana- rammano ti ? Amanta. 408 KATHAVATTHU. [IX. 4. Avijja sainkharakkhandhapariyapanna anarammana ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Avijja sainkharakkhandhapariyapanna sarainmana ti? Anianta. Avijjanusayo samkharakkhandhapariyapanno saram- niano ti ? . ' Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Avijjanusayo samkharakkhandhapariyapanno ana- rammano, avijja sainkharakkhandhapariyapanna saram- mana ti ? Amanta. Samkharakkhandho ekadeso sarammano, ekadeso ana- rammano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samkharakkhandho ekadeso sarannnano, ekadeso ana- rammano ti ? Amanta. Vedanakkhandho, saiiiiakkhandho, vinhanakkhandho ekadeso sarammano, ekadeso anarammano ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 9. Na vattabbam " Anusaya anarammana ti " ? Amanta. Puthujjano kusalabyakate citte vattamane " sanusayo ti " vattabbo ti ? Amanta. Atthi tesain anusayanam arammanan ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Tena hi anusaya anarammana ti. 10. Puthujjano kusalabyakate citte vattamane " sarago ti " vattabbo ti? Amanta. Atthi tassa ragassa arammanan ti ? Na h'evaiii vattabbe — pe — Tena hi rago anarammano ti. Anusaya anarammana t i k a t h a . IX. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 409 IX. 5. 1. Nanam anaramiiianan ti '? Ainanta. Rupam nibbanaiu cakkhayatanam — pe— photthabbaya- tanan ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Nanain anaranimanan ti ? Amanta. Paiina, panfiindriyam, paiinabalam, sammaditthi, dhainmavicayasambojjhango anaraminano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Panna, pannindriyain, paiinabalam, sammaditthi, dhammavicayasanibojjhango sarammano ti '? Amanta. Nanain sarammanaii ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Nanam anaranimanan ti? Amanta. Katamakkhandhapariyapannan ti ? Sanikharakkhand- hapariyapaimaii ti. Sainkharakkhandho anarammano ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sanikharakkhandho anarammano ti? Amanta. Vedanakkhandho, saiiiiakkhandho, vinnanakkhaiidho anarammano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Nanain samkharakkhandhapariyapannaiu anarani- manan ti ? Amanta. Pahha samkharakkhandhapariyapanna anarammana ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paiiha samkharakkhandhapariyapanna sarammana ti ? Amanta. Nanain samkharakkhandhapariyapannam sarammanaii ti? " ' ' Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 410 KATHAVATTHU. [IX. 6. 4. Nanaiii saipkharakkhandhapariyapannam anaram- manain, panna samkkarakkhandhapariyapanna sarammana ti'?' " Amanta. Samkharakkhandho ekadeso saraiinnano, ekadeso ana- ranimano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe- — pe — Sanikharakkhandho ekadeso saraniinano, ekadeso ana- rammano ti '? Amanta. Vedanakkhandho, sannakkhandho, vinnanakkhandho ekadeso sarammano, ekadeso anaramanano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Na vattabbam " Nanaiii anarammanan ti " ? Amanta. Araha cakkhuviiinanasainanoi " nanlti " vattabbo ti ? Amanta. Atthi tassa iianassa arammanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi hanam anarammanan ti. 6. Araha cakkhuvihiianasamahgl " paiihava ti " vattabbo ti ?_ Amanta. Atthi taya paiihaya arammanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi pahha anarammana ti. N a n a m ana r a m m a n a ii t i k a t h a . IX. 0. 1. Atltarammanain cittam anarammanan ti ? • • • Amanta. Nanu atltarammanan ti V Amanta. Hahci atltarammanain, no vata re vattabbe " Atltaram- manam cittam anarammanan ti." IX. 7.] KATHAVATTHU. 411 Atltaramnianam ^ anarammanan ti, niicclia : hanci va pana anarammanam, no vata re vattabbe " Atitaram- maiian ti : " anarammanam atltarammanan ti, miccha. '2. Atitarammanani cittain anarammanan - ti ? Amanta. Nann atltam arabbha atthi avattana — pe — panidhiti '? Amanta. Hanoi atitam arabbha atthi avattana — pe — panidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Atitarammanani cittam anarammanan • • • • ti." A 1 1 1 a r a m m a n a k a t h a . IX. 7. 1. Anagatarammanam cittam anarammanam ti ? Amanta. Nanu anagatarammanan tiV Amanta. Haiici anagatarammanain, no vata re vattabbe " Ana- gatarammanam cittam anarammanan ti." Anagatarammanain anarammanan ti, miccha : hahci va pana anarammanain, no vata re vattabbe "Anaga- tarammanan ti:" anarammaiiam anagatarammanan ti, miccha. 2. Anaoatarammanam cittam anarammanan ti ? o • • • • • Amanta. Nanu anagatam arabbha atthi avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Haiici anagatain arabbha atthi avattana — pe — panidhi, no vata re vattabbe " Anagatarammanaiii cittam ana- rammanan ti." 8. Paccuppannain firal^bha atthi avattana — pe — panidhi, paccuppannarammanani cittani sarammanan ti? Amanta. 1 M. inserts cittam after atitarammanani. 2 P. omits sec. 2. 412 KATHAVATTHU. [IX. 8. Atitam arabbha atthi avattana — pe — panidhi, atitaram- nianam cittaip saranimanan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paccuppannam arabbha atthi avattana — pe — panidhi, pacciippannarammanam cittam sarammanan ti ? Amanta. Anagatam arabbha atthi avattana— pe — panidhi, anaga- tarammanam cittam saranimanan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Atitam arabbha atthi avattana — pe — panidhi, atlta- rammanam cittain anarammanan ti ? Amanta. Paccuppannam arabbha atthi avattana— pe — -panidhi, pacciippannarammanam cittam anarammanan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatain arabbha atthi avattana — pe — panidhi, ana- gatarammanam cittam anarammanan ti '? c • • • • Amanta. Paccuppannani arabbha atthi avattana — pe — panidhi, pacciippannarammanam cittani anarammanan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Na vattabbani " Atltarammanam cittam anaram- manan ti " ? Amanta. Nanu atltarammanam n'atthlti '? Amanta. Haiici atltarammanam n'atthi, tena vata re vattabbe " Atltarammanam cittani anarammanan ti." A n a g a t a r a m m a 11 a k a t h a . IX. 8. 1. Sabbain cittain vitakkanupatitan ti '? Amanta. Sabbani cittam vicaraniipatitam, pitanupatitam, su- khanupatitam, dukkhanupatitam, somanassanupatitani, IX. 9.] KATHAVATTHU. 413 domanassaimpatitani, iipekkhanupatitam, saddhanupati- taiii, viriyanupatitaip, satanupatitam, samadhanupatitam, panilanupatitam, raganupatitam, dosanupatitain — pe — anottappanupatitan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Sabbam cittam vitakkanupatitan ti ? Amanta. Nanu atthi avitakko vicaraniatto saiiiadhiti ? Amanta. Hanoi atthi avitakko vicaraniatto samadhi, no vata re vattabbe "Sabbam cittam vitakkanupatitan ti." 3. Sabbam cittain vitakkanupatitan ti '? Amanta. Nanu atthi avitakko avicaro samadhiti ? Amanta. Haiici atthi avitakko avicaro samadhi, no vata re vat- tabbe " Sabbam cittam vitakkanupatitan ti." 4. Sabbam cittain vitakkanupatitan ti '? Amanta. Nanu tayo samadhi vutta Bhagavata, savitakko savicaro samadhi, avitakko vicaraniatto samadhi, avitakko avicaro samadhiti ? Amanta. Hahci tayo samadlil vutta Bhagavata, savitakko savicaro samadhi, avitakko vicaraniatto samadhi, avitakko avicaro samadhi, no vata re vattabbe " Sabbam cittaiii vitakkanu- patitan ti." V i t a k k a n u p a t i t a k a t h a. IX. 9. 1. Sabbaso vitakkayato vicarayato vitakkavipphjlro saddo ti? Amanta. Sabbaso ^ phusayato phassavippharo saddo, sabbaso ^ sabbato, P. 414 KATHAVATTHU. [IX. 10. vedayato vedanavippharo saddo, sabbaso sanjanato sanna- vippharo saddo, sabbaso cetayato cetanavippharo saddo, sabbaso cintayato cittavippharo saddo, sabbaso sarato sativippharo saddo, sabbaso pajanato pannavippharo saddo ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Sabbaso vitakkayato vicarayato vitakkavippharo saddo ti'? Amanta. Vitakkavippharo saddo sotaviiiiieyyo, sotasmim pati- hafinati, sotassa apatham ^ agacchatlti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu vitakkavippharo saddo na sotavinneyyo, na sotas- mim patihahiiati, na sotassa apatham agacchatlti? Amanta. Hahci vitakkavippharo saddo na sotavihfieyyo, na sotasmim patihahnati, na sotassa apatham agacchati, no vata re vattabbe " Sabbaso vitakkayato vicarayato vitak- kavippharo saddo ti." Vitakkavippharasaddakatha. IX. 10. 1. Na yatha cittassa vaca ti '? Amanta. Aphassakassa vaca, avedanakassa vaca, asahhakassa vaca, acetanakassa vaca, acittakassa vaca ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu saphassakassa vaca, savedanakassa vaca, sasanna- kassa vaca, sacetanakassa vaca, sacittakassa vaca ti ? Amanta. Hahci saphassakassa — pe — sacittakassa vaca, no vata re vattabbe " Na yatha cittassa vaca ti." ^ abadhani, P. IX. lO.j KATHAVATTHU. 415 2. Na yatha cittassa vaca ti ? Amanta. Anavattantassa vaca, anabhogassa vaca — pe — apanida- hantassa vaca ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu avattantassa vaca, abhogassa vaca — pe — paiiida- hantassa vaca ti '? Amanta. Hafici avattantassa vaca, abhogassa vaca — pe — panida- hantassa vaca, no vata re vattabbe " Na j^atha cittassa vaca ti." 3. Na yatha cittassa vaca ti ? Amanta. Nanu vaca cittasamiitthana cittena saha jata cittena saha ekuppada ti? Amanta. Hahci vaca cittasamiitthana cittena saha jata cittena saha ekuppada, no vata re vattabbe " Na yatha cittassa vaca ti." 4. Na yatha cittassa vaca ti ? Amanta. Na bhanitnkamo bhanati, na kathetukamo katheti, na alapitukamo alapati, na voharitukamo voharatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Nanu bhanitukamo bhanati, kathetukamo katheti, alapitukamo alapati, voharitukamo voharatiti? Amanta. Hanci bhanitukamo bhanati, kathetukamo katheti, alapi- tukamo alapati, voharitukamo voharati, no vata re vattabbe " Na yatha cittassa vaca ti." 5. Na vattabbam " Na yatha cittassa vaca ti " ? Amanta. Nanuatthi koci "afinam bhanissamiti " aniiam bhanati, " afiham kathessamiti " aniiam katheti, " ahhain alapas- samlti " annam alapati, " aiiiiam voharissamiti " ahhain voharatiti ? Amanta. Hahci atthi koci " ahhain bhanissamiti" ahham bhanati, 416 KATHAVATTHU. [IX. 11. " annam kathessaniiti " aiinam katheti, " annam alapas- samlti " aniiam alapati, "annam voharissamiti " aniiam voharati, tena vata re vattabbe " Na yatha cittassa vaca ti." Na yatha cittassa vaca ti katha. IX. 11. 1. Na yatha cittassa kayakamman ti? Amanta. Aphassakassa kayakammam, avedanakassa kayakam- mam, asahhakassa kayakammam, acetanakassa kayakam- mam, acittakassa kayakamman ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Nanu saphassakassa kayakammam, savedanakassa kaya- kammam, sasahhakassa kayakammain, sacetanakassa kayakammam, sacittakassa kayakamman ti ? Amanta. Hahci saphassakassa — pe — sacittakassa kayakammam, no vata re vattabbe " Na yatha cittassa kayakannnan ti." 2. Na yatha cittassa kayakamman ti '? Amanta. Anavattantassa kayakammain, anabhogassa kayakam- mam — pe — apanidahantassa kayakamman ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu avattantassa kayakammam, abhogassa kayakam- mam — pe — panidahantassa kayakamman ti ? Amanta. Hahci avattantassa kaj^akammam, abhogassa kayakam- mam — pe — panidahantassa kayakammain, no vata re vat- tabbe " Na yatha cittassa kayakannnan ti." 3. Na yatha cittassa kayakamman ti ? Amanta. Nanu kayakammam cittasamutthanam cittena saha jatam cittena saha ekuppadan ti ? Amanta. IX. 1-2.] KATHAVATTHU. 417 Hanoi kayakamniam cittasamutthanam cittena saha jataiii cittena saha ekuppadain, no vata re vattabbe " Na yatha cittasa kayakamman ti." 4. Na yatha cittassa kayakamman ti ? Amanta. Na abhikkamitukamo abhikkamati,na patikkamitukamo patikkamati, na aloketukamo aloketi, na viloketukamo viloketi, na sammihjitukamo sannnifijeti, na pasaretukamo pasaretiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nann abhikkamitukamo abhikkamati, patikkamitu- kamo patikkamati, aloketukamo aloketi, viloketukamo viloketi, samminjitukamo sammihjeti, pasaretukamo pasaretiti "? Amanta. Hanci abhikkamitukamo abhikkamati, patikkamitu- kamo patikkamati, aloketukamo aloketi, viloketukamo viloketi, sammiiijitukamo sannniiijeti, pasaretukamo pasareti, no vata re vattabbe " Na yatha cittassa kaya- kamman ti." 5. Na vattabbam " Na 3^atha cittassa kayakamman ti " ? Amanta. Nanu atthi koci " ahhatra gacchissamiti " aiihatra gac- chati — pe — "annam pasaressamiti " ahham pasaretiti? Amanta. Hahci atthi koci " aiihatra gacchissamiti " ahhatra gac- chati — pe — ^" ahhain pasaressamiti" ahham pasareti, tena vata re vattabbe " Na yatha cittassa kayakamman ti." N a yatha cittassa kayakamman t i k a t h a . IX. 12. 1. Atltena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Nanu atltam nirucldham vigatani viparinatam atthah- gatam abbhatthahgatan ti ? Amanta. 28 418 KATHAVATTHU. [IX. 12. Hafici atltam niriiddham vigatam viparinatani atthan- gatam abbhatthaiigatam, no vata re vattabbe " Atltena sainannagato ti." 2. Anagatena samannagato ti '? Amanta. Nanu anagatam ajatam abhutam asaiijatam anibbattam anabhinibbattam apatubhutan ti '? Amanta. Hanci anagatam ajatam abhutam asafijatam anibbattam anabhinibbattam apatubhutam, no vata re vattabbe " Ana- gatena samannagato ti." 3. Atltena rupakkhandhena samannagato, anagatena rupakkhandhena samannagato, paccuppannena rupak- khandhena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Tlhi rupakkhandhehi samannagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atitehi pancahi khandhehi samannagato, anagatehi pahcahi khandhehi samannagato, paccuppannehi pancahi khandhehi samannagato ti ? Amanta. Pannarasahi khandhehi samannagato ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Atltena cakkhayatanena samannagato, anagatena cakkhayatanena samannagato, paccuppannena cakkhaya- tanena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Tihi cakkhayatanehi samannagato ti"? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atitehi dvadasahi ayatanehi samannagato, anagatehi dvadasahi ayatanehi samannagato, paccuppannehi dva- dasahi ayatanehi samannagato ti ? Amanta. Chattiins' ayatanehi samannagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Atltaya cakkhudhatuya samannagato, anagataya cakkhudhatuya samannagato, paccuppannaya cakkhu- dhatuya samannagato ti? IX. 12.] KATHAVATTHU. 419 Amanta. Tlhi cakkhiidhatiihi samannagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atltahi attharasahi dhatuhi samannagato, anagatahi attharasahi dhatuhi samannagato, paccuppannahi attha- rasahi dhatuhi samannagato ti '? Amanta. Catupaiiiiasadhatuhi samannagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Atltena cakkhundriyena samannagato, anagatena cakkhundriyena samannagato, paccuppannena cakkhund- riyena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Tlhi cakkhundriyehi samannagato ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atltehi bavlsat' indriyehi samannagato, anagatehi bavls- at' indriyehi samannagato, paccuppannehi bavlsat' indri- yehi samannagato ti? Amanta. Chasatth' indriyehi samannagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Na vattabbam " Atltanagatehi samannatjato ti " "? Amanta, Nanu atthi atthavimokkhajhayi catunnam jhananain nikamalabhl, catunnam anupubbaviharasamapattlnam labhl ti ? Amanta. Haiici atthi atthavimokkhajhayi catunnain jhananam nikamalabhl, catunnam anupubbaviharasamapattlnam labhl, tena vata re vattabbe " Atitanagatehi samanna- gato ti. Atltanagatapaccuppannakatha. Anisamsadassavissa sahnojananam pahanain, Amataram- manam saiifiojanaiu. 420 KATHAVATTHU. [IX. 12. Kupam saranimanain, Anusaya anaramniana, evameva fianam, Atltanagatarammanam cittam, Sabbam cittam vitakkanu- patitam, Sabbaso vitakkayato vicarayato vitakkavippharo saddo, Na yatha cittassa vaca, tath'eva kayakammain, Atltana- gatehi samannagato ti. N a V a 111 o V a g g o . X. 1.] KATHAVATTHU. 421 X. 1. 1. Uppattesiye panca khandhe aniruddhe kiriya paii- ca khandha iippajjantlti '? Amanta. Dasannamkhandhanain samodhanamhoti, dasa khandha saminukhlbhavam agacchantiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Dasannamkhandhanam samodhanam hoti, dasa khandha samniukhibhavam agacchantiti "r* Amanta. Dvinnam phassanain — pe — dvinnam cittanam samo- dhanam hotiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Uppattesiye pahca khandhe aniruddhe kiriya cattaro khandha uppajjantiti ? Amanta. Navannam khandhanain samodhanam hoti, nava khandha samniukhibhavam agacchantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Navannam khandhanam samodhanam hoti, nava khandha sammukhlbhavam agacchantiti ? Amanta. Dvinnam phassanam — pe — dvinnam cittanam samo- dhanain hotiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Uppattesiye pahca khandhe aniruddhe kiriya iianam uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Channam khandhanain samodhanam hoti, cha khandha samniukhibhavam agacchantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Channam khandhanam samodhanam hoti, cha khandiia sammukhlbhavani agacchantiti ? Amanta. Dvinnam phassanain- -pe — dvinnam cittanam sauio- dhanani hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 422 KATHAVATTHU. [X. 2. 4. Uppattesiye pafica khandhe niruddhe maggo uppaj- jatlti '? Ainanta, Mato maggain bhaveti, kalamkato maggam bhavetiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Nirodhakatha. X. 2. 1. Maggasamangissa rupam maggo ti ? Ainanta. Saraninianain, atthi tassa avattana abhogo samanna- haro manasikaro cetana patthana panidhiti V Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Nanu anaraminanam, n' atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Ainanta. Hanoi anaraininanain, n'atthi tassa avattana —pe — panidhi, no vata re vattabbe " Maggasamangissa rupam maggo ti." 2. Sammavaca maggo ti '? Ainanta. Sarammana, atthi taya avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Nanu anarammana, n'atthi taya avattana — pe — pani- dhiti ? Ainanta. Haiici anarammana, n'atthi taya avattana — pe — panidhi, no vata re vattabbe " Sammavaca maggo ti." 3. Saminakammanto — pe — samma-ajlvo maggo ti ? Amanta. Sarammano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Nanu anarammano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — pani- dhiti y X. 2.] KATHAVATTHU. 423 Amaiita. Hanci anaraiumano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhi, no vata re vattabbe " Samina-ajivo maggo ti." 4. Sammaditthi maggo, sa ca sarammana, atthi taya avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Saniniavaca maggo, sa ca sarammana, atthi taya avat- tana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — -pe — Sammaditthi maggo, sa ca sarammana, atthi taya avat- tana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Sammakammanto — pe — samma-ajlvo maggo, so ca sarammano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5 . Sammasamkappo — pe — samma vay amo — pe — sam- masati — pe — sammasamadhi maggo, so ca sarammano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Sammavaca maggo, sa ca sarammana, atthi ta3'a avat- tana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sammasamadhi maggo, so ca sarammano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Sammakammanto — pe — samma-ajlvo maggo, so ca sarammano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Sammavaca maggo, sa ca anarammana, n'atthi taya avattana^pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Sammaditthi maggo, sa ca anarammana, n'atthi taya avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sammavaca maggo, sa ca anarammana, n'atthi taya avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Sammasainkappo — pe — samma vay amo — pe — samma- 424 KATHAVATTHU. [X. 3. sati — pe — saniinasainadhi niaggo, so ca anarammano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 7. Sanimakammanto — pe— sainnia-ajivo inaggo, so ca anarammano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhTti ? Amanta. Sammaditthi — pe — sammasamkappo, sammavayamo, sammasati — pe — sammasamadhi maggo, so ca anaram- mano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Na vattabbam " Maggasamangissa rupam maggo ti"? Amanta. Nanu sammavaca sammakammanto samma-ajlvo maggo ti ?_ Amanta. Hafici sammavaca sammakammanto samma - ajTvo maggo, tena vata re vattabbe " Maggasamangissa rupain maggo ti." Rupam maggo t i k a t h a . X. 3. 1. PaiicaviManasamangissa atthi maggabhavana ti? Amanta. Nanu paiica viilhana uppannavatthuka uppannaram- mana ti ? Amanta. Haiici panca viiifiana uppannavatthuka uppannaram- mana, no vata re vattabbe " Pancavihiianasamahgissa atthi maggabhavana ti." Nanu pahca ^ vihiiana purejatavatthuka purejataram- mana, ajjhattikavatthuka bahirarammana, asambhinna- vatthuka asambhinnarammana, nanavatthuka, nanaram- . phassa, P.S.S2. X. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 425 mana, na annamannassa gocaravisayam paccanubhonti,i na asamannahara uppajjanti, na amanasikara uppajjanti, na abbokinna^ uppajjanti, na apiibbam acarimam uppaj- janti, na aiiiiamannassa sanianantara uppajjanti — pe — nanu paiica viniiana anabhoga ti ? Anianta. Hanci paiica viiiiiana anabhoga, no vata re vattabbe " Pancaviiinanasaniangissa atthi maggabhavana ti." 2. Cakkhuvihiianasamangissa atthi maggabhavana ti ? Amanta. Cakkhuviiinanain sufiiiatam arabbha uppajjatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkhuviniianam suiiiiatam arabbha uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Cakkhuii ca paticca sunnatan ca uppajjati cakkhuvihha- nan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkhuh ca paticca suhhataii ca uppajjati cakkhuviniia- nan ti '? Amanta. " Cakkhuii ca paticca suhhatah ca uppajjati cakkhuviiiha- nan ti," atth'eva suttanto ti? N'atthi. " Cakkhun ca paticca rupe ca uppajjati cakkhuvinhanan ti," atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Haiici "cakkhuh ca paticca rupe ca uppajjati cakkhuviii- nanan ti," atth'eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe "Cakkhuh ca paticca suhhatah ca uppajjati cakkhuvihhanan ti." 3. Cakkhuvihhanasamahgissa atthi mafjcrabhavana ti ? Amanta. Cakkhuvihhanain atltanagatam arabbha uppajjatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkhuvihhanasamahgissa atthi maggabhavana ti ? Amanta. 1 paccanubhavanti, P.S.S2. 2 abbhokinna, P. 82- 426 KATHAVATTHU. [X. 3. Cakkhuvinnanam phassam arabbha vedanaip arabbha saiinaiii arabbha cetanam arabbha cittaiii arabbha cak- khuiii arabbha — pe — kayaiu tirabbha saddam arabbha — pe — photthabbaiu arabbha uppaj jatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Manovinhanasamahgissa atthi inaogabhavana, mano- vihnanam sunhatam arabbha uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Cakkhuvinnanasamangissa atthi maggabhavana, cak- khuvinnanaiu sunhatam arabbha uppajjatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Manoviiiiianasamahgissa atthi maggabhavana, mano- vihhanam atitanagatam arabbha uppajjatiti V Amanta. C'akkhuviiiiianasamahgissa atthi maggabhavana, cak- khuviiiiianam atitanagatam arabbha uppajjatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Manovinhanasamahgissa atthi maggabhavana, mano- vihhanain phassam arabbha — pe — photthabbam arabbha uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Cakkhuvinnanasamangissa atthi maggabhavana, cakkhu- vihhanain phassam arabbha — pe — photthabbain arabbha uppajjatiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 4. Na vattabbain " Paiicaviiiiianasamahgissa atthi maggabhavana ti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttani Bhagavata — " Idha Bhikkhave bhikkhu cakkhuna rupain disva na nimittagahl hoti nanubyahja- naggahl — pe — sotena saddam sutva — pe— ghanena gan- dham ghayitva — -pe — jivhaya rasam sayitva — pe — kayena photthabbain phusitva na nimittaggahi hoti nanubyahja- naggahl ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi pahcaviiihanasamahgissa atthi maggabhavana ti. P a ii c a V i h h ii n a s a m a h g i s s a m a g g a k a t h a. X. 4. J KATHAVATTHU. 427 X. 4. 1. Paiica vinnana kusala pi akusala piti ? Amanta. Nanii panca vinnana iippannavatthuka uppannarani- mana ti ? Amanta. Haiici panca viiifiana uppannavatthuka uppannarani- mana, no vata re vattabbe "Panca vinnana kusala pi akusala piti." Nanu paiica viiifiana purejatavattliuka purejatarain- mana, ajjliattikavatthuka bahiraranimana, asambliinna- vatthuka asanibhinnaraniniana, nanavattliuka nanaram- niana, iia annaniafiiiassa gocaravisayam paccanubhonti, na asaiiiannaliara uppajjanti, na amanasikara uppaj- janti, na abbokinna uppajjanti, na apubbam acarimam uppajjanti, na aniiamaiinassa samanaiitara uppajjanti — pe — nanu paiica viniiana anabhoga ti '? Amanta. Haiici paiica vinnana anabhoga, no vata re vattabbe " Panca viiifiaiia kusala pi akusala piti." 2. Cakkliuviiinanam kusalaii ti? Amanta. Cakkliuviiifianam sumiatam arabbha uppajjatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkliuviiiiianam suiiiiatain arabbha uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Cakkhuh ca paticca suhnatari ca uppajjati cakkliuvifi- fianan ti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkhuii ca paticca suhhatah ca uppajjati cakkhuvih- naiian ti ? Amanta. " Cakkhufi ca paticca suhhatah ca uppajjati cakkhuvih- hanan ti," atth'eva suttanto ti ? N'atthi. " Cakkhuh ca paticca riipe ca uppajjati cakkhuvihhanan ti," atth'eva suttanto ti V 428 KATHAVATTHU. [X.-4. Amanta. Hafici " cakkhun ca paticca rnpe ca uppajjati cakkhuvin- nanan ti," atth'eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe " Cakkhun ca paticca snnnatan ca uppajjati cakkhuviiinanan ti." 8. Cakkbuvinnanain kusalani pi akusalam piti ? Amanta. Cakkhuvinnanain atltanagatam arabbha uppajjatiti ? • Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Cakkhuvinnanain kusalam pi akusalam piti ? Amanta. • Cakkhuvinnanain phassain arabbha vedanaiu arabbha saiinam arabbha cetanam arabbha cittam arabbha cak- khuin arabbha — pe — kaj'ain arabbha saddam arabbha — pe — photthabbain arabbha uppajjatiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — ])e — Manoviiifianam kusalani pi akusalain pi, manoviiihanain suhiiatam arabbha uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Cakkhuviiinanam kusalani pi akusalain pi, cakkhuvin- nanain suniiatam arabbha uppajjatiti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Manovinhanain kusalam pi akusalam pi, manovifihanam atitanagatain arabbha uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Cakkhuvihhanain kusalam pi akusalain pi, cakkhuvih- lianam atitanagatain arabbha uppajjatiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Manovifihanam kusalam pi akusalain pi, manovinhanain phassain arabbha — pe — photthabbain arabbha uppajjatiti'? Amanta. Cakkhuviiiiianani kusalani pi akusalain pi, cakkhuvin- nanain phassain arabbha — pe — photthabbain arabbha uppajjatiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 4. Na vattabbain " Pahca vihhana kusala pi akusala piti"? Amanta. Nanu vuttain Bhagavata — " Idha Bhikkhave bhikkhu X. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 429 cakkhuna rupani disva nimittaggahl hoti — pe— na nimit- taggahl hoti — pe — sotena saddain sutva — pe — kayena photthabbam phusitva nimittaggahl hoti— pe — na nimit- taggahl hotlti." Atth'eva siittanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi panca viimana kusala pi akusala piti. P a h c a V i h n a n a k ii s a 1 a piti k a t h a. X. 5. 1. Paiica vihhana sabhoga ti ? Amanta. Nanu pahca vinnana nppannavatthuka uppannaram- mana ti ? Amanta. Hanoi panca vihhana nppannavatthuka uppannaram- mana, no vata re vattabbe " Pahca vihhana sabhoea ti." Nanu pahca vihhana purejatavatthuka purejataram- mana, ajjhattikavatthuka bahirarammana, asambhinna- vatthuka asambhinnarammana, nanavatthuka nanaram- mana, na ahhamahhassa gocaravisayam paccanubhonti, na asamannahara uppajjanti, na amanasikara uppajjanti, na abbokinna uppajjanti, na apubbam acarimani uppaj- janti, nanu pahca vihhana na ahhamahhassa samanantara uppajjantiti? Amanta. Hahci pahca vihhana na ahhamahhassa samanantara uppajjanti, no vata re vattabbe "Pahca vihhana sabhoga ti." 2. Cakkhuvihhanam sabhogan ti ? Amanta. Cakkhuvihhanam suhhatain arabbha uppajjatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkhuvihhanam suhhatain arabbha uppajjatiti ? Amanta. 430 KATHAVATTHU. 'X. 5. Cakkhiin ca paticca sunnatafi ca iippajjati cakkhuvin- nanan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkhun ca paticca suiinatan ca iippajjati cakkhuvin- iianan ti '? Ainanta. " Cakkhun ca paticca suniiataii ca uppajjati cakkhuvin- fianan ti," atth'eva suttanto ti? N'atthi. " Cakkhun ca paticca rupeca uppajjati cakkhuvihhanan ti," atth'eva suttanto ti '? Amanta. Hahci " cakkhun ca paticca riipe ca uppajjati cakkhuvih- nanan ti," atth'eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe " Cakkhun ca paticca suiifiatah ca uppajjati cakkhuvihiianan ti." 3. Cakkhuvihiianam sabhogan ti ? Amanta. Cakkhuvihhanam atitanagatam arabbha uppajjatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkhuvihhanam sabhogan ti ? Amanta. Cakkhuvihhanam phassam arabbha vedanam arabbha sahhain arabbha cetanam arabbha cittain arabbha cak- khum arabbha — pe — kayam arabbha saddam arabbha — pe — photthabbam arabbha uppajjatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Manovihhanam sabhogam, manovihhanam suhhatam arabbha uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Cakkhuvihhanam sabhogani, cakkhuvihhanam suhha- tam arabbha uppajjatiti '? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Manovihhanam sabhogam, manovihhanani atitanaga- tam arabbha uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Cakkhuvihhanam sabhogani, cakkhuvihhanam atitana- gatam arabbha uppajjatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — X. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 431 Manoviniianam sabhogam, manovinnanam phassani arabbha — pe — photthabbam arabbha uppajjatiti '? Amanta. Cakkhuvinnanam sabliogam, cakkhiivifinanain phassaip arabbha — pe — photthabbaui arabbha uppajjatiti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — 4. Na vattabbain " Pahca vihhana sabhoga ti " "? Amanta. Nanu vuttain Bhagavata — " Idha Bhikkhave bhikkhii cakkhuna rupam disva nimittaggahl hoti — pe — na nimit- taggahl hoti — pe — sotena saddam sutva — pe — kayena photthabbam phusitva nimittaggahl hoti — pe — na nimit- taggahl hotlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Ten a hi paiica vinfiana sabhoga ti. Sabhogakatha. X. 6. 1. Maggasamahgi dvlhi sTlehi samannagato ti? Amanta. Maggasamahgi dvlhi phassehi dvlhi vedanahi dvlhi sah- hahi dvlhi cetanahi dvlhi cittehi dvlhi saddhahi dvihi viri- yehi dvihi satlhi dvlhi samadhlhi dvlhi paiiiiahi samanna- gato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Maggasamahgi lokiyena sllena samannagato ti '? Amanta. Maggasamahgi lokiyena phassena lokiyaya vedanaya lokiyaya sahhaya lokiyaya cetanaya lokiyena cittena lokiyaya saddhaya lokiyena viriyena lokiyaya satiya lokiyena samadhina lokiyaya pahhaya samannagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Maggasamahgi lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca sllena samannagato ti ? Amanta. 432 KATHAVATTHU. [X. 6. Maggasamangi lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca phassena samannagato — pe — lokij'aya ca lokuttaraya ca paiinaya sauiannagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Maggasamangi lokiyena sllena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Maggasamangi puthujjano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Maggasamangi lokiyaya sammavacaya samannagato ti V Amanta. Maggasamangi lokiyaya sammaditthiya samannagato ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Maggasamangi lokiyaya sammavacaya samannagato ti?_ Amanta. Maggasamangi lokiyena sammasamkappena — pe — • lokiyena sammavayamena — pe — lokiyaya sammasati3^a — pe — lokiyena sammasamadhina samannagato ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Maggasamangi lokiyena sammakammantena — pe — lokiyena samma-ajlvena samannagato ti '? Amanta. Maggasamangi lokiyaya sammaditthiya — pe — lokiyena sammasamadhina samannagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Maggasamangi lokiyaya ca lokuttaraya ca sammava caya samannagato ti ? Amanta. Maggasamangi lokiyaya ca lokuttaraya ca sammadit- thiya samannagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Maggasamangi lokiyaya ca lokuttaraya ca sammava- caya samannagato ti ? Amanta. Maggasamangi lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca sammasam- kappena — pe — lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca sammavaya- X, 7.] KATHAVATTHU. 433 mena — pe — lokiyaya ca lokuttaraya ca sammasatiya— pe — lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca sammasamadhina samanna- gato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe^pe — 6. Maggasamangi lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca samma- kammantena — pe — maggasamangi lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca samma-ajlvena samannagato ti ? Amanta. Maggasamangi lokiyaya ca lokuttaraya ca sammadit- thiya samannagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Maggasamangi lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca samma- ajlvena samannagato ti '? Amanta. Maggasamangi lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca sammasam- kappena — pe — lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca sammasama- dhina samannagato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Na vattabbam " Maggasamangi dvlhi sllehi saman- nagato ti." ■? Amanta. Lokiye slle niruddhe maggo uppajjatiti '? Amanta. Dussllo ^ khandasllo chinnasllo maggam bhavetiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi maggasamangi dvlhi sllehi samannagato ti. Dvlhi sllehiti katha. X. 7. 1. Sllam acetasikan ti ? Amanta. Hupam nibbanam cakkhayatanam — pe — kayayatanaiii -pe — rupayatanam — pe — photthabbayatanan ti ? I dnssalo, M. 29 434 KATHAVATTHU. [X. 7. Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Sllain acetasikan ti ? Amanta. Phasso acetasiko ti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sllani acetasikan ti ? Amanta. Vedana — pe — sanna — pe — cetana — pe — saddha — pe — viriy am — pe — sati — pe — samadhi — pe — paMa acetasika ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Phasso cetasiko ti ? Amanta. Sllam cetasikan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vedana — pe — saiiha — pe — cetan a — pe — saddha — pe — viriyam — pe — sati — pe — samadhi — pe — paniia cetasika ti "? Amanta. Sllain cetasikan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Sllani acetasikan ti ? Amanta. AnitthaphakMi ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu itthaphalan ti ? Amanta. Hahci itthaphahiiii, no vata re vattabbe " Sllam aceta- sikan ti." 4. Saddha itthaphala, saddha cetasika ti ? Amanta. Sllam itthaphalain, silani cetasikan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Viriyam, sati, samadhi — pe — pahha itthaphala, pahha cetasika ti ? Amanta. Sllani itthaphalain, sllam cetasikan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Sllain itthaphalain, silaiii acetasikan ti? X. 7. KATHAVATTHU. 435 Anianta. Saddha itthaphala, saddha acetasika ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Silam itthaphalam, sllam acetasikan ti ? Amanta. Viriyain, sati, samadhi — pe — paiina itthaphala, pahiia acetasika ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Sllam acetasikan ti '? Amanta. Aphalam avipakan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Nanu saphalam savipakan ti ? Amanta. Hahci saphalam savipakam, no vata re vattabbe " Sllam acetasikan ti." 7. Cakkhayatanam acetasikam avipakan ti ? Amanta. Sllam acetasikan! avipakan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sotayatanam — pe — kayayatanam — pe — rupayatanam — pe — photthabbayatanam acetasikam avipakan ti ? Amanta. Sllam acetasikam avipakan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Sllam acetasikam savipakan ti ? Amanta. Cakkhayatanam acetasikam savipakan ti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sllam acetasikam savipakan ti ? Amanta. Sotayatanam — pe — kayayatanam — pe — rupayatanam — pe — photthabbayatanam acetasikain savipakan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 9. Sammavaca acetasika ti ? Amanta. Sammaditthi acetasika ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 436 KATHAVATTHU. [X. 7. Sammavaca acetasika ti? Amanta. Sammasamkappo — pe — samniavayamo — pe — samma- sati — pe — saminasamadhi acetasiko ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sammakamnianto — pe — samnia-ajlvo acetasiko ti V Amanta. Samniaditthi acetasika ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe- — Samma-ajivo acetasiko ti ? Amanta. Sammasamkappo — pe — samniavayamo — pe — samma- sati — pe— sammasamadhi acetasiko ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 10. Sanmiaditthi cetasika ti ? Amanta. Sammavaca cetasika ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samniaditthi cetasika ti ? Amanta. Sammakammanto — pe — samma-ajivo cetasiko ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sammasamkappo - — pe — samniavayamo — pe — samma- sati — pe — sammasamadhi cetasiko ti ? Amanta. Sammavaca cetasika ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sammasamadhi cetasiko ti ? Amanta. Sammakammanto — pe — samma-ajivo cetasiko ti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 11. Na vattabbam " Sllam acetasikan ti " ? Amanta. Slle uppajjitva niruddhe dussilo ^ hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi sllam acetasikan ti. Silain acetasikan ti katha. ' asllo, P.S.S2. X. 8.1 KATHAVATTHU. 487 X. 8. i. Sllam na cittanuparivattiti V Anianta. Kupam nibbanain cakkhayatanani — pe — kayayatanam — pe — riipayatanain — pe — photthabbayatanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8ilam na cittanuparivattiti ? Amanta. Phasso na cittanuparivattiti ? Na h'evarn vattabbe — ^pe — Sllam na cittanuparivattiti ? Amanta. Vedana — pe — saiiiia — pe — cetana — pe — saddha — pe — viriyam — pe — sati — pe— samadhi — pe — paiiiia na cittanu- parivattiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Phasso cittanuparivattiti ? Amanta. Sllain cittanuparivattiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vedana — pe — saniia — pe — cetana — pe — saddha — pe — - viriyam — pe — sati — pe — samadlii — pe — paiina cittanupari- vattiti V Amanta. Sllam cittanuparivattiti ? Na h'evaiii vattabbe — pe^ 8. Bammavaca na cittanuparivattiti ? Amanta. Sammaditthi na cittanuparivattiti ? Na h'evaiii vattabbe — pe — Sammavaca na cittanuparivattiti ? Amanta. Sammasanikappo — pe — sammavayamo — pe — sanima- sati — pe — sammasamadhi na cittanuparivattiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sammakammanto — pe — samma-ajlvt) na cittanupari- vattiti V 438 KATHAVATTHU. [X. 8. Amanta. Sainmaditthi na cittanuparivattlti ? Na h'evaiu vattabbe — pe — Samina-ajlvo na cittanuparivattlti '? Amanta. Sammasamkappo — pe — sammavayamo — pe — samnia- sati — pe — sanimasamadhi na cittanuparivattlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Sannnaditthi cittanuparivattlti? Amanta. Sammavaca cittanuparivattlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sainmaditthi cittanuparivattlti ? Amanta. Sammakammanto — pe — samma-ajlvo cittanuparivat- tlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — - Sammasamkappo — pe — sammavayamo — pe — saiiima- sati — pe — sammasamadhi cittanuparivattlti ? Amanta. Sammavaca cittanuparivattlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sammasamadhi cittanuparivattlti ? Amanta. Sammakammanto — pe — samma-ajivo cittanuparivat- tlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Na vattabbam " Sllam na cittanuparivattlti " ? Amanta. Sile uppajjitva niruddhe dussilo ^ hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi sTlam na cittanuparivattlti. Silaiii na cittanuparivattlti katha. ^ asllo, P.S.Ss. X. 9.] KATHAVATTHU. 439 X. 9. 1. Samadanahetukam sllam vaddhatiti ? Amanta. Samadanahetuko phasso vaddhati, vedana vaddhati, sanna vaddhati, cetana vaddhati, cittam vaddhati, saddha vaddhati, viriyam vaddhati, sati vaddhati, samadhi vad- dhati, pahha vaddhatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Samadanahetukam sllam vaddhatiti ? Amanta. Lata viya vaddhati, mahwa viya vaddhati, riikkho viya vaddhati, tinam viya vaddhati, munjapuhjo viya vaddha- titi ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Samadanahetukam silani vaddhatiti ? Amanta. Sllam samadiyitva kamavitakkam vitakkentassa bya- padavitakkani vitakkentassa vihimsavitakkam vitak- kentassa sllam vaddhatiti ? , Amanta. Dvinnam phassanam — pe — dvinnam cittanam samo- dhanam hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dvinnam phassanani — pe — dvinnam cittanam samo- dhanam hotiti ? Amanta. Kusalakusala savajjanavajja hinappanlta kanhasukka- sappatibhaga dhamma sammukhlbhavam agacchantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Kusalakusala savajjanavajja hinappanlta kanhasukka- sappatibhaga dhamma sammukhlbhavain agacchantiti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Cattar'imani Bhikkhave suvidnravidurani. Katamani cattari ? Labhaii ca Bhik- khave pathavl ca, idani pathamam suviduravidurain — pe — tasma satam dhammo asabbhi araka ti." Atth'eva sut- tanto ti ? 440 KATHAVATTHU. [X. 10. Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbain " Kusalakusala savajjanavajja hinappanlta kanhasiikkasappatibhaga dhamma saiuniu- khlbhavam agacchantlti." Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Na vattabbam " Sainadanahetukam sllam vaddha- tlti"? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhaoavata — " Aramaropa vanaropa — pe — Dhammattha sllasampanna Te jana saggagamino ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi samadanahetiikani silam vaddhatlti. Samadanahetiikakatha. X. 10. 1. Vihhatti silan ti V Amanta. Panatipata veramaniti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Adinnadana veramaniti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamesu micchacara veramaniti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Musavada veramaniti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Suramerayamajjapamadatthana veramaniti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Abhivadanain silani, pacciitthanani ^ sllam, ahjallkam- mam sllam, samlcikammam sllam, asanabhiharo sllam, seyyabhiharo sllain, padodakabhiharo sllam, padakatha- liyabhiharo sllam, nahane ^ pitthiparikammam sllan ti '? I paccupatthanani, P.M. - nhane, M.K. X. 11.] KATHAVATTHU. 441 Anianta. Panatipata veramanlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Suramerayainajjapamadatthana veramanlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Na vattabbam " Vinnatti sllan ti." Dussllyan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi viiihatti silan ti. V i 11 ii a 1 1 i Sllan t i k a t h a . X. 11. 1. Avimiatti dussllyan ti '? Amanta. Paiiatipato ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — -pe — Adinnadanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamesu micchacaro ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Musavado ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Suramerayamajjapamadatthanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Papakammam samadiyitva danam dadantassa piifi- nafi ca apuiiiiaii ca iibho vaddhantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Pmlhan ca apunnah ca ubho vaddhantiti ? Amanta. Dvinnam phassaiiani — pe — dvinnam cittanaiii samo- dhanani hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dvinnain phassanain — pe — dvinnam cittanain samo- dhanain hotiti ? Amanta. 442 KATHAVATTHU. [X. 11. Kusalakusala savajjanavajja hlnappanlta kanhasukka- sappatibhaga dhainma sainmukhibhavam agacchantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kusalakusala savajjanavajja hlnappanlta kanhasukka- sappatibhaga dhamma samniukhibhavam agacchantiti V Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Cattar'imani Bhikkhave suviduravidurani. Kataniani cattari ? Labhah ca Bhik- khave pathavl ca, idam pathamam suviduravidurani — pe — tasma satam dhanimo asabbhi araka ti." Atth'eva sut- tanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Kusalakusala savajjanavajja hlnappanlta kanhasukkasappatibhaga dhamma sammukhl- bhavain agacchantiti." 8. Papakammam samadiyitva civaram dadantassa, pindapatam dadantassa, senasanam dadantassa, gila- napaccayabhesajjaparikkharam dadantassa, abhivada- narahassa abhivadentassa, paccutthanarahassa paccut- thentassa, ahjallkammarahassa aiijallkammam karontassa, sammicikammarahassa sammlcikammam karontassa, asanarahassa asanam dadantassa, maggarahassa maggam dadantassa puhnah ca apuiinan ca ubho vaddhantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Puhiiah ca apuhhah ca ubho vaddhantiti ? Amanta. Dvinnani phassanam — pe — dvinnam cittanani samo- dhanain hotiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Dvinnam phassanam — pe — dvinnam cittanam samo- dhanam hotiti ? Amanta. Kusalakusala savajjanavajja hlnappanlta kanhasukkasap- patibhaga dhamma sammukhlbhavam agacchantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kusalakusala savajjanavajja hlnappanlta kanhasukkasap- patibhaga dhamma sammukhlbhavain agacchantiti ? Amanta. X. 11.] KATHAVATTHU. 443 Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Cattar'imani Bhikkhave suviduravidurani. Kataniani cattari '? Labhan ca Bhikkhave pathavl ca, idain pathamam suviduraviduram — pe — tasma satam dhammo asabbhi arakati." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Kusalakusala savajjanavajja hlnappanita kanhasukkasappatibhaga dhainma saminiikhl- bhavam agacchantlti." 4. Na vattabbain " Aviiiiiatti dussilyan ti " ? Amanta. Nanu papakammam samadinno asiti ? Amanta. Hahci papakammam samadinno asi, tena, vata re vattabbe " Aviiihatti dussilyan ti." A V i h h a 1 1 i dussilyan t i k a t h a . Maggasamahgissa rupam maggo, Paiicavihhanasaman- gissa atthi maggabhavana, Paiica vifihana kusala pi akusala pi, Panca vihhana sabboga, Maggasamangi dvlhi silehi sainannagato, Sllam aceta- sikain, Sllam na cittanuparivatti, Samadanahetukam silam vaddhati, Viiiiiatti sllam, Avihhatti dussilyan ti. D a s a m o V a g g o . D u t i y a p a n n a s a k o . Niyamasaingahagatanisainsata atthi paiicavokara- bhavo maggasamahgissa ^ no pahcavokarabhavo. ^ maggasamangi, P.S.S.o; nirodho maggasamangi, M. 444 KATHAVATTHU. [XI. 1. XI. 1. 1 . Anusaya abyakata ti ? Amanta. Vipakabyakata kiriyabyakata rupam nibbanam cakkha- yatanani — pe — photthabbayatanan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 2. Kamaraganusayo abyakato ti? Amanta. Kaniarago kainaragapariyutthanam kamaragasaii- fiojanain kainogho kamayogo kamacchandanivarariam abyakatan ti ? Na b'evani vattabbe — pe — Kaniarago — pe — kaniacchandanivaranain akusalan ti ? Amanta. Kamaraganusayo akiisalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Patighanusayo abyakato ti ? Amanta. Patighain patighapariyiitthanam patighasaiinoj anam abyakatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Patighain patighapariyiitthanam patighasahhojanam akusalan ti ? Amanta. Patighanusayo akusalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Mananusayo abyakato ti ? Amanta. Mano manapariyutthanam manasahhojanam abyakatan ti? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Mano manapariyutthanam manasahhojanani akusalan ti? Amanta. Mananusayo akusalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — XI. 1.] KATHAVATTHU. 445 5. Ditthanusayo abyakato ti '? Anianta. Ditthi ditthogho ditthiyogo ditthipariyutthanam ditthi- sannojanam abyakatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ditthi ditthogho ditthiyogo ditthipariyutthanam ditthi- sahiiojanam akusalan ti ? Amanta. Ditthanusa^'o aknsalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Vicikicchanusayo abyakato ti? Amanta. Vicikiccha vicikicchapariyutthanam vicikicchasahho- janam vicikicchanlvaranam abyakatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vicikiccha vicikicchapariyutthanam vicikicchasahho- janam vicikicchanlvaranam akusalan ti ? Amanta. Vicikicchanusayo akusalo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Bhavaraganusayo abyakato ti? Amanta. Bhavarago bhavaragapariyutthanam bhavaragasaniio- janam abyakatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Bhavarago bhavaragapariyutthanam bhavaragasanho- janam akusalan ti ? Amanta. Bhavaraganusayo akusalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— b. Avijjanusayo abyakato ti ? Amanta. Avijja avijjogho avijjayogo avijjapariyutthanam avijja- sanhojanam avijjanlvaranarn abyakatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Avijja avijjogho avijjayogo avijjapariyutthanam avijja- sahhojanani avijjanlvaranarn akusalan ti ? Amanta. 446 KATHAVATTHU. [XI. 1. Avijjanusayo akusalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 9. Na vattabbam " Anusaya abyakata ti " ? Amanta. Puthujjano kusalabyakate citte vattamane " sanusayo ti " vattabbo ti ? Amanta. Kiisalakusala dhamma sammnkhlbhavam agacchantlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi anusaya abyakata ti. Puthujjano kusalabyakate citte vattamane " sarago ti " vattabbo ti '? Amanta. Kusalakusala dhamma sammukhibhavam agacchantlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — ^pe — Tena hi rago abyakato ti. 10. Anusaya ahetuka ti ? Amanta. Rupam nibbanam cakkhayatanam — pe — photthab- bayatanan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamaraganusayo ahetuko ti ? Amanta. Kamarago kamaragapariyutthanain kamaragasaiiho- janam — pe — kamaraganlvaranam ahetukan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamarago kamaragapariyutthanain kamaragasahho- janam — pe — kamaraganlvaranam sahetukan ti? Amanta. Kamaraganusayo sahetuko ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Patighanusayo— pe — mananusayo, ditthanusayo, vici- kicchanusayo, bhavaraganusayo — pe — avijjanusayo ahetuko ti ? Amanta. Avijja avijjogho avijjayogo avijjapariyutthanam avijja- saniiojanain avijjamvaranam ahetukan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — XI. 1.] KATHAVATTHU. 447 Avijja avijjogho — pe — avijjanivaranam sahetukan ti ? Amanta. Avijjanusayo sahetuko ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 11. Na vattabbam " Anusaya ahetuka ti " '^ Amanta. Puthujjano kusalabyakate citte vattamane " sanusayo ti " vattabbo ti? Amanta. Anusaya tena lietuna sahetuka ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — • Tena hi anusaya ahetuka ti. Puthujjano kusalabyakate citte vattamane " sarago ti " vattabbo ti ? Amanta. Rago tena hetuna sahetuko ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi rago ahetuko ti. 12. Anusaya cittavippayutta ti? Amanta. Eupain nibbanam cakkhayatanam— pe — photthabbaya- tanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamaraganusayo cittavippayutto ti ? Amanta. Kamarago kamaragapariyutthanain kamaragasahiio- janani kamogho kamayogo kamacchandanlvaranam citta- vippayuttan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamarago — pe— kamacchandanlvaranam cittasampa- yuttan ti ? Amanta. Kamaraganusayo cittasampayutto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 18. Kamaraganusayo cittavippayutto ti ? Amanta. Katamakkhandhapariyapanno ti ? Samkharakkhan- dhapariyapanno ti. 448 KATHAVATTHU. [XI. 1. Sainkharakkhanclho cittavippayutto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samkharakkhandlio cittavippayutto ti ? Amanta. Vedanakkhandho, vifinaiiakkhandho cittavippayutto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 14. Kamaraganusayo samkharakkhandhapariyapanno cittavippayutto ti? Amanta. Kamarago samkharakkhandhapariyapanno cittavippa- yutto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamarago samkharakkhandhapariyapanno cittasampa- yutto ti ? Amanta. Kamaraganusayo samkharakkhandhapariyapanno citta- sampayutto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 15. Kamaraganusayo samkharakkhandhapariyapanno cittavippayutto, kamarago samkharakkhandhapariyapanno cittasampayutto ti ? Amanta. Samkharakkhandho ekadeso cittasampayutto ekadeso cittavippayutto ti *? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samkharakkhandho ekadeso cittasampayutto ekadeso cittavippayutto ti ? Amanta. Vedanakkhandho, vihhanakkhandho ekadeso cittasam- payutto ekadeso cittavippayutto ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 16. Patighanusayo, mananusayo, ditthanusayo, vicikic- chanusayo, bhavaraganusayo, avijjanusayo cittavippayutto ti? Amanta. Avijja avijjogho avijjayogo — pe — avijjanlvaranam citta- vippayuttan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — XI. 1.] KATHAVATTHU. 449 Avijja avijjogho avijjayogo — pe — avijjanlvaranam citta- ■sampayiittan ti "? Amanta. Avijjanusayo cittasampayutto ti ? Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — 17. Avijjanusayo cittavippayutto ti? Amanta. Katamakkhandhapariyapanno ti ? Samkharakkhan- ■dhapariyapanno ti. Samkharakkhandlio cittavippayutto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — • Samkharakkhandho cittavippayutto ti ? Amanta. Vedanakkhandho, safinakkhandho cittavippayutto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 18. Avijjanusayo samkharakkhandhapariyapanno citta- vippayutto ti ? Amanta. Avijja samkharakkhandhapariyapanna cittavippayutta ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Avijja samkharakkhandhapariyapanna cittasampayutta ti ?_ Amanta. Avijjanusayo samkharakkhandhapariyapanno cittasam- payutto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 19. Avijjanusayo samkharakkhandhapariyapanno citta- vippayutto, avijja samkharakkhandhapariyapanna citta- sampayutta ti ? Amanta. Samkharakkhandho ekadeso cittasampayutto ekadeso cittavippayutto ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samkharakkhandho ekadeso cittasampayutto ekadeso cittavippayutto ti ? Amanta. Vedanakkhandho, safiiiakkhandho ekadeso cittasam- payutto ekadeso cittavippayutto ti'? 30 4r)0 KATHAVATTHU. [XI. 2. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — '20. Na vattabbam " Anusaya cittavippayiitta ti " ? Amanta. Puthujjano kusalabyakate citte vattamane " sanusayo ti " vattabbo ti? Amanta. Anusaya tena cittena sanipayutta ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi anusaya cittavippayutta ti. Puthujjano kusalabyakate citte vattamane " sarago ti " vattabbo ti ? Amanta. Eago tena cittena sampayutto ti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi rago cittavippayutto ti. T i s s o pi a n u s a y a k a t h a . XL 2. 1. Ahhane vigate hanavippayutte citte vattamane na vattabbam ' ' nam ti " '? Amanta. Kage vigate na vattabbam " vitarago ti " ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ahhane vigate hanavippayutte citte vattamane na vat- tabbain " haul ti " ? Amanta. Dose vigate — pe — mohe vigate — pe — kilese vigate na vattabbam " Nikkileso ti " ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe- — 2. Bage vigate vattabbam " vitarago ti " ? Amanta. Ahhane vigate ilanavippayutte citte vattamfuie vattab- bam ' ' hani ti " ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — XI. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 451 Dose vigate^pe — luohe vigate — pe — kilese vigate vat- tabbam " nikkileso ti " ? Amanta. Anfiane vigate nanavippayutte citte vattamane vattab- bam ' ' nam ti " '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Aniiane vigate iianavippayutte citte vattamane vat- tabbain ^ " nam ti " ? Amanta. Atltena lianena iiani, niruddhena vigatena patipassad- dhena iianena iianl ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N a n a k a t h a . XI. 3. 1. Nanam cittavippayuttan ti ? Amanta. Riipam nibbanam cakkhayatanam — pe — photthabbaya- tanan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Nanam cittavippayuttan ti ? Amanta. Panha pannindriyam pahhabalam sammaditthi dhamma- vicayasambojjhahgo cittavippayutto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — • Panna pannindriyam pahiiabalam sammaditthi dhamma- vicayasambojjhaiigo cittasampayutto ti ? Amanta. Nanam cittasampayuttan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe^pe — 2. Nanam cittavippayuttan ti? Amanta. na vattabbam, P. 452 KATHAVATTHU. [XI. 3. Katamakkhandhapariyapannan ti ? Samkharakkhan- dhapariyapannan ti. Samkharakkhandho cittavippayutto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samkharakkhandho cittavippayutto ti ? Amanta. Vedanakkhandho, safmakkhandho cittavippayutto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Nanam samkharakkhandhapariyapannam cittavip- payuttan ti ? Amianta. Paiiha samkharakkhandhapariyapanna cittavippayutta ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Pahha samkharakkhandhapariyapanna cittasampayutta Amanta. Nanam samkharakkhandhapariyapannam cittasampa- yuttan ti ? Na h'evarn vattabbe — pe — 4. Nanam samkharakkhandhapariyapannam cittavippa- yuttam, paiina samkharakkhandhapariyapanna cittasam- payutta ti ? Amanta. Samkharakkhandho ekadeso cittasampayutto ekadeso cittavippayutto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — -pe — Samkharakkhandho ekadeso cittasampayutto ekadeso cittavippayutto ti ? Amanta. Vedanakkhandho, saiihakkhandho ekadeso cittasampa- yutto, ekadeso cittavippayutto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Na vattabbam " Nanam cittavippayuttan ti "'? Amanta. Araha cakkhuvifiiianasamahgi " iiani ti " vattabbo ti ? Amanta. Nanam tena cittena sampayuttan ti ? XI. 4.] KATHAVATTHU. 453 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi nanam cittavippayuttan ti. Araha cakkhuvifinanasamangi " pamiava ti " vattabbo ti? Am ant a. Paiina tena cittena sampayutta ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi pahiia cittavippayiitta ti. Nanam cittavippayuttan ti katha. XI. 4. 1. " Iclam dukkhan ti " vacam bhasato " idam dukkhan ti " hanam pavattatiti ? Am ant a. " Ayam samudayo ti" vacam bhasato "ayam samudayo ti " hanam pavattatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — " Idam dukkhan ti " vacam bhasato " idam dukkhan ti " hanam pavattatiti ? Amanta. " Ayam nirodho ti " vacam bhasato " ayam nirodho ti " hanam pavattatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — "Idam dukkhan ti " vacam bhasato "idam dukkhan ti " hanam pavattatiti '? Amanta. "Ayam maggo ti " vacam bhasato "ayam maggo ti " hanam pavattatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. " Ayam samudayo ti " vacam bhasato na ca " ayam samudayo ti " hanam pavattatiti? Amanta. " Idam dukkhan ti " vacain bhasato na ca " idam dukkhan ti " hanam pavattatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 454 KATHAVATTHU. [XI. 4. " Ayam nirodho ti " vacam bhasato na ca " ayam nirodho ti " nanam pavattatiti '? Amanta. " Idam dukkhan ti " vacam bhasato na ca " idam dukkhan ti " nanam pavattatiti? Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — " Ayam maggo ti " vacam bhasato na ca " ayam maggo ti " nanam pavattatiti ? Amanta. " Idam dukkhan ti " vacam bhasato na ca " idam dukkhan ti ' ' nanam pavattatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. " Idam dukkhan ti " vacam bhasato " idam dukkhan ti " hanam pavattatiti ? Amanta. " Riipam aniccan ti " vacam bhasato " rupam aniccan ti " nanam pavattatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — "Idam dukkhan ti " vacam bhasato "idam dukkhan ti " iianam pavattatiti ? Amanta. " Vedana — pe — saiiha — pe — samkhara — pe — viiihanam aniccan ti " vacam bhasato " vihhanam aniccan ti " nanam pavattatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. " Idam dukkhan ti " vacam bhasato " idam dukkhan ti ' ' nanam pavattatiti ? Amanta. " Bupam anatta ti " vacam bhasato " rupam anatta ti " nanam pavattatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — " Idam dukkhan ti " vacam bhasato " idam dukkhan ti " nanam pavattatiti ? Amanta. " Vedana — pe — sanha — pe — samkhara — pe — vihhanam anatta ti " vacam bhasato "vihhanam anatta ti " nanam pavattatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — XI. 4. J KATHAVATTHU. 455 5. " Kiipam aniccan ti " vacam bhasato iia ca " iTipaiu aniccan ti " nanam pavattatiti '? Amanta. " Idam dukkhan ti " vacam bhasato na ca " idam dukkhan ti " nanam pavattatiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — " Vedana — pe — saiina — pe — samkhara — pe — viniianam aniccan ti " vacam bhasato na ca " vihhanam aniccan ti " nanam pavattatiti ? Amanta. " Idam dukkhan ti " vacam bhasato na ca " idam dukkhan ti ' ' nanam pavattatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. " Kiipam anatta ti " vacam bhasato na ca " rupam anatta ti " nanam pavattatiti? Amanta. "Idam dukkhan ti " vacam bhasato na ca "idam dukkhan ti ' ' nanam pavattatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — " Vedana — pe — safiiia — pe — samkhara — pe — vihhanam anatta ti " vacam bhasato na ca "vihhanam anatta ti " nanam pavattatiti ? Amanta. "Idam dukkhan ti " vacam bhasato na ca "idam dukkhan ti " nanam pavattatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. " Idam dukkhan ti " vacam bhasato " idam dukkhan ti " nanam pavattatiti ? Amanta. Iti I ca danti ca ruci ^ ca khanti 3 ca nanam pavattatiti '? Amanta. Idam dukkhan ti katha. I iti, P.S.S2. ' == duti, M. ; duti, K. 3 cakkhan ti, M. 456 KATHAVATTHU. [XI. 5. XI. 5. 1. Iddhibalena saniannagato kappam tittheyyati '? Amanta. Iddhimayiko so ayu, iddhimayika sa gati, iddliiniayiko so attabhavapatilabho ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Iddhibalena samannagato kappam tittheyyati ? Amanta. Atltam kappam tittheyya, anagatam kappam titthey- yati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Iddhibalena samannagato kappam tittheyyati ? Amanta. Dve kappe tittheyya, tayo kappe tittheyya, cattaro kappe tittheyyati '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — '2. Iddhibalena samannagato kappam tittheyyati ? Amanta. Sati jivite jivitavasese tittheyya, asati jivite jivitavasese tittheyyati ? Sati jivite jivitavasese tittheyyati. Hahci sati jivite jivitavasese tittheyya, no vata re vattabbe " Iddhibalena samannagato kappam tittheyya- ti." Asati jivite jivitavasese tittheyyati. Mato tittheyya, kalamkato tittheyyati ? Na h'evam vattabbe^ — pe— 3. Iddhibalena samannagato kappam tittheyyati '? Amanta. Uppanno phasso ma nirujjhiti labbha iddhiya pagga- hetmi ^ ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Uppanna vedana — pe — uppanna sahha — pe — uppanna cetana — pe — uppannain cittam — pe — uppanna saddha — pe — uppannam viriyam — pe — uppanna sati — pe — uppanno ^ vagga°, P. XI. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 457 samadhi — pe — uppanna paniia ma nirujjhlti labbhii iddhiya paggahetnn ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Iddhibalena samannagato kappam tittheyyati ''* Amanta. Rupam niccam hotuti labbha iddhiya paggahetun ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vedana — pe — sahha — ^ pe — samkhara — pe — vifiiianam niccam hotuti labbha iddhiya paggahetun ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Iddhibalena samannagato kappam tittheyyati "? Amanta. Jatidhamima satta ma jayimsriti ^ labbha iddhiya pagga- hetun ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Jaradhannna satta ma jirimsu ^ — pe — byadhidhamma satta ma byadhiyinisu 3 — pe — maranadhamma satta ma miyimsu 4 labbha iddhiya paggahetun ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Na vattabbam "Iddhibalena samannagato kappain tittheyyati " '? Amanta. Nanu vuttain Bhagavata — " Yassa kassaci Ananda cattaro iddhij)ada bhavita bahullkata yanlkata vatthukata anutthita paricita susamaraddha, akankhamano so Ananda kappam va tittheyya kappavasesam va ti." Atth'eva sut- tanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi iddhibalena samannagato kappain tittheyyati. 7. Iddhibalena samannagato kappain tittheyyati ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Catunnam Bhikkhave dhammanani n'atthi koci patibhogo samano va brahmano va devo va Maro va Brahma va koci va lokasmim. Kata- mesam catunnam ? Jaradhammo ina jiviti n'atthi koci I jayisuti, P.S.S2. ^ jitisu, P.S.S2. ; jiyimsu, M. 3 byadhiylsu, P.S.S2. 4 miyisu, P.S. 458 KATHAVATTHU. [XI. 6. patibhogo samano va brahmano va devo va Maro va Brahma vji koci va lokasmim, byadhidhammo ma byadhi- ylti — pe — maranadhammo ma miyiti — pe — . Yaiii kho pana tani pubbe katani papakani kammani samkilesikani ponobhavikani nissarani ^ dukkhavipakani ayatiin jatija- ramaraniyani, tesam vipako ma nibbattiti n'atthi koci patibhogo samano va brahmano va devo va Maro va Brahma va koci va lokasmin ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Iddhibalena samanna^rato kappain tittheyyati." I d d h i b a 1 a k a t h a . XL G. 1. Cittasantati samadhiti ? Amanta. Atlta cittasantati samadhiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cittasantati samadhiti '? Amanta. Anagata cittasantati samadhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu atitain niruddham, anagatain ajatan ti? Amanta. Hanci atltam niruddham, anagatam ajatam, no vata re vattabbe " Cittasantati samadhiti." 2. Ekacittakkhaniko samadhiti ? Amanta. Cakkhuvinhanasamahgl samapanno ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sotavihhanasamahgl — pe — ghahavihnanasamahgl — pe — jivhavihiianasamahgi — pe — kayavihhanasamahgl — pe — ^ saranani, P.S.S2. ; nissarani, M. ; sadarani, Morris, Ang. IV. 182. diikkhudrayani, K. XI. 7.] KATHAVATTHU. 459 akusalacittasamangl — pe — ragasahao-atacittasamangi — pe — dosasahagatacittasamangl — pe — mohasahagatacitta- samangi — pe — anottappasahagatacittasamangi samapanno ti? Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Cittasantati samadhiti ? Amanta. Akusalacittasantati samadhiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ragasahagata — pe — dosasahagata — pe — mohasahagata — pe — anottappasahagata cittasantati samadhiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Na vattabbam " Cittasantati samadhiti " '? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Aham kho avuso Niganha'^ pahomi anihjamano^ kayena abhasamano vacam sattaratt- indivani ekantasukhapatisamvedi viharitmi ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi cittasantati samadhiti. S a m a d h i k a t h a . XI. 7. 1 . Dhammatthitata parinipphanna 3 ti ? Amanta. Taya thitata parinipphanna ti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Taya thitata parinipphanna ti '? Amanta. Taya tay'eva n'atthi dukkhass' antakiriya, n'atthi vatt- upacchedo, n'atthi anupadaparinibbanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — I Nirantho, K. ^ anicchamano. P. 3 parinibbana, P.S.S2. 460 KATHAVATTHU. [XI. 8. 2. Rupassa thitata parinipphanna ti ? Ainanta. Taya thitata parinipphanna ti ? Na h'evaiii vattabbe — pe — Taya thitata parinipphanna ti ? Anianta. Taya tay'eva n'atthi dukkhass'antakiriya, n'atthi vattii- pacchedo, n'atthi anupadaparinibbanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Vedanaya thitata — pe — sannaya thitata — pe — sam- kharanam thitata — pe — vihnanassa thitata parinipphanna ^ ti? * ' Amanta. Taya thitata parinipphanna ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Taya tay'eva n'atthi dukkhass' antakiriya n'atthi vattu- pacchedo n'atthi anupadaparinibbanan ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — D h a m ni a 1 1 h i t a t a k a t h a . XL 8. 1. Aniccata parinipphanna ti '? Anianta. Taya aniccataya aniccata parinipphanna ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Taya aniccataya aniccata parinipphanna ti ? Amanta. Taya tay'eva n'atthi dukkhass'antakiriya, n'atthi vattu- pacchedo, n'atthi anupadaparinibbanan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — '2. Jara parinipphanna ^ ti ? Amanta. Taya jaraya jara parinipphanna ti ? ^ parinibbanna, P. = parinipphanna, P.S.Sa- XI. 8.] KATHAVATTHU. 461 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — . Taya jaraya jara parinipphanna ti '? Amanta. Taya tay'eva n'attlii dukkhass'antakiriya, ii'atthi vattu- pacchedo, ii'atthi anupadaparinibbanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Maranam pariiiipphannan ti ? Amanta. Tassa maranassa maranam parinipphannan ti "^ Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tassa maranassa maranam parinipphannan ti ? Amanta. Tassa tass'evan'atthi dukkhass'antakiriya, ii'atthi vattii- pacchedo, n'atthi anupadaparinibbanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Kupam parinipphannaiu, rupassa aniccata atthiti ? Amanta. Aniccata parinipphanna, aniccataya aniccata atthiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Biipam parinipphannam, riipassajara atthiti? Amanta. Jara parinipphanna, jaraya jara atthiti'? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kiipam parinipphannam, rupassa bhedo atthi, antara- dhanam atthiti ? Amanta. Maranam parinipphannam, maranassa ])hedo atthi, anta- radhanam atthiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe— pe — 5 . Vedana — pe — sahfia — pe — samkhara — pe — vimianam parinipphannarn, vihnanassa aniccata atthiti ? Amanta. Aniccata parinipphanna, aniccataya aniccata atthiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Viiihanani parinipphaimain, vihnanassa jara atthiti? Amanta. Jara parinipphanna, jaraya jara atthiti? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 462 KATHAVATTHU. [XI. 8. Viniianam parinipphannam, vinnanassa bhedo atthi, antaradhanam atthiti ? Amanta. Maranam parinipphannam, maranassa bhedo atthi, antaradhanam atthiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — A n i c c a t a k a t h a . Anusaya abyakata, ahetuka, cittavippayntta, Ahhane vigate nam, Nanam cittavippaynttam, Yattha sadde hanani pavattati, Iddhibalena samannagato kappam tittheyya, Cittasantati samadhi, Dhammatthitata, Aniccata ti. E k a d a s a m o V a g g o . XII. l.J KATHAVATTHU. 463 XII. 1. 1. Samvaro kaininan ti '? Amanta. Cakkliundriyasamvaro cakkhukamman ti ? Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — Sotindriyasamvaro — pe — ghanindriyasamvaro — pe — jivhindriyasainvaro — pe — kayindriyasamvaro kayakamman ti •? ' Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — Kayindriyasamvaro kayakamman ti '? Amanta. Cakkhundriyasamvaro cakkhukamman ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — • Kayindriyasamvaro kayakamman ti ? Amanta. Sotindriyasamvaro — pe — ghanindriyasamvaro — pe — jivhindriyasainvaro jivhakamman ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Manindriyasamvaro manokamman ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Manindriyasainvaro manokamman ti '? Amanta. Cakkhundriyasamvaro cakkhukamman ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Manindriyasamvaro manokamman ti? Amanta. Sotindriyasamvaro — pe — ghanindriyasamvaro — pe — jivhindriyasainvaro — pe — kayindriyasainvaro kayakam- man ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Asamvaro kamman ti ? Amanta. Cakkhundriya-asaiiivaro cakkhukamman ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Sotindriya-asamvaro — pe — ghanindriya-asamvaro — pe — jivhindriy a- asamvaro — pe — kayindriya-asamvaro kayakam- man ti ? 464 KATHAVATTHU. [XII. 2. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kayindriya-asamvaro kayakamman ti ? Amanta. Cakkhundriya-asamvaro cakkliukamman ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kayindriya-asamvaro kayakamman ti ? Amanta. Sotindriya-asamvaro — pe — ghanindriya-asamvaro — pe — jivhindr3^a-asamvaro jivhakamman ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Manindriya-asamvaro manokamman ti'? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Manindriya-asamvaro manokamman ti ? Amanta. Cakkhundriya-asamvaro cakkhukamman ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Manindriya-asamvaro manokamman ti '? Amanta. Sotindriya-asamvaro — pe — ghanindriya-asamvaro — pe — jivhindriya-asamvaro — pe — kayindriya-asamvaro kaya- kamman ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Na vattabbam " Sarnvaro asamvaro pi kamman ti"? Amanta. Nanu vuttaip Bhagavata — " Idha Bhikkhave bhikkhu cakkhuna rupam disva nimittaggahi hoti — pe — na nimit- taggahihoti, sotenasaddam sutva — pe— manasa dhammam vihhaya nimittaggahi hoti — pe— na nimittaggahi hotlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi sarnvaro asamvaro pi kamman ti. S a m V a r o k a m man t i k a t h a . XII. 2. 1. Sabbam kanimam savipakan ti ? Amanta. XII. -2.] KATHAVATTHU. 465 Sabba cetana savipaka ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — -pe — Sabba cetana savipaka ti ? Amanta. Vipakabyakata cetana savipaka ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sabba cetana savipaka ti ? Amanta. Kiriyabyakata cetana savipaka ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sabba cetana savipaka ti '? Amanta. Kamavacara vipakabyakata cetana savipaka ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sabba cetana savipaka ti ? Amanta. Riipavacara, ampavacara, apariyapanna vipakabyakata cetana savipaka ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sabba cetana savipaka ti ? Amanta. Kamavacara kiriyabyakata cetana savipaka ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sabba cetana savipaka ti ? Amanta. Rupavacara, arupavacara kiriyabyakata cetana savipaka ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Vipakabyakata cetana avipaka ti ? Amanta. Haiici vipakabyakata cetana avipaka, no vata re vattabbe " Sabba cetana savipaka ti." Kiriyabyakata cetana avipaka ti ? Amanta. Hahci kiriyabyakata cetana avipaka, no vata re vattabbe " Sabba cetana savipaka ti." Kamavacara, rupavacara, arupavacara, apariyapanna vipakabyakata cetana avipaka ti ? 31 466 KATHAVATTHU. [XII. 3. Amanta. Hanoi apariyapanna vipakabyakata cetana avipaka, no vata re vattabbe " Sabba cetana savipaka ti." Kaniavacara, rupavacara, arupavacara kiriyabyakata cetana avipaka ti ? Amanta. Hanci arupavacara kiriyabyakata cetana avipaka, no vata re vattabbe " Sabba cetana savipaka ti." 8. Na vattabbani " Sabbam kammam savipakan ti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Naham Bhikkhave safi- cetanikanam kammanam katanam upacitanam appati- samveditva byantibhavam vadami tan ca kho ditth'eva ' dhamme nppajje ^ va apare va pariyaye ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi sabbam kammam savipakan ti. K a m m a k a t h a . XII. 3. 1. Saddo vipako ti '? Amanta. Sukhavedaniyo, dukkhavedanlyo, adnkkhamasukhave- danlyo, sukhaya vedanaya sampayntto, dukkhaya vedanaya sampayutto, adukkhamasukhaya vedanaya sampayntto, phassena sampayutto, vedanaya sampayutto, saiiiiaya sampayutto, cetanaya sampayutto, cittena sampayutto sarammano, atthi tassa avattana abhogo samannaharo manasikaro cetana patthana panidhiti ? Amanta. Nanu na sukhavedaniyo, na dukkhavedanlyo — pe — anarammano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti '? Amanta. I ditthe va, P.Sg.K. - uppajjam, P.S.S2. XII. 4.] KATHAVATTHU. 467 Hafici na sukhavedanlyo, na dukkhavedanlyo — pe — anarammano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhi, no vata re vattabbe " Saddo vipako ti." 2. Phasso vipako, phasso sukhavedanlyo — pe — saram- mano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhlti? Amanta. Saddo vipako, saddo sukhavedanlyo — pe — sarammano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Saddo vipako, saddo na sukhavedanlyo — pe — anaram- mano, n'atthi tassa avattana — -pe — panidhlti ? Amanta. Phasso vipako, phasso na sukhavedanlyo — pe — anaram- mano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhlti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3 Na vattabbam " Saddo vipako ti" '? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " So tassa kammassa katatta upacitatta ussannata ^ vipulatta brahmassaro ^ hoti kara- vlkabhanl ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi saddo vipako ti. Saddo vipako ti katha XII. 4. 1. Cakkhayatanam vipako ti ? Amanta. Sukhavedanlyam, dukkhavedaniyam — pe — saramma- nam, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhlti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu na sukhavedanlyain — pe — anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana— pe — panidhlti ? Amanta. I ussanata, P.S2. ^ brahmasaro, M.K. 468 KATHAVATTHU. [XII. 4. Hanoi na sukhavedamyam — pe — anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhi, no vata re vattabbe " Cak- khayatanam vipako ti." 2. Phasso vipako, phasso sukhavedaniyo — pe — sarani- mano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Cakkbayatanam vipako, cakkhayatanam sukhavedam- yam — pe — sarammanam, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkhayatanam vipako, cakkhayatanam na sukhave- damyam — pe — anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana— pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Phasso vipako, phasso na sukhavedaniyo — pe — anaram- mano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Sotayatanam — pe — ghanayatanam — pe — jivhaya- tanam — pe — kayayatanam vipako ti ? Amanta. Sukhavedamyam, dukkhavedanlyam — pe — saram- manam, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu na sukhavedamyam— pe — anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Haiici na sukhavedamyam — pe — anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhi, no vata re vattabbe " Kaya- yatanam vipako ti." Phasso vipako, phasso sukhavedaniyo — pe — saram- mano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Kayayatanain vipako, kayayatanam sukhavedaniyam — pe — sarammanam, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kayayatanam vipako, kayayatanam na sukhavedanlyani — pe — anarammanani, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? XII. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 469 Amanta. Phasso vipako, phasso na sukhavedanlyo — pe — anaram- mano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe- — panidliiti ? Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Na vattabbam " Salayatanam vipako ti " ? Amanta. Nanu salayatanain kanimassa katatta uppannan ti ? Amanta. Hanoi salayatanam kammassa katatta nppannam, tena vata re vattabbe " Salayatanam vipako ti." S a 1 a y a t a n a k a t h a. XII. 5. 1. Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamata niyato ti '? Amanta. Mata jivita voropita, pita jivita voropito, Araha iivita voropito, dutthena cittena Tathagatassa lohitam uppa- ditam, Samgho bhinno ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkliattu\)aramata niyato ti ? Amanta. Abhabbo antara dhammam abhisametnn ti ? i Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Abhabbo antara dhammam abhisametun ti ? Amanta. Mata jivita voropita, pita jivita voropito, Araha jivita voropito, dutthena cittena Tathagatassa lohitani uppa- ditam, Samgho bhinno ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamata niyato ti '? Amanta. Atthi so niyamo, yena niyamena sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamata niyato ti ? Na h'evarn vattabbe — pe — 470 KATHAVATTHU. [XII. 5. Atthi te satipatthana, sammappadhana, iddhipada, indriya, bala, bojjhanga, yehi bojjhangehi sattakkhattu- paramo pnggalo sattakkhattuparamata niyato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. N'atthi so niyamo, yena niyamena sattakkhattu- paramo puggalo sattakkhattuparamata niyato ti? Amanta. Hanci n'atthi so niyamo, yena niyamena sattakkhattu- paramo puggalo sattakkhattuparamata niyato, no vata re vattabbe " Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkliattu- paramata niyato ti." N'atthi te satipatthana — pe — bojjhanga, yehi bojjhan- gehi sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamata niyato ti ? Amanta. Hanoi n'atthi te bojjhanga, yehi bojjhangehi sattak- khattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamata niyato, no vata re vattabbe " Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattak- khattuparamata niyato ti." 5. Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamata niyato ti ? Amanta. Sakadagaminiyamenati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagaminiyamenati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahattaniyamenati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Katamena niyamenati ? Sotapattiniyamenati. Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamata niyato ti ? Amanta. Ye keci sotapattiniyamam okkamanti, sabbe te sattak- khattuparamata niyata ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Na vattabbam " Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattak- khattuparamata niyato ti"? XII. 7. J KATHAVATTHU. 471 Am ant a. Nanu so sattakkhattuparamo ti ? Amanta. Haiici so sattakkhattuparamo, ten a vata re vattabbe " Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamata niyato ti." S a 1 1 a k k h a 1 1 u p a r a m a k a t h a . XII. 6. 1. Na vattabbam " Kolamkolo i puggalo kolamkolata niyato ti " ? Amanta. Nanu so kolamkolo ti V Amanta. Haiici so kolamkolo, tena vata re vattabbe " Kolamkolo puggalo kolamkolata niyato ti." 2. Na vattabbam " Ekabljl puggalo ekabljita niyato ti " ? Amanta. Nanu so ekabljl ti ? Amanta, Haiici so ekabljl, tena vata re vattabbe " EkabijI puggalo ekabljita niyato ti." XII. 7. 1. Ditthisampamio puggalo saiicicca paiiani jivita voropeyyati ? Amanta. Ditthisampamio puggalo sahcicca mataram jivita voro- peyya — pe — -pitaram jivita voropeyya, Arahantam jivita voropeyya — pe — dutthcna cittena Tathagatassa lohitam uppadeyya — pe — Samgham bliindeyyati '? I kolo, P.S^. 472 KATHAVATTHU. [XII. 7. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe- — • 2. Ditthisainpanno piiggalo saficicca panain jlvita voro- peyyati ? Amanta. Ditthisainpanno puggalo Satthari agaravo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dhamme — pe — Sainghe — pe — Sikkhaya agaravo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Nann ditthisampanno puggalo Satthari sagaravo ti ? Amanta. Hahci ditthisampanno puggalo Satthari sagaravo, no vatare vattabbe "Ditthisampanno puggalo saficicca panam jlvita voropeyyati." Nanu ditthisampanno puggalo Dhamme — pe — Samghe — pe — Sikkhaya sagaravo ti '? Aixianta. Hahci ditthisampanno puggalo Sikkhaya sagaravo, no vata re vattabbe " Ditthisampanno puggalo sahcicca. panam jlvita voropeyyati." . Ditthisampanno puggalo Satthari agaravo ti ? Amanta. J^, Ditthisampanno puggalo Buddhathupe ohaneyya, ^ omutteyya, nitthubheyya,- Buddhathupe apabyamato 3 ^ A fT "^ ^ kareyyati ? ~^ """ TTaTli'evam vattabbe — te — 5. Ditthisampanno puggalo sahcicca panam jlvita voro- peyyati ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Seyyathapi Bhikkhave r / mahasamuddo thitadhammo velam nativattati, evameva \^~:^ kho Bhikkhave yain maya savakanam sikkhapadam 'v f'^ . If^Spahhattam, tarn mama savaka jivitahetu pi natikkam- mantiti." Atth'eva suttanto ti"? ^ ohareyya, P.S.Sa- 2 nitthuseyya, P.Ss- ; nitthupeyya, M. ; nitthukeyya, K. 3 asabyakato, M. ; abyato, P.S. ; apabyato, S-. XII. 8.] KATHAVATTHU. 473 Anianta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Ditthisampanno pug^alo sancicca panam jivita voropeyyati." Jivita voropanakatha. XII. 8. 1. Ditthisampannassa puggalassa pahina duggatiti? Amanta. Ditthisampanno puggalo apayike rupe rajjeyyati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Hahci ditthisampanno puggalo apayike rupe rajjeyya, no vata re vattabbe " Ditthisampannassa puggalassa pahina duggatiti." 2. Ditthisampannassa puggalassa pahina duggatiti ? Amanta. Ditthisampanno puggalo apayike sadde — pe — gandhe — • pe — rase — pe — photthabbe — pe — amanussitthiya,tiraccha- nagatitthiya, nagakahhaya methunam dhammaiu patise- veyya, ajelakam patigganheyya, kukkulasukaram patig- ganheyya, hatthigavassavalavam patigganheyya — pe — tittiravattakamorakapihjalam ^ patigganheyyati '? Amanta. Hahci ditthisampanno puggalo tittiravattakamorakapni- jalam patigganheyya, no vata re vattabbe "Ditthisampan- nassa puggalassa pahina duggatiti." 8. Ditthisampannassa puggalassa pahina duggati, ditthi- sampanno puggalo apayike rupe rajjeyyati '? Amanta. Arahato pahina duggati, Araha apayike rupe rajjeyyati? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ditthisampannassa puggalassa pahina duggati, ditthi- sampanno puggalo apayike sadde — pe — gandhe — pe — rase — pe — photthabbe — pe — tittiravattakamorakapihjalam patigganheyyati ? ' °pihjaraiu, M. 474 KATHAVATTHU. [XII. 8. Amanta. Arahato pahlna duggati, Araha tittiravattakamorakapiii- jalam patigganheyyati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Arahato pahlna duggati, na ca Araha apayike rupe raj[eyyati '? Amanta. Ditthisampannassa puggalassa pahlna duggati, na ca ditthisampanno puggalo apayike rupe rajjeyyati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahato pahlna duggati, na ca Araha apayike sadde — pe — gandhe — pe — rase — pe — photthabbe — pe — amanus- sitthiya, tiracchanagatitthiya, nagakahhaya methunam dhammam patiseveyj^a, ajelakam patigganheyya, kukkula- sukaram patigganheyya, hatthigavassavalavam patiggan- heyya — pe — tittiravattakamorakapihjalam patigganhey- yati ? Amanta. Ditthisampannassa puggalassa pahlna duggati, na ca ditthisampanno puggalo tittiravattakamorakapihjalam patigganheyyati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Navattabbam " Ditthisampannassa puggalassa jDahlna duggatiti " ? Amanta. Ditthisampanno puggalo nirayam upapajjeyya^ — pe — tiracchanayonim upapajjeyya — pe — pittivisayani upapaj- jeyyati '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi ditthisampannassa puggalassa pahina duggatiti. Duggati k at ha. uppajjeyya, P.S.S, XII. 9.] KATHAVATTHU. 475 XII. 9. 1. Na vattabbam " Sattamabhavikassa ^ puggalassa pahlna diiggatiti " ? Amanta. Sattamabhaviko ^ pnggalo nirayam upapajjeyya, tirac- chanayonim upapajjeyya, pittivisayam upapajjeyyati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi sattamabhavikassa puggalassa pablna duggatlti. S a 1 1 a m a b h a V i k a k a t h a . Samvaro kammam tath'eva asamvaro, Sabbam kammam savipakam, Saddo vipako, Salayata- nam Anpako, Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamata ni- yato, Kolamkolo puggalo kolamkolata niyato, Ekabljl puggalo ekabljita niyato, Ditthisampanno puggalo sancicca panam jivita voropeyya, Ditthisampannassa puggalassa pahlna duggati, Tath'eva sattamabhavikassati. Dvadasamo Vaggo. Sattamakassa, P.S.S2. ^ °bhaviko, P.S.S5 476 - KATHAVATTHU. [XIII. 1. XIII. 1. 1. Kappattho kappam tittheyyati ? Am ant a. Kappo ca santhati ^ Buddho ca loke uppajjatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kappattho kappam tittheyyati ? Amanta. Kappo ca santhati Sanigho ca bhijjatiti "? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Kappattho kappam tittheyyati '? Amanta. Kappo ca santhati kappattho ca kappatthiyam kammam karotiti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Kappattho kappam tittheyyati ? Amanta. Kappo ca santhati kappattho ca puggalo kalam karotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — ^^ Kappattho kappam tittheyyati ? Amanta. Atltam kappain tittheyya,anagatamkappain tittheyyati? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kappattho kappani tittheyyati ? Amanta. Dve kappe tittheyya, tayo kappe tittheyya, cattaro kappe tittheyyati ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Kappattho kappam tittheyyati ? Amanta. Kappattho kappe dayhante ^ kattha 3 gacchatiti ? Aiiham lokadhatmn gacchatiti. Mato gacchati, vehasam-i gacchatiti ? Mato gacchatiti. 5 Kappatthiyain kammam aparapariyavepakkan ^ ti r 9 I satthati, P. ; sanhati, S. ^ vayante, P. 3 tattha, P. 4 velasam, S. 5 P. omits. '^ aparayadipe pakkantiti, P.S. XIII. 2.] KATHAVATTHU. 477 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vehasam gacchatiti ? Amanta. Kappattho iddhima ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kappattho iddhima ti ? Amanta. Kappatthena chandiddhipado bhavito viriyiddhipado bhavito cittiddhipado bhavito vimamsiddhipado bhavito tr? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Na vattabbam " Kappattho kappam tittheyyati " ? Amanta. Nanu ^ vuttam Bhagavata — " Apayiko nerayiko kappattho samghabhedako Vaggarato adhammattho yogakkhemato dhamsati Samgham samaggam bhetvana kappam nirayamhi paccatiti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi kappattho kappam tittheyyati. Kappatthakatha. XIII. ± 1. Kappattho kusalam cittam na patilabheyyati V Amanta. Kappattho danam dadeyyati ? Amanta. Hanoi kappattho danam dadeyya, no vata re vattabbe " Kappattho kusalam cittam na patilabheyyilti." Kappattho kusalam cittam na patilabheyyati ? Amanta. Kappattho clvaram dadeyya, pindapatam dadeyya, senasanam dadeyya, gilanapaccayabhesajjaparikkharain ^ P. and S. omit from here to end. 478 KATHAVATTHU. [XIII. 3. dadeyya, khadanlyani dadeyya, bliojanlyam dadeyya, panlyaiii dadeyya, cetiyam vandeyya/ cetiye malam aropeyya, gandham aropeyya, vilepanam aropeyya, cetiyam padakkhinam ^ kareyyati '? Amanta. Hailci kappattho cetiyam padakkhinain kareyya, no vata re vattabbe "Kappattho kusalam cittam na patila- bheyyati." 2. Kappattho kusalam cittam patilabheyyati ? Amanta. Tato vutthanams kusalam cittam patilabheyyati? Amanta. Rupavacaram — pe — ariipavacaram — pe — lokuttaram kusalam cittam patilabheyyati '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — K u s a 1 a p a t i 1 a b h a k a t h a . XIII. 3. 1. Anantarapayutto puggalo sammattaniyaman,i okka- meyyati "? Amanta. Micchattaniyamah ca sammattaniyamah ca ubho okka- meyyati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anantarapayutto puggalo sammattaniyamam okkamey- yati ? Amanta. Nanu tarn kammam payuttam kukkuccam uppaditam 4 vippatisariyam janitan ti '? Amanta. Hahci tarn kammain payuttam kukkuccani uppaditam vippatisariyam janitam, no vata re vattabbe "Anantarapa- yutto puggalo sammattaniyamam okkameyyati." I vamdadeyya, P. = abhidakkh", M. ; dakkho, S. 3ratthanam, P.S.S2. + upparahitam, P.S. ; upadahitam, K. XIII. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 479 2. Anantarapayuttopuggalo abhabbosammattaniyaniam okkamitun ti ? Amanta. Mata jivita voropita, pita jivita voropito, Araha jivita voropito, diitthenacittena Tathagatassa lohitam uppaditam, Samgho bhinno ti ? Na h'evaiu vattabbe — pe — Anantarapayutto puggalo tarn kanimam patisamharitva ^ kukkuccam pativinodetva vippatisariyain pativinodetva ^ abhabbo sammattaniyaniam okkamitun ti ? Amanta- Mata jivita voropita, pita jTvita voropito, Araha jivita voropito, dutthena cittena Tathagatassa lohitam uppadi- tam, Samgho bhinno ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anantarapayutto puggalo tarn kammam patisamharitva kukkuccam jDativinodetva vippatisariyain pativinodetva abhabbo sammattaniyamam okkamitun ti ? Amanta. Nanu tani kammaiu patisamhatam kukkuccam pativi- noditam vippatisariyain pativinltan ti ? Amanta. Hahci tain kammain patisamhatam kukkuccam pativi- noditam vippatisariyain pativinTtam,3 no vata re vattabbe " Anantarapayutto puggalo tarn kammain patisamharitva kukkuccam pativinodetva vippatisariyain pativinodetva abhabbo sammattaniyamam okkamitun ti." 8. Anantarapayutto puggalo sammattaniyamam okka- meyyati ? Amanta. Nanu tarn kammam payutto atthiti ? Amanta. Haiici tain kammain payutto atthi, no vata re vattabbe "Anantarapayutto puggalo sammattaniyamam okkameyya- ti." Anantarapayuttakatha. ^ patiharitva, P.S.S2. - vinetva, P.S.S2. ^ pativinoditain, P.S.S2. 480 KATHAVATTHU. [XIII. 5. XIII. 4. 1 . Niyato niyamam okkamatlti '? Amanta. Micchattaniyato sammattaniyamam okkamati, sammat- taniyato niicchattaniyamam okkamatlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Niyato niyamam okkamatlti ? Amanta. Pubbe maggam bhavetva paccha niyamam okkamatlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Pubbe sotapattimaggam bhavetva paccha sotapattiniya- mam okkamatlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Pubbe sakadagamimaggam — pe — anagamimaggain — arahattamaggain l)havetva paccha arahattaniyamam okka- matlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Pubbe satipatthanam — pe — sammappadhanam — pe — iddhipadain — pe — indriyain — pe — balam — pe — boj j hah- gam bhavetva paccha niyamam okkamatlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — - 2. Na vattabbain " Niyato niyamam okkamatlti ? " Amanta. Bhabbo Bodhisatto taya jatiyadhammam nabhisametun ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi niyato niyamam okkamatlti. Niyatassa nij-amakatha. XIII. 5. 1. Nivuto nivaranain jahatiti ? Amanta. Ratto ragain jahati, duttho dosani jahati, miilho' moham jahati, kihttho kilese^ jahatiti? I mulo, M. 2 ogam^ p. XIII. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 481 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Eagena ragam jahati, doseiia dosam jahati, mohena moham jahati, kilesehi kilese jahatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Eago cittasampayutto maggo cittasampayutto ti ? Amanta. Dvinnam phassanam — pe — dvinnam cittanam samodha- nam hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe^pe — Eago akusalo maggo kusalo ti ? Amanta. Kusalakusala savajjanavajja hmappanlta kanhasukka- sappatibhaga dhamma sammukhibhavam agacchantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kusalakusala savajjanavajja hmappanlta kanhasukka- sappatibhaga dhamma sammukhibhavam agacchantiti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Cattar'imani Bhikkhave suviduravidurani. Katamani cattari ? Nabhah ca Bhik- khave pathavl ca idam pathamam suviduraviduram — pe — tasma satain dhammo asabbhi araka ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Kusalakusala — pe — sammukhi- bhavam agacchantiti." 2. Nivuto nivaranam jahatiti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " So evam samahite citte parisuddhe pariyodate anaiigane vigatupakkilese mudu- bhute kammaniye thite anehjapatte ^ asavanam khayaha- naya cittam abhininnametlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Nivuto nivaranam jahatiti." 3. Na vattabbam " Nivuto nivaranam jahatiti " '? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Tassa evam janato evam ^ anahja°, P.S. ; auehcao, M. 32 482 KATHAVATTHU. [XIII. 6. passato kamasava pi cittam vimuccati — pe — avijjasava pi cittam vimuccatlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi nivuto nlvaranam jahatiti. N i V u t a k a t h a . XIII. (5. 1. Sammukhlbhuto saMojanam jahatiti? Amanta. Ratto ragam jahati, duttho dosam jahati, miilho moham jahati, kilittho kilese jahatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ragena ragam jahati, dosena dosam jahati, mohena moham jahati, kilesehi kilese jahatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Eago cittasampayutto maggo cittasampayutto ti ? Amanta. Dvinnam phassanam — pe — dvinnam cittanam samodha- nam hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Rago akusalo maggo kusalo ti ? Amanta. Kusalakusala savajjanavajja hinappanita kanhasukka- sappatibhaga dhainma sammukhibhavam agacchantiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Kiisalakusala savajjanavajja hinappanita kanhasukka- sappatibhaga dhamma sammukhibhavain agacchantiti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Cattar'imani Bhikkhave suvidiiravidiirani. Katamani cattari? Nabhah ca Bhik- khave pathavi ca idam pathamain suviduravidiiram — pe — tasma satam dhammo asabbhi araka ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Kusalakusala — pe — sammu- khibhavam agacchantiti." XIII. 7.] KATHAVATTHU. 483 '2. Sammukhlbliuto sannojanam jaliatiti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " So evam samahite citte parisuddhe pariyodate anangane vigatupakkilese niudu- bhute kammaniye thite anenjapatte asavanain khayana- naya cittain abhininnametiti." Atth'eva snttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Sammukhlbhuto sannojanam jahatlti." 3. Na vattabbam " Sammukhlbhuto sannojanam jaha- tlti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttain Bhagavata — " Tassa evam janato evam passato kamasava pi cittam vimnccati — pe — avijjasava pi cittam vimuccatlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi sammukhlbhuto sannojanam jahatlti. S a 111 111 u k h i b h u t a k a t h a . XIII. 7. 1. Samapanno, assadeti jhananikanti jhanarammana ti ? Amanta. Tarn jhanam tassa jhanassa arammanan ^ ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tarn jhanam tassa jhanassa arammanan ti? Amanta. Tena phassena tain phassam phusati, taya vedanaya tarn vedanam vedeti,^ taya sahhaya tain sahhaiii janati, taya cetanaya tarn cetanain ceteti, tena cittena tarn cittam cinteti, tena vitakkena tarn vitakkam vitakketi, tena vicarena tarn vicaram vicareti, taya pitiya taiii pitim piya- yati, taya satiya tain satim sarati, taya pahhaya tain pahham pajanatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — I anaraiii°, S. ^ vediyati, P., vedayati, S. 484 KATHAVATTHU. [XIII. 7. 2. Jhananikanti cittasampayutta jhanam cittasampa- yuttan ti ? Amanta. Dvinnam phassanain — pe — dvinnam cittanam samo- dhanain hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Jhananikanti akusala jhanam kiisalan ti ? Amanta. Kusalakusala savajjanavajja hlnappanlta kanhasnkka- sappatibhaga dhamma sammukhlbhavam agacchantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kusalakusala savajjanavajja hlnappanlta kanhasukka- sappatibhaga dhamma sammukhlbhavain agacchantiti? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Cattar'imani Bhikkhave suviduravidurani. Katamani cattari ? Nabhaii ca Bhik- khave pathavl ca idam pathamam suviduraviduram — pe — tasma satam dhammo asabbhi araka ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbaiu " Kusalakusala — pe — sammukhi- bhanam agacchantiti." 8. Na vattabbam " Samapanno assadeti, jhananikanti jhanarammana ti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Idha Bhikkhave bhikkhu vivicc'eva kamehi vivicc' akusalehi dhammehi pathamam jhanaiu upasampajja viharati, so tarn assadeti tain nika- meti tena ca vittiin ^ apajjati, vitakkavicaranaiii vupasama — pe — dutiyain jhanain — pe — tatiyain jhanain — pe — catut- tham jhanam upasampajja viharati, so tarn assadeti tarn nikameti tena ca vittini apajjatiti " ? Amanta. Tena hi samapanno assadeti, jhananikanti jhanaram- mana ti. Samapanno a s s a d e t i k a t h a . I vitti, M. XIII. 8. J KATHAVATTHU. 485 XIII. 8. 1. Atthi asatarago ^ ti ? Amanta. Dukkhabhinandino satta atthi keci diikkham pattlienti ^ pihenti 3 esanti gavesanti pariyesanti dukkham ajjhosaya titthantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu sukhabhinandino satta atthi keci sukham patthenti pihenti esanti gavesanti pariyesanti sukham ajjhosaya titthantiti '? Amanta. Hahci sukhabhinandino — pe — titthanti, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi asatarago ti." 2. Atthi asatarago ti ? Amanta. Dukkhaya vedanaya raganusayo anuseti, sukhaya ve- danaya patighanusayo anusetiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu sukhaya vedanaya raganusayo anuseti, dukkhaya vedanaya patighanusayo anusetiti ? Amanta. Haiici sukhaya vedanaya raganusayo anuseti, dukkhaya vedanaya patighanusayo anuseti, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi asatarago ti." 3. Na vattabbain " Atthi asatarago ti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttain Bhagavata " So evam anurodhavirodham samapanno yam kifici vedanam vediyati,-+ sukhani va dukkham va adukkhamasukham va, so tam vedanam abhi- nandati abhivadatis ajjhosaya titthatiti." Atth'eva sutta- nto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi atthi asatarago ti." Asataragakatha. * asso, M. 2 dukkhappattenti, P. 3 pihanti, M. ; pihonti, S.; vihenti, P. 4 vedayati, M. 5 omits. P. 486 KATHAVATTHU. [XIII. 9. XIII. 9. 1. Dliiimmatanha abyakata ti? Anianta. Vipakabyakata kiriyabyakata rupam nibbanam cakkha- yatanam — pe — photthabbayatanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dhaminatanha abyakata ti '? Aiiianta. Eupatanha abyakata ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dhaminatanha abyakata ti ? Amanta. Saddatanha — pe — gandhatanha — pe — rasatanha — pe — - photthabbatanha abyakata ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Rupatanha akusala ti '? Amanta. Dhammatanha akusala ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Saddatanha — pe — photthabbatanha akusala ti '? Amanta. Dhammatanha akusala ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Dhammatanha abyakata ti ? Amanta. Nanu tanha akusala vutta Bhagavata ti ? Amanta. Haiici tanha akusala vutta Bhagavata, no vata re vattabbe " Dhammatanha abyakata ti." Dhammatanha abyakata ti ? Amanta. Nanu loljho akusalo vutto Bhagavata, dhammatanha lobho ti ? Amanta. Hahci lobho akusalo vutto Bhagavata, dhammatanha lobho, no vata re vattabbe " Dhammatanha abyakata ti." 3. Dlianimatanha lobho al)yakato ti ? XIII. 9. J KATHAVATTHU. 487 Amanta. Bupatanha lobho abyakato ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dhammatanha loblio abyakato ti '? Amanta. Saddatanha — pe^gandhatanha — pe — rasatanha — pe — photthabbatanha lobho abyakato ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Eiipatanha lobho akusalo ti ? Amanta. Dhammatanha lobho akusalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Saddatanha — pe — photthabbatanha lobho akusalo ti ? Amanta. Dhammatanha lobho akusalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Dhammatanha abyakata ti '? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata "Yayam tanha ponobhavika "^ nandiragasahagata tatratatrabhinandini, seyyathldam ka- matanha bhavatanha vibhavatanha ti " Atth'eva suttanto ti? ' Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Dhammatanha abyakata ti." 5. Na vattabbam " Dhammatanha abyakata ti " ? Amanta. Nanu sa dhammatanha ti ? • ; Amanta. Hahci sa dhammatanha, tena vata re vattabbe " Dham- matanha abyakata ti." D h a 111 m a t a n h a abyakata t i k a t h a . I ponobbh" M. 488 KATHAVATTHU. [XIII. 10. XIII. 10. 1. Dhammatanha na dukkhasamudayo ti ? Ainanta. Rupatanha na dukkhasamudayo ti '? Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — Dhammatanha na dukkhasamudayo ti ? Ainanta. Saddatanha — pe — photthabbatanha na dukkhasamu- dayo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kupatanha dukkhasamudayo ti '? Amanta. Dhammatanha dukkhasamudayo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Saddatanha — pe — photthabbatanha dukkhasamudayo ti?_ ' Amanta. Dhammatanha dukkhasamudayo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Dhammatanha na dukkhasamudayo ti ? Amanta. Nanu tanha dukkkasamudayo vutto Bhagavata ti ? Amanta. Hanoi tanha dukkhasamudayo vutto Bhagavata, no vata re vattabbe " Dhammatanha na dukkhasamudayo ti." Dhammatanha na dukkhasamudayo ti ? Amanta. Nanu lobho dukkhasamudayo vutto Bhagavata, dham- matanha lobho ti ? Amanta. Haiici lobho dukkhasamudayo vutto Bhagavata, dham- matanha lobho, no vata re vattabbe " Dhammatanha na dukkhasamudayo ti." 3. Dhammatanha lobho na dukkhasamudayo ti? Amanta. Kupatanha lobho na dukkhasamudayo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — XIII. 10."] I£ATHAVATTHU. 489 Dliammatanha lobho na diikkhasamudayo ti '? Amanta. Saddatanha — pe — photthabbataiiha lobho na dukkhasa- mudayo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Rupatanha lobho dukkhasamudayo ti ? Amanta. Dhaminatanha lobho dukkhasamudayo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Saddatanha — pe — photthabbataiiha lobho dukkhasamu- dayo ti '? Amanta. Dhammatanha lobho dukkhasamudayo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Dhammatanha na dukkhasamudayo ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata " Yayam tanha ponobhavika ^ nandiragasahagata tatratatrabhinandini, seyyathldam kamatanha bhavatanha vibhavatanha ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti '? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam "Dhammatanha na dukkhasa- mudayo ti '? 5. Na vattabbani " Dhammatanha na dukkhasamudayo ti?" Amanta. Nanu sa dhammatanha ti ? Amanta. Hailci sa dhammatanha, tena vata re vattabbe " Dham- matanha na dukkhasamudayo ti." Dhammatanha na dukkhasamudayo ti ka tha. ponobbh°, M. 490 KATHAVATTHU. [XIII. 10. Kappattho kappam tittheyya, Kappattho kusalaiii cittam na patilablieyya, Anantarapayutto puggalo sammattaniyamam okkameyya, Niyato niyamam okkameyya, Niviito mvaranam jaliati, Sammukhibhuto sannojanam jahati, Jhananikanti, Asatarago Dhammatanha abyakata, Dhammatanha na dukkhasa- mudayo ti. Terasaiuo Vaggo, XIV. 1.] KATHAVATTHU. 491 XIV. 1. 1. Akusalamtilam patisandahati knsalamulan ti? Anianta. Ya akusalassa uppadaya avat tana — pe — panidhi, sa va kusalassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — Akusalaniulam patisandahati kusalamulam, na vattab- bam " Ya akusalassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhi, sa va kusalassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhiti " ? Anianta. Kusalam anavattantassa uppajjati — pe — apanidahan- tassa uppajjatlti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kusalam avattantassa uppajjati — pe — panidahantassa uppajjatlti ? Amanta. Hanoi kusalam avattantassa uppajjati — pe — panida- hantassa uppajjati, no vata re vattabbe " Akusalamiilani patisandahati kusalamulan ti." 2. Akusalaniulam patisandahati kusalamulan ti ? Amanta. Akusalam ^ ayoniso manasikaroto uppajjatlti ? Amanta. Kusalam ayoniso manasikaroto uppajjatlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nairn kusalam yoniso manasikaroto uppajjatlti ? Amanta. Hanoi kusalam yoniso manasikaroto uppajjati, no vata re vattabbe " Akaaalamalani patisandahati kusa- lamulan ti." 8. Akusalaniulam patisandahati kusalamulan ti ? Anianta. Kamasahhaya anantara nekkhammasahna uppajjati, byapadasanhaya anantara abyapadasafiha uppajjati, vihimsasahhaya anantara avihimsasaiiha uppajjati, bya- ^ kusalamulan!, P. and S. ; akusalaniulam, M. 492 KATHAVATTHU. [XIV. 1. padassa anantara inetta uppajjati, vihimsaya anantara karuna uppajjati, aratiya anantara niudita uppajjati, patighassa ^ anantara upekkha uppajjatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— 4. Kusalamulam patisandahati akusalaiuulan ti ? Amanta. Ya kusalassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhi, sa va akusalassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kusalamulam patisandahati akusalamrllarn, na vattab- bam " Ya kusalassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhi, sa va akusalassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhiti " '? Amanta. Akusalain anavattantassa uppajjati — pe — apanidahan- tassa uppajjatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Akusalam avattantassa uppajjati — pe — panidahantassa uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Hanoi akusalam avattantassa uppajjati — pe — panida- hantassa uppajjati, no vata re vattabbe " Kusalanmlam patisandahati akusalamulan ti." 5. Kusalamulam patisandahati akusalamiilan ti ? Amanta. Kusalani yoniso manasikaroto uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Akusalam yoniso manasikaroto uppajjatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu akusalam ayoniso manasikaroto uppajjatiti '? Amanta. Hahci akusalam ayoniso manasikaroto uppajjati, no ca vata re vattabbe " Kusalamulam patisandahati akusa- lamulan ti." 6. Kusalamulam patisandahati akusalamulan ti ? Amanta. Nekkhammasahiiaya anantara kamasahha uppajjati, ^ oaya, M. XIV. 2.] KATHAVATTHU. 493 abyapadasaniiaya anantara byapadasaiina uppajjati, avihiinsasaniiaya anantara vihimsasaiina uppajjati, met- taya anantara byapado uppajjati, karunaya anantara vihimsa uppajjati, niuditaya anantara arati uppajjati, upekkhaya anantara patigham uppajjatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Na vattabbam " Akusalaimilam patisandahati kusala- niulam, kusalaniiilam patisandahati akusalainulan ti " "? Amanta. Nanu yasmin fieva vatthusmim rajjati tasmin iieva vatthusmim virajjati, yasmiii iieva vatthusmim virajjati tasinih heva vatthusmiin rajjatiti ? Amanta. Hanoi yasmin neva vatthusmim rajjati tasmiii neva vatthusmim virajjati, yasmin heva vatthusmim vn-ajjati tasmin heva vatthusmim rajjati, tena vata re vattabbe " Akusalamulam patisandahati kusalamulam, kusalamii- 1am patisandahati akusalamiilan ti." Kusalakusalapatisandahanakatha.^ XIV. 2. 1. Salayatanam apubbam acarimam matukucchismim santhatiti ? Amanta. Sabbahgapaccahgi ^ ahinindriyo 3 matukucchismim okkamatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Uppattesiyena cittena cakkhayatanain santhatiti ? Amanta. Uppattesiyena cittena hattha santhanti, pada santhanti, sisam santhati, kanno saiithati, nasika santhati, mukham santhati, danta santhantiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — I °sandhara,° P. and S. ; sandhana°, Atth°. °paccam, P. and S. 3 ahirino, P.S.Sa. 494 KATHAVATTHU. [XIV. 2. Upi^attesiyena cittena sotayatanam — pe — ghanayata- nam — pe — jivhayatanam santhatiti ? Amanta. Uppattesiyena cittena hattha santhanti, pada santhanti, sisam santthati, kanno santhati,. nasika santhati, mukham santhati, danta santhantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Matnkiicchigatassa paccha cakkhayatanam iippajja- tlti ? Amanta. Matukucchismim cakkhupatiklbhaya kanimam karotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Matukucchigatassa paccha sotayatanam — ^pe — ghana- yatanam — pe — jivhayatanam uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Matukucchismim jivhapatitabhaya kammam karotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Matukucchigatassa paccha kesa loma nakha danta atthi Tippajjantlti ? Amanta. Matukucchismim atthipatilabhaya kammam karotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Na vattabbam " Matukucchigatassa paccha kesa loma nakha danta atthi uppajjantiti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Pathamam kalalain hoti, kalala hoti abbudam, Abbuda ^ jayate pesi, pes! nibbattati ghano, Ghana pasakha jayanti kesa loma nakha pi ca, Yaii c'assa bhuhjati mata annam panah ca bhojanam Tena so tattha yapeti matukucchigato naro ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi matukucchigatassa paccha kesa loma nakha danta atthi uppajjantiti. S a 1 a y a t a n u p p a 1 1 i k a t h a . I ambuda, P.K. XIV. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 495 XIV. 3. 1. Cakkhuvififianassa anantara sotavifinanam uppajja- tlti_? Amanta. Ya cakkliuviniianassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhi, sa va sotavififianassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkhuvifinanassa anantara sotavifinanam uppajjatiti, na vattabam " Ya cakkhiivinnanassa uppadaya avattana — pe — -panidhi, sa va sotavinhanassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhiti " "? Amanta. Sotaviiihanam anavattantassa uppajjati, apanidahantassa uppajjatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu sotaviniianam ava^tantassa uppajjati, panidahan- tassa uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Hanoi sotaviniianam avattantassa uppajjati, panidahan- tassa uppajjati, no vata re vattabbe " Cakkhuvifinanassa anantara sotaviniianam uppajjatiti." 2. Cakkhuvihhanassa anantara sotaviniianam uppajja- titi ? Amanta. Cakkhuviiihanam rupanimittam manasikaroto uppajja- titi ? . Amanta. Sotaviiihanam riipanimittam manasikaroto uppajjatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkhuvihhanam ruparammanah iieva na ahharam- manan ti ? Amanta. Sotaviiihanam ruparammanah heva na ahharam- manaii ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Cakkhuh ca paticca rupe ca uppajjati cakkhuvihhanaii ti? Amanta. 496 KATHAVATTHU. [XIV. 3. Gakkhnii ca paticca rape ca uppajjati sotavinnanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkhun ca paticca rtipe ca uppajjati sotavinnanan ti ? Ainanta. " Cakkhun ca paticca rape ca uppajjati sotaviniianan ti," atth'eva suttanto ti ? N'atthi. " Cakkhuii ca paticca rupe ca uppajjati cakkhuvinnanan ti," atth'eva suttanto ti '? Amanta. Hahci " cakkhun ca paticca rupe ca uppajjati cakkhu- vinnanan ti," atth'eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe " Cakkhuii ca paticca rupe ca uppajjati sotavinnanan ti." Cakkhuvihhanassa anantara sotaviiiiianani uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Tan iieva cakkhuvihiianam tarn sotaviiiiianan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Sotavihhanassa anantara ghanavihhanam uppajjati, ghanavihhanassa anantara jivhaviimanam uppajjati, jivha- vihiianassa anantara kayavihiianam uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Ya jivhavihhanassa uppadaya avattana — pe — paniclhi, sa va kayaviiinanassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Jivhavihhanassa anantara kayavihhanam uppajjatiti, na vattabbain " Ya jivhavihhanassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhi, sa va kayaviiinanassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhiti ' ' '? Amanta. Kayavihhanam anavattantassa uppajjati, apanidahan- tassa uppajjatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu kayaviiihanani avattantassa uppajjati, paiiida- hantassa uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Hahci kayavihhanam avattantassa uppajjati, paiiida- hantassa uppajjati, no vata re vattabbe "Jivhavihhanassa anantara kayavihhanam uppajjatiti." XIV. 3.] KATHAYATTHU. 497 4. Jivhavimianassa anantara kayavinnanam uppajjatiti? Amanta. Jivliaviiinanam rasanimittam manasikaroto uppajjati- ti? Amanta. Kayavinnanam rasanimittam manasikaroto uppajjati- ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Jivhaviimanam rasarainmanaii fieva na annarammanan ti?_ Amanta. Kayaviniianam rasarammanaii iieva na annarammanan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Jivhan ca paticca rase ca uppajjati jivhaviiinanan ti ? Amanta. Jivhaii ca paticca rase ca uppajjati kayavimianan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Jivhah ca paticca rase ca uppajjati kayavinnanan ti? Amanta. " Jivhan ca paticca rase ca uppajjati kayavinnanan ti,"" atth'eva suttanto ti ? N'atthi. " Jivhan ca paticca rase ca uppajjati jivhavihhanan ti," atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Hafici " jivhaii ca paticca rase ca uppajjati jivhaviiinanan ti," atth'eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe "Jivhan ca paticca rase ca uppajjati kayavinnanan ti." • Jivhavimianassa anantara kayavihhanam uppajjati- ti ? Amanta. Tail heva jivhavihhanain tain kayavinnanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Na vattabbam " Pahca vifiiiana annamafihassa sama- nantara uppajjantiti " ? Amanta. Nanu atthi koci naccati gayati vadeti, rupaii ca passati, 83 498 KATHAVATTHU. [XIV. 4. saddan ca simati, gandhaii ca ghayati, rasafi ca sayati, photthabbail ca phusatiti ? ^ Ainanta. Hanoi atthi koci — pe — pliusati, tena vata re vattabbe " Panca vinnana annamannassa samanantara iippajjantiti." A n a n t a r a p a c c a y a k a t h a . XIV. 4. 1. Ariyarupam mahabhiitanam iipadayati ? Amanta. Ariyarupam kusalan ti '? ' ' Amanta. Mahabhuta kusala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Mahabhuta abyakata ti ? Amanta. Ariyarupain abyakatan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Ariyarupam mahabhiitanam upadayati ? Amanta. Ariyarupam anasavam asaiihojanlyain aganthaniyain ^ anoghanlyam ayoganlyam anlvaraniyain aparamatthain anupadaniyam asainkilesikan ti ? Amanta. Mahabhuta anasava — pe — asamkilesika ti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Mahabhuta sasava — pe — samkilesika ti ? Amanta. Ariyarupam sasavam — pe — sainkilesikan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Na vattabbain " Ariyarupam mahabhutanam upa- dayati " '? Amanta. I phussati, M. 2 agandho, p.s. XIV. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. -.1:99 Nanu vnttam Bhagavata — "Yam kinci Bhikkhave rupain cattari mahabhutani catunnaii ca mahabhutanam upadaya rupan ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi ariyarupam mahabhutanam upadayati. A r i y a r u p a k a t h a . XIV. 5. 1. Anno kamaragannsayo ahham kamaragapariynttha- nan ti ? Amanta. Anno kamarago ahhani kamaragapariyutthanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sv'eva kamarago tarn kamaragapariyutthanan ti ? Amanta. vSv'eva kamaragannsayo tarn kamaragapariyutthanan ti'? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Afiho patighanusayo ahham patighapariyutthanan ti ? Amanta. Ahham patigham ahham patighapariyutthanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tan heva patighain tarn patighapariyutthanan ti ? Amanta. Bv'eva patighanusayo tain patighapariyutthanan ti ■-• Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Ahho mananusayo ahhain manapariyutthanan ti ? Amanta. Ahho mano ahham manapariyutthanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sv'eva mano taiii manapariyutthanan ti? Amanta. Sv'eva mananusayo tarn manapariyuttlianan ti ? Na h'evam vattabl)e — pe — 500 KATHAVATTHU. [XIV. 5. 4. Anno ditthannsayo aiinaiu ditthipariyutthanan ti V Anianta. Anna ditthi afifiam ditthipariyutthanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sa va ditthi tarn ditthipariyutthanan ti ? Amanta. Sv'eva ditthannsayo tarn ditthipariyutthanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Anno vicikicchanusayo aiiiiam vicikicchapariyuttha- nan ti ? Amanta. Anna vicikiccha ahnam vicikicchapariyutthanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sa va vicikiccha tain vicikicchapariyutthanan ti ? Amanta. Sv'eva vicikicchanusayo tain vicikicchapariyutthanan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 0. Ahho bhavaraganusayo ahnain bhavaragax^ariyuttha- nan ti ? Amanta. '^.hfio bhavarago ahiiam bhavaragapariyutthanan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Sv'eva bhavarago tain bhavaragapariyutthanan ti ? Amanta. Sv'eva bhavaraganusayo tain bhavaragapariyutthanan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Anno avijjanusayo ahhain avijjapariyutthanan ti ? Amanta. Anna avijja afinani avijjapariyutthanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Sa va avijja tain avijjapariyutthanan tiV Amanta. Sv'eva avijjanusayo tain avijjapariyutthanan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Na vattabbaiii " Ahho anusayo anhain parij^uttha- nan ti ? XIV. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 501 Amanta. Puthujjano kusalabyakate citte vattamane " sanusayo ti " vattabbo ti '? Amanta. " Pariyutthito ti " vattabbo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi aiino anusayo aniiaiu pariyutthanan ti. Puthujjano kusalabyakate citte vattamane " sarago ti " vattabbo ti ? Amanta. " Pariyutthito ti " vattabbo ti. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi ahiio rago afiham pariyutthanan ti. A n fi o anusayo t i k a t h a . XIV. 6. 1. Pariyutthanam cittavippayuttan ti ? Amanta. Kupam nibbanam cakkhayatanam — pe — photthabbaya- tanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Pariyutthanam cittavippayuttan ti ? Amanta. N'atthi saragam cittam sadosam cittam samoham cittam — pe — akusalam cittam samkilittham cittan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu atthi saragam cittain sadosam cittam samoham cittam— pe — akusalam cittam sainkilitthani cittan ti ? Amanta. Hafici atthi saragam cittam sadosam cittain samohain cittam — pe — akusalam cittain samkilitthaiu cittain, no vata re vattabbe " Pariyutthanam cittavippayuttan ti." Pariyutthanam cittavippayuttan t i k a t h a . 502 KATHAVATTHU. [XIV. 7. XIV. 7. 1. Buparago rupadhatum anuseti rupadhatupariyapanno ti? Anianta. Sainapattesiyo iippattesiyo dittliadhainmasukhaviharo samapattesiyena cittena uppattesiyena cittena dittha- dhammasukhaviharena cittena sahagato sahajato sam- sattho sampayutto ekuppado ekanirodho ekavatthuko eka- rammano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu na samapattesiyo na iippattesiyo na ditthadham- masukhaviharo na samapattesiyena cittena na uppattesi- yena cittena na dittliadhammasukhaviharena cittena sahagato sahajato samsattho sampayutto ekuppado ekani- rodho ekavatthuko ekarammano ti ? Amanta. Hahci na samapattesiyo — pe — ekarammano, no vata re vattabbe " Euparago rupadhatum anuseti rupadhatupari- yapanno ti." 2. Euparago rupadhatum anuseti rupadhatupariya- panno ti '? Amanta. Saddarago saddadhatum anuseti saddadhatupariyapanno ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Euparago rupadhatum anuseti rupadhatupariyapanno ti? Amanta. Gandharago — pe — rasarago — pe — photthabbarago phot- thabbadhatum anuseti photthabbadhatupariyapanno ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Saddarago saddadhatum anuseti na vattabbam sadda- dhatupariyapanno ti ? Amanta. Euparago rupadhatuin anuseti na vattabbain rupadha- tupariyapanno ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— XIV. 7.] KATHAVATTHU. 603- Phottliabbarago photthabbadhatum anuseti na vattab- bam photthabbadhatupariyapanno ti ? Amanta. Euparago rupadhatuni anuseti na vattabbain rupadha- tupariyapanno ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Aruparago arupadhatum anuseti arupadhatupariya- panno ti? Amanta. Samapattesiyo uppattesiyo ditthadhammasukhaviharo samapattesiyena cittena uppattesiyena cittena dittba- dhammasukhaviharena cittena sahagato sahajato sam- sattbo sampayutto ekuppado ekanirodho ekavatthuko ekaranimano ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — • Nanu na samapattesiyo na uppattesiyo na dittha- dhammasukhaviharo na samapattesiyena cittena na uppattesiyena cittena na ditthadhammasukhaviharena cittena sahagato sahajato samsattho sampayutto ekup- pado ekanirodho ekavatthuko ekarammano ti ? Amanta. Hahci na samapattesiyo — pe — ekarammano, no vata re vattabbe " Aruparago arupadhatum anuseti arupadhatu- pari3'apanno ti." 4. Aruparago arupadhatum anuseti arupadhatupariya- panno ti ? Amanta. Saddarago saddadhatum anuseti saddadhatupariyapanno ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — - Ai'uparago arupadhatum anuseti arupadhatupariya- panno ti ? Amanta. Gandharago — pe — rasarago — pe — photthabbarago phot- thabbadhatum anuseti photthabbadhatupariyapanno ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Saddarago saddadhatum anuseti na vattabbam sadda- dhatupariyapanno ti ? 504 KATHAVATTHU. [XIV. 8 Ainanta. Aruparaoo arupadhatum annseti na vattabbam ariipa- dhatupariyapanno ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Photthabbarago photthabbadhatum anuseti na vattab- bam photthabbadhatupariyapanno ti "? Amanta. Aruparago arupadbatnm anuseti na vattabbam arupa- dhatupariyapanno ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Na vattabbam " Kiiparago rupadhatum annseti rupa- dhatupariyapanno, aruparago arupadhatum anuseti arupa- dhatupariyapanno ti " '? Amanta. Nanu kamarago kamadhatum anuseti kamadhatupari- yapanno ti ? Amanta. Hahci kamarago kamadhatum anuseti kamadhatupari- yapanno, tena vata re vattabbe " Kuparago rupadhatum anuseti rripadhatupariyapanno, aruparago arupadhatum anuseti arupadhatupariyapanno ti." P a r i y a p a n n a k a t h a . XIV. 8. 1 . Ditthigatain aby akatan ti '? Amanta. Vipakabyakatam kiriyabyakatam rupam nibbanam cak- khayatanam — pe — photthabbayatanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ditthigatain abyakatan ti ? Amanta. Ditthigatasampayutto phasso abyakato ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ditthigatain abyakatan ti ? Amanta. XIV. 8.J KATHAVATTHU. 505 Ditthigatasampayutta vedana — pe — safina — pe — cetana — pe — cittam abyakatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ditthigatasampayutto phasso akusalo ti ? Amanta. Dittliigatam akusalan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ditthigatasampayutta vedana — pe — sahiia — pe — cetana — pe — cittam akusalan ti ? Amanta. Ditthigatam akusalan ti '} Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Ditthigatam abyakatan ti ? Amanta. Aphalam avipakan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu saphalam savipakan ti ? Amanta. Hahci saphalam savipakam, no vata re vattabbe " Ditthi- gatam abyakatan ti." Ditthigatam abyakatan ti '? Amanta. Nanu micchaditthiparamani vajjani vuttani Bhaga- vata ti '? Amanta. Hahci micchaditthiparamani vajjani vuttani Bhagavata, no vata re vattabbe " Ditthigatam abyakatan ti." 3. Ditthigatam abyakatan ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Micchaditthi kho ^ Vaccha^ akusala, sammaditthis kusala4 ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Ditthigatam abyakatan ti." Ditthigatam abyakatan ti ? Amanta. ^ ko, S. 2 Yaccha, P. 3 dhammaditthi, M.S. 82. 4 akusala, M, 506 KATHAVATTHU. [XIV. 8. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Micchaditthissa ^ kho ahain^ Punnas dvinnam gatlnain annataram gatim vadami, iiirayam va tiracchanayonim va ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti '? Ainanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Ditthigatam abyakatan ti." 4. Na vattabbam " Ditthigatam abyakatan ti " '? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Sassato loko ti kho Vaccha abyakatam etam, asassato loko ti kho Vaccha abyakatam etam, antava loko ti kho Vaccha abyakatam etam, anan- tava loko ti kho Vaccha — pe — tarn jivam tarn sariran ti kho Vaccha — pe — ahhain jivam ahham sariran ti kho Vaccha — pe — hoti Tathagato param marana ti kho Vaccha — pe — na hoti Tathagato param marana ti kho Vaccha — pe — hoti ca na ca hoti Tathagato param marana ti kho Vaccha — pe — n'eva hoti na na hoti Tathagato param marana ti kho Vaccha abyakatam etan ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi ditthigatam abyakatan ti. 5. Ditthigatam abyakatan ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Micchaditthikassa Bhik- khave purisapuggalassa yah c'eva kayakammam yathadit- thisamattam samadinnam yah ca vaclkainmam — pe — yafi ca manokammam ya ca cetana ya ca patthana yo ca pani- dhi ye ca samkhara, sabbe te dhamma anitthaya akantaya amanapaya ahitaya dukkhaya samvattantlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam "Ditthigatam abyakatan ti." A b y a k a t a k a t h a . micchaditthiyain, S. ; micchaditthi, P. ^ ayaip, S. 3 pana, P. ; so, S. XIV. 9.] KATHAVATTHU. 507 XIV. 9. 1. Ditthigatam apariyapannan ti ? Amanta. Maggo phalam nibbanam, sotapattimaggo sotapattipha- 1am, sakadagamiinaggo sakadaganiiplialam, anagamiinaggo anagamiphalaip, arahattainaggo arahattaphalam, satipat- tlianam sainmappadhanain iddhipado indriyain balam bojjhango ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Na vattabbam " Ditthigatam apariyapannan ti "' '? Amanta. Puthujjano " kamesn vitarago ti " vattabbo ti ? Amanta. » " Vigataditthiyo ^ ti " vattabbo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi ditthigatam apariyapannan ti. A p a r i y a p a n n a k a t h a. " V a g g o c IT d d a s a m o Akusalamulam patisandahati knsalamiilam, Kusalamulam patisandahati akusalamtilam, Salayatanam, Cha viiihanakaya, Ariyarupam mahabhutanain upadaya, Sv'eva anusayo tain pariyutthanam, Cittavippayuttain, Yatha dhatu tail iieva anuseti, Ditthigatam abyakatam, Ditthigatam apaiiyapannan ti. ivita°, P.S.Sa. 508 KATHAVATTHU. [XV. 1. XV. 1. 1. Paccayata vavatthita ti '? Amanta. Nanu vimamsa hetn, so ^ ca adhipatlti "? Amanta. Haiici vimamsa hetu, so ca adhipati, tena vata re vat- tabbe " Hetiipaccayena paccayo, adhipatipaccayena x^ac- cayo ti." Nanu cliandadhipati sahajatanam dhammanam adhi- patlti ? Amanta. Hanoi chandadhipati sahajatanam dhammanam adhipati, tena vata re vattabbe " Adhipatipaccayena paccayo, saha- jatapaccayena paccayo ti." '2. Nanu viriyadhipati sahajatanain dhammanam adhi- patlti '? Amanta. Hahci viriyadhipati sahajatanam dhammanam adhipati, tena vata re vattabbe " Adhipatipaccayena paccayo, saha- jatapaccayena paccayo ti." Nanu viriyadhipati sahajatanam dhammanain adhi- pati, tan ca indriyan ti? Amanta. Hahci viriyadhipati sahajatanam dhammanam adhipati, tan ca indriyam, tena vata re vattabbe "Adhipatipaccayena paccayo, indriyapaccayena paccayo ti." Nanu viriyadhipati sahajatanam dhammanam adhipati, tail ca maggahgan ti ? Amanta. Haiici viriyadhipati sahajatanam dhammanam adhipati, tan ca maggahgam, tena vata re vattabbe " iVdhipatipac- cayena paccayo, maggapaccayena paccayo ti." 3. Nanu cittadhipati sahajatanam dhammanam adliipa- titi ? I yo S., P. omits the whole question. XV. 1.] KATHAVATTHU. 509 Am ant a. Haiici cittadhipati sahajatanam dhanimanam adhipati, tena vata re vattabbe " Adhipatipaccayena paccayo, saha- jatapaccayena paccayo ti." Nanu cittadhipati sahajatanam dhammanam adhipati, so ca aharo ti '? Amanta. Hanci cittadhipati sahajatanam dhammanam adhipati, so ca aharo, tena vata re vattabbe " Adhipatipaccayena paccayo, aharapaccayena paccayo ti." 4. Nanu cittadhipati sahajatanam dhammanam adhipati, tail ca indriyan ti ? Amanta. Hahci cittadhipati sahajatanam dhammanam adhipati, tan ca indriyam, tena vata re vattabbe "Adhipatipacca- yena paccayo, indriyapaccayena paccayo ti." Nanu vimamsadhipati sahajatanam dhammanam adhi- pati ti ? Amanta. Hahci vimamsadhipati sahajatanam dhammanain adhi- pati, tena vata re vattabbe " Adhipatipaccayena paccayo, sahajatapaccayena paccayo ti." Nanu vimamsadhipati sahajatanam dhammanam adhi- pati, tan ca maggahgan ti? Amanta. Hahci vimamsadhipati sahajatanam dhammanam adhi- pati, taiica maggaiigam, tena vata re vattabbe " Adhipati- paccayena paccayo, maggapaccayena paccayo ti." Nanu ariyam dhammam garunikatva uppajjatipaccavek- khana, tafi c'araminanan ti ? Amanta. Hahci ariyam dhammani garuni katva uppajjati pacca- vekkhana, tahc'arammanani, tena vata re vattabbe "Adhi- patipaccayena paccayo, arammaiiapaccayena paccayo ti." 5. Nanu purima purima kusala dhamma pacchimanam pacchimanani kusalanain dhammanam anantarapacca- yena paccayo, sa ca asevanii ti ? Amanta. 510 KATHAVATTHU. [XV. 2. Hanci pnrima purima kusala dhamiiia pacchimanam pacchimanam kusalanani dhammanam anantarapacca- yena paccayo, sa ca asevana, tena vata re vattabbe " Anan- tarapaccayena paccayo, asevanapaccayena paccayo ti." 6. Nanu purima purima akusala dhamma pacchimanam pacchimanaiu akusalanam dhammanam anantarapacca- yena paccayo, sa ca asevana ti ? Amanta. Hahci purima purima akusala dhamma pacchimanam pacchimanam akusalanam dhammanam anantarapaccayena paccayo, sa ca asevana, tena vata re vattabbe " Anantara- paccayo, asevanapaccayena paccayo ti." 7. Nanu purima purima kiriyabyakata dhamma pacchi- manain pacchimanam kiriyabyakatanam dhammanam anantarapaccayena paccayo, sa ca asevana ti '? Hahci purima purima kiriyabyakata dhamma pacchima- nain pacchimanam kiriyabyakatanam dhammanain ananta- rapaccayena paccayo, sa ca asevana, tena vata re vattabbe " Ana^ntarapaccayena paccayo, asevanapaccayena ]3accayo ti." 8. Na vattabbain " Paccayata vavatthita ti " ? Amanta. Hetupaccayena paccayo hoti, arammanapaccayena pac- cayo hoti, anantarapaccayena paccayo hoti, samananta- rapaccayena paccayo hoti ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi ^ paccayata vavatthita ti, Paccayakatha. XV. '2. 1. Avijjapaccaya pi samkhara, na vattabbain " sainkha- rapaccaya pi avijja ti " ? Amanta. Nanu avijja samkharena sahajata ti ? I M. inserts na vattabbam after hi. XV. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 511 Amanta. Hanci avijja samkharena sahajata, tena vatare vattabbe " Avijjapaccaya pi samkhara samkharapaccaya pi avijja ti." 2. Taiiliapaccaya pi ^ upadanam, na vattabbam " npada- napaccaya pi tanha ti " '? Amanta. Nanu tanha npadanena sahajata ti ? Amanta. Haiici tanha upadanena sahajata, tena vata re vattabbe " Tanhapaccaya pi upadanain upadanapaccaya pi tanha ti." 3. " Jaramaranapaccaya Bhikkhave jati, jatipaccaya bhavo ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? N'atthi. Tena hi avijjapaccaya pi samkhara, na \attabbam " samkharapaccaya pi avijja," tanhapaccaya pi upadanam, na vattabbam " upadanapaccaya pi tanha ti." 4. " Vihiianapaccaya Bhikkhave namarupam, namaru- papaccaya pi vihhanan ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi avijjapaccaya pi samkhara samkharapaccaya pi avijja, tanhapaccaya pi upadanain upadanapaccaya pi tanha ti. A ii h a m a f\ h a p a c c a y a k a t h a . XV. 3. 1. Addha parinipphanno ti ? Amanta. Rupan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vedana — pe — saiiiia — pe — samkhara — pe — vihhanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atlto addha parinipphanno ti '? ^ va K. 512 KATHAVATTHU. [XV. 3. Bupan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Vedana— pe — sanna — pe — samkhara — pe — vinnanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Anagato addha parinipplianno ti ? Ainanta. Rtipan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Amanta. Vedana — pe — saiiha — pe — samkhara — pe — vinnanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paccuppanno addha parinipphanno ti ? Amanta. Rupan ti ? ^ Na h'evam vattabbe- — pe — Vedana — -pe — sahila — pe — samkhara — pe — vinnanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Atltain rupam vedana safiiia sainkhara viimanam, atlto addha ti ? Amanta. Atita pahc'addha^ ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatam rupam vedana sahha samkhara vihfianam, anagato addha ti ? Amanta. Anagata pane' addha ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paccuppannam rupani vedana sahha sainkhara vihha- nam, paccuppanno addha ti ? Amanta. Paccuppanna paiic' addha ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — 4. Atlta pahcakkhandha atlto addha, anagata pahcak- khandha anagato addha, paccuppanna pahcakkhandha paccuppanno addha ti '? Amanta. ^ pahcakkhandha, P. and S. always. XV. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 513 Pannaras'addha ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — AtTtani clvadas' ayatanani atito addha, anagatani dvadas* ayatanani anagato addha, paccuppannani dvadas' ayata- nani paccuppanno addha ti ? Am ant a. Chattims' addha ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Atlta attharasa^ dhatuyo atito addha, anagata attha- rasa dhatuyo anagato addha, paccuppanna attharasa dhatuyo paccuppanno addha ti ? Amanta. Catupahhas' addha ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — • Atltani bavlsat'indriyani atito addha, anagatani bavlsat' indriyani anagato addha, paccuppannani bavlsat'indriyani paccuppanno addha ti '? Amanta. ChasatthI addha ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Na vattabbain " Addha parinipphanno ti " "? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhao-avata — " Tin'imani Bhikkhave kathavatthuni. Katamani tlni ? Atltam va Bhikkhave addhanam arabbha katham katheyya ' evam ahosi atltam addhanan ti,' anagatani va Bhikkhave addhanam arabbha katham katheyya ' evani bhavissati anagatani addhanan ti,' etarahi va Bhikkhave paccuppannam addhanam arabbha kathain katheyya ' evam hoti etarahi paccup- paniian ti.' Imani kho Bhikkhave tliii kathavatthunlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi addha parinipphanno ti. A d d li a Iv a t h a . atho, M. 34 514 KATHAVATTHU. [XV. 5. XV. 4. 1. Khano parinipphanno, layo parinipphanno, muhut- tam parinipphannau ti ? Amanta. Kupan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vedana — pe — saniia — pe — samkhara — pe — vinnanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Na vattabbam " Muhuttam parinipphannau ti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Tln'imani Bhikkhave kathavatthiini. Katamani tlni? Atitam va Bhikkhave addhanam arabblia katham katheyya ' evam ahosi atitam addhanan ti,' anagatain va Bhikkhave addhanam arabbha katham katheyya ' evam bhavissati anagatam addhanan ti,' etarahi va Bhikkhave paccuppannam addhanam arabbha katham katheyya ' evam hoti etarahi paccuppannam ti.' Imani kho Bhikkhave tlni kathavatthiinlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti '? Amanta. Tena hi muhuttam parinipphannau ti. K h a n a 1 a y a m u h u 1 1 a k a t h a . XV. 5. 1. Cattaro asava anasava ti V Amanta. Maggo phalam nibbanam sotapattimaggo sotapattipha- 1am — pe — bojjhahgo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Na vattabbam " Cattaro asava anasava ti " ? Amanta. Atth'afih'eva asava ^ yehi asavehi te asava sasava hontiti ? I anasava, P.S.M. XV. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 515 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi cattaro asava anasava ti. A s a V a k a t h a . XV. 6. 1. Lokuttaranam dhanimanam iaramaranam lokuttaran ti? Amanta, Maggo phalam nibbanam — pe — bojjhango ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sotapattimaggassa jaramaranam sotapattimaggo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sotapattimaggassa jaramaranam sotapattimaggo ti ? Amanta. Sotapattiphalassa jaramaranam sotapattiphalan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sakadagamimaggassa — pe — sakadagamiphalassa — pe — anagamimaggassa — pe — anagamiphalassa — pe — arahatta- maggassa jaramaranam arahattamaggo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahattamaggassa jaramaranam arahattamaggo ti '? Amanta. Arahattaphalassa jaramaranam arahattaphalan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Satipatthananam sammappadhananam iddhipadanam indriyanam balanam bojjhahganam jaramaranam boj- jhango ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — '2. Na vattabbam " Lokuttaranam dhammanam jarji- maranam lokuttaran ti " '? Amanta. Lokiyan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi lokuttaran ti. J a r a m a r a n a 1< a t h a . 516 KATHAVATTHV. [XV. 8. XV. 7. 1. Sannavedayitanirodhasamapatti lokuttara ti ? Amanta. Maggo phalam nibbanam— pe — bojjhaiigo ti V Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Na vattabbam " Sannavedayitanirodhasamapatti lokuttara ti " ? Amanta. Lokiya ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi lokuttara ti. S a ii h a V e d a y i t a k a t h a XV. 8. 1. Sannavedayitanirodhasamapatti lokiya ti? Amanta. Rupan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vedana saMa samkhara vihhanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kamavacara ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Rupavacara ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arupavacara ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Na vattabbain " Sahhavedayitanirodhasamapatti lokiya ti"? Amanta. Lokuttara ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi lokiya ti. D u t i y a s a h h a V e d a y i t a k a t h a . XV. 9.] KATHAVATTHU. 517 XV. 9. 1. Sannavedayitanirodhasamapanno kalam kareyyati ? Amanta. Atthi sannavedayitanirodhasamapannassa niaranan- tiyo ^ phasso, maranantiya vedana, maranantiya saniia, maranantiya cetana, maranantiyam cittan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N 'atthi saiinavedayitanirodhasamapannassa maranan- tiyo phasso — pe — maranantiyam cittan ti V Amanta. Hanci n' atthi sahhavedayitanirodhasamapannassa maranantiyam cittam, no vata re vattabbe " Sahhave- dayitanirodhasamapanno kalam kareyyati." 2. Saiihavedayitanirodhasamapanno kalam kareyyati ? Amanta. Atthi sahhavedayitanirodhasamapannassa phasso ve- dana saima cetana cittan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N 'atthi saiihavedayitanirodhasamapannassa phasso vedana saiiiia cetana cittan ti '? Amanta. Aphassakassa kalakiriya,^ avedanakassa kalakiriya — pe — acittakassa kalakiriya ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu saphassakassa kalakiriya — pe — sacittakassa kala- kiriya ti ? Amanta. Haiici saphassakassa kalakiriya — pe — sacittakassa kala- kiriya, no vata re vattabbe " Saiiiiavedayitanirodhasama- panno kalam kareyyati." 8. Safinavedayitanirodhasamapanno kalam kareyyati ? Amanta. Sahhavedayitanirodhasamapannassa kaye visain ka- meyya, sattham kameyya, aggi kameyyati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — I maranantiyo, M.K. ^ kalam°, M. 518 - KATHAVATTHU. [XV. 10, Samiavedayitanirodhasamapannassa kaye visam na kameyya, sattham na kameyya, aggi na kameyyati ? Anianta. Hanoi aggi na kameyya, novata re vattabbe " SaMave- dayitanirodhasamapanno kalain kareyyati." 4. Sannavedayitanirodhasamapannassa kaye visam ka- meyya, sattham kameyya, aggi ^ kameyyati ? Amanta. Na nirodhasamapanno ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sannavedayitanirodhasamapanno na- kalam kareyyati? Amanta. Atthi so niyamo yena niyamena niyato saiinavedayita- nirodhasamapanno na kalam kareyyati '? N' atthi. Hanoi n'atthi so niyamo yena niyamena niyato sahhave- dayitanirodliasamapanno na kalam kareyya, no vata re vattabbe " Sannavedayitanirodhasamapanno na kalam kareyyati." 5. Cakkhuvinnanasamahgl na kalam kareyyati ? Amanta. Atthi so niyamo yena niyamena niyato cakkhuviiihana- samahgi na kalam kareyyati ? N'atthi. Hanoi n'atthi so niyamo yena niyamena niyato cakkhu- viiihanasamahgl na kalam kareyya, no vata re vattabbe '' Cakkhuvihiianasamangi na kalam kareyyati." T a t i y a s a h h a V e d a y i t a k a t h a . XV. 10. 1. Sahhavedayitanirodhasamapatti asafihasattupika 3 ti? Amanta. Atthi sahhavedayitanirodhasamapannassa alobho kusa- I ao-gim, M. ^ M.. omits na. 3 satthu°, P.S. XV. 11.] KATHAVATTHU. 519 lamnlam, adoso kusalamulaip, amoho kusalamulam^ sadclha viriyam sati sainadhi paiina ti ? Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — N'attlii samiavedayitanirodhasainapannassa alobho ku- salamulam — pe — panna ti '? Amanta. Hanci n'atthi paiina, no vata re vattabbe " Saniiave- dayitanirodhasamapatti asamiasattiipika ti." 2. Saiiiiavedayitanirodhasamapatti asamiasattiipika ti ? Amanta. Attlii saiinavedayitanirodhasamapannassa phasso vedana saiifia cetana cittan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N'atthi saiinavedayitanirodhasamapannassa phasso vedana saiifia cetana cittan ti ? Amanta. Aphassakassa maggabhavana, avedanakassa magga- bhavana — pe — acittakassa maggabhavana ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu saphassakassa maggabhavana — pe — sacittakassa maggabhavana ti ? Amanta. Haiici saphassakassa maggabhavana — pe — sacittakassa maggabhavana, no vata re vattabbe " Saiihavedayita- nirodhasamapatti asahiiasattupika ti." 3. Saiihavedayitanirodhasamapatti asamiasattiipika ti '? Amanta. Ye keci samiavedayitanirodham samapajjanti, sabbe te asahiiasattupika ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Na vattabbain " Saiifiavedayitanirodhasamapatti asafihasattiipika ti " ? Amanta. Nanu idhapi asaiifii tatrapi asahfii ti ? Amanta. Haiici idhapi asahhi tatrapi asafihl, tena vata re vattabbe " Sahhavedayitanirodhasamapatti asahiiasattupika ti." A s a h h a s a 1 1 u p i k a k a t h a . 520 KATHAVATTHU. ' ;;XV. 11. XV. 11. 1. Annain kammam anno kammtipacayo ti ? Amanta. Anno phasso anno phassupacayo, aiina vedana aiifio vedanupacayo, anna sanna anno sanfiupacayo, aniia cetana anno cetanupacayo, aiinam cittam anno cittupacayo, anna saddha anno saddhnpacayo, annam viriyam anno viriyupa- cayo, anna sati anno satupacayo, aniio samadhi anno sama- dhupacayo, aiina panna anno pannupacayo, aiino rago anno ragupacayo — pe — aiinam anottappam aniio anottap- piipacayo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Annam kammam aiiiio kammiipacayo ti "? Amanta. Kammiipacayo kammena sahajato ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kammiipacayo kammena sahajato ti ? Amanta. Kusalena kammena sahajato kammiipacayo kusalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kusalena kammena sahajato kammiipacayo kusalo ti ? . Amanta. Sukhaya vedanaya sampayuttena kammena sahajato kammiipacayo sukhaya vedanaya sampayutto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dukkhaya — pe — adukkhamasukhaya vedanaya sampa- yuttena kammena sahajato kammiipacayo adukkha- masukhaya vedanaya sampayutto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Kammiipacayo kammena sahajato ti ? Amanta. Akusalena kammena sahajato kammiipacayo akusalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Akusalena kammena sahajato kammiipacayo akusalo ti? Amanta. XV. 11.] KATHAVATTHU. 521 Sukhaya vedanaya sampayuttena kanimena sahajato kammiipacayo sukhaya vedanaya sampayiitto ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dukkhaya — pe— adukkhamasukhaya vedanaya sampa- yuttena kammena sahajato kamniupacayo adukkhama- sukhaya vedanaya sampayutto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Kammam cittena sahajatam, kammam sarammanan ti?_ ' Amanta. Kamniupacayo cittena sahajato, kammiipacayo saram- mano ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kammiipacayo cittena sahajato, kamniupacayo anarani- maiio ti '? Amanta. Kammam cittena sahajatam, kammam anarammanan ti? ' Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kammam cittena sahajatam, cittam bhijjamanani, kam- mam bhijjatlti? Amanta. Kamniupacayo cittena sahajato, cittam bhijjamanani kammiipacayo bhijjatlti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kammiipacayo cittena sahajato, cittam bhijjamanani, kammiipacayo na bhijjatlti '? Amanta. Kammam cittena sahajatam, cittam bhijjamanam, kammani na bhijjatlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Kammamhi kammiipacayo ti ? Amanta. Tail heya kammain, so kamniupacayo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kammamhi kammiipacayo, kammiipacayato vipako nibbattatlti ? Amanta. 522 KATHAVATTHU. [XV. 11. Tan neva kammam, so kammupacayo, so kammavipako ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kaminamhi kamniupacayo, kammupacayato vipako nibbattati, vipako sarammano ti ? Amanta. Kamniupacayo sarammano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kammupacayo anarammano ti ? Amanta. Vipako anarammano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Annam kammain anno kammupacayo ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — "Idha Punna^ ekacco sabya- pajjham pi abyapajjham pi kayasainkharain abhisam- kharoti, sabyapajjham pi abyapajjham pi vaclsamkharam — pe — manosamkharam abhisamkharoti, so sabyapajjhani pi abyapajjhain pi kayasamkharam abhisamkharitva, sa- byapajjham pi abyapajjhain pi vaclsamkharam — pe — manosamkharam abhisamkharitva sabyapajjham pi abya- pajjham pi lokam upapajjati, tam enam sabyapajjham pi abyapajjham pi lokam ^ upapannam samanam sabyapajjha pi abyapajjha pi phassa phusanti ; so sabyapajjhehi pi abyapajjhehi pi phassehi phuttho samano sabyapajjham pi abyapajjham pi vedanam vedeti vokinnasukhadukkham,3 seyyathapi manussa, ekacce ca deva, ekacce ca vinipatika; iti kho Punna bhutabhutassa upapatti hoti, yam karoti, tena upapajjati ; upapannam etam phassa phusanti. Evam paham Punna kammadayada satta ti vadamlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Ahham kammam anno kam- • • • mupacayo ti." K a m m u p a c a y a k a t h a . I pana, S.M. ^ o]-^^^ p_ 3 votinnam, P. XV. 11.] KATHAVATTHU. 523 V a g g o p a n n a r a s a m o . Paccayata vavattliita, Paticcasamuppado, Addha ca khano layo muhuttam, Cattaro asava anasava, LokuttaranaiD dhainmanam jaramaranam lokuttaram,^ Sannavedayitanirodhasamapatti lokuttara, Sannavedayitanirodhasamapatti lokiya, Safinavedayitanirodhasamapanno kalam kareyya, Sv'eva maggo asamiasattupapattiya, Annam kammam aiino kammupacayo ti. Anusaya, Samvaro, Kappo, Mnlam, Vavattliita. Tatiyo Pannasako. I ora, M.P.S. 524 KATHAVATTHU. j'XVI. 1. XVI. 1. 1. Paro parassa cittam nigganhatlti ? Amanta. Paro parassa cittam ma rajji ma dussi ma muyhi ma kilisslti nigganhatlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paro parassa cittam nigganhatlti ? Amanta. Paro parassa uppanno phasso ma nirujjhiti ^ nigganha- tlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe^ — Paro parassa uppanna vedana — pe — uppanna sanha — pe — uppanna cetana — pe — uppannam cittam — pe — uppanna saddha — pe — uppannam viriyam — pe — uppanna sati — pe — uppanno samadhi — pe — uppanna pahiia ma nirujjhiti nigganhatlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Paro parassa cittam nigganhatlti '? Amanta. Paro parassa atthaya ^ ragam pajahati, dosam pajahati — pe — anottappam pajahatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paro parassa cittam nigganhatlti ? Amanta. Paro parassa atthaya maggam bhaveti, satipatthanam bhaveti — pe — bojjhahgam bhavetiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paro parassa cittain nigganhatlti ? Amanta. Paro parassa atthaya dukkham parijanati, samudayam pajahati, nirodham sacchikaroti, maggam bhavetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paro parassa cittam nigganhatlti ? Amanta. I nirujjhati, P. and S. ^ attaya, P. ; vittaya, S. XVI. 2.] KATHAVATTHU. 525 Aiiiio annassa karako, param katam siikhain clukkham anno karoti anno patisamvedetiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — • 3. Paro parassa cittam nigganhatiti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Attana va ^ katam papain, attana samkilissati, Attana akatam papain, attana va visujjhati, Suddhi asuddhi paccattam - nanno annam visodhaye 3 ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Paro parassa cittam nigganha- titi." 4. Na vattabbam " Paro parassa cittam nigganhatiti " '? Amanta. Nanu atthi balappatta 4 atthi vaslbhuta ti ? Amanta. Haiici atthi balappatta atthi vaslbhuta, tena vata re vattabbe " Paro parassa cittam nigganhatiti." Niggahakatha. XVI. 2. 1. Paro parassa cittam pagganhatiti ? Amanta. Paro parassa cittain mil rajji ma dussi ma muyhi ma kihssiti pagganhatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paro parassa cittain pagganhatiti ? Amanta. Paro parassa alobhani kusalamulam janeti, adosam ^ ca, P.S2.M. 2 oantaiu, P. 3 odhayye, P. 4 pala°, S. ; phala^ P. 526 IvATHAVATTHU. [XVI. 2. kusalamulam janeti, amoham kusalamnlam janeti, sad- dham janeti, viriyam janeti, satim janeti, samadhim janeti, pafiiiam janetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paro parassa cittam pagganhatiti ? Amanta. Paro parassa upjianno phasso nia nirnjjhiti pagganha- titi ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paro parassa uppanna vedana — pe — uppanna sahiia — pe — uppanna cetana — pe — uppannam cittam — pe — nppanna saddha — pe — uppannam viriyam — pe — uppanna sati — pe — uppanno samadhi — pe — uppanna pahha ma nirujjhiti pagganhatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Paro parassa cittam pagganhatiti? Amanta. Paro parassa atthaya ragam pajahati, dosam pajahati — pe — anottappam pajahatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paro parassa cittam pagganhatiti ? Amanta. Paro parassa atthaya maggam bhaveti, satipatthanam bhaveti — pe — bojjhaiigam bhavetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paro parassa cittam pagganhatiti ? Amanta. Paro parassa atthaya dukkham parijanati, samudayam pajahati, nirodham sacchikaroti, maggam bhavetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paro parassa cittam pagganhatiti ? Amanta. Afifio ahhassa karako, param katani sukham dukkham anno karoti anno patisamvedetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Paro parassa cittam pagganhatiti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhaijavata — XVI. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 527 " Attana va katam papam, attana samkilissati, Attana akatam papam, attana va visujjhati, Suddhi asuddhi paccattam nanfio aniiam visodhaye ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Paro parassa cittam pagganha- tlti." 4. Na vattabbam " Paro parassa cittam pagganhatiti " ? Amanta. Nanu atthi balappatta atthi vaslbhuta ti "? Amanta. Hanoi atthi balappatta atthi vaslbhuta, tena vata re vattabbe " Paro parassa cittam pagganhatiti." P a g g a h a k a t li a . XVI. 3. 1. Paro parassa siikham anuppadetiti ? Amanta. Paro parassa dukkham anuppadetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paro parassa dukkham na anuppadetiti ? Amanta. Paro parassa sukham na anuppadetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Paro parassa sukham anuppadetiti ? Amanta. Paro parassa attano sukham anuppadeti, aiiiiesam sukham anuppadeti, tassa sukham anuppadetiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paro parassa n'ev'attano na aiihesarn na tassa sukham anuppadetiti ? Amanta. Haiici paro parassa n'ev'attano na arii"iesani na tassa 528 KATHAVATTHU. [XVI. 4. sukhain anuppadeti, no vata re vattabbe " Paro parassa. sukham annppadetlti." Paro parassa sukham anuppadetiti '? Amanta. > Aiino annassa karako, param katam sukham dukkharp. aniio karoti aiiho patisamvedetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Na vattabbain " Paro parassa sukham anuppade- titi " ? Amanta. Nanu ayasma Udayn etad avoca — " Bahunam vata no Bhagava dukkhadhammanam apahatta,^ bahunam ^ li*/'! vata no Bhagava sukhadhammanam upahatta, bahunani *^' J vata no Bhagava akusalanam dhammanam apahatta, bahunam vata no Bhagava kusalanam dhammanam upahatta ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi paro parassa sukham anuppadetiti. S u k h a n u p p a d a n a k a t h a . XVP 4. 1. Adhigayha manasikarotiti '? Amanta. Tena cittena tarn cittam pajanatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena cittena tarn cittam pajanatiti ? Amanta. Tena cittena tain cittam cittan ti pajanatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena cittena tarn cittam cittan ti pajanatiti ? Amanta. Tarn cittam tassa cittassa arammanan ti ? ^ Upadayi, P.S. ^ apahatatta, P.S.Sa. always. XYI. 4.] ICATHAVATTHU. 529' Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tarn cittam tassa cittassa arammanan ti "? Am ant a. Tena phassena tarn phassam phnsati, taya vedaiiaya, taya sannaya, taya cetanaya, tena cittena, tena vitakkena, tena vicarena, taya pitiya, taya satiya, taya paniiaya tarn paniiam pajanatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Atltain atltan ti manasikaronto anagatain anagatan ti manasikarotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atitain atltan ti manasikaronto anagatain anagatan ti manasikarotiti '? Amanta. Dvinnam phassanam — pe — dvinnam cittanam samo- dhanani hotiti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atitam atltan ti manasikaronto paccnppannain paccup- pannan ti manasikarotiti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atitam atltan ti manasikaronto paccuppannam paccup- pannan ti manasikarotiti ? Amanta. Dvinnam phassanam — pe — dvinnam cittanam samo- dhanam hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atitam atltan ti manasikaronto anagatain anagatan ti manasikaroti, paccuppannam pacciippannan ti manasi- karotiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atitam atltan ti manasikaronto anagatam anagatan ti manasikaroti, paccuppannam paccuppannan ti manasi- karotiti ■? Amanta. Tinnam phassanaiii — pe — tinnam cittanam samodha- nam hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Anagatam anagatan ti manasikaronto atitam atltan ti manasikarotiti ? 35 530 KATHAVATTHU. [XVI. 4. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatam anagatan ti manasikaronto atitam atltan ti manasikarotlti '? Am ant a. Dvinnam phassanam — pe — dvinnam cittanam samo- dlianam hotlti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatam anagatan ti manasikaronto paccuppannam paccuppannan ti manasikarotlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatani anagatan ti manasikaronto paccuppannam paccuppannan ti manasikarotlti ? Amanta. Dvinnam phassanam — pe — dvinnam cittanam samo- dhanam hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatam anagatan ti manasikaronto atitam atltan ti manasikaroti, paccuppannam paccuppannan ti manasi- karotlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagatam anagatan ti manasikaronto atitam atltan ti manasikaroti, paccuppannam paccuppannan ti manasi- karotlti ? Amanta. Tinnam phassanam — pe — tinnam cittanam samodha- nam hotlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Paccuppannam paccuppannan ti manasikaronto atitam atltan ti manasikarotlti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Paccuppannam paccuppannan ti manasikaronto atitam atltan ti manasikarotlti '? Amanta. Dvinnam phassanam — pe — dvinnam cittanaiu samo- dhanam hotlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paccuppannam paccuppannan ti manasikaronto anaga- tam anagatan ti manasikarotlti ? XVI. 4.] KATHAVATTHU. 531 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paccnppannam paccnppaniian ti manasikaronto anaga- tam anagatan ti nianasikarotlti '? Amanta. Dvinnam phassanam — pe — dvinnam cittanam samo- -dhanam hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paccnppannam pacciippannan ti manasikaronto atltam atltan ti manasikaroti, anagatam anagatan ti manasi- karotlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Paccuppannam paccuppannan ti manasikaronto atitam atltan ti manasikaroti, anagatani anagatan ti manasi- karotiti ? Amanta. Tinnam phassanam — pe — tinnain cittanam samodha- nam hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Na vattabbam " Adhigayha nianasikarotlti " *? Amanta. Nanu vuttain Bhagavata — " ' Sabbe samkhara anicca ti " ^ 3-ada panhaya passati, Atha nibbindati dukkhe esamaggo visuddhiya.^ ' Sabbe samkhara dukkha ti ' yada panhaya passati, Atha nibbindati dukkhe esamaggo visuddhiya. ' Sabbe dhamma anatta ti ' yada panhaya passati, Atha nibbindati dukkhe esamaggo visuddhiya ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi adbigayha nianasikarotlti. A d h i g a V h a 111 a n a s i k a r a k a t h a . i ti, M. omits. 2 visuddhiya, P. 532 KATHAVATTHU. [XVI. 5. XVI. 5. 1. Rupam hetuti ? Ainanta. Alobho hetuti ? Is a h'evam vattabbe — pe — Adoso lietu — pe — amoho lietu, loblio hetu, doso lietu^ moho hetuti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Bupam hetuti ? Amanta. Saraninianam, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu anarammanam, ii'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Haiici anarammanain, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhi, no vata re vattabbe " Eupain hetuti." 2. Alobho hetu sarammano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti '? Amanta. Eupam hetu saraiximanam, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe^ — pe — Adoso hetu, amoho hetu, lobho hetu doso hetu moho hetu sarammano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti? Amanta. Riipam hetu sarammanam, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Bupam hetu sarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Alobho hetu anarammano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Rupam hetu anaranmianam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? XVI. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 533 Amanta. Adoso lietu — pe — moho hetu anarammano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Na vattabbam " Eupam hetuti " ? Amanta. Nanii inahabhuta upada ^ rupanam upadaya hetuti '? Amanta. Hanoi mahabhuta upada rupanam upadaya hetu, tena vata re vattabbe " Kilpam hetuti." B u p a 111 hetuti k a t h a . XVI. 6. 1. Eupam sahetukan ti ? Amanta. Alobhahetuna ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Adosahetuna ti — pe — amohahetuna ti, lobhahetuna ti, dosahetuna ti, mohahetuna ti ? Na h'evaiii vattabbe — pe — Kupam sahetukan ti ? Amanta. Sarammanam, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Haiici anarammanani, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhi, no vata re vattabbe " Eupam sahetukan ti." 2. Alobho sahetuko sarammano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Eupaiii sahetukani sarammanam, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — I upadaya, K. 534 KATHAVAIIHU. [XYI. 7. Adoso sahetuko — pe — aiuolio saddha virij^am sati samadhi panna lobho doso moho mano ditthi vicikiccha thinam uddhaccam ahirikam anottappam sahetukam saraiiimanain, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Eupam sahetukam sarammanam, atthi tassa avattana — pe — ^panidhlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Rupam sahetukam anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Alobho sahetuko anarammano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Rupain sahetukam anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti '? Amanta. Adoso sahetuko — pe — anottappam sahetukam anaram- manam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Ka h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Na vattabbam " Eupam sahetukan ti " ? Amanta. Nanu rupam sappaccayan ti ? Amanta. Hahci rupam sappaccayam, tena vata re vattabbe " Eupam sahetukan ti." Eupam sahetukan t i k a t h a . XYI. 7. 1. Eupain kusalan ti ? Amanta. Sarammanam, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. XVI. 7.] KATHllYATTHU. 535 Haiici anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhi, no vata re vattabbe " Eiipam kiasalan ti." 2. Alobho kusalo sarammano, atthi tassa ayattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Eupam kusalam saranunanam, atthi tassa avattana — ^pe — panidhiti '? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — Adoso kusalo, anioho kusalo, saddha viriyam sati samadhi — pe — pahha kusala sarammana, atthi tassa ayattana — pe — ^panidhiti ? Amanta. Eupam kusalam sarammanam, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Eupam kusalam anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Alobho kusalo anarammano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — Eupam kusalam anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana. — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Adoso kusalo, pahha kusala anarammana, n'atthi tasssr. avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Xa h'evani vattabbe — pe — 4. Eupam akusalan ti ? xAmanta. Sarammanam, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — Xanu anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti '/ Amanta. Hahci anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhi, no vata re vattabbe '' Eupam akusalan ti."' 5. Lobho akusalo sarammano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti "? 536 KATHAVATTHU. [XVI. 8. Amanta. Rnpam akusalam saramnianain, attlii tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Doso moho mano — pe — anottappam akusalam saram- manam, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti '? Amanta. Rupam akusalam sarammanam, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Rupam akusalam anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Lobho akusalo anarammano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Rupam akusalam anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta, Doso, moho, anottappam akusalam anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana^ — pe — panidhiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Na vattabbam " Riipam kusalam pi akusalam piti " '? Amanta. Nanu kayakammam vaclkammam kusalarn pi akusalam pIti ? Amanta. Haiici kayakammam vaclkammam kusalam pi akusalam pi, tena vata re vattabbe " Riipam kusalam pi akusalam pIti." R u p a rn k u s a 1 a k u s a 1 a n t i k a t h a . XVI. 8. 1. Riipam vipako ti ? Amanta. Riipam sukhavedanlyam dukkhavedanlyam adukkhama- XVI. 8.] KATHAVATTHU. 537 snkhavedaniyam, snkliaya vedanaya sanipayuttam, duk- kliaya vedanaya sampayuttam, adukkhamasukhaya veda- naya sampayuttam, phassena sampayuttam — pe — cittena sampayuttam sarammanam, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu na sukhavedaniyaiu — pe — na dukkhavedanlyam — pe — anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — pani- dhiti '? Amanta. Haiici na sukhavedaniyam — pe — panidhi, no vata re vattabbe " Eupam vipako ti." 2. Phasso vipako phasso sukhavedanlyo — pe — saram- mano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Eupam vipako rupam sukhavedaniyam — pe — saram- manain, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Eupam vipako rupam na sukhavedaniyam — pe — anarammanam, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Phasso vipako phasso na sukhavedanlyo — pe — anaram- mano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3 Na vattabbam " Eupam vipako ti " ? Amanta. Nanu kammassa katatta uppanna cittacetasika dhamma vipako ti ? Amanta. Hanoi kammassa katatta uppanna cittacetasika dhamma vipako, tena vata re vattabbe " Kammassa katatta uppannam rupam vipako ti." E u p a in V i p a k o t i k a t h a 538 KATHAVATTHU. [XVI. 9. XVI. 9. 1. Atthi rupam rupavacaran ti ? Amanta. Samapattesiyam uppattesiyam ditthadhammasukhavi- haram samapattesiyena cittena uppattesiyena cittena ditthadhanimasukhaviharena cittena sahagatam sahajatam samsatthaiii sampayuttain ekuppadam ekanirodham eka- vatthiikam ekaramiXLanan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu na samapattesiyam na uppattesiyam na dittha- dhammasukhaviharam na samapattesiyena cittena na uppattesiyena cittena na ditthadhanimasukhaviharena cittena sahagatam — pe — ekarammanan ti '? Amanta. Haiici na samapattesiyam — pe — ekarammanam, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi rupam rupavacaran ti." 2. Atthi rupam arupavacaran ti '? Amanta. Samapattesiyam uppattesiyam ditthadhammasukhavi- haram samapattesiyena cittena uppattesiyena cittena ditthadhammasukhaviharena cittena sahagatam sahajatam samsatthain sampayuttam ekuppadam ekanirodham ekavatthukam ekarammanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu na samapattesiyam na uppattesiyam na dittha- dhammasukhaviharam na samapattesiyena cittena na uppattesiyena cittena na ditthadhammasukhaviharena cittena sahagatam — pe — ekarammanan ti ? Amanta. Hanoi na samapattesiyam — pe — ekarammanain, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi rupam arupavacaran ti." 8. Na vattabbam " Atthi rupain rupavacaram, atthi rupam arupavacaran ti " ? Amanta. Nanu kamavacarakammassa katatta rupam kamava- caran ti "? Amanta. Hafici kamavacarakammassa katatta rupaiii kamava- XVI. 10.1 KATHAVATTHU. 539 caram, tena vata re vattabbe " Eupavacarakammassa katatta rupam rupavacaram, arupavacarakammassa katatta rupam arupavacaran ti." Rupaiii rupavacar arupavacaran ti katha. XVI. 10. 1. Euparago rupadhatupariyapanno ti ? Amanta. Samapattesiyo uppattesiyo ditthadhammasukhaviharo samapattesiyena cittena uppattesiyena cittena dittiia- dhammasukhaviharena cittena sahagato sahajato sam- sattho sampayutto ekuppado ekanirodho ekavatthuko ekarammano ti ? ^ Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Nanu na samapattesiyo na uppattesiyo na dittha- dhammasukhaviharo na samapattesiyena cittena na uppattesiyena cittena na ditthadhammasukhaviharena cittena sahagato — pe — ekarammano ti '? Amanta. Hahci na samapattesiyo — pe — ekarammano, no vata re vattabbe " Euparago rupadhatupariyapanno ti." 2. Eiiparago rupadhatupariyapanno ti? Amanta. Saddarago saddadhatupariyapanno ti? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — Euparago rupadhatupariyapanno ti ? Amanta. Gandharago — pe — rasarago — pe — photthabbarago photthabbadhatupariyapanno ti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Saddarago na vattabbain " saddadhatupariyapanno ti "? Amanta. Euparago na vattabbain " rupadhatupariyapanno ti" ? Xa h'evani vattabbe — pe — Gandharago — pe — rasarago — pe — ^photthabbarago na vattabbain " photthabbadluitupariyapanno ti " ? 540 KATHAVATTHU. [XVI. 10. Amaiita. Euparago na vattabbam " rnpadhatnpariyapanno ti " ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Aruparago arupadhatupariyapanno ti '? Aiiiaiita. Samapattesiyo uppattesiyo ditthadhammasukhaviharo saiuapattesiyena cittena uppattesiyena cittena dittliadham- masukhaviharena cittena sahagato saliajato samsattho sampayutto ekuppado ekanirodho ekavatthuko ekarain- mano ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu na samapattesiyo na uppattesiyo na ditthadham- masukhaviharo na samapattesiyena cittena na uppat- tesiyena cittena na ditthadhammasukhaviharena cittena sahagato — pe— ekarammano ti ? Amanta. Hahci na samapattesiyo — pe — ekarammano, no vata re vattabbe " Aruparago arupadhatupariyapanno ti." 5. Aruparago arupadhatupariyapanno ti ? Amanta. Saddarago saddadhatupariyapanno ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Aruparago arupadhatupariyapanno ti ? Amanta. Gandharago — pe — rasarago — pe — photthabbarago phot- thabbadhatupariyapanno ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Saddarago na vattabbain " saddadhatupariyapanno ti'":^ Amanta. Aruparago na vattabbain " arupadhatupariyapanno ti"? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Gandharago — pe — rasarago — pe — photthabbarago na vattabbam " photthabbadhatupariyapanno ti " '? Amanta. Aruparago na vattabbam " arupadhatupariyapanno ti " ? XVI. 10.] KATHAVATTHU. 541 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Na vattabbam " Knparago rupadhatupariyapanno, aruparago ampadhatupariyapamio ti " ? Amanta. Naiiu kamarago kamadhatupariyapanno ti ? Amanta. Haiici kamarago kamadhatupariyapanno, tena vata re vattabbe " Ruparago rupadhatupariyapanno, aruparago arupadhatupariyapanno ti. " R u p a r a g o rupadhatupariyapanno, aru- parago arupadhatupariyapanno t i k a t h a. V aggo s o lasamo. Cittaniggaho, Cittapaggaho, Sukhanuppadanam, Adhigayha manasikaro, Riipam hetu, Rupam sahetukam, Rupam kusalam pi akusalam pi, Rupam vipako, Atthi rupam rupavacaram, Atthi rupain arupavacaram, Sabbe kilesa kamadhatupariyapanna ti. 542 KATHAVATTHU. [XVII. 1. XVII. 1. 1. Atthi Arahato pimiiupacayo ti? Amanta. Atthi Arahato apuhhupacayo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N' atthi Arahato apufihiipacayo ti ? Amanta. N' atthi Arahato puhiiupacayo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Atthi Arahato pmlfiupacayo ti ? Amanta. Araha ^ puhiiabhisaiiikharam abhisamkharoti, aneiija- bhisamkharam ~ abhisamkharoti, gatisamvattanikam kammam karoti, bhavasamvattanikam kammam karoti, issariyasamvattanikam kammam karoti, adhipaccasamvat- tanikam kammam karoti, mahabhogasamvattanikam kammam karoti, mahaparivarasanivattanikam kammam karoti, devasobhagyasamvattanikam kammam karoti, manussasobhagyasamvattanikam kammam karotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3- Atthi Arahato puhhiipacayo ti ? Amanta. Araha acinatiti 3 ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Araha apacinatiti 4 ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Araha pajahatiti 5 — pe — Araha upadiyatiti ^ — pe — Araha visinetiti 7 — pe — Araha ussinetiti — pe — Araha vidhupetiti — pe — Araha sandhiipetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — I Arahato, P.S. ^ anahiiabhi°, S. ; anafij°, M. 3 bhavInatthTti, P.S. 4 apaclnatinti, P. ; apacinatthlti, S. 5 pacatiti, P.S. ^ na upadiyatiti, P.S. 7 vicio, P.S. XVII. 2.1 KATHAVATTHU. 543 Nanu Araha nev'acinati na apacinati apacinitva thito ti ?_ Amanta. Hanci Araha nev'acinati na apacinati apacinitva thito, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi Arahato puhhupacayo ti." Nanu Araha neva pajahati na upadiyati pajahitva thito, n'eva visineti na ussineti visinetva thito, n'eva vidhupeti na sandhiipeti vidhupetva thito ti '? Amanta. Hanci Araha neva vidhiipeti na sandhiipeti vidhiipetva thito, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi Arahato punhupacayo ti." 4. N' atthi Arahato piiiiniipacayo ti ? Amanta. Araha danam dadeyyati ? Amanta. Hanci Araha danam dadeyya, no vata re vattabbe "N'atthi Arahato pmihupacayo ti." Araha civaram dadeyya — pe — pindapatam dadeyya, senasanam dadeyya, gilanapaccayabhesajjaparikkharam dadeyya, khadanlyam dadeyya, bhojaniyain dadeyya, panlyam dadeyya, cetiyam vandeyya, cetiye malam aropeyya, gandharn aropeyya, vilepanam aropeyya — pe — cetiyam abhidakkhinam kareyyati ? Amanta. Hanci Araha cetiyam abhidakkhinam kareyya, no vata re vattabbe " N' atthi Arahato puhhupacayo ti." Atthi Arahato puhhupacayo t i Iv a t h a. XVII. 2. 1. N 'atthi Arahato akalamaccuti ? Amanta. N 'atthi Arahantaghatako ti '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Atthi Arahantaghatako ti ? Amanta. 544 KATHAVATTHU. [XVII. 2. Atthi Arahato akalamaccuti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. N' atthi Arahato akalamaccuti ? Anianta. A'o Arahantam jivita voropeti, sati jivite jivitavasese jivita. voropeti, asati jivite jivitavasese jivita voropetiti ^ ? Sati jivite jivitavasese jivita voropetiti. Hanoi sati jivite jivitavasese jivita voropeti, no vata re vattabbe " N'atthi Arahato akalamaccuti." Asati jivite jivitavasese jivita voropetiti, n'atthi Arahan- taghatako ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. N'atthi Arahato akalamaccuti ? Amanta. Arahato kaye visam na kameyya, sattham na kameyya, aggi na kameyyati '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu Arahato kaye visam kameyya, sattham kameyya, aggi kameyyati '? Amanta. Hahci Arahato kaye visam kameyya, sattham kameyya, aggi kameyya, no vata re vattabbe "N'atthi Arahato akalamaccuti." 4. Arahato kaye visain na kameyya, sattham na kameyya, aggi na kameyyati ? Amanta. N'atthi Arahantaghatako ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Atthi Arahato akalamaccuti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Naham Bhikkhave sahce- tanikanam kammanam katanam upacitanam appatisamve- ditva byantibhavamvadami, tan ca kho ditth'eva dhamme tippajje^ va apare va pariyaye ti.3 " Atth'eva suttanto ti? °peti, M. 2 uppajjam, P.S. ; upapajje, K. 3 pariyayehi, P. XVII. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 545 Anianta. Teha hi n'atthi Arahato akalamaccuti. N ' a 1 1 h i Arahato akalamaccuti hatha. XVII. 3. 1. Sabhaiii idani kanimato ti V Anianta. Kammaip pi kanimato ti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sabbam idaiu kanimato ti ? Amanta. Sabbam idam pnbbekatahetuti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Sabbam idam kammato ti ? Anianta. Sabbain idani kammavipakato ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Sabbani idam kammavipakato ti ? Amanta. Kammavipakena panani haneyyati '? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Panatipato saphalo ti ? Amanta. Kammavipako saphalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kammavipako aphalo ti ? Anianta. Panatipato aphalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Kammavipakena adinnam ildiyeyya — pe — nnisa bhaneyya, pismiani bhaneyya, pharusam bhaneyya, sani- phappalapeyya, sandhim chindeyya, nillopam harey- ya, ekagarikain kareyya, paripanthe tittheyya, parada- ram gaccheyya, gamaghatani kareyya, nioamaghritain kareyya, kammavipakena danaiu dadeyya, clvarain 36 ' . " 546 KATHAVATTHU> [XVII. 4. dadeyya, pindapatam dadeyya, senasanam dadeyya, gilanapaccayabhesajjaparikkharain dadeyyati ? Anianta. Gilanapaccayabhesajjaparikkharo saphalo ti ? Amanta. Kammavipako saphalo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Kammavipako aphalo ti ? Amanta. Gilanapaccayabhesajjaparikkharo aphalo ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Na vattabbam " Sabbam idam karamato ti " '? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Kammnna ^ vattati loko kammuna vattati paja Kammanibandhana satta rathassaniva ^ yayato. Kammena kittim 3 labhate pasamsam, Kammena janim 4 ca vadhan ca bandham, Tam kammam nanakaranam viditva Kasma vade n'atthi 5 kamman ti loke ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi sabbam idain kammato ti. Sabbam idam k a m m a t o t i k a t h a . XVII. 4. 1. Indriyabaddhafi iieva dukkhan ti ? Amanta. Indriyabaddhah neva aniccam samkhatam paticca- I kammanam, P.S. ^j-apassani, S. ; rathasanl, P. skitti, P. -^jati, P. ; janam, M. ; nati, S. s vedanatthi, P.; vadenanti, S. XVII. 4.] KATHAVATTHU. 547 samiippaniiam khayadhammam vayadhammam viraga- dhammam nirodhadhamniaiu viparinamadhamman ti "? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Nanu anindriyabaddJiam aniccam samkhatam paticca- samuppannam khayadhaniinam vayadhammam viraga- dliammam nirodhadhamniaiu viparinaiiiadhainman ti "? Amanta. Hahci ail indriyabaddham — pe — viparinamadhammam, no vata re vattabbe " Indriyabaddhaii fieva diikkhaii ti." 2. Anindriyabaddham aniccam — pe — viparinama- dhammam, tail ca na ^ dukkhan ti '? Amanta. Indriyabaddham aniccam — pe — viparinamadhammam, tan ca na ^ dukkhan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Indriyabaddhain aniccam — pe — viparinamadhammain, tan ca dukkhan ti ? Amanta. Anindriyabaddham aniccam — pe — viparinamadham- mam, tail ca dukkhan ti? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — 3. Indriyabaddhaii heva dukkhan ti ? Amanta. Nanu yad aniccam tain dukkham vuttam Bhagavata, anindriyabaddham aniccan ti '} Amanta. Hahci yad aniccam tarn dukkham vuttani Bhagavata, anindriyabaddham aniccam, no vata re vattabbe " Indriya- baddhaii iieva dukkhan ti." 4. Na vattabbain " Indriyabaddhaii heva dukkhan ti " ? Amanta. Yatha indriyabaddhassa dukkhassa parihhaya Bhagavati brahmacariyam vussati, evamevain anindriyabaddhassa dukkhassa parihhaya Bhagavati brahmacariyam vussatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Yatha indriyabaddham dukkham parihhatani na puna I M. omits na. 548 KATHAVATTHU. [XVII. 5. uppajjati, evamevam anindriyabaddham dukkhaiu parin- iiatam na puna uppajjatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi iiidriyabaddhan iieva dukkhan ti. I n d r i y a b a d d h a k a t h a . XVII. 5. 1. Thapetva ariyamaggam avasesa samkhara dukkha ti? Am ant a. Dukkhasaniudayo pi diikkho ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dukkhasamudayo pi dukkho ti ? Amanta. Tln'eva ariyasaccaniti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Tin'eva ariyasaccaniti ? Amanta. Nanu cattari ariyasaccani vuttani Bhagavata — Duk- kham, Dukkhasamudayo, Dukkhanirodho, Dukkhaniro- dhagaminl patipada ti ? Amanta. Hanci cattari ariyasaccani vuttani Bhagavata — Duk- khain, Dukkhasamudayo, Dukkhanirodho, Dukkhaniro- dhagamim patipada, no vata re vattabbe " Tln'eva ariya- saccaniti." 2. Dukkhasamudayo pi dukkho ti? Amanta. Ken'atthenati? Aniccatthenati . ^ Ariyamaggo anicco ti ? Amanta. Ariyamaggo dukkho ti ? aniccatthena, M. XVII. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 549 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ariyamaggo anicco so ca na dukkho ti ? Amanta. Dukkhasamudayo anicco so ca na dukkho ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dukkhasamudayo anicco so ca dukkho ti ? Amanta. Ariyamaggo anicco so ca dukkho ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — -pe — 3. Na vattabbam " Thapetva ariyamaggam avasesa sam- khara dukkha ti " ? Amanta. Nanu sa dukkhanirodhagamini patipada ti '? Amanta. Hanoi sa dukkhanirodhagamini patipada, tena vata re vattabbe " Thapetva ariyamaggam avasesa samkhara dukkha ti." Thapetva ariyamaggan ti katha. XVII. 6. 1. Na vattabbam " Samgho dakkhinam patiganhatiti^ " '? Amanta. Nanu Samgho ahuneyyo pahuneyyo dakkhineyyo aiijahkaraniyo anuttarani puhhakkhettam lokassati? Amanta. Haiici Samgho ahuneyyo— pe — lokassa, tena vata re vattabbe " Samgho dakkhinam patiganhatiti." 2. Na vattabbam " Saingho dakkhinam patiganhatiti " ? Amanta. Nanu cattaro purisayuga, attha purisapuggala dakkhi- neyya vutta Bhagavata ti ? Amanta. Hafici cattaro purisayuga, attha purisapuggala dakkhi- -3 — " ■" ' I patiggo, P.Sa. 550 KATHAVATTHU. [XVII. 6. neyya vntta Bhagavata, tena vata re vattabbe " Samgho dakkhinam patiganhatiti. ' ' 3. Na vattabbam "Samgho dakkhinam patiganhatiti"? Anianta. Nanu atthi keci Samghassa danam dentiti ? x\manta. Hanoi atthi keci Samghassa danam denti, tena vata re vattabbe " Samgho dakkhinam patiganhatiti." Nanu atthi keci Samghassa civaram denti, pindapatam denti, senasanam denti, gilanapaccayabhesajjaparikkharam denti, khadanlyam denti, bhojaniyam denti — pe — panlyam dentiti ? Amanta. Hanoi atthi keci Samghassa civaram denti, pindapatam denti, senasanam denti, gilanapaooayabhesajjaparikkharam denti, khadanlyam denti, bhojaniyam denti — pe — panlyam denti, tena vata re vattabbe " Saingho dakkhinam patigan- hatiti." 4. Na vattabbam "Samgho dakkhinam patiganhatiti"? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Ahuti ' jatavedo va mahamegham va medinl^ Samgho samadhisampanno patiganhati dakkhinan ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi Samgho dakkhinam patiganhatiti. 5 Samgho dakkhinam patiganhatiti ? Amanta. Maggo patiganhati, phalam patigaiihatlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N a vattabbam " S a m g h o d a k k h i n a m pati- ganhatiti" katha. ''ahutim, P. ; ahati, S. ^ j^^^ej^i^^i^ p, j medanl, S.M. XVII. 7.] kj^thavatthu. 551 XVII. 7. 1. Na vattabbam " Samgho dakkhinam visodhetiti " ? Amanta. Nanii Samgho ahuneyyo pahuneyyo dakkhineyyo afijallkaraniyo anuttaram punfiakkhettam lokassati ? Amanta. Hanoi Samgho ahuneyyo — pe — lokassa, tena vata re vattabbe " Samg-ho dakkhinam visodhetiti." 2. Na vattabbam " Samgho dakkhinam visodhetiti " ? Amanta. Nanu cattaro purisayuga attha purisapuggala dakkhi- neyya vntta Bhagavata ti ? Amanta. Hahci cattaro purisayuga, attha purisapuggala dakkhi- neyya vutta Bhagavata, tena vata re vattabbe " Samgho dakkhinam visodhetiti." 3. Na vattabbam " Samgho dakkhinam visodhetiti " ? Amanta. Nanu atthi keci Samghassa danam datva dakkhinam • O • • • aradhentiti ? Amanta. Hahci atthi keci Samghassa danani datva dakkhinam aradhenti, tena vata re vattabbe " Samgho dakkhinam visodhetiti." Nanu atthi keci Samghassa civaram datva — pe — pin- dapatam datva — -pe — senasanam datva — pe — gilana- paccayabhesajjaparikkharam datva — pe — khadanlyam datva — pe — bhojanlyam datva — pe — panlyam datva dak- khinam aradhentiti ? Amanta. Hahci atthi keci Samghassa panlyam datva dakkhinam aradhenti, tena vata re vattabbe " Samgho dakkhinam visodhetiti." 4. Sanif^ho dakkhinam visodhetiti ? Amanta. 552 KATHAVATTHU. [XYII. 8. Maggo visodheti, phalam visodhetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N a V a 1 1 a b b a 111 " S a m g h o d a k k h i n a m visodhetiti" katha. XVII. 8. 1. Na vattabbam " Samgho bhufijati pivati khadati sayatiti " ? Ainanta. Nann atthi keci samghabhattani karonti, uddesabhattaiii karonti, yagupanani ^ karontiti '? Ainanta. Hafici atthi keci samghabhattani karonti, uddesabhattaiii karonti, yagupanani ^ karonti, tena vata re vattabbe " Samgho bhuhjati pivati khadati sayatiti." 2. Na vattabbam " Samgho bhuiijati pivati khadati sayatiti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata ganabhojanarn paramparabho- janam atirittabhojanam anatirittabhojanan ti ? Amanta. Hanoi vuttam Bhagavata ganabhojanain paramparabho- janani atirittabhojanam anatirittabhojanam, tena vata re vattabbe " Samgho bhuiijati pivati khadati sayatiti." 3. Na vattabbam " Samgho bhuhjati pivati khadati sayatiti " ? Amanta. Nanu attha panani vuttani Bhagavata — ambapanam jambupanam cocapanam mocapanam madhupanam mud- dikapanam salukapanani pharusakapanan ti '? Amanta. Hahci attha panani vuttani Bhagavata — ambapanam jambupanam cocapanam mocapanam madhupanam iiiud- '^ yagunapani, P. XVII. 9.] KATH-AVATTHU. 553 dikapanam salukapanam pharusakapanam, tena vata re vattabbe " Samgho bhmijati pivati khadati sayatiti." 4. Samgho bhuiijati pivati khadati sayatiti ? Am ant a. Maggo bhuiijati pivati khadati sayati, phalam bhm~ijati pivati khadati sayatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N a V a 1 1 a b b a 111 " S a iii g h o b h ii h j a 1 1 1 i " k a t h a. XYII. 9. 1. Na vattabbam " Saiiighassa diniiam mahapphalan ti"V Amanta. Nanu Samgho ahuiieyyo pahimeyyo dakkliiiieyyo aiijahkaraiilyo anuttaram puhiiakkhettam lokassati '? Amanta. Hafici Samgho ahuneyyo — pe — lokassa, tena vata re vattabbe " Saiiighassa dinnani mahapphalan ti." 2. Na vattabbain " Saiiighassa dinnam mahapphalan ti"? Amanta. Nanu cattaro purisayuga, attha purisapuggala dak- khineyya vutta Bhagavata ti '? Amanta. Hahci cattaro purisayuga, attha purisapuggala dak- khineyya vutta Bhagavata, tena vata re vattabbe " Saiiighassa dinnam mahapphalan ti." 3. Na vattabbain " Saiiighassa dinnam mahapphalan ti"? Amanta. Nanu vuttaiu Bhagavata — " Sanighe Gotanil dehi,i Saiiighe te diniie ahan c'eva pfijito bhavissami Samgho cati." ' deti. M. 554 KATHAVATTHU. [XVII. 9. Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amaiita. Tena hi Samghassa dinnam mahapphalan ti. 4. Na vattabbam " Samghassa dinnam mahapphalan ti'y? Amanta. Nanu Sakko devanam indo Bhagavantam etad avoca — " Yajamananam manussanam pmihapekhanapaninam ^ Karotain ^ opadhikam 3 pmiham kattha dinnam mahap- phalan ti." " Cattaro ca patipanna cattaro ca phale thita Esasamgho ujubhuto pahiiasllasamahito. Yajamananain manussanain pmihapekhanapaninam Karotain opadhikani pnhham Samghe dinnam mahap- phalan ti." " Eso hi Samgho vipulo mahaggato Esappameyyo udadhlva sagaro Ete hi settha naravlrasavaka 4 Pabhahkara dhammam udlrayan ti.5 Tesam sudinnam suhutam suyittham Ye samgham uddissa ^ dadanti danam Sa dakkhina Samghagata patitthita Mahapphala lokaviduna 7 vannita ^ ^r^ Etadisam yahham anussaranta 9 Ye vcdajuta '° viharanti " loke - Vineyya maccheram alam samalain ^^ Anindita saggam upenti thanan ti." ^ puhhasekli°, M. ^ karontam, P. 3 opacitam, P.M.S.Sa- 4 nivirayasavaka, M. ; naraviriyasavaka, P.S.Sa. 5 dhamma mudirayan ti, M. samghassa muddissa, P.Sa; samghassa muditta, S. 7 lokavidmia, M. ^ vannita, S. 9 odanta, S. ^° ye'va jata, S. ; ce da jata°, P. ^' vicaranti, K. ^^ vineyya malam samnla, 8. XVII. 10.] IliATHAVATTHU. 555 Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Anianta. Tena hi Samghassa dinnam mahapphalan ti. N a V a 1 1 a b b a m " S a in g h a s s a d i n n a ni mahap- phalan t i " k a 1 1 1 a . XVII. 10. 1. Na vattabbam " Buddhassa dinnam mahapphalan ti"? Amanta. Nann Bhagava dipadanam ^ aggo, dipadanam settho, dipadanam pamokkho, dipadanam uttamo, dipadanam pavaro asamo asamasamo appatisamo appatibhago appatipuggalo ti ? Amanta. Hanci Bhagava dipadanam aggo, dipadanam settho, dipadanam pamokkho, dipadanam uttamo, dipadanam pavaro asamo asamasamo appatisamo appatibhago appati- puggalo, tena vata re vattabbe " Buddhassa dinnam mahapphalan ti." 2. Na vattabbam " Buddhassa dinnani mahapphalan ti"? ' ' Amanta. Atthi keci Buddhena samasamo sllena samadhina panhayati ? N' atthi. Hahci n'atthi keci Buddhena samasamo sllena sama- dhina panhaya, tena vata re vattabbe " Buddhassa dinnam mahapphalan ti." 3. Na vattabbam " Buddhassa dinnain mahapphalan ti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Nayimasmiin va loke ^ dvipadanam, M. 556 KATHAVATTHU. [XVII. 11. parasmim va pana ^ Buddhena settho ca ^ samo ca vijjati,3 yamahuneyyanam 4 aggatam gato, punnattikanam vipulaphalesinan s ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi Buddhassa dinnam mahapphalan ti. N a V a 1 1 a b b a in "Buddhassa dinnam mahap- phalan t i " k a t h a . XVII. 11. 1. Dayakato va danam visujjhati, no patiggahakato ti? Amanta. Nanu atthi keci patiggahaka ahmieyya pahmieyya dakkhineyya aiijah'karaniya anuttaram pmihakkhettam lokassati ? Amanta. Hahci atthi keci patiggahaka ahmieyya pahuneyya dakkhineyya ahjalikaraniya anuttaram puhhakkhettam lokassa, no vata re vattabbe " Dayakato va danam visujjhati, no patiggahakato ti." 2. Dayakato va danam visujjhati, no patiggahakato ti ? Amanta. Nanu cattaro purisayuga attha purisapuggala dak- khineyya vutta Bhagavata ti ? Amanta. Haiici cattaro purisayuga attha purisapuggala dak- khineyya vutta Bhagavata, no vata re vattabbe "Dayakato va danam visujjhati, no patiggahakato ti." 8. Dayakato va danam visujjhati, no patiggahakato ti '? Amanta. ^ puna, M. 2 After ca P. inserts na. 3 vijjhati, M. 4 yatha ahunveyyanam, M. 5 °sinan ti, M. XVII. 11. j KATHAVATTHU. 557 Nanu atthi keci sotapanne ^ danam datva dakkhinain aradhentiti ? Amanta. Hanoi atthi keci sotapanne danam datva dakkhinain aradhenti, no vata re vattabbe " Dayakato va danam visnjjhati, no patiggahakato ti." Nanu atthi keci sakadagamissa — pe — anagamissa — pe — Arahato danain datva dakkhinain aradhentiti ? Amanta. Hahci atthi keci Arahato danain datva dakkhinain aradhenti, no vata re vattabbe "Dayakato va danam visujjhati, no patiggahakato ti." 4. Patiggahakato danain visujjhatTti ? Amanta. Anno ahhassa karako, parakatam sukhadukkham, ahfio karoti ahfio patisamvedetiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dayakato va danam visujjhati, na patiggahakato ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Catasso kho im' Ananda dakkhina visuddhiyo. Katama catasso ? Atth' Ananda dakkhina dayakato visujjhati no patiggahakato, atth' Ananda dakkhina patiggahakato visujjhati no dayakato, atth' Ananda dakkhina dayakato c'eva visujjhati patig- gahakato ca, atth' Ananda dakkhina n'eva dayakato visujjhati no patiggahakato. Ima kho Ananda catasso dakkhina visuddhiyo ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Dayakato va danam visujjhati, no patiggahakato ti." Dakkhina v i s u d d h i k a t h a . °panna, M. 558 KATHAVATTHU. [XVII. 11. V a c: g; o s a 1 1 a r a s a m o . f5 t) Atthi Arahato pufinnpacayo, N'atthi Arahato akalaniaccu, Sabbam idam kamiiiato, Indriyabaddhan neva dnkkham, Thapetva ariyainaggam avasesa saiukhara dukkha, Samgho dakkhinani patiganhati, Saiiigho dakkhinam visodheti, Samgho bhuiijati pivati khadati sayati, Samghassa dinnam mahapphalam, Atthi danam visuddhiya ti. XVIII. 1.^ KATHAVATTHU. 559 XVIII. 1. 1. Na vattabbam " Buddho Bhagava manussaloke atthasiti " ? Amanta. Nanu atthi Buddhavuttani "^ cetiyani aramaviharagama- nigamanagarani ratthani janapadanlti ? Amanta. Hanci atthi Buddhavuttani cetiyani aramaviharagania- nigamanagarani ratthani janapadani, tena vata re vattabbe " Buddho Bhagava manussaloke atthasiti." 2. Na vattabbam "Buddho Bliagava manussaloke atthasiti ' ' ? Amanta. Nanu Bhagava Lumbiniya - jato, Bodhiya mule abhisam- buddho, Baranasiyam Bhagavata Dhammacakkam pavat- titam, Capale 3 cetiye ayusamkharo ossattho, Kusinarayam Bhagava parinibbuto ti ? Amanta. Hanoi Bhagava Lumbiniya jato, B(Klhiya mille abhisam- buddho, Baranasiyain Bhagavata Dhammacakkam pavat- titam, Capale cetiye ayusamkharo ossattho, Kusinarayain Bhagava parinibbuto, tena vata re vattabbe "Buddho Bhagava manussaloke atthasiti." 3. Na vattabbam " Buddho Bhagava manussaloke atthasiti ' ' '? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Ekani idaham Bhikkhave samayam Ukkatthayam viharami Subhagavane salaraja- mtile ti, ekam idaham Bhikkhave samayam Uruvelayain viharami Ajapalanigrodhe pathamabhisainbuddho ti, ekam idahain Bhikkhave samayam Eajagahe viharami Veluvane Kalandakanivape ti, ekam idaham Bhikkhave samayam Savatthiyain viharami Jetavane Anfithapindikassa arame I vutthani, K. ^ Lamo, P. 3 Tapale, P. ; Catapale, 8. ; Pavale, K. 560 ICATHAVATTHU. [XVIII. '2. ti, ekam idaham Bhikkliave samayam Vesaliyam viharami Mahavane kutagarasalayan ^ ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi Buddho Bhagava manussaloke atthaslti. 4. Buddho Bhagava manussaloke atthaslti ? Amanta. Nanu Bhagava loke jato loke sambuddho lokam abhi- bhuyya viharati anupahtto lokenati '? Amanta. Hahci Bhagava loke jato loke sambuddho lokam abhi- bhuyya viharati anupalitto lokena, no vata re vattabbe "Buddho Bhagava manussaloke atthaslti." Manussalokakatha. XVIII. -2. 1. Na vattabbam " Buddhena Bhagavata Dhammo desito ti " ? Amanta. Kena desito ti ? Abhinimmitena desito ti. Abhinimmito Jino Sattha Sammasambuddho Sabbahhu Sabbadassavl DhammasamI Dhammapatisarano ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Na vattabbain " Buddhena Bhagavata Dhammo desito ti " ? Amanta. Kena desito ti "? Ayasmata Anandena desito ti. Ayasma Anando Jino 8attha — pe — Dhammapatisarano ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Na vattabbam " Buddhena Bhagavata Dhammo desito ti"? Amanta, . ^ ' Kuttlia°, M. XVIII. 8. J KATHAVATTHU. 561 Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Samkhittena pi kho aham Sariputta dhamniam deseyyam, vittharena pi kho ahain Sariputta dhaniinam deseyyam, samkhittavittharena pi kho aham Sariputta dhammam deseyyam, amiataro va dullabha ^ ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi Buddhena Bhagavata Dhammo desito ti. 4. Na vattabbam " Buddhena Bhagavata Dhammo desjto ti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " iVbhihhayaham Bhikkhave Dhammam desemi no anabhihhaya, sanidanaham Bhik- khave Dhammam desemi no anidanam, sappatihariyaham Bhikkhave Dhammam desemi no appatihariyam, yaii c'assa^ mayham Bhikkhave abhihhaya Dhammam desayato no anabhihhaya, sanidanam Dhammam desayato no anida- nam, sappatihariyam Dhammam desayato no appatihari- yam karaniyo ovado karaniyo anusasani, alaii ca pana vo Bhikkhave tutthiya,3 alam attamanataya, alam somanas- saya Sammasambuddho Bhagava, svakhyato4 Dhammo suppatipanno Samgho ti. Imasmim ca pana veyyakaranasmim bhahhamane dasasahassi lokadhatu akampittha ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi Buddhena Bhagfavata Dhammo desito ti. D h a m m a d e s a n a k a t h a XVIII. 3. 1. N'atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karuna ti ? Amanta. N'atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato metta ti '? I duUabho, P.Sa. ^ K. reads tassa for yah c'assa. 3 °yo, P. 4 svakkhato, P.S. 37 562 KATHAVATTHU. [XVIII. 3. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N'atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karuna ti'? Aixianta. N'atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato mudita — pe — upekkha ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato metta ti ? Amanta. Atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karuna ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato mudita — pe — upekkha ti ? Amanta. Atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karuna ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. N'atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karuna ti ? Amanta. Bhagava akaruniko ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu Bhagava karuniko lokahito lokanukampako lokatthacaro ^ ti ? Amanta. Hanoi Bhagava karuniko lokahito lokanukampako lokatthacaro, no vata re vattabbe "N'atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karuna ti." 4. N'atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karuna ti ? Amanta. Nanu Bhagava mahakaruna samapattim ^ samapajjiti ? Amanta. Hafici Bhagava mahakaruna samapattim samapajji, no vata re vattabbe "N'atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karuna ti." 5. Atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karuna ti ? Amanta. Bhagava sarago ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — • Tena hi n'atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karuna ti. K a r u n a k a t h a . I lokattacarano, P.S. - opatti, P.S. XVIII. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 563 XVIII. 4. 1. Biiddhassa Bhagavato uccarapassavo ativiya anile ^andhajate adhiganhatiti '? Amanta. Bhagava gandhabhoj! ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nann Bhagava odanakmnmasam ^ bhuiijatlti '> xlmanta. Haiici Bhagava odanakummasam bhunjati, no vata re vattabbe " Buddhassa Bhagavato uccarapassavo ativiya aiihe gandhajate adhiganhatiti." 2. Buddhassa Bhagavato uccarapassavo ativiya aiihe gandhajate adhiganhatiti '? Amanta. Atthi keci Buddhassa Bhagavato uccarapassavam nahayanti - vihnipenti 3 uccarenti, pelaya patisainenti, karandaya nikkhipenti, apane pasarenti,4 tena ca gandhena gandhakaranlyam karontiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — G a n d h a j a t i k a t h a . XVIII. 5. 1. Ekena ariyamaggena cattari samahhaphalani sacchi- karotiti ? Amanta. Catunnani phassanam — pe — catunnam sannanam samo- dhanam hotiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ekena ariyamaggena cattari samahhaphalani sacchi- karotlti ? Amanta. ^ °kumasam, M. 2 nhayo, M.K. 3 viHpanti, M.K. 4 passarenti, M. 564 KATHAVATTHU. [XVIII. 5. Sotapattimaggo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sakadagami — pe — anagaminiaggo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kataniena maggenati '? Araliattamaggenati. Arahattamaggena sakkayaditthim vicikiccham sllabba- taparaniasam jahatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahattamaggena sakkayaditthim vicikiccham sllabba- taparamasam jahatiti ? Amanta. Nanii tinnam saiiiiojananam pahanam sotapattiphalam vuttam Bhagavata ti ? Amanta. Hahci tinnam saiiiiojananam pahanam sotapattiphalam vuttam Bhagavata, no vata re vattabbe " Arahattamag- gena sakkayaditthiin vicikicchain silabbataparamasam jahatiti." •2. Arahattamagoena olarikam kamaraoam olarikam byapadam jahatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahattamaggena olarikam kamaragam olarikam byapadam jahatiti ? Amanta. Nanu kamaragabyapadanam tanubhavam ^ sakadagami- phalam vuttam Bhagavata ti ? Amanta. Haiici kamaragabyapadanam tanubhavam sakadagami- phalam vuttam Bhagavata, no vata re vattabbe "Arahat- tamaggena olarikain kamaragam olarikam byapadam jahatiti." 3. Arahattamaggena anusahagatam kamaragam anusa- hagatam byapadam jahatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahattamaggena anusahagataiii kamaragam anusaha- gatam byapadam jahatiti ? I patanuo, P. So. XVIII. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 565 Amanta. Nanu kamaragabyapadanam anavasesappahanam ana- gamiphalam vuttam Bhagavata ti ? Amanta. Hanci kamaragabyapadanam anavasesappahanam ana- gamiphalain vuttam Bhagavata, no vatare vattabbe " Ara- hattamaggena anusahagatam kamaragam anusahagatam byapadam jahatlti." 4. Na vattabbain "Ekena ariyamaggena cattari saman- naphalani sacchikarotlti " ? Amanta. Bhagavata sotapattimaggo bhavito ti '? Amanta. Bhagava sotapanno ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Bhagavata sakadagami^pe — anagamimaggo bhavito ti? Amanta. Bhagava anagami ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Bhagava ekena ariyamaggena cattari samahhapha- lani sacchikaroti, savaka catuhi ariyamaggehi cattari samahhaphalani sacchikarontiti ? Amanta. Savaka Buddhassa Bhagavato adittham dakkhinti/ anadhigatam adhigacchanti, asacchikatam sacchikaronti- ti? ' Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — E k a m a g g a k a t h a . XVIII. 6. 1. Jhana jhanain samkamatiti? Amanta. dakkhanti, M.K. 566 KATHAVATTHU. [XVIII. 6. Pathama jhana ^ tatiyam jhanam samkamatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Jhana jhanam samkamatiti ? Am ant a. Dutiya jhana catuttham jhanam samkamatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Pathama jhana dntiyam jhanam samkamatiti'? Amanta. Ya pathamassa jhanassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhi, sa va dutiyassa jhanassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Pathama jhana dutiyam jhanam samkamati, na vat- tabbam " Ya pathamassa jhanassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhi, sa va dutiyassa jhanassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhiti " V Amanta. Dutiyam jhanain anavattantassa uppajjati — pe — apani- dahantassa uppajjatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu dutiyain jhanam avattantassa uppajjati — pe — panidahantassa uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Hanoi dutiyam jhanam avattantassa uppajjati — pe — panidahantassa uppajjati, no vata re vattabbe " Pathama jhana dutiyam jhanam samkamatiti." 8. Pathama jhana dutiyain jhanam samkamatiti ? Amanta. Pathamam jhanam kame adinavato ~ manasikaroto uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Dutiyam jhanam kame adinavato manasikaroto uppaj- jatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Pathamam jhanain savitakkam savicaran ti ? pathamajjhana, P.S.Sg. ^ adi°, M. XVIII. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 567 Amanta. Dutiyam jhanam savitakkam savicaran ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Pathama jliana dutiyam jhanam samkamatlti ? Amanta. Tan neva pathamam jhanam tarn dutiyam jhanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Dutiya jhana tatiyam jhanam samkamatlti '? Amanta. Ya dutiyassa jhanassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhi, sa va tatiyassa jhanassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dutiya jhana tatiyam jhanam samkamati, na vat- tabbam " Ya dutiyassa jhanassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhi, sa va tatiyassa jhanassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhiti " '? Amanta. Tatiyam jhanam anavattantassauppajjati^pe — apanida- hantassa uppajjatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu tatiyam jhanam avattantassa uppajjati — -pe — pani- dahantassa uppajjatiti '? Amanta. Hahci tatiyam jhanam avattantassa uppajjati — pe — panidahantassa uppajjati, no vata re vattabbe " Dutiya. jhana tatiyam jhanam sainkamatiti." 5. Dutiya jhana tatiyam jhanam samkamatlti? Amanta. Dutiyam jhanain vitakkavicare adinavato manasikarota uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Tatiyam jhanam vitakkavicare adinavato manasikarota uppajjatiti'? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dutiyam jhanam sappitikan ti ? Amanta. Tatiyaiu jhclnani sappitikan ti ? ■568 KATHAVATTHU. [XVIII. 6. Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dutiya jhana tatiyam jhanam samkaiiiatiti ? Amanta. Tan neva dutiyam jhanam tarn tatiyam jhanan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— 6. Tatiya jhana catuttham jhanam samkamatiti ? Amanta. Ya tatiyassa jhanassa uppadaya avattanji — pe — panidhi, sa va catutthassa jhanassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tatiya jhana catuttham jhanam samkamati, na vat- tabbam " Ya tatiyassa jhanassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhi, sa va catutthassa jhanassa uppadaya avattana — pe — panidhiti " "? Amanta. Catutthana jhanam anavattantassa uppajjati — pe — apani- •dahantassa uppajjatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu catuttham jhanam avattantassa uppajjati — pe — panidahantassa uppajjatiti ? Amanta. Haiici catuttham jhanam avattantassa uppajjati — pe — panidahantassa uppajjati, no vata re vattabbe " Tatiya jhana catuttham jhanam samkamatiti." 7. Tatiya jhana catuttham jhanam samkamatiti '? Amanta. Tatiyam jhanain pitim ^ admavato manasikaroto uppaj- jatiti ? Amanta. Catuttham jhanam pItim admavato manasikaroto uppaj- jatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tatiyam jhanam sukhasahagatan ti ? Amanta. ' Catuttham jhanam sukhasahagatan ti ? ^ piti, P.S2. XVIII. 7.] KATHAVATTHU. 569 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tatiya jhana catuttham jhanam samkamatlti ? Amanta. Tan neva tatiyam jhanam tarn catuttham jhanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 8. Na vattabbam " Jhana jhanam samkamatlti " ? Amanta. Nann vuttam Bhagavata "Idha Bhikkhave bhikkhu vivicc'eva kamehi — pe — catntthain jhanam npasampajja viharatiti." Atth'eva snttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi jhana jhanam samkamatlti. J h a n a s a m k a n t i k a t h a . XVIII. 7. 1. Atthi jhanantarika ti ? Amanta. Atthi phassantarika — pe — atthi sahhantarika ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi jhanantarika ti '? Amanta. Dutiyassa ca jhanassa tatiyassa ca jhanassa antare atthi jhanantarika ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Atthi jhanantarika ti ? Amanta. Tatiyassa ca jhanassa catutthassa ca jhanassa antare atthi jhanantarika ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Dutiyassa ca jhanassa tatiyassa ca jhanassa antare n' atthi jhanantarika ti ? Amanta. Hahci dutiyassa ca jhanassa tatiyassa ca jhanassa antare 570 KATHAVATTHU. [XYIII. 7. n'atthi jhanantarika, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi jhanan- tarika ti." Tatiyassa ca jhanassa catutthassa ca jhanassa antare n'atthi jhanantarika ti ? Amanta. Hahci tatiyassa ca jhanassa catutthassa ca jhanassa antare n'atthi jhanantarika, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi jhanantarika ti." 3. Pathamassa ca jhanassa dutiyassa ca jhanassa antare atthi jhanantarika ti '? Amanta. Dutiyassa ca jhanassa tatiyassa ca jhanassa antare atthi jhanantarika ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Pathamassa ca jhanassa dutiyassa ca jhanassa antare atthi jhanantarika ti '? Amanta. Tatiyassa ca jhanassa catutthassa ca jhanassa antare atthi jhanantarika ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Dutiyassa ca jhanassa tatiyassa ca jhanassa antare n'atthi jhanantarika ti '? Amanta. Pathamassa ca jhanassa dutiyassa ca jhanassa antare n'atthi jhanantarika ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tatiyassa ca jhanassa catutthassa ca jhanassa antare n'atthi jhanantarika ti '? Amanta. Pathamassa ca jhanassa dutiyassa ca jhanassa antare n'atthi jhanantarika ti? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 5. Avitakko vicaramatto samadhi jhanantarika ti ? Amanta. Savitakko savicaro samadhi jhanantarika ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Avitakko vicaramatto samadhi jhanantarika ti ? Amanta. XVIII. 7. J KATHAVATTHU. 571. Avitakko avicaro samadhi jhanantarika ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Savitakko savicaro sainadhi na jhanantarika ti ? Amanta. Avitakko vicaraniatto sainadhi na jhanantarika ti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Avitakko avicaro sainadhi na jhanantarika ti ? Amanta. Avitakko vicaramatto samadhi na jhanantarika ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Dvinnam jhananam patupannanam ^ antare avitakko vicaramatto samadhlti ? Amanta. Nanu avitakke vicaramatte samadhimhi vattamane pathamam jhanam niruddham, dutiyam jhanam anu- pannan ^ ti ? Amanta. Hahci avitakke vicaramatte samadhimhi vattamane pathamam jhanam niruddham, dutiyam jhanam anu- pannam, no vata re vattabbe " Dvinnam jhananam patup- pannanam antare avitakko vicaramatto samadhlti." 8. Avitakko vicaramatto sainadhi na jhanantarika ti ? Amanta. Avitakko vicaramatto sainadhi pathamam jhanam — pe — dutiyam jhanam — pe — tatiyam jhanam — pe — catuttham jhanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi avitakko vicaramatto samadhi jhanantarika ti. 9. Avitakko vicaramatto sainadhi jhanantarika ti ? Amanta. Nanu tayo sainadhi vutta Bhagavata — savitakko savi- caro samadhi, avitakko vicaramatto sainadhi, avitakko avicaro samadhlti ? Amanta. Hahci tayo samadhi — pe — avicaro samadhi, no vata re 1 patipaniiclnam, P.S2. ; paccuppannruiain, Attb. 2 patuo, M. 572 KATHAVATTHU. [XVIII. 8. vattabbe " Avitakko vicaraniatto samadhi jhanantarika ti." J h a n a n t a r i k a k a t h a . XVIII. M. 1. Samapanno saddam sunatlti? Amanta. Samapanno cakkliuna rupam passati — pe — sotena — pe — ghanena — pe— jivhaya — pe — kayena photthabbam phusa- titi ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samapanno saddam siinatiti ? Amanta. SotavinnanasamangI samapanno ti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — Xanu samadhi manovihhanasamahgissati '? Amanta. Hanoi samadhi manovihhanasamangissa, no vata re vattabbe " Samapanno saddam sunatlti." 2. Samadhi manovifmanasamahgissa sotavihhanasa- mahgi saddam smiatlti ? Amanta. Hahci samadhi manoviilhanasamahgissa sotaviiihana- samahgl saddam sunati, no vata re vattabbe " Samapanno saddam smiatlti . ' ' Samadhi manoviniianasamahgissa sotavihiianasamahgl saddam sunatlti ? Amanta. Dvinnain phassanam — pe — dvinnarn cittanain samodha- nam hotiti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Xa vattabbam " Samapanno saddam sunatlti " ? Amanta. X'anu pathamassa jhanassa saddo kantako ^ vutto Bha- gavata ti ? I kandako, M. XVIII. 9.] ILiTHAVATTHU. 573 Anianta. Hanoi pathamassa jhanassa saddo kantako vutto Bhaga- vata, tena vata re vattabbe " Samapanno saddain suiia- titi." Pathamassa jhanassa saddo kantako vutto Bhao-avata ti, samapanno saddam smiatiti "? Amanta. Dutiyassa jhanassa vitakko vicaro kantako vutto Bha- gavata, atthi tassa vitakkavicara ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Pathamassa jhanassa saddo kantako vutto Bhagavata ti, samapanno saddam sunatiti ? Amanta. Tatiyassa jhanassa piti kantako, catutthassa jhanassa assasapassaso kantako, akasanahcayatanam samapannassa rupasahha kantako, vihhanahcayatanam samapannassa aka- sanahcayatanasahiia kantako, akihcahhayatanam samapan- nassa vifihanahcayatanasaiiha kantako, nevasaiihanasaiiha- yatanam samapannassa akihcahhayatanasafina kantako, sahnavedayitanirodham samapannassa sahha ca vedana ca kantako vutto Bhagavata, atthi tassa sanha ca vedana cati? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Saddam sunatiti k a t h a . XVIII. 9. 1. Cakkhuna rupani passatiti ^ ? Amanta. Rupena rupam passatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Eupena rupam passatiti ? Amanta. Rupena rupam pativijilnatlti? I phassatiti, P, 574 KATHAVATTHU. [XVIII. 9. Nca h'evam vattabbe^ — pe — Kupena rupam pativijanatiti ? Amanta. Eupam manovinnanan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Cakkhuna rupam passatiti ? Amanta. Atthi cakkhussa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Nanu n'atthi cakkhussa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Hanci n'atthi cakkhussa avattana — pe — panidhi, no vata re vattabbe " Cakkhuna rupam passatiti." 3. Sotena saddam sunatiti — pe — ghanena gandham ghayatiti — pe — jivhaya rasam sayatiti — pe — kayena phot- thabbam phusatiti '? Amanta. Rupena rupam phusatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Eupena rupam phusatiti ? Amanta. Eupena rupam pativijanatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Eupena rupam pativijanatiti ? Amanta. Eupam manovinnanan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Kayena photthabbam phusatiti ? Amanta. Atthi kayassa avattana — pe — panidhiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu n'atthi kayassa avattana — pe — panidhiti '? Amanta. Hahci n'atthi kayassa avattana — pe — panidhi, no vata re vattabbe " Kayena photthabbam phusatiti." 5. Na vattabbain " Cakkhuna rupam passatiti — pe — kayena photthabbam phusatiti " ? Amanta. XVIII. 9.] KATHAVATTHU. 575 Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Idha Bliikkhave bliikkhu cakkhuna rupam passati— pe — kayena photthabbam phusatlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi cakkhuna rupam passatlti — pe — kayena phot- thabbam phusatlti. Cakkhuna rupam passatlti k a t h a . Vaggo attharasamo. Buddho Bhagava manussaloke atthasi, Buddhena Bhagavata Dhammo desito, N'atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karuna, Buddhassa Bhagavato uccarapassavo ativiya ahiie gan- dhajate adhiganhati, Ekena ariyamaggena cattari samahhaphalani sacchika- roti, Jhana jhanam samkamati, Atthi jhanantarika, Samapanno saddam sunati, Cakkhuna rupam passati, Kayena photthabbam phusatlti. 576 KATHAVATTHU. [XIX. 1.. XIX. 1. 1. AtTte kilese jahatiti ? Amanta. Niruddham nirodheti, vigatam vigameti, khlnam khepeti, atthaiigatam ^ atthangameti, abbhatthangatam abbhat- thangametiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atite kilese jahatiti? x4.manta. Nanu atltam niruddhan ti ? Amanta. Hanci atitam niruddham, no vata re vattabbe " Atite kilese jahatiti." Atite kilese jahatiti ? Amanta. Nanu atltam n'atthiti ? Amanta. Hanoi atltam n'atthi, no vata re vattabbe " Atite kilese jahatiti." 2. Anagate kilese jahatiti? • Amanta. Ajatam ajaneti, asahjatam asahjaneti, anibbattam anib- battati, apatubhutam apatubhavetiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Anagate kilese jahatiti? Amanta. Nanu anagatam ajatan ti ? Amanta. Hahci anagatam ajatam, no vata re vattabbe "Anagate kilese jahatiti." Anagate kilese jahatiti ? Amanta. Nanu anagatam n'atthiti ? Amanta. Haiici anagatam n'atthi, no vata re vattabbe " Anagate kilese iahatlti." ^ atthagatam, P. XIX. l.J KATHAVATTHU. 577 8. Paccuppanne kilese jahatiti ? Amanta. Ratto ragain jahati, duttho dosam jahati, mulho moham jahati, kilittho kilese jahatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ragena ragam jahati, dosena dosaru jahati, mohena moham jahati, kilesehi kilese jahatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Rago cittasampayutto, maggo cittasampayutto ti ? Amanta. Dvinnam phassanam — pe — dvinnarn cittanaiii samo- dhanam hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Rago akusalo, maggo kusalo ti ? Amanta. Kusalakusala savajjanavajja hinappanlta kanhasukka- sappatibhaga dhamma sammukhlbhavam agacchantlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kusalakusala savajjanavajja ?ilnappanlta kanhasukka- sappatibhaga dhamma sammukhlbhavam agacchantlti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttarp Bhagavata — " Cattar'imani Bhikkhave suviduravidurani. Katamani cattari ? Nabhah ca Bhik- khave pathavl ca, idaiii patharaam suviduravidurani — pe — tasma satam dhammo asabbhi arakati." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Kusalakusala — pe — agacchan- tlti." 4. Na vattabbaiu " Atlte anagate paccuppanne kilese jahatiti " ? Amanta. N'atthi kilesajahana ' ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi atlte anagate paccuppanne kilese jahatiti. K i 1 e s a j a h a n a Iv a t h a . ^ kilese jahatiti, M. ; kilesajahatlti, P.S. ; kilesajahana, Attho. m 578 KATHAVATTHU. [XTX. 2. XIX. 2. 1. Sufinata samkarakkliandliapariyapanna ti ? Amanta. Animittam samkharakkhandhapariyapannan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sunnata samkharakkhandhapariyapanna ti '? Amanta. Appanihito samkharakkhandhapariyapanno ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Animittam na vattabbam " samkharakkhandhapari- yapannan ti " ? Amanta. Sunnata na vattabba " samkharakkhandhaparij^apanna ti " ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Appanihito na vattabbo " samkharakkhandhapariya- panno ti " ? Amanta. Smihata na vattabba " samkharakkhandhapariyapanna ti"? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. SuMata samkharakkhandhapariyapanna ti ? Amanta. Samkharakkhandho na anicco na sainkhato na paticca- samnppanno na khayadhammo na vayadhammo na viraga- dhammo na nirodhadhammo na viparinamadhammo ti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — Xanu samkharakkhandho anicco samkhato paticca- samuppanno khayadhammo vayadhammo viragadhammo nirodhadhammo viparinamadhammo ti ? Amanta. Hahci samkharakkhando anicco — pe — viparinama- dhammo, no vata re vattabbe " Smiiiata samkharakkhan- dhapariyapanna ti." 4. Eiipakkhandhassa smihata sanikharakkhandhapariya- panna ti ? Amanta. XIX. 3. J KATHAVATTHU. 579 Samkharakkhanclhassa sunnata rupakkliandliapariya- panna ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Vedana — pe — ^saiiiia — pe — vinfianakkhandhassa sun- nata samkharakkhandhapariyapanna ti ? Anianta. Samkliarakkhandhassa sunnata vinnanakkhandhapariya- panna ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Samkharakkhandhassa sunnata na vattabba " rupak- khandhapariyapanna ti " ? Ainanta. Rupakkhandhassa sunnata na vattabba " samkharak- khandhapariyapanna ti " '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samkharakkhandhassa^ smihata na vattabba " vinfia nakkhandhapariyapanna ti " ? Am ant a. Vihhanakkhandhassa sminata na vattabba " samkba- rakkhandliapariyapanna ti " ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Na vattabbam " Smihata samkharakkhandhapariya- panna ti " ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Smlham idam Bhikkhave samkhara attena va attaniyena ^ va ti." Atth'eva sut- tanto ti ? - Amanta. Tena hi smihata samkharakkhandhapariyapanna ti. Sunnata katha. XIX. 3. 1. Samahhaphalam asainkhatan ti ? Amanta. attaniye, P. 580 KATHAVATTHU. [XIX. 3. Xibbanam tanam lenam saranam parayanam accutam amatan ti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — - Samaniiaphalam asamkhatam, nibbanam asamkhatan ti? Am ant a. Dve asamkhatamti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve asamkhatamti '? Amanta. Dve tanani — pe — antaiika va ti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Samafinaphalam asamldiatan ti ? Amanta. Samafinam asamkhatan ti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samahiiam samkhatan ti ? Amanta. SamanBaphalam samkhatan ti "? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Sotapattiphalam asamkhatan ti ? Amanta. Sotapattimaggo asamkhato ti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sotapattimaggo samkhato ti '? Amanta. Sotapattiphalam samkhatan ti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Sakadagami — pe — anagami — pe — arahattaphalam asamkhatan ti '? Amanta. Arahattamaggo asamkhato ti "? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahattamaggo samkhato ti ? Amanta. Arahattaphalam samkhatan ti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. SotapattijDhalain asamkhatarn, sakadagami — pe — XIX. 4.] KATHAVATTHU. 581 anagami — pe — arahattaphalam asamkhatam, nibbanam asamkhatan ti '? Amanta. Panca asainkhatanlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Panca asainkhatanlti ? Amanta. Panca tanani — pe — antarika va ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Samannaphalakatha. XIX. 4. 1 . Patti asamkhata ti "? Amanta. Nibbanam tanam lenam saranam parayanam accutam amatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Patti asamkhata, nibbanam asamkhatan ti '? Amanta. Dve asainkhatanlti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve asainkhatanlti V Amanta. Dve tanani — pe — antarika va ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Civarassa patti asamkhata ti ? Amanta. Nibbanam — pe — amatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Civarassa patti asamkhata, nibbanam asamkhatan ti ? Amanta. Dve asamkhataniti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve asamkhataniti ? Amanta. Dve tanani — pe — antarika va ti "? 582 KATHAVATTHU. [XIX. 4. Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — 3. Pindapatassa — pe — senasanassa — pe — gilanapac- cayabhesajjaparikkharassa patti asamkhata ti ? Amanta. Nibbanam — pe — amatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Gilanapaccayabhesajjaparikkharassa patti asamkhata, nibbanam asamkhatan ti? Amanta. Dve asamkhatamti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve asamkhataniti ? Amanta. Dve tanani — pe — antarika va ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Civarassa patti asamkhata — pindapatassa — pe — senasanassa — pe ^ — gilanapaccayabhesajjaparikkharassa patti asamkhata, nibbanam asamkhatan ti ? Amanta. Pahca asamkhataniti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Pahca asamkhataniti ? Amanta. Paiica tanani — pe — antarika va ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Pathamassa jhanassa patti asamkhata — evam sabbami vittharetabbam— dutiyassa tatiyassa catutthassa jhanassa akasanahcayatanassa vihhanaiicayatanassa akihcahiiaya- tanassa nevasaimanasaiihayatanassa — pe — sotapattimag- gassa sotapattiphalassa, sakadagami anagami — arahatta- maggassa arahattaphalassa patti asamkhata ti ? Amanta. Nibbanam — pe — accutam amatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Arahattaphalassa patti asamkhata, nibbanam asamkha- tan ti ? ^ sabbattha, P.S2. XIX. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 583 Anianta. Dve asamkhatanlti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve asamkhatanlti ? Ainanta. Dve tanani — pe — -antarlka va ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — (5. Sotapattimaggassa patti asamkhata, sotapatti- phalassa patti asamkhata — pe — arahattamaggassa patti asainkhata, arahattaphalassa patti asamkhata, nibbanain asamkhatau ti ? Amanta. Nava asamkhatanlti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nava asamkhatanlti ? Amanta. Nava tanani — pe — antarlka va ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. Na vattabbam "Patti asamkhata ti " ? Amanta. Patti riipam vedana saiiha samkhara vihiianan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi patti asamkhata ti. Patti k at ha. XIX. 5. 1. Sabbadhammanam tathata asamkhata ti '? Amanta. Nibbanam tanam lenam saranain parayanam accutam amatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sabbadhammanam tathata asamkhata, nibbanam asam- khatan ti ? Amanta. Dve asamkhatanlti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — 'o 84 KATHAYATTHU. [XIX. 5. Dve asamkhatanlti ? Amanta. Dve tanani — pe — antarlka va ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Eupassa rupata, nana rupata asamkhata ti ? Amanta. Xibbanam tanam lenam saranam paravanam accutam amatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Eupassa rupata, nanu rupata asaipkhata ti ? Amanta. Dve asarpkhataniti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dve asainkhataniti ? Amanta. Dve tanani — pe— antarlka va ti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Vedanaya veclanata, nanu vedanata — pe — saniiaya sahhata, nanu sahhata — pe — samkharanam samkharata, nanu samkharata — pe — viiiiianassa vihhanata, nanu vinha- nata asamkhata ti ? Amanta. Xibbanam tanam lenam saranain parayanam accutain amatan ti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — Viiihanassa vihhanata, nanu rupata asamkhata ti ? Amanta. Cha asamkhatanlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cha asamkhatanlti ? Amanta. Cha tanani — pe — antarlka va ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Na vattabbam " Sabbadhammanam tathata asam- khata ti " ? Araanta. Saobadhammanani tathata rupam vedana saiiha sam- khara vihhanan ti "? XIX. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 585 Amanta. Tena hi sabbadhammanam tathata asamkhata ti. Tathata katha. XIX. 6. 1. Nibbanadbatu kusala ti ? Amanta. Sarannnana, atthi taya avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Nanu anarammana, n'atthi taya avattana — pe — pani- dhiti? Amanta. Hanoi anarammana, n'atthi taya avattana — pe — panidhi, no vata re vattabbe " Nibbanadbatu kusala ti." 2. Alobho kusalo sarammano, atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Nibbanadbatu kusala sarammana, atthi taya avattana — pe — panidhiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Adoso kusalo — pe — amoho kusalo — pe — saddha viriyam sati samadhi — pe — pahha kusala sarammana, atthi taya avattana — pe— panidhiti ? Amanta. Nibbanadhatu kusala sarammana, atthi taya avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — - Nibbanadhatu kusala anarammana, n'atthi taya avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Amanta. Alobho kusalo anarammano, n'atthi tassa avattana — pe — panidhiti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Nibbanadhatu kusalfi anarammana, n'atthi taya avattana — pe — panidhiti ? 586 KATHAVATTHU. [XIX. 7 Amanta. Adoso — pe — panna kusala anarammana, n'atthi taya avattana — pe — panidhiti '? Na h'evarn vattabbe — pe — 3. Na vattabbam " Nibbanadhatu kusala ti " '? Amanta. Nanu nibbanadhatu anavajja ti ? Amanta. Hanoi nibbanadhatu anavajja, tena vata re vattabbe "Nibbanadhatu kusala ti." K u s a 1 a k a t h a . XIX. 7. 1. Atthi puthujjanassa accantaniyamata ti? Amanta. Matughatako accantaniyato, pitughatako, Arahanta- ghatako — pe — ruhiruppadako — pe^ — Samghabhedako ac- cantaniyato ti ? Na h'evarn vattabbe — pe — Atthi puthujjanassa accantaniyamata ti ? Amanta. Accantaniyatassa puggalassa vicikiccha uppajjeyyati ? Amanta. Hahci accantaniyatassa puggalassa vicikiccha uppaj- jeyya, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi puthujjanassa accan- taniyamata ti." 2. Accantaniyatassa puggalassa vicikiccha n'uppajjey- yati I ? Amanta. Pahlna ti ? Na h'evarn vattabbe — pe — Pahlna ti ? Amanta. Sotapattimaggenati ? ^ uppajj°, P. and S. XIX. 7.] KATHAVATTHU. 587 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sakadagami — anagami — araliattamag£:enati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — "OS" Katamena maggenati ? Akusalena maggenati. Akusalo maggo niyaniko khayagami bodhagami anasavo — pe — asamkilesiko ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanii akusalo maggo aniyaniko samkilesiko ti ? Amanta. Hanoi akusalo maggo aniyaniko samkilesiko, no vata re vattabbe " Accantaniyatassa puggalassa vicikiccha akusalena maggena pahina ti." 3. Sassataditthiniyatassa puggalassa ucchedaditthi uppajjeyyati"? Amanta. Hanoi sassataditthiniyatassa puggalassa ucchedaditthi uppajjeyya, n6 vata re vattabbe " Atthi puthujjanassa acoantaniyamata ti." 4. Sassataditthiniyatassa puggalassa ucchedaditthi n'uppajjeyyati ? Amanta. Pahina ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — - Pahina ti ? Amanta. Sotapattimaggenati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sakadagami — anagami — arahattamaggenati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Katamena maggenati '? Akusalena maggenati. Akusalo maggo niyaniko khayagami bodhagami anasavo — pe — asamkilesiko ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu akusalo maggo aniyaniko samkilesiko ti ? Amanta. Hahci akusalo maggo aniyaniko samkilesiko, no vata 588 KATHAVATTHU. [XIX. 7. re vattabbe " Sassataditthiniyatassa puggalassa uccheda- ditthi akusalena maggena pahina ti." 5. Ucchedaditthiniyatassa puggalassa sassataditthi uppajjeyyati ? Amanta. Hanoi ucchedaditthiniyatassa puggalassa sassataditthi uppajjeyya, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi puthujjanassa accantaniyamata ti," 6. Ucchedaditthiniyatassa puggalassa sassataditthi n'uppajjeyyati ? Amanta. Pahina ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Pahina ti ? Amanta. Sotapattimaggenati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sakadagami — anagami — arahattamaggenati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Katamena maggenati ? Akusalena maggenati. Akusalo niaggo nlyaniko khayagami bodhagami anasavo — pe — asamkilesiko ti V Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Nanu akusalo maggo aniyaniko — pe — samkilesiko ti ? Amanta. Hahci akusalo maggo aniyaniko — pe — samkilesiko, no vata re vattabbe " Ucchedaditthiniyatassa puggalassa sassataditthi akusalena maggena pahina ti." 7. Na vattabbam "Atthi puthujjanassa accantani- yamata ti " '? Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — "Idha Bhikkhave ekacco puggalo samannagato hoti ekantakalakehi akusalehi dhammehi, so sakim nimuggo ^ nimuggo va hotlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. ' °gga, P. XIX. 8.] KATHAVATTHU. 589 Tena hi atthi puthnjjanassa accanfcaniyamata ti. 8. Vuttam Bhagavata — " Idha Bhikkhave ekacco puggalo samannagato hoti ekantakalakehi akusalehi dhamiMehi, so sakiiu nimuggo nimnggo va liotiti " katva teiia ca karanena atthi puthujjanassa accantani- yamata ti ? Amanta. Vuttam Bhagavata — " Idha Bhikkhave ekacco puggalo ummujjitva ^ nimujjatlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Sabbakalam iimmujjitva nimnjjatlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 9. Vuttam Bhagavata — " Idha Bhikkhave ekacco puggalo samannagato hoti ekantakalakehi akusalehi dhammehi, so sakim nimuggo nimuggo va hotiti " katva tena ca karanena atthi puthujjanassa accantani- yamata ti '? Amanta. Vuttain Bhagavata — " Idha Bhikkhave ekacco pug- galo ummujjitva thito hoti, ummujjitva vipassati viloketi, ummujjitva patarati,- ummujjitva patigadhappatto hotiti." Atth'eva suttanto ti '? Amanta. Sabbakalam ummujjitva patigadhappatto hotiti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe — pe — A c c a n t a n i y a m a k a t h a . XIX. 8. 1. N'atthi lokiyam saddhindriyan ti ? Amanta. N'atthi lokiya saddha ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N'atthi lokiyam viriyindriyam — pe — satindriyam — pe- samadhindriyam — pe — pahhindriyan ti '? ' uppaj", P.S. 2 patahati, S. ; pajahati, P 590 KATHAVATTHU. [XIX. 8. Anianta. N'atthi lokiya paniia ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Atthi lokiya saddha ti ? Amanta. Atthi lokiyam saddhindriyan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi lokiyam viriyam — pe — ^paiiiia ti ? Amanta. Atthi lokiyam pahnindriyan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Atthi lokiyo mano, atthi lokiyam manindriyan ti ? Amanta. Atthi lokiya saddha, atthi lokiyam saddhindriyan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi lokiyo mano, atthi lokiyam manindriyan ti ? Amanta. Atthi lokiya pahfia, atthi lokiyam pahnindriyan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi lokiyam somanassam, atthi lokiyam somanassin- driyam, atthi lokiyam jivitam, atthi lokiyam jTvitindriyan ti? " Amanta. Atthi lokiya saddha, atthi lokiyam saddhindriyan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi lokiyam jivitam, atthi lokiyam jivitindriyan ti ? Amanta. Atthi lokiya pahha, atthi lokiyam pahnindriyan ti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — 4. Atthi lokiya saddha, n' atthi lokiyam saddhindriyan ti ? Amanta. Atthi lokiyo mano, n'atthi lokiyam manindriyan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi lokiya pahha, n'atthi lokiyam pahnindriyan ti ? Amanta. Atthi lokiyo mano, n'atthi lokiyam manindriyan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi lokiya saddha, n'atthi lokiyam saddhindriyan ti ? XIX. 8.] KATHAVATTHU. 591 Am ant a. Atthi lokiyam somanassam, n'atthi lokiyam somanassin- driyaiii, atthi lokiyam jivitam, n'atthi lokiyam jivitindriyan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi lokiya pahna, n'atthi lokiyam pahhindriyan ti ? Amanta. Atthi lokiyam jivitam, n'atthi lokiyam jivitindriyan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Atthi loknttara saddha, atthi lokuttaram saddhin- driyan ti ? Amanta. Atthi lokiya saddha, atthi lokiyam saddhindriyan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Atthi lokuttara pahha, atthi lokuttaram paiiiiindriyan ti? Amanta. Atthi lokiya pahha, atthi lokiyam pahhindriyan ti "? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 6. Atthi lokiya saddha, n'atthi lokiyam saddhindriyan ti? Amanta. Atthi lokuttara saddha, n'atthi lokuttaram saddhindri- yan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi lokiya pahha, n'atthi lokiyam pahhindriyan ti ? Amanta. Atthi lokuttara pahha, n'atthi lokuttaram pahhindriyan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 7. N'atthi lokiyani pane' ^ indriyaniti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata " Addasa kho aham Bhikkhave Buddhacakkhuna lokain volokento^ satte apparajakkhe maharajakkhe tikkhindriyc mudindriye svakare 3 suvihha- pam^, P. = lokanto, P. ; olokento, S. 3 suvri°, S. 592 KATHAVATTHU. [XIX. 8. paye appekacce paralokavajjabhayadassavino ^ viharante ^ ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti '? Anianta. Tena hi atthi lokiyani panc'indriyanlti. I n d r i y a k a t h a . V a g g o e k u n a V 1 s a t i 111 o . Atlte kilese jahati, Anagate kilese jahati, Paccuppanne kilese jahati, Suhiiata samkharakkhan- dhap ariy apanna, Samahfiaphalam asamkhatam, Patti asamkhata, Sabbadhammanam tathata asamkhata, Nibbanadhatu kusala, Atthi puthnjjaiiassa accantaniyamata, N'atthi lokiyani pahc'indriyanlti. ^ °ne, P.S.S2. ^ vasaradeti, P. ; saraceti, S. XX. ].] KATHAVATTHU. 593 XX. 1. 1 . Asancicca mataram jivita voropetva anantariko hotiti ? Amanta. Asancicca panam hantva panatipati hotiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Asancicca mataram jivita voropetva anantariko hotiti ? Amanta. Asaiicicca adinnam adiyitva — pe — musabhanitva musa- vadl hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Asancicca panani hantva panatipati na hotiti '? x4.manta. Asaiicicca mataram jivita voropetva anantariko na hotiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Asancicca adinnam adiyitva — pe — musabhanitva musa- vadl na hotiti ? Amanta. Asancicca mataram jivita voropetva anantariko na hotiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Asancicca mataram jivita voropetva anantariko hotiti '? Amanta. " Asancicca mataram jivita voropetva anantariko hotiti," •atth'eva suttanto ti? N'atthi. " Saiicicca mataram jivita voropetva anantariko hotiti," atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Haiici " sahcicca mataram jivita voropetva anantariko hotiti," atth'eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe "Asancicca mataram jivita voropetva anantariko hotiti." 4. Na vattabbam " Matughatako anantariko ti " '? Amanta. Nanu mata jivita voropita ti '? Amanta. Hahci mata jivita voropita, tena vata re vattabbe ■"Matughatako anantariko ti." 5. Na vattabbain " Pitughatako anantariko ti " ? 39 59-4 KATHAVATTHU. [XX. 1. Amanta. Nanu pita jivita voropito ti ? Amanta. Hanci pita jivita voropito, tena vata re vattabbe " Pitiigliatako anantariko ti." 6. Na vattabbain " Arahantaghatako anantariko ti " V Amanta. Nanu Araha jivita voropito ti ? Amanta. Haiici Araha jivita voropito, tena vata re vattabbe "Arahantaghatako anantariko ti." 7. Na vattabbam " Lohitnppadako ^ anantariko ti " ? Amanta. Nanu Tathagatassa lohitam uppaditan ti '? Amanta. Haiici Tathagatassa lohitam uppaditam, tena vata re vattabbe "Lohitnppadako anantariko ti." 8. Samghabhedako anantariko ti ? Amanta. Sabbe Sainghabhedaka anantarika ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sabbe Samghabhedaka anantarika ti ? Amanta. Dhammasaiim Samghabhedako anantariko ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dhammasaiihl Samghabhedako anantariko ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Atth' UpaH Samghabhedako apayiko nerayiko kappattho atekiccho, atth' Upah Sam- ghabhedako na apayiko na nerayiko na kappattho na atekiccho ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbain " Dhammasaiiiil Sainghabhedako anantariko ti." 9 . Na vattabbam ' ' Dhammasaiim Sarnghabhedako anan- tariko ti " ? I ruhiruppadako. M.K. XX. 2.] KATHAYATTHU. 595 Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Apayiko nerayiko kappattho Samghabliedako Vaggarato adhammattho yogakkhemato dhamsati Samgham samaggam bhetvana kappam nirayamlii paccatlti." Atth'eva snttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi Samghabliedako anantariko ti. A s a fi c i c c a k a t h a . XX. -2. 1. N'atthi puthujjanassa hanan ti? Amanta. N'atthi puthujjanassa paima pajanana vicayo pavicayo dhammavicayo sallakkhana npalakkhana paccupalakldiana ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu atthi piithiijjanassa paiiiia — pe — pacciipalakkhana ti'?_ Amanta. Hanoi atthi puthujjanassa paiiiia — pe — paccupalakkhana^ no vata re vattabbe " N'atthi puthujjanassa fiaiian ti." 2. N'atthi puthujjanassa iianan ti ? Amanta. Puthujjano pathamam jhanam samapajjeyyati ? Amanta. Haiici puthujjano pathamam jhanam samapajjeyya, no vata re vattabbe " N'atthi puthujjanassa hanan ti." Puthujjano dutiyam jhanam — pe — tatiyam jhanam — pe — catuttham jhanam — pe — akasanahcayatanam samapaj- jeyya, viimanahcayatanam akiiicaiiiiayatanam nevasahiia- nasahfiayatanam samapajjeyya, puthujjano danam dadeyya, 596 KATHAVATTHU. [XX. 3. — pe — civaram, pindapatam, senasanam, gilanapacca- yabhesajjaparikkharam dadeyyati '? Amanta. Hanoi puthujjano gilanapaccayabhesajjaparikkharam ■dadeyya, no vata re vattabbe " N'atthi puthujjanassa nanan ti." 3. Attlii pnthnjjanassa nanan ti '? Amanta. Puthujjano tena nanena dukkliam parijanati, samuda- yam pajahati, nirodham sacchikaroti, maggam bhavetiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanakatha. XX. 3. 1. N'atthi nirayesu nirayapala ti ? Amanta. N'atthi nirayesu kammakarana ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi nirayesu kammakarana ti ? Amanta. Atthi nirayesu nirayapala ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Atthi manussesu kammakarana, atthi ca karanika^ ti? Amanta. Atthi nirayesu kammakarana, atthi ca karanika ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi nirayesu kainmakarana, n'atthi ca karanika ti ? Amanta. Atthi manussesu kammakarana, n'atthi ca karanika ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Atthi nirayesu nirayapala ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — ^ karunika, P. XX. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 597 " Na Vessabhu no pi ^ ca Pettiraja Soino Yamo - Vessavano ca raja Sakani kaminani hananti tattha Ito panunnams paralokapattan 4 ti." Attli'eva siittanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi n'atthi nirayesu nirayapala ti. 4. N'atthi nirayesu nirayapala ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — "Tarn enam Bhikkhave nirayapala pancavidhabandhanam 5 naina ^ karanam karenti, tattam ayokhllamhatthegamenti, tattam ayokhl- 1am dutiye hatthe gamenti, tattam ayokhilam pade ga- menti, tattam ayokhilam dutiye pade gamenti, tattam ayokhilam majjhe urasmim gamenti ; so tattha dukkha tibba 7 katuka vedana vedeti, na ca tava kalam karoti yava na tarn ^ papakammam byanti hotiti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi atthi nirayesu nirayapala ti. 5. N'atthi nirayesu nirayapala ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — "Tarn enam Bhikkhave nira- yapala 9 samvesitva^o kudharlhi" tacchanti, tarn enam Bhikkhave nirayapala uddham padam adhosiram thapetva vasihi tacchanti, tarn enam Bhikkhave nirayapala rathe yojetva adittaya ^- pathaviya sampajjalitaya sajotibhutaya sarenti ^3 pi pacca sarenti pi, tarn enam Bhikkave niraya- pala mahantam Ahgarapabbatam ^4 adittam sampajjalitam ^ hi, S. 2 Soyamo, P. ; soyamoyamo, S. 3 panunam, P. ; pakunnam S. ; pannunnam, Attho. 4lokam matanti, P. ; pattan, S. sona, P.S. 6nama, om. P.S.S2. 7 tippa, P.S.K. Syayattam, P. 9 opala ti, P. 10 palasmim dhesitva, S. "khudadlhi, S. i^aditthaya, P. ispajenti, P. ; padenti, S. ^4 Alamkarao, S. 598 KATHAVATTHU. [XX. 4. sajotibhutam aropenti pi oropenti pi, tarn eiiam Bliik- khave nirayapala uddham padam adhosiram gahetva tattaya lohakuinbhiya pakkhipanti ^ adittaya sampajjali- taya sajotibhutaya, so tattha phenuddehakam ^ paccati, so tattha plienuddehakam paccamano sakim pi uddham gacchati sakim pi adho gacchati, sakim pi tiriyam gac- chati, so tattha dukkha tibba katuka vedana vedayati 3 na ca tava kalam karoti yava ca na tarn papakammam byanti hoti, tam enam Bhikkhave nirayapala mahaniraye pakkhi- panti. 4 So kho pana Bhikkhave Mahanirayo Catukkanno s catiidvaro Vibhatto bhagaso mito Ayopakarapariyanto Ayasa patikujjito,^ Tassa ayomaya7 bhumi Ahta tejasa yutta.^ Samanta yojanasatam Pharitva titthati sabbada ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi atthi nirayesu nirayapala ti. N i r a y a p a 1 a k a t h a . XX. 4. 1. Atthi devesu tiracchanagata ti ? Amanta. Atthi tiracchanagatesu deva ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi devesu tiracchanagata ti ? ^°penti, P.S. 2peno^ p.S. Svediyo, P.S.Sa. 4 0penti, P.S. 5 okanno, P. ; catukkavanno, S. 6okujito, P. 7 Omaha, S. Syuta, P.S. XX. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 599 Amanta. Devaloko tiracclianayonlti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi devesu tiracchanagata ti ? Amanta. Atthi tattha kita ^ patanga makasa luakkhika ahl vic- chika satapadi gandupada ^ ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. N'atthi devesu tiracchanagata ti ? Amanta. Nanii atthi tattha Eravano nama hatthinago sahassa- yuttam dibbam yanan ti ? Amanta. Hanci atthi tattha Eravano nama hatthinago sahassa- yuttam dibbain _janam , tena vata re vattabbe "Atthi devesu tiracchanagata ti." 3. Atthi devesu tiracchanagata ti '? Amanta. Atthi tattha hatthibandha assabandha yavasika 3 ka- ranika bhattakaraka ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi n'atthi devesu tiracchanagata ti. T i r a c c h a n a k a t h a . XX. 5. 1. Pancangiko maggo ti '? Amanta. Nanu atthahgiko maggo vutto Bhagavata, seyyathldain sammaditthi — pe — sammasamadhiti ? Amanta. Hahci atthangiko maggo vutto Bhagavata, seyyathldam ^ kita, M. S. has Atthi tattha kita padanani mahasa akkhikil ahivicchikilsahadigambahada ti. ^mandukadl ti, P. 3 yavassika, M. 000 KATHAVATTHU. XX. 5. saminaditthi — pe — sammasamadlii, no vata re vattabbe " Pancangiko maggo ti." 2. Pancangiko niaggo ti ? Anianta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — _ « " Magfo-anam atthangiko^ settho saccanam^ caturo pada P^ ^ ' Virago settho dhaninianani dvipadanan 3 ca cakkhuma Atth'eva suttanto ti '? Anianta. Tena hi atthahoiko maggo ti. 3. Saminavaca maggahgam, sa ca na maggo ti ? Amanta. Sammaditthi maggahgam, sa ca na maggo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sammavaca maggahgam, sa ca na maggo ti ? Amanta. Sammasamkappo — pe — sammavayamo — pe — samma- sati — pe — sammasamadhi maggahgam, so ca na maggo ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sammakammanto — pe — sammaajivo maggahgam, so ca na maggo ti ? Amanta. Sammaditthi — pe — sannnasamadhi maggahgam, so ca na maggo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Sammaditthi maggahgam, sa ca maggo ti ? Amanta. Sammavaca maggahgain, sa ca maggo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sammaditthi maggahgam, sa ca maggo ti ? Amanta. Sammakammanto — pe — sammaajivo maggahgam, so ca maggo ti ? ^ maggan'atth, P.S. ^ pacchanam, S. ; sakhanano, P. 3 dveo, P. XX. 5.j KATHAVATTHU. 601 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sammasamkappo — pe — sammasamadhi maggangam, so ca maggo ti '? Amanta. Sammavaca — pe — sammaajlvo maggangam, so ca maggo ti? ' . Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Atthaiigiko maggo ti? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Pubbe va ^ kho pan'assa kayakammam vaclkammani ajivo suparisuddho hoti, evam assayam ariyo atthangiko maggo bhavanaparipurim ^ gacchatlti." 3 Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi pahcahgiko maggo ti. 6. Pahcahgiko maggo ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Yasnhm kho Subhadda Dhammavinaye ariyo atthangiko maggo na upakibbhati, samano pi tattha na upalabbhati, dutiyo pi tattha samano na upalabbhati, tatiyo pi tattha samano na upalabbhati, catuttho pi tattha samano na upalabbhati, 3'asmim ca kho Subhadda Dhammavinaye ariyo atthangiko maggo upa- labbhati samano pi tattha upalabbhati, dutiyo pi — pe — tatiyo pi — pe — catuttho pi tattha samano upalabbhati ; imasmim kho Subhadda Dhammavinaye ariyo atthangiko maggo upalabbhati, idh'eva Subhadda samano idha dutiyo samano idha tatiyo samano idha catuttho samano, suhha parappavada samanehi4 ahhehiti."5 Atth'eva suttanto ti ? ' Amanta. Tena hi atthangiko maggo ti. M a gga k a t h a . I ca, P.S. 2 oj-i^ p_ 3 gacchanti, P.S. 4 samano ti, 1\S. 5 anno ti, P. ; aljliirifio, S. 602 KATHAVATTHU. [XX. 6. XX. 6. 1. Dvadasavattliukam nanam lokuttaran ti? Amanta. Dvadasa lokuttaranananiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dvadasa lokuttaranananiti ? Amanta. Dvadasa sotapattimagga ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dvadasa sotapattimagga ti ? Amanta. Dvadasa sotapattiphalaniti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Dvadasa sakadaganh — pe — anagami — pe — arahatta- magga ti? Na h'evam vattabbe^pe — Dvadasa arahattamagga ti ? Amanta. Dvadasa arahattaphalanlti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Na vattabbam " Dvadasavatthukam iianam lokutta- ran ti " " ■? Amanta. Nanu vuttain Bhagavata — " Idam dukkham ariyasaccan ti me Bhikkhave pubbe ananussutesu dhammesu cakkhum udapadi iianam udapadi vijja udapadi pamia udapadi aioko udapadi, tarn kho pan'idam dukkham ariyasaccam parih- neyyan ti me Bhikkhave — pe — parihhatan ti me Bhikkhave — pe — idam dukkhasamudayo ariyasaccan ti me Bhik- khave — x^e — tarn kho pan'idam dukkhasamudayo ariya- saccam pahatabban ti me Bhikkhave — pe — pahinan ti me Bhikkhave — pe — idam dukkhanirodho ariyasaccan ti me Bhikkhave — pe — tam kho pan'idam dukkhanirodho ariyasaccam sacchikatabban ti me Bhikkhave — pe — sacchi- katan ti me Bhikkhave — pe — idam dukkhanirodhagamini patipada ariyasaccan ti me Bhikkhave — pe — tam kho pan'idani dukkhanirodhagamini patipada ariyasaccam XX. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 603 bhavetabban ti me Bhikkhave — pe — bhavitan ti me Bhik- khave pubbe ananussutesu dhammesu cakkhnin udapadi — pe — aloko iidapadlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi dvadasavatthukam nanam lokuttaran ti. N a n a k a t h a . V a g g o V I s a t i m o Matughatako anantariko, Pitnghatako anantariko, Arahantaghatako anantariko, Enhiruppadako ananta- riko, Samghabhedako anantariko, N'atthi pnthnjjanassa na- nam, N'atthi nirayesu nirayapala, Atthi devesu tiracchana- gata, Pancangiko mafi-go, dvadasavatthukam hanam lokuttaran ti. C a t u 1 1 h o p a n n a s a k o . Niggaho, punhasamcayo, atthasi, atitena ca matugha- tako ti. 604 KATHAVATTHU. [XXI. 1. XXI. 1. 1. Sasanam navakatan ^ ti ? Amanta. Satipatthana navakata ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sasanam navakatan ti ? Amanta. Sammappadhana — pe — iddhipada — pe — indriy a — pe — bala — pe — bojjhanga navakata ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Pubbe akusalam paccha kusalam katan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Pubbe sasavam — pe — safiiiojaniyam gandhaniyam ogha- nlyam yoganlyain nivaranlyam paramattham upadaniyam samkilesikam paccha asamkilesikam katan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Atthi koci Tathagatassa sasanam navam karotiti '? Amanta. Atthi koci satipatthane navam karotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi koci sammappadhane — pe — bojjhahge navam ka- rotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi koci pubbe akusalam paccha kusalam karotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Atthi koci pubbe sasavam — pe — samkilesikam paccha asamkilesikam karotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Labbha Tathagatassa sasanam puna navam katun ti ? Amanta. Labbha satipatthana puna navam katun ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Labbha sammappadhana — pe— bojjhanga navam katun ti? I navam kat°, M.K.. XXI. 2.] KATHAVATTHU. 605 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — • Labbha pubbe akusalam paccha kusalam katun ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Labbha pubbe sasavam — pe — samkilesikam paccha asamkilesikam katun ti? Sasanakatha. XXI. 2. 1. Puthujjano tedhatukehi dhammehi ^ avivitto ti? Amanta. Puthujjano tedhatukehi phassehi — pe — vedanahi saiiha- hi cetanahi cittehi saddhahi viriyehi satihi samadhlhi — pe — tedhatukahi paiiiiahi avivitto ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Puthujjano tedhatukehi dhammehi avivitto ti ? Amanta. Yasmim khane puthujjano civaram deti, tasmim khane pathamam jhanam upasampajja viharati — pe — akasanah- cayatanam upasampajja viharatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Yasmim khane puthujjano pindapatam deti — pe — sena- sanam deti — pe — gilanapaccayabhesajjaparikkharam deti, tasmim khane catuttham jhanam upasampajja viharati, nevasahhanasahhayatanam upasampajja viharatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Na vattabbam " Puthujjano tedhatukehi dhammehi ^ avivitto ti " ? Amanta. Puthujjanassa rupadhatu — arupadhatCipagam kammam pariiihatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe— Tena hi puthujjano tedhatukehi kammehi avivitto ti. Avivittakatha. '■ kammehi, M.P. ; kappehi, S.S2. ; dhammehi, K. Atth°. 2 dhammehi, P.S2. 606 KATHAVATTHU. [XXI. 4. XX] 3. 1. Atthi kifici saiinojanam appahaya arahattappattiti ? Am ant a. Atthi kihci sakkayaditthim appahaya — pe — vicikiccham silabbataparamasam ragaiii dosam moham anottappam appahaya arahattappattiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Atthi kihci sahhojanam appahaya arahattappattiti? Amanta. Araha sarago sadoso samoho samano samakkho sapa- laso I sa-iipayaso sakileso ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanii Araha nirago niddoso nimmoho nimmano nim- makkho nippalaso nirupayaso nikkileso ti ? Amanta. Hanoi Araha nirago niddoso nimmoho nimmano nim- makkho nippalaso nirripayaso nikkileso, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi kihci sahhojanam appahaya arahattap- pattiti." 3. Na vattabbam " Atthi kihci sahhojanam appahaya Arahattapattiti " '? Amanta. Araha sabbam Buddhavisayain = janatiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi atthi kihci sahhojanam appahaya Arahattap- pattiti. Sahhoj an a k at ha. XXI. 4. 1. Atthi adhippaya-iddhi Buddhanam va savakanam va ti? Amanta. I saph°, P. ^ Buddhakiccam, P.S. XXI. 4.] KATHAVATTHU. 607 Niccapanna rukkha hontuti attlii adhippaya-iddlii Biiddlianam va savakanain va ti ? Na h'evaiii vattabbe — pe — Niccapuppha rukkha hoiitn — pe — niccaphalika ^ rukklia hontu, niccam jnnham- hotu, niccaiu khemam liotu niccani subhikkham hotu, niccam suvatthi 3 hotuti, atthi adhippaya-iddhi Buddhanam va savakauam va ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Atthi adhippaya-iddhi Buddhanam va savakanain va ti ? Am ant a. Uppanno phasso ma nirujjhlti atthi adhippaya-iddhi Buddhanam va savakanain va ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Uppanna vedana — pe — paiiiia ma nirujjhlti atthi adhippaya-iddhi Buddhanam va savakanain va ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 3. Atthi adhippaya-iddhi Buddhanain va savakanain va ti y Amanta. Bupam niccam hotuti — pe — vedana — pe — saiiha — pe — sainkhara — pe — viiihanam niccam hotiiti, atthi adhippaya- iddhi Buddhanam va savakanain va ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Atthi adhippaya-iddhi Buddhanain va savakanain va ti ? Amanta. Jatidhamma satta ma jajdinsiiti,^ atthi — pe — jara- dhamma satta ina jarimsiiti s — pe — byadhidhainma satta ma byadhiyimsuti — pe — maranadhamma satta ma mlyiin- siiti, atthi adhippaya-iddhi Buddhanam va savakanain va ti"? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 5. Na vattabl)am "Atthi adhippaya-iddhi Buddhanam va savakanain va ti ? I opaUta, P.S. ; phaHiio, K. - janliaiu, P.S.S; 3 suvutthikam, K. 4 jayanti, P.S. 5 jiyisuti, P.S. 608 KATHAVATTHU. [XXI. 6. Ainanta. Nanu ayasma Pilindavaccho ranno Magadhassa Seni- yassa Bimbisarassa pasadam suvannan t'eva adhimucci, suvanno ca pana asiti ? Am ant a. Hanoi ayasma Palindavaccho ranno Magadhassa Seni- yassa Bimbisarassa pasadam suvannan t'eva adhimucci, suvanno ca pana asi, tena vata re vattabbe " Atthi adhippaya-iddhi Buddhanain va savakanam va ti." I d d h i k a t h a . 5. 1 . Atthi Buddhanam Buddhehi hlnatirekata ti ? Amanta. Satipatthanato ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — • Sammappadhanato — pe — iddhipadato — pe — indriyato- pe — balato — pe — boj jhangato — pe — vasTbhavato ^ — pe- sabbanhutahanadassanato ti '? ^ Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — B u d d h a k a t h a . XXI. 6. 1. Sabba disa Buddha titthantiti ? Amanta. Puratthimaya ^ disaya Buddha titthantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Puratthimaya disaya Buddha titthantiti ? Amanta. Kinnamo so Bhagava, kinijacco, kimgotto, kinnama I P. omits. 2 purattimaya, M. XXI. 7.] KATHAVATTHU. 609 tassa Bhagavato matapitaro, kinnamam tassa Bhagavato savakayugam, ko namo tassa Bhagavato upatthako, kidisam civaram dhareti, kidisam pattam dhareti, kata- rasmim game va nigame va nagare va ratthe va janapade va ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Dakkhinaya disaya — pe — pacchimaya disaya — pe — uttaraya disaya — pe — hetthimaya disaya Buddho tittha- titi ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Hetthimaya disaya Buddho titthatiti ? Amanta. Kinnamo so Bhagava — pe — janapade va ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ux^arimaya disaya Buddho titthatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Uparimaya disaya Buddho titthatiti ? Amanta. Catummaharajike titthati — pe — Tavatimse titthati — pe — Yame titthati — pe — Tusite titthati — pe — nimmanara- tiya titthati — pe — paranimmitavasavattiya titthati — pe — Brahmaloke titthatiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sabbadisa katha. XXI. 7. 1. Sabbe dhamma niyata ti '? Amanta. Micchattaniyata ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sammattaniyata ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N'atthi aniyato rasiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe— pe — Nanu atthi aniyato rasiti ? 40 610 KATHAVATTHU. [XXI. 7. Amanta. Hanoi atthi aniyato rasi, no vata re vattabbe " Sabbe dhamma niyata ti." 2. Sabbe dhamma niyata ti ? Amanta. Nanu tayo rasi vutta Bhagavata — micchattaniyato rasi, sammattaniyato rasi, aniyato rasiti ? Amanta. Haiici tayo rasi vutta Bhagavata — micchattaniyato rasi, sammattaniyato rasi, aniyato rasi, no vata re vattabbe " Sabbe dhamma niyata ti." 3. Rupam rupatthena niyatan ti ? Amanta. Micchattaniyatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sammattaniyatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — ^pe — Vedana — pe — sahha — pe — samkhara — pe — viiiiianam vihiianatthena niyatan ti '? Amanta. Micchattaniyatan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sammattaniyatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Na vattabbam " Rupam rupatthena niyatam — pe — vedana — pe — sahha — pe — samkhara — pe — vihhanam vih- nanatthena niyatan ti " ? Amanta. Ruparn hoti, vedana hoti, sahha hoti, samkhara honti, vihhanam hoti, vedana, sahha, samkhara, vihhanam rupam hoti, vedana hoti, sahha hoti, sainkhara hontiti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi rupani rupatthena niyatam, vedana, sahha, samkhara, vihhanam vihhanatthena niyatan ti. D h a m m a k a t h a . XXI. 8.] KATHAVATTHU. 611 XXI. 8. 1. Sabbe kamma niyata ti ? Amanta. Micchattaniyata ti ? Na li'evam vattabbe — pe — Sammattaniyata ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N'atthi aniyato rasiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu atthi aniyato rasiti ? Amanta. Hanoi atthi aniyato rasi, no vata re vattabbe '* Sabbe kamma niyata ti." 2. Sabbe kamma niyata ti ? Amanta. Nanu tayo rasi vutta Bhagavata — micchattaniyato rasi, sammattaniyato rasi, aniyato rasiti '? "Tlahci tayo rasi vutta Bhagavata — micchattaniyato rasi, sammattaniyato rasi, aniyato rasi, no vata re vattabbe " Sabbe kamma niyata ti." 3. Ditthadhammavedaniyam kammam ditthadhamma- vedaniyatthena ^ niyatan ti '? Amanta. Micchattaniyatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Sammattaniyatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Upapajjavedanlyani kannnam — pe — aparapariyavedani- yam kammam aparapariyavedaniyatthena niyatan ti ? Amanta. Micchattaniyatan ti ? Na h'evain vattabbe — pe — Sammattaniyatan ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 4. Na vattabbain "Ditthadhammavedaniyam kanmiam I ditthadhammasukhaniyatan ti, P.S.Sz. 612 KATHAYATTHU. [XXI. 8. ditthadhammavedaniyatthena niyatam, upapajjavedanl- yam kammam — pe — aparapariyavedaniyam kammam aparapariyavedaniyatthena niyatan ti " ? Amanta. Ditthadhammavedaniyam kammaiu upapajjavedanlyam hoti , aparapariyavedaniyam lioti — pe- — upapaj j avedamyam kammam ditthadhammavedaniyam hoti, aparapariya- vedaniyam hoti, aparapariyavedaniyam kammam dittha- dhammavedaniyam hoti upapajjavedanlyam hotiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi ditthadhammavedaniyam kammani dittha- dhammavedaniyatthena niyatam, upapajjavedanlyam kammam — pe — aparapariyavedaniyam kammam apara- pariyavedaniyatthena niyatan ti. K a m m a k a t h a . V a g g o e k a V I s a t i m o . Sasanain navakatain, Atthi koci Tathagatassa sasanam navam karoti, Labbha Tathagatassa sasanam puna navam katum, Puthujjano tedhatukehi dhammehi avivitto, Atthi kihci sahfiojanam appahaya arahattappatti, Atthi adhippaya-iddhi Buddlianam va savakanam va, Atthi Buddhanam Buddhehi hinatirekata, Sabba disa Buddha titthanti, Sabbe dhamma niyata, Sabbe kamma niyata ti. XXII. 2.] KATHAVATTHU. 618 XXII. 1. 1. Atthi kifici sannojanam appaliaya parinibbanan ti ? Amanta. Atthi kinci sakkJiyaditthim appahaya — pe — vicikiccham sllabbataparamasam ragam dosain moham anottappani appahaya parinibbanan ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Atthi kihci sannojanam appahaya parinibbanan ti ? Amanta. Araha sarago sadoso samoho samano samakkho sapalaso sa-upayaso sakileso ti ? , Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanii Araha nirago niddoso nimmoho nimmano nim- makkho nippalaso nirupayaso nikkileso ti ? Amanta. Hahci Araha nirago niddoso nimmoho nimmano nim- makkho nippalaso nirupayaso nikkileso, no vata re vat- tabbe " Atthi kiiici sahiiojanam appahaya parinibbanan ti." 8. Na vattabbain "Atthi kihci sannojanam appahaya parinibbanan ti " ? Amanta. Araha sabbam Buddhavisayam janatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi atthi kihci sahhojanam appahaya parinibbanan ti? Parinibbanakatha. XXII. 2. 1. Araha kusalacitto parinibbayatiti ? Amanta. Araha pmihabhisamkharam abhisainkharonto, anehja- bhisamkharam ^ abhisainkharonto, gatisamvattanikain I anahc°, P. ; anahj°, S. G14 KATHAVATTHU. [XXII. 2. kanimam karonto, bhavasamvattanikam kammam karonto, issariyasamvattanikani kainmam karonto, adhipaccasam- vattanikam kammam karonto, mahabhogasamvattanikam kannnam karonto, mahaparivarasamvattanikam kammam karonto, devasobhagyasanivattanikam kammam karonto, manussasobhagyasaiuvattanikain kammain karonto pari- nibbayatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Araha kusalacitto parinibbayatiti '? Amanta. Araha acinanto, apacinanto,i pajahanto, upadiyanto visinento, ussinento,^ vidhupento, sandhupento parinib- bayatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu Araha nev'acinati na apacinati apacinitva thito ti? Amanta. Hafici Araha nev'acinati na apacinati apacinitva thito^ no vata re vattabbe " Araha kusalacitto parinibbayatiti." Nanu Araha neva pajahati na upadiyati pajahitva thito, neva visineti na ussineti visinetva thito, nanu Araha neva vidhupeti na sandhupeti vidhupetva thito ti ? Amanta. Hahci Araha neva pajahati na upadiyati pajahitva thito, neva visineti na ussineti visinetva thito, hahci Araha neva vidhupeti na sandhupeti vidhupetva thito, no vata re vattabbe " Araha kusalacitto parinibbayatiti." 3. Na vattabbain " Araha kusalacitto parinibbayatiti " ? Amanta. Nanu Araha upatthitasati 3 sato sampajano parinibbaya- titi ? Amanta. Hahci Araha upatthitasati sato sampajano parinibba- yati, tena vata re vattabbe "Araha kusalacitto parinibba- yatiti." K u s a 1 a c i 1 1 a k a t h a. ^ P.S.Sg. omit. 2 upacinanto, P. ; ucin°, S. 3 upam°, M. XXII. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 615 XXII. 3. 1. Araha aneiije ^ thito parinibbayatTti ? Amanta. Nanu Araha pakaticitte thito parinibbayatTti ? Amanta. Hahci Araha pakaticitte thito parinibbayati, no vata re vattabbe " Araha anehje thito parinibbayatTti." 2. Araha aneiije thito parinibbayatTti? Amanta. Araha kiriyamaye citte thito parinibbayatTti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu Araha vipakacitte thito parinibbayatTti ? Amanta. Haiici iVraha vipakacitte thito parinibbayati, no vata re vattabbe " Araha anehje thito parinibbayatTti." 3. Araha anehje thito parinibbayatTti? Amanta. Araha kiriyabyakate citte thito parinibbayatTti ? Xa h'evam vattabbe— pe — Nanu Araha vipakabyakate citte thito parinibbayatTti ? Amanta. Hahci xAraha vipakabyakate citte thito parinibbayati, no vata re vattabbe " Araha anehje thito parinibbayatTti." 4. Araha anehje thito parinibbayatTti ? Amanta. Nanu Bhagava catutthajjhana vutthahitva samanantara parinibbuto ti ? Amanta. Hahci Bhagava catutthajjhana vutthahitva samanan- tara parinibbuto, no vata re vattabbe " Araha anehje thito parinibbayatTti." A n e h j a k a t h a . anahje, P.S.Bs 616 IsATHAVATTHU. [XXII. 5. XXII. 4. 1. Atthi gabbhaseyyaya dhammabhisamayo ti '? Amanta. Atthi gabbhaseyyaya dhammadesana ^ dhammasava- nam, dhammasakaccha, paripuccha, sTlasamadanam, indriyesu guttadvarata, bhojane mattahhuta, pubbaratta- pararattam ^ jagariyanuyogo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — N'atthi gabbhaseyyaya dhammadesana — pe — jagariya- nuyogo ti '? Amanta. Haiici n'atthi gabbhaseyyaya dhammadesana — pe — jagariyanuyogo, no vata re vattabbe " Atthi gabbhasey- yaya dhammabhisamayo ti." 2. Atthi gabbhaseyyaya dhammabhisamayo ti ? Amanta. Nanu dve paccaya sammaditthiya upadaya, parato ca ghoso, yoniso ca manasikaro ti ? Amanta. Hanoi dve paccaya sammaditthiya upadaya, parato ca ghoso, yoniso ca manasikaro, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi gabbhaseyyaya dhammabhisamayo ti." 3. Atthi gabbhaseyyaya dhammabhisamayo ti '? Amanta. Suttassa pamattassa mutthasatissa asampajanassa dham- mabhisamayo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe- — pe — Dhammabhisamayakatha. XXII. 5. 1 . («) Atthi gabbhaseyyaya arahattappattiti ? Amanta. ^ dhammasenam, P. ^ parattam, P.S^ XXII. 6.] KATHAVATTHU. 617 Suttassa pamattassa mutthasatissa asampajanassa ara- hattappattiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — (b) Atthi supinagatassa clhammabhisamayo ti ? Amanta. Suttassa pamattassa mutthasatissa asampajanassa dhammabhisamayo ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — -pe — (c) Atthi supinagatassa arahattappattiti ? Amanta. Suttassa pamattassa mutthasatissa asampajanassa ara- hattappattiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tisso pi hatha. XXII. 6. 1. Sabbam supinagatassa cittam abyakatan ti ? Amanta. Supinantena panam haneyyati '? Amanta. Hahci supinantena panam haneyya, no vata re vattabbe " Sabbam supinagatassa cittam abyakatan ti." Supinantena adinnain adiyeyya — pe — musa bhaneyya — pe — pisunam bhaneyya — pharusam bhaneyya — samphap- palapeyya — sandhirn chindeyya — nillopam kareyya — ekagarikam kareyya — paripanthe tittheyya — paradaram gaccheyya — gamaghatam kareyya — nigamaghatam kareyya — supinantena methunain dhammam patiseveyya — supinagatassa asucimucceyya — supinantena danam dadeyya — civaram dadeyya — pindapatain dadeyya — sena- sanain dadeyya — gilanapaccayabhesajjaparikkharam da- deyya — khadanlyain dadeyya — bhojanlyam dadeyya — paniyam dadeyya — cetiyam dadeyya — cetiye malani aropeyya — gandham aropeyya — vilepanam aropeyya — pe — cetiyam abhidakkhinam kareyyati ? 618 KATHAVATTHU. [XXII. 7. Amanta. Hanoi supinantena cetiyam abhidakkhinam kareyya, no vata re vattabbe " Sabbam supinagatassa cittam abyaka- tan ti." 2. Na vattabbam " Sabbam supinagatassa cittam abya- katan ti " ? Amanta. Nanu supinagatassa cittam abbohariyam vuttam Bhaga- vata ti ? Amanta. Hanci supinagatassa cittain abboliariyam vuttam Bha- gavata, tena vata re vattabbe " Sabbam supinagatassa cittam abyakatan ti." Abyakatakatha. XXII. 7. 1. N'atthi kaci asevanapaccayata ti V Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Panatipato Bhikkhave asevito bhavito bahullkato nirayasamvattaniko tirac- chanayonisamvattaniko pittivisayasamvattaniko, yo sab- balahu so panatipatassa vipako manussabhutassa appayu- kasamvattaniko hotiti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi atthi kaci asevanapaccayata ti 2. N'atthi kaci asevanapaccayata ti? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Adinnadarain Bhikkhave asevitani bhavitani bahuhkatam nirayasamvattanikam tiracchanayonisamvattanikam pittivisayasamvattanikam, yo sabbalahu so adinnadanassa vipako manussabhutassa bhogabyasanasamvattaniko hoti — pe — yo sabbalahu so kamesu inicchacarassa vipako manussabhutassa sapattave- rasamvattaniko hoti — pe — yo sabbalahu so musavadassa XXII. 7.] KATHAVATTHU. 619 vipako, manussabhutassa abbhutabbhakkhanasamvatta- niko hoti — pe — yo sabbalahn so pisuiiaya vacaya vipako, manussabhutassa mittehibhedanasamvattaniko hoti — pe — yo sabbalahu so pliarusaya vacaya vipako, manussab- hiitassa amanapasaddasamvattaniko hoti — pe — yo sab- balahu so samphappaiapassa vipako, manussabhutassa anadeyyavacasainvattaniko hoti, suramerayapanam Bhik- khave asevitain — pe — yo sabbalahu so suramerayapanassa vipako manussabhutassa ummattakasamvattaniko hotiti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi atthi kaci asevanapaccayata ti. 3. N 'atthi kaci asevanapaccayata ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Micchaditthi Bhikkhave asevita bhavita bahullkata nirayasamvattanika tiracchana- yonisamvattanika pittivisayasamvattanika ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi atthi kaci asevanapaccayata ti. 4. N' atthi kaci asevanapaccayata ti ? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Micchasamkappo — pe — micchasamadhi Bhikkhave asevito — pe— pittivisayasam- vattaniko ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi atthi kaci asevanapaccayata ti. 5. N'atthi kaci asevanapaccayata ti"? Amanta. Nanu vuttam Bhagavata — " Sammaditthi Bhikkhave asevita bhavita bahullkata amatogadha hoti amataparayana amatapariyosana ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi atthi kaci asevanapaccayata ti? G. N'atthi kaci asevanapaccayata ti? Amanta. Nanu vuttani Bhagavata — " Sammasanikappo — pe sam- masamadhi Bhikkhave asevito bhavito bahullkato 620 KATHAVATTHU. [XXII. 8. amatogadho hoti amataparayano amatapariyosano ti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Tena hi atthi kaci asevanapaccayata ti. Asevanapaccayakatha, XXII. 8. 1. Ekacittakkhanika sabbe dhamma ti '? Amanta. Citte mahapathavl santhati, mahasamuddo santhati, Sineru pabbataraja santhati, apo santhati, tejo santhati, vayo santhati, tinakatthavanappatiyo santhantiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Ekacittakkhanika sabbe dhamma ti ? Amanta. Cakkhayatanam cakkhuvihhanena sahajatan ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Cakkhayatanam cakkhuvihhanena sahajatan ti "? Amanta. Nanu ayasma Sariputto etad avoca — " Ajjhattikah c'eva avuso cakkhum aparibhinnam hoti, bahira ca rupa na apatham agacchanti, no ca tajjo samannaharo hoti, n'eva tava tajjassa vihhanabhavassa ^ patubhavo hoti ; ajjhattikah c'eva avuso cakkhum aparibhinnam hoti, bahira ca rupa apatham agacchanti, no ca tajjo saman- naharo hoti, n'eva tava tajjassa vihhanabhavassa patubhavo hoti ; yato ca kho avuso ajjhattikah c'eva cakkhum aparibhinnam hoti, bahira ca rupa apatham agacchanti, tajjo ca samannaharo hoti, evain tajjassa vihhanabhavassa patubhavo hotlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti ? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Cakkhayatanam cakkhuvihha- nena sahajatan ti." 3. Sotayatanani — pe — ghanayatanarn — pe — jivhayata- nam — pe — kayayatanam kayavihhanena sahajatan ti '? I °bhagassa. Trenckner. Majjho. I. 190. XXII. 8.] KATHAVATTHU. 621 Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Kayayatanam kayavifinanena sabajatan ti ? Amanta. Xanu ayasma Sariputto etad avoca — " Ajjhattiko c'eva aviiso kayo aparibbinno boti babira ca phottbabba na apatbam agaccbanti no ca — pe — ajjhattiko c'eva avuso kayo aparibbinno boti babira ca phottbabba apatbam agaccbanti no ca — pe — ^yato ca kho avnso ajjhattiko c'eva kayo aparibbinno hoti babira ca riipa phottbabba apatbam agaccbanti tajjo ca samannaharo boti, evam tajjassa vimianabhavassa patubbavo hotlti." Atth'eva suttanto ti? Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam " Kayayatanam kayavinhanena sabajatan ti." 4. Na vattabbam " Ekacittakkhanika sabbe dhamma ti"? Amanta. Sabbe dhamma nicca dhnva sassata aviparinama- dhanima ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Tena hi ekacittakkhanika sabbe dhamma ti. K h a n i k a k a t h a . Vaggo bavisatimo. Atthi kihci sahiiojanam appabaya pariniblianam, Araba kusalacitto parinil)bayati, Araba anehje thito parinibbayati, Atthi gabbhaseyyaya dhammabbisamayo, Atthi gabbhaseyyaya arahattappatti, Atthi supinagatassa dhammabbisamayo, Atthi supinagatassa arahattappatti, Sabbain supinagatassa cittain abj'akatani, N'atthi kaci asevanapaccayata, Ekacittakkhanika sabbe dhamma ti. 622 KATHAYATTHU. 'XXIII. 2. XXIII. 1. 1. Ekadhippayo ^ methiino dhammo patisevitabbo ti? Am ant a. Ekadhippayena asamanena hotabbam, abhikkhuna hotabbam, chinnamulena hotabbam, parajikena hotabban ti? ' Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Ekadhippayena methuno dhammo patisevitabbo ti ? Amanta. Ekadhippaj^ena pano hantabbo, adinnam adiyitabbam, musa bhanitabba, pisiinam bhanitabbam, pharusam bhanitabbam, samphappalapitabbam, sandhi cheditabba, nillopam hatabbam, ekagarikam katabbam, paripanthe thatabbam, paradaro gantabbo, gamaghato katabbo, nigamaghato katabbo ti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — E k a d d li i p p a y a k a t h a . XXIII. 2. 1. Arahantanam vannena amanussa methunam dham- mam patisevantiti '? Amanta. Arahantanam vannena amanussa panam hananti — pe — adinnam adiyanti, musa bhananti, pisunam bhananti, pharusam bhananti, samphapj^alapanti, sandhiin chin- danti, nilloparn haranti, ekagarikam karonti, paripanthe titthanti, paradaram gacchanti, gamaghatam karonti, nigamaghatam karontiti ? X'a h'evarn vattabbe pe — A r a h a n t a V a n n a k a t h a . ekadhippayena, M. XXIII. 3.] KATHAVATTHU. 623 XXIII. 3. 1. Bodhisatto issariyakamakarikahetu vinipatam gac- chatlti ? Amanta. Bodhisatto issariyakamakarikahetu nirayam gacchati, sanjivam gacchati, kalasuttam gacchati, tapanam gacchati, patapanam gacchati, samghatakam gacchati, roruvam ^ gacchati, avicim gacchatiti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Bodhisatto issariyakamakarikahetu vinipatam gaccha- titi ? Amanta. Bodhisatto issariyakamakarikahetu vinipatam gaccha- titi, atth'eva suttanto ti ? N'atthi. Hafici Bodhisatto issariyakamakarikahetu vinipatam gacchatiti, n'atth'eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe " Bodhisatto issariyakamakarikahetu vinipatam gaccha- titi." 2. Bodhisatto issariyakamakarikahetu gabbhaseyyam okkamatiti '? Bodhisatto issariyakamakarikahetu nirayam upapaj jeyya, tiracchanayonim ^ upapajjeyyati ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Bodhisatto issariyakamakarikahetu gabbhaseyyam okka- matiti '? Amanta. Bodhisatto iddhima ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Bodhisatto iddhima ti ? Amanta. Bodhisattena chandiddhipado bhavito — pe — viriyiddhi- pado — pe — cittiddhipado — pe — vimamsiddhipado bhavito ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — I roravam, P.Ss. ^ yonigain, P. 624 KATHAVATTHU. [XXIII. 3. Boclbisatto issariyakamakarikahetu gabbhaseyyam okka- matlti ? Amanta. Bodbisatto issariyakamakarikabetn gabbbaseyyam okka- matlti, attb'eva suttanto ti ? N'attbi. Hanci Bodbisatto issariyakamakarikabetu gabbbasey- yam okkamatiti, n'attb'eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe " Bodbisatto issariyakamakarikabetu gabbhaseyyam okka- matiti." 3. Bodbisatto issariyakamakarikabetu dukkarakarikam akasiti ? Amanta. Bodbisatto issariyakamakarikabetu sassato loko ti paccbagaccbi, asassato loko ti — pe — antava loko ti — pe — anantava loko ti — pe — tarn jivam tarn sarlran ti, annam jivam aiifiam sarlran ti, boti Tathagato param marana ti, na boti Tatbagato param marana ti, boti ca na ca boti Tathagato param marana ti, n'eva boti na na boti Tatha- gato param marana ti paccbagaccbiti '? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Bodbisatto issariyakamakarikahetu dukkarakarikam akasiti ? Amanta. Bodbisatto issariyakamakarikahetu dukkarakarikani akasiti, attb'eva suttanto ti '? N'attbi. Hanoi Bodbisatto issariyakamakarikabetu dukkarakari- kam akasiti, n'atth'eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe " Bodbisatto issariyakamakarikahetu dukkarakarikam akasiti." 4. Bodbisatto issariyakamakarikabetu aparantapam ^ akasi, ahiiam sattbarani uddislti^? Amanta. Bodbisatto issariyakamakarikahetu sassato loko ti pacchagacchi, asassato loko ti — pe — antava loko ti — pe — I aparantabbam, P.S. ^ udisati, P. ; uddissati, S. XXIII. 4.] KATHAVATTHU. 625 anantava loko ti — pe — tarn jlvam tarn saiiran ti, anfiam jivam anfiam sarlran ti, hoti Tathagato param iiiarana ti, na hoti Tathflgato param marana ti, hoti ca na ca hoti Tathagato param marana ti, n'eva hoti na na hoti Tatha- gato param marana ti pacchagacchiti ? Na h'evani vattabbe — pe — Bodhisatto issariyakamakarikahetu ahham sattharam ucldisiti ? Amanta. Bodhisatto issariyakamakarikahetu anham sattharam uddisiti, atth'eva suttanto ti ? N'atthi. Hanoi Bodhisatto issariyakamakarikahetu ahiiam sat- tharani uddisiti, n'atth'eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe " Bodhisatto issariyakamakarikahetu aiihain sattharam uddisiti." I s s a r i V a k a m a k a r i k a k a t li a . XXIII. 4. 1. Atthi na rago ragapatirupako ti "? Amanta. Atthi na phasso phassapatirupako, atthi na vedana vedanapatirupaka, atthi na sahiia sannapatirupaka, atthi na cetana cetanapatirupaka, atthi na cittam cittapatiru- pakam, atthi na saddha saddhapatirupaka, atthi na viriyam viriyapatiriipakam, atthi na sati satipatirupakil, atthi na samadhi samadhipatirupako, atthi na pahhil pahhclpatirupaka ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — 2. Atthi na doso dosapatirapako, atthi na moho nioha- patirupako, atthi na kileso ^ kik^sapatiriipaka ti ? Amanta. I kilesiyo, M.P. 41 626 KATHAVATTHU. [XXIII. 5. Atthi na phasso phassapatirupako — pe — atthi na paniia pannapatirupaka ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Patirnpakatha. XXIII. 5. 1. Eupam aparinipphannan ti '? Amanta. Rupam na aniccam na samkhatam na paticcasamup- annam na khayacUiammain na vayadhammam na vira- adhammam na nirodliadhammam na viparinama- Ihamman ti? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu rtipam aniccam samkhatam paticcasamnppannam khayadhammam vayadhammam viragadhammam niro- dhadhammam viparinamadhamman ti '? Amanta. Hanoi rupam aniccam samkhatam paticcasamuppannam khayadhaiximam vayadhammam viragadhammam niro- dhadhammam viparinamadhammam, no vata re vattabbe " Rupam aparinipphannan ti." 2. Dukkhah fieva parinipphannan ti ? Amanta. Nanu yad aniccam tarn dukkham vuttam Bhagavata, rupam aniccan ti ? Amanta. Hafici yad aniccam tarn dukkham vuttam Bhagavata, rupam aniccam, no vata re vattabbe " Dukkhah heva parinipphannan ti." 3. Vedana — pe — sahha — pe — samkhara — pe — vnmanani — pe — cakkhayatanam — pe — cakkhudhatu— pe — cak- khundriyam — pe — ahhatavindriyam aparinipphannan ti ? ' Amanta. XXIII. 5.] KATHAVATTHU. 627 Annatavindriyam na aniccam — pe — na viparinama- dhainman ti ? Na h'evam vattabbe — pe — Nanu annatavindriyam aniccam — pe — viparinama- dhamman ti? Amanta. Haiici annatavindriyam aniccam — pe — viparinama- dhammam, no vata re vattabbe " Annatavindriyam apari-' nipphannan ti." 4. Dukkhaii iieva parinipphannan ti ? Amanta. Nanu yad aniccam tarn dukkham vuttam Bhagavata, aniiatavmdriyain aniccan ti ? Amanta. Hafici yad aniccam tarn dukkham vuttam Bhagavata, aiiiiatavindriyam aniccam, no vata re vattabbe " Dukkhaii iieva parinipphannan ti." A p a r i n i p p h a n n a k a t h a . Vaggo tevlsatimo. Ekadhippayena methuno dhammo patisevitabbo, Arahantanam vannena amanussa methunam dhammam patisevanti, Bodhisatto issariyakamakarikahetu vinipatam gacchati, gabbhaseyyam okkamati, dukkarakarikam akasi, aparantapam akasi, aiiham sattharam uddisi, Atthi na rago ragapatirupako, atthi na doso dosapatirupako, atthi na moho mohapatirupako, atthi na kileso kilesapatirupako, Rupain parinipphannam, annatavindriyam aparinip- phannan ti. 628 KATHAVATTHU. [XXIII. 6. Mahaniyamo annsaya niggaho khuddakapancamo/ Parappavadamaddano suttamulasamahita Ujjotana sattliusamaye ^ ti. Katbavatthuppakarane pancatimsa 3 bhanavaram nittbitam. ^ opaficaina, P. 2 sattasamayo, P.; sattbusamayo, S. 3 visa, P. ; pancavisati, S. INDICES. INDICES. INDEX OF PEOPER NAMES. (The numbers are those of the pages.) Akanitthagami, 105, 106. Akanittha deva, 207, 208. Ahgarapabbata, 597. Ajapalanigrodha, 559. Atappa deva, 207. Anathapindika, 559. Appamanasubha deva, 207. Appamanabha deva, 207. Aviha deva, 207. Asanhasatta deva, 262. Akasanahcayatanupaga deva, 207, 208. Ananda, 66, 67, 203, 287, 804, 393, 394, 457, 557, 560 Abhassara deva, 207. Ukkattha, 559. Uttarakuruka, 99. Uttiya, 268. Udayi, 528. Upaka, 289. UpaH, 594. Uruvela, 559. Eravana, 599. Kaccayana, 89, 269. Kakindakanivapa, 559. Kassapa, 89, 269, 286. Kalakahjaka Asura, 360. Kiisinara, 559. Kevatta, 339. Kotthika, 89, 269. Gavampati, 220. Gotama, 267. Gotaim, 553. Cakkavattisatta, 284. Citta, 288. Catumniaharajika deva, 207, 609. Capala, 559. G31 682 INDICES. Jambuclipaka, 99. Jetavana, 559. Tavatimsa, 99, 207, 609 Tusita deva, 207, 609. Dhotaka, 194. Nandaka, 142. Niganha, 459. Nimmanariti deva, 207. Paccekasambuddha, 97. Panthaka, 89, 269. Paranimmitavasavatti deva, 207. Parittasubha deva, 207. Parittabha deva, 207. Pataliputta, 314, 394. Pilindavaccha, 608. Punna, 522. Phagguna, 142. BaranasI, 97, 559. Bimbisara, 608. Bodhisatta, 284, 286. Brahmaparohita, 207. Brahmaparisajja, 207. Brahma, 457. Magadha, 97. Mahabrahma deva, 207. Mara, 66, 457. Marakayika devata, 164, 165. Moggallana, 89, 269, 304. Mogharaja, 64. Yasa, 268. Yama deva, 207, 609. Rajagaha, 559. Lumbini, 97, 559. Vacchagotta, 267, 505, 506. Vajira, 66. Vepacittiparisa, 360. Vesali, 559. Vehapphala deva, 207. Veluvana, 559. Sakka, 554. Saripiitta, 257, 304, 561, 620, 621. Srivatthi, 100, 559. Sikhi, 203. Sineru, 46, 49, 50,51,52,620. Sndassa deva, 207. SudassI deva, 207. Subhakinna deva, 207. Subhagavana, 559. Subhadda, 601. Setu, 268. Seniya, 68. Hatthaka, 288. INDICES. 633 II. INDEX OF PASSAGES FEOM THE SUTTA PITAKA QUOTED m THE KATHAYATTHU. Ajjliattikan c'eva avuso cak khum, XXII. 8. 2. Ajjhattiko c'eva aviiso kayo, XXII. 8. 3. Attana ca katam papain, XVI. 1. 3 ; Xvi. 2. 3. ' Attani va Bhikkhave sati, 1. 1. 242. j Atthi nu klio tain bhante - cakkhmn, I. 6. 61. Atthi nu kho bho Gotama koci gihl, IV. 1. 4. Atthi puggalo attahitaya patipanno, I. 1. 147. Atth' Upali samghabhedako, XX. 1. 8. Adinnadanam Bhikkhave asevitam, XXII. 7. 2. Addasa kho aham Bhikkhave buddhacakkhuna, XIX. 8. 6. Anamattaggayam Bhikkhave samsaro, I. 1. 159. Anupubbena medhavl, I. 4. 17; II. 9. 18. Abhihhflyaham Bhikkhave dhammani desemi, XVIII. 2. 4. Amatan te Bhikkhave na paribhufi]'anti, I. 9. 6. Asadharanam ahhesam, VII. 7. 3. ' ' Aham kho avuso Niganha pahomi, XL 6. 3. Ahu pubbe lobho, I. 6. 62. Ahesum te atltamse, I. 5. 14. Apayiko nerayiko, XIII. 1.3; _ XX. 1. 9. Arainaropa vanaropa, VII. _ 5. 4; X. 9. 4. Ahuti jatavedo va, XVII. 6. 4. Idam dukkham ariyasaccan ti," IV. 9. 8 ;' XX. 6. 2. Idha Kevatta bhikkhu para- sattanam, VII. 3. 5. Idha Punna ekacco sabj^a- pajjhaiu pi, XV. 11. 6. Idha brahmacariyavaso ti, I. 3. 15. Idha Bhikkhave bhikkhu cakkhuna rupain disva, X. 3. 4; X. 4. 4; X. 5. 4; XII. 1. 3. Idha Bhikkhave bhikkhu cakkhuna rupani passati, XVIII. 9. 5. Idha Bhikkhave bhikkhu nibbane sukhanupassi vi- harati, IX. 1. 4. Idha Bhikkhave l^hikkhu vivicc'eva kamehi, XIII. 7. 3; XVIII. 6. 8. 684 INDICES. Idha Bhikkhave ekacco pug- galo samannagato hoti, XIX. 7. 6. Idha Bhikkhave ekacco png- galo mumiijjitva thito hoti, XIX. 7. 7. Idh' ekacco annam deti, VII. 4. 6. Uccavaca hi patipada, I. 2. 56. Unname udakam vuttham, VII. 6. 3. Ekapuggalo Bhikkhave loke uppajjamano, I. 1. 237. Ekam idaham Bhikkhave samayam Ukkatthayam viharami, XVIII. 1. 3. Ekayano ay am Bhikkhave maggo, I. 9. 7. EtadisI dhammapakasanet- tha, II. 3. 20. Kabahmkare ce Bhikkhave ahare atthi rago, I. 6. 68. Kabahmkare ce Bhikkhave ahare n'atthi rago, I. 6. 64. Kammuna vattati loko^ XVII. 3. 4. Kassape aham Ananda Bha- gavati, IV. 8. 6. Kaye va Ananda sati kaya- sahcetanahetu, VIII. 9. 87. Kin nu satto ti paccesi, I. 1. 240. Cakkhmi ca paticca rtipe ca, VI. 7. 2; VL 8. 2. Catasso kho im' Ananda dakkhina, XVII. 11. 4. Catunnam Bhikkhave dham- manam n'atthi koci pati- bhago, XL 5. 7. Cattar'imani Bhikkhave ta- thani, VI. 4. 6. Cattar'imani Bhikkhave su- viduravidtirani, VII. 5. 3; X. 9. 3; X. 11. 2; XIII. 5. 1; XIII. 6. 1; XIII. 7. 2; XIX. 1. 3. Cattaro'me Bhikkhave puii- habhisanda, VII. 5. 5. Cittah h'idam cetasika ca dhamma, VII. 3. 4. Cetanaharn Bhikkhave kam- mam vadami, VIII. 9. 36. Jatipaccaya Bhikkhave jara- maranam, VI. 2. 4. Janatvaham Bhikkhave pas- sato asavanam khayain vadami, II. 2. 17. Tani enaiii Bhikkhave nira- yapala, XX. 3. 4. and 5. Tayo'me Bhikkhave nirutti- patha, I. 6. 60. Tayo'me Seniya sattharo, I. i. 248. Tassa evam janato evam passato. III. 4. 6 ; XIII. 5. 8; XIII. 6. 3. Tassa sammavimuttassa san- INDICES. 635 tacittassa bhikkhuno, I. 2. 58. Tin'imani Bhikkhave asam- khatassa asamkhatalakkha- nani, I. 1. 227. Tin'imani Bhikkhave sam- khatassa samkhatalakkha- nani, I. 1. 227. Tin'imani Bhikkhave katha- vatthimi, XV. 3. 6 ; XV. 4. 2. Tin'imani Bhikkhave cak- khiini, III. 7. 4. Tihi Bhikkhave thanehi Jam- bndipaka manussa, I. 3. 15. Te ariyassa vinaye vuccanti, VIII. 4. 3. Tividha Bhikkhave kaya- sahcetana, VIII. 9. 38. Dukkham eva uppajjamanain uppajjati, I. 1. 239. Dvattims'imani Bhikkhave mahapurisassa mahapuri- salakkhanani, IV. 7. 6. Dve'ma Bhikkhave dhatuyo, I. 1. 225. Na Vessabhii no pi ca Petti- raja, XX. 3. 3. Nayiniasinim va loke, XVII. 10. 3. Naham gamissaini pamoca- naya, II. 4. 20. Naham Bhikkhave ahriain ekam dhammain pi sania- nupassami, II. 7. 2. Naham Bhikkhave saiicetani- kanam kammanain, XII. 2. 3;' XVII. 2. 4." Nibbanam nibbanato sahja- nati, IX. 2. 7. N'eva pubbenivasaya, III. 9. 5. . Pahca kamagmia loke, VIII. 3. 2. Pahc'imani Bhikkhave in- driyani. III. 6. 13. Pahc'imani Bhikkhave tha- nani, VII. 6. 4. Pahc'imani Bhikkhave da- nani, VII. 4. 5. Pahc'ime Bhikkhave kama- gmia, II. 8. 3 ; VIII, 3. 5 ; Vlil. 4. 2. Pahc'ime Bhikkhave dham- ma, L 2. 59. Pathamam kalalani hoti, XIV. 2". 3. Passam'aham Bhikkhave dib- bena cakkhmia, I. 1. 198. Panatipato Bhikkhave ase- vito, XXII. 7. I. Patahputtassa kho Ananda tayo antaraya, V. 9. 4. Pubbe va kho pan' assa kaya- kammaiu, XX. 5. 5. Bahunam vata no Bhagava dukkhadhammanain XVI. 3. 3. Magganam atthahgiko settho , XX. 5. 2. 636 INDICES. Micchaditthi klio Vaccha akusala, XIV. 8. 3. Micchaditthi Bhikkhave ase- vita, XXII. 7. 3. Micchaditthissa kho aham Punna, XIV. 8. 3. Yaj amananam manussanam, XVII. 9. 4. Yada have patubhavanti dhaimua, II. 3. 20. Yani kiiici Bhikkhave rupam cattari mahabhiitani, XIV. 4. 3. Yain kihci Bhikkhave riipam atltanagatapaccuppannam, I. 6. 59. Yasmim kho Subhadda dhamniavinaye, XX. 5. 6. Yasmim Bhikkhave samaye ariyasavakassa virajam, I. 4. 19; II. 2^21. Yassa kassaci Ananda cattaro iddhipada, XI. 5. 6. Yayam tanha ponobhavika, XIII. 9. 4; XIII. 10. 4. Ye kahkha samatikkanta, II. 3. 20. Ye te Bhikkhave bhikkhu puthujiana silasampanna, II. 1. 21. Eahho Bhikkhave Cakkavat- tissa patubhava, I. 9. 8. Labha vo Bhikkhave, snlad- dhaiu vo Bhikkhave, II. 8. 4. and 5. Vihiianapaccaya Bhikkhave jati,'xV. 2. 3. Vitatanho anadano, I. 2. 57. Sa sattakkhattuparamam san- dhavitvana puggalo, I. 1. 159. Sacayam Ananda samiddhi moghapuriso, VIII. 9. 39. Santi Bhikkhave Asahhasatta nama deva, III. 11. 5. Saddha hiriyam knsalaii ca danam, VII. 4. 4. Sappikumbho ti, I. 1. 244. Sabbam Bhikkhave anabhi- janain, II. 2. 19. Sabbam Bhikkhave adittam, II. 8. 2. Sabbabhibhii sabbavidii' ham asmi, IV. 8. 7. Sabbe dliamma anatta ti, I. 1. 238. Sabbe samkhara anicca ti, XVI. 4.' 5. Samkhittena pi kho aham Sariputta, XVIII. 2. 3. Samghe GotamI dehi, XVII. 9". 3. Sammaditthi Bhikkhave ase- vita, XXII. 7. 4. Sammukha me tarn avuso Bhagavato sutam, II. 9. 19. Sassato loko ti kho Vaccha, XIV. 8. 4. Saha v'assa dassanasampa- daya, I. 4. 18 ; II. 2. 20 ; II. 9. 20 and 21. INDICES. 637 Sikhissa Ananda bhagavato arahato, II. 5. 22. Sukho vivekt) tutthassa, II. ■8. 8. Sunnato iokam avekkhassti, I. 1. 234. Surinam idam Bhikkhave, XIX. 2. 6. Sunno loko sunno loko ti bhante vuccati I. 1. 241. Seyyathapi Bhikkhave mak- kato araiine pavane cara- mano, II. 7. 3. Seyyathapi Bhikkhave maha- samuddo anupubbaninno, 11. 9. 17. Seyyathapi Bhikkhave niaha- samuddo thitadhammo, XII. 7. 5. So evam aiiurodhavirodham samapanno, XIII. 8. 3. So evam samahite citte, III. 4. 7 ; XIII. 5. 2 ; XIII. 6. 2. So tassa kammassa katatta, XII. 3. 3. So hi nama Bhikkliave snnetto sattha, I. 5. 15. Ube ©resbam iprcss, UNWIN BROTHERS, WOKING AND LONDON. SOUTHERN REGIONAL LIBRARY FACILITY 305 De Neve Drive - Parking Lot 17 • Box 951388 LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90095-1388 Return this material to the library from which it was borrowed. r=' ? 7001 Form L9-50m-4,'61(B8994s4)444 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA-LOS ANGELES L 007 682 627 UC SOUTHERN RFGIONAL LIBRARY FACILITY AA 000 348 287 4 PK 4591 K3T2 \rr "t^^ ■■/:• W- ^C-^<^-i^^ "f^N^^ #^: ^c L.t%, •T/ ^ C V' '^'■l K ' • * ■:^Wv' ^ -^^^■ '^«-^ '^... La._>. ..•.^ V\