Digitized by the Internet Arciiive 
 
 in 2008 with funding from 
 
 IVIicrosoft Corporation 
 
 http://www.archive.org/details/ashtabulaplanofmOOashtrich 
 

 The Ashtabula Plan 
 of 
 Municipal Government ^ 
 
 The Commission- Manager Form with 
 Proportional Representation 
 
 \ 
 
 The text of the novel features of the Charter 
 and an account of the first election Nov- 
 ember 2, 1915 
 
 PUBLISHED BY THE 
 
 Iashtabula chamber of commerce 
 
 *"' ASHTABULA, OHIO 
 
 Copies of this pamphlet may also be obtained on request from 
 
 The National Short Ballot Organization, 381 4th Avenue, N. Y. 
 
 (Which publishes other pamphlets on the Commission-Manager Plan) 
 
 The American Proportional Representation League, Haverford, Pa- 
 
 (Which publishes other pamphlets on Proportional Representation) 
 
The Ashtabula Plan 
 
 
 This pamphlet is intended to provide a careful answer to the 
 many questions that are being addressed to Ashtabula in regard to its 
 unique new plan of government. 
 
 Ashtabula, Ohio, is a thriving industrial community of about 
 20,000 population (18,266 in the 1910 Census). Politically its history 
 has been uneventful except for the incessant contests between wets 
 and drys on the liquor question, on which the city divides very evenly, 
 sometimes inclining to one side and sometimes to the other. There 
 was no serious allegation of graft in the old mayor-and-council gov- 
 ernment: the new charter was adopted mainly to realize the benefits 
 of the home-rule provisions of the new state constitution and to mod- 
 ernize and simplify the municipal machinery. 
 
 General Charter Provisions 
 
 The govefn^g body, is a body of seven members elected at large 
 by the Hare system of proportional representation for a term of two 
 years. Salary pf.membiers; $100 a year, with $50 extra for the chair- 
 man (called presid'eiit)'. -No* other elective officers in the city govern- 
 ment — a Short Ballot facilitating control by the people. 
 
 The council is instructed to "appoint a City Manager who shall 
 be the administrative head of the municipal government under the 
 direction and supervision of the Council and who shall hold office at 
 the pleasure of the Council." The council also appoints the City 
 Solicitor, City Treasurer, Health Officer, City Auditor, and Civil Ser- 
 vice Commission. All other appointments are in the hands of the 
 Manager. 
 
 The charter includes the Initiative, Referendum, and Recall. 
 
 Except for the unique proportional representation feature, it will 
 be seen that the charter conforms to the commission-manager plan of 
 Dayton, Springfield, and some forty other American cities. 
 
 Ashtabula takes its position in the following sequence of pioneers 
 in municipal government. 
 
 1900 Galveston Commission Plan 
 
 1905 Pes Moines Commission Plan with non-partisan elections 
 
 and other improvements 
 (copied by over 350 cities) 
 
 1913 Dayton Commission Plan with City Manager 
 
 (copied by 40 cities up to date) 
 
 1914 Cadillac Commission-Manager Plan with Preferential 
 
 Ballot 
 
 (copied by 4 cities) 
 
 1915 Ashtabula Commission-Manager Plan with Proportion- 
 
 al Representation 
 
 2 
 
> tCi^ 
 
 The First Proportional Representation Election in America' 
 
 By A. R. HATTON 
 
 Professor of Political Science, Western Reserve University 
 
 Has Ashtabula shown the way to the final type of city government 
 on this continent ? There is more than a fair chance that she has. 
 
 Ashtabula chose a Charter Commission under the Ohio home rule 
 amendment early in 1914. The Commission elected was favorable to 
 the Commission-Manager Plan of government with a council elected at 
 large. 
 
 Already, however, the objection had been advanced in Ashtabula 
 that a council elected at large in the usual way would probably repre- 
 sent only one party, and that this was not desirable if the council was 
 to choose the Manager, who was expected to be a permanent expert 
 non-political official. 
 
 The man who had brought this idea to Ashtabula was C. G. Hoag, 
 General Secretary of the American Proportional Representation 
 League. Mr. Hoag was invited to address the Charter Commission at 
 its first formal meeting. On that occasion he again proposed, as a way 
 out of the difficulty, the election of the council at large by proportional 
 representation. Several members of the Commission accepted the idea 
 as sound in theory. One of them, Mr. W. E. Boynton, an engineer on 
 the Lake Shore Railroad, who had previously been President of the 
 City Council, embraced the proposal with enthusiasm, thoroughly 
 acquainted himself with the proportional system, and became the de- 
 voted and efficient leader of a campaign for its adoption by Ashtabula. 
 
 The Commission finally rejected proportional representation as a 
 novelty likely to jeopardize the acceptance of the charter as a whole 
 when submitted to the voters. As submitted in November, 1914, the 
 charter provided for a council of seven, nominated by a 5 per cent 
 petition and to be elected at large in the usual way on a non-partisan 
 ballot. This charter was adopted. 
 
 Although Mr. Boynton is quiet, he is persistent. He at once set 
 about to initiate his proportional representation amendment to the 
 new charter. This amendment was voted on in August, 1915, before 
 the first election of the council. 
 
 ♦From the Cleveland Plain Dealer, November 8th, with Changes 
 Sanctioned by the Author 
 
 3 
 
Though the vote was light, proportional representation carried in 
 all but five of the fifteen precincts of the city. It was under this 
 amendment that Aish tabula elected its first council under the new 
 charter. 
 
 .-, f /.' '}■ : '. !Whaf is Proportional Representation? 
 
 The theory of proportional representation is that each consider- 
 able party or group of opinion should be represented in the council 
 or representative body in proportion to its voting strength. Thus if, 
 in an election at which seven representatives are to be chosen, the 
 Democrats cast four-sevenths, the Republicans two-sevenths, and the 
 Socialists one-seventh of the vote, those parties should be represented 
 in the council by four, two, and one representative respectively. 
 
 If the division of opinion is not along party lines, the divisions 
 should nevertheless be represented in proportion to their voting 
 strength. 
 
 In Ashtabula the lines of division in the recent election had little 
 to do with national parties except that there was a Socialist group. 
 There was first the question of local representation. The Harbor dis- 
 trict lies at some distance from the city proper. Under the old ward 
 plan this district had always been represented by one member of the 
 council. Under the usual plan of election at large it would probably 
 not have been represented at all. Then there is in Ashtabula the 
 question of nationalities. The city has a large foreign element, the 
 chief groups being Irish, Italians, Swedes, and Finns. 
 
 The voters are also sharply divided on the liquor issue, the city 
 swaying first to the dry and then to the wet side. Finally, there is the 
 question of adequate representation for the substantial business ele- 
 ment of the community. It will be interesting to note the extent to 
 which these various groups and interests secured representation at 
 the recent election. 
 
 There are several plans of proportional representation. That 
 adopted is the Hare plan. 
 
 There are seven members of the council to be chosen. The candi- 
 dates get their names on the ballot by filing a petition signed by 2 per 
 cent of the voters. No voter can sign a petition for more than one 
 candidate. The ballot has no party marks. The voter marks his 
 preferences for as many candidates as he pleases, the figure 1 for his 
 first choice, the figure 2 for his second choice, etc. Though any num- 
 ber of preferences may be marked, and though seven members are to 
 be elected, no ballot can be actually counted for more than one candi- 
 date. In order to be elected a candidate does not need a majority, 
 or even a plurality of all the votes, but only a trifle more than an 
 eighth of them. 
 
 To determine the number of votes necessary for election to the 
 council the total number of valid ballots is divided by eight, and the 
 whole number next higher than the quotient thus secured is taken as 
 the number of votes required to elect. This number is chosen because 
 
 4 
 
it is the smallest whole number that can be taken seven but not eight 
 times from the total. In other words, it would be possible for seven 
 candidates to get that many votes out of a given total but eight could 
 not possibly do so. 
 
 In Ashtabula the total number of valid ballots cast was 2,972. 
 This number divided by 8 gives a quotient of 371 -}. The next whole 
 number larger than this quotient is 372, and this was therefore the 
 number of votes required for election. The number so established 
 is known as the "quota" or constituency. 
 
 One^j&agdidaLfe, SrcCIii re. r e f^^^'^'^d n^nvo thg n tj^ i s numbe r of first- tI 
 chp«!^otes, namely 392. '.The extra 20 ballots, taken fromTnS ballotsk^ '^^ 
 ft random but equally from'Ti ie, b attots of each precinct, were trans- ) *^^, 
 ferred to second-choice candidates, each one in accordance withjl 
 instructions given by the voter's figures on the ballot. Fjic--ers?irriple, 
 
 .these 20 ballo ts were tra flsferrejl.lflLMcCaaeHjgeause on them ^ W^ 
 McCune 's name was marked with the figure 2. a* 1 7^ 
 
 Next, the candidate having fewest votes was declared defeated AAk 
 and out of the count, and all his ballots were distributed to other can- Pn Jj_ • 
 didates in the same way. This done, the candidate now lowest was i^ 
 declared defeated and out, and his ballots transferred. And so the 
 count proceeded until all the ballots except an odd remainder found 
 their way into one or another of seven surviving piles. 
 
 An abstract explanation of the process gives an impression of 
 great complexity. When it came to the actual work of the count, 
 however, no trouble whatever arose. Although the board of election 
 had had no previous experience with such a system and was without 
 proper office equipment for handling such a ballot, the transferring 
 of the ballots and the tabulation of the vote was accomplished in about 
 three hours. At no time were the officials in serious doubt concerning 
 the steps to be taken. 
 
 ♦ * ♦ 
 
 "With one exception the seven standing highest on first-choice 
 votes were finally elected, the exception being Mr. Rinto, a young 
 Finnish lawyer. McCune, Hogan, Briggs, and Corrado, four of the 
 successful candidates, are members of the present city council. The 
 other three candidates who are members of the present council were 
 defeated. 
 
 How well do the men chosen represent the city? McClure is man- 
 ager of a department in one of the large stores. Hogan is one of the 
 leading physicians of Ashtabula, McCune is a greenhouse man, Gud- 
 mundson assistant cashier of a bank in the Harbor district, Earlywine 
 clerk and paymaster of a large ore company, Briggs a newspaper 
 man, and Carrado a saloon-keeper. 
 
 The business element may be said to have three representatives. 
 The Irish, Swedes, and Italians each elected a member. The Socialists 
 elected one member, and the Harbor district is represented. On the 
 liquor issue, three of the successful candidates are pronounced drys, 
 three are classed as liberal, and one as very wet. 
 
In general, the opinion in Ashtabula seems to be that, taking both 
 quality and representative character into consideration, a better 
 choice could hardly have been made from the list of candidates. It 
 is generally agreed that the new council will contain more ability than 
 the present one elected on the ward plan, and that it will aho be more 
 representative of the entire body of the voters. 
 
 I think it may be said that Ashtabula has shown other cities the 
 way. They have been shown how to elect a council in a manner to 
 provide equitable representation to all parties and interests; a plan 
 under which the majority will control while the minority or minor- 
 ities will have representation in proportion to their actual importance. 
 
 Under the Ashtabula system we may expect the quality of the 
 council to improve. When groups of opinion come to understand 
 that if they have a little more than one-eighth of the vote they cannot 
 be denied representation in the council, their ablest representatives will 
 be willing to become candidates. Men of high professional and busi- 
 ness ability will stand for election to the council because they will be 
 sure that if they really represent their element they will win. Gerry- 
 mandering and a large measure of political jockeying and wire- 
 pulling will disappear. Parties will be obliged to find a basis on 
 principle rather than largely on patronage, as is the case at the pres- 
 ent time. 
 
 The manager-plan opens the way for permanent, expert service 
 in city administration and for the elimination of politics from that 
 part of our municipal governments. Proportional representation will 
 provide a council which may properly be allowed to choose a city 
 manager — a council which is truly representative, the members of 
 which stand for policies and the fundamental interests of the commun- 
 ity rather than for a more or less artificial party organization. 
 
 Ashtabula has a short ballot, the manager-plan, and a council 
 chosen by proportional representation. That is the latest word in 
 city government, and as yet no one has arisen to suggest that any- 
 thing further can be said. 
 
From the Ashtabula ''Beacon," Nov. 5, 1915 
 
 Proportional representation has been demonstrated and found 
 better than expected. 
 
 In analyzing the results we find that all sections and factions are 
 represented in the new council. There are two from the first ward, 
 one from the second, two from the third, and two from the fourth. 
 Three from the Harbor and four from uptown. One from the east 
 side and two from the west side at the Harbor. One from the west 
 end, one from the south end, and two from the central portion of the 
 uptown section of the city. Four of the old council were re-elected. 
 
 The drys and wets are represented. The Protestants and Cath- 
 olics, the business, professional and laboring men. the Kepublicans, 
 Democrats, Socialists, the English, Swedes, and Italians are all repre- 
 sented, while there were more divisions than places. 
 
 It would be hard to select a more representative council in any 
 other way. 
 
 From the Ashtabula "Star," Nov. 5, 1915 
 
 It is generally conceded that it [the new voting system] has given 
 Ashtabula a broadly representative council, probably the most repre- 
 sentative body in the city's history. 
 
 The ward system elects each councilman by a con- 
 stituency of voters who live together and think apart. 
 
 The proportional system elects each councilman by a 
 constituency of voters who live apart and think together. 
 
First Proportional Election in Ashtabula, November 2, 1915 
 
 FOR THE SEVEN MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL 
 
 Procedure 
 
 1. Ascertain the quota. (The total number of valid ballots was 
 
 2,972) 2,972 divided by 8=371f 
 
 The next number larger than this quotient, namely 372, 
 is the "quota" or constituency, i. e. enough to elect, being 
 the smallest number which seven, but not eight, candidates 
 can get. 
 
 2. First-choice votes. McClure, having more first-choice votes than 
 
 the quota, was forthwith declared elected and out of the 
 count. 
 
 Tke figures referred to in each of the folio Mring ptu-agraphs will appear directly opposite in the table. 
 
 3. The 20 surplus ballots of McClure were taken at random from his 
 
 ballots (an equal number being drawn from the returns of 
 each precinct) and transferred, each one separately accord- 
 ing to the second choice indicated on it. 
 
 4. Lampela, the lowest man, was now declared defeated and out of 
 
 the count, and all his ballots (except those on which no 
 available lower choice was indicated) were transferred in the 
 same way. If the second choice on a ballot was McClure, 
 that ballot was transferred according to third choice, of 
 course, since McClure had already been elected. 
 
 5. Loose, the man now lowest, was next declared defeated and out of 
 
 the count, and his ballots were transferred just as Lampela's 
 had been. (Note that only 64 out of Loose's 107 ballots 
 could be transferred because only 64 of them had marked an 
 available lower choice. For example, a ballot marked only 
 for Loose as first, McClure as second, and Lampela as third 
 choice could not be transferred, because McClure had been 
 elected and Lampela had been eliminated.) 
 
 6. Cook, the man now lowest, was declared out and his ballots 
 
 transferred. 
 
 7. Carlson and Flower were now tied for lowest place, with 165 votes 
 
 each. Carlson, who had been the lower of the two at the 
 previous count, was declared out and his ballots transferred. 
 
 8. Flower, now lowest, was declared out and his ballots transferred. 
 
 Before this transfer was finished, Hogan had the quota and 
 was declared elected. 
 
 9. Tilton, now lowest, was declared out and his ballots transferred. 
 
 This brought McCune's votes up to the quota and elected 
 him. 
 
 10. Rinto, being now lowest, was declared out. As this left only 
 
 seven candidates standing, it was unnecessary to count 
 further. (Rinto had stood higher than either Corrado or 
 Briggs on first choices, but he was not well known except in 
 his own section and so did not attract many second and 
 lower choices.) 
 

 
 For ar 
 
 I explanation ol 
 
 each 1 
 
 ne of figures, see paragraph directly opposite. 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 B 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 O 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 > 
 
 tfi 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 <u 
 
 -a 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 0) 
 
 
 aj 
 
 c 
 
 c 
 
 
 ^ 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 J2 
 
 u 
 3 
 
 u 
 
 c 
 
 c 
 
 =3 
 
 u 
 
 
 3 
 
 be 
 
 -a 
 
 u 
 u 
 
 o 
 
 ■4-1 
 J3 
 
 c 
 o 
 
 4-1 
 
 
 3 
 O 
 
 J4 
 
 O 
 
 (V 
 
 o 
 
 a 
 S 
 
 u 
 
 O 
 
 o 
 
 rt 
 
 3 
 
 *n 
 
 O 
 
 
 rs 
 
 o 
 
 03 
 
 o 
 
 o 
 
 03 
 
 S 
 
 X 
 
 ^ 
 
 W 
 
 o 
 
 PQ 
 
 U 
 
 s 
 
 H 
 
 E 
 
 u 
 
 U 
 
 J 
 
 J 
 
 392 
 
 322 
 
 309 
 
 289 
 
 292 
 
 211 
 
 196 
 
 237 
 
 193 
 
 147 
 
 138 
 
 114 
 
 107 
 
 25 
 
 
 
 
 11 
 
 2 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 1 
 
 1 
 
 2 
 
 2 
 
 
 
 1 
 
 
 
 
 1 
 
 3 
 
 1 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 4 
 
 
 
 1 
 
 1 
 
 1 
 
 
 
 
 
 12 
 
 10 
 
 6 
 
 
 
 2 
 
 5 
 
 2 
 
 3 
 
 10 
 
 14 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 5 
 
 3 
 
 11 
 
 6 
 
 3 
 
 10 
 
 1 
 
 3 
 
 5 
 
 10 
 
 
 
 
 
 24 
 
 1 
 
 8 
 
 12 
 
 16 
 
 32 
 
 2 
 
 4 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 8 
 
 27 
 8 
 
 6 
 
 38 
 
 9 
 
 24 
 
 20 
 34 
 
 30 
 9 
 
 2 
 14 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 372 
 
 372 
 
 372 
 
 361 
 
 343 
 
 286 
 
 282 
 
 263 
 
 204 
 
 165 
 
 165 
 
 115 
 
 108 
 
 25 
 
 Elected 
 
 -Defeated- 
 
Advantages of Proportional Representation 
 
 This system of voting is known as the Hare plan of proportional 
 representation. It is new to America, but has been used successfully 
 for a number of years in Tasmania and South Africa. It is considered 
 to offer the fullest and freest expression of the opinions of the elector- 
 ate. Its expected advantages over the common plurality system are 
 as follows: 
 
 1. It gives proportional representation, i. e., it gives each party 
 or group of voters its due proportionate share of members in the coun- 
 cil or commission. Instead of electing a solid block of seven dry or 
 seven wet Republicans, Ashtabula elected four Republicans, two Dem- 
 ocrats, and a Socialist, of whom three were classed as dry, and four as 
 liberal or wet. // is just, making the body that spends the taxes of all truly 
 representative of all. 
 
 2. The stahiliiy and continuity of membership in the council, 
 through successive terms, will be much greater. The tenure of a good 
 Manager is thereby made more secure. A ten per cent fluctuation in 
 public opinion will produce only a corresponding change in the coun- 
 cil, whereas under the common at-large method the swing of ten per 
 cent may produce either a hundred per cent overturn in the personnel 
 of the governing body or no change at all. 
 
 3. The voter can vote exactly as he desires with no fear of wast- 
 ing his vote. A Prohibitionist, for instance, may mark his sentimental 
 first choice for a probably hopeless Prohibition candidate and yet also 
 turn his influence toward the selection of some one who has a better 
 chance of election. 
 
 4. No political organization, or caucusing of any kind to prevent 
 a group of voters from being split among too many acceptable candi- 
 dates, is necessary. The alternative second and lower choices will 
 automatically bring the group together again in the count. The whole 
 field of political bluff and strategy is swept away. A minority, no 
 matter how compact and well-drilled in its machine organization, can- 
 not capture the control, no matter how split up and disorganized the 
 opposition may be. The scheme makes machines weaker but makes 
 live parties stronger, 
 
 5. The voter can make his ballot a possible source of strength 
 to any candidate he approves of, no matter how many such there may 
 be in the field. 
 
 6. The Short Ballot principle is conserved without either concen- 
 trating the power into the hands of a very small commission or divid- 
 ing the city into districts. 
 
 10 
 
7. It tends to secure for the administration the co-operation of all 
 interests and of all sections of public opinion. This great advan- 
 tage of the system was recently brought out by Dr. Lent D. Upson, 
 formerly Director of the Bureau of Municipal Research of Dayton, 
 where the Manager Plan gives the city an administration of splendid 
 efficiency and zeal for the public welfare but where the commission, 
 elected at large by the majority system, represents only the one dom- 
 inant group in the city. 
 
 The experience of a year and a half has now demonstrated 
 the need of a more satisfactory method of connecting public 
 opinion with the government itself. Our administration is 
 honest, highly efficient, and has exceeded my most enthusias- 
 tic expectation so far as results are concerned. I feel, how- 
 ever, that its work would be strengthened if every element 
 had a voice in the policy-making body, and were compelled to 
 go on record regarding the very matters which they are now 
 criticizing. 
 
 I have said this publicly a number of times, and in a num- 
 ber of published articles. I feel confident that the greatest 
 success of our present type of government will come under 
 some system of proportional representation. 
 
 11 
 
Sample of the Ashtabula Ballot as 
 marked by a voter 
 
 The voter who marked 
 his ballot as indicated said 
 to the Tally Clerk in effect: 
 "Count this ballot for Mr. 
 Lampela, who is my first 
 choice; but if he does not 
 need my vote, or if it is 
 found that he is so weak 
 that votes for him are 
 useless, transfer this ballot 
 to my second choice, Mr. 
 McClure; if my vote cannot 
 help either Mr. Lampela or 
 Mr. McClure, count it for 
 Mr. Hogan, and so on." 
 
 As Mr. Lampela was 
 found in the counting to 
 be hopelessly weak, this 
 ballot was available for Mr. 
 McClure. But Mr. McClure 
 did not need it, already 
 having votes enough to 
 elect him. Therefore the 
 ballot went to Mr. Hogan, 
 and was one of the 372 bal- 
 lots that elected him. 
 
 
 1 MUNICIPAL TICKET 
 
 
 DIRECTIONS TO VOTERS - 
 
 Put the figure 1 opposite the name of = 
 
 your first choice for the Council. If you — 
 
 : want to express also second, third, and — 
 
 : other preferences, do so by putting the = 
 
 = figure 2 opposite the name of your second — 
 
 - choice, the figure 3 opposite the name of — 
 
 - your third choice, and so on. You may — 
 
 - express thus as many preferences as you — 
 
 - please. This ballot will not be counted — 
 
 - for your second choice unless it is found — 
 
 - that it cannot help your first; it will not — 
 
 - be counted for your third choice unless it — 
 
 - is found that it cannot help either your z= 
 J first or your second; etc. The more tJ 
 
 - choices you express, the surer you are to _ 
 
 - make your ballot count for one of the ^^ 
 
 - candidates you favor. — 
 
 A ballot is spoiled if the figure 1 is put _ 
 
 - opposite more than one name. If you :_ 
 
 - spoil this ballot, tear it across once, re- — 
 
 - turn it to the election officer in charge of — 
 
 - the ballots, and get another from him. — 
 
 ~ 
 
 I ' 
 
 For Members of Council = 
 FRED A. BRIGGS - 
 
 E 
 
 JOHN CARLSON — 
 
 
 E 
 
 M. R. COOK - 
 
 :: 
 
 = 
 
 NICK CORRADO ^ 
 
 = 
 
 1 5 
 
 ROBT. W. EARLYWINE = 
 
 E 
 
 JAMES H. FLOWER - 
 
 
 — 
 
 C. 0. GUDMUNDSON - 
 
 
 1 3 
 
 J. J. HOGAN - 
 
 
 1 1 
 
 ROBERT LAMPELA - 
 
 
 E 
 
 GEORGE H. LOOSE 
 
 
 1 2 
 
 J. H. McCLURE = 
 
 
 1 
 
 E. R. McCUNE = 
 
 
 E 
 
 ARTHUR RINTO - 
 
 
 1 4 
 
 E. N. TILTON tJ 
 
 12 
 
Proportional Representation in Ashtabula 
 
 A Statement of the Facts Concerning: the Adoption of Proportional Represen- 
 tation and the First E^lectlon Held Thereunder In the City of Ashtabula, 
 by the Chamber of Commerce. 
 
 ♦•* In 1913 Mr. W. E. Boynton, who was at the time a member of this Cham- 
 ber, first brought the matter [proportional representation] before the Chamber 
 and later Mr. C. G. Hoag, General Secretary-Treasurer of the American Pro- 
 portional Representation League, appeared and addressed the Chamber upon 
 this subject. 
 
 Under the provisions of the Constitution of Ohio adopted in 1912, the prop- 
 osition of a new charter for this city was taken up by the Chamber, and we 
 were largely instrumental in bringing about the election of the Charter Com- 
 mission at the November election in 1913. 
 
 Proportional Representation was ably advocated before the Charter Com- 
 mission by Mr. Boynton, Mr. Hoag and others, but was rejected by a vote of 10 
 to 5. The charter prepared by the Commission was adopted at the November 
 election in 1914 to take effect on the first of January, 1916. In the spring of 
 1915 petitions were circulated to secure a vote upon an amendment to the char- 
 ter so that the Council first to be elected under the new charter, in November, 
 1915, should be elected by the proportional representation method. A special 
 election upon this charter amendment was held August 10th, 1915, and was 
 participated in by 988 voters, which number was about one-fourth of the total 
 vote of this city. The Amendment was adopted by a vote of 588 to 400, and 
 the first election for seven members of Council under the charter as so amended 
 was held November 2, 1915. 
 
 In this election 3334 votes were cast, of which 362 were thrown out as in- 
 valid. The quota required for election was 372. Of the seven members de- 
 clared elected one member was elected on flrs't choice ballots with a surplus of 
 20 votes. Another was elected on the 7th count, another on the 8th count; and 
 the remaining four, having respectively 361, 343, 286 and 282 votes, were declared 
 elected under the provisions of the amendment, that when the candidates have 
 been eliminated down to the number to be elected, those candidates remaining 
 shall be declared elected whether having the quota of votes or not. During 
 the process of transfer 321 votes were rendered ineffective through the failure 
 of the voters to mark sufficient choices. No great difficulty was experienced 
 In counting and transferring the ballots, the matter of transferring being com- 
 pleted in about three hours. 
 
 The result of the first election seems to have given the city a fairly repre- 
 sentative council, in which nearly all elements sufficiently important to be en- 
 titled to representation have selected one or more members. Ashtabula is a city 
 of about 22,000 people, located on the south shore of Lake Erie. It has a magnif- 
 icent harbor, with the greatest ore receiving and coal shipping facilities in the 
 world. Formerly a large amount of labor was required in dock operations so 
 that a considerable proportion of our population is of foreign birth. Of the 
 numerous nationalities represented here the only three that have sufficient 
 voting strength to approximate a quota are the Italians, Swedes and Finns. The 
 council-elect contains one member of Italian birth and one of Swedish birth. 
 The city is divided into four wards. The council-elect contains two members 
 from the first ward, one from the second, two from the third, and two from the 
 fourth, which is perhaps as near in proportion as may be to the proportionate 
 voting strength of the four wards. 
 
 The members of the council-elect consist of four Republicans, two Dem- 
 ocrats and one Socialist. While the Republican and Democratic strength is 
 more nearly equal, the election of one member fairly represents the voting 
 strength of the Socialist party. The most important issue before the voters 
 at this election was the wet and dry question, and the City of Ashtabula re- 
 turned a dry majority of 327. Of the members of council-elect three are dry, 
 three are liberal, and one very wet. 
 
 Whether the organization of this council, its appointments of the adminis- 
 trative officers of the City, and its conduct of municipal affairs, will result 
 In an efficient, economical administration of the business of the City, time will 
 tell. 
 
 (Signed) Legislative Committee, 
 
 F. R. HOGUE 
 B. P. HALL 
 J. M. McCLURE. 
 
 The above report was unanimously adopted by the members of the Chamber 
 of Commerce of the City of Ashtabula at a meeting held on the fifteenth day 
 of November, 1915. 
 
 (Seal of the Chamber) 
 
 Attest: THEODORE HALL, Secretary. 
 
 13 
 
Text of the Election Provisions 
 
 of the 
 
 Ashtabula Charter 
 
 (The only officials elected are the seven members of the council) 
 
 Marking the Ballot 
 
 Section 46-1. Ballots for the election of members of the Council shall be 
 marked according to the following: rules and the same shall be printed at the 
 top of each ballot under the head of "Directions to Voters:" [Here follow the 
 directions to voters as given on the sample ballot on a previous page.] 
 
 Rules for Counting the Ballots 
 
 Section 46-2. Ballots cast for the election of members of the council shall 
 be counted and the results determined by the election authorities according to 
 the following rules: 
 
 (a) No ballot shall be declared invalid except one on which the first choice 
 of the voter cannot be clearly ascertained. A ballot marked with a cross 
 opposite one name, but with no other mark, shall be treated exactly as if It 
 had been marked with a figure 1 opposite the same name, but with no other 
 mark. 
 
 (b) The ballots shall first be sorted and counted at the several voting 
 precincts according to the first choice of the voters. The valid ballots so cast 
 for each candidate shall be sorted into two groups, that of valid ballots on which 
 the voter's second choice is clearly indicated and that of valid ballots on which 
 his second choice is not clearly indicated. Each such group shall be tied up 
 by itself and properly marked on the outside and the two for each candidate 
 shall then be tied up in one bundle which shall also be properly marked on the 
 outside. All the bundles thus made up at a precinct, together with the invalid 
 ballots and a record of all the ballots cast at the precinct, showing the number 
 of invalid ballots, the number of valid ballots, the total number of first-choice 
 ballots for each candidate, and the number of ballots in each of the two groups 
 of first-choice ballots received by each candidate, shall be forwarded to the 
 Board of Deputy State Supervisors of Elections, as directed by that Board, and 
 the counting of the ballots shall proceed under its direction. 
 
 (c) First-choice votes for each candidate shall be added and tabulated as 
 the first count. 
 
 (d) The whole number of valid ballots shall then be divided by a number 
 greater by one than the number of seats to be filled. The next whole number 
 larger than the quotient thus obtained shall be the quota or constituency. 
 
 (e) All candidates the number of whotre votes on the first count is equal 
 to or greater than the quota shall then be declared elected. 
 
 (f) All votes obtained by any candidate in excess of the quota shall be 
 termed the surplus of that candidate. 
 
 (g) The surpluses shall be transferred, successively In order of size from 
 the largest to the smallest. Each ballot of the surplus that is capable of trans- 
 fer shall be transferred to and added to the votes of continuing candidates, 
 according to the higrhest available preference on it. 
 
 (h) "Ballots capable of transfer" means ballots from which the preference 
 of the voter for some continuing candidate can be clearly ascertained. "Con- 
 tinuing candidates" means candidates who have not been declared elected or 
 defeated. 
 
 14 
 
(I) The particular ballots to be taken for transfer as the surplus of such 
 candidate shall be obtained by taking as nearly an equal number of ballots 
 as possible from the first-choice ballots, capable of transfer, that have been 
 cast for the candidate in each of the different precincts of the city. All such 
 surplus ballots shall be taken as they may happen to come In the different 
 packages without selection. 
 
 (j) After the transfer of all surpluses the votes standing to the credit 
 of each candidate shall be counted and tabulated as the second count. 
 
 (k) After the tabulation of the second count (or after that of the first 
 count if no candidate received a surplus on the first) the candidate lowest on 
 the poll as it then stands shall be declared defeated and all his ballots capable of 
 transfer shall be transferred to the continuing candidates, each ballot being 
 transferred to the credit of that continuing candidate preferred by the voter. 
 After the transfer of these ballots a fresh count and tabulation shall be made. 
 In this manner candidates s'hall be successively declared defeated, and their 
 ballots capable of transfer transferred to continuing candidates, and a fresh 
 count and tabulation made. After any tabulation the candidate to be declared 
 defeated shall be the one then lowest on the poll. 
 
 (1) Whenever in the transfer of a surplus or of the ballots of a defeated 
 candidate the votes" of any candidate shall equal the quota, he shall immediately 
 be declared elected and no further transfer to him shall be made. 
 
 (m) When candidates to the number of the seats to be filled have been de- 
 clared elected, all other candidates shall be declared defeated and the count 
 shall be at an end; and when the number of continuing candidates shall be re- 
 duced to the number of seats to be filled, those candidates' shall be declared 
 elected and the count shall be at an end; and In this case the ballots of the last 
 candidate defeated need not be transferred, 
 
 (n) If at any count two or more candidates at the bottom of the poll have 
 the same number of votes, that candidate shall first be declared defeated who 
 was lowest at the next preceding count at which their votes were different. 
 Should it happen that the votes of these candidates are equal to each other on 
 all counts, lots shall be drawn to decide which candidate shall next be declared 
 defeated. 
 
 (o) In the transfer of the ballots of any candidate who has received bal- 
 lots by transfer, those ballots shall first be transferred upon which the defeated 
 candidate was first choice. 
 
 (p) On each tabulation a count shall be kept of those ballots which have 
 not been used in the election of some candidate and which are not capable of 
 transfer, under the designation "Non-transferable ballots." 
 
 (q) Every ballot that is transferred from one candidate to another shall 
 be stamped or marked so that its entire course from candidate to candidate 
 throughout the count can be conveniently traced. In case a recount of the 
 ballots is made, every ballot shall be made to take in the recount the same 
 course that it took in the first count unless there is discovered a mistake that 
 requires its taking a different course, in which case such mistake shall be cor- 
 rected and any changes' made in the course taken by ballots that may be requir- 
 ed as a result of such correction. The particular ballots the course of which is 
 to be changed in the recount as a result of such corrections shall be taken as 
 they happen to come, without selection. 
 
 (r) So far as may be consistent with good order and with convenience In 
 the counting and transferring of the ballots, the public, representatives of the 
 press, and especially the candidates themselves shall be afforded every facility 
 for being present and witnessing these operations. 
 
 15 
 
Ashtabula 
 
 Situated on the south shore of Lake Erie in north 
 eastern Ohio, midway between New York and 
 Chicago . 
 
 Population at last federal census was 18,266. Is now 
 about 21,000. 
 
 Climate healthful, tempered both summer and winter 
 by adjacent Lake Erie. 
 
 Excellent transportation facilities afforded by two great 
 trunk lines east and west, the New York Central 
 Lines and the Nickel Plate, by branch lines of the 
 New York Central and the Pennsylvania Company 
 to the south, and by the gigantic waterway system 
 of the Great Lakes to the north and north-west. 
 Trolley connections also with Cleveland and 
 Buffalo. 
 
 Water obtained from Lake Erie in abundance and fil- 
 tered before distribution. 
 
 Highly efficient municipal electric light and power 
 plant. 
 
 Natural gas available for all purposes. Found in great 
 quantities within three miles of the city. 
 
 Oil found within two miles of the city. 
 
 Coal abundant and cheap from the Pennsylvania and 
 West Virginia fields. 
 
 Over two hundred acres of public parks. 
 
 Schools ample and thoroughly modernized. 
 
 Enormous quantities of iron ore and coal handled 
 annually. Dock facilities for unloading 20,000,000 
 tons of iron ore from lake boats each season. 
 
 Ship yards and dry-docks for the construction and 
 repair of the largest lake freighters. 
 
 Labor troubles unknown. 
 
 Many desirable factory sites available. 
 
 Write Theodore Hall, Secretary Chamber of Commerce, 
 Ashtabula, 0., for further information. 
 
LIBRARY USE 
 
 RETURN TO DESK FROM WHICH BORROWED 
 
 MAIN LIBRARY 
 CIRCULATION DEPARTMENT 
 
 „, THIS BOOK IS DUE BEFORE CXOSING TIME 
 ^ ON LAST DATE STAMPED BELOW 
 
 
 LD62A-30ot-7,'73 General Library 
 
 (R227Bl0)94l2-A-32 University of California 
 
 Berkeley 
 
 LD z!Vlwbm-6, 56 Universi 
 
 General Library _ 
 uu ^-rivv,.,. -, -- University of California 
 
 (B931l8l0)476 Berkeley 
 
Pamphlet 
 
 Binder 
 
 Gaylord Bros., Inc. 
 
 Stockton, Calif. 
 T. M. Reg. U.S. Pat. Off. . 
 
 iiii'iinii iiiiii 
 
 CDBiaBDTT? 
 
 987284 TSsf47 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA UBRARY 
 
 •■ \ •