&4 y *> Cds.i x V d A 4>< // < V ^ US 25" THE LIBRARY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA OGDEN LIBRARY Digitized by the Internet Archive in,2008 with funding from r Microsoft Corporation http://www.archive.org/details/examendeingeniosOOhuarrich Ex amen de Inge mo s : OR, THE Crpal of WHt%. DISCOVERING The great Difference of WITS among Men, and what Sort of Learning fuits bed with each Ge- nius. Published Originally in Spanifh by Doftor Juan Huartes. An A made Englifh from the moft Correct Edition fy Mr. Bellamy. aifefulfo? all JFatljerg; S^afla%€uto?^&c. LONDON, Printed for EtC&atOSarf, at Grays-Inn-Gate mHolborn, MDCXCVIII. To the RIGHT HONOURABLE CHARLES MONTAGVE, Chancellor of His M A J E S T Y's Exchequer, 0ne of trie Lords of the Treafury, and a Member of His M A J E S T Y"s Moft Honourable Privy Council. TO whom can the Tryal of Wit f more properly belong, than to him that is every way qualified for one of the Tryers, if fuch, as it is to be wifli'd, were appointed by the State ? And who has a better Right to judge of the feveral Differences oiWit in Others^than A 2 ' he The Dedication^ he who has firft affembled and united them All in Himfelf fc fe The Difference of Studies feems not greater, than the Di- verfity of Talents in Men that are framed for them : The Ge- nius of a Logician lies not the fame way with that of a good Grammarian,infbmnch that DuU hardy Ludovkus Vives's Mafter, ufed to fay, as his Scholar himfelf has told us, that the worfl: Gram- marian would make the belt Lo- gician : Nor are the Talents of a Linguift the fame with thofe of a Mathematician, as appeared in a Tryal of Skill between an Eminent Linguift, and a Mathe- matician of nolefs Name, of ourdi Own, Bryan PValton y Bi{hop.o{ Cbefter, The Dedication. Cbefter, and Mr- Ougbtred upon a mutual Agreement between them, that each ftiould teach the other his Skill. The Succefs of which was no other than this, that tho' the Bifhop proceeded a great way in making Mr. Ougb- tred a good Oriental Linguift, yet ib far was the other in Re- turn from making the Bifhop a tolerable Mathematician, that he could never get hm to take out io plain a LefTon as that in Euclide of ab JEqualibur 3 ft demfferis JEqua- lia y manent JEqualia. And I find a htc* Italian Author taking no- ' tice of fuch Studies as will not well aflbciate and match toge- ther, particularly inftances in. thefe, A Poetical Pbyjician,a Pbi- Injofbkal Bartofa. The Dedication. lofopbical Hijiorian, a Mathema- tical Civilian; all which are, as he terms them, no lefi than Monfters in a Learn'd Academy. Nor is the Dilproportion between ie- veral Arts greater or more vifible, than even the Disparity between feveral Parts of the fatrie Art, of which, to fay no more, this may fuffice for Inftance, which hath been obferv'd by Painters, of Men of their own Profeflion, that the greateft Matters in Co- louring, have rarely or ever pro- ved good Defgnerfy and (o on the contrary : Whether it be eafier for Colours to meet and mingle, than to unite good Co- louring and Defign in the fame Picture j or whether it be that Painters The Dedication, Painters in this 'inherit the Fate of their own Colours, and that different Parts of their Employ- ment will no more unite thandi£ agreeing and unfbciable Colours, I leave to others to enquire. This only I take leave to fay, that nothing is more ordinary than for that as well as other Profef- fions to abound with Pedants, and Men of narrow Spirits,whofe Heads are filled with Images all of one Colour, whereas but few alas ! ( Sir ) befides Your fel£ appear of fbllniverfal and Com- municative a Genius arid .Capa- city as the Light, which is alike Friendly and Impartial in the Vifits it makes, and the Colours it receives, difdaining not to def cend The Dedication. cend equally to every Eye, and to communicate indifferently with all Colours. More I might add, but that You pofiefs another and a greater Quality of Light, which is the faireft Thing in the World, and yet it felf knows nothing of it , as Your Excellences are only unknown to Your Selt at the lame time as they Shine to Vi- fible to all the World of Your Admirers, and in particular to The Meanest of lour Servants, Edw. Bellamy. TO T O T H E READER. 1 Here prefent you Examen de Inge- nios, made Englifh from the Ori- ginal j whereas that which was done before^ was from the Italian, which of it felf was but a Tranflation. I /hall fay nothing in Difparagement of the Qld y or in Favour of this New Verjlon. 1 quejiion not but that Gentleman did his Be]}, as I have now done mine ; and I hope this Cu- rious and Critical Jge will kindly receive it j as being my Virgin-Ejjay ; which may encourage, me to proceed to teach fome more Spanifh Juthors of great Wit and Learn* ing (Strangers as yet to this Nation) foon to fpeah^our Tongue. Nor need I offer one Word in Behalf of this Excellent Bool^ becaufe it /peaks fuf ficiently for it felf) it is well known among a the The PREFACE. the Learned) and was well received when firfi Writy and is yet no lefs in Efteem a- mongft mo ft Men of Letters. There have been no lefs than Five or Six federal Editions of the Original \ Three of the Italian^ n or Eleven of the French, into which it was at two federal times Tranjlated ; as alfo Once into Latin 5 and as often into Dutch. * If all this Proclaims not its Merits at leaft it f peaks its good Fortune^ in the kind Reception this Book, has met with in the World. Of this only I am to inform the Reader^ that Huartes a few Tears before he died y made fome Additions to y and Retrench- ments in feVeral Places^ entirely leaving out the Seventh^ in the Old) and adding the Fir ft. Second, and Fifth Chapters in the New Edition, with a large Supplement to the Proem. It would be no f mall Advantage to this Kingdom (in Particular) and to the Com- monwealth of Learning ( in General) if this Reformation were attempted, and put in Practice 7 for if there were Triers of Wit „ The PREFACE. Wit appointed by the State, according to gur Authors Propofal, to watch the Genius of Children, in their firSl Appearances and Efforts, whether to make the Scrutiny as the Antients advifed, by leading them to the Shops of Mechanics, and to chufe Trades for them, according to the Tools they chufe to Play with, or to defend fa far as to obferVe their Childijh Plays and Diverfions, wherein the Man is often re- prefented in Miniature. Thus Vefalius began in his Childhood to cut up Fats and Mice. Michael Angelo at the fame Age to draw Figures^ and Galen to make Me-* dicines. By thefe Means there would be fewer Dunces in the UniDerjities, as well as fewer Bunglers in the Shops ; not a few upon En- 2' uiry in the Schools and bins of Court would e fent to take their Degrees in the Trades arid Manual Arts ; their Bodies being made for Labour, net their Minds ^ and their Geriiusfuiting rather withfuch Frofejfons^ cis require more good Shoulders and good Backs, than good Heads : Nor upon Lxa- a 2 minalion The PREFACE. initiation would there be found fewer in the Shops, fit to fill the Places of many Gra- duates in the Univerjities. And thus by this mutual Transplantation, in the end, the Unher/ities might be fupplied with abler Profejfors from the Shops, and the Shops again in Return, jtored with better Artifls from the Unherfities. Were this Care duly takpn to present the Mifmatching Men and Profeffions, what furer and more ef- fectual Way could' be opened, for the Ad- vancement of % Learning, and the Flourijh- ingof Trade at once 2 Much more might be faid upon this Sub- je£l 9 but I Jhall detain you no longer from the Work, it felf, not doubting in the lea fi but you will be not a little pleafed and edi- fied with the Curious and Uncommon No- tions of this Spaniard. And that you may be jo, has been the Endeavour of 9 Your Humble Servant, E. Bellamy, to T His Catholic Majefty. SIR. TO the end that the Works of all Artifts may attain the utmoft Pitch of Perfe- ction, and be 6f the greateft ufe to the Common- Wealth, it feems very Rea- fonable that by a Law it mould be provided, that the Carpenter mould not interfere with the Hus- bandman, nor the Weaver with the Architect, nor yet the Lawyer*play the Phyfician, nor the Do&or the Advocate, but that each Ihould ftick clofe to the Profeflion moft agreeable to his Ta- lent, and let the reft alone. For confidering how fhort and limited the Wit of Man is to one thing and no more } I have been always of Opinion, that no Man could underftand two Arts perfectly well, without proving defe&ive in one of them : And that accordingly none might err in the Choice of that which was moft agreeable to the Bent of his Natural Inclination, there ihould be Triers ap- pointed by the State, Men of approved Sagacity and Knowledge, to fearch and found the Abili- lities of Youth, and after due Search, to oblige them to the Study of that Science their Heads lean- ed moft to, inftead of abandoning them to their own Choice. Whence would proceed in Your Majefty's Kingdoms and Dominions, the moft ini- mitable Artifts in the World, as well as the moft a 3 Accom- To Hit Catholic Majejfy. Accomplifti'd Works, by this way of fuiting Art and Nature. I would have the fame thing Pra- &ifed in all the Univerfities in Your Kingdoms, feeing they allow not the Student to proceed to another Faculty till he be firft well entred in the Latin Tongue :, for even there fhould alfo be Triers^ to difcover if he that defigned to Study Logic, Philofophy, Phyfic, Theology, or the Law, had a Genhu adapted to each of thofe Sciences \ if not (befides the detriment accruing from fuch a one to the State, exercifing a Profeflion he is inca- pable of) 'twould be a fhame to fee a Man flave and beat his Brains for a thing impoflible ever to be cxtra&ed thence. And for want of fuch Caution at this day, the Chriftian Religion is in danger by Pretenders to Divinity, who want proper Genim"*, for it ^ nay, unskilful Phyficians have deftroyed Mens Bodies^ nor has the Sftill of the Law arrived at that Pitch it ought, for want of knowing to what Rational Faculty the life and true Interpre- tation of the Laws belong. All the Antient Philo- fophers have found by Experience, that where Na- ture difpofes not a Man for Knowledge, 'tis in vain for him to labour in the Rules of the Art. But not one of them has clearly and diftin&ly declar'd what that Nature is, which renders a Man fit for one, and unfit for another Science, nor what difference of Wit is obferved among Men, nor what Arts and Sciences are moil fuitable to each Man in particular, nor by what Marks they may be difcern'd, which is of the greateit Importance. Thefe four Points (tho' feemingly impoffible) are contained in the %\ alter here treated of, befides many other that by the by fall in with this Do&rin, to the intent that curious Fathers may learn the Art and Secret of and Diftemper'd, and that you may well be fb, being Born as I was, in an intemperate Re- gion, and that the fame Thing may happen to us, as to thofe Four Men, who feeing a Piece of Blue Cloath, fwore, one, that it was Scarlet ^ the o- ther, White*, the third, Yellow; and the fourth, Black *, not one of them fpeaking true, becaufe each had a particular Vitiation in the Organ of Sight. A Table of the CHAPTERS and ARTICLES. CHAP. I. WHat Wit is, and what Differences of it are or* dtnarily obferved among Men. Page I Chap. II. The Differences amongft Men unqualified for Sciences. 22 Chap. III. The Child who has neither Wit nor Ability re qui fie to the intended Science, cannot prove a great Proficient, though he have the be ft Mafters, many Books, and foould labour at it all the Days of his Life. 31 Chap. IV. Nature only qualifies a Man for Learn- ing. 47 Chap. V. What Power the Temperament has to make a Man Wife and good Natur'd. 62 Chap. VI. What Part of the Body ought to be well Tempered, that the Child may be Witty. 91 Chap. VII. That the Vegetative, Senfitive, and Ra- tional Soul are knowing, without bein? directed by Teachers, when they meet with a Temperament a- qreeable to their Operations. 1 01 Chap. VIII. Prom thefe three Qualities alone, Heat^ Moifture, and Drinefs, proceed all the Differences of Wit obferv'd among Men. 1 29 Chap. IX. Some Doubts and Arguments again ft the Doclrin of the loft Chapter, with their Anfwers. 155 Chap. X. Each Difference of Wit is appropriated to the Science with which it moft particularly agrees^ removing The Contents. removing what is Repugnant or Contrary to hi Chap. XI. That Eloquence and Politenefs of Speech are not to be found in Men of great Vnderftanding. 206 Chap. XII. That the Theory of Divinity belongs to the Vnderftanding, and Preaching (which is the Pra- tt ic) to the Imagination* 214 Chap. XIII. That the Theory of the Laws pertains to the Memory ; Pleading Caufes and Judging them (which is the Pratlic) to the Vnderftanding ', and Governing of a Commonwealth to the Imagination. 244 Chap. XIV. That the Theory of Thy fie belongs part to the Memory, and part to the Vnderftanding ; and the Pr attic, to the Imagination. 279 Chap. XV. To what Difference of Wit the Art-Mili- tary belongs, and by what Marks the Man may be known that has it. 314 Chap. XVI. To what Difference of Ability the Office of a King belongs, and what Marks he ought to have, that has this kind of Wit. 367 Chap. XVII. In what manner Parents may beget Wife Children, and of a Wit fit for Learning. 397 Article I. By what Marks the Degrees of Heat and Drinefs are to be difcover*d in each Man. 41 6 Art. II. What Women ought to Marry with what Men, to have Children. 422 Art. III. What Confiderations to be ufed to get Boys, and not Girls. 4.26 Art. IV. What is to be obferv'd that the Children may prove Witty and Wife. 443 Art. V. Rules to be obfervd to preferve Wit in Chi- dren after they are Bom. 487 Authors Authors made ufe of in this WO K K. A Bulenfis. jtV. Alex. Aproh. Horace. Jofephus. Aquinas. Juvenal. Ariftotle. Lyra. St. Auftin. Nemefius. Cajetan. Perfius. Celfus. Pindar. Cicero. Plato. Democritus. Pliny. Demofthenes. Saluff. Donatus. Suetonius. Galen. Tacitus. Hippocrates. Vegetius. Homer. * Xenocrates, ERRATA PAge 14. line 20. read the being ; p. 26. 1. 10. r. lfeff#7 : p. 42. 1. 17. r. Mafter : p. 93. 1. 19. dele U : p. 117. 1. 4. r. Delirous : p. 152. Margin, r. >#•*/: p. 158. 1. 5. r. Peripate- tics : p. 174.I. $• r. which is : p. 179. Margin, r.XVth : p. 190. 1. 12. r. Rcquefens: ib. I. 18. r. under flood Latin', p, Tfc* L/ttr*/ *»fl? Paginal Mi flakes the Reader may pleafe t» Con-eft. " ' «i THE TRYAL O F WITS, &c CHAP. 1. PWhat Wit is^ and what Differences of it are ordinarily obfervd among Men. TT^IS one of Plato's Precepts, That all who pretend to Write or Teach, ought to begin their Do- ~^ ftrin with the Definition of the thing treated of, its Nature, Difference, and Propriety. That gives the Learner a true relifh, and prevents the Writers launch- ing out into needkfs Questions, or flying from thofe moft proper for compleating the Work. The realon of this is, that the Definition ought to be fo clofe,, and com- B prehen* €lje Crpal of CZSitg- Chap. I. prehenfive, that there fhould hardly be found any thing either in the handling that Science, or in the due method, which mould not be pointed to in it : Therefore if they do not begin thus, 'tis impoffible to obferve Order in any fort of Science. Seeing then that Wit and Ability in Men is> the entire Subject of this Book, it will be convenient, firft, to underftand the Definition, and what it effentially comprehends ; for when we rightly apprehend that, we fliall then alfo find the true method of teaching this New Po&rin ; and whereas the Name, as the fame Philofopher obferves, is^r theln- firument by which the Sub fiances of things Itre t Might and diftinguiftpd ; We muft know this word Ingenio in Spanijh, and Ingenium in Latin, which fignifies Wit, is derived from one of thefe three Latin Words, Gig- no, Genero, Ingenero, as much as to Ingender ; and it feems rather to come from the laft, confidering the Sound and Number of Let- ters and Syllables it borrows thence, and what we fhall hereafter add of its Signifi- cation. The Reafon upon which the firft Inven- ters of this Word built, is not trivial, in order to know how to find the Names, and good Agreement, which thipgs lately dif- cover'd require. Platofoy s this only belongs to Heroes, and to Men of deep Thought, as Chap. I €lje €t}>(il of Wlt& as may be feenin the Invention of this Word Ingemo ;■ to find it out there will be requi- red much fubtle Speculation, aixi ftrong Natural Philofophy,by which one may dis- cover two generative Powers in Man, one common with the Bealts and Plants, and the other Participating of Spiritual Sub- fiances, God and the Angels. It is our Province to difcourfe of the firit, which is well known, there being more difficulty in thefecond,becaufe their Birth, and manner of Procreation, are not fo manifeft to all the World : Neverthelefs,fpeaking according to Natural Philofophers, 'tis a clear Cafe, that Wit is a Generative Power, and if we may fo fay, becomes pregnant, and brings forth ; that has, I fay, Children ; and moreover, as Plato affirms, wants a Midwife to deli- ver her. For like as the Plant or Animal in the Generation of the fir It fort, gives a real and fubitantial Being, to what they produce, which they have not before Gene- ration ; even fo Wit has the Power and natu- ral Force to produce and bring forth within it felf a Son,which the Natural Philofophers call Not ion ■, or as it has been accounted, the Word of the Spirit. And not only the aforefaid Philofophers fpeak of it after this manner, maintaining the Underftanding to be a Generative Faculty, and calling that a Son which it produces ; but Sacred Writ it B 2 felf Clje €wal of OKitg, Chap. I. felf, fpeaking of the Generation of the Eter- nal Word, makes ufe of the fame Terms of Father and Son, or Ingender and bring forth. When there were no Depths I was brought forth, when there were no fountains abounding with Water ; before the Mountains were fetled y 'before the Hills was I brought forth : So alfo is it certain that the Divine Word had its Eternal Generation from the Prolifick Underitanding t>f the Father. My Heart, that is to fay , my Thoughts y have in- ditfed a good Word : And not only the Di- vine Wond, but alfo all things comprehend- ed in the Univerfe, Vifible and Invifible, have*been produced by the felf-fame Power. Whence the Natural Philofophers confi- dering the Fecundity of the Divine Under- ftanding, have named it Genius, which is, by an Excellence, as much as the Engen- derer. And though the rational Soul, and other Spiritual Subftances, may be calPd Genii, from being Fruitful in the Produ&ion of fome Thoughts relating to Science and Wit dom, yet they have not always an Intellect of fufficient Force and Power in their Gene- ration to give a real being to what they In- gender, as fubfifting by its felf, Me as it happens in the Generation of thofe things which God has made ; all their Generative Virtue ferves to produce an accident in the Memory, Chap. I. €fje Crwtf of CSttg, Memory, which after it is produced, is in the end but an Idea and Image of what we know and underftand ; very far from that, which comes to pafs in the Ineffable Generation of the Word Divine, where that which is Engendered, is of the fame Sub ft ■ ance with the Fat her , as the other things, which God has product, reprefent him from without, by a real and fubftantial Be- ing, which we now fee in them ; but for the Ideas in Man's Underftanding, if they are fuch things as relate to Art, they don't im- mediately receive the Being they ought to have : However, thus much muft be done to draw a perfeft Idea, by which we are to form 'em ; 'tis neceflary before-hand to make a thoufand ftrokesin the Air, to build many Models, and in the end to fet our hana to the Work to give them the Being they ought to have; and notwithstanding all that, they happen for the moft part to be defeftive. The fame thing falls out in other Conceptions Man forms to under- ftand Natural things, and what relates to theirbeing there, or the Image the Under- ftanding conceives of 'em, by an Admira- ble Refemblance of the firft Thought, with fomething living; and to draw a Copy, than may come up pretty near the Original, 'tis requiliteto affemble an Infinite N umber of Spirits, to labour a longtime, that after all, B 3 fpend eijc zmw of mug. chap, t fpend thcmfclves in producing only a thou-* land Extravagancies. This Doctrin then being fupposM, we mull now underftand, that the Arts and Sciences Men ft udy,are only a fort of Images, and Figures, begotten by their Minds in their Memory, which reprefent to the Life the Pofture and natural Compofition of the Subjeft relating to the intended Science : As for Inftance, Phyfick was nothing elfe in Hippocrates and Galen's Heads, but a Pi- cture, nakedly prefenting the Structure of the Body of Man, together with the Caufe a nd Cure of his Difeafes. The Skill of the Law is another Figure, reprefenting the Form of Juftice, which preferves Human- Society, making Man live in Peace and Tranquility. Whence 'tis eafy to perceive, that if a Scholar under the Conduct of an c'ble Mafter, cannof form in his memory inch another Image, and as exaft as that laid before his Eyes, when he is difcourfing to him of it, there is no doubt to be made, but he has a barren Invention, and fuch as H never be able to conceive, or bring forth any thing but Extravagancies and Monftcrs. And fo much for the Word In- gmio y deriv'd from the Verb Ingenero, as ich as to fay , to Engender within himfelf an mtii t a, d true figure y reprefenting to the Life ■-- nature of the Subjeff intended to beftudied* Cicero Chap. I. €fje Ctpal Qi flLtitSi. Cicero defines Wit after this manner, Do- cility and Memory ordinarily called by the fame name of Wit ; wherein he has followed the Opinion of the common People, who reft themfelves contented, if their Children are butDocible, to be the eafier inftrufted by another, and endu'd with a competent me- mory to retain and preferve the Figures con- ceived in the Understanding : For which reafon Ariftotle faid ? That the Ear and the Memory muft be join'd to reap any Advan- tage from the Sciences. But to fpeak truth, that Definition is too (hort, not compre- hending all the differences of Wit, whereas this word Docility only, imports Wits that want a Mafter, leaving out a great many others, whofe Felicity is fuch, that aflifted by the fubje£l only, without the help of any Body, produce a thoufand Conceits they never heard fpoke of; fuch were.thofe who firft found out the Arts. El fe where Tully adds Memory to the Definition of Wit, of which however Galen fays, That it has no kind of Invention ; as much as to fey, that it is un- able of it felf to Engender any thing, for fo much Ariftotle teaches us, that when 'tis in Excellence, it impedes the Copioufnefs of the Underftanding, as not being prompt to conceive, or bring forth, but feeming only to keep and preferve the Figures and Spedes of what the other Powers have conceived, B 4 ' as Clje Ctpai of mttil* Chap. L as is obferv'd of the Learn'd, who have ex- cellent Memories, that they (peak and write nothing but what others have been the Au- thors of. 'Tis true, if we confider well the term Docility, we lhall find that Cicero has hap- pily hit on't ; for Arijiotle fays, that Pru- dence, Wifdom, and the Truth of Sciences are ftow'd among natural Things, there to be fought after, as in their proper Fountain. The Natural Philofophers that believe a Propofition, becaufe^//?^/efpokeit, with- out enquiring any further, want Wit, be- caufe Truth is not in his Mouth that affirms it, but inthething.inqueftion, crying out with a loud Voice, and teaching Man the Being Nature has given him, and to what end {he was created, according to that, Does not Wifdom cry out y and Prudence does not fhe make her Voice to be heard ? He that has fharpnefs of Under Handing, and a good Ear to diftinguifh what Nature teaches and di- vulges in her Works, fhall wonderfully improve by the Contemplation of natural doings, and has no need of a Matter to Ihew him what he may learn well enough from the Brute Beafts and the Plants. Go Drone, take thy Leffonfrorn the Ant ; confider her toyl, and become wife by her Example ; fee how fhe y without Teacher or Learning, lays up Provi- Jim m the Summer for the Wmter* Pkto took Chap. I. Cije&ralofQEKt*. ' took little notice of this Docility, imagining perhaps there were no other Mafters to in- ftruft Men, than thofe mounted in Chairs ; which made him fay, The Field and the Trees can teach me nothings but the Conver- fxtion of Men only in the City. Solomon fpoke better, when not in the leaft doubting but that the fecond kind of Docility might really be found, he begg'd of God the Ability to Govern his People. Give, if thou pleafefi, God) to thy Servant Judgment , that he may Rule thy People, and diftinguifl) between Good and Evil. By which he ask'd only a clear and refin'd Underftanding, (infomuch that what he obtained was more than he de- manded) to the end that when Doubts oc- curred to him in his Government, he might derive from the Nature of the -thing the true Judgment he ought to make of it, without going to feek it in Books ; as is evi- dently feen in the Sentence he pronounced upon the firft Difference that ardfe between the two Women ; for no doubt it was the Nature of the thing that informM him, which was the Child'strue Mother, namely fhe, who could not bear the dividing of it.; The fame kind of Docility and cTcarnejTs of Underftanding was given by Jefus Chrift to hisDifciples, for their underftanding the Holy Scriptures, after .their natural Dull- nefs and Indifpofition of mind was with- drawn, io Cfje Ccpal of &ift& Chap. I. drawn, as it is faid, He opened their Vnder- ft an dings, that they wight under (I and the Scri- ptures. For which reafon the Catholick Church, as being fenfible of what high Im* portance it is to have all due Qualifications to comprehend the Divine Book, forbids all Novices as well as Superannuated Perfons to ftudy Theology : For we muH inviohtely obferve a Law, to exercife in all forts of Sci- ences young Men only ; and not all thofe with- out diftinction, but chiefly thofe that are Wit- ty > banifhing thence all the Dotards, and thofe whpfe Intellects are dull and depraved. . P/^fpeakingofWits that were to learn the Divine Sciences, has faid the fame thing, becaufe Spiritual Subftances are fo remote from Senfe, and of fo pure Matter in them- ielves, that moft elevated and nice Wits were to be chofen; 'twas therefore he de- clared , That they ought not only to make choice of Bold Men y that Jhouldflri&e a Terror tnto their Enemies > but alfo more of thofe to whom Nature had been liberal in the Gifts re- quifite to Divinity ', that is to fay, tljofe of a Jharp and rea,dy Wit; By the way repre- hending Solon for faying, this fort of Sci^ ence was to be Studied in Old Age. Thofe that are Mafters of fuch Qualifi- cations, proceed in the Studies they are engaged in with very little Labour ; be- caufe their Underftandinghas nothing to do but Chap. I. €i)e t£rpal of W\t&. 1 1 but to prefervc in their memory the Figures and Species, that enable them upon occa- fion to Difpute ; thofe natural things at all times, fuggefting to us fuch Ideas as we would frame to our felves in Speculation, and when they are Supernatural, they need only to underftand the Species and Figures that have paft through their Senfes : Which occafioned Plato to fay, That we need, not divefl Sublime things of their Matter , to make them fen fible to us ; for being in their nature moH excellent and elevated, they are not fuch as naked Reafon is fo rve/l able to comprehend. So faid he, that the greateft Wits were re- quired for Divine Studies rather than any other, feeing they were above our Reafon, Whence 'tis certain, that that fo fam'd Maxim of Ariflotle, That there is nothing in the Vnderflanding, but what hits pafi through the Senfe ; has no place in the fecond fort of Docility, but only in the firft, in which the Ability extends no farther than to receive and retain in the Memory what the Matter has faid and taught. Whence may be clearly collected what Abufe is committed in thefe days in the Study of Theology, feeing without making the choice, Catho- lic Church requires, many Perfons whom Nature defignM to Cultivate and Till the Earth, are very forward to thruft them- felves into Holy Orders. With 1 2 C&c Crpal of aziftft Chap. i. With thefe two forts of Qualities of which we have treated, correfpend as ma- ny kinds of Wit; Ariftotle takes notice of the firft, He has true Wit that acquiefces in y and, agents to him that freaks Truth, becaufe the Man who remains not convinced by ftrong and folid Reafons, and that forms not in his Memory a good Idea of what is proposed to him, lufficiently declares to us, that his Underftanding is fhallow. 'Tis true, there is fomething in.this worthy of Confederation, whifch is tliis, we may ob- ferve many Scholars very readily learn all their Matters teach them, retaining and preferving it in their Memories, without any difficulty, which for two Reafons,may happen, either becaufe the Matter is of great Ability, and fuch a one as Arifiotle defcri- bed, when he faid, that it is requifite for a Learned, Man not only to know all that may be drawn from the "Principles, but alfo that he have a perfect knowledge of the Principles themfehes. Thofc Scholars that concurr with fuch a Matter, without doubt have an excellent Wit ; which they alfo further fhew, when they receive thfc Doftrinof the Matter that Inftru&s them, without his fubjoining, or declaring his own Opinions and Conclu- Uoris, with the Principles upon which they are founded. Not* Chap. I. €&e Ctpal of mitn. i ? Not to lead a Wit this way, which is foveryfhort, and narrow, a thoufand Dif- ficultiesat all times readily prefent them- felves to him, and as many different Rea- fons ; for he that learns from fuch a Mafter, forms not to himfelf the true Idea and Cor- refpondence required by the true Principles of Learning ; fo that his Underftanding ever remains doubtful, and difquieted, which is occafion'd by the fault of him that teaches him. There are other rude and grofs Dunces, who perceiving the fharper Wits in more Efteem, very inconveniently, and for quite different Reafons, oppofe their Mafters at the end of their Leffon, and in imitation of the other, prefs him with a thoufand Im- pertinences, he not being fo able to clear their Doubts, as they are to difcover their Weaknefs, more than if they had been fi- lent : 'Tis of them Plato fays,That they have not Senfe enough to be convinced. But he that has a nimble and ready Wit, need not wholly rely on his Mafter, nor fwallow down any thing that appears not to be con-, fonant to his Dofrriri. Others are filent, and obey their Mafter without the leaft Contradiction, becaufe they have not Wit enough to difcern the Fallity and ill Confequence of his Corolla- ries, from the firft Principles. Jrijtotk 1 4 .Cfje Crpal of mite. Chap. I. Jriftotle has thus defin'd thefecond Dif- ference of Wit, He has the most excellent Wit , n^tf of himfelf under Jlands every thing : Which kind of difcerning Wit, bears the fame proportion with regard to Knowledge and Underftanding, as humane Sight does to Forms and Colours, when 'tis clear and penetrating. As foon as one opens his Eyes, he diftinguifhes every thing, failing not to tell where the Place is, and what di- ftance there is interpofed between the Ob- jects , without another View or Re- port ; but if the Sight be fhort and weak, the moft apparent and cleareft things in View cannot be difcern'd, without borrow- ing the Eyes of a third Man, who repre- fents them to him. An Ingenious Man, when he Contemplates (that is to fay, opens the Eyes 6f his Underftanding) compre- hends from the leaft Difcourfe, being of Natural Things, their Difference, Proprie- ty, and to what end they were Created ; but if there be not fo large a Capacity, the Mailer of courfe muft take the more pains with him, and yet even then (as 'tis fre- quent) all his Labour and Application are to no purpofe. The Vulgar are not acquainted with this Difference of Wit, imagining 'tis no where to be found ; and indeed not without great ■fliaw of Reafon, as the fame PhMbpher has Chap, t Cfje Ctpal of aaiitu, i 5 has very Well obferv'd. No Man ever came comfleatly Learned into the World, nor is there any Natural Knowledge amongH Men : In ef- fect, we fee by Experience, that all they who have ftudied, even to this very day, have wanted a Maftcr. Prodicus was Socrates^ Matter, who by the Oracle of Apollo was pronounced the wifeft Man in the World ; and Socrates taught Plato, whofe Wit was fo extraordinary, that he deferv'd the Sir- name of Divine : Plato was ArifiotlPs Ma- tter, of whom Cicero faid, That he was the greatefi Wit that ever mas. Now if this laffc Difference of Wit had been to be found in any, without doubt it would have been amongft thofe Eminent Perfons : Seeing then not one of them had it, 'tis a ftrong prefumption Nature cannot give it us. Adam only himfelf, as the Divines deli- ver, was born entirely inftrutted, and filPd with the infused Sciences; and he 'twas, who communicated them to his Succeflbrs : From whence it may be concluded for cer- tain, that there is nothing new, and that there is no Opinion in any kind of Science, that has not been maintain'd by one or other, according to that faying, There is nothing yet [aid, that has not been [aid be- fore. To this 'tis anfwer'd, That Arifiotle has defined a perfed Wit, as it ought to be, rather i* Cfje Ctpal of watfr Chap. I. rather than as it was ; for he knew full well, there was none fuch in Nature. Even as Tully defcrib'd a compleat Orator, not but that himfelf own'd, 'twas impoffible to find fuch a one, but that he would be the beft Orator that approach'd neareft'to the Idea he had drawn of one. 'Tis the very- fame in this Difference of Wit ; for though we cannot meet with fuch a perfeft one as Ariftotle has fram'd, yet it muft be grant- ed, we have obferv'd many Perfons ap- proach very near it, inventing and faying fuch things as they never heard from their Matters, nor any Mouth, and that have been able todifcern and difprove the Errors they taught them ; and the truth is, they fhew'd them that they could of themfelves comprehend, being arrived at the greateft Pitch of Wit ; at leaft it cannot be denied of Gale n, that he had this Difference of Wit, when hefaid, 1 have found out all things my Jelf having no other Guide but the Light only of my Natural Reajbn, whereas had I follow- ed Jome Mafters, I had fallen into a thoufand Errors. Now though Nature gave thefe very Perfons a Wit that had its rife, in- creafe, perfeftftate, and declenfion, yet fhe rendered them compleat at laft, with- out doubt, though they arrived late at it, ~ as Jrijlotlefaid ; but fince fhe gives it not but with thefe Conditions, we need not be amazed Chap. I. Cfje Ccpal of aaift& w amazed \S Plato and Ariftotle flood in need of their Mafters to initruQ: them. . There is a third Difference of Wit, which neverthelefs is not abfolutely different from what I have but now treated of; by means of which, fome have without Art or Study fpoke iuch fubtle and furprizing things, and yet true, that were ne^er before feen, heard, or writ, no nor ever fo much as thought of. Plato calls this fort of Wit, An excellent Wit, with a mixture of Madnefs. 'Tis the fame which Infpires the Poets with what is impoffible for them to conceive (fays the fame Divine Philofopher) with- out Divine Revelation. Whereupon he adds, Well may a Poet be all in Flames and Raptures, his Perfon being wholly Sacred, he can Jing nothing but what is full of God, who agitates him, transporting him beyond himfelf and above his own Reafon': But as for thofe of an unelevatcd Spirit^ they can never tnake moving Verfts, nor prevail in Profkefy. It is not then from any humane Art Poets chaunt fuch fine things, that thou, 0. Homer, breath- est, but rather from Tranfports Divine. Tins third Difference of Wit adjufted by Plato, is actually found among Men, of which I am an Eye-witnefs, and could alfo, if need were, with a Finger point cut thofe that have it : But to affert what they fay to be by Divine Revelation, and not to C pro- i 8 €fje Ctval of ©Hit*. Chap. I. proceed from their particular Nature,would be an apparent and manifeft Abufe, and ill-becoming fo great a Philofopher as Plato ; and is to have recourfe to Univerfal Caufes, without having before-hand made an exact Enquiry into Particulars. Arifiotle did better, who being curious to know the Reafon of thofe wonderful things pro- nounced in his time by the Sibyls, faid, That it came not to pafs by Diftemper, nor by Divine Inspiration^ but only by a natural 1/l-Tempe- , ramen't. The Caufe whereof is evident in natural Philofophy ; for all the governing Faculties in Man, the Natural, the Vital, the Animal, and even the Rational, require each their particular Temperament to per- form their Funftions as they ought, with- out prejudicing , or interfering one with another. The Natural Virtue, as digeftive of the Food in the Stomach, muft have a due Heat; that which gives Appetite, Cold ; the Retentive, Dnnefs ; and the Expulfiye, of what is Naufeous or Super- fluous, a due Moifture. Whichfoever of thefe Faculties pofTeffes in a greater degree any of the four Qualities, by which it ope- rates, will thereby become more powerful in that Point, but not without impairing the reft ; becaufe, in efteft, it feems im- poflihle that all the four Virtues and Facul- ties, fliould be aiTembled in one and the fame Chap. I. Cfte Ctpal of aaiftfif. 1 9 fame place ; fince if that which requires fome Heat, becomes more Potent ; the other that operates by Cold, cannot but be found more Weak : Which made Galen fay, That a hot Stomach digefted much, yet had a bad Appetite ; that a cold Stomach dige- fted ill, but had' a good one. The fame thing happens in the Senfes, and Motions, which are Operations of the Animal Facul- ty. Great Strength of Body fhews. abun- dance of Earthinefs in the Nerves andMuf- cles ; for if thofe Parts are not finewy, hard and dry, they cannot aft fteadily : On the contrary, to have a quick and lively Senfe, is a fign the Nerves are composed of more airy, 'fine, and delicate Parts ; and that their Temperament is hot and moift : How is it then poflible that the fame Nerves fhould have the Temperament, and natu- ral Compofition which is.requirM for Mo- tion and for Senfe, at one and the fame time, feeing that for thefe two things, there muft be quite contrary Qualities ? Which is clear'd from Experience ; for whereas a Man that is very Robuft of Bo- dy, has infallibly the Senfe of Touching rude and grofs, fo when that Senfe is very exquifite, he is faint, and if one may fay lb, ravelled out. The" Rational Powers, Memory, Ima- gination, and Underftanding are under the C 2 fame so <£&e Cwal of {fflite, Chap. L fame Rules. The Memory to be good and tenacious, requires fome Moifture, and that the Brain be of a grofs Subftance, as we fliall prove hereafter : On the contrary, the Underftanding muft have a dry Brain, compos&of very fubtile and delicate Farts : The Memory then proceeding to a pitch, the Underftanding muft neceiTarily be lowered and diminifh'd as much : But be it as it will, I beg the curious Reader to Re- flect upon all the Men he has known en- dued with an Excellent Memory, and I am affur'd he'll find, as to the Operations belonging to the Underftanding, they are in a manner indifcernible. The fame happens as to the Imagination when it exerts its felf : For as to the Ope- rations relating to it, it produceth prodigi- ous Conceptions, and fuch as aftonifhed Plato : And when a Man endued with fuch an Imagination, comes to concern himfelf in afting with Underftanding, one may bind him without doing him any Injury,*as a Lunatic, and void of Reafon. Whence may be concluded, that the Wifdom of Man muft be moderate, well tempered,, and not fo unequal; as Galen efteems thofe the wifeft Men that are well tempered, becaufe, they are not as it were intoxicate with too much Wifdom. Democritfts Chap.I. Clje Crpal of33tt& 21 Dcmocritm was one of the greateft Na- tural and Moral Philofophers of his Time, though PUto faid of him, That he was a better Divine than Naturalift, who ar- rived at fo great a Perfection of Under- ftanding in his Old Age, that he entirely loft his Imagination, infomuch, that he both faid and did things fo extraordinary, that the whole City of Ahdera took him for a Natural, and accordingly difpatch'd a Cou- rier to the Ifle of Coa, where Hippocrates lived, to entreat him earneftly, with offer of abundance of rich Prefents, to come im- mediately to Cure Democntus, who had loft all his Senfes : Which Hippocrates rea- dily complied with, as being curious to fee and confer with the Man, ofwhofe admi- rable Wifdom he had heard fo muchnoifc; He departed that very initant, and being arrived at the Place of his Abode, which wasaDefart, where he lived on a Plain, he fell to difcourfe him ; and upon asking him Queftions in order to difcover the Defefts of his Rational Faculty, found . him the Wifeft Man in the World ; and told them that had brought him thither, That they, themfelves were Fools, and void of Senfe, for having given fo rafh a Judgment of fo Difcreet a Perfon ; Tor as good Fortune would have it for Democritm, the Matters treated on with Hippocrates, C j as 22 Cfje Crpai of wm> Chap. II. at that time, appertain'd to the Underftand- ing, and not to the Imagination, which wasdifabled. CHAP. II. The Differences amongfi Men unqualified for Science. ONE of the greateft Indignities that can be offer'd in Words to a Man ar- rived at the Years of Difcretion, is, faid Jri- riftotle, to accufe him of want of Wit, be- caufe all his Honour and Nobility, as Cicero obferves, cbnlifts in his being favoured with, and having an Eloquent Tongue: As Wit is the Ornament of a Man, fo 'Eloquence is the Light and BeAuty of Wit. In this alone he diftinguifhes himfelf from the Brutes, and approaches near to God, as being the great- eft Glory which is poflible to be obtained in Nature. On the contrary, he that is born a Blockhead, is incapable of any fort of Li- terature ; and where there is no Wifdom, there, fays Plato, can neither be true Ho- nour, nor good Fortune ; infomuch, as the wife Man declared, The Fool is bom to his own Shame y feeing he muft neceffarily be degraded to the inferior Animals, and be . . ..... one Chap. II. €Ije Ctval of fiBtt& 23 one of the Herd, although he enjoy other Advantages, as well thofe of Nature as For- tune, in being Handfom, Noble, Rich, High-born, and raifed eyen to the Dignity of a King or Emperor. This will appqar yet more evident, if we come to confider the Happy and Ho- nourable State in which the firlt Man was placed before he loft the Wit with which he was Created, and what he was after he was fpoiled of his Wifdom ; Man that is in Honour ', and underftandeth not, is like the Be aft s that perifh. Where we may obfer ve, that Sacred Writ is not content to compare him only to other Animals, but even to the Brutes of the brutes ; if we remember that in another place it has praifed the Wifdom and Subtilty of die Serpent and the Ant, with whom, of all kinds of Creatures, Man without Wit bears no comparifon. Now the Sacred Text with a more particular regard to the greatnefs of this Indignity, and to the ill Opinion • concei- ved of him, who lies under fo unhappy an Imputation , has declared, Whofaever ' in Anger jhall fay to his Brother, Racha, (as much as to [ay Shallow- fate) jhall be in danger ofibe Council \ but whojoever jhall faj > Thou fool, [hall be in danger of Hell Fire. Hitherto this Indignity has paflcd no fur- ther than a bare Examination and Cenfure C 4 in 24 . Clje Crpal of Z&its. Chap.H. in fo many Courts, and Tribunals, becaufe in a' heap of Words even this may have dropt from one to another, jR ac ha, yet with- out Paflion, and with no defign of Provo- cation. From him that has an excellent Underftanding, we have taken away Me- mory ; from him' that is endued with a happy Memory, the Underftanding ; from him whofe Imagination is Excellent, both Underftanding and Memory ; from the Pra&ical Preacher, School Divinity ; and from the great School Divine, Polemical Divinity : To him that has been well vers'd in Pofitive Divinity, we have faid that all his Stock of Sufficiency lay only in the Me- mory, a picquant Touch th^: has galled, from him that fhould be a good Advocate, we have taken away all kind of Govern- ment ; and after this manner we have pro- ceeded for the moft part ; but becaufe we have not yet calPd any Man Fool or Dunce, the Imputation has not defeiVd Fire. Now I forefee fome that have, read this Book again and again, looking for the Chapter that difcovers their Genius, and what kind of Learning they fhould advance moft in, but not! finding it, are ready to Arraign the Title of this Book of Falfity, and to fay, that the Author made large Pro- mifes, but that his Performances were as {lender; and not fatisfied with that, take the Chap. II. Clje Crpal of £21ttg- 2 5 the Liberty of making many other" bafe Re- flections, as if J were obligM in this Work, to give Wit to thofe to whom God and Nature have denied it. The Wife Man has given us two very juft and reafonable Cautions, which by confequence he requires us to obferve. The one is, ylnjwer not a Fool according to hu folly, lefl thou alfb be like unto him ; the Other, Anfwer a Fool according to his folly, left be be wife in his own conceit ; and not unjuft- ly ; becaufe nothing can be more prejudicial to the good of the Commonwealth, than For a Bool to pafs for a Man of Senfe, efpe- cially if he have any Poft in the Govern- ment. And for what touches the Tryal of Wits, of which we treat, 'tis certain that Learning and Wifdom, as much more as they qualify a Man for Difcourfe and Philofophizing, ib much and more they expofe him that by Nature is a . Blockhead. Learning is afnare to the feet of the Fool, and as Manicles to his right hands : He that is not a Man of Parts, will be much more paffable without Letters than with them ; becaufe when one is not engaged in any Study, he may live in the World with lels noife. Therefore Arts and Sciences are in a manner Chains to fetter the Minds of Fools, rather than to difpofe them to be more free and eafy; which may be clearly feen 26 €8e r €m\ Of mttfr Chap. II; feen in Univerfity Scholars, amongft whom fomemay be found that learn more in the firft Year than in the fecond, and in the fecond more than in the third : Whence came the faying, In the firft Year, they are Doctors; in the fecond, Licentiates \ in the third, Batchelors-j and in the fourth, Igno- ramus's ; and the reafon of it is, as the Wifeman faid, The Precepts and Rules of Arts are but Letters for Infipids. Where- upon> knowing full well that many fuch have read, and will read this Treatife, in hope to find what Wit and Ability falls to their {hare ; it feems proper to me, 'that I fhould obferve the Wife-Man's Precept, in fetting forth here the different Difabilities to be found amongft Men, withrefpeft to Learning, and by what Marks one may know them, to the end that they who come to feek their own kind of Wit, may in lieu thereof meet with the Indications of their Incapacity,in imitation of Solomon y \vho{aid)' Anjvcer not a fool ; for by this means taking their folemn leave of Letters, it may be they will apply themfelves to another manner of Life, much more agreeable to the fenfe they have, than the other, feeing that there is no Man, howgrofsand imperfeft foever formed, but Nature has defign'd him for iomething. To Chap. II. £I)C Crpal of l&it$. 27 To come then to matter of Fa&, you muft know to the three kinds of Wit pro- pos'd in the foregoing Chapter, correfpond three refpe&ive kinds of Difability. There - are fome Men whofe Souls are fo im- merft in Matter, and clogg'd with the Qualities of the Body, that opprefs the Rational Facutty, that they are eternally incapable of conceiving or a£ting anything relating to Learning and Knowledge. The Difability of thefe People, very much re- fembles that 6f Eunuchs ; for as there are Men unable for Generation, wanting the Parts proper thereunto, fo like wife are there difabled Underftandings, cold and malefic, if one may fay fo, without tiatural Heat or Vigor to emit the leaft thought of Learn- ing ; thefe never arrive fo much as at the firlt Principles of all Arts implanted in the Scholar's Mind, before he begin to learn, for which the Wit can give no other proofs of it felf, than to receive them as things al- ready known ; and if he be not able to form an Idea of them in his Mind, we may ftrongly conclude him wholly incapable of the Sciences , and that the Gate through which they fhould pafs is compleatly barr'd ; fo that he need not break his Brains to Stu- dy, for neither the Lafh of the Rod, nor his Cries, nor Method, nor Examples, nor Time, nor Experience, nor any thing in Nature, *8 C&e Ctpal Btmitil. Chap. II. Nature can fufficiently Excite him to bring forth any thing. The Men of this Incapacity differ not at all from Brute Beafts, they • are ever drowfy, nor feem they ever to a- wake; of fuch the Wife-man fpeaks, To fit m the Treafures of Wifdom before the Ejes of a Fool, is as fpeaking to a Man in a found, Sleep ; the Companion is vet y juft and pro- per, becaufe Sleep and Stupidity proceed alike from the fame Principles, that is to fay, the great Coldnefs and exceeding Moi- fture of the Brain. There is another kind of Incapacity in Wit, not quite lb Stupid as the former, becaufe at leaft they conceive the firft Prin- ciples, and dr£w Conclufions thence, tho' few, and not without much pains ; but the ImprefTion of them remains in their Memories no longer than their Matters are talking to them, and making them' underftand the fame by Examples and Methods of Teaching, agreeable to their rude and grofs . Underftandings. They refemble fome Women, who being big with Child, are delivered, but the Child dies as foon as it is born. Thefe Mens Brains are full of a Flegmatic Moifture, for which caufe the Ideas finding nothing Oily, or Vifcous, neither ftick nor are pliant ; lb to teach them, would be to draw Water with a Sieve. A FooPs Heart and Mind are Chap. II. €fje STrpai of aaHw. 29 . jo Cfje Ctpal of mits. Chap. IL Nay, I have obferv'd a fourth Defett amongft Men of Letters, which is not al- together Incapacity, and yet they have not Wit enough ; for I find they that poffefs it, take Learning, retain it firmly in their Memory, fix the Forms with the Corref- pondencethey ought tohave,fpeakingand aftingvery well when there isoccafion for it, but if one founds them, and fhould ask the EfTential Caufes of what they know and underftand , they are eafily found they have no bottom, and that all their Suf- ficience was but a Facility to comprehend the Terms and Axioms oftheDgftrinthey were taught, without penetrating why, or how it was fo. Ariflotle faid of thefe, That there are fome Men who Brute-beafl-likc fpeak by Natural lnftinci, and fay more than they know ^ or confider, after the manner of inani- mate Beings, who fail not to att very well, al- though the) are as infenfible of the Effects they produce, as the Fire of what it burns', and the Caufe of this is, Nature leads them, fo that they cannot fail of attaining their End. Ari- fiotle might well have compared them to fome Animals, who feem to perform all their Actions with a fhow of Reafon and Defign ; but he fuppofing thefe Animals had at leaft fome kind of knowledge of what they did, paft to Inanimate Agents, becaufe in his Opinion, thefe though not wife. Chap. III. €&e Ctpal of wit8. 3 1 wife, and wanting Wit, yet operated, and very well too, without being able to diftin- guifh the Effeft from the ultimate Caufe. This difference of Incapacity, or if you pleafe of Wit, might Jjb fully made out, if without offence to any, I were permitted to' point to them with my Einger, for I have both feenand known many fuch. CHAP. III. The Child who has neither Wit nor Abi- lity requifite to the intended Science , cannot prove a great Proficient, though he have the be (I Mafiers^ many Bookj, and jhould labour at it all the Days of his Life. TW A S a happy thought in Cicero (in order to accomplifh his Son Marcus in that fort of Learning he had made choice of for him) that it would be fufficient to fend him to an Academy fo famous through- out the World, as that of Athens, to place him under fo great a Mafter as Cratippus y one of the molt celebrated Philofophers of the Age, and in a City, which by the vafl Concourfe of People of all Nations met to- gether, 32 Cljc Crpal of mm. Chap. III. gether, muft unavoidably furnifh him with a multitude of great Examples and novel Accidents, that would experimentally in- ftrufr him, in his defigned Studies ; Yet notwithftanding all flie beft Methods an indulgent Father could take (buying fome and Writing*other Books for him) Hiftory informs us that he prov'd a meer Block- head, equally deftitute of Eloquence and Philofophy (Nature being often even with the Son, for her Prodigality to the Father) ; and indeed the great Orator was mistaken in imagining that the Induftry of fuch a Matter, the beft Books, the moft refin'd Converfation of that famous Town, and an unwearied application of Mind, together with time fufficient to build his Hopes up- , on, could fupply the Defedrsof a Soul na- turally incapable both of Eloquence and Philofophy. At length w£ find he was dif- appointed, which is the lefstobewonckr'd at, being milled by innumerable Inftances of the like Rencounters, thatflatter'd him with the fame change in the difpofition of * Lib. de his Son. Nay, he himfelf acquaints* us, E*w. That Xenocrates had no Genius for the ftudy of Natural and Moral Philofophy, (for Plato ufed to call him his Hopelefs Scholar) yet the indefatigable Diligence of the Tu- tor, and continued Endeavours of the Pupil, produced an Excellent Philofopher. He . , fays ciiap. in. c&e €mi of taift& 3 ? fays alfo of Cleanthes, that he was fo dull and ftupid, that no Mafter would admit hini to his School, which fliamed and con- founded the Youth to fuch a degree, that .by an affiduous Application, he acquired tne Name of a Second Hercules in know- ledge. Nor were there the leaft hopes that Demofthenes fhduld ever fucceed in Elo- quence, who (as Authors affirm) was at- moft a Man before he could fpeak ; yet, through his own unwearied Labours, and the affiftance of good Matters, he became the greateft Orator in the World. .And Tutly, amongft other things, recounts, that he had fuch an Impediment in his. Speech, that he could not pronounce the Letter R i yet by his Addrefs,he fo happily overcame it, that it was impoflible to difcern his former Defeft, which gave Birth to the Saying , That Humane Capacity for Studies , refembles a Game at Tables, where if the Dice run crofs y the Gamejler mujl fupply the want of Fortune with his better Play. But, according to my Principles, the Anfwer is ready .to all Cicero's Examples. For, as I (hall prove hereafter, a flow Wit in Children promifes a happier Progrefs in their riper Age, more than an early acute Wit ; as a pregnant Infancy preiages a declining Manhood . Had Cicero teen acquainted with the genuine Signs, which difcover a Genim- in the firft Age, D he 34 €6e €tpal of mit$. Chap. III. he would have found, that Demofihenes\ Stammering, and Xenocrates*s Dulnefs, were happy Indications of a future Ability. For not to rob good Matters of the Reward ofc their Induftry and Fatigue, in cultivating rude, as well as docile Tempers , yet if the Youth has not a pregnant Intellect fuf- ceptible of proper Rules and Precepts ap- propriated to the Art he Studies, even the Roman Orator's diligent care of his Son, as alfoall the Prudence of the'beft of Fathers prove Vain and Fruitlefs. Thofe that have * Dialog de read * Plato will foon be fatisfied of the Ssiemia. Truth of this Do£trii5, who tells us, That Socrates was the Son (as he himfelf re- counts) of a Midwife, yet that his Mother (though of great Experience in her Profef- fion) could not deliver a Woman JSXXSSS& thatcam e toher,excepdh e were demanding alone, becaufe hilt With Child ; lollkeWllehe he taught bylnterroga- J n (i m i tat i 0n of his.Motliei') ttng; in a manner caufing ^ , . . ' theSchtUr to attain the could not inculcate Learning m- saence withm being t his Scholars,if their Geniu5\v?L$ taught it. pQt ac j a pted to it, he knew full well, Sciences were in a manner natural to thofe only that had proper Wits ; and fo it happens (as we find by Experience) to thofe that haveforgot what they knew for- merly, who upon receiving the leaft Hints, recoiled the whole matter. Nor have Matters any more to do with their Scho- lars (as I take it) than to open the way to Learning ; Chap. III. C&e Ctpal Of ElftS. 5 S Learning ; for if they have good Inven- tions, 'by thefe alone they may attain great Perfection ; otherwife they do but plague themfelves and their Teachers, and \yi!l never arrive at what they pretend to. For were I my felf a Mafter, before I received any Scholar to my School, I would lift him narrowly, to find out if I could, what kind of Genius he had ; and if I difcover'd in him a propenfity for Learning, I profefs I fhould chearfully receive him ; for it is a great fatisfa&ion to the Teacher to inftruft a Man of Parts, otherwife I fhould advife him, to apply himfelf to fome Study fitter for him ; but if I found he was not in the leaft capable of any Learning, I fhould ad~ drefs to him in fuch tender and endearing Words as thefe ; Br dier, there being no likelihood of your ever fucceeding in what you have undertaken, for God's fake, Waft© no more Time, nor lofe no more Pains* but feek out fome other way to live, that requires not fuch Abilities as Learning. Experience exaflly agrees with this, for we fee a great many Scholars enter upon the Study of each Science ( lei the Ma- fter be goodfc>r bad)«andintheconclufion > fome attain to great Learning, othsrs to indifferent, and the reft have done nothing throughout their whole courfe, but lqit their Time, fpent their Money, and beat their Brains to no purpofe- D 2 I 36 €fje EtWrt Of O3it0. Chap. 111. I cannot imagin how this fhould happen, they all having the fame Mafter, and ufing equal care and diligence of their own ; the Dull too, it may be, taking more pains than the Sharp Witted. The Difficulty yet feems greater, when we obferve that thofe who are unapt for one, are fit for an- other Science ; and the molt Ingenious in one fort of Learning, proceeding to ano- ther make nothing of it. Nay, I my felf can atteft the Truth of this, for there were three School-fellows of us, that were fet at the fame time to learn Latin, one took it very readily, the other two could never fo much as make a tolerable Oration. However, all three fell upon Logic, and one thatcduld make no hand of Grammar, Ea- gle-like penetrated into that Art, whereas the other two could not advance the leaffc ftep therein, during the whole Coiirfe. But then again, all three pafling to the Study of Afironomy, a thing very obfervable, he that could neither learn Latin, nor Logic, in a few daysfpace underftood Aftronomy bet- ter than the Matter that taught him, of which the other two could underftand no- thing. Whereat being a litie furpriz'd, I forthwith began to Reafon, and play the Philolbpher, and at length found, that each Science required a particular and proper Genius, which being diverted from that, was Chap. in. €fje Crpai of Wli$. 37 was infignificant in any other. Admitting this to be true (as it is, of which we fliall by and by give Proof) whoever fhould at this time of day, go into any of our Col- leges, to found and examin their Abilities, how many would he move from one Sci- • ence to another, and how many would he turn out of Doors for Dunces, and Block- heads, and how many would he put in their places, whofe narrow Fortunes have con- demned them to fopie Mechanic Trade, that neverthelefs are by Nature better qua- . lifted for Learning? But feeing this is not to be done, nor remedied, we fhall even leave it as we found it. 'Tisnot to be denied, but that, as I have faid, fome Wits that are difpos'd for one, are not fo fit for another Science. And for that very reafon, it is convenient before the Child be fent to School, to difcover his In- clination, and the tendency of his Parts, to find out what Study is moft agreeable to his Capacity, fo to order Matters, that he wholly apply himfelf to that. But it is re- quifite alfo to recoiled that what I have faid upofl this occafion, is not fufficient to pro- duce a Learned Man, but we muft confider other Qualifications no lefs necefTary than a natural Difpofition. Therefore * Hippo- * Lib. lex. crates faid, That Wit in Man may hold< H, >M fome proportion with the Earth, and the D 3 Seed 3 8 m)C CtTai Of (KLlit0* Chap. III. Seed fown in it ; for though the Soil of it felf prove fertile and fat, neverthelefs it muft be manured, and care taken what fort of Seed is moil natural to it, for all Land is not alike fit for all Grain, without diftin- ftion , fome bearing better Wheat than Barley, other better Barley than Wheat ; and of that very Grain fome is obfeiVd to bring forth brighter and plumper, not in the leaft admitting any other : Nor is this all that a good Husband-man is to do , for aftej- he has till'd the Ground in due Seafon, he waits the proper Seed-time, which is not to be expe&ed at all Parts of the Year ; and the Corn being grown, he clears it of the Weeds, that it may multiply and thrive, to produce the expefted Fruit. So like- Vyife it is requifite the Science moft natural to the Man being known, that he fhould be fet to the Study of it in his Childhood, *xxxs^abecaufe * Anflotle fays that is the fitteft Frob. iv. time to learn. Befides, that the Life of Man is fhort, but Arts tedious and toilfom ; wherefore, it is neceffary there be time e- nough allotted to learn them, and to exer- cife them, by that means to bring advan- tage to the Commonwealth. The Memo- \ ibid. ry of Children, fays f Ariflotk, refertibles a blank Paper without an Image, which being but young and tender, is capable of any Impreffion \ not like that of grown Men, Chap. III. tC6e €tval of K3tt& 39 Men, which being fluffed with a multitude of Objefts they have feen in the long courfe of their Life, is not fo capable of receiving new ones. For this very reafon, fays * P/ato, in the prefence of our' Children we * £ ia1 °- d « ought never to talk of any thing but true ,u °' Stories and good Actions, which may ex- cite them to Virtue, for whatever they learn at that Age, they will never forget. Quite contrary to f Gden y who affirms, the pro- 1 i n Ora- per time to learn Arts and Sciences, is, when ri °- ^ uafor - Nature has attained her utmoft Force,which artes. ™* is not agreeable to Reafon, except there be fome diftinftion made. Whom- ever would learn Latin, or any In tfofemd Hwf m of other Language, ought to do it JK^SJ&S in his tender Age, .for if he flays (»s f»r « f,^ik) «r, till he arrives at a confirm'd Ma- ™"\ '*«*«•'»* >f »* , .... r - the matt temperate, there tunty, he will never fucceed. f ore m t convenient to fufi In the fecond part of Man's Age, f er ** t9 ? a fi <™<*y>*>' it h which is Youth,* fome pains fSEStf^, IhOUlcrbe taken in the Art Of Munis U ma{e profeffon. Syllogifms, for then the Under- standing begins to difcover it felf, which Jiolds the fame proportion with Logic, as Clogs do with the Feet of Mules, not yet broke, with which having travelled fome days, they infenfibly acquire a better Grace in their going. -Even lb the Underftand- ing being inured to the Rules and Precepts ofXogic, falls infenfibly info more familiar D 4 Methods 40 €lje Ctpai of mit8* Chap. III. Methods of difcourfing and arguing in the Sciences and Difputations. Manhood comes next, when all the fpeculative Sciences may be learned, for then the Underftanding is mature. It is true, Ariflotle excepts Natu- ral Philofophy, alledging, that a Young Man is not fufficiently qualified for that Undertaking, in which he has hit the Truth, becaufe that is a Science of higher Confide- ration, and therefore requires a ftronger Judgment than any other. The Age adapt- ed for Sciences being known, a proper place to learn them in ihould be forthwith fought after, where they teach . nothing CicijOft elfe *, as at the Academies; for the Youth muft be fet out from his Father's Houfe, becaufe the Fondnefs (tf his Mother, Bre- thren, Relations, and Friends (none of them of his Profeffiony are great Impediments to Study. Which is very vifible in fuch Scholars as are Natives of thofe Cjties and Places where Univerfities are featea, none of them (unlefs almoft by Miracle) ever prove Learn'd. But this might be eafily remedied, by tranfplanting the Academies, and fending the Natives of Salamanca to Study in the City of Alcala de Henares r and thofe of Alcala in Salamanca. To aban- don ones Native Country to be made Wi- ier and Worthier is of fuch Importance, that no JMafter in the World can teach one more, Chap. III. €&e ZtVAl Of mit0. 41 more, efpecially if fuch a Man finds him- *- <~elf at Liberty from the Engagements and Pleafures of his own Country. Get thee out of thy Country (fays God to * Abraham) and from thy Kjndred, and from ;» Gen.XlI. thy Fathers houfe, unto a Land that I will f^fherv thee ; and I will make of thee a great Na- tion, and I will blefs thee. God fays the fame now in pffeQ: to all Mankind, who defire to improve in Knowledge and Wit dom ; for although he can. blefs them in their Native Country, neverthelefs he will have them make ufe of the Means he ap- points, and not to wait for Wifdom as the pure Effeft only of his Favour. But this is tobeunderftood, fuppofing the Man to N be Witty and able, for if he be not, Who- ever goes a Beajl to Rorpe, returns from Tu nihiI thence the fame. It avails but little for a invita Di- Dunce to go to Study at Salamanca, if he <** facie,Ve have no Brains, norSenfe, nor any Mafter ,nem ' to teach him. Tlie third Caution is, to find out a Ma- fter of a clear Head, and good Method in teaching, of folid and found Learning, without Sophiftry or Trifling ; for all that the Scholar has to do during the time he learns, is to receiv? all the Mafter pro- pounds, becaufe he has neither: Wit nor Difcretion fufficient to difcer n or diftinguifh between Right and'Wrong ; and it proves a 42 €(JC €tj>al Of E^tsf* Chap. III. a meer chance, not in the choice of the Pupil, to come at that very inftant the Univerfity - is ftored with good or bad Tutors. Thus •vm.Meth it befel certain Phyficians (of whom* G*- *• lK len makes mention) who being convinced from Reafonand Experience of the Errors in their Practice, fo highly prejudicial to*| Mens Bodies/ dropt Tears from their Eyes in the Prefence of the famePhyfician, and began to Curfe their ill Fate, for lighting on fuch bad Matters, when they entred on their Studies. True it is, there are to be found fome Sagacious Pupils, that can im- mediately penetrate into the.Parts of their Tutor, and ifhisDoftrin.be bad, rejeft, if good, approve it. Such as thefe, at the long run inftruft their Mafters more than he does them ; for in fifting, and fubtilly pofing them, they inform him in the fharp Replies they make, fuch as he would never have once dream'd of, or known, if the Scholar by his happy Wit had not put them into his Head. But of fuch as can d& thefe feats, there be but one or two at moft, but the Dunces are without Number ; where- fore it is expedient (feeing no care istaken to Eleft and Examin what Wits are fit for Sciences) that the Academies Ihould be al- ways provided with able Mafters, of ' clear Heads, and found Learning, which may not impoie their Errors and falfe Do&ins on the Ignorant. The Chap. III. Clje Crpai of U&itfi. 4 j The fourth Confideration to be made ufe of, is, to Study the Science with Order, beginning at its very Principles, palling through the middle to the end, not making thofe Firft Principles, which prefuppoie Others. For this reafon it was ever efteem- ed a fault to hear feveral Leftures on divers Subjects, and to carry them home promif- cuoufly, leaving, by this means, fuch a medly of things in the Underftanding, that when they come to be put in Praftice, a Man can have no recourfe to the Precepts of his Art, becaufe they are not in any con- venient Order : It is much better to take fome pains in each diftinft Study, in a me- thod moft natural toitS Institution, becaufe the fame way it is acquired, it will be ftili . retained in the Memory. And more par- ticularly it is neceffary this be obferv'd by fuch as have naturally a confused Under- ftanding, which may be eafily remedied, by hearing one thing at once, and that be- ing over, to proceed to another, and fo till the whole Art be run through. * Gden * Lib, dc well knowing of what Importance it was °^ n Vuo •' to ftudy the Matter with Method and r um. Order, Writ a Book on purpofe to direft the Method which ought to be obfeiVd in Reading his Works, to the end the Phyfi- cian might not be confounded. To this Others add, That a Scholar in Learning Should 44 €fje &W\ Of 2Btt0* Chap. III. fhould never have more than one Book, in which is clearly contained the Point he Stu- dies, and apply himfelf to that alone, and not to many, left he fhould be confounded and perplexed ; and fo far they are in the right. The laft thing that makes a very Learned Man, is to fpend much time in Study, to wait patiently its Digeftion, and to allow it good Settlement ; for even as the Body is not nourifhed by the quantity of what we Eat or Drink in a day, fo much as by the quality of it, when it is affimila- ted and digefted by the Stomach ; fo our Underftanding is not improved by the great deal we read in a fhort time, but by what we underftand by little and little, ^ and paufe upon between whiles. Our Wit en- creafes more and more each day, in light- ing by length of time upon thofe things we fhould not otherwife have known or apprehended. Wit, like £lant, Animal, and Man, has its feveral Stages, that is to fay, its Beginning, Progreflion, Perfect State and Declenfion : It fprings in Child- hood, grows up in Nonage, comes to a Confiftence in the Middle-age, and de- clines in Old Age. So that he, who would know when his Underftanding is at the Pitch of Perfe&ion, may be affur'd 'tis be- tween Thirty-three, and the end of Fifty Years, moreorlefs; in which compafs, he may Chap. III. Cfje Ctpal Of &&{(& 4S may be able to judge of Grave Authors, who in the cour fe of their Lives have broach- ed uncommon Opinions. And whoever would write Books, fhould do it at that very Age, not fooner, or later, unlefs he would eat his Words, or change his Opi- nion. However the Age of Man holds not in all People the fame Meafure and Propor- tion ; for in fome, Childhood draws to a Period in the Twelfth ; in others, not till the Fourteenth ; in fome, it determines the Sixteenth; and in the reft, not- till the Eighteenth Year. Thefe live long, becaufe their Youth reaches not to little lefs than Forty ; and their Manhood holds on to Six- ty Years. Befides which, they have Twen- ty Years of Old Age ; whence their Thread it retches tc^Eighty ; which is the limit of the HealtraR. The firft that finiflh their Childhood at Twelve Years, are very fhort liv'd, begin early to Difcourfe, their Beard comes foon, and their Wit kits but a little time ; thefe ordinarily decline at Thirty- five, and end their Days at Eight and forty Years. There is not one of all the Qualifications already mentioned, but what is very necef- fary, ufeful, and convenient to be obferv- ed, that jhe yCung Student may come to fomething ; but above all, to poiTefs a Gf- nim fuitable to the Science he is to Study, I 46 €f)e Crpal of SBits. Chap. III. For with this we have obferv'd, Nature is the nojlne- ^ m Men W J 10 have be- cefary Condition of all, by aZjk C r u a which thofe that apply gun to Study in a tar ipent Age; themjeives to Am, pm> Nay, though they have lighted 2S£2£l PP ' u P° n *** Mafters_> an ill Me- Baidus coming to Study thod, and ftudied in their Na- the La* in his old Jge t i ve Country, yet all this not- •was laughed at, and told, . «A J* u ru SerovenisBaide, in alio withitanding, have in a ihort fecuio eris Advocams. time prov'd very Learned Men. g^T^S''^; For if Wit be wanting (fays Law, he proved in ajhon Hippocrates) all other rams are time a very extraordinary J Q ^ jsj Man Confirms the Lawyer. Truth of this better than honeft Tulij, who full of Grief to fee his Son fuch a Blockhead, arid that nothing could make him a Scholar, exprefs'd himfelf after this manner^ Tofirive againfl Nature, what is it but Giant-like to make War witjp the Gods ? As if he would havefaid. What more re- fembles the Giants. War with Heaven, than for an Infipid to fet up for a Man of Parts ? For like as the Giants never Conquered the Gods, but were always baffled by them ; even fo empty Pretenders to Learning, that ftriveagainft Nature, will in the end have the Worft of it. Nay, Cicero himfelf ad- vifes us not to offer Violence to Nature, nor attempt to be Orators in fpite of her, for it will be but loft Labour. CHAP, chap. iv. €6e Ctpal of aa*it& 47 CHAR IV. Nature only qualifies a Man for Learning* IT is a common Saying, and much ufed by the Antient Philosophers, that Na- ture qualifies Man for Learning : Art with its Rules and Precepts facilitates, but Ufe and Experience of Particulars gains the Maftery. But no Man has yet declared what this Nature is, nor in what Clafs of Caufes it ought to be rank'd; they only affirm, Whojoever pretends to Learning, and wants that alone. Arts, Experience, Majlers^ Books, and Indujlry prove but all in Vain. There is a great Conteft between the Na- tural Philofophers, and the Vulgar, about afligning djb caufe of this Effect ; The Vulgar observing a Maa of great Abilities, immediately declare God to be the Author of them, without giving themfelves any further trouble, and with good reafon, be- caufe in Ejfecl every good and per feB Gift cometh from above, % from the Father of Lights. There is no Natural Caufe (fay the Phi- lofophers) £an produce Effefts arm'd with fuch Force and Energy as God : So far they are all agreed, that the firft Caufe heats more than Fire, refrefhes more than Water, illuminates more than the Sun himfelf^ and ixi 48 €!je €rj>al of mits. Chap. iv. in our particular Formation, 'tis that which , .prefides over Nature, and that difpenfes or denies Wit to Men. Which Confideration made the Royal Prophet David cry out, Thy hands have made me andfajhionedme y give me 'Understanding that I may learn thy Com- mandments. All the Antient Philbfophers in a fort confefs the fame thing, by Inftinft of Nature alone, conducted by right Rea- fon to atteft this Truth in^fpight of all Op- . pofition. 'Twas upon that foot, Plato knowing no City could be built without the Divine Afliftance, nor any good Laws made to confer ve Men in Peace after an Eftablifh- ment thereof, framed a Law, by which it was provided, That the Divine Afliftance (hould be invoked at the beginning of every A5lion^ becaufe without that mgooa thing could have a juft Accomplijbtimjt. Which is the fame thing, that was laid by King David before, Except the Lord keep the City, the Watchman waketh but in vain. Hippo- crates defigning to reduce into Method the Art of Curing thofe Difeafes to which Women, by reafon of their Sex, are ex* pofed, and efteemingit to be a very diffi- cult matter, .faid, He that would treat of thefe Matters to purpofe^ ought firfi to invoke the Gods, and afterwards to confider'and nice- ly diftinguifh the Nature^ Age^ andTempera- ment of Women, m alfo the Climate where they Chap. IV. €f)£ Ztni Of fe't& they live. Which the Natural Philofophers could not away with, becaufe when they were to fearch into the Caufe of any Efteft, they ftop'd at the Firft and Univerfal, without looking further, or having regard to the Order or Dependence of Second Caufes, as if they had not been Influenc'd to produce fuch an Eflfefr. Which occa- fion'd Hippocrates to blame Diaries Priefts for moving the Women, in their grievous Difeafes, to offer up at the Temple, their ftately Garments,and moft precious Jewels, and to leave there the Medicines; whereas the proper Remedy for their Malady, was (as Hippocrates fays) to Bleed, or Purge, it maybe, or ad vile them to Marry, i£they were at Age. A Natural Philofopher be- ing in Difcourfe one day with a Gramma- rian, a curious Gardiner came up to them, and asked them, what was the reafon that having taken luch pains with the Earth, to dig, tofift, tocleanfe, and dung it, yet it never brought forth fo good Seed as he Sow'd ; whereas the Plants it produced of its own accord, grew up with a great deal of eafe ? The Grammarian aniwer 7 d, It came to pals' by the Divine Providence, which had fo difpos'd it, for the good Go- vernment of the World. But the Natural Phiiolopher fell a Laughing at thatanfwer, feeing he had recourfe to God, as being Ig- E norant 50 Cfje Crvai of QEft& Chap. IV . norant of the Connexion of Natural Caufes, and in what manner their Effe&s are pro- duced. The other feeing him Ji*52£«Sr, laugfc ask'dhimifhendicul'd bow far itsjurifd&ion ex* him? The Philofopher anfwer'd, tends, and what Qpeflicm ft was not him, but the Mafter properly belong to it. 111 1 1 • 1 that had taught him no better, becaufe the Cognizance and Solution of the Motions of Divine Providence (as they are Supernatural A&s) appertain to the Meta- phyficians, (now a-days called Divines) for the Gardener's queftion was Natural, and properly belonged to the Natural Philofo- phers, thofe being eftahlifh'd and manifeft Caufes, whence iuchEflefts are produced. For which reafon the Philofopher fays,That the Earth refembled a Mother-in-law, that took a particular care of her own Children, but ftarved thofe of her Husband; for we obferve hers to be plump and in good liking, but the other meager, lank, and ill colour- ed. The Plants the Earth produces of her felf, come out of her own Bowels ; thofe the Gardener raifes, are forced by Art, be- ing the Daughters of another ftrange Mo- ther, void of the Virtue and Nourishment that fhould m^ke them thrive, and what is communicated only to the Plants, fhe her felf brings forth. • in Epift. * Hippocrates confirmed this in his Vifit he iti£ am€ " mac * e t0 t ' ie S reat Philofopher Democritus, getuIT ' \jho Chap. IV. Cfje €t?>al of Wilts. 5 i who acquainted him with the falfe Notions the People had of Phytic, who, as if they were free from all Difeafes, had nothing in their Meuths, but that God had healed them, and if it had not pleafed him, the Phyficians Care and Skill Had been all em- ployed to no purpofe, and the like. This is the old way of Talking, and which has fo often been in vain exploded by the Natu- ralifts, that it is not worth while to endea- vour to filenceit; Neither is it altogether convenient, becaufe the Vulgar, who are not acquainted with the particular Caules of any Efteft whatever, anfwer better, and with more truth,from the uni verfal Caufe ( w hich is God) than to run into Impertinences. However, I have many times confider'd with my felf, whence it fhould come, that the Vulgar fhould fo readily afcribe all things to God, taking no notice at all of Nature,and not without fome fecret Abhorrence of Na- tural Means. I know not well how to divine the true Caufe, but thus much I find, that the Generality of People being ignorant, which Efre&s more immediately to refer to God, and which to Nature, prate after this manner \ befides, that Men are (for the moftpart) impatient, and Friends to thofe that fir ft gratify their Defires. And the Procefs of Nature being flow, and requi- ring length of Time, they have not Pa- E 2 tience 52 m)t €tvnl Of mitS. Chap. IV. tience to attend the Event, but knowing the Omnipotence of God, who in anlnftant does what he pleafes, of which they want not many Inftances, they either beg at his Hands Health, with the Paralitic ; orWif- dom, with Solomon; or Riches, with Job; or Deliverance from their Enemies, with David. An other Reafon is, becaufe Men are Opinionative and Conceited, moft of them wifhing in their Hearts that God would di- ll inguifh them by fome particular Favour, not in the common Road, and as he makes the Sun to fhine upon the juft and the Un- luft, and the Rain to defcend upon all alike ; Favours being rather the more efteemM, by how much the Rarer they are, and more Appropriate to a few. Upon which pre- tence wehavefeen many Men feign Mira- racles, in Times, and Piaces of Devotion, tor which caufe People flock about them,and pay juft Veneration to them, (as Perfons in Favour and Efteem with Heaven) and if they are poor, they beftow confiderable Alms upon them, who play the Religious Counterfeits for Intereft. The third Caufe is, Men are lovers of their Eafe, and Natural Caufes being infiich an Order, and Concatenation, as requires a great deal of Time and Application to dis- cover their Effe&s ; therefore they had ra- ther Chap. IV. Cfje Crpal of f33ft& 5? ther God fhould exert his Omnipotence, that fo they might without the leaft Pain or Delay obtain their Defires. I fliall take no notice of the Malice of thofe,* who feek for Miracles fronf God, to tempt his Om- nipotence, to try if he can work them ; nor of others, who to gratify their Revenge, * call for Fire from Heaven, and the like fe- vferelnftances of the Divine Vengeance. Thelaft Reafonis, tliat the Vulgar, ge- nerally fpeaking, are very Religious, and defirous that God fhould be greatly Ho- noured, and much Glorified, which comes to pafs by Miracles, rather than Natural Events; for the common People j are not aware, that'God is not the Author of all Supernatural and Extraordinary tilings, fo much to proclaim his Almighty Power to the Ignorant, as to employ them as nobler Arguments to confirm his Doftrin,- and that unlefs upon fuch an Emergency, he never works any. This is eaiily under- ftood, if we confider, that God works not now fuch Miracles as once in the Old and New Teftament^ and the Reafon is, becaufe he has already done all that was neceilary on his part, that Man might not pretend Ignorance, but to imagine that he fhould be ready to employ the fame Arguments again and again, and work new Miracles to confirm afrefh his old Doftrin (as in the E 3 In, XXXUI 54 ®l)C CtMl Of £ftitt0. Chap. IV. Inftances of raifing the Dead, giving Sight to the Blind, Feet to the Lame and Para- litic) is a great miftake ; for at the fame inftant as God teaches Men what is conve- nient, he confirms it by Miracles, without I- l S n C T h ' re P eat i n S them every day a-new. * God [poke once , and did not repeat the fame a fecond time. The cleareft Indication I have to difcover a Man that has no Wit p^- penfe to Natural Philofophy, is, when I fee him referring all things to Miracles, without any diftinftion : As on the other hand, there is no need to call in queftion their Underftanding, who cannot reft fa- tisfied without difcerning the particular Caufe of 'every Effe£t. Thefe are well a- ware that fome Events are to be referred immediately to God, as are Miracles ; and others again to Nature, as thofe that have their immediate Caufes, from which they ordinarily "flow. But let us talk at what rate we pleafe, God is always underftood to be the Author, even of the laft ; for when Arifiotle faid, -j- God and Nature make no- thing in Vain, he never meant that Nature was an Univerfal Caufe, having a Power independent upon God. but a Name only of that Order and Subordinate Rule ap- pointed by God himfelf, in the Creation of the World? to the end that # fuch Effefts might duly fucceed, as were neceifary to its t Lin. I. tit Ccdo. Chap. IV. tCBe €tpal of (Kltts* 5 5 its Confervation and Continuance in the fame ftatc. So we fay the King and pivil Right can do no Wrong, by which man- ner of fpeaking, no Man takes the Term (Right) to fignifie another Prince of fepa- rate Jurifdiftion from the King, but rather as a Term by its fignification importing all the Laws and Ordinances made by the King himfelf to prefer ve the State in Peace. Like as a King has fome peculiar Pre- rogatives , that cannot be Determined by the Law, as being Paramount and Ex- traordinary ; even fo has God refervM to himfelf the Effefts of Miracles, for the Pro- duftion of which, he has given no Com- miflion or Power to Natural Caufes; where, by the way, we may obferve that he who takes them for fuch, and can diftin- guifh them from natural Effects, muft needs be a very acute Natural Philosopher, and underftand no lefs than every Effeft, as it fprings from its immediate Caufe, tho' this is not enough neither, if the! Catholic Church hath never declared The/tm-Mceofmtu- them for fuch ; for like as Ad- « r *i pkihfotyZJkh m!h vocates engaged in the Study of *M» ^'w/« when they the Civil Law, have it imprint- >""»•'• ed in their Memory, the better to know and underftand the Kings Pleafure in the Determination of each particular Cafe: E- \ ven fo the Natural Philofophers (being E 4 Advo- 56 ftlje Ccpai of mite. Chap. IV. Advocates in their Faculty) place their whoje Study in this, to know the Order God eftablifih'd at the inftant he created the World, thebetter to difcern what Cau- fes produce, what Efte&s and why ? And ( as it would be ridiculous for a Lawyer to alledge in his Breviate, as a ftrong Proof, that the King commanded fuch an Arreft in fuch a Cafe, without fhewing the Law, . and the Rule of Court, by which it ought to be decided : So the Natural Philofophers laugh at them, who pronounce this or that is God's Work, without running through the Order, and infeparable Connexion of all the particular Caufes concerned in its imme- diate Pr oduclion. And for the fame reafon as a King de- nies to hearken to thofe that prefs him to Abrogate and Null a juft Law, or finally to decide a Cafe c@ntrary to the Handing Rules and Orders of his Minifterial Courts ; fo neither will God likely hearken to thofe that importune him for Miracles and Signs out of the ordinary Courfe and Miniftry of Nature, when there is no Qccafion for them. For Ihould a King every day null and make Laws, and alter the Courfe of Juftice (be it for the diver fity of Occafions, or through the changes in his Councils, be- cause Right and Juftice are not arrived at all at opce) yet the Natural Order of die Univerfe A Chap. iv. Cfje Ctyal of flHft*. 57 Univerfe, by us called Nature, from the Creation to this Day, has fuffer'd no Change or Alteration intheleaft; for he made it with fo much Wifdom and Prudence, that not to continue conftant in that Order, would be tacitly to lay a blame upoft his Works. But to return to that common Saying of the AntientPhilofophers, Nature makes Me ; it is to be underftood, that there is a Wit and Ability beftow'd by God on Men, out of the ordinary Courfe of Nature, fuch was the Wifdom of the Apoftles, who being rude and illiterate, Were wonderfully enlightned and filPd with Wifdom and Knowledge. Which fort of Parts and Qualifications ve- rify not that Nature makes able ; for that is a Work to be attributed immediately to God, and not to Nature. The like is to be underftood of the Wifdom of the Prophets, and of all others, upon whom God has pour- ed any of his Gifts. There is another fort of Wit among Men, produced by the Or- der and Dependence of Caufes appointed by God to lead to fuch an end ; and of this kind it may be truly faid, Nature makes able. For ( as we fhall prove in the laft Chapter of this Work) there is a certain Order and Dependence of Natural Caufes, fo that if Parents in the Aft of Genera- tion would duly obferve it, all their Chil- dren 5 8 CIjC Ctval of mttSi. Chap. IV. dren would be Wife, and none of them O- therwife. However, in this Difcourfe fuch a figni- fication of Nature is tooloofe andconfiis'd, nor is the Underftanding content to reft here, without tracing every particular EfFe£t up to its Ultimate Caufe ; and* therefore there is need to find out another tpeaning of this Word (Nature) which may be more accommodate to our purpofe. ♦Lib. It * Jriftotk, and all other Natural Philo- f^fa ClCm fophers, were more Particular, calling Na- ture, every fubftantial Form that gives Be- ing to a thing, and is the Principle of all its Operations. In which fenfe, our Rational Soul with good Reafon is call'd Nature, for from thence we receive the Form and Be- ing we have of Men, and the fame is the Principle of all our Aftions ; for all Rational Souls are of equal Perfe&ion ( as well the Wife Man's as the Fool's) and fo we may not pronounce, that it is Nature fin this fenfe; makes a Man witty; for if that were true, all Men w r ould be equal in Wit and txxx. Capacity, and thereupon the famef Ari- Seft. Prob. fiotk found out another Signification of 1 Nature, importing the Reafon and Caufe of a Man's being capable or incapable ; fay- ing, that the Temperament of the four firft Qualities fHeat, Cold, Moifiure, and DrinefsJ were to be call'd Nature, inaf- much chap. iv. Cfje Crpai of mite. 59 much as from them proceed all the Abili- ties of Men, all the Virtues and flees, and all the great variety of Wit we difcover in the World. And he proves it clearly by confideringthe feveral Parts of the Age of the wifefl^Man, who in his. Childhood is no more than a Brute Beaft , employing no other Powers than the Irafcible and Con- cupifcible; when Youth comes, he betrays an admirable Wit, which we fee continues to a certain Period, and no longer ; for old . Age drawing on, his Wit e v^ry day declines, till in the End it is wholly loft. AflureHly the diverfity oF Wit proceeds not from the Rational Soul, for that in all Ages is the fame, without fuffering any Alteration in its Vigor, or Subftance, except a Man in the feveral Stages of his Life changes his Conftitution, or has a different Difpofition ; and from hence is it that the Soul a£ls one part in the Childhood, another in Youth, and yet another in old Age; whence may be drawn an evident Argument, that fee- ing the fame Soul performs contrary A&s in one and the fame Body, by having in each Divifion of Age, a different Temperament ; whenfoever of two Boys, the one is Witty, the other a Dunce, the fame happens by each having a diverfe Temperament from the other, which (being the Principle of all the Operations of the reafonabie Soul) is 6d €f)C Ctjtti Of mitti* Chap. IV. is by Ptyficians and Philofophers call'd Nature ; in which fenfe this Saying, Na- ture makes able, is properly Verified. In confirmation of which DoQxin, Galen writ a Book, proving, that the Operations of the Soul, were influenced by theTempera- ment of the Body, in which it dwelt; and that by reafon either of the Heat, Cold, Moiftureand Drinefs, of the Climate where they lived, or the Qualities of the Meat, they eat, and of the Waters they drank, and of the Air they breathed in, fome were Fools, and others Wife ; fome Stout, and others Cowards ; fome Cruel, and others Gentle ; fome Referv'd, and others Open ; fome Ly ars, and others Speakers of Truth ; fome Traytors, and others Loyal ; fome Turbulent, and others Calm ; fome Craf- ty, and others Sincere ; fome Sordid, and others Generous ; fomeModeft, and others Impudent ; fome Incredulous, and others Credulous; in Proof of which, he quotes many Places out of Hippocrates, Plato, and Arifiotky aflerting, that the Diverfity of Nations as to the Frame of their Bodies, and the Turn of their Soul, was owing to this Difference of Temperament. Which is found true by Experience, how much the Greeks differ from the Scythians, the French from the Spaniards , the Indians from the Germans y and the Ethiopians from the Chap. IV. Cfje Ctpal Of QEUtff* 61 the Englijb. Neither is this only to be ob- ferv'd in Parts fo remote from each other, but if we confider even the Provinces that furround all Spain 7 we may diftribute the Virtues and Vices already mentioned a- mongft the Inhabitants, allotting to each his Virtue and his- Vice refpe&ively. For if we refleft on the Wit and Manners of the Catalans, Valentians, Murcians, Granadins, Andaluftans, Efiremadurians , Portugueses , Gallicians, Afturians, Miquelets, Bijcajners y Navarrers, Arragonians, and Caftilians , who fees and knows not that they differ one from another, not only in the Lineaments of their Faces, and Make of their Bodies, but alfo in the Virtues and Vices of the Soul, and that all this is the Conference of each Provinces poffefling a different Temperament ? Nor is this Diverfity of Manners only to be obferv'd in Countries fo disjoined, but even in Places feated not more than a little League diftant, the Vari- ety of Wit amongft the Inhabitants is hard- ly to be believed. Finally, what Galen writ in his Book, is the Foundation of this Work ; although he did not arrive at the particular dffcuflion of the Difference of Wits amongft Men, nor the Sciences which each in particular required ; yet he knew full well it was neceflary to make a Repar- tition of the Sciences among the Youth, and 62 C&e Ctpal of WXitS. Chap. v. and to aflign to each, that which was moft fuitable to his Genius ; when he faid, that Well-order'd Republics fhould employ Men of great Wifdom and Knowledge, who in their growing Years fhould found the Wit and Natural Application of each, fo to engage them to learn the Art moft agreeable to them, not leaving it to them to aft at their own choice. CHAR V. What Tower the Temperament -has to make a Man Wife and good Na- ttered* TIppocrates, in confideration of the good X JL difpofition of our Rational Souls, and how frail, and every way fubjefl: to change Human Bodies, wherein they dwell are ; delivered a Sentence worthy fo great an Author. Our Rational Soul is always the fame, throughout the whole courfe of our Life, in Touth and in Age, when we are Children, and grown Men ; the Body cfuite contrary, never continues in one State, nor is 'there any Means to keep itfo. And although fome Phyficians have been in fearch of an Art tothispurpofe, yet they have never been able Chap. v. €&e Cvpal of s, we can neither Merit nor Demerit. But on the contrary, we fee a great many Perfons, who fail not to be Virtuous, in ipite of a Ccn- ftitution that is Vitious and Deprav'd, and F fuch 66 C&C Ctpal Of 2Btt& Chap. V. fuch as rather difpofes them to Evil than Good, according to that Saying, ' That a wife Man is Superior to the ill Influences of Heaven : And for what concerns wife and difcreet A&ions, we fee many indifcreet Actions committed by very Wife and well Tempered Men ; as on the other fide, not a few* difcreet Aftions committed by Per- fons that are not fo ; atid who are of no happy Conftitution. . Whence we may collect, that Prudence and Wifdom, and other Human Virtues, are from the Soul, and depend not at all upon the Compofi- tion or Frame of Body, as Hippocrates and Galen have vainly imagin'd. Though it may feem ftrange,that thefe two great Phy* ficians, and wim them Ariflotle and Plato, were of the fame Opinion, and all without Truth. We are to take notice therefore, that the Perfe£t Virtues, fuch as the Moral Philofophers treat of, are Spiritual Habits, \ which have place in the Rational Soul, and whofe Being is altogether independent up- on the Body. From which it is evident, there is in Man neither Virtue nor Vice, ' (I fay nothing of Supernatural Virtues, as being not of this Rank) that has its proper Temperament of Body, either to facilitate, or retard him in his Aftions ; this Temperament then, the Moralifts im- properly call Virtue, or Vice, cojifidering that chap. v. C&e Crpal of wata. 67 tliat Men, ordinarily fpeaking, betray no other Inclinations than thofe mark'd out by this Temperament ; I fay ordinarily fpeak- ing, becaufe in effefl: many Mens Souls are fiird with perfeft Virtue, although the Organs of their Body afford them no Tem- perament fubfervient to accompliih the Defires of the Soul ; and yet neverthelefs for all that, by virtue of. theic Free Will, they fail not to aft like good Men, though not without fome Struggle and Reluclance : According to which St. Paul has faid, I de- light in the Law of God after the Inward Man , but I fee another Law in my Members warring againji the Law ofmyMind ? and bringing me into Captivity to the Law of Sin, which is in my Members. wretched Man that I am y . who fhall deliver me from the Body of this Death ? I thank God through Jefus Chrift our Lord. So then with the Mind I my felf ferve the Law ofGod, but with the Fle/h the Law of Sin. In which Words St. Paul gives us to underlland, that he felt within himfelf two Laws, wholly oppofite ; one in his Soul, which made him to love God's Law ; the other in his Members, that led him to .Sin. Whence we may gather, that the Vir- tues St. Paul had in his Soul, did not cor* refpond with the Conititution of his Body, it being neceffary for them to aftfwith a F 2 fweet 62 CljeCrpalofGHitg. Chap.V. fweet Confent, and without the Refiftance of the Flefh, his Soul afpir'd to Pray and Meditate ; but when in order to this, the motion prefented to his Brain, it was found indifpofed, becaufe of his great Coldnefs and Moifture, which are ftupifying Qua- • lities, aAd proper to move to Sleep. Of the fame Temper were the three Difciples that accompanied Jefus Chrift in the Gar- den, when he Pray'd, telling them, The Spirit is willing, but the Flejb is weak. In like manner his Spirit would have Fafted, and when to that end the Offer was made to his Stomach, he found if weak and with- out ftrength, as having an unruly Appe- tite : His Soul would have him Chaft and Continent, but when the motion prefent- ed to the Parts of Generation, it found them inflamed with Concupifcence, and inciting him to Aftions of a contrary Nature and Tendency. With fuch like Inclinations as thefe, virtuous Perfofts find it a hard Task to live well, and not without Reafon was it faid, That the Road to Virtue was covered over with Therm : But if the fame Soul that is bent upon Meditation, rrfeets a Brain Hot and Dry,whicharethe Difpofitions peculiar to Watching ; and if when it attempts to Faft, it finds a Stomach Hot and Dry, of which Conftitution, according to Galen, the Chap. V. Cfje VLtm tfmitfr 69 the Man is that loaths Meats ; and if when it aims to Embrace Chaftity, it meets the Parts of Generation Cold and Moift, with- out doubt it will accomplifh the feveral Propofals without any Struggle or Relu- ftance whatever j becaufe the law of the Mind and the Law of the Members exact botli the fame thing, and fuch a Man, in fuchaCafe, may aft V'irtuoufly, without any Violence to his Nature. Wherefore Galen faid, That it was the Part of a Phy- fician to make a Man Virtuous, that was formerly Vitious ; ^nd that the Moral Phi- lofophers committed a great over-fight in not making me of Phyfic, for attaining the Perfection of their Art ; fince in Correct- ing only the ill Conftitution of the Body, they might make the Virtuous aft with-r .out any Check, and with a fweet Con- fent. What I would defire of Galen, and all the Moral Philofophers, is, that admitting it to be true, that to each Virtue and Vice feated in the Soul, there correfponds a par- ticular Temperament of Body, which Aids, or Diverts it in Aftirig, they would have given us a particular Account of all Mens Virtues and Vices ; and have told us by which Corporal Qualities, both one, and the other, are Supplanted, or Maintain'd, to the End we might not be to feek for a proper Remedy. F 5 Ari- jo Cfje €ipal of Ulit$> Chap, V. Ariftotle knew well, that a good Tem- perament made a Man Prudent, and of a good Difpofition, which occafion'd him to lay, That the good Temperament did not only affect the Body, but aljb the Mind of Man: But he has not {hewn what this good Tem- perament was ; on the contrary, he affert- cd, That Mens Difpofitions were founded upon Hot and Cold/ But Hippocrates and Galen exclude thofe two Qualities as Vi- tious, approving the Equality of Tempe- rament, where the Heat exceeds not Cold ; northeMoifture, Drinefs. Which made Hippocrates fay , If the great Moifiure of the Water^ and the excefflve Drinep of the Fire, are equally Tempered in the Body, the Man will he very Wife, Neverthelefs many Phyfi- cians, becaufe of the great Reputation of the Author, upon Enquiring into this § Temperament, have found that it does not * Anfwer what Hippocrates promifed ; but on the contrary, their Opinion was, that thofe who had it, were Weak Men, and of little Vigor, and did not exprefs in their Aftions fo much Conduft as thofe of an ill Conftitution : They are of a very Sweet and Affable Temper, and Inoftenfive to every Man in Word and Dee4 , which makes them pafs for very Virtuous, and void of Paffion, which raiies Tempefts in the Soul. Thefe Phyficians difapprove the equal Chap. v. C&eCtval of Wlite* 71 equal Temperament, inafmuch as it dif- ables and flats the force of the Spirits, and is the caufe they do not aft freefy as they ought. Which appears evidently in two Seafonsofthe Year, the Spring, and Au- tumn, when the Air falls out to be Tem- perate, for then happen the Difeafes, info- much that the Body is obferv'd to be much more healthful when it is either very Hot or very Cold, than during the mediocrity of the Spring Time. Sacred Writ, in fpeaking of the fenfible Qualities, feems in a manr^r to favour this Opinion, / would thou wert either Cold or Hot ; fo then becaufe thou art Lukewarm, I willffue thee out of my Mouth. Which feems to me to be grounded upon AriftotWs Do- ftrine, who held for an infallible Opinion, that all the Natural Aftions of Man con- fifted in Heat and Cold, and not in a Luke- warmnefs and Mediocrity of Coftititution. But Anfiotle would have done well to have told'us, what Virtue correfponds to each of the Qualities, and to what again the contrary Vice, that fowe might have ap- plied in Praftice the Remedies prefcribed by Galen. As for me, I believe Cold is of more Im- portance to the Rational Soul, to preferve 'its Virtues in due Peace, and to prevent all undue Ferments amongft the Humours ; F 4 for ^z C&e Ct pal of Witfl* Chap. V. for Galen fays no lefs, there is no Quality fo much blunts the Concupifcible and Iraf- cible Faculty as Cold, nor that fo power- fully excites the Rational Faculty, as Ari- fiotle affures us that does, efpecially if it be joined with Drinefs ; for this is certain, as the Inferior Part is difabled or depreffed, the Faculties of the Rational Soul in the fame proportion are exalted and inlarged. But be that as it will, I would prefent to a Moral Fhilofopher a Luxurious Drunkard and a Glutton, to manage him according to the Rules of l^s Art, and to inftill into his; Soul the contrary good Habits of Chaftity and Temperance, by thefe means reducing him to aft with all Moderation and Sobrie- ty, without introducing into -his Constitu- tion Cold and Drinefs, and without cor- refting the over-ruling Heat and Moifture there was before ; let us fee how he will go about it. Without doubt the firft thing he does will be to fhew him the Sordidnefs of Luxury, and to lay before him the Train of Evils it draws after it, and in what dan- ger his Soul would be, if Death fhould happen to furprize him on a fudden, with- out giving him refpite to repent of his Sins< After this, he gravely admonifhes him to Faff, Pray, and Meditate ; to Sleep but little, to lie hard, and without Delicacy \ to wear Hair Clothes, and Diicipline him- '• fel£ Chap. v. C&e Ctpal Of GBftfc 7} felf ; to fly the Company of Women, and to give himfelf wholly to Pious Works ; all which are comprized in this fine Aphorifm of St.Paul y Ikeep under my Body, andiring it into Subjection. By means of thefe Aufte- rities, if he practices them long, he'll ap- pear Meager, Pale, and muchAlter'd from what he was, infomuch that he who before hunted after Women, and that placed all his Happinefs in the Pleafures of Eating and Drinking, will hardly have Patience to hear them fpoke of. The Moralift be- holding the Lewd Man fo changed, will fay, and not without reafon, this Man has ndw acquired a Habit of Chaftity and Temperance : But becaufe his Art reaches no further, he vainly imagines thefe two Virtues $r e come I know not from whence to make him a yifit, and to take up their Lodgings in his Rational Soul, without having fo much as part through his Body. Inftead of which the difcerning Phyfician, who knows whence his lofs of Blood and Spirits proceeds, and how the Virtues are Begot, and the Vices Extinguifhed, will be apt to pronounce, that this fame Man has now the Habit of Chaftity and Tem- perance, inafmuch as by means of thefe Au- fterities he has impaired liis Natural Heat, in whofe ftead the Cold is introduced : For if we refleft a little further, we fhall clear- ly 74 <£& Ctpal Of {E»ft& Chap, V. ly fee this new way of living is capable of cooling him more ; the Horror into which the Reprimand he received threw him, and the awful confideration of the Pains of Hell prepared for him, if he had died in mortal Sin, had without doubt mortified and chiPd his Blood. Whereupon Ariftotle propofed this Queftion ; Why thofe who are in fear falter in their Speech, tremble with their Hands , and hang their Lip? his (fays he) becaufe this Pajfion is a defect of Heat , which commences from the Parts above : Whence comes the Palenefs of the Face. Ab- ilinence like wife is one of the things which chiefly mortifies the Natural Heat, leaving the Man cold : For our Nature is fupport- ed, fays Galen, by Eating and Drinking, in the fame manner, as the Flange of the Lamp is fed by the Oil ; . and there is fo much natural Heat in the Body, that has digeftedFlefh-meats, that they afford him Nourifhment in proportion to his Heat, and if they ihould yield him lefs in quan- tity, his Heat would infehfibjy diminifh. Which made Hippocrates forbid the letting of Children faft, becaufe their natural Heat Evaporated and Wafted for want of being fed. * The Difcipline given, if it be dolo- rous, and reach even to the fetching Blood, every man knows it extreamly diflipates ■" the vital and animal Spirits ; and from the lofs Cfaap. V. Cfie Crpal of U3iit$. 7 5 lofs of Blood, the Man foon comes to lofe his Hair, and natural Heat. As for Sleep, Galen&ys, it's one of the things which moil fortifies our Heat, for by it's means that in- finuates into the hidden receffes of our Bo- dies, and Animates the Natural Virtues ; and much after the fame manner our Food is affimilated and turned to our Sub/lance : Whereas Waking generates Corruptions and Crudities ; and the reafon is, becaufe Sleep warms the inward Parts, and cools the outward; as on the contrary , Waking cools the Stomach, Liver, and Heart, which are the Vitals, and inflames the external Parts, the lefs noble, and lefs neceffary : Hence he that does not Sleep well, mull needs be fubjeft to many cold Difeafes. To Lie hard) to Eat but once a day, and to go Naked, Hippocrates laid was the utter Ruin of the Flefh and Blood, wherein the natural Heat is plac'ck And Galen giving the Rea- fon why a hard Bed weakens and waftes the Flefa, faid, That the Body was in pain and fuftered deeply for want of Sleep, and that by the uneafie changes of motion from fide to fide, it was Haraffed in the vain purfuit of reftlefs Nights ; and how the Natural Heat decays, and is diffipated by bodily Labour, the feme Hippocrates de- clares, teaching how a Man may become Wife : In order to be Wife, a Man muft not bt: 7 6 €lje Crpal of mit&> Chap. v. be opprejfed with too much Flejh, for that he* longs to a hot Temperament^ which is the Qua* lity that defiroys Wifdom. Prayer, and Me- ditation, caufetheHeatto mount up to the Brains, intheabfence of which, the other Parts of the Body remain cold, and if the Intention of Mind be great, they foon lofe the fenfe of Feeling, which Arifiotle affirm- ed to be necefTary to the Being of Animals, and that the other Senfes, in comparifon of that, ferved only for Ornament and Well- Being. For in effe£t we might live with- out Tailing, Smelling, Seeing, and Hear- ing; but the Mind being bufied in fome high Contemplation,* fails to difpatch the Natural Faculties to their Pofts ; without which, neither the Ears, can hear; nor the Eyes, fee; nor the Noftrils, breath; nor theTafte,reliih; nor the Touch feel; in- fomuch as they who Meditate are neither fenfible of Cold, Heat, Hung£r,Thirft,nor any Wearinefs whatever : And Feeling be- ing the Sentinel that difcovers to a Man the Good or HI done to him, he cannot be without it : So that being Frozen with Cold, or Burnt up with Heat, or Dying away with Hunger, or Thirft ; he is not fenfible of any of thefe Inconveniencies, be- caufe he has nothfng to report them to him. In fuch a ftate, Hippocrates fays, the Soul neglects its Charge, and whereas its Duty Chap, V. Cfje Crpai of mitg* 77 Duty is to Animate the Body, and to im- part to it Senfe and Motion, yet neverthe- lefs it leaves it wholly deftitute and unpro- vided of any Succours. They who are hurt in any Part of the Body, and feel no Pain, afTuredly arediftempered in Mind. But the worft Difpofition obferved a- mong Men of Learning, and thofe that are devoted to Studies, is a Weak Stomach, becaufe the Natural Heat required for Di- geftion is wanting, that very Heat being ufually carried to the Brain, which is the caufe the Stomach is filled with Crudities and Phlegm. For which reafon, Corne- lius Celfus recommends it to the Phy ficians care to Fortify that Part in Men of Medi- tation more than any others, becaufe Pray- er, Meditation, and hard Study extreamly cool and dry the Body, rendering it Me- lancholy. For which reafon Ariftotk de- manded, Whence it is we fee all that have Excelled, whether it be in the. Study of Philofophy, or Government, or the Poets, or in any other Art whatfoever, have been Melancholy. Never to fee Women but to fly wholly their Company, how much that over-cools the Body, and what new Changes are in- cident to Perfons becoming Chaft, Galen makes appear by abundance of Obferva- tionshe had made. He recounts, amongft others, ?S €6e Ctpal of Mite. Chap. v. others, what happened to a Friend of his, a Widdower, who immediately loft his Stomach to that degree as he could only digeft the Yolk of an Egg ; and if by con- ftraint he Eat as formerly, he ftrait Vomi- ted ; and was withal Lumpifh and Dull, upon which Galen's advice to him was, to Marry again if he'd recover his Health ; and thereupon faid he, He was immediately freed, from all his Complaints, as foon as he returned to his old way of Living. The fame Phyfician tells of fome Chorifters, who find- ing by Experience the near Correfpondence between the Teft icles and the Throat, and that to fport with Women endangers the fpoilingof the Voice ; they were Chaft by conftraint , that they might not lofe the good Cheer, and the Pay which were the returns of their Mufick : And Galen fays further, That their Privy Parts were fo fmall, fo cold, and fo lank, as they look'd like Old Men. But on the contrary, the Wanton had large Genitals, becaufe they kept them often in ufe, the Seminal Vet fels being large and diftended, from which iffued abundance of Spirits, and Natural Heat; for as Plato obferv'd longfince, It is Exercife makes the Parts of the Body more able, as they are Impaired by not Exerting them as they are directed. As it is certain, that in each Aft of Venery, the Parts of Gene- Chap. V. Cfje Ctpai of MiitsL 7 9 Generation are more and more provoked, remaining more able and difpofed to repeat the Aft again ; but as often as a Man checks his Inclination, he becomes colder, and lefs able for Generation. Whence I col- lect, that a Man who by this means is be- come Continent and Cbaft, foon obtains an habitual Frigidity, by which he Per- forms with the fame Averfion and Relu- ftance, as an Old Man, or one that is born Impotent, or an Eunuch. Thofe then that defireto be Chaft, and not to be pro- voked by the Flefh, being confeious of their Infirmity, may ferve themfelves of cold Medicines, and of fych. things as by Impairing and Confuming the Seed, render them frigid, and in this Senfe this Paffage is to be underftood, Happy are they that are majle'Eunuthsfor the KJngdom of Heaven. All that ever we have faid, and confirm- ed, in relation to Chaftity and Inconti- nence, is no lefs true of other Virtues and Vices refpe&ively, for each has his parti- cular Temperament of Heat and Cold, and is to be underftood more or lefs of the Con- ftitution of each Part of the Body, and of the greater or leffer degrees of thefe two Qualities. I have declared for Heat and Cold, becaufe there is neither Virtue nor Vice rooted in Moifture nor in Drinefs ; for, according to Ariftotle*% Opinion, thefe two 8o %\]t Ctpal Of mltg* Chap. V, two Qualities are purely Paflive, as Heat and Cold are Aftive. Whereupon he af- ferted, That our Natural Inclinations are more from Heat and Cold y than from any thing elfe in our Bodies ; and in this he confpires with the Holy Scripture, which fays, I would rather thou wert Cold or Hot, &c. The reafon of which is, becaufe there is no Man found of fo exaft a Conftitution as is required to be the Foundation of Virtue. Whereupon Sacred Writ and Philofophy, ch6fe Heat and Cold* becaufe there are no other Qualities wherein to place the Virtues, although this be not without fomething in Counterballance to them ; for fuppofe there are abundance of Virtues correfpondent to Cold and Heat, thefe Qualities fail no lefs at all times to be the fource of abundance of Vices, by which means it is a great Miracle if there be a Man found fo Lewd, who has not fome Virtues natural to him, or fo Virtuous that has not fome Vices. But the Quality obferved to be beft for the Rational Soul, is the cold Conftitution of Body. This is eafily prov'd, if we run through the.feveral Stages of Man's Life,; Infancy, Youth, Manhood, Middle-Age, and Old- Age ; for we find that becaufe each Age refpe&ively has its particular Temperament, accordingly at one time a Man is Yitious, at another Virtuous ; in one Chap. v. Cfje € ml of mit$. 8 1 one he is Indifcreet, or Perverfe, and in the other Wife and better AdvisM. Infan- cy is nothing elfe but a hot and moift Tem- perament, in which Plato faid, the Rational Soul was as it were plunged and itifled, not being able freely to employ the Un- derftanding, Will, or Affeftions, till in length of Time it paffes to another Age, and has gain'd a new Temperament* The Virtues of Infancy are very many, and the Vices but very few ; Children, fays Plato, admire from what Principles the Sciences arife. In the next Place they are Docile, Tra&able, Gentle, and Eafy to receive the Impreflion of all Kinds of Virtues* In the third Place, they are Balhful, and full of Fear, which, according to Plato, is the Foundation of Temperance. In the fourth place they are Credulous and Eafy to be led ; they are Charitable, Frank, Chart, Humble, Innocent, and Undefigning. To which Virtues Jefus Chrift had regard , wheu he faid to his Difciples, Except you be- come as litt le 'Children, you jhall not Enter into the Kjngdom of Heaven. We know not of what Age the Child was, whom God pro- pofed for our Imitation, but you mult know Hipocrates divided Infancy into three or four Stations, and becaufe Children from the Firft to the Fourteenth Year always admit abundance of Humours, and a varie- G ty 82 myz Ctpal of £Bttg* Chap. V. ty of Temperament; fo likewife they are fubject to divers Difeafes, and their Souls at the fame time not without a great many different Virtues and Vices. In confidera- tion of which, Plato began to Inftruft a Child from the very Firit Year, although he could not then Speak, direfting his Nurfe, how to diftinguifh by his Laugh- ing, his Tears, and even his Silence, his Virtues and Vices; and how fhe fhould Correft them. Holy Writ declared that Saul had the Virtues of this Age, when he was chofen King, He was a Child of a Tear Old when he began to Reign. Whence it appears, that God made the fame Divifion as Hippocrates, obferving the Virtues of In- fancy by the Years. Xouth, which is the Second Age of Man, is reckoned from the Fourteenth to the Five and Twentieth Year ; this Age, ac- cording to the Opinion of Phyficians, is nei- ther Hot nor Cold, norMoiftnorDry, but Temperate, and in a Mediocrity of all the Qualities ; the Parts of the Body in this Temperament are fuchasthe Soul requires for all forts of Virtues, and efpecially for Wifdom. For after this manner fpeaks Hippocrates ; if the great Moifture of the Water, and the extream Drinefs of the Fire happen to be equally Tempered in the Body, the Man will be very Wife, and endued Chap. V. €&e €tj?al Of 2£t!t0. 8 j endued with an Excellent Memory. TJie Virtues we have allotted to Infancy, feem to be £cts proceeding from meer Inftinft <3f Nature, like thofe of Ants, Serpents, and little Bees, which aft without Reafon ; but thofe of Youth are performed with Judg- ment and Difcretion ; fo that he who a£ts at that Age, difcerns what he does, and with what defign, and knowing the End accordingly he difpofes the Means that lead to it. Where the Holy Scripture fays, That the Heart of Man was inclined to Evil from bis Touth; that is to be underftood exclu- fi vely, that is to fay, from the time he pafles from Infancy to Youth, which are the moft virtuous Ages of Man's Life. The third Age is Manhood, which is reckoned from Twenty-five to Thirty-five Years ; its Temperament is Hot arid Dry, of which Hippocrates faid, When the Firs exceeds the Water y the Mind becomes Mad and Furious ; and Experience no lefs con- firms it, for there is no 111 which a Man is not acquainted with, and tempted to at that very Time: PalTion, Gluttony, Lechery, Pride, Murders, Adulteries, Thefts, and Rapines; rafh Defigns, Vanity, Tricks, Lyes, Quarrels, Revenge, Hatred, Indig- nities, and Infolence, are the faireft Inhe- ritance of thefe; at which Age David per- ceiving himfelf to be, cried out, Lord cut G 2 me 84 Cfje Ctyai of Wiit0. Chap. v. , me not off in the mid.fi of my days : For Man- ho6d is the middlemoft of the Five Ages of Man's Life, which are Infancy, Youth, Manhood, Middle-Age, and Old-Age ; and Man is fo Wicked at that Age, as Solo- mon has faid, There he three things which are too wonderful for me, yea four , which I know not ; the way of an Ragle in the Air ; the way of a Serpent upon a Rock ; the way of a Ship in the midft of the Sea ; and the way of a Man with a Maid. From all which it is no lefs than evi- dent, thatihe Soul may in fome fenfe de- ferve. Excufe, if fhe makes any falfe Steps, feeing (he is the fame through the whole Courfe of the Ages of Man's Life, as per- fect as God has Created her at firft ; who then can blame the divers Temperaments which the Body pafles through in each Age, becaufe in Manhood the Body is more In- temperate, which occafions the Soul to en- cline with more difficulty to what is Vh- tuous, and with* more eafe to what is Vi- tious i 'Tis to the very Letter, what the Wifeman Intimates ; / had for my Lot a good Soul) and from my Infancy I appeared of great Wit, and ft ill growing wifer and wifer, (which is to to be underftood of his Youth.) I had neverthelefs a filthy and Intemperate Body y (fuch an one is in Manhood,) and I found at the end of the account , that Man could not be Qhaft or Continent, were it not for the fpecial Chap. V. Cfje €rpal of mit#. 85 [fecial Grace of God. Whereupon David knowing he had efcaped fo dangerous an Age, and remembring what had paft there- in, faid, Remember not the Sins of my Touth, nor my Tranfgreffions. At the fourth Age, which is the Middle Age, or Age of Confiftence, Man returns to be more Temperate, becaufe in pro- ceeding from Hot to Cold, he muftnecef- iarily pais through the intermediate Degrees by which with that Drinefs that Manhood has left in the Body, the Soul is made Wife. ■ Whence it comes that Men who have lived foft in their Younger Days, are fubjeft to the great Changes we fee every Day appear, when they recoiled their ill— fpent Days , with Endeavour to amend them. This Age begins from Thirty-five Years, and reaches to Forty-five, more or lefs, in proportion to the Temperament and Complexion of each refpeftively. The laft Age of Man, is Old-Age, in which the Body is Cold and Dry, fubjeft to a Thoufand Ills and Infirmities, all the Faculties are befotted, arid difabled in per- forming their ordinary Functions ; but be- aufethe Rational Soul is ftill the fame in Infancy, Youth, Manhood, Middle-Age, and Old-Age, without receiving any Change to diminifh its Powers, therefore when it reaches this laft Age, and to this G j Cold 86 %[)z &cpal Of mitt. Chap. V. Cold and Dry Temperament ; it is Juft, Prudent, Strong, and endued with Tem- perance ; and though we ought to attribute thefe Virtues to the whole Man, yet is the SoulallowM to be the firfl: Mover, accord* ing to this, That the Soul is the Principle from which weVnderfland. So long as the Body is vigorous and aftive in its Vital, Natural, and Animal Faculties, Man is but very flenderly provided with Moral Vir- tues ; but as that comes to lofe its ftrength, the Soul ftrait advances in Virtues. St. Paul feem'd to infinuate no lefs in thefe Words, For when I am Weak, then am I Strong, And afluredly this is very true, becaufe the Body in no Age is w r eaker than in Old-Age, nor the Soul more expedite to perform fuch Actions as are conformable to Reafon. Notwithftanding all which, Arifiotle always reckoned Six Vices incident to Old Men, from the coldnefs of Age. The Firfl:, That they are Cowarcls, be- caufe Courage and Valour have great Fire in them, and a large Stock of Blood, of which Old-men have but very little, and that • little too CongeaPd. The Second, That they are Covetous, and that they guard their Treafure more carefully than they need ; for though they find themfelves ar- rived at the laft Stage of their Lives, and that Reaion fhouid teach them/ where the journey Chap. V. €fje Crpal of $&it$. 87 Journey is fhort, the Charge of defraying it is fmall, their Avarice nevertheless and their Thrift fail not to haunt them, as if they were but yet in their Infancy, and they were to run through no lets than all the Five Stages of their Lives, and that it is good to Store, as if they were always to live. The third, that they are fufpicious ; but I cannot imagin why Ariftotle calls this a Vice, fince it is certain, that it pro- ceeds from the Experience they have had of fo many Tricks in the World, and alfo from recollecting what part {hey them- felves Afted in their Younger days ; Info- much as they are ever upon their Guard, as knowing full well how little Men are to be trufted. The Fourth, That they are Diffident, and of fmall Hopes, n^ver promifmg themfelves fuccefs in their Af- fairs, and of two or three Defigns they rpay have, they always fall upon the Worft, and upon that lay out all their Applica- tion. , The Fifth, that they are fhamelefs, becaufe, as Arifiotk fays, Bafhfulnefs and Blufhing are full of Blood, of which Old Men have fo little, as by confequence they are without Shame. The Sixth, That they are very Incredulous, thinking that th6 Truth is never told them, becaufe their Memories are fo frefh of the Jugling and i Deceits they have met within the World, G 4 during 88 %\)t Ctpal Of mitit. Chap. V. during the pad: Courfe of their Lives. Young Children have, as Arifiotle has noted,all the Virtues quitexontrary to their Vices ; they areFearlefs, Frank, not Di- ftruftful in the leaft, always full of Hopes, very Bafhful, eafily perfwaded and impo- ied'upon. The fame things we have evidenced in the feveral Ages of Man's Life, we might alio fhew in the difference of Sex, what V irtues and what Vices Man has, and what Woman, as well by the reafon of the Hu- mours, Blood, Choler, Phlegm, and Me- lancholy ; as alfo from the Diverfity of Climates, and Particular Countries. In one Province the Men are Valiant, in an- other, Cowards ; in this, Deliberate ; in that, Rafti ; in one, lovers of Truth ; in another, Lyars; according to that of the Apoftle, The Cretians are always Lyars, evil Beafts, flow Bellies. And if we run through all the Variety of Meats and Drinks, we fhall find that fome feed this Virtue, and ftarve that Vice ; and others on the contra- ry, nourilhfuch a Vice, and deprefs fucha Virtue; but in fuch a manner, as the Man neverthelefsftill remains free to chufeashe pleafes ; according to that, He hath jet Fire and Waterbefore thee y fir etch out thy hand un- to which thou wilt ; for there is no Confti- tution can do more than incite the Man, without Chap. V. C&e Ctpal of mitt. 89 without forcing him, if he lofes not his Reafon ; and it is to be obferved, that in Studying, and Contemplating things, Man acquires another Temperament befides what belongs naturally to the Conftitution of his Body ; for, as we fhall prove here- after, of the three Powers a Man has, the Memory, common Senfe, and Imagination ; the Imagination only , as Arifiotle has noted, is free to frame what it pleafes ; and by the Operations of this Faculty, Hippocrates and Galen fay, the vital Spirits, and the Blood of the Arteries are always fet on Work, and in Motion ; fhe difpatches them where it feems good to her, and the Parts to which the Natural Heat flies, become thereby more effectual to perform their Funftions, and other Parts weaker. Hence Galen ad- viied the Chorifters of Diana, not to deal with Women, finceby thofe means, with- out attending the Confequences, the Parts of Generation would be inflamed, and as they once took Fire, the Voice would ap- pear more harfh and untuneable, becanfe, OS Hippocrates noted, The Heat of the Tejii- cles lays the Cough , and Jo on the Contrary ; . for let any be put to theBlulh at an Offence taken, the Natural Heat ftrait mounts up, all the Blood flying to the Heart to fortify the Irafcible Faculty, and to deprefs the Rational But if we proceed to confider, tltyt 90 CIjC Ctpai Of mitgt. Chap. V, that God enjoins us to forgive Injuries, and do good to our Enemies, and to refleft a while upon the recompence attending it, all the Natural Heat and Blood ftrait rifes up to the Face, to ftrengthen the Rational and debilitate. the Irafcible Faculty ; and fo it being at our choice, with the Imagina- tion to fortify what Faculty we pleafe, we are juftly Rewarded when we itreng- then the Rational and difable the Irafcible Faculty ; and as fairly Punifhed when we raife the Irafcible and deprefs.the Rational Faculty. From which we may judge, with how good reafon the Moral Philofophers recommend to us the Study and Confi- deration of Divine Matters^ lince by thefe means alone we might acquire the Tem- perament and Strength which the Rational Soul has ufe of, as well as fupprefs the In- ferior Part. But I cannot forbear adding one thing before I end this Chapter, which is, That a Man may Exercifeall the Afts of ' Virtue without having that advantageous Conftitution of Body required, although not without great pain and difficulty ; A£ts of Prudence excepted ; for if the Man be by ' Nature Imprudent, nothing but God can Cure it with a Remedy ; the fame is to be underftood of diftributive Juftice, and of all the Arts and Sciences acquired. CHAP. Chap, VI. Cfje Crpal of mit$. 91 CHAR VI. What Part of the Body ought tq be well Tempered^ that the Child may be . Witty. THE Body of Man having fo great a Difference of Parts and Powers (each deftin'd to its end ) it will not be imperti- nent, but rather highly necelTary above all things, to know what Part Nature has con- trived as the principal Inftrumentto difpofe a Man to be Wife and Prudent. For it is .certain we reafon not with the Foot, nor walk upon our Head , nor fee with our Nofe, rtor hear with our Eyes; but each Part has its proper Ufe and particular Com- pofition, for the Office it is to difcharge. That the Heart is the chief Seat where Reafon refides, and the Inftrument by which our Souls perform the Aftions of Prudence, Memory, and Underftanding, was a received Opinion amongft the Na- tural Philofophers before Hippocrates and Plato were born. The Heart is therefore ftiled the Superior Part of Man in many places of Sacred Writ, which accommo- dates it felf to the way of fpeaking in ufe at that time. But thole two great Philofo- phers 92 %ty Ctpal Of Edit** Chap. VI. pliers have given us to underftand, that this Opinion is Falfe, and with great Reafon and Experience have proved the Brain to be the chief Seat of the Rational Soul ; and thus it was generally received, Ariftotle onlydiffenting, who revived that old Opi- nion, endeavouring by Topical Arguments, and feveral Conje&ures, to make it proba- ble, for the fake of contradi&ing PUto in every thing. Not to difpute which is the truelt Opinion (for in our days there is not a Philofopher but allows the Brain to be the Inftrument by Nature defign'd to make a Man Wife and Prudent) it will only be requifite to lay down the Conditions where- by that Part is beft Organized, that the Youth may thereby become towardly and Witty. That the Rational Soul may conveni- ently perform the Aftions of Underftand- ing and Prudence, there are required four (Salifications of the Brain. Good Confi- guration, is the Firft. Unity of Parts, the Second. That the Heat exceed not the Cold, nor the Moifture furpafs the Drinefs, is the Third. That the Subftance of the Brain be compofed of very fine and deli- cate Parts, is the Fourth. Four other things are comprized under the good Configuration. A good Figure, . is the Firft. Sufficient Quantity, the Se- cond, Chap. VI. €&e Ctpal Of mitft. 93 cond. That there be four feparate and di- ftin£t Ventricles in the Brain, each difpofed in its proper place, the Third. That its Capacity fhould not be greater nor lefs than is convenient for its Functions, the Fourth. • We are taught by * Galen to know when * Lib. Arr. the Figure of the Brain is good, for in re- ^ edlc * cb ' fle&ing on the outward Form and Figure of the Head, he declares it is as it ought to be, if it refembles a Ball of Wax made ex- actly round, and compreft gently on each fide ; which is much the Turn of the Fore- head, and the Hind-part of the Head a little jetting out ; whence it follows that the Forehead and Hind-part of the Head very flat, are a fign the Brain has not the Fi- gure approved for a fharp Wit and Abi- lity. What is mod to be admired is the Quan- tity of Brains the Soul hasoccafiontomake ufe of for Reafon and Difcourfe ; becauie not one amongft all the Brute-Animals has fo much as Man. Infomuch, that if the Brains of two very large Oxen were join- ed, they would not fo much as equal the Brains of one Man, though never fo little \ and what is yet more obiervable, is, that amongft Brute Bealts, thofe who approach nearelt to Man in Wit and Cunning (as the Monkey, the Fox, and the Dog) have . ftiU 94 Cfje €rpal of SBitjs. Chap. vi. ftill a greater quantity of Brains than other Animals, although the fame Animals are much oT greater bulk than thefe. Which ♦ Lib. Art. made * Galen fay, That a little Head in Med. cap. Man was always defective, becaufe it want- XXI ' ed Brains ; as he alfo affirm'd, it was no lefs an ill Indication, to be Born with a great Jolt Head, becaufe it was all Flgfh and Bones, with very little Brains ; as it fares with very fair Oranges, which when they come to be opened, have little Juice and Pulp, but a very thick Rind. Nor is any thing more grievous to the Rational Soul, than to- be plunged in a Body over- ftock'd with Bones, with Fat, and with Flefh. Hippocrates (peaking of the Cure of a certain kind ofPhrenzy, caufed by Ex- cefsof Heat, above all gave in charge that the Sick fhould eat no Flefh, but only Fifh and Herbs, and drink no Wine at all, but only Water ; and if he were too Corpulent, too Grofs, and Unweildy, their Endeavour fhould be to bring down his Flefh \ and for this Reafon he faid, It was abjolutely necef- faryfor a Man that would be very Wije y not to be oppreffed with much Fleflj, nor Fat, but rather to be lean andjlender : For the Flefljy Temperament is Hot and Moijt, with which 7 £is impoffible, or at leafl very improbable, but the Soul Jhould become Blockijh and Stupid* He brings for Inftance the Hog, affirming him Chap. VI. €lje jttrpa! of unit*; 9 5 him to be of all Brute Beads the moft Stu- pid, becaufe of the load of Flefh abouthim , his Soul, (in the Words of Chryfippws) be- ing of no other ufe to him thaaSifc to pre- ferve Jiis Body from ftinking. Ariftotle confirms this Opinion, affirming tfyat Man, to be a Sot that had an over-great Head , and flefhy ; comparing him to an Afs, be- came in proportion to the other Parts of his Body, there is no Beaft's Head fo very flefhy as an Afs's. But as to Corpulence, it ought to be obferv'd, grofs Men are of two forts, fome abounding with Flefh and. Blood, ^whofe Temperament is hot and moift; as others again, who have not fo much Flefh and Blood as they are crammed with Fat ; thefe are of a cold and dry Con- ftitution. Hippocrates's Opinion is to be un- derftood of the firft, becaufe of the great Heat and Humidity, and the abundance of Fumes and Vapors arifing without inter- million in thofe Bodies, which' cloud and overthrow their Reafon ; which is not the cafe of the other, that are only plump and fat, "whom the Phyficians dare not bleed, becaufe they have too little Blqod ; and there is ordinarily abundance of Wit to be found, where there is not fo much Flefh and Blood. That we may throughly un- derftand the great Agreement and Corre- spondence bet ween the Stomach and Brains, efpe- 96 %\)t €tpal of lau'ttf* Chap. VI. efpecially in what relates to Wit and Cun- ning,. Galen has declared, A grofs Paunch makes a grofs Under (landing. But if he means this of thofe that are fat, he has lefs reafon, for they have a very waterifh Wit. Perftus proceeded upon this Reafon, when he {aid, That the Belly gave Wit. Plato affirmed there is nothing darkens the Soul fo much, nor more overcaftsMie Brain, than the black Fumes and Vapours arifing from the Stomach and the Liver at the time .of Digeftion; nor is there on the other hand, any thing that elevates it to fuch high Meditations as Fafting and a fpare Body, not too overcharged with Blood, as the Catholic Church fings, Thou that en- livenejl and relieveft the Spirit by Mortifi- cations and Humbling of the Body, and by the fame means deprejfefi Vices, and bejloweft Vir- tues onus, and with them their Reward. This great Grace God did to St. Paul, when he called to him out of thehigheft Heaven, he remained three days without Eating, ra- vifhed in .Extafy with admiration of the incomparable Favours he had received at the very inftant he was plunged in Vice and Sin. ^Moreover Plato affirms, that the Heads of wife Men are ordinarily tender, and apt to be anoy'd upon the Ieaft occa- fion ; and the reafon why Nature has made them of fo delicate a Head, feems to be for Chap. vr. Clje Curat of Min& 97 for feai* of loading them with too much Brains to the diminishing of their Wit. So true is this Doftrin of P/ato, that tho' the Stomach be far enough from *the Brain, neVerthelefs it annoies it, if it be overcharg- ed with Fat and Flefli : Nor is there any Myftery in this, becaufe the Brain , and the Stomach are knit and tyed together by means of certain Nerves, which Commu- nicate flieirDifafteflions to each other; and on the contrary, if the Stomach be dry and empty, it much fharpens the Wit, as we may fee in thofe who are pinch't with Hunger and Want. But what is more qb- fervable upon this Occafi on is, that if the other parts of the Body are Fat andFlefhy, and the Man by this means be over-Grois, * Ariftotk affirms he runs a rifqueof hav- * l& iv# ing no Wit at all. For which reafon I am de pare »- of Opinion, ifa Man has a great Head, let nimalum - it be from meer Strength of Nature, and from too-great abundance of well-difpofed Matter, yet fuch a one will not have fo much Capacity as if he had a Head of a more moderate Size* \ Arijlotk demanding, what mav be the t XXX Reafon of Man's b^ing the Wifeft of all &a. prob. Creatures? Is of a contrary Opinion, when he replies, that no living Creature has fo fmall a Head as Man in proportion to the Bulk of his Body, for even amonglt Men H them- OMI €fie Crpat of SBitg, Chap, v I. themfelyes (faidhe) they are the^Vifeft who have the leail Heads,* tho' there be no Reafon for this, for if he had ever opened a man's Head, he might have found fo great a Stock of Brains, that, that of two Horfes equals not that of one Man. What I have found by Experience is, that little Men have large Heads, as on the contrary great Men have little Heads; for a very moderate quantity of Brains better Mini- fters to the rational Soul in difcharge of her Functions. Befides all this, it is requitite that there be four Ventricles in the Brain, to enable the rational Soul to Reafon and Difcourfe; one difpofed on the right, the other on the left Side, the third in the Middle, and the fourth in the hinder part of the Brains, as appears from Anatomy. Hereafter where we fhall treat of the Difference of Wits, we fhall fhew what ufe the rational Faculty makes of thefe Ventricles, be they greater or lefs. That the Brain be well figured, of fuffi- cient Quantity, and the Number of Ven- tricles fo many, little or great,as we have fhewn, is not yet enough. It's parts mult alfo obfervea kind of Continuity, without being disjoyned ; for which Caufe we have obferved fome Men wounded in the Head, have loft their Memory, others their com* men Chap. VI. Cfje Cryat of ailftsf. 99 mon Senfe, and others their Imagination, nay even tho' the Brain after Cure lias been rejoyned by Art, becaufe there was not the fame Natural Union as before. ' The third of the Four Principal Qualifi- cations, is, that the Brain fhould be Tern- . perate, of a moderate Heat, and without Excefs of the other Qualities ; which dif~ pofition of the Brairt we have already af- firmed to be that, called True* Temper, for 'tis that which makes a Man capable, , and the contrary Incapable. The Fourth, that the Brain fhould be Compofed of very fine and delicate Parts, and is what Gden thought the moft Im- portant Qualification of all the reft. For giving an Indication of the good Compo^ fition of the Brain, hefaies, that the fharp Wit fhews the Brain to be formed of very fubtileand delicate Parts ; but if the Under- ftanding be Dull, it denotes the Brain to be Compofed of a Grofs Subftance, where he takes no Notice of the Temperament. To the end the Rational Soul might by this means Reafon well, the Brain ought to have thefe Qualities. But here arifes a great Difficulty, which is in opening the Head of any Beaft whatever, we fhall find his Brains compofed after the felf fame manner as Man's, without being wanting in any of the Conditions mentioned. To which it is H 2 Anfwer- ioo €&e Crval of mit$. Chap. VI. Anfwered, that in this, Man and Brute Beads agree, in having a Temperament of the four firft Qualities, without which 'twould be impoffible for them to Subfift ; fo are they compofed of the four Elements, Fire , Air , Water , and Earth , whence fpring and proceed, Heat, Cold, Moyfture, and Drynefs. In the Aftions of the Vege- tative Soul they alfo agree; accordingly Na- ture has given to both alike Organs and Inftruments neceffary for Nouriftiment; fuch are the right Fibres , traverfe and oblique, fubfervient to the four Natural Fa- culties. They alfo confpire in the Senfitive Soul, for fo they have Nerves and Sinews alike for the Inftruments of Senfe. In lo- cal Motion they alfo agree no lefs, thus have they both Mufcles, as fit Inftruments dire&ed by Nature to move from place to place. They alfo accord in Memory and Fancy, for fo have they both Brains, as an Inftrument iubfervient to thofe two Facul- ties, that are alike compofed in both. The Underftanding is the fole Faculty that di- ftinguifhes Man from Beaft, and becaufe the Underftanding afts without any corpo- real Organ, or depends not on the fame for it's being or prefer vation, therefore Nature had no need of a new Turn in the compofi- tion of man's Brain. However the Under- ftanding hath Occafion for other Faculties to Chap. VII. C6c Crpal of JKHitsf. 101 to operate, which Faculties likewife have the Brain for the Inftrument of their Opera- tions : We add farther, that the Brain of Man requires the Conditions we have laid down, to the end the Rational Faculty may by means thereof perform Operations every way agreeable and conformable to its Species. As to Brute Beaits, it is cer- tain they have Memory and Fancy, and fome other Power that Apes the Under- ftanding, even as a Monkey Apes a Man. CHAP. VII. lhat the Vegetative^ Senficive, and Ra- tional Soul are knowing, without be- ing direBed by Teachers^ "token they meet with a Temperament agreeable to their Operations* '"■^HE Temperament of the four Firfi JL Qualities, which we have already called Nature, hath force fufficient of it felf, to leave the Plants, the Brutes, and Man unprovided of nothing wherewith to Aft well, each according to his Species, and to arrive at the higheft Perfeftion each is capable of; for without any Teach- H 3 er 102 €(je Crval of ffllitiS* Chap. VII. er the Plants know how to fpread and take Root in the Earth, to draw Nourifhment, to keep it, to digeft it, and throw off the Excrementitious Parts; and Brute Beafts know as foon as ever they are born into the World, what is agreeable to their Nature, as well as to avoid what is Evil and Noxi- ous. And what moft aftonifhes thofe that do not upderftand Natural Philofophy, is, that Man having a well tempered and difpofed Brain, fuitable to each Science, immediate- ly, and without being direfted by any Teachers, fpeaks concerning that Science of his own accord fuch elevate and fubtle Things,as are almoft incredible.Vulgar Phi- lofophers feeing the admirable Aftions per- formed by Brute Beafts, fay that there is nothing in them to Surprize us, becaufe they ad thofe things by Inftin£l of Nature, which direfts each Species what it ought to do. They fay well, for as we have pro- ved already, Natuit is no other thing but - the Temperament of the four Eirlt Quali- ties, and that the fame is the Mafter, in- ftrufting our Souls how to perform their Offices. But thefe Philofophers call Inftwtt of Nature a certain Heap of things they know not what, which they have never beet} able in the leaft to Explain, or make Intelligible. Thofe Excellent Philofophers, H^gc rates, Plato, and Arijtotle, have re- ♦ ferred Chap. VII. C&e CtVtll Of ffiitS. 103 ferred all thefe admirable Operations to Heat, Cold, Moifture, and Drynefs, which they take for the firft Principles without going further ; and being asked, who has taught the Brute Beafts to perform fuch furprizing Aftions? And Men to Reafon, * Hippocrates replied, Nature, without any * Lib. cis would come Eunuchs or Hermaphrodites ccaquis. - mt0 ^ World; and if it were too Hot t IV. Seft. and Dry, f Ariftotle has noted, they would prob. iv. p rove Hair-Lipped,Splay-Footed, and Flat- Nofed, as the Ethiopians ; and if too moift, g Lib. de || fays the fame Galen y they are like to prove confute. un k c k't, and unfhapen Lubbers ; and if too IV. * dry, it makes them dwindle to a Dwarfilh Stature ; all which enormous Defe&s, are great Deformities in * Mankind, for which there is little reafon to magnifie Nature, or to Efteem her Wife ; but had God been the Author of thefe Works, each of thefe forementioned Qualities could not havefail- *Dialc.de ed f Perfection. which as they are found in order, the Vegeta- tive Soul performs her part very well ; but if fhe Coricurrs. not as fhe ought, a thou- land Abfurdities are produced. The good Order Chap. VII. %\)Z Ctpal Of Kattg* 105 Order for this Effe£t, is, that the Vege- tative Soul have a right Temperament. Otherwife let Galen and all the Philofo- phers in the World give a Reafon? why jttk the Vegetative Soul fhouldhave more Skill and Ability in the tirft Age of Man's Life,to fhape the Body, to Nourifh, and make it Thrive; than when Old Age approaches, •when fhe is difabled ? For inftance, if an Old Man have a Tooth drop out, there is no means or expedient to. get another to grow in the. fame Place; whereas, if a Child lofe all his, we fee Nature repairs the Lofs, by helping him to new ones. How then is it poflible that a Soul that has no 0- ther Bufinefs throughout the whole Courfe of Life; but toattraft Aliments, to retain and digeft them, and expel the Excre- ments, and duly repair the loft Parts, at the end of our Life fhould either forget or not be able- to do the fame ? Certainly Galen would reply, that the Vegetative Soul is skilful and able in Infancy, becaufe of the great Degrees of Natural Heat and Moi- fture; and that in Old Age, fhe wants ei- ther Ability or Skill to do the like, be* caufe of the extream Cold and Drynefs, of the Body incident to Age. In like manner the Skill of the Senfitive Soul depends much on the Temperament of the Brain, for if it be fuch as it's Operati- • ons ao4 CfjC Crpai Of K»ft& Chap. VII. ons require, it fails not to perform them aright ; otherwife, fhe commits a Thou- fand Errors, as well as the Vegetative Soul. * Lib^i. * Galen's T^ft to difcover in one view the deiocisaf- skill and Efforts of the Senfitive Soul, was fcrais. cap. ^ Retook a Kid newly Kidded, which being on his Legs began to go, as if he had been informed and taught that his Feet were given for that very end ; after he had dried up the Superfluous Humor, that came with him from his Dam,* and lift up his Feet, and rubbed behind his Ears, finding before him feveral Platters full of Wine, Water, Vineger, Oyl and Milk, upon fmelling to each of them, he lapped only the Milk. Which being obferved by ma- ny Philofophers prefent, they began to cry out, that Hippocrates had with good Rea- fon faid,- That Souls were directed, what to do without the Teaching of any Majler. Which is the fame with the wife Mans faying, Goto the Ant thou Sluggard, confider her waies, and be wife, which having no Guide, Overfeer, or Ruler ', provideth her Meat in+the Summer, and gather eth her Food in the Harvett. Ga~ len not refting contented with this fingle Ex- periment, two Months after he brought the Kid into the Fields, almoft Starved to Death, and fmelling on feveral forts of Herbs, he fed only on that which was Goats-meat. But it Galen, who ruminated • on Chap. VII. Clje Crpai of ffiHitg. 107 on the Efforts of this Kid, had feen three or four of them together , and obferved fome run better than their Fellows, Ihift better, and fcratch their Ears better ; and quit themfelves better in each Point we have mentioned ; and had Galen brought up two Colts of the fame Mare, he might have obferved the one to be more Graceful ingoing, to have better Heels, to be more Manageable, and flop better than the 0- ther ;and had he taken an Airy of Hawks to train, he might haj/e difcovered, that one would have delighted much in Seizing his Game, another to be Rank- winged, and the third aHaggard,andIll-mannM.' He would have found the fame Difference in Setting- Dogs, or Harriers, tho' each were littered from the fame Sire and Dam, the one needs only thenoifeof the. Chafe,and Roufe the o~ ther never fo loudly, it would aftefl: him no more than a Shepherds Dog. ' All which can never be afcribed to the vain Inftin&s of Nature, 'imagined by Philofophers ; for if they were asked, why one Dog has. a better InltinQ: than an other, both being of the fame kind and breed ? I know not what they could Anfwer, without having recourfe to their common Shift, namely, that God had trained one above the other, having given him abetter Natural Inftinct. And if they were further ask'd, why this hopeful io8 €&e€tpalof«3tt0- Chap. VII. hopeful Hound , when Young , hunted well, but become Old, was not fo good for the Sport ; and on the other Hand, why the other when Young , could not Hunt, but being Old, was Expert and fit to fly at all Game ? I know not what they could fay. For my particular, I fhould fay, that the Dog that hunted better than the other, had more Sagaci- ty; and as for him that hunted well when Young, and turned Cur when Old, that fo it fared, becaufe fometimes he had the Qualities fit for the Chafe, which at other times he wanted. Whence we may Colleft, that fince the Tempera- ment of the four Firft Qualities is the Reafon why one brute Beaft aquits him- felf better than another of the fame Kind, the Temperament is no lefs the Matter which direfts the Senfitive Soul what.it ought to do. Had Galen but refle&ed on the Steps and Motions of the Ant, and ob- ferved her Providence, her Mercy, Ju- ftice, and good Government, he would have been at a lofs , as we are , to fee fo fmall an Animal endued with fo great Senfe, without the Teaching of a- ny Mafter whatfoever. But when we come to confider more clofely the Tem- perament of the Ant's Brain, and obfgVe how proper it is, for Prudence, as we i fhall Cfofc. VII. C6e Crpal of ©HttjJ* 109 Ihallhereafter make appear,then will all our Admiration ceafe, a Fauimer affirmed t 9 and we fhall underftand, that ZIZ ^'JhJ'k Brute Beafts, from the 1 em- fir sp$rt t which became perament of their Brain , and *"' f or n " hin &> *!' * X. T , ' , applying a Cautery he re* the Images that enter there, eovtn d him. thro' the Senfes, arrive at the Ability we difcover in them. And where- as amongft Animals of the fame Kind,one is more Docile, and Ingenious than ano- ther, It happens from the Brain, being tetter Tempered ; fo that if by any Acci- dent or Diftemper it fhould chance to alter and impair, he would forthwith lofe his Ability, as Man does under the like Cir- cumftances. But here arifes a Difficulty touching the Rational Soul, how fhe comes to be En- dued with this Natural Inftintt, where- by (he performs the A&s proper to her Species, of Wifdom and Prudence , and yet all on a fudden, by means of a good Temperament, a Man may underftand the Sciences without the help of a Teacher, e- fpecially fince we are told by Experience, if they do not learn them, no Man brings them into the World with him. It has long been a controverted Point betwixt Plato and Jriftotle,\vhich way Man comes by Knowled ge;one faies,that the Rational Soul is much Older than the Body, and it's Natural no Cfje Crpal of mm. Chap. VII Natural Birth enjoying in Heaven the Company of God, from whom fhe came filled with Wifdom and Knowledge, but after fhe dropt down to inform the Body, fhe loft this Wifdom and Knowledg, becaufe of | the ill Temperament fhe met with, till by _. . , -r u tra & of Time this ill Tempera- Plato taking from Ho- ^ n. J J r • • h writ, the beft Sentences ment was Corrected,and fo in. its in his Works, thence got place fucceeded a better, by the Name ,/Divine. means rf ^^ as ^^ mQrQ fit for the Sciences fhe had loft,fhe camety little and little to recolleft what fhe had once . forgot. ThisOpinion is falfe, and I ad mire fo great a Philofopher or Touch; for the Underftanding can receive no No- tices, but what mull firft pafs through fome one ofthefiye Senfes. For which Reafon he faid, * that the Natural Pow- * L fo. fa ers were in the Nature of a Blank-Paper, de ani. which Opinion is no lefs falfe than PUto\ and to make Proof, and Illuftration of this, I muft firft agree with the Philofophers, that there is but one Soul in a Human-Bo- dy, which is the Rational, that is the Prin- ciple of whatever we do or Accomplifh ; altho' there want not contrary Opinions, afferting no lefs than two or three diftinft Souls befides the Rational. This, being fo, as to the Afts performed by the Rational Soul, fo far forth as it is Vegetative, we have already proved that it knows how to - Form a Man, and to Figure him as he ought to be; that we know how to draw Nourifhment, to retain and digeft the fame, as well as to expel Excrements ; and if there be Defefts in any parts of the Body, it knows how to repair them anew , and to give them that Stru&ure which their ufe requires. And as to the Afts of the Senfi- tive and Motive Faculties, a new-born- Babe can apply and lay its Lips clofe to prefs the Milk, and this with fo much Art and 1 1 2 Clje Crpal of mitts. Chaf>. vn. and Addrefs, as the wifeft Man in the . World knows not how to do it fo well. Befidesthis, it follows what tends moft to the Prefervation of it's Nr.ture, and flyes what is noxious and offenfive, he knows how to Laugh and to Cry, without flay- ing to be Taught by any. And if this be not fo, who can the Vulgar Philofopher pretend has taught Children to perform thefe Aftions, or through which oftheir Senfes have any Notices arrived , that made them do it ? I know well they may feply, that God has given them the fame Natural Inftinct as to Brute' Beafts , in which they fay not ill, if by Natural In- ftinfl: they mean no other thing than the Temperament. Man asfoon as he is born cannot exert Afts proper to the Rational Soul ; fuch as are to Underftand, Imagine, and Remem- ber; becaufe the Temperaments of Chil- dren are not well Adapted to fuch Afts, but rather appropriate to the Vegetative and Senfitive, as the Temperament in Old Age is more proper for the Rational Soul, and Iefs for the Vegetative and Senfitive Soul ; and if the Brain, which bylittleand little acquires the Temper that Wiidom requires, might obtain it at once, Man at the fame inftant would be able to Reafon and Difcourfe better than if he had learnt the Chap. vil. €fle Crpal of aatit& n$ the fame at any time in the Schools ; but as Nature cannot beftow it but fucceflively and in time, fo Man by degrees gains Know- ledge. This is the main Reafon, as one may ctearly fee, if he will confider, that from the time a Man arrives at die pitch of Wifdom, by little and little he declines to Ignorance, becaufe ashfe approaches nearer to the laft and decrepit Age, he daily ac- quires another Temperament wholly new. As for me, I am of Opinion, that whereas Nature makes a g^/Wf ftJjS Man Of llOt and mOlft Seed , Matters of which we are which is the Temperament that f orme *> ***M f»*™# ; ,. 01 . r r - Jr , by means of which Ternpe* directs the Vegetative and Sen- ramen t children, are of fjtive Soul What it OUght tO do ; neeeffity Stupid and Igm- if inftead of that fhe had form- Jg^ ™& ,ib ' l df ed him of cold and dry Seed, he would Difcourfe and Reafon foon after he was Born, and would not be able to Suck> inafmuch as his Temperament would not well agree with fuch Aftions. But to the end we may by Experience know, if the Brain be Temperate, fo far as the Natural Sciences require, we need no Matter to teach us, but only to attend to a thing, which happens every day ; that if a Man falls fick of any Diftemper, that changes the Tem- perament of his Brain on a fudden (as in Madnefs, Melancholy, and Frenzy) he would lofe in a moment, though he were I once U4 *K* Gtyal Of 2Bit!3* Chap. VIL once Wife and Underftanding, whatever Wifdom, Underftanding, and Knowledge, he had, and would utter a thoufand Extra- vagances; and on the contrary, though he had been once m Ignorant Fellow, he would be Infpired with more Wit and A- bility than ever he had before. To prove which, I cannot forbear telling you what happened at Cor dub a, in the Year 1570. (the Court being then there) to a Cour- tefaninher Sicknefs, named Lovifa Lopez,^ who was turned Fool : She had during her ' Health utterly loft her Underftanding, but as for her Imagination, fhe converfed Plea- fantly, and made her Complements with a good Grace; a certain contagious Difeafe then rife, threw her into a malignant Fe- ver, in the midft of which, fhe {hewed fo much Wit and Judgment, as furprizedthe whole Court. Infomuch, that when they had given her the Sacraments, fhe made her laft Will, the difcreeteft in the World, and died begging the Mercy of God, and Pardon for her Sins, But what raifed the greateft Admiration was, that the fame Diftemper feized on a very fenfible and fober Man, who had the Cure of this Sick Perfon in charge, who died bereft both of Wit and Judgment, and neither did, nor fpoke the leatt fenfible thing. And the Reafonofthis was, that the Temperament of Chap. VII. €&e Ctyal Of Wtit8. 1 1 5 of the laft, to which he owed his Wit when he was well, was the felf fame that Lovifi Lopez, took poffeflion of by her Diftemper, inftead of the Temperament ihe had in her Health, which was the lot of the other in his Sicknefs. Let me give you an Inftance of this, in a certain Labourer, who being Frantic, made a Speech in my hearing, wherein he recommended his Welfare to thofe about him, defiring them to take care of his Wife and Children, if it fhould pleafe God to call him out of this World, with fo many drains of Rhetoric, and fo great Elegance, and Purity of Speech, that CV- cero himfelf could fcarce have made a better Harangue in the open Senate : At which, the Standers-by, not a little iurprized, ask- ed me, whence appeared fo great Wit and • Eloquence in a Man, who in his Heal* could lay nevera iSSK&'SC wife Word r I remember Man fluent, fuggtjHng to his I made anfwer, That the ^' ^ ?!***'* fy**" n r> i rrT the referv d have all a cold fluent Faculty ol Haranguing 3^ *, ,*, greMt Talkers a proceeded from a certain £•* ***- T ^ frenzy was noinr or rlear^e nf Hear of e * u f^ h abundance of Gho* point 01 ccgrwe 01 neat, 01 Ur r//jhb , u in the SubSianct Which tlliS Labourer Was of the Brain, for that is the poffeffed, by means of his r^^f^p^ry^huh r^n 7 J T r occajton d Horace to jay .That Diltemper. I can confirm } f the choim were ^/purged the Truth 'of this, fromano- **>*y in **>* tying, there ther Lunatic, W ho for more Z^Zt^'^'Z than eight days, fpoke never Poetica. I 2 a word, \6 fcfje Ctval ofesait0. Chap. VIL a word, and then immediately fell into a fit of Rhiming, very often making no lefs than a good entire Stanza ; the By- ftanders furprized to hear a Man Difcourfe all in Verfe, who in his Health never knew how to make one ; I told them it could never well be, that he who was a Poet in his Madnefs, fhould be one when he was well, becaufe the Temperament of the Brain a Man has in Health, and from which he is to turn a Poet, is ordinarily Renver- fed inhisSicknefs, which is thecaufe of his falling into Raptures. I remember the Lunatic's Wife, and Sifter (whofe Name was Mary Garcia) chid him for fpeaking ill of the Saints, which fo enraged him^ that he fpoke to his Wife after this manner. Then I renounce God for your fake, and the Virgin Mary for Mary Garcia'* fake , and Saint Yztzvfor John ofOlmz&o'sfake, which fell into the following Spanijh Stanza: Pues reniego de Dios 9 . Por amor de he„ci spirit ef Prophecy infufed came the Sybils , And the Mxnades, by God ; for it was not e- m ^ f^ a$ ^ete fuppofed to be In- rtough to poffijs a Natural r • i r r\- ■ & • • /- Wit, though never fi sub- Jftred by a Divine Sprit ; this lime, to reveal fuch eh- happening not Co much by Sicknefs* V^d.hi^a^heyMd. J by a fi at{l / a l Exce f s , Mk6>1 a Citizen flfSiracufe, was the better Poet for it, when he was out of his Wits \ and thofe in whom this exceffive Heat is more remijs and moderate , are compleatly Melancholic , but much W.ifer.- - By thefe Words Arijlotle openly owns, that many Men by reafon of the extream Heat of their Brain, know things to come, even as the Sybils did ; which proceeds not, as he fays, fo much from Sicknefs, as from the Inequality of Natural Heat. And for this very Reafon he proved it clearly in the Inftance of Mar- cus the Syracufian, who was a very excel- lent Poet all the time he was befide himfelf, from an over-heated Brain ; but as this great Heat came to be moderated, he loft the Chap. VII. C6e Cml of MS* m the Art of making Verfes, though he re- mained more Prudent and more Wife. So that Ariftotle not only allows the Tempe- rament of the Brain for the principal Caufe ofthefe ftrange Effecls, but alfo reproves them that affirm it to J)e by Divine Reve- lation, and not a Natural thing. Hippocrates was the firft that gave the name of Divine to thefe wonderful Effefts. * If there be any thing Divine in Dijlempers, 1 L '£'£ the Prognoftic of it muftalfo'be learned. By whichheadvifesthePhyficians, ' when they guefs at Difeafes, JS&ffiS* they fhould thence frame a it is * si S n thv 'he ad- judgment in what ftate they >;<»">' j'" 1 * *fiH*d J & J from tioe Body, and none are, and from that, predict the f uc h Recover : Cicero Crifis of their Diftemper. But %* int ° '£< f"»* &r«r< what furprized me moft in this Pr0 Arch,a Poew - Cafe, is, That if I fhould ask Plato, how it comes, that of two Children of the fame * Father, one fhould know how to make Verfes without any. Matter's teaching, and the other, after all his Labours in the Art of Poetry, fhould not know how to Compofe any? He might' Anfwer perhaps, That he who is Born a Poet, is poffeft with a De- mon that Infpires him, and the other, not. It was therefore with reafdn Ariftotle repre- hended him, feeing he might have fairly imputed it to the Temperament, as he did in another Place, ' As 1 22 eije ®tmi of mit& chap. vn. As for the Lunatic that fpoke Latin with- out having learn 7 d it when he was well, it fhews the Analogy and Correfpendence between the Latin Tongue, and the Ra- tional Soul. Or it may be, as we fhall hereafter prove, becaufe there is a parti- cular and proper Wit to invent Languages. Latin Words, and the manner of fpeaking this Tongue, are fo Rational, and fo agree- ably ftrike the Ear, that the Rational Soul meeting with the Temperament neceffary to invent a very eloquent Language, im- mediately ftumbles on the Latin : For that two Inventers of Languages may forge the fame Words, having both the fame Inventi- on and Ability, may be clearly ijnderftood, ifwefuppofe, that as God created Adam, he prefented all the Creatures to him, to give them what Names they ought to have ; fo he might have made another at the fame time with the fame Perfection, and Super- natural Grace ; Now I demand, had God prefented to this other, ' the fame Creatures for him to give them Proper Names, what Names would he have given them ? It is not rb be doubted but they would have been the fame that Aiam gave them ; and the reafon is clear, becaufe both in Naming would have confider'd the Nature of the Crea- ture, which was but One. In like manner the Lunatic might ftumble on the Latin Tongue, Chap. VII. €&e Crpal of WiitfS. 12 j Tongue, and fpeak Latin without having learn'd it in his Wits ; becaufe the Natural Temperament of his Brain being altered by that Diftemper, he might do it in a fhort time after the fame manner, as he who firft invented the Latin Tongue, and fo he might pronounce almoft the fame Words, though notfuch laboured Periods, or with fuch a continued Elegance ; be- caufe this is a fign the Devil moves their Tongue, according to what the Church teaches her Exorciils. The fame thing is affirmed by Ariftotle to have befallen fome Children, who at their Birth pronounced diftin&ly fome Words, and afterwards be- came mute. He reproves the Vulgar Phi- lofophers of his time, who being ignorant of the natural Caufe of that Efte£t, attri- buted it to the Demons. Though he could never difcover the Reafon and Caufe of Chitdrens fpeaking at their Birth, and be- ing afterwards mute ; yet notwithstand- ing it never once entered into his thoughts that it was the Invention of the Devil, or any Supernatural Effect, as the Vulgar Philofophers vainly imagine, who finding themfelves entangled with the fublime and fubtle things of Natural Philofophy, pof- fefs them that know nothing, that God, or the Devil, are the Authors of fuch rare and prodigious Effects, becaufe they are Igno- rant ^H €lje€tj>aIOfaBit& Chap. VII. rant of their natural Caufes. Children that are begot of cold and dry Seed, as thofe got in old Age, begin to reafon and dif. courfe a few Days and Months after they are Born, became the cold and dry Tem- perament, as §/c fhall prove hereafter, is more appropriate to the Operations of the Rational Soul, and what Time, and the long fucceffion of Days and Months might effed, is fupplied by the fudden Tempe* rament of the Brain, that after this manner is pufhed forward by many Caufes leading p*b Sca# t0 that end ' * Art fi otle tells of other Chil- XXVH. dren, who began to fpeak as foon as they were Born, and afterwards were mute, till they arrived at the Age allotted for fpeak- ing ; fo that this Eftedt was occafionM by the fame thing, as that we remembred in the Page, and the other Lunatics, nay, and of him who all on a fudden fpoke I^ati^ without having learn'd it in his Senfes. Now that Children while yet in their Mother's Wombs, and as foon as they are Born, may be afflifted with the like Diftempers, is a thing not to be denied. As for the She-Lunatic who Divined, how that might be, I will make more in- telligible from Cicero, than from the Natu- ral Philofophers, who defcribing the Na- ture of Man, fpeaks after this manner. t De Divi-.f That Creature of Fore fight, Sagacious, mcione. , (barf Chap. VII. €IjeCtpalOf£2Iit& 125 fharp-witted, capable of all Things, of good Memory, endued with Reafon and Council, which we call Man : And more particularly he affirm'd, That fome Men by Nature fur- pafs others in the Knowledge of Futurities. For there is a power and kind of Nature, which penetrates and predicts things to come, the Force and Nature of which, has never been yet explained by Reafon. What led the Na- tural Philofophers into an Error, was their not confidering, (as Plato did ) that Man was made after the likenefs of God, and that he participates of the Divine Provi- dence, being qualified to diftin- rj guifh all the three differences of £*£*%%£?, Times, with Memory for the m endued with a kind of Paft, Senfe for the. Prefent, I- gg£2^ cicer0 d ° magination and Underftanding for the Future. And as there are obfer- ved fome Men furpaflin'g others in the Re- membrance of what is Paft, and fome ex- celling others in the Knowledge of the Prefent, fo are there fome who are natu- rally more capable than others in gueffing what is to Come. One of the fixongeft Arguments that enforced Tully to believe the Rational Soul incorruptible, was the obferving with what certainty fick People predict Futurities, efpecially when they are neareft Death. But the difference there is betwixt the Prophetic Spirit, and this Na- 26 €f>e Crpal of Ettitt. Chap. VII. Natural Wit, is this, what God has by the Mouth of the Prophets declared is Infal- lible, becaufe it is his exprefs Word : But that which a Man Prognofticates by the ftrength of Fancy, has not the fame cer- tainty. Thofe who fay the She-Lunatic difco- vered the Virtues and Vices of thofe who came to fee her, by the Artifice of the De- vil, may underftand that God gives to Men a Supernatural Grace, by which they may know, which are the Works of God, and which of the Devil. This St. Paul ranks among the Divine Gifts, calling it The Difcernwg of Spirits. 'Tis by this we know, whether it is a good or bad Angel comes to move us ; for the Devil comes often to us under the Appearance of a good Angel,, the better to deceive us : Upon which occafion wefhall ftand in need of this Supernatural Gift to know and diftinguilh him from the good Angel. Thofe who have not a Genius proper for Natural Philo- fophy, will be furtheft from this Gift; be- caufe both that Science and the Superna- tural which is Infpired by God, fall upon the fame Faculty, which is the Understand- ing; at leaft it is fo for the moft part, when God in the Communicating of liis Gifts, accommodates himfelf to each Man's Na- tural (J. ; .5, as I have laid before. Jacob Chap. VII. Cfje Cipal Of Mlttjn 1 27 * Jacob being at the point of Death* Ge £. cb. (which is a time when the Rational Soul is x the freell to forefee Futurities) all his Twelve Sons came into his Chamber, to fee him, he told each in particular their Vir- tues and their Vices, and predicted what fhould befal both them and their Children. 9 Tis certain he did this by the Spirit of God ; but if Holy Writ and our Faith had not affured us of it, how fhould the Natural Philofophers know that this was the Work of God, and that of the She Lunatic's tell- ing thofe that came to fee her, their Virtues and Vices, was a Work of the Devil, fince that in part it refembled Jacob's? They conceive the Nature of the Rational Soul to be far different from that of the Devil, and that its Powers, the Underftanding, Imagination, and Memory, are of another kind much different : In which they are miftaken ; for let the Rational Soul animate a well-organizM Body, fuch as Jdam'swas, it fhall know no lefs than the molt clear- lighted Devil ; and when it is feparated from the Body, it has as fubtle Faculties as he. Say now that the Devils difcover what is to come, by conje&uring and reafoning from certain Signs, the Rational Soul can do as much, wheiyteliver'd from the Body, or when it has that difference of Tempera- ment, which gives, Man the Knowledge of 12% mz Crpal ef ffiBftfc Chap, y II of Futurities ; fo that it is as difficult to the Underftanding to conceive how the Devil can know fych elevated and hidden things ; of which the Knowledge is attributed to the Rational Soul. It cannot enter into their thoughts, that there can be Signs in Natural things whereby to foretel what is to come : And I my felf hold that there are fome Indications fubfervient to us in the knowledge of the Paft, of thePrefent, and that help us to conje&ure at the Future ; nay, and to guefs at certain Secrets of Hea- ■• Chap. I. ven. * For the things of God from the Crea- to the R«- tion of the World are clearly feen y beingunder- flood by the things that are made. He that fliall have the requifite Faculty to attain it, may attain it ; and the other fhall be fuch a one as Homer fpeaks of, The Ignorant underftand the Pail, but not the Future ; but the Prudent and Difcreet is the Ape of God, imitating him in many things ; and though he cannot do it to fo great a Per- fection, yet neverthelefs he can counterfeit it in fome meafure. •mans. CHAPi £hap. vil. Cfje Ctval of wiitfH 12^ CHAP. VIII. Frotft theje three Qualities alone^ Hetty Moijiurej and Drinefs, proceed all the differences of Wit obferi d among Men. AS long as the Rational Soul is # in thd Body, it is impoflihle it fhould perform different and contrary Aftioris, if to each it have its proper and peculiar Inllruments. This is clearly feen in the Animal Faculty, which exercifes divers AttionS in the exterior Senfes, eaich having its particular and proper Organ ; the Sight has it after one manner, the Hearing after another ; the Tafte, the Smell and the Touch after another ; and if this were not fo, there would be biit one fort of Aftions, all would confift either in the Sight, or iii the Hearing, or in the Tafte, or in the Smell, or in the Touch ; becauie the Organ determines the Power to one Aftidri only, and not to more. From what paffes plain- ly through the exterior Senfes, we may colled what is afted in the Interior. We Underftand, we Imagine, and Remember, by the fame Animal Virtue. But if it be true, that each Aftion requires its particular "[nftrumeut ; there mult neceffarily be one K Organ =1 i jo Ufa Ctpal Of EOit& Chap. VIIL Organ in the Brain to Underftand, another to Imagin, and a third to Remember ; for if tlfe whole Brain were Organized after one and the fame Manner, all would be either Menlbry, or Underftanding,or Imagination. But when we fee fuch different A&ions, of neceffity there muft alfo be divers Initru- ments. And yet if one fhould Diffeft a Head to Anatomize the Brain, all would feem compofed after the fame manner, of the lite fuhftance, without difference of Parts or diverfity of Kinds. I fay, that itfeems fo, becaufe, as Galen has obferv'd, Nature has placed abundance of things in Man's Body, that are compound, which the Senfes neverthelefs judge to be fimple, becaufe of the Subtilty of the Mixture : Which may alfo happen in the Brain of a Man, though to fight it feems no fuch thing. Befides this, there are four fmall Ventricles in the Cavity of the Brain, of which Galen taught the ufe to him that, would learn it of him : But for my part, I hold, that the fourth Ventricle, which is behind the Head, has no other Function than to digeft and refine the Vital Spirits, and turn them into Animal Spirits, enabling them to give Senfe and Motion to all the Parts of the Body, becaufe we cannot find in Humane Bodies two fuch contrary Operations, that inter- fere with each other, fo much as Reafon- . ing and the Digeftive Faculty, The reafon is Chap. VIII. Cfte Ctpal of WlitfS. *$| is, that Speculation requires the Repofe, Serenity, and Clearnefs of the Animal Spi- rits ; whereas the Digeftion is made with noifeand ferment, and from that Opera- tion ariles many Vapours which infeft and darken the Animal Spirits, in fuch manner as the Rational Soul cannot well diftinguifh the Figures of things. Nor was Nature fo Inconnderate to join in one place fwo Ani- ons that are performed with fo great a Re- pugnance and Contrariety. Be it how it will, * Plato mightily commends the Pro- * DiaJogo vidence and Care of him, who made us ; . i. Faculty. At leait according to * Galen's and how it is the Caufe of it y and that it cannot be other- wife produced. Which we are ignorant of, when we have only Faith and a Pious Opinion of him that teaches us. But if we will carry tbjp Confideration yet fur- ther, we (hall find, that Man has not only leave to Examine and bring to the Proof what Ariflotle and Plato, and all the other Natural Philofophers affirm ; but if the Philofophers, and even the Angels them- felves, who know more than all the Phi- lofophers in the World, come to teach him any Doftrin' whatever, he is direfted and commanded not to believe, without ha- ving before-hand tried and known if the Do&rin Chap. viil. ( fcge€rrarofaaift& ut Doftfin be true or falfe, and" without duly oppdfirig all the Difficulties and Arguments he can mike and objefr upoft that rtiatten 'Twas therefore the Apofile confidering that we are without ceafirig encompaffed with Devils feeking how they may deftroy us, and our good Angete who guard and preferveus; and that both the one and the other fpeak to us, and fhew us the things in their fpiritual Language ; advifes us not to give any affent to them, till we have Tried and Examined if they are good or evil Angels. . Accordingly faid he, My Brethren, believe not every Spirit f but try the Spirits, whether they are of God* What more certain and truer Embaffy, and of more Importance to Mankind was ever made in the World, tharf that of the Arch- Angel Gabriel to the Bleffed Virgin ? Yet ne- verthelefs fhe failed not tirit to Try and Exa- mine it, and to oppofe the If rongeif Reafons , Ihe could find upon that occafion, and feeing and believing that it was a good Angel, and that it was a good Salutation, fhe ipoke to it, Behold the Handmaid of the Lord, be it unto mt according to thy Word. Which had {lie done without this Precaution, fhe had not per- formed her Duty. But to return to our Bufinefs, Plato fays, 7 hat he who will not affent to what is faid to him y ought to difprove it ; and he thai cannot d/fprove it, ought to af[ent. % By which he gives us to ideritand; that there are two different forts L of H# CfeCl#alBf©HttL Chap.VIlL of Wits among Men of Learning ', fome who are not able enough to difprove, and thofe lie directs to affent, although they be not fatis- fied with the Author's Doftrin ; Others, who are able enough to difprove, whom he obliges to give a Reafon for their Dilfent, Since then the Anfwer Ariflotle give to the Pro- blem fatifiesmeftot, Tarn obliged by what I have now faid to give a Reafon, why my Understanding will not admit it, and the reafon is very clear, becaufethat if the Spe- cies and Figures which are in the Memory had matter and quantity to poffefs place, itieems that his Anfwer would have been good ; but being Indivifible and Immaterial as they are, they can neither fill nor vacate the place where they are- Nay, We fee by Experience, the more the Memory is exercifed in receiving every day new Figures, the more capable (he is to receivethem. According to my Doftrin, the Anfwer to the Problem is very eafie ; for I fhould chufe to fay that Old Men have a good Underftanding, becaufe they are very dry ; and that they have no Memory, be- caufe they have no rnoifture. By which means the fubitance of their Brain is harden- ed, fothat they cannot receive the Impreflion of Figures, neither more nor lefs than hard Wax receives with difficulty the Figure of the Seal; but that which is loft receives it eafily. Among Young People the contrary happens, who from abundance of rnoifture of the Chap. VIH. Cfje Crpal of WOtti 147 the Brain want Understanding, and have a good Memory, becaufe of the fweetnefs andt foftnefs of the fame Brain, in which by reafon of the moifture the Figures and Species from without make a good, firm, eafie; and deep Impreffion. That the Memory is better and readier in the morning than evening, is not to be denied, but not for the Reafon Jriftotle+gave but juft now. The night fleep is the caufe of it, that moiftens and ilrengthens the Brain, which by the waking of the whole day drysup and hardens. Therefore * Hippocrates laid, They •vi.Apho; that defire to drink in the night, being very dry, if com XXVI * they fleep upon it, it ts good ; and that the drought goes off, becaufe fleep moiftens the Body, and fortifies the Ruling Faculties of Man. But that fleep produces fomeeffeft, it - ' follows clearly from this Doftrin ; Arifiotle himfelf confefies, That the Underitanding . and the Memory are oppofite and contrary Faculties ; fo that he who hath a great Me- mory, may want Under {landings and on the other hand, he whcj has a better Underftand- ing, may not have a good Memory ; becaufe it is impoffible for the Brain to be moift and dry at the fame time in an intenfe degree. * Atijlotle built upon this Maxim, to prove t L'^ <*e •that the Memory is a different Faculty from ^nifc.* Remembrance, apd forms his Argument after this -manner; S^h as have a great Remem- brance are Men of great Underftanding, and L 2 thole, 148 fcfie Ctpal of mitj3. Chap. VIII. thofe who have a good Memory, want Un- derftanding ; the Memory and Remembrance then are two Contrary Powers. According to my Doftrin the firft Propofition is falfe , bccaufe they who have a great Remembrance want Underftanding, but are Matters of a large Invention, as I fhall prefently prove : But the fecond Propofition is true, though Jrifiotk did rfot know the Reafon upon which x he grounded the Contrariety between the Underftanding and the Memory. The Imagination arifes from the Heat (which is the third Quality) becaufe as there remains in the Bflain no other Rational Fa- culty, fo have we no other Quality to afcribe to it. For the Sciences appertaining to the Imagination, are the Exercife of them that rave in their Sicknefs, and not the fame with thofe which belong to the Underftanding and Memory. And iuppofe that Phrenfy, Mad- hefs, and Melancholy, are the over-heated Padions of the Brain, we may thence draw a ftrong Proof, that the Imagination confifts in Heat. There is but one thing in which I End fome difficulty, which is, that the ima- gination is contrary to the Underftanding, and to the Memory alfo ; and the reafon is hot cleared by Experience, becaufe greag heat •and drinefs may well enough meet in thf Brain in an intenfe degree, and fo may great heat and moifture ; infc&auchy that a Man may gave a good Underftlnding with a- great Inven- Chap. vili. ttfje Ctpal of mm. 149 Invention, and a happy Memory with a vaft Invention ; and yet neverthelels it is .a won- der to find one of a great Invention, who has neither a good Underftanding nor a good Memory. The reafon of which is, that the Underftanding requires that the Brain be compofedofveryfubtle and delicate Parts, as^ we have elfewhere proved frem * Gale??, and ^jf" ^ that a great Heat difcuffes and confumes the xii. . Cip * more delicate Parts, leaving behind thofe that are more grofs and earthy. And for the fame reafon a good Invention cannot be coupled with a great Memory, becaufe theexceffive Heat diffolves the moifture of the Brain, lea- ving it hard and dry ; by which means it cannot fo eafily receive the Figures. So that there remain no more than three principal Differences of Wit to be found in Man, becaufe there appear but three Pri- mary Qualities, whence they can proceed; But under thefe three General Differences are contained many other Particular Differences, •by reafon of the feveral Degrees, Heat, Moi- fture, and Drincfs may have ; Yet is it not precifcly true, that from every Degree of thefe three Qualities refults a different Wit, becaufe the Drinefs, Heat and Moifture, ntey exceed to fuch a degree as the whole Rational Faculty may be Renverfed ; according to that ot \ Gakn^Every Excejs of Temperament diffohes x ^ h T j the Powers. A thing moft fure ; for altho' A P h. com. the Underftanding be advantaged by Dri-** L 5 nefs; \ So Cfje Gtpa! «f 8ZMt& Chap. VIII. nefs ; yet neverthelefs it may be in fuch Ex- cels, as to incommode its Operations. Which *Lib.Quod neither * Galen nor the Antient Philofophers animi mo. allow of ; for they, on the contrary, allure res. wp.V. „ ^pi '. f AU t> • ] us, 1 hat it Old-mens Brains were not over- cojd, they would never decay, though they were dry even in the fourth Degree. But in this there is no r^.fon, as appears by what we fhall prove from the Imagination, for though its Operations are performed by means of Heat, as foon as it is paft the third Degree, that Faculty forthwith begins to decay, and the fame equally happens to the Memory from too great a Moifture. Now I cannot fay in particular how many Differences of Wit arife by reafon of the in- tenfe Degrees of each of thefe three Qualities ; but I muft jii^ft deduce, and retount all the Operations of the Underftanding, •Imagina- tion, and Memory ; then amongft fo many, you are to know there are three principal Aftions of the Underftanding : TheFirft is, to Difcourfe; the Second, to Diftinguifh ;• and the Third, to Chufe. And thefe Con- flitute the three Differences of the Under- ftanding ; the Memory is likewife divided into three other, into that which readily re- ceives, and as loon lofes; that which diffi- cultly receives, but long retains ; and that which eafily receives, and is long a lofing. The Imagination comprehends many more Difference!; ; for it has three of them, accord- ingly Chap. VIIL > {EfteSttalOfQIfttf. i$* ingly as the' Underftanding and the Memory, and from each Degree arifes three others. We will hereafter fpeak more diftinftly of them, Where we (hall affign to each the Sci- ence that Anfwers it in particular. But he that would confider the three other Differences of Wit, (hall find, that there are- Certain Abilities amongft thofe that Study ; fbme of which naturally difpofe them to the clear and eafie Speculation of the Art they learn; but when they of %^^^J e ^ k l proceed.to the Subtle and Obfcure, ; hu /! n?\nfaA*tht it is in vain for the Mafter to break */?, "*W ofkimfdf cam- hisBrainstoteachthem, either to &&$»«)& endeavour to make them conceive -who follow, him that is them by proper Examples, or *gg i^^iiitdi that they themfelves fhould flxive Animal ' to form an Idea of them in their Imaginations; for they have-no Capacity for them. In this Rank are all the half-Witted in all Sciences whatever, who beijig Exa* mined in the obyious Points of their Art, an- fwer all they underftand of it ; but being put to the very delicate and fubtil Part, utter a \ thoufand Abfurdities. There are other Wits which rife a ftep higher ; for they are docile, and readily receive the Impreffion of all .the Rules and Confiderations of the Art, clear, obfcure, eafy and difficult ; but the Doftrin, the Arguments, the Anfwers, the Doubts, and the Diftinftions, all thefe coft them a great deal of trouble ar^d pains; thefe have L 4 need i If cjjc Crpai of aHftjJ* Chap- VIII. need to learn the Science from able Mafters, who know a great dead, to have abundance of Books, and be affrduous in Study, for the lefs they read and labour, Rill the lefs they know. Of thefe the noted Saying of Anfiotle may be verified ; Our Vnderftanding^ resem- bles a blank Table-Book, wherein nothing is writ- ten • becaufc whatever they know or learn, they muft take it from another, and beyond that, have no Invention of th^ir own. In the, third Degree, Nature makes forae Wits fo £erfecl, as they are in no want ofany.Mafter to direft them to Reafon ; for from any Re- mark the Mailer (hall {lightly have dropt, they raife (trait a thoufand Confiderations ot their own, ancf without telling them any thing; are wholly furprized to find their Mouths fo full of Science and Knowledge, Thefe Wits deceived Plato, and made him &y, That all our Knowledge is but a certain kind of Remembrance ; upon hear^ w!:VSf«£ ingtherafpeakandfayfuchthings ■ting of Bocks is obtained a$. never entered into the 1 hought hthe vnMa»ciin g or f M ai1 . To thefe alone and no t'e Memory, or the Una- . . \tnation- therefore he that others it may be allowed to write Vrifet, that be may' re- Books g for the Order to be ob- &^£9£&£ ferved, tothe-end that Sciences mew. Lib. I. de officio may daily receive Advancement Medic. conAp. iv. an j g reatQr p e rfeft;ion , is to fuper- add new Inventions of thofe ncjw living, to What the Ancients have left written in their Books, For if each ip his time would do thus,, ; '' , -i ■ all Chap. VIII. €6e Ctpal of &3iW* i s j all the Arts would improve, and the Men that are yet unborn, would enjoy the Labours and Inventions, of thofe that lived before them. The Commonwealth fhould give no allowance to the other who . nu &&***« •/ wit want Invention to write Bobks, V^^fa*^. and come out irtfrint ; fojr all that deriding ought to abid* they give us are but bare Repe- tttk'clZt f.% titions of what is to be found m and declared. grave Authors before. And while they play the Plagiaries, ftealing from one, and the other ; there is no Man nowcompo- fes a Work of his Own. The Inventive Wits are termed in the Tufcan Tongue Capri- cious, for the refemblance they bear to a Goat. Who takes no pleafure in the open and eafy Plains, but loves to Caper along the Hill-tops, and upon the Points of Precipices, not caring for the beaten Road, of the Company of the Herd. Of the fame Nature is the Rational Soul that meets a well Organized and Tem- pered Brain, as is never bounded with any Speculation, ever afpiring and daily looking out to difcover things new and elevate. Of this fort of Souls, that of * Hippocrates is to be * VI F - d under rtood, The Thought of Man is the Work v. Com. of the Soul. For we find other Men, who XL never go beyond one Speculation, imagining there is nothing more in the World to know. Thefe have a Sheep-like Quality, who never • (juit the Ram's Walk, not daring to wander ki defert and untrac'd Ways, but only where the 1 54 F €|je €tpl Of Wlttl* Chap. VIII. the beaten Path goes along with them, and yet go not at all it fome goes not before them. Thefe two differences of Wit are This Diferem* of wit ver y ordinary iamongft Men of; S7XH5:St L^ers; fome there are who are follow the Divine Autho- elevated, and above the cgimmon *ity declared by the My \^ t \ judging aod treating of Gvtncds and thi Sacred . . ». ' o o v. t? vtttorj. things in a very particular manner, and are free to give their Opinion without following any Man. There are o- thers, who are Referved, Humble, Peaceable, and'Diftruftful of themfelves, flicking clofe to the Opinion of fome Grave Authors, whom they follow, whofe Words and Opinions pafs wifch them for certain Demonftrations,efteem- ing whatever agrees not with them to be a Paradox, and a Lye. * Thefe two Differences of Wit are of great advantage when united, for the fame reafoa that in a great Flock of Sheep, the Shepherds are ufed to prick a dozen Goats to egg them on in the fearch of frefh and new Paffures : en fo it is no lefs requifite in Humane: Learning, there fhould be iomeof thefe Capri- cious Wits todifcover to flow and Sheep-like . Underftandings new Secrets of Nature, and raife them to-unheard-of Speculations, to Ex- tra fe themfelves in \ for after this manner the A it j would improve, and Men become more .v'wiiig ever). d< CHAP. , Chap. IXf %\)Z Ctpal Of TO$f, 1 55 CHAP. IX. Some Doubts and Arguments againfi the • DoBrin of the lafi Chapter^ with their Jnfwers. ON E of the Reafons why the Wifdom of Socrates has beenfo Celebrated even to this day, was, That after he had been pro- nounced by the Oracle of Apollo the Wifeft Man in the World, he fpoke thus : This only I know j that I know nothing. All who heard or read this Saying, were of Opinion, that it was his, becaufe Socrates was an humble Man, who defpifed the things of this World, and in refpeft of Divine things counted them nothing. But they were deceived in effeft, for not one of the Antient Philofophers was endued with that Virtue of Humility, nor fo much as knew what it was, till the Coming of our Lord, who taught it us. All that* Socrates intended thereby, was, the little certaintv there is m Human Sciences, and how far the Knowledge of Philofophy is in whatever it pretends, from any Satisfacti- on or Affurance ; finceitis found by Experi- ence, that all is full of Doubts and Difputes ; and that they cannot give their Sentiment in any one thing whatever, without fear of be- ing Contradicted ; to which purpofe is that Saying, 1 56 mv Ccpai of jikw; t:hap. ix. Saying 77* Thoughts of Men are full of fear, and all their fore fight uncertain. But he that has the true Knowledge of things, may be fettled and at eafe, without Fear or Doubt of being deceived, and the Philofopher that is not fo, may truly, and without the leaft diffimulation aflert, that he knows nothing. Galen made the fame Reflexion, when he * Lib I - ^^ * Science & a fort of Kjiow ledge , congruous, rr<>duc. c. fettled, and never wide of Reafbn : Not to be v * found among the Philojbphers, efpecially whefi they fear ch into the Nature of things, and yet much lefs in the Art of Phyfic ; and to fay all in a word, it is unknown to Men. According to this the true Knowledge of things is placed out of our reach, Man only having a kind of Opinion, which holds him wavering and in fufpence, whether what he affirms .be true or rio. But what Galen obfervM more parti- cularly in this, was, that Philofophy and PhyfiC are of all Sciences in ufe among Men the moil uncertain: And if this be true, what fhall we fay to the Philofophy here handled, in which the Underftanding make? an Anato- my of things, fo obfeure, as are the Powers and Faculties of the Rational Soul ? In which Matter, fo many Doubts and Difficulties of- fer themfelves, that there is nothing upon which one may fafely rely or depend. One. of which is, that we have given to the Un- derftanding for an Inftrument wherewith to Aft, the Brain with Drinefs , having faid there- Chap. IX. % tarfie Crpal of JBHitsf. 157 thereupon, that the reafon why Men have Brains organized much after the fame man- ner as Brute Beafts, was, becaufe the Under- ftanding (by which Man much excels other Animals) was a. Faculty which wanted not Corporeal Organs, and lo Nature wifely pro- vided no particular Inftrument for it, in the Brain of Man. Which Arifiotlt proved clear- ly, when he faid, That it belonged to this Faculty to know and underftand. Befides, die Reafons on which Ariftotle inlifted, to prove that the Underftanding was not an Organic Faculty, are of fuch force, that it cannot well be otherwife concluded ; becaufe to this Faculty belongs to know and under- ftand the Nature and Being of all the material things in the World ; infomuch, as if it were united with any Corporeal thing, that very thing would hinder the Knowledge of all others; as we fee in the exterior Senfes; that if the Tafte be bitter, whatever the Tongue touches has the fame favour ; and if the Cri- ftalin-Humour be green or yellow, the Eye judges whatever it fees to be of the fcme Co- lour ; and the Caufe of it is, that lnmtr dTin- (lures bar the era ranee of Objects from without. Ariftotk &v& z\fo 7 that if the Underftanding were united ,to any Corpoccal Inftrument, it would be fufceptible of a material Quality, becaufe that which is united to it, be it hot or cold, muft ncceirarily have Communicati- on witli heat or cold* But to fay the Un- derftandin<* 158 C&eCrpalofilBttsf. t Chap. IX. derftanding is hot, cold, moift, or dry , is a Propofition abominable to the Ears of any Natural Philofopher. The other principal Difficulty is, That -A riftotle, and all the Peripatitics, have eftablifh- ed two other Powers befides theUnderftajid- iug, Imagination, and Memory ; which are the Remembrance and the Common Senfe ; in purfuance of this Rule. The Faculties are difcerned by their Atis. They find befides the Operations of the Underftanding, Imagina- tion, and Memory, there are two others very different; the Wit of Man then arifes from Five. Faculties, and not from three alone, as we have already proved. We have alfo faid in the foregoing Chap- ter, following Galen's Opinion, that the Me- mory does nought elfe in the Brain but bare- ly prefer ve the Figures and Species of things, even as a Coffer keeps Clothes and whatever elfe is laid up in it. Ancf if by this Compa- rifon we may come to underftand the Office ' of this Faculty, there will be ftill need to find * a Ratiqpal Faculty to draw and fetch out the Figures from the Memory, and reprefent them to the Underftanding, even as it is no lefs than neceffary for fome hand to open the . Coffer, to take out thence whap was laid up therein. Moreover we have faid, that the Underftanding and Memory were two con- trary Powers, and that one deftroyed the other ; becaufe one required much Drinefs ; and Chap. IX, Clje Crpal of aaiit& 1 59 and the other, much Moifture and Softnefs of Brain. But if that be true, how came Plato and * Ariftotle to affirm, That Men of* ub. II. a foft Flefh had a great deal of Underftand- deanima. ing, fince foftnefs *is an effeft «pf moifture ? We have alfo granted, That to have a good Memory the Brain muft be foft, inafmuch as the Figures muft be ftamped thereon, to make an Impreffion , and if it were hard , they could not be fo well imprinted. True it is, that to receive the Figures eafily, it is necef- fary the -Brain fhould be foft, but to prefer ve the Species long, all the Philofophers aflert, that hardnefs and drinefs are no lefs necefTa- ry ; as it appears in things from without ; for an impreflion in a foft Matter foon wears out; but is never utterly effae'd, if made on a dry and hard Body. Accordingly we fee many learn eafily by Heart, what they as foon after for- get. Of which f Galen giving the Reafon, t Lib. Am affirms, That fuch from the abundance of j^f' ca P* Moifture have a fluid and no folid Subftance in the Brain, which occafions the Figure to wear out as foon as it would do, fhould any pretend to Grave on Water. On the contrary, the other difficultly take any tiling, but never lofe what they have once learned. •Wherefore it fcems impoffible to have that Difference of Memory we have fpoke of, to learn readily and to retain long. 'Tis alfo no lefs difficult to underftand how fo many Figures can be imprinted together in the x6o €f)e Crpal Of Wit8. Chap. IX; the Brain, without one effacing the other j and • 1 thatthefamethingfallsnotoutaswefeeinfoft Wax, on which if one imprints feveral Seals of different Forms,fome will force out the others, there remaining only behind a promifcuous Confufion ofJFigures. And what affords no lefs pain and difficulty, is, to know whence it arifes, that the Memory by conftant Ex- ercife is made more capable to receive the Fi- gures ; fince it is certain, that the Exercife not only of the Body, but even of. the Mind, dries andconfumes the Flefh. It is alfo as difficult to difcern how the Imagination is contrary to the Underftand- ing, if there appear no other reafon more preffing than to fay the fubtil Parts of the Brain are refolved and difcuffed by much Heat, and that there remain behind the groflelt and moft earthy, fince Melancholy is allowed to be one of the grofleft and carthieft Humors of the Body. Yet Ariftotk faid, That the Underftanding received more Advantage from that, than from any other : The difficulty feems yet greater, when we <:ome to confider, that Melancholy is a grofs, cold, and dry Humor; and that Choler is of a delicate Subftance, and of a hot and dry Temperament. This appears repugnant to Reafon, becaufe this lait Humor promotes the Underftanding by means of two Qualities, and is contrary only to one, which is Heat: And Melancholy favours it by Drinefs alpne, and Chap. IX. &W €cpal of ffliifo iii and nothing elfe, being contrary to if, both in the coldnefsand groiTnefs of the Subftance, which is what the Understanding moft of all abhors. For which reafon * Galen affigned * Lib. t more Wit and Prudence to Choler than Me- falS lancholy . Dexterity and Prudence are owing to C om. I. C holer ^ but the Mel Ant holy Humour is thecaufe of Integrity andConjiancy, Laftly it is demanded, Whence it comes, that the Application to Study and Afliduous Speculation renders many knowing and wife, who at the beginning wanted the good Na- tural Qualities we have mentioned, and yet neverthelefs by the force of Intention of Mind- they have attained the Knowledge of many Truths, of which before they were ignorant when it appears they had not thfc requifite Temperament to arrive at it ; for if they had had it, they needed not to have taken fo much pains. All thefe Difficulties; and many friore, are oppofite to the Dbctrin laid down in the laft Chapter, becaufe in efte& Natural Philo- fophy has no fuch certain Principles to pro- ceed by as the Mathematics, in which a Phy- fician and Philofopher (who is alio a Mathe- matician) may always give fomel^emoriitra- tions ; but in coming to Cure Difeafes ac- cording to the Rules of Phyfic, lie will com- mit therein many Errors, not always through his own fault, (Gnce in the Mathematics he may be alway s lure) but becaufe of the Uncer- M tainty i6a t£fje Ct^al Of (K3(t& Chap. IX. * Lib. I. tainty of his Art. Which made * Arifiotk Topic, i fay, The Phyfician who ufes all the Diligence re- quired by his Art) though he does not always Cure the Patient^ yet he ought not to be ejleemed Un- skilful in his Profeffion. But if the fame man ftiould commit the leaft Error in the Mathe- matics, he would be without Excufe, becaufe if they employ what care they ought in this Science, it is impoflible to fail of being cer- tain. So that fince there is no Demonftration ' to be given of our Do&rin, all the fault is not to be attributed to Defett of Skill, nor is it to be inferred from thence th$t what we have delivered is falfe. To the firft and main Doubt we Anfwer, that it muft be confider'd there are two forts of Underftanding in man, one of which is the Power in the Rational Soul, and that is as incorruptible as the Rational Soul it felf, with - out depending in the leaft upon the Body or its material Organs, either for its Being, or Prefervation ; and Ariftotle's Arguments have only place, with regard to this Power. The other fort of Underftanding is all that, which appears neceflary in the Brain of man, to the end he may underftand as he ought : 'Tis in this Senfe weufe to fay Peter has a better . Underftancftpg than John, which cannot be taken for the Power lodged in the Soul, be- caufe it is of equal Perfection in all, but ra- ther for fome of the organic Powers, which the Underftanding makes uie ofinitsA&s; fome Chap. IX. €&c €tpal of mitt. 165 fome of which it performs well, and others ill ; not at all through its own fault, but be- caufe the Powers it makes ufe of in fome iind food Organs, and in others ill. Which is to e underftood in no other manner, finCe we find by Experience, not only that fome men Reafon better than others ; but even that the fame Perfon Reafons and DifcourfBs well at one Age, and ill at another, as we have al- ready provM; Nay, there are fome who lofe their Judgment, even as others recover it, from certain Diftempers of the Brain: . Which is particularly feen in the Heftic Fever* better than in any other ; for when that once begins to reach the Brain,the Sick Perfon begins alfo to Speak and Reafon more Eloquently and Judicioufly thanheufed, and how much the deeper that Evil gets Root* fo much the more excellent are the Operations of the Un- derftanding ; which was not confider'd by fome of the Antient Phyiicians, though this Knowledge be of fo great importance in the firft Appearance of the Difeafe when the Cure • ^ iseafy. But what thefe organic Powers are, of which the Underllanding makes ufe in its O* perations, has not yet been refolv'd or de- termined , feeing tlie Natural Philofophers fay, that if one man Reafons better than ano- ther, it comes from the Underftanding's be- ing an Organic Power, and better difpos'd in one than another, and not for any other M .2 "Reafon, 164 C()C Ctvat Of G3it0. Chap. IX- Reafon. For all Rational Souls and their Capacities (when feparated from their Bo- dies) are of equal Perfe&ion and Knowledge. Thofe that follow the Do&rin of Ariftotle, feeing by Experience that fome Reafon better than others, have found out a feeming Co- lour, faying, That if one Man Reafons better than another, it comes not from the Under- ftanding's being an organic Power, nor from the Brain's beingbetter difpofed in one than in the other, but becaufe the Underftanding, fo long as the Rational Soul is in the Body, has occafion for thefe Figures and Species which are in the Imagination and Memory ; in de- fect of which, the Underftanding happens to Difcourfe ill, though not through its own Fault, or by being joined to ill Organized Matter. But. this Anfwer contradifts the • Lib. e Crpal of muss. Chap. IX. Qualities of this Humour, that make a Man •Lib. VI. fubjeSt to Laughter. * In a Phrenjj the Laugh* Apb. LHI. i n g fits are jecurer^ and the crying fits more dejperate ; for the firft is made by means of the Blood, which a very benign Humour ; but the other is no lefs than an effeft of deep Melancholy* But we grounding only on the Doftrin we have handled, may eafily under- ftand what is to be known in this matter. The caufe of Laughter is no other (in my Opinion) than a tacit allowance of the Ima- gination, when it fees or hears fome Ren- counter or Accident, which proves very agree- able. And as this Power refides in the Brain, when any of thofe things prefent, it is ftrait mov'd, and with it the Mufcles all over the Body ; fo we often approve fharp and witty Sayings, by a nod of the Head* But when the Imagination is very good, it is not grati- fied with every Paffage, but with thofe only, which are very pleafing ; and if they are not fuch, it receives rather a Difguft than Plea- fure. Whence it comes, that we feldom fee Men of good Invention laugh ; and what is yet more confiderable, is, that thofe who rally the mod agreeably, and are very Face- tious, never laugh at their own Jefts, or thofe of others; becaufe they have fo delicate and fine a Fancy, that their own witty Expref- fions, and Railleries, are not moving, nor l,iave all the Agreeablenefs and Grace they ought, to have. To which* may be added, That Chap. ix. €&e €* pal of mifttf, 1 7 $ That the Grace and Air of the thing fpoke, oroffer'd, ought to be new, unheard-of, and unfeen. Which is not the aim only of the Imagination, but alfo of the other ruling Powers in Man. Accordingly we find the Stomach ftrait naufeates the fame Food it re- ceived twice ; the Sight, the return of the fame Figure and Colour ; the Hearing, the re- petition of the fame Tune, though it be good ; and fo even the Underftanding is tired with the fame Thought. Therefore he that rallies well, laughs not at all at his own witty Jefts, becaufe e'er they proceed out of his mouth, he knows well enough before-hand what he is to fay. Whence I conclude the great Laughers want Imagination ; and let the Jeft be what it will, as flat as it is, it extreamly moves and tickles 'em. And therefore thofe who are very fanguine, as they have a great deal of moifture, which we have affirm'd to be con- trary to, and deftru&iveofthe Imagination, fo they alfo are very great Laughers. Moi- fture has this peculiar, that beqaufe of its fmoothnefs and fofcnefs, it blunts the edge, Ipnd allays the heat, caufing it not to burn fo much: Accordingly that agrees belt with Drinefs, becaufe it quickens its Aftions ; Add to this, that where Moifture is found, it is a fign that the Heat is Hack and moderate, be- caufe it cannot refolve and confume it, nor can the Imagination with fo wealc a Heat fpeed its own Operations. From whence al- fo 1 76 mt Crpal af .fflifw. Chap. IX fo it follows, that Men of great Underftand- ing are great Laughers, becaufe they want Invention. As we may read of that great Philofopher Democritm „ and many others whom I have feen and obferved. Thus by means of Laughter \ye may difcern, if the Perfons that have hard and rough Ftefti, and befides that, black andcrifp, harfh and hard Hair, excel in the Underftanding, or Imagi- nation. So that Ariftotle has been miftaken in what regards the fmoothnefs or foftnefs of the Fleih. One may Anfwer the fifth Argument, That there are two forts of Moifture in the Brain y one, which proceeds from the Air, when that Element is prodominant, in theCompo- fition \ and the other from Water, by means of which, die other Elements are blended to- gether. If the Brain partake of the firft Moifture, the Memory will be very good, eafie to re- ceive, and ftrong to retain the Figures long,, becaufe the moifture of the Air is very Oily, and unctuous, in which the Species of things filften ftrongly, as may be feen by Painting in Oil, which expoied to the Sun, or caft into the Water, fuftains no damage; and if we rub a Writing all over withOif, it never wears out. Since that which is obliterated to that degree thatone cannot read it, is made legible by Oil, which gives it a- kind of cle? rnefs and tranfpaf ence* But if the fmoothnefs and foft- nefs Giiap. vL €$e Ccwtf of aaift& *?? nefs of the Brain proceed from any other Hu- mour, the Argument is ftrong ; for if it re- ceive eafily the Figure, it alfo as fuddenly wears out, bccaufe the moiftiire of the Water has no Oil, to which the Species could flick and catch. Thefe two kinds of Moilture are diftinguifhed in Hair ; that which proceeds from Air, makes them thick, oily, and grea* fy; and that from Water, (limy and limber. The fixth Argument may receive this An- fwer, That the Figures of things in the Brairi are not imprinted there like the Figure of the Seal in the Wax, but only by penetrating* remain there fixt ; or after the manner a$ Birds are caught with Birdlime, and Flies with Honey, beeaufe thefe are not Corporeal Figures, and cannot be bleaded, nor break in upon one another. We may refolve the feverith Difficulty thus, That the Figures confound and fofteri the Subliance oT the Brain^ neither more nor lefs than Wax is foftned between the Fingers* Befides that the Vital Spirits have the Virtue to foften and moiften the Members that are hard and dry, even as we fee the heat of the Fire foften Iron. And we have already pro- ved, that die Vital Spirits afcend up to the Brain, as often as any thing is learn'd by heart„ Whether all Corporeal and Spiritual Exer- cite drys or not, all Phyficians hold, that mo- derate Exercife fattens* N Th« i 7 8 €lje Crpal of ffiHitg- Chap. IX. The eighth Argument is capable of this Reply, there are two kinds of Melancholy ; *G*ten.\\b. * one Natural, which is as it were the Cement II de fa- f ^ Blood, whofe Temperament is cold end" m " anci dl 7> mA which is of a very grofs fub- ftance, and the fame is of no advantage to the Wit, but makes Men Fools, Sots, and Gig- lers, becaufe of a defeft in their Imagination. There is another call'd Atra-bilis, black or * in. Sea. burnt Choler, which, according to * Ariftotlfs Prob. I. opinion, made the wifeft Men ; whofe Tem- perament is various, as is that of Horace reports O^ vinegar, which fometimCS pro- U have been made J itc ha * O J ^ ~ r . f. me, but that he would do duces fome effects ot heat, making «« harm to any onejpeah t i ie j7 art h quake like Dough , and tngr very fine thinzsirovn , . l i_ ' • • the h-ighlnefs of his c ho- at other times too much coois it ; hr. and therefore he [aid, but is always dry, and of a very ffX»i?/! ndidabafc delicate fubftance. Cicero owtfd, he had a flow Wit, becaufe he had no aduft Choler, and he fpoke truth ; for if he had been fo, he would not have proved fo Eloquent ; for the Men of black Choler ? want Memory, to which belongs Volubility of Speech. It has another quality, which mightily helps the Underftanding, that is to be as refplendent as an Agat, by means of which Splendor, the Brain is illuminated, to the end the Figures may be clearly reflected. And this Her adit us meant, when he faid, A dry Light makes a mofl excellent Wit ; which Splendor, the Natural Melancholy has not, but its Black, is Sleep and Death. And we (halt Chap. IX. Cbe €rj>al of mito. 1 79 fhall hereafter prove, that the Rational Soul hasoccafion to have a Brain of Light to reflect the Figures and the Species. The Anfwer to the ninth Argument, is,That the Prudence and Dexterity of Wit, as Galea faid, belonged to the Imagination, by means of which Futurities are known, and with Allu- lion to this, * Ckero affirmed, The Memory is * d: «io o?.$urt* N 2 rounded 1 8© €lje Crval of BGKW. Chap. IX, rounded with Dead and Flead Beafts; at which Hippocrates being f urpriz'd, asked him what he did with thofe Beafts that were in fucha cafe? He Anfwer'd him, that he was in fearch of the Humor that made M$n Fickle, Crafty, Falfe, and Deceitful ; and that in dif- fering thofe brute Beafts, he had found, that Choler was th^caufe of this mifchievous Quality, and that to be revenged on Men of Gall and Guile, he would treat them as he had done the Fox, the Serpent, and the Ape. This kind of Prudence is not only odious to * Ch.VIH. Men, but alfo * St. Paul fays, The Carnal to the Ro- Mind is at Enmity againfi God. And Plato gave the Reafon of it, faying, That Knowledge ab (trailed from 'Juflice, rather merits the name of Craft and Cunning j than of Wifdom. The Devil always makes ufe of fuch Weapons, when he would do mifchief to Men. This fC&.III. Wifdom (faA'\ ( i)X.?fames) defcendeth not front above , but is earthy 'Jenfual, and devilift). There is another fort of Wifdom attended with Up- rightnefs and Simplicity, by .which Men fol- low that; which is good, arid fly that which is gUMlf. €vil. \\Galen fays this kind belongs to the pmg. coir. Undemanding, becaufethat Faculty is wholly incapable of Craft or Malice, only knowing lio w Evil is not done, but is Upright, • Juft, Frank and Innocent. The Man who is en- dowed with this kind of Wit, is Called Up- right and Simple. Accordingly Demojihenes being defirous- to win the good Will of the Judges^ Chap. IX. €be Crpai Of WLitfr 181 Judges, in a Speedi he made againft Efehines, Called them Juit and Upright/ having an eye to the Simplicity of their Employment, Of whom * Cicero faid, Their Duty U fimple, and* Pl0 s y j. one only Caa/e of all Good. The Coldnefs and la. the Drinefs of Melancholy is a very proper Initrument for this kind of Wifdom, but then it muit be compoied of fine and very delicate Parts. We may Anfwer to the laffi Doubt, That when a Man is engaged in the Contempla- tion of a truth he would know, and does not prefently attain it, it is becaufe his Brain is deprived of the Temperament convenient to what he defir'd, but fixing a while in Con^ templation asfoonas the Natural Heat (that is in the Vital Spirits and Arterial Blood) flys to the Head, the fame caufes the Temperament of the Brain to rile AV < 4 *> h ** rm t> or ; always till it arrive at the degree it g% ^Jn^X^uf} has occafion for. 5 Tis true, that VMtiv fryer Temper*. much Plodding does good to fame, me>it in the Brani " "/ txt : , . o • O, ... £~7 /« \ LL the Arts (faid * Cicero) are fetled PocM. y-^ U p Qn certa j n Univerfal Principles, which being learned with Study and Labour, the Science at length is acquirM. Only the Art of Poetry has this in ^peculiar, That if God and Nature make not the Man a Poet, he will nevqr be enabled by Rules and Pre-? cepts to make a Verfe, which occafion'd him to fay. The Study and Knowledge of other things. depend upon the Precepts of Art ; but the Poet mjo by Nature, he i tioned, when the firft In venters affembling together, framed Words according to their bterjlfa 6 Fnancy, as * Arijlotle obferved, and jointly V " V- ■■ n . agreed Chap, at Clje Cwal of Wilt8. 185 agreed about the Signification of each. From thence came fo great a number of Words, and fo many different Modes of Speech, with fo fewRutes, and as little Reafon, that without a good Memory it would not be poffible, ei- ther to comprehend, or retain them by any other Faculty. How improper the Imagi- nation and the Underftanding are, to learn the Languages, and the different Modes of Speech, Infancy plainly proves, in which, though it be an Age wherein the Child is leaf i provided with thefe two Faculties, ne- ver thelefs, as *Arifiotle fays, he learns any * xxx. Language what-ever better than Adult J eft - P r °k Men ; though thefe be much more Rational, and without being taught by him,* Experi- ence fhews us it : For we fee if a Bifcayner of Thirty or Forty Years of Age comes to live at Caftile, he will never learn the Language of the Country ; but if he be very Young, in Two or Three Years he palfes for a Native of Toledo. The fame happens in the Latin, and all other Tongues, becaufe they are all of the fame Nature : If then it be true, that in the Age wherein the Memory flourifhes, and the Understanding and Imagination are low, the Tongues are fooner learned than when the Memory is in the Decline, and the Under- Handing in its full Vigor, it is certain they are acquired by means of the Memory, and not at all by any other Faculty. * Jrijlotle 1.86 Cfje €n>ai of mitti* Chap* X. * L H-!* V ' * Arifiotle faid , that the Tongues were not fnirfiai.' t0 be learn'd by Reafon, as not depending cap. ix. upon Difcourfe, and that therefore it was neceffary to hear from another the^Words, and their Meaning, and to bear them in mind. * In purfuanceof which, he proves, That if a Man be born Deaf, he would infallibly be Dumb, becaufe he can't hear from another the found of the Words, nor the meaning gi- ven them by their firft Inventers. That the Tongues are no other than an effeft of the Humor and Caprice of Men,, may be clearly inferred from this, that the Sciences may be equally taught in all Languages, and that in each, may be fpoke and made known, what any one of them would fay ; Accordingly there # are no grave Authors to be found, who have fought for a Foreign Tongue, to make their Thoughts underftood ; but the Grecians have Writ in Greek ; the Romans,, m Latin ; the %m, in Hebrew ; the Moors, in Arabic ; and to do I in Spanifhy becaufe I underftand that Language better than any other. The Ro- mans, (as being Lords of the World) finding it was expedient to have a common Lan- guage, by means of which all Nations might Communicate together, and themfelves en- abled to underftand fuch as came to fue for Juftice of them, and to treat of Matters rela- ting to the Public Affairs of every Province, appointed Schools to be Erefted in all Parts of their Empire, for teaching the Latin* Tongue, chap. x. cijc €t?ai of mm. i s 7 Tongue, which by thefe means has flourifh- ed as the Univerfal Tongue even to this Day. As for School Divinity, it is certain that it refers to the Under [landing, becauie the Ope- rations of this Faculty are to Diftinguifh, to Infer, to Reafon, to Judge, and to Chufe, and that nothing is dope in this Science, but to raife Doubts from Inconveniences, to An- ftver with Diftinfrion, to infer againft the Anfwer what may be collected from good Confequences, andfoto reply again, till the Underitanding be at eafe, and reft fatisfied. But the belt Proof that can be made of this SubjeQ:, is, to let you underftand how diffi- cultly the Latin Tongue, and School Divi- nity, meet in one Perfon, and how it rarely % happens that a Man be at the fame time a good Latinift, and profound School-Divine, At which Efteft ibme more Curious being furprized, in taking notice of it, have fearch- ed whence it might .proceed, and have been of Opinion, that School-Divinity being Writ in a harfh and barbarous Language, and the Ears of good Latinifts being inured to the pure and elegant Stile of Cicero, they could not fettle to, nor take pleaiure in that Science, It would be well for thefe Gentlemen, that underftand Latin fo well, that this were the true caufe, for then by constraint and other* wife accuftoming their Ears, they might at: length find out a Remedy for this Incoiiv. ni^nce : i88 Cf)C Crpal Of mm Chap. X. nience ; but to be plain with them, the De- feel is not fo much in their Ears as in their Capacities. They that are good Latinifts, have moft afluredlyan Excellent Memory, for without that they could never prove fo expert in a Language which is none, of their own; and becaufe a great and happy Memory is as it were contrary to a great and elevated Under- standing in the fame Subject, one debafes and depreifes the other. From whence it comes, that he who has not fo exquifite and lofty an Underftanding (the Faculty to which belongs to Diftinguifh, to Conclude, to Difcourfe, to Judge, andtoChufe) gains no great ground, nor makes any confiderable Progrefs in School Divinity. Whoever is not fati^fied with this Reafon, lethimreadSt.T^w^r, Scotm, Du- randus, and Cajetan, who are the Leading Men in that Faculty and Profeffion, and he will find great Subtilties in their Works, but writ, and delivered, in very courfe Church* Latin. For which there appears no other reafon, but that. thefe great Authors having in their Youth very mean Memories, prov'd not more Excellent in the Latin Tongue, but applying themfelves to Logic, Metaphyfics, and School-Divinity, they mounted up to the highcft- Degree of the Sciences we admire, becaufe .they weire endued with a great Un- derftanding. At leaft lean teftify this of a School*Diviae (well known to many more — - - ■ ■ - ' "^ thai; Chap. X. €fce €t pa! of mite. i tg that were acquainted and converfed with him) who was a Miracle in that Science, and yet not only could not reach the Elegances, nor the round Periods of Cicero », but when he read in the Chair, his Scholars took no- tice that his Latin was but very bafe -and mean, infomuchthat they advifed him (as thofe that were unacquainted with our Do- ftrin) that he fhould fecretly borrow a few hours from the Study of School-Diviility, and employ them in reading Cicero. And taking this as the Advice of good Friends, he not only endeavoured in private but publickly to remedy it ; for after having treated of the Matter of the Trinity (and how the Divine Word was made Flelh) he entred the Form amongft the reft to improve his Latin; and what was very remarkable, that during the long time he ciid thus, he not only learn'd not any thing new, but had almoft forgot all the Latin, fuchasitwas, that he had learn'd before, fo that in the end he was driven to read his Ledure in his Jyiother-Tongue. Pope PW the Fourth enquiring what Divines were the Leading Men at the Council of Trent, was told particularly of a certain Spa- nijb Di-vine, whofePvefolutions, Arguments, Diftin&ions, and Anfwers, were truly wor- thy of Admiration. The Pope being curious to fee and know fo fingular a Man, difpatch- ed his Orders to him, to come to Rome, to give him an account of all the Proceedings ia the 1 90 Cfje Crpal of K3itgf. Chap. X. the fame Council. Being arrived, he did him a great many Honours, amongft others he bid him be cover'd, and taking him by the Hand, led him out to walk up to hisCa- ftle of 'St'. Angelo, and entertaining him in very elegant Latin about certain Works, he intended to make, in Fortifying it better, ask- ed his Opinion of each of his Defigns. To which he anfwered with" fo much pain, as not being able to fpeak good Latin, that the then Spanijh Ambaffador, Don Lays de Re* quiefcens, Great Goyernor oiCaftile, took up the Difcourfe for him, to relieve him with the favour of his Latin, and to divert the Pope to fome other matter. In a word, his Holi- nefs faid to fome one of his Confidents, that it \^as utterly impoffible for a Man that un- derftood fo meanly, to be fo Excellent in Di- vinity as was reported ; But whereas he tried him in this Language (which is a work of the Memory) and in Fortifications and Buildings (which things belong to a good Invention ;) ib had he but founded him in what relates to the Underftanding, he might have heard Di- vinc«things from him. In the Lift of Sciences which refer to the Imagination, we have particularly placed Poetry, not at Random, nor without good Coniideration, but to let them know, how far they are from having'Underftanding, who Jtiave a good Vein in Verifying. According- ly we fhall find, that the lame difficulty the Latin Chap. X. Clje Ctpal Of KaitjL 1 9 J L/tf/'/z Tongue has in uniting with School- Divinity, the fame or greater beyond Com- panion is obferved betwixt that Science and the Art of Verfifying, this Art being fo con- trary to the Underftanding, that for the fame Reafon, lie that would fet up for a Topping- Poet, muft take leave of all the Sciences re- lating to that Faculty, and even of the Latu Tongue It felf, becaufe of the Contrariety there is between a good Imagination and a good Memory. Arifiotle could not find out the Reafon of ' die firft, yet he confirms my Opinion by an Experiment, when he faid, * Marcus a G'-*xxxSea tizen flfSyracufe was a better Poet after he had Prob * ,r lofi his Vnderftanding. See here the Reafon, it is becaufe the difference of the Imagination (to which Poetry belongs) requires three De- grees of Heat (and as we faid but now) fuch an Excefs of Heat entirely deftroysthe Under- ftanding. 'Tis what die iame Arifiotle noted, when he affirm'd, That the Syracufian^ as he came to be more Temperate, had a better Underftanding, that he could not make fo good Verfe becaufe of the defeft: of Heat, with which this difference of Imagination aft- cd. Which Talent Cicero himfelf fliew'd he ' wanted, when defigning to defcribe the He- roicActsofhisConfulfhipin Verfe, and how his City had the good Fortune of a Second Birth, in having been under his Government^. heexcL.«med after this manner : 192 €ljc€rpalofaflitt& Chap.X, Fortune am natam me Confide Romam! O Rome, how happy wert thou to be Born What Time theConfulfhipwas Tulltes turn ! And becaufe Juvenal could not apprehend, that the Art of 'Poetry was contrary to fuch a Wit as Cicero's, helalh'd him in his Satyrs, faying, Had you rehearfed your Philippics againit Marc- Antony in fuch delicate Verfe, it had never coft you your Life. * in So * ¥l&to was yet more miftaken, when ho phift. afferted Poetry to be no Human Science, but rather a Divine Infpiration, becaufe the Poets not being befide themfelves, or Infpired by God, were not able to compofe, nor fpeak any Excellent thing ; which he proves by this Reafort, That Man having but his own fXXXSea Judgment free, cannot Verfify. But f An* ?C Ctpal OfCTltt0* Chap. & they undertake, ready at every Turn to fpeak, and to anfwer to the Point ; they are fit for the Courts/ and to be Solicitors and Attor- neys in Caufes, for Merchants and Fa&ors, to Buy and Sell, but not for Learning. Here- in the Vulgar are deceived, who obfervin? them fo Pra&ic'd in every thing, imagin ftrait tliey would h&ve prov'd fingular Men, had . they been brought up to Learning ; when in truth, there are no Genius's mofe Repugnant, and more Contrary to it than leirs. Children that arrive late at the ufe of Speech, have in their Tongue and Brain too much Moifture, whichas it wears oft' in tract of Time, they become very fluent, and great Talkers, becaufe of the great Memory they acquire, as their Moifture is abated . Which, as we formerly noted, once happened to that Celebrated Orator Demojlhenes, , at whom (aswehavefaid) Cicero wasfurpriz'd, being of fo rude a Speech in his Youth, and when a grown Man, fo very Eloquent. Young Men alfo, who have a good Voice, 2nd have by Exercife dilated the Paffages of their Throat, are very unfit for all the Sci- ences, becaufe they "are CokJ and Moift, which two Qualities united together (as we have already affirmM) deftroy the Rational Part* The Scholars who punftually learn. ajtid repeat the Leffon Word for Word, as they have it from the Mafter, promife a good Memory Chap. X. €&e Ctral of mite. 1 99 Memory, butattheExpenceoftheir Under- Handing. In this Doflrin arife fome Ploblems and Doubts, the Solution of which will, it may be, ferve for a Light the better to clear the Truth of what we affirm. The firft is ; Whence it comes that the good Latinifts are more Arrogant and prefumptu- ous in their Knowledge than Men very learn'd in the kind of Learning appertaining to the Underftanding are, in fuch fort as to know the Grammarian, there is a Proverb which fays, The Grammarian is nothing lejs than Arrogance itfelf. The Second is, How it happens that the Latin Tongue is fo contrary to the Genius of the Spaniards, andfo proper and natural to the French, Italians, Germans, Englijh, and to all the other Northern People? As appears in their Works ; for no fooner do we fee a Book writ in good Latin, but know the Author is a Foreigner, and when we meet one of Barbarous and Unpolifhed Latin, we conclude it was Compofed by a Spaniard. The Third Problem is, Why the tilings that are Writ, and Spoke in the Latin Tongue, found better, have more Force? more Grandure, and Eloquence, than in any other Tongue, though never fo good? See- ing (as we havefaid before) all Languages are owing to the Caprice and Humor of thofc that invented them, without having any foundation in Nature. The Fourth Objc- Q 4 &io*\ 2C-0. ©&e Ctyal of (KJttjS* Chap. X. ftion is, How it can be reconciled, that atl the Sciences belonging to the Understanding, being Writ in Latin, that even {uch as want a good Memory, can Read and Study thofe Books, the Latin Tongue being fo repugnant to them, by reafon of a defefti ve Memory ? We may folve the firft Problem thus, There is no better Teft to difcover, if a Man wants Undemanding, than to note if he be Haughty in Pun&ilio's of Honour, Prefump- tuoi$s, Elated, Ambitious, and Ceremonious. The reafon is, that all thefe are the Eftecte of a Difference of Imagination, which requires no more than one Degree of Heat, with which the "great Moifture requifite to Memory confifts well, becaufe this Degree of Heat is not of force fufficient to refolve it. On the contrary, an infallible fign that a Man is na- turally humble, is, when he is obfervM to undervalue himfelfand whatever comes from him, or relates to him, and that not only v hne Vaunts not, and commends not himfelf, but that hum-^s offended at, and fcarce admits the Praifes huth kin.* beftow'd on him by others, being uneaiie and JLnl\tit' m pain with Pun&ilio's, and in places of kis* heart Cej^mony ; that Man, I fay, who has thefe *%& l e!> ^ ai 'k s m ^Y j l] ttly pafs for a Man of great Un- t\zf.c.xiz. derilanding, but of little Imagination and . Memory. I laid naturally Humble, becaufe if it be by Art, it is no certain fign ; whence itcpmcj that the Grammarians are provided with io great a Memory, and uniting with ifc Chap. X. Cf)e Ctyal of EBfttL 201 it this difference of Imagination (which we juft now mentioned) they are neceffarjly de- ficient in their Undefftanding, and fuch as the Proverb defcribed. To thefecond Problem may be anfwerM, That * Galen gathering the Wit of Men from 'Lib .quod the Temperament of the Region they inhabit, "j" 1 ^ " fays, That all thofe who dwell Northerly are xix. defe&ive in Underftanding, and thofe Situa- ted between the North and the Torrid Zone, are moft Prudent; which Pofition anfwers exa&ly to our Country, and without doubt it isfo ; for 'Spain is neither fo Cold as the Northern Climes, nor fo Hot as the Torrid Zone, f Arijlotle feems to be of the fame *xiv Sea. Opinion, when he Enquires, Why thofe that ProbXV. live in very cold Countries have not fo good an Underftanding, as thofe Born in very hot? In his Anfwer he treats but courfly the F lem- mings^ Germans, Engliflj, and French , faying, That the greater part of the "Wits of thofe Nations refembled that of Drunkards, for which reafon they could not fearch into, or know the Nature of things : And the Caufe of this is, the overflow of Moifture in ttjeir Brains, and other Parts of their Body, whifch the fairnefs of their Complexions, and the flaxen Colour of their Hair denotes, and that it is a wonder to fee a German bald ; and be- fides that they are all big, and of large Sta- ture, through the abundance of Moiihire, wliich is a dilater of the Body. The contra- ry 202 H\)Z €tpal Of 2Bft& Chap. X. ry is difcern'd in the Spaniards, who are a little Tawny, black Hair'd, of mean Stature, and for the mod part Bald ; which is a difpo* *Lib. Art. fition affirmM by ^ Galen proceeding from a Med. cap. hot and dry Brain. And if that be true, they *y» & muft of neceflity have an ill Memory, but a good Understanding ; and the German a great Memory, and little Understanding; Accord- ingly one of them cannot learn Latin, and the other learns it readily. The reafon given by Arifiotle, to prove the little Underftand- ing of the Northern People, is, that the great Ambient Cold of the Country forces the Na- tural Heat inward by an Antiperiftafis, and hinders it from being diflipated, and fo they have abundance of Moifture, and Heat; it is therefore thefe People are at the fame time furnifhed with a good Memory for the Tongues, and with a good Imagination; by means of which they make Clocks, bring the Water from the River to Toledo, invent Ma- chines, and very curious Works, which the Spaniards tannot make, becaufe they want Imagination ; but if they apply themfelves to any point of Logic, Philofophy, School-Di* irtnty, Phyfic, and the Laws, a Spaniard, without Comparifon, will fpeak more fyb- lime and quainter tilings in his own Tongue, and in barbarous Terms than a Stranger can do with all his fine Latin ; for take thefe Peo^ pie out of their Elegant and Polite Road of Writing, and they perform .nothing Extra-* ordinary^ Chap. X. ttfie Ctpal Of 2Htt0. 20 j ordinary, nor have they any Invention. In Proof of this Dofrrin, * Galen fays, In 8e^-*Ljb.qood thia, (which is a Northern Country) as a Won- ™^ m £ der there arofe one Philofopher, where a* at A- thens they are all fuch. But though Philofo- phy, and the other Sciences, by us named, are repugnant to thefe Northern People, yet the Mathematics and Aftronomy are proper to them, becaufe they have an Excellent I- magination. The Anfwer to the third Problem depends . on a much agitated Difpute between Plato and Arijlotle. One affirms, that there are Words which naturally fignify Things, and that much Wit is required to invent them ; which Opinion is favoured by Holy Writ, telling us that 'Adam gave to each Creature God let before him the proper Name moft fuitable to it. But * Arijlotle would not yield t Lib r. de that there was in any Tongue any Term or Sp 'S*" Figure of Speech that naturally' fignified the thing ; but that all Words were by Institution according to the Caprice and Fancy of Men. Accordingly it is known by Experience, that Wine has more than Threefcore Names, and Bread as many, and each its own, in each Tongue ; nor can it be affirmed of one, that it is more proper and natural than all thereit, for if it were, all the Men in the World would life that. However after all, Plato's Opinion is truer. For fay, tfre firil: Inventers of Tongues impofed "Naples according to their • Fancy, 204 €&e Ctpftl Of tBCtftjBP; Chap. X Fancy, that Fancy was ftill with Reafon, as well in confulting the Ear, as having regard to the Nature of the thing, and obferving the Graces of Pronounciation , fo as that the Words be not too long, or too fhort, and that there be no need of diftortingthe Mouth in Speaking, giving the Accent in the proper place, and the like Conditions to be obferv'd, that the Tongue be Eloquent, and not Bar- barous. Of the Opinion of Plato was zSpa- nijh Cavalier, who diverted himfelf with Writing Books of Chivalry ', becaufe he was furnifihed with that difference of Imagination, which inclines a Man to fuch Stories and Lyes. It is reported of him, that being to bring into his Romance a certain fierce Giant, he was for feveral days ftudying what Name would be moft anfwerable to his Exploits-, but he could never chop upon it, till playing one day at Tables with a Friend of his, he heard the Mailer of the Houfefay, Ola Mo- chacbo traquitantas a eft a mefa. That is to fay, Holla Boy, bring hither fome Dice for the Tables. The Gentleman no fooner heard-the Word TraquitantoSj but weighing the well founding Name in his Ears, without any longer it ay for good Fortune, rofe up, and laid, Gentlemen I play no longer, for I have been a long while Inventing a Name that ihould agree well with a fierce Giant, whom I make ufe of in certain Fi&ions I havecom- pofed, and could hot for my Life light upon it Chap. x. Clje Ctyal of oaitsL 205 P till I came to this Houfe, where I always received fome Favours. The firft Inventers of the Latin Tongue, had the fame Care and Curiofity as this Gentleman, that calPd his Giar\t Tr acquit antos, therefore they found out a well-founding Language to pleafe the Ear. Nor ought wetobeiurprized, if things fpoke and Writ in Latin found fo well, ana in the other>Tongues fo ill, becaufe the firft Inven- tors of thefe lad were Barbarians. For the laft Doubt, I have been obliged to fet it down for the fake of many, who ftum- ble at it, tho' the Solution of it be very eafy ; for thofe that have a great Underftanding, are not wholly deprived of Memory, becaufe if they had none at all, their Underftanding could never reafon after the manner of the World, the Memory being the Faculty which Treafures up the Matters and the Species, out ©f which the Speculations are formed : But whereas the Memory is fo very weak in thefe Men, of three degrees of Perfe&ion that arc to be acquired in the Latin Tongue (which are to Underftand, to Speak, and Write it well) they cannot proceed beyond the firft, but very awkwardly , hefitating at every Word. CHAP. ac$ €&e Crpal of Wiitfr Chap. XIJ CHAP. XI. That Eloquence and Politenefs of Speech are not to be found in Men of great Underftanding. * Cicero/oi^^NE of the Graces that inclines the that the \_J Vulgar to think a Margery Wife and IZTisi," Prudent, is to hear him fpeak with great Elo- kavewlt, quence, to obferve his Difcourfe adorn'd and but the H*. embelilh'd with Choice of feleft and fignifi- Tfjdfun cant Words, to bring many pertinent In- bt **ty*«*ftancesofthc Subjeft in Queftion ; though Cte' cfaris * n e ^ e< ^ $^5 " ia PP ens not but where there is Orator, an Union of the Memory and Imagination in a degree and medium of Heat, that cannot refolve the Moifture of the Brain, but ferves only to raife the Figures, and make them boil, by means of which many things are re- prefented to the Mind to be faid. It is im* poffible that the Underftanding fhould be Phro re. found in this Union, becaufe as we have al- eon»ts it in ready faid and proved, that Faculty abhors de'scfatia ^ ^ eat extream ty> and can no more confift & in Con- with Moifture. Which Doftrin had the w' i0 - Athenians known, they would not have been fo much furprized to fee fo wife and knowing a Man as Socrates, not to have the Gift of Utterance, infomuch as they who were Ig- norant of his Worth, Taid, That his Speeches and Chap. XI. €&e Crpal of ffiiiit& %oj andExpreflionsrefembledaCheft, ^ , ' plain, .and unpolled without, JJ^&S but when opened, had within it th§ v*mow Poet Virgil, exquifite Carving and admirable ^Z^'Zt figures. In the fame Error were accounted a Blockhead. they, who pretending to give a realon of the Obfcurity and bad Stile of Ariftotle, faid, That induftriouily, and to gain to his Works the greater Authortiy, Ee affe&ed that Jargon , with fo few Fi- gures, and Ornaments of Speech. Andifwc confider alfo the Difficulties of Plato, and his Concife Sentences, the Obfcurity of his Rea- Tons, and the ill Connexion of his Difcourfes, we fhall find, that nought elfe fave this al- ready mentioned, occafioned the fame : But what fhall we fay to Hippocrates's Works howheleftouttheNouns i J2ft&!?fJ. and verbs, the ill Diipofition of That // Jupiter had * his Sayings and Sentences, the ill ^^^^'^i' Connexion of his Reafons, and, in pJTto. Dc Clans orator' a word, how few things prefent- ed to his Mind to clear up, and lay the Foun- dation of his Doftrin ? What would you more? unlefs when he was about to give a very large Account to his Friend Damagetes, how Jrtaxerxes King of Per ft a folicited him to come to him, with a promife of giving him as much Gold and Silver as he could Vifh, and of ranking him amongft the Gran- dees of his Kingdom; (without a dirtinct Anfwer to everv Propofal ) laid only thus: The 2o8 m* tctpai Of Jfflft^. Cliap. xr. The Kjng of Perfia ^.r /?#/• /tfr w* to come to hint, not knowing that Wifdom is of more ac- count with me than Gold. Farewel. Had this'; Subjeft fallen into the Hands ofErafmu*, or of any other Man provided with as good an In- vention and Memory as he, how many Sheets of Paper would it have coft to dilate upon it? And who would dare to confirm this Do- ftrin by fuch an Inftance of St. Paul's, and affirm, that he was a Man of vaft Under- ftanding and bad Memory, but fuch a one with all his Natural Abilities as could not learn the Tongues, nor fpeak with any Orna- ment and Politenefs, had he not owned it ♦ II Conn, himfelf, in thefe Words ; * J furpofe I was not chap, XI. A ^fc t b e hi nc l the ^en chief eft Apojtles ; but tho* I be rude in Speech, yet not tn Kjiowledge. Which difference of Wit was fo accommo- dated to the Preaching of the Gofpel, that k wasfcarcepoffible to chufe a better, becaufe there was no need on that occafion of much Eloquence, or great Ornaments of Speech, fince the Skill of the Orators of thofe Times lay moft in impofiftg upon their Auditors Fak fities for Truths, to perfwade the People by the force and Subtilty of Rhetoric, that what they received for good and profitable was quite contrary as to maintain that it was • better to be Poor than Rich, Sick than well, Ignorant than Knowing, and a Thoiifand other fuch tilings, which were manifeftly op- pofite to the received Opinion, For which reafon Chap. xil. Cfje €ml of aaiit& 309 reafon they were calPd by the Jews, Gevanin, as much as to fay, Sophifters. Cdto Major was of the fame Sentiment, finding that it was dangerous to retain them at Rome, be- caufe the ftrength of that Empire was found* ed in Arms, and that thofe Men already be- gan to perfwade them that it would be bet- ter for the Roman Youth to quit them, and apply therrifelves to the other Exercifes, and Sciences. They were forthwith barufhed Rome, never more to return thither. Say then, that God had made choice of ah Eloquent Preacher, poffeffed of all the Or- naments of Speech, who fhould&o to Athens or Rome, and teach, that at Jerusalem the Jews had Crucified a Man, who was the True God, dnd that he died of his own good Will and Pleafure to redeem Sinners, and that he rofe again the third day, and afcended into Heaven, where he now' is ; what would the Auditory think, but that this Propofition was in the number of thofe Vain and Foolifhones ufed by the Orators to perfwade by the Power of their Art ? Fop thus much St. Paul fays, * Chrifi j'ent me not to Baptize, but to Preach * I Caft the Gofpel; not rvtth Wifdom of Words, left the cha ?- h Crofs of thrift fhould be made of none effetl. St. PauPs Wit was very proper for this Mi- niftry, becaufe he had a Capacious Under- (landing, to defend and prove in the Syna- gogues, and amongft the Gentiles, thatjfe/*** Umft was theMeffiah promised in the Law,and P that sicv Efje Crval of mii§. Chap. XI. that no other was to be expefted ; but with this he had but an indifferent Memory, fo that he could not embelifti his Difcourfe with perfuafive and moving Speeches; and this was the difference of Wit the Preaching of the Gofpel required. Neverthelefs I fhall not go about to infer from hence, that St. Paul had not the Gift of Tongues, for it is certain, that he fpoke them all as readily as his own. Neither ftrall I maintain, that to defend the Name of Jefa Chrift, the ftrengthofhis Un- derftanding was fufficientof it felf, without the Gifts and particular Affiftance that God gave him for that purpofe. All that I pre- tend, is, to affirm that Supernatural Gifts are much more efficacious when they meet with afuitable Difpofition, than when they fall, upon a Sotand a Blockhead. To this alludes the Doftrin of St. "Jerome in his Proem upon Efay and Jeremy, demanding what hvtws^L&vle si. isthereaibn, that though it was v.mYs, jet fy. reafon of the fame Holy Spirit which fpoke thcf^rcnccofstite.was m b ot h their Mouths ; Efay deli- t>y jo7/ie believed not to t?e . . . _ TT . • i •/- ■ bu ■, utt thofe the church vered what he W nt With lo much has condemned as Here Elegance, and Jeremy hardly knew *"*' howtofpeak? Heanfwer'd, that the Holy Spirit accommodates it felf to the natural manner of Proceeding of each Pro- phet, unlefs Grace changes their Nature, or teaches them a new Language to deliver their Prophecies in. You mult know then, that Efay was a Nobleman, bred at Court, and in the Chap. XL €fje Crpal of SBits. 2 1 1 the City oijerufalemfix which reafon his Dif- eourfe was more Elegant and Polite ; but^V- remy was Born and brought up in a Village near Jerufalem, calPd Anathoth, fo that in his Stile he was Courfe and Rude as a Peafant, and fuch a Stile the Holy GJioft made ufe of in the Prophecy he Infpired him with. The fame may befaid of St.P<*///'sEpiftles,that the Truth of the Holy Spirit prefided in him when he writ them,to the end that he might not Err,but that the Language and Manner of Speech was no other than the Language and Manner of Speech natural to St. Paul, accommodated to the Do&rin he taught ; becaufe the Truth '- of School-Divinity abhors a multiplicity of Words. The Knowledge of Tongues, arid the Or- naments and Politenefs of Speech accord ad- mirably with Pofitive-Divinity, becaufe that Faculty belongs to the Memory, and is no other than a Mafs of Catholic Sayings, and Sentences, cull'd out of the Holy Fathers , \ and from Sacred Writ, and treafured up in that Faculty, in like manner as a Gramma- rian felecte the fine Flowers of Virgil, Horace, j Terence, and other Latin Poets he reads, and i;;as occafion prefents, fets himfelf to deliver them, or pertinently cites fome Faffagesfrom Cicero, or Quintilian, to make (how of his Reading to his Auditors. They that are furnifhed with this Union of Imagination and Memory, and diligently Colled whatever has been faid and Writ, P 2 that 212 C&e Crpal of CHiW. Chap. XL that is confiderable in the Science they profefs, and quote them at due time, and place, with trie Ornaments of good Lan- guage ; as having already found in all the Sci, encesfo many things, appear very profound in the Opinion of thofe who are Ignorant of our Doarin, though in effeft, they are but fuperficial, and will difcover their defe£t as foon as they arefifted to the bottom, of what they deliver with fo much Aflurancc. And the reafon is, that the Underftanding,to which appertains the Knowlege of the Truth of things, from their Root, is not agreeable with the abundance of fine Speeches. 'Tis of thefe ♦Proverbs the Holy Scripture fpeaks, ^The talk of the lips tenaeth to Penury f Such as have thefe two Faculties, the Ima- gination and Memory joined together, bold- ly attempt the Interpretation of Holy Scrip- tures, conceiting, becaufe they underftand a great deal of Hebrew , Greek, and. Latin^ it is eafy for them to give the true Senfe of the Letter; but after all they are out. Fir ft, be- caufe the Words of Holy Scripture, and its manner of fpeaking have many other Signi- fications more than Cicero knew in his Tongue. Secondly, Becaufe. fuch People want Under- ftanding, which is the Faculty that difcerns whether the Senfe be Catholic or not. Tis this Faculty which, with the Affiftance of Supernatural Grace, of two or three feveral Meanings drawn from one Text, can make choice Chap. XI. Clje Crpal of WLit& 21 j choice of that which is the Trueft and moft Catholic. It never happens, faidP/4/0, that Men are deceived in things that are very diftinguifha- ble, fo eafily as when many of the like Nature prefent themlelves together ; for if we fet before the moft clear-fighted Eyes in the World a little Salt, Sugar, Meal and Chalk, all finely powder'd and fifted, and each by it felf, what Ihould he do who wanted his Tafte, to be able to diftinguifh upon fight each of thefe Powders, without any miftake, fo as to point in particular which is Salt, which Sugar, which Meal, and which Chalk. Without doubt no Man but would be mifta- ken, becaufe of the great Affinity between thefe things. But were there a heap of Wheat, another of Oats, another of Chaff, another of Earth, and another of Stones, it is no lefs certain, becaufe of the great diverfity of each Objeft, this Man whole fight was not very good, could never fail to name each heap. We fee the fame happen every day in the Senfe and Meaning the Divines give of the Holy Scripture ; for you may obferve two or three which at firft fight feem to be Catholic, and to agree well with the Letter ; whereas in truth, they arenotfuch, nor does the Holy Spirit fay fo. To chufe the bed of all the Meanings, and rejeft that which is bad, it is certain. that the Divine makes ufe of neither Memory nor Imagination, but of P 3 the 214 €5e &rval of £Clit0. Chap. XII. the Undemanding only. And accordingly I affert, that the Pofitive-Divine ought to confult the Scholaftic, and defire him to chufe which of all the meanings he fhall findbeft, if he would not be fentfome fair Morning to the Inquifition : For which reafon the He- refies are in fuch dread of School-Divinity, and would have it abfolutely rooted out of the World, becaufe by Diftinguifhing, Infer- ring, Reafoning, and Judging, the Truth at laft comes to be diftinguifhed from Falhood - CHAP. XII. That the Theory of Divinity belongs to the Under [landings and Preaching (which is the PraSlic) Jo the Imagi- nation. IS a Point much Controverted, not only amongft the Wife and Learned, but even luch as has not efcaped the very Vulgar, who daily ask the Reafon, Whence it comes that a Divine who is a great School- man, fharpinDifpute, ready in his Anfwers, Reads and Writes with admirable Learning; neverthelefs when he gets once into the Pui- * pit, he knows not how to Preach ; and on the other hand, when a Man is an Excellent Preacher, Eloquent, Acceptable, drawing all Chap. XII. Cfje €ml Glfflita. 2 1 5 all the People after him, it is a great Miracle if he knows much of School-Divinity. And for this Reafon, it is not admitted as a good Confequence, fuch a one is a good School- Divine, therefore he is a very good Preacher ; neither on the other hand, muft it be conclu- ded, that fuch a one is a great Preacher, therefore he is not a great School-man ; fo that to deftroy one and the other Confe- quence, there are more Instances offered of each than there are Hairs in our Head. No Man till now has been able to give any toiler Anfwer than that ordinarily returned, which is to attribute all this to God, and to - the Diftribution of his Gifts ; and I own it is very well done, when they know not at leaft the particular Caufe. We have in a manner folv'd this doubt in the preceding Chapter, though not fo exaftly as it ought. For I have already faid, that School-Divinity pertained to the Understanding. Now I aifert, and will prove, that Preaching (which is thePra- ctic) is a Work ?of the Imagination. And accordingly *is it is difficult to join in the fame Brain a good Understanding with a great Imagination, fo it cannot well be, that a Man fhouid at the fame time be a great School-Divine and a famous Preacher. And that School-Divinity is a Work of the Un- derstanding, we have elfcwhere already pro- ved, Shewing the Inconfiftcnce between that and the Latin Tongue, therefore there is no P 4 need 2 1 6 Cije Ctpal of (DSJttk Chap. .XII. need to prove it again. Only I would have it underftood, that the good Graces, by means of which good Preachers draw the People after them, and hold them Charm'd and Ra- vifh'd, are all but a Work of an Excellent • Imagination, and in part of a happy Memory. And to the end I may better explain my felf, and touch it as it were with my Finger, it muft firft hefuppofed, that a Man is a Rational Creature, fociable and politic ; and to the end his good Natural Parts might bq improved by Art, the Antient Philofophers Hum*™ found out Logic, to teach him how he was to science cw> Reafon, by what Rules and Precepts, how fhJ£X t0 define «S Nature of Things, diftinguifh, fitti speech, divide, infer, judge, and chufe, without which and in the ^q s lt jg impoffible for any Artift to pro- $S£ cee d : And to the end he ihould be Sociable Paul the and Politic, it was but reafon he Ihould fpeak, ^cok^chi anc * ma ^ e known to others what he concei- ved in his mind. But left he fhould deliver them without Order, or Rule, they have in- vented' another Art calPd Rhetoric, which with- its Rules and Precepts embelifties his Difcourfe, with fine Words and elegant Phrafes, with Aflfe&ions and Colours that are moving. " In like manner as Logic teaches a Man to Difcourfe and Reafon, not only in one Science, but in All without diltin&ion ; fo Rhetoric iiiftructs how to fpeak in Divi- ■7, fhyfic, Law, the Art-Military, and ail Other Sciences and Modes of Convention among Chap. XII. fclje Ctpal of &3ft& 117 among Men. So that if we would feign to our felves a perfeft Logician, or compleat Orator, they cannot pais for fuch unlefs they are knowing in all Sciences, becaufe they are all within their Province, and in each of them . without diftinftion he may Exercife his Art. Tis not fo in Phy fie, Natural and Moral Phi- lofophy, Metapnifics, Aftronomy, and the reft, tnat are all limited in the Matter they treat of; which made * Cicero fay, Wherever Dtptr- the Orator Jets Foot, it is his own Ground. And k&o Ora- in another place, That in a compleat Orator a/l t0Kt the Philojbphers knowledge was to befound. For which caufe the fame Cicero affirmed, that there was no Artift found with fuch difficulty, as a perfeft Orator, which he might have faid with more Reafon, had he known the Repugnance there isinUniting all the Sciences in one particular Art. Antiently the Men of Law held the name and office of Orators, becaufe to make a compleat Advocate no lefs is required than the Knowledge and Skill of all the Arts in the World, becaufe the Laws Judge all indiffe- rently ; and to know the Rights and Pleas; of each diftinft Profeflion, it becomes necef- fary to have the particular Knowledge of them all ; and accordingly \ Cicero faid, No Lib d< Man is to be ranked in the Number of the Or a- Qrat. tors but he that is compleatly furni(hed with all > the Arts. But feeng it was impoffible to learn all die Sciences ; firft, becaufe of the brevity of 2 1 8 C(je Ctpal of Chap, xn The Choleric unmoved Speak Well and Readily, becaufe they then have the degree of Heat requifite to the Tongue, and to a good Imagination ; but being put into a Paf fion, the Heat rifes a degree higher than it ought, and perturbs the Imagination. The Flegmatic being unprovoked, have a very Cold and Moiit Brain ; whence nothing of- fers to their Speech, and their Tongue is re- laxed with too much Moifture ; but when they are Vext, and their Gall once tfirred, the Heat gets a Degree, and quickens their Imagination, which occafions much to offer to be faid, and their Tongue is freed from Impediment when once it is Heated. SucH have no good Talent in Verifying, for they are Cold of Brain ; but when they are Heat- ed, they make better Verfes, and with more ] eafe, againft thofe that nettle them: To which purpofe^wWfaid, Si A 7 atura negatfacit Indignatio verfum. If Nature wanting be to make the Poet, Choler alone ferves for a Mufe to do it. Thro' this defeft of Tongue, Men of great Underftanding, cannot be good Orators, nor good Preachers, and particularly inafmuch as the Aftion requires they fhould fpeak fometimes High, and fometimes Low, and that iuch as are flow Tongued, cannot pro- nounce Chap. XII. C&e Ctval cf mitts. 2 3 1 nounce without Bawling with open Throat, which is one of the Things that tire the Au- ditors : Accordingly Arijlotle inquires, *' XI Soft. Why thofe of flow Speech cannot fpeak Low, To vyy v which he Anfwers very well, that the Tongue which is as it were Glued to the Palate by the great Moifture, better difengages it felf by Force, than if ope fhould gently endeavour it : even as he that would raife a heavy Launce, taking it by the end, would raife it better ail at once, and by a Jerk, than in railing it by little and little. It feems to me I have well prov'd that the good Natural Qualities a perfeft Orator ought to have, arife from the Imagination , for the moft part, and fome from the Memory r and if it be true that the great Preachers of our Times pleafed the People becaufe they are furnifhed with the fame qualities we have Spoke of, it follows then, that he who proves an Eminent Preacher, knows very little of School Divinity, and he that is a good School- Divine cannot Preach, thro 7 the great contra-, riety that the Underftanding carries with the Imagination. Anfiotle knew well by experience, that tho' the Orator Studies Natural and Moral Philofophy, Phyfic, Metaphyfics, the Laws, the Mathematics, Aftrology, and all the other Arts and Sciences, yet he knows no more of them than the Flowers, and retains only the. moil received Propofitions, without fetching CL 4 from 2 j 2 Clje Ctpal of wait*. Chap, XII. from the Root the Reafon and Caufe of any of them ; But he believed the not underftandirtg Divinity, nor the true and effential reafon of Things, arofe from their not making Search and Enquiry into it. Accordingly he En- quires, Whj) and in what rve think the Philojb- pher differs from the Orator, fince they both Study Philofophy. To which Problem he Anfwers, that the Philofopher employs his whole Study to find out the Reafon and the Caufe of each Effeft, and the Orator only to know the Effeft, and no more. But indeed there is no other Reafon of Difference than this ; that Natural Philofophy belongs to the Underftanding, of which Faculty the Orators are in Want, and fo pierce no deeper in Philo- fophy than a Superficial Knowledge of the Na- ture of Things. The fame difference is found between the School-Divine, and the Pofitive, for own knows the Reafon of that which concerns his Faculty ; and the other the molt received Propositions, and no more. The Cafe ftanding thus, it proves a very danger- ous Thing ; that the Preacher fhould have the Nox noai Office and Authority of Teaching the Truth indicatSci-to Chriftian people, and the Auditory be S^f™ obliged to believe it, and yet this Preacher is W£kt defective in this Power by which Truths are ^""fdi <%S ec * U P fr° m the* 1 * Roots;wemay withju- tage ' ftice apply to him thefeWords of our Saviour. "Mat. G>?. * Let them alone , they are. Blind leaders of the Blind : and if the Blind lead the Blind both \ ft 4 Chap. XII. 3Llje Ctpai of ffiflftsL 2 j j {hall fall into the D/frA.'Tisan intolerable thing to fee with what AfTurance fome pretend to Preach, tho' they Underftand not a tittle of School-Divinity, nor have the leaft Natural difpofition to Learn it. St. Paul complains heavily of thefe Men, when he fays, * The *^ T J"« end of the Commandment it Charity, out of a pure Hearty and of a good Confcience, and of Faith unfeigned : From which fome having fiver* ved y have turned afide unto vain Jangling: De- firing to be Teachers of the Law, Vnderflanding neither what they fay nor what they affirm. The idle Talk and Prating of the German y Englifh^Flemifb andFrench Divines,and the reft of the Northern Nations, has often hazarded the ruin oftheGhriftian 'Auditory, with all their Skill in Languages, and their Graces and Ornaments of Preaching ; becaufe they had not that Understanding proper to find out the Truth. And that they are for the moft part unfurnifhed of Undemanding, we have al- ready proved from the Opinion of Jriftb- tle , and from many Reafons and Expert- . ments produced to that purpofe. But if the Englijby "and German Auditories would have regarded what St. Paul writ to the Romans, (who were furrounded and circumvented with falfe Teachers ) it may be they would . pot fo eafily have been deceived, * Now I *^ ? ' befeech ye Brethren mark them which caufe Divisi- ons and Offences, contrary to the Docirin which ye have Learned, and avoid them \ for they that are 2 $ 4 Clje Crpai of JG3f t& Chap. XII. /*r? y#^, y£n>£ #0£ 0#r Lord Jefus Chrijl, but their own Bellies, and by good Words and fair Speeches deceive the Hearts of the Simple. Betides this, we have already proved, that thofe who are furnifhed with a good Imagi- nation are Choleric, Subtil, Malitious, and Cavillers, who are ever inclined to Evil, and know as well how to compafs it with great Dexterity and Craft. Ariftotle demands of the Orators of his * XVni. time, * Why do we call the Orator crafty and not Sea. Prob. t h e Mi n ft r il nor ABorsfo? And the difficulty would have grown yet greater, had Arifiotle known that Mufic and Afting are works of the Imagination. To which Problem he an- fwers, that the Minftrils and Stage-Players have no other Aim more than to divert the Houfe, but that the Orator labours to pro- ' cure fomething for himfelf, therefore he has occafion to ufe Wiles and Fetches, to the end the Audience may not difcover his Drift and "Defign. Such Properties as thefe have thofe falfe Preachers, of whom the Apoftle fpeaks, Wri- * II Chap, ting to the % Corinthians. But 1 fear lefl by any means oa the Serpent beguiled Eve through his Subtilty, foyour Minds jhould be corrupted from the fimptlcity that is /^Christ. Forfuch are falfe Apoftles\ deceitful workers transforming themfelves into the Apoflles of Christ ; and no marvel, for Satan himfelf is transformed into an Angel of Light, therefore it is no great thing if u xi Chap. XII. €lje Crpat of WLitfr 235 his Minifiers alfo be transformed as Minifiers of Right eoufnefs, whofe end (Ij all be according to their Works. All which Properties are well known to be the Works of the Imagination, and that Ariftotle faid very well , that the Orators are Crafty, and Cunning, becaufe they always purfue their own Intereft. We have already faid above, that thofe who have a ftrong and powerful Imagination are of Conftitution very Hot , and from this Heat fpring three principal Vices in Man, Pride, Gluttony, and Luxury ; whereupon faid the Apoftle, * For they that are fuch, ferve not our * Rom Lord Jefus Chrifl, but their own Bellies. And Xvi. accordingly they Endeavour to Interpret thQ Holy Scriptures after fuch a Manner as agrees beft with their Natural Inclination, 'giving thofe to underftand who know little, that Priefts may Marry, that there is no occafion for Lent or Fafting Days, nor that the Sins we commit againft God are to be difcovered to a Confeflbr. And tricking them with a • wrong Application of Scripture, they Colour their Vices and ill Actions with the Appear- ance of Virtues, to be by the Peopleefteemed for Saints. Now that from Heat proceed thefe three bad Inclinations, and from Cold the contrary Virtues, Artftotle proves, faying thus, * That * xxx. from Heat and Cold Proceed all the Conditions $ e &- Prob. and Habits of Men, becaufe that thefe two Qua- lities alter our Natures more than any other : Whence p 3 6 €(je Crpal of mttfr Chap. XII. Whence it comes that Men of great Imagi- nation are ordinarily Lewd and Vitious, for they give themfelves up to purfuethe bent of their Natural Inclination, and want no Wit or Ability to be lewd. And therefore Art- * XXIX. ft ot ^ e asked, * Why Manjvho has the moft JQtorv- Sed. Prob. ledge y is the moft un]uft of all the other Creatures ? vn - To which Ptoblem he Anfwers that as Man has a good Wit, and a great Imagination, fo he finds out more Ways to do Evil ; and as he naturally defires Pleafure, and to be Superior to all, and happier than others, of neceflity he mull: offend, for thofe things cannot be purfued without doing Wrong to many. But Ariftotle knew neither how to put this Problem, nor to anfwer it, as it ought. He might better have ask'd, Why ill Men ordi- narily are of the greateft Wit, and amongft them, fuch as have greater Abilities commit the lewdeft Pranks, fince it is more Rea- fon that great Wit and Ability fhould rather incline a Man to Virtue and Goodnefs than to Vices and Villanies. The Anfwer to this is, that thofe who exceed in Heat, are People of great Imagination, and the fame Hea|: that makes them ingenious, tends no lefs to make them Lewd and Vicious. But when the Underftanding predominates, ordi- narily the Man inclines to Virtue, becaufe this Power is founded in Cold and Dry, from which two qualities proceed feveral Virtues, fuch asContinence,Humility and! emperance, and / • Chap. XII. Cfje Ctpal of WliM. 2^7 and from Heat the contrary. Which Phi- lofophy xiAriflotle had underftood, he would have known how to Anfwer this Problem, ¥ which demands, * What is the Reafon that ^ p^ y Strolling-Players, Sutlers, lnn-keepers y Vint-\x. nersf,ooks, Alehoufekeepers, Butchers, that is to fay, all the Crafts-men of Bacchus , and merry- making, with the fever al Retainers toOr dinar ies y andGaming-houfes^arefor the mofl part of aLervd and profligate Life f To which he anfwers, that being imployed in thofe Idle Trades they have no leifure to be ferious, and fo they pais away their time in Debauchery, to which their Poverty contributes, which of it felf is wont to lead to many Evils alone. But indeed this is not the true Reafon ; rather he might have faid, that to aft Comedies, and to order Merry-makings, fprings from a difference of Imagination, which invites to this manner of Living. And as this difference of Ima- gination confifts in Heat, all fuch people have very keen Stomachs, and a fharp Ap- petite to Eat and Drink ; and if they fhould give themfelvesto Letters, they would make no Hand of it ; Nay, tho' they w T ere Rich, they would proftitute themfelvcs to thefe Of- fices, were they Bafer than they are, for I each Man's Genius and Difpofition runs to the Art that fuits beft with it. Whereupon Jriflotle demanded, * Why Men are more Con- * *Y?V" /• 1 r ri CI 1 1 ■ ScCt. PlOb«. verjant tn baje Employments if they be their \\ Choife ? than tn Honeft ones, as for Inflame to flay the 2 j 8 Cbe Ctpal Of mm Chap. XIL the Jugler, Mimic i, or Trumpeter, but take no ' pleajure in being Orators or Astronomers ? To which Problem he Anfwers very well, faying, that a Man foon finds to what Art his Natu- ral Difpofition leads, becaufe he has fome- what within him that Teaches him ; Nay, Nature goes fo far with Incentives, that tho* the Art or Employment be fo little agreeable, to the Dignity of him that learns it, he ap- plies himfelf ftrait to it, and not to other Honorable Exercifes. But fince we have allowed this difference of Wit as improper for the Fun&ion of a Preacher, and that we are obliged to give and aflign to each difference of Wit, the Science that futes beft in particular with it ; it is con- venient to affign what difference of Wit he ought to have, to whom the Office of Preach- ing is trufted, which is of lb great importance to a Chriftian State. You are to conceive, that tho' we have already proved, that it im- plies a Natural Repugnance to affociate a great Underitanding with a large Jmagina* tion and Memory, yet is there no Rule fo General in any Art but admits of fome limits and exceptions. In the latt Chapter but one of this Book, we fhall prove at large, that when Nature is ftrong with all her Forces, and meets no Obftacle, fhe makes fo perfeft a difference of Wit, that fhe unites in one a great Underftanding with a great Imaginati- on and Memory, as if thole Powers were not Chap. XII. €fje Ctpal of mi tsf ♦ 23 9 not Contrary, or held any Natural Oppofiti- on. The fame is the moft proper and conveni- ent qualification for the Employment of a Preacher, if it could be found in many per- fons, but ( as we fhall declare in the fore- cited place ) they are fo few, that I have found but one of a hundred Wits under this Confideration. And therefore we muft look out another difference of Wit more familiar tho' lefs perfeft than the former. For you are to understand that there is a great Diffen- tion between the Phyfitians * and PJiilofo- ¥ Oaien\ih. phers in refolving the Temparament and ^y imp - * qualities of Vinegar, of Choler aduft, and of Afhes ; in as much as thofe things at one time are the effeft of Heat, and at another of Cold. And upon this they fell into different Opinions, but the Truth is, that all thefe things thatfuffer Aduftion, and confumeand watte by Fire, are of a various Tempera- ment. The greater part of the Subjeft is Cold and Dry, but there are other parts intermixt, ft) fubtil and delicate, andoffuch Order and Heat, that tho' they be little in Quantity, yet they Aft with moreEfficacy than all the other i parts together. Accordingly we fee Vinegar, and Melancholy through Aduftion pierce and leaven the Earth with their Heat, and dofe it not, tho' the moft part of thofe Humors are Cold. Whence Q4° ^Ite ®*pal $ aoiittf. chap, xit Whence we may gather that the Melancho- lic by Aduftion unite a great Underftanding with a great Imagination ; but they all are weak of Memory, becaufe the fame Adufti- on dries and hardens the Brain. They make good Preachers, at leaft they are the belt to be found, next thofe perfeft ones we have fpoke of; fontho' they are Weak of Memory, their own Invention is fo large that their very Imagination ferves them in lieu of Memory and Remembrance, fupplying them with Figures, and fornifhing them wherewith to Speak, without ftanding in need of any thing, which they have not, who Con th^ir Sermons Word by Word; for if they make the leaft Trip, they prefently lofe their Cue, without being provided with Matter enough to reco- ver themfelves. Now that Melancholy by Aduftion has -this Variety of Temperament, of Cold and Dry, for the Underftanding, and of Heat fete the Imagination, Jrifiotle declares in thefe Terms, That Melancholy Men are of Temper 9 , various and unequal^ becaufe the Aduji Choler is a humor very various and unequal^ it being equally capable of Hot and Cold in extr earns by turns. The Tokens by which this Temperament may be difcerned, are very evident, their Complexion is of a dark Green or Olive, their Eyes very red, (for which Reafonhe is called a Bloody-Eyed-Man ) the Head Black and Bald ; Fkfh Chap. XII. Cfje Crpal ofM«t& 24* Flefh hard and hairy, great Veins, are very ™*™£ good Company, and affable, but Luftful,"^,^' 7 ' Proud, Stately, Blafphemers, Crafty, Double, through n* Injurious, Friends of ill Doing, and Revenge- **',*',?£ ful. This is to be underftood when Melan- &**. choly is kindled for if it be cooled, forthwith Arift. Kb. arife in them the contrary Virtues, Chaftity, y^"' Humility , Fear , and Reverence of God , Charity, Mercy, and deep Acknowledgement of their Sins, with Sighs and Tears. By reafon of which, they live in perpetual War and Strife, without ever enjoying Eafe or Reft. Now Vice prevails in them, and then Virtue ; but with all thefe Faults, they are the moil ingenious, and able, for the Service of Preach- ing ; and for all forts of things wherein world* ly Wifdom is required ; becaufe they have a great Underftanding to find the Truth, and a powerful Imagination to perfwade. In order to this, let us fee what God did when he would fafhion a Child in his Mother's Womb, to the end he might be able to difco- ver to the World the coming of his Son, and have the Gift to prove and perfwade, that Jefas Chrrjl was the Mefliah promiied under the Law j and we {hall find, that making him of a great Underftanding and Imagination, it fell of courfe ; ob- XJ% UpU f iG *l ierving the Order ot Nature, that MuheS;iv t ,mb,andt<>c*u he form'd him of this adult and m( 6 ** <***. <*** ** burnt Choler. This will appear mXT^clll R plain, '&& %fy Ctpal of (GOfttf. Chap. XII. plain, if we confider with what Fire and Fury he perfecuted the Church, and the pain the Synagogues were in, when they faw him Converted, in having loft a Man of fo great Importance to themfelves, and of fuch Ad- vantage to the contrary Party. This alfo appears by the Reparties foil of rational Choler with which he fpoke and an- fwered the Proconfuls and Judges that ap- prehended him, defending his own Perfon, and the Name of JefusChrift, with fuch Skill and Dexterity, as confounded them all. E- yen though he had an Impediment in his Speech, and was not ready in Utterance; which Property, Ariftotle lays, falls to the Melancholic, by Aduftion. The Vices he confeffed himfelf fubjeft to before his Converfion, ftiew him to have poifeffed this Temperament. He was a Blaf- fhemer and Injurious Perfecutor y which are the effects of a great Heat : But the moft evi- dent Token importing that he had that aduft Choler may be colle&ed from the continual Conflict which he confeffed was within him, between the Superior and Inferior part, fay- ing, * I fee another Law in my Members warring again fi the Law* of my mind, and bringing mt into Captivity to the Law of Sin. To which inward Contention we have prov'd accord- ing to the Opinion of Jriftotle, the Melan- cholic by Aduftion are fubjeft. True it is, asfomeGlofs (and very well) this Conflict arifes * I. ro Tim c£-»p. I. Chap. XII. €fjc Crpal of E3it0. 24 j arifcs from the diforder Original Sin has raif- cd between the Flefh and Spirit, though ne- verthelefs being fo fierce and conftant, I am of Opinion it proceeded alfo from the ine- quality of the Black Choler that remained in his Natural Conftitution. In eftetl the Royal Prophet David participated (equally) of O- riginal Sin, yet complained not fo much of it, as Si. Paul, but on the contrary affirmed , he found the Inferior Part in Confent with Reafon, when he would rejoice in God. * My heart and my jlejb have rejoiced in the li- * p^j m ving God. And as we fhall fhew in the laft i*x.Hi?. Chapter fave one, David had the beft Tem- perament Nature could give, and, according to the Opinions of all the Philofophers, the fame which ordinarily inclines a Man to be Virtuous, without much Contradiftion from the Flefh. The Wits then that fhould be made choice of for Preachers, in the firft place are thofe that unite a great Underftanding with a great Imagination and Memory, whofe Tokens we (hall treat of in the laft Chapter fave one. For want of fuch, there fucceed in their room thofe that are Melancholic by Aduftion ; w|io unite a great Underftanding with a great "Imagination, but are wanting in Memory, and accordingly have noftore of Words, nor flow with a full ftream before the Auditory. In the third Rank are Men of a great Under- ftanding, without Imagination and Memory , R z thefe 244 C&e ®tpal Of WiitfS. Chap. XIII. thefe Preach not gracefully, but Preach found Daftrin. The laft (to whom I would not recommend the Preaching Fun&ion) arethofe who join a happy Memory to a vaft Imagi- nation, but want Understanding. Thefe draw all the People after them, and hold them well pleafed,and in fufpenfe, but when they dream but a little of it, axe in a fair way ♦To the to the Inquifition; becaufe, * By good Words Row. chap. Mdfair Speeches they deceive the Hearts of the Simple. CHAR XIII. That the Theory of the Laws pertains to the Memory • Pleading Caufes and Judging them (which is the Pr attic) to the Understanding • and Governing of a Commonwealth^ to the Imagination. IT is not without a Myftery, that in the 5^///^ Tongue this Word Letrado, Letter- ed is a common Term denoting all forts of Lettered Men, as well Divines, as Lawyers, Phylicians, Logicians, Philofophers, Orators, Mathematicians, and Aftrologers ; neverthe- lefs when it is faid, FuUno es letrado, fuch a one is Lettered, we all underftand with one confent, the Skill in the Laws is his Profeffion, as if it were his proper and peculiar Style, and of Chap. XIIL €&e Crpai of mit&. 245 of no others. Altho' to folve this Doubt be eafy, neverthelefstodo it fatisfa&orily, it is requifite to know firft, what the Law is, and what Obligations they are under who apply themfelves to the Study of this Profeffion, to be afterwards made ufe of in the Employment of Judges or Advocates. The Law ( to take it right) is nothing but the reafonable Will of the Legiflator, by which he fets forth and declares in what manner fuch Cafes fhall be determined, as are ordinarily emergent in the Commonwealth, forconferving the Sub- jects in Peace, and dire&ing them haw they are to live ; and what they are to forbear. I faid a reafonable Will, becaufe it is not fufficient that a King or Emperor (who are the efficient Caufe of the Law) declare their Will at any rate, that it may be Law; for if the fame be not Juft and Reafonable, neither is it nor can it be called a Law, no more than he is a Man, who wants a Reafonable Soul. And there- fore it has been agreed, that Kings fhoulden- afl: their Laws with the Advice of very Wife and Understanding Men ; to the end they fliould be right, equal, and good, and the Subjects fhould receive them willingly, and be the more obliged to keep and obfervethem. The material Caufe of the Law, is what is done in fuch Cafes as ordinarily happen in the Commonwealth, after the Order of Nature, and not of utter Impoffibilities, or of rare Contingencies. The Final Caufe is, to order R 3 the 2j6 ®6c Crpal of Ulltg. Chap. XIIL the life of Man, to teach him what to do, and .what to forbear, that fo being conforma- ble to Reafon, the Commonwealth may be prcferv'd in Peace. For which end the Laws cire appointed to be Written in clear Words, not Equivocal, Obfcure, or of divers Senfes; v ithout Cyphers, or Abbreviations, but fo Obvious and Manifeft, that whoever reads them may readily underftand and bear them in mind. And becaufe none may plead Igno- rance of them, they are appointed to be openly Proclaimed, that whoever breaks them may be Punifhed. In refpect therefore of the Care and Dili- gence obferv'd by good Legiflators, that their Laws lhouldbe fuft and clear, Judges and Ad- vocates had given them in Charge ; Thujh*k not do fire:/* Xhat in Aciwns , or Judgments , il'tgtever \uVcm- none of them Jhould abound in their manded, cbferve and do own Senfe, but be directed by the Au- ,v; thou jbah mt «ad thority of the Laws. That is to fay, thereto, nor diiximjb Vr • t* t -r i t/i tbtnfmn. not to diipute it the Law be J uit, or Unjuft, nor to give it any other Senfe than it naturally bears, according to the Letter. From which it follows, that the lawyers are to keep clofe to the Text of the F xi W, and take the meaning which is drawn from thence, and no other. This Doftrin being fuppofed, it is eafie to underftand whence the Lawyer is called Le- fe, and other Lettered Men not fo ; which is to lay , he is a letra dado, tied to the Letter , a Chap. XII I. €&e Crval of mite. 247 a Man that is not left at liberty to judge ao cording to his own Underftanding, but is ob- liged to follow the very Letter. Which having been fo conltrued by thofe who are the belt Prafrifed in this Profeflion, they dare neither Affirm nor Deny any thing concerning the Decifion of any Cafe, if they have not before them the Law deciding it in exprefs Terms ; and if at any time they ad- vance any thing of their own Head, inter- pofing their own Authority and Reafon, with- out founding it on the Law, they do it not without Doubting and Modefty ; and ac* cordingly we have a common Proverb, Eru- befcimits dum fine lege loquimur, importing, that weareafham'dtojudgeand ad vife where we have not the Law before us, that deter- mines the matter. The Divines cannot be calPd (inthisSenfe) Letrados, Learn'd, bc- caufe in Holy Writ, * The Letter kills , but the * II Co* Spirit gives Life. That being full ofMyileries, ** and abounding with Figures, dark and not obvious to every Understanding : Its Terms and Manner of Speech, of a very remote Sig- nification, from that given by thofe skilled in the three Vulgar Tongues. Therefore he that interprets it according to the Letter, and takes the Senfe that is drawn from the Gramma-. ticalConftruftionwill fall into many Ertors. Nor are the Phyficians more obliged to fubmit to the Letter, for if Hippocrates and Galen 7 and other Grave Authors* of that Sci- II 4 'ence 248 C&e Ctpai of agftW* Chap. xm. ence affirm a thing/ and Experience and Rea- fon fhew the contrary, they are not bound to follow them, and the reafon is, becaufein Phy- {ic, Experience has more plate than Reafon, and Reafon more than Authority : But in the Laws it happens quite otherwife, for there Authority ,and the Decretals have more Power and Prevalence than all the Reafons to the contrary. Which being fo, we have a way open to affign the Wit proper for the Laws ; for if the Lawyer is to have his Underftanding and Imagination determined to follow blind- ly whatever the Law fays, without addingor diminifhing, it is certain, this Faculty relates to the Memory, and all they have to dd is, to know the number of the Laws, and the Rules of Right, and to bear in mind each in particular by Heart, to reduce to Heads every Cafe and its Determination ; to the end that as any Cafe occurs, he may know' what Law determines-it, and in what manner. There- fore it feems to me, that the bell Difference pf Wit for a Lawyer, is, to have a great Me- mory, and a final! Underftanding rather than much Underftanding and little Memory; for if he is not to make ufeof his Wit and Abili- ty, but mufthave regard to the great number of Laws as they are fo diftinguiihM from each other, with fomany Exceptions, Reftri&ions, and Enlargements, it is more to the purpofe to have by Heart what is determined by the Law in each Cafe that occurs, than tQ Difcourfe or Reafon Chap. XIII. %fy Cipai Of Witfr 249 Reafon after what manner it ought to be de- termined; for one is neceffary, and the other impertinent; no other Opinion being fufficient to carry the Point but the decifion of the Law. So that it is certain, that the Theory of the Law belongs to the Memory, and not to the Underftanding or Imagination ; for which reafon the Laws are fo entirely pofitive, and the Lawyers have their Unaerftandings fo determined by the Will of the Ligiflator, that they cannot interpofe their own Opinion, but where they are in doubt what the Law has declared, when their Clients confultthem, they are alio w'd to fay, I will look for the Cafe in my Books, which (hould the Phyfician fay when they come for Cure of any Difeafe, or a Divine in a Cafe of Confcience, they would pafs for Men of fmall Ability in their Profef- iions. And the reafon of it is, that thefe two laft Sciences have their Definitions and Prin- ciples Univerfal, under which particular Cafes are contained ; but in the Faculty of the Law, each Law contains only one Cafe, the follow- ing Law not depending on it, though they are placed both under one and the fame Title. Wherefore it is neceffary to have notice of all the Laws, to Study each in particular, and to lay them up all diftinftly in the Memory. However againft thisDoftrin Plato obferves a thing very confiderable, which is, that in his time that Lawyer was fufpe&ed that knew much Law by Heart ( finding by Experience they 250 C&e tEtpai of (BEUtft Chap. XIII. they never made fuch good Judges and Plea- ders as their Oftentation promifed ) of which without doubt he reached not the Caufe, fince he faid nothing of it in fo proper a place, only hefaw by Experience, that the Lawyers of great Memory being to defend a Caufe, or give their Opinion in it, applied not the Law fo well as became them. The Reafon or Caufe of this Effect is not hard to affign from this Doftrin, fuppofing that the Memory be contrary to the Under- ftanding, and that the true Interpretation of the Laws, to Amplify, to Reftrain, and to Analyfe them with their Contraries and their Contexts, is done by diftinguifhing, conclu- ding, arguing, judging, and chufing which Works, (as we have often faid already) are A&s of the Under Handing; and for the Lawyer of a great Memory it is fcarce poflible he fhould ponefe them. We have noted elfewhere, that the Me- mory feems to have no other Office in the Head, than the Trull: to preferve the Figures and Ideas of things ; and that the Underftand- ing and Imagination are Powers that work with them, boas if the Lawyer have his whole Art in his Memory, and yet be wanting in Un- derftanding and Imagination, he will no more be able to Judge or Plead a Caufe than the Code, or Digejt it fclf, which though they contaiu all the Laws and Rules of Right, yet know not how to Write ever a Letter in the Book. Further- Chap. XIII. €ije €t?ai Of WLit8. 2 5 1 Furthermore, though it be true, that the Law ought to be fuch as its Definition im- ports, yet is it no lefs than a Miracle to find tilings with all the Perfe&ions the Under- . ftanding feigns in them. That the Law be juft and reafonable, that it forefee and provide againft all that may happen ; that it be Writ in clear Terms, void of Ambiguities, or Oppo- fitions, and admit no different Senfes, is not always to be attained, becaufe in a word, it has beeneftablifhed by Man's Council, which is not of fufficient force to provide for all Con- tingencies, as is feen by daily Experience ; for after a Law has been Enacted, upon due Advice and Confutation, in a fhort time it comes to be Abrogated, becaufe between its The Promulgation and Execution a thoufand jfor r W**«/ conveniences difcover themfelves, which were^JJ* , ,J never dreamt of, in theConfults of Making it. their kre- For which reafon, the Law direfts Kings and k htHncer - Emperors to think it no fhame to mend and wiTdom correct Laws; becaufe after all, they are Men, chap ix. and no wonder that they Err. So much the rather, becaufe there is no Law that can com- prehend in Words or Sentences all the Cir- cumftances of the Cafe to be decided 5 becaufe ♦ the Wicked have more Finenefs to find out Tricks, than the Good have Skill to try or give Judgment upon them. . And therefore it was faid, *That it is impoffible to write Laws * L nec or Ordinances of the Senate in fuch a manner m leges F. - *•