U^u^e^U^yt^ ^^a/^r?^i/ (^0. c //f/jr y//// //<;/<, (< ■ r.j • • * • • • • • • ■ • , PREFACE. This work is an account of the progress of a State in India which was civilised under our rule, and which it is now proposed to hand over, against the wishes of its people, to certain Native Princes. It is published with the object of appealing to the protection of public opinion in England, on behalf of a loyal and industrious population. The Portrait facing the title-page is that of General Hall, C.B., who was the founder, and main promoter, of the reforms in Mair- wara. 512936 CONTENTS. CHAPTER I. PAGB Introductory Remarks i CHAPTER II. An Account of Mairwara, up to the Year 1848 9 CHAPTER III. An Outline of the History of Mairwara, from 1848 to the Present Time ... 90 Appendices A to F 119 — 134 v ! *• THE STORY OF MAIRWARA &c. CHAPTER I. INTRODUCTORY REMARKS. Mairwara is a small Spartan state in Cen- tral India, adjacent to Ajmeer. On taking the latter territory from the Mahrattas, in 1818, we found ourselves compelled, by the injuries we had sustained, and the incursions to which we were exposed, to reduce the pre- datory people of Mairwara also. This we accomplished in 1822, and they became, in our hands, a peaceful, prosperous peasantry, the modern instance of able, active govern- ment. In the Great Mutiny of 1857, — which broke out not far from their borders — they ;. ::.:•.:>;''«•: ; ,«/, : 2 7/£ on the fart of Government : , to obtain water for irrigation * &c. The money- advances for irrigation works were, as we have seen, greatly extended in the time of Colonel Dixon, and he was thereby enabled to accomplish all that he did so well ; but public works of the same de- scription had been erected, and advances made, in like manner, in the time of Colonel Hall ; and it was in consequence of the beneficial operation of these works, and their proved results, that the system of advances was ex- tended. It was a rule of the Indian Govern- ment at that time, not to sanction advances for agricultural improvements, until their value and importance had been thoroughly ascertained. On this account, Colonel Hall was not enabled to proceed as rapidly with irrigation works, as his successor; but the system was the same, and its value was tried, established, and strikingly exhibited, in the im- proved condition, both of country and people, before Colonel Dixon ever built a tank. Our Rule in India. 75 Thus are the three averments, in that short extract, all inaccurate. Colonel Sutherland was, no doubt, justly pleased with the activity of Colonel Dixon, and the condition of his province, and possibly, in an access of official facility, forgot for a moment that he ever had a predecessor. We have good reason for remarking on this extract. Mr. Kaye, in his well-known work* on c The Administration of the East India Company/ takes his account of Mair- wara from the c Sketch '; does some injustice to the claims of Colonel Hall ; and cites this passage in a note, as one of his main autho- rities. In the heading of his chapter on the c Progress of Civilisation/ we have, c Dixon and the Mairs/ but not the name of Colonel Hall. The latter is afterwards introduced to us as c Captain Hall, of the 1 6th Bengal Native Infantry, an officer who, in the Quar- termaster-General's Department, had exhibited * * History of the Administration of the East India Com- pany. 1 By John William Kaye. One vol. 8vo. Bentley : London, 1853. 76 The Story of Mairwara, or considerable ability and force of character/ and the moral and administrative reforms are mostly referred to him ; but the irrigation works are as wholly ascribed to Colonel Dixon, as if his predecessor had never once thought about them : c He (Dixon) saw at once what was the great want of the country. Eager to develope the productiveness of an unyield- ing soil, and to stimulate the industry of an unyielding people, he addressed himself to this great matter of the water-supply, and left untried no effort to secure it.' * c The financial results of the experiment were highly favourable ; the moral results were more favourable still.' j- . . . c His (Dixon's) name will live as the regenerator of the Mairs. It is no small privilege, to the compiler of such a work as this, to chronicle, even in a few imperfect pages, the recent annals of Mair- wara, and to show how a wild and lawless * Kaye's • History of the Administration of the East India Company,' pp. 468-9. f Ibid. p. 469. Our Rule in India. 77 people were reclaimed by a single European officer, taken from an expense-magazine/ * The readers of Mr. Kaye's very clever book — for such it is — may admire his style ; but, as we have shown, they have some reason to distrust his infallibility. The extract on which we have been ob- serving, is from a report made by Colonel Sutherland, embodied, indeed and adopted in the c Sketch ' ; but we have now to ask the reader's attention to another, which is alto- gether Colonel Dixon's own. After recording the retirement of Colonel Hall, and his own appointment, Colonel Dixon proceeds to say : — It was manifest that water was the great deside- ratum, and that the first step towards improvement, must be to provide for its supply. It was the one thing necessary to bind the inhabitants to the soil, to attach them to our form of government, and to admit of our moulding them into the habits of life we desired. It was evident that on its provision, * Kaye's ' History of the Administration of the East India Company," p. 472. 78 The Story of ' M air war a, or which would ensure the ripening of the crops, de pended future prosperity. It has been said that the rains are light and uncertain ; but though the fall, in reference to more favoured climes, is small, still, were arrangements matured and carried out, for re- taining all the rain that fell on the soil, there was a confident promise that sufficient would be reserved for the purpose of the cultivator. The plan was easy of conception — the difficulty was to carry it out. Its enforcement involved the outlay of considerable sums of money. The people at that time were too much impoverished to afford any gratuitous assistance. Measures involving an immediate expenditure for what might have been considered a problematical benefit, were not likely to be favourably entertained by the Government. Colonel Hall, during his thir- teen years' administration, had made and repaired seven tulaos. The benefit to the people and the return of revenue had been great, but the outlay had been inconsiderably small. To have progressed at the slow rate which then prevailed, would have been to have protracted the final completion of all the works of irrigation that were necessary, to an inde- finite period. The Superintendent had been recently appointed. His character might not be sufficiently known to the authorities, to warrant a deviation from the then established rule, which was, to dis- Our Rule in India. 79 courage advances or outlays, on agricultural purposes. Still, some essay towards effecting improvement was imperative. The subject was brought to the notice of the Government, such circumstances as favoured the project being duly set forth. The proposition was favourably entertained, and sanction accorded. The requisition embraced the construction of two tulaos. The work contemplated was inconsiderable in respect to what was to be accomplished — to place the country in a position to withstand a season of drought. But as the Government had vouchsafed its sanction, there was a confident expectation that its support would be continued, and more liberally extended to the outlay of larger sums, on the utility, alike to the people and to the State, of works of irrigation being made palpably manifest. The ques- tion of the support of the Government having, hap- pily, been answered in the affirmative, it became necessary to arrange, systematically, for the spread of improvement throughout the district. The ex- pense of the larger works, it was evident, must be borne by us ; but there was no reason for allowing the inhabitants to remain inactive. It was desirable to enlist their hearty co-operation in the fulfilment of contemplated improvements. — Sketchy pp. 85-6. We submit that the impression which this passage is calculated to convey is, that 80 The Story of M air war a, or although Colonel Hall built a few tanks in thirteen years. Colonel Dixon was the first who saw the real value of irrigation works, and gave the impulse to their construction ; that, when he took charge of the district, the advantages arising from these, might have been regarded as c problematical ' by the Go- vernment, and their utility as not yet made c palpable.' This is, accordingly, the impres- sion imbibed, not only by Mr. Kaye, but also by Captain Baird Smith, who, in his valuable book on c Italian Irrigation/ * gives an abstract of Colonel Dixon's book ; and it appears again, in a notice of the c Sketch/ in the February number of c Blackwood's Ma- gazine' of the year 1853. c Blackwood,' and Baird Smith, give each their meed of praise to Colonel Hall ; but the reader will rise, from the perusal of both, with the conviction that the order of the respective merits of Colonels Hall, and Dixon, refers the social reforms to * < Italian Irrigation.' By Captain Baird Smith, Bengal Artillery. 2 vols. Blackwood: Edinburgh, 1852. Our Rule in India. &i the former, while the irrigation works and agricultural improvements, are the fruits of c a new system ' — c a new era/ introduced by the latter : — For thirteen years [says Captain Baird Smith*] Colonel Hall devoted himself to the social ameliora- tion of the Mairs ; to the abolition of demoralising and pernicious customs \ to the substitution of honest labour and settled habits of thrift among the people, for an uncertain, predatory mode of life. Though it was reserved for his successor, to develope irriga- tion work, as a great engine for the improvement of the country, and of the people ; it was Colonel Hall who first tamed the wild race, who substi- tuted law and order, for anarchy and disorder, and so laid the foundation of all subsequent ameliorations. Let the reader compare this passage with another in the next page (p. 405), when, after speaking of the appointment of Captain Dixon, he adds : — It soon became manifest to the new Superin- tendent, that water was the great desideratum in Mairwara, and that the first step, &c. The same views are reproduced in c Black- * * Italian Irrigation, ' vol. i. p. 404. G 82 The Story of Mairwara, or wood/ a magazine which, we need hardly say, is not more esteemed for its ability, than for the straightforward character of its articles. In the number for February 1853 (p. 208), after enumerating the moral and social re- forms of Colonel Hall, it adds : — In 1835, ill-health drove Colonel Hall to another climate, and he was succeeded by Captain (afterwards Colonel) Dixon, of the Artillery : with him began a new era in the history of Mairwara. It soon became manifest to the new Superinten- dent, that water was the great desideratum in Mair- wara, &c. And so it is assumed, throughout both the abstract of the c Sketch ' in Smith, and the ar- ticle on Mairwara in c Blackwood's Magazine/ that the merit of the irrigation movement — without which, as we have already observed, all other reforms would be unavailing — belongs, not to Colonel Hall, but to Colonel Dixon. We do not impute to these writers any intentional disparagement of the claims of Colonel Hall. They have, probably, been misled by a want of clearness in their only Our Rule in India. 83 book of authority, the c Sketch.' Colonel Dixon makes many acknowledgments of the services of his predecessor ; but it so happens, that these are vague, save in their reference to social reform, and that, when compared with other passages of his work, they leave those very impressions, which have been taken up by every author who has referred to it. It is but justice to Colonel Dixon to add, that the errors of his work, may arise from its being prepared amidst absorbing duties ; from its having passed through the press while he was far away ; and from its having been originally made up, less for the English public than for the Indian Government, who were well acquainted with the real facts. How- ever this may be, it is certain that when Colonel Hall left Mairwara, the importance of tank- embankments in that province, was not c pro- blematical/ nor had their c utility' to be made c palpable/ This officer had availed himself of every means in his power, to encourage irrigation works, and had made their results 84 The Story of ' M air war a, or palpable, in the changed aspect of the country, and the improved condition of its people. In proof of this, we can adduce the independent testimony of an accomplished observer, who had no disposition to describe the doings of the East India Company too favourably. The French naturalist, M. Victor Jacquemont, visited Mairwara, and wrote of what he saw, as follows ; we cite from the c Letters from India/* 2nd vol., p. 285, first English edition: — I have seen the superb Jeypore and the delight- ful Ajmeer; and during my very short stay in the latter, I have contrived to visit Mairwara, the former abruzzie of Rajpootana. It was well worth eighty miles of riding, in little more than twenty-four hours. I saw a country whose inhabitants, since an immemorial time, had never had any other means of existence but plunder, in the adjacent plains of Marwar and Meywar — a nation of murderers, now changed into a quiet, industrious, and happy people * ' Letters from India during the Years 1828, 1829, 1830, 183 1. By Victor Jacquemont. 2 vols. London: Churton, 1834. See Appendix B., p. 121. Our Rule in India. 85 of shepherds and cultivators. No Rajpoot chiefs, no Mogul emperors, had ever been able to subdue them. Fourteen years ago, everything was to be done with them, and since six or seven years, every- thing is done already. A single man has worked this wonderful miracle of civilisation — Major Henry Hall, the son-in-law of Colonel Fagan, of whom I have written to you at Delhi. As I know it will be gratifying to your feelings, and to your opinions on the subject, I shall add, my dear friend, that Major Hall has accomplished this admirable social experiment, without taking a single life. The very worst characters of Mairwara he secured, confined them, or put them, in irons, at work on the roads. Those who had lived long by the sword, without becoming notorious for wanton cruelty, he made soldiers ; they became, in that ca- pacity, the keepers of their former associates, and often of their chiefs ; and the rest of the population was gained to the plough. Female infanticide was prevalent with the Mairs, and generally through Rajpootana ; and now female casualties among infants, exceed not male casualties — a proof that the bloody practice has been aban- doned, and scarcely has a man been punished for it. Major Hall did not punish the offenders ; he removed the cause of the crime, and made the 86 The Story of Mairwara, or crime useless, even injurious to the offender, and it is never now committed. Major Hall has shown to me, on the field, the corps which he has raised from amongst these for- mer savages ; and I have seen none in the Indian Army, in a higher state of discipline. He was justly proud of his good work, and spared no trouble to himself, that I might see it thoroughly, in the few hours I had to spend with him. Upwards of one hundred villagers were summoned, from the neigh- bouring villages and hamlets. I conversed with them on their former mode of life ; it was a most miserable one, by their accounts. They were naked and starving. Now, poor as is the soil of their small valleys,, and barren their hills, every hand being set to work, there is plenty of clothes and food ; and so sensible are they of the immense benefit conferred on them by the British Govern- ment, that willingly they pay to it, already, 500,000 francs,, which they increase as their national wealth admits of it. Often I had thought, that gentle means would prove inadequate to the task of breaking-in popu- lations, addicted, for ages, to a most unruly, savage life — such as the Greeks, for instance ; yet the Klaphtes were but lambs, compared to the Mairs — Our Rule in India. 87 and the Mairs, in a few years, have become an in- dustrious and well-behaved people. I see by the Bombay papers that M. Capo d'Istrias has been murdered. I wish Major Hall were his successor ; for now I have the greatest confidence in the efficacy of gentle means ; but a peculiar talent, too, which is a gift of nature, is required in the ruler, without which, the most be- nevolent intentions would prove useless.* In connection with Jacquemont's most in- teresting letter, we transcribe, from a printed document, a note addressed to Colonel Hall, by the late Lord Metcalfe, then Governor- General of India : — Allahabad, 10th February, 1835. My dear Colonel, — Many thanks for your kind letters. I have read your interesting report regarding Mairwara. Your management there will immortalise you! It has already brought your name before the public with proud distinction. Jacquemont says, you ought to be King of Greece. * Jacquemont, again referring to Major Hall, says (vol. ii. p. 291): — 'There are few Major Halls to work the miracles he has done.'* 88 The Story of Mairwara, or You have my wishes to be whatever you may desire to be. Yours, most sincerely, C. T. Metcalfe. Jacquemont visited Mairwara in 183 1. Colonel Hall left that province in 1835. Thus it appears that, four years before this officer left the Mairs, he had changed them c into a quiet, industrious , and happy people of shepherds and cultivators ; ' that he had c gained them to the plough;' that c there was plenty of food and clothes ; ' that, at this period, he had accomplished their reformation — had c worked this miracle of civilisation. 1 Colonel Dixon, we gladly repeat, evinced the most enduring zeal, reclaimed large tracts, induced new settlers, extended irrigation works, built a town, and (as was said of him by a com- petent authority) c did enough to immortalise one man.' Still, the system he pursued so well, had been introduced, and proved, by his predecessor. Our Rule in India. , 89 The testimony of Jacquemont would alone establish the claims of Colonel Hall. We persuade ourselves that there was no actual intention of impugning them ; but as they have been, in fact, impugned, our duty, and our desire, is to defend the right. In closing this chapter, we must express a hope, that the more popular form in which we are now presenting c The Story of Mairwara,' may help to make known to widening circles, the fruitful labours of Colonel Dixon, and General Hall. Such workers are the stars of India, worthy of being numbered with those whose names we honour, and to whom we erect statues. 90 The Story of Mairwara, or CHAPTER III. AN OUTLINE OF THE HISTORY OF MAIRWARA, FROM 1848 TO THE PRESENT TIME. Impelled by the ordinary feeling in favour of fair-play, we tried, in the preceding chapter, on its first appearance, to set right some mis- apprehensions in reference to the respective shares of Colonel Hall and of Colonel Dixon, in the civilisation of the Mairs. We discussed the topics simply with the desire of doing justice, and do not think it necessary, on our reconsideration of the subject, to alter what we have said, or to advert to it any further. Colonel Dixon was not inferior in energy to his predecessor, Colonel Hall. Within a year of his appointment, he had made a per- sonal inspection of all the districts then under him, and laid before the Government an im- Our Rule in India. 9 1 portant Report, calling on them to assist him with a largely increased expenditure, for irri- gation, and other field-works. In this he met with all the encouragement he could have hoped for, and was thus enabled to carry out the many great undertakings, to which we have referred in the preceding chapter. In the same first year, he founded and reared a city, thus seeking to extend to commerce, the momentum which had been already given to agriculture. We have spoken of Nya Nug- gur ( c The New City ') before, but so great an achievement deserves a further notice. Up to the period of the building of Nya Nuggur, there was scarcely a trader in all Mairwara. Their long ancestral fame for robbery and rapine, was far too firmly fixed to allow of the Mairs being looked on, by the merchant class, without some lingering feelings of apprehen- sion and distrust ; and although Colonel Hall had, with a view to the promotion of trade, established some lines of intercourse, still these were chiefly used for cattle ; and the 92 The Story of Mairwara, or people got such articles as they required from Nusseerabad or Ajmeer, distant, respectively, some thirty or forty miles, paying, of course, enhanced prices. As the country was pros- pering, this form of dependence was incon- venient. Colonel Dixon accordingly circu- lated notices in the neighbouring towns, intimating his intention of building a city which would be well situated for commerce, being between the states of Marwar, Meywar, and Ajmeer ; and that a wide field was thus open to merchants, for the investment of their money, while all settlers should find protection, and be received with kindness. It was added, that the customs-duties, leviable on merchandise in the new town, should be remitted for the first two years. These invi- tations were well received, and people came in numbers to learn particulars, and to judge for themselves. The houses were to be of stone, the streets regular and broad, and to have the shade of trees ; and provision was made for a good supply of water. Candi- Our Rule in India. 93 dates at once came forward for forty shops, and the buildings were begun. The bazaar was to be after the model of that at Ajmeer, and was opened for traffic three months after the first stone was laid. Religious edifices were added, and in due time c the business of life/ says Colonel Dixon, c fell into the course of steady regularity which characterises the internal economy of old towns/ Two years later, Colonel Dixon completed another great public work — that is, the ram- part-wall, already spoken of, which surrounds his town. This was a concession to the resi- dent traders, to secure their increasing stores, from the hazards of possible raids. The building of Nya Nuggur appears to have answered the objects for which it was undertaken. In his last published Report, dated 1848, Colonel Dixon says: — The tables have now been turned, and, in place of seeking supplies from distant towns, we have ourselves become the source of supply to surround- ing countries. In the course of twelve years, a town has been built, and fortified by a wall two 94 The Story of M air war a, or miles in length. A population, numbering perhaps nine thousand souls, entire foreigners to the country, have come to settle with us, and, having built their shops and houses, are now sedulously engaged in their own immediate callings. An extensive and prosperous trade has arisen, and has become cemented by time ; while Nya Nuggur presents a great variety in its manufactures, and is a sample of industry worthy of imitation by our neighbours. — Sketch, p. 109. It is now twenty years since the last date in Colonel Dixon's c Sketch/ and we are happy to hear, from persons who have the means of knowing the country, that it is prosperous, and fairly progressive. Nya Nuggur has not, of late, increased much in population; but it has become the centre of a well-rooted, thriving cotton-trade with Bombay, as well as with other places ; and an active com- merce in other articles — such as grain, salt, sugar, spices, tobacco, opium, and wool. Colonel Hall and, after him, Colonel Dixon, took long-continued pains to train their people to industrious ways. They had them in- structed in building, in the making of tank- Our Rule in India. 95 embankments, and of all field-works, and supplied them with tools and implements. Their desire was, to have every individual employed, and every foot of ground under careful cultivation. They even led the min- strels, who were chartered idlers, to turn their soft hands to farm- labour. It is gratifying to find that the good habits, so cherished and enjoined, continue still. As to their success in agriculture, a competent observer, now in Mairwara, writes as follows : — Better cultivation than that which is brought to bear on its narrow strips of hill-bosomed land, I have seen nowhere else out of Scotland. Indeed, it would compare favourably with the model farming of Mid-Lothian. In these hill-valleys, no foot of ground is lost, and at this season (February) a sheet of vivid green, from wheat or barley, spreads from base to base of the hills, and pushes the village footpaths up on the bare hill-sides, where no corn can grow, or fertile soil be lost. The cardinal events of the later history of the Mairs are, — the death of Colonel Dixon, and the revival of the claims of the native princes, to have a large portion of their territory 96 The Story of Mairwara, or transferred to them. We shall discuss the sub- ject of the transfer presently, but must first pay our tribute to the memory of Colonel Dixon. Early in 1 857, the year of the Great Mutiny, Colonel Dixon, worn by climate, and by the responsibilities of an arduous position, died, and was truly mourned for, by the people he had served, so devotedly, and so well. We remember reading, in the Memoirs of Warren Hastings,* that for long years after his depar- ture from India, no native from the provinces entered the Government-Hall in Calcutta, without doing reverence to his portrait. This was the unbought homage, the genuine tes- timony, of public opinion, which consoled him for the Athenian gratitude he had experienced at home. Colonel Dixon, and General Hall, had no ingratitude to encounter, but they too found, in the strong regards of their people, the reward they valued most. Their names are always spoken of in tones expres- * * Memoirs of the Life of the Right Hon. Warren Hast- ings.' By the Rev. G. R. Gleig, M.A., 3 vols. Bentley : London, 1841. Our Rule in India. 97 sive of veneration and regret. c Ah,' they said, c the days of Hall Sahib, and Dixon Sahib, are no more ! They took us, when we were as wild beasts on the mountains, and made men of us!' c The name/ said an elder, c of Hall Baba will be known amongst us, as long as our mountains last/ We have seen the remarkable success of the moral, social, and economic measures in- troduced by General Hall in Mairwara, and that, after an experience of forty-five years, their good results continue, and abide. Order and industry have become established, slavery has been abolished, the cruel customs of sell- ing wives and mothers have been put down, and female infanticide — one of the great diffi- culties of statesmen and philanthropists in India — has been wholly eradicated. The tes- timony of Captain Baird Smith, who knows India well, is : — c The sale of women, and female infanticide, are among the customs thus abolished ; and so effectually, that the former is scarcely ever heard of, and the latter H 98 The Story of Mairwara, or is regarded as a heinous crime, by the Mairs themselves/ * Mr. Kaye, in his c History of the Adminis- tration of the East India Company/ and in a chapter on Female Infanticide which does them honour, tells of the efforts made by ener- getic men, in various parts of India, to put down this revolting practice — by such men as Duncan, Walker, Wilkinson, Willoughby, Erskine, Lang, Ludlow, Unwin, Macpher- son, Campbell, and others ; of their failures, their partial and temporary successes — and then refers to the result of General Hall's measures in Mairwara, as c The first unequi- vocal success,' as one which had stood the trial of more than twenty years. His words are, c The result appears to have justified the sanguine expectations of Colonel Hall.' Writing more than twenty years after- wards, his successor, Colonel Dixon, says — Thus infanticide received its deathblow, through the diminution of the expenses attending on mar- * • Italian Irrigation,' vol. i. p. 404.. Our Rule in India. 99 riages, which were now brought within the reach of all sections of society. For many years past, no female children have been put to death. The practice has fallen altogether into desuetude. Indeed, so greatly have the ideas of the people changed on this, and other usages, since the introduction of our rule, that the commission of such an act, would now be viewed as a most heinous crime.* The twenty years above referred to, may now be written down as forty-five, and the reports of missionaries, who have been living amongst this people for the last eight years, state, that infanticide is as little known there now, as it is in England. They add, that in all that time, they heard of but one case of wife-selling, and that was surreptitious, and known to be illegal. These peaceful triumphs were all devised and carried out by Colonel (now General) Hall, and all, as Jacquernont adds, with evident exultation, by gentle means. We have two other topics to touch upon, * Vide Dixon's ' Mairwara,' as cited in Kaye's ' History of the Administration of the East India Company,'' pp. 564-5. H 2 ioo The Story of ' M air war a, or in order that our readers may have a just impression of the actual condition of Mair- wara. These are, — Education and Religion. Whatever has been done in either of these departments, appears to have been owing, altogether, to the United Presbyterian Church. In 1858, some members of that denomination, moved by the terrors of the recent Mutiny, and by the more appalling barbarism which they disclosed, and desirous of sharing in the evangelisation of India, came to the deter- mination of sending a mission there. The field they selected, was the British provinces of Ajmeer and Mairwara. They had learned that the hillmen were less under the in- fluence of customs, and superstitions, than the dwellers in the plains, and that, accordingly, Gospel-teaching was more likely to make progress amongst them. In 1 860, they sent out one medical and two ordained missionaries; and they appear to have now eight European agents there, engaged in preaching, and teach- ing. They have fixed stations, with central Our Rule in India. 161 schools, whence they supervise and inspect other schools in the villages about them. From these stations, they itinerate through given districts, preaching and ministering as occasions offer. In their eight years' experience, they have found no serious hindrance to their efforts, but only, now and then, some little difficulty arising from caste, or prejudice, or super- stition ; and their addresses are listened to, with grave attention. Neither do the people make any difficulty about sending their children to the mission schools, although the missionaries uphold the healthy doctrine, that secular education and religious teaching should go hand-in hand. Indeed, the farmers and peasantry (the real original Mairs), take a very practical view of the value of education. Having been hitherto wholly unacquainted with what, in days gone by, the Irish school- master was used to call the c three R's '(reading, writing, and arithmetic), they found themselves obliged to entrust the keeping of their ac- 102 The Story of Mairwara> or counts to the Bunneahs, or merchant-class, who, at stated times, came round to assist them. These people are said, as a rule, to falsify accounts, and, through fictitious re- presentations of debt, to practise a great deal of oppressive fraud. Hence, fathers have become very sensible of the advantage of having their children able to assist them in the keeping of their accounts. In 1 865, the missionaries had twelve schools in and around Beawr, with a daily attendance of 470 children ; and, in the following year, there was a public examination of their schools, in the presence of the authorities of the neigh- bourhood. In addition to the ordinary stu- dies, they were examined in mental arithmetic, and in the first seven chapters of the Acts of the Apostles, and answered well. The number in actual attendance then was 470 ; but one school, numbering 1 00, and said to be well pre- pared, refused to attend, having taken it into their heads that they were all to be spirited off to an imaginary place called Willayat. The Our Rule in India. 103 Pundit said that, to oppose them, would be to break up the school, so they had their way. The same day afforded another instance of the impulsive character of this people, and of the suddenness with which they act on their impressions. General Hall had directed that a remembrance-feast should be given, in his name, to such survivors as had served under him in any capacity. About 140 veterans came forward, many of them walking from a considerable distance. They rested in groups, beneath the banyan and orange trees, enjoyed their hookah and their talk; and the feast, consisting of piles of pastry and of sweets, and of all such things as they think good, was announced. At that instant it was suggested, that the whole object of the feast was to make them Chris- tians, and that there was something wrong mixed with the food. All hesitated, and some got up, and tying pieces of cocoa-nut in their turbans were going off, leaving the feast untasted. Fortunately for the enjoy- ]04 The Story of Mairwara, or ment of the day, there was one sensible man amongst them. He pointed out to them, that the eatables had come direct from their first confectioner, whose shop their best Brahmins frequented daily ; and, showing round the photograph of General Hall, he asked them if they could believe that he would practise such a contrivance on them ? No one, on consideration, believed it, and the appeal was triumphant. In addition to the schools around Beawr, there are village schools connected with the several stations, and in all these, adults may be seen, as well as children — young farmers reading with the Scripture classes, and an- swering from a Catechism, which the mission- aries have rendered into the Hindee. While, however, they are openly, and with their own goodwill, teaching them great truths, the missionaries are by no means disposed to re- ceive converts hastily, and have declined admitting several. Colonel Dixon was not inattentive to the Our Rule in India. 105 value of schools. He had twelve in Nya Nuggur — ten in which Hindee was taught, and two for instruction in Persian. The number of children attending, at the date of his last report, amounted to 118. Besides these, he had village schools, amounting in all to fifty. They were of little use, and have nearly all disappeared since Colonel Dixon's death ; owing partly to there being no system of inspection, and partly to the pundits (or teachers) being idle, ignorant, and under- paid — their wages being hardly better than those of a cooly, or common porter. When the missionaries first came, there were, in all the Mugra or Hill country, but eight schools. Two were Government schools, paid for by the Indian treasury, and the remain- ing six were supported, partly by a sum taken from the land-tax of the district, and partly from other funds at the Commissioner's dis- posal. The Government teachers received six rupees a month, the others four The result, of course, was, that such schools were altogether 106 The Story of Mairwara, or useless, and this the peasantry quite under- stood. When asked to send their children, their ordinary answer was, c Why should we ? They learn nothing there, and they are of some sort of use to us in the fields.' No schools will do in India which are not under a vigilant superintendence, and, for want of that, Colonel Dixon, with all his energy, was wholly unsuccessful. The missionaries take a more judicious course ; they content themselves with establishing schools within a morning's ride of their stations, and postpone attempting their further extension, until they have centres which may bring them within their reach. In want of these, they have de- clined applications for schools from farmers, with offers of support. Having now completed our outline of the history and present position of Mairwara, we revert to the topic with which we commenced — the transfer of large portions of this territory to the two native princes who claim them as their own. These claims have been doubt- Our Rule in India. 107 ful and doubted, since our first subjugation of the country, and have been the subject of many arrangements, but of no final agreement as yet. They were at first too easily con- ceded, and hence the great trouble they have given us. The officials to whom the Com- pany of that day referred the examination of their titles, were deceived by evidence which they who offered it knew to be untrue. For example, the Mairs were accustomed, at cer- tain festivals, to offer a goat or a hare, or some such trifling present, to the lowland lord near whom they lived. These were re- presented as symbols of allegiance, when they were, in fact, nothing of the kind, but only tokens of respect, for which they received in return an allowance — usually a too liberal allowance — of drink. The truth, as it is now known, is, that the chiefs of Meywar and Marwar have no title to any portion of Mairwara, unless it be that of their having made continual claim to it. The Mairs were never in bondage to any man, 108 The Story of M air war a, or They have been an independent people from a period of great antiquity — it is said, even from the thirteenth century. They never paid tribute, but had long and regularly levied it from districts, which chose to buy from them that protection which their own chiefs could not afford them. Some chiefs compounded with them for an annual payment in corn or cash, and some by the assignment of a village. It is quite true that the question of these claims is not free from difficulty. We ac- cepted them in the first instance, and have dealt with them in agreements and treaties. Still, it may be urged that we were led into all this, by misstatements and wrong represen- tations, and might justly repudiate a title so tainted with, what a court of equity would call, fraud. This course is not unattended with difficulty ; but had we only a choice of difficulties, it would be incomparably better to accept it, rather than resort to the fearful alternative of handing a whole people back to barbarism, and foregoing all those moral Our Rule in India. too, obligations which a long connection with them has induced. We have, however, yet another course. These claimant-States entered into agreements with us, to make over what they called their districts, to meet the expenses of the Mair Battalion, and, in the treaties made in refer- ence to these districts, it is expressly stipu- lated c that they should be held by us so long as may suit our convenience.' We may then, as is suggested by the two Indian journals, cited in our first chapter, fall back upon this clause, and keep the provinces as long as we please. This course may be practically the best, but neither is it without its difficulty. The whole agreement appears to contemplate only a temporary retention of the districts, and is calculated to preclude the Mairs from ever regarding their connection with England as permanent. In any negotiation that may be entered into with these two neighbour States, it may be well to bear in mind, that, on the subju- no The Story of Mairwara, or gation of the Mairs, we were the only party who had a right to their country. The Mairs had forfeited all rights. Such Ishmaelites knew they had none. They had broken agreements, violated treaties, and assailed and plundered us in incessant raids, and so com- pelled us to subdue them. France had not a more righteous title to Algeria than we had to Mairwara — an unquestionable right by conquest. The princes of Mey war, and Mar- war, were never regarded by the Mairs as anything more than pretenders. This people respected our fame in arms, and acknowledg- ing and feeling our title by the sword, ' Deemed it No loss of pride ■ to accept and obey our rule. They have learned to value their union with us, by nearly half a century of the truest services, and, come what may, we must not abandon them. We shall now refer to some short docu- ments, which show in what light the proposed transfer was regarded by high officials in Our Rule in India. 1 1 1 India, as well as by the Mairs themselves, when it was debated in 1846. The first is the opinion of Colonel Suther- land, Lieutenant-Governor of the North- western Provinces. We transcribe it from Colonel Dixon's s Sketch' (p. 224) : — It may be a question whether the British Go- vernment would be justified in now withdrawing its protection. Under the native governments no limit to the demands of the State exists, but the power of one party to exact, and the ability of the other to pay. If, by mild and conciliatory measures, the Mairs have been reduced from a state of wild ferocity to one of civilisation and industry, it would amount to almost a breach of faith to give them over, in their present comparatively helpless condition, to be plundered by persons whom they hate. The probable results of their transfer would be, their impoverishment, the diminution of their culti- vation, and their more or less rapid demoralisation, till they resumed their old habits of plunder, and became such a source of uneasiness to their neigh- bours, and disquietude to the country at large, as to render our interposition again necessary. But it could not then be rendered with the same effect as now. The remembrance would be fresh of what 1 1 2 The Story of Mairwara, or would appear to the people a betrayal of their interests, They would be slow to adopt habits and to follow suggestions which, at some future time, would only make them the better objects of plunder. We next show a document drawn up by the Mairs themselves in 1832, when it was rumoured that our rule was about to be abolished, and the Mairs given over to the native princes who claimed them. The cir- cumstances of their position then, and now, are the same ; only their aversion to being transferred has become stronger by length of time, and by their greater experience of the advantages of good rule. The document is a petition from the Mair zemindars of Shamgurh, dated 12th June, 1832:— The government of the English extends to thou- sands of koskos, and they are kings of the earth. We never yielded to any Raja, or Bhoomeah, when- ever any such came with troops to attack us, we never submitted, but beat them back with our own power. What have the Bhoomeahs to do with us, that we should pay them revenue ? On the contrary, Our Rule in India. 113 they (such as the Thakoors of Mussooda and Khurwa) paid us revenue, that we should abstain from plundering them. When you came to reduce our hills, we recognised you as our king, and made no resistance, but as the subjects of a king consented to pay revenue. Our lands were given to us by no one. At one time King Akbar took our an- cestors to Delhi, circumcised them, rendered us his subjects, and gave us those towns. From those days to this, no government has been established in Mairwara. Considering you our original kings, we pay you revenue. We have derived our injuries from you ; but such benefits have followed, that nobody is in want of food or raiment, and we are as happy, if not more so, than in former times. But now that the Thakoors of Mussooda, and Khurwa, have told us that they will take revenue from us, desire us to cultivate well, and point out our boundaries ; we represent to you, that these lands do not belong to Thakoors, or Bhoomeahs. Boundaries have never been fixed ; and it cannot be that the Thakoors of Khurwa or Mussooda shall take revenue from us. If only one of your chu- prassees came, all the inhabitants of the district are obedient, with supplicating hands, but we never will submit to any other masters except you. In 1843 ^ s question of the transfer was 1 H4 2% Story of ' M air war a, or again revived, and is referred to by Colonel Dixon, as follows : — This paragraph expresses the sentiments I entertained in 1840. Nor have I, after a lapse of two years and a half, any cause for changing those opinions. On the contrary, further experience has satisfied me of the correctness of the views I then formed. By way of illustration, it may be remarked that during the last month, reports have been rife that our arrangements in Mairwara were to be broken up, and the villagers given over to the States bearing their names. Numerous petitions have been re- ceived, and all breathing the same painful and heart- breaking sentiments : extreme despondence that they should be transferred to States to which they only paid a nominal allegiance ; that the British Go- vernment, through extreme kindness, conciliation, and liberality, had weaned them from their former predatory habits, and had taught them the arts of peaceful industry; that, under the favour and soli- citude of that paternal government, their children were becoming an industrious peasantry, looking alone to the produce of their lands as the means of their livelihood ; that at present they were eating the bread of industry, in full security that what they earned was their own, and in full confidence that Our Rule in India. 115 they, and their posterity, would live in happiness under the shade of the English Government ; that they had sunk all their savings and profits on the improvement of their paternal lands ; that their separation from the British rule would dissipate, and utterly destroy all the visions of happiness they had so fondly hoped would be permanent, and descend from father to son in perpetuity ; that now, each man received a patient and willing hearing from the Superintendent. The Kamdars would treat them with haughtiness and tyranny, fleece them of all their hard earnings, and ultimately drive them to desperation — forcing them either to quit their native soil, or to have recourse to the paths of their fore- fathers in resuming a predatory life. These are a {qw of the melancholy anticipations which rumour alone has created, in the breasts of the denizens of Mairwara. — (Sketch, p. JO.) The Government had decided on making over a number of the villages to the State of Marwar ; but on receiving the above remon- strance from Colonel Dixon, they reconsidered their views, and came to an agreement with the Raja of Marwar, for their further con- tinuance under British rule. The arguments in the remonstrance are, in the main, as appli- 1 1 6 The Story of ' M air war a, or cable to the Mairs of the present day, as they were to those of 1843. No doubt Mairs, born and bred under our rule, are less likely to recur to predatory habits than their fathers were. Still, there is too much reason to be- lieve that, if long placed in unfavourable cir- cumstances, they would relapse into all bad ways, and that it would be more difficult to reclaim them than ever. Before leaving this part of the subject, there are one or two circumstances which it is worth while noticing. Part of the arrange- ment come to in 1843, was > tnat certain vil- lages which had been placed under our management in 1835, snou lci be given back to Marwar, the State that claimed them. With us they prospered, and their revenue had nearly trebled ; but on their re-transfer, veri- fying the prophetic fears of Colonel Dixon, they deteriorated, the land relapsed into waste jungle, and many of the inhabitants migrated to within our jurisdiction. These villages, we have seen, fell away Our Rule in India. 117 from the advancement they had made under us. We have the cases of other Mair vil- lages, which, in our first arrangements, were left in the hands of the chiefs that claimed them, and which never attained to any ad- vancement. We speak of the villages on the western side of Mairwara. Thus it would appear, as far as these examples teach, that the native princes of India have little taste or talent for statesmanship, even while they see beside, and around them, the gains and the comforts of active rule. If, in despite of the enough that has been said, and of the more that might be added, the Mairs are to be indeed abandoned ; if sen- timental conciliation, and the cloud-capp'd principle of nationalities, are to be extended to the yet happy valleys of Mairwara, let them at least have that semblance of freedom — that nominis umbra which is implied in a plebiscite. Were such a course practicable, we are persuaded that no influence would avail to prevent their showing to all the world 1 1 8 The Story of Mairwara. what their feeling is, and that our Govern- ment would find itself compelled to protect them. If, however, transfer is their fate, abandonment their doom, their country will soon fall back into anarchy, and our conquest of 182 1 will have to be re-enacted. That accomplished, there will remain this disastrous difference between our present, and our future positions. The Mairs will no longer feel the enthusiastic attachment to English connection which actuates them now : they will have lost all faith in European justice, all trust in British truth. ... In now closing our case in behalf of the Mairs, we desire to submit it to the sure tribunal of public opinion, in the hope that, for the sake of our own fair fame, for the sake of our influence in India, for the sake of the Mairs — whom, up to this time, we have signally served — so fatal a measure as this dreaded transfer, may never be allowed to receive the sanction of any section of our Government ! Appendix A. 119 APPENDIX A. The Mairs face tigers with as much indifference as they would any domestic animal, and, with sword and shield, think themselves safe against man or beast. A few facts, out of many we have been supplied with, will show this. They are of no rare occurrence. A tiger came near a village, and seizing a dog ran off with it in his mouth. One of the inhabit- ants seeing this, ran after it, and struck it with a stick. The enraged animal dropped the dog, and flew at him. Another of the villagers came to his aid, and the tiger, dropping the first man, seized him. A third came and shared a like treatment, while the inhabitants, collecting to the number of fifteen, assailed the tiger with sticks, until he dropped the man and went off. The three men recovered from their wounds. A Mair, cutting wood on a hill, was snapped up by a tiger ; but, having a stick in his hand, he beat the animal so soundly about its head and ears, while 120 Appendix A. actually in his mouth, that the tiger was glad to let go his prey and escape. This poor man died of his wounds, after linger- ing for some time. Two Mairs were cutting grass, when one of them was snatched up by a tiger. His comrade pursued, and beat the animal until it let him go. The wounded man recovered. A cow having been killed by a tiger — a very common incident — a Mair lay in ambush all night with a loaded matchlock, with intent to kill him as he should come to feed again. The animal came, and was wounded by the matchlock-ball, but got off. Soon, however, some thirty or forty vil- lagers collecting, set off in pursuit of the abscond- ing tiger, and found him on a hill. He was assailed in various ways, and two or three of the villagers were severely wounded in the encounters. One, at length, went up singly, with his sword and shield, put the shield in the tiger's face, and inflicted two or three deadly wounds with the sword ; but we are sorry to add that the gallant fellow lost his own life. The villagers, wishing to recover their comrade from the grasp of the tiger, had resort to throwing stones ; but, perceiving that the animal was motion- less, they approached and found him lying dead, Appendix B. 121 with the bold Mair cruelly torn, but close beside him. These facts respecting tigers, were communicated to the author by General Hall. APPENDIX B. Victor Jacquemont, a distinguished naturalist and an accomplished traveller, was, at the instance of Baron Cuvier, sent by the French Government to visit India. Before entering on his voyage he came to London, and was given all the facilities which our public men and men of science could afford him. He made the tour of India, visited the Punjaub, crossed the Himalayas, entered China, and, re- turning, explored Cashmere, where he remained for five months. He had the advantage of being made known to Runjeet Singh — the Lion of Lahore — by General Allard, a French officer, who trained that monarch's soldiers to European drill. Runjeet Singh was so much attracted by his talents and acquire- ments, and impressed by his character, that he urged him to accept the appointment of Viceroy of Cashmere, with, what may be well called, a fabulous income. The offer does credit to Runjeet's sagacity ; but it was, unhappily, as we think, declined. 12 2 Appendix C. The wish expressed that Colonel Hall should be made King of Greece is playfully referred to by Lord Metcalfe, but was probably thought of in sober earnest by the young philosopher, who, as we have seen, had occasion to ponder well the subject of princely positions, and fairy-tale-like fortunes. Jacquemont was early lost to science, and to the many circles in which he was highly regarded. He died in India. A new edition of his Travels and Letters was brought out by c Michel Levy, Freres, Paris/ in the close of last year. APPENDIX C. The following tells of a new form of asking a favour : — Colonel Hall was alone, in his tent, without a defensive weapon, and with no one near him, when an armed brigand sprang in, and demanded pardon for all his past offences. c No,' said Colonel Hall ; c they are too great for that. All I shall grant you is one quarter of an hour to escape. After that I shall do my best to have you brought to punish- ment.' The robber, and the difficulty, disappeared at once. Appendices D and E. 123 APPENDIX D. Colonel C. J. Dixon, a native of Scotland, entered the army, and was appointed to the Bengal Artillery, in 18 1 2. He succeeded Colonel (now General) Hall, in 1835, as Superintendent, or Governor, of Mair- wara, and attained his rank of Colonel in 1854. He died in India in the early part of 1857, tne y ear of the Mutiny. He had thus been twenty-three years in India when he was nominated to the charge of Mairwara, and forty- five when his services were terminated by his death. APPENDIX E. General Henry Hall, C.B., of Knockbrack, County Galway, and Merville, County Dublin, is descended from a collateral branch of the family of Roger Hall, of Narrow Water, County Down, Ireland. He is the fourth son of the late Vene- rable Archdeacon Hall, by Christiana, daughter of — Trail, Esq., and was born in 1789. In 1827 he married Sarah, eldest daughter of the late General Fagan, Adjutant-General of the Bengal Army. 1 24 Appendix E General Hall entered the army in 1804, sailed for India in 1805, an d arrived in Calcutta on his seventeenth birthday. He was sent on at once to Cawnpore, where he was placed under the command of Captain Delamaine. On the first introduction of Light Infantry into the Bengal Army, Captain Dela- maine gave young Hall the command of the light company of his regiment. At the close of 1806 he was sent, with his regiment, on service in Bundel- cund, where they formed part of a force which was destined to complete the subjugation of that country. The district was studded with forts, to the number of four-and-twenty, each with its independent chief. After taking two minor forts, they attacked a third, which presented serious difficulties, and where they lost two of their officers, and put about three hundred men to the sword. Captain Delamaine received a wound in the head, which ultimately led to his death. After this, Lieutenant Hall was appointed adjutant of his battalion, and was ordered to Benares. Thence he proceeded again to Bundelcund, and was engaged in the reduction of forts. One of these, built on the summit of a hill some eight hundred feet high, was regarded as very formidable. Before, however, they had reached it, they had to attack a fortified position named Regoulee, where they found a much stronger force than they had counted on, advantage- Appendix E. 125 ously placed. Hall led the assault up a steep ascent, with much gallantry, and had a ball through his hat. Soon after this, the fortress, which they thought would give them so much trouble, unexpectedly surrendered, and their campaign was for a while broken up. In 18 17, Captain Hall, having filled with credit several staff appointments, was nominated, by the Marquis of Hastings, to the Ouartermaster-Gene- raFs Department, and joined a force, which, under the command of Sir David Ochterlony, was pro- ceeding against the Pindarees, whose subjugation was, in the result, effected. In consequence of the absence of his senior, Captain Hall had, at this time, the advantage of being led into direct communication with the General. Their next exploit was to reduce the hill-fortress of Paragur, at Ajmeer, which was regarded as well nigh impregnable. They had further to put down some troublesome chiefs in the Jeypore States, whose towns and forts they captured. Captain Hall received, for his services on these occasions, the marked thanks of the General. Captain Hall was next directed to join Brigadier Knox, at Ajmeer, where he had to lay out the largest cantonment then in India. His senior officer 126 Appendix E. having been removed to another station, Captain Hall was left at the head of his department in Rajpoo- tana. While there, he employed himself in making surveys of the country. Next came his active efforts for the reduction of the Mairs, and, subse- quently, his appointment as Commissioner, Super- intendent, or Governor of Mairwara. This was in 1822, and from that period, until his departure from India in 1835, his life is part of the history of that country, as we have sketched it in our text. Meagre as this summary of General Hall's services must be, we ought not to omit stating that his name was publicly noticed on many occasions — on the occasion, for example, of the attack on Regoulee, and at the siege of Adjeehur in 1809, at Callingur in 18 12, at Modherajpoona and Neepreeda in Raj- pootana in 18 18, and in a short campaign in Mair- wara in 18 19, besides the first campaign there, before adverted to. We must add that he volun- teered to conduct one of the columns in the night- attack on Modherajpoona, and that his name ap- peared in the c London Gazette ' of the following dates, as well as in those of other dates not men- tioned: 'London Gazette,' August 7, 18 19, pp. 1388-1389 j March 20, 1822, p. 490; March 24, 1823, pp. 479-480. General Hall thus served in India for thirty-two Appendix E. 127 years. He was made a C.B. in 1838, and became Lieutenant-General in 1858. He is a magistrate for the counties of Galway and Dublin. We have taken the particulars of the family of General Hall, from a work entitled c The County Families of the United Kingdom,' and those of his military services, chiefly from a printed document, which had to be laid before the late East India Company. Jacquemont, after observing that there were c few Major Halls to work the miracles he has done,' adds, in another letter, that ' a peculiar talent, too, which is a gift of nature, is required in the ruler, without which the most benevolent intentions would prove useless.' This just remark appears to be illustrated in the character and career of General Hall, whose talents for government 2 re, in fact, part and parcel of his nature. In advanced life, and amid the bereavements which render it so solitary, and so deeply sad, he retains and exhibits the energy, the assiduity, the benevolence, the active benefi- cence, and the unfailing judgment which, in other days, achieved for him such great results in India. At the age of eighty, he is one of the most effective magistrates of his neighbourhood, and the chief man of business of many institutions, committees, and public societies. He is a regular attendant at 1 2 8 Appendix F. the Poor-house, some miles' distance from his resi- dence, and takes a lead in the management of its details, and a personal interest in the boys' and girls' schools, giving them frequent prizes to stimulate their progress. On his estates in the West of Ire- land, he shows the same capacity as marked his Mairwara days, and is the generous promoter. of advancement in every form — in agriculture, in education, in the promotion of religious objects ; and, amidst these many activities, never forgetting the interests of that far-off Indian people, who have now, for forty long years, looked up to him, and will ever continue to regard him, as their first re- former, and their great benefactor. APPENDIX F. Remarks,* by General Hall, on perusing the article, on the subject of Mairwara, in the c Dublin Univer- sity Magazine' for July 1853 : — The observations contained in this Sketch of Mairwara, as to the injustice done to General Hall, are generally correct ; but he is convinced, without * These Remarks were printed some years ago, for pri- vate circulation. As they refer, partly, to a matter of much public interest, the abolition of Female Infanticide, they are, with General Hall's permission, now added. Appendix F. 129 any intention, either on the part of Colonel Dixon, or the reviewers adverted to. It is obvious enough that Colonel Dixon must have compiled the work, as ordered by Government, under the serious disadvantage of great pressure in the carrying on of his current business, and without an opportunity of revisal, preparatory to its going to press. The length of time which intervened between General Hall's relinquishment of office, and Colonel Dixon's compilation, must have contributed much to the apparent intermixture of their respective labours. But the very complimentary manner in which Colonel Dixon so frequently refers to his prede- cessor, together with the frank acknowledgment contained in the few lines (p. 81 of the Review), that c whatever may have been efFected in amelio- rating the condition of the people, or in advancing them in the arts of civilised life, it is to Colonel Hall that the credit is due, for having laid the foundation of these good works,' clearly indicates the absence of all intentional misrepresentation. The fact however is, as the reviewer states, that from the nature of Colonel Dixon's statements, any- one cursorily reading the compilation would infer that he had been the originator of the highly im- portant undertaking of irrigation, in all its branches, 130 Appendix F. though the most decided proof to the contrary is contained in the work ; and even one of the lakes (Gohana), constructed by General Hall, was selected by the Governor of Agra, for the publication, and appears there in full, with drawings. Captain Baird Smith calls it, in his work on irri- gation, c A very beautiful lake, securing 250 acres of cultivation, giving food and occupation to fifty- nine families, and amply repaying the State's out- lay.' * More need not be said for the prqsent purpose ; for such ample testimony, afforded so many years after General Hall's labours had terminated, must be quite conclusive of his having established the system, and procured to the Supreme Government its great advantages, thus enabling his successors to proceed with well-assured and rapid success ; and though General Hall's time was so much occu- pied with all the preliminary rough work, his mea- sures for irrigation were not slow, considering the circumstances in which he was placed. The approbation of Government was to be gained — success to be rendered certain ; the supply to keep pace with the demand, rather than all at once (even if he could) to have run into a large expenditure, which could not be remunerative until long after ; * 'Italian Irrigation/ vol. 1. p. 418. Appendix F. 131 besides reserving at command the means of affording employment to the people, in times of scarcity or famine. As carried out, in some instances, the expense was covered by the increase of revenue the first year, and it contributed most materially to the relief of multitudes, during one of the most severe famines that, perhaps, ever visited any country, completely destroying the food of both man and beast. No one can be more ready to acknowledge the admirable manner in which Colonel Dixon has car- ried on his duties, than General Hall, and, in fact, his feelings towards him are of a most grateful nature, on that account ; nor does he make these observations in the way of complaint, nor would he ever have commented on these errors, had they not been rendered prominent by the notice in the c Dublin University Magazine.' As General Hall never contemplated his exertions in Mairwara becoming public, he would be wanting in the ordinary feelings of human nature, were he not much gratified at his measures, and their results, being so favourably noticed. His abolition of female infanticide, alone, saved numbers of lives annually, and Mr. Kaye* pro- * See Mr. Kaye's very valuable work, ' The History of the Administration of the East India Company,' pp. 563-4. 132 Appendix F. nounced it as the c only instance on record of com- plete success/ but with some infelicity of remark detracts from his merits, by ascribing it to a simple municipal regulation. Now, this was far from being the case : it cost him very great preparatory exertion, in order to effect it through the people themselves, being satis- fied that by no other means could permanent results be reckoned upon. Prohibitory orders would have been useless, as proof could rarely, if ever, be obtained, when all were united in keeping up the practice. No medical men could be scattered through such an extent of country; nor can corpses remain unburied,to await examination from a distance. It was by gaining the confidence of the people, working upon their feelings in various ways, dis- covering and showing them the causes of the cus- tom, and how easily they could be removed, to the great future benefit of the community at large ; by noticing occasionally female children, and appealing to parental affection, that all were eventually con- vinced, and won over to a general consent; so that, so far from the abolition of infanticide being the re- sult of a merely municipal regulation, the latter only gave effect to a long course of anxious preliminary measures, bearing on the wished-for result. Appendix F. 133 In conclusion, it must be admitted to add not a little to his satisfaction, that while General Hall was simply carrying on his unpretending duties, he has in some degree contributed to do justice to the Indian Government, by exhibiting the advantages of its administration to the great country confided to its charge. P.S. — It is a most interesting and important fact, that the fidelity of the Mair troops and people, contributed wonderfully to the safety of the Euro- pean community, when the mutiny broke out at Nusseerabad. The city of Ajmeer stands in re- lation to the country, as the city of Delhi stood to its neighbourhood. The former, as well as the latter, had a treasury, a well-stocked magazine, jail, &c, &c, and all defended by a wall and bastions. There were 250 of the Mair corps there ; the mutinous sepoys, only ten miles distant, tried to seduce them, but happily failed, and thus was Ajmeer preserved from becoming a second Delhi. On that dreadful occasion, all the European families found refuge in the cities of Ajmeer and Beawr, the head-quarters of the corps ! On a subsequent occasion, the Mair corps distinguished themselves against the mutineers, under Brigadier- General (now Sir G. St. P.) Lawrence. 134 Appendix F. Colonel Dixon died in the year of the Mutiny (1857), but before the outbreak. It is only justice to his memory to say, that had he not retained the confidence of the Mairs, and kept up the efficiency of the Mair Battalion, Mair- wara, Ajmeer, and the whole of Rajpootana, would have been in rebellion against us. H. HALL, General. LONDON: PRINTED BY SPOTTISWOODE AND CO., NBW -STREET SQUARE AND PARLIAMENT STREET ' ^ UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LIBRARY BERKELEY Return to desk from which borrowed. This book is DUE on the last date stamped below. APR 7'65 4f»M ) 21— 100m— 11 '49 (B7146sl6)476 r Yb 28467 512986 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LIBRARY