4? ^ "" Haitt^ y 0AH THE LIBRARY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LOS ANGELES INV-SOI^ %H3 :ALIFO^ ^ 1L & o & ^EUN'IVER% ^ N PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSK.I. M E M O I B S OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI AND HIS forty ^teafor I. DOCUMENTS RELATIVE TO THE PRINCE'S NEGOTIATIONS WITH PITT, FOX, AND BROUGHAM, AND AN ACCOUNT OF HIS CONVERSA- TIONS WITH LORD PALMERSTON AND OTHER ENGLISH STATESMEN IN LONDON IN 1832 EDITED BY ADAM GIELGUD TWO VOL U M ES WITH PORTRAITS VOL. I SECOND EDITION REMINGTON & CO., PUBLISHERS HENRIETTA STREET, COVENT GARDEN 1888 ALL RIGHTS RESERVKD EBRATA In pages IS and If), for "\Volocxyn, rend Wolczyn. In the footnote to page 73, for 1795, read 1794. In the footnote to page 74,/-/?' 1434, rend 1595. In page 151, line 11, for Wiszniowiec, read Wisniowiec : and in line 13. far Wiszniowiecki, read Wisniowiecki. In page 152, line 5. and the footnote, for Wiszniowiecki, raid Wisnio- wiecki. In the footnote to page 152. for 1(575, rnttl 1(>73. In jiage 170, line 27, for 1793, read 1798. In the footnote to page 183, introduce the word* and at Narva after v.-here. [An Alphabetical Index to this work will be found at end of Second Volume .] College Library DK 435.5* 228 . / -~f.oo.5~*- PREFACE .......... vii CHAPTER I INTRODUCTORY TO THE MEMOIRS ..... I CHAPTER II 1776-1782 EARLY YOUTH. FAMILY RECOLLECTIONS. LIFE IN A POLISH COUNTRY- HOUSE. PRINCES AND PRINCESSES ON THE STAGE. A CRIMINAL PRIEST. THE POLISH DIET . . . . . . 17 CHAPTER III 1783 JOURNEY TO VOLHYNIA AND PODOLIA. INTERVIEW WITH FREDERICK THE GREAT ........ 33 1142108 iv CONTENTS CHAPTER IV 1784-1787 PULAWY. EDUCATION AND STUDIES . . . . . 42 CHAPTER V 1786 A HOLIDAY IN GERMANY. WIELAND. GOETHE. A POLISH CARNIVAL. VISITS TO ENGLAND ....... 44 CHAPTER VI 1794-1795 JOURNEY TO ST PETERSBURG. LEADING PERSONAGES IN RUSSIAN SOCIETY UNDKR THE EMPRESS CATHERINE. THE ZUBOFFS. CATHERINE. HER COURT. THE YOUNG PRINCES ENTER THE RUSSIAN SERVICE ....... 55 CHAPTER VII 1796 CONVERSATIONS WITH ALEXANDER. STAY AT TSARSKOE-SELO. RELATIONS BETWEEN THE GRAND-DUKE PAUL AND HIS SONS. BIRTH OP NICHOLAS . . . . . . . 109 CHAPTER VIII 1796 THE PATE OP THE PRISONERS. REFLECTIONS ON ALEXANDER'S EDU- CATION. ARRIVAL OF THE KING OF SWEDEN. FAILURE OF THE NEGOTIATIONS FOR HIS MARRIAGE WITH THE GRAND-DUCHESS ALEXANDRA. DEATH OF CATHERINE. . . . . 127 CONTENTS v CHAPTER IX 1796-1798 ACCESSION OF PAUL I. HIS CHARACTER. ARRIVAL OP KING STANIS- LAS AUGUSTUS. THE EMPEROR'S CORONATION AT MOSCOW. A POLISH ENVOY TO ENGLAND. PRINCE ADAM'S RELATIONS WITH ALEXANDER. COUNT STROGONOFF AND M. DE NOVOSILTZOFF. PROPOSED ANNEXATION OF GALICIA TO HUNGARY. DEATH OF STANISLAS AUGUSTUS. PRINCE VOLKONSKY. PRINCE GALITZIN. AN IMPERIAL PROGRESS TO KAZAN. A PALACE PLOT. RUSSIA, ENGLAND, AND MALTA. PITT AND ROSTOPCHIN. EUROPEAN COALITION AGAINST FRANCE . . . . . I (JO CHAPTER X 1798-9 STAY AT VIENNA. THE GRAND-DUKE CONSTANTINE. POZZO DI BORGO AND THE BRITISH GOVERNMENT. THE KING OF SARDINIA. ALFIERI. QUARREL BETWEEN RUSSIA AND AUSTRIA. RAPPROCHE- MENT WITH FRANCE. THE NEAPOLITAN COURT. A RUSSIAN LOTHARIO . . . . . . . . . 198 CHAPTER XI 1801 ASSASSINATION OF THE EMPEROR PAUL .... 223 CHAPTER XII 1801-2 MY RELATIONS WITH ALEXANDER. THE SECRET COUNCIL. EUROPEAN COALITION AGAINST ENGLAND. THE DON COSSACKS MARCH UPON INDIA. NELSON'S BOMBARDMENT OF COPENHAGEN. ARRANGE- MENT BETWEEN RUSSIA AND ENGLAND. MISSION FROM NAPOLEON TO ALEXANDER. ALEXANDER'S CORONATION. INTERVIEW BE- TWEEN ALEXANDER AND FREDERICK WILLIAM III AT MEMEL. THE STROGONOFFS. THE VORONTZOFFS. PLANS OF REFORM. MY APPOINTMENT AS ASSISTANT FOREIGN MINISTER OF RUSSIA. STATE OF EDUCATION IN RUSSIA . . . . . . 256 vi CONTENTS CHAPTER XIII 1803-4 DIFFERENCES WITH SWEDEN. THE CHANCELLOR VORONTZOFF's POLICY. THE FOREIGN AMBASSADORS AUSTRIA, PRUSSIA, ENGLAND, FRANCE, AND SWEDEN. ALEXANDER^ PROFESSED LIBERALISM PUT TO THE TEST. HIS FOREIGN POLICY AND THAT OF NAPO- LEON. PRINCE CZARTORYSKI BECOMES UNPOPULAR AT COURT. A DUEL. THE CHANCELLOR'S ILLNESS. NAPOLEON AND THE RUSSIAN AMBASSADOR 313 PREFACE PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI has long -been known, and is perhaps still remembered, in England as the friend of Earl Grey, Lord Brougham, and other leading English statesmen of the time of the first Reform Bill, and as the representative and champion of his unhappy country during the thirty years which he passed in exile. His Memoirs,* the greater part of which were written from his dictation in occasional hours of leisure in Paris, end at the battle of Austerlitz ; they give vivid pictures of the life of the Polish aristocracy dur- ing the latter part of the eighteenth century, of the Court of the Empress Catherine, of the assassination of the Emperor Paul, and of the character of Alexander I, * A French edition, with a preface by M. Charles de Mazade, of the French Academy, was published in Paris in May, 18S7 by M. M. Plon, Nourrit, & Co. viii PREFACE who had made Prince Adam his Minister and con- fidential friend. Of the remainder of his busy and eventful life no detailed history has yet appeared. It is not attempted in the present work to furnish such a history, but only to supplement the Memoirs by diplomatic papers, and other matter hitherto unpub- lished, which are of especial interest to an English reader. The documents and extracts from private letters and diaries have been copied or translated from the originals in the archives of the Czartoryski family, the introductory chapter is based on facts taken from the late M. B. Zaleski's excellent biography of the Prince, unfortunately unfinished, and the account of his stay in England after the collapse of the Polish Revolution of 1830-1 is derived from a manuscript work now in preparation, which has been kindly placed at my disposal by M. L. de Gadon, secretary to Prince Ladislas Czartoryski, the son of Prince Adam and the present head of the family. In order to elucidate the text, the Memoirs and other papers have been arranged in order of date, and are connected by a brief narrative of the incidents to which they refer, thus presenting, it is hoped, a clear, if incomplete, survey of the career of a statesman whose distinguished abilities, lofty virtue, and ever-fervent patriotism mark him out as one of the noblest and most striking figures of the century. A. G. JHtmoirs of prince Jltmm QUariorgsfei CHAPTER I INTRODUCTORY TO THE MEMOIRS. THE Czartoryskis come of an old Lithuanian family, related to the royal dynasty of the Jagiellons. In 1569, John and Alexander Czartoryski took a promi- nent part in bringing about the union of Poland with Lithuania, and during the seventeenth century various other members of the family distinguished themselves by their valour in battle and their ability a,s politicians and churchmen, but it did not attain the height of its celebrity until the middle of the eighteenth centur}^ when, in the words of Mickiewicz, it became the only private family in Europe that had a political history. The heads of the house were at that time the Princes Michael and Augustus. Michael, the eldest, a man of remarkable talents and energy, received an excellent training in statesmanship under his friend Count Fleming, the Minister of King Augustus II, and VOL. I. A 2 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI rapidly rose to a position of almost unexampled in- fluence among his countrymen. Augustus, his brother, proud and reserved in character, but ambitious and passionate, chose the military career. He became a Knight of Malta, and took part in the capture of Belgrade under Prince Eugene, who presented him with a sword of honour in recognition of his bravery on the occasion. In 1729, he became a Major-General in the Polish army, and in 1731, after a duel with one of his rivals for the hand of Madame Denhoff, a lady of rare intelligence and immense wealth, she selected him out of a crowd of suitors, among whom were various foreign princes, such as the Duke of Braganza, the Prince of Charolais, and the Duke of Holstein. Prince Augustus thus became one of the wealthiest men in Europe, and by good management he not only paid the debts on his wife's estates, but doubled her income. At the end of the first year after their marriage, he sent to her a number of boxes full of gold pieces, representing the revenue from her estates, which she at once ordered to be returned to him ; and this ceremony was repeated annually during the forty years of their married life. When Augustus III was called to the Polish throne in 1741, Poland was enjoying the blessings of peace, while the surrounding countries were desolated with the conflicts of hostile armies ; and her people presented all the outward signs of prosperity. But as a State she was powerless. In some countries it is a frequent subject of complaint that the people do riot take sufficient interest or part in politics, and that the Government consequently falls into the hands of pro- INTRODUCTORY 3 fessional politicians. In Poland, not to take part in public life was regarded almost as a crime. Nearly every voter* was an active politician ; but this pro- duced an exaggerated sense of the importance of individuals in the State. Each man had his own opinions, and refused to be bound by those of others ; the liberum veto, originating in times when the principle of government by majority had not yet been discovered, was regarded as a palladium of liberty. Under such circumstances government was impos- sible. t The Diets had repeatedly to be dissolved with- out passing the measures necessary for administration, and a wide field was opened for the intrigues of foreign powers and ambitious magnates, especially as the old principle of elective monarchy was still retained. The two Czartoryski princes set themselves to the task of restoring order in this chaos, of combining and directing the national forces which were dissipating themselves in futile individual effort, and of enabling Poland to resume her position among the independent States of Europe. But the difficulty of the task was greatly increased by the fact that the Poles did not see their * It is a common mistake among Englishmen to talk of Poland as ' an aristocratic republic. ' The so-called nobles did not form an aristocracy in our sense of the term, but consisted of all those who had political privileges. In the eighteenth century they numbered one-fifth of the population a proportion considerably greater than that of the electorate to the population in England, even after the first Reform Bill. t Another cause of the weakness of Poland as a State is thus indicated by Mr Lecky (History of England in the Eighteenth Century, vol. vi. chap. xxii. p. 104) : ' The objects of Governments are not only various, but in some measure incompatible, and the Dutch constitution, like the old constitutions of Poland, being mainly con- structed with the object of opposing obstacles to the encroachments of the central power, had left the country wholly incapable of prompt and energetic action in times of public danger. No augmentation of the military or naval forces, no serious measure of defence, could be effected without the separate assent of all the provinces, and the forms that were required by law were so numerous and so cumbrous that it was probably chiefly its more favourable geographical position that saved the United Provinces from the fate of Poland. ' 4 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI danger and did nothing to second the efforts which were made to save them. The princes began by associating with them in the execution of their plan some of the younger and more active members of the great Polish families the Oginskis, the Poniatowskis, and the Zamoyskis. They thus formed a strong party in the country, which by its wealth and influence was able to give effective support to the Government and to check the flood of anarchy which was rapidly undermining the State. In the midst of the general indolence and disorganisa- tion, people looked up with respectful awe to these self-denying patriots who, in the midst of wealth and luxury, devoted their days and nights to the improve- ment of the administration and the strengthening of the position of their country with regard to foreign powers. Not content with being themselves hard workers in the cause, the two princes selected a number of intelligent and able young men whom they trained at their own expense, both at home and abroad, for the various branches of the public service. Their object was, above all things, to establish a strong and orderly government in Poland, and their own conduct of affairs was a model on a small scale of such a government. With their immense wealth and extensive social relations all over the country, they constantly stepped in to remedy the defects of the existing system, protecting the poor and weak against the rich, coming forward as the champions of order in the midst of the incessant conflict of opinion in the Diets, and setting an example of steady work and high political aims. This naturally excited the jealousy INTRODUCTORY 5 and alarm of other great Polish families, such as the Potockis and the Radziwills ; but they persistently carried out their scheme of action in the face of all obstacles. Foreign alliances at that time took a very different shape from what they do at present. In 1746 Eng- land, Austria and Russia were combined against Frederick the Great, who was supported by France and Turkey. The Czartoryskis sided with the former powers, the Potockis with the latter. Poland had sunk into such a state of anarchy that no Polish statesman could gain any great influence among his countrymen unless he had the support of some foreign ambassador, and it was therefore necessary for the Czartoryskis to declare themselves openly as the partisans of one of the great powers which struggled with each other for leadership in the moribund Polish State, especially as the King himself, alarmed at their steadfast and uncompromising honesty, had gone over to the side of Prussia and France. This was the beginning of the alliance of the Czartoryskis with Russia an alliance into which they entered with the best of motives, but which had the most disastrous consequences. The first fruit of the alliance was the mission of Stanislas Augustus Poniatowski, the nephew of the Czartoryski princes, to the Russian Court in the capacity of secretary to Sir Hanbury Williams, the British Ambassador. Poniatowski, young, handsome, and with all the accomplishments of a courtier, speedily gained the favour of the Grand- Duchess, afterwards Empress, Catherine, and this greatly strengthened the position of the Czartoryskis 6 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI at the Russian Court. Finding themselves abandoned by the King, they looked more and more to St Petersburg for support, and the accession to the Russian throne of the Empress Catherine in 1762 seemed at length to hold out a prospect of the realisa- tion of their hopes. In a long letter announcing the event to Poniatowski, she informed him that she would at once send Count Keyserling to Warsaw to make Poniatowski King after the death of the reigning sovereign ; or, if this should not be possible, to endea- vour to obtain the election to the throne of Prince Adam Casimir Czartoryski, the son of Prince Augustus and the father of the writer of the following Memoirs.* Catherine was thought at that time to be a sovereign of liberal ideas, who would give her people a constitution, and would introduce a new era of freedom and universal justice. These illusions were so general that even such experienced and sagacious politicians as the Czartoryski princes were deceived by them ; they thought that the regeneration of Poland, for which they had worked thirty years, was at hand. But King Augustus's favourite Minister, Brlml, did his utmost to foil their plans. The chief dignities in the country were taken from the Czartoryskis and their adherents and given to their adversaries, and scandalous scenes were got up in the Diets with the object of decrying thorn in the eyes of the public.! * ' J'envoie incessamment le Comte Keyserling ambassadeur en Pologne pour vous faire roi, apres le deces de celui-ci, et en cas qu'il ne puisse re"ussir pour vous, qxie ce soit le Prince Adam.' Memoires de Stanislas Auguste Pouiatowski et sa corres- pondance avec Catherine II. Posen, 1862. t The following letter, of which there is a copy in the Czartoryski archives, was addressed on this subject by the Empress Catherine to her ambassador Count Keyserling : ' M. le Comte de Keyserling : Je viens d'apprendre que la diete en Pologne est rompue et que vos amis ont pense" etre massacres. Je vous recommande INTRODUCTORY ^ This brought matters to a crisis. The two heads of o the Czartoryski family were growing old, and Catherine was showing an inclination to conclude an alliance with Frederick the Great ; it seemed to them that if they did not at once take decisive action, all the fruit of their life-labour might be lost. The occasion was afforded by the candidature of Prince Charles of Saxony, the favourite son of the King of Poland, for the dukedom of Courland. The Russian candidate, Biron, was supported by the Czartoryskis, but the majority of the senate declared itself in favour of Prince Charles, and a note asserting his claims and in- timating doubts as to the legitimacy of Catherine was addressed by the Ministry to the Russian ambassador. This was equivalent to a rupture with Russia, and the Czartoryskis proposed to Catherine that they should form an armed confederacy, not against the King of Poland, but against his Minister Bruhl, recalling the words of the Due de Gramont to Louis XIV : ' We make war against Cardinal Mazarin, but we serve your Majesty.' The confederacy was to take the government of the country into its own hands, restore order and reform abuses, and after the death of Augustus III give up the throne to a prince whose election should be agreeable to Russia. In order to avoid a civil war, the Czartoryskis asked that Russia should send an overwhelming force into the country to support them, and in return they promised to recognise Catherine as Empress of Russia, d'offrir tout mon appui aux princes Czartoryski et a leurs amis et de ne rien negliger en tout ce qui leur peut procurer surete, appui, et profit. Je vous fais cette lettre a ce sujet, vous assurant d'ailleurs de mon affection. Moscou, ce 13 Octob. 1762. Catherine. ' 8 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI and Biron as Duke of Courland ; to regulate the frontier between Poland and Russia ; and to give the Empress satisfaction for the insult which had been inflicted upon her. That the Czartoryskis, mistaken and disastrous as their policy has proved, were sincere in their professions of disinterestedness and wished only for the good of their country, was uni- versally acknowledged at the time, and even Herr Benoit, the Prussian Ambassador, wrote to Frederick the Great that ' they were too patriotic to seek the throne for themselves so long as Augustus III was alive, and only thought of the regeneration of their country.' Their only object was to establish a strong arid orderly system of government in Poland ; and finding that they could not obtain sufficient support for carrying out this object among their own country- men, they unhappily trusted in the apparent liberalism and justice of the young Empress of Russia. The hesitation of Catherine, and the death of Augustus III in 1763, necessarily postponed the execution of their projects. The Empress, who had been gradually entering into friendly relations with Frederick the Great, wrote to him that she agreed in his opinion that the crown of- Poland should not be retained by the House of Saxony, and that it should be given to a Pole ; and she suggested that Poniatowski should be elected king, as having the least right to the crown, he would be most under obligation to the two powers that helped him to it. Frederick readily consented, and a treaty was accord- ingly concluded between the two sovereigns binding them to joint action with regard to Poland. This INTRODUCTORY 9 alliance opened the eyes of the Czartoryskis to the danger which threatened their country : their nephew Poniatowski was fully aware of their plans and had so far supported them, but he was totally unfitted to occupy the throne of Poland at so critical a period of her fortunes, and it seemed only too evident that Russia and Prussia intended to use him merely as a tool for establishing their influence in Poland and perhaps destroying her independence. What they most dreaded, however, was a civil war, which they were convinced could only precipitate the dangers by which Poland was threatened ; and they accordingly persisted in the course of policy on which they had started. When the Diet was convoked they came supported by a large Russian force ; their opponents protested, and left the House ; and the Czartoryskis at once took the opportunity of introducing the reforms for which they had laboured so long. The system under which the high State dignitaries were indepen- dent of each other and of the King, which was one of the chief causes of the anarchy into which Poland had fallen, was abolished, and replaced by an organisation of Ministers appointed by the sovereign and responsible to the Diet ; all classes of the population were made equal before the law ; and a multitude of smaller reforms, all in the same spirit of liberty and order, became part of the Polish constitution. Rulhiere, the historian of the Saxon party, could not restrain his admiration at the Czartoryskis having ' in six weeks carried out reforms which the French., kings had only executed in six centuries.'* * Histoire o ALFIEKI 209 to declaim aloud verses from his tragedies without paying the slightest attention to passers-by or to the objects which surrounded him. In the evening he looked tired and exhausted, and directly he returned from his rambles he used to sit down to a game of chess. His youth had been, as he himself says in his memoirs, a very stormy one. It was Madame d' Albany, to whom he was warmly attached, who had advised him to write the tragedies and other works which even during his lifetime had rained him a c> o great reputation. Some years before I had met him in Paris. At first he was an ardent admirer of the principles of the French Revolution, but afterwards, disgusted by its excesses, he looked upon France with horror, and devoted all his zeal to the cause of King Emmanuel, strongly blaming himself for not having been constantly faithful to it. When some years later a sudden illness had deprived him of the means of con- tinuing his usual walks, he concluded that he would soon die, and he passed away in a few days. He was a man of great merit, and looked upon events from a truly elevated point of view ; but he was the slave of an exalted imagination, and was subject to illusions. The inertia into which the Sardinian Court and the society of Florence were plunged, was too monotonous to be interesting ; the days followed each other without bringing anything new. Under these circumstances I decided to go to Pisa to see M. Francis Rzewuski, formerly Marshal of the Polish Court. He was a friend of my parents, and I and my mother had lived in his house during our stay in Paris. He received me with great cordiality, though VOL. i. o 210 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI he was in pain ; he had already been attacked by the malady which ended in his death. He was very impatient as regards suffering, and always relieved it by taking opium. He did this with the approval of a physician who was a professor in the university of Pisa ; but there is no doubt that by taking so much opium he hastened his end, and that it did not prevent him from suffering horribly. We had known and loved M. Rzewuski since we were children. He always had some sweets for us, and we used often to go from Powonski to his house at Marimont, which he had fitted up with much luxury and taste. He was a man full of good qualities amiable, beneficent, scrupulously honest, but too fond of ease ; he was generous and a great nobleman in the true sense of the word, of a race which is now extinct. Sometimes he would not show himself to his guests, though he treated them with munificent hospitality. When he was in good health he liked to come down to his meals, and was very fond of conversation, which he made very interesting by relating a number of anecdotes. One of these referred to his stay at St Petersburg. He had been sent there by the King after his accession, and was on very friendly terms with Count Pariin, Chancellor of the Empire, and tutor to the Grand- Duke Paul. Being one day at the Count's house he took the young prince on his knees, when the latter had a fit. 'I was never so frightened in my life,' he said, ' and I took good care not to play again with this sickly child, who might have died in my arms.' He knew all the scandalous gossip of Warsaw and St Petersburg by heart, and was much attached to the ROME 211 King, though after being for a long time his Minister he at once abandoned the Court when he perceived that the King was not faithful to his engagements. I profited by my leisure at Florence in visiting the masterpieces of art in the galleries, and in studying the Italian language. I read Dante with a priest who was remarkable for his extreme cowardice, and was constantly repeating the expression ' ho paura/ which at that time people were not ashamed to use. The Italians have greatly changed since then. This tranquil and monotonous existence lasted all the winter ; in the spring people's faces began to lengthen, they talked in whispers, and signs of great anxiety followed the placid security of the previous months. At length we all had the news of the cross- ing of the Alps by Buonaparte and of the battle of Marengo and its results. Sommariva disappeared with his troops, and the King of Sardinia with all his Court, myself included, hastily packed our things to go to Rome. o The impression produced by the sight of Rome, when one comes there for the first time, is indefinable. One gathers together all one's recollections, one O O ' strives to remember all one has learnt, read, and heard of this ancient capital of the world, and to com- bine all these echoes of the soul to make them more sonorous. It is difficult to realise the idea that you are really at the spot where such great events have occurred, that you tread the soil trodden by such great men. At the age especially when one has just completed the study of the classic writers who tell you what has passed and give you the names of those 212 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI who have lived at Rome, the very name of the Holy City raises up a multitude of thoughts. You do not see things as they really are, but by a magical effect of imagination you see them as they were formerly ; the present puts on the pomp and the colours of the past. Directly I had alighted from my carriage I hurried to the Capitol and the Palatine Hill. I could not subdue my impatience I could not sufficiently occupy my eyes and my imagination with the sight of the places which had witnessed such great actions. 1 Is it possible,' I said to myself, ' that it was here that lived the Scipios, the Catos, the Gracchi, the CaBsars, that it was here that Cicero thundered and that Horace sang ? ' and I recalled to my memory all that had since my infancy been the object of my admiration and my sympathies, all that history and the poets had taught me. I regret much that at the time of which I am speaking the Christian antiquities of Rome did not interest me as greatly as they do now ; all my dreams were only of heroic but pagan Rome. Penetrated with these grandeurs of the past, I thought of nothing else during my stay in the Holy City. I determined to visit every trace of its antiquity, and by examining the ruins and studying all that had been written on the streets and buildings of ancient Rome, to construct the plan of the city as it appeared at different epochs. My idea was to make not only general plans, but a series of drawings of portions of Rome, such as the Tiber, the seven hills, arid the edifices built upon them, so far as imagination can picture them beginning with the first foundation of Rome on the Palatine hill and the Capitol, then show- BO ME 213 ing her as she was under the Kings and in the various phases of the Republic, when she was still built of brick, and finally under Augustus, when she became a city of marble. Each of these drawings was to repre- sent something characteristic of the epoch. The above plan, which to me was new, had been conceived by others, but it has never been thoroughly executed. The drawings representing the open spaces, the temples, and the forts of the city divided into seventeen districts (regioni) occupied me during the whole period of my stay. I wished my work to be exact and con- scientious, and to make it so required much time, expense, and research. It was necessary to consult a multitude of authors, to check their statements, to employ antiquaries, architects and draughtsmen. I did not finish the work ; all I could do was to begin it. I had a very good plan and two water-colour drawings made of the city. One represented the Forum as it was at the time of the Republic, with a crowd of people opposite the Palatine hill, as was usual in stormy times ; an orator above the rostra ; and the via sacra with the edifice where the voting was to take place. The other drawing, which was of large size, also represented the Forum, but on the side opposite the Capitol. The subject was the triumph of Germanicus. All the temples on the slope of the Capitoline hill were there, and Tiberius, his face dis- torted with hatred and rage, was represented as coming out of one of them accompanied by the members of the Senate. A third drawing, which I ordered to be made during my absence, was to repre- sent the grottoes on the Tiber near the Palatine hill 214 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI during the first period after the foundation of Rome ; but it did not in any way carry out my idea. My enforced absence from my country, my family, and my friends, and the fact that my position was un- congenial and without aim, plunged me into a sort of lethargy similar to that which had oppressed me on my first arrival at St Petersburg, and the gravest and most unexpected events could not rouse me. During the whole of my life the sole motive of my actions has always been one exclusive and dominating senti- ment the love of my country. That which did not in some way promote the welfare of my fatherland or of my fellow-countrymen had no value in my eyes, while the most futile matters relating to Poland interested me. Thus at Warsaw there was a good French theatre and a very indifferent Polish one ; yet I went to the latter much oftener than to the former. The period of my stay in Rome was, however, by no means barren of events. Pius VI, who had been elected Pope at Venice, entered the Holy City while it was still suffering from the excesses committed by the French troops. I recollect that at a reception of Romans and foreigners at the house of Monsignor Consalvi, who had just been promoted cardinal, the Russian Consul, wishing to pay him a compliment, awkwardly predicted that he would become Pope, and that Consalvi very sincerely protested against the idea. I may say in passing that in my official reports I did not hesitate to censure the French for their conduct. This seemed greatly to astonish M. Karpoff, the first secretary of the legation, an old Russian official who had probably been instructed to QUARREL BETWEEN RUSSIA AND AUSTRIA 215 watch my movements. Knowing the sympathy generally felt by the Poles for France, he almost reproached me for my severity ; but I replied that if the French behaved badly I could not speak well of them. All men, whether French or not, lose on a nearer view much of the prestige and enthusiasm which they inspire at a distance. The friendly relations which had existed between the Emperor Paul and Austria began about this time to grow cool. There were various reasons for this ; I will give some which are not generally known. The Grand-Duchess Alexandra, the eldest of Paul's daughters, who, as I stated in a previous chapter, was intended by Catherine to marry the King of Sweden, became the wife of the Archduke Joseph, Prince Palatine of Hungary. This union was contracted at a period when the Courts of St Petersburg and Vienna were on the best terms with each other, and at the time when Souvaroff had gained his vic- tories in Italy. The Archduchess was of uncommon beauty ; her features resembled those of her brother Alexander, she was most graceful, and she possessed all the moral qualities which are the highest orna- ments of her sex. When she came to Vienna, she inspired universal admiration, respect, and enthusiasm, without in any way seeking it. Her popularity ex- tended from the highest classes of the capital to the most populous districts of Vienna. This displeased the Neapolitan wife of the Emperor Francis II, a woman of jealous and eccentric character and of ex- traordinary habits. She loved monsters, and filled her gardens with burlesque statues. There was something underhand and cunning in her manner, and she never looked one straight in the face. The only persons with whom she was intimate were her servants, who never ventured to rival her in beauty or wit ; she gave them bizarre banquets and private theatricals in which she played herself, and her husband, whose mind was also not very brilliant or suited to a more distinguished society, used to take part in these entertainments, of which singular stories were related at Vienna. The Archduke Joseph's beautiful and amiable wife was regarded by the Austrian Empress as a rival, and she rendered the Archduchess's life so intolerable that the latter had to withdraw with her husband to Ofen. She was Paul's favourite child, and when he learnt how she had been treated he flew into a rage, demanded that she should be sent back to St Petersburg, and even threatened war. Her death, which happened almost simultaneously with that of her father, rendered any further action useless, but it plunged the whole of St Petersburg in deep mourn- ing, while Austria, having re-established herself in Italy, had begun to treat the Russian Cabinet with less deference. The Austrians had sent away SouvarofF with little ceremony, and thinking them- selves already masters of the country, they were glad to rid themselves of an inconvenient and haughty ally. Then came the defeats of the Russians in Holland and Switzerland, which con- tributed still further to estrange Paul from Austria. Buonaparte, taking advantage of this change, hastened to send back to Paul all the Russian prisoners, clothed RAPPROCHEMENT WITH FRANCE 217 in new uniforms and well provided in every respect. This friendly step on the part of the First Consul gained the Emperor's heart, and he declared to his Ministers and the people with whom he was intimate that Russia had been too lavish of her blood and money for Austria, who only repaid her by ingratitude. He enlarged on Buonaparte's ' noble conduct,' and interpreted it as a sign that he sincerely wished for the alliance of Russia ; he had, Paul said, suppressed anarchy and the demagogues, and there was no good reason why Russia should not come to an under- standing with him. Paul accordingly sent General Levaschoff to Naples to mediate between the French Government and that of the two Sicilies. In passing through Rome the General gave me a letter from Count Rostopchin, the Foreign Minister the first I had received from him introducing General Levas- chofF to me and instructing me to give him my services. I did this readily, for the General was not only a good companion, but was very friendly. Soon after I received a second missive from Count Rostop- chin informing me that the Emperor, not being satisfied with the conduct of the Sardinian Court, wished me to leave it under the pretext of visiting Naples. I was delighted at this order, and left for Naples at once. The Court was not there ; its only repre- sentative was the Chevalier Acton, an all-powerful Minister, who had left Sicily to govern the kingdom. Though Naples, thanks to its brilliant sun and its unequalled position, cannot be otherwise than beauti- ful, it had at that time a very melancholy appearance. 218 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI M. Italinsky, afterwards envoy at Constantinople and then at Rome, a Ruthenian and formerly a surgeon, had for some years been at Naples on a diplomatic mission. He was, or at least he tried to be, a learned man. He studied archaeology and physics, and knowing how to do his own business people concluded that he would also know how to do that of others. In ordinary matters he certainly acquitted himself very well, but he was never very successful, either from want of capacity or of good fortune, in dealing with affairs of greater importance. He owed his favour with Catherine to some letters on the eruptions of Mount Vesuvius, and he always stated at the end of his despatches that he had blotted them with some of the volcanic ash that had fallen upon Pompeii eighteen centuries before. He was also helped in his career by his ill-health. He suffered from a sort of aneurism which obliged him to lead a very regular life, but it lasted many years. The Court of Naples sought to take advantage of the friendly relations which had been established between Paul and Buonaparte. It solicited the Emperor's intervention against the advance of the French, which people thought would, after Marengo, be continued to the most southerly point of the peninsula. Italinsky proceeded, at the instigation of the Chevalier Acton, to Florence, where Murat then was, to obtain some favourable conditions for Naples ; but his efforts produced no result. He started before my departure from Rome, and M. Karpoff, my first secretary, being jealous of Italinsky, and wishing to revenge himself for his sarcasms, THE NEAPOLITAN COURT 219 called this fruitless journey 'The Italinsky Pilgrim- age.' On my arrival at Naples I requested Italinsky to present me to the Chevalier Acton. We found him at a table covered with papers. He was a thin, sickly-looking man, with a gaunt and sallow counten- ance and black eyes. His demeanour showed at every movement the ravages of time ; he walked with a stoop, and constantly groaned under the weight of his labours and misfortunes. Yet he was said to be the favourite lover of the Queen Caroline, who was the absolute mistress of her husband and the kingdom. O Nothing was done except by her will, and even official letters bore her signature by the side of the King's, to show that they governed together. She had all the activity of her brother, the Emperor Joseph ; this was sufficiently proved by her sparkling glance, her quick movements, and her shrill voice. I saw her at Leghorn when she was disembarking with her daughters, one of whom, the Princess Amelie, after- wards married Louis-Philippe. Maria Theresa had fashioned her daughter's mind to. domination long before she was married to King Ferdinand. This habit of governing afterwards became her passion. She also had a succession of favourites ; her tiery temperament was stimulated by the Neapolitan climate, and it would have been difficult to believe her boast that she had never had a child of whom Ferdinand was not the father, if there were not an unfortunate likeness between them and Ferdinand not only as regards personal appearance, which, in his case, was anything but attractive, but also as to 220 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI character and mind. Queen Amelie was the only exception to this ; her rare moral qualities were in strong contrast to the characteristics of Caroline's other children. The Russian army corps which then occupied Naples was under the command of General Borozdin, the eldest of three brothers. There was at one time some idea of pushing on the combined forces as far as Rome in order to check the French advance, and the General had himself gone to Rome with this object. But he could not come to an understanding with General Roger de Damas, the commander of the Neapolitan troops, as to who was to have the general command, and the plan was dropped, fortunately for the two generals, who would otherwise have inevitably been defeated. General Borozdin was a dandy of the time of Catherine ; he was very amiable in society, but his military talents were doubtful. Being in the most voluptuous of climates and furnished with ample means, by the Neapolitan Government, which reckoned on the Russian troops more than on its own, Borozdin had all a Russian can desire display and enjoyment. To complete his pleasures, fortune had also placed in his hands a conquest which he valued more highly than any other. A British Consul who had married a young and charming lady had thought fit to escape from Naples directly he heard of the defeat of the Austrians at Marengo and the victorious march of the French towards Florence and the south. In order not to expose his young wife to the dangers of a precipitous journey, he determined to place her in the charge of General Borozdin, with whom he was A RUSSIAN LOTHARIO 221 on intimate terms. The worthy Englishman doubtless thought he had deposited his treasure in safe hands, but the temptation was too strong. The lady was like a rosebud, and Borozdin had with the husband's permission located her in the house where he himself lived, on the plea that he would thereby be able to take better care of her. The result may be imagined. When the panic of a French invasion was over, the Consul returned, took back his wife, and could not sufficiently express his gratitude to his friend for the service he had rendered him. Shortly after, when I left Naples to go back to Rome, the General accom- panied me. He was in very good spirits, and did not speak any more about the Consul's wife, whom he had doubtless soon forgotten. , CHAPTER XI 1801 ASSASSINATION OP THE EMPEROR PAUL. THE news of the death of the Emperor Paul suddenly fell upon us like a clap of thunder in a summer sky. The first result of the unexpected news was astonish- ment accompanied by a sort of fear, but these senti- ments were soon followed by others of joy and relief. Paul had never been loved even by those whom he had benefited. He was too fantastic and capricious ; no one could ever rely upon him. The messenger who brought the news to the legation looked as if he were deaf and dumb ; he did not answer any questions, and merely uttered unintelligible sounds. He was terrified, and had been ordered to keep silence. All he did was to convey to me a few words from the Emperor Alexander, who asked me to come to St Petersburg at once. [The following is a translation of Alexander's letter : March 17 tk 1801. YQU have already heard, dear friend, that owing to the death of my father, I am at the head of affairs. ASSASSINATION OF THE EMPEROR PAUL 223 I do not mention any details, as I wish to give them to you by word of mouth. I write to ask you at once to hand over all the affairs of your mission to the next senior member of it, and to proceed to St Petersburg. I need not tell you with what impatience I am waiting for you. I hope heaven will watch over you during your journey and bring you here safe. Adieu, dear friend, I cannot say more. I enclose a passport for you to show at the frontier. ALEXANDER.] This order gave me immense pleasure. Italy is undoubtedly a delicious country, full of interest, especially for those who have leisure to study it. The wars which had ravaged it had at this period deprived .it of some of its charms, though the ravages were in themselves not without interest. But I was far from my country, my family, and all I loved ; I was sad and solitary ; I was never quick to make acquaint- ances ; much time and peculiar circumstances were necessary to break the ice which separated me even from people whom I saw often. My old friendships, though not numerous, are dear to me, and I do not O ' ' feel inclined to contract new ones. It was with inexpressible pleasure, therefore, that I made my preparations for departure ; but I could not leave Naples without visiting Vesuvius, Herculaneum, Pompeii and Portici. As I was ascending Mount Vesuvius, I stumbled and began to slip down towards the crater, when the guide ran up, gave me his hand, plunged his iron-shod staff into the moving debris, and thus saved my life. The idea of death was at 224 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORY8KI that moment very painful to me ; I was about to return to my people, and to exchange a passive for an active existence. I felt that I was more attached to life than ever, as radiant visions of hope, not yet dis- pelled by experience, were floating before my eyes. On the day following that on which the news of the death of the Emperor Paul was communicated to us, the messenger sent from St Petersburg by the Neapolitan Ambassador brought us a circumstantial account of the catastrophe. It did not astonish me, as I saw before my departure that the whole of the Court was planning a conspiracy against the Emperor. At Naples the general impression was one of joy almost exceeding the bounds of decency. On the second day after the messenger's arrival, General Borozdin gave a ball to which he invited the best society of the town. The dancing was kept up all night, and the General encouraged by his example public demonstrations of a gaiety which, to say the least, was ill-timed. The wife of the British Consul was conspicuous at this fete in a pink dress. My companion on the journey from Rome to Florence was General Levaschoff; he was very amiable and full of anecdote. He had been sent to Naples with the secret intention of negotiating an armistice between the belligerents. The Emperor Paul, who had withdrawn from the coalition, wished by this means to avoid all reproach ; and General Levaschoff had been despatched immediately after the defeats in Holland and Switzerland on the pretext of visiting Italy for his pleasure. His instructions were drawn up by Count Rostopchin, then Foreign MURAT 225 Minister, who was shortly after deprived of his port- folio and retired to Moscow, upon which Paul broke off his relations with Austria, declared war against England, and prepared to enter into a cordial alliance with Buonaparte. All this happened during my absence, and although I was on good terms with O cj Kutaysehoff,* I never could learn the exact details either of Levaschoft's mission or of Rostopchin's dismissal. LevaschofFs negotiations, which he was authorised by the Cabinet to continue after Paul's death, were not successful. The French negotiators at once suspected that Alexander would not be so easy to manage as Paul had been. This was doubtless also Murat's opinion, for, without waiting for instruc- tions from Paris, he occupied the whole of Tuscany, and continued his advance. The more he suspected, however, the more loudly he proclaimed his belief in the maintenance of a friendly understanding between France and Russia. He occupied the palace of the Duke of Tuscany, where he gave me and General Levaschoff a splendid dinner to which all the generals and the principal people of Florence, comprising some sixty persons, were invited. We sat on each side of Madame Murat, who was very slim and pretty. Murat, who sat opposite, paid us constant attention, and was more amiable than his wife. He proposed the health of the Emperor of Russia, and afterwards drank the health of both of us. When the General went to see him in his box at the play he observed that above his head were the Russian and French flags crossing each other. * The Emperor's barber. See page 184. VOL. I P 226 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI Before leaving Italy I went to Leghorn to bid farewell to Marshal Rzewuski, whom I found very ill. I met at his house several of my countrymen ; among them was Sokolnicki, a very active officer of engineers whom I had known in Lithuania during our campaign of 1792,* and Rozniecki, who was with me in the camp of Golomb and in the skirmish at Granno. Both heartily shook me by the hand, recalling with emotion the events we had witnessed together. Rozniecki told me that he had introduced into the Polish legions the system of drill practised at Golomb, which made the Polish cavalry of the republican army superior in rapidity of movement to the French cavalry. I left Rzewuski with a heavy heart, and this illustrious man, proved friend, and worthy citizen passed away soon afterwards. He is buried in the Campo Santo at Pisa. His family intended to erect a monument to his memory, but I believe they did not carry out their intention. After staying two days at Vienna, I went on to Pulawy, where I found the whole of my family ; but much as they wished me to stay, they felt that it was necessary I should go on at once. I travelled day and night until I reached St Petersburg, where my brother joined rne soon after. I approached the Russian capital with mixed feelings of joyful impatience to see the persons to whom I was attached, and of uncertainty as to the changes which time and new circumstances mio-ht o o have produced in them. A messenger met me at Riga with a friendly note from the Emperor and a * See page 53. RETURN TO ST PETERSBURG 22 j written order for post-horses to accelerate my journey. The note was addressed to me in the Emperor's own hand, and gave me the title of Privy Councillor, which gives the rank of General. I was surprised at this rapid promotion, which I decided not to accept. When I arrived at St Petersburg I showed Alex- ander the envelope, and he admitted that he had given me the title in a moment of forgetfulness, but I could have taken advantage of the mistake had I wished to do so. I never received any rank or honorary distinction in Russia than that which had been conferred upon me by the Emperor Paul. The first impression produced upon me by the Emperor Alexander confirmed my presentiments. He had just come back from, parade, and was pale and tired. He received me cordially, but with a sad and depressed air, as if he were under a feeling of constraint. Now he was the master, I thought I observed in him perhaps wrongly a tinge of re- serve and embarrassment which pained me. He took me into his room. ' You have done well to come/ he said ; ' our people expect you with impatience ' alluding to some persons who he thought were more enlightened and liberal than the rest, whom he re- garded as his particular friends, and in whom he placed entire confidence. ' If you had been here/ he added, ' things would not have turned out as they did ; I should never have been led away if I had had you by my side.' Then he spoke to me of his father's death with inexpressible grief and remorse. We often returned to this subject, and Alexander gave me full details of it which I shall repeat below, 228 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI together with information communicated to me by other actors in the tragedy. As regards the matters which had formerly absorbed our attention, and as to which I wished to ascertain how far his feelings had been changed by his sudden elevation to the throne, I found him much as I expected ; not quite aroused from his past dreams, to which he still always returned, but already in the iron hands of reality ; yielding to force, and not yet knowing the extent of his power or how to use it. Alexander told me that the first man who spoke to him about the plans of the conspirators was Count Panin, and he never forgave him. This personage seemed destined more than anyone else to play an important part in the affairs of the Empire, and he had all that was wanted for such an undertaking ; a celebrated name, uncommon talents, and much ambition. While still young he had made a brilliant career. He was appointed Russian Minister at Berlin, from which post he was recalled by the Emperor Paul to be a member of the Council of Foreign Affairs under the orders of Prince Alexander Kourakin, his maternal uncle and Paul's faithful friend, the companion of his infancy and youth, who alone of the leading men at the Imperial Court had escaped the Emperor's caprices and remained steadily in favour. Besides his relationship to Prince Kourakin, Count Panin was the son of the eminent General of that name, and the nephew of the Minister who had been the Grand-Duke Paul's tutor. These antecedents gave Count Panin a certain assurance and air of importance. He was a tall, reserved-looking COUNTS PANIN AND PAHLEN 229 'man, and wrote in excellent French; his despatches were perfect in every respect both as regards matter and style. He had the reputation of being a man of great talent, energy, and good sense, but of dry and imperious character. After remaining for some months in the Foreign Office, he displeased the Emperor, who deprived him of his appointment and sent him back to Moscow. As will be seen further on, Panin was one of the chief leaders of the con- spiracy which brought about Paul's death, though he did not actually take part in it. During my previous stay in the Russian capital I had never met him, for having entered the diplomatic career at an early age, he scarcely ever came there. His wife, a Countess Orloff, did not follow him abroad ; she was good and amiable, and had been very kind to me. When I returned to St Petersburg she insisted on bringing me and her husband together, and did everything in her power to make us friends, but without success. Apart from other reasons, the Count's exterior would, I think, almost have alone been sufficient to make this impossible. I have often been struck by his icy expression ; his impassive countenance, on a body as straight as a spike, did not induce one to address him. I saw him but little, however, and my judgment of his character might have been erroneous and even unjust. The two Counts Panin and Pahlen were at that time the strongest heads of the Empire. They saw further and more clearly than the other members of Paul's Council, to which both of them belonged ; and they agreed to initiate Alexander into their plans. 230 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI It would not have been prudent to attempt anything without being: assured of the consent of the heir 'to c5 the crown. Devoted fanatics or enthusiasts might no doubt have acted otherwise. By not implicating the son in the dethronement of his father, by exposing themselves to a certain death, they would have better served both Russia and the prince who was to be called upon to govern her ; but such a course would have been almost impracticable, and it would have demanded an audacity and antique virtue which in these days very few men possess. Pahlen, as Governor of St Petersburg, had easy means of access to the Grand-Duke, and obtained from him a secret audience for Panin ; their first interview took place in a bath. Panin represented to Alexander the evils from which Russia was suffering and would continue to suffer if Paul continued to reign. He said that Alexander's most sacred duty was to his country, and that he must not sacrifice millions of people to the extravagant caprices and follies of a single man, even if that man was his father ; that the life, or at least the liberty, of his mother, of himself, and of the whole of the Imperial family was threatened by Paul's inconceivable aversion for his wife, from whom he was entirely separated ; that this aversion increased from day to day, and might prompt him to the most out- rageous acts ; and that it was therefore necessary to save Russia, whose fate was in Alexander's hands, by deposing Paul, which would be the only means of preventing him from inflicting greater calamities on. his country and his family, and securing to him a quieter and more happy life. This speech produced ASSASSINATION OF THE EMPEROR PAUL 231 a great impression on Alexander, but it did not con- vince him. It required more than six months to enable his tempters to obtain his consent to their plans. Pahlen had at first left all the speaking to Panin, who was an adept at specious arguments ; but when the latter was sent to Moscow, Pahlen completed the work of his colleague by hints and allusions, in- telligible only to Alexander himself, which were so skilfully introduced, with a military frankness which he made almost as effective as eloquence, that Alex- ander became more and more persuaded that the aims of the conspiracy were just and good.* It was a thousand pities that a prince so anxious and so well qualified to be a benefactor to his country did not hold entirely aloof from a conspiracy which resulted almost inevitably in his father's assassination. Russia certainly suffered much under the almost maniacal Government of Paul, and there are no means in that country of restraining or confining a mad sovereign ; but Alexander felt and exaggerated in his own mind all his life the sombre reflection of the crime committed on his father, which had fallen on himself, and which he thought he could never wipe out. This ineffaceable stain, although it was brought about solely by his inexperience and his total and innocent ignorance of Russian affairs and the Russian people, settled like a vulture on his conscience, paralysed his best faculties at the commencement of * Pahlen had the reputation of being one of the most astute men in Russia. There was no one like him to get out of a difficulty, and to advance his interests in spite of all obstacles. He fell, however, just at the moment when he seemed to have nothing to fear. He came from Livonia, where they used to say of him : ' Er hat die Fiffologie studiert ' (he was a student of Fiffology from the German word, fiffig cunning). 232 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI his reign, and plunged him into a mysticism some- times degenerating into superstition at its close. At the same time it must be admitted that the Emperor Paul was precipitating his country into incalculable disasters and into a complete disorganisa- tion and deterioration of the Government machine. Paul governed intermittently, without troubling him- self about the consequences, like a man who acts without reflection according to the impulse of the moment. The higher classes, the principal officials, the generals and other officers of rank all, in a word, who thought and acted in Russia were more ' O or less convinced that the Emperor had fits of mental alienation. His reign became a rule of terror. He was hated even for his good qualities, for at bottom he desired justice, and this impulse sometimes led him to do a just thing in his outburst of rage ; but his feeling of justice was blind, and struck at all without discrimination of circumstances ; always passionate, often capricious and cruel, his decrees were constantly suspended over the heads of the military and civil officers, and made them detest the man who thus filled their lives with uncertainty and terror. The conspiracy had the sympathy of all, for it promised to put an end to a regime which had become intolerable. A sovereign may commit grave mistakes, bring evils on his country, cause its wealth or its power to decline, without exposing himself to death as a punishment for his misdeeds. But when the sovereign authority weighs at every moment on each individual in the State, and continually disturbs like a fever the peace of families in the ordinary ASSASSINATION OF THE EMPEROR PAUL 233 relations of life, passions are excited which are much more formidable than those produced by evils which, though affecting the entire community, are little felt by individuals. This was the real motive of Paul's assassination. I utterly disbelieve the story that English money contributed to this event. For even supposing and I am sincerely convinced there is no foundation for such a belief that the English o Government of that day was devoid of all feelings of morality, such an expenditure would have been totally unnecessary. The deposition, if not the murder, of Paul had become inevitable in the natural course of events. Even before my departure from St Petersburg it was the fashion among the young men of the Court to talk freely on this subject, to make satirical epigrams on Paul's eccentricities, and to suggest all kinds of absurd plans for getting rid of him. The universal aversion to his rule was shown, often without any attempt at concealment, on every possible occasion ; it was a State secret which was confided to all, and which no one betrayed, though the people lived under the most redoubted and the most suspicious of sovereigns, who encouraged espionage, and spared no means of obtaining exact information not only of the actions, but of the thoughts and intentions of his subjects. The wish to get rid of the Emperor Paul showed itself more strongly the nearer one approached the Court and the capital, but it did not really become active until almost at the moment of its execution. Notwithstanding the extreme favour with which the conspiracy was regarded in the most distinguished society of the Empire, it could not have 234 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI attained its objects, and would probably have been discovered, if the appointment of Governor-General of St Petersburg, which placed at his disposal the garrison and the police, had not been in the hands of the chief promoter of the enterprise. One day the Emperor said, with a scrutinizing glance at Pahlen : ' I hear a conspiracy is being formed against me.' ' Such a thing is impossible, Sire/ replied the General with his frank and good- natured smile ; ' it cannot be formed unless I belong to it.' This reassured Paul, though it is said that his suspicions were aroused by anonymous letters, and that on the eve of his death he had sent for General Araktcheyeff to give him the place of Governor- General of St Petersburg, after dismissing Pahlen. If Araktcheyeff had come in time St Petersburg would have been the scene of many tragic events ; he was a man imbued with a strong sentiment of order and with an energy which sometimes grew into ferocity. His return would probably have been fol- lowed by that of Count E-ostopchin, and Paul might then have been saved. He had dismissed so many of his Ministers that he was surrounded by incapable men to whom he had given the highest offices of State. Prince Kourakin continued to direct Foreign Affairs with much kindness of heart and little wisdom, while an insignificant man named Obalianinoff held the important post of Procurator-General, involving the direction of the police and the whole administra- tion of the Empire, solely because he had formerly been steward of the Gatchina estate. Kutayschoff was still the man in whom Paul most trusted. When ASSASSINATION OF THE EMPEROR PAUL 235 he was arrested on the day after his master's death, letters were found in his pocket revealing the objects of the conspiracy, the time when it was to be executed, and the names of the conspirators. But he never opened his letters directly he received them. His favourite saying was ' business to-morrow/ and he put these important letters in his pocket in order not to interrupt his pleasures that evening. Paul had just finished the construction at immense expense of the palace of St Michael.* This building was erected after his own designs, and was a sort of fortified castle where the Emperor thought his life would be safe. 'I never felt happier or more at ease/ he said when he took up his residence in this palace, and he became more self-indulgent and -autocratic than ever. Although everybody sympathised with the con- spiracy, nothing was done until Alexander had given his consent to his father's deposition. The men who undertook to carry out the plan were Pahlen arid the two Zuboffs, whom Paul had recalled from exile and loaded with favours, thinking he had nothing to fear from them now he was in his new castle. Their first step was to induce a number of Generals and other officers of rank who were their friends to come under various pretexts to St Petersburg ; and this was rendered more easy by the fact that Paul himself had invited many high functionaries and Generals to be * The swindling which took place at the erection of this building is almost incredible. The chief architect, B . . ., was an Italian foreman, whom Count Stanislas Potocki had brought from Italy, and who passed from Warsaw to the service of the Grand-Duke Paul at Gatchina. B . . . 's commissions on the work he performed were enormous, and he left a large fortune to his daughter's husband and their children, who became Russian diplomatists. 236 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI present at the fetes he was about to give on the marriage of one of his daughters. Pahlen and the Zuboffs took steps to enlist the services of some of the more eminent of the Generals, without stating positively what they intended to do. But it was necessary to act at once, for the slightest imprudence or revelation might place the Emperor in possession of their secret, and he was already so suspicious that he might at any moment take some step which would be their ruin. It was not known whether he had already sent for Araktcheyeff and Rostopchin. The former lived at twenty-four hours' journey from St Petersburg and might come at any moment. Doubt- less he and Rostopchin would endeavour to moderate the Emperor's excesses, but their influence would probably not be sufficient to put a stop to the severities he wished to exercise with regard to several members of the Imperial family. It was evident that any further delay or vacillation would be most dangerous, and' miff ht be the cause of incalculable calamities; * O and the conspirators accordingly decided to strike the blow on the 3rd of March, 1801. On that evening Plato Zuboff gave a grand supper, to which were invited all the Generals and other officers of rank who were supposed to approve of the objects of the conspiracy. These were only now clearly explained to them, as the only way to secure the enterprise against accidents was for two or three leaders to prepare it, and not to announce it to the others who were to take part in it until the moment for its execution should arrive. Zuboff represented to his guests the deplor- ASSASSINATION OF THE EMPEROR PAUL 237 able condition in which Russia was placed by the insanity of her sovereign, the dangers to which both the State and each individual citizen were exposed, and the probability that new and more outrageous excesses might at any moment be expected. He pointed out that the insane act of a rupture with England was contrary to the essential interests of the Russian nation, dried up the sources of its wealth, and exposed the Baltic ports, and the capital itself, to the gravest disasters; and that none of those whom he addressed could be sure of their fate on the morrow. He enlarged on the virtues of the Grand-Duke Alexander, and on the brilliant destinies of Russia under the sceptre of a young Prince of such promise, whom the Empress Catherine, of glorious memory, had regarded as her successor, and had intended, if she had not been prevented by her death, to place on the throne. He concluded by declaring that Alexander, rendered desperate by the misfortunes of his country, had decided to save it, and that all that was now necessary was to depose the Emperor Paul, to oblige him to sign a deed of abdication, and, by proclaiming Alexander Emperor, to prevent his father from ruining both himself and his Empire. Pahlen and both the Zuboffs repeated to the assembled guests the assurance that the Grand-Duke Alexander ap- proved of their plan. They were careful not to say how much time it took them to persuade him, and with what extreme difficulty and with how many restrictions and modifications his consent was finally obtained. The last point was left vague, and every- one probably explained it after his own fashion. 238 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI When the company had been made to understand that Alexander's consent had been given, there was no further hesitation. Meanwhile champagne was drunk freely and there was general excitement. Pahlen, who had gone away for a short time on 1 business connected with his functions as Governor- General, came back from the Court and announced that the Emperor did not seem to suspect anything, and had said good-night to the Empress and the Grand-Dukes as usual. Those who had been at supper in the palace afterwards said they recollected that Alexander, when he took leave of his father, did not change countenance or show that he was conscious of the scene which was preparing. Pro^ bably they did not look at him, for he has often told me how agitated he was, and certainly the risks he ran not only for himself, but for his mother, his family, and many others were enough to make him sad and anxious. The Grand-Dukes were always obliged to maintain an attitude of strict reserve before their father, and this constant habit of con- cealing their emotions and thoughts may explain why at this grave and supreme moment no one perceived in Alexander's countenance what was passing in his mind. At the Zuboffs' house the guests had become so convivial that time went fast. At midnight the con- spirators set out for the Emperor's palace. The leaders had drunk but moderately, wishing to keep their heads clear, but the majority of those who fol- lowed them were more or less intoxicated ; some could even hardly keep their legs. They were divided ASSASSINATION OF THE EMPEROR PAUL 239 into two bands, each composed of some sixty Generals and other officers. The two Zuboffs and General Bennigsen were at the head of the first band, which was to go to the palace direct ; the second was to enter through the garden, and was under the command of Pahlen. The aide-de-camp in waiting, who knew all the doors and passages of the palace, as he was daily on duty there, guided the first band with a dark lantern to the entrance of the Emperor's dressing-room, which adjoined his bedroom. A young valet who was on duty stopped the con- spirators and cried out that rebels were coming to murder the Emperor. He was wounded in the struggle which ensued, and rendered incapable of further resistance. His cries waked the Emperor, who ofot out of bed and ran to a door which communi- O cated with the Empress's apartments and was hidden by a large curtain. Unfortunately, in one of his fits of dislike for his wife, he had ordered the door to be locked ; and the key was not in the lock, either because Paul had ordered it to be taken away or because his favourites, who were opposed to the Empress, had done so, fearing lest he should some day have a fancy to return to her. Meanwhile the conspirators were confused and terrified at the cries of Paul's faithful defender, the only one he had at a moment of supreme danger when he believed in his omnipotence more than ever and was surrounded by a triple line of walls and guards. Zuboff, the chief of the band, lost heart and proposed to retire at once, but General Bennigsen (from whom I obtained some of these details) seized him by the arm and protested against such a dangerous 24 o MEMOIRS OF PRIXCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI step. ' What ? ' he said, ' You have brought us so far, and now you want to withdraw ? We are too far advanced to follow your advice, which would ruin us all. The wine is drawn, it must be drunk. Let us inarch on.' It was this Hanoverian that decided the Emperor's fate ; he was one of those who had only that evening been informed of the conspiracy. He placed himself at the head of the band, and those who had most courage, or most hatred for Paul, were the first to follow him. They entered the Emperor's bedroom, went straight to his bed, and were much alarmed at not finding him there. They searched the room with a light, and at last discovered the unfortunate Paul hiding behind the folds of the curtain. They dragged him out in his shirt more dead than alive ; the terror he had inspired was now repaid to him with usury. Fear had paralysed his senses and had deprived him of speech ; his whole body shivered. He was placed on a chair before a desk. The long, thin, pale, and angular form of General Bennigsen, with his hat on his head and a drawn sword in his hand, must have seemed to him a terrible spectre. * Sire,' said the General, ' you are my prisoner, and have ceased to reign ; you will now at once write and sign a deed of abdication in favour of the Grand-Duke Alexander.' Paul was still unable to speak, and a pen was put in his hand. Trembling and almost unconscious, he was about to obey, when more cries were heard. General Bennigsen then left the room, as he has often assured me, to ascertain what these cries meant, and to take steps for securing the safety of the ASSASSINATION OF THE EMPEROR PAUL 241 palace and of the Imperial family. He had only just gone out at the door when a terrible scene began. The unfortunate Paul remained alone with men who were maddened by a furious hatred of him, owing to the numerous acts of persecution and injustice they had suifered at his hands, and it appears that several of them had decided to assassinate him, per- haps without the knowledge of the leaders or at least without their formal consent. The catastrophe, which in such a case was, in a country like Russia, almost inevitable, was doubtless hastened by the cries above referred to, which alarmed the conspirators for their own safety. Count Nicholas Zuboff, a man of her- culean proportions, was said to be the first that placed his hand on his sovereign, and thereby broke the spell of imperial authority which still surrounded him. The others now saw in Paul nothing but a monster, a tyrant, an implacable enemy and his abject sub- mission, instead of disarming them, rendered him despicable and ridiculous as well as odious in their eyes. One of the conspirators took off his official scarf and tied it round the Emperor's throat. Paul struggled, the approach of death restoring him to strength and speech. He set free one of his hands and thrust it between the scarf and his throat, crying out for air. Just then he perceived a red uniform, which was at that time worn by the officers of the cavalry guard, and thinking that one of the assassins was his son Constantine, who was a colonel of that regiment, he exclaimed : ' Mercy, your Highness, mercy ! Some air, for God's sake ! ' But the con- VOL. i. Q 242 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI spirators seized the hand with which he was striving to prolong his life, and furiously tugged at both ends of the scarf. The unhappy Emperor had already breathed his last, and yet they tightened the knot and dragged along the dead body, striking it with their hands and feet. The cowards who until then had held aloof, surpassed in atrocity those who had done the deed. Just at that time General Bennigsen O returned. I do not know whether he was sincerely grieved at what had happened in his absence ; all he did was to stop the further desecration of the Emperor's body. Meanwhile the cry ' Paul is dead ! ' was heard by the other conspirators, and filled them with a joy that deprived them of all sentiment of decency and dignity. They wandered tumultuously about the corridors and rooms of the palace, boasting to each other of their prowess ; many of them found means of adding to the intoxication of the supper by break- ing into the wine cellars and drinking to the Emperor's death. Pahlen, who seems to have lost his way in the garden, came to the palace with his band imme- diately after the deed had been consummated. It is said that he had delayed his arrival on purpose, so as to be able to profess to have come to the Emperor's assistance in case his colleagues should have failed. Be this as it may, he was extremely active directly he arrived, giving the necessary orders during the rest of the night, and omitting nothing which could give him a claim to reward as the prime mover and commander of the enterprise. ASSASSINATION OF THE EMPEROR PAUL 2^3 It will be seen from the above narrative how easy it would have been for the undertaking to have been foiled by an accident, notwithstanding the precautions \vhich had been taken to ensure its success. The conspiracy had the sympathies of the higher classes and most of the officers ; but not of the lower ranks of the army. The persons who suffered from Paul's insane fits of rage and severity were usually the higher military and civil officials ; his caprices very seldom affected men of the lower ranks, who, more- over, were continually receiving extra pay and rations of bread, wine, and brandy when they were on drill or on a parade. The punishments to which the officers were exposed did not therefore produce any unpleasant impression on the common soldier ; on the contrary, they were a sort of satisfaction to him for the blows and ill-treatment he constantly had to endure. Moreover, his pride was flattered by the great importance attached to his calling, for to Paul nothing could be more important than a foot raised too soon on the march, or a coat badly buttoned on parade. It amused and pleased the soldiers to see their Emperor dispensing endless punishments and severities among the officers, while he took every opportunity to afford to the men ample compensation for the work and trouble that was required of them. The soldiers of the Guard, many of whom were married, lived with their families almost in opulence, and both they and those of the other regiments were satisfied with and attached to their Emperor. General Talyzin, one of the principal conspirators, who was very popular among the soldiers, had under- 244 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI taken to bring to the palace one of the battalions of the first regiment of the Guard which was under his command. He assembled the men after leaving Zuboffs supper, and began to tell them that their fatigues were about to cease, and that the}' would now have an indulgent and kind sovereign who would not impose upon them the rigorous duties they had hitherto had to perform. He soon per- ceived, however, that his words were not listened to with favour ; the soldiers preserved a gloomy silence, their faces had a sombre expression, and some mur- murs were heard. The General cut short his speech, uttered in a sharp tone of command the words ' Right wheel march,' and the battalion, which had now again become a machine, marched to the palace, all the outlets from which it occupied. Count Valerian Zuboff, having lost a leg in the Polish War, could not belong to either of the bands of the conspirators. He entered the palace soon after the death of the Emperor became known, and then went to the guard-room to sound the opinions of the soldiers. He congratulated them on having a new and a young Emperor ; but this compliment was ill received, and he was obliged to leave the room hastily to avoid disagreeable manifestations. All this shows how easy it would have been for Paul to crush the conspirators if he had been able to escape them for a moment and to show himself to the guards in the courtyard. It also shows how illusory and impracticable was Alexander's plan of keeping his father in confinement. If Paul's life had been saved, blood would have flowed on the scaffold, Siberia ASSASSINATION OF THE EMPEROR PAUL 245 would have been crowded with exiles, and his venge- ance would probably have extended to his sons. I will now. describe what happened during this terrible night in the part of the palace which was inhabited by the Imperial family. The Grand-Duke Alexander knew that his father would in a few hours be called upon to abdicate, and without undressing he threw himself on his bed full of anxiety and doubt. About one o'clock he heard a knock at his door, and saw Count Nicholas Zuboff, his dress in disorder, and his face flushed with wine and the excitement of the murder which had just been committed. He came up to Alexander, who was sitting on his bed, and said in a hoarse voice: ' All is over.' 'What is over?' asked Alexander in consternation. He was some- what deaf, and perhaps he feared to misunderstand what was being said to him, while Zuboff on his side feared to state exactly what had been done. This somewhat prolonged the conversation; Alexander had not the least idea that his father was dead, and did not therefore admit the possibility of such a thing. At length he perceived that Zuboff, without clearly explaining himself, repeatedly addressed him as ' Sire ' and ' Your Majesty,' while Alexander thought he was merely Regent. This led to further question- ing, and he then learnt the truth. Alexander was prostrated with grief and despair. This was not surprising, for even ambitious men cannot commit a crime or believe themselves the cause of one without repulsion, while Alexander was not at all ambitious. The idea of having caused the death of his father filled him with horror, and he felt that his reputation 246 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI had received a stain which could never be effaced. As for the Empress, directly the news reached her she dressed hastily and rushed out of her apartments with cries of despair and rage. Perceiving some grenadiers, she said to them repeatedly : ' As your Emperor has died a victim to treason, I am your Empress, I alone am your legitimate sovereign ; follow me and protect me.' General Bennigsen and Count Pahlen, who had just brought a detachment of men whom they could trust to the palace to restore order, strove to calm her and forced her with difficulty to return to her room. She had scarcely entered it, however, than she wished to go out again, although guards had been placed at her door. At first she seemed determined at all risks to seize the reins of government and avenge her husband's murder. But though she was generally respected, she was not capable df inspiring those feelings of enthusiastic devotion which cause men to act impulsively and without weighing the conse- quences. Her appeals to the soldiers (which were perhaps rendered somewhat ridiculous by her German accent) produced no effect, and she retired in con- fusion, vexed at having uselessly disclosed her ambitious views. I never heard any details of the first interview between the Empress and her son after Paul's assassination. Subsequently they came to an under- standing with each other ; but during the first terrible moments Alexander was so absorbed by his remorse that he seemed incapable of saying a word or thinking of anybody. His mother, on the other hand, was in a passion of grief and animosity ; the ASSASSINATION OF THE EMPEROR PAUL 247 only member of the Imperial family that retained her presence of mind was the young Empress. She did her utmost to console Alexander and give him courage and self-reliance. She did not leave him during the whole of the night, except when she went for a few moments to calm her mother-in-law and persuade her to stop in her room and not expose herself to the fury of the conspirators. While in this night of trouble and horror some were intoxicated with triumph and others plunged in grief and despair, the Empress Elizabeth alone exercised a mediatory influence between her husband, her mother-in-law, and the conspirators. During the first years of his reign, Alexander's position with regard to his father's murderers was an extremely difficult and painful one. For a few months he believed himself to be at their mercy, but it was chiefly his conscience and a feeling of natural equity which prevented him from giving up to justice the most guilty of the conspirators. He knew that there was a general sympathy for the objects of the conspiracy, and that those who had personally taken part in their realisation had only decided to do so when they were assured of his consent. It would have been difficult under these circumstances to dis- tinguish between degrees of guilt ; every member of the society of St Petersburg was more or less an accomplice in the fatal deed, for those who wished Paul to be deposed must have known that his de- position, if resisted, might have involved his death. If the assassins alone had been brought to trial, they would certainly have accused the other conspirators 248 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI and have referred to Alexander's consent in justifica- tion of their action, though the crime had been com- mitted against his express wish. Moreover, he did not for many years know who they were, as all the conspirators were interested in keeping the secret. The assassins all perished miserably, including Count Nicholas Zuboff, who, not daring to show himself at Court, died in retirement, consumed by illness, by remorse, and by disappointed ambition. Although Alexander's mother continually urged him to proceed against his father's murderers, it was not possible for him to do so by the ordinary and public legal means. He looked with horror upon those who had led him to give his consent to the conspiracy, and he used every other means in his power to discover and punish the assassins. General Bennigsen was removed from his post of Governor- General of Lithuania, which was given to General Kutuzoft', and it was not until the year 1806 that Bennigsen's military reputation compelled Alex- ander to place him at the head of the army which fought at Eylau and Friedland. Prince Plato ZubofF, the ostensible chief of the conspiracy, failed, notwith- standing all his efforts, to obtain any appointment, and feeling that his presence was disagreeable to the Emperor, he retired to his estates, married a hand- some Polish woman, and then went abroad. His bad reputation, however, everywhere preceded him, and he died obscure and unregretted. As for General Pahlen, he at first thought himself strong enough to maintain his position without support. It was he who took the external and ASSASSINATION OF THE EMPEROR PAUL 249 internal measures which had become urgently necessary by the probability of the British fleet entering the waters of Riga, Revel, and Cronstadt, after the battle of Copenhagen. Nelson had won this battle shortly after the Emperor Paul was assassinated.* The news did not become public for some days, and in the trouble and confusion which followed, Pahlen took into his own hands the reins of State, wishing to add to his important functions as Governor-General of St Petersburg the still more important ones of Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs. The proclamations issued at that time were all signed by him ; nothing could be done except through him and with his consent ; he affected to protect the young Emperor, and scolded him when he did not do what he wished, or rather ordered. Alexander, overcome with sadness and despair, seemed to be in the power of the conspirators ; he thought it necessary to treat them with consideration and bend his will to theirs. Just at this time the important post of Procurator- General, which combined the direction of all the administrative departments of the Empire, became vacant by the dismissal of one of Paul's favourites who had occupied it. Alexander had the happy idea of selecting for this place General Beklescheff, who had been summoned by Paul to St Petersburg perhaps with the same object. He was a Russian of the old school, with coarse and abrupt manners, ignorant of the French language or barely under- * Paul was assassinated on the night of the 23rd of March 1801 ; the battle of Copenhagen was fought on the 2nd of April, 1801. 250 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI standing it, but firm, straightforward, and compassion- ate for other people's misfortunes. His reputation as a man of high character was generally established, and he had even preserved it while he was Governor- General of the Polish provinces of the South, where he showed himself just to the people he governed and severe to his subordinates. He had done his best to prevent robbery and falsehood, and did not permit the officials to sell justice by auction as other Russian governors did. When he left he was followed by the gratitude of the people whom he had ruled. No more difficult task can be given to a high Russian official, and not many have acquitted themselves so well. He knew nothing of what was going on beyond the frontier, but he was thoroughly acquainted with the ukases and the routine of 'Russian administration ; he executed them with rigour, but with all the justice of which they were capable. He had been a complete stranger to the conspiracy, and Alexander complained to him of Pahlen's dictatorial w r ays. Beklescheff, with his usual abruptness, expressed surprise at a Russian autocrat complaining that he did not do as he pleased. ' When flies annoy me,' he said, ' I drive them away.' The Emperor took the hint, and signed an order directing Pahlen at once to leave St Petersburg and proceed to his country house. Beklescheff, who was an old friend of Pahlen's, under- took as Procurator-General to take this order to him and make him leave within twenty-four hours. He came to Pahlen early on the following morning, and the latter at once obeyed the Emperor's decree. This event made much noise at St Petersburg, and Alex- ASSASSINATION OF THE EMPEROR PAUL 251 ander was accused of duplicity because on the day before Pahlen was banished he had behaved to him as usual when he received his daily report. He could, however, hardly have done otherwise, and the fact is that this act of absolute sovereignty on the part of the young Emperor displeased and alarmed the leaders of the conspiracy. The views of the Zuboffs as to the conspiracy were communicated to me by Count Valerian Zuboff a few days after my return to St Petersburg. He com- plained that the Emperor did not declare himself for his true friends, who had placed him on the throne and had not feared any danger they had incurred in his service. The Empress Catherine had acted other- wise ; she had always supported those who had helped her, and had not hesitated to maintain them in power. By this wise and sagacious conduct, said Zuboff, she had been able always to reckon on their devotion. No one hesitated to make a sacrifice for her, as such sacrifices were always rewarded ; but Alexander was exposing himself by his vacillating conduct to the most serious consequences, and was discouraging his best friends. Zuboff added that the Empress Catherine had expressly enjoined him and his brother to look upon Alexander as their only legiti- mate sovereign, and to serve him alone with unshaken zeal and fidelity. This they had done, and what was their reward ? He said this to exculpate his brother and himself in the eyes of the young Emperor with regard to the assassination of his father, and to prove to him that their conduct was the .necessary result of the engagements Catherine had demanded of them as 252 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI to her grandson. But they did not know that Alexander, and even his brother Constantine, by no means regarded their grandmother's memory with veneration or attachment. During this conversation, which lasted more than an hour, I several times interrupted the Count to explain the young Emperor's conduct. It was evident that the Zuboffs wished me to communicate their views to the Emperor, and though I did not promise, I considered it my duty to do so. Their statements produced but little impres- sion on Alexander, but they showed that the con- spirators were still very proud of their achievement, and that they felt convinced they had done a great service to Russia, had a right to Alexander's gratitude and confidence, and were necessary to the security and prosperity of the new reign. They even hinted that their discontent might be dangerous to him. Alexander, however, w T as deaf both to their arguments and their threats. He could not look with favour on his father's murderers, or give himself up into their hands. Moreover, he had already dismissed Pahlen, who was perhaps the only one of the con- spirators who by his ability, his connections, his boldness, and his ambition, could inspire serious fear or become really dangerous. Alexander also dismissed other leaders of the conspiracy who were not dangerous, but the sight of whom was odious and disagreeable to him. The only leader w r ho remained at St Petersburg was Count Valerian ZubofF, who was a member of the Imperial Council. His amiability and frankness pleased Alexander and inspired him with confidence ; and this feeling was ASSASSINATION OF THE EMPEROR PAUL 253 confirmed by the attachment which the Count pro- fessed (I think sincerely) to have for the Emperor personally, and also by his indolence, his unwillingness to take appointments to which onerous duties were attached, and especially by his amours, which occupied nearly the whole of his time. The punishment of Pahlen and .the other leaders of the conspiracy was the most painful that could have been inflicted on them, and Alexander punished him- self with more severity than the others. His grief and the remorse which he was continually reviving in his heart were inexpressibly deep and touching. In the midst of the pomp and the festivals of the coronation, the young Emperor was reminded of the similar ceremonies which had been passed through by his father, and he saw in imagination Paul's mutilated and blood-stained body on the steps of the throne which he was now himself to ascend. This brilliant display of supreme power, instead of rousing his ambition or flattering his vanity, increased his mental tortures, and he was never, I think, more unhappy. He remained alone for hours, sitting in silence with fixed and haggard / O oo looks. With me, as the confidant of his secret thoughts and troubles, he was most at his ease, and I sometimes entered his room when he had been too long under the painful influence of these fits of despair and remorse. I tried to recall him to his duties ; he acknowledged that a painful task was before him, but the severity of his condemnation of his own conduct deprived him of all energy. He replied to 254 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI all my exhortations and words of encouragement and hope : ' No, it is impossible, there is no remedy. I must suffer. How can I cease to suffer ? This can- not change.' Those who approached him often feared that his mind would be affected, and as I was then the only person who could speak to him freely I was constantly urged to do so. I think I was of some use in pre- venting Alexander from succumbing under the weight of the terrible thought that pursued him. Some years later, the great events in which he took a leading and glorious part gave him some consolation and for a time, perhaps, absorbed all his faculties ; but I am certain that towards the end of his life it was the same terrible thought that so depressed him, filling him with a disgust of life and a piety which was perhaps exaggerated, but which is the sole possible and real support in the most poignant grief. When we returned to this sad topic, Alexander often repeated to me the details of the plan he had formed to establish his father in the Palace of St Michael and afterwards to enable him as much as possible to reside in the Imperial Palaces in the country. ' The Palace of St Michael,' he said, ' was his favourite residence, and he would have been happy there. He would have had the whole of the winter garden to walk and ride in.' Alexander intended to attach a riding- school and a theatre to the palace, so as to bring together within its precincts everything that could have amused the Emperor Paul and made his life happy. He judged of his father by himself. There was always in his noble character a feminine ele- ASSASSINATION OF THE EMPEROR PAUL 255 merit, with its strength and weakness. He often used to make plans which could not be realised, and on this idealistic foundation he raised complete struc- tures which he made as perfect as possible. Nothing was more impracticable especially in Russia than the romantic means which Alexander had devised of rendering his father happy, while depriving him of his crown and of the possibility of tormenting and ruining the country. Alexander was not only young and inexperienced ; he had almost the blind and con- fiding inexperience of childhood, and this characteristic remained with him for some years until it was de- stroyed by the realities of life. I have not concealed anything in regard to the catastrophe which inaugurated his reign, for this was the best way of doing him justice. The complete truth, without any restriction, exculpates him up to a certain point from an odious accusation, and explains how he was led into an action which he abhorred and why he seemed not to have punished the assassins with sufficient rigour. I have shown how inexperi- enced and unambitious he was, and what were the plausible and even honourable motives by which he was actuated. We may pity Alexander, but we must hesitate to condemn him.* * M. de Langeron's account of the assassination of the Emperor Paul is true, but it does not give the whole truth, as it does not explain how Alexander was induced to give his consent to his father's deposition and why he did not bring the conspirators to trial. (Note by Prince Adam Czartoryski,) CHAPTER XII 1801-2 MY RELATIONS WITH ALEXANDER. THE SECRET COUNCIL. EUROPEAN COALITION AGAINST ENGLAND. THE DON COSSACKS MARCH UPON INDIA. NELSON'S BOMBARDMENT OF COPENHAGEN. ARRANGE- MENT BETWEEN RUSSIA AND ENGLAND. MISSION FROM NAPOLEON TO ALEXANDER. ALEXANDER'S CORONATION. INTERVIEW BE- TWEEN ALEXANDER AND FREDERICK WILLIAM III AT MEMEL. THE STROGONOFFS. THE VORONTZOFFS. PLANS OF REFORM. MY APPOINTMENT AS ASSISTANT FOREIGN MINISTER OF RUSSIA. STATE OF EDUCATION IN RUSSIA. THE opinions and sentiments which had seemed to me so admirable in Alexander when he was Grand - Duke did not change when he became Emperor ; they were somewhat modified by the possession of absolute power, but they remained the foundation of all his principles and thoughts. They were for many years like a secret passion which one dares not acknowledge before a world incapable of compre- hending it, but which constantly dominates us and colours our actions whenever its influence can make itself felt. I shall often have occasion to return to this important subject in explanation of Alexander's character, for at other times the Emperor, being thoroughly aware of his power and the obligations it imposed upon him, might have been compared to a THE SECRET COUNCIL 257 man who still likes to amuse himself with the toys of his childhood, and leaves his favourite recreation with regret in order to return to the occupations and duties of real life. There was no longer any question of the old reveries of extreme liberalism ; the Emperor ceased to speak to me of his plan of giving up the throne, or of the document he had made me write. But he was constantly thinking of more practical matters, such as the administration of justice, the emancipation of the masses, equitable reforms, and liberal institutions ; this was his diversion when he was alone with me. He understood the often insurmountable obstacles which the most elemen- tary reforms would meet with in Russia ; but he wished to prove to those with whom he was intimate that the sentiments he had expressed to them were still the same, notwithstanding the change in his position. It was necessary, however, not to disclose them, and still less to take a pride in them, in the presence of a public which was at that time so little prepared to appreciate them, and would have regarded them with surprise and horror. Meanwhile the government machine continued to work according to the old routine, and the Emperor was obliged to take part in its management. In order to remedy the discrepancy between Alexander's opinions and his acts, he established a Secret Council composed of persons whom he regarded as his friends and believed to be animated by sentiments and opinions in conformity with his own. The first nucleus of this Council was formed by the young VOL. I. K 258 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI Count Paul Strogonoff, M. de Novosiltzoff, and myself. We had long been in near relations with each other, and these now became more serious. The necessity of rallying round the Emperor and not leaving him alone in his desire of reform drew us more closely together. We were regarded for some years as models of intimate and unshakeable friendship. To be superior to every personal interest, and not to accept either presents or distinctions, was the principle of our alliance. Such a principle could not take root in Russia, but it was in accordance with the ideas of Alexander's youth and inspired him with special esteem for his friends. I was the sole author of the principle, which indeed was specially suited to my peculiar position. It was not always liked by my companions, and the Emperor himself afterwards grew tired of servants who wished to distinguish themselves by refusing to accept rewards which were so eagerly sought by everyone else. The understanding between us had, as I have shown, begun at the coronation of the Emperor Paul at Moscow, and we had for a long time been on intimate terms, as we met daily at Count Strogonoff s. The fourth member admitted by the Emperor to the Secret Council was Count Kotchoubey. Being the nephew of Count Bezborodko, a Minister who had been held in high esteem by the Empress Catherine, he was sent when still very young to the embassy at Constantinople, and was recalled under the Emperor Paul to give place to M. Tarnara. While at Constanti- nople he conducted himself to the satisfaction of his Government, and was perhaps the only Russian who THE SECRET COUNCIL 259 was well treated in the capital. This was at the time of our grand Diet,* and during the reign of Leopold, when Russians used to be received by ladies in drawing-rooms in a manner anything but flattering. I remember the Countess Caroline, afterwards Lady Guildford, being asked by Count Tchernitcheff to insult him in order to enable him to gain a wager, upon which she said : ' You are a Russian.' But to return to Count Kotchoubey. He had acquired a certain European varnish and grand manners which made him a favourite in society. Vanity, a general defect among men, and especially among Russians and Slavs of all kinds, exposed Kotchoubey to sarcasms from other vain people, but he was too good-natured to resent them. He was also accustomed to business, but he had not much knowledge ; his intelligence was clear, but not deep, and he had more good-nature and sincerity than are usually found in Russians. This did not save him from certain weaknesses characteris- tic of his nation a great wish for place, for dis- tinction, and especially for a fortune to cover his expenses and those of his family, which had become very numerous. He showed an extreme readiness to adopt any opinion that might be in fashion and to follow any lead imposed upon him by a superior will or by the conventions of society. When he was with us he professed liberalism, though with a certain reserve, as it was not to be reconciled with his real opinions. His vanity was such that it betrayed it- self when he strove most to conceal it, which ex- * The Diet which passed the Constitution of the 3rd of May, 1791. It sat for four years, from 1788 to 1792. (See page 52). 260 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI posed him to the satire of iny two colleagues. I did not join in their jokes, as he had estimable qualities and showed me much friendly feeling, of which I had strong evidence some years later. We were privileged to dine with the Emperor without a previous invitation, and we used to meet two or three times a week. After coffee and a little conversation, the Emperor used to retire, and while the other guests left the palace, the four members of the Secret Council entered through a corridor into a little dressing-room, which was in direct communica- tion with the private rooms of their Majesties, and there met the Emperor. Various plans of reform were debated ; each member brought his ideas, and sometimes his work, and information which he had obtained as to what was passing in the existing administration and the abuses which he had ob- served. The Emperor freely expressed his thoughts and sentiments, and although the discussions at these meetings for a long time had no practical result, no useful reform was tried or carried out during Alex- ander's reign which did not originate in them. Mean- while the Official Council, namely, the Senate and the Ministers, governed the country in the old way. Directly the Emperor left his dressing-room he came under the influence of the old Ministers, and could do nothing of what had been decided upon in the Secret Council ; it was like a masonic lodge from which one entered the practical world. This mysterious Council, which was not long con- cealed from the suspicions, or ultimately from the knowledge, of the Court, and was designated ' the 26l young men's party,' grew impatient at not obtaining any result whatever from its deliberations ; it pressed the Emperor to carry out the views he had expressed to us and the proposals he considered desirable and necessary. Once or twice an attempt was made to induce him to adopt energetic resolutions, to give orders and make himself obeyed, to dismiss certain superannuated officials who were a constant obstacle to every reform and to put young men in their place. But the Emperor's character inclined him to attain his end by compromises and concessions, and more- over he did not yet feel sufficiently master of the position to risk measures which he thought too violent. In our Council Strogonoff was the most ardent, Novosiltzoff the most prudent, Kotchoubey the most time-serving, and I the most disinterested, always striving to curb undue impatience. Those who urged the Emperor to take immediate and severe measures did not know him. Such a pro- posal always made him draw back, and was of a nature to diminish his confidence. But as he com- plained of his Ministers and did not like any of them, an attempt was made in the Council, before inducing him to change them, to discuss the matter in a practical spirit, apart from the abstract considerations of reform which had pre- viously occupied us. Strogonoff accepted the post of Procurator of the First Department of the Senate ; and Novosiltzoff was appointed one of the Emperor's secretaries, a place which gave him many advantages, as every letter addressed to the Emperor passed through his hands, and he had a right to publish the 262 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI Emperor's ukases. His special department, however, was at first to deal with promoters of public under- takings, who are sometimes men of talent, but more often adventurers of very doubtful honesty who flock to Russia from abroad at the beginning of each new reign. This was a duty for which he was qualified by his varied knowledge in matters of finance and industry, and it was at the same time a school which did much to form his character. I must not here forget the fifth member of the Secret Council, M. de la Harpe, Alexander's tutor, who had come on a visit to his former pupil. He did not take part in the after dinner meetings, but he used to have private conversations with the Emperor, and frequently handed to him memoranda reviewing all the branches of the administration. These memo- randa were first read at the secret sittings, and afterwards passed on from one member of the Council to the other to be considered at leisure, as they were interminably long. M. de la Harpe was at that time about forty-four years of age ; he had been a member of the Swiss Director} 7 , and always wore the uniform of that appointment, with a large sword fastened to an embroidered belt outside his coat. We were all of opinion that he did not merit his high reputation and the esteem in which Alexander held him. He belonged to the generation of men nourished with the illusions of the last part of the eighteenth century, who thought their doctrine a sort of philosopher's stone, or universal remedy which removed all difficulties to the regeneration of society. M. de la Harpe had his own particular panacea for Russia, and THE SECRET COUNCIL 263 he explained it in such diffuse papers that Alexander himself had not the courage to read them. One of his favourite phrases was organisation reglementaire an important idea no doubt, but he used to repeat it so often and with such emphasis that it was at last attached to him as a sort of nickname. The Emperor, perhaps without admitting it to himself, began to think less of the capacity of his former tutor, though he was always seeking reasons for raising him in our esteem ; his character he always continued to value highly. He did not like us to cast ridicule on the inanity of M. de la Harpe's papers, and he was always much pleased when we praised any of his former tutor's suggestions. But in truth M. de la Harpe had little or no influence on the reforms which Alexander afterwards introduced. He had the good sense to hold aloof from our meetings, and the Emperor himself preferred this, in order, I suppose, to avoid the scandal which might have been produced by an ex-director of the Swiss Republic and a recognised revolutionist preparing reforms for the Russian Empire. He was, however, recognised as one of our colleagues ; there was always a chair ready for him at our meetings, and when he left St Petersburg he assured us that he would still in spirit take part in our deliberations. Immediately after the Emperor's accession the Margravine of Baden, mother of the Empress Elizabeth, hastened to St Petersburg, being happy and impatient to see again a beloved daughter from whom she had been separated for seven years. She was accompanied by the Margrave of Baden, her 264 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI husband, son of the reigning Grand-Duke, arid the Princess Amelia, the eldest of their children. These visitors represented an influence totally opposed to the principles which were at that moment being advocated by M. de la Harpe at St Petersburg. The Margravine was the sister of the first wife of the Emperor Paul,* who died in Russia while still young and beautiful, and was more regretted by the Empress Catherine, her family, and the whole Court than by her husband, who discovered after her death from some letters which she had imprudently kept that he was not the sole possessor of her heart.! The Margravine was tall, with a grand air and much dignity in her movements, and it was evident that in her youth she must have been beautiful. She had justly obtained a high reputation for wisdom, pru- dence, and wit, which placed her far above the generality of German princesses of similar rank. The Empress Dowager, instead of rejoicing at the prospect of the Margravine's influence counteracting that of M. de la Harpe, took umbrage at it ; the two princesses were too unlike each other to agree. Moreover, the Margravine had brought about the marriage of her youngest daughter with the King of Sweden, who had refused the Grand-Duchess Alex- andra.! This marriage, which at that time was * A third sister was married to the Grand-Duke of Saxe-Weimar ; she had a daughter who was married to the Duke of Mecklenburg, and became the mother of the Duchess of Orleans. I recollect that when the Duchess of Orleans arrived in Paris I was struck by her likeness to the members of her family whom I had known in Russia. (Note by Prince Adam Czartoryski.) t The gentleman who had attracted the Grand-Duchess's attention was Count Andrew Razumovski, then young and strikingly handsome. He made so many conquests among the ladies of St Petersburg that he was sent as ambassador to Stock- holm, and afterwards to Naples, where he gained the favour of the Queen. (Note by Prince Adam Czartoryski.) t See page 135. THE MARGRAVINE OF BADEN 265 regarded as the most brilliant in Europe, was a triumph of which the Margravine was very proud, and did not contribute to reconcile her with the Empress Dowager, especially as the eldest of the daughters of the House of Baden, the twin sister of the Princess Amelia, had married the Elector, who afterwards became King of Bavaria, while none of the Russian Grand-Duchesses had attained so elevated a position. On the other hand, the Margravine was disappointed to see that the Empress Dowager re- tained all the advantages of a reigning sovereign and had not given up any of them to her daughter- in-law. When Alexander ascended the throne, being desirous above all to appease the continual regrets of his mother since the catastrophe which had made him Emperor, he left her the dower of a million roubles which Paul had assigned to her at the begin- ning of his reign, and added nothing to the moderate allowance of which his wife was in receipt as a Grand- Duchess. The latter readily and graciously accepted this arrangement, which afterwards placed her in a painful position, and deprived her of the means of responding to the numerous applications for assistance which were addressed to her. The Empress Dowager continued to have the sole direction of various char- itable, educational, and even manufacturing, establish- ments with which she had been charged during the preceding reign, while the Margravine would have liked her daughter to take a more active part in affairs and to be in a position to distribute the largesses and benefits which one has a right to ex- pect from the wife of the sovereign. 266 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI I was very amiably received by the Margravine, and afterwards she honoured rne for many years with marks of her kindness. She often spoke to me about the Emperor with the most lively interest. She feared that the reforms he was contemplating would prove ill-timed, hurtful, and dangerous, and wished him to be dissuaded from introducing them ; she did not approve his tendency to diminish the ceremonial and the splendour of the Court, and she especially objected to his assumed simplicity of manner, which, she said, made those who approached him and whose duty was to obey him too familiar, thereby giving his Court an appearance ill-suited to the greatness of the Empire. She pointed to the example of Buonaparte, who, she said, was better acquainted with mankind and with what was neces- sary to obtain its respect, its obedience, and its admiration ; who surrounded himself by pomp and magnificence, and neglected nothing that could aug- ment the prestige without which supreme authority cannot be maintained. She wished to rouse Alex- ander's ambition, to make him profit by the lessons which so great a genius was then giving to the world, and to induce him to become Napoleon's rival without being his enemy, so that the acts of his Government, like those of the First Consul, should be continual proofs of greatness, of strength, and of decided will. The Russians, she said, want such a Government quite as much as the French. I communicated these conver- sations to the Emperor ; I thought some of the things said by the Margravine were just and true, and that they might strike him and be of use to him. But they THE SECRET COUNCIL 267 made no impression whatever. He admired Napoleon, but did not think himself capable of imitating him. They were two opposite natures, and their lines of action were different. It was not till many years after that a supreme danger, the boundless ambition of the ruler of France, and his incredible blunders, gave Alex- ander an opportunity of showing great though always defensive qualities, which enabled him to conquer his rival. After some months' stay, the Baden family left St Petersburg to visit the Queen of Sweden, the youngest sister of the Empress Elizabeth, at Stock- holm. During this journey a great misfortune hap- pened: the Margrave died in consequence of a carriage accident. This made it impossible for the Margravine to reign over the Grand-Duchy, and had fatal con- sequences for her family. During the summer of 1801 the Secret Council continued to meet. The only measure it decided upon before the coronation was the dismissal of Count Panin, whose participation in the conspiracy which brought about the death of Paul filled Alexander with dislike and suspicion. After much discussion it was resolved that Panin should be succeeded as Minister of Foreign Affairs by Count Kotchoubey, but should be allowed to remain at St Petersburg. The Emperor, wishing to avoid disagreeable scenes, treated Panin as a Minister up to the last moment, and this again was interpreted as a sign of duplicity. The Emperor's will was notified to Panin by letter, and Kotchoubey entered upon his duties to the great satisfaction of Alexander and of our council. So long as Panin remained at St Petersburg he 268 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI was surrounded by spies, and the Emperor every day received reports from the secret police stating in detail all that Panin had done from the morning till the evening, where he had been, whom he had spoken to in the street, how many hours he had passed out of doors, who had visited him, and as far as possible what he had said. These reports were read in the Secret Council, and were drawn up in the mysterious style affected by police agents to give a certain interest to the most insignificant circumstances. They did not really contain anything remarkable, but the Emperor was extremely anxious, and was always suspecting Panin of new plots. He had no peace till Panin had left St Petersburg, which he did soon after, knowing that he was everywhere pursued by spies, and that his presence was disagreeable to the Emperor. He subsequently received orders never to show himself in any town where the Emperor might be staying, and passed the rest of his life in retirement at Moscow or in the country. In this way three of ' ours,' as the members of the Secret Council were called by the Emperor, were placed in the sphere of practical affairs, and obtained experience of the difficulties and obstacles which are met with directly one becomes a wheel in the govern- ment machine. As for me, I had no ambition to serve Russia ; I was there merely by accident, like an exotic plant in a foreign land, with sentiments which could not, as regards their full scope, be brought into entire accord even with the intimate opinions of the friends whom accidental and quite ordinary circum- stances had given me ; and I remained the only THE SECRET COUNCIL 269 member of the Secret Council that had held aloof from practical life, and was glad not to enter it. I was often tired of my position, and yearned after my country and my parents ; I wished for nothing so much as to go back to them, and the only thing that retained me was my personal attachment to the Emperor and the wish to be able to serve my country through my influence with him. But this hope often seemed entirely to disappear. The dreams of my early youth had vanished like the morning mists before the sun's rays, and whose was the blame ? Could I expect of men more than they can or know how to give ? Those whose pretensions and hopes are in advance of realities and possibilities in this short life of ours are doomed to cruel disappointment ; but when one's illusions have gone, one hopes at least not to be deprived of some prospect of happiness, and this was in many respects denied me. I accordingly often thought of leaving St Petersburg. The Emperor spoke to me of Poland at more and more prolonged intervals ; when he found me anxious and discouraged, he returned to the subject, but no longer in the same way. He used to console me vaguely or keep silence on a matter with which he found it more and more difficult to deal, though it was the only real bond of connection between us. At the same time, while avoiding precise explanations, he wished me always to believe that on this point as on many others he had not changed his opinions or his intentions. But in his position what could he do and what could I reasonably ask for ? On my return to St Petersburg, I had no longer 270 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI found there Buonaparte's aide-de-camp, Duroc, who had come with another officer to compliment Alex- ander on his accession. Paul's death was a severe blow to the First Consul ; he had hoped much from a sovereign who would never admit that what he ordered was impossible. Fortune had favoured Buonaparte in his efforts to gain the good-will of the Emperor Paul. The news of the Russian prisoners who had been clothed and sent back to their country by France, and that of other advances skilfully made to Russia, had arrived at St Petersburg at the moment when Paul was in a violent rage with Austria and England, partly on account of the defeat of the Russian armies in Switzerland and Holland, which Paul attributed to the lukewarm ness of the allies, and partly because of the capture of Malta, which Buonaparte had offered Paul, and which the English, now masters of the island, had refused to give up to him, although he had already been appointed Grand-Master of the Order. Under these circumstances, Paul, always passionate and impulsive, took a violent fancy to Napoleon and the French Government, whom he had detested, and an equally violent dislike for the allies, who had been the particular objects of his affection and zealous support. As usual with him, his likes and dislikes became stronger as time went on. After the chivalrous challenge which I have already mentioned,* he concluded a maritime alliance with Denmark and Sweden with trie object of closing the Baltic to the English, and maintaining the inviolability of neutral flags. France, Spain, and Holland were to join their * See page 192. EUROPEAN COALITION AGAINST ENGLAND 271 fleets to those of the Northern powers in order to destroy the maritime supremacy of England. Paul had ordered the whole of the Don Cossacks to march at once to India under the command of their attaman Platoff; and although this order had spread consterna- tion among the Cossacks, and their chief did not know how to execute it, he was preparing to obey it. What would have happened if Paul had continued to reign it is not easy to say. Nelson's expedition to Copenhagen had certainly foiled the plan of a naval combination against England, but its success had been almost entirely due to Nelson's boldness and good fortune. If the Danes had had the courage to persevere, this rash enterprise might have ended very differently. So great, however, was the terror inspired by Paul that the Danes adhered to his alliance in spite of their defeat. He had ordered his coasts and his harbours to be placed in a state of defence, and I doubt whether the British fleet could without con- siderable reinforcements have attempted an attack upon Cronstadt or Revel ; if not, time would have been given for reforming and strengthening the alliance of the naval powers. Paul's sudden death at once dissipated all the difficulties of the coalition, and created new ones for Napoleon, as it lost him a powerful friend. In his infatuation for the First Consul, Paul had persuaded himself that it did not matter whether the ruler of France were legitimate or not, so long as he could make himself obeyed. He had accordingly expelled Louis XVIII from his dominions,* and encouraged * Louis returned to Russia after Paul's death. 272 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI Napoleon in his ambition to become Emperor of France. His death changed everything. The naval alliance lost its strength and value, there was no further necessity for fortifying the coasts and harbours, and trade, which had been suspended in Russia to the great detriment of the proprietors of mines and land, resumed its ordinary course, while the Don Cossacks, who had already proceeded on a day's march towards the Caucasus, turned their horses' heads homewards and crossed themselves in gratitude for the abandonment of Paul's insane enter- prise. The immediate result of Paul's death, so far as European politics were concerned, was an arrange- ment between Russia and England. The state of war which Paul had maintained against that power which had long been Russia's best customer for iron, corn, wood for building, sulphur, and hemp was one of the principal grievances of the Russian people against their Emperor, and immediately after his death the Government hastened to effect an arrange- ment with England which showed how eager Russia was to effect a reconciliation at any price. The interests of her maritime allies were not sufficiently considered, and essential points on the question of the neutral flag were either passed over in silence or left in doubt. The cessation of hostilities was the great object aimed at. Alexander had in reality no great sympathy for England. His education had given him ideas and inclinations totally different from those of the policy of Pitt ; and Napoleon's aide- de-camp Duroc was accordingly received by him with MISSION FROM NAPOLEON TO ALEXANDER 273 a sincere cordiality which was hardly to be expected in a moment of reaction against Paul's infatuation for the First Consul. Duroc's reception was, indeed, the result of Alexander's secret and personal sympathy for the principles of 1789, which had been inspired in him by M. de la Harpe. Alexander was glad to see at last Frenchmen of the famous Revolution, who he supposed were still Republicans ; he regarded them with curiosity and interest, having talked and thought so much about them. Both he and the Grand- Duke Constantine took great pleasure in addressing them as ' citizens,' thinking that the title was one they were proud of. This was a great mistake, and Napoleon's envoys had repeatedly to point out that the term had gone out of fashion in France before Alexander and his brother ceased to use it. Napoleon's chief motive in sending his confidential aide-de-camp to St Petersburg was to sound the young Emperor as to his feelings with regard to a French alliance. I was told that Duroc wrote to Napoleon that there was no cause for either hope or fear ; this statement was at the time perfectly accurate, and was founded on an exact knowledge of Alexander's character at the beginning of his reign ; but later on it was belied by events. Count Panin, who was then Foreign Minister, had concluded a convention with Duroc which did not mention any of the difficulties that had long sown discord between the two countries, and had prevented them from being at peace with each other. In this convention there was only one remarkable article, and it was directed against Poland and the Poles. VOL. i. s 274 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI Russia and France engaged reciprocally not to protect political refugees, and not to help them in their efforts against the order of things established in their respective countries. This article was aimed by France against the Legitimists, and by Russia against the Poles. Thus Alexander's first public act was an abandonment of the sentiments which had united us. He did not tell me anything of it, and it was doubt- less a very natural arrangement to make between two countries that wished to be on good terms with each other ; it was the necessary consequence of an agree- ment between Russia and France, which must be always fatal to the Poles. I made this remark with some sadness to the Emperor, who answered with embarrassment that the article had no real signifi- cance, that he could not avoid accepting it, as it had been proposed by France and agreed to by Count Panin, that it was a mere formality which ought not to cause me any anxiety, and that the destinies of Poland were as dear to him as ever. The best and most powerful man can do nothing if circumstances do not permit him to act and to keep his promises ; and it may safely be asserted that Alexander was the only sovereign of that time who, without publicly admitting it, still remembered and busied himself about the future of Poland. She had for the moment been forgotten by all Europe, with France at its head. Since the treaty of Luneville there had not been any Polish troops in France ; the legions were either broken up or sent to St Domingo never to return.* * The Polish legions were formed in Italy by Dombrovski in 1797, with the object of restoring Poland to her former independence. They rendered great services to France in her Italian campaigns, but were afterwards abandoned by Napoleon, who did not wish to offend the partitioning powers. MISSION FROM NAPOLEON TO ALEXANDER 275 Our patriots, having lost all hope for their country, had retired from the French service, and the glorious fall of Kosciuszko and the massacre of Praga had been effaced by the misfortunes we had suffered in other countries. No one thought of us, and it is not surprising that this general oblivion should have had some influence on Alexander's disposition in our behalf. Not having any wish to take a prominent part in Russian affairs, and often losing the hope which had sustained me of being able to serve my country, I continually had fits of depression and did not conceal my wish to go back to my parents. The Emperor, to fulfil his old promises and prove to me that he had not changed, generously determined of his own initia- tive to give the inhabitants of the Polish provinces he governed proofs of his good-will. This sometimes raised my spirits and consoled me for the impossibility of realising brighter hopes whose disappointment became the regret and torment of my life. In the two first years of Alexander's reign I had the happiness of rendering services to many of my countrymen who had been sent to Siberia either by Catherine or by Paul, and had been forgotten in their banishment ; these were restored by Alexander to their liberty and their families. Their sentences were cancelled, their confiscated estates were given back to them, either in land or in money, and the refugees who had served in France or in the legions were allowed to come back without any difficulty. The Emperor also interfered on behalf of the Poles confined in the fortress of Spielberg and other foreign 276 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI prisons, and his wishes were zealously carried out by Kotchoubey, Panin's successor at the Russian Foreign Office. The abbe Kollontay, who was regarded as the most revolutionary of the Poles, was set free and came to live and die in the part of Poland which was under Alexander's rule. Count Oginski and several others were also invited to return ; they were received with distinction and were given back their fortunes, which were in several cases considerable. The days of persecution, of political trials and en- quiries, of suspicious precautions, had gone by, and for some time the Poles were trusted and left at peace by their Russian rulers. The Emperor also wished to improve the admin- istration and regularise the course of justice in the Polish provinces. He looked for Poles capable of filling the principal posts, which had previously been occupied by Russians. Trials were expedited and made more equitable, both on the spot and in the third department of the Senate of St Petersburg, which was the final Court of Appeal charged with cases arising in the Polish provinces. These acts deserved our gratitude, but could not com- pensate us for the loss of our national existence, and they were far from realising the hopes expressed in the conversations of our youth. While consoled from time to time by the advantages which were granted to my countrymen, I could not see what more I could obtain for my country. My life was one continuous struggle between the consolation of having done some good and the regret not to say the self-reproach of never being able to reach the object of my wishes and ALEXANDERS CORONATION 277 hopes. When I felt that the realisation of the noble sentiments Alexander had expressed for my country was indefinitely postponed, I was utterly discouraged, and felt invincible disgust for the Court and all its members. Although on intimate terms with my colleagues of the Secret Council, I could not entirely confide in them ; their Russian thoughts and feelings, which they often expressed, were too incompatible with my hopes. It was to Alexander only that I could freely disclose my sadness and its cause. Our old intimacy, though it was more restricted, had not ceased, and while my position with regard to current affairs was insignificant, I still possessed the Emperor's confidence more than any one else ; when he was with me he was more confiding and more at his ease than with the others ; I understood him better, and could more freely tell him the truth about men and things, and even about himself. Our secret interviews were interrupted by the coronation at Moscow. The recollection of this ceremony, to which I have already alluded, left me a painful impression. I know nothing more disagree- able than these occasions, when everything is thrust out of its accustomed order. Festivals generally give me a feeling of emptiness and melancholy ; there is an inflated and exaggerated spirit about them which causes fatigue and is typical of the vanity of human things. The gaiety which u would be naturally; elicited by the occasion disappears directly it becomes obliga- tory. One gets tired of the long periods of waiting, during which one has ample time to think of the nullity of such pleasures ; and while surfeited with 278 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI inaction, one is incapable of action. In Russia these festivals are very sumptuous, and comprise innumer- able masked balls, banquets, illuminations, fireworks, and popular amusements of all sorts. I have seen so many of them that I look upon them with aversion, and I am truly glad whenever I can avoid them. The melancholy shed over the beginning of Alexander's reign was in strong contrast to the brilliancy with which it was endeavoured to invest his coronation. The father's tragical death and the sou's remorse deprived these fetes of the vivacity and fresh- ness they should have had, and the joy which was at first felt by the people at their deliverance from the fantastic tyranny of the Emperor Paul was followed by the exhaustion produced by deceived expectations, as often happens at the beginning of a new reign, when all classes imagine their hopes will be realised, and are always disappointed. The young and hand- some couple who were to be crowned did not look happy, and could not inspire a joy or satisfaction which they did not appear to feel themselves. Alexander had not the art of influencing and con- tenting those whom he wished to please ; this faculty, so necessary to a sovereign, was absent in him, especially at the beginning of his reign. The ceremony of the coronation increased his sadness ; he had never more strongly felt remorse at having contributed, though against his will, to his father's death. I again strove to pacify him by reminding him of the great task he was called upon to perform ; these exhortations were only partially effectual, but they contributed to r give him sufficient ALEXANDER AND FREDERICK WILLIAM III 279 self-command not to betray his despair in public. The recollection of that time is one of the saddest of my life, and I cannot recall it without painful emotion. The Court returned to St Petersburg: for the O winter, and our after-dinner meetings were resumed. They were soon interrupted, however, by the meeting of Alexander and the King of Prussia * at Memel in the spring of 1802. The Emperor was at that time beginning to pay special attention to foreign affairs. Kotchoubey, the Foreign Minister, had adopted a system which he believed to be in entire conformity with the Emperor's opinions and views, and at the same time with his own. This was to hold Russia aloof from European affairs, and to keep on good terms with all foreign Powers, so as to devote all her time and attention to internal reforms. Such was indeed the Emperor's wish and that of his intimate advisers, but none of them had adopted it with more conviction, or main- tained it with more persistence, than Kotchoubey. Russia, he used to say, is great and powerful enough both as regards population and extent of territory, and geographical position ; she has nothing to fear from any one so long as she leaves other Powers in peace ; and she has too often mixed herself Up with matters which did not directly affect her. Nothing had happened in Europe but she claimed to have a part in it ; she had made costly and useless wars. The Emperor Alexander was now in such a fortunate position that he could remain at peace with * Frederick William III. 8 o MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI all the world and devote himself to internal reforms. It was at home, not abroad, that Russia could make immense conquests, by establishing order, economy, and justice in all parts of her vast empire, and by making agriculture, commerce, and industry flourish. European affairs and European wars were of no advantage whatever to the numerous inhabitants of the Russian Empire ; they only lost their lives through them or had to furnish new recruits and taxes. What was necessary to their prosperity was a long peace and the incessant care of a wise and pacific adminis- tration a task eminently suited to the Emperor, with his ideas of reform and liberal government. This system was somewhat similar to that advo- cated by the English radicals. The idea is plausible and not without a basis of truth, but it has the disadvantage of reducing to insignificance and humi- liation the State which follows it too literally, as by so doing it incurs the risk of becoming the vassal and tool of more enterprising and active States. More- over, a consistent adherence to such a system would require much tact and firmness to avoid damaging com- promises, which, in the then existing state of European relations, would have become almost inevitable. This is what happened to the Emperor Alexander in the case of the Memel interview. The Prussian and Russian sovereigns had both expressed a wish to meet each other. The former thought this would be a means of facilitating to his advantage the question of indemnities in Germany, which at that time was being dealt with under the influence of France, while Alexander's sole object was ALEXANDER AND FREDERICK WILLIAM III 281 to become personally acquainted with his neighbour and relative. He had a liking for the Prussians and their King which arose from his military education at Gatchina, and he looked forward to seeing the Prussian troops, of whom he had a great idea ; he would, moreover, get an opportunity- of augmenting his knowledge of drill, uniform, and parades, to which he attached great importance. He also wished to make the acquaintance of the beautiful Queen of Prussia, and to appear before her and her Court as the Emperor of Russia. For all these reasons he started on his journey with much anticipation of pleasure, and he was accompanied by Kotchoubey as Foreign Minister, Novosiltzoff as Secretary, and Count Tolstoi, who had administered the affairs of his house when he was Grand-Duke, as Marshal. Tolstoi was sincerely attached to the Emperor, and was very zealous in his service ; but he possessed little intelligence or instruction, and was often laughed at by Alexander, though he placed implicit trust in his fidelity. At Memel, where the same sovereigns had after- wards to meet in very different circumstances, there were many parades, reviews, and balls. The Emperor contracted a personal friendship for the King of Prussia to which the latter afterwards owed the pre- servation of his monarchy, and the King hastened to take advantage of the good impression he had made on Alexander to secure his consent and support for the arrangements which were then preparing between Prussia and France with the object of withdrawing Germany from the influence of the Church. Kotch- oubey had been opposed to the interview, whose 282 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI consequences he foresaw ; he endeavoured to dissuade the Emperor from going to Memel, and went there himself very unwillingly. To interfere in the affair of the indemnities would be contrary to the principle of non-intervention adopted in the Secret Council, and would be playing into Prussia's hands. What especially displeased Kotchoubey in the proposed arrangements, and made him wish not to take part in them, was that the disposal of the indemnities was left entirely to Napoleon's good pleasure, and that the latter might consequently be regarded as the prime mover in the whole business. But the two sovereigns settled the matter personally, without con- sulting their Ministers a bad way of dealing with political affairs, as it necessarily makes dupes of those who are straightforward, disinterested, and generous. It was also at this first interview at Memel that began the Platonic coquetry between the Emperor of Russia and the Queen of Prussia a sort of connection which was especially pleasing to Alexander and to which he was always ready to sacrifice much time. It very seldom happened that the virtue of the ladies to whom Alexander paid his attentions was really in danger. The Queen was always accompanied by her favourite sister, the Princess of Sal in, now Duchess of Cumberland,* about whom there was much scandal- ous gossip. She relaxed the Court etiquette, made conversation more merry, and introduced more familiarity into intimate society. She was thoroughly informed of her sister's secret thoughts, and would have been of her secret actions if there had been any. * Afterwards Queen of Hanover. ALEXANDER AND FREDERICK WILLIAM III 283 After one of his interviews the Emperor, who then had transferred his affections to some one else, told me he was seriously alarmed at the distribution of the rooms which communicated with his, and that at night he used carefully to lock his bedroom door to prevent his being surprised arid led into dangerous temptations which he wished to avoid. He even said this plainly, with more frankness than gallantry, to the Queen of Prussia and her sister. On returning from Memel, the Emperor made a tour in Lithuania, and showed that he took an in- terest in the Poles by distributing some favours and repairing some acts of injustice, and at the same time holding out the prospect of further benefits. All this was very hurriedly done, as is usually the case during the tour of a sovereign in his dominions. When he arrived at St Petersburg, the treaty relative to the indemnities was made public, and it turned out to be a general distribution of ecclesiastical property in which Prussia had the largest share. In Paris the property was sold by auction : the First Consul took the leading part in the arrangements, but Talleyrand was entrusted with the details of the distribution, and as a] rule the highest bidder got the property. Right had little chance unless it had money to back it. Germany was parcelled out for the advantage of Prussia whose favour the First Consul wished to gain and of the distributors in Paris. The import- ance of France was sensibly increased, while that of Russia was greatly diminished ; she played a second- ary part and was led into giving her assent to an arrangement which was far from honourable in its 284 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI origin and the results of which she could hardly ap- prove. Kotchoubey was much distressed, and in the salons people talked of the insignificant part Russia had been made to play. France, on the other hand, boasted of her triumph, and the Prussian Ministers were delighted. In order to gild the pill for Russia, Napoleon offered sonic advantages to the houses of Wiirteinberg and Baden, which were allied with her ; but these States felt that their fate must ultimately depend on the good-will of France, and not on the power of Russia. " As for the Duke of Oldenburg, the Empress Dowager's son-in-law, he complained of the prejudicial effect of the treaty upon his estates, but he could not obtain any redress : Napoleon had been offended by his strong German feeling and his stiff manners. The meetings of the Secret Council were now resumed, and they had become the more important as three of its members Kotchoubey, Novosiltzoff, and Strogonoff were now in the service of the State. Novosiltzoff's ante-chamber began to fill ; men with new ideas sought and obtained employment. Many matters passed through his hands and were influenced by his liberal leanings. The Emperor found him useful for giving Russian forms to his European aspirations. We were also supported by some of the older and more distinguished functionaries of the O Empire. One of these was the father of Count Paul Strogonoff, who had passed the greater part of his life in Paris at the time of Louis XV. He had been in the society of Grimm, d'Holbach, and d'Alembert ; he had been a frequent visitor in the salons of THE STROGONOFFS 285 celebrated women, where the greatest noblemen used to meet men of letters ; his conversation was full of the anecdotes and good sayings of that day, and he had in many things adopted its opinions. He was very impulsive and enthusiastic, but the slightest obstacle sufficed to cool his enthusiasm. He was a singular mixture of the encyclopaedist and the old Russian boyard. His mind and his language were French, his manners and customs Russian ; he had a great fortune and many debts, a large elegantly furnished house, a good picture gallery, of which he had himself drawn up a catalogue, and an immense number of servants (including some French valets) whom he treated as slaves, though with great kind- ness. He was surrounded by disorder, and his servants robbed him ; but he did not care. He kept open house, and anybody could come to meals on certain days in the week. The society was less mixed, and included more learned men and artists, than at the house of the Grand Equerry Narishkin, and the complete absence of etiquette, together with the Count's extreme amiability, made his house very pleasant. He had taken a great liking to me, and was angry when I did not come to his dinners ; he treated me as one of the family. By natural inclination and by his French training the Count was liberal so far as his words and desires were concerned. He wished to give happiness and liberty to everybody ; but at the same time he was a thorough courtier, and the favour and consideration of his sovereign was to him a necessity. He was not ambitious or desirous of place ; but a cold reception or 286 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI a frown from the Emperor made him unhappy and deprived him of all energy and rest. He had been liked by Catherine, by Paul, and by the Empress Maria, and he was especially so by Alexander. The latter was his son's friend, and was very fond of the young Countess, who by her amiable character had obtained a great influence over him. At the old Count's he felt in his element, for he used to meet people who understood and appreciated those modern and liberal ideas which were at that time Alexander's secret passion. The special favour enjoyed by the Strogonoff family at the beginning of Alexander's reign gave the old Count more weight than he had ever had before, and as he was a senator, and his Russian manners had gained him much popularity among the nobility of the district of which he was Marshal, his enthusiastic approval of the new ideas which were supposed to be entertained by Alexander and the members of the Secret Council was very valuable to the latter. An even more important supporter was Count Alexander Vorontzoff, who was regarded in Russia as one of her ablest statesmen. He and Count Zavadovsky had been Count Bezborodko's friends ; they used to come to see him to talk about public affairs, and it is said that when they left Bezborodko used to have the doors and windows opened, and to wander about the rooms panting, fanning himself, and saying, ' Thank God, the pedagogues have gone,' as they were con- stantly reproaching him for his indolence and his yielding temper. They were, however, true friends. I do not know what induced Count Vorontzoff to THE VORONTZOFFS 287 withdraw from public affairs during the reign of Catherine. He used to have fits of bad temper, and his ambition was riot easily satisfied. While Paul was on the throne the Count had the good sense to remain in retirement, although Paul was very well disposed towards the Vorontzoff family on account of the liaison of Peter III with one of their sisters. It was only at the time of the new Emperor's accession that Vorontzoff reappeared at St Petersburg, with the reputation he had enjoyed during the reign of Catherine still further increased by his having so long and so wisely remained in retirement. He did not join the old Ministers, most of whom were in- ferior to him in knowledge and judgment, and whom it would have been necessary to dismiss in order to find a place for him. The position he assumed was a more elevated one ; he undertook the task of reconciling the Emperor's ideas with those of the old Russian routine, of moderating the changes which he foresaw might arise from Alexander's inclinations. It was easy to adopt and at the same time to guide them, and thereby to gain favour and power. Vorontzoff accordingly entered the ' young men's party,' feel- ing that in order to rise it was necessary to free one's self from the old traditions, and that in any new arrangement the first place would be secured to him. VorontzofFs brother Simon had also arrived at St Petersburg after a long absence. He had very fixed opinions and sentiments, and was always a blind and passionate partisan of any idea he adopted, or any man he chose as his idol. During the revolution 288 MEMOIRS OF PRIXCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI which placed Catherine II on the throne he was a subaltern officer in the grenadiers, and loudly declared himself in favour of the unfortunate Peter III, which did not prevent him from being afterwards employed by Catherine and appointed Ambassador in London. It is known that one of VorontzofFs sisters was Peter Ill's mistress, while another was a confidante of the Empress Catherine. The zeal he had shown in his youth for Peter III, induced the Emperor Paul to recall him from London to St Petersburg, and offer him the first posts in the Empire, but he refused them all and asked to be left in London. He had acquired friends in England by his noble, frank, and determined character, and had, so to say, taken root in the country. England had quite fascinated him ; he loved her more than the most bigoted of Tories, and he adored Pitt to such an extent that he looked upon the slightest criticism or even doubt as to his policy and doctrines as simple nonsense, and as show- ing an inexcusable perversion of mind or heart. Be- sides his worship of England and Pitt, he cultivated another which was more natural and of older date- that of his elder brother. He considered him the ablest and most virtuous man in Russia, and his decisions were to him oracles. His devotion to his brother was indeed touching, for it was quite spon- taneous and sincere. The two brothers were so united that they did not even divide the property left them by their father. Alexander, who managed the property, gave his brother his share, and there was never the slightest altercation between them on the subject. THE VORONTZOFFS 289 Novosiltzoff, during the years he had passed in England while Paul was on the throne, had been a frequent visitor to Simon Vorontzoff s house, to which he had been introduced by Count Strogonoff; he had gained his intimacy and confidence, and thus became a sort of bond between Alexander Vorontzoff and the 'young men's party.' Simon's arrival at St Peters- burg 1 made these relations more intimate and effec- o tive. His Tory opinions were regarded in Russia as extremely Liberal, and they had considerable influence on his brother, through whom they were transmitted to the Emperor, who was already elaborating a plan of reform. Alexander Vorontzoff was in no way opposed to certain Liberal ideas ; on the contrary, he was inclined to adopt and support them, and this inclination was fostered by the traditions of the old Russian aristocracy which had wished to limit the power of the Empress Anne when she was called to the throne. He once told me that in passing through Warsaw in his youth, during the reign of Augustus III, to make a tour in Europe, he had thought that nothing could have been better or more fortunate for o himself and his country than that he should be a great nobleman like those of Poland, with the same rights and privileges. The Russian aristocratic spirit of one of the brothers and the pure Toryism of the other both looked to the Senate for a solution of the problem. The basis and the source of all reforms should, they thought, be found in the Senate ; by that body alone could they be carried out without danger. Yet, though various plans were discussed in the Secret Council, nothing was done. This discontented the Vorontzoffs, VOL. i. T 2 9 o MEMOIRS OF PR1SCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI and they agreed with the ' young men's party ' to take a decided step to draw the Emperor out of the timid inertia in which he had entrenched himself. The country house of Kamienny Ostrog, where the Emperor then lived, was separated from that of Count Strogonoff by the river Neva, over which there was a bridge. The Emperor and Empress went to dine at Count StrogonofFs, and the Vorontzofts were also there. After we had got up from table, the Emperor walked in the garden and went into one of the pavilions, where he found Novosiltzoff ; we all followed him, and entered into conversation. Simon Vorontzoif had been chosen as the speaker on this occasion, as, having only just come from England, and being a stranger to what had passed at St Petersburg, he had a right to be regarded as impartial and to state his views freely. His speech was not as eloquent as we had expected ; the Emperor, who was very clever in raising objections and difficulties, re- peatedly disconcerted both Simon and his brother. They tried to prove to him that it was necessary to do something, that improvements were expected of a new reign, and that both Russia and Europe generally expected them, especially of him. These were only vague phrases ; and when the Emperor asked what line the improvements should take and how he was to proceed, the Vorontzoffs could only answer that if the authority of the Senate were re-established all diffi- culties would be removed. They held that this body, if restored to its power and dignity, would possess all the safeguards and the means necessary for bringing about the projected improvements. Each sentence in PLANS OF REFORM 291 Simon VorontzofFs speech began and ended with the Senate, and when he did not know what to say or answer he simply repeated the word. This affectation was somewhat awkward and ridiculous, and was more likely to chill the Emperor than to rouse him. The Senate had certainly much changed since its establish- ment by Peter I, and it could no longer be said even to have the power it enjoyed in the reigns which immediately succeeded that of the founder of modern Russia. In all difficult questions the Senate was al ways referred to, but it was nothing but a name ; it was composed of men who were for the most part incapable and without energy, selected for their insig- nificance, and it could not therefore act as a mediator between parties or be of any weight either on one side or the other. At length the Emperor's vague and floating ideas were consolidated into a practical shape. All the eccentric views which were mere fireworks were abandoned, and Alexander had to restrict his wishes to the realities and possibilities of the moment. He consoled himself by indulging in his hours of leisure, which were daily becoming more rare, in hopes of progress which enabled him not to give up entirely the dreams of his youth. These dreams seemed to me like a tree transplanted into a dry and arid soil and deprived of its exuberant vegetation, whose despoiled trunk puts forth a few weak branches and then perishes. The Emperor's first step was to issue an ukase or manifesto to restore the authority and dignity of the Senate ; this was a prudent course, cal- culated to predispose the public for the changes which 292 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI were to follow. In speaking of the Senate he spoke a language which the Russians understood and which flattered the nobility ; it was already the Supreme Court of Justice and Administration, for although every order of the Emperor, whether written or spoken, had the force of law, they had (especially those relat- ing to general administration and the civil and criminal law) all to be addressed to the Senate, which was entrusted with the task of publishing them and seeing to their due execution. The various depart- ments of the Senate were charged not only with trying on final appeal the civil and criminal cases of the empire, but also with punishing contraventions of the administrative regulations. It had the right of issuing ukases of its own founded on those of the Emperor, and, when necessary, explaining and develop- ing them ; and it presented him with reports for his approval. The governors and financial authorities of the provinces were under its direct supervision, and it was their duty to send to the Senate regular and formal reports upon which the sovereign gave such orders as he pleased. It was accordingly called ' The Senate administering the Empire.' Its vague func- tions, partly judicial and partly executive, were not in accordance with modern ideas, being so cumbrous in form that they retarded and might even em- barrass the course of government ; but there was no way of touching this ancient organisation without exposing internal affairs to even greater confusion, as the institution of the Senate had become part of the routine and the habits of the government machine. The Senate was consequently allowed to retain its PLANS OF REFORM 293 administrative functions, though it was intended to let them fall by degrees into desuetude. All its powers were confirmed in pompous terms of which the author was Vorontzoff, and to them was added the right of making representations on the Emperor's ukases. It was at the same time laid down that all the Ministers should make detailed reports of their functions, which the Emperor would send to the Senate for its opinion. This, it was hoped, would be a first step in the direction of national and representative government. The idea was to deprive the Senate of its executive powers, to leave it those of a Supreme Court of Justice, and gradually to convert it into a sort of upper chamber to which would afterwards be attached deputies of the nobility who, either as part of the chamber or as a separate body, would, for the Emperor's information, state their views on the management of affairs by the Ministers and on the laws which were in existence or in preparation. This plan was never carried out, and what really happened was very different. Those who think that the Senate of St Petersburg can ever be of any importance for the destinies of Russia are entirely mistaken, and only show that they do not know Russia. The Russian Senate in its present form is less able than any political body in the world to make itself respected or to act on its own initiative. It can neither give an impulse nor even receive one ; it is a marionette which one can move about as one pleases, but which has no motive power of its own . 294 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI Those who are tired of official life and wish to retire and live quietly in idleness are the sort of people who seek the appointment of Senator. The Senate thus becomes a receptacle for the indolent and the superannuated ; all its work is done by the pro- curators and the secretaries, who decide questions at their pleasure and then take the decisions to the Senators, who as a rule sign them without reading them. These decrees are drawn up in a more diffuse and tedious style even than the official documents of other countries ; the minutes in each case fill an immense volume, and it would require some courage to read them. One or two Senators who do read the decrees that are submitted to them for signature are spoken of with admiration as heroes. It is evident that such a political body is incapable of undertaking or following up any reform. After laying the first stone of the edifice of a regu- lated legislative power, and devising a limit to the autocratic power, the Emperor turned his attention to the organisation of his government, so as to make its action more enlightened, more just, and more methodi- cal. The government machine was irregular and intermittent in its action, and the administration was a chaos in which nothing was regulated or clearly defined. The only administrative authorities that were recognised were the Senate and the Committees of War, of the Navy, and of Foreign Affairs. These were not deliberative or consultative bodies ; one of the members of each committee, usually the president, brought the reports of the committee to the sovereign and then informed it of his decisions. The Procu- PLANS OF REFORM 295 rator-General united in his person the offices of Minister of the Interior, of Police, of Finance, and of Justice ; but sometimes the sovereign created separate departments, and the Empress Catherine placed the conquered provinces under the direction of one of her favourites, such as Potemkin or Zuboff, who were independent of the Senate and reported direct to the sovereign. Moreover, when the reports of the Senate and the various committees were handed to the sovereign by the Ministers or other high function- aries of State, they were often put away in a drawer, and after some time had elapsed a decision totally opposed to the one suggested was issued. Thus there was practically no bar to the caprices of the sovereign. Paul, who thought he was a great general, and was especially jealous of any control over the army apart from his own, appointed one of his aides-de-camp in whom he had confidence to examine and submit to him all the proposals of the War Committee, and all promotions and appointments. The direction of Foreign Affairs was nominally entrusted to a com- mittee of three members, each of whom worked with the sovereign separately, and had the management of some particular question which was kept a secret from his colleagues. This post was much sought after, and Catherine's favourites obtained some magnificent presents from foreign powers in employing for a negotiation with which they had been charged by the Empress one of the members of the Foreign Affairs Committee on whose complaisance they could rely. This was the case with Prince Zuboff and Count 296 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI Markoff, who were handsomely rewarded for advoca- ting the two last partitions of Poland. In the time of the Emperor Paul foreign affairs were often directed by his favourite aides-de-camp. The Vice-Chancellor or the eldest of the members of the committee only had the direction of the admin- istrative and financial branch, and of the current correspondence. This system suited an able sovereign like the Empress Catherine, who, notwithstanding its disadvantages and a complete absence of unity, still ultimately carried out a consistent policy. Paul, with his incessant caprices and changes of mind, yet had a most decided, almost furious, will which all the wheels of the government machine had at once to obey. But with a sovereign of vacillating character it is evident that the system of administration above described must lead to serious evils. The Emperor was continually exposed to making mistakes, to seeing only one side of a question ; he w r as liable to be confused by a mass of opinions from persons many of whom had an interest in not letting him know the whole truth ; and he could never advance towards a definite object. Russia therefore had reason to be grateful to the Emperor Alexander and those whose advice he then followed for having sought to introduce more order and method in the Imperial administration. The object of the reform was to establish a system somewhat similar to those adopted in most other European States by separating the departments, defin- ing their limits, assembling in each department matters of the same kind, centralising their management, and thereby augmenting the responsibility of the principal PLANS OF REFORM 297 functionaries of State. It was hoped among' other things that this would be an efficacious means of checking the numberless abuses and frauds which are the curse of Russia. The Emperor accordingly created for the first time Ministries of the Interior and of Police, of Finance, of Justice, of Public In- struction, of Commerce, of Foreign Affairs, of War, and of the Navy. As to the War Department, Alexander continued the system adopted by his father, insisting that everything relating to the army, down to the smallest appointment, should emanate direct from the sovereign, and that the army should know it. The post of aide-de-camp charged with the man- agement of the personnel of the army became gradually converted, in imitation of Napoleon, into that of Major-General, so as to show that Russia always considers herself in a state of war, and wishes to be in a position to make war at any moment. In the manifesto establishing the changes above referred to, it was stated that all the Emperor's ukases were in future to be countersigned by one of the Ministers an attempt to introduce the principle of responsibility and the Ministers were directed to meet in a council, in which they were to discuss the most important questions of State. This was a new administrative machine superior to the Senate, which retained all its functions and was invested with new ones ; but those which related to administration properly so called, became in its case almost purely formal. By the creation of the new Ministers the administrative authority of the Government was concentrated, while hitherto it had not had any legal 298 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI or definite status except in the person of the sovereign. The Council of State also was not changed, although some of its most eminent members became Ministers. The Emperor continued occasionally to refer to this Council various disagreeable or complicated questions, in order to give it something to do, and not let it die too soon ; but it speedily perished through its insigni- ficance, and Alexander afterwards created another Imperial Council on quite a different and much more extensive plan. These changes, which elsewhere would seem the very A B C of politics, seemed at that time to the Russians novel and immense. The manifesto made much noise in the whole Empire and especially in the salons of St Petersburg and Moscow ; each man had his own opinion of it, and the majority judged it not by its intrinsic merits or the benefits it might confer on the State, but by the effect it would be likely to have on their own advancement. Those who obtained places approved it, while those who remained in the cold criticised the juvenile infatuation that wished to change the old and venerable institutions under which Russia had become great. The personages high in office who had not been consulted, and did riot expect so considerable a change, were taken by surprise, finding themselves eclipsed by those who during the reign of Paul and the beginning of that of Alexander had held aloof. They strove to vent their disappoint- ment by smiling with pity at the young men who were trying to reform the Empire, and at the foolish- ness of some older men who consented to be the instruments of a servile and awkward imitation of PLANS OF REFORM 299 foreign institutions. The easy good-nature of the Emperor encouraged these criticisms, so far as they were possible in Kussia, and they found a certain amount of support in the Empress Dowager, who was annoyed, without admitting it, at not having been more consulted by her son and at not being able to influence his decisions. She perceived in all these novelties a germ of liberalism whose development she feared, and her salon became a centre of opposi- tion where people came to express their discon- tent. The head of the new administration was Count Alexander Vorontzoff, who was made Foreign Min- o ister, and also Chancellor a title of which he had long been ambitious, and which had not been given to any one for many years. Kotchoubey left the Foreign Office without regret, even with pleasure, as he thought nothing could be done in it under that system of impassiveness which he considered most suitable to Russia and most in conformity with the Emperor's character and his views and wishes ; he threw himself with extreme ardour into the new sphere of action opened to him by his appointment as Minister of the Interior. The important branches of police and general administration of which this department was composed had until then been buried in the mass of the functions attributed to the Senate, to the Procurator-General, and occasionally to some of the sovereign's secretaries. Kotchoubey had entirely to reorganise an administration which had been long neglected, and which in the more distant provinces was without any direction or supervision, 3 oo MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI and given up to all the abuses arising from the ig- norance and cupidity of subordinate officials. It was a noble and arduous task, and if he did not succeed as well as he had wished, it was not for want of zeal or good-will. He began by organising his office, dividing it into several sections, each of which had to deal with a distinct branch of the vast de- partment. He invited the assistance of all the able and experienced officials he could find, and en- deavoured to raise in general estimation the post of Governor of a province by appointing in that capacity men whose character and position afforded guarantees of integrity, and who, though inexperienced in official work, were likely soon to obtain the necessary knowledge. It seemed as if order was going to break through the chaos, and the immediate effects of the change were soon felt by the people. One of the reforms he introduced was in the supply of salt, which in Russia is a matter of great importance. This was not nominally a Government monopoly, but the Government alone was able to supply salt to all parts of the Empire by obtaining it from the salt marshes or distilling it from sea-water. Kotchoubey took steps to reduce the cost of production and of convey- ance to the lowest possible point, so as to enable the people to buy salt more cheaply, and the Government to be repaid its expenses. The new Finance Minister was Count Vasilieff, a capable and honest official who had in financial matters been the right hand of Prince Viaziemskoy, the only Procurator-General who had been mentioned with praise at the time of the Empress Catherine. PLANS OF REFORM 301 In the various changes which had taken place since the Prince's death in 1794, M. Vasilieff, as treasurer of the Empire, had been indispensable ; he was a steady worker, appreciated new ideas, and adopted them when he thought they were opportune. All the branches of the public revenue, the brandy traffic, the Imperial Bank, etc., were comprised in this depart- ment, to which was added the mines department, which had been reorganised on a larger scale. The functions of Minister of Justice were united to those of Procurator-General of the Senate. General Beklescheff did not wish to stop in this department, as it had been deprived of the greater part of its functions by the creation of the Ministers of the Interior and of Finance ; and he was succeeded by the Senator Dzierzanin. He was the personal choice of the Emperor, without communication with the Secret Council. A worthy man, and the writer of some much admired lyrics which were full of swing and passion, he was imperfectly educated and knew no language but Russian. The Emperor had been attracted to him by his ardent sentiments and poetic dreams, not being able to resist fine phrases ; the vaguer they were the better they pleased him, as he could then easily assimilate them to his hopes, which also were not very clear. He liked expressions of energetic liberalism, and was especially attracted by admiration of himself when it was couched in the language of devotion to the cause of humanity. The Emperor had direct and special relations with certain persons whom he himself introduced at our meetings ; he liked to patronise them and defend 3 o2 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI them against objections raised sometimes by people who knew them more intimately. It gave him pleasure to have these relations without the know- ledge of his friends, who already at that time had begun to displease him because they were so united among themselves. Yet it was absolutely necessary to introduce members of ' the young men's party ' into the administration, for all Alexander's hopes rested upon them for the zealous continuation and accomplishment of the reforms he had at heart. Kotchoubey was provided for, but what was to be done with the others ? It would be too much to make them Ministers, and it was accordingly decided that assistants to the Ministers should be appointed ; in this way the. Emperor's friends would be able to direct their chiefs in accordance with the Emperor's views, and to keep him fully acquainted with what was going on. Count Paul Strogonoff was at his request ap- pointed assistant to the Minister of the Interior, and Novosiltzoff obtained the post of assistant to the Minister of Justice, retaining his former appointment of Secretary to the Emperor. This gave Novosiltzoff the most important place in the administration, as it was through him that the Emperor was to begin the work of reforming jurisprudence and the existing laws. He was well qualified for the task, as he had studied jurisprudence and political economy in Eng- land, arid had made good use of the opportunities thereby afforded him of becoming conversant with those subjects. No one in Russia was at that time his superior in that administrative knowledge which PLANS OF ME FORM 303 was then only to be obtained by reading French and English works. His practical mind rejected all vain theories ; he possessed skill and tact in dealing not only with individuals, but with the Russian public, which he knew thoroughly. He had bad qualities also ; but these had not yet developed themselves. One of his greatest merits was that he seconded Alexander's wishes as to the improvement of the condition of the peasants, and he drew up the first ukase on this subject. He also reconstituted the commission for the revision of the law. This com- mission had been formed by the Empress Catherine, who thereby gained the flattering appreciation of Voltaire and the Diderots ; but the only result was the publication of the philanthropic and philosophical instructions addressed by Catherine to the commission. It was dissolved soon after, and its proceedings were never made public. The new commission was organ- ised by Novosiltzoff with the assistance of a German jurist, Baron Rosenkampf, on a vast and well-con- ceived plan. It was directed to codify all the exist- ing Russian laws, which were very numerous and often contradicted each other, classifying them accord- ing to subjects, omitting such as were obsolete, and adding new ones when necessary, but taking care to re- tain in the new codes all that had entered for many years into the life of the Russian people, even if not quite reconcilable with the ideas of modern jurisprud- ence. The system adopted was somewhat similar to that of Justinian ; but the task of the Russian codifiers was far more difficult than that of the Roman ones. The latter merely had to select and classify out of a 304 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI somewhat confused mass of laws, most of which were admirable examples of wisdom and legislative science, while in Russia the laws were not only confused, but in many respects defective and insufficient. For such a work not only jurists, but real legislators were wanted. A similar code was to be prepared for the outlying provinces of the Empire, such as Livonia, Esthonia, Courland, and the Polish provinces of Little Russia, each of which had its own particular language, laws, and customs. This great undertaking was begun methodically and pursued for some time with activity ; Novosiltzoff was allowed by the Minister of Justice to make it his exclusive occupation. The classifications were pre- pared by Baron Rosenkampf, and so long as they were adhered to the work progressed ; but it did not produce the results which were expected of it. This, is usually the case in Russia ; if there is no immediate result, the persons entrusted with the execution of the work are changed, and it has to be begun over again. I was the only member of the Secret Council who remained without employment. Alexander offered me, with Count VorontzofFs concurrence, the post of assistant to the Minister of Foreign Affairs, and all my friends, the Emperor especially, pressed me to accept the offer. I hesitated for a long time, feeling how much surprise and dissatisfaction such an appoint- ment would cause in Russia. The Emperor observed that during my mission to the King of Sardinia I had made myself favourably known by my despatches, and that iny nomination to the Foreign Office ought APPOINTED ASSISTANT FOREIGN MINISTER 305 not therefore to be a matter of astonishment, besides which Count VorontzofF, who alone had a right to be consulted on the subject, had consented to my becoming his assistant. I replied that he (the Emperor) knew more than anyone my feeling-s with regard to my country ; that they could never change, and that I had some reason to fear that they might be incompatible with the duties of the appoint- ment he wished to give me ; the safest and most proper course, therefore, would be for me not to accept it. To this Alexander rejoined that he did not at present anticipate any such contradiction as that which I feared ; that I should always be at liberty to give up my post if such a contradiction were to arise ; and that, on the contrary, he thought that events would occur which would be favourable to my views. He added some very flattering expressions with regard to my qualifications for the post. It is every man's duty, he said, to pay his debt to humanity ; when one has talents one must not refuse to employ them in the most useful way. I still declined, but Alexander was bent on my taking the appointment ; this was one of his irresistible fancies which nothing could induce him to abandon until they were satisfied. His persistence and kindness to me were such that at length I yielded, on the express condition that I should be allowed to resign the appointment directly its functions should become incompatible with my feelings as a Pole. My chief object in this was, by spending some years in the Emperor's service, to prove to him my sincere attachment and my grati- tude for his friendship and confidence. I accepted VOL. i. u 306 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSK1 with some sadness, as by so doing I was entering on a new career full of pitfalls which would retain me at St Petersburg, where I was always like an exotic plant which could not take root ; I felt I could not enjoy life unless I were with my own people. I will not pretend that I had more foresight and prudence than was really the case. In accepting the post which was offered me, I was determined not to do anything which might exercise an injurious in- fluence on the destinies of my country ; but I had no clear or decided idea as to the nature of the ser- vices I might be called upon to render to Poland in my new position. In this respect, a substantial bait was offered me as a reward for having at length yielded to the Emperor's wishes. He entrusted to me the direction of the schools in the eight Polish pro- vinces, which at that time constituted the whole of that portion of Poland which belonged to his dominions. The creation of a Ministry of Public Instruction was a remarkable innovation in Russia which was fruitful of great and salutary results, and posterity will owe gratitude both to Alexander and to the young men, then so much criticised, who supported him in his plans and gave them practical shape by dividing into special branches the confused organisa- tion which was then in existence. Nothing could be more wretched or insufficient than public instruction in Russia up to the reign of Alexander. There was an Academy of Sciences at St Petersburg which owed its only celebrity to the presence of some learned men whom the Government had brought to STATE OF EDUCATION IN RUSSIA 307 the Russian capital from abroad. Euler came when he was already an old man, and died there soon after. The transactions of this Academy were for the most part written in the French and German languages ; it had no relations whatever with the country, and exercised no influence on its progress. At Moscow there was a university which was equally isolated, and was attended by not more than a hundred students maintained at the expense of the Government. The only other educational establishments in Russia proper were the so-called ' National Schools.' The teaching in these schools was bad and extremely meagre ; the teachers were poor wretches whom idleness and ennui had rendered drunkards, and no respectable person sent his children to them. The establishment of the Ministry of Public Instruction completely changed all this. The existing universities of Moscow, Wilna, and Dorpat were better endowed, and three new ones were created those of St Petersburg, Kharkoff, and Kazan, each forming an educational centre for a prescribed district, in which it directed all the educa- tional arrangements. The University of Wilna was exclusively Polish, and during the next few years the whole of Russian Poland was covered with schools in which Polish feeling freely developed itself. This University, to which I appointed the njost distin- guished literary and scientific men of the country, and some eminent professors from abroad, directed the movement with admirable zeal and intelligence, and its consequences, which the Russians afterwards deeply regretted, seemed at that time to flow naturally from the Emperor's generous intentions with 3 o8 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI regard to the Poles. The University of Kazan was to look after the instruction of the Tartars and of Siberia generally. Each university had its curator, and the curators formed a council of public instruction, the President of which was the Minister. The persons appointed to these posts by the Emperor were such as to give a hope that the work of public instruc- tion would be pushed forward with zeal and success. General Klinger, commandant of one of the cadet corps, was appointed curator of Dorpat. He was a distinguished German author, with liberal opinions which might almost be called Utopian, although he had been in the service of the greatest despots ; his intentions, however, were good, and he was full of zeal for the advancement of science and instruction. His eccentric and dreamy views were expressed with a German bluntness which gave him an appearance of frankness and energy, and all this had gained him Alexander's favour. Count Severin Potocki was appointed Curator of the University of Kharkoff, which was the centre of a district the inhabitants of which were strongly desirous of obtaining the means of instruction. Count Severin, as a Pole, had been treated with great consideration by Alexander when he was Grand-Duke ; he had been admitted, like my brother and myself, into his familiar circle, and was one of his most enthusiastic admirers. The Emperor appointed him not only curator of Kharkoff, but also senator of the third department of the Senate, which issued decisions on appeals against measures taken by the administrations of the Polish provinces. Count Severin obtained some celebrity in Russia as a senator, STATE OF EDUCATION IN RUSSIA 309 and in his capacity of curator he showed zeal and perseverance. The universities which were most progressive were Wilna, Dorpat, and Kharkoff. The nobility of Livonia, Esthonia, and Courland did not look with favour upon the University of Dorpat, which had declared itself the protector of the peasants and the bourgeoisie. One of the professors of this univer- sity was named Parot ; he was a worthy man who expressed boundless attachment to the Emperor Alexander, and was very anxious about his health. Once Madame Parot sent a waistcoat, woven by herself, which she said would preserve the Emperor's life. Parot begged him to wear it, and by such manifestations of affection he gained Alex- ander's favour, and had private conferences with him during his frequent journeys to St Petersburg. The Curator of Moscow was M. de MouraviefF, one of the gentlemen formerly attached to Alexander's service when he was Grand-Duke, and also his former secre- tary. He was a worthy man, but excessively timid and quite devoid of energy. The Emperor appointed him assistant to the Minister of Instruction in order that it should not be said that young men only per- formed the duties of assistant, and that these posts were created only for the members of the Secret Council. NovosiltzofF was appointed Curator of St Petersburg. As there was already in that capital a faculty of medicine dependent on the Ministry of the Interior, and a faculty of law could not be established before the commission for the revision of the laws had ter- minated its labours, Novosiltzoff for the present 3 io MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI confined himself to establishing a faculty of philo- sophy, with the special object of training professors of the exact sciences, of administration, and of literature, This faculty began brilliantly by turning out some distinguished pupils, but they did not afterwards realise the hopes that had been formed of them, and the institution perished without leaving any durable results. A university with privileges and endow- ments would have better maintained itself, as was shown by the universities of Moscow and Kharkoff, which, though they declined, were still active in the midst of the indifference and oblivion by which they were long surrounded. Count Zavadovsky was appointed Minister of Public Instruction. He had been secretary to Count Romantzoff at the same time as Prince Bezborodko, and they had remained friends ever since. Count Romantzoff had presented them both as secretaries to the Empress Catherine, and this was the origin of their brilliant fortunes. Bezborodko, to whom I have already referred, soon rose by his great capacity for work ; he enjoyed the confidence of his sovereign and attained to the highest dignities. Zavadovsky's success was obtained by other means. The Empress made him her favourite ; he became attached to her and was very unhappy when after six months had elapsed he was dismissed. His friends Bezborodko and Vorontzoff endeavoured to console him, and the presents which Catherine always lavished on a dis- missed favourite were in his case richer than usual, as she recognised in him other merits than those which had merely attracted her fancy. He after- STATE OF EDUCATION IN RUSSIA 311 wards married, and continued to be well received at Court. His friendship with Vorontzoff, and the reputation for writing pure Russian which he had gained by certain manifestoes that he had written for the Empress Catherine, obtained him the post of Minister of Instruction. He was a man of just and benevolent character, but of somewhat stolid mind. He was not quick of intelligence, and did not perceive shades of meaning, while at the same time he wished to understand new ideas, and not to be reckoned among those who could neither learn nor forget any- thing. Yet he possessed in a high degree one of the most marked traits of a Russian administrator profound submission to everything that comes from superior authority. He was enthusiastic in his admiration of classic writers and was fond of quoting the passages he remembered. The literature of his own country also greatly interested him. By a singular accident he had learnt Latin in one of the Polish schools managed by the Jesuits ; he had not forgotten his Polish, and he prided himself on his knowledge of that language, speaking with much admiration of our ancient poet John Kochanowski,* some fragments of whose poems he knew by heart. All this gave him a certain predilection for Poland and the Poles ; as was shown even at his dinners, which always consisted of Polish dishes. While the other curators were often overruled in their projects by the Minister, who was not always disposed to yield to ideas of reform and progress, I never had to complain on this score. Vorontzoff * Born 1530. Died 1584. 3 i2 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI always trusted me implicitly, and he was always most kind in supporting every proposal I made. I owe him much gratitude for the condescension, the frank- ness, and the friendly feeling with which he always treated me. CHAPTER XIII 1803-4 DIFFERENCES WITH SWEDEN. THE CHANCELLOR VORONTZOFF's POLICY. THE FOREIGN AMBASSADORS AUSTRIA, PRUSSIA, ENGLAND, FRANCE, AND SWEDEN. ALEXANDER'S PROFESSED LIBERALISM PUT TO THE TEST. HIS FOREIGN POLICY AND THAT OF NAPO- LEON. PRINCE CZARTORYSKI BECOMES UNPOPULAR AT COURT. A DUEL. THE CHANCELLOR'S ILLNESS. NAPOLEON AND THE RUSSIAN AMBASSADOR. DIRECTLY after my appointment I was admitted to all the Chancellor's Conferences with the Foreign Min- O isters, and I drew up the protocols which he took to the Emperor. I did this work with much care, and to his satisfaction. A well- written protocol often gives precision and clearness to a desultory conversa- tion. Vorontzoff was satisfied with what I made him say, as it expressed what he thought, though in a more complete manner than he had himself done ; I had guessed his intentions, and this greatly pleased him. The practice I thus gained was very useful to me, and the conferences at which I was present enabled me to be fully informed of the relations of Russia with Foreign Governments. It was also my duty to draw up the despatches which resulted from these confer- ences, and the Emperor's rescripts to his Ministers 3 i4 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI abroad. Having accepted these functions, I threw myself heartily into the work. I sometimes wrote incessantly for eight or nine hours at a time. This produced a sort of nervous disorder which Dr Roger- son said might have serious consequences ; but I was young, and did not pay any attention to his counsels. Later on I had reason to regret that I did not do so. The policy of Russia was in essence the same under VorontzofF as it had been under Kotchoubey ; but it became stronger and more dignified in form. Its leading principle, which was well adapted to Alexander's character and projects, was to be on good terms with all the world, and not to interfere in European affairs, in order to avoid being carried too far ; in a word, carefully to avoid difficulties without appearing to fear them. The principle was not changed ; it was only the way of carrying it out that was different. The Russian Cabinet assumed a tone of hauteur which deceived people as to its true policy, and somewhat reminded one of the spirit of Catherine's diplomacy. The Chancellor was very careful to avoid any quarrel, or even slight estrangement, with any of the great Powers ; but he was not sorry when an opportunity presented itself to frighten the weak ones and crush them under the weight of Russian power. This is what happened with Sweden. The two Governments had a difference as to the possession of a wretched little island in a river which at that time separated Finland proper from the Russian province of that name. The point at issue was on which branch of the river was to be the bridge constituting the frontier. This question THE CHANCELLOR VORONTZOFFS POLICY 315 had been pending for some time, and the Chancellor resolved to cut the knot. He addressed Sweden in a dry and imperious tone, and I was very glad that I was not asked to write the despatches on this matter, which were in Russian ; my abstinence afterwards obtained for me proofs of confidence on the part of the King of Sweden and his Government. At the same time Russia seemed to prepare for a rupture, and Russian generals were sent to inspect the Swedish frontier. The Emperor himself went there, and I accompanied him with Strogonoff and Novosiltzoff. We passed along the greater part of the frontier on horseback. The soil mostly consists of a slight layer of earth on a substratum of granite, and there is some extraordinary scenery, with magnificent water-falls, but the country was not populous, and we often had to sleep in thinly scattered villages, at the houses of the clergy, some of whom knew no other language than the Finnish. The villages and parson- ages were surrounded by meadows, but the general appearance of the country was melancholy and arid. I refer here only to the portion of Finland which at that time belonged to Russia, as other portions are rich and abound in corn. Beyond the town of Abo the country looked more cultivated, and the people seemed more prosperous. We visited the disputed island, and the fortress and harbour in its vicinity, which in case of war were to form the basis of our operations. General Suchtelen, then commander of the engineers, and afterwards Russian Minister in Sweden, was having some works constructed in this fortress according to a new system of his own inven- 3 i6 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI tion ; it was more simple, he said, than those of Vauban and Coehorn, which it combined and made more effective. The King of Sweden was very obstinate in his resistance to the demands we had made in so imperious a tone. Count Stedingk, the Swedish Ambassador at St Petersburg, often expressed to me his astonish- ment on this subject, and shrugged his shoulders in speaking of the offensive way in which Russia dealt with a matter which in reality was quite unimportant. Sweden resisted for a long time, and we continued preparations for war. She had to give way at last, but the conditions imposed upon her were insignificant, and Sweden could not be mad enough to make war on account of them. The Chancellor was very proud of his victory, but it might easily have been obtained without humiliating Sweden which I think would have been preferable. The conduct of Russia left a bitter feeling in the mind of a neighbour which had already been often ill-treated, and which, notwith- standing its relative weakness, might on occasion do much harm. But Vorontzoff knew Russia, or at least those who spoke in her name. He knew that every demonstration of power, even if unjust, pleases the Russians ; that to domineer, to command, to crush is a necessity of their national pride. Not being able to overcome the strong, the Chancellor attacked the weak, hoping thereby to bring into prominence the } 7 oung Emperor's government. I am con- vinced that this was one of the motives which induced him loudly to proclaim his pretended victory over Sweden ; but the Russian public was not de- THE CHANCELLOR VORONTZOFFS POLICY 317 ceived. There was at that time in the two capitals among the civil officials and in the army the class which afterwards formed the elements of public opinion a vague desire of improvement, or rather of events which should be more interesting, more profit- able, and especially more flattering to their vanity. It must be admitted that the Emperor Alexander did not at that time have public opinion on his side, and this was indeed but seldom the case during the whole of his reign. At that period especially his conduct was too natural, his views too pure and too much in conformity with the welfare of the great majority of his subjects, to be appreciated by a country whose upper classes had tasted of a corrupt civilisation and had been excessively indulged in their avidity and vanity. The goodness, the kindness, and the pure intentions of Alexander as he then was did not suffice to make him popular. Notwithstanding all the Chancellor's efforts, no great satisfaction was expressed at the advantage gained by him over an adversary of such little importance as Sweden ; on the contrary, the old Minister was reproached for attempting to throw dust in the eyes of the public and take advan- tage of its vanity. Count Sauvan was then the Austrian Ambassador ; he used always to come to the Chancellor in full dress, and conferred with him in a very solemn manner. The policy of Austria was at that time lachrymose and sentimental. The peace of Luneville had only lately been signed,* and the Vienna Cabinet sought for consolation. Russia did not reject its mournful * On the 29th of February, 1801. 3 i8 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI representations, but only replied by assurances of interest and good-will which meant nothing. Prussia was represented by Count Goltz ; the only qualities which had obtained him advancement were a good memory, a knowledge of routine, and a kind heart, and he was completely under the domination of his wife, remarkable for a somewhat noisy and brusque vivacity. When Prussia, perfidiously violating the treaties of the past ten years, took her share of the plunder of Poland, he succeeded M. Lucchesini as Ambassador at Vienna. He treated me with a defer- ence which betrayed a feeling of regret, almost of shame, at the conduct of his Government towards my country. His predecessor at St Petersburg was M. Tauentzien, afterwards known as one of the ablest of the Prussian generals. While my mother was at Berlin on the occasion of my sister's marriage with the Prince of Wiirtemberg, he was an officer of the Guards, and often came to her house, w r here he was deeply smitten by Mdlle. Constance Narbutt (afterwards Madame Denbowska). She refused his offer of marriage, but the only result was that during his stay at St Peters- burg he often asked me and my brother to dinner. The relations of Russia with Prussia were purely personal between the two sovereigns, as there was no sympathy between the Cabinets, the armies, or the people of the two States. Prussia's equivocal conduct, her base submission to France, and the acquisitions which she obtained by it, were much disapproved by the Russians, who did not spare their sarcasms on the sub- ject. The Emperor, however, remained faithful to his friendship with the King, and to the high opinion he FOREIGN AMBASSADORS 319 had formed of the Prussian army. This perseverance, which was often blamed at St Petersburg 1 , was never- O ' theless of great advantage to Russia, as she managed thereby to attract Prussia to her side and make her a sort of satellite. England had just concluded the peace of Amiens. Her ambassador at St Petersburg was Sir John Warren, an excellent admiral, but an indifferent diplomatist. He was a perfect representative of the nullity and incapacity of the Addington Ministry which had appointed him. In those days the English Government was seldom happy in its choice of ambassadors. The diplomatic service, though much sought after, contained few able men ; the most important posts were given by favour or through party arrangements, either to satisfy some supporter of the Ministry or to obtain a few more votes in the House of Commons. Other promotions were entirely by seniority ; want of know- ledge or of intelligence was no disqualification. It was generally remarked at that time that there was neither ability nor zeal among the great majority of English diplomatists. All this is entirely changed ; the English diplomatists are now among the ablest in Europe. General Hedouville represented France. He had obtained a reputation as a General by his pacification of La Vendee, but he did not seem very likely to sustain the reputation of French diplomacy, whose cleverness and general ability seemed even to increase under the Consulate and the Ministry of Talleyrand. In selecting a Minister so benevolent and quiet, not to say tedious, in manner and conversation, the French 320 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI Government probably intended to reassure and tran- quillise those whose friendship it wished to gain. He represented one of those dead calms which in diplomacy follow or precede a storm. There was nothing important or even interesting in the relations of Russia with the other great Powers ; they reduced themselves, so far as I re- member, to an exchange of rounded phrases the drift of which was : ' Let us be quiet and avoid all embar- rassments and conflicts.' This feeling was shared even by the Governments which had suffered from the peace ; they would have been glad to strike another blow in the hope of regaining what they had lost, but they did not dare to confess it. Even England did not expect a speedy rupture. Austria groaned only in secret, and when she thought she could complain without compromising herself; while Prussia congratu- lated herself on her constant neutrality and looked upon it as a source of prosperity and progress. France, too, seemed to have turned all her attention to internal affairs. The First Consul was organising the administration and the laws of the country ; but all eyes were still turned to this vigorous sap which could not long be satisfied with the immense terri- tories it had already fertilised. All continental Europe feared France, while Russia, although she was both pacific and inoffensive, assumed a tone which denoted a consciousness of equal power and a feeling of independence. The relations of the Chancellor with General Hedouville showed a friendliness based on mutual consideration. A convention of no great significance was concluded, and the Chancellor took THE FOREIGN AMBASSADORS 321 the opportunity of offering to the French Minister the usual present of 4000 ducats and a gold snuff box adorned with diamonds and the Emperor's portrait. The Chancellor was ill, and received the Ambassador in bed while the ratifications were being exchanged. The presents were laid out on the bed, and I never saw a face so beam with pleasure as did the General's when he saw the bags of ducats. Forgetting all decorum and the little speech he should have delivered on the Emperor's portrait, his eyes were fixed on the money-bags, and he carried them away with an expression of delight which was quite comic. He was a very worthy man, however, and everyone would have been glad to see him so happy if he had been a little more dignified in showing his Among the members of the diplomatic body the most remarkable was Baron Stedingk, the Swedish Ambassador. He was distinguished both by his wisdom and by his noble sentiments ; with a simple exterior, his conduct also was marked by simplicity, by tact, and by perfect loyalty, and was strictly honourable in the highest sense of the word. He had that rare perspicacity which always appreciates both men and events at their true value. In his youth he had served with distinction against the English in the American war, and had been decorated with the cross of St Louis, which, being a Protestant, he wore with a blue ribbon. Afterwards, being honoured with the confidence of Gustavus III, he distinguished himself at the head of the army corps which fought the Russians in 1789 and 1790. When peace was signed VOL. i. x 322 he was appointed Ambassador at the Court of St Petersburg, where he was already known by his military successes. He remained at this post during three consecutive reigns, serving his country in the most difficult emergencies, without ever losing any of the high consideration he had acquired. Of all the men I ever met he seemed to me one of the best and the most worthy of confidence ; he was a man whom one could not help liking, and whom one would wish always to have for a friend. I think he was mine, so far as he could be in view of our different positions, which afterwards entirely separated us. As second in the Ministry, I was not obliged to take an active part in the difficulty which had arisen between Russia and Sweden, and the Chancellor wished to conduct the matter himself in order to gain the merit of having brought it to a triumphant conclusion. His insulting affectation of superiority, and the way in which he deprived a weaker power of a worthless island which was only taken to humiliate her, inspired me with pro- found repugnance, and, as I have already remarked, this gained for me marks of gratitude and confidence from the Swedes. The progress of internal reform in Russia was abruptly stopped by an unexpected incident. Count Severin Potocki, who, as I said above, was a great admirer of the Emperor, often addressed memoranda to him on various subjects. The Senate had received from the Emperor, among other important preroga- tives, the right of making representations to him, but it had hitherto not made any use of this right. Count Severin naturally thought the Emperor was sincere ALEXANDERS LIBERALISM PUT TO THE TEST 323 in his liberal opinions ; the Emperor himself thought so ; and the Count therefore imagined it would be a good thing, and would please his Imperial master, if the Seriate were prompted to exercise its preroga- tives. For this an opportunity soon presented itself. Although almost every noble in Russia entered the army, he was not obliged to do so, and could leave it when he thought proper. This double privilege was granted by Peter III in an ukase for which many blessed his memory. Alexander, however, restricted the privilege to nobles who held the rank of officer ; those below that rank were obliged to serve for twelve years. This was looked upon as an attack on the guaranteed rights of the nobility, and pro- duced a deep and painful sensation. The Minister of War, an old military bureaucrat of low origin, was said to be the author of the new ukase, and Count Severin Potocki proposed to the Senate that it should address representations to the Emperor on this violation of the nobles' charter. His proposal was read to the general assembly of all the departments, and the senators, seeing that one of the confidential advisers of the Court was taking the initiative in the matter, and that his opinion was warmly supported by Count Strogonoff, thought they could safely vote in its favour. They gladly did this, under the impression that by so doing they could without danger assume an air of independence in a matter to which it was believed the Emperor did not attach any serious importance. Count Severin's proposal was adopted, notwithstand- ing the opposition of the Procurator-General (Minister of Justice), which was supposed to be feigned in order 324 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI to give more appearance of reality to the little scene which it was believed had been got up for the occasion. Count Strogonoff, who was deputed with two other senators to take the representations of the Senate to the Emperor, readily set out on his mission ; but the deputation was received by Alexander very coldly, and Strogonoff, disconcerted and not knowing what to say, withdrew. The Emperor sharply reprimanded the Senate, ordered it not to meddle with things which did not concern it, and directed it by a new decree to carry out the very ukase against which it had appealed. To my great astonishment it was Novosiltzoff who was the agent of the Emperor's unjust anger in this matter. This failure of the first move of the Senate in the direction of liberalism sufficed to discourage people whose generous aspira- tions were not, it must be admitted, very strong. The Senate did not again attempt any independent action, and its rights became a dead letter. At my first interview with the Emperor after this incident, I could not help smiling at his extreme alarm in presence of the new attitude of the Senate. My jocular remarks on this point were ill received by Alexander, and I believe they left in his mind a certain anxiety as to my liberal tendencies which afterwards came back to him. This was an indication of Alexander's true character, which then appeared to ine in a novel and unfortunately too real light. Grand ideas of the general good, generous sentiments, and the desire to sacrifice to them part of the Imperial authority, and resign an immense and arbitrary power in order the better to secure the future happiness of ALEXANDERS LIBERALISM PUT TO THE TEST 325 the people, had really occupied the Emperor's rnind and did so still, but they were rather a young man's fancies than a grown man's decided will. The Emperor liked forms of liberty as he liked the theatre ; it gave him pleasure and flattered his vanity to see the appearances of free government in his Empire ; but all he wanted in this respect was forms and appearances ; he did not expect them to become realities. In a word, he would willingly have agreed that every man should be free, on the condition that he should voluntarily do only what the Emperor wished. Alexander never forgot Count Severin's indiscre- tion ; he was still received at Court on the same footing as heretofore, but he no longer shared the confidence and favour of his sovereign. The incident gained him great credit at Moscow and in the ancient provinces of the Empire, where he was regarded as a true Russian patriot and a generous defender of the immunities of the nobility. This wave of popularity had so much charm for the Count that it made him forget his old Polish sentiments. In his youth, at the diet of the 3rd of May, he had been an ardent Polish patriot ; in his old age he forgot his country, thought only of augmenting his fortune and living pleasantly, and amused himself by opposing the Russian Government. He got into the habit of travel- ling continually between his estates and the Senate, reading much on the journey, and preparing the speeches which he made every year either at Moscow or at St Petersburg. His mind tended rather towards doubt than action ; he seldom expressed any positive 326 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI opinion, and sentiment did not in any way affect his decisions, which were invariably prompted by con- siderations of personal interest. His self-love was greater than his fear, which could not indeed be very great, as Alexander, at that time especially, never persecuted anybody, and his displeasure could be in- curred without danger. Count Severin retained as long as he liked his appointments of senator and curator, which gave him a circle of activity that pleased him. He was able and well informed, but made light of everything except what touched his material interests, and had no religious sentiments whatever. Such a man was destined to end his days without friends or sympathy. I did not see him again. Alexander had given him the use of a con- siderable estate for fifty years ; I had done my best to arrange the matter, and later on I did some service to his son Leo. All this established a reciprocity of good feeling between us which lasteM as long as I was in Russia, and afterwards gradually died out. If it had been in the nature of man to be satisfied with what is practicable, Alexander ought to have satisfied the Russians, for he gave them a tranquillity, a prosperity, and even a degree of liberty which were unknown before his reign. But the Russians wanted something else. Like the gambler who seeks violent emotions, they were tired of the monotony of their prosperity. They did not like their } T oung Emperor : he was too simple in his manners, too averse to pomp, too disdainful of etiquette. The Russians regretted the brilliant Court of Catherine and its abuses, the opening which it gave to so many passions, struggles^ ALEXANDER'S POLICY AND THAT OF NAPOLEON 327 intrigues and successes. They regretted the days of the Imperial favourites, and the possibility of gaining colossal positions and fortunes like those of Orloff and Potemkin. The courtiers had no ante-chambers to go to, and sought in vain for an idol before which they could burn their incense ; their platitude was condemned to inaction, and there was no one to whom they could cringe and bow. The grumblers at Moscow, too, did not like the Court because it no longer afforded food for their censure, while it did not offer them any of the advantages which they valued. Their liberalism, moreover, was very different from that of the Emperor Alexander ; he inclined rather to the democratic and levelling ideas of the Emperor Joseph of Austria, though in a milder form. Only the Empress Dowager attempted to main- tain the customs and the brilliancy of the old Court. Alexander's Court was of an exaggerated simplicity, totally devoid of etiquette, and he met his courtiers only on intimate and familiar terms. The Emperor and his family only appeared in full dress on Sundays and holidays, when they went to church. Dinners and soirees were mostly given in the private apartments, and were quite different from what they had been in the preceding reigns. Later on, Alexander became more sumptuous in his receptions, but at the beginning of his reign he was not sufficiently so. While Napoleon surrounded himself with a pomp and ceremonial re- vived from the times of the monarchy, Alexander liked to eclipse himself and to behave like an ordinary citizen. His friends found fault with him for this especially the Margravine of Baden, his mother-in- 328 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI law, who wanted to give the young Emperor every possible quality and success. She endeavoured to stimulate him by the example of Napoleon, but in vain. The two Emperors went in opposite directions in everything ; one demolished, while the other re- stored, old ideas ; and the comparison made between them was not to Alexander's advantage in the eyes of the very Russians for whom he was working. He was, in fact, not at all popular during the first few years of his reign, although he was never more devoted than he was then to the good of his country. But men want to be dominated and fooled, and this neces- sity is nowhere so much felt as in Russia. At the beginning of his reign, Alexander did not know how to do this ; he learnt it later, but even then, and notwithstanding his great success, he never attained the popularity and the moral power of his grand- mother, who could have said of the Russians, as Buonaparte said of the French, that they were in her pocket. The Emperor had made it a maxim to respect other people's opinions, and not to punish anybody for expressing them, so that no great courage was required to criticise the sovereign and tell him unpleasant truths. Full advantage was taken of this privilege, especially in the salons of the two capitals. Every- thing that the Government did was found fault with, and these criticisms, growing like the waves of a heavy sea, used in the same way to subside and grow again at the least breath of wind. Such was the constant state of opinion in Russia during the first year of Alexander's reign. The old courtiers used to THE PRINCE BECOMES UNPOPULAR AT COURT 329 say, in order to calm the anxiety of the young ones, that all new reigns began in the same way, and that the first years of the reign of Catherine were marked by the same pre-occupations. What people most ob- jected to, however, in the case of Alexander, was my presence at his Court, and my appointment as assistant to the Minister of Foreign Affairs. ^A o merely honorary title would not have shocked the Russians, but they could not accustom themselves to see me at the head of the department : a Pole enjoying the confidence of the Emperor, and initiated into all the secrets of State, was to them an intolerable innovation.* This was a fertile subject of suspicion and calumny in the Russian salons. My parents had always been averse to Russian influence, and their fortune had been confiscated on account of their participation in Polish revolutions. That their son, who had never concealed his enthusiastic devotion to his country's cause, who had often loudly proclaimed it, and proved it by the national spirit in which he promoted public instruction in the Polish provinces, should be the intimate and confidential adviser of the sovereign, was naturally the subject of much comment. It was easy to imagine that I betrayed the interests of Russia, and that I would at any moment prove false to my duties as a Minister and a friend in order to advance the cause of Poland. All the ambitious men who thought themselves more worthy of the Emperor's confidence than a stranger all the young men of * ' Prince Czartoryski, ' says Lord Whitworth in a despatch to Lord Hawkesbury (in the Record Office), dated January 4, 1803, 'for some years past the intimate and most confidential friend of the present Emperor of Russia, ... is now second in point of precedency, but perhaps first in point of influence, in the Foreign Depart- ment.' 330 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI Alexander's Court were agreed on this point. But their suspicions were unfounded. I do not think I have ever been more zealous and devoted than I was in the Emperor's service. He knew better than any- one my attachment to my country, and it was this knowledge which was the first basis of our intimate relations and the source of the esteem and friendship with which he honoured me. He did not at that time think that the welfare of Russia was really incompatible with that of Poland. Perhaps he did not have a very clear idea of that grave question, and as its solution appeared distant, he did not think it necessary to go very deeply into it. Meanwhile he accepted the services which I cordially rendered him, and he thought it just and proper to reward them by giving me a certain liberty of action in regard to the Polish provinces under his rule. I of course availed myself of this concession ; I reorganised public in- struction in Poland on a larger and more national basis, and made it more conformable with modern ideas. The Russians could not understand my rela- tions with Alexander, and indeed they were only to be explained by the fact that we were both very young and had become friends at an age when generous impulses are stronger than reflection. The Russians, however, attributed our connection to personal ambi- tion and dissimulation on my part and silly good- nature on that of Alexander. They imagined that I secretly favoured France, and that I wished to bring Alexander under the fascination of Buonaparte's genius. It was to my influence that they ascribed the some- what colourless policy adopted by the Emperor in THE PRINCE BECOMES UNPOPULAR AT COURT 331 European politics, which they thought arose from my connivance with France. This was also the Empress Dowager's opinion, and she propagated it among the young officers of the army. My position was not an easy one. The part played by Russia was certainly not so brilliant or preponderant as might have been desirable, and was not at all in accordance with Russian vanity or Russian pretensions. Alexander was eclipsed by Napoleon, who, at the pinnacle of military glory, introduced into diplomacy, hitherto so discreet, that bluntness and rapidity of decision which were the secrets of his success on the battlefield. He took the initiative in every European question, and daily gained ground, increased his preponderance, and showed that he intended to become the arbiter of Europe. I constantly heard Russians complain of the weakness and want of dignity of their Cabinet ; and if I had ascribed these faults to Alexander's character and opinions, I would have cast the whole blame upon him. Among the most active and ambitious of the malcon- tents was the young Prince Dolgorouky. He was the prime mover of the Russian party, and his passionate vexation at seeing a stranger occupy a post which he considered should have been given to him made him witty, much to the surprise of his friends. Being one of the Emperor's aides-de-camp, he was con- tinually at Court, and I often met him, on which occasions he used to pursue me with reproaches and sarcasms on the indolence of the Russian Foreign Office. He provoked me so far that I once told him he should address his remarks to the Chancellor, 332 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI who was the head of the department. He replied that he knew well there was an understanding between the Chancellor and myself to refer matters from one to the other in order to avoid the diffi- culty of a precise answer. The discussion almost became a quarrel, and the Emperor had to interfere to put a stop to Dolgorouky's remarks. We no longer spoke to each other, but he continued his in- trigues with more animosity than ever. Under the reign of Paul we had been on very good terms, and he had shown me much confidence in an affair of honour which he had with M. de Wintzingerode, a worthy German, very stiff and punctilious. Having quarrelled with Dolgorouky, he challenged him, and both agreed to take me as the only witness of the duel. The scene of the encounter was a garden, and I loaded the pistols and placed the adversaries in such a way as to make it exceedingly difficult for them to hit each other. The result was that both missed, and the incident was closed by a complete reconciliation. The Chancellor's health now began to break down. He was several times seriously ill, and he often thought of temporarily retiring to his estates near Moscow, though he had no wish to withdraw from political life altogether. One day when he was ill I was seated by his bed ; he was in a high fever, and speaking with much animation, though somewhat delirious, he said several times : ' These young men wish to govern everything, but I will not allow it ; I alone will remain at the head of affairs.' I thought it probable that some one had led him to suspect those THE CHANCELLORS ILLNESS 333 who were called the Emperor's friends ; perhaps these suspicions had spontaneously arisen in his mind. I am convinced, however, that he never distrusted me, or listened to the insinuations which people made against me. The extreme and entire confidence which he showed me lasted to the end of his life, which is surprising, as so many people had an interest in making us quarrel. He gave his confidence and friendship to very few people ; his sentiments were delicate and noble, and although they were not based on strict principle, they showed that he was kind- hearted and sensitive. Always inclined to render a service, he judged others with great indulgence, and even at times when he spoke his mind most freely, I have never detected in him any feeling of hatred or desire for revenge. The Emperor, however, had an invincible dislike for him, which increased every day. His somewhat old-fashioned manners, his voice, his deliberate way of speaking, even his gestures, were antipathetic to him. During his frequent attacks of illness, the Chancellor used to send me with his papers to the Emperor, and the latter expressed his joy at not being obliged to see him. In spite of all I said in his behalf, he used to ridicule the old Minister, and often told me he would like to be rid of him. I was at this time in high favour with the Emperor, and he spoke with marked approval of my drafts of despatches and rescripts. He in no way opposed the Chancellor's wish for rest ; on the contrary, he encouraged it in every way. The friendly relations which had hitherto existed between Russia and France began about this time to 334 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI be disturbed. Count Markoff, supposed to be the ablest man in Russia, and the prototype and almost the last living representative of the diplomacy of Catherine, had been sent as Ambassador to Paris. When Paul became Emperor Markoff fell into disgrace, and was banished to Podolia, on one of my father's confiscated estates. After Alexander's acces- sion he hastened back to the capital, and Count Panin, who was then Foreign Minister, fearing in him a dangerous rival, decided to send him on a mission abroad. The most important task in foreign affairs was at that time the renewal of friendly relations with France, and for this it \vas necessary to send Napoleon an Ambassador capable of controlling and restraining his policy, and sustaining the dignity of Russia. Markoff, who was selected for this post, accepted it with eagerness, for he knew Alexander did not like him, and he was pleased at the idea of playing an important part in a capital where Napoleon and other personages already celebrated were influenc- ing the destinies of the world. He did not, however, justify his reputation,* which had already been impaired by his extraordinary want of tact in the affair of the proposed marriage of the King of Sweden with the Grand Duchess Alexandra, which was the cause of Catherine's death. Notwithstanding his aversion for Napoleon and his Ministers, Markoff did not succeed in preventing the dismemberment of Germany to compensate the princes who had lost part of their * Lord Whitworth, then English Ambassador in Paris, says of him : ' He has not the talent of inspiring confidence, and indeed his conduct here is such as to render any confidential intercourse with him extremely dangerous. ' (Despatch to Lord Hawkesbury of November 1C, 1802, in the Record office). NAPOLEON AND THE RUSSIAN AMBASSADOR 335 dominions, and to indulge the avidity of Prussia. The Convention was sent to the Emperor for his approval after it had been concluded, and when it was too late to make any change in it. A more favourable result would no doubt have been difficult to obtain, but Markoff did not even attempt to do so ; he did not give the Cabinet of St Petersburg the necessary time to state and defend its opinions, and compelled it to accept the Convention like a child forced to obey orders. He was a creature of the Zuboffs, and he had voted with them for the partition of Poland ; he was the incarnation of an unscrupulous State policy and a diplomacy without justice or pity ; very extra- vagant, he was inflexible in money affairs, and though fond of presents, he would not take them if by so doing his pride w^ould suffer. His face, seamed with the smallpox, constantly expressed irony and scorn ; his round eyes and his mouth, depressed at the corners, resembled those of a tiger. Though he had adopted the language and the grand airs of the Court of Versailles, his manners were haughty and rude. He spoke, excellent French, but what he said was gener- ally harsh, trenchant, disagreeable, and totally devoid of feeling. Such w r as the pearl of Russian diplomatists sent to Napoleon by Russia in evidence of her desire to be on good terms with him. He was at first received with much distinction, and he satisfied the First Consul by his complaisance in the matter of the indemnities ; but after a time his scornful manner and his sarcasms irritated Napoleon and gave rise to violent scenes. One evening the latter looked about 336 MEMOIRS OF PRINCE ADAM CZARTORYSKI for a Pole to give him an opportunity of venting his bile on the Russian Ambassador, thinking thia would be the best way of mortally offending him. Seeing M. Z. . ., a stupid and insignificant person- age who happened to be present, he took him by the button of his coat, moved him forward into the middle of the room, and after asking him whether he was a Pole, violently condemned the partition of Poland anc, the Powers which had committed and allowed it, aftei which he left without taking any notice of Markoff Shortly after, the French Government sent a despatcl, to St Petersburg complaining of MarkofFs conduct , but the Chancellor, feeling the necessity of demonstra tively asserting the dignity of Russia, proposed the Emperor that Markoff should be invested wii the ribbon of St Andrew, which he had long desire The Emperor entirely approved of this proposal, an Markoff appeared at his next audience of Napoleo decorated with the order, and looking more proud an satisfied than ever. This time the First Consul IK not the laugh on his side ; but Markoff did not thir it right to remain in Paris after his triumph, and r. was recalled at his own request. END OF VOL. I RETURN TO "* 1 1 1C si WlO ilVJ do i =< 53 pK I =O I WCElfju \\\EUNIVER5/A < cc OQ