She stopped with her hand on the banister, like Louise of Prussia 
 
.LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 BY 
 
 ALICE DUER MILLER 
 
 Author of "Come Out of the Kitchen," etc. 
 
 ILLUSTRATED BY 
 PAUL MEYLAN 
 
 NEW YORK 
 
 THE CENTURY CO, 
 
 1917 
 
Copyright, 1917, by 
 THE CENTURY Co. 
 
 Copyright, 1917, by 
 INTERNATIONAL MAGAZINE Co 
 
 Published, October, 1917 
 
 
LIST OE ILLUSTRATIONS 
 
 PAGE 
 
 She stopped with her hand on the banister, like 
 
 Louise of Prussia Frontispiece 
 
 And then, with a clean towel, he deliberately dried 
 
 her hands, finger by finger 69 
 
 11 Isn't that rather a reckless way for a man in your 
 
 situation to talk ?" 91 
 
 " Well, heaven itself can't save a fool," said Mrs. 
 
 Almar 119 
 
 It was arranged that he was to bring Dorothy to 
 
 dine with them that evening 147 
 
 He stood like a rock under her caress . . . . 173 
 
 " May I ask, Mr. Riatt, what rights in the matter 
 
 you consider that you have? " Linburne pursued 199 
 
 " Max," she said, " I love you "...... 241 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 CHAPTER I 
 
 MRS. USSHER was having a small house 
 party in the country over New Year's Day. 
 This is equivalent to saying that the half dozen 
 most fashionable people in New York were out of 
 town. 
 
 Certain human beings are admitted to have a 
 genius for discrimination in such matters as objects 
 of art, pigs or stocks. Mrs. Ussher had this same 
 instinct in regard to fashion, especially where 
 fashions in people were concerned. She turned 
 toward hidden social availability very much as the 
 douser's hazel wand turns toward the hidden 
 spring. When she crossed the room to speak to 
 some woman after dinner, whatever that woman's 
 social position might formerly have been, you could 
 be sure that at present she was on the upward 
 wing. When Mrs. Ussher discovered extraordi- 
 nary qualities of mind and sympathy in some 
 
 * 3 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 hitherto impossible man, you might be certain it 
 was time to begin to book him in advance. 
 
 Not that Mrs. Ussher was a kingmaker; she 
 herself had no more power over the situation than 
 the barometer has over the weather. She merely 
 was able to foretell; she had the sense of approach- 
 ing social success. 
 
 She was unaware of her own powers, and really 
 supposed that her sudden and usually ephemeral 
 friendships were based on mutual attraction. The 
 fact that for years her friends had been the small 
 group of the momentarily fashionable required, 
 in her eyes, no explanation. So simple was her 
 creed that she believed people were fashionable 
 for the same reason that they were her friends, 
 because " they were so nice." 
 
 During the short period of their existence, Mrs. 
 Ussher gave to these friendships the utmost loyalty 
 and devotion. She agonized over the financial, 
 domestic and romantic troubles of her friends; she 
 sat up till the small hours, talking to them like a 
 schoolgirl; during the height of their careers she 
 organized plots for their assistance ; and even when 
 their stars were plainly on the decline, she would 
 
 4 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 often ask them to lunch, if she happened to be 
 alone. 
 
 Many people, we know, are prone to make 
 friends with the rich and great. Mrs. Ussher's 
 genius consisted in having made friends with them 
 before they were either. When you hurried to her 
 with some account of a newly discovered treasure 
 -. a beauty or a conversable young man she 
 would always say: " Oh, yes, I crossed with her 
 two years ago," or " Isn't he a dear? he was 
 once in Jack's office." The strange thing was 
 these statements were always true; the subjects 
 of them confessed with tears that " dear Mrs. 
 Ussher " or " darling Laura " was the kindest 
 friend they had ever had. 
 
 Her house party was therefore likely to be 
 notable. 
 
 First, there was of course Mrs. Almar of 
 course without her husband. There is only one 
 thing, or perhaps two, to be said for Nancy Almar 
 that she was very handsome and that she was 
 not a hypocrite, no more than a pirate is a hypo- 
 crite who comes aboard with his cutlass in his 
 teeth. Mrs. Almar's cutlass was always in her 
 
 5 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 teeth, when it was not in somebody's vitals. 
 
 She had smooth, jet-black hair, done close to her 
 pretty head, a clear white-and-vermilion com- 
 plexion, and a good figure, not too tall. She said 
 little, but everything she did say, she most poign- 
 antly meant. If, while you were talking to her, 
 she suddenly cried out: " Ah, that's really 
 good! " there was no doubt you had had the good 
 fortune to amuse her; while if she yawned and left 
 you in the midst of a sentence there was no ques- 
 tion that she was bored. 
 
 She hated her husband not for the conven- 
 tional reason that she had married him. She 
 hated him because he was a hypocrite, because he 
 was always placating and temporizing. 
 
 For instance, he had said to her as she was about 
 to start for the Usshers' : 
 
 " I hope you '11 explain to them why I could 
 not come." 
 
 There had never been the least question of Mr. 
 Almar's coming, and she turned slowly and looked 
 at him as she asked: 
 
 " You mean that I would not have gone if you 
 had?" 
 
 6 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 He did not seem annoyed. 
 
 " No," he said, " that I 'm called South on busi- 
 
 ness." 
 
 "I shan't tell them that," she said, slowly 
 wrapping her furs about her throat; and then fore- 
 seeing a comic moment, she added, " but I '11 tell 
 them you say so, if you like." 
 
 She was as good as her word she usually 
 was. 
 
 When the party was at tea about the drawing- 
 room fire, she asked without the slightest change 
 of expression: 
 
 " Would any one like to hear Roland's expla- 
 nation of why he is not with us? " 
 
 " Had it anything to do with his not being 
 asked? " said a pale young man; and as soon as 
 he had spoken, he glanced hastily round the circle 
 to ascertain how his remark had succeeded. 
 
 So far as Mrs. Almar was concerned it had not 
 succeeded at all, in fact, though he did not know 
 it, nothing he said would ever succeed with her 
 again, although a week before she had hung upon 
 his every word. He had been a new discovery, 
 something unknown and Bohemian, but alas, a day 
 
 7 
 

 LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 or two before, she had observed that underlying 
 his socialistic theories was an aching desire for 
 social recognition. He liked to tell his bejeweled 
 hostesses about his friends the car-drivers ; but, oh, 
 twenty times more, he would have liked to tell the 
 car-drivers about his friends the bejeweled host- 
 esses. For this reason Mrs. Almar despised him, 
 and where she despised she made no secret of the 
 fact. 
 
 "Not asked, Mr. Wickham!" she said. "I 
 assume my husband is asked wherever I am," and 
 then turning to Laura Ussher she added with a 
 faint smile : " One's husband is always asked, 
 isn't he? " 
 
 " Certainly, as long as you never allow him to 
 come," said another speaker. 
 
 This was the other great beauty of the hour 
 or, since she was blond and some years younger 
 than Mrs. Almar, perhaps it would be right to 
 say that she was the beauty of the hour. 
 
 She was very tall, golden, fresh, smooth, yet 
 with faint hollows in her cheeks that kept her fresh- 
 ness from being insipid. Christine Fenimer had 
 another advantage she was unmarried. In 
 
 8 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 spite of the truth of the observation that a married 
 woman's greatest charm is her husband, he is also 
 in the most practical sense a disadvantage ; he does 
 sometimes stand across the road of advancement, 
 even in a land of easy divorce. Mrs. Almar, for 
 instance, was regretfully aware that she might have 
 done much better than Roland Almar. The great 
 stakes were really open to the unmarried. 
 
 She was particularly aware of this fact at the 
 moment, for the party was understood to be await- 
 ing a great stake. Mrs. Ussher had discovered 
 a cousin, a young man who, soon after graduating 
 from a technical college, had invented a process 
 in the manufacture of rubber that had brought him 
 a fortune before he was thirty. He was now en- 
 gaged in spending it on aviation experiments. He 
 was reckless and successful. Besides which he was 
 understood to be personally attractive his pic- 
 ture in a silver frame stood on a neighboring table. 
 He was of the lean- type that Mrs. Almar ad- 
 mired. 
 
 Now it was perfectly clear to her why he was 
 asked. Mrs. Ussher adored Christine Fenimer. 
 Of all girls in the world it was essential that 
 
 9 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 Christine should marry money. This man, Max 
 Riatt, new to the fashionable world, ought to be 
 comparatively easy game. The thing ought to go 
 on wheels. But Mrs. Almar herself was not in- 
 different to six feet of splendid masculinity; nor 
 without her own uses at the moment for a good- 
 looking young man. 
 
 In other words, there was going to be a contest; 
 in the full sight of the little public that really mat- 
 tered, the lists were set. Nobody present, except 
 perhaps Wickham, who was dangerously ignorant 
 of the world in which he was moving, doubted 
 for one moment that Miss Fenimer had resolved 
 to marry Max Riatt, if, that is, he turned out to 
 be actually as per the recommendations of Mrs. 
 Ussher; nor was it less certain that Mrs. Almar 
 intended that he should be hers. 
 
 Of course if Mrs. Ussher had been absolutely 
 single-minded, she would not have invited Mrs. 
 Almar to this party; but though a warm friend to 
 Christine Fenimer, Laura was not a fanatic, and 
 the piratical Nancy was her friend, too. 
 
 Mrs. Almar could have pleaded an additional 
 reason for her wish to interfere with this match, 
 
 10 
 

 LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 besides the natural one of not wishing Miss Feni- 
 mer to attain any success; and that was the fact 
 that Edward Hickson, her brother, had wanted 
 for several years to marry Christine. Hickson 
 was a dull, kindly, fairly well-to-do young man 
 exactly the type you would like to see your rival 
 marry. Hickson had motored out with his sister, 
 and had received some excellent counsel on thef 
 way. 
 
 " Now, Ned," she had said, " don't cut your own 
 throat by being an adoring foil. Don't let Chris- 
 tine grind your face in the dust, just to show this 
 new man that she can do it." 
 
 " You don't do Christine justice," he had 
 answered, " if you think she would do that." 
 
 His sister did not reply. She thought it would 
 have been doing the girl injustice to suppose' that 
 she would do anything else. 
 
 They were still sitting about the tea-table at a 
 quarter to seven, when Christine and Mrs. Almar 
 rose simultaneously. It was almost time for the 
 arrival of Riatt, and neither had any fancy for 
 meeting him save at her best in all the panoply 
 of evening dress. 
 
 ii 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " We 're not dining till a quarter past eight, my 
 dears," said Mrs. Ussher. 
 
 Both ladies thought they would lie down before 
 dinner. And here chance took a hand. Riatt's 
 train was late, whereas Christine's clock was fast. 
 And so it happened that she came downstairs just 
 as he was coming up. 
 
 There had been no one to greet him. He was 
 told by the butler that Mrs. Ussher was dressing, 
 that dinner would be in fifteen minutes; he 
 started to bound up the stairs, following the foot- 
 man with his bags, when suddenly looking up the 
 broad flight he saw a blond vision in white and 
 pearls coming slowly down. He hoped that his 
 lower jaw had n't fallen, but she really was ex- 
 traordinarily beautiful; and he could not help 
 slowing down a little. She stopped, with her 
 hand on the banisters, like Louise of Prussia. 
 
 " Oh, you 're Mr. Riatt," she said, very gently. 
 " You know you 're most awfully late." 
 
 u I wish," he said, " that I were wise enough to 
 be able to say: * Oh, you 're Miss ' " 
 
 " I might be a Mrs." 
 
 " .Oh, I hope not," he answered. " Are you? " 
 12 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 She smiled. 
 
 " You '11 know as soon as you come down to 
 dinner." 
 
 " I shall be quick about dressing." 
 
 He went on up, and she pursued her slow prog- 
 ress down. She felt that her future had been 
 settled by those few seconds on the stairs. 
 
 " He will do admirably," she said to herself, 
 and a smile like that of a sleeping infant curved 
 her lips. She felt calmly triumphant. She had 
 always said there was no reason why even a rich 
 man should be absolutely impossible. She re- 
 called certain great fortunes with repulsive own- 
 ers, which some of her friends had accepted. For 
 herself she had always intended to have every- 
 thing love and money, too. And here it was, 
 almost in her hands. There had been moments 
 when she had been so discouraged that she had 
 actually made up her mind to marry Ned Hick- 
 son. How wise she had been to hold off ! 
 
 She leant her arm on the mantelpiece and 
 studied herself in the mirror. It was a Chinese 
 painted mirror, and the tint of the glass was 
 green and unbecoming, yet even this could not 
 
 13 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 mar the dazzling reflection. The only object on 
 which she looked with dissatisfaction was her 
 string of pearls; they were imitation. She 
 thought she would have emeralds; and she heard 
 clearly in her own inner ear this sentence: 
 "Yes, that is young Mrs. Max Riatt; is she not 
 very beautiful in her emeralds ! " 
 
 Fortunately she did not say it aloud, for Mrs. 
 Ussher came down at this moment, and soon Hick- 
 son, and then in an incredibly short space of time 
 Riatt himself. 
 
 Undoubtedly he would do magnificently. He 
 stood the test even of evening clothes, though 
 Christine fancied as she studied him that she 
 would alter his style of collars. They would be 
 better higher. Mrs. Ussher brought him over at 
 once and introduced him. 
 
 "This is my cousin Max, Christine, about 
 whom I Ve talked so much. Max, this is Miss 
 Fenimer." 
 
 They smiled at each other with a common im- 
 pulse not to confess that earlier meeting on the 
 stairs ; and he was just about to settle down beside 
 her, when the door opened and, last of all, Mrs. 
 
 14 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 Almar came in. She was wearing her flame- 
 color and lilac dress. Christine knew she would 
 have it on; knew that she saved it for the greatest 
 moments. She did not advance very far into the 
 room, but stood looking around her. 
 
 " Well," she said, " where is Cousin Max? " 
 
 It must not be supposed from this question that 
 she had not seen him almost through the crack 
 of the door as the butler opened it for her; but 
 by speaking just when and where she did, she 
 forced him to get up from Christine's side, and 
 come to where she was to be introduced to her. 
 Then as dinner was at the same instant an- 
 nounced, she put her hand on his arm. 
 
 " Take me in to dinner, Cousin Max," she said. 
 
 " I did not know he was your cousin," said 
 Wickham, who suffered from the fatal tendency 
 in moments of doubt to say something. 
 
 Mrs. Almar looked at Riatt. 
 
 "Will you be a cousin to me?" she asked. 
 " It commits you to nothing." 
 
 " I don't consider that an advantage," he re- 
 turned, drawing his elbow slightly inward, so that 
 her hand, if not actually pressed, was made to 
 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 feel secure upon his arm. '* There are some 
 things I would n't a bit mind being committed to." 
 
 Mrs. Almar moved her black head from side 
 to side. 
 
 " You must be more specific," she said, u or I 
 sha'n't understand you." 
 
 " More specific in words? " he inquired gently. 
 They were crossing the hall, and had a sort of 
 privacy for an instant. 
 
 " Dear me," she returned, " you do move rather 
 rapidly, don't you?" 
 
 " I 'm an aviator, you see," he answered. 
 
 Across the table Christine was trying to be 
 gracious and graceful while she put up with Hick- 
 son, but she was feeling as any honest captain feels 
 at having a prize cut out from under his very 
 nose. 
 
 Mrs. Ussher seeing this, decided that such 
 methods as Nancy's ought not to prevail; she 
 seated herself on Max's other side, and instantly 
 engaged in conversation. 
 
 " Don't you think my dear little Christine is an 
 angel?" she said, without any encumbering sub- 
 tility. 
 
 16 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " She certainly looks like one." 
 
 "Who looks like what?" asked Mrs. Almar, 
 from his other side. She had had this sort 
 of thing tried too often not to be on her 
 guard. 
 
 Mrs. Ussher leant forward. 
 
 " Max was just saying that Christine looks like 
 an angel." 
 
 Nancy looked at him and made a very slight 
 grimace. 
 
 u Are you so awfully strong for angels?" she 
 said. He laughed. 
 
 " I never met one before." 
 
 " You have n't met one to-night." 
 
 " You mean that you 're not an angel, Mrs. 
 Almar?" 
 
 "I? Oh, I'm well and favorably known as 
 the wickedest woman in New York. I meant that 
 Miss Fenimer is not an angel." 
 
 " You don't like her?" 
 
 " How you jump at conclusions ! To say she 
 is n't an angel, does n't mean dislike. As a mat- 
 ter of fact, I am eager to secure her as my sister- , 
 in-law." 
 
 17 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 Riatt glanced at Hickson and was aware of 
 the faintest possible pang. What qualities, he 
 wondered, had a man like that. 
 
 " Oh," he said, " is she engaged to your 
 brother ?" 
 
 " Certainly not," answered Mrs. Almar. 
 " But it is fairly well understood by every one 
 except my brother, that if she does n't find any- 
 thing better within the next few years she will 
 put up with him." 
 
 At this a slight feeling of disgust for both' ladies 
 took possession of Riatt. 
 
 " I see," he said rather coldly, and turned to 
 Mrs. Ussher, but Nancy was not so easily disposed 
 of. 
 
 " You mean," she went on, " that you see it is 
 my duty as a sister to prevent anything else turn- 
 ing up. Suppose, for example, that a handsome, 
 rich, attractive young man should suddenly appear 
 upon the scene and show an interest in the angelic 
 Christine." (By this time Riatt had turned again 
 to her, and she looked straight into his eyes as 
 she ran through her list of adjectives.) " Don't 
 you think it would be my duty to distract his atten- 
 
 18; 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 tion to go almost any length to distract his. 
 attention?" 
 
 " However personally disagreeable to you the 
 process might be?" 
 
 " Probably if he were as I described him, the 
 process would not be so disagreeable." 
 
 He smiled. There was no denying he found 
 her amusing. 
 
 In the meantime, the couple across the table 
 had reached a somewhat similar point. 
 
 Hickson had said as they sat down: 
 
 "Well, and what do you think of this new 
 fellow?" 
 
 Christine's natural irritation appeared in her 
 answer. 
 
 " I have hardly had an opportunity of judging," 
 she answered, " but, watching your sister's atten- 
 tions to him, I would say he must be extremely 
 attractive." 
 
 Hickson looked a little dashed. 
 
 " Oh," he said, " Nancy does not mean any- 
 thing when she goes on like that." 
 
 The only effect of this speech was to depress 
 further Miss Fenimer's estimate of her compan- 
 
 19 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 ion's intelligence, for in her opinion Nancy's whole 
 life was one long black intention. Feeling this, 
 Ned went on: 
 
 " As a matter of fact, one reason why she 's so 
 nice to him is to keep him away from you and give 
 me a chance." 
 
 " Not very flattering to you, is it? " 
 
 " What do you mean? " 
 
 " The assumption that the only way to make 
 a woman take an interest in you is to prevent her 
 speaking to any other man." 
 
 "Oh, I didn't mean that " Hickson began, 
 but she interrupted him. 
 
 " That, if anything, Ned." And she turned to 
 Wickham, who sat on her other side. 
 
 Wickham was waiting for a little notice and 
 began instantly. 
 
 " I have been taking the liberty of looking at 
 your pearls, Miss Fenimer, and indulging in such 
 an interesting speculation. Here on the one hand, 
 you are wearing round your throat the equivalent 
 of life, health and virtue for half a hundred work- 
 ing girls, as young, as human, as yourself. Are 
 
 20 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 we to say this is wrong? Are we to say that 
 beautiful jewels worn by beautiful women are a 
 crime against society " 
 
 " One moment, Mr. Wickham," she said. 
 " My pearls are imitation and cost eight dollars 
 and fifty cents without the clasp. But," she 
 added cruelly, seeing his face fall, " you can say 
 that same thing to your friend Mrs. Almar, be- 
 cause hers are not artificial, though I have heard 
 her assert sometimes that they are," and turning 
 back to Hickson, who was laboriously trying to 
 carry on a conversation with his host, she inter- 
 rupted ruthlessly to say, hardly lowering her 
 voice : 
 
 ; ' Why in the world, Ned, did Nancy bring this 
 Wickham man here ? He 's perfectly impossi- 
 ble." 
 
 " Nancy did n't bring him," answered her 
 brother innocently. " I motored out with her 
 myself." 
 
 " She said she would n't come unless he were 
 asked. Still I know the answer. Nancy has al- 
 ways had a weakness for blond boys, and last 
 
 21 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 week she was crazy about this one. Now she 
 has turned against him, she wants to foist him 
 off on us, but I for one don't intend to help her 
 out" 
 
 By this time Wickham, aware that he had been 
 rebuffed, had found an explanation for it. The 
 girl was annoyed at having been forced to admit 
 her pearls were imitation. He decided to put 
 everything right. 
 
 " Miss Fenimer," he said, and she turned her 
 head perhaps half an inch in his direction, " I 
 think you misunderstood me just now. My stand- 
 ards are probably different from those of the 
 men you are accustomed to. To me the fact that 
 your pearls are not real is an added beauty. I 'm 
 glad they're not " 
 
 " Thank you," said Christine, " but I 'm not." 
 And this time he understood that he had lost her 
 for good. 
 
 After dinner, Mrs. Almar, knowing that her 
 innings were over, very effectively prevented 
 Christine having hers, by insisting on playing 
 bridge. She had an excellent head for cards, and 
 always needed money. Christine allowed herself 
 
 22 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 to be drawn in, supposing that Riatt would be one 
 of the players, and found herself seated opposite 
 to Hickson and next to Jack Ussher. 
 
 Wickham, feeling very much left out and de- 
 sirous of showing how well accustomed he was to 
 the casual manners of polite society, consoled him- 
 self with an evening paper. Laura Ussher led 
 Riatt to a comfortable corner out of earshot of 
 the bridge-table. 
 
 " Now do tell me, Max," she said, " what 
 you think of them all." 
 
 " I think, my dear Laura," he answered, " that 
 they are a very playful band of cut-throats, and 
 next time you ask me to stay, I hope you and 
 Jack will be entirely alone." 
 
 The servants in a household like the Usshe 
 were subjected to almost every strain, except th 
 of early rising. No one dreamed of coming do 
 stairs before eleven, and most people not ur.t 
 lunch time. 
 
 The next morning Riatt was among the first 
 
 ' ?j T- 
 
 that is to say he was up earty enough not to be 
 able to escape a tour of inspection of the place 
 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 under the guidance of his host. He had seen the 
 stables and the new garage, and the sheet of snow 
 beneath which lay the garden, and the other totally 
 different sheet of snow beneath which was the soil 
 in which Ussher intended next summer to plant 
 a rose garden. He had gone over, tree by tree, 
 the plantation of firs, and had noted how the tips 
 of some were injured, and had given his opinion 
 as to whether or not it were likely that deer had 
 stolen down from the wild country near at hand 
 and nibbled the young firs in the night. 
 
 " It 's perfectly possible," said Ussher. " I 
 have five hundred acres myself, and then the Club 
 owns a huge tract, and then there 's some state 
 land. You see we have hardly any neighbors 
 except the Fenimers and they 're eight or nine 
 miles away.'* 
 
 "They live here?" 
 
 " In summer and then only when Fred Feni- 
 mer is in funds, and that 's not often. A precari- 
 ous sort of existence, his gambling in mining 
 stocks, almost always in wrong. Hard on the 
 daughter wish some nice fellow would come 
 along and marry her." 
 
 24 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " He probably will," answered Riatt rather 
 coldly. " It 's beginning to snow again." 
 
 Ussher had just had his pond swept so that his 
 guests could skate, and now could n't imagine what 
 he should provide for them for the afternoon, so 
 that his thoughts were instantly and completely 
 turned from Christine's problems to his own. 
 
 At the house they found every one waiting for 
 lunch; Mrs. Almar and Christine chattering to- 
 gether on a window-seat as if they were the most 
 intimate allies; Hickson reading his fourth morn- 
 ing paper, and Mrs. Ussher paying the profound- 
 est attention to something Wickham was saying. 
 She had suddenly wakened to the fact that he 
 was having a wretched time and that he was after 
 all her guest. But he interpreted her actions dif- 
 ferently, and supposing that he was at last being 
 appreciated, he had launched fearlessly forth upon 
 the conversational sea. It was this spectacle that 
 had drawn Christine and Nancy together, in their 
 whisperings and giggles in the window. 
 
 ' This perhaps will illustrate my meaning," he 
 was saying rather loudly: "this is the difference 
 in our outlook on life. If you say ' she dresses 
 
 * 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 well,' you intend a compliment, but to me it is 
 just the reverse. The idea is repellent to me that 
 a woman wastes time, thought, money on her 
 vanity, on decking her body " 
 
 " One on you, my dear," whispered Chris- 
 tine. 
 
 "Isn't he tiresome?" answered Nancy, shut- 
 ting her eyes. 
 
 " I thought he was your selection." 
 
 " Nobody 's infallible, my dear. Besides, I 
 telegraphed him not to accept the invitation, but 
 he says he never got my message." 
 
 " Why does he think you sent it? " 
 
 " Because I could n't trust myself " 
 
 They grinned at each other. 
 
 With the entrance of Riatt and Ussher they 
 went in to lunch, and there maneuvering for 
 places for the afternoon immediately began. 
 
 Hickson supposed that by starting early he could 
 secure Christine's company. So he at once asked 
 her what she was going to do, and before she had 
 time to answer he had suggested that she skate, 
 take a walk, or go sleighing with him. Ussher 
 explained that the skating was spoiled, and Chris- 
 
 26 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 tine under cover of this diversion managed to 
 avoid committing herself. 
 
 As a matter of fact her afternoon was arranged. 
 She had told Laura Ussher a pathetic story of 
 having to go over to her father's house, and look 
 up an old fur coat of his which had been left 
 behind when the house was shut for the winter. 
 Mr. Fenimer was known to be rather an irritable 
 parent where questions of his own comfort were 
 concerned; it was not impossible that he would 
 make himself disagreeable if his orders were not 
 carried out. Laura did not inquire very closely, 
 but she agreed that the best way for Christine 
 to traverse the distance would be for Riatt to 
 drive her over in the cutter. Riatt sat next to 
 Laura at luncheon, and she put it to him, when 
 the general conversation was loudest. 
 
 " Would you mind awfully driving poor little 
 Christine over to her own place to get something 
 or other for that horrid father of hers? " 
 
 Of course Riatt didn't say he did mind; as a 
 matter of fact he did n't. He might even have 
 enjoyed the prospect, if it had n't been for the 
 slight hint of compulsion about it. 
 
 27 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " It *s snowing, you know," he said. 
 
 " It does n't amount to anything," answered his 
 cousin. " But surely, Max, you 're not afraid of 
 a little snow, if she is n'tl " 
 
 " Anything to oblige you, Laura," he said. 
 
 She did not quite like his tone, but felt she might 
 safely leave the rest to Christine. 
 
 Mrs. Almar, unaware of these plots, settled 
 down as soon as the meal was over, on a com- 
 fortable sofa large enough for two, with a box 
 of cigarettes at her side and a current magazine 
 that contained a new article on flying. The bird- 
 like objects in the huge page of cloudy sky at once 
 caught Max's eye. He came and bent over it 
 and her, with his hands in his pockets. Still ab- 
 sorbed in it, she half-unconsciously swept aside 
 her skirts, and he sat down beside her. She mur- 
 mured a question it was only about planes, and 
 he answered it. Their heads were close together 
 when Christine came down in her dark furs ready 
 to go. The bells of Jack Ussher's fastest trotter 
 were already to be heard tinkling at the door. 
 
 "Are you ready, Max?" said Laura, rather 
 sharply. 
 
 28 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 "Laura expects every man to do his duty," 
 murmured Nancy, without looking up. 
 
 Riatt expressed himself as entirely ready. 
 Ussher lent him a fur cap and heavy gloves, 
 warned him about the charmingly uncertain char- 
 acter of the horse; he and Christine were tucked 
 into the sleigh, and they were off. 
 
 The snow, as Laura had said, did not seem to 
 amount to much, the wind was behind them, the 
 horse fast, the roads well packed. Riatt glanced 
 down at his lovely companion, and felt his spirits 
 rising. He smiled at her and she smiled back. 
 
 " I do hope you really feel like that," she said, 
 " not sorry, I mean, to go on this expedition. Be- 
 cause it was extremely wicked of me to forget my 
 father's coat, and this was obviously the occasion 
 to make amends, but there was no one to take 
 me" 
 
 " No one to take you? " 
 
 " Oh, I suppose one of the grooms might have 
 driven me over, but I should have hated that. 
 There was no one else. Jack is much too selfish, 
 and I wouldn't have gone with that Wickham 
 person for anything in the world, even if he had 
 
 29 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 ever driven a sleigh, which I am sure he has n't." 
 
 " And how about Mr. Hickson? " Riatt asked. 
 " Was n't he a possibility? " 
 
 " What has Nancy Almar told you about her 
 brother and me? " 
 
 " Nothing but what he told me himself in every 
 look and word that he loves you." 
 
 Christine sighed. 
 
 He smiled at her. 
 
 " And you 're glad of it," he said. 
 
 " You mean I care for him? " 
 
 " I don't know anything about that, but you 're 
 glad he cares for you." 
 
 " You 're utterly mistaken." 
 
 " How would you feel if another woman came 
 and took him away from you to-morrow? " 
 
 "Took him away from me?" cried Christine, 
 in a tone of surprise that made Riatt laugh aloud. 
 
 " That 's the wonderful thing about the so-called 
 weaker sex," he said. " Saying * no ' seems to 
 have no terrors to them at all. The timidest girl 
 will refuse a man with no more trouble and anxiety 
 than she would expend on refusing a dinner invita- 
 tion; whereas men, with all their vaunted courage, 
 
 30 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 are absolutely at the mercy of a determined 
 woman. I have a friend who has just married 
 a girl whom he three times explicitly refused 
 only because she asked him to." 
 
 Miss Fenimer looked at him thoughtfully. 
 
 " Surely you exaggerate," she said. 
 
 He shook his head sadly. 
 
 " I wish I did," he returned, " but I assure you 
 that is the great secret that any man would 
 rather marry any woman than refuse her to her 
 face. You see, no graceful way for a man to 
 say * no ' has ever been discovered." 
 
 " Why, you poor defenseless creatures 1 " said 
 Christine. " I '11 teach you some ways immedi- 
 ately. I couldn't bear to think of your going 
 about a prey to the first woman who proposed 
 to you. Let us begin our lessons immediately. 
 Have I your attention?" 
 
 " Completely." 
 
 " Let me see. In the first place there are sev- 
 eral general types of proposal. There is the 
 calmly rational, the passionate whirlwind, the 
 dangerously controlled, or volcano under a sheet 
 of ice " she broke off. " I don't know how 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 women do it," she said. " I only know about 
 
 men." 
 
 He smiled, " But you admit to knowing all 
 about them, I gather ? " 
 
 It would have been folly to deny it. 
 
 " And then there 's the meltingly pathetic," she 
 went on. " I imagine that 's what women attempt 
 oftenest. Let us begin with that. Now you are 
 to suppose that I, with tears streaming down 
 my face, have just confessed that I have always 
 looked up to you as a sort of god, that I hardly 
 dare" 
 
 " Wait, wait! " cried Riatt. " This is by far 
 the most interesting part of the lesson, and you 
 go so fast. I have no imagination. I don't know 
 how it would be, you must say all those things." 
 
 " Do I have to cry? " said Christine. 
 
 Riatt debated the point. 
 
 " No," he answered at length, " I can imagine 
 the tears, but everything else you must act out. 
 Particularly that part about my seeming like a 
 god to you." 
 
 " But how in the world can I teach you what 
 to do, if I have to act a part myself? " 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Well, before we begin, just give me a sketch 
 of what I ought to do." 
 
 " You must be very cold and firm, and explain 
 to me that though my mistake is natural, you are 
 really not a god at all; and then that gives you 
 an excuse to talk a great deal about yourself, and 
 tell how wicked and human and splendid you are, 
 and that you are not worthy of a simple, good girl 
 like myself, and how you don't love me anyhow. 
 And then the essential thing is to go away quickly, 
 and end the interview before I have a chance to 
 begin all over again." 
 
 He looked doubtfully at the snow. 
 
 " Must I get out and walk home? " he asked. 
 
 " No," she said. " I think that 's too compli- 
 cated. We might try an easier one to begin. 
 Suppose we do the calmly rational first. I explain 
 to you that I have watched you from boyhood, and 
 have come to the conclusion that our tastes, our 
 intellects, our " 
 
 " Oh, no," said Riatt, " there 's really no use 
 in going on with that. Even I should have no 
 difficulty with any lady who approached me in that 
 way. But there was one of the others that 
 
 33 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 sounded rather promising and difficult. How 
 about the passionate whirlwind? I say to try that 
 
 next." 
 
 To her surprise, Christine found herself color- 
 ing a little. 
 
 "Ah," she said, laying her hand on her lips 
 and shaking her head, " that 's very difficult, be- 
 cause you see, it really can't be imitated " 
 
 "Can't be imitated!" cried Max. "Why, 
 what sort of a teacher are you? I believe you 
 don't know your job. You are the sort of teacher 
 who would tell an arithmetic class that long divi- 
 sion could not be imitated. I believe the trouble 
 with you is that you don't understand the passion- 
 ate whirlwind yourself. I believe you 're a fraud, 
 and I shall have your license to teach taken away 
 from you. Can't be imitated 1 Well, let me sec 
 you try, at least." 
 
 Christine felt that he had the better of her, but 
 she said firmly: 
 
 " Are you teaching this subject, or am I? " 
 
 " Certainly you can't think you are. But if 
 you say so, I '11 have a try." 
 
 Not sorry to create a diversion, Christine 
 34 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 looked about her, and was more diverted from the 
 subject in hand than she had expected to be. 
 
 They were on the wrong road. What with the 
 snow and the fact that she had been so busy talk- 
 ing that she really had no idea how far they had 
 been, it took her a moment to orient herself anew. 
 Sfrfc ftold him with a conscience-struck look. 
 
 r ' And you," said Riatt, " who do not even 
 know the road to your own house, were volunteer- 
 ing to pilot me through an emotional crisis." 
 
 Even a suggestion of adverse criticism was un- 
 pleasant to Miss Fenimer. She was not accus- 
 tomed to it; and she answered with some sharp- 
 ness: 
 
 " Yes, but the road is real, whereas I under- 
 stand your embarrassment through the attentions 
 of ladies is purely fictitious." 
 
 Riatt wondered how fictitious, but he turned the 
 cutter about in obedience to her commands. The 
 horse started forward even more gaily, under the 
 impression that he was going home. But for the 
 drivers, the change was not so agreeable. A high 
 wind had come up, the snow was falling faster, 
 and the light of the winter afternoon, already be- 
 
 35 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 ginning to fade, was obscured by high, dark, silver- 
 edged banks of clouds. 
 
 " Upon my word," said Riatt, " I think we had 
 better go back." 
 
 " It 's only a little way from here," Christine 
 answered, trying hard to think how far it really 
 was. She did want to get her father's coat, but 
 she was not indifferent to the triumph of making 
 Riatt late for dinner, and leaving Nancy Almar 
 throughout the afternoon with no companion but 
 Wickham or Jack Ussher. 
 
 The wind cut their faces, the horse pulled and 
 pranced, the gaiety had gone out of their little 
 expedition. They drove on a mile or so, and 
 then Riatt stopped the horse. 
 
 " We Ve got to go back, Miss Fenimer," he 
 said firmly. 
 
 "Oh, please not, Mr. Riatt; we are almost 
 there, and," she added with a fine sense of filial 
 obligation, " I really feel I must do as my father 
 asked me." 
 
 Riatt felt inclined to point out that she, with 
 her muff held up to her face, was not making the 
 greatest sacrifice to the ideal of duty. 
 
 36 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Have you any very clear idea where your 
 house is ? " he asked. His tone was not flattering, 
 and Christine was quick to feel it. 
 
 " Do I know where I live five months of the 
 year?" she returned. "Of course I do. It's 
 just over this next hill." 
 
 The afternoon was turning out so perversely 
 that she would hardly have been surprised to find 
 that the house had disappeared from its accus- 
 tomed place. But as they came over the crest, 
 there it was, in a hollow between two hills, looking 
 as summer houses do in winter, like a forlorn toy 
 left out in the snow. 
 
 " But it 's shut up," said Riatt. " There 's no 
 
 one in it." 
 
 " I have the keys to the back door." 
 He touched the horse for the first time with 
 the whip, and they went jingling down the slope, 
 in between the almost completely buried gate- 
 posts, and drew up before the kitchen door. 
 
 Miss Fenimer kicked her feet free from the 
 rugs, jumped out, and from the recesses of her 
 muff produced a key which she inserted in the 
 lock. 
 
 37 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Now you won't be long, will you? " said Riatt, 
 with more of command than persuasion in his 
 tone. 
 
 It was a principle of life on the part of Chris- 
 tine that she never allowed any man to bully her; 
 or perhaps, it would be more nearly just to say 
 that she never intended to allow any man to do 
 so until she herself became persuaded that he 
 could, and with this object she always made the 
 process look as difficult and dangerous as possible 
 at the very beginning. 
 
 She looked back at him and smiled with irri- 
 tating calm. 
 
 u I shall be just as long as is necessary," she 
 replied, and so saying, she turned, or rather at- 
 tempted to turn, the key. 
 
 But disuse, or cold, or her own lack of strength 
 prevented and she was presently reduced to asking 
 Riatt to help her. He did not volunteer 
 his assistance. She had definitely and directly 
 to ask for it. Then he was friendliness 
 itself. 
 
 "Just stand by the horse's head, will you?" 
 he said, and when he saw her stationed there, he 
 
 38 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 sprang out, and with an almost insulting ease 
 opened the door. 
 
 Just as he did so, however, a gust of wind, 
 fiercer than any other, swept round the corner 
 of the house and carried away Christine's hat. 
 She made a quick gesture to catch it, and as she 
 did so, struck the horse under the chin. The ani- 
 mal reared, and Christine jumped aside to avoid 
 being struck by its hoofs ; the next instant, it had 
 thrown its head in the air, and started at full 
 speed down the road, dragging the empty sleigh 
 after it. Riatt, who had his back turned, did not 
 see the beginning of the incident, but a cry from 
 Christine soon roused his attention, and he started 
 in pursuit, calling to the animal to stop, in the 
 hope that the human voice might succeed when 
 all other methods were quite obviously useless. 
 But the horse, now thoroughly excited by the hang- 
 ing reins, the bells, and the sense of its own power, 
 went only faster and faster, and finally disap- 
 peared at full speed. 
 
 Riatt came slowly back; he was sinking in the 
 snow to his waist at every step. Christine was 
 watching him with some anxiety. 
 
 39 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Is there a telephone in the house ? " he asked. 
 
 She shook her head. 
 
 " No, it 's disconnected when we leave in the 
 autumn." 
 
 There was a moment's silence, then she said 
 questioningly : " What shall we do? " 
 
 " There 's only one thing we can do," he re- 
 turned; " go into the house and light a fire." 
 
 But Christine hesitated. 
 
 " I don't think it will be wise to waste time 
 doing that," she said, " if you have to go back on 
 foot to the Usshers' " 
 
 " Go back on foot! " Riatt interrupted. " My 
 dear Miss Fenimer, that is quite impossible. It 
 must be every inch of ten miles, it 's dark, a bliz- 
 zard is blowing, I don't know the way, and we 
 have n't passed a house." 
 
 " But, but," said she, " suppose they don't res- 
 cue us to-night? " 
 
 " They probably will to-morrow," answered 
 Riatt, and he walked past her into the house. 
 
 40 
 
CHAPTER II 
 
 /CHRISTINE was glad to get out of the wind, 
 V^ but the damp chill of the deserted house 
 was not much of an improvement. Ahead of her 
 in the darkness, she could hear Riatt snapping 
 electric switches which produced nothing. 
 
 " Isn't the light connected? " he called. 
 
 " I don't know." 
 
 " Are n't there lamps in the house? " 
 
 " I don't know." 
 
 " Where could I find some candles? " 
 
 "What a tiresome man!" she thought; and 
 for the third time she answered : " I don't know." 
 
 A rather unappreciative grunt was his only re- 
 ply, and then he called back: " You 'd better stay 
 where you are, till I find something to make a 
 
 light." 
 
 She asked nothing better. She was oppressed 
 with a sense of crisis. An inner voice seemed to 
 be saying, in parody of Charles Francis Adams's 
 
 41 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 historic words : " I need hardly point out to your 
 ladyship that this means marriage." 
 
 She had thought, lightly enough, that everything 
 was settled the evening before on the stairs when 
 she had made up her mind that he would do. But 
 with all her belief in herself, she was not unaware 
 even then that unforeseen obstacles might arise. 
 He might be secretly engaged for all she knew 
 to the contrary. But now she felt quite sure of 
 him. With Fate playing into her hands like 
 this with romance and adventure and the 
 possibilities of an uninterrupted tete-a-tete, she 
 knew she could have him if she wanted him. And 
 the point was that she did. At least she supposed 
 she did. She felt as many a young man feels 
 when he lands his first job < triumphant, but con- 
 scious of lost freedoms. 
 
 Marriage, she knew, was the only possible solu- 
 tion of her problems. Her life with her father 
 was barely possible. As a matter of fact they 
 were but rarely together. The tiny apartment in 
 New York did not attract Fred Fenimer as a win- 
 ter residence, when he had an opportunity of going 
 to Aiken or Florida or California at the expense 
 
 42 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 of some more fortunate friend. In summer it 
 was much the same. " My dear," he would say 
 to his daughter, " I really can't afford to open the 
 house this summer." And Christine would coldly 
 asquiesce, knowing that this statement only meant 
 that he had received an invitation that he pre- 
 ferred to a quiet summer with her. 
 
 Sometimes throughout the whole season father 
 and daughter would only meet by chance on some 
 unexpected visit, or coming into a harbor on dif- 
 ferent yachts. 
 
 " Isn't that the Sea-Mew's flag? " Christine 
 would say languidly. " I rather think my father 
 is on board." 
 
 And then, perhaps, some amiable hostess in need 
 of an extra man would send the launch to the 
 Sea-Mew to bring Mr. Fenimer back to dine; 
 and he would come on board, very civil, very neat, 
 very punctilious on matters of yachting etiquette ; 
 and he and Christine having exchanged greeting, 
 would find that they had really nothing whatsoever 
 to say to each other. 
 
 Their only vital topic of conversation was 
 money, and as this was always disagreeable, both 
 
 43 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 of them instinctively tried to avoid it. Whenever 
 Fenimer had money, he either speculated with it, 
 or immediately spent it on himself. So that he 
 was always able to say with perfect truth, when- 
 ever his daughter asked for it, that he had none. 
 The result of this was that she had easily drifted 
 into the simple custom of running up bills for what- 
 ever she needed, and allowing the tradesmen to 
 fight it out with her father. 
 
 Such a system does not tend to economy. 
 Christine's idea of what was necessary, derived 
 from the extravagant friends who offered her the 
 most opportunity for amusing herself, enlarged 
 year by year. Besides, she asked herself, why 
 should she deny herself, in order that her father 
 might lose more money in copper stocks? 
 
 Sometimes during one of their casual meetings, 
 he would say to her under his breath : " Good 
 Heavens, girl, do you know, I Ve just had a bill of 
 almost three thousand dollars from your infernal 
 dressmaker? How can I stop your running up 
 such bills?" And she would answer coolly: 
 " By paying them every year or so." 
 
 She knew she had always known since she 
 44 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 was a little girl that from this situation, only 
 marriage could rescue her, and from the worse 
 situation that would follow her father's death; for 
 she suspected that he was deeply in debt. Not 
 having been brought up in a sentimental school she 
 was prepared to do her share in arranging such 
 a marriage. In the world in which she lived, com- 
 petition was severe. Already she had seen a pos- 
 sible husband carried off under her nose by a little 
 school-room mouse who had had the aid of an ef- 
 ficient mother. 
 
 But now for the first time in her life, she saw 
 that the game was in her own hands. She had 
 only to do the right thing only perhaps to avoid 
 doing the wrong one and her future was safe. 
 
 She heard Riatt calling and she followed him 
 into the laundry, where he had collected some 
 candles: he was much engaged in lighting a fire 
 in the stove. 
 
 " But would n't the kitchen range be better? " 
 she asked. 
 
 " No water turned on," he answered. 
 
 To her this answer was utterly unintelligible. 
 What, she wondered, was the connection between 
 
 45 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 fire and water. But, rather characteristically, she 
 was disinclined to ask. She walked to the sink, 
 however, and turned the tap ; a long husky cough 
 came from it, but no water. 
 
 After this burst of energy she sank into a chair, 
 amused to watch his arrangements. Thoroughly 
 idle people and there is not much question that 
 Miss Fenimer was idle learn a variety of meth- 
 ods for keeping other people at work, and prob- 
 ably the most effective of these is flattery. Chris- 
 tine may have been ignorant of the feminine arts 
 of cooking and fire-making; but of the super-fem- 
 inine art of flattery she was a thorough mis- 
 tress. 
 
 Now as Riatt finished building his fire, and be- 
 gan to bring in buckets of snow to supply their 
 need of water, the gentle flow of her flattery 
 soothed him as the sound of a hidden brook 
 in the leafy month of June. Nor, strangely 
 enough, did the fact that he dimly apprehended 
 its purpose in the least interfere with his en- 
 joyment. 
 
 " If ever I 'm thrown away on a desert island, 
 I speak to be thrown away with you," she said. 
 " There is n't another man of my acquaintance 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 who could bring order out of these primitive con- 
 ditions." 
 
 He laughed. " Well, you know," he said, 
 " this is n't really what you 'd call primitive. I 
 was snowed up in Alaska once." 
 
 " Alaska ! You Ve been snowed up in 
 Alaska? " she echoed in the tone of a child who 
 says: was it a black bear? 
 
 Oh, yes, it lightened his toil. Nevertheless, he 
 asked for her assistance in trying to find some- 
 thing to eat. She knew no more about the kitchen 
 than he did, but she advanced toward a door and 
 opened it gingerly between her thumb and fore- 
 finger. It was the kitchen closet. She opened a 
 tin box. 
 
 " There is something here that looks like 
 gravel," she called. He rushed to her side. It 
 was cereal. He found other supplies, too, a little 
 salt, sugar, coffee, and a jar of bacon. 
 
 " How clever of you to know what they all are," 
 she murmured, and he felt as if he had invented 
 them out of thin air, like an Eastern magician. 
 
 He carried them back to the kitchen. " I won- 
 der if you 'd get the coffee grinder," he said. 
 
 47 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 She had n't the faintest idea what a coffee 
 grinder looked like, but she went away 'to find it, 
 and came back presently with an object strange 
 enough to serve any purpose. 
 
 "Is this it?" she asked. 
 
 " That 's a meat chopper," he answered, and 
 then laughed. " You 're not a very good house- 
 keeper, are you?" 
 
 " Of course not," she said. " Did you ever 
 know an agreeable woman who was? Good 
 housekeepers are always bores, because they can 
 never for an instant get their minds off the most 
 tiresome things in the world like bills, and how the 
 servants are behaving. All clever women are bad 
 housekeepers, and so they always find some one 
 like you to take care of them." 
 
 He was putting the cereal to boil, and answered 
 only after a second. " Perhaps you '11 think me 
 old-fashioned, but I cannot help respecting the art 
 of housekeeping." 
 
 " Oh, so do I in its place," replied Miss Feni- 
 mer. " My maid does the whole thing capitally. 
 But let me give you a test. Think of the very 
 best housekeeper you ever met. Would you like 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 to have her here instead of me? You may be 
 quite candid." 
 
 Riatt stopped and considered an instant with 
 his head on one side. " She 'd make me awfully 
 comfortable," he said. 
 
 Miss Fenimer nodded, as much as to say: yes, 
 but even so 
 
 " No," he said at length, as if the decision had 
 been close. " No, after all I would rather do 
 the work and have you. But it is n't because you 
 are a poor housekeeper that I prefer you. It 's 
 because " 
 
 Compliments upon her charms were platitudes 
 to Christine, and she cut him short. u Yes, it is. 
 It's because I'm so detached, and don't interfere, 
 and let you do things your own way, and think 
 you so wonderful to be able to do them at all. 
 Now if I knew how to do them, too, I should be 
 criticizing and suggesting all the time, and you 'd 
 have no peace. You like me for being a poor 
 housekeeper! 9 
 
 He smiled. " On that ground I ought to like 
 you very much then," he answered. 
 
 " Perhaps you do," she said cheerfully. " Any- 
 49 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 how I 'm sure you like me better than that other 
 girl you were thinking of that good house- 
 keeper. Who is she?" 
 " I like her quite a lot." 
 
 " I see you think she 'd make a good wife." 
 " I think she 'd make a good wife to any man 
 who was fortunate enough " 
 
 " Oh, what a dreadful way to talk of the poor 
 girl!" 
 
 " On the contrary, I admire her extremely." 
 " I believe you are engaged to her." 
 " Not as much as you are to Hickson." 
 Christine laughed. " From the way you de- 
 scribe her," she said, " I believe she 'd make a 
 perfect wife for Ned." 
 
 " Oh, she J s much too good for him." 
 " Thank you. You seem to think I '11 do nicely 
 for him." 
 
 " Ah, but she 's much better than you are." 
 " And yet you said you 'd rather have me here 
 than her." 
 
 He smiled. " I think," he said, and Christine 
 rather waited for his next words, " I think I shall 
 go down and see if I can't get the furnace going." 
 
 5 
 

 LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 Nevertheless, she said to herself when he was 
 gone, " I should not feel at all easy about him, 
 if I were the other girl." 
 
 She knew there was no prospect of their being 
 rescued that night. When the sleigh arrived at 
 the Usshers', if it ever did arrive, its empty shat- 
 tered condition would suggest an accident. The 
 Usshers were at that moment probably searching 
 for them in ditches, and hedges. The marks 
 of the sleigh would be quickly obliterated by the 
 storm. No, she thought comfortably, there was 
 no escape from the fact that their situation was 
 compromising. The only question was how could 
 the matter be most tactfully called to his attention. 
 At the moment he seemed happily unaware that 
 such things as the proprieties existed. 
 
 At this his head appeared at the head of the 
 cellar stairs. 
 
 " Watch the cereal, please," he said, " and see 
 that it does n't burn." 
 
 "Like King Alfred?" 
 
 " Not too much like him, please, for that piti- 
 ful little dab of food is about all we have to 
 
 eat." 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 When he was gone Christine advanced toward 
 the stove and looked at the cereal looked at it 
 closely, but it seemed to her to be but little bene- 
 fited by her attention. Presently she discovered 
 on a shelf beside the laundry clock a pinkish purple 
 paper novel, called: " The Crime of the Season.' 7 
 Its cover depicted a man in a check suit and side- 
 whiskers looking on in astonishment at the removal 
 of a drowned lady in full evening dress from a 
 very minute pond. Christine opened it, and was 
 so fortunate as to come full upon the crime. She 
 became as completely absorbed in it as the laun- 
 dress had been before her. 
 
 She was recalled to the more sordid but less 
 criminal surroundings of real life by a strong 
 pungent smell. She sniffed, and then her heart 
 suddenly sank as she realized that the cereal was 
 burning. She recognized a peculiarly disagreeable 
 flavor about which she had often scolded the cook, 
 thinking such carelessness on the part of one of 
 her employees to be absolutely inexcusable. 
 
 She ran to the head of the cellar stairs. " Mr. 
 Riatt!" she called. 
 
 He was now shaking down the furnace, and 
 5.2 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 the noise completely drowned her voice. "Oh, 
 dear, what a noisy man he is," she thought and 
 when he had finished, she called again : " Mr. 
 Riatt!" 
 
 This time he heard. "What is it?" he an- 
 swered. 
 
 "Mr. Riatt, what shall I do? The cereal is 
 burning terribly." 
 
 " I should think it was," he said. " I can smell 
 it down here." He sprang up the stairs and 
 snatched the pot from the stove. " You must 
 have stopped stirring it," he said. 
 
 "Oh, I did n't stir it!" 
 
 "What did you do?" 
 
 " You did n't tell me to stir it." 
 
 " I certainly did." 
 
 " No, you said just to watch it." 
 
 Riatt looked at her. " Well," he said, " I Ve 
 heard of glances cutting like a knife, but never 
 stirring like a spoon. If I were a really just 
 man," he went on, " I 'd make you eat that burnt 
 mess for your supper, but I 'm so absurdly in- 
 dulgent that I '11 share some of my bacon and 
 biscuits with you." 
 
 53 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 His tone as well as his words were irritating 
 to one not used to criticism in any form. 
 
 " I don't care for that sort of joke," she said. 
 
 " I was n't aware of having made a joke." 
 
 " I mean your attitude as if I were a child that 
 had been naughty." 
 
 " It would n't be so bad if you were a child." 
 
 " You consider me to blame because that 
 wretched cereal chose to burn?" 
 
 " Emphatically I do." 
 
 " How perfectly preposterous," said Christine, 
 and a sense of bitter injustice seethed within her. 
 " Why in the world should / be expected to know 
 how to cook? " 
 
 " I 'm a little too busy at the moment to explain 
 it to you," Riatt answered, " but I promise to take 
 it up with you at a later date." 
 
 There was something that sounded almost like 
 a threat in this. She turned away, and walking 
 to the window stood staring out into the darkness. 
 He was really quite a disagreeable young man, 
 she thought. How true it was, that you could n't 
 tell what people were like when everything was 
 going smoothly. She wondered if he would al- 
 
 54 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 ways be like that trying to keep one up to one's 
 duty and making one feel stupid and ignorant 
 about the merest trifles. 
 
 " Well, this rich meal is ready," he said pres- 
 ently. 
 
 She turned around. The table was set she 
 could n't help wondering where he had found the 
 kitchen knives and forks the bacon was siz- 
 zling, the tin of biscuits open, and the coffee bub- 
 bling and gurgling in its glass retort. 
 
 She sat down and began to eat in silence, but 
 as she did so, she studied him furtively. She was 
 used to many different kinds of masculine bad 
 temper; her father's irritability whenever any- 
 thing affected his personal comfort: and from 
 other men all forms of jealousy and hurt feel- 
 ings. But this stern indifference to her as a human 
 being was something a little different. She de- 
 cided on her method. 
 
 " Oh, dear," she said, " this meal could n't be 
 much drearier if we were married, could it?" 
 
 " Except," he returned, unsmilingly, " that then 
 it would be one of a long series." 
 
 " Not as far as I 'm concerned," she answered. 
 
 55 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " I should leave you on account of your bad 
 temper." 
 
 " If I had n't first left you on account of " 
 
 "Of burning the cereal?" 
 
 " Of being so infernally irresponsible about 
 it." 
 
 "Oh, that's the trouble, is it?" she said. 
 "That I did not seem to care? Well, I assure 
 you that I don't like burnt food any better than 
 you do, but I have some self-control. I would n't 
 spoil a whole evening just because " A sud- 
 den inspiration came to her. Her voice failed 
 her, and she hid her face in her pocket handker- 
 chief. 
 
 Riatt leant back in his chair and looked at her, 
 looked at least at the back of her long neck, and 
 the twist of her golden hair and the occasional 
 heave of her shoulders. 
 
 The strange and the humiliating thing was that 
 she had just as much effect upon him when he 
 quite obviously knew that she was insincere. 
 
 " Why," he said gently, " are you crying? Or 
 perhaps I ought to say, why are you pretending 
 to cry?" 
 
 56 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 She paid no attention to the latter part of his 
 question. 
 
 " You 're so unkind," she said, careful not to 
 overdo a sob. " You don't seem to understand 
 what a terrible situation this is for me." 
 
 " In what way is it terrible? " 
 
 " Don't you know that a story like this clings 
 to a girl as long as she lives? That among the 
 people I know there will always be gossip " 
 
 " You 're not serious? " 
 
 She nodded, still behind her handkerchief, 
 " Yes, I am. This will be something I shall have 
 to live down, as much as you would if you had 
 robbed a bank." 
 
 She now raised her head, and wiping her eyes 
 hard enough to make them a little red, she glanced 
 at him. 
 
 Really she thought it would save a great deal 
 of time and trouble, if he could just see the thing 
 clearly and ask her to marry him now. 
 
 But apparently his mind did not work so 
 quickly. 
 
 "Who will repeat it?" he said. "Not the 
 Usshers " 
 
 57 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Nancy Almar won't let it pass. She '11 have 
 found the evening dull without you, and she '11 
 feel she has a right to compensation. And that 
 worm, Wickham; it will be his favorite anecdote 
 for the rest of his life. I was horrible to him 
 last night at dinner." 
 
 " Sorry you were? " 
 
 " Not a bit. I 'd do it again, but I may as 
 well face the fact that he won't be eager to con- 
 ceal his own social triumphs for the sake of my 
 good name. Can't you hear him, ' Curious thing 
 happened the other day at my friends the 
 Usshers'. Know them? A lovely country 
 place _'_" 
 
 "I'm awfully sorry," he said. "What a 
 bore ! Is there anything I could do " 
 
 " Well, there is one thing." 
 
 He looked up quickly. If ever terror flashed 
 in a man's eyes, she saw it then in his. Her heart 
 sank, but her mind worked none the less well. 
 
 " It 's this," she went on smoothly. " There 's 
 a lodge, a sort of tool-house, only about half a 
 mile down the road. Couldn't you take a Ian- 
 
 58 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 tern, couldn't you possibly spend the night 
 there?" 
 
 " It is n't by any chance," he said, " that you 're 
 afraid of having me here? " 
 
 " Oh, no, not you," she answered. " No, I 
 should feel much safer with you here than there." 
 (If he went her case was ruined, and she was 
 now actually afraid perhaps he would go.) " I 
 should be terrified in this great place all by myself. 
 Still, I think you ought to go. It 's not so very 
 far. You go down the road a little way and 
 then turn to the right through the woods. I think 
 you '11 find it. The roof used to leak a little, but 
 I dare say you won't mind that. There is n't any 
 fireplace, but you could take lots of blankets < " 
 
 " I tell you what I '11 do," he said. " No one 
 will come to rescue us to-night. I '11 sleep here 
 to-night, and to-morrow as soon as it 's light, I '11 
 go to this cottage, and when they come, you can 
 tell them any story you please. Will that do? " 
 
 It did perfectly. " Oh, thank you," she said. 
 " How kind you are ! And you do forgive me, 
 don't you? " 
 
 59 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 "About the cereal? Oh, yes, on one condi- 
 tion." 
 
 "What is that?" She was still meltingly 
 sweet. 
 
 " That you wash these dishes." 
 
 She felt inclined to box his ears. Had he seen 
 through her all the time? 
 
 " I never washed a dish in my life," she ob- 
 served thoughtfully. 
 
 " Have you ever done anything useful? " 
 
 She reflected, and after some thought she re- 
 plied, not boastfully, but as one who states an 
 indisputable fact: "Never." 
 
 He folded his arms, leant against the wall and 
 looked down upon her. " I wish," he said, " if 
 it is n't too much trouble that you would give me 
 a detailed account of one of your average 
 days." 
 
 * You talk," said she, " as if you were study- 
 ing the manners and customs of savages." 
 
 " Let us say of an unknown tribe." 
 
 She leant back in her chair and stretched her 
 arms over her head. " Well, let me see," she 
 said. " I wake up about nine or a little after if 
 
 60 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 I have n't been up all night, and I ring for my 
 maid. And about eleven " 
 
 " Don't skip, please. You ring for your maid. 
 What does she do for you? " 
 
 Imagine any one's not knowing! Miss Feni- 
 mer marveled. " Why, she draws my bath and 
 puts out my things, and while I 'm taking my bath, 
 she straightens the room and lights the fire, if 
 it 's cold, and brings in my breakfast-tray and my 
 letters. And by half-past ten, I 'm finally dressed 
 if no one has come in to delay me, only some one 
 always has. Last winter my time was immensely 
 occupied by two friends of mine who had both 
 fallen in love with the same man one of them 
 was married to him and they used to come 
 every day and confide in me. You have no idea 
 how amusing it was. He behaved shockingly, 
 but I could n't help feeling a little sorry Tor him. 
 They were both such determined women. Fi- 
 nally I went to him, and told him how it was I 
 knew so much about his affairs, and said I thought 
 he ought to try and make up his mind which of 
 them he really did care for. And what do you 
 think he said? That he had always been in love 
 
 61 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 with me." She laughed. " How absurdly things 
 happen, don't they? " 
 
 " Good Heavens! " said Riatt. 
 
 " But even at the worst, I 'm generally out by 
 noon, and get a walk. I 'm rather dependent on 
 exercise, and then I lunch with some one or 
 other" 
 
 " Men or women? " 
 
 " Either or both. And then after lunch I drive 
 with some one, or go to see pictures or hear music, 
 and then I like to be at home by tea time, because 
 that 's, of course, the hour every one counts on 
 finding you ; and then there 's dressing and going 
 out to dinner, and very often something after- 
 wards." 
 
 " Good Lord," said Riatt again, and after a 
 moment he added: " And does that life amuse 
 you?" 
 
 " No, but it does n't bore me as much as doing 
 things that are more trouble." 
 
 "What sort of things?" 
 
 " Oh, being on committees that you don't really 
 take any interest in." She rather enjoyed his 
 amazement. 
 
 62 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Now tell me one thing more," he said. 
 " What would you do if you had to earn your 
 living?" 
 
 The true answer was that she would marry 
 Edward Hickson, but, though heretofore she had 
 been fairly candid, she thought on this point a 
 little dissembling was permissible. " I should 
 starve, I suppose," she returned gaily. 
 
 " And suppose you fell in love with a poor 
 man?" 
 
 She grew grave at once. " Oh, that 's a dread- 
 ful thing to happen to one," she said. " I Ve 
 had two friends who did that." She almost 
 shuddered. " One actually married him." 
 
 " And what happened to her? " 
 
 Miss Fenimer shook her head. " I don't 
 know. She 's living in the suburbs somewhere. 
 I have n't seen her for ages." 
 
 u And the other?" 
 
 " She was more practical. She married him 
 to a rich widow ten years older than he was. 
 That provided for him, you see, at least. But 
 it turned out worse than the other case." 
 
 "How?" 
 
 63 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Why, he fell in love with this other 
 
 woman " 
 
 " His wife, you mean? " 
 1 Yes. Imagine it! Men are so fickle." 
 
 " Do you know that you really shock me? " 
 
 " It 's better to appreciate the way things are." 
 
 " It is n't the way things are among decent 
 normal human beings." 
 
 She shrugged her shoulders. " Oh, I imagine 
 it is," she said, " only they 're not honest enough 
 to admit it." 
 
 He continued to stare at her and, strangely 
 enough, she had never seemed to him more beauti- 
 ful. 
 
 " And do you mean to tell me," he said, " that 
 people who have the standards that you describe 
 will attach the slightest importance to an innocent 
 little adventure like this of ours?" 
 
 " Of course. They are the very people who 
 will." 
 
 " Nonsense." 
 
 " Yes, because they make a point of always 
 believing the worst, or at least of pretending to." 
 
 "Why pretend?" 
 
 64 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Because it makes conversation so much more 
 amusing. Sometimes,'' she added thoughtfully, 
 " I have a terrible suspicion that there really is n't 
 an atom of harm in any of them that they all 
 behave perfectly well, and just excite themselves 
 by talking as if they did n't." 
 
 " And you call that suspicion terrible?" 
 
 " Well, it makes it all seem a little flat. But 
 then sometimes," she went on brightly, " one does 
 find out something absolutely hideous." 
 
 " See here," he said, " it 's a crime for a girl of 
 your age to talk like this. It 's a silly habit. I 
 don't believe you 're like that at heart." 
 
 " You talk," said she, " like Edward Hickson." 
 
 " In some communities that would be thought 
 a fighting word," he returned. " But you 
 have n't yet answered my question. You 've told 
 .me what your friends have done; but what would 
 you do yourself, if you fell in love with a poor 
 man?" 
 
 " In the first place, I never should. What 
 makes a man attractive to me is power, preemi- 
 nence, being bowed down to. If I lived in a mili- 
 tary country, I 'd love the greatest soldier ; and 
 
 65 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 if I lived in a savage country, I 'd love the strong- 
 est warrior; but here to-day, the only form of 
 power I see is money. It 's what makes you able 
 to have everything you want, and that 's a man's 
 greatest charm." 
 
 " And it seems to me that the most tied-down 
 creatures I ever saw are the rich men I 've met 
 in the East." 
 
 She was honestly surprised. " Why, what is 
 there they can't do ? " she asked. 
 
 He smiled. " They can't do anything that 
 might endanger their property rights," he an- 
 swered, " and that seems to me to cut them off 
 from most forms of human endeavor. But no 
 matter about that. You say you would not be 
 likely to fall in love with a poor man, but suppose 
 you did. Perhaps it has happened already? " 
 
 Miss Fenimer looked thoughtful. " I was 
 trying to think," she said. " Yes, there was a 
 young artist two years ago that I was rather in- 
 terested in. He was very nice looking, and 
 Nancy Almar kept telling me how much he was 
 in love with her." 
 
 "And that stimulated your interest?" 
 66 
 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Of course." 
 
 " Just for the sake of information," he said, 
 " do you always want to take away any man who 
 is safely devoted to another woman? " 
 
 Christine seemed resolved to be accurate. " It 
 depends, " she answered, " whether or not I have 
 anything else to do, but of course the idea always 
 pops into one's head: I wonder if I couldn't 
 make him like me best." 
 
 " And do you always find you can? " 
 
 " Oh, there 's no rule about it; only as a new- 
 comer one has the advantage of novelty, iand 
 that 's something." 
 
 " And what happened about this artist? " 
 
 Christine smiled reminiscently: " I found he 
 wasn't really in love with Nancy at all: he just 
 wanted to paint her portrait." 
 
 " I should think he would have wanted to paint 
 yours." 
 
 " He did and gave it to me as a present, and 
 then he behaved very badly." She sighed. 
 
 "What did he do?" 
 
 " Well," she hesitated. " He did not really 
 want to give me the picture. He thought he 
 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 wanted to keep it himself. It was much the best 
 thing he ever did. I had to persuade him a good 
 deal, and in persuading him, I may have given 
 him the impression that I cared about him more 
 than I really did. Anyhow, after I actually had 
 the portrait hanging in my sitting-room, I told 
 him I thought it was better for us not to meet 
 any more. Some men would have been flattered 
 to think I took them so seriously. But he was 
 furious, and one day when I was out he sent for 
 the portrait and cut it all to pieces. Was n't that 
 horrible? My pretty portrait ! " 
 
 " Horrible ! " said Riatt. " It seems to me the 
 one spark of spirit the poor young man showed." 
 
 She glanced at him under her lashes. " What 
 would iyou have done?" 
 
 . " I'd take you but to the plains for a year or 
 so, and let you find out a little about what life 
 is like." 
 
 " I don't think it would be a success," she re- 
 turned. " I don't profit by discipline, I 'm afraid. 
 But," she stood up, " I 'm perfectly open minded. 
 I '11 make a beginning. I '11 wash the dishes 
 just to please you." 
 
 68 
 
nd then, with a clean towel, he deliberately dried her hands, finger 
 by finger 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE . 
 
 He watched her go to the kitchen sink, and 
 pour water from the steaming kettle into a dish 
 pan, saw her turn up her lace-frilled cuffs, and 
 begin with her long, slim, inefficient hands to 
 take up the dirty plates. Suddenly, much to his 
 surprise, he found he could n't bear it, could n't 
 bear to see the lace fall down again and again, and 
 her obvious shrinking from the task. 
 
 He crossed the room and took the plates from 
 her, and then with a clean towel, he deliberately 
 dried her hands, finger by finger, while she stood 
 by like a docile child, looking up at liim in wonder. 
 
 " Don't you want to reform me?'* she asked 
 plaintively. 
 
 " No," he answered shortly. 
 
 "Why not?"- 
 
 " Because you would be too dangerous," he 
 returned. " Now you have every charm except 
 goodness. If you turned good and gentle you 'd 
 be supreme." 
 
 " I never thought goodness was a charm" she 
 objected. 
 
 " And that 's just what I hope you will never 
 find out." 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 She laughed. " I don't believe there 's much 
 danger," she said. " I think I shall go on being 
 wicked and mercenary and selfish to the day of 
 my death, and probably getting everything I 
 want." 
 
 " I hope not. I mean I hope you won't get 
 what you want." 
 
 " Oh, why are you so unkind? " 
 
 " Because I shall want to use you as a terrible 
 example to my grandchildren." 
 
 " Do you think you will remember me as long 
 as that?" 
 
 " I feel no doubt about it." 
 
 She smiled. " It seems rather hard that I have 
 to come to a bad end just to oblige your horrid 
 little grandchildren," she said. " As a matter of 
 fact, I shall probably run them down in my motor 
 as they go to work with their little dinner-pails. 
 And as I take their mangled forms to the hospital, 
 I '11 murmur : * Riatt, Riatt, I think I once knew 
 a half-hearted reformer of that name/ ' 
 
 " You think you, too, will remember as long as 
 that?" 
 
 " I have an excellent memory for trifles," she 
 72 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 returned, and rose yawning. " And now I think 
 I '11 go to bed unless there 's anything more you 
 want to know about our tribal customs. Are you 
 going to write a nature book about us : 4 Head- 
 hunting Among the Idle Rich '? " 
 
 " ' The Cannibals of the Atlantic Coast ' is the 
 title," he answered as he gave her a candle. 
 " I '11 leave your breakfast for you in the morning 
 before I go. And by the way, if some one comes 
 to rescue you, don't go off and leave me in the 
 tool-house, will you? " 
 
 " Oh, I 'm not really as bad as that." 
 
 He shook his head as if he did n't feel sure. 
 ' She went away well satisfied with her evening's 
 work. There had been something extremely flat- 
 tering in his mingled horror and amusement at 
 her candid revelations. Holding up the candle 
 she looked at her own image in her mirror. 
 " I wonder," she thought, " if that young man 
 knows what a dangerous frame of mind he 's 
 in?" 
 
 He had some suspicion, for as he dragged a 
 mattress downstairs and laid it before the kitchen 
 fire, he kept repeating to himself, as if in a last 
 
 73 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 effort to rouse some moral enthusiasm : " What 
 a band of cut-throats they are ! " 
 
 Christine woke the next morning to find the 
 sun shining on an unbroken sheet of snow. The 
 storm had passed in the night. She dressed 
 quickly and went down to find the kitchen empty, 
 and the track of footsteps in the snow leading 
 away in the direction of the tool-house. Her 
 coffee was bubbling and slices of bacon neatly laid 
 in the frying pan were ready for cooking. She 
 thought he might have stayed and cooked it for 
 her. 
 
 " No one will come as early as this," she 
 thought, plaintively. 
 
 But hardly had she finished her simple meal, 
 when the sound of sleigh bells reached her ears, 
 and running to the window she .saw that Ussher 
 and Hickson in a two horse sleigh were driving 
 down the slope. 
 
 A moment later they were in the kitchen. And 
 after the minimum time had elapsed during which 
 all three talked at once recounting their own indi- 
 vidual anxieties, Ussher asked: 
 
 "Where's Max?" 
 
 74 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 Christine cast down her eyes with a sort of 
 Paul-and-Virginia expression, as she answered: 
 " Oh, he is sleeping in the tool-house! " 
 
 ; ' Well, I call that damned nonsense," said 
 Ussher. " Let a man freeze to death ! Upon 
 my word, Christine, I thought you had more 
 sense." And he strode away to the back door. 
 " Yes, here are his tracks, poor fellow." Ussher 
 went out after him, and Hickson turned back. 
 
 " But you think I was right, don't you, Ed- 
 ward?" said Christine, for she had never failed 
 to elicit commendation from Edward. 
 
 But now his brow was dark. " But, I say, 
 Christine," he said, " there 's one thing I don't 
 understand. These tracks of his footsteps in the 
 
 snow." 
 
 u He did n't fly, Ned, even if he is an aviator." 
 
 ' Yes, but it did n't stop snowing until four 
 o'clock this morning." 
 
 How irritating the weather always is, Christine 
 thought. For though she was willing to use scan- 
 dal as a weapon over Riatt, she was not sure that 
 she wished to put it into Hickson's hands. 
 
 She thought hard, and then said brightly: 
 75 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Oh, perhaps he came back for his breakfast be- 
 fore I was up." 
 
 Hickson shook his head: " They only lead 
 one way," he said. 
 
 In the face of the tactlessness of hard facts, 
 Christine decided to create a diversion. 
 
 " I can't stand here gossiping about the con- 
 duct of an aviator," she said, " when there 's so 
 much to be done. Look at all these dirty plates. 
 What ought to be done with them, Edward, 
 dear? " she appealed to him as to a fountain of 
 wisdom, and he did not fail her. 
 
 " They ought to be washed," he said. " Give 
 me a towel. I '11 do it." And he felt more than 
 rewarded when, as she handed him a towel, her 
 hand touched his. 
 
 The many duties of which she had just spoken 
 seemed suddenly to have melted away, for she sat 
 down quite idly and watched him. 
 
 " How well you do it, Edward," she said, not 
 quite honestly, for she compared his slow gestures 
 very unfavorably with Riatt's deft hands. " It 's 
 quite as if you had washed dishes all your life." 
 
 " Ah, Christine," he answered, looking at her 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 sentimentally over a coffee-cup, " I should n't ask 
 anything better than to wash your dishes for the 
 rest of my life." 
 
 " Thank you, Edward, but I think I should ask 
 something a good deal better," she answered. 
 
 It was on this scene that Ussher and Riatt en- 
 tered, and the eyes of the latter twinkled. 
 
 " Engaged a kitchen-maid, I see," he said in a 
 low tone to Christine. 
 
 " I think it 's so good for people to do some- 
 thing useful now and then, don't you ? " 
 
 " A form of education that you offer almost 
 every one who comes near you." 
 
 Hickson did not hear everything, but he caught 
 the idea, and said severely: 
 
 " I don't suppose any one would ask Miss 
 Fenimer to wash dirty dishes." 
 
 Riatt laughed : " No one who had ever seen 
 
 her try." 
 
 J 
 
 Ussher, who had been fuming in the back- 
 ground, now broke out: 
 
 " Upon my word, Christine, that tool-house was 
 like a vault. It was madness to ask any one to 
 spend the night in such a place." 
 
 77 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Did you spend the night in the tool-house? " 
 said Hickson with unusual directness. 
 
 " There are worse places than the tool-house," 
 said Riatt, as he and Ussher hurried down to the 
 cellar to put out the furnace fire. 
 
 Hickson turned to Christine. " The fellow 
 did n't answer me," he said. 
 
 " Perhaps he thought it was none of your busi- 
 ness, Edward, my dear," she answered. 
 
 " Everything connected with you is my busi- 
 ness," he returned. 
 
 " Oh, Edward, what a dreary outlook for 
 me!" 
 
 " Christine, answer me. Did or did not this 
 man make advances to you? " 
 
 " Edward, he did." 
 
 "What happened?" 
 
 " He gave me a long, tiresome, moral lecture 
 and, judging by you, my dear, that is proof of 
 affection." 
 
 1 You 're simply amusing yourself with me ! " 
 
 " I 'm not amusing myself very much, Edward, 
 if that 's any comfort." 
 
 " You drive me mad," he said and stamped 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 away from her so hard, that Ussher came up from 
 the cellar. 
 
 "What's Edward doing?" he said. 
 
 " He says he 's going mad," returned Christine, 
 " but I thought he was washing the dishes." 
 
 " There 's no pleasing Edward," said Ussher. 
 " He was in my room at six o'clock this morning 
 trying to get me to start a rescuing party (and 
 I need n't tell you, Christine, we none of us had 
 much sleep last night), and now that he is here 
 and finds you safe, he seems to be just as restless 
 as ever." And Ussher returned to the cellar still 
 grumbling. 
 
 ' You know why I 'm restless, Christine," Hick- 
 son said when they were again alone. 
 Christine seemed to wonder. " The artistic 
 temperament is usually given as the explanation, 
 but somehow, in your case, Edward " 
 
 He came and stood directly in front of her. 
 
 " Christine, what did happen last night? " 
 
 Although not a muscle of Miss Fenimer's face 
 moved, she knew very well that this was a turning- 
 point. She had the choice between killing the 
 scandal, or giving it such life and strength that 
 
 79 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 nothing but her marriage with Riatt would ever 
 allay it. She knew that a few sensible words 
 would put Hickson straight, and Hickson would 
 be a powerful ally. On the other hand, if he 
 came back plainly weighted with a terrible doubt, 
 no one would ask any further evidence. The 
 question was, how much would Riatt feel the re- 
 sponsibility of such a situation. It was a fighting 
 chance. Themistocles when he burnt his ships 
 must have argued in very much the same way, 
 but probably not so rapidly. 
 
 " There are some things, Edward," Christine 
 said in a low shaken voice, " that I cannot discuss 
 even with you." 
 
 Hickson turned away with a groan. 
 
 80 
 
CHAPTER III 
 
 /CHRISTINE had been right when she told 
 V^4 Riatt that Nancy Almar would be resentful 
 after a dull evening at the Usshers'. 
 
 The evening, as far as Nancy was concerned, 
 had been very dull indeed. To be bored, in her 
 creed, was a confession of complete failure; it 
 indicated the most contemptible inefficiency, since 
 she designed the whole fabric of her life with the 
 unique object of keeping herself amused. Noth- 
 ing bored her more than to have the general atten- 
 tion centered on some one else, as all that eve- 
 ning it had been focussed on the absent ones. 
 Not only did she miss the excitement of her con- 
 test with Christine over the possession of Riatt, 
 but she was positively wearied by the Usshers 1 
 anxiety, by her brother's agony of jealousy and 
 fear, and by Wickham's continual effort to strike 
 an original thought from the dramatic quality of 
 the situation. 
 
 She was finally reduced to playing piquet with 
 81 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 Wickham, and though she won a good deal of 
 money from him more, that is, than he could 
 comfortably afford to lose she still counted the 
 evening a failure, bad in the present, and ex- 
 tremely menacing to the future. For with her 
 habitual mental candor, she admitted that by this 
 time Christine, if not actually frozen to death 
 which after all one could not exactly hope had 
 probably won the game. The chances were that 
 Riatt was captured. 
 
 "What is the matter, Ned?" she said to her 
 brother, as he fidgeted about the card-table, after 
 a last futile expedition to the telephone. " Can't 
 you decide whether you 'd rather the lady of your 
 love were dead or subjected for twenty-four hours 
 to the fascinations of an irresistible young man? " 
 
 " What an interesting question that raises," ob- 
 served Wickham, examining rather ruefully the 
 three meager cards he had drawn. " A modern 
 Lady-or-the-Tiger idea. I am not of a jealous 
 temperament and should always prefer to see a 
 woman happy with another man." 
 
 " And often do, I dare say," said Nancy. " I 
 have a point of seven, and fourteen aces." 
 
 82 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " I must own I can't see Riatt's irresistible qual- 
 ity," said Hickson irritably. 
 
 " Rich, nice-looking and has his wits about 
 him," replied Mrs. Almar succinctly. 
 
 " About as good-looking as a fence-rail." 
 
 " And they say women are envious ! " exclaimed 
 his sister. 
 
 "Are you a feminist, Mrs. Almar?" inquired 
 the irrepressible Wickham. 
 
 " No, just a female, Mr. Wickham." 
 
 " I never thought a big bony nose made a man 
 a beauty," grumbled Hickson. 
 
 " Ah, how much wisdom there is in that reply 
 of yours, Mrs. Almar," said Wickham. " Just 
 a female. Your meaning is, if I interpret you 
 rightly, that you are content with the duties and 
 charms which Nature has bestowed upon your 
 sex" 
 
 "Until I can get something better," replied 
 Nancy briskly, drawing the score toward her and 
 beginning to add it up. " My idea is to let the 
 other women do the fighting; if they win, I shall 
 profit; if they lose, I 'm no worse off. I believe 
 I Ve rubiconed you again, Mr. Wickham." 
 
 83 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Well, I don't understand women's taste, any- 
 how," said Hickson. 
 
 " You never spoke a truer word than that, my 
 dear," said Nancy. " Seventy-four fifty, I think 
 that makes it, Mr. Wickham, subtracting the dol- 
 lar and a half you made on the first game. Oh, 
 yes, a check will do perfectly. I 'm less likely to 
 lose it." 
 
 " I never had a worse run of luck," observed 
 Wickham with an attempt at indifference. 
 
 Mrs. Almar stood up yawning. " Doubtless 
 you are on the brink of a great amorous tri- 
 umph," she said languidly, and went off to bed. 
 
 Hickson did not attempt to sleep. He sat up 
 for the remainder of the night, in the hope that 
 some sudden call might come, and at six o'clock 
 as Ussher had told Christine, he was ready for 
 new efforts. 
 
 Rescued and rescuers reached the Usshers' 
 house about half past ten the following morning. 
 Nancy was not yet downstairs. Wickham had 
 not been able to judge what was the correct note 
 to strike in connection with the whole incident, 
 and so did not dare to sound any. The arrival 
 
 84 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 was comparatively simple. Mrs. Ussher re- 
 ceived her beloved Christine with open arms; 
 Riatt went noncommittally upstairs to take a bath; 
 Hickson had decided, in spite of his depression of 
 spirits, to try to make up a little of last night's 
 lost sleep, when he received a summons from his 
 sister. Her maid, a clever, sallow little French- 
 woman, came down with her hands in her apron 
 pockets to say that Madame should like to speak 
 to Monsieur at once. 
 
 He found Nancy still in bed; her little black 
 head looking blacker than usual against the lace 
 of the pillows and the coverlet and of her own 
 bed-jacket. The only color about her was the 
 yellow covered French novel she laid down as he 
 entered, and the one enormous ruby on her fourth 
 finger. 
 
 " And now, Ned, my dear," she said quite af- 
 fectionately for her, " I hear you have brought 
 the wanderers safely home. Tell me all about 
 it." 
 
 Hickson, to whom this summons had not come 
 as a surprise, had resolved that he would confide 
 none of his anxieties to his sister but, alas, as 
 
 85 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 well might a pane of glass resolve to be opaque 
 to a ray of sunlight. Within ten minutes, Nancy 
 knew not only all that he knew, but such addi- 
 tional deductions as her sharper wits enabled her 
 to draw. 
 
 " I see," she murmured, as he finished. " The 
 only positive fact that we have is that he did not 
 leave the house until after five. How very inter- 
 esting! " 
 
 " Very terrible," said Hickson. 
 
 " Terrible," exclaimed Nancy, with the most 
 genuine surprise. " Not at all. From your 
 point of view most encouraging. It can mean 
 only one thing. The young man very prudently 
 ran away." 
 
 Edward was really stirred to anger. " Nancy," 
 he said, " how do you dare, even in fun " 
 
 " Oh, my dear," answered his sister, as one 
 wearied by all the folly in the world, " how can 
 I be of any use to you if you will not open your 
 eyes? He ran away. We don't know of course 
 just from what; but we do know this: Max 
 Riatt is the best match that has yet presented him- 
 self, and that Christine is the last girl in the world 
 
 86 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 to ignore that simple fact. Come, Ned, even if 
 you do love her, you may as well admit the girl 
 is not a perfect fool. Fate, accident, or possibly 
 her own clever maneuvering put the game into 
 her hands. The question is, how did she play 
 it? I know what I 'd have done, but I don't 
 believe she would. I think she probably tried to 
 make him believe that she was hopelessly com- 
 promised in the eyes of the world, and that there 
 was no course open to an honorable man but to 
 ask her to marry him." 
 
 " I can't imagine Christine playing such a 
 part." 
 
 " I tell you, you never do the poor girl justice. 
 If she did that and the chances are she did 
 then his running away is most encouraging. It 
 means, in your own delightful language, that he 
 did not fall for it did not want to run any risk 
 of compromising her, if marriage was the con- 
 sequence." 
 
 " But, Nancy, Christine almost admitted that 
 that he tried to make love to her." 
 
 " I can't see what that has to do with it, or 
 what difference it makes," replied Mrs. Almar. 
 
 87 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " However, too much importance should not be 
 attached to such admissions. I have sometimes 
 made them myself when the facts did not bear me 
 out. No woman likes to confess, especially to 
 an old adorer like you, that she has spent so 
 many hours alone with a man and he has not 
 made love to her." 
 
 Hickson shook his head. " I 'm not clever 
 enough to be able to explain it," he said, " but 
 I received the clearest impression from her that 
 she had been through some painful experience." 
 
 " Good," said Nancy. " Do you know the 
 most painful experience she could have been 
 through?" 
 
 "No, what?" 
 
 " If he had n't paid the slightest attention to 
 her; and that, my dear brother, is what I am in- 
 clined to think took place. No, the game is still 
 on ; only now she '11 have the Usshers to help her. 
 This is no time for me to lie in bed." 
 
 Ned looked at her doubtfully. " I thought 
 I 'd try and sleep a little," he said. 
 
 "The best thing you can do," she returned. 
 " Lucie ! Lucie 1 Where are the bells in this 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 house! What privations one suffers for staying 
 away from home! Oh, yes, here it is," and she 
 caught the atom of enamel and gold dangling at 
 the head of her bed, and rang it without ceasing 
 until the maid, who regarded her mistress with 
 an admiration quite untinctured by affection, ap- 
 peared silently at the doorway. 
 
 In an astonishingly short space of time, she 
 was dressed and downstairs, presenting her usual 
 sleek and polished appearance. Wickham was 
 alone in the drawing-room, and a suggestion that 
 they should have another game of piquet quickly 
 drove him to the writing of some purely imagi- 
 nary business letters. 
 
 The coast was thus clear, but Riatt was still 
 absent. 
 
 Nancy's methods were nothing if not direct. 
 She rang the bell and when the butler appeared 
 she said: 
 
 "Where is Mr. Riatt?" 
 
 " In his room, madam." 
 
 " Dressing? " 
 
 " No, madam, he is dressed. Resting, I should 
 say." 
 
 89 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 Nancy nodded her head once. " One mo- 
 ment," she said; and going to the writing table 
 she sat down and wrote quickly: 
 
 " I should like five minutes' conversation with 
 you. Strange to say my motive is altruistic 
 so altruistic that I feel I should sign myself * Pro 
 Bono Publico,' instead of Nancy Almar. There 
 is no one down here in the drawing-room at the 
 moment." 
 
 She put this in an envelope, sealed it with seal- 
 ing wax (to the disgust of the butler who found 
 it hard enough, as it was, to keep up with all 
 that went on in the house) and told the man to 
 send it at once to Mr. Riatt's room. 
 
 She did not have long to wait. Riatt, with all 
 the satisfaction in his bearing of one who has 
 just bathed, shaved and eaten, came down to her 
 at once. 
 
 " Good morning, Pro Bono Publico," he said, 
 just glancing about to be sure he was not over- 
 heard. " It was not necessary to put this inter- 
 view on an altruistic basis. I should have been 
 
 90 
 
Isn't that rather a reckless way for a man in your situation to talk ? " 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 glad to come to it, even if it had been as a favor 
 to you." 
 
 She looked at him with her hard, dark eyes. 
 " Is n't that rather a reckless way for a man in 
 your situation to talk? " 
 
 " I was not aware that I was in a situation." 
 
 This was exactly the expression that she had 
 wanted from him. It seemed to come spontane- 
 ously, and could only mean that at least he was 
 not newly engaged. 
 
 She relaxed the tension of her attitude. " Are 
 you really under the impression that you 're 
 not?" 
 
 " I feel quite sure of it." 
 
 " You poor, dear, innocent creature." 
 
 " However," he went on, sitting down beside 
 her on the wide, low sofa, " something tells me 
 that I shall enjoy extremely having you tell me 
 all about it." 
 
 Tucking one foot under her, as every girl is 
 taught in the school-room it is most unladylike to 
 do, she turned and faced him. " Mr. Riatt," she 
 said, " when I was a child I used to let the mice 
 out of the traps not so much, I 'm afraid, from 
 
 93 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 tenderness for the mice, as from dislike of my 
 natural enemy, the cook. Since then I have never 
 been able to see a mouse in anybody's trap but my 
 own, without a desire to release it." 
 
 " And I am the mouse? " 
 
 She nodded. " And in rather a dangerous sort 
 of trap, too." 
 
 He smiled at the seriousness of her tone. 
 
 " Ah," said she, " the self-confidence which 
 your smile betrays is one of the weaknesses by 
 which nature has delivered your sex into the hands 
 of mine. I would explain it to you at length, but 
 the time is too short. The great offensive may 
 begin at any moment. The Usshers have made 
 up their minds that you are to marry Christine 
 Fenimer. That was why you were asked here." 
 
 " Innocent Westerner as I am," he answered, 
 " that idea " 
 
 She interrupted him. " Yes, but don't you see 
 it 's entirely different now. Now they really have 
 a sort of hold on you. I don't know what Chris- 
 tine's own attitude may be, but I can tell you 
 this: her position was so difficult that she was on 
 the point of engaging herself to Ned." 
 
 94 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Oh, come," said Riatt politely, " your brother 
 is not so bad as you seem to think." 
 
 " He 's not bad at all, poor dear. He 's very 
 good; but women do not fall in love with him. 
 You, on the contrary, are rich and attractive. 
 You '11 just have to take my word for that," she 
 added without a trace of coquetry. " And so 
 and so and so, if I were you, my dear Cousin 
 Max, I should give orders to have my bag packed 
 at once, and take a very slow, tiresome train that 
 leaves here at twelve-forty-something, and not 
 even wait for the afternoon express." 
 
 There was that in her tone that would have 
 made the blood of any man run cold with terror, 
 but he managed a smile. " In my place you 
 would run away? " he said. 
 
 She shook her head. " No, I would n't run 
 away myself, but I advise you to. I shouldn't 
 be in any danger. Being a mere woman, I can 
 be cruel, cold and selfish when the occasion de- 
 mands. But this is a situation that requires all 
 the qualities a man does n't possess." 
 
 "What do you mean?" 
 
 " Does your heart become harder when a 
 
 95 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 pretty woman cries ? Is your conscience unmoved 
 by the responsibility of some one else's unhappi- 
 ness? Can you be made love to without a haunt- 
 ing suspicion that you brought it on your- 
 self?" 
 
 " Good heavens, no ! " cried Riatt from the 
 heart. 
 
 " Then, run while there 's time." 
 
 As the ox fears the gad-fly and the elephant the 
 mouse, so does the bravest of men fear the emo- 
 tional entanglement of any making but his own. 
 For an instant Riatt felt himself swept by the 
 frankest, wildest panic. Misadventures among 
 the clouds he had had many times, and had looked 
 a clean straight death in the face. He had never 
 felt anything like the terror that for an instant 
 possessed him. Then it passed and he said with 
 conviction : 
 
 " Well, after all, there are certain things you 
 can't be made to do against your will." 
 
 " Certainly. But you are not referring to mar- 
 riage, are you? " 
 
 " Yes, I was." 
 
 "My poor, dear man! As if half the mar- 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 riages in the world were not made against the 
 wish of one party or the other." 
 
 His heart sank. " It J s perfectly true," he 
 said. " And yet one does rather hate to run 
 away." 
 
 " Not so much as one hates afterward to think 
 one might have." 
 
 He laughed and she went on : " The moment 
 is critical. Laura Ussher and Christine have 
 been closeted together for the better part of two 
 hours. Something is going to happen immedi- 
 ately. At any moment Laura may appear and 
 say with that wonderfully casual manner of hers, 
 * May I have a word with you, Max?' And 
 then you '11 be lost." 
 
 " Oh, not quite as bad as that, I hope," said 
 Riatt. 
 
 " Lost," she repeated, and leaning over she 
 laid one polished finger tip on the bell. " When, 
 the man comes, tell him to get you ready for that 
 early train." 
 
 There was complete silence between them until 
 the footman appeared and Riatt had given the 
 necessary orders. 
 
 97 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 u I wonder/* he said when they were again 
 alone, " whether I shall be angry at you for this 
 advice, or grateful. It 's a dangerous thing, you 
 know, to advise a man to run away." 
 
 " Dine with me in town on Wednesday, and you 
 can tell me which it is." 
 
 " You don't seem to be much afraid of my 
 anger." 
 
 " I think perhaps your gratitude might be the 
 more dangerous of the two;" 
 
 While he was struggling between a new-found 
 prudence, and a natural desire to inquire further 
 into her meaning, a door upstairs was heard to 
 shut, and presently Laura Ussher came sauntering 
 into the room. 
 
 " You 're up early, Nancy," she said pleas- 
 antly. 
 
 " I thought I ought to recognize the return of 
 the wanderers in some way particularly, as I 
 hear we are to lose one of them so soon." 
 
 Mrs. Ussher glanced quickly at her cousin. 
 " Are you leaving us, Max? " 
 
 " I 'm sorry to say I Ve just had word that I 
 must, and I told the man to make arrangements 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 for me to get that twelve-something-or-other 
 
 train." 
 
 Mrs. Ussher did not change a muscle. " I 'm 
 sorry you have to go," she said. " We shall all 
 miss you. By the way, you won't be able to get 
 anything before the four-eighteen. That midday 
 train is taken off in winter. Did n't the footman 
 tell you ? Stupid young man ; but he 's new and 
 has not learnt the trains yet, I suppose. Do you 
 want to send a telegram? They have to be tele- 
 phoned here, but if you write it out I '11 have it 
 sent for you." 
 
 " How wonderful you are, Laura," murmured 
 Mrs. Almar. 
 
 Mrs. Ussher looked vague. " In what way, 
 dear?" 
 
 " In all ways, but I think it 's as a friend that 
 I admire you most." 
 
 Mrs. Ussher smiled. " Yes," she said, " I 'm 
 very devoted to my friends even when they don't 
 behave quite fairly to me. But I love my rela- 
 tions, too," she added. " Max, since I 'm to lose 
 you so soon, I 'd like to have a talk with you 
 before lunch. Shall we go to my little study? " 
 
 99 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 Nancy's eyes danced. " No, Laura," she said, 
 " he will not. He has just promised to teach 
 me a new solitaire, and I won't yield him to any 
 
 one." 
 
 Riatt, terrified at this proof that Nancy's proph- 
 ecy was coming true, resolved to cling to her. 
 
 " Sit down and learn the game, too, Laura," 
 he said. " It 's a very good one." 
 
 " I want to speak to you about a business mat- 
 ter, Max." 
 
 " I never attend to business during church 
 hours, Laura," he answered. " We '11 talk about 
 it after lunch, if you like." 
 
 Laura had learnt the art of yielding gracefully. 
 " That will do just as well," she said, and sat 
 down to watch the game. 
 
 Presently Wickham, seeing that Mrs. Almar 
 seemed to be safely engaged, ventured back. And 
 they were all thus innocently occupied when lunch- 
 eon was announced. 
 
 Christine came down looking particularly 
 lovely. It is a precaution which a good-looking 
 woman rarely fails to take in a crisis. She was 
 wearing a deep blue dress trimmed with fur, and 
 
 IOO 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 only needed a solid gold halo behind her head 
 to make her look like a Byzantine saint. 
 
 " Well, Miss Fenimer," said Wickham, as they 
 sat down. " You look very blooming after your 
 terrible experiences." 
 
 Christine had come prepared for battle. 
 " Oh, they were n't so very terrible, Mr. Wick- 
 ham, thank you," she said, and she leant her 
 elbow on the table and played with those imita- 
 tion pearls which she now hoped so soon to give 
 to her maid. " Mr. Riatt is the most wonderful 
 provider expert as a cook as well as a furnace- 
 
 man." 
 
 " It may n't have been terrible for you," put 
 in Ussher, who had a habit of conversational 
 reversion, " but I bet it was no joke in the tool- 
 house 1 How an intelligent woman like you, 
 Christine, could dream of making a man spend 
 the night in that hole, just for the sake 
 of" 
 
 " But I thought it was Mr. Riatt's own choice," 
 said Nancy gently. 
 
 " You would n't think so if you could have felt 
 the place," Ussher continued. " And what dif- 
 
 101 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 ference did it make? Who was there to talk? 
 Every one knows that their being there was just 
 an unavoidable accident " 
 
 " Oh, if it had been an accident ! " said Nancy, 
 and it was as if a little venomous snake had 
 suddenly wriggled itself into the conversation. 
 Every one turned toward her, and her brother 
 asked sternly: 
 
 "If, it had been an accident, Nancy? What 
 the deuce do you mean by if?" 
 
 Nancy shook her small head. " I express my- 
 self badly," she said. " English rhetoric was left 
 out of my education." 
 
 " You manage to convey your ideas, dear," 
 said Laura. 
 
 " I was trying to say that if poor, dear Chris- 
 tine had not been so unfortunately the one to hit 
 the horse in the head, and start him off " 
 
 Wickham pricked up his ears. " Oh, I say, 
 Miss Fenimer," he exclaimed, " did you really 
 hit the horse?" 
 
 " Certainly, I did, Mr. Wickham." 
 
 " But what did you do that for? " 
 
 Christine did not trouble to answer this ques- 
 102 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 tion. Hickson, who had been suffering far more 
 than any one, rushed to the rescue. 
 
 " Miss Fenimer did not do it on purpose, 
 Wickham. She happened to be standing " 
 
 "Oh, is that what your sister meant?" said 
 Christine, as if a sudden light dawned on her. 
 " Tell me, Nancy darling, do you really think I 
 hit the horse on purpose, so as to have an uninter- 
 rupted evening with Mr. Riatt? How you do 
 flatter men ! It 's a great art. I 'm afraid I 
 shall never learn it." 
 
 For the first time, Riatt found himself looking 
 at her with a certain amount of genuine admira- 
 tion. This was very straight fighting. " They 
 have the piratical virtues," he thought, " courage, 
 and the ability to give and take hard blows." 
 
 Mrs. Almar was not to be outdone. " Well," 
 she said, " I may as well be honest. I can 
 imagine myself doing it, for the right man. And 
 we should have had an amusing evening of it, 
 which was more than we had here, I can tell you. 
 We were very dreary. Mr. Wickham tried to 
 relieve the monotony by a game of piquet, but 
 I 'm afraid he did not really enjoy it, for he has 
 
 103 
 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 not asked me to play since." And she cast a quick, 
 stimulating glance at Wickham, whose usual in- 
 ability to say nothing again betrayed him. 
 
 " Oh," he said, " I enjoyed our game im- 
 mensely." 
 
 " Good," answered Nancy. " We '11 have an- 
 other this afternoon then." 
 
 u Indeed, yes," said Wickham, looking rather 
 wan. 
 
 " After Mr. Riatt has gone," said Nancy dis- 
 tinctly. She knew that Laura had had no oppor- 
 tunity to convey this intelligence to Christine, and 
 it amused her to see how she would support the 
 blow. Christine's expression did not change, but 
 her blue eyes grew suddenly a little darker. She 
 turned slowly toward Riatt. 
 
 " And are you leaving us? " she asked. 
 
 " Sorry to say I am." 
 
 "What a bore," said Miss Fenimer politely. 
 Hickson's simple heart bounded for joy. " She 's 
 refused him," he thought, " and that 's why he 's 
 rushing off like this." 
 
 " Yes," said Ussher, " I should think he would 
 want to go home and take some care of himself. 
 
 104 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 It 's a wonder if he does n't develop pneu- 
 
 monia." 
 
 Christine smiled at Riatt across the table. 
 " They make me feel as if I had been very cruel, 
 Mr. Riatt," she said. 
 
 " Cruel, my dear," cried Nancy. " Oh, I 'm 
 sure you were n't that" and then intoxicated by 
 her own success, she made her first tactical error. 
 She turned to Riatt and said: "Don't forget 
 that you are dining with me on Wednesday eve- 
 ning." She enjoyed this exhibition of power. 
 She saw Laura and Christine glance at each other. 
 But they were not dismayed; they saw at once that 
 Max had not been playing his hand alone; he was 
 going not entirely on his own initiative, and that 
 was encouraging. 
 
 Riatt, who perfectly understood the public pro- 
 tectorate that was thus established over him, re- 
 sented it; in fact by the time they rose from the 
 table, he was thoroughly disgusted with all of 
 them weary, as he said to himself of their 
 hideous little games. He hardened his heart even 
 as Pharaoh did, and he felt not the least hesita- 
 tion in according Laura the promised interview, 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 for the reason that he felt no doubt of his own 
 powers of resistance. 
 
 He permitted himself to be ostentatiously led 
 away, upstairs to her little private sitting-room, 
 with its books, and fireplace, and signed photo- 
 graphs, and he pretended not to see Nancy 
 Almar's glance, which was almost a wink, and 
 might have been occasioned by the fact that she 
 herself was at the same moment gently guiding 
 Wickham in the direction of a card-table. 
 
 Laura made her cousin very comfortable, in a 
 long chair by the fire, with his cigarettes and his 
 coffee beside him on a little table, and then she 
 began murmuring: 
 
 " Is n't it a pity Nancy Almar is so poisonous 
 at times ! She is n't really bad hearted, but any- 
 thing connected with Christine has always roused 
 her jealousy the old beauty and the new one, 
 I suppose." 
 
 " I wonder," said Riatt, " what is the differ- 
 ence, if any, between a pirate and a bucaneer? 
 Miss Fenimer and Mrs. Almar seem to me to 
 have many qualities in common." 
 
 " Oh, Max, how can you say that? Christine 
 106 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 is so much more gentle and womanly, so much " 
 " My dear Laura, we have n't very much time, 
 and I think you said you wanted to talk to me on 
 a business matter." 
 
 Laura Ussher had the grace to hesitate, just 
 an instant, before she answered: " Oh, yes, but 
 it 's your business I want to talk about. I want 
 to speak to you about this terrible situation in 
 which Christine finds herself. Do you realize 
 that Nancy and Wickham between them will 
 spread this story everywhere, with all the embel- 
 lishments their fancy may dictate, particularly em- 
 phasizing the fact that it was Christine who made 
 the horse run away. It will be in the papers 
 within a week. You know, Max, just as well as 
 I do, that it was n't her fault. Is she to be so 
 cruelly punished for it? Can you permit that? " 
 " It 's not my fault either, Laura." 
 " You can so easily save the situation." 
 "How?" 
 
 " By asking her to marry you." 
 " That I will not do." 
 " Are you involved with some one else? " 
 " I might make you understand better if I said 
 107 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 yes, but it would not be true. I 'm not in love 
 with any individual, but I know clearly the type 
 of woman I could fall in love with, and it most 
 emphatically is not Miss Fenimer's." 
 
 " Yet so many men have fallen in love with 
 her." 
 
 " Oh, I see her beauty; I even feel her charm; 
 but to marry her, no." 
 
 "Think of the prestige her beauty and posi- 
 
 tion" 
 
 " My dear Laura, what position? Social posi- 
 tion as represented by the hectic triviality of the 
 last few days? Thank you, no, again." 
 
 " Dear Max," said his cousin more seriously 
 than she had hitherto spoken, " you know I would 
 not want you to do anything that I thought would 
 make you unhappy. But this would n't. I know 
 Christine better than you do. I know that under 
 all her worldliness and hardness there is a vein 
 of devotion and sweetness " 
 
 " Very likely there is. But it would not be 
 brought out by a mercenary marriage with a man 
 who cared nothing for her. If that is all you 
 have to say, Laura, let 's end an interview which 
 
 108 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 has n't been very pleasant for either of us." 
 
 " Oh, Max, how can you abandon that lovely 
 creature to some tragic future? " 
 
 " You know quite well she is going to do noth- 
 ing more tragic than to marry Hickson." 
 
 " And you are willing to sacrifice her to Hick- 
 son?" 
 
 " My dear Laura, I cannot prevent all the 
 beautiful, dissatisfied women in the world from 
 marrying dull, kind-hearted young men who adore 
 them." 
 
 Mrs. Ussher stared at him in baffled, unhappy 
 silence, and in the pause, the door quickly and 
 silently opened and Christine herself entered. 
 She looked calm, almost Olympian, as she laid her 
 hand on Laura's arm. 
 
 " Let me have just a word alone with Mr. 
 Riatt," she said; and as Laura precipitately left 
 the room, Christine turned to Riatt with a reas- 
 suring smile. " Don't be alarmed," she said. 
 " Your most dangerous antagonist has just gone. 
 I Ve really come to rescue you." She sank into 
 a chair. " How exhausting scenes are. Let me 
 have a cigarette, will you?" 
 
 109 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 She smoked a moment in silence, while he stood 
 erect and alert by the mantel-piece. At last, 
 glancing up at him, she said: 
 
 " I suppose Laura was suggesting that you 
 marry me? " 
 
 He nodded. 
 
 " Laura J s a dear, but not always very wise. 
 You see, she thinks we are both so wonderful, she 
 can't believe we would n't make each other happy. 
 And from her point of view, it is rather an obvi- 
 ous solution. You see, she does not know about 
 that paragon in the Middle West." 
 
 " She existed only in my imagination." 
 
 " Oh, a dream-lady," said Christine, and her 
 eyes' brightened a little. " No wonder you 
 thought her too good for Ned. Well, that brings 
 me to what I came to tell you. I have decided 
 to marry Edward Hickson." 
 
 There was a blank and rather flat pause, during 
 which Riatt took his cigarette from his mouth and 
 very carefully studied the ash, but could think of 
 nothing to say. The thought in his mind was that 
 Hickson was a dull dog. 
 
 no 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Have you told Hickson? " he asked after a 
 moment. 
 
 She shook her head. " No, and I sha'n't till 
 I get more accustomed to the idea myself. It 
 isn't exactly an easy idea to get accustomed to. 
 The prospect is not lively." 
 
 " I dare say you will contrive to make it as 
 lively as possible." 
 
 She smiled drearily. " How very poorly you 
 do think of me ! I sha'n't make Ned a bad wife. 
 He will be very happy, and Nancy and I will 
 be like sisters. By the way, you 're not in love 
 with Nancy, are you? " 
 
 " Certainly not." 
 
 " Good. They all say it 's a dog's life." She 
 yawned. " Oh, is n't everything tiresome ! If 
 I had had any idea my filial deed in going to find * 
 my father's coat would have resulted in my hav- 
 ing to marry Ned, I never would have gone." 
 
 Riatt struggled in silence. He wanted any 
 man would have wanted to ask her whether 
 there wasn't some other way out; but knowing 
 that he himself was the only other way, he re- 
 
 iii 
 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 frained and asked instead: "Is there anything 
 I can do to help you?" 
 
 " There is," she responded promptly. 
 " Rather a disagreeable thing, too. But it will be 
 all over in an instant, and you can take your after- 
 noon train and forget all about us. Will you do 
 it?" 
 
 He hesitated, and she went on: 
 
 " Ah, cautious to the last ! It 's just a demon- 
 stration, a beau geste. It J s this : J[ou see, the 
 situation, as I have discovered from a little talk 
 with Ned, is more ugly than has yet appeared. 
 They are holding one thing up their sleeve. Ned, 
 it seems, noticed the track of your feet leaving 
 the house, and it did not stop snowing until the 
 morning. That was rather careless of you, 
 was n't it? Nancy can make a good deal of that 
 one little fact." 
 
 " What people you are ! " 
 
 " Rather horrid, are n't we? Did Laura keep 
 telling you what a wonderful advantage it would 
 be for you to be one of us? I wish I could have 
 seen your face." 
 
 " Yes, she did say something of the advantages 
 112 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 of belonging to a group like this. Do you know 
 what any man who married you ought to do with 
 you," he added with sudden vigor. " He ought 
 to take you to the smallest, ugliest, deadest 
 town he could find and keep you there five 
 years." 
 
 " Thank you," she said. " You have achieved 
 the impossible. You have made Ned seem quite 
 exciting. Hitherto I have taken New York for 
 granted, but now I shall add it to his positive 
 advantages. But you have n't heard yet what it 
 is I want you to do." 
 
 "What is it?" 
 
 " I want you to make me a well authenticated 
 offer of marriage before you go for good." 
 
 " Miss Fenimer, I have the honor to ask you 
 to marry me." 
 
 " I regret so much, Mr. Riatt, that a previous 
 attachment prevents my accepting but, my dear 
 man, thaft is n't at all what I mean. Do you sup- 
 pose Wickham and Nancy will believe me just 
 because I walk out of this room and say you asked 
 me to marry you ? No, we must have some proof 
 to offer." 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Something in writing? " 
 
 She hesitated. 
 
 " No," she said, " one really can't go about 
 with a framed proposal like a college degree. I 
 want a public demonstration." 
 
 " Something with a band or a phonograph? " 
 
 She was evidently thinking it out or wished 
 to appear to be. " Not quite that either. This 
 would be more like it. Suppose I send for Nancy 
 to come here now and consult with me as to 
 whether I shall accept your offer or not. If I 
 told her before you, she could hardly refuse to 
 believe it. And you would be safe, for there 
 is n't the least doubt what advice she will give 
 
 me." 
 
 u You think she will advise you against me? " 
 
 Christine nodded. " She will try to save you 
 
 from the awful fate she is reserving for her 
 
 brother." She touched the bell. " Do you feel 
 
 nervous? " 
 
 " A trifle," he answered, and indeed he did, 
 for he knew better than Christine could, how 
 strange this coming interview would appear to 
 Mrs. Almar after the conversation before lunch. 
 
 114 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 He consoled himself, however, by the thought that 
 train-time was drawing near, " and then, please 
 heaven," he said to himself, " I need never see 
 any of them again." 
 
 "Isn't it strange," began Miss Fenimer, and 
 then as a servant appeared in the doorway: 
 " Oh, will you please ask Mrs. Almar to come 
 here for a few minutes and speak to me. Tell 
 her it is very important. Is n't it strange," she 
 went on, when the man had gone, " that I 'm not 
 a bit nervous, and yet I have so much more at 
 stake than you have." 
 
 * You have a good deal clearer notion of your 
 role than I." 
 
 " Your role is easy. You confirm everything 
 I say, and contrive to look a little depressed at 
 the end. Nothing could be simpler." 
 
 He hesitated. " Simpler than to look de- 
 pressed when you refuse me? " 
 
 " No one really likes to be refused," she said. 
 " Even I, hardened as I am, felt a certain distaste 
 for the idea that Laura had been urging me on 
 your reluctant acceptance. By the way, you did 
 seem able to say no, after all your talk on our 
 
 "5 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 unfortunate drive about no man's being able to 
 refuse a woman." 
 
 " Oh, a third party," he answered. " That 's 
 a very different thing. Had it been you yourself, 
 with streaming eyes " He looked at her sit- 
 ting very cool and straight at a safe distance. 
 
 " I don't think I could cry to save my life," she 
 observed. " Certainly not to save my reputa- 
 tion." 
 
 He did not answer. The situation had begun 
 to seem like a game to him, or some absurd farce 
 in which he was only reading some regular actor's 
 part; and when presently the door opened to 
 admit Mrs. Almar, he felt as if she had been 
 waiting all the time in the wings. 
 
 Nancy stopped with a gesture of surprise, on 
 finding that she was interrupting a tete-a-tete. 
 Christine ignored her astonishment. 
 
 " Nancy dear," she said. " How nice of you 
 to come, when I know how busy you were teaching 
 Wickham piquet. Sit down. This is the reason 
 I sent for you. As one of my best friends, I want 
 your candid advice about this horrid situa- 
 
 tion." 
 
 116 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " But Laura is one of your best friends, too," 
 said Mrs. Almar. 
 
 " You '11 see why I did not send for Laura. 
 She is so ridiculously prejudiced in favor of Mr. 
 Riatt. There 's no question as to what her ad- 
 vice would be. In fact," said Christine with the 
 frankest laugh, " she 's advised it long ago 
 even before he asked me." 
 
 At these sinister words, Mrs. Almar gave a 
 glance like the jab of a knife at Riatt. 
 
 " See here, Christine," she said, " every min- 
 ute I spend here is a direct pecuniary loss to me. 
 Let 's get to the point." 
 
 " Of course. How selfish I am," answered 
 Miss Fenimer. " The point is this. In view of 
 the gossip and talk, and your own dear little sug- 
 gestion, darling, that I had frightened the horse 
 on purpose, Mr. Riatt has thought it neces- 
 sary to ask me to marry him. I say he has 
 thought it necessary, because in spite of all his 
 flattering protestations, I can't help feeling that 
 he 's done it from a sense of duty. But whatever 
 his sentiments may be, I Ve been quite open about 
 mine. I 'm not in love with him. In view of all 
 
 117 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 this, Nancy, do you think it advisable that I accept 
 his offer? " 
 
 Mrs. Almar had never been considered partic- 
 ularly good-tempered. Now she jumped to her 
 feet with her eyes positively blazing. " Have I 
 been called away from the care of my depleted 
 bank account to take part in a farce like this? " 
 she cried. " You ought to be ashamed of your- 
 self, Christine. You know just as well as I do 
 that that young man never even thought of asking 
 you to marry him." 
 
 Christine was quite unruffled. " Oh, Nancy 
 dear," she said, " how helpful you always are. I 
 see what you mean. You think no one will be- 
 lieve that he ever did propose unless I accept him. 
 I think you 're perfectly right." 
 
 " They won't and I don't," said Nancy, and 
 moved rapidly to the door. 
 
 " One moment, Mrs. Almar," said Riatt, firmly. 
 " You happen to be mistaken. I did very defi- 
 nitely ask Miss Fenimer to marry me not ten 
 minutes ago." 
 
 " And do you renew that request? " said Chris- 
 tine. 
 
 118 
 
Well, heaven itself can't save a fool," said Mrs. Almar 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " I do." 
 
 Christine held out her hand with the gesture 
 of a queen. " And I very gratefully accept your 
 generous offer," she said. 
 
 " Well, heaven itself can't save a fool," said 
 Mrs. Almar, and she went out of the room, and 
 slammed the door after her. 
 
 As she went, Riatt actually flung the hand of 
 his newly affianced wife from him. " May I 
 ask," he said, " what you think you are doing? " 
 
 Christine had covered her face with her hands, 
 and had sunk into a chair. For an instant Riatt 
 really thought that the strain of the situation had 
 been too much for her; but on closer inspection 
 he found that she was shaking with laughter. 
 
 " I can't be sure which was funnier," she 
 gasped, " your face or Nancy's." 
 
 Riatt did not seem to feel mirthful. " Do you 
 take in," he asked her sternly, " that you have 
 just broken your word." 
 
 " I Ve just plighted it, have n't I? " 
 
 " You promised to refuse me." 
 
 She sprang up. " I did not. I never said a 
 word like it. If a stenographer had been here, 
 
 121 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 the record would bear me out. You inferred it, 
 I dare say. Besides, what could I do? Even 
 Nancy herself told us no one would believe us 
 unless I accepted you at least for a time." 
 
 "For what time?" 
 
 " Oh, don't let us cross bridges until we get 
 to them. We are hardly engaged yet Max! 
 I must practise calling you Max, mustn't I?" 
 In attempting to repress an irrepressible smile she 
 developed an unknown dimple in her left cheek. 
 The sight of it made his tone particularly relent- 
 less as he answered : 
 
 " If by the fifteenth of this month you have 
 not broken this engagement, 1 11 announce its 
 termination myself." 
 
 " And you," she went on, as if he had not 
 spoken, " must get into the habit of calling me 
 Christine." 
 
 " Listen to me," he said, and he took her by 
 the shoulders with a gesture that no one could 
 have mistaken for a caress. " I do not intend to 
 marry you." 
 
 " I see you feel no doubt of my wishes in the 
 
 matter." 
 
 122 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " I wonder where I got the idea." 
 
 " Be reassured," she said, finding herself 
 released. " My intentions are honorable. I 
 would not marry any really nice man absolutely 
 against his will. Although I did say to myself 
 the very first time I saw you, coming downstairs 
 in that well-cut coat of yours or is it the shoul- 
 ders ? I did say : * I could be happy with that 
 man, happier, that is, than with Ned.' You may 
 think it is n't much of a compliment, but Ned has 
 a very nice disposition, nicer than yours." 
 
 " And I should say it was the first requisite 
 for your husband." 
 
 She became suddenly plaintive. " Of course I 
 can see," she said, " why any one should n't want 
 to be married, but I can't see why you object to 
 being engaged to me for a few weeks." 
 
 " How can I be sure you will keep your 
 word?" 
 
 " I '11 give it to you in writing," she returned. 
 "Write: This is to certify that I, Christine 
 Fenimer, have enveigled the innocent and unsus- 
 pecting youth " 
 
 " I won't," said Riatt. 
 123 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " I will then," she answered, and sitting down 
 she wrote : 
 
 ; ' This is to certify that I, Christine Fenimer, 
 have speciously, feloniously and dishonorably in- 
 duced Mr. Max Riatt to make me an offer of 
 marriage, which I knew at the time he had no 
 wish to fulfil, and I hereby solemnly vow and 
 swear to release him from same on or before the 
 first day of March of this year of grace. 
 (Signed) CHRISTINE FENIMER." 
 
 " There," she said, " put that in your pocket- 
 book, and for goodness' sake don't let your pocket 
 be picked between now and the first of March." 
 
 He took it and put it very carefully away, ob- 
 serving as he did so : " It 's a long time to the 
 first of March." 
 
 " It may n't seem as long as you think." 
 
 " Are you by any chance supposing," he asked 
 with a directness he had learnt from her own 
 methods, " that by that time I may have fallen 
 in love with you? " 
 
 She did not hesitate at all. " Well, I think it 
 is a possibility." 
 
 " Oh, anything 's possible, but I can tell you 
 124 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 this: Even if I were in love with you, you are 
 not the type of woman I should ever dream of 
 marrying." 
 
 " What would you do?" 
 
 " If I saw the slightest chance of falling in love 
 with you which I don't I should try all the 
 harder to free myself." 
 
 " I don't see how you could try any harder than 
 you have. You begin to make me suspicious." 
 
 " Miss Fenimer " 
 
 " Christine, please." 
 
 " Christine, I am not the least bit in love with 
 you." 
 
 " Quite sure that you 're not whistling to keep 
 your courage up? " 
 
 " Quite sure." 
 
 " Well," she said, " just to show my fair spirit, 
 I '11 tell you that I entirely believe you. Shall I 
 add it to the contract: And I credit his repeated 
 assertion that he is not and never will be in the 
 least in love with me? No, I think I '11 omit the 
 * and never will be ' clause." 
 
 " And may I ask one other question," he con- 
 tinued, ignoring her last suggestion. " What did 
 
 125 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 you mean when you told me that you had decided 
 to marry Hickson? " 
 
 "So I have. Don't you see? He and I are 
 really engaged, but he does n't know it. You and 
 I are not really engaged, and you do know it." 
 
 " I wish I did," he returned gloomily. 
 
 " Oh, yes," she said, " you know it and I know 
 it, but the dog that's Nancy she doesn't 
 know it." 
 
 He seemed unimpressed by the humor of the 
 situation. He walked away and put his hand on 
 the knob. 
 
 " One thing more," he said. " I would like 
 to be sure that you understand this. The weap- 
 ons are all in my hands. The only strength of 
 your position lies in my good nature and willing- 
 ness to keep up appearances. Neither one is a 
 rock of defense. I 'm not, as you said yourself, 
 good-tempered, and I care very little for appear- 
 ances. The risk you run, if you don't play abso- 
 lutely fair, is of being publicly jilted." 
 
 " And I should hate that," she answered can- 
 didly. 
 
 " I 'm sure you would," he answered. " And 
 126 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 I don't particularly enjoy threatening you with 
 such a possibility." 
 
 " Really," said she. " Now I rather like you 
 when you talk like that." 
 
 " Fortunate that you do," he returned, " for 
 you will probably hear a good deal of it." 
 
 She nodded with perfect acquiescence. " And 
 now," she said, " if you have no more hateful 
 things to say, let 's go and tell our friends of the 
 great happiness that has come into our lives." 
 
 127 
 
CHAPTER IV 
 
 AS they went down the stairs those same 
 stairs on which only two evenings before 
 they had first met toward the drawing-room 
 where their great announcement was to be made, 
 Riatt stopped Christine in her triumphal progress. 
 'You're not going to have the supreme cru- 
 elty," he said, " to let poor Hickson think that 
 our engagement is a genuine one? " 
 
 Christine paused. " I wonder," she answered 
 thoughtfully, " which in the end would deceive 
 him most to make him think it was real or 
 fake?" 
 
 " You blood-curdling woman," said Riatt. " I 
 am not engaged to you." 
 
 " Oh, yes, you are until March first." 
 " I am pretending to be until March first." 
 She leant against the banisters, and regarded 
 him critically. " Is n't it strange," she remarked, 
 " that you dislike so much the idea of my trying 
 
 128 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 to make you care for me ? Some men would be 
 crazy about the process." 
 
 " Oh, if I enjoyed the process, I should regard 
 myself as lost." 
 
 She shook her head. " I 'm not sure that this 
 terror is n't a more significant confession of weak- 
 ness. Who is it is most afraid of high places? 
 Those who feel a desire to jump off." 
 
 " I 'm not afraid," he returned crossly. " I 
 just don't like it. I don't want to be made love 
 to. That 's one of the mistakes women are al- 
 ways making. They think all men want to be 
 made love to by any woman. We don't." 
 
 Christine sighed gently. " You 're getting dis- 
 agreeable again," she said with the softest re- 
 proach in her tone. " Let 's go on." 
 
 " You have n't answered my question," he said. 
 " Are you going to tell Hickson the truth? " 
 
 " How can I? If I told him, Nancy would 
 know at once, and the whole aim of this plot 
 is to deceive Nancy. However," she added 
 brightly, " I shall do what I can to alleviate his 
 sufferings. I shall tell him that I am not in the 
 least in love with you, that you have never s<? 
 
 129 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 much as kissed me, and that my present intention 
 is that you never shall.'* 
 
 " And you may add that my intention is the 
 same," replied Riatt with some sternness. 
 
 Christine smiled. * There 's no use in telling 
 him that," she answered, " for he would n't be- 
 lieve it." 
 
 " Upon my word," said he, " I think you 're 
 the vainest woman I ever met." 
 
 " Candid, merely," she returned, as she opened 
 the door of the drawing-room. The scene that 
 greeted them was eminently suited to their pur- 
 pose. Laura and Ussher were standing at the 
 table watching the last bitter moments of the 
 game between Nancy and the unfortunate Wick- 
 ham. Hickson was not there. 
 
 " Oh, Laura," said Christine, " could I have 
 just a word with you?" 
 
 Mrs. Ussher looked up startled. She had been 
 deeply depressed by her unsuccessful conversation 
 with her cousin. He had seemed to her abso- 
 lutely immovable, but there was no mistaking the 
 significant bride-like modulations of Christine's 
 voice. 
 
 130 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " With me?" she said, and in her eagerness 
 she was already at the door, before Christine 
 stopped her. 
 
 " Really," she said, " I don't know why only 
 with you. I know you are all enough my friends 
 to be interested even Mr. Wickham. Max 
 and I wanted to tell you that we are engaged. 
 Only, of course, it 's a secret" 
 
 Riatt had resolved that he would not look at 
 Mrs. Almar, and he did n't. She was adding up 
 the score, and her arithmetic did not fail her. 
 " And that makes 387, Mr. Wickham," she said, 
 and then she looked up with her bright, piercing 
 eyes, in time to see Laura fling herself enthusi- 
 astically into Riatt's arms. She got up with a 
 shrewd smile. " Let me congratulate you, too, 
 Mr. Riatt," she said. " I always like to see peo- 
 ple get what they deserve." 
 
 " Oh, Nancy, I 'm sure you think I 'm getting 
 far more than I deserve," said Christine. 
 
 " You have n't actually got it yet, darling," re- 
 turned Mrs. Almar. 
 
 " That sounds almost like a threat, my dear." 
 
 " More in the line of a prophecy." 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 At this moment the footman created a diver- 
 sion by announcing that the sleigh was waiting to 
 take Mr. Riatt to the train, and Riatt explained 
 that he had decided not to take the train that 
 day. Then Christine, on inquiring, found that 
 Hickson was writing letters in the library, and 
 went away to talk to him. She had no fear of 
 leaving Max; she knew he was in safe hands; 
 Laura would not allow Nancy an instant alone 
 with him. Nor, as a matter of fact, was Riatt 
 himself eager to subject himself to the cross-ex- 
 amination of that keen and contemptuous intel- 
 ligence. Indeed Nancy soon drifted out of the 
 room, and Riatt found himself committed to a 
 long tete-a-tete with Laura on the subject of Chris- 
 tine's perfections, and his supposed deceitfulness 
 in pretending indifference. " Oh, you protested 
 too much, my dear Max," Laura insisted with the 
 most irritating exuberance. " I knew when you 
 began to say that she was the last woman in the 
 world you would fall in love with, that your hour 
 had come. No man ever lived who could resist 
 Christine when she chooses to make herself 
 agreeable." 
 
 132 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 Riatt felt he was looking rather grim for an 
 accepted lover, as he answered that it was a great 
 comfort to feel one had succumbed only to the 
 irresistible. Before very long Christine came 
 back, and taking in what had been going on, man- 
 aged to get rid of her friend. Laura made it 
 plain that she was only too glad to accord the 
 lovers a few blissful moments alone. 
 
 " I can't describe to you," he said crossly, 
 " how intensely disagreeable I find the situation." 
 
 Christine laughed. " And did you look like 
 that while Laura was detailing my perfections? 
 A judge about to pronounce the death sentence is 
 gay in comparison. Cheer up. I have n't had a 
 pleasant fifteen minutes myself. I never thought 
 myself kind-hearted, but I assure you I really 
 longed to tell Ned the truth. He is the nicest 
 person." 
 
 " I believe he will make you an excellent hus- 
 band." 
 
 " Oh, dear, I 'm afraid he will." She sighed. 
 " Safety first will be a dull motto to go through 
 life with. Do you want to know what I told 
 him? No? Well, I'm going to tell you any- 
 
 133 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 how. I said that you had made me this magnifi- 
 cent offer, prompted, I felt sure, by the purest 
 chivalry; and that I felt I owed it to my family, 
 my friends and my reputation to accept it, but that 
 you had left my heart untouched, and that if he 
 and you were both penniless, I should prefer him 
 to you. That was n't all perfectly true." 
 
 Suddenly Riatt found himself smiling. " My 
 innocent child," he said, " let me make one thing 
 clear to you. Any effort on your part to create 
 an impression that you have fallen in love with 
 me will not be crowned with success." 
 
 Christine was quite unabashed by his direct- 
 ness. 
 
 " I 'm not a bit in love with you," she said - 
 " not any more than you are with me, only I 
 realize that there is a possibility for either of us, 
 and of the two," she added maliciously, " I really 
 think I 'm the more hard-hearted." 
 
 " Perhaps you will think I am running away 
 from danger," he answered, " when I tell you 
 that as soon as I have seen your father, got your 
 ring, and fulfilled the immediate necessities of the 
 occasion, I shall go home." 
 
 134 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 "Oh, you can't do that!" cried Christine, in 
 genuine alarm. 
 
 " You surely don't expect me to neglect my 
 legitimate business on account of this ridiculous 
 farce." 
 
 For the first time a certain amount of real hos- 
 tility crept in their relation. They looked at each 
 other steadily. Then Christine said politely: 
 " Well, we '11 see how things go." He knew, 
 however, that she was as determined that he 
 should stay as he was to leave, and the knowledge 
 made him all the firmer. 
 
 The evening was a stupid one, devoted largely 
 to toasts, jokes, congratulations and a few stabs 
 from Nancy. Through it all poor Hickson's 
 gloom was obvious. 
 
 The next day the party broke up. Wickham 
 and Hickson taking an early express; the others, 
 even Nancy who abandoned her motor on account 
 of the snow, going in by a noonday train. Al- 
 ready, it seemed to Riatt that the bonds of matri- 
 mony were closing about him as he found himself 
 delegated to look up Christine's trunks, maid and 
 dressing-case. 
 
 135 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 Soon after the arrival of the train he had an 
 appointment, made by telephone, with Mr. Feni- 
 mer. The interview was to take place at Mr. 
 Fenimer's club, a most discreet and elegant organ- 
 ization of fashionable virility. Riatt was not 
 kept waiting. Fenimer came promptly to meet 
 him. 
 
 He was a man of fifty, well made, and su- 
 premely well dressed. He was tanned as befits 
 a sportsman; on his face the absence of furrows 
 created by the absence of thought was made up 
 for by the fine wrinkles induced by poignant and 
 continued anxiety about his material comforts. 
 In his figure the vigor of the athlete contended 
 with the comfortable stoutness of the epicure. 
 He had left a discussion in which all his highest 
 faculties had been roused, a discussion on the re- 
 plenishing of the club's cellar, and had come to 
 speak to his future son-in-law, with satisfaction 
 but without vital interest. His manner was a per- 
 fect blending of reserve and cordiality. 
 
 " You will hardly expect a definite answer from 
 me to-day, Mr. Riatt," he said. " You under- 
 stand, I am sure, that knowing so little of you 
 
 136 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 an only child, my daughter" He waved his 
 hand, not manicured but most beautifully cared 
 for. Riatt noticed that in spite of these chilling 
 sentences, Fenimer was soon composing a para- 
 graph for the press, and advocating the setting 
 of the date for the wedding early in April, as he 
 himself was booked for a fishing-trip later. He 
 did this under the assumption that he was yield- 
 ing to Riatt' s irresistible eagerness. " You have 
 an excellent advocate in Christine. My daughter 
 has always ruled me. And now in my old age 
 I am to lose her. I had a long letter from her 
 by the early mail, speaking of you in the highest 
 terms." He smiled. Riatt rose, and allowed 
 him to return to the question of the club's wines. 
 
 Something about this interview was more shock- 
 ing to him than the cynicism of Nancy and Chris- 
 tine; Fenimer's suave eagerness to hand his daugh- 
 ter over to a total stranger, did not amuse him as 
 the women's light talk had done. He felt sorry 
 for Christine and a little disgusted. He wondered 
 what that letter had really said. Was Fenimer a 
 conspirator, too, or only a willing dupe ? 
 
 From the club he went to the jeweler's and 
 
 137 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 selected the most conspicuous diamond he could 
 find. Her friends should not miss the fact that 
 she was engaged if a solitaire could prove it to 
 them. He ordered it sent to her, much to the 
 surprise of the clerk, who pointed out that it was 
 usual to present such things in person. 
 
 After this he went to his hotel and found a pile 
 of letters had accumulated in his absence. 
 
 The first he opened was in a round childish 
 hand with uncertain margins, and a final " e " on 
 the word Hotel. 
 
 " Dear Cousin Max," it said, " I do not know 
 you, but Mamma says that you are going to marry 
 Christine. I think you are very lucky, and am 
 glad you are bringing her into our family. Victor 
 and I love her. She comes to the nursery some- 
 times, but never stays long. 
 
 " Your loving cousin, 
 
 " MURIEL USSHER." 
 
 Riatt laughed as he laid it down. " I bet she 
 does n't stay long," he said. " How she does skim 
 the cream! " And then with an exclamation of 
 surprise he tore open another envelope which had 
 been left by hand. It said: 
 
 138 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 "Dear Max: 
 
 " I hope you will be pleasantly surprised to find 
 that Mother and I are staying in this hotel. I find 
 New York more wonderful but more unfriendly 
 than I had been told, and I want terribly to see a 
 familiar face. Won't you look us up as soon as 
 you can? 
 
 " Yours as ever, 
 
 " DOROTHY." 
 
 He went to the telephone, found that she was 
 in and immediately arranged that she should go 
 out to lunch with him. 
 
 All the morning and some of the night, he had 
 been engaged in the composition of a letter to 
 Dorothy Lane. Theirs was an old and senti- 
 mental friendship, which adverse circumstances 
 might have ended, or favoring circumstances have 
 changed into love. As things were, it seemed to 
 be tending toward their marriage without any 
 whirlwind rapidity. 
 
 There was no doubt he was very glad to see 
 her, as he hurried her into a taxicab, and told the 
 man to drive to the restaurant of the hour. She 
 was very neatly and nicely dressed in a tailor-made 
 
 139 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 costume for which she had just paid twice as much 
 as a native New York woman would have paid. 
 In fact she was an essentially neat and nice little 
 person. They talked both at once like two chil- 
 dren about all the people at home, until they were 
 actually seated at table, and lunch was ordered. 
 Then Riatt made up his mind he must take the 
 plunge. 
 
 " Dolly," he said, " do I look as if something 
 tremendous had just happened? " 
 
 " Don't tell me you Ve invented a submarine, or 
 something? " 
 
 " No, this is something of a more personal na- 
 ture." 
 
 " Oh, Max, you Ve fallen in love? " 
 
 A waiter rushing up with rolls and butter sug- 
 gested that Madame probably preferred fresh but- 
 ter to salted, before Riatt answered: " No, that 
 is just what I have n't done and that 's the 
 secret, Dolly. I 'm not a bit in love, but I am 
 engaged to be married." 
 
 "Max! But why if" 
 
 " I '11 tell you on the second of March. It 's 
 a good story. You '11 enjoy it, but for the present, 
 
 140 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 my dear, you must just accept the fact that I am 
 engaged, that I am neither wildly elated nor un- 
 duly depressed." 
 
 Miss Lane had grown extremely serious. 
 "Who is she?" she asked. 
 
 " Her name is Christine Fenimer." 
 " I Ve seen her name in the papers." 
 " Who has not? " he returned bitterly. 
 " What is she like?" 
 
 Riatt felt some temptation to answer truthfully 
 and say: " She is designing, mercenary, hard- 
 hearted and as beautiful as a goddess." But he 
 did not, and, as he paused he saw the head waiter 
 spring forward from the doorway, smiling and 
 holding up a pencil to attract the attention of some 
 underling, and then he saw that Christine, Hick- 
 son and Mr. and Mrs. Linburne were being ush- 
 ered in. Christine approached, tall, beautiful, 
 conspicuous, and as divinely unconscious of it as 
 Adam and Eve of their nakedness; she moved 
 between the tables, bowing here and there to peo- 
 ple she knew, not purposely ignoring all others, 
 but seeming to find them invisible as thin air. 
 Riatt watched as if she were some great spectacle, 
 
 141 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 and was recalled only by hearing Dorothy's voice 
 saying : 
 
 " What a lovely creature ! " 
 
 " That is Miss Fenimer." 
 
 A sudden and deep flush spread over Miss 
 Lane's face. 
 
 " And you have been telling me of your indif- 
 ference to her?" she asked bitterly. " How 
 could any man be indifferent! " 
 
 " Good Heavens," cried Riatt fiercely. " All 
 you women are alike ! Beauty is n't the only 
 thing in the world for a man to love. There 
 are such things as truth and honor " 
 
 " Yes, and old friendship, too," said Miss Lane, 
 u but they don't always amount to much." 
 
 c That is an unnecessary, unkind thing to say," 
 he answered. " My friendship for you means a 
 good deal more to me than my engagement to 
 her." 
 
 " Max, I don't need to be consoled or soothed 
 about your engagement," said Miss Lane with 
 a good deal of spirit. " As far as I am concerned 
 you are quite free not only to become engaged, 
 but to have any feeling you like for the lady you 
 
 142 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 have chosen. I 'm sure I congratulate you very 
 heartily." 
 
 " You mean you don't believe a word of what 
 I have been trying to tell you." 
 
 " Oh, yes, I do. I believe you are en- 
 gaged." 
 
 Perhaps it was as well that at this instant, Chris- 
 tine's eyes fell upon her; she stared, then laughed, 
 and pointed him out to Hickson, who glanced at 
 him coldly; he was evidently thinking that he 
 would not have taken another girl out to lunch 
 the very day his engagement was announced. 
 
 " I suppose I had better go and speak to them," 
 Max said. 
 
 " I should think so," replied Dorothy tonelessly. 
 "Who are the others?" 
 
 Riatt, not sorry for a moment's respite, entered 
 into a detailed account of Lee Linburne. He was 
 the third generation of a great fortune, augment- 
 ing rather than decreasing with years. He was 
 but little over thirty and had taken the whole field 
 of amusement and sports as his own. He played 
 polo, had a racing stable and a racing yacht, had 
 gone in recently for flying (hence Riatt's connec- 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 tion with him), occasionally financed a theatrical 
 show, and now and then attended a directors' 
 meeting of some of his grandfather's companies. 
 The result was that his name was as widely known 
 through the country as Abraham Lincoln's. Dor- 
 othy knew as soon as she heard his name, that he 
 had married a girl from Pittsburg, and had gone 
 through her native city in a private car on his 
 honeymoon three years before, and had stopped, 
 she rather thought, and had lunch with the Gov- 
 ernor of the State. 
 
 On Hickson, Max touched more briefly. 
 
 When at last he did cross the room, Christine 
 received him with the utmost cordiality. 
 
 ;i What luck to run across you, though of course 
 this is the only place in New York where one can 
 get food that does n't actually poison one. Last 
 week do you remember, Lee ? We dined 
 somewhere or other with the Petermans and noth- 
 ing from the beginning of dinner to the end was 
 fit to eat. But, bless them, they did not know. 
 Have you met Mrs. Linburne? Oh, she knows 
 all about us. In fact every one does, for I can't 
 resist wearing this." She moved her left hand 
 
 144 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 on which his diamond shone like a swollen star. 
 " How did you find my father? " 
 
 " Most amiable," answered Riatt rather poison- 
 ously, and regretted the poison when he saw the 
 Linburnes exchange an amused glance. Of course 
 every one knew that Mr. Fenimer would present 
 no obstacles. 
 
 "Who are you lunching with, Max? Is that 
 your little secretary?" 
 
 The tone, very civil and friendly, made Max 
 furious, as if any one that Christine did not know 
 was hardly worth inquiring about. 
 
 u No, it 's Miss Lane an old friend of mine. 
 I think I must have spoken to you about her." 
 
 " Oh, the perfect provider? Is that really 
 she ? " Christine craned her neck openly to stare 
 at her. " Why, she 's rather nice looking for 
 a good housekeeper, that is. You 're dining with 
 me to-night, are n't you? " 
 
 " No," answered Riatt, with a sudden inspi- 
 ration of ill-humor. " I 'm dining with Miss 
 Lane." 
 
 " Bring her, too I Won't she come? " 
 
 " I really can't say." 
 
 145 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " You can ask her.'* 
 
 " To your house? " 
 
 Christine always knew when she was really 
 beaten. She got up with a sigh. " Take me 
 over," she said to him, " and I '11 ask her myself." 
 And she added to the Linburnes : " Out-of-town 
 people are always so fussy about little things." 
 
 Riatt did not know if this slightly contemptuous 
 observation were meant to apply to him or to 
 Miss Lane; he hoped in his heart that Dorothy 
 would refuse the invitation. But he under-esti- 
 mated Christine's powers. No one could have 
 been more persuasive, more meltingly sweet, and 
 compellingly cordial than she was, and it was soon 
 arranged that he was to bring Dorothy to dine 
 that evening. 
 
 When it was over, and he was back again in 
 his own seat, he could see, by glancing at Chris- 
 tine that she was engaged in a long humorous ac- 
 count of the incident, for her own table; and he 
 could tell, even from that distance, when he was 
 supposed to be speaking, when Dorothy, and when 
 Christine was repeating her own words. Mean- 
 while Dorothy was saying: 
 
 146 
 

 It was arranged that he was to bring Dorothy to dine that evening 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " How charming and simple she is, Max. You 
 always hear of these people as being so artificial 
 and elaborate." 
 
 " Oh, they 're direct enough," returned Riatt 
 bitterly. 
 
 The bitterness was so apparent that Dorothy 
 could not ignore it. She looked up at him for 
 an instant and then she said seriously : " I be- 
 lieve I know what the trouble with you is, Max. 
 You can't believe that she loves you for yourself. 
 You 're haunted by the dread that what you have 
 has something to do with it. Is n't that it? " 
 
 Max now made use of the well-known counter 
 question as an escape from a tight place. 
 
 " And what is your judgment on that point, 
 Dolly?" 
 
 " She loves you," said Miss Lane, with con- 
 viction, and a moment afterward she sighed, 
 
 "Without disputing your opinion," returned 
 Riatt, " I should very much like to know on what 
 you base it." 
 
 " Oh, on a hundred things on her look, her 
 manner, her being so nice to me on woman's 
 intuition in fact." 
 
 149 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 Riatt thought to himself that he had never had 
 much confidence in the intuition theory and now 
 he had none. 
 
 They did not part at the termination of lunch. 
 It was almost a duty, Riatt considered, to show 
 a stranger a few of the sights. Miss Lane, who 
 was extremely well-informed on all questions of 
 art, suggested the Metropolitan Museum; and 
 after that they took a taxicab and drove along the 
 river and watched the winter sunset above the 
 palisades; and then they went and had tea at the 
 Plaza, and by the time they returned to Mrs. 
 Lane it was almost the hour for dressing for 
 dinner; and then Max sat gossiping with Mrs. 
 Lane, for whom he had always had the deepest 
 affection, until he knew he was going to be late. 
 
 They were late . a difficult thing to be in the 
 Fenimer household. The party, a small one, was 
 waiting when Miss Lane and Mr. Riatt were 
 ushered in. Nancy was there, and Hickson, and 
 Mr. Linburne without his wife this time; and 
 Mr. Fenimer himself, doing honor to his future 
 son-in-law by taking a meal at home. 
 
 Christine in a wonderful pink chiffon and lace 
 150 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 tea-gown came forward to greet Dorothy, rather 
 than Max, to whom she gave merely an under- 
 standing smile, while she held the girl's hand an 
 instant. 
 
 " Max says this is your first visit to New 
 York," she said, after she had introduced her 
 father and Nancy. " It is good of you to give 
 us an evening, when there are so many more amus- 
 ing things to do, but Max says we are as inter- 
 esting as Bushmen or Hottentots. I hope you '11 
 find us so." 
 
 The hope seemed unlikely to be fulfilled, for 
 while the presence of Mr. Fenimer, who was 
 rather a stickler for etiquette, prevented the per- 
 fect freedom that had reigned at the Usshers', 
 the talk turned on people whom Dorothy did not 
 know, and it was so quick and allusive that no out- 
 sider could have followed it. Hickson, soon ap- 
 preciating something in Miss Lane's situation not 
 utterly unlike his own, was touched by her obvious 
 isolation, and tried to make up for the neglect of 
 the others. Riatt, sitting between Nancy and 
 Christine, had little time left to him for observa- 
 tion of any one else. 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 When dinner was over Christine instantly drew 
 him away to her own little sitting-room, on pre- 
 tense of showing him some letter of congratula- 
 tion that she had received. But once there, she 
 shut the door, and standing before it, she said, 
 with an air of the deepest feeling: 
 
 " You 're in love with this girl." 
 
 Riatt, who had sunk comfortably down on a 
 sofa by the fire, looked up in surprise. 
 
 "And if I am?" he answered. 
 
 " You need not humiliate me by making it so 
 evident," she retorted, and almost stamped her 
 foot. " Lunching with her in public, and taking 
 her to tea, as I was told, getting here so late for 
 dinner- -I wish you could have heard the way 
 Nancy and Lee Linburne were goading me before 
 dinner about it." 
 
 " My dear Christine," said Max, and he was 
 amused to hear a tone of real conjugal remon- 
 strance in his voice, " you have lunched and dined 
 in one day with Hickson, and yet I don't feel I 
 have any grounds of complaint." 
 
 " Every one knows how little I care for Ned," 
 she answered, " but people say you do care for 
 
 152 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 this little Western mouse. I hate her. She 's 
 good and nice, and the kind of a girl men think 
 it wise to marry, and just as different from me 
 as she can be. I do hate her and I hate myself 
 too." And she covered her face with her hands. 
 
 " Come here, Christine," said Riatt, without 
 moving, and was rather surprised when she 
 obeyed. He made her sit down beside him, and 
 taking her hands from her face, was astonished 
 to find that she was really crying. 
 
 " Why, my dear child," he said, in the most 
 paternal manner he could manage. " What is 
 this all about?" And it was quite in the same 
 note that Christine wept a moment on his shoul- 
 der. Then she raised her head, with a return 
 of her old brisk manner. 
 
 " I 'm jealous," she said. " Oh, don't suppose 
 one can't be jealous of people one does n't care 
 for. I could be jealous of any one when Nancy 
 begins teasing me and making fun of me. And 
 I 'm jealous too, because I 'm sure she 's a nice 
 girl and I Ve made such a mess of my life, and 
 I deserve it all; but when you came in to- 
 gether, as if you had just been happily married, 
 
 153 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 and I looked at Ned and thought how wretched 
 I 'm always going to be with him, and what silly 
 things I shall undoubtedly do before I die " 
 
 " I hate to hear you talk like that." 
 
 " Why should you care ? She 'II never do silly 
 things that 's clear. Is that why you love 
 her?" 
 
 " As a matter of fact I am not in love with 
 Miss Lane." 
 
 " My dear Max, there 's really no reason why 
 you should deceive me about it." 
 
 " That 's just what she said about you." 
 
 " You mean " Christine sprang to her feet 
 and gazed at him like an outraged empress 
 " You mean that you told her that you did n't 
 love me? " 
 
 " I most assuredly did." 
 
 " Max, how could you be so low, so despicable, 
 so false?" 
 
 Riatt laughed. " Well, it certainly was not 
 false, Christine," he said. " It happens to be 
 true, you know; and I felt I owed a measure of 
 truth to a very old and very real friendship. I 
 
 154 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 told her nothing more than that I was engaged 
 and not madly in love." 
 
 Christine threw up her hands. " The game is 
 up," she said. " She '11 tell everybody, of 
 
 course." 
 
 " She '11 tell absolutely no one." 
 
 " Because she 's perfect, I suppose? " 
 
 " Because she did n't for one moment believe 
 
 me." 
 
 "Didn't believe we were engaged?" 
 
 " Did n't believe that any one could be engaged 
 to so beautiful and charming a person as you are 
 and not be in love with her." 
 
 Christine's manner softened slightly. " She 
 thinks me charming?" 
 
 " She thinks you irresistible, almost as irresisti- 
 ble as Laura thinks you ; and she is trying to find 
 out why I am so eager to deceive her in the 
 matter." 
 
 Christine clapped her hands, and executed a 
 few steps. " She 's jealous, too," she cried. 
 " The perfect woman is jealous. I never thought 
 of her suffering, too." 
 
 155 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " She is not jealous, but I suppose it may hurt 
 her feelings a little that I shouldn't " 
 
 " Oh, nonsense, Max, she loves you. Do you 
 think I could be deceived on such a subject? She 
 watches you all the time. She loves you. And 
 I think it would be very impertinent of her not 
 to. I should think very poorly of her if she 
 didn't. Imagine what she must be undergoing 
 at this moment, by our prolonged absence." 
 
 " Perhaps, we 'd better be going back," said 
 Riatt calmly. 
 
 Christine barred the door, spreading out both 
 her arms. 
 
 " She thinks you 're making love to me, Max." 
 
 " And yet, Christine, I 'm not." 
 
 " But she does n't know that; she does n't know* 
 what an immovable iceberg you are." 
 
 " No, indeed she does n't" 
 
 Christine's manner again changed utterly. All 
 the playfulness disappeared. " You mean," she 
 said, " that you 're not cold and immovable with 
 her?" 
 
 " What 's the use of my telling you anything, 
 if you don't believe me?" The idea of teasing 
 
 156 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 Christine had never occurred to him before, but 
 he thought highly of it. She came toward him at 
 once. 
 
 " Oh, Max, my dear," she said, " don't be 
 horrid, when I 'm having such a wretched time 
 anyhow. Don't you think you might pretend to 
 care for me just a little? " 
 
 Riatt rose. " Yes, I do," he said, " and so I 
 shall, in public." 
 
 Christine was all the gentle, wistful child im- 
 mediately. 
 
 " Never when we 're alone? " she asked. 
 
 Max lit a cigarette briskly. " I don't suppose 
 we shall very often be alone," he returned. 
 "After all, why should we?" 
 
 She looked at him like a wounded bird: " No 
 reason if you don't want to." 
 
 At this moment the door opened and her father 
 came in. 
 
 " Come, come, my dear, this is no way to treat 
 your guests," he said. " I must really insist that 
 you go back to the drawing-room. Upon my 
 word, Riatt, you ought not to keep her like 
 this." 
 
 157 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " It was a great temptation to have her a few 
 minutes to myself, Mr. Fenimer," said Max, and 
 Christine grinned gratefully at him behind her 
 father's back. 
 
 " Very likely, very likely," said Mr. Fenimer 
 crossly, " but I want to go to the club, and how 
 can I, unless she goes back? You can't think 
 only of yourself, my dear fellow." 
 
 Riatt admitted that this was true and he and 
 Christine went back to the drawing-room. 
 
 Very soon afterwards, he gave Dorothy a keen 
 prolonged look, which she did not misunderstand. 
 She got up at once and said good night. In the 
 taxicab, he questioned her at once as to her im- 
 pressions. 
 
 " I did n't like Mr. Linburne or Mrs. Almar 
 at all, Max. She kept asking me the greatest 
 number of questions about you and the story of 
 your life. What interest has she in you, I won- 
 der? " 
 
 " None,' 1 answered Riatt, but added rather 
 quickly, " And what did you think of Lin- 
 burne?" 
 
 " I could n't bear him, though I own he 's nice 
 
 158 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 looking. But he told Mrs. Almar a story I 
 could not help hearing I never heard such a 
 story in my life." 
 
 " I gather it did not shock Mrs. Almar." 
 
 " She knew it already. * Lee,' she said, * that 
 story is so old that even my husband knows it,' 
 and every one laughed." 
 
 " I 'm afraid you did not enjoy yourself." 
 
 " I like Mr. Hickson very much. And I 
 thought Miss Fenimer more beautiful than before. 
 He was telling me what a wonderful nature she 
 has. He said he had never seen her out of 
 temper." 
 
 " Yes, Hickson 's crazy about her," said Riatt 
 casually. 
 
 " Dear Max, why do you try to deceive your- 
 self about your own feeling for her?" 
 
 " Deceive myself," he said angrily. " If you 
 knew the truth, my dear Dolly!" His heart 
 stood still. Deceive himself! What an insult- 
 ing phrase. He repressed a strong impulse to 
 propose on the instant to Dolly. That would 
 show her how indifferent he was to Christine. 
 It would assure him, too. 
 
 159 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 Instead he formed a plan to go home with her 
 and her mother, when they went. 
 
 "When are you going back, Dolly?" 
 
 " The day after to-morrow." 
 
 "Any objections to my going, too?" 
 
 "Objections! Max, dear!" 
 
 He engaged his ticket at once at the hotel office. 
 Having done so, he felt tranquil and relieved, and 
 perhaps the least little bit dull. The clerk as- 
 sured him he was fortunate to be able to get a 
 berth at such short notice. " Very fortunate," 
 he agreed and was annoyed at a certain cold ring 
 in his voice. 
 
 The next day, true to his promise to show 
 Christine all attentions that the public could ex- 
 pect, he sent her a box of flowers, and at four 
 he stopped for her and they went and took a long 
 walk together, hoping to meet as many people 
 whom they knew as possible. 
 
 " We won't walk in the Park," said Christine. 
 " No one sees you there, though of course if they 
 do, it makes an impression. But, no ; we '11 stick 
 to Fifth Avenue, and study all the windows that 
 have clothes or furniture in them, as if our minds 
 
 1 60 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 were entirely taken up with trousseaux and house- 
 furnishing." 
 
 She was true to her word, and not squeamish. 
 Riatt found it rather amusing to wander at her 
 side, dressing her in imagination in every garment 
 that the windows so frankly displayed, and an- 
 swering with real interest her constant inquiry: 
 " Do you think that would become me? Would 
 you like me in that? Do you prefer silk to 
 batiste?" 
 
 They were standing in front of a stocking shop 
 in which on a row of composition legs which might 
 have made a chorus envious, " new ideas in 
 hosiery " were romantically displayed, when Riatt 
 decided to tell her of his approaching departure. 
 He chose the street, because he was well aware 
 that she would not approve of his plan, and he 
 wished to avoid a repetition of last evening's 
 scene. 
 
 " I shall have to go away the day after to-mor- 
 row," he said, and glanced quickly down on her 
 to see how she would take it. 
 
 She was studying the stockings, and she drew 
 away with her head at a critical angle. 
 
 161 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " It 's a queer thing," she said, " that certain 
 stripes do make the ankle look large. Theoreti- 
 cally they ought to make it look slim, but you 
 take my word for it, Max, they don't." 
 
 " Nothing could make your ankles look any- 
 thing but slim, Christine," he replied politely. 
 
 " No, my ankles are rather good, are n't they? " 
 she replied, and then as if she had now disposed 
 of the more serious topic, she added : " And so 
 you are going home ? Well, you may n't believe 
 it, but I shall really miss you a great deal. Oh, 
 look at these jade flowers! They're really 
 good." 
 
 Riatt looked at the pale lilac and pink blossoms 
 starting from their icy green leaves, but he hardly 
 saw them. He was disgusted at the discovery 
 of an unexpected perversity in his nature. He 
 found himself hardly pleased at the absence of 
 protest with which his announcement was greeted. 
 All her attention was absorbed by the jade. 
 
 " Would n't it look well on our drawing-room 
 mantel-piece? " she said. 
 
 " I '11 give it to you as a wedding present," he 
 162 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 answered. " That is, if you think Hickson would 
 like it." 
 
 " I don't think he '11 like anything you ever 
 give me. He did not even like my ring. He 
 thinks the stone too large. By the way, I never 
 properly thanked you for the ring. It has been 
 most splendidly persuasive. Even Nancy grew 
 pale when she saw the proof of your sin- 
 cerity." 
 
 " Will it be sufficient even in the face of my 
 continued absence?" he asked, for it occurred to 
 him that perhaps she had not understood that he 
 meant to remain in the West indefinitely. 
 
 " Oh, I think so," she answered, pleasantly. 
 " You might write to me now and then, and I '11 
 show just a suitable paragraph here and there to 
 an intimate friend." 
 
 A new idea suddenly occurred to him. Had 
 she any motive for desiring his absence? Had 
 some unexpected possibility cropped up? Did 
 she want to get rid of him? Not, he added, that 
 he minded if she did, but it would be rather inter- 
 esting to know. 
 
 163 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " I 'm going a little earlier than I expected," 
 he went on, " because the Lanes are going, and 
 I hate to make that long journey alone." 
 
 She nodded understandingly. " It will be much 
 nicer for you to have them." 
 
 He looked at her coldly. It seemed to him 
 he had never known a more callous nature. And 
 to think that the evening before she had actually 
 shed tears, simply because he took another girl 
 to lunch! It caught his attention, he said to him- 
 self, just as a study in human nature. 
 
 He did not see her the next day until evening. 
 They were both to dine at Nancy's (thus had 
 the proposed dinner with Mrs. Almar deterio- 
 rated) and go afterward to the opera. Nancy 
 of course would not have dreamed of crowding 
 three women into her box, so the party consisted 
 of herself and Christine, Riatt, Roland Almar 
 a pale, eager, little man, trying to placate the 
 world with smiles, and once again Linburne, whose 
 handsome dark head, and curved mouth, half 
 cynical, half sensuous, began to weary Riatt inex- 
 pressibly. 
 
 After dinner he found that he and Mrs. Almar 
 164 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 were to go in her tiny coupe, and the four others 
 in Linburne's large car. 
 
 " And so," she observed as soon as they started, 
 " the mouse preferred the trap after all? " And 
 he could feel that she was laughing at him in the 
 shadow. 
 
 " But feels none the less grateful for the kind 
 intention to rescue him." 
 
 " Oh, I don't care much for the gratitude of a 
 man in love with another woman." 
 
 " You judge me to be very much in love? " 
 
 This general conviction on the part of the ladies 
 of his acquaintance was growing monotonous. 
 Nancy continued: 
 
 " But come back in two years, and we '11 talk 
 of gratitude then. In the meantime let us stick 
 to the impersonal. What do you think of Lin- 
 burne?" 
 
 " I Ve had many opportunities of judging. 
 I Ve been nowhere for two days without meeting 
 him." 
 
 Mrs. Almar laughed with meaning. 
 
 " I wonder why that should be," she said. 
 
 "What do you mean?" Riatt asked, but at 
 
 165 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 that moment they drew up before the Thirty- 
 ninth Street entrance, and the doorman, opening 
 the motor's door, shouted " Ten Forty-five " 
 
 a cheerful lie he has been telling four times 
 a week for many years. 
 
 In the opera box, Riatt at once seated himself 
 behind Christine. There is no place like the 
 opera for public devotion. Christine was re- 
 splendent in black and gold with a huge black and 
 gold fan that made the fans of the temple dancers 
 
 the opera was " Ai'da " look commonplace 
 and ineffective. 
 
 Behind it she now murmured to Max: 
 
 " And what poisonous thing did dear Nancy 
 
 tell you coming down? " 
 
 " Nothing except what everyone has been 
 
 telling me for the last few days that I seemed 
 
 very much in love." 
 
 " And that annoyed you, I suppose. " 
 
 " On the contrary. I was delighted to find I 
 
 was such a good actor." 
 
 " People who pretend to be asleep sometimes 
 
 end by actually doing it. Pretending is rather 
 
 dangerous sometimes.'* 
 
 166 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Yes, but you see I sha'n't have to pretend 
 after to-morrow." 
 
 " Are you all packed and ready? " 
 
 " Mentally I am." 
 
 In the entr'acte which followed quickly after 
 their entrance, Christine dismissed him very po- 
 litely. " There," she said, " you don't have to 
 stay on duty all the time. You can go and stretch 
 your legs, if you want." 
 
 He rose at once, and as he did so, Linburne 
 slipped into his place. 
 
 Riatt had caught sight of Laura Ussher across 
 the house, and knew his duty demanded that he 
 should go and say a word to his exuberant cousin 
 who, he supposed, regarded herself as the artificer 
 of his happiness. 
 
 " Oh, my dear Max," she began, hastily bun- 
 dling out an old friend who had been reminiscing 
 about the days of the de Rezskes, and waving 
 Riatt into place, " every one is so delighted at the 
 engagement, and thinks you both so fortunate. 
 How happy she is, Max! She looks like a dif- 
 ferent perstfn," 
 
 " I thought she looked rather tired this eve- 
 167 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 ning," answered Riatt, who always found himself 
 perverse in face of Laura's enthusiasm. 
 
 Mrs. Ussher raised her opera glass and studied 
 Christine's profile, bent slightly toward Linburne, 
 who was talking with the immobility of feature 
 which many people use when saying things in pub- 
 lic which they don't wish overheard. " Oh, well, 
 she does n't look as brilliant as she did when you 
 were with her. But isn't that natural? I won- 
 der why Nancy asked Lee Linburne and where is 
 that silly little wife of his. Oh, don't go, Max. 
 It 's only the St. Anna attache ; we met him on the 
 coast last summer." 
 
 But Riatt insisted on making way for the South 
 American diplomat, who was standing courteously 
 in the back of the box. 
 
 He wandered out into the corridors, not enough 
 interested in any of his recent acquaintances to 
 go and speak to them. Two men coming up 
 behind him were talking; he could not help hear- 
 ing their dialogue: 
 
 " Who 's this fellow she 's engaged to? " 
 
 " No one knows a Western chap with a lot 
 of money." 
 
 168 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 "Suppose she cares anything about him?" 
 
 " Oh, no, she 's telling every one she does n't. 
 They say he 's mad about her." 
 
 " Ought to be, by Jove. I always thought the 
 only man she ever cared for " 
 
 Riatt found himself straining his ears vainly 
 to catch the name, but it was drowned in other 
 conversations that rose about him. He under- 
 stood now why Christine had been angry at his 
 telling Dorothy that he was not in love, for he 
 found himself annoyed at the idea of her having 
 told everybody that she was n't. But, it 's a dif- 
 ferent thing, he thought, to tell one intimate friend 
 in confidence, or to give the news to every Tom, 
 Dick and Harry. Then the juster side of his 
 nature reasserted itself, and he saw that she was 
 only laying the trail for the breaking of her en- 
 gagement. Yet this evidence of her good faith 
 did not entirely allay the irritation of his spirit. 
 
 When he went back to the box, Linburne was 
 gone, and the man who had replaced him, yielded 
 to Riatt with the most submissive promptness. 
 But this time no easy interchange occurred be- 
 tween them. 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 About half past ten, Christine leaned over to 
 her hostess, and said: 'Would you care at all 
 if I deserted you, dear? I 'm tired." 
 
 " Mind when I have my Roland to keep me 
 company?" said Nancy. "One seems to take 
 one's husband to the opera this year." 
 
 At this point Linburne, who had been standing 
 in the back of the box, came forward and said: 
 "Won't you take my car, Miss Fenimer? I'll 
 go down and find it for you." 
 
 A look that passed between them, a twinkle in 
 Nancy's eyes, suddenly convinced Riatt that the 
 scheme was for Linburne to take Christine home. 
 He did not stop to ask why this idea was repug- 
 nant to him, but he said firmly: 
 
 " I have a car of my own downstairs, and I '11 
 take Miss Fenimer home." It was of course a 
 lie, as the simple taxicab was his only means of 
 vehicular locomotion, but a taxi, thank heaven, can 
 always be obtained quickly at the Metropolitan. 
 Christine consented. Linburne stepped back. 
 
 They drove the few blocks in silence. He went 
 up the steps of her house, and when the door was 
 opened he said: " May I come in for a few min- 
 
 170 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 utes? I sha'n't have time to-morrow probably." 
 
 " Do," said Christine. She went into the draw- 
 ing-room and sank into a chair. " Who ever 
 heard of not saying good-by to one's fiancee? " 
 
 He saw that she was in her most teasing mood, 
 and somehow this made him more serious. 
 
 " Perhaps," he said rather stiffly, " you think 
 I carry out your instructions too exactly. Per- 
 haps I show a more scrupulous devotion in public 
 than you meant." 
 
 " Oh, no. It looked so well." 
 
 " It would not have looked so well for Lin- 
 burne to take you home." 
 
 She clapped her hands. " Excellent," she said, 
 " but you know it is not necessary to take that 
 proprietary tone when we are alone." 
 
 " Even as a mere acquaintance I might offer 
 you some advice," he said. 
 
 " I 'm rather sleepy as it is," she returned, 
 yawning slightly. 
 
 For the first time Riatt had a sense of crisis. 
 He knew he must either save her, or leave her. 
 He could not give her a little sage advice and 
 abandon her. It would be like advising a starv- 
 
 171 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 ing man not to steal and going away with your 
 pockets full. He could not say, " Have nothing 
 to do with a selfish materialist like Linburne," 
 when he knew better perhaps than any one how 
 empty of any ideality or hope her relation to 
 Hickson was bound to be. Yet on the other hand, 
 he could not say, " Come to me, instead." He 
 despised her method of life, distrusted her charac- 
 ter, disliked her ideas, and was under no illusion 
 as to her feeling for himself. If he had come to 
 her without money she would have laughed in 
 his face. What chance would either of them 
 have under such circumstances? It was simple 
 madness to consider it. And why was he consid- 
 ering it? Just because she looked lovely and wan, 
 sunk in a deep chair in all her black and gold 
 finery, just because her face had the lines of an 
 Italian saint and her voice had strange and mov- 
 ing tones in it. 
 
 " Good-by," he said briefly. 
 
 She sprang up. " Good gracious," she said, 
 " and are you going just like that? You know it 
 is customary to extract a promise to write. At 
 least to beg for a lock of the hair." (She drew 
 
 172 
 
He stood like a rock under her caress 
 

LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 out a golden lock, and let it crinkle back into place 
 again.) " Or do you think you will remember 
 me without it? " 
 
 " I 'm not so sure I want to remember you." 
 
 " I hope you don't. It 's the things you don't 
 want to remember that you never can get out of 
 your head." 
 
 " Good-by," he said again. 
 
 " Have n't you one nice thing to say to me 
 before you go?" 
 
 "Not one." 
 
 " Would n't you at least admit that I had en- 
 larged your point of view? " 
 
 " Are n't you going to shake hands with me? " 
 he said. 
 
 She shook her head, and began to approach 
 him. He felt afterward as if he had known ex- 
 actly what she meant to do, and yet he seemed to 
 lack all power to prevent her or perhaps it 
 was will that was lacking. She came up to him, 
 very deliberately put her arms about his neck, and, 
 almost as tall as he, laid her head on his shoulder; 
 and then murmured under his chin: " But you 
 must never, never come back." 
 
 175 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 He stood like a rock under her caress; he did 
 ngt make any answer ; he did not attempt to undo 
 the clasp of her arms. He was as impassive as 
 a hunted animal who, in some terrible danger, 
 pretends to be already dead. 
 
 It was a matter of only a few seconds. Then 
 she dropped her arms, and he went away. 
 
CHAPTER V 
 
 RUNNING away is seldom a becoming ges- 
 ture, yet it is one that should at least bring 
 relief; but as Riatt went westward, he was con- 
 scious of no relief whatsoever. The day was bit- 
 ter and gray, and, looking out of the window, 
 he felt that he was about as flat and dreary as 
 the country through which he was passing. 
 
 He sat a little while with the Lanes in their 
 compartment. 
 
 " I suppose you '11 be glad to get home and see 
 George and Louise and the children," said Mrs. 
 Lane, referring to some cousins of Riatt's about 
 whom, it is to be feared, he had not thought for 
 weeks. 
 
 Dorothy laughed. " What does he care for 
 home-staying cousins when he is leaving a lovely 
 creature languishing for him in New York? " she 
 said. 
 
 " I doubt if Christine does much languishing," 
 he returned, though the idea was not at all disa- 
 greeable to him. 
 
 177 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " You two are the strangest lovers I ever 
 knew," said Miss Lane. 
 
 Riatt wondered if that were an accurate de- 
 scription of them lovers, though strange ones. 
 
 He left his old friends presently and went and 
 sat in the observation-car. What, he wondered, 
 had Christine meant by her last words, about 
 never coming back? Never come back to annoy 
 with his critical attitude? Never come back to 
 watch her deterioration as Hickson's wife? Or 
 never come back to disturb her peace of mind and 
 heart by his mere presence? He debated all in- 
 terpretations but the last pleased him most. 
 
 A bride and groom were in the car. The girl 
 was not in the least like Christine. She was small 
 and wore a pair of the most fantastic gray and 
 black boots that Riatt had ever seen; but she was 
 very blond and very much in love. Riatt hated 
 both her and her husband. " People ought not to 
 be allowed to show their feelings like that," he 
 said to himself, as he kicked open the door leading 
 to the back platform, with a violence that was 
 utterly unnecessary. 
 
 Nor did things mend on his arrival at his home. 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 His native town was naturally interested in his 
 engagement; it showed this interest by keeping the 
 idea continually before him. It assumed, of 
 course, that he was going to bring his bride home. 
 The rising architect of the community came to 
 him with the assumption that he would wish to 
 build her a more suitable house than that of his 
 father, which, large and comfortable, had been 
 constructed in the very worst taste of the early 
 " eighties." No, Riatt found himself saying 
 with determination, his father's house would be 
 good enough for his wife. He thought the senti- 
 ment sounded rather well, as he pronounced it. 
 But this did not solve his difficulties, for now it 
 was but too evident that he must at least redeco- 
 rate the old house ; and he found himself, he never 
 knew exactly how, actually in process of doing 
 over a bedroom, bathroom and boudoir for Chris- 
 tine, just exactly as if he had expected her ever 
 to lay eyes on them. 
 
 Mrs. Lane came to him with the suggestion that 
 he would wish Christine to be one of the patron- 
 esses of the next winter's dances. The list was 
 about to be printed. Max hesitated. " It would 
 
 179 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 be a little premature to put her down as Mrs. 
 Riatt, wouldn't it?" he objected. Mrs. Lane 
 thought this was merely superstitious, and ordered 
 the cards so printed without consulting him fur- 
 ther. 
 
 Every one asked him what he heard from her, 
 so that he actually stooped once or twice to invent 
 sentences from imaginary letters of hers. He 
 even went so far as to read the society columns 
 of the New York newspapers, so that he might 
 not be caught in any absurd error about her where- 
 abouts. Such at least is the reason by which he 
 explained his conduct to himself. 
 
 He was shocked to find that he was restless and 
 dissatisfied. The only occupation that seemed to 
 give any relief was gambling; or, as a mine-owning 
 friend of his expressed it, in making " a less con- 
 servative and more remunerative investment of 
 his capital." He spent hours every day hanging 
 over the ticker in the office of Burney, Manders 
 and Company and this young and eager firm 
 of brokers made more money in commissions dur- 
 ing the first two weeks of his return than they had 
 during the whole year that preceded it. 
 
 180 
 
 
 

 LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 On the whole he lost, and Welsley, his mining 
 friend, seeing this began to urge on him more 
 and more the advisability of buying out the ma- 
 jority of stock in a certain Spanish-American gold 
 mine. At first he always made the same answer: 
 " You know as well as I do, Welsley, I would 
 never put a penny into any property I had not 
 inspected." 
 
 But gradually a desire to inspect it grew up in 
 his mind. What would suit his plans better than 
 a long trip, as soon as the breaking of his engage- 
 ment was announced? A week at sea, two or 
 three days on a river, and then sixty miles on mule- 
 back over the mountains there at least he would 
 not be troubled by accounts of Christine's wed- 
 ding, or assertions that she had looked brilliant 
 at the opera. 
 
 He had been at home about two weeks, when 
 her first letter came. So far the only scrap of her 
 handwriting that he possessed was the formal re- 
 lease that she had. given him the afternoon they 
 became engaged, and which, for safe keeping 
 doubtless, he always carried in his pocketbook, 
 and which he sometimes found himself reading 
 
 181 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 over * not as a proof that he could get out of 
 his engagement, but rather in an attempt to verify 
 the fact that he had ever got into it. 
 
 However unfamiliar with her writing, he had 
 not the least doubt about the letter from the first 
 instant that he saw it. No one else could use such 
 absurd faint blue and white paper and such large 
 square envelopes. As he took it up, he said to 
 himself that it had never occurred to him that 
 she would write, and yet he saw without any sense 
 of inconsistency that he had looked for this letter 
 in every mail. And yet, so perverse is the nature 
 of mankind, that he opened it, not with pleasure, 
 but with a sudden return of all his old terror of 
 being trapped. 
 
 " Dear Max," it said. " I have been pretend- 
 ing so often to write to you for the benefit of my 
 inquiring friends, that I think I may as well do 
 it as a tribute to truth. 
 
 "How foolish that was the night you went 
 away! One gets carried awa^y sometimes by the 
 drama of a situation, without any relation to the 
 facts, and the idea of parting forever from one's 
 fiance is rather dramatic, isn't it? I cried all 
 
 182 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 night, and rather enjoyed it. Then in the morn- 
 ing when I woke up, everything seemed to have 
 returned to the normal, and I could not under- 
 stand what had made me so silly. 
 
 " Don't suppose that because you have gone, 
 I am therefore freed from the disagreeable criti- 
 cism of which you made such a speciality. Ned 
 comes in almost every day to tell me that he does 
 not approve of my conduct. I am not behaving, 
 it appears, as an affianced bride should. Don't 
 you like to think of Ned so loyally protecting your 
 interests in your absence? His criticisms are, I 
 suppose, based on the attentions of a nice little 
 boy just out of college, who calls me ' Helen,' and 
 writes sonnets to me which are to appear in the 
 most literary of weeklies. Look out for them. 
 They are good, and may raise your low estimate 
 of my charms. The best one begins : 
 
 "When the blond wonder first on Paris dawned 
 
 "Isn't that pretty? 
 
 " Write to me. At least send me a blank en- 
 velope that I may leave ostentatiously on my desk. 
 " Yours at the moment, 
 
 " CHRISTINE/' 
 
 Riatt's first thought on laying down the letter 
 was; "Hickson never in the world objected to 
 
 183 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 any little poet just out of college, and she knows 
 it very well. It 's Linburne he is worried about 
 -. Linburne, whose name she does not even men- 
 tion." And how absurd to attempt to make him 
 believe she had cried all night. That was simply 
 an untruth. Yet oddly enough, it came before his 
 eyes in a more vivid picture than many a scene 
 he had actually witnessed. 
 
 A few minutes later he went to the club and 
 looked up the literary weekly of which she had 
 spoken. There was no sonnet in it, but the issue 
 of the next week contained it. Riatt read it with 
 an emotion he could not mistake. It brought 
 Christine like a visible presence before him. Also 
 it made him angry, to have to see her like this, 
 through another man's eyes. " Little whelp," he 
 said, " to detail a woman's beauty in print like 
 that! What does he know about it anyhow? I 
 don't believe for one second she looked at him 
 like that." 
 
 The sonnet ended : 
 
 She turned, a white embodiment of joy, 
 And looking on him, sealed the doom of Troy. 
 184 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 He was roused by a friendly shout in his ear. 
 " Ho, ho, Max, reading poetry, are you? What 
 love does for the worst of us ! " It was Welsley, 
 who snatched the paper out of his hand, running 
 over the lines rapidly to himself: " Hem, hem, 
 * carnation, alabaster, gold and fire.' Some queen, 
 that, eh? Have you had your dinner? Well, 
 don't be cross. There 's no reason why you 
 should n't read verse if you like. And this young 
 man is the latest thing. My wife says they are 
 going to import him here to speak to the Greek 
 Study Club." 
 
 " I shall be curious to hear him, if the Greek 
 Club will ask me," said Max. 
 
 " Oh, you '11 be in the East getting married," 
 answered Welsley. 
 
 Strangely enough, it was with something like a 
 pang that Max said to himself that he would n't 
 be. 
 
 " Carnation, alabaster, gold and fire." 
 
 It was not a bad line, he thought. 
 
 After dinner, he felt a little more amiable, and 
 so he sat down and wrote his first real letter to 
 his fiancee". 
 
 185 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " If we were really engaged, my dear Chris- 
 tine," he wrote, " you would have had a night let- 
 ter long before this, asking you to explain to me 
 just how it was that you did look on that amorous 
 young poet. His verse is pretty enough, though 
 I can't say I exactly enjoyed it. However, my 
 native town thinks very highly of him, and intends 
 to ask him to come and address one of our local 
 organizations. If so, I shall have an opportunity 
 of questioning him on the subject of the sources 
 of his inspiration. 'Is Helen a real person?' 
 I shall ask. ' Not so very,' I can imagine his 
 replying. Ah, what would we both give to 
 know? 
 
 " My friends here, stimulated by Dorothy 
 Lane's ravishing description of you, have asked 
 many times to see your picture. I am ashamed of 
 my own carelessness in having gone away without 
 obtaining one for exhibition purposes. Will you 
 send me one at once ? One not already in circula- 
 tion among poets and painters. I will set it on 
 my writing table, and allow my eyes to stray senti- 
 mentally toward it whenever I have people to 
 dinner. 
 
 " By the way, the day I left New York I told 
 a florist to send you flowers every day. We 
 
 186 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 worked out quite an elaborate scheme for every 
 day in the week. Did he ever do it? 
 
 " Yours, at least in the sight of this company, 
 
 " MAX RIATT." 
 
 In answer to this, he was surprised by a tele- 
 gram: 
 
 " So sorry for absurd mistake. Entirely mis- 
 understood source of the flowers. Enjoy them a 
 great deal more now. Yes, they come regularly. 
 A thousand thanks. Am sending photograph by 
 mail." 
 
 Riatt did not need to ask himself from whom 
 she had imagined they came. Not the poet, un- 
 less magazine rates were rising unduly. Nor 
 Hickson, who failed a little in such attentions, 
 No, it was Linburne and evidently Linburne's 
 attentions were taken so much as a matter of 
 course, that she had not even thanked him, nor 
 had he noticed her omission. 
 
 He did not answer the telegram, nor did he 
 acknowledge the photograph but, true to his word, 
 he established it at once on his desk in a frame 
 which he spent a long time in selecting. The pic- 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 ture represented Christine at her most queenly and 
 unapproachable. She wore the black and gold 
 dress, and the huge feather fan was folded across 
 her bare arms. Every time he looked at it, he 
 remembered how those same arms had been 
 clasped round his own stiff and unbending neck. 
 And sometimes he found the thought distracted 
 his attention from important matters. 
 
 It was about the middle of February when he 
 received one morning a letter from Nancy Almar. 
 He knew her handwriting. She was always send- 
 ing him little notes of one kind or another. This 
 one was very brief. 
 
 " Clever mouse ! So it knew a way to get out 
 all the time ! " 
 
 All day he speculated on the meaning of this 
 strange message. Had Nancy discovered some 
 proof of the nature of his engagement? Had 
 Christine been moved by pity to tell Hickson the 
 truth? On the whole he inclined to think that 
 this was the explanation. 
 
 The next day he knew he had been mistaken. 
 He had a letter from Laura Ussher not the first 
 in the series urging him to come back at once. 
 
 188 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Max," she wrote, with a haste that made her 
 almost indecipherable, u you must come. What 
 are you dreaming of- to leave a proud, beauti- 
 ful, impressionable creature like Christine the prey 
 to so finished a villian as Linburne ? You are not 
 so ignorant of the ways of the world as not to 
 know his intentions. Most people are saying you 
 deserve everything that is happening to you. I 
 try to explain, but I know you saw enough while 
 you were here to be put upon your guard. Why 
 don't you come? I must warn you that if you 
 do not come at once you need not come at all." 
 
 Riatt had just come in; it was late in the after- 
 noon. The letters were lying on his writing table ; 
 and as he finished this one, he raised his eyes and 
 looked at Christine's picture. 
 
 He did not believe Laura's over-wrought pic- 
 ture. Christine was no fool, Linburne no villain. 
 There was probably a little flirtation, and a good 
 deal of gossip. But that would all be put a stop 
 to by the announcement of Christine's engagement 
 to Hickson. He did not even feel annoyed at his 
 cousin's suggestion that he did not know his way 
 about the world. He knew it rather better than 
 she did, he fancied. 
 
 189 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 And having so disposed of his mail, he took 
 up the evening paper which lay beneath it, and 
 read the first headline : 
 
 Mrs. Lee Linburne to seek divorce: Wife of well- 
 known multimillionaire now at Reno 
 
 As he read this a blind rage swept over Riatt. 
 He did not stop to inquire why if he were willing 
 to give Christine up to Hickson he was infuriated 
 at the idea of Linburne's marrying her; nor why, 
 as he had allowed himself to be made use of, he 
 was angry to find that he had been far more useful 
 than he had supposed. He only knew that he was 
 angry, and with an anger that demanded instant 
 action. 
 
 He looked at his watch. He had time to catch 
 a train to Chicago. He went upstairs and packed. 
 He knew that what he was doing was foolish, that 
 he would poignantly regret it, but he never wav- 
 ered an instant in his intention. 
 
 He reached New York early in the afternoon. 
 He had notified no one of his departure, and he 
 did not announce his arrival. He went straight 
 to the Fenimers* house not indeed expecting to 
 
 190 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 find Christine at home at that hour, but resolved 
 to await her return. 
 
 The young man at the door, who had known 
 Riatt before, appeared confused, but was- decided. 
 
 Miss Fenimer, he insisted, was out. 
 
 Glancing past him Riatt saw a hat and stick on 
 the hall table. He had no doubt as to their owner. 
 
 " I '11 wait then," he said, coming in, and hand- 
 ing his own things to the footman, who seemed 
 more embarrassed still. 
 
 Taking pity on him, Riatt said : 
 
 " You mean Miss Fenimer is at home, but has 
 given orders that she won't see any one ? " 
 
 Such, the man admitted, was the case. 
 
 " She '11 see me," Riatt answered, " take my 
 name up." 
 
 The footman, looking still more wretched, 
 obeyed. Riatt heard him go into the little draw- 
 ing-room overhead, and then there was a long 
 pause. Once he thought he heard a voice raised 
 in anger. As may be imagined his own anger was 
 not appeased by this reception. 
 
 While he was waiting, the door of a room next 
 the front-door opened and Mr. Fenimer came out. 
 
 191 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 His astonishment at seeing Riatt was so great 
 that with all his tact he could not repress an ex- 
 clamation, which somehow did not express pleas- 
 ure. 
 
 " You here, my dear Riatt I " he. said, grasping 
 him cordially by the hand. " Christine, I 'm 
 afraid" 
 
 " I Ve sent up to see," said Max, curtly. 
 
 " Ah, well, my dear fellow," Mr. Fenimer went 
 on easily, " come, you know, a man really can't 
 go off in the casual way you did and expect to find 
 everything just as he likes when he comes back. 
 I have a word to say to you myself. Shall we 
 walk as far as the corner together? " 
 
 To receive his dismissal from Mr. Fenimer was 
 something that Riatt had never contemplated. 
 
 " I should prefer to wait until the footman 
 comes down," he answered. 
 
 " No use, no use," said Mr. Fenimer, suddenly 
 becoming jovial, " I happen to know that Chris- 
 tine is out. Come back a little later " 
 
 " And whose hat is that, then? " asked Max. 
 
 It had been carelessly left on its crown and the 
 initials " L.L." were plainly visible. 
 
 192 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 Mr. Fenimer could not on the instant think of 
 an answer, and Riatt decided to go upstairs un- 
 announced. 
 
 As he opened the drawing-room door he heard 
 Christine's voice saying: " Thank you, I shall 
 please myself, Lee, even without your kind per- 
 
 mission." 
 
 The doors in the Fenimer house opened silently, 
 so that though Christine, who was facing the 
 door, saw him at once, Linburne, whose back was 
 turned to it, was unaware of his presence, and 
 answered: 
 
 " You ought to have more pride than to want 
 to see a fellow who has made it so clear he does n't 
 care sixpence about seeing you." 
 
 Christine openly smiled at Max, as she an- 
 swered: "Well, I do want to see him," and 
 Linburne turning to see at what her smile 
 was directed found himself face to face with 
 Riatt. 
 
 Max made a gesture to the footman, and shut 
 the door behind his hasty retreat, then he came 
 slowly into the room. 
 
 "In one thing you are mistaken, Mr. Lin- 
 
 193 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 burne," he said. " I do care whether or not I 
 see Miss Fenimer." 
 
 Linburne was angry at Christine, not only for 
 insisting on seeing Riatt, but for the lovely smile 
 with which she had greeted him. He was glad 
 of an outlet for his feelings. 
 
 He almost shrugged his shoulders. " An out- 
 sider can only judge by your conduct, Mr. Riatt," 
 he answered. " And I may tell you that you have 
 subjected Miss Fenimer to a good deal of disa- 
 greeable gossip by your apparently caring so lit- 
 tle." 
 
 "And others by apparently caring so much," 
 said Max. 
 
 Christine was the only one who recognized at 
 once the fact that both men were angry; and she 
 did not pour oil on the waters by laughing gaily. 
 " You can't find any subject for argument there," 
 she observed, " for you are both perfectly right. 
 You have both made me the subject of gossip; 
 but don't let it worry you, for my best friends 
 have long ago accustomed me to that." 
 
 " I hope you won't think I 'm asking too much, 
 - Riatt," said Linburne, with a politeness that 
 194 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 only accentuated his irritation, " in suggesting that 
 as your visit is, I believe, unexpected, and as mine 
 is an appointment of some standing, that you will 
 go away and let me finish my conversation with 
 Miss Fenimer." 
 
 Max smiled. " Oddly enough," he said, " I 
 was about to make the same request to you. But 
 I suppose we must let Miss Fenimer settle the 
 question." 
 
 Christine smiled like an angel. " Can't we have 
 a nice time as we are?" she asked. 
 
 This frivolous reply was properly ignored by 
 both men, and Riatt went on : " Don't you think 
 you ought to consider the fact that Miss Fenimer 
 and I are engaged? " 
 
 " Miss Fenimer assures me she does not intend 
 to marry you." 
 
 " And may I ask if you consider that she does 
 intend to marry you that is if you should hap- 
 pen to become marriageable? " 
 
 " That is a question between her and me," re- 
 turned Linburne. 
 
 Riatt laughed. " I see," he said. " The mat- 
 rimonial plans of my future wife are no affair of 
 
 195 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 mine? " And for an instant he felt his most pro- 
 prietary rights were being invaded. 
 
 " Miss Fenimer is not your future wife." 
 
 " Well, Mr. Linburne, I hear you say so." 
 
 " You shall hear her say so," answered Lin- 
 burne. " Christine," he added peremptorily, 
 " tell Riatt what you have just been telling me." 
 
 There was a long painful silence. Both men 
 stood looking intently at Christine, who sat with 
 her head erect, staring ahead of her like a sphinx, 
 but saying nothing. After a moment she glanced 
 up at Max's face, as if she expected to find there 
 an answer to her problem. She did not look at 
 Linburne. 
 
 " Christine," said Max very gently, " what have 
 you told Mr. Linburne? " 
 
 " She has told me everything," answered Lin- 
 burne impetuously, and then seeing by the glance 
 that the two others exchanged that such was not 
 the case, his temper got the best of him. 
 
 " Do you mean you Ve been lying to me? " he 
 asked. 
 
 " Just what did you tell him, Christine? " said 
 Riatt, finding it easier and easier to be calm and 
 
 196 
 

 LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 protecting as his adversary grew more violent. 
 
 Christine looked up at him with the innocence 
 of a child. " I told him that we did not love 
 each other, and that our engagement was really 
 broken, but that no one was to know until March." 
 
 " Why did you tell him that? " 
 
 "It's the truth, Max almost the truth." 
 
 "Almost the truth!" cried Linburne. "Do 
 you want me to think you care something for this 
 man after all?" 
 
 " In the simple section of the country from 
 which I come," observed Riatt, "we often care 
 a good deal for the people we marry." 
 
 Linburne turned on him. " Really, Mr. Riatt," 
 he said, " you don't take an idea very quickly. 
 You have just heard Miss Fenimer say that she 
 did not love you and that she considered your 
 engagement at an end." 
 
 (" I heard her say she had told you that." 
 " You mean to imply that she said what was 
 untrue?" 
 
 " I could answer your question better," said 
 Riatt, " if I understood a little more clearly what 
 your connection with this whole situation is." 
 
 197 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " The connection of any old friend who does 
 not care to see Miss Fenimer neglected and humili- 
 ated," answered Linburne, all the more hotly be- 
 cause he knew it was an awkward question. 
 
 Perhaps the young poet had not been so wrong 
 in attaching the name of Helen to Miss Fenimer, 
 for she sat now as calmly interested in the con- 
 flict developing before her, as Helen when she 
 sat on the walls of Troy and designated the Greek 
 heroes for the amusement of her newer friends. 
 
 " May I ask, Mr. Riatt, what rights in the 
 matter you consider that you have?" Linburne 
 pursued. 
 
 For Riatt, too, the question was an awkward 
 one, but he had his answer ready. " The rights," 
 he said, " of a man who certainly was once engaged 
 to Miss Fenimer, and who came East ignorant 
 that the engagement was already at an end." 
 
 Christine laughed. " Very neatly put," she 
 said. 
 
 " Neatly put," exclaimed Linburne. " You talk 
 as if we were playing a game." 
 
 4 You have the reputation of playing all games 
 well, my dear Lee," she returned. The obvious 
 
 198 
 
May I ask, Mr. Riatt, what rights in the matter you consider that 
 you have ? " Linburne pursued 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 fact that she was enjoying the interview, made 
 both men eager to end it but, unfortunately, 
 they wished to end it in diametrically opposite 
 ways. 
 
 " Christine," said Linburne, " will you ask Mr. 
 Riatt to be so kind as to let me have ten minutes 
 alone with you ? " 
 
 Riatt spoke to her also. " I will do exactly as 
 you say," he said, " but you understand that if I 
 go now, I shall not come back." 
 
 Christine smiled. " Is that a threat or a prom- 
 ise? " she asked, the sweetness of her smile almost 
 taking away the sting of her words. 
 
 Seeing that she hesitated, Riatt went on: 
 " Since I have come more than a thousand miles 
 to see you, don't you think you might suggest to 
 Mr. Linburne that he let me have my yisit undis- 
 turbed?" 
 
 There was a long and rather terrible pause, 
 terrible that is to the two men. Christine prob- 
 ably enjoyed every second of it There was noth- 
 ing in Linburne's experience of life to make him 
 think that any woman whom he had honored with 
 his preference was likely to prefer another man 
 
 20 1 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 to himself. So the pause was terrible to him, 
 not because he doubted what the climax would 
 be, but because he felt his dignity insulted by even 
 an appearance of hesitation. Max, on the other 
 hand, was still a good deal in doubt as to her 
 ultimate intentions. 
 
 It was to him, finally, that she spoke. 
 
 " Max," she said, " do you remember that 
 while we were staying at the Usshers' we com- 
 posed a certain document together?" 
 
 He nodded, and then as she did not continue, 
 he opened his pocketbook and took out the re- 
 lease. 
 
 She made no motion to take it ; on the contrary, 
 she leaned back and crossed her hands in her 
 lap. 
 
 " jYes," she said, " that 's it. Well, you may 
 stay, if you care to burn that scrap of paper." 
 
 It was now Max's turn to hesitate, for the deci- 
 sion of freedom or captivity was in his own hands; 
 the crisis he had so recklessly rushed to meet was 
 now upon him. 
 
 " What is in that paper? " asked Linburne, as 
 one who has a right to question. 
 
 202 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 Christine was perfectly good-tempered as she 
 answered : " Well, Lee, it still belongs to Mr. 
 Riatt; but if he decides not to burn it, I promise 
 to tell you all about it as we drink our tea. n 
 
 " Do you promise me that, Christine?" 
 
 " Most solemnly, Lee." She looked up at Lin- 
 burne, and before Max knew what he was doing 
 he found he had dropped the paper into the 
 fire. 
 
 Strangely enough, though the fire was hot, the 
 paper did not catch at once, but curled and rocked 
 an instant in the heat, before it disappeared in 
 flame and smoke. Not until it was a black crisp 
 did Christine turn to Linburne, and hold out her 
 hand. 
 
 " Good-by, Lee," she said pleasantly. But he 
 did not answer or take her hand. He left the 
 room in silence. 
 
 When the door had shut behind him, Christine 
 glanced at her remaining visitor. " And now," 
 she said, " I suppose you are wishing you had 
 
 not." 
 
 " What sort of a woman are you ? " Riatt ex- 
 claimed. "Will you take any man that offers, 
 
 203 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 me or Hickson, or Linburne or me again, just as 
 luck will have it?" 
 
 " I take the best that offers, Max and that 's 
 no lie." 
 
 The implied compliment did not soften Riatt. 
 He went on: "If you and I are really to be 
 married " 
 
 " If, my dear Max! What could be more cer- 
 tain?" 
 
 " Since, then, we are to be married, you must 
 tell me exactly what has taken place between you 
 and Linburne." 
 
 "With pleasure. Won't you sit down?" 
 She pointed to a chair near her own, but Riatt 
 remained standing. "Shall we have tea first?" 
 
 " We '11 have the story." 
 
 " Oh, it 's not much of a story. Lee and I 
 have known each other since we were children. 
 I suppose I always had it in mind that I might 
 marry him " 
 
 "You loved him?" 
 
 " Certainly not. He always had too high an 
 opinion of himself, and I used to enjoy taking it 
 out of him and making it up to him afterwards, 
 
 204 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 too. I used to enjoy that as well. Sometimes, 
 of course, he found the process too unbearable; 
 and in one of his fits of anger at me, just after 
 he left college, he went and blundered into this 
 marriage with Pauline. She, you see, took him 
 at his own valuation. His marriage seemed to 
 put an end to everything between us " 
 
 " You surprise me." 
 
 Christine laughed. " Ah, I was younger 
 then." 
 
 " You kept on seeing him? " 
 
 " Naturally we met now and then. Sometimes 
 he used to tell me how I was the only woman " 
 
 " That is your idea of putting an end to every- 
 thing? " 
 
 " Oh, if one took seriously all the men who 
 say that I did not think much about Lee's 
 feelings for me, until my engagement was an- 
 nounced. Then it appeared that the notion of 
 my marrying some one else was intolerable to 
 him." 
 
 " A high order of affection," exclaimed Riatt. 
 " He was content enough until there seemed some 
 chance of your being happy." 
 
 205 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Perhaps he did not consider that life with 
 you would promise absolute happiness, Max." 
 
 " I don't call that love. I call it jealousy." 
 
 At this Christine laughed outright. " And 
 what emotion, may I ask, has just brought you 
 here in such haste ? " 
 
 The thrust went home. Riatt changed coun- 
 tenance. 
 
 " But I," he said, " never pretended to love 
 you." 
 
 " Why then are you marrying me? " 
 
 " Heaven knows." 
 
 " I know, too," she answered, unperturbed by 
 his rudeness, " and some day if you 're good I '11 
 tell you." 
 
 Her calm assumption that everything was well 
 seemed to him unbearable. " I don't know that 
 I feel very much inclined to chat," he said, turning 
 toward the door. " I '11 see you sometime to- 
 morrow." 
 
 She said nothing to oppose him, and he left the 
 room. Downstairs the same footman was wait- 
 ing to let him out. To him, at least, Riatt seemed 
 a triumphant lover, only as Linburne had long 
 
 206 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 since heavily subsidized him, even his admiration 
 was tinctured with regret. 
 
 As for Max, himself, he left the house even 
 more restless and dissatisfied than he had entered 
 it. 
 
 To be honest, he had, he knew, sometimes 
 imagined a moment when he would take Christine 
 in his arms and say: "Marry me anyhow." 
 'Such an action he knew would be reckless, but 
 he had supposed it would be pleasant. But now 
 there was nothing but bitterness and jealousy in 
 his mood. What did he know or care for such 
 people ? he said to himself. What did he know of 
 their standards and their histories? How much 
 of Christine's story about Linburne was to be 
 believed ? What more natural than that they had 
 always loved each other? Some one knew the 
 truth every one, very likely, except himself. 
 But whom could he ask? He could have be- 
 lieved Nancy on one side as little as Laura on 
 the other. 
 
 And as he thought this, he saw coming down the 
 street, Hickson a witness prejudiced, perhaps, 
 but strictly honest. 
 
 207 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 For the first time in their short acquaintance, 
 Hickson's face brightened at the sight of Riatt, 
 and he called out with evident sincerity: " I am 
 glad to see you." 
 
 " I came on rather unexpectedly." 
 " I 'm glad you did. Quite right." Hickson 
 stopped at this, and looked at his companion with 
 such wistful uncertainty, that it seemed perfectly 
 natural for Riatt, answering that look, to say: 
 " You may speak frankly to me, you know." 
 Ned took a long breath. " I believe that I 
 may," he said. " I hope so, anyhow. I have n't 
 had any one I could be frank with. Between our- 
 selves, Fenimer is no good at all." 
 "What, my future father-in-law?" 
 " Is that what he is? " Hickson asked with, for 
 him, unusual directness. 
 
 Riatt's affirmative was not very decided, and 
 Ned went on: 
 
 " I can't even talk to Nancy about it. She 's 
 keen, but she does not understand Christine. She 
 attributes the most shocking motives to her, and 
 when I object, she says every one is like that, 
 only I have n't sense enough to see it. Well, I 
 
 208 
 
 I 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 never pretended to have as much sense as Nancy, 
 but I see some things that she does n't. I see, for 
 instance, that there 's something noble in Chris- 
 tine, in spite of I beg your pardon for talking 
 to you like this, but you must remember that I 
 have known her a good deal longer than you have, 
 and that in a different way perhaps I care for 
 her almost as much as you do." 
 
 " I told you to speak frankly," answered Riatt. 
 " What is it that Mrs. Almar says of Christine? " 
 
 At first Hickson refused to answer, but the 
 suffering and anxiety he had been undergoing 
 pushed him toward self-expression, and Riatt did 
 not have to be very skilful to extract the whole 
 story. Nancy had asserted that Christine had 
 never intended for a minute to marry Riatt - 
 that she had just used him to excite Linburne's 
 jealousy to such a point that he would arrange 
 matters so that he could marry her himself. For 
 once Riatt found himself in accord with Nancy. 
 
 " Do more people than your sister think that? " 
 
 Hickson was not without his reserves. " Oh, 
 I dare say, but I don't care about that sort of 
 gossip. It 's absurd to say she and Lmburne are 
 
 209 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 engaged. How can a girl be engaged to a mar- 
 ried man? " 
 
 " We must move with the times, my dear Hick- 
 son," said Riatt bitterly. 
 
 " Linburne 's no good," Ned went on, " not 
 where women are concerned. He would n't treat 
 her well if he did marry her. Why, Riatt," he 
 added solemnly, " I 'd far rather see her married 
 to you than to him." 
 
 If Max felt disposed to smile at this innocent 
 endorsement, he suppressed the inclination, and 
 merely answered: 
 
 1 You may have your wish." 
 
 " I hope so," said Ned. " But you must n't go 
 off to kingdom-come, and leave Linburne a clear 
 field. He 's a man who knows how to talk to 
 women, and what with the infatuation she has al- 
 ways had for him " 
 
 " You think she has always cared for him? " 
 asked Max. He tried to smooth his tone down 
 to one of calm interest, but it alarmed Hickson. 
 
 " I don't know," he returned hastily. " I used 
 to think so, but I may be wrong. I thought the 
 same thing about you at the Usshgrs'. She kept 
 
 210 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 saying she was n't a bit in love with you, but it 
 seemed to me she was different with you from 
 what she had ever been with any one else. I 
 suppose I oughtn't to have said that either. 
 Upon my word, Riatt, it is awfully good of you 
 to let me talk like this I I can assure you it is a 
 great relief to me." 
 
 His companion could hardly have echoed this 
 sentiment. As he walked back alone to his hotel, 
 he found that Hickson's words had put the last 
 touches to his mental discomfort, 
 
 At first his own conduct had seemed inexplicable 
 to him. Everything had been going well, he had 
 been just about to be free from the whole entangle- 
 ment, when an impulse of primitive jealousy and 
 fierce masculine egotism had suddenly brought him 
 to New York and bound him hand and foot. It 
 had not been an agreeable prospect to live 
 among people whose standards he did not under- 
 stand, with a woman whom he did not love. But, 
 since his conversation with Hickson, his eyes were 
 opened, and he saw the situation in far more 
 tragic colors. 
 
 He did love her. He did not believe in her 
 
 211 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 or trust her; he had no illusions as to her feeling 
 for him, but his for her was clear he loved 
 her, loved her with that strange mingling of pas- 
 sion and hatred so often found and so rarely ad- 
 mitted. 
 
 He could imagine a man's learning, even under 
 the most suspicious circumstances, to conquer jeal- 
 ousy of a woman who loved him. Or he could 
 imagine having confidence in a woman who did 
 not pretend love. But to be married to a woman 
 whom you love, without a shed of belief either in 
 her principles or her affection, seemed to Riatt 
 about as terrible a prospect as could be offered to 
 a human being. 
 
 There was just one chance for him that 
 Christine might be willing to release him. If she 
 really loved Linburne, if there had been some sort 
 of understanding between them in the past, if his 
 coming had only precipitated a lovers 1 quarrel, 
 then certainly Christine had too much intelligence 
 to let such a chance slip through her fingers just 
 on the eve of Linburne's divorce. Nor was she, 
 he thought bitterly, too proud to stoop to ask a 
 man to reconsider ; nor did it seem likely, however 
 
 212 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 deeply Linburne's vanity had been wounded, that 
 he would refuse to listen. 
 
 With this in mind, as soon as he reached his 
 hotel, he sat down and wrote her a letter : 
 
 "My dear Christine: 
 
 " What was it, according to your idea, that 
 happened this afternoon? I believed that for the 
 first time I asked you to marry me, and that you, 
 for the first time definitely accepted me. But as 
 I think over your manner, I am led to think you 
 supposed it was just a continuation of our old 
 joke. 
 
 "Did you accept me, Christine? And if so, 
 why? Why commit yourself to a marriage with- 
 out affection, at the psychological moment when 
 a man for whom you have always cared is about 
 to be free? 
 
 " If you still need me in the game, I am ready 
 enough to be of use, but I will not be bound to a 
 relation unless you, too, consider it irrevocably 
 binding. 
 
 " Yours, 
 " M. R." 
 
 He told the messenger to wait for an answer, 
 but he thought that Christine would hardly be 
 
 213 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 willing to commit herself on such short notice, 
 or without an interview with Linburne. 
 
 But, within a surprisingly short interval, her 
 letter was in his impatient hands. 
 
 "Dear Max: 
 
 " I will not be so cruel as to leave you one 
 moment longer in the false hope that your little 
 break for freedom may be successful. Face the 
 fact, bravely, my dear. I am going to marry 
 you. We are both irrevocably bound at least 
 as irrevocably as the marriage tie can bind nowa- 
 days. If this afternoon my manner seemed less 
 portentous than you expected, that must have been 
 because I have always counted on just this termi- 
 nation to our little adventure. You must do me 
 the justice to confess that I have always told you 
 so. As for Lee, in spite of Nancy (I suppose it 
 was Nancy to whom you rushed for information 
 from my very doorstep) I have never cared six- 
 pence for him. 
 
 " Yours till death us do part, 
 
 " CHRISTINE." 
 
 Max read the letter which was brought to him 
 while he was at dinner. He put it into his pocket, 
 finished an excellent salad, went to the theater, 
 
 214 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 came back to the hotel and went to bed and to 
 sleep rather congratulating himself on the fact 
 that he had become callous to the whole situation, 
 and that, so far as he was concerned, the crisis was 
 past. 
 
 But of course it was n't. With the rattle of the 
 first milkcart, which in a modern city has taken 
 the place of the half-awakened bird, he woke up, 
 and if he had been in jail he could not have felt 
 a more choking sense of imprisonment. There 
 was no escape for him, no hope. 
 
 He got up and looked out at the city far below, 
 all outlined like a great electric sign that said 
 nothing. There must be some way of being free, 
 besides jumping from the twelfth story window. 
 He lit a cigarette, and stood thinking. Men dis- 
 appeared every day; it could be done. What 
 were the chances, he wondered, of being identified 
 if he shipped as steward, or engineer for that 
 matter, on a South American freighter? 
 
 It was full daylight before he found himself 
 in possession of a possible scheme. He remem- 
 bered the legend of a certain Saint, told him by 
 his nurse in his early days. She had been beauti- 
 
 215 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 ful, too beautiful for her religious ideals ; the num- 
 ber of her suitors was distracting; so to one of 
 them who had extravagantly admired her eyes she 
 sent them on a salver. 
 
 Riatt did not intend sending Christine his 
 worldly goods, but recognizing that they were the 
 source of the whole trouble, he decided to get rid 
 of the major part. The problem was simply to 
 lose his money before the date set for the wedding. 
 And that was not so difficult, after all. There 
 were a number of people in the metropolis he 
 thought who would give him every assistance. 
 
 The problem of getting it back again at some 
 future time was more complicated, but even that 
 he thought he could accomplish. He had made 
 one fortune and he supposed he could some day 
 make another. 
 
 The practical question was : What sum would 
 make him impossible to Christine as a husband? 
 Twenty thousand a year would be out of the ques- 
 tion. But to be perfectly safe he decided to leave 
 himself only fifteen thousand. He would begin 
 operation as soon as the exchange opened in the 
 morning. In the meantime what about that mine 
 
 216 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 of Welsley's? There was an easy means of sink- 
 ing almost any sum. 
 
 He took up the telephone and sent a telegram 
 at once. 
 
 " Plans for my wedding prevent trip to mine. 
 Have, however, decided after minute investigation 
 here to invest $500,000 in it. Believe we shall 
 make our fortunes." 
 
 He stood an instant with the instrument still in 
 his hand. " Suppose the damned thing succeeds," 
 he thought, " I shall be worse off than ever." 
 
 Then his faith returned to him. " Nothing of 
 Welsley's ever did succeed," he thought; and with 
 this conclusion he went back to bed and slept like 
 a child. 
 
 217 
 
CHAPTER VI 
 
 WITH his definite decision and unalterable 
 plan of action, wonderful peace of mind 
 has come to Riatt. He said to himself that he 
 was now to have a few weeks whatever time 
 it should take him to lose his fortune decently 
 of being engaged to a woman whom, he now 
 acknowledged, he passionately loved. He in- 
 tended to make the best of it. 
 
 The next day as he walked up Fifth Avenue on 
 his way to lunch with her, another inspiration 
 came to him; it was not necessary to lose his 
 money; spending it would be quite as effective. 
 Acting on this idea, he went into a celebrated 
 jeweler's shop, and with astonishing celerity chose, 
 paid for and pocketed a string of brilliant pearls. 
 
 It was a present that might have made any man 
 welcome and Christine had never be" " accused 
 of not being able to express herself vvhen she 
 wanted to but Christine had already welcomed 
 him for his changed demeanor; his brilliant smile 
 
 218 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 and unruffled brow told her as soon as she saw 
 him that he was a very different person from the 
 tortured and irritable creature who had left her 
 the preceding afternoon. 
 
 Never were two people more disposed to find 
 each other and themselves agreeable, and Riatt 
 was in process of clasping the pearls about Chris- 
 tine's neck (for she had had some unaccountable 
 difficulty in doing it for herself) when the draw- 
 ing-room door opened and Nancy Almar strolled 
 in. 
 
 Her jaw did not actually drop at the scene that 
 met her eyes, for that did not happen to be her 
 method of expressing surprise, but her manner con- 
 veyed none the less an astonishment not very 
 agreeable. 
 
 " Was I mistaken," she said, " in thinking I 
 was to stop and take you to the Bentons' ? " 
 
 "Quite right, my dear. Only Max's return 
 has put everything else out of my head." 
 
 " What, you did n't ever expect him to come 
 back?" 
 
 " You talk, Nancy, as if you had never heard 
 that we were engaged." 
 
 219 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " If you really are, Christine, why are the Lin- 
 burnes being divorced? " 
 
 " Because they loathe each other, I imagine." 
 
 u What a changeable creature you are, Chris- 
 tine ! It seems only the other day that you were 
 crying your eyes out because Lee was engaged." 
 
 Without glancing at Max, Christine became 
 aware that some of the gaiety had gone from his 
 expression. 
 
 "Have you seen my pearls, dear?" she said. 
 
 It was a complete answer, so far as Nancy was 
 concerned, for she was one of the women who can 
 never harden herself to the sight of another 
 woman's jewels. 
 
 " How beautiful, love," she answered. " If 
 they were only a trifle larger they might be mis- 
 taken for your old imitation string." Then feel- 
 ing that she could never better this, she took her 
 departure. 
 
 " Oh, dear," sighed Christine, " do you think 
 I shall ever get so superior that Nancy can't tease 
 me when she says things like that? " 
 
 " Did you really cry, Christine? " 
 
 " The night you went away? " 
 220 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " When you first heard of Linburne's engage- 
 ment ?" 
 
 She nodded at him, like a child who would like 
 to lie its way out of a scrape. 
 
 " But then I often cry over trifles," she added. 
 
 u Like my going away? " 
 
 " Really, Max, you ought to be able to under- 
 stand why I cried over Lee's engagement. It was 
 Nancy who brought me the news, and she was so 
 triumphant over it. She said every one would 
 think he had been making a fool of me. You 
 know she has the power of teasing me more than 
 any one in the world except, perhaps, you." 
 
 " I have a piece of news for you, Christine." 
 
 "Good or bad?" 
 
 " Indifferent, I think you would say. It 's a 
 scientific discovery." 
 
 "An invention, Max? Could I understand 
 it?" 
 
 " I think you can if you make an effort." 
 
 "What is it?" 
 
 He put his arms suddenly about her. " I find 
 I 'm in love with you," he said, and added a 
 moment later: " And just think that I Ve been 
 
 221 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 engaged to you so long and that 's the first time 
 I Ve kissed you." 
 
 Christine with her head still buried on his shoul- 
 ders murmured, " But it won't be the last." 
 
 Riatt's expression changed. " Not absolutely 
 the last, perhaps," he answered with something 
 that just was n't a sigh. 
 
 She looked up at him. " That piece of indif- 
 ferent news of yours " she began. 
 
 " Didn't I describe it correctly?" 
 
 " It was n't news to me." 
 
 " You mean you had already guessed that I 
 loved you? " 
 
 " I Ve always known it." 
 
 "Always?" 
 
 " You can't think I would ever have let you 
 go away at all, if I had not felt sure. And if 
 you had n't loved me, I could n't have brought 
 you back." 
 
 " I came back because " 
 
 " Because the Linburnes were getting a divorce, 
 and because Laura wrote you a letter. Do you 
 fancy I had nothing to do with either of those 
 events?" 
 
 222 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 And Riatt found himself answering almost in 
 the word of Cyrano: 
 
 " Non, non, mon cher amour, je ne vous aimais pas" 
 
 The days that followed were the happiest that 
 Riatt had ever known. Only those who have 
 lived in a brief and agreeable present can under- 
 stand the fullness of joy that he was able to extract 
 from it. If he had been under sentence of death 
 he could not have given less thought to the future. 
 He gave himself up wholly to the two excitements 
 of making love and losing money. 
 
 At first he prospered more at the former than 
 the latter. For at first, for some time after he 
 had acquired the stock of the mine, the reports 
 from it grew more and more favorable and old 
 friends came to him and begged him to allow them 
 to take up a little of it. His curt refusal to all 
 such propositions increased the impression that he 
 knew he had a very good thing and meant to keep 
 it all for himself. 
 
 But he did not have very long to wait for the 
 turn of the tide. Within a few weeks he received 
 a letter from Welsley, alarming only because its 
 
 223 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 intention was so obviously to allay alarm. It 
 appeared that a liberal revolution was threatened; 
 the concession from the government then in power 
 would not bear the scrutiny of an impartial wit- 
 ness such as our own State Department. If, in 
 other words, the present government fell, the con- 
 cession would fall, too. 
 
 " However," Welsley wrote cheerfully, 
 " though the revolution has the support of the 
 uneducated element of the population, which com- 
 prises most of the people, as they have neither 
 arms, ammunition nor money, they can't do much, 
 unless some fool in the north is induced to finance 
 them. You could help us a lot by looking about 
 and seeing if there is any danger of such a thing." 
 
 On receipt of this, Riatt instantly telegraphed to 
 Welsley as follows: 
 
 " Count upon me. What is the name and ad- 
 dress of the revolutionary agent here?" 
 
 The next day in a back bedroom of a down- 
 town hotel, $10,000 changed hands between a 
 slight, dark, very finished gentleman who spoke 
 
 224 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 English with the slightest possible accent, and a 
 tall, fine-looking young American whose name 
 never appeared in the transaction. Within a 
 month a shipment of arms had been smuggled into 
 a certain South American country, with the result 
 that the revolution was completely successful 
 as indeed it deserved to be. One of the first acts 
 of the new government was to revoke the iniqui- 
 tous concession of the San Pedro gold mine, made 
 to " a group of greedy North American capital- 
 ists by the former corrupt and evil administra- 
 tion." 
 
 Riatt's bearing during this unhappy experience 
 was universally praised. As he went in and out 
 of his broker's office, not a trace of anxiety visible 
 upon his countenance, men would nudge each other 
 and whisper, " Did you ever see such nerve? He 
 stands to lose a million." 
 
 The only moment of regret that he suffered was 
 when one day, when things first began to look 
 badly, he met Linburne and another man in Wall 
 Street, and there was something subtly insulting 
 and triumphant in the former's manner of con- 
 doling with him about the situation. 
 
 225, 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 Rumors of it reached Christine. She liked the 
 picture of Riatt's courage and calm, and hated 
 the danger of his losing money. 
 
 " You 're not risking too much, are you, Max? " 
 she asked. 
 
 " Would n't you enjoy love in a cottage, Chris- 
 tine? " he answered. 
 
 She tried to make it clear to him how little such 
 a prospect would tempt her, and gathered from 
 the fact that he hardly listened to her reply that 
 he felt confident there was no real danger. 
 
 With the success of the revolution, Riatt re- 
 alized that his holiday was over, that he must 
 tell Christine the truth and then retire to his old 
 home and begin a new method of life on his de- 
 creased income. 
 
 It was now early April a warm advanced 
 spring when he decided that the next day should 
 see the end of his little drama. But, as we all 
 know, it sometimes happens that those who set 
 a mine are the most startled by the explosion; and 
 Riatt, at an early breakfast (for he and Christine 
 were going into the country for the day), with 
 a mind occupied with the phrases in which he 
 
 226 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 should bid her good-by and eyes lazily reading 
 the newspaper, was suddenly startled beyond 
 words by a short paragraph on the financial page. 
 This stated in the baldest terms the failure of his 
 brokers at home. 
 
 There was no country expedition for Riatt that 
 day. He rushed down-town, leaving a short mes- 
 sage for Christine, and by night he knew the 
 worst, knew that the liabilities of the firm far ex- 
 ceeded any possible assets, knew positively that 
 the comfortable sum he had intended to preserve 
 for himself had been swept away, knew that he 
 now really had to begin life over. 
 
 That night when he came back to his hotel, he 
 understood for the first time that he had through- 
 out been cherishing an unrecognized hope; that 
 he had not been honest with himself, and that all 
 the time beneath his great scheme had lain the 
 belief that when the truth was known Christine 
 would prefer him and his moderate income to 
 Linburne and his wealth; that, in short, the great 
 scheme had been all the time not a method of 
 freeing himself, but a test of her affection. 
 
 Now any such possibility was over. Now he 
 227 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 himself was facing the problem of mere existence 
 at least he would be as soon as he had collected 
 his wits enough to face anything. 
 
 The next day, which was Sunday, he spent en- 
 tirely with his lawyer. When he came back to his 
 hotel, between the entrance and the elevator a 
 figure rose in his path. It was Hickson. 
 
 " Riatt, I 'm awfully sorry about this," he said. 
 
 " Thank you, Hickson. It 's very decent of 
 you to be," Max answered as cordially as he 
 could, but he was tired and wanted to be let alone, 
 and there was not as much real gratitude in his 
 heart as there should have been. He did not ask 
 Ned to sit down until he had explained with his 
 accustomed simplicity that he had something of 
 importance to say. Then Riatt let him lead the 
 way to one of those remote and stuffy sitting- 
 rooms in which all hotels abound. He saw at 
 once that Hickson found it difficult to say what 
 he had come to say, but Riatt was in no humor 
 this time to help him out. 
 
 " I 'm awfully sorry this has happened," Hick- 
 son went on, " not only on your account, but on 
 Christine's. I mean that I did begin to hope that 
 
 228 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 life with you meant peace and happiness for 
 her" 
 
 To cut him short, Riatt said quickly: " Now, 
 of course, the marriage is out of the question." 
 
 Hickson's face brightened, as if the difficult 
 words had been said for him. " You do feel 
 that? " he said, nodding a little as if to encourage 
 his friend. 
 
 Max did not answer at first in words; he 
 laughed rather bitterly, and then after a pause he 
 said, " Yes, Hickson, I do." 
 
 Ned was clearly relieved. " Of course," he 
 said, " I did not know how that would be. But 
 I own it did occur to me. The world is very cen- 
 sorious of poor Christine. Every one will say 
 that she is the kind of woman who can't stick to 
 a man in adversity. Yes, I assure you, Riatt, lots 
 of these women who can't put down one of their 
 motors without having nervous prostration will 
 pillory Christine for breaking her engagement, 
 unless " he paused. 
 
 " I don't follow your idea, Ned." 
 
 Hickson sighed. " Why, as long as you recog- 
 nize the impossibility of the marriage, couldn't 
 
 229 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 you in some way make it appear that the breaking 
 of the engagement came from you as 
 if " 
 
 " I see," said Riatt. There was a short silence, 
 and then he asked in a tone that sounded perfectly 
 calm to Hickson : " Is this a message from Chris- 
 tine?" 
 
 " Oh, no. Not a message from Christine, 
 though she has been trying to communicate with 
 you for two days. She can't see why you won't 
 even answer her letters. I told her I would find 
 you" 
 
 " In fact, it is a message, or at least you are 
 her messenger? " 
 
 " No, Riatt, at least not from her. I have a 
 message for you, but not from her." 
 
 " From whom ? " 
 
 " From Linburne. He has the greatest ad- 
 miration for your power, abilities, in spite of 
 any differences you may have had. He wants 
 to offer you a position, only he felt awkward about 
 doing it himself after what has taken place. He 
 asked me to speak to you. It 's a good salary, 
 only it means going to Manchuria, no " 
 
 230 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " One moment," said Riatt. " These two mes- 
 sages, are they in any way connected? " 
 
 " I don't understand. 1 ' 
 
 " Linburne's offer is not by any chance the re- 
 ward for my giving Christine a suitable release? " 
 
 Hickson was really shocked. " How can you 
 think such a thing, Riatt? " 
 
 "Where did you see Linburne?" 
 
 Hickson hesitated, but confessed after some 
 protest that it had been at Christine's house. 
 " But you don't understand, you really don't," 
 he said. " She has been distracted by your re- 
 verses, and not hearing from you she has turned 
 to me, to Jack Ussher, to any one who could 
 give her news and help you, as she imagined " 
 
 " I understand quite enough," answered Riatt. 
 " Thank Mr. Linburne for his kind offer and say 
 I have other plans ; and tell Christine she can have 
 her absolution for nothing. I '11 give her a letter 
 that will put her right with every one." And 
 walking to a desk: 
 
 " My dear Christine," he wrote. " As you 
 are aware, I have lost everything I have in the 
 world, and though I know, that to a spirit like 
 
 231 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 your own poverty could not alter love, I must 
 own that I, more experienced in privation, find 
 that the situation has had a somewhat chilling 
 effect upon my emotions. In short, my dear, I 
 cannot begin life over again hampered by a wife. 
 Thanking you for the loyalty with which you have 
 stood by me in this crisis, and wishing you every 
 happiness in the future, believe me 
 
 " Sincerely yours, 
 
 " R. M. RIATT." 
 
 He handed the note to Hickson. " I think 
 that, taken externally, will effect a cure," he said. 
 " Good night, Hickson. I 'm dead tired, so you 
 won't mind my going to bed. Oh, and I 'm off 
 to-morrow, so I sha'n't see you again. Good-by." 
 
 " Are you going home? " Hickson asked. But 
 Max maintained a certain vagueness as to his 
 plans, which Hickson, having accomplished his 
 purpose, did not notice. He was very much 
 pleased with the results of his diplomacy. No 
 one could say a word against Christine now. It 
 was n't her fault if the engagement was broken. 
 Riatt was a noble fellow only, the noblest some- 
 times forgot these simple, practical details. 
 
 232 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 The next day Riatt paid his bill at the hotel and 
 went away without leaving an address. 
 
 Few of us have driven past rows of suburban 
 cottages, or through streets lined by city flats, with- 
 out considering how easy it would be to sink one's 
 identity and become part of a new unknown life. 
 Riatt certainly had often thought of such a pos- 
 sibility and now he put his plans into operation. 
 He took no great precautions against discovery, 
 for he had no notion that any one would be par- 
 ticularly interested in knowing his whereabouts. 
 But he allowed those at home to suppose he was 
 working in New York, as he suggested to those 
 in New York that he had very naturally gone 
 home. 
 
 As a matter of fact, he had taken a position 
 
 i i ' i 
 
 with a new company which was constructing aero- 
 planes for the market, into which in past times 
 he had put a little money. He hired a small flat 
 in Brooklyn, on the top floor, so that he had a 
 glimpse of the harbor from his sitting-room win- 
 dows. He spent the last of his ready money in 
 buying out the dilapidated furniture of his pred- 
 ecessor; and then with the assistance of the jani- 
 
 233 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 tor's wife, who gave him his breakfast and did 
 what she called " redding up the place," he began 
 to live on the slim salary that his new job gave 
 him. 
 
 Every afternoon he would take the new ma- 
 chines out and fly at sunset over the sandy plains 
 of Long Island, would dine cheaply at some 
 neighboring restaurant, and would return to his 
 flat about ten, go to bed early and be ready for 
 work the next morning. 
 
 The only relaxation he allowed himself was the 
 excitement of hating Christine, to which he now 
 devoted a great deal of time and thought. It 
 was the only thing that gave life any interest. 
 
 What was loss of money, after all, he said to 
 himself, for an able-bodied man? He could bear 
 that well enough, if his life had not been poisoned, 
 if hope had n't been taken from him. She had 
 spoilt him for everything else. His success, if 
 ever he should succeed, would not bring him what 
 most men wanted of success a companion and 
 a home. He had nothing to work for, and yet 
 nothing to do except work. It was all his own 
 fault, he said; and blamed her all the more bit- 
 
 234 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 terly. He was glad, he thought, that he had 
 made it impossible for her to have a final inter- 
 view with him ; and in his heart he could not for- 
 give her for not having overcome the obstacles 
 to a meeting which he had set up in the last 
 frenzied days in New York. 
 
 " If I were of a revengeful disposition," he 
 said to himself, " I should ask nothing better than 
 that she should marry Linburne " ; and he con- 
 cluded that he was not revengeful because he 
 found he did not want it. He made up his mind 
 after the most prolonged consideration that a 
 woman such as Christine exercised the maximum 
 influence for evil; a thoroughly wicked woman 
 could not help inspiring distrust, but a nature like 
 hers had enough good to attach you and yet left 
 you nothing to depend upon. 
 
 He read the papers, awaiting the announcement 
 of her marriage, but found no mention of her 
 name except once, toward the end of May, a 
 short paragraph announcing that she had gone out 
 of town for the season. 
 
 It was soon after he had read this that he came 
 home earlier than usual and let himself into his 
 
 235 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 little flat. The day had been successful, a new 
 device in the engine was working well and the 
 company had had a large order from abroad. 
 And as usual, with the prospect of success had 
 come to him a bitter sense of the emptiness of 
 the future. He was thinking of Christine, and 
 when he turned the switch of the electric light, 
 there she was. She was sitting in a large shabby 
 armchair, drawn close to the window, so that she 
 could look out at the river. She had taken ->ff 
 her hat, and her hair shown particularly golden 
 and her eyes looked brightly blue in the sudden 
 glare of light. 
 
 " You 're dreadfully late," she said, quite as if 
 she had charge of his comings and goings. " I Ve 
 been here hours and hours and hours." 
 
 Now that he actually saw her before him, it 
 was neither love nor hate that he felt, but an un- 
 definable and overmastering emotion that seemed 
 to petrify him, so that he stood there quite silent 
 with his hand on the switch. 
 
 " Well," she went on, " are n't you surprised to 
 see me? " 
 
 He bent his head. 
 
 236 . 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Can you guess why I have come? " 
 
 He shook his head. 
 
 She looked a little distressed at this. " Then 
 perhaps I Ve made a mistake in coming." 
 
 At this he spoke for the first time. " I should 
 say that the chances were that you had," he said, 
 and his tone was not agreeable. 
 
 The edge of his words seemed to give her back 
 all her confidence. " Now, how strange that you 
 should not know why I 'm here ! I Ve come, of 
 course, to return your pearls." He saw now, be- 
 tween the laces of her summer dress that she was 
 wearing them. " In common honesty I could 
 hardly keep them." She put up her hands to the 
 clasp, but it did not yield at once to her touch, 
 and she looked up at him. " I think you '11 have 
 to undo it for me," she murmured, with bent head. 
 
 " I don't want them," he answered, with tem- 
 per. " I never want to see them again." 
 
 " Nor me, either, perhaps? " 
 
 " Nor you either perhaps." 
 
 She rose and approached him. " I '11 keep 
 them on one condition, Max that you take 
 permanent charge of both of us." Then seeing 
 
 237 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 that she had produced no change in his expression, 
 she came very close indeed. " There 's no use in 
 looking like a stone image, Max. It won't save 
 you." 
 
 " Save me! And what is my danger? " 
 
 " I 'm your danger, my dear." 
 
 " Not any longer, Christine." 
 
 " You mean you don't love me any more? " 
 
 " Not a bit." 
 
 At this she shifted her ground with admirable 
 ease. 
 
 " In that case," she said cheerfully, " we can 
 talk the whole subject over quite dispassionately." 
 
 " Quite, if there were anything to talk over." 
 
 " Only first," she said, " are n't you going to 
 ask me to stay to dinner? It 's very late, you 
 know" 
 
 " I don't dine here," he answered, " and I 
 doubt if you would eat very much at the restau- 
 rant where I take my meals." 
 
 " Well, would you mind my going into the 
 kitchen and making myself a cup of tea ? " 
 
 He gave his consent, but evinced no intention 
 of accompanying her. To see her like this, in 
 
 238 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 his own home, where he had so often imagined her 
 being and where she would never be again, was 
 torture to him. 
 
 After an interval that seemed to him an eternity, 
 she came back flushed and triumphant, carrying 
 a tray on which were tea, toast and scrambled 
 eggs. 
 
 " There," she said, " don't you think I Ve im- 
 proved? Don't you think I 'm rather a good 
 housewife? " 
 
 The element of pathos in her self-satisfaction 
 was too much for him. " I 'm afraid I 'm not in 
 the mood either for comedy or for supper," he 
 said. 
 
 Her face fell. " I thought you 'd be so hun- 
 gry," she observed gently. " But no matter. 
 Sit down and we '11 talk." 
 
 " I know of nothing to talk about," he returned, 
 but he dropped reluctantly into a hard, stiff chair 
 opposite her. 
 
 " I '11 tell you what there is to talk about," 
 said Christine. " Something that has never been 
 mentioned in all the discussions that have been 
 taking place. And that is my feelings." 
 
 239 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Your feelings," Riatt began, rather contemp- 
 tuously, but she stopped him. 
 
 " No," she said, " you sha'n't say what you 
 were going to. My feelings, my feelings for you. 
 You Ve told me that you did not love me, that you 
 despised me, that you did love me, but you 've 
 never asked how I felt to you." 
 
 " But you Ve made it so clear. You felt that, 
 in default of anything else, I would do." 
 
 She leaned across the table and looked at him 
 gravely. " Max," she said, u I love you." 
 
 He made no motion, not even one of contempt, 
 and so she got up, and coming round the table, 
 she knelt down beside him and put her arms tightly 
 about him. Still he did not move, except that his 
 hands, which had been hanging at his sides, now 
 gripped the edges of the chair with the rigidity 
 of iron, and he said in a voice which sounded 
 even in his own ears like that of a total stranger: 
 
 " What folly this is, Christine 1 " 
 
 "Why is it folly?" 
 
 " If you had said this six weeks ago, while I 
 still had enough money to " 
 
 240 
 
" Max," she said, " I love you " 
 

LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " If I had said it then you would n't have be- 
 lieved me." He looked at her; it was true. 
 
 " But now," she went on rapidly, " you must 
 believe me. If I come now to live with you and 
 work for you, no one can accuse me of mercenary 
 motives - not even you, Max. I sha'n't get any- 
 thing from the bargain but you, and that is all I 
 
 want" 
 
 " This is madness," said Riatt, trying not very 
 sincerely to free himself. 
 
 " Yes, of course it 's mad, like all really logical 
 things," she answered. " But that 's the way it 's 
 going to be. I love you, and I am going to stay 
 with you." 
 
 u I could n't let you," he said. " I could n't 
 accept such a sacrifice." 
 
 " A sacrifice, Max. That 's the first really 
 stupid thing I ever heard you say. It is n't a 
 sacrifice ; it 's a result, a consequence of the fact 
 that I love you. It is n't a question of my doing 
 it, or your letting me. It simply can't be other- 
 wise. The other things I used to value parties 
 and pretty clothes and luxuries they were a sort 
 
 243 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 of game I played because I did not know any 
 other. But only part of me was alive then. I 
 was like a blind person; and they were my stick; 
 but now that I can see, the stick is just in my way. 
 It is n't silly and romantic to believe in love, Max. 
 The hardest-headed, most practical people believe 
 in it every one who has any sense really believes 
 in it, when they find it. To be poor, to be uncom- 
 fortable it 's a price, but a small one to pay 
 for love. Is n't that true true, at least, as far 
 as you 're concerned? " 
 
 " Oh, yes, as far as I 'm concerned " 
 
 " Then what right have you to think it 's not 
 true to me? Don't be such a moral snob, Max. 
 If love 's the best thing in the world for you, it 's 
 ever so much more so for me I need it more." 
 
 " Nobody could need it more than I do," he 
 answered, suddenly clasping her to him. 
 
 " It 's the way it 's going to be, anyhow," she 
 murmured. 
 
 " I can't let you go," he said, as if arguing with 
 an unseen auditor. 
 
 She nodded in a somewhat contracted space. 
 " That 's it," she announced. " It has to be." 
 
 244 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 It was only a few days later that Nancy Almar, 
 driving past a well-known house-furnishing shop 
 on her way home to tea, was surprised to observe 
 her brother standing, with a salesman at his elbow, 
 in trancelike contemplation of a small white enam- 
 eled ice-box. With her customary decision, Nancy 
 ordered her chauffeur to stop, and entering the 
 shop by another door she stood close beside Hick- 
 son during his purchase of the following articles: 
 the ice-box, an improved coffee percolator and a 
 complete set of kitchen china of an extremely 
 decorative pattern. 
 
 " Bless me, Ned," she said suddenly in his ear, 
 " might one ask when you are going to housekeep- 
 ing, and with whom? " 
 
 There was no denying that Ned's start was 
 guilty, and his manner confused as he answered, 
 " Oh, they 're not for me " 
 
 The salesman who, perhaps, lacked tact, or pos- 
 sibly only wanted to get away to wait on another 
 customer, said at this point: 
 
 "And the address, sir? I have the name 
 Mrs. Max Riatt." 
 
 " Riatt married ! " cried Nancy. " But to 
 245 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 whom? I thought he had nothing left in the 
 world." 
 
 " He has n't," answered Ned, hastily scribbling 
 the address on a card and handing it to the man. 
 
 " Oh, then he 's married some one who loves 
 him for himself alone, I know. That faithful 
 sleek-headed girl from his home town. Won't 
 Christine be angry when she hears it ! She always 
 likes her old loves to pine a long time before they 
 console themselves. Let us go and tell her. Or 
 is she away still? " 
 
 A rather sad smile lit up Hickson's countenance 
 as he followed his sister to her motor. " I think 
 she knows it," he said. 
 
 Nancy put her hand on his arm. " Oh, dear, 
 darling Ned," she said. " Get in and drive home 
 with me and tell me all about it. I knew he really 
 never cared for Christine. She dazzled and dis- 
 tressed him in about equal proportions. And yet 
 I doubt if Miss Whatever-Her-Name-Was 
 will be very exciting " 
 
 " It is not Miss Lane, who, by the way, I like 
 and admire very much," said Ned, firmly. 
 
 " Who is it? Some one I know? " 
 246 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Yes, you know her." 
 
 Something in his extreme solemnity transferred 
 the idea to her. 
 
 " You don't mean that Christine " 
 
 He nodded. " I was at their wedding yester- 
 day." 
 
 " And where are they? " 
 
 " That 's it, Nancy. They 're living in a flat 
 and they have no servant " 
 
 His sister leaned back and laughed heartily, and 
 then composing her countenance with an effort, 
 she said: " My poor dear! But it's really all 
 for the best. She won't stay with him six 
 months." 
 
 " Nancy! She '11 stay with him forever." 
 
 "Where is this flat?" 
 
 " I Ve promised not to tell. They don't want 
 to be bothered by all of us." 
 
 " They want to conceal their deplorable situa- 
 tion, of course. Well, my dear, I can wait. Six 
 months from now I '11 ask them to dine to meet 
 Linburne. Christine's dresses will be a little out 
 of fashion, and they '11 come in a trolley car, and 
 she '11 have a veil over her head " 
 
 247 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 " Six months from now Riatt may be on the way 
 to making a nice little sum. He has a very good 
 thing, he thinks." 
 
 " He 'd better be quick about it. A flat in sum- 
 mer ! Oh, the cinders on the window-sill, and the 
 sun on the roof, and the knowledge that all of us 
 are going out of town to lawns and lakes* 
 He 'd better be quick, Ned." 
 
 The motor had stopped before the door of 
 Nancy's little house which was arrayed in its sum- 
 mer dress of red and white awnings, and red and 
 white window boxes. The footman had rung the 
 bell, and was waiting with his eye on the front 
 door, so as to catch the right second for opening 
 the door of the motor. 
 
 " Nancy," said her brother, with real horror in 
 his tone, " you talk as if you wanted her to fail." 
 
 " I do. I do, of course." 
 
 "Why? Do you hate her?" 
 
 Nancy nodded. " Yes, I hate her now. I 
 did n't used to." 
 
 " It seems to me this is just the moment to ad- 
 mire her. It may be foolish, but surely what she 
 has done is noble, Nancy." 
 
 248 
 
LADIES MUST LIVE 
 
 The hall door opened and simultaneously the 
 door of the motor, and Nancy, putting out one 
 foot, said over her shoulder: 
 
 " Oh, Ned, what a goose you are ! Don't you 
 know any woman would have done what she 's 
 done, if she had the chance the real chance? " 
 
 She ran up the steps and into her house, leaving 
 her brother staring after her in amazement. 
 
 THE END 
 
 249 
 
THIS BOOK IS DUE ON THE LAST DATE 
 STAMPED BELOW 
 
 AN INITIAL FINE OF 25 CENTS 
 
 WILL BE ASSESSED FOR FAILURE TO RETURN 
 THIS BOOK ON THE DATE DUE. THE PENALTY 
 WILL INCREASE TO SO CENTS ON THE FOURTH 
 DAY AND TO $1.OO ON THE SEVENTH DAY 
 OVERDUE. 
 
 MOV 19 1Q3S 
 
 UAH 03 2000 
 
 
 
 4UL y i~ 
 
 JUN 2 3 ZOO? 
 
 
 T,n 9.i_i nni.7 'q 
 
YB 
 
 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LIBRARY