UC-NRLF mill ii B 3 15A 2D3 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LIBRARY THIS BOOK IS NOT TO BE TAKEN FROM THE READING ROOM WHEN DONE WITH, RETURN AT ONCE TO ITS PLACE ON THE SHELVES LIBRARY OF THE University of California. Gl FT OF Supt, of Documents, Class LIBRARY OF CONGRESS SELECT LIST OF REFERENCES ON THE BRITISH TARIFF MOVEMENT (CHAMBERLAIN'S PLAN) COMPILED UNDER THE DIRECTION OP A. P. O. G-RIFFIN CHIEF BIBLIOGRAPHER WASHINGTON- GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE 1904 LIBRARY OF CONGRESS SELECT LIST OF REFERENCES OX THE BRITISH TARIFF MOVEMENT (CHAMBERLAIN'S PLAN) COMPILED UNDER THE DIRECTION OF A. P. . C. G-RIFFTX CHIEF BIBLIOGRAPHER WASHINGTON GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE 1904 v\ ^ *ft£' INTRODUCTION This List is intended to show what this Library contains relative to the fiscal controversy which has been agitated in Great Britain since the pronouncement of the Honorable Joseph Chamberlain in favor of the preferential treatment of the colonies in trade relations. The authoritative statement of the Chamberlain programme i.s found in his speeches printed under the title, "Imperial union and tariff reform," London, 1003. S. H. Jeyes's "Mr. Chamberlain, his life and public career,' 1 London, 1003, may also be consulted. An important contribution to the literature on the controversv is "Economic notes on insular free trade, 1 ' by the Honorable Arthur James Balfour, Prime Minister. The Economic Journal expresses the opinion that "For different reasons these 'notes' which were cir- culated by the Prime Minister to his colleagues in the Cabinet in the early days of August last, seem not unlikely to take a prominent place among the most remarkable of English State-papers." Mr. Balfour expressed qualified concurrence in the Chamberlain plan. He advo- cated scrutiny of the free-trade dogma and its effectiveness in present trade conditions. The Chamberlain programme finds an advocate in Professor W. J. Ashley, a political economist of the historical school, in his work entitled ''Tariff problems," London, 1904. Professor J. S. Nicholson, while not approving Ashley's thesis states in a review published in the Economic Journal that the author "seems to deserve the distinc- tion of having produced the best book on the Protectionist side of the controversy now raging." L. G. Chiozza-Money, in his ik Elements of the fiscal problem," undertakes to reply to the arguments of Ashley. Lord Brassey's "Fifty years of progress and the new fiscal policy" is said to be a "business like, scientific, and eommon-sense statement of the Free Trade position, based upon official statistics. Blue Books, and speeches of leading statesmen, British and Colonial." A series of controversial articles by Harold Cox and E. E. Williams have been brought together in a volume entitled "Free trade v. pro- tection; a fiscal duel between Harold Cox and Ernest E. Williams, with an introduction by L. G. Chiozza, 1 ' London, 1903. 4 LIBRARY OF I >NGBE88 The vrork edited by H. W. Massingham, entitled "Labour and pro- tection: a series of studies," is a collection of essays intended " to pre- sent a simple but complete nexusoi argument against Mr. Chamber- lain's protectionist policy from the point of view of labor." The doctrines of the Manchester school arc represented in a series of selections from speeches and writings of its founders in a volume edited by Francis \Y. Hirst, London. l ( .><>3. A free trade argument based on statistical history from L785 is the work by (J. Armitage-Smith. entitled "The free trade movement and its results," London, 1903. \Y. II. Mallock, in his work. "The fiscal dispute made easy." Lon- don. 1903, passes in review the arguments advanced by either side, lie aims to make clear to the ordinary mind the principles which are advanced by the advocates of free trade on the one hand, and protec- tion on the other. The agitation for a change of fiscal policy has caused the preparation of a number of Parliamentary blue books dealing with the various phases of the trade relations of the Empire. These are noted in the list under Great Britain. En some respects the most important of these documents is what is popularly known as the " Fiscal blue book" published under the title. " British and foreign trade and indus- try. Memoranda, statistical tables, and charts, prepared in the Board of trade with reference to various matters bearing on British and foreign trade and industrial conditions." London. 1903. It contains a mass of statistical information in regard to the industrial and trade conditions of the Empire. Among the important papers may be mentioned the following: ••Imports and exports of manufactured goods into and from the United Kingdom, with notes of tariff and other important changes and event- for a series of years;" "Export trade of the United King- dom to protected and unprotected foreign countries and colonies for a series of years;" •'Value of foodstuffs imported from foreign coun- tries:" "Wheat prices in the United Kingdom. France. Germany, and the United States, from 1840-1902;" "Consumption of food and cost of living in the United Kingdom and foreign countries;" "'The export policy of trusts in certain foreign countries;" " Statistics on the industrial condition of the United Kingdom and certain foreign countries;" " Imports from foreign countries into the self-governing colonies." Sir Robert Giffen's ••Economic inquiries and studies," London, Bell, 1904, was published too late to be entered in the body of this li-t. It is noted here because of the high standing of the author as a writer on economics. The writer claims the distinction of having debated a- early as L871 an imperial tariff of a preferential and of an incidentally protective nature. INTRODUCTION Professor William Graham has just published, through Kegan Paul, a work entitled "Free trade and the empire," "a volume in which the author supports certainly a two-shilling, and possibly even a four- shilling, duty on wheat, and some measure (not particularly specified) of retaliation and of opposition to dumping, but in which he opposes what he describes as 'an indiscriminate tax of 10 per cent, on the average on manufactures, as Mr. Chamberlain suggests/ ' In the "Edinburgh review" for January, 1904, there is an article on the tariff controversy, using as a text Chamberlain's " Imperial union and tariff reform," the "Fiscal blue book," Ashley's "Tariff problems,' 1 and Pigou's "Riddle of the tariff." Among the writers of monographs noted in the body of this List who support the Chamberlain policy are Caillard, whose work is said by a critic unfriendly to Caillard's thesis to be "a reasoned statement of the case for the reversal of [the British] fiscal policy, " Byng, Dale, Fell, Gaskell, Molesworth, Pope, and Wilson. Fli'irscheim in his "Clue to the economic labyrinth" argues for an imperial protective tariff. "Imperial reciprocity" is a series of articles, grouped under the topics "The retaliation issue,"" "The inquiry," "Food and transfer of taxation," presented to advance the cause of fiscal reform. Among the writers in opposition are Chiozza- Money, Cox, McClel- land, Perris, and Pigou. Sir John Barnard Byles's work is "A treatise in favor of protection, published in 1849" which has been reprinted with an introduction and notes by W. S. Lilly and C. S. Devas with regard to the present fiscal controversy. Agacy, in his work entitled "Free trade, protection, dumping, bounties, and preferential tariffs," discusses in a few chapters the issues of the fiscal policy, and favors modification of the present regulations without destroying the principles of free trade; decides that it is not desirable to abandon free trade for protection; advises countervailing duties to prevent dumping, and a preferential treatment which will steer clear of the evils of protection, with a resume of the arguments. In the "Economic journal" it is stated that "the chief merit of the book lies in the presentation with a due sense of proportion of the principles, ideas, and ideals of the controversy rather than in a final treatment of any one topic." The periodical pres"s has teemed with articles on the controversy, and most of them have taken position in accordance with party affiliations. The "Saturday review" has been a consistent supporter of the Cham- berlain scheme. It announces in an advertisement that "its policy is the policy of the greatest Secretary of State the Colonies ever had; and is supported by many of the chief daily, weekly, ana monthly periodicals." (\ LIBRARY OF CONGRESS The other leading weeklies, the Spectator and the Speaker, are ranged w ith the opposition. The following monthly magazines contain articles favorable to the Chamberlain policy: "Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine," the "Nine- teenth century and alter." and the "National review." The "Maga- zine of Commerce, an illustrated monthly for men of affairs," which is devoted to "the advancement of commerce," contains numerous articles in favor of the Chamberlain plan. The "Economic review." London, and the "Economic journal, journal of the Royal Economic Society." admit articles on both sides of the question. The "Economist," "Fortnightly review." ''Contemporary review," "Edinburgh review," "Independent review." and the "Westminster review." are on the side of the opposition. Ajnong Chamberlain's most ardent supporters are Sir Gilbert Parker. ( . Arthur Pearson, and W. A. S. Hewins. The present List contains references to magazine articles written by them in advocacy of the fiscal policy. The index will direct to these articles. Some of the leading magazine writers in opposition are Augustine Birrell, Winston S. Churchill, Leonard Courtney, Sir Robert Giffen, G. Shaw Lefevre, J. A. Spender, and Lucien Wolf. Statistics of trade are given in the following official publications of the British government: •• Annual statement of the trade of the United Kingdom and British possessions;" "Monthly trade and navigation accounts;" "Monthly trade and navigation accounts of foreign countries and British posses- sions;" "The Board of trade journal;" "Statistical abstract for the United Kingdom in each of the last fifteen years;" " Statistical abstract for the several colonial and other possessions of the United Kingdom in each year;" "Statistical abstract relating to British India:" k ' Sta- tistical abstract for the principal and other foreign countries in each year." Elaborate statistical tallies, with special reference to present fiscal condition- in Great Britain, are printed in the Financial Reform Almanack. A. P. C. Griffin, Herbert Putnam, Librarian of < '<>/) ss. Washington, D. C, Aprils, 1901,. C %ief Bibliographer LIST OF REFERENCES ON THE BRITISH TARIFF MOVEMENT (Chamberlain's Plan) Agacy, Henry A. Free trade, protection, dumping, bounties and preferential tariffs. Longmans, Green, and go., London, [etc.], 1903. (6), 83 pp. 8°. Ashley, William James. The tariff problem. London: P. S. King. 1903. 210pp. Folded tables. 8 l . "An able defence of Chamberlain's policy chiefly on the following grounds: (1) the efficacy of retaliation; (2) 'anti-dumping;' (3) the alightnesa of the prospective burden on commerce." Quarterly journal of economics, vol. IS: 312. ed. British industries. A series of general reviews for busi- ness men and students. Longmans, Green, and go., London, [etc.], 1903. scv, (1), 232 pp. 12°. Contexts: The British iron and steel industries: their conditions and outlook, by Stephen S. Jeans; The Midland iron and steel wages board, by Daniel Jones; The British cotton industry, by Elijah Helm; The woolen and worsted industries of Yorkshire, by Frederick Hooper; The British linen and flax industry, with special reference to its position in Ireland, by Sir R. Lloyd Pat- terson; British railways as business enterprises, by Charles H. Grinling; British shipping, and its present position, by Benedict VY. Ginaburg; The trust movement in Great Britain, by Henry W. Macrosty. Balfour, Arthur flames. Economic notes on insular free trade. New York, London, [etc.]: Longmans, Green, and co., 190S. 32 pp. 8 . Bastable, C. F. The theoiy of international trade, with some of its applications to economic policy. London: Macmillan <& co., 1903. xvi, 197 pp. 8°. "Governments in their dealings with foreign trade should he guided by the much-vilified maxim of Laissez faire." Econ. rev., Jan. 15, 1904: 1~'S. Brassey, Lord. Fifty years of progress and the new fiscal policy. London, [etc.]: Longmans, Green, and co., 190 L£. 110 pp. 8°. Concludes "that a return to protection would be disastrous." 7 LIBRAE? OF CONGRESS Buxton, Sydney. A handbook to political questions of the day and the arguments on either side. With an introduction. 11th ed. London: John Murray, 1903. axe, ^ /-/'/'• < -?°* Contains special chapters in 1'ivirrnnv, Retaliation, Protection, etc. Byles, Sir John Barnard. Sophisms of free trade and popular polit- ical economy examined. New ed. London: John Lane, 1903. Ixi, ./.'/ pp. 8°. "A treatise in favor of protection, published in 1849. The editors, \Y. s. Lilly and ('. S. Devas, have added an introduction and notes, which are, in part, concerned with the present British fiscal controversy." Quarterly journal of economies, vol. 18: 312. Byng, G. Protection: the views of a manufacturer. London: Eyri and Spottiswoode, 1901. xi, (1), 23-5 pp. 8°. Caillard, Sir Vincent Henry Penalver. Imperial fiscal reform. London: Edward Arnold, 1903. xx, 288 pp. Folded tabU. 12°. Favors preferential trade with the colonies. Chamberlain, Joseph. Imperial union and tariff reform. Speeches delivered from May 15 to Nov. 1, 1903. London.: Grant Richards, 1903. xi, 211, (1) pp. 8°. Contents: Introduction; A demand for injury; The case for tariff reform and Mr. Chamberlain's proposals; Retaliation; An answer to some objections; How the policy affects workinginen; Results of the new policy: What the colonies will do; The policy restated: How it affects trade unionism and shipping; The question of employment; A reply to Lord Goschen; The changed conditions since the repeal of the corn laws. Chiozza-Money, Leone George. British trade and the Zollverein issue. By Leone George Chiozza. Londmi : The " ( bnwu rcial intt lligt net " publishing <■<>.. ltd., 1902. (6),[9]-71 pp. Folded map. Folded diagram. 8°. [SelVs " Commercial intelligence" handbooks, no. 1.) Elements of the fiscal problem. London: P. S. King <& son, 1903. 237pp. 8°. "A strikingly successful attempt to set forth the free trade side of the British fiscal controversy.'" Quarterly journal of economics, vol. IS: 812. Through preference to protection. An examination of Mr. Chamberlain's fiscal proposals. London: Publishedby the Free trade union, 1903. 80pp. 8 . Cobden, Richard. Speeches on questions of public policy. Edited by John Bright and James E. Thorold Rogers. London: Macmillan and co., limited, 1903. r/\ (2), 622 pp. LIST OF REFERENCES ON BRITISH TARIFF MOVEMENT 9 Cox, Hiirolcl. The policy of free imports. London: T. Fisher Unwin, 1903. 34 pp. 8°. "Being a paper read at Liverpool on February 16th, 1903, to the New Century Society." Cox, Harold, and Ernest E. Williams. Free trade v. protection; A fiscal duel between Harold Cox and Ernest E. Williams, with an introduction by L. G. Chiozza. London: The ' ' Commercial intelligence " publishing co. , 1903. 99pp. Portraits. 8°. (Sell's " Commercial intelligence" handbooks, no. 2.) Dale, Bernard. Free imports; why our present system has resulted in transferring- a large portion of the labouring population of the United Kingdom to foreign countries . . . London: Effingham Wilson, 1903. xi, (1), 19 pp. 8°. Fell, Arthur. The failure of free trade as proved by the foreign commerce of England. London: Henry J. Drone, [1903 f] 61pp. 16°. Flurscheim, Michael. Clue to the economic labyrinth. London: Sioan Sonnenschein <& co., [1903]. xvi, 51f7 pp. 8°. "Free trade or protection," pp. 257-292. Free trade union. Handbook to the tariff question. [2d rev. ed.] London: Published by the Free trade union, 1903. 117, (3) pp. 8°. Leaflets, no. 1-29. London: Published by the Free trade union, 1903. 29 nos. 8°. Gaskell, Thomas Penn. Free trade a failure from the first. London: Macmillan and co., 1903. x, 91 pp. Folded dia- grams. 8°. Great Britain. Board of trade. British and foreign trade and industry. Memoranda, statistical tables, and charts, pre- pared in the Board of trade with reference to various matters bearing on British and foreign trade and indus- trial conditions. Presented to Parliament. London : Eyre and Spottiswoode, 1903. xvi, 4,95 pp. Tables. Diagrams. Charts. F°. Popularly known as the "Fiscal Blue book." Canada (Preferential tariff for goods from the United Kingdom). Ordered, by the House of Commons, to be printed. 3 August, 1903. -i pp. (In Great Britain. Parliament. Sessional papers, 1903. no. 310.) lit LIBRARY OF C(»N<1RKSS G-reat Britain. Board of trade. Colonial import duties. 1902. Re- turn relating to the rates of import duties levied upon the principal and other articles imported into the colonies and other possessions of the United Kingdom. Duties in force, so far as notified to the Hoard of trade, at date of issue of this return, November, 1902. xi, 459 pp. 8 . (In Great Britain. Parliament. Sessional papers, 1902, vol. 100. Cd. 1356.) Germany. New general customs tariff. Translation of the new general customs tariff of Germany, with com- parison as far as possible, of the rates of customs duty con- tained in the tariff with the rates at present in force on imports with Germany from the United Kingdom. 1903. 1 1 >2 pp. ( In Great Britain. Parliament. Sessional papers, 1903. Cd. 1479.) Preferential trade. Return to an order of the honour- able the House of Commons, dated 2 July, 1903; for, Return ''showing in regard to those countries where we do not enjoy de jure or de facto most- favoured-nation treatment the character and amount of the advantages granted to other countries; showing also the amount of British trade with such countries for the five years preceding and the five years succeeding the date when the differentiation came into force in each case.'"' Ordered, Iry the House of Com- mons, to be printed, 11 August, 1903. 11 pp. (In Great Britain. Parliament. Sessional papers, 1903. no. 329. ) Trade (Colonies and United Kingdom). Return "show- ing the trade of the various British colonies and possessions, inclusive of bullion and specie, with the United Kingdom, other British possessions, and foreign countries during each of the years 1890-1900/' Ordered, by the House of Com- mons, to be printed, 20 July, 1903. 15 pp. (In Great Britain. Parliament, Sessional papers, 1903. no. 262.) Translation of the new general customs tariff for the European frontiers of Russia, with comparison, as far as possible, of the rates of customs duty contained in the tariff, with the rates at present in force on imports into European Russia from the United Kingdom. Presented to both houses of Parliament. 19<>3. To pp. (In Great Britain. Parliament, Sessional papers, 1903. Cd. 1525.) LIST OF REFERENCES ON BRITISH TARIFF MOVEMENT 11 Great Britain. Board of trade. Translation of the proposed new general customs tariff for Austria-Hungary, with compari- son, as far as possible, of the rates of customs duty contained in the proposed tariff, with the rates at present in force on the imports into Austria-Hungary from the United Kingdom. Presented to both houses of Parliament. L903. 95 pp. (In Great Britain. Parliament. Sessional papers, 1903. Cd. 1672.) Colonial office. Colonial conference, 1902. Papers relating to a conference between the secretary of state for the eolo- nies and the prime ministers of self-governing colonies; June to August, 1902. Presented to both houses of Par- liament, October, 1902. xii, 155 pp. (In Great Britain. Parliament. Sessional papers, 1902. CM. 1299. ) "Board of trade memorandum on effect of the Canadian preferen- tial tariff on trade between the United Kingdom and Canada," pp. 83-117; "Canadian memorandum respecting the operation of the preferential tariff," pp. 118-129. Copy of Canadian sessional paper containing corre- spondence in connection with the German tariff. Presented to both houses of Parliament, August, 1908. 20 pp. (In Great Britain. Parliament. Sessional papers, 1903. Cd. 1781.) Foreign office. ComuurciaL no. J (1903). Correspondence with the Governments of Belgium and Germany as to their commercial relations with Great Britain and British colo- nies. Presented to both houses of Parliament. July, 1903. vi, 45 pp. (In Great Britain. Parliament. Sessional papers, 1903. Cd. 1630. ) Parliament. Debates on fiscal policy in Parliament. May 28, 1903-March 3, 1904. (/// The Parliamentary debates, 4th ser., vols. 123-131.) Hillier, Alfred. Our fiscal system. (In Royal colonial institute. Proceedings, vol. 35, pp. 79-104. London. 1904. 8°.) Hirst, Francis W., ed. Free trade and other fundamental doctrines of the Manchester school set forth in selections from the speeches and writings of its founders and followers. London and New York: Harper d- brothers, 1003. xxv, (1), 520 pp. 13. "Colonial and fiscal policy." pp. 38G-475. Imperial reciprocity: a study of fiscal policy in a series of articles, revised and reprinted from The Daily Telegraph. London: Office of the Daily Telegraph, [1903]. xx, 113 pp. 12 LIBRARY OF CONGRE88 Imperial tariff committee. Trade and the empire. Birmingham: Published by t?u Tariff committee, [1903], 29 nos. .' cartoons. 8 . Library lias nos. 1, 3-30, inci. B. 28 and B. 29. A collection of leaflets on the tariff controversy in < rreat Britain. The Imperial tariff for L903. Containing tin' laws and regulations governing the importation and warehousing, as well as the exportation or transhipment of all kinds of merchandise. Bv T. E. O'Reilly. Li >ml mi: Eyrt and Spottiswoode, [1903]. I. 783, 31£ j>j>. 16°. India. Government. East India (tariffs). Views of the government of India on the question of preferential tariff's. Presented to both houses of Parliament. London, !■'>"',. 49 pp. F°. {In Great Britain. Parliament. Sessional papers, 1903. Cd. 1931.) Jeyes, Samuel Henry. Mr. Chamberlain, his life and public career. London, \etc?\l Sands d- <■<>., 1903. \ii£\-xxxii, 803, (1) pp. 8°. Knight, William. Reciprocity in trade the empire's safeguard. No. 1. Preferential colonial tariffs. London: W. Heinemann, 1903. 58 pp. 12°. McClelland, James. The fiscal problem; with diagrams. London: T. Fisher Unwin, 1903. mi, (1), 87 pp. 12°. Mallock, William Hurrell. The fiscal dispute made easy; or, A key to the principles involved in the opposite policies. London: Eveleigh Kadi, 1903. vi, 102 pp. 12°. Massingham, II. ^V., ed. Labour and protection; a series of studies. London: T. Fisher Unwin, 1903. xadii,(l), 322,(1) pp. 12°. Contents: Preface; Political dangers of protection, by John Burns; Protection as a working-class policy. — 1. The general case, by J. A. Hobson; 2. Protection and wages, by J. A. Hobson; In the days of protection. — 1. By George Jacob Holyoake; 2. How the workers lived; The workman's cupboard, by Thomas Lough; The co-operative housewife, by Rosalind Nash; The people on the margin, by B. Seebohni Kowntree; Protection in the staple trades, by George X. Barnes; An object lesson from Germany, by W. Harbutt Dawson. " The object of the following essays is to present a simple but com- plete nexus of argument against Mr. Chamberlain's Protectionist policy, from the point of view of labour." Preface. Mr. Chamberlain's proposals. The question of preferential tariffs. Protection v. Free trade. Facts, figures, and arguments. London: Westminster gazette, 1903. 4 ■ LIST OF REFERENCES ON BRITISH TARIFF MOVEMENT 13 Molesworth, Sir Guilford L. Our empire under protection and free trade. With diagrams. Ward, Lock&co., limited. London, [etc.], 1902. 125pp. 16°. Mongredien, Augustus. History of the free trade movement in England. A new ed. . with introductory and supplementary chapters by the Rev. Dr. H. de B. Gibbins. London, Paris tt* Melbourne: Gassell & co., limited, 1S97. .,;;. [isywopp. 12 . Perris, George Herbert. The protectionist peril. An examination of Mr. Chamberlain's proposals. Methuen &co., London, 1903. mi, {!). 11(3 pp. 12°. Pigou, A. C. The riddle of the tariff. London: Johnson, 1903. 107 pp. 8°. Pope, J. Buckingham. The curse of Cobden and the worship of Diana. New ed. London: Duckworth and go., 1903. mii,{Ji),77 pp. 12°. Root, J. W. The trade relations of the British empire. Liverpool: J. W. Boot, 1903. xvi, 431 pp. 8°. Contains chapters on "The basis of customs union:" "The Cana- dian preferential tariff." Smith, George Armitage-. The free trade movement and its results. 2d ed. London: BlacUe & son, 1903. 276 pp. 12 z . {The Victo- rian era series.) The Speaker, the Liberal review. Supplement. London, 1903-190 If. Began publication July 18, 1903, as The Free trade circular; name changed after the second issue to Supplement to the Speaker. Free trade paper, issued with The Speaker, and given up to the tariff question. United States. Bureau of statistics {Treasury departnn nt). Modern tariff systems. The maximum and minimum, conventional, and general tariff systems of the principal countries of the world. Washington: Government printing office, 1902. Hi. 3095- 3168 pp. 4°. •■ From the Summary of commerce and finance for February, 1902." Vince, Charles Anthony. Mr. Chamberlain's proposals: what they mean and what we shall gain by them. With a preface by the Right Hon. Joseph Chamberlain. M. P. Third impression. London: Grant Bichards, 1903. viii, 86, (1) pp. 8°. 14 LIBRARY OF CONGRESS Willoughby, F. S. Suggestions for securing fair play for British manufactures first, and ultimately securing preferential trade between the various portions of the British empire. Manchester: CoJMnsdb Kingston, 1903. 8°. "Wilson, II. W. Mr. Chamberlain's new policy. Fifty years of free trade and the result. London: Swan Sonnenschein <& oo., ltd., 1903. 32 _pp.' 8°. BRITISH TARIFF MOVEMENT: ARTICLES IN PERIODICALS 1901. The outlook for British trade. H. E. Roscoe. Monthly revieic, vol. 2 {Feb., 1901): 09-81; vol. 3 {May, 1901): 40-53. 1901. The alleged economic deca3 T of Great Britain. W. H. Mallock. Monthly review, vol. 4 {Sept., 1901): 21-35. 1902. British commerce, 1881-1900. J. Holt Schooling. Monthly review, vol. 6 {Jan., 1902): 40-57. 1902. Free trade or protection for England '. A plea for reconsid- eration. John Beattie Crozier. Fortnightly review, n. s., vol. 71 {Mar. 1, 1902): 427-433. 1902. The approaching abandonment of free trade. J. A. Hobson. Fortnightly revieic, n. s., vol. 71 {Mar. 1, 1902): 4^4-444- 1902. Foreign trade and home markets. Vincent Caillard. National review, vol. 39 {Mar., 1902): 51-77. 1902. The commercial needs of the empire. E. J. Dillon. Contemporary review, vol. 81 {April, 1902): 457-481. 1902. Some suggestions towards an imperial tariff. Vincent Cail- lard. National review, vol. 39 {April, 1902): 209-227. 1902. The dream of a British Zollverein. Sir Robert Giffen. Nineteenth century and after, vol. 51 {May, 1902): 693-705. 1902. The promotion of trade within the empire. John B. C. Kershaw. Monthly review, vol. 7 {June, 1902): 59-78. 1902. w, The dream of a British Zollverein:" a reply to Sir Robert Giffen. Vincent Caillard. National review, vol. 39 {June, 1902): 597-605. 1902. Preferential tariff's within the empire. A reply to Sir Robert Giffen. Hemy Birchenough. Nineteenth century and after, vol. 51 {June, 1902): 891-899. 1902. How to ruin a free-trade nation. John Beattie Crozier. Fortnightly review, n. s., rot. 72 {July 1, 1902): 32-51. 15 u\ LIBRARY OF CONGRESS 1902. The economic taproot of imperialism. J. A. Hobson. Contemporary review, vol. 82 (Aug., 1902): $19-23%. 1902. The promotion of trade within the empire: A reply to ]\Ir. Kershaw. R. II. Brand. Monthly review, vol. 8 [Aug., 1902): 56-72. 1902. A natural outcome of protection. Walter F. Ford. Economic review, vol. 12 (Oct. /■'>. 1902): 385-398. 1902. Free trade is danger. George Martineau. New liberal review, vol. / (Nov., 1902): 496-503. 1902. An imperial Zollverein with preferential tariffs. C. F. Bas table. Economic journal, vol. 13 (/)<<:., 1002): '107-613. 1903. The natural outcome of free trade. G. Byng. Economic review, vol. 13 (Jan., 1903): 45. Reply toarticle by W. F. Ford in Economic review fur October, 1902. "It is the object of the present article to show that the natural out- come of free trade is the decline of British industries." 1903. Trade relations within the empire. Vincent Caillard. Empire review, vol. 6 (Feb. , 1903) : 19-28. 1903. The colonial office conference and preferential trade within the empire. John B. C. Kershaw. Feilden's magazine, vol. S (Feb.. 1903): 166-161. 1903. Free trade and its critics. A. C. Pigou. Fortnightly review, n. s., vol. 73 (Mar., 1903): 543-664. 1903. Mr. Chamberlain's new chapter. Edward Salmon. Fortn ightly review, n. s. , vol. 73 (Apr. , 1903) : 038-645. 1903. The demerits of our fiscal policy. G. Byng. Magnziht of Com m< ■■/'<■>-. vol. 2 (May, 1903): 273-277. 1903. Free trade and its defenders. Vincent Caillard. National review, vol. 4-1 (May, 1903): 420-434.. 1903. Free trade or empire? Saturday review, vol. 95 (May 30, 1903): 672-673. 1903. The new mercantilism, or differential free trade. Scrutator. Speaker, n. 8., vol. 8 (May 30, 1903): 202-203. 1903. Premier Balfour on tariff retaliation. Commercial and financial chronicle, vol. 76 (June 27, 1903): 1378-1380. 1903. Germany and Canada. E.J. Dillon. Contemporary review, vol. 83 (June, 1903): 876-884- BRITISH TARIFF MOVEMENT: ARTICLES IN PERIODICALS 17 1903. The Canadian view of Mr. Chamberlain's preferential tariff suggestions. Economist {London), vol. 61 {June 20, 1903): 1081-1082. 1903. Mr. Chamberlain's new chapter. C. Kinloch-Cooke. Empire review, vol. 5 {June, 1903): J^7-JiS3. 1903. Why Canada should be granted a preference in the markets of Great Britain. Albert Swindlehurst. Empire review, vol. 5 {June, 1903): 492-499. 1903. The colonies and imperial defence. A. W. A. Pollock. Maomillan's magazine, vol. 88 {June, 1903): 99-104. 1903. The antidote for Chamberlain. Nation., vol. 76 {June 4, 1903): 450-451. 1903. The influence of free trade on wages. G. Byng. National review, vol. 41 {June, 1903): 640-661. 1903. Die britische Zollverein. M. Beer. Neue Zeit, 21. Jahrg., vol. °2 {June 6, 1903): 293-300. 1903. Imperial reciprocity. I. Herbert Maxwell. II. Sir Gilbert Parker. III. Benjamin Taylor. Nineteenth century and after, vol. 53 {June, 1903): 897-905; 906-910; 911-917. 1903. Imperial and foreign trade: two views. Public opinion {London), vol. S3 {June 26, 1903): 816-818. 1903. The imperial Zollverein policy. Review of reviews {London), vol. 27JJune, 1903): 573-575. 1903. Mr. Chamberlain's attack upon free trade. Review ofreviews t {London), vol. 27 {Jam', 1903): 631-633. 1903. The position of the government. Speaker, n. s., vol. 8 {June 13, 1903): 245-240. 1903. The mystery of the corn tax solved. Speaker, n. s., vol. 8 {June 13, 1903): 246-247. 1903. The new mercantilism or differential free trade. Scrutator. Speaker, n, s., vol. 8 {June 13, 1903): 247-248. 1903. Protection and the working classes. F. Maddison. Speaker, n. s., vol. 8 {June 13, 1903): 248-249. 1903. Canadian and German tariff war. Scrutator. Speaker, n. s., vol. S {June 27, 1903): 291-292. 1903. The duty of imperialist free-traders. Spectator, vol. 90 {June 6, 1903): 884. 24346—04 2 is I.IBKAKY OF CoNOKFSS 1903. •• Bleeding to death." Spectator, vol. 90 {Jum 27, 1903): 1022-1028. 1903. The new protection. Spectator, vol. 90 (Jum 27, 1903): 1028. 1903. Preferential treatment of the colonies. Statist, vol. 51 (-Jim, 6, 1903): 1213-12U. 1903. England's new conditions. American monthly review of reviews, vol. 28 {July. 1903): 1903. Britain's imperial Zollverein policy. American monthly n /. s magazine, vol. 88 (July, 1903): 213-218. 1903. Our fiscal policy. Francis Franklin. Magazine of commerce, vol. 3 (July, 1903): 1-2. 1903. A brief review of recent protectionist pleus. Elijah Helm. Magazine of commerce, vol. 3 (July, 1003): 3-6. 1903. Should free trade be worshipped? Mr. Helm's article replied to, with some further arguments in support of Mr. Cham- berlain's proposals. G. Byng. Magazine of commerce, vol. 3 {July, 1903): 8-13. 1903. "The demerits of our fiscal policy." Magazine of commerce, vol. 3 (July, 1903): 13-16. 1903. Mr. Chamberlain's proposals. Viscount Goschen. Monthly review, vol. 12 (July, 1903): 38-55. Living age, vol. 238 (Aug. 15, 1903): 398-4-08. 1903. Free trade and preferential tariffs. Ralph Neville. Monthly review, vol. 12 (July, 1903): 56-63. 1903. British fiscal policy: a plea for inquiry. C. A. Cripps. National review, vol. tf. (July, 1903): 758-709. 1903. Preferential trade. Alfred Emmott. New liberal review, vol. 5 (July, 1903): 743-755. 1903. The colonial view. E. T. Cook. New liberal review, vol. 5 (July, 1903): 750-764- 1903. A colonial point of view. Arthur II. Adams. New liberal review, vol. 5 (July, 1903): 765-768. 1903. "Ties of interest." L. Chiozza Money. New liberal review, vol. 5 (July, 1903): 769-775. 1903. The new departure and how to meet it. J. A. Spender. New liberal review, vol. 5 (July, 1905): 776-781. 1903. The failure of protection in France. A warning to England. Frederic Lees. New liberal review, vol. 5 (July, 1905): 737-794. 0(| I.IBK\KY OF CONGBE88 1903. The opposition to the proposals of Mr. Chamberlain. New liberal review, vol. 5 {July, 1903): 795 818. 1. Ministerialist objections. II. Labour objections. III. Special interviews: sir Charles Dilke; Benry Broadhurst; sir John ( rorst 1903. Imperial policy and free trade. I. Sir Robert Giffen. II. Edward Dicey. III. Benjamin Kidd. Nineteenth century and after, vol. •"/ {July, 1903): l-3.\. 1903. Mr. Chamberlain's scheme. Harold Cox. North American review, vol. 177 {July, 1903): 1-11. 1903. Imperial trade and tariffs. Benjamin Taylor. PagJs magazine, vol. 3 {July, 1903): 65-70. 1903. British foreign trade in L902. J. W. Root. Protectionist, vol. 15 {July, 1903): 799-802. 1903. British preferential trade. [Mr. Chamberlain's speech.] [Protectionist, vol. 15 {July, 1903): 807-811. 1903. England's momentous problem. F. C. Chappell. Protectionist, vol. 15 {July, 1003): 816-817. 1903. The tariff contest in Britain. Protectionist, vol. 15 {July, 1903): 838S1&. 1903. The grand inquest of the nation. Public opinion {London), vol. 84 {July 3, 1003): 6-0. 1903. Tariffs and parties. Not a "Little England v. imperialist" issue. Public opinion {London), vol. 84 {July 10. 1003): 1^1-^2. 1903. Fiscal policy and party loyalty. Saturday review, vol. 96 {July .J. 1903): 6-7. 1903. A word about "dumping." Speaker, n. s., vol. 8 {July 11, 1003): 333-336. 1903. The colonies and Mr. Chamberlain's proposals. Spectator, vol. 01 {July 11. 1903): 45-lfi. 1903. The new protection. [Letters to the, editor.] Spectator, vol. 01 {July 11. 1903): 31-33. 1903. Preferential treatment of the colonic-. Statist, vol. 52 {July 11. 1903): 59-61. 1903. The facts about preferential trade. World's work {London), vol. 2 {July, 1903): 137-160. 1903. Fiscal policies in L903. BlackwoooVs Edinburgh magazine, vol. 174 {Aug., 1003): 277-300. BRITISH TARIFF MOVEMENT: ARTICLES IX PERIODICALS 21 1903. Imperialists of yesterday and to-morrow. John A. Cooper. Canadian magazine, vol. 21 {Aug., 1903): 297-306. 1903. Mr. Chamberlain's balloon. Leonard Courtney. Contemporary review, vol. 81(, {Aug., 1903): '265-279. 1903. Imperial reciprocity. Herbert Maxwell. Sir Gilbert Parker. Benjamin Taylor. Eclectic magazine, vol. 11,1 {Aug., 1903): 11,1-156. 1903. Preferential tariffs and Mr. Chamberlain. I. Cobdenism and the colonies. Calchas. II. The proposed reversal of Eng- lish commercial policy. Lujo Brentano. III. Free trade and home rule. Edward Dicey. Fortnightly review, n. s., vol. 71, {Aug. 1, 1903): 193-231. 1903. Imperial policy and free trade. Edward Dicey. Living age, vol. 238 {Aug. 8, 1903): 31(5-357. 1903. The colonies and imperial defence. A. W. A. Pollock. Macmillan's magazine, vol. 88 {Aug., 1903): 286-289. 1903. Protection or free-trade? Percy F. Rowland. Macmillan's magazine, vol. 88 {Aug., 1903): 255-261. 1903. The fiscal question. Jlaguzine of commerce, vol. 3 {Aug.. 1903): 94-99. 1903. The changing order. S. L. Bensusan. Magazvne of co?nm,erce, vol. 3 {Aug., 1903): 107-109. 1903. Mr. Byng's reply to a South "Wales critic. Magazi/m of commerce, vol. 3 {Aug., 1903): 164-165. 1903. Le protectionnisme imperialiste anglais et les interets agricoles de la France. D. Zolla. Mondt econo/ziioue, 13 e an nee {Aug. 29, 1903): 259-260. 1903. The position of the unionist free traders. Henry Hobhouse. Monthly review, vol. 12 {Aug., 1903): 55-61. 1903. Imperial trade and tariffs. Hugh Bell. Monthly review, vol. 13 {Aug., 1903): 62-73. 1903. Free traders at bay. Ernest E. Williams. National review, vol. U {Aug., 1903): 930-91,0. 1903. The revolt against Cobdenism. II. W. Wilson. National review, vol. 41 {Aug., 1903): 91,1-91(9. 1903. The cabinet empirics. J. H. Yoxall. New liberal review, vol. 6 {Aug., 1003): 14-22. 1903. Germany and Canada. Andrew Caird. N w liberal r< riew, vol. 6 {Aug., 1903): 25-27. oo LIBRAE"? OP 0ONGBEB8 1903. Mr. Chamberlain's proposals. Sir John E. Gorst. Vorth American review, vol. 177 {Aug. , 1903): 161-171. 1903. The proposed British Zollverein. Archibald K. Colquhoun. Vorth American review, vol. 177 (Aug., 1903): 172 1X2. 1903. Mr. ( Jhamberlain's imperial tariff plan. Henry Loomis Nelson. North American review, vol. 177 (Aug., 1903): 183-191. 1903. Aic the colonies forcing England into a Zollverein? V. C. Chappell. Protectionist, vol. 15 (Aug., 1903): 862-863. 1903. England's tariff educational campaign. Protectionist, vol. 15 (Aug., 1903): 864-870. 1903. The passing of free trade John F. Scanlan. Protectionist, vol. 15 (Aug., 1903): 890-893. 1903. Preferential trade in its relation to Canada and the empire. George \V. Ross. Canadian magazine, vol. 21 (Sept., 1903): 411-416. 1903. To unionists and imperialists. A. V. Dicey. Contemporary review, vol. 84- (Sept.. 1903): 305-317. 1903. The inner meaning of protectionism. J. A. Hobson. Contemporary review, vol. 84 (Sept.. 1903): 36h-37J h 1903. The fiscal enquiry. J. W. Root. Economic journal, vol. 13 (Sept., 1903): 293-302. 1903. Statistical methods and the fiscal controversy. A. L. Bowley. Econ&mic journal, vol. 13 (Sept., 1903): 303-312. 1903. The effect of export and import duties on price and production examined by the graphic method. H. Cunynghame. Economic journal, vol. 13 (Sept.. 1903): 313-323. 1903. Canada and the German tariff. Economist (London), vol. 61 (Sept., 1903): 1534-1535. 1903. L'aventure de M. Chamberlain. Paul Leroy-Beaulieu. tconomiste francais, 31' cmnee, vol. 2 (Sept, 26, 1903): 429- ',31. 1903. Free trade and its fruits. J. A. Spender. Fortnightly review, n. s., vol. 74 (Sept., 1903): 391-411. 1903. The eve of the campaign. Calchas. Fortnightly review, n. s., vol. 74 (Sept., 1903): 412-427. 1903. An American view of Mr. Chamberlain's proposals. Robert Ellis Thompson. Fortnightly review, n. s., vol. 74 (Sept., 1903): 466-473. 1903. 1903. 1903. 1903. 1903. 1903. 1903. BRITISH TARIFF MOVEMENT: ARTICLES IN PERIODICALS 28 Canada's second thought on a preference. John Davidson. Fortnightly review, n. s., vol. 71+ {Sept., 1903): 1+71+-1+79. British comments on Mr. Chamberlain's fiscal policy. Harper's weekly, vol. 47 {Sept. 12, 1903): 11+69-11+70. The future of the British iron trade as affected by pending tariff proposals. Iron and coal trades review, vol. 67 {Sept. 1+, 1903): 727-731. The fiscal question: history's argument. C. B. Roylance Kent. Macmillan's magazine, vol. 88 {Sept., 1903): 336-31+3. L'Angleterre et l'economie politique. N. C. Frederiksen. Monde economigue, 13 e annee {Sept. 19. 1903): 353-351+. A view of the fiscal controversy. Sir M. E. Hicks-Beach. Monthly review, vol. 12 {Sept., 1903): 28-39. Die Wirkung der canadischen Vorzugszolle. Paul Arndt 77 '6-778. Nation {Berlin), 20. Jahrgang {Sept. 5, 1903), 1903. The economics of empire. National review, vol. 1+2 {Sept.. 1903): Special supplement, 1-106. London's case against protection. Frederick Dolman. New liberal review, vol. 6 {Sept., 1903): 171+-185. The great fiscal problem. Avebury [Sir John Lubbock]. Lionel Phillips. W. H. Mallock. Nineteenth century and after, vol. 51+ {Sept., 1903): 353-390. Preferential treatment of the colonies. Statist, vol, 52 {Sept. 5, 1903): 1+26. A free trading imperial Zollverein. Leonard M. Burrell. Westminster review, vol. 160 {Sept., 1903): 237-21+5. The experts and Mr. Chamberlain. World's work {London), vol. 2 {Sept., 1903): 31+2-31+7. GiYes the text of the "pronouncement signed by no fewer than fourteen professors of economics, including, with possibly one exception, all the leading recognised authorities upon political economy, upon Mr. Chamberlain's proposals." The food tax: how it would affect eggs and poultry. Edward Brown. World's work {London), vol, 2 {Sept., 1903): 357-358. The fiscal crisis. Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, vol. 171+ {Oct., 1903): 561-581+. 1903. 1903. 1903. 1903. 1903. 1903. 1903. 24 LIBBABY OF 0ONGBE88 1903. Mr. Balfour and economic fact. J. S. Mann. Contemporary review, vol. #4 {Oct., 1903): $9-483. 1903. The trade of the empire. Mark Warren. Contemporary review, vol. 84 [Oct., 1903): .'^.'f-497. 1903. Free trade and protection. Jehangir C. Coyaji: East and west, vol. 2 {Oct., 1903): llU-1119. 1903. The confessions of an eccentric free trader. East and west, vol. 2 {Oct., 1903): 1169-1177. 1903. Some advantages of preferential tariffs. I. Increased exports and higher wages. Albert Swindlehurst. II. Commercial prosperity in Ireland. F. St. John Morrow. III. Effect on Canada. Sir Charles Hibbert Tapper. Empin review, vol. 6 {Oct., 1903): %l-262. 1903. The unionist plunge into protection. Autonomos. Fortnightly review, n. s., ml. 7J+ (Oct. 1, 1903): 555-561. 1903. The fiscal problem. 1. The present state of the case for Mr. Chamberlain's policy. W. A. S. Hewins. II. Sir Robert Feel and Mr. Chamberlain: 1845-1903: a contrast. Harold Spender. III. Will a preferential tariff oppress the poor? David Christie Murray and J. W. Atkinson. Fortnightly review, n. s., vol. 74 (Oct. 1, 1003): 590-626. 1903. Colonial preference. Edwin Carman. Independent review, vol. 1 {Oct., 1903): 39-51. 1903. Protection and the steel trade. Hugh Bell. Independent review, vol. 1 (Oct.. 1903): 52-73. 1903. English and American tariff experience. TnstituU of social economics. Lectin-' bulletin, vol. 7 {Oct. 15, 1903): 17-32. 1903. L'iinperialisme economique en Angleterre. Paul Beauregard. Mond economique, 13' annet (Oct. in. 1903): 449-451. 1903. Mr. Chamberlain's fiscal policy. Sir Edward Grey. Monthly review, rot. 13 (Oct.. 1U03): 11-25. 1903. Preference and retaliation. Lord Hugh Cecil. Monthly review, vol. 13 {Oct. ^ 1003): 26-37. 1903. Canada, the empire, and Mr. Chamberlain. Gold win Smith. Monthly review, vol. 13 {Oct., 1003): 38-5/+. 1903. Chamberlain's motive. M. J. Bonn. Nation {Berlin),%l. Jahrgang (Oct. 10, 17,24, 1003): 22-21+; $-43; 52-55. 1903. Protection and the ^t' (Nor., 1903): 307-399. 1903. Mr. Balfour's economic notes. Yves Guvot. Monthly review, vol. 13 (Nov.. 1903): 1-8. IV, LIBRARY OF CONGRESS ■ 1903. La these de M. B:ilt'<»ur. Yves G-uyot. Monthly review, vol. 13 (Nov., 1903): 9-16. 1903. Sheffield and its shadow. Winston S. Churchill. Monthly review, vol. 13 (Nov., 1903): 17-31. 1903. The policy of imperial preference. Joseph Chamberlain. National review, vol. $ (Nov., 1903): 351-370. Living age, vol. 239 (Dec. U. 1903): 61,1-655. 1903. The electorate and the tariff tempation. J. Ramsay Mac- donald. New liberal review, vol. 6 (Nov., 1903): 436-4^8. 1903. Mr. Chamberlain's scheme. Benjamin Taylor. Nineteenth century view, vol. 96 {Nov. U, 1903): 603-601,. 1903 Preferential tariffs or as we are. Saturday review, vol. 96 (Nov. 21, 1903): 632-633. 1903. Protection and character. Speaker, n. 8., vol. 9 (Nov. 7, 1903): 127-128. 1903. The fiscal campaign. Speaker, n. 8., vol. 9 (Nov. 14, 1903): Supplement. Contains extracts from speeches by John Morley and Joseph Cham- berlain, with a diary of the fiscal campaign, November 4-10. 1903. Mr. Chamberlain's fiscal fallacies. Spectator, vol. 91 (Nov. 28, 1903): 911,-916. 1903. A plea for absolute free trade. Leonard M. Burrell. Westminster review, vol. 160 (Nov., 1903): 1,77-499. 1903. Commercialism and imperialism: I. External trade. II. Arti- ficial regulation of trade. John George Godard. Westminster review, vol. 160 (Nov.. 1903): 506-521; (Dec, 1903): 621-639. BRITISH TARIFF MOVEMENT: ARTICLES IN PERIODICALS 1903. 1903. 1903. 1903. 1903. 1903. 1903. 1903. 1903. 1903. 1903. 1903. 1903 1903. 1903. 1903. 1903. C. Kinloch Mr. Chamberlain's scheme. Lucien Wolf. World to-day, vol. 5 {Nov., 1903): 11,15-lJfiO. Mr. Chamberlain's case and the answer. World's work (London), vol. 2 {Nov., 1903): 576-58.',. Canada and Mr. Chamberlain: a symposium. John Charlton, Chancellor Wallace, Professor Shortt, Sir Thomas Shaugh- nessy, W. C. Nichol, R. P. Roblin. Canadian magazine, vol. 22 (Dec, 1903): 130-137. Canada and the new imperialism. E. Farrer. Contemporary review, vol. 84 (Bee., 1903): 76 1-77 J,.. Preferential tariffs and Canadian interests. A. W. Flux. Economic journal, vol. 13 (Dee., 1903): 469-485. The economic possibilities of an imperial liscal polic} r . L. L. Price. Economic journal, vol. 13 (Dec., 1903): 486-504. India and preferential tariffs. C. A. Elliott. Empire review, vol. 6 (Dec, 1903): 465-4:73. Imperial tiscal union: trend of colonial opinion. Cooke. Empire review, vol. 6 (Dec, 1903): 4^4-4^6. The myth of the big and little loaf. W. H. Mallock. Fortnightly review, n. s., vol. 74 (Dec, 1903): 893-909. Mr. Balfour and retaliation. G. Shaw Lefevre. Fortnightly review, n. s., vol. 74 (Dec, 1903): 941-955. The free trade revolt in England. J. R. Bishop. International quarterly, vol. 8 (Dec, 1903): 405-417. The daughters of the house. W. P. Reeves. Monthly review, vol, 13 (Dec, 1903): 33-49. Authority for a closer union with the colonies. more. National review, vol. 42 (Dec , 1903) : 553-562. The economics of empire. II. Preference and the food supply. National review, vol. 42 (Dec , 1903) : Special supplement, 1-62. Mr. Chamberlain wins. Outlook (London), vol, 12 (Dec. 19, 1903): 585-586. Dulwich and Lewisham. Public opinion (London), vol. 84 (Dec 18, 1903): 773-775. Ireland and the fiscal question. Saturday review, vol. 96 (Dec 12, 1903) : 724-725. C. A. Whit- LIBRARY OF 0ONGEE88 1903. More fiscal fallacies. II. Quelch. Social-Democrat^ vol. ? {Dec. 15, 1903): 715-720. 1903. Protection and reform. Speaker, n. «., vol. '■> {/>>>: 19, 1903): 289-290. 1903. Points from speeches. Sir William Harcourt, Lord Rosebery, Sir Edward Grey, Herbert ELAsquith, Edmund Robertson. Speaker, n. 8., vol. 9 (Dec. 19, 1903): Supplement, 3. 1903. Hew to save the free-trade unionist seats. Spectator, vol. 91 {Dec. 12,1903): 1012-1013; {Dec. 19,1903): 1075-1076. 1903. Mr. Chamberlain's speech and the by-elections. Spectator, vol. 91 {Dec. 19, 1903): 1068. 1903. Mr. Chamberlain and Mr. Balfour. Spectator, vol. 91 {Dec 26, 190.}): 1116-1117. 1904. The main features of the present foreign trade of the United Kingdom. Solomon Huebner. Aim rican academy of political and social science. Annals, vol. 23 (Jan., 1904): 84-104. 1904. The development of Mr. Chamberlain's fiscal policy. Thomas W. Mitchell. American academy of political and social science. Annals, vol. 23 (Jan., 1904): 10-5-120. 1904. Chamberlain at Cardiff. American economist, vol. 33 (Jan. 1, 1904): 8-10. 1904. A letter from England: the issue of protection. R. Brimley Johnson. Atlantic monthly, vol. 93 (Jan., 1904): 14.1-2 '4 '/■ 1904. The fiscal controversy: discussion at the Bankers 1 institute. Banker s magazim (London), vol. 77 (Jan.. 1904): 49-56. 1904. Richard Cobden. Ill, ol,-, mud's Edinburgh magazine, vol. 175 (Jan. , 1904) : 1$- 149. 1904. Mr. Chamberlain's campaign. Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, vol. 17-5 (Jan.. 1904): 150- 151).. 1904. Canada and the Chamberlain movement. J. W. Longley. Canadian magazine, vol. .'.'{Jan.. 1904): 833-236. 1904. Professor Ashley and the tariff problem. J. M. McEvoy. Canadian magazine, vol. 22 (Jan., 1904): 237-^42. 1904. Is free trade a fallacy \ R. E. Macnaghten. Economic review, vol. 14 (J"". 15. 1904): 23-3*. BRITISH TARIFF MOVEMENT! ARTICLES IN PERIODICALS 29 1904. The failure of free-traders to attain their ideal. W. Cun- ningham. Economic review, vol. Up {Jan. 15, 190 If): 39-53. 1904. Fiscal allusions. Ernest Foxwell. Empire review, vol. 6 (Jan., 190 If): 577-587. 1904. Imperial fiscal union: trend of colonial opinion; the Ottawa conference on preference. C. Kinloch Cooke. Empire review, vol. 6 (Jan., 190 If): 588-600. 1904. The known and the unknown in Mr. Chamberlain's policy. A. C. Pigou. Fortnightly review, n. s., vol. 75 (Jan., 1901f): 36-IfS. 1904. India and preferential tariffs: from the Indian point of view. Sir Roper Lethbridge. Imperial and Asiatic quarterly review, 3d ser., vol. 17 (Jan., 1901f): 1-16. 1904. Land reform versus protection. Charles Trevelyan. Independent review, vol. 1 (Jan., 190 If): 5 42-55 Ip. 1904. Canada and the Empire. George Peel. Independent review, vol. 1 (Jan., 190.!f): 611-628. 1904. Protection and the wool trade. J. H. Clapham. Independent review, vol. 1 (Jan., 1901f): 61/1-650. 1904. Decisions of chambers of commerce on the question of fiscal reform. Magazine of commerce, vol. If. (Jan., 190If): 51-54-. 1904. Foreign trade and the money market. Felix Sehuster. Monthly review, vol. llf (Jan., 1901+) : 1-33. 1904. Fiseal reform. Charles Booth. National review, vol. Jf2 (Jan., 1904): 686-701. 1904. Cotton, Cobden, and Chamberlain. M. W. Ridley. National review, vol. 4% (Jon., 1904): 799-807. 1904. Ineffectual preferences. Sir Robert Giffen. Nineteenth century and after, vol. 55 (Jan., 1904): 1-11. 1904. The larger basis of colonial preference. Benjamin Kidd. Nineteenth century and after, vol. 55 (Jan., 1904): 12-29. 1904. Why 1 shall vote for Mr. Chamberlain. Alfred W. Pollard. Pilot, vol. 9 (Jan. 3, 1904): 7-8. 1904. The tariff tumult. Saturday n view, vol. 97 (Jan. 23, 1904): 100-101. 1904. Mr. Booth, Mr. Chamberlain, and Mr. Peel. Speaker, u. $., vol. 9 (Jan. 2, 1904) ■ 553-531, . .".ii LIBRARY OF CONGRESS 1904. A more than royal commission. Speaker, n. s., vol. 9 {Jan. .'. 1904): Supplement, 3-4. 1904. The value of the New Zealand preference. Speaker, n. 8., vol. 9 (Jan. 9, 1904): Supplement, 7-8. 1904. Mr. Chamberlain and the city. Spectator, vol. 92 (Jan. 3. 1904): 5-7. 1904. Free-trade and home-rule. Spectator, vol. 9% (Jan. 9, 1904): 40-42. 1904. Need for home trade statistics. Statist, vol. 53 (Jan. 2. 1904): 15-16. 1904. I> Mr. Chamberlain making headway 'i Statist, ml. 53 (Jan. 23, 1904): 146-147. 1904. The fantastic fallacy of an empire builder: a challenge to Mr. Chamberlain. Leonard M. Burrell. Westminster review, vol. 161 {Jan., 1904): 7-20. 1904. The fiscal question and its surroundings. E. B. Husband. \Y< xt in 'muter review, vol. 161 (Jan., 1904): 21-26. 1904. Chamberlain's campaign. E. Morgan. American economist, vol. 33 (Feb. 5, 190^): 68-69. 1904. The position of railway and shipping companies under **pro' tection." Charles H. Grinling. Banker's magazine (London), vol. 77 (Feb., 1904): 211-218. 1904. Free trade, New South Wales, and protected Victoria. C. H. Chomley. Contemporary revieio, vol. 85 (Feb., 1904): 172-185. 1904. The mystery of dumping. J. A. Hobson. Contemporary review, vol. 85 (Feb., 1904): 186-197. 1904. Mr. Charles Booth's proposals for fiscal reform. Bertrand Russell. Conti m porary review, vol. 85 (Feb., 1904): 198-206. 1904. The protectionist idea of foreign trade. W. M. Lightbody. Fortnightly n vu w, n. s., vol. 75 (Feb., 1904): 308-31!. 1904. England's tariff education. Guntorts magazine, vol. 26 (Feb., 1904): 108-117. 1904. La politique de M. Chamberlain. N. C. Frederiksen. Mondt economigue, 1.'/ wnnee (F<1>. 13, 190j): 193-195. 1904. A national tariff for national defence. Nai 'tonal review, vol. 4& (Feb., 1904): 884-895. 1904. Colonial friends and foreign rivals. R. H. Inglis Falgrave. National review, vol. 42 (Feb., 1904): 979-1000. BRITISH TARIFF MOVEMENT'. ARTICLES IN PERIODICALS 31 Leonard 1904 The colonies and Mr. Chamberlain. E. T. Cook. Few liberal review, vol. 7 (Feb., 1901,): 20-32. 1904 Behind the fiscal veil. Montague Crackanthorpe. Nineteenth century and after, vol. 55 {Feb., 190],): 255-266. 1904 Free trade and British shipping. W. H. Renwick. Nineteenth, century and after, vol. 55 (Feb., 1901,): 323-335. 1904 Why I shall not vote for Mr. Chamberlain. R. F. Cholmeley. Pilot, vol. 9 (Feb. 6, 1901,): 137-138. 1904. Le mouvement protectionniste en Angleterre. H. Rhein. Beforme economique, 13" annee (Feb. 28, 190$: 272-271,. 1904. The rout of the protectionists: a forecast of the coming gen- eral election. Review of reviews (London), vol. 29 (Feb., 1901,): 131^137. 1904 L/imperialisine anglo-saxon. N. Colajanni. Revue socialiste, vol. 39 (Feb., 1901,): 205-230. 1904 Free trade and interference with labour. Saturday review, vol. 97 (Feb. 20, 1901,): 226-227. 1904. Mr. Balfour, the fiscal problem and England's fate. M. Burrell. Westminster review, vol. 161 (Feb. , 1901,) : 161-177. 1904. British tariff commission. E. Morgan. American economist, vol. 33 (Mar. 1,, 1901,): 116-117. 1904. The fiscal question and the money market. W. R. Lawson. Banker's magazine (London), vol. 77 (Mar., 1901,): 361,-380. 1904. " Have you no opinion of your own? " Augustine Birrell. Contemporary review, vol. 85 (Mar., 1901,): 323-326. 1904. The argument for preference. William J. Ashley. Economic journal, vol. 11, (Mar., 1901,): 1-10. 1904. The fiscal question and the experience of the Austro-Hungarian empire. Leo Petritsch. Economic journal, vol. 11, (Mar., 1901,): 21,-26. 1904. Pure theory and the fiscal controversy. A. C. Pigou. Economic journal, vol. 11, (Mar., 1901,): 29-43. 1904. Mr. Chamberlain's future. Fortnightly review, n. s., vol. 75 (Mar. 1, 1904): 1,1^-1^9. 1904. The fiscal question— a bird's-eye view. Charles Follett. Fat nightly review, n. s., vol. 75 (Mar. 1, 190',): 1,60-1,70. Favorable to Mr. Chamberlain's policy. 1904. Dumping. Hugh Bell. Independent review, vol. 2 (Mar., 1901,): 211,-231. 32 LIBRARY <>F (<>N'>■!■ mui,', {Mar. 15, 1904): 321-340. 1904. Tht' favoured foreigner: a comparison in burdens. H. J. Tennant. Monthly review, vol. 14 {Mar., 1904): 37-61. "I have endeavoured to 'leal with the three propositions with which we set out: (1) That there is no inconsistency in a defence of free imports and a belief in the wisdom and necessity of our industrial laws; (2) That foreign workmen are in many material respects as carefully sheltered from industrial abuses as British workmen, and in certain others more fully secured; and (3) That protective laws produce a higher standard of workmen and an increased efficiency of work, from which we may rather look for economic gain than increased cost of production." 1904. Some reflections on the fiscal question. Duke of Bedford. National i'-' Beer, M 17 Bell, Hugh 21, 24, HI Bensusan, S. L - - ' Birchenough, Henry ' •> Birrell, Augustine 31 Bishop, J. R - - - - 27 Bonn, M. J 24 Booth, Charles 29 Bowley, A. L Bran.l, R. II --- 16 Brassey, Lord ' Brentano, Lujo 21 Bright, John, ed 8 Broadhurst, Henry 20 Brown, Edward 23 Burns, John 12, 25 Burrell, Leonard M 23, 26, 30, 31 Buxton, Sydney 8 Bvles, Sir J< ihn Barnard 8 Byng, G --- 8,16,17,19 Caillard, Sir Vincent Henry Pen- alver 8,15,16 Caird, Andrew 21 Calchas [pseud. ] 18, 21, 22, 25 Caliban, James 25 Campbell, John 32 Cannan, Edwin 24 Cecil, Lord Hugh 24 Chamberlain, Joseph 8, 13, 26 Chapped, F. C 20, 22 Charlton, John Chiozza-Money, Leone George. . . 8, ( !hi ilmeley, R. F Chomley, C. H Churchill, Winston S Clapham, J. H Cobden, Richard Colajanni, X Colquhoun, Archibald R Cook, E. T ( !ooke, C. Kinloch 17, Courtney, Leonard Cox, Harold Coyaji, Jehangir C Crackanthorpe, Montague Cripps, C. A Crozier, John Beattie Cunningham, W Cunynghame, H Dale, Bernard - Davidson, John Dawson, W. Harl >utt Devas, C. S., ed Dicey, A. V Dicey, Edward Dilke, Sir Charles Dillon, E. J Diplomatics [pseud.}. I Si e Wolf Lucien. ) Dolman, Frederick Dowman, James Elliott, C. A Eltzbacher, O - Emmott, Alfred Farrer, E Fell, Arthur Flurscheim, Michael Flux, A. W Follett, Charles Ford, Walter F Foxwell, Ernest Franklin, Francis Frederiksen, ~S. C Free trade union 35 Page 27 9,19 31 30 26 29 8 :;i 22 L9,31 27, 29 21,25 9,20 24 31 19 15,18 29 22 9 23 12 8 22 20, 21 20 15, 16 23 33 27 25 19 27 9 9 27 31 16 29 19 23, 30 9 36 U'TIIOK IN'DKX Page t raskell, Thomaa Penn 9 Gibbins, II. de B. ed 13 Giffen, Sir Robert 15,20,29 Ginsburg, Benedid W 7 Godard, John George 26 Gorst, Sir John K 20,22 Goschen, Viscount L9 Great Britain. Boardoftradt 9-11 < 'olonial office 11 /■',,■, ',,1,1 office 11 Parliarrn nt 11 Grey, Sir Edward 24,28 < rrinling, ( lharles II 7, 30 Guyot,Yves 18, 19,25,26,32 Haldane, R. B L8,33 Harcourt, Sir William 28 Helm, Elijah 7. L9,25 Herbert, Sir Eloberl (i. W 18 Hewins, W. A. S 24 Hicks-Beach, Sir M. E 23 Hillier, Alfred 11 Hirst. Francis W. ed H Hobhouse, Henry 21 Hobson, .1. A....' 12,15,16,22,30 Holyoake, < reorge Jacob 12 Hooper, Frederick 7 Huebner, Solomon 28 Hunt, Lewis 33 Husband,E.B 30 Imperial reciprocity 11 Imperial tariff committee 12 Imperial tariff for 1 (to:; 12 India. Government 12 Jeans, Stephen S 7 Jeyes, Samuel Henry 12 Johnson, R. Brimley 28 Jones, Daniel 7 kViit.C. B. Roylanee 23 Kershaw, John B. C 15, 16 EOdd, Benjamin 20, 29 Knight, William.. 12 Lawson, W. R :; l Lees, Frederic 19 Lefev re, < • . Shaw 27 Leroy-Beaulieu, Paul 22 Lethbridge, Sir Roper 29 Lightbody, W. M 30 Lilly, W. S., ed 8 Longley.J.W 28 Ex)ring, Arthur II 19 Lough, Thomas 12 Lubbock, Sir John 23 Luzzatti, Luigi 26 Page Lyon, Charles is McClelland, James 12 Macdonald, .1. Etamsay 26 McEvoy, .1. .M 28 Macnaghten, R. EC 28 Macrosty, Henry W 7 Maddison, F 17 Mallock, William Hurrell.. L2, 15, 23, 27 Mann, .1. S. 24 Martineau, < re< »rge 16 Massingham, II. W., ed 12 Maxey, Edwin 25 Maxwell, Herbert 17.21 Meredith, II. 33 Mr. Chamberlain's proposals 12 Mitchell, Thomas W 28 Molesworth, Sir Guilford 1 13 Mongredien, Augustus 13 Morgan, E . •"><>. 31 Morley, John 26 Morrow, F. St. John 24 Murray, 1 »avid Christie 24 Nash, Rosalind 12 Nelson, Henry Loomis 22 Neville, Ralph 19 Xichol, W. C 27 O'Brien, M. D 32 O'Reilly, T. E 12 Palgrave, R. II. Inglie 30 Parker, Sir < rilbert 17, 21 Patterson, Sir R. Lloyd 7 Pearson, C. Arthur 33 Peel, George 29 Perris, ( reorge Herbert 13 Petritsch, Leo 31 Phelps, L. R 18 Phillips, Lionel 23 Pigou, A. C 13, Id, 29, 31 Pollard, Alfred W 29 Pollock, A. W. A 17, 21 Pope, J. Buckingham 13 Price, L. L 25, 27 Quelch, H . 28 Reeves. W. P 27 Renwick, W. H 31 Rhein, II 31 Ridley, M. W 29 Roberts, Paul E 33 Robertson, Edmund 28 Roblin, R. P 26, 27 Rogers, James E. Thorold, ed 8 Root, J. W 13, 20, 22 Roscoe, H. E 15 AUTHOR INDEX 37 Page Rpsebery, Lord 28 Ross, George W 22 Rowland, Percy F 21 Rowntree, E. Seebohm 12 Russell, Bertram! 30 Salm< »n, Edward 16 Sassoon, Edward 32 Scanlan, John F 22 Schooling, J. Holt 15 Schuster, Felix 29 Scrutator [pseud. ] 16, 17 Shaughnessy, Sir Thomas 27 Shortt, Professor 27 Sinceny, P - 26 Smith, George Armitage- 13 Smith, Goldwin 24 Spender, Harold 24 Spender, J. A 19, 22 Swindlehurst, Albert 17,24 Taylor, Benjamin 17, 20, 21, 26 Page Tennant, H. J 32 Thompson, Robert Ellis 22 Thring, Lord 32 Trevelyan, Charles 29 Tupper, Sir Charles Hibbert 24 United States. Bureau of Statistics ( Treasury Department) 13 Yince, Charles Anthony 13 Wall, Walter W 24 Wallace, Chancellor 27 Warren, Mark 24 Welby, Lord 18 Whitmore, C. A 27 Williams, Ernest E 9, 21 Willoughby, F. S 14 Wilson, H. W 14, 21 Wise, B. R 32 Wolf, Lucien 18, 27 Yoxall, J. PI 21 Zolla, D 21 O BERKELEY THIS BOOK IS DUE ON THE LAST DATE STAMPED BELOW Books not returned on time ar^su-tajeCt to a fine of 50c per volume after the third day overdue, increasing to fl.00 per volume after the sixth day. Books not in demand may be renewed if application is made before expiration of loan period. MAR 7 1930 * «••> FEB 9 Jul'52M JUN2 5K 4Nor56rt-JI LJ LD OCT 21 1956 i3Aug'&eeG i3iisn 50w-7,'29