I'll I i ! iii ilii i i II i M * LIBRARY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA. I Electric Furnaces and their Industrial Applications ELECTRIC FURNACES AND THEIR INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS J. WRIGHT it WITH 57 ILLUSTRATIONS or THE ^ UNIVERSITY NEW YORK THE NORMAN W. HENLEY PUBLISHING CO 132 NASSAU STREET wg- INTRODUCTION THE development of the electric furnace, and the various industries with which it is associated, as a necessary auxiliary to the processes involved, is making vast strides, and is regarded with ever-increasing interest by the electro- chemist and metallurgist, who see in it possibilities, far beyond those offered, until some few years back, by the blast furnace on a commercial scale, and the oxy-hydrogen flame in the laboratory. The limitations of temperature imposed by the methods available prior to the introduction of electricity as a heating agent, were such as to render commercially impossible many of the processes now % carried out by its aid. On the other hand, the introduction of the electric furnace with its vast possibilities in the field of exceedingly high tempera- tures, gave rise at first to misuse of the power available ; i.e. the temperatures required for the various reactions were over, rather than under estimated, and, as a result, the sub- stances which should have 'been produced by the furnace were again split up into constituent elements, or built up into compounds other than those which it was originally intended to produce. Many of the early failures were due to this cause, especially in furnaces of the "arc" type y but experience has taught the usual lesson, and it is now possible to regulate the temperature of an electric furnace within far narrower limits than is possible with furnaces of the ordinary type, consuming coke and coal fuel. There is hardly an electro-metallurgical process to which the electric furnace has not been applied, either experi- INTRODUCTION mentally, or on a commercial scale, and, though many of the experimental attempts have, thus far, proved abortive, the success of the remainder justifies the hope that perseverance, aided by the incentive to progress in the shape of much valuable material, such as low-grade ores, so-called " waste products," etc., at present unworkable, may lead to increased research in this promising field, in which it is fairly safe to predict that the indefatigable worker will not go unrewarded. The introduction of acetylene gas for illuminating purposes, has of course, been responsible for the great advance in the carbide industry, which at present con- stitutes the largest branch of electric furnace work, although at one time the boom, and consequent over production, threatened ruin to many works. So great, in fact, was the reaction consequent upon an overstocked market, that many factories possessing furnaces and plant for the manufacture of calcium carbide, turned their atten- tion to other substances, which, with a little adaptation, their furnaces could be made to produce. Alloys of the ferro-chrome type are amongst the substituted products, being largely used in hardening armour plates, etc. Electric smelting furnaces for the reduction of iron and other ores to the metallic state, have also provided a subject for extensive research, with no small measure of success, it having been found possible to apply the electric smelting process in many cases where the blast furnace, either from scarcity of fuel or similar causes, was out of the question. It is naturally impossible at the present stage of our knowledge concerning the generation of electrical energy from coal and other fuels, for the electric smelting furnace to compete with smelting furnaces using fuel direct, but there are many instances in which the electrical process can be introduced with advantage, and a fair promise of profit to the metallurgist. Metalliferous ores frequently abound in localities where fuel of any description is scarce, but water power plentiful ; INTRODUCTION in such cases, a hydro-electric generating plant, though expensive to instal, frequently provides a ready way out of the difficulty. Water power has, in fact, been the salvation of the electro-chemical and electro-metallurgical industries which for the greater part involve a vast expenditure of power within a comparatively small compass. Hence we find almost all the large works concerned in the foregoing, allied industries, confined to America and the Continent, and frequently to localities where fuel is comparatively scarce but water power plentiful. Niagara, with its 50,000 H.P. derived from the celebrated Falls, is a case in point, and it is worthy of note that by far the greater proportion of this huge power is utilized in the two industries enumerated above. It is unnecessary to enlarge further, at this point, upon the many applications of the electric furnace in modern in- dustry, in that the various processes will be alluded to iifc connexion with the several furnaces to be described later, There is also a type of furnace which the author proposes to include in this work, with the object of rendering it complete, and that is the electrolytic type. Although not, strictly speaking, furnaces, in the ordinary acceptation of the term, there are several forms of apparatus which depend for their action on a combination of thermal, electrolytic, and chemical effects. Since the office of the furnace proper, viz., that of heating the raw materials, is an essential auxiliary in such cases, it has been resolved to include them in the pages which follow, the necessary line of demarcation between a thermal and an electrolytic process pure and simple being determined by the presence of an aqueous solution. Only such methods and apparatus will be dealt with as involve the presence of a fused electrolyte. Several of the types of electric furnace construction, de- scribed in detail in the pages which follow, have never pro- gressed beyond the experimental stage. Their descriptions are included with a view to showing the extraordinary INTRODUCTION amount of ingenuity which has been expended upon electric furnace design, with a view to rendering them efficient, and, as far as possible, automatic in action. It is this very ingenuity, entailing a certain elaboration of detail which has militated against the commercial success of several very promising furnace inventions. To put the matter in a nutshell, the aspiring designers of some electric furnaces have attempted to apply principles of construction and operation comparable with the delicate mechanism and controlling principles of the self -regulating arc lamp. It is obviously a mistaken feature in electric furnace design, this elaboration of detail. In an apparatus whose parts may be, and frequently are, subjected to extremely high temperatures, it is necessary that every part shall possess stability, in order to resist the destructive tendency of such great heat, a stability which the nature of some of these inventions, renders impossible of attainment. The illustrations in this book are essentially in the nature of sectional diagrams, representing " principles of construc- tion " rather than views of the objects as they actually appear to the observer. Photographs of the majority of electric furnaces would convey little or no information to the reader ; a mass of brickwork, with perhaps some iron plates ; a series of heavy cables leading in ; and one or two flues for carrying off the gaseous products : that is all. J. W. viii SUMMARY OF CONTENTS SECTION I PAGES HISTORICAL AND GENERAL 1-20 SECTION II ARC FURNACES ....... . . 21-26 SECTION III RESISTANCE FURNACES AND TYPICAL PROCESSES . . 27-57 SECTION IV CALCIUM CARBIDE MANUFACTURE . . . 58-106 SECTION V IRON AND STEEL PRODUCTION IN THE ELECTRIC FURNACE 107-164 SECTION VI PHOSPHORUS MANUFACTURE IN THE ELECTRIC FURNACE . 165-169 SECTION VII GLASS MANUFACTURE IN THE ELECTRIC FURNACE . 170-175 SUMMARY OF CONTENTS SECTION VIII PAGES ELECTBOLYTIC FURNACES AND PROCESSES . . . 176-213 SECTION IX MISCELLANEOUS ELECTRIC FURNACE PROCESSES . 214-220 SECTION X LABORATORY FURNACES AND EXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH 221-234 SECTION XI TUBE FURNACES * . . . . . . 235-245 SECTION XII TERMINAL CONNEXIONS AND ELECTRODES . . . 246-256 SECTION XIII EFFICIENCY AND THEORETICAL CONSIDERATIONS . 257-264 SECTION XIV MEASUREMENT OF FURNACE TEMPERATURES 265-283 f\8 R A OF THE { UNIVERSITY } SECTION I HISTORICAL AND GENERAL Definition. Strictly speaking, an electric furnace is an apparatus for bringing about a physical or chemical change in materials by the aid of heat obtained from the transforma- tion of electrical energy. There is, however, another class of apparatus, which the writer has seen fit to include, under the title " Electrolytic Furnaces," in which the action is in part electro-thermal, as in the electric furnace pure and simple, and, for the rest, electrolytic. This class of furnace is mainly employed for the electrolysis of fused salts, as, for instance, in the manufacture of aluminium, where heat is a necessary auxiliary if the requisite fusion of the electro- lyte is to be maintained. Historical. As early as 1853 a form of arc furnace con- struction, devised by Pichon, was described in the Practical Mechanics' Journal. It consisted of a series of arcs, set up between electrodes of large size, and through the several independent heat zones of which, metallic ores, mixed with carbon, were passed, with the object of reduction. There is no record of such a furnace having ever existed, except on paper. Sir William Siemens may justly be credited with having been the first to suggest the employment of electric furnaces on a commercial scale. For some time (1878-1879) he conducted experiments, with a view to determining the possibilities of the arc furnace as an auxiliary to certain industrial processes, and in June, 1880, embodied the results of his researches in a paper which he read before the then ELECTRIC FURNACES AND Society of Telegraph Engineers. In the course of his experi- ments with the furnace described below, he succeeded in obtaining an efficiency of 33 per cent., and summed up his conclusions as follows : 1. The degree of temperature attainable in the electric furnace is theoretically unlimited. 2. Fusion may be effected in a perfectly neutral atmo- sphere. 3. Furnace operations can be carried on in a laboratory, FIG. l. without much preparation, and under the eye of the operator. 4. The limit of heat practically obtainable, with the use of ordinary refractory materials is very high, because, in the electric furnace, the fusing material is at a higher tempera- ture than the crucible, whereas, in ordinary fusion, the tem- perature of the crucible exceeds that of the material fused within it. The historical furnace used in connexion with these early experiments is depicted in Fig. 1, and consisted of a THEIR INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS refractory crucible A, of plumbago, magnesia, lime, or other suitable material, which may be varied according to the nature of the substance to be treated within it. It is supported at the centre of a cylindrical jacket B, and is packed around with broken charcoal, which, being a poor conductor of heat, isolates it from the surrounding atmosphere, and conserves the heat developed within the crucible to such an extent that there is very little loss due to radiation or diffusion. The negative electrode consists of a massive carbon rod C, passing axially through the centre of the crucible lid, and free to move vertically therein, the clearance opening being, for obvious reasons, very small. The cathode, C, is suspended from the lower extremity of a copper strap D, which conducts the current from it, being attached at its upper end to the curved extremity of a hori- zontal beam E. The positive electrode F, which may be of iron, platinum or carbon, consists of a cylindrical rod of one or other of these materials, passing up through the centre of the crucible base. The other side of the beam, E, carries, suspended from its extremity by a hinged joint, a hollow soft iron cylinder G, forming the core of the solenoid S. The core G works in a dash-pot P, the tendency of the solenoid S, when active, being to raise it against the counteracting force of the adjustable counterweight W, thus lowering the cathode G into the crucible. The solenoid winding is connected in shunt to the two electrodes. The furnace^ was originally designed by Siemens for the fusion of refractory metals, and their ores ; consequently, once the action is started, electrical connexion is established between the lower electrode F and the semi-metallic mass in the crucible, and the arc continues to play between the surface of the mass and the movable carbon rod C. As the current through the furnace increases, that through the shunt winding of the solenoid diminishes, and the weight W, coming into play, causes its end of the beam to descend, thus raising the cathode C, and restoring equilibrium. 3 ELECTRIC FURNACES AND To Moissan we are, of course, indebted for much valuable information to as the possibilities opened up by the intro- duction of the electric furnace, and the results of his researches into the subject, duly assembled in convenient form in his book Le Four Electrique, are well worthy of careful study by those interested in the subject of high temperatures. Moissan's most valuable researches into the chemistry of high temperatures, rendered possible by the introduction of the electric furnace, were carried out during 1893 and 1894. Many conclusions may be drawn from an exhaustive study of Moissan's work, and those having, or promising to have an industrial importance are well summarized by Blount, in his book Practical Electro-Chemistry , as follows " The stable form into which carbon, whether amorphous, or crystallized as diamond, tends to pass, is graphite. Under ordinary conditions, carbon does not melt, but passes directly into the gaseous state ; if subjected to high pressure, as it may be by suddenly cooling a liquid, e.g. iron, in which it is dissolved, it may be liquefied, and then may crystallize as diamond. " Lime, magnesia, molybdenum, tungsten, vanadium, and zirconium may be fused. Silica, zirconia, lime, aluminium, copper, gold, platinum, iron, uranium, silicon, boron and carbon may be volatilized. The oxides among these substances may be deposited in a crystalline form. Oxides usually regarded as irreducible, e.g., alumina, silica, baryta, strontia and lime, uranium oxide, vanadium oxide, and zirconia may be reduced by carbon in the electric furnace. Many metals which are reduced with difficulty in ordinary furnaces, such as manganese, chromium, tungsten, and molybdenum, may be prepared in quantity. Moreover, in the electric furnace, these metals may be obtained of approximate purity, in spite of their great tendency to unite with the oxygen and nitrogen of the air. It often happens that, when a metallic oxide is reduced with excess of carbon in the electric furnace, a carbide of the metal is 4 THEIR INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS first formed. From this the pure metal can usually be prepared by fusing the carbide with the oxide of the metal. The carbon is oxidized and an equivalent of the metal reduced. The behaviour of such metals in dissolving carbon at high temperatures, in rejecting it on cooling, and in losing it when subjected to selective oxidation, in general resembles that of iron, which is well known. One class of bodies is particularly stable at the high temperatures attainable by the electric furnace to wit, that comprising the carbides, borides, and silicides. These substances are usually of simple composition : SiC (silicon carbide), CaC 2 (calcium carbide), Mn 3 C (manganese carbide), Fe 2 Si (iron silicide), FeB (iron boride), CB 6 (carbon boride), will serve as examples. Some members of the group are extremely hard. Thus carbon silicide (or silicon carbide) is harder than emery, while boron carbide and titanium carbide may actually serve to cut a diamond not merely to polish it, as does silicon carbide, but to produce definite facets. Others of the carbides have another claim to interest from an in- dustrial as well as from a scientific standpoint. Everyone knows nowadays that calcium carbide is decomposed by water and yields acetylene ; but it is not always realized that the property of thus giving rise to a hydrocarbon is general for a large number of similar bodies, e.g. the carbides of lithium, aluminium, thorium, and cerium. Lithium carbide (Li 2 C 2 ) yields acetylene ; aluminium carbide (A1 4 C 3 ) gives methane ; cerium carbide (CeC 2 ), a mixture of the gases acetylene, ethylene, and methane, and a notable proportion of liquid hydrocarbons. This brief catalogue of facts will show how large a field for industrial research exists, and how well mapped are the paths by which it may be entered." Passing record of the earlier researches into the possibilities of the electric furnace as an industrial auxiliary may be gleaned from the Report of the Franklin Institute, July, 1898, on the researches of M. Henri Moissan. The electric furnace utilized by Moissan for conducting 5 ELECTRIC FURNACES AND these researches was devised by him, and is of very simple construction. It belongs to that class known as " Indirect arc furnaces," so called from the fact that the arc itself is not brought into actual contact with the material under treatment, which receives its heat, instead, by reflection from the furnace walls or roof. It is represented in Fig. 2, and consists of two blocks of chalk, A, A, so hollowed out that, when placed together, they form a cavity for the reception of the carbon crucible C, which contains the material to be treated, and constitutes, in point of fact, the hearth of the furnace. Two carbon electrodes E E pro- ject through the sides of the blocks, and meet, with the exception of an arcing space, at a point just above the mouth FIG. 2. FIG. 3. of the crucible C. Electrical connexion with the source of current is secured through the metal clamps M M. Metal bands B serve to hold the chalk blocks together whilst the furnace is active. As a laboratory type, this simple furnace has many advantages ; it is built up of refractory material, and com- prises comparatively few parts, which are easily taken to pieces and reassembled. Furthermore, the centre of activity, surrounded as it is, on all sides, by a considerable thickness of refractory and non-conducting material, can be brought to an extremely high temperature, with very little accom- panying loss of energy. 6 THEIR INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS One of the earliest resistance furnaces or muffles, which depended for its action on the heat generated in a conductor of reduced cross-section embedded in the substance of its walls, was that patented by Faure in 1883. It was intended for the manufacture of sodium, and a sectional view is repre- sented in Fig. 3, from which it will be seen that the conductors c c were embedded in the hearth. One or two later modifications of this early type are described in the section dealing with laboratory furnaces. The commercial resistance furnace is the outcome of the inventive genius of Messrs. Eugene H. and Alfred H. Cowles, who, after numerous experiments, selected coarsely powdered carbon as a suitable material for the resistance core, whilst, at the same time, a necessary ingredient, for the reduction of oxides. From an historical point of view, the following extract from a paper read before the American Association for the Advancement of Science, in 1885, by Professor Chas. F. Mabery, may prove of interest : " A short time since, Eugene H. Cowles, and Alfred H. Cowles, of Cleveland, conceived the idea of obtaining a con- tinuous high temperature, on an extended scale, by intro- ducing into the path of an electric current, some material that would afford the requisite resistance, thereby pro- ducing a corresponding increase in the temperature. After numerous experiments, that need not be described in detail, coarsely pulverised carbon was selected as the best means for maintaining a variable resistance, and at the same time the most available substance for the reduction of oxides. When this material, mixed with the oxide to be reduced, was made a part of the electric circuit in a fire-clay retort, and submitted to the action of a current from a powerful dynamo machine, not only was the reduction accomplished, but the temperature increased to such an extent that the whole interior of the retort fused completely. In other 7 ELECTRIC FURNACES AND experiments, lumps of lime, sand, and corundum were fused, with indications of a reduction of the corresponding metal ; on cooling, the lime formed large, well-defined crystals, the corundum, beautiful red, green, and blue, hexagonal crystals. " Experiments already made show that aluminium, silicon, boron, manganese, magnesium, sodium, and potassium can be reduced from their oxides with ease. In fact there is no oxide that can withstand temperatures attainable in this electrical furnace. Charcoal in considerable quantities is changed to graphite ; whether this indicates fusion, or solution of carbon in the reduced metal, has not been fully determined. " As to what can be accomplished by converting enormous electrical energy into heat within its limited space, it can only be said that it opens the way into an extensive field for pure and applied chemistry. It is not difficult to conceive of temperatures limited only by the capability of carbon to resist fusion." The Cowles furnace made its first appearance in public in 1885, its initial application to the needs of industry being in the reduction of oxides (vide the zinc furnace, in which a graphite crucible forms one electrode). In 1887, the Cowles Brothers took out a patent on a furnace with an arrangement for continuous feeding of the charge. Temperatures Attainable in the Electric Furnace. The maximum temperature attainable by the combustion of fuel, either in solid, liquid, or gaseous form, and under the most favourable conditions for the conservation of the heat developed, is in the neighbourhood of 2,000 C.=3,632F., although Heraeus, in a paper before the German Bunsen Society in 1902, claimed that he had succeeded in con- structing a non-electric furnace, in which temperatures up to 2,200 C.=3,992F. could be produced. He employs an 8 THEIR INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS iridium tube, suitably mounted in a furnace, and heated by means of an oxy-hydrogen flame. The temperature was measured by the aid of a thermo-couple, consisting of abso- lutely pure iridium, and an alloy of 90 per cent, iridium with 10 per cent, ruthenium. Up to 1,650C.=3,002F. a direct comparison was made between this thermo-couple, and a standard calibrated by the Reichsanstalt. Above this temperature the several values were arrived at by calcula- tion. The temperature of the electric arc itself has never been de- termined, the only available data on the subject of such high temperatures being the results of temperature or calori- metric measurements, made on the active extremities of the carbons. Thus, in 1893, Violle tested the temperature of the positive carbon crater by photometric methods, and found it to be 3,500C.=6,332F., and independent of the magnitude of the current producing it, between 10 and 400 amperes. This estimate is only subject to error through a corresponding miscalculation of the specific heat of carbon, and was subsequently modified by the investigator to 3,600C.:=6,512 F., as the result of assigning a slightly different value to this specific heat. It is probable that the temperature of the arc itself is slightly higher than the above figure, which may nevertheless be taken as the approximate limiting temperature of furnaces operating on the arc principle, at atmospheric pressure, and with carbon electrodes. Assuming this to be the temperature at which carbon vaporizes, it is obvious that a limit is similarly set upon the temperature obtainable in furnaces of the " resistance " type, in which a carbon core is employed. Basing his deductions upon an interesting and instructive experiment performed by Moissan, Townsend (Electrical World, April 6, 1901), suggests defining the limiting tempera- ture of the arc between carbon electrodes, as that tempera- ture at which the complex carbon molecule breaks down ; 9 ELECTRIC FURNACES AND and that of the resistance furnace, with carbon core, as th6 true point of vaporization of carbon, the former tempera- ture being distinctly lower than the latter. The experiment referred to as having been performed by Moissan is mentioned in Comptes Eendus, vol. cxix, p. 776, and consisted in exposing to the direct heat of a 2000 ampere, 80 volt arc, a carbon tube having an internal diameter or bore, of one centimetre. The experiment served to demonstrate the volatilization and condensation of carbon, the interior of the tube becoming filled, under the intense heating effect of the arc, with carbon vapours, which subsequently con- densed upon its walls in the form of graphite. Crystallized silicon, placed at the lower extremity of the tube, fused and volatilized, with the result that its ascending vapour, meet- ing the descending carbon vapour, combined with it to form transparent needle-like crystals of silicon carbide (carbor- undum). Townsend argues that, since silicon carbide was formed in this manner the temperature of the vapours was below that at which this compound is decomposed, e.g. below that of the Acheson graphite furnace ; hence his deductions as to the relative limiting temperatures of arc and resistance furnaces as set forth above. The heat intensity, or temperature attainable, in an electric furnace depends, among other things, on the heat-conserving qualities of the materials of which the furnace is constructed. In furnaces of the Moissan type, but lined with blocks of pure carbon, and reinforced, on the outside, with a re- fractory non-conductor of heat, such as chalk or magnesia, it is possible, therefore, to obtain a temperature of approxi- mately 4,000C.=7,232P. whilst temperatures ranging from 2,000-3,500C.=:3,632 -6,332 F.,are easily reached and maintained in the commercial electric furnace. Classification. There are two leading types of electric furnace, distinguished from one another by the method in which the heat energy is produced. They are known 10 ^ \ * B X- V OF THE { UNIVERSITY ) \^ where K is a constant. Thus fl, 2 o~~ If the material outside the core is also a cylinder, with a radius p 2 , a heat conductivity of K 15 and a temperature at its outer surface of 6 Z ,Q = while between the outside of the cylinder of material under treatment and the walls of the furnace, the passage of heat per second is similarly q _ ^ 3 ~ *' Pz or, if p 2 p 3 =t, and is very small 84 Now, since the efficiency of the furnace is 9~? K ' and Mo 03-04 must be kept small to make q small. Graphite and electrode furnaces, however, cannot be made indefi- nitely large, because the last equation shows q to vary directly as the product of L, and p 2 . In the case of the carborundum furnace, the chief equation may be written To make the largest amount of carborundum, K t must be as great as possible, this being effected by having the mixture surrounding the core, of high density, for then the crystal mass formed will be also dense. 261 ELECTRIC FURNACES AND ~ # 3 should also be large ; but the latter is fixed at a temperature just below that of the formation of carborun- dum, while # 2 can only be raised to a point short of its decomposition. As regards the outside of the carborundum cylinder, nothing can be done to diminish k, but 3 4 may be kept small by having a good thickness of raw material always present. Since the value of p 2 increases with the length of the run, a point will eventually be reached where q=Q in the efficiency equation, so that a time comes when no more carborundum is made. To work efficiently, the furnace must be stopped long before this happens. According to MM. Gin and Leleux (Comptes Eendus, 126, pp. 36), the temperature of the arc, when employed for heating purposes, may be computed from the equation where p is the resistance of the envelope of gas, c is the specific heat of gas per unit of volume, $ is the sectional area of the electrodes, t is the temperature of the arc. Expressed in words, this formula tells us that the tem- perature (t) increases directly as the square of the current density, and directly as the ratio of the total resistance of the gaseous envelope to the specific heat per unit volume of the same. M. Gin has since supplemented this formula by others (Elelctrochemische Zeitschrift, May, 1902) representing tem- perature changes and efficiency of the arc furnace, assuming, contrary to the above reasoning, that the medium sur- rounding the electrodes, in the neighbourhood of the arc, is a conductor. They are as follows Let I be the length of the separating medium s diameter p ,, resistance ,, ,, c ,, specific heat ,, ,, based on unit volume. 262 THEIR INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS Then the amount of energy converted into heat in unit time is C 2 R, and the corresponding heat evolved is I /I \ a A\s ) If the arc be surrounded by a heat insulating substance, the equation becomes - f ] pis cist, from which it will A\sJ be seen that the temperature of the arc in the mass, will in- crease in proportion to the square of the current density, a condition which holds good, whether the intervening medium between the electrodes be in a gaseous or fluid state. M. Gin's formulae for calculating the temperature of a resistance furnace are somewhat complicated, and are, moreover, based on certain assumptions, which render results more or less approximate. In applying the following equations, the quantities must be expressed in gramme-calories. Let Cs be the mean specific heat of the core, or other substance, in a solid state. Cf be its latent heat of fusion. Cl be its mean specific heat in a fluid state. Or be the heat absorbed as a result of the chemical changes. P be the weight of the substance passing through the furnace in unit time, when in full operation. Tf be its temperature of fusion. Let Tr be the temperature at which the reaction occurs, and 2 be the total superficial area of the exterior of the furnace from which radiation occurs. Then EJ = M6 [P(CsTf + Cf + Cl (Tr-Tf) + Cr)+K2STr]. From this, Tr can be approximately calculated. Since K Z S is a constant for one type of furnace, it may be written K ; then, omitting CsTf, the equation simplifies down to EJ = M6 [P(Cf+Cr + Cl (Tr-Tf) +KTr]. 263 ELECTRIC FURNACES AND whilst the effective work of the furnace is represented by the formula P[ Cf + Cr + Cl (Tr-Tf)] P [Cf +O+C1 (Tr-Tf )]+KTr, from which it follows that the lower the temperature at which the desired reaction takes place, the lower will be the thermal efficiency of the furnace, whilst the latter will in- crease in proportion to the heat absorbed by the various changes, both chemical and physical, taking place in the substance of the furnace charge as a result of the reaction. 264 THEIR INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS SECTION XIV MEASUREMENT or FURNACE TEMPERATURES It is necessary for the sake of uniformity, as also for purposes of research, and the general advancement of scientific knowledge concerning the reactions which take place in the electric furnace at high temperatures, that some convenient and reliable means be provided for indica- ting, and, if necessary, recording, the temperature at which any particular operation is being carried out. The provi- sion of such means for high temperature measurement is by no means so simple as would appear at first sight. Owing to the extremely high degree of heat which a furnace of the electrical variety is capable of evolving, it is impossible to introduce anything in the nature of a ther- mometer structure into the furnace itself, without risk of its speedy destruction, either by fusion or combustion. The ordinary types of thermometer which depend, for their action, on the expansion, under heat, of a column of liquid are, of course, out of the question, and it becomes necessary to fall back upon some method, which either per- mits the use of a very refractory material in the thermo- meter bulb proper, or, for still higher temperatures, involves a comparison by simple observation, between the tempera- ture of the furnace and that of a known standard, which can be safely manipulated from a point external to the furnace itself. So far as our present knowledge carries us, the only two reliable and exact methods of direct furnace temperature measurement depend upon a portion of the apparatus being 265 ELECTRIC FURNACES AND subjected to the direct heat of the furnace, and their range is, in consequence, somewhat limited. Some very accurate and valuable records of temperature have nevertheless been obtained by their aid. They are both of an electrical character, and depend for their action, the one upon the rise in electrical resistance of a short length of platinum wire, when subjected to heat, and the other, upon the electro-motive force set up at the hot junction of a refrac- tory thermo-couple. Much valuable work in the perfecting of these two thermo- electric methods of high temperature measurement, and the means for accurately indicating and recording the temperatures registered by them, has been done by Profs. Callendar and Griffiths, their various designs being worked out and manufactured on a commercial scale by the Cam- bridge Scientific Instrument Company. No work on the industrial application of high temperatures would be com- plete without a description of these various forms of appa- ratus, and we will therefore proceed to briefly discuss them in their bearing on electric furnace work. Of the two methods of electric thermometry, just con- sidered, the resistance method yields the more accurate results up to about 600C.= 1,112F. ; whilst, on the other hand, the thermo-couple method has a greater range, and permits the measurement of high temperatures in very small enclosures. Its comparatively negligible time lag also renders it especially suitable in cases where a con- tinuous record of rapidly varying temperatures is desired. Reverting for the moment to a consideration of the platinum resistance thermometer, Professor H. L. Callendar, in an article in the Philosophical Magazine for December, 1899, adduces several reasons for its adoption as a practical standard for high temperature measurements, chief among which may be cited the facility for establishing such a standard in any part of the world, it only being necessary to send a few grammes of the standard wire in an ordinary 266 THEIR INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS letter to any desired spot in order to reproduce the scale with great accuracy. A paper by Mr. H. M. Tory, on his investigations into the probable order of accuracy obtainable in comparing high temperatures by means of commercial samples of platinum wire, was read by Professor Callendar before the Physical Society on June 22, 1900. Five different samples in all were subjected to comparison, each wire being directly compared with a pure platinum standard by winding the two side by side on the same thermometric tube. It was found that between 400 and 1,000C.=752 and 1,832F., the fundamental coefficients of the wires varied within 40 per cent, of the maximum value, but that the temperatures registered by them, when calculated on the platinum scale by means of the ordinary formula, did not differ by more than 9 at 1,000C. Curves were plotted from the results obtained, having the platinum temperatures of the standard wire as abscissae and the difference between the temperatures indicated by the two wires under comparison, as ordinates. Within the limits of observation these were all straight lines, thus indicating that it is only necessary to determine two con- stants in order to compare a commercial platinum resist- ance thermometer with the standard, and therefore with the scale of the gas thermometer usually accepted as a primary standard. These two constants are obtainable from observations at the boiling point of sulphur and the freezing point of silver, permitting the construction of a practical thermometric scale, which, between and 1,000 does not vary from the gas scale by more than two or three degrees. In No. 435, Proceedings of the Royal Society, C. Chree treats of some important investigations carried out at Kew Observatory with a view to determining the accuracy of platinum resistance thermometry. Six of these thermo- meters were tested by means of a Callendar-Griffiths resist- 267 ELECTRIC FURNACES AND ance bridge, and no less than thirteen possible sources of error were discovered. Among the principal ones are thermo-electric currents, set up at the various junctions ; heating of the resistance wire by the battery current em- ployed in taking the temperature resistance measurements ; errors in the temperature coefficient for the particular sample of platinum wire used ; insufficient immersion in the substance or space, whose temperature it is required to measure, and excessive time lag, or slowness in acquiring the temperature of the surrounding medium. The effects of insufficient immersion, resulting in heat being conducted away through the leads and external con- nexions is, for commercial work, negligible, though it may, if the total immersion be less than 10 c.m., amount to as much as 0'01C., or even more. The time lag calls for more consideration, especially if the thermometer tube be only inserted in the furnace at intervals, and thus not left continually immersed. The six thermometers tested were found to take from four to five times as long in acquiring the temperature of the surrounding furnace atmosphere, as a mercurial thermo- meter. So important a value has the platinum resistance method of high temperature measurement acquired of late years, that in 1887 Professor Callendar, by dint of elaborate and careful investigations which he then made into the pos- sibilities of this method of thermometry, introduced the scheme of " Platinum Temperatures," or the Platinum Scale, which is a standard for the platinum resistance method of thermometry, just as the Fahrenheit, Centigrade, and Reaumur scales are standards for the previously exist- ing mercurial instruments. These platinum temperatures are obtained from the formula where pt is the platinum temperature, corresponding with 268 THEIR INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS the ohmic resistance R of a given wire, the resistance of which at 100C. and 0C.=212F. and 32F. are Rl and Ro respectively. The researches of Professors Callendar, Dewar, Fleming, Griffiths and others show that this law holds good for all temperatures between -200C. and 1,300C. = -328F. and 2,372F., irrespective of the extremes and rapid varia- tions of temperature to which the wire may be subjected, provided it be carefully annealed ; and that the platinum wire invariably offers the same resistance at the same temperature. So far, however, as the actual variation of resistance with temperature goes, the law appears to be of a complicated nature. Among others, J. D. Hamilton has investigated this subject, and in the Philosophical Magazine for December, 1897, he suggests the formula (R+) 2 = p (t+b), where a, p, and b are constants, and R and t the resistance and temperature respectively. This most nearly repre- sents the results hitherto obtained. The constants have, however, to be individually obtained for each wire by a series of careful observations. Messrs. Crompton & Co., of Chelmsford, in this country, and Messrs. Hartmann & Braun, of Frankfort, both manu- facture a direct reading electrical thermometer based on the platinum resistance principle. The indicator itself, resembles a direct-reading ohm-meter, and consists of two intersecting coils, mounted, and capable of rotation in a non-homogeneous magnetic field. A standard resistance of known value is included in the circuit of one coil, whilst the other is connected with the coil of the resistance thermo- meter. The latter, for high temperatures, is constructed, as usual, of platinum, whilst, for lower degrees of heat, a " nickelin " wire is employed. The scale is graduated 269 ELECTRIC FURNACES AND directly in degrees, and has a range extending up to 1,200C., the highest temperature that can be measured by its aid. For regular and constant use an open scale in the neigh- bourhood of the most usual temperatures under measure- ment can be obtained by a suitable adjustment of the shape of the pole pieces. The current required to actuate the indicator is only 0*03 ampere at 5 volts. Messrs. Siemens Bros, also manufacture a conven- ient form of platinum resistance pyrometer, in which the resistance wire is wound upon a refractory cylinder, and protected, for the greater part of its length, by an iron tube ; being additionally safeguarded at its active extre- mity, which is exposed to the direct heat of the furnace, by a platinum shield. An increase in the resistance of the platinum spiral, from 10 ohms to 44'9 ohms, corresponds with a rise in temperature from 14C. to 1,205C.=58F. to 2,204F. Two methods of reading the indications are provided by the makers, either one of which can be adopted. One consists of a differential galvanometer and a set of resistance coils, which, used in conjunction with a battery, give the required resistance in ohms, the corresponding temperature being read off a scale supplied with the instru- ment. The other apparatus consists of a Wheats tone bridge combined with a D'Arsonval galvanometer, the variable arm of the former being arranged in the form of a circle, traversed by a sliding contact arm, carrying an index which moves over a circular scale calibrated to read directly in degrees Fahrenheit. The use of the thermo-couple for high temperature ther- mometry was proposed as far back as 1826 by the late M. Becquerel. He adopted it for the measurement of the underground temperature in the Natural History Museum of Paris ; an iron-copper couple was employed, one junction of which was situated in the underground area, whose temperature was desired, whilst the other was immersed 270 THEIR INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS in a bath, the temperature of which was capable of regula- tion either by artificial heating or cooling, and could be measured by means of an ordinary mercurial thermometer. A galvanometer was included in the thermo-couple circuit, and the temperature of the bath regulated until its deflection became zero, a sure indication that both junctions were at the same temperature. The temperature of the bath, and consequently of the underground space, was then measured by means of an ordinary mercurial thermometer. M. Henri Becquerel, the grandson of the above, has suggested a more direct method of using the thermo-couple for this purpose, which he designates as the " Sliding Scale " method. A high resistance D'Arsonval galvanometer is included in the circuit from the thermo-couple, and has its scale graduated to read directly in degrees of temperature. In setting up the instrument to indicate the temperature of a given enclosure, such as a furnace, the scale is so placed that the zero or undeflected position of the galvanometer mirror indicates upon it the temperature of the room in which it is placed, and which has been previously deter- mined by means of an ordinary mercurial thermometer. Any subsequent deflection then gives the required tempera- ture of the other junction directly, and without the neces- sity for calculation, or for keeping the cold junction at zero by immersion in an ice bath. In Comptes Bendus, April 28, 1902, M. D. Berthelot gives some very interesting and practical information respecting the calibration of thermo-couples for use in high temperature thermometry. According to him, the cheapest and most satisfactory couple is formed of platinum, in conjunction with a 10 per cent, alloy of platinum and iridium. To ensure regularity in the curve of comparisons, the calibration should be carried out in an atmosphere of air, nitrogen, or carbon dioxide gas. Between the temperatures of 400 and 1,100C.= 752 and 2,012F., the curve denoting the relationship between 271 ELECTRIC FURNACES AND Log. E.M.F. and Log. temperature is to all practical intents and purposes a straight line. M. Berthelot employed, for his limiting temperatures, the melting point of zinc (419C.= 786F.) and the melting point of gold (1,064C.= 1,947F.), the latter being deter- mined automatically by the insertion of a piece of that metal between the elements at the hot junction, and reading the E.M.F. at the instant before the circuit is interrupted by the fusion of the gold. The Reichsanstalt apparatus for calibrating thermo- couples for high temperature measurement is described in the portion of the book dealing with laboratory furnaces. Mr. H. J. Robinson, in letters to the Electrical Review, March 6 and April 17, 1903, calls attention to some of the drawbacks incidental to the use of thermo-electric pyro- meters as at present constructed, and points out how they may be in part eliminated. His experience appears to have been gained in the use of platinum, platinum-rhodium, or iridium thermo-couples, made up of wires "018 in. in dia- meter, threaded through porcelain insulators, and protected by a steel tube, merging, at its outer end, into a water-cooled terminal box. In this type of pyrometer, the primary trouble was experienced at the hot junction, which is effected by fusing the ends of the two wires together. Mr. Robinson found it more conducive to a constant reading, when the ends forming the hot junction are tightly twisted together for about a quarter of an inch, and fused or not fused, in addition, as the case may be. Another source of trouble was the rapid deterioration of the wires, owing to the hot furnace gases entering the tube ; this was circumvented by an extra sheathing of iron steam pipe, slipped over the steel protecting tube, and its open extre- mity welded up. This latter procedure also reduces the trouble consequent on the liability of the platinum to become brittle or " short " with continued usage. In this connexion, he has found heating the wire white hot in air 272 THEIR INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS a number of times, by passing a suitable current through it, to be efficacious. A 120- volt supply was utilized, the current being switched on and off about twenty times, which removed all tendency to brittleness. The wire should be well cleaned before replacing in its mounting. Consequent on Mr. Robinson's letters came a communica- tion from Mr. S. Weiss containing a suggestion that the steel protecting tube, and water-cooled terminals be dispensed with altogether, and the pyrometer mounting made entirely of fire-clay, some 3 or 4 ft. in length, a form of construction which, in the writer's opinion, is impracticable on the score of weakness and liability to fracture. Mr. Weiss further states that such a fire-clay tube may be rendered impervious to furnace gases by washing it over with a mixture of pure kaolin and water, mixed to the consistency of cream. The possibilities of thermo-electric pyrometry are limited by the fusing temperature of the metals employed in the construction of the thermo-couples, and by the fact, recently pointed out by Nernst, that all substances, commonly em- ployed as refractory insulators, become good electrical con- ductors at high temperatures. As we travel higher in the temperature scale, we have to fall back, as already stated, upon other methods, all of which are founded on more or less direct comparison with a negotiable standard situated outside the furnace. One of the simplest and most ingenious of these methods, which is also, unfortunately, limited as to its range of applicability, consists in the comparison, by observation, of the degree of incandescence of an electric lamp filament with that of the heated interior wall of the furnace, an inspection opening being provided for the purpose in the wall of the latter. The apparatus in general resembles a telescope, mounted on a light tripod, and placed with its axis in line with the opening in the furnace wall. A small, low-voltage, incan- descent electric lamp, fed with current by two or more dry 273 T ELECTRIC FURNACES AND cells, or small accumulators, is fitted within the tube of the telescope, the current through it, and, consequently, its degree of incandescence, being regulated by means of a rheostat and switch. The method of taking a temperature observation consists in viewing the incandescent filament of the lamp against the glowing background of the interior furnace wall ; if the filament appear black, or dark, then its condition of incan- descence, and consequently its temperature, is lower than that of the furnace ; whereas if it appear as a white or light line, its temperature is higher than that of the furnace interior. By means of the regulating resistance and switch, the current through the lamp is regulated until the filament, as viewed against the incandescent furnace wall, apparently disappears. This signifies that the two are in an equal state of incandescence, and, consequently, that their temperatures are equal. The actual temperature of the filament is then read off from a scale, previously prepared by experiment, which gives the relation between the current passing, as registered on an ammeter included in the circuit, and the temperature. The range of this ingenious device is limited to 1,980C. = 3,600F. The optical pyrometer has lately been elaborated and constructed on a more practical basis by Dr. H. Wanner. It is being manufactured and marketed by Messrs. Emier & Amend, of New York, and is applicable to temperatures of 4,000C. = 7,232F., or above. The following is Dr. Wanner's description of the appa- ratus and principle involved " The law, as established experimentally, permits at least for a certain group of glowing bodies (the so-called theoretically ' black bodies '), measurement up to the highest temperatures. When a compact body is heated, the rays emanating from the same may be observed by the human eye, and the body's colour will change, with 274 THEIR INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS rising temperature, from dark red to light red, to yellow, and to bright white. This means that at first mainly red rays are observed, to which, at the higher temperatures, the other spectrum colours, orange, yellow, etc., are added, until the rays appear white. " In analyzing the rays by a prism it is found that with the rise of temperature, some single colour, for instance, red, undergoes a rise in intensity, which can be measured progressively with a specially constructed photometer. If we know the law for the mutual relation between the determining factors (the temperature and the light intensity of the single colour, and its wave length) we are enabled to measure high temperatures by the photometric measure- ment of the light intensity of a certain colour. " The apparatus to be applied is therefore a photometer, containing at the same time a prism, to separate a single colour. A spectrum is produced in the ordinary manner with the aid of a slit, lenses, and a prism, from which, by means of a diaphragm, the light of a certain wave length is separated, and the measurement of the light intensity is made by polarization. To that part of the apparatus which faces the radiation to be examined, a small incan- descent lamp is attached, the light of which is used for comparing the intensity of the light to be measured. " On looking through the apparatus one observes the circular field of vision, divided into two halves (like in a one-half shade sugar- testing polariscope), one of which is illu- minated by the small incandescent lamp, and the other by the light of the glowing body being examined. Both halves of the field show red colour. On turning the eye-piece containing the Nicol prism both halves of the field of vision can be easily brought to equal intensity, and on a circular scale the number of degrees are read. The actual tempera- ture is found from a table which accompanies each instru- ment. The temperatures given on the table have been calculated by means of the law mentioned before. 275 ELECTRIC FURNACES AND " The entire procedure is so simple that it can be readily learned by any foreman or intelligent workman within a short time. The whole apparatus is 30 c.m. long, built like a telescope, and can be easily handled without a sup- port. It does not matter how great the distance is from which the measurements are taken, if only the field of vision is properly illuminated by the light emanating from the body to be examined. " The exactness of this new method depends solely on the accuracy of the observer, and on the degree to which the body under test approximates what is called in the theory of radiation, a ' black body.' Errors due to lack of experience of the observer are practically eliminated, for various parties, who have been asked to take measurements, and who used this apparatus for the first time, have obtained the same correct results. The nearest approximation to the theoretical ' black body ' are the insides of the closed furnaces, as muffles, etc., the glow of which is observed through a small opening, which, however, must not be covered by glass or mica during the measurement. The measured temperature is equal to the real one within a few degrees." Another method of high temperature determination, which verges more nearly on direct measurement than the foregoing, is based, in principle, on Stefan's law, which runs to the effect that the radiation from an absolutely black body is proportional to the fourth power of its absolute temperature. By an " absolutely black body " is meant, in this case, one which receives and retains all the heat imparted to it, and only gives it out again by radiation, and not by reflection from its surface. Kirchoff has shown that the interior walls of an enclosure, such as a furnace, which are at a high uniform temperature, behave as an absolutely black body, according to the above definition, and its existence as such is not materially altered by the presence of the small orifice necessary for taking 276 THEIR INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS the temperature observation. Given, then, an absolutely black body, in this case a portion of the incandescent wall of the furnace, it is possible to concentrate, and measure, a certain small definite proportion of the radiated heat, and by this means determine the temperature. The apparatus for achieving this in practice also takes the form of a species of telescope, with an objective of fluor- spar. The latter substance is chosen for this purpose by the inventor, M. Fery, because its absorption of radiant heat is very small, and the consequent error from loss, due to the passage of the rays through it, is correspondingly small. In actual practice, the sensitiveness of the device is decreased by about 10 per cent. The radiant heat thus concentrated by the fluor-spar objective is received upon the junction of a miniature thermo-couple placed at the focus ; the resulting E.M.F. is measured, and, by simple computation, gives the required temperature of the furnace. The lens is disposed for parallel rays, and a diaphragm cuts off all but a certain pre- determined cone, which is allowed to reach the thermo- couple, thus rendering the device independent of its dis- tance from the furnace. M. Fery's apparatus has been standardized by comparison with a Le Chatelier pyrometer, and exhibited an error well below 1 per cent., between temperatures of 914C. and 1,450C.=1,677F. and 2,642F. respectively. Owing to the minuteness of the mass to be heated (less than 1-1 00th of a milligramme) there is practically no time lag, the appa- ratus following quick variations in the temperature under measurement with surprising accuracy. Neither has any diffi- culty been experienced with the zero, which is very constant. The temperature of the positive arc carbon, as measured by this device, was found to be 3,490C.= 6,314F. M. C. Fery has also experimented with a somewhat similar method of high temperature measurement by radia- tion, which is based on Wien's complex law. 277 ELECTRIC FURNACES AND Am T=A, where X is the wave length, T the absolute temperature, and m refers to the maximum energy radiated at a particular wave length. This gives the radiation in terms of any chosen wave length, instead of the total radiation as in the previous method founded on Stefan's law. M. Fery has compensated the complexity of Wien's formula by a method of considerable ingenuity. He reduces the standard radiation to equality with that under measurement by interposing an acute-angled prism of absorbent glass, in the path of the rays. This prism is so displaced as to interpose varying thicknesses. The absorb- ing power of the prism also follows a formula of the Wien type, and is such that the displacement is inversely pro- portional to the temperature under measurement. The latter is thus read off from the degree of displacement of the prism, when the two radiations have been equalized. By this method, temperatures of 3,867C. and 3,897C.= 6,992F. and 7,046F., in red and green light respectively, have been obtained for the positive carbon of the arc. There is thus a discrepancy between these values, and the 3,490C.= 6,314F. obtained by the previous radiation method, and it is accounted for by the fact that carbon does not behave as an absolutely black body at the tem- perature of the arc. As far back as 1858 Balfour Stewart demonstrated that the emissivity and the absorptive power of a body at a given temperature, are equal for any radiation. This is known in England as Stewart's, and on the Continent as Kir- choff's, law, having been independently proved by the latter. By " absorptive power " is meant that portion of the total radiation received by a surface, which is absorbed, whilst the " emissivity " of a body at a given temperature, for any given radiation, is the ratio of the quantity of that radiation which it emits, to the quantity of the same radia- 278 THEIR INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS tion emitted by an ideal black body at the same tempera- ture and under the same conditions. In 1879 Stefan evolved the law which is known by his name, and is to the effect that the total radiation from any ideal black body varies as the fourth power of the absolute temperature. In 1884, a theoretical proof of this law was furnished by Boltzmann, who based his reasoning on one of Maxwell's fundamental laws regarding the electro-magnetic theory of light, viz., that a beam of light exerts, in the direc- direction of propagation, a pressure, per unit of area, equal to the energy in unit volume of the radiations. Following closely on the deductions of Boltzmann, came two laws, formulated by Wien, and expressed by the equations : XT = a constant, or \mT=a> constant, and EwT~ 5 = a constant. The former, which is known as the " Law of Displacement," has it that any monochromatic radiation is moved towards the shorter wave length by a rise of temperature. It has remained for MM. Lummer and Pringsheim to supply the connecting link between theory and practice, which they have recently done, by proving experimentally the truth of these various relations between radiation and absolute temperature. These investigators, taking the mean of several readings, have proved the constant, for an ideal black body to be \mT= 2,940. These two investigators (Berichte der Deutschen Physi- Icolischen Gesettschaft, I., 1903) state the three laws relating to black radiation to be as follows (l)/ 00 EXdX=:0-T 4 (Stefan-Boltzmann Law). (2) AmT=A (contained in Wien's Displacement Law). (3) EmT 5 =B. where EXdX is that portion of the black radiation contained between X and X + dX at the temperature T of the gas ther- mometer scale ; Xm is the wave length for which, at this 279 ELECTRIC FURNACES AND temperature, the emissive power EX, in the normal spectrum, reaches its maximum Em ; m is the maximum energy radiated at a particular wave length, whilst ome, and London. 288 MINERAL TEEHNOLQGY LIBRARY UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LIBRARY BERKELEY Return to desk from which borrowed. This book is DUE on the last date stamped below. JUL 1 4 1990 1954 LD 21-100m-9,'48(B399sl6)476