ffirNRLF B 4 IDS 37 »3 .^^ ^3 ^ro i ^ %i1 ^.-— ' i The Sons of Strength And ivhy the Sons of Strength have been Her cherished offspring ever . . . . . . perusing love ivill shoiv.'" — Meredith, W©S^^QA^ in ^m "' ^^ /^3?^2!^?\ j Strength ^1 f^miii! J. R. P. Sclater |/|m! New North Church vBvvil ^ .^jJiiJiwlAJll Edinburgh S, London '^ Y\ \ Lir^^^^l^M ^**P*^^"*» Anderson Sf Jl 1 /^Sui^Hnl ^ terrier tj4ln TRINTED liY TURNBULL AND SPEARS, EDINBURGH Contents PAGE Introductory Note ..... 7 I. The Call to be Strong . . . • 9 II. The Nature of the Strong . . .21 The Mark of Unity The Mark of the Love of the Real The Mark of Assent III. The Inspirations . . •4' The Companionship The Forward View 55^7o',> Introductory Note The quotation which stands at the beginning of this brief booklet is somewhat misleading : for it might suggest that what follows pretends to be an exposition of George Meredith's " reading of Earth." Even in regard to the restricted points indicated in these pages, no such claim is made. All that is done in them is to sketch some dis- tinctively religious ideas, which are given in Meredith's poems, and to use them as a basis for exhortation rather than for exposition. During the past winter, it has been my privilege to lecture to a Sunday evening class in the New North Church, Edinburgh, on the message of this strong prophet of our own time ; and this booklet is, in part, a by-product of the work then done. This at least is certain, that in the writings of him, who so recently was laid to rest amidst the reverent mourning of a nation, there is much that teachers of Christianity will do well to ponder. For he garments great religious thoughts in fresh language, and emphasises aspects of the right life which we have been apt to neglect. " Faith," we are told, " cometh by hearing." Hearing requires a listener as well as a speaker. And men incline to listen most readily to him whose 8 The Sons of Strength speech is new and arresting. The underlying thought, indeed, need not be new. In fact, it is only because Meredith's chief religious message is old that it is valuable. But the clothing should be new. The Church will do well to heed one whose manner of speech has won attention from so many of the best and strongest of his day. The Call to be Strong " The Kingdom of Heaven suffer eth violence; and the violent take it byforceJ'^ The late F. W. H. Myers somewhere puts up a prayer after this manner: "From the torpor of a foul tranquilHty may our souls be delivered unto war." It is not the least debt which we owe to George Meredith, that he has stirred all who are willing to give him a hearing, to make that prayer their own. He has laid us under this further obligation, that he has impressed upon us the need of strong effort, without por- traying our present condition in a blackness which tends to breed despair. This is a new method of calling to battle. That which is commonly adopted by those who appeal to their fellows to be up and doing is to emphasize the all but hopelessness of things as they are. This state of affairs is so awful, they say, that reasonable men must rise and make an end. Meredith's appeal is the precise contradictory of this. As Mr Chesterton points out, he in effect ^^~-\ I o The Sons of Strength says, "Life is already a very splendid thing. Let us, therefore, make it better : " with this result, that he is at once the prophet of the joy of hving and the herald of life's war. On both these grounds, we hail him as a teacher who can claim a hearing. We are, let it be acknowledged, more than a little weary of our Cassandras, of whom we have had a plentiful crop. At the best, they cause us to underestimate the value of their message, inasmuch as they seem never to see things whole. They are born blind to existing good and to the reasonableness of gladness. At the worst, if we take them to possess the right perspective, they tend to develop an inactivity based on helplessness. If the world is as bad as all that, we think, we may as well ' sit and eat our pot of honey on the grave.' And if we are weary of Cassandras, we are still more weary, with a fuller justification, of teachers who take no delight in strife. The paleness of the right life has been presented more than sufficiently. What we need is colour in the ideal : and we turn with relief to one whose blood is manifestly red, who finds an unconcealed satisfaction in the fact that Hving here spells battle. We welcome him none the less heartily, when we find that his tactics are not solely those of defence. It will be agreed that there is something to be urged on behalf of the plan of campaign advocated by Admiral Sir John Hawkins, of violent memory, when he said that there were two ways to treat an enemy. The first is to say, "Do that again, and I'll hit thee "; The Call to be Strong 1 1 the second (and the right) method is to say, " Do that at all, and I'll hit thee again." When we find a teacher who brings something of that spirit into the moral sphere, we have found one to whose prelections we are likely to give heed. What may attract many to the life-teaching of Meredith, in the first instance, is this manifest battle-energy that there is in him. He loves strength, and welcomes occasions for the use of strength. In the ideal character which can be constructed from his writings, whatever else is lacking, the note of a certain violence is un- questionably present. To him man is " A creature matched with strife To meet it as a bride.'* His delight in the sound of the trumpet's note recurs again and again. He rejoices that for the chosen there is never to be peace, in the poorer sense of the term. In morals, in love, in ordinary circumstances of stress, we find him continually urging on us a series of attitudes, which range from an eager demanding and an eager grasping of the best to a quiet fortitude. In the presence of death itself, he would have us show the same front. When the last shadow had begun to fall upon one very dear to him, it was her " Fortitude, quiet as Earth's At the shedding of leaves,'' that he noted and set in remembrance. If we would have in general a description of the type of manhood that is Earth's chosen, and that 1 2 The Sons of Strength is dear to his own heart, we may find it clearly- exhibited in a familiar passage in Hard Weather — " Look in the face of men who fare Lock-mouthed, a match in lungs and thews For this fierce angel of the air, To twist with him and take his bruise. That is the face beloved of old Of Earth, young mother of her brood : Nor broken for us shows the mould When muscle is in mind renewed : Though farther from her nature rude, Yet nearer to her spirit's hold : And though of gentler mood serene. Still forceful of her fountain-jet/' Inasmuch as he holds that the quality of courageous strength is the quality chiefly to be desired, he naturally welcomes those experiences which tend to produce it. " Behold the life at ease ; it drifts. The sharpened life commands its course." He is grateful for all happenings that come to us from without, that have a " sharpening " effect, all that — "... may give us edgeing keen. String us for battle, till as play The common strokes of fortune shower." Thus it is that in the apparent harshness of experience, he sees evidence of a kindly, and not of a cruel, thought for the children of Earth. He tells us that if we can take his position, emphasising to ourselves the good that comes through stress, and making the development of a The Call to be Strong 13 strong mind and character our chosen life-purpose, no happening will fall upon us, not even the great happening of death, which will contain for us an element of terror. The forest of life's perplexity- contains no goblins that peep and mutter, no ' eyeballs under hoods ' for those who dare. If we are amongst that shining company who are " Hopeful of victory most When hard is the task to sustain Assaults of the fearful sense At a mind in desolate mood," the reward of the banishment of that which, from without, strikes chillness and fear into men's hearts will be ours. Life's terror, he would tell us, is a projection of man's own fearfulness. If this be not entirely true, unless cowardice is taken to cover all sin, it deals with a sufficient range of fact to be well worth assimilating. Courage in the moments of hardness : courage based upon faith in the continuous victory of the good, and in the good waiting to be gathered from all experience : courage, with the discovery of the unreality of the source of terror as its re- ward — these are the words that Meredith has to give us. To them we may well attend. For, certainly, he would be bold who would say that teaching such as this is too well known, and too commonly acted upon, to be needed. Even within the Christian Church, with its great words of God's Fatherhood and of Christ's war- fare on behalf of men, and His call to His followers that they themselves should battle, there is sore 14 The Sons of Strength lack of this same message of buoyant courage. General propositions about the state of a society so diversified as the Church are seldom true ; but it may fairly be said that in many circles definitely Christian there has grown up an alarming fear and distrust of vitality. When a hymn-writer needs to exhort ^'fearful saints" to take fresh courage, when songs of devotion mourn, not sin, but the circumstances of living which are the expression of the Perfect Will, there is clear necessity for a recall to that attitude of joyous acceptance of hardness, which ought to be the natural outgrowth of Christian faith. Fearful- ness, however excusable in many common circum- stances, should be recognized as the mark of a state not yet perfectly sanctified. Indeed, the term '• fearful saint " should be acknowledged to be as paradoxical as " irritable saint." It stands parallel to such a name as " distrustful believer." Not that a man who is wrestling on towards heaven 'gainst the storm and wind and tide of his own fear is not a true and right man; but he would be a better one, and would show a clearer understanding of what Christianity means, if, through his faith, he was able to greet the unseen with a cheer. This sinister dread of life, which marks one type of religious attitude, is seen more clearly when we note the ethical ideal which is implicit in the speech and practice of many Christian people. They describe the good negatively. Their gospel is that the right life may be reached The Call to be Strong 15 inactively. Their method of winning wholeness, in a life full of dangers, is always to play for safety. In any case that is not a very heroic pro- ceeding : but for a religious society to fling up defensive works and to sit cowering behind them spells certain disaster. For the Church is called to the high and lofty place : and what will be its portion, if it becomes afraid of that which is high? Its prospects are as gloomy as those of a climber, who, through fear, can neither ascend nor descend. The fact is that when the Church begins to set forth what a man should be in terms of ' thou shalt not ' rather than of ^ thou shalt,' it is whimpering to the world that it has lost its nerve. At the present time, part of the alleged detachment of youth from the Church may be explained simply on the ground that the most vocal section of the Church, which is taken to be representative of it, is hesitating a doubt whether it is safe to dare to lay hold on life : a thing which our young, although they do not so phrase it to themselves, are most surely resolved to do. When the Christian ideal consists merely in avoidance, there need be no wonder that it is an ideal definitely rejected by the healthiest of our youth. The Church can never keep its hold upon its vital children if it sets up as an ideal a kind of permanent bloodlessness. It will only retain them, if it teaches frankly that the battling and enjoying character, the character of a man who has a light in his eye and a smile on his lips when he faces life, is one worthy of development. 1 6 The Sons of Strength The message of Meredith is needed not only within the Church. It is still more required beyond its borders. If the conception of the right man is given by some religious persons as a man good by avoidance, and not a little dull and futile withal, the conception given by many who sneer at the Church is poorer far. For the ideal of the Church is always strong in one respect : always it involves flesh-mastery by the spirit. Whereas, the ideal of the man in the street frequently involves no such thing. It is true that it has the thought of courage and of honour in it : but both of them are held in a restricted sense. A man need not be brave in hidden temptation to be worthy of commendation. He need have no sense of honour to God — for the matter of that, he need have very little sense of honour towards women. Provided that he does not run away when he is being shot at and that he does not cheat at cards, he has fulfilled the Law and the Prophets according to this teaching of the market-place. One other mark of the complete man, indeed, is added : and in the estimating of character an absurdly disproportionate emphasis is placed upon it. A man must be genial. No matter how true is his core, or how deep his inner worth, he is implicitly banned if he fail in those graces which make him a pleasant and attractive com- panion. Geniality is a worthy quality, no doubt. If we consider the matter, we may be surprised to find how much importance we attach to it in our semi-conscious appraisings of our fellows. The Call to be Strong ly But as a mark of ethical attainment it may easily be overdone. For geniality and graciousness of bearing are a matter of temperament and endow- ment, and are not in the least inconsistent with a good deal of rascaldom. It is quite simple to smile and smile, and be a villain. The Prodigal Son, I make no doubt, was the most popular person in his village ; and many a scamp since him has made assemblies shine. The Sons of Strength cannot always command the gayest laugh. Often, to their own sorrow, they may lack the faculty of easy sympathy. Nevertheless, it is they, and not those who were born popular, who are Earth's chosen offspring ever. The fact is that in this so common thought of what a man should be — a thought compounded of physical courage, honour within limits and social graciousness — it is precisely the quality of strength that is lacking: though, if the man in the street is told that this is so, he will meet the assertion with strong denial. It is exactly on strength that he prides himself. Notwithstand- ing, it is true that he ails here. For, in all his conception, restraint in the chambers of the heart and of imagery is not so much as hinted at. To all who live as if a man might be a proper man, while content to remain the slave of his lower self, Meredith comes with a much-needed word, when he proclaims that a man is a Son of Strength only when he is harmonising with Earth's process for the enthronement of spirit as lord of the flesh. 1 8 The Sons of Strength Still further, this teaching of Meredith comes most aptly to a large class both inside the Church and outside it. In our society, a dismal figure is painfully prevalent, whom we may term the Looker-on. Within his ranks he includes many different types : from the man who is too intelli- gent to consider anything definitely wrong and de- finitely requiring eradication, to the good-natured, but futile, person, who, while sympathising with efforts for the extension of the Kingdom of God, is too inert to do any of the spade-work himself. He is, no doubt, full of good intentions for the morrow : but his morrow is a day that always remains in the future. He and his brethren stand in bad need of the re-vitalising, which a teacher such as Meredith can give. For, while such men do not act in opposition to those who are anxious that things should be done, they prove themselves a dead-weight upon the energies of the world. Although they do not imagine them- selves to be opponents of the forces that make for righteousness, their immobility and inaction cause them to be the most effective kind of brake upon the wheels of progress. Within the Church, for instance, none tends more to the ineffectiveness of the society as a whole, — not even those who stand in direct opposition — than the " apathetic fringe." They not only deny the Church the positive help which they might give, and thus oppose by subtraction, but they become a Laodicean leaven that leavens the whole. For themselves, they are frequently the most The Call to be Strong 19 good-natured persons alive. Their heart, they assure us, is in the right place. They are, unfor- tunately, too busy, or too weary, or too nerye- strained to give any positive help to the cause of Christ. But they experience emotions ranging from surprise to indignation, when they are told that they are a positive hindrance to the work with which they claim to be in sympathy. The worst, they exclaim, that can be urged against them is that they do nothing. To brand them as opponents of Christianity, they expostulate, is to rage furiously and to utter a vain thing. Such men need to ponder that * great and terrible Scripture,' " He that is not with Me is against Me." For the fact is that these, and all like them, are the murderers of the enthusiasms of the Church ; which is a very fearful charge to be laid against any man. For an enthusiasm is a breath from God, which comes to possess a man unto his stirring to do something and to dare something in the brave venture of faith. When a man is caught into an eagerness of this sort, he is caught into greatness for a moment. And all who are inadvertently creating a public opinion, in which enthusiasms are difficult to retain, are by their sins of omission doing their best to annihilate the driving force by which the world grows from flesh to spirit. Such an one will often say that his inaction is of little account ; for he is but one, and what can one do, or undo ? That is the most miserable defence of all. One man may not be able to do much : but all that he can do is all that 20 The Sons of Strength he can do. If he leaves it undone, he is reach- ing his own maximum in the way of omission. A man who makes this defence has forgotten Meredith's strong word that in him who adopts it, we can see the nation dying. Anyone, then, will be bold, who, in the face of all this, denies that the teaching of Meredith, that we must aspire after a strong and courageous virility, is not a word in season to the Church, as well as those beyond its borders. We badly need manhood-. manhood of the sort possessed by the great apostle of the Gentiles, who, in his own person, displayed so signally the type preached to us by this teacher of a later day. Give us men with something of his spirit : men who have the mark of violence in their character : men who have a right impatience of unessentials, and are eager to get things done : men who are willing to take a risk : who are not afraid to be ambitious in service : in whom the old dragon is being slain : who are mastered by that ' devotedness which we account the ultimate in man :' and sooner, perhaps, than even at our most hopeful we dare believe, there will come the dawning of the society of the ' glad eyes, frank hands, and a fellowship real ' of which Meredith so splendidly dreamed. II The Nature of the Strong But it is necessary that we propound to our- selves this question, what does Meredith mean by a Son of Strength? In answer, it might be sufficient to say (in his phraseology) one who loves Earth, — reads her, that is to say, with sympathy and insight, and acts accordingly : trusts her, and therefore does not fear what experience may bring unto him. But such an answer, apart from the difficulties of the phrasing, is too general for us, who love the concrete and the detailed. Consequently, it is worth our while to see if there be not some marks of the desirable character, clearly set forth in his writings, which may help to give form to his general conception. Of such marks we may note three. (a) The Mark of Unity " All things are yours . . . ///>." In the first place, the character at which we are to aim, is one in which, frankly acknowledg- ing that a man has a body as well as a mind, we propose to ourselves completion in respect of 22 The Sons of Strength both. Meredith stands opposed not only to those who would define goodness by negations. He stands equally opposed to the sensualist on the one hand, and to the ascetic on the other. According to him, man is ' blood and brain and spirit.' If he would deny his constitution in any of these respects disaster lies before him : — " Blood and brain and spirit, three (Say the deepest gnomes of Earth), Join for true felicity. Are they parted, then expect Someone sailing will be wrecked : Separate hunting are they sped. Scan the morsel coveted. Earth that Triad is : she hides Joy from him who that divides ; Showers it when the three are one Glassing her in union." Whatever else this difficult passage means, it sets forth clearly enough, that any man who attempts to slay (' slain is no word in Westermain ') any part of his own nature may look forward to trouble. That which the body desires without the consent of the mind, or that which the mind covets, having no regard to the interests of the body, is a morsel which needs to be eyed care- fully. The chances of its proving to be desirable are remote. Separate the mind from the body : let the one forget the intimate companionship, which it has with the other : and there will be wrecking somewhere. In this and kindred passages, Meredith in- dicates that full manhood is not reached either The Nature of the Strong 23 by him who is the slave of his flesh, or by him who crucifies it akogether. The mariner, who permits his ' crazy barque ' to guide him where- ever it would, will break upon the rocks sure enough : but he who lacerates and disfigures the tabernacle of his spirit will bring disaster no less sure. Now, it is by no means clear that these are the days when fulminations against asceticism are most to the point. Probably a little more asceticism in practice would do most of us no harm. Certainly, if in no clear manner of self- denial are we keeping up the warfare between the flesh and soul, we fall pitifully below the level of those who counted the world and all its joys well lost, if so be that the evil in them might die. In many respects, this is an easy day. Some of our acutest intellects are exercising themselves chiefly to make it easier. Our houses, our furni- ture, our methods of travel, our anaesthetics, and all that is ours are being so fashioned, that, physically, life may be made as comfortable as possible. The occasions of physical stress and physical endurance are becoming fewer and fewer: and we are not so grown from flesh to spirit, that a little enduring of hardness in this sort might not be good for us. Very likely the word chiefly requiring to be spoken is the word that calls to some voluntary physical discomfort. At the same time, the propounding of a plan to meet a particular case is one thing, and the statement of an ideal is another. In the 24 The Sons of Strength region of ideals, there can be no question chat Meredith's is not only the right one, biic the loftiest and the most Christian. The great ascetics, says Mr C. F. G. Masterman, have been " the wonder and despair of the world." Perhaps that is true, in that they saw sin through the eyes of Christ, and saw the marvel of glorifying God and enjoying Him — saw it so that no price of wounded body or of solitary soul was too great to pay for its winning. But they are the 'wonder and despair' that they are, because of the clearness of their spiritual vision : not because of the method which they adopted to win the great Good. They are to be reverenced, that is to say, as seers, not as ascetics; or if as ascetics, then only in so far as their practice gave proof of the genuineness of their spiritual desire. That ascetics were splendidly religious and good men does not prove that asceticism is a good thing. Inquisitors were occasionally religious and good men : but the Inquisition was neither the one nor the other. So also with asceticism — though in a very different degree. Our objection to it is that by its means, if the renunciation of earth's joys be complete, men cannot reach the full God-intended state of being — for man is ' blood and brain and spirit.' In this shape it was that God made Him in His own image : and in this shape it is, when the stains of selfishness are removed, that God pur- poses His image in man to stand out clear once again upon this earth of ours. Is it straining the facts to say that the ascetic The Nature of the Strong 25 solution of the problem of the attainment of holiness is not the wonder of men, but the rejected of men, because it is too simple'^. There is a dim appreciation, at least in many minds, that perfection cannot be reached by that method : that it is not the God-purposed path: and that men in adopting asceticism, splendidly heroic though it often is, are attempting a short cut to the Great Reward, in the course of which someone sailing is very likely to be wrecked. It is even possible to believe that if asceticism offered to the mind in man a real solution of the problem of holiness, so great is the desire for goodness deep-planted in the hearts of us, that there is not a cave on all our shores, that would be untenanted to-morrow. The difficulty is that we recognise life's problem as insoluble upon these terms. Everywhere we have to strike a balance between forces that seem to be opposing. The middle way between cheerful carelessness and earnest gravity, between self-care and the care of our neighbour, between flesh and spirit — this it is that is hard to find. But this it is that God calls us to discover. If only the balance would come down comfortably upon one side or the other, our task would be easier. If, for instance, Jesus had said, "Thou shalt love thyself and not thy neighbour," the project would have been simple. If He had said, " Thou shalt not love thyself, but thou shalt love thy neighbour," at least the project would have been clear. But because He says, " Thou shalt love thy neighbour 26 The Sons of Strength as thyself/' life becomes complex. So is it when a man finds himself at once flesh and spirit. The problem becomes not only a problem of strife against tempting, but also a problem of adjust- ment. Neither the one nor the other is to be denied. And the man who seeks wholeness on these terms, is setting himself to a 'stey brae.' At any rate, difficult or not, there is no doubt that this unified view of hfe is the Christian one. There is a very fine phrase used by the Apostle Paul in regard to Jesus Christ. "In Him," he says, " was yea." The great word of Christ, when faced with life and all it brings of joy and woe, was 'yes.' He says 'yes' to the laughter of little children, ' yes ' to the gladness of their eyes : ' yes ' to friendship and ' yes ' to feasting : * yes ' to the beauty and the wonder of the world : ' yes ' to the energy and the vigour of life : 'yes' to marriage. Everywhere, over the whole of life, except to that which in itself is wrong, He flings His splendid 'yes.' It has, however, to be repeated, that those who reject asceticism as an ideal, substituting for it that perfection of blood and brain, which Meredith sets before us, are choosing an ideal still more difficult of attainment than that which they have set aside. That is not the common apprehension : but it is a fact. To live holily, as well as com- pletely : to Hve a man amongst men : to enter into the full relations of living, and still to keep the soul white, this is the hard task. It is a The Nature of the Strong 27 project of which we may speak in Meredith's own words, written in a very different connection : — " She whom I love is hard to catch and conquer, Hard, but O the glory of the winning were she won ! '' But it must never be imagined that Meredith, while he keeps a very watchful eye on the ascetic, leaves any sort of doubt as to the side on which the mastery lies in this dual relation. In his adjustment of blood and brain, the control is with mind. The proper man, according to this conception, is one who lives a full life, but always at the dictates of reason. By a reading of Earth, he has come to a knowledge of those practices which will enable him to be healthiest alike in body and in mind : and, according to his under- standing of reality and its laws, he orders his whole conduct. Thus he comes to be one who dwells in the world as in a glad home, wherein he moves about as master. " Sharing still its bliss and woe ; Harnessed to its hungers, no." Such a position, he maintains, can only be achieved by a race which at once has a highly developed intellect and a proper regard for intellect. He lays great stress on his belief, based on his reading of Earth, that experience is tending to produce a race of clear and strong minds, that can read the laws of physical and moral wxll- being accurately and can frame conduct in consonance with them. 28 The Sons of Strength " Change is on the wing to bud Rose in brain from rose in blood." That is to say, experience is developing virility in the mental sphere, as previously it developed virility in the physical sphere. So complete is the sovereignty of mind to be that it is to be master of the seat of emotion, the heart, as well as of the seat of passion, the body. " First then, nor utterly then Till our lord of sensations at war, The rebel, the heart, yields place To brain, each prompting the soul. Thus our dear Earth we embrace For the milk, her strength to man." It is an attractive conception. He presents to us the thought of a man entirely human, in every tingling vein life strongly beating, but with the impulses of his flesh under the severe, unrelaxing hold of his reason, which is so enlightened by a constant companionship with the real, that nothing that he does will be to the hurt of himself or of the society of which he is a part. It may cer- tainly be objected that he takes an unduly hopeful view of that which intellect can do. ' The rebel, the heart,' will need to do a good deal of ' prompting ' of the soul, along with brain, if a man is rightly to be master in his own house. Martineau in Faitb and Self -Surrender points out how often, in actual fact, appeal may be made to a man's reason to give up habits which are im- poverishing his life and the lives of those about him, with no eflfect: ''but touch the lever of The Nature of the Strong 29 his affections and you move his world." Meredith undoubtedly would not deny the value of an appeal to the emotions, if their impulse was to a course of action approved by reason. All that he teaches is that where there is clashing between the ' heart ' and the mind, it is the latter that must be permitted to take control. At the same time, in his enthusiasm for intellect, he seems to underesti- mate, or at least to neglect, the great part that the ' heart ' plays in bringing men to a right conduct, and, it may be, even to a knowledge of the true. It will probably be agreed that in emphasising unity as he does, Meredith is only giving voice to the thought that is in the minds of most of us. To permit the mastership of the flesh is, we admit, to acknowledge defeat in the battle of life. As for that, our desire is to be able to exclaim, in words which Myers has put into the mouth of St Paul :— *' Well, let me sin, but not with my consenting, Well, let me die, but willing to be whole : Never, O Christ, so stay me from relenting. Shall there be truce, betwixt my flesh and soul." At the same time, we recognise that the ascetic ideal will not work. We are members one of another, and meant to live as such. The joys of human companionship, the ripplings of laughter, the love of a man for a maid and of a maid for a man, — these things are our possessions. It is not only our right, but our duty, to lay hold on life. And the man who tells us that it is only in the endeavour to possess it all, that we can 30 The Sons of Strength fulfil the purpose for which we are made, is tell- ing us that which we feel to be implicit in the fact of things. We cannot but believe that the character thus indicated, strong, loving, human, ^ pure from the night and splendid for the day,' is a character for which much striving and many- prayers will not be cast away, if only, by any means, it may be achieved. (J?) The Mark of the Love of the Real. And ye shah know the truth, and the truth shall make you free. The emphasis which Meredith places on unity is an outcome of the facing of fact. He looks at man as he is, and constructs his conception accordingly. He implies that it is only by adopting a similar attitude that man can become what he ought to be. This, then, let us note as the second element in his conception of strength. He is strong, who not only recognises that he is blood as well as brain, but also has a faculty of facing the thing that is. This faculty will only develop in him who has a love of the real. The quality of fact-facing is one of the qualities, which strike us first in coming to Meredith's writings. In a moment of great sorrow he writes of himself : — " I fled nothing, nothing pursued." He might very well have said that he fled nothing at any time. Those things which were there he acknowledged to be there. Despite his The Nature of the Strong 3 1 invincible optimism, which is an optimism of feeling as well as of thought, he never flinches from the facts of pain, which he sees about him : and he never attempts to hide them in ineffective draperies, as is the tendency of so many loving hands to do. Whatever else his readers may gain from him, they will be compelled by him to look fair and square in the face at the darker facts of our living. In speaking of his own dying wife, in the greatest of his didactic poems, when he is looking with weary eyes to our Mother Earth for comfort, ' for crumbs by the way to sustain,' he writes as one who is steadily accepting the fact that she, ^ his own, his good companion, mate, pulse of him,' was unquestionably taking the long farewell. He states — " Her sentence I knew past grace." Earth's sentence of death he knew and recog- nised and acknowledged : and it was with his front to the real that comfort came to him. The first of his poems which the present writer came across is specially distinguished by a note of clear-cut acknowledgment of shadowed fact : and it was the strong vigour of realisation in this poem that sent him reading further : — " A wind sways the pines, And below Not a breath of wild air ; Still as the mosses that glow On the flooring and over the lines Of the roots here and there, The pine-tree drops its dead ; They are quiet, as under the sea. 32 The Sons of Strength Overhead, overhead Rushes life in a race, As the clouds the clouds chase ; And we go And we drop like the fruits of the tree, Even we, Even so." We cannot read this without appreciating the almost brutal genuineness of it. But in so facing fact, the poet is only behaving as a true Son of Earth, which is, as he himself describes it — "... Mother of simple truth, Relentless quencher of lies." Now, there are those who say that this is the whole of Meredith's gospel ; as if his message ran, ' here are facts : you have the power to recognise them as such : commonsense tells you that you had better do so and act accordingly.' It is maintained that this does not take us much farther. Well, perhaps that is true. At the same time, we need not admit that it is a work of supererogation to remind us that it is advisable to look at things as they are. For willingness to look at fact, and the power of recognising fact when we are willing to look, is one of the rarest endowments on earth. Our sins, our omissions of duty, our squandering of faculty and oppor- tunity — what do they indicate but sheer neglect of fact ? If we would only look at ourselves as we know ourselves to be, and would frankly ac- knowledge to our own minds the loss that is necessitated by our inertia and slackness of spirit, surely the sum total of the world's sinning would The Nature of the Strong 33 be reduced. At any rate, if we faced fact, the devil's favourite suggestion, that we can begin the enterprise of righteousness to-morrow, would fail of its effect. We have had long enough experience of that to-morrow to know that it never comes : that to-day is the day if we will hear God's voice. The faculty that we have chiefly cultivated in these matters is that of placing the telescope to the blind eye ; and a teacher is doing us no disservice who tells us to shift it to the seeing one. But, of course, it is untrue to say that this is the whole of Meredith's message in this region. He makes it clear that there is a difference between the recognition of fact and the realising of fact : between the mere acknowledgment that such and such a thing is true, and the biting of that truth into the mind so that it becomes a motive of action. " Strange^'" he writes, " when it strikes to within is the known." He proceeds to teach us two great lessons in connection therewith. First, that one of the effects of the grief of life is precisely to make the known 'strike to within.' Even his own 'pure white cherry in bloom' became * richer than newness revealed,' when he saw it at the moment of his great sorrow. Second, he teaches us that when truth fairly strikes to within, it brings with itself that which enables us rightly to face it. " And when from my soul I said, . . . smite, Sacred Reality ! power Filled me to front it aright." 34 The Sons of Strength It is true that, in this passage he is thinking of the dethronement of self, which is necessary before a man can put up such a prayer. Nevertheless, the passage also contains the idea with which we are concerned. When a man bares himself to the truth, and permits it to grip him, the act of so doing makes him strong for any circumstances. It is the lesson which Another taught us when He said, "And ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free." A text this for all who are engaged in moral teaching to ponder. Get a man convinced of the great facts — of Sin, of Pardon, of Christ, and of the Indwelling Power — let it come upon his mind one day that these things are true — and behold ! he is set free. It is no wonder that one who understands men as well as Meredith pleads with us strongly to desire to know, and to realise, the thing that is. (c) The Mark of Assent. *' Thy will be done J ^ If we are asked to give two phrases which are specially characteristic of Meredith, we should not err in offering these two — first, ' assent to Earth,' and second, 'the rapture of the forward view.' Both require to be considered, if we would obtain a grasp of his thought of strength ; but only the former can be taken to indicate an element in strength. We set it down now as a third mark. It follows naturally on the facing of facts and the need for realising them, which we have j ust noted. Truth The Nature of the Strong ^^ must not only be acknowledged. It must also be accepted. If, after Meredith's fashion, we pray sacred reality to smite, we imply that we are will- ing to assent to its blows. Our heads are in no sort to be ' bloody, but unbowed.' Whatever reality may spell for us, our eyes are to remain serene : and their serenity is to be that of acceptance. It is very remarkable that, from a teacher so full of fight as this man is, we should obtain, as one of his chiefest words, that which seems to bring him into harmony with those who emphasise resignation. "The sighting brain her good decree accepts." " Accept, she says ; it is not hard In woods ; but she in towns Repeats, accept ; and have we wept, And have we quailed with fears, Or shrunk with horrors, sure reward We have whom knowledge crowns ; Who see in mould the rose unfold. The soul through blood and tears." What he has to say upon the duty of accept- ance of experience coming from without, or at least that part of it which is caused by the working of natural law, is not very far removed from the Christian teaching upon this matter. For — and let it be underlined in our minds — we are not to think of Meredith's message as a non-religious one. He urges upon us no sort of impotent, sullen yielding to the decrees of a blind force. In considering his teaching, we have to bear in mind that Earth, to which assent is to be 36 The Sons of Strength given, is the revelation of the will of ' the Great Over-Reason we name Beneficence.' His resigna- tion, therefore, is the resignation of a religious man ; of a man, that is to say, who trusts in the Power that is round about him, constantly- expressed in the happenings which he is called upon to accept. His teaching is a restatement (in less simple and less adequate terms be it granted) of the older word, * Thy will be done.' It is worth noting that one, who is alleged to stand apart from the main stream of Christianity, comes to us with this so Christian instruction. His resignation, however, it need hardly be said, is not a state of mind in which he folds his hands and allows the external to have its will of him. What he does is to recognise that there are limitations imposed upon us, and that, in so far as we can be active, it is within those limitations : while, at the same time, urging us to be none the less active for that. His anxiety is that we should not spend time and energy, which ought to be given to right living, to bewailing restrictions which we cannot remove, which have been placed upon us in order to act as spurs to endeavour. He has no sympathy with kicking against the pricks. The kind of man who says, * I did not ask to be here : there- fore, I have a right to complain of what I do not like,' would receive short shrift at his hands. Almost angrily, he would fling the words ' assent, accept,' at him; and then, more tenderly, 'read The Nature of the Strong 37 Earth, and assent will be easy when you share in her dream of the blossom of good, and perceive the processes by which she is turning it into fact.' The thought, which he is here pressing upon us, is like some which we have already looked at, semi-consciously possessed by many of our unreflecting best. A man is a right man, it is felt, who goes on doing his duty, ' playing the game,' with satisfaction in the playing of it, despite the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune. Such a man, without grumbling at that which he cannot avoid, proceeds to make the best of that which he has : and all with a smile on his lips. The smile becomes a genuine expression of a contented mind, according to Meredith, if he have enough understanding and love of Earth to recognise that those experiences, which seem at first blush to justify complaint, are the spurrings of a kindly mother that desires her children to grow into men. " Ye that nourish hopes of fame ! Ye who would be known in song ! Ponder old history, and duly frame Your souls to meek acceptance of the thong. Lo ! of hundreds who aspire, Eighties perish — nineties tire ! They who bear up, in spite of wrecks and wracks. Were season'd by celestial hail of thwacks. Fortune in this mortal race Builds on thwackings for its base ; Thus the All-Wise doth make a flail a stafl^, And separates his heavenly corn from chaff." 38 The Sons of Strength To those who are perplexed, not merely by the difficulties which stand in the way of achievement, but by the great facts of bereave- ment and death, he has similar counsel. Death is but one part of the process of the great Bene- ficence to produce true Sons of Strength. In his teaching on this matter, he falls foul of a certain type of sentiment that has crept into the Christian Church. With the attitude which calls the normal difficulty of moral achievement bad names, and looks forward to new conditions in which goodness will be made easy of access, he has no sort of sympathy. The Lord God, he would say, is one God, and His will is expressed in the steep ascent of holiness which we find on earth. Nowhere shall we find the conditions altered. The differ- ence between heaven and earth, if he would permit such a distinction momentarily to be made, is not in these conditions of life, but in the state of the persons living. Those whose w411s are harmonised to the Over-Will are in heaven. Those whose wills are not harmonised, are even now surrounded by ^ eye-balls under hoods, which have them by the hair ' ; and they will find no change in their surroundings till themselves change. With that we ought all to agree. We have, upon this earth of ours, the eternal conditions of attainment clearly set forth. If ever we are to gain peace, we must adapt ourselves to them. They will not be changed to suit our fancy. And we may go on to agree with his corollary from this position, that if Earth is to be called hard names, so is all God's The Nature of the Strong 39 Universe. To speak of Earth, as God made it, as a desert drear, is dangerously like rebuking the Perfect Will. Meredith will have done the Christian Church no ill service if he has helped to banish from its speech phrases which, however pardonable in moments of heaviness and of sorrow, are really cries of unfaith. And how is this splendid power of assent to be reached ^ Here again he gives us an entirely Christian word. It is to be reached by the slaughter of self. In the emphasis upon self he finds the primal source of all the world's fears. If our experience is sore, it is Earth that is wrestling " with our old worm Self in the narrow and wide," with the worm that ' slavers at the root ' of our heart-wounds, to the end that we, being purged of the emphasis upon self, may find the ' well of the sorrows cleansed ' in us. This is the central point of his teaching. It may appear to many, as it does to the present writer, that he confuses selfishness, or self-willedness, with the thought of personality as a whole. Some of his views would seem to imply that any relation into which the '' I " enters is a relation which may be termed selfish — a position which would lead to strange paradoxes. It is by some such straining of words that he says that a freedom from selfishness will deliver us from a desire from immortality, and, therefore, from bitter grief for our dead. But apart from criti- cisms which may be made upon his attitude to 40 The Sons of Strength immortality, we can have nothing but admiration for the force and point and courage with which he has re-phrased the teaching of long ago, that a man to save his life must lose it, and that if he is to be able to say that he lives, he must be able to say that he lives no longer, but that Another has come to dominate him and make him His own. Ill The Inspirations It is one thing to construct an ideal: it is another to live up to it. Systems of good con- duct may easily be fashioned, but the practice of them is another affair. Here we have a character and an attitude to hfe portrayed which is mani- festly of great worth. It is a character which aims at a full Hfe, which loves the real, which assents to the Perfect Will, and works for the purging of self. But what we would particularly be at is how to achieve that character. In especial, do we set forth upon this warfare at our own charges, or are there any inspirations that will be given us ? It is in this region that we turn to Meredith with most attention. For here is a man who for himself won much of the strength which he taught; and we are ever justifiably eager to discover the secret of one who thus, in the noblest sense, succeeds in life. From the Chris- tian point of view what he has to say is specially interesting. For we proclaim that a man cannot win the best by himself, and that it is only reason- able to call upon us to work out our own salva- 42 The Sons of Strength tion, because it is God that worketh in us. Wherefore, we wonder what this man, with a right to speak, has to say on this high matter. Now, one thing at any rate may be stated definitely ; and that is that Meredith does not teach us that we can scale the heights of good- ness unaided. He is not one of those who tell us that man is the sole architect of his moral fortunes. The achievement of worth is a process of co-operation between the man and a Power that is without, that makes for righteous- ness. There are inspirations of which it may be more truly said that they seize the man, than that the man seizes them. Further, it is of much inter- est to observe that the inspirations, which he finds catching him and strengthening him with might in the inner man, are precisely those which religion, understood in the Christian sense, has to offer — namely, the inspiration of the Companionship and the inspiration of the Forward View. (a) The Companionship ** / have called you friends. '^ '"'' Lo ! I am with you alnvay.^^ The most important of the poems, for the purpose of discovering Meredith's intimate thought, is A Faith on Trial. Not that the majority of his poems are other than frankly didactic ; but in A Faith on Trial he is giving us his statement of how he ' came of his faith's ordeal,' at a time when that faith was subjected to the most severe The Inspirations 43 test to which a faith can be exposed — the loss of one who made the world glad to him. In a poem written in such circumstances, with an admitted candour, we should expect to find the writer dis- playing insight at its deepest and most frankly- uncovering the secret places of his heart. More weight may be placed on such a poem, in an attempt to state the author's final teaching, than on a volume written when the known is not striking so sharply to within. It is important that we should note this for reasons which we shall come to shortly. Meantime, we mark it for this, that in the moment of his stress we find him seeking a Companionship. He goes out to commune with the Nature that he loved. " The changeful visible face Of our Mother I sought for my food ; Crumbs by the way to sustain." It is from that companionship, bringing, as it does, into lively remembrance a moment of long ago when the gracious pressure of the ' Great Unseen, nowise the dark Unknown ' had been very strong upon him, that he finds the strength by which he can face his sorrow and come forth conqueror. And here, especially, we are to remember that the Earth, into whose Com- munion he comes, is, to him, the revelation of the Beneficent Over-Reason. This also we must note, that he, on his side, had fulfilled the condition of conscious companion- 44 The Sons of Strength ship, by seeking, from his youth up, that with which he would commune. He found, as we have already remarked, his Friend in Nature. And he deserved so to do. For with delight and expectation he had looked in Nature's face for many a day. The water 'first of singers,' the leaves fluttering together into a pathway of gold beneath sun, the living things, the lark ascending, above all his famous pure wild cherry — these had been the light of his eyes all through the journey. So greatly did he love Nature, that she taught him a new voice of song. Just as Browning forgets to be harsh and breaks into a melody that is pure, when his song tells of his love, so Meredith forgets to be obscure, when he hymns the delights of Earth. For the most part, it has to be admitted his poetry is too much of a metrical version of philosophy. His poetry is the ' vessel of the thought ' : and some may be inclined to apply prophetically his own words to his writ- ings, ' the vessel splits, the thought survives.' He is one who is compelled to teach and chooses to sing, rather than one who is compelled to sing and chooses to teach. His manner of teaching, in Henley's phrase, often requires ' a dark lantern and a case of jemmies.' But when he comes to nature description, he wins the true soul of song. Let anyone who thinks that he is a novelist, who has strayed by mistake into the realm of poetry, turn, for instance, to The Lark Ascending^ and take any of its passages, such as this : ~ The Inspirations 45 " He rises and begins to round, He drops the silver chain of sound, Of many links without a break. In chirrup, whistle, slur and shake. All intervolved and spreading wide, Like water-dimples down a tide Where ripple ripple overcurls And eddy into eddy whirls ; A press of hurried notes that run So fleet they scarce are more than one. Yet changeingly the trills repeat And linger ringing while they fleet, So thirsty of his voice is he. For all to hear and all to know That he is joy, awake, aglow. The tumult of his heart to hear Through pureness filtered crystal-clear. And know the pleasure sprinkled bright By simple singing of delight. Shrill, irreflective, unrestrained. Rapt, ringing, on the jet sustained Without a break, without a fall. Sweet-silvery, sheer lyrical. Perennial." Or let him turn to passages in T^he Bay of the Daughter of Hades ^ or to such prose poems as the description at the beginning of Vittoria^ and then deny, if he can, to Meredith the power of poetry. Not that it is in Nature-description only that he reaches the heights. Love in a Valley stands to prove that untrue. But it fis when inspired by a Nature theme that he most frequently finds his grasp and reach to be equal, and that he is most definitely a singer pure and simple. 46 The Sons of Strength Now, the point we are to emphasise is this : that to Nature, that sets him carolling for sheer delight, he comes successfully for companionship in his day of need, because he has ever been glad to be at her side. He was a man whose heart, despite its battle-loving, rested when he could ' leave the uproar, and at a leap strike a woodland path ; ' one whose own feeling is represented in Woodland Peace. " Sweet as Eden is the air, And Eden-sweet the ray, No Paradise is lost for them Who foot by branching root and stem, And lightly with the woodland share The change of night and day. Sweet as Eden is the air, And Eden-sweet the ray." Of such a man it can be said that he is one in whom the spirit has so far gained the mastery. For the flesh-controlled are not at home in Nature. ^'The heavens declare the glory of God : and the firmament sheweth His handi- work ; " and so does Earth. Is it wonderful that those who are opposed to God turn uneasily from the place of His glory .? The splendour of the hills, the might and majesty of the sea, the more tender beauty of the woodland are no companions for the man who is controlled by his lower self. Indeed, we may say that he only finds companionship from our Mother, who has in him the child-like spirit. Watch a child in a wood, when the sunlight is breaking through the branches on to the fern and the heather. The Inspirations 47 He is come into his own place. For a moment he gazes down the aisles of it, stilled into a wonder : then, with a new note of glee, ' irreflective, unrestrained,' he runs along the woodland path, in harmony with all that surrounds him. The trees are his brothers : he looks up at them and smiles : and their branches bend caressingly towards him. After his manner, re- ceptive, simple, trustful must the heart ever be that can rest in the companionship of the forests and the mountains. It is not pressing the thought too much to quote the old words, with this emphasis : " Who shall ascend into the hill of the Lord .f* He that hath clean hands and a pure heart : who hath not lifted up his soul unto vanity, nor sworn deceitfully." The more child-like and the better the man, the more the companionship will be manifest. On the other hand, the closer the companionship the more simple goodness will be won. Thus God and man ever work together for man's raising from poverty to richness of life. The intimate communion into which Meredith came with Nature implied definite eifort on his part. He sought Nature. ' Our Mother I sought for my food.' And behind that particular eifort referred to in A Faith on Trial there stood a whole life-time of purposeful communion. In his moment of need, he tells us, he had but one asset left, and that was his ' disciplined habit to see.' As it proved, that was sufficient: but apart from that disciplined habit, the inspiration, which finally came to him, would not have been 48 The Sons of Strength his. He contributed his share to the Companion- ship, by deliberately attending to the word of God in Earth. Now, this is the crux of the whole matter. The problem of the winning of strength, the problem of life, is solved by the right attention, which leads to the right Companionship. We are placed in a world in which we can make companionships of two main sorts. Whether we like it or no, we are bound to have them of one sort or the other. Our problem is to choose the right sort : and that problem finds its solution in the region in which we are freest, the region of attention. We can, for the most part, choose where our minds are to dwell. We cannot, indeed, alter the subsequent effects of our choice of dwelling. If we choose the companionship of the true, we cannot avoid being impelled thereby to genuineness. If we choose the companionship of the base, we cannot avoid the development of baseness in our minds. Our choice lies in the matter of which companionship it is to be ; the choice of where our minds are to dwell. Dwell — that is the significant word. For there is such a thing as ' the homing instinct of the mind.' When our minds are set free from present business, they spread the wings of their thought and fly home. And where is their dwelling ? In the midst of the white mountains, in the glad and sunlit vales, in the high and lofty place? Our destinies stretch themselves out brightly, if that be so. Or, are they in the The Inspirations 49 dark places, which love not the light ? Ah ! it is ill with us then. There is a great strangeness and a great solemnising in the remembrance of what different worlds men may make for themselves out of apparently the same constituents, by the process of attending. I remember once buying a book of poems, which had evidently lain long in some old library, before it found its way into the mingled tray outside the bookseller's shop. Throughout, the poems had been marked, pro- bably by some dead hand. It was easy, so far, to reconstruct the mind that once had per- used the lines. A wholesome mind it must have been. Every unexpected phrase, every courtly turn of words, every dainty image and fancy had been lined for remembrance. It was a pleasure to think of this charming gentleman of the older school, possessed of a grace and dignity that now are lost, dwelling with delight on the daintiness of the poet. Some time afterwards, I happened to be in a public library and took up a volume of the same poet for reference. Here was marking again. But what a different world this second reader hved in from the first. All that was unlovely, all that could set the machine of imagery working corruptly was emphasised, every morsel of naughti- ness was set aside for future rolling on the palate. This man, too, we might know. He was one making a companionship of the base ; and, while he sought that friendship, no efforts and no sudden fears could change the sure degrading of his mind. 50 The Sons of Strength Whenever he was set free, he would go to his own place, until it became his prison, from which there w^as no escaping. The thought of Companionship is not, however, presented to us only in the metaphorical sense of companionship with ideas. Meredith's com- muning with Nature, or Earth, is of deeper religious value. For there is a mysticism in him, and his Earth-rapture reaches the height that it does because in Earth he comes into relation with a Spirit, a great, pervading Presence, which is the Uncreated Loveliness. Earth, it cannot be too often emphasised, is the revelation of God, The closing passages of A Faith on Trial can mean nothing but a faith in a great Unseen felt through Earth. The language is such that we find it difficult to avoid the belief that it is a One with whom^ not an It with which^ he communes. This, if it be true, brings him into harmony, in the central place of religion, with those whom we more com- monly call religious teachers. The communion which has come to him, which he seeks by purposive attention to develop, is a communion with the spirit of God. Although he speaks of it in terms of Earth, it is, in the last instance, coming into touch with God that is the source of his strength. He is brought still more completely into harmony with the religious experience of Christian men by the hint which he gives in the poem to which re- ference is being specially made, that in the moment of his need the Presence in Earth brought to his mind the memory of a vivid moment of companion- The Inspirations 51 ship in days gone by. In the days of his youth, at that period when our spirits are laid open to God's touch, a vision of what life might be, a vision which contained in it an expression of the splendour of the Mind behind things, struck home strongly upon him. Through ^ a pure wild cherry in bloom ' strange voices spoke to him : in it, a Presence came very near to him. And in his day of sorrow, the sight of the same tree "Choir over choir white-winged, White-bosomed fold within fold,'* brought back to him the thought of life which had been given him long before. A voice in Earth spoke to him by the present and through the past, telling him to be strong and very courageous, and to trust unto the end. When we read what he has to say about the effect of the ' forest's white virgin ' upon him, in connection with closing lines of the poem, which tell so clearly of an Over-Mind that is Beneficence, it is hard to escape from the conviction that Meredith, like all whose teachings on religion take a lasting hold of the at- tention of men, is stating, even if it be in language that sounds strange, that he found his power from communion with Him who is Love and Life. At any rate, it is clear that the inspiration of companionship is to be found in this poem. Now, it takes two to make a companionship. For the great companionship of religion one of these two must be God. Not that we need to attempt to define Him. Attempts at defining only put Him 52 The Sons of Strength far away. But there must be the acknowledg- ment of a Someone, a Great Unseen, who bends to us as we approach Him, a Spirit that can hear, and hearing, can interpenetrate us with His hfe, that we may be strong. I do not think that the term "religious teaching" should be applied to any system or statement of experience that has not in it this acknowledgment of the touch of a Someone with whom we have to do. For, let it be understood, the religious inspiration is nothing more nor less than the inspiration of the com- panionship of God. The Christian inspiration is the inspiration of the companionship of the God seen in Christ. It is but imperfectly realised. Our selfishness dulls its vividness. But when the moment comes that we wake to behold His glory and to feel him near, from that time onwards we are new men : for we never quite escape from Him again. When we have need of Him, at least we remember that moment of awakening ; though we see Him not, we cannot doubt that He is by our side. If we would be strong, our great purpose should be to seek His near Presence at all times ; to think His thoughts after Him ; and so to live, and so to pray, that our spirits again may be open to His breath, when He listeth to breathe upon us. For a Christian man the practice of the Presence ought to be no unwilling task, seeing that we have Christ to give us, so that our minds can understand, the heart of God. Surely we need not hesitate to seek the God that is in Christ Jesus. If a man by The Inspirations 53 seeking has reached this, that his mind, when set free, turns to the regions into which the Unstained can accompany him, and if, though it be with varying vividness, he feels that Christ is round about him as his guide and sheker, then that man can say with confidence that he will not be moved. Our great difficulty is to present the fact of the Divine companionship as a fact, and as having its parallel in other experiences of men. It re- quires constant re-phrasing ; if possible, by men who are neither singers of many words nor professional theologians. Meredith, being, on the one hand, a poet addressing himself to the intellect, and, on the other, the contradictory of a schoolman, has laid us under a heavy debt in uttering this great religious fact in a manner which is catching the attention of some, who are weary of the set of phrases of religious speech. Possibly, the fact that a man so downright, so reality-loving, hints at this region of the in- expressible as containing the supremely real, may have its effect on those whose temper of mind leads them to suggest that the companionship of the Great Spirit, and the strengthening that comes from it, is too intangible a conception for practical men. For there are minds of that sort. When St Paul, for instance, writes that he prays that friends of his may be strengthened with might by God's Spirit in the inner man, they turn on us and ask how that may be. By companion- ship, we answer. But they shake their heads 54 The Sons of Strength and reply that we use words that have sound but little meaning, words unintelligible to men that have to deal with hard facts. Yet there is no fact harder than that strengthening comes from the right companionship. Any man who has a friend worth the having knows that well. If a man has lived with one who is truer than himself, more delicate-minded, with a higher sense of honour and of duty, whose delight is in that which is lovely and true and of good report, he simply cannot help having caught something of his friend's spirit into himself. When he examines himself, he will be the first, if he is candid, to recognise how much he owes to his friendship ; and, probably, he will agree that his debt is not ill-expressed in the phrase that he has been strengthened with might by his friend's spirit in the inner man. Now, it is our claim that in friendship we get the best analogies of the relation between God's spirit and man's. Given that the companionship exists, the strengthening is bound to follow in this region also. We are grateful to Meredith for giving us, in a fresh and strong phrasing, a statement of the manner in which the Over-spirit communes with men. But it is not the only phrasing. We would say that it is not the best. For it is in terms of Christ that the noblest of the saints, who have ' lain breast to breast with God,' have set forth the Friend who made them strong. There are, indeed, a reference or two to Christ in Meredith's writings. The loftiest The Inspirations 55 part of his teaching is the teaching of Christ re- stated. And yet there is a regret left in the mind, that Earth is not forgotten for a moment as a vehicle of the knowledge of God, and He in whom Earth has touched highest, placed where He ought to be, as the sum and completion of all God's long revealing of Himself Such, at least, will be the thought of Christian people as they come to this man for instruction. But, as for them, their possession of Christ will only make the inspiration of the Companionship more mighty. For He who was the gracious and the true, whose heart bled for the weak, to whom little children ran ; who, with willing hands, pressed the points of the world's pain to His own bosom ; who, when done to death by men whom it was His passion to save, gave His last breath to prayer that they might be forgiven, — He it is that in- terprets the strange Presence that is upon us in the stillness. If it be one like unto the Son of Man that calls us friends, and strengthens us with might by His spirit, what may we not dream of whiteness and of truth to be won by those who with Him dwell ? But, manifestly, a companionship will not give its inspiration if it is not sought. Nor can it be tested as a real thing, if it is not sought. Of what manner of use is it for men to tell us that the claims of religion are not genuine, if they never attempt to ' taste and see ' that the Lord is gracious.'' Little aid should we get from our friend, if, when he came to have speech with us, 56 The Sons of Strength we barred the door upon him and refused him en- trance. Likewise, little help can we expect from the companionship of God in Christ, if to the thought of Him we never turn, if to His voice we give deaf- ness, and to His eyes, as they plead, the averted face. (b) The Forward View ** The things nvhich God hath prepared for them that love Him.^* The sense of companionship is not the only inspiration which religion offers for the right directing of life. Religion is never content with the present. It reaches into the future, until finally it rests in the halls of Eternity. In addi- tion to the inspiration of companionship, it gives the inspiration of an unbounded forward view. Now, it is true, that, as far as Meredith is concerned, the inspiration of the future is con- fined to the future of the race. He has no hope, apparently, for the individual as such. Instead, he wages war upon the desire for individual immortality, holding that it is a desire essentially selfish, and that a reading of Earth offers no evidence that it is a desire that will be granted. Since such is the case, he maintains that it is the duty of right men resolutely to set it from them, and to accept life joyously as a good, whether they themselves are to continue or no. ** Then let our trust be firm in Good Though we be of the fasting ; Our questions are a mortal brood, Our work is everlasting. The Inspirations 57 We children of Beneficence Are in its being sharers ; And whither vainer sounds than whence For word with such wayfarers.'* But while he does not give ground to the in- dividual for dwelling in the light of eternal life for himself, he urges upon him with greater force and insight than any other modern English writer the fact that he should live in the light of the everlasting in regard to his work. He holds that, in the thought of ourselves living on in those that come after us, enough greatness is given to our living and our working, to create in us hearts devoutly thankful that we are alive. Extended quotation could be adduced to show the varied emphasis with which he re-iterates his message than we can gain all needed inspiration for self-development from the fact of our im- mortality in the race : — " The young generation ! ah, there is the child Of our souls down the Ages ! to bleed for it, proof That souls we have." And we, who find new life rising from our ashes, which will gain from our energy, and will have opportunity of tasting the gladness of being, may easily be content to undergo that process of dissolution which is only one aspect of the process of development. "... The fuel, decay Brightens the fire of renewal : and we ? Death is the word of a bovine day, Know you the breast of the springing To-be." 58 The Sons of Strength He draws, with evident delight, a glad and vivid picture of society, which life and death together are bringing to birth. " By my faith, there is feasting to come. Not the less, when our Earth we have seen Beneath and on surface, her deeds and designs : Who gives us the man-loving Nazarene, The martyrs, the poets, the corn and the vines. By my faith in the head, she has wonders in loom ; Revelations, delights.'* Now, in his teaching on this matter, three points emerge. First, we, in our lives, have work to do that is effective. " Whence looks he on a land Whereon his labour is a carven page ; And, forth from heritage to heritage Nought writ on sand." Second, it is work that has effect upon the living. What we are, and what we do, is per- petuated in lives. Third, it is work, which is part of a great process for the developing of a society, in which our dreams of the best shall become actual fact. It is worth noting that at the end of A Faith on Trial he comes back to this thought. It is ' the dream of the blossom of good ' that sustains him so that he is enabled to acquiesce in his sorrow, because he recognises that death and loss are parts of the same process as life and possession. ** By Death, as by Life, are we fed : The two are one spring." The Inspirations 59 We ourselves, he implies, are the result of a double process of life and death, continually pro- ceeding through countless ages in the past ; and if we have rejoiced in our lives, and in their activities and their companionships, let us not fall to com- plaining when we have to pass through the second part of the process, namely death, whereby new lives are coming into being, which, in their turn, may rejoice in their labours under the sun. All this is worthy of our grave attention. 'Nought that we do is writ on sand.' All that we think, all that we desire, all that makes up the sum of what we are, in some sort lives on in the days to come. From generation to genera- tion, we are bound up in the bundle of life. Our influence is spreading out from us horizontally upon the men of our own time, and down from us vertically through our children. No man can set a bound to the effect of his living. When we remember how we shall be perpetuated in the good or evil of the young generation, how, when the place where once we were shall know us no more, still, in the truth and honour, or in the baseness and self-centredness, of those that in life were dear to us, we ourselves are alive, the remembrance may well stir in us a new gravity and seriousness. It is through parentage, perhaps, that the inspiration of the forward view comes most poignantly. When a man has a child he begins to bethink himself. Whatever we may have achieved 6o The Sons of Strength for ourselves, our desire for our children is that they shall do justly and love mercy and walk humbly before, their God. And, if it be that at a time, we must remember that we, having walked far from Christ, have made it harder for them to walk near Him, there is a purpose of ' the zealous amendment of our whole lives ' created within us. It is recorded in the Old Testament that ' Enoch walked with God after he begat Methuselah.' Well, we are not surprised. When, in addition, we have such faith as Meredith had, in the Power of the Universe to form at last a society of those who have grown from flesh into spirit, and recognise that all who do not aid in that process are standing outside the stream of Earth's activity and are losing thereby the inspiring which comes from the sense of being part of a great whole, a desire may possess us, during such life as remains, to work in harmony with the Over-will, whose plan, up to this point, we discern. A man must have sunk far, if he is content to recognise himself as one of Earth's waste products. It is something to observe that Meredith, while not giving that inspiration from the future, which is given by Christianity, places so much emphasis upon the inspiration from the future, which he finds himself able to obtain. The fact is that he was much too great a man to be content with the present. No one, to whom life is a ' great and noble calling,' can dwell contentedly in to-day alone. Only one who is ^ at peace among the The Inspirations .'^i: little worths ' can do that. We must, to live well, live in some light of the eternal. Meredith would not have caught the attention which he has, if his teaching had contained no suggestion of the power of an endless life. But he has given us that, in the long and hopeful look which he casts on our children's children. " So mine are these new fruitings rich The simple to the common brings ; I keep the youth of souls who pitch Their joy in this old heart of things : Who feel the Coming young as aye, Thrice hopeful as the ground we plough ; Alive for life, awake to die ; One voice to cheer the seedling Now. Full lasting is the song, though he, The singer, passes : lasting too, For souls not lent in usury, The rapture of the forward view." These then are the inspirations that he would give us ; the inspiration of companionship with the Unseen through the Seen, and the inspiration of the forward view. Truly, they are old inspirings ; but they are none the less true for that. They are inspirings that come from Christ. We are not to maintain that Meredith's gospel is complete. His apparent rejection of im- mortality leaves a blank which the ' general heart,' justifiably or no, will demand to have filled. And, indeed, he seems to mistake what manner 62 The .Sons of Strength of desire the desire for life hereafter may be. It is a misuse of language to call it necessarily a sel- fish desire. So to describe it becomes a contra- diction in terms, when the life, which is longed for, is a life under the complete domination of the Spirit of Christ, and, therefore, a life of continual readiness for self-loss for love's sake. If he is angry with us because, in Mr G. M. Trevelyan's phrase, we regard immortality as ' a claim established on the Universe,' he misrepresents our position. The claim, if claim there be, is established, not upon the Universe, but upon the Fatherhood of God ; which is a very different thing. Moreover, unquestionably, he can be charged with never indicating a sense of the exceeding sinfulness of sin. To him, it is but the re-appear- ance of tendencies seemly enough in the lower stages of life whence we are sprung, — a kind of ethical casting-back. There is no hint of that shuddering sense of its awfulness, of which those very near to God have spoken with bated breath. ' Enmity towards God ' : ^ alienation from God ' : * the body of this death ' : these are not the words of Meredith, though they come with so clear an accent of conviction from such an one as Paul. Thus, it may be, is it that we find in him, strangely seldom, reference to Christ. It seems, indeed, that we must see sin through Christ's eyes, before He becomes the greatly Desired. These, truly, are grave omissions. Nevertheless, he has a word in season, and not least for the Church. Live whole : accept the workings of the per- The Inspirations ^?, feet Will : make effort exultantly as men whose lives — "... Are but a little holding Lent to do a mighty labour." And for the rest, trust. For the great Power has us in His guidance : and His hand is strong, and His purpose is a purpose of good toward the children of men. 14 DAY USE RETURN TO DESK FROM WHICH BORROWED LOAN DEPT. This book is due on the last date stamped below, or on the date to which renewed. Renewed books are subject to immediate recall. ,iJ«n'6^R"^9 JUL 8 1968 1 8 JfJ-STACf ^S j'j\'24 '68 JAiM 1 3 19BP ■^~%y?g,SVj ? ' ' -iJ'Cd- ■ '■ " ■"• 1 -1 ., ' ■ ■'■'' .^ ■■ LD 21A-50m 4,'60 u-S^S^JlfS^M. (A9562sl0)476B ^"^'"g^JeliT^ f ijt.'^i.. .rrpfc- I: 4 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LIBRARY