WB A A r^ e RNRI 9 EGIO 3 1 '~ 3 2 — t. 3 o ItVCRSITY 0» AUK>RNIA ;an DIE&O J 1/NIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SAN m99 LA JOLLA. CALIFORNIA I ADDRESS SOCIAL FESTIVA.I. OF THE BAR OP WORCESTER COUNTY, 3yE-A.ss-A.oia:xjssa:TS, FEB. 7, 1856 B Y HON. EMORY WASHBURN. ^VORCESTER: PRINTED BY HENRY J. ROWLAND, 245 Main Street. F 12. SOCIA.L FESTIVAL. At a meeting of the Bai- of the County of Worcester, held, in pursuance of notice, at the Law Library, Sept. 15, 1855, L-a M. Barton was called to the chair, and Joseph Mason appointed Secretary. On motion of the Hon. Nathaniel Wood, of Fitchburg, a com- mittee was raised to consider the subject of a Social Festival of the Bar, with instructions to report at a future meeting, and the following gentlemen were appointed : Ira M. Barton, Nathaniel Wood, Benjamin D. Hyde, Francis Deane, George W. Richardson, Henry Chapin, George F. Hoar. During the Law Term of the Supreme Court, holden at Wor- cester on the first Tuesday of the next October, the Committee reported in favor of such a Festival, to embrace also the objects of an historical address, the improvement of the County Law Library, and the formation of an Association of the Bar. The Report of the committee was unanimously accepted, and the same gentlemen were appointed a committee of arrangements, to carry their recommendations into effect. The time and place designated for the Festival, was Worcester, Feb. 7, 1856, it being the day of the first semi-annual meeting of the Justices of the Court of Common Pleas, in that city ; and the Hon. Emory Washburn accepted an invitation to deliver the address upon the occasion. Distinguished members of the Bar and of the Bench, from Mas- sachusetts and the neighboring States, were invited as guests, and on the day appointed, at 5 o'clock P. M., at the New Court House, Ex-Governor Washburn delivered his address. Immediately after the address, the company, under the direction of Col. Geo. W. Richardson, the Sherift' of the County, and Marshal of the occasion, repaired to the Bay State House, where, after an hour's agreeable re-union in the spacious and elegant saloons of that establishment, more than an hundred sat down to a supper, well provided by Messrs. Clifford & Foster. A blessing Avas invoked by the Rev. Dr. Alonzo Hill, and the Hon. Ira M. Barton presided, assisted by the Hon. Messrs. Newton, Wood, Chapin and Deane, as Vice Presidents. The festive part of the occasion was introduced by remarks from the President, in the course of which he referred in appro- priate and respectful terms, to Mr. Justice Byington of the Com- mon l^leas, whose lamented and very recent demise, deprived ihe company of the honor of the presence of all the Judges of that Court. The following sentiments were then announced by the Chair. 1. The President of the United States, and the Governor of the Common- wealth. 2. The Judiciary of the Commonwealth, and the health of j\Ir. Justice Thomas. This sentiment was very eloquently responded to by the Hon. Benj. F. Thomas, one of the associate justices of the Supreme Court. 3. Our national and State .Judiciaries. Complicated and nicely adjusted systems of jurisprudence. But under an administration by good and wise men, upon the just principles of international law, no colli-sion can ever take place between them ; certainly not on this occasion. The following letter was received from the Hon. Benj. R. Curtis of Boston, an associate justice of the Supreme Court of the United States. For the reading of this and other letters, the chair was indebted to Chas. C. B. Snow, Esquire, of Fitchburg. "Washington, Jan. 21, 1856. Hon. Tea. IM. Barton, — Dear Sir : I received your invitation, in behalf of the Committee of the Bar of the County of Worcester, to attend their Social Festival, to be held at AVorcester on the evening of the 7th Feb. next. If my duties hei'e would permit, it would give me much pleasure to be present. With some of the older members of the Bar of Worcester County, I have had, in former years, relations too pleasant to be easily forgotten ; and for the younger members of the profession there, as well as elsewhere in my native State, I feel an interest, which would render me glad to meet them, and make their acquaintance. Notwithstanding the severe contests of the bar, which a stranger might suppose would inevitably alienate law- yers from each other, I believe there is no profession, or occupation, whose followers entertain for each other, so much cordial good will, and do so much to help one another, as the members of our profession. And I have long thought that it would promote these kindly feelings, and be in no small degree serviceable, particularly to the younger members of the profession, to meet together as you propose to do. I made a strong effort, some years since, to arrange a plan for this purpose. It failed, but I was not convinced that the objects were not desirable, or were unattainable. I am glad to learn that you are about to have a Social Festival of the Bar of AYorcester County. I do not know whether there will be any place for what is called a " sen- timent" in these times, when toasts must not be spoken of — if there is, I would offer the enclosed. With great respect. Your Obed't Serv't, B. E. CURTIS. A learned, industrious, upright and faithful Bar — The indispensable guide and support of a just, wise, courageous and learned Bench — The Common- wealth of Massachusetts has always had both, and its people have known how to value them. 4. Hon. Judge Sprague, of the District Court of the United States. Brought up at the feet of a Worcester Gamaliel, he has done equal honor to himself, and to his instructor. BosTox, Jan. 18, 1856. Gentlemen : — I regret that it is not in my power to accept your invi- tation to the Social Festival of the Bar of Worcester County. The state of my health peremptorily forbids me that pleasure. It would have afforded me peculiar satisfaction to have visited Worcester upon such an occasion. My associations with your Bar, go b ick to the year 1811:, when I was a student in the office of the Hon. Levi Lincoln, who was then distinguished as a Lawyer and an Advocate, and h is since most honorably filled two of the most eminent offices in the State. And I have a vivid recollection of many of the eminent Lawyers, who then and since have so greatly distin- guished the Bar of Worcester Cuuuty. Accept my thanks. Gentlemen, for the honor conferred by your invitation, and believe me, Very PiespectfuUy yours, P. SPRAGUE. To Messrs. Ira M. Barton and others. 5. Ex-Governor Lincoln. The Nestor amongst Massachusetts lawyers, Judges and Governors. This sentiment elicited a very interesting speech from the Hon. Levi Lincoln. The health of the Hon. Samuel Hoar of Concord, was here given, and received by the company rising. The venerable com- peer of Ex-Governor Lincoln, acknowledged the compliment in remarks at once forcible and happy. 6. New Hampshire. A standing demonstration of the fact, that " giving does not impoverish." She has given us her Websters, her Masons, her Bells, and her Parkers ; but yet, she has more of the same sort left. In the absence of Chief Justice Perley of the Supreme Court of New Hampshire, whose presence was prevented by sickness, the company called for the Hon. Joel Parker, one of the emigrants referred to. But before responding, the chair requested him to notice, also, the following sentiment. 7. The Law School of Harvard College. By the sound principles of Con- stitutional law, there inculcated, and the genial associations of young men, there formed, it constitutes the best guaranty of the Union. These sentiments Avere aptly and eloquently spoken to by Pro- fessor Parker, of the Dane Law School in Harvard College, and formerly Chief Justice of New Hampshire. 8. Maine. A worthy daughter of Old Massachusetts. She may well rejoice in her Heraldic " Dirigo," but she must never undertake to direct the old folks. The following note was received from the Hon. John S. Ten- ney, a native of Massachusetts, and now Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Maine. NoRRiDGEWocK, Feb. 2, 1856. Ira M. Barton, Esq., — Dear Sir : On returning to my residence from a long absence, T found your favor of the 12th ult., kindly inviting me to attend the " Social Festival " of the Bar, on the evening of Thursday, tlie 7th inst., at Worcester. On such an occasion, and to hear an address from the distinguished gentleman selected for the purpose, it would give me gi-eat pleasure to be present with the members of the profession, to which I am proud to consider myself as belonging, in my native Commonwealth, especially in the County of Worcester, where the Bar has been conspicuous for gentlemen of talents and legal attainments. But I am sorry to say, that I must deny myself this gratification on ac- count of business of an official character, which cannot be postponed. Accept, dear sir, for yourself personally, and the committee, in whose behalf you extended your invitation to me, the feeling of the highest respect. JOHN S. TENNEY. The Hon. R. H. Vose of Augusta, a distinguished naember of the profession, who received his legal education in Worcester, transmitted to the committee the following sentiment. The Bar of Worcester County. May the glorious history of the past, never be dimmed by the future. The Hon. Chief Justice Redfield, of the Supreme Court of Vermont, sent the following complimentary note, regretting his inability to attend the Festival. Windsor, Jan'y 22, 1856. Hon. Ira M. Barton, — Dear Sir : It would afford me very sincere pleas- ure, to be able to attend your Festival, but as the time comes in the midst of one of our terms, it will not be in my power. The slight acquaintance I have had with the Bench and the Bar of Massachusetts, and their uniform and marked courtesy towards me, certainly renders the deprivation which I now suffer, in not being able to avail myself of this opportunity of meeting them, a serious disappointment. Very truly yours, ISAAC F. REDFIELD. 9. The Ex-Judges of our Supreme Court. Equally honored upon the Bench, and in their retirement. The following letter and sentiment from the Hon. Richard Fletcher, formerly an associate justice of the "Supreme Court, were then read. Boston, Feb. 4th, 1856. Dear Sm : — I regret that it will not be in my power to be present at the Social Festival of the Bar of Worcester County, on the 7th instant. You will please to make my acknowledgments to the Bar for their kind invita- tion. It would be well if such meetings were more frequent. They might do much good by animating and encouraging the members of the profession in their efforts for advancement in learning and usefulness, and by incul- cating and keeping alive, and in action, those high and honorable principles and maxims, which should form the characters, and govern the conduct of those, who minister in the temple of Justice. It is unhappily too true, that the lawyer is constantly exposed to temptation to overstep the bounds of right and duty. In the earnest and ardent contests of the forum, his zeal for his client, and his desire for victory, tend to divert his attention from the claims of truth and justice ; yet certain it is, that no better mode has been discovered, no better mode is known, for administering justice, than by the services of a body of men properly educated and prepared to represent the suitors, to present their claims, and discuss their rights. Such a body of men is indispensable, to do for parties what they are unable to do for themselves. The profession of the law, properly pursued, is a useful and honorable profession. But to maintain that character, lawyers must vigilantly and scrupulously guai'd themselves against the evils and dangers, with which they are continually beset. From age to age the profession has been adorned by good and great men. Two eminent men. Judges Wilde and Jackson, have recently departed from among us, who have left us noble ex- amples of pure, upright, honorable and useful lives. There should be some more enduring memorial of such men, than a brief eulogy, suddenly called forth, at the time of their decease. I earnestly hope and trust that your Festival may be an occasion of great pleasure and profit to the Bar of Wor- cester County, for whom I entertain the highest respect and regard. I subjoin a borrowed sentence, which expresses a just and appropriate sentiment. Very faithfully and truly yours, RICHARD FLETCHER. Hon. Ii"a M. Barton, for the Committee. The Profession of the Law, " Let it be remembered and treasured in the heart of every student, that no man can ever be a truly great lawyer, •who is not, in every sense of the word, a good man." 10. The Hon. Judge Merrick. A refugee from the Worcester Bar. We have lost a good companion; the State has gained a good Judge. The following note was received from Mr. Justice Merrick of the Supreme Court. Boston, Feb. 7th, 1856. My Dear Sir : — It is with the deepest regret that I find myself unable to unite with the gentlemen of the Bar of the County of Worcester in their Festival this evening. I had looked forward to a participation with them in the pleasure of this occasion, with the utmost expectation and desire, and I am greatly disappointed that I cannot do so. My health, within a few days past, has given way, and I am unavoidably detained at home by an illness, which, though it does not threaten to be of long duration, is still sufficient, at present, to confine me to my house. Thus constrained against my will to be absent from you this evening, I shall yet heartily sympathize with you in your festivity. It was in the midst of the scenes of their present occupation, that I have spent the largest, the most laborious, and the happiest portion of my life, and I cannot, therefore, but feel identified a ■with my professional friends and brethren of the Bjxr of the County of Wor- cester. And I can never fail to take the deepest interest in whatever ad- ministers to their gratification or advances them in the honorable rank they hold in the community. I shall always rejoice in whatever promotes their welfare, or contributes to their individual prosperity, success, and happiness. I am very trujy yours &c., &c, I'LINY MERRICK. Hon. I. M. Barton, for Committee of Bar of County of Worcester. 11. The Ex-Judges of the Court of Common Pleas. None the less entitled to our respect and reverence, although they tread upon our corns somewhat more lightly than in days gone by. Hon. E. R. Hoar well sustained the family reputation in his happy response to this sentiment. 12. The Old Plymouth Colony. She can never lose caste in the Bay State, so long as she produces our Shaws, our Spragues and our Cliffords. She has furnished more than one distinguished Page in our history. The following is a sentiment received from the Hon. J. H. W. Page of New Bedford. The Social Festival of the Bar of Worcester County. May it be crowned with all success, and prove the re-dawning of a day which old members of the Bar remember with pride. 13. The Orator of 1829. In erecting a " Corinthian column " to the memory of those who first gave distinction to this Bar, he created for himself a monument equally beautiful and lasting. This sentiment drew a neat and interesting response from Jo- seph Willard,. Esquire, of Boston, who addressed this Bar, on an occasion like the present, Oct. 2, 1829. It. The Bar of Suffolk. Confessedly, the head of the Bar of the Com- monwealth. But they should remember where their best lawyers come from. The truth of this sentiment was happily illustrated by Hon. Wm. Brigham, of the Suffolk Bar ; but claiming the double dom- icil of Boston and Grafton. 15. The river Counties of Old [Massachusetts. While the names of Mills, Alvord, Ashmun and Bliss, throw a melancholy glory over the past, the light of genius, eloquence and tiue hospitality, shed a brilliant radi^ance over the present. The speech of the Hon. Wm. G. Bates in answer to this senti- ment, was characterized by genuine wit, and attic taste. 9. 10 The President here congratulated himself and the company, that he had a Vice President, who was both a poet and a lawyer, and he, with great pleasure, introduced the Hon. Henry Chapin, as poet lawyerate and presiding officer. Mr. Chapin read the following pleasant effusion, and then pro- posed the concluding sentiments. We hasten to this festive board, In omnibus and car, To feed on what our means afford, We children of th^ Bar. Old Worcester County gathers now, Without a single jar, Her sons, who make their earnest vow, Ne'er to disgrace the Bar. 'Tis well for men, at times, to know Precisely what they are. And law and fact combine to show, When one has seen the Bar. The Frenchman, as he staggers up And utters his " be gar," Fresh with the flavor of the cup, Has surely seen a Bar. The yankee, as he swells and swears. And smokes his long cigar, Upon his perfumed image bears The impress of a Bar. But we, who battle for the right, With many a wound and scar, Must stand and fight, with all our might, At quite another Bar. And he who means to triumph here, Though he may wander far. Must watch with vision bright and clear, Our jewels of the Bar. We greet without the weakest wine. Full many a brilliant star. While round us now, are bound to shine, These meteors of the Bar. li And as we meet, with chastened glee, May nought our feelings mar, And while the shades of evening flee. Let's consecrate the Bar. IG. The city of Springfield. While the beautiful in natm-e — the skillful in art, and the best of good eating commend themselves to the taste or the appetite of man, the Queen City of the Valley will continue to be a sort of Mecca to the pilgrims of Old Massachusetts. This sentiment was appropriately responded to by Hon. K.. G. Chapman, of Springfield. 17. The Town of Fitchburg. One of the brightest jewels in the good old County of Worcester. We have been friends together, The past we can't forget, What'er the wind or weather,. Oh do not part us yet. This sentiment called up Hon. Nathaniel Wood, of Fitchburg, who, as usual, was at home. 18. The Judge of Probate of the County of Worcester. Like his prede" cessors, he not only fulfils the duties of his office with dignity and fidelity, but is remarkably popular among the poor widows of the County. This sentiment elicited a happy response from. Hon. Judge Kinnicutt. 19. The past and present District Attornies of the County of Worcester* The maxim that more worship the rising than the setting sun, here fails in its application, for they all have, and deserve to have, the confidence and respect of their brethren of the Bar, and of the community with which they are so closely connected. There being so many to whom this sentiment applied, the com- pany lost the benefit or any specific reply. 20. The Sheriff of the County of Worcester. His courtesy to the people, his kindness to the prisoner, and his generous smoothing of the rough spots in a lawyer's existence, richly entitle him to our heartfelt wish, that his shadow may never be less. To this sentiment, sherifi" Richardson made a characteristic reply. 21. Old Uxbridge. God bless her. In former days she rejoiced in a duet. To day she supports a trio. George S. Taft, Esq., well represented the place of his birth in a response to this sentiment. 12 22. The Town of Petersham. The blood of the fathers yet runs in the veins of the sons. We welcome to our feast to night a son worthy of his sire. F. A. Brooks, Esq., of Boston, son of tlie late Hon. Aaron Brooks, of Petersham, made a brief and appropriate reply. It being now nearly 1 o'clock, the company separated with the best feelings, satisfied that the occasion had been fully equal to the most ardent expectations of the most sanguine advocate of it. And if the spirit which animated the members at this Festival, shall be carried to its legitimate result, similar gath- erings will ensue, and serve to brighten and perpetuate those gen- erous and fraternal sentiments in the hearts of the members of the bar, which are alike honorable to themselves, agreeable to the courts, and useful to their clients. Worcester, Feb. 22, 1856. Hon. Emoey Washburn, Dear Sir : — As Chairman of the Committee of Arrangements for the recent Festival of the Bar of the County of Worcester, and in pursuance of a vote of the Bar, I am instructed to tender you " Their sincere thanks, for your valuable, interesting, and eloquent Address, delivered on the oc- casion, and to request a copy of the same for publication." Very Respectfully Yours, IRA M. BARTON, Worcester, 3Iarch 1, 1856. Dear Sir : — In complying with the request contained in your note of the 28th ult., I am performing a pleasant duty, rather than following any personal wish to give publicity to the address. The memorials that a lawyer is ordinarily able to leave of his efforts at the bar, are necessarily brief. The arena upon which his powers are exer- cised, is removed from public observation, and some of the noblest exertions of the human intellect have been spent in determining questions of private right, to be forgotten with the occasion that called them forth. If, therefore, my brethren have furnished me an occasion to collect some memorials of those who have heretofore iilled places at the Bar, and are willing to give them a more permanent form than the entertainment of a festive hour, I do not feel that I have a right to decline the request. I am, Very Respectfully, Your Ob't Serv't, EMORY WASHBURN. Hon. IRA M. BARTON, Chairman ^c. ADDRESS. I am to speak this evening of the Law and its progress, and of this Bar and its changes, during the last twenty-five years. Measured by the experience of a life, how large is the space which that period occupies ! Of all those who filled the places we occupy, twenty-five years ago, how few are here to night, to share in the remi- niscences which it is designed to awaken. And what a grave has been opened and closed over bright hopes, generous as- pirations, and stirring ambition, in the solemn experience of these few brief years. What a change have they wrought in the individual man ! The stout frame has been bowed, the flowing locks have been bleached and scattered, the beaming eye clouded and dimmed, the gladsome spirits saddened, and the shadows of coming evening grown fearfully long, as the lingerer stops in his lonely walk, and looks around in vain for some once familiar companion of his earlier days. They found a young man full of hope, they have made him an old man full of experience. But if we contemplate this period in contrast with the life of the Common Law, of whose history it forms a most important chapter, it dwindles to the measure of a moment's space. The origin of that system is indeed so distant that the long vista of ages, through which, alone, the mind can re- 16 gard it, blends in its perspective, the hues of truth and error, like the melting of the dim outline of the blue ocean with the bluer sky, when we look out upon its waters, as they sleep in the stillness of a summer's twilight. I go back in my research, to the day when Rome was gathering up her giant limbs to die, and left the few and scattered fragments of her imperial institutions, like the relics of half legible inscriptions, and old imperishable stone work, on which the eye of the antiquary reads the tale of the five centuries of Roman power and glory in that island. I trace the slow and silent growth of institutions, which through another period of six hundred years, were spring- ing up, under the rule of a rude people, and I pause to ad- mire the sturdy independence, so nearly approaching to freedom, of the Saxon, while I read the simple but wise ordinances of Ina and Alfred, and listen to the counsels of their Wittenageraot — the future Parliament of Great Britain, and mark the first rough outline of that form of trial, which has since protected so many against the power of the oppres- sor, by the majesty of a Juror's oath. And, as I contemplate this broad, deep laid, rough foun- dation of Saxon law, I see planted and rising upon it, that stupendous fabric of Feudalism, which the Norman conquest brought with it as the element of its power and its perpe- tuity. The Baron's castle in the midst of his broad domain, is frowning over the hut and cottage of his vassal and his serf. The mitred Bishop keeps the conscience of the King, and is stealing in upon the frank and manly doctrines of the English law, with the subtle and artful inventions of the church, while the monarch is himself waging an unequal contest against the ascendency of the Pope on the one hand, and a storm of domestic faction with his Barons on the other. I see these Barons gathering at Runny mede, and among the memorable records of what those stern old warriors thought and did there, I read as a concession wrung from royal fear, but treasured forever after in a nation's heart, 17 the development of that great element of personal right and private justice — " NuUi vendimus nulli negabimus, aut di ffer emus, ^miiiiSiVa. vel rectum." And as we recall that scene in fancy, and the thought flashes across the mind that some gifted spirit among those men of iron nerve, may, with prophetic vision, have read that memorable declaration, as we may now, engraved upon the seal of a Court of Common Law, presiding over the civil rights of a million of Freemen, with a wisdom and learning of which the pages of Glanville and Bracton fur- nish but barren rudiments, — in a land which even fancy had, till that moment, never conceived, the whole comes back upon the imagination, as a spectacle of moral grandeur, compared with which the by-play of war sinks into insig- nificance. I trace, still onward, that course of events, which, infus- ing new elements into the body of the law, changes not only the relations of property, but the very ideas of social duties and political rights. The cunning shrewdness of the clergy has substituted under the guise of " Uses " the superstitions of a vitiated conscience, for the plain, homely precedents of feudal sim- plicity, cheating alike the crown and the Lord of their cherished prerogatives, and gathering into the granary of the church the best fruits of the English soil, in spite of charter and of statute. There is something even dramatic in witnessing this strug- gle, — sturdy, English doggedness triumphing over priestly cunning. Parliament has met at Merton. The Bishops are seeking to introduce their own canon law, and are ready, in order to accomplish it, to minister to the passions and vices of the impulsive Barons- But the appeal is vain. In terms which could not be mistaken, and in words which will be read with admiration in after days, they tell those ambitious churchmen, *'nolumus leges Angliae mutare," and England and her institutions are English still. 8 18 I pass over another period of four hundred years — A long and severe struggle has been going on, the anathema of the Pope, and the thunder of the Vatican have lost their terror. Interdict and Excommunication can no longer clothe a people in sack-cloth. And the prestige of royalty itself has ceased to dazzle the eye of a fickle multitude. A Ple- bian Parliament has laid sacreligious hands upon the Lord's anointed. But Law has been, during all this time, silently gaining strength and consistency in the kingdom, and the people are beginning to learn that without rules to guide and check their rulers, the rights of the citizen can never be secure. And when, at last, that feeling of an Englishman's Loy- alty, which had been cherished by the teachings of a thou- sand years, triumphed over the party of freedom and fanat- icism. Liberty was found asserting her claims in behalf of private right, and personal security against power and pre- scriptive wrong. At one blow. Chivalry and Knight service, under which the tenant of every manor in England had been groaning for six hundred years, were laid prostrate, while that single engine of magic power, the Habeas Corpus was placed within the reach of the humblest citizen, and at its touch the bars and bolts of the deepest dungeon gave way, and the fetters of the oppressor fell broken from the limbs of his victim. As we come down from this eventful period, our pathway grows luminous and clear in the light of Judicial learning. The struggle between prerogative and the people, between the crown and the priesthood, has passed and is passing away, while the cumbrous frame work of antiquated iorms is giving place, in the study of the jurist and the statesman, to the vitalizing principles of social advancement and indi- vidual right. Commerce and Trade are fixing more firmly their marts in the growing cities of the kingdom, and thrift is rewarding the enterprise of toiling industry. The Common Law, in the mean time, has kept pace with It) the changes that are thus going on, and has expanded to meet the unaccustomed wants of a community, no longer confined to the culture of the soil. Under the guidance of her great masters, her Holts, her Blackstones and her Mansfields, she has added to her prim- itive elements, what she has gleaned from the systems of continental Europe, and especially from the great store house of Eoman Jurisprudence, the elements of symmetry and consistency which adapted to the condition of a commercial people, the rugged relics of feudalism and the business of arms and agriculture which still give character to her laws, and form the basis of her constitution. The heretofore rival systems of law and equity, have learned how to blend and harmonize with each other, under the administration of the Hardwickes and Camdens of the time, till a system of Jurisprudence has grown up and be- come incorporated into the constitution of the government, surpassing that of Kome in the brightest days of her glory. Fifty years more in the history of the English law, and we find ourselves at the commencement of the period to which I am liinited in what I am to say this evening. Yet brief as is this little space on the great chart of English history, I am greatly misled or we shall find that more has been accomplished in changing some departments of the law, and in fitting and adapting the great body of its prin- ciples to the practical wants of the community, than had been eflFected in either, if not all the antecedent periods of which 1 have spoken. Those periods had been either too dead for action, or too full of struggle, as it were, for life itself, to allow the action of great minds, such only as can work out great problems of reform, in a field so uninviting as the details of admin- istering private justice. The public mind was too much engrossed to heed the absurdities and inconsistencies which deformed the patch-work systems of local customs, ancient usages, and statute expedients, which made up so much of the existing body of her municipal institutions. 20 The first and earliest of those periods can hardly be said to belong to the historic age of the lavf. The elements of society were being shaped into the form and consistency of the state. But the extent to which the masses had rights to be protected, or, that they should be provided with remedies for private wrongs, beyond some- thing like a domestic police, seems to have entered but feebly into the spirit of its rulers or its laws. In the next era, we see little more than a long, doubtful, three-sided struggle between the Crown, the Barons, and the Church, in whose alternate successes, the people came in for a meagre share only of whatever was gained by either side. A strong national feeling was growing up among them, it is true, but it was, after all, a period of struggle between masters, in which the people were chiefly passive and their rights unheeded. Nor was it till the spirit of inquiry which the Eeforma- tion awakened, had infused life and energy into the torpid action of the popular mind, that the great third estate — the Commons of England — learned how to measure the power they afterwards wielded. It would be pleasant to pause in this rapid review, on what was achieved for the cause of popular right during the Commonwealth and at the Restoration, and especially in the so-called Revolution of 1688, when the hallowed sanctity of royal prerogative gave way before the storm of popular indignation. It would be pleasant to trace how the learning and independence of Coke, the profound sagacity of Bacon, the mild virtues and uncompromising intpgrity of Hale, and the varied labors of the patriotic, and upright Somers, became inwrought into the science of the Common law, while Courts and Juries were gaining that independ- ence which was at last guarantied to the Judges of England, by the act of William 3d. And it would be no less inter- esting to trace how questions of personal rights, and rights of property, at last, became the engrossing business of the 21 courts, in place of what should be the limits of prerogative, the jurisdiction of rival courts, or by what means the power of a papal hierarchy should be disarmed of its terror. It should be borne in mind that the commercial spirit of the last century was engrafted upon the landed interests of England, for the regulation and preservation of which so much of the Common Law had come into existence. And the facility with which these were blended into a common system, and administered by the same courts, is but another illustration of the wonderful adaptation of that Common Law, to the wants and condition of a nation made up of men in all the walks and employments of life. When, therefore, the attention of the leading minds in the kingdom had been withdrawn from the political excite- ments, and the almost continuous wars in which the nation had been ennraged for more than a o-eneration, it is not sur- prising that it should have been directed to the incongruous materials of which the Common Law was composed, — the customs and forms of the days of the B[enr3's and the Ed- wards registered upon the same page with the broad cos- mopolitan jurisprudence of an era of arts, and commerce, and navigation. Among these stand prominently the names of Eomilly in the department of criminal jurisprudence, and of Brougham in the various other departments of the law, as the reform- ers of the present century. Those who are familiar with the changes which have ac- tually been accomplished in England during the last twenty- five years, will be ready to accord to it the character of the great age of English legal and judicial Eeform. Indeed, so rapid and important have those changes been, that it was stated by a writer in Blackwood, that when, re- cently, one of the leading lawyers at the Queen's Bench proposed to republish Blackstone with corrections and addi- tions that should adapt the work to the present state of the law, it was found that, with the exception of the first vol- 22 ume, the identity of the work would be destroyed, and the proposal was abandoned after the publication of a single volume. Neither good taste nor your patience would admit of my dwelling upon these at large, and I can therefore name only a few. Among these, Fines and Kecoveries, the long toler- ated farce of feigned issues, fictitious parties and false rec- ords in a grave court of Justice, are forever abolished. Conveyances of land have been stripped of their useless verbage, and rendered simple and intelligible. The mystic subtilties of lineal and collateral warranties, no longer puz- zle the brain of the lawyer. The forms of more than fifty actions at the common law have been expunged. Volumes devoted to points as nice as the line between the north and northeast side of a hair, upon the interest of witnesses, have been rendered pointless by opening the witness stand to the very parties themselves. So far has this measure of reform been carried, that the very bones of Fitzherbert, and Saunders, and Booth, and Kastal must have stirred in their graves as the sacreligious hand was laid upon one after an- other of the beauties and romances of real actions, and special pleading, — upon the" Qidhus" and the "Post," the " Ayel," and the " Besayil," the " Traverse," and the " giving color," and their places supplied with English terms and English common sense. Nor was this accomplished without many a sigh from the living old school conservatives of the day. When at last it was seriously proposed to abolish " contingent remainders," — the very poetry of legal abstractions — one of this class is said to have exclaimed. " abolish contingent remainders! Why not repeal the law of gravitation ?" The quaint rubbish that had gathered around the body of the common law, in the progress of a thousand years, like the sea weed and barnacles that grow and cling to the bottom of a noble frigate, was scraped off by the hand of reform, till courts and the popular mind have begun to sym- 23 patliize with each other in the new revelation, that the ends of justice had better be sought for, than its antiquated forms and machinery preserved. When we consider what has been accomplished in England since 1828, when Lord Brougham made his first great speech upon the necessity of legal reform, we shall find that it lias not been limited to matters of form and detail alone. It has pervaded the apirit of English Jurisprudence, embracing alike the interests of commerce and the arts, while it has moulded and fitted these to the prescriptive rights of birth, and the rents and burdens of the tenantry of the soil. It is a green and vigorous life springing out of and sus- tained by the firm old buttresses which were reared by Titan hands away back in the obscurity of ages. Around the walls of that old Abby — old almost as the Common Law itself- — within whose aisles, the pc^rtrait statue of Lord Mansfield holds an honored place among monu- ments of kings and nobles, of statesmen and poets, and heroes, the green and glossy ivy has twined itself into a shroud of living verdure. But there is a principle in its very growth that endangers the stout old fabric to which it clings. The fibres and tendrils of its roots searcli out every softening and decaying particle, every crack and scale in the stone work of which it is composed, and with almost magic power loosen and eat out the very walls themselves, so silently, yet so irresistibly, that new materials are con- stantly being supplied to preserve it from a slow but certain decay. Such is the care and skill, the wisdom and foresight, which are perpetually demanded in an age of change, and a vig- orous parasitacal growth to preserve that venerable fabric of the Common Law, in which are found so many noble monuments of past ages, and such rich treasures of consti- tutional liberty and personal right. It is a matter of state, and even national pride, that while the mother country is striving to adapt her laws, in 24 respect to personal rights, and her forms of attaining private JLisfcice, to the wants of her citizens, she has, perhaps un- consciously, copied so largely from the simple laws and cus- toms of these, her off-shoot republics. AVhen, therefore, we turn to the records of our own com- monwealth, during the same period to which I am limited, we may indulge something like a feeling of gratified self- love to see how little occasion there has been for anything like a radical reform here. That we have seen changes it is true, hut profound as is presumed to be the wisdom of our legislatures, it may, in the end, be discovered that even legislative change is not always improvement or reform. And, if T might look abroad for illustration, I might ven- ture to doubt the successful working of a system which makes the popular voice the criterion of judicial fitness for office. It will be long, I fear, before we shall see a Kent, or a Livingston, or a Spencer, rising out of that bubbling cauldron whose ingredients are to be supplied from time to time by the popular passions of Whigs or Kepublicans, of Hard shells and Soft shells, of Know nothings and Know some- things, as they one after the other snatch at the spoils that feed their patriotism. But without anticipating what are to be the fruits of re- form here, let me pay at least this tribute to the present and the past. For many years the business associations of my life have been with the courts of Massachusetts. That feeling of respect, almost of awe, with which I first looked upon the venerable men who then graced these seats of justice, has hardly lost the freshness of association by familiarity. Of the changes that have taken place in the incumbents of the highest of these, it may not be delicate for me to spenk individually on this occasion. But while I speak of the past, in paying a humble, but just tribute to the courts 26 of onr own commonwealth, I miglit extend my reTnarks to other courts, state as well as national, whose presence and learnino; I have heen permitted to witness. The feelings of veneration with which an American Law- yer first enters the courts of Westminster Hall, are partly traditionary, and partly the result of the associations and circumstances by which he finds himself surrounded. Those who have read, and who has not? the sketch of Warren Hastings, by Maccauly, will at once recall his magni- ficent description of the scene of the trial of his impeachment. That glorious old Hall, built by William Eufus, the scene of so many of the great events in English History, two hundred and seventy feet in length, and ninety in height, without a column or pillar, or any thing to break the eflect of its imposing gothic proportions, serves as a vestibule to the respective apartments, in which these courts are held. But for the mind, already excited by the recollection of events connected with the history of the hall, through which he has just passed, there is nothing to awaken an emotion in the style or magnitude or decorations of the pent up quarters into which these courts are crowded. He is, however, any thing but to be envied, who can stand in the conscious presence where Coke, and Hale, and Mans- field, and Ellenboro have sat in judgment, and Dunning, and Wedderburn, and Erskine, and Follet have pleaded, without feeling awed by the very genius of the place. Pardon the seeming egotism, if I say, it was the first object I sought in that vast metropolis, and the spot to which I directed my daily walk, with feelings like those of a pilgrim at the shrine of his devotion. I looked upon that array of Judges in their robes of office, and I heard them addressed as " Your Lordships " by titled Barristers, and Crown officers amono- the leadino- men in Parliament, with a profound respect that was not all as- sumed. I saw members of these courts presiding over trials at Nisi Prius, in causes which enlisted some of the first tal- 4 26 ent in the land. And I felt more than I could utter, as I stood within those precincts, where the associations of the past mingled with the emotions which novelty and the im- posing dignity of the scene could not fail to awaken. But when I came to analyze this spectacle, to lay aside for a moment the adventitious decorations and historic asso- ciations — to regard only the men of whom the bench was composed, grave, learned and reverend as they were, and to listen to their occasional remarks, and their more elaborate opinions, it seemed to me, that for true dignity, high judi- cial bearing, quick apprehension, patient attention, and seem- ing impartiality, we need not go to Westminster Hall for better models than we may find at home. Without undertaking to compare the present condition of the Bar of Massachusetts, with what it once was, it is safe to affirm that a system of educational training, of prac- tice and of professional intercourse and deportment, which reared and fitted the men who have honored these seats of Justice, should be approached with some distrust, at least, by him who should seek to revolutionize or reform it. And yet, the attempt to do this has been ruthlessly made more than once, within the recollection of some of us, and a radical change has been thereby wrought in the constitution and preparation for the Bar. Instead of the period of three or five years novitiate, which was once required before enter- ing the outer courts of the sanctuary of the profession, and tarrying in that middle ground, between hope and fruition, for two years, and yet au other two years before donning the robes, and title, and privileges of a " Counsellor," he now starts " from the rough," and in two short years, by the polishing process of what goes by the name of an " exami- nation," comes out the fit companion and associate of the very sages of the law. And what must strike the uninitiated as something like a solecism, the more books there are to read, the less is the time necessary for the task. The more the relations of 27 business and society become multiplied and complicated, the more quickly are tliey mastered, and the higher the de- mands for scholarship, learning and mental discipline in the profession, the less the occasion to acquire either, before entering it, and claiming its honors and its rewards. We witness as the fruits of one branch of this reform, the scattered and uncared for county libraries of which the excise, cheerfully contributed by the older members of the bar, had laid a creditable foundation. But I leave the memory of such a reformer to the blessings of him, who, after seeking in vain in the place where it should be, the volume, always the missing one, which he most needs, plods back to his office and recalls the cause of his disappointment and his fruitless search. And yet, there have been changes during this period in some of the details of our legal system, which many were disposed to regard as veritable reforms. All of us have read of the beauties and charms of special pleading, which drew forth from my Lord Coke, among others, such high and frequent eulogiums. With him, words were, literally, things, and " placitum a placendo," — to plead well and to please well, were, in his mind, an obvious synonym. But to a layman who has never mastered this refined system of the keenest logic, I fear it would be useless, if I were able, to describe its beauty and its symmetry, or to show the use of pleas, and rejoinders, and surrejoinders, and re- butters, and traverses, and (1( raurrers, which the skillful players in the legal game of chess, play out like pawns on the chess board, before they bring forward the pieces by which they are eventually to win. When I think of the power of old associations, and re- member that our meeting is not limited to those of our own number, I know not how far it is safe to confess the part which this Bar took in the blow that struck down that ancient system. A report prepared by their direction, upon the subjecc, is still extant, which found its way into the 28 newspapers of the clay, and was nearly coincident with the act of the legislature of 1836, which declared that "in every civil action hereafter to be tried — all matters of law or fact in defence of such action, may be given in evidence under the general issue, and no other plea in bar shall be pleaded." But whatever were the motives for such a reform, whether because its advocates knew too much or too little, to stand by a system which had engaged the keenest minds and sharpest intellects at the English Bar, it had, at least, the apology of being designed to simplify and render intelligi- ble the proceedings of our courts, and to do something to save, if possible, a sacrifice of justice to the mysteries of technicality. But it is true, that even after this, the language of law papers was not reduced to the homely vernacular of the nursery or the work shop, and a man was, sometimes, shocked to learn that he had been guilty of " trover and conversion " in claiming property that he owned, or to see some hasty expressi .' ■';";' it! wiP 1.