BANCROFT LIBRARY THE LIBRARY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2007 with funding from Microsoft Corporation http://www.archive.org/details/amalgamationatonOOIambrich jlivIJLIwOJL]sz[jltion: AT THE Ontario Mill coiwIfaeled with The RUSSELL PROCESS AT THE Marsac Mill. Comparison with Smelting, BY W. G.XAMB, F^RK Cl^Y, UXAH, Oeoenaber 1, 1802. Reprinted, and Extended, from the Engineering and Mining JournUi >b 6H^h COIvIFJLniSOK BETWEEN THE Amalgamation Process at the Ontario Mill AND THE Russell Process at the Marsac Mill. 1891-1893. By W. G. Lamb, Superintendent of Marsac Leaching Department. In a preceding pamphlet by Mr. W. A. Wilson has been given a comparison of Amalgamation at the Ontario, with the Russell procjpss at the Marsac Mill (Daly Mining Co. , Park City, Utah,) for the first three months of 1891. The object of the following pages is to continue the com- parison for the whole year, and to present statistics on points not covered in previous publications. The Russell process has now been in continuous use at the Marsac for nearly four years, starting Jan. 1, 1889, running con- tinuously during that year in competition with amalgama|;ion, the ore treated being divided between the two processes, and finally superseding amalgamation at the end of that year. The amalgamation statistics here given are from the On- tario Mill, located in the same camp. In that mill amalgama- tion has been in continuous use since its start in January, 1877. From th^ir long experience with it — fifteen years — the On- tario obtains as good results by this process as are possible. As the cost of labor, fuel and supplies are the same for the two mills, a comparison of statistics is of value in determining the general efficiency and economy of the two processes. The L3' 2 THE RUSSELL PROCESS. figures here given are taken from the books and reports of the two companies, and are published by permission of the managements. The properties of the two companies adjoin and are on the same vein. The equipment of the two mills and mill men employed, is as follows : STATEMENT A. ONTARIO. MARSAC. 2 Rock Crushers, 1 Rock Crusher, 2 Rotary Driers, 2 Rotary Driers, 40 Ore Stamps, 30 Ore Stamps, 10 Salt Stamps, 5 Salt Stamps, 2 Stetefeldt Furnaces, 1 Stetefeldt Furnace, 24 Pans, 6 16 ^ft. Ore Vats, 12 Settlers, 8 9-ft. Precipitating Tanks. 71 Mill Men. 51 Mill Men. The Ontario Mill treats only the ore from the Ontario Mine, and the Marsac only ore from the Daly Mine. The analyses and values of the ore treated at the Ontario and Marsac Mills for 1891, are as follows, the samples on which these analyses were made being composed of all the battery samples taken each day during the entire year: STATEMENT B. ONTARIO. MARSAC. Per cent. Per cent. Silica 75.0 76.60 Zinc 5.73 5.30 Lead 1.80 3.50 Iron 2.80 1.65 Sulphur 2.23 0.70 Lime (CaO.) 1.76 1.32 Magnesia (Mg O.) - 0.23 trace Copper U.29 0.39 Ozs. Ozs. Silver 39.50 39.10 Gold ($0.91) 0.044 (fO.91) 0.044 These two ores are practically the same, both in composi- tion and value. THE RUSSELL PROCESS. * 3 The statistics which will be here given on the Ontario and Marsac Mills, refer, of course, only to the comparative efficiency of Amalgamation and the Russell process. But the question has been asked w^hy these ores are not sold to the smelters instead of being milled. To sell the ore (which is milled at the Marsac) to the smelters would result as follows : The expenses of the Daly Mining Co. for the above year (1891) are : STATEMENT C. Extraction (Mining) $6.52 Prospecting 1.65 Hauling to Mill 0.83 Milling , 6.27 Sundries 0.96 Making a total of $16.23 With the exception of ' ' milling " and ' ' hauling to mill, " these expenses, if the ores w^ere sold to smelters instead of milled, would stiU continue. Deducting these two items, the expenses are $9.13. On the other hand, with silver at 83 cents per ounce, and lead at $4. 00, the highest price offered by the Salt Lake, Kan- sas City, Leadville and Denver smelters, for ore of the above analysis, 39.10 ounces per ton in silver and 91 cents gold, is $14.06 f. o. b. at Park City, the seller to pay hauling to sam- pler, and all sampling and shipping charges, amounting to $2.68 net per ton of ore. The total expense incurred, therefore, by the Daly Com- pany before the ore can be sold to the Smelters is $11.81 per ton; the price offered being $14.06, there w^ould be a net profit on each ton sold to the smelters of $2. 25. But by milling, after deducting all mining, prospecting, hauling, milhng, sundry and product expenses, the net profit per ton on the same ore is $12.88, making the net difference between smelting and milling $10,63 per ton, or, on 24,214 tons per year, a difference in favor of the latter of $257,394.82. THE RUSSELL PROCESS. To return to the comparison of Ontario and Marsac. following table gives the crushing statistics for 1891 : The TABL.E I. AMOUNT OF ORE, TIME ON BATTERY, MESH OF SCREEN, RATE OF CRUSHING. 1891. MILL. Ore Time Battery Run Mesh of Screen Rate of Crushing per day Rate of Crushing per stamp per day Tons Days. Mesh. Tons. Tons. Oktario, | 40 Stamps ( Marsac, I 30 Stamps f 25,650 24,214 341.8 347.0 26 20 75.0 70.0 1.87 2.33 The above difference in rate of crushing per stamp is prob- ably not due entirely to difference in mesh of screen, as Ontario ore may not crush as fast as Daly, even in the same battery and with same mesh of screen, owdng to less dryness, or tem- perature, of the ore as it goes to the battery from the dryers. Table II — This gives the comparative fineness and baseness of the product for 1891, as shipped from the Ontario and Mar- sac Mills, the product of the Ontario being bars of bullion, and that of the Marsac dried sulphides, the form in which all Mar- sac products were shipped during 1891. TABL.E II. FINENESS AND BASENESS OF PRODUCT. 1891. SILVER. GOLD. COPPER. Fineness of Product. Fineness of Product. Baseness of Product. Ontario. Marsac. Ontario. Marsac. Ontario. Marsac. Fine. Fine. Fine. .425 .313 .00025 .00026 .575 .153 The figures given for the Marsac represent the average dried precipitates from the wash water and leaching solutions, excepting the lead carbonate product. THE RUSSELL PROCESS. 5 The distribution of the silver in the products for 1891 was as follows: STATEMENT D. Base Sulphides— from Wash Water 11.63 per cent. Regular '* — Ordinary and Extra Solution 85.55 per cent. Lead Carbonate *' " " 1.71 per cent, Mill Cleanings— under filters and in launders 1.11 per cent. The large amount, 1 1.63 per cent, of silver product as wash water precipitate, is caused by precipitating the weak hyposul- phite solution in same tanks with the wash water. The wash water product assays per ton 3957.0 ozs. silver and ;^ 5 8. 44 gold. The regular sulphides from leaching solutions assay from 7150.0 ozs. to 1 1420.0 ozs. — averaging 9815.0 ozs. silver per ton for year 1891, and ;^i 87. 00 gold. During the present year, 1892, all the lead has been pre- cipitated by soda ash, making the average value of regular sul- phides in silver 1 1527.0 ozs., and ^246.00 in gold, or again of 1 7/4 P^^ cent, in fineness of sulphides, due to the precipita- tion of the lead by itself by soda ash. For reasons connected with the chemical reactions in the refining of the product, also, it is essential that lead should be kept out of the sulphides, thus necessitating the use of soda ash as a precipitant for the lead. An analysis, by Stallman, of an average lot of dried sul- phides, is as follows : Copper 21.60 per cent. Sulphur : 24.83 Iron 0.75 Alumina 0.25 " Arsenic trace Antimony 0.18 per cent. Silica 0.25 Lead 0.50 *' Silver 34.78 *' Gold 0.03 Soluble in water : 12.76 •' The lead carbonate assays 30 per cent. Lead, so far for 1 892. Table III gives the comparison of [fineness of product in silver for 1891-1892. THE RUSSELL PROCESS. TABI.E III. COMPARISON OF FINENESS OF PRODUCT IN SILVER, ETC. 1891-1892. 1 Year. Ontario Bullion. Marsac "Regular" dried Sulphides. Marsac Total dried Sulphides. Marsac Bullion. Cost of market- ing product peroz.of silver produced. Price obtained per ounce for silver. Fine. Fine. Fine. Fine. Cts. $ Ontario 3.47 Marsac Ontario Marsac 0.9700 1891 1892 .425 .380 .337 .395 .313 .351 No Sulphides refined at Mill. .923 3.45 0.9755 The figures given for 1892 are up to Sept. ist. During 1 89 1 all the product of the Marsac Mill was shipped in the dried state. The ' ' regular " sulphides referred to are the pre- cipitates from the ' ' ordinary " and ' ' extra solutions. " The ' ' total " sulphides include the ' ' wash water precipi- tate " also. During 1893 all the gold and silver in Marsac sulphides will be parted and refined at the mill by a new wet process. According to the terms of the contract which has been made, the full corrected assay value of the sulphides produced at the mill, is to be returned as silver bullion 998, and gold bullion 995 fine, which can be shipped directly to the mint, requiring no further treatment. The total cost, according to the contract, is to be I ){ cents per ounce of silver treated. By the term ' ' full corrected assay value, " or ' ' exact assay, " is meant the assay value of the sulphides, as determined by the best method of fire assaying, plus the silver (and gold) found by assaying the slag and cupel, which may be called the by products of the assay, and which contain, on an average, 1.3 per cent, of the full value of the sulphides. THE RUSSELL PROCESS. The following table gives the fineness of products in gold for 1 89 1 and 1892. TABLE ly. FINENESS OF PRODUCTS IN GOLD. 1891-1892. Year. Ontario Bullion. Marsac "Regular" Sulphides. Marsac Total Sulphides. Marsac Bullion. Net price obtained per ounce for gold. Fine. Fine. Fine. Fine. $ Ontario 0.00 20.67 Marsac 1891 1892 .00025 .00023 .00034 .00041 .00026 .00032 No Sulphides refined at Mill. .00097 20.00 20.67 The table for 1892 goes up to Sept. first only. Both of the above products of the Marsac are finer in gold than the bullion of the Ontario. Table Y covers only the year of 189 1, as no comparisons are made on these points, except at the end of the year, and, 892. therefore, can not now be given for TABL.E V. WATER, CHEMICALS, IRON AND POWER. 1891. Water used per ton. Total Chemicals and quicksilver per ton. Wrought and cast iron con- sumed per ton. Power for driv- ing' pans, stir- ring&handling solution, press- ing and grind- ing product. Machinery Expense. Ontario. Marsac Ontario. 1 Marsac. Ontario. Marsac. Ontario. Marsac. Ontario. 1 Marsac, Cubic feet. $. lbs. H. P. $ 400 56 1.315 0.900 5.5 0.05 108 8 0.31 1 0.07 The figures given on consumption of iron represent the amount actually consumed, i. e., the amount purchased, less the amount sold as ' ' scrap " to foundries and smelters. The amount of w^ater given for Marsac includes that used for sluicing out tailings, which is about 1 6 cubic feet per ton of ore. 8 THE, RUSSELL PROCESS. The cost of chemicals per ton of ore for 1890 was ;$o.658, and for 1891 ;^o.825, an increase per ton of $0.16'/, This increase is due to use of warm sohitions and baser ore. A comparison of results is of interest. STATEMENT E. 1890 Value of ore 37.31 ozs. 1891 " " 39.10 ozs. 1890 Mill Extraction, cold solution, 50° F 88.77 per cent. 1891 " " warm solution, 100° F 91.57 per cent. 1890 Cost of chemicals, per ton of ore $0,658 1891 *' " " " $0,825 T4BL.E VI. COMPAEISON OF CHEMICALS CONSUMED AT MARSAC MILL WITH COLD (50°) AND WARM (100°) SOLUTION. 1890—1891. Year. Solution how used. Chemicals consumed per ton of ore. Cost of chemicals per ton of ore. Chemicals per oz. of silver produced Cost of chemicals per oz. of silver produced. Silver value of ore treated. Actual extraction based on raw ore value 0. Fah. lbs. $ lbs. $ oz. per cent. 1890 1891 Cold (50 F) 13.51 Wam(lOOF) 18.75 0.658 0.825 .424 0.0175 .521 0.0229 37.31 39.10 88.77 91.57 Note. — The cost of Marsac chemicals in Table V is for total mill chemicals, of which only $0,825 belongs to the leaching department. The above figures show a gain of 2.8-10 per cent, in ex- traction for 1 89 1, with warm solutions, over 1890, when cold solutions were used, amounting to 1.095 oz. per ton of ore. STATEMENT F. 24,214 tons treated at 1.095 oz. additional extraction 26,514.33 ozs. Less extra cost of chemicals per ton of ore $0,167 " " " " steam for heating solution 0.02 Total extra cost per ton !5l0.187 Making total extra cost for year % 4528.01 26,514.33 ozs. silver at average value 97c $ 25,718.90 Total extra cost for year. 4,528.01 Net gain for year $ 21,190.89 THE RUSSELL PROCESS. 9 The total cost of all steam to leaching department is $o. 1 297 per ton of ore. This includes steam for — Air compressor, which supplies air for stirring wash- water and solutions. Elevating solution to storage tanks, and pressure tank for pressing all products. Heating all solutions and wash water. Dissolving caustic soda in making sodium sulphide. Ejectors for leaching vats. Ejectors for filtered solution. Engine for precipitate grinder. The cost of heating solutions is not over ^0.02 per ton of ore. Tables VII and VIII. — ^These give comparative figures, by months, between amalgamation at the Ontario, and the Eussell process attheMarsac, for 1891, using warm solutions. Coarser crushing could probably be adopted at the Marsac w^ithout de- creasing the extraction percentage. Little, however, w^ould be gained by the change, as the capacity of the Mill would still be limited by the capacity of the Ore Driers, which are already being run to their limit. The Stetefeldt Furnace, with a slightly increased draft, could probably treat 1 2 5 tons per day. In former years, w^hile w orking decomposed ore from the upper levels of the Daly Mine, which crushed very easily, as high as 95 tons per day have been roasted. The comparison of fuel is between wood at the Ontario and coal at the Marsac. While w^ood was used at the Marsac the amount consumed was about .114 cords as against .153 cords at the Ontario. The temperatures represent that in the amalgamation pans and that of the solution running out of the ore vats. Of course the amount of water to be heated for amalgamation is much less than that of the solutions for leaching. It is not always necessary, how ever, to heat the leaching solutions, but as warm solutions filter more rapidly than cold, where the leaching rate is slow, or vat capacity insufiicient, the using of warm solution permits of increased volume. The rates of leaching cold and warm solutions, at Marsac, is as two and one-half to three. 10 THE RUSSELL PROCESS. w tf o H , W M M H ^ Px^ O 1^ ^ n 1— 1 < H H ^ T3 _ 0) S oj S5^.55.§.iS52g5^,^.S.^. CO S to (M c5 00 QO 00* 00 00 OO' OO' OO" OO' 00 QO oo' oo' "1 s| O "in u ^_ s^ 00 q iH q CO 00 «D i> iH Tf< o> o ^ r}^' CO (N CC CO TjJ Tl^ CO Tt^* t}5 rt^ rj CO* 0) £3 tH (1^ o ^ a> °-i! o3 THLSOOii-iioioioi:©©^!© o I! J3 00 05 o o «> 00* 00* as t- t-" lo* CO d SOCOt^t-COCDCOCOCDCOCOt^ t- w <" ^ » ^ p< f3 o a> O -:i d C- iq i> q ic CO i> (N q q q co lO tH la «. 00* CO CO* lO* tH r-" -^ l6 ri^ c6 -^ iO lO cococccocococOcococococo CO w ^ JJ y o "i t^ i^ ti O(N00(Ml>t^(N s . £ i-l05r^THOCOTHOOC:05(N 1 55 ^.d OS (NT-((M(^1!Mr-l(N(MCit:^CO(N-^KO-^l>-^ o ^ p- 'h THlO00(MC0CD i» • .d ;h II ^5 5 CO i3 o > A 7^ 1 > > < o -^ O a OS :5 u o B QQ c3 (N lO a bo 'S d o THE RUSSELL PROCESS. 11 > 1 n CD •-< > =1 ct- ^ ^ January... February . March April May Jnnfi 00 <0 : (-1 S'T- 1, W ? H p sa &J to -^ to rzi- S i^ ■ ■ ( H b S w g ■ ? H ^ • T) -09T- 3 1 p a 3 S ?? W i ^" 001 f §^ t> O' w p p ppppp p p p p p p 3 ag. i^ \t^ rf^ 4;^ '^ 'ht;^ ^ 'h(^ '^ '^ if^ rfii. \tL. COOOOlCOCnOSOlCOOJQOCOOS 1 ■^2 w Oi 9» 1^. p w p p^z^ppppoppppp ? &s H CO to CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO 3 "i-^ CDCOls3tOh-fcObOtOOt-'h-tO p g fD HH ^ r^ ^ {Q 3 3- m CO 0986 3. p 2.n > o ^ €« g 3 0- g i -588 i ^ ^ H S W CO OOCOCOCOOCOOOQCCOCOCbcO o- Oi p OOH-'Ot-'tOCJiOOGOtOh-itOH-' t vj ^ bo *co rfi^ Hji' I-i at ^ 05 Hi cc CD If*. I-i i* p l=! '^bS H^ (0 s B^ »— < 'to CD