Ha 
 
 IN MEMORIAM 
 BERNARD MOSES 
 
:,- 
 
THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART 
 
THE 
 
 MINISTRY OF FINE ART 
 
 TO 
 
 THE HAPPINESS OF LIFE 
 
 JSSSAVS ON VARIOUS ARTS 
 
 BY 
 
 T. GAMBIER PARRY 
 
 LONDON 
 
 JOHN MURRAY, ALBEMARLE STREET 
 1886 
 

 BERNARD 
 
DEDICATION AND APOLOGY 
 
 To the many friends at whose desire these Essays are 
 published I dedicate them, with an earnest apology for 
 the too bold attempt to put into such limited forms sub- 
 jects which can only be adequately treated in volumes. 
 
 They are but sketches, and pretend to be no more, 
 on subjects which best minister to life's happiness by 
 leading it aside to look beyond it. 
 
 T. G. P. 
 
 HIGHNAM COURT, 
 GLOUCESTER, June 1886. 
 
 78'77'C 
 
ERRATA 
 
 FOR 
 
 page 
 
 line READ 
 
 it is not so, an artist, &c. 
 
 9 
 
 8-9 it is not so. An artist, &c. 
 
 morall ight 
 
 13 
 
 3 moral light 
 
 overcame 
 
 . 67 
 
 last overcome 
 
 Aldebrandine 
 
 no 
 
 19 Aldobrandine 
 
 lithostratos 
 
 i*5 
 
 6 lithostrotos 
 
 Julio 
 
 . 147 
 
 1 8 Giulio 
 
 Tsaurian 
 
 . 168 
 
 1 8 Isaurian 
 
 St. Philibertse . 
 
 . 219 
 
 1 6 St. Philibert 
 
 Deiderius 
 
 224 
 
 3 Desiderius 
 
 movements 
 
 . 276 
 
 17 monuments 
 
 p. 160 
 
 . 3i7 
 
 note 2 pp. 186-188 
 
 thec hurch 
 
 355 
 
 note the church 
 
CONTENTS 
 
 ESSAY I 
 
 PAGE 
 
 THE PURPOSE AND PRACTICE OF FINE ART . i 
 
 ESSAY II 
 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART TO COMMON LIFE . 21 
 
 ESSAY III 
 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART TO SPIRITUAL LIFE . 34 
 
 ESSAY IV 
 FINE ART IN ARCHAEOLOGY 51 
 
 ESSAY V 
 
 THE MINISTRY OF COLOUR TO SCULPTURE AND 
 
 ARCHITECTURE 62 
 
 Part I COLOUR AND SCULPTURE . . . 62 
 Part II ARCHITECTURAL WALL PAINTING . 97 
 
VI 11 CONTENTS 
 
 ESSAY VI 
 
 PAGE 
 
 A SKETCH OF THE HISTORY OF MOSAIC . . . 114 
 
 Part I ANCIENT . . . . . .114 
 
 Part II CHRISTIAN . . . . .160 
 
 ESSAY VII 
 
 THE ART AND THE ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING, 
 
 ANCIENT AND MEDIAEVAL . . . . .211 
 
 ESSAY VIII 
 
 THE ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS . . . 263 
 
 Part I PURPOSE EARLY CHRISTIAN EXAMPLES 
 
 PORTRAITURE OF CHRIST CRUCIFIXION . 263 
 Part II EMBLEMATIC FIGURES STYLE MOTIVE 314 
 
 ESSAY IX 
 
 THE BUILDERS AND BUILDINGS OF THE ABBEY OF ST. 
 
 PETER AT GLOUCESTER, NOW THE CATHEDRAL . 338 
 
 APPENDIX 
 THE METHOD OF SPIRIT FRESCO PAINTING . 363 
 
ESSAY I 
 
 THE PURPOSE AND PRACTICE OF FINE ART 
 
 T^INE ART comes of the union of love and labour, 
 for without love it has no sufficient motive, and 
 without labour it can have no success. As all ideas 
 cannot be put in words, art is in some form or other 
 a human necessity ; and in the general estimate of 
 human happiness, the result is perhaps not to be de- 
 plored that there is no other subject that in theory and 
 practice is treated with so much liberty. It is so easy 
 to talk about it, and so easy and pleasant to produce a 
 modicum of effect in it, that it is the world's favourite ; 
 as an amusement to the multitude, who care not to look 
 below the surface of anything, and as a bright refresh- 
 ment for the many who are wearied by the hardness of 
 busy life. 
 
 So for these, and for much higher purposes than 
 these, Fine Art may be said to have a mission in the 
 world ; at least, if by that we understand the employ- 
 ment of cultivated faculties, such as in eloquence, poetry, 
 or any other combination of soul and sense by which 
 men affect each other ; and as each one's talent may 
 be, his mission is to do that talent's work. Thus genius 
 finds its purpose, and had best follow its own bent, 
 whether in prose or poetry. The genius of the artist 
 needs both, for the real and the ideal, which in their 
 general meaning answer to them, are the body and 
 
 B 
 
2 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 soul of all art ; for in the broad sense of its require- 
 
 ments, realism is but fidelity to nature's laws, without 
 
 which all would be distortion and discord, and idealism 
 
 '!' : :'-. is fyut : ,ttie; play of imagination, drawing fresh notes from 
 
 the great instrument of nature's music. But all the 
 
 '. i ':' vX^orld -ne.ecj -not-'be critics, and for their 
 
 happiness they 
 had better not ; for the strife over the real and ideal, 
 inflamed by the differences of taste and temper, can 
 never be fought out till the inherent and misleading 
 varieties of thought and sense cease to exist in human 
 character. 
 
 Art is no light matter for those who would really 
 master it. Its science is as needful as its poetry ; for 
 its works may be ideally conceived, but they need to 
 be produced as things of reality to bring them within 
 reach of comprehension. It is this compound nature 
 that gives them all their charm and power ; on their 
 material side as things of skill, on their spiritual side as 
 the interpreters of the intellect, the emotions, and the 
 passions of men ; and thus it is that art approaches so 
 closely to our affections, and can become the companion 
 of our lives. The soul of art may sound a mere poetical 
 expression, but it is as true as the plainest prose ; for 
 just as in ourselves the life of the soul is the invisible 
 source of all that gives value to our outward forms, so 
 that mysterious life which glows from within the cold 
 marble of the sculptor, or gleams from beneath the 
 surface of the painter's art, is that without which their 
 works are worthless, but before which we bow in 
 acknowledgment of that soul in them which claims 
 sympathy with our own. 
 
 A writer on Art has difficulties unknown to scien- 
 tific literature. Without precision science would become 
 a wilderness ; so its language is simple, clear, and 
 definite ; but in art, of which the first element is liberty, 
 language can only hope to express its elasticity by 
 
i THE PURPOSE AND PRACTICE OF FINE ART 3 
 
 adopting a pliancy suited to it. Words must often 
 be taken on trust. If science were to demand of her 
 sister a rigid definition of grace or beauty, and to 
 require their comparison without confusion of terms, 
 or the difference between power and vigour, in their 
 artistic sense, or the definition of such qualities as 
 freshness, purity, harmony, all which have equally and 
 distinctly a moral as well as a material signification, 
 the answer would, at least, not be easy. A wide 
 margin must be allowed ; and, lastly, there is the 
 word " art " itself, a very bane of letters, with a signifi- 
 cation wide enough to embrace every work of hand or 
 brain, and yet so utterly inadequate as to be useless 
 without an adjective. The art of the mechanic is the 
 embodiment of his skill ; the art of the artist is the 
 embodiment of his ideas : but the best artist needs to be 
 half mechanic, for though his genius is a thing of spirit, 
 his labour is upon things of material ; and as his work is 
 to give form and consistency to what is ethereal and ideal, 
 he needs as much the mechanic's skill as the poet's fire. 
 
 The first step in a student's life is to divest his mind 
 of all idea that genius can dispense with labour. Art- 
 feeling is not sentimentality nor art-practice ingenuity. 
 A good eye and nimble fingers are great natural advan- 
 tages ; but let him beware of them, for they are the 
 qualities of a talent that is painfully likely to run away 
 with itself, and without training can only come to grief. 
 Let him approach nature as something to love and work 
 with, as something so deep and full as takes a life to 
 learn. Be his disposition what it may, be the ultimate 
 object of his study what it may, the same devotion, the 
 same labour, the grasp of the same great principles by 
 which his mind is trained to master what his hand is 
 trained to do, make the one and only grammar of suc- 
 cess for all. 
 
 The student's next step is to learn all about his 
 
4 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 materials, and not to leave them haphazard on trust, as 
 though such mechanical and material things were be- 
 neath his notice. He has some good examples to the 
 contrary from men who, valuing their talents as worthy 
 of fame, and their works worthy of durability, mastered 
 and supervised the whole detail of their art, from 
 the times of Apelles, who painted the portrait of Alex- 
 ander the Great, with his lads all about him working up 
 his colours, to those of Pietro Perugino surrounded by 
 his pupils, training them to their business, in what he 
 called not his studio but his shop. The third step is a 
 long one from youth to age, to realise to himself the 
 dignity of an artist's office and duty to the world ; and 
 to cultivate a manly vigour as the tone of mind, and a 
 pure freshness as the disposition of heart, with which he 
 will certainly be best able to perform it. Manliness is 
 the corrective of that sentimentality which is art's bane ; 
 and clear and fresh is the atmosphere that invigorates 
 an artist's life, breathing health into all his impressions, 
 thoughts, and works. The tenderest subject, the most 
 exalted strain of religion, the utmost refinement of 
 poetry, are no exceptions. ' Morbid humour and weak 
 sentiment mar them ; but just as a strong man's fingers 
 touch an instrument of music with the surest delicacy, 
 the sculptor and the painter prove the same result, that 
 the manliest mind, in the purity of its health, as tender 
 as it is strong, is best able to stir to anger or to melt to 
 tears. 
 
 And this is no less the case in subjects altogether 
 apart from any direct human interests, or any such as 
 appeal to the emotions stirred by the incidents of daily 
 life or history ; but in such as external nature affords 
 to those with capacity to comprehend them, it is by the 
 healthy strength of deeply human thought that its effects 
 are best apprehended and illustrated. Ask the artist, 
 ask the poet, sensible to such impressions, what it is in 
 
I THE PURPOSE AND PRACTICE OF FINE ART 5 
 
 his pursuits that so absorbs him, and he will reply that 
 in all the things and circumstances of existence he 
 traces the presence of a hidden life : that if he studies 
 with so deep devotion the forms and features of the 
 material world, it is so because in them he reads the 
 great character of a language to which the depth of his 
 own nature responds. The universe seems his own, 
 overwhelming him by its sublimity, encouraging him by 
 its beauty, and thus he loves to write or paint these 
 things, that he may clothe in tangible, visible, enduring 
 forms the deep thoughts which all these things sug- 
 gested to him ; and to interpret to men with less 
 insight than himself those signs of power and beauty, 
 wisdom and beneficence, which God's creative finger- 
 marks have left traced and tinted, engraved and 
 stamped on everything. 
 
 Here is a great motive which suggests the question, 
 "What is the purpose of fine art?" i.e. is any purpose 
 assignable as the basis of its existence that distin- 
 guishes it from all other subjects ? The arts which 
 compose it are totally distinct in ideal and in execution, 
 and every artist appears to have a special purpose in 
 every work he produces. Is there then no general 
 purpose which binds them all together? The common 
 broad division of subjects into science, art, and litera- 
 ture, indicate some clear definition ; and of these, science 
 and literature appear to tell their purpose at once and 
 plainly, but fine art is so wide and various in its 
 nature and its works that it does not so. Music and 
 architecture are essentially constructive, painting and 
 sculpture are representative : . yet there is one quality 
 that links them all, and what is that but the expression 
 of the sense of beauty ? 
 
 It is the element of beauty that characterises all 
 fine art. Where other arts, as those of the artificer or 
 manufacturer, infringe upon it, as many do in many 
 
6 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 ways, it is that element of beauty that blends their 
 outlines. The sense of beauty, and the desire to 
 express it, is the vital spark of an artist's impulse, 
 and it may be aroused as much by moral as by 
 material Nature. Some motive drawn from history, 
 religion, or the events of daily life, or from effects of 
 external nature, may have interested his imagination, 
 and he seizes on a subject for a picture. It is easy to 
 perceive how the sense of physical beauty may have 
 arrested him, and have engrossed his powers ; but even 
 where no visible beauty is present, the admiration of 
 his moral sense has engaged him, as by the beauty of 
 fidelity, the beauty of self-devotion, of heroism, of the 
 elements of a great character, of noble actions, of 
 charity, life, and truth, all of them subjects of effective 
 illustration, even where very little of physical or 
 material beauty appeared. An artist may be com- 
 missioned to do a work irksome to himself, and it is so 
 because there is no form or character of beauty in it to 
 which his sense, i.e. his moral or physical perception, can 
 respond. Where his impulse is, there is beauty. The 
 effect of beauty is to engage affection, and its power is 
 irresistible. We love what is beautiful ; we cannot love 
 what is hideous. Devoted love blinds the eyes where 
 beauty shines through some transcendent loveliness of 
 character, or where a great and noble one commands that 
 admiration which needs but one touch of nature to 
 kindle love. It does so where no form or feature of 
 external beauty may exist. So too it is the beauty of 
 structure in the perfect union of great forces of nature, 
 such as weight and equilibrium, with perfect proportion 
 ideally and harmoniously wrought together, as in archi- 
 tecture, which is the beauty of power in repose. Even 
 horror, fury, or desolation may be so intimately con- 
 nected with some form or character of beauty in the 
 artist's moral sense as to have impelled him to its 
 
i THE PURPOSE AND PRACTICE OF FINE ART 7 
 
 expression ; such as the beauty of grief in view of ruin, 
 the beauty of intensest sympathy with either the cause 
 or the sufferer from the fury which agonised it, the 
 beauty of pathos, and even of death. So in music and 
 in sculpture, it is the rhythmic beauty of form and 
 sounds into which the artist is impelled to clothe and 
 to express his thoughts. In external nature, where 
 man has not marred it, all is beautiful, in calm or storm, 
 in fertility or in desert. So too in much of animal 
 life, and in the exquisite cosmos of all created things. 
 The sense of moral or physical beauty is the source of all 
 art's motive. That beauty gained the artist's love, and 
 his labour realised it. The purpose of all fine art is 
 tJie^expression of the sense of bea^ity. 
 
 But why and what is art's existence? what is the 
 mystery that lies at the bottom of that necessity for it 
 that all mankind has felt from the prehistoric carver of 
 things and ornaments to the most civilised and most 
 thoughtful of the modern world ? The existence of 
 art is at once a testimony and an appeal ; the witness 
 to and the appeal from that which by its irresistible 
 force obliges us to recognise it as a reality, a reality 
 irrespective of time and space, of life or death, always 
 urgent for attention a witness to a power beyond 
 mortal grasp or range of sense, a power that asserts 
 itself as commanding our respect, an appeal like a 
 voice ever sounding in our ears, as from a living 
 source, that we cannot refuse to listen to ; its existence 
 is a mystery, and is inexplicable, else it were no 
 mystery ; but mysteries inexplicable exist as facts, 
 and this one of art's existence is so ; and as a fact 
 it is that man in every age and in every condition 
 has been and is its pupil, its servant, its disciple, com- 
 manded by it, blessed by it, benefited by it, because 
 the voice of it, the voice of spiritual and physical 
 beauty, is one that he has no power to resist, for it 
 
8 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 comes from the divine source of his own self and of all 
 things else, and speaks, calls, appeals to him from and 
 for a higher life than that of sense, and stirs him in 
 the deepest depths of his being. It is that sense of 
 divine beauty that masters him ; and his art is the 
 feeble expression of his sense of it ; his acknowledgment 
 and his worship of that which has cast across his path 
 of mortal toil the light of its life and the shadow of its 
 reality. 
 
 The truism that " a poet is born, not made," is often 
 no more than the apology of indolence ; but the poet 
 must go to school, and his wings must grow by practice. 
 If they be exceptions which other days afford, such as 
 those of Homer and of Dante, as beings endowed with 
 genius to create at once a language and a literature, 
 history also records the thousand names of other men 
 who created the philosophy, the science, and the arts 
 of the world, whose genius was transcendent, but whose 
 trust was only in study and self-help, as the one safe 
 maxim of successful life. Well then may we bless the 
 memories and follow in the steps of those grand patri- 
 archs of modern sculpture and painting, Niccola Pisano, 
 Orcagna, Arnolfo, Giotto, who fed the enthusiasm of 
 their genius by lifelong study among the models and 
 suggestions of a living, beautiful, and inexhaustible 
 nature. Such were and so worked those men, and 
 others like them, of undying fame. They lived to 
 work, and they worked to live ; for it is no mere 
 flourish of vain rhetoric to say that it is the hand of 
 industry alone that can put the crown upon the head 
 of Genius. 
 
 One main part of an artist's study is to learn to see. 
 Blind men always say they see, but most people have 
 no idea how blind they are for any artistic purpose, 
 simply because they don't know what to look for, or 
 how to look at it. The real artist-eye is a creature of 
 
i THE PURPOSE AND PRACTICE OF FINE ART 9 
 
 education. It does what it is told ; but there is no short 
 and easy way of drilling it to this obedience, but only 
 by thoughtful analysis and work. An artist learns both 
 how to see and how not to see. A student cannot see too 
 much for learning, but an artist can see too much for 
 painting. In the unlimited breadth of nature an in- 
 finity of detail may exist without marring the unity of 
 effect ; but in the very limited field of art it is not so, 
 an artist cannot be too conscientious ; but art is art, 
 and by overdoing it he may paint out all his poetry. 
 An overloaded work of sculpture, or of painting, or of 
 any other art, is as wearisome as an overloaded sentence. 
 
 Let us examine these statements by a few examples. 
 What is the purpose that an artist sets before him ? 
 What is the process in the artist's mind that culminates 
 in a work of highest character ? If it be merely to re- 
 produce the facts of what he has seen a representative 
 copy of some group of things or figures ; why, then, the 
 mechanism of his art and a good deal of patience will 
 do all he wants. But can it be for some such poor pur- 
 pose of commonplace as that ? Is there no difference 
 between the artist and the artisan ? Is it for such bare 
 portraiture of the outsides of things that men like these 
 are possessed by an impulse, call it passion, call it in- 
 spiration, call it what you will, that urges them forward 
 to express in outward character what their heart had 
 conceived ? Surely not ! Some occasion of life or 
 history, some accident of forms and colours, some 
 poetry of action, or the equal poetry of repose, some 
 thought, some memory of all these, heightened by asso- 
 ciation, has occupied their whole mind, and has fired 
 their imagination. It was not the image nor idea, but 
 the emotion which that idea aroused that urged him to 
 expression, and brought forth his art. 
 
 It was the impulse of an emotion such as this which 
 produced the figure of the Apollo Belvedere. The 
 
io THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 moment of the action is supreme. The head is turned ; 
 the eyes are intently fixed. The arrow has flown ; the 
 right hand is thrown back in satisfaction, and the joy 
 of the artist is expressed in the dignified agitation of 
 the god. 
 
 One needs a portion of a poet's genius to under- 
 stand his poetry ; and to understand a work of high art, 
 as such, one needs to appreciate the motive of the 
 artist's inspiration. When Leonardo da Vinci under- 
 took the commission to paint the subject of the " Last 
 Supper," an event was presented to his mind of which 
 no record had preserved the detail. Many artists had 
 treated that subject before his time. Some had chosen 
 one period of it, some another. Some, like Beato 
 Angelico, had selected that moment when the Eucharist 
 was instituted. The devotional habit of his mind was 
 reflected in the character of his composition. He re- 
 presented the Apostles in the attitude of kneeling, to 
 express at once the intensity of their reverence, and his 
 conception of the solemnity of that scene. Leonardo 
 da Vinci chose a totally different ideal of it. His sub- 
 ject is that of the moment before Judas's betrayal. 
 The scene, as he depicted it, was essentially that of the 
 Last Supper of the Hebrew Passover, as distinguished 
 from the Institution of the Christian Eucharist. There 
 was no model for such a picture. Had Leonardo seen 
 the agape in the Catacombs, their suggestions of a tra- 
 ditional ceremonial would have added nothing to those 
 of the few and pregnant words of Holy Scripture. His 
 work was to realise an ideal of his own. The vivid 
 picture which occupied his imagination was not merely 
 one of men's figures and attitudes, and forms and com- 
 binations of pictorial effect. His was a mental vision, 
 entrancing him by the conception of that scene of un- 
 paralleled pathos. The artist's spirit is mute in the 
 presence of that company ; awed by the quiet dignity 
 
i THE PURPOSE AND PRACTICE OF FINE ART 11 
 
 and resignation of the Divine Master, and by all that 
 power of intellectual and moral beauty that could be 
 conceived in the countenance of One who said, and who 
 was the actor of what He said, " Greater love hath no 
 man than this, that he lay down his life for his friends." 
 The quiet majesty of that central figure is magnified 
 by the dramatic movement of the Apostles on the right 
 and left, each in an attitude of characteristic emotion 
 astonishment, remonstrance, incredulity, horror that 
 One so divinely holy, so perfectly lovable by all, 
 should declare that " One of YOU shall betray me." If 
 poetry be indeed, as it truly is, only another form of 
 art, Fine Art, I mean, here in this wondrous wall paint- 
 ing we realise it to perfection. The work is great, 
 because the depth of its poetry is great. Many others 
 have portrayed that scene, but who has ever concen- 
 trated all its interest as in this masterpiece ? Leonardo 
 felt it with intensity, and filled to the full with the 
 poetry of it, he laboured to realise not a mere repre- 
 sentation of the event or record of its story, but his 
 own ideal conception of its beauty, its religion, and its 
 pathos. 
 
 The impulse of all high art, be the subject what it 
 may, must operate in the same manner ; for, after all, 
 art would fail of half its mission, which is the inter- 
 change of human sympathies, if its works were no more 
 than representations of matters of fact. If it be argued 
 against this theory that no Art can transcend Nature, 
 nor exceed the beauty of natural effect (be the subject 
 what it may), and that this natural beauty and the 
 utmost intensity of expression is, in that case, " matter 
 of fact," I entirely assent to such a statement of the 
 case, but what I urge is something beside it. It is 
 mere waste of words to talk of allowing and insisting 
 that Art could not surpass the facts or the beauty of 
 Nature, and that the result would only be exaggeration 
 
12 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 and deformity if it attempted to do so. But I venture 
 rather to insist that Nature (in the artistic sense of the 
 word, distinct from all scientific associations) Nature 
 is in the soul of men quite as truly and powerfully as 
 in the things and appearances of the external world. 
 The nature of the world within and that of the world 
 around the artist is the same Beauty is an abstract 
 quality, utterly mysterious, attributed on one side to 
 the actions and appearances of things, but assigned on 
 the other side, with equal or greater force, to the ideal 
 of their moral qualities and associations. For just as it 
 is a scientific fact that the phenomenon of noise would 
 not exist if ears had not been created, though all the 
 heavens crashed with thunder, so it is that all the 
 variety of natural forms which now charm our eyes 
 those colours, proportions, and effects which arrest and 
 delight us would be as though they were not, but for 
 the capacity of the mind to comprehend them as sym- 
 bols of grace or grandeur. Their forms and colours are 
 for themselves mere necessities of growth, and the effect 
 of their chemistry and light. Their movements are the 
 results of pressure of air, water, or their own weight. 
 They are in themselves items of creation, with variety 
 of purpose and value in the economy of Nature. They 
 present figures to the eyes of beasts, and by their size, 
 shape, and colour, they are distinguished as poisonous 
 or good for food ; the secluded lake attracts the heron 
 for its fish ; the colour and the scent of the rose attract 
 the insects for its honey. But bring them within reach 
 of that power of moral perception which is within us, 
 that inward vision by which those figures are received 
 on the retina of our mind, and then all their character 
 is changed; their forms become types of moral qualities, 
 such as power or grace ; their variety, their colours, 
 their very existence, become a joy till then unknown ; 
 their natural history is changed to poetry ; their growth, 
 
I THE PURPOSE AND PRACTICE OF FINE ART 13 
 
 their movements, and all the living things around them, 
 the morning and the evening, become illumined by that 
 moral-1 ight which beams back upon them, reflected from 
 within ourselves. All Nature is seen, suffused at once 
 with the charm with which our moral insight perceives 
 it to be clothed. The moral of beauty is a concep- 
 tion of the soul, interpreting the address of Nature. 
 
 These thoughts were suggested by the consideration 
 of what was the process within the artist's mind by 
 which great works of art were produced. 
 
 Fine art, though in one sense it is a work of skill, 
 is, in the other (and the only sense that makes it 
 precious to the world), the mirror of the artist's mind. 
 Thus it has often happened that some subject unnoticed 
 by common eyes, or some sudden revival of memory, 
 has struck a chord in the music of an artist's poetry ; 
 and at once he grasps its transitory beauty, he throws 
 upon it the whole energy of his art, he rescues the 
 vision for life, and stamps it, in perpetuity, with the 
 beauty and the interest that he saw and felt in it, for 
 the joy of men. 
 
 It was thus that the scene of an old hulk, disfigured 
 by work and war, worn out and useless, fit only to be 
 broken up for firewood or old iron, struck upon the 
 imagination of our great landscape painter Turner. 
 What might it not have been in other hands than 
 his ? Probably the form of any old ship, battered into 
 picturesqueness by force of age, and indebted to the 
 work of weather and sea-water for the broken colours 
 of its timbers, its rusty iron and green corroded copper, 
 might have made a fair subject for a picture, even by 
 the most prosy copyist of the facts before him. 
 
 Not so Turner that devoted student, that exquisite 
 copier of Nature, as he was, who delighted the world, 
 not as the mere chronicler of Nature's facts, but, by 
 bringing Nature's life to Nature's surface, he drew out 
 
14 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 all her latent beauty, he seized it by his skilful art, and 
 gave it permanence. His pictures are not the mere 
 portraits of things, but expressions of the way he loved 
 to think about them. He presented to the world 
 pictures of well-known scenes and circumstances, not 
 as either he himself or as any one else, perhaps, ever 
 saw them. He, as the accomplished student of Nature, 
 knew what they might appear under some pJiase of 
 natural effect most suited to them ; and thus, as an 
 artist, he knew what they ought to be, with all their 
 features and their character true to Nature, but with 
 all the prose of their commonplace transformed to 
 poetry. 
 
 Thus, in the illustration I have chosen, the old 
 disfigured hulk, being dragged away to be broken up 
 into the ugly rubbish of a marine storedealer, became, 
 through the magic of his conception of it, that perfect 
 poem upon canvas, the old ship (the Temeraire) towed 
 away to her last home. The deep glow of an autumnal 
 and shrouded sunset, reflected in the still waters of the 
 harbour, gives the tone and key to the whole scene. 
 About the centre of the picture lies the old ship, with 
 all the disfigurements of the battle and the storm veiled 
 from sight by the mellow twilight. It is drawn forward 
 slowly and heavily by a small steamboat, with rolling 
 smoke and gurgling wreaths of steam, and, by their 
 contrast to the intense quietude around, making the 
 silent procession of that old hero's funeral only still 
 more solemn. Such was Turner's conception of the 
 scene. A hero's epitaph written in colours. 
 
 You may remember that just now I said that one 
 phase in the art of seeing Nature was to train the eyes 
 what not to see. For that purpose I have drawn your 
 attention to two works of totally different character ; 
 each, regarded as the work of human skill employed for 
 the expression of human feeling, perfect. And if you 
 
i THE PURPOSE AND PRACTICE OF FINE ART 15 
 
 analysed the composition of those great works, you 
 would find that their power of expression depended as 
 much on the artifice of omission as on what was repre- 
 sented ; just as in the drama, where the author pro- 
 duces a climax of effect by skilful omission, leaving the 
 last deed of tragedy to the excited imagination of the 
 audience. The principle is the same in sculpture as in 
 painting. It is simply the avoidance of all that would 
 disquiet the design, or contribute nothing to its expres- 
 sion. The qualities of repose and dignity, which are 
 among the greatest characteristics of the greatest art of 
 all times, are mainly obtained by the artifice of selection 
 and omission. Its extreme use is shown in the Assyrian 
 and Egyptian sculptures. The extreme opposite is only 
 too apparent at all periods of depraved and fallen arts, 
 where ornament attempts to mask the absence of idea. 
 
 In no case in modern art (meaning by that all that 
 is not classical or mediaeval) is this great principle of 
 artistic effect more completely illustrated than in the 
 figure of Lorenzo dei Medici by Michael Angelo in the 
 Medicean Chapel at Florence. The design is the em- 
 bodiment of one great conception. Not one scrap of 
 detail embarrasses the sight. The great sculptor knew 
 well what to avoid as well as what to accentuate for the 
 expression of his idea. There is no intrusion there 
 upon the solemnity of that awful figure. That statue is 
 the perfect ideal of a troubled mind, occupied in the 
 silent horror of its thoughts. 
 
 I hope that I am not fatiguing you with too many 
 illustrations. You will find, the deeper you pursue 
 your study, that the perfected skill of the trained eye 
 and hand in the employment of this apparently simple 
 artifice is the last attainment of the greatest artist, and 
 the secret of the breadth and power of his works. In 
 this too lies the secret charm of all good conventional 
 art. We may notice it in many ways. For instance, 
 
1 6 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 it explains the peculiar beauty which the very imperfect 
 works of early and mediaeval art possess. But any one 
 who failed to read the undercurrent of their poetry 
 (which he would, if he had none in himself), would be 
 likely to condemn them by a criticism which has much 
 truth on the surface of it. He would say that the 
 omissions in them were not the meritorious omissions 
 of good work, but the omissions of ignorance, producing 
 blemishes and deformities. But these works, with all 
 their evident defects, are a mine of religious poetry, and 
 all their excellence is in the expression of it. Suppose 
 it to be a group of figures on panel, on glass, or in mosaic. 
 The group is that of a mother, a child, a bird, a wreath, 
 a crown, a golden halo : but the features are incorrectly 
 drawn, not a finger has a knuckle, the perspective is 
 wrong, the draperies are false ; but who cares ? Why 
 criticise that which makes no pretension ? What critic 
 worthy of his name would look for what was not known 
 to Art at the time the work was executed ? No ; look 
 rather for what does pretend to be there ; a holy family ; 
 a mother wrapt in contemplation of her own Child : 
 that Child's majesty indicated by the crown it wears, 
 its divinity by the aureole, its innocence and tenderness 
 by its simple attitude. Let the technical defects be 
 allowed, and let the generosity of educated criticism 
 pass them over, but see beneath the poor surface of 
 that frail art the earnest genius of the artist, and the 
 fervent devotion of his religious poetry ; such as all the 
 training of modern art would fail to approach, unless, 
 indeed, the same spirit were there to guide the more 
 educated hand. 
 
 The greatest scope for the exhibition of these great 
 principles is where the arts of sculpture and painting 
 combine with architecture, that great art which embraces 
 all others within herself. So true is this, that the 
 safest advice to a young architectural student is to let 
 
I THE PURPOSE AND PRACTICE OF FINE ART 17 
 
 all specialities of architecture wait till he has mastered 
 the great principles which underlie all art composition, 
 design, contrast, the construction and meaning of 
 ornament, the use and power of colour, shadow, mass, 
 and the treatment of detail. All these must first be 
 known, for architecture is no mere thing of capitals 
 and columns, groined roofs or sculptured cornices ; but, 
 in a word, it is the focus of all mechanical and artistic 
 knowledge, science, and genius, brought together by 
 one grasp of comprehensive intelligence. All its styles, 
 technicality, and mathematics, can be learnt by rote 
 but a great architect must be first an artist. 
 
 Those works which ultimately affect us the most 
 powerfully are those which suggest rather than define, 
 and leave our thoughts room to expand. Architecture 
 has a special power to effect this, for its character is 
 essentially abstract. Breadth of effect is as much the 
 excellence of one art as of another ; and just as it is 
 that none but a great architect dares to build an 
 expanse of bare wall (for he knows well the power of 
 its effect when used rightly), so the great artist painter 
 will afford, in all his works, areas of quietude, that our 
 eyes may wander about or rest at will, and thus come 
 fresh upon his points of interest and emphasis, charmed 
 by the alternation of action and repose. Treated by 
 this plain artifice, the commonest things may become 
 objects of interest and beauty. What, for instance, 
 could be less attractive under ordinary effects than a 
 Cambridgeshire fen or a Dutch plain ? And yet what 
 can be more charmingly poetical than some landscapes 
 by such men as Cuyp or Both, with their simple com- 
 position of a subject where all the incidents are per- 
 haps little more than a willow-tree and a cow or two ? 
 But the air is so pure and full of light, the villages 
 clustering round their church steeples on the horizon 
 lie so quiet in the happy rest of evening, the contrast 
 
 C 
 
1 8 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 of the rounded forms of summer clouds with the level 
 lines of the landscape, and the long cool shadows of 
 the setting sun, make a lovely poem out of nothing. 
 Our interest demands no more, and our eyes can feast 
 on it in charmed repose. 
 
 But I need trouble you with no more examples. 
 I have spoken of students, but the greatest artist has 
 ever been the keenest student to his dying day. 
 Nature has been to him his unfailing resource and 
 relief, and is to him as the very food of his life ; his 
 heart and mind are occupied in the contemplative 
 study of it ; he sees, he feels, he marvels at its beauty ; 
 he asks what is this power that so entrances him ? 
 Here are qualities, properties of external nature totally 
 distinct from any action of the physical phenomena 
 about him : forms and colours are physical necessities ; 
 but it is by no means with them alone that he is con- 
 cerned ; it is that extraneous quality belonging to 
 them, beauty, physically useless and materially unac- 
 countable, that occupies his whole mind. Here is a 
 power as universal as material existence, but utterly 
 free and independent of its laws. How is it then that 
 we, if we be but creatures of material, can be affected by 
 it ? By what capacity, by what faculty of our nature 
 do we perceive it, know it, love it, and by its irresistible 
 influence we love all things that possess it ? Here is a 
 power in weak, perishable, insensate things, which is 
 itself imperishable. If beauty be not a hallucination, it 
 must of necessity be accepted as a fact. Call it a 
 quality of things, call it a phenomenon, call it an 
 attribute, but it remains a fact ; and all the more 
 marvellous as a property of material things, and yet 
 possessing no phenomena in common with them. It 
 is a power without force, a reality without measure of 
 its existence. 
 
 By all the experience, by all the evidence of the 
 
THE PURPOSE AND PRACTICE OF FINE ART 19 
 
 moral and physical world, beauty is a thing of life. 
 In ourselves the very recognition of beauty is an 
 earnest of immortality. Our moral sense of it is in 
 unison with our physical sense. We measure things 
 by its formula, because all that is good appears beauti- 
 ful, and evil is but a negation, the moral deformity of 
 what once was good. 
 
 The measure of the human soul can be taken only 
 by the measure of its moral faculties. In the contem- 
 plation of beauty, and in the cultivation of our know- 
 ledge of it, we are feeding the highest faculties of our 
 nature. In that image the human soul recognises 
 some elements of its own nature. The height of its 
 aspirations offer to it a criterion for its estimate of 
 itself, and it possesses through that element of beauty 
 a communion with all nature, deep and intimate as by 
 no other means is possible. 
 
 The source of art's immortal fire is in the hearts of 
 men ; and the beauty of external nature is the symbol 
 of that Divine light which illuminates both it and them. 
 It is not the poetry of the artist that clothes Nature 
 with those Divine attributes but by that precious gift 
 implanted in him, he sees them as others cannot, and 
 so reflects them from his own mind as to make them 
 at once comprehensible to others and their delight. 
 Indeed, one of the most precious duties that fine art 
 can perform is so to present Nature to men's eyes as to 
 make them love that Nature more. Nature is the 
 embodiment of the thoughts of God : and Fine Art is 
 the embodiment of the thoughts of men, to which that 
 Nature has afforded the motive and expression a 
 treasury of things and thoughts most precious to 
 human life, as inexhaustible by the hopeful enthusiasm 
 of youth, as by the meditative memory of age. 
 
 Such is the character of art's best ministry to the 
 intellectual health and happiness of life. Imagination 
 
20 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY i 
 
 and those emotions that art expresses may act and 
 react on each other, as the impulse of character directs 
 them ; but let an artist remember that the value of 
 his skill is not merely in the writing of his own 
 thoughts well, but in teaching others to read them. 
 Incomprehensible art is only so much rubbish, and 
 selfish and sensual art is only worthy of the flames. 
 Under an impulse, well - nigh irresistible, an artist's 
 mind is carried onward as by a passion, without 
 thought of self or others ; but the heart of the man 
 for light or darkness, sympathy or selfishness, good or 
 evil, underlies it all, and is its own unconscious witness 
 to the world of the real worth of all he does. Earnest- 
 ness, ability, and skill are, of course, the elements of 
 all success ; and with these the noblest heart will 
 always do the noblest work, to dignify the aims of 
 life, to fill its waste places with strength, and to satisfy 
 its best desires. There is thus a fire that burns within 
 a man's breast, kindling heart, mind, and imagination, 
 raising memory to idea, and inspiring material with 
 life : but the man is stopped in his upward career by 
 the barriers of his earthly state ; he battles with the 
 irksomeness of his mortal bonds ; he knows that his 
 work is but a flash from the light which shines within 
 him ; that his weak hands can never reach, nor can 
 their poor tools realise the full greatness of his burn- 
 ing thoughts. He bows, obeys, and works. What can 
 he more? 
 
 The highest and the purest art is that which is fed 
 at the fountain of healthy imagination, for the food of 
 that is Truth. 
 
ESSAY II 
 
 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART TO COMMON LIFE 
 
 TJ*INE art cannot make but ministers to life's happi- 
 ness by contributing to the elements of its enjoy- 
 ment, spreading its works freely before the world for 
 acceptance or rejection, and leaving the pleasure and 
 the profit of them dependent on the capacities it 
 approaches and the sympathies it meets. Without 
 them its work and office is but a blank. Without 
 capacity to appreciate or sympathy to endear them, 
 its loveliest works are as worthless as food is to sight 
 or music to the sense of smell ; and all its offers and 
 appeals fall profitless, as sunshine on the desert or 
 eloquence on the ears of the dead. Art may contribute 
 to the luxury of life, but luxury does not make life's 
 happiness. Art's delight is in the individual mind that 
 opens to it ; and its contribution to the brightness of 
 public life is its result on many minds, affording that 
 sense of pleasure and contentment that the multitude 
 receives, acknowledging the enjoyment without caring 
 to comprehend. It needs no knowledge of how such 
 pleasure comes ; but, as freely as it breathes the air, 
 that multitude enjoys and loves the arts that cheer its 
 homes and embellish its cities, where the lust of the 
 eye is not a sin, nor the pride of life other than a 
 patriotic virtue. 
 
 There is a closer relationship between prose and 
 
22 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 poetry, romance and reality, in the course of common 
 life about us than many, who are deeply versed in the 
 dry business of it, care to take account of. But if the 
 incidents were brought to light, and the tales were told 
 of all the suffering and heroism, the misfortunes, the 
 infirmities, and the struggles of humanity that, with all 
 their lights and shadows of noble virtue and uncommuni- 
 cable sadness, compose the real pictures of those social 
 states about which statistics are registered and philo- 
 sophic schemes are formed, the volumes would read like 
 romances, and the records would be subjects more fit for 
 poets and artists than for the statist or the politician. 
 
 In the cold, mechanical routine of life that necessity 
 may have forced upon them, our people need heart- 
 relief as much as rest of head and muscle. They have 
 souls to satisfy and sympathies that crave response ; 
 and to many such as they art offe/s, as naught else can 
 with equal ease, the resources of cheering and congenial 
 enjoyment. In whatever way it be regarded, whether 
 for its practice or its pleasure, its poetry or its prose, 
 as an object of pursuit or an element of education, it 
 would be hard to find, unless in the equally wide and 
 fascinating interest of natural sciences, aught else that 
 opens the way to so many issues of healthy pleasure 
 or of solid benefit. But it pretends to no panacea for 
 all the ills of life. A power it is, but one which rather 
 follows than leads ; for its forces depend on what they 
 find to act upon, and the wills and ways that are open 
 to them. There is indeed a power greater than it, and 
 art can be its effective servant to tell through faithful 
 eyes the truths that ears are often dull to. But there 
 is another power also greater than it that loves to deck 
 out evil in the garb of beauty, and would pervert its 
 course from purity to shame ; such heights does it 
 open to those who will to rise, such depths to those 
 who choose to fall. 
 
TO COMMON LIFE 23 
 
 It needs no artist's eye or sentiment to perceive 
 how greatly life is affected by the aspects of things 
 around it. Climate and race may decide the national 
 lines and features of it, but its accidents and aspects 
 are the influences that sway its tone and temper, to 
 brighten or depress, to exalt or barbarise. 
 
 Our national arts had flourished once, but they were 
 wrecked some centuries ago. Since then the demand 
 for any sort of art at all, for many long years, came 
 only from the wealthy few, and mainly for their vanity's 
 sake. The things that surrounded the daily life of our 
 people gradually lost all that had given a colour of 
 blitheness or artistic sense to it. The national char- 
 acter, which had been reflected in the aspect of all 
 around them, and had been the secret of all the charm 
 in the incidents of public and private life, had gradually 
 disappeared. Things had once been lovable for their 
 national individuality. The old narrow street, with all 
 its interest of home endearment, with its pleasant out- 
 line of overhanging roofs and gables, quaint dormers, 
 turrets, and spires of shining shingle carved woodwork 
 and painted panelling, and all the cheery sense of 
 friendship, warmth, and comfort that they gave the 
 deep chimney corner, the pleasant open porch, with 
 their associations of rest, of refreshment, of warm- 
 hearted hospitality and all else that could nourish 
 in our people the last and least sense of the poetry of 
 common life, gave way before the desolating hand of 
 social and political change. National taste and feeling 
 became a blank. A foreign form of art in its repulsive 
 character of bleak unsuggestiveness came into vogue. 
 Stiffness and meanness took the place of the old- 
 fashioned pleasantness and elasticity, and all forms of 
 art endeared by national sympathy died away. So 
 had all great and good art everywhere, and what 
 remained was forced, unnatural, and frivolous. All 
 
24 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 over civilised Europe no art but that of lowest type 
 was presented to the people, and in our own country 
 so deep had been the fall of public feeling, that con- 
 tempt for art was regarded as a virtue akin to manli- 
 ness. But the craving for beauty is irrepressible. It 
 may be for awhile kept still by inevitable events of 
 national or individual life ; it may be poisoned by 
 calamity, misdirected by vice, chilled by oppression, 
 and dormant for the very want of all healthy food : 
 but the hunger for it is a part of our nature, because 
 beauty is a natural element of life, and is inseparable 
 from it. It was from the very weariness of the national 
 and individual heart for want of things beautiful that 
 the cry arose that awoke the dormant spirit of the 
 arts. 
 
 If in one more than in another, it has been rather 
 in town than in country life that their aid has been 
 most needed and their benefit most evident. Country 
 life brings with itself its own opportunities of refresh- 
 ment in pure Nature's beauty spread lavishly around 
 it, with its varying phases that change with every 
 mood of mind, as though the very air were in- 
 habited by some sympathising spirit that received and 
 responded to all that humanity might feel or tell ; but 
 town life, especially for such as necessity binds closely 
 within it, has no such ever-present restoratives. Some 
 change of interest or occupation is their main resource, 
 but rarely such as to relieve them from themselves ; 
 and the aspect of life about them is heavy with fatigue. 
 Wide and delightful opportunities are opened to them 
 by the pursuits of literature and science, though not 
 without exertion ; but the pleasure and profit that pure 
 art brings to such as they are too often worn with 
 toil or jaded with artificiality are like the balmy fra- 
 grance of a mountain breeze, or such light and refresh- 
 ment to weary minds as a spring morning spreads upon 
 
TO COMMON LIFE 25 
 
 the weary world, when all things seem bright and 
 blithe, as though winter were gone for ever. 
 
 Art is serious work indeed, as those know well who 
 know it best ; but art must have its holiday, and no 
 phase of it, however light it be, is to be despised if it 
 do but keep its self-respect. The very object of it all 
 is happiness; so no art worthy of its name is despicable. 
 What is despicable comes not of the effusion of hearty 
 feeling as the grotesque often does, and good carica- 
 ture does always but of vicious affectation. 
 
 Beside those grander forms of art which represent 
 the scenes of history and religion, and are precious for 
 the fame of noble deeds and national honour, there are 
 many less serious modes of interest and expression that 
 throw sunshine over life. Among them the art of 
 landscape is like a perpetual holiday. Fresh and free, 
 with emotions of vague pleasure, far from the cares of 
 life or thoughts of trouble and fatigue, it borrows the 
 poetry of Nature's transient charms, that come like a 
 breath and vanish like a ray, but staying their flight 
 and making them a lasting joy. 
 
 It seems strange that landscape painting should 
 have so long delayed its development as to have reached 
 its maturity only in modern times ; for if there be any 
 form of art that is universal in its relation to human 
 feeling, it is that of landscape an art which addresses 
 itself not merely to those who have the poetic sense to 
 perceive the moral of its beauty, but to the homeliest 
 sentiments and commonest interests of daily life. It 
 was the universal recurrence to Nature for the power of 
 its illustration and the tenderest touches of its sentiment 
 that, from earliest times, endeared poetry to mankind ; 
 and yet the representative arts paid no regard to it but 
 for the general purpose of a background, nor to its 
 features but for their symbolism, as emblems of personal 
 or moral attributes. These were the notes only, with 
 
26 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 here and there a phrase, but not the full chorus of 
 Nature's universal hymn : its figures were idealised ; its 
 powers were deified, but the power of its beauty was 
 not comprehended, nor the depths of Nature's nature 
 touched by it. It needed a new ideal of thought and 
 aspiration to train the faculties so to perceive the 
 elements of poetry in the effects of the external world, 
 and so to embrace the union of its moral and material 
 beauty as to translate its impressions into the language 
 of art. Music, the latest of the arts to attain its highest 
 development in our own time, has an intimate relation- 
 ship with this art of landscape in the sources of its 
 inspiration, and even in some cases a greater power 
 than it in portraying the surrounding scenery of life. 
 Human passion does not exhaust the range of musical 
 expression as it breaks out in the power and loveliness 
 of song, but the whole poetry of Nature is open to it. 
 Music can pursue the storm, and follow the passing 
 hours, the changing aspects of earth, sea, and sky, of 
 day and night ; and, with profounder sympathy than 
 any other art, music can bring within the range of 
 sense the echo of those whispers that, from the depths 
 of Nature's mystery, arrest and overwhelm the soul ; 
 while landscape art, though its range seems infinite, 
 and its charms as inexhaustible as Nature, can do no 
 more than seize upon some transient effect, the action 
 or the sentiment of one passing scene, and perpetuate 
 only the beauty of a moment 
 
 But there is another sphere of art the very opposite 
 of this, wilful and artificial indeed, but most pleasant, 
 that must not be omitted among the many forms of it 
 that contribute to life's happiness ; for if art is to be 
 entertained as a means to that beneficent result, the 
 wider range, within reason and respect, that we can 
 give it, the more approaches will be open to the many 
 varying capacities of mind it has to reach. Lyric art 
 
TO COMMON LIFE 27 
 
 has always had its place, and ought to have it still. 
 Lyric painting, no less than lyric poetry and music, is 
 lovely ; lyric sculpture is the very embodiment of grace 
 and happiness ; and even lyric architecture is possible, 
 not merely in those studied forms of which the choragic 
 monument of Lysicrates in ancient classic, or the fagade 
 of the Ca d'Oro at Venice in mediaeval domestic, or the 
 chapel of Rosslyn in northern Gothic, may suggest ideas, 
 but in its lighter and more wayward forms among the 
 pleasant and graceful buildings that mingle with the 
 sylvan scenery of our parks and gardens, and add by their 
 brightness to the charm of the picturesque. If some- 
 times the strains of lyric art need apology, they have it 
 in their playfulness ; but to avoid offence such play 
 needs to be like that of Leonardo da Vinci's caricatures, 
 that, in all their exuberance of whim, never transgressed 
 anatomy. It is a possible but confessedly a dangerous 
 experiment, for there are borders and precipices in art 
 as in nature and in morals ; but it is possible to 
 approach the brink without falling over. Within these 
 limits then let lyric art have free play for all the poetry 
 of its gay inventiveness ; for, so long as the freshness 
 of wit and whim breaks out in genial happiness from 
 the human heart, it would be but morbid temper and 
 sour criticism to mar the passing joy. Let the world 
 be free and happy ; only, when it plays with art, let it 
 play within the bounds of natural enthusiasm and self- 
 respect. Transgress that limit, and all beyond it is but 
 a wilderness of offensive, unreal, untrue, and vulgar 
 vanity. 
 
 But it needs no wandering into the byways of the 
 arts to afford brightness to common life. In the busy 
 struggle of our English life it has been a blessing to 
 have found such resource of real pleasure and benefit 
 to our people as the arts afford. 
 
 Even if our experience or witness of actual life be 
 
28 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 insufficient, it needs but little stretch of imagination to 
 picture to ourselves realities which, in every class of our 
 social state, are hidden from the outside world by the 
 tender care, the refinement, the self-sacrifice of those 
 who labour on, though irksomely, for others from whom, 
 through age and trouble, all hope and resource has 
 been cut off. Many are they, to whom Nature has 
 denied strength for severer work, who thus occupy 
 themselves in the simpler spheres of art persons of 
 whom the world might well be proud if it did but 
 know them : angelic lives in dreary homes ; a living 
 smile where all else is sad. 
 
 But art's highest sphere is one of intellectual interest 
 and attainment, apart from all private or individual 
 value the sphere of national service, by which the 
 cultivation of a whole people is affected ; and, whether 
 observed or unobserved by themselves, their interests 
 and pursuits, their labour and their recreation are 
 supplied and enlightened by it. 
 
 But we have a very mixed multitude to deal with. 
 There are classes among our fellow-men over whom 
 shadows seem to have settled impenetrably, and the 
 dulness of their dreary homes has driven them to drown 
 their weariness in vice. It would be a worthy work to 
 open the eyes of such as they are to their own relief, 
 and to show them how close it is within their reach. 
 We believe that by the narrow wedge of counter- 
 attractions we may introduce elements of interest and 
 occupation that will raise the tone and purify the 
 motives and habits of our people, and shaming them 
 away from evil, may induce some brighter thought and 
 hopefulness of life to disperse its shadows. 
 
 I passed two cottages, and, by the aspect of their 
 windows side by side, the thought was forced on me 
 how strong must be the contrast in character and life 
 of those within them. One window was bright with its 
 
TO COMMON LIFE 29 
 
 pots of simple flowers, and, like the door beside it, it 
 was shaded by wreaths of clustering rose and honey- 
 suckle. The other was broken, dirty, and neglected, 
 with a tattered rag hung up within to hide all behind 
 it. I ventured to enter them. One family met me 
 with a smile, the other with a frown. Not long after I 
 learnt that a child from that forlorn abode brought 
 home a simple prize from school ; it was a coloured 
 print. Her mother pinned it to the dirty wall, and the 
 cobwebs were brushed away. Its bright colours and 
 clean border seemed a pleasure, and made the disorder 
 and raggedness around it painful. The child had felt 
 the happiness of encouragement. Next year another 
 bright-looking prize was added to the stock. Some 
 pride then touched the heart of the family. Those 
 small treasures became precious to them as things of 
 beauty. Insensibly other little ornaments accumulated, 
 and the other walls were cleaned to receive them. The 
 seed was sown, and the infection spread. After a while 
 the whole cottage became orderly as it never used to 
 be. The garden, once but a wilderness, was tended, 
 and flowers were in the windows, and, as time wore on, 
 a bright and cheery gleam seemed to shine where all 
 before had been sad and shadowy. Another year I 
 passed those cottages again, no more contrasted as in 
 former days ; both bright and clean and cheery ; and, 
 entering them, I was met with frowns no more. 
 
 It was no development of artistic sense in that 
 family that turned their wretched home into a com- 
 parative paradise. It was the gradual influence of 
 educating beauty falling on ground capable of receiving 
 it ; and that influence, the educating influence of experi- 
 ence, must be the basis of all that we can hope to do, 
 to undermine the degradation and disgrace around us, 
 and by the narrow edge of better things to introduce with 
 patience the materials of a higher and a happier life. 
 
30 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 Of all the vices which pollute the source and thwart 
 the progress of fine art, the striving after novelty is 
 among the worst. No one versed in his art could be 
 guilty of it. But it is no uncommon thing to hear 
 complaints of the trammels of old principles ; and 
 arguments are warm and numerous that it is but a 
 miserable slavery to be tied down to follow in the steps 
 of generations whom we have altogether surpassed in 
 civilisation and intelligence ; that our ideas and habits 
 of life are different ; that we are capable of striking 
 out new principles ; and that art, like other things, 
 must be changed to meet them. They say that people 
 are wearied with the everlasting sameness, that art 
 used on its old system is used up ; but that it is infinite 
 in its capabilities, that a new standpoint is possible, 
 and then, all trammels being removed, fresh ideas, fresh 
 principles, fresh effects would rise fresh, beautiful, and 
 complete as Minerva from the head of Jove, or Aphro- 
 dite from the foam of the sea. But, in truth, art is no 
 more than the representative of human thoughts and 
 feelings, and it is they that must first be changed. 
 
 Originality is a precious, but a perilous talent, with 
 a good and a bad side to it, like many other worse and 
 better things, the best being that which is ignorant of 
 its own existence. Original ideas are not got by looking 
 for them. The most true and precious originality is 
 that which venerates the humanity from which it sprang, 
 and loves the old things and ways that generations of 
 human hearts and poetry have consecrated, and then, 
 with warmth and brilliancy all its own, breaks forth 
 with beauty born afresh, and age transformed into the 
 bloom of youth. 
 
 But it needs the touch of supreme refinement to 
 play with novelty. All that we poor mortals can do 
 by mental labour is but little otherwise than that which 
 is the sum total of the labour of our hands the moving 
 
TO COMMON LIFE 31 
 
 of old things into new places. The course of human 
 genius is like that of a river ; at one time sleeping in 
 the quietude of deep pools, losing all identity with the 
 running stream, and reflecting all things from its lucid 
 surface ; at another time impulsive, rapid, and irresistible. 
 Originality may turn the old river into a new channel, 
 but it is only the channel that is new. The genius 
 most precious to mankind is continuous : if not in 
 itself, at least in the vitality it imparts to others, as 
 trees which seed themselves and yet are always different. 
 Originality that is sudden and spasmodic fascinates, 
 but is of little use. Our poet -artist Blake was the 
 master of it. He wrote and drew with marvellous 
 genius, but I doubt whether any one has or would care 
 to follow in his steps. Nature allows no break. The 
 river's meandering course is the solution of all our 
 riddle ; and though enthusiasm may disturb, and 
 aspiring youth may fret, Nature, whether that around 
 us or that within us, will ever guide the ceaseless stream. 
 If any nation ever had to begin its arts again, it 
 was England nearly a century ago. A few great names, 
 like Wren and Inigo Jones, Hogarth, Reynolds, Gains- 
 borough, Flaxman, Wedgewood, and some others, seemed 
 to stand out like tops of mountains above the mist. 
 Such names cast a halo of glory on their age, but the 
 public was but half alive to it. If, a few hundred 
 years ago, the fanatics and panoclasts of the coun- 
 try had been instructed to smash everything that was 
 hideous, instead of destroying everything refined and 
 beautiful that the care and intellect of ages had 
 produced, we should still have in England models of 
 national arts to our incalculable advantage. In spite 
 of that, however, art began again in earnest ; but with 
 it sprang up a new difficulty, not by the want but by 
 the plethora of models, making the education of public 
 taste all but hopeless. The confusion of all the styles 
 
32 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 of art of the habitable world, ancient and modern, was 
 cast before it like a flood, and public taste broke down, 
 like an overworked linguist, under the multitude of his 
 languages, jumbling his words and idioms into nonsense. 
 But experience will cure all this. 
 
 The poetry of art is no mere transient sentiment, 
 except to minds incapable of no more ; nor is the 
 artist's study of sounds, forms, and colours mere super- 
 ficial dealing with Nature's accidents. They are to 
 him realities for which he acknowledges responsibility. 
 For the purpose of his art, and of all that is to result 
 from it, he cannot know too much nor feel too deeply ; 
 for feeling without knowledge can produce no science, 
 and knowledge without feeling can produce no art. 
 With him the real and the ideal are in close contact. 
 His work is to make ideal things realities and realities 
 ideal. There is a perpetual movement within his mind 
 between the material and spiritual world. Sounds, 
 forms, and colours are not things the musician, the 
 sculptor, or the painter cares to rest on but for the 
 expression of his thoughts. The poet, the musician, 
 the artist are all one in relation to the world of things 
 and of their fellow-men. The whole realm of nature 
 is theirs but not for themselves. It is a large patri- 
 mony to -inherit ; and it is the free possession of all 
 who have sense and power to perceive and appreciate 
 it a noble inheritance, without dispute of title, equally 
 for the humble and the noble, the rich and the poor ; 
 the home of that beneficent power that ministers to the 
 happiness of their life. Nature has been art's nursery, 
 art's school, art's workshop, art's council chamber. In- 
 firmity may dull its sight and bar its upward course, 
 but the goal to which Nature points its way is a lofty 
 one a pure ideal where the human and divine life 
 meet. 
 
 The perception of beauty is one of the most pre- 
 
TO COMMON LIFE 33 
 
 cious endowments with which God has blessed humanity. 
 The wise and benevolent do well to foster it in their 
 fellow-men ; and we do well to bless God for the 
 inestimable gift, so far as we possess it ourselves, 
 accepting the ministry of art as the surest means for 
 its cultivation to enlighten and refresh the world, and 
 accepting, in relation to it, the fundamental testimony 
 of Nature, that God has spread man's path with beauty 
 because He has consigned his life to work. 
 
 D 
 
ESSAY III 
 
 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART TO SPIRITUAL LIFE 
 
 F all the services that Fine Art has rendered to man- 
 kind the most valuable is that by which it has 
 evoked and cultivated the spirit-born faculty of the im- 
 agination. It has done so by the power of that element 
 in Nature that we know as beauty, an element that per- 
 vades the universe, exhibiting itself both morally and 
 materially, not merely in the outward guise of things, 
 but in the whole order of their being. Beauty is a 
 reality most evident and most mysterious, of which 
 science may explain the intermediary action, but can- 
 not touch either its beginning or its end ; but which the 
 human soul, looking both farther back and farther for- 
 ward, perceives as an element of divine life, and through 
 it is conscious of the silent witness of Himself, by the 
 Creator, to the spiritual comprehension of His creatures. 
 
 But as Nature is art's prototype and the source 
 from which all external effects of beauty are derived, 
 one might have inclined to attribute to it all the power 
 requisite for this beneficent influence ; but it is not so. 
 The effects of external Nature upon many minds is 
 too direct; they receive from them no more than im- 
 mediate and ordinary impressions ; and in many cases 
 the circumstances of life and their own dispositions 
 disqualify them for any refined perception. Nature 
 may seem beautiful to them and pleasant, but only 
 
ESSAY in THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART 35 
 
 so as an affair of daily occurrence, and too familiar to 
 arouse any special feeling. It is possible on the con- 
 trary for the effect of art upon such minds to be very 
 different, for art is Nature with humanity superadded, 
 and thus bringing with it the human idea of Nature's 
 beauty, it helps them by the power of an unconscious 
 sympathy to perceive what otherwise would have passed 
 unheeded. 
 
 But like many other things fine art is a power for 
 evil as well as good, and its attractiveness makes that 
 power great. For evil, we find it in works of vanity 
 and vice ; for good, we see it in the fire which shines 
 from beneath the surface of good men's works. Will 
 and genius are the sources of its power, and thus a 
 work of marble or of colours becomes a thing of pur- 
 pose and of life ; and a more true and clear exponent 
 than language of men's nature and men's thoughts, for 
 language may hide and pervert truth, but art would 
 convict itself of the lie it would try to tell. 
 
 The impulse of art comes the artist knows not 
 whence. An irresistible and untraceable ideal haunts 
 him ; its imagery falls on him like a reflection from 
 another state of being ; the mystery of it engages 
 him, the beauty of it fascinates him ; its power in- 
 creases in his search to realise it ; his heart and mind 
 are oppressed at the sense of it, and the expression of 
 it by his art alone affords the means of their relief. A 
 work of art comes forth because it must. 
 
 The first rude sculptor may well have started back, 
 agitated before the embodiment of his soul's concep- 
 tion. Whence that conception ? Forms of an unsought 
 imagery had passed before him. The breath of a 
 strange influence had impinged upon his thought as 
 mysteriously as the light air wafts across his forehead. 
 Whence came it and whither it went he knew not ; but 
 now it stands before him a reality, startling in its 
 
36 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 reality, an embodied shadow, an emanation from his 
 own life, a film of thought that had flashed out from 
 the unknown, and was the next moment lost, like a 
 fragrance from the earth or the gloss upon the dew, 
 but caught up, recovered, reproduced by his rude skill. 
 Whence was the birth of that first image ? Was it in 
 an agony of grief or terror, or throb of conscience, or 
 in emotion aroused by the sublime effects of Nature's 
 awful grandeur, that an ideal of unearthly majesty had 
 struck and stamped itself on his imagination ? He 
 looked blindly into infinity, conscious of a light he 
 could not see, and the reality of the unseen had forced 
 upon him the idea of Deity. He felt the divine ele- 
 ment in life, he felt the divine life in things, he 
 fashioned the symbols of them, he realised their 
 forms, his own impassioned life transfused them, and 
 the people called them Gods. 
 
 As with that primitive sculptor, so art, in all time, has 
 been and is the creature and the producer of emotion ; 
 and most natural therefore is it that the subject which 
 produces the deepest emotions produces the greatest 
 art. The impulses of poetry, simplest or most sublime, 
 and the emotions of religion are its congenial elements. 
 Its strength is in their strength. The eloquence of 
 literature and of speech may have more power to repel, 
 but attraction is art's own prerogative. Wickedness and 
 horror may be pictured in vain, but by appeals to the 
 heart and conscience through what is lovely, pure, and 
 true, it wins every cause it pleads. Illustrations of 
 agony, vice, and shame are themselves as repulsive as 
 the evils they wish to cure. It is hard to believe that 
 Hogarth's pictures of the Rake's progress ever stopped 
 the course of vice, or that Morland's illustrations of the 
 fall and ruin of Letitia ever stayed the folly of a frivolous 
 girl. But there can be no doubt of art's power to 
 clench a conviction once received, from whatever source 
 
in TO SPIRITUAL LIFE 37 
 
 derived, or to add force equally to superstition or to 
 truth ; for the arts of all times have illustrated this, 
 from the idol and fetich of the savage, which was but 
 the embodiment of the demon of his dread, to the per- 
 fected arts of both Pagan and Christian civilisation. 
 
 The embodiment of the religious ideal, and deeper 
 far than that, the Impersonation of that ideal, has been, 
 through all ages, a longing desire of mankind, approach- 
 ing a necessity. The irresistible conviction of spiritual 
 existence, the idea of the power and beauty of invisible 
 things, has so possessed the minds and imaginations of 
 men, that the whole material universe has been peopled 
 with them, from the gods and goddesses who reigned in 
 the starry heavens, to those bright and graceful beings 
 with which mythology has filled the woods and foun- 
 tains, the rocks, the ocean, and the very air itself. Im- 
 personation of deity in human form was the highest 
 ideal on which the Pagan arts had been perfected. 
 Those arts had swayed the emotions of men ; but yet, 
 with all their beauty and with all their power, an im- 
 penetrable shadow hung over them. There was a sad- 
 ness in their joy ; satisfaction was incomplete. The 
 impersonation was inanimate. The story of Pygmalion 
 was but the common dream of men ; they felt after 
 divine life, and longed for it with a certainty of its 
 reality and truth of which their unaided senses were 
 incapable. Human sense had vainly grasped at what 
 the human spirit had yearned to see ; but only the 
 material of an inanimate symbol was all that art could 
 give in reply. Neither intellect nor sense were satis- 
 fied. The heart, the mainspring of humanity, was not 
 relieved. A great ideal in philosophy, in literature, 
 and in art had for ages occupied the mind and imagi- 
 nation of mankind. But whence its power if it were 
 but a thing of fancy or a dream ? The whole fabric of 
 it would have long since perished but for the uncon- 
 
38 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 querable conviction of its inward truth. That convic- 
 tion was the forecast of a great reality. From remotest 
 antiquity all art had strained its eyes to that subject of 
 mankind's unconscious prophecy. The loftiest music of 
 all poetry had raised its voice to it. What the hearts 
 of all nations had longed for was the Impersonation of 
 Life ; and at length, and in the fulness of time, that 
 Life was manifested ; that Life was the light of men, 
 and the heart of humanity was satisfied. 
 
 The Christian artist is like the sower who went 
 forth to sow : and art is truly a divine seed, whose fruit 
 is for the sweetness of man's life, and with it he need 
 not sow in tears to reap in joy. Art has many func- 
 tions in the world, for use, for livelihood, for enlighten- 
 ment, for honour ; but the artist's highest commission 
 is to teach the world, through the evidence of the uni- 
 verse, in the mystery of beauty, the provision of the 
 Creator for the happiness of His creatures. The divine 
 attributes of power and infinity might overwhelm the 
 world with fear, but the attribute of love reassures it. 
 Beauty is the symbol of divine love. Reason cannot de- 
 fine nor imagination fathom it ; and he that bears the 
 commission of that message can do no more than, by 
 the simple eloquence of truth, to win the sympathies of 
 men, and to train them, as he has trained himself, to see 
 in the lineaments of beauty not the mere fancy of a 
 fascinated sense, but a power overlying, underlying, per- 
 vading all things the mystery of Beauty ; not a mere 
 quality of material, but an element of life ; not a mere 
 accident in Nature, but a designed purpose of its 
 existence. 
 
 But if the hand of its Creator is to be sought in 
 Nature, it must be upward and not downward. The 
 destructive process of analysis would only dig deeper 
 the grave of spiritual sense, if conviction were sought 
 among the scientific tests of material evidence. There 
 
in TO SPIRITUAL LIFE 39 
 
 is evidence most rich and precious in such phenomenal 
 analysis ; but the perception of the truth to which it 
 witnesses varies according to the animus with which it 
 is approached. To seek God in Nature, and to test 
 His dealings with men as though He were a force, a 
 quality, a machine, a thing obedient to the search or 
 subject to speculation, which if wrong would fail, but 
 if right would " find out God," would be to reverse the 
 order of existence, and to make man, not God, the 
 master. 
 
 Nor can intellectual analysis by the tests of philo- 
 sophy succeed any better, for the same reason. The 
 Master must be first acknowledged before he is sought. 
 It is their Master and not man that must bow the 
 heavens if He is to come down. So the search by hard 
 reasoning stultifies itself, because on these most certain 
 grounds it is unreasonable. The gist of the whole 
 matter had been misconceived, and the scaling ladder 
 had been placed on a wrong foundation, and against a 
 wall where nothing was to be gained. But another 
 mode of approach is possible, where reason would be 
 right ; for, on the ground of mere consistency, if spiritual 
 Being is the object of inquiry, the evidence must be 
 spiritual, no matter through what means it is conveyed, 
 and its discernment must be spiritual also ; and reason 
 directed thus upward, and not downward, would then 
 reach "the mind of God." So too Nature, the out- 
 come of its Maker's inscrutable intentions, is incompre- 
 hensible unless similarly approached. The discoveries 
 of science in material and life surpass all art and 
 poetry in the sublimity of that view of Nature's per- 
 fect cosmos which they spread before the imagination. 
 Whether they be her recorded facts, or theories so 
 firmly based as to be accepted certainties, the revelations 
 of science are precious stepping-stones, capable of lead- 
 ing to invaluable evidence ; but, again, it is the animus 
 
40 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 that takes those steps that leads either to light or dark- 
 ness, if the attempt be to elucidate the ideal of what 
 Nature is. 
 
 With such purpose in view, to study Nature's things 
 without reference to that Master power whose will they 
 unconsciously represent, would be to deviate at its very 
 source the stream of all intelligence and response, to 
 pervert and to befool the highest faculties of humanity, 
 which have no worth in themselves nor meaning beyond 
 themselves, except in relation to Him whose purposes, 
 known or unknown, are the causes of their existence, 
 and the only assignable reason of their being. The 
 illimitable conceptions of which mind is capable are 
 themselves a sufficient evidence that, in the sphere of 
 human existence, material is but the method, not the 
 end of life ; and that steps of progress, if there be steps 
 at all, must be steps trodden on sense for the very pur- 
 pose of reaching things beyond sense. The beauty of 
 the universe, which comes of the union of material and 
 life, tells with irresistible evidence of an authorship and 
 a rule of supreme Will ; and that is a power inconceiv- 
 able unless associated with personality of individual 
 being. The unity of Nature implies the unity of that 
 Will ; but such supremacy as this surpasses govern- 
 ment, for government is not an originating authority, 
 but an intermediary power to continue order initiated 
 by another, and therefore only sharing a divided allegi- 
 ance. A supremacy compatible with perfection must 
 therefore reach from beginning to end, and origin and 
 destiny, no less than present rule, must be among its 
 prerogatives. 
 
 But the upward steps which lead to such conviction 
 as this do not stop here. We find here not only the 
 action of one supreme and undivided Will, without 
 which cosmos would be chaos, but beyond this the con- 
 sideration of its perfect work forces upon our conviction 
 
in TO SPIRITUAL LIFE 41 
 
 the complex character of that Will a triple power, the 
 power of initiative authority the power of intermediary 
 intelligence and contact between the formative com- 
 mand and the obedient material and the power of 
 administrative life, to which mind owes illumination, 
 the forces of Nature their continuance, and the equili- 
 brium of all things its stability. By such alone, 
 whether creation be by immediate act or by endow- 
 ment expanding itself to perfection through eternity, it 
 matters not, for human mind can fathom neither but 
 by such alone and at once the very existence of the 
 universe appears possible, and its beauty compre- 
 hensible. 
 
 The impulse of a spiritual ideal has ever been an 
 agitating power within the human heart ; but religion, 
 which is its practical expression, has been too often and 
 wilfully misconceived and mistaught, as though its 
 origin had been in the consciousness of human weak- 
 ness overwhelmed in contrast with Nature's power and 
 immensity. But superstition is not religion, and devo- 
 tion is incompatible with terror. The intuitive con- 
 science of each individual, perceptive of its own posi- 
 tion in the world, conscious, from the very nature of 
 things, that the anomalies which surround it are but 
 transitory material combined with spirit, good and 
 evil side by side takes the order of beauty in the uni- 
 verse as its guiding light, and is conscious of the 
 response of Nature's life to its own unutterable appeals. 
 Thus is it that, pining for expression, the artist takes 
 the things, the forms, the beings that surround him as 
 the only available interpreters of his thought, the light 
 and darkness, life and death, storm and calm, growth 
 and decay, equal in their awfulness and in their beauty, 
 and with them as the symbolic language of his convic- 
 tion, his worship, and his love, he pours out his soul to 
 God and man. 
 
42 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 To such an one, the tenor of whose study for his 
 art, among the things and effects of the world around 
 him, has led him to regard beauty as but a veil separat- 
 ing the seen from the unseen of Nature, and through it 
 to watch that great Master-spirit of life that moves 
 among its vast machinery, it is as painful as it is strange 
 to witness the course of other minds, profoundly trained 
 in the knowledge of the same material universe, and of 
 the relationship their own intelligence bears towards it, 
 arriving by various paths of study to the same place as 
 himself, but then to stop, refusing to go on. Whether 
 it be from invincible aversion, or from the pride of am- 
 bitious intellect, mistaking its freedom for independence, 
 their result is the opposite of his own. They appear 
 to have placed intentionally a bar to all progress beyond 
 their own special sphere of thought or knowledge, as 
 though there were but one basis for reasonable intelli- 
 gence, and but one approach to sure convictions. The 
 disposition and habits to which their minds are trained 
 are contrary to such considerations ; for having elimi- 
 nated from Nature its Creator and man's intelligent soul, 
 as having no part in it, and content to register the 
 appearances and to calculate the latent forces of Nature, 
 but disregarding that latent Life which is the secret of 
 them all, the direct and mechanical conclusions from 
 material appear to them alone consistent with right 
 reason, and all else no better than delusion. The sub- 
 jects of their studies are, indeed, of inexhaustible inte- 
 rest, and the value of them inestimable to all mankind ; 
 but their pursuit appears at fault when the means, 
 which seemed to minister to strength and breadth of 
 intellect, end only in binding round it the bands of an 
 exclusive system intolerant of all others beside or 
 beyond it. 
 
 The ultimate goal to which such subjects of con- 
 templation and study appear to other minds, that take 
 
in TO SPIRITUAL LIFE 43 
 
 a larger range, less barred by speciality than theirs, 
 naturally to lead, is the great truth which alone is of 
 paramount interest to mankind, his destiny ; but to such 
 as refuse to look beyond the realm of sense, and cannot 
 because they will not see, the result has too often been 
 to habituate the mind to a strict and stern correctness 
 in one direction alone ; so the mental vision becomes 
 warped and clouded to all else, and at last distorted to 
 believe that nought else was possible. Intellect was 
 glorified, but the soul ignored. 
 
 There is, however, another sphere of life and sight 
 to which their eyes are never raised ; and there is 
 another atmosphere than that which impinges on the 
 material to which they cling, the atmosphere of a liberty 
 that is none the less complete because it acknowledges 
 the service of a Master for that service is one that 
 saves a man from himself, and is his only perfect 
 freedom. 
 
 To reach such healthy breadth of view, and to 
 estimate aright, in their worth and relationship, the 
 spirit of the man within him and of the material around 
 him, the great machinery of his intelligence needs the 
 mutuality of all its faculties as completely as those of 
 the body are needed for the healthy action of its life. 
 No mental function can arrogate its own independence 
 and sufficiency without a fall. Conscience uninformed 
 and undisciplined grows morbid and oblique; imagina- 
 tion may soar superior to the other faculties, but grows 
 vain and bewildered without the weight and balance of 
 the rest ; so too reason and sense cannot stand alone 
 without loss : unaided, they would make but a crippled 
 machine to trust the course of life to, without conscience 
 to restrain and imagination to liberate them. The 
 work of imagination, too subtle for verbal definition, 
 too vast and varied for mental grasp, thus disciplined, 
 supported, and supplied, is, both in purpose and effect, 
 
44 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 essentially and practically real ; it is the source of 
 invention in active life, of relief and exhilaration in 
 wearied life, and the aid upward from baser to better 
 life in whatever form it be regarded. Its work is no 
 vague dream. The powers and beauty of the external 
 world give form and fashion to it, whether in the realm 
 of moral or material ; to its authorship are due man- 
 kind's most imperishable monuments ; but the prompt- 
 ings to which its own vitality responds (for all subjects 
 take their colour from men's minds) come from the 
 deep things of Nature, and those are no other than "the 
 deep things of God." It is the mirror into which beauty 
 is reflected, to be presented to the vision of the soul. 
 It is the faculty through which the fine arts those 
 faithful intermediaries of all human sympathy minister 
 to spiritual life. When not marred and darkened by 
 an evil will, it is a divinely-constituted means of spiritual 
 intelligence, illuminating mortal sense from the fountain 
 of immortality. It is a creative power within that 
 gives form to spirit, substance to faith, and reality to 
 the unseen. Without it how desolate the wilderness, 
 how deep the darkness through which the spiritual 
 vision strains toward the light that gleams above the 
 horizon of mortal sense ; but with unflinching gaze it 
 follows upward to its source the ray that issues from 
 the Light that lightens light itself. Imagination is 
 that great faculty by which the soul ascends to the 
 contemplation of the Divine nature, and listens to that 
 Voice that is in the stillness of the universe. Without 
 it that precious spark would die, which, among the 
 paradox and mystery of existence, like a shining star, 
 makes clear the pathway from the life we know to the 
 life we are conscious of, but know not ; supporting the 
 timid soul by that certainty of its divine relationship 
 which raises it for ever. 
 
 The immortal soul is self-conscious. It is conscious 
 
in TO SPIRITUAL LIFE 45 
 
 too of universal life, and of its own place in it. In- 
 fidelity has offered to it the gospel of Death, and it has 
 refused it. It is satisfied with the knowledge of the 
 fact of mystery, as that without which eternity would 
 be an idle void. It listens to the echoes of a distant 
 past. It has never let go the hand of God. It sees 
 and hears His guiding spirit in the trial sphere of 
 human life. It knows His footsteps ; it sees His light; 
 it traces Him in the excellence and beauty of the 
 universe, for all Nature is His parable. 
 
 But the influence of fine art upon thought and life, 
 both in those who produce and in those who receive it, 
 depends upon the tenor of individual disposition and 
 capacity ; for some minds turn all poetry to prose, and 
 some invest the simplest things with the halo of their 
 own brightness ; and thus it happens that the appeals 
 of beauty through the forms of art too often fail. Its 
 elements are insoluble in some minds ; and, as the 
 course of life is often rough, and the ways of it not 
 ways of pleasantness, but of infirmity and depression, 
 it too often happens that, amid the absorbing neces- 
 sities which harden practical life, fine art is valued 
 by the multitude rather for its furniture than its 
 poetry. 
 
 Regard for one moment the effect of a great picture 
 and sculpture gallery upon the mass of the spectators. 
 What do they find ? a vast array of pictures and statues, 
 portraits and landscapes of all nationalities ; here and 
 there a scenic representation of a religious subject from 
 one school, or an academic composition from another ; 
 then, more rarely indeed, a gem of devotional expres- 
 sion ; the rest are portraits, boats, or battles, or domestic 
 scenes most picturesque, or of vice and revelry most 
 offensive ; and the sight-seers disperse, some perhaps 
 delighted with their entertainment and exhilarated by 
 its brightness, and some perhaps utterly confounded by 
 
46 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 its multiplicity. But pause one moment. There were 
 some who lingered there and went away thoughtfully, 
 for there were those among that multitude men, 
 women, and children too on whom some lovely ray 
 of thought had struck. The poetry of colour, the 
 mystic charm of Nature's truth and beauty, or the 
 aspirations of devotional expression, still breathing from 
 the surface of some old canvas as the poor artist had 
 left it, with his last sigh, a legacy for the world, had 
 found their kindred spirits, and had struck home at 
 last. Those were the souls that Nature had already 
 tuned, and the old artist's poetry had struck them and 
 brought out their music. 
 
 But the source of the inspiration of art's poetry, that 
 comes as a breath we know not whence, must be sought 
 far deeper than in the emotion of the passing moment. 
 The power whence springs that impulse, whose ultimate 
 result is art, must not be measured by the means of its 
 expression. The urgent motive, the rapid search, the 
 restless spirit battling against the bondage of material 
 all witness to a living power impatient of control. That 
 impulse is indeed vivid, vigorous, irresistible, as those who 
 have felt it know right well, as though mastered by some 
 mighty will, or urged forward by some great unseen 
 hand ; but whence comes our power to respond to it ? 
 Whence in our nature does that throb of sympathy 
 arise that answers to the call of the spirit of beauty 
 and truth ? That power is ours, but it comes of too 
 long an ancestry to be traceable only among the 
 surroundings of present life. But are we left to that 
 alone ? Are love, thought, and memory bounded by 
 its limits ? Have hope and terror no history beyond 
 the annals of humanity ? Has the majesty of philo- 
 sophy, the pride of knowledge, the reign of sense, ever 
 satisfied mankind ? 
 
 What is the secret of that power that holds the 
 
in TO SPIRITUAL LIFE 47 
 
 mind enthralled as the after-glow of sunset fills the 
 eyes ? Whence comes that sense of rest and yet of 
 longing, lingering desire as the sight loses itself in that 
 ocean of light ? Why no sense of solitude in those 
 awful depths ; no fear, but only joy in that sublime 
 infinitude ? Why ? but for the conscious presence of 
 more there than sight perceives. That glorious sheen 
 of light and colour is but the clothing of a sphere of 
 life into which we pierce and find no strangeness in it. 
 Its fascination is not that of novelty, but of reminis- 
 cence. We are no more alone : a sense of relationship 
 to all that sphere contains invites onward, as to a home 
 once known and long since left, but not forgotten 
 another but a true sphere of life a spiritual scenery 
 reflected from heaven's mirror. Thus does sublimity 
 of external effect, which only art's deepest poetry can 
 recall, stir in the affections of the human breast the 
 echoes of life beyond the horizon of our sight a life 
 not lost, but, like the sunset, sunk beneath the shadows 
 of a distant past, shrouded from sight and interrupted 
 for a while, as though to test fidelity a life once ours, 
 ours still, and ours for ever: no dream, but the con- 
 scious reality of the silent soul. 
 
 The spirit of beauty, whether enshrined in material 
 or moral form, the beauty of strength or weakness, the 
 beauty of reality or idea, all come from the same source 
 whence our own nature itself has come, and has been 
 endowed with power to feel and to comprehend it. 
 That spirit of beauty, like the Spirit of the Eternal 
 Being, of whose presence and character beauty is itself 
 both the evidence and the purest symbol, is appre- 
 hended not by the scrutiny of the intellect but by 
 the affections of the heart ; and fine art, profoundly 
 more a thing of spirit than of sense, is the minister . 
 commissioned to interpret its lovely parables to the 
 world. 
 
48 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 There is an Oriental adage that " Beauty is in the 
 eye of him who sees it " an expression most true, 
 indeed, if by it is understood that power of mental 
 sight beyond mere physical sense ; for then the inde- 
 pendence of the spirit of beauty is rightly apprehended 
 as an element as subtle as life itself, an element of ex- 
 traneous existence by which, through sense, the mental 
 faculty is impressed ; but it is most untrue if by that 
 saying it be implied that the perception of beauty is 
 but a whim or waif of poetic fancy, self-deceptive, 
 applying a bright quality of itself to the things it calls 
 beautiful ; as though the emotions of the imagination 
 were created by a power which it had first created 
 itself! 
 
 No ; beauty, like the spirit of life, in its own nature 
 infinite and independent, such as no time nor place can 
 bound, no thought can grasp, nor words define, is the 
 subtlest witness that the universe affords of the nature 
 of spiritual life. It is as a bridge connecting two 
 worlds : on one side leading to infinitude of all perfec- 
 tion, on the other, attached to material, not as though 
 belonging to it, nor bounded by it, but transcending 
 every quality it possesses, investing them with its own 
 excellence, and overflowing them with its illimitable, 
 irrestrainable stream of life. What is there in inert 
 material, unfathomable mystery though it be, that can 
 touch the spiritual element of mind and emotion ? 
 What sympathy can there be between what is lifeless, 
 unstable, corruptible, and spirit that thing of immor- 
 tality ? Surely none ; but the spirit of beauty can 
 and does transfuse material, and does animate the en- 
 dowments of bodily sense with power to penetrate the 
 thin shadow that separates those two worlds, and 
 opens to the prisoned spirit of the man an access, 
 clear and unrestrained, to the free air of the world 
 invisible to him. 
 
in TO SPIRITUAL LIFE 49 
 
 To such an one, whether practically an artist or 
 not, but at least contemplatively one, whose powers 
 of natural insight have been cultivated and refined 
 by all that it is Art's sacred mission to teach to such 
 an one Nature has opened wide her treasury of divine 
 life. She has spread before the eyes of his responsive 
 spirit, in a vista of infinity, the mystery of divine 
 beauty. Unsolved, unsolvable ! He gazes with 
 adoration ; the highest faculties of his nature, of 
 body, soul, and spirit, in silence bow before it. Sense 
 perceives, imagination portrays, reason accepts, con- 
 science assures, with all the power of their blended 
 testimony, that that inscrutable mystery of beauty is 
 the mode in which it has pleased the blessed God to 
 communicate to His creatures the perfection of His 
 wisdom and His love. 
 
 The sublime vision is beyond the range of mortal 
 sight ; the moral sense, that voice of the soul within, 
 has answered " Yes " ; and then the heart turns to 
 its course in human life, the sphere of a short pil- 
 grimage, fortified and content. The convictions which 
 thought, study, and the experience of life had heaped 
 together stored, sorted, purified in the great labora- 
 tory of memory have been illuminated by a ray from 
 the throne of immortality. Fear vanishes. Difficulties 
 which tempt, infirmities which impede, are but the 
 discipline of an existence conscious of its own transi- 
 tory nature. The way of life lies out before. The 
 light of divine beauty has been shed upon it : and 
 thus along the pathway of this mortal life, whether 
 it be earthward or heavenward, the footsteps of the 
 travellers are made light and their hearts rejoiced 
 with the blessings of assurance and of peace. 
 
 Such is the lovely message that Fine Art is com- 
 missioned to carry to the world ; and such is its work, 
 to minister to the spiritual life of those who seek it. 
 
 E 
 
THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART 
 
 ESSAY III 
 
 The origin and consummation of beauty is in 
 that love which God has said He " is." The com- 
 munication of it is the expression of the Will of that 
 love ; and happy they who have their hearts pure and 
 their intelligence of sense and spirit bright, to per- 
 ceive, beneath the outward show of things, the living 
 Majesty of that Wisdom, Power, and Love Divine, 
 whence PERFECT BEAUTY, the fountain of all joy, flows 
 forth for ever. 
 
ESSAY IV 
 
 FINE ART IN ARCHAEOLOGY 
 
 *T^HE arts in archaeology are like the sounds of many 
 voices coming from a distance, arresting our 
 attention by their mystery of mingled clearness and 
 uncertainty, and fascinating us more and more with 
 all the charm of poetry's vague suggestiveness, as they 
 die away upon the distant air. Such opportunities 
 of mental travelling as their pursuit affords over the 
 wide and varied area of past time is the romance of 
 reality, and its intellectual locomotion is as invigorating 
 to the spirit as change of air and scene is to the body. 
 It is a kind of journeying free from all but pleasurable 
 fatigue, so varied as to dismiss all weariness ; or if 
 sometimes the way seems long and the traveller's steps 
 begin to flag, new interests break out where least 
 anticipated, with all their cordial of new hope and 
 enterprise, as refreshing to heart and sense as the oases 
 and springs of the desert. 
 
 What can exceed the interest of that retrospect 
 that spreads before the imagination the light of dawning 
 intellectual life, of which the relics of earliest art are 
 the few remaining testimonies ? But now even they 
 appear strange in age and origin, and the tale they tell 
 seems so lost among the world's morning mists, that all 
 we know of most of them is but the literary notice of 
 some venerable author who handed on from an unre- 
 
52 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 corded source a tradition that had interested him, and 
 left for us no more than the whispering myth of a 
 reality of which only the silhouette remains. Thus is 
 the intensity of interest redoubled as we, who are 
 antiquaries now, regard the works and records of anti- 
 quaries of a long past age, who themselves have plunged 
 into the depths of the age before them. Such was 
 Solon, and such his feeling when, having vaunted the 
 glories and antiquity of his own nation, he sat wrapped 
 in astonished interest as the Egyptian priest, smiling 
 at his small notions of antiquity, recorded to him the 
 origin of his own and other peoples from the great 
 island continent, then long since no more, that once 
 had all but filled the ocean space beyond the pillars of 
 Hercules that wondrous land, the great Atlantis, with 
 its sheltering Alps and fertile plains, rich mines and 
 crowded cities, inhabited by tribes now only dimly 
 known as the Oceanides, the Atlantides, and the 
 Hesperides, a real but now a mythic people, whose 
 story lives only in the romance of unwritten history. 
 
 If archaeology involved no more than a study of 
 things^ old things, it would still find favour with many 
 minds ; but as the study of old things implies also the 
 study of all that throws light upon them, such as what 
 a scientific man would call their environments, and a 
 poet their associations, the boundaries of archaeology 
 become exceedingly wide, and its actual limits hard to 
 define. In it the studies of the scholar, the philosopher, 
 the poet, and the historian find full scope. Its wide 
 range of interest, its scattered facts, its vague suggestive 
 thoughts, tell how great the need its student has of 
 quietude, time, and care, to brings its elements into 
 focus, and to frame for the profit and pleasure of the 
 world the varied pictures it presents. But time is the 
 trouble of our age, and impatience its characteristic ; 
 so the genius of movement in this busy world is apt to 
 
iv FINE ART IN ARCHEOLOGY 53 
 
 regard the antiquary as a sort of living curiosity. It 
 looks on him as a creature infected with mould and 
 rust, and has no idea of the enthusiasm which lies 
 beneath his quiet skin. Happily for human nature, 
 enthusiasm is of many kinds, and is often the shallowest 
 where it is most demonstrative. The fact is that the 
 world knows very little of its component parts, and 
 little does it reflect on the words of the poet who spoke 
 of men's " hermit souls " ; but those words would go to 
 the very heart of an antiquary, and express to him his 
 very self; picturing to him the quiet depth of that 
 stream of gentle but invincible enthusiasm which buoys 
 him up and carries him through his work, brightening 
 the spirit of his enterprise, and rilling the mirror of his 
 contemplation with ideas. I am not confounding per- 
 severance with enthusiasm. An antiquary's work is 
 hard, and there is no doubt of his perseverance if he 
 be worth his rust. It might at first blush be hard to 
 believe in the enthusiasm of writing a dictionary, or of 
 collating dates, or of classifying musty deeds or rusty 
 coins ; but granting its indomitable perseverance, and 
 granting, too, the dry, mechanical labour it involves, I 
 believe that, without that quality of a deep and quiet 
 enthusiasm which is the very life of all good continuous 
 work, the spirit of the archaeologist, whether he be 
 historian, philosopher, poet, or antiquary, would sink 
 beneath its work, and his " hermit soul " would die. 
 
 The association of fine arts with archaeology, and 
 the part they play in it, will be measured by the know- 
 ledge that people have of them, and be valued according 
 to the tone and tenor of their many-sided minds. The 
 thorough antiquary should be at once a historian and 
 an artist. Art and history must go side by side in 
 archaeology to supply and illustrate each other, for 
 what is history without poetry, and what is art without 
 fact ? History is the typal picture of men and things 
 
54 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 in all time ; and art is that power over material by 
 which men in all ages have rejoiced in setting forth to 
 others their deepest thoughts. Thus art and history 
 are bound together, and poetry and philosophy belong 
 to both ; for philosophy is the moral of history, and 
 poetry is that plastic power of illustration which gives 
 life and action to it all. 
 
 What is it that fills the history of ancient art with 
 all its vivid interest, and what is it that endows that 
 art itself with all its captivating charm, but that it 
 embodies the very soul of mankind ? Facts and 
 feelings are equally precious in any just and true 
 estimate of human life ; for feeling is, in truth, a great 
 result, the end of a complicated tissue of sympathies 
 and antipathies that may for the moment be taken as 
 a point of rest. But life cannot rest, and the more 
 intense its power to feel, the more impossible to rest. 
 It may be stayed for a while in contemplation ; it may 
 ponder and linger captivated or overwhelmed : but the 
 fire that smoulders will break out at last ; and the 
 result, in a burst of eloquence, poetry, or art, is the 
 relief of the over-burdened mind. 
 
 To such an origin as this it is that we owe the 
 birth, the growth, and the perfection of ancient art, 
 with all its power to fascinate, to command, and to 
 draw together the whole brotherhood of humanity. It 
 is the design and intention, the warmth and passion of 
 the living man, that glows in that ancient art, that 
 makes it precious to us through all time. The intellect 
 alone may be as cold as the moon and live, but art 
 must have sun in it or die. 
 
 But the broad brotherhood of archaeologists must 
 not be expected to appreciate art alike. Their unani- 
 mous verdict would probably go at least as far as this, 
 that its pursuit was interesting and pleasurable; but 
 only those who could interpret its forms and features 
 
iv FINE ART IN ARCHEOLOGY 55 
 
 into a living language could feel the sacred fire. But 
 if the poetry and symbolism of perfect art is ill under- 
 stood by some, the rudeness of primitive art, and that 
 of half civilised nations, is even less so. But, in truth, 
 rough work is often the most expressive, like a bold 
 sketch dashed off under strong impulse. So with 
 primitive art ; its very roughness and impracticability are 
 often the true signs of an impulse and an idea too big 
 for the untrained mind to grasp, or the hand to form. 
 The form of beauty or of power that the mind of such 
 a man could grasp was one of hard severity, like his 
 life. The angular boldness of its extreme simplicity 
 was the very type of that life which gave it all its 
 interest. It is folly to despise archaic art for want of 
 beauty. It is better far to allow the weakness of the 
 artist, and through his rude lines to love the man, and 
 honour the grandeur of his emotions. There is more 
 vigour of life and heroic grandeur in the bold action of 
 the sculptures of Nineveh than in half the modern art 
 we see, with all its perfection of anatomy and analysis 
 of expression. There is often more touch of nature 
 and intensity of feeling in the architecture and painting 
 of our own middle ages than in many a modern work 
 the world admires. It is folly to talk of their faults of 
 technicality and want of precision, which are evident to 
 all. For what is it that makes all ancient art precious 
 but its testimony to the emotions that impelled it, and of 
 that life, with all its surroundings, its nature, its motives, 
 its joys and pains, that made those emotions possible ? 
 
 Those works are the precious relics of men and 
 nations ; and cold is the sense and shallow the criticism 
 that fails to trace, through all their faulty forms, the fire 
 of their poetry ; and through the rough hewings of their 
 sculpture and the ideal conventionality of their painting, 
 to reverence the simple grandeur of ancient days. 
 
 But the unpoetic or scientific archaeologist, for 
 
56 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 whom the sacred fire burns in vain, will hardly care to 
 regard them in this light. He will be contented to 
 allow that the fine arts have always been associated 
 with the highest intelligence and civilisation of their 
 age. His interest in them is rather for the witness 
 they afford than the beauty they produce. He will 
 value their styles as arbiters of chronology. He will 
 trace up their origin to their fountain head in archi- 
 tecture. He will go farther, and trace up architecture 
 itself to the necessities of construction and materials. 
 He may, and probably rightly, attribute our pointed 
 architecture, with all its grace and piquancy, to the 
 inexhaustible genius of Oriental fancy. He may trace 
 the perfect architecture of classic times to its earliest 
 types in the constructive edifices of wood. The very 
 form of the Pyramids suggests to him their origin, long 
 before the earliest dynasty, in the heaps of piled stones 
 which mark the passage or the resting-places of wander- 
 ing tribes, or the monument of prehistoric victories. 
 And further still in the depth of time, Chinese archi- 
 tecture, with its turned-up ridges and quirked gables, 
 seems to him (as they certainly do to me) to find their 
 first forms in the primitive huts and barns of a race 
 living on the wide watery plains of that land of rivers, 
 where the bamboo, reeds, and rushes gave the first 
 materials ready at hand for roof and shelter. 
 
 Thus will he note the rise and progress of other 
 arts, and trace their development from the ingenuity of 
 human necessity to their employment for the purposes 
 of social life ; but his pleasure in the subject is solely 
 intellectual, and beyond that his sympathies and profit 
 nil. He goes in for knowledge, and the clash of theories 
 and the intellectual pugnacity of schools and scholars 
 only add to the zest and interest of his pursuit. 
 
 Others there are, true archaeologists indeed, who 
 seem to have reversed the order of life, and to have 
 
iv FINE ART IN ARCHAEOLOGY 57 
 
 turned the stream of futurity backward ; individuals to 
 whom pursuit means retrogression, and progress is 
 scored only down the pathway of receding ages. 
 Others again there are, as dry as dust, who love, if 
 they love anything, only what they can see and touch 
 of facts and things, antiquaries of the arid type, men 
 of persistency, of large memories and small sympathies, 
 to whom tedium is unknown, imagination a blank, and 
 romance impossible ; most useful men indeed, who 
 repeat, only in reversed order, what their predecessors 
 did, who in old days occupied the dulness of their un- 
 counted hours in drawing up the inventories of house- 
 hold goods, and properties of church or state or private 
 life ; who doted over their dry lists, page after page 
 with " item " this and " ditto " that, as an auctioneer 
 glories over a catalogue, or a miser eyes his jottings of 
 unprofitable coin ; such dry chroniclers little dreaming, 
 in their sleep of time, what mines of interest they were 
 laying up for us, who draw from them pictures as true 
 as though the realities were before us, of the character 
 of those times remote, of the ways of social and 
 domestic life, the pursuits, the habits, and even the 
 moral worth of those who lived in them. 
 
 The works of art which are the glory of antiquity 
 were accomplished in times when all the world was 
 alert with intrigue or war, or in those short and stirring 
 intervals of peace when warriors devoted their spoils of 
 victory to their country's honour. Those too which 
 adorn the ages nearer to our own, and which now stand 
 up among us as the monuments of peace, the types of 
 the religious spirit that had conceived them and the 
 devotion that had realised them, were no less than 
 their glorious predecessors the accomplishment of 
 nations struggling with moral if not with martial foes, 
 warring with barbarism and fighting for life, amid that 
 movement of events, that gave the motive, the dramatic 
 
58 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 action, the incident, and the very vital spark itself to 
 their unconscious genius. Thus was it that, when all 
 was astir with uncertainty and change, those immortal 
 works of art and poetry were produced which shone 
 like stars in the stormy sky of classic history, and like 
 angels of consolation among the sighs and sorrows of 
 the middle ages. 
 
 Most true it is that both heart and intellect are fed 
 upon the stores of that continuous stream of life which 
 flowed on from age to age, and has left along its banks 
 the scattered pearls of human genius. Far off in the 
 remote ages of geology we may begin to draw our first 
 glimmerings of human history. Their silent annals 
 present a counterpart to the world of intelligence and 
 life, for deeper and deeper as the shaft is driven, the 
 richer and more inexhaustible are the treasures of re- 
 search ; but the whole value of the past is in the use 
 we make of it, and all our accumulated knowledge, 
 whether of material or mind, is no more than lifeless 
 fact and prosy chronicle till touched by the fire of 
 human sympathy. Treasure is of no profit till it can 
 pass into currency ; and facts accumulated into mount- 
 ains are useless to us until we assimilate them. We 
 need to breathe and live on the fresh free air which 
 blows over the wide field of life and things gone by; 
 not only to fill our minds with knowledge, and store 
 them with the treasures of resource, but also to freshen 
 the motive and brace the heart for good work upon the 
 world, the times, and the men around us. 
 
 It would be a melancholy system of dry morality, 
 and a cold philosophy indeed that merely filled the 
 mind with matter and ignored the heart and soul of 
 humanity. The value of archaeology, whether for the 
 enlightenment or for the interest of maturer years, lies 
 not in the pedantic knowledge of antiquity, but in the 
 thought-felt, heart-felt realisation of its life. 
 
iv FINE ART IN ARCHEOLOGY 59 
 
 Art is in its nature pure, vast, heaven-born, and the 
 antiquary who takes the true, noble, and right view of 
 the place and work of it in the world, will find that all 
 the elements of his study in history, philosophy, poetry, 
 and antiquity will concentrate upon it. He then esti- 
 mates it no more as the mere furnisher of the illustra- 
 tions of facts and things, but the embodiment of that 
 life and spirit that make history live. 
 
 The retrospect of the world's story resembles the 
 picture of individual life except in this, that the world's 
 life is always young ; its infancy veiled in impenetrable 
 mist, its bounding youth an epic of heroism, blotted 
 with fault, but starred with gems of virtue ; its age a 
 struggle of alternating progress and decline, but its life 
 still young, and its winters the balance of a perpetual 
 spring. Things and minds, not life, grow old ; and it 
 is that parallel of decline that gives to antiquity that 
 touch of sadness in the sympathy of thoughts and 
 things, long since passed away for ever, that intensifies 
 its absorbing interest. That touch of nature that 
 makes art so fresh and pure is the link of human 
 brotherhood. In the depth of unrecorded geological 
 age, the cave-man relieving the tedium of his weary 
 life, etching with his flint arrow-point upon bones the 
 forms of animals that peopled his lonely hunting- 
 grounds, was but the elder brother artist, alive to the 
 same charm of natural life, and impelled by the same 
 motive spirit as young Giotto of our own age, as Cima- 
 bue found him drawing upon stones the forms of the 
 sheep he tended upon the Tuscan Apennine. So too 
 the potter of prehistoric days decorated his pottery with 
 spots, lines, and chevrons, at Nature's own suggestion 
 adopting the fundamental principles of repetition, pro- 
 portion, and contrast, by which the most consummate 
 art has ever since been ruled. 
 
 The unity of mankind is not more plainly shown 
 
60 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 by its anatomy than by its habits and moral, as they 
 are illustrated in the arts of life. It may be that here 
 and there a rude race is found as that of Terra del 
 Fuego, of the Andamans and the Australians 
 descendants of weak families pushed outwards and 
 flying before the vigorous expanse of early migration, 
 as wild animals fly before the advance of men ; and 
 who, isolated uncomputable centuries ago by changes 
 of earth and ocean, themselves originally outcasts, un- 
 intelligent, resourceless, and dispirited, have lost their 
 clue and tradition of community ; and so utterly over- 
 whelmed in the loneliness of nature and their own 
 poverty and distress, that what little good they carried 
 with them has dropped out of memory. But with all 
 others, whether in the happier climes or the most 
 distant refuges of the world, their story, as written in 
 their arts, tells, from remotest ages, the same tale, 
 that as with ourselves, the same aspirations stirred 
 them, the same needs, the same motives, the same 
 energies moulded the habits of their life. 
 
 It is thus among the associations of life, to which 
 the relics of art are the unfailing witnesses, that 
 archaeology draws the subjects of its deepest interest. 
 Its paths may not be always easy, but the tracks of 
 human feet that have trodden them before, are the 
 secret of that fascination which tempts us onward. 
 Uncertainty increases interest, and a sense of mystery 
 adds zest to the pursuit, as they lead on amidst that 
 silent and shadowy scenery of the past, where time 
 itself is lost in mist and the last fading colours of 
 tradition die away ; but even there, with apparently no 
 more than the materials of antiquity around us, the 
 breath of thought still rests upon their forms, and the 
 deep silence is broken by the whispers of life. 
 
 Artists engrossed in their work are little aware 
 how often they portray themselves. Their friends and 
 
iv FINE ART IN ARCHEOLOGY 61 
 
 critics call it mannerism, but the touch of art is deeper 
 and more subtle than the accidents of style. Music, 
 painting, and sculpture lend themselves plastically to 
 individual character, and even the calculated forms of 
 architecture, which seem to allow no place for elasticity, 
 tell the individuality of mind and hand. 
 
 Thus has art in archaeology spread out in the dim 
 light of centuries a picture within which is concentrated, 
 with truest portraiture, the habits and characters of all 
 ages and generations of mankind ; a picture of the 
 realities and the romance of human history, but pre- 
 eminently a picture of the unbroken affinities of human 
 nature, and the brotherhood of human souls. For if it 
 be that in the records of history we trace the life if 
 in the annals of commerce and of travel we ascertain 
 the habits if in literature we learn the wisdom it is 
 in art that, throughout the ages of the past, we feel 
 the spirit, and we mingle with the hearts of men. 
 
ESSAY V 
 
 THE MINISTRY OF COLOUR TO SCULPTURE AND 
 ARCHITECTURE 
 
 PART I COLOUR AND SCULPTURE 
 
 T N Nature, colour serves many purposes ; in Art, its 
 service is to make beautiful things more beautiful: 
 ugly things it cannot serve, but to intensify their ugliness. 
 Nature affords us no reasons for its selection, so we 
 may be tempted to regard its use of colour as arbitrary ; 
 but it can hardly be so, where, as in universal nature, 
 system and reason are supreme. We have no right to 
 affirm natural colour to be arbitrary and without law, 
 any more than the winds. Nature is nowhere lawless. 
 There must be some law in the natural employment of 
 colours. Indeed it may not be a mere childish dream 
 that a deeper law and purpose, than our weak faculties 
 can fathom, may underlie those mechanical relations 
 which we attribute to chemistry and light. The power 
 of colours is a mystery to which something in our in- 
 ward nature responds, a method of expression of which 
 we hardly yet have learnt the alphabet. It is indeed 
 hard to believe that such traits of loveliness as are 
 possessed by the colours of external nature can be 
 mere mute and arbitrary signals without significance. 
 We hear their music, and we are entranced by it, but 
 we cannot tell whence it comes, or whither it goes. A 
 law it must have, but it is one that all the chemistry 
 
ESSAY v COLOUR AND SCULPTURE 63 
 
 and mathematics of our science fail to explain ; and 
 imagination, which goes deeper than them all, to the 
 very depths and springs of our nature, can tell no 
 more than of their mystery and their beauty. 
 
 Whatever be the law that orders their relation to 
 the things they adorn, it is measurable, if measurable 
 at all, only by special aptitudes of mind and sense ; 
 but even here there is no basis for comprehension, for 
 the perception of colour is so various, that sense dis- 
 agrees about its use ; and minds susceptible of the 
 moral of it, form their estimate according to their own 
 individual intelligence. Where then is the conclusion 
 to be ? That which in its own nature is infinite, which 
 sense cannot exhaust nor mind fathom, which seems to 
 play with all the fickleness of fire, but is subject to laws 
 which rule its apparent license into an exquisite order, 
 we must be content to accept as a wonder and a joy. 
 
 An artist needs to have a spirit of very subtle 
 penetration to comprehend in one broad grasp the 
 material and moral qualities of the things that Nature 
 has lavished for his use. His main difficulty is in 
 their selection. Such is the infinitude of forms and 
 colours, an infinitude made still more embarrassing by 
 their combination, that only those who know not what 
 there is to know, will plunge into art with reckless 
 haste, as though its heights were to be scaled with ease, 
 or its pathway only strewn with flowers. 
 
 A student has plenty to learn, but learning in art 
 is not like learning facts and figures that serve to train 
 him for other things, for art is a speciality to be learnt 
 rather by training faculties than by learning rules ; for 
 though there are great principles to be mastered, and 
 great experiences to be gained, there is no hope where 
 the heart does not go before the education. A pupil 
 needs first to make the elements of his art as though 
 they formed part of his very nature, and then at last 
 
64 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 as an artist to use them for his heart's expression. If 
 sculpture be the art of his choice, and he be blessed 
 with a genial spirit that can descend from the upper 
 airs of abstract idea to the sphere of common men, he 
 will inevitably be some day struck with the contrast 
 between the works of his hands and the models from 
 which he had fashioned them. Those works may be 
 beautiful, but they have stopped short and vaunt their 
 superiority in their sublime ideal of abstract form. 
 The idea was fine, but the method of attaining it afforded 
 no reason for stopping where he has stopped. He 
 realised figures of ideal representation a hero, a god- 
 dess, what not ? by idealising the forms of Nature, that 
 is, by modulating those he saw to those conceived in 
 his imagination, till the special figure of his conception 
 was complete. If then Nature be not transgressed by 
 taking such mental liberties with her forms, why should 
 any violence be implied by applying the same liberty 
 to colours ? Thus, at the outset, interesting problems 
 will arrest him, and, among them, few will be more 
 difficult to solve than the relation of forms to colours. 
 They appear to be distinct entities, and to have no 
 necessary relationship, but Nature has made them in- 
 separable, and, when harmonised, they charm our sight 
 and master our moral sense, and come at last to be in 
 the artist's hand a power to arouse every emotion, and 
 excite every passion of our nature. 
 
 The perception of colour is a speciality. Some 
 people feel colour, some people only see it, or think 
 they do ; but eyes might be equally faithful in them all 
 for the mechanism of sight, but the intelligent percep- 
 tion of colour is a very different matter, and varies in 
 them from a reality to a blank. Colours are the 
 creatures of light, and where light is there are colours. 
 White is beautiful, more by association than in reality. 
 All colours are contained in it, for it is not by their 
 
v COLOUR AND SCULPTURE 65 
 
 annihilation but by their union that they produce white. 
 We associate purity with white : but colours are as 
 pure ; it would be hard to find impurity in the rain- 
 bow, but there is no white there. Sea-foam and snow, 
 a chalk cliff and a lily, are white, but all their whites 
 are different ; and every undulation of form, every half 
 tint or light reflected upon them, and, still more, their 
 shadows, make those whites again more different. 
 Why do we associate perfect purity with white ? Is 
 it not because of its exquisite union of all colours ? 
 We do well to treasure the idea of its purity, but none 
 the less is colour pure. The snow-white mountain 
 against the mid-day blue is as the white of an opal, 
 and as the morning rises and the evening sets upon it, 
 it turns to gold and ruby, and at night it is more 
 silvery than the moon. Those colours are but elements 
 of its whiteness, and are as veils of beauty thrown over 
 it, in Nature's varying moods. Colour is all pure in 
 itself, and it is perhaps the very intensity of our sense 
 of its perfect purity, that induces our dread of art's 
 imperfect use of it ; as though colour were an element 
 so divinely pure as could be entrusted only to that 
 Hand that clothed all Nature with it. 
 
 If form be pure, then colour purely used can only 
 enhance that purity, for it is but an ethereal element 
 of light. The forms of sculpture are not changed by 
 it ; but it may be that for want of custom or experience 
 our inner sense is confused by that union of form and 
 colour ; still it is unreasonable to object, except on 
 confession of our mental inability to reconcile our sense 
 or mind to the union of what our habits of thought had 
 separated. But were they, are they right in that 
 separation ? where is their authority ? Certainly not 
 in Nature, for in all that surrounds our life colour is 
 everywhere ; but the sense of abstract purity conveyed 
 by white is so universal and so strong, and in our 
 
 F 
 
66 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 inward conviction its symbolism is so sacred, that to 
 offend it would be sacrilege. But if colour is as pure 
 as white, as the very elements of that which is pure 
 cannot be less pure than that which they combine to 
 produce, and the source from which they flow, may not 
 the intelligent sense of colour demand an equal courtesy 
 of respect ? In light is the fountain of all existence ; 
 it brings life with it, and whether in the unity or the 
 separation of its elements it is equally an emanation of 
 divine beauty. 
 
 The greatest difficulty that art has to meet, in its 
 communication of thought from man to man, is that 
 variety of disposition and sense that results in a tangle 
 of irreconcilable convictions which no reasoning can 
 touch, because the very basis of comprehension does 
 not exist between them. We must therefore agree to 
 differ, and we must respect each other's differences ; for 
 the senses to which art addresses itself are the en- 
 dowments of our individual natures ; and art's best 
 hope is in her power both to delight and teach, and 
 thus to break through the crust of indifference or 
 inability, and to enter, as naught else can enter but 
 by appeal to the universal sympathies of mankind, by 
 inspiring thoughts that turn men's minds inwardly 
 upon themselves, and lead them at last to the percep- 
 tion of that soul in art, which, through the skilful 
 semblances of outward beauty, appeals to them and 
 wins them. 
 
 In practice the association of colour with sculpture 
 can be only rightly conceived by mastering the pro- 
 prieties of it, proprieties that are not limited by what 
 such form or colour might be in Nature, but such as 
 would best aid the expression of the idea they are 
 designed by the artist to convey. The conception and 
 choice of colours are apt to be embarrassed by the 
 recollection of them in relation to accustomed forms 
 
COLOUR AXD SCULPTURE 
 
 and effects, and thus associating them in our ideas with 
 truth and untruth. But if sculpture be rightly under- 
 stood as appealing to the moral and intellectual sense, 
 rather than by mockery of imitation to delude the 
 sight, all the choice of form, composition, relief, colour, 
 and all else that combines to produce its expression, 
 must be guided by an art that would of necessity 
 include the idea of nature and reality ; but at the 
 same time would assume, with all the supreme author- 
 ity of genius, the power and the right to use and 
 modulate the whole scale of those material means, 
 and so to embody its life and purpose as genius had 
 itself conceived them. 
 
 With this view and to this end it is at once clear 
 that the conception of colour, in its relation to all 
 arts, must come from within, from the mental reflex of 
 external truth ; and the associations of its truth or 
 untruth, its fitness or unfitness, must be grasped as 
 completely in relation to idea as to fact Colour, as 
 art uses it, is true when it is true to the great pur- 
 pose of its existence, viz. to enhance existing beauty, 
 by the marriage of two beauties, of form and of itself, 
 thus making one. It is untrue when its purpose is a 
 lie, by the attempt to make a thing appear what it is 
 not The nude of a statue is not flesh, the drapery 
 of it is not stuff of woven flax or wool, and colour that 
 would be used in either case with the purpose of de- 
 ception, would be a falsity and offence. Those forms 
 were conceived, composed, and executed to satisfy the 
 sculptor's impulse, to present to others the embodied 
 idea of what his own heart and mind had drawn from 
 the depths of Nature's inspiration ; and just as his 
 idea may have been one of power or of tenderness, of 
 simplicity or majesty, of life or death, his purpose was 
 so to arrest the minds of other men as the inspiration 
 of it had arrested and overcome his own ; and then, 
 
68 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 if, in the completeness of his art, he let colour come 
 to breathe upon those forms, it was not to flush their 
 surface with a mock reality, but to perfect their ideal, 
 by making tenderness more tender, death more solemn, 
 life more lovely, majesty more sublime. 
 
 Do you ask how is all this to be obtained ? I can 
 only reply that no mortal can teach the secret of it ; 
 for there is nothing in the whole range of art more 
 spontaneously artistic, undefinable, and ideal, than the 
 relation of colour to form. The perception of it lies 
 in intuitive genius ; and the only ruling of it is that of 
 a pure mind and of a knowledge, taste, and judgment 
 profoundly matured. 
 
 It is a laudable jealousy that would restrict an art 
 to its own sphere, and so far as this is the opponent 
 motive to the use of colour with sculpture, it is worthy 
 of all respect ; but the limits of any art's sphere are 
 not easily assigned ; its characteristics may be readily 
 defined, but they are not its exhaustive definition. 
 When Socrates, himself a sculptor in his youth, said to 
 his friend Crito that the province of sculpture was " to 
 represent the emotions of the soul by form," he beauti- 
 fully expressed the speciality of the art ; but art is too 
 elastic and expansive to be shut up within the limits of 
 an aphorism. As well might we say that " the pro- 
 vince of eloquence is to express the emotions of the 
 soul by words ;" but what does not intonation of voice, 
 expression of countenance, and bodily action add of 
 life and power to those words ? So too in sculpture 
 the intonation of its material may be invaluable in its 
 effect on form, as Gibson felt when he wrote to a 
 friend " form is spiritualised by the tinting ; it makes 
 its forget the material ; the Greeks were right." Sculp- 
 ture from the days of Daedalus to Praxiteles has pro- 
 gressed, like every other art, by the gradual accumula- 
 tion of graces ; and in its progress it has been so 
 
v COLOUR AND SCULPTURE 69 
 
 sensitive to external influences that the poetry, the 
 philosophy, and the contemporary civilisation, have 
 affected it throughout The merely abstract ideal of 
 " form " in sculpture was by itself insufficient " to 
 express the emotions of the soul ;" so poetry suggested 
 the attributes of the figures, philosophy and religion 
 suggested its motive and symbolism, refinement of 
 civilised life suggested its accompaniments and acces- 
 sories of expression, all which the sculptor felt by 
 turns, and breathing into his work the breath of his 
 own life, he reproduced the influences he had received. 
 Still " form " was indeed paramount, as words are 
 paramount in eloquence ; and all that accompanied 
 form was but an item of accumulated grace to give 
 it moral and intellectual interest, and thus to em- 
 phasise the speciality of its beauty. So Socrates's 
 dictum remains unquestioned ; but as form is precious 
 not merely " for the expression of the sculptor's soul," 
 but still more for that of humanity, the power of its 
 beauty is at once asserted, and all that could help its 
 interpretation, as in some cases at least the added 
 element of colour might do, would enhance and endear 
 it to mankind : and thus men would feel " the emotions 
 of their own souls " relieved in the expressive eloquence 
 of the artist's work. 
 
 Each art has indeed its own sphere, but each has 
 many spheres within itself; and to these it must be 
 true, and by their limits alone can it be fairly barred. 
 Within them all is liberty, a liberty that is conscious of 
 itself; and, conscious of the dignity of self-restraint, it 
 ranges with freedom within the fences that " truth to its 
 own purpose " has alone the authority to impose. Where 
 then is the career of sculpture to be stopped ? Sculpture 
 is not limited by its subjects. Carving may mark its 
 lower, statuary its higher sphere ; but from the flowers 
 and fruit of Grinling Gibbons to the Venus of Praxiteles 
 
70 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 all is sculpture. The panels of Ghiberti's doors may 
 seem to invade the art of painting, and the Cariatides 
 of the Erectheum to trespass upon true architecture ; 
 but all these are recognised as not only beautiful but 
 legitimate, because they are seen to fulfil their various 
 purposes with propriety and grace. Where then is the 
 limit to be placed ? 
 
 Again I must say that no mortal can teach the 
 secret of it ; and no rule but " truth to its own pro- 
 vince " can limit any art : a rule indeed dangerously 
 indefinite, a free will that is open to good or evil, like 
 that of the life of men and nations, of which fine art is 
 the reflection and the exponent. Purity, propriety, and 
 truth are counsels of perfection exquisitely ideal, and 
 by their standard must all fine art be judged ; but the 
 words have not yet been written that could frame the 
 indictment. 
 
 All art is the union of material and mind, and it 
 is the artist's touch that makes and consecrates their 
 marriage. In sculpture it is not merely by the choice 
 of subjects nor the composition of its forms, but by the 
 subtlety of touch that it fascinates the world. But the 
 sculptor's work, however beautiful in other ways, may 
 be marred by imperfections of its surface. There is 
 hardly a limit to its finish. It is the unceasing move- 
 ment of undulation on the surface of a statue that gives 
 it, from every point of view, that mystery of rounded 
 profile that captivates the sight. Much of this effect 
 may be due to the material, and white marble has been 
 the sculptor's favourite resource, as offering the greatest 
 facilities and the fewest defects. Materials of dark 
 colour, like bronze and porphyry and black marble, 
 need highly-polished surfaces to make their modelling 
 visible, and consequently are liable to the disagreeable 
 effect of bright high lights in violent contrast to their 
 local colour, all which is avoided in white marble. 
 
v COLOUR AND SCULPTURE 71 
 
 The brilliant high lights that give vivacity to pottery 
 are not equally agreeable as bright spots on the muscles, 
 limbs, and features of a statue. A surface of modified 
 lustre is the best ; but even that depends somewhat on 
 the tone of it. Pure white marble, freshly cut, fails to 
 show the delicacy of its modelling as the same would 
 show it, if relieved of its intense glare of whiteness. So 
 terra cotta has been a favourite and successful material 
 from the soft richness of its tint. Ivory too has been 
 so for the same reason, and for the facility of its 
 colouring. But marble is the queen of all materials 
 for sculpture ; and, to remedy its one defect of white- 
 ness the greatest artist of art's greatest days supplied 
 to it, by a simple artifice, what time has done to it for 
 us by the mellowing effect of age. 
 
 It is not merely to the ocular but to the mental 
 vision that sculpture addresses itself, and hence the 
 difficulty of its complex artifice. The works are 
 addressed to the world at large, and are felt and 
 thought about, just as it may happen that they fall on 
 heedless or thoughtful eyes ; how much therefore their 
 effect depends on external circumstances it would be 
 hard to exaggerate. We, whose sight is trained to the 
 veiled light of northern sunshine, can only realise by 
 imagination the needs of southern eyes. They crave 
 for colour. Their bright atmosphere imbued their very 
 nature, and even where, from mere habit, all idea and 
 thought about it was a blank, the mental happiness, 
 unconscious of its source, was there, and came of the 
 soothing joy of satisfied sense. Colour was with them 
 a necessity. As their world would be lifeless without 
 it, so their works without it seemed bald and wanting. 
 It would be hardly chargeable with exaggeration to 
 say that their works were always coloured either 
 artificially or by the choice of material ; for there is no 
 style nor period of art, when by some form of evidence, 
 
72 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 direct or indirect, it may not be asserted that colour 
 was an element of it. 
 
 Colour, as bluntly conceived by unaccustomed minds, 
 must not be confounded with the refined delicacy of its 
 use in the hands of a consummate artist. The language 
 of colour has an unwritten grammar, that has a 
 phraseology of its own according to its varying mood 
 and purposes. Some plain rules and great principles 
 may be laid down for its use, but beyond them 
 the true artist's use of it must be learnt by the love 
 of it, and matured by that thought and care to 
 which that love alone is sure to lead. Doubtless 
 it needs a natural aptitude for its comprehension ; 
 but it is a great reality which those who cannot 
 appreciate must be content to accept. They may 
 glory in the colours of pictorial art, but they battle 
 with the idea of colour used with sculpture, because 
 their sense is confounded by what their minds fail to 
 reconcile. 
 
 In early days of art it may have pleased barbarous 
 eyes, and in better times even those blinded by the 
 affections of archaeological association, to have seen the 
 statues of the gods daubed with vermilion ; and such 
 may have been the result of habit even upon the most 
 trained eyes and taste, that all sculpture may have 
 seemed wanting in effect without at least some colour- 
 ing, where the very air itself was full of colour, making 
 the cold white marble an offensive blot. But be the 
 colouring of their sculpture what it might, its object 
 could not have been illusion, nor its principle that of 
 bare naturalistic reproduction, for it is impossible to 
 believe that such heroes of art's acme, as those of the 
 days of Pericles, could for a moment have tolerated the 
 annihilation of all their art's poetry by the substitution 
 of the base for the ideal, the sham of reality for the 
 truth of feeling, in the production of what even to our 
 
v COLOUR AND SCULPTURE 73 
 
 inferior sense and taste could be only stigmatised as 
 demonstrative vulgarity. 
 
 If we seek a guide to our judgment on such sub- 
 jects and look back to the days that all regard as those 
 of art's perfection, we find our views enlarged and our 
 practice modified by such a review. They must be so 
 only with this reserve, that no age must be the slave 
 to another, nor one country to another's arts, which the 
 exigencies of their climate and the habits of the people 
 must originate and naturalise among them, if their arts 
 are to be worth their name. In looking for precedents 
 to such times, difficulties arise from the absence of any 
 complete examples, and from our dependence on the 
 writings of travellers, archaeologists, and dilettanti, who 
 were not experts in the arts they describe. Still, such 
 is the aggregate testimony, that all great principles 
 involved are clear enough to reconstitute those arts, so 
 at least as to represent them to our minds, though our 
 skill might fail to reproduce them. 
 
 In early poetry and early art we find the germs of 
 what maturer times produced. It needed the sunshine 
 of national enthusiasm to complete their growth. The 
 earliest sculpture that we know was painted, or made 
 or ornamented with coloured materials. As we might 
 expect, all eyes turn southward for any historic art 
 with the attribute of early genius ; and thence sculpture 
 came with all its colour, and there many of its ancient 
 models still remain. Eastward too there was light and 
 warmth and wealth for art's development, and, what 
 was needed also, the cultivated civilisation and natural 
 aptitude of the people. Architecture, providing for 
 life's earliest necessities, was the first to be developed ; 
 and with that we are at once introduced to the use of 
 colours. Sculpture followed as its natural relief, with 
 its forms of mingled wood and marble, painted and 
 clothed with embroidered drapery. From the splendid 
 
74 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 palaces of Assyria to the temples on the Nile all was 
 coloured. Even where the dread of idolatry excluded 
 imitation, as in the temple of Solomon, no limit was 
 imposed on the glorification of all other modes of art 
 with gold and vermilion, cedar, ivory, and metals, 
 " bright ivory overlaid with sapphires and pillars of 
 marble set in sockets of gold." l Although the artists 
 may have been comparatively rude, rejoicing in effects 
 of colossal size and gorgeous display, they certainly 
 had mastered the great principles of adapting material 
 and ornament to their right place and purpose. Their 
 art was essentially objective. It needed centuries of 
 refining civilisation to develop the subjective sense of 
 beauty and expression ; and still more to reach that 
 most abstract of all phases of art, when an uncoloured 
 statue became a possibility. 
 
 The arts travelled westward with all their tradition 
 of splendour and their strange mixture of barbaric and 
 refined idea, consecrated by associations of antiquity ; 
 with combinations of material and skill that East and 
 South had brought into full practice, and needed only 
 the genius of Pheidias to bring to perfection. The 
 sculptured wall -pictures of Nineveh and Egypt, the 
 golden gates of Shalmanezer's palace, 2 with their pro- 
 cessions of countless figures in relief and incidents of 
 history and warfare, were the first suggestions of an 
 art perfected at last in the friezes of Athens and 
 Pheigalia. 
 
 Such were the conditions, the forms, and materials 
 of art that the Greeks received as a precious legacy 
 from the nations of the world ; and, with the mighty 
 mind and skill of that great people, they perfected and 
 adapted them to their own national character and use. 
 
 1 Canticles V., vs. 14-15. 
 
 2 The gates from Ballawatt, now in the Assyrian Department, British 
 Museum. 
 
v COLOUR AND SCULPTURE 75 
 
 Transforming them by their genius, transfusing them 
 with their poetry, they made them all their own. 
 Greece plucked the fair flowers from the gardens of her 
 neighbours, and sowed their seed at home, that when 
 they bloomed again they might be only Greek. 
 
 The inquiry into their use of colours at the highest 
 period of their arts is not easily satisfied, because it 
 depends in great degree upon the careful inference 
 of experts, and cannot be, except in a few cases, posi- 
 tively demonstrated. We acknowledge their authority, 
 and without yielding a tittle of the genius and power 
 of our own times, we may accept the canons of their 
 taste, and profit by their experiences. But colours are 
 themselves so frail and fugitive, and the preparatory 
 film of material on which they were laid was so tender, 
 that scarcely a scrap of them remains. The deep 
 recesses of sculptured forms, the sheltered corners of 
 walls and hollowed mouldings alone retain the evidences 
 of what once covered them. The descriptions of ancient 
 travellers, the quotations from ancient authors, the dis- 
 coverers of our own time who have dug out broken 
 remnants that carelessness, fanaticism, or greed had 
 failed to destroy ; the inferior works of latest classic 
 work exhumed from buried cities or found upon the 
 ruins of ancient monuments and cemeteries, preserve at 
 least, although in shadowy forms, the traditions of the 
 arts of past great days, and make, with rare exceptions, 
 the total catalogue for our reference ; still they are 
 sufficient to convince unprejudiced judgment, that 
 colour was an important element of sculpturesque and 
 architectural effect in the greatest works of classic art. 
 Materials that in the South and East were common, 
 with us are rare ; and we are too apt to appreciate for 
 their rarity what the great artists of antiquity valued 
 only as subservient to the production of their effects : 
 so they gilt and painted what we should quail to touch. 
 
76 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 But it is a grievous task to attempt description of them, 
 or to convey to others the true import of one's words, 
 where all depends upon the subtleties of art. The 
 refinements of artistic sense are indescribable ; form 
 cannot be conveyed in words ; and of colour it is hope- 
 less to insure the true impression, where each mind 
 takes them in its own sense, and the bare mention of 
 them suggests to many an effect of glare and violence, 
 when all that was meant might have been but the 
 tenderest blush of white or the opalescence of a pearl. 
 
 Wherever we look among the sites of ancient 
 celebrity, as at ygina and Athens, in the Morea or in 
 Asia Minor, at Olympia and Halicarnassus and the 
 islands of the ^Egean ; at Paestum, Girgenti, or Selinunte, 
 and among the countless remains scattered far and wide, 
 but of which all trace or name is lost : unquestionable 
 evidences from travellers whose very purpose as scholars 
 and artists was to search out and verify the history 
 and arts of classical antiquity, all combine to one and 
 the same result. In many places the colouring remained 
 bright ; in others, where the gold or encaustic had 
 perished from the sculpture, the stain remained ; where 
 the colour had faded from the architecture the etched 
 outlines showed where the architect had designed upon 
 his mouldings the ornament for the painter : holes in 
 the marble plainly indicated where metal decorations 
 had been fastened on the frieze, where the gilt bronze 
 harness had been fitted to the horses, and where helmets 
 and weapons had been attached to the figures of gods 
 and men. 
 
 But beyond the mere fact of the existence of this 
 colouring that which gives special interest to its varied 
 use is the plain distinction which had evidently pre- 
 vailed between the treatment of different kinds of 
 sculpture, namely, that in high or low relief and the 
 two distinct classes of statues those associated with 
 
v COLOUR AND SCULPTURE 77 
 
 architecture and those independent of it. If it be borne 
 in mind how absolutely distinct is the principle of 
 architectural effect from that which constitutes the 
 beauty of independent statuary, the principles of all 
 ornamental treatment will fall at once into distinct and 
 reasonable systems. For instance, in sculpture, taken 
 independently, however definite the composition may 
 be, however bold its effects of contrast and relief, its 
 beauty depends on those qualities which exemplify 
 life ; and the blending together of its distinct features, 
 and the modulation of the curves and undulations of 
 surface and profile into one another, are the special 
 elements of its treatment. In architecture, on the con- 
 trary, its composition is based on precisely opposite 
 principles of construction and effect. There is no 
 blending of its parts, no softening of its outlines, no 
 thought of life (not that architecture lacks life, for 
 every fine art is a thing of life, and in architecture its 
 vitality is the measure of its excellence, the life of idea 
 from which it sprang, and the life implanted in its every 
 feature by the mind and hand that executed them). 
 This contrast between architecture and sculpture will 
 be better appreciated by remembering that every 
 feature in architecture is an entity complete in itself, 
 cut off from every other by sharp definitions, as the 
 abacus separates the capital from the entablature, and 
 the astragal cuts off the capital from the shaft, the 
 metopes, the triglyphs, the frieze, the cornice, or the 
 arch having each a complete individuality and inde- 
 pendence except that Art has so built them up 
 together, and so combined their differences, as to make 
 of them all one completed thing of beauty. 
 
 The beauty found in each of these two arts depends 
 of course on the excellence of its artistic treatment. 
 If then any other art, as that of colour, comes to be 
 employed upon them, or any ornamental material be 
 
78 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 used to enhance their effects, such art must follow the 
 ideals of their distinctive beauties, and maintain their 
 respective characters, if it would not disfigure rather 
 than adorn them ; and such were the plain and simple 
 principles which, whether thought out or instinctively 
 perceived, appear to have been accepted and practised 
 by the greatest Greek artists. 
 
 Thus their architecture was parti -coloured and 
 treated with no feeble hands ; and this leading prin- 
 ciple, viz. their recognition of the entire distinctness of 
 each architectural feature, is exhibited in the method of 
 their coloured treatment of it : for instance, triglyphs 
 were usually painted in positive colours, without regard 
 to the metopes between them. A traveller at Athens 
 in 1837 described a metope lately found there as 
 " sculptured in high relief, and painted red, blue, and 
 green," but the flats of the architrave below them 
 appear quite plain. Mouldings were selected for special 
 colouring, such as the bands of richly -polychromed 
 design of honey-suckle scrolls and frets which covered 
 the grouped mouldings of the pediments and the level 
 cornices of the finest marble models of Grecian archi- 
 tecture ; and belts of deep colouring were carried 
 independently all round these buildings, like the band 
 along the peristyle above the Panathenaic frieze. The 
 ground of that frieze was blue, and the figures relieved 
 with gold and colours, some of the horsemen's head- 
 dresses being coloured and their arms and ornaments 
 gilt, while, in strong contrast, the bulk of the archi- 
 tecture beneath them was left plain. 1 
 
 1 There is now no irrefragable evidence whether the external plain 
 surfaces, such as columns, the flat parts of entablatures, etc., of marble 
 architecture were or were not generally coloured. That the marble was 
 coated with encaustic, whether as a preservative or to impart high finish to 
 it, is from Vitruvius's account, writing from Greek sources, probable ; but 
 whether those parts were coloured or not cannot now be assured. The 
 mouldings have the most positive evidences of colours and their patterns ; 
 
v COLOUR AND SCULPTURE 79 
 
 The grounds of the tympana and metopes were 
 painted everywhere, in some cases, as in Sicily, red, 
 in others, as in Greece, blue, against which the statues 
 were relieved, and when nude were comparatively 
 plain ; while in strong relief, their emblems, arms, 
 drapery, and ornaments were boldly marked with colour, 
 gilding, and metal -work. They grouped with the 
 architecture, and as architecture was so were they. The 
 capitals of the antae and of the colonnade under the 
 porticoes were painted and gilt, while the white marble 
 columns and capitals of the great peristyles were left 
 uncoloured. Thus by all of these, which are but typical 
 illustrations of what is found elsewhere, we perceive 
 that the same principles on which architectural con- 
 struction depended that is to say, on the distinct in- 
 dividuality of eacJi feature so also the colouring of the 
 associated sculpture appears to have been ruled, viz. by 
 the arbitrary selection of a fine constructive taste, taking 
 parts here and there and loading them with richest 
 decoration, and leaving the rest plain stone or marble. 
 
 The statues in the pediments at ^Egina may be too 
 archaic to guide our taste ; but in them we have at 
 least the plainest record of this traditional treatment of 
 architectural sculpture, and the finer statuary of the 
 Theseum may be quoted to the same effect. In both 
 cases, indeed in all cases where fine Greek art has been 
 sufficiently preserved to illustrate it, the colouring was 
 positive, and composed in no relation to the picture or 
 wall painter's art, but architecturally ; indeed so power- 
 fully so as to have been too self-assertive and dis- 
 
 but the thin pattina of colour on the large plain surfaces, if they had any, 
 would have perished before the writers, on whom we depend, had seen 
 them. Stone temples were coated with cement, as at Paestum and in 
 Sicily ; the question being whether these, of which there is no doubt about 
 their colouring all over, were so coloured in imitation of their greater 
 models of art, viz. those of marble ? Pliny, Pausanias, and Lucian, and 
 Vitruvius wrote 'of them about five hundred years after they were built. 
 
8o THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 agreeable but for their association with a parti-coloured 
 architecture. If this were an archaeological or con- 
 troversial volume instead of an essay limited in its 
 address, very much detail could be mentioned here to 
 illustrate further this clear and distinct character of 
 architectural treatment, and of the difference between 
 architectural and independent sculpture ; but it may be 
 said without prejudice that while some parts may have 
 been left without definite tint beyond that of the wax 
 and oil of the encaustic, in such pediments as those of 
 Olympia and the Parthenon, just inference leads to a 
 contrary opinion as to those of the more archaic 
 ^Egina and the highly-decorated Theseum at Athens ; it 
 is at the same time most unlikely, that those apparently 
 uncoloured figures could have remained crude as they 
 left the sculptor's or the mason's hands. It should be 
 remembered that we are here referring to no ordinary 
 works, or ordinary criticism, but to artists of unequalled 
 refinement, and a population of extraordinary perception, 
 who, undisturbed by the multiplicity of such life as ours, 
 passed an out-of-door life, identifying themselves with 
 their national arts, and regarding them not as the 
 merely ornamental accessories of life but as important 
 elements of national glory. Such men would regard 
 all works of art around them with a seriousness and 
 reality that a modern would smile at. They valued 
 things not for their material but for their effect, and if 
 the unmitigated glare of such a sunshine as theirs 
 interfered with the perfection of sculpturesque effect, as 
 in the delicacies of half- tints and reflected lights it 
 certainly would, it is reasonable to infer that some treat- 
 ment would be adopted to remedy such defects. As 
 we see those marbles now, time has mellowed them ; but 
 it has bared them also of the materials of that treatment 
 by which their surfaces had been originally mellowed, 
 viz. of that tender film by which the encaustic painter 
 
v COLOUR AND SCULPTURE 81 
 
 had prepared them for colouring and gold, which has 
 all likewise perished. But we are not altogether left in 
 ignorance about these matters, for Greek artists and 
 architects left writings descriptive of their principles 
 and systems on many subjects, such as perspective, 
 geometry, proportion, anatomy, and methods of painting, 
 of which Vitruvius availed himself, and has preserved 
 many valuable details from them. The originals have 
 perished, but we have his description of the old Greek 
 system of preparing walls for painting, and the method 
 of treating the marble surfaces of both statues and 
 walls. Pliny quotes from the same authorities, which 
 lead to the inference that the encaustic preparation 
 was all but an universal practice ; and by our own 
 experience we know how the wax and oil, with or 
 without resins, rubbed in and fixed by heat affects the 
 marble, giving it a peculiar quality of effect between 
 white alabaster and ivory, and either tinting it or not 
 as may be : but in either case blending it with the 
 coloured and otherwise rich effect of all around it. 
 
 It appears therefore that the treatment of archi- 
 tectural and independent sculpture differed on plain and 
 reasonable grounds. The former had made part of a 
 complex effect, and in consistency with the demand of 
 artistic breadth, it had yielded to the stern demands of 
 architectural composition. Colour had formed a very 
 important part in it. Independent statuary, on the 
 contrary, was clear of all obligation, and its colouring 
 had relation to itself alone. With exception of a few 
 touches of colour on drapery and accessories, to save 
 the whole from insipidity, the treatment appears to have 
 been very tender, the main purpose having been to clear 
 the supports and parts of inferior importance from the 
 figure itself, and thus by contrast to emphasise the 
 beauty of the nude. 
 
 The great chryselephantine statues of Pheidias at 
 G 
 
82 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 Athens and Olympia, and the Hera of Polycleitus with 
 its ivory arms, its gorgeous robe and throne of gold, 
 have had all the splendour of their colouring described 
 by eye-witnesses ; but both through them and by the 
 positive evidence of modern research, we know that all 
 this magnificence of material was not isolated, but 
 formed part of the general effect, being supported by 
 other sculptures, by inlaid paintings, by coloured walls, 
 such as those by Pansenus round the screen of the 
 sanctuary at Olympia, by decorative metal -work, em- 
 broidered drapery, and coloured marbles. And thus 
 the breadth of result that an artist's sense demands 
 was secured : but on individual and independent 
 statues such was the influence and such the demands, 
 of all the coloured materials around them everywhere, 
 without which ancient art appears to have been re- 
 garded as incomplete, that these too were not left of 
 unstained or unalloyed metals, nor of crude untempered 
 marble. Details of universal use, the common daily 
 effects of things, are not noticed in written records. 
 The very commonness of that use of colour accounts 
 for the rarity of remarks about it. Great works, 
 that we know to have glowed with it, are described 
 by ancient authors without a word about their 
 colouring. It was taken for granted in sculpture as 
 well as in architecture ; and unless for some special 
 reason we only incidentally come upon the notice of it, 
 as in Virgil's dedication to Venus of a figure of Cupid 
 with many-coloured wings and a painted quiver, and 
 of a marble statue with crimson sandals to Diana ; or 
 when Callistratus admires the blush on the cheeks of 
 a bronze cupid by Praxiteles, or where the sculptor 
 Aphrodisius is designated as the sculptor and statue 
 painter (' ^aX/mro-Troto? ey/cavar^'), mere passing notices, 
 which could be greatly multiplied, and which by their 
 incidental character testify to the ordinary nature of 
 
v COLOUR AND SCULPTURE 83 
 
 the remarks. The greatest works of Greek independent 
 sculpture appear not to have been of marble but of 
 bronze and other metals ; indeed the list of materials 
 used in them reads like a catalogue of colours. The 
 metals were varied by alloys, stained surfaces and 
 gilding, and the marble when it left the sculptor's hand 
 was submitted, for complete finish, to another art than 
 his. The profession of the statue painter was one of 
 recognised importance, and his confraternity appears to 
 have included the distinct occupations of the encaustic 
 painter, the gilder, and the stainer, 1 skilled decorators, 
 but in their ways artists. The encaustic was variously 
 compounded of wax, oil, and resin, and sometimes 
 tinged with colours, as the"circumlitio variata" mentioned 
 by Seneca implies. It gave to fresh marble the mellow- 
 ness of age, and aided the sight of the tenderest 
 undulations by counteracting all glare, without inter- 
 fering with its crystalline luminousness. The deli- 
 cate movements of the surface of fine sculpture are at 
 the mercy of material. They are lost in the plaster 
 cast, and are invisible in stone : hence the preference 
 in critical Greek eyes for such compact surfaces as of 
 ivory and metal. If in this respect marble fell at all 
 short of these materials it was superior to them in 
 many ways, by its easy workmanship, its adaptableness 
 to any subject, and pre-eminently to the work of the 
 encaustic painter, who remedied all defects, giving 
 consistency to its surface, softening its rounded profiles, 
 and harmonising it with surrounding colours. Encaustic 
 painting was not necessarily colouring, but served as 
 the preparation for it, and for protection of the surface 
 when colours were not used. To write of painting 
 statues might mislead a reader : the expression might 
 have applied to archaic figures and reliefs, where 
 
 1 "AydX/j-aTUv ^yKavaral, xpu(ru>ra2, /cal /3a0ets. Plutarch, De Glor. 
 Athen. 6. 
 
84 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 painted architecture, whether Greek or Gothic, required 
 such treatment ; but in all thought of the colouring of 
 such sculpture as I now speak of, independent high- 
 class work, the barest idea of paint as commonly under- 
 stood must be at once dismissed, and in place of it 
 must be conceived an art peculiar to itself, of utmost 
 refinement of sight and handling. Its purpose was 
 altogether subordinate ; less with a view to any imitation 
 of nature than of conventionally aiding materials to the 
 more perfect display of the beauty that sculpture had 
 itself already produced. Hence the intense refinement of 
 it. It was a useful ornament, but would cease to be so if 
 obtrusive or suggestive of a second idea apart from 
 form. The arts of the " stainer " and of " encaustic " 
 combined, whether on drapery or emblems, accessories 
 or supports, or on the figure itself, had for their one 
 sole purpose the perfect exhibition of the figure by the 
 relief and contrasts that they afforded. 
 
 So in all ways colour, whether tenderly or power- 
 fully used, was within the strict limits and province of 
 the great art it served. It would marr rather than aid 
 the effect of sculpture if it transgressed those limits. 
 Sculpture is the highest and most difficult of the 
 imitative arts ; and they are rightly called imitative, 
 from the artist's sheer necessity, having only Nature's 
 models to follow ; but imitation in art is an intellectual, 
 not a mechanical process, a matter of translation ; it is 
 Nature's voice spoken by the artist's method ; it is the 
 realisation of impressions, that, in passing through the 
 artist's mind, are affected by his character and motive 
 in the image that he gives to his idea. The highest 
 value of his work is in the moral aspect of it ; the 
 whole force of it depends on the unity of its ideal ; 
 and whether colour or no colour be used, it is so used 
 or not, and only so to insure the completeness of its 
 expression. Even if in such master works as the 
 
v COLOUR AND SCULPTURE 85 
 
 Theseum or the Parthenon the nude parts of the 
 pedimental sculpture had been tinted or stained flesh 
 colour, this mere flat wash of colour as contrasted 
 with the actual painting of flesh, as in a picture, with 
 its fixed composition of light and shade, its countless 
 gradations and broken tints, is a totally different 
 matter ; and it is impossible to believe that such men 
 as Pheidias (himself a painter before he was a sculptor), 
 or his chief encaustic artist Pansenus, or at the Theseum, 
 Myron, both painter and sculptor, could for an in- 
 stant have transgressed the province of their arts, or 
 have done more than to use a consistent local tint, 
 whether such were warm, as some flesh tints would 
 be, or merely with the mellowness of the olive com- 
 plexions of the south ; but, whatever it was, so modified 
 as finest taste would suggest to harmonise the white 
 marble with the richly-ornamented architecture, the 
 painted mouldings and the deep shadows of the 
 pediment above, and of the portico below. It was 
 with the instinct of the artist that they acted ; and, 
 whatever was the course they pursued, they knew too 
 well both what art and nature meant, to be guilty of 
 the weak folly of making mock realities. The soft 
 white Parian marble was as precious to the Greek as 
 to us ; but he used it with the independence of an 
 artist's genius, colouring, toning, gilding, and otherwise 
 adorning it or not to suit his purpose. He knew full 
 well that the end of art was not to delude but to 
 delight ; the very thought of illusion would never cross 
 his mind. His work was art ; his mistress Nature, too 
 revered for mimicry ; but the bald marble might be 
 too self-assertive, too obtrusive of its own material for 
 his desired result. His purpose was to realise imagery, 
 which haunted his imagination, not to glorify marble, 
 and most certainly not to counterfeit flesh. His result 
 would be a work of art, natural indeed, but ideal also, 
 
86 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 to bring his conception of Nature's beauty to the 
 hearts of other men ; a work so schemed and executed, 
 simple or complex, plain or coloured, but such as would 
 leave all sense and thought unimpeded, by the mere 
 technicalities of art, to range freely in the action and 
 story of it, and to enjoy that motive poetry of it with 
 which his own mind and imagination had been filled. 
 The artist speaks only through his works, and Nature's 
 forms are all he has to use ; and it would be difficult 
 to conceive a greater libel against her, who is the 
 source and centre of all the real and the ideal both of 
 art and life, than the mocking image of pretended 
 truth, in the attempt to produce the thing without the 
 life which is all that gives value to that thing's reality. 
 The art of art is not to hide itself, but to hide its 
 artifice. A work of art is not a pretence. A statue is 
 a reality, but a reality of art ; not as the rival of 
 Nature's work, but the reflection of her spirit. 
 
 Colour is but one mode of an artist's expression. 
 Doubtless the ideal of sculpture is the perfect beauty of 
 abstract form ; but expression is the life of it ; without 
 it art is dead ; for what is art's action in its highest 
 sense but the appeal of the living to the living ? Even 
 if death be its subject, it is the grandeur or the pathos 
 of that death that makes the poetry of it beautiful, and 
 the sculpture of it precious. Colour does not alter 
 form, but argument is out of place where Nature 
 rules ; and art has no logic for cold reason, but goes 
 straight to the heart by the rhetoric of sympathy. 
 
 The " How and how much ?" of colouring, of inde- 
 pendent classical sculpture, must be ever a matter of 
 uncertainty. The notices of ancient writers are vague ; 
 and time, accident, and atmosphere have done their 
 worst, and have left us but little positive evidence, as 
 compared with what remains on works of architecture. 
 Nearly five centuries had passed over the master- 
 
v COLOUR AND SCULPTURE 87 
 
 pieces of antiquity before such writers as Pausanias, 
 Pliny, Strabo, and Lucian described their state. Still 
 there is an ample accumulation of many scraps and 
 kinds of testimony to justify the inference of how great 
 a part colour played in all the master works of art's 
 greatest days, and how thorough were the knowledge 
 and the taste of their authors. As their grandest works 
 of sculpture, the colossal figures in the temples of the 
 gods, were enriched with every coloured material and 
 every mode of coloured ornament that ingenuity could 
 devise, the use of colour is implied on others standing 
 near them, to save them from a contrast painfully 
 obtrusive. In the Heroum at Olympia there were 
 above twenty statues of gold and ivory, and such figures 
 were the special subjects for the coloured ornamenta- 
 tion of jewelry and enamel. The heroic statues were 
 commonly of bronze, sometimes gilt, sometimes of 
 metal much alloyed, sometimes stained with bitumen : 
 the marble statues were tinted by encaustic, the 
 famous " circumlitio " being the process of its use. 
 With these the temples within and without, the 
 porticoes, the galleries of the market-places, the 
 Lesche, the Agorae, and the public walks, were orna- 
 mented, and such was the general taste for coloured 
 and varied materials that statues of ivory and gold, 
 exported by hundreds, became an important part of 
 Athenian trade. Such was the proud magnificence to 
 which victorious Athens had trained her people. The 
 artist's mind was full of the romance and heroism of 
 his own times ; and his imagination, enriched with the 
 myths, the poetry, and the traditions of his country's 
 history, realised to the people the just mead of their 
 own devotion. For us imagination alone can form a 
 picture of it. No painted casts, no plaster models of 
 temple fronts and groups of sculpture, even were 
 Aphrodisius, Pansenus, and Nicias called up to paint 
 
88 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 them, could give the faintest idea of those glories of old 
 art. Colour needs colour ; and colour supports colour, 
 and the material it adorns makes much of its beauty. 
 No grouped or isolated illustrations could inspire the 
 idea of what that reunion of the arts produced ; nor 
 reproduce that symphony of harmonious form and 
 colour that the wealth and refinement of Greek cities 
 realised, and Greek sun and atmosphere made possible. 
 
 Nature has taught and trained us all. It has 
 endeared to us our sober scenery, our misty skies, and 
 the gray moss and lichen on our storm-stained walls ; 
 but to them, that glorious flood of light that turned 
 their distant glaciers into jewelry, that deep blue sea, 
 those cliffs and sun-browned rocks that had trained 
 their sight to the revelry of colours, had made such 
 backgrounds for all that human hands could raise in 
 front of them, that their architecture and sculpture 
 would have been intolerable without some artifice to 
 harmonise them with Nature. So colour was the note 
 to which they were all attuned ; and Pheidias and his 
 friends let their artistic enthusiasm go free in the gold 
 and vermilion of their sunny cornices, and in the 
 vigorous contrasts and reliefs of their groups of 
 sculpture. 
 
 The common reference that the opponents of colour- 
 ing make to the authority of Lucian to prove the absence 
 of all colour on the finest works of ancient sculpture, by 
 citing the whiteness of Praxiteles's masterpiece, the 
 Venus of Cnidos, appears to me to savour of a criticism 
 inspired by an exaggeration or misconception of the 
 use of colour, and indeed in some persons by a natural 
 inaptitude or a temper of resolute antipathy. Lucian 
 presents the subject in the form of an imaginary con- 
 versation, in which the 'speakers are engaged not so 
 much in artistic criticism as in lauding the exquisite 
 complexion of a beautiful lady. They compare it with 
 
v COLOUR AND SCULPTURE 89 
 
 the finest known works of sculpture and painting, and 
 to this statue in particular, concluding that marble is 
 too white for it ; and hence modern opinion has jumped 
 to the result that all the finest marble sculpture of 
 antiquity was left crude white from the master's hand. 
 Then how about Praxiteles's opinion, which was dia- 
 metrically the opposite of this? The idea of repre- 
 senting the natural effect of flesh in the colouring of 
 statues, or even the broader treatment of washing a 
 statue over with what is commonly understood as flesh 
 tint, except in the necessary conventionality of archi- 
 tectural sculpture, would be an equal insult to human 
 eyes and to Nature. I can, however, imagine an art- 
 loving literary archaeologist, but certainly not an artist, 
 writing that he " meant by painting a statue, the 
 employment of colours so as to give to the face and 
 body the actual hues which they have in nature." 1 
 Praxiteles would have thought Nicias gone mad if he 
 had written that. It is not to be wondered at that 
 Lucian's conversation concludes that sculptured marble 
 was too white for comparison with the flesh of that 
 lady. 2 It is the misconception of the art of applying 
 colour to sculpture that presses the argument, without 
 
 1 Quatremere de Quincy, Le Jupiter Olympien. 
 
 2 If Lucian's imaginary allusions to the Venus of Cnidos be properly 
 estimated, it will be remembered that the statue was above 450 years old 
 when he saw it, and that the colour used for such a tint as such a statue would 
 have had, would have been very fugitive. The real colour would in all prob- 
 ability have been a merely mellowing tint, with which its encaustic would 
 have been " variata." He does not mention colour or white, but describes 
 the effect as \afj.7rpoTr]s, which answers exactly to Pliny's word " nitescunt." 
 If &'jwarm tint were used on it, the colour would have been most probably 
 prepared with vermilion and treated in the most delicate manner. Archaic 
 statues were much prized in the time of Praxiteles for some pleasant or 
 quaint associations, and these were painted all over with unmitigated ver- 
 milion[; but even in that excess of colour, such was its quality that those 
 statues had to be frequently repainted. Any other colour would have 
 been stains, still more fugitive, or ocres uselessly opaque. Lucian's 
 testimony as to the non-existence of colouring on that or any other sculpture 
 contemporary with it, seems therefore to me worthless. 
 
90 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 thought of circumstances or the limits of each art, 
 that " proximity to naturalist representation marks the 
 degrees of an art's perfection." It may do so as regards 
 mechanical imitation, for perfect mechanism would 
 make any number of copies the same, but no two out 
 of twenty artists, worth their salt, would or could make 
 their copies alike if acting independently, especially if 
 they were studies from Nature, for a copy is the 
 idea or impression of each individual mind reflected in 
 his work, and there is none such in a mechanical 
 copyist. An artist not merely sees but feels, and 
 works as he feels. So in using colour, if condescend- 
 ing to the base trade of a wax portrait modeller, he 
 would probably "represent nature" (!) better than any 
 other man ; but as a sculptor, putting out the whole 
 energy of his artistic sense, the feeling which prompted 
 his idea would be his guide, and colour would then 
 become an abstract conception, totally irrespective of 
 simple natural effect, and, if used at all, would be so, 
 not as an element of representative art, but as an 
 element of perfection to be moulded to his purpose, to 
 enhance the expression of his work, an imitation, 
 indeed, if you will, both of form and colour, but the 
 imitation of the ideal of Nature in his mind. 
 
 Parian marble was so tender in texture and hue 
 that to use the word asperity, as a fault of its natural 
 surface, would be an exaggeration ; but works of art 
 are not independent of surrounding circumstances, and 
 the treatment of marble surfaces in sculpture by the 
 ancients in some way or other, beyond the last touch 
 of file or chisel, is indubitable ; and in doing so, there 
 could be no purpose but to modify them. In Lucian's 
 conversation, the surface was not declared to be un- 
 coloured, but only too white for human flesh. The 
 Venus of Cnidos was said to be so, but that was all. 
 White has a very wide range indeed of hues, short of 
 
COLOUR AND SCULPTURE 91 
 
 the tender life -blood -tint even of the fairest flesh. 
 That statue was cited as an exquisite example, but a 
 defect in the marble, marked by a dark spot on one of 
 the legs, has been especially noticed as a proof that the 
 statue was not " painted." Most true, indeed, it was 
 not so, as this crude idea of " paint " implies, which no 
 artist's mind would have conceived. The marble was 
 marble still, not for its own exhibition of lime and 
 crystals, but to serve its purpose ; not mimic flesh, to 
 delude and offend by vulgar trickery, but marble still, 
 with unobtrusive surface, toned, veiled, and made beauti- 
 ful as only art can make it. But as this was one of the 
 master's finest works, of which he said those " pleased 
 him most " that his young friend the encaustic painter 
 Nicias had touched, 1 it is but a fair inference that this, 
 his masterpiece, the Venus of Cnidos, was among that 
 number that " pleased him most." That figure was the 
 ideal of female beauty, and not in form only, but in 
 tone and texture, all would have been done by such a 
 master to make it perfect. The encaustic circumlitio, 
 whether plain or " variata," but equally mellowing and 
 transparent, would have exactly produced the desired 
 effect, and the softness of its tint would have made 
 refinement more refined. All was coloured round it. 
 The open shrine in which it stood, was surrounded by 
 all that cost and artifice of ornamental gardening could 
 produce ; and if upon the statue itself the mellow tint 
 of the encaustic painter produced a blush that did but 
 play into the fancy of the eyes, without pretending to 
 reality, the marble would only have been softened 
 by it, not disguised, and, by contrast, have been made 
 only more beautifully white. 
 
 The negative evidence of the non-existence of 
 
 1 " Dicebat Praxiteles interrogates que maxime opera sua probasset in 
 marboribus quibus Nicias manum admovisset,' tantum circumlitioni ejus 
 tribuebat." Pliny, N. H. xxxv. 
 
92 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 examples, or of any definite account of the artistic 
 treatment of this class of sculpture, is not conclusive. 
 The positive evidence of the finest works having been 
 subject to the encaustic painter, 1 as those of Praxiteles, 
 or worked in variously coloured materials as those of 
 Pheidias, or decked with jewels and gold as was the 
 Venus dei Medici, indicates sufficiently the direction of 
 public taste of that age as guided by its greatest men. 
 By piecing together the fragments of ancient and 
 modern testimony, it seems to me inevitable to con- 
 clude that colour was very widely used in the finest 
 sculpture of the Greeks, and that its general use pre- 
 vented any effect of peculiarity and strangeness which 
 its extreme rarity produces upon us. It may be im- 
 possible to say exactly where and how much, especially 
 with respect to the actual tinting of the nude parts ; 
 but taking for granted the finest discrimination in its 
 use, there is strong testimony for its artistic propriety. 
 From what we know of the style in which ancient writers 
 treat such subjects, a perfectly definite description 
 of colours could not be expected. For instance, Plato's 
 admiration of the local propriety of the colours used on 
 painted statues leaves all detail to the imagination. 
 Gilding, colours, and statue painting, are mentioned 
 again and again by old authors, but almost always 
 with poetic vagueness. Statues are said to have been 
 sometimes painted with vermilion, but we know that 
 that colour varies from the most offensive violence to 
 the ground of the tenderest blush. The choice of ivory 
 for the nude parts suggests the almost necessary use of 
 a stain upon it, 2 as in the case of ornaments where such 
 
 1 " Uti signa marmoria curantur." Vitruvius, vii. 9. Quoting from 
 ancient Greek writers. 
 
 2 Among the Athenian artists of the time of Pericles, Plutarch men- 
 tions e\^0ai/Tos co7/3a0oi, painters of ivory, or painters from life on ivory. 
 Ivory was treated with great independence by the ancients, who, careless 
 of its beautiful colour, very commonly used it as a vehicle for other colours. 
 
v COLOUR AND SCULPTURE 93 
 
 treatment was universal ; but in the use of it for the 
 nude parts of statues, it was necessary to overcome the 
 unbecoming blots and tints of its inlaid pieces, or its 
 liability to turn yellow. But realistic imitation of flesh 
 is nowhere specified, nor are there any remains of any 
 attempt at flesh-tint, such as is generally understood 
 by that word, except on statuettes and figures in 
 coloured terra -cotta ; but ivory of itself approached 
 so near to the tone and texture of flesh, that anything 
 done to it by the artist would have been inevitably in 
 the direction of greater likeness, however much or little 
 he modified his tints of yellow, olive, red, or brown ; 
 so that from all we naturally infer, and from what we 
 gather by the facts of special " ivory painters " being 
 employed, or by Plato's expressed admiration of the 
 " appropriateness " of the colouring of statues, or from 
 the use of jewelry to give brightness to the eyes, and 
 the entirely naturalistic effect of the enamel-embroidered 
 drapery and of the constructive materials, it is inevit- 
 able to conclude that if in any form of sculpture 
 realistic effect was the result of its ornament, it was in 
 those colossal statues of ivory and gold. But this was 
 contrary to the great sculptor's wish. Pheidias had 
 urged to the utmost his preference for marble ; but he 
 was overruled, and the employment of ivory was forced 
 upon him by the popular will ; and every touch that 
 degraded the ideal to the level of imitative reality was 
 executed by other hands than his. 
 
 In the writings of numerous travellers and artists, 
 both English and foreign, early in this century, we 
 
 In several places Homer mentions it, as in Iliad, IV. v. 141, where he de- 
 scribes the ornaments of purple stained ivory of the harness. The plaques 
 of ivory from Assyria and Egypt are commonly so carved for the purpose 
 of inlaid coloured enamel, that not half the ivory surface is left. The 
 mediaeval ivories were also frequently painted, just as the ancient Greeks 
 had treated their marble architectural sculpture, painting strong flat back- 
 grounds, gilding all ornaments, and colouring forcibly the linings of 
 draperies and accessories. 
 
94 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 have the clear evidence of eye-witnesses of the colour- 
 ing of the finest marble : as Professor Cockerell writes 
 of the Parian marble sculpture of the Theseum, "The 
 Minerva, the central figure of the Western Pediment, 
 was painted with chequers of beads ; the ^Egis was 
 painted all over, with gilded scales, etc. ; " and Mr. 
 Dodwell, writing in 1813, says of the marble figures 
 of the Pediment of ^Egina, "The statues were all 
 painted, the colours are still visible;" and of the 
 Theseum, he writes (in 1801-6), "the armour and the 
 accessories have been gilt to represent gold or bronze ; 
 the drapery is generally green, blue, or red, the favourite 
 colours of the Greeks. The scene took place in the 
 open air, so the ground is painted blue." 1 And thus 
 many others have written about other places and other 
 sculpture, of which these are but specimens ; and 
 although such notices apply exclusively to temple 
 statues and reliefs on temple walls, they indicate at least 
 the general principle how architectural sculpture was 
 treated in other buildings, for colour and gold was not 
 peculiar to temple architecture ; but the statues in the 
 
 1 The references to authorities on the subject of sculptural and archi- 
 tectural colouring are too lengthy and numerous for quotation. Travellers 
 and archaeologists from most countries in Europe have contributed to 
 them. The following are some of the most easily accessible and worthy 
 of study : Of ancient authors Pausanias, Strabo, Lucian, Pliny, Vitruvius, 
 Callistratus's Descrip. Stat., Plutarch's De Glor. A then. Of modern date 
 Mr. DodwelFs Travels in Greece, Mr. Clarke's ditto, Professor Cockerell's 
 sEgina and Basses, Col. Leake's Topography of Athens, Stuart's Athens, 
 Kennard's edition of ditto, Mr. Donaldson's Supplement to ditto, Sir C. 
 Fellows's Lycia, Faulkener's Dadalus and Mitseum of Classical Antiquities, 
 Mr. Penrose's Principles of Athen. Arch, and Polychromy, with coloured 
 illustrations, R. Rochette's Peintures Antiqties and Lectures on Ancient 
 Art, Letronne's Lettres d^un Antiqnaire, etc., Millin's Monuments Inedits, 
 Quatremere de Quincy's Jupiter Olymp., Report of the French Expedition 
 to the Morea, Report of German Expedition to Olympia, Bronsted's Voyage 
 en Grece, Weigmann's Die Malerei der Alien, Kugler's Ueber die Poly- 
 chromie, Hittorff's Temple d^Empedocle, Stackelberg's Apollo Tempel zu 
 Bass<z, Winckelman's Reflections on Painting and Sculpture of the Greeks, 
 Labrouste's Restitution des Temples de P&stum, for the Ecole des Beaux 
 Arts, and plates. 
 
v COLOUR AND SCULPTURE 95 
 
 Propylaeae, the Agorae, and Leschae, and all such public 
 buildings, would be subject to a treatment at least in 
 some degree similar to those on the great models of 
 Greek architecture. Isolated statues would be treated 
 independently, but the most independent of them were 
 always associated with those public places, and were 
 usually placed within them or in their niches, or on 
 pedestals in front of them ; and such statues, thus 
 placed, embrace the greatest masterpieces of antiquity. 
 The accounts we have of the discovery of numerous 
 statues in many places, assert the vividness of their 
 original colouring when first unearthed, but that upon 
 exposure it faded away at once. 1 If then such was 
 the case with the powerful colours of their drapery 
 and accessories, how much more would this effect of 
 time and exposure be evident on the tender encaustic 
 painting of their limbs ; a painting that was free from 
 opacity, and, by all that we can judge, amounted, in 
 independent sculpture, to no more than a transparent 
 glaze and polish through which the crystalline beauty 
 of the marble would show its toned whiteness, as silver 
 does in translucent enamels, and as Pliny says, after 
 describing the encaustic process, " Sicut et marmora 
 nitescunt" But for our eyes nothing has been spared ; 
 those statues, whether independent or architectural, 
 were at first well cleaned upon their discovery, then, 
 on arrival at their destinations, well soaped for taking 
 plaster casts, then chemically washed to get rid of the 
 soap (as the Elgin marbles and others in the British 
 Museum were treated) and at last presented to us 
 
 1 Mr. Newton, in a letter addressed to Mr. Faulkener, and quoted at 
 length in his interesting volume Dcedalus, referring to the colouring on the 
 sculpture found at Halicarnassus, of which the finest extant specimens are 
 now in the British Museum, writes thus of the colours which he found on 
 many parts both of the architecture and statues, " I saw them fade away 
 in the sunlight like a ghost. " Professor Cockerell writes of the colours on 
 the statues at /Egina, " They were discovered in all their original vividness, 
 which quickly disappeared on exposure." 
 
96 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY v 
 
 bare marble ; and people think that they were ever 
 bare, from which the old encaustic painter's work has 
 thus been ruthlessly stripped, and not a blush of it 
 remains. To form our judgment of the practice and 
 effect of that art, granted that but little more than 
 written evidence and inference remains, but it is infer- 
 ence not vainly based on fancy, but on all that we 
 know too well of the conditions under which the 
 arts flourished together in those days, to need further 
 reference. 
 
ESSAY V Continued 
 
 THE MINISTRY OF COLOUR TO SCULPTURE 
 AND ARCHITECTURE 
 
 PART II ARCHITECTURAL WALL PAINTING 
 
 /"COLOUR as an element of architectural effect was in the 
 ^ earlier years of this century generally regarded as 
 a novelty. The traditions of classic art were lost or in 
 abeyance ; the colouring of Christian buildings had 
 been all but exclusively internal ; the systems of wall 
 painting were, however, being studied afresh, aroused 
 to interest by the discoveries in Greece and at Pompeii, 
 and thus, whether for within or for without, the idea 
 of colour was dawning as a new light. The former 
 generation had been educated in a purism which kept 
 the arts estranged. The painter, the sculptor, and the 
 architect knew little or nothing of each other's arts. 
 The idea of modulating them into one great rhythm 
 was not dreamed of, and they cared for them as little 
 as they knew. The public cared for none of those 
 things, and the few who were spared from politics, 
 commerce, or righting, received as gospel the common 
 art-tradition that colour was the province of pictures, 
 and that sculpture and architecture were sacred alone 
 to the ideal of abstract form. Such was the art religion 
 of the day : all else was sacrilege ; and there was much 
 truth in it, so much so, indeed, that with all our 
 
 H 
 
98 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 emancipation and liberty of conscience in such matters, 
 we must acknowledge much in it to revere and to 
 admire, for its foundation was a sound one, and lay in 
 an ideal of purity, in a recognition of the excellence of 
 abstract beauty, and in that modesty of art which is 
 implied by singleness of purpose. 
 
 The employment of colour with architecture in the 
 times of its perfection is now too generally admitted to 
 need proof. The beauty of nude and colourless forms 
 may be very great, but they need to be of the highest 
 art to bear the trial of such nude exposure. The nude 
 beauty of uncoloured architecture is certainly of the 
 most pure and abstract kind. Architecture is an in- 
 tellectual creation, but as such it is too artificial, too 
 abstract, too exclusive of all that is common to external 
 Nature to command all hearts. There is a note wanting 
 in its scale. One touch might bring the refinement of 
 its calculated symmetry into a closer harmony with 
 external Nature, and the abstractions of human genius 
 into nearer accord with the feelings of human nature, 
 and that is the touch of colour. 
 
 A thing of colour is a thing of life. A colourless 
 thing in Nature, if there be such, savours more of death 
 than life. In art a colourless thing is but a passionless 
 abstraction. It may be in both pure and lovely, even 
 though the idea of life may have no part with it. But, 
 as life is better than death, so are things that represent 
 it ; and, as Nature without colour is inconceivable, so 
 art without colour is incomplete. 
 
 The colouring by the ancients, whether by their 
 wall paintings within or the polychrome of their sculp- 
 ture and architecture without, was as contemporaneous 
 with their building as each case allowed. The example 
 of an uncoloured temple or public building as being 
 exceptional or indicating its unfinished condition, was 
 well illustrated in the story told by Herodotus of the 
 
v ARCHITECTURAL WALL PAINTING 99 
 
 reply given to the Siphnians, who in much anxiety had 
 consulted the Pythian oracle, and received this many- 
 coloured answer : " When the Prytaneia in Siphnos 
 shall be white, and the Agora white-fronted, then there 
 is need of a prudent man to guard against a wooden 
 troop and a crimson herald." They were white at that 
 time, being scarcely completed, and so they remained, 
 for the "prudent man " did not appear in time to save 
 the people from the ruin that immediately befell them 
 by the invasion of the Samians. Those buildings 
 were of Parian marble. The oracle had specified their 
 whiteness as a peculiarity. 
 
 In such magnificent beauty as in the works of the 
 architect Ictinus and the sculptor Pheidias, in their 
 full glory of mingled natural and artificial colouring, 
 we hear no regrets of the great artists themselves, nor 
 complaints of their contemporaries, that colour inter- 
 fered with the beauty of their forms. In their days 
 was realised that power of artistic combination by 
 which colour could be felt as pure and beautiful in art 
 as it was in nature. In those days the grandeur and 
 the beauty of form, as represented by the highest ideal 
 of architecture and of sculpture, could be and was re- 
 cognised no more in the tender hue of the Venus of 
 Cnidos than in the splendour of the Minerva of the 
 Parthenon ; no more in the white shafts and cornices 
 of Siphnos than in the coloured glories of Athens and 
 Olympia. No, in those days, to which we turn with 
 reverence for the classic education of art as for the 
 classic education of its literature, we hear nothing of 
 such bald objections, which seem only to imply either 
 weakness of sense or poverty of imagination. The 
 ideal of beauty in form is rightly loved for its purity, 
 but I am convinced that, as in ancient days, so too in 
 our own, a larger-hearted and not less pure-minded 
 perception of its excellence will find no hindrance in 
 
ioo THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 its association with the equally pure element of colour, 
 if only rightly used, but rather will love the loveliness 
 of colour all the more, which only makes the ideal form 
 more lovely still, as it has nature for its universal guide 
 and human sympathies for its universal exponent. 
 
 When the sculptor, the painter, and the architect 
 thus worked together, the spirit of the age which had 
 brought their arts into life and action inspired them 
 alike ; but in tracing the progress of their arts' develop- 
 ment it has been too common to treat each stage of 
 it with comparative indifference, as but a passing phase 
 of its condition, and, with the view directed only to the 
 ultimate result, to ignore the principles which at each 
 period prevailed. Such principles may, indeed, have 
 been inchoate and perhaps unheeded, but they definitely 
 marked the turnings of the road that led to their per- 
 fection ; and, as such, each turn exhibited an experi- 
 ment, at the time invaluable, but lost sight of in the 
 general halo of their advance. A spirit of independence 
 was perhaps inevitable, as each art developed, and was 
 regretable only in its excess, when their unity was im- 
 paired by indifference and self-assertion. In earlier 
 days such discord did not exist. A definite style, no 
 matter of what age, was the expression of a definite 
 idea ; it was perfected by the union of many arts, and 
 the more perfect their union, the more perfect was the 
 expression of that idea. Destroy that union and you 
 destroy the very means of its expression, for the 
 whole charm of style lay in the purity and clearness 
 of its voice as the articulate expression of individual 
 character. 
 
 But in modern times, since the beginning of the 
 fifteenth century, the union of painting with architec- 
 ture has been greatly impaired by the growth, and at 
 last by the excess of independence. The development 
 of the painter's art led to the development of one ex- 
 
v ARCHITECTURAL WALL PAINTING 101 
 
 elusive phase of it, that of pictorial effect. But the 
 true greatness of the art consists rather in the greatness 
 of its adaptability, in its width and power to respond to 
 the most opposite demands. But now it is restricted 
 to one only phase, one and one only is supposed, , com- 
 patible or proper to its highest aims, that whefrbeiVil "be 
 applied within the limits of a gold frame, qr be spread 
 over some great surface, needed for the J repose' ' and 
 grandeur of architectural effect, yet still that the same 
 ever -repeated phase of picture should prevail. It is 
 strange that artists should fail to recognise the weak- 
 ness of this restriction, that their grand art should 
 manifest such poverty of invention and resource that, 
 under conditions so opposite, it should still remain the 
 same. 
 
 The modern painter has made himself a slave to 
 the mere technicalities of naturalistic and pictorial com- 
 position, but the greatness of his art lies in design^ not 
 in the mere technicalities of linear or atmospheric re- 
 lief. But art was in this way narrowed centuries ago, 
 even by those who in the great days of its revival 
 glorified it by their genius. Painting was reduced to 
 illusive pictorial effect, drawn in within one narrow 
 code of practice. The picture, the altar-piece, the 
 window, and the wall, the fresco and the mosaic, were 
 all brought within the category of the same rigid table 
 of art laws ; and why ? because the artists were in 
 bondage to one view or principle, and had ignored the 
 varying conditions of art in its place, its purpose, and 
 its materials ; and popular opinion, with its eyes half 
 closed, was miseducated by its masters. 
 
 To the honour of English art, there have been two 
 great spirits who broke loose from the track of common- 
 place and asserted in practice the true theory of design, 
 both in decorative and in the highest order of illus- 
 trative art, Wedgwood and Flaxman. 
 
102 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 Linear and atmospheric perspective are, of course, 
 among the primary essentials of an artist's education, 
 but as accomplishments they rank with his alphabet 
 and spelling-book. In dealing with them successfully 
 Qn : a scale and under circumstances where a modifica- 
 tion' ''<$' them is necessary, lies an artist's skill. For 
 "tetaiice. in a long wall painting, which a spectator 
 w6uld necessarily move about to see, such modification 
 is inevitable ; several points of sight must be taken ; 
 but such dealing with linear perspective is a very dif- 
 ferent thing from ignorant or wilful outrage of it. 
 Subjects may be so treated as to render such modifica- 
 tion possible and agreeable, and composition may be 
 so arranged as wellnigh to cloak the effects of per- 
 spective. The foreshortening which is the perspective 
 in figure-drawing is of course an absolute necessity and 
 inviolable, but that is an effect of local as distinct from 
 pictorial and general perspective, and in no way inter- 
 feres with the restrictions that are necessary in some 
 conditions of wall painting. I know that such restric- 
 tions do cause difficulty to those who will not or cannot 
 embrace the idea and principle they involve. The 
 easy freedom of ordinary picture painting is gone. A 
 disciplined and dignified simplicity is imposed on the 
 artist, a simplicity that concentrates his mental con- 
 ception of a subject and checks his hand, but the result 
 may be all the nobler for this discipline. 
 
 The design, the composition, the colour, and all 
 that in the unfettered freedom of pictorial effect were 
 helped by technical convenience, or hidden and screened, 
 shirked or scamped by artistic ingenuity, are now laid 
 bare and open to all eyes, and must be met and 
 mastered. The sculpturesque simplicity of ultimate 
 effect demands his highest attainments. The strain 
 calls out powers hitherto unbidden. The rigour of the 
 discipline deepens and matures his study, and, if genius 
 
v ARCHITECTURAL WALL PAINTING 103 
 
 be there, his work is grander for the victory he has 
 gained, and the loss of minor effects is more than 
 compensated by the perfection of the greater and 
 nobler elements of his art, form, proportion, and equi- 
 librium. 
 
 Michael Angelo in the Sistine Chapel, and Raphael 
 in the Stanze, painted on walls with full and free pic- 
 torial effect, and rightly^ because in both cases no archi- 
 tectural obligations were in their way. Raphael then 
 painted upon the mere walls of rooms, and what archi- 
 tectural forms were there, were merely decorative and 
 tantamount to picture frames. In the Sistine Chapel 
 there are no forms of architectural construction to 
 falsify, so the artist was free. The whole is painted ; 
 the whole interior is a scene of architecture, sculpture, 
 frames, and pictures ; an interior of the extremest 
 conventionality, that must be accepted in honour of 
 the splendid genius displayed in it. It falsifies and 
 violates no constructive architecture. It is a work of 
 thorough and consistent artifice, and clashes with no 
 principle that I advocate. 
 
 It would be entirely to misunderstand my purpose 
 if it were supposed that I could possibly underrate the 
 merits of pictorial composition and all those splendid 
 accomplishments which lead to its perfection. It would 
 be worse than absurd to suppose that my advocacy of 
 a distinctly architectural treatment of painted subjects 
 should apply to all occasions of wall painting, as though 
 such as adorn the open spaces of the walls of public 
 buildings, where incidents of national or local history 
 are displayed, such paintings should be deprived of 
 more than half their interest by denying them their 
 scenic completeness and the charm of natural effects. 
 What would the ancient walls of the libreria at Siena 
 be if Pinturicchio's historic works were deprived of all 
 the vivid interest in the stories completed in their 
 
104 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 backgrounds, or those by Herbert and Maclise in the 
 modern palace of Westminster ? All such are too 
 precious for present and future record and enjoyment 
 to be curtailed of a tittle of their value by submission 
 to severe or conventional principles. But I am writing 
 of a totally different matter and of a different occasion. 
 I desire only to press the duty of the painter to accept 
 the obligations of architectural constructive effect, and 
 to curb artistic licence, where the mere A B C of 
 atmosphere and perspective are displayed as merits, 
 where indeed they exhibit only the artist's limited per- 
 ception and poverty of resource, and mar the beauty 
 of a sister art. 
 
 Let picture painting be as free as the air it imitates, 
 but architectural wall painting is bound by the respect 
 that one art owes to another. In the former, the effect 
 of it should be the annihilation of surface, in the 
 latter, its emphasis. 
 
 By all that we can learn from the relics of ancient 
 monuments and the records of ancient literature, we 
 find that everywhere, when those arts were combined 
 without mutual injury, a system, even if it cannot be 
 dignified as a principle, was implicitly followed, and, 
 purposely or by intuition, the artists worked with archi- 
 tecture without stultifying it, and produced works mag- 
 nificent in their consistency. 
 
 If we reach back to long past times for precedents 
 that would command respect, we may have to pass 
 over centuries in which the true principles of monu- 
 mental wall painting were unbroken, but where, as in 
 the waning art of Rome and Byzantium or the 
 waking art of the Christian middle ages, the art 
 itself was too faulty or incomplete in other ways to be 
 accepted as authority. The crude and lifeless pro- 
 ductions of the Byzantine school, such as those which 
 in painting or mosaic cover the walls and cupolas of 
 
v ARCHITECTURAL WALL PAINTING 105 
 
 Constantinople, Ravenna, Salonica, and Trebizond, were 
 based on the traditions of antiquity. Their isolated 
 groups and single figures were composed, in relation 
 to each other, on a system which they had not in- 
 vented, but which, inherited and perpetuated by them, 
 feebly and sometimes painfully, did nevertheless in 
 their way represent the true architectonic ideal of their 
 great ancestors. When the archaeologist Pausanias 
 describes the chest of Cypselus he describes a system 
 of composing a series of subjects upon one surface 
 which has prevailed for centuries before and since, from 
 the wall paintings and coloured reliefs of Egypt and 
 Assyria to the sculpture, the paintings, and ivory 
 carvings of the Christian middle ages. And when he 
 and others write of the great wall paintings of the days 
 of Pericles, their descriptions picture to our imagination 
 systems of composition conceived in the same manner. 
 Such is the idea we form of the great works of Micon 
 in the cella of the Theseum, which he covered with 
 the battle groups of Centaurs and Lapithae, Greeks 
 and Amazons. So also were those of Polygnotus at 
 Thespiae, and his vast works which covered the walls 
 of the Lesche at Delphi with historic scenes of the fall 
 of Troy and the fabled visit of Ulysses to Tiresias in 
 Hades, with their many groups and subjects arranged 
 in succession and above or below each other. It was 
 thus that Pheidias in his younger days must have 
 painted the Olympion at Athens, and thus his nephew 
 Panaenus covered with groups of fighting Amazons the 
 shield of Minerva in her temple at Elis and the archi- 
 tectural spaces round the great Jupiter of Olympia ; 
 thus too must Pausias have painted when he restored 
 the works of Polygnotus on the injured walls of 
 Thespiae. These were the days of consummate genius, 
 when principles were worked out and fixed that have 
 prevailed, and in art must prevail for ever, where per- 
 
io6 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 feet reason and perfect imagination combine their equal 
 powers which genius alone can sway. 
 
 The feeble Byzantines, the Christian mosaicists, and 
 the Gothic wall painters only followed on the lines which 
 had reached them through dark and evil times from 
 the finest art-schools of antiquity, for the golden thread 
 of artistic sympathy which bound together those true 
 but unequal friends has never been broken. The fifth 
 century B.C. was the great classic building age, and archi- 
 tecture then ruled the arts and inspired the sculptor 
 and painter with its ideal of consummate dignity. We 
 have but the relics of their arts in ruined fanes and 
 broken statues, in the copies, or at least the influence 
 of their works in the imagery of their painted pottery, 
 but even with these we have enough, by careful in- 
 ference, to realise in imagination the grandeur of their 
 genius. 
 
 There were two distinct systems of painting by the 
 Greeks, one on panels, the other on walls. With the 
 first we have nothing to do here, for they were inde- 
 pendent pictures, free from all architectural conditions, 
 and usually let into walls, framed or hung upon them. 
 Wall painting was essentially the art of the great 
 building age ; grand, heroic, monumental. Panel pic- 
 tures were produced equally with their wall paintings 
 by the great masters of the age, but were essentially 
 the development of a later time and a more delicate 
 technicality, the work of independent genius supplying 
 the costliest votive offerings of the temples and the 
 gems of public and private property. 
 
 It would be an offence to the works of those great 
 wall painters of Elis, Athens, Thespiae, and Delphi to 
 draw from the designs of the vase painters, refined and 
 beautiful as they often were, a further comparison with 
 them than that which a weaker art may suggest of a 
 greater, viz. the broad ideal of its conditions. But that 
 
v ARCHITECTURAL WALL PAINTING 107 
 
 much we certainly may draw, for it is impossible to 
 account for the combination of such magnificence of 
 idea and composition with such frequently weak and 
 faulty handling as those vases present, otherwise than 
 by attributing their derivation to the works of the great 
 masters of their age. If therefore from them we de- 
 duce the impression that those master -works were 
 characterised by the dignity of sculpturesque self- 
 restraint, as distinguished from the freedom of the 
 picturesque, we shall be forming a just idea of them, 
 for all other available testimony confirms it, from 
 traditional description, from eye-witnesses, from models 
 of design in contemporary sculpture, from the bas-reliefs 
 of the Heroum of Zanthus to the friezes of Pheigalia, 
 from the pictures on the prize Lechithoi of Athens, and 
 from the far-reaching influence of their characteristic 
 conditions, that can be traced back to them from the 
 walls of Pompeii and the decorative paintings of Rome. 
 The Greek, the Rhodian, and the so-called Etruscan 
 vases, which are painted only in outline, or admitting 
 rarely the introduction of white and gold, 1 afford but an 
 imperfect idea of the modelling and effect of the great 
 compositions from which they are derived, except in 
 the examples of the Athenian Lechithoi, which retain 
 fragments of the richest colours, and from them may 
 be formed a fair conception of the splendour of the old 
 Greek wall painting. An admirable specimen of this 
 kind of composition is seen on a Lechithos in the 
 British Museum, on which is painted the group of 
 Orestes, Electra, and Iphigenia at the tomb of Aga- 
 memnon. It is a perfect wall painting ; the figures 
 are exquisitely drawn, the colouring is intense, the 
 
 1 One of the finest compositions of this kind is that of the surprise of 
 Thetis by Peleus on the Cameirus vase, in the British Museum, on which 
 Eros is painted white with gold and blue-enamelled wings, and the figure 
 of Thetis is pure white. 
 
io8 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 composition is entirely free from pictorial relief, the 
 background is a mere architectural indication, and the 
 unoccupied space above is a flat tint of uniform blue. 
 
 We are, therefore, justified by these various styles 
 of vase painting in forming a definite idea of the essen- 
 tially architectonic character of the great works from 
 which they have drawn their motives, corroborated as 
 they are by contemporary bas-reliefs which represent 
 the pictorial element of sculpture, and to form, at the 
 same time, a high estimate of their artistic merits, con^ 
 firmed as it is by the admiration which the great 
 originals universally obtained ; for, taking Polygnotus 
 as a representative of the age and style, the art must 
 have been of a noble kind that could have drawn forth 
 such praises as those of Aristotle, who attributed to 
 him the highest excellencies of both technical and 
 moral beauty, or such as those of the critical Lucian, 
 who ranked him among the best of Greek colourists. 
 
 The result was a style which on all accounts de- 
 manded the highest artistic powers, unaided, as it was 
 in later and pre-eminently in modern art, by the acces- 
 sories of elaborate backgrounds. Landscape painting, 
 as a distinct art, had no existence in that age ; nor 
 even, so far as it is possible to ascertain, was it ever 
 developed on naturalistic principles by the Greeks. 
 The perspective necessary for it was not known till 
 a later age ; for that which has been attributed to the 
 architect and scene-painter Agatharcus, and described 
 by Democritus and Vitruvius from his writings, amounted 
 only to the elements of linear effects. Historical and 
 mythological subjects and athletic national pursuits 
 engrossed public attention ; and where out-of-door life 
 in such a country and climate was the habit of the 
 people, such art as that of landscape painting was not 
 needed to fill up any void left by the beautiful Nature 
 around them. 
 
v ARCHITECTURAL WALL PAINTING 109 
 
 The examples of pictures saved from the ruins of 
 Pompeii and Rome, which savour most of ancient 
 Greek tradition, bear evidence, in contrast with the 
 complex and realistic naturalism of modern art, how 
 simple, symbolic, and conventional was the treatment 
 of all backgrounds by the ancient classic school. The 
 late Pompeian and Roman paintings of the time of 
 the empire, 1 and such as, later still, the genre-painter 
 Ludius had influenced, belong to a quasi-modern school 
 of the picturesque, having lost all the dignity which 
 characterised the Greek school. Such are the wall 
 paintings of the house of the Empress Livia, which 
 represent panel-pictures with all the attempt at pic- 
 torial effect common to that period, exhibiting the 
 utmost known of atmospheric relief, as in the back- 
 ground to the group of lo, Mercury, and Argos, with 
 their landscape of mist and mountain ; or the scene 
 through an imaginary window, where the street and 
 houses are drawn in such perspective as no child could 
 now be guilty of. But the panels to which I refer as 
 
 1 A very illustrative series of pictures of this kind may be studied in 
 Bartoli's two volumes, Recetdl de Peintiires Antiques, 1783, and in the 
 volumes of the Museo Borbonico, and R. Rochette's Peintures Antiques 
 Inedites. In some of these the landscape occupies the greater part of the 
 scene, but without any definite principles of composition, scattered and 
 ill drawn, with here and there imperfect effects of atmospheric perspective, 
 and, where buildings are introduced about the scene, each is drawn with 
 a linear perspective of its own, and even then without any approach to 
 definite rule, the result being exceedingly crude and awkward. 
 
 Landscape painting, as a distinct art, is that of modern times and 
 northern nations. Of the landscape scenery of the Greek theatres nothing 
 is clearly known but that special places were indicated in them, and that 
 in Greek pictures particular objects were admirably illustrated ; but the 
 distinct selection of natural scenery and effects, as the sole purpose of 
 pictorial illustration, was an art springing from sympathies which as yet 
 were immature, and, though attempted here and there, as in the spirited 
 little mosaic landscape (of uncertain date) among the Roman and Pompeian 
 pictures in the British Museum, nothing in antiquity approaches to land- 
 scape of nature and imagination worked into a high class of fine art, as 
 we know it in the various styles of Claude and Poussin, Both and Berg- 
 hem, Gainsborough and Turner. 
 
no THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 thoroughly Greek in the evident tradition of their art, 
 have their backgrounds composed with a studied sim- 
 plicity, as though to avoid all possible disturbance of 
 the interest concentrated in the actors of the scene. 
 Such is the case in that fine mosaic picture at Naples, 
 the choregium of the Casa del Poeta tragico, where 
 several groups of actors are seen rehearsing their parts, 
 to which the background is no more than a level colour 
 with two or three Ionic shafts against it, and festoons 
 of wreaths and ribands hanging from them. Such also 
 is the spirited scene of the Pompeian wall painting 
 representing the discovery of Achilles by Ulysses in 
 the palace of Lycomedes, where the figures occupy 
 almost the entire space, the rest being a portico of 
 simple architectural character of columns and wreaths 
 with the least possible relief. Thus many others have 
 no more than backgrounds of drapery or plain colour, 
 as is the case in the well-known panel of the Nozze 
 Aldebrandine, representing the marriage of Thetis and 
 Peleus, with attendant Muses and other figures, with 
 a plain wall behind them and a flat tint of blue 
 above it. 
 
 Thus, with these examples as a centre, if we look 
 back to the past and forward to our own age, from the 
 greatest works of antiquity, from the walls of Assyria 
 and yEgypt, to the traditions of Greek art in the days 
 of its perfection, the tombs of Etruria and the walls of 
 Pompeii, the great mosaics of the east and west, the 
 paintings of the early Christian times, and the frescoes 
 of their development, present to us a system and a 
 sense of art in one continuous stream of common 
 feeling as painting allied to architecture in harmony 
 and completeness. If I urge the consideration of this 
 more architectonic type of this great art, I do so only 
 where the conditions either recommend or demand it, 
 and with a view rather to enlarge its sphere than to 
 
v ARCHITECTURAL WALL PAINTING in 
 
 restrict it. The architectural character of a building 
 may demand from the painter some adaptation of style 
 to harmonise his art to that upon which he works, but 
 such need entail no return to palpable errors in techni- 
 cality nor to archaism of faulty drawing or bad com- 
 position. No rules or definitions, but only the feeling 
 and discretion of the artist can guide him in such treat- 
 ment. I am advocating a principle which involves no 
 return to the errors of the past, and certainly to no 
 abnegation of any superior knowledge of our own ; but 
 I certainly do advocate the practice of painting in a 
 wider sense of its powers than is commonly found 
 among us now. I look to it to harmonise itself to 
 whatever it may be associated with, and whatever be 
 its style. I look to that union of the arts rather as 
 their espousal than their vassalage. If in architectonic 
 painting the art were denied some of its common re- 
 sources, it would be but to draw out and elevate the 
 rest. Design need lose nothing of dramatic expression, 
 figures need lose nothing of their vigour or refinement. 
 Art would rather gain by its opportunities. Pictorial 
 effects and accessories are only too often the means of 
 escape from some crucial difficulty of composition. 
 But where these find no place, and all resource for 
 artistic indolence or cloak for inability is cut away, a 
 painter is put upon his mettle ; his design must be 
 more matured, his composition more studied, and his 
 whole art thus necessarily raised to a higher standard. 
 It would be no ill day for our arts if there were 
 anything thus pressing upon them to force them up- 
 wards. 
 
 But, to conclude, monumental art is, of all others, 
 the highest in its aim. Its condition of success is that 
 the resources of all the arts which compose it be 
 brought into unison. The success of former ages was 
 the result of that unison in which the whole chorus of 
 
ii2 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 the arts joined. It is the modern self-assertion of the 
 individual that renders success in monumental art well- 
 nigh impossible. Let each art be free as air, and revel 
 in its own powers when it is alone and uncontrolled^ but 
 then> and only then. In either case the painter's triumph 
 may be complete. Let him paint as the spirit moves 
 him, and, with all the freedom of independence, do all 
 that natural effect or picturesque incident may inspire. 
 But then, associate his art, in full swing of its liberty, 
 with the calmer dignity of architectural design, and the 
 result is this both mind and eye are offended, he has 
 made all light which the architect had purposely left 
 massive, bold, and broad ; he has placed the two arts 
 in direct antagonism ; he has stultified the architecture 
 and reversed every condition of its construction and 
 equilibrium, opening that which should be closed, 
 lightening that which should be heavy, and leaving 
 weighty masses of masonry without apparent support ; 
 he has turned cupolas into thin air, thick walls into 
 scenes of aerial perspective, and has left massive arches 
 to carry the clouds. 
 
 But the great works of other times have given us 
 the precedents and principles to attain results of success 
 similar to their own. Individual taste may nowadays 
 revel in vanity and self-assertion, but great artists of 
 the greatest days did otherwise. I am confident that 
 in conjunction with architecture all arts are raised at 
 once to their highest sphere. Architecture is the most 
 conventional of all arts, the creature of thought most 
 abstract and refined ; and with it others can find com- 
 panionship complete and sympathetic only in their 
 purest and noblest character, where all power is con- 
 centrated to symbolise and suggest rather than to 
 realise, to address imagination rather than to satisfy 
 curiosity. 
 
 The title of an architect is that of the " chief of 
 
ARCHITECTURAL WALL PAINTING 113 
 
 artists," and the consummation of his genius is in the 
 union of all arts for the perfection of that which is 
 especially his own ; for, as gold is among colours, so is 
 architecture among the arts ; it is the centre toward 
 which they are all attracted by mutual regard and 
 interest, and round which, as in natural relationship, 
 they group their various attributes ; with all their skill 
 and all their poetry making architecture itself com- 
 pletely beautiful, at once the home and the glory of 
 them all. 
 
ESSAY VI 
 
 MOSAIC 
 
 PART I ANCIENT 
 
 TT would be easier to imagine than to certify the 
 * origin of mosaic. Happy accident has been the 
 source of most of our arts and ingenuities, and to that 
 the origin of mosaic may be safely consigned. It was 
 a conviction rather than an invention. A dozen people 
 in the depths of antiquity may have hit upon it inde- 
 pendently and at the same time, and as many more 
 since who had never heard of them. In its rudest 
 form l pebbles set together before a doorstep was a 
 natural device for comfort, and suggested the orderly 
 arrangement of their sizes and colours into a pattern 
 as a natural device for pleasure ; and the next door 
 neighbours, pleased with the good sense of the whole 
 thing, adopted it ; and others, whose conviction as to 
 its use and pleasantness brought it into fashion, de- 
 veloped it into the character of a decorative art. 
 
 There is no art about the early history of which so 
 little is known as this : and it is not a little remarkable 
 
 1 Dr. Schliemann in his Troja, 1884, pp. 53, 54, writes thus : "We 
 found a house-floor of large white pebbles, which extended to the very wall 
 on the north side, and of which a large part may still be seen. This 
 singular house-floor must necessarily have belonged to one of the first 
 buildings of the second inhabitants here." This "second city" was 
 "Troy proper," "The Ilios of Homeric legend." Title, chap. iii. 
 
ESSAY vi ANCIENT MOSAIC 115 
 
 that, such being the case, there is none to the various 
 forms of which such a multitude of names have been 
 given. It would be useless to give a catalogue of 
 them here ; but it may be said that some appear to be 
 common-sense definitions, such as the Greek name 
 "lithostratos," 1 for a pavement, and "psephosis" for tessel- 
 lation generally, the Latin " opus tessellatum," etc. ; some 
 names are fanciful, such as the " opus vemiculatum," so 
 called from the lines of its tesserae undulating like the 
 coils of worms ; one is complimentary, viz. the " opus 
 Alexandrinum," said to have been so called from its 
 inventor the Emperor Alexander Severus. 2 Purple 
 and green marbles were imported from Alexandria, 
 and during that emperor's reign some ingenious 
 mosaicist appears to have hit upon a very effective 
 combination of them, which the emperor (" instituit ") 
 was pleased to " appoint " for use in his palace. 
 Hence its invention and its name might for flattery's 
 sake have been attributed to the emperor, as is affirmed, 
 but for every other sake to Alexandria, whence its 
 materials came. Some names for it are technical, such 
 as " opus figlinum," i.e. of the nature of pottery ; some 
 might be relegated to a comedy of errors like the 
 derivation of the word " musiva " or " musaeva " from the 
 name of the mythic poet Musaeus ; or the idea of the 
 learned commentator on Theophilus, who suggests that 
 "mosaic "comes from " mosque," because it is so commonly 
 found in that kind of building. 3 A mediaeval writer 
 
 1 This word is properly an adjective, the word "edaphos" being 
 understood, and forming the complete description of a ground or " floor 
 spread with stones." Psephosis mosaic- work, from psephos, a pebble or 
 tessera. 
 
 2 " Alexandrinum opus de duobus marmoribus, hoc est cle Porphyretico 
 et Lacedemonio, primus instituit : palacio exornato hoc genere marmor- 
 andi." Lampridius, Life of Alex. Sev. 
 
 "Alexandrina marmora Numidicis crustis distincta sunt ... in 
 picturse modum variata." Seneca, Epist. 86. 
 
 3 Hendrie, p. 37 of preface. 
 
ii6 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 disposes of the difficulty without hesitation by his 
 comprehensive description of it as " materia musica " ; l 
 but long before his time the same idea had struck the 
 Emperor Theophilus, who early in the ninth century 
 added to his palace at Constantinople, in which the 
 empress's apartment was so beautifully ornamented 
 with mosaic, that in consequence of the rhythm and 
 harmony of its colouring he called it the embodiment 
 of music (Mover ^09). Indeed the origin of the word 
 " mosaic " has been the subject of such speculation and 
 controversy as leaves one at the end in a vague con- 
 dition of mind between the ornamentation of museums 
 and the company of the Muses ; but be the origin of it 
 what it may, its heterogeneous application has turned 
 its confused etymology into worse confusion by dignify- 
 ing with its name any and every kind of inlaid materials, 
 from the grand pavement of the Battle of Issus to the 
 picture of the Madonna made of inlaid flowers by 
 Italians at a village festa. 2 
 
 Nor are the frequent references to its earliest use 
 much more satisfactory. It is vaguely stated that 
 " the Chinese practised it from high antiquity " a con- 
 tingency of considerable probability, but without a 
 single authority or illustration being offered of an art 
 apparently so well suited to a people of great ingenuity, 
 and simply taken for granted successively by one writer 
 from another. Ornamental inlaid porcelain must not 
 be confounded with mosaic ; and such was the only 
 approach to it known in China, as in the Tower of 
 
 1 Ciampini, vol. i. p. 78 "Nee desunt qui Musivum aut Mosivum a 
 Grseco verbo (JLovveiov, id est Musico Cantu deducant, " a derivation expres- 
 sive of the same idea. 
 
 2 Constantine Porphyrogenitus (905-959), describing the luxury and 
 extravagance of the Byzantine Court, mentions the habit of wearing 
 mosaics as ornaments of dress ; and he adds that ij/fauffis, the proper 
 word for tessellated work, did not suffice to express the minuteness of 
 those ornaments, so the words povcelov , (JLOVGOIOV, /xoixretci/ua, and 
 
 were invented for it. 
 
ANCIENT MOSAIC 1 1 7 
 
 Nankin. That " porcelain pagoda " has been thus des- 
 cribed as having " its outer face covered with slabs of 
 glazed porcelain of various colours, principally green, 
 red, yellow, and white : the body of the edifice is of 
 brick." l It is indeed impossible to quote any author 
 to the effect that mosaic was never practised by the 
 Chinese ; but the absence of any notice of it by the 
 closest observers of the arts, antiquities, trades, and 
 habits of that people, is at least negative evidence 
 against it. Among the lists given of Chinese arts and 
 manufactures mosaic is never mentioned. In the places 
 most likely for it, it is not referred to, such as in de- 
 scribing the Imperial Academy, a great public hall at 
 Pekin, which is known as " the court of gems," no 
 allusion is made to it ; nor in the famous apartment or 
 guest-room in the empress's palace known as "the 
 flowery wall " is any reference made to anything of 
 the nature of mosaic on its walls or floor. In Chinese 
 paintings and ornamental work no suggestion of mosaic 
 is afforded, except in that of carpenter-work, marquetry 
 of cabinets and boxes with pieces of mother-of-pearl 
 inlaid upon their carved surfaces. This kind of work 
 on a large scale is the special manufacture at Ningpo, 
 where furniture inlaid with light and dark woods is 
 produced, ornamented with a marquetry of figures, 
 animals, and conventional patterns, a Chinese edition 
 of the Italian intarsiatura of the sixteenth and the 
 French of the seventeenth centuries. Their ancient 
 enamels have often the effect of most refined mosaics, 
 but they belong to a totally different art. Beside these, 
 their inlaying on metal and other materials is a beautiful 
 art, in which precious stones of various colours, some- 
 times carved in projection, make part of the design ; 
 but it is not mosaic. In the Yuen-Ming-Yuen, or 
 summer palace of Pekin, there was no mosaic ; its 
 
 1 The Middle Kingdom, by S. Wells Williams, vol. i. p. 83. 
 
ii8 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 principal hall was " paved with slabs of gray marble 
 laid chequerwise." l " Tiles, glazed blue and green for 
 roofs of temples, and yellow for palaces, are made of 
 stoneware, but the common flooring tiles are burned 
 from brick clay." 2 Geometrical patterns, which of 
 themselves suggest a mosaic treatment, are the rarest 
 elements of Chinese ornament, which has all but 
 invariably curved or flowing outlines. The pattern 
 which has the least of this character is an occasional 
 band or border resembling the Greek fret. In the 
 numerous works illustrating Chinese art nothing of 
 mosaic is found beyond the subsidiary work of inlaid 
 wooden furniture. The floors of public edifices, ancient 
 or modern, are commonly laid with alternate squares 
 of contrasted marble, and in others of tiles, earth, 
 or cement. If wall or pavement mosaic exists in 
 China it is at least unknown to the rest of the world ; 
 and if it ever existed it must have been no more than 
 what an accidental variety is in the realm of botany, a 
 " sport " that did not repeat itself. From Marco Polo 
 in the thirteenth to the latest traveller in the nineteenth 
 century no reference is made to the subject, beyond the 
 trivial notice of a pleasant conceit observed a few years 
 ago on the gravel walks of a garden outside Canton, 
 described as "a pretty device ... in a rude kind of 
 shell-and-pebble mosaic in the gravelly paths, repre- 
 senting birds, animals, or other figures." In short, 
 mosaic, architectural or pictorial, appears to be " con- 
 spicuous by its absence " among the arts of the 
 Celestial Empire. 4 
 
 1 Sir John Davis, China, vol. i. p. 435. 
 
 2 S. Wells Williams, The Middle Kingdom^ vol. ii. p. I2O. 
 
 3 Ibid. p. 10. 
 
 4 The best books of reference are silent on the subject. Staunton's 
 Embassy, 2. vols., does not mention it, but says "the floors are of marble 
 or indurated earth," vol. ii. p. 370. The works of Barrow, Sir John 
 Davis, and Wells Williams do not mention it. The Jesuit fathers Riccino 
 and Trigault, A.D. 1616, and Ellis, who accompanied Macartney in his 
 
vi ANCIENT MOSAIC 119 
 
 A similar statement, and in the same vague manner, 
 has been made about Egypt : certainly with more 
 reason, but by no means- with satisfactory result. It 
 would be as possible for an ancient Egyptian as for 
 any one else to have arranged an ornament mosaically, 
 and no doubt he did so, as the wild Indians of North 
 America did, and as the Mexicans do admirably with 
 inlaid feathers to the present day. The inlaying of 
 regularly- formed tiles in an ornamental pavement or 
 against a wall should not, however, be classed with 
 mosaic, if there is to be any orderly comprehension of 
 the word. Of such kind is the earliest known applied 
 architectural ornament in Egypt round a doorway of the 
 Pyramid of Saccara, where small tiles of two colours 
 placed alternately are set against the wall, and form an 
 effective ornament to the entrance. This has been mis- 
 takenly described as a mosaic. Nor can the arrange- 
 ment of glass beads woven together on threads into flat 
 tablets of ornamental pattern on the pectoral plates of 
 mummies, often mingled with figures in porcelain and 
 both in real and imitative jewelry, 1 be rightly classed as 
 mosaics, though writers have carelessly called them so. 
 The frequent covering of a surface with little squares 
 of inlaid materials has also often led to mis-statements 
 about Egyptian mosaic. These inlays are found on 
 furniture and boxes of which the sides are ornamented 
 with alternate squares of dark and light blue glass or 
 of ivory white and stained, cut out of sheets of about 
 one-eighth of an inch thick, and cemented upon the 
 wooden surface, looking like the tessellation of mosaic, 
 but being no more than a coarse kind of geometrical 
 incrustation, tarsiatura, or marquetry. 2 There is 
 
 Progress Overland to Pekin in 1816, are silent about it, and such is the 
 case with others foreign and English. 
 
 1 As in the Egyptian Museum at Turin. 
 
 2 Specimens are in the Egyptian Collection of the British Museum, 
 No. 5897, and others near. 
 
120 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 among the Egyptian antiquities of the British Museum 
 a curious little head-dress 1 of a figure found at Thebes, 
 the surface of which is covered with little beads set 
 longways and edgeways into a plaster ground to pro- 
 duce the effect of the edges of small curls, and round it 
 is a band or fillet richly set with imitation jasper and 
 gold, with a mosaic appearance, but, like the surface of 
 the boxes mentioned above, being no more than an 
 incrustation of small pieces of glass about one-third of 
 an inch square and one -sixteenth thick. This little 
 head-dress has been quoted as a mosaic. It is simply 
 a unique and ingenious imitation of hair by the edges 
 of small beads. 
 
 There is a form of Egyptian ornament that is pro- 
 duced precisely as the English Tunbridge ware is made, 
 viz. by laying together long sticks of glass of various 
 colours so arranged that, when cut across, the ends 
 present the appearance of a minute tessellated mosaic 
 with some definite design, such as a head or bird, or 
 the many-coloured feathers of the winged orb or sacred 
 hawk. These glass rods are fused together into a 
 block, and being made elastic by heat, are drawn out 
 to any length, the arrangement of the pattern being 
 unchanged, and when thus reduced to the size of 
 threads, and cut across, the extreme minuteness of the 
 ornament would surprise a person unaware of the 
 ingenious and simple way of producing it. If Tun- 
 bridge ware is rightly called mosaic, then this Egyptian 
 glassware and its little curiosities of ingenuity may be 
 so too. 
 
 The inlaying of pieces of coloured paste, glass and 
 pottery is met with in places and belonging to periods 
 that are independent of any relative influence. In the 
 comparatively modern Frankish and Anglo - Saxon 
 burial-places of the sixth and seventh centuries A.D. 
 1 No. 2280. 
 
vi ANCIENT MOSAIC 121 
 
 in England, France, and Germany, ornaments of great 
 variety have been found, having an appearance as much 
 like mosaic as these Egyptian inlays, or of cloisonne 
 enamels, but composed of thin pieces of coloured glass, 
 and occasionally of coloured pastes and enamels set 
 like jewels within thin fillets of metal ; but these 
 are not mosaics ; and precisely in the same manner 
 we find that in the distant ages of Egyptian art, 
 jewelry and ornaments of costume were inlaid with 
 little flat pieces of precious stone, fitted with exquisite 
 nicety into forms of a design which are marked by 
 their fillets of gold, similar to those of cloisonnes 
 enamels. In this manner also, ivory tablets were 
 ornamented with inlaid lapis lazuli in the form of 
 feathers on the wings of the Bull of Nineveh and of the 
 winged orb of Egypt This system of partial inlay was 
 most effectively used by Egyptian artists of the four- 
 teenth and fifteenth centuries B.C. in ornamental designs 
 made sometimes in relief upon tablets of baked clay 
 or cement, on which the principal subject or figure, 
 admirably modelled and clothed with elaborate draperies, 
 had been painted with enamel colours, having the parts 
 selected for special ornament hollowed out and inlaid 
 with small strips or borders variously coloured j 1 but, 
 again, these are not mosaics. 
 
 These inlaid tablets of cement or tile, with their 
 crisp designs and multiplicity of refined detail, afford 
 surprising evidence of the completeness at which the 
 arts had arrived at that age. There is nothing experi- 
 mental about them, but all their composition and orna- 
 ment is effected with an artistic selection and con- 
 fidence which only that maturity could have produced 
 which implies centuries of previous civilisation. 
 
 The patterns painted on mummy cases are often 
 
 1 Vide especially some tablets of the time of Rameses III., Egyptian 
 Room Brit. Mus., No. 12321, and others about it, from 133010 1400 B.C. 
 
122 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 so like mosaics as to appear like copies of real mosaics 
 elsewhere, but no such originals are known or recorded. 
 The only employment of anything like tesserae as the 
 nearest approach to a real Egyptian mosaic was in the 
 chequer ornament often found on tiles and plaques. 
 These chequers are usually of two colours, and are 
 constructed not with tesserae of these colours, but by 
 colouring the surface of the tablets one colour, and 
 hollowing out the alternate squares and filling them up 
 with little cubes or tesserae of the other colour. 
 
 A few years ago a tomb was discovered near the 
 Pyramid of Meydoun, dating from the second or third 
 dynasty (about B.C. 2400), on the side of which the 
 stone was overlaid with a coating of a strong red 
 cement, and upon it lines had been incised and filled 
 with a white material to accentuate the features of the 
 design. The principal subjects were the portraits of a 
 man and woman seated side by side, and of somewhat 
 less than natural size. They are described as drawn 
 with much dignity, and that the effect of their eyes 
 was very brilliant, " being inlaid with ivory, crystal, 
 and dark ore" (much as the eyes among coloured 
 hieroglyphic forms are habitually inlaid), and the whole 
 picture was painted over black, red, and yellow, on a 
 ground of white. A great authority has called this a 
 mosaic; 1 if it be one, we must accept Egyptian mosaics 
 as a genus absolutely apart. 
 
 The piecing and inlaying things and colours is so 
 simple and natural a system of ornament that it is 
 found everywhere and of all ages from Joseph's coat to 
 a modern chess - board ; and ornamental materials, 
 mosaically arranged, are as common in Egypt as else- 
 where ; but any unquestionable mosaic, beyond the 
 character of set jewelry or of inlaid ornamental acces- 
 
 1 History of Ancient Egypt. By Brugsch-Bey. First edition, vol. i. 
 p. 66. 
 
vi ANCIENT MOSAIC 123 
 
 series of an altogether secondary character, is not 
 known in Egypt, unless the little gems of glass Tun- 
 bridge ware be accepted as such. No monumental 
 mosaic, as an art of national origin, whether tessellated 
 like the pavements and pictures of Pompeii, or sectile 
 like the walls and works of Florence, is to be found 
 there. 
 
 An inscription on the wall of a tomb in the hill of 
 Abt-el-Qurnah gives an account of the offerings made 
 by Thutmes III. (about B.C. 1600) to the temple of the 
 god Amon, and among them it describes " a beautiful 
 harp inlaid with silver and gold, and blue, green, and 
 other precious stones." 
 
 Thus in various forms of ornamental work their 
 colours were arranged much as a mosaicist would have 
 arranged them ; and this and the decorative inlay and 
 combination of materials in the semi-mosaic methods 
 I have described, appear to have been their nearest 
 approach to complete mosaic. The true mosaics in 
 Egypt were first Greek then Roman in design and 
 workmanship, and lastly Byzantine and Arab. 
 
 If the Greeks were in truth the earliest pre-eminent 
 in this art, whence did they get the elements of it ? 
 They were a people of quick artistic perception, apt to 
 seize upon an incomplete idea, no matter where or 
 whence, and to turn it into a thing of beauty. All 
 other of their arts were matured from initial forms 
 created elsewhere. Were mosaics among them ? Greece 
 had all the elements of pictorial mosaic in use in the 
 middle of the fifth century B.C., but the commerce of 
 other nations had enriched it long before that time, 
 and had brought to its shores mostly through inter- 
 mediary Phoenicia, the convenient centre in that age 
 for the reception and dispersal of all art influences 
 the suggestive models of Oriental and Southern arts. 
 The inlaid ornaments of Assyrian and Egyptian work- 
 
124 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 manship had thus been known to it, but the fashion of 
 adorning exteriors with inlaid coloured marbles appears 
 in Greece itself at a very distant age. The tomb of 
 Atreus, which was of the twelfth century B.C., is de- 
 scribed by its latest explorer 1 as having originally pre- 
 sented a rich effect of colour as well as of ornamental 
 carving. He writes of it thus : " The front surface, 
 built of polished brescia blocks, was once coated in its 
 upper part with slabs of red, green, and white marbles 
 . . . the outer frame (of the facade) was formed of two 
 slender embedded pillars of dark gray alabaster, the 
 shafts of which were richly ornamented with sharp zig- 
 zags, spirals, etc. . . ." Nineveh could have taught it 
 no better, for although many Assyrian ornaments had 
 a mosaic character, and their architecture was adorned 
 and inlaid or coated with figures, and numerous 
 natural forms enamelled upon bricks, such work was 
 not mosaic, nor had it any pictures in mosaic tessella- 
 tion to give its first lesson to Greece. Nor could 
 Persia do more, for it had derived the first models of 
 its ornamental arts directly or indirectly from Assyria, 
 Chaldaea, and Egypt. The only architectural mosaic 
 of Persia, if indeed it may be dignified with the name, 
 was of the most elementary kind, formed with bricks of 
 two colours, gray and red, laid in patterns, of which, 
 after all, the principal effect was obtained by their 
 arrangement in projection or recess, producing those 
 patterns in relief by light and shadow, as they are seen 
 on the facades of the rock-cut tombs of the valley of 
 
 1 Dr. H. Schliemann's Tiryns. 1886. Preface, pp. 39, 40. This em- 
 ployment of inlaid variously coloured marbles in architectural ornament 
 had been recorded long before Dr. Schliemann by English travellers. In 
 DodwelFs Classical Tour, vol. ii. p. 239, is an account of this monument : 
 "The relief of the two lions which closes the triangular space over the 
 gate of lions at Mycsenge consists of greenish marble, like the green basalt 
 of ^Egypt." "Fragments of decoration on both sides of the entrance of 
 the Treasury of Atreus are of green, red, and white stone," etc. etc. 
 Donaldson's supplement to Stuart's Athens, and Dodwell as above. 
 
vi ANCIENT MOSAIC 125 
 
 Doganlu and the neighbourhood of Persepolis. The 
 inlaid marble floors of Ahasuerus (Xerxes) at " Shu- 
 shan, the palace" (Susa), about B.C. 480, were certainly 
 of sectile mosaic character, possibly of such designs as 
 the sculptured floors of Assyria had suggested, and 
 such as the pieces of coloured marbles found near 
 Babylon justify us in believing. Such a fashion would 
 have been known to other nations for centuries, but 
 they afford no precedent for pictorial tessellation, nor 
 did any other part of Persian architecture, of which the 
 polychromatic ornament consisted in coloured materials 
 used broadly, as by enamelled bricks and constructional ^_ 
 and inlaid marbles. 
 
 But at a time many centuries before all these, a 
 complete mosaic applied to architectural ornament had 
 been perfected in Chaldsea. On the site of the ancient 
 Erech, 1 in the province of Babylon, now known as 
 Warkah, was discovered a few years ago, among its 
 most ancient remains, a building ornamented with 
 tessellated mosaic, covering with various contrasted 
 patterns the forms of its original architecture. The 
 style of this architecture is rudely simple, consisting of 
 alternate plain surfaces and groups of seven semi- 
 columns, suggesting an original construction of wood, 
 in which these large shafts or stems would have been 
 the poles of straight timber (palm-tree ?) set close to- 
 gether of equal lengths without base or capital. These 
 forms, subsequently followed in the earliest brick archi- 
 tecture of Babylon, are found at the great necropolis of 
 Warkah. The mosaic is formed of tesserae (or, as 
 from their shape, they are called "cones") of terra- 
 cotta, some left with their natural yellow colour, some 
 coloured red and black, and so shaped as to suit the 
 inlaying of the rounded surfaces of those half-columns, 
 by being tapered at one end like pegs. The wall, of 
 
 1 Babel and Erech, and Accad and Calneh. Genesis x. 10. 
 
126 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 which about thirty feet remained, and the mosaic are 
 thus described by their discoverer. 
 
 " The cones, embedded in a cement of mud with 
 chopped straw, were fixed horizontally with their 
 circular bases facing outwards ; some had been dipped 
 in red and black colour, and were arranged in various 
 ornamental patterns (of three colours] such as diamonds, 
 triangles, zigzags, and stripes. . . . The wall had a flat 
 surface of 14. feet long (covered with a diamond pattern 
 mosaic] projecting I foot 9 beyond a series of half 
 columns on each side of it, ornamented with spirals, 
 zigzags, and lozenges"^ The site was evidently that of 
 a vast burial-place, and " from its position, scarcely 
 above the level of the desert, I regard it as one of the 
 earliest relics discovered at Warkah." 2 
 
 Elsewhere in Babylonia the ruins of similar mosaics 
 are found. 3 But beside these aboriginal tessellated 
 
 1 W. K. Loftus's Travels and Researches in Chaldcea, etc., 1857. 
 
 2 "Warkah, its ruins and remains," published separately from the 
 Transactions of the Royal Society of Literature, March 1856, p. 23. W. 
 Kennet Loftus. 
 
 With respect to the date of this mosaic no exactness can be ascertained, 
 but close by it is a building of precisely the same character, of which the 
 sun-dried bricks "bear the impression of a cuneiform inscription, and are 
 cemented with bitumen, recording . . . the dedication of the building to 
 the Moon by King Urukh about 2234 B.C." The wall of this building 
 is so curious that its description may interest the reader. "The most 
 striking feature of the front settles, I think, the moot question whether 
 the Babylonians employed the column as an architectural embellish- 
 ment Seven times on the lower portion of the building is the same 
 sacred number of half columns repeated, the rudest perhaps that were 
 ever reared, but built moulded with semicircular bricks. . . . The 
 entire absence of cornice, capital, base, or diminution of shaft, as charac- 
 teristic of other columnar architecture, and their peculiar and original 
 disposition in rows like palm-logs, suggest the type from which they sprang. 
 There is not a line in the face to which foreign influence can be traced." 
 Other peg-shaped but much larger cones were found lying about in great 
 numbers, but these were sepulchral memorials with cuneiform inscriptions 
 all over them, referring even to still earlier dates. In the British Museum 
 (Chaldaean collection) is a cylinder of green jasper inscribed with the name 
 of Hashamar, a viceroy under Ur-Id or Amil-ea, "the man of the River 
 God, King of Erech" Warkah: about 2300 B.C. 
 
 3 At Mugeyer were found "many pieces of polished marble perforated 
 
vi ANCIENT MOSAIC 127 
 
 mosaic, the same country affords the evidence of 
 mosaic of sectile marble suggesting some idea of that 
 in the Palace of Shushan ; whether for floors or dadoes 
 cannot be said, but the recurrence of marble knobs 
 among the flat pieces suggests ornamentation more 
 suited to walls than floors. Their discoverer thus 
 describes them as " numerous pieces of marble, alabaster, 
 and agate, of all shapes heart-shaped, oval, circular, 
 square, and some like a ball. They are found all over 
 the mounds in the Jezireh and Iraq, particularly at 
 Maujur." He then refers to the vast quantity of mosaic 
 cones found in the same place, and to Mr. Loftus's 
 description of them at Warkah, and adds " with regard 
 to those pieces of sectile marbles, from the number of 
 fragments discovered at various places, it seems to have 
 been one of the most usual decorations employed in 
 Lower Babylonia." 1 
 
 Here then we seem to find ourselves among the 
 very originals of all mosaic. Certainly in no other 
 country has anything of the kind been found at such a 
 date. It is complete tessellation, only with round 
 instead of angular tesserae. The Chaldaeans had to 
 decorate their coarse and only building materials, 
 brickwork ; so with these forms of mosaic and marbles, 
 and with sheets of precious metals and painting they 
 
 at the back, fragments of plain cones and cylinders, curious-shaped tiles, 
 and small bricks about \ an inch thick and 6 inches long, floors of beaten 
 clay or sand, walls covered with fine plaster rudely painted, on one was 
 the figure of a man holding a bird in his hand, and a smaller figure near 
 him in red paint. . . . (p. 411). The mounds were literally covered with 
 conical pieces (mosaic cones) of baked clay, about \ to j inch diameter 
 . . . and in nearly all the trenches were found marble and limestone cones 
 4 to 10 inches long ; some had their edges painted black, some with a rim 
 round the edge filled with copper, from I to 3 inches diameter at the base 
 (tapering to a point)." T. E. Taylor. Journal of the Royal Asiatic 
 Society, vol. iv. p. 410. 
 
 1 Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society , vol. iv., 1855, "Ruins of 
 Mugeyer," pp. 260 and 410, and vol. xv., 1855, PP- 2 68, 2 74> 4 II '4 I 5- 
 T. E. Taylor. 
 
128 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 covered their walls. Commerce, much wider and more 
 active than commonly supposed, carried with it the 
 traditions of the style and fashions of the arts. Caravan 
 roads were common both inland and to the sea-coast, 
 and thence to the western world the character of 
 Chaldaean art was spread far and wide. Assyria and 
 the east, that is to say Persia, were educated by it ; 
 and from the Syrian coast it can hardly have failed to 
 reach Greece. But as far as mosaics are concerned, 
 those of Babylonia were decorative, not pictorial ; they 
 possessed, however, the true principle of decorative 
 tessellation. 1 Anything of such early date approaching 
 pictorial representation, by arrangement of self-coloured 
 materials, is not found, except in the minute glass gems 
 of Egypt, made for rings and brooches, on which are 
 set, as already described, microscopic figures, such as 
 heads, birds, and hieroglyphs. These may have sug- 
 gested to artistic Greek eyes the conversion of the 
 Chaldsean architectural tessellation to pictorial effect ; 
 but all such explanation, though most probable, can 
 only be speculative. Egypt had nothing like Greek 
 mosaic, and Greece had nothing like the diaper patterns 
 of Babylonian mosaic ; but the ideas are fusible, and 
 directly or indirectly from those aboriginal arts, the art 
 of Greece must have derived its birth. 
 
 But on the soil of Greece itself, at Tiryns, have 
 been found pavements of very early date suggestive of 
 coloured mosaic floors. 2 In works of ornamental art, 
 Tiryns, itself of Phrygian origin, traded with Phoenicia 
 and Egypt. The floors found there, and of a date not 
 less than 1000 B.C., are of clay, with a thickness of 
 lime concrete above them, into which, in situations at 
 all exposed to wear or weather, pebbles were set, and 
 
 1 Of various degrees of coarseness and fineness the cone tesserse have 
 been found varying from above an inch to a quarter of an inch diameter. 
 
 2 Tiryns, by Dr. H. Schliemann, pp. 275, 276. London, 1886. 
 
vi ANCIENT MOSAIC 129 
 
 Dr. Schliemann, describing them, writes that " in the 
 great men's court and in the great Propyleum,in the latter 
 the pebbles were so prominent that we may describe 
 the floor as a mosaic of pebbles. In the rooms these 
 pebbles are generally absent, and accordingly they have 
 a smoother floor ; but, instead, the mortar is made into 
 a carpet-pattern of scratched lines . . . remains of red 
 and blue colour found in several rooms show that the 
 floor was also painted ; in one place we could still per- 
 ceive the colouring of the floor with red geometrical 
 ornaments of circular and waving lines." If two and 
 two may be put together, we have here not indeed the 
 complete fact, but a very plain suggestion of a coloured 
 mosaic tessellation, sufficient for the eye of a quick 
 artist to adopt, and about which the last words read 
 like a description of many mosaics that we know well. 
 
 From the walls of Babylonia and the floors of 
 Tiryns there is a long interval before we come to the 
 earliest known pictorial mosaics. They were in Greece, 
 at Delphi and Olympia. The earliest reference in 
 literature to what appears to have been a pictorial 
 mosaic, is found in a scholium upon a passage in 
 Lucian, who, writing about miscellaneous subjects, refers, 
 in passing, to the story of Jupiter determining the 
 centre of his earthly dominions by the flight of two 
 eagles, eastward and westward, that, having made the 
 circuit of the earth, its centre would be ascertained by 
 the spot on which they met. This spot was marked 
 by a large stone, which from that story was called the 
 Omphalos or navel of the earth, over which the Temple 
 of Delphi was built. Lucian refers so incidentally to 
 the legend that the scholiast, to enlighten his readers, 
 comments on the passage thus : ". . . the centre of 
 the earth. . . . They say that in Delphi there is an 
 omphalos upon the pavement in the temple, and 
 about it an eagle is represented (or painted, 
 
 K 
 
130 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 ' by setting together of stones! an d this place is said to 
 be the centre of the (whole) earth." Lucian merely 
 refers to the story, his scholiast refers to a local work 
 of art illustrative of it, as an anecdote explanatory of 
 the text, such as a well-informed writer of the time 
 would afford from his own acquaintance with artistic 
 or archaeological subjects. His words clearly refer to 
 a mosaic ; and the probability of such an ornament 
 being found there is corroborated by the discovery of 
 one at Olympia, similar in character of construction, of 
 a date slightly subsequent to what might with prob- 
 ability be assigned to this at Delphi. 1 
 
 The mosaic at Olympia was discovered by the 
 members of the French Scientific Expedition, in the 
 Pronaos of the Temple of Jupiter. It is " still in situ, 
 and probably the earliest extant specimen of Greek 
 mosaic." 2 The description of it in the Report of the 
 French Expedition in the Morea, states : " This mosaic 
 is evidently of the same date as the building of 
 the Temple ; it is executed in pebbles from the river 
 
 1 The passage in Lucian occurs in the line 70, p. 251, vol. ii., edit. 
 Amsterdam, 1743. " De Saltatione." " Kal TO nt<rov TT}S 7775 evpivKo^evov 
 TTTTJffei, T&V dercoj'." The words of the scholium are " Ae7oi'<r' e^ AeX0ots 
 8fj.<pa\ov eiVcu e?rt roO 8d(j)ovs rov vew, /ecu Trepl avrbv aUrbv yeypd(f>6ai airb 
 o~vvd<r(i6S \id<j)v KO.I roOro e0acr/cw TO ^o~ov cnrdo"r)S TTJS 7175." The existence 
 of this "navel" of the earth (an aerolith? "the stone which fell down 
 from Jupiter ") is referred to by Strabo and Pausanias. The former, thus : 
 " deiKvvrai d /ccd 6/A0aX6s ris ev ry va<^ TenutHOpfros Kal e?r' avrw at duo eiKoves 
 rov [j,v6ov." "There is exhibited too in the temple a certain omphalos, 
 and upon it the two figures of the story." He thus adds to the illustration 
 given by Lucian's scholiast, who describes not the omphalos but the orna- 
 mental work of a "painting made by the composition of stones" on "the 
 pavement around it, the figure of an eagle being its principal subject, 
 which in no way interferes with Strabo's reference to the great stone alone 
 with " two figures of the story " upon it. Pausanias's notice of it leads to 
 the same conclusion, but he specifies the omphalos as of white marble. 
 " Pausanias describes in the Temple of Apollo itself two old stones, one 
 apparently an aerolith which were treated with great respect." Mahaffy, 
 Rambles and Studies in Greece, p. 22O. 
 
 2 C. T. Newton's Collected Essays on Art and Archaeology, p. 342. 
 1880. 
 
vi ANCIENT MOSAIC \y. 
 
 Alphseus. The design is oblong, of two nearly square 
 compartments, enclosed within a broad border of double 
 interlacing fret, and in the centre of each is a figure, 
 one of a Triton, the other of a Syren, surrounded by a 
 graceful border of Greek honeysuckle." 1 
 
 The Triton is drawn with great spirit, with one 
 hand holding to his mouth a spiral shell horn, brand- 
 ishing an oar with the other, and carrying a child on 
 the coils of his tail. The colours are very distinct, the 
 hair being chestnut, the bodies pale flesh tint, and other 
 parts varied with black, white, red, and yellow, the 
 figure of the Syren being similarly coloured. It was 
 found under a pavement of fine marbles, with another 
 mosaic near it, but of less ancient date. Mosaic appears 
 to have been confined to the subsidiary parts of great 
 Greek temples. The pavement of the central nave at 
 Olympia, as that of the Parthenon, was of white marble ; 
 the side aisles had been floored with stucco at a level 
 slightly above the central floor, and round the space 
 where the throne of Pheidias's great chryselephantine 
 Jupiter had been placed, the pavement of black marble 2 
 was found in situ. 
 
 Such were Greek mosaics about the middle of the 
 fifth century B.C., but they afford no clue to their own 
 history, or to the art out of which they grew. Here 
 then are specimens of a developed art, suggesting 
 the same difficulty as that of the well-known example 
 of the work of Sosus (about B.C. 220), described by 
 Pliny, as so complete a picture of the things appar- 
 ently littered upon the floor of a room, as to have 
 seemed realities. In the centre was the famous design 
 of the so-called Pliny's doves, 3 similar to that in 
 
 1 Expedition Scientifique en Morec. A. Blouet. Paris, 1831. 
 
 2 Ibid. 
 
 3 Commonly called so from his description of them, "Mirabilis ibi 
 columba bibens, et aquam umbra capitis infuscans. Apricantur alise 
 scabentes sese in canthari labro." H. N. xxxvi. 60. 
 
132 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 the Capitol at Rome, which is not altogether rejected 
 by competent archaeologists from being the actual work 
 of Sosus, the point of objection being that some of 
 the small tesserae are of glass, and it being asserted by 
 others that glass was not used in mosaics till the time 
 of the empire, a criticism to which I venture to reply 
 that it would be true at Rome, but that, if this be the 
 original, it is a Greek mosaic, and at the places whence 
 Greece mainly drew the use of glass, that material was 
 used for many ornamental purposes, and notably for 
 that of the imitation of precious marbles and jewels, 
 which (as in that of the Battle of Issus) were used pro- 
 fusely in Greek mosaic. The mosaic of Pliny's doves 
 is composed of marbles, jewels, and a few glass imita- 
 tions of them. Still, the originality of this work can 
 only be conjectural, especially as another of the same 
 subject was found at Naples in 1833, and equal in 
 execution to that at Rome. 1 
 
 The use of ornamental floors (subsequently known 
 at Rome as "pavimenta sculpturata") may have been 
 common long before that date, as in Assyria, and the 
 colouring of them would have been a natural develop- 
 ment as at Tiryns. It is to about B.C. 480 that the 
 common reference is made for the earliest known 
 description of a (possible) mosaic, viz. that of the floor 
 in the palace of Ahasuerus, mentioned in the book of 
 Esther, as " a pavement of red and blue and white 
 and black marble ;" but whether this were a merely 
 geometrical pavement, or one of sectile pieces of 
 ornamental forms, we have no means of knowing. 
 Some inference as to the character of its design may 
 however be drawn from a fine piece of ornamental 
 floor 2 from the North Palace of Sardanapalus at 
 
 1 The fineness of the work of the doves of the Capitol may be under- 
 stood from there being an average of 160 tesserse to the superficial inch. 
 
 2 Now in the Assyrian collection, British Museum. 
 
vi ANCIENT MOSAIC 133 
 
 Koujunjik, of above a century earlier, richly carved in 
 a single block (measuring about 1 3 feet 6 inches by 
 9 feet), for the arts of Persia were as much indebted to 
 Assyrian traditions as Assyria itself was to Chaldaea. 
 The design is that of a diaper of conventional flowers 
 fitting each other in squares, and enclosed by a broad 
 border of lotus buds and flowers, suggesting a still 
 earlier derivation from the painted and sculptured 
 designs of Egypt It is a grand specimen of the 
 " pavimentum sculpturatum" of the seventh century 
 B.C., and of a design admirably suitable for a mosaic, 
 whether tessellated or sectile. 
 
 The actual locality to which the origin of the art 
 of picture in mosaic can be assigned, is therefore still 
 obscure. Varieties of it may have existed for centuries 
 before Greece was a nation, but to the graceful imagi- 
 nation of the Hellenes 1 may probably have been rightly 
 assigned the application of it to pictorial representation, 
 such as the examples already mentioned sufficiently show, 
 at least as early as the middle of the fifth century B.C. 
 
 Only a few names of Greek mosaicists have been 
 preserved, among the best known of which are Parnesos, 
 an artist of Elis, and Sosus of Pergamus, the artist of 
 Pliny's doves, and of the pavement of the " unswept 
 floor," only known by Pliny's description. One of the 
 finest of the Pompeian mosaics, constructed of tesserae 
 of vitreous enamel, 2 is also signed by its artist in Greek 
 " Dioscorides the Samian did this." The subject of it 
 is a group of three musicians practising, of which the 
 central figure wears a female mask, and is playing the 
 castinets, bending forward as if marking the time of 
 the man, who in an attitude of gay complacency holds 
 up his tambourine to his ear. The third is a woman 
 
 1 " Pavimenta originem apud Gnecos habent elaborata arte picturae 
 ratione." Pliny, N. H. xxxvi. 6. 
 
 2 Vide R. Museo Borbonico, V. iv. tav. 34. 
 
134 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 standing behind them playing the double pipe, and a 
 boy near her watches intently ail that is going on. The 
 excellent pose of the figures and draperies, and the 
 delicious combination of comedy and gravity in the 
 whole group is so admirable as to suggest its derivation 
 from some fine original of which Dioscorides has been 
 the ingenious copyist. 
 
 The absence of any notice of mosaics among the 
 works of art in Greece at the time of Pausanias must not 
 be taken as any reason for supposing their non-existence. 
 He was more scholar than artist, and more interested 
 in the search for historical works than in any independ- 
 ent notice of others by himself. The demand for 
 works of Greek art was no less an archaeological than 
 an artistic craze among the dilettanti of the empire, 
 and all available works were taken to Rome without 
 consideration of cost or injury. Had mosaics existed 
 in the form of pictures upon walls, they would indubit- 
 ably have been among the choice things removed ; but 
 as pavements they may easily have disappeared by 
 spoliation, as invaluable quarries for Roman mosaicists, 
 just as Roman works themselves became subsequently 
 the stores of tesserae and coloured glass for Christian 
 artists of the middle ages. Some of these at Pompeii 
 were wall pictures, as that one by Dioscorides, but the 
 finest of all, that of the Battle of Issus, is a pavement. 
 If such as this were commonly so, as there is reason to 
 believe, the Greeks, no less than the luxurious Romans, 
 were indeed reckless in their use of valuable materials, 
 among which not only tesserae of rare marbles, but of 
 precious jewels also were introduced. Whence their 
 designs were derived is not and probably never will be 
 known, but their reference to great originals is on all 
 grounds a fair presumption. The style is Greek, and, 
 when signed, they are so with Greek names ; it is 
 therefore fair to conclude, that whether imported from 
 
vi ANCIENT MOSAIC 135 
 
 Greece, or made on the spot in Italy, they represent 
 the Greek method, and the choice and use of materials 
 such as were received traditionally from Greek mosaicists 
 of long past time. 
 
 The subject of the most famous Pompeian mosaic 
 is that of the Battle of Issus, in which the prominent 
 figure appears to be Alexander the Great, in the thick 
 of the fight, having just speared his foe, whose horse 
 has fallen in the attempt to fly. The tide of the battle 
 has at that moment turned, and victory gained. The 
 direction of the groups, the attitudes of the figures, 
 confirm that idea, and the whole composition has been 
 most artfully conceived, representing by comparatively 
 few figures the rout of a great army. All is confusion, 
 but without the smallest confusion in the arrangement 
 of the picture. The artist has all his feeling and ex- 
 pression well in hand ; and by a more masterly scheme 
 never was the crisis of a battle more admirably exhibited 
 than in this fragment of a half- ruined mosaic. The 
 rich owner of the House of the Fawn used it as a 
 pavement ; and it is not known whether the Greeks 
 ever used mosaic for other purposes, but if not, their 
 rule was certainly this, that where art was to be per- 
 fected, cost and materials were beyond consideration. 
 
 The earliest mosaic in Italy, of which an account has 
 been preserved, is that which, on Pliny's authority, was 
 made for Sylla and placed in the Temple of Fortune 
 at Preneste (Palestrina). There is, however, the utmost 
 uncertainty as to what this was. Several mosaics have 
 been found there, and fragments of them are now in 
 the Hall of the Animals in the Vatican Museum, one 
 of which is a fine arabesque in black and white marble 
 tesserse, having for its central subject an eagle killing 
 a hare ; but the great one specially known as the 
 Palestrina mosaic, somewhat over 18 feet long by 14 
 broad, and plainly the work of Greek artists, from the 
 
136 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 numerous Greek words inlaid in it, bears such evidence 
 upon itself as to its date and motive as to put it out of 
 all association with the goddess of Fortune or with 
 Sylla. The scene is evidently upon the Nile, and the 
 period it represents is that of the Empire. The 
 costumes, the armour, the galley with many oars, and 
 the general character of the art would be Roman of 
 that period. It is an archaeological curiosity, but 
 beyond that, a peculiar interest in this large work is 
 the suggestion it affords of the way in which great wall 
 paintings were arranged by the Greeks. Here is a 
 complex representation of numerous incidents, each 
 one forming a group complete in itself, and isolated 
 from the rest, though forming together the picture of 
 one descriptive history. This pavement, if placed 
 against a wall, would have the upper part occupied by 
 bare sandy hills with groups of negroes in various 
 places, and wild beasts prowling near the banks of the 
 river. The intermediate country, occupying that part 
 which in a modern picture would be the middle dis- 
 tance, is broken up into spaces of open water, rocks, 
 and islands, with figures of wild beasts, birds, and 
 fishes, boats and fishermen, tents and houses, scattered 
 about till it approaches the lowest part or foreground, 
 where numerous buildings and groups of persons 
 engaged in peaceful pursuits, sitting on the banks 
 under awnings of trellis - work, with flowers of the 
 lotus budding and blooming above the water, illustrate 
 a scene of peaceful civilisation. In the corner towards 
 the right hand is an architectural portico, beneath 
 which and under an ample awning a figure, that can 
 be none other than a Roman emperor, is depicted, 
 attended by a group of soldiers, and in an attitude of 
 address toward a female figure standing on the opposite 
 bank, in a doorway with the Roman eagle above it. 
 Thus this varied composition appears to suggest 
 
ANCIENT MOSAIC 137 
 
 the mode of pictorial composition, by which " the whole 
 story of the Iliad " was represented in mosaic in the 
 apartments of the great yacht which Archimedes 
 designed for Hiero of Syracuse (in the third century B.C.), 
 a continuous composition of numerous subjects, and 
 following, as might reasonably be supposed in a country 
 specially under Greek influence, the traditional treat- 
 ment of complex historical wall painting. This Pales- 
 trina mosaic, taken as an upright picture, appears to 
 fulfil, though roughly, the artistic conditions that char- 
 acterised those classic paintings. It treats each group 
 as a complete composition ; the landscape of the upper 
 part which represents distant objects, far up the wind- 
 ings of the Nile, is represented on the same scale on 
 the same plane, and in the same tones of colour as the 
 groups and scenery below, its many events forming but 
 one picture. 
 
 Irrespective of its peculiarities as a work of art, its 
 subject is curious and interesting. It has been taken 
 by one antiquary for a map of Egypt ; and certainly it 
 is composed much as a map of ancient style might be, 
 and the figures of negroes, hippopotami, crocodiles, 
 palms, and lotus flowers, are as characteristic of Egypt 
 as the creatures and inhabitants of the world are in- 
 tended to be, on the mediaeval Mappa Mimdi of 
 Hereford. Another, taking as his guide the emperor's 
 figure, with attendant soldiers, and the fulness of the 
 river, the extent of country exhibited, and the quiet 
 occupations of the people, has explained this complex 
 picture as that of Egypt, at the period of peace 
 immediately subsequent to the expedition of Augustus, 
 which occurred at the season when the Nile was over- 
 flowing its banks. Another has hit upon an explana- 
 tion equally possible, that it is a work executed during 
 the Egyptian mania at Rome, flattering to the taste of 
 the Emperor Hadrian, who on his return introduced 
 
138 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 Egyptian fashions and deities, eagerly adopted by the 
 blaze's Romans, delighted at the waif of novelty. 
 
 Artistically it is coarse, but valuable for the reasons 
 described ; and, as a work of a very inferior artist, who 
 would follow, however clumsily, the broad system of 
 the better painters of his day, it suggests much as to 
 what was practised and approved in the arts preceding 
 and contemporary with it. 
 
 The ambition of Roman life was rather bodily and 
 intellectually muscular than artistic ; but whatever 
 glorified that life in public estimation, or glorified the 
 individual by the exhibition of his wealth, was an 
 essential element in that life ; things of grand effect, 
 luxury and splendour, were estimated at the highest, 
 just so far as in use and degree they ministered to 
 such purposes. Individuals rested their social position 
 on the splendour of their possessions, so the world was 
 ransacked for them : the gods of Greece were torn 
 from their thrones, the pictures and statues of the " old 
 masters" were imported, reckless of the disfigurement 
 of the ancient shrines or of the prices paid for them. 
 The marbles, elephants, and obelisks of Africa added 
 to the heterogeneous magnificence of Rome, and only 
 the weight of the pyramids secured them to the desert. 
 
 In one very early, and at a later period, the Romans 
 surpassed the Greeks in their sense of artistic propriety, 
 namely in assigning to the higher class of mosaic the 
 honour of a safe position upon walls. They maintained 
 indeed the Greek fashion of rich pavements, and inlaid 
 them with precious stones, and then trampled their costly 
 beauty with their heels, as Lucan scornfully describes 
 them, " Purpureusque lapis, totaque effusus in anla cal- 
 cabatur onyx ;" but under better auspices they went on 
 to the development of pictorial mosaic, and prepared the 
 way for that vast extension of it that soon after took place 
 under Christian influences. The common use of variously 
 
vi ANCIENT MOSAIC 139 
 
 coloured glass afforded this opportunity, so the tesserae 
 no longer laboriously obtained from marble were cast 
 in glass, and the skill attained in gilding it was applied 
 to them at small cost, and thus all the materials which 
 ultimately contributed to the glory of Byzantine and 
 other sacred buildings in east and west were prepared. 
 Among the pictorial purposes for which mosaic was 
 used, portraiture was much favoured in Rome, one of 
 the earliest known instances of which was that of a 
 portrait of himself in a mosaic of precious stones and 
 pearls which Pompey displayed in his triumphs. The 
 great pavement covered with portraits of Caracalla's 
 favourite gladiators will be at once remembered a 
 brutal gallery; and the portraits of the friends of the 
 Emperor Commodus which were erected in a portico 
 or alcove of his garden, as described by Spartian, " in 
 porticu curva picturata de musivo," among which that 
 of his friend Pescennius Niger figured in the attitude of 
 one carrying the insignia of the goddess Isis. Imaginary 
 portraits are also occasionally found in ancient tessel- 
 lated pavements, as on one in the museum at Cologne, 
 on which are the busts of Socrates, Diogenes, Cleobulus, 
 and Sophocles, with their names inlaid in Greek. The 
 practice of real portraiture in this manner continued for 
 many centuries, two good examples of which are the 
 portraits of Flavius J. Julianus and his wife M. 
 Simplicia Rustica, found in 1656 in the catacomb of 
 Santa Ciriaca, which have a particular interest in the 
 extreme rarity of mosaics in the catacombs, and from 
 the near relationship of these persons to the Imperial 
 family, which the names of Flavius Julianus, borne by 
 all the sons of Constantine, suggest, and those of 
 Rusticus Julianus further corroborate, 1 who died pre- 
 
 1 These portraits are preserved in the Chigi Library at Rome. Vide De 
 Rossi Musaici Christiani, 1872, where facsimiles are given in colour, and 
 an excellent historical reference to the persons. 
 
140 THE MINISTR Y OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 feet of Rome in A.D. 388, and had been regarded as a 
 possible successor to the Empire. The portraits are 
 small, within circles contained in a framed background 
 about nine inches across. Julianus is habited in a 
 dress of gold tissue and purple, characteristic of a 
 nobleman. His wife, in a dark dress of great simplicity, 
 is in the Christian attitude of prayer, her hands being 
 extended as an " Orante." Another historical mosaic 
 portrait was that of Constantine placed by Phocas in a 
 chapel on the site of the Forum of Augustus at Rome, 
 of which no traces remain. The well-known portraits 
 of Justinian and the Empress Theodora in San Vitale at 
 Ravenna are unmistakably real, that of Justinian being 
 very remarkable for the natural character of its draw- 
 ing, and its definite and intelligent expression. The 
 largest portrait ever made in mosaic was probably that 
 of a full length of Theodoric in the forum at Naples, of 
 which the tesserae composing the head fell off the wall, 
 by a singular fatality, just before his death. These are 
 but a few illustrations of a practice which continued in- 
 creasingly in .the progress of the art, of which only one 
 other historical example need be mentioned, viz. that of 
 Charlemagne in the triclinium of the Lateran, which was 
 rescued from the fire which occurred there in the troublous 
 times of Clement the Fifth (i 305-16), and of which the 
 much-injured remains are now preserved in the Vatican. 
 The application of mosaic to figures in relief need 
 only be mentioned as a curiosity of the art, and indeed 
 a misuse of it, for mosaic is essentially pictorial, and 
 has no quality in common with sculpture, but is rather 
 a hindrance to its effect. The few attempts that have 
 been made of it, and which have been beautiful in spite 
 of themselves, have owed all their excellence to the fine 
 taste of the artists experimenting upon a tour de force! 
 
 1 Faulkener's Dcedahts, p. 124, and R. Rochette's Peintures Antiques, 
 Incdites. Appendix. 
 
vi ANCIENT MOSAIC 141 
 
 Early in the first century mosaic had become a 
 necessity of furniture among the Romans, not at home 
 merely, but wherever their conquests and their colonies 
 took them. The " pavement " in the Hall of Judgment 
 at Jerusalem was but another word for mosaic, which 
 was then universally used to dignify the seat of a 
 governor and to furnish the tent of a general, as had 
 been the practice as early as the time of Julius Caesar, 
 who carried mosaic about in his campaigns, that his 
 official " pavement " might be always ready. 1 This 
 general adoption of it, which extended to basilicas and 
 baths, public halls and private houses, necessitated the 
 adaptation of native materials, where the marble of the 
 earlier styles and the glass tesserae of the later could 
 not be obtained ; so red, blue, and yellow-coloured stone, 
 as commonly used for their mosaics in England, and 
 clay baked black or red, supplied their requisite 
 materials. With so much that is interesting in them, 
 it is the more to be regretted that no clue has been 
 obtained to the artists who composed their designs ; 
 but the whole character of them, the usual excellence 
 of their composition, the artistic grouping and attitudes 
 of the figures, the arrangement and appropriateness of 
 the decorative parts, suggest that the originals were the 
 work of better heads and hands than those of the 
 skilled artisans who would have sufficed to copy the 
 cartoons and to set the tesserae. 
 
 Thus in numerous examples an inestimable service 
 has been rendered by mosaics by their preservation of 
 the designs of ancient pictures and wall paintings, 
 illustrating the specialities of artistic principles of 
 ancient schools, and in many cases with a truer remini- 
 scence of their colouring than the painted lechithoi or 
 the plastered walls of buried cities have afforded. 
 
 1 Suetonius, in his Life of Julhts Casar, describes it thus, "In expe- 
 ditionibus tessellata et sectilia circumtulisse. " 
 
142 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 Beside that of the Battle of Issus, already described, 
 one illustration, with its Greek associations at Pompeii, 
 and one with those of classic Rome, will be enough. 
 
 The subject of the former is Force overcome by 
 Love, a circular mosaic pavement in the Neapolitan 
 Museum, figured and described in the seventh volume 
 of the Museo Borbonico, plate 61. In the centre a lion, 
 of colossal proportion in comparison with the figures 
 around him, has snapped the bands of which the tattered 
 ends are flying from his legs ; but he bows his head 
 before the Amorini who have bound him with a wreath 
 of flowers, and are scattering others among his mane 
 from a cornucopia. Behind him a most coy figure of a 
 little cupid sits with half-averted face, playing a lyre, 
 and near him a priestess, draped most gracefully, and 
 with her head crowned with vine leaves, stands at the 
 angle of a terrace which forms the background, and 
 pours a libation to Bacchus, with her wreathed thyrsus 
 in the other hand, and her tambourine laid beside her. 
 In front two cupids present to the lion a torch and a 
 bouquet, and two presiding nymphs in rich drapery 
 and with wreathed hair are seated on rocks right and 
 left; trees, rocks, and the front of a small temple filling 
 in the vacancies. The colours are as charming as the 
 playful and modest gracefulness of the composition 
 an architectonic picture, of which the original must 
 have afforded the opportunities for the highest char- 
 acter of drawing and expression in its individual figures, 
 but indifferent to the easy artificialities of pictorial effect. 
 That this was a copy of some famous work is inferred 
 from the studied character of the design, and from an- 
 other mosaic of the same subject (with a few alterations 
 or omissions common to almost all such copies) found 
 at Antium. 
 
 Of a different character, but the copy of some 
 ancient work, and illustrative of the same principles, is 
 
ANCIENT MOSAIC 143 
 
 the Roman mosaic of Bellerophon found at Autun. 
 The young hero is represented mounted upon Pegasus, 
 and rising in the air to attack the chimaera ; one arm 
 is hidden behind the horse's ample mane, the other is 
 raised directing the thrust of his spear, and the effect of 
 vigour and rapidity is enhanced by the whirling folds 
 of drapery as if rolled round him by a storm, and form- 
 ing a wild frame above his head. The attitude of the 
 winged Pegasus, rampant above the double-headed 
 monster, to which Bellerophon is dealing his death- 
 blow, completes the dramatic action of the group. 
 
 But an interest of wider scope both to archaeologist 
 and artist has been afforded by the variety of subjects 
 in these ancient works taken from contemporary life. 
 Mythological subjects and conventional forms of com- 
 position are indeed the most common, but beside them 
 are illustrations of the habits and occupation of the 
 people, such as in domestic or hunting scenes, races 
 and combats of the circus, costume, portraiture, and all 
 kinds of incident and detail that exhibit the prevailing 
 taste and civilisation of the age. 
 
 One of the best examples of this kind is the great 
 mosaic of Italica near Seville. About one-third of its 
 central space, in length and breadth, is occupied by a 
 representation of the Roman circus, sufficiently complete 
 to illustrate the whole arrangement of its ground-plan. 
 Groups of men and horses are distributed all over it, 
 some in full swing of the race, some wandering about 
 on foot as if lost in it ; in one place a charioteer has 
 come to utter grief and is struggling beneath his horses, 
 at another two men are helping a wounded combatant 
 off the ground, and at the farther end, separated from 
 the race, is a space occupied by gladiators. The 
 remaining two-thirds of the mosaic is filled with numer- 
 ous circles, enclosing within wreaths and coloured 
 borders busts of the muses with their names inlaid, and 
 
144 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 others containing figures of birds, animals, centaurs, and 
 branches of leaves and fruit in natural colours, the 
 whole being enclosed in a richly coloured border of 
 many patterns. But the once brilliant city of Italica is 
 no more. It owed its origin to Scipio Africanus, who 
 after his conquest of the province, founded it as a home 
 for his disabled soldiers. It rose to great importance, 
 and was the birthplace of the Emperors Trajan, 
 Hadrian, and Theodosius ; but now no more remains 
 upon its ancient site but the small village of Santiponce 
 or Sevilla la vieja. 
 
 Nowhere, however, is the entire scene of the circus 
 exhibited in such completeness as in the great mosaic 
 at Lyons. It is a superb work. The general design 
 consists of a central subject set within a broad border 
 of conventional foliage and flowers that spring from a 
 scrolling stem beautifully drawn and coloured. Within 
 this, on a black ground throughout, is the Roman 
 circus with all its apparatus complete. At one end is the 
 Praetorian lodge raised above the arena and shaded by an 
 ornamental awning, and within it is a group of figures, 
 the central one of which is the Praetor or presiding judge, 
 leaning forward and holding over the front of his seat 
 the handkerchief that had signalled the start. Beneath 
 is the main entrance to the arena, with attendant figures 
 or heralds standing right and left. A strong high 
 palisade guards the spectators from the combatants. 
 In the centre of the arena is the spina, which appears 
 as an elaborate construction with an obelisk in the 
 centre, and enclosing a long canal of water within its 
 low boundary walls. At each end is a massive block 
 of masonry forming the two metae, which are dis- 
 tinguished by three tall pointed posts painted at one 
 end of the course red, at the other white. Over the 
 canal, and near each end, are slight barriers supporting 
 figures of dolphins, and the gilt wooden eggs, sacred to 
 
vi ANCIENT MOSAIC 145 
 
 Castor and Pollux, that marked the number of the 
 courses to be run round the spina, one egg being taken 
 off at each round, till the winning chariot reached the 
 white line drawn across the sand, which marked the 
 beginning and end of the race (ad calcem pervenire). 
 Eight chariots are contending for the prize, and by the 
 accidents that are exhibited and the excited attitudes 
 of the attendants, some on horseback, some running on 
 foot, one brandishing a whip to urge on the horses of 
 his faction, one. with a basin of water to throw over the 
 heated wheels, the race seems to be approaching its 
 close. There are four chariots on each side, probably 
 all intended to be quadrigae (four-horsed), but where 
 they are fallen to the ground and the men and horses 
 are thrown into struggling heaps, the artist has not 
 clearly shown that number, but the smash in each case 
 is well depicted by the broken remnants of wheels and 
 chariots overturned, and the drivers prostrate upon their 
 infuriated horses. The charioteers are dressed in green, 
 blue, red, and white, the four orthodox colours of the 
 factions, before Domitian added the purple and gold. 
 The horses with long tails (more Britannico) are bay, 
 white, and gray, and the whole scene is most animated. 
 The realities of such events were the delight of Roman 
 life. The charioteers were commonly drawn from the 
 social class of slaves, but nobles and even emperors 
 have taken part with them, shrouding the vainglory of 
 popular applause beneath the pretended heroism of 
 Homeric examples. Women too have contended in 
 the arena. The race of the fleet-footed Atalanta was 
 but child's play to the violence in which Roman women 
 joined, to the dishonour of their sex. The antagonism 
 of the factions led at last to such scenes of violence, too 
 well remembered in the early history of Constantinople, 
 that the discontinuance of these games was decreed by 
 Justinian, and not renewed till by order of Pope Paul 
 
 L 
 
146 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 the Second, in 1495, they were reinstituted in simpler 
 form, and continue to this day as an amusement of the 
 Carnival. 
 
 In classical times the provision of the games of the 
 circus was a sure and easy way to popularity ; but at 
 Lyons the public benefactor Ligurius was estimated for 
 services more solid than these, and recorded on a tablet 
 erected to his memory by his fellow-citizens, who in 
 enumerating his honours could not fail to wind them 
 up by the climax that "he had given them public 
 games " (" Idem ludos circenses dedit "), such as this 
 great mosaic represents. 
 
 Another very favourite subject was taken from the 
 realm of Neptune, and the increasing recurrence of it 
 towards and after the close of the first century A.D. has 
 been attributed to the increased popularity of that 
 deity on the extension of Roman commerce by sea, 
 which reached its acme at the time when mosaic 
 became the common appendage of every house in 
 countries under Roman influence. From northern 
 Britain to the African shores of the Mediterranean this 
 was the case ; and although there may be other reasons 
 for marine subjects being adopted, as they were very 
 appropriately in baths, and from the general adaptability 
 of the ideal forms of tritons, syrens, and sea monsters 
 to the scrolling ornament and the rough and broad 
 designs suitable to pavement mosaic, still there is some 
 ground to credit the popular cultus of Neptune as the 
 originating motive of the very wide adoption of those 
 subjects. The coast of Spain affords a good instance 
 of it on the floor of the church of St. Michael at 
 Barcelona, where the whole glory of the ocean kingdom 
 is portrayed in mosaic, with fishes, nereids, and tritons 
 sporting among the waves, and indicating the spot to 
 have been once occupied by a temple of Neptune. 
 
 But of all glorifications of Neptune, the design of a 
 
vi ANCIENT MOSAIC 147 
 
 mosaic found at Constantine is unequalled. In con- 
 trast with the animation of the whole scene, Neptune 
 and Amphitrite, relieved of all impediments of drapery, 
 as is the wont of marine deities, stand side by side full 
 front in their golden chariot, drawn by four dark green 
 hippocamps surging wildly through the waves a grand 
 ocean quadriga ; winged genii have thrown a rich red 
 scarf as an arch above their heads ; below them two 
 children are riding upon dolphins, and two boats at full 
 sail occupy the principal place, steered by children, 
 while others are fishing from the bows ; and all about 
 are shells, fish, and marine insects, drawn and coloured 
 to the life. The whole sea and air are full of life. 
 This artistic whirl of imaginary beings, of figures and 
 animals in water and air, is the dash of a broad sketch 
 realised in mosaic that, had it been a work of the 
 renaissance instead of the decline, might have come of 
 the free taste and free hand of such a one as Julio 
 Romano, or even a greater decorative artist than he. 
 The mosaicist may show a failing here and there, but 
 his design bears the sure stamp of a master's hand. 
 This picture marks the place of dignity at one end of 
 a large pavement, the rest of which is covered with a 
 geometrical design divided into octagons by wreaths of 
 laurel leaves beautifully coloured with blended green 
 and blue, and with interweaving ribbons and fleurettes 
 of countless colours filling up the spaces of the white 
 ground. 1 
 
 This and other pavements found on the site of 
 ancient Carthage, at Constantine, Utica, and their 
 neighbourhoods, form a distinguished group among the 
 mosaics of the world. The subtle refinement in the 
 art of colouring which they display approaches very 
 nearly to the finest of the old mosaics found at Pom- 
 
 1 It is admirably illustrated in colour in the "Report of the French 
 Researches in Algeria," vol. Archeologie. 
 
148 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 peii and elsewhere, that reflect the traditions of Greek 
 influence. The artistic sense and technical delicacy 
 with which their tesserae were handled can only be 
 likened to the masterly mosaic with which a great 
 painter inlays his work, his brush at every stroke inlay- 
 ing and multiplying tints and hues that singly seem to 
 have no affinity to their place, but together, like drops 
 fallen from a rainbow, blend into an effect of rich and 
 harmonious breadth. 
 
 One of the most important of the mosaics of classic 
 times (measuring originally nearly thirty feet square) was 
 discovered on the site of Carthage in i860. 1 Its frag- 
 ments, fairly complete in themselves, represent a little 
 above a quarter of the whole, but, the entire centre and 
 two sides being lost, they are insufficient to certify the 
 whole scheme of the design. The figures of its sub- 
 jects seem to mark it as the floor of a sacred place ; 
 and being all female, they suggest that place to have 
 been the temple of a female deity. Large female busts 
 in circular medallions fill the four corners, and full- 
 length figures fill the isolated panels of the ground, set 
 like independent pictures among scrolling foliage. 
 Only three of these remain. Two of them stand in 
 graceful attitudes, presenting gifts on their altars, and a 
 third is dancing before an altar to the music of her 
 castinets. 
 
 The special interest of this great work is derived 
 from the evidence it affords of being a relic of ancient 
 Carthage. It lay more than ten feet below the ground 
 level, 2 beneath a bed of burnt materials, with two other 
 mosaic floors at different levels above it. There are 
 no glass tesserae in it, as in other undoubted Roman 
 mosaics about the same neighbourhood, but all are 
 
 1 It is now set up in the British Museum with others from Carthage, 
 Utica, Halicarnassus, Ephesus, etc. 
 
 2 Carthage and her Remains , p. 213. Dr. N. Davis. London, 1861. 
 
vi ANCIENT MOSAIC 149 
 
 cut from valuable stones and marbles of a marvellous 
 variety, and set both as to their foundation and cement 
 in a manner different from the Roman. The well- 
 known features of Roman mosaics, with their strong 
 generic likeness, do not occur here ; the borders and 
 frames, whether the Vitruvian, the fret, the plait, or 
 the guilloche, are not found here ; and instead of the 
 usual schemes of concentric circles, or of round octa- 
 gons and hexagons set in borders, as in Roman de- 
 signs, this great pavement has a number of independ- 
 ent subjects in eight parts divided by long pyramidal 
 masses of bay or laurel leaves growing upwards to the 
 centre. This artistic treatment differs from any known 
 mosaic, and the style and costume of the figures is 
 neither Greek nor Roman. 
 
 The interpretation of its figures would vary accord- 
 ing to their being regarded as Punic or Roman ; in the 
 former case they would be simply representative, in the 
 latter they might be symbolic ; for instance, one of the 
 heads of the remaining corner medallions would, if 
 Punic, be simply that of Ceres, but if Roman it might 
 serve as the symbol of summer. An authority 1 whose 
 opinion on these subjects is greatly respected, taking 
 this latter view, regards the two heads at the angles as 
 two of the seasons, and the three remaining figures by 
 their altars as three of the months, the dancing figure 
 being April, the month of Venus, the draped statuette, 
 of which only the lower quarter remains on the altar, 
 being taken to represent that goddess ; the other two 
 figures being assigned to March and July ; and he 
 supplies the other nine by analogy drawn from other 
 classes of works of art, and he supplies ideally the 
 centre of this pavement to complete the scheme. 
 
 But why not Punic ? The various particulars al- 
 ready specified are devoid of all Roman character. 
 
 1 A. W. Franks. Recent Excavations at Carthage. London, 1860. 
 
150 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 The two grand female heads at the angles might with 
 equal propriety be assigned to Ceres and Dido, and 
 those that are lost to Anna, the deified sister of Dido, 
 and Proserpine, the daughter of Ceres, all being divini- 
 ties of the ancient Carthaginian Pantheon. The full- 
 length female figures standing or dancing before their 
 altars, are both in attitude and occupation appro- 
 priately priestesses ; and as for any hesitation about 
 Carthage possessing mosaics, its early association with 
 Greeks and their arts in Sicily, and acquaintance with 
 Greek art through Phoenicia and her mother-city Tyre, 
 would have made her acquainted with mosaic as a per- 
 fected art in common use a century at least before it 
 was even heard of in Rome. Carthage was destroyed 
 B.C. 146 ; but the nations she had long known by the 
 intercourse of a common civilisation had been the most 
 famous centres of the world's arts ; and commanding 
 the commerce of the world, she would equally have 
 commanded its arts, and have thrown that genius and 
 ambition, which characterise her history, into them also. 
 The exceeding paucity of mosaics of the second 
 and third centuries B.C., of which any knowledge has 
 been preserved, beside the famous " aserotos oikos " 
 described by Pliny, and those which lined the great 
 ship of Hiero, has affected general opinion with a sense 
 of blank, as though the art had produced nothing else ; 
 but it must be apparent that such a work as that 
 of Sosos at Pergamos, or the other at Syracuse, could 
 not have been solitary masterpieces in the midst of 
 waste. Perfect works such as those could only have 
 come of great attainment in the art around them and 
 elsewhere. They stand out like two stars in a dark 
 heaven, but only because contemporary and subsequent 
 works have perished. Carthage was the city of highest 
 cultivation at that time, and mosaic was the common 
 heritage of its age. This great work is altogether 
 
vi ANCIENT MOSAIC 151 
 
 unique ; and for the numerous reasons I have stated, I 
 venture to suggest as not unreasonable to regard it as 
 a relic of ancient Carthage, possibly of the same age 
 or a little subsequent to the famous pavements of 
 Pergamos, and the work of either Greek, Phoenician, or 
 Punic artists. 1 
 
 England also abounds with mosaics from north to 
 south, from the banks of the Humber to the Welsh 
 Caerleon, recalling the memories of those of Europe 
 and Africa, wherever the Romans have settled, for 
 where they were, there were mosaics. More might 
 have been rescued from the havoc of time and ignor- 
 ance had their value been known ; but, like so much 
 beside art, their interest is in their associations, which 
 
 1 In the limited space and in such a broad review of the whole sub- 
 ject as this essay alone pretends to be, it is impossible to do more than 
 select out of the hundreds of mosaics, classic and Christian, which exist, 
 certain prominent and illustrative examples. It is equally out of reach to 
 enter fully into archaeological controversy for the same reasons ; but with 
 regard to this particular pavement I must add that in judging of the date 
 by the style of any mosaic, it must be remembered that the similarity of 
 materials and form of tesserae, from their origin in the stones and marbles 
 of the neighbourhood, or accessible by commerce, would remain almost 
 identical in any one place from beginning to end. And further, this art 
 having been derived even by Rome entirely from Greek sources, and all 
 its earliest artists as well, certain favourite types and modes of producing 
 artistic effects (such as flesh and the shadows of flesh) would, in an art so 
 much dependent on traditional uses, be likely to remain a common pro- 
 perty of its artists for centuries. Thus, for instance, the head of Ceres in 
 this mosaic bearing some similitude to one at Cirencester is easily 
 explained by the original of them both having been a favourite model 
 from some great work copied many times in many places, as the Madonna 
 della Seggiola is copied and repeated now nearly 400 years since it was 
 designed. All the remains of this great mosaic are in the British Museum, 
 and near it are some very fine specimens of Roman work from Carthage, 
 Utica, and Boudrum (Halicarnassus). The particulars of these last are 
 given in the Report of the excavations at Boudrum, presented to Parlia- 
 ment in 1858, page 34. Of the former the colossal head of Neptune, the 
 hunting scenes, a mounted man catching a deer in a lasso, and a mosaic 
 picture of a basket of fish thrown out upon the ground, are among the 
 most remarkable. There is also a very fine mosaic slab representing a 
 triton with fish floating about him, and a dolphin carrying a trident 
 from a Roman building within the peribolus of the temple of Diana at 
 Ephesus. 
 
152 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 imply both that knowledge and feeling which turn 
 archaeology into romance, and all the more fascinating 
 because it is all true. These broken relics of old 
 times are precious pages. These remnants of old 
 mosaics in our land mark the spots where men, whose 
 names still live in classic history and literature, once 
 passed a stirring life of war and enterprise, where they 
 summoned councils and held their courts ; or, in times 
 of peace, gathered their families about them and laid 
 for their former foes the foundations of the best civilis- 
 ation that they knew. 
 
 The position occupied by ancient London both for 
 defence and commerce was too clearly marked to 
 escape the observation of the Romans ; but the in- 
 terest of its history in their times would have no place 
 here did not the beauty of its mosaics arrest our 
 attention, and warm the imagination to realise in idea 
 the scenes those silent floors once witnessed : a history 
 that was but written upon air. In modern times the 
 excavation of walls and alteration of streets have 
 revealed those relics of a past age ; and when we read 
 the familiar names of Bishopsgate Street, Leadenhall 
 Street, Lombard Street, the India House, Threadneedle 
 Street, and The Exchange, and see or hear about the 
 mosaics that have been found beneath or near them, 
 the changes, which centuries of life have wrought, strike 
 us with their startling contrasts, as those tessellated- 
 floors reveal the fact that where now the strife of the 
 world's commerce rages round its crowded centre, was 
 once the quiet Belgravian suburb of Roman London. 
 
 Of all the parts of England that bear witness to 
 Roman residence, Gloucestershire appears to have been 
 a favourite. The grassy dells of the Cotteswolds 
 afforded them a scenery which, perhaps, the unde- 
 veloped sense of landscape in those days may have 
 failed to interest ; but they settled there, and have left 
 
vi ANCIENT MOSAIC 153 
 
 along the whole length from the Painswick beacon to 
 the hills and valleys westward of Dursley the relics of 
 many of their homes. It was a tempting site for them. 
 The wide hunting ground of the Cotteswold country 
 was behind them, and their city Corinium, the modern 
 Cirencester, at the junction of their principal roads, was 
 within easy reach ; Aquasolis (Bath) also and Caerleon, 
 and their "castra exploratoria " on the points of all the 
 hills. The great military establishment at Glevum (the 
 modern Gloucester) lay in the valley below them, on 
 the bank of the meandering Severn ; and far beyond, 
 the country of the Silures, the scene of their great 
 campaign, stretched out into the wide distance, blend- 
 ing the woods and hills of its horizon with the mists of 
 the setting sun. 
 
 Here in one of its loveliest spots, now Woodchester, 
 a palace was built, which from the evidence of its 
 extent and wealth was one of much importance. Its 
 historian has with most reasonable inference traced 
 here the site of imperial residence, where Claudius and 
 Hadrian trod its tessellated floors. Ostorius Scapula 
 was Propraetor of Britain under Claudius, and is known 
 to have constructed many " castra " along the Severn 
 valley. Claudius's 7th Legion was for many years 
 stationed at Gloucester, and this favoured spot, Wood- 
 chester, afforded precisely the central and secure posi- 
 tion required for the governor's residence. Its great 
 central open court was an atrium of all but fifty feet 
 square. The mosaic of its pavement is one of the 
 largest known, and though coarsely executed, it ex- 
 hibits all the best features of Roman mosaic art of that 
 period. The ground of it is a warm white, and within 
 a grandly-designed border is one large circle divided 
 into several rings with an octagonal centre. The 
 central figure is lost ; but Orpheus, who commonly 
 occupies that place, is here delineated within one of the 
 
154 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 inner circles, with animals and birds duly tamed by his 
 music quietly following each other all round. The 
 colour is rich and simple ; and the materials which are 
 mostly of local production have, for the purest white 
 tesserae, the hard calcareous stone imported for the 
 purpose, the same as is found in Roman mosaics in 
 various parts of Europe. It is approached by a cor- 
 ridor 1 1 4 feet long and 9 broad, from end to end 
 mosaic ; and in various directions are the foundations 
 of rooms, of which the evidences of their once tessellated 
 floors still remain. The character of the latest of these 
 pavements is of a style that would date about the reign 
 of Septimius Severus ; and in relation to that emperor a 
 coincidence is worthy of remark, that a group of figures 
 ornamenting the floor of one of the rooms, is that of 
 two genii, without wings, but in the attitude of flying, 
 carrying between them a basket of fruit, and inlaid 
 below them is the motto " Bonum Eventum " a motto 
 that is found on the reverse of coins of that emperor 
 and of his son Geta. He remained some time in 
 England, and this device seems to bring him to this 
 spot, the floor having been thus inlaid in honour of his 
 residence. 1 
 
 Of the numerous relics of Roman mosaic in Eng- 
 land it is hard to pass over such fine specimens as those 
 at Littlecote in Wiltshire, at Stonesfield near Blenheim, 
 at Cirencester, and other places, but three will suffice 
 to illustrate their best characteristics, viz. those at 
 Frampton, Horkstow, and Bignor, of which the two 
 first contain symbols which seem to associate them 
 with the earliest Christian age in Britain. 
 
 1 For description and illustration of these and other important mosaics 
 in England vide Lysons's Woodchester, published 1797, and his Reliquice 
 Britannico- Romance, London, 1801. Also Fowler's Ilhistrations of 
 Mosaics in all Parts of England, published in 1810. Roach Smith's 
 Roman London and Collectanea Antiqua, and journals of principal archaeo- 
 logical societies, etc. 
 
vi ANCIENT MOSAIC 155 
 
 The contrast between the grandly artistic schemes 
 on which the floors are laid out, and the ignorance of 
 drawing and detail in the execution of most of them, 
 have inevitably suggested their derivation from some 
 good sources, of which the original cartoons have 
 perished. The mosaicists seem in most cases to have 
 been skilled artisans of a superior class, furnished with 
 a store of designs and patterns common to the archi- 
 tectural style of the time ; and with these as their 
 " stock " they gave to their repetitions of them the 
 appearance of originality by the ingenious variety of 
 their combinations. Human figures, birds and beasts, 
 gods and goddesses, often designed in admirable atti- 
 tudes, but blundered to the utmost in execution, are 
 accounted for on the same theory ; thus, no two 
 mosaics, though containing every element the same, 
 appear actually alike. 
 
 There are, however, two remarkable exceptions, 
 viz. those at Bignor in Sussex and at Avenches in 
 Switzerland, where not only the unique circumstance 
 occurs of each having a bath or cistern in their centre, 
 but the evidence of both pavements having been in 
 great part taken from the same original cartoons, is 
 plain from the similarity of the figures, which is so 
 great as to extend even to their faults in drawing and 
 proportion. Avenches, where the great mosaic meas- 
 ures 55 French feet long by 36 broad, owed its im- 
 portance to its strategical or otherwise convenient 
 position during the wars with Germany, and flourished 
 under the patronage of Vespasian and Titus, which 
 affords a clue to its probable date. The mosaic at 
 Bignor corresponds with this date, and being somewhat 
 Pompeian in character, its ornaments differ both in 
 style and arrangement from most others in England, 
 and present an appearance of greater antiquity. 
 
 The several pavements of this place, ruinous as 
 
156 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 their condition now is, have such peculiar interest that 
 it is a regrettable necessity in a sketch of the history 
 of the art such as this, that only the main features of 
 any one example can find place. These at Bignor are 
 probably the earliest of Roman mosaics of any im- 
 portance in Britain. Their extent implies the decora- 
 tion of the rooms of a governor's residence, the capital 
 of whose province was the modern Chichester, from 
 which it is about twelve miles distant. The pavements 
 have suffered very greatly from wilful as well as acci- 
 dental injury. The usual Roman combination of circles 
 within squares form the general scheme of the designs, 
 of which the smaller circle is occupied by the figure of 
 Ganimede carried by the eagle, and the larger one 
 divided into hexagons contains dancing nymphs, which 
 recall to mind the paintings of Pompeii. The mimic 
 gladiators which occupy the four small compartments 
 of another floor are unique in England ; as are also 
 the two labyrinths in another part. These gladiators 
 are winged children. The panels of each subject 
 measure 2 feet 9 by 16 inches, and contain in minia- 
 ture the complete arrangement of the gladiatorial 
 combat. In the first the little figures stand in two 
 groups preparing for the fight, which is to be that 
 between the retiarius and the mirmillo, the former 
 being armed with a net and trident, the latter with a 
 sword and shield. Each is attended by a veteran 
 gladiator, the rudiarius, whose business was to instruct 
 and assist the rising genius. The attendant of the 
 mirmillo is lifting the helmet to the young gladiator's 
 head, while his shield rests on the ground before him ; 
 and he wears the orthodox grieve on his left leg. His 
 adversary with his net and trident is dressed with a 
 cassula over his tunic, and has his head correctly bare. 
 He seems to shrink a little as his friendly rudiarius 
 leads him to the contest. In the next compartment 
 
vi ANCIENT MOSAIC 157 
 
 the retiarius is evidently pressed hard, and his friend 
 comes to the rescue. In the last he is fallen disarmed 
 and wounded in the thigh. In another part of the 
 pavement is a remarkable female bust, that can be 
 none other than that of Venus, crowned with a chaplet 
 of flowers, the tresses of her hair falling over her bare 
 shoulders. As a goddess she has a light-blue nimbus 
 over her head, and takes the place of the Bacchus with 
 his blue nimbus also, on the pavement at Avenches ; 
 cornucopia, festoons, and birds decorate the surround- 
 ing space. 
 
 At a distant part of England from this, near the 
 mouth of the Humber, is one of the most important 
 mosaics in England, at Harkstow. It was discovered 
 in 1796 close to the Roman road from Lincoln to the 
 river, near the station Praetorium of the first stage of 
 Antonine's Itinerary. In the central circle of the main 
 floor sits Orpheus with his lyre, wearing the usual 
 Phrygian bonnet, with a peacock at his side, and 
 attendant animals, the hare and dog, bear, boar, and 
 elephant ; birds of various kinds, among which are 
 doves with coloured wings, make up the company. 
 The four spandrels or corners of this and the adjoining 
 square are remarkable, the one from its four male busts 
 drawn in brown outline upon the white ground, and 
 having on each side of them the Christian symbol of 
 the cross inlaid in red tesserae. The corresponding 
 angles of the adjacent floor are not occupied by Titans, 
 as they have been described, but by demoniacal figures 
 with outstretched arms holding up the edges of the 
 central circle, their bodies painted black and red, and 
 having in place of legs huge coiling snakes with red 
 crests and fiery tongues ; demons of unrest in significant 
 contrast with the calm Christian busts hard by. The 
 great circle of this floor is beautifully arranged with 
 graceful groups of figures in four large blue medallions, 
 
158 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 with nereids, tritons, and marine creatures between 
 them, and winged genii dancing and waving wreaths 
 round the small central circle of which the subject is 
 lost. 
 
 If, as is possible from those symbolic representa- 
 tions, this was the floor of a Christian establishment, 
 the pagan character of the rest is only in common with 
 all early mosaics ; the mosaicist having none other for 
 it than his usual stock of subjects. 
 
 Next to this is a spirited mosaic picture of a Biga 
 race. Four chariots are engaged, and two mounted 
 men accompany them. The chariots are apparently 
 of light straw plait like beehives, or of wickervvork, and 
 the drivers kneel in them. One is upset, with its 
 wheel broken off, and a horseman, dismounted, stretches 
 forward to save the falling charioteer. The horse of 
 another is in the act of falling headlong, and the other 
 two are at full speed. The charioteers are not clothed 
 with the orthodox colours, but are red and buff, and 
 their horses are chestnut, brown, black, and bay. The 
 spina dividing the course is plainly drawn, and the 
 meta at each end of it is surmounted with two 
 pyramids. 
 
 Only one other Roman mosaic in England need 
 be mentioned, perhaps the most interesting of all, that 
 at Frampton near Dorchester. Here there are pave- 
 ments of three rooms of important size connected by 
 long corridors with mosaic floors throughout. The 
 design of one of these (an oblong of 30 x 20 feet) is 
 characterised by the prevailing idea of Deity over- 
 coming evil. One figure, very rarely found, is that of 
 Mars Pacifer, the symbol of war waged for the sake 
 of peace, dressed like a Roman soldier, wearing the 
 Phrygian cap of liberty, but with an olive-tree growing 
 beside him, and an olive branch in his hand. Another 
 is Neptune spiking with his trident a sea monster who 
 
ANCIENT MOSAIC 159 
 
 is attacking him from below. A third is Apollo killing 
 the Python, represented as a snake coiled on a tree and 
 in the attitude of attack. A fourth is the peaceful 
 Bacchus, filling the place, which would otherwise have 
 been properly filled by the more pugnacious Vulcan. 
 A second pavement at the end of a long passage is 
 altogether in honour of Neptune, its panelled hexagons 
 and octagons being filled with figures of nereids and 
 dolphins and busts of men holding long spiral shells as 
 sceptres. 
 
 The principal room is of basilican form of three 
 compartments, the main body being a square with a 
 narrow oblong projecting from one side and uniting it 
 to a semicircular apse. The ornamental border of the 
 square is filled with dolphins and with the head of 
 Oceanus as a central medallion in it on the side toward 
 the apse. In the centre of the oblong is the monogram 
 of Christus in its central circle, the rest of the space 
 being filled with scrolling foliage. The apse has at its 
 extremity an oblong panel of plain tesserae, as if to 
 mark the place for a statue, a throne, or an altar. A 
 vase in its centre is its only ornament. 
 
 The form and ornamentation of this floor suggests 
 that the apartment was one of importance dedicated 
 either to judicial or religious use ; if to the former, the 
 apse would have been the place of the Praetorian chair ; 
 if the latter, it would have contained the statue of the 
 god ; and to judge by the figures and emblems through- 
 out the mosaics of this extensive palace, this would 
 have been Neptune ; and the prominent Christian 
 monogram, the subject of Constantine's vision, and of 
 the labarum of his army, would have been inserted when 
 Christianity was proclaimed ; the statue in the apse 
 giving place to the altar, and the temple consecrated 
 as a British church. 
 
ESSAY Ml Continued 
 
 MOSAIC 
 
 PART II CHRISTIAN 
 
 E adoption of Christianity marked the beginning 
 of a new era in this art, not by a revolution in its 
 practice or its purpose, but by the new direction given 
 to them both. Both use and motive indeed remained 
 the same ; for whether to adorn a palace for its owner's 
 pleasure or to aid devotion in a sacred place, the 
 springs of the artist's energy and the motives for his 
 art's employment were the same ; but the source of 
 those springs was changed, and the force of his motive 
 was initiated elsewhere. In ornamental art the joy of 
 human life had still to be served, and in sacred places 
 the ideal of Deity had still to be glorified ; but the 
 aspect and aspirations of his life were changed. So 
 the arts, those methods of men's hearts' expression, 
 were changed too, not in nature but in voice, with new 
 purposes to serve, new thoughts to tell, and new in- 
 spirations to obey. 
 
 Practically such a change could not be at once 
 exhibited. Works were continually required, but the 
 designs made in this new spirit were not immediately 
 forthcoming. It needed time to formulate the repre- 
 sentative ideas on which such designs could be realised. 
 So the result was inevitable, as illustrated by such 
 
ESSAY vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 161 
 
 works as the mosaics in the church of Santa Costanza at 
 Rome, which some critics have disposed of as pagan, 
 some as Christian, but which were in fact that union 
 of both that was unavoidable in a work ordered by the 
 first Christian Emperor at his daughter's request, and 
 executed to the best of their power by mosaicists who 
 took what they could and what they knew best, to 
 please their Imperial patrons, like the well-instructed 
 scribe who brought out of his treasures things both 
 new and old, 
 
 Thus was adopted at once that employment of 
 mosaic which distinguished the general use of it under 
 Christian from that of pagan influences, the latter 
 having assigned its finest works to floors, the former 
 to walls and ceilings. Not indeed that such was the 
 universal practice, for from Aosta and Siena to Rheims 
 and Cologne the pavements of Christian buildings have 
 been enriched with pictorial representations of the best 
 that their day could produce ; but the general tend- 
 ency has prevailed to apply to floors the mechanical 
 designs of inlaid marbles, and to lavish on the wafts 
 and vaulting the whole glory of the artist's genius. 
 The ever-quoted examples of Ravenna and Constanti- 
 nople show this. The basilicas of Monreale in Sicily, 
 of the Lateran at Rome, and of St. Mark's at Venice 
 are splendid with all that the wealth of marble and 
 ingenuity of device could spread upon their floors ; but 
 for their walls and vaulting are reserved those master- 
 pieces of the art with which only poetry and devotion 
 could combine to clothe them. 
 
 At Sour, near to the traditional tomb of King 
 Hiram, the friend of Solomon, on a site that once 
 was a necropolis, in the neighbourhood of the ancient 
 city of Tyre, has been found a mosaic floor of a small 
 Christian church, of which the consecration to St. 
 Christopher, as commemorated by an inscription, set 
 
 M 
 
162 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 in marble tesserae, has a peculiar significance, from this 
 being the country to which has been assigned the 
 birthplace of that mythic Saint whose colossal figure, 
 bearing the infant Christ upon his shoulder, has made 
 the subject of so many wall paintings in the mediaeval 
 churches of western Christendom. The fabric of this 
 church exists no more, but its foundations show it to 
 have had a central nave and two side aisles ; and, with 
 the exception of their three apses, their entire floors 
 remain, though saved from theft and injury only by a 
 few inches of garden soil. Judging by its style, it 
 would belong to the age of Constantine (as a central 
 date), the design of it recalling the motives which 
 characterise part of the vaulting of Santa Costanza's 
 church and of the Lateran baptistery at Rome, and 
 the ground of part of the great floor at Italica (already 
 described), which would have preceded it, and the 
 beautiful mosaic pavement of the Christian basilica 
 at D'Jemila, in Algeria, which would follow it. The 
 system of covering spaces with numerous circles, con- 
 taining figures of all sorts of animals, birds, little 
 winged genii, reptiles, and sprigs of leaves, was a 
 favourite device at that period. Indeed, so entirely 
 was this ideal of ornament received as of right taste 
 and universal propriety, even in sacred buildings, that 
 a little after the reign of Constantine the writer and 
 statesman Olympiodorus, seeking advice from St. 
 Nilus about the decoration of the interior of a church, 
 suggested that the walls on each side of the sanctuary 
 should be ornamented with figures of animals and fish, 
 with incidents of the chase, and " histories of all kinds of 
 birds and beasts, reptiles and plants." The Saint's reply, 
 objecting and suggesting a higher order of iconography, 
 shows how Christian influence soon prevailed to stop 
 this system of decoration, which after the fifth century 
 is rarely if ever found, except in very modified form, as 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 163 
 
 at Rome, Aosta, and Rheims, and other places, where the 
 circle, as a natural form for medallions, was employed, 
 but where they were filled, not with animal forms for 
 want of anything better, but with such, whether of things, 
 persons, fish, animals, and birds, as had some symbolic 
 reference to Christianity, or the moral of human life, of 
 which the calendar, with its ring of circular medallions, 
 was a simple and favourite illustration. 
 
 The mosaic at Sour is a complete illustration of the 
 style of its age. The principal pavement of the nave, 
 of oblong form, is a work of great refinement ; the 
 general design being that of traditional simplicity, with 
 a vase at each angle, from which plants grew, forming, 
 with their branches, numerous small circles, filled with 
 precisely such a scheme of figures, taken from the 
 animal world, as St. Nilus at a later time rejected. 
 In the central circle (of thirty) is drawn, much in the 
 same spirit as the vintage mosaic of Santa Costanza, a 
 group of two children, apparently playing musical in- 
 struments one sitting, the other standing, in a wine- 
 press, with a tub in front to catch the grape juice, and 
 at the back, rising above the heads of the children, a tall 
 cross. The rest of the circles are filled with animals 
 playing or fighting, such as a fox at full speed carrying 
 a cock on his back, a lion seizing a stag, and a snake and 
 a squirrel, to judge by their expressive figures, startled 
 at their sudden meeting. There are also single figures 
 of children hunting, and one engaged in the less excit- 
 ing occupation of dragging an unwilling donkey loaded 
 with panniers. A double row of circles, with guilloche 
 borders, fill the side aisles, containing busts of figures 
 representing the four seasons, the twelve months, and 
 the four winds, each distinguished by its name in 
 Greek ; and numerous pairs of animals, birds and fish. 1 
 
 1 The inscription forming part of this pavement has led to much con- 
 troversy. It states that the church was dedicated at a date corresponding 
 
1 64 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 The continuance of the same traditional use, bor- 
 rowed from classical designs, of the forms of animals 
 
 to A.D. 652-3 ; and it is added that " the whole work of this mosaic ('to 
 panergon tes Psephosios') was included in the dedication." The ques- 
 tion is about the date of this pavement. The inscription does not specify 
 the pavement (" Lithostrotos "), but mosaic work (" Psephosis"). Had 
 the Greek writer of the inscription referred specially to the pavement he 
 would have written "Lithostrotos," which was the word universally 
 adopted by the Greek translators of the Septuagint at Alexandria for 
 mosaic pavements. " Psephosis " was the Greek for mosaic in its 
 largest sense as applied to tessellated architectural work by the Greeks 
 of Constantinople ; but when a novel employment of tessellation for 
 small pictures and minute ornaments, used like jewelry upon dresses, 
 became the fashion in the time of Constantine Porphyrogenitus, another 
 name appeared necessary for its designation, and the words "mousa- 
 kion," "mousaion," and others, from "mousa," were applied to it. 1 
 
 By its style this pavement, which has not a single Byzantine feature in 
 it, would reasonably be assigned to the date mentioned in the text. The 
 materials of the inscription being of similar material to the rest is no 
 sufficient argument for identity of date. The whole character of it, and 
 of the Greek letters used in it, is absolutely distinct. It almost speaks 
 for itself, and suggests what appears to me a simple explanation. The 
 churches of Palestine were at that date (652), under Byzantine influence, 
 habitually decorated with mosaics throughout ; and the persons effecting 
 so grand a work as that in their own style would have cared but little for 
 the pavement, then 300 years old, of a style associated with pagan tradi- 
 tions, and being probably that of one of the many small churches erected 
 in Syria by Constantine or his mother, St. Helena. Mosaic was so com- 
 mon in the seventh century that indifference would easily have led these 
 advanced mosaicists to ignore the old pavement in comparison with their 
 own great work of covering the interior walls with sacred subjects. Thus, 
 on dedicating the church anew to St. Christopher, their idea of "all 
 this mosaic work" ("psephosis") was what they had just done. Their 
 tesserae would have been all of glass, and just such as despoilers would 
 have certainly robbed, having subsequently become in great demand for 
 the walls and dadoes of Mahomedan mosques. For the pavement of 
 their church those mosaicists of the seventh century would not have em- 
 ployed tessellation, but that mixed mosaic of sectile and Alexandrian 
 work then universally in fashion in the East, as at Thessalonica, Constan- 
 tinople, and other places ; and in that manner they would have paved 
 the three apses with slabs and inlays of valuable marbles, which also re- 
 commended themselves to the same robbers for the same purpose when 
 the whole fabric was destroyed and pillaged by the victorious Moslems. 
 The sand soon swept over the old tessellated pavement, and garden soil 
 has preserved it till our time. So the inscription and its date relate to 
 the large work on the walls, which has entirely perished, and not to the 
 pavement into which it had been inlaid, in a totally different style of design 
 from the more ancient part described in the text. 
 
 1 Const. Porphyr. De Ceremon. aulcz Byzantince. 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 165 
 
 and plants in the decoration of Christian buildings at 
 that period, is beautifully illustrated in a somewhat 
 similar floor in the early African church at D'Jernila in 
 Algeria. The scheme of the design as an architectural 
 ornament is faultless ; more thoroughly geometrical 
 than the principal pavement at Sour, with interlacing 
 borders enclosing circles surrounded with octagonal 
 wreaths of bay leaves, containing in the centre of each, 
 on a white ground, birds and animals, drawn in 
 quiet attitudes, and including the elephant, camel, and 
 ostrich, apparently selected from such as were natural 
 to Africa ; the one exception of symbolic reference to 
 Christianity being the dove carrying the olive branch. 
 
 A very different class of art was now begun at 
 the two imperial centres, Rome and Constantinople. 
 Christianity was now free, and the mosaics upon the 
 walls and vaults of its sacred places were spread as 
 vast pictures illustrating the incidents of its history 
 and faith. The great mosaics of the first nine cen- 
 turies in the churches at Rome have been so often 
 and so well described that their very names are as 
 household words in the history of art. They need no 
 repetition - here (for my purpose is rather historical 
 than descriptive), nor scarcely any notice beyond that 
 of the testimony they bear to the gradual decline of 
 the artistic spirit of their age, and the struggle it made 
 to live ; sometimes rising, at least in the poetry of 
 religious intention, as in the dignified portraiture of 
 the apse of Santa Pudeziana, and the sacred symbolism 
 in that of SS. Cosmo and Damian ; at another time 
 failing in all artistic sense, as in the ill-composed and 
 worse-drawn subjects which surmount, from end to 
 end, the grand architectural avenue of S. Maria 
 Maggiore ; and sinking at last to its lowest depth 
 in the stolid figures which signalise the very death of 
 art in the apse of SS. Nereus and Achilleus. 
 
1 66 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 The Romans unhappy in their fallen state, the 
 fatal wreck of ancient pride, deserted by their em- 
 perors, distracted by internal disorder and continuous 
 war, their city reduced to a dependency of Ravenna, 
 taken and sacked by Goths, Vandals and Heruli ; 
 ruined and impoverished in men and means, and com- 
 pleting a period of alternating pillage and servitude 
 during little less than a century and a half, at last to 
 find itself, about the middle of the sixth century, the 
 vassal of the East had lost all spirit for the finer arts 
 of life. What little original power they had ever pos- 
 sessed in them had now been crushed by national 
 disaster, and a darkness had fallen upon them that 
 was not to be lifted for centuries. Individuals there 
 doubtless were, lovers of the arts of peace, who, in 
 the quieter moments of that distracted life, had clung 
 to the associations of happier days, and had main- 
 tained some traditions of their arts ; but there is no 
 record and but little evidence of them left. The 
 Church, their only source of comfort and quiet occu- 
 pation, employed them at various intervals of time, 
 but under masters from elsewhere whom the East or 
 the Exarchate could spare. 
 
 The works of this art in Rome, spread over a 
 period of four centuries, with various fortune, and 
 sometimes with long intervals of sleep, were but of 
 inferior class to what was being produced elsewhere. 
 The collapse of all original power in art was evident 
 from the repetition of the same subject in four dif- 
 ferent churches, each inferior to its predecessor ; and 
 at last, by the monopoly of all art in the hands of 
 artists from the East, who, regardless of Rome, adopted 
 in their works Greek inscriptions, attitudes, costumes, 
 and compositions, the gorgeous ornament of oriental 
 taste in their accessories, as their favourite saint, S. 
 Agnese, was displayed in the splendid dress and 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 167 
 
 jewelry of an Eastern empress ; and at last so en- 
 tirely Greek as, under the eyes of Roman pontiffs, 
 to figure the Saviour in the Greek attitude of bene- 
 diction. The interest which the mosaics at Rome 
 arouse since the fifth century, when the last great 
 work had been realised in the church of SS. Cosmo 
 and Damian, is dashed with the melancholy of de- 
 clining life. That church once exhibited in its 
 triumphal arch and apse a glorious work of archi- 
 tectural painting in mosaic ; but the building was 
 subsequently altered, and the fine completeness of its 
 mosaic picture was destroyed by diminution of its 
 walls. It had doubtless from the first a certain 
 severity of character which the types and habits of 
 the Gothic invaders had introduced, and the Byzan- 
 tine spirit had stereotyped on its composition ; but 
 the original effect of it must have been exceedingly 
 grand. It possessed no single element of old Roman 
 pictorial composition ; but broad and simple in its 
 arrangement of numerous groups of figures, with that 
 of Christ for the centre, on which the whole scheme 
 culminated, it was also embellished with such beauty 
 of religious symbolism as filled this vast composition 
 with the deepest and most affecting interest. Above, 
 upon the wall over the apse, is the figure of the 
 Lamb of God lying upon a jewelled altar, with the 
 cross above it, and the seven golden candlesticks 
 standing on either side. Below, in, the form of a 
 frieze, at the base of the whole composition, the 
 figurative river Jordan flows forth, and on its bank 
 the Lamb stands, with six others approaching Him from 
 either side out of the cities of Jerusalem and Bethlehem, 
 emblematic of the churches of the Old and New Testa- 
 ments, from opposite directions, united in Himself. To 
 the comparatively rude spectators of those days of 
 darkness and trouble it must have been like an open 
 
1 68 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 book of sublime poetry, heightened by the inspira- 
 tions of the purest piety, with a glory of effect that 
 seemed to break upon them from heaven. In its 
 original condition it was wider, and supported on each 
 side beneath by those grandly -conceived groups of 
 glorified martyrs, in white robes, presenting their 
 crowns to Christ, as the copy of this subject in the 
 same position in the church of Santa Prassede still re- 
 presents them. 
 
 It is the completeness of the composition thus 
 secured on the walls of Santa Prassede that, in spite of its 
 great inferiority, produced so grand an effect. This 
 repetition (with a few changes among the figures) was 
 made about A.D. 820, little short of 300 years after the 
 original in SS. Cosmo and Damian, and twice again, 
 at each time marred by the evidences of rapidly declin- 
 ing art, in the churches of S. Cecilia and S. Mark. 
 
 The iconoclastic edicts of Leo the Tsaurian in A.D. 
 726 at Constantinople gave such a blow to art as it 
 never recovered till the revival in the twelfth century. 
 Many of the best artists migrated. Some came to 
 Rome and established themselves in a college known 
 as the Schola Greca, close to a church which received 
 the name of S. Maria in Cosmedia from the beauty of 
 their works in it ; but though their influence is very 
 evident, there is no distinct reference to them in the 
 records of any important work which followed. It was 
 not till the time of Leo III., about half a century later, 
 that any energy was thrown into this art. This friend 
 of Charlemagne was in his sphere a worthy coadjutor 
 of the Emperor, and as active in the employment of 
 the arts as in all else, but the best of the mosaics 
 executed for him have perished. One only of the most 
 important, the triclinium of the Lateran palace, is still 
 seen in its original place, in part the copy in part the 
 restored remnant of what fire, accident, and neglect had 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 169 
 
 left, and the much injured portraits of the Pope and 
 the Emperor, now preserved in the Vatican. 
 
 But "the stars in their. courses fought against" the 
 arts, and anarchy and barbarism were spreading 
 their deep shadows over society and government. All 
 art that could properly be called Italian had died out 
 heart-broken, and in all that related to it, the Greek 
 influence, depressed and depressing, became more and 
 more pronounced. The weak hands to whom it had 
 been relinquished could produce no warmth to save the 
 expiring flames. Still even in the feebleness of its 
 waning life there had been in the very nature of mosaic 
 a quality and effect of massiveness and breadth that 
 saved it in great degree from the offences to which 
 other arts were liable ; but even that grandeur, which 
 results from simplicity and solemnity alone, gradually 
 sank into gloom ; and at last all its tenderer elements 
 of beauty disappeared, as the songs of birds die away 
 before the deepening chills of winter. 
 
 In the meantime another phase of art had been 
 developed at Constantinople, the phase of splendour. 
 The natural disposition of its eastern people, the haste 
 and reckless cost of a new centre of civilised life, artifi- 
 cially excited, infused it with the prevailing energy. 
 The art of mosaic with which only we are here con- 
 cerned, had to take its part in the universal indulgence 
 of display, and contributed its quota of magnificence by 
 the effect of gold, spread over vast architectural spaces 
 as the background of its coloured subjects. The origin 
 of these gold backgrounds was probably no more than a 
 new phase of what had been a practice among the arts 
 of ancient Byzantium, and in reality due to the exten- 
 sive use of gold plates in the more ancient oriental 
 decoration. Gold tesserae had long been used at 
 Rome, but not as grounds for pictures. The East 
 afforded no precedent for gold ground mosaic, nor had 
 
i;o THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 it been used in classic Greece, but plates of gold and 
 architecture overlaid with gold, as distinguished from 
 gilding, had been for centuries the recognised mode of 
 regal and religious decoration in those Eastern lands 
 which had been the first nurseries of the arts. The 
 ruins of t Chaldaean architecture have afforded the evi- 
 dence of towers and fagades having thus been plated 
 with gold, and of walls of rooms ornamented with gold 
 plates in the place of pictures. The facility for such 
 splendour of effect was now immediately at hand in the 
 gilt glass tesserae for mosaics ; their cost was compara- 
 tively nil y their extent unlimited, and the opportunity of 
 display was all that could be desired by the gorgeous 
 taste of the imperial founders and citizens of Constanti- 
 nople. 
 
 The conversion of Byzantium into the imperial city 
 of Constantinople gave such a spring to the arts as 
 seemed to promise their revival in force. The energy 
 of novelty, the ambition of wealth, the motive power of 
 a new religious ideal, and all else that could contribute 
 to stir artistic enthusiasm were concentrated on that 
 favoured spot. Ancient Greece was despoiled of its 
 treasures, and what Rome had left was accumulated at 
 Constantinople. But the models of antiquity had no 
 elements, but those of abstract beauty, in common with 
 the part that fine art was now called upon to play. 
 Their beauty was transcendent and their forms perfect, 
 and they had reached the acme of what human genius 
 could effect for the glory of their own ideal. Those 
 works might glorify a city and satisfy the display an 
 oriental population loved. They had sprung from an 
 enthusiasm common to all mankind, and had risen to 
 be idolised by it, but their very perfection was a bar 
 to progress. Genius had exhausted itself upon them. 
 They had told their tale and had finished their special 
 ministry. The happiness they gave they could give 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 171 
 
 still, and would give as long as their frail materials 
 would last. All that was pure and beautiful in them, 
 all that their rich eloquence could speak of what was 
 common to the divine element in humanity, was and 
 ever would be theirs, but art had now other demands 
 to meet, and, as of old, so still must she draw from the 
 same Nature the models of her works, but a Nature seen 
 under a new aspect and with all the circumstances of 
 its life actuated by other motives and pointing to 
 another destiny. 
 
 Constantine was a great builder, and pre-eminently 
 of churches, and in all of them mosaic or inlaid marbles 
 were the chief mode of ornament Eusebius describes, 
 perhaps with too great fervour, the emperor's great 
 basilica at Jerusalem, as exhibiting a splendour only 
 comparable to what the prophets had foretold of the 
 new Jerusalem ; the walls were inlaid with marbles, and 
 were enriched with gold, silver, and precious stones. 
 But little remains of any mosaics that can be with 
 certainty attributed to him, beside the Roman church 
 of Santa Costanza and of the Lateran baptistery ; for 
 those of the first S. Peter's at Rome, at Constantinople, 
 and Jerusalem have perished. 
 
 The history of Constantinople was one of trouble 
 and disturbance. The palace of Constantine was 
 burnt, and a time of general displacement and restless- 
 ness followed the reign of its founder, till the city rose 
 again in greatness and beauty in the days of Justinian. 
 He too was a mighty builder of palaces and churches. 
 Next to the imperial palace, of which nothing but 
 magnificent description remains, the church of the Holy 
 Apostles had been the most important work of Con- 
 stantine. It was the first built in the form of the cross, 
 with a long nave and a dome over the centre, covered 
 with bronze. His tomb was under this dome, and the 
 whole interior was coated with rich marbles. It was 
 
172 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 ruined by an earthquake, and its place is now occupied 
 by the mosque of Mahomet II. A nobler edifice now 
 rose under the auspices of Justinian, dedicated to Holy 
 Wisdom in the centre of his renovated city, to be its 
 glory for all time Agia Sophia. Its foundation stone 
 was laid on the 23d of February 531. The arts broke 
 forth anew, pressed into the service of this great build- 
 ing, and among them, as sculpture was not yet realised 
 in its Christian sense, and painting had been relegated 
 to the humbler sphere of the easel and illumination, 
 architecture and mosaic reigned supreme. The interior 
 of Santa Sophia by the harmonised elements of space, 
 power, and grace, presents the sublimest effect of which 
 its style of architecture is capable. The modes and 
 forms of architectural grandeur are severally distinct, 
 incomparable, and unique. The monuments of Egypt, 
 the temples of Greece, the cathedrals of Europe have 
 each their own, and are each supremely expressive of 
 their own intent. This wondrous Agia Sophia was 
 absolutely unique ; and for the purpose of worship in a 
 faith that realised to the imagination the sublimest con- 
 ceptions of Deity, this work of purest art fulfilled and 
 satisfied all aspirations. 
 
 Its vast dome is constructed with a number of 
 narrow ribs, richly coloured, and with plain spaces of 
 gold between them rising to a central circle, now 
 painted over, but originally filled in mosaic with a 
 colossal figure of Christ seated in majesty, the ray- 
 shaped golden spaces of the dome, which are now 
 meaningless, forming then a splendid glory radiating 
 over the whole vast space, as though they emanated from 
 the central figure. Below it the four corner pendent- 
 ives, from [which the dome springs, are covered with 
 the wings of four gigantic cherubim, thus completing 
 the sublime conception of the central subject. The 
 figure of Christ is described by those who saw it long 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 173 
 
 ago as seated within a rainbow (in iride) expressive of 
 the " rainbow round about the throne ;" and, if we may 
 be allowed to complete the picture by analogy from 
 others elsewhere, this rainbow surrounded the circular 
 panel, as, in the form of a vesica, it was commonly 
 used in subsequent times, and whether on a blue 
 ground, as in another part of the church, or on gold, 
 the central figure was seated not upon a throne, as it is 
 in the narthex, but upon a globe iridescent with stars. 1 
 The figure of the globe had been known in very ancient 
 art as the symbol of eternity and the universe, but its 
 acceptance and conversion to Christian art as an 
 appropriate symbol, and as the throne of One who was 
 its creative Word and final Judge, had not been seen 
 before. This grand idea, found in other works of 
 immediately subsequent date, must have had some 
 great exemplar, and none more likely than this in a 
 building from which so much has been copied and 
 repeated in all directions. This mode of composing 
 the subject of the Majesty is found in mosaic in the 
 church of S. Vitale at Ravenna, which was built after 
 the model of Santa Sophia and ornamented by the same 
 school of mosaicists. It is found also at Rome over 
 the great arch of the basilica of San Lorenzo, dating 
 from a few years only after Santa Sophia, and in the apse 
 of St. Theodore, and in the seventh century mosaic 
 work of the lateral apse of Santa Costanza, and in the 
 baptistery of San Giovanni at Florence in a mosaic by 
 Andrea Tafi, in the thirteenth century. It is also found 
 in other forms of art, such as in Byzantine, ivory carv- 
 
 1 Du Cange's Historia Byzantina, book iii., page 30, edition 1680. 
 " In interiore Tholi, seu ut vocant Trulli, centre ac Testitudine, Justinia- 
 nus opere musivo Christum in iride sedentem orbis judicantis effigie, 
 describi curavit ut avroirrai testantur." " In the inner central part and 
 dome of the cupola, or as they call it, Trullus, Justinian caused to be 
 represented in mosaic work Christ within a rainbow seated after the 
 fashion of one judging the world, as the very eye-witnesses testify." 
 
174 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 ing, 1 where the figure is seated on a globe covered with 
 stars, and it was painted by the Giottesque Cavallini in 
 the apse of S. Georgio in Velabro at Rome, in the 
 place of a previously existing mosaic. Many single 
 figures, including all the authors of both the Old and 
 New Testaments, are spread about upon the flat and 
 arched surfaces, but the only important subject visible 
 at the time the interior was being cleaned and repaired 
 in I 847, and of which a coloured drawing was taken, 2 
 is that of Pentecost, which covers one of the domes of 
 the women's aisle, on the south side. The breadth and 
 grandeur of its composition affords some idea of what 
 the whole interior must have originally displayed. In 
 the crown of this dome Christ sits enthroned with the 
 blue of heaven around Him, enclosed within a broad 
 aureole of gold. From His figure proceed twelve white 
 rays which fall on the heads of the apostles standing 
 around below, and groups of the first Christian disciples 
 fill the four angular spaces from which the cupola 
 springs. As a complete subject it is unique. The best 
 known work in this grand church is that in the 
 narthex, which is one of the finest existing mosaics, 
 exhibiting the typal composition of the Majesty, 
 followed in all succeeding ages from that to the present, 
 in every form of art throughout all Christendom. It is 
 in the lunette over the king's entrance, where on a gold 
 ground the figure of Christ sits on a jewelled throne, 
 in the attitude of blessing with the right hand and hold- 
 ing a book in the left, bearing the inscription on its open 
 pages, " Peace to you, I am the Light of the world." 
 Right and left are circular medallions containing busts 
 of the blessed Virgin and St. Michael, and on the pave- 
 ment at Christ's feet Justinian crowned prostrates him- 
 
 1 A Byzantine ivory plaque, in the Soltikoff collection figured in 
 Labarte's Moyen Age, vol. i. p. 46. 
 
 2 Saltzenberg, Alt. Christ liche . . . von Constant inopeL Berlin, 1854. 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 175 
 
 self. Such are shortly the main features of mosaic art 
 at Santa Sophia, the architectural type of all succeed- 
 ing Christian churches and Mahomedan mosques of the 
 East. 
 
 But it is not only in such sites of wealth and 
 government that important works of this art are still 
 to be found. At the foot of Mount Sinai, where 
 tradition assigns the first building to the time of the 
 apostles, 1 in the present church, 2 built, and with its 
 monastery endowed and fortified by Justinian, the 
 eastern wall, arch, and apse are covered with con- 
 temporary mosaics from designs adapted to the peculiar 
 interest of the surrounding associations. The church 
 of the monastery, in the wild open desert, the most 
 isolated in the world, with the grand, triple-headed 
 Mount Sinai rising above it, is dedicated to St. 
 Catherine ; and over the semicircular vault of the 
 bema in which the relics of the saint are preserved, on 
 the wall high up toward the left, the figure of Moses is 
 represented kneeling before the burning bush ; on the 
 right side he stands, having just received the two tables 
 in his hands, a light breaking forth from above, with 
 its rays falling upon him. All detail in these pictures 
 has been obscured by the smoke of the altar candles, 
 accumulated upon them for many centuries ; but suffi- 
 cient can be seen to show that the subject of the 
 Transfiguration fills the vault of the bema. The figure 
 of Christ, with his hands joined upon his breast, stands 
 within an oval aureole, occupying the centre, with those 
 of Moses and Elias, also standing and in the attitude 
 of benediction. On the right and left, separated from 
 these on each side, and within circular medallions, are 
 the portraits of Justinian and Theodora ; and the 
 composition is completed by a series of heads within 
 
 1 Neale's Holy Eastern Church, vol. i. 
 
 2 Voyage de i? Arable Petrce, Leon de Laborde. 
 
1 76 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 circular borders, representing the apostles and the chief 
 functionaries of the monastery at the time of its estab- 
 lishment, viz. " the very saintly priest " Longinus and 
 Hugomenos, the name of each being inlaid by every 
 figure. The inscription, beginning with the invocation 
 of the Holy Trinity (not forgetting Mount Sinai here), 
 forms the base line of the whole, supported by the 
 busts of all the prophets of the Old Testament. 
 
 Wanting in the peculiar interest of so sacred a site, 
 but interesting and important in their several associa- 
 tions, a great part of the works which that age pro- 
 duced in the important cities of Thessalonica, Trebizond, 
 and Ravenna still remain for our admiration. In the 
 two first-named places there are churches dating cer- 
 tainly from the time of Constantine, even if not earlier, 
 and there are mosaics earlier than the reign of Justinian ; 
 but in the principal of those which remain it is evident 
 that the artists followed the style of the masterpieces 
 of Constantinople. They planned no great pictures, 
 nor cared for dramatic action nor historic subject, but 
 peopled their vast golden surfaces of cupola and wall 
 with single figures, each, in his own individual capacity, 
 taking part in some great event ; as in the dome of Sa. 
 Sophia at Thessalonica, where, in a double row, the 
 apostles with the blessed Virgin, in the early Christian 
 attitude of prayer, with two angels beside her, stand, as 
 in awe and adoration, witnessing the ascension of Christ, 
 below whose figure and the flying angels supporting 
 the vesica which surrounded it, is inlaid the text, 
 " Ye men of Galilee, why stand ye here gazing up into 
 heaven ?" The central figure, with the exception of 
 the feet, has been blotted out and covered with an 
 Arabic text ; and, indeed, in most places Mahomedan 
 paint or plaster has hidden the principal figures of 
 Christian iconography. 
 
 The church of St. George, a round church in the 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 177 
 
 same place, has a very different design in its cupola. 
 We see there the architectural background of a sanc- 
 tuary, with columns, round arches under pediments, 
 and partly closed by looped-up curtains, in front of 
 which stand single figures of ecclesiastics splendidly 
 vested, with their names above them of Saints who 
 died before the time of Constantine a subject of 
 gorgeous effect, but better suited for a wall than for a 
 cupola. 
 
 At Trebizond the fine churches of St. Mary and 
 Sa. Sophia, rich with mosaics and paintings, have been 
 with rare exception covered with whitewash ; but the 
 floor of Sa. Sophia is famous for its mosaic pavement 
 of the kind known as Opus Grecanicum, 1 which is 
 an enriched modification of the Roman Opus Alexand- 
 rinum, varied with slabs of sectile marble, and richly 
 inlaid, as on the floors of St. Mark's at Venice, St. 
 Lorenzo and Sa. Maria in Trastevere at Rome, Sa. 
 Sophia at Constantinople, and many other places, pre- 
 eminently here at Trebizond. 
 
 The buildings and mosaics at Ravenna are too well 
 known, and their story has been too well told, to need 
 repetition ; but the great artistic features which charac- 
 terise them must not be passed without a word. They 
 surprise us indeed by their extent and their technical 
 excellence ; but the qualities which at once command 
 our admiration are the grandeur of idea which prevailed 
 throughout and inspired their compositions, the sincerity 
 of their enthusiasm, and an architectonic sense, applying 
 
 1 The so-called Opus Grecanicum, as it is commonly found in Italy, 
 derives great brilliancy from its consisting of coloured marbles set in a 
 white ground, the white marble slabs of the pavement being cut out at a very 
 slight depth according to the pattern required, with marbles and sometimes 
 glass mosaic set in the grooves thus obtained. In this manner also screens, 
 walls, pulpits, and shrines were decorated in mosaic by the famous school 
 of the Cosmati. But Pliny, Ixxxvi. ch. 35, describes as "genus Pavimenti 
 Grecanici " an inlaid floor of porphyry and serpentine, which is the essen- 
 tial composition, viz. of purple and green, of the Opus Alexandrinum. 
 
 N 
 
1 78 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 ornament and pictorial design with complete mastery to 
 the forms and effects of architecture. The want of variety 
 in the figures, which form the two long series on the walls 
 of S. Apollinare Nuovo, may be evident to all eyes ; 
 but the quiet and stately expression of those dignified 
 figures, following in procession with their crowns in 
 their hands, on one side from the old seaport town of 
 Classe, and on the other from the palace attributed to 
 Theodoric, taken all together as a mode of covering such 
 a wall with an appropriate sacred subject, are worthy of 
 all admiration. On one side male saints and martyrs 
 are conducted to the feet of Christ by the first martyr, 
 St. Stephen. 1 On the other side a procession of female 
 saints in a long row, each with her name above her, 
 approach, not, as too commonly and carelessly described, 
 to the adoration of the blessed Virgin, but, as they 
 are there depicted, following the lead of the three Magi, 
 who bow before the divine Child seated on her knees, 
 and represented in the attitude of blessing, to receive 
 the gifts they present a subject as old as the art of 
 early Roman catacombs. 
 
 The Christian Greek artists delighted in the poetry 
 of symbolic expression, and have so filled our minds 
 with it through their works, that we are apt to pass it 
 by as a matter of course, and to ignore the interest of 
 its original production. The art of their classic ances- 
 tors had been constantly enlivened by allusion and 
 emblem, but there was in it no source or motive for 
 such depth of sentiment and awe of expression as the 
 sublime realities of the Christian revelation produced 
 on those who had the handling of its subjects in the 
 forms of fine art. The mosaics of Rome and Ravenna 
 that are traceable to Byzantine artists, or to those 
 influenced by them, are rich in this mode of devotional 
 
 1 Originally so, but that figure has been lost and clumsily substituted 
 by an angel. 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 179 
 
 expression, as in the church of SS. Cosmo and Damian 
 at Rome, already described, and pre-eminently at 
 Ravenna, among many works which are extant there. 
 
 The most remarkable and complete example of 
 this mode of treatment is the subject of the Transfigura- 
 tion in the apse of the church of S. Apollinare in 
 Classe (A.D. 567), where in place of the figure of Christ 
 stands the cross alone, richly jewelled, with the head of 
 Christ set as a medallion in the centre of it, and the 
 half figures of Moses and Elias rising from clouds on 
 either side. Above the cross are inlaid in capital 
 letters the word 'IX0T2, representing here the initial 
 letters of the Greek words for " Jesus Christ the Son of 
 God the Saviour." Beneath the cross, where the figures 
 of the three witnessing disciples are usually grouped, 
 are three sheep looking upward to the cross ; and below 
 them stands the patron of the church, S. Apollinare, 
 with his arms extended, and sheep on his right and 
 left, on a foreground of grass and lilies. The scheme 
 of the whole work is completed on the wall above the 
 apse by another medallion head of Christ, supported 
 by the symbolic figures of the evangelists, and sheep 
 on either side proceeding toward Him from Bethlehem 
 and Jerusalem, the two cities "consecrated by their 
 associations with His birth and death." 
 
 Totally different from these, but equally and entirely 
 symbolic in their treatment, are the two mosaic pictures 
 representing the Eucharist, one of which is in the choir 
 of San Vitale, where Melchisedech, supported on the 
 right and left by Moses and Isaiah, is seen standing 
 before an altar on which are two loaves and a chalice ; 
 and in a similar place in the church of S. Apollinare 
 in Classe the subject is even more complete, where the 
 figure of Melchisedech at the altar is supported on one 
 side by Abel holding in his arms a lamb, as though 
 presenting it before the altar, and on the other 
 
i8o THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESS AT 
 
 by Abraham leading forward Isaac with the same 
 significance. 
 
 These afford a good idea of the religious poetry of 
 the artists of those days. What was done in the time that 
 Theodoric was in possession is not accurately known, 
 beyond that of his having sent to Rome for marble 
 masons, among whom mosaicists were especially in- 
 cluded, 1 for his palace and the Arian cathedral and bap- 
 tistery begun by him ; but before his reign two important 
 works, which are still extant, had been completed for 
 the Empress Galla Placidia, one known as her mauso- 
 leum, the other as the orthodox baptistery, both richly 
 and beautifully clothed with mosaics. The mausoleum 
 is built upon the plan of a Greek cross, with a central 
 dome in which are represented the starry heavens, and 
 a golden cross at the summit, and enriched all about 
 the arches and spandrels with other figures natural and 
 emblematic. But this chapel is most famous for that 
 symbolic figure of Our Lord so loved and so often 
 repeated by the early Christians the Good Shepherd. 
 He is here represented amid a rocky landscape, seated 
 
 1 Letter of King Theodoric to Agapetus, " Pnefectus Urbis " (this 
 letter has been commonly cited as addressed to Pope Agapetus, but there 
 was no pope of that name till 535, nine years after Theodoric's death) 
 " I am going to build a great Basilica of Hercules at Ravenna, for I wish 
 my age to match preceding ones in the beauty of its buildings as it does 
 in the happiness of the lives of my subjects. Send me, therefore, skilful 
 workers in Mosaic." 
 
 Cassiodorus was private secretary, "comes rerum privatarum," and 
 chancellor to Theodoric, who reigned as King of Italy in Ravenna from 
 A.D. 493 to 526. The letter quoted above is one of the king's letters 
 preserved by him, but the opinion about the art of mosaic from a man 
 of his high accomplishments may interest the reader. He writes thus, 
 " Send us from your city some of your most skilful marble workers, who 
 may join together those pieces which have been exquisitely divided, and 
 connecting together their exquisite veins of colour, may admirably repre- 
 sent the natural appearance. From art proceeds this gift which conquers 
 Nature. And thus the discoloured surface of the marble is woven into 
 the loveliest variety of pictures ; the value of the work now as always being 
 increased by the minute labour which has to be expended on the produc- 
 tion of the Beautiful." (Letters of Cassiodorus, Hodgkin, p. 147. Lon- 
 don, 1886.) 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 181 
 
 and with sheep around him, one of which He stoops 
 to caress, and with the other hand He holds a cross. 
 The figure is classic in the gracefulness of its attitude, 
 and beautiful also in the harmony of its colouring. 
 Indeed, whether in design, colour, or expression, it is 
 the most impressive representation of this lovely sub- 
 ject in early Christian art. 
 
 The artists at Ravenna were, however, as successful 
 in representing historic and dramatic subjects as the 
 mystic and ideal. Of that kind the two great pictures 
 of Justinian and Theodora, surrounded by their courtly 
 attendants at the consecration of the church of S. 
 Vitale, are well-known examples, valuable for portraiture, 
 costume, and historical incident. But after that time 
 the arts at Ravenna soon came to their close, and as the 
 capital of the Exarchate its glory was short-lived. At 
 headquarters intrigue, crime, and disaster desolated 
 Constantinople ; and Ravenna itself shared in the 
 troubles of the age, changing its masters rapidly from 
 the empire to the Lombards, from them to the Franks, 
 and at last to the see of Rome ; and little more than 
 two centuries after its finest works had been completed, 
 a shadow fell" on it, as on those that are out of sight 
 and out of mind, and its disregarded mosaics were 
 robbed with the sanction of its absent rulers. 
 
 The gloom of a dark age had settled upon Europe. 
 The world was at war, and gave no heed to the arts of 
 peace. The East was in confusion, and Rome had been 
 handed over to the care, civil, military, and diplomatic, 
 of those whose office was founded, and whose educa- 
 tion had trained them, for other than mundane affairs, 
 and the result was inevitable ruin. But the time of the 
 North had come, and the genius of Charlemagne was 
 consolidating an empire on the Rhine. As politician, 
 soldier, and churchman, he was the equal of the best, 
 and superior to them all in courage, grasp, and will. 
 
1 82 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 He felt and acted on the truth of the adage about art 
 that he may have never heard, "emollit mores"; and 
 into no subject of all that home and foreign difficulties 
 forced upon him, did he act with more energy than for 
 the introduction of civilising arts among his turbulent 
 and even barbarous subjects. Fixing the northern 
 centre of empire at Aquis Grani (Aix la Chapelle), the 
 place of invaluably healing springs, the first appendage 
 to his palace was a cathedral. He knew from his 
 southern experience what art was, and he sent there for 
 his workmen and his artists ; but whatever their nation- 
 ality may have been, their art was Byzantine. He 
 wanted mosaic for his palace and his church ; but it 
 was an art that for two hundred years the Romans had 
 found no zest nor heart to cultivate. Time pressed, and 
 materials must be found ready to his hand, so Ravenna 
 was pillaged with licensed robbery. 1 With the written 
 authority of Pope Adrian the First, the tesserae were 
 stripped from the walls and the marbles from the pave- 
 ments, and the cathedral at Aix was clothed with their 
 stolen glories. Pictures of sacred subjects were thus 
 executed on its walls, and upon the cupola was dis- 
 played the subject of Christ enthroned with the elders 
 casting their crowns before Him, a fine choice of sub- 
 ject as the first tribute of art to religion by the first 
 Christian emperor of the north ; but no part of these 
 works remain ; and only a bad engraving preserves a 
 tradition of the subject of that cupola. 2 
 
 Little is known of the immediate results of this intro- 
 duction of the arts into Northern Germany ; but scattered 
 notices of its continuance come from Cologne, Lyons, 
 
 1 Letters of Pope Adrian the First are preserved in the Vatican. In 
 one answering the application of Charlemagne, the Pope writes thus : 
 " Carolo Regi musiva et marmora urbis Ravennoe, tarn in Templis quam 
 in Parietibus et stratis sita sicut petierat donat. " In another letter 
 similar words conclude, " vobis concedimus auferanda." 
 
 2 Ciampini, Vetera Man., in loco., and Barbier de Montault, Die 
 Mosaiken irn Miinster zu Aachen. 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 183 
 
 Hildesheim, and the convent of Centula in Picardy, 
 where the abbot, a friend of Charlemagne, availed him- 
 self of the artists introduced by the emperor ; and here 
 and there a few relics of the art are preserved, as at 
 Germigny des Pres in Loiret, faint reflections of the 
 light that had gleamed and died away at Aix. 
 
 The only really fine work of that century (about 
 835-40) was one executed in the interesting church of S. 
 Ambrogio at Milan, in which is perpetuated by mosaic 
 the story of the saint having fallen asleep during the 
 performance of mass there, and dreaming of the death 
 of S. Martin of Tours, which occurred at that time. 
 The upper part of the composition exhibits the figure 
 of Christ in glory with flying figures of archangels, and 
 below them saints standing on either side. It was 
 about the same time that the first mosaic was intro- 
 duced at Venice, in the church of S. Margaret, long 
 since lost. 1 
 
 In the East all record of the arts of this age are 
 hidden beneath the mists of troubled earth and heaven. 
 Mahomedan victories prevailed far and wide, and 
 mosques were rising with costly magnificence ; and as 
 mosaic was admirably adapted for their arabesque orna- 
 ment, it is not surprising to hear that at the con- 
 clusion of peace at Constantinople, the Caliph Walid 
 stipulated for a contribution of a quantity of mosaic 
 tesserae for his mosque at Damascus ; and again, two 
 hundred years later, we learn that Romanus II. pre- 
 sented to the Caliph Abderraman glass tesserae for the 
 
 1 In a general sketch of this very wide subject, the writer trusts his 
 readers will perceive how impossible it would be to refer to any more 
 than representative examples of this art, without disturbing the course of 
 general interest, wearying the reader with descriptions, and producing a 
 result more like a catalogue than a history. He therefore somewhat un- 
 willingly omits reference to many examples belonging to the Christian era 
 in France, Germany, and Italy, and confines description to such as are 
 not intimately known, or possess some speciality that has not been suffi- 
 ciently noticed. 
 
184 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 kibla of his mosque at Cordova. Thus the art dragged 
 on a faint existence beneath the shadows of a dark age. 
 Monastic seclusion afforded its safest retreat, where a 
 few quiet men in the quiet places of the earth kept up 
 its life ; and it was thus among the inaccessible shrines 
 of Mount Athos that the best artists found their home 
 and the safest deposit of their art's traditions. 
 
 It was about the year i ooo A.D. that the first dawn 
 of reviving art in Europe appeared at the court of the 
 successors of Charlemagne at Aix, and with it the first 
 hopes of civilising influences. Such was the condition 
 of life, even in the highest circles of the court and 
 nobility at that age, as the pages of painful history 
 have but too vividly pictured, that if there was indeed 
 a dawn of a more genial age, it was but a sad one, for its 
 sun had risen in deepest mists that would lift only after 
 long waiting for the day. In the time of the young 
 Emperor Otho the Third, his mother, the widow empress 
 and regent of the empire, who was a Greek, invited 
 from her native land men skilled in various arts, to 
 pick up any traditions that Charlemagne's artists had 
 left, and to introduce some cultivation among her rude 
 people. The cathedral of Hildesheim again possessed 
 an energetic bishop, Bernward by name, the young 
 emperor's tutor, who is credited by his biographer with 
 having added mosaics to the adornment of his church, 
 and as having worked at them with his own hands. 1 
 He also enumerates the subjects represented, but with 
 insufficient accuracy about their method ; but at any 
 rate an inference in favour of their having been executed 
 in true mosaic is fair, from that art being intimately 
 connected with those of glass making and enamelling, 
 about the introduction of which by those very Greeks, 
 and with wide ultimate effect, there is ample evidence. 
 
 1 " Musivum . . . propria industria, nullo mostrante composuit." 
 Taiigmar Chronicle. 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 185 
 
 It was full half a century later that a similar age of 
 revival dawned in Italy, where the day broke more 
 quickly, for there was more sun to brighten it and more 
 aptitude in the people. It was due to the impressions 
 received in Constantinople by the cardinal abbot of 
 Monte Cassino when there on a diplomatic service 
 between the pope and the emperor, that on returning 
 to his home, the contrast of its cheerless walls with 
 what the buildings of the East had presented to him 
 called into activity the taste that these had aroused. 
 His biographer describes art as dead in Italy : so to 
 the East again the appeal was made ; and under the 
 abbot's spirited influence the Greeks, established at 
 Monte Cassino, initiated those schools of many arts to 
 which Italy mainly owes the education of her reviving 
 genius. 
 
 It was a few years later that the first mosaics were 
 begun in St. Mark's at Venice, of which some, with 
 happier fate than those at Monte Cassino, still remain 
 as precious reflections of the first gladdening rays of 
 light in that new morning of art and civilisation. 
 
 The life thus regained by art was real. For three 
 centuries no mosaic had been executed at Rome ; but 
 now the age was startled by its sudden reappearance 
 on the walls of one that was then, and still is, among 
 the grandest of its churches, Sa. Maria in Trastevere 
 (A.D. 1 130-43). Its fagade and the wall of its apse are 
 covered with elaborate works to which age only adds 
 to that respect and interest which their own time ac- 
 corded to them. The principal subject on the exterior is 
 that of the wise and foolish virgins, with the group of the 
 Infant Christ and His mother in their midst. The great 
 mosaic of the interior is, in spite of all the peculiarities 
 of its antique style, magnificent. It exhibits a scene 
 of celestial glory, which is commonly described as the 
 coronation of the blessed Virgin. Such might for mani- 
 
i86 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 fest reasons be expected, but its own account of itself 
 is otherwise. At the base of the composition is the 
 flock of twelve sheep, much as they are seen in other 
 mosaics right and left of the Lamb on the mount, from 
 which flow the four rivers of Paradise. Above is a 
 single range of figures, the evident work of original 
 genius inspired by the traditions of the Greek school, 
 but with power to throw its own free life into its work, 
 and make it all Italian. The scene represented is 
 Christ seated on His throne, which is rich with drapery 
 and jewelry, and with figures of saints standing on 
 either side, St. Peter being the nearest on His left. On 
 the same throne is seated a female figure designed with 
 great grace and beauty, her features and expression 
 being those of youth, with her braided hair falling 
 behind her shoulders, so richly jewelled as to look like 
 a wreath of gems ; a nimbus is round her head, and 
 her dress is splendid with embroidery and jewels. 
 There is no crown on her head, nor is she bending to 
 receive one as in all the subjects of her coronation. 
 Our Lord is seated by her side holding an open book, 
 and instead of a posture of respect and honour, as 
 though crowning or enthroning His mother, He is repre- 
 sented in the attitude of familiar affection, embracing 
 her neck and laying His hand upon her opposite shoulder. 
 The subject is plain, but still plainer as described by 
 itself, for the scroll held open by both her hands and 
 the book held by Christ, are inlaid with parts of texts 
 from the Song of Solomon about the Bride and Bride- 
 groom, descriptive of such a scene as the artist has 
 here delineated, " His left hand is under my head and 
 His right hand doth embrace me," and, on the open 
 book, " Come, my chosen one, and I will place thee on 
 my throne," " electa " being used for " dilecta " in the 
 quotation, " Come, my beloved," etc., from which the 
 inscription is paraphrased. This great picture is just 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 187 
 
 such as an artist, designing in the completest but 
 simple manner compatible with the art of that time, 
 would have composed it if inspired by the words in 
 the book of the Revelation of St. John, " The marriage 
 of the Lamb is come, and His wife had made her- 
 self ready," and " Come hither, I will show thee the 
 bride, the Lamb's wife" (Rev. xxi. 19). This subject 
 was well known to art at and before that time, as illus- 
 trated in MS. illuminations, where Christ is seated, as 
 in this mosaic, on His throne with a female figure 
 crowned and by his side, and the meaning of the group 
 made clear by the inscribed words, " Jesus et Ecclesia," 
 and in another case, "Jesus Christus et Ecclesia sua." 
 
 Whatever interpretation may be given to this great 
 mosaic, it most certainly is not that of the " Coronation 
 of the Virgin." That subject, represented by the blessed 
 Virgin being crowned by the hand of Christ as the Queen 
 of Heaven, had not yet been known in art. In this case 
 there is no crown ; but a crowned figure thus seated 
 would not necessarily be that of His mother, for as such 
 it was already known and written as " Ecclesia." The 
 peculiar alteration of the word " dilecta," " beloved " 
 (which might apply to both), into the word " electa " 
 suggests a special purpose, and designates the figure in 
 this mosaic as the representative of His " elect," that 
 is to say, His Church, His Bride. She is represented 
 in that bridal song of Holy Writ, the Song of Solomon, 
 as we see her here, beautiful ; and in the triumphant 
 language of the 45th Psalm, the same figure appears 
 in the glorification of God's elect, poetically personified 
 as " the King's daughter," and as " a Queen in a vesture 
 of gold wrought about with divers colours," and de- 
 scribed as being " brought to the King, . . . with 
 joy and gladness . . . and shall enter into the King's 
 palace." " Thy throne, O God, endureth for ever." 
 This grand subject of the triumph or glorification of 
 
i88 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 the Church appears to have been the original idea and 
 composition, from which the splendid illustrations of 
 the Coronation of the Virgin, in every form of art, were 
 ultimately developed, as the subject itself developed in 
 the twelfth and subsequent centuries. 1 
 
 The introduction of the figure of Ecclesia was well 
 illustrated in a mosaic of the same period, viz. about 
 A.D. 1210, with which Pope Innocent III. adorned the 
 tribune of the basilica of St. Peter at Rome, and of 
 which Ciampini has given an engraving from a painted 
 copy taken at the time of the demolition of the ancient 
 Church. The subject of it was extensive and gave 
 evidence of the influence of Greek artists still at Rome, 
 the Saviour being represented in the Greek attitude of 
 benediction ; but the only purpose for which this 
 mosaic is referred to here is from its comprising a 
 figure of Ecclesia which is found in the remarkable 
 group of the Pope and " the Church " (as a female 
 crowned figure) standing on the right and left of the 
 symbolic Lamb, in the midst of the company of dis- 
 ciples, who are here as elsewhere symbolised by sheep 
 approaching this group from each side. The grand 
 female figures representing the Christian and Jewish 
 Churches in a mosaic of the fifth century in the church 
 of Santa Sabina at Rome are well known as among 
 the finest specimens of art that remain of that date 
 (A.D. 424), recalling the style of the antique in propor- 
 tion and design. These representatives of the two 
 churches are distinguished by inscriptions, and, before 
 the greater part of the composition to which they 
 
 1 The misstatements and misrepresentations of this mosaic as that of 
 the Coronation of the Virgin have been corrected by the inexorable truth 
 of photography. In the engravings of it the female figure is crowned 
 magnificently. Among others, in Mrs. Jameson's Legend of the Madonna 
 at page 16, where the figure is called " 1'incoronata, " she is so crowned, 
 evidently copied from an Italian engraving; and among Mr. Parker's 
 photographs of Roman mosaics in the art library at S. Kensington is 
 another engraving or etching where the figure is similarly misrepresented. 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 189 
 
 belong was destroyed in the seventeenth century, their 
 attendant apostles stood above them, that of the Christian 
 Church " Ecclesia ex gentibus " being thus accompanied 
 by St. Paul, and the " Ecclesia ex circumcisione " by St. 
 Peter. 1 
 
 The personification of the Church as the bride of 
 Christ, sometimes crowned, sometimes enthroned, alone 
 or contrasted with the figure of the Jewish Church, and 
 often in connection with the subject of the crucifixion, 
 is common throughout early and mediaeval art ; but as 
 the illustrative examples of it that I would venture to 
 give are not in mosaic, I defer them to another place. 2 
 
 As mosaic pictures of historical subjects, distinct 
 from scriptural or legendary, are at this period very 
 rare, those which in St. Mark's at Venice occupy a 
 large space in the south transept are all the more 
 valuable, and interesting also from the story which they 
 illustrate. The subject of them is the consecration of 
 the present Church in 1085. These two pictures are 
 curiosities of design, without pretence of detail or pro- 
 portion, giving a complete idea of the interior, by the 
 simple scheme of an architectural section showing one 
 side of the choir and nave in their earliest condition, 
 and the insides of the half-domes of the five cupolas 
 with their crosses and the sky above them. But the 
 special interest in these pictures is the account which 
 they preserve of an event of the utmost importance to 
 the subsequent fortunes of this Church, viz. the dis- 
 covery (the " invention ") of the relics of St. Mark. 
 The first in order of the two represents the ceremony 
 of the consecration. The bishop is officiating at the 
 altar beneath a canopy of twisted shafts with golden 
 capitals supporting a vault of blue mosaic framed in 
 
 1 These are shown in Ciampini's engraving in his Vetera Monumenta, 
 in loco. 
 
 2 Essay on "The Adornment of Sacred Buildings," Part II. 
 
190 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 gilt metal work. He is richly vested in a purple cope, 
 clasped on his breast with a morse of inlaid jewels ; 
 behind him, within a choir distinguished by a low white 
 screen wall, a number of bishops in various coloured 
 copes and of inferior clergy in white, prostrate them- 
 selves to the ground ; and beyond them stands the 
 dignified figure of Doge Vital Falier in rapt attention 
 and reverential attitude, followed by members of his 
 council, like himself bowing before the altar. He wears 
 a tall brown cap with jewelled bands, and a rich dress 
 of green with gold borders, and a cloak of gold tissue, 
 as his figure in the next picture shows it, lined with 
 fur. The nave of the church is crowded with laity, the 
 men grouped first, the women toward the west. But 
 all this was but the preparation for the great event of 
 the day, which cannot be better described than by 
 Corner, as quoted in The Stones of Venice}' But to 
 appreciate this it must be remembered that the original 
 church in which the relics of St. Mark were enshrined 
 was burnt down in 976 and rebuilt and reconsecrated 
 in 1085, an interval of above a century, when such con- 
 fusion existed as can alone account for the relics of St. 
 Mark being lost, in fact destroyed by the fire, because 
 it needed a miracle to restore them. Flaminio Corner 2 
 thus describes the scene 
 
 " After the repairs undertaken by the Doge Orseolo, 
 the place in which the body of the holy evangelist 
 rested had been altogether forgotten ; so that the Doge 
 Vital Falier was entirely ignorant of the place of the 
 venerable deposit. This was no light affliction, not 
 only to the pious Doge but to all the citizens and 
 people, so that at last, moved by confidence in the 
 divine mercy, they determined to implore, with prayer 
 and fasting, the manifestation of so great a treasure, 
 
 1 Vol. ii. page 60. 
 
 2 F. Corner, Notizie Storiche delle Chiese di Venezia. 1758. 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 191 
 
 which did not now depend upon any human effort. A 
 general fast being therefrom proclaimed and a solemn 
 procession being appointed for the 25th of June, while 
 the people assembled in the church interceded with 
 God in fervent prayers for the desired boon, they 
 beheld, with as much amazement as joy, a slight 
 shaking in the marbles of a pillar, near the place where 
 the altar of the cross is now, which, presently falling to 
 the earth, exposed to the view of the rejoicing people 
 the chest of bronze in which the body of the evangelist 
 was laid." 
 
 The second picture, to the right, represents what 
 those words describe. The doors of the nave are 
 thrown open, and a procession headed by the bishop 
 in the attitude of prayer approaches the wonder of the 
 day. A white marble pier has broken asunder in the 
 midst, and has exposed a recess in which the relics lie. 
 The Doge, with hands raised as in prayer, and a group 
 of his council follow, and behind them come the citizens, 
 men first then women and children, in attitudes ex- 
 pressive of astonishment and reverence. Such is the 
 foundation of the faith in the present relics of St. Mark. 
 The pictures are valuable also for their illustration of 
 the costume and manners of the day, and of the charac- 
 ter of the marble and gold mosaic of the architecture. 
 
 The art thus revived soon broke out into a chorus 
 of fine works from east to west. In the east the 
 interior of Coristantine's basilica of the Nativity at 
 Bethlehem was clothed with sacred subjects for the 
 Emperor Manuel Comnenus in the middle of the 
 twelfth century, by the mosaicist, Ephrem, those of the 
 choir relating to Christ's infancy, those in the nave to 
 the general history of His career. In the west, in 
 Sicily, under Norman rule, some of the finest works of 
 the age were produced, even to profusion, at Cefalu, at 
 Palermo, and in the basilica at Monreale which crowns 
 
192 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 the valley golden with orange gardens above that city. 
 These mosaics are such in quantity and quality as no 
 description could adequately portray. They owe their 
 extent and richness to the devotion of two Norman 
 sovereigns, Roger the Second during the first half of 
 the twelfth century, and William the Good immediately 
 after him. Those at Cefalu are much ruined, but were 
 the most refined of them all, executed by direction of 
 King Roger in 1148. Those of the Capella Palatina 
 are second only to these, and illustrate well the art as 
 attained by the united Greek and native artists, of 
 which the numerous Greek and Latin inscriptions all 
 over the building give evidence. 
 
 The subjects with which the nave, transepts, and 
 choir of the great basilica of Monreale are covered, 
 exhaust the principal incidents of sacred history. At 
 the extreme east a colossal bust of Christ, with the 
 typical group of the Virgin and Child beneath it, are the 
 culminating objects of its long vista ; and these with 
 ranks of single figures covering the sanctuary and 
 choir, all on gold and otherwise richly ornamented 
 grounds throughout, produce at once a dignity and 
 splendour of effect unsurpassed by any building of its 
 date. It has the great advantage of contemporaneous 
 works throughout its architecture and decoration, 
 securing to it the repose of unity which all the 
 splendour of its material and variety of ornament does 
 not disturb. The great size of the building has also 
 its share in the grandeur of effect ; and the whole is 
 well brought together and harmonised by the sober 
 richness of its inlaid marble floor. It lacks only one 
 great feature in which its neighbour the Capella Pala- 
 tina at Palermo and the unrivalled St. Mark's at Venice 
 surpass it, namely, a vaulted and mosaicked roof, for 
 here it is only of open timber illuminated with colours. 
 Irrespective of the artistic activity this great work dis- 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 193 
 
 plays, the amount of industry alone which it represents 
 is wonderful ; for mosaic compared with other modes 
 of painting is like the stippling of a miniature. Its 
 chronicler states that it was the work of 150 mosaicists 
 during three years. Among the accessories which con- 
 tribute to the completeness of the effect is the royal 
 throne in the choir, an imposing and sumptuous work 
 of mosaic, of the kind subsequently perfected by the 
 school of the Cosmati ; and above it on the south wall 
 a mosaic picture of Christ crowning " Rex Guilielmus," 
 the Norman " King William the Good," to whom this 
 great building owes its completion. Its style through- 
 out well represents the characteristics of its day, viz. 
 the transition from the trammels of Byzantine prescrip- 
 tion to freedom and originality. 
 
 But such freedom is not found everywhere at that 
 time ; there were few if any but Greeks and their 
 Italian pupils who practised this art, and although 
 they had been the safe keepers of the art's traditions, 
 their artists had fallen very low in its work. Venice 
 was then their principal resort in Italy, and even later, 
 for it was to Venice that the painter Tafi was sent in 
 1225 to obtain instruction and assistance for the work 
 the Florentines had commissioned him to execute in 
 mosaic in their baptistery. About half a century before 
 that time a great mosaic covered the western wall of 
 the cathedral of Torcello, the great cathedral of ancient 
 Venice, begun in the seventh century and completed in 
 1008, and now left desolate in that island of poetic 
 loneliness, with its baptistery and that little gem of 
 architecture, the church of Sa. Fosca, as the sole occu- 
 pants of that once crowded spot, where now the sigh- 
 ing of the wind about its reedy banks alone breaks the 
 silence of the lagoon. 
 
 The subjects of the Torcello mosaic are divided in 
 several compartments across the western wall. Of 
 
 O 
 
194 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 these the two highest contain the scenes of the cruci- 
 fixion and the descent to Hades, the three lower ones 
 representing on one side Paradise, and on the other, 
 with more than Dantesque horror, the terrible scenes of 
 hell. The execution of divine punishment is here 
 depicted by a stream of fire meandering among the 
 figures below the throne till it breaks out into flames 
 among the condemned in hell. The horrors of the 
 representation are such as rather to mar than to en- 
 hance the enjoyment which the opposite scenes of 
 Paradise are intended to convey. The land of the 
 blessed appears as a garden, with the tree of life at its 
 entrance and an angel guarding the gate. Abraham 
 sits in the midst of it, and outside St. John the Baptist 
 and St. Peter offer entrance to the saved, and St. John 
 the Evangelist and the Virgin welcome them, their 
 figures being invested with all the beauty the old artist 
 could express. 
 
 The mosaics of Murano, where the single figure of 
 the blessed Virgin with the Child in her arms stands 
 alone, beautiful and majestic, in the apse above the altar 
 of its old cathedral and those of Venice, are as well known 
 as those of Torcello are too commonly neglected and 
 ignored. Together they illustrate the whole history of 
 contemporary art. It had shown itself in its utter de- 
 cadence at St. Mark's, but it was now awaking to a 
 higher ideal, as that wondrous Duomo exhibits it in 
 every phase. The mosaics of the western and central 
 domes and the porch best illustrate the art of this date, 
 from the last years of the eleventh to the end of the 
 twelfth century. The subject of the western cupola, 
 which surmounts the nave, is Pentecost, and is most 
 effectively expressed by the rays of the symbolic dove 
 descending on the heads of the twelve apostles, while 
 below them, round the cupola, are groups of persons 
 representing separately, and with their names above 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 195 
 
 them, the many nations speaking those many tongues 
 with which the chosen twelve had been endowed. The 
 pendentives below are appropriately filled with colossal 
 figures of the four archangels. The cupola next beyond 
 it, over the cross of the transepts, has the glorious sub- 
 ject of the general benediction of Christ at his ascen- 
 sion, with attendant figures grouped all round beneath, 
 with the olive-tree of the Mount of Olives between 
 each of them ; and on the pendentives supporting the 
 dome the four evangelists are seated with the symbolic 
 figures of the four rivers of Paradise pouring out the 
 streams of the Gospel to the four quarters of the world. 
 
 The works of this period in the porch are exceed- 
 ingly numerous, including in their subjects the whole 
 history of the book of Genesis, and of the wandering of 
 the Israelites in the desert, mostly of great originality 
 in design, but rather to be seen than to be described. 
 
 In the early years of this renaissance a fashion had 
 widely prevailed north and south of the Alps of lavish- 
 ing work and material upon great pavements. South 
 of the Alps those at St. Mark's and Murano and 
 Palermo are the earliest. North of the Alps they are 
 also always called mosaics ; and no doubt in greater 
 part they were so, with large slabs of coloured marble 
 helping to cover space impossible for tesserae ; but many 
 of them and other such works of that age have 
 perished ; for there was an iconoclasm in the north-west 
 in the middle of the twelfth century, excited by the 
 spiritual enthusiasm of St. Bernard of Clairvault, to 
 whose denunciations, mistaking with reckless imparti- 
 ality the elements of education in a rude age for 
 elements of idolatry, the loss of many precious works 
 are traced. One at least of them which has been en- 
 tirely ruined was too grand a work to be passed without 
 record, namely, that of the great choir of St. Remi, at 
 Rheims. It was covered with a marble marquetry of 
 
196 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 real and symbolical subjects of great variety and refine- 
 ment, described by its chronicler as " representing an 
 infinity of figures as though drawn with the brush." 1 
 At the entrance of the choir lay a great figure of King 
 David playing his harp ; and beyond it numerous groups 
 arranged in large circles and squares, the nearest of 
 which had for its principal figure St. Jerome, with 
 prophets, evangelists, and saints around him, each dis- 
 tinguished by his name inlaid. The next compartment 
 contained figures pouring out water from their urns, 
 the original mode of symbolising the four rivers of 
 Paradise, and the dispersal of the four gospels over the 
 world ; and in the centre a woman riding on a dolphin 
 represented the earth and sea, the words " Terra" and 
 " Mare " being inscribed beside them. The next great 
 square was filled with scrolling foliage, and beyond it 
 another with impersonations of the four seasons ; and 
 by way of a pendent to the Terra and Mare was intro- 
 duced the figure of a man seated by a river, described 
 as " Orbis terrse," occupying the centre. The adjacent 
 compartment appears to have been a fine composition, 
 of which the figures representing the seven liberal arts 
 were the principal, and beyond them was an oblong 
 division enclosing large circles, in one case having 
 Moses seated in the centre with an angel standing on 
 his knee, and around him figures representing the 
 twelve months, the virtues, and the four points of the 
 compass, balanced in the other circle by the animals 
 representative of the constellations of the Great and 
 Little Bear surrounded by the twelve signs of the zodiac. 
 For the sanctuary and steps of the altar were reserved 
 the symbolic subjects of the sacrifice of Isaac, Jacob's 
 ladder, and others, the remaining parts of the floor 
 being inlaid with jasper and other precious marbles, 
 
 1 Berger, Histoire des grands Chemins, gives a long detailed account of 
 it, vide Annales Arc7uz, t vol. x. p. 6. 1850. 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 197 
 
 " set as jewels are set in rings." In front of the abbot's 
 chair was the figure of Wisdom, " Sapientia," thrusting a 
 pointed staff at Idleness, and Ignorance crouched at her 
 feet. Such was this great pavement at Rheims, a 
 wonder of its kind and of its age, executed in the last 
 years of the eleventh century, and an irreparable loss 
 for our own. To the same age, if not a little earlier, 
 belongs the pavement in the cathedral of Novara, which 
 was set in black and white, not so effective artistically, 
 but richer in the more exclusively religious subjects and 
 symbolism, including those of the Lamb among the 
 seven candlesticks, the pelican feeding its young, the 
 phoenix rising from the fire, the vine and the peacock, 
 the dove drinking from the chalice, and much else, an in- 
 teresting record of the feeling and art of its day, and, with 
 better fortune than that at Rheims, preserved to our time. 
 The large pavements of mosaic character in the 
 early middle ages, north of the Alps, were, however, of 
 such a style as is not to be entirely classed with 
 mosaics. So many have been destroyed that it is hard 
 to make sure from contemporary accounts exactly what 
 they were ; but by reasonable inferences they were less 
 of true mosaic, if indeed at all so in some cases, than of 
 inlaid pieces on the principle of what is known as 
 Florentine mosaic. Of this style, but in fictile work, 
 there is an interesting English example of the four- 
 teenth century on the floor of Prior Crawden's chapel 
 among the old buildings of St. Etheldreda's convent at 
 Ely. It occupies the altar pace. The subject of it is 
 the Fall, and the colours of its enamelled pieces remain 
 in parts sufficient to indicate its original condition. 
 Adam and Eve, the serpent and the tree, form the old 
 composition, the flatly-coloured forms being aided by 
 incised black lines. On each side the spaces are 
 covered, in the same kind of fictile inlay, with figures of 
 lions and geometrical patterns very variously coloured. 
 
198 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 But the attempt to include such work with mosaic 
 would lead to the interminable subject of " sectile " and 
 " tarsia," from the enamelled walls of the great mosque 
 at Ispahan, and of Omar at Jerusalem, to the inlaid 
 precious stones and marbles on the monuments of the 
 Taj Mahal, and of Itmud-ud-Doulah at Agra, and to 
 such floors as that of Siena Cathedral, where in " sectile 
 mosaic " of coloured marbles, great scriptural and 
 emblematic compositions cover the entire space of nave, 
 transepts, and choir, but indeed the subject would not 
 stop there, for such sectile work is as fine in other 
 material as marbles, and would range from the fine old 
 Roman work of "The Rape of Hylas" 1 inlaid in precious 
 stones, to the exquisite devices designed by young 
 Raphael, and executed in coloured woods in the churches 
 of Perugia. I venture therefore to omit all such and to 
 return to the works of the truer, i.e. tessellated, mosaic. 
 
 Among the favourite subjects of designs for pave- 
 ments were the labyrinth, the zodiac, and the calendar, 
 this last being usually treated much in the same way 
 as in MS. illuminations, with a ring of circles filled 
 with emblematic figures of the months engaged upon 
 their seasonable labours. At Aosta is a unique 
 example of this subject in which, with the twelve 
 months arranged in order all round, in the central 
 circle is seated on a throne a grand female figure of 
 " the year," plainly designated Annus, with a nimbus 
 round her head, and the sun and moon to the right 
 and left, a richly-coloured work of tessellated mosaic 
 of the close of the eleventh century. 2 
 
 1 Two fine examples of sectile mosaic were found in the hall or basilica 
 of Junius Bassus (consul, A.D. 317), one the Rape of Hylas, the other a 
 group of a consul or other Roman official in a chariot with mounted 
 attendants, etc. Vide Ciampini, Vet. Mon. Mosaic, in loco, and an 
 elaborate article on them and sectile mosaic generally, by Mr. Alex. 
 Nesbitt, Archaologia, vol. 45. 
 
 2 Annales Archaologiques, t. xvii. for 1837, in which coloured engrav- 
 ings of this and another mosaic in the same place are given. 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 199 
 
 The labyrinth is archaeologically too large a subject 
 to be treated here, but in relation to mosaic it forms 
 quite an important feature, and ranges in every variety 
 of character from the inlaid floor, where for penitential 
 purposes its intricacies were threaded sometimes on the 
 feet, sometimes on the knees, and sometimes with the 
 fingers, as in the labyrinth engraved upon one of the 
 piers of the porch of the cathedral at Lucca, to others 
 where it was merely used as an ornamental device and 
 often richly coloured in marble, enamelled tiles and 
 mosaic in classic and Christian art, varying in style 
 from those on the old Roman floors of Bignor in 
 England, and at Caerleon in Wales, to the mediaeval 
 pavement inlaid in black and white under the western 
 tower of Ely Cathedral. 
 
 The associations of ancient and mediaeval art were 
 singularly brought together by these labyrinths, as 
 those of the Roman mosaic at Salzburg and the 
 Christian example at Chartres are sufficient to illus- 
 trate, where in each case the centres were originally 
 occupied by the classic fable of Theseus slaying the 
 Minotaur in the famous labyrinth in Crete, which 
 certainly in Christian art, and very probably in Pagan, 
 symbolised the heroism of self-devotion overcoming evil. 
 The passages of the Christian labyrinth were sometimes 
 engraved with the verses of the Miserere for repetition 
 by the penitents as they followed the track, and for 
 all others their moral was to " represent the difficult 
 ways of life, before arriving at celestial rest." In the 
 ancient basilica at Orleansville in Algeria, founded as 
 early as A.D. 328, the Church, " Sancta Ecclesia," is 
 written in mosaic in the centre of the labyrinth, as the 
 haven of the soul's rest, with pathways sometimes 
 approaching, sometimes diverging from it, as in the 
 waywardness of life. Every century till the close of 
 the fourteenth, affords examples of pavements orna- 
 
200 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 mented with labyrinths. On the floor of the grand 
 Lombard church of San Michele at Pavia is a fine 
 one dating from the sixth century, on which also the 
 figures of Theseus and the Minotaur originally filled 
 the centre. The labyrinths, thus designed for devo- 
 tional purposes, were, when space allowed them, of very 
 large dimensions ; for instance, the early thirteenth 
 century example at Rheims measured 35 feet in dia- 
 meter, octagon in form, with projecting bastions, and 
 was used penitentially in place of pilgrimage to the 
 Holy Land, and hence called "the road to Jerusalem." 
 Another of the same century, but still larger, at Amiens, 
 measured 42 feet in diameter, having for its central 
 device an inlaid brass cross as the object of attainment. 
 The great circular labyrinth which occupied the centre 
 of the floor in the nave of Chartres Cathedral was of 
 such extent as to require an hour to trace its passages, 
 and hence called " La Lieue." Its paths were inlaid 
 white, with the Miserere engraved all along them, the 
 divisions and barriers being blue, and in the central 
 medallion the figures of Theseus and the Minotaur, 
 explicable in such a situation only by the attribution 
 of the deepest Christian symbolism, Among the latest 
 labyrinths is that one which forms the centre of the 
 pavement in encaustic tiles of the chapter - house at 
 Bayeux in Normandy, where the enamelled colouring 
 has been worn off by the persistent devotion of the 
 Chanoines. There is much interest in this subject 
 from the curious variety of devices, which, however, do 
 not affect mosaic, such as the labyrinth worked in 
 embroidery on one of the imperial robes of state at 
 Rome in the ninth century, 1 several engraved upon 
 walls, as those of Poictiers Cathedral and Lucca, and 
 one encrusted in lead at the west end of the cathedral 
 
 1 Graphia aiiretz urbis Roma, pp. 92 and 178. A. F. Ozanan. Also 
 Archceological Journal^ 1858. E. Trollope. 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 201 
 
 at Sens, and the still more curious labyrinths cut in 
 turf in numerous places in England and Wales, for the 
 games of swains and lasses of old times. After the 
 fifteenth century, whether for religious use or ornament, 
 the device appears to have been discontinued, till 
 restored in modern times among the pleasant conceits 
 of ornamental gardening ; among which, in the days 
 of Queen Elizabeth, fancy called them Troy-town or 
 Julian's Bower. 
 
 But enough of pavements. In Italy the art of 
 mosaic was now, during the twelfth century, rapidly 
 developed upon walls and vaulting, principally by 
 artists from Siena and Florence, whence the names of 
 the Greek Apollonius and the Italian Cimabue and 
 Mino da Turrita, Duccio and Tafi, Gaddi and Giotto, 
 awaken associations of such interest in history, art, 
 and religion as, once known, haunt the memory for 
 life. 
 
 Their works must be seen to be understood. They 
 abound with much zeal and poetry, and at once engage 
 our sympathy and admiration by the earnestness of 
 feeling and the grand artistic genius they display. 
 Words can do but little more than chronicle their 
 subjects, for to embody their poetry by any other 
 mode of expression than their own, or to convey that 
 devotional sense to which they owe their inspiration is 
 impossible. Both modes of composition, the symbolic 
 and the dramatic, were revived together. The con- 
 templative Sienese, the practical Florentine, the ideal 
 Greek, infused their works with this variety of their 
 conceptions. The symbolism which had characterised 
 the mosaics of Ravenna was now consummated at 
 Rome over the altars of San Clemente and the apsidal 
 recesses of the Lateran and Santa Maria Maggiore, 
 affording examples of a reviving art that for magnifi- 
 cence of effect and expressive grandeur, under the 
 
202 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 obligations of architectural constraint, have not been 
 surpassed. 
 
 The ornamentation of the apse of San Clemente is 
 essentially symbolic. The four arms of the cross, which 
 form its central motive, are inlaid with white doves, 
 and in the centre is the figure of the Crucified of such 
 exceedingly small size as all but to escape observation, 
 as though to avoid to the utmost all dramatic represent- 
 ation. Enclosed, within a branch of thorn bent in the 
 form of a vesica, small figures of the Virgin and St. 
 John stand close against the lower arm of the cross, 
 and from its base, considerably below them, spring vine 
 tendrils which cover the entire vault with their graceful 
 curves. Numerous emblematic and other figures fill 
 the vacant spaces, and among them are seen the four 
 fathers of the Western Church seated writing. The 
 stream of the water of life breaks out as a river from 
 the foot of the cross, and on each side deer stand 
 and drink from it. A broad band, like a frieze at the 
 springing of the vault, is occupied by twelve sheep with 
 the symbolic Lamb in the centre of them, and on the 
 wall beyond it, at each end of it, are represented 
 the cities of Jerusalem and Bethlehem. The complete 
 text of the " Gloria in excelsis " surrounds the arch, and 
 on the wall above it is the bust of the Saviour in the 
 act of benediction, with figures, on each side, of St. Paul, 
 St. Laurence, and Isaiah on the dexter, and opposite 
 them St. Peter, St. Clement, and Jeremiah. With 
 regard to the inscriptions, it is remarkable that the two 
 essentially Roman martyrs are distinguished by the 
 Greek appellations of "agios Paulos" and "agios 
 Petros," the rest in Latin. 
 
 The great mosaic in a similar position in the 
 Lateran is a stately composition admirably combining 
 its purpose as a dignified architectural ornament with 
 the calm expression of devotional religion. It is 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 203 
 
 entirely free from dramatic effect. Its central subject 
 is as conventional as that of San Clemente, and even 
 more intently symbolic. Its central figure is a huge 
 cross, the consummating symbol of the Christian faith, 
 built up of ornamental forms like one vast jewel, with 
 no figure on it, but a small medallion in its centre con- 
 taining the subject of the baptism of Christ. From 
 above, the Holy Spirit as a dove sheds down rays like 
 streams of water falling on each side of the cross upon 
 the symbolic Calvary, and at its base a small building 
 represents the gates of Paradise with an angel guarding 
 it, and the tree of life above it with the Phoenix, the 
 symbol of immortality, seated on its branches. The 
 four rivers with their names written, Pison, Euphrates, 
 Tigris, Gion, flow forth, with groups of sheep and deer 
 drinking from them. The broad stream "Jordanes" 
 flows below, about which winged children are sailing 
 and playing with swans and other birds. On each side 
 of the cross, on a border of grass strewn with flowers, 
 stand calm figures of the Virgin and St. John the 
 Baptist in the place of honour, and beyond them on 
 each side three, St. Peter, St. Paul, and St. Francis, 
 and St. John Evangelist, St. Anthony, and St. Andrew, 
 all with raised hands turned toward the cross. Above 
 all this is a separate compartment of blue sky chequered 
 with many-coloured clouds ; and immediately above the 
 cross is a bust of Christ arched over by a choir of seraphs. 
 This grand composition is supported by a deep 
 band of mosaic filling up the spaces between the 
 windows below, and containing many saintly figures 
 standing with palm-trees between them. Severe 
 criticism would find fault with anything, but certainly 
 here, fine as the work is, it is liable to remark on the 
 displeasing adoption of various scales for the figures, as 
 though representing their spiritual dignity by their 
 physical size, by making the saints Francis and 
 
204 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 Anthony diminutive in comparison with the grander 
 figures around them, and worse still with that of Pope 
 Nicolas IV., who crouches at the feet of the Virgin. 
 But the bust of Christ above, frequently thus intro- 
 duced, and in this case with a really fine head, certainly 
 mars the quietude of the general proportions by its 
 colossal size, and by its obtrusive reality it spoils the 
 quiet completeness of the symbolism, to which the 
 whole centre of the composition is otherwise devoted. 
 It peeps out from behind nothing, as though it had no 
 place there, and the personages below are adoring not 
 Him but the cross. But this head has a miraculous 
 story, having been always regarded by the people as 
 representing the head of Christ Himself, which in that 
 place appeared to Constantine on the occasion of the 
 consecration of his church in 323-24. The legend 
 goes on to state that it had escaped seven fires unhurt, 
 and its removal and replacement without injury ; but 
 the extant order of Nicolas IV. in 1290 that it should 
 be placed there seems to resolve the mystery, as by the 
 style of the head might be expected, that it is, at least 
 mainly, the work of the two artists whose signatures 
 exist below. This mosaic has a further interest in its 
 preserving the names of its artists, the one who signs 
 the base of the mosaic of the semi-cupola being Jacobus 
 Toriti l pict. ; and among the figures between the win- 
 dows below are represented two Franciscan monks 
 kneeling, one without any inscription, who may there- 
 fore represent Toriti, whose name is on the mosaic above 
 him, carrying in his hand the compass and the square ; 
 the other, a younger monk, with the inscription " Fr. 
 
 1 There has been some confusion about this artist owing to similarity 
 of names. Vasari is very hazy on the subject. This Jacobus, who signed 
 his family name Toriti and Torriti, was a Roman. The Jacobus with 
 whom he has been confounded was a Florentine, his predecessor, who had 
 been engaged on the baptistery at Florence above half a century before. 
 A historian of his order had styled him from the place of his birth "Da 
 Turrita" hence the mistake. 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 205 
 
 Jacob, de Camerino," carrying in one hand a trowel and 
 in the other the long pointed hammer peculiar to his art. 
 
 Of the three other great apsidal mosaics of the 
 thirteenth century at Rome, viz. those of .St. Peter's, St. 
 Paul's outside the walls, and Sa. Maria Maggiore, only 
 the last remains. St. Paul's was destroyed by fire, St. 
 Peter's by vandalism. That of Sa. Maria Maggiore, 
 but little affected by injury and repair, is a grand monu- 
 ment of Italy's first great renaissance of art and genius. 
 It is the work of the same artist, who either composed or 
 so far reconstituted the great work in the apse of the 
 Lateran as to have practically made it his own, and has 
 signed it here as there " Jacobus Torriti pictor," adding 
 on the opposite corner the date of this work 1295. 
 The design is as simple as it is grand in its architectonic 
 conception. In a great central medallion, occupying a 
 third of the semi-dome, is represented, of colossal 
 dimensions, Christ in the act of crowning His mother. 
 They sit upon a spacious and richly-ornamented throne, 
 relieved upon a background of the blue heavens gemmed 
 with stars ; a crowd of angels are below them on each 
 side, and beyond them figures of saints standing in 
 attitudes of adoration. The rest of the vault is filled, 
 upon a gold ground, with scrolls of foliage and birds 
 seated on the branches. Below it the waters of the 
 Jordan symbolise the separation of this troublous world 
 from the celestial scene above. If the drawing of the 
 figures may be charged with fault it is but that common 
 to its age, and if the colour may be criticised as strong, 
 it is but what the wealth of coloured marbles, metals, 
 and golden ornament of the sanctuary and altar beneath 
 had prepared for it. Torriti's art was that of an archi- 
 tectural mosaicist, and he was master of it. 
 
 This grand basilica had derived its original name 
 of Sa. Maria ad Nives from the strange circumstances 
 alleged to have attended the selection of the site. 
 
206 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 Nothing is too marvellous for a legend. It tells that 
 in the year 352 the blessed Virgin appeared simul- 
 taneously in dreams to the Bishop of Rome, Liberius, 
 and to a certain good patrician John, who desired to build 
 a church in her honour, and indicated to them both that 
 its place would be marked by a fall of snow. The 
 truth of these dreams was realised by the bishop, the 
 patrician, and their attendants rinding at the highest 
 point of the Esquiline Hill a patch of snow in the form 
 of the ground-plan of a basilica ; so the church was 
 built, and called after that strange revelation " ad 
 Nives." This legend affords the subjects of a series of 
 mosaics which covered the facade in the first years of 
 the fourteenth century, by an artist who has signed his 
 name above them, " Philipp. Rusuti fecit hoc opus." 
 A majesty of the old typical character occupies the 
 centre, with the Virgin standing on one side and St 
 John Baptist on the other, with St Peter, St Paul, and 
 other apostles ; and below them various picturesque 
 illustrations of the bishop and the good John asleep, 
 with the Virgin appearing to them, and other subse- 
 quent incidents of the fall of snow and the foundation 
 of the church ; but with indifference to such works, 
 characteristic of the last century, a new facade of heavy 
 arches and balconies was erected in 1741 in front of 
 these mosaics, destroying some and obscuring the rest 
 Enough, however, remains 1 to show by these works the 
 interesting advance this art had made. 
 
 The genius of the West had now asserted itself, 
 and worked clear of that Greek tutelage which it had 
 too long allowed. The Greek school was effete. It 
 had faithfully preserved the traditions of its technicality, 
 but its art was dead. Mosaic was one of the passions 
 of Italian art in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries ; 
 
 1 An excellent chromo-lithograph of them is given by De Rossi, 
 Mosaici delU Chiesc di Roma. 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 207 
 
 and now fine works were multiplied to such a degree 
 as to defy description. Gaddo Gaddi, the father of a 
 family of artists, was a mosaicist, a friend of Cimabue 
 and Tafi, and a fellow -workman with Torriti and 
 Rusuti. His works in St. Peter's and elsewhere were 
 numerous and important, such as those which covered 
 the vaulted ceiling of the cathedral at Arezzo, but time 
 and accident have dealt hardly with them, leaving 
 scarcely any but the figures of the apostles in the 
 baptistery and the Coronation of the Virgin in the 
 cathedral of Florence. 
 
 At that time a remarkable family of artists, the 
 Cosmati, distinguished themselves at Rome. They 
 were adepts at sculpture, architecture, and in a less 
 degree in painting also : but most famous for the 
 refinement in their works of mosaic, which was rather 
 decorative than architectural, and devoted rather to 
 the ornamentation of monuments and the accessories 
 of buildings than to great works of pictorial design. 
 Among their pupils was Pietro Cavallini, who, by a 
 maze of hypothesis, has been associated with the 
 mosaics of the shrine of Edward the Confessor in 
 Westminster Abbey, where the work is certainly of the 
 Cosmati character of this age, but with which Cavallini 
 could have had nothing to do. 1 He was an accomplished 
 artist, the pride of that refined school of mosaicists and 
 the pupil of Giotto in painting ; but like Gaddi, he too 
 
 1 The shrine was completed in 1270. The dates of Cavallini's birth 
 vary in his biographies by Lanzi and Vasari ; according to the former he 
 was born in 1259, and would have been eleven years old at the comple- 
 tion of that monument. According to Vasari he was born in 1279, nine 
 years after that completion. The inscription on the shrine is "Petrus 
 duxit in actum Romanus civis." George Vertue, whose Anecdotes of 
 Painting were published by Horace Walpole, appears to have caught at 
 the name Pietro, and knowing of Cavallini as a mosaicist pupil of the 
 Roman Cosmati of that age and style, decided, regardless of dates, that 
 the Petrus Romanus civis could be no other than that distinguished artist. 
 Vide for this, and the equally futile idea of Cavallini having designed Queen 
 Eleanor's (Gothic) crosses, Walpole's Anecdotes of Painting, vol. i. pp. 
 30-35- 
 
208 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 has been unfortunate, for his great works, which covered 
 the walls of the nave and the fagade of St. Paul's at 
 Rome, perished in the fire which destroyed that basilica 
 in 1823; but in Sa. Maria in Trastevere his fine mosaic 
 pictures illustrating the life of the blessed Virgin still 
 adorn the walls of the apse. 
 
 The supplementary effect of colouring by mosaics 
 on the exteriors of important buildings of this age was 
 finely exhibited on the fagade of the cathedral at 
 Orvieto, where a Sienese artist, Andrea, worked for 
 some years ; and on that of Siena from Michele 
 Memmo in the fourteenth to David Ghirlandajo in the 
 latter part of the fifteenth century. At Rome the 
 fagade of St. Peter's was richly ornamented in this 
 manner with the great Apocalyptic scene of the com- 
 pany of heaven before the throne of Christ, the principal 
 personages of the New Testament being grouped 
 around Him, and the elders casting their crowns at 
 His feet. The great mosaics on the fronts of St. Paul's 
 and Sa. Maria Maggiore have been already mentioned, 
 and those which still decorate the front of Sa. Maria in 
 Trastevere. The Navicella by Giotto was one of the most 
 famous of this class. The original of it was over the 
 main entrance in the portico of St. Peter's ; but having 
 been removed three times, twice to outside walls and 
 once inside, it was entirely wrecked, and the present 
 copy of it, partly traditional partly from an old cartoon, 
 represents the old composition, but is of entirely modern 
 work. The subject of it is St. Peter walking on the 
 waves, a scene composed with great animation and 
 telling the story effectively ; but whether Giotto ever 
 worked upon the mosaic is not known ; his part would 
 rather have been in the design than in the time-con- 
 suming speciality of setting the tesserae, which in this 
 case, according to Vasari, was mainly the work of his 
 pupil, Pietro Cavallini. The question may probably be 
 
vi CHRISTIAN MOSAIC 209 
 
 asked and answered in the same way about Cimabue, 
 who, in the first years of the fourteenth century, was 
 associated with the mosaicists at work in the cathedral 
 of Pisa, where Tura and subsequently Vicino were the 
 principal artists ; but no actual mosaic work is attributed 
 to Cimabue's own hand. 
 
 After the twelfth century mosaic appears rarely 
 north of the Alps. The architects and artists spent all 
 their enthusiasm and their means in developing their 
 new ideal of pointed architecture, and what mosaic they 
 used was their own version of it, in the sectile glass of 
 their windows and pavements of enamelled tiles. South 
 of the Alps, although the development of wall painting 
 in tempera and fresco had won the public taste and 
 had dethroned the supremacy of mosaic, this latter art 
 was still cultivated, and many names of the leading 
 painters of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries are 
 associated with it, such as Lippi, Baldovinetti, Ghir- 
 landajo, Botticelli, sometimes for the repair of old 
 works and sometimes on originals. Their work was 
 what would be expected from such men most refined ; 
 but the architectural sense that gave the older mosaics 
 their great character in monumental art had lost its 
 power and had no place in them. A contrary ideal had 
 crossed its path, the ideal of individuality. The frescoes 
 and wall paintings of that age were works of individual 
 excellence, conceived in relation to themselves alone, 
 and beautiful in themselves, but without relation to the 
 walls they covered. The painter did not think of them ; 
 but mosaic had been an art devised for them, and had 
 become part of them in fact as much as in idea, uniting 
 the arts of painter and architect, and participating in the 
 grandeur of their broad harmony. Baldovinetti, the 
 Florentine painter, was the most earnest to maintain 
 the honour of the art ; and Peselli, whose name is well 
 known among the interesting annals of the early 
 
 p 
 
210 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY vi 
 
 Florentine school of painting, ornamented with mosaic, 
 in 1416, Orcagna's lovely shrine in the church of Or' 
 San Michele. Even Raphael was pressed into the 
 service, but the works executed from his designs in 
 Sa. Maria del Popolo at Rome are not worthy of him. 
 They represent illusive openings in the roof, through 
 which the figures of the Almighty and of the cycle of 
 the planets are seen from below. 1 The architectonic 
 ideal was no more. 
 
 The real centre of activity in the art was now St. 
 Mark's at Venice, where the old traditions were main- 
 tained to the utmost in their conflict with the inde- 
 pendent school of painting, then rapidly advancing 
 upon them. In 1430 Michele Giamboni adorned the 
 walls of the chapel of the Mascoli in St. Mark's with 
 illustrations of the life of the blessed Virgin, designed 
 and wrought by him ; a work of considerable extent, 
 and inspired with a charming simplicity and earnest- 
 ness. But by the middle of the following century that 
 phase of monumental art was over ; and Titian, Tin- 
 toretto, Pordenone, and their followers, drew cartoons 
 and painted pictures, and skilled mosaicists copied 
 them upon walls and vaulting without regard for what 
 surrounded them, or the faintest attention to congruity 
 of style or effect ; and thus the shadows gathered 
 round this grand old art, as its day drew rapidly to 
 its close. Another art and another ideal had risen 
 to their zenith, and the last honours of monumental 
 mosaic were lost amid the glare and flourish of an 
 indifferent age. 
 
 1 They were designed by Raphael for the Chigi Chapel in that church, 
 and executed by a Venetian, Luca or Luigi della Pace, who dates his work 
 1516. Raphael and the banker Agost. Chigi died in the same month 
 of 1520, and the chapel was unfinished at that date (C. and C., vol. ii., 
 pp. 252 and 337). The whole subject is fully discussed in the Life of 
 Raphael, by Crowe and Cavalcaselle, vol. ii., pp. 337-4 and notes '> and 
 in the Critical Account of Drawings by Michael Angela and Raphael, by 
 Mr. T. C. Robinson. Oxford, 1870, pp. 265-69. 
 
ESSAY VII 
 
 THE ART AND THE ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 
 
 ANCIENT AND MEDIAEVAL 
 
 WHEN Pliny wrote these words of commendation 
 about the use of glass for artistic purposes " nee 
 est alia nunc materia sequatior, aut etiam picturae ac- 
 commodatior " (" nothing adapts itself more pleasantly 
 to the art of the painter than glass"), it was in very 
 general use, and the choice specimens of it were highly 
 prized among those graceful works that adorned the 
 luxury of life. He saw it artistically in many forms 
 brought to perfection, but the most effective of them all 
 was unknown to him ; and it was not till among the 
 darkest days of a succeeding age that the art of glass 
 painting for translucent pictorial effect came into use. 
 That it was actually invented in those ill-recorded days 
 of the middle ages cannot be affirmed ; for like all 
 other arts it had come of the growth of opportunities ; 
 and until the amount and price of the material made it 
 available, the ancient use of it sufficed only to suggest 
 that which not till centuries later became possible, viz. 
 the employment of opaque enamel to define ornamental 
 design upon the colours of glass used transparently. 
 Its development, as we now know it, was due to the 
 requirements and tastes of conventual life in the middle 
 ages. 
 
212 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 If such use of glass was practised to any extent 
 in classical times, it is at least unrecorded. A mode of 
 painting with the materials of glass upon glass, which is 
 in fact enamelling, had indeed been common for many 
 centuries B.C., but that was mostly if not exclusively for 
 opaque effects visible rather upon than through the sur- 
 faces. Such were those pictures upon circular plates of 
 glass which Suetonius describes as ornamenting the 
 walls of Horace's bedroom, and a fair illustration of 
 what such paintings may have been is afforded by a 
 circular plaque discovered early in last century in the 
 cemetery of St. Agnes at Rome, and figured among 
 Buonarrotti's elaborate illustrations of ancient glass. 1 
 It is a work of painting with and upon glass of the first 
 or second century A.D., and a short description of it is 
 well worth giving here. It formed the foot of a large 
 glass vase or cup, such as was given as a prize to a 
 victor at the public games. The ground of it was blue, 
 and within an arabesque border there was a group of 
 two reclining figures ; one of them was that of a young 
 woman with children and picturesque accessories about 
 her, her dress was silver, her hair of a light chestnut 
 colour, the arabesques and cornucopia being gold ; the 
 male figure, personating a river deity, was of gold, and 
 its drapery silver striped with purple, the water from a 
 vase beneath his arm was sea green ; the fruit carried 
 by one of the children in the folds of its tunic were 
 coloured red and gold, and those in the cornucopia were 
 all of their natural colours, the winged children above 
 them and the crown of flowers carried by one of them 
 were gold and crimson. A small relic of a similar kind 
 of painting was found at Cumae in 1 8 1 9 ; it was a panel 
 of vitreous paste, and the subject painted on it was the 
 prow of a ship lying near a pier with a lighthouse upon 
 it, the anchor and a trident being the only accessories. 
 
 1 Osservazioni sopra alcuni frammenti di vasi antic hi di vetro, 1716. 
 
viz ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 213 
 
 Another treatment of a similar subject on a glass 
 vessel l shows the pier with round arches, the ship being 
 moored in front of the lighthouse, and round the cover 
 a red circle was drawn bordered with fillets of gold and 
 gold spots, surrounded by a garland of flowers painted 
 in red and gold. Such effective illustrations of figure 
 subjects painted in various colours upon glass could not 
 fail to have become general, as imitations of marbles 
 and alabaster were, among the glass plaques commonly 
 used for ornament, inlaid upon walls, but only a few 
 smaller examples have been found. Among relics of 
 similar art of about A.D. 200, a remarkable disk was 
 found at Cologne in 1866, covered with gold illumina- 
 tion of sacred subjects with many colours introduced. 
 Among them was one of Daniel clothed in a tunic of 
 crimson and gold, with lions on each side and trees 
 rising up behind coloured emerald green. In the sub- 
 ject of the three figures in the fiery furnace the flames 
 are painted red. The water round the monster, from 
 whose mouth Jonah is emerging, is coloured blue ; and 
 other subjects such as the Nativity, Isaac, and the 
 paralytic carrying his bed, have backgrounds of emerald 
 coloured trees. The enamelled colours are opaque, and 
 the effects entirely upon the surface. 2 Other examples 
 might be adduced, but these may suffice to show how 
 glass was painted in its earliest days. 
 
 The representation of ornament and pictorial 
 designs by gilding alone, which became common at 
 Rome in and after the second century (A.D.) was a form 
 of art that was developed with very great beauty of 
 effect. It was an art followed by the Alexandrian, 
 Greek, and Roman artists, and is seen in the utmost 
 refinement in two basins found at Canosa, and now in 
 
 1 Campana Collection, Rome. 
 
 2 Illustrated Catalogue, Slade Collection, by Mr. Alex. Nesbitt, 1871, 
 page 50. For old Christian glass with occasional colour introduced, -vide 
 Diet. Christ. Antiq., vol. i., page 731 and note. 
 
214 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 the British Museum, on which the gold design consists 
 of delicate conventional foliage, and flowers springing 
 from a central rosette, and enclosed in a rich border 
 worthy of Greek art of the finest period. The effect is 
 produced by engraving upon thin gold attached to the 
 glass, and protected by another coat above it, a system 
 which subsequently came into common use upon the 
 feet of vases, and on plaques enclosing portraits and 
 groups of figures, emblems, and inscriptions, both Pagan 
 and Christian, during the first four centuries A.D. A 
 remarkable specimen of this work is upon a vase, for- 
 merly in Mr. Horace Walpole's collection, representing 
 in one part Cupid and Psyche in a cypress grove, with 
 children playing about them, on another part of which 
 is a draped bust within a wreathed vine branch. On 
 Jewish and early Christian glass in this style elaborate 
 subjects are represented, repeating in miniature those of 
 the catacombs. 
 
 The method of painting with glass fused into and 
 upon glass was an art of great antiquity, and is seen 
 in the combination of opaque and transparent 
 ornament found in Phoenician beads and gems, and 
 on Egyptian bottles and small amphorae decorated 
 with bands of various design, such as chevrons and 
 palmated leaf-like patterns in a great variety of colours. 
 Many of these are of high antiquity ; for instance, there 
 is a small turquoise blue bottle in the Egyptian collec- 
 tion of the British Museum, of which the handle is 
 ornamented with lines of black, white, and yellow on 
 the blue ground, a ring of gold colour round its edge, 
 and on the side a small yellow branch with the hiero- 
 glyph of Thothmes the Third in the same colour, i.e. 
 B.C. 1600. Among the ruins of Nimrond many relics 
 of coloured glass were found, and as some evidence of 
 their date, there was found with them a vessel of dull 
 white glass bearing the name of Sargon, who reigned 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 215 
 
 B.C. 722. A very ancient mode of painting with the 
 materials of glass was also that of fusing vitreous 
 enamels on blocks of cement or terra-cotta and on tiles, 
 of which fine examples are illustrated in the works of 
 Botta, Layard, and Place from Nineveh and Korsa- 
 bad, among which are figures of men and animals, and 
 numerous ornamental devices variously coloured, and 
 used as architectural enrichments inlaid upon walls. 
 In Egypt this had been from early times a favourite 
 mode of ornament. In Phoenicia and Egypt coloured 
 glass with surface ornament of many patterns was 
 equally famous, and in both those countries the first 
 element of glass painting by multiplying its colours 
 had in remote times been brought to such perfection 
 that gems, precious stones, and marbles were suc- 
 cessfully imitated, and objects thus falsified in glass 
 were regarded as jewels and called by their names. 
 Such was the emerald sceptre of Sesostris, the great 
 table of a single emerald found in the pyramid of Cheops, 
 and the column in the temple of Hercules at Tyre. 
 Sidon also was celebrated for its art of imitative jewelry 
 of many colours, especially for its jasper and emerald, 
 and for coloured ornaments moulded in relief. Egypt 
 had excelled in the imitation of ruby, emerald, jasper, 
 turquoise, and lapis lazuli, and from Alexandria and 
 later Rome came many of those colours, besides por- 
 phyry and onyx, agate, sard, and sapphire. Imitative 
 obsidian was also made at Rome, where Pliny describes 
 statuettes of Augustus as " vitri obsidiani." The 
 imitative murrhine, of which the original material was 
 of fabulous value among the dilettanti of Rome, 1 was 
 made at Thebes, if the authority of Arrian is to be 
 trusted, " vasa vitrea et murrhina in urbe Diospoli 
 elaborata ; " and at Alexandria, on the authority of 
 Pliny, " fit et album et murrhinum imitatum." Its 
 
 1 W. King, Precious Stones, 1865, and Antique Gems, 1860. 
 
216 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 imitation was, with the exception of that of pure rock 
 crystal, the most costly of all glass, and, if truly repre- 
 sented by the few specimens that remain, it affords a 
 rich effect of wavy streaks of indigo, purple, green, and 
 white, blending into each other with beautiful opalescence. 
 One of the most effective representations of pic- 
 torial design in ancient glass was that of cameo relief, 
 such as the Portland and Aldjo vases, the small blue 
 amphora in the museum at Naples, and other known 
 specimens. The subject on the first of these is the 
 meeting of Peleus and Thetis, with other figures among 
 the rocks and trees of Mount Pelion. The Neapolitan 
 vase has also a cameo surface of blue ornamented with 
 elaborate subjects in white relief, the principal of which 
 are groups of children in a vineyard plucking and 
 treading the grapes and playing on musical instruments, 
 very gracefully designed. This had long been a 
 favourite style of work in glass, and we find glass copies 
 of fine cameo gems in many colours to have been worn 
 at Athens in the palmiest days of its arts. 1 At Rome 
 in the time of the empire the use of glass for coloured 
 ornament became universal, and walls, ceilings, and 
 friezes were inlaid with painted panels of it, and 
 figures and pictures in relief, as in the theatre of 
 Scaurus, the baths of Agrippa, and in private houses, as 
 in that of Horace mentioned above, and the famous 
 house of Firmus, the rich merchant and petty tyrant 
 of the time of Aurelian, which is described by his 
 biographer, Vopiscus, as encrusted with " vitreae quadra- 
 turae " (glass pictures) ; and as Statius describes that of 
 Claudius Etruscus, " effulgent camerae vario fastigia 
 vitro." Ceilings in his time were usually painted and 
 enriched with ornamental medallions, cameos, and 
 panels of figure subjects, and these " were brilliant with 
 coloured glass." 
 
 1 Boekh, Corp. inscrip., n. 150. 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 217 
 
 Such are a few well-known examples selected as 
 sufficient at least to indicate the method of using 
 coloured glass for ornament and painting with glass 
 upon glass among the nations of antiquity, but it will 
 be noticed throughout that there is neither relic nor 
 record of actual glass painting depending on translu- 
 cency for its effect. Of the artists themselves and their 
 monograms many are known, but not upon glass 
 assignable to a time earlier than the close of the Roman 
 republic. Four of the best known of them were 
 Sidonians, and the names of most of them were Greek, 
 such as Alexandros and Ennion, whose name is stamped 
 on glass found on the site of the ancient Panticape, 
 near Kertch on the Bosphorus, and like other artists 
 he added " eirouei " (he made it) to his name. Ariston 
 and Neon are two others who sign themselves as 
 Sidonians ; and Eirenaios of Sidon, whose name is 
 signed on an amber-coloured seal, and his date is indi- 
 cated by a blue medallion apparently taken from an 
 intaglio gem of the Emperor Caligula. Artas of Sidon 
 is a name well known by his bilingual stamps of various 
 colours in Greek and Latin, to which he commonly 
 adds in Greek that " he made this " ; as also Nicocles, 
 who designates himself of Sparta ; and Dorus the 
 Rhodian. It may not, however, be a matter of certainty 
 whether these were the signatures of the artists or of 
 merely the makers of the glass, but it is probable that, 
 as was the case in the Christian middle ages, the maker 
 and the artist were often the same, for glass was not 
 then used as now for the commonest purposes of life, but 
 when employed as an art manufacture its works were 
 individual productions, and were as much or more 
 valued for their coloured and gold ornamentation than 
 for their material or form ; so when found stamped 
 "Ariston of Sidon made this," or " Eirenaios did it," it 
 is fair to infer generally that we have the artist's mark. 
 
2i 8 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 It is in vain that we search for positive information 
 of translucent glass painting till the tenth or eleventh 
 century A.D. Many theoretical conclusions about the 
 origin of it have been drawn ; as by Winckelmann, whose 
 idea is a very possible one, that the mosaics in glass 
 tesserae and sectile marble marquetry, of walls and 
 floors, suggested similar designs in windows ; another 
 German antiquary supposes its derivation from the 
 curtains and carpets used before the introduction of 
 glass in windows, the figures and patterns of their 
 embroidery having suggested the same on glass ; 
 another advocate for the early use of glass painting 
 in classical times conceives that when Martial wrote, 
 " Sed rus est mihi magnus in fenestra," he might have 
 had a window painted like a landscape. But this 
 is properly explained by Mazois in his Palace of 
 ScauruS) describing the method of closing and de- 
 corating windows before the use of glass, where he 
 adds that the Romans usually " closed their lowest 
 windows with iron grills, and those of the floors above 
 were ornamented with cases full of plants and flowers, 
 which gave to each room a pleasant and gardenesque 
 effect (' quelque chose de gai et de champetre ')." The 
 employment of glass in windows, although quite com- 
 monly used in other ways, appears not to have be- 
 come by any means rapidly universal, if we may judge 
 by the employment of transparent alabaster in the win- 
 dows of the south aisle of the cathedral of Torcello, 
 early in the eleventh century, and at San Miniato at 
 Florence, at a time when glass was practically com- 
 mon and glass mosaic universal. Many quotations 
 are made which go no farther than to prove the use 
 of coloured glass, and possibly of a mosaic pattern, as 
 in the small square panes set in the pierced slabs of 
 marble which formed the windows of Sa. Sophia at 
 Constantinople, and as Prudentius, of the fourth and 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 219 
 
 early fifth century, describes the large coloured win- 
 dows in the first church of St. Paul at Rome. Ciam- 
 pini states among the acts of the Emperor Honorius 
 (A.D. 400) that in rebuilding the church of Sa. Agnese 
 he decorated it with richly-coloured glass. The church 
 built by St. Patient at Lyons, A.D. 450, is described by 
 S. Apollinaris as having windows decorated " versi- 
 coloribus figuris" and " sapphiratos lapillos." So too 
 St. Fortunatus, Bishop of Poictiers, at the end of the 
 sixth century, wrote of the effect of coloured glass in 
 the interior of the church of Notre Dame, built by 
 Childebert ; and Anastasius, the librarian at Rome, in 
 his Life of Leo III., A.D. 795, writes of the enrichments 
 of the basilica of St. John Lateran by that builder and 
 art-loving Pope " Fenestras de absida ex vitro diversis 
 coloribus conclusit." St. Philibertae, the founder of 
 the abbey of Jumieges, about A.D. 655, introduced 
 glass into the windows there ; but these are only 
 modestly described as pleasant to read by, "Lumen 
 optabile tribuens legentibus," which suggests the 
 greenish and otherwise imperfectly white glass of 
 earlier times to have been the kind introduced into 
 England by the workers in glass brought from France 
 by St. Benedict Biscop in the latter part of the 
 seventh century, and St. Wilfrid for his churches, 
 described by Bede, at Hexham, York, and Ripon. 
 
 At last, in the middle of the ninth century, we 
 come upon a definite statement of a window filled with 
 a picture mosaic of transparent glass, which appears to 
 me the earliest notice known. Gregorius, in his History of 
 Mediaeval Rome, produces a passage from the pontificals, 
 recording the restoration of the church of Sa. Maria in 
 Trastevere at Rome by Pope Benedict VIII. in 855. 
 It was on the site of the first church that had been 
 built by Pope Callixtus. The windows are there 
 described as ornamented with coloured design of 
 
220 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 transparent glass mosaic, " Fenestras vero vitreis 
 coloribus, et pictura musivi decoravit." It would 
 have been hard to believe that in the studied beauty 
 of such a building as that, and of another still more 
 magnificent viz. the basilica of St. Paul that the 
 windows described as being of glass of many colours 
 could have been a mere network of confusion without 
 device ; but that they would have represented, in 
 transparent glass, the ornamental designs already com- 
 mon upon the architecture, walls, and pavement. In 
 that quotation we have, therefore, the evidence con- 
 firmatory of so natural a deduction. 
 
 This method of ornamenting windows was at that 
 time adopted in the Mahomedan buildings in the East. 
 The glass was inlaid in a diaper pattern on the outer 
 side of a framework of plaster, the inner side of which 
 was level with the interior wall, and was protected 
 outside by an open reticulation of tiles. The glass 
 was very thin, the depth of colouring not necessarily 
 depending on its thickness. The deepest ruby is 
 hardly ever more than an eighth of an inch thick 
 in Gothic glass, strengthened by being spread on a 
 basis of pure white. The oriental glass was simply 
 the ruby without the white. So too were the other 
 colours. That thin glass was set in frames of which 
 the openings showed many patterns, some being geo- 
 metrical and some having the form of plants and 
 flowers growing from a vase, which became a common 
 subject in oriental wall mosaic. In the more ancient or 
 in the wealthier mosques this framework was of pierced 
 marble, in others it was of plaster ; and the glass was 
 cemented to the back of the framework with colours 
 arranged according to the carved or moulded device. 
 
 The only other case that I can discover of this 
 style of windows, and use of glass in the Christian 
 art of Western Europe, is in the history of the con- 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 221 
 
 vent of Monte Cassino. Its historian Leo, recording 
 the rebuilding of the church of that convent by the 
 Abbot Desiderius between the years 1050 and 1071, 
 describes the windows in the nave, the sanctuary, and 
 the aisles, and states that the artists were obtained 
 from Constantinople, who were expert in the art of 
 glass and mosaic. The windows of the nave and 
 sanctuary he describes as of glass, set in lead, and 
 strengthened with iron bars ; but those in the aisles 
 on each side were worked in plaster with patterns, 
 equally beautifully as the others. 1 These last were 
 precisely of the same kind as the oriental windows 
 I have just described. The whole account of that 
 great convent of Monte Cassino is a most interest- 
 ing record, going into great variety of detail, for 
 the antiquary and lover of old art invaluable. It 
 may have been that in the earlier examples to which 
 I referred viz. those of Sa. Agnese of the fifth 
 century and of Pope Leo III. of the eighth cen- 
 tury, and those of the basilica of St. Paul outside 
 Rome the construction and design may have been 
 such as those about which there remains no doubt 
 at Monte Cassino and in the church of Sa. Maria 
 in Trastevere, but the accounts of them are not de- 
 finitely so. The " versicoloribus figuris " (i.e. variously 
 coloured patterns] in the windows of St. Patient's 
 Church at Lyons, A.D. 450, can hardly have been 
 other than of transparent glass mosaic ; and, if so, 
 they are the earliest recorded, but those of the 
 Trastevere at Rome are the earliest plainly described 
 as " pictura musivi" A.D. S55. 2 
 
 1 " Quse vero in lateribus utriusque porticus sunt gypseas quidem sed 
 eque pulcras effecit." 
 
 2 In the small square reticulation of the pierced windows, A.D. 538, 
 of Sa. Sophia, Constantinople, " tenui pariete fenestellis vitreis pleno," 
 and in those described by Gregory of Tours, A.D. 525, " fenestras ex 
 more habens quse vitro tignis incluso clauduntur " may have possibly been 
 of this kind also, but coloured glass is in neither case certain. 
 
222 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 That painting figures and subjects on glass was 
 continued to be practised at Constantinople might 
 be naturally inferred from its common use quite 
 early in the days of the Roman Empire ; but the 
 question is whether the art of painting such subjects 
 on transparent glass, as it began to show itself in 
 Europe about A.D. 1000, originated at that head- 
 quarter of art traditions, Constantinople, or where? 
 The story of the portrait of the Emperor Constantine 
 the Seventh, sent by him in the year 949 to the Caliph 
 Abd-ur-rahmon, 1 and stated to have been executed 
 upon coloured glass, is a description that does not 
 settle the question, being equally applicable to the 
 old opaque glass system or to a cameo, or even of 
 etched gold, which was often used on a coloured 
 ground. Indeed, the invention of glass painting as 
 an art which began to be applied to windows is not 
 easily timed and placed. A learned antiquary 2 claims 
 that honour for his city, Limoges ; but though some- 
 thing may be said for it, nothing can be proved to 
 to that effect. Filiasi, in his curiosities of mediaeval 
 commerce, 3 states that artificers in glass were sent 
 from Constantinople to France in A.D. 687, and these 
 were, in all probability, artists and not merely manu- 
 facturers of glass, which was well known at Limoges 
 before that date, as St. Ouen, describing the entry 
 of St. Eloi into that city, about A.D. 650, adds that 
 a number of persons got into the church of St. 
 Sulpice by breaking through two large glass windows 
 near the entrance. An independent testimony as to 
 the early use of glass by the French is also afforded 
 by the monk Theophilus, who wrote that " Franci 
 in hoc opus peritissimi," and " quidquid in fenestra- 
 rum preciosa verietate diliget Francia ; " but no place 
 
 1 Vitreous art, Manchester Exhibition, Augs. Franks. 
 
 2 The Abbe Texier, Peinture siir verre en Limousin. 
 
 commercio. 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 223 
 
 is specified. Certainly Limoges, as an ancient city 
 of Roman foundation and preserving the traditions 
 of Roman arts, may have been early a centre of this 
 art and of trade in it, as by the latter part of the 
 twelfth century it had established its fame for it and 
 the associated art of enamel ; but long before that 
 date both the arts of enamelling and glass painting 
 had been successfully established in Lorraine and the 
 Rhenish provinces of Germany. 
 
 The often-quoted passage from the records of the 
 Abbey of St. Benignus at Dijon describes the figure 
 of St. Paschasia, as painted in a glass window of the 
 church, which was rebuilt there A.D. 1001. The anna- 
 list, writing in 1052, mentions this window with 
 admiration, as existing in his time, and known as 
 an ancient one. His words are, " Antiquitus facta, 
 et usque ad nostra perdurans tempora eleganti per- 
 monstrabat pictura ; " but how far this antiquity may 
 reach beyond, if beyond at all, the rebuilding of that 
 church, he does not state. That abbey had been 
 much favoured by Charles le Chauve (who died in 
 A.D. 877), and the previous church had been rebuilt 
 in his time. It is also known that that king was a 
 great patron of " glaziers," under which name glass 
 painters were included at that time, by his having 
 granted, at the Abbey of St. Amand, to two glaziers, 
 Regenulf and Balderic, in A.D. 863, two houses "en 
 jouissance commune avec 1'abbaye." If that win- 
 dow of St. Paschasia was really so " antiquitus facta " 
 as to have been brought from that first church, it 
 certainly would be the first painted window on re- 
 cord ; but the window no more exists, and nothing 
 can be more definitely known about it. At any rate 
 its date would not be later than the earliest years of 
 the eleventh century. 
 
 This was precisely the time when the famous St. 
 
224 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 Bernwald, bishop of Hildesheim, in northern Germany, 
 at the end of the tenth century, and fifty or sixty years 
 later the Cardinal Abbot Deiderius, at Monte Cassino, 
 in Southern Italy, established their schools of art, which 
 spread their influence far and wide among the deepest 
 shadows of the middle ages. A century or more before 
 that date an impulse had been given to the arts by the 
 works of Charlemagne ; but the times were too disturbed 
 for any artistic influence to be long maintained after 
 his death. About the year 977 a more peaceful era 
 was begun, in the days of Otho II., who had married in 
 972 a Greek princess, Theophania, daughter of the 
 Byzantine emperor Romaniis the Second ; and through 
 her interest many artists were invited from Constan- 
 tinople. Otho died early, leaving his infant son to the 
 care of the empress, whose chaplain, Bernward, became 
 bishop of Hildesheim, and died there in 1021. He 
 was a man thoroughly imbued with the love of .art, 
 working with his own hands at the completion of his 
 cathedral, and establishing a school with many native 
 pupils under the Byzantine artists then living there. 
 The eight cathedrals established by Charlemagne in 
 that part of his empire became, as Gibbon writes of 
 them, "the first schools and cities of that savage land, 
 and the religion and humanity of the children atoned in 
 some degree for the massacre of the parents." Hildes- 
 heim was one of these ; and Cologne, subsequently the 
 residence of the empress, became the next centre 
 whence the cultivation of fine art was developed in 
 northern Europe. Enamelling was a favourite art 
 there ; and the names of two enamel painters, Gilbertus 
 of Cologne and Nicholas of Verdun, are preserved from 
 those early times. 
 
 Glass painting was an art nearly allied to enamel- 
 ling from the similarity of the materials and apparatus, 
 and frequently pursued by the same persons, and it is 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 225 
 
 to that part of Germany, Lorraine, Alsace, and the 
 neighbouring Rhine provinces that we may look with 
 some confidence, if not for its actual origin, at least for 
 the earliest development of that form of it which was 
 developed in the middle ages. At Neiiviller, on the 
 lower Rhine, is a relic of perhaps the oldest existing 
 painted window. The original church was built there 
 in 741, and the present church has attached to it what 
 appears to be a part of that more ancient building, in 
 which is a small window painted with the figure of St. 
 Thomas Martyr. The ground colour of it is ruby, and 
 within a border of conventional foliage the half-length 
 figure is draped with a blue cloak fastened at the neck 
 with a double brooch, and round the head is a white 
 rayed nimbus with the name of the saint above. The 
 design is of extreme Byzantine style. 1 
 
 At the Benedictine abbey of Tegernsee, in Bavaria, 
 have been preserved letters written between the years 
 982 and 1000, and among them one from the abbot 
 relating to the death of the Empress Theophania (A.D. 
 999), and desiring to institute an annual memorial of 
 her. It is recorded in the annals of that abbey that 
 glass works were established there in the year 1003, 
 and the records exist of many commissions for painted 
 windows having been received there, to be supplied to 
 distant places, with the directions as to the subjects to 
 be delineated in them. 2 This establishment appears to 
 have lasted for a great length of time, for the name of 
 Eberhardt as one of its glass painters is preserved there 
 in a document of the thirteenth century, relating to the 
 amount paid to him by Duke Albert of Austria. The 
 monk Theophilus, from whom the earliest account of 
 glass painting is obtained, lived, if not at the time, 
 certainly very shortly after the death of the Empress 
 
 1 Lasterie, Peinture sur verre, Appendix. 
 
 2 Baron de Schauenberg, Peinture sur verre. Societe literaire de 
 Strasburg. 1865. 
 
 Q 
 
226 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 Theophania. His proper name appears to have been 
 Riidiger, or latinised Rugerus, that of Theophilus being 
 his name assumed as a monk. He was not a Greek, 
 but by the adoption of that name he exhibited his 
 Greek sympathies, and his writings bear witness to 
 Byzantine influence. The first mediaeval writer who 
 mentions his work, Diversarum Artium Sckedula, states 
 that he received it from a monastery in Germany, and 
 the principal and completest copies of it appear to 
 have been traced to that country. 1 In a thirteenth- 
 century MS. copy of it found at Cambridge, and now 
 in the British Museum, it is implied that the author 
 was a Lombard, as the work begins with these words, 
 " Sic incipit Tractatus Lombardicus qualiter tempe- 
 rantur colores ad depingendum," for which it may 
 be supposed some evidence existed at that time 
 (nearly two centuries after his death), but which 
 is now lost. A claim has been made for that abbey 
 of Tergernsee as that at which he lived ; 2 and putting 
 all the strings of the story together, there appear to be 
 some fair reasons for that inference. He was deeply 
 versed in all the arts then practised by the Greeks, on 
 which account such a man had special claims to be re- 
 ceived among those artists who had been invited to the 
 court of Theophania, if not from Constantinople, at least 
 from among the pupils of the Schola Greca at Rome, or 
 from the north of Italy, where works under Greek artists 
 were at that time attracting attention. The change of 
 the Empress's residence to Cologne, the works going on 
 at Heidelberg, Bamberg, and in other parts of Germany, 
 and finally her death, may be supposed to have 
 scattered the original company of artists, and in some 
 way the abbey of Tergernsee was beholden to her, as 
 shown by the abbot's letter referred to above ; and the 
 
 1 Hendrie's Theophilus % Introduction. 
 
 2 Baron Schauenberg : a lecture delivered to the Societe literaire at 
 Strasburg, 1865. 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 227 
 
 establishment of glass painters there was evidently one 
 of leading importance, which the records of its wide 
 employment testify. This Rugerus or Riidiger, whose 
 artistic education may have been among the Byzantine 
 artists engaged in Lombardy, and whence his title 
 Lombardicus, but whose literary works have been 
 mainly traced to Germany, is believed to have retired 
 some time after the Empress's death to the quiet seclu- 
 sion of that abbey, and there to have written his 
 famous work, which is one that could only have been 
 produced by an artist of great practical experience, and 
 embracing detailed instruction on painting in general, 
 carving and moulding ivory, mosaic, glass painting, art 
 metal work, enamelling, organ -building, etc. ; and he 
 wrote as others of his time and after him have done 
 under a sense of the sacredness of art employed in the 
 service of religion, begging for " the prayers of those of 
 his readers who have profited by him ... as he wrote 
 not for human praise nor for temporal recompense, but 
 to glorify God by helping and advancing men." 
 
 Whence then can we trace the origin of the art as 
 Theophilus teaches it, and as it is still practised in our 
 own days ? The completeness of his instructions im- 
 plies the knowledge of an art then in full practice, but 
 whence did he get it ? Among the artists at Con- 
 stantinople there is no record of its use. In Rome and 
 in Italy it was not at all generally practised till cen- 
 turies later, although Heraclius, who lived at Rome, whose 
 work is specially designated as de coloribus et artibus 
 Romanorum, and who is believed by sufficient collateral 
 evidence to have lived in the earliest years of the 
 eleventh century, wrote of glass painting in terms 
 similar to those of Theophilus. The employment of 
 coloured glass in windows, and the mosaic designs used 
 in them were in his time very common throughout the 
 East and in Italy, but not glass painting as he de- 
 
228 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 scribes it ; nor has it left even a silhouette of its exist- 
 ence in the East. In France and in Germany the 
 exigencies of climate encouraged a far more general use 
 of glass, and the Byzantine or semi-Greek artists from 
 Rome, who from the days of Charlemagne worked 
 there, had brought with them to the more northern 
 countries such a knowledge of the kindred arts of 
 enamelling, mosaic, and wall painting as would be 
 almost involuntarily transferred to the broad surfaces 
 of the glass windows then but lately come into use, 
 and certainly suggested by them. 
 
 By all the positive and negative evidence that can 
 be found, it appears that glass painting began about 
 that time, and not improbably making its first essays 
 from previous examples of painting on glass with some 
 distemper medium. It is impossible to say at what 
 place that art originated. From the similarity of the 
 instructions given for it by Heraclius at Rome, and 
 Theophilus in Germany, writing about half a century 
 later, the probability of a common origin is inevitably 
 suggested, and that one only place was Constantinople. 
 The first elements of the art may very possibly have 
 been realised there where glass was used in every 
 artistic form, and have been sufficiently matured to 
 have provided both those writers with their knowledge. 
 Constantinople may even still earlier have received it 
 from late Roman artists but all is theory the fact 
 being that it never rose at either of the great centres to 
 a position of practical importance. If it had ever lived 
 in either of them, practically it died ; preserved only in 
 the written secrets of medical and artistic manuscripts. 
 That part of Europe, where Charlemagne gave the first 
 and Theophania the second impulse to the cultivation 
 of the arts, appears to have been the site of its practical 
 origin in the form subsequently developed, as we now 
 know it. It was evidently well understood and prac- 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 229 
 
 tised by Theophilus, and therefore initiated before his 
 time, but the completeness of it had been attained at 
 the time he wrote by the perfecting of the enameller's 
 materials and processes applied to the burning-in the 
 design upon the surface of the glass. The artists for 
 whom Charlemagne had sent were by his special order 
 restricted to such as could be provided from within the 
 limits of his own empire, i.e. from Rome and Lom- 
 bardy for in Germany there were few if any ; but 
 even if from Rome, they were half Byzantine ; and it 
 is a plain fact that those artists who worked at his 
 "chapel" at Aix have left no record of this art, nor did 
 they practise it there, though glass was common to them 
 in their use of mosaic. It was in their time that the 
 great ecclesiastical establishments in Germany were 
 founded, and the arts, freeing themselves from either 
 Roman or Byzantine influences, became nationalised in 
 them. Those artists cannot have failed to leave their 
 pupils and their influence ; and within the limit of a 
 century and a half between their great patron's death 
 and the arrival of their successors at the court of Theo- 
 phania that art appears to have had its north European 
 birth ; and from those men, then and there by all the 
 facts that reasonable inference allows, Theophilus, Pres- 
 byter et Monac/ius, German by birth or German by 
 adoption, but Greek by education, learnt his art, ob- 
 tained his experience, and subsequently wrote .his 
 treatise at the close of the eleventh century in his 
 retirement at Tegernsee. 
 
 The art spread widely and rapidly, as it is known 
 by the records or remains of it at distant places in 
 Germany, France, and England. Still Lorraine and 
 the Rhenish provinces, as the fountain-head of all such 
 arts, north of the Alps, held their own, and it was 
 thence that the Abbot Suger sent A.D. 1147 for the 
 artists in enamel to complete the enrichment of his 
 
230 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 cathedral of St. Denis, near Paris. The extent to 
 which glass painting had reached by his time is illus- 
 trated by the statement that his windows "are the 
 works of skilled masters from various nations." In 
 Suger's own account of the administration of his abbey 
 he describes the windows as inlaid with sapphires, 
 which reminds one of the habit in very ancient days of 
 calling glass objects by the names of the jewels they 
 imitated ; and he states that the treasury of his abbey 
 was opened to the glass painters. With regard to the 
 use of valuable materials in the production of glass we 
 may remember what Pliny wrote about the finest glass 
 of the East that it was made with rock crystal ; and, 
 nearer to our own time, that the same process was 
 used in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries in 
 the best glass-houses of Venice j 1 but Suger's record 
 is very positive about it, as he writes " vitri vestiti, 2 
 et saphirorum materiae ; . . . materiam saphirorum 
 locupletem administravit" The use of rock crystal 
 in glass making is at once understood from that crystal 
 being the purest natural form of silica, the funda- 
 mental material of glass ; and the use of sapphires 
 is simply explained on reference to the directions of 
 Theophilus, where in his twelfth chapter he directs how 
 the deep blue glass was to be made which forms the 
 characteristic ground and diapers of the early windows 
 of that time, and of the twelfth and thirteenth centuries 
 generally as at Canterbury, Chartres, Cologne, etc., which 
 he describes as being made from " saphireum " pro- 
 duced from tesserae of " pagan mosaics " the " saphiri 
 Greci pounded between two porphyry slabs," which 
 melted down and spread and fused upon a sheet of 
 
 1 King, Precious Stones, p. 345. 
 
 2 "Vitri vestiti," coated glass ; i.e. a sheet of white glass with another of 
 sapphire or ruby fused together. Ruby glass was made in this manner 
 throughout the middle ages, and in modern times other colours are so 
 treated for effects of abrasion. 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 231 
 
 white glass formed " tables of sapphire very precious," 
 " and useful in windows ;" not that all blue glass was 
 made out of the tesserae of despoiled mosaics, for 
 similar tesserae and other objects of the same colour 
 were at that time commonly used in the East and at 
 Constantinople, whence his technical traditions had 
 come, and where the secrets of the craft were preserved 
 from the treasury of antiquity. Those cubes of blue 
 glass which Theophilus describes as saphiri Greci would 
 have ranked as gems in Suger's collection, and were 
 without doubt the reputed sapphires used by his glass 
 painters. 
 
 Such was the novel and startling development of 
 fine art at that time that the splendour-loving abbot 
 found himself the object of severest criticism. He had 
 been for long associated with royalty, as the favourite 
 of Louis le Gros, and at his death the regent for the 
 young Louis VII. ; his tastes had been trained to the 
 standard of all that their courts and wealth could pro- 
 duce, and as Abbot of St. Denis it was but consistent 
 with such an education to lavish all that the arts of his 
 time could produce to complete his abbey church. But 
 this burst of artistic splendour brought him under 
 the lash of the great Cistercian St. Bernard, Abbot of 
 Clairvaux, who remonstrated with severity worthy of 
 his order, launching at him a quotation from Persius, 
 " Say, O high priests, what place has gold in the sanctu- 
 ary ? " and " But I say, tell me, O ye poor, what worth 
 has gold in the holy place ? your church glitters with 
 wealth upon its walls, but it is barren to the poor ; 
 . . . He has covered his stones with gold, and has left 
 his children naked ! " Such words and sentiments 
 with all their worth and weight, were the expressions, 
 and not impossibly the exaggerated expressions of the 
 great leader of a religious order whose practice was 
 regulated upon the severest of self-imposed poverty ; 
 
232 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 for the special characteristic of such institutions as the 
 Abbey of St. Denis was, even to a fault, the ministry 
 and doles of charity, and attendance on the sick poor. 
 On that very ground, therefore, such denunciations as 
 those of the great St. Bernard have been ignored or 
 contradicted by the enthusiasm of all generations of 
 men, whose impulse repudiated such limits, and who, in 
 the spirit of that ancient wisdom which had grouped as 
 three Graces, the true, the beautiful, and the good, have 
 through all time expressed their devotion by offering 
 their best ; that best being the most beautiful they could 
 find, their spontaneous, most natural, and truest sacrifice. 
 Such men as have covered their temple walls with 
 gold have not been commonly such as left their breth- 
 ren naked. Even the Cistercians soon yielded to the 
 inevitable impulse ; and dissatisfied with that beauti- 
 ful grisaille of silvery white glass which was due to 
 their influence, and adopted far and wide in the thir- 
 teenth century, soon yielded to the common craving for 
 colour ; and in their windows were painted, contrary to 
 all his orders, the figure of their own St. Bernard, and 
 panels, pictured with all the incidents of his life ; and 
 we who in England can grieve over the ruins of the 
 Cistercian Tintern, have at least in them the fairest 
 architectural example of what the beauty-loving genius of 
 their Order could produce ; and in the eastern windows 
 of Lichfield Cathedral we see the consummation at 
 which their art of glass painting could arrive, in the glass 
 brought there from the desecrated Cistercian convent 
 of Herckenrode. Such works were interdicted when in 
 the first days of their piety their convent was estab- 
 lished in the twelfth century, for in their cartularies are 
 preserved these severe injunctions of their founder, 
 " Let the glass of their windows be white, without 
 pictures or crosses, ... let not sculptures and paint- 
 ings be made in any of our churches or monasteries ; 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 233 
 
 we interdict them, because while attention is drawn to 
 them, the use of profitable meditation, and the discipline 
 of religious gravity is apt to be neglected"; 1 but the 
 experience of life and human infirmity appears to have 
 taught them, as it has taught others, that fine art 
 inspired by sacred motive is most useful, not only to 
 teach the ignorant, but to fill the void of vacant 
 minds. 
 
 Thus began the career of that art which every- 
 where followed in close companionship with pointed 
 architecture from east to west, developing its styles side 
 by side with it, assimilating the best of its crisp and 
 graceful ornament, and combining more than any other 
 of the associated arts with the beauty of architectural 
 effect. Those styles were as much marked by special 
 technicalities as by their variety of artistic composi- 
 tion. The glass painter used no colours, but taking 
 the various tints and hues produced by the glass- 
 founder, he painted upon them in monochrome, 
 producing by the simple process of a few dark 
 lines a perfect clearness of design, that left the 
 transparency of the glass unimpeded, glowing like 
 a sheet of jewelry. This was pre-eminently the 
 case in the earliest style ; for then the medallions in 
 which the figure subjects were designed were so 
 crowded, or the figures themselves so small, that at the 
 most moderate distance the whole window resolved 
 itself into a display of jewels ; as though the object of 
 the artist had been less to illustrate a story than to 
 glorify the sacred place by the splendour of its illumina- 
 tion. After a while this system was modified by im- 
 provement in the art of drawing, when single and 
 grouped figures became more prominent, and archi- 
 tectural accessions and canopies took such a place in 
 the design as to suggest that the architect himself had 
 
 1 Annaks Cistercienses. Lyons, 1642. 
 
234 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 drawn them. If we may judge from the works of 
 Wilars de Honecort, 1 an architect of the I3th century, 
 who has left among his drawings scores of studies of 
 figures, draperies, and proportion, the figures in the 
 windows may sometimes have been the work of the 
 architect also ; for in those days he was apt to be more 
 than in name alone the chief artist. Arts were less 
 subdivided in those times than they are now, so the 
 glass painter often embraced in his work the whole art 
 of his profession from the first preparation of the glass 
 to the painting of the finished window ; as in the case 
 of the Alsatian glass painter Jean de Kirkheim, who 
 had executed great works in Strasburg Cathedral 
 (about A.D. 1340), where he is described as "Vitreator 
 factor vitrorum, glasseator, Pictor." 
 
 The interest of all such work done in England in 
 those times has been grievously impaired by the whole- 
 sale destruction of records, such as foreign abbeys and 
 other great establishments have been more fortunate in 
 preserving, unless some at least of our own still lie un- 
 disturbed beneath the sacred dust of the record office. 
 The violence of their destruction was, however, some- 
 times equalled by the ingenuity of their preservation, 
 as of those of Newstead Abbey which lay for centuries 
 unsuspected in the brass ball of its lectern, now stand- 
 ing in the choir of Southwell Minster. A story has 
 indeed been preserved in the cartularies of the Abbey of 
 Braine near Soissons of a painted window having been 
 sent in 1153 for the east end of that abbey by Matilda 
 of Boulogne, Queen of King Stephen of England (or 
 by her order previous to her death in 1152) to Agnes 
 de Baudemont (" sa parente "), foundress of that abbey ; 
 but no more is known of it ; and whether the glass 
 were of English work or not is not recorded. The 
 
 1 Facsimile of the Sketchbook of Vilars de Honecort. London. 
 Willis. 1859. 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 235 
 
 church is now a ruin. There is no doubt that much 
 glass used in England at that time was foreign, as for 
 instance the windows for Rivaulx Abbey, which were 
 sent from France in 1 140. It is not known where the 
 contemporary windows were painted which William of 
 Malmesbury describes, with great admiration, in the choir 
 of Canterbury Cathedral, windows which must have 
 perished in the fire which destroyed the whole of the 
 choir in the year 1 174, nearly 30 years after his death ; 
 but the employment of a French architect, William of 
 Sens (at that time famous for its glass), to rebuild that 
 choir, significantly refers the association of art works in 
 that place to a foreign origin. The earliest recorded 
 commission for a painted window in England appears 
 to have been in the early part of the thirteenth century, 
 quoted by Horace Walpole, vol. i. p. 7, to the effect of 
 an order by Henry III. for the whitewashing of the 
 Chapel of St. John in the Tower, and for making three 
 glass windows in which were to be represented " a little 
 Virgin Mary holding the child, and the Trinity, and St. 
 John the Apostle." Very much painting was ordered 
 by the King as decorative work in rooms and chapels 
 at Woodstock, at Westminster, and Winchester, etc., 
 which suggests considerable artistic activity ; but there 
 is no reference that can clear up the nationality of the 
 artists. 
 
 The early glass painters in all countries appear 
 to have rarely signed their works. The few names 
 that I have already mentioned are preserved not in 
 windows but in archives ; the earliest known window 
 signature quoted by general writers being that of 
 Clement of Chartres (vitrearius Carnotensis) in a 
 window of the cathedral at Rouen (about A.D. 1270). 
 It is not till 1303 that we come upon the name of an 
 English glass painter which is preserved in the history 
 of Exeter Cathedral, where for 140 feet of painted 
 
236 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 glass and other such work in the windows there, "Walter 
 the glazier" was paid various sums. By reasonable 
 inference, work may be attributed to native artists in 
 the thirteenth century from the architectural style of 
 the designs, and by the character of drawing in known 
 English illuminated MSS. ; but by the end of that 
 century and beginning of the fourteenth there can be 
 no doubt about English glass painters ; for a few years 
 after Walter of Exeter, the name of Robert of York is 
 preserved, as having been paid in 1338 at the rate of 
 twelve pence per foot for his painted glass. 1 He 
 painted the great west window of York Cathedral. At 
 the close of that century (A.D. 1391) the name of 
 another glass painter is found among the records of 
 Exeter Cathedral, Robert Lyen, whose name rather 
 suggests a foreign origin ; but as he is designated 
 " glazier and citizen of Exeter," he may be accepted as 
 an Englishman ; his work was the present east window, 
 which is composed partly of his own work and partly 
 the adaptation of the former window ; and happily for 
 himself and for the good of his work he was paid by 
 yearly salary, and thus trusted to do his best as every 
 good artist ought to be ; and paid extra on some 
 detail in the use of old and new glass, and so much 
 weekly for an assistant. 2 
 
 The high estimation of men of this craft in former 
 times has been signalised by the special protection and 
 liberties granted to them ; as by an edict of Constan- 
 tine A.D. 337 the "vitrarii and diatritarii " (artificers 
 and artists in glass and glass cutting) were associated 
 with architects and painters in exemptions from all 
 public taxes and imposts. In the same manner the 
 Emperors Theodosius and Valentinian relieved the 
 artists in glass and mosaic from all public charges. 
 
 1 Weale's Quarterly Papers, vol. i. 
 
 2 Vide Britton's History of Exeter Cathedral. 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 237 
 
 At Venice the master glaziers of Murano were honoured 
 by high social privileges, admitting them to inter- 
 marriage with the Venetian nobility, and to the rank 
 of nobles with their titles inscribed in their Libro d'oro. 
 The island was governed by magistrates independent 
 of Venice, and by a special code of laws, one of which 
 assigned the penalty of death to any one who disclosed 
 the secrets of the craft. Both Charles V. and Charles 
 VI. of France granted special liberties to glass painters 
 " peintres vitriers," that they should be free of all taxes 
 and rates " garde de porte, guet, arriere guet, et autres 
 subventions quelconques," A.D. 1390. In Lorraine the 
 " gentilshommes verriers " received the right of nobility 
 from the Dukes of Lorraine in the fifteenth century. 
 In Normandy they possessed local privileges of freedom 
 and social position as "gentilshommes artistes verriers 
 Normans." Early in the fifteenth century Rene, King 
 of Anjou, was a patron of this art, and himself an adept 
 at it ; as described among the incidents of his varied 
 life, when made prisoner in 1430 by the Count Vaude- 
 mont, he was imprisoned at Dijon, where he relieved 
 his tedious hours by glass painting, some of his subjects 
 being portraits of Philippe le Bon and himself, and orna- 
 mental designs principally the emblazonment of coats 
 of arms, which were subsequently presented to the 
 chapel of the Chartreuse and preserved there. Of all 
 window inscriptions, York Cathedral contains one of 
 the most remarkable, showing the social position of the 
 glass painter of the day, when the knighted mayor ot 
 that city, Sir John Pety, was also the glass painter of 
 its cathedral, and of other churches in his city. The 
 opportunity has been taken of making one of his works 
 in the cathedral a memorial to him, by the introduction 
 of a kneeling figure of himself and an inscription be- 
 neath it to this effect, " Orate pro" anim& Johannis Pety, 
 glasiarii et Majoris Ebor : qui obiit I2th Nov. 1508." 
 
238 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 In no country has the destruction of works of this 
 frail art been at once so wanton and lamentable as in 
 Italy. Those works were numerous and beautiful, 
 some of them from the hands of Italy's greatest masters, 
 but they have disappeared no one knows how, or left to 
 perish from indifference. There was no excuse, as 
 elsewhere, of religious fanaticism or political revolution ; 
 for art was a common ground of peace, and even the 
 ferocity of Italian passion paused before it, and ven- 
 geance found no pleasure in its destruction. It was an 
 art that had not at once captivated the national taste, 
 as elsewhere in Christendom. With the general use of 
 mosaic and wall painting, rude as they were between 
 the decline and revival of the fifth and twelfth centuries, 
 Italian interiors needed no artifice of coloured light to 
 make them pleasant, or to alter the beauty of their 
 natural sunshine. Coloured glass was used as an ele- 
 ment of wealth and splendour in a few grand basilicas, 
 but such was the native indifference to it that when 
 Venice, its chief emporium for glass, developed its 
 works, glass painting made no part, and coloured win- 
 dow glass but an insignificant part among its industries. 
 The Venetians were pre-eminently colourists, but in 
 their use of glass it is remarkable that throughout 
 Venetian territory their windows are, with rare excep- 
 tions, white. Like pointed architecture, glass painting 
 was in Italy an imported art, and its earliest known 
 works bear such marks of northern relationship that 
 the rich jewelry of the windows of San Francesco 
 d'Assisi would have graced with equal consistency the 
 choirs and chapels of Canterbury or Chartres. The 
 effect of a few fragments of classic art in the Campo 
 Santo at Pisa upon Niccola Pisano is well known. It 
 marked the revival of true art in Italy : and so too 
 with other arts, the works and styles of their northern 
 neighbours, which, on entirely independent principles, 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 239 
 
 and with a genius specially its own, had grown up 
 and developed before and during his life (1207-78), 
 sufficed to suggest to the appreciative Italian sense the 
 artistic expression of a prevailing and popular idea. 
 So glass painting was accepted and flourished. The 
 literary notices of it are numerous, occurring in local 
 histories, and in biographies, often where least expected. 
 They abound in archives of ancient establishments, 
 recording the names of the artists, the patrons, the 
 subjects, and often the contract of price and time 
 allowed. 
 
 Among the memorials of Florence there is preserved 
 an account of a convent outside the Porta a Pinti, form- 
 erly occupied by a community of the order of the 
 Gesuati. It had been known by the name of S. Giusto 
 alle mura> from its having been built against the walls 
 of the city, and was thus exposed to the ravages of the 
 siege in 1529, when it was entirely ruined. The 
 monks had established themselves therein 1383, and 
 the tenor of their occupations suggests a pleasant picture 
 among the episodes of conventual life. They were 
 famous for their ingenuity in various arts, " in opere di 
 mano eccellenti," and among them pre-eminently for 
 glass painting. Their workroom is described as having 
 a good light on the second floor, and beside it they 
 had their distillery for scents and medicines, and for 
 the preparation of colours. Their prior prepared with 
 his own hands the ultramarine for Pietro Perugino for 
 the frescoes which he painted on the walls of the con- 
 vent ; and for Michael Angelo, upon his undertaking 
 the frescoes on the vaulting of the Sistine Chapel in 
 the Vatican. 1 They produced also all manner of plea- 
 sant things " for the convenience and comforts of life," 
 
 1 Among the Buonarotti archives at Florence occurs the following 
 letter from Michael Angelo to the prior of the Gesuati at Florence : 
 
 " FRATE JACOPO I, being about to cause to be painted certain things 
 here, or to paint them, it occurs to me to let you know that I have need 
 
240 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 which Lastri 1 describes as " the best and finest that 
 could be imagined ;" but although occupied by the 
 special rule of their order in numerous avocations, 
 including those already mentioned, and embroidery, 
 architecture both civil and military, and engineering, 
 they were more especially known as " Frati dipintori di 
 vetri da finestre" (Brethren painters of glass for win- 
 dows), and for their works at Florence, Perugia, Arezzo, 
 Pisa, and elsewhere, some of the leading artists of the 
 day furnished them with designs, among whom were Fr. 
 Granacci, a pupil of Ghirlandajo, and Pietro Perugino. 
 Other conventual establishments of Florence had also 
 their glass painters of great eminence at that time, and 
 among them one Fra Bernardino di Stefano of Santa 
 Maria Novella, who is called in the necrology of the 
 convent " Magister fenestraram vitrearum optimus," the 
 best of glass painters, who painted the great circular 
 window (still in its place) of the fagade of the cathedral 
 at Florence, from the designs of Ghiberti, and two 
 others in the clerestory of the nave, from designs by 
 the same hand. 
 
 That art had by this time attained a place of high 
 consideration ; indeed before the end of the fourteenth 
 century it had won the national taste throughout 
 northern and central Italy ; but like pointed architec- 
 ture, it rarely penetrated the south. Siena and Pisa 
 had their schools of this art ; and in the former place 
 occurs one of the few known window signatures of 
 Italian glass painters of the fourteenth century, viz., 
 that of " Jacopo Castelli," an artist of Siena, in a win- 
 dow of the church of S. Francesco at Pisa in 1390. 
 
 of a certain quantity of beautiful blues, and if you can serve me through 
 your brethren here with the quantity which you have, of fine quality and 
 at a just price, before taking it I will pay you here or there as you prefer. 
 Yours, MICHELAGNIOLO Sculptor, Rome. 
 
 "May 13, 1508." 
 
 1 Uosservatore Fiorentino. 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 241 
 
 Of the school of Pisa many artists names have been 
 preserved, among whom are the two who, about the 
 year 1460, filled with their painted glass the arcade on 
 two sides of the Campo Santo, for the preservation of 
 the frescoes there from the action of the sea breezes, by 
 name B- da Scarperia and Leonardo, a Florentine. 
 Among others of that school was one B. Pollini, a Sar- 
 dinian by birth, whose fame is preserved in the annals of 
 the convent of Santa Caterina, as a great glass painter, 
 " fenestras vitreas operabatur optime," but as a man 
 also of such accomplishments as would have well quali- 
 fied him for a fellowship in the graceful society of the 
 Oxford College of All Souls in the palmy days of past 
 generations, for he is described in the same annals as 
 " a man highly esteemed, pure in mind, refined in 
 manners, and charming in conversation ; he sang well, 
 he wrote beautifully, and was master of his art." l He 
 died about 1340. 
 
 This art had its Beato Angelico in the person of a 
 young German artist, afterwards known as Fra Beato 
 Giacomo d'Ulma, the son of a merchant at Ulm, whose 
 education in mechanical arts had trained his hand for 
 the neat technicality of glass painting, to which the 
 taste and aptitude of his youth had drawn him. Being 
 impelled by strong religious fervour to visit the tomb 
 of the apostles at Rome, he arrived there at the age of 
 twenty-five in 1432 ; but his means failing for want of 
 employment, he entered the military service of King 
 Alphonso at Naples. This mode of life, however, 
 proved most distasteful to him, and after four years he 
 travelled homeward, stopping at Bologna, where he 
 entered the order of Frati Predicatori of the convent of 
 S. Domenico ; and there he spent a devoted life, suc- 
 ceeding, as, his biographer says, "some other saintly 
 men have done, in making the pursuit of art a means 
 
 1 Michele, Memorie dei Pittori Domenicani, v., p. 350, text and note. 
 
 R 
 
242 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 toward the perfection of religious life." Here he 
 resumed his favourite art, and after a long life left 
 many important works, of which the best known are 
 the great windows in the church of S. Petronio, exe- 
 cuted with the assistance of his favourite pupils Frati 
 Ambrogino and Anastasio, in his adopted city Bologna. 
 A very different man from this saintly German 
 was the Frenchman from Verdun, whose story has been 
 well told by Vasari, under the name of Guglielmo di 
 Marcilla. The occasion of his coming to Italy was the 
 building at the Vatican for Pope Julius II. by Bra- 
 mante, which that pope required to be decorated with 
 painted glass, for which Raphael had furnished the de- 
 signs, and having heard great accounts of a Frenchman 
 of the name of Claude, he invited him to Rome. 1 
 Guglielmo was a friend of this Claude, and so accom- 
 plished in all the technicality of his art that Claude 
 persuaded him to accompany him. Guglielmo had 
 entered the Dominican order, not like the Beato Gia- 
 como for religious reasons, but to escape the secular 
 courts of justice, with which he was threatened for an 
 unfortunate affair in which he had been accidentally 
 implicated. When this trouble had blown over, so far 
 as he was concerned, he yielded to Claude's persuasions, 
 and throwing up his conventual obligations he went to 
 Rome. Not long after their arrival, Claude died of 
 
 1 These windows were destroyed at the siege of Rome by the Conne- 
 table de Bourbon in 1527, to make bullets of the lead in which the glass 
 was set. The loss of them is the more to be regretted because the 
 account of them that they were not only executed under the direction of 
 Raphael, but from his designs, is probably true. The direction of all 
 decorative art at the Vatican was consigned to him by Julius II., and to 
 such as Raphael whose art was universal, and nothing too great or too 
 small for it, designs for glass painting would have been but a slight addi- 
 tion to the list. He designed for tapestry as of those of Hampton Court, 
 for carving and inlaid woodwork as in the fine tarsiatura of the church of 
 the Casinensi at Perugia, for mosaic as in the church of Santa Maria del 
 Popolo at Rome, as an architect at the Vatican, and a sculptor in the 
 figure of Jonah in the Chigi chapel, which is by his hand. His only re- 
 corded design for glass is thus unhappily lost. 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 243 
 
 fever, leaving his responsibilities to his companion, who 
 from deficiency of artistic education was thrown into 
 much difficulty. He had the wisdom, however, to 
 place himself at once under tuition, and applying all 
 he learned to his own special art, he attained such 
 eminence, that his works have been allowed by universal 
 judgment to be the masterpieces of that art in Italy. 
 Marchese in his lives of Dominican artists confirms 
 this opinion, for when writing of a certain Fra Barto- 
 lomeo of Perugia (who was elected Superior of the 
 Dominican convent there in 1413), as the greatest of 
 native Italian glass painters, after a description of one 
 special work by him in the church of San Domenico, 
 he says of it that " such were its merits in size, compo- 
 sition, and colour, as to yield to none in Italy save only 
 those in Arezzo by Giuglielmo di Marcillat." 
 
 The stages of progress in this art had been much 
 the same north and south of the Alps ; the character 
 of the advance from the thirteenth to the fourteenth 
 century having been from exclusive conventionalism to 
 Nature, from the fourteenth to the fifteenth that of 
 improvement in the higher qualities of design, and in 
 the following century by the introduction of the use of 
 coloured glass enamels, affording to the glass painter 
 as varied a palette as the painter in oil. Guglielmo 
 adopted this system completely. His ambition was to 
 rival in glass all the efforts of the picture and wall 
 painter ; and such was his success that Vasari writes 
 in admiration, especially of his works at Cortona and 
 Arezzo, that " one would say that they were composed 
 of living figures and not of coloured and transparent 
 glass, but in truth marvellous pictures." Whether such 
 elaboration was the proper province of so frail a material 
 as glass was a question that these works soon settled 
 in his mind, for he threw up the art and turned fresco 
 painter. 
 
244 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 It is remarkable how much the success of this art 
 in Italy was due to northern influence. Notwith- 
 standing its popularity and the eminence in it of many 
 native artists, the invigoration of its styles was greatly 
 due to the infusion of new blood from beyond the Alps. 
 Its best materials were imported ; as Vasari says, the 
 best glass for it came from Germany, France, and 
 England, and the best smalti, i.e. coloured enamels, 
 were German. With rare exception, the artists who 
 left the greatest mark upon their age were foreign, or 
 the Italian pupils of foreign masters ; as the Beato 
 Giacomo from Ulm and the school which he established 
 at Bologna, and Claude and Guglielmo from France, 
 and Pastorino, the pupil of the latter, who executed the 
 great window of the facade of Siena Cathedral from the 
 design attributed to Perino del Vaga (1548-49). At 
 Venice and Treviso a German monk of the minor order 
 of Franciscans, who was known as the Frater Teutonicus, 
 seems to have been the leading spirit of his art in all 
 that neighbourhood early in the fourteenth century. His 
 works became the models of the art, and the copies of 
 them are described as having been carried out in due 
 respect to him, "pictse ad modum Teutonicum ;" 
 numerous works elsewhere are attributed to another 
 foreigner, Luca d'Ollanda, an ideal name, that through- 
 out Italy covers a multitude from Germany and the 
 north. 
 
 Baldinucci, in his Life of Lorenzo Ghiberti, and giving 
 an account of the windows in the cathedral of Florence, 
 writes that Ghiberti'was not only one of the greatest 
 of Italian sculptors, but " being curious in everything 
 appertaining to the arts, he turned his attention to the 
 noble work of that kind of painting which is called the 
 mosaic of coloured glass." Ghiberti, not satisfied with 
 the Italian glass and its painters, having heard of a 
 Florentine who had begun his education as a glass 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 245 
 
 painter in the convent of the Gesuati at Florence, and 
 had perfected his art at Lubec, represented the case to 
 the council of the Operai. In Lastri's Osservatore 
 Florentine is given the text of a document drawn up 
 by this council of artificers in 1436, resolving that this 
 accomplished glass painter should be invited to Florence 
 to paint the windows " in Sa. Maria del Fiore ; that he 
 should be brought with all his family without cost, and 
 be protected from all harm and loss, that he might 
 work in security, and that his art might reflect honour 
 on his native Florence." Ghiberti designed the win- 
 dows, and Livi da Gambasso painted them " in his 
 German manner" The window representing the corona- 
 tion of the Virgin was also painted by him from the 
 design of Donatello. 
 
 The grand ruins which add the poetry of regret to 
 the natural beauty of Scotch scenery must once have 
 possessed windows glowing with this art. Two years 
 before the eminent glass painter, just mentioned, Livi da 
 Gambasso came to Florence, in reply to the invitation 
 dated in 1436, he was at work in Scotland. Among 
 the same archives is preserved a letter dated August 
 26, 1434, addressed to him in Scotland, pressing him 
 to come to Florence. It is there recorded as a " Letter 
 written to the master glass painter Gambassi, then in 
 Scotland, and who made works in glass of various 
 kinds, and was held to be the best glass painter in the 
 world." That such an artist should have been engaged 
 there implies no ordinary estimation of that art in 
 Scotland, nor would an artist of such eminence have 
 attended to any but invitations from important persons 
 and for important works. But all have perished, and 
 the record of them is lost. 1 
 
 1 The writer on this subject in the Ency. Brit., vol. x. p. 670, Mr. 
 Heath Wilson, himself a Scotchman, thus concludes his notice, "It is 
 now vain to express the feeling with which Scotch people must regret the 
 destruction of the works of this excellent artist in Holyrood Chapel." The 
 
246 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 The colour-loving Spaniards had of old been suc- 
 cessful in their production of artistic glass, in which, in 
 the time of the Roman empire, they had been acknow- 
 ledged to have rivalled the works at Rome. In Chris- 
 tian times, with the introduction of pointed architecture, 
 they revived the art in its wider form of ornamental 
 windows, but neither so early, nor with the help of 
 designs by their more distinguished native artists, as 
 was the case in Italy. The names of numerous Spanish 
 glass painters have been preserved, but among those 
 who followed that art in Spain so many have foreign 
 designations, or by their names are so evidently of 
 northern origin, such as Mercier, Ulrich, Arnao de 
 Flandre, Albert and Nicolas de Holanda, Karl de Bruga, 
 etc., as to show how Spain, no less than Italy, had 
 availed itself of the genius of the north. 
 
 The glass in its cathedrals are as pure as can be 
 found in Europe ; but the detail of its history is not so 
 easily obtained as elsewhere. Toledo had been famous for 
 its painted glass as early as the thirteenth century ; and 
 from the recorded names of its artists, there appears 
 to have been a continuous succession of native and 
 Flemish glass painters there from the beginning of the 
 fifteenth to that of the eighteenth century ; indeed the 
 art had become such a complete speciality there that 
 the chapter of the cathedral established a school of it 
 in 1542, with the provision for a continuous professor- 
 ship. The windows in that cathedral are very numerous, 
 as might be supposed in so great a building of five 
 aisles, besides their projected chapels ; the glass, which 
 
 best relics of old Scotch glass are heraldic, of which several exist in the 
 chapel of St. M. Magdalene, Cowgate, Edinburgh, of about A.D. 1556, 
 and a few others elsewhere, as in Fyvie Castle, Aberdeenshire, dated 
 "Alex. Seton, Lord Fyvie, 1599." In the Stoball Chapel, Cargill, near 
 Perth, some scraps of very rich colours are preserved in the windows. A 
 small portion of coloured glass was found at Melrose Abbey in 1 742, vide 
 Proceedings Soc. Antiq.^ ii. 33, and others from Dunblane Cathedral and 
 Dunfermline Abbey. 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 247 
 
 is generally of high class, was painted by both native 
 and Flemish artists ; but here, at any rate, Spain holds 
 her own, the finest window being the work of a 
 Spaniard, Gonzalo de Cordova (1510-13). The 
 greatest loss of what by all accounts appear to have 
 been the finest works in Spain was at Burgos, where all 
 the glass of the cathedral was destroyed by an explo- 
 sion in the Castle in 1813. Near it a Carthusian 
 convent, known as " la Cartuja," illustrates the constant 
 reference to Flanders for glass, whence it was obtained 
 complete for insertion into its windows. It is still in 
 the chapel, but is not of the highest class. The most 
 eminent glass painter in Spain appears to have been 
 Micer Cristobal, who is designated as " Aleman " (i 504), 
 but whether he was German, as this would imply, or 
 French, is not certain, the designation Alengon being 
 also associated with his name. His works are in the 
 cathedral of Seville ; but at Avila, Barcelona, and 
 Leon, no less than at Seville and Toledo, and at 
 Oviedo, where the two wheel windows of the transepts 
 are famous works, Spanish artists took their honourable 
 share ; the last who was eminent among them being 
 Sanchez Martinez, who was appointed professor of the 
 school of glass painters at Toledo in 1713, where he 
 wrote a book upon his art, and dedicated it to the 
 chapter of the cathedral. 1 
 
 It would be tedious to attempt any adequate 
 account of the great works of this art in France, Ger- 
 many, Holland, and Belgium. Their masterpieces are 
 too numerous to be recorded here, or to find a place 
 for their worthy description. The special features of 
 every date and style in France, from the early windows 
 
 1 For notes about this art in various parts of Spain, written with much 
 artistic appreciation, vide O'Shea's Spain and Portugal. There is great 
 want of a history of this art in Spain. S. Martinez's book might have 
 been very valuable ; but, after diligent inquiry through the best sources, 
 I am unable to find any account of its publication. 
 
248 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 of Bourges and Chartres to the latest by Jean Cousin 
 and Pinaigrier, are too well known to need further 
 reference. 
 
 The cause of its decline was the same here as else- 
 where. The enamellers of Limoges had so developed 
 the production of colours for their art, that being also 
 glass painters, they introduced a system which became 
 universally popular, not only in France, but wherever 
 the art was followed. The ruby, the sapphire, the 
 emerald, the jasper, and other grand and simple colours 
 had been known by very ancient tradition ; and chem- 
 istry had done but little to effect any changes in the 
 art during the first four centuries of its development. 
 The warm tint that served as early as the thirteenth 
 century, if not earlier, for flesh, and the yellow stain 
 from silver, were among the few mediaeval additions to 
 the old list ; but at the beginning of the sixteenth 
 century a revolution overthrew the ancient practice, and 
 in place of the grand old-fashioned colours, white glass 
 came into use to be painted upon with enamels, as in 
 oil or water colour ; and new technicalities introduced 
 in the previous century now became universal, such as 
 the abrasion of colour on one side of the pane and 
 enamelling it with various colours on the other, and so 
 forth, till glass painting changed its function, and 
 produced cabinet pictures, landscape transparencies, 
 miniatures, and copies of the works of great masters in 
 oil and fresco, as when Bernard Palissy, whose greatest 
 fame had been as a discoverer in the art of coloured 
 pottery, painted on glass copies of Raphael's history of 
 Cupid and Psyche for the family of Montmorency at 
 Ecouen. 
 
 In the Netherlands the advance of chemical know- 
 ledge had equally prepared the way, as at Limoges, for 
 its application to the colouring of glass : and this style 
 of the art developed greatly in the time of Charles V. 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 249 
 
 and under the administration of Marguerite d'Autriche, 
 who greatly patronised the glass painters. Among the 
 greatest works thus executed were those in the cathedral 
 of St. Gudule at Brussels, where Jan Haeck and Bernard 
 von Orley, an artist of considerable merit also as an oil 
 painter, carried out this system with great effect, but 
 exhibiting the utter loss of that luminous colour that 
 had been the glory of days then gone by. 
 
 In Germany, from the earliest appearance of the 
 art in Europe to its decline, it had continued a national 
 favourite, and its most 'famous artists have left their 
 influence upon its compositions ; but they are not 
 always easily identified with their works for want of 
 signatures. Aldegrever, a Westphalian by birth, began 
 his early art experiences in France by designs for glass 
 painting. His signature is on some fine glass in the 
 choir of the church at Conches ; but he soon discon- 
 tinued this class of work, and entered the school of 
 engravers under Albert Durer at Nuremberg. Of 
 Albert Durer himself there is no doubt about his in- 
 fluence on this art, but no works can with certainty be 
 assigned to him ; the only ones with any probability of 
 truth being those on the north side of the nave of the 
 cathedral at Cologne, that are associated with his name. 
 His biographer describes him as " the founder of an im- 
 proved school of more correct perspective and archi- 
 tecture, and for sacred subjects, particularly for painted 
 glass ;" and, indeed, as he worked in so many arts, it is 
 fairly possible that this may have been one of them ; 
 especially as it is known from entries in his diary that 
 glass painters were among his intimate friends, where for 
 instance, in the year 1521, he has written "presented 
 to Master Aert, the glass painter, a copy of the life of 
 Our Lady ; " and in another place " I presented two 
 of my great works to Kcenig, the glass painter." Braun 
 and Dierrick, who had distinguished themselves in the 
 
250 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 same art, were also among his friends ; but with respect 
 to the personal history and the works of these men, the 
 loss by the violence of the Gueux outbreak at the 
 establishment of the Inquisition in that country by 
 Philip II., and the loss of all that is precious in the 
 authority of documentary history by the great fire at 
 Liege, is incalculable. 
 
 The influence of his school is noticeable far and 
 wide. The grand windows of St. Jaques at Liege bear 
 witness to it. Some of those in the church of Fair- 
 ford in Gloucestershire, have been attributed to him 
 from a casual remark by Van Dyck, who " came to 
 see the Fairford windows, and told me the drawing 
 was by Albert Durer ;" l those windows were brought 
 there between 1491 and 1500, at which last year 
 Albert Durer was twenty-nine years of age. But it is 
 not his genius alone that can be thus plainly traced : 
 for the refined style of the Van Eycks, and the still 
 more refined school of Hemling, left their fair impress 
 on the glass painting of their age. There are a good 
 many relics of what once were the works of this late 
 Flemish school in England ; and it would have been 
 well if there had been none other. The two Crabeths 
 at Gouda had carried their special style and technicality 
 to the utmost limit that it would bear ; and those who 
 developed a school upon their style, brought the art to 
 its inevitable close. In spite of all the faults of their 
 enamel system, and the qualities which distinguish the 
 Dutch school of figure painting, the works of the two 
 brothers Crabeth at Gouda have received much admir- 
 ation ; but whatever good they contain only deepens the 
 regret at their rejection of the great qualities that had 
 once distinguished the then declining art. One brother 
 
 1 Cough's Collection of Gloucestershire Papers. Bodleian Library, 
 Oxford, and The Fairford Windows, by Rev. T. G. Joyce, 1872. Van 
 Dyck's father was a glass painter. 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 251 
 
 had worked for the church under its Roman Catholic 
 masters, the other under the Protestants ; and Adrian 
 de Vriee rivalled him in a work in the church at Gouda 
 (then cathedral no more), composed with such freedom 
 as the veriest pagan would have scarcely surpassed, in 
 what has always since been known as " the liberty of 
 conscience " window. 
 
 England suffered from the imported works of their 
 followers, and of those of them who settled here. Van 
 Linge came to England in the time of James I. He 
 inherited a failing system, he brought bad principles, 
 and he left bad precedents. His dense enamels are 
 peeling off the glass : the result is offensive and irre- 
 mediable ; and those gloomy and inauspicious-looking 
 saints, who darken the windows of the chapel of Lin- 
 coln's Inn, are the last shadows which collect about his 
 expiring school. So much for the once-glowing and 
 beautiful art in glass. Its days were numbered. There 
 was, however, one man still, an Englishman of worthy 
 fame, one Godfrey, whose works were much admired in 
 France. But the spark could last no longer ; and in 
 spite of Sir James Thornhill's cartoons for William Price 
 at Oxford, the genuine and graceful talent of Mrs. 
 Pearson, and Sir Joshua Reynolds's designs for Thorn- 
 ton's window, of what Horace Walpole called "the 
 washy virtues," the last glimmer of this art died away. 
 
 The habit adopted by glass painters, alike in all 
 countries, of availing themselves occasionally of other 
 men's designs, must not be understood as detracting from 
 their merit ; for such designs made independently of the 
 knowledge of the peculiar exigencies of the art, could 
 only be rendered into glass by an ability of artistic and 
 technical character altogether special. In the rarest 
 instance would the drawing completed by a sculptor or 
 painter be possible in glass ; its detail might be undesir- 
 able, its refinements impossible, its colouring unsuitable. 
 
252 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 The art had a special skill and genius of its own, and 
 on them depended the success, whether the conception 
 of the subject or the drawing of it were the original 
 work of the actual glass painter, or, as in Italy, by the 
 distinguished men whose names have been mentioned ; 
 or, as more commonly the case in Germany, France, 
 and England, by those wandering artists of many 
 accomplishments who passed from abbey to abbey 
 illuminating their books, painting their walls or design- 
 ing for their windows, but whose names are lost to 
 fame. 
 
 The relics of this art are but remnants of the works 
 which ornamented the civic, palatial, and ecclesiastical 
 buildings of the middle ages ; and the words of lament 
 used by the biographer of the Beato Giacomo may be 
 well applied far and wide to countless other works than 
 his, where he writes, " one grieves at the unhappy con- 
 ditions of this art, of which the productions are allowed 
 no hope of enduring life, where the work of long study 
 and of infinite diligence is often in shortest time and 
 for slightest cause destroyed." Such expressions may 
 well expand upon a very wide horizon of regret in the 
 thought of what those works contained ; of how they 
 pictured not only the incidents of well-known secular 
 and sacred history, but illustrations also of such sub- 
 jects of local and personal interest and traditions as 
 once were familiar in the by-ways of a manuscript 
 literature long since lost ; of events and subjects which 
 occupied the thoughts and conversation of the best and 
 most intelligent men of their age, which made those 
 simple paintings precious, but are now lost among the 
 shadows of their common ruin. Beside all these there 
 were also figured the memorials of national and religious 
 customs, of civic ceremonials and domestic habits, of 
 costumes, manners, trade, and war, the incidents of 
 daily life, the condition of their arts, the architecture of 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 253 
 
 their streets, the decoration of their houses, and much 
 else that brought to the memory true records of the 
 past, rude perhaps in their representation, but touch- 
 ing by their simple familiarity gems of art that have 
 been left unheeded to perish with the annals they con- 
 tained. 
 
 This art so captivated public taste in the middle 
 ages as to affect the development of the great art 
 which at first it pretended only to adorn ; the archi- 
 tecture of that age so yielding to its charms as to 
 expand itself purposely for their display. Thus the 
 windows of the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries in- 
 creased in height and breadth ; and in the fourteenth 
 and fifteenth so universally did this fashion prevail that 
 the constructive principles of buildings were affected by 
 it, and all the weight of the groined roof and the 
 arcades within, and of the spires and towers without, 
 was left to rest on slender piers and flying buttresses, 
 which alone remained for their support, the solid walls 
 having given place to sheets of pictured glass. 
 
 The earliest form of this development was in the 
 great wheel windows, commonly placed at the ends of 
 transepts of important buildings, and occasionally at 
 the west end, filling up the whole interior space be- 
 neath the groining. Among the earliest of these was 
 the circular window of the north transept of Lincoln 
 Cathedral, part of the work of the great St. Hugh, 
 and dating from about or before A.D. 1200. The 
 wide central quatrefoil and numerous circular open- 
 ings in its pierced or plate tracery still contain their 
 original glass : the general subject of the whole series 
 being that of the Church triumphant, the outer circles 
 containing at the top the figure of our Lord in 
 majesty, seated on a rainbow ; and in the others 
 angels holding the instruments of the Passion, scenes 
 from the general Resurrection, and single figures of 
 
254 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 saints ; and in the large central space is a representa- 
 tion of Paradise, with Christ seated among the blessed. 
 
 The excellent effect of these wheel windows in- 
 duced their adoption by Gothic architects of all 
 countries during this and the following centuries, and 
 was probably, also, the origin of the development of 
 ordinary window-heads to the entire space under the 
 groining. Among the finest early specimens of this 
 fashion are the windows of the Ste. Chapelle at Paris, 
 the building of which was completed in 1248, and 
 the greater part of which contain their original glass. 
 The desire to obtain the greatest possible space for 
 these openings is well illustrated by the east window 
 of Gloucester Cathedral, where the walls of the most 
 eastern bay are sloped outwards to obtain an extra 
 space for the mouldings of the window frame, and 
 thus to secure the entire width of the choir for the 
 glass. This great window still contains its original 
 glass, dating from about A.D. 1370, the parts repaired 
 being supplied by old fragments from windows of the 
 clerestory and Lady Chapel. The subjects painted are 
 a series of single figures under canopies, with the group 
 of the coronation of the blessed Virgin above them. 
 
 This architectural development led to changes in 
 the artist's employment of the glass, and the greater 
 liberty thus obtained affected the character of its 
 painting and ornament. The improvement made in 
 the production of the glass itself and in the chemicals 
 of its colouring, and the advance in design and draw- 
 ing, combined to enlarge the whole sphere of the 
 subjects and treatment ; so the artists, no longer 
 confined by the comparative costliness of the materials 
 and the small pieces which, in the earlier styles, they 
 had to deal with, adopted a more ambitious course, 
 and drawing more directly upon nature for their com- 
 positions, with freer minds and freer pencils, they de- 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 255 
 
 lighted the world with the enthusiasm of that mingled 
 piety and genius that added living fire to the glory of 
 their work. 
 
 But this liberty brought danger with it, as liberty 
 always does where high principle is sapped by ambi- 
 tion. Their sphere enlarged, their knowledge and 
 skill developed, exhibited themselves in the charm 
 of individual expression. Their figures had more 
 truth, their draperies more grace, their detail more 
 exactness, their ornament more wealth ; their com- 
 positions, enlarged in scale, looked no longer like a 
 mosaic of transparent gems, but a picture and a 
 representation that interpreted itself by the clearness 
 of its pictorial composition, whether far or near, and 
 thus, with a subtlety scarcely noticed by themselves, 
 their work approached a naturalism and a pictorial 
 reality that was at last the ruin of their art. It 
 happily took centuries before that degradation brought 
 it to its close. It had been by that thoroughly archi- 
 tectonic sense which prevailed in its earlier phases, 
 and till the closing years of the fifteenth century, that 
 this noble art, with all the dignified reserve of self- 
 respect, had held its right place among its compeers ; 
 but as time advanced it happened with it, as with 
 other things, that the idea of development became 
 confounded with that of progress, and a system was 
 introduced which delighted the unthinking popular 
 sense with much that was admirable in the strictest 
 sense of art, and glorious in effect, but with it also 
 a loss of principle and a flattery of ambition that 
 brought it to a lingering but certain fall. 
 
 No change more lamentable can overtake an art than 
 that which tempts it to a sphere not properly its own. 
 It is a fundamental principle in art that all its pro- 
 ductions are subject to the restrictions which the 
 nature of their materials and the nature of human 
 
256 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 sight impose. We have now to do with an art 
 which is especially connected with those of architec- 
 ture and of picture with the former as an adjunct 
 and ornament, with the latter as a sister art of colour 
 and design, but the nature of glass itself differs from 
 anything else that these arts have to do with. Both 
 these arts are based on definite principles and bound 
 by definite limitations. Let a picture be black as 
 night or fresh as morning, severe or sketchy, it will 
 be good only if it have not transgressed the laws of 
 chiaroscuro, of form and colour, and of linear and 
 atmospheric perspective all of which involve prin- 
 ciples that are inviolable ; and beyond them no good 
 work of picture painting ever was or ever can be 
 produced. They are the natural laws of the materials 
 in relation to sight. The other art, architecture, 
 whether classic, Gothic, modern, or aught else, has 
 equally its laws and limits. It cannot without ruin 
 trangress the powers of its own materials, nor can it, 
 without offence, violate that science of numbers which 
 we call proportion. Is, then, glass painting to be free 
 of all control the only art let loose in the vanity of 
 unmitigated fancy ? 
 
 Pictorial effect is a quality common to sculpture, 
 picture, mosaic, and glass, though different in each. 
 In the two first it is always regulated by the space 
 it occupies. No figure-painter, no sculptor of alto 
 or basso relievo, would so treat a subject, extending 
 over a series of distinct spaces, as to ignore the forms 
 of the architectural construction which bounded them. 
 Each group would be complete ; their connection 
 would be made by the interest of their story. The 
 metopes of the Parthenon, to a certain degree, illus- 
 trate this. It is much to be regretted that glass 
 painters are impatient of this law, which binds all 
 other arts. They also violate the very nature of their 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 257 
 
 own materials in the attempted pictorial effects of 
 atmosphere. These are attainable only by modula- 
 tion of colour and loss of outline ; and neither of 
 these are properly producible, for modulation is im- 
 possible where every piece of glass is of a different 
 tint, and loss of outline is impossible where every 
 piece is held in its place by a black frame of lead. 
 It is answered that these effects are possible, and 
 easily produced by painting in coloured enamels. 
 Let the answer hold good ; but we come then to 
 the question of other limits limits of the right and 
 wrong of human labour, and limits of the duty to 
 human sight. Excessive " finish" is not a necessary 
 quality of high art ; the highest art is that in which 
 the greatest conception is the best expressed. The 
 too high-wrought picture in glass condemns itself by 
 the prodigality of human labour on a material so 
 fragile that the least injury would mar it ; and, if 
 the artist were dead or distant, it would be irre- 
 parable. It condemns itself also by offering such 
 work as no eye can rest upon to analyse without pain 
 and fatigue. The fault of ambition lies in the pre- 
 tension of an unjustifiable independence. If the 
 glass painter be impatient of all limits, whether of 
 architecture or of the special qualities of his own 
 materials limits, too, of the pleasure, power, or en- 
 durance of human sight and the use or abuse of his 
 labour let him throw up his art and take to canvas. 
 Then he may labour without stint and satiate the eye 
 without fatigue ; but if he is to be a glass painter, let 
 him honour his own art, and neither borrow the 
 specialities nor wander into the province of another. 
 
 With respect to this beautiful art, I must venture 
 to repeat what I have said of painting in other forms, 
 that it is an insult to art that all its forms and phases 
 should be forced into one groove or ground to one 
 
 s 
 
258 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 level. A perfect work of art must be thought out in 
 its own language. A picture-painter rarely designs 
 well for glass, because he cannot think in glass, and 
 he is often a bad judge of works in glass for the like 
 reason that he is always thinking in his own art- 
 language, and mistakes for good what another art has 
 borrowed and mimicked from his own. Hence it 
 comes to pass that this beautiful art of glass painting is 
 often misconceived both by artists and by the public. 
 The art, with all its limitations, is large enough to 
 open a field for ever to real genius. A man cannot 
 draw too well for it, nor think too poetically ; only let 
 him remember ivhat he has for the translation of his 
 thoughts glass, lead, and light 
 
 The history of this art in England has as yet been 
 but imperfectly written. There are materials for it, 
 scattered and miscellaneous as they are, not for mere 
 records and dry descriptions of the works themselves, 
 most of which now lie in their ruins, sacred to the 
 memory of the Reformation and the Protectorate, but 
 rather for a book which would sketch the ins and outs 
 of artistic life in England in the middle ages, its styles 
 and schools, its connection with foreign countries, its 
 patronage, its roving confraternities, and so forth. It 
 might bring together in this way a mingled mass of 
 anecdote, archaeology, and memoir, which would fill 
 very agreeably a gap that is still left open in English 
 literature. 
 
 Some references have already been made to English 
 glass painters. Of later ones, John Thornton, the 
 " glazyer " of Coventry, was the most famous. He 
 undertook the great east window of York Cathedral in 
 1405, and left a monument of genuine English work 
 as fine as any foreign school of the age could produce, 
 executed, as by the words of his contract he agreed, 
 " to portray the said windows with his own hand, and 
 
viz ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 259 
 
 the histories, images, and other things to be painted in 
 it." The subjects of his work range over a wide page 
 of sacred writ. At the top is a small figure of Christ 
 in majesty, with figures of saints and angels in the 
 tracery below it; then subjects selected from the creation 
 to the death of Absalom, and below them scenes from 
 the book of the Revelation, and individual dignitaries 
 of Church and State. 
 
 At a later date it became common for the " glaziers," 
 i.e. the providers and painters of the glass, to be supplied 
 with designs from other and sometimes foreign hands, 
 as in the contract for the Beauchamp Chapel at Warwick 
 with J. Prudde, glazier of Westminster, in which it is 
 agreed that he rt shall embellish matters, images, and 
 stories that shall be delivered and appointed by the 
 said executors by patterns in paper ... to be pictured 
 in rich colours at the charges of the said glazier." 
 
 Another similar contract for thus providing the 
 design is authorised by the will of King Henry VII. 
 for his chapel at Westminster, that " the stories, images," 
 etc., for the window be " redily devised and in picture 
 delivered to ... the master of the works of Our said 
 Chapel." One of the glaziers thus employed was a 
 man who acquired well -merited fame, one Bernard 
 Flower, who was also engaged in a contract for some 
 of the windows of Henry VIII.'s Chapel at King's 
 College, Cambridge. These were executed between 
 the years 1526 and 1531 by contract with four 
 " glaziers " living in Southwark, Middlesex, London, 
 and Westminster, i.e. glass painters' establishments 
 capable of furnishing the designs and executing those 
 works, according to the words of the contract, in " suer 
 and perfyte glasse and oryent colours and imagery of 
 the story of the Olde Lawe and ye Newe Lawe;" and, 
 further, to complete the windows of Bernard Flower, 
 who had died ; in all which the influence of various 
 
260 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 schools and the work of many hands are easily trace- 
 able, both English and foreign. 
 
 But let us now turn to the practical phase of the 
 subject to glass painting as a means of artistic ex- 
 pression. Our lesson must be learnt from the successes 
 and failures of former times ; and it must not be for- 
 gotten that we have difficulties which at no other time 
 were ever dreamt of. In former times Art flowed 
 onward in one pleasant and continuous stream, but 
 with us it is one continuous cataract. There are no 
 quiet waters of comfort : the unhappy glass painter 
 launched upon them may be a perfect master of his 
 craft, but the public, with vulgar pertinacity, persist in 
 steering him ; one way he turns to please himself, one 
 way to please his patrons ; and if he does not alto- 
 gether lose his self-possession in this vortex of conten- 
 tion and questionable taste, it is but to open his eyes 
 on the Scylla of the classic school on one side, and the 
 Gothic Charybdis on the other. Right principles alone 
 can be the guiding light on his horizon. 
 
 But why speak of styles ? There is a far greater 
 matter than them one which involves the whole 
 future of glass painting and that is the self-denying 
 mastery which will recognise, and act upon the recogni- 
 tion, that glass painting is a special art, with its own laws, 
 its own powers, its own limits ; that the laws of picture 
 have no more to do with it than those of sculpture have ; 
 that it is light that has to be dealt with, not shadow ; 
 translucent glass, not solid canvas ; open air, not a 
 picture-frame. If men set about glass painting, with 
 some such spirit as this, they would find no difficulty 
 about styles. We need talk no more of good or bad 
 drawing that phase is over ; but the fight must now 
 be for what people are not so ready to adopt, viz. the 
 limitation of the art to its proper sphere. But it is 
 immediately objected that this places a limit on the 
 
vii ART AND ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING 261 
 
 development and excellence of art ; though it is indeed 
 the precise opposite of this. The range of the art of 
 painting is not to be restricted. It would be so if it 
 were to follow the same rules and principles, under all 
 the various and even opposite circumstances in which 
 it is placed. It is to save it from this restriction that 
 glass should be recognised as imposing special obliga- 
 tions on the artist. Art will gain in dignity rather 
 than suffer loss by this. Its powers and elasticity are 
 at once recognised rather than confined. It is one 
 thing in the picture which hangs over the altar, another 
 thing on the broad expanse of frescoed wall, and an- 
 other in the window, different (ever so different in 
 each), but perfect in them all. 
 
 Why was it that such men as Lorenzo Ghiberti, 
 Perugino, Perino del Vaga, Giovanni da Udine, needed 
 to call to their country of the arts in their very halcyon 
 days, the northern Jaques PAllemand from Ulm, 
 Livi from Lubec, and Guillaume from Verdun ? Were 
 not those giants of art able to manage painted windows? 
 No, by their own confession, that art was a special one, 
 not their own. It was not the mere glass that they 
 wanted from the north ; they had that glass already. 
 The well-known French and German smalti were at 
 their hand in universal use in Italy. What they 
 needed, and what they sent for, were men who could 
 translate their works into glass. There was the secret : 
 there was the difficulty. The pencil of Ghiberti had 
 known what to put on the cartoon, but it was the 
 German-taught glass painter who knew how, and what 
 of it to put into glass ; and both were pleased with 
 each other's works though both were different. 
 
 Let there be nothing, therefore, said about placing 
 a limit on high art. Let us have no limit to the 
 highest attainment of design ; but let each office of the 
 art be recognised in its place, and there perform its 
 
262 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY vn 
 
 duties. Let us have the picture, the fresco, and the 
 window, each as beautiful as art can make them, in 
 each case wrought on different principles, as beautiful 
 as Perugino used to design them, or as the Beato 
 Giacomo could translate them into glass. 
 
 There need then be no fear for it. As an art it 
 would then stand firm on the sure ground of its own 
 merits ; and the artist, relieved from the trammels of 
 other arts and systems, would revel freely in the glory 
 of his glass. 
 
ESSAY VIII 
 
 THE ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 
 
 PART I PURPOSE EARLY CHRISTIAN EXAMPLES- 
 PORTRAITURE OF CHRIST CRUCIFIXION 
 
 T T has always been under the quiet shade of religious 
 contemplation that fine art has dedicated its love- 
 liest conceptions to the ideal of the heart's worship. 
 The light that gleamed in pagan faiths was but a ray 
 still vibrating within them from the origin of all faiths 
 in long anterior days. Imagination, crowded and dis- 
 turbed by events and uncertainties, convictions and 
 doubts, at one time darkened by the awe of Nature's 
 mastery, at another inspired by the grandeur of her 
 strange relationships of material and life, had raised up 
 images rather of terror than of love, and had so clouded 
 the pure ray of Deity that once had shone upon 
 the dawn of human life, that there remained no more 
 of it but superstitious reverence, and dreams of ideal 
 powers haunting the empty places of heaven and earth. 
 Hence the deep sadness that pervaded all pagan 
 religions, which their mysteries only deepened, and 
 their festivities, goaded by riot into artificial joy, failed 
 to dispel. Still a ray of religious sense remained; 
 and within all their apparent idolatry of material, their 
 fears and hopes, and their conscious weakness, an in- 
 tuitive trust bore testimony to the glimmering light 
 
264 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 within them, that there was a Power supreme to whom 
 their appeals for support and justice were not addressed 
 in vain. 
 
 The relationship of national character to national 
 religion has often been exhibited in greater force by its 
 external expression than by the speciality of its faith ; 
 because the multitude having but little time and less 
 ability to study and comprehend the subtleties of 
 religion, has commonly fallen into a system, partly 
 routine, partly superstitious ; and by force of circum- 
 stances has satisfied itself with formalities, offerings, and 
 sacrifices, as the material symbols of devotional expres- 
 sion. Individual religion may be very independent of 
 externals ; but a national religion has always needed a 
 vast machinery of order both of things and persons ; 
 and whether Christian or Pagan, the national impulse 
 has prevailed to dedicate the noblest and best that the 
 nation could give, as the dignified accessories of its 
 public worship. 
 
 In such places separated for devotion and conse- 
 crated by association with the highest purposes of 
 human life, an artist may well pause before he puts his 
 hands upon these walls and realise the duty and respon- 
 sibility he undertakes ; for his art, whatever it may be, 
 is always prominent and must be effective in one or 
 other direction for benefit or injury ; from its very 
 nature it must assert itself and be noticed ; and whether 
 in sculpture or in painting it cannot fail to affect the 
 general sense of respect or contempt toward the place 
 it occupies. He needs to realise the speciality of his 
 position, that his art is an active present power, and for 
 the future a living witness to generations of his fellow- 
 men ; and therefore that his work may so affect their 
 mind that they may read at once the purposes to which 
 it points apart from and beyond itself; and though 
 the memory of it may grow vague, and the forms of its 
 
vin ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 265 
 
 sacred imagery may fade away, still that the thoughts 
 which sprang from them may flow brightly to life's 
 end, and cast a halo about their passing years. 
 
 The adornment of sacred buildings has been the 
 expression of the universal religious sense of mankind. 
 Under all varieties of belief and practice the temple has 
 been regarded as the house of God. The pagan temple 
 was the abode of the visible representative of some 
 ideal deity, in the splendid figure worshipped in his 
 honour. The Christian temple has been consecrated by 
 the promised presence of God, and all that the arts 
 could do has culminated there to testify to the faith in 
 the eternal and unseen. In the pagan temple there 
 might have been some restraint imposed upon the 
 enrichment of the interior, lest by contrast the splendour 
 of the idol figure might be diminished. The treatment 
 of the Christian temple had no such impediment, but 
 only that of the infirmity of religious expression ; so in 
 simplicity of spirit and acknowledged weakness, the 
 highest and best of art that the place and age could 
 produce has ever thus been lavished upon it. To the 
 pagan the glorification of his temple was an inherited 
 and immemorial tradition. To the Hebrew it had been 
 a work of divine direction, and to the Christian the 
 involuntary impulse of spiritual aspiration. The 
 universal consent and demand for such treatment of 
 their sacred buildings, whether pagan or Christian, came 
 from human infirmity seeking aids to faith, by satisfy- 
 ing sense with the signs and symbols of things on which 
 both memory and hope were centred. They sought 
 those sacred shrines as generations before had sought 
 them for the love of that sacred atmosphere which gave 
 them rest. Association hallowed them, and it was their 
 artist's privilege to indue their walls with pictured thoughts 
 and memories which brought together the souls of those 
 who worshipped there, and of those who had gone before. 
 
266 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 But their endearment was their danger. Who 
 would offend their household gods ? Who of the 
 ancients could divest their, minds of the haunting 
 visions of superstition, and what was that superstition 
 but the vague reflex of awful truth ? As in the physi- 
 cal constitution an accident of birth brings out the 
 latent characteristics of the tribe, and witnesses to the 
 race from which they sprang, by some startling evidence 
 of what had been lost even to the vague memory of 
 tradition ; so in mind, occasional gleams reveal the 
 latent truth long since forgotten, and a Plato among the 
 Greeks or an Aurelius or a Cicero among the Romans, 
 and others such as they, may reflect a ray from those 
 distant springs of light long lost among the shadows of 
 human life. But around even such minds as those 
 comparative darkness reigned. Religion was not 
 indeed to them, as to their compatriots, a mere political 
 necessity ; but devotion, another word for love, could 
 find no place where no Person was, on whom to spend 
 it. But in the depth of individual mind a latent power 
 still held a partial sway, and though the accepted 
 theology was monstrous, the reality of the unseen was a 
 power beyond it, universal and irresistible ; and the 
 result was that tribute of mingled fear and hope which 
 poor humanity gave, by the best of all it knew or had 
 to give, and expressed its worship, too deep for common 
 things, in the language and by the aid of genius. 
 
 But here was material again, and employed as a 
 means of spiritual expression ; for art, except in the 
 words of poetry, has no other language, and there are 
 those whose spiritual sense is keen and to whom 
 material expresses no more than material, and is an 
 offence. It was so in great degree with the first 
 Christians, The works of classic genius around them, 
 embodying ideals of religion, had reference both 
 spiritual and sensual which they knew too well. Art, 
 
viii ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 267 
 
 sprung from the purest fountain of life, had been defiled. 
 From its origin to its end, as presented in their age, 
 it served fatuous idolatry alone, or grossest luxury. 
 Its forms were an offence, so they hated rather than 
 feared them. Their attitude toward the ideal of life 
 was the absolute opposite of that of the pagan world. 
 To them a Person engaged not their worship only but 
 their affections. A visible reality at once human and 
 divine had engaged them, at once too majestic and too 
 tender, too holy and too pure for aught of material form 
 to reach. But the need of it was too strong to last 
 unsatisfied. The need of visible form to mark the spot 
 or to secure the record of the blest departed, of the 
 hope that had now changed to certainty, of the sorrow 
 that was surpassed by joy for those who had " entered 
 into life " ; such need of record found its words in signs 
 and symbols, some new, some old made new by change 
 of sense, the dove, the olive branch, the anchor, and the 
 palm, and thus their first germs of art found place among 
 their silent cemeteries, where still they tell the story of 
 their faith. 
 
 The form they took was such as all the influences 
 around them would have led us to expect. The 
 religions of paganism were written in their arts. The 
 myths, which the finest arts of heathendom had em- 
 bodied, were allegories of the deepest significance, and 
 had often had their origin in the purest motive. The 
 sculpture and painting of antiquity, from the very 
 nature of their subjects (except such as were devoted 
 to national history and portraiture), were inspired in the 
 choice and treatment of all their subjects by that deep 
 traditional poetry which underlay the relation of the 
 outer to the inner life of men, of material to mind. 
 The eyes and thoughts of multitudes, brought up in 
 such cities as Athens, Corinth, Ephesus, and Rome, had 
 been from childhood habituated to the influence of the 
 
268 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 fine arts in their utmost perfection and power. The 
 poetry, the allegory, the symbolism, which were the 
 very life of those glorious works, then abounding all 
 around them, were among the most powerful elements 
 of an involuntary education for the inhabitants. The 
 Christian converts had been as subject to those influ- 
 ences as any others. They had learnt to abhor the 
 idolatry and to loathe the abuse of the arts, but it was 
 impossible for them to change the habitual sentiment 
 of allegory and symbol to which their minds had been 
 inevitably trained. The doctrines and the rites of the 
 new faith they had adopted were deeply figurative, and 
 like the works of heathen sculpture to which they were 
 accustomed, whatever was objective in them bore a 
 recondite and spiritual interpretation. The earliest 
 lessons of their faith had been conveyed in the allegori- 
 cal form of parables. The miracles of its Founder had 
 been shown by Him, as in the case of the multiplica- 
 tion of the loaves and fishes, to possess a depth of 
 meaning far beneath and beyond the external acts and 
 objects themselves. The religious rites prescribed by 
 Him were profoundly symbolical. The ancient scrip- 
 tures, to which He had referred his disciples for the 
 foundation of all He did and taught, embodied all their 
 historical and prophetic reference to the new faith in 
 the forms and words of allegory, type, and symbol. 
 
 Such concurrent influences, so numerous, so attrac- 
 tive, and so powerful, could produce but one result. 
 The early art among the Christians followed naturally 
 in the course thus prepared for it. The necessity for 
 secrecy confirmed the use of it It was easy to main- 
 tain, when clothed in symbol, what, openly exhibited, 
 would be death. The mysteries of their faith gained 
 force and value even to themselves when thus used. 
 The poetry of art could symbolise them with more 
 subtlety and refinement than any language. Hence 
 
vin ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 269 
 
 may in great degree be explained their early reconcilia- 
 tion to the employment of forms of art, and the 
 subsequent and rapid development of its use without 
 prejudice or fear. 
 
 If we look for the illustrations of it we must be 
 contented with its ruins. At that period all art was 
 in a failing condition. Great works of antiquity 
 remained but all practical art, in the second century 
 of our era, had well-nigh ceased, except as a subject of 
 display and luxury. Originality existed no more. The 
 old forms and styles alone remained. The artist's pro- 
 fession could scarcely be followed by the Christians, for 
 works of heathen sympathies were impossible, and their 
 opportunities among their own community afforded 
 them no means of livelihood. They possessed churches 
 in the principal cities ; but so long as their religion was 
 periodically tolerated and proscribed, and themselves 
 protected and persecuted by turns, they found nothing 
 around them sufficiently stable to encourage any 
 development of a new art on Christian principles. That 
 was reserved for other days. Those early disciples, con- 
 tent to bear their changing fortunes, were content also 
 to take and to utilise what they found about them, 
 and they have left the history, not merely of themselves 
 but of their faith, in the lineaments of a faltering art, 
 weak at its outset, and weaker in its progress, but 
 embodying, to the best of their power and of their poor 
 opportunities, the testimony of their fortitude and 
 devotion. 
 
 The vine, the lamb, the crown, the phoenix, and the 
 peacock were to them symbols of the deepest interest ; 
 and the fish and the cross still more intimately told the 
 story of their creed. To them it was but as yesterday 
 that the great drama of their redemption had been acted 
 out. But, as centuries elapsed, and the realities of that 
 awful history receded farther and farther into the past, 
 
270 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 a craving desire arose for anything that could restore 
 to them the sense of its proximity, and fill, by some 
 external and sensible expression, the void where 
 memory or imagination failed. For this some con- 
 secutive composition was needed, and consistently with 
 their tender choice of subjects, one of the earliest of 
 them was the figure of the Good Shepherd. He is 
 represented in many ways, sometimes in the attitude 
 of walking, with a lamb across His shoulders ; some- 
 times in repose, standing with His sheep about Him, 
 some feeding, some gazing up at Him, or listening to 
 His voice. Sometimes He carries the shepherd's crook, 
 sometimes the pipe with seven tubes, and with all the 
 signs of pastoral joy around Him, expressed in the 
 simple landscape forms of flowers, trees, and singing 
 birds. But this subject was not altogether new. The 
 simplicity and grace of this easy composition had 
 already made it a subject of classic art, but totally 
 devoid of all such surrounding scenery and symbol, in 
 the Hermes Criophoros, where the god was indeed no 
 good shepherd, but the herald of the sacrifice of 
 Arcadian tradition, carrying the ram upon his shoulders ; 
 or as the protector of Tanagra, carrying the ram round 
 its walls to save the city from a pestilence. To the 
 Christians it afforded at once the opportunity of a 
 beautiful allegory suggested in their Master's own 
 language ; and thus consecrated to a new ideal, recom- 
 posed in features and embellished with deep significance, 
 they painted it and sculptured it with untiring interest 
 and variety. Thus, too, with most aspiring poetry they 
 converted many a lurking memory of their former 
 religion, and purified it in the brightness of their new 
 faith. So the story of Cupid and Psyche, the per- 
 sonified emblems of love and the soul, was raised in 
 the issue of its idea, to symbolise that love which had 
 won for the soul its eternal life. Thus all that the 
 
vni ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 271 
 
 poetry and the innate yearning of the heathen world 
 had testified to its unexpressed convictions, fell naturally 
 to Christian use, and then lifted from the realm of 
 dreams to the certainty of that faith which had inter- 
 preted them, they were at once adopted without change. 
 Another significant subject adopted by them very early 
 from classic art was that of Orpheus with his lyre, 
 surrounded by the animals whom his music had tamed. 
 In the early Christian's love of recondite and mystic 
 symbolism this figure of Orpheus, who had descended 
 into Hades, had achieved his purpose, and had returned 
 alive, represented the risen Christ ; and his lyre 
 symbolised the music of the Gospel subduing the 
 hearts of men. 
 
 But all the favourite subjects of the early Christians 
 are known too well to be repeated here. The fondness 
 for clothing abstract truths in allegory and emblem was 
 fostered by every influence around them. It was a 
 characteristic of their time. They had known it in 
 the symbolism of Jewish rites, and in the prophetic 
 language of the Old Testament, they found it in the 
 parables and prophecies of their own Scriptures, they 
 were accustomed to it in heathen art and poetry, and 
 they read it in the language of the early fathers of the 
 Church, whose allegorical and mystic interpretations 
 fostered a similar spirit in their art. 
 
 Their works of art were acts of faith. They lost 
 all thought of self in the glories of that faith for which 
 they lived and died. The tombs of the martyrs be- 
 came their altars, and the open halls in front of them 
 their churches. Their pictures were not devised for 
 luxury and ornament ; but the more fertile a subject 
 might be in its illustration of doctrine and belief, the 
 more it was adopted. Hence the group of the Divine 
 Infant and His mother expressive of the incarnation of 
 the Son of God ; of Abraham and Isaac carrying the 
 
272 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 wood, as prophetically illustrative of the preordained 
 sacrifice of the Crucifixion. With other meanings, 
 Noah and his ark, episodes in the history of Jonah, 
 the raising of Lazarus, the giving sight to the blind, 
 making a series of subjects full of that fact and allegory 
 combined, which gave them all their value, were painted 
 on their walls and ceilings continually. 
 
 In the works of those early times or rather in the 
 spirit which inspired them their poetry and their pur- 
 pose were the germs out of which the religious art of 
 Christendom has grown, but the style and character of 
 their design waned away beneath that general influence 
 of change which then prevailed. They have never been 
 revived. It is perhaps possible to trace a distant like- 
 ness to them in the "classic" of a long subsequent age 
 in the works of such men as Penturicchio, Botticelli, 
 Perugino, and Piero di Cosimo, who lived in a time of 
 classic revival, when every influence of learning, litera- 
 ture, art, and poetry tended to that result. But the 
 likeness is only slight and transient. The spirits of 
 those distant times, above a thousand years apart, may 
 have had much sympathy, but the genius of each age 
 and race of man was original. From the beginning 
 art has ever been the fruitful exponent of its own age, 
 locality, and purpose ; and its varying styles have been 
 no more than the varying fashions and dialects of its 
 multiform and inexhaustible language. 
 
 Pagan Rome had but little originality in art. Her 
 artists were mostly Greeks. Scarcely the name of one 
 painter conspicuous in high art survives. Doubtless 
 there were native artists, but it was to wandering com- 
 panies of Greeks that Italy, especially in the south, was 
 indebted for her fine arts ; and to them we must attri- 
 bute most of the works of the early Christians, long 
 before that peculiar Greek type appears which was due 
 to the Byzantine influence. The Early Christian Church 
 
vin ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 273 
 
 in Italy was very Greek. If we may trust so careful a 
 historian as Dean Milman, we may accept at least as 
 mainly true this passage, in which he described its early 
 state : " Their language was Greek, their writers Greek, 
 their Scriptures Greek ; and many vestiges and tradi- 
 tions show that their Ritual and their Liturgy were 
 Greek. Through Greek the communication between the 
 Churches of Rome and of the West was kept up 
 with the East." To this Professor Westcott adds, 
 speaking of the early Church in Rome : " As far as we 
 can learn, the mass of the poorer population, every- 
 where the great bulk of the early Christians, was 
 Greek, either in descent or speech. Among the names 
 of fifteen bishops of Rome, to the close of the second 
 century, only four were Latin." 
 
 The age of early Christianity was that when the 
 disruption of the old systems of the world had begun. 
 The old classic style was fading away in its last weak- 
 ness. The arts of the Catacombs, like those of Her- 
 culaneum and Pompeii, only served to reflect, like 
 marred and broken mirrors, the traditions of the great 
 arts of old. The genius and glory of the works of 
 ancient days had waned away ; and the echo of their 
 distant voices were the only signs of life in the lan- 
 guage of the arts which remained. The first Christian 
 possessed, in the only artists he could command, but 
 poor exponents of the ideas he desired to record. His 
 artists were probably the poorest decorators of the day. 
 Here and there a few fair works are found, but they 
 are slight and sketchy, and mostly devoid of good draw- 
 ing or composition, as might be expected from such 
 workmen. But they are not to be condemned for that. 
 The paintings of the Catacombs were done in the 
 dark : the best light the artist could command was but 
 the flare of the torch or flickering lamp beside him. 
 Nor could they be better seen by those who came 
 
 T 
 
274 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 there. A work of art is not good for its genius and 
 its science alone. Human skill and time and labour 
 have their intrinsic value. If those works were slight 
 and rapid they were all that they needed to be and 
 so far good as fit for their place, and fit for the impres- 
 sions and the scanty time of those who saw or cared 
 for them. 
 
 Weak as those works were, their artistic value to 
 us is very great. They preserve in their feeble linea- 
 ments and imperfect execution the character and 
 technicality of the great times. Picture painting in 
 the greatest days of ancient art was probably very 
 different from what our eyes are accustomed to. 
 Figure painting was as beautiful as the perfect taste 
 and perfect models of ancient Greece could lead us to 
 expect ; but composition of figure subjects was prob- 
 ably more sculpturesque than picturesque. All scenic 
 background was of the simplest kind ; and when natural 
 or architectural forms were introduced, they were devised 
 less to complete a picture, as nowadays, with landscape 
 and perspective, than to fill up by a few accentuated 
 forms and lines the general composition of the subject. 
 In ancient art the backgrounds were often plain 
 monochrome, from which the figures, singly or in 
 groups, stood out in clear relief, beautiful in their 
 freedom from all unneeded accessories and all disturb- 
 ance. Landscape painting, as we understand it now, 
 was not appreciated. The trees and rocks and other 
 forms of external nature represented in the back- 
 grounds of pictures in Herculaneum, Pompeii, and the 
 Catacombs are conventional in the extreme, and, from 
 the universality of this treatment, we may fairly believe 
 that these plain marks of style and character are the 
 signs of what they had traditionally received from 
 ancient times. Thus we may regard the classic art 
 of Grecian painting and of the Roman also, which 
 
viii ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 275 
 
 was but its echo as rather based on the principles of 
 architectural than of the more definitely pictorial art. 
 Thus was the painting far more beautiful in its sculp- 
 turesque harmony with the architecture, whether it was 
 executed on the walls themselves or in pictures hung 
 upon them far more beautiful indeed in the entire 
 unity of the general effect than all the resources of 
 linear and atmospheric perspective in modern art, which 
 only too commonly belies and contradicts the architec- 
 ture that it pretends to adorn. 
 
 Thus also in Christian art we often find both single 
 and grouped figures left with only plain monotone back- 
 grounds ; and this even where natural objects form part 
 of the illustration, as in such subjects as Moses striking 
 the rock with the waters flowing out, or Jonah beneath 
 his gourd, or cast into the sea, or restored to land with 
 all the many accessories of such subjects, his com- 
 panions, the ship, the waters, and the whale ; or other 
 compositions, equally involved, such as the sacrifice of 
 Isaac ; the baptism of Christ, or the sermon on the 
 mount ; or that beautifully-symbolic subject of the ship 
 coming into safe harbour, with furling sails and cargo 
 stored on deck, and a sure landing-place at hand, 
 emblematic of the end of the storms of life, and the 
 soul received into its rest at last. All these and many 
 other subjects, which involved the necessary introduc- 
 tion of natural objects to explain them, are treated 
 with all the traditional simplicity of ancient classic art. 
 The love and the labour of the artist were thrown into 
 the expression of his figures, and all else was omitted 
 but a few conventional or emblematical accessories to 
 explain his subject and to enhance its dramatic interest 
 
 On these good and simple artistic principles all the 
 painting of the early Christians is based. And although 
 the style of art was entirely changed in after times, 
 those principles remained inviolate until the science of 
 
276 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 perspective and the new passion for realistic landscape 
 painting at the close of the fourteenth century opened 
 a new era in the theory and practice of fine art. 
 
 Thus is it with deepest interest that a Christian 
 artist turns to the sources whence the arts have sprung, 
 that from earliest days to his own have stamped on 
 each age the unfailing evidences of its motives and its 
 worth. He wanders among those illustrations of sacred 
 story, a biblical cycle, composed with a manifest sim- 
 plicity of purpose to satisfy the craving for expression, 
 to record the truth and to teach it. But he had also 
 read the written history of those times, and of the 
 heroism of generations that surpassed romance in 
 interest and pathos. The records of their history had 
 described the storms of unpitying savagery that had 
 swept around their lives, but all that art has engraved 
 on their movements only commemorates their peace; 
 if a cross is marked upon their grave it denotes not 
 suffering but life ; the dove and the olive only symbo- 
 lise the purity and freshness of their faith, the anchor 
 and the palm affirm their victory. A sense of the ex- 
 treme sacredness associated with the history and doc- 
 trines of their faith was certainly one cause of that 
 reserve which characterised the early Christian artists. 
 No doubt the prevailing sentiment would have affected 
 them which denounced the arts as only pandering to 
 idolatry, and their own abhorrence of the prevailing 
 sentiment and misuse of art, in an age of rapidly- 
 deepening corruption, would have increased the inten- 
 sity of that reserve ; but the motives of caution and 
 fear imposed a further and even stronger restraint upon 
 the outward expression of their faith, too sacred for ex- 
 posure to inevitable sacrilege, too pure and powerful to 
 be borne by the pagan magistrate, whose hatred of it 
 told the conscious shame of his own contrasted life, and 
 whose fear alone, and not whose scorn, explained his 
 
viii ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 277 
 
 violence, leading them to the certainty of trouble or of 
 death. 
 
 It might seem at first sight strange that, in spite of 
 all such motives and restraints, the one subject in which 
 art would have been most precious to them has been 
 left without any faithful witness, the memorial of their 
 Master's form or countenance. The mind of early 
 Christendom had been so entirely concentrated on the 
 character and Gospel of Christ that all material sense 
 or memory of Him had been overwhelmed in the halo 
 of His divinity. The pride and grandeur of external 
 beauty with which the image gods of the heathen had 
 been invested, and their divinity expressed, little ac- 
 corded with the first Christian's ideal of his gentle and 
 self-sacrificing Master. His belief in the awful majesty 
 that was hidden in that figure overwhelmed his imagin- 
 ation. He approached its representation in fear, and 
 took refuge in symbols. But to us who, at this dis- 
 tance of time, receive in one united sound the echoes of 
 the many and various notes which directly or indirectly 
 vibrate through the voices of tradition, it is natural and 
 with some confidence of truth to suppose, that at that 
 time when delineative and representative art was the 
 common and facile practice of the age, there were, 
 among the first followers of Christ, men whom both 
 habit and ability would have induced to sketch or even 
 to complete the memorial image of that Being who 
 occupied their whole mind with a love and devotion 
 that were the very first springs of their life. His 
 countenance would haunt the memory of those who 
 knew Him, and the imagination of those who had not 
 seen Him but believed. No conversation among such 
 disciples could have passed without some personal 
 reference to their Master. The teaching of His doc- 
 trines would have involved anecdotes of Himself, His 
 conduct, His manner, His appearance, and His voice ; 
 
278 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 and would have been like pictures to their hearers' 
 minds ; as riveting in interest to those who listened as 
 to those, who, pouring out their stores of incident, told 
 how He stood and wept before the grave of Lazarus, 
 how His face was scarred and all the beauty they would 
 have desired in Him was marred, as He sank beneath 
 the weight of the cross ; and with what smile of recog- 
 nition He welcomed them in the haze of morning upon 
 the shore of Tiberias, and invited them to " come and 
 dine." Such tales were pictures, and His was their 
 central figure. No words of His were repeated by 
 those who had heard His voice but that His image 
 was there before their mental sight, an indelible reality. 
 An old anecdote does but relate the event of many 
 such probable occasions ; how at the supper table in 
 the house of Pudeus the conversation turned to the 
 subject of our Lord's personal appearance, and St. 
 Peter, yielding to the urgency of Sa. Prassede, drew an 
 outline of his Master's head upon her napkin. The 
 intensity of that deep and quiet enthusiasm that per- 
 vaded the heart of earliest Christendom was concen- 
 trated on the person of its Lord. His divinity was too 
 awful for art to approach, but His presence was human. 
 If His words were related, their occasions would have 
 been told with the brightness of fresh memory ; and thus 
 the traditions of His appearance, which we still value, 
 had their source at the stream's fountain-head. If those 
 which art has embodied appear at first sight incon- 
 sistent, their uncertainty is easily dissipated if we 
 recollect that not those who saw but only those who 
 had heard about Him were the artists to whom we owe 
 the few and faded memorials of His person. The 
 stories of His lovely youth and of His wan maturity 
 filled the anecdotes of His career ; both equally true 
 and penetrating, whether their words were inspired by 
 the purity of His character or the pathos of His life. 
 
vni ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 279 
 
 The early dread of that idolatry round which the 
 course of pagan life was plunged in vileness, may have 
 restrained the artist's hand and the worshipper's desire; 
 still, much that looks like mere symbolic reference may 
 have been true to the life ; and those figures of the 
 young Christ that surprise us, are but the images which 
 a consecrated tradition had left printed on their minds, 
 as faithful in ideal portraiture as those lineaments of 
 solemn beauty which mature Christendom has intui- 
 tively accepted as the truth. Those youthful heads 
 which the first Christian sculptors and painters assigned 
 to Christ wore the expressions of artistic poetry, based 
 indeed upon truth, but inspired by their individual con- 
 ceptions of a being whose life no age could affect ; and 
 whether as a child among the doctors in the Temple, or 
 seated on His Throne with the arch of heaven beneath 
 His feet, they portrayed him as the Lord of eternal 
 youth. 
 
 Art has preserved no certain portraits of His 
 maturer years ; but although St. Augustine's assertion 
 that no portrait of Him existed, may be true, and 
 though the literature of the early fathers of the Church 
 is troubled by the contending waves of controversy as 
 to the divinity which illumined or the humanity which 
 marred His countenance, still the golden thread of 
 unanimous conviction has been woven without break 
 through the tissue of contending thoughts ; and whether 
 as a head of solemn beauty such as once adorned the 
 vault of the cemetery of St. Callixtus, or even those of 
 late Byzantine feebleness, or such as Da Vinci painted 
 it, from first to last, through phases of art which the 
 events of centuries had modified and the varying tones 
 of religious sentiment had changed, the same ideal can 
 be traced throughout to an original of mingled gentle- 
 ness and power, expressed by features of grave propor- 
 tion, with the lips closed, the brow open, the cheek- 
 
280 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 bones marked, the face long, and the parted hair undu- 
 lating behind the shoulders, of a man whose true 
 portraiture had been presented, never to the sight 
 but only to the heart of humanity, on lines that none 
 could draw but those inspired hands which pictured it 
 in the lineaments of the written Gospel. 
 
 Still artists will have to do with that divine head 
 of which Origen said that it had no certain aspect, but 
 varied according to circumstances and the persons 
 connected with them : and, indeed, experience since his 
 time has shown how each artist, each nation, and each 
 age has changed that aspect, although maintaining the 
 general idea and proportions of the ancient type. They 
 began by the attempt to glorify it according to classic 
 models ; in the troubles of a subsequent age they cast 
 their own gloom over it, and in the days of ascetic 
 discipline they marred it with the lines of agony and 
 grief; but by none has that noble loving face been 
 more degraded than by the degenerate schools of more 
 modern times, which, taking refuge in the meekness 
 and gentleness of Christ to screen the feebleness of 
 their own conceptions, ignoring the grander elements 
 of His character, His splendid independence, His bold- 
 ness in denunciation, and, when needed, His ruthless 
 severity, they picture him a mere creature of weak 
 sentimentality, effeminate, inane. 
 
 Many pretended portraits of Christ, both in painting 
 and sculpture, occasionally in statuettes of gold and 
 silver, existed in the earliest times, but principally, if 
 not altogether the work of, and possessed by the 
 Gnostics. The only two statues of any importance of 
 which early notices remain are the one erected by the 
 Emperor Alexander Severus among his portrait sculp- 
 ture of eminent persons, of which sufficient evidence as 
 to the fact is preserved, but not as to the authenticity 
 of the likeness. Of its fate there is no record, as there 
 
viii ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 281 
 
 is of the other, which was a bronze figure that the 
 woman, healed of the issue of blood, is related to have 
 raised as a memorial of devotion in her native city, 
 Caesarea Philippi, and to have been held sacred there 
 for the miracles of healing produced by it, but which 
 was destroyed through the animosity of Julian the 
 apostate, and replaced by a statue of himself. 
 
 Of picture portraits, to which such sanctity is still 
 attached as would be justifiable only on the certainty 
 of their truth, the histories are utterly mythic. They 
 are those associated with the stories of Agbarus, King 
 of Edessa, and of Sa. Veronica. Of the former the 
 story is preserved by Eusebius (A.D. 338), who, taking 
 his information from the fragmentary writings of Julius 
 African us of the third century, relates that King 
 Agbarus, having heard of the miracles of Christ, sent 
 a messenger to beg his cure. To this Christ sent a 
 letter in reply through an apostle, by which his cure 
 was conveyed. Eusebius makes no mention of a 
 portrait on that occasion, but states that picture por- 
 traits of our Lord existed in his time, of which he 
 affords no clue to their origin, but such had been long 
 known and used as objects of worship by the Gnostics. 
 The first notice, trustworthy as regards authorship, of 
 any portrait at Edessa is in the Ecclesiastical History 
 by Evagrius, who died at the close of the sixth century, 
 and the first asserted eye-witness of it was a certain Leo 
 of the Church of Constantinople, who stated before the 
 second council of Nicaea (which had been summoned 
 against the iconoclasts, A.D. 787) that he had seen at 
 Edessa the portrait which Christ had sent of Himself 
 to King Agbarus, and that it was venerated as an 
 object of the utmost sanctity. About two centuries 
 before that time the miraculous powers of this picture 
 had been assured to the devout inhabitants of Edessa 
 on the occasion of the siege of the city by the Persians 
 
282 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 under Chosroes ; for a tower of attack, principally 
 composed of wood, had been raised outside to overtop 
 the walls, and had defied the attempts of the defenders 
 to burn it, till despair suggested their recourse to mira- 
 culous agency, and having placed the picture beneath the 
 woodwork, the fire immediately took effect : the tower 
 was burnt and the city saved. With equal fertility of 
 devout invention the stories, resulting perhaps rather 
 from pious imagination than from pious fraud, about 
 the production of this sacred picture began to multiply, 
 and at last became so confused with the story of Sa. 
 Veronica as to need as much ingenuity to unravel them 
 as they had needed credulity to originate. In the 
 eighth century we are for the first time informed of the 
 miraculous production of this picture, how that the 
 king was as anxious for a portrait of Christ as for his 
 cure, and had sent an artist to take it, but, baffled by 
 the marvel of the divine countenance, the artist was 
 consoled by the compassion of Christ, who pressed a 
 part of His own dress upon His face, and sent the 
 portrait thus produced to the king. Another story by 
 the Emperor Constantine Porphyrogenitus (A.D. 959) 
 relates that Christ consigned a portrait of Himself, 
 produced in the same manner, to St. Thomas, who sent 
 it after the Ascension to Edessa by the apostle Thad- 
 deus. Thus the stories roll up into a romance, and 
 the western development of that Eastern tale tells that 
 it was neither the artist nor St. Thomas, but an enthu- 
 siastic woman, to whom the musical name of Veronica 
 has been given, who obtained it from the u sacro volto " 
 as Christ was sinking beneath His cross on the road to 
 Calvary. 
 
 The subsequent history of these portraits is as great 
 a curiosity of confusion as their origin. Edessa fell 
 into the hands of the Mahomedans, and was retaken 
 by the Greeks in the tenth century, when the alleged 
 
viii ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 283 
 
 portrait was foun'd there, and being brought to Con- 
 stantinople in 944, was deposited in the basilica of 
 Sa. Sophia. The honour of having transported this 
 picture to Rome, rescued from desecration by the 
 Moslems, is claimed by the Venetians, and of their 
 having presented it to the church of St. Sylvester ; but 
 there is no historic authority for the story. It is with 
 more authority claimed by the Genoese, as having been 
 presented by the Emperor John Paleologus to Lionardo 
 Montaldi in 1384, and presented by him to the 
 Armenian church of St. Bartholomew at Genoa. This 
 was just 440 years since its transportation to Sa. 
 Sophia, and in the meantime Constantinople had been 
 sacked by the Turks, and all account of the picture 
 had been lost. 
 
 The portrait in St. Peter's at Rome, described as 
 that given by our Lord to Sa. Veronica, is without 
 doubt a picture of great antiquity. In what way it 
 reached Rome is not known. Among the strange 
 traditions about it, one is, that it was brought there by 
 Martha, the sister of Lazarus ; but any definite date to 
 which it can be traced, and that but vaguely, is not 
 earlier than the beginning of the eighth century. It 
 was preserved for a long time among the treasures of 
 the church of St. Mary of the Martyrs (the Pantheon), 
 and transferred thence by Pope Urban the Eighth 
 (1623-1644) to the chapel now well known as that of 
 Sa. Veronica under the dome of St. Peter's. The story 
 of Veronica is a variation of that of the artist sent by 
 Agbarus ; and the idea of a woman being associated 
 with the story at all, appears to have been developed 
 by degrees from the tradition of that portrait being 
 confused with the one attributed to the woman of 
 Caesarea Philippi, whose name, as perpetuated through 
 Gnostic tradition, was Prounice, known subsequently, in 
 the sixth century, as Berenice, by the change of the 
 
284 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 allied initial, and thence by a similar change to V, 
 developed into the half-Latin, half-Greek appellation, 
 Vera-icon (true likeness), whence the well-known 
 Veronica has been accepted, not indeed as a woman, 
 but as the popular name for the likeness itself. 
 
 The vagueness of tradition, and the value of 
 authorities on such subjects, is well illustrated by 
 another portrait, of which there appears to be no 
 intimation before the year 826, 1 as having been painted 
 by the evangelist St. Luke, a story repeated by others 
 of that age, and even mentioned with respect by such 
 an one as St. Thomas Aquinas (A.D. 1274). It was 
 then in the chapel of the Santa Scala of the Lateran, 
 and guaranteed by the authority of Pope Gregory IX. 
 in 1234 by an inscription placed by his order beneath 
 it : " Salvatoris nostri effigies a S. Luca depicta." 
 
 Such is the pious romance of the portraits of Christ, 
 of which the alleged copies are equally ideal. The 
 printed copies of that at Genoa are taken from a totally 
 unauthenticated copy of an original which no one is 
 allowed to examine. The printed copies of the Veronica 
 picture at Rome are described on the best authority to 
 be " pious souvenirs, but not an object of the least 
 iconographic value." 2 Still the tradition remains as a 
 haunting shadow which, through all the centuries, has 
 pictured our Lord in His mature life with a coun- 
 
 1 Michael, a Greek monk, in his biography of Theodoras Studites. 
 
 2 M. Barbier de Montault, a learned antiquary, who, as a member of 
 the Roman clergy, was admitted on a rare occasion to the exhibition of 
 the picture of the volto sacro of Sa. Veronica, writes thus: "The holy 
 face is enclosed in a silver gilt frame. A plate of metal covers the field 
 up to the outline of the face. One is led to conjecture flowing hair reach- 
 ing to the shoulders, a short beard bifurcated, and other features so vaguely 
 indicated and so completely effaced that it requires the liveliest imagination 
 in the world to perceive traces of eyes or nose. The place of the impres- 
 sion exhibited only a blackish surface, not giving evidence of human 
 features. . . . The so-called facsimiles of the head are sold in the sacristy, 
 but there is no guarantee that they resemble the original." Quoted in the 
 Quarterly Review, October 1867. 
 
vin ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 285 
 
 tenance of deep solemnity, power, and gentleness, 
 suffering, resignation, and love ; and for such combined 
 expressions we may take with confidence the ideals 
 which reverence may draw from those models which 
 neither history nor art, but only the mystery of an 
 inherited conviction, has authorised as the likeness of 
 our Lord. 
 
 We may therefore wander freely and without 
 offence among the thoughts and works of other 
 times, and linger or turn aside, as our own sympathies 
 may lean. We can fill up the sketchy art of the 
 Catacombs with our own imaginings ; we can interpret 
 the severity of the Byzantine and the rude spirit of the 
 Lombards by our knowledge of their genius and history. 
 We can appreciate the intense poetry of the Gothic, 
 and the matured art of the Renaissance, and satisfy 
 our own individual conceptions from those inexhaustible 
 fountains of religious idea. But had it been otherwise 
 had some veritable representation, or even some 
 reliable type of the portrait of Christ existed, recorded 
 in history and preserved to our time ; had our eyes 
 been trained to it from the first, and our affections 
 filled with it, there would now remain no rest for us 
 between the power of one artist, whose success would 
 risk idolatry, and the incompetence of another, whose 
 failure would offend our deepest sense with an insult 
 akin to sacrilege. 
 
 By much the same mode of research we learn that no 
 reminiscence has been preserved of the features of the 
 blessed Virgin. St. Augustine writes plainly to that effect, 
 "Neque novimus faciem Virginis M arise " but others 
 of his age, impelled by devotional imagination, wrote of 
 her that her beauty was only equalled by the loveliness 
 of her character. And thus with deepest reverence 
 have all artists painted her from the simple figures of 
 the Oranti in the Catacombs to the " Madonna di San 
 
286 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 Sisto," when the Divine afflatus fired the pencil of 
 Raphael. There are, however, two portraits on which 
 some reliance can be placed, viz. those of St. Peter and 
 St. Paul. With some allowance for varieties of style 
 and date, the characteristics of those apostles have been 
 preserved from very early times till now. We recognise 
 St. Peter's head at once by the general compactness of 
 the features, by the short and crisp hair and beard, and 
 other well-known traits, to all of which those of St. 
 Paul are in strong contrast, by the more flowing hair, 
 the longer head, and the expression of countenance, 
 indicating a higher origin and a finer mind. From 
 early times there have been traditional portraits of St. 
 Paul. Several early writers and Fathers of the Church 
 have mentioned them and of these, St. Ambrose and 
 St. Chrysostom, more particularly referred to a portrait 
 known by them, and accepted as authentic. There is 
 not such particular evidence about St. Peter. St. Basil 
 mentions portraits of apostles and martyrs generally as 
 being known and received from Apostolic times ; but 
 with regard to St. Peter, for whose portrait, with that 
 of St. Paul, any strong claim of authenticity is made, 
 we can but feel that the unchanging type of head and 
 features assigned to him from first to last suggests the 
 confidence with which his likeness was received from 
 earliest times, and allows a very fair presumption for 
 its traditionary truth. The heads of these two apostles 
 were constantly figured together. They are found so 
 in the middle of the third century in etchings on gold 
 of the ornamental glass cups and plates then very much 
 in vogue. Occasionally they are represented standing 
 opposite to each other, with a great cross between 
 them ; and sometimes only their busts are given. At 
 a later date they stand right and left of the figure of 
 Christ, and are found so in sculpture, painting, and 
 mosaic. 
 
vin ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 287 
 
 The reverence which withheld the hands of the early 
 Christians from the representation of their Master's 
 person and led to the indirect use of symbolic figures in 
 picturing the events of His life, prevailed with even 
 greater force and persistency in relation to His death. 
 The feeling of the artists even in the representation of 
 such subjects as made his presence necessary, induced 
 them to maintain the symbolic rather than the real 
 expression of His acts ; and for centuries after the 
 introduction of His bodily form had been commonly 
 accepted by all Christendom, still the symbols of the 
 Lamb, the Cross, the Altar, and the Book as " the 
 Word " of God were equally employed and approved 
 as the reverential expression of more forcible appeal to 
 each individual mind than what the weak tools of art 
 could effect through direct representation. Thus till 
 the sixth century realism and symbolism had continued 
 side by side on all subjects but that of their Master's 
 death. Upon that the vision only of devoted faith had 
 been fixed ; for no hand had dared to portray a sub- 
 ject surrounded with such awful mystery as the self- 
 sacrifice of Christ an event so stupendous as the 
 crucifixion of the Son of God. 
 
 Such, however, would inevitably be introduced into 
 the practice, as it had been shown symbolically in the 
 purpose of an art which was not only useful for its 
 witness to the faith, for its power of instruction, for the 
 soothing comfort of its effects upon the contemplative 
 spirit of religion, but, under many circumstances, for 
 its absolute necessity. The intention, the history, the 
 need of the world had been leading up to this great 
 event Suffering and death had been recognised 
 throughout the existence of humanity as the only 
 ultimate punishment for crime ; and from the depth of 
 time the conscience of mankind had accepted sacrifice as 
 the only means of that atonement of reconciliation which 
 
288 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 could obliterate evil. Whatever sacrifice men could 
 make, the infirmity and inalienable corruption of their 
 nature would mar the offering of the very best of them ; 
 but here was the sacrifice of the only faultless man, the 
 central figure of the world's history. In its divine ideal 
 it was impossible of representation ; but imagination 
 may be too much constrained. Human sense must 
 be satisfied when its object may be gained without 
 offence. Humanity had its entire part in that its central 
 sacrifice ; and for its sight it craved that which had 
 been already pictured in its heart. 
 
 For above a thousand years among the numberless 
 subjects which have covered the walls of sacred places 
 the bare cross was still prominent. In the sacred 
 solitudes of the Catacombs the crucified figure was not 
 seen till for seven hundred years the cross alone had 
 sufficed to fill the minds of Christian worshippers. To 
 their accustomed eyes the cross personified their Master, 
 and was itself an epitome of gospel story. If in the 
 secret recesses of individual lives the craving for reality 
 had allowed what no other eyes were to rest upon, and 
 the figure of the Crucified was drawn, engraved, or set 
 as a treasure of jewelry, an amulet or a memorial, 
 such it was and no more. The unoccupied cross ex- 
 pressed the idea of Christendom as the symbol of 
 victory. Its form was drawn upon the ground as the 
 plan on which Constantine's great basilicas were built, 
 the church of the Holy Apostles at Constantinople and 
 of St. Peter's within and St. Paul's without the walls of 
 Rome. Embossed with jewelry on solid gold, it was 
 the chief ornament of the ceiling in his Imperial palace 
 of the East. It filled the centre of the dome of the 
 mausoleum of the Empress Placidia. In the baptistery 
 of St. Pontianus at Rome it still stands above the pool 
 of water, painted of large dimensions, rich with jewels, 
 and richer still with its symbolism of sacrifice and life, 
 
viii ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 289 
 
 bearing on its cross-beam the two lighted candles with 
 the Alpha and Omega suspended beneath them, in 
 place of Him who in two natures was " the Light of 
 the world," " the first and the last." Here the jewelled 
 cross was itself the symbol of His precious death, and 
 the fresh branches of leaves and flowers, which grew 7 
 out all up its stem, as it rose from the water, were the 
 symbols of His life. In the apse of St. Pudentiana 
 the bare cross represents not suffering but victory over 
 death and evil, as it rises above His enthroned figure 
 with the emblems of the evangelists right and left. 
 It personates Him in the scene of the transfiguration 
 as it stands on the mount between Moses and Elias 
 with the three disciples symbolised as sheep beneath it, 
 over the altar of S. Apollinare in Classe at Ravenna. 
 As late as the thirteenth century it was set in mosaic, as 
 the great cross of baptism, in the apse of the Lateran 
 basilica, where the stream of blessing poured from 
 above issues from its base as a fountain of living water, 
 and then separates into the four rivers of Paradise. 
 
 In less prominent forms but executed with the 
 utmost care the bare cross was multiplied during the 
 first five centuries, sometimes with a sacramental, some- 
 times with a personal reference, as it is seen taking the 
 place of Christ's majesty, placed on a throne sur- 
 rounded by the standing figures of the apostles, on the 
 cupola of the baptistery at Ravenna ; or, even in a 
 more remarkable manner, occupying the place of 
 honour on the wall above the apse of Santa Maria 
 Maggiore at Rome, where in the centre above the 
 subjects of the annunciation, the adoration of the Magi, 
 and others, a throne, much in the form of an altar, is 
 placed with the sacred roll of the Scriptures upon it, 
 and a small black cross, crowned and covered with a 
 veil standing upon it, representing the offering upon 
 the altar, while a large cross rises up above it, richly 
 
 U 
 
290 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 jewelled, reaching to the roof, the symbol of the sacri- 
 fice. In sculpture the cross is equally various and 
 beautiful. On the front of the sarcophagus of Anicius 
 Probus, Praetorian Prefect of the province of Italy in 
 395, a tall and youthful figure of Christ stands under 
 the central arch supporting by His right hand an orna- 
 mented cross, of the same height as Himself, and with 
 the left holding the roll of the Gospel. One other 
 sculptured sarcophagus must not be passed without 
 notice, because of the emphasis given to the crucifixion 
 as the one subject omitted among the many relating to 
 it. It is in the Lateran Museum, and dates about A.D. 
 400. The cross occupies the central position, with 
 doves seated on the transverse beam, and its upper 
 limb supporting the monogram XP enclosed within a 
 wreath. Beneath it are seated two figures, and on the 
 right and left are sculptured the groups of Christ held 
 by a soldier -before the judgment-seat ; an attendant 
 bringing the basin and water to Pilate, who is seated, 
 with averted face, in doubt ; balanced on the opposite 
 side by the subjects of Christ bearing the cross and a 
 soldier crowning Him with thorns, in this case more 
 like a wreath of leaves, the central subject of the cruci- 
 fixion being expressed only by its symbols. As the 
 symbol of baptism, a tall cross is carved upon the font 
 of the church of S. Apollinare Nuovo at Ravenna, where 
 it stands supreme upon the globe (about A.D. 570). 
 
 As the prominent devotional ornament of a church, 
 Paulinus, the Bishop of Nola, about 403, describes 
 in one of his poetical epistles in honour of St. Felix, 
 the way in which he combined the cross with the figure 
 of the Lamb. He had covered the entrance through 
 the cloisters to the church with pictures to tempt the 
 people to come in, and other parts of the building with 
 subjects from the Old Testament ; but in the apse of 
 the basilica at Fondi, above the altar, he represented 
 
vii ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 291 
 
 the Lamb with a crimson cross above it, about which 
 he writes thus : 
 
 " The work and wage of saints hold well together, 
 Steep though their cross, their prize is high their crown 
 God's self to us Lord both of cross and crown, 
 Midst heavenly groves of glorious Paradise. 
 In the white Lamb beneath a blood red cross, 
 Christ stands the Lamb the sinless victim doom'd 
 To undeserved death." l 
 
 The desire to realise the scene of the crucifixion, 
 and yet the dread of exposing its suffering and shame, 
 was exhibited in the ingenious expedients of its indirect 
 representation, of which there is a beautiful illustration 
 in a small work which has so nearly attained the com- 
 plete subject of the crucifixion as to have represented 
 the two thieves crucified right and left, with a vacant 
 cross between them, the blessed Virgin being on one 
 side and St. Peter holding his keys on the other, and 
 below them the tomb with the two Maries approaching, 
 and the angel watching beside it. At the top of the 
 whole composition is the head of Christ glorified, with 
 a cruciform nimbus, and the sun and moon on either 
 side ; but the one figure, the key to the whole, is 
 omitted, and the cross, with two figures (Adam and 
 Eve ?) kneeling beside it, stands in the centre unoc- 
 cupied of living wood covered with its leaves. 
 
 This is the subject figured upon one of the metal 
 flasks containing holy oil from the graves of the martyrs 
 in the catacombs of Rome, which Gregory the Great 
 presented in A.D. 604 to the Lombard Queen Thodo- 
 linda. The traditional account of these flasks, and 
 
 1 Sanctorum labor et merces sibi rite cohserent, 
 Ardua crux pretiumque crucis sublime corona, 
 Ipse Deus, nobis princeps crucis atque corona, 
 Inter gloriferi cseleste nemus paradisi, 
 Sub cruce sanguinea niveo stat Christus in agno, 
 Agnus ut innocua injusto datus hostia leto. 
 
 EPISTLE xxxii. 
 
292 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 corroborated by the character of their art, is that they 
 were brought to Rome from Jerusalem, where they had 
 served to hold the oil for lamps in the holy places. 
 They now belong to the treasury of the cathedral at 
 Monza. On another of these flasks the crucifixion is 
 represented by the figure of Christ in the attitude of 
 crucifixion, and fully draped, but with no cross be- 
 hind it. 
 
 But England is not wanting in works of this kind. 
 The work may be rude, but the poetry of its intention 
 is none the less for the roughness of its handling ; and, 
 indeed, if the place of England among early Christian 
 nations is remembered, the struggle of the faith and the 
 roughness of life, such works have an interest that so 
 attracts our feeling to the poor uninstructed artist as to 
 disarm all criticism of his handiwork, -and to engage 
 our sympathy toward the deep far-reaching idea in his 
 mind an idea loved and precious to him, vaguely con- 
 ceived and realised only by an artless art, but precious 
 to all time as an evidence of the pervading idea of 
 Christendom to its most distant shores. 
 
 Perhaps the earliest objects of Christian represen- 
 tative art in England are the rude figures on the 
 crosses, of which the ruins remain in some quiet church- 
 yards up and down the country, and of which the 
 models were evidently derived from those erected by 
 the saintly Columba in the island of lona. From 
 about A.D. 580 he and his companions had spread 
 Christianity in the north of England, and among the 
 most eminent of them, St. Aidan from lona, in 635 
 founded the monastery of Lindisfarne ; and another, 
 Diuma by name, who died in 659, was consecrated at 
 Repton the first bishop of the Mid- Angles. With these 
 men and those who came with them, the traditions of 
 Christian art were brought to the heart of England. 
 But art itself was non-existent there, and the earliest 
 
viii ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 293 
 
 attempts were the works of artless hands of men feeling 
 after the means to realise the ideas which fascinated 
 and occupied their imagination. We need not wander 
 far south from that immediate neighbourhood to find 
 illustrations of their works. At Wirkworth Church in 
 Derbyshire, in the year 1820, a stone measuring 5 feet 
 long by 2 feet 9 inches wide was turned up from the 
 covering of a grave in the chancel, 2 feet below the 
 floor, of which the side that had been reversed was 
 found covered with elaborate sculpture. It was of the 
 rudest kind. The design was divided into two series 
 of subjects, one over the other, somewhat confused in 
 arrangement, and leaving much, but plainly, to be inter- 
 preted. On the left at the top the subject is that of 
 Christ stooping to wash the Apostles' feet. Next to 
 them is a broad plain cross taking the whole height 
 of the division, and with all four arms equal. In the 
 centre of its flat unornamented surface is a small 
 medallion, precisely where the medallion of Christ's 
 portrait occurs in the great cross of the Transfiguration 
 at Ravenna, and that of His baptism upon the cross of 
 the Lateran at Rome ; but here the medallion is occu- 
 pied by the figure of a dead lamb. It is but poorly 
 executed, but the whole idea is there. The little 
 animal, with his head drooped in death and his legs 
 crumpled together, was in the poor artist's mind the 
 figure of the " Lamb as it had been slain." Thus the 
 poorest art often contains the deepest poetry, and is 
 often all the more effective from its pure and simple 
 suggestiveness, incapable of realism. It cannot be told 
 when this work was executed, but it must have been 
 in Saxon times. The Norman conquerors had ruined 
 all that they could reach that might remain to the 
 glory of the vanquished ; and this reversed and buried 
 monument, without a name and without a record, tells 
 the story of their reckless policy. To what purpose it 
 
294 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 could have served can only be conjectured, for it might 
 equally well have formed the side of a sarcophagus, or 
 an altar frontal or a reredos. 
 
 Thus, and in countless other ways, the subject of 
 the crucifixion was approached in northern and 
 southern art as mingled fear and reverence sur- 
 rounded and restrained it. To represent its reality 
 was irksome and grievous, so the figure of the cross 
 alone became the accepted symbol of the sacrifice, 
 and the flowers and foliage springing from its stem 
 were the symbols of the life which that sacrifice had 
 won ; or, if that would not suffice, the Lamb was 
 drawn standing by the cross, or on Mount Calvary, 
 bleeding from five wounds, or laid upon the altar, 
 with the cross or monogram rising above it, or with 
 the seven golden candlesticks or the four archangels 
 grouped on either side. It was the favourite subject 
 carved by rudest hands no less than the honoured 
 subject chosen for works of the highest art that the 
 time could produce, as we find it selected for the 
 central medallion of the silver-gilt cross presented to 
 the basilica of St. Peter at Rome by the Emperor 
 Justin II. in the sixth century, where the figure of 
 the Lamb, that by its nimbus is shown to personify 
 Christ, is represented carrying the cross. 
 
 But sight craved for more : such art could not 
 satisfy ; the mere animal form of the Lamb could 
 afford no expansiveness of expression, nor among the 
 circumstances of the crucifixion could it take but an 
 insufficient part, and arouse but a limited sympathy. 
 Its effect was extremely various, for to some minds 
 the strain of thought which symbolism demanded 
 became wearisome, and the very symbol itself be- 
 came at last repugnant ; while to others the attri- 
 buted sanctity of its associations aroused a devotion 
 akin to idolatry. It was, therefore, at an age of 
 
viii ADORNMENT OF ACRED BUILDINGS 295 
 
 matured Christianity, in no spirit of irreverence, nor 
 in want of adequate reason, that the Greek Council 
 at Constantinople in 692 broke through the antipathy 
 and dread that Christendom had hitherto felt to direct 
 representation, and ordered that in place of these 
 symbols, the figure of Christ should be represented. 
 
 There was good ground for the theory on which 
 the judgment of that Council was based, for realism is 
 the absolute opposite to that mysticism in which dis- 
 ordered imagination loses its way into the regions of 
 idolatry. Every approach to realism in art is a step 
 in the direction of that perfection which so absorbs all 
 interest in itself as to allow no space nor spring for 
 individual independence. The consummate art of 
 Greek sculpture or of Raphael's painting seems to 
 balk all further thought. Its interest or poetry of 
 idea is concentrated within itself. The subject, the 
 treatment, the expression are complete; they absorb 
 all thought and master all imagination. If feeling 
 is roused, it is within the limits of the subject itself; 
 if devotional sense is touched, it is in sympathy alone 
 with the artist's expression of it. But a vaguer art, 
 symbolic and ideal, whether simply so or made so by 
 consummate artifice, touches another chord in human 
 nature, sets the heart free, and opens wide the springs 
 of association an art, apparently unconscious of itself, 
 that all generations have loved for its pure and fresh 
 suggestiveness ; an art that had no power to satisfy, 
 but set the mind pondering, far off in time and place, 
 on the realities of the past and of the future, where the 
 affections might rest or the imagination wander free. 
 
 It had been only through the excess of this ideal 
 freedom that the pure purposes of early Christian art 
 had been perverted ; but now, in the fearlessness of 
 direct representation, the way of art's advance was 
 cleared, and though the figure of the symbolic " Lamb 
 
296 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 as it had been slain" that antiquity had hallowed, and 
 martyrs, saints, and generations of the faithful had 
 looked upon and loved, had power still to appeal to 
 all hearts by the touch of poetry, and of nature too, 
 that it possessed, the more grave and great reality 
 of Christ's own figure, slowly, but surely, gained that 
 place which the enlarging sphere of art itself, and the 
 expanding intelligence of more cultured life, demanded. 
 
 Still reverence stayed the artist's hand. The author- 
 ity of the gospels that His garment and His vesture 
 were taken from Him, confirmed by the common 
 custom at Roman crucifixions, presented a reality 
 too painful for representation. Pain and degradation 
 might be thought of, but the higher ideal of dignity 
 prevailed ; and if the sacred body of the Son of God 
 that alone almost too awful for thought was to 
 be represented on the cross, it must be with reverence. 
 So the figure was draped from the shoulders to the 
 feet. The nude figure, clothed only with a short 
 skirt about the loins, sketched as a caricature on the 
 walls of the palace of the Caesars, has been offered 
 as a proof of the representation of this subject being 
 practised by Christians in the second century ; but 
 the whole tone of early symbolism, the avoidance of 
 the .subject in all places where early art is extant, 
 the marked omission of the figure even where the 
 absence of it spoils a composition, the negative evi- 
 dence of early literature in which the subject, in 
 relation to the arts, finds no place, are a sufficient 
 reply. The scene of a crucifixion was common at 
 Rome at that time, and furnished the caricaturist 
 with all he needed to throw scorn on those who were 
 the Christians of Caesar's household. 
 
 Archaeology has been searched in vain to ascer- 
 tain the earliest example of the crucifixion as a 
 subject of wall painting. If any surmise might be 
 
viii ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 297 
 
 fairly made from the illustrations of it in smaller 
 works, it must have had its earliest development in 
 the Eastern rather than the Western Church. The 
 approach to it appears to have been characterised by 
 the reverential avoidance of the nude figure ; but it 
 is remarkable that the illustration, which bears evi- 
 dence of being the earliest known extant specimen 
 of it in painting, exhibits the figure nude, with the 
 exception of a small loin cloth. The reason for this 
 peculiarity, exceptional in the early practice, is in- 
 teresting and explains the adoption of it in that par- 
 ticular instance and its prevalance in after ages. 
 
 The controversies relating to the person and nature 
 of Christ greatly disturbed the peace of the Church at 
 that time, from the fifth to the seventh centuries, and 
 among the various parties into which the contending 
 sects of Nestorians and Eutychians formed themselves 
 was one which, from the desertion of its leaders, who 
 joined the orthodox Church, called themselves " the 
 akephaloi," headless. Against these, who had adopted 
 the monophysite heresy, the monk Anastasius Sanaita, 
 about A.D. 600, composed a written refutation, and to 
 give force to his arguments, which, with their answers, 
 have been preserved among his writings, he states that 
 he drew a picture of the Crucified ; and such was the 
 successful employment of this illustration in the con- 
 troversy, that he left at his death a request that who- 
 ever copied his MS. should also copy his picture. 
 This was done, and led to the adoption of that par- 
 ticular form of the composition for its doctrinal value, 
 and thus to the perpetuation of it to the present day, 
 with such slight variation of detail only as style, 
 country, or date may have suggested. The picture 
 presents the crucifix alone, with the body rather 
 standing than hanging from the cross, uncovered, ex- 
 cept by a short skirt from the hips to above the knee- 
 
298 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 caps. The head, with a rayed nimbus, declines to the 
 right, its long hair falling down behind the shoulders ; 
 each foot being nailed to the support, and blood flow- 
 ing from the five wounds. 1 
 
 It has been already mentioned that although the 
 Council at Constantinople in 692 had ordered the 
 picturing of Christ's body on the cross, it had not 
 actually originated that practice, for natural representa- 
 tions of the crucifixion were known previous to that 
 time in miniature painting and in objects of private 
 use. For instance, there is a small cross among the 
 treasures of the cathedral at Monza which dates from 
 a period above half a century before that Council ; and 
 by the account of it, which there is reason to accept as 
 true, this precious object of devotion h'ad belonged to 
 Gregory the Great, who had sent to the Queen Theo- 
 dolinda the flask of holy oil, and who subsequently 
 sent this pectoral cross to her on the birth of her son 
 Adulowald. The figure of Christ is here designed as 
 standing on a suppedaneum, and nailed to an inlaid 
 piece of the true cross, His body being draped from 
 the neck to the feet, the arms and feet being left bare. 
 The piece of the true cross is inlaid upon a small 
 golden cross, ornamented with a beaded outline and 
 with minute enamelled figures of the Virgin and St. 
 John at the extremities of the cross bar, a rich nimbus 
 round the head, and the sun and moon above the 
 superscription. 
 
 But another illustration, half a century previous to 
 the last, viz. in 586, is the earliest picture I am able to 
 find of the entire subject of the crucifixion, with the 
 associated persons and incidents complete. It is on 
 the first page of a manuscript of the Gospels in the 
 Laurentian library at Florence, which purports to be 
 
 1 Kimstgeschichte des Kreuzes. Von Dr. J. Stockbauer, Schaffhausen, 
 1870, pages 163-4. 
 
viii ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 299 
 
 written at that date by one Rabula, a monk of Zaba 
 in Messopotamia. Here also the figure of Christ is 
 entirely draped, hanging upon a cross somewhat higher 
 than those on each side, where hang the two thieves, 
 their bodies being nude, with the exception of a very 
 small loin cloth. The composition forms a complete 
 picture, and in spite of infirmities of drawing it is 
 full of expression, both in attitude and countenance. 
 A small amount of sky only appearing at the top, with 
 the disks of the sun and moon above the central cross, 
 the groups of figures are relieved against a background 
 of rugged mountain. To the right (dexter] of the cross 
 Longinus, whose name is written above him in Greek, 
 pierces Christ's side with a spear, and on the opposite 
 side a figure draped in a long tunic, holding the " vessel 
 full of vinegar" in his left hand, raises with the other 
 the sponge upon a stalk of hyssop. Beneath this group 
 three soldiers are gambling for the vesture, and groups 
 of women standing on the extreme right and left com- 
 plete the composition. Of these, only one has a nimbus, 
 which at once designates her as the blessed Virgin, close 
 to whom a figure (more probably that of the Magdalene 
 than St. John) stands with her hand raised to her face 
 in an attitude of grief; and on the opposite side the 
 three women who had " followed Him from Galilee, and 
 ministered to Him of their substance," balance the com- 
 position. Thus these two first forms of representing 
 the figure crucified, as described above, and this picture 
 of the scene of the crucifixion in a manuscript gospel 
 of the year 586, seem to have been so completely con- 
 ceived as to have formed the types from which these 
 subjects have been repeated with but little variation till 
 now just 1300 years. They are both Greek. 
 
 The reverence, which such illustrations of the sub- 
 ject exhibit, was carried still farther by representing 
 the figure of Christ as the Lord of Life, standing before 
 
300 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 the cross crowned. The famous crucifix at Lucca is 
 perhaps the earliest extant example of this treatment. 
 The figure is of cedar wood, and by its style it is 
 evidently of oriental origin. It is clothed in a rich 
 garment of gold damask, reaching to the feet. The 
 legs were also clothed and the feet covered with silver 
 shoes, and beneath them is placed the sacramental 
 chalice. Though the age of this work cannot be 
 definitely fixed, the date of the sixth century, which 
 has been assigned to it, may be true. It was brought 
 to Lucca in 782. 1 The expression of similar reverence 
 
 1 As a result of accident, credulity, and imposture, many works of art 
 have been attributed to St. Luke, but totally without historical authority. 
 It is hardly necessary to refer to the extreme improbability of St. Luke 
 being an artist as well as physician, from the antipathy to all artistic re- 
 presentation in which as a Jew he had been brought up, an antipathy 
 inherited by all the early Christians. The earliest date at which he is 
 represented as a painter is at the close of the tenth century in the illumin- 
 ations of the Menologion of Basil II., where he is drawn at his easel 
 engaged upon a portrait of the blessed Virgin. Bologna possesses one 
 such portrait attributed to him, of which Masius in Bologna perlus- 
 trata, gives an account, that it was brought to Bologna in the latter half 
 of the twelfth century, having been found at Jerusalem by Eudosia, wife 
 of Theodosius the Younger (408-450), and sent by her to her sister Pul- 
 cheria at Constantinople, where after its miraculous preservation from fire, 
 it was kept in Sa. Sophia ; but there is no historical reference to St. Luke 
 at that time ; indeed I find no notice of him as a painter before the sixth 
 century. In the Diet, of Christ. Antiq., page 878, is a reference to a 
 writer about A.D. 518, which I have not the opportunity to verify, who 
 mentions this same picture. It appears to be the earliest reference to him 
 as an artist. The author was Theodoras the Lector of Constantinople, 
 whose original work is lost, and only known by its relics or excerpts quoted 
 in Nicephorus's Ecclesiastical History. These extracts treat of church 
 history, and particularly of works of art at Constantinople ; and by events 
 to which he refers the earliest date to which his writings can be assigned is 
 to the reign of Justin I. (518-527), or for good reasons more probably above 
 200 years later. The tale about Eudosia's picture by St. Luke was but 
 an anecdote for which he offers no authority. Nicephorus, through whom 
 we have the quotation, died about A.D. 1470. So there was ample time 
 for any development. The first person who mentions this Theodoras Lector 
 is St. John Damascene, who died about A.D. 758, whose predilections on 
 such subjects are well known. The portrait of Christ by St. Luke, set up in 
 the Vatican by Pope Gregory IX. in 1234, illustrates the confidence with 
 which St. Luke's artistic productions were received in the early middle 
 ages. The jealousy of cities and religious establishments led to the 
 miraculous multiplication of these portraits, as was subsequently the case 
 
viii ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 301 
 
 is found in painting in a manuscript of the Gospels 
 belonging to the nunnery of Niedermunster, at Regens- 
 burg, of the earliest years of the eleventh century, 
 
 with that of Sa. Veronica ; and any mysterious-looking Byzantine picture 
 at Rome or elsewhere, of which no one knew the origin, was conveniently 
 attributed to St. Luke. 
 
 The figure at Lucca, which came to be known as the "Volto Santo 
 di Lucca," was brought there in 782, at that time not assigned to St. Luke 
 but to Nicodemus. The confusion between the name of the place and 
 that of the evangelist is the only assignable reason for its fame as the 
 work of St. Luke. A simple transposition of a letter might equally account 
 for its attribution to Nicodemus : for the figure is one of Eastern origin, 
 and may have very possibly been brought from the East soon after its rescue 
 from the emissaries of Leo the Iconoclast, about A.D. 730, and have been 
 introduced, at its last resting-place, Lucca, as the " Sacro Volto di Nico- 
 demia " (for Nicomedia, one of the most important and wealthy Christian 
 cities of the East), and as the geographical knowledge of the inhabitants of 
 Lucca was nil, the word would have been at once associated with the only 
 name that every one did know, viz. Nicodemus. This figure had also been 
 confounded with a wonder-working image at Baryta, afterwards brought to 
 Constantinople, but at that time associated neither with Nicodemus nor St. 
 Luke. It was subsequent to the fame attained by this "Volto Santo" at 
 Lucca that St. Luke became generally regarded as an artist. It was to 
 the interest of the supporters of the Second Council of Nicea, A.D. 787, 
 that he should be so. But nothing can be too wonderful for tradition on 
 such subjects. Manni, in his Lezione del vero Litca Santo, illustrates their 
 absurdity by quoting an author who describes a picture of the Virgin, painted 
 on wood by St. Luke, that was brought to Rome by St. Peter and presented 
 by him to St. Romolo. Another solemnly asserts that it was Martha the 
 sister of Lazarus who brought to Rome a portrait of Christ. He further 
 illustrates the confusion of names and authorities in the middle ages, by 
 referring to a work published at Florence in 1441, dedicated to " St. John, 
 Baptist, Apostle, and Evangelist," and to the same effect he quotes the 
 Capitoli of the Academy of St. Luke the Evangelist, in which the saint is 
 called "Apostolo." 
 
 After the fame of the Lucca crucifix, confused with the name of St. 
 Luke, had originated the fashion of attributing many works to that saint, 
 the monk Niceforus Calistus, writing in the fourteenth century an account 
 of the church of the company of Nostra Donna dell' Impruneta at Florence, 
 states that that (then famous) picture was painted by St. Luke " Christi 
 matris imaginem Apostolus Lucas suis ipse manibus depinxit," etc. This 
 was an evident confusion of names derived from that of a certain Luca, a 
 man of such saintly life in Florence in the eleventh century as to have been 
 styled Luca Santo. He was an artist, and had been employed by the 
 founders of a Romitorio (an establishment of recluses) in 1097. The 
 church of the "Impruneta" existed at that time, and its famous picture is 
 attributable to this Luca Santo. But so completely had the name of the 
 evangelist taken his place that the Government authorities of Florence in 
 1385, writing to Pope Urban VI., vindicated the authority of this picture 
 
302 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 which represents Christ standing before the cross, 
 crowned^ draped, and with a crossed nimbus about his 
 head. He looks downward to a female figure standing 
 beside the cross, with her hands raised as in adoration, 
 wearing a crown with a small cross above it, who, by 
 the word VITA written beside her, is evidently in- 
 tended to impersonate redeemed life. On the opposite 
 side is the male figure of MORS, death, in the attitude 
 of falling, and holding a broken spear which wounds 
 his head. There is a beautiful illustration of this 
 tribute of honour to the crucified Saviour in a wall- 
 painting of the middle of the thirteenth century, in the 
 church of St. Sylvestro at Rome, which presents a very 
 complete picture, with the two thieves crucified, and 
 Longinus with his spear on one side and Stephaton 
 with the sponge of vinegar on the other ; but the 
 specially original feature of the scene is the figure of 
 an angel hovering above the cross, placing with the 
 right hand a royal crown on the Saviour's head, and 
 with the left carrying away the crown of thorns. 
 
 Among the number of invaluable works of early 
 and mediaeval art, of which all vestiges have been lost 
 by the destruction of the original basilica of St. Peter 
 at Rome, were two important pictures of this subject 
 in mosaic. They were executed by direction of Pope 
 John VII. in the year 706, and had they existed till 
 now they would have been unique among Christian 
 mosaics as specimens of the earliest pictures of the 
 crucifixion publicly exhibited at Rome, important in 
 the dimensions and the completeness of their design. 
 They ornamented the space above the entrance, and 
 
 as one by " St. Luca, Apostolo." Vide also Manni "del errore che per- 
 siste di attribuirsi le pitture al Santo Evangelista. " He quotes Padre 
 Landucci on the subject of many pictures of the blessed Virgin painted by 
 St. Luke, on the authority that "in the year 359 the dead body of St. 
 Luke was discovered, and that at the head of the grave was found a 
 portrait of the Virgin," but the author wisely abstains from stating where 
 this occurred ! 
 
vin ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 303 
 
 on one of the interior walls of a chapel dedicated by 
 him to the blessed Virgin. The exterior mosaic was 
 the more complete, exhibiting the crucified figure 
 clothed in a long tunic to the feet, and, though pierced 
 by the spear, alive, with open eyes and without trace 
 of suffering in quiet dignity, as though triumphant 
 over death even upon the cross. The figures of the 
 sponge -bearer, His mother, and the faithful disciple 
 stood beside Him. The other picture, within the 
 chapel, presented a similar figure of the living Christ, 
 also clothed to the feet, with angels on each side in 
 attitudes of adoration, the sun and moon being shown 
 above, and the figures of His mother and St. John 
 standing below. 1 
 
 These few examples are enough at least to illustrate 
 the tone of feeling with which such subjects were then 
 approached. It was an age perhaps justly charged 
 with ignorance and superstition, its misfortune rather 
 than its fault, but holding firmly to a genuine faith in 
 the realities of those great truths which art was thus 
 employed to teach ; and worthy at least of our reverence 
 and regard for that spiritual ideal which it possessed, 
 but which our own age wants, an ideal as precious as it 
 is rare. 
 
 To refill the void, which accident and the frailty of 
 materials have caused, the sole resource open to us is 
 to recreate in imagination the great works with which 
 the walls of sacred buildings were once covered, by 
 picturing them as in character and composition similar 
 to those smaller works which to our day have been pre- 
 served in sculpture or among the pages of illumination, 
 or treasured in the forms of enamel or jewelry. The 
 painting of the crucifixion upon a wall, which claims 
 the earliest date, is the one mentioned in the writings 
 of St. Gregory of Tours, about A.D. 600, in the cathe- 
 
 1 Vide Ciampini, De Sacris sEdificiis. Tav. xxiii. 
 
304 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 dral of Narbonne. It has long since perished. In that 
 picture the figure of Christ was nude ; and by the same 
 authority the story is preserved that the exposure of 
 the sacred body so distressed the good bishop of that 
 See, that by his direction a curtain was kept drawn 
 before it. Another early wall painting of the cruci- 
 fixion is that in the Julian catacomb at Rome, in all 
 probability of the eighth or ninth century, in which our 
 Lord stands before the cross upon a suppedaneum, with 
 both hands nailed, and clothed from the neck to the 
 feet in a long white robe. It is composed, as very 
 many have been since, with the cross measuring the 
 main height and breadth of the picture, and with none 
 but the figures of the blessed Virgin and St. John 
 beside it. Our Lord is alive, and in perfect repose. 
 He bows His head and looks down upon His mother 
 as though addressing to her the words, " Woman, behold 
 thy son." 
 
 Thus, in all the works of whatever kind representing 
 this subject, it is worthy of remark, that till the close 
 of the first 1000 years of the era, with rarest exception, 
 the figure of Christ is represented alive, and not till the 
 eleventh century were developed the types of suffering 
 and death. 
 
 It is a common remark that the character of an 
 age is illustrated by its arts ; and it would be strange 
 if it were not so, for art is no more nor less than a 
 mode of expressing human feeling ; it is as a tool in a 
 man's hand, and as the heart is that guides that hand, 
 so will the art be. Those centuries were saddened by 
 violence and barbarism, and art only repeated the sense 
 of oppression which characterised them. Refuge and 
 relief were sought in monastic seclusion, but the disci- 
 pline of the cloister only too often consummated the 
 sadness which prevailed in the world outside. When 
 life awoke in the following age, the inherited asceticism 
 
viii ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 305 
 
 still swayed the minds of the church's most devoted 
 sons, and turned the course of their spiritual life into 
 an enthusiasm of suffering. Thus art was still veiled 
 in sadness, and the central figure of all its interest was 
 exhibited scored with pain, wearied, wan and dead. 
 And the spirit of sadness has pervaded the arts of 
 religious expression ever since ; but as the day of 
 trouble cleared, art cleared too, still often sad, as remi- 
 niscence might well make it, but turning sadness into 
 poetry, making suffering heroic and pathos sublime. 
 
 But such result was not attained at once, nor indeed 
 has it at any time been attained but by few. In that 
 age the ideal of suffering had mastered the mind of 
 art. Self-imposed suffering had become the accepted 
 sign of sanctity; for the Master was the great example; 
 and from this an ideal was formed of human life asso- 
 ciated with Deity, against which art had for centuries 
 struggled by recourse to symbol and emblem ; but, 
 having once succumbed, it was held spell-bound ; and 
 Christ no more the spotless Lamb with the rivers of 
 Paradise breaking forth from beneath His feet, no more 
 as the Lord of life in triumph over the Cross before 
 which He stood habited as King, and crowned as 
 Supreme, His precious death was pictured not as rest 
 but agony. 
 
 To attain the higher ideal it needed conditions 
 which that age had neither the sensibility to feel nor 
 the power to express. Art had fallen everywhere. In 
 the north, what little remained from the influence of 
 such feeble art as Roman conquerors had introduced 
 had been lost in the succeeding barbarism. The 
 dignity that had first been acquired from classic models, 
 and in the days of its decline had imparted a charm of 
 reserve and repose to Byzantine art, had now degene- 
 rated into stiffness ; and the dramatic action of Italian 
 art had fallen into imbecility. Beauty was impossible 
 
 x 
 
306 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 to either. The crucifix was the symbol of a grievous 
 penance ; the attitude of the Crucified was of one bent 
 in pain and debased in helplessness. The great artists 
 of the first renaissance, such as Giunta of Pisa, Margari- 
 tone of Arezzo, Guido of Siena, Cimabue of Florence, 
 set painful examples. Through all the phases of Gothic 
 painting and sculpture in Europe at that age, the 
 Saviour was known only as the Man of Sorrows, 
 wounded, dead. It needed the devotional sense of the 
 Umbrian school to mitigate the exhibition of pain, and 
 the piety of Giovanni da Fiesole to present the Lord 
 in quietude upon the cross. 
 
 The artists who had treated the subject till the 
 eleventh century had represented it with dignified 
 reverence, and had done their best to relieve it of all 
 pain but such as was inevitable to it. They pictured 
 the Crucified alive, calm and painless ; and maintained 
 the tradition of the sacred words that "His mother 
 was standing by His cross," as they painted her some- 
 times, motionless, in silent grief, sometimes with arms 
 stretched out, or hands and head raised towards Him, 
 as though listening to His last words. St. John too 
 was standing there with equal calmness contemplating 
 his dying Master. 
 
 But art became confused and depressed, and 
 another ideal was adopted, which spread far and wide. 
 With the Italians it had declined altogether, and north 
 of the Alps it hardly existed. The Greeks who had 
 been invited in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries to 
 Venice and Florence, the native painters who had risen 
 in Pisa, Lucca, Siena, and Arezzo, had spread their 
 influence in the south ; and the pilgrims from afar 
 had carried home tales of wonder, and spread their 
 reminiscences among the artists of the north. The 
 pictures of these Greeks and their Italian pupils were 
 composed sometimes with the isolated figure alone, 
 
viii ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 307 
 
 sometimes with small panels filling up the intervals 
 afforded by the arms of the cross, and painted with 
 incidents from our Lord's life. The figure itself was 
 often colossal, and always painful, emaciated and dis- 
 torted in form, livid and unnatural in colour. It could 
 only repel the sight and harass the thought, in the 
 attempt to show what load of suffering, for what mass 
 of sin, as that of the whole world, was needed for its 
 redemption. It was the result of a morbid state of 
 religious life. Whether from the roughness of the 
 times, or the false ideal of terror as the only element of 
 power to affect the rudeness of the public mind, the 
 true idea of the crucifixion was missed or ignored. A 
 finer sense could alone conceive and portray the 
 beauty of self-devotion, in a sacrifice self-imposed, a 
 death accepted as the only mode of sacrifice, irrespec- 
 tive of its terror or its pain ; the fulfilment of the 
 mystery of reconciliation, by the wrong done by death 
 to a perfectly just Man, to balance the wrong done by 
 sin to a perfectly just God ; and thus in the person of 
 Christ, as between God and man, to redress the equi- 
 poise of perfect justice. Such a conception of love as 
 of one who had "laid down His life for His friends," 
 who accepted the conditions with a perfect obedience 
 less perfectly illustrated in the sufferings of His death 
 than in the dignity of His resignation, was an ideal, 
 if not beyond the apprehension, at least beyond the 
 expression of the artists of those days. 
 
 There was but little joy and less consolation to be 
 got from such art as theirs. Their feeling was sincere, 
 but their art was constrained ; for their age was in the 
 throes of troublous uncertainty, hardness, and contest, 
 and they spoke its sentiment. But the eyes of wor- 
 shippers grew weary and longed for other things ; their 
 faith had hope in it, and they looked for that to meet 
 their eyes that would reflect the hope they felt. It is 
 
308 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 therefore easy to conceive how welcome was the change 
 from those lifeless, severe, forbidding forms, which pre- 
 sented to them only their Redeemer's agony, to bleed 
 the heart in scathing penance rather than tell how their 
 " sorrow and sighing should flee away," how welcome 
 was the relief in that full flow of life and warmth of 
 human sympathy, which glowed in the works of the 
 youthful Giotto. He brought to them a pure and 
 nature-loving genius, fresh as the air of his native 
 Apennines, and rich in variety as the flowery vale he 
 had adopted as his home. As with those who had 
 gone before him, the subject for which all eyes looked 
 was Christ upon the cross ; and it was to his higher 
 sense of the dignity and pathos of that scene that are 
 due those elements of natural emotion, of dramatic 
 interest and devotional expression that he realised in 
 his works, which opened the way to all succeeding 
 artists to delineate, in such variety of suffering or resig- 
 nation, sorrow or rest, as might most deeply touch the 
 heart of each one of them, the awful scene of that 
 central tragedy of the world. Giotto was still young 
 when he painted it on the sacred walls of Assisi. The 
 figure of the Crucified as he there painted it is dead, 
 but no more in the attitude of distorting agony. 
 Suffering and sorrow have indeed left their marks upon 
 it, but rather by that self-imposed sacrifice to engage 
 the adoration of His love than to strike with awe by 
 the exhibition of His pain. His mother had stood 
 beside His cross, and had heard His last words to her ; 
 but " a sword had pierced through her heart also," and 
 she has fallen fainting in the arms of her friends. The 
 other Maries, and those whom the gospel story had 
 described, are there ; and, as if prefiguring those who 
 were to take up the cross and follow Him, St. Francis 
 and the brothers of his order stand there, also His faithful 
 witnesses, and angels hover above in attitudes of grief. 
 
viii ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 309 
 
 Young Giotto's art was still imperfect ; the tradi- 
 tions of the school in which he had been trained were 
 not to be dispelled at once, but his great soul had found 
 the true means of its expression ; his genius had 
 restored life to art and had set it free. 
 
 If at this period we look for the great exemplars in 
 the countries of the south and east, it is inevitable, for 
 north European art was then but just settling from its 
 first enthusiasm into definite systems of native and 
 independent growth, and had but just laid the first lines 
 on which the beauty of its maturity was to be drawn. 
 In the east there still lived the tradition of great days, 
 but in low estate. Its technical knowledge was invalu- 
 able, and had been eagerly sought and studied as the 
 foundation on which art in many parts of Europe had 
 received the first elements of its education. But a 
 more living art now bloomed in Italy, and it is there 
 that we must look in this age for its finest models. 
 
 From that great fresco in the lower church at 
 Assisi, every variety in the treatment of its subject has 
 been developed, as the feeling of each artist conceived 
 it, between the extremes of conventionality and realism. 
 There are two great wall paintings which may suffice 
 to illustrate this, the one devotional by Beato da 
 Fiesole, the other dramatic by Tintoretto. 
 
 On the wall of the chapter room of St. Mark's at 
 Florence, Angelico has presented the subject as one of 
 ideal devotion in a painting of large dimension with 
 figures life-size. The three crucified figures are there 
 high above the company of kneeling and adoring saints, 
 a scene wholly conventional, and without regard to 
 time or place. Christ hangs in peace upon the cross ; 
 His head, wearing the crown of thorns, bends slightly 
 down, asleep in death. All pain has ceased. He has 
 " given his life for the world," and " It is finished." 
 
 The only historic incident introduced is the group 
 
310 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 of his fainting mother, supported on one side, as she 
 falls, by her sister Mary, the wife of Cleopas, and on 
 the other by St. John. The Magdalene kneels in front 
 of her and clasps her in her arms. Beside them the 
 Baptist stands with the usual cross of reeds in his hand, 
 and St. Mark kneels in front of him supporting the 
 open volume of his Gospel on his knee. All the other 
 figures are those of the doctors and saints of the early 
 and mediaeval Church. In the place of honour, kneel- 
 ing close below the cross, is St. Dominic, the founder of 
 the order, with head thrown back, directing his eyes 
 upward, and holding out both arms in an attitude of 
 rapt adoration ; St. Ambrose stands behind him point- 
 ing to the cross, and, slightly turned, looks down 
 toward St. Jerome, who kneels with hands clasped in 
 prayer: With equally expressed devotion and in great 
 variety of attitude a crowd of other saintly men, some 
 stand, some kneel, among whom the more prominent 
 are St. Bernard, St. Thomas Aquinas, St. Benedict and 
 St. Francis of Assisi bending forward as he kneels in 
 the intensity of his devotion, engrossed in the contem- 
 plation of the cross, his refined face in profile express- 
 ing that combination of enthusiasm and humility which 
 characterised his life. On the opposite side St. 
 Laurence and two others complete the saintly com- 
 pany. It is a scene of exquisite tranquillity, with its 
 many figures in action and yet at rest, independent yet 
 united in the one absorbing idea of the adoration of the 
 Redeemer. 
 
 It might be easily conceived how different would be 
 the conceptions of two such minds as those of Beato 
 Angelico, trained to the purest spiritual aspirations in 
 the quiet contemplative life of the cloister, and of Tin- 
 toretto, the brilliant genius brought up and mingling 
 daily in the busy turmoil of Venetian society, in an 
 age and in a place where civilisation had lost its moral 
 
vin AD ORNMENT OF SA CRED B UILDINGS 3 1 1 
 
 and religion its spirituality. And indeed no contrast 
 could be greater than their ideals of this great subject. 
 Tintoretto has produced a stupendous work, a scene 
 of awful agony. With fine dramatic effect he has 
 hidden the countenance of Christ in shadow, as the 
 head crowned with thorns droops forward in death. The 
 figure is grandly quiet upon the only upright cross ; 
 and the halo of pallid light, which envelops it above, 
 gleams weirdly in that scene of gloom. It is a vast 
 picture, with numerous figures scattered over it, some 
 interested, but the most part indifferent; the soldiers at 
 the entrance of a small cavern in the foreground are 
 casting dice for the sacred vesture ; and implements of 
 agony, the axe, the hammer, the saw and the pegs 
 with which the crosses are fixed in the ground, lie 
 about in painful reality. There is no sympathy round 
 the cross. St. John and St. Joseph have left it, and 
 the holy women are grouped upon the ground fainting 
 in despair. On each side the executioners are crucify- 
 ing the thieves, as they lie stretched and struggling on 
 their crosses upon the ground, a scene of stupendous 
 horror. 
 
 It is with infinite relief one turns to contemplate 
 another and very different phase of the subject, and one 
 of exceeding beauty. 
 
 Since that age of sadness in the tenth and eleventh 
 centuries the figure of Christ alive upon the cross is 
 seen but rarely. Throughout northern art in every 
 form in which the crucifixion was multiplied, on walls, 
 in sculpture or in glass painting, the ideal was ever that 
 of the precious death. In southern art the same senti- 
 ment prevailed, but with some beautiful exceptions. 
 The creative genius of the first renaissance of the arts 
 in Italy, Nicholas of Pisa, in the thirteenth century, in 
 carving a panel for the pulpit in the baptistery of his 
 city, represented the Crucified by such a figure as till 
 
312 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 then had not been seen. Reverently did the artist's 
 hand strike from the marble the ideal of his Redeemer. 
 Calm and dignified in attitude, without sign of pain, 
 Christ looks down with half-closed eyes upon His 
 followers who crowd toward Him. His mother has 
 fallen backwards into the arms of her friends, and St. 
 John, in front of her, stands close to the cross, looking 
 upward, as though silently listening to the message 
 which committed her to his care. On the opposite 
 side, the sinister side, all are Jews ; and of these, a 
 scowling Pharisee and a priest pointing upward in con- 
 tempt stand forward from the rest, while the multitude 
 behind them express the mingled sentiments of those 
 who had raised the cry to crucify Him, and of those 
 who now awe-struck looked upon Him and would smite 
 their breasts and return. 
 
 In later art it would be hard to find a grander 
 example suggestive of accompanying events or of 
 greater intensity of feeling, all- concentrated in the re- 
 presentation of a single figure, than in that of the cruci- 
 fixion by Guido at Modena. The solitary figure is 
 alive, but just about to die ; in pain, indeed, but beauti- 
 ful, looking upward in utter resignation, as if the last 
 words had just died upon His lips, " Father, into Thy 
 hand I commend my spirit," as the darkness settles 
 around Him, and the storm of wind, indicative of the 
 earthquake, agitates his drapery. 
 
 The last I will mention is a work of Michael 
 Angelo. There is no known picture or sculpture of 
 the complete subject of the crucifixion by him ; but 
 among his drawings in the British Museum there is one 
 that was evidently a design for a great altar-piece in 
 basso relievo. It was never executed, but had it been 
 so, it would have been, if not one of the most powerful, 
 certainly among the most beautiful of his works. It is 
 in red chalk, sketchy and incomplete, only the three 
 
vin ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 313 
 
 crucified figures being finished, the rest but slightly 
 indicated, but the whole composition is suggested and 
 the whole story told. If ever with so few lines the 
 intensest feeling of this awful scene of solemn grief and 
 troublous confusion was expressed it is here. The 
 crosses rise very high above the figures around them. 
 Men are still engaged, one on the top, another upon a 
 ladder at the foot of the central cross. The figure of 
 our Lord is beautiful ; stretched with its arms raised 
 upward on a Y-shaped cross, painless, motionless, ex- 
 quisitely patient. The head is slightly drooped in 
 shadow, as though its mingled love and grief were too 
 intense to be gazed into ; and so turned toward the left 
 that only the profile is seen, but still looking upward as 
 he appeals to heaven, " Father, forgive them, they know 
 not what they do." There are many figures stretched 
 below, some in grief holding up their arms to Him, 
 some grouped round His mother, who has sunk faint- 
 ing to the ground. It is the picture of a tragedy 
 indeed, for what else could it be ? but composed with 
 such reverence, and expressed with such intensity of 
 mingled tenderness and power, as to engage the deepest 
 sympathy, and arouse ideas that will not be forgotten. 
 
 Sacred imagery is precious to those who can re- 
 spond to it ; an aid to the weak, a delight to the 
 strong, a store unfailing for art to use, to adorn not 
 walls alone but minds, with thoughts of what is highest, 
 noblest, loveliest that the blessed God had spread along 
 the path of life, to lead them upward to Himself. 
 
ESSAY VIII Continued 
 
 THE ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 
 
 PART II EMBLEMATIC FIGURES STYLE MOTIVE 
 
 THAT passing sketch of the greatest motives on which 
 Christian art has been engaged, may be enough 
 at least to show how it is the spirit that impels an 
 artist in his work, that is the source of all its worth. I 
 am not writing a history of the art, but pretending only 
 to indicate, in relation to the adornment of sacred 
 places, the spirit in which an artist should approach 
 them. His work is not by ornament to pander to the 
 luxury of sense or satisfy the refinements of cultivated 
 taste, but to aid architecture by supplementing its 
 highest purposes, to lift poor mortality above its low 
 estate, and to add force and interest to the spiritual 
 influences around it. 
 
 Those great buildings which in still dignity tower 
 above the busy cities around them, witness by their very 
 forms to motives other than those which actuate com- 
 mon life ; and within them all that the arts have com- 
 bined to do, is to tell what those motives are, and, like 
 incense in the air, to fill the atmosphere with the balm 
 of rest and hope and heaven-directed thought. Thus 
 can art minister to spiritual life, and thereby to life's 
 greatest happiness. Its motto is " sursum corda," but 
 as we look back on its history and note how various 
 
ESSAY viii ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 315 
 
 are the forms and phases of character to which men's 
 minds and the spirit of each passing age have moulded 
 its pliant nature, how sacred art was felt to be, with 
 what reverence its first essays were inspired, with what 
 reserve its powers were invoked ; and as the cravings of 
 a fainting faith in days of trouble cried for its help, or 
 weak intelligence hailed with gratitude the beautiful 
 language of its instructive imagery, we see how art 
 betook to bolder steps, and, impelled by new motives 
 to satisfy the world's desires, drew from the dramatic 
 scenery of history, and the vivid truths of life, the 
 language of her appeals, losing hold on the heart as she 
 gained on the understanding, and filling with the 
 limited realities of facts and things, the space that in 
 a former age had been occupied by the free spirit and 
 expanding thoughts of allegory. 
 
 The development of realism had its losses as well as 
 its gains. It had progressed steadily from the fourteenth 
 to the sixteenth century, when the classical furor, carry- 
 ing all before it, forced art into a new direction, turning 
 Christian subjects into academic studies, and gradually 
 materialising its heart. What classicism left, the con- 
 temporary advance of philosophy and science destroyed, 
 fascinating the intelligence of the age with theories 
 which opened a new heaven to the flights of imagina- 
 tion. Art became artificial ; the source of all its 
 spiritual interest was sapped, and the springs of its 
 spontaneous poetry were dried up. 
 
 In discordant contrast with all that early art had 
 conceived, with all that Christian art throughout all its 
 ages had consecrated, with all that early English 
 poetry, " with its strong Teutonic sense," had told and 
 taught, a stilted allegory became the new ideal of the 
 art, and as the sacred associations of its earlier years 
 had lost all their charm, its novel symbols owed their 
 creation to the inspirations of contemporary scholarship 
 
316 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 and secularity. So figures of Saturn, or of Death, in 
 the interesting condition of a skeleton, presided over the 
 tombs, brandishing a scythe or shaking an hour-glass 
 in the face of the world by way of religious consolation. 
 Neptune wielding his trident marked the sarcophagus 
 of a Christian admiral, 1 and Fame, that would have 
 gladly emulated the flight of the winged Nike of 
 Paeonius, trumpeted to heaven the worldly glories of a 
 Christian hero. If the cause of morality and religion 
 happened to need advocacy, the figures of " Patience on 
 a monument smiling at Grief" were suggested to the 
 poet's mind, and the elegantly grouped trio of Faith, 
 Hope, and Charity did duty for its Graces. But when 
 the poetry of symbolism was invoked to aid religion's 
 highest flights, then the obelisks of Egyptian supersti- 
 tion, the broken column of classic Greece, the weeping 
 willow from the waters of Babylon, or the cinerary urn 
 of pagan cremation, marked the Christian graves, and 
 Death's head and cross-bones suggested the aspirations 
 of immortality ! 
 
 Such were the edifying symbols and emblematic 
 figures by which art was engaged to interpret that kind 
 of spiritual life which the age had drawn from mate- 
 rialism and philosophy. At another time it had been 
 otherwise. A different inspiration had produced the 
 natural poetry of such symbols as the palm, the dove 
 with its olive branch, the heart with the cross upon it, 
 the lamb, the anchor, and the crown. Even paganism 
 had surpassed that Christian age of spiritual independ- 
 ence in the beauty of its emblematic art, by that deep 
 and far-reaching poetry, which only simple sincerity and 
 the true nature of unaffected religion, quite irrespective 
 of its character or form, can inspire. 
 
 1 The late Dean Mansel, describing one such monument in St. Paul's, 
 suggested that the sceptre of the god might have been intended for the 
 symbol of Tridentine theology. 
 
vin ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 317 
 
 The emblematic figure which for the longest time 
 continued to be represented in Christian art was that 
 of Ecclesia, the Church. It had begun in the early cata- 
 combs and continued into the heart of the middle ages, 
 when it was supplanted by the figure of the blessed Virgin. 
 As the Orante of the catacombs it impersonated the mili- 
 tant church in prayer on earth ; as the Betrothed it 
 stood nearer to the cross than the virgin Mother ; as 
 the Bride it had been seated on the heavenly throne. 
 The female Oranti have been variously assigned to the 
 portraits of the faithful, on whose tombs they were 
 painted, or to the blessed Virgin, or to the Church as the 
 woman regenerated, or the soul united to Christ, as 
 individual peculiarities indicated them to be. The 
 most respected authority of early Christian art writes 
 thus about them, " Souvent 1'orante represente, soit une 
 martyre, soit une fidele morte, et que plus d'une fois 
 encore elle personnifie 1'Eglise." 1 
 
 Of the figures of " Jesus et Ecclesia " in MS. illumi- 
 nation, and of representations of Ecclesia in mosaic, I 
 have written in a former essay, 2 where examples were 
 given from works of the tenth and thirteenth centuries. 
 But it is not only found in such monumental works as 
 those, but in every other form and material of art At 
 the back of the Siegmaringen crucifix, 3 within a circle 
 occupying the space of the intersection of the four 
 arms, is engraved a female figure seated upon a throne, 
 not crowned, but with apparently a polygonal nimbus, 
 richly draped, holding in her right hand a standard and 
 in her left a chalice, with the inscription, *J Sancta 
 Ecclesia (holy church), engraved round the frame of 
 the medallion. This crucifix is of about the same date 
 
 1 II Cavaliere T. B. de Rossi. Images de la Vierge choisies dans les 
 Catacombs de Rome. 1863. 
 
 2 Christian Mosaic, supra, page 160. 
 
 3 An engraving of this is given in the History of ozir Lord in Art, by 
 Lady Eastlake, vol. ii. p. 332. 
 
318 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 as the great mosaic of the triumph of the Church, in 
 the character of Christ's Bride upon His throne, in the 
 church of Sa. Maria in Trastevere at Rome. 
 
 Of about this period, or probably somewhat earlier, 
 there is a remarkable illustration of Ecclesia in an 
 illuminated MS. in the Bodleian Library at Oxford, 
 where the figures of Ecclesia and Christ are side by 
 side, in the same attitude as in the famous Roman 
 mosaic, Christ's arm being thrown over her neck, with 
 the hand appearing on the opposite shoulder. The 
 Bride is crowned ; her drapery is of gold colour and 
 emerald green, the napkin beneath the crown being 
 blue. Both figures have a golden nimbus, and by one 
 is written the monogram XPC, by the other " ecclla." 
 Like the Roman mosaic, in which all the scriptural 
 quotations are taken from the Song of Songs, this 
 picture also illustrates that bridal poetry, being the 
 illumination of an initial letter of one of St. Thomas 
 Aquinas's sermons on that book. 1 
 
 The emblematic accessories of the chalice and the 
 flag mark this figure in almost all the examples where 
 she stands beside the cross. As the accepted Bride she is 
 frequently contrasted with the faithless bride of the Jewish 
 Church, who is also usually distinguished from other 
 figures by carrying a standard. In mediaeval designs 
 the figure of the Church abounds in painted glass, as in 
 that of Chartres, Mans, Bourges, and St. Denis, some- 
 times carrying a cross, sometimes a model of a little 
 church, usually with a nimbus about its head and 
 crowned ; while the figure of the Jewish Church is treated 
 with indignity, being thrust away with hand or spear, 
 or, as in the painted glass at Chartres, she has her 
 eyes bandaged and blinded by a demon ; or, as in that 
 of Mans, she faints despairingly into the arms of Aaron, 
 while St. Peter crowns the accepted Ecclesia ; or in 
 
 1 Lib. Bod., Laud MS. 127, old number, beneath it [Laud 150]. 
 
vin ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 319 
 
 that at St. Denis, where she is repudiated by Christ, 
 who turns with favour to His accepted Bride. As such 
 it is also found in MS. miniatures, on carved ivories, 
 and in sculpture. Of the former there is a curious 
 illustration in a miniature belonging to the church of 
 St. Cross at Ratisbon, in which, to avoid all mistake, 
 the Church has her title as the Bride plainly written 
 "Sponsa." She stands next to the cross and herself 
 pierces the side of the Crucified, while another figure, 
 named Fides, issuing from a cloud, holds out the chalice 
 to catch the blood. Other figures taking part in the 
 scene are similarly named Pity, Wisdom, and Obedience, 
 who with gentle care fasten the nails of the cross. On 
 the opposite side to the Sponsa, is the contrasted group 
 of an angel reaching from a cloud and urging away 
 from the cross the figure of the Synagogue, who flies, 
 with her mantle wrapped closely round her, and carry- 
 ing in her hand the broken staff of her standard. In 
 another German painting 1 which forms part of a 
 thirteenth century altar-piece a similar group is found, 
 where the angel with rougher hand urges the unfaithful 
 Synagogue away at the point of a spear. The sacra- 
 mentary of Metz, now in the National Library at Paris, 
 is believed to have been written and illuminated for 
 Bishop Dogon, the son of Charlemagne, about A.D. 850, 
 and in one of the miniatures of this MS. the Church is 
 represented standing close to the cross and reaching up 
 with her chalice to receive the blood from Christ's 
 wounded side, while the Virgin and St. John stand at a 
 distance to the right and left. 
 
 In sculptured ivory there is a plaque on the bind- 
 ing of an evangeliary of the ninth century in the 
 Treasury of Tongres, in the diocese of Liege, on which 
 four figures stand beside the cross. Those of the 
 Virgin and St. John are placed outside ; and nearer 
 
 1 Forster's Monuments de la Peinture en Alleniagne. 
 
320 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 to the cross, on the dexter side, is a graceful figure of 
 a young woman holding in her right hand three flowers, 
 and, in her left, the pole of a banner, against which the 
 profile of her head is beautifully relieved. This is Ec- 
 clesia, and the three flowers in her hand are the triple 
 symbol of the revelation of the Divine Nature, com- 
 mitted to her custody for the benefit of the world. She 
 is herself the emblem of the world's new birth through 
 that revelation. The blessed Virgin has been also 
 regarded in the same light, and has been therefore 
 called the second Eve ; but Ecclesia, the spouse of 
 Christ, is pre-eminently so, 1 for the Church of Christ is 
 the " Electa," the embodiment of all its members, and is 
 not figuratively only but really one body 2 with Himself, 
 and thereby has been otherwise named His Bride. 
 Contrasted with her on the other side of this com- 
 position is another young woman symbolising the Jewish 
 Church, and carrying in her hand the palm branch, the 
 emblem of her country Palestine, who, turning from the 
 cross, looks back at it over her shoulder in scorn. In 
 the sky above, two flying angels hold a crown above 
 the head of Christ. On the great ivory plaque which 
 forms part of the binding of an evangeliary, that the 
 Emperor St. Henry (A.D. 1002-1024) gave to the 
 cathedral at Bamberg, and now preserved in the library 
 at Munich, the subject of the crucifixion is elaborately 
 carved, and supported by others below it, of which 
 the Maries visiting the tomb is the principal, with em- 
 blematic figures of the Sea and the Earth beneath them. 
 In this composition Ecclesia is a most expressive figure. 
 She stands close to the cross, and, with her head thrown 
 
 1 On this subject St. Augustin writes in one of his sermons thus : 
 ' ' Quid enim profluxit de latere nisi sacramentum quod accipiunt fideles, 
 Spiritus sanguis et aqua ? . . . De ipso sanguine et aqua significatur nata 
 Ecclesia. Et quando exivit sanguis et aqua de latere? Quum clum 
 dormiret Christus in cruce ; quia Adam in Paradiso somnum accepit, et 
 sic illi de latere Eva producta est." 
 
 2 i Corinthians xii. 13 ; Ephesians i. 22, 23 ; Colossians i. 1 8, 24. 
 
viii ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 321 
 
 back, looks up straight into the face of the dying 
 Saviour ; Longinus stands below her, and with a long 
 lance inflicts the wound from which, with the chalice 
 in her hand, she receives the blood. The standard 
 rises from behind her with its flag flying above her 
 head. The whole subject of this ivory is beautifully 
 thought out by the sculptor. He has placed the 
 crucified figure lying calmly against the cross, made 
 of the wood of a rough tree, with angels flying above 
 it, and above them the hand of God in the act of 
 benediction. The Virgin and the other Maries stand 
 together behind Ecclesia ; and on the other side, the 
 sponge -bearer is close to the cross, with St. John 
 behind him ; and beyond them is another figure of 
 Ecclesia with her standard in her left hand, and with 
 her right stretched out upon the edge of a shield, 
 which a majestic figure of the Synagogue holds upon 
 her knees as she sits upon a canopied throne with a 
 civic crown upon her head. 
 
 A remarkable figure of Ecclesia, altogether different 
 from those described, is sculptured on an ivory slab in 
 the National Library at Paris. On the space, which 
 in the Bamberg ivory is occupied by a huge serpent 
 coiling round the base of the cross, here sits upon a 
 throne a finely-draped figure of Ecclesia, with her head 
 turned to look upward to the Crucified, holding in her 
 right hand the banner, and with her left hand support- 
 ing a globe, the symbol of the world, and of her com- 
 mission to it. 1 The groups round the crucifixion are 
 also arranged in an unusual manner. On the dexter 
 side the Virgin and St. John stand with their arms ex- 
 tended toward the cross, and on the left side is another 
 figure of Ecclesia, in an attitude of energetic address, 
 with her right hand pointed at a queenly figure seated 
 on a throne before her, impersonating Jerusalem as the 
 
 1 St. Mark xvi. 15 ; St. Matthew xxviii. 19. 
 Y 
 
322 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 emblem of the Jewish Church, draped richly, holding 
 in her left hand, as it rests upon her knee, the axe- 
 shaped knife of the executioner, with the right hand 
 grasping the pole of a large banner, and having a 
 unique nimbus formed of a circular wall and five 
 towers, which stand out with their pointed roofs like 
 rays round her head. 
 
 There are other illustrations as careful and beautiful 
 as these, but I need trouble the reader with no more 
 than one, which belongs to an important work in 
 marble of the thirteenth century. It is the panel by 
 Niccola Pisano in the baptistery pulpit at Pisa, repre- 
 senting the crucifixion already described. Here Niccola 
 has introduced the Christian and the Jewish Churches 
 in contrast, behind the crowded groups on each side of 
 the cross. On the right, above the Christian multitude, 
 the young and graceful figure of Ecclesia, attended by 
 an angel, leans forward and holds a vase to catch the 
 blood falling from Christ's right hand ; and in contrast 
 to this group, and above the crowd of Jews, an older 
 woman personifies the unfaithful Synagogue, holding 
 out her standard as she hurries from the scene, and 
 turns her head back reproachfully toward the angel 
 who follows and urges her away. 
 
 The refinement of taste and labour expended on 
 such works as these, which were but among the minor 
 accessories which furnished and adorned the sacred 
 places of the early and middle ages, shows how deeply 
 penetrated Christendom was with the beauty of idea 
 which pervaded the history and doctrines of the faith ; 
 and if in such lesser works we find such thought and 
 care, still more do the grander features of its arts, 
 whether constructive or decorative, give expression to 
 the same spirit of strong faith and sincere devotion. 
 
 The enthusiasm of artistic life which characterised 
 the great building age of the twelfth and thirteenth 
 
viii ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 323 
 
 centuries, producing works of architecture and the 
 accessory arts with a power rather of creative genius 
 than of growth, can only be likened to that sudden 
 morning of joy and beauty to which the world awakes 
 when, in April, Nature breaks the bonds of winter with 
 the rush of her irrestrainable life. The reality of a 
 genuine love sweetened all its labour, and allowed no 
 hindering thought of difficulty or fatigue to stay its 
 rapid course. Inspired with truth, and strengthened 
 with sincerity, it won the whole heart of its age, and 
 with the brightness of its vigorous life it awakens the 
 dormant sympathies of our own. 
 
 That harmony of result was produced in days long 
 gone by, when the arts were not dissevered. Those were 
 days of much interest for us to look back upon, when all 
 that we now see and do was in its first vigorous germ 
 of growth. There was a stir and struggle everywhere. 
 Life was rough. Society was chaotic. The turmoil of 
 the world outside had driven into communities men 
 who cared for other things than the amateur romance 
 of knight-errantry, or the alternations of dulness and 
 uproar of the feudal castle. Those communities were 
 held together by ties of sympathy and rules of religion. 
 There is a sunny brightness in the picture which one's 
 imagination conceives of their inner life ; and, whether 
 one's dreams of them be true or false, one can picture, 
 without exaggeration, the happy flow of their golden 
 hours, when all worked together with singleness of 
 heart, inspired by one spirit and working to one end 
 the trades with their handicraft, the arts with their 
 poetry, raising those beautiful retreats for learning and 
 shrines for devotion, which, even in their ruins, form 
 the models of our taste. 
 
 The early styles of sculpture and painting in those 
 days were born of architecture, and moved onward 
 with it. Artists were creating their arts as they went 
 
324 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 on side by side. The masters had little to teach. The 
 sources of instruction were few and difficult to reach. 
 The painter was ignorant of pictorial effects. He knew 
 little or nothing of the principles of design. He had 
 but little science in the use of colours, and less of 
 chiaroscuro. His drawing was indifferent. His know- 
 ledge of anatomy was but small. There was but little 
 to be seen of other works of art, and less to be gained 
 by the sight of them. Such was the case of the Chris- 
 tian painter on the revival of art in the early middle 
 ages and it sounds but a sorry one. But the case of 
 the early classic artist had been to a certain degree the 
 same. Yet they both worked on with the happiest 
 results. They worked in entire sympathy with the 
 ideal of their architect and, however imperfect their 
 art may have been in science or technicality, they 
 found their just reward in a grand and reposeful unity 
 of effect, which, after all, is the greatest charm that even 
 the most consummate art in any form can produce. 
 
 Religion had been the great motive of them both. 
 Pagan and Christian, far apart in time and place, had 
 thus both worked upon their temple walls. Their 
 pictures were not pictures in our sense. The resources 
 of their art were limited. They had little care for fore- 
 grounds and backgrounds. The grouped figures told 
 their story with but little artifice ; their composition 
 was broad and simple. They worked for earnestness 
 of expression rather than for power of effect. Their 
 accessories, chosen to aid the composition or to explain 
 the subject, were few, and those commonly rather 
 symbolical than real. Simple as all this was, it satis- 
 fied all need. It was the representation rather of the 
 artist's thought than the attempt to realise a scene. 
 The design sufficed to illustrate the story. It was 
 hampered by no detail. Its motive and sentiment 
 were impressed upon it and then the imaginations of 
 
vin ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 325 
 
 the multitude were left to wander about it unimpeded 
 and undisturbed. Such was the work of those times. 
 It was in one sense merely the bud of art ; but 
 certainly in another it was the full-blown flower of 
 poetry. 
 
 When this art had grown to its full and purest 
 practice, it is remarkable how similar were the prin- 
 ciples on which it was worked at periods far remote 
 from each other. During the fourth and fifth centuries 
 B.C., and from the earliest days of Christian art to the 
 end of the fourteenth century, wall paintings, whether 
 of figures or ornamental design, were conceived in the 
 same spirit. Painting was at both those periods under- 
 stood architecturally it was practised so, and not as 
 an independent art working for its own glory. It 
 worked under rule, and was subject to the laws and 
 style of construction. Of all the arts subsidiary to 
 architectural completeness, it was the most important ; 
 and when all the rest had done their work, it was the 
 painter who brought their labours into harmony and 
 gave them that last touch of bloom which made their 
 effect complete. 1 
 
 It is an interesting question in the study of all 
 decorative arts applied to sacred buildings how far we 
 should resort to old styles. The argument that any 
 such resort or revival would be only retrogressive must 
 in consistency forbid recurrence to the ancient styles of 
 architecture itself, whether classic or Christian, no less 
 than to the styles of their decoration. But the ques- 
 tion itself is not easily answered ; it involves so much 
 more of individual inclination and feeling than of aught 
 else, that the answer can be but ill fitted into words. 
 Those styles represent intelligent principles, and they 
 
 1 The subject of the distinctive principles between wall painting and 
 picture painting would follow here, but as they have been stated in the 
 former essay on Colour in Sculpture and Architecture, I must not repeat it 
 here, but refer the reader to Essay V., Part II. 
 
326 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 possess the deeper interest of their associations with the 
 habits and opinions of their times. Those styles grew 
 naturally in the atmosphere of national life. They 
 were results of the forces of opinion and civilisation. 
 Their constructive forms were developed, as all archi- 
 tecture was, under the needs imposed by climate, but 
 their beauty was the embodiment of the national 
 soul ; and the detail of all other arts expended on it 
 expressed the varying tides of popular sentiment or 
 aspiration. 
 
 In old times art was definite ; it was not distracted 
 by the multiplicity of opinion and the internecine 
 interests of modern times. They are called the arts of 
 peace ; but it would belie their origin to confound the 
 peace in which fine arts flourish with the worthless 
 leisure of national stagnation. Peace they required, 
 but the peace of independent genius that could stand 
 like a pillar in a storm. Genius has shone the brightest 
 in the agitation of national life ; an agitation, not that 
 of destructive political strife and revolution, but the stir 
 of national intelligence, and in that vigorous action 
 both of public and private life of which that movement 
 is the spring. National arts were the creation of the 
 individual reply to the demands of public spirit. They 
 developed, indeed, in quiet places and in quiet souls 
 amid surrounding agitation. Those haunts of rest and 
 quietness, by the sheer contrast of their peace, fostered 
 habits of thought that were but ill at ease among the 
 contentions of public life ; and such men as sought 
 their gentler shade, gave expression to the spirit that 
 was moving in them, in the forms and language of 
 their national poetry and arts, which were the solace to 
 the hearts and the stay of the souls of the working and 
 weary world. 
 
 An artist would revolt, and rightly too, against any 
 retrogression degrading to his art ; but he may not 
 
vin ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 327 
 
 always be right as to what really is retrogression. The 
 characteristics of classical painting he would probably 
 allow, considering them mainly much the same as his 
 own ; but he might object to the styles of so-called 
 Gothic arts in sculpture and painting as imperfect ; 
 and here, but only as regards their technicalities,he would 
 be right again. To regard them solely with contempt and 
 antipathy would be but an exhibition of blind prejudice, 
 at once both short-sighted and small-hearted. Those 
 styles and characters of arts mark the stages of national 
 culture, and are the turns and idioms of its phraseology. 
 As such they are worth learning ; and excluding those 
 that savour of mere barbarism and ignorance, there are 
 in them all, for those who will take the pains to look, 
 elements that may be separated from the rest, and are 
 such as the fundamental language of all art includes. 
 It may be that some one with special insight into the 
 underlying spirit of archaic art may have repeated its 
 peculiarities so as to have aroused antipathy. He knew, 
 perhaps, better than his critics, its faults no less than 
 its excellencies ; but its imperfections were immaterial 
 to him, for its specialities were to him distinctly repre- 
 sentative ideas, interesting from their associations, 
 and so full of intention and reference, that his mind 
 was engrossed by them, and all its superficial imperfec- 
 tions and technical faults were passed over unheeded. 
 If he failed in practice, it was only through forgetfulness 
 that no artist works for himself alone. 
 
 There are, indeed, styles of old work in drawing 
 and design that are not fine art at all. Art they may 
 be, as hieroglyphics are, or the demoniacal ornamenta- 
 tion of Mexican painting or the fetiches of savages ; 
 but when art comes to make itself felt as fine art by 
 touching the fine feelings of our nature, its elements 
 are evident at once, and, with the intuitive discretion of 
 a true artist, may be used, turned, and interpreted to 
 
328 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 good effect, no matter what the specialities of the style 
 may be. Beauty may be worked out wherever an 
 element of real fine art can be found. Granted that a 
 marked conventionality is forced upon the artist who, 
 for harmony of architectural effect, is obliged to adopt 
 the characteristics and specialities of a style ; but his 
 apology is in his acknowledged acceptance of peculiar 
 conditions. There is a congeniality between all those 
 arts that have grown up together, that can be felt but 
 not described. He felt this, and adapted his own art 
 to conditions for which he was not responsible, but he 
 followed them for consistency and harmony's sake. 
 
 Styles of some sort there must be, and buildings 
 must follow them in the principles of their construction ; 
 but the subject here is the adornment of that con- 
 struction, not only in merely decorative ornament but 
 in illustrative representations ; and in both of these, 
 consistency offers an ideal of practice which seems to 
 override all else ; for all ornament in art, if nature is to 
 be any guide, must take its rule from natural principles, 
 and of them the first of all is the rule of growth ; so 
 that as in nature individuality is complete in every 
 object by the consistent growth of all its parts, and is 
 the first and greatest element in its beauty, so in every 
 style of art that character in design and form of orna- 
 ment is best which follows the construction out of 
 which it grew. 
 
 Conventionality of some sort is inevitable. The 
 whole art of painting is a convention : by its transfer- 
 ence of all the relief, distance, and gradations of natural 
 effects to a level surface it transmutes the act of vision, 
 and calls in the aid of the imagination as interpreter; 
 its many styles and methods are but so many conven- 
 tionalities, some right some wrong, but all included in 
 that broad discretion, with which every independent 
 artist must be allowed to work. It is a mistake to 
 
viii ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 329 
 
 confound conventionality with the blemishes of an 
 undeveloped art. Modern art has rested too exclu- 
 sively on the study of naturalistic combination. Its 
 ancient style or principle was not so, but was as com- 
 plete as it was simple. It may be called, as it has been, 
 the "Monumental," the "Sculpturesque," the "Heroic." 
 I care not what its name be, but I am confident 
 that its genius must be awakened if ever the great art 
 of painting is to rise again to its level of full honour, 
 to extend its field of poetry and instruction, and to be 
 again what it once was, what all time has demanded of 
 it and now demands again a power of abstract and 
 ideal expression, in harmony with that greatest creation 
 of man's genius architecture. 
 
 This is the best reply that I can make in so few 
 words to the doubts and questions about convention- 
 ality, and these are the simplest reasons I can offer for 
 our regard and reverence due to ancient styles of art. 
 If an artist has the genius to appreciate them and the 
 heart to love them, let him follow them ; elsewise not 
 at all. Styles and their conventionalities are the idioms 
 of artistic expression ; and if an artist cannot feel them 
 he cannot interpret them, and then had better to leave 
 them alone. 
 
 The extent to which colouring and figure painting 
 was employed on the walls of sacred buildings in ages 
 when art seemed dead and all culture that could have 
 enjoyed it seemed nil, would surprise many whose eyes 
 and ideas have been trained to the Puritan negative of 
 whitewash and bare stone. The times and work were 
 rough but real. Stucco and plaster, which coated the 
 interiors of such buildings as at all aspired to complete- 
 ness, were the simple and honest preparation for the 
 artist But they were perishable materials. Literature, 
 more durable than gesso, has, however, preserved the 
 story of art's services to religion, and so mingled with 
 
330 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 references to the lives and work, the ideas and motives 
 of those who produced them, as to have spread out a 
 web of interwoven incident and anecdote of inexhaust- 
 ible interest that tells to us, more plainly than they 
 were themselves aware, the source and secret of their 
 inspiration. 
 
 The sacred memorials of earliest Christian life, the 
 storied pictures, the poetic allegory that covered the 
 walls and monuments of the catacombs, were the 
 endeared models that for centuries formed the subjects 
 of the artist's work. Even in the darkest and wildest 
 days of that " distress of nations with perplexity " that 
 overwhelmed Europe from the ninth to the eleventh 
 century, we hear everywhere of cathedrals and churches 
 completely illuminated with sacred subjects. Many of 
 the failing pictures of the catacombs were repainted in 
 the ninth century. The mosaics that adorned the 
 basilicas of Rome, Milan, Pavia, Ravenna, and Torcello 
 in the south ; of Greece, Constantinople, and Palestine 
 in the east, were but the exemplars for less costly 
 work elsewhere. In northern Europe the first cathedrals 
 of Germany and France followed in their course. In 
 the tenth century at Treves, Avignon, Rheims, Auxerre, 
 Hildesheim, and others, the walls were covered with 
 paintings and enriched with embroidered draperies, metal 
 work, and marble ; and still earlier, the gold mosaic 
 of the church at Toulouse, won for it the title of St. 
 Marie la Daurade. In Germany, Charlemagne promul- 
 gated laws for the covering the walls of churches with 
 paintings, authorising them by the publication of his 
 enlightened opinion in these words, "Whereas we 
 despise nothing that relates to images except their 
 worship, we sanction the use of the figures of the saints 
 in our basilicas, not for their adoration, but as memo- 
 rials of their works and for the adornment of the walls." 
 In another place he prescribes the use of pictures in 
 
vin ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 331 
 
 churches to draw the rude Saxon from his less splendid 
 temples, and to teach him his new faith. 1 
 
 In the early British Church whatever art may have 
 prevailed, we know but little of it beyond what St. 
 Columba's devoted followers brought from lona, and of 
 what Bede tells of Biscop's purchases of pictures at 
 Rome, with which he adorned his church at Wear- 
 mouth. But, once awakened, the spirit of the arts 
 broke out like sunshine from a storm, and spread its 
 gladness far and wide with the rapidity of light. 
 
 The first important impulse to art in England was 
 due to the Lombard archbishop Lanfranc, when, after 
 building his cathedral at Canterbury, he so adorned it 
 that " by the splendour of colours and the loveliness of 
 beauty his noble art delighted all hearts." 2 His suc- 
 cessors continued to foster the taste he had initiated by 
 colouring the flat, wooden ceiling, 3 characteristic of 
 Norman buildings, and painting the walls. The in- 
 fluence of the art thus introduced is too well known 
 by the industry of archaeology to need illustrations 
 here ; but, as the sad case is with us now, that if we 
 seek the specimens of our early arts we must be 
 contented with their ruins, the scraps that time and 
 trouble have left must suffice us to suggest what no 
 exaggerating fancy is needed to complete, and to show 
 how the national spirit became interested in the work 
 
 1 " Ut honorem habeant majorem et excellentiorem quam fana 
 idolorum." Capitul. De part. Sax. anno 789. 
 
 " . . . Ut missi nostri per singulos pagos prasvidere studeant, primum 
 de ecclesiis ... in tectis, in maceriis, sive in parietibus, sive in pavi- 
 mentis, nee non in pictura, etiam et in luminariis," etc. Capitul. anno 
 807. 
 
 " Dirutce ecclesise pleniter restaurentur atque ornentur." " Si vero 
 essent ecclesise ad jus regium proprie pertinentes, laquearibus vel muralibus 
 ordinandae picturis, id a vicinis Episcopis aut abbatibus curabatur." 
 Capitul. Car. Mag. 
 
 2 William of Malmesbury, " splendore fucorum. et pulchritudinis gratia, 
 ars spectabilis rapiebat animos." 
 
 3 " Ibi cselum ligneum egregia pictura decoratum." Gervasius, in loco. 
 
332 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 of artistic expression, and how genuine was the national 
 feeling that characterised its works. 
 
 We learn by the many records of local history, 
 which continental nations have more happily pre- 
 served than ourselves, how the practice prevailed, at 
 the very outset of Christian art in Europe, not merely 
 of ornamenting parts of consecrated buildings, but of 
 covering them entirely with sacred subjects. There 
 are many relics of old work in English churches which 
 authorise the idea of such having been also the case 
 here. The interiors of Norman buildings were usually 
 not left rough, but coated with a thin layer of stucco, 
 but so thin as to have too often perished, and to have 
 carried away the old paintings with it. There are, 
 therefore, few, if any, relics of that early time of a 
 building entirely covered with its old pictures more 
 complete than that of the little chancel of the church 
 of Kempley, in Gloucestershire, where the whole church 
 was originally covered with sacred subjects. In the 
 nave only a few scraps and indications remain, but 
 the chancel is in a fair condition, and is painted 
 throughout. Its wagon roof, which is but a continua- 
 tion of the walls, without any interrupting cornice, is 
 covered with figures, and, with the side walls, appears 
 to form one large general subject of the glorification 
 of Christ. His figure, within an aureole, occupies the 
 centre of the arched ceiling, and above and below it 
 are somewhat rudely arranged those of the Virgin and 
 St. Peter, St. Michael weighing a soul, the seven 
 golden candlesticks, and the four evangelistic symbols ; 
 and below them, on each side, six of the apostles are 
 seated under canopies that indicate their twelve thrones, 
 expressing by gest of head or hand the adoration 
 of their Master enthroned above. This is evidently a 
 genuine English work of the date about 1 1 6O. 1 
 
 i The arch of the wagon-roof has given way, and caused a deep crack 
 
vin ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 333 
 
 The traditional subjects of old Christian art had 
 at once fascinated our people, and were already com- 
 mon within a short time after the days of Lanfranc. 
 As might be expected, their relics are but rude, but 
 none the less curiously interesting from the original 
 character of their design. For example (and one 
 such may be enough to illustrate many), upon a stone 
 (five feet long by three broad) that had been removed 
 and formed the step of the north door of the Norman 
 church at Balsover, is sculptured, in high relief, the 
 scene of the adoration of the Magi. The Virgin 
 Mother is sitting up at the end of a long bed, with 
 the child Jesus standing in front of her. On the 
 farther side stands one of the Magi, and another at 
 the foot of the bed holding out his gift, which is in 
 the form of a censer, and he is in the attitude of 
 swinging it in front. The third of his company stands 
 a little way behind him, and above them is a long- 
 shaped projecting block with the heads of two animals 
 protruding over it, evidently, but most rudely, intended 
 to represent the manger, with the ox and ass. 
 
 The conditions of British life had not been 
 favourable to the development of the arts, but with 
 the impulse given to them before the Conquest by 
 Edward the Confessor, and subsequently by Lanfranc, 
 their first faltering steps soon changed to that grand 
 march which carried them triumphantly through the 
 middle ages. Beautiful in the whole course and order 
 of their being they had come forth, the creatures of 
 imagination realised by genius, in answer to the needs 
 and to express the hearts of men feeling their way 
 upward, from the impeding mist and conscious evil of 
 the present, to a higher life, of which not the mere 
 
 along its greater part, much injuring the figures. The walls are in good 
 condition. There is in the British Museum MS. Department an English 
 psalter in precisely the style of this painting numbered in the catalogue 
 "Nero C 4." 
 
334 THE MINIS 'TR Y OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 thought and hope, but the sure and certain convic- 
 tion, possessed their souls. But at length a new ideal 
 and standard of life was propounded and prevailed, 
 encroaching upon their reign, and a scholarship, 
 foreign to them, introduced antagonism to all they 
 had held sacred. And now those arts have been 
 long since at rest. Their creative energy was aroused 
 by no new appeals ; the thought and fancy of the 
 inconstant world took other flights elsewhere. Their 
 journey was over, their work was done, but their monu- 
 ments remain the splendid memorials of their life, and 
 still among the sad scenes of desolation, where passion 
 and neglect have wrought an equal ruin, their spirits 
 haunt the shadows of their wasted shrines, and the 
 echoes of their poetry still linger upon the air. 
 
 But why all these arts, and to what good can they 
 have served ? Their action and their progress were 
 involuntary. They sprang from unknown depths ; their 
 purpose was uncalculated and indefmed. They grew 
 up, as it were, involuntarily in the atmosphere of 
 Christian faith ; but that faith was a thing of spirit, 
 and theirs was but of base material. Could, then, 
 such work as theirs supplement the deficiencies of 
 Christian souls or compensate for the poverty of 
 worship ? Could their poor perishable forms have 
 any worth in the sight of Him " who sees not as 
 man sees " ? Could the altars devoted to His ser- 
 vice, or great halls, consecrated by the assembly of 
 His worshippers, be the better in His regard for all 
 that gold and "goodly stones," already His own, 
 could supply, or for what the cunning of men's hands 
 could do in them ? In the privacy of communion 
 between the spirit of the man and the spirit of his 
 Maker, No ; but as " a tribute of reasonable service 
 from humanity to God," Yes. 
 
 Art is the chorus of universal praise. If the pure 
 
vni ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 335 
 
 fountain whence fine art sprang were reached, and 
 its stream cleared from the defilements of folly and 
 corruption that in the sad course of human life have 
 polluted it, the source of universal joy and adoration 
 would be laid bare, whence, through the ages, the 
 great hymn of all humanity has ascended from earth 
 to heaven. 
 
 It is only in the quietude of a contemplative 
 spirit that a work of really religious art can be con- 
 ceived. The subject does not make the art. Many 
 a work of so-called religious art has been produced 
 from which not one spark of religious light could 
 ever gleam. For such a work, therefore, as the re- 
 storation and adornment of the fabrics of the Chris- 
 tian Church we need such men as can rise to the 
 high level of its faith, with pure motive and confidence 
 in it. Such alone have been, and such will ever be, 
 the men whose works have power to influence the 
 world by the sacredness of the life which beams 
 through all they put their hands to. 
 
 If the exterior of the Christian temple may typify 
 the rude contest of the Christian in the outer world, 
 the interior may well express the peace and beauty 
 of his inner life. Let, therefore, the exteriors be as 
 rough as men may care to build them let them be 
 fortified against storms and enemies of all sorts but 
 let us have peace and sacred quietude within, where 
 the dignity of beauty is not marred, nor the fine 
 religious sense insulted. Thus only can that tran- 
 quillity be secured that must be art's first and final 
 purpose in such a place. She has to provide there 
 not for quiet spirits only, but for troubled ones, who 
 come there to find rest. It should be a place of 
 pleasantness and peace, where sight meets no dis- 
 traction and thought no disturbance, but where both 
 sense and heart may find repose in its sacred shade. 
 
336 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 The seclusion of nature's calm retreats, the still 
 solitudes of the forest, the shadow of a great rock 
 in a weary land, may afford desired spots for thought 
 and devotion ; but in the more common course of 
 life in the crowded cities or unquiet homes, it is to 
 those sacred fanes that architecture has raised among 
 them, that men owe the precious opportunities of 
 spiritual rest. Fine art has done her best in them 
 to foster the associations of comfort and strength. 
 It is in the great art of architecture, as in a jewel, 
 that all other arts are set, and all that each one has 
 perfected for the benefit and happiness of mankind 
 here finds its resting-place. A nation's temples have 
 ever been the centre of the nation's arts. The history, 
 the poetry, the religion of the world, have been written 
 in them. The power and devotion of human genius 
 have been lavished upon them, the most pure and 
 favourite handmaids of a nation's faith. 
 
 It may have been that in this high purpose their 
 power has been some time misused. If so, the error 
 lay in those who perverted them. It was their power 
 which dictated the destruction of their monuments. 
 But art is immortal. Men's souls need an alphabet 
 of expression above and beyond the alphabet of com- 
 mon life. They have arts at their command for it. 
 It has been by them that generations and genera- 
 tions have learnt to read each other's thoughts and 
 live in each other's hearts. The arts have been the 
 records of the devotion, the sufferings, and the aspira- 
 tions of mankind. They have come and they have 
 passed away. It is now our day. The unceasing 
 stream flows by us now, and for our short life we 
 direct its current. The arts are in our hands to use or 
 to misuse them. Our honour in them will depend upon 
 our motive ; and whatever our works may be, we shall 
 live in them to all time for contempt or for gratitude. 
 
vin ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS 337 
 
 But here, in this place, rises before our eyes one 
 of England's grandest monuments, worn by age and 
 battered by revolution, but who will dare to touch 
 those sacred walls? 1 Time has often proved the best 
 of artists, and there has spread upon those stained 
 and mottled stones such records of the past, and upon 
 those chipped monuments and broken architecture, that 
 tell of wild days of violence and change, has traced 
 such lines of story as no words can tell. The soften- 
 ing breath of centuries has toned and tinted them into 
 such a mystery of loveliness as no hand can paint. 
 Beneath the shadow of those arcades storied antiquity 
 rests there in silence. The sun rays streaming through 
 those shattered panes, like the harmony of many voices 
 carried upon the wind, still spread their vague and tender 
 flood of colours on those walls, and, like the inaudible 
 music of thought, the echoes of the past still ebb and 
 flow upon them. Once swept away no thought can 
 restore the poetry of the past, nor can the hand re- 
 place it. 
 
 1 Lincoln Cathedral in 1868, when the short paper that forms the 
 basis of this essay was read before the Lincoln Diocesan Architectural 
 Society. At that time considerable work was contemplated there. 
 
ESSAY IX 
 
 THE BUILDERS AND BUILDINGS OF THE ABBEY 
 OF ST. PETER AT GLOUCESTER, NOW THE CATHEDRAL 
 
 THE estimate of anything from an artist's point of 
 view is apt to be as various as the minds that 
 make it ; and commonly to share the same fate in its 
 reception, by the light and shade cast upon it from 
 every variety of individual taste or capacity. A 
 naturally good taste, helped by a congenial spirit and 
 occupations, is a pleasant possession ; but it is a better 
 guide to begin with than to end with, for fine art is a 
 deep well to draw from ; it covers a wide space, it 
 penetrates far below the surfaces of things, and it appeals 
 to a wide range of sympathies, embracing subjects near 
 akin to science and poetry, philosophy and religion. 
 
 It is this last that has most to do with the arts 
 which have combined to produce these sacred buildings, 
 where architecture, consecrated to its highest purpose, 
 has appropriated from every art beside all such elements 
 of religious expression as could contribute to its own 
 completeness. Thus was this great abbey of St. Peter 
 once complete, as it stood in the fulness of its beauty, 
 its pride of beauty ; but troublous times have inter- 
 vened and left a wreck. 
 
 Those who have read the history of such establish- 
 ments as this have sickened at the repetition of wreck 
 and ruin which has been their fate ; devastations by 
 
ESSAY ix GLOUCESTER CATHEDRAL 339 
 
 fire and sword, by the irruption of hostile and pagan 
 tribes, reducing the monasteries and churches to ashes, 
 Christianity itself being all but extinguished ; and what 
 is yet more painful, the fitful wantonness of our own 
 people, whose passions, once aroused, have been like 
 the bursting of a pent-up storm which seems to revel 
 in ruin. Such was the impulse which now above three 
 hundred years ago swept down, in succeeding tides of 
 desolation, those monuments which, during past cen- 
 turies, the highest culture, poetry, and religion of the 
 nation had produced. Those who raised the storm had 
 their reasons ; some high-minded and pure, some base 
 and contemptible ; but not so the undiscriminating 
 multitude ; for a mob is not actuated by the refine- 
 ments of religious opinion. It was no nice perception 
 of varieties of faith that aroused their ignorant fanati- 
 cism. They had no thought nor wish to change an 
 item of their creed ; but it was the resentment of a 
 discontented multitude, discontented not with their 
 religion, but with their oppressed condition, utilised by 
 the partisans of politics and religion, goaded on by its 
 own sense of injury, injustice, and suffering, and fanned 
 into a flame of destruction by any pretext that could 
 serve the purpose of its unreasoning vengeance. The 
 Church had lorded it overmuch ; its exactions and its 
 presumption had often pressed hard upon the people. 
 So the day of retribution came ; and, as usual, where 
 blind ignorance took part, reform was ruin, and the loss 
 irreparable ; and here in this that once was among 
 the richest and most beautiful of national monuments 
 bare walls alone remained, and all that had clothed 
 them with life was no more. 
 
 It had been under happier auspices, and in days of 
 simple faith, now just twelve hundred years ago, that 
 the first abbey of St. Peter at Gloucester had its 
 beginning. It was founded and endowed by kings, 
 
340 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 and royal dames were its first abbesses. Its buildings 
 stood near those around us. On the north side of the 
 choir of the present cathedral, and next to the high 
 altar, is a monument known as that of the Viceroy 
 Osric, the noble-born friend of Ethelred, the second 
 Christian King of Mercia, by whose authority he 
 founded this abbey. This monument is the tribute of 
 the last abbot to the man who, eight hundred years 
 before, had laid the first stone of the first abbey of St. 
 Peter. The recumbent figure holds the model of a 
 church, which is interesting as a piece of archaeological 
 reverence on the part of a sixteenth-century abbot ; 
 for the character of its fagade, roof, and tower is of the 
 earliest type of Norman work, or even before it. The 
 figure, unworthy of the royal name it bears, is such 
 that the puritan iconoclast, dealing ruin right and left, 
 passed it by with a smile, that the very ugliness of such 
 a " graven image " saved him the trouble of breaking it 
 At the time of the foundation of this abbey (A.D. 
 68 1) society was so broken, and private life so harassed 
 by the disturbance of lawlessness and war, that as 
 Christianity was fast spreading and arousing in men's 
 minds aspirations for a better mode of life, for which 
 no peace was found in their precarious homes, establish- 
 ments were founded as refuges from the noise and 
 storm around them, and as centres of religious life. 
 Such were those of St. Hilda in the north, or St. Ethel- 
 burga in the east, and of Osric in our south-western 
 Gloucester. But within a century the troubles pre- 
 vailed, and war with all its vice and tumult occupied 
 the ground, and the years of the first abbey of St. Peter 
 were numbered. Never were the first fair blossoms of 
 the early year more mercilessly withered by the biting 
 winds of spring than were those first fair homes of 
 peaceful life and charity ruined by the violence that 
 marks their chequered history. 
 
ix GLOUCESTER CATHEDRAL 341 
 
 So ends the first age of our abbey. Its inhabit- 
 ants were terrified, scattered, lost ; and of their place 
 and buildings not even the tradition of a memory 
 remains. We may yet, however, form a fair idea of 
 them, for it must be remembered that no art is isolated ; 
 it comes of that which was before, and hands on its 
 lamp of life to those which follow it. The character of 
 all building in all countries has of course depended 
 first on climate, and then on the nature of materials at 
 hand, and the ability of the people. All round Glou- 
 cester in those early days were vast forests, on one 
 side covering the great part of what is now Worcester- 
 shire, on the other side the wide range of our Forest 
 of Dean ; and yet nearer, the picturesque outline of 
 what we still know as the Hill of Robin's Wood ; and 
 just over Severn, but close at hand, where the aged 
 oak of Lassington, and the Highnam chestnut-tree link 
 our degenerate woodlands with the heroes of primeval 
 forest. Such then was the wealth of building material, 
 as easily got as the stubborn oak would yield to the 
 axe, and as cheaply as the Severn boats and rafts 
 would bring it ; and the builder of the first abbey of 
 St. Peter fetched it home, as Chaucer describes one in 
 the "Miller's Tale": 
 
 ... " I trow that he is sent 
 For timbre, that our Abbot hath him sent." 
 
 There is still, in that once forest land of Cheshire, 
 a fine example of the timber building of early times in 
 the church at Warburton, where the piers and arches 
 of the nave are formed of large oak-trees cut in half 
 lengthways, based on stone blocks, and joining their 
 curved forms above produce the arcades on which the 
 whole superstructure is borne. A timber arch still 
 marks the place of the north-west doorway, and the 
 chancel is of similar construction. 
 
342 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 Time and trouble have left us few examples ; but 
 there are so many valid grounds on which to formulate 
 our ideas that it needs but little stretch of imagination 
 to rebuild the first abbey of St. Peter. Like the first 
 great church on the wild island of Lindisfarne, it may 
 have been built with wood and thatched with reeds. Its 
 aisles may have been arched with oak like those at 
 Warburton ; and its tower like that near at hand at 
 Upleadon, where the long upright oaken timbers, with 
 white panels between them, are like those which Holin- 
 shed admired in the buildings of old England which 
 " are commonlie so strong and well timbered that there 
 are not aboue foure or six or nine inches between stud 
 and stud." Thus may we easily imagine that group of 
 monastic buildings, bright with the contrast of dark 
 oak and white panelling, with its long cloistral enclos- 
 ure, and all the apartments for refectory, dormitory, 
 and guest-house, with its church and its tower rising 
 above them, on a site chosen for its quietude, on the 
 farther side of what was then the sparkling stream of 
 the Twiver, whose banks, covered with willows and 
 alder -trees, separated it from the town ; an ancient 
 town, whose British and old Roman buildings pictur- 
 esquely mixed together, with the Severn rolling beneath 
 them, with smiling meadows all around it, and the 
 background of the beechy Cotteswolds, had won for it 
 the title of " The Fair City " (Caer Glowe). 
 
 Such might have been, and probably was, the 
 pleasant scene that presented itself, when just twelve 
 hundred years ago King Ethelred came to visit his 
 brother Wolfere's widow, or the sister of his friend 
 Osric Kymberga, the first abbess, whose name 
 modernised into Kymbrose is still familiar to the poor 
 of Gloucester by their most ancient hospital. 
 
 There is yet, however, another picture that we 
 could draw, with at least some ground of truth, to 
 
ix GLOUCESTER CATHEDRAL 343 
 
 illustrate the state of the arts in England at that time, 
 and particularly of such as might have been found at 
 Gloucester, it may be as well to take it. 
 
 If the age had been dark, it certainly had been of 
 all things darkest in relation to the arts ; but before 
 the foundation of this abbey the day of their revival 
 had risen. From lona to Canterbury Christianity was 
 the dominant religion. It spread as an element of 
 light and peace, and the undercurrent of its influence 
 prevailed. Men woke to the horror of the crime 
 around them. An ideal altogether new was introduced 
 into their life. The reality instead of the mere super- 
 stition of spiritual existence was forced upon them. 
 The conviction weighed heavily on many minds. Men 
 craved for quietude, and yearned to escape from a life 
 they had learned to hate. A new light had dawned 
 upon them, and with it a sense of the beauty of that 
 light. It awoke their dormant faculties of mind, heart, 
 and imagination, and opened a fresh vista to the pur- 
 pose and direction of their lives. 
 
 Monastic life afforded the only refuge : monasteries 
 were the homes not only of religion but of learning, and 
 then the arts came in to minister to them both ; and thus 
 their spark was kindled. Some years before that time 
 two men came upon the scene whose enthusiasm fanned 
 that spark into a flame. St. Wilfrid and his friend 
 Benedict Biscop had learnt what art was among the grand 
 relics of the south, and had returned from years spent in 
 Italy and Gaul, not only to introduce the customs of 
 the Roman Church among his old British fellow-Chris- 
 tians of the north, but to build them churches, till then 
 unthought of, with finished masonry, with lead for roof- 
 ing, and glass for windows. Their story has been too 
 often told for me to repeat it here, or do more than to 
 remind you how they had brought with them from 
 France and Italy artists and workmen to revive the 
 
344 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 art of building, and to teach the English the mysteries 
 of painting and making glass ; and how they founded 
 monasteries and built churches, adorned with pictures 
 and relics, service books, sacred vessels, and em- 
 broidery. 
 
 The earliest Christian churches of the south appear 
 to have been constructed with the three clearly-marked 
 divisions of the sanctuary, nave (with or without aisles), 
 and narthex, for the ministry, the congregation, and the 
 catechumens. Among the most interesting relics that 
 time and revolution have spared is the underground 
 church built by St. Wilfrid at Hexham. It was built 
 about ten years before the foundation of the abbey at 
 Gloucester, and is a complete model of the early Chris- 
 tian churches, with a chancel, a nave with aisles, and a 
 narthex opening to the staircase which leads down to 
 it, denuded of course of all that may have once em- 
 bellished it, of small dimensions, but in perfect preser- 
 vation, constructed of materials which seem to tell the 
 tale of their origin in the great wall of Hadrian which 
 is near at hand. But before the building of this crypt, 
 and about twelve years before Osric began his work at 
 Gloucester, St. Wilfrid had built a church at Ripon, 
 about which Leland quotes this glowing description 
 from Eddius, that it was " a basilica constructed of 
 wrought stones from the foundation, and divers pillars 
 and porticoes formed part of its arrangement." This 
 church was dedicated to St. Peter, in the presence of 
 Kings Egfrid and ALlwm. An underground chapel 
 still remains of Wilfrid's work at Ripon. 
 
 To return to Gloucester. If we are to accept the 
 document given by Dugdale, Wolfere the king, and not 
 his brother and successor Ethelred, was the real founder 
 of this abbey. Gloucester had but lately been added 
 to his kingdom of Mercia, and he is there stated to have 
 enlarged and beautified the town of Gloucester and laid 
 
ix GLOUCESTER CATHEDRAL 345 
 
 the foundation of the abbey. Laying the foundation 
 may simply mean the assignment of lands for the 
 establishment of the abbey. Then his brother and 
 successor took up the work, and hence his charter of 
 foundation to Osric. But Wolfere had been at Ripon, 
 and must have seen Wilfrid's great church there. The 
 bias of Ethelred's character was to peace, to the arts of 
 peace, and to a religious life, as shown by the end he 
 chose for it, for after thirty years spent in the weary 
 work of ruling, he retired to the monastery of Bardley, 
 among the fens of Lincoln, and there died. St. Wilfrid 
 had been his intimate friend, and his guest at Bardley, 
 and it is a fair inference that the works as well as the 
 character of such a man must have exercised strong 
 influence on a mind so entirely sympathetic as that of 
 King Ethelred. It is also fair to infer that Gloucester 
 must have occupied a prominent place in the mind of 
 the whole royal family from the facts just mentioned 
 about its foundation, from Wolfere's widow being its 
 second abbess, and further, that the succeeding king 
 and his friend Offa, King of the East Saxons, were 
 among the number of its benefactors. 
 
 All this points but one way. I have no wish to 
 exaggerate the supposition which can only be based on 
 inference ; but Gloucester evidently held no common 
 place among the noblest and wealthiest of the land, 
 who had thus centred their interest and influence upon 
 it. Once more, and I leave it in your hands. Builders 
 have been always reckless pilferers, and at these times 
 no such idea as the sacredness of antiquity had entered 
 their heads. Gloucester had been a Roman city, a 
 wealthy one, with every building required for its com- 
 mercial, military, and religious establishments. But 
 these were then in ruins, and we may rightly fancy 
 their massive sides and angles, like the great buttressed 
 walls and nooks of many a mediaeval cathedral, covered 
 
346 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 and filled in with hives of houses piled up against 
 them for support and shelter. But those mines of 
 building stone were used for other purposes, as badly or 
 as well as the world may think it ; and just as the 
 first subterraneous church at Hexham was built of 
 the pilfered ruins of Hadrian's wall, so might the first 
 church of St. Peter at Gloucester have owed its build- 
 ing materials to the wrecks of the walls, the Pretorium, 
 the Forum, and the Temples, of which we now trace 
 the foundation, the mosaics, and the bases of their 
 ruined architecture. 
 
 However that might have been, little occurred to 
 affect the architecture of those buildings till the be- 
 ginning of the eleventh century. I am not concerned 
 here upon the history of the abbey, interesting as it is 
 in all respects, except as regards the story of the arts 
 which have been associated with its building ; otherwise 
 there would be much to say here, and subsequently also 
 much that for consistency's sake I must omit. The 
 really important change in the circumstances of the 
 place in those early days occurred when, under Bishop 
 Wolstan of Worcester in A.D. 1022, it was changed 
 from an establishment for secular clergy to a monastery 
 under the rule of St. Benedict. The bishop found the 
 church richly endowed, two of the Mercian kings 
 having been, a few centuries before, its benefactors. 
 The place was so important, and the opportunity so 
 great, that he took the bold course of reconstructing 
 the whole establishment, and of consecrating it afresh 
 under the new title of St. Peter and St. Paul. 
 
 I am well aware how often in ancient Chronicles 
 larger establishments than this at Gloucester are de- 
 scribed as having a " lignea basilica;" and smaller 
 ones as being, in plain English, built of wattle and dab, 
 and roofed with straw. But at the time I am speaking 
 of, stone was used in building quite small churches, such 
 
ix GLOUCESTER CATHEDRAL 347 
 
 as the one still nearly perfect at Bradford-on-Avon j 1 
 and stone was then also used where in some places it 
 would have to be brought from a distance, as at Deer- 
 hurst Here at Gloucester all sorts of stone were easily 
 obtained. The herring-bone masonry at Ashleworth 
 and the reticulated work on the chancel at Dymock 
 may be possibly of that period. On such an occasion 
 as I was describing, some change in this building almost 
 of necessity occurred ; and we might then have seen 
 rising above Bishop Wolfstan's church a tower of that 
 peculiar style that was then in vogue, marked by its 
 masonry of long and short stones alternately, and even 
 more marked still by the long narrow strips of stone, 
 slightly relieved from the rubble surface of the walls, 
 and dividing them into long upright panels. 2 The 
 divisions of the stories of the towers being also marked 
 by horizontal strips of the same sort, and the angle- 
 headed window openings formed also of two short 
 pieces leaning against each other. 
 
 It is easy to trace many features of the marble 
 architecture of Greece and the Lycian monuments to 
 the wooden construction out of which they had grown ; 
 and here in Anglo-Saxon times we find, when stone was 
 used for walls, the principal features both of construc- 
 tion and ornament were derived from the wooded frame- 
 work with its white-wattled panels between, which had 
 been the primitive style of the country ; and farther on 
 still we may perhaps be allowed to trace, from those 
 long flat strips of stone, the tall, thin, and pilaster-like 
 projections which constantly divide in a similar manner 
 the facades of Romanesque and Norman buildings, all 
 
 1 Vide illustration of this building, E. A. Freeman, English Towns and 
 Districts, p. 136. 
 
 2 For illustrations of work of this Saxon period to which those build- 
 ings at Gloucester belonged, vide Fergusson's Handbook of Architecture, 
 vol. ii. page 845 (Earl's Barton Tower), and E. A. Freeman's English 
 Towns and Districts, pages 244-5, Towers at Oxford and Cambridge. 
 
348 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 having their distant origin in the oak frame-work of 
 former days. 
 
 Such, in the year 1022, may have been the tower 
 of the newly-constituted abbey on the banks of the 
 Twyver. 
 
 But the great change was yet to come. A subse- 
 quent bishop, a man of great ability and ambition, 
 formed the scheme of a still more important establish- 
 ment His name was Ealdred, to whose lot it fell to 
 crown both Harold and William of Normandy. He 
 was not a man to do small things. His vigour may 
 be inferred from the remonstrance he addressed to 
 William the Conqueror, which brought the Conqueror 
 on his knees before him in presence of his Court on 
 the floor of Westminster Abbey. He held for some 
 years the sees of Hereford and Worcester, including 
 the present diocese of Gloucester ; and he subsequently 
 became Archbishop of York. If he and Wolsey could 
 have interchanged their dates of birth, he might have 
 played the part of Wolsey. This man, recognising the 
 importance of the opportunity, acted on his resolve, 
 and laid out a great scheme for the future Abbey 
 nearer to the city. The sites almost invariably chosen 
 for monasteries had been solitudes of sea-coast, forest, 
 or fen ; and in course of time the cottages of their 
 dependants so accumulated as to change their solitude 
 to a city. But here at Gloucester the city existed 
 close at hand. The original monastery of St. Kym- 
 burga had chosen its site in a quiet place beyond the 
 Roman wall, among the groves of alder-trees which 
 stretched upwards from that island of the Severn which 
 from them still holds its ancient name of Al-ney. But 
 now the opportunity occurred for the foundation of an 
 important establishment, capable of service both for its 
 own inmates and for the city. He chose the new site, 
 and there he built it. 
 
ix GLOUCESTER CATHEDRAL 349 
 
 According to Abbot Frocester's History this re- 
 markable man was consecrated Bishop of Worcester in 
 1058, i.e. eight years before the Norman Conquest; 
 and it records that he constructed the abbey church de 
 novo from its foundation, and re-dedicated it according 
 to its original title of St. Peter's. The next we hear 
 of any building is in the time of the first Norman 
 Abbot Serlo ; and of that work we only learn that the 
 first stone of the " Glevornensis ecclesia " (the Gloucester 
 church) was laid in 1089, twelve years after the Con- 
 quest, and was consecrated with great pomp in 1 1 oo. 
 Thus the great Abbey, of which the bulk now stands, 
 was completed. It had been a gigantic undertaking ; 
 and we can easily imagine the workmen sitting down 
 within the western wall to contemplate their finished 
 work. They saw before them the vista of a grand 
 arcade on massive piers, and in the distance, closed by 
 an apse behind the high altar, and covered in from 
 end to end by a flat ceiling of wood, panelled and 
 painted as the fashion was. Right and left along the 
 nave and choir, and all round the apse, vaulted aisles 
 added to the grandeur of effect : beyond the choir were 
 three chapels, with groined roofs and apses round their 
 altars ; and at the opening of the choir, north and 
 south, were transepts, with chapels projected from them 
 eastwards. In the centre, where the four great arms 
 of the building met, rose a tower which might have 
 been of wood, otherwise it probably was like that on 
 Osric's tomb, with an interior arcade, and open like a 
 lantern to the church below, as that of Tewkesbury was 
 in Norman times. All round above the aisles of the 
 choir was a spacious groined triforium, with chapel for 
 chapel and altar for altar as below ; and beneath them 
 all a lower church (now miscalled the crypt), with 
 chapels, aisles, and groins, and altars repeating all that 
 was above. Nor was this nearly all, for that was but 
 
350 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 the huge shell which enclosed the finer things of sculp- 
 ture and glass, embroidery and metal work. But time 
 would fail to tell of all outside the transept towers, 
 deep doorways richly carved, the great chapter-room, 
 and the gloomy passage of the slype, with its long 
 arcade leading out to the burial-ground and all this 
 vast and varied work of one style throughout, complete 
 and beautiful in its unbroken unity. Those workmen 
 may well have looked with awe on this gigantic product 
 of their hands. The foundation for it would alone 
 have been a thing for giants. But was all this work 
 really theirs ? Had the short term of eleven years 
 sufficed to devise, to organise, to finish such a work as 
 that to collect its mountain of materials, with all the 
 painful strain of transport to overcome, and all the 
 rudeness of their machinery ? As they sat there weary 
 beneath its shade, had they, in that short space of 
 fleeting years, shaped and finished such a work as this? 
 If I had been one of those who had to answer, I should 
 have answered " No." 
 
 If we remember the circumstances under which 
 mediaeval records were compiled, we shall not look for 
 that accuracy of statement or description which we 
 expect to find in the chronicles of our own days. The 
 studious monks, happy in their heedlessness of time, at 
 work in those quiet little carols which flank the whole 
 length of the southern cloister, inditing or illuminating 
 their parchment pages, were free from those distracting 
 elements which mark the self-consciousness of modern 
 literature ; but less happily free and unaided by those 
 facilities which modern life affords for its richness and 
 truth. Their narratives were simple and unadorned ; 
 or if adorned at all, they were so by traditional illustra- 
 tions, and influenced rather by the sacredness of wonder 
 than the severity of fact. Thus it is that in reading 
 Abbot Frocester's valuable chronicle, we are inevitably 
 
ix GLOUCESTER CATHEDRAL 351 
 
 struck by the broad and general terms which he applies 
 to what in fact were important events, such as the 
 frequent destruction of the abbey by fire, and the re- 
 building of it ; or where he describes the refounding of 
 the vast establishment, with all the costly and compli- 
 cated work that it entailed, without a word of reference 
 to what remained of previous buildings, or of how their 
 materials were used, their remaining parts incorporated, 
 or who and whence their artists were. 
 
 In offering to you an outline of what appears to me 
 the probable account of the building of this great abbey 
 church, and taking all the recorded facts of its history 
 as my guide, I venture to put it into a narrative form ; 
 and for that purpose I present to you a scene that might 
 have very possibly occurred. 
 
 In that group of workmen there sat one who was a 
 master among them, a man of some age and evident 
 intelligence. A young monk of the Priory of Tewkes- 
 bury, but lately come to Gloucester, joined them, and 
 asked many questions about the building ; so the old 
 mason told him this story. He said : " I am a native 
 of Deerhurst. My father was a builder there, and he 
 sent me to the monks' school at the Priory. I saw a 
 great deal of building work under my father, for he did 
 all the work for the Priory, and when the rich Earl 
 Odda built a Royal Hall close by the old church of the 
 Priory, my father built it for him. There was a very 
 busy Bishop at Worcester then ; his name was Ealdred ; 
 he was a great friend of the Earl's, and came and blessed 
 his new buildings for him. But the biggest place the 
 Bishop had to do with was here at Gloucester : and 
 King Edward (God bless him !) was often here ; for 
 the place is a strong one, with that old wall and the 
 castle down by the Severn and the marshes out beyond ; 
 and there's a sight of business done by the boats that 
 come up from the sea. So King Edward liked the 
 
352 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 place ; and the Bishop, who was always wide awake to 
 business (so he's got made Archbishop of York now), 
 used often to come here ; for the King liked all Church 
 work, and buildings, and so forth, and had a number of 
 Frenchmen about him ; and as the Bishop was a great 
 traveller, they got on very well together. The first time 
 the Bishop came to Gloucester he brought me with him 
 from Deerhurst, for he knew the Abbey here was in a 
 bad state, and that I had a good knowledge of building 
 and all that from my father. We found the place in a 
 poor way ; and the Bishop thought to please the King, 
 and to get the King to help him, if he tried to build a 
 large Church like what the King was building then 
 near London. 1 So the Bishop and I talked it over ; 
 and the new Abbot here, Wilstan, he too thought to 
 please the King, so we worked together and laid out a 
 place for it close to where the old Roman wall was, so 
 as to make it the Chief Church of the city ; with the 
 Abbey buildings snug and quiet on the other side. The 
 Bishop had been in France and had seen all that was 
 doing there ; but he said it would be no use putting 
 our English men to work like that, but to build in their 
 own way strong and simple work like what our folk 
 could do best. So we struck out the plan on the 
 ground, and I was frightened when I saw how big the 
 Bishop meant to build it, and I told him he'd never do 
 it. So he set me over the work, and I got a lot of 
 men and things together, and we began at the east end, 
 and there the undercroft was built, with low vaults 
 and large blocks of masonry to carry those above, and 
 against them we built small columns to carry the groins. 
 There were some small columns in the old ruined place 
 close by ; so we put them in the middle, under where 
 the high altar was to be : they were like some I re- 
 member among the old Priory buildings at Deerhurst. 
 
 1 Which we now know as Westminster Abbey. 
 
ix GLOUCESTER CATHEDRAL 353 
 
 So we got on and put up the piers of the choir those 
 big rounded ones that you see out there round the 
 altar, such as our men could do, for they didn't like 
 the sort the Bishop wanted, which was the French way 
 of work, large square ones with lots of angles and 
 notches and little shafts in them, which our folk weren't 
 accustomed to. So we worked in our own way, and 
 after some years we got the choir all done and ceiled 
 it over flat with boards. Outside the church we built 
 the slype leading out to the burial-ground, and we 
 ceiled it plain like the undercroft ; and we built a long 
 wall where the cloisters were to be, which is now the 
 Prior's garden. There was an arch in that wall which 
 opened into the slype, and two others 1 into the Chapter 
 House, which was a very large room built of wood, 
 where good King Edward used to meet his Witan 
 most years in winter time. And there was a long 
 dormitory over the slype, which was built of wood too, 
 but all those wooden buildings were burnt down. We 
 were at work at the transepts at the same time : for 
 the King was building his big church near London on 
 a plan like a cross, which was quite new to us ; and 
 the Bishop here, thinking to make a fine thing and to 
 please the King, was set on making his new church 
 like the King's. We got on with the transepts, and 
 finished their east walls and the chapels in them ; but 
 we never got any further ; for the Bishop was always 
 about the Court, and liked to have all the nobles about 
 him, and he spent his money too fast with them. As 
 soon as we got the choir ceiled he got the King's friends 
 about him, and the Abbots of Malvern and Pershore, 
 and the Priors of Tewkesbury and Deerhurst, and many 
 
 1 These arches may still be seen, now embedded level with the wall 
 both outside and within the chapter-house, and their stones bear evidence 
 of fire, being burnt red, like those of the lower parts of the piers of the 
 nave which were burnt by the blazing timbers of Abbot Serlo's original 
 ceiling. 
 
 2 A 
 
354 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 more, and there was a great feast, and he blessed the 
 new church in the name of St. Peter. But he left us 
 then, for the King was so pleased with him that he 
 had him made Archbishop of York ; and he stopped 
 all the work here by seizing three or four parishes about 
 here to repay himself for what he had spent ; so there 
 was no money to pay the men. And then the good 
 King died, and the men went away to fight under King 
 Harold, for they didn't want the French Duke William. 
 So the place was left not half done, and so it remained 
 for many years. But what grieved me most was that by 
 that Bishop's way of living, and the cost of that great 
 building, and his taking away the worth of those fine 
 parishes from the Abbot here, the place was ruined ; 
 and the poor monks went away, for they had no means 
 of living here any more ; and Abbot Wilstan, with his 
 heart nearly broken, left us and went to Jerusalem and 
 died. So all our work was left to go to chance. 
 
 "After that, things were changed a good deal in 
 England, and our old Bishop went from York and 
 crowned the Frenchman King of England in good 
 King Edward's own Church down by the Thames at 
 Thorney. After brave King Harold's death some of 
 our masons went to work for the French at Dover 
 Castle, but I stayed here and did work at St. Oswald's 
 Priory close by and St. Kyneburg's up in the town. 
 Some six years after that, we had a Frenchman made 
 Abbot here, one Serlo, who had been an Abbot before 
 in France ; and when he came here he found the place 
 very poor, for Bishop Aldred had ruined it ; and there 
 were only two old monks and a few boys left in the 
 place. Our good Abbot had been here just sixteen 
 years (1088), when a great fire destroyed the roof and 
 all the timber-work of the choir and made the place 
 like a ruin, but our building was strong and the stones 
 were not hurt. So the Abbot, who was well pleased 
 
ix GLOUCESTER CATHEDRAL 355 
 
 with all the work we had done in the choir, sent for 
 me, as I knew all about it, and I went over it all 
 with him. It was all sound but the groining of the 
 undercroft, which had cracked, for we had had bad 
 lime for mortar, and for many years there was no one 
 here to care about it. But he was pleased at Bishop 
 Aldred's plan, and as the choir part for the monks 
 was done, he took to the nave, as Bishop Aldred had 
 laid it out, and he ordered me to see to the build- 
 ing of it as a great church 1 for the town people, and 
 he got the Bishop of Hereford here to lay the first 
 stone of this work. But there was an earthquake that 
 year, which made our old work in the undercroft all 
 the worse ; so some while afterwards he made us under- 
 build it with stronger piers and arches, as you can see 
 if you go down there. Many of our men soon came 
 back ; and the French Abbot wanted them to build as 
 they do in France ; but our men didn't take to it ; so 
 we went on the same plan with those big piers as in 
 Bishop Aldred's choir, only taller. But the Frenchman 
 was not satisfied with our plain work ; so we got stone 
 carvers here, and all the arches were carved as you see, 
 and the mouldings above too, and the groinings of the 
 new aisles are carved, and all the work we did for him 
 looks richer than any we did before ; but the masonry 
 looks the same, for the same men did the best part of 
 it. And the French Abbot was so fond of rich work 
 that when we put in the strong groins down in the 
 
 1 In Abbot Frocester's History this building is described as the Gle- 
 vornensis Ecclesia, and rightly so described "thec hurch of the city of 
 Gloucester," for the nave, which was all that the Abbot Serlo had to 
 build, beside the repairs after the fire in choir and transepts, was that part 
 of the conventual church frequently known as the " ecclesia parochialis," 
 with its altars in it, on the west side of the main screen, for the people's 
 services, as at St. Albans, the choir being properly the "chorus fratrum," 
 reserved entirely for the monks of the Abbey. The " church of the city " 
 was not necessarily the parish church, which in this case was that of St. 
 Mary de Lode. 
 
356 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 undercroft, he had them carved too ; and there is a 
 chapel down there on the right near the east end that 
 he had made very rich with little shafts and arches ; 
 we could only put them up there by standing them 
 out against the old work, and these were carved too. 
 You'll always know the work we did for him, for he 
 was never pleased without some rich work somewhere 
 about ; and we finished the transepts and the tower, 
 and finished it above with a wooden steeple, and we 
 built the new chapter-house just where the old one was 
 burnt, and put little arches, all richly cut and carved, 
 along the sides of it ; but you'll never find one scrap of 
 our old work with anything like that upon it, or any- 
 thing else but strong and plain. The last thing we 
 did was the flat ceiling all along, and some Frenchmen 
 came and painted it in squares and patterns, black and 
 white. And now we've done it all, and to-morrow we 
 shall have four bishops here to open the church to the 
 people and bless it. Your old Priory at Tewkesbury is 
 in a poor plight, and if ever your Prior there wants 
 men, he'd better give us the work, and we'll put it up 
 strong for him like this ; that is what our men can do, 
 for it's the English way of work." 1 So ended the old 
 mason's story, and all the group dispersed. 
 
 We may easily imagine how imposing was the scene 
 when that grand church was opened to the people. 
 Good Abbot Serlo had won his way by the great- 
 ness of his character and his piety. " Ecclesiae murus, 
 virtutis gladius, buccina justiciae," are the words written 
 to his memory by William of Malmesbury. The wealth 
 and work of that good man attracted other good men 
 to him ; and among them was one Peter his prior, who 
 
 1 The completed work at Gloucester was dedicated in the year noo. 
 The rebuilding of the Priory of Tewkesbury was immediately begun, and 
 in 1 1 02 it was used for service and raised to the dignity of an Abbey. 
 The style is very peculiar, and precisely similar to that at Gloucester r 
 whence the idea that the same workmen built it. 
 
ix GLOUCESTER CATHEDRAL 357 
 
 succeeded him as abbot, a man of literary and artistic 
 pursuits, who first began a library here, and collected 
 rich mass books, and embroidery, and filled the treasury 
 with valuable things, among which was the famous 
 Gloucester Candlestick, now in the safe custody of the 
 South Kensington Museum, which, with all its grotesque- 
 ness of design and ornament, is no mere relic of antique 
 curiosity, but a work ot such excellence as, even in 
 these fastidious days, to command our surprise and 
 admiration. It must have been a heart-breaking scene 
 for the good abbot and his art-loving prior to witness, 
 only two years after their dedication festival, their 
 glorious Abbey Church devastated by fire. The great 
 roof and painted ceiling lay smouldering upon the floor. 
 But, as, thank God, in so many human affairs, good 
 comes out of evil, the terror and ruin of those recurrent 
 flames, which sear the history of all such buildings, 
 brought about the use of stone vaulting, which, both for 
 its skill and beauty, became the consummating glory 
 of mediaeval genius. After four destructive fires, the 
 first work of Gothic vaulting here, which the monks of 
 the abbey devised and worked at with their own hands, 
 was, however, not an artistic success. They cut and 
 maimed the features of the fine old Norman cleres- 
 tory, and placed their thin weak work too low, destroy- 
 ing all the original grandeur of effect. If it were just 
 at all to stigmatise the arts of Romanesque or Norman 
 times as grotesque or rude, there was yet about them 
 that breadth and vigour of purpose which are the best 
 elements of grandeur. But here in this first pointed 
 vaulting was a grievous and irreparable injury, destroy- 
 ing all sense of proportion throughout the whole 
 building. 
 
 If our subject could be extended to embrace the 
 stirring events of contemporary history, such scenes 
 as these old walls have witnessed, when the last 
 
358 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 Saxon Edward trod these aisles, or met his Witan 
 on this very spot ; or when the Conqueror William 
 came to Gloucester at Christmas time to hunt the 
 neighbouring forest, or met his Parliament within 
 these very walls ; or when the child King Henry the 
 Third was crowned upon those very altar steps ; or 
 when in solemn stateliness the murdered Edward was 
 laid beneath those stones such events as these would 
 afford the opportunities of most picturesque descrip- 
 tion ; for by ancient Chronicles, by illuminated manu- 
 scripts, and by inference from similar events well known 
 elsewhere, we could paint those pictures to the life. 
 But our attention here is limited to those arts of ancient 
 days that we see illustrated around us. If then we 
 cast the eyes of our imagination backwards to those 
 wondrous times, marked as they are by the contrasts 
 of intense refinement with intense barbarity, we shall 
 find in the broken record of their arts, such as the great 
 religious houses present either to our memory by their 
 records, or by their relics to our eyes, such works of sur- 
 passing beauty, such evidences of exquisite piety, as 
 are enough to cool our pride and engage our deepest 
 sympathies. If we remember how those arts of the 
 middle ages grew in beauty and strength, not by imi- 
 tation or by rote, but from the womb of creative genius; 
 if we reflect how deep are the sentiments, the sympathy, 
 the aspiration they express, we can trace through their 
 means that unity of motive and action which is the 
 beating of the great heart of humanity from generation to 
 generation ; forward to ourselves, whose sense responds 
 to every syllable of their poetry, or backwards, to 
 very ancient days when one who was a poet, a pro- 
 phet, and a king poured out his heart in such words 
 as these : " I have set my affection on the house of 
 my God, I have prepared onyx stones, and stones to 
 be set, glistening stones, and of divers colours, and all 
 
ix GLOUCESTER CATHEDRAL 359 
 
 manner of precious stones, and marble stones in abund- 
 ance ; and gold for the things of gold, and silver for 
 things of silver " or to one who followed in such 
 work, and added to it " blue and purple and crimson and 
 fair linen " or to the ancient seer whose inspired sense 
 of the future glory of Christ's Church broke out in such 
 rhapsody as this : " Oh thou afflicted, I will lay thy 
 stones with fair colours, and thy foundations with 
 sapphires ; I will make thy windows of agates, and thy 
 gates of carbuncles, and all thy borders of pleasant 
 stones." 
 
 Among the relics of this once great Abbey of St. 
 Peter there are the evidences of such enterprise in 
 art, such record of the devotion of men's lives, their 
 thoughts, their piety, their skill, as are better felt than 
 told. They are their own interpreters. But we might 
 tell of such things as these, how that some forms of 
 art seem to have sprung up first here, at Gloucester, 
 such as the fan vaulting of the cloisters ; and the web 
 of screens, and tracery of a style before its time, 1 that 
 enrich St. Andrew's aisle ; or of that master genius of 
 architecture, whose name is among the great unknown, 
 fired by the success and beauty of that work of Abbot 
 Wygmore, and impelled by an enthusiasm, approaching 
 recklessness, that broke through the eastern apse, chang- 
 ing its gloom into a flood of light ; and paring down 
 the venerable walls, covered them with a film of tracery, 
 and then threw up a vault of network stone so playful, 
 so light, as seemed to need nothing but the air to carry 
 it. We might still further tell of the qualities of ancient 
 glass, so refractive as to turn it all to jewelry ; or of 
 
 1 This so-called aisle is the south transept, which was in great part re- 
 built by Abbot Wygmore (1329-1337), and although of the early years of 
 the fourteenth century, it is characterised by the distinctive features of the 
 Perpendicular style, which was evidently initiated by the masons of Glou- 
 cester. The same may be said of the earliest fan tracery known, which 
 is in the cloisters, begun by Abbot Horton 1351-1377, vide Prof. Willis, 
 Gent. Mag., 1860. 
 
360 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY 
 
 that masterpiece of refined colouring, still traceable 
 among the shreds of ruin, on the reredos of the Lady 
 Chapel ; or again, we might praise the successful 
 audacity which poised the great tower in mid-air, and 
 crowned it with embroidery in stone. But all these 
 things are rather for the study of years than for this 
 passing hour. Take, rather, one broad glance at this 
 mighty fabric. Place yourself where you can command 
 the view, or wander in the aisles and see that great 
 work in the completion of its beauty, as it was on the 
 morning of that day, all but three centuries and a half 
 ago, when the Prior met the King's Commissioner and 
 surrendered the Abbey for its dissolution. 
 
 How different from what we see it now, denuded 
 of its colour, poor in sculpture, robbed of those import- 
 ant features which made its architectural effect har- 
 monious and complete, and others added which are an 
 injury and a hideous disgrace. Of what it was we 
 know enough by history and by inference to build it 
 up again ; but words will not build, and description 
 would fail to bring adequately before you the full effect 
 of what the art and the devotion of centuries had 
 accumulated within its walls. In front of you would 
 rise the great central rood on its loft, approached by 
 stairs in the aisle upon your left ; and beneath them 
 the two altars for the people's church, placed right and 
 left against the stone screen which parted it from the 
 choir, each altar with its background of sculptured 
 niches and coloured statuary. 
 
 If there is a feature more remarkable than others, 
 even now, it is the multitude of stone screen work 
 about the choir and its aisles and transepts ; but in 
 those days we know of at least two more, which must 
 have had imposing effect, at the end of each aisle of 
 the nave ; but these and others have been swept away. 
 Raised upon the steps within that choir, who can doubt 
 
ix GLOUCESTER CATHEDRAL 361 
 
 what the high altar and its retable must have been, that 
 were the work of that unsurpassed genius who changed 
 the grim old Saxon apse into a wonder of graceful- 
 ness and light ? Nor less beautiful was its background 
 of aisles and chapels, now alas empty and disused, but 
 then with their apses filled with sculpture and their 
 walls covered with storied painting ; and last, not least 
 indeed, that incomparable Lady Chapel, now desolate, 
 but then a wonder of coloured walls and windows, and 
 such a reredos as neither our fancy nor our skill could 
 replace, now a blackened wreck ; but then a work of 
 highest art, and of exquisite workmanship in sculpture 
 and in colours, before which we can only stand admir- 
 ing, grieved, and silent. 
 
 Turn then from these materials to the moral of 
 their tale. The Church in those days had its enemies, 
 some just and learned, some ignorant and unjust. 
 Rightly or wrongly (it is not our business here to 
 discuss the faith of Christianity as it then presented 
 itself, whether in the plain guise of its primitive truths 
 or modified in the passage of centuries by all that 
 ignorance, superstition, or the poetry of romance had 
 done to darken or adorn it), the people were content, 
 and they received the recompense of their simple faith. 
 It was to them the light and the solace of their lives 
 in an age of hardship and rough company. How 
 natural, then, their reverence and regard for all that 
 these sacred walls contained, that brought to their 
 faithful eyes the assurance of consolation and support. 
 The altars were their sanctuaries of refuge. The quiet 
 aisles, whose peace was only deepened by the echoes 
 from the world without, were their resting-places. 
 Architecture had embellished them, sculpture had 
 enriched them, and painting, which was then the 
 poor man's literature, had covered them with stories, 
 suggesting thoughts of devotion and peace. 
 
362 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART ESSAY ix 
 
 But what are all these arts ? Does any estimate 
 of them that we can take exhaust their nature ? 
 Whence come they ? For what do they exist, if it 
 be not for their power of appeal from man to man ? 
 Of what good that lofty choir, if it be but to enclose 
 a vague and useless space ; of what good to raise 
 above it that great tower, if it be but to pile up sense- 
 less stones ; for what good the bulk and body of the 
 great minster itself, if it be but a mass of meaningless 
 masonry ? No ; but as the spark is that lights the 
 .candle, so has the touch of fine art illumined those 
 stones. The hands of their builders are dead, but 
 their art lives ; and their heart, their mind, their de- 
 votion, their very lives, still animate those monuments. 
 
 So ends my story ; and the moral of it all is this : 
 The foundation of all fine art lies in that relationship 
 which exists between the things of material and the 
 things of spirit ; and the degree of its perception and 
 the power of its use is the gauge of all art's genius. 
 By force of that relationship Fine Art testifies to that 
 Divine life which underlies the whole sphere of man's 
 mortal state. She testifies to the utter inadequacy of 
 all material things to measure the range, or to satisfy 
 the aspirations, of that which is itself illimitable the 
 human soul. She is herself that soul's interpreter. 
 Her greatest works are but symbols. She is conscious 
 of her own feebleness, and of those impenetrable clouds 
 which dim her mortal sight. But she is conscious also 
 of that light which shines beyond those clouds ; and by 
 an impulse of desire and faith she stretches out her 
 arms to the heavens, and, silent, she binds around her 
 lovely brow this motto : " What is not seen is eternal." 
 
APPENDIX 
 
 THE METHOD OF SPIRIT FRESCO PAINTING 
 
 Reprinted from a letter addressed, by request, to the Secretary, 
 Science and Art Department, South Kensington, March 1880. 
 
 SPIRIT Fresco Painting is not the mere addition of one more 
 medium to the many already known, but a system, complete 
 from the first preparation of a wall to the last touch of the 
 artist. 
 
 The advantages which it ventures to offer are (i) dura- 
 bility (the principal materials being all but imperishable) ; (2) 
 power to resist external damp and changes of temperature ; 
 (3) luminous effect ; (4) a dead surface ; (5) freedom from all 
 chemical action on colours. 
 
 It is designed mainly for purposes of great works on walls, 
 and to afford to monumental art in this country the advantages 
 peculiar to the various systems of Buon Fresco, tempera, oil, 
 the true encaustic, and water glass, with freedom from those 
 objections to them which are due to the dampness and dark- 
 ness of our climate. 
 
 I am the more glad of the opportunity of sending you a 
 full explanation of the system, because its manifest advantages 
 in rapid drying and dead surface have led to the production of 
 works of considerable importance, which, though professedly 
 in Spirit Fresco, have been executed with too much considera- 
 tion of time and cost, by the adoption of the Medium, but by 
 neglect of the System, on which the whole excellence of the 
 matter depends. Such works, having merely a superficial 
 existence, that is to say, no incorporation with the wall on 
 which they are painted, are liable to perish from want of con- 
 sistency, and might bring the system into disrepute. 
 
364 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART 
 
 The Wall Surface. 
 
 The wall must be dry. No painting materials can be 
 durable on a damp foundation ; it is enough to contend with 
 external damp and the atmosphere of crowded places. The 
 surface to be painted must also be perfectly dry and porous, 
 not merely absorbent, but porous. The best is good common 
 stucco, precisely the same as that always used for Buon Fresco, 
 of which the proportions of lime and perfectly washed gritty 
 sand vary according to the nature of the lime and the time 
 given to slake it. For important works the lime was formerly 
 run and kept closed from the atmosphere for above a year, in 
 which case the proportions would be one of lime to two of 
 perfectly clean grit. Lime imperfectly slaked will blister and 
 blow off. For a great work this must be purposely prepared ; 
 but for ordinary work the common plaster (stucco), viz. one of 
 lime to three of clean grit, in the interior of buildings care- 
 fully executed, may be trusted. The one primary necessity is 
 that it should be left with its natural surface, its porous quality 
 being absolutely essential. All smoothing process or "float- 
 ing " with plaster of Paris destroys this quality. All cements 
 must be avoided, some of them having too hard and smooth 
 a surface, and consequently being devoid of all key or means 
 of attachment for colours, and others being liable to efflor- 
 escence and chemical action. The next best surface, after that 
 of stucco on a wall of good dry brick, is that of coarse and 
 porous Bath stone, or any other free stone with that essential 
 quality ; all sand-papering or other process being objectionable 
 from its filling the pores of the stone with powder. 
 
 The Medium and Preparation of Colours. 
 
 Take, in any multiple of these proportions, according to 
 the quantity required for a work : 
 
 Elemi resin (Gum elemi} . 2 oz. ) 
 Pure white wax . . 4 oz. J 
 
 Oil of spike lavender . . 8 oz. | 
 Finest preparation of artist's > mesure 
 
 copal . . . 20 oz.) 
 
 (If a stronger kind of copal is used 18 ounces are sufficient) 
 
 With these materials, incorporated by heat, all colours, in 
 
 dry powder, must be mixed, and the most convenient system 
 
APPENDIX 365 
 
 is to do so precisely as oil colours are mixed on a slab, and 
 put into tubes. The colours keep in this way for many years. 
 I have many in tubes above twenty years old, as fresh as 
 when put there. 
 
 The proper method of compounding this medium is this. 
 Take 2 oz. of Elemi resin, and melt them in 2 ounces of 
 rectified turpentine in a small pot or saucepan over the char- 
 coal, and strain when quite liquid through muslin (to clear 
 it of pieces of leaves and bark) into the larger pot. Into 
 this put 4 oz. of white wax in small pieces, and melt with the 
 Elemi. When melted, add 20 oz. of copal, and boil all 
 together to a white foam, stirring well with a spoon reaching 
 to the bottom, remove from the fire and boil again. Immedi- 
 ately upon the last removal from the fire add 8 oz. of spike 
 oil, stirring all well together. This volatile ingredient would 
 be wasted if added sooner and boiled. 
 
 N.B. It is necessary to be extremely careful lest any 
 spark from the charcoal (no flame being allowed) should ignite 
 the liquid, every ingredient being inflammable. It should be 
 done out of doors. 
 
 Decant through a funnel into strong clear glass bottles, 
 that the condition of the medium may be clearly visible before 
 use, the quart size being the most convenient j and leave un- 
 corked to cool. When used, the bottles may require shaking, 
 not that the materials will ever again disintegrate, but from the 
 weight of the wax they will tend to thicken at the bottom. 
 
 Preparation of the Wall Surface. 
 
 Choose a time of dry and warm weather. 
 
 Dilute the amount of medium required in once and a half 
 its bulk of good turpentine. The mixture is more effective if 
 compounded by heat, which is very easily done in a large 
 iron cauldron over charcoal free from flame ; and the " Wall 
 Wash " thus made can be kept for any time in large bottles. 
 (If kept in tins for any length of time its condition for use 
 would be hidden.) With this wash let the surface of the wall 
 be well saturated, the liquid being dashed against it rather 
 than merely washed over it. After two days' interval this must 
 be repeated. After a few days left for evaporation, mix equal 
 quantities of pure white lead (in powder) and of gilder's 
 whitening (common whitening being often full of large grits 
 
366 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART 
 
 and too strong of lime) in the medium slightly diluted with 
 about a third of turpentine, and paint the surface thickly, 
 and when sufficiently evaporated to bear a second coat, add 
 it as thickly as a brush can lay it. This, when dry, for 
 which two or three weeks may be required, produces a per- 
 fect surface so white that colours upon it have all the inter- 
 nal light of Buon Fresco and the transparency of pure water 
 colours, and it is so absorbent that their attachment is complete. 
 
 Method of Painting. 
 
 Paint boldly and simply as in Buon Fresco ; as much 
 as possible alia prima, and with much body ; and use pure 
 oil of spike in your dipper freely. Decision is very necessary, 
 because by much harassing the surface, the materials are 
 liable to be disintegrated, the resins rise to the surface and 
 perfect deadness is lost. If the surface has been left for so 
 long as to have become quite hard, wash over the part for the 
 morning's work with pure spike oil, to melt the surface (hence 
 the name Spirit Fresco) and prepare it to incorporate the 
 colours painted into it. If any part requires second painting 
 the next day, do not wash again with the spike oil, it is liable 
 to bring the resins to the surface, but use plenty of spike oil, 
 which renders the surface moist (Fresco) to be painted into. 
 Paint rather solidly than transparently. Transparent glazing 
 is less likely to dry dead than colours used with white lead. 
 
 The Rationale of the painting is therefore this, that the 
 colours in powder being incorporated with material identical 
 with that which has already sunk deep into the pores of the 
 wall surface, and has hardened there by the evaporation of 
 the spirit vehicle, may be regarded as belonging to the mass- 
 of the wall itself, and not as mere superficial applications. 
 This result is produced by the spike oil being the one com- 
 mon solvent of all the materials, which turpentine is not ; 
 the moment the painter's brush touches the surface it opens 
 to receive the colours, and on the rapid evaporation of the 
 spike oil it closes them in, and thus the work is done. 
 
 Important Cautions. 
 
 Take care that the spike oil or turpentine does not run 
 down, or by any carelessness be sprinkled on any finished 
 work. It produces a shine by bringing up the resins, and is 
 indelible, except by solid over-painting. 
 
APPENDIX 367 
 
 Very clean habits are necessary, for every ingredient is so 
 sticky that unless the brushes, palette, etc. etc., are thoroughly 
 cleaned with turpentine at the close of every day's work the 
 result is great discomfort. 
 
 Let all preparation of the surface and rubbing up of the 
 colours for tubes be overlooked by the artist, as in old days when 
 the technical work was done in the artist's own " bottega." 
 A thoroughly respectable colourman interested in serving the 
 artist may be trusted, but the colourman's man (somewhere 
 else) most certainly is not. The colours dry so rapidly while 
 he is rubbing them up on the slab, that he is tempted to 
 dilute them with turpentine, and thus destroy their power and 
 consistency, which the use of pure medium alone ensures. 
 
 Result. 
 
 All this sounds very complicated and troublesome in 
 description, but in practice, when once " en train" it is 
 perfectly simple and easy. I do not pretend that it is a 
 cheap method, or free from all trouble, but that trouble is as 
 nothing in comparison with. Buon Fresco Painting and several 
 other methods. 
 
 If this system is really what, after more than twenty years' 
 work in it, I have confidence that it is, it is worth that little 
 trouble (only felt when first beginning) by an artist who de- 
 sires to ensure the durability of his work. It is for this that 
 the adoption of entire system is absolutely essential. 
 
 With all the many and manifest faults of amateur work, 
 my own paintings executed over the chancel arch of Highnam 
 Church in 1 860-61, the procession in the aisle of that church 
 begun in 1868, and the work in St. Andrew's Chapel in 
 Gloucester Cathedral, finished in 1867, simply regarded as 
 tests, afford for all practical purposes of wall painting every 
 quality that a fresco painter, under the exigencies of English 
 climate and darkness, can require. I only quote my own 
 works because I know that in them every condition has been 
 followed. Their surfaces are hard and smooth. The rapidity 
 of drying prevents any stickiness, and the surface becomes 
 immediately compact, but it requires a year or two at least 
 for its perfect induration by the complete evaporation of the 
 volatile oils. 
 
368 THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART 
 
 Another Method for Wood or Canvas. 
 
 As a system of painting for large works of high class other 
 than upon walls, where dead surface and durability are de- 
 siderata, I venture to add that for large wooden panels or 
 extensive areas of wooden ceilings I have found, after many 
 experiments, the following most pleasant in use and perfectly 
 successful in result : 
 
 Take one part, in bulk, pale drying oil, 
 
 ditto, ditto, strong copal varnish, 
 two ditto, japanner's gold size, 
 
 two ditto, turpentine, 
 
 have them thoroughly shaken together, and always strongly 
 shaken before use. In this (which, by way of specifying it, 
 I have called the Ely medium) have all dry powder colours 
 rubbed up and put into tubes, or, if quantity is wanted, into 
 pots kept covered against dust and evaporation. Paint ac- 
 cording to habit or circumstance, transparently as in water- 
 colour or massively as in oil. Use as vehicle in the dipper a 
 compound of three parts turpentine and one part medium. 
 It dries with such rapidity that outline under-painting and 
 final effect may follow immediately on each other. It is very 
 pleasant and easy of use. It dries perfectly dead and hard 
 as iron. Ordinary decorators often use japanner's gold size 
 alone, because of its dead surface, but it is useless alone, 
 having no consistency nor any binding power to preserve 
 colours. This Ely medium is exceedingly dark in colour, 
 but it produces no appreciable effect on the powder colours 
 that are rubbed up in it, not even white. If any effect at all, 
 it is that of a slight mellowness. With this the whole of the 
 eastern half of the nave roof, the whole lantern and octagon, 
 and the baptistery transept ceiling at Ely Cathedral were 
 painted, the former as long ago as 1863-64. 
 
 THE END 
 
 Printed by R. & R. CLARK, Edinburgh. 
 
ALBEMARLE STREET 
 July, 1886. 
 
 MR, MURRAY'S LIST 
 
 OF 
 
 NEW PUBLICATIONS 
 
 Through the British Empire. 
 
 SOUTH AFRICA, AUSTRALIA, NEW ZEALAND, THE STRAITS 
 
 SETTLEMENTS, INDIA, THE SOUTH SEA ISLANDS, 
 
 CALIFORNIA, OREGON, CANADA, &c. 
 
 By BARON VON HUBNER, 
 
 Membre Associe de 1'Institut de France : last Surviving Member of the Congress of Paris. 
 Author of " Sixtus V.," "A Ramble round the World," &c. 
 
 With Map. 2 Vols. Crown 8vo. 24^. 
 
 " I remember a great statesman saying that an official had so much manuscript to read 
 that he could hardly be expected to read anything that was printed. I think, however, that 
 officials must be very busy indeed who cannot find time to read two remarkable books which 
 had appeared this year. One of these is written by the Austrian statesman, Baron Hiibner, 
 a Conservative among Conservatives in his own country, but who overflows with sympathy, 
 not only for Englishmen, but for our more democratic relations across the ocean." Earl 
 GranmUe, A^ril 7, 1886. 
 
 Days and Nights of Service. 
 
 WITH SIR GERALD GRAHAM'S FIELD FORCE AT SOUAKIM, 
 By MAJOR E. A. DE COSSON, 
 
 Author of the "Cradle of the Blue Nile." 
 
 With Illustrations,. Crown Sfo. 14^. 
 
 " The most vivid, detailed, and picturesque version of the war about Souakim that I havj 
 yet seen. Every one who cares about British valour should read it." Daily News. 
 
Mr. Murray*s List of New Publications, 
 
 Lord Beaeonsfield's Letters. 
 
 1. HOME LETTERS, WRITTEN IN 183031. Post 8m 
 
 2. CORRESPONDENCE WITH HIS SISTER, 1832-1852. 
 
 With Portrait. Crown 8vo. IDJ. 6d. 
 
 An Introduction to the Study of 
 The New Testament. 
 
 AND 
 
 AN INVESTIGATION INTO MODERN BIBLICAL CRITICISM 
 BASED ON THE MOST RECENT SOURCES OF INFORMATION. 
 
 By GEORGE SALMON, D.D., D.C.L., &c. 
 
 Chancellor of St. Patrick's Cathedral, Regius Professor of Divinity in the University of Dublin. 
 
 A New, Revised, and Enlarged Edition. 8vo. [Ready. 
 
 THE 
 
 Western Pacific, and New Guinea. 
 
 WITH NOTICES OF THE NATIVES, CHRISTIAN AND CANNIBAL, 
 AND SOME ACCOUNT OF THE OLD LABOUR TRADE. 
 
 By HUGH HASTINGS ROMILLY, 
 
 Deputy Commissioner for the Western Pacific, and Acting Special Commandant for New Guinea. 
 With Map. Crown 8vo. 7;. 6d. 
 
 CONTENTS :- 
 
 THE ISLAND AND ISLANDERS. 
 
 NEW BRITAIN. 
 
 CANNIBALISM IN NEW IRELAND. 
 
 THE SOLOMON ISLANDS. 
 
 POISONED ARROWS. 
 
 CRUISE IN SOUTHERN SEAS. 
 
 OTHER ISLANDS. 
 
 Two SMALL BRITISH POSSESSIONS. 
 
 THE OLD LABOUR TRADE. 
 
 WHITE MEN IN THE PACIFIC. 
 
 BULLY HAYES. 
 
 NEW GUINEA. 
 
 " The future of the islands of which he speaks has become quite a burning question lately 
 but though everybody talks nobody knows about them, and Mr. Romilly's pages give < 
 better idea of the islands and inhabitants than any book we know of ; indeed the book is ful 
 of good things, and there is a drv humour in Air. Romilly, together with a modest, unaffectec 
 way with him, that makes his book a very pleasant one to read." Pall Mall Gazette. 
 
Mr. Murray's List of New Publications. 
 
 THE 
 
 Student's History of Modern Europe. 
 
 FROM THE CAPTURE OF CONSTANTINOPLE BY THE 
 
 TURKS, 1453, TO THE TREATY OF BERLIN, 1878. 
 
 By RICHARD LODGE, M.A., 
 
 Fellow and Tutor of Brasenose College, Oxford. 
 
 Post Svo. js. 6d. 
 %* Forming a New Volume of MURRAY'S STUDENT'S MANUALS. 
 
 " It is constructed on true and well planned lines : it abounds in rich and etact knowledge 
 it usually groups with true insight masses of events in their just relations, points out the 
 threads which connect the order and interdependence of European progress, and vindicates 
 amid apparent disorder the general unity of the affairs of the Continent." Academy. 
 
 Bolingbroke ; 
 
 His Political Life Life in Exile Literary Life, 
 
 AN HISTORICAL STUDY. 
 
 REPRINTED FROM THE "QUARTERLY REVIEW," 
 TO WHICH 'iS ADDED AN ESSAY ON 
 
 "VOLTAIRE IN ENGLAND." 
 
 By J. CHURTON COLLINS. 
 
 Crown 8vo. "js. 6d. 
 
 " These essays are amongst the best literary essays that have recently appeared, and we 
 cordially commend them to all who are interested in the attractive subjects with which they 
 deal." Literary World. 
 
 The Punishment of Death. 
 
 TO WHICH IS ADDED 
 
 PUBLIC RESPONSIBILITY, AND THE VOTE BY BALLOT. 
 
 By the late HENRY ROMILLY, M.A. 
 
 Crown &'>>. 9*. 
 
 "These posthumous essays by a talented son of a talented lawyer are certain to attract 
 attention. The question is stated with all the skill of a great thinker, not of an advocate who 
 holds a brief for a particular side in an argument." Nonconformist. 
 
Mr. Miirrays List of New Publications. 
 
 Popular Government 
 
 FOUR ESSAYS. 
 
 I. PROSPECTS OP POPULAR GOVERNMENT. II. NATURE OF DEMOCRACY.- 
 III. AGE OF PROGRESS. IV. CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES. 
 
 By Sir HENRY SUMMER MAINE, K.C.S.I , LL.D., F.R.S., 
 
 Foreign Associate Member of the Institute of France, 
 Author of " Ancient Law," &c. 
 
 Third Edition. Svo. I2J. 
 
 Principles of Greek Etymology. 
 
 By Professor G. CURTIUS. 
 
 Of the University of Leipzig. 
 
 TRANSLATED INTO ENGLISH, WITH THE AUTHOR'S SANCTION. 
 By A. S. WILKINS, Litt.D., LL.D. and E. B. ENGLAND, M.A., 
 
 Professor of Latin and Comparative Assistant Lecturer in Classics, Owens Coll. 
 
 Philology. Manchester. 
 
 Fifth Edition, Thoroughly Revised.. 2 Vols. 8vo. 2%s. 
 UNIFORM WITH THE ABOVE, 
 
 The Greek Verb, its Structure and Development. 
 
 By Professor G. CURTIUS, 
 
 Second Edition. Svo. 12s. 
 
 THE 
 
 Epistle of St. Paul to the Romans. 
 
 WITH INTRODUCTION AND NOTES 
 By E. H. GIFFORD, D. D., 
 
 Archdeacon of London, Canon of St. Paul's, and Examining Chaplain to the Bishop of London. 
 
 Medium 8z'0. 7 . 6d. 
 [REPRINTED FROM THE SPEAKER'S COMMENTARY.] 
 
Air. Miirrays List of New Publications. 5 
 
 A Glossary of Anglo-Indian Colloquial 
 Words and Phrases. 
 
 AND OF KINDRED TERMS, 
 
 ETYMOLOGICAL, HISTORICAL, GEOGRAPHICAL, 
 AND DISCURSIVE. 
 
 By Col. HENRY YULE, C.B., LL.D., 
 
 Editor of "The Book of Ser Marco Polo," &c. 
 
 And the late ARTHUR BURNELL, Ph.D., C.I.E., 
 
 Author of " The Elements of South Indian Paleography." 
 Medium 8vo. 36^. Half boimd. 
 
 "It is a handy cyclopedia for the Eastern traveller, a general book of reference, of 
 entertaining reading, of table talk, a conversational lexicon, a book where you will find every- 
 thing you can expect to find or in India are likely to want, as easy and unlaboured as a simple 
 magazine article, and as trustworthy as the best authorities can make it." Guardian. 
 
 Index to the Quarterly Review. 
 
 VOL. CLX., CONTAINING A GENERAL INDEX TO Nos. 281 318 INCLUSIVE. 
 
 2 Parts. Svo. I2J. 
 
 Tiryns : 
 
 A PREHISTORIC PALACE OF THE KINGS OF TIRYNS. 
 .DISCLOSED BY EXCAVATIONS IN 1884-85. 
 
 By HENRY SCHLIEMANN, F.S.A., D.C.L., &c. 
 
 Author of " Troy and its Remains," " Ancient Mycenae," " Ilios," " Troja," &c. 
 
 WITH PREFACE AND CONTRIBUTIONS BY PROF. ADLER AND 
 DR. DORPFELD. 
 
 With Coloured Lithographs, Woodcuts, Plans ; <SrY., from Drawings made on the spot. 
 
 Crown 4/0. 42*. 
 
 " The attitude of scholars is one of just appreciation. They recognise the vast importance 
 of Dr. Schliemann's discoveries, and the amazing enthusiasm, industry, and sacrifice of time 
 and means which have enabled him to achieve them. Upon the whole it is not too much to 
 say of Dr. Schliemann's Tirynthian discovery that it has made darkness to be light." The 
 Times, 
 
Mr. Murray's List of New Publications. 
 
 The Country Banker: 
 
 HIS CLIENTS, CARES, AND WORK. 
 
 FROM THE EXPERIENCE OF FORTY YEARS. 
 
 By GEORGE RAE. 
 
 Author of "Bullion's Letters to a Bank Manager." 
 New Edition^ Revised. Crown %vo. Js. 6d. 
 
 The Works of Alexander Pope. 
 
 PROSE WORKS, VOLS. IX., X. 
 EDITED, WITH COPIOUS NOTES AND INTRODUCTIONS. 
 
 By W. J. COURTHOPE, M.A. 
 
 8vo. los. 6d. each. 
 
 ALREADY PUBLISHED : 
 
 Vols. L, II., III., IV. POETRY. 
 
 Vols. VI., VII., VIII. CORRESPONDENCE. 
 
 ** Vol. V. t containing THE LIFE and GENERAL INDEX, in preparation. 
 
 Life of Dr. William Carey. 
 
 SHOEMAKER AND MISSIONARY. 
 
 PROFESSOR OF SANSCRIT, BENGALEE, AND MARATHEE AT THE 
 COLLEGE OF FORT WILLIAM, CALCUTTA. 17611834. 
 
 By GEORGE SMITH, LL.D., 
 
 Author of the Lives of John Wilson and Alexander Duff. 
 Portrait and Illustrations. 8v0. i6s. 
 
Mr. Murray s List of New Publications. 
 LIFE OF 
 
 General Sir Charles J. Napier. 
 
 By the Hon. WM. NAPIER BRUCE. 
 
 With Portrait and Plans of Battles > &>c. Crown 8vo. izs. 
 
 THE 
 
 Endowments and Establishment of 
 The Church of England. 
 
 By Rev. J. S. BREWER, M.A. 
 
 Late Preacher at the Rolls, and Hon. Fellow of Queen's Coll., Oxford. 
 
 Revised and Edited by LEWIS T. DIBDIN, M.A., 
 OF LINCOLN'S INN, BARRISTER-AT-LAW. 
 
 Third Edition. Post 8vo. 6s. 
 
 Eeelesiastieal History. 
 
 INCLUDING THE 
 
 ORIGIN AND PROGRESS OF THE ENGLISH REFORMATION 
 FROM WICLIF TO THE GREAT REBELLION. 
 
 By WM. FITZGERALD, Late Bishop of Killaloe and Clonfert. 
 
 EDITED 
 By WM. FITZGERALD, A.M., and JOHN QUARRY, D.D. 
 
 WITH A MEMOIR OF THE AUTHOR. 
 
 2 Vols. Sro. 2U. 
 
 " This last quality (Irish vivacity) is most clearly visible when Fitzgerald has occasion to 
 attack some opponent. Quite in the spirit of Donnybrook Fair does he turn aside from his 
 subject to pulverise the unfortunate person who offends him. These attacks form agreeable 
 interludes, and are so amusing that their frequent irrelevance may be forgiven ... The 
 author sweeps down the ages with easy flight, and ' gives to historical questions a free poetical 
 treatment.' . . . The volumes possess undoubted merit." Literary World. 
 
Mr. Murray's List of Neiu Publications. 
 
 Glenaveril ; 
 
 OR, THE METAMORPHOSES. 
 
 A TOEM IN SIX BOOKS. 
 By the EARL OF LYTTON. 
 
 2 Vots. Fcap. Svo. 12s. 
 
 " I may say at once that this strikes me as the freshest, the strongest, the most varied and 
 entertaining volume of new verse I have ever had occasion to review. The poem has the 
 discursive freshness and force of extremely brilliant conversation. It, may possibly prove an 
 epoch-making book. It is almost certain to have many imitators." Academy. 
 
 Symbols and Emblems of Early and 
 Mediaeval Christian Art. 
 
 WITH 500 EXAMPLES DRAWN FROM PAINTINGS, MINIATURES, 
 SCULPTURES, AND MONUMENTS, 
 
 By LOUISA TWINING. 
 
 Second Edition. With Illustrations. Crown %vo. 12s. 
 
 " No student of Christian Symbolism should fail to add this most attractive volume- with 
 its wealth of illustrationsto his library." John Bull. 
 
 SKETCHES OF 
 
 The History of Christian Art. 
 
 By the late LORD LINDSAY 
 
 (EARL OF CRAWFORD AND BALCARRES). 
 Second Edition. 2 Vols. Crown 8vo. 2^s. 
 
 " The book so far as it goes is full of charm, even of fascination, but as a historian it is 
 Lord Crawford's best title to honour that he was the first to point out a new line of research.' 
 Guardian, 
 
Mr. Murray's List of New Publications. 
 
 Letters of Princess Alice, 
 
 GRAND DUCHESS OF HESSE, 
 
 TO 
 
 THE QUEEN. 
 
 With a Memoir by H.R.H. the PRINCESS CHRISTIAN, 
 
 A New and Popular Edition. Portrait. Crown 8vo. "js. bd 
 
 A HANDBOOK TO THE 
 
 Political Questions of the Day. 
 
 WITH THE ARGUMENTS ON EITHER SIDE. 
 By SYDNEY C. BUXTON. 
 
 Sixth Edition. Revised and considerably Enlarged. Svo. Js. >d. 
 
 NEW SUBJECTS IN THIS EDITION. Allotments Extension Incidence of Taxation 
 Free Schools (re-written) Irish Church Disestablishment Results. The whole book 
 carefully revised, and much of it re-written. 
 
 Landscape in Art. 
 
 BEFORE CLAUDE AND SALVATOR. 
 By JOSIAH GILBERT, 
 
 Author of "Excursions among the Dolomites;" and "Cadore, or Titian's Country. 
 With an Index and 140 Illustrations. Medium 8vo. 30^. 
 
 " There are some books, published either of old or nowadays, which nothing but genuine 
 love of their subjects could have inspired ; and of such a kind is the one before us. 
 Mr. Gilbert has had the rare power to write a work upon a subject of early art history which 
 is readable throughout, full of interesting facts clearly expressed, and thoroughly to l,e recom- 
 mended to all who are interested in the study of art." Spectator \ 
 
io Mr. Murray's List of New Publications. 
 
 The Moon. 
 
 CONSIDERED AS A PLANET, A WORLD, AND A SATELLITE. 
 By JAMES NASMYTH, C.E., and JAMES CARPENTER, F.R.A.S. 
 
 With 26 Illustrations of Ltmar Objects, Phenomena, and Scenery, prodticed from Draivings 
 made with the aid of powerful Telescopes, and numerous Woodcuts, 
 
 THIRD EDITION. Medium 8vo. 2is. 
 
 " The illustrations to this book are so admirable, so far beyond those one generally gets 
 of any celestial phenomenon, that one is tempted to refer to them first of all. No more 
 truthful or striking representations have ever been laid before his readers by any student of 
 science. The more carefully the text is read, the more obvious does it become that 
 Mr. Nasmyth and Mr. Carpenter have produced a work which is not only a very beautiful, 
 but an admirable production." Nature. 
 
 Pre-historie America. 
 
 A SURVEY OF THE MONUMENTS LEFT BY ANCIENT 
 AND EXTINCT RACES IN THE NEW WORLD. 
 
 By the MARQUIS DE NADAILLAC. 
 Translated by N. D'ANVERS. 
 
 With Illustrations. 8vo. \6s. 
 
 " A really delightful book. An admirable compendium of the scattered monographs on 
 the pre-historic antiquities of America. It is possible that some of our readers are unaware 
 of the great variety and the extent of the traces of ancient races in the new world." Literary 
 Churchman. 
 
 Autobiography of James Nasmyth, 
 
 INVENTOR OF THE STEAM HAMMER. 
 Edited by SAMUEL SMILES, LL.D. 
 
 A New and Popular Edition. With Portrait and Woodcuts. Post 8vo. 6s. 
 UNIFORM WITH THE " SELF HELP " SERIES, 
 
Mr. Murray's List of New Publications. 1 1 
 
 The Eton Latin Grammar. 
 
 PART I. ELEMENTARY. 
 
 FOR USE IN THE LOWER FORMS. 
 
 COMPILED WITH THE SANCTION OF THE HEADMASTER, 
 
 By A. C. AINGER, M.A., Trin. Coll. Cambridge; 
 
 And H. G. WINTLE, M.A., Ch. Ch. Oxford; 
 
 ASSISTANT MASTERS AT ETON COLLEGE. 
 
 Crown %vo. %s. 6d. 
 ALSO, BY THE SAME EDITORS, 
 
 A First Latin Exercise Book, 
 
 ADAPTED TO THE ETON LATIN GRAMMAR. 
 
 Crown 8vo. 2s. 6d. 
 
 THE CROKER PAPERS. 
 
 Letters and Journals 
 
 OP THE LATE 
 
 Rt. Hon. John Wilson Croker, LLD., 
 
 (SECRETARY TO THE ADMIRALTY 1809 to 1831.) 
 
 RELATING TO THE CHIEF POLITICAL AND SOCIAL EVENTS OF 
 THE FIRST HALF OF THE PRESENT CENTURY. 
 
 Edited by LOUIS J. JENNINGS, 
 
 Second Edition, Revised. Portrait. 3 Vols. 8vo. 4$s. 
 
12 
 
 Mr. Murray's List of New Publications. 
 
 MR. ROBINSON'S NEW GARDEN CYCLOPAEDIA. 
 
 The Vegetable Garden. 
 
 ILLUSTRATIONS, DESCRIPTIONS AND CULTURE OF THE 
 GARDEN VEGETABLES OF COLD AND TEMPERATE CLIMATES. 
 
 By MM. VILMORIN-ANDRIEUX, or Paris. 
 
 AN ENGLISH EDITION PUBLISHED UNDER THE DIRECTION OF 
 W. ROBINSON, Editor of "The Garden." 
 
 With 750 Illustrations. Medium Svo. 15^. 
 
 English Names of Plants ; 
 
 Applied in England and among English- 
 speaking Peoples to Cultivated and 
 Wild Plants, Trees, and Shrubs. By 
 WILLIAM MILLER. Medium Svo. 
 
 I2J. 
 
 English Flower Garden ; 
 
 Designs for Laying it Out, and 
 Figures of Flowers, Description of 
 Plants, their Culture and Arrangement. 
 By W. ROBINSON. With Illustra- 
 tions. Medium 8vo. i$s. 
 
 Greenhouse and Stove Plants, 
 
 and 
 
 Palms, Ferns, and Lycopodiums. With full details of the Propagation and Cultivation 
 of 500 Families of Plants, suitable for growing in the Greenhouse, Intermediate 
 House, and Stove. By THOMAS BAINES. Svo. Ss. 6J. 
 
 Letters and Papers of 
 
 Sir James Bland Burges, Bart. 
 
 Under Secretary of State for 
 Foreign Affairs from 1789 to 
 1795. With Notices of his Life. 
 
 Edited by JAMES MUTTON, 
 
 Author of "James and Philip Van 
 Arteveld." &vo. i$j. 
 
 The Reign of Henry viii. 
 
 From his Accession to the 
 Death of Wolsey. Reviewed and 
 Illustrated from Original Docu- 
 ments. 
 
 By the late Professor J. S. 
 BREWER, M.A. Edited by JAMES 
 GAIRDNER, of the Public Record 
 Office. With Portrait. 2 Vols. 8vo. $0*. 
 
Mr. Murray's List of New Publications. 
 
 Adventures and Experiences of 
 a Magistrate, 
 
 DURING THE INDIAN MUTINY. 
 
 By MARK THORNHILL, 
 
 Bengal Civil Service Retired. 
 With Frontispiece and Plan. Crown 8v0. I2s. 
 
 The Student's Elements 
 
 of Geology. 
 
 By Sir CHARLES LYELL, Bart., 
 
 F.R.S., Author of "Principles of 
 Geology, &c " A New Edition, entirely 
 revised, by Professor P. MARTIN 
 DUNCAN, F.R.S. With 600 //lus- 
 trations. Post 8vo. gs. 
 
 Little Arthur's History 
 
 of France. 
 
 From the Earliest Times to the 
 Fall of the Second Empire, for 
 Young Readers. 
 
 On the plan of "Little Arthur's 
 England." With Map and Illustra- 
 tions. Foolscap Sz'o. 2s. 6d. 
 
 History of Greek Sculp- Greece. 
 
 turf, 
 
 From the Earliest Times down 
 to the Age of Pheidias and his 
 Successors. 
 
 By A. S. MURRAY, Keeper of the 
 Greek and Roman Antiquities in the 
 British Museum. With 130 Illustra- 
 tions. Complete in Tiuo Vols. Medium 
 $vo. $2s. 6d. 
 
 A Descriptive, Historical, and 
 Pictorial Account. 
 
 By the late BISHOP WORDS- 
 WORTH. With an Introduction on 
 the Characteristics of Greek Art, by 
 George Scharf, F.S.A., Director of the 
 National Portrait Gallery. New 
 Edition, edited by H. F. TOZER, 
 M.A. With 400 Illustrations. Royal 
 
 Life and Works of Raphael. 
 
 By J. A. CROWE and G. B. CAVALCASELLE. 
 
 2 Vols. Svo. 33-r. 
 
 " There are no students of Raphael but will find fresh light thrown on his practice and 
 procedure in this latest essay of the writers. Passages of admirable description are frequent, 
 but it is the pages of careful analysis, fixing in the mind the origin and import of the com- 
 positions, their relationship when forming part of a series, and the essential qualities of their 
 surpassing excellence which will be pronounced the more valuable." Times. 
 
14 Mr. Murray's List of New Publications. 
 
 Plato, 
 
 AND THE OTHER COMPANIONS OF SOCRATES, 
 By GEORGE GROTE, D.C.L. LL.D., 
 
 Author of the " History of Greece." 
 
 A NEW AND REVISED EDITION, 
 Edited by ALEXANDER BAIN, LL.D., 
 
 Rector of the University of Aberdeen. 
 4 Volumes. Croitm 8vo. 6s. each. 
 
 Asiatic Studies The Liberal Movement 
 
 Religious and Social. 
 
 By Sir ALFRED C. LYALL, 
 K.C.B., Lieut-Governor of the N.-W. 
 Provinces. Second Edition. Svo. I2s. 
 
 in English Literature. 
 A Series of Essays. 
 
 By W. J. COURTHOPE, M.A. 
 
 Editor of Pope's Works, c. 8vo. 6s. 
 
 UNIFORM SERIES OF THE WORKS 
 
 OF THE LATE 
 
 DEAN STANLEY. 
 
 Essays on Church and Historical Memorials of 
 
 State. Canterbury. 
 
 Crown 8vo. 6s. 
 
 The Eastern Church. 
 
 Plans. Crown 8vo, 6s. 
 
 The Jewish Church. 
 
 Portrait and Plans. 3 Vols. crown 
 8v0. 6s. each. 
 
 Christian Institutions. 
 
 Crcnvn 8vo. 6s. 
 
 Illustrations. Crown 8vo. 6s. 
 
 Life and Correspondence 
 
 of Dr. Arnold. 
 Portrait. 2 Vols. crown 8vo. I2s. 
 
 Sinai and Palestine. 
 
 With Coloured Map's. 8vo. iis. 
 
Mr. Murray's List of New Publications. 
 
 Handbook-Dictionary of 
 
 the English, French, and German 
 Languages. 
 
 Including all Phrases and Col- 
 loquial Expressions required by 
 Travellers. Printed in a Conve- 
 nient Shape for the Hand or 
 Pocket. 
 
 By GEORGE F. CHAMBERS, 
 F R.A.S., of the Inner Temple, Bar- 
 rister-at-Law. Oblong 161110. 6s. bound. 
 
 HandbookofTravelTalk. 
 
 In English, German, French, 
 and Italian. 
 
 An Attempt to Supply the Needs of 
 Travellers on a Journey with the Col- 
 loquial Phraseology of The Railway, 
 Ticket Taking, Luggage, Post Office and 
 Telegraph, '1 he Hotel, Table (THote, 
 Bedroom, Sight Seeing, Shopping, Trades- 
 people, Money Changing, Restaurants 
 and Cafes, Physicians, Cabs and Omni- 
 buses, Mountain Travel, Horse Hiring, 
 <5rv. v5rV. Seventeenth Edition, Small 
 %vo. 3-r. 6d. 
 
 The Wild Tribes of the 
 
 Soudan. 
 
 With a Description of the 
 Route from Wady Halfah to 
 Dongola and Berber. 
 
 By F. L. JAMES. Also a Chapter 
 on the Soudan. By Sir SAMUEL 
 BAKER. New Edition. With Map 
 and 21 Illustrations. Crown $vo. 'js.bd. 
 
 The "Rob Roy" on the 
 
 Jordan, Nile, Red Sea, Gennesareth, 
 &c. 
 
 A Canoe Cruise in Palestine, 
 Egypt, and the Waters of Damas- 
 cus. 
 
 By JOHN MACGREGOR. A 
 
 New and Revised Edition ivitJi Plates, 
 Maps, and Illustrations. Crown 8vo. 
 
 Dog-breaking. 
 
 THE MOST EXPEDITIOUS, CERTAIN, AND EASY METHOD, 
 
 WHETHER GREAT EXCELLENCE OR ONLY MEDIOCRITY BE REQUIRED : WITH ODDS 
 AND ENDS FOR THOSE WHO LOVE THE DOG AND THE GUN. 
 
 By General W. N. HUTCHINSON. 
 
 Eighth Edition. With 41 Illustrations. Crown 8vo, ~s. 6d. 
 * t * A SUMMARY OF INSTRUCTIONS c or Dog Breakers separate ', price ONE SHILLING. 
 
i6 
 
 Mr. Murray's List of New Publications. 
 
 Cfie 
 
 Comnuntarp* 
 
 A Commentary on the Holy Bible; 
 
 EXPLANATORY AND CRITICAL, WITH A REVISION 
 
 OF THE TRANSLATION. 
 BY THE BISHOPS AND CLERGY OF THE ANGLICAN CHURCH. 
 
 Edited by F. C. COOK, M.A., 
 
 Canon of Exeter, and Chaplain to the Queen. 
 
 The Old Testament. The New Testament. 
 
 Complete in 6 Vols. Medium 8vo. 
 
 6 15,. 
 
 30^. 
 
 Complete in 4 Vols. Medium 8v0. 
 4 W> 
 
 L. 
 
 I. SS. MATTHEW, MARK, LUKE. 
 
 II. ST. JOHN, ACTS OF THE APOSTLES. 
 
 20S. 
 
 III. ROMANS PHILEMON. 28^. 
 IV. HEBREWS REVELATION. 28s. 
 
 I. GENESIS DEUTERONOMY. 
 II. JOSHUA I. KINGS. 2os. 
 III. II. KINGS ESTHER. i6.r. 
 IV. JOB SONG OF SOLOMON. 24^. 
 V. ISAIAH, JEREMIAH, LAMENTA- 
 TIONS. 20S. 
 VI. EZEKIEL MALACHI. 25^-. 
 
 %* The following are sold separately: THE BOOK OF PSALMS and ST. JOHN'S 
 GOSPEL, IO.T. 6d. each. THE EPISTLE TO THE ROMANS, 7*. 6<t. 
 
 "We regard these volumes as a specimen ot 
 English scholarship of which we need not be 
 ashamed. The arrangement is admirable." 
 Nonconformist. 
 
 LIST OF WRITERS: 
 
 CANONS WESTCOTT, ESPIN, RAWLINSON, 
 COOK, ELLIOTT, KAY, DRAKE, GIF- 
 FORD, EVANS, WAITE. 
 
 PROFESSORS GANDELL, LUMBY, FULLER. 
 
 PREBENDARIES CURREY, HUXTABLE, 
 
 "There can be no question that the Speaker's 
 Commentary will supersede all older commentaries 
 for English readers, so far as an external commen- 
 tary is concerned." Guardian. 
 
 ARCHBISHOP OF YORK. 
 
 BISHOPS JACKSON, HAROLD BROWNE, 
 LORD ARTHUR HERVEY, BASIL 
 JONES, JACOBSON, & ALEXANDER. 
 
 DEANS MANSEL, JOHNSON, PLUMPTRE, 
 PAYNE SMITH, HOWSON, SCOTT. 
 
 ARCHDEACONS LEE, ROSE. 
 
 KINGSBURY, MEYRICK, WACF, AND 
 BULLOCK ; AND REVS. S. CLARK, 
 J. F. THRUPP, &c. 
 
 The Student's Edition of the Speaker's 
 Commentary. 
 
 Abridged and Edited by J. M. FULLER, M.A., 
 
 Professor of Ecclesiastical History, King's College, Londonj and Vicar of Bexley, Kent. 
 
 The Old Testament. 
 
 VOL. I. GENESIS DEUTERONOMY. 
 VOL. II. JOSHUA ESTHER. 
 
 The New Testament. 
 
 VOL. I. THE GOSPELS AND ACTS. 
 
 4 Vols. Crown 8vo. "js. 6d. each. 
 
 I VOL. III. JOB SONG OF SOLOMON. 
 
 1 VOL. IV. ISAIAH MALACHI. 
 
 2 Vols. Crown 8vo. "js. 6d, each. 
 
 VOL. II. THE EPISTLES AND REVELATION. 
 
 [/// October. 
 
 It is not surprising that it should have occurred to those interested in the Speaker's Commentary 
 that its voluminous matter might be made use of for the benefit of another and more numerous class of 
 readers. This has accordingly been done by the competent hands of Mr. J. M. P'uller, and with much 
 care and skill." Chitrch Quarterly Review, 
 
ALBEMARLE STREET, 
 July, 1886. 
 
 MR, MURRAY'S LIST 
 
 OF 
 
 FORTHCOMING WORKS 
 
 L(ife 
 
 of 
 
 WITH AN AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL CHAPTER. 
 Edited by his Son, FRANCIS DARWIN, F.R.S, 
 
 With Portrait and Woodcuts, 2 Vols. 8vo. 
 
 of ^ine Sit to tl\e 
 of L(ife. 
 
 By T. GAMBIER PARRY. 
 8m 
 
 CONTENTS. 
 
 1. THE PURPOSE AND PRACTICE OF FINE ART. 
 
 2. THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART TO COMMON LIFE. 
 
 3. THE MINISTRY OF FINE ART TO SPIRITUAL LIFE. 
 
 4. THE MINISTRY OF COLOUR TO SCULPTURE AND ARCHITECTURE. 
 
 5. THE HISTORY OF MOSAIC, (i) ANCIENT, (ii) CHRISTIAN. 
 
 6. THE ART AND THE ARTISTS OF GLASS PAINTING, ANCIENT AND MEDI/EVAL. 
 
 7. THE ADORNMENT OF SACRED BUILDINGS. 
 
 8. ART IN ARCHAEOLOGY. 
 
 9. THE BUILDERS AND BUILDINGS OF THE ABBEY OF ST. PETER, NOW THE 
 
 CATHEDRAL AT GLOUCESTER. 
 
i8 Mr. Murray's List of Forthcoming Works. 
 
 ,Mf. kywkfd'^ I<ettei% 
 
 BEING A SELECTION FROM THE 
 
 CORRESPONDENCE OF THE LATE ABRAHAM HAYWARD, Q.C 
 
 FROM 1834 TO 1884. 
 
 EDITED, WITH NOTES AND AN INTRODUCTORY ACCOUNT OF HIS EARLY LIFE, 
 By HENRY E. CARLISLE. 
 
 PRACTICAL NOTES ON ADMINISTRATIVE DIFFICULTIES. 
 By ROBERT KERR, 
 
 Author of " The English Gentleman's House," " A Small Country House," &c. 
 Crown Svv. 
 
 This is a handy book for Architects, Surveyors, Agents, Solicitors, Contractors, and the public 
 at large, dealing with the multifarious questions which arise in the transactions of building. 
 The contents are arranged under the following heads : i. Consultation and Evidence. 2. 
 Arbitration Cases. 3. Question of Structural Damage. 4. Easements. 5. Ancient Lights. 
 6. Questions of Support. 7. Sanitary Cases. 8. Leasehold Questions. 9. Questions of Valua- 
 tion. 10. Building Questions, n. The Building Act. 12. Architects' Disputes and Etiquette. 
 
 By DAVID MILNE, M.A. 
 
 The English language is composed of two elements, the Saxon and the Classical. Words of 
 Saxon origin such as hand, shoe, cat, cow, hard, high, go, get, &c., are familiar to us from 
 infancy and need no explanation. Nearly all our harder words come to us directly or 
 indirectly from Latin and Greek roots. The main purpose of this work is to provide for those 
 who either do not get a classical education, or who are mere beginners in the study of Greek 
 and Latin, an easy, interesting and instructive method of acquiring a thorough knowledge 
 of the derivatives from these languages common in English. 
 
 THE 
 
 oiree 
 
 By A. V. DICEY, M.A. 
 
 liversity of Oxf 
 Law of the Co 
 
 Croivn $z>0. 
 
 Vinerian Professor of Law in the University of Oxford, Fellow of All Souls' College. 
 Author of " The Law of the Constitution," &c. 
 
Mr. Murray's List of Forthcoming Works. 1 9 
 
 Sijftofy of tl\e limited 
 
 FROM THE FOUNDATION OF VIRGINIA TO THE 
 
 END OF THE WAR OF SECESSION AND THE 
 
 RECONSTRUCTION OF THE UNION. 
 
 By PERCY GREG, 
 
 Author of "Across the Zodiac," &c. 
 With Maps. 2 Vols. 8vo. 
 
 A COMPLETE 
 
 f)i6tio:qafy of 
 
 SETTING FORTH THE ORIGIN AND HISTORY OF GREEK AND LATIN HYMNODY 
 AND OF THE HYMNS IN COMMON USE IN GREAT BRITAIN AND AMERICA, 
 A DESCRIPTION OF THE MOST POPULAR HYMNALS, AND BIOGRAPHICAL 
 NOTICES OF THEIR AUTHORS AND TRANSLATORS. 
 
 BY VARIOUS WRITERS. 
 Edited by JOHN JULIAN, F.R.S.L., 
 
 Vicar of Wincobank, Sheffield. 
 
 1. THE HISTORY OF EVERY HYMN IN GENERAL USE, EMBRACING ORIGINALS AND TRANSLATIONS. 
 
 2. NOTICES OF AUTHORS, TRANSLATORS, AND COMPILERS OF HYMNS. 
 
 3. ENQUIRIES INTO ANONYMOUS AUTHORS OF HYMNS. 
 
 4. ORIGIN or HYMNS IN GREEK, LATIN, FRENCH, DANISH AND GERMAN, &c., FROM WHICH 
 
 ENGLISH TRANSLATIONS HAVE BEEN MADE. 
 
 5. THE SOURCES OF ENGLISH HYMNOLOGY. 
 
 One Volume. Medium 8v0. 
 Uniform with "DR. WM. SMITH'S DICTIONARIES." 
 
 - +4 - 
 
 of 
 
 By CHARLES DARWIN. 
 
 A Neiv Edition^ with the Author's Latest Corrections, 
 With Illustrations. Crown Svo. 
 
By JOHN w. BURGON, Dean of Chiches.er. 
 
 CONTENTS. 
 *. MARTIN 
 
 ^ HUGH JAMES 
 
 . EDWARD HAWKINS. 
 
 VTT 
 
 . 
 
 Christian. RICHARD LYNCH COTTON 
 P^ons Librarian. HENRY OCTAVIUS COXE. 
 FaitkfUl SUWard ' RICHARD GRE -^WELL. 
 f'^ Philos ^ HEN ^ LONGU.VILLE MANSER. 
 S lng le,mnded Bi sho p. WILLIAM JACOBSON. 
 Good Layman. CHARLES LONGUET HIGGINS. 
 
 WITH A COMMENTARY, EXPLANATORY AND CRITICAL. 
 
 BY VARIOUS WRITERS. 
 Edited by REV. HENRY WAGE, D.D 
 
 acher of Lincoln's !, Prebendary ^ ^ 
 
 2 Ft//r. Medium &vo 
 
 Introduction . 
 
 Esdras 
 
 Tobit 
 
 Judith 
 
 Esther 
 
 Wisdom 
 
 Ecclesiasticus 
 
 Baruch 
 
 Song- of Three Children 
 
 Susanna . 
 
 Bel and Dragon 
 
 Manasses 
 
 Maccabees 
 
 [UN/FORM 
 
 Rev. DR. SALMON. 
 
 Rev. J. H. LUPTON, Surmaster of St. Paul's School 
 
 Rev J. M .FULLER, Professor of Ecclesiastical 
 
 History m King's College, London. 
 Rev. C. J. BALL, Chaplain of Lincoln's Inn. 
 Rev. Professor FULLER. 
 Ven. Archdeacon FARRAR, D.D. 
 Rev. Dr. EDERSHEIM. 
 Ven. Archdeacon GIFFORD, D.D. 
 
 Rev. C. J. BALL. 
 
 Rev. Canon RAWLINSON. 
 
 THE SPEAKER'S COMMENTARY, "\ 
 
Mr, Miirray's List of Forthcoming Works. 21 
 
 Old 
 
 ECCLESIASTICAL, DECORATIVE, AND DOMESTIC; 
 ITS MAKERS AND MARKS. 
 
 WITH IMPROVED TABLES OF THE DATE-LETTERS USED IN ENGLAND, SCOTLAND, 
 
 AND IRELAND. 
 
 By WILFRED J. CRIPPS, M.A., F.S.A. 
 
 Third and Revised Edition, with Additional Illustrations. Medium 8z>0. 
 
 Sook'^ CVfcl\ idtior^fy: 
 
 A MANUAL OF REFERENCE FOR CLERGYMEN AND 
 
 STUDENTS. 
 
 By WALTER FARQUHAR HOOK, D.D. 
 
 Late Dean of Chichester. 
 A New Edition, Thoroughly Revised, and adapted to the Requirements of the Present Day. 
 
 Edited by 
 Rev. WALTER HOOK, and Rev. W. R. W. STEPHENS, 
 
 Rector of Porlock. Prebendary of Chichester. 
 
 One Volume. Svo. 
 
 THE EARLY MILITARY LIFE OF 
 
 WRITTEN BY HIMSELF FOR HIS CHILDREN. 
 Edited by his Son, General WM. O. E. NAPIER. 
 
 CHOICE OF A PROFESSION THREATENED INVASION OF ENGLAND NELSON 
 EXPEDITION TO SWEDEN CO.NVEN TION OF CINTRA BATTLE OF CORUNA PASSAGE 
 OF THE DOURO TORRES VEDRAS BUSACO PURSUIT OF MASSENA RETURN TO 
 ENGLAND MARRIAGE REJOINS 52ND BATTLE OF TOULOUSE APPOINTED TO THE 
 COMMAND OF 7isT LIGHT INFANTRY. 
 
 A Ne~jo and Cheaper Edition, with Addi. ions, Portrait. Post &vo. 
 
22 Mr. Murray s List of Forthcoming Works. 
 
 FOURTH AND CONCLUDING VOLUME OF 
 THE DICTIONARY OF 
 
 , I^itef ktufe, 
 
 DURING THE FIRST EIGHT CENTURIES. 
 Edited by WM. SMITH, D.C.L., and HENRY WAGE, D.D. 
 
 Medium Svo. 
 
 to ttie 
 
 LLANDAFF, ST. DAVID'S, BANGOR, AND ST. ASAPH. 
 
 A New and Thoroughly Revised Edition , with Illustrations. Crown 8vo. I $s. 
 
 fikqdbook- 
 
 THE ALPS OF SAVOY AND PIEDMONT, DAVOS, &c. 
 THE ITALIAN LAKES AND PART OF DAUPHIN. 
 
 A New and Thoroughly Revised Edition, ivilh Additions, Maps and Plans. In Two 
 
 Parts. Post Sz'O. los. 
 
 Pfactidkl fektife 
 
 By Sir E. d. REED, K.C.B., M.P., 
 
 Vice-President of the Institution of Naval Architects, &c. 
 Second and Revised Edition, with Plans and Woodcuts. Sw. 
 
 *** In this Edition the improvements in Naval Construction, consequent upon general 
 introduction of Steel, will be fully set forth. 
 
Mr. Murray's List of Forthcoming Works. 23 
 
 COMPLETION OF 
 
 r- \ / 
 
 tlje 
 
 ABRIDGED FROM "THE SPEAKER'S COMMENTARY." 
 
 VOL. II. THE EPISTLES AND REVELATION, 
 
 (Completing the work). 
 
 Edited by J. M. FULLER, M.A., 
 
 Vicar of Bexley, and Professor of Ecclesiastical Hist., King's Coll., London. 
 Crown 8vo. 7s. 6d. 
 
 L(0:qdo:q. 
 
 ITS HISTORY, ANTIQUARIAN AND MODERN. 
 
 FOUNDED ON 
 
 The "Handbook" by the late PETER CUNNINGHAM, F.S.A. 
 
 A NEW AND THOROUGHLY REVISED EDITION. 
 By JAMES THORNE, F.S.A., and H. B. WHEATLEY, F.S.A. 
 
 Library Edition on Laid Paper. 3 Vols. Royal 8vo. 
 
 of tl\e 
 
 FROM THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE EMPIRE TO THE 
 
 ACCESSION OF COMMODUS, A.D. 180. 
 
 Post Svo. 
 
 %* This work will take up the History at the point at which Dean Liddell leaves off, and 
 carry it down to the period at which Gibbon begins. 
 
24 Mr. Murray's List of Forthcoming Works. 
 
 of tl\e 
 of 
 
 By HENRY WAGE, D.D., 
 
 Principal of King's College, London. 
 
 Post 8vo. 
 
 " We are glad to hear that Mr. Wace is preparing for Mr. Murray's Student's Series a 
 Manual of the Evidences of Christianity, a work long wanted, which could not be placed in 
 better hands. " Quarterly Review. 
 
 f^iqdipik. Part in. 
 
 PROSE COMPOSITION. 
 
 CONTAINING A SYSTEMATIC COURSE OF EXERCISES ON THE 
 SYNTAX, WITH THE PRINCIPAL RULES OF SYNTAX. 
 
 I2tno. 
 
 CONTINUATION OF 
 
 Ekijttkl of 
 Sijftofy. 
 
 FROM 1717 TO THE PRESENT TIME. 
 By G. G. PERRY, M.A., 
 
 Rector of Waddington, and Canon of Lincoln. 
 Post %vo. 
 
 L;ife of 
 
 By W. J. COURTHOPE, M.A. 
 
 FORMING THE COMPLETING VOLUME OF 
 
 THE LIFE AND WORKS OF ALEXANDER POPE. 
 
 Edited by the Rev. WHITWELL ELWIN and W. J. COURTHOPE. 
 
 With an INDEX to the Whole Work. Sw. 
 
 fcRADBURY AOXKW, <K CO.. PRINTERS, WIUTEFR1ARS. 
 
 C 
 
THIS BOOK IS DUE ON THE LAST DATE 
 STAMPED BELOW 
 
 AN INITIAL FINE OF 25 CENTS 
 
 WILL BE ASSESSED FOR FAILURE TO RETURN 
 THIS BOOK ON THE DATE DUE. THE PENALTY 
 WILL INCREASE TO SO CENTS ON THE FOURTH 
 DAY AND TO $1.OO 'ON THE SEVENTH DAY 
 OVERDUE. 
 
 WOV 10 1 
 
 OV 17 1959 
 
 REC'D LD 
 
 MOV 2 11959 
 
 MAR 30 1953 LU 
 
 
 
 MOV 8 1953 
 
 18P S c'57LW 
 REC'D u*- 
 
 LD 21-100m-8,'34 
 
YC 22566 
 
 787708 
 
 o-> 
 
 UNIVERSITY OF CAUFORNIA LIBRARY