B H lag aso RELIM1NARY REPORT ON THE- FIRST SEASOtt'K WORK OP THE I OF YESSO, BENJAMIN SMITH LYMAN. TOKE1: i SHED BT Ti-' ; KAITAKI :lr> tSQ.^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ ^"V^VXVXVXVXXySXXy ^XV^XW^XXVx-^-V^^V^^ PRELIMINARY REPORT ON THE FIEST SEASON'S WOEK OF THE OF YESSO, BY BENJAMIN SMITH LYMAN. TOKEI: PUBLISHED BY THE KAITAKTJSHI, 1874. EARTH SCIENCES Preliminary Report on the FirstaSeason's Work of the Geological Survey of Yesso. PAGE. Nature of Survey Limits of Survey General Plan Fossils 4 Topographical Method "> Advantages for studying the Geology setting forth 6 Surveying required of the Geologist himself ... 6 Assistants 6 Their good behavior 7 General nature of their work ... 8 Benefit of the work to them 8 Instruments 9 Office work 9 Choice of points to Survey 10 Economy of Geological Surveys 10 History of Operations 11 'End of April to 1st July 11 1st July to beginning of October. . . 12 Beginning of October to middle -of November 13 Geology of the Region surveyed 15 Alluvium 15 New 15 Old 16 Volcanic-pebble Rocks 16 Volcanic Rocks 17 Toshibets Karaf to System 18 Coal Bearing Rocks 18 Hornmui Kavafto System' 19 Toshibets Kuril System 20 Economic Geology -" Coal .< .'. 20 Knytiuoma 20 Situation and Geology 20 Coal Beds 21 / Shipping 21 Tramway 21 Harbor Hornxnui 23 Situation and extent 23 Geology 23 II Coal Beds 24 Shipping 24 Kudow 25 Iron Sand 25 Yurap to Otoshibe 26 Kobui village 27 Southwesterly of Kobui 27 Shirikishinai 28 Komangadake 28 Whole amount 29 Sulphur o<) Esan 29 Tarumai . . 3} Iwaonobori . . 32 Nuburibets 32 Oi Lake 33 Kobui : 33 Whole Amount 34 Limestone 34 Garonosawa 34 Ishizaki 35 Kamiyunosawa 35 Washinoki 35 Traces elsewhere ... 36 Gold . ;;; 36 Toshibets . 3g Kudow 37 Esashi 33 Jimikishi 3g Other Rivers 38 Whole Amount 33 Rock Tar 33 Washinoki 39 Yamukushinai 49 Idzumisawa 41 Mineral Springs ... 41 Table \\\ '" 42 Summary . 4^ SHIBA, YEDO ; 25ra DECEMBER, 1873. To the Honorable K. KURODA, Jikuwan of the Kaitakuslii. SIR, My orders on leaving Sapporo were to report to yon fully at Yedo in regard to the past season's geological wjrk in Yesso. As it will take some time yet to work up the details and set them forth in maps and fnll reports, I hasten now after arriving at Yedo to give you a sketch of what has been done, its nature and its probable results. The work according to your instructions has been confined to the four south-westernmost provinces, Oshirna, Shiribets, Iburi and Ishcari, about one-third of the island. Indeed only the lower part of the pro- vince of Tshcari was visited, by the direction of Governor MA.TSMOTO ; since nothing of mineral value was reported from the upper Welters, and it would have taken three months or more to visit them, and there was little prospect of seeing much of geological interest without making, in addition, long and difficult excursions away from the almost unvarying alluvial plains that border the river itself. Within the region examined the aim has been to learn something definite in regard to a few important points at least, rather than even to go over much more ground and obtain only vague and wholly imperfect information ; since it is certain that the one method gives results ten. times more valuable than the other. All places, how- ever, where useful minerals were reported to exist have been visited, with scarcely a single exception, even though they often proved to be worthless either in quantity or quality ; and in passing from one point to another, an effort has been made to learn as far as possible the general geology of the region aside from its useful minerals merely. For this purpose also a number of fossils have been collected at several places ; and they will probably be useful not only in recognising rocks of the same age at other points in Yesso, but in determining their age as compared with the rocks of the rest of the world, and so possibly enabling conjectures to be formed sometimes of the quantity and quality of certain minerals they are likely to contain. A more minute study of the fossils is of great interest to paleontologists and of great value for the progress of learning, and I would urgently recom- mend placing the collection in the hands of somebody specially skilled in such matters, to be studied, described and published. As our libraries here in Japan are too defective in this branch of learning, to say nothing of the lack of a man well fitted for the study, it would probably be best to send the fossils abroad. There are yet too few fossils and too little prospect of large ad- ditions to the number hardly to "justify the employment hero for the present at least of a foreign paleontologist for Yesso alone. For the education of the youth of Japan, in general, it would however no doubt be de- sirable to have such a foreigner come here, and if one should come, these fossils might be turned over to him. In the survey, the American, Pennsylvanian topogra- phical method has been used ; for the creation and im- provement of which, not only in its working details on the small scale, but in the discovery of its. general laws on a large scale, geology owes so mucl} to Professor J. PETER LESLEY, of Philadelphia ; as I had the honour- of showing about two years, ago in a paper read to the American Institute of Mining Engineers. That method is indeed, as compared with others in geology, what quantitative analysis in chemistry is to mere qualitative analysis, and is no less important for theoretical purposes, than it is useful for practical ones. It strives to de- termine the extent and position of mineral deposits both underground and at their outcrop, by means of laying down on paper the shape of the surface of the ground (bf contour lines), as well as all the dips and strikes of the rocks that can be- observed ; so that the contour of any rock bed or vein may be drawn as it is even under- ground, and its contents above or below any given level or within any given limits rqay be calculated. In short, the surface and the deposit are geometrically constructed on paper. Of course, just as a chemical quantitative analysis may be more or less exact according to the difficulties of the case, so these geological surveys are only roughly exact when poor instruments are used or when the case is specially difficult; "but in almost any case are far better than merely qualitative observations alone. They are, in fact, as far as they go, definite and precise ; while ordinary geological surveying, so called, gives vague and conjectural results, just as tlie qual- itative analysis of a mineral enables the quantitative composition only to be guessed at. The topographical method moreover gives by its maj s very much the best means of compactly and clearly setting forth to others, observed geological facts and the conclusions arrived at. From such a representation of the facts, inferences can readily be drawn by others independently of the observer's opinions, confirming or opposing his judgment. The results of the season's work then will be not merely personal opinions, but facts so gathered and arranged that in future any other geologist can form his own conclusions from thrm with no need of revisiting the ground, unless a more d( tailed survey should be desired. A quantitative measurement naturally requires much more time and work than a mere qualitative one ; and that has hindered the more general adoption of LESLEY'S method in countries where time and work are -dear, in spite of its abundantly countervailing advantages ; and has even caused professed geologists to remain in ignorance of it and of its merits. There is perhaps 110 country in the world whose surface has already been topographically mapped minutely enough to answer in a detailed measurement of the rock deposits ; and only few countries which have been mapped well enough for somewhat more general geological purposes. It is there- fore necessary for the geologist to undertake the map- ping of the surface as well as of the underground features ; and he can do it better for his purpose than a mere topographer, because his work is guided by the geological structure. The assistants you kindly furnished me have added very much to the amount of work that could have been done by any one man ; even though they were young and inexperienced, and for the most part wholly ignorant at the outset, not only of geology but of surveying, drawing and even almost of common arithmetic. They have been very useful, partly because they have eagerly and rapidly learned what they could in a very short time ; airl partly because siich surveys require much work of a comparatively very simple character. Mr. HENRY S. MUNROE, the American assistant, was, by his former studies, much better fitted than the Japanese assistants for undertaking such work, although it was in great part practically new to him. He entered upon it with interest and intelligence, and has worked industri- ously and faithfully. He was especially useful at first in teaching the others drawing, and in the field has 'had charge of the details of the work of one-half of them and the whole' management of the gold surveys, under very general instructions. Of the Japanese assistants Mr. T. YAMAUCHI by his greater age and therefore more advanced education and matured judgment has easily stood at the head. Mr. H. SATOW, besides, his remark- able success as interpreter and his good service as an assistant in surveying, has with admirable zeal made for us an excellent botanical collection. My quartermaster since August, Mr. Y. AKIYAMA, from mere love of learning, frequently made himself very useful also in surveying though it was quite outside of his required duties to do so. He has therefore more than replaced the single assistant whom it was found necessary to dismiss. Mr. MUNROE'S quartermaster, Mr. S. ICHIGHI, has kindly improved the opportunity of his abundant leisure on the Toshibets by making an interesting col- lection of insects. All the assistants, (including besides those already named, Messrs. INAGAKI, KUWADA, MISAWA, TAKAHASHI, KADA, SAKA and SAITO), with a laudable desire .to do even more than their mere duty, and to help forward the interests of the survey and with eagerness for their own improvement have done more than could be reasonably exacted from them ; or, at any rate, in addition to bearing many hardships cheerfully, have worked harder both bodily and mentally than even laboring nien in Japan are commonly expected to work with their bodies alone. I have tried to turn the assistants' services to the best account by giving them the simpler but more time- taking work to do, while I myself (after they had had a few weeks' practice) visited a larger number of places more rapidly, and attended especially to purely geological observations, where either little other work was required, or Where it was done by the rest. Besides the aid they have given, notice should be taken of the benefit to them and to the empire of the knowledge these Japanese have gained by their season's labor. They are not only the first Japanese but the first Asiatics to undertake the study and practice of geology ; and although, the training of native geologists in India has been begun nearly at the same time, (or is soon to begin), I trust that ours will continue to take the lead, and that Japan will become in a few years independent of foreign countries in their profession. The young assistants have not only learned something of surveying and geology, but have in the field work, had under them each two or more laborers for rod-men and choppers, and have therefore gained a little" experience in the management of men a matter of very great consequence, if they are ever to be put in charge of important mining works. It is, however, a matter too apt to be wholly neglected in the training of the young men in all but the military schools of foreign countries, although quite as needful in civil or mining engineering or in agricul- tural affairs as in military. On account of the shortness of the time for prepara- tion and practice before going into the field, the Japanese Mssisfcants neither learned the use of the larger and more exact kinds of surveying instruments, nor were such instruments received in time and in numbers enough to be made much use of ; in fact only two came to hand in the course of the summer, and one of them in a poor condition. The surveys therefore were almost wholly made with small and in part badly made instruments, generally without the useful occasional checks of a larger one. Still, the surveys made this season were mostly of a somewhat preliminary nature and required less exact- ness than would be needed in the actual working of a mine ; and they are in that respect probably satisfactory enough for present purposes. The measurements were mostly made with prismatic compasses, hand levels, aneroids and pacing ; and owing to the partial balancing of the numerous small errors, sometimes less sometimes more than the exact truth, the errors of the results were far less than inexperienced surveyors would suppose. Between the exactness of such results and merely con- jectural mapping, by even the best head most familiar with the ground, there is simply no comparison whatever. For another season it would be very desirable to have at least a few somewhat larger, light, more correctly made instruments, by which with a stadia both compass or transit running and levelling and the measurement of distinces could be done almost or quite as rapidly as they could be with this year's instruments and much more exactly. Surveys with such instruments of the better kind would be satisfactory as far as they went for working maps in any possible future mining. It is a great advantage to have the first rough mapping of such surveys keep pace from day to day with the field work, but owing to the changeableness of the climate, 10 (which sometimes brought several rainy days together), and owing to the inexperience of the assistants in office work, so that it would have required more time, and for other reasons, it was on the whole thought advisable, this year at least, to leave much of even the rough mapping to be done in the winter after returning to Yedo. This arrangement has enabled somewhat more field-work to be done, and has made the employment of the laborers and some other matters rather more convenient ; but besides, the disadvantage with respect to the surveys themselves will lessen the time that the assistants can give to other practice and studies during the winter, and will therefore leave them next spring less well fitted than they otherwise would have been for another season's work. In determining the importance of the points to be more carefully surveyed, regard was had chiefly to their mining value ; for the importance of any one of them in respect to theoretical geology was sure to be great enough ; and it was likely that those that should be specially studied would throw such light on the general geology of the island as to make it comparatively easy to fill up the gaps with sufficient exactness by the time the whole of Yesso should have been gone over on the present system. In regard to the general geology of the field of this year's work some important points remain still undetermined, such as the relative age and the superficial extent of certain groups of rocks ; but some of them will perhaps be made known by the winter's mapping ; while others may be cleared up by the surveys of other parts of the island, or may possibly require special examination at some future time. Many places were visited where valuable minerals had been supposed to exist, but where they proved to be deficient either in quantity or in quality. Indeed, on 11 the island of Yesso as almost everywhere else the chief directly practical benefit of a geological survey is far more in saving the expense of foolish outlay in mining worthless deposits than even in guiding productive work, and much money would have already been saved in Yesso if competent men had long ago been employed to examine the deposits properly, and authoritatively dis- courage the working of mines whose ruins now remain MS marks of the hopefulness of human nature. This hopefulness here, as in other countries, leads most men to the ruinous belief that the part of a deposit that is hidden deep within the earth, is better than the part exposed near the surface ; so that good deposits are sure to be worked however unskilfully even without the re- commendation of a geologist ; while bad ones are apt also to be tried until his advice puts an end to further waste of money. It would be very interesting if the millions wasted all over the world in foolish mining that would have been prevented by a good geological examination could be compared on the one hand with the perhaps hardly greater profits of successful mining, and on the other with the relatively trifling cost of such a survey. On coming to Yesso towards the end of April we went at once to -Sapporo according to the instructions given at Yedo, expecting to begin at that time the survey of the country to the north, hitherto geologically unexplored. But owing to the reported high stage of the Ishcari Hiver we were directed to go first southward for forty or fifty days to the coal mines at Kayanoma and its neigh- borhood. After finishing the coal survey, I sent Messrs. MQNBOE, SATOW, INAGAKI, MISAWA, KADA and SAKA still further southward to make a somewhat detailed survey of the Toshibets gold region, against my visit t,here in September, and then to go on towards Hakodate ; as 12 they afterwards did, making rapid surveys of the small gold regions near Kudow and Esashi, and of the lead mines at Yurap. The other five assistants and myself arrived again in Sapporo at the end of ahout fifty days having visited the gypsum at Yunai in the Raiden mountain (apparently too poor to work) ; the zinc blende, galena and copper pyrites vein near Yudomari and Sak- kadzuki (quite too thin to work) ; and the place of the supposed traces of coal at Furubira (merely a lump of coal that had been brought, no doubt, by some boat or by the hand of a mail, and dropped on the river shore). On the way, moreover, according to instructions, we went quite around the Shakotan peninsula, without how- ever hearing of any minerals of economical importance ; though we had an interesting view of the rocks as we passed along, sometimes by land where there were roads, at other times by sea. After a week of office work and preparation we set out from Sapporo for the coal field On the Horumui, a branch of the Ishcari ; from a rapid survey of which we returned to Sapporo in just a month, after many unexpected delays occasioned by the weather and other causes beyond my control. From Sapporo I sent Mr. YAMAUCHI and the three other assistants then left with me, to Horikap to make a small addition t6 the Kayanoma survey, against my revisiting that place in company with General CAPRON ; and myself visited the blende,, galena, pyrites and or- piment place (worthless as it turned out) near the Jozan hot-springs on the upper waters of the Toyahira ; and afterwards according to instructions, accompanied General OAPKOtf to the mouth of the Ishcari, to Tobets, and then to Iwanai, Horikap and Kayanoina, on the way visiting the pyrites place near Rubeshibe, which proved however to be quite insignificant. After inspecting the work of the four assistants at Horikap and making a survey of 13 the Chatsunai and Stiibui harbors and a visit of explora- tion across the mountain to the Furubira River, I took the assistants to the Ivvaonobori Sulphur place, and made with their help a hasty survey of it. From there I sent them to begin surveys at Yamukushinai and Washinoki ; while with Mr. AKIYAMA I went myself across the Shiri- bets valley to Usu on the east coast, and visited the sulphur place there, which turned out to be wholly un- important. We went thence still further north-eastward along the coast to the sulphur place at Nuburibets hot-spring, and then to the one on the top of Tai*umai volcano. Returning south-westward we visited some newly discovered Ores of zinc, lead arid copper on the Horobets, and found them too poor to work ; and also investigated a reported discovery of coal at the mouth of the Washibets near Mororan ; but it proved to be several lumps of coal that had been washed ashore from a wrecked steanier. Then following the sea shore as far as Kunnui, we went to the gold mines on the Toshibets ; but as Mr. MUNKOE had just gone with his party to the Kudow gold field and by some mistake had left none of his mapping behind and no special information in regard to the surveys he had made, after a day or two of examination of the gold washings we went to Yamuku- shinai. Here with the help of the rough mapping of Mi; YAMAUCHI'S party the oil place and the iron ore sand of the beach were examined and the daily yield of oil was measured. Fronl Yamukushinai Mr. AKIYAMA and I made a short trip to the old lead mines of Yurap, and left somewhat detailed instructions in regard the survey to be made there by Mr. MUNROE and his party. Thence we went to Washinoki, visiting the Bord and Kusuri hot-springs while passing Ofcosliibe. At Washinoki, the oil place was visited rtn