Ex Lions '.. K. OGDEN DISCOURSES ON SPECIAL OCCASIONS, BY THE LATE REV. ROBERT S. M'ALL, LL.D., A SKETCH OF HIS LIFE AND CHARACTER, REV. RALPH WARDLAW, D.D. VOLUME I. LONDON: JACKSON AND WALFORD, 18, ST. PAUL'S CHURCHYARD. 1840. GLASGOW : FULLARTON AND CO., PRINTERS, VII.LAFIELD. CONTENTS OF VOL. I. Page SKETCH OF LIFE AND CHARACTER. v PREFATORY NOTICES clxxxix DISCOURSE I. A FUNERAL SERMON ON THE DEATH OF THE REV. WILLIAM ROBY, MANCHESTER. Luke xii. 42 44. " Who then is that faithful and wise steward, whom his lord shall make ruler over his household, to give them their portion of meat in due season ? Blessed is that servant, whom his lord, when he cometh, shall find so doing. Of a truth, I say unto you, that he will make him ruler over all that he hath." 3 Duties. DISCOURSE II. AN ADDRESS, DELIVERED ON OCCASION OF THE PRIVATE ANNUAL MEETING OF MINISTERS, FROM LANCASHIRE AND NEIGHBOURING COUNTIES, FOR PURPOSES OF SOCIAL DEVOTION AND MUTUAL BENEFIT. . . 45 Discourses on tftc Opening of (Tiinpds. DISCOURSE III. DELIVERED AT THE OPENING OF BELGRADE CHAPEL, LEEDS. Isaiah Ix. 13. " I will make the place of my feet glorious." . . 87 DISCOURSE IV. DELIVERED AT THE OPENING OF EVERTON CRESCENT CHAPEL, LIVERPOOL. 1 Cor. i. 23, 24. " We preach Christ crucified, unto the Jews a stumbling-block, and unto the Greeks foolishness; but unto them which are called, both Jews and Greeks, Christ the power of God, and the wisdom of God." 145 1 1276-11 IV CON1 KM i B. DISCOURSE V. Page DELIVERED AT THE REOPENING OF QUEEN STREET CHAPEL, CHESTER. Rev. xxi. 3. " And I heard a great voice out of heaven, saying, Be- hold, the tabernacle of God is with men." .... 201 Ordination jerr.btr.r0.' DISCOURSE VI. INTRODUCTORY DISCOURSE AT THE ORDINATION OF THE REV. THOMAS PARRY OVER THE CONGREGATIONAL CHURCH IN BLACKBURN, LANCASHIRE 247 DISCOURSE VII. INTRODUCTORY DISCOURSE AT THE ORDINATION OF THE REV. MR. SUNDERLAND AT BURY, LANCASHIRE Exod. xii. 26. " What mean ye by this service?" .... 299 DISCOURSE VIII. CHARGE ADDRESSED TO THE REV. JOHN ELY ON HIS REMOVAL FROM ROCHDALE TO SALEM CHAPEL, LEEDS Rom. xi. 13. " I magnify mine office." 341 DISCOURSE IX. CHARGE ADDRESSED TO THE REV. W. H. STOWELL, ON HIS SETTLE- MENT AS PASTOR OF THE CHURCH, AND THEOLOGICAL TUTOR OF THE COLLEGE, AT ROTHERHAM Arts xx. 24. " That I might finish my course with joy." . . 393 SKETCH OF THE LIFE AND CHARACTER OF THE LATE REV. DR. M'ALL NEVER was request more unanticipated than the one which, in editing these Volumes, and in prefixing to them a sketch of the life and character of their lamented Author, I now fulfil. By the Trustees and relatives of the deceased, how- ever, the request was presented in such a manner that I could not find in my heart to resist it. I use this phrase, as emphatically expressing the real state of the case. Had I consulted only my judgment, I might have met the proposal with objections of no mean strength. There were those who, having enjoyed long and intimate acquaintance with my departed friend, and, through this intimacy, multiplied and varied opportunities of marking and duly appreciating the peculiarities of his personal and official character, would, on this as well as on other grounds, have been more compe- tent for the interesting task; and, if it was requisite that one who was himself so justly eminent should be introduced at all otherwise than by the simple presentation to the public of some of the products of his own powerful, accomplished, and holy mind would have done it with more appropriate- ness, efficiency, and grace. But there are occasions, when a man must yield to the judgment of others, rather than rest upon his own ; and there will be no great difficulty in obtain- ing his acquiescence, when, how much soever his judgment vi LIFE AND CHARACTER OF may misgive him, his heart is on the side of the solicitation. This was pre-eminently the case. The memory of such a friend not admired only and venerated, but embalmed in all my affections; the wishes of those relatives, and fellow- Christians, to whom, as well as to myself, he was dear; the assurance given me of their unanimous conviction that, in presenting the request, they were doing what would have been most in harmony with his own wishes; the pleasure I experienced in the thought, let the reader ascribe it to what motive he will, of having my own name associated with his, in a memorial rendered permanent by the intrinsic excel- lence of those " remains" of which it was to be my duty to superintend the publication; and the benefit I expected to derive from the closer study of such a character, by which my own mind and heart might be brought into more intimate and influential contact with those qualities which constituted its genuine worth, and gave it its undisputed claim to admi- ration and love: all contributed to induce my compliance. I had counted it an honour, and felt it a happiness, during his life, to possess the affectionate confidence of such a mind ; and it was like a prolongation of the honour and the hap- piness, to be permitted thus to associate myself with him in that posthumous life which his character and writings will give him on earth; thus preventing the feeling of entire dis- ruption, and forming a kind of intermediate stage between his society in this world and the everlasting union of heaven. I must confess, however, that the task was undertaken with too little consideration of its sacred responsibility, and of the difficulties attendant upon its creditable execution One of these difficulties has arisen from the fact of the lamented subject of this memoir having, immediately before his death, laid his nearest relatives under an interdict, and exacted from them a corresponding promise, that they would furnish no materials for a LIFE of him. The cause or causes for his taking this step may be found in certain features of his character, which are thus, at the very outset, forced upon our notice. It did not arise merely from a general dislike though that, there is reason to believe, was not small of the THE HEV. DR. M C II AK.U TEU OF termination and disclosure, and the avowed surrender of the heart to God. It is rather the season of " first love" than of first impression. There may be a series of successive im- pulses, of which the subject of them himself is hardly con- scious, and which do not appear to the observation of others, which yet have been divine, and have contributed to prepare the heart for the successful influence of that by which it is ultimately won. This may at times be the case even with persons advanced in life, and hardened in worldliness and sin. By a succession of providential incidents, by the steady consistency, silently watched, of some religious friend, by " words spoken in season," by a thousand circumstances, each in itself of a power hardly perceptible, there may be a conviction long and gradually working its way in the mind, an influence, counteractive of the previous domination of evil, slowly but surely insinuating itself into the conscience, by which the Spirit of God, in his own mysterious way, is leading on to a final result, preparing for the still reserved impulse, that is finally to loosen the heart from the last bond that continued to hold it, and effect its avowed separation from the world, and subjugation to God. By how many unseen and long-continued physical agencies, by how many winters' frosts and summers' thaws, how many secret oozings and drippings, how many gradually yielding fragments and slowly opening fissures, is the mountain avalanche brought to that awful poise, which the impulse of a breath may disturb, and send it thundering to the plain ! And that which is the occasional experience of the oldest and most confirmed world- ling, there is reason to believe is almost invariably the fact in the early conversion of such as have been brought up under Christian instruction. Not that I would place the workings of the infant mind on a par with those of the man of maturity, or bring upon myself the charge of the bathos by applying to the former the image I have taken from one of Nature's most magnificent and tremendous scenes. All that I mean U. that when, as in the present instance, a child of eight years, that has been religiously educated, is said to be " first affected with divine things" under a particular sermon, that THE REV. DR. M given. THE REV. DR. M*ALL. divine authority of the sacred oracles, and had strongly tempted him, though happily without final success, to enrol himself among the esprits forts of " science falsely so called," and to prefer a place among the "wise and prudent" to one among the " babes in Christ." Why should we shrink why should even those, to whom his memory is dearest, shrink from such a conclusion ? I concur in the sentiment of my friend Dr. Collyer, that we owe it to the grace of God, instead of covering, to note, whether in ourselves or in others, such circumstances as contribute to the more signal manifestation of its power and riches; and that we owe it also to truth, instead of being backward to admit such temporary aberrations as may seem to cast a shade over the radiance of hallowed names, to give it, with cheerfulness, all the advantage arising from the greater weight and satisfac- toriness of the testimony subsequently borne to it by restored and established faith. There are two or three additional particulars which seem deserving of notice, as to the fact of his sceptical state of mmd, and as to the means of his recovery. With regard to the former, there is, in the first place, a passage in a letter of his own to Dr. Collyer, dated from the Rev. Mr. Brotherston's, Dysart, July 14th, 1813, that is, it would appear, after the close of his third session in Edin- burgh, which, although the terms of it are general, I can- not resist interpreting as, to a certain degree at least, the record of his own experience, and as thus furnishing a key to the mystery of the workings of his mind at this interest- ing crisis. The letter is written after the time when, ac- cording to Mr. Brotherston's statement, his mind had re- covered from its distressing scepticism, and was again settled in the faith ; and it is throughout distinguished by his cha- racteristic ease and even playfulness. A few sentences preceding the passage to which I have referred, and intro- ductory to it, may be extracted, as affording the reader information of the particular descriptions of reading and study which were most in favour with him at that time : "I was lately reading the Lectures on Scripture Facts; 1 LIKE AND CHARACTER OF " you may be sure, not without great satisfaction. As a " proof how much I was interested in them, I will, when I " see you, show you a long list of the reflections which " occupied my attention, and the few inaccuracies which I " thought might be easily corrected. These are the books I " dwell on with delight. In them, more than my judgment " is interested. I love literature better than science in every " shape : but when that literature is sanctified by being 44 consecrated to divine subjects, I then feel as though I " could not pollute my eyes again by casting them on a sci- " entific performance. Some men in Edinburgh wonder that " I don't like medicine, and botany, and chemistry, and that ' a mind which they suppose to be somewhat inquisitive and " tolerably informed, should witness without ecstasy the bril- 4 ' liant discoveries which philosophers are making on rela- " tive forces, elective attractions, definite proportions, and " all the other marvels of the age ; and that, while they " are reading of the researches of Davy, and Berzelius, " and the whole tribe of philosophers, (that is, modern great " men,) I am busied in following the footsteps of a Cowper 44 through this valley of tears, or bending over the record " he has given of the sublimest feelings in songs which thrill " every chord of the heart. Let them wonder. If a man " goes about to be astonished, he will find enough to be sur- " prised at. I don't like science, nor Scotland, after all. " Both are good in their places; but literature, religion, and 44 Blackheath,* suit my palate better. Is it not strange, " that I should cry down science, and speak so lightly of my " old friend Scotland, and particularly my Alma Mater Edin- 44 burgh ? Strange as it is, I can't help it. I am tired of ** the one; three years is long enough to answer all that pur- " pose : and of the other, I am very doubtful as to the mo- " ral and religious tendency. I find and can account for it " too that where those studies called, as a whole, by the " name of science, are prosecuted (as they are in the present 44 day from the college to the drawing-room) to the exclusion * The rc&idcnce of the friend he was addressing. C THE REV. DR. M ( ALL. li of elegant literature, such as language, history, and po- etry, there, I say, will the reverence of God, and obe- " dience to his gospel, and belief in his revelation, propor- " tionally decline; and that, for two great reasons: because " they pretend to account for every thing, and therefore " render the interference of a superior power the less essential. " One of those luminaries of the age, called chemists, was " puzzled the other day to contradict (so plain was the testi- " mony in its favour) the fact of Christ's raising the dead. " The gentleman was not caught yet ' You know,' says " he, ' that Galvanism can do very strange things ; it can " make a man's muscles move after his head is off: how do " you know but, in the progress of discovery, I shall one day " restore one positively dead to the use of his limbs and " senses?' This is the first ' because: now for the second. " Here it is, then. Those studies, called by the name of " science, are conversant only with things: the classification " of dismembered and dissected flowers, the operation of a " certain specific in a certain disorder, the relation of this " same disorder to others of its genus, and its arrangement " in its proper species, the effect of a certain acid upon a " certain solid substance, and their mutual relation ; these " constitute the whole of their inquiries. I might appeal to " experience ; and you see that men of science too often act " according to this rule. The elements of nature they re- " gard only as inert substances obeying certain laws, which " they call ' laws of nature.' The fearful and wonderful " frame of man they look upon only as a machine, in which " the parts actuate each other to produce that infinite variety " of effects, which engage the understanding, and delight the " eye. They are satisfied when they have traced the course " of an artery, or estimated the force of a muscle. They see " that the fact is so and there is an end. They personify " they deify nature, even till one is tired of the very "name: * nature does nothing in vain' 'this is a wise " provision of nature' 'nature is sparing of her resources.' " Thus they abuse our ears, till the absolute existence of " God is forgotten, except when they bring it to remem- Hi LIFE AND CHARACTER OF " brance by their profane but fashionable imprecations. Am " I wrong, then, in preferring literature to science, and la- " menting that the latter is the rage of the day? See the " converse of the picture. When a man devotes his time to " the cultivation of languages, or poetry, or history, or mo- " ral philosophy ; he learns from tongues that they may all " be reduced to one original, and meets perpetually with con- " firmations, both written and traditional, of the truth of " religion. He finds everywhere traces of a deluge, of the " fall, of the evil of sin, of a God, an atonement, and a fu- " ture world. He learns from history the mental character " of man ; sees the operations of the human mind under all " the variety of circumstances and countries ; and, if he be " inclined to investigate the causes of human actions, will " often, from the unanticipated and surprising results of the " most trifling event, be led to feel and to acknowledge the " secret workings of a hidden but almighty agent Poetry " derives her richest charms from depicting his nature, and " her sublimest flights are directed toward his throne. Moral " philosophy, like her, is engaged by researches into this " great mystery, by enforcing our relation to him, the duties " it involves, and those finest feelings of the human heart " which she stamps with the seal of virtue and happiness. " I beg pardon for this long and tiresome sermon I have " never preached since I have been in Scotland; although, " like you, I have been asked to officiate in several pulpits, " but refused on account of the risk incurred by the worthy " clergymen. He in whose house I write this is one of the " most evangelical and popular preachers in the church. I " long to stand again in the pulpit, and look forward with " great eagerness to coming to London on that account. " My views have become far more evangelical since I saw " you last; and I am more determined to preach Christ cruci- " fied as the only rock of salvation, as ' my Lord and my " God.' I fear I shall have to struggle with strong preju- " dices from the suspicion 9f heterodoxy. I look to God "and conscience for my defence; and the testimony of my " respected friends will do much. Doctor Collyer must not THE REV. DR. M C ALL. liii " refuse his support. I think he will rejoice in the change " in the feelings of his friend." Sincerely and ardently was this joy experienced by the friend to whom he thus wrote, and by many more friends than him. It was a happy change. If he had now become " far more evangelical," however, than when, three years before, he had parted from that friend, there seems good ground for believing that he had, in the first instance, become much less so. Whether, like Mr. Hall, he had ever become a materialist, does not appear. But it is not improbable, that he had imbibed somewhat, though how largely cannot be determined, of the spirit of science, pursued on the prin- ciples and in the manner he so truly describes as character- izing too many of its most eminent votaries; that he had become the subject of its anti-spiritual tendencies, and of that insidiously sapping process by which it has so often, to a greater or less extent, undermined, not only the firmness of faith in the essential verities of the Gospel, but the strength of reliance on the evidences of divine revelation. It is likely that from some such experience arose the strong expression above quoted of his disrelish of science and his preference of literature ; in which, it must have struck the reader, he hardly holds the balance fairly between the two, the evils imputed to the one being such as arise from the abuse of it, and the beneficial effects ascribed to the other, from its appropriate use. No man better understood than he, nor could any one more ably illustrate or more eloquently enforce, the legitimate tendencies of science; its tendencies, when rightly used, when wrested from atheistical NATURE, and consecrated to " NATURE'S GOD." But his spirit was at this time, it may be supposed, smarting from the remembrance of its recent deleterious influence, while pursued under the tutorage of undevout men men of nature, not of God, and in associa- tion with fellow-students, too many of them of kindred char- acter This was his time of high-minded speculation, during which, in the language of Asaph, " his feet were almost gone, his steps had well nigh slipped." This was the period referred to in his dying moments, when, anxious to 9 liv LIFE AND CHARACTER OF assure men both of literature and science that the testimony he then bore to the cross was not the testimony of a visionary or educational enthusiast, but of one who had thought for himself, and knew his ground, he used the terms to which Dr. Collyer alludes, and which will be noticed in their pro- per place. And in further evidence of the distressing scepti- cism of his mind during this period, without endeavouring to determine to what proportion it extended of his stay in Edinburgh, I may refer to an expression of his own, used by him in the outline of his religious history embodied in the confession of faith delivered at his ordination, or induc- tion, at Manchester; only premising that from lips charac- terized, as his w r ould eminently be on such an occasion, by a discreet abstinence from prosing detail, brief notices are to be interpreted on the principle of multum in parvo. He spoke, on that occasion, of " doubts once productive of un- speakable anguish gradually yielding to increasing clearness of evidence." He had never remitted his investigations. His mind was of too inquisitive a character to admit of that ; while it was too exquisitely sensitive, to harbour doubts on subjects which his sound judgment pronounced of such infinite importance, without an agonizing conflict The result was happy. A brighter day returned, of which the dawning and growing light dispelled the clouds that had hung so densely and heavily over his soul. And he then " went on his way rejoicing;" with augmented pleasure in the exercises of devotion, and in the paths of faith and obe- dience. So that, when he left the university to return home, it was, as his letter shows, and his subsequent statements certified, with a firmer determination than ever to devote himself, unreservedly and for life, to the service of God in the gospel of his Son. The reader will have observed the state of his feelings in reference to the ministry, as indicated by his startling exclamation when walking on the sea-beach with Mr. Bro- therston, on the supposition being made of his yet engaging in it. And yet the letter, written evidently during the same visit to Dysart, anticipates the employment with de- THE REV. DR. M'ALL. lv light. His extremely susceptible temperament made him ever apt to use superlatives, giving vehement utterance to vehement emotions, arising from some strongly-impressed view of a particular subject at the moment, and producing an apparent incongruity with other expressions, used perhaps at no distant interval, when the same subject presented itself under a different aspect, or to the mind in a different mood. He might, I am satisfied, be quite conscious of the change in his views and feelings, and be cherishing the desire to be again employed in the sacred work of the ministry, even at the time when, under an overpowering impression of its very sacredness and of his own consequent unworthiness, he ex- claimed with such energy " Impossible ! my heart is enough to pollute that ocean !" It is not the man in whom there is least sin that will think least of it. The holier the heart in which sin remains, the more intense will be the abhorrence of it, and the deeper the self-loathing on account of it. It is the man in whom sin abounds and reigns, whose thoughts of it will be lightest. So that we should form a very false estimate of a believer's real character, were we to interpret with a literal strictness what he says of himself, when groan- ing under a sense of his remaining corruption, and longing and struggling to be free. We should even, in such cases, be nearer to the truth, were we to interpret by the rule of contrary. And this I take to be the true secret of the strong expressions used by Paul respecting himself " The law is spiritual; but I am carnal, sold under sin O wretched man that I am ! who shall deliver me from the body of this death?" With regard to the means by which this favourable change was wrought in Mr. M' All's mind, forming an epoch in his history of which the results bore relation not to time alone but to eternity, and which, therefore, in the estimate of the Christian, must ever appear beyond comparison the most important, it is not easy to speak with certainty Amidst the doubts, whatever was their nature and extent, to which he himself refers, there was still, all the while, I cannot but believe, within his own bosom, a redeeming influence, a Ivi LIFE AND CHARACTER OF germ of sound principle, retaining its vitality, how much so- ever it might at times appear in danger of extinction. And the influences by which the life of this germ was at length fully recovered, and strengthened to renewed growth and productiveness, appear to have been various They were internal as well as external. He was not one of those, of whom, alas! there are so many, whose vicious and libertine propensities impart a false colouring to the pretensions, and a factitious strength to the arguments, of irreligion. His were rather the " lusts of the mind." With the conscious powers of a lofty, penetrating, and excursive intellect, he was determined to take nothing for granted, but to search and sift the evidence of every alleged fact and of every re- ceived doctrine. He scorned the thought of continuing to hold for truth what he had not fully examined, what he had rather adopted from others than embraced for himself, and what, when investigated, might be found to rest on no satisfactory proofs, but to have been, to those from whom he had received it as well as to himself, the object of a merely traditionary attachment, or educational prejudice. But amidst all his inquisitive speculations, there was a deep-seated in- fluence of early piety that never left his heart. He had still the secret "witness in himself," in his conscience and in his affections, of the divine excellence of the principles in which he had been trained. His was no cold heartless scep- ticism; it was rather the scepticism of solicitude after truth, maintaining doubt till ground was seen for faith, and equally fearful of retaining or of embracing what was not accredited by sufficient evidence. Such a mind as his was capable of discerning, almost by intuition, the weak points of any argu- ment, of detecting the hidden sophistry of the plausible, and exposing to merited scorn the shallowness of pretended depth : and, his judgment not being warped by the power of worldly and vicious propensities, while the pride of intellectual inde- pendence was silently counterworked by the latent spirit of early reverence for all that is sacred, we do not marvel at the ultimately happy result. The Spirit of God, the Spirit of light, and peace, and love, was brooding over the troubled THE REV. DR. M'ALL. Ivii waves of that mental conflict, controlling their turbulence, and gradually inducing a settled and permanent rest. While he was conscious to himself of the salutary influence, on the moral feelings and habits, of those religious principles in which he had been brought up, he had opportunity to wit- ness the opposite effects of the principles of infidelity on the characters of many of his associates in medical and scientific study, by whose libertinism he could not fail to be revolted, and swayed by the contrast to the side of truth. The cir- cumstance, alluded to by Mr. Brotherston, of the remarkable change on such a man as Dr. Chalmers, might tell also with favourable influence on the course of his inquiries. The pre- sent correspondence of parents and others might co-operate with the recollections of early piety in inclining his heart to God. The judicious conversation and discreetly directed influence of his friend the minister of Dysart, evidently con- tributed not a little to allay prejudice and help forward con- viction. Then, in a state of health naturally conducive to serious reflection, and in circumstances such as on a mind so susceptibly alive as his to the beauties and sublimities of nature were eminently fitted to impress the sentiments of de- votion amid the wild, the lovely, and the grand of Highland scenery, where his spirit would melt and swell alternately, and his eye, swimming in ecstasy, " Look through Nature up to Nature's God," came the perusal of the volume on " Scripture Facts," thus bringing before him at once the God of nature and the God of revelation with abundant evidence of their identity, carry- ing increase of conviction to his understanding and of right feeling to his heart. I cannot wonder at my friend Dr. Collyer delighting to dwell on what could not fail to com- municate the liveliest satisfaction to his heart the thought of any production of his having contributed to the settlement of such a mind. But he must not claim a monopoly of this pleasure. He must share it with other instruments. Some have already been noticed. In addition to these, the Rev. Samuel Thodey of Cambridge mentions Mr. Hall as having, Iviii LIFE AND CHARACTER OF according to Mr. M' All's own statements, more perhaps than any other then living writer, given his conflicting mind satis- faction. Referring to certain letters of Mr. M'All to him- self (which I regret not having been able to procure, as they are described to have been " of a highly interesting charac- ter" and to have "detailed some impressive circumstances con- " nected with his own religious history") he says "Among " other things he particularly specified the great obligation " he had been under to the writings of Robert Hall, con- " sidering that some of the best and most powerful impres- " sions upon his mind, in favour of revealed religion, he owed " to a deep and incessant study of the productions of that " great man." And for myself, I am, as a biographer, bound in fidelity to record the fact, of which I need not say with what pleasure I had the assurance from his own lips, that the " Discourses on the Principal Points of the Socinian Controversy" came opportunely to his hands during the same interesting period, and had a providential share in confirming his faith of the great essential truths of the Gospel It is a duty to mark these things. Not that in themselves they were necessary to the result. The inward reflections and arguings of such a mind, furnished from its own resources, and unaided save by the word and Spirit of God, might have led to the same blessed issue. But when Divine Providence is pleased to employ extraneous instrumentality, even how inferior soever the agency to the mind on which it operates, it becomes us humbly and gratefully to acknowledge it. In the narrative of Mr. Brotherston, mention is made, in very plain terms, of young M' All's " contempt" of Mr. Spencer. If, under the influence of an excessive admiration of intellect and genius, and a consciousness of his own superior endow- ments, both natural to youth, he did, at that early period, indulge a somewhat disdainful feeling towards his inferior competitors, never was wrong more thoroughly atoned for than in the present instance : and I give this prominence to the circumstance, because it bears directly upon character, and affords an interesting illustration of the change in his sentiments and feelings, when, after having passed through THE REV. DR. M ALL. lix the deep mental conflicts to which we have been adverting, his " soul returned unto its rest," and settled in the humble faith of the gospel. He then saw both himself and others in a different light. He had received a stronger impression of the value of " the simplicity that is in Christ," of that divine illumination, which is withheld from " the wise and prudent," and vouchsafed to " babes," of the superior excel- lence and desirableness of moral and spiritual qualifications to all that is merely intellectual, and of the enviableness of such endowments as, though of humbler pretension in regard to all that confers literary and scientific eminence, fit their possessor officially for a more than ordinary measure of use- fulness, and personally for converse with God and for the kingdom of Heaven. Every emotion of disdain then gave place to humble and affectionate admiration of that lamented youth, whom, how far soever his inferior in genius and mental capacity, it pleased the Head of the Church so signally to qualify for early service, so remarkably to honour with suc- cess, and so mysteriously to remove at the very outset of a career so full of promise. The Lines written on a blank leaf of Dr. Raffles's Life of Spencer I should have thrown into a note below, had it not been that I regard them as a touching and pleasing memorial of the important change that had passed upon the character of his own mind. On this account I introduce them here. The date is " Dysart, June 6th, 1813." "LINES WRITTEN BY ONE OF MR. SPENCER'S FELLOW-STUDENTS ON READING A COPY OF HIS * LIFE.' ' " WAIT the great Teacher Death" the Christian says " And wisely says ; for Death alone can teach Unnumber'd truths so darkly imaged here. How does his arm that awful cloud withdraw That on the chambers of the grave is hung ! To what wild realms of unimagined woe, What shapes of horror, bear the guilty soul, And plunge it in destruction ! What a scene Shall Death unfold to the admiring eye Of the rapt spirit, on the farthest verge Lc LIFE AND CHARACTER OF " Where Jordan rolls his dim-disco ver'd stream ! " Regions of bliss, and armies of the sky, " Immortal crowns, and flowers that never fade, " Heaven's throne of light eternal, and the man " That bled on Calvary, robed in beams divine ! " Such, SPENCER ! such the fair unbounded view " Burst in full brightness on thy ravish'd sight ! " So, when the deepest shades of midnight fall, " Though earth recedes, in darkness lost around, " Quick on the traveller's eyes a thousand rays " Dart through the gloom, a thousand orbs appear : " The world's vast concave shines, at once reveal'd, " And suns and systems, rolling through the void " All that was veil'd in noontide's dazzling glare ! " How does mortality's dread voice impress " Departed goodness on the trembling soul, " And give resistless charms to vanish'd worth " Which life had never known ! It taught me soon " To read of beauties in thy mind, and powers " Before unseen, or but in part beheld. " And even to thee, perhaps, this voice hath said, " Not all the faults thy heaven- illumined eye " In me had seen, were written on my heart. " Vile and unworthy is that heart, I feel ; " But yet methinks the day shall quickly come, " When we shall meet in worlds of better joy. " O could I mark thy footsteps on to Heaven, " And, following with a firmer, speedier tread, " Gain but the mount of bliss where thou art now ! " Then, young like thee, in form so much alike " That heedless eyes have oft the lines o'erlook'd " That mark'd us from each other, I would rise " With thee to glory, and with thee to grasp " An angel's lyre, though in an infant's hand!" R. S. M. This was not the mere poetic utterance of temporary emotion and pensive tenderness. We shall have a still more satisfactory testimony hereafter of the permanence both of the sentiment and the feeling. That during his curriculum in the Edinburgh University Mr. M'All was signally successful in the prosecution of his literary, metaphysical, scientific, and medical studies, will excite the surprise of none who knew him. He attracted the notice, and was honoured with the favour and intimacy, of THE REV. DR. MALL. xi that most eminent metaphysician and most accomplished arid amiable man, the late Dr. Thomas Brown, then Professor of Moral Philosophy, by whom his extraordinary talents, at so early a period, were highly appreciated, and who is re- corded to have, on one occasion, said to him, " Mr. M' All, at Oxford and Cambridge there is the office of Christian Advocate: there is no such office at Edinburgh; if there were, we could not do better than elect you to it." Such a compliment, from such a quarter, was no slight testimony to the eminence of his endowments His powers were remark- able, among other distinguishing qualities, for their versatility. He had, as all have, his special predilections; but to whatever 'he applied his mind, whether the application was dictated by choice or by duty, he was sure to excel. So eminent were his advances in the various departments of medical science, then anticipated as his probable professional career, that even in the second year of his course, it was proposed to elect him president of the Royal Medical Society, an Institution, in whose discussions he had taken a prominent and brilliant part ; but this distinction, high in itself, and at so early a period of youth and of study, it is presumed, unprecedented, he spontaneously declined, withdrawing his claims in favour of another. The views thus given of the assiduity with which his studies were prosecuted, of the eminent mental powers dis- played in their pursuit, and of the height of distinction which he speedily attained and permanently kept, I am glad to be able to confirm by the testimony of one who then became ac- quainted with him, was fascinated by his talents and charac- ter, and, retaining to the end his admiration, expressed it, at a subsequent period, by proposing his name for the honorary degree of Doctor in Laws to the senate of the university, over which he continues to preside :* " I was first intro- " duced to Mr. M'All in the house of the late Rev. Dr. " Campbell, one of the ministers of Edinburgh, in 1810. I " at once saw that the young Englishman was no ordinary * Rev. Dr. Devvar, Principal of Marischal College, Aberdeen. h btii LIFE AND CHARACTER OF "man; an impression which was deeply made on the mind of "the eminent minister whose name I have mentioned. I " was struck with his power of observation, with the depth " and acuteness of his remarks, and with his frankness " and playfulness of manner, which was to me extremely "engaging. Our friendship began that evening, which was " intimate and lasting; and during the two following winters "which I passed in Edinburgh, we met daily; and very often " where we first became acquainted, at the hospitable board "of Dr. Campbell. " No one could be long in the company of my excellent " friend, without perceiving the strong bent of his mind " towards metaphysics and ethics. He had read much, and "thought more, on these subjects; and they formed the " theme of our frequent conversation in the class-room of our " common friend the late Dr. Thomas Brown, where, after " listening to a profound and eloquent lecture from that ad- " mirable man, we often joined the professor in conversation " on the topic or topics on which he had been discoursing. " There was, indeed, a remarkable similarity in the mental " character of Mr. M' All to that of the amiable and accom- " plished professor of moral philosophy. Both were profound " metaphysicians : both also were men of lofty genius and " poetical imagination. They resembled each other also in " their manners. They were both open and unreserved; and " their conversation was full, even to overflowing, of brilliant " remark. Perhaps there was more of the nervous irritability " of the poet in the constitution of Dr. M' All than in that of " Dr. Brown. 1 The range of his studies was ex- " tensive ; and his ardour in pursuing them was beyond his " bodily strength." Trying as the circumstances were by which his destination to medical studies at Edinburgh was necessitated, I cannot but admire in it that divine foresight by which, in the ex- perience of his people, " all things" are made to " work to- " gether for good." I see the Master's hand preparing the instrument for his work ; the " Captain of salvation" polishing the shaft for his quiver. His studies at the university served THE REV. DR. M*ALL. Ixiii to complete the furniture of his mind. Its powers were sharpened and invigorated, their energy and their readiness being alike augmented by competition with a stronger and more trying antagonism than before, while both the variety and the amount of its acquirements were greatly amplified. The course of sceptical investigation and of mental conflict through which he passed, while it gave acuteness and dexterity to his powers of ratiocination, imparted what was still more valu- able, a depth of self-experience, and a more intimate acquaint- ance with the deceitful workings of the human heart ; and by opening to his mind the many sophistries of infidelity, and the various forms and phases of error, fitted him the more re- ,markably for coping with the advocates of them all, and contributed to the settled stability of his own subsequent pro- fession. He was brought into personal contact and inter- change of mind with unbelievers ; and had thus an opportu- nity of discerning the secret sources of their hostility to re- vealed religion, of acquiring a knowledge of their arguments, and an experimental tact in meeting and confuting them, which were of essential benefit to him in the sphere for which the Master he was to serve was preparing him. By this salutary process, moreover, he learned a lesson, at once more difficult of attainment and more truly valuable than the know- ledge of the extent of his powers, I mean the knowledge of their limitation. His estimate of the capabilities of the human mind was moderated : and in his own, the license of specu- lation was restrained, without any abatement of the thirst for knowledge; and the spirit of intellectual high-mindedness was subdued into a more profound and lowly submissiveness than ever to divine dictation. And, how prone soever the philosophy of the world may be to call this weakness, it was real strength, it was true mental vigour. The mightiest and most capacious of human minds have bowed to the evi- dences of divine revelation, and have pronounced them irre- fragable. That is no proof of imbecility, unless Newton himself was a driveller. And, when once the claim to divine authority has been satisfactorily substantiated, genuine mental strength lies in schooling and disciplining the mind to sub- LIFE AND CHARACTER OF jefction, in controlling 1 and reining-in its natural wayward- ness and dogmatism. When we have ascertained any principle to be manifestly reasonable, and I know not of one more palpably so than the propriety of implicit submission to divine teaching, then the special effort to which the mind is sum- moned, and success in which becomes the criterion of its might and mastery, is the effort to bring all its dispositions and tendencies into conformity with this principle. When a child refuses to believe what all besides itself know to be true, the cause is not largeness but limitation, not strength but weakness, of intellect. When the mind attains subse- quent expansion and vigour, the man becomes ashamed of the incredulity of the child. He sees now to be folly what he then thought wisdom, and that to be vanity which he deemed spirit and independence. He perceives that what he wanted when a child, was capacity enough to know his own in- capacity, strength enough to admit his own weakness. We smile at the child. Angels may so smile at us. The self- sufficiency of unsubmissive intellect may be, in their eyes, the mere positiveness of childhood, seeing, as they may, that, had we the range of their mental vision, we should have a clear and full perception of what our place in the scale of being, or our situation as fallen creatures, requires us to accept as matters of faith. There is no true strength of mind in allowing a natural fondness for uncontrolled and self-willed speculation, a lofty disdain of being dictated to, to come between the understanding and a just perception and appre- ciation of the evidences of revealed religion ; in allowing a determination not to be fettered to prevent our examining the divine workmanship of the chain, and discerning the divine hand that imposes it. This would be the very bondage of freedom. There is the same kind of mental greatness in disdaining the teaching of omniscience, as there would be in disdaining the support of omnipotence. In either case, how misnamed! It is not greatness, but littleness; it is not strength, but weakness. There is no diminutiveness more pitiable, than the affected majesty of independence on the part of a creature whose very power of thought is not his THE REV. DR. Mr. Raffle*. THE REV. DR. M'ALL. the New Testament, either as to commencement or cessation. Timothy was a youth, when called to the sacred service ; Peter, and Paul, and others were aged when they closed it. While life and ability remain, the growing experience of years only serves to augment the fitness, and to render pro- longation the more desirable. Death of course terminates the ministry of the earthly sanctuary ; and by many causes inability may be induced before it. It may be assumed as a general principle, that the extreme of youth is hardly con- gruous with the weight and solemnity of the office. But there are minds divinely fitted by their peculiar, even though somewhat diverse, constitutions, for early usefulness, which, when a strong desire for the good work discovers itself, it would not be warrantable to keep back. Such were those of Spencer and M'All, widely different, yet allied, " facies non una, nee diversa tamen," their powers and capacities hardly to be compared, yet both admirably, though vari- ously, fitted for their respective modes and departments of service. Mr. M' All's father being at that time pastor of the con- gregation in Zion chapel, London, thither he then repaired. The following memorandums of him, at this period, are from the pen of an esteemed congregational minister, already referred to,* who was then a student at Homerton, and who had previously known Mr. M'All as an occasional visitor at his father's house during his stay at Hoxton : " On one oc- " casion, Mr. M'All, shortly after his return from Edinburgh, "spent a day with usf at Homerton; and on that occasion, " the power of his conversation, and the versatility of his " talents, produced an impression upon all who witnessed " them, which no length of time has been able to efface. " Even at that early period, such was the ripeness of his in- " tellect, and the decided bias of his mind towards religious " subjects, that it was impossible to be in his company, or to " hear him engage in any religious exercise, without being " convinced that he was marked by the hand of Nature and * The Rev. Mr. Thodey. t The students, namely. THE REV. DR. M*ALL. " Providence as no common man ; and all anticipated that he '* would, at no distant period, shine forth as a star of the first " magnitude, the light and ornament of the sphere to which " he belonged. The students, who shortly afterwards heard " him preach, were anxious to obtain some of his manuscript " productions, which were read with avidity, and diligently " copied : among which I may specify a beautiful sermon " on the spiritual life, an outline of which I have in my pos- " session at the present time Between the interval of his " return from Edinburgh and his settlement at Macclesfield, " he preached a sermon at the Adelphi, upon Col. ii. 8. " ' Beware lest any man spoil you through philosophy and vain " deceit, after the traditions of men, after the rudiments of " the world, and not after Christ ;' which his more intelligent " auditors considered to be one of the most masterly and elo- " quent sermons they had ever heard upon the fallacious " pretensions of the infidel philosophy, and the divine attesta- " tions to the Christian faith. Nor was it only on subjects "purely intellectual that his mind delighted to expatiate; " he seemed equally at home in the minuter developments of " character, and the detection of the sophistries of the heart. " Many of the same persons who had heard his argumenta- " tive discourse at the Adelphi, which, if I mistake not, was " read throughout, were equally impressed with a sermon " marked by much simplicity and pathos, which he preached " at Clapton about the same time, from Acts vii. 39. ' And in " their hearts turned back into Egypt.' This, though whol- " ly extemporaneous, excepting the bare outline, exhibited " a singular power in analysing the springs and motives of "human action, his object being, to trace some of the " causes that operated to produce a departure in heart from "the love and service of God, on the part of those who " neither relapsed into open infidelity, nor abandoned the out- " ward profession of religion which they had made. These ser- " mons were the more remarkable from the extreme youth of " the preacher ; and were quite sufficient to indicate, that, " whatever might be the minor variations of feeling through " which he had passed, his own religious opinions, far from THE REV. DR. M