JMMfc 
 
 
 
 A'A'i'3'O A V, 
 
 iM 
 
 * * * .
 
 /5 r"
 
 

 
 p 
 
 MEMOIRS 
 
 * OF 
 
 THE LIFE 
 
 OF THE 
 
 RIGHT HON. WARREN HASTINGS, 
 
 FIRST GOVERNOR-GENERAL OF BENGAL. 
 COMPILED FROM ORIGINAL PAPERS. 
 
 BY THE REV. G. R. GLEIG, M.A. 
 
 I 1 * 
 
 CHAPLAIN TO THE ROYAL HOSPITAL AT CHELSEA, AND RECTOR OF IVYCHURCH, IN KENT. 
 
 AUTHOR OF 
 THE LIFE OF SIR THOMAS MUNRO. 
 
 VOL. I. 
 
 LONDON: 
 
 RICHARD BENTLEY, NEW BURLINGTON STREET, 
 in rtJmarj) to Her fflajttty. 
 1841.
 
 LONDON: 
 
 Printed \iy W. CLOWES and SONS 
 Stamford Street.
 
 ADVERTISEMENT. 
 
 THE following volumes I offer to the public, not 
 without a distressing consciousness that they do 
 imperfect justice to a subject at once so important 
 and so comprehensive as that which they have 
 undertaken to discuss. Neither of any lack of 
 zeal on my part to bring about a different issue, 
 nor of the absence either of care or of assiduity in 
 digesting the materials submitted to me, can I 
 indeed accuse myself ; for the compilation of the 
 work has constituted my principal literary em- 
 ployment throughout the space of four entire years. 
 Yet I feel, when all is done, that the results of my 
 labours fall far short of the anticipations which I 
 had ventured to form when they began ; and that 
 a larger share of indulgence must be sought for at 
 the hands of my reader, than, under ordinary cir- 
 cumstances, I should be entitled to expect. Let 
 me, however, tell my own tale with all the brevity 
 
 a 2
 
 iv ADVERTISEMENT. 
 
 and candour which are becoming in one situated 
 as I now am, and then throw myself, without 
 hesitation, upon the considerate kindness of such 
 as may take the trouble to follow the details of my 
 explanation and judge of their fitness. 
 
 That the task which I have now completed 
 I do not say how imperfectly was not an easy 
 one, may be gathered from the following state- 
 ment of facts: Not long after Mr. Hastings's 
 death, and at a period when, of the friends of his 
 manhood, many were yet alive, it was proposed to 
 Mr. Southey to become the biographer of the 
 greatest statesman whom British India has pro- 
 duced. The proposition being acceded to, the 
 whole of the family papers were put into Mr. 
 Southey' s hands, who kept them by him a good 
 while, and then returned them with a frank avowal 
 that he could not command the time and attention 
 that would be necessary for the management of an 
 undertaking so extensive and so complicated. 
 Mr. Hastings's executors were much disappointed 
 at the result; and the project lay for a time in 
 abeyance, till by and bye the late Mr. Impey, the 
 son of Sir Elijah Impey, and a man every way 
 qualified for the undertaking, revived the idea. 
 To him, in his turn, the voluminous documents
 
 ADVERTISEMENT. V 
 
 were committed, and in his possession they re- 
 mained, if I mistake not, about six years. But 
 Mr. Impey did nothing with them. His assiduity 
 at the India House appears, indeed, to have been 
 extraordinary, for he visited that great depot of 
 historical information every day ; and the count- 
 less memoranda which I have discovered in his 
 own handwriting, show that he left few of the 
 Company's records unexamined. Yet not one 
 page of the memoirs had he begun to write when 
 he died, and all the hopes which the friends of Mr. 
 Hastings's good name rested upon his exertions 
 died with him. Once more, therefore, the papers 
 were restored to the drawers and cabinets of 
 Daylesford House, where, in absolute confusion, 
 they remained, till, in the summer of 1835, they 
 were finally handed over to me. I confess that I 
 received them with unmixed satisfaction, because 
 my opinion of Mr. Hastings's character and merits 
 had long been formed; and I rejoiced in the 
 thought that through me so illustrious a name 
 might be in some sort redeemed from unmerited 
 neglect. But as I certainly was not then aware 
 of the stupendous nature of the undertaking on 
 which 1 was about to embark, so I do not hesitate 
 now to acknowledge, that had the truth been made
 
 yi ADVERTISEMENT. 
 
 apparent to me, I should have declined it. That 
 which Mr. Southey and Mr. Impey failed to effect, 
 I had certainly no right to attempt. Nor after the 
 attempt was made should I have gone forward 
 with it, but for a constitutional weakness, if the 
 feeling deserve no harsher name, which renders it 
 positively painful to me to be foiled in any purpose 
 of the sort, till I shall have exhausted both mental 
 and physical strength in the endeavour to effect it. 
 After many distressing pauses, therefore, and many 
 hours and days of absolute despondency, the work 
 has at length been brought to a termination, and 
 now goes forth with a thousand imperfections upon 
 its head, which no human eye can see more clearly 
 than my own, but which I profess myself quite 
 incompetent to remedy. 
 
 It will be seen that in the management of my 
 work I have rendered Mr. Hastings as much as 
 possible the narrator of his own acts and intentions. 
 There can be no doubt in the mind of any thinking 
 person as to the wisdom of this arrangement, more 
 especially in cases where, like the present, conse- 
 cutive series of letters have been even partially pre- 
 served. But the letters entrusted to me are not 
 always consecutive ; and it has unfortunately hap- 
 pened, that precisely at points where most of all it
 
 ADVERTISEMENT. vii 
 
 was essential that I should find materials for my 
 biography in the handwriting of the subject of it, 
 or of his personal friends, such materials were 
 wanting. This has been especially true in re- 
 ference to Mr. Hastings's early history, to that 
 period in a great man's life which is often more 
 replete than any other with interest, when, 
 forcing his own way to eminence through innu- 
 merable obstacles, he conveys to others the gravest 
 lessons of wisdom and enterprise and moderation. 
 Over that stage in Mr. Hastings's career a dense 
 curtain is drawn, which his correspondence with 
 Lord Clive can be said very imperfectly to raise ; 
 and I have been forced, in consequence, to generalize 
 where I could have wished to proceed upon a 
 different principle, by speaking more of the nature 
 of the employments in which he was engaged, 
 than of the condition, and habits, and personal 
 occupations of the man. I lament this exceedingly, 
 but I cannot help it, any more than I have been 
 able to escape, in the course of the chapters which 
 follow, from frequent epitomes of historical detail, 
 without keeping which immediately in view, the 
 reader might find in the correspondence much 
 that would be to him unintelligible. It were 
 idle to expect that they who peruse such epitome
 
 viii ADVERTISEMENT. 
 
 will give the writer credit for the degree of toil 
 which has been bestowed upon them ; for that 
 which we read with ease in ten minutes, we are 
 all too apt to forget, may have cost as many days, 
 or even weeks, in the composition. But the expe- 
 rienced in such matters know better. It is a far 
 harder task to compress than to dilate, even when 
 the subject may be familiar to us ; the difficulties 
 are increased a thousand-fold, when, for the at- 
 tainment of a few- grains of truth, we are com- 
 pelled to wade through whole piles of old and 
 often unmeaning correspondence. This has been 
 precisely my case while striving from the letters 
 of Mr. Hastings's friends, to fill up blanks in his 
 personal history, which his own could not supply ; 
 and I am reduced at last simply to the expression of 
 a hope that as the labour has been excessive, so the 
 results may not wholly disappoint either my own 
 wishes or the wishes of others. 
 
 Of the memorable impeachment to which Mr. 
 Hastings was subjected, as the reward of a long life 
 spent in his country's service, I have given no 
 detailed account. I do not apprehend that any 
 judicious critic will blame me for this ; for as the 
 charges brought against him were assumed to 
 spring out of the vices which disfigured the whole
 
 ADVERTISEMENT. ix 
 
 
 
 of his administration, so is their refutation far 
 more satisfactorily set forth in a plain unvar- 
 nished narrative of the administration itself, than 
 could have been done by lingering over the 
 iniquitous proceedings with which his public 
 life was consummated. For Mr. Hastings, like 
 every other great and good man, is the best 
 guardian of his own fair fame even in the grave. 
 His actions and his motives alike speak for them- 
 selves. And as the issues of the trial were, as far 
 as character was affected by them, altogether 
 satisfactory, I cannot conceive that to follow the 
 course of its progress could excite the interest or 
 gratify the tastes of any one. Besides, the task 
 was long ago performed with perfect impartiality 
 by a pains-taking though anonymous compiler, 
 who has woven into a consecutive history the 
 events of each day as they befel ; and to that 
 volume I confidently refer all who may be desirous 
 of farther information, touching both the violence 
 of the accusers, and the forbearance and long 
 suffering of the accused. 
 
 Finally there is one great and obvious truth of 
 which no candid inquirer, when he sits down to try 
 the moral prolity, not of Mr. Hastings alone, 
 but of other Englishmen by whom the affairs of
 
 X ADVERTISEMENT. 
 
 I 
 
 India have been administered, will ever be forget- 
 ful : -~-tlie whole of our proceedings in Asia, have 
 been from the first, and still are, grounded upon 
 moral wrong. We are usurpers there of other 
 men's rights, and hold our empire by the tenure of 
 the sword. For this neither the nation, nor indivi- 
 duals, may be in strict propriety responsible, be- 
 cause the current of events, and not their own am- 
 bitious plans, swept the India Company onwards 
 to the position which they now hold ; yet the facts 
 are as I have stated them to be, and we cannot 
 escape from them. Now unless the moralist be 
 prepared to contend, that an English Governor of 
 India is bound to betray the trust which is reposed 
 in him, that some rule of abstract right requires 
 that he shall sacrifice the interests of his employers, 
 whenever the efforts to sustain them may threaten 
 to involve him in the necessity of encroaching still 
 farther upon the rights of the native princes, I 
 think that he will be very cautious how he con- 
 demns proceedings which arise, not out of any 
 selfish anxiety on the Governor's part to increase 
 his own wealth, or his own renown, but from a 
 conscientious zeal to uphold the honour and ad- 
 vance the prosperity of the commonwealth from 
 which his authority is derived. Far be it from me
 
 ADVERTISEMENT. xi 
 
 to insinuate, that in any of his proceedings Mr. 
 Hastings was ever driven to cover private wrong 
 with the cloak of public duty. Individual chiefs 
 may have fallen before him, as they fell before his 
 predecessor, and continue to fall now ; but to the 
 people at hirge his administration was a blessing, as 
 the reverence in which his memory is still held may 
 suffice to prove. And if it be the true end of all 
 governmentto secure the greatest possible amount of 
 good to the greatest possible amount of persons, then 
 had he no cause to blush for the effects of his just 
 and gentle, yet vigorous, sway over tribes, whom 
 their native princes were either unable, or un- 
 willing, to protect from anarchy. 
 
 To sum up all, Mr. Hastings has been accused of 
 cruelty and oppression. The very persons whom 
 he was represented to have most deeply injured, 
 were among the foremost to declare their attach- 
 ment to his person and government. Mr. Hastings 
 has been accused of involving British India in an 
 expensive war, for the mere purpose of gratifying 
 his own inordinate ambition. The whole energies 
 of his mind were devoted either to the mainte- 
 nance of peace, or to remedy the blunders of others, 
 which rendered war inevitable. Mr. Hastings has 
 been accused of venality and corruption to an incal-
 
 xii ADVERTISEMENT. 
 
 culable extent. He returned home after thirty- 
 five years spent in the service of the Company, 
 during thirteen of which he presided over the des- 
 tinies of India, with a fortune barely adequate to 
 support him in the rank of an English country 
 gentleman. And even that, the prosecution to 
 which political and personal hostility subjected him 
 swept away. 
 
 Surely since the days when Athens sent her best 
 benefactors into banishment, there has been no such 
 instance of devotion to the public interests bringing 
 to him who practised it so strange a reward. For 
 if Mr. Hastings was corrupt, it was to advance the 
 interests of England that he practised his cor- 
 ruption; if he was venal, she and she alone pro- 
 fited by his venality; if he was rapacious, into the 
 public treasury all the fruits of his rapacity went. 
 And so skilful was he in the management of mate- 
 rials, beneath which, for the most part, empires are 
 crushed to pieces, that the very country in which 
 he was described as building up this extraordinary 
 fabric flourished and grew great under its shadow. 
 Yea, and more than this. The system of adminis- 
 tration, for introducing which Mr. Hastings under- 
 went such a lengthened persecution, earned for his 
 successors who acted faithfully up to it, the thanks
 
 ADVERTISEMENT. Xlll 
 
 of the legislature, and the gratitude of the nation. 
 So full of inconsistencies are all human affairs, and 
 so little is even the best of men the master of his 
 own fame and fortunes ! 
 
 And now there remains for me only the pleasant 
 task of expressing the deep sense which I enter- 
 tain of the kindness of all those who, whether 
 directly or indirectly, have afforded me assistance 
 in the collection of my materials. .Among these 
 I am especially called upon to mention by name 
 Sir Charles and Lady Imhoff, the near connexions 
 and devoted attendants on the last hours of the 
 deceased; Mr. and Mrs. Winter, the former the 
 rector of Daylesford, the latter the amiable niece 
 and companion for many years of the late Mrs. 
 Hastings ; Mr. Anderson, of St. Germains, and 
 Mr. Augustus Thompson, of the Middle Temple, 
 the sons of two of Mr. Hastings's oldest and most 
 faithful friends ; and last, though not least, Mr. 
 E. B. Impey. To this latter gentleman, indeed, 
 I am indebted for such details of Mr. Hastings's 
 private habits and tastes as would have scarcely 
 reached me through any other channel ; and the 
 value of such information can be estimated only 
 by those who, like myself, have felt how unsatis- 
 factory, in cases like the present, it is to depend,
 
 XJV ADVERTISEMENT. 
 
 in forming our judgment, absolutely on written 
 documents, and on the sort of notion which they 
 are apt to create of the moral feelings of the 
 writer. 
 
 Finally, let me thank the Directors of the East 
 India Company for the liberality with which they 
 threw open for my inspection the voluminous re- 
 cords at the India House, arid the consideration 
 which induces) them to afford me every accom- 
 modation and facility for making extracts from 
 them. I am fully aware that mine is not a solitary 
 case; for. the same privileges which they afforded 
 to me they are prompt to afford to all who seek 
 them : yet is the personal obligation laid upon 
 me in nowise diminished by the consideration that 
 I am but one out of many on whom similar favours 
 have been bestowed. 
 
 Chelsea College, December, 1840.
 
 CONTENTS OF VOL. I. 
 
 CHAPTER I. 
 
 Page 
 
 Early genealogy of the family of Hastings Its downfall Birth of 
 Warren His childhood -Goes to school at Newington Butts and 
 Westminster Elected a King's Scholar Death of his uncle Howard 
 Appointment to India as a writer 1 
 
 CHAPTER II. 
 
 General View of the Company's Governments in the beginning and 
 middle of the Seventeenth Century Summary of the Political State 
 of India at the same time ...II 
 
 CHAPTER III. 
 
 Hastings arrives in India Employed in the Secretary's Office Re- 
 moved to Cossimbazar Rupture with Suraj ud Dowlah War- 
 Hastings serves as a Volunteer Suraj ud Dowlah dethroned 
 Hustings'* first Marriage 32 
 
 CHAPTER IV. 
 
 His residence at the Court of Moorshedabad Correspondence with 
 Lord Clive Wins the good opinion of his Employers .... 51 
 
 CHAPTER V. 
 
 Clive resigns the Government Succeeded by Mr. Holwell and Mr. 
 Vansittart New Revolution, and appointment of Cosseim Ali as 
 Nabob Mr. Vansittart an object of jealousy to his Council, and is 
 in the minority Mr. Hastings a Member of Council His negocia- 
 tions with the Nabob Violences on all sides Rupture Deposition 
 of Meer Cossim Mr. Hastings's return to England 79 
 
 CHAPTER VI. 
 
 Mr. Hastings in England The embarrassment of his Affairs His de- 
 sire to return to India Examined before the House of Commons 
 Retrospect of Occurrences in Bengal and Carnatic 133
 
 xv i CONTENTS. 
 
 Page 
 CHAPTER VII. 
 
 Outline of the Political and Financial Affairs of the Company, from 
 1765 to 1772 The Court's Instructions to Hastings His Reply- 
 Letters upon various subjects 1 
 
 CHAPTER VIII. 
 
 Settlement of the Provinces Arrangement of the Nabob's Household 
 Mahommed Reza Cawn and Shitab Roy subjected to Trial Gene- 
 ral Correspondence 265 
 
 CHAPTER IX. 
 
 View of the difficulties to be surmounted in working out his Reforms 
 Correspondence with different Functionaries 311 
 
 CHAPTER X. 
 
 Foreign relations of the Company Treaty of Benares Letters on 
 various Subjects 335 
 
 CHAPTER XI. 
 
 Change of Revenue System Letters carrying on the History of his 
 Government 378 
 
 CHAPTER XII. 
 
 Minor details in Mr. Hastings's Government Regulations concerning 
 Native Marriages Asylum offered to the Vizier's family Mission 
 to the Tershoo Lama Rohilla War 405 
 
 CHAPTER XIII. 
 
 Parliamentary Proceedings concerning the Affairs of India The Re- 
 gulating Act of 1773 Arrival of the new Councillors at Calcutta 
 Beginnings of Strife . 443 
 
 .CHAPTER XIV. 
 
 Continuation of Discords Attacks on the private Character of Mr. 
 Hastings General Correspondence .481
 
 MEMOIRS, 
 
 CHAPTER I. 
 
 Karly genealogy of the family of Hastings Its downfall Birth of Warren 
 His childhood Goes to school at Newington Butts and Westminster 
 Elected a King's Scholar Death of his uncle Howard Appointment to 
 India as a writer. 
 
 THOUGH the family from which Warren Hast- 
 ings derived his descent possessed in ancient times 
 a large share both of wealth and of influence, the 
 state of decay into which it had latterly fallen was 
 so complete, that the very birthplace of the subject 
 of the following memoir cannot now with perfect 
 accuracy be pointed out. Two parishes, one in 
 Worcestershire the other in Oxfordshire, distant 
 about five miles from each other, equally lay claim 
 to the honour of having produced him. Of the 
 former, Daylesford, his grandfather was undoubt- 
 edly the incumbent ; and the traditions of the 
 hamlet assert that in his grandfather's parsonage 
 the future governor of British India was born. 
 On the other hand, I found, upon visiting the spot, 
 that not only is his baptism recorded in the parish 
 VOL. i. u
 
 2 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 register of Churchill, but that a particular house in 
 the village is pointed out to strangers as that in 
 which he first saw the light. Moreover the occu- 
 pants of the house in question a brother and sister 
 well stricken in years assured me that their parents 
 had frequently conversed with them about the event; 
 and that their mother in particular, who died at an 
 advanced age, perfectly recollected having been, 
 when a child, disturbed from her sleep by the 
 arrival of the accoucheur who attended Mrs. Hast- 
 ings in her illness. Under these circumstances 
 I am inclined to give the preference to Churchill 
 over Daylesford as the place of Warren Hastings' 
 nativity ; more especially as there were peculiari- 
 ties in his father's state and circumstances which 
 go far to assure me that my judgment is correct. 
 
 I have spoken of the branch of the Hastings' 
 family from which Warren drew his descent, as 
 having been at one period in the possession of 
 considerable power and very extensive estates. 
 His grandfather, an antiquary of no mean repu- 
 tation, traces back his own pedigree to Hastings 
 the Dane. This may or may not be a dotage, but 
 at least it is certain that the manor of Daylesford 
 was held so early as the reign of Henry II. 
 by one of the name, and that the records of the 
 Tower of London make mention of Milo de 
 Hastings as lord of the same place, in the thirty- 
 third year of Edward I. From the same stock
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 3 
 
 sprang likewise the Barons of Abergavenny, who, 
 by the marriage of John Hastings with the heiress 
 of Aimer de Valentia, became Earls of Pembroke, 
 and mixed their blood with the Plantagenets ; and 
 though the earldom died out through the failure 
 of heirs, and the barony passed by marriage to 
 Reginald de Grey, not yet were the Hastingses de- 
 prived of their nobility. The Earls of Hunting- 
 don, once among the most powerful of the English 
 aristocracy, took their rise from a younger branch 
 of the house of Day les ford. 
 
 Time passed, and this old and illustrious race 
 declined by degrees from their original splendour. 
 The manor-house of Daylesford, where their hos- 
 pitality had for ages been dispensed, fell into 
 decay ; and they transferred their residence to 
 Yelford, called, in the ancient writings, Yelford 
 Hastings, near Bampton, in Oxfordshire. Here, 
 at the commencement of the great civil war, dwelt 
 John Hastings, a worthy scion from a noble stock, 
 whose devoted loyalty not only carried him person- 
 ally into the field, but caused him to sacrifice lands, 
 and plate, and money with a free hand, in order 
 to raise funds for the supply of the king's neces- 
 sities. Having expended the value of four large 
 manors in the service of Charles I., John Hast- 
 ings considered himself fortunate on the termina- 
 tion of the struggle, because he was permitted to 
 redeem from confiscation the wreck of a princely 
 
 B2
 
 4 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 fortune, by making over to Speaker Lenthall his 
 estate of Yelford. 
 
 From the effects of these sacrifices to principle 
 the family of Hastings never recovered. The 
 estate of Daylesford, grievously reduced in extent, 
 remained indeed for awhile in their possession, and 
 they continued to inhabit the manor house, though 
 little better than a ruin. But even this, the last 
 remaining monument of former greatness, their 
 necessities at length compelled them to alienate. It 
 was sold in the year 1715 by Samuel, the great- 
 grandfather of Warren Hastings, to Jacob Knight, 
 of Westbury in Gloucester, Esq., and a merchant 
 of the city of London. 
 
 Such is a brief outline of the fortunes of the 
 family from which Warren Hastings derived his 
 descent. His grandfather, the second son of 
 Samuel, last lord of the manor, having been 
 educated for the Church, was presented, in 1701, 
 to the rectory of Daylesford ; a poor benefice, of 
 which the advowson belonged to his father, but 
 which never seems to have brought to the incum- 
 
 o 
 
 bent more than the means of a bare subsistence. 
 Like others in his situation, however, he preferred 
 to share his indigence with a partner, rather than 
 suffer it alone ; so he married, and had two sons, 
 the elder born in 1711, the younger in 1715. The 
 former, by name Howard, seems to have been a 
 prudent, well-behaved, kind-hearted man; who,
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 5 
 
 obtaining a situation in the customs, lived and 
 died respected. The latter, called Pynaston, de- 
 serves to be held in remembrance for nothing, 
 except that he was the father of such a son as 
 Warren. Nor, indeed, has it fared with him 
 otherwise than it fares with the volatile and the 
 improvident in general. His very children were 
 always shy of alluding to him ; so that the few 
 records of his career which I have succeeded in 
 picking up have been gathered from other, and, of 
 course, less authentic sources. 
 
 It appears from the register of the parish of 
 St. Andrew, Worcester, that Pynaston Hastings, 
 bachelor, was, in the year 1730, married to Hester 
 Warren, the daughter of Mr. Warren, the pro- 
 prietor of a small estate called Stubhill, near 
 Twining, in Gloucestershire. The youth could 
 not have been at the date of his marriage more 
 than fifteen years of age, and the consequences of 
 a connexion formed so improvidently were such 
 as never fail to ensue in like cases. The young 
 couple soon began to experience the extremity of 
 remorse and destitution. How they contrived to 
 subsist at all I am quite at a loss to conceive, for 
 the rector of Daylesford was by this time involved 
 in an expensive law-suit respecting tithes with 
 the new squire of his parish, and his means, slender 
 at the outset, utterly failed in conducting it. Yet 
 they did live together for two years, during which
 
 6 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 his wife presented her boy-husband with two chil- 
 dren first a daughter, to whom they gave the 
 name of Ann, and afterwards a son, in bringing 
 whom into this world she brought her own miseries 
 to a close. Warren Hastings was born on the 6th 
 of December, 1732, and his mother died a few days 
 afterwards. 
 
 The baptism of the child took place, as I have 
 already said, in the parish church of Churchill, 
 when he received, after his maternal grand- 
 father, the name of Warren ; but what became of 
 him afterwards, or where the season of his infancy 
 was spent, I do not know. His father seems to 
 have quitted Churchill almost immediately on the 
 decease of his wife ; indeed I find him married again, 
 soon afterwards, in the town of Gloucester, to the 
 daughter of a butcher ; but of the means by which 
 he gained a livelihood there no trace remains, 
 while those that mark his after-career are few 
 and imperfect. The subject was one to which 
 Mr. Hastings never voluntarily alluded; and, 
 when questioned concerning it, he always appeared 
 reluctant to answer : " There was not much in my 
 father's history that would be worth repeating," 
 said he to Mr. Impey, from whom I derive this 
 anecdote, "except that, when he became old enough, 
 he entered into holy orders, and went to one of the 
 West India Islands, where he died." 
 
 Such was the commencement, inauspicious in
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 7 
 
 the extreme, of the long, and brilliant, and che- 
 quered life of the great and good man whose 
 career I have undertaken to describe. It seems 
 difficult to conceive how the dawn of human life 
 could be, under any circumstances, more intensely 
 overclouded ; indeed I feel that I am not going 
 too far when I venture to assert that had the 
 individual thus brought into the world been the 
 object of an ordinary providence, he never could 
 have emerged out of obscurity. For, virtually 
 an orphan from his mother's womb, his sole de- 
 pendence was upon one, who, though he might 
 watch over the opening of the child's faculties, was 
 too poor to bestow upon them any extraordinary 
 culture, and too little familiar with the world to 
 find out for the youth an opening through which 
 he might work his own Avay to eminence. It ap- 
 peared, too, at one time, as if a life of poverty and 
 neglect were all to which Warren Hastings had a 
 right to look forward. His grandfather, utterly 
 ruined by his contest with Mr. Knight, found 
 himself driven to quit Daylesford when Warren 
 was about two years old, and, accepting the curacy 
 of Churchill, sent the child to a foundation or 
 charity school, which still exists in the village 
 Thus reduced to associate with the children of the 
 humblest classes, and beholding little else at home 
 than the squalor of poverty, it would have been 
 the reverse of wonderful had the tone of the
 
 8 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 boy's mind adapted itself to the condition of his 
 body, in which case he would have slid, without so 
 much as a murmur of regret, into the ranks of the 
 agricultural peasantry, and been forgotten. 
 
 The Author of his being had, however, bestowed 
 upon young Hastings a soul worthy of the noble 
 line from which he was descended. Even at the 
 foundation school of Churchill, he exhibited an 
 ardent desire to excel, so that to this day the old 
 people relate of him that "Warren aye took 
 his laming kindly." He seems, likewise, to have 
 possessed a vivid and active imagination, which 
 delighted to exercise itself in dreams connected 
 with the ancient honours of his house. He began 
 early to inquire both into the deeds of his fore- 
 fathers, and into the causes which had produced 
 his own degradation, and he would listen by the 
 hour together to any one who would talk to him 
 of the munificence of the former proprietors of 
 Daylesford, and the respect in which people held 
 them. There is a small stream or brook, which, 
 skirting the hill along which Churchill is built, 
 falls, after passing Cornwall, the seat of another 
 branch of the Hastings family, into the Evenlode, 
 and with its new parent is finally absorbed by the 
 Isis near Cotswold. " To lie beside the margin 
 of that stream, and muse, was," said Mr. Hastings 
 to a friend who was frequently his guest after 
 the termination of his persecutions, " one of my
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 9 
 
 favourite recreations ; and there, one bright sum- 
 mer's day, when I was scarcely seven years old, I 
 well remember that I first formed the determination 
 to purchase back Daylesford. / I was then literally 
 dependent upon those whose condition scarcely 
 raised them above the pressure of absolute want ; 
 yet somehow or another, the child's dream, as it 
 did not appear unreasonable at the moment, so in 
 after years it never faded away. God knows there 
 were periods in my career, when to accomplish 
 that, or any other object of honourable ambition, 
 seemed to be impossible, but I have lived to ac- 
 complish it. And though, perhaps, few public 
 men have had more right than I to complain of 
 the world's usage, I can never express sufficient 
 gratitude to the kind providence which permits me 
 to pass the evening of a long, and I trust not a 
 useless life, amid scenes that are endeared to me 
 by so many personal as well as traditional associ- 
 ations."" 
 
 It is much to be lamented that Mr. Hastings, 
 who, after playing so great a part on the stage of 
 life, could hardly fail to be aware, that, sooner or 
 later, he would become the subject of history, 
 should have left no memoranda behind him, from 
 which it is possible to draw out even a connected 
 outline of the mode of his existence in boyhood 
 and early youth. Even in conversation he ap- 
 peared reluctant to enter upon the subject, and
 
 10 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 when questioned respecting it, his answers were 
 always brief and general. I am led from these 
 circumstances to conclude that childhood and early 
 youth were not with him seasons of much enjoy- 
 ment, though whether overshadowed and oppressed 
 by a mere sense of dependence, or subjected to the 
 more direct and palpable mortifications which 
 dependence too often brings in its train, I cannot 
 undertake to say. All, indeed, that I have been 
 enabled to discover respecting the first stage in his 
 career amounts to this ; that he remained in the 
 country till the year 1740, when his uncle Howard, 
 of whom I have spoken as holding a situation in 
 the customs, took charge of him. 
 
 The first regular school to which he was sent, 
 was kept by Mr. Pardoe, at Newington Butts. 
 His master is said to have been a good one, but 
 Hastings himself never referred to the period of 
 his sojourn in that school with any degree of plea- 
 sure. He complained that the boys were half- 
 starved ; and attributed the delicacy of his own con- 
 stitution, and his stunted growth, in a great measure 
 to the wretched feeding at this seminary. He did 
 not remain there, however, more than two years 
 ere he was transferred to Westminster, to win 
 the honours of which, and to be elected on the 
 foundation, became immediately the object of his 
 ambition. It chanced that there were among his 
 contemporaries some of the cleverest lads of which
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 11 
 
 Westminster had for many years been able to 
 boast ; such as Lord Shelburne, Sir Elijah 
 Impey, Cowper the poet, and others, the whole 
 of whom, by the way, were his seniors in point of 
 age, some of them by not less than two years. 
 Yet nothing daunted by his acquaintance with 
 their powers, he became an intense student, inso- 
 much as well nigh to break down a frame deli- 
 cate from the first, and now more than ever fra- 
 gile. The result was, however, that when the 
 season of trial came round, his triumph was com- 
 plete. He was elected on the foundation at the 
 head of all his competitors in the year 1747, and had 
 in consequence his name engraved in golden cha- 
 racters on the wall of the dormitory, where it may 
 still be seen. 
 
 I have made many anxious inquiries relative to 
 his habits as a Westminster scholar, which have 
 obtained for me, I regret to say, but imperfect in- 
 formation. Of those who were his contemporaries 
 not one now survives ; and the memories even of 
 its most distinguished members soon fade from a 
 public school. It is said, however, that neither 
 his delicate constitution, nor his diminutive stature, 
 in the smallest degree affected his spirit. Quick 
 he was and mild, much addicted to contemplation, 
 and a hard student ; but he was likewise bold 
 when necessity required, full of fire, ambitious in 
 no ordinary degree, and anxious to excel in every
 
 12 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 thing to which he addressed himself. His fa- 
 vourite pastime appears to have been swimming, 
 in which he was very expert, and few could beat 
 him with a pair of sculls ; in other respects he was 
 much as other boys are, except that his sweet 
 temper and readiness at all times to oblige, ren- 
 dered him a universal favourite. 
 
 Hastings had been a King's scholar at West- 
 minster three years, and the greatest expectations 
 were formed of his success at the university, when 
 an event befel which gave a totally novel turn to 
 all his prospects. His kind uncle Howard died, 
 bequeathing him to the care of a Mr. Chisvrick, 
 on whom he had by relationship slender claims, 
 and who does not seem to have over-rated their 
 importance. I believe that the connexion between 
 them took its rise from the marriage of Mr. 
 Hastings's great grandfather with a lady of Mr. 
 Chiswick's family ; but how far their blood did or 
 did not flow from a common fountain I do not know. 
 It is certain, however, that Mr. Chiswick at once 
 determined that Warren should not go on with 
 his classical studies, and that Dr. Nichols, then 
 head master of the school, was informed of the 
 determination. "What," exclaimed the Doctor, 
 when his favourite pupil announced to him his 
 purpose of withdrawing from the school, " lose 
 Warren Hastings lose the best scholar of his 
 year ! That will never do at all. If the want of
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 13 
 
 means to keep you here aye, and at college too 
 be the only hinderance, we can easily remove that. 
 You shall go on with your education at my 
 charges. I cannot afford to lose the reputation 
 which I am sure to obtain through you." 
 
 The proposal most delicately made was alike 
 honourable to the master and his pupil, but it 
 could not be acceded to. For a few months 
 longer Hastings remained where he was ; but his 
 new guardian eventually withdrew him. Being 
 in the direction of the East India Company, Mr. 
 Chiswick determined to send his ward in the ca- 
 pacity of a writer to Bengal ; and, to fit him for 
 the situation, he placed him for a time under the 
 tuition of Mr. Smith, the teacher of writing and 
 accounts at Christ's Hospital. This was in 1749; 
 on the 14th of November in which year he signed 
 his petition for the proffered appointment. It was 
 acceded to immediately ; and in the month of 
 January, 1750, after fitting himself out as well as 
 his slender finances would allow, Warren Hastings 
 set sail on board the London East Indiaman for 
 the place of his destination at Calcutta.
 
 14 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 CHAPTER II. 
 
 General View of the Company's Governments in the beginning and 
 middle of the Seventeenth Century Summary of the Political State of 
 India at the same Time. 
 
 THE field of exertion on which Mr. Hastings was 
 about to enter differed in all respects so essentially 
 from that which it has since become, that, in order 
 to make the narrative of his after-life intelligible, 
 it is necessary that 1 should preface what I am 
 going to say with a brief account of it. 
 
 Early in the eighteenth century the rival East 
 India Companies, which had for several years 
 competed and wrangled for exclusive privileges, 
 brought their disputes to an end, and under the 
 title of the United Company of Merchants trading 
 to the East Indies, were by Act of Parliament 
 erected into a species of corporation. Regulating 
 their affairs at home by means of courts of pro- 
 prietors and directors, which again were presided 
 over by chairmen, and carried on the details of 
 business in committees, the company in question 
 maintained abroad three principal settlements, one 
 of which was established at Bombay, another at 
 Madras, and the third at Calcutta, or Fort 
 William, on the Hoogley. 
 
 These, which were called presidencies, were all
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 15 
 
 independent one of the other ; each exercised 
 supreme jurisdiction within its own limits, each 
 was responsible only to the home authorities, and 
 each consisted of a president or governor, and a 
 council, appointed by commission from the com- 
 pany, and by the company liable to be recalled. 
 Moreover, the council was not restricted as to 
 numbers, which, on the contrary,, varied ac- 
 cording to the views of the directors at the 
 
 a 
 
 moment, so that it consisted sometimes of nine, 
 sometimes of twelve members, according to the 
 presumed importance or extent of the business to 
 be transacted. In like manner the council was 
 made up of the superior servants of the company, 
 not belonging to the military class, who were pro- 
 moted according to the rule of seniority, except in 
 special cases where directions from home inter- 
 fered. Finally, in the president and council con- 
 jointly all power was vested, insomuch that no 
 question could be determined, nor any regulation 
 passed, except by a majority of votes. 
 
 The extent of territory over which these presi- 
 dencies respectively exercised control was in every 
 instance narrow. At Calcutta the company had 
 acquired by purchase a domain which encircled 
 their capital in a radius of perhaps seven English 
 miles. Madras caused her will to be respected as 
 far as the mount of St. Thome ; while Bombay 
 gave the law to the island of Salsette and no
 
 1C) MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 more. Other settlements there doubtless were, 
 which in various parts of India looked to one or 
 other of the presidencies as to their head ; but, 
 with the exception of Fort St. David, itself a minor 
 species of capital, and Bantam, originally a presi- 
 dency, none of them either obtained or de- 
 served titles more lofty than those of factories. 
 Such were those of Cossimbazar near Moorsheda- 
 bad, Masulapatam, on one of the mouths of the 
 Kishna, and Surat, in the bay of Cambay ; and 
 such were many others, which in this place it is not 
 necessary to particularise. 
 
 The single purpose for which these establishments 
 were erected being the prosecution of commercial 
 devices, and the management of the parties engaged 
 in them, it would be idle to try their forms of 
 government by any such test as a comparison be- 
 tween them and the colossal machinery by which 
 the affairs of British India are now kept in order. 
 Though bound by solemn engagement to act ac- 
 cording to the spirit of such instructions as might 
 be transmitted to them from home, the British 
 settlers in India were yet, in some sense, dependent 
 on the native princes ; that is to say, they held 
 their lands on such tenures as the native princes 
 might have dictated, and in all their trading 
 operations were subject to such regulations as the 
 native princes might impose. Accordingly, the 
 sale of those commodities which they imported from
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 17 
 
 Europe, they conducted for a while in the simplest 
 and easiest of all ways, namely, by sending them 
 into the interior, in the common hackeries of the 
 country, and exposing them to public auction at 
 such warehouses as in the most convenient of the 
 market towns they might have established. But 
 the confusion which ensued on the breaking up 
 of the Mogul empire rendered this mode of pro- 
 ceeding too insecure, and a rule was in conse- 
 quence adopted, which hindered any person in the 
 Company's service, or under its jurisdiction, from 
 removing far from the coast without leave obtained 
 from the governor and council of the station to 
 which he belonged. From that time forth, there- 
 fore, the care of distributing the goods into the 
 country, and introducing them to the consumers, 
 was left to the native and other independent 
 dealers. 
 
 While the import trade was thus managed, a 
 more complicated machinery was required in order 
 to purchase, and collect, and take care of the goods 
 which constituted the export trade, or freight 
 for England. As the country was not sufficiently 
 advanced in point of wealth and civilization to 
 possess manufacturers and merchants on a large 
 scale men who were capable of executing 
 extensive orders, and delivering the goods con- 
 tracted for on a specified day the Company 
 were obliged to employ their own agents to gather 
 
 VOL. i. c
 
 18 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 together, here and there, in such quantities as pre- 
 sented themselves, the different articles of which 
 the cargoes to Europe were composed. For the 
 reception of these when collected, and their safe 
 keeping till the ships from England should arrive, 
 depots or stations were needed. Hence the erec- 
 tion, at convenient points, of warehouses, counting- 
 houses, and other apartments, where the business 
 of the Company might be carried on and its agents 
 lodged : in other words, hence the establishment of 
 those factories which have already been described 
 as intimately connected with each of the presidencies 
 and dependent on them. This was the first step ; 
 and the second was the providing for the Com- 
 pany's agents who might be stationed there, ade- 
 quate protection against the attacks of marauders. 
 On the native powers, shaken by continual revolts, 
 no reliance could be placed, so the factories were 
 inclosed by works, rude perhaps, yet adapted to 
 the exigencies of the moment, and garrisoned partly 
 by the Company's civil servants, each of whom 
 was trained to the use of arms, partly by such 
 a body of regular troops as the limited resources 
 of the presidency could afford. 
 
 Of the manner in which the affairs of the fac- 
 tories were conducted, the most distinct idea will 
 be formed, provided we confine our regard to that 
 branch of the Company's trade which had for its 
 object the exportation of manufactured goods to
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 19 
 
 England. In dealing for spices and other na- 
 tural productions of the climate, the same arrange- 
 ments were substantially adopted. But the case of 
 the weavers is a specific one, and will serve our 
 purpose better than any other. I need scarcely 
 observe, that the weavers in India, like the labour- 
 ing classes in general, were then, and are now, 
 miserably poor ; that their means of subsistence 
 never exceeded the lowest point at which nature 
 can be supported, and that he who desired to obtain 
 from them a piece of manufactured cotton or silk, 
 found it necessaiy not only to supply the funds 
 wherewith to purchase the raw material, but to 
 make constant advances towards the workman's 
 maintenance while the work was going On. To 
 manage all this, to deal with each weaver sepa- 
 rately, to watch him while the web was in pro- 
 gress, so that he might not dispose of it to somebody 
 else, could not but be a transaction of excessive 
 detail ; and if the demand happened to be great, it 
 gave employment to a multitude of agents. A multi- 
 tude of agents there accordingly were at each fac- 
 tory. First, there was the European chief, with his 
 assistants more or less numerous in proportion to 
 the importance of his station. Next, there was 
 the banyan, or native secretary, through whom the 
 whole of the business was transacted. The banyan, 
 in his turn, hired a body of gomastahs, or native bro- 
 kers, at so much per month. Eachgomastah repaired
 
 20 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 to the manufacturing town which was assigned to 
 him, and fixing upon a house, which he called his 
 cutcherry, there took up his ahode. Again, the 
 gomastah was provided with a competent num- 
 ber of peons, or armed servants, and hircarrahs, or 
 messengers, whom he immediately despatched to 
 summon round him the dallals, pycars, and com- 
 mon weavers of the place. The dallals and pycars, 
 he it observed, were alike brokers, only that the 
 one class was inferior to the other ; for the pycars 
 dealt directly with the weavers, whereas the dallals 
 dealt only with pycars. Thus, between the indivi- 
 dual who produced the article required, and the agent 
 of the Company for whom he produced it, not fewer 
 than four separate agencies intervened a ready 
 means, if not a fruitful source, of trick and collusion, 
 from which the highest and the lowest of the parties 
 affected by it were almost equally sure to suffer. 
 
 Nor was it merely in giving his orders, and in 
 seeing that they were fairly executed, that the 
 chief of the factory was at once liable to be 
 himself imposed upon, and sorely tempted to 
 impose upon others. Attached to the European 
 agent, and independent of his banyan, was in every 
 instance a mohurrie or clerk, with a convenient 
 number of peons and hircarrahs. This personage 
 had the care of disbursing to the gomastah at 
 the outset as much money as he might judge suf- 
 ficient to purchase the materials out of which
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 21 
 
 the web was to be woven, as well as to afford 
 subsistence to the weaver, during at least part of 
 the time in which he might be occupied in weaving 
 it. By and bye, when the job was finished, the 
 cloth was removed into a warehouse, where each 
 separate piece was marked with the weaver's 
 name. And last of all, the gomastah held what 
 he called his kattah ; that is to say, he examined 
 each piece separately, fixed the price which ought 
 to be paid for it, and took account of the advances 
 already made to the fabricator. It was then in 
 a vast variety of instances, that the poor weaver 
 sustained his heaviest loss. The gomastah did not 
 care what price the article might fetch if exposed 
 in open market. He gave only what his own 
 generosity might suggest, and generosity in such 
 cases rarely came up to the standard of justice. 
 
 For some time after the establishment of the 
 United Company, the powers exercised by the 
 president and council were at each of the pre- 
 sidencies wholly undefined. Representing a body 
 which regarded all its agents as servants, the local, 
 authorities naturally adopted a similar tone, and 
 as the individuals who acted under them had 
 entered the service as the business of their lives, 
 no impediments to the exercise of an unlimited 
 authority were anywhere offered. For a long while, 
 indeed, the power of life and death, when dealing 
 with civilians, was not formally entrusted to them ;
 
 22 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 but they might arrest, imprison, and send to 
 England ; and they did so without scruple, on the 
 authority of the charter granted by Charles II. in 
 1661, by which the presidents and council in 
 their factories were empowered to dispense civil 
 and criminal justice according to the laws of Eng- 
 land. In 1726, however, a new order of things 
 began, when there was established at each of the 
 three presidencies a Mayor's Court, with power to 
 decide in all civil cases without restriction, though 
 subject to an appeal to the president and council. 
 In like manner the mayor and nine aldermen were 
 authorized to hold courts of quarter sessions, for 
 penal judicature, in all cases except those of high 
 treason. Finally a Court of Requests or Court of 
 Conscience was instituted, where, by summary 
 procedure, pecuniary questions, provided the 
 sums at issue were inconsiderable, might be 
 decided. It is not worth while to inquire how far 
 these tribunals did or did not serve the purposes 
 for which they were created. Men educated 
 in the details of commercial life are not always 
 qualified either by their learning or their habits of 
 thought to dispense justice fairly, while in this 
 particular instance there were jealousies at work 
 which increased their difficulties fourfold. Be- 
 tween the Mayor's Court and the Council violent 
 disputes arose ; while the one complained that its 
 authority was encroached upon, and the other
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 23 
 
 that its rights were wantonly disregarded or 
 despised. 
 
 All this while, for the administration of Indian 
 law to the natives who dwelt within the limits of 
 the Company's jurisdiction, there existed the usual 
 Zemindary courts, namely, the Phousdary for the 
 arrangement of criminal matters, the Cutcherry 
 where civil cases were heard, and the Collector's 
 Court, into which, all questions connected with 
 matters of revenue were brought. Over these the 
 Company's servants presided, being appointed by 
 the governor and council, and holding their offices 
 during pleasure ; while the rule of judgment was 
 the supposed usage of the country, or, to speak 
 more correctly perhaps, the discretion of the court. 
 Thus at each of the presidencies the judicial and 
 executive functions were combined in the persons 
 of the members of council, insomuch that the 
 power even of a justice of the peace was intrusted 
 only to them. 
 
 So far the president may be regarded as bearing 
 to his council no other relation than that of primus 
 inter pares. By indirect methods, indeed, he might 
 accomplish almost any object on which he set his 
 heart ; while ostensibly his will was dependent on 
 that of the majority of his councillors. There were, 
 however, certain departments in the management 
 of which he stood alone. Whatever forces, for ex- 
 ample, might be kept on foot for the defence of the
 
 24 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 presidency and the factories dependent on it, were 
 under bis absolute command, and in him the right of 
 nominating to commissions was exclusively vested. 
 He was the sole organ, likewise, of correspondence 
 with the native powers, whether it might be car- 
 ried on by letter or otherwise ; and to his discre- 
 tion was left the choice both of the time when its 
 results should be communicated to the council, 
 and of the most convenient method of making 
 such communication. These were important pri- 
 vileges, of the value of which every day's experience 
 gave him proof. They contributed not a little to 
 the extension of his power, and were guarded in 
 consequence with a very natural jealousy. 
 
 With respect, again, to the remainder of the 
 Company's servants, they were divided into four 
 classes, namely, writers, factors, junior merchants, 
 and senior merchants. The writer found employ- 
 ment in managing the details of business, in super- 
 intending the warehouses, and keeping accounts. 
 At the end of five years he became a factor, when 
 similar pursuits, though on a more extensive 
 scale, occupied him ; three years more saw him 
 advanced to the rank of junior merchant, whence, 
 after another period of three years, he passed into 
 the order of senior merchants. From this latter 
 class were chosen all members of council, heads of 
 factories, and, indeed, persons whom it was judged 
 expedient to employ in affairs of government :
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 25 
 
 while the president's chair itself was open to their 
 ambition, provided a vacancy should occur, and 
 the home authorities omit to fill it. 
 
 While things continued in this state, that is to 
 say during the space of almost half a century, the 
 attitude maintained by the East India Company 
 towards other powers was exceedingly humble. 
 Enemies it doubtless had, with whom its servants 
 came occasionally into collision ; but these were 
 either the interlopers whom the ports of England 
 sent forth to interfere with chartered rights, or 
 colonists from Portugal, Holland, and France, 
 who, like themselves, had taken root along the 
 shores and islands of the Indian seas. Against 
 any of the native princes the Company's servants 
 thought not, except in the last extremity, of 
 making a stand ; and as to visions of conquest and 
 dominion, these seem never to have entered into 
 their minds. Happy men were they so long as 
 the nabobs and soubahdars left them in quiet pos- 
 session of their settlements, and permitted them, 
 amid the wars and confusion which prevailed 
 around, to carry on their trade unmolested. But 
 this state of things could not endure for ever. The 
 breaking up of the Mogul empire brought such a 
 multitude of combatants into the field, that it was 
 impossible for the English to adhere to their pacific 
 policy ; and it would be hard to decide whether 
 they were more surprised or alarmed when they
 
 26 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 found themselves come forth from every quarrel 
 in which they took part the gainers. The annals 
 of the human race produce no parallel instance of 
 a people driven against their will, hy the mere 
 force of circumstances, to power and extensive 
 dominion. The East India Company desired 
 nothing more than space and room enough for the 
 maintenance of their commercial depots. The cur- 
 rent of events swept them along with it, till they 
 have become masters of the whole continent of 
 India. It will be necessary to sketch, with a 
 rapid hand, some of the principal causes which led 
 to this great issue. 
 
 The Mogul empire had attained to its utmost 
 height of grandeur but a few years prior to the 
 consolidation of the rival Companies in London. 
 Aurungzebe, the most illustrious of the descendants 
 of Baber, filled at that time the throne of Delhi, 
 and wielded his power with such vigour and effect, 
 that almost the whole of what we called India 
 obeyed his mandates. From the Indus to the 
 Brahmapooter there was scarce a district or prin- 
 cipality which refused either to accept its rulers 
 from his hands, or to pay him tribute. The Mah- 
 rattas alone, a predatory horde which had risen 
 into note about the middle of the sixteenth cen- 
 tury, offered a feeble resistance to his arms ; yet 
 even they were reduced to find shelter in the fast- 
 nesses of the Concan, whither it was difficult for
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 27 
 
 regular troops to follow them. In assuming to 
 himself, therefore, the title of Lord of all India, 
 this great man advanced no claim which the 
 actual condition of affairs appeared not to sanction ; 
 for even the Mahrattas were not regarded as a 
 rival power, but only as a nest of rebels or plun- 
 derers, whom the physical obstacles of morass and 
 deep wood hindered the Emperor's lieutenants 
 from extirpating. 
 
 While the sceptre was wielded by such a hand 
 as this, nothing could be more regular or uniform 
 than the system of administration which prevailed 
 throughout the empire. Divided into provinces, 
 which obtained various titles according to some 
 rule into the origin of which it is not worth while 
 to inquire, we find it governed by chiefs who owed 
 their nomination to the will of the sovereign, and 
 were at any moment liable to be superseded, and 
 set aside. Thus, while the capital, with a vast 
 district dependent on it, was managed under the 
 emperor, by the vizier, all that tract of territory 
 which lay south of the Nerbudda, looked to the 
 Soubahdar of the Deccan as to its immediate head. 
 In like manner, as the whole empire was divided 
 into three principal parts, so each of these was 
 subdivided into an indefinite number of lesser 
 parts. In Hindoostan, for example, there were 
 Bengal, Bahar, Oude, Malwa, and many more, 
 over each of which a distinct viceroy presided ;
 
 28 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 whilst the Deccan could boast of Arcot, the Circars, 
 Berar, and Tanjore, all managed independently one 
 of the other, yet all equally held accountable in 
 their respective governments to the Soubahdar. 
 Moreover, that the dependence of these subordinate 
 governments on the supreme power might be 
 complete, care was taken to separate in each the 
 management of the affairs of the revenue from 
 the command of the military force, and the 
 general administration of justice. Each viceroy 
 was checked and controlled by the presence at 
 his court oa dewan, or finance minister, who, like 
 the viceroy himself, obtained his nomination at 
 Delhi, and was there expected to give an account 
 of the matters which were entrusted to his charge. 
 Such an order of things was manifestly de- 
 pendent for its pliability on the personal vigour 
 and talents for business of the Emperor. While 
 Aurungzebe lived, the empire continued both 
 nominally and really a whole. His death, in 
 1707, shook the ill-assorted fabric to its base. 
 There was first a contest between his three sons 
 for the succession. There was next, the necessity 
 imposed upon the conqueror of conciliating the 
 goodwill of the chiefs who raised him to the 
 throne. There was, thirdly, the natural result 
 of civil war within the empire itself an oppor- 
 tunity afforded to the Mahrattas, of which they 
 were not slow to avail themselves, of re-establish-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 29 
 
 ing more than the semblance of a kingdom. And 
 last, and worst of all, Nadir Schah broke in 
 from Persia, and threw all things into confusion. 
 Then began viziers, soubahdars, and other gover- 
 nors of provinces, to deal with their delegated 
 power as if it were inherent in themselves, till 
 by and bye, not only was the Deccan severed from 
 the rest of the empire, but such minor chiefs as the 
 nabob of Bengal and the vice-king of Oude 
 learned to act as if they were independent 
 princes. 
 
 In the endless struggles, both foreign and do- 
 mestic, which throughout a quarter of a century 
 rent the empire to pieces, the English took no part. 
 As often as one or other of the provinces within 
 which their settlements stood became the seat of 
 war, then, indeed, the servants of the Company 
 assumed a defensive attitude, but their preparations 
 never went farther than to put themselves in a 
 condition to repel violence, should it be offered. 
 In the contest, whatever it might be, which was 
 going on, they did their best to preserve a strict 
 neutrality. On the other hand, the native princes, 
 as w r ell during the vigour as in the decline 
 of the empire, treated them on almost all occa- 
 sions with singular favour. Partly because they 
 reaped large profits from the European trade, 
 partly because they did not as yet see reason to be 
 jealous of a few European settlers on the coast,
 
 30 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 they not only permitted them to dwell at peace, 
 but extended to them commercial privileges far 
 greater than those which were granted to the 
 native merchants. Accordingly, neither the revo- 
 lutions which went on at Delhi, nor the establish- 
 ment of an independent sovereignty in the Dec- 
 can, in any way interfered with the routine of 
 business. Continuing, at least in Bengal, to pay 
 to the public treasurers the sums which had been 
 fixed as composition in lieu of transit duties, they 
 sent their agents and servants as usual into the 
 interior ; and found that their dusticks, or pass- 
 ports, were universally respected, wherever there 
 existed any thing like a settled government. 
 
 With these privileges the English were content, 
 and had they been the only European settlers in 
 India, it is extremely probable that they never 
 would have looked beyond them. But they were 
 not the only European settlers in India ; the 
 French, after repeated efforts, had succeeded, about 
 1720, in establishing themselves both among the 
 islands and on the continent; and being at all 
 times more disposed to indulge in dreams of glory 
 than in details of business, they soon began to 
 play a part in the political game which they 
 beheld in progress round them. Their first great 
 measure was to carry the war, which broke out in 
 1744, between France and England, to the distant 
 shores of the Carnatic. Being greatly superior
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 31 
 
 both by sea and land, they made themselves 
 masters of Madras, and reduced the affairs of the 
 English East India Company to a very low ebb. 
 But the peace of Aix-la-Chapelle restored to the 
 Company their ancient local capital, and in some 
 degree forced upon them a change of policy. I 
 am not going to repeat the thrice told tale of the 
 great war of succession in the Carnatic ; far less 
 to contrast with the magnificence of M. Dupleix's 
 views, the petty devices and ill-assorted schemes 
 of his rival. My purpose is sufficiently served 
 when I state that the treaty of concord was scarce 
 ratified between them, when the French and the 
 English Companies found themselves arrayed on 
 opposite sides, in a struggle which, begun for the 
 ostensible purpose of giving a nabob to the Car- 
 natic, was, in point of fact, to decide by which of 
 these two European nations the destinies of India 
 were to be guided. 
 

 
 32 MEMOIRS OP WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 CHAPTER III. 
 
 Hastings arrives in India Employed in the Secretary's Office Removed 
 to Cossimbazar Rupture with Suraj ud Dowlah War Hastings serves 
 as a Volunteer Suraj ud Dowlah dethroned Hastings' first Marriage. 
 
 SUCH was the condition of affairs in Indira, as 
 related both to the Company and the native powers, 
 when Warren Hastings made his first appearance 
 on a stage where he was destined, by and bye, to 
 play so conspicuous a part. The war of the Car- 
 natic was in full progress, and all the powers of 
 the Deccan, including the Mahrattas as well as 
 the English and the French, took part in it. North 
 of the Nerbudda, there was confusion in every 
 quarter. Ihe emperor Ahmed Shaw, threatened 
 on all sides by his refractory chiefs, was without 
 power in his own capital. The Rohillas, in open re- 
 bellion, had not only established for themselves a 
 sort of independence, but threatened to give law to 
 Delhi itself, while the Mahrattas, in possession of 
 all that tract of country which extends from Orissa 
 to the Western Ocean and from Agra to the Car- 
 natic, were become a terror and a scourge to the 
 surrounding provinces. From the three eastern go- 
 vernments alone, the valour and ceaseless activity of 
 Alaverdi Cawn excluded them ; and even he, in 
 his extreme old age, was glad to purchase rest from
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 33 
 
 unceasing warfare by partial submission. Yet in 
 the midst of all these troubles the English con- 
 tinued to maintain themselves, not by the terror 
 of their arms, or their skill in diplomacy, but as a 
 body of merchants, and nothing more. It is true 
 that when the alarm of the Mahratta invasion was 
 at its height, they applied to the Nabob for per- 
 mission to fortify the presidency, and having ob- 
 tained it, they threw up a citadel, and dug a ditch : 
 but Alaverdi, though he so far yielded to the ne- 
 cessities of the case, was immovable on another 
 point concerning which they experienced at least 
 as much anxiety. He would on no account permit 
 them to interfere with the French settlement at 
 Chandernagore, insisting that whatever grounds of 
 quarrel there might be among the Europeans in 
 distant regions, the peace of his country should 
 not be disturbed by them. Accordingly while in 
 the sister presidency of Madras men planned and 
 fought for political ascendancy, in Calcutta there 
 was at least the semblance of repose ; and the 
 affairs of trade went forward as briskly as the 
 straitened means at the command of the Com- 
 pany would allow. 
 
 Into a community thus circumstanced, Warren 
 Hastings, on the 8th of October, 1750, made his 
 entrance. He did not come alone, for I find 
 among his papers a fragment which, touching upon 
 
 VOL. I. D
 
 34 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 the principal events of his boyish days, states that 
 he was the last of eight young men who composed 
 the list of the establishment for that year. Un- 
 fortunately, however, I cannot find more : " This 
 is all," says he, " that I shall retain in writing of 
 my private history, though the particulars of it if 
 known might afford much subject of curious spe- 
 culation, both from their influence on the temper 
 and disposition of mind which constituted my 
 public character, and from one circumstance of 
 peculiar uniformity attending the whole course of 
 my existence to its present moment, and probably 
 to its ultimate and now not remote period that of 
 a solitary insulated wanderer through life, placed 
 by His will who governs all things, in a situation 
 to give birth to events which were connected with 
 the interests of nations ; which were invariably 
 prosperous to those of his own, but productive to 
 himself of years of depression and persecution, and 
 of the chances of want only relieved by occasional, 
 and surely providential means; though never af- 
 fecting the durable state of his mental tranquillity." 
 How much is it to be regretted that he who could 
 thus express himself, should have been induced by 
 any consideration of inferior worth, to withhold so 
 great a lesson from mankind ; for there can be little 
 doubt that matters of which he speaks as the sources 
 of " curious speculation," would have conveyed
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 35 
 
 to such as examined them with a philosophic eye, 
 instruction of the gravest kind, and on the most 
 important of all human subjects. 
 
 I took occasion in a previous chapter to explain 
 the nature of the duties which were imposed, at 
 the period of which we are now speaking, on 
 junior civil servants of the Company. To these, 
 on his arrival, Hastings proceeded to apply him- 
 self, though under whose auspices, or with what 
 degree of relish on his own part, there are no 
 records in existence which authorize me to say. 
 All that I have been able to ascertain, indeed, in 
 reference to this portion of his career is, that he 
 remained two full years in Calcutta, during which 
 he was employed as an assistant in the secretary's 
 office ; and that on the 1st of October, 1753, he 
 was removed to the factory at Cossimbazar. 
 There, as well as in the capital, his occupations 
 were for a time such as fell to the lot of junior ser- 
 vants in general. He had little else to attend to 
 than matters of detail, and we know nothing of 
 him farther than that he seems to have trodden, 
 unnoticed and therefore conscientiously, the even 
 tenor of his way. For though an anonymous 
 writer in the Gentleman's Magazine has described 
 him as devoting much of his time to the acquisition 
 of the Persian language, Mr. Hastings himself, in 
 certain manuscript notes which are now before me, 
 gives no countenance to the statement. " I never 
 acquired," he says, " a profound knowledge of the 
 
 D>2
 
 36 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 Persian, and what I did know of it was acquired 
 only from official practice." 
 
 Throughout a space of rather more than two 
 years, subsequently to his settlement at Cos- 
 simbazar, there occurred but a single event 
 in the personal history of Warren Hastings of 
 which it is necessary to make mention. This 
 was his nomination in 1755, to the council at the 
 factory, an office of greater trust and more liberal 
 emolument than he had yet held ; for of his move- 
 ments from point to point, according as the exigen- 
 cies of the moment chancedto require, nothing more 
 can be said than they were all in the ordinary 
 routine of the service. But Hastings had fallen 
 upon times when each new day might be expected 
 to bring with it such changes as should affect the 
 fortunes, not of individuals only, but of nations. 
 Alaverdi Cawn, the steady friend of the English, 
 was a very old man, whose death might from time 
 to time be expected, while the person whom he 
 had chosen to be his successor on the musnud 
 was well known to regard all foreigners with less 
 than indifference. And the calamity, so long an- 
 ticipated, befel at last. On the 17th of January, 
 1756, the aged Nabob gave up the ghost. The 
 throne was immediately seized by his grandson 
 Suraj ud Dowlah, and the worst fears of those who 
 knew him best, and entertained the gravest appre- 
 hensions from his violence, were more than realized. 
 
 Of the occurrences that followed, including the
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 37 
 
 Nabob's cruelty to his relations, his breach with 
 the English, and subsequent march upon Fort 
 William, I am not in this place required to give 
 an account. They are but little connected, at 
 least directly, with the personal history of the great 
 man whose biographer I have undertaken to be ; 
 neither can I discover among his papers any scrap 
 or fragment, which seems to throw a new light 
 upon them. Yet were they in their results of the 
 gravest importance to him. It is well known 
 that when the factory at Cossimbazar surrendered, 
 he, with Mr. Watts, and the rest of the Europeans 
 employed there, became prisoners to Suraj ud 
 Dowlah. They were sent off without loss of time 
 to Moorshedabad, where, however, they not only 
 suffered no violence, but appear to have been 
 treated with much kindness. " I was made a 
 prisoner," says Mr. Hastings, in a memorandum 
 which has been preserved, " but permitted to go 
 at large ; Mr. Vynett, the chief of the Dutch 
 factory at Cullapore, giving bail for my appear- 
 ance." Nor is this all : " Mr. Drake," continues 
 the same memorandum, " and his council wrote to 
 me from Fullta, the place of their residence near 
 the mouth of the river after their flight from 
 Calcutta, desiring me to send them intelligence 
 from Moorshedabad, and to that correspondence 
 I owe my first consequence in the service." 
 The correspondence alluded to in this extract is
 
 38 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 to be found among the records at the India House. 
 It places the character of Hastings, considered as 
 a public man, in an exceedingly favourable light, 
 and shows that already his judgment, as well as 
 political courage, had matured itself; but it is at 
 once too voluminous and too technical to warrant 
 the insertion of any portion of it here. I content 
 myself, therefore, with giving its substance in my 
 own words ; nothing doubting that even this im- 
 perfect view of the case will sufficiently justify 
 Mr. Hastings in his encouragement of the honest 
 pride, with which in after life he never failed to 
 look back upon it. 
 
 It will not be forgotten, that when Fort William 
 ceased to be tenable ; or, to speak more accu- 
 rately, when their personal fears represented it in 
 this light to themselves, Mr. Drake, the governor, 
 with a large portion both of the European and 
 native inhabitants, fled to their ships, and left the 
 garrison to its fate. The fugitives took shelter in 
 Fullta, an island of the Hoogley ; narrow in its 
 dimensions, and perfectly barren ; where they estab- 
 lished themselves in absolute dependence on the 
 fleet, even for the means of subsistence from day 
 to day. Expresses having been previously sent off 
 to apprise the Madras government of their dan- 
 ger, they flattered themselves that from that quar- 
 ter supplies would reach them ; but long before 
 any such could arrive, the horrors of famine began
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 39 
 
 to stare them in the face. Under these circum- 
 stances, they came to the conclusion that it would 
 be best to throw themselves on the clemency of the 
 Nabob at once ; and Major Kill pat rick was directed 
 to write in a submissive tone to request that a 
 supply of provisions might be afforded them. 
 
 This letter the Dutch authorities at Chinsura 
 refused to forward ; as indeed they had previously 
 declined all interference in the business : where- 
 upon Major Killpatrick sent it to Mr. Hastings, 
 with a request that he would get it translated into 
 Persian, and place it, without loss of time, in the 
 hands of Suraj ud Dowlah. 
 
 Mr. Hastings so far obeyed these instructions, 
 that he caused the letter to be translated into 
 Persian ; but he did not present it : because he 
 believed that the moment was unfavourable for 
 such a course, and his moral courage did not shrink 
 from the responsibility of avoiding it. The nabob 
 was involved in difficulties nearer home, which, 
 according to Mr. Hastings's view of the matter, 
 might render him anxious for an accommodation 
 with the English almost on their own terms. 
 It appeared that the rebellious governor of Pur- 
 neah was not only determined to keep his place, 
 but that having obtained from the emperor a com- 
 mission which nominated him to the nabobship of 
 Bengal, he was in arms to assert his claim to the
 
 40 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 latter dignity. Meanwhile Suraj ud Dowlah, 
 the slave of his own passions, and as treacherous 
 as he was violent, had quarrelled with his chiefs, 
 both civil and military ; one of whom, Jugge-seat, 
 he cast into prison, because he presumed to remon- 
 strate against a plan which was proposed for 
 exacting a large sum of money from the merchants. 
 Such an act of violence and folly could not be 
 endured even at Moorshedabad. Jaffier Aly 
 Cawn, the commander in chief of the army, with 
 othej: leaders subordinate to him, instead of push- 
 ing, as they had been desired, against the rival 
 Nabob, returned to the capital, and throwing down 
 their arms, declared that they would never take 
 them up again unless a regular phirmaun should 
 be procured from Delhi, and Jugge-seat restored to 
 freedom. Nor was this all. Intelligence came 
 in that the emperor, with his son and vizier, were 
 on their march to reduce the provinces. The 
 Mahrattas, too, were moving : in a word the 
 affairs of the nabob were in absolute confusion. 
 
 It was Mr. Hastings's opinion that the interests 
 of the Company would be best served by abstain- 
 ing, under such circumstances, from all negocia- 
 tions, particularly as the English were never 
 spoken of at court in terms which implied the 
 continuance of a hostile feeling towards them. 
 But his views were not approved of at Fullta. He
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 41 
 
 was again directed to present the letter, and again 
 had the boldness to hesitate : indeed, when he 
 did act upon the suggestions of his superiors at last, 
 it was with such excellent skill, that by Suraj 
 ud Dowlah the extremities to which the English 
 were reduced seem never to have been surmised. 
 Hastings kept his letter by him till the cloud 
 which hung over the Nabob's fortunes appeared to 
 have dispersed, and then he laid it, not before the 
 Nabob himself, but before his dewan, whose dis- 
 position was friendly. The results were that a 
 bazaar was opened, by means of which the wants 
 of the fugitives were supplied, without any abject 
 display of weakness or anxiety on their parts ; of 
 which Suraj ud Dowlah would have certainly 
 availed himself only to aggravate their sufferings 
 and establish a permanent influence over them. 
 
 Besides this, I find in the disjointed papers that 
 have reached me, traces of another secret intrigue 
 in which Mr. Hastings was at this time engaged ; 
 but which, as he never seems to have approved of it, 
 either in its details or its design, so in his hands, 
 at least, it came to nothing. I allude to a secret 
 correspondence with Jugge-seat, and others of the 
 discontented merchants and nobles of Moorshe- 
 dabad, into which, at the suggestion of Ormachund, 
 a name of ill-omen in Indian history, the English 
 were prevailed upon to enter. As far as I can
 
 42 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 trace the story, it is this. Ormachund, a traitor 
 doubly dyed, who has been compassionated in the 
 termination of his career, only because care has not 
 been taken to watch his history in its previous 
 stages, appears already to have conceived the idea 
 of aiming at a revolution in Bengal. A revolution 
 in Bengal, however, would not serve his purpose, 
 unless the English should be persuaded to commit 
 themselves to its accomplishment ; because his 
 single object was to extract money either from 
 their fears or their ambition, and the annals of 
 the times have recorded how nearly he had suc- 
 ceeded. Accordingly, having persuaded the mem- 
 bers of council that the project was feasible, he 
 wrote in their name a letter to Jugge-seat ; which 
 letter they caused their native secretary to tran- 
 scribe; and then sent it to Mr. Hastings, with 
 general instructions how to proceed. I do not 
 feel myself in a condition to trace out the mean- 
 derings of this extravagant scheme, further than 
 to state, that the part played in it by Mr. Hastings 
 was very inconsiderable. Ormachund, indeed, 
 appears to have established for himself a good 
 name with his employers, which he retained only 
 till the superior sagacity of Lord Clive brought 
 the truth to light : but his plot came to nothing ; 
 and Mr. Hastings, whether betrayed by him or 
 not, found his situation at Moorshedabad so un-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 43 
 
 comfortable, that he was glad to make his escape 
 as soon as possible, first to Chunar and ultimately 
 to the island of Fullta. 
 
 Of the events that followed, including the defeat 
 and death of the Purneah nabob, the return of 
 Suraj ud Dowlah to his capital, and the arrival of 
 Admiral Watson and Colonel Clive in the river, 
 it is unnecessary for me to make any particular 
 mention. Neither is it my province to describe 
 the military operations that ensued, as well for the 
 recovery of Fort William as subsequently to that 
 achievement ; but I am bound to put the fact upon 
 record, that in most of these, including the battle 
 of Booj-booje_, and the several affairs in front of 
 the presidency when the Nabob for the second 
 time invested it, Mr. Hastings took personally a 
 share. He carried a firelock as a volunteer, and 
 did his duty as became him. It would seem, 
 moreover, that even in those stirring times, other 
 and more suitable employment was found for 
 talents like his than that of the simple musketeer. 
 While the Nabob hesitated in carrying matters to 
 an extremity, and desired, after the recapture of 
 Fort William, to try the effect of negociation, Mr. 
 Hastings was appointed, in connexion with Mr. 
 Amyatt, to act as the representative of his nation ; 
 and in this, as in former instances, the conduct of 
 the youthful diplomatist fully justified his seniors 
 in the choice which they had made. The nego-
 
 44 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 ciation terminated, it is true, unsatisfactorily for 
 the present ; that is to say, to the demands made 
 by the English, Suraj ud Dowlah would not 
 consent ; but of the wisdom of the demands them- 
 selves nobody enterta ned a doubt, and after a 
 second trial of strength in the field they were, in 
 the most important, at least, of their stipulations, 
 cheerfully conceded. 
 
 Of the judicious behaviour of Messrs. Hastings 
 and Amyatt while conducting this business we 
 require no better proof than is afforded by the 
 tone of bitterness which marked a future corre- 
 spondence between the Nabob and Colonel Clive. 
 After the repulse of the former from before Fort 
 William, and his flight upon Moorshedabad, he 
 lost no time in reopening the negociation ; and it 
 is worthy of remark, that for the abortive issues 
 in which it had terminated at the first, he laid 
 all the blame upon the English Commissioners. 
 They had treated him, he said, with intolerable 
 insolence and neglect. They had misrepresented 
 him to his friend the English commander. They 
 had entirely mistaken, either through ignorance 
 or malice, the amount of the concessions which he 
 was willing to make. In a word, he accepted the 
 terms, the proposal of which by Mr. Hastings had 
 so violently excited his anger, and promised ample 
 compensation for the losses sustained both by the 
 Company and by individuals during the war. On
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 45 
 
 one point only, arid I notice it because its conse- 
 quences proved by and bye to be very serious, the 
 second treaty differed essentially from the first. 
 Into the former a clause had been introduced 
 which secured from search and molestation of every 
 sort, all boats and goods, protected by the Com- 
 pany's dustuck, while in progress to and from 
 Fort William. From the second this clause was 
 entirely omitted ; and out of that omission arose,, 
 beyond all doubt, the misunderstanding and wrongs 
 which gave its character to a future period of 
 English history in India. 
 
 The peace thus concluded with Suraj ud Dowlah 
 was felt by Colonel Clive to be necessary, how- 
 ever, little he may have ventured to count upon 
 the chances of its continuance. For a full month 
 previous to the ratification of the treaty both he 
 and Admiral Watson had known that there was 
 war declared and actually begun between England 
 and France ; and independently of their apprehen- 
 sions of the arrival on the coast of reinforcements 
 to the French garrison at Chandernagore, they 
 justly dreaded the co-operation of the troops 
 already in occupation of that place with the 
 numerous, though undisciplined, armies of the 
 Nabob of Bengal. Besides, Bussey was not far 
 distant, M. Law was nearer at hand, and the 
 union of all or even a portion of their respective 
 corps with Suraj ud Dowlah must give to him a
 
 46 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 preponderancy such as the English would find 
 themselves unable to sustain. Hence the readiness 
 with which, in the moment of victory, Clive con- 
 sented to treat; and hence, too, another act of 
 statesmanship of which, to say the least of it, the 
 morality is much more questionable. The governor 
 of Chandernagore had been kept quiet during the 
 progress of hostilities with the Nabob by the esta- 
 blishment between him and the English of a 
 system of strict neutrality. But the necessity to 
 the English of adhering to that system no sooner 
 ceased to be felt than Clive made up his mind to 
 abandon it, and preparations were forthwith set 
 on foot to reduce the French settlements in Ben- 
 gal. In spite of a stout resistance, and in defiance 
 of protests and reclamations, these, one after an- 
 other, were captured. Great and not unmerited 
 offence was thus, for the third time, given to Suraj 
 ud Dowlah ; and for the third time both parties 
 braced themselves to a renewal of the struggle. 
 
 With the progress and results of this last and 
 decisive struggle every reader of history is 
 acquainted. Meer Jaffier, the Nabob's commander- 
 in-chief, having been gained over by Clive, pro- 
 mised to join the English on the day of battle ; 
 and the English in consequence pushed on to 
 Plassey, where they encountered and overthrew the 
 flower of the Bengal army. This was followed by 
 the triumphant entry of the victors into Moorshe
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 47 
 
 dabad ; by the flight, and capture, and death of 
 Suraj ud Dowlah ; by the formal advancement of 
 Meer Jaffier to the throne ; and by the ratification 
 of a treaty of eternal friendship and alliance be- 
 tween him and the East India Company. It is 
 scarcely necessary to add, that the terms of this 
 treaty were in every respect favourable to the 
 English. Besides ample gratuities to the imme- 
 diate actors in the drama, enormous presents made 
 to Clive, to Watson, and to the officers and men 
 serving under them, the new Nabob undertook to 
 make large advances to the Company, under the 
 plea of remunerating them for the expenses of the 
 war; to confirm all the privileges, both of territory 
 and commerce, which had been granted to them by 
 his predecessors, and to exclude the French, and 
 indeed all other European nations, from forming 
 establishments within his coasts. Finally, he 
 consented to receive at his durbar an English 
 resident, with the right of constant access to the 
 Nabob's presence ; and Mr. Scrafton being nomi- 
 nated to the important office, Clive reported to 
 his employers in Leadenhall-street that the tran- 
 quillity of the country was restored. 
 
 Great things were by these means doubtless 
 accomplished, yet they proved but the preludes to 
 greater still. It very soon appeared that having 
 given a nabob to Bengal the English were bound to 
 maintain him there ; and the endeavour to do so
 
 48 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 involved them in transactions with which, as the 
 biographer of Warren Hastings, I am very little 
 concerned. There broke out at Patna, for ex- 
 ample, a conspiracy which, without the assistance 
 of the English, MeerJaffier declared himself unable 
 to repress, and troops were in consequence sent to 
 his support. By and bye the resident reported that 
 " avarice had taken such deep root in the Nabob's 
 mind that it would be very difficult, if not im- 
 possible, to make him comply with the remaining 
 half of the treaty in ready money." Yet the truth 
 seems to have been that Meer Jaffier, in his eager- 
 ness to ascend a throne, had promised a great deal 
 more than the low condition of his exchequer 
 and the impoverished state of the provinces could 
 afford ; and that the English, entirely discrediting 
 this fact, charged upon avarice a delay which 
 originated in the absolute exhaustion of his means. 
 Still the same policy which had dictated his ele- 
 vation to the musnud required that he should be 
 supported there. Accordingly while they conti- 
 nued to press the liquidation of the debt, and 
 urged him to mortgage his very revenues should 
 the measure be necessary, they never withdrew 
 from him their military protection, which abund- 
 antly sufficed to put down rebellion wherever it 
 chanced to appear, and checked the progress of a 
 hostile movement which the Mogul himself seemed 
 at one period disposed to make.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 49 
 
 Of the part played by Mr. Hastings in the 
 management of these affairs, or whether he played 
 any part in their management at all, I am entirely 
 ignorant. Not a scrap has been preserved of his 
 correspondence during this stage of his career from 
 which it might be possible to collect a scintilla of 
 information, and tradition, as may well be imagined, 
 has long died out. Yet I learn, from the same 
 source which has more than once availed me already, 
 that at least one event occurred in the interval 
 between the commencement and the termination of 
 these great revolutions, which could not fail se- 
 riously to affect him for good or for evil ; I allude 
 to his marriage, in 1756, with the widow of a 
 Captain Campbell, who seems to have died in the 
 military service of the Company, but concerning 
 whom no other record has been preserved. With 
 this lady Mr. Hastings formed an acquaintance 
 during the occupation by the fugitives from Fort 
 William of the island of Fullta. He paid his 
 addresses to her, was accepted, and in due time 
 made her his wife. But the union, whether happy 
 or the reverse for on that head, too, tradition is 
 silent was not of long continuance. After bring- 
 ing him two children, one of whom, a daughter, 
 died on the nineteenth day after its birth, while the 
 other, a boy, survived only long enough to be sent 
 home for the purposes of education, Mrs. Hastings 
 fell a victim to the climate, and was buried by her 
 
 VOL. i. E
 
 50 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 husband at Cossimbazar, where, at the period of 
 her last illness, he was resident. These are but 
 meagre details of the early life of one whom Pro- 
 vidence had destined in after years to fill so large 
 a space in the minds of his contemporaries. Yet 
 they are all that a long and patient research have 
 enabled me to offer, and I therefore pass at once, 
 not less disappointed than my reader, to what may 
 be termed a graver chapter in this history.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 51 
 
 CHAPTER IV. 
 
 His residence at the Court of Moorshedabad Correspondence with Lord 
 Clive Wins the good opinion of his Employers. 
 
 HITHERTO the career of Warren Hastings, though 
 abundantly honourable to so young a man, had 
 been of necessity obscure ; the time was now come 
 when for the exercise of his talents a wider and 
 more appropriate field should be opened. Sir 
 John Malcolm has said that it was Clive who first 
 took notice of the young civilian's rare aptitude for 
 public business, and placed him in a situation 
 favourable to the development of his powers. I 
 have no doubt that the statement is substantially 
 correct ; yet let honour be given where it is due, 
 even in a minor degree. In the records at the 
 India House it appears that Mr. Watts had some 
 share in this excellent work, inasmuch as it was 
 during Mr. Watts's temporary occupation of the 
 president's chair at Fort William that Hastings 
 was removed from the factory at Cossimbazar and 
 placed about the Nabob's person at Moorshedabad. 
 But the appointment, as first settled, had this ano- 
 malous character attached to it, that it neither 
 withdrew Hastings absolutely from his duties as 
 member of council at the factory, nor gave him all 
 
 E2
 
 52 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 the powers which of right belong to a resident at 
 the court of a native prince. Still it was in every 
 point of view creditable to so young a servant of the 
 Company, because indicative of the perfect confi- 
 dence which his superiors reposed in him, and the 
 duties attached to it, arduous as they were, he dis- 
 charged entirely to their satisfaction. He collected, 
 with infinite difficulty, a considerable portion of the 
 outstanding balances that were due from Meer 
 Jaffier to the Company ; he put down, by the 
 exercise of a sound discretion, more than one 
 tumult in the city ; he conducted many delicate nego- 
 ciations both with the Nabob and his great officers of 
 state, so as to call for the warm approbation of the 
 council ; and he rendered to the Company another 
 service, which was regarded at the moment as not 
 the least important of the whole. In the course of 
 his indefatigable inquiries into the real state of the 
 relations between the body which he represented 
 and the prince at whose court he was resident, 
 Hastings discovered that the title by which the 
 company held the territories recently granted to 
 them by Meer Jaffier, was, in point of fact, good for 
 nothing. He lost no time in communicating the 
 circumstance to his employers, and immediately on 
 the receipt of instructions to that effect, set himself 
 to the task of rectifying the error. Such a task 
 could not be accomplished without some difficulty, 
 but accomplished it ultimately was ; for Mr. Has-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 53 
 
 tings ceased not to importune the durbar on the 
 subject, and had the satisfaction of transmitting to 
 Fort William a new deed, which, instead of ren- 
 dering the Company's tenure of the twenty-four 
 pergunnahs dependent on the caprice of each suc- 
 cessive nabob, gave to them the sovereignty over 
 the district both then and for ever. 
 
 It would be a tedious tale to tell were I to relate 
 how Hastings was harassed and annoyed all this 
 Avhile by the intrigues of the natives Avith whom 
 he came in contact, whether they represented the 
 interests of the nabob, or acted as collectors of 
 the revenues of different zemindaries under the 
 Company. The atmosphere in which the Asiatics 
 seem alone to live is one of chicanery, and it rarely 
 happens, even to this day, that an European can 
 pretend, till after long and patient study of their 
 character, to follow them through the labyrinth 
 into which they are continually diverging. But the 
 opportunities of twisting and turning, as well as 
 the inducements to take advantage of such oppor- 
 tunities, are in these clays comparatively few, 
 whereas at the period of which I am now speaking 
 they were without number. Thus I find Mr. 
 Hastings called upon at one moment to counteract 
 the devices of the nabob's agent, who endeavours 
 to appropriate to his master's use revenues that had 
 been granted to the Company. At another a native 
 in the Company's service pushes himself, as it
 
 54 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 were, into Mr. Hastings's province, and succeeds, 
 very much to the chagrin of the latter, in getting 
 his schemes sanctioned by the council at Fort 
 William. Then we have rival gomastahs some 
 whom the factory at Cossimbazar had nominated, 
 others who profess to act by authority of Clive 
 squabbling at different stations and impeding the 
 progress of the public service, because each is 
 anxious to appropriate to himself the profits of 
 agency and commission on the goods manufactured. 
 And when we go farther, we see the Nabob at 
 variance with his finance minister ; the Nabob's son 
 building up a party of his own ; governors of pro- 
 vinces on the eve of revolt, because they either are 
 or believe themselves to be marked out for destruc- 
 tion ; and the very troops in open mutiny from time 
 to time, because tiieir pay is always in arrear. I 
 will not, however, attempt to go into a detail of 
 matters in themselves neither interesting nor in- 
 structive, but content myself with transcribing so 
 much of Mr. Hastings's correspondence during 
 their progress as may throw some light upon the 
 general nature of his position and the frame of 
 mind with which he set himself to meet and over- 
 come its difficulties. 
 
 The following, which is dated Moraudbaug, 
 12th of August, 1758, explains the circumstances 
 under which Hastings emerged from the obscurity 
 of an export and warehouse keeper at Cossim-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 55 
 
 bazar. It is addressed to the Honourable Robert 
 Clive, Esq., president and governor of Fort 
 William : 
 
 Honourable Sir, Mr. Watts acquainted me when he 
 was at this place, that he had orders from the Board at 
 Calcutta, to appoint me the resident for the Company 
 at Moraudbaug, in the room of Mr. Scrafton, who has 
 accordingly delivered over the management of the 
 affairs at this place to my charge. I have already been 
 introduced by Mr. Watts to the Nabob and the prin- 
 cipal persons of this city, but as this is very insufficient 
 to give me that credit and influence which a person in 
 this station ought to be invested with, I request the 
 favour of you, Sir, to give me letters to the Nabob and 
 Chuta* nabob, recommending me strongly to their 
 notice as a person appointed by your direction, and the 
 Company's agent at this place for the management of 
 all affairs at the Durbar. The same introduction, I 
 think, would be necessary to the Seats and Roy 
 Doolub, whenever he may return. 
 
 The Nabob being now on his way to Calcutta, should 
 it meet with your approval, it would be of signal service 
 to me were you to mention me to him as a person in 
 whom you have a confidence, and recommend me to 
 him in that light. I need not mention to you, Sir, how 
 necessary it will be to give me some consequence on 
 my first introduction to an employ of such importance, 
 as on this my success in it will in a great measure en- 
 tirely depend ; which consideration, I hope, will excuse 
 my giving you this trouble. 
 
 As I look upon myself to be indebted principally to 
 you for my being allotted to this office, of whatsoever 
 advantage it may prove to me with respect to my own 
 private interest, I think it incumbent on me to make 
 
 * Young nabob that is, the nabob's son.
 
 56 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 my sincere acknowledgments to you for your favour- 
 able intentions herein, which I cannot do better than 
 by a constant attention to the business intrusted to my 
 charge, and my earnest endeavours to promote the in- 
 terest of the Company as far as my capacity will enable 
 me, in which I hope I shall have the good fortune to 
 meet with your approbation. 
 
 There are certain references in this letter to men 
 and things, and more will occur hereafter, which 
 seem to require explanation. Mr. Hastings speaks 
 of the Nabob as on his way to Calcutta, and requests 
 letters of introduction to the Seats and Roy Doolub 
 whenever he shall return. The Seats, as per- 
 haps it is unnecessary to explain, were wealthy 
 Hindoo bankers, of whom Roy Doolub was the chief. 
 But Roy Doolub was more than a banker. He had 
 held office under both Alaverdi Gawn and Suraj 
 ud Dowlah as dewan or principal minister of 
 finance, and had been largely instrumental in accom- 
 plishing the revolution which placed Meer Jaffier 
 on the throne of Bengal. Yet the latter no sooner 
 found himself secure on his seat than he began to 
 exhibit an unfriendly disposition to wards his dewan. 
 The truth, indeed, is, that Meer Jaffier was not slow 
 in discovering that he had promised a great deal 
 more as the price of his elevation than the ex- 
 hausted state of the provinces would enable him 
 honestly to make good. The money at his disposal 
 was soon paid away, his jewels and plate were in 
 like manner disposed of, the revenues were antici-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 57 
 
 pated in many quarters, and still he was in arrear. 
 Under these circumstances, he began, according to 
 the habits of his race and country, to look with an 
 evil eye upon every person who so much as seemed 
 to be possessed of property, and Roy Doolub, being 
 a very wealthy man, was, among others, marked 
 out for destruction. 
 
 It was not the least curious among the many 
 curious pictures which our native alliances at that 
 time presented, that we took not only sovereign 
 princes, but their subjects and servants, under our 
 especial protection. The Company had given the 
 throne of Bengal to Jaffier ; yet the Company was 
 under engagements to support Roy Doolub and 
 other Hindoo nobles, such as the governor of 
 Patna, Ramnarrain, against all attempts to deal 
 unjustly towards them, even by the Nabob himself. 
 Now this circumstance, though it withheld the 
 Nabob from open wrong and violence, served also 
 to chafe his pride, and to whet the feeling of 
 rancour whicli he entertained towards his subordi- 
 nates. He saw that they looked more to the 
 English than to him ; and as he Avas the first 
 sovereign of Bengal before whom these English 
 had not stood as suppliants, he could not but be 
 conscious that the position which he filled was a 
 degraded one. He began, therefore, to lay plans 
 for the ruin of his own subjects ; and when, by the 
 vigilance of the Company's servants, his schemes
 
 58 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 were detected and overthrown, the hostility which 
 at first had been directed exclusively against the 
 Hindoos, extended its bitterness to them. Not 
 yet, however, had this disposition displayed itself 
 to a degree, at least, that was calculated to produce 
 anxiety. The dovvnfal and plunder of Roy Doolub 
 was his great object ; and it was in the hope of 
 being able to lead Clive into an acquiescence in 
 these views that he made the journey to Calcutta, 
 to which the preceding letter alludes. 
 
 Meanwhile Roy Doolub, and his countrymen in 
 general, were not ignorant of the Nabob's inten- 
 tions respecting them. In the provinces several 
 were strengthening themselves for a contest, and 
 even Roy Doolub had on one occasion been besieged 
 in his house ; but Mr. Scrafton, who then resided 
 at the Durbar, interfered, and peace was, at least 
 in appearance, restored. Then was permission 
 obtained for Roy Doolub to accompany his master 
 to Calcutta, and he went accordingly. But though 
 the dewan himself was thus personally safe, he 
 had left to the mercy of the Chuta nabob his wife 
 and daughter, with his brothers, who held office 
 under him, and these he was desirous to remove. 
 The following correspondence I give, not only be- 
 cause in themselves the letters are exceedingly 
 characteristic of the writers, but because they show 
 at once the sort of control under which Hastings 
 acted, and the frankness with which, when he
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 59 
 
 believed that his superior was in error, he, in 
 no wise refusing to obey, entered his protest 
 against the proposed measure. 
 
 From Colonel CLIVE to Mr. HASTINGS. 
 
 Calcutta, 20th April, 1758. 
 
 Sir, I have received your favour, and you may be 
 assured of my assistance to increase your influence at 
 the Durbar. I have already told Omud Roy, the new 
 Subah Duan, that you are appointed by me to collect 
 the money at Muxadavad. Moreover, I now inclose 
 you a letter for him, as also one to the Chuta nabob, 
 and to the Seats, to that purpose. 
 
 If Roy Doolub's family should apply to you for a 
 guard of sepoys to escort his family down to Calcutta, 
 you will let him have them. 
 
 I hope you will soon be able to collect the remainder 
 of the last sixth, for we are in great want of money at 
 present. 
 
 I am, Sir, 
 Your most obedient servant, 
 
 ROBERT CLIVE. 
 
 From Mr. HASTINGS to Colonel CLIVE. 
 
 Moraudbaug, 24th August, 1758. 
 
 Sir, I have received your favour of the 20th instant, 
 with the inclosed letters for the young Nabob, the 
 Seats and Omud Roy ; for which I return you many 
 thanks. 
 
 If Roy Doolub's family should apply to me for an 
 escort of sepoys, I shall send them to him, agreeably to 
 your orders. There are some circumstances which oblige 
 me to desire your further directions on this subject, as 
 it may not be in my power to afford them the assist- 
 ance they may require, at least without occasioning 
 some very bad consequences. The Chuta nabob has
 
 60 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 placed hircarrahs in every passage leading to Roy 
 Doolub's house, and one upon each of his boats, to pre- 
 vent the removal either of his family or effects. He 
 sent me word of it yesterday, with assurances that he 
 had no other intention herein, than to detain Roy 
 Doolub's brothers till they had settled the Khalsa ac- 
 counts with Omud Roy. The same message, as I have 
 just learned from Ross-beharry, the young Nabol 
 has sent to him. 
 
 As the removal of Roy Doolub's family, with all 
 effects and movables belonging to them, is not so easy 
 to be effected, or with the same just pretence, as the 
 departure of Roy Doolub was, you will see the necessity 
 I am under of waiting for your orders before I can well 
 interfere herein, which I therefore request I may be 
 speedily favoured with. 
 
 I shall use all means in my power to collect in the 
 remainder of the last sixth, but the absence of the 
 greatest part of the principal Assammees who are gone 
 with the Nabob to Calcutta, has proved a great ob- 
 struction to me in this business, and will be till his re- 
 turn. 
 
 In the interval between the despatch of his first 
 letter and the receipt of Hastings's answer, Clive 
 wrote again, in consequence of a report having 
 reached him of certain tumults in Moorshedabad, 
 during which one rajah had placed in confinement 
 the son of another. Hastings assures him in 
 return that there was no ground for the report, 
 though he states that Rajah Bullub, the party 
 accused, is a very troublesome person ; and then 
 the correspondence concerning Roy Doolub is 
 resumed.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 61 
 
 From Colonel CLIVE to Mr. HASTINGS. 
 
 Calcutta, 31st August, 1758. 
 
 Sir, I have received your letters of the 24th and 
 26th August. Your apprehensions of matters coming to 
 extremities in case a guard be sent to bring away Roy 
 Doolub's family are founded in reason. I never in- 
 tended you should use force, but only furnish them with 
 a party of sepoys to escort them down to Calcutta ; 
 you are not acquainted with the connexion between 
 Roy Doolub and the English, and that they are bound 
 not only to protect him, but his family also. You may 
 remonstrate with decency, as often as opportunity offers, 
 that it is unjust to keep the mother and daughter from 
 the father. As for the brothers, it is not worth inter- 
 fering about them. In short, I would have you to act 
 on all occasions so as to avoid coming to extremities, 
 and at the same time show as much spirit and resolu- 
 tion as will convince the Durbar that we always have it 
 in our power to make ourselves respected. 
 
 You must be a little severe in exacting the remainder 
 of the last sixth. It is the nature of these people to 
 do nothing through inclination. Ten sepoys orchokeys, 
 now and then, will greatly expedite the payment of the 
 money. 
 
 The adjustment of Roy Doolub's affair was 
 scarcely brought about when different grounds of 
 annoyance presented themselves to Hastings, of 
 which the subjoined letters will show that he neither 
 thought liglitly nor considered himself bound to 
 conceal the expression. Olive's answer to the young 
 resident's remonstrance, though abundantly stern, 
 indicates no disposition on the part of the writer to 
 give wanton pain. It is the letter of one who has
 
 62 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 taught himself to hold the indulgence of even 
 amiable feeling altogether subordinate to the de- 
 mands of the public service. 
 
 Mr. HASTINGS to Colonel CLIVE. 
 
 Moraudbaug, 7th September, 1758. 
 
 Sir, I have been honoured with your favour of the 
 31st ultimo, and have now the satisfaction to acquaint 
 you that the Nabob has given his permission for the 
 removal of Roy Doolub's family to Calcutta; they wait 
 only for the sealing- the Perwannah to depart. 
 
 I shall use all possible means for collecting the re- 
 mainder of the last sixth, and hope very shortly to have 
 gathered in the greatest part ; but you must be sen- 
 sible there is a wide difference between securing the 
 payments due from a large amount, and that of collect- 
 ing in several small balances remaining on old ac- 
 counts. 
 
 I was greatly surprised at the contents of a letter, 
 which I received two days ago from the Burdwan Rajah, 
 informing me that the Nuncomar had sent peons to 
 him, with orders to pay the revenues to him at 
 Hughley, and to repair immediately to Calcutta in 
 order to settle the monthly payments of his tuncaw 
 for the present year. As there is a considerable 
 balance on the last year's account, and I have received 
 no orders from you to give up the management of the 
 Burdwan affairs to Nuncomar, I doubt not but you 
 will approve of my having sent express injunctions to 
 the Rajah to pay no regard to any orders of that kind 
 till ratified by advices from me, as he may be assured the 
 business entrusted to my charge will not be taken out of 
 my hands without my being previously informed of it 
 by my employers. I have likewise, on this occasion, 
 repeated the orders which I gave the Jemetdar of the 
 sepoys, who are gone with the Rajah, not to suffer him
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 63 
 
 or his people to be molested by any persons in the 
 collecting their revenues. 
 
 Though in this affair I have acted upon the sup- 
 position, (and indeed without the least doubt,) that 
 this proceeding of Nuncomar's is entirely without 
 orders, yet I will not pretend to be ignorant that I 
 have sometime since heard, that he was to be appointed 
 collector of the Burdwan and Nuddea tuncaws, and 
 received a letter yesterday from himself, in which he 
 acquaints me that he had received the Killaut from 
 you for that purpose. However, if I am to relinquish 
 all concern in the affairs of those zemindaries, I beg 
 to be favoured with proper orders for that end, that I 
 may have it in my power to quit them with some 
 degree of credit ; and not by meeting with opposition 
 in the performance of my duty from other persons 
 appointed to the same service, appear to usurp an 
 office for which I have no authority, or as abruptly 
 dismissed from it for some misconduct or incapacity. 
 
 In the mean time I think it incumbent on me to 
 represent to you, that the Burdwan revenues are already 
 six months and a half in arrears, and the most plen- 
 tiful season now coming on. The Burdwan Rajah, in his 
 letter to me, complains that the demand of Nuncomar 
 has prevented his paying any part of the new kist 
 which he agreed with me, and if he is obliged to go 
 to Calcutta to settle afresh kistbundee with Nuncomar, 
 it must unavoidably occasion the loss of at least a 
 month more. For this reason I now send you a copy 
 of the kistbundee which I settled with the Burdwan 
 people at their departure from hence, which if you 
 approve of, I recommend it to you to abide by the 
 agreement already made with them, as it will save 
 them a great expense and unnecessary loss of time, 
 and greatly expedite the payment of their revenues. 
 With the above copy, I have likewise transcribed for
 
 64 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 your perusal the kistbundce by which tho Burdwan 
 rents are annually paid in to the Government, which 
 will the better enable you to judge of that which I 
 have made. 
 
 Colonel CUVE to Mr. HASTINGS. 
 
 Calcutta, 10th September, 1758. 
 
 Sir, I have now received your letter of the 7th 
 instant, the contents of which I must confess have 
 surprised me as much as Nuncomar's appointment 
 could you, for I cannot account for your ignorance that 
 Nuncomar was to be appointed collector of the re- 
 venues of Burdwan, Nuddea, and Hughley, for the 
 two ensuing years, and that the money collected was 
 to be paid at Hughley. This was agreed upon at 
 Muxadavad when I was there, and before we had 
 thoughts of desiring you to accept the management 
 of the Durbar affairs ; and one reason for desiring to 
 have the money paid at Hughley in preference to Mux- 
 adavad was to avoid giving the Nabob and the great 
 men about him umbrage in seeing such large sums 
 coming into the public treasury, and then sent out 
 again for the use of the English. 
 
 Mr. Watts, who is now present, assures me he in- 
 formed you of these things; and that you had only 
 to collect about three and a half lacs of rupees, the 
 remainder of the last sixth, and to carry on the Durbar 
 affairs. This I can say, that if Mr. Scraf'ton did not 
 fully explain to you our intentions of receiving the 
 revenues of the two ensuing years at Hughley, ho was 
 wanting in the duties of his office when he delivered 
 over affairs into your hands, for he was well acquainted 
 with them. 
 
 I cannot say I think there is any blame due for not 
 making known to you in form what I thought you was 
 fully acquainted with by Messrs. Watts and Scrafton 
 before they left Muxadavad.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 6<5 
 
 That you should attribute taking the management 
 of the tuncaws out of your hands to misconduct or 
 incapacity gives me much concern, for no one will be 
 more ready to support your character and welfare than 
 myself, when it can be done without prejudicing the 
 concerns of the Company. This being the case at 
 present, in the opinion of the council, I am persuaded 
 you will think no slight could be intended you. I 
 desire you will write the Burdwan Rajah to comply 
 with Nuncomar's orders about coming to Calcutta. 
 The kullat was given him in full council without the 
 least thought or design of lessening your credit or 
 authority at the Durbar. 
 
 Your news of Roy Doolub's family having liberty to 
 come to Calcutta gives great satisfaction here. 
 
 Mr. Hastings's reply to this letter seems to me 
 to be every way worthy of the man. It puts the 
 hardship of his case in a proper light, yet 
 indicates no unwillingness on the part of the 
 writer to postpone his personal feelings and per- 
 sonal credit to what was considered the interest of 
 the Company ; and while it shows that in the view 
 which Clive had taken of the matter he was some- 
 what in error, it affords the best evidence of the 
 perfectly good understanding which subsisted 
 between two men of all whom British India lias 
 produced in their respective walks of life beyond 
 comparison the greatest. It is a long letter, but I 
 do not think that it ought to be withheld. 
 
 Mr. HASTINGS to Colonel CLIVE. 
 
 Moraudbaug, 14th September, 1758. 
 
 Sir, I have been duly honoured with your letter of 
 the 10th instant. 
 
 VOL. I. F
 
 66 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 I was not ignorant of the report that Nuncoinar was 
 to be appointed collector of the Burdwan and Nuddea 
 revenues, but neither Mr. Watts nor Mr. Scrafton 
 ever gave me the least intimation that such part of 
 their revenues as were included in their accounts of 
 the last sixth, were to be taken out of my hands ; the 
 contrary of which was expressly declared by Mr. 
 Scrafton, as will evidently appear from his last letter to 
 the Board, in which he mentions those of Burdwan 
 and Nuddea amongst the other balances which he 
 had left to my charge ; therefore it was surely no un- 
 reasonable thing in me to imagine that whenever these 
 revenues were to be taken out of my hands, I should 
 be previously ordered to resign them, till when it was 
 my duty to oppose every person that interfered with 
 me in my business. 
 
 All the instructions which I received relating to my 
 office were from Mr. Scrafton, and to this purpose : that 
 I was to collect the remainder of the last sixth which 
 amounted to about eleven lacs of rupees, and wait the 
 orders of the Board with regard to the Burdwan and 
 Nuddea tuncaws for the year. For the further ex- 
 plication of the different parts of my business he left 
 me his letters and all his papers, agreeably to which 
 I have acted all along. As there was a balance of 
 near four lacs due from Burdwan on the old tuncaw, 
 the payment of which it was my business to settle 
 before they left the city, I thought I could not do it 
 more properly than by adding that amount to that 
 of the tuncaw for the present year, and settle the 
 payments of the whole together, which method I 
 observed Mr. Scrafton had taken with the Nuddea 
 revenues ; and this appeared more properly my duty 
 then, both as five months of the Burdwan accounts for 
 this year were already elapsed, and as the apprehen- 
 sions they were under from the government and the
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 67 
 
 need they stood in of my protection, gave me a fair 
 opportunity of finishing their kistbundee more expedi- 
 tiously and more for the advantage of the Company, 
 than I could have done at another time. My conduct 
 in this affair the reasons I have given will, I hope, 
 sufficiently justify. And indeed I must confess I 
 ascribed some degree of merit to myself in having so 
 happily concluded an affair which had been so long a 
 time depending ; nor does it give me small concern to 
 find, that you disapprove of that agreement. 
 
 I have wrote, in obedience to your orders, to the 
 Burdwan Rajah, to advise him that I have no longer 
 any business in the collection of his revenues, for all 
 particulars relating to which he is to obey Nuncomar's 
 orders. The same orders I shall likewise send to the 
 Nuddea Sazoul, though it may not, perhaps, be quite 
 so requisite, as I am informed he has already, without 
 waiting for any advices from me, sent away 83,000 
 rupees of the Nuddea tuncaw to Hughley. 
 
 As I know not whether any part of the remaining 
 balances belong to the Hughley accounts, I am entirely 
 at a loss how to proceed with them, being apprehensive 
 of meeting with a fresh mortification in case I should 
 
 O 
 
 again meddle with any of the zemindars of Nun- 
 comar's jurisdiction. I shall therefore be much 
 obliged to you if you will favour me with your instruc- 
 tions on this point. 
 
 It would ill become me to object against any mea- 
 sures which have had the sanction of yours and the 
 Council's approbation. I shall, therefore, cheerfully 
 apply myself to the small part of the business which 
 still remains upon my hands, of which I hope very 
 shortly to have acquitted myself. 
 
 I am sorry to find you have misinterpreted one 
 passage in my letter, which I must beg leave to rectify. 
 I never had the least suspicion that the transferring 
 
 F2
 
 68 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 of the Burdwan and Nuddea affairs to Hughley pro- 
 ceeded in the least from any ill opinion of my conduct 
 or capacity, but that it would be construed as such 
 by every body here, as it was universally believed that 
 I was appointed at Moraudbaug principally for the 
 collection of those revenues. But 1 must beg leave to 
 declare that the confidence which I place in the pro- 
 mises which you have made me, and suffer me to add, 
 the expressions which I am told you have done me the 
 honour to make use of in my favour, are sufficient to 
 prevent my entertaining the least thought that you 
 intended me any slight or prejudice on this occasion. 
 
 Since writing the above, a complaint has been made 
 to me, that Nuncomar has put peons on the Mysoddul 
 gomastah at Hughley, upon account of 86,388, the 
 balance of the Mysoddul account, which has been lately 
 paid to me at Moraudbaug ; insisting on the gomastah's 
 paying him that amount, as belonging to the Hughley 
 accounts, with the charge of which he is invested. I 
 must suppress what I feel from these daily indignities ; 
 but surely, Sir, I may at least conclude that this pro- 
 ceeding is without your authority, otherwise it will 
 be impossible for me to know what accounts still re- 
 main in my charge ; and I am sure, Sir, it was never 
 your intention, in placing me at Moraudbaug, that I 
 should only hold the business for Nuncomar, till he 
 was properly settled and at leisure to take it out of 
 my hands. 
 
 This unpleasant affair was yet upon Hastings's 
 mind, when there occurred an event which was 
 well calculated to alarm him- not on his own 
 account, but on account of his employers, whose 
 interests required that tranquillity should be strictly 
 preserved in every part of the Nabob's dominions.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WAEREN HASTINGS. 69 
 
 It is worth while to give my account of that move- 
 ment in the words of these illustrious corre- 
 spondents, because the letters of Loth are remark- 
 able ; and that of Clive, which Lears on the most 
 delicate part of the subject, is a perfect lesson in 
 the philosophy of the Asiatic mind, which was 
 not wasted upon him who received it. On the 
 15th of September Mr. Hastings writes as 
 follows : 
 
 Sir, I write this expressly to inform you that 
 the Nabob's forces have surrounded him for their pay. 
 It is reported, and I believe with truth, that an at- 
 tempt was intended two nights ago against his life, 
 but rendered ineffectual, the Nabob having received 
 timely notice of it. I hope there is no danger. Upon 
 the first report which I heard of this disturbance I 
 sent the Vakeel to the Nabob to be informed of the 
 truth. He has confirmed the above particulars, and 
 has wrote to you about them, desiring me likewise to 
 acquaint you with this affair. The Vakeel is this 
 instant returned. I shall go myself to the Nabob in 
 the morning. 
 
 This hurried note was followed by a second, 
 which is without date, but runs thus : 
 
 Sir, I informed you in a letter of the 15th instant 
 of the danger which lately threatened the Nabob ; the 
 following particulars I have learned since from the 
 Nabob's own mouth, and am desired by him to trans- 
 mit them for your information. 
 
 On the 9th night of the Mohurrum (August 13th 
 our style) the Nabob went from his palace by water to 
 the Chuta nabob's, attended only by a few menial
 
 70 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 servants. In the way he observed the shore and all 
 the gauts between his house and the Chuta nabob's 
 covered with vast shoals of people. After a short stay 
 at the Chuta nabob's he returned in his palankeen to 
 the Imambarree, which he found surrounded and filled 
 with sepoys who were gathered together in a very 
 tumultuous and disorderly manner. As he had ap- 
 pointed Coja Huddee to place proper guards about 
 the Imambarree, and relied entirely upon his care to 
 prevent any disorders, the Nabob still entertained no 
 suspicion of any clanger, till one of his hircarrahs (upon 
 his arrival at the Imambarree) came to him and told 
 him that Coja Huddee had armed all his people, who 
 seemed to threaten some disturbance. Upon this 
 information he gave orders to those of his own people 
 who by this time were assembled about him, to turn 
 the crowd out of the Imambarree, and planted guards 
 at the different avenues to prevent any insurrection. 
 Shokum Sing, and the other jemetdars belonging to 
 Coja Huddee, who were sitting in the Imambarree, 
 seeing their plot discovered, immediately rose up and 
 hastily went away. 
 
 In the morning Bahader-bcg, a duffadar of Rohum 
 Cawn's forces, came to the Nabob and acquainted him 
 that he had had a very miraculous escape, for that 
 Coja Huddee had armed and assembled the other 
 jemetdars and sepoys, on purpose to take away his 
 life. Presently after Shokum Sing and Harroon Cawn 
 (formerly of Roy Doolub's Rissalla) came in and dis- 
 covered to him the whole affair, acquainting him that 
 Hoy Doolub had sent Coja Huddee a bill of exchange 
 to Meer Alice, for two lac of rupees, to be distributed 
 amongst the sepoys, that under pretence of demanding 
 the arrears of their pay, they might surround and cut 
 off the Nabob. In consequence of this discovery the 
 Nabob has dismissed Coja Huddee from his service,
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 71 
 
 and appointed Mahumder Cawn (a patan) the buxey 
 of his forces in the room of the former, whom he has 
 likewise ordered to leave the city. 
 
 This is the purport of what I can recollect of the 
 Nabob's discourse. If I have omitted any circumstance, 
 you will have it, I imagine, from the Nabob himself, 
 as lie mentioned that he should write to you about it. 
 He is greatly exasperated against Roy Doolub, whom 
 he looks upon as the author of all this confusion. 
 
 In addition to these letters, Hastings wrote 
 u^ain on the 22nd, and inclosed a translation of 
 the Nabob's florid epistle, in which all his griev- 
 ances were set forth. It is not worth while to 
 transcribe these, more especially as Olive's reply 
 to the communications of an earlier date seems to 
 have set the question of Roy Doolub's guilt or inno- 
 cence at rest for ever. 
 
 Colonel CLIVE to Mr. HASTINGS. 
 
 Calcutta, 6th October, 1758. 
 
 Sir, I have received your letter of the 9th, the 
 contents of which were of such a nature that I could 
 not dispense with making them known to the Com- 
 mittee, reserving that part which related to Watts 
 and Scrafton. 
 
 You have not yet been long enough at the Durbar 
 to make yourself acquainted with the dark designs of 
 the Mussulmans. The moment I perused your letter 
 I could perceive a design in the Nabob and those about 
 him against Roy Doolub, and you may be assured 
 what is alleged against him and his letters to Coja 
 Huddee is a forgery from beginning to end. Roy 
 Doolub is not such a fool as to give anything under his 
 own hand. His cautious behaviour previous to the
 
 72 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 affair of Placis is a convincing proof of it ; besides, let 
 his inclinations be what they will, he knows my at- 
 tachment to the Nabob to be so firmly fixed, that he 
 would never dare to intrigue against him, Avell know- 
 ing that his life and fortune are in my power. How 
 easy is it to counterfeit hands and seals in this country ! 
 and the Moors in general are villains enough to 
 undertake anything which may benefit themselves at 
 another's expense. In short, the whole of the scheme 
 is to exasperate me so much against Roy Doolub 
 that the Nabob may have the plucking of him of all 
 his money. The withdrawing our protection from a 
 man to whom it has been once promised would entail 
 disgrace and infamy upon the English nation. 
 
 I cannot avoid entertaining the strongest resent- 
 ment against the Nabob, if what you write about Coja 
 Huddce be true. The man who dared to accuse me 
 of entering into schemes of assassination ought to have 
 been punished upon the spot. After the treatment 
 he received at Calcutta, he must have known that the 
 English are endued with sentiments of honour and 
 conscience, which the Moors are utter strangers to ; 
 and I must desire you will inform him that if he give 
 ear to such things as these, there will soon be an end 
 to all confidence and friendship between us. 
 
 Such were Olive's views of this pretended con- 
 spiracy, and such the grounds on which lie rested 
 them. They were adopted at once by Hastings, 
 and the event proved, that in every point of view 
 they were correct. No plan at all had ever been 
 formed by Roy Doolub to take away the Nabob's 
 life ; nor did his sepoys, by tumultuously assembling, 
 aim at any thing more than the payment of the
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 73 
 
 arrears which were due to them. So the matter 
 being lightly dealt with, both at Moorshedabad and 
 Calcutta, men soon ceased to notice it in their 
 talk, and Roy Doolub continued to enjoy the 
 protection of the English. 
 
 The next letter which seems to me to demand 
 transcription is that which relates to the defect in 
 the title by which the Company held their lands in 
 and around Calcutta. It bears date 27th of Sep- 
 tember, 1758, and is addressed, as usual, to the 
 Hon. Robert Clive, Esq., President and Governor, 
 &c. in Council of Fort William. 
 
 ' Honourable Sir and Sirs, My last address to your 
 honours was of the 25th instant, in which I inclosed a 
 copy of the government's demands on the Honourable 
 Company, for the revenues of the pergunnah of 
 Moodagolcha, and I now take the liberty of informing 
 your honours that I have lately discovered what I 
 conceive to be a great defect in the Company's present 
 title to the new lands granted them by the late treaty 
 with the Nabob. I understand that those lands are at 
 present held only by virtue of the Nabob's perwannah ; 
 but no sunnud has yet been granted for them, nor have 
 they been duly entered in the conongou books as the 
 zcmindarree of the Company, being stated therein 
 the mudaukhelut of (or lands possessed by) the English 
 Company, as you will observe in the account inclosed 
 in my last, in which they arc so named, that being a 
 copy of the conongou books. 
 
 This distinction, perhaps, may appear trivial, but 
 may hereafter prove a subject of great contention 
 if proper measures are not taken to prevent it in time. 
 The Nabob's perwannah will, I doubt not, be of suffi-
 
 74 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 
 
 cient validity during his life, but can be of no force 
 with his successors if they choose to dispute it. 
 
 I do not apprehend that there can be any difficulty 
 in obtaining a sunnud for the zemindarree of the 
 Honourable Company's lands, though it may not be so 
 easily effected if too long deferred, as it may then look 
 like a new demand, and will be most probably called 
 such, especially if we should lose any part of our pre- 
 sent influence with the government. 
 
 I hope I shall not need any excuse for troubling 
 your honours on this subject, as it is my duty to lay 
 before you every thing that comes to my knowledge, 
 by which the Company's interest may be any way 
 affected, though it may not immediately concern my 
 particular employ. Your honours will please to make 
 such inquiry into this affair as you may judge it de- 
 serves. Should you think proper to lay any commands 
 upon me concerning this matter, I shall not be want- 
 ing in my endeavours to execute them in the best 
 manner I am able for the Honourable Company's ad- 
 vantage. 
 
 The preceding communication was received as 
 it deserved by the governor in council, and Mr. 
 Hastings was desired to exercise his own discretion 
 as to the best and speediest method of having the 
 defect in the Company's title made good. Accord- 
 ingly, on the 20th of November, he writes again 
 as follows, after having been nearly two months 
 negociating for the requisite sunnud. 
 
 To the Hon. ROBERT CLIVE, President and Governor, &c., Select 
 Committee. 
 
 Honourable Sir and Sirs, By orders from the pre- 
 sident, I have paid the Nabob a lac of rupees on ac-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 75 
 
 count of the Calcutta lands. A few days ago the 
 Nabob desired that another lac might be paid him on 
 the same account, and intimated a request that the 
 Company would advance him two lac besides, which 
 he would repay with the customary interest. His first 
 demand being but reasonable, and it being of the ut- 
 most consequence, just at this juncture, to keep upon 
 the best terms with the Nabob, I immediately agreed 
 to the payment of the sum required, and have accord- 
 ingly paid him another lac of rupees, which I hope 
 your honours will approve of. By the inclosed account, 
 your honours will observe, that after the deduction of 
 the sums above-mentioned, there still remains a ba- 
 lance due from the Company to the Nabob. 
 
 In case the Nabob should again mention anything 
 concerning the proposal of borrowing two hundred 
 thousand rupees of the Honourable Company, I shall 
 be glad to be favoured with your orders in what 
 manner I shall answer him. I must take the liberty 
 to observe, that the Nabob's wants are to all appear- 
 ance very pressing, and it would not a little contribute 
 towards the success of the negotiation now on foot at 
 the Durbar, to gratify him in this point. 
 
 I have the pleasure to inform you, that the greatest 
 difficulties in the settlement of the Company's lands 
 are happily surmounted. The lands without the line, 
 extending as far as Bangenbazar, are allowed the 
 Company. This point having been some time since 
 settled with Royroyan, without any application to the 
 Nabob, there remains only to get a perwannah for the 
 possession of Annoorpoor, and to settle the accounts 
 of Ballia Bussendree. The latter will be concluded in 
 a very few days ; the former the Nabob has already 
 given his consent to, and has ordered the Royroyan to 
 deliver to him a draft of that country, with an account 
 of the revenues arising from it. These points settled,
 
 76 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 I hope the sunnud will be drawn out and executed 
 without any further impediment. The other claims 
 made by your honours, relating- to the seway and 
 other arbitrary taxes imposed on the zemindars by 
 the government, not being included in the sunnud, 
 are left to be adjusted with the Nabob after the sunnud 
 is obtained, which being of the greatest consequence 
 to the Honourable Company, and what only can 
 render the title to their lands valid according to the 
 laws of the country, the other articles may be safely 
 disputed when this is once secured, but would only 
 serve to cause dangerous delay were they to be too 
 soon introduced. Your honours will observe, that the 
 seway, chout, &c. are, for the above-mentioned cause, 
 included. 
 
 The governor and council were very grateful to 
 Mr. Hastings for the discovery which he had made, 
 and very urgent with him to bring the negotia- 
 tion to a favourable issue ; but the idea of lending 
 money to the Nabob of Bengal was by no means 
 congenial to their feelings. Accordingly, Clive 
 replies, on the 28th of November, in the following 
 terms : 
 
 Sir, Your letter of the 25th I received this morn- 
 ing. .For that part of it which relates to the Calcutta 
 lands I must refer you to another opportunity. 
 
 Yours to the Committee about the loan of a sum of 
 money to the Nabob has been laid before the Council, 
 being a matter which more particularly comes under 
 their cognizance, and requires some consideration. 
 However, I cannot think that he is in that distress for 
 want of money which you represent. To my certain 
 knowledge he is in possession of gold to the amount of
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 77 
 
 several lacs of rupees, and if you were to hint to him, 
 whenever he pleads poverty, that you are not ignorant 
 of his hidden resources, I believe it might put an end 
 to the disagreeable topic of borrowing money. 
 
 I cannot think Nuncomar deserving of the Nabob's 
 resentment, without it be for his known attachment 
 to the English, of which I am fully convinced. The 
 Burdwan revenues are little or nothing behind hand : 
 
 o - 
 
 the tuncaws on the other lands he has nothing to do 
 with. The true cause of the Nabob's hatred to Nun- 
 comar proceeds from his not joining with Omer Beg 
 in Roy Doolub's ruin and overthrow. Nuncomar has 
 now, under the Nabob's own hand, offers of a title and 
 jaggeer if he would bring the affair of Roy Doolub's 
 letter to a good issue. By this you will judge what 
 the Nabob is about. You may lay it down as a maxim, 
 that the Mussulmans will never be influenced by kind 
 treatment to do us justice; their own apprehensions 
 only can and will induce them to fulfil their agree- 
 ments. The present situation of our affairs requires 
 our being more compliant than would be consistent 
 with the interest of the Company at any other time. 
 
 From the preceding correspondence, some idea 
 may be formed as to the nature of the more im- 
 portant affairs, the management of which devolved 
 upon Mr. Hastings during the earlier portion of 
 his residence at the court of Meer Jaffier. Mixed 
 up as they were with many and complicated ques- 
 tions relative to the finance, and revenue, and trade 
 of the country, they proved no bad materials where- 
 with to discipline to habits of business the mind of 
 the future governor of India, while the success with 
 which he conducted them was not more conducive
 
 78 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 to his own personal credit, than satisfactory to 
 those under whom he acted. " I am very sensible," 
 Clive writes, some time subsequently to his letter 
 of the 28th of November, " of the pains you have 
 taken, and shall not fail acquainting the Company 
 by the first opportunity, how much you have con- 
 tributed to bring that important matter to so happy 
 an issue. " Such praise coming from such a 
 quarter could not fail of proving eminently grati- 
 fying to its object ; neither was it barren of results, 
 for to his management of this business Hastings 
 was always accustomed to look back, as to the first 
 decided step which circumstances enabled him to 
 take on the road to eminence.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 79 
 
 CHAPTER V. 
 
 Clive resigns the Government Succeeded by Mr. Holwell and Mr. Van- 
 sittart New Revolution, and appointment of Cosseim Ali as Nabob Mr. 
 Vansittart an object of jealousy to his Council, and is in the minority 
 Mr. Hastings a Member of Council His negotiations with the Nabob 
 Violences on all sides Rupture Deposition of Meer Cosseim Mr. 
 Hastings returns to England. 
 
 IT will be seen from the contents of the preceding 
 chapter, that even under the superintendence of 
 such a man as Olive, the affairs of India were, at 
 this juncture, exceedingly hard to manage. The 
 state of the Nabob's mind, not less than of his 
 finances, was altogether unfavourable to order. 
 He was at enmity with most of the leading men 
 in the provinces ; he was irritable, uneasy, chafed, 
 and thoroughly discontented. His title, though at 
 one time recognized at Delhi, was now again called 
 in question ; while of the English, on whose sup- 
 port the very existence of his government de- 
 pended, he entertained a boundless jealousy. Clive 
 alone appears to have commanded both his respect 
 and his confidence, for dive's was a master spirit 
 which caused its superiority to be felt and acknow- 
 ledged by all who came within the reach of its 
 influence. Yet even Clive found, from time to 
 time, that the task of managing and controlling 
 elements so discordant was a difficult one. It 
 was hardly to be expected that his successor in
 
 80 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 office, be he whom he might, would succeed him 
 also in his rare talent for command ; and certainly 
 the lot fell, at all events for a season, on one who 
 was as little qualified as can well be imagined 
 for the duties that were imposed upon him. 
 
 On the 25th of February, 1760, Clive sailed for 
 England, leaving the temporary care of the go- 
 vernment to Mr. Holwell, by whom it was to be 
 handed over, so soon as lie should arrive from 
 Madras, to Mr. Vansittart. There is no denying 
 that the difficulties which encountered Mr. Hol- 
 well at the outset were very great. The Shazada, 
 All Gowher, the Mogul's eldest son, had again 
 entered Bahar, and was busily employed collecting 
 forces and raising contributions. Tikarra, the 
 capital of the zemindarree of Gya, was his re- 
 sidence. His principal supporter was Camgar 
 Cawn Alii, the Rajah of Herswa, whilst many of 
 the jeinetdars, and other military chiefs whom 
 Meer Jaffier had dismissed, enlisted under his 
 banner, and swelled his numbers. Moreover there 
 was, on the part of Ramnarrain, the deputy or 
 governor of Patna, a very culpable degree of neg- 
 ligence, if, indeed, no graver charge might be 
 brought against him ; for he took no pains to watch 
 the movements of his own jematdars, not a few 
 of whom were known to be disaffected. And 
 finally, advices being received of the assassination 
 of Alemgeer, the Shazada caused himself to be pro-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 8i 
 
 claimed Emperor by the title of Shah Allum, 
 appointing, at the same time, Sujah ud Dowlah 
 the Nabob of Oude, to be his vizier, and sending 
 summonses into all the provinces, to require that 
 his authority should be acknowledged. Now 
 though the power of the Mogul had long virtually 
 ceased, there was a charm in the name which 
 still went for something, more especially in cases 
 where, like the present, men were looking round 
 for a legitimate excuse to rebel. Not in Bahar, 
 therefore, alone, but everywhere else, the young 
 Emperor found many friends who gathered round 
 him, not more out of respect for the ancient title 
 which he had assumed, than because the yoke of 
 Meer Jaffier sat heavy on their shoulders. 
 
 While such was the threatening aspect of affairs 
 on one side, in other quarters dangers and grounds 
 of embarrassment were not far to seek. Caucler 
 Hossein Cawn, the Naib or Deputy of Purneah, 
 assumed an attitude which was well calculated to 
 create uneasiness. During the two years which he 
 had held office, he had devoted all his energies to 
 the accumulation of a treasure, and the organiza- 
 tion of an army, and he now lay upon one of the 
 branches of the Ganges, at the head of 10,000 
 good troops, without declaring either for Meer 
 Jaffier or the Emperor. The Mahrattas, too, were 
 moving upon Cuttack, of which the revenues had, in 
 Alaverdi Cawn's time, been assigned to them ; and 
 
 VOL. i. G
 
 82 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 the Dutch, by whom Jaffier's title had never been 
 recognised, evinced symptoms of hostility. The 
 province of Bengal alone wore somewhat of a 
 peaceable appearance. The war was not yet 
 sufficiently ripe to break out so near to the metro- 
 polis: yet even there many powerful individuals 
 were suspected, whom it would be necessary to 
 watch, and, on the first appearance of discontent, 
 to put down. 
 
 If there had existed between Meer Jaffier and 
 the Government at Fort William the same good 
 understanding which used to exist, in other 
 words, had Mr. Holwell possessed, like his prede- 
 cessor, such temper and firmness as the exigencies 
 of the moment required, it is not impossible but 
 that the clouds which obscured the political hori- 
 zon might all have been dispersed by a process less 
 violent than that which was adopted. But Mr. 
 Holwell had neither temper nor firmness ; he 
 appears to have regarded the Nabob all along with 
 an eye of extreme disfavour. His errors, and 
 he committed many, were all exaggerated ; his 
 embarrassments, and they were abundant too, were 
 all undervalued. No attempt was made to lead 
 him into the right way ; and his very frailties of 
 temper were treated as offences against the dignity 
 of the English name. His poverty, likewise, 
 which was extreme, was treated as a crime. The 
 subsidies which he had promised were in arrear,
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 83 
 
 and no excuse for their non-payment would be 
 accepted. In a word, there was a prejudice against 
 him on the part of Mr. Holwell, which soon ex- 
 cited a similar prejudice in him against both Mr. 
 Holwell and his colleagues, of which the results 
 were, after much intriguing on both sides, absolute 
 ruin to the one party, and anything but an acces- 
 sion of honourable fame to the other. 
 
 With the detail of the military operations which 
 went forward from the beginning of December, 
 1759, to the month of July, 1760, I have here very 
 little concern. They were not, in any respect, 
 controlled or directed by Mr. Hastings, whose 
 position all the while was at the court of Meer 
 Jaffier, where the confused state both of the 
 Nabob's and the Company's accounts found him 
 ample employment. Neither do I think that any 
 good purpose would be served, were I to plunge 
 myself and my reader into the troubled waters of 
 fiscal detail and complicated accounts. Enough is 
 done when I state that the Nabob was in every 
 way the Company's debtor ; that independently of 
 the arrears of subsidy that were due, he had bor- 
 rowed money at Calcutta, which, the treasury 
 there being wholly exhausted, the authorities were 
 urgent to have repaid; and that Mr. Hastings, 
 finding how impossible it is to draw water from 
 the rock, was glad to accept, in lieu of the ready 
 cash, a tuncaw or bond over the revenues of Burd- 
 
 G2
 
 84 MEMOIRS OF WARRtiN HASTINGS. 
 
 wan and Kistnagur. Even this assignment, how- 
 ever, was of no avail either to relieve the English, 
 or to set the Nahob right in the eyes of his patrons. 
 Whatever misfortune befel, whatever embarrass- 
 ment arose, was attributed by Mr. Holwell to the 
 deliberate malice of Meer Jaffier, while Meer 
 Jaffier regarded Mr. Holwell as his sworn enemy, 
 whom it would be fair to overreach, and commend- 
 able to thwart, by every means in his power. 
 
 In spite of the ill-disguised hostility of the two 
 Governments, the war was carried on with as 
 much of vigour as the impoverished state of their 
 finances would allow. The young Emperor, 
 though successful in his first effort against Ram- 
 narrain, sustained a severe defeat from the combined 
 armies of Colonel Caillaucl and Meeram, the 
 Chuta Nabob ; and after an ineffectual attempt to 
 surprise Moorshedabad, and a second repulse before 
 Patna, was compelled to retreat into Hindoostan. 
 Captain Knox, a brave and skilful officer, over- 
 threw the rebel Rajah of Purneah with great 
 slaughter; while the Mahrattas were held in 
 check, and the Dutch pacified, by Meer Cosseim 
 Ali, the Nabob's son-in-law, and the handful of 
 Europeans that supported him. Nevertheless, an 
 event befel, in the midst of these successes, which 
 produced some uneasiness at the moment, and 
 proved, in due time, the proximate cause of a new 
 revolution in Bengal. I allude to the death of
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 85 
 
 the Nabob's son, Meeram, who, though a violent 
 and cruel man, had been the main support of his 
 father's throne ; partly because of the absolute sub- 
 mission of his will to that of Clive, partly because 
 his reckless generosity acquired for him the attach- 
 ment of the army. While marching, with Colonel 
 Caillaud, in pursuit of Hossein Cawn, his tent was 
 struck with lightning, and he himself, being asleep 
 at the moment, for the storm occurred during the 
 night, was killed on the spot. 
 
 Though the good management of Caillaud 
 hindered the army in the field from revolting, 
 it was impossible under the circumstances to 
 continue the campaign ; so he retraced his steps 
 to Patna, and there went into quarters. At 
 Moorshedabad, a different result ensued. The 
 armed rabble, which represented an army there, 
 were no sooner informed of Meeram's death, than 
 they surrounded the palace in a threatening man- 
 ner and demanded their arrears of pay. Finally, 
 as if to complete the sum of evils, the Mahrattas 
 broke in, and the last bond of order in the pro- 
 vinces was broken. 
 
 It was amid scenes of war,' and mutiny, and 
 plunder, like these, that Mr. Vansittart assumed 
 the government of Bengal. Owing his elevation 
 entirely to Clive's recommendation, there is no 
 reason to doubt that he was well disposed to pur- 
 sue the course of policy which Clive had marked
 
 86 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 out. But however easy it may be for a man of 
 moderate talent to follow genius in a smooth and 
 beaten track, his capability of doing so ceases so 
 soon as the road becomes indistinct and rugged, 
 and a deviation, be it ever so slight, inevitably leads 
 to the widest separation from him who preceded. 
 This was precisely the case with Mr. Vansittart. 
 With a clear perception of the difference between 
 right and wrong in the abstract, his powers of 
 mind were not adequate to the task of rightly 
 directing him in action ; indeed his letters and 
 minutes drawn up soon after he took his seat at 
 the Council Board show that he was quite in- 
 competent to take a comprehensive view of the 
 great and conflicting interests committed to his 
 charge, and still less able to quell the violent passions 
 that were in action. His estimate of the Nabob's 
 character appears to have been formed from the 
 representations made to him by Mr. Holwell. He 
 believed him to be not only unable but unwilling 
 to act uprightly ; and the whole bent of his policy 
 was directed to one end, namely, the erection of 
 such an influence within the Durbar itself, as should 
 force upon the Nabob attention to duties which, 
 except by compulsion, he would never be brought 
 to perform. 
 
 The power of the sword is in every state of 
 society very great ; in the East it is, and always 
 was, supreme. Meer Jaffier himself owed his
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 87 
 
 elevation mainly to the facilities of successful 
 
 revolt which his position as commander-iii-chief 
 
 had afforded him, while Meeram his sou, for the 
 
 self-same reason, had been all powerful under his 
 
 father. It became therefore a point of the first 
 
 importance to get the authority which Meeram had 
 
 wielded transferred to some one who should both 
 
 enjoy the confidence of the English, and possess 
 
 talent enough to administer the affairs of the Souh- 
 
 badary aright. Now there were two candidates 
 
 for this honour, Meer Cosseim Ali Cawn, and 
 
 Maharajah Raje-bullub, the former the Nabob's 
 
 son-in-law, and the husband of his only legitimate 
 
 daughter ; the latter, a dewan, or principal officer 
 
 of revenue under the deceased Meeram, to whom 
 
 the guardianship of the Nabob's two illegitimate 
 
 grandsons was committed. Moreover, another 
 
 question was involved in that of the command of 
 
 the army, for the right of succession to the mus- 
 
 nud itself was disputed, Raje-bullub claiming it 
 
 for the elder of his two wards, and Cosseim Ali 
 
 Cawn asserting that he, by virtue of his wife, was 
 
 the legitimate heir. It is not worth while to 
 
 explain at length the means which the rival 
 
 claimants adopted to accomplish their respective 
 
 ends. Raje-bullub found supporters in Colonel 
 
 Caillaud and Mr. Amyatt ; Cosseim Ali Cawn 
 
 was favoured by Mr. Hoi well and the select 
 
 committee ; and on this as on every other question,
 
 88 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 Mr. Holwell, with the reins of government, made 
 over his own views of things to Mr. Vansittart. 
 I do not, however, mean to insinuate, that in this 
 case Mr. Hoi well's views were incorrect. If there 
 had heen any rule of legitimacy by which Indian 
 successions could be regulated, Cosseim Ali was 
 the unquestionable heir; and what was more to the 
 purpose, besides that he was in the very vigour 
 of life his attachment to the English was un- 
 doubted. But Mr. Vansittart had no business to 
 press the matter with so high a hand as that which 
 his prejudices led him to employ. It might be 
 prudent, and even proper, to exercise his influence 
 for the purpose of obtaining for his protege the 
 honours which he sought ; but he had no right 
 to force upon the Nabob a commander-in-chief and 
 successor, under circumstances which deprived the 
 Nabob of all except the shadow of authority in 
 the state. Such, however, was the course Avhich, 
 within two months after his arrival at Fort 
 William, the new governor judged it expedient to 
 follow. Cosseim Ali Cawn, making a journey to 
 Calcutta, entered into a treaty with the authorities 
 there, by which, binding himself to pay oft' all out- 
 standing arrears, and to make over to the English 
 certain large tracts of country, he received from 
 them in return assurance of such support as 
 should render him virtually master, where lie 
 affected only to take rank as servant.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 89 
 
 In the judgment at which Mr. Hoi well ar- 
 rived, touching the superior nature of Cosseim Ali's 
 claims over those of Raje-bullub, Mr. Hastings 
 heartily concurred. There is now lying before 
 me a letter addressed by him to Mr. Vansittart, 
 and the members of the select committee, in 
 which he argues at length in favour of the Nabob's 
 son-in-law, and which I abstain from inserting 
 only because it refers to subjects of which the in- 
 terest has long since died away. But I do not 
 find that he was an advocate for the very violent 
 measures which were adopted. His reasonings 
 all apply to the disputed point of succession, and 
 to the Avisdom of assigning the power of the sword 
 where it was not likely to be abused ; he seems 
 never to have contemplated the possibility of Meer 
 Jaffier's deposition, and the raising of his son-in- 
 law to the throne. It is very true that his opi- 
 nion of Aleer Jaffier's talents for business was 
 low ; and that here, as well as elsewhere, he 
 expresses a strong conviction, that something more 
 than remonstrance must be used, if any hope of 
 restoring order to the affairs of the Souhbadary 
 were entertained. " I have too frequently had 
 occasion," he observes, " to bewail the opportu- 
 nities which have been lost of putting a final stop 
 to the troubles which have so long distressed these 
 provinces, by the indolence and irresolution of the 
 two nabobs, and the knavery and intrigues of
 
 90 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 their ministers. The revenues of their country 
 have been dissipated in idle schemes of luxury 
 and ill-timed vanity ; mis-spent on useless alliances, 
 and so scantily and injudiciously employed in the 
 expenses of the war, that the sepoys are starving 
 and dissatisfied with the service, the country left 
 a prey to every invader, and the enemy, after 
 continual losses and repeated disappointments, 
 more powerful than ever. I need not observe 
 how small a part of the province of Bahar is in 
 the' 1 Nabob's possession. In this the Rajah of 
 Beerboom has publicly thrown off his allegiance, 
 and his example will most probably be soon fol- 
 lowed by the defection of the other zemindars on 
 the borders of the province. Private intrigues 
 have been forming at the city ; and, in a word, we 
 may expect at the opening of the next campaign 
 to see the whole country become a scene of war. 
 The earliest and most vigorous measures are there- 
 fore required to obviate the impending dangers. 
 There now remain but two months for the con- 
 clusion of the rains, and this time, which should 
 be employed in settling the operations of the en- 
 suing campaign, will, unless prevented by your 
 timely interposition, be fruitlessly wasted in de- 
 liberating who shall fill the place of the late com- 
 mander. Whether, therefore, Cosseim Ali Cawn 
 or Raje-bullub be the man destined for this station, 
 permit me to say it is necessary your honours'
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 91 
 
 declaration in favour of the one or the other 
 should immediately determine this contention." 
 
 This is strong language, doubtless, and coming 
 from one whose opportunities of observation were 
 as abundant as his powers 'of observing correctly 
 were indisputable, it goes some way towards jus- 
 tifying the extreme step which soon afterwards 
 was taken. But I cannot see that the step itself 
 is either hinted at or approved. Mr. Hastings, 
 the resident at the Durbar, is, simply in the dis- 
 charge of a great duty, setting forth the state of 
 disorder into which all departments of the govern- 
 ment were thrown, and recommending to his 
 superiors the adoption of such measures as seem 
 best suited to avert the evils with which both they 
 and their ally were threatened. 
 
 The progress of Mr. Vansittart to Moorsheda- 
 bad, his interview with Meer Jaffier, and the 
 consequences arising out of it, are all matters of 
 history. It stands upon record, likewise, that through- 
 out the whole of the transactions which led to the 
 deposition of one nabob and the setting up of 
 another Mr. Hastings played an active part : yet 
 Mr. Hastings, like Mr. Lushington, was nothing 
 more than an instrument in the hands of his 
 superior, whose orders it was his duty to obey 
 Avithout remonstrance. At the same time it would 
 be an act of injustice towards all parties to con- 
 ceal, that the revolution having been once effected
 
 92 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 Mr. Hastings expressed his hearty approval of it. 
 As has been already shown, he thought meanly of 
 Meer Jaffier's abilities, and reposed very little con- 
 fidence in his integrity ; and hence, though he might 
 have hesitated, if in authority, to set him absolutely 
 aside, he did not feel that, as a subordinate, he 
 had any thing to do, except to support, as far as 
 his means extended, the policy of his superiors. It 
 would have been well for Mr. Vnnsittart, and, 
 indeed, for the credit of the English name in India, 
 if a like spirit had actuated others Avhose oppor- 
 tunities of doing both good and evil were more 
 extended than those of Hastings. 
 
 Sir John Malcolm, in his life of the. great Lord 
 Clive, has said, " there is no page in our Indian 
 history so revolting as the four years of the weak 
 and inefficient rule of Mr. Vansittart." This is per- 
 fectly just, even when the grand results of what may 
 be called public measures are looked to. It is a 
 thousand times more just when we come to 
 examine as well the motives by which individuals 
 were actuated, as the tone of their personal bear- 
 ing one towards another. To the Council, with which 
 he was expected to act, Mr. Vansittart was from 
 the outset an object of jealousy, if on no other 
 grounds, for the obvious reason that he had been 
 brought in over the heads of the persons composing 
 it from another presidency. To individual mem- 
 bers of the Council he gave great offence, now
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 93 
 
 by the little attention which he seemed to pay to 
 their suggestions, now by the preference which in 
 the distribution of patronage he gave to one over 
 another. But the circumstance which most of all 
 excited a feeling of unmitigated hostility towards 
 him was, that such a thing as a revolution, the 
 dethroning of one nabob, and the establishment of 
 another, should have been managed, not by the 
 Council collectively, but by the portion of it which 
 made up the select committee. Men were not forget- 
 ful of the enormous fortunes which a former revolu- 
 tion had secured to individuals ; and they were very 
 little disposed to sit down quietly under the idea, 
 that of their fair share in the spoil they had been 
 deprived. Accordingly, the change was scarcely 
 effected, and affairs put, as was believed, on a sound 
 footing, ere protests were entered in the minute 
 book against the entire series of transactions ; 
 which, if they served no other purpose, opened the 
 door to bickerings and strife, amid the din of 
 which not the public interests alone, but all the 
 respect due from one man to another, seemed to 
 have been forgotten. 
 
 The first year of the new Nabob's reign was 
 marked by many and important successes in the 
 field. With the assistance of an English detach- 
 ment under Major Yorke he put down the rebel- 
 lion of the chiefs of Beerboom and Burdvvan ; 
 while Major Carnac triumphed completely over
 
 94 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 the emperor and M. Law. Had the mind of 
 dive been present to turn these advantages to 
 account, the most beneficial results would have 
 accrued to all parties. The Nabob's throne was 
 undeniably rendered secure by them ; and there 
 needed only the exercise of firmness, discretion, 
 and good faith on both sides to place his relations 
 with the Company upon a just footing. But while 
 the English Government was wanting in the moral 
 energy without which it i's impossible to give the 
 law, except by violence, even to a dependent, the 
 Nabob thought only of confirming his own power, 
 with a view, as has been broadly asserted, of sooner 
 or later shaking off the yoke. " It was impos- 
 sible," says Mr. Verelst, " that Meer Cosseim 
 should rest the foundation of his government upon 
 our support. Self-defence taught him to look for 
 it in independence, and he sought it in the blood 
 of all who enjoyed the English protection." It is 
 not quite certain that any device of the kind had 
 as yet matured itself in the mind of Meer Cosseim ; 
 but the circumstance is by no means improbable ; 
 and a little more experience of the tempers of those 
 with whom he had to deal could hardly fail of 
 confirming him in the bold determination. 
 
 Meer Cosseim had offered an enormous price for 
 his elevation to the throne ; he soon found that the 
 exercise of economy, even on the most rigid scale, 
 would not enable him to pay the debt. He there-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 95 
 
 fore began to inquire narrowly into the manner in 
 which his deputies administered the affairs of 
 their respective provinces ; and of these, there was 
 one, Ramnarrain, the chief of Patna, whom he 
 early marked out as his victim ; partly because he 
 believed that a large booty would accrue to him 
 from the plunder of the Hindoo ; partly because 
 Ramnarrain was suspected, whether justly or not, 
 of a disposition to intrigue against him. Now 
 Ramnarrain was, to a remarkable extent, under the 
 protection of the English. There were treaties in 
 existence which bound them to uphold him against 
 every movement of violence or even of severity from 
 the Nabob, so long as he should make good the 
 payments to which he was liable, and act with 
 fidelity in other respects towards his master. Meer 
 Cosseim, however, either could not or would not see, 
 that he had no right to demand, from Ramnarrain, 
 a full explanation of his accounts. He made the 
 demand accordingly, Avhich was evaded ; and be- 
 came forthwith involved in bitter disputes with the 
 representatives of the English government at 
 Patna. Appeals were, of course, made by the 
 contending parties to the governor and council at 
 Fort William, by whom, at the outset, a disposition 
 was evinced to protect RanmaiTain at all hazards : 
 but violence produces violence in every situation ; 
 and when the temper is irritated, the judgment is 
 seldom clear. Major Carnac and Colonel Coote
 
 96 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS, 
 
 both went too far, rather in the tone of their 
 remonstrances, than in the views which they 
 adopted ; while Mr. Vansittart was equally in 
 fault when he attributed to a feeling of personal 
 hostility towards himself conduct which was dic- 
 tated by a sense, perhaps mistaken, of public duty. 
 The results were, that the Nabob carried his point 
 in every particular. Rarnnarrain, abandoned by the 
 English, was arrested, his office made over to 
 Raje-bullub, and himself put to death under cir- 
 cumstances of excessive injustice and cruelty. 
 
 The immediate consequence of this tragedy was 
 the cessation of all friendly correspondence between 
 the English and the native nobility. It was seen 
 or imagined that the former had changed their line 
 of policy ; and while the Hindoos, as a measure of 
 self-preservation, either gave in, or pretended to 
 give in, their adhesion to the Nabob, the Mussul- 
 mans, anticipating a return to former usages, cor- 
 dially supported him. Now it might, or it might 
 not be wise on the part of the Europeans to add as 
 much stability as possible to Cosseim Ali's throne ; 
 but it was clearly the reverse of wise to do so at 
 the expense of their own reputation ; for the very 
 existence of the English power was and is bound 
 up in the belief that a guarantee once given by 
 them shall never be violated. Accordingly, at the 
 moment when he was writing to Mr. Vansittart, 
 in the language of one whose existence depended
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 97 
 
 on the favour of the English, Meer Cosseim was 
 preparing for a breach, which the weakness of 
 some and the extreme intemperance of others of 
 the Company's servants hurried continually for- 
 ward. 
 
 Thus far there can be no doubt that Mr. Van- 
 sittart was entirely to blame. He was not justi- 
 fied in granting to Meer Cosseim, powers which he 
 had refused to Meer Jaffier ; for though he might 
 have purchased the throne at a more extravagant 
 rate, Meer Cosseim held it on precisely the same 
 terms which had been granted to his predecessor. 
 But if the president was prompt to yield too much, 
 his colleagues in office were equally well inclined 
 to make encroachments. There had prevailed 
 from time immemorial a practice all over India, of 
 collecting customs on the transit of goods in the 
 interior of the country : and to that custom Euro- 
 peans as well as natives were everywhere subject. 
 In Bengal, however, so much inconvenience had 
 been found to arise from the system it had proved 
 the source of so many quarrels between the 
 Nabob's officers and the Company's agents that 
 an arrangement was entered into in explanation of 
 the emperor's firman, by which the Company's 
 flag and dustuck, whether in their boats or other 
 conveyances should protect from search the goods 
 that might be in passage. Moreover, as the Com- 
 pany's trade consisted solely of goods imported 
 from foreign parts, or purchased in the country 
 
 VOL. I. H
 
 98 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 and designed for exportation, so their privilege 
 interfered but partially with the inland trade ; 
 whilst so long as the nabobs and their officers con- 
 tinued in the possession of substantial authority, 
 any attempt to abuse it was easily defeated. But 
 when a new order of things arose, and the English, 
 by the setting up of Meer Jaffier, had become 
 all powerful, abuses crept in which it was found 
 difficult to counteract. The Company's servants, 
 who then enjoyed the privilege of private trade, 
 and looked rather to the profits arising from it 
 than to their salaries for the means of acquiring a 
 competency, not only covered their private specu- 
 lations by passports drawn out in the Company's 
 name, but permitted their servants and depend- 
 ents to claim exemption from internal duties on 
 the same plea, and entered largely into the in- 
 ternal trade of the country. Now all this was in 
 gross and unjustifiable violation of existing treaties. 
 There was no sanction for it at all, even in the 
 connivance of the Nabob, who from time to time 
 complained of the injustice and under Clive always 
 obtained redress. Nevertheless the practice could 
 not be entirely put down, because the revenue 
 officers were afraid, except in very gross cases, to 
 interfere with the Company's flag, or question the 
 right of a Company's servant to use it. Such 
 was the state of things under Meer Jaffier and 
 Clive, and such it continued to be when Cosseim 
 Ali and Mr. Vunsittart succeeded them ; for in all
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 99 
 
 the conventions which settled the terms on which 
 the soubahdary changed hands, not one word is 
 introduced which can be interpreted as referring, 
 even indirectly, to the rights of individual traders, 
 whether foreign or domestic. 
 
 The spirit of cupidity, which even under Clive 
 could not be wholly restrained, was not likely, 
 under Mr. Vansittart, to slumber. Meer Cosseim 
 was not slow in discovering that the abuses under 
 which his predecessor had often suffered were 
 still practised, and that individuals were protecting 
 their private speculations from duty by means of 
 the Company's flag. Of that, as well as of the inso- 
 lence of the gomastahs and other native agents, he 
 made numerous complaints ; and so long as a ma- 
 jority of votes in the Council could be reckoned 
 upon, the governor exhibited every disposition to 
 afford redress. But in the month of August, 
 1761, there arrived from the Court of Directors an 
 order to dismiss from their service Messrs. Simmer, 
 McGwire, and Playdell ; obedience to which, as 
 it was peremptory and absolute, gave a new turn 
 to the whole face of affairs. Mr. Vansittart was 
 thenceforth in a minority on every question con- 
 cerning which any differences of opinion could 
 arise. The Council seems not to have considered 
 what might be for the benefit of their employers, 
 so much as how they could most effectually exhibit 
 their contempt and hostility to their chief; and 
 
 H2
 
 100 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 there followed such a complication of errors, such 
 an exhibition of violence, folly, and injustice, as it 
 would be very difficult to set forth in detail, were 
 the task of detailing it even desirable. 
 
 Up to this moment the part played by Mr. 
 Hastings in the game of Indian politics had been 
 altogether inconsiderable. As resident at the 
 Nabob's Durbar he had little else to do than to obey 
 such instructions as might be conveyed to him, 
 and to communicate in his turn, to his superiors 
 at Calcutta, whatever information he might judge 
 worthy of their notice. Moreover I find that he 
 was often referred to as a translator of papers 
 and letters when the members of Council were 
 either too indolent, or too little conversant with 
 the native languages to translate for themselves. 
 But the removal of these gentlemen, together with 
 the voluntary resignation of Mr. Smith, brought 
 him at once into a situation of greater promi- 
 nency, as well as difficulty. Together with 
 Messrs. Carter, Johnstone, and Hay, he became a 
 member of the Supreme Council, and his name is 
 henceforth associated, unavoidably at times, but 
 never discreditably, with occurrences which have 
 their record in " the most revolting page of our 
 Indian history." 
 
 The changes which had occurred in the Council 
 necessarily extended their influence to the out- 
 stations. Mr. McGwire, Avho had heretofore re-
 
 MEMOIRS OP WARREN HASTINGS. 101 
 
 sided as chief of the factory at Patna, gave place 
 to Mr. Ellis, one of the most violent impugners of 
 the late revolution, as well as Mr. Vansittart's 
 bitterest political enemy. Nobody could antici- 
 pate good from such an arrangement, though few, 
 perhaps, calculated on the extent of the evil that 
 followed ; yet were the first proceedings in Council 
 connected with, and arising out of it, sufficiently 
 startling. The governor, distrustful of Mr. Ellis's 
 temper, drew up a code of instructions, in which he 
 prohibited him from interfering, on any pretext 
 whatever, between the Nabob and his subjects ; 
 further than that he was to aid the Nabob, if for- 
 mally required to do so, with all or any portion of 
 the troops which might occupy the factory. On 
 tfiis a debate ensued, some of the board contend- 
 ing that an unlimited discretion should be granted 
 to Mr. Ellis, as well as the right of judging 
 whether or not the Nabob's motives were pure, and 
 the president, though supported by Mr. Hastings 
 and Mr. Smith, was left in a minority. The omen 
 was a dark one, and the events that ensued accom- 
 plished the prediction to the uttermost. Mr. 
 Ellis went to Patna, bent, as he asserted, on sup- 
 porting the interests of the Company, and the 
 honour of the English name ; and in a short time 
 
 O 7 
 
 the affairs of the English and the Nabob were 
 plunged in irremediable confusion. 
 
 The tale of the troubles and calamities which
 
 102 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 ensued, of the violence which marked men's pro- 
 ceedings in action, the intemperance and obstinacy 
 which distinguished them in debate, has been told 
 too often, and too much at length, to render a repe- 
 tition of the narrative necessary by me, " A ma- 
 jority of the Council," to use the words of Mr. 
 Verelst, " viewed with jealous eyes every act 
 of government. They considered all resistance 
 to the privilege they claimed (that of private 
 trade) as a settled determination to subvert the 
 power of the Company ; and passion thus uniting 
 with interest, they urged a measure of national 
 policy with the little peevish petulance of a per- 
 sonal character." On the other hand, Cosseim Ali, 
 finding that his representations produced no effect, 
 and that the orders of the government were either 
 evaded or disobeyed, became impatient of further 
 delay, adopted himself measures of violence, and 
 authorized their adoption by his officers, which 
 seemed but to increase the hostility and discontent 
 of the party opposed to Mr. Vansittart. An open 
 rupture was the inevitable consequence, and the 
 rashly planned and ill-conducted attack by Mr. 
 Ellis upon Patna brought the question at once to 
 the arbitration of the sword. 
 
 Before matters came to this extremity, Mr. 
 Hastings anxiously exerted himself to produce 
 something like unanimity in the Council, and to 
 restore, at least, the semblance of a good under-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 103 
 
 standing between Mr. Ellis and the Nabob. He had 
 nothing whatever to gain by supporting Mr. Van- 
 sittart ; it is certain that to some of Mr. Vansittart's 
 measures he was greatly opposed, yet in the main 
 he supported the governor, because he believed 
 that justice, and a sense of what was due to the 
 Company's interests, required that he should do so. 
 When "the tyrant majority" proposed, for example, 
 to introduce a dangerous novelty into the mode of 
 conducting business, by requiring that the foreign 
 correspondence, which had heretofore been en- 
 trusted to the governor alone, should be carried on 
 by the Council in its collective capacity, Mr. Hast- 
 ings set his face steadily against the innovation ; 
 and seeing that there yet lingered some relics of 
 good feeling among his colleagues, he succeeded, 
 after a severe struggle, in carrying his point. In 
 like manner Mr. Hastings opposed himself through- 
 out to the extravagant claims which were set up, 
 not by the Council as the representatives of the 
 Company, but by individuals ; arguing, with perfect 
 truth, that a change in the person of the Nabob 
 had effected no change either in the liabilities of 
 the office, or the rights of those by whom the 
 change had been effected. At the same time he 
 was not blind to the excessive rigour with which 
 Cosseim Ali appeared disposed to vindicate his own 
 dignity, and would willingly have lent his aid to 
 moderate the feeling, had the tempers of those
 
 104 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 with whom he was associated permitted. But if 
 the Nabob was determined, Mr. Ellis and his sup- 
 porters were overbearing in the extreme ; so that 
 each new day brought only a continuance of com- 
 plaints, with which there was neither inclination 
 nor power to deal wisely. 
 
 At length, after repeated interruptions both to the 
 public and private trade, and arrests of the parties 
 offending, leading here and there to blows, a cir- 
 cumstance befel, which produced great and ge- 
 neral uneasiness. There were quartered at Patna 
 upwards of two thousand sepoys, besides three hun- 
 dred European troops, in the pay of the Company, 
 among the former of which a disposition to desert 
 had recently manifested itself. Mr. Ellis more 
 than insinuated that the evil was fostered, if not 
 caused, by the Nabob's officers. He was in this 
 humour when a report reached him that some de- 
 serters had taken refuge in the fort of Mongheer, 
 and he instantly inarched a body of troops towards 
 the place, with orders to search for the delinquents. 
 Now Mongheer was not only one of the Nabob's 
 fortresses, but it was a royal residence or palace. 
 To insist upon dealing with it as with an open 
 village or even a town, was therefore to insult the 
 Nabob in the grossest manner ; and his governor, 
 or killadar, aware of that fact, refused to give ad- 
 mission to the party. If Mr. Ellis was indig- 
 nant previously to this check, he became absolutely
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 105 
 
 furious after it had been received. He directed 
 the commander of the detachment to hold his 
 ground within a mile and a half of the fortifica- 
 tion, while he himself made a report to the autho- 
 rities at Calcutta of the insult which had been 
 offered their representative. 
 
 The most wrong-minded member of the ruling 
 body could be no longer blind to the fact, that if 
 it were intended to avoid an open rupture with 
 the Nabob, some step must be taken to soothe his 
 irritated feelings. It was accordingly determined 
 to send a deputation to his court, in order that the 
 grounds of quarrel between him and the chiefs 
 of the factories might be investigated ; and Mr. 
 Hastings, being as little infected with the spirit of 
 party as, under the peculiar circumstances of the 
 times, it was possible for any man to be, received 
 a commission to undertake the delicate charge. 
 Moreover, Mr. Hastings was in other respects far 
 better qualified for the trust than any other mem- 
 ber of the Council. His long residence at the 
 Durbar had enabled him to become acquainted, 
 not only with the persons of the leading men, but 
 with the tempers of their minds, and their peculiar 
 modes of acting. And as there was almost as 
 much ground for uneasiness in the unsettled state 
 of things among the natives themselves, as in the 
 misunderstanding which had arisen between Meer 
 Cosseim and the English, his experience,] it
 
 106 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 was felt, would be eminently useful in unravelling 
 the mystery. For Cosseim Ali had taken great 
 pains of late to recruit and discipline his armies. 
 He had put to death, with a vigorous hand, several 
 refractory chiefs or zemindars, driven others of whose 
 fidelity he was distrustful beyond the frontier, 
 and entered into a closer alliance with the Vizier 
 Nabob of Oude than appeared to the gentlemen at 
 Calcutta to be quite desirable. Into the real mo- 
 tives which swayed him in reference as well to 
 these matters as to his intercourse with their own 
 agents, Mr. Hastings had it in charge to inquire ; 
 and the manner in which he conducted his investi- 
 gation distinctly proved that to none could they 
 have been more safely or judiciously entrusted. 
 
 Taking with him a military officer, Lieutenant 
 Ironside, and a small guard of sepoys, Mr. Hast- 
 ings left Calcutta early in the month of April, 
 1762. The following letters to the governor will 
 describe better than any words of mine, both the 
 objects which he had in view and the principle on 
 which he proposed to act in their attainment. 
 
 Moraudbaug, 15th April, 1762. 
 
 Sir, I have received your letter of the 12th instant 
 with the Nabob's letter inclosed. I shall not fail to 
 enforce the several demands which you have directed 
 me to make to the Nabob with every argument that 
 may ensure their success. 
 
 Though I do not expect to find the deserters at 
 Mungheer, I am heartily glad this foolish affair is at
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 107 
 
 length upon the point of a conclusion. If I find the 
 killadar in fault, I will represent it to the Nabob, and 
 insist upon his showing a proper resentment in punish- 
 ing the instrument of so much ill-will. 
 
 As the news of the appointment of the present 
 Nabob must have reached England before the despatch 
 of the Chesterfield, you will doubtless learn with what 
 temper that event was received at home, and will be 
 able to form a very probable conjecture what measures 
 will be taken in consequence of it. Any intelligence 
 you can communicate to me relating to the subject, as 
 it is what I am most anxious to learn, I shall be par- 
 ticularly thankful for. 
 
 The Nabob in his letter to me says, that he hopes to 
 see me at Patna or at Sarsaran, from which I anti- 
 cipate that he intends to stay at Sarsaran. Indeed I 
 am much afraid he is reluctant to trust himself this 
 way, and waits to see what resolution the Company 
 may have taken in the affair of his government. This 
 is certainly the case from the reports which I find to 
 prevail even here ; yet I wish he may be persuaded to 
 come down to Ragemahl at least, as an appearance of 
 distrust will hurt both his interests and the Company's. 
 This, Sir, if you think proper, I will urge him to do. 
 
 I arrived at Moraudbaug yesterday, and had a visit 
 from the Naib this morning. He has behaved with 
 great civility to me, and has assisted me with several 
 conveniences for my journey. He is a Persian, and 
 speaks the Hindostan language but imperfectly, an 
 elderly plain sensible man, and hitherto much liked in 
 the city. I shall return his visit to-morrow morning, 
 and the next day proceed on my journey. 
 
 One coss beyond Baggulpoor, 25th April. 
 
 Sir, I beg leave to lay before you a grievance 
 which calls loudly for redress, and will, unless duly 
 attended to, render ineffectual any endeavours to
 
 108 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 create a firm or lasting harmony between the Nabob 
 and the Company; I mean the oppressions committed 
 under the sanction of the English name, and through 
 the want of spirit in the Nabob's subjects to oppose 
 them. This evil, I am well assured, is not confined to 
 our dependents alone, but is practised all over the 
 country by people falsely assuming the habits of our 
 sepoys, or calling themselves our gomastahs. As, on 
 such occasions, the great power of the English intimi- 
 dates the people from making any resistance, so on 
 the other hand the indolence of the Bengalees, or the 
 difficulty of gaining access to those who might do 
 them justice, prevents our having knowledge of the 
 oppressions, and encourages their continuance, to the 
 great though unmerited scandal of our government. 
 I have been surprised to meet with several English 
 flags flying in places which I have passed; and on the 
 river I do not believe that I passed a boat without 
 one. By whatever title they have been assumed (for 
 I could only trust to the information of my eyes, with- 
 out stopping to ask questions), I am sure their fre- 
 quency can bode no good to the Nabob's revenues, to 
 the quiet of the country, or the honour of our nation ; 
 but evidently tend to lessen each of them. A party of 
 sepoys, who were on the march before us, afforded us 
 sufficient proofs of the rapacious and insolent spirit of 
 these people when they are left to their own discretion. 
 Many complaints were made against them on the road, 
 and most of the petty towns and serais were deserted 
 on our approach, and the shops shut up from the ap- 
 prehension of the same treatment from us. 
 
 You are sensible, Sir, that it is from such little irre- 
 gularities, too trivial, perhaps, for public complaint, 
 and continually repeated, that the country people are 
 habituated to entertain the most unfavourable opinions 
 of our government ; and by them the English credit
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 109 
 
 suffers much more than by matters which are made of 
 greater consequence in the debates between the Nabob 
 and us. You have already pointed out one method 
 by which the truth of the complaints against our 
 gomastahs may be inquired into and redressed, which 
 I shall not fail to represent in a proper manner to the 
 Nabob. But nothing, I fear, will ever reach the root 
 of those evils, till some certain boundary be fixed 
 betwixt the Nabob's authority and our privileges. 
 Were I to suppose myself in the place of the Nabob, I 
 should not be at a loss in what manner to protect my 
 own subjects or servants from insults ; but whilst the 
 principle prevails, that no point (however little beneficial 
 to ourselves) is to be given up to the Nabob, and that 
 his authority is on every occasion to be checked for the 
 security of our own, I should hardly venture to propose 
 to any other besides yourself to restrain the power 
 of our gomastahs to the immediate concerns of the 
 Company, to which we ourselves are limited by the 
 phirmaun, and our treaty with the Nabob ; and where 
 any persons assuming the English name are guilty of 
 acts of violence or oppression to the Nabob's subjects, 
 and within his territory, that the magistrate take such 
 means as his office and the matter in question may 
 require for preventing them, without making any dis- 
 tinction in such cases betwixt our agents and the 
 dependents of the government. As the power of 
 executing justice must be lodged somewhere, and our 
 servants, if inj ured, have always the means of appeal- 
 ing, we may be certain that the magistrates will be 
 very cautious how they give any such cause for com- 
 plaint against them as may endanger their dismission, 
 which should be insisted on as the slightest punish- 
 ment for any notorious perversion of justice. 
 
 With regard to the abuse of our flag in defrauding 
 the government of its duties, I know of no method so
 
 110 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 likely to prove effectual as those which have been re- 
 peatedly recommended, and which it is needless for 
 me to mention. 
 
 I shall forbear saying anything fully to the Nabob 
 concerning the complaints against our people till I am 
 favoured with your further opinion on this subject, 
 that I may know from thence how far I may proceed 
 towards settling that point, and preventing all future 
 differences that may arise between us and the Nabob 
 out of the present irregular and perplexing situation 
 of affairs between us. 
 
 The preceding letter sets in a clear and intel- 
 ligible light not only the difficulties with which 
 the affars of the provinces were encumbered, but 
 the causes in which those difficulties originated. 
 It contains, moreover, suggestions which were 
 dictated by the most obvious rules of justice and 
 common sense ; for the remedy hinted at in the 
 concluding paragraph was the adjustment of an 
 ad valorem duty, similar in principle to that of 
 which I shall have occasion to speak by and bye ; 
 but of which the good effects were never permitted 
 to show themselves. I subjoin the following ex- 
 tracts, because they exhibit both the results of Mr. 
 Hastings's inquiry into the nature of the Nabob's 
 relations with the King of Oude, and the effects 
 of his administration on the internal condition of 
 the country. It will be seen, too, that the affair 
 of the deserters was disposed of to the entire satis- 
 faction of all concerned, and that the writer's
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. Ill 
 
 opinion of Mr. Ellis's behaviour was the reverse 
 of favourable. 
 
 Soonygurrab, 2Sth April, 1762. 
 
 Sir, I have received your commands of the 21st 
 instant. I agree entirely in your opinion concerning 
 the reports of Shujah Dowlah's* intention of marching 
 this way, and of our Nabob's engagements with him ; 
 the latter absurd to a degree of almost impossibility, 
 the former hardly practicable this season. I shall 
 spare no pains to learn what designs are really form- 
 ing, and what is the state of affairs to the northward. 
 Hitherto I have not heard a word of news from that 
 quarter, except through your letters. * 
 
 Mr. Ironside has acquainted you with the particulars 
 of his search after the deserters in Mongheer fort 
 yesterday, which makes it needless for me to say any- 
 thing on that subject. I visited the fort likewise 
 myself, though not with a view of assisting his inquiry ; 
 for I would as soon hope to find a stray pebble on the 
 mountains around it as a deserter in a place like 
 Mongheer. The sepoys and sergeant are still at their 
 station at Juffiabad. I shall inform Mr. Ellis of the 
 search having been made, in the hope that he will be 
 content to recall them. 
 
 Patna, 4th May, 1762. 
 * * * * * * 
 
 The first inquiry that I made upon my arrival was 
 concerning the late executions. I am informed that the 
 Nabob had intercepted letters from Sutaram, Sheikh 
 Sadoolla, and others, to Pulwan Sing and other disaf- 
 fected persons, encouraging them in their rebellion by 
 arguments drawn from the disagreements between the 
 Nabob and Mr. Ellis, which they should contrive to 
 draw to such length as to induce the Nabob to quit the 
 
 * The King of Oude, of whose hostile designs many rumours were afloat.
 
 112 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 province, and then the design was laid to take his life. 
 Sutaram and the hircarrahs were confronted with the 
 letters in a large and public Durbar. They all con- 
 fessed their guilt, and threw themselves upon his 
 mercy ; but the whole assembly unanimously declared 
 that they deserved death, and the same instant they 
 were accordingly carried out and executed. Sheikh 
 Sadoolla being stationed at some distance, the Nabob 
 summoned him to appear before him, but he refused it, 
 and the Nabob detached a party to bring him by force. 
 A fray ensued, and Sheikh Sadoolla, with some others 
 on both sides, was slain. 
 
 I shall leave no means untried to learn the true 
 causes of the late disputes, and the just state of com- 
 plaints on both sides I shall freely and fully represent. 
 You, I hope, Sir, will do me the justice to believe that 
 I have no prejudices so violent as to make me support 
 any cause to the prejudice of truth, nor that I have 
 made so little use of the experience I have had of the 
 Durbar transactions as to give credit to every interested 
 information that is given me, or form any conclusion 
 but on facts, or a fair statement of arguments on each 
 side of the question. 
 
 I could have wished to have seen Mr. Ellis, who is 
 at Surgia. Had he been inclined to a reconcilement 
 with the Nabob, or to restore a good harmony between 
 us, I think he would (knowing that I came on such a 
 commission) have put it in my power, at least, to have 
 seen him. 
 
 A similar impression of the justice and vigour 
 of the Nabob's administration, as well as the 
 honesty of his designs in the alliance which he 
 had formed with Sujah Dowlah, is conveyed in the 
 following passages, which I select from Mr.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 113 
 
 Hastings's memorable letter to the governor, bear- 
 ing date January the 26th, 1762. I do not 
 transcribe the whole, though the whole is excel- 
 lent, because the opinion of the writer touching 
 Mr. Ellis's misconduct was a great deal too 
 valuable not to have found its way into Mr. Van- 
 sittart's narrative. 
 
 Whatever was the Nabob's motive for his continuance 
 in this country, he has certainly employed his time to 
 the greatest advantage, having entirely reduced the 
 province to his obedience, placed garrisons in all the 
 principal fortresses, and made the most prudent regu- 
 lation of the revenue, which, by his account, will 
 hardly fall short of that of Bengal. Besides this, he 
 has disbanded all his refractory jemctdars, and com- 
 pelled them to quit the province, which he could not 
 have so easily managed at a greater distance from his 
 borders. * There seems to be a great 
 
 harmony subsisting between Shujah Dowlah and 
 Cosseim Ali Cawn. They have reciprocally engaged to 
 deliver up the malcontent zemindars of each side that 
 shall take refuge in each other's districts. It is in con- 
 sequence of this contract that the Nabob has taken the 
 fort of Seringia for Shujah Dowlah from Door-bussy 
 Singh, one of the Baujepoor zemindars who had pos- 
 sessed himself of it, and has delivered it up to Dowlah, 
 who, it seems, has not been deficient on his part, though 
 the particulars have not yet come to my knowledge. 
 The conclusion which I should naturally form from 
 these appearances is, that Shujah Dowlah is earnestly 
 bent on supporting the King's pretensions to the throne, 
 and is willing to keep on good terms with a neighbour 
 who might greatly interrupt him in his designs. He 
 would hardly join our Nabob in distressing the enemies 
 
 VOL. I. I
 
 114 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 of this province if he had any intention of invading it. 
 It is, besides, inconsistent with the spirit he has ever 
 shown to quit an enterprise so flattering to his am- 
 bition for a mere acquisition of territory, in which, too, 
 he would scarce succeed so well. 
 
 The Nabob is so well pleased with his situation and 
 prosperity that he seems little inclined to leave this 
 place soon. 
 
 To Colonel COOTE. 
 
 Sarsaram, May 14. 
 
 You should have heard from me sooner had I any 
 other subject to communicate to you besides the pro- 
 gress I had made in my journey, which I thought little 
 worthy of attention. 
 
 I arrived at Sarsaram the 9th, and was kindly re- 
 ceived by the Nabob. He inquired in a friendly manner 
 both after the governor and yourself, and expressed 
 towards you such a disposition as I wished. The 
 motives of the Nabob's stay in this country have been 
 much misrepresented, if I may judge from the use he 
 has made of it. He has driven Palwan Sing and the 
 Baaj-poor zemindars entirely out of the country, and 
 obliged them to take refuge at Ghazepoor, where they 
 are likely to be plundered by Shujali Dowlah's zemin- 
 dars. He has very prudently garrisoned the forts of 
 the country, and stationed a considerable force at each 
 of the passes from the next province. In short, he has 
 acquired the unmolested possession of the whole pro- 
 vince of Bahar on both sides of the Ganges. 
 
 Besides this reasonable inducement for his con- 
 tinuance here, he had another not less important, if not 
 so lucrative I mean the discharging of his troops. 
 Most of the principal jemetdars had been the succes- 
 sive jemetdars of the government from the time of 
 Lefroy Cawn to the present. By the help of false 
 musters, into which, by a long connivance, the neglect
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 115 
 
 of his predecessors, and the pretence of a very long 
 arrears, it became dangerous to scrutinize, their ex- 
 penses eat up the Nabob's revenue, though scarce one 
 would go upon any service when required by him. 
 This determined the Nabob to dismiss them, and new 
 model his army. He chose this place for that work, 
 being the most convenient by its situation for ex- 
 pelling them from the country as he disbanded them ; 
 and this point he has very effectually settled. 
 
 You have doubtless been entertained with the report 
 of the Nabob's alliance with Shujah Dowlah as you 
 were before I left Calcutta with his engagements with 
 Shewbrit, the murders of Sutaram, &c. for their wealth, 
 and his retirement to the borders of his dominions 
 through fear of the Company's annulling his appoint- 
 ment to the soubahship. Excepting the last, which, 
 from the general opinion, was not a very improbable 
 conjecture, I look upon those rumours as so opposite to 
 the Nabob's character, his interest, and to common 
 sense, that I should be ashamed to pay so ill a com- 
 pliment to your penetration as to make use of any 
 arguments to show their falsity, were I ignorant of the 
 uncommon pains which have been taken to make them 
 plausible. 
 
 With regard to the Nabob's alliance with Shujah 
 Dowlah, it is true that they are upon very good terms, 
 having reciprocally engaged to deliver up the rebel- 
 lious zemindars on each side that shall fly to cither for 
 protection ; which, to me, is a conviction that Shujah 
 Dowlah is fixed in his design of carrying the King to 
 Delhi, and is willing to keep on a footing of friendship 
 with Cosseim Ali Cawn, who might prove an obstacle 
 to his enterprise or attack his country in his absence. 
 But that Cosseim Ali Cawn would invite so powerful an 
 enemy into his own territories with no other view than 
 to expel the English the very proposition (not to
 
 116 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 mention the strong tincture which it bears of prejudice) 
 carries on it such self-evident marks of inconsistency, 
 that the Nabob must be stark mad before I would give 
 it so much credit as even to debate the truth of it. 
 
 With regard to Shewbrit, the Nabob has assured me 
 of his intention to fit out an expedition against him and 
 for the recovery of that province the next season ; and 
 the Mahratta Vakeels have been long since dismissed. 
 
 The story of Sutaram's plot is very long ; the prin- 
 cipal facts I will inform you of: 
 
 Letters from Rajah Sutaram, one of the Nabob's 
 principal dewans, and Sheikh Sadoolla, ajematdar who 
 was greatly in his confidence, to Pulwan Sing and 
 others of the disaffected zemindars, were intercepted 
 by the Nabob. From these it appeared that they had 
 engaged the zemindars in their resistance, and planned 
 a scheme for the Nabob's destruction, and that the 
 Munseram and Norram Sing hircarrahs were the prin- 
 cipal managers in the correspondence. They (Sadoolla 
 excepted) were confronted with the letters in a large 
 and public Durbar, and confessed their guilt. The 
 whole assembly pronounced them worthy of death, and 
 they were accordingly conducted without the camp 
 and shot. About the same time Sheikh Sadoolla Cawn 
 retired from the camp without the Nabob's order, who 
 sent for him ; and, upon his refusal to come, attended 
 with an insolent message, a party was detached to bring 
 him by force, or put him to death if he resisted. He 
 still refused to obey the summons, and lost his life by it. 
 
 I have in the beginning of this letter accounted for 
 the Nabob's stay so long near his borders, and need say 
 no more on the surmises occasioned on that head. 
 
 This candid and sensible letter I have been 
 tempted to give at length, because it contains a 
 plain statement of Mr. Hastings's opinion in refer-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 117 
 
 ence to the Nabob's general mode of proceeding, 
 as well with his own subjects as with his neigh- 
 bours. It shows that in Mr. Hastings's view of 
 the case Cosseim Ali was neither a tyrant nor an 
 intriguer, but simply a man of vigorous under- 
 standing, who, finding himself placed in a station 
 of high authority, was determined to command both 
 the obedience of his vassals and the respect of those 
 with whom he might enter into treaties. In like 
 manner I cannot resist the desire which I feel of 
 transcribing one other, written four days subse- 
 quently to the preceding, because I think that there 
 will be found in it the clearest and most satisfactory 
 proofs that up to this date, at least, Mr. Hastings 
 was actuated by sentiments the very opposite of 
 those which tempt a man to outrage the rights of 
 others, simply because he believes that he may do 
 so with impunity. It is addressed to Mr. .Vansit- 
 tart, and was by that gentleman inserted long ago 
 into the narrative of his government ; 
 
 Sarsaram, 18th May, 1762. 
 
 I explained to the Nabob what you wrote to me con- 
 cerning the abuse of the English name and authority, 
 and the expedients proposed for their removal, which 
 I extracted from your letter, and gave him, written 
 under the following heads : 
 
 First, That strict orders be given to the darogas of 
 the chokeys to require every English boat that passes 
 to produce a dustuck, under the seal of the government 
 or any chief of the subordinate factories, and in case 
 of a refusal that they compel the boats to bring to.
 
 118 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 Second, That every boat with English colours, and 
 not having a dustuck, be stopped ; and if the goods be 
 English property, that notice be given to the chief of 
 the nearest factory, that it may be inquired into ; but 
 if it be the property of a subject of the circar, that the 
 Nabob take what notice of it he may think proper. 
 
 Third, That strict orders be given to the officers 
 and foujdars of the circar, if any English gomastah 
 commit any act of aggression, or interfere in the affairs 
 of the government, to forbid them ; and if they refuse 
 to hear reason, to use force to make them desist. 
 
 Fourth, That strict orders have been sent from the 
 presidency that none of the gomastahs or servants of 
 the factory intermeddle with the affairs of the govern- 
 ment, and that the officers of the circar be likewise 
 strictly enjoined not to obstruct the Company's busi- 
 ness or oppress the people employed in it. 
 
 Fifth, That no grants of wadadaries, farms, or other 
 offices of the government, be allowed to the Company's 
 gomastahs. 
 
 Sixth, That the Company's gomastahs shall be 
 allowed an English flag at the place of their residence ; 
 but no private gomastahs shall have an English flag 
 or assume any distinction from the English name. 
 
 Seventh, That by an order from the presidency, no 
 European shall be employed in the country without a 
 permission from the board, and giving security that he 
 would not interfere in any affairs of the government 
 
 Upon the two first heads the Nabob remarked, that 
 it was to no purpose for him to give such orders to his 
 officers, though backed with your dustucks, since both 
 have proved ineffectual to restrain the presumption of 
 our people, who seldom choose to produce their dus- 
 tucks ; and if the officer acts as his duty requires him, 
 a complaint is instantly sent to the next factory of the 
 insolence of the chokeys, the indignity offered to our
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARKEN HASTINGS. 119 
 
 flag, and the infringement of our dustucks. Sepoys 
 are despatched to seize the offender, and others, dread- 
 ing the like treatment, let pass all boats indiscrimi- 
 nately, and amongst them many that have no dustucks. 
 
 In the third article I have deviated a little from 
 your instructions, as I believe that you will be con- 
 vinced that the gomastahs are not to be kept in awe 
 by threats alone ; but some coercive power must be 
 allowed the magistrates, without which the gomastahs, 
 knowing the difficulty of finding out the truth of facts 
 so remote from our inquiries, will be continually inter- 
 meddling in matters which do not concern them. I 
 make no doubt but the officers of the government will 
 be tempted, as they have many times done, to abuse 
 their authority ; but the Company's business and the 
 English name will suffer less by a few instances of this 
 kind than by the unlimited power so often assumed by 
 our agents. An example made of the first attempts of 
 the magistrates to oppress our people will intimidate 
 others ; but to have every little grievance on either side 
 referred to the Nabob or yourself will be a source of 
 perpetual disagreement, and the inquiries will be found 
 so perplexed that I doubt if any redress will be ob- 
 tained on either side. 
 
 Notwithstanding this alteration, the proposal is not 
 satisfactory to the Nabob, as long as a power is lodged 
 with the gentlemen of our factories, on every complaint 
 of the gomastahs, to send out parties of sepoys against 
 such as they pretend have misbehaved to them. This 
 evil is, therefore, first to be redressed. 
 
 To the fifth the Nabob gives his entire assent, and 
 desires that the gomastahs and all others under our 
 protection be forbid to take or to solicit offices under 
 the government, which he has found very detrimental 
 to the peace of the country. 
 
 The sixth, 1 hope, expresses your intention, as the
 
 120 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 private gomastalis have no need of the protection of the 
 English name to carry on their business at the aurungs, 
 nor can claim any privilege above other traders, 
 besides that of bringing away their goods when pro- 
 vided with the Company's dustuck. 
 
 To these the Nabob desired another article might be 
 added, though implicitly included in the foregoing, viz., 
 that the gomastalis shall not force their goods on his 
 subjects against their will or at their own prices, nor 
 compel the workmen to provide goods for them at un- 
 reasonable rates ; but that every man be left at his own 
 option to buy or sell, as he finds his advantage in 
 either. 
 
 As the Nabob has no objection to any of the means 
 which you have so often proposed for preventing the 
 disputes between his people and the Company's, but 
 only to the want of a proper authority to enforce the 
 execution of them, he desires that whatever regulations 
 you may judge necessary for the above end, may be 
 drawn up in form and sent to him, with the seal of the 
 Company ; and if your name added to it be not sufficient 
 to prevent future cavils, that it be signed likewise by 
 the rest of the Council. Such a warrant will limit, 
 beyond the possibility of a dispute, the extent of our 
 privileges and his authority, and point out the means 
 by which he may preserve his government entire, 
 without incurring the imputation of trampling on the 
 rights of the Company. 
 
 It seems difficult to understand upon what prin- 
 ciple propositions so fair to all parties, and at the 
 same time so advantageous to the English, should 
 have been rejected. Rejected, however, they were. 
 The majority in the Council denounced the gover- 
 nor's plan as insulting to the honour of the English
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 121 
 
 name, and insisted upon their own rights, and the 
 rights of their servants, to trade upon terms which 
 must bring ruin upon all the native merchants. 
 That any boat bearing the English flag, moreover, 
 should be stopped by the Nabob's officers, or any 
 person claiming the protection of that flag be 
 punished by the Nabob's magistrates, was not to be 
 tolerated for a moment. They were quite willing 
 to avoid a rupture, and indeed to be upon amicable 
 terms with Cosseim Ali ; but then it must be upon 
 their own terms. Accordingly Mr. Hastings, after 
 three months of anxious labour, returned to the 
 presidency, having accomplished nothing ; for all 
 the bad passions which it had been his object to 
 soothe were still raging, and prejudice was as 
 violent as ever. 
 
 I must hurry over the residue of this narrative, 
 which there is the less necessity to prolong, because 
 the part played by Mr. Hastings in the transactions 
 that followed was altogether secondary. When it 
 was found that neither by argument nor entreaty 
 could the majority in the Council be induced to alter 
 their opinions, that they would not entrust the 
 Nabob with the slightest degree of authority, but 
 persisted in arresting his officers and magistrates 
 as often as a complaint was lodged against them by 
 one of their own agents, a new scheme was devised 
 by Mr. Vansittart and his party, of which they con- 
 sidered it judicious to keep the details secret till
 
 122 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 after the whole should have been fully matured 
 and digested. The scheme in question was that 
 memorable compact by which the right of private 
 trade was guaranteed to the English on the payment 
 of an ad valorem duty of nine per cent, on the 
 prime cost of the articles purchased for barter. 
 Unfortunately, however, the qualities of moderation 
 and temper were alike wanting on the side of the 
 Council and of the Nabob. The former tired up 
 when it was explained to them that to the Nabob's 
 officers was conceded the right of adjudication and 
 enforcement of the fiscal demands ; the latter 
 evinced a determination not to abate one jot of the 
 powers which belonged to him by virtue of the 
 treaty. Moreover he acted with some degree of 
 bad faith in making public the particulars of the 
 convention, before these had been confirmed by the 
 Council at Calcutta. The consequences are well 
 known. Everywhere confusion became doubly 
 confounded, till by and bye the Nabob, in a paroxysm 
 of fury, abolished all the transit duties throughout 
 his dominions, and so threw open the inland trade 
 to merchants of all nations. 
 
 This act of the Nabob, though the mere offspring 
 of necessity, and fatal in its consequences to his own 
 revenue, was exclaimed against at Calcutta as an 
 infringenient of all his engagements with the Com- 
 pany. They insisted upon that it should be an- 
 nulled ; and while two of their body were sent to
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 123 
 
 lay the sense of their grievances before the Durbar, 
 it was determined, in the face of a protest from 
 both the governor and Mr. Hastings, not to be 
 satisfied with less than absolute submission. In a 
 word, the majority in the Council appear to have 
 forgotten that from men in high stations some 
 regard to justice and some display of temper are 
 expected. They passed a resolution that from all 
 the out-stations the absent members of their body 
 should be called in. They invited to assist them 
 by their opinions and votes the two chief com- 
 manders of the troops, as if a dispute about trade 
 had been a military question, on which alone, 
 by the fundamental constitution of the govern- 
 ment, military officers were permitted to advise. 
 Finally, they made new distributions of their 
 troops, despatched a supply of arms to Patna, 
 and gave to Mr. Ellis authority to plunge them 
 into war whenever, according to his prejudiced 
 conception of things, the fitting moment should 
 arrive. All that followed is matter of history; 
 Mr. Amyatt and Mr. Hall were arrested ; the 
 boats laden with arms were detained ; Mr. Ellis, 
 in an evil hour, made an attack upon Patna, and 
 hostilities began in earnest. They ended, it 
 is true, in the overthrow of Cosseim Ali and the 
 unconditional submission of his ally, Shujah Dow- 
 lah ; but not till they had cost the lives of many
 
 124 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 estimable persons, of whom none were more justly 
 or universally lamented than Mr. Amyatt. 
 
 Throughout the whole of these transactions I 
 find Mr. Hastings voting with steadiness and tem- 
 per on the side of moderation, and in support of 
 the governor. For this he was severely censured 
 by his colleagues ; indeed, to such a height was 
 the rancour of one at least of the number carried, 
 that more than angry words passed between him 
 and Mr. Hastings at the very Board. I allude to 
 Mr. Batson, who,' not content with delivering a re- 
 mark to the effect that " the governor and Mr. 
 Hastings had espoused the Nabob's cause, and, as 
 hired solicitors, defended all his actions, however 
 dishonourable and detrimental to the Company and 
 the nation," carried his hostility to the latter of 
 these gentlemen so far as to give him the lie, and 
 strike him a blow in the public Council. Such 
 an insult, offered in such a place, was not to 
 be vindicated by an appeal to the pistol. Mr. 
 Hastings left to the Council the care of vindicating 
 their own honour, which, more than his, had been 
 outraged by the behaviour of Mr. Batson ; and the 
 Council, albeit little disposed to favour the com- 
 plainant individually, were yet forced to deal with 
 the affair as it deserved. Mr. Batson, severely 
 censured by a unanimous vote of the Council, was 
 called upon " to make such satisfaction as the 

 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 125 
 
 members of the Board shall judge proper, and 
 the Company's orders do, in such cases, direct." 
 
 This quarrel with Mr. Batson occurred on the 
 9th of June, 1763. It was not, however, the only 
 dispute into which a sense of public duty hurried 
 Mr. Hastings. His protest against the authority 
 given to the chief and council at Patna, of taking 
 such measures as they thought proper for their 
 own security, obtained for him the personal ill-will 
 of Mr. Ellis ; while Major Carnac owed him more 
 than a grudge for the opposition which he gave to 
 the appointment of that officer to the chief com- 
 mand at Patna. "I beg leave," says Mr. Hastings, 
 in a minute which bears date the 21st of March, 
 " to remind the Board, upon this occasion, of the 
 repeated declarations made by Major Carnac, and 
 now upon record in the consultations of 1761, that 
 he would obey no orders from the president and 
 council, which agreed not with his sentiments of 
 honour, justice, and propriety. Till, therefore, 
 Major Carnac shall retract that resolution, which 
 may be productive of the most unhappy conse- 
 quences to the service, and entirely subverts the 
 authority of the Board, I think it my duty to pro- 
 test against his being allowed to take the field 
 witli the command of the troops." Such a protest 
 could hardly fail of drawing from him who was its 
 object a very angry reply. Yet it is a remarkable 
 fact, that this very person, whom his colleagues
 
 126 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS 
 
 accused of desiring to sacrifice them and the in- 
 terests of the Company to the Nabob, whom he 
 favoured, should have been charged by the same 
 Nabob, at the very same instant of time, of having 
 been the principal cause of all the disorders which 
 had arisen. The following letter from Cosseim Ali 
 to Mr. Vansittart appears to me too curious to be 
 omitted. It seems to prove that the whole bent 
 and aim of Mr. Hastings's policy was to mediate 
 fairly between two parties, neither of whom would 
 listen to his suggestions, because they were both 
 grossly in the wrong. The date of the letter I 
 cannot discover, but it was received at Calcutta on 
 the 26th of June, 1763 :- 
 
 " I have received your letter. You write that when 
 I went to Calcutta I made this entreaty, that Meer 
 Mahmud Jaffier Cawn might only sit on the musnud 
 of the Nizamut, and the affairs be under my direction, 
 which was accordingly agreed to, and you came to 
 Moor shed ab ad in order to engage the assent of the 
 Cawn aforesaid. That again I said to you at Murad- 
 baug, ' If the measures agreed upon do not take place 
 to-day, I shall not live till to-morrow ;' for which 
 reason you placed some forces at the house of the 
 Cawn afore-named, and I continued in my own house 
 till their arrival ; that after this the Mahratta army 
 ravaged the districts of Burboom, &c., and you ask 
 whether the Shaw's army was defeated by the forces 
 of the circar or the English; that both great and 
 small in this country know that if at that time the 
 English forces had not been present in every place, 
 my subahdary would not have been of three months'
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 127 
 
 duration ; that the condition of the Cawn aforenamed, 
 in such a state of the country and the Nizamut at that 
 period, appeared to you without remedy ; that when I 
 went to Calcutta, I professed the same opinion ; and 
 if I had any other design in my mind, it was unbe- 
 coming in me to deceive you, and engage in that 
 business. 
 
 " Sir, in the commencement of affairs, what I said, and 
 what ' entreaties' I made to you, gentlemen, at Calcutta 
 and Moorshedabad, and in what manner the English 
 forces went to the house of Meer Mahmud Jaffier Cawn, 
 and how I sat still in my house, these particulars are 
 every one as manifest as the sun ; they are clear and 
 evident to you, and to write or speak them is super- 
 fluous. Nevertheless, you no doubt well know this, 
 that all this distraction and ruin brought upon my 
 affairs are owing to Mr, Hastings, both in what is past 
 and what is to come. Two or three months before 
 this transaction I was desirous of taking upon me the 
 business of my own family, and the care of the country. 
 That gentleman said, ' Engage the English in your 
 interests.' From the business which I undertook, and 
 the snare which I fell into, by trusting to their friendly 
 engagements, the day is come on which I am to hear 
 these stories, and to see these evils. 
 
 " With regard to that expression of mine, that 
 1 1 shall not live till to-morrow,' this, too, you very well 
 know, when I had departed from my own house, in 
 what manner you sent your people with me for the 
 protection of my life ; and whether I went to Murad- 
 baug of my own accord, or you sent for me ; and during 
 four days that I remained in my own house, with my 
 friends, with my artillery, &c., in readiness, what care 
 you took of me. It is true that on the day of the 
 removal of the said Nabob from the administration of 
 the Nizamut, when my people went four ghurrees 

 
 128 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 before day, and surrounded the palace; and I after- 
 wards rode out and stood before my own gate ; then 
 Mr. Hastings, with the English forces, arrived, and 
 prevailed upon me by expressions' of friendship and 
 flattering promises. Otherwise that Nabob was my 
 lord, why should I have deserted him ? I should have 
 restored him to his authority, and regarded the exact 
 performance of my duty to him as my own happiness. 
 But how long shall we argue upon this subject ? It 
 is as manifest as the sun, and there is no need to write 
 about it. The author of all these evils is Mr. Hastings. 
 
 "That you expelled the Mahrattas from Burbhoom, 
 and defeated the prince in Bahar ! oh gracious God ! 
 This reformation and order was brought about by the 
 forces of you gentlemen ! It was not the work, nor in 
 the power, of any other, that the prince's army laid 
 waste and plundered the country, in spite of the army 
 of Meer Mahmud Jaffier Cawn, assisted by your own 
 forces! What relief did you afford on this occa- 
 sion ? Why did you not expel the prince's army from 
 the country, instead of inviting him, by entreaties and 
 prayers, into Azimabad, and subjecting me, for the 
 space of six months, to the heavy charge of maintain- 
 ing both my own army and the troops of the prince? 
 Since Mcer Mahmud Jaffier Cawn was your ally, why 
 did you expose him to sink under the expenses of his 
 army? Why did you not drive out the Mahrattas 
 from his country, who for five years had been destroy- 
 ing it, and the prince's troops which were laying it 
 waste ? and why did you not apply a remedy to the 
 ruinous state of the country ? These evils you may 
 call victories ; but every one knows that such gentle- 
 ness and kindness shown to enemies, arc the effects of 
 weakness and not of power. 
 
 " You ask me again why I deceived you ? In what 
 have I deceived or betrayed you ? I never devoured
 
 MEMOIRS OF WAUREN HASTINGS. 129 
 
 two or three crores of rupees of the treasure of Meer 
 Jaffier Cawn. I never seized a boga or a beswa of the 
 land belonging to Calcutta, nor have I ever imprisoned 
 your gomastahs. Have 1 not discharged the debts 
 contracted by the Cawn aforenamed? Did I procure 
 from you, gentlemen, the payment of the arrears of 
 his army, or put you to the expense of maintaining 
 the Company's forces ? In which of these instances 
 have I deceived or betrayed you ? I gave you a 
 country which produced near a crore of rupees. Was 
 it for this only, that after two or three months you 
 should place another on the musnud of the Nizamut ? 
 By what religious custom or treaty are these practices 
 authorized, that such designs should find a place in 
 your hearts ? To raise a Nazim and then depose him 
 is only the business and in the power of you, gentle- 
 men ; none other can do it. Three years are the same 
 as three months. If such be your design, what does it 
 signify? Let your design appear, nor be longer 
 deferred. 
 
 " In a word, sir, consider well whether to take the 
 country of Burdwan, a country of near a crore of 
 rupees, for the expenses of your forces, on the stipu- 
 lated condition of assisting me with those forces, and 
 from the date of the treaty till now to act in contra- 
 diction to it, arc arguments that I have deceived you, 
 gentlemen, or you me. On this point I call on you for 
 justice." 
 
 Two facts would, I think, be established, even by 
 this letter did it stand alone, first, that "the four 
 years of Mr. Vansittart's government exhibit the 
 darkest page in the volume of our Indian history ;" 
 and next, that by whomsoever that page may have 
 been thrown into the shade, no portion of the blame 
 
 VOL. i. K
 
 130 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 attaches to Mr. Hastings. He was not one of 
 those who desired to wring from the unhappy Nabob 
 concessions which were not only not stipulated for 
 in the treaty which raised him to the throne, but 
 which, if obtained, could not have failed of invol- 
 ving him, and all who looked to him for protection, 
 in irretrievable ruin. Yet Mr. Hastings, the de- 
 fender of the Nabob's rights, and the champion, 
 throughout, of the just rights of the Nabob's sub- 
 jects, is the man whom in after years we shall find 
 arraigned before the House of Lords, as a remorse- 
 less oppressor of the natives of India. But I must 
 not anticipate the course of my narrative ; and I 
 have hazarded this remark only by way of attract- 
 ing the attention of my readers, to the ground of 
 hostility, which thus early in his career was taken 
 up against him by his associates in the government 
 of Bengal. 
 
 With the events which followed upon this open 
 breach between Meer Cosseim and the English, in- 
 cluding the massacre of Mongheer, the deposition 
 of the Nabob, the restoration of Meer Jaffier, and 
 the successful campaign of Major Adams, Major 
 Carnac, and Major Munro, I have here very 
 little concern. Though he had strenuously opposed 
 himself to the policy of the Council while yet there 
 seemed a chance of an amicable settlement of 
 the disputes between them and Cosseim Ali, Mr. 
 Hastings did not hesitate to join the governor in
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 131 
 
 voting for the deposition of the Nabob, so soon as 
 the question came to be one of absolute existence; 
 and his best efforts were never wanting to push 
 the war to an extremity. But it is quite certain 
 that he lamented the necessity which drove him to 
 adopt this course, and never afterwards ceased to 
 speak of it as in the highest degree disgraceful to 
 the English character in India. 
 
 I exceedingly regret that of the tenor of Mr. 
 Hastings's private life, I am unable, during this 
 interesting period, to give any detailed account. 
 Of his familiar correspondence, not a shred, as far 
 as I know, has been preserved, and as all his con- 
 temporaries have long ago been gathered to their 
 fathers, even tradition is silent on the subject. I 
 find myself, therefore, without authority to say more, 
 than that in addition to the death of his daughter 
 he lost his wife, where, or under what circum- 
 stances, I know not, in 1759 ; and that in 1761 
 he sent his son George to Europe, for the purpose 
 of prosecuting his education. So complete, how- 
 ever, and so impenetrable is the mystery which has 
 enveloped the early career of this great man, that 
 I have not been able to ascertain so much as the 
 name of the parties to whom this precious charge 
 was intrusted. It is probable, indeed, that he com- 
 mitted him to the care of his sister, Mrs. Wood- 
 man, and her husband, and it cannot be doubted 
 that, if the case were so, they disposed of the child 
 
 K-2
 
 132 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 where they believed that he would be rightly dealt 
 by. Yet all this is mere conjecture. I must 
 therefore content myself with stating, that after 
 fifteen years of laborious service in India, Mr. 
 Hastings resigned his seat as a member of council 
 in the month of November, 1764, and returned, 
 master of a very moderate fortune, in his Majesty's 
 ship the Medway, together with his friend Mr. 
 Vansittart, to England.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 133 
 
 CHAPTER VI. 
 
 Mr. Hastings in England The embarrassment of his Affairs His desire to 
 return to India Examined before the House of Commons Retrospect of 
 Occurrences in Bengal and Carnatic. 
 
 A FOURTEEN years residence in the golden pro- 
 vince of Bengal, during winch more than the usual 
 opportunities of amassing wealth were afforded 
 him, had not, in Mr. Hastings's case, produced the 
 results on which it was customary in those days to 
 calculate. Not once can I find his name included 
 in the list of those, to whom nahob, or vizier, 
 or native agent of either, had offered a gift ; 
 nor in a solitary instance was the suspicion 
 excited towards him, that he might have accepted 
 presents, yet kept the secret to himself. I do not 
 mean to assert that he received no mark of the 
 good will of the prince at whose court he so long 
 resided ; or that the nobles of Moorshedabad with- 
 held from him the keilat, or gift of ceremony, 
 which it was their custom to extend to the rest of 
 their guests. But in the legitimate fruits, or 
 what were so accounted, of the various revolutions 
 which he contributed to bring about, it is clear 
 that, for some reason or another, he was not 
 a partaker. Of Drake, Clive, Vansittart, Car- 
 nac, MuurOj Spencer, and indeed of all who from
 
 134 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 1757 down to 1764, had acted as governor, corn 
 mander of troops, or member of council, in the Com- 
 pany's service, it is officially on record, that they 
 extorted sums, always considerable, in various in- 
 stances enormous, out of the gratitude, or it may 
 be the necessities, of the native princes. But in the 
 catalogue of persons so honoured, I have not been 
 able, after the most diligent search, to discover, that 
 the name of Hastings is anywhere included. 
 
 I may, perhaps, be permitted to add, that the 
 fact, for such it is, reflects immortal honour on his 
 memory. ,1 am sure that men's knowledge of it 
 ought to have screened him, in a later stage of his 
 career, from some of the calumnies with which 
 party malice sought to overwhelm him ; yet is it 
 past dispute, that the consequences of his own 
 moderation were in the meanwhile extremely in- 
 convenient to himself. Mr. Hastings returned to 
 the land of his birth comparatively a poor man, 
 and so extreme had been his carelessness in the 
 adjustment of his personal affairs, that he soon 
 became a needy one. I have been told by those 
 who enjoyed the advantages of his intimacy, and 
 heard him converse, which he could seldom be in- 
 duced to do, upon the events of his early life, that 
 he brought with him only a small portion of his 
 savings to England, and that the bulk of them 
 was left in Bengal on security which failed him. 
 Though I cannot, on such authority, give the state-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 135 
 
 ment as a fact, I see no just reason why it should 
 be questioned, because it was from first to last a 
 conspicuous trait in Mr. Hastings's character, that 
 he never put the smallest value upon money. 
 But there is now lying before me a letter from 
 Mr., afterwards Sir Francis Sykes, bearing date 
 Muxadabad, 24th November, 1768, which seems 
 to establish the truth of the rumour beyond 
 dispute : "" I hope our friend Hastings," says he, 
 " will before this have, by the interest of his friends, 
 secured an appointment in the service. He has 
 managed his cards very ill, and between you and 
 me, I never saw such confused accounts as he left 
 behind him." Whether the property which he had 
 failed to realize ere quitting the scene of his 
 labours was or was not lost I know not ; but the 
 short extract just transcribed clearly proves that 
 he was the reverse of cautious respecting the 
 means that were adopted to secure it. 
 
 Mr. Hastings returned to England in compara- 
 tively narrow circumstances, and soon, for the 
 reasons just detailed, fell into embarrassments ; 
 yet was the generosity of his disposition abun- 
 dantly displayed in the care which he took to 
 minister to the necessities of others. His sister, 
 as has elsewhere been stated, had married a Mr. 
 Woodman, who afterwards, if I am rightly in- 
 formed, became steward to the Duke of Bridge- 
 water. To her, so early as 1764, he made a pre-
 
 136 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 sent of 1000, while on his aunt, Mrs. Elizabeth 
 Hastings, whose means appear to have been very 
 limited, he settled an annuity of 200. It would 
 appear that towards the end of his temporary 
 sojourn in England, he found serious difficulties 
 in fulfilling: the latter contract. Nevertheless he 
 
 O 
 
 made no proposal to diminish, far less to withdraw, 
 the allowance, though he was driven, in the end, 
 to the necessity of borrowing in order to make his 
 payments good. 
 
 It has been a subject of great regret to myself, 
 and cannot fail, I am sure, of disappointing my 
 readers, that all the inquiries which I have made 
 into the manner of Mr. Hastings's life and conver- 
 sation at this stage in his career, have led to no- 
 thing. Of his epistolary correspondence I have not 
 succeeded in recovering any portion, and even com- 
 mon fame, a poor substitute at the best for the liter a 
 scripta, is silent on the subject. I have been 
 given to understand, indeed, that in conversation 
 he was well-nigh as reserved in his allusions to the 
 interval between 1765 and 1769, as he was shy of 
 referring to the season of his boyhood ; and I draw 
 from the circumstance a conclusion similar to that 
 which forced itself upon me when sketching the 
 occurrences of earlier days. But whether his time 
 passed unpleasantly, or that his silence was occa- 
 sioned by the mere dearth of matter, on which to 
 dilate, I cannot undertake to determine. Un-
 
 MEMOIRS. OF WARREN HASTINGS. 137 
 
 der these circumstances there remains for me only 
 one course to follow: I must confine myself 
 rather to the correction of one or two mistakes into 
 which others have fallen, than attempt any expo- 
 sition of matters which are hidden from me ; and 
 then pass on to a more inviting field, where his 
 own letters will illustrate better than any narra- 
 tive of mine, both the nature of his occupations, 
 and the habits of his mind. 
 
 I find it stated in the Gentleman's Magazine, 
 and again in several numbers of the Oriental 
 Herald, that so early as the winter of 1765, " he 
 employed all his interest to be allowed to return 
 to India, and failed in obtaining the requisite 
 permission." I am not in a condition to say 
 whether this statement be or be not correct, but 
 in those which follow I know that there are errors. 
 He may have devoted himself, for aught I know 
 to the contrary, " to the cultivation of literature, 
 and the enjoyment of the society of men of genius." 
 To literature Mr. Hastings manifested a decided 
 predilection at every stage in his long and eventful 
 life ; and for the enjoyment of such society as his 
 anonymous biographer describes, he was eminently 
 fitted. But if it be the purport of this remark to 
 convey an impression that Mr. Hastings ever 
 sought to turn his literary talents to a profitable 
 account, the writer has quite misapprehended the 
 truth of the case. I have the best authority for
 
 138 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 asserting, that Mr. Hastings never printed or 
 published any treatise, or poem, or essay, except 
 at a pecuniary loss to himself. Again, there 
 occurs, in continuation of the narrative, expressions 
 from which it has been inferred that Warren 
 Hastings meditated at one time a plan for sup- 
 porting himself by the drudgery of tuition. 
 " The year after his arrival in London," says the 
 Calcutta Journal, " he submitted a proposition for 
 establishing a professorship for the Persian lan- 
 guage at Oxford, with a view, among other mo- 
 tives, to his obtaining the emoluments of that situ- 
 ation in aid of his own income." Now there are 
 two mistakes here, both of which, on the authority 
 of somememorandainMr. Hastings's handwriting, 
 I am enabled to correct. In the first place, it was 
 not at Oxford, but in some seminary to be founded 
 by the East India Company, that Mr. Hastings 
 proposed to establish a professorship ; and in the 
 next place, he made his proposition without any 
 view at all to his own personal profit. " I formed," 
 says Mr. Hastings, in the manuscript notes now 
 before me, " a plan for such an institution, but I 
 never offered, nor intended, to superintend it. I 
 was not qualified for it ; indeed my intention was 
 to obtain professors from India." 
 
 But whatever Mr. Hastings's views might be, 
 however straitened his means or cheerless his 
 prospects, events were already working out for
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 139 
 
 him the prospect of a return to that field of po- 
 litical exertion, in which he was so well qualified 
 to excel. It will be borne in mind that in the 
 year 1766, the affairs of the Company came much 
 under the notice of the public, and that in the House 
 of Commons a rigid inquiry was instituted as to 
 the system by which their newly acquired empire 
 was governed. Mr. Hastings, among others, 
 was on that occasion called upon to give his evi- 
 dence, and the clear and masterly views which he 
 took of the whole subject, drew upon him the 
 regard both of the minister and the Court of Di- 
 rectors. The consequences were the entertain- 
 ment in a much more friendly spirit of his appli- 
 cation to be restored to the service ; and his ulti- 
 mate appointment, in the winter of 1768, to the 
 office of second in council at Fort St. George. It 
 will be necessary to a right understanding of much 
 that is to follow, that I should here break off, for 
 a little space, in the thread of his personal history, 
 while we trace with a rapid hand the outline of the 
 most important of the events, which befel both in 
 Bengal and the Carnatic during Hastings's tempo- 
 rary sojourn at home. 
 
 BENGAL. 
 
 Notice has elsewhere been taken of the re-in- 
 statement in 1763 of Meer Jaffier on the throne 
 of Bengal. It was an act to which both Mr. 
 
 o
 
 140 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 Vansittart and Mr. Hastings were consenting, and 
 it secured to the Company the permanent posses- 
 sion of the provinces of Midnapore, Burdwan and 
 Chittagong, over the revenues of which a mortgage 
 had been granted by Cossim Ally as security for 
 the payment of the sums that were still due from 
 him. Meer Jaffier, however, did not enter at this 
 time upon the unrestricted exercise of all the 
 powers which former nabobs had wielded. The 
 English obtained from him the unlimited right of 
 free trade, and forced upon him a finance minister 
 under the title of Naib Duan. This was Nunco- 
 mar, an intriguing and crafty man, of whom notice 
 has elsewhere been taken, and of whom notice will 
 be taken again ; and he was appointed in prefer- 
 ence to a Mahommedan financier, Mahomrned 
 Reza Cawn, for no other ostensible reason than 
 because the majority in the Council were still re- 
 solute to thwart the governor in every thing. 
 
 Meanwhile hostilities were carried on with 
 perfect success against Meer Cossim, who retreated 
 into the territories of Oude, and was there joined 
 by the vizier Shujah Dowlah, and the forces of 
 Shah Alluin, the king or great mogul. The union 
 of the latter was indeed understood to be compul- 
 sory, for he was in the Vizier's power, and his agent 
 at Calcutta, Shitob Roy, made the Council aware 
 of the circumstance ; but had the case been other- 
 wise, there was no longer any disposition on the
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 141 
 
 part of the English to deal with him except as 
 their own conveniences might suggest. Accord- 
 ingly the army marched across the frontier, under 
 major, afterward Sir Hector Munro, and at a 
 place called Buxar, on the Ganges, engaged the 
 forces of the allies, and on the 23d of October, 
 1764, totally defeated them. 
 
 On the 5th of November, Mr. Vansittart, at- 
 tended by Mr. Hastings, embarked, as has been 
 related, on board his Majesty's ship the Medway, 
 leaving the charge of the government, and the 
 care of settling the country, to Mr. Spencer. 
 Under his auspices the war was prosecuted with 
 vigour. The King withdrew from his dependence 
 on Shujah Dowlah and was taken under the pro- 
 tection of the Company. He made over to them 
 by grant, on the 29th of December, the country 
 of Ghazeepoor, and indeed the whole of that ze- 
 mindarree within the soubahship of Oude, of which 
 Rajah Bui want Sing was in the occupation, and 
 received from them in return a pledge, that they 
 would establish him at Allahabad, and put him in 
 possession of the remainder of Shujah Dowlah's 
 territories. That pledge, in spite of a partial failure 
 before Allahabad, they contrived by and bye to re- 
 deem, though the terms of the agreement were ul- 
 timately changed. By the subsequent treaty of 
 Allahabad, to which the Company, the Nabob, and 
 Shujah Dowlah were parties, the Vizier was rein-
 
 142 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 stated in all his dominions, Corah and Allahabad. 
 Rajah Bulwant Sing was in like manner permitted 
 to resume the management of his zemindary, while 
 provision was made for the Emperor's dignity by 
 granting him, out of the revenues of Bengal, an 
 annual tribute of twenty lacs, together with the 
 two districts above specified, of which the reve- 
 nues were estimated at five lacs additional. These 
 events, however, it is necessary to observe, did not 
 befal till the summer of 1765, when arrangements 
 had been concluded with the Nabob which placed 
 the Company in a new attitude, and rendered them 
 competent to discharge so heavy a pecuniary obli- 
 gation. 
 
 Whilst these events were in progress, Meer 
 Jaffier died, and his son, Nujeem ud Dowlah, as- 
 cended the throne. The servants of the Company 
 were not, of course, neglectful of the opportunity 
 which was thus afforded of enriching themselves. 
 They extorted from the young Nabob valuable 
 presents, and setting aside Nuncomar, no longer 
 an object of their regard, promoted Mahommed 
 RezaCawn to the office of Naib Duan, and caused 
 him, as well as his master, to pay for his advance- 
 ment. It cannot be said of them that they were 
 equally attentive either to the interests of their em- 
 ployers, or the prosperity of the provinces. To be 
 sure they took upon themselves the whole military 
 defence of the soubahdary, an arrangement from
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 143 
 
 \vliich they anticipated both greater security to the 
 Nabob, and diminished expenditure by themselves ; 
 and they stipulated for a continuance during the war 
 of five lacs per month towards defraying the expenses 
 entailed upon them. But they were much more 
 in concert on the subject of free trade, to which by 
 the terms of a formal treaty they established their 
 right. Hence not only were opportunities afforded 
 of acquiring large fortunes within a limited period 
 of time, but the attention of members of council, 
 of factors, and even of junior merchants, was turned 
 absolutely into a new channel. The Company's 
 affairs were left to shift for themselves, while each 
 man gave up his best attention to his own. 
 
 The circumstances under which Lord Clive re- 
 assumed the government at Bengal are too well 
 known to demand repetition here. He went out 
 armed with authority to correct all abuses, and 
 wielded the power thus entrusted to him with a 
 vigorous hand. Great expectations were in con- 
 sequence excited, which, like all that had pre- 
 ceded them, fell to the ground ; for though his 
 regulations may have been the best which the 
 exigencies of the moment would permit him to 
 establish, they were certainly not such as to ensure 
 to the provinces the blessings of a good govern- 
 ment in perpetuity. Lord Clive struck, indeed, 
 at the root of one serious evil by causing the 
 covenant to be ratified which precluded the Com-
 
 144 MEMOIRS OF WARltEN HASTINGS. 
 
 pany's servants from the acceptance of presents 
 beyond a trifling value. Under him, likewise, the 
 grant of the duanie was obtained, while the trade 
 in betel, opium, salt, and tobacco, was so regu- 
 lated, that it ceased to be a snare to the junior 
 functionaries, and became a monopoly in the 
 hands of the seniors. Some advantage was doubt- 
 less obtained from it to the Company considered 
 as duan, for duties were laid upon the several 
 articles to the amount of 100,000 annually ; but 
 all beyond this went to enrich certain function- 
 aries, of whom the governor himself was one. 
 On the other hand, to the Emperor a yearly pay- 
 ment was promised of twenty-six lacs ; to the 
 Nabob an annuity of fifty lacs, while in the super- 
 intendence of his affairs, as well public as private, 
 both Rajah Dooloob Ram and Juggeet Seat the 
 Vakeel were associated with Mahommed Reza 
 Cawn, the recognized Naib Duan. Moreover, Bui- 
 want Sing, Zemindar of Benares and Gauzepoore, 
 having joined the English in their struggle with 
 the Nabob, was taken, as it were, under their 
 protection, and in the restoration of his dominions 
 to Shujah Dowlah the English became respon- 
 sible for the safety of his vassal. I cannot, how- 
 ever, find that in the treaty of Allahabad any 
 specific change in the nature of Bulwant Sing's 
 position is effected. He is still dealt with as a 
 zemindar, or great vassal of the Nabob of^Oude ;
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 145 
 
 and though secured against the vexations to which 
 a desire of revenge on the part of his sovereign 
 might have subjected him, nothing is said which 
 exempts him from the pressure of such demands 
 as in seasons of danger to the state, the state was 
 accustomed to make on all the nobles and great 
 men under the Musselman governments. Finally, 
 the Emperor was left in possession of Allahabad 
 and Corah ; Shujali Dowlah was fined in sixty lacs 
 for the expenses of the war ; a treaty was formed by 
 which the Company undertook, on his requisition, 
 to supply him with a portion of their army, while 
 he engaged to pay, as a remuneration for their 
 services, at the rate of 115,000 lacs per mensem. 
 
 Of the efforts of Lord Clive to reduce the Com- 
 pany's military expenditure, of the mutiny which 
 ensued, and the steps which were taken to sup- 
 press it, I have no concern. As little am I re- 
 quired to transcribe any sentences from his Lord- 
 ship's correspondence, in which he congratulates 
 the Directors on the brilliant prospects that were 
 before them, and foretels a golden age for their 
 newly acquired eastern empire. These were doubt- 
 less written in all sincerity, for Lord Clive was too 
 able a politician to deal in promises of which he 
 did not believe that some at least would be accom- 
 plished. But a little attention to the anomalous 
 state into which matters were brought in the pro- 
 vinces, an acquaintance, however superficial, with 
 
 VOL. I. L
 
 146 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 the sort of machinery which was to carry on the 
 current business of the day, will be sufficient to 
 satisfy every reflecting person that the realization 
 of hopes thus excited was not only difficult but 
 impossible. By the acquisition of the duanny 
 the Company had become virtually the sovereign 
 of Bengal, Bahar, and Orissa. The Nabob had 
 no longer the slightest control over the revenues 
 of his country ; he was a mere pensioner, and 
 nothing more, on the bounty of his European 
 masters. But it did not fall in with the received 
 notions of the day to make these truths palpable 
 to the world, and the Nabob continued, in conse- 
 quence, to enjoy the state, and to keep up the 
 character of an independent prince. Upon him, 
 indeed, devolved the care of administering both 
 civil and criminal justice throughout the soubah- 
 dary. It was in his courts, presided over by 
 natives who professed to be guided in their pro- 
 ceedings by a traditionary law, that the injured 
 cultivator, or weaver, or merchant came to seek 
 redress against his oppressor ; and how far he had 
 a chance of obtaining it, in the event of the wrong 
 having been perpetrated by a European or his 
 agent, it is hardly necessary to state. For beyond 
 the narrow circle of Calcutta and its dependencies, 
 the control of the English government was not felt, 
 and amid the wreck of the Nizamut, where the 
 authority of the English government extended not,
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 147 
 
 the only check imposed upon the rapacity of Eng- 
 lishmen and their servants was to be found in the 
 natural consciences of the former. 
 
 There was no such thing as justice, or law, or 
 adequate protection to person or property any 
 where in Bengal, Bahar, and Orissa, except at Cal- 
 cutta. The ancient courts had lost their influence, 
 and the native magistrates were destitute of autho- 
 rity. In the collection and management of the 
 revenue, likewise, the single rule observed appears 
 to have been, to exact as much as possible from the 
 occupants of the soil, without paying the slightest 
 regard to their capabilities. For as yet Europeans 
 shrank even from the responsibility of a general 
 superintendence, and left everything to be managed 
 by natives. " A resident," says the fifth report, 
 " at the Nabob's court, who inspected the manage- 
 ment of the Naib Duan, and the chief of Patna, 
 who superintended the collections of the province 
 of Bahar, under the immediate management of 
 Shetab Roy, maintained an imperfect control over 
 the civil administration of the districts included in 
 the duanny grant ;" but these gentlemen did not 
 pretend to possess a sufficient knowledge of the civil 
 institutions and the interior state of the country to 
 qualify them for the trust, and so left the native 
 collectors to be guided very much by their own 
 discretion. Now without going so far as to ac- 
 cuse Mohammed Reza Cawn or Shetab Roy
 
 148 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 of direct or systematic malversation, it would be 
 strange indeed had they risen entirely above the 
 temptations which assailed them ; while it is past 
 dispute that giving them credit for the most un- 
 bending honesty, the difficulties of their position 
 were of the very gravest kind. It is quite clear 
 that the fiscal affairs of countries, of which the 
 revenue is mainly derived from a tax upon the 
 produce of the soil, must fall into confusion so 
 soon as the cultivators are made to feel that the 
 government either cannot or will not protect them ; 
 while trade must languish if it cease not altogether, 
 where the strong are permitted to prey upon the 
 weak. Such however Avas, in melancholy truth, 
 the state into which the soubahdary had fallen, 
 at the very moment when Clive was prophesying 
 of the wealth which was by and bye to be gathered 
 from it ; and if even his vigorous arm and clear 
 judgment so permitted things to be, there was 
 slender room to hope for amelioration under his 
 immediate successors. 
 
 Under the administration of Mr. Verelst, and 
 his temporary successor, Mr. Cartier, the seeds of 
 evil thus plentifully sown brought forth abundantly 
 their legitimate fruit. There was not only no 
 surplus revenue, wherewith to increase the divi- 
 dends at home, but the profits of the duanny 
 proved quite inadequate to cover the expenses of 
 the local government. Bills were drawn to a
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 149 
 
 large amount upon the Court of Directors. The 
 bullion sent from London for purposes of trade 
 with China was in whole or in part appropriated, 
 and the Company's investments sank to a degree 
 which created both embarrassment and alarm in 
 Leadenhall-street. Moreover, there was no war 
 during several years to create an extraordinary 
 pressure on the treasury, nor any other ostensible 
 reason why the golden harvest which Clive had 
 procured should not be reaped ; yet from week 
 to week, and from day to day, the Company's finan- 
 cial difficulties increased, till the attention both of 
 the King's Government and of the country at large 
 were forcibly drawn to them. I allude to the 
 proceedings of 1767, both in parliament and else- 
 where, out of which emanated the further enact- 
 ments of 1769, 1772, and 1774: all of them im- 
 portant ; all seeking one end ; and some at least, 
 if not all, eminently mischievous. It is not how- 
 ever at this stage of my narrative that I can pretend 
 to speak of them in detail. As far as the manage- 
 ment of affairs in Bengal were affected, their results 
 amounted only to this : the authorities at Calcutta 
 were forbidden to draw upon the Directors for a 
 sum exceeding 70,000 in any one year; the 
 monopoly of the salt trade, which had been secured 
 to the senior servants, was broken down ; Euro- 
 pean officers, called supervisors, were distributed 
 through the country, to overlook the collection of
 
 150 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 the revenue, and the administration of justice by the 
 native functionaries ; and at Moorshedabad and 
 Patna two councils were established, with authority 
 to check and control the proceedings of the super- 
 visors. Finally, the supervisors were instructed 
 to make themselves familiar with the history of 
 their respective provinces ; to inquire into " the 
 state, produce, and capacity of the lands, the amount 
 of the revenues, the cesses or arbitrary taxes, and 
 of all demands whatsoever which were made on 
 the cultivators ; the manner of collecting them, 
 and the gradual rise of every new import; the 
 regulations of commerce, and the administration of 
 justice." 
 
 The ultimate design of these arrangements was 
 questionless to prepare the way for a wiser and 
 better system of administration than had as yet 
 been devised. Their immediate effect was cer- 
 tainly not to relieve either the local government or 
 the Court of Directors from their embarrassments. 
 Matters grew continually worse instead of better ; 
 while, as if to sum up the measure of evil, first war 
 and then famine came like a scourge upon the 
 provinces. It was in Bengal that the famine raged 
 with such fury as to cut off in the course of one 
 year full one third of the inhabitants : it was on 
 the Company's settlements in the Carnatic that 
 the war fell ; and to these, for the present, I must 
 turn the reader's attention.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 151 
 
 MADRAS. 
 
 On the 10th of February, 1763, the treaty of 
 Paris was ratified, by which the French, with- 
 drawing from all pretence at political ascendency 
 in the Deccan, secured the recognition of Salabut 
 Jung as Soubahdar, themselves consenting to 
 acknowledge Mohammed AH as lawful Nabob of 
 the Carnatic. It made no change in the spirit of the 
 treaty, that Salabut Jung was already dethroned, 
 and his brother, Bassalut Jung, reigning in his 
 stead. The principle was fully acknowledged by 
 it, that the endeavour to give both a Soubahdar to 
 the Deccan, and a Nabob to the Carnatic, had been 
 on the part of the French an unwise one ; and that in 
 all which seemed to be important to themselves the 
 English were successful. Nevertheless, the fact 
 that at a general treaty of peace, an Indian 
 prince had been treated as a party consenting to 
 such treaty, furnished ground for those to act upon, 
 by whom the Company's privileges were regarded 
 with disfavour; and by and bye it came to be 
 gravely argued, both in the Cabinet and in the 
 House of Commons, whether with the King and 
 not in a mercantile body the right of keeping up 
 diplomatic and other relations with the crowned 
 heads of India was vested. Hence the appointment 
 in 1770 of Sir John Linsay and Sir. Thomas Har- 
 land as successive plenipotentiaries at the durbar 
 of Mohammed Ali ; as if Mohammed Ali had been
 
 152 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 able to stand alone, independently of the support 
 afforded him by the Company. At the same time 
 it is worthy of remark, that this arrangement owed 
 its origin, not to any deliberate conviction in the 
 minds of the King's ministers, but to the unwearied 
 and eminently successful intrigues of the Nabob 
 himself. Oppressed with debts, both to the Com- 
 pany and to individuals, he ceased not, so soon as 
 an opening was afforded, to labour at the consolida- 
 tion of a party for himself among men of influence 
 in London ; and he so far succeeded, that but for 
 the exercise of more than common firmness at 
 Madras, great and serious evils might have over- 
 taken the settlement. These, however, are mat- 
 ters with which I am no further concerned than 
 that the allusions made to them in Hastings's cor- 
 respondence shall be intelligible ; for before he un- 
 dertook the chief management of matters at Calcutta, 
 that bubble had burst ; and there was nothing in the 
 experience of the issues in Avhich it resulted which 
 could tempt even party politicians to desire a repe- 
 tition of the experiment. 
 
 In 1765, a phermaun was obtained from the Em- 
 peror Shah Allum, which made over to the Madras 
 government the sovereignty of the northern Cir- 
 cars ; a maritime district which had heretofore 
 belonged to the soubahdary of the Deccan, and of 
 which a portion was assigned by Nizam AH in 
 jaghire to his deposed brother Bassalut Jung.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 153 
 
 The Soubahdar, or Nizam, as lie is called by writers 
 in general, resented this encroachment on his dignity, 
 and composing some differences which had arisen 
 between him and the Mahrattas, prepared to carry 
 his arms into the Carnatic. But the English, not 
 conceiving that they were strong enough to under- 
 take the war, hastened to enter with him into a 
 compromise. They agreed to become his renters 
 in these provinces ; to hold a body of troops 
 in readiness ; to settle, in everything, his high- 
 ness's government ; and to make him a present of 
 five lacs of rupees, which they called upon the 
 Nabob to furnish. The Nabob complained of this 
 addition to his previous burdens, and found many, 
 both at home and abroad, ready to coincide with 
 him ; yet there can be little doubt that, in a pecuniary 
 point of view, he was the gainer by it : inasmuch 
 as the ravages of war would have fallen entirely 
 upon his country, and these were certainly not to 
 be measured by any such scale as five lacs of 
 rupees. 
 
 If the Madras government had not pledged 
 themselves to furnish the Nizam with troops, their 
 false step in diplomacy would have been of 
 little moment, but the consequence of that incon- 
 siderate pledge was to involve them almost imme- 
 diately in Avar. Between the Nizam and Hyder 
 Ali, by this time King of Mysore, there was a 
 grudge ; and the English Avere required to assist
 
 154 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 the former in the reduction of Bangalore. I need 
 not go into a detailed account of what followed. 
 Hyder, a perfect master of diplomacy, soon de- 
 tached the Nizam from his European alliance ; 
 after which the two Indian princes united their 
 strength, and poured it into the Carnatic. The 
 results were eminently disastrous hoth to the 
 Nabob and the presidency. However superior the 
 Company's troops might be, and however unvaried 
 their success in battle, all the advantages, in a 
 course of nearly two years' warfare, rested with 
 their enemies. Hyder swept over the face of 
 the country, rendering it a desert, and finally dic- 
 tated his own terms at the very gates of Madras. 
 These implied a restitution of conquests on both 
 sides, the cession to Hyder of a narrow tract, 
 which had formerly been cut off from Mysore, and 
 last and worst of all, the assurance of mutual aid 
 and alliance in case either of the contracting 
 parties should be attacked from without. Now 
 when it is considered that by the terms of separate 
 treaty with the Nizam, the authorities at Fort St. 
 George stood pledged to support him, on demand, 
 with a specific amount of force, the excessive 
 temerity of entering on such a compact with 
 Hyder will be perceived, for Hyder and the Nizam 
 were so circumstanced that a long continuance of 
 amity between them was impossible, and in the 
 event of a rupture, from which party could the
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 155 
 
 English keep aloof ? Nevertheless, so desperate 
 was the state of affairs in all quarters, and so 
 great the anxiety of the home authorities, that 
 peace even on such terms was considered prefer- 
 able to a continuance of hostilities. The Directors 
 blamed the local government severely, yet their 
 own recorded proceedings distinctly show that 
 peace they were resolved to have, let them make 
 for it what sacrifices they would. 
 
 While such was the condition of the foreign 
 relations in which the Madras government became 
 involved, the internal state of the province, con- 
 sidered as a source of strength and emolument to 
 the East India Company, proved to be even more 
 unsatisfactory. So far from contributing to swell 
 the amount of the dividends, the presidency of 
 Fort St. George was compelled to seek aid both 
 from Calcutta and elsewhere, for the purpose of 
 meeting the heavy demands which the war im- 
 posed upon them. There was no regularity in the 
 management of the investments ; there was a 
 positive loss both on the foreign and country trade ; 
 and the Directors became, not without reason, both 
 anxious and alarmed. Under these circumstances 
 it was determined to interfere with a vigorous 
 hand, by bestowing upon a select committee the 
 powers which had heretofore been wielded by the 
 governor and council, and Mr. Hastings was gra- 
 tified by finding that his merits were not over-
 
 156 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 looked, nor his frequently expressed wish for 
 responsible employment forgotten. With the 
 general approbation of a full court, he was nomi- 
 nated to the important office of second in council 
 at Fort St. George ; the right of succession to 
 the presidency so soon as the chair should he- 
 come vacant, being secured to him, as well as a 
 prominent place in the select committee, on the 
 exertions of which so much reliance was placed. 
 
 While circumstances were thus working out 
 for him, an avenue to further usefulness and dis- 
 tinction, Mr. Hastings was spending his time in 
 that state of comparative obscurity which sets all 
 research, after the lapse of half a century, at 
 defiance, and leaves a biographer absolutely nothing 
 to say. Of one event, however, I am enabled to 
 make mention, which to him was the source of 
 deep and lasting sorrow I allude to the death of 
 his son ; who, after giving great promise of future 
 excellence, died I do not know where of an 
 ulcerated sore throat. Now, when I add that 
 Mr. Hastings always delighted in the society of 
 young people that if he had a wish on earth 
 more earnest than the rest, it was to bear the name 
 and cherish the feelings of a parent the extent of 
 this privation will be far better understood than if 
 I were to describe his grief as unappeasable. The 
 truth, indeed, seems to be, that he never abso- 
 lutely overcame it. His second marriage, however
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 157 
 
 fruitful in other sources of happiness, failed to 
 supply him with this, and could not, therefore, 
 teach him to forget that the blessing had for a 
 long space been lent to him. And as the blow en- 
 tirely overwhelmed him when it first fell, so months, 
 and even years elapsed, ere he ceased to shrink 
 from it. Mr. Hastings was told of his son's death 
 almost the first thing after landing in England ; 
 and he carried the cloud on his brow throughout 
 the entire period of his sojourn in this country. 
 
 An active mind like that of Mr. Hastings, how- 
 ever, though it may suffer acutely for a season, is 
 not often permanently unhinged by misfortunes, 
 against which there is no guarding. Mr. Hastings 
 sought relief from this domestic affliction in such 
 pursuits as were congenial to his habits. He gave 
 free scope to his benevolence by showing kindness 
 to those who had claims upon him, and in the 
 society of men capable of appreciating the rare 
 qualities of his mind, he found both instruction 
 and amusement for his lighter hours. There is an 
 expression in one of Dr. Johnson's letters, intro- 
 duced by Boswell into his life of that great man, 
 which seems to indicate that between Mr. Hastings 
 and the moralist some intercourse at this time 
 took place ; and if Hastings were an associate, 
 even at intervals, of the colossus of literature, it 
 is extremely improbable that he failed to make 
 the acquaintance of men inferior, no doubt, to
 
 158 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 Johnson, but all of them eminent in their degree. 
 Though, therefore, I have no documents beside me 
 to prove the fact, I am ready to accept as true the 
 statement of his anonymous biographers that as 
 an amusement " he applied himself to the culti- 
 vation of literature, and to the enjoyment of the 
 society of men of genius." 
 
 He was thus circumstanced when that par- 
 liamentary inquiry into the affairs of India took 
 place, with which I am only so far concerned as 
 it bore, in its results, upon Hastings's future 
 fortunes. As has already been shown, the evidence" 
 which he gave before the committee evinced such 
 a thorough knowledge of his subject, that the 
 hands of his original friends in the Direction were 
 strengthened, and new patrons presenting them- 
 selves, he was nominated, as I have just related, 
 to a high place in the government of Fort St. 
 George. 
 
 The following are the terms, in the highest 
 degree complimentary to Mr. Hastings, in which 
 the Court of Directors made their representatives 
 aware of the motives which induced them to give 
 to the presidency of Fort St. George so expe- 
 rienced and gifted a councillor : 
 
 " Mr. Warren Hastings, a gentleman who has 
 served us many years upon the Bengal establish- 
 ment with great ability and unblemished character, 
 offering himself to be employed again in our
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 159 
 
 service, we have, from a consideration of his just 
 merits, and general knowledge of the Company's 
 affairs, been induced to appoint him one of the 
 members of our Council at your presidency, and 
 to station him next below Mr. Du Pre. He will 
 proceed in one of the coast and bay ships, by which 
 you will be advertised of such further directions as 
 may be necessary concerning this appointment." 
 
 The rank in Council thus allotted to him deter- 
 mined also, in a great measure, the nature of the 
 employment in which Mr. Hastings was expected 
 to engage. Mr. Du Pre, it may be remembered, 
 was at this time president, or first in Council, and 
 on the second in Council devolved, as a matter of 
 course, all the responsibilities of export warehouse 
 keeper. Now with the export warehouse keeper 
 it rested to superintend the Company's investments, 
 to deal with the native contractors through whom 
 the goods were supplied, and by the exercise of 
 diligence and care in sorting the bales, previous 
 to their shipment, to guard the proprietors at home 
 against imposition. But one great ground of 
 complaint in reference to Fort St. George was 
 produced by the negligence with which this im- 
 portant duty had heretofore been discharged. The 
 investments had not only failed, of late, in point 
 of quantity, but the quality of the articles com- 
 posing them was deteriorated ; and Mr. Hastings 
 had it especially in charge to inquire into the
 
 160 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 causes of the evil, and to take such steps as he 
 might judge expedient in order to prevent its re- 
 currence. This, however, was not the only busi- 
 ness, as well delicate as important, to which Mr. 
 Hastings was directed in a marked manner to 
 apply himself. Another letter from the Court, 
 dated March 17, 1769, appoints a select com- 
 mittee, to consist of the governor, Mr. Warren 
 Hastings, Brigadier General Joseph Smith, Mr. 
 Bourchier, and Mr. Wynch, with full powers to 
 pursue whatever means they might judge most 
 proper for restoring peace to the Carnatic, settling 
 all disputes with the Rajah of Tanjore, and causing 
 the Nabob's debts, both to the Company and to 
 individuals, to be put in a train for liquidation. 
 Finally, the same letter empowers the select com- 
 mittee to examine into and correct abuses of every 
 kind, particularly in the collection and management 
 of the revenue, as to the method, execution, and 
 propriety of the contracts for furnishing the army 
 with all its requisites, and, besides looking into the 
 affair of the investments, to detect abuses and to 
 punish offenders. These were trusts which re- 
 quired, in the conduct of them, not merely firmness 
 and integrity, but a sound and even a delicate dis- 
 cretion ; because nothing is more unfair than to 
 condemn, hastily, proceedings which custom may 
 have in some measure sanctioned, on the plea that 
 they will not stand the test of a rigid examination.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 161 
 
 It is easy to collect, from the tone of Air. 
 Hastings's correspondence at this time, that his re- 
 appointment to the Company's service gave him 
 extreme satisfaction. Very few of his letters have, 
 indeed, reached me, and these are all hurried com- 
 positions, some of them being devoted to the details 
 of business, into which it is not necessary to enter. 
 For it is a fact, that such was the embarrassed state 
 of his affairs, that he found himself under the 
 necessity of raising, by loan, the money that was 
 required to cover the expenses of his outfit. 
 Nevertheless lie expresses himself on all occasions, 
 even when setting forth his own necessities and 
 urging his agents to use despatch in providing the 
 means of their removal, like one who, being con- 
 scious of his own powers, is nowise distrustful of 
 the future. Moreover, his perfect unselfishness 
 makes itself apparent in the anxiety which he 
 manifests to the last moment, that those who in 
 some degree depended upon him for support 
 should suffer no inconvenience from his departure. 
 His aunt is well taken care of by a deed regu- 
 larly executed ; the expenses of his nephew's 
 education are directed to be charged to his account, 
 and other pensioners, whom it might be indelicate 
 to particularize, are confirmed in the receipt of their 
 annuities. In a word, the single being concerning 
 whose private interests he seems at this period to 
 have been indifferent, was himself. 
 
 VOL. I. 
 
 M
 
 162 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 Having completed all his arrangements, and put 
 his baggage on board the Duke of Grafton, in the 
 port of London, Mr. Hastings proceeded on the 
 23d of March to Dover, and immediately em- 
 barked. A hurried note, bearing date twelve 
 o'clock, addressed to John Woodman, Esq., an- 
 nounces the fact, and as the temper of mind set 
 forth even under its very common-place phrase- 
 ology is characteristic, I am tempted to transcribe 
 it I- 
 My dear Brother and Sister, I am arrived safe, the 
 pilot is just leaving us, and this is the last opportunity 
 I shall have to write to you from this part of the world. 
 A good apartment, less confusion and difficulty than I 
 expected, a fair wind and most pleasant weather, are 
 fine omens of a pleasant and prosperous voyage. Give 
 my love to my dear Tom, my aunt, and all friends. 
 Again receive my last wishes. May every blessing 
 attend you, and a few years unite us again. 
 
 I cannot pretend to see in this letter anything 
 more than the transcript of a temper generous and 
 sanguine, and very kindly affection ed ; yet I feel 
 that I am in some sort bound to place it upon 
 record, because the voyage, on the happy progress 
 of which the writer counted so surely, was pro- 
 ductive to him of results from which the whole 
 web of his after life may be said to have taken its 
 colouring. I trust that my motives for dwelling- 
 lightly on the matter in question will not be mis- 
 understood. The breath of censure never, as far as
 
 MEMOIRS OP WARREN HASTINGS. 163 
 
 I know, fell upon the good name of either party, 
 that is to say, I never heard that there existed in 
 any quarter so much as a suspicion of criminality 
 between them ; but we are in this country, and 
 wisely so, stern moralists where the marriage tie 
 is affected, and do not, therefore, recognize as con- 
 sonant with God's law the facilities of divorce 
 which in the Protestant states of Germany are 
 afforded. I trust, therefore, that I shall be excused 
 if I confine myself strictly to an account of the 
 leading facts of the case as they occurred, while to 
 the good feelings of rny readers I leave it to deal as 
 tenderly as they can with a matter which, if tried 
 by the rigid test of moral right, will not, I am 
 afraid, admit of the shadow of an excuse. 
 
 Mr. Hastings found among his fellow passengers 
 in the Duke of Grafton two individuals, with whom 
 he soon entered into terms of familiar intercourse. 
 These were Baron Adam Carl Imhoff, a native 
 of Franconia, in Germany, a man of good family, 
 though reduced in his circumstances, who was 
 
 o 
 
 going out to Madras for the purpose of following 
 there the profession of a portrait painter, and his 
 lady, a person of singularly attractive manners, of a 
 very engaging figure, and a mind highly cultivated. 
 It was not my good fortune to become acquainted 
 with Mrs. Hastings till the last shadows of old age 
 had fallen upon her ; arid we are seldom able to 
 determine with accuracy, if we see them for the 
 
 M2
 
 164 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 first time in so dim a light, how either men or 
 women may have comported themselves when they 
 were young. Yet I can testify that even then she 
 was no ordinary woman ; while they who knew her 
 better and had other and more extensive opportu- 
 nities of judging, assure me, that long after she had 
 passed the period of middle life, she was altogether 
 fascinating. It so happened that between this 
 gifted young person and her husband there was no 
 conformity at all either of tastes or of disposition. 
 On neither side, I believe, could any grievous faults 
 be charged, and he, especially, in his own rude way, 
 was kind to her ; but their union was one of those 
 against which nature vehemently protests, and 
 which are never contracted without entailing on 
 the ill-fated pair long years of discomfort, if not of 
 positive misery. Let me not, however, linger over 
 a subject, even to glance at which necessarily in- 
 volves both the reader and the writer in difficulties. 
 If persons circumstanced as were the Baron and 
 Baroness Imhoff are permitted to pass through life 
 without encountering those towards whom the 
 deeper springs of their affections are instinctively 
 attracted, it is well for them. They may never 
 know what happiness is, but, at least, they will 
 escape its opposite. Should the contrary fate be 
 theirs, then more than human strength is necessary 
 to hinder them from yielding to an impulse which 
 must, of necessity, render the cup of their domestic
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 165 
 
 existence more bitter than ever. Strong principle 
 and a just sense of religion will, indeed, save them 
 from crime, but woe to the heart into which the iron 
 has fairly entered ; there is no chance of rest or 
 peace for it except in the grave. 
 
 Between the Baroness Imhoff, such as I have 
 described her, the wife of one whom she had never 
 loved, and Mr. Hastings, one of the most fasci- 
 nating as well as chivalrous men of his day, it 
 would have been strange if a friendship had failed to 
 arise, which gradually, and to themselves, perhaps, 
 unconsciously, took from day today a deeper colour- 
 ing. For she discovered in him all the qualities, 
 the absence of which hindered her from giving 
 her heart where she had bestowed her hand, while 
 he found in her more than the realization of the 
 brightest dream which his imagination had ever 
 ventured to form. Moreover, as if it had been 
 God's will to try the strength of their principles 
 to the utmost, Mr. Hastings was seized with a 
 dangerous illness during the voyage, throughout 
 the whole of which she nursed him with a sister's 
 care, watching by his bed-side often when he knew 
 it not, and administering to him all his medicines 
 with her own hand. I repeat, that I never heard 
 so much as an insinuation hurtful to the honour of 
 either party. They were both too high-minded to 
 inflict on a husband an injury which never can be 
 repaired ; but they were not firm enough to hold
 
 166 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 out against the strong temptation which the laws 
 of Protestant Germany, in reference to the marriage 
 contract, cast in their way. Mr. and Mrs. Imhoff 
 lived together, with good repute, a whole year in 
 Madras. They acted upon the same wise and 
 judicious plan after they followed Mr. Hastings to 
 Bengal. Yet all this while a suit was going 
 forward in the proper courts of Franconia for a 
 divorce. The divorce was obtained after much 
 delay ; the Baroness Imhoff became Mrs. Hastings, 
 and the Baron returned to his native country a 
 richer man than he ever could have hoped to become 
 by the mere exercise of his skill as a painter. 
 
 Before I quit this part of my subject, I think it 
 right to state that a union more productive than 
 this of perfect happiness to both parties has never 
 been contracted. I have read almost all the letters 
 that Mr. Hastings at various times addressed to 
 his wife; and, from the first to the last, I can find 
 no decline there ; they breathe throughout a 
 spirit of devoted attachment, such as I have rarely 
 seen equalled, such as could not be surpassed. 
 Moreover, Mrs. Hastings's children, for she had 
 two sons by her first marriage, became imme- 
 diately to Mr. Hastings as if they had been his 
 own. One of these was unfortunate, and died 
 early, but the other, the present Lieutenant- General 
 Sir Charles Imhoff, still lives to speak of Mr. 
 Hastings as of a parent whose tenderness and care
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 167 
 
 will never pass from his grateful recollection till 
 memory cease to do its office. 
 
 I return now to the more dry details of 
 Hastings' s public history ; from which we learn 
 that he arrived at Fort St. George without the 
 occurrence of any accident, and that, having taken 
 the oaths as well as his seat at the council-board, 
 he was immediately, with the governor and the rest 
 of the gentlemen specified in the Court's letter, ap- 
 pointed to act as a select committee. Some portion 
 of the business which the Directors had entrusted 
 to the committee's management was indeed already 
 completed. There was peace in the Carnatic, pur- 
 chased no doubt at a very heavy cost, yet beneficial, 
 on the whole, to the Company's interests ; while 
 Avith the Rajah of Tan j ore a negociation had been 
 opened, from which satisfactory results were ex- 
 pected by and bye to flow. But all the questions 
 touching the settlement of the Nabob's debts, as 
 well as the means of introducing an improved system 
 into the management of the investments, still re- 
 mained open, and to these the committee addressed 
 themselves. I do not find that, in reference to the 
 former of these points, Mr. Hastings took any 
 prominent part. His opinions seem to have con- 
 curred with those of his colleagues in general, and 
 with them he laboured so to arrange matters as 
 that, giving a preference to the Company over in- 
 dividuals from whom the Nabob had borrowed, they
 
 168 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 might yet secure to all the prospect of an equitable 
 adjustment of their accounts. The case, however, 
 is different as regards the arrangement of an im- 
 proved plan for providing the investments, and 
 rendering them profitable when provided. Of this 
 the merit belongs exclusively to Mr. Hastings; and 
 I therefore conceive that I am bound, at the 
 hazard of fatiguing wherever I may fail to instruct, 
 to explain matters so that the grounds on which he 
 secured the approbation of his employers at this 
 time may become apparent. 
 
 The investments from the Carnatic, or, to speak 
 more accurately, the most valuable portions of 
 them, consisted at that time : first, of manufac- 
 tured goods of silks and cottons woven in the 
 piece ; and next, of the cocoons of the silk- worms, 
 or the thread itself, wound off and made ready for 
 the use of the manufacturer at home. In pro- 
 viding these it had heretofore been the custom to 
 contract with certain native merchants, who having 
 engaged to furnish no more than a specified amount 
 of each article, and being left to make with the 
 growers and the weavers their own bargain, were 
 paid according to the quality as well as quantity 
 of the goods sent in by them to the Company's 
 warehouses. Now if the superintendence exer- 
 cised over the proceedings of these native con- 
 tractors had been sleepless, and such, in other 
 respects, as the nature of the transaction required,
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 169 
 
 though the poor weavers and growers might have 
 suffered wrong, the Company at least would have 
 been protected from imposition. But the very 
 reverse was the case. 
 
 The contractors, after cheating the ryots a class 
 of men whose abject poverty keeps them in con- 
 stant bondage to the money-lender so packed 
 their bales as to exact for the worst qualities of 
 goods prices which had been promised only for the 
 best, while they whose duty it was to guard 
 against the perpetration of the wrong, partly 
 through ignorance, partly through the lack of at- 
 tention, suffered it, season after season, to pass 
 unnoticed. For the custom of the service was to 
 confer the office of export warehouse keeper on 
 one whose duties as second in council were of 
 themselves sufficiently onerous to occupy the 
 whole of his time ; while lie had as his assistants 
 the youngest servants of the Company mere 
 lads, who, having just arrived, knew nothing about 
 the matter, and were too well assured of a speedy 
 removal to higher employment ever to think of 
 reforming themselves. The obvious consequences 
 were, an oppression upon the weavers which grew 
 heavier every season, till by and bye it threatened 
 to paralyze them altogether ; and a progressive de- 
 terioration in the worth of the goods exported, 
 from the sale of which in the London market the
 
 170 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 proprietors of India stock counted on receiving their 
 dividends. 
 
 To remedy these evils, and by so doing to con- 
 fer substantial benefits on the native population, 
 as well as on his employers, Mr. Hastings recom- 
 mended the adoption of the following expedients : 
 He advised that the office of export warehouse 
 keeper should thenceforth become separate and 
 distinct in itself; that a gentleman skilled in the 
 trade and manufactures of the country should be 
 appointed to fill it ; and that he should be assisted 
 in his labours by a body of clerks from whom both 
 diligence and a thorough knowledge of details 
 should be required. With respect again to the 
 mode of remunerating these functionaries, Mr. 
 Hastings suggested that they should be allowed a 
 per-centage on the goods sold in the country for 
 which it was certain that the demand would 
 become continually greater in proportion to the 
 increased and increasing wealth of the native 
 population. Moreover, the whole system of con- 
 tracts, including the profits of the middle man or 
 native merchant, was to be set aside. Both in the 
 Carnatic and elsewhere, the manufactures were 
 then, and are still, carried on in villages all, or 
 almost all, the inhabitants of which find subsist- 
 ance by working at the loom ; while of the villages 
 themselves a certain number used at that period to
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 171 
 
 be comprehended in a district, for the produce of 
 which the native merchant or contractor engaged 
 with the Company. Mr. Hastings recommended 
 that the whole of this machinery should be 
 abolished, and that persons employed immediately 
 by the export warehouse keeper should pay 
 periodical visits to the manufacturing villages, 
 and on the spot make arrangements with the chiefs 
 or head men of those villages for the investments. 
 At the same time it was his opinion that the 
 Company ought to limit its corporate dealings to a 
 certain number of these villages, taking a pledge 
 from the societies thus favoured that they would 
 work for no private masters, while with the pro- 
 ceedings of the rest they no further concerned 
 themselves than by extending to the ryots in all 
 their transactions the ordinary protection of the 
 law. Such, in few words, is the substance of a 
 plan which I find laid down at great length in a 
 minute by Mr. Hastings, bearing date the 7th 
 of December, 1771, and which, having been una- 
 nimously approved of, both at Fort St. George 
 and in London, was in due time carried into exe- 
 cution, very much to the benefit both of the native 
 manufacturer and the European purchaser. 
 
 To complete his own scheme and bring it into 
 operation, while at the same time he took his share 
 in the current business of the settlement, gained 
 for Mr. Hastings both occupation and honour till
 
 172 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 the end of December, 1771. It was then notified 
 to him, both from Europe and Calcutta, that the 
 Directors, as a mark of their high approbation, had 
 nominated him to the place of second in council 
 at Bengal, with the assurance that so soon as 
 Mr. Cartier should retire, it was their wish 
 that he should take upon himself the charge of 
 the government. Many reasons combined to 
 render this arrangement peculiarly acceptable to 
 the object of it. In the first place, it opened to 
 his ambition the great ruling yet well regulated 
 passion of his soul a far wider and more im- 
 portant field than that which the Carnatic could 
 afford. In the next place, Mr. Hastings seems 
 ahvays to have cherished a strong yet natural 
 partiality for the scene of his early labours ; and 
 last of all, there appeared to be a better chance of 
 acquiring a competency in the very highest than 
 in any other and subordinate situation in the service 
 of the Company. And though there never lived 
 a man so indifferent as Warren Hastings to 
 money, considered as such, and of course to the 
 means of its accumulation, still all his habits were 
 such as to render the possession of at least a 
 moderate fortune necessary to his very existence. 
 Nevertheless, he could not contemplate without some 
 regret the prospect of removing from a position in 
 which he had the satisfaction to know that he had 
 performed good service to the public, without
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 173 
 
 exciting towards himself one angry feeling in the 
 breasts of individuals. He was not, indeed, blind 
 to the many errors in policy of which both his 
 immediate colleagues and their predecessors had 
 been guilty. But he felt for the extraordinary 
 difficulties of their situation, and would have freely 
 shared it with them, had such been the will of his 
 superiors. The following series of letters, indi- 
 cative of these sentiments, I insert, not without 
 some little apprehension in my own mind that 
 they contain allusions which to the uninformed 
 reader may appear obscure, if not unmeaning. At 
 the same time, as I cannot undertake to give in 
 this place a general history both of India and of 
 England, I must presume something on the 
 previous acquaintance with these subjects of all 
 who are likely to take an interest in the life of 
 Warren Hastings ; I therefore give the letters as 
 I find them, in the order of their dates, and 
 without one word of note or comment. 
 
 To Mr. and Mrs. WOODMAN. 
 
 Fort St. George, 30th January, 1771. 
 
 My dear Brother and Sister, I am at this time 
 busied in preparations for leaving this settlement, and 
 repairing to my new residence ; may it prove as easy, 
 as comfortable, as this has been, but more profitable, 
 I hope. I have only time to inform you that I have 
 cased a pipe of old Madeira, and ordered it to be sent 
 to England in the first ship, directed to you. I beg 
 you will divide it with Mrs. Hancock; it will last you 
 both, I hope, till I can send another, for your families
 
 174 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 are but small, and consume but little wine in the year. 
 You will be informed by my attorneys in what ship it 
 goes. 
 
 I shall make another remittance of money, sufficient 
 to discharge the remainder of my debts ; but I am not 
 yet sure of the amount ; that, too, Mr. Woodman will 
 learn from my attorneys. 
 
 I cannot answer your letters, for I am at a distance 
 from them. I remember they told me you were all 
 well; that Tommy was become a great scholar, and 
 my niece a most thriving and fine child ; indeed, I 
 have letters that speak wonders of her accomplish- 
 ments. May every year bring me the same glad 
 tidings ; I wish not for better, and would compound 
 for many a misfortune to be sure of such an annual 
 present. I leave this place in health and in spirits, 
 except what I feel in parting from it. Accept the 
 repeated assurance of my affection, of my warmest 
 wishes for your long, long continued happiness, my 
 dearest brother and sister, aunt, Tommy, Bessy ; may 
 God bless and protect you is the prayer of your most 
 affectionate. 
 
 To FRANCIS SVKES, Esq. 
 
 Fort St. George, 30th January, 1772. 
 
 Dear Sykes, I have not time, as you may well 
 imagine, for a long letter, but hope for more leisure in 
 my passage to Bengal, and more composed thoughts. 
 I am now taking leave of this place, and shall embark 
 the 2nd, in the morning. Yet I would not lose the 
 first occasion to tell you how much joy it has given me 
 to learn that I am much indebted to you for my late 
 appointment. How sensibly 1 feel the obligation I 
 cannot tell you; but you are the friend you have 
 always professed yourself, and you shall always find 
 me your most warm and hearty friend. I leave this 
 place in actual peace, and likely to continue so for a
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 175 
 
 couple of years to come ; what will afterwards follow 
 God knows. It will depend more on the measures 
 from home than in what can be done here. I am happy 
 in leaving Mr. Du Pre still in the chair. I hope the 
 Directors will encourage him to continue in it. His 
 abilities are very great, and if equalled by any quali ty 
 it is by his unwearied assiduity and application. 
 
 I have sent you one pipe of Madeira ; I forget by 
 what ship. You will receive another by one of the two 
 next. Old wine and the pipe cased. My attorney 
 will inform you by what ship it goes. Adieu. Believe 
 me most sincerely and affectionately your obliged 
 friend. 
 
 To Lord SHELBURNE. 
 
 Fort St. George, 31st January, 1772. 
 
 My Lord, The enclosed is a duplicate of a letter 
 which I had the honour to address to your Lordship 
 some months ago. The Court of Directors have since 
 been pleased to confer upon me the government of 
 their possessions in Bengal, an honour equally unso- 
 licited and unexpected on my part. By whatever 
 means it has fallen to my lot, there is a degree of con- 
 fidence implied in the manner of it, which claims a 
 more than ordinary share of my attention to the very 
 weighty affairs of that presidency. You will permit 
 me to say, my Lord, that you have furnished an addi- 
 tional motive to my ambition, in the desire which I feel 
 to merit the good opinion which your Lordship has 
 already been pleased to express of me. 
 
 This letter will be conveyed to your Lordship, as 
 my last was, by the means of W. M'Pherson. Had it 
 been my fortune to remain in this place, I should have 
 sought for some means of doing him service. Your 
 recommendation, and his o\vn merit, and useful talents, 
 would have entitled him to my best offices. But I fear 
 I have no better proof of my friendship left to show him
 
 176 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 than my good wishes. Allow me, my Lord, to repeat the 
 assurances which I have already expressed of my desire 
 to receive your commands, and of the great respect 
 with which I have the honour to be, my Lord, your 
 Lordship's most obedient and most humble servant. 
 
 To Mrs. HANCOCK. 
 
 Fort St. George, 31st January, 1772. 
 
 My dear Madam, I reserve to myself the pleasure 
 of replying at large to your letters during the time of 
 my voyage, which will afford me both leisure and com- 
 posure of mind. I am obliged to borrow from the 
 hours of sleep this opportunity of telling you that I 
 shall leave this place in health and in confidence of 
 future success. 1 shall embark the 2nd of next month, 
 in the morning. I feel a regret at parting from the 
 people of this settlement, having lived with much com- 
 fort among them ; and am flattered with the assurance 
 that I shall leave more who are sorry than who are 
 glad that they lose me. My associates at the Council 
 Board deserve, and will ever have, my kindest remem- 
 brance, for I never did business with men of so much 
 candour, or in general of better disposition. I doubt 
 whether I shall really profit by the change, but either 
 my pride, or partial attachment to Bengal, makes me 
 much pleased with it. 
 
 I have recommended the little Watson to the pro- 
 tection of Sir Robert Fletcher, who has promised to be 
 kind to him. 
 
 I have cased a pipe of old Madeira, which was 
 spared to me as a favour, and left it under charge of 
 my attorney, to be sent by the Lord North to Mr. 
 Woodman, and I have desired him to share it with 
 you. I hope it will prove acceptable to you, and that 
 you will not be displeased at my choosing this manner 
 of conveying it, as I consider your two families as
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 177 
 
 united, and it will prove a store sufficient for both till 
 I can send another. I shall also desire the captain to 
 take three pieces of chintz, being the first trial made 
 of painting on dooruars. 
 
 I have the satisfaction to inform you that my fortune 
 is not worse than it was when I came here ; I am not 
 certain that it is better. The best part of it is gone to 
 Bengal, where I hope it has been employed to a good 
 account. My going there shall be attended with one 
 useful effect, for I am determined on bringing our con- 
 cerns to some sort of a conclusion. I shall not have 
 the difficulties which Mr. Wancock had to encounter, 
 nor he neither perhaps now. I hear he is thoroughly 
 well, though he sometimes talks of his old fever, the 
 gout ; and my health has held out amazingly, though 
 I seldom stir from town. I attribute much to the dry 
 air of Madras, but more to temperance, which neces- 
 sity has now rendered almost habitual to me. 
 
 Kiss my dear Bessy for me, and assure her of my 
 tenderest affection. May the God of goodness bless 
 you both. 
 
 Before I close my letter let me gratify my present 
 feeling by telling you that great as my obligations 
 have been to you, you have increased them by a recent 
 and disinterested instance of your friendship for me 
 in your last letter. My next shall remind you of the 
 subject. Till then, adieu, my dear and ever-valued 
 friend. Remember me, and make my Bessy remember 
 and love her godfather and her mother's sincere and 
 faithful friend. 
 
 To Sir GEORGE COI.EBROOKE, Bart. 
 
 Fort St. George, 1st February, 1772. 
 
 Sir, Mr. Stuart has informed me how greatly I am 
 indebted to you for my late appointment. I have also 
 heard the same from other hands. I am poor in 
 
 VOL. I. N
 
 178 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 expressions of thanks, but I can assure you I feel as I 
 ought this fresh instance of your confidence. It shall 
 be my most earnest study to merit it. Let me entreat 
 you, Sir, to continue to me the same support. I feel 
 too sensibly the weak ground on which my interest 
 stands, unless supported by the most wary conduct in 
 the administration of the very weighty affairs entrusted 
 to my charge ; and I know too well both the proneness 
 which people in general have to misrepresent the 
 actions of those in authority, and too great readiness 
 with people at home to credit implicitly such misrepre- 
 sentations. It is impossible to avoid errors ; and there 
 are cases in government in which it may be necessary 
 to adopt expedients which are not to be justified on 
 such principles as the public can be the judges of. 
 
 While the general tenor of my conduct shall show 
 that I have the good of the Company at heart,, and that 
 I neglect no part of my duty, I shall hope that no little 
 defects shall be noticed, no interests of other ex- 
 pectants, nor the want of personal interest in myself, 
 will be the means of depriving me of the favour of my 
 employers, and the just rewards of my service. Hitherto 
 I have received from you patronage, protection, and 
 countenance; and little as I may be entitled to these 
 advantages, they will no longer content me, I look up 
 to your friendship. Permit me to say, Sir, that I claim 
 it, and even for your own sake- Without powerful 
 and effectual friends, I cannot hope to answer the 
 expectations of those to whose opinion merely I owe 
 my present advancement ; and the credit of your choice 
 must depend on the success of the man on whom it 
 has fallen. 
 
 My mind is at this time too much disturbed by the 
 business of my departure, and continual interruption, 
 to admit of my replying as I would wish, by this con- 
 veyance, to your letters. This I must beg leave to
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 1?9 
 
 defer to the leisure which I am likely to have in my 
 voyage ; and my next letter will probably reach you, 
 within a very short time, as soon as this. I shall add 
 to it but one subject. The acquisition of an officer of 
 Sir Robert Fletcher's distinguished merit and active 
 spirit has given great joy to the gentlemen who com- 
 pose this administration. There have been some cir- 
 cumstances, however, which have made him very uneasy 
 in his situation, and in the distance of his prospects 
 to the chief command. From the length of time that 
 Sir Robert Barker has had the command in Bengal, it 
 may be concluded that the Court of Directors may 
 have formed some thoughts of naming a successor to 
 him. I wish not anything to the prejudice of those 
 who stand next in the line of succession, if their abi- 
 lities shall be thought equal to the trust. But there 
 are surmises that interest is making for the appoint- 
 ment of others not on the list. In such a case I cannot 
 help expressing my wish that Sir Robert Fletcher may 
 be the man. I do not presume on the short ac- 
 quaintance with which you have honoured me, either 
 to recommend or solicit favours. But I may with pro- 
 priety urge as an argument, that it most essentially 
 concerns the service, that the person who is in the chief 
 administration of affairs, should have a confidence in 
 the officer who is at the head of the forces. Sir Robert 
 Fletcher's reputation is very high in Bengal and in 
 the provinces beyond it ; and 1 have been, in some 
 respect, a witness of the spirit and conduct by which he 
 distinguished himself in the short time that he had the 
 command there ; short as it was, it was sufficient for the 
 conquest of the province of Oude. I shall not add more 
 on this subject ; you will be so good as to excuse me, if 
 you think I have said more than enough. I must sin- 
 cerely wish that you may long continue to direct the 
 administration of the Company's affairs; and am, with 
 
 N2
 
 180 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 the greatest esteem, Sir, your most obliged and most 
 obedient servant. 
 
 To Mr. Du PUK. 
 
 Fort St. George, 31st January, 1772. 
 
 Sir, I had the honour to address a letter to you by 
 the means of his Excellency the Nabob, to inform you 
 of my appointment to the Government of the Com- 
 pany's affairs in Bengal, and that I should shortly 
 leave this place and proceed to my allotted station. 
 Having performed the duties of respect in that address, 
 permit me, Sir, now to indulge the sentiments' of my 
 heart, in expressing the personal concern which I feel 
 in losing, with your presence, the hopes which I had 
 conceived of being admitted to a share of your con- 
 fidence and friendship. The distance to which I shall 
 shortly be removed, almost wholly deprives me of so 
 pleasing a prospect, at the same time that it furnishes 
 me with the means of offering you this declaration of 
 my esteem, without hazarding the imputation or sus- 
 picion of flattery. 
 
 I hope still to be honoured with a place in your 
 remembrance as a person who would have esteemed it 
 a happiness to have devoted his best services to the 
 support of your welfare. I on my part shall never 
 forget the many instances which I have received of 
 your kindness, nor yet the very great and amiable 
 qualities which eminently distinguished your character, 
 especially the sincerity and candour of your expres- 
 sions, and the gentleness of your manners. These are 
 virtues which in private life will always command love 
 and respect ; but in persons of your elevated sphere 
 are the best endowments in the gift of heaven, and the 
 source of blessings to mankind. 
 
 May the Almighty keep you in his protection, and 
 bless you with a long life of accumulated honour and
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 181 
 
 felicity. I have the honour to be, Sir, your devoted 
 and faithful servant. 
 
 To LAURENCE SULIVAN, Esq., per Lord Holland. 
 
 Bay of Bengal, 10th February, 1772. 
 
 Dear Sir, My last was dated the 30th January, 
 and was left to go by the Lord North packet. I shall 
 now reply to your favours of the 28th January, 30th 
 April, (as I judge from a reference in your next, for it 
 has no date), 8th May, and 12th June, 1771. The 
 first of these was delivered to me by Mr. Kirkham ; I 
 told him hovv earnestly you had bespoke my good 
 offices towards him, and expressed my regret that I 
 saw no probable means of affording him any service, as 
 his destination and mine were so remote. 
 
 Your sentiments with respect to General Coote's 
 powers, though such as I expected, afforded me great 
 satisfaction. May success and honour attend him in 
 any other part of the world, but God forbid that he 
 should ever return to any part of India again. 
 
 I .shall have little occasion hereafter, I hope none, to 
 introduce the Nabob of Arcot into my letters. I shall 
 be as concise as possible in what I may now have to 
 say concerning him. Your wish to bring about a re- 
 conciliation between him and Hyder is equally con- 
 sistent with sound policy, and the friendship which you 
 bear him ; but you may be assured that it is not pos- 
 sible. The Nabob is implacable, and all his political 
 projects contribute to make him, were he not so al- 
 ready, the enemy of Hyder. 
 
 The encouragement given him by His Majesty's 
 ministers, and the opinion of his interest with the 
 Company, have not only given him hopes of an entire 
 independency, but have enabled him to pursue the 
 most dangerous projects with impunity. The perse- 
 verance in his rage for an alliance with the Mahrattas, 
 and the favourable disposition lately shown by him
 
 182 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 towards the French, his new allies by the new con- 
 struction of the treaty of Paris, are well worthy of your 
 attention. While he is allowed to guide all the public 
 measures in which the Company have an equal risk, 
 and which their power must support ; and whilst he is 
 assured of the protection of the Crown, and the coun- 
 tenance of the Directors against the acts of the govern- 
 ment of Fort St. George, you are not to hope for any 
 benefit in his alliance. Perpetual disputes will arise 
 between him and your servants, whom he will study by 
 every artifice to draw into his measures ; measures 
 which have but one object, the establishment of his 
 own independency on the ruin of the Company's and 
 the national influence. You will not always have men 
 of equal firmness and ability to the present governor ; 
 nor of equal candour and integrity to the present 
 members of your Council, to oppose his schemes. If 
 these are allowed to continue, they will infallibly end 
 either in a total separation of his interests from the 
 Company's, or in the total deprivation of his authority ; 
 or in the ruin of both. I shall use no arguments to 
 prove this, nor for saying that the greatest proof that 
 you can give the Nabob (who, doubtless, will not re- 
 ceive it as such) of your real friendship for him, will be 
 to restore him to that state of confidence in the Com- 
 pany, and union with them, which subsisted for so 
 many years, till broken by higher connexions ; by em- 
 powering your representatives to assume the lead in 
 all such of their common transactions with him as may 
 materially affect the interests of the Company, by au- 
 thorizing them to reserve for the Company a share in 
 every acquisition made by their arms ; by establishing 
 a more equitable proportion of the expense to be de- 
 frayed by each for the support of the country, by 
 taking the jagheer into your own hands, that you may 
 have the necessaries of life at your command; (and
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 183 
 
 which ought to have been first named, for without it 
 all else you do will be in vain ;) by the final recall of His 
 Majesty's Minister, and the everlasting abolition of all 
 intervention between the King and the Nabob but 
 that of the Company. Volumes might be written 
 upon these subjects ; but your judgment and expe- 
 rience will furnish you with all the reasons on which 
 my opinions are grounded. I fear to enter on so 
 copious an argument. 
 
 I received the warmest assurances of the Nabob's 
 friendship, on parting from him, and on my expressing 
 a regret that I should be separated from him before I 
 had had an opportunity of convincing him of my at- 
 tachment, he did me the honour to declare that he 
 thought himself obliged to me for the moderating part 
 which I had acted in many instances of the debates 
 between him and the committee, and that he was en- 
 tirely satisfied with every part of my conduct. This 
 was too honourable a testimony for me to receive with 
 a safe conscience, but I can with an unblemished one 
 affirm that I never opposed any interest to his, but 
 that of my employers. 1 dare appeal to Mr. Bourchier 
 for his opinion of the temper which he perceived in my 
 behaviour to the Nabob during the short interval of 
 his government. 
 
 I am very glad that you showed my letter to Sir 
 George Colebrooke, since it must have proved that the 
 advice imputed to you was totally without foundation, 
 as it was scarce possible that you should have desired 
 the Nabob to place such an improper reliance on me, 
 without communicating to me that you had done it. I 
 did not think myself at liberty to mention this circum- 
 stance to Mr. Du Pre, though I wish I could have had 
 his explanation upon it. He is of a disposition sus- 
 ceptible of jealousy. It is almost the only defect I 
 know in his character; but I cannot help persuading
 
 184 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 myself that in this particular instance his expressions, 
 whatever they may have been, have been reported to 
 you with exaggerations. I have made it a point to act 
 with the strictest honour on all occasions with him, and 
 have every reason to believe he was entirely satisfied 
 .with my conduct. I told him of every letter which T 
 received from you to be delivered to the Nabob. It 
 was a point of duty which I thought I could not dis- 
 pense with. I saw no reason to affect a mystery in the 
 delivery of them, and it was not in my power, had I 
 been disposed to it, to have concealed them from his 
 knowledge. I have reasons of the last importance to 
 desire that this may not be communicated. It is not 
 from your letters that the Nabob derives his great 
 support and importance. He has other correspondents, 
 and other means of communication, by which he ac- 
 quires the knowledge of many transactions, and of 
 things intended to be transacted, which 1 am sure you 
 would wish him to be ignorant of. He has agents too 
 in this colony, who inflame his jealousy of our govern- 
 ment, feed his resentments with every rascally tale 
 that the idle conversation of the settlement can furnish 
 them with, and assist him in his literary polemics, for 
 such his letters of the last two years may be truly 
 called. A very powerful bias to politics, and a most 
 unconquerable aversion to those who have more power 
 than themselves, have gained the Nabob a formidable 
 party in the Scottish inhabitants of this colony, who 
 to a man almost are partisans of the Nabob, or discon- 
 tented with the government. 
 
 I fear that my letter may have done me no service 
 with. Sir George Colebrooke, for there were some pas- 
 sages in it which might have given him offence, and 
 I have had an intimation given me from a friend in 
 England, that I was not sufficiently communicative to 
 him ; I rely on your good offices to impress him with
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 185 
 
 sentiments of kindness and confidence towards me. I 
 shall want much more than the feeble support which I 
 may be entitled to from the bare consideration of the 
 public service. My friends must be such from inclina- 
 tion. Such a friendship I have experienced from you, 
 and I hope to receive this additional proof of it. 
 
 I cannot pass your very friendly congratulations on 
 my late appointment without stopping to repeat my 
 thanks to you for this fresh instance of your benevo- 
 lence to me. I am yet unacquainted with the means 
 by which this very unexpected change in my fortune 
 was brought about ; but I know it had all the help 
 that your influence could give it, and I am sure no one 
 received more satisfaction from its success. Pardon 
 me, if I express myself with presumption. I speak 
 my entire belief, and my feelings are consonant to it. 
 I hope I shall never discredit your partial opinion of 
 me. Let me receive the support which the conscious- 
 ness of my own sentiments entitles me to lay claim to, 
 and I will merit it. 
 
 I received with, I believe, equal joy the news of your 
 return to the direction, though it was what I had some 
 time expected, and I was the more pleased as you came 
 in single. I fear I express myself more on this occa- 
 sion like a servant of the Company than the friend of 
 Mr. Sulivan, but I flatter myself that in the end you 
 will be equally satisfied with it, as I suppose that your 
 superior knowledge and long practice in the Company's 
 affairs are the most likely means to give you that as- 
 cendant which you formerly possessed in the admini- 
 stration of them. 
 
 I have but a word to say to your recommendations, 
 which is, to assure you that they shall be most punc- 
 tually complied with. I fear Miss Sanders, if she 
 thought it worth a reflection, may have suspected me of 
 inattention to her in the short stay which she made at
 
 186 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 Madras. I did see her, and should have been happy 
 to have contributed to make the place more agreeable 
 to her, had I not been prevented by the awkwardness 
 of my situation with respect to Colonel Wood, in whose 
 family she lived. 
 
 Your letter of the 5th May, relating to the affairs 
 of Bengal only, I cannot at this time reply to. I 
 shall pay strict attention to it when the points alluded 
 to shall come in the course of business before me. I 
 shall be sorry to begin my new office with retrospec- 
 tions, but you have enjoined it, and I shall set aside 
 every consideration but that of obedience to the com- 
 mands, the first commands of my employers. 
 
 In the attention paid by the Court of Directors to 
 the improvement of their investments, I feel a secret 
 satisfaction and assurance that the diligence which I 
 have used to bring that branch of their concerns to a 
 state of perfection in the Carnatic will receive their 
 approbation. Gomastahs have been established in the 
 principal manufacturing towns of the Jagheer, and new 
 regulations formed for every process of the investment, 
 which I hope will be found to be such as to promise 
 both immediate and lasting success to it. The prices 
 of the fine goods have been exceedingly reduced, and 
 all, I believe, will be found much improved in their 
 quality, and in the way to receive greater improve- 
 ments. The buyers, too, will find their account in the 
 sorting which is performed by professed sorters. I 
 believe the Lord North will carry home the first bales 
 that have gone from Madras for the last thirty years 
 with goods of equal assortments. 
 
 I have desired Mr. Smith who has succeeded me, to 
 send you a copy of a minute delivered in to the Board, 
 with other papers which will give you a clear explana- 
 tion of the whole system. I entreat you to read them, 
 and that you will give yourself the trouble to examine
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 187 
 
 the goods, and to make the comparison between them 
 and those formerly provided by the merchants. I have 
 desired that a comparative account of each may be 
 transmitted to the Court of Directors with the invoice. 
 
 I am much pleased with Mr. Stuart. He is a sen- 
 sible man, and appears to possess a good temper. I 
 hope to benefit by the assistance which he is certainly 
 capable of affording me, especially as he is destined to 
 succeed to that station in which I shall most want a man of 
 ability. At. the same time that I receive a satisfaction 
 in the choice of the Court of Directors having fallen on 
 so fit a man for their secretary in Bengal, I cannot 
 avoid remarking that the precedent is very dangerous. 
 There will always be found men of abilities in the 
 service, acquainted at the same time with all the 
 official forms, which kind of knowledge a man from 
 England cannot well possess, and it is of the greatest 
 utility in the despatch of business. It has been always 
 the practice for the governor to make choice of the 
 new secretary on every vacancy, a privilege in which 
 the Council have rarely interfered, and the reason 
 is that the secretary is not so much the assistant of the 
 Council as of the governor, who is the only responsible 
 person for the execution of the resolution of the Board, 
 and ought to be satisfied with the person on whom 
 his credit must so much depend. 
 
 Your choice of Mr. Stuart will do credit to the Di- 
 rectors, and I have reason to hope will be well received 
 in Bengal. But if it is once made the rule that this 
 appointment is to be filled from England, may not 
 men without abilities and without integrity, in time 
 find means through mere interest to obtain it ? May 
 not men of dangerous connexions thus become possessed 
 of all the secret transactions of your government? 
 May not the spirit of emulation of your own servants 
 suffer by these supercessions, and many who want but
 
 188 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 such an office to display the most useful talents, be lost 
 to the service, and exert themselves only in the pursuit 
 of private gain ? We were alarmed the last year with 
 the report that Mr. Stuart was actually designed for 
 Madras, and to be immediately employed as secretary 
 there. Mr. Scrafton too, a little before I left England, 
 told me that he believed Dow would be sent out to 
 Madras with the appointment of Persian translator. 
 Good God, what an injury would have been done to 
 two of the most valuable servants that ever filled those 
 employs, Goodlad and Stracey ! What an injury to 
 the governor, to the service, in the loss of such assist- 
 ants ! It is not so with the accountant's office. This 
 I wish to have always supplied from England. It re- 
 quires talents of a particular kind with much practice, 
 and ought to be as little exposed to change as possible. 
 One very good reason I have heard given for sending 
 persons from England for both offices, which is, that 
 they are the least lucrative of any employs in the 
 service, to which the Company's servants of any rank or 
 character can aspire, and therefore are not worth the 
 acceptance of those whose abilities entitle them to more 
 advantageous places. This is too true, but you may 
 depend upon it that the governor will always choose 
 the fittest man that he can get for secretary, and the 
 pride of distinction and the hope of future promotion 
 will operate more forcibly on the minds of young men 
 of real merit than present gains. It is not wholly the 
 fault of those who have had the administration of your 
 affairs abroad that the emoluments attached to the 
 several employs are not proportioned to the labour or 
 importance of the duties annexed to them. This has 
 introduced another evil by causing profitable employs 
 to be joined with such as are more laborious, but have 
 no advantages, and of course the former are often en- 
 tirely neglected. Thus my late employ of export ware-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 189 
 
 house keeper, a trust of much hazard, and much trouble, 
 afforded me a profit of about 1300 pagodas in two 
 years during the time I held it. The office of com- 
 missary general was a mere sinecure (indeed I had an 
 excellent man for my deputy), and for that I received 
 a monthly gratuity of 100 pagodas. I mention this 
 not so much to support the argument with which J in- 
 troduced this subject, as to show the necessity of making 
 the rewards of the service generally more adequate to 
 the duties of it, in which respect I am told the estab- 
 lishment in Bengal is more defective than any other. 
 Nothing animates diligence in the same degree, or 
 gives equal vigour and despatch to public business, as 
 emoluments depending on the attention which is be- 
 stowed on it. At the same time nothing is so difficult 
 to discover as the means of applying this useful maxim 
 to the various branches of the service. I hope I have 
 proved that it may be done in the new arrangements 
 which have been made in the export warehouse, and 
 the proceedings of the committee of works will afford 
 other instances of it in the appointment of Mr. Des- 
 voeux and Mr. Barnard. The former is agent for 
 providing bricks, the latter for chunam, two articles of 
 much importance both to the Company and the inha- 
 bitants. I could wish to refer you to the minutes 
 containing the grounds and regulations for both these 
 appointments, for the same principles will be produc- 
 tive of the same effects in others of the first importance. 
 But I am ashamed to have already laid claim to so 
 unreasonable a share of your attention in the resources 
 which I have already recommended to you, and in the 
 length of this letter ; foreseeing too that I shall have 
 occasion to give you more trouble by the despatch 
 that shall carry this to you. I shall hasten, therefore, 
 to bring it to a conclusion. 
 
 I left Madras the second of this month, and am at
 
 190 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 this instant about half way in my passage to Bengal. 
 If you find this letter very tedious, or any part of it 
 not very intelligible, be so good as to lay it to the 
 account of an uneasy stomach and confused head, the 
 inseparable companions of a sea life in a small vessel. 
 
 Wishing you health, fortune, power, and every thing 
 that can contribute to your honour and happiness, I 
 am, dear sir, your obliged and faithful humble servant. 
 
 To Sir G. COLEBROOKE, per Lord Holland. 
 
 Bay of Bengal, 15th February, 1772. 
 
 Sir, I have now the pleasure to reply to your 
 favours of the 14th January, 4th May, and 4th June, 
 1771. The first of these was sent to me from Bengal 
 by Mr. Fowke, whom I shall study to serve as far as 
 it lies in my power. I am much pleased with Mr. 
 Stuart. He may depend upon every mark of friend- 
 ship that I can show him, and I promise myself great 
 benefit from his abilities. I am happy at the same 
 time that your recommendations of him, his connexions, 
 and the knowledge which I before had of his character, 
 authorize me to place that degree, of confidence in 
 him which I could not have given to a mere stranger. 
 I wish, on many accounts, that he may long continue 
 in the office destined for him. Pardon me, Sir, if I 
 mention as one motive for this wish, my fear that his 
 place may not be supplied by one whom I shall like so 
 well. There are many reasons which require that the 
 accountant should be nominated by the Court of Di- 
 rectors, and fixed to his station. He is responsible for 
 the business of his office ; the president for that of the 
 secretary, who is only his assistant, and ought to be one 
 on whom he can depend. I beg you will not receive 
 this intimation as proceeding from any dislike of the 
 past measure ; I am afraid from some instances which 
 have fallen under my own observation, there was a
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 191 
 
 necessity for it, but as an objection which occurs to the 
 general rule which you, the Court of Directors have 
 adopted, of sending out persons to succeed to this post. 
 There are others equally strong which I forbear to 
 mention. 
 
 You may depend upon my attention to the improve- 
 ment of the Company's finances, as far as it can be 
 effected without encroaching on their future income. 
 It might be an useful policy to force as large a present 
 revenue from the country as it could yield, if I had no 
 other view than to establish a temporary interest, and 
 to quit my station as soon as I could attain the purpose 
 of completing my own fortune. But such a conduct 
 would be but an ill return to the confidence which the 
 Court of Directors have placed in me, and I see ex- 
 pressions in your letter which assure me that so per- 
 nicious a principle would justly excite your resentment. 
 The provinces have suffered much by the late calami- 
 ties which have greatly hindered its cultivation and 
 manufacture, and lessened the number of its inhabit- 
 ants. Under such circumstances the revenue will re- 
 quire much management and a very gentle hand. If 
 I am rightly informed, more is to be done by economy 
 than can possibly be effected by enlarging the collec- 
 tions. But I speak only as yet from speculation, and 
 therefore shall drop the subject of the affairs of Bengal, 
 till I can form my opinion from observation. 
 
 I hope you will find that my conduct in the narrow 
 sphere allotted me at Fort St. George has been strictly 
 conformable to the principle which you so strongly re- 
 commend. The uncommon abilities and unwearied 
 application of Mr. Dupre left me little room to exert 
 myself beyond the limits of my own particular depart- 
 ment the export warehouse, in which I flatter myself 
 that I shall have merited the approbation of my em- 
 ployers. You have been already publicly informed
 
 192 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 that the Board came to the resolution in the month of 
 May last, of providing the Madras investment by means 
 of gomastahs. The execution of this design was left 
 to me. I met with great difficulties in the beginning, 
 but by a perseverance which might have been attended 
 with the loss of one year's investment, and of the most 
 fatal consequences to my interest, I have happily suc- 
 ceeded in establishing the business on a footing which 
 promises much future improvement, and an increase of 
 the investment to as large an amount as the Company 
 will be likely to require. At the same time I have a 
 present satisfaction in informing you that the goods 
 have already turned out much superior to those for- 
 merly provided by contract both in price and quality, 
 particularly the fine goods, which are beyond all com- 
 parison better. I have had the satisfaction of having 
 received from the Board every testimony that I could 
 wish of their approbation ; and I cannot help quoting 
 it as a proof of their candour and disinterestedness, as 
 of their conviction of the propriety of my recommenda- 
 tions, that at the time that I was pointing out addi- 
 tional emoluments to the post of warehouse keeper, 
 usually the office of the second on the spot, they all 
 cheerfully acquiesced in an appointment which pre- 
 cluded themselves from all chance of succeeding to it, 
 by giving the charge of it to Mr. Charles Smith (though 
 not a member of Council) under the present direction 
 of the president. I shall say no more on this subject, 
 but to refer you to our minutes of ;December last, in 
 which you will find a very explicit account of all the 
 arrangements made in this department. 
 
 As to the rest of my conduct, I must content myself 
 with the humble merit of having made it my study to 
 give every support in my power to the measures pursued 
 by the president, and to contribute my share to the 
 good understanding which I had the happiness to see
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 193 
 
 reign at the Board during the whole time that I was 
 a member of it. I cannot wish myself a better fortune 
 than to be seconded by men equally disposed to sup- 
 port and co-operate with me, and equally satisfied with 
 the rectitude and propriety of my conduct. I beg leave 
 to add this further testimony of the spirit which has 
 directed the resolution of the Board, that in many 
 points of the greatest importance their private in- 
 terests have manifestly been opposed by the public 
 measures. Many of the Council are among the 
 Nabob's creditors whose claims they have firmly con- 
 tested; and in almost every point contested with the 
 Nabob. The facilitating the payment of his debts has 
 generally been urged by him as an inducement for the 
 Board to consent to his demands. 
 
 Here permit me to express my acknowledgments 
 for my share in the candid and generous approbation 
 given by the Court of Directors in their last general 
 letters, particularly that to the select committee, of 
 the conduct of the Board. Such an encouragement is 
 the best security that you can have for the continuance 
 of their zealous attachment to the service, and I am 
 greatly mistaken if you do not find this opinion justified 
 by the event. 
 
 I do not mean that you are to look for splendid 
 successes, or large contributions to the Company's 
 income from the Madras adminstration. All I fear 
 that you have yet to hope for from that presidency is 
 a conduct guarded against legal censure, and a pro- 
 crastination of the dangers with which it is surrounded. 
 The confirmation of the peace was an event of the 
 last importance to the safety of the Company in the 
 Carnatic. 
 
 Threatened by the Marhattas on our borders, obliged 
 to take up arms against an enemy which had begun to 
 create alarms in the very heart of the province; in- 
 
 VOL. I.
 
 194 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 suited and embarrassed by the King's late minister; 
 deprived of all confidence in the N abob who had de- 
 clared, that he considered himself in a state of neu- 
 trality with respect to our contests with the French, 
 who were his allies by the late forced construction of 
 the treaty of Paris; and unprovided with money, 
 provisions, and of every requisite of war, but men and 
 stores from our own resources; under all these dis- 
 advantages we received from you the news of an 
 impending war with France expressed in terms im- 
 plying an almost certainty of it ; at the same time we 
 had advices of absolute certainty, that the French were 
 preparing to bring a great armament from their islands 
 against us. I will not say what would have happened 
 had their design taken place, but nothing less than 
 the interposition of a miracle could have brought 
 about an event so favourable to the Company, or con- 
 tributed so seasonably to their salvation, as the 
 Spanish convention. These reflections on^a^^ dangers 
 cannot be imputable to timidity, a very harsh censure 
 which you cast, allow me to say, too hastily, on a 
 paper which went home last year, and which was 
 written with a very different spirit, and with a ten- 
 dency very foreign from that supposed by the Court 
 of Directors. Our suspicions of the French which you 
 treat as chimerical were supported on the same 
 grounds, and expressed in terms yet less alarming 
 that those which we received from the Company in a 
 letter of nearly the same date with those reflections. 
 
 The picture of your affairs was very fairly drawn ; 
 every possible consequence from every measure was 
 stated, that you might the better judge for yourselves 
 what expedients were necessary for such a condition 
 of your affairs, and neither be obliged to trust blindly 
 to our recommendations, nor to form unsuitable mea- 
 sures for want of due information. Though the
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 195 
 
 dangers to which each proposition was liable were 
 strongly coloured and enumerated with much pre- 
 cision, they are justified by past experience when 
 you lay under fewer disadvantages than you now do ; 
 but they are represented as far from unsurmountable, 
 provided the hands of your servants were loosed from 
 the shackles by which they are hindered from re- 
 pelling them. This is the scope of all the arguments 
 contained in that paper; and I will almost venture to 
 stake my credit on the consequences foretold in it, if 
 the Marhattas become masters of the Ballaghaut. 
 
 Much has been said upon the subject of the powers 
 given to His Majesty's minister, in our general 
 letters, and in the correspondence with them. The 
 approbation which you have expressed of the past 
 conduct of our Government, and the promise of your 
 future support, is a great encouragement to it in the 
 part which it may yet have to act with the King's 
 minister ; they are not equally matched. The latter 
 may exceed his commission, may make demands in the 
 King's name without authority, may plead the same 
 sanction for other unconstitutional acts, and all the 
 notice taken of it is that his proceedings are disavowed, 
 and his successor enjoined to observe a more wary 
 conduct. What would have been the consequence 
 had the Company's representatives committed the 
 smallest error of which the ministry could have taken 
 an advantage. 
 
 I am not myself a competent judge of the ad- 
 vantages which may be obtained by the presence of a 
 squadron in India, even if a war were to happen, 
 will dare to affirm that all the stores of Mauritius, and 
 every man in the island, may be safely transported 
 without even the hazard of being intercepted by Sir 
 Robert Harland, were his force even quadruple of 
 what it is, unless he could know with certainty the 

 
 196 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 exact time, place, and course of their destination, which 
 is impossible. He may shut up their principal port 
 he may protect ours, and his ships may accidentally 
 fall in with one of their vessels of trade; they may 
 possibly do more, for I repeat that I am but imper- 
 fectly acquainted with the subject. But is it in the 
 power of a squadron to afford any services that can 
 compensate for the national loss sustained by so 
 enormous an expense, and the absence of so great a 
 part of the national strength? What equivalent can it. 
 afford to the Company for the injury which their 
 reputation has sustained by the unnatural powers 
 given to the man who commands ? powers given not 
 to extend the Britishdominion, or increase the honour 
 of the nation, but surreptitiously stolen out for the 
 visible purpose of oppressing the King's subjects, and 
 weakening the hands by which his influence is sus- 
 tained in India ! Gracious God ! what ideas are the 
 powers of this empire taught to entertain of the Ma- 
 jesty of the King of Great Britain ! 
 
 Whether there be peace or war your affairs will 
 never prosper till the King's minister is recalled. His 
 presence can do no good. It alienates the Nabob 
 from the Company, and is the original cause of all the 
 distress which you have suffered and are likely to suffer 
 in your finances. This has not yet indeed been very 
 great, but it has been sufficient to prevent the execu- 
 tion of the works which have been ordered, and which 
 appear very necessary fo'r putting the fort in a state 
 of defence, and to suspend the advances for the in- 
 vestment at a time when they were most wanted, and 
 when the novelty of the business made it of the utmost 
 consequence that it should meet with as few retard- 
 ments as possible. I mention this effect of the minis- 
 terial interference, because I apprehend it counteracts 
 one of the most essential objects of the administration,
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 197 
 
 if it be expected that Fort St. George is to bear its 
 quota of the annual tax paid to Government, which 
 it most assuredly will not, and cannot, while such a 
 power exists. 
 
 I understand that Sir Robert Harland intends to 
 visit Bengal. I do not know any pretext that can 
 require his presence there, unless it be to examine the 
 ditch at Chandernagore, an object beneath the dignity 
 of the royal representative. However, I do not ap- 
 prehend that he can create much trouble there, as I 
 do not see how the King can be considered by any 
 implication as a guarantee of the peace of Bengal. 
 
 Having mentioned the removal of the King's 
 minister as essential to the prosperity of your affairs, 
 give me leave to add, that it is equally necessary to 
 restore to your government of Madras that authority 
 which it always exercised till lately in the administra- 
 tion of the affairs of the Carnatic, such I mean as are 
 connected with their own, to ascertain a more equitable 
 proportion of the charge to be borne by the Com- 
 pany and the Nabob of the military disbursements ; 
 and to secure a share in all the advantages which may 
 be acquired by your arms ; at present the risk is almost 
 wholly the Company's and the fruits entirely the 
 Nabob's. The Board have recommended, and I have 
 also found occasion in treating of the investment to 
 make use of some arguments enforcing the same pro- 
 position, to take the management of the Jagheer into 
 your own administration. A great military establish- 
 ment, with a fund to support it, or any means of im- 
 mediate subsistence, but such as you receive from the 
 Nabob's bounty, and which it is at his option to 
 withhold from you, can never be effectually employed 
 for your own service, and may prove your destruction. 
 I will not make any apology for the liberty which I 
 have taken in giving my opinion thus freely. I hope
 
 198 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 I need not. I can have no motive of self interest in 
 what I have recommended. If I have thrown any new 
 lights on your affairs, what I have said will be useful. 
 If you think I err in my judgment of them, it will at 
 least do no harm. 
 
 I say nothing on the subject of affairs in the Balla- 
 ghaut, because you will have it probably at large in the 
 general letter. 
 
 I left Fort St. George the 2d of this month, and 
 expect to reach Calcutta within four days more. I 
 close my letter now, as I do not expect that I shall 
 have either occasion or leisure to add much to it on 
 my arrival. 
 
 I will not repeat the subjects of my former letter, 
 having already lengthened this beyond all reasonable 
 bounds. I beg the continuance of your protection and 
 confidence, and shall ever remain with the sincerest 
 attachment, Sir, your most obedient and devoted 
 servant.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 199 
 
 
 CHAPTER VII. 
 
 itline of the Political and Financial Affairs of the Company, from 1765 
 to 1772 The Court's Instructions to Hastings His Reply Letters upon 
 various subjects. 
 
 THOUGH I have not judged it expedient to linger 
 over the history of a province, in the management 
 of which Mr. Hastings never played except a 
 secondary part, I conceive that imperfect justice 
 would be done to his merits were I to launch him 
 all at 'once on the troubled sea of Bengal politics 
 without explaining the nature of the difficulties 
 which met him there, by describing the state of 
 absolute confusion into which, in all its departments, 
 the affairs of that settlement had fallen. Some 
 portion, indeed, of this explanation has already been 
 given. In a previous chapter I sketched an out- 
 line of the principal events which occurred between 
 the acquisition of the duanny in 1765 and the 
 final return of Lord Clive to England ; touching 
 lightly, at the same time, on the various parliamen- 
 tary inquiries to which, up to a later date, the 
 Company's affairs were subjected. But it is neces- 
 sary that the results both of the one and the other 
 should be more distinctly set forth ; and I must, 
 therefore, crave at once the indulgence and the
 
 200 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 attention of my reader, while I endeavour, with as 
 much brevity as possible, to do so. 
 
 The general results of Lord Olive's second 
 administration may in few words be thus described. 
 He entirely remodelled the Company's military 
 establishment ; he brought the English as a sub- 
 stantive power into political connexion with the 
 Emperor and the Nabob of Oude ; he caused the 
 covenant against the acceptance of presents by the 
 servants of the Company to be executed ; and he 
 threw impediments in the way of the prosecution 
 by them or their agents of an inland trade. Into 
 the latter arrangement he seems, indeed, to have 
 entered with reluctance ; for it was a profitable 
 source of emolument to individuals, out of which, 
 under the head of duty, about one hundred thousand 
 pounds per annum passed into the public treasury. 
 But the Directors were resolute, and even Clive was 
 forced, in profession at least, to give way ; though 
 not till he had secured to his friends and himself, 
 and to all future governors, as a compensation, a 
 per centage of one and an eighth on the whole of 
 the revenues collected. In other respects, I can- 
 not find that Lord Clive did much for his employers. 
 The scheme of a double government, which owed 
 to him its existence, was by him confirmed and 
 established. No advantage was taken of the death 
 of the Nabob Nujam ul Dowlah, either to introduce 
 a better system into the administration of the
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 201 
 
 country, or to diminish the expenses of that already 
 in force ; but his brother Sijeff ul Dowlah was 
 raised as a matter of course to the musnud, and 
 became, on account of his extreme youth, more 
 than ever a tool in the hands of his courtiers. 
 Accordingly, while Clive was proclaiming in Lon- 
 don that the golden age was come, and the pro- 
 prietors of India stock, trusting to his assurances, 
 were increasing their dividends while they bor- 
 rowed money to pay them, the country out of 
 which this inexhaustible supply of wealth was 
 expected to be gathered sank day by day more 
 deeply into confusion. For, the entire manage- 
 ment of the revenues being in the hands of natives, 
 without any efficient control, or knowledge suf- 
 ficient to exercise it, on the part of the Company's 
 servants, zemindars, rajas, and other agents made 
 their own terms, both with the ryots and the 
 Duan, of which the results were, that on all 
 occasions the Company sustained a loss, no one 
 being able so much as to point out the particular 
 account into which errors might have crept. 
 
 The authorities at Bengal soon found themselves 
 incapable of satisfying the expectations of their 
 superiors at home. Instead of forwarding to Lon- 
 don large remittances, they discovered that the 
 resources of the country were inadequate to pay for 
 its protection : and after drawing bills till for- 
 bidden to continue the practice any longer, they
 
 202 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 were driven to the necessity of raising money 
 upon public loan. Tins was a terrible blow to 
 the proprietors, who had gone so far in May, 
 1767, as to vote for that year a dividend of twelve 
 per cent, on their capital : neither did it escape the 
 notice of the public. A prodigious outcry was 
 raised, of which the King's government, already 
 eager to possess itself of the patronage of India, 
 failed not to take advantage. Then followed ques- 
 tions as to the capability of subjects of the crown to 
 acquire sovereign power in any part of the world 
 except for the nation ; committees then sat in the 
 House of Commons to consider these questions ; 
 and, finally, in June, 1767, the first of a series of 
 Acts was passed, which ended in establishing on the 
 part of Parliament an absolute right of interference 
 in all the concerns of the Company. By that Act, 
 it was declared, that till the next session no divi- 
 dend should be voted at the India House of more 
 than ten per cent. ; while by and bye the territorial 
 revenues were secured to the Company, only for 
 the limited space of two years, and at the expense 
 to them of an annual payment of 400,000 into 
 the public exchequer. 
 
 From that day began a system of fierce political 
 warfare, of which the belligerents were the East 
 India Company on the one hand, and the King's 
 ministers on the other. It was the object of the 
 latter to wrest from the Company all the power
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 203 
 
 and patronage of the East ; it was the object of 
 the former to resent this aggression, and to retain 
 both the patronage and the power in their own 
 hands. Between them the public, as must always 
 happen in like cases, could alone decide ; for neither 
 might the minister hope to carry his point without 
 carrying the nation along with him, nor could the 
 Company sustain the struggle against the minister, 
 unless the people and their representatives should 
 support them. Hence both parties were assiduous 
 in their efforts to spread reports abroad the one 
 of systematic mismanagement and corruption on 
 the part of the Company's agents, the other of 
 better and more prosperous times to come, so soon 
 as the effects of many revolutions should have passed 
 away, and India be permitted to enjoy for a few 
 seasons the blessings of an enlightened administra- 
 tration. Moreover, it is worthy of remark that 
 not one of all the many changes which occurred, 
 either in the persons or the professed opinions of 
 the individuals composing the King!s cabinet, 
 effected any substantial change in reference to this 
 question. The Rockinghams, the Norths, the 
 Rockinghams again, the Coalition, all these, as well 
 as Pitt's government, which succeeded the Coali- 
 tion, aimed at the same thing. Some might be less 
 scrupulous than others, both as to the means 
 chosen, and the extent to which they desired those 
 means to be applied ; but all coveted at least a
 
 204 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 share, and that a large one, in the distribution of 
 Indian patronage ; and all, either by fair means or 
 by foul, succeeded in obtaining it. 
 
 From the date of Lord Clive's return to Eng- 
 land, in 1767, every thing seemed to contribute, 
 for awhile, towards the accomplishment of the 
 ministers' wishes. Under Mr. Verelst there was 
 neither an increase of profit to the Company, nor 
 any movement made towards securing to the people 
 of Bengal the benefits of an efficient government. 
 The war with Hyder, on the contrary, from which the 
 Carnatic suffered so much, tended but to drain the 
 sister presidency of its resources, while the debt 
 continued to accumulate from day to day, and 
 the investments became proportionably valueless. 
 Still Lord Clive's opinions were held every where 
 in profound respect. He pronounced that the fault 
 rested exclusively with the local authorities at Fort 
 William, a view of the case in which both the 
 ministers who desired to subvert the Company's 
 privileges, and the Company which struggled to 
 retain these privileges, professed to coincide. They 
 were alike blind to the fact, that the chief if not 
 the whole blame was attributable to the very 
 absurd system of government which Lord Clive 
 himself had established. Accordingly, the mi- 
 nisters wrung from the Company in 1 769 a further 
 subsidy of 400,000 per annum, besides exten- 
 sive advantages to the general commerce of the
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 205 
 
 nation, as the price of a retention for five years 
 longer of the much loved territorial revenues. On 
 the other hand, the Company resolved to institute 
 a searching inquiry into the conduct of their repre- 
 sentatives abroad. With this view, a commission 
 was voted, at a general meeting of proprietors, to 
 consist of three gentlemen, Mr. Vansittart, the late 
 governor of Bengal, and Mr. Scrafton and Colonel 
 Ford,with powers to investigate on the spot, and 
 to introduce into every department of the state 
 such reforms as might to themselves appear expe- 
 dient. It was hardly to be expected that such a 
 proposal should meet with no opposition, both in 
 the Cabinet and elsewhere. The Cabinet had no 
 desire to see the Company's power consolidated 
 and improved, individuals who profited by abuses 
 were reluctant that they should be remedied. 
 Accordingly, while the latter declaimed against 
 any measure of the sort, as entirely uncalled for, 
 and therefore involving the Company in needless 
 expense, the former insisted that to King's officers, 
 to the commanders of the King's ships, or, at all 
 events, to persons nominated by the crown, and, 
 of course, acting as the crown's representatives, 
 authority should be given to adjust all maritime 
 affairs, to negociate with native princes, and other- 
 wise to play a principal part in the offensive and 
 defensive policy of the country. 
 
 Great was the alarm in the Court of Directors
 
 206 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 when this proposition was communicated to them. 
 They saw, that if acceded to it must end in the speedy 
 subversion of the Company's government, and they 
 urged the proprietors by every means in their 
 power to oppose it. Accordingly, the proprietors 
 met, and, after a long and acrimonious debate, it 
 was decided that the powers demanded for an 
 officer of the crown were inadmissible. The 
 ministers were not disposed at that time to enforce, 
 by any violent procedure, the acceptance of their 
 terms. The Company would agree to sanction the 
 interference of the officer commanding the King's 
 ships only within the limits of the Persian Gulf, 
 where with some of the chiefs exercising authority 
 along its shores, they were embroiled ; a requi- 
 sition which had been sent in for two ships of the 
 line for the Bay of Bengal was suspended, and the 
 legal objection to the commission of the supervisors 
 fell to the ground. Two frigates were soon after- 
 wards ordered upon Indian service. In one of these 
 the three Commissioners took their passage, and 
 neither of them nor of the vessel that contained 
 them has any account been received up to the pre- 
 sent hour. 
 
 Meanwhile, Mr. Verelst, having resigned the 
 chair at Fort William, Mr. Cartier, one of Has- 
 tings's early contemporaries and friends, became 
 president in his room. This was in the beginning 
 of 1770 ; and the same year brought upon Bengal,
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 207 
 
 in addition to the other miseries under which 
 it groaned, the heavy scourge of a famine. The 
 loss of life occasioned by this calamity was fearful ; 
 it has even been estimated at one-third of the 
 population of the province ; and the detriment to 
 the revenue, which depended always on the results 
 of the harvest, fully kept pace with it. Yet no 
 attempt was made by the existing government 
 either to lessen the amount of direct expenditure, 
 or to diminish, even in a trivial degree, the costs of 
 collection. Though the death of the young Nabob, 
 which occurred on the 10th of March, furnished 
 them with an excellent opportunity of retrench- 
 ment ; and though they were not unaware that the 
 allowance made for the maintenance of his house- 
 hold greatly exceeded that which their employers 
 conceived to be sufficient, they confirmed Mubarick 
 ul Dowlah, likewise a minor, in all the emolu- 
 ments and privileges which had been conceded to 
 his brother. For this they were sharply reproved 
 in a general letter from the Court of Directors, 
 bearing date 10th of April, 1771 ; in which the 
 following sentence occurs : " Convinced as we are 
 that an allowance of sixteen lacs per annum will be 
 sufficient for the support of the Nabob's state and 
 rank, while a minor, we must consider every addi- 
 tion thereto as so much to be wasted on a herd of 
 parasites and sycophants who will continually sur- 
 round him ; or, at least, to be hoarded up, a con-
 
 208 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 sequence still more pernicious to the Company. 
 You are, therefore, during the nonage of the Nabob, 
 to reduce his annual stipend to sixteen lacs of 
 rupees." 
 
 The instructions quoted here are worthy of 
 remark, as indicating an early wish on the part of 
 the Directors, to effect that which no one had the 
 courage to attempt till the matter was taken up 
 by the subject of this memoir. For the rest I 
 have little else to record, than that neither from 
 it, nor from any other of the hints which the Court 
 from time to time threw out, was any benefit, even 
 the most trivial, derived to the Company. Under 
 Governor Cartier, the difficulties both of the pre- 
 sidency and the courts at home continued pro- 
 gressively to increase. On the 1st of January, 
 1771, the bonded debt of Bengal amounted to 
 612,628. At the beginning of the following year 
 it had increased to upwards of 1,700,000, while 
 at home, after some fruitless efforts to brazen the 
 matter out, the Company was reduced to the 
 necessity of soliciting a loan, both from the Bank 
 of England, and from the King's Government. 
 The minister did not refuse to come to the rescue, 
 but he came upon his own terms. The affairs of 
 India were prominently noticed in the King's 
 speech. A Bill introduced by the deputy chair- 
 man, for the regulation of the Company's trade, 
 and the better administration of justice in the pro-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 209 
 
 vinces, was rejected ; a Select Committee of the 
 House of Commons sat again to inquire ; and in 
 the end the ministerial measure of 1773 was pro- 
 posed and carried. Into a consideration of that 
 Act, however, and of the consequences to which 
 it led, I shall not for the present enter. Rather 
 let me recapitulate in few words, the substance of 
 much that has been said elsewhere, in order 
 that the precise state of Bengal, both in its poli- 
 tical and financial relations, may be seen, at the 
 period when Mr. Hastings took possession of the 
 Government. 
 
 Mr. Hastings, though he quitted Fort St. 
 George so early as the latter end of 1771, and 
 arrived at Calcutta in February, 1772, did not 
 take his seat as President of the Council, till the 
 month of April following. The interval was 
 not, however, wasted, for he devoted it to a study 
 of the nature of the machine which he was 
 expected to regulate, and found it to be in all its 
 departments inefficient. In the first place, the 
 great change which had taken place in the politi- 
 cal situation of the presidency had been met by 
 no adequate change in the condition or powers of 
 its government. This was still the same, both in 
 construction and in name, that it used to be when 
 the settlement was purely commercial ; while the 
 orders from the Court of Directors were all so 
 
 .med as to check every attempt at innovation in 
 
 VOL. I. 
 
 P
 
 210 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 the outset. Not appearing to take the circum- 
 stance into account, that they had acquired an ab- 
 solute dominion over an extensive and populous 
 nation, the Directors ceased not to remind their ser- 
 vants that they were the agents not of a military 
 but of a trading body ; and that every step taken 
 with a view to change the nature of their rela- 
 tions with the inhabitants of India would be re- 
 garded at home as an act of disobedience, and 
 visited with the Court's displeasure. The conse- 
 quence was, that, as far as it was possible, the Presi- 
 dent and Council held aloof from interference in 
 the political affairs of the provinces. Indirectly, 
 indeed, they exercised an important influence, of 
 which the tendency was the reverse of beneficial ; 
 but greater pains were taken to hide the source 
 from which even that influence proceeded, than 
 would have sufficed, if rightly applied, to improve 
 and arrange into order the valuable materials which, 
 in the course of fifteen years, the Company had 
 been accumulating. 
 
 While the President and Council of Fort Wil- 
 liam found occupation in providing the Com- 
 pany's investments, in managing the sale of import 
 cargoes, in despatching ships, and transmitting to 
 the Court of Directors minutes of the proceed- 
 ings of the Board of Revenue and the letters of 
 the commander-in-chief of their forces, the execu- 
 tive government was administered in the name of
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 211 
 
 the Nabob, Mobarick ul Dowlah, a minor, by 
 Mahonimed Reza Cawn, a man of no rights 
 or pretensions, on whom had been conferred the 
 style of Nazim of Bengal, Baha'r, and Orissa. 
 In like manner the revenues were managed by 
 him, and paid over to certain covenanted ser- 
 vants of the Company, who, with the title of 
 supervisors, resided at the principal towns of their 
 respective districts ; and were responsible to two 
 boards, stationed, one at the city of Moorshedabad 
 for the superintendency of the districts of Bengal, 
 the other at Patna for that of Bahar. The annual 
 income of the provinces thus collected amounted, 
 in 1772, to 2,373,650. The annual disbursements 
 at the same period came up to 1,705,279, leaving 
 a surplus of revenue over expenditure of 668,371 ; 
 to be applied to the purchase of investments, the 
 supply of foreign settlements, the interest of the 
 public debt, and the gradual liquidation of its 
 principal. But so entirely inadequate was this 
 surplus to the drains that were made upon it, that 
 the investments alone required not less a sum than 
 634,000. Under such circumstances, the embar- 
 rassment of the presidency could not fail of be- 
 coming continually more oppressive. In 1772, the 
 debts of every denomination stood at the amount 
 of 1,783,300. In the month of April, 1773, 
 they had increased, with the credit of the Go- 
 vernment exhausted, to 2,168,691.
 
 212 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 Among the current expenses to which the presi- 
 dency was subject, the payments to the Emperor 
 and the Nabob Mobarick ul Dovvlah. were neither 
 the least vexatious nor the least heavy. To the 
 former were annually transmitted, under the deno- 
 mination of tribute, thirty-five lacs, or 30,000 ; 
 to the latter thirty-two lacs, or 27,000, a dimi- 
 nution, doubtless, of the pension originally assigned 
 to him by Lord Clive, yet greater by far than had 
 been enjoyed by any of his predecessors, unless 
 indeed tKe whole revenues of the soubahdary 
 deserve to be accounted their private poverty. 
 Meanwhile, imposing as the Company's politi- 
 cal position really was, the Company's local 
 government had as yet entered into no connexion 
 with any of the chiefs of India, except with the 
 Mogul or King, Shah Allum, and the Vizier, 
 Shuja Dowlah, Nabob of Oude. The former, as 
 has been stated elsewhere, abandoned the English 
 in 1771, to place himself under the protection of 
 the Mahrattas. With the latter the connexion 
 continued in full force under the sanction of a 
 treaty concluded in August 1765 ; and of which 
 I have already detailed the substance. But 
 though the Nabob was thus entitled, whenever the 
 exigencies of his condition should require, to claim 
 from the English military support, for the extra- 
 ordinary expenses of which he undertook to pay, 
 the intercourse between his government and that
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 213 
 
 )f Fort William was so managed, that by the 
 latter it was difficult, if not impossible, to obtain 
 at any given moment accurate or satisfactory in- 
 formation as to the truth of the statements which 
 the Nabob might put forth. For to the commander- 
 in-chief of tbe forces the presidency had committed 
 the charge of communicating between them and 
 their ally, and the commander-in-chief, for reasons 
 not hard to discover, appears to have kept them, 
 upon most subjects, pretty much in the dark. 
 In the beginning of 1772, Sir Robert Baker, who 
 
 ^ 
 
 was at the head of the Bengal army, did duty 
 with an entire brigade, constituting the third part 
 of their whole force, within the Nabob's domi- 
 nions. 
 
 Lastly, for I must not dwell too much upon 
 matters of dry detail, Mr. Hastings found that the 
 Supreme Council exercised no efficient control 
 over its subordinate functionaries. On the con- 
 trary, as there was a total absence of system 
 from its own proceedings, and a total ignorance of 
 the extent to which its powers extended, the 
 Council seemed rather to be guided by the views 
 of its dependents, than to give the tone to those 
 dependents, in whatever line of duty they might 
 be employed. 
 
 The appointment of Mr. Hastings to fill the 
 president's chair at Calcutta was the first decisive 
 step taken by the East India Company to intro-
 
 214 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 duce into the provinces over which their rights of 
 duanny extended, a new and more efficient system of 
 general administration. For some time previously 
 they had begun to suspect that Lord dive's theory 
 of the two-fold government was a false one ; and 
 they at length determined, in the words of their 
 own despatch, " to stand forth as Duan, and, by the 
 agency of the Company's servants, to take upon 
 themselves the entire care and management of 
 the revenues." Such a change, however, could 
 not take place, without its influence being felt in 
 every corner of the Empire. It would be neces- 
 sary, therefore, to proceed with extreme caution in 
 the business ; to collect and digest large stores of 
 information, ere any movement should be made ; 
 and above all, to have at the head of affairs, some 
 one on whose vigour and discretion absolute de- 
 pendence could be placed. Mr. Hastings's conduct 
 while member of the select committee at Fort 
 St. George, equally with the views he had expressed 
 when under examination before the House of 
 Commons, pointed him out as eminently qualified 
 to carry into effect the designs of the home autho- 
 rities. He was accordingly nominated to the high 
 and important charge, and proceeded, as has been 
 explained in his own letters, to undertake it. 
 
 If the Courts of Proprietors and Directors had 
 acted with ordinary prudence, they would have 
 taken care on this occasion to throw into the hands
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 215 
 
 of their new president an accession of authority. 
 The task which they had assigned him was an Her- 
 culean one ; for it implied nothing less than the ac- 
 complishment of a total revolution in Bengal ; yet 
 they sent him to undertake it with powers nowise 
 enlarged above those which had proved, in the 
 hands of his immediate predecessors, inadequate 
 to the purposes of ordinary detail. Mr. Hastings 
 found himself one of a body of persons, each of 
 whom possessed the same weight in the government 
 with himself. His vote told for no more, in questions 
 of state, than the vote of any other member of the 
 Council, unless indeed there should be a division of 
 opinions so perfect, that a casting voice might 
 decide it. Nor was this all. While he depended 
 entirely for the influence which he might acquire, 
 on the moral weight which a well-earned fame gave 
 him, the Directors saw fit, by committing to him 
 what they were pleased to term secret instructions, 
 to place him in a somewhat invidious light to- 
 wards his colleagues at the very outset. Though 
 awakened to the evil tendency of Lord Clive's de- 
 lusive system, the Directors still believed that a 
 part at least of their misfortunes might fairly be 
 charged on their servants. In particular the fall- 
 ing off in the value of the investments they attri- 
 buted either to the culpable negligence or the in- 
 tentional dishonesty of the individuals charged with 
 providing them, and their anxiety to bring the de-
 
 216 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 faulters to punishment was extreme. The fol- 
 lowing shows the extent to which their feelings on 
 this head were carried, while at the same time it 
 appears to justify me in what I have said as to the 
 imprudence with which they would have involved 
 in personal disputes, the very man whose means 
 of usefulness depended on the success with which 
 he might succeed in conciliating the good will of 
 those around him. 
 
 From the Secret Committee of the Court of Directors. 
 
 East India House, London, 8th May, 1771. 
 
 Sir, The Court of Directors could not have evi- 
 denced more clearly the confidence they repose in your 
 abilities, zeal, and integrity, than they have done by 
 their appointment of you to preside in their council in 
 Bengal. The importance of the Company's concerns 
 on that side of India will require the full exertion of all 
 those qualifications which we are persuaded you pos- 
 sess, and which will, we assure ourselves, ever be fully 
 exerted while you fill the important station of governor 
 at that presidency. In full confidence thereof, we, the 
 secret committee, now write to you upon an affair 
 which is the subject matter of the sixteenth paragraph 
 of the general letter to the governor and council of the 
 3rd instant. For although the Court have in the above- 
 mentioned letter directed that very particular inquiry 
 be made into this business, we do, nevertheless, in the 
 most confidential manner, signify to you that we place 
 a singular trust and dependence upon your own par- 
 ticular and personal researches into the whole of this 
 transaction ; and we therefore direct that you do not 
 fail to investigate it to the bottom, that you obtain the 
 most perfect intelligence of the names of all persons
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 217 
 
 concerned, either in recommending the measure at first 
 or in purchasing any of the goods in question. That 
 you also ascertain precisely whose property these goods 
 were, and by whom they were examined,, sorted, packed, 
 and invoiced, with every other circumstance Avhich can 
 in any degree tend to elucidate an affair which has 
 operated so much to the Company's disadvantage. 
 
 And if you shall be able to discover that any persons 
 in our service, of whatever rank or station they may be, 
 have so far forgot and departed from their fidelity as 
 to prefer the convenience or interest of individuals to 
 that of the Company, in any part of the transaction 
 now so very particularly recommended to your im- 
 partial investigation, that in such case you do use your 
 utmost endeavours to prevail on your Council to sus- 
 pend, until the Court's pleasure be known, all and every 
 person or persons who shall appear to you to have 
 acted inconsistent with their duty and the trust reposed 
 in them. We are, your loving friends. 
 
 WARREN HASTINGS, Esq. 
 
 It was not, however, of those alone who, in pro- 
 viding the investments, postponed, without scruple, 
 the Company's interests to their own that the 
 Court of Directors complained. The determined 
 resistance of their servants to the orders sent out 
 for an immediate discontinuance of the inland 
 trade, especially in the articles of salt, betel, and 
 tobacco, excited their warmest indignation. They, 
 therefore, wrote to Mr. Hastings the following 
 letter, a too ready attention to the matter of which 
 must have led to irreparable discord in the settle- 
 ment, and frustrated all his future powers of
 
 218 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 usefulness. Mr. Hastings, however, on this, as 
 on every other occasion, tempered firmness with 
 delicacy. He caused the obnoxious trade to be 
 abolished, sacrificing for a while all the benefits 
 which used to arise from it, both to the Company 
 and to individuals. But he did so with such gen- 
 tleness that their parties deprived of their emolu- 
 ments could take no offence, even while they felt 
 equally with himself that the natives would be 
 very little the gainers by the change. I subscribe 
 the letter because it may be advantageously re- 
 ferred to after the reader shall have gone forward 
 a stage or two in Mr. Hastings's history. 
 
 To WARREN HASTINGS, Egq., our President and Governor of Bengal. 
 
 London, 18th December, 1771. 
 
 1. Notwithstanding we have so often expressed to 
 the successive governors and councils of our presi- 
 dency of Bengal, our solicitude to promote the pros- 
 perity and happiness of the natives of those provinces, 
 from which the public, as well as the Company, derives 
 such great advantages ; and that, to effect the same, 
 we have repeatedly given the most peremptory orders 
 for laying open to the natives the several articles of the 
 inland trade, more particularly those of salt, betel nut, 
 and tobacco, which are considered by them as the 
 necessaries of life ; yet we are at length constrained to 
 believe that our intentions have been counteracted and 
 our orders disobeyed, even by some of our servants 
 whose stations we had reason to hope would have pre- 
 vented them from pursuing their private emolument 
 by any indirect and unwarrantable means. 
 
 2. We therefore shall not hesitate to declare that
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 219 
 
 vc have received such information as will not permit 
 is to doubt but that several of our Council who were 
 icmbers of that board at the time of the despatch of 
 the Lord Mansfield, in April, 1771, and many of our 
 servants in the different districts of the country, ap- 
 )inted as supervisors of the collection of our revenues, 
 lad, in manifest violation of our orders, entered into 
 a combination and unduly exercised the power and 
 influence derived from their stations in order to carry 
 >n a monopoly in the several articles of salt, betel 
 mt, and tobacco ; and that they had been so far lost 
 the principles of justice and humanity as to include 
 rice and other grain in the same destructive monopoly, 
 by which an artificial scarcity was made of an article so 
 necessary to the very being of the inhabitants. 
 
 3. As upon a charge of this nature we cannot but 
 apply every means in our power to detect the guilty, 
 and by exemplary punishment prevent the continuance 
 of such proceedings as are not only a dishonour to our 
 service, but a reproach to human nature and as we 
 repose the most feperct confidence in your abilities, 
 integrity, and zeal ;or our service we have thought 
 fit to commit to your sole care the detection of those 
 crimes which have been charged on the servants of the 
 Company. It is, therefore, our pleasure and command 
 that you enter without delay into a strict scrutiny of 
 the conduct of the several members who composed our 
 Council at the time of the Lord Mansfield's departure 
 from Bengal, in April, 1771, and of the persons ap- 
 pointed to supervise in the different districts of the 
 country the collection of the revenues, in respect to 
 their having been engaged in a monopoly of salt, betel 
 nut, tobacco, and grain ; and in this investigation we 
 most seriously enjoin you not to suffer any bias of 
 friendship to interrupt or weaken your researches ; and 
 this we have the greater reason to expect, since the
 
 220 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 result of your inquiries may bring due chastisement 
 vipon the offenders, and thereby conciliate the minds of 
 the natives to our government, and restore prosperity 
 to those extensive provinces which are entitled to 
 our utmost care, both from the ties of interest and 
 humanity, 
 
 4. Relying, therefore, upon your judgment and 
 impartiality, and not doubting but they will lead you 
 to the means of obtaining full evidence of those enor- 
 mities which may have been committed, we hereby 
 direct that if it shall appear to you that any member 
 or members of our before-mentioned Council, or any of 
 our servants appointed to supervise the collection of 
 our revenues, or any other persons in our service, civil 
 or military, have been any ways concerned in these un- 
 warrantable monopolies, such servant or servants be 
 forthwith dismissed our service ; and we hereby declare 
 them to be actually so dismissed, as unworthy of hold- 
 ing any office or employment under the Company. 
 
 One more specimen of the sort of confidence 
 which the Court of Directors at this juncture re- 
 posed in him it is necessary to give. It was 
 believed in Leadenhall-street, not only that the 
 administration of Mahommed Reza Cawn had 
 been eminently disadvantageous to the Company, 
 but that Mahommed himself had been guilty of the 
 grossest peculation, as well as of excessive tyranny 
 in his dealings with the people. As a step pre- 
 paratory to the introduction of the improved 
 system, the Court was desirous that the delin- 
 quencies of Mahommed and his coadjutor Rajah 
 Dooloob Ram should be brought to light; and
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 221 
 
 to Mr. Hastings they entrusted the care of ac- 
 complishing that work. Again, therefore, is he 
 desired to act in a delicate matter apart from his 
 colleagues, and without consulting them ; and again 
 he is exposed, by the inconsideration of his supe- 
 riors, to the hazard of offending his Council. 
 
 To WARREN HASTINGS, Esq. 
 
 London, 28th August, 1771. 
 
 Sir, By our general address, you will be informed of 
 the reasons we have to be dissatisfied with the adminis- 
 tration of Mahomet Reza Cawn, and will perceive the 
 expediency of our divesting him of the rank and influ- 
 ence he holds as Naib Duan of the kingdom of Bengal. 
 But though we have declared our resolution in this 
 respect to our President and Council, yet, as the mea- 
 sures to be taken in consequence thereof might be 
 defeated by that minister, and all inquiry into his 
 conduct rendered ineffectual, were he to have any pre- 
 vious intimation of our design, we, the secret committee, 
 having the most perfect confidence in your judgment, 
 prudence, and integrity, have thought proper to en- 
 trust to your especial care, the execution of those 
 measures which alone can render the Naib's conduct 
 subject to the effects of a full inquiry, and secure that 
 retribution which may be due, on the detection of any 
 fraud, embezzlement, or collusive practice in his public 
 or private transactions. 
 
 In order, therefore, to make him amenable to a due 
 course of justice, and to prevent the ill consequences 
 which might result from the resentment and revenge 
 which he may conceive on the knowledge of our inten- 
 tions, we hereby direct and enjoin you, immediately on 
 the receipt of this letter, to issue your private orders 
 for the securing the person of Mahomet Reza Cawn,
 
 222 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 together with his whole family, and his known partizans 
 and adherents, and to make use of such measures as 
 your prudence shall suggest, for bringing them down 
 to Calcutta. And it is our pleasure and command, 
 that they be by no means suffered to quit the place 
 until Mahomet Reza Cawn shall have exculpated him- 
 self from the crimes of which he now stands charged 
 or suspected, or shall have duly accounted for the re- 
 venues collected by him in the Chucklah of Dacca, 
 and have made restitution of all sums which he may have 
 appropriated to his own use, either from the Dewanny 
 revenues or the Nabob's stipends ; and, until he shall 
 also have satified the claims of all such persons as may 
 have suffered by any act of injustice or oppression 
 committed by him in the office of Naib Duan. 
 
 As the detection of any corrupt practices of which 
 Mahomet Reza Cawn may have been guilty, and the 
 retribution which, in such case, is to be required of 
 him, are equally the objects of public justice and the 
 Company's interest, we assure ourselves that you will 
 sedulously endeavour to penetrate into the most hidden 
 parts of his administration, and discover the reality of 
 the several facts with which he is charged, or the just- 
 ness of the suspicions we have of his conduct. In this 
 research, your own judgment will direct you to all such 
 means of information as may be likely to bring to 
 light the most secret of his transactions. We, however, 
 cannot forbear recommending to you to avail yourself 
 of the intelligence which Nuncomar may be able to 
 give respecting the Naib's administration ; and, while 
 the envy which Nuncomar is supposed to bear this 
 minister may prompt him to a ready communication of 
 all proceedings which have come to his knowledge, we 
 are persuaded that no scrutable part of the Naib's 
 conduct can have escaped the watchful eye of his 
 jealous and penetrating rival.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 223 
 
 Hence, we cannot doubt but that the abilities and 
 disposition of Nuncomar may be successfully employed 
 in the investigation of Mahomet Reza Cawn's adminis- 
 tration, and bring to light any embezzlement, fraud, 
 or malversation which he may have committed in the 
 office of Naib Duan, or in the station he has held 
 under the several successive Subuhs; and while we 
 assure ourselves that you will make the necessary use 
 of Nuncomar's intelligence, we have such confidence 
 in your wisdom and caution, that we have nothing to 
 fear from any secret motives or designs which may 
 induce him to detect the mal-administration of one, 
 whose power has been the object of his envy and 
 whose office the aim of his ambition ; for we have the 
 satisfaction to reflect that you are too well apprized of 
 the subtlety and disposition of Nuncomar to yield him 
 any trust or authority which may be turned to his 
 own advantage, or prove detrimental to the Company's 
 interest. 
 
 Though we have thought it necessary to intimate to 
 you how little we are disposed to delegate any power 
 or influence to Nuncomar, yet should his information 
 and assistance be serviceable to you, in your investi- 
 gating the conduct of Mahomet Reza Cawn, you will 
 yield him such encouragement and reward as his 
 trouble and the extent of his services may deserve. 
 
 In our general address, we deemed it advisable to 
 mention only that we had received information of 
 Mahomet Reza Cawn's having increased the calamities 
 of the poor, during the height of the famine, by a mo- 
 nopoly of rice and other necessaries of life. We were, 
 indeed, restrained from an open communication on this 
 subject, fearing the consequences which might ensue 
 from the minister's revenge, should he learn by whom 
 such accusation had been brought against him ; but, 
 persuaded as we are of your secrecy and discretion,
 
 224 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 we herewith transmit to you extract of a letter from 
 Huzzeramul to Robert Gregory, Esq., wherein Ma- 
 homet Reza Cawn is charged with a crime of so atro- 
 cious a nature, and we the rather advise you of Huz- 
 zeramul's information, as we rely on your endeavours 
 to obtain full evidence respecting the truth of this 
 allegation, as well as of such others as are the objects 
 of the scrutiny we have directed to be made into the 
 Naib's conduct. 
 
 Sensible as you must be of the importance of the 
 charge thus confidentially committed to you, we shall 
 not seek to animate your zeal for the Company's 
 welfare, but observe only that, by the effectual execu- 
 tion of the separate trusts reposed in you, you will at 
 once render the Company a signal and essential ser- 
 vice, and approve yourself worthy of the opinion we 
 have formed of your judgment, prudence, and integrity, 
 and which we have so fully manifested in selecting you 
 to preside in the administration of the government of 
 Bengal. We are, your loving friends. 
 
 Such was the spirit in which the Directors of 
 the East India Company entrusted the chief ma- 
 nagement of their affairs to Mr. Hastings, at a 
 period when, by their own confession, those affairs 
 stood upon the very brink of ruin. Of the temper 
 with which he accepted the trust, and the ardour 
 with which he applied himself to its execution, 
 a far better idea will be formed from the perusal 
 of his own correspondence than from any outline 
 of facts which I could give. I would have con- 
 fined myself exclusively, in the selection which 
 I now offer, to communications which tell the
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 225 
 
 tale of the writer's public life connectedly, did I not 
 fancy that the reader might wish to go somewhat 
 beyond this. For we love to see a great man in 
 solitude as well as in the crowd, inasmuch as the 
 true character is often shown more distinctly by 
 trifles than by matters of grave importance. 
 
 The allusions contained in the following to the 
 comparative strength of Hyder Ally and the Mah- 
 rattas will amuse the reader of the nineteenth 
 century. Mr. Hastings himself remained at the 
 head of affairs in India long enough to change his 
 views entirely on that subject. 
 
 To JOHN PURLING, Esq. 
 
 Fort William, 22nd February, 1772. 
 
 Dear Sir, I have received your favours of the 30th 
 April, 3rd May, and llth June, 1771. These contain 
 principally recommendations. I have delayed replying 
 to them till this late period in the hopes of receiving 
 another letter, referred to in the first of these as 
 having been sent by the Colebrooke ; but, I know not 
 by what accident, it has not yet come to my hands. 
 Letters so rarely miscarry that I do not despair of 
 being- able to reply to it by the next despatches, thougli 
 my present disappointment gives me much uneasiness. 
 
 Accept, Sir, of my sincere thanks for my late ap- 
 pointment. The obligations which I before lay under 
 for the countenance and effectual support which you 
 afforded me on my first return to the service were be- 
 yond my power to repay. Whether I have really 
 benefited by my removal from Fort St. George to a 
 station of more eclat, but of more trouble and difficulty, 
 and I fear of more danger, from its being an object of 
 
 VOL. I. Q
 
 226 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 more competition, I must doubt. My partiality to this 
 part of the Company's possessions has, nevertheless, 
 made me rejoice in the exchange, and it shall be my 
 study to render it equally satisfactory to my employers. 
 Let me have their confidence and their support, and 
 arduous as I know my duty will be, I do not despair of 
 acquitting myself of it with credit, to myself and to 
 them also, in the choice which they have made of me 
 to conduct the affairs of this government. I hope, 
 however, that I shall not be made responsible for more 
 than is committed to my charge, for I fear that the 
 powers of this government are more ostensible than 
 real. If the several districts are subject to the juris- 
 diction of the inferior servants of 'the Company ; if the 
 business of the revenue is entrusted to the chiefs and 
 councils of Murshedabad and Patna, though subject 
 to the control of the presidency, which can only judge 
 of the propriety of their transactions from their own 
 materials; I will take upon me to affirm that the 
 authority of the presidency is in these points merely 
 nominal, nor ought it to be charged with the conse- 
 quences of any mismanagement, if any, that may have 
 been committed in the country. I only suppose, but 
 do not know, that this is the established system, not 
 having yet had leisure or opportunity to inform myself 
 of the state of the public affairs, in which I find I have 
 much to learn. 
 
 I find that the Mahrattas are become almost as 
 dangerous neighbours to these provinces as they are to 
 the Carnatic. I much fear that the pacific system 
 enjoined at Fort St. George, and the too sanguine hopes 
 of which the Court of Directors seem to have formed of 
 the ability of their forces on that establishment to 
 withstand the efforts of all the powers of Indostan, will 
 prove in the end of the most fatal consequences to your 
 affairs.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. '227 
 
 The Mahrattas might a t this time, by a vigorous 
 conduct, be repelled from the Ballaghant, for that 
 country is exhausted of its resources, and their armies 
 subsist by convoys extending in a long line from the 
 borders of their own dominions. These would lie 
 entirely at our mercy, nor could the plunder of the 
 Carnatic, nor even the temporary supplies which the 
 Mahrattas might receive from Tanjour, enable them to 
 live. I do suppose that by this time a peace has been 
 confirmed between them and the Nabob of the Car- 
 natic, through the representations of their Vac-keel, the 
 liberality of the Nabob, and the hopes given them of 
 future assistance by his Majesty's minister. The con- 
 sequences will be that Hyder, deprived of all hope of 
 our support, must fall. This will join the dominion of 
 the Mahrattas to our own borders. A year or two of 
 undisturbed cultivation will restore the resources of 
 the Ballaghant, and enable them to lay up stores at 
 hand, and to invade the Carnatic with impunity from 
 every quarter, nor will all the powers of India, added 
 to yours, save that province from utter ruin. All my 
 hopes are in the spirit and perseverance of Hyder, 
 which may give time for fortune to throw some unfore- 
 seen event which may give another turn to his affairs, 
 or suspend his ruin till measures can be taken to 
 prevent it, that is, till the presidency of Fort St. 
 George shall be empowered to take such measures, and 
 for once to assume a dictatorial power in the operations 
 of the Carnatic. 
 
 I observe that the Court of Directors have ordered 
 the gomastahs to be withdrawn, and the investment to 
 be provided by Daducy merchants. This is a little 
 singular, and rather discouraging to the hopes which I 
 had entertained of receiving the commendations of my 
 employers, for an arrangement which is the very reverse 
 of these orders, and which I was hilt-ly employed to
 
 228 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 execute in the investment at Madras. Let me entreat 
 of you to read the minute on our consultations on this 
 subject. They will be found (as I recollect) in the 
 proceedings of the beginning of May and the beginning 
 of December, 1771. 
 
 The former contain the reasons for this change, the 
 latter a description of the new establishment and an 
 account of its success. I hope the genius and consti- 
 tution of the two governments will be duly attended to 
 in the judgment which shall be formed of this mea- 
 sure. It is strictly consonant to former orders of 
 the Company. 
 
 Your goods are already improved in their quality and 
 in their price. They are rendered capable of greater 
 improvement. The investment may be increased to a 
 double amount, and the weavers, instead of complaining 
 of oppression, will be thankful for your protection. 
 Your sales, too, I hope, will receive an additional ad- 
 vantage in the strictness of the sorting. 
 
 I am not yet a competent judge of the propriety of 
 the Company's orders respecting the investment at this 
 presidency ; but it appears to me to be well grounded, 
 and even necessary to restore the free trade of this 
 country. I am not sure that it will have that effect. 
 It will have none but that of debasing the cloths and 
 increasing their price, if the merchants are to be allowed 
 the same privileges, and exclusive powers which were 
 before given to the gomastahs. Some sacrifice will 
 most probably be necessary for effecting the change 
 proposed, and some will be equally requisite for restor- 
 ing the general trade of the country. A man well 
 experienced in the affairs of this country, and who, I 
 dare say, never read Montesquieu, told me, in answer to 
 some questions which I proposed to him, that the trade 
 of this country was ruined because the magistrate of 
 the country was concerned in it.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 229 
 
 It will afford me the greatest pleasure if I can be of 
 service to your nephew, and I shall seek for occasion 
 to serve him, happy if I can repay to him a part of my 
 obligation to you. 
 
 Mr. Stuart I know. He has great abilities, and I 
 hope to profit by them. I foresee that I shall want 
 such an assistant. 
 
 Permit me to request the continuance of your pro- 
 tection and support. Allow me to add my hopes of 
 being honoured with your friendship. I will venture to 
 assure you that you shall never experience anything in 
 my private or public conduct which shall give you 
 cause to regret the confidence which you have reposed 
 in me, or which you may hereafter give me. I am with 
 the greatest esteem, dear Sir, your much obliged and 
 faithful servant. 
 
 The following is addressed to the widow of his 
 early friend, Mr. Vansittart, of whose loss on his 
 passage as a member of the commission to Bengal 
 notice has already been taken. I transcribe it, 
 because of the tone of good feeling which it 
 breathes : 
 
 To Mrs. VANSITTAHT. 
 
 Fort William, 23rd February, 1772. 
 
 Dear Madam, I received the favour of your letter 
 on my arrival at this place, by the hand of your son ; 
 I was so fortunate as to be here just in time to see him 
 and to converse with him. He is now going in the 
 Lord Holland to Madras, where his presence will be a 
 great comfort to Mr. and Mrs. Morse, who have been 
 greatly disappointed by the Colebrooke's passing 
 Madras without stopping there. I do not think he 
 will lose much time by this absence from the settle- 
 ment, as he is of a disposition uncommonly studious,
 
 230 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 and seems determined to make himself master of the 
 Persian tongue, one of the first requisites for business 
 in this country. I had the great satisfaction, in my 
 short acquaintance with him, to observe that he pos- 
 sessed a very solid understanding, with a degree of 
 diffidence, which I think rather a recommendation in so 
 young a man, and which will gradually wear off as he 
 mixes with the world. His temper is such as I should 
 have expected he would derive from both his parents, 
 amiable and gentle, and has gained him the affection, 
 as I am assured, of all his shipmates. I mention these 
 qualities (though I believe I but add my single testi- 
 mony of them to that of all who know him), as I think 
 them the surest pledges for his future success in life. 
 I shall be happy if it should be ever in my power to 
 contribute to it. If his uncle George does not insist on 
 his being with him, I shall press his consent to let him 
 stay with me, and be a part of my family. I think it 
 may be better for him than the retirement of a subor- 
 dinate factory, and I hope he will be equally in the way 
 of improvement. I shall consider him as having the 
 strongest claim to more than my attention, to my affec- 
 tion ; and I shall be happy, if in the proofs which it 
 may be in my power to afford him of it, I can at the 
 same time show that the friendship which I ever bore 
 for his father, was not confined to him alone, but ex- 
 tended itself to every one who was dear to him. 
 
 No one knows more, I believe, than I do the mis- 
 fortune which you have sustained in the loss of a man 
 who was beloved by everyone who was acquainted with 
 him, and who would have returned to his family with 
 accumulated honour had it pleased God to have enabled 
 him to fulfil the purposes of his commission. There is 
 yet a possibility, in the conjectures which may be formed 
 to account for his having so long been missing, of his 
 safety ; but it is a chance too >veak to build any hopes
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 231 
 
 upon. Your surest resource will be found in that forti- 
 tude of mind of which you are so happily possessed, and 
 in the hopes that some recompense may yet be made to 
 you for the worst that may have happened in the 
 blessings which Providence may have in store for your 
 children. 
 
 I shall not be wanting in affording every assistance 
 which can be required from me in collecting in the 
 remainder of Mr. Vansittart's affairs. Indeed I believe 
 my own are much connected with them. I have not 
 yet had leisure to look into my own, but Mr. Hancock 
 gives me hopes that both are nearly concluded. 
 
 I beg leave to offer my sincere wishes for your hap- 
 piness, and to assure you that I am, with the greatest 
 esteem and respect, dear Madam, your most obedient 
 humble servant. 
 
 To the Honourable JOSIAS DUPRE, Esq. 
 
 Fort William, 22d February, 1772. 
 
 Dear Sir, I am yet a stranger to the system of this 
 government. My time has hitherto been mostly 
 engrossed by the usual ceremonials, and my first busi- 
 ness I believe will be to make such a disposition of it as 
 to secure a share of it to myself. 
 
 I desired Stracey to show you a letter which I had 
 written to the young Nabob, and either to deliver it 
 into his hands or repeat the substance of it in a verbal 
 declaration, or suppress it wholly, as you should advise. 
 I felt a sort of repugnance at taking the same formal 
 leave of him that I did of the Free Mason, because I 
 have a real esteem for him on account of the qualities 
 Avhich I have ascribed to him in my letter. But I 
 wrote it in a hurry and at a late hour, and on reading 
 the copy of it since, I have thought that though the 
 meaning included in the latter part of it is very good 
 and perfectly consonant to my opinion of him, yet the 
 expression looks mightily like nonsense. On that
 
 232 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 account I shall be glad if he has an assurance only of 
 my esteem for him verbally. I have troubled you with 
 a letter for the Nabob; it contains only compliments. 
 Will you be so good as to send it to him ? I think I 
 ought to write to his sons, but as it might give offence 
 to him, I have omitted it. 
 
 You make me happy in the assurance which you give 
 me that my desire to contribute to the support of your 
 administration has received your approbation. I can 
 assure you that I do not wish for anything more than 
 that I may find the same disposition in the members 
 of this board to co-operate with me, as I have ever felt 
 myself impressed with towards you, not less, I can truly 
 say, from motives of personal esteem, than from a just 
 sense of my duty to the public. I have not the vanity 
 to hope that I shall have an equal claim to it. I shall 
 write to you often, and without ceremony I hope with 
 more matter than this letter contains. I am, with the 
 sincerest esteem and regard, dear Sir, your most obe- 
 dient and faithful servant. 
 
 I beg the favour of you to present my compliments 
 to Mrs. Dupre, with my best wishes, and that you will 
 suppose the same in all my future letters. 
 
 To the Honourable JOSIAS DUPRE, Esq. 
 
 Fort William, 14th March, 1772. 
 
 Dear Sir, I have not written to you since the 22d 
 of last month, which was the date of my last by the 
 Lord Holland, because nothing new has occurred that 
 required to be communicated. 
 
 Captain Leslie* is gone, and my apprehensions of 
 the secret design of this visit appear to have been 
 groundless. Nevertheless, I am not much pleased with 
 these trials. The serpent (as the Nabob would observe 
 upon it) has found out the way, and may bite when he 
 
 * Captain Leslie was one of those officers whom the government unwisely 
 thrust into the position of King's envoy to the powers of India.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 233 
 
 comes next. I think we are secure from any injury 
 that can be intended us, having the power in our own 
 hands, and being out of the reach of the treaty of 
 Paris, though all the grammarians in Europe were to 
 club their invention to infer from it that the King of 
 Great Britain is a guarantee for the peace of Bengal. 
 
 The Cuddaloor schooner was despatched, I think the 
 2nd, for Artrin and Cudda. 
 
 I much fear we are on the eve of a war with the 
 MahrattaSj in spite of the pacific injunctions of our 
 masters, in spite of our endeavours to avoid it, and of 
 the necessities of the country, which much wants an 
 interval of peace and ease. The Mahrattas have 
 entered the country of the Rohillas, lying on the north 
 side of the Ganges, defeated the Rohillas, and entirely 
 dispersed all their forces, and taken possession of Sek- 
 ketaul, their capital (a city on the north bank of the 
 Ganges, about ninety miles from Delly) ; Zabata Cawn, 
 their great chief, has fled to Najeelgur (God knows 
 where), and the other chiefs are shut up in their strong 
 holds, so that the whole country, to the borders of 
 Shuja Dowla's dominions, lies at their mercy. The 
 enclosed best describes the miserable state of that 
 country. The brigade ordered by Sir Robert Barker 
 to join him has received orders from hence to halt until 
 we receive some intimation from the Vizier that he 
 wants our assistance. I hope he may have no occasion 
 for it. The time of the year, the situation of the 
 country, shut in by the mountains on the north, and 
 the river which in less than three months more will be 
 impassable, are circumstances which afford us a secu- 
 rity for this season. But the Vizier is the only re- 
 maining power to oppose them, and we must defend 
 him it' they invade his country. 
 
 I shall send you the newspapers and other intelli- 
 gence as often as anything new occurs ; and you will
 
 234 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 not take it amiss if they are not always accompanied 
 with the formality of a letter when I have nothing to 
 write. 
 
 I am yet unemployed, except in reading, learning, 
 but not inwardly digesting. I fear I have a laborious 
 and difficult part to act; but I have hopes of able 
 support and willing. I wish for no more. Mr. Alex- 
 ander will have given you the portrait of this govern- 
 ment. 
 
 I fear your hands are tied, whatever turn the Com- 
 pany's affairs may take in this quarter, as I hear the 
 Mahrattas have concluded the proposed treaty with the 
 Nabob and his Majesty's minister, and I can scarce 
 hope that it would be in your power, after the Mah- 
 rattas shall have reduced Hyder, even with the heartiest 
 support the Nabob could give you, to act with effect 
 against them. What will become of your half of the 
 Carnatic, when the other half is in their possession ? 
 
 To the Honourable JOSIAS DUPRE, Esq. 
 
 Fort William, 26th March, 1772. 
 
 Dear Sir, I am much obliged to you for your favour 
 of the 28th ultimo, and for the gazettes. I think a 
 war with France very improbable, but I much fear the 
 news of Coote's returning is too well founded. If it 
 proves so, he will probably return a slave of the 
 ministry, not a servant of the Company. I am flat- 
 tered greatly by your approbation of the letter from 
 Madras, because it is a literal translation of a part of 
 one of my own. The portrait of Bengal extracted 
 from another letter, I am grieved to say, falls short of 
 the life. Will you believe that the boys of the service 
 are the sovereigns of the country under the unmean- 
 ing title of supervisors, collectors of the revenue, ad- 
 ministrators of justice, and rulers, heavy rulers of the 
 people ? They are said to be under the control of the 
 Board of Revenue at Murshedabad and Patna, who are
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 235 
 
 lords of those capitals, and of the districts annexed to 
 them, and dispose of the first offices of the state. 
 Subject (as it is said also) to the Governor and Council, 
 who, you may take my word for it, if the conclusion be 
 not self-evident, have neither power, trust, nor emolu- 
 ment, but are honoured only with responsibility. This 
 is the system which it seems my predecessor was turned 
 out for opposing, and I will be turned out too, rather 
 than suffer it to continue as it is. Thus much for our 
 internal government. Now for the political. This I 
 will give you in the detail of so much of our occurrences, 
 as it may concern you to be acquainted with. 
 
 The Mahrattas have crossed the Ganges, taken 
 Sukkertaul, the capital of the Rohilla country, which 
 lies between the Ganges, the mountains of Tibbet, and 
 the dominions of the Vizier. They have defeated and 
 dispersed the Rohilla forces which opposed them, and 
 the whole country of course became subject to their 
 ravages. 
 
 Sir Robert Barker, who, it seems, is minister pleni- 
 potentiary with the Vizier, instantly sent orders to the 
 brigade quartered at Patna to march to the assistance 
 of the Vizier, whom lie represented as in a state of the 
 most abject despair ; and he desired the Board to give 
 their sanction to this act of authority. It is remark- 
 able that he had before desired the Board to order the 
 brigade to march to the banks of the Carrumnassa, 
 lest they might be wanted, and that they had actually 
 marched before orders were received, and that the first 
 news of it came in private letters. The Board, how- 
 ever, have disapproved of these acts of the general, 
 and have ordered the army to halt. I hope the next 
 orders will be for their return. Look at the map, and 
 reflect on the time of the year, and you will see how 
 little probability there is of the Mahrattas disturbing 
 the Vizier this year. In all this time the Government
 
 236 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 has not received a letter from the Vizier, nor does the 
 general intimate even that he wants our assistance. 
 On the contrary, he says he can hardly keep him from 
 taking advantage of the calamities of his neigh- 
 bours, and joining the Mahrattas in the plunder of the 
 country; and a letter just received from him mentions 
 an offer of the Mahrattas to cede to him all the Ro- 
 hilla country on that side of the river, in the hope of 
 obtaining his acquiescence in their attempts to possess 
 themselves of the countries lying on the other side 
 a compromise not likely to take effect. I wish it could, 
 for I see less danger from it, than from running head- 
 long into a war with them. I must again refer you to 
 the map for my reasons. I need not tell you that I 
 write for your inspection only. I shall keep no secret 
 from you, because I think you ought to know what is 
 doing here for your own guidance in the transactions 
 which have any connexions with this government. In 
 most they will be found to be united. I shall be 
 obliged to you too for your opinion and advice when I 
 can furnish materials sufficient for either. I am with 
 the sincerest and most affectionate regard and esteem, 
 dear Sir, your most obedient humble servant. 
 
 The following, which relates to a practice then 
 in operation of pressing the cattle of the cultiva- 
 tors as often as troops happened to march through 
 any district, I give, not on account of its import- 
 ance, considered as a public document, for, in that 
 point of view, it is of slight value ; but, because 
 it exhibits the kind and playful disposition of the 
 writer in a very pleasing light.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 237 
 
 To GEOKGE VANSITTART, Esq. 
 
 Dear George, I received yours of the 27th March 
 yesterday. I do not choose to give 700 rupees for a bauz, 
 but the Nabob will like it the better for being dear. 
 One pair I must have, and desire they may be cheap. 
 I thank you for your present. Don't you know that 
 this looks like a hint to trouble you with no more 
 commissions, if I chose to take it ? 
 
 Wilkins is going home. Poor Reid, I fear, is on the 
 eve of a longer voyage, to that place from whose bourne 
 no traveller returns. What plan or project will you 
 devise for your continuance where you are ? You have 
 time before you sufficient to think of it, and I shall be 
 happy if I can join in adopting it. As you have com- 
 municated your thoughts on this subject to nobody, 
 you had better keep them to yourself. I except my- 
 self. 
 
 Your last general letter was debated at our last 
 council, and a resolution passed upon it, which I per- 
 ceive waits to grow cold before it is to be sent to you. 
 The portrait of your pressing system does honour 
 equally to your good sense and humanity. The Board 
 thinks, and so do I, that the expedient proposed will 
 burthen the Company with a heavy expense, and not 
 answer the end ; and the following theorem is proposed 
 in its room. Suppose every farmer in the provinces 
 was to be enjoined to maintain a number of good ser- 
 viceable bullocks, proportionate to the amount of his 
 farm, to be allowed to make what use of them he 
 pleases, during a time of peace, or want of service ; 
 but be obliged to furnish the Government with them 
 on a requisition made to him by the collector in writing 
 (not by seepoys, delects, or hercarras), and the collector 
 to send them to the army. Would not this answer the 
 end proposed ? Would not they choose rather to sub- 
 mit to so trifling a charge than be frightened, plun-
 
 238 MEMOIRS OF WAltREN HASTINGS. 
 
 dered, and insulted, and have their lands deserted on 
 every rumour of a march of a party of seepoys ? I will 
 suppose the whole province to be let out in farm, and 
 every farmer possessed of a revenue of 10,000 rupees to 
 be assessed for tlixee bullocks. This tax, which will 
 scarcely be felt, will produce near 1,500 bullocks, and 
 you in your estimate suppose 1,000 to be sufficient ; 
 and the annual expense of these, allowing them to last 
 but a year, and allowing them to be idle all the year, 
 and only eat grain, which are three great allowances, 
 will be but 132 rupees. But it might be proved that 
 it would not amount to 50 rupees. Where there is no 
 farmer, the shiedar, or aumil, that is, the district, should 
 furnish the number prescribed. The order might be 
 issued at once to all the collectors, and by each collector 
 to the farmers, or aumils, who should be fined if they 
 failed within a given time to send their quota, or if 
 the cattle they sent were unserviceable ; and exempla- 
 rily punished if, in default of their own, they took 
 those of tlie tenants. I maintain that the whole might 
 be collected in a fortnight's time with ease from the 
 remotest parts of the province. In like manner 
 cooleys might be furnished by a tax on the people : 
 for if every village was obliged to send one, or but 
 every pergunnah one, and be responsible for the at- 
 tendance of that one, and no pressing were allowed, 
 ;you might have what number you pleased. Don't 
 throw yourself back in your burra chokey, and tell me 
 it won't do the orders will not be obeyed the 
 farmers are entitled by their leases to a deduction for 
 plunder and oppression that it is the custom of the 
 country to press, (that I know you won't say) that it 
 is easy to make regulations, &c. &c., but consider 
 seriously what effects such an order will have reduced 
 to practice, and, if practicable, lay it down as a rule 
 that it shall be obeyed. If the farmers refuse, (they
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 239 
 
 dare not refuse,) let them be entitled to no greater de- 
 duction than the amount of the maintenance of so many 
 bullocks as you require them to keep, in order to save 
 them from plunder. I have this moment received the 
 draught of your letter. It is proposed to provide for 
 1,000 bullocks only. This is not sufficient but you 
 may improve on the hint. Yours most affectionately. 
 
 I subjoin a specimen of his manner of dealing 
 with the young men whom those in power, or his 
 own private friends, recommended to his notice : 
 
 To Mr. ELLIOT. 
 
 18th April, 1772. 
 
 Sir, I received your letter, with that of Mr. Pasley 
 inclosed. I am happy on all occasions of showing at- 
 tention to Mr. Pasley's recommendation, and shall be 
 glad of the occasion which your presence here (when- 
 ever your business permits) may afford me, of assuring 
 you of my particular good dispositions towards you, 
 from the interest which Sir George Colebrooke takes 
 in whatever concerns you, as well as the desire I have 
 to conciliate the esteem of one of Sir G. Elliot's emi- 
 nence and worth. There is, however, one recommen- 
 dation which will always be stronger with me than either 
 that of connexion or mere predilection of favour 
 I mean that of real merit. I am happy to learn that 
 this will not be wanting on your part, and I mention it 
 not as mere matter of compliment, but as the properest 
 encouragement to a young man of honourable feelings, 
 to make him persist in that line which will best recom- 
 mend him to the favour and protection of his superiors 
 in general, as well as to the particular friendship of, 
 Sir, your affectionate humble servant.
 
 240 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 Y* 
 
 To Sir ROBERT BAKER. 
 f\ 
 
 Fort William, 21st April, 1772. 
 
 Sir, I received with much pleasure the favour of 
 your letter, and return you my thanks for your congra- 
 tulation on my arrival in Bengal. 
 
 I should have been earlier in this acknowledgment, 
 but that I wished to accompany it with my sentiments 
 on other subjects; which, added to the incessant inter- 
 ruption which lias been my lot since my arrival at this 
 place, has been the cause of my protracting it to this 
 time. I should be very sorry that this delay should 
 give you room, in our early acquaintance, to suspect 
 me of inattention ; and I beg leave to obviate such a 
 conclusion by the assurance of my sincere esteem, 
 founded on the knowledge of your character for many 
 years past, as well as on the opinion of many of my 
 friends who have had opportunities of being personally 
 acquainted with your merit and abilities. 
 
 The late correspondence between you and this Board 
 has been a subject of great uneasiness to me. I meant 
 to have said something upon it, but I think it has 
 been sufficiently canvassed in the late letters from 
 hence. Allow me only to remark in a word, that inde- 
 pendent of the considerations which respect the poli- 
 tical state of affairs in this country, there are many 
 powerful causes which render every kind of caution 
 and circumspection necessary to prevent the appearance 
 of our taking an active part in the quarrels of our 
 neighbours, but more especially such as the Mahrattas 
 are concerned in. I will explain myself more clearly 
 upon this subject when I have more leisure to give you 
 my thoughts upon it. In the mean time, I beg you 
 will be assured that it would give me infinitely more 
 pleasure to add to your consideration, if my aid were 
 necessary -to it, than to take any measure that might 
 tend, in the least degree, to lessen it.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 241 
 
 Enclosed is a letter to the Vizier, which I beg leave 
 to send under your cover. It contains only assurances 
 of the readiness of this government to afford him 
 assistance, and such an explanation of the Board on 
 the subject of his requisition, as might prove more 
 satisfactory to him. I would send a copy of it for your 
 perusal, but am too late to get one written to-night; 
 and I take it for granted that you will be made 
 acquainted with the substance of the letter from the 
 Vizier. I am, with very much esteem, Sir, your most 
 obedient humble servant. 
 
 To SAMUEL MIDDLETOK, Esq. 
 
 Fort William, 22ud April, 1772. 
 
 Dear Sir, I have been favoured with your letters 
 of the 10th, 13th, and 16th instant. 
 
 Your recommendation of Mr. Russell would be a 
 sufficient inducement, had I not received other testi- 
 monies of his merit, for my wishing to continue him in 
 his present charge. I hope there will appear no 
 objection to it. 
 
 I have had much conversation with Mr. Graham on 
 the subject of the ensuing settlement, and am happy to 
 find our ideas agree in every material point. I am 
 assured by him that they correspond also with yours. I 
 leave him to inform you of particulars, for I have not 
 sufficient leisure. The Board have resolved on farms 
 and long leases. This is the only subject which has 
 been yet before them. I wait but for a day's exemption 
 from the duties of my new office, to prepare the subject 
 for the general determination upon it, and hope to get 
 it concluded within the next week. The points which 
 are likely to take place, and which I mention in con- 
 fidence, for fear of i 1 ! consequences from their being 
 known, are these : 
 
 The first I have mentioned above. 
 
 VOL. I. R
 
 242 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 The second, a committee of the Board to go on a 
 circuit to form the settlement of each district on the 
 spot. 
 
 The third, I believe, I need not mention. A former 
 letter of yours has pointed out both the necessity of it, 
 and your ideas and expectations concerning it. 
 
 The rest are rather corollaries on these. On the 
 second I wish to be favoured with your sentiments and 
 wishes. I should be glad to have your assistance in 
 it. Your experience, and, allow me to add, your dis- 
 position, equally contribute to make me desirous of it. 
 As the head of the revenue branch at the city, there 
 seems a propriety in it. It may also be pleaded against 
 it, that your presence at the city may not be dispensed 
 with. I state both arguments, and request your deci- 
 sion upon them, remarking, by-the-bv, that this is a 
 matter on which the Board must decide. I almost 
 fear to have a voice in it. Mr. Graham will of course 
 be one. 
 
 I thank you, my dear Sir, for the pleasing sentiments 
 which you express on my admission to the government. 
 I have not been able yet to attend to your application 
 for military stores, but the subject shall not rest much 
 longer. 
 
 I will write to you on the subject of the court martial 
 to-morrow. It is a new matter, and will form a pre- 
 cedent ; it must, therefore, be maturely considered. 
 
 On the question proposed by Mr. Harwood these 
 queries occur : Have the officers of the brigade sepoys 
 stationed with him, orders to obey him as their supe- 
 rior? (I think I can answer this in the affirmative.) 
 Has Mr. Harwood any kind of warrant to order court 
 martials? If yes, undoubtedly his authority on this 
 point is the same with the brigade as with the per- 
 gunnah sepoys. 
 
 I need not tell you that I write in a hurry. I wisli
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 243 
 
 you may understand me. I am, with the most un- 
 feigned regard, dear Sir, your most obedient and faith- 
 ful servant. 
 
 I subjoin a communication on a different subject. 
 From the management of treaties with crowned 
 heads to the preparation of silk thread, and the 
 purchase of cacoons, there was nothing which 
 eluded the personal attention of the governor. 
 
 To Mr. WITS. 
 
 Fort William, 29th April, 1772. 
 
 Sir, I am favoured with your letters of the 27th 
 February and 12th instant. The length of these 
 letters, my desire to be informed of the subjects to 
 which they allude, and the little leisure which has been 
 allowed me from other affairs, have been the reasons 
 which have hitherto prevented my reply to them. 
 
 In the first place, allow me to return you my thanks 
 for your congratulations on my arrival in this country. 
 In the execution of the many duties annexed to my 
 station, it will afford me a very sensible satisfaction if 
 I can contribute to the success of the business entrusted 
 to your charge, and which you seem to prosecute with 
 so much zeal and assiduity. 
 
 I am sorry to learn that you have met with diffi- 
 culties and obstructions in the establishment of your 
 filatures. There is no doubt that the inhabitants may 
 be easily persuaded to sell their cacoons. They will 
 voluntarily fly to you from all quarters of the province 
 with their goods for sale, if they understand that they 
 will receive a larger profit by your purchases, than by 
 converting their cacoons into putney. But there is a 
 great hazard of the price of silk being so much aug- 
 mented by the encouragements thus offered them by 
 you, as to render it unfit for the Company's trade. It 
 
 R2
 
 244 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 is beyond a dispute that the price of silk is universally 
 double of what I have known it, or of what it was but 
 a few years past It is also past a doubt that the silk 
 manufactured by you, although excellent, and perfect 
 in its fabric, is so dear, that upon a comparison of it 
 with the prices of the best silk sold at the Company's 
 sales, the Company will infallibly lose by it. The 
 causes of this I know not. They appear to be in the 
 price given for the cacoons ; as I am firmly persuaded 
 that the charges of your filature, taking into your 
 account the superior quality of the silk produced from 
 it, are much below those of the silk manufactured in 
 the usual progress of the natives. 
 
 An oven for killing the worms is indispensably neces- 
 sary. If I mistake not, orders have been sent for the 
 construction of them. 
 
 I will frankly confess to you that I do not see the 
 same advantages in 'the expensive works which you 
 have annexed to your reels. I mean the bassines, the 
 furnaces, and bars of iron for the tender threads of 
 silk to pass through. These will prove a heavy article 
 in the Company's dead stock. They will for ever 
 require repairs, and by being made the necessary 
 appendages to your improvements, which, otherwise, 
 I think are admirable, they will preclude the inha- 
 bitants from adopting the same method of winding the 
 oilk from the cacoons. Why will not your reel, with 
 the earthen pots, the occasional moveable stoves, 
 and the other simple implements to which the natives 
 are accustomed, which are all within their reach, and 
 cost nothing, answer all the purposes of a more com- 
 plete or a more showy mechanism ? I propose these 
 as doubts, or queries, not as assertions. A better 
 information from you may possibly show that I am 
 mistaken. 
 
 I shall write very particularly to Mr. Grueber, and
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 245 
 
 make no doubt that he will readily afford you all the 
 assistance in his power. You may at all times depend 
 on mine, in such matters as I can understand. It is 
 not in my power to go through the long correspondence 
 which has passed between the factory of Cossimbazar 
 and you ; nor could it convey to me the information 
 which I wish for, since it consists rather of comments 
 and alterations than a regular series of facts or 
 proposals. 
 
 In any representation which you may have occasion 
 to make, if you will do me the favour to communicate 
 your sentiments to me as to a person totally unin- 
 formed, I shall cheerfully bestow as much time [as I 
 have to spare in considering and replying to them. 
 I should be very sorry to put you to the. trouble of a 
 journey to the presidency for the sake of a personal 
 explanation of any matters which respect your employ. 
 Three written words convey more information, and 
 contribute more to real business, than fifty used in 
 conversation. I am, Sir, your obedient servant. 
 
 P. S. Since writing the above, I have received your 
 letter of the 20th, with the musters of silk. 
 
 There is a prodigious accumulation of corre- 
 spondence upon my table additional to this, in 
 the course of which every step that was taken to 
 establish a better system of management is traced ; 
 and an admirable picture set forth of the business- 
 like habits, and extraordinary versatility of talent, 
 which distinguished the writer ; but it would be 
 drawing too much upon the patience of the general 
 reader were I to insert it. My object will be 
 sufficiently attained when I state, that from the 
 hour of his accession to the governor's chair, Mr.
 
 246 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 Hastings caused his influence to be acknowledged 
 everywhere; and that, for a season at least, he 
 carried along with him the hearty approbation of 
 his employers, as well as the support sometimes 
 obtained not without difficulty of those around 
 him. The subjoined despatch, with the official 
 reply to it, will show how exactly his arrange- 
 ments had fulfilled, and promised to fulfil, the 
 wishes of the Court of Directors. 
 
 To the Secret Committee of the Honourable Court of Directors for the 
 Affairs of the Honourable United East India Company. 
 
 Cossimbuzar, 1st September, 1772. 
 
 Gentlemen, This accompanies a duplicate of my 
 letter of the 24th April last. 
 
 Since that date I have duly received the duplicate 
 and triplicate of your commands of the 28th August, 
 1771. 
 
 The immediate departure of the Colebrooke, which 
 sailed (as I recollect) the day after my letter of the 
 24th April had reached her, prevented my giving you 
 further intelligence of the issue of the measures which 
 I had taken for the arrest of Mahommed Reza Cawn. 
 As your commands were peremptory, and addressed to 
 myself alone, I carefully concealed them from every 
 person except Mr. Middleton, whose assistance was 
 necessary for their execution, until I was informed by 
 him that Mahommed Reza Cawn was actually in arrest, 
 and on his way to Calcutta. To have consulted the 
 Board on a point on which your authoritative com- 
 mands had left me without a choice, or to have desired 
 their assistance when I had sufficient power to act with- 
 out it, would have been equally improper. But I will 
 confess that there were other cogent reasons for this
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 247 
 
 reserve. I was yet but a stranger to the characters and 
 dispositions of the members of your administration. I 
 knew that Mahommed Reza Cawn had enjoyed the sove- 
 reignty of this province for seven years past, had pos- 
 sessed an allowed annual stipend of nine lacs of rupees, 
 the uncontrolled disposal of thirty-two lacs entrusted to 
 him for the use of the Nabob, the absolute command 
 of every branch of the Nizamut, and the chief authority 
 in the Dewannee. To speak more plainly, he was in 
 everything but the name the Nazim of the province, 
 and in real authority more than the Nazim. I could 
 not suppose him so inattentive to his own security, nor 
 so ill versed in the maxims of Eastern policy, as to 
 have neglected the due means of establishing an interest 
 with such of the Company's agents as by actual autho- 
 rity, or by representation to the honourable Company, 
 might be able to promote or obstruct his views. I 
 chose therefore to avoid the risk of an opposition, to 
 put the matter beyond dispute, and then to record 
 what I had done. The same reflections occurred to 
 me when I proposed to entrust Mr. Middleton with the 
 execution of your commands, which might with more 
 certainty have been effected by an order to the com- 
 manding officer of the brigade stationed at Burram- 
 poor. But this would have been productive of much 
 disturbance. I was convinced that I might securely 
 rely on Mr. Middleton, and his behaviour justified 
 that confidence. Indeed I am bound in justice to bear 
 the same testimony to his faithful attention to your 
 interests in many other instances which I have had 
 occasion to experience of his subsequent conduct, in 
 which he has shown himself a zealous asserter of your 
 rights, and a supporter of the authority of your govern- 
 ment. 
 
 Your public records will inform you that Mahommed 
 Eeza Cawn was brought without delay to Calcutta, 

 
 248 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 where he has been detained ever since in an easy con- 
 finement ; that it was judged advisable and consistent 
 with the tenor of your commands, that Rajah Shitab 
 Roy should be arrested, and brought likewise to Cal- 
 cutta. For the particulars of these transactions, and 
 the debates concerning them, I beg leave to refer you 
 to the proceedings themselves, which will better explain 
 than I can the motives which influenced the resolu- 
 tions of the Board, and the opinions of the different 
 members upon them. Something more may be neces- 
 sary to be said concerning my own conduct, which, as 
 it was grounded solely on the several instructions 
 which you had been pleased to give me for my guid- 
 ance, become a proper subject of this address. 
 
 It may at first sight appear extraordinary that Ma- 
 hommed Reza Cawn and Rajah Shitab Roy have been 
 so long detained in confinement without any proofs 
 having been obtained of their guilt, or measures taken 
 to bring them to a trial. Very valid reasons for this 
 delay have been assigned in our minutes. I beg leave 
 to call to your recollection, that by a strange concur- 
 rence of unforeseen causes, your administration had at 
 this time every object that could engage the care of 
 government, war only excepted all demanding their 
 instant attention : the dismission of the Naib Dewan 
 and Naib Subah of the provinces; the enquiry into his 
 conduct for a course of years preceding ; the dismission 
 of the Naib Dewan of Bahar, and enquiry into his con- 
 duct ; the establishment of the Dewannee on the plan 
 directed by the Honourable Company ; the arrange- 
 ment of the Nabob's household ; the reduction of his 
 allowance and expenses; the establishment of a regular 
 administration of justice throughout the province ; the 
 inspection and reformation of the offices at the presi- 
 dency : and independent of all these, the ordinary duties 
 of the presidency, which, from the amazing growth of
 
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 249 
 
 your affairs, were of themselves sufficient to occupy the 
 whole time and application which we could bestow upon 
 them, and even more than we could bestow, from the 
 want of a regular system, the natural consequence of the 
 rapidity with which these affairs have accumulated. So 
 circumstanced, we were under an absolute necessity to 
 leave many affairs suspended that we might give due 
 despatch to the rest. The first in immediate consequence 
 claimed our immediate regard ; this was the settlement 
 of the revenue. It was late in the season ; the lands 
 had suffered unheard of depopulation by the famine and 
 mortality of 1769. The collections, violently kept up 
 to their former standard, had added to the distress of 
 the country, and threatened a general decay of the 
 revenue, unless immediate remedies were applied to 
 prevent it. The farming,system, for a course of years 
 subjected to proper checks and regulations, seemed the 
 most likely to afford relief to the country, and both to 
 ascertain and produce the real value of the lands with- 
 out violence to the ryots. It was therefore resolved 
 that this business should first take place, and it was 
 deemed necessary for this purpose that a committee, 
 composed of the members of the Council, should be 
 appointed to carry it into execution. The arrange- 
 ments of the l)e\vannee and the regulation of the 
 Nabob's household were added to the charge of the 
 Committee, and as these comprehended the most 
 valuable parts of your concerns, it was thought proper 
 that I, as president, should be joined with it. This ren- 
 dered it necessary to suspend the trials of Mahommed 
 Reza Cawn and Rajah Shitab Roy, and this reason is 
 assigned for it in our minutes. Neither Mahommed 
 Reza Cawn nor Rajah Shitab Roy complain of the 
 delay as a hardship. Perhaps all parties, as is usual 
 in most cases of a public concern, had their secret 
 views, which on this occasion, though opposite in their
 
 250 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 direction, fortunately concurred in the same point. 
 These had conceived hopes of a relaxation of the 
 Company's orders ; Mahommed Reza Cawn had even 
 buoyed himself up with the hopes of a restoration to 
 his former authority by the interest of his friends, and 
 a change in the Direction, and his letters and the letters 
 of his Dewan to the city declared these expectations. 
 I pretend not to enter into the views of others, my own 
 were these : Mahommed Reza Cawn's influence still 
 prevailed generally throughout the country ; in the 
 Nabob's household and at the capital it was scarce 
 affected by his present disgrace ; his favour was still 
 courted, and his anger dreaded. Who, under such dis- 
 couragements, would give information or evidence 
 against him ? His agents and creatures filled every 
 office of the Nizamut and Dewannee ; how was the 
 truth of his conduct to be investigated by these ? It 
 would be superfluous to add other arguments to show 
 the necessity of prefacing the inquiry by breaking his 
 influence, removing his dependents, and putting the 
 direction of all the affairs which had been committed to 
 his care, into the hands of the most powerful or active 
 of his enemies. With this view too the institution of 
 the new Dewannee obviously coincided. These were 
 my real motives for postponing the inquiry. Whether 
 my precautions will have their effect is yet a question of 
 doubt. 
 
 The same principles guided me, though not unin- 
 fluenced by other arguments of great force, in the 
 choice of Munny Begum, the widow of the Nabob Meer 
 Jaffier, and of Rajah Goordass, the son of Mahrajah 
 Nund Comar, the former for the chief administration, 
 the latter for the Dewannee of the Nabob's house- 
 hold, both the declared enemies of Mahommed Reza 
 Cawn. To the latter indeed I was principally inclined 
 by your commands, and I hope it will appear that I
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 251 
 
 have adopted almost the only expedient in which they 
 could be exactly fulfilled. You directed that " if the 
 assistance and information of Nund Comar should be 
 serviceable to me in my investigating the conduct of 
 Mahommed Reza Cawn, I should yield him such encou- 
 ragements and reward as his trouble and the extent 
 of his services may deserve." There is no doubt that 
 Nund Comar is capable of affording me great services 
 by his information and advice ; but it is on his abili- 
 ties, and on the activity of his ambition and hatred to 
 Mahommed Reza Cawn that I depend for investigating 
 the conduct of the latter, and by eradicating his in- 
 fluence for confirming the authority which you have 
 assumed in the administration of the affairs of this 
 country. The reward which has been assigned him 
 will put it fully in his power to answer these expecta- 
 tions, and will be an encouragement to him to exert all 
 his abilities for the accomplishment of them. Had I 
 not been guarded by the caution which you have been 
 pleased to enjoin me, yet my own knowledge of the 
 character of Nund Comar would have restrained me 
 from yielding him any trust or authority which could 
 prove detrimental to the Company's interests. He 
 himself has no trust or authority, but in the ascend- 
 ancy which he naturally possesses over his son. An 
 attempt to abuse the favour which has been shown him 
 cannot escape unnoticed, and if detected may ruin all 
 his hopes. The son is of a disposition very unlike his 
 father, placid, gentle, and without disguise. From him 
 there can be no danger. 
 
 You will perceive by the records that this appoint- 
 ment has not taken place without opposition from a 
 majority of the gentlemen who form the committee now 
 at this place. I know not whether you will approve or 
 disapprove of the silence which I have observed with 
 respect to your orders, in the arguments which I have
 
 252 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 used in support of my recommendation. My reason 
 was, that I thought the measure in itself so proper 
 that I did not doubt of its receiving the confirmation 
 of the Board at large, and unless some material advan- 
 tage could be gained by it, I did not think myself at 
 liberty to divulge your secret commands. I am at this 
 time most firmly persuaded that no other measure what- 
 ever would have been likely to prove so effectual either 
 for promoting the inquiry which you have directed or 
 giving strength and duration to the new system. 
 
 I hope I shall not appear to assume too much im- 
 portance in speaking thus much of myself in justifica- 
 tion of the motives which led to this recommendation ; 
 that I had no connexion with Nund Comar or his family 
 prior to the receipt of your letter by the Lapwing ; 
 that, on the contrary, from the year 1 759 to the time 
 when I left Bengal in 1764, I was engaged in a con- 
 tinued opposition to the interests and designs of that 
 man, because I judged him to be adverse to the wel- 
 fare of my employers ; and in the course of this conten- 
 tion I received sufficient indications of his ill will to 
 have made me an irreconcileable enemy, if I could 
 suffer my passions to supersede the duty which I owe 
 to the Company. My support of Nund Comar on the 
 present occasion could not, therefore, proceed from 
 partiality. It will be as obvious that my preference of 
 him to other competitors could not arise from in- 
 terested motives. I may be charged with inconsistency, 
 but the reasons which I have urged in the minute of 
 the committee in support of this measure will, I trust, 
 acquit me to my honourable employers ; and if my 
 conduct shall stand the test of their judgment, it is 
 a point of duty to bear with the reproaches of the 
 uninformed part of the world. To the service of the 
 Company, and to your commands, I have sacrificed 
 my own feelings (pardon the presumption of this repeti-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 253 
 
 tion), and I have combated those of others joined with 
 me in the administration of your affairs. I claim your 
 approbation of what I have done, not as a recompense 
 of integrity, but as the confirmation of the authority 
 which you have been pleased to confide in me, and of 
 your own which is involved in it. 
 
 I with pleasure do justice to the committee in de- 
 claring that, strenuously as they opposed the measure 
 while it was a point of debate, it had no sooner re- 
 ceived the sanction of your Council than they all con- 
 curred with me in supporting both that and the other 
 resolutions which were connected with it, as steadily as 
 if they had never dissented from it. 
 
 The appointment of Munny Begum, I believe, will 
 require no apology. It was unanimously approved, 
 and if I can be a judge of the public opinion, it is a 
 measure of general satisfaction. 
 
 The only man who could pretend to such a trust 
 was the Nabob Yesteram o' Dowla, the brother of 
 Meer Jaffier, a man, indeed, of no dangerous abilities, 
 nor apparent ambition, but the father of a numerous 
 family, who by his being brought so nigh to the 
 musnud would have acquired a right of inheritance to 
 the subahship ; and if only one of his sons, who are all 
 in the prime of life, should have raised his hopes to 
 the succession, it, would have been in his power at any 
 time to remove the single obstacle which the Nabob's 
 life opposed to the advancement of his family. The 
 guardian at least would have been the Nazim while 
 the minority lasted, and all the advantages which the 
 Company may hope to derive from it in the confirma- 
 tion of their power would have been lost, or could only 
 have been maintained by a contention hurtful to their 
 rights, or by a violence yet more exceptionable. The 
 case would be much the same were any other man 
 placed in that station.
 
 254 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 The truth is that the affairs of the Company stand 
 at present on a footing which can neither last as it is, 
 nor be maintained on the rigid principles of private 
 justice. You must establish your own power, or you 
 must hold it dependent on a superior, which I deem to 
 be impossible. 
 
 The Begum, as a woman, is incapable of passing the 
 bounds assigned her ; her ambition cannot aspire to 
 higher dignity. She has no children to provide for, 
 or mislead her fidelity ; her actual authority rests on 
 the Nabob's life, and therefore cannot endanger it. 
 It must cease with his minority, when she must depend 
 absolutely on the Company for support against her 
 ward and pupil, who will then become her master. Of 
 course her interest must lead her to concur with all the 
 designs of the Company, and to solicit their patronage. 
 I have the pleasure to add that, in the exercise of her 
 office, she has already shown herself amply qualified for 
 it, by her discernment, economy, and a patient atten- 
 tion to affairs. 
 
 In the execution of your commands of the 8th May, 
 1771, I hope I shall not appear to you to have been 
 guilty of remissness. The inquiry therein directed- 1 
 have been obliged to entrust to the previous con- 
 sideration of a Committee, the many weightier affairs 
 of your Government rendering it absolutely impos- 
 sible for me to enter on a scrutiny of that nature 
 myself, which, however, I mean to take up as soon as 
 I conveniently can after my return to the presidency. 
 I have the honour to be, Gentlemen, your most obedient 
 and faithful servant. 
 
 From the Secret Committee of the Court of Directors to WARREN HASTINGS, 
 Esq., our President and Governor of Bengal. 
 
 London, 16th April, 1773. 
 
 1 . We have received by the Nottingham your letter 
 addressed to our secret committee, dated at Cossim-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 255 
 
 buzar, the 1st September, 1772, informing us of the 
 measures you had adopted for carrying into execution 
 the orders of the secret committee, dated 28th of 
 August, 1771, and of the arrangements and regula- 
 tions which you deemed necessary for the public peace 
 and welfare of the provinces. And although the public 
 records to which you refer us are not come to hand, we 
 assure you that, so far as we are enabled to judge of 
 your proceedings by your own letter, and by that of 
 our Council, received by the same conveyance, they ap- 
 pear to us in the most favourable light, the steps you 
 have taken judicious, and indeed the whole of your 
 conduct seems to have fully justified the choice of the 
 secret committee, who entrusted to your management 
 the execution of a plan of the utmost importance. 
 
 2. We have been long sensible of the utter impro- 
 priety of lodging an absolute power in the hands of 
 Mahommed Reza Khan, but the remedy was not without 
 its difficulties ; we trust the evil is on the point of being 
 eradicated. Inconveniences generally attend great 
 and sudden alterations ; but we dare hope that your 
 agency will render them as few, as temporary, and as 
 light as possible. 
 
 3. Although you will observe that sundry changes 
 have lately taken place in the direction of the Com- 
 pany's affairs at home, those changes will not in the 
 least affect the measures in which you are engaged ; 
 on the contrary, we take this early opportunity not 
 only of testifying our entire approbation of your con- 
 duct but of assuring you of our firmest support in 
 accomplishing the work you have so successfully com- 
 menced ; and we doubt not but it will issue in the 
 deliverance of Bengal from oppression, in the esta- 
 blishment of our credit, influence, and interest in 
 India ; and consequently in every advantage which the 
 Company or the nation may justly expect from so im- 
 portant a transaction.
 
 256 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 4. As you have distinctly marked in your letter those 
 objects of inquiry and regulation which we should 
 otherwise have pointed out to you, we assure our- 
 selves that you will prosecute your inquiries with stea- 
 diness, impartiality, and to full effect, notwithstanding 
 the many difficulties and temptations which we are 
 sensible may be thrown in the way of persons engaged 
 in inquiries of this nature in order to weaken their 
 zeal for the public good, and to render their endea- 
 vours ineffectual for the great purposes of reforma- 
 tion. 
 
 5. Your attention to the settlement of the revenues, 
 as a primary object, has our entire approbation ; and 
 it is with the utmost satisfaction we observe, that the 
 farming system will be generally adopted, more espe- 
 cially as the researches and discoveries made in the 
 two preceding years must have nearly ascertained the 
 value and produce of the lands, so that imposition on 
 the part of the farmers respecting the value of the 
 lands, and oppression of the tenants, may, we hope 
 be easily avoided. 
 
 6. The extirpation of Mahommed Re/a Khan's influ- 
 ence was absolutely necessary, and the apprehending 
 of Shitab Roy equally so, as the latter had been too 
 long connected with Mahommed Reza Khan to be inde- 
 pendent of him ; but if that had not been the case, it 
 would have been absurd to continue a Naib Dewan in 
 the province of Bahar after abolishing that office in 
 Bengal ; and as to any hopes which Mahommed Reza 
 Khan may entertain of profiting by changes in the 
 Court of Directors, those hopes must speedily vanish ; 
 for however different their sentiments may be in some 
 particulars, they heartily concur in the propriety and 
 necessity of setting him aside, and of putting the ad- 
 ministration of the Company's affairs in the hands of 
 persons who may be rendered responsible in England 
 for their conduct in India.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 257 
 
 7. Your choice of the Begum for guardian to the 
 Nabob we entirely approve ; the use you intend making 
 of Nundcomar is very proper, and it affords us great 
 satisfaction to find that you could at once determine to 
 suppress all personal resentment when the public wel- 
 fare seemed to clash with your private sentiments 
 relative to Nundcomar. 
 
 8. We observe with great pleasure the testimonial 
 given by you of Mr. Middleton ; you will assure him 
 of our entire approbation of his conduct on this occa- 
 sion. And as the committee have concurred heartily 
 in supporting a measure, which, in the course of 
 debate, the majority had strenuously opposed, we 
 cannot be dissatisfied with their conduct unless the 
 perusal of their debates should oblige us to alter our 
 opinion respecting them. 
 
 9. As the shortness of our time will not permit us 
 to be more particular, we can only repeat to you our 
 assurances of protection and support, in carrying into 
 full execution the arrangements you have so happily 
 begun; and as we desire particularly that you will 
 distinguish and encourage merit wherever you find it, 
 so do we most strictly conjure you, not to suffer rank, 
 station, or any connexion or consideration whatever to 
 deter you from bringing every oppression to light, and 
 every offender, native or European, to condign punish- 
 ment. 
 
 10. If the abolition of the office of Naib Dewan, and 
 stepping forth as principals, should in any degree alarm 
 your European neighbours, we rely on your prudence 
 for removing every improper jealousy that may be en- 
 tertained on this account. 
 
 11. Notwithstanding this letter is signed by us, the 
 Court of Directors, we mean it as secret, and transmit 
 it confidentially to you only; and we leave it to your 
 discretion, to lay the contents or any part thereof 
 
 VOL.1.
 
 258 MEMOIRS OF W ARK EN HASTINGS. 
 
 before the Council, if circumstances should, in your 
 opinion, render it necessary, or if you should judge it 
 for our interest so to do, and not otherwise. We are 
 your loving friends. 
 
 I cannot better conclude this chapter than with 
 the following letter to Mr. Du Pre. It is written 
 with all the openness of along established friend- 
 ship; and as it gives a general view of Mr. Hastings's 
 policy, in a very important branch of his adminis- 
 tration, up to a certain date, both the reader and 
 myself are saved by it from following details which 
 it might be necessary to give, but which I could 
 not hope to render interesting. 
 
 To the Honourable JOSIAS DUPRE, Esq. 
 
 Fort William, 8th October, 1772. 
 
 Dear Sir, I beg you will not attribute it to any 
 fault, intentional at least, of mine, that I have suffered 
 so many of your letters to lie so long unanswered. I 
 shall not attempt an excuse, for I can neither describe 
 the state of my mind, or the life I have led for some 
 months past. I should consider it as a misfortune were 
 this to be the means of my losing the pleasure of 
 hearing from you. I am thankful to you that I have 
 not, for I can truly assure you that I received more 
 comfort from your letters, than from any written thing 
 on this side of the Cape, or perhaps on the other. I 
 have received your two letters by Captain Gore. I 
 think I may venture to promise that you shall see him, 
 at least by Christmas- day. It shall be Aldersey's 
 fault, as I have told him, if you do not. I shall claim 
 the merit of it if you do. I have found Mr. Aldersey 
 such as you represent him, a man of more useful talents 
 than many who pass themselves upon the world as 
 clever fellows. He is friendly, hearty, and capable.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 259 
 
 I confess I am interested enough to wish you may 
 change your mind and stay another year, because if 
 you do, I know it will be from motives that will do you 
 credit, and because I shall be, or think myself, secure 
 of having added to my present perplexities, a share in 
 those of Fort St. George. I cannot help thinking 
 that you may receive an invitation from the Directors 
 to remain, as they have let their resentment drop so 
 lightly, and have yet thought of no person for your 
 successor. 
 
 I will endeavour to give you in as few words as I 
 can, the sum of all the transactions and events in this 
 quarter since I have been an actor in them. They 
 may amuse by their novelty and variety. During the 
 remainder of Mr. Cartier's government, I endeavoured 
 to inform myself of the nature and state of the revenues, 
 and formed a set of regulations for the management of 
 them for the ensuing five years, the first proposition 
 being to let them for that term in farms. It was una- 
 nimously approved, and a committee appointed to 
 examine each district, and to form the settlement of 
 each on these grounds. 
 
 In the mean time, the Lapwing arrived with orders 
 to bring Mahommed Reza Cawn to Calcutta, and to 
 accuse him of frauds, embezzlements, and adding to the 
 late famine by a monopoly of rice. Rajah Shitabroy the 
 Dewan of Patna, being nearly in the same predicament 
 with respect to the suspicion of embezzling the re- 
 venue, it was judged necessary to extend the same 
 orders to him. They were both accordingly brought 
 down prisoners, the former by my authority unknown 
 to the Board, the Court's orders being addressed to 
 me alone, which I did not chuse to expose to a contest, 
 by communicating them till they were executed. A 
 contest arose about the mode of receiving him. The 
 majority agreed that a member of the Board should
 
 260 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 meet him, a measure which I suspect those who pro- 
 posed it are now sorry for. Our evenings were mostly 
 employed during all this time in regulating the dif- 
 ferent offices, and retrenching the expenses, a work 
 which has stood still for these four months past, but 
 which I hope we shall soon resume and accomplish. 
 
 In our military retrenchments we cut off' at once all 
 our Cavalry, which has engaged us in a violent squabble 
 with the general, who attacked us very impetuously 
 upon it ; but happily the Directors in their last letters 
 have unknowingly justified the measure by ordering it 
 to be done, and assigning nearly the same reasons that 
 we had given for it. 
 
 I have before told you of an order which the general 
 had given to the first brigade to march into the 
 Vizier's dominions, which the Board disapproved and 
 forbade the brigade to proceed. This also has been a 
 matter of much uneasiness between us, it being asserted 
 on our side that besides the irregularity of the act, 
 there was no necessity for it, since it was not probable 
 the Mahrattas would invade the Vizier's dominions ; on 
 the other, that it was necessary, as was proved by their 
 not daring to approach the Vizier, through fear of the 
 brigade. 
 
 On the 3d of June I set out with the committee- 
 We made the first visit to Kissemnagur, the capital of 
 Nuddeea, and formed the settlement of that district, 
 farming it in divisions for five years. We proceeded 
 next to the city, where we arrived the last of the month : 
 here a variety of occupations detained me till the 1 5th 
 of last month ; two months and a half. This period was 
 employed in settling the collections, and the govern- 
 ment of the districts dependant on Moorshedabad, which 
 were large, very numerous, and intricate ; in reducing 
 the Nabob's stipend from thirty-two lacs to sixteen, a 
 work which ought to have taken place in January last ;
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 261 
 
 in reducing his pension list, and other expenses ; in 
 forming, recommending, and executing a new arrange- 
 ment of his household ; and in framing a new system 
 for conducting the business of the Dewannee, or re- 
 venue. These two last operations will not be under- 
 stood without some enlargement. 
 
 When the Company dismissed Mahommed Reza 
 Cawn from his employment of Naib Dewan, they also 
 directed that the Nabob should be applied to, to divest 
 him of his post of Naib Subah, which was accordingly 
 done. They declared their resolution to stand forth 
 as Dewan themselves, left it to the direction of the 
 Board to place the management of the collections on 
 a proper footing, and conformable to that resolution, 
 ordered that an ostensible minister should be ap- 
 pointed to act in cases where the other companies 
 were concerned ; that another Naib Subah should be 
 recommended, and that every caution should be taken 
 to eradicate the influence of Mahommed Reza Cawn. 
 On these grounds the committee proceeded to the fol- 
 lowing arrangements : 
 
 Munny Begum, the widow of old Jaffier, was pro- 
 posed for the superintendency of the Nabob's house- 
 hold, and guardianship of his person. Raja Goordas, 
 the son of Nundcomar, (whose name you are probably 
 acquainted with,) to assist her in quality of Dewan. 
 This nomination was opposed by a majority of the 
 committee, but approved by the Board, which una- 
 nimously confirmed that of the Begum . The execution 
 of these measures was a matter of much delicacy, 
 because the Nabob's servants were in possession, and 
 his mother was considered as the head of the family. 
 However, by avoiding every appearance of violence, 
 and by a proper address to the Nabob's counsellors, 
 he was easily induced, with a very good grace, and
 
 262 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 without opposition, to give his assent to the appoint- 
 ments, which were conferred in form in the presence 
 of the committee. I should have mentioned that it 
 had been previously resolved in the Nabob's council, 
 that he should solemnly protest against them, claim the 
 administration of his own affairs, or declare his re- 
 solution to abdicate the government and retire to 
 Calcutta ; he did neither. I had the honour some time 
 afterwards to reconcile the two ladies, and to bring 
 about a meeting between them ; an event from which 
 I claim some merit, although I do not imagine there is 
 a grain of affection subsisting between them. 
 
 The office of Naib Subah is abolished, because the 
 person invested with it would of course become the 
 principal, as Mahommed Reza Cawn did. The Begum 
 is equal to the charge of directing the Nabob's house- 
 hold, and both she and her Dewan are the inveterate 
 enemies of Mahommed Reza Cawn ; of course the fittest 
 persons to eradicate his influence, which was still great. 
 I expect to be much abused for my choice of the 
 Dewan, because his father stands convicted of treason 
 against the Company, while he was the servant of Meer 
 Jaffier, and I helped to convict him. The man never 
 was a favourite of mine, and was engaged in doing 
 me many ill offices for seven years together. But I 
 found him the only man who could enable me to fulfil 
 the expectations of the Company, with respect to Ma- 
 hommed Reza Cawn ; and I had other reasons which 
 will fully justify me when I can make them known. 
 For these and those I supported his son, who is to 
 benefit by his abilities and influence ; but the father 
 is to be allowed no authority, lest people should be 
 suspicious of his abusing it. The opposition which I 
 met with in this business, and my success, have done 
 me much service with the people of the country, who
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 263 
 
 had been convinced that I had no more than a vote in 
 the Council,, and that others had more by an invincible 
 combination against me. 
 
 For the better management of the dewannee, it 
 was proposed and agreed to, to bring the collections 
 to Calcutta. Thither, too, we have brought the superior 
 courts of justice; we have established two at the 
 presidency for appeals of civil causes, and for the in- 
 spection and confirmation of all proceedings in capital 
 cases ; and two inferior courts of the like kind in each 
 district. By these arrangements the whole power and 
 government of the province will centre in Calcutta, 
 which may now be considered as the capital of Bengal. 
 The establishment of the courts of justice in Calcutta 
 was almost an act of injustice, the criminal judicature 
 being a branch of the Nizamut. But it was so con- 
 nected with the revenue, and the Mahometan courts 
 are so abominably venal, that it was necessary ; it met 
 with no opposition, and it is now a point determined, 
 although neither of these courts have yet begun to 
 exercise their functions for want of proper places to sit 
 in. Unfortunately too, a new judicature and a new 
 code of laws are framing at home, on principles dia- 
 metrically opposite to ours, which is little more than a 
 renewal of the laws and forms established of old in the 
 country, with no other variation than such as was 
 necessary to give them their due effect, and such as 
 the people understood #nd were likely to be pleased 
 with. 
 
 Loaded with all these materials, I returned to Cal- 
 cutta. The rest of the committee proceeded to visit 
 the other districts, Mr. Middleton excepted, who re- 
 mained to keep peace and order at the city. 
 
 Here I now am, with arrears of business of months, 
 and some of years to bring up; with the courts of 
 justice and offices of revenue to set a going ; with the
 
 264 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 official reformation to resume and complete ; with the 
 Lapwing to despatch; with the trials of Mahommed 
 Keza Cawn and Raja Shitabroy to bring on, without 
 materials, and without much hope of assistance (On 
 ne pend pas des gens qui ont un million dans leur 
 poche), and with the current trifles of the day, notes, 
 letters, personal applications, every man's business of 
 more consequence than any other, complainants from 
 every quarter of the province hallooing me by hun- 
 dreds for justice as often as I put my head out of 
 window, or venture abroad, and, what is worse than all, 
 a mind discomposed, and a temper almost fermented to 
 vinegar by the weight of affairs to which the former 
 is unequal, and by everlasting teazini;. We go on, 
 however, though slowly ; and in the hopes of support 
 at home, and of an easier time here when proper chan- 
 nels are cut for the affairs of the province to flow in, 
 I persevere. Neither my health nor spirits, thank 
 God, have yet forsaken me. I should have added to 
 the list of things to be done, an inquiry into the trade 
 in salt, betel nut, tobacco, and rice, carried on by the 
 principal persons of this Government, which their com- 
 mands have directed me to prosecute, a mark of dis- 
 tinction on which my friends in England congratulate 
 me. Such partial powers tend to destroy every other 
 that I am possessed of, by arming my hand against 
 every man, and every man's of course against me. 
 
 In our political state you are interested. The 
 Vizier has declared his intentions to attack the Mah- 
 rattas, lest they should begin with him, and has 
 demanded the aid of our forces to join in the pro- 
 secution of that design. We have promised him a 
 force for the protection of his country, but have declared, 
 in plain and peremptory terms, that it shall not pass 
 his borders, nor join him in an offensive war. He 
 indirectly threatens to join the Mahrattas, but we 
 shall abide by our first determination.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 265 
 
 CHAPTER VIII. 
 
 Settlement of the Provinces Arrangement of the Nabob's Household Ma- 
 hommed Reza Cawn and Shitab Roy subjected to Trial General Corre- 
 spondence. 
 
 THUS far in the month of October, that is to say, 
 within the short space of half a year from the date 
 of his accession to office, Mr. Hastings had pro- 
 ceeded towards the accomplishment of the Her- 
 culean task which his employers had committed to 
 him. Their principal object was to infuse, through 
 his means, so much of new life into their own 
 affairs as to deprive the King's government of all 
 pretext to claim a right of interference with them. 
 His designs tended not only to accomplish this, 
 but to render the European's dominion a blessing 
 to the multitudes over whom it was extended, 
 while at the same time it should prove a source of 
 permanent and increasing benefit to the English 
 Company and the English nation. From the 
 letter with which I closed the preceding chapter a 
 correct notion will have been formed of the general 
 results of his endeavours to remodel the system 
 under which the land revenues were collected. 
 But the adjustment of that point, though doubtless 
 of the first importance, was not the only matters 
 which put in strong claims u pon Mr. Hastings'
 
 266 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 attention. As has been elsewhere explained, the 
 administration of justice had become so defective 
 throughout the provinces, that beyond the limits of 
 Calcutta and the districts immediately dependant 
 on it, there was no protection anywhere for life 
 or property. Commerce, too, and especially the 
 inland trade, on which the natives chiefly depended 
 for their prosperity, and their rulers for no trivial 
 portion of their revenues, was all but extinct. 
 Then again the foreign relations of the empire for 
 such it may now be called were not satisfactory, 
 and there were many difficulties and impediments 
 in the way of improving them. I say nothing of 
 the settlement which he was required to make of 
 the Nabob's domestic concerns of the investiga- 
 tion which had been ordered into the past conduct 
 of those by whom the Nabob's government used 
 to be administered of the retrenchments to which 
 the proprietors looked in every department of the 
 state, civil as well as military and above all, of 
 their extreme anxiety on the score of the invest- 
 ments, and of the dividends, which were entirely 
 dependant on them. These were all, to Mr. 
 Hastings, subjects of anxious care ; and to the 
 adjustment of all he applied himself with a vigour 
 which held out the best prospects of success. T do not 
 know that I am required to preface the following 
 letters with any remarks from myself explanatory 
 of their contents. They seem to me to carry on
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 267 
 
 the history of the writer's public life with singular 
 accuracy, and the tone which pervades them is 
 surely excellent throughout. I therefore insert 
 them in the order of their dates. 
 
 To JOSIAS DUPRE, Esq. 
 
 Fort William, 6th January, 1773. 
 
 Dear Sir, I have already given you a brief history 
 of the most material events of this government since 
 my appointment to the charge of it. I have long wished 
 to communicate to you our proceedings at large upon 
 such points as are most likely to interest the attention 
 either of the Company or of the public, in the hopes of 
 profiting by your advice and opinion upon them for my 
 future conduct ; and if you were fixed in your resolution 
 for returning to England, that you might be furnished 
 with complete materials to judge of the propriety of 
 our measures, assuring myself that I should be sup- 
 ported by your voice in my favour if you thought I 
 deserved it. Some scruples about the regularity of 
 parting with the records of the Company have 
 hitherto withheld me ; but as these were not the 
 scruples of my own conscience, but of the consciences 
 of others, which are always the most tender in the 
 judgment which they form of actions in which they 
 have no concern; and as I have nothing to impart to 
 you but facts as notorious as the light of the sun, and 
 reasonings upon those facts, which of course can be 
 as little secret to those who choose to exercise their 
 understandings upon them I am satisfied in my own 
 mind with the rectitude of my intention, which aims at 
 no more than the support of the measures which I 
 believe to be necessary to the Company's interest and 
 of my own reputation, as it depends on the approbation 
 which my conduct may meet with ; and I rely on your 
 secrecy for preventing the objections of others. Some-
 
 268 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 thing I ought in decency to add by way of excuse for 
 giving you so much trouble, but I persuade myself you 
 will not regret it, and I have already said too much for 
 a mere preface, and am ashamed of it. What I have to 
 say upon the business of this letter shall be brief. 
 
 I have desired Colonel Campbell to take charge of a 
 packet which he will deliver to you with this. It con- 
 tains the following extracts from the proceedings of the 
 board and of the committee appointed to make the 
 circuit of the lands of Bengal. 
 
 No. 1 contains the plan and regulations for the set- 
 tlement of the revenue of this province. This is the 
 ground-work of all our subsequent proceedings. It is 
 sufficiently explained in the commentary placed oppo- 
 site to each article of the regulations. Who was it 
 that said that he had given such laws to his people as 
 they were capable of receiving, not the best that could 
 be framed? On a similar principle we have suffered 
 one capital defect to remain in our constitution I 
 mean the collectors. Do not laugh at the formality 
 with which we have made a law to change their name 
 from supervisors to collectors. You know full well how 
 much the world's opinion is governed by names. They 
 were originally what the word supervisor imports, 
 simple lookers-on, without trust or authority. They 
 became collectors, and ceased to be lookers-on ; but 
 though this change had taken place two years before I 
 arrived, yet I found, to my astonishment, that they 
 were known to the Court of Directors only in their 
 original character. It was necessary to undeceive the 
 Company ; and to that end we have called these officers 
 by a title which will convey the true idea of the nature 
 of their office. It was once intended to withdraw the 
 collectors entirely. They monopolize the trade of the 
 country, and of course prevent the return of specie by 
 trade, since they trade with the amount of their per-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 269 
 
 quisites. These perquisites I believe to be an oppres- 
 sion on the people and an obstruction of the revenue. 
 They are most of them the agents of their own banyans, 
 and they are devils. And as the collectorships are 
 more lucrative than any posts in the service (the 
 government itself not excepted whatever it may prove 
 hereafter), we cannot get a man of abilities to conduct 
 the official business of the presidency without violence ; 
 for who would rest satisfied with a handsome salary of 
 three or four thousand rupees a-year to maintain him 
 in Calcutta, who could get a lac or three lacs, which I 
 believe have been acquired in that space, and lire at no 
 expense, in the districts ? But whatever motives we 
 had for recalling these officers, it appeared that there 
 were amongst them so many sons, cousins, or eleves of 
 directors, and intimates of the members of the Council, 
 that it was better to let them remain than provoke an 
 army of opponents against every act of administration, 
 by depriving them of their emoluments. They con- 
 tinue, but their power is retrenched ; and the way is 
 paved for their gradual removal; and the Court of 
 Directors have sufficient arguments furnished them to 
 order their recall immediately. 
 
 No. 2 contains the regulations of the Nabob's house- 
 hold, the appointment of Munny Begum as guardian, 
 and of Rajah Goordass as Dewan to the Nabob ; also 
 the removal of the Khalsa (or the Supreme Court of 
 Eevenue) from Murshedabad to Calcutta. These are 
 very different subjects, but they have been copied 
 together, and are therefore marked as one number. 
 
 The appointment of the Begum was unanimously 
 agreed to by all the members of the board. She has 
 no children or relations to provide for, or to intrigue 
 for. Her power must at some time expire, and then 
 the Nabob will be her greatest enemy, because she now 
 rules him. We want the time of his minority to
 
 270 B1EMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 establish and confirm the Company's authority in the 
 country ; and as all her future hopes of protection rest 
 solely in the Company, there is no fear of her opposing 
 our measures or thwarting our views. Indeed, she assents 
 to everything ; and I do not think we have been unrea- 
 sonable ; for the power we assume is no more than the 
 safety and peace of the country indispensably requires. 
 The Nabob had some troublesome people about him, 
 who had instructed him to protest against this arrange- 
 ment ; but by a proper address to them they were in- 
 timidated, and he of course acquiesced in everything. 
 We were careful to avoid every appearance of violence ; 
 and therefore, though the committee went to the 
 Nabob's palace in form, we had not a sepoy with us, 
 nor scarcely the usual retinue of chubdars and other 
 unarmed attendants ; so that everything passed without 
 noise, nor was a murmur heard without the Perdas of 
 the Zenana. You will easily perceive of how much 
 advantage this was to our credit ; and how the general 
 courts would have rung with declarations against our 
 perfidy, violation of justice, &c. &c. had we acted with 
 more eclat, or assumed but the appearance of violence. 
 I must observe that the Nabob has very near male re- 
 lations ; but they would most probably have employed 
 their authority, (had any such been invested with the 
 trust given to the Begum,) and the Nabob's wealth, in 
 getting into his place, as Mahommed Reza Cawn in 
 effect did, nor could we have been sure of so passive 
 an administration. 
 
 The appointment of Rajah Goordass was not so well 
 approved of. His father did us many ill offices in the 
 time of Mecr Jaftier ; and when I was in Bengal 
 before, I rejected every offer of reconciliation with him. 
 I still dislike him, although I countenance and employ 
 him. I had secret motives, in addition to those which 
 I have assigned, for the promotion of his son. I cannot
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 271 
 
 relate them ; but the latter are alone, in my judgment, 
 sufficient to justify my choice. The arguments which 
 were urged against the proposal have great, force. I 
 need not desire that no other person may see or know 
 that you have seen them. 
 
 I can add nothing to the reasons recorded in the 
 proceedings of the committee for the removal of the 
 seat of the collections to Calcutta. It has exceedingly 
 added to my labours ; but I have hitherto every reason 
 to be pleased with the change. The board of revenue 
 at Moorshedabad, though composed of the junior 
 servants of the Company, was superior, before this 
 alteration, to the Governor and Council of the presidency. 
 Calcutta is now the capital of Bengal, and every office 
 and trust of the province issues from it. 
 
 No. 3 contains the arrangement of the officers de- 
 pendant on the Khalsa, or Court of Revenue. It is 
 nearly the same with those formerly established at 
 Moorshedabad, but with much fewer offices and fewer 
 servants. The few innovations in point of form which 
 this court has received are such only as were necessary 
 to adapt it to the general system, and to give the 
 members of the Council that knowledge and control of 
 the business which might prevent its falling under 
 improper influence ; and the superintendence being 
 divided, and of short duration, is not so liable to be 
 abused. The officers are completely established, and 
 the business in as good a train as could possibly be 
 expected so soon after so great a revolution. We have 
 found it advisable also to form a new and distinct de- 
 partment for the business of the revenue, with a sepa- 
 rate council house, secretary, and offices ; and it is with 
 pleasure I can add, that this department is as regular 
 and as much on train as if it had existed since the days 
 of Job Channock. 
 
 No. 4 contains the establishment and regulations for
 
 272 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 the administration of justice. The only material 
 changes which we have made in the ancient constitu- 
 tion of the country are in dividing the jurisdiction in 
 civil and criminal cases by clearer lines than were 
 formerly drawn between them, and in removing the 
 supreme courts of justice to Calcutta. There are other 
 trivial innovations, which will appear in comparing the 
 ancient forms of judicature as they are described in the 
 letter to the Board with the regulations ; but the spirit 
 of the constitution we have preserved entire. Our 
 interfering in the courts of the Nizamut, or the criminal 
 courts, is an usurpation, but we could not avoid it. 
 Had we left them to the Nabob, they would have been 
 made the sources of venality and oppression, and our 
 collections would have been perpetually interrupted by 
 their officers. The collectors, zemindars, and farmers 
 would have been for ever quarrelling with their ministers 
 and disputing their authority. It would be endless to 
 enumerate all the evils which would have attended the 
 exercise of a power which could not support itself nor 
 enforce its own decrees, and subsisted only by the 
 sufferance of a power which was its rival. To avoid a 
 great evil, and that justice might have a footing by 
 hook or by crook in Bengal, we chose the less evil, and 
 took her under our own protection ; but, to obviate the 
 reproach of irregularity, we have recommended the 
 officers of the superior, or Nizamut Adawlat, to the 
 Nabob, and receive his sunnud for their appointment. 
 The completion of this work has been much retarded 
 by the multitude of agents to whom it has been en- 
 trusted, the old offices and forms which were to be 
 abolished to make way for it, and the thousand little 
 doubts and objections that started up with every step 
 that we made. It is at length nearly concluded. 
 
 We have been very unfortunate in the time which 
 we have chosen for our judicial improvements, for we
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 273 
 
 cannot undo what we have done ; and if the Lord Chief 
 Justice and his judges should come amongst us with 
 their institutes, the Lord have mercy upon us ! We 
 shall be in a complete state of confusion here, and we 
 shall be cruelly mauled at home, especially if the Parlia- 
 ment should lay hold on our code, for we have not a 
 lawyer among us. Necessity compelled us to form 
 some establishment of justice ; we chose the best we 
 could ; and if this shall not be found so perfect as more 
 time and more knowledge might have made it, it is 
 yet capable of receiving improvement, and is a good 
 foundation for a more complete system of judicature. 
 Is it not a contradiction of the common notions of 
 equity and policy that the English gentlemen of Cum- 
 berland and Argyleshire should regulate the polity of 
 a nation which they know only by the lacs which it has 
 sent to Great Britain, and by the reduction which it has 
 occasioned in their land-tax ? 
 
 No. 5 is an appendix to the last, and the last act of 
 the Board on that subject. 
 
 I neither desire nor expect that you will read these 
 folios now. If you can make them an amusement in 
 your voyage, as they are not totally devoid of ori- 
 ginality, it is all I can wish. You will perceive by 
 these papers, and by the constant tenor of my letters, 
 that I have made the revenue my principal object. It 
 has been my study, for indeed I had the whole science 
 to learn when I first engaged in it. I think I have not 
 laboured unsuccessfully, as I seldom find myself em- 
 barrassed by any point of it that comes before me ; my 
 next care shall be to divest it of the mystery and per- 
 plexity in which it is at present involved, and to make 
 it intellio-ible to the Court of Directors. The political 
 
 * 
 
 line which I have drawn for my conduct has a relation 
 to the good of the revenue peace. In this my inclina- 
 tions are happily and heartily seconded by those of the 
 VOL. I. T
 
 274 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 Board. I fear the cession of Cora to the Mahrattas 
 may compel us to a war ; but I am resolved it shall 
 not be begun on our part, if I can prevent it. A few 
 years of peace and quiet population will retrieve all the 
 losses which this country has sustained by the famine, 
 although that has swept off near one half of its in- 
 habitants. The decay of its trade, and the diminution 
 of its currency, require many years and a better regu- 
 lated government than this is to repair them. The 
 effects of these we at this time feel severely in some of 
 the northern districts, whose collections are at a 
 stand for want of purchasers for the grain which has 
 been produced this year everywhere in uncommon 
 abundance. 
 
 I will not trouble you longer. If you will tell me 
 that I have your permission, I wish to inform you from 
 time to time of the occurrences of this government, and 
 shall think myself obliged by a line from you with your 
 sentiments upon them. 
 
 I beg you will present my compliments to Mrs. 
 Dupre. I shall be glad if you can make me useful in 
 executing any commands which either she or yourself 
 may have here. May health and happiness attend 
 you. I am, with the sincerest esteem and affection, 
 dear Sir, &c. &c. 
 
 The following letter tells its own tale. It refers 
 to the proceedings of an adventurer at the Mogul 
 court, who endeavoured to raise himself into im- 
 portance by working on the credulity of the Asiatic 
 Emperor and the cupidity of the king's govern- 
 ment at home. He was destitute of the talent 
 necessary for playing such a game, and he soon 
 sank into insignificance.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 275 
 
 , To Sir GEORGE COLEBROOKE. 
 Fort William, 14th January, 1773, per Prince of Wales. 
 
 Sir, You will learn from our general letters, ancl 
 from our records in the secret department and select 
 committee, that Major John Morrison, late an officer 
 in the Company's service, who resigned his commission 
 in 177 , and obtained the permission of this govern- 
 ment to proceed by land to Europe, had accepted a 
 commission in the army of the King Shaw Allum, and 
 was since returned to Bengal in the character, whether 
 real or assumed, of ambassador from that prince to the 
 court of Great Britain. 
 
 On his arrival at Chinsurah he wrote me a letter 
 formally notifying his appointment, requiring of me to 
 let him know whether I would receive him in his public 
 character, and demanding a passage in one of the 
 Company's ships to England. I wrote him in reply, 
 with the advice of the select committee, that I would 
 neither receive him in his public character, nor allow 
 him a passage in any vessel belonging to this port. 
 My letter might have contained an unlimited acqui- 
 escence in his demands with equal effect, for it was re- 
 turned unopened, with a second letter from him ex- 
 plaining his reasons for this behaviour, which were, 
 that I had addressed him simply by the title of Major 
 John Morrison, instead of giving him the rank which 
 he bore by his present commission, or that of Captain, 
 which he held in the service of his Britannic Majesty, 
 and concluding with an apology regarding myself, 
 which is certainly no reparation of the insult offered to 
 me in my public character. These letters are copied 
 in our select committee proceedings. A translation of 
 the letter which he is said to bear from Shaw Allum is 
 entered on our consultations, and went in the last 
 packet. It is a production equally replete with the 
 
 T2
 
 276 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 basest treachery and ingratitude. Of all the powers of 
 Indostan, the English alone have really acknowledged 
 the King's authority ; they invested him with the royalty 
 he now possesses ; they conquered for him and gave him 
 a territory ; they paid him an annual tribute, the only 
 pledge of fealty which he has ever received, of twenty- 
 six lacs of rupees, (325,000 sterling,) while the trade 
 and revenue of their own provinces suffered a visible 
 decay by this diminution of their specie, and they were 
 compelled to pay a yearly interest of ten lacs for money 
 borrowed, to furnish their investment and defray the cur- 
 rent expenses of their government ; yet, because we sus- 
 pended the payment of this tribute, when the provinces 
 of Bengal and Bahar had lost nearly one half of their 
 inhabitants by the mortality of 1770, and the survivors 
 in many parts were unable to pay their rents by the 
 want of purchasers, and of money to purchase the pro- 
 duce of their harvests, and when he had made himself 
 an instrument of the Mahrattas who threatened the 
 dominions of our ally and our own with their devasta- 
 tions ; such was the infatuation of this ill-advised man, 
 that, regardless of all the bounties which he had re- 
 ceived from the only power which had ever treated 
 him with the least degree of kindness, he considered 
 himself as robbed of his right, and as a retribution to 
 his benefactors, or as a resource for his own wants, he 
 formed the project of making a tender of their pro- 
 perty to the King their sovereign, on the condition of 
 the like pecuniary homage as the Company has hitherto 
 paid him, and the little less expensive vassalage of 
 military service. With these insolent and incendiary 
 propositions is Major Morrison said to be charged, and 
 now preparing to embark for England. 
 
 At any other period such a project, and the authors 
 of it, would have been treated with contempt ; but I 
 confess I see so near a similitude between the offers of
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 277 
 
 the King and the claims of the ministers of our own 
 court on the government of Fort St. George, that I 
 could not. but be alarmed for the consequences with 
 which they might be attended, and I judged it of the 
 most essential importance to prevent Major Morrison, 
 if possible, from arriving in England before the Court 
 of Directors could be furnished with full intelligence of 
 his errand, and have had time to take the necessary 
 measures for obviating their effect. Understanding 
 that he had taken his passage in a Danish ship lately 
 bound for Europe, I applied to Mr. Bie, a gentleman 
 of the Superior Council of Tranquebar, deputed to re- 
 gulate the affairs of the Danish Company in Bengal, 
 and through his means obtained an order from the 
 factory of Fredericnagore forbidding his admission in 
 their vessel, and I promised to represent to the Court 
 of Directors this instance of the ready attention 
 shown by those gentlemen to the interests of our 
 Company. .1 herewith enclose you copies of Mr. Bie's 
 letters to me, with the correspondence of the Council 
 of Fredericnagore with Major Morrison, and my an- 
 swer. I do not think it necessary to take any further 
 steps in this business ; what I have done is sufficient 
 for the purpose which I intended. I neither wish to 
 detain him in India, nor indeed is it possible. He 
 continues at Chinsurah, and I am told, but by doubt- 
 ful authority, purposes to apply to Admiral Harland, 
 to be received on board one of the King's ships which 
 may return this year to England. 
 
 As I know not what construction may be put on this 
 detention of Major Morrison in England, I have taken 
 no notice of it on our proceedings, choosing rather to 
 hazard the consequences of it in my own person than, 
 by making it an act of government, involve the Com- 
 pany in trouble by my indiscretion. I leave it to you, 
 Sir, to lay this letter before the Court of Directors, if
 
 278 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 you think it contains any matter of consequence enough 
 to merit their attention, and that it may with propriety 
 be communicated to them, otherwise I beg it may rest 
 with yourself. I am, Sir, &c. 
 
 To Sir GEORGE COLEBROOKE. 
 Fort William, 15th January, 1773, per Prince of Wales. 
 
 Dear Sir, Our affairs have undergone little change 
 since my last. The King has sent a Vakeel to de- 
 mand the arrears of his tribute. It yet remains to be 
 decided whether we shall comply or not : I am deter- 
 mined against it. The General has given his opinion 
 in a minute, which is in our consultations, that we 
 ought to pay him ; he has supported this position with 
 such weak arguments, that I have let it rest for the 
 present unanswered. The subject must be brought 
 soon to a determination, and I believe he will stand 
 single in his opinion, as it can hardly be a dispute who 
 should have the preference, if the Company and the 
 King cannot both be served. 
 
 The Mahrattas and the King have quarrelled; the 
 former are now absolute masters of his person, and 
 they have obtained from him the cession of the Corah 
 country. The Vizier has turned this event, as usual, 
 to a subject of alarm, and written for all the forces of 
 Bengal to protect him against their apprehended in- 
 vasion. It does not appear to me that the affairs of 
 the Mahrattas are mended by this revolution, since 
 they have lost by it the sanction of the King's autho- 
 rity, if that ever afforded them any real service, and 
 considered as one party when united with him, the 
 possession of Corah has added nothing to their 
 strength, since it was theirs ; at least with respect to 
 us, it was the same when the King and they together 
 possessed it. 
 
 It is not yet resolved whether we shall oppose their
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 279 
 
 possessing themselves of the Corah province : I think 
 we have no good cause to interfere in it. Madebrow> 
 the Mahratta chief, is dead ; his brother, a youth of 
 nineteen, has succeeded him. It is natural to expect 
 some effects from this change; it is more likely to 
 breed distractions in that state than to strengthen it. 
 
 We have engaged lately in an expedition in the 
 country of Cooch Bahar, a province lying between 
 Rungpore and the mountains of Bootan, against the 
 Bootanners, who had possession of it. We have had 
 some success in it, and, to enforce the complete reduc- 
 tion of it, we have agreed to employ a whole battalion 
 on the service. I have no fear of the event: although 
 I shall ever oppose remote projects of conquest, yet I 
 shall sedulously promote every undertaking which can 
 complete the line of our own possessions, or add to its 
 security. 
 
 What I have written to you upon the subject of 
 Major Morrison will appear trifling, if his project 
 should not meet with a favourable reception from the 
 ministry. It appears to me a direct violation of the 
 laws, but he is said to have a warm patron in Lord 
 North, and the grant of the Dewannee of Bengal to 
 the Crown may be deemed a valid plea for dispossess- 
 ing the present proprietors of it. I hope the steps 
 which I have taken to discourage and impede it will 
 meet with your approbation, especially as I have taken 
 the most obnoxious part of it upon my own shoulders. 
 
 I shall send you by the last ship an estimate of the 
 loss sustained by the province of Bengal in its inhabit- 
 ants, by the late famine and mortality, taken from the 
 reports of the different collectors. If it answers no 
 better purpose, it will at least serve to answer for the 
 variations which have taken place, or may hereafter, in 
 the value of the revenue. I have great reliance on 
 the effects of the system which we have adopted, and
 
 280 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 still hope for an annual improvement both in the po- 
 pulation and wealth of the country. Its greatest dis- 
 tempers are the want of specie and the decay of trade. 
 
 I have taken much pains to investigate the conduct 
 of Bajah Shitabroy : I can discover no defect in it : he 
 has shown himself an able financier. This inquiry will 
 be brought to a conclusion, I believe, this next week. 
 There are points of dangerous consequence to the re- 
 putation of your government, since it is not possible to 
 steer clear of the imputation of injustice on one side, 
 or bribery on the other. I hope the character which I 
 have studied to establish in the course of above twenty 
 years' service will exempt me from the suspicion of 
 either, for truths cannot possibly be obtained either to 
 convict or acquit me. 
 
 Mahommed Reza Cawn's trial is still suspended. He 
 has many friends ; it is difficult to collect materials in 
 support of the charge against him. I verily believe him 
 culpable, and some of the charges I think I can clearly 
 establish, but I want both time and assistants for such 
 a work. I am resolved, however, to bring it on before 
 the last despatch, and hope to make such a progress 
 in it as may afford some lights into the probable issue 
 of it : do not impute these delays to my inattention ; 
 my whole time and all my thoughts, I may add all my 
 passions, are devoted to the service of the Company ; 
 and I am sure I do not labour in vain. But you cannot 
 form a conception of the infinite calls which I have 
 perpetually upon me, by the greatest charge which has 
 devolved to this government, every part of which is 
 now full, and the channels through which the business 
 of it should flow scarcely opened for its conveyance. 
 
 I am happy to find all my hopes answered in the 
 success of the revenue branch ; on this I have bent my 
 first attention, and it shall be my endeavour to reduce 
 it to so simple a state, as to make it equally intelligible
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 281 
 
 to the Court of Directors with the most ordinary affairs 
 of their government that they may be enabled to 
 judge with certainty of the diligence and ability by 
 which it shall be at any time conducted. I am, &c. 
 
 To Sir GEOKGE COLEBROOKE. 
 Fort "William, 2nd February, 177.3, per Duke of Graham. 
 
 Dear Sir, It was yesterday determined in Council 
 to undertake the defence of the Corah province against 
 the Mahrattas, who, as I mentioned in my last, had 
 extorted a grant of it from the King. It is within the 
 defensive line marked out by the Court of Directors, 
 and I hope the resolution will meet your approbation. 
 I, for my own part, wish it could with honour and 
 safety have been avoided. 
 
 The reduction of the Nabob's expenses is at length 
 completed, and the annual amount of his establishment 
 fixed at 15,45,689 ; 8 rupees, which is something, as you 
 will perceive, within his income. It was difficult, and 
 I own a painful work, to bring it thus low. I have 
 taken every precaution that it may not be exceeded, 
 and I think I can depend on the Begum and her 
 Dewan that it shall not. The Nabob will suffer no- 
 thing by this reduction : he will maintain a greater 
 state, without a competitor, than when thirty-two lacs 
 were paid to M. R. C. for his use. The reduction of 
 his stipend takes place from the month of January, 
 1772, the time when the orders of the Company were 
 signified to him by my predecessor, although they were 
 never understood by him to be so peremptory; and 
 his expenses were suffered to run on at the same rate 
 of twenty-seven lacs a-year till the month of July, 
 when I was with the Committee at Cossimbuzar; so 
 that the Company's orders, though suspended, have 
 lost no time in their effect. 
 
 Major Morrison is gone, as I hear, in a Dutch ship;
 
 282 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 the Government of Chinchura having on this occasion 
 broken through the rule of their service, which forbids 
 the admission of foreigners as passengers on their 
 vessels to Europe. 
 
 You will hear of great disturbances committed by 
 the Sinassies, or wandering Fackeers, who annually 
 infest the province about this time of the year, in pil- 
 grimages to Jaggernaut, going in bodies of 1,000, and 
 sometimes even 10,000 men. An officer of reputation 
 (Captain Thomas) lost his life in an unequal attack 
 upon a party of these banditti, about 3,000 of them, 
 near Rungpore, with a small party of Pergana sepoys, 
 which has made them more talked of than they de- 
 serve. The revenue, however, has felt the effects of 
 their ravages in the northern districts. The new esta- 
 blishment of sepoys which is now forming on the plan 
 enjoined by the Court of Directors, and the distribution 
 of them ordered for the internal protection of the pro- 
 vinces, will, I hope, effectually secure them hereafter 
 from these incursions. 
 
 So little space has elapsed since my last, and the 
 Rockingham will so soon follow, that I content myself 
 with this miscellaneous detail of facts for the present, 
 and to assure you that I am ever, dear Sir, &c. 
 
 To Mr. SVKES. 
 Fort William, 2nd March, 1773, per Rockingham. 
 
 My dear Sykes, My last was dated the 10th De- 
 cember, and went by the Greenwich. Since that date 
 the Mahrattas have quarrelled with the King, beat him, 
 and made him give them a sunnud for the Corah pro- 
 vince, which, it is said, they are now preparing to take 
 possession of. The S. brigade has orders to enter it 
 first, and oppose them. The general is returned to 
 the army, with orders to defend that country for the 
 King, and Oude for the Vizier, but not to pass the
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 283 
 
 Hinds of either. I think the Mahrattas will not give 
 is any trouble. They are much reduced in number, 
 and sick of a long campaign. Their chief Mahdebrow 
 is dead, and succeeded by Narain Row his brother, a 
 youth of nineteen. 
 
 The settlement of Bengal is at length completed ; 
 Chittagong excepted, and the committee expected in 
 another week. 
 
 We have entered on the inquiry of Rajah Shitabroy, 
 who will escape with credit. Indeed, I scarce know 
 why he was called to an account. 
 
 We have at length begun that also of Mohammed 
 Reza Cawn. The charges against him consist of the 
 following articles : the monopoly of rice in the time 
 of the famine ; the embezzlement of the money of the 
 Nizamut ; a heavy balance unaccounted from him as 
 renter of Dacca at old Jaffier's death ; and a treacherous 
 correspondence with the King and Mahrattas. This 
 last is a new and accidental charge. 
 
 That of the rice is begun ; God knows when the in- 
 quiries will all end : he has great friends. I shall 
 proceed with strict impartiality, without friendship or 
 enmity towards him. In one point only I am against 
 him. I will never suffer him, if I can help it, to regain 
 his power. The Directors are mad if they do ; for the 
 government of the provinces is now entirely at their 
 disposal, without a competitor for the smallest share of 
 their authority. 
 
 These retrospections and examinations are death to 
 my views, as I have not an hour to spare from the 
 business of the day, even if they did not interfere with 
 it. And I fear the Court of Directors will be much dis- 
 pleased that their expectations are not fulfilled in other 
 matters of the like nature. I will take them all in 
 their turn, but no good will be got by them ; they breed 
 dissensions, and they retard the course of real business.
 
 284 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 Justify me, my friend, if you hear me blamed for not 
 doing more than I can do. Let them look at our pro- 
 ceedings, and see what has been done. We have fixed 
 councils for four days in the week, and we have often 
 had six. I have not missed three since I have been in 
 the country, and every moment of my time besides is 
 devoted to the more immediate duties of my station, 
 Sundays excepted, and sometimes Saturdays, which I 
 pass in the country, and generally as much involved in 
 papers there as in town. 
 
 Let me recapitulate the principal points which have 
 taken place : 1. The reduction of the Nabob's stipend 
 from thirty-two lacs to sixteen, ordered in December, 
 1771, two months before I arrived m the country, and exe- 
 cuted in July, 1772,'without any loss from so long a sus- 
 pension. 2. The reduction of the expenses from about 
 29 lacs to 15-2 yearly, and fixed at that sum. 3. The 
 removal of Mahommed Reza Cawn from the Neabut 
 and Dewanny. 4. The establishment of the Nabob's 
 household, the appointment of the Munny Begum to 
 the management, and Goordass to the Dewanny of the 
 Nizamet. 5. The plan and execution of a new settle- 
 ment of the lands on leases of five years. 6. The 
 plan and establishment of the new courts of justice, 
 consisting of two superior courts at Calcutta; the one 
 for the causes of property appealed, the other for cri- 
 minal cases : and similar dependent courts in every 
 district. 7. The removal of the Calsa from Moorshe- 
 dabad to Calcutta, the institution of a new council 
 of revenue, and many other dependent arrangements. 
 8. A reformation of expenses, and an inspection into 
 all the offices of Government, begun, but not completed 
 for want of time. 9. Improvements in the police of 
 Calcutta. 10. Changes in the military establishment, 
 and regulations for the internal defence of the country. 
 These are all I now recollect of the general regulations.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 285 
 
 Hhers of inferior concern, and the multitude of auxiliary 
 institutions required to give effect to the great ones, I 
 cannot enumerate. I will only add that by the trans- 
 lation of the Calsa to Calcutta, by the exercise of the 
 Dewanny without an intermediate agent, by the present 
 establishment and superintendency of tho Nabob's 
 household, and by the establishment of the new courts 
 of justice, under the control of our own government, 
 the authority of the Company is fixed in this country 
 without any possibility of a competition, and beyond 
 the power of any but themselves to shake it. The 
 Nabob is a mere name, and the seat of government 
 most effectually and visibly transferred from Moorshe- 
 dabad to Calcutta, which I do not despair of seeing 
 the first city in Asia, if I live and am supported but a 
 few years longer. At the same time, the suspension of 
 the King's tribute, (which was a fatal drain to the cur- 
 rency of this country,) the stoppage of Mahommed Reza 
 Cawn's, and Shitabroy's, allowances, and the reduction 
 of the Nabob's stipend, amount alone to an annual 
 saving of fifty-seven lacs of rupees ; and whenever we 
 shall have our official reforms, now under charge of the 
 council of inspection, I make no doubt that a con- 
 siderable retrenchment (which has already in part taken 
 place) will be still effected. 
 
 On the other hand, the collections have suffered, 
 though not greatly, by the effects of the famine, to 
 which we have had additional cause this year in the 
 northern districts by the irruption of the Senassies. 
 But these have been so speedily and vigorously 
 checked, that they have been obliged to quit the 
 country without doing much mischief. I am not with- 
 out my fears of suffering by want of personal interest 
 at home, of being sacrificed in a party accommodation, 
 or condemned from the false suggestions of private 
 letter writers. I have no time to write. If I had, I
 
 280 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 can neither submit to the villainy of attacking cha- 
 racters in the dark, nor defending my own from assaults 
 which I cannot see. Every individual in this settle- 
 ment has the advantage of me in this respect, if he 
 chooses to avail himself of it. When I look back on 
 what I have done, I sometimes exult in the thought of 
 having merited the applause of my employers. I 
 oftener dread censure from misrepresentation, from 
 misconstructions, from the disappointment of the ex- 
 pectations of the Court of Directors on points of trivial 
 consequence, or impracticable in the execution, and 
 more from their inability to read and inform them- 
 selves properly of what has been done. 
 
 [In confidence let me add, that if I was to lose my 
 government to-day, I should leave it a poorer man 
 than when I assumed it.] 
 
 Some addition I made to my fortune at Madras, if I 
 recover all I left behind me there. There I had some 
 leisure to attend to my own affairs, and you will stare 
 when I tell you that my books were balanced to the 
 month preceding my departure, and my cash account 
 closed to the very day of it. Adieu, my dear friend. 
 
 To Sir GEORGE COLEBROOKE. 
 
 Fort William, 3rd March, 1773. 
 
 Dear Sir, Nothing material has happened since the 
 departure of the Duke of Graf ton. I hope the reso- 
 lution lately formed for the defence of Cora will be 
 approved. It was formed (as you will see) on a para- 
 graph of a general letter written on an occasion so 
 exactly parallel to that before us, that we could not act 
 otherwise. I do not apprehend that it will draw us 
 into difficulties, and I am sure everything has been 
 done, that could be done, to prevent its loading us with 
 an expense. 
 
 Being much more solicitous about what remains un-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 287 
 
 done, than for the effect of measures already taken, I 
 take the freedom to send you enclosed a minute which 
 is just prepared to be laid before the Board containing 
 a new scheme of regulations for levying the public 
 customs. It was drawn up under my directions by 
 Mr. Lushington, a young man of abilities, and versed 
 in the subject, having been some time a comptroller of 
 one branch of the Customs, the Buxbunder. The 
 plan is simple, and if it passes, (for it has not yet been 
 communicated to any of the members of council,) .1 
 think it will bid fair to restore the trade of the pro- 
 vince the most rational way of increasing the 
 amount of the Customs that any I know of. 
 
 It has already been advertised that the dustucks are 
 to cease after the 1 2th of April next. 
 
 I hope, before the close of the Hector's packet, to set 
 on foot a plan for the provision of the investment, con- 
 formable to the principles laid down by the Court of 
 Directors, and to free the weavers (if possible) from 
 that state of vassalage to which they are now subjected, 
 and which, I am sorry to say, falls with heavier oppres- 
 sion on the Company's weavers than any other. The 
 design is liable to difficulty, and the investments will 
 become dearer, apparently very much dearer, for it. I 
 say apparently, because I am assured that the cloths 
 are so greatly under-rated, that a great part of the 
 advances are lost in irrecoverable balances, so that a 
 piece of cloth which is invoiced at six rupees, in effect 
 costs eight, the difference remaining on account, but 
 never to be realized. Something must be done, and 
 heartily supported, for the trade of this country is be- 
 yond decay; it is utterly gone. I much fear that the 
 superior advantages possessed by the collectors, ex- 
 cluding all competition, are among the first causes of 
 it. 
 
 The inquiry into the conduct of Rajah Shitabroy is
 
 288 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 not yet finished. By the assistance of Mr. Vansittart, 
 who has lately taken his seat at the Board, I hope to 
 conclude it soon, as he is intimately acquainted with 
 the subjects with which Shitabroy is charged. 
 
 The examination into the charges alleged against 
 M. R. Cawn has at length taken place. Some days 
 have been consumed in taking depositions concerning 
 the purchase and sale of rice during the famine, by his 
 order. Much time must elapse before we can close 
 this part of his inquiry. The other articles relate 
 merely to accounts. These trials are a grievous im- 
 pediment to public business, of which I have already 
 felt the effects, and do now most sensibly in the close 
 of this packet, which was fixed for the first of the 
 month, and the fourth is now almost past. I fear, too, 
 our general letter will appear but imperfect from the 
 precipitate manner in which we have been obliged to 
 form it. 
 
 The committee appointed to make the circuit of 
 Bengal have finished their tour, and are daily expected. 
 The Mahrattas have not yet made any decisive ad- 
 vances. They are weak, and seem irresolute. The 
 general was at Patna the 25th of last month, and is by 
 this time with the army. I am, dear Sir, yours, &c. 
 
 P. S. Captain Hamilton has been so obliging as to 
 take charge of two deer, a male and female, of a species 
 which is called neel-gow, and is, I believe, unknown in 
 Europe, which he will deliver to you in my name. I 
 request your acceptance of them. They are a hardy 
 animal, and will, I dare say, find themselves as happy 
 in the lawns of Gatton, as they were in their native 
 mountains of Napaul. 
 
 To Sir GEORGE COLEBKOOKE. 
 
 Fort William, 7th March, 1773. 
 
 Dear Sir, I have often lamented that the connexion 
 between us hath hitherto subsisted on no firmer ground
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 289 
 
 than an intercourse of official communication. I feel 
 a diffidence in expressing my thoughts upon many 
 subjects of a confidential nature, because I am not yet 
 sufficiently acquainted with your sentiments towards 
 me, to judge how far these may entitle me to your 
 support in cases which reach beyond the ordinary line 
 of the Company's service. A sense of the obligations 
 which I owe you, and which I can never repay, is an 
 insurmountable bar to my seeking to add to them by 
 soliciting personal favours, and even restrains me from 
 proposing measures of public advantage, by which my 
 own interest may be virtually promoted, or my ambi- 
 tion gratified. These considerations alone have pre- 
 vented my addressing you much earlier upon a subject 
 in which I conceive the interests of the Company to be 
 very essentially concerned, and which I have now de- 
 termined to submit to your consideration, although 
 the tendency of it may expose me to the suspicion of 
 seeking my own advantage under colour of the public 
 service. I hope that the constant tenor of my conduct 
 in the course of a very long service will exempt me 
 from such imputations ; but whatever my motives may 
 be supposed, your judgment in the decision can have 
 no improper bias. You may acquire an increase of 
 reputation by the success of such measures as you shall 
 pursue, but I do not sec how it is possible for you to be 
 a gainer by them, if they are such as may bring a re- 
 proach upon your administration. 
 
 The want of clear and distinct lines to mark the dif- 
 ferent parts of which the Government of Bengal is 
 composed is the greatest of the many defects which clog 
 this establishment. 
 
 By the constitution of the Company, the Council at 
 large have the supreme authority in all matters which 
 either come in the course of office before their notice, 
 or of which they choose to take cognizance ; but as their 
 
 VOL. I. U
 
 290 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 power exists only while they sit in a body, so much of 
 it is delegated to the governor, their president, as is 
 supposed to be necessary for giving a continual cur- 
 rency to business, or for executing such of their 
 functions as do not appertain to any distinct office of 
 government. It is not easy to determine what points 
 fall under this description. In effect, the governor is 
 no more than any other individual of the Council, if the 
 others choose to partake of his authority, although the 
 responsibility of affairs seems to rest with him only. 
 An opinion that he possesses something more, and a 
 superior share of diligence or ability, may give him an 
 influence in the administration which he wants consti- 
 tutionally ; but in the latter he may be exceeded by 
 others, and the former must vanish the instant it is put 
 to the test; and whenever these cases happen, the 
 government, for want of a power to preside and rule it, 
 must fall into anarchy. 
 
 These indeed are the inevitable consequences of the 
 ancient form of government, which was instituted for 
 the provision of the investment, the sale of the Com- 
 pany's exported cargoes, and the despatch of their ships, 
 being applied to the dominion of an extensive king- 
 dom, the collection of a vast revenue, the command of 
 armies, and the direction of a great political system, 
 besides the additional charge devolved to their com- 
 mercial department by its relation to the general trade 
 of the country, and its effect on the public re'venue. 
 
 A system of affairs so new, requires a new system of 
 government to conduct it. The variety and impor- 
 tance of the objects which depend upon it, require 
 consistency, steadiness, and despatch, qualities incom- 
 patible with a body of men. 
 
 To remedy these defects in our constitution, the 
 select committee has been appointed with powers to 
 conduct the detail, or dependent operations of the
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 291 
 
 political and military lines, without an immediate 
 communication with the Council. But as the move- 
 ments of the army, and every determination immediately 
 respecting peace or war, depend solely on the Coun- 
 cil at large, the powers of the select committee are 
 confined to so narrow a compass, that in effect they 
 are next to nothing, and only serve to embarrass and 
 multiply business. If you will give yourself the 
 trouble to turn over the proceedings of this committee 
 since I have been a member of it, you will find that 
 not one event or measure of consequence is recorded in 
 them, which was not communicated to the board for 
 their decision upon it. I do not know whether you 
 are acquainted with it, but it was originally owing to 
 the Council not being consulted on the arrangements 
 which brought on the resignation of Mcer Jaffier, and 
 the subsequent, elevation of Meer Cossim, that the 
 opposition first took rise against Mr. Vansittart ; and 
 it soon found materials to work with, as the change of 
 Government introduced by Mr. Vansittart and his 
 committee, though so far successful, required daily and 
 perpetual measures to support it, which depended en- 
 tirely on the will of the Board, who showed their aver- 
 sion to it by such effectual means, and in a manner so 
 notorious, that it at last ended in another revolution. 
 
 Little more need be said to show the necessity of 
 distinguishing the powers of the Council, the select 
 committee, and the governor, and of substituting to 
 the nominal authority of the latter, such a degree of 
 actual control as may enable him to support with cre- 
 dit the character of the ostensible head of Government, 
 to give vigour to its decrees, and preserve them from 
 inconsistencies. 
 
 For this purpose I have formed the three following 
 propositions, which, without further preface, I refer to 
 your consideration, only requesting that if you do not 
 
 u 2
 
 292 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 approve of them, you will not divulge them, for obvi- 
 ous reasons. 
 
 1. The select committee shall have the power of 
 making peace or war, and of determining all measures 
 respecting both, independent of the Council at large. 
 But they shall enter into no treaty of alliance, whether 
 offensive or defensive for a longer duration than two 
 years, without a special authority from the Honourable 
 the Court of Directors. Every such treaty shall be 
 communicated to the Council at large, as soon as it 
 conveniently may be, that their opinion upon it may 
 be transmitted with it to the Court of Directors. 
 
 2. It shall nevertheless be allowable for the presi- 
 dent to bring any matter before the Council at large, 
 although included within the above limitations, and 
 the decision of the Council thereon shall be valid and 
 binding on the select committee. But no other mem- 
 ber of the committee shall be allowed the same privi- 
 lege. 
 
 3. The president shall have the privilege of acting 
 by his own separate authority on such urgent and ex- 
 traordinary cases as shall in his judgment require it, 
 notwithstanding any decision of the Council or the 
 select committee passed thereon. On every such 
 occasion the president shall record his resolution to 
 act in the manner above specified in virtue of the 
 power thus vested in him, and shall expressly declare 
 that he charges himself with the whole responsibility. 
 
 These, Sir, are the outlines of the plan of govern- 
 ment which I presume to recommend. Many inferior 
 and subsidiary regulations might be added, but these 
 I would rather leave to your better judgment. One re- 
 mark permit me to make, that a total change has 
 been lately effected in the government of this province, 
 in the mode of administering justice, and in the col- 
 lection of the revenue.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 293 
 
 Every intermediate po\ver is removed, and the 
 sovereignty of this country wholly and absolutely 
 vested in the Company. If these innovations are ap- 
 proved, 1 shall be entitled, as the instrument by which 
 they were produced, to all the support which the Court 
 of Directors can give me. No man can have an equal 
 interest in the success of any new system with the 
 author of it. Leave it at large to a variable body of 
 men, or to the quick succession of single managers, it 
 will soon lose its original principles, and fall into 
 decay. I am, with the sincerest esteem and regard, 
 dear Sir, &c. 
 
 To JOHN PURLING, Esq. 
 
 per Hector, 31st March, 1773. 
 
 Dear Sir, The close attention I pay to the affairs 
 of this government, disqualifies me for the business of 
 a private correspondence. My inclination is good, but 
 the want of leisure on these occasions is an insupe- 
 rable obstacle ; it is unnecessary, however, to expatiate 
 on it, as I cannot but flatter myself, you have already 
 placed my long silence to its proper cause. Indeed I 
 have considered myself, since my accession to this 
 government, as corresponding with every member of 
 the direction in every general letter addressed to them, 
 as I have not a thought on the affairs of the Company 
 worth communicating which is not inserted within. 
 
 2. My last address to you was on the llth of No- 
 vember, 1772, in which I acknowledged the receipt of 
 your favour of the 25th March, and referred you to 
 the letters from our public departments for such infor- 
 mation as you would wish to arrive at relative to our 
 transactions here; pointing out, and recommending, 
 such facts for your serious consideration, as I thought 
 best deserved it. You will find we have not been 
 idle, and I hope will be able to discover that our 
 aims have been confined to such points as tend
 
 294 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 most essentially to the interest and honour of the 
 Company, and particularly to the improvement of the 
 revenue. 
 
 3. Next to the revenue, the object of my consider- 
 ation has been the security of these provinces from the 
 calamities of war, and notwithstanding the most press- 
 ing importunity of the Vizier, positive orders have been 
 given to General Barker, who is now with the army, 
 to act on the defensive only. How far the necessity 
 of untoward circumstances may disappoint my hopes 
 on that score, I dare not pretend to determine, for 
 the affairs of the Empire in that quarter are in a state 
 of the utmost confusion. The Mahrattas have quar- 
 relled with the King, and have extorted from him the 
 grant of his dominions. Of the provinces of Cora and 
 Allahabad they have declared their intention of taking 
 possession, and we have already taken possession; 
 they are so weak, and we have so powerful a force at 
 hand to oppose them, that I fear no danger in the 
 issue of the campaign. 
 
 4. We have lately been much troubled here with 
 herds of desperate adventurers called Senassies, who 
 have over-run the province in great numbers, and 
 committed great depredations. The particulars of 
 these disturbances, and of our endeavours to repel 
 them, you will find in our general letters and consul- 
 tations, which will acquit the government of any de- 
 gree of blame from such a calamity. At this time we 
 have five battalions of sepoys in pursuit of them, and I 
 have still hopes of exacting ample vengeance for the 
 mischief they have done us, as they have no advantage 
 over us, but in the speed with which they fly from us. A 
 minute relation of these adventurers cannot amuse you, 
 nor indeed are they of great moment ; for which reason 
 give me leave to drop this subject and lead you to one 
 in which you cannot but be more interested, as it fur-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 295 
 
 nishes me with an occasion of saying some things which 
 are as much to the reputation of your nephew as they 
 are likely to prove advantageous to the Company. 
 
 5. The reduction of the Cooch Bahar province has 
 proved a more arduous undertaking than we at first 
 imagined. The inhabitants of Boutan, who were 
 in possession of it, are a resolute and daring people. 
 They made a desperate defence of the fort of Bahar, 
 which Captain Jones stormed, and took, with the loss 
 of nearly one fourth of his detachment killed and 
 wounded; himself and another officer being of the 
 latter number; and since that time they attacked a 
 small detachment under the command of Lieutenant 
 Dickson, in the middle of the night, with desperate 
 resolution, many of them meeting death at the muzzle 
 of the sepoys' pieces : but not it seems, with great 
 judgment, for although their number exceeded 3000, 
 and Lieutenant Dickson's detachment only consisted 
 of 226 rank and file, they were beat off with great loss, 
 as soon as daylight appeared. On this occasion your 
 nephew, who was there, had his full share of the danger 
 and honour of the field. This knowledge I received 
 in a letter from Lieutenant Dickson, who had bestowed 
 on Mr. Purling the highest commendations, and I be- 
 lieve truly deserved. I have taken care that Lieutenant 
 Dickson's letters on this subject may be known to the 
 Court of Directors, and in confidence I tell you my 
 principal view (though there are other obvious reasons 
 for it) was the desire I had of making generally known 
 a conduct and behaviour so much to the credit of my 
 young friend Purling. 
 
 6. If the reduction of Cooch Bahar is likely to be 
 effected with more difficulty than was imagined, I must 
 at the same time remark, that it proves to be a far 
 more valuable acquisition than we expected, being in 
 fertility and abundance equal to any district of the
 
 296 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 same dimensions in Bengal. As we have capable 
 officers there, and they will shortly be reinforced by 
 another battalion, I make no doubt but they will be 
 able to take entire possession of the Cooch Bahar 
 country, and to secure it to the Company, by station- 
 ing small garrisons at proper posts, during the rains. 
 Indeed there is every reason to suppose the Boutans 
 would be glad to come into our terms, in order to 
 secure a communication for their merchandise into 
 Bengal by the passes through the Cooch Bahar 
 province, which are the only inlets from the country. 
 I think also that there is not a doubt, but that the 
 revenue produced by this acquisition to the country 
 will do much more than support the expense of keep- 
 ing a small military force there, to secure the posses- 
 sion of it. 
 
 Having communicated everything you can think 
 material, let me present you my best wishes for your 
 welfare, and assure you of my being, with a sincere 
 esteem, dear Sir, &c. 
 
 To Sir GEORGE COLEBROOKE. 
 
 per Hector, 31st March, 1773. 
 
 Dear Sir, In my last I mentioned that we had 
 every reason to suppose the Senassie Fakiers had 
 entirely evacuated the Company's possessions. Such 
 were the advices I then received, and their usual 
 progress made this highly probable ; but it seems they 
 were either disappointed in crossing the Burramputrah 
 river, or they changed their intention, and returned in 
 several bands of about 2000 or 3000 each ; appearing 
 unexpectedly in different parts of the Rungpoor and 
 Dinagepoor provinces. For in spite of the strictest 
 orders issued and the severest penalties threatened to 
 the inhabitants, in case they fail in giving intelligence 
 of the approach of the Senassies, they are so infatuated
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 297 
 
 by superstition, as to be backward in giving the infor- 
 mation, so that the banditti are sometimes advanced 
 into the very heart of our provinces, before we know 
 anything of their motions ; as if they dropt from 
 heaven to punish the inhabitants for their folly. One 
 of these parties falling in with a small detachment 
 commanded by Captain Edwards, an engagement 
 ensued, wherein our sepoys gave way, and Captain 
 Edwards lost his life in endeavouring to cross a 
 nullah. This detachment was formed of the very 
 worst of our Purgunnah sepoys, who seem to have be- 
 haved very ill. This success elated the Senassies, and 
 I heard of their depredations from every quarter in 
 those districts. Captain Stuart, with the 19th batta- 
 lion of sepoys, who was before employed against them, 
 was vigilant in the pursuit, wherever he could hear of 
 them, but to no purpose ; they were gone before he 
 could reach the places to which he was directed. I 
 ordered another battalion from Burrampore to march 
 immediately, to co-operate with Captain Stuart, but 
 to act separately ; in order to have the better chance 
 of falling in with them. At the same time I ordered 
 another battalion to march from the Dinapoor station, 
 through Tyroot, and by the northern frontier of the 
 Purneah province, following the track which the Senas- 
 sies usually took, in order to intercept them, in case 
 they marched that way. This battalion, after acting 
 against the Senassies, if occasion offered, was directed 
 to pursue their march to Cooch Bahar, where they are 
 (o join Captain Jones, and assist in the reduction of 
 that country. 
 
 Several parties of the Senassies having entered into 
 the Purneah province, burning and destroying many 
 villages there, the collector applied to Captain Brooke, 
 who was just arrived at Panity, near Rajahmahl with 
 his new- raised battalion of light infantry. That
 
 298 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 officer immediately crossed the river, and entered upon 
 measures against the Senassies ; and had very near 
 fallen in with a party of them, just as they were crossing 
 the Cosa river, to escape out of that province ; he 
 arrived on the opposite bank before their rear had en- 
 tirely crossed ; but too late to do any execution among 
 them. 
 
 It is apparent now that the Senassies are glad to 
 escape as fast as they can out of the Company's pos- 
 sessions; but I am still in hopes that some of the 
 many detachments now acting against them may fall 
 in with some of their parties, and punish them ex- 
 emplarily for their audacity. 
 
 It is impossible, but that, on account of the various 
 depredations which the Senassies have committed, the 
 revenue must fall short in some of the Company's 
 districts; as well from real as from pretended losses. 
 The Board of Revenue, aware of this last considera- 
 tion, have come to the resolution of admitting no 
 pleas for a reduction of revenue, but such as are 
 attended with circumstances of conviction, and by this 
 means they hope to prevent, as much as in their power, 
 all impositions on the Government, and to render the 
 loss to the Company as inconsiderable as possible.* 
 Effectual means will be used, by stationing some small 
 detachments at proper posts on our frontier, to prevent 
 any future incursions from the Senassie Fakicrs, or any 
 other roving banditti ; a measure, which only the ex- 
 traordinary audacity of their last incursions hath 
 manifested to be necessary. This will be effected 
 without employing many troops ; and I hope, that in 
 no future time the revenues shall again suffer from 
 this cause. 
 
 * You will not find this resolution in our Records. I venture to mention 
 it as my own, and that of the other members in private communication with 
 each other.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 299 
 
 To JOSIAS DUPRE, Esq. 
 Fort William, 9th March, 1773, per Hector. 
 
 Dear Sir, Nothing could be more welcome to me 
 than your letters of the 30th of January and 1st of 
 February. I had received intelligence two days before 
 of your departure, and my conscience had begun to 
 whisper to me that my omissions had drawn upon me 
 the disappointment of not hearing from you then as a 
 just retaliation. I am fortunate that you received my 
 packet, on which I impatiently wait for your opinion. 
 It may decide my fortune possibly before you can 
 arrive in England. 
 
 I had before heard of the vexatious contests in 
 which you had been engaged some time before your 
 departure. You have concluded them most triumph- 
 antly, and it is with pleasure I can inform you that 
 every person whom I have heard speak of these trans- 
 actions, and every letter that has related them, do 
 justice to your conduct, and severely condemn that of 
 your opponents. I am sorry to have been so much 
 deceived in Mackay. It is impossible to devise an 
 extenuation of his behaviour. Sir Robert's as yet ap- 
 pears only ridiculous, for I know of no particulars of it 
 besides his unfortunate plea of parliamentary duty, 
 although I cannot help feeling my share of the injury 
 offered you by the daily opposition which I am told he 
 raised against you at the Board, for you may remem- 
 ber, and I am now sorry for it, how warmly I was his 
 advocate with you when Wood stood between him and 
 the succession, which I should never have been but 
 from the very high opinion in which I held his military 
 talents, and the solemn assurances which he gave me 
 that he would ever exert himself in the hearty support 
 of your government. I wish to hear from Macpherson. 
 I have ever believed him to be the man you report 
 him. I have very little personal interest in England,
 
 300 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 but the little I Lave I will heartily employ in seconding 
 his pretensions,, and shall rejoice to see him here. This 
 service wants men of abilities, who have no pretensions 
 to desert it, for every man capable of business runs 
 away to the collectorships, or other lucrative sta- 
 tions where I fear their talents are perniciously applied 
 more to the improvement of their own fortunes than 
 the Company's benefit. At the presidency, where the 
 best assistance is required, the worst only can be had ; 
 the Company being as rigid about visible salaries and 
 emoluments here as at Fort St. George, and as in- 
 different about perquisites, though the former are but 
 pittances and the latter amount to lacs. I have already 
 written to Sir George Colebrooke, and as much as I could 
 write in favour of Macpherson. I shall obey your instruc- 
 tions with respect to Captain Weller's Bond. Aldersey 
 merits so much from me, that I can want no additional 
 inducement to cherish his friendship ; he has always 
 shown himself most cordially my friend, supported me 
 like a man, and is much more the man of business 
 than many who pass for more brilliant understandings, 
 which I have often had the disappointment to find 
 mere surfaces. 
 
 I am happy in the assurances which you give me of 
 your friendship, and thankful for the promise of your 
 support. My own heart tells me that I have a just 
 claim to the former, and I shall endeavour by every 
 means to maintain my claim to it until I am so for- 
 tunate as to meet you in England. I know not 
 whether my pride is not as much interested as my for- 
 tune in the opinion which you may entertain of my 
 conduct. I shall contrive from time to time to submit 
 it to you, and shall be obliged to you for your advice 
 and unreserved sentiments upon it. 
 
 I have already entered more than one caveat against 
 the too rigid censures of our honourable masters, by
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 301 
 
 declaring upon record that it was necessary we should 
 err ; the importance of despatch when we are crowded 
 with more business than we can push through, making 
 it more eligible to resolve without debate, than to debate 
 without resolving, or, which is much the same, to give 
 so much time on the prudent accomplishment of one 
 measure, as to leave many others suspended. You 
 may therefore condemn me as freely as you please ; 
 allowing me this reserve, for it is ten to one that I join 
 with you in the sentence. 
 
 The greatest part of the preceding pages were 
 written to go by the Rockingham, but 1 was hindered 
 from concluding it in time, and kept it for the Hector's 
 packet, which will be the last of the season. I have 
 endeavoured to imitate the punctuality of the Madras 
 despatches, and have so far succeeded as to be 
 generally within two or three days of the day ap- 
 pointed, which, considering all things, is a great point 
 effected. 
 
 Since the date of this letter our Board has been re- 
 joined by the members who were absent on a circuit of 
 the province, and my friend, George Vansittart, has 
 been admitted into Council. This has brought an 
 addition of very capable hands, and I am happy to 
 add that, after various contests, disputes, protests, and 
 an almost open rupture, a perfect harmony and con- 
 fidence have at length taken place amongst us. With 
 our divisions you are already acquainted. They were 
 never conducted with asperity or ill temper, and by 
 proper explanations every source of dissent is, I think, 
 effectually removed. I am assured of a most cordial 
 support from my associates, and can venture to delegate 
 a share of the labours which I have hitherto under- 
 taken alone to others, without the same hazard of 
 sacrificing my own authority. There is, however, one 
 exception, but of no consequence. I hope I shall not
 
 301 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 experience another in the General, who is lately re- 
 turned to the army, and by an act of disobedience on 
 a subject almost too frivolous to be mentioned, has 
 drawn on him a public expression of the Board's dis- 
 pleasure. Captain Harper, an officer who had re- 
 sided some time at the Vizier's court, was ordered 
 to return to Bengal with the battalion which he com- 
 manded. The Vizier insisted rather too warmly on 
 his continuance, and the General urged it at the Board, 
 but without effect. Captain Harper was on his return 
 when the General set out for the army, and he has 
 taken him back with him. The Board have issued a 
 public order for his instant return, and forbidden every 
 officer of whatever rank to detain him, but avoided 
 cither a correspondence with the General on the occa- 
 sion, or to commit more of the affair to record than 
 was necessary, from professed motives of moderation, 
 as the affairs in which he is now engaged require a 
 good and confidential understanding between him and 
 the Board. It rests with him to let this little spring 
 run to a torrent, or stop its course at once by a silent 
 acquiescence. To prevent disagreements from mat- 
 ters of importance, his instructions were drawn out 
 with the greatest precision, and, I think, with great 
 perspicuity. 
 
 The King having ceded Corah to the Mahrattas, 
 we as his allies, and the original proprietors, resolved 
 to defend it; and the Vizier being alarmed for the 
 safety of his dominions, we resolved also on the defence 
 of them. In both these measures we are guarded by 
 express orders of the Company. On the north of the 
 Vizier lies a tract of country bounded by the Ganges 
 and the mountains of Tartary, governed by Hafiz 
 Rahmut Cawn, a Rohiila chief, who was defeated and 
 plundered by the Mahrattas the last year. 
 
 We empowered the Vizier to extend his operations
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 303 
 
 on that side of the river to this country (but not to 
 pass the river), whether Hafiz Rahmut should be our 
 ally, or join the Mahrattas against us. 
 
 We limited his operations in Corah to the line of 
 that province. He is to take present possession of it 
 for the Company, and to appropriate a lac of rupees 
 monthly from its collections to the charge of the 
 brigade. He is to require assignments for the stipu- 
 lated monthly payment of 115,000 rupees from the 
 Vizier, or to leave him. 
 
 The Mahrattas are weak, and, I believe, will under- 
 take nothing this season. If they do not, our army 
 will probably return to their own quarters in the 
 rains. 
 
 Our own provinces have worn something of a war- 
 like appearance this year, having been infested by 
 bands of Senassies, who have defeated two small par- 
 ties of Purgunnah sepoys (a rascally corps), and cut off 
 the two officers who commanded them. One was Cap- 
 tain Thomas, whom you knew. Four battalions of the 
 brigade sepoys are now in pursuit of them, but they 
 will not stand an engagement, and have neither camp 
 equipage, nor even clothes, to retard their flight. Yet 
 I hope we shall yet make an example of some of them, 
 as they are shut in by the rivers, which they cannot 
 pass when closely pursued. 
 
 The history of this people is curious. They inhabit, 
 or rather possess, the country lying south of the hills 
 of Tibbet from Caubul to China. They go mostly 
 naked. They have neither towns, houses, nor families, 
 but rove continually from place to place, recruiting 
 their numbers with the- healthiest children they can 
 steal in the countries through which they pass. Thus 
 they are the stoutest and most active men in India. 
 Many are merchants. They are all pilgrims, and held 
 by all castes of Gentoos in great veneration. This in-
 
 304 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 fatuation prevents our obtaining any intelligence of 
 their motions, or aid from the country against them, 
 notwithstanding very rigid orders which have been 
 published for these purposes, insomuch that they often 
 appear in the heart of the province as if they dropped 
 from heaven. They are hardy, bold, and enthusiastic 
 to a degree surpassing credit. Such are the Senassies, 
 the gipsies of Hindostan. 
 
 We have dissolved all the Purgunnah sepoys, and 
 fixed stations of the brigade sepoys on our frontiers, 
 which are to be employed only in the defence of the 
 provinces, and to be relieved every three months. 
 This, I hope, will secure the peace of the country 
 against future irruptions, and as they are no longer to 
 be employed in the collections, the people will be freed 
 from the oppressions of our own plunderers. 
 
 A plan is on foot for the establishment of a bank in 
 Calcutta for the purpose of bringing the collections by 
 bills to the presidency, and affording individuals the 
 same means of making remittances to the awrungs, or 
 markets of the country, for trade. The scheme is 
 formed, and waits only for fit persons to execute it. I 
 shall endeavour to get it copied for this enclosure. 
 
 A plan has been formed and completed for collecting 
 the public customs. It is simple, calculated for the 
 freedom of trade, and liable to no abuses. All the 
 petty Chokeys of the country arc withdrawn, and the 
 distinction of the dustuck, which (among other objec- 
 tions) pointed out to the rogues in office what boats 
 they were to pass unmolested, and what they might 
 plunder with impunity, is abolished. The duty is 
 fixed to 2| per cent. ; the prices of every article fixed 
 and made public, and the duty paid ; the goods pass 
 unmolested to the extremities of the province. 
 
 I have hopes of being able to effect another reforma- 
 tion, which will also contribute much to the freedom of
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 30,3 
 
 trade, by recalling all the gomastahs, and providing the 
 investment by Dadney contracts, or ready money 
 purchases ; to declare the weavers free to work for 
 whom they will, and to support them in that freedom. 
 You will guess why I have marked the sentence at the 
 top of this page. Different circumstances require dif- 
 ferent, and often opposite measures. The Company, 
 and their collectors and chiefs of factories are the only 
 merchants of the country ; they force advances of money 
 on the weavers, and compel them to give cloths in return 
 at an arbitrary valuation, which is often no more than the 
 cost of the materials, so that the poor weaver only lives 
 by running in debt to his employers, and thus becomes 
 their slave for life. The collectors trade with the 
 money which they get in the districts, which affects 
 the circulation as well as commerce of the country. 
 By the mode proposed the investment will be dearer, 
 but the trade of the country will be restored, and in- 
 deed this country has wonderful resources for it. The 
 remittances of the revenue will flow back in circulation, 
 and in their customs or collections the Company will 
 obtain an ample compensation for the difference which 
 it will make in the price of their cloths. Jf they do 
 not, they can better afford to pay dear for them than 
 the Dutch or French can. 
 
 I have some thoughts of making another excursion 
 for the purpose of obtaining a meeting with the Vizier, 
 who has also expressed his wish more than once for an 
 interview. Hitherto he has been entirely managed by 
 the military, who have contrived to keep him so weak 
 that his alliance is of no manner of use to us, but 
 obliges us on every alarm to send our army to prevent 
 his being overpowered by his enemies, which has been 
 usually done at the Company's expense, little being 
 required for reimbursement, and that little paid after 
 long delays. I wish to establish a new and more 
 
 VOL I. X
 
 306 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 rational alliance between him and the Company, and 
 more creditable to both, and to establish his depend- 
 ance on the government instead of the military in- 
 fluence which has hitherto ruled him. In this design 
 I am assured of the most hearty support of the 
 Council. 
 
 It is scarcely worth mentioning that we have been 
 lately engaged in a kind of Polligar war with the in- 
 habitants of Boutan, for the recovery of Cooch Bahar, 
 which lies between their mountains and Rungpore, and 
 has been for some years in their possession. We have 
 fought and defeated them in two desperate engage- 
 ments, and we have possession of the country, but they 
 appear resolutely bent on retrieving their misfor- 
 tunes,, and will give us much trouble, being a sturdy, 
 intrepid race of people. In a late engagement with a 
 detachment of 226 sepoys, which lasted from two in the 
 morning till seven, and in which they were the assail- 
 ants, 200 of them were killed on the spot. We have a 
 battalion on this side commanded by a very good officer ; 
 it will be reinforced by another. The country is equal 
 in fertility and cultivation to any in Bengal, and I have 
 no doubt of the revenue repaying our charges at least. 
 I hope more from the possession of it, besides that it 
 will complete our boundary, and confine these hardy 
 neighbours to their own hills. 
 
 I fear every thing that looks stockjobbish, for which 
 reason I send you the copy of a minute which was de - 
 livered into our Board since the close of our despatches 
 (mentioned the last of the season) proposing a reduc- 
 tion of the Company's interest from eight to five per 
 cent., with the opinion and resolution of the Board upon 
 it, in two separate papers. I suspect the former may 
 find its way to the newspapers. I know not whether 
 you will think the objections to it well supported. I 
 hope we shall be able to reduce the debt, but I cannot
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 307 
 
 approve of touching the interest, and teaching people 
 to take an advantage of our necessities by availing 
 ourselves of theirs. I need not mention that I mean 
 these papers for your own perusal only. The first of 
 them may afford you a little insight into the character 
 of its author. 
 
 If you are an idle man, you may read this long letter 
 without much regret for the expense of time which it 
 will cost you. If a man of business, excuse it, and run 
 it over at your leisure. It will bear to be divided, 
 each paragraph being I believe on a different subject. 
 Is not this a piece of a blunder, since you must have 
 read the foregoing sheets before you come to this ? 
 
 I remember hearing you declare you would lead a 
 country life, and have no more concerns in public 
 business, I hope., and am not altogether selfish in 
 hoping it, that you will not adhere to this resolution. 
 
 But whatever line you may make your choice, may 
 you be happy, loved, honoured and esteemed as much 
 as I think you deserve. Can my services here be of 
 use to you? I wish you would employ them. I beg 
 to be remembered with my compliments and best 
 wishes to Mrs. Dupre. I am, dear Sir, your sincerely 
 affectionate and faithful servant. 
 
 To Sir GEORGE COLEBROOKE. 
 
 Fort William, 3rd April, 1773. 
 
 Dear Sir, The plan of customs which I sent you 
 with my last despatches has been since completed, and 
 a Board of Customs formed to superintend it. It is 
 simple : the expense reduced, all the inferior chokeys 
 withdrawn, and the goods, after one payment, free to 
 go wherever the owners please without molestation. 
 The dustuck will be abolished the 12th of this month, 
 which will put an end to that distinction, which seems 
 to have been the chief cause of oppression to the un- 
 
 X2
 
 308 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 protected traders. I venture to pronounce it a good 
 regulation, and the first effectual step to that free trade 
 which I know you have much at heart. 
 
 I am busy in collecting materials for another inno- 
 vation from which I promise myself equal success in 
 promoting the same. It is to withdraw all our gomas- 
 tahs, and to provide the investment either by Dadney, 
 or ready money purchases, to declare the weavers free 
 to take advances from whom they please, and to sup- 
 port them in this 'privilege. Your investment will be 
 dearer, and perhaps inferior in quality the first year, 
 but it will greatly multiply the number of manufac- 
 turers and increase the trade of Bengal. We want 
 such an aid to recruit our revenue. Bengal is capable 
 of supplying the markets, both of Europe and Asia, 
 with its manufactures, if these are duly encouraged ; 
 and as it wants none of the superfluities of life, and 
 amply abounds in all the necessaries of it, it may re- 
 ceive a yearly flow of specie from this source to supply 
 the drains which have been of late years too lavishly 
 made of its treasure, without the least provision made 
 or thought of for replacing it. As to the price of your 
 cloths, they are now falsely rated, many of the charges 
 being unnoticed in the valuation of the loss in every 
 advance, by bad and irrecoverable debts, which arc in 
 fact a part of the cost, and the means by which the 
 poor weaver escapes being starved, remaining as a 
 balance under a fallacious head in the general books. 
 Besides, if we do pay dearer for our goods, the Dutch 
 and French must do so too, who cannot so well afford 
 it. 
 
 The unequal and impeded circulation of specie which 
 has distressed these provinces for some years past, and 
 which is an inevitable consequence of the remittances 
 of treasure from the districts to the capital, and the 
 want of trade to return it, has rendered it necessary to
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 309 
 
 form a general bank for the purpose of establishing the 
 practice of remittances by bill. Other uses also it is 
 hoped will attend the institution. I say no more of it, 
 as I shall enclose the scheme itself, which has lain 
 before the Board some time, and which will be accom- 
 plished nearly, if not entirely, in the form in which you 
 will receive it. The rates of hoondian or commission 
 are fixed. We have received from most of the col- 
 lectors the current rates of exchange in the districts, 
 and wait but the rest to fix the rates for our bank, 
 when it will be opened. The discount on old siccas 
 will be totally abolished, and to put a stop to the arti- 
 fices by which the shroffs draw a profit from the rupees 
 coined in the different mints of the two provinces, by 
 affixing a batta on them, notwithstanding a simili- 
 tude of the impression, I believe we shall find it expe- 
 dient to have but one mint, and that of course in Cal- 
 cutta. 
 
 I mentioned in some of my former letters that I pro- 
 posed to form an estimate of the loss which the country 
 had sustained in its inhabitants by the famine. The 
 accounts which I have received are formed on such 
 different plans that I cannot reduce them to one form, 
 or establish the proportional loss with accuracy, but I 
 send you an abstract of the materials which have been 
 sent me, and from them you may judge of the effects 
 of that dreadful calamity. I do not believe they are 
 over-rated at one half. The increase in Rungpore, as 
 explained to me by Mr. Purling the collector, was 
 owing to the annual overflowing of the river Toosta 
 about this time of the year, which preserved that dis- 
 trict from the effects of the general drought, and by 
 the plenty which prevailed, occasioned a resort of 
 people from other districts, multitudes of whom 
 perished, but others still remained and became inhabit- 
 ants of that quarter. The violence with which the
 
 310 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 collections were kept up, notwithstanding this desola- 
 tion, and particularly in the assessment which you will 
 find under the explanation of the term na-jay in our 
 first letter from the Board of Revenue, a tax (in a word) 
 upon the survivors to make up the deficiencies of the 
 dead, prevented the instant effect which it might have 
 been expected to produce on the collections, though its 
 influence has operated to the prejudice of the present 
 settlement. This is now completed, and it must be 
 the work of the ensuing four years of the general 
 lease to repair the damages of the country. 
 
 Our political affairs continue nearly in the same 
 state. The General is with the Vizier in the Rohilla 
 country. The Mahrattas appear more inclined to 
 retreat than to fight. 
 
 The Vizier has fixed his ambition on the Rohilla 
 country which adjoins to his, and is included by the 
 Ganges and the mountains of Tartary, and has made 
 tempting offers for our assistance in conquering it for 
 him. It would be a complete addition to his domi- 
 nions, and the hostile part which the Rohillas have 
 taken against him would justify the measure. It is 
 but newly suggested, and I can say no more upon the 
 expediency or probability of its taking place. 
 
 I must beg your excuse for the hurry and uncon- 
 nection of this letter. I have scarcely time to write at 
 all. I am, with unfeigned regard and esteem, dear 
 Sir, &c. 
 
 P.S. I beg the favour of you to show the plan for a 
 bank to Mr. Sulivan, as I have not time to make 
 another copy.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 311 
 
 CHAPTER IX. 
 
 View of the difficulties to be surmounted in working out his reforms Cor- 
 respondence with different functionaries. 
 
 IT is not to be supposed that such results as are 
 described in the preceding letters could be brought 
 about either in a moment, or without encountering 
 a good deal of opposition. Mr. Hastings's plans for 
 the management of the revenue were objected to 
 by all the supervisors, and by such members of 
 the Supreme Council as they were able to influ- 
 ence. His proposed reduction of a corps of cavalry, 
 as well as his desire to establish an improved me- 
 dium of communication with the Court of Oude, 
 excited the indignation of the Commander in Chief, 
 and at the outset, at least, of the Nabob himself. 
 Of such opposition, however, Mr. Hastings made 
 very light ; he took it with all possible good 
 humour : he reasoned points wherever he found 
 men open to reason, and finally prevailed, not 
 merely to carry his own measures, but, in almost 
 every instance, to carry them with the perfect ap- 
 probation of his colleagues. I subjoin one or two 
 letters, rather as specimens of his style in con- 
 ducting controversies of the sort, than because they
 
 312 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 throw any great additional light on the history of 
 this portion of his administration. 
 
 Mr. Harwell, to whom he writes with so much 
 good taste and good feeling, was then opposed to 
 him in the Council, though he afterwards became, 
 under circumstances much more trying, his steady 
 supporter. Mr. Marriott was a collector, who, 
 like many more, dreaded the proposed change be- 
 cause it would interfere with his personal interests ; 
 and Mr. Grueber one of the commissioners who 
 had it in charge to prepare the provinces for the 
 new settlement. It is worthy of remark, that all 
 these letters were written while Mr. Hastings was 
 himself engaged in the prosecution of the survey ; 
 for he did not hesitate to take his share in this 
 subordinate labour, or to give to others less skilled 
 in fiscal details the benefit of his experience. 
 
 To Mr. MARRIOTT. 
 
 Cossimbazar, July 22, 1772. 
 
 Dear Sir, You have been equally misinformed both 
 with respect to the supposed accusations against you, 
 and the separation of Selburris from Dinagepoor. It 
 is possible and probable that both Selburris, and Ber- 
 bazoo, and Attya (I think the last forms a part of 
 your collectorship) may be separated from Dinage- 
 poor, not upon account of any misconduct in the col- 
 lector, (this would be a strange kind of retribution,) 
 but because they have been improperly annexed to 
 your district, and arc too remote to be included in 
 your collection. It will rest with the committee to 
 make such a disposition of the districts as they, upon
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 313 
 
 the spot, shall think most expedient for the country 
 and for the easy collection of the revenues. But you 
 may be assured that nothing is nor can yet be deter- 
 mined concerning them. 
 
 I will not conceal from you that I have heard it 
 frequently alleged as a general charge against the 
 collectors that they were the sole traders in their 
 respective provinces, and particularly in the article of 
 grain. But I have never heard your name mentioned 
 upon such a subject, nor in any way that could reflect 
 a censure upon it. 
 
 I am pleased to remark in the sentiments which you 
 express on this occasion, the effects of that spirit which 
 is the attendant of conscious integrity ; but the pre- 
 cautions which you have taken to obviate any reports 
 to your prejudice were unnecessary with me. You 
 may be assured that I shall never give credit to any 
 complaints against you, unless supported by the 
 strongest proofs, and then I shall certainly inform you 
 of them, if I think them of such a nature as to merit 
 attention. 
 
 To Mr. N. GRUEBER. 
 
 Cossimbazar, 21st July, 1772. 
 
 You have my permission to take with you what 
 number of sepoys you think requisite for your defence 
 on the journey. When you return them I recommend 
 to you to give strict injunctions to the officer who 
 commands them to prevent their committing any dis- 
 turbance in the way, as he shall be made answerable 
 for any complaints that shall be proved against the 
 rest. 
 
 I have given letters to many complainants whose 
 causes I desire you will take immediate cognizance of, 
 and dismiss them, giving each a copy of your decree ; 
 a rule which ought to be invariably practised with all 
 persons who appear either as complainants or respond- 
 ents before you.
 
 314 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 I earnestly recommend to you to set apart a fixed 
 portion of your time daily, or as often as your other 
 duties will permit, to hear and decide all complaints 
 that shall be brought before you. It will facilitate 
 your business much if you keep a brief register of all 
 causes that shall be brought before you, entering the 
 names of the complainant and the respondent, with 
 the general charge, and your decision ; those of each 
 pergunnah being registered apart. By this means you 
 will at any time see by a glance on your register 
 whether the same persons have ever been brought 
 before you, or the same causes before decided- 
 
 A few instances of strict justice afforded to the 
 persons injured, and a few severe examples made of 
 great offenders, will save you much future trouble by 
 lessening the number of complainants as there will be 
 fewer causes of complaint. 
 
 Your own servants, unless attended to with a most 
 watchful eye, will be the greatest oppressors of the 
 country, each in proportion to the confidence that you 
 repose in him. You cannot avoid committing much 
 to their charge, but one of the most likely means of 
 restraining their licentiousness will be to pay a parti- 
 cular attention to the complaints against them, and to 
 make it known that you will protect the complainants 
 from their resentment. 
 
 I earnestly recommend these points to your constant 
 attention, as no less necessary to your own ease and 
 reputation than to the credit of our government and 
 the interest of the Company. Wishing you health 
 and success, I remain, &c. &c. &c. 
 
 To R. C. HARWELL, Esq. 
 
 Cossimbazar, 22nd July, 1772. 
 
 Dear Sir, Our argument on the Vackaulut is likely 
 to remain long undecided. I have told you my objec- 
 tions. They appear to me incontrovertible. But you
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 315 
 
 are of a different opinion, and it is possible that I may 
 have expressed myself differently upon it at the time 
 which you allude to, which is very distant ; but I pro- 
 fess to you that I cannot trace back this subject in my 
 memory to any point of time when I should have 
 approved of the fixed residence of a member of Council 
 at the Court of Shuja Dowla. I always thought the 
 man and his connexion of too little importance, and 
 the office of too little, besides the Company's express 
 orders which forbid it. You join vackeel and ambas- 
 sador as terms synonymous. They are not altogether 
 so, and perhaps I may approve of the one and dislike 
 the other. In effect, I begin to wish for the latter. 
 You will be informed by the papers which were sent 
 two days past to the Board, that the General and his 
 coadjutor have brought our affairs into that critical 
 state in which, if ever, it becomes necessary for the 
 Board to interfere, by the representation of some per- 
 son who may be furnished with their sentiments and 
 clear instructions upon the political line to be observed 
 in all their negociations with the Vizier and his friends 
 and opponents. He has told us that the Mahrattas 
 are preparing to invade him ; and it is not unlikel}', 
 as he has entered into a contract with the Rohillas to 
 attack the Mahrattas, and, I fear, has proceeded to 
 this length on some assurance of our joining him, 
 Whatever may be the intention of the Mahrattas, we 
 are forbid, peremptorily forbid, to be the aggressors, 
 and therefore must wait till they begin, unless the 
 Company's promised instructions shall authorize us to 
 provide against remote and greater danger, by meet- 
 ing it before it is ripe and ready to fall on us. But it 
 will not be in our power to keep within the peaceable 
 track which is required of us, while the Vizier is left at 
 liberty to draw us, step by step, imperceptibly into his 
 own projects. A person of trust and consequence,
 
 316 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 resident with him while the present scene lasts, might 
 effectually check him in his career, by protesting 
 against every measure which tended to an unnecessary 
 breach with the Mahrattas. 
 
 This juncture, therefore, and this state of affairs, has 
 drawn our opinions closer to each other, though they 
 are not likely to meet ; for I am clearly of opinion that 
 a member of the Board should now be deputed to the 
 Vizier, to explain the Board's intentions, and to advise 
 him in his operations, but to reside with him no longer 
 than the occasion which suggested the commission 
 shall require the continuance of it. Favour me with 
 your opinion upon this proposition. If it is to be car- 
 ried into execution, it should be resolved on imme- 
 diately. Indeed, I am told, though I should not 
 believe it, but that i have found the reports to be well 
 grounded, that the General himself is coming down, 
 which will leave the Vizier altogether at large. 
 
 This matter will require other discussions when it is 
 decided that it shall take place. 
 
 I now proceed to your second letter, for which accept 
 my thanks, with the assurance that, as I have frequently 
 solicited, so I shall think myself obliged to you for 
 your opinion upon every business of importance. That 
 now before us is of the first. I make no apology for 
 my late reply to it. I do not like to speak without 
 thought, and God knows I have little time for thought, 
 being indebted for the present vacant hour to the 
 kindness of a plentiful shower of rain that has kept off 
 all interruption. 
 
 Your observation upon the impossibility of obtain- 
 ing a perfect, system is perfectly just. In many cases 
 we must work as an arithmetician does with his Ride 
 of False. We must adopt a plan upon conjecture, 
 try, execute, add, and deduct from it, till it is brought 
 into a perfect shape. Yet this mode is liable to many
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 317 
 
 inconveniences. It affords scope for the reproach of 
 levity, and the finishing stroke which shall be given 
 to a measure so conducted, though the result of all the 
 former proceedings shall bear away all the credit of it, 
 while the losses, troubles, and embarrassments attend- 
 ing the first experiment, and unavoidably incident, as 
 you justly observe, to all innovations, will be charged 
 to the account of the first projectors. This is precisely 
 our present case. The new government of the Com- 
 pany consists of a confused heap of undigested mate- 
 rials, as wild as the chaos itself. The powers of 
 government are undefined; the collection of the re- 
 venue, the provision of the investment, the administra- 
 tion of justice (if it exists at all), the care of the police, 
 are all huddled together, being exercised by the same 
 hands, though most frequently the two latter offices 
 are totally neglected for the want of knowing where to 
 have recourse for them. Added to the difficulties 
 attendant on the arrangement of each, we have them 
 all to separate, and bring into order at once. With 
 such a variety of objects, the little we can do will bear 
 so small a proportion to what we shall leave undone, 
 that I fear, if we escape censure, we have little ground 
 to hope for applause from our superiors. But to come 
 to the point. 
 
 We are agreed in the first step to be taken for the 
 management of the Dewannee, i. e. the removal of the 
 collections, with all their dependent offices, to Calcutta. 
 The mode of inspection which you have proposed, 
 though very clear and well imagined, requires much 
 consideration ; and I foresee one ill consequence which 
 is likely to attend it, which makes me dread its insti- 
 tution. You propose twelve separate offices for the 
 collections. That one member of the Board shall be 
 the inspector of each, and one general office which is 
 to receive and control the accounts of the rest ; subject
 
 318 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS 
 
 to whom ? I conclude the president. The arguments 
 by which you support this distribution are very strong 
 and incontrovertible. They can only be opposed by 
 their probable effects thrown into the opposite scale. 
 
 Now give me leave to enumerate these effects. 
 
 Each inspector will become virtually the collector- 
 general of his division. The emoluments of the col- 
 lections will be his. He will be the patron of the 
 resident collector (or collectors), and the sovereign of 
 the district, with this singular restriction on his autho- 
 rity, that he must act by a delegated power, and will be 
 responsible for whatever is done in his absence. 
 
 You have placed the power of control over those 
 inferior offices in the general office; but how is that 
 control to be exercised ? The Bengal accounts are the 
 only accounts by which the collections can be regu- 
 lated, and the business of the revenue conducted. 
 These will be abstracted and rendered into unintelligible 
 English for the office of the sudder. Unintelligible, 
 I say, because it is next to impossible to render them 
 intelligible, nor is there any incitement to render them 
 intelligible. These ^will be again abstracted, and 
 brought into the general office, the head of which is to 
 check and control the whole; that is, he is to be the 
 blind and passive instrument of authenticating the 
 acts of the inspectors, or he is to inquire into the par- 
 ticulars of the receipts and disbursements, which can 
 only be done by summoning the officers of the collec- 
 tions, calling for the papers of the mofussul, and com- 
 paring them with the abstracts of his own office, a 
 duty which must inevitably draw on him their enmity 
 whose accounts fall under his inspection. The conclu- 
 sion is certain and infallible. Even on the supposition 
 that the inspector receives no advantage from his em- 
 ployment, his pride is attacked by every inquiry made 
 by another into the business of which he is the imme-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARHEN HASTINGS. 319 
 
 diate superintendent. Every fraud, oppression, or irre- 
 gularity detected by another, reflects upon his want of 
 care; and as the collector will consult him on most 
 occasions, and screen himself under his authority, fur- 
 nishing him with such materials of information alone 
 as he thinks fit ; he will of course appeal to his patron 
 against every attack that is made on himself, or 
 attempt to bring him to justice; and the arbitrary 
 inquisitor will have every member of the Board unite 
 against him as the common enemy. 
 
 Make whom you will inspector-general I will not 
 be the man. I will neither be responsible for the acts 
 of others, nor stand forth as the general reformer, and 
 make every man whose friendship and confidence are 
 necessary for my support my inveterate enemy. 
 
 Excuse me, my friend, for taking such liberties with 
 your plan. You see the grand principle of my objec- 
 tion, it is the first principle of all my researches, a 
 cordial unanimity with my associates in the administra- 
 tion. It shall never be my fault if I fail in my aim to 
 attain it. In return, I will give you an opportunity to 
 make reprisals by submitting to your judgment and 
 correction such thoughts as have occurred to me on 
 this very interesting subject, for it is not fair to pull 
 down a system without furnishing the materials at 
 least for erecting another. My desire is to accomplish 
 every end that you yourself aim at, and I shall hope 
 to effect it in such a manner as to establish concord 
 and unanimity, instead of furnishing matter of jealousy 
 and disunion, which I dread in your distribution. 
 
 But this will lead me too far beyond the bounds 
 of a letter, and four sheets are enough, in conscience, 
 to burthen you with at once. Hereafter, that is the 
 next vacant hour, you shall have the sequel of this 
 discussion. What 1 have here suggested, I hope will
 
 320 MEMOIRS OF \VARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 be received with the same sentiments of candour and 
 friendship with which they were written. 
 
 I must here premise that my next letter will be a 
 confidential one. Forgive me the question, but it is 
 necessary : Are your sentiments towards me of such a 
 nature as to admit of a mutual communication of opi- 
 nions, without caution or reserve ? I shall be satisfied 
 with a simple affirmative in reply. From frequent and 
 unaccountable disappointments, I am compelled to 
 entertain doubts, having met with cold looks, and 
 more than symptoms of dislike sometimes, where I had 
 built the surest hopes of entire good will towards me. 
 Your letters to me betray no such indications, but you 
 best know whether pains have not been taken to inspire 
 them. 
 
 I find that a peevish expression accidentally 
 dropped from me at Kishennagur, respecting the sus- 
 pension of the councils in Calcutta, in which your 
 name was mentioned, has been carefully transmitted 
 to you. I forget the words, for I do not treasure such 
 things in my memory. They are the ideas of a 
 moment, the ideas of a clouded mind, which catch fire, 
 pass, and leave no traces behind them. Something I 
 know I did say, and I know that it has travelled to 
 Calcutta, because I have received it back from Mr. 
 Aldersey, who thinks himself taxed with having said 
 something to me which occasioned it : lest this should 
 hurt him in your opinion, I can assure you most truly 
 that he never said or hinted anything to me from 
 which any conclusion could be drawn to your pre- 
 judice. 
 
 I make no apology for dwelling so long on such a 
 subject ; it is not a trifle, nor can I regard it as such. 
 I beg you will believe me to be with a sincere regard 
 and esteem, dear Sir, your most obedient servant.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 321 
 
 Such a letter as the preceding would seem to 
 have deserved at least a respectful perusal. Mr. 
 Bar well appears to have thought otherwise ; and 
 the following closed the correspondence of the two 
 members of government on the subject at that 
 time under discussion : 
 
 To RICHARD BARWELL, Esq. 
 
 Cossimbazar, 5th August, 1772. 
 
 I am favoured with yours of the 26th ultimo and 3rd 
 current. My letter was not meant to express my dis- 
 trust of others, but to explain what concerned ourselves. 
 You have satisfied me. I should have given you, long 
 before this, the sequel of my thoughts on the main 
 subject of my last, had not the attention which I have 
 been compelled to bestow on other matters of a public 
 and more urgent nature prevented me. Such subjects 
 are not to be wildly treated, with a head embarrassed 
 by a variety of interesting objects. They require a 
 vacant and tranquil mind, an uninterrupted chain of 
 close reasoning, and an undisturbed view of every pos- 
 sible consequence that may arise from the design pro- 
 jected. But your last letter has made it unnecessary 
 for me to resume the subject, for you say you have re- 
 corded your sentiments upon it. I hope, however, that, 
 on maturer reflection, and on a perusal of the minutes 
 of the committee upon the motives of the removal of 
 the Dewanny to Calcutta, you will change your opi- 
 nion, and think your preliminary unnecessary. 
 
 To Sir ROBERT BARKER. 
 
 Cossimbazar, 28th August, 1772. 
 
 Sir, On revisal of the letters you have occasionally 
 favoured me with, they have not, I perceive, been 
 replied to with the punctuality I could have wished. 
 
 VOL. I. Y
 
 322 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 The laborious and very important task the Company 
 lately imposed on their administration here, commenced 
 with my accession to it. To fulfil it with any prospect 
 of success adequate to the expectations formed at home, 
 the intermission of many things, and even those of 
 moment, unavoidably ensued. Of this kind has been 
 my whole circle of correspondence. I early discovered 
 the impossibility of applying to general objects (omit- 
 ting incidental matters), while my regards were con- 
 centered, nay commanded to particular ones, of a 
 pressure and embarrassment requiring every effort of 
 application and capacity. To obviate that distraction, 
 which is the invariable result of a divided attention, my 
 only resource was to do one thing at once. The work 
 was arduous, the season unfavourable, the labourers 
 but few, and our time to the September despatches 
 short. Domestic policy and economy are of the first 
 consideration in every state. Where these are affected, 
 foreign concerns can have only a secondary place. A 
 competition with the first exposes the security of both. 
 For the conduct of the latter, indeed, I was less soli- 
 citous. They were already in a train, and the direction 
 of it in possession of a gentleman, of whose zeal for the 
 common cause I was thoroughly convinced, and of his 
 passion for its welfare. In this alternative of diffi- 
 culties my aim has been to choose the least. Rather 
 in regularity and form, than in more essential points, 
 I believe I shall be found defective. Where indis- 
 pensable, my replies, if I mistake not, have been imme- 
 diate. To two or three transactions only in your 
 quarter was my interposition particularly required. 
 The rest I was under the necessity to refer to the 
 Board, whose sentiments usually conveyed answers 
 both to your public and private despatches. Defect in 
 minute points will be more easily excused than super- 
 fluity; yet if it should seem that I have really tres-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 323 
 
 passed on punctilio beyond the strict rules of propriety, 
 I must beg you will confide in my assurances that it has 
 been a source of no inconsiderable mortification and 
 regret to me, and that I cannot pursue my inclinations 
 more agreeably than by the most unreserved cor- 
 respondence with every member of the Board in every 
 contingency of the public good. Thus bereaved of the 
 freedom of communication,, I really consider myself as 
 the sufferer. That I enumerate the causes of my re- 
 missness, proceeds from a repugnancy to have my 
 silence misconstrued or ascribed to motives as foreign 
 to my nature as they are remote from my thoughts ; 
 for you may rely on my cordial wishes for a perfect 
 conformity of sentiment, where I am confident there is 
 of principle and intention. 
 
 My opinion of Major Morrison's engagements cor- 
 responds to yours. His letter to the Board is no less 
 rude than intrusive. My counsel has been either to 
 disregard it entirely, or to treat his conduct in the 
 criminal way it deserves, to reject his offers with dis- 
 dain, and to command his instant departure from the 
 Shah's service. To this purport I should not be averse 
 from making a requisition to the King, were there a 
 prospect of compliance with it ; but as we have little at 
 present to bestow on his Majesty, it is not a likely 
 season to obtain Mr. Morrison's dismission as a favour, 
 and nothing exposes weakness so much as demands that 
 cannot be enforced. Pursuant, however, to your advice, 
 his imposition on government shall not escape unno- 
 ticed ; it will constitute an article in our next general 
 letter, with the necessary comments, and a remonstrance 
 to the directors to represent his artifice, and the 
 eventual mischief of such practices, to the ministry. 
 
 Receive, if you please, my thanks for the general 
 returns. Their form is equally methodical and per- 
 spicuous, and I should be glad if every officer would
 
 324 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 imitate so clear and perfect a model in the construction 
 of theirs. 
 
 From the multiplicity of business I myself experience 
 in the military line, I am sensible of the necessity of 
 another assistant to your department. On my return 
 to the presidency, I mean to move your proposal for an 
 adjutant-general, and in the interim should be glad if 
 you would indulge me with such further explanations 
 on the nature of that employment as may serve to 
 instruct the Board, and to secure the continuation of it 
 by justifying the expediency of the appointment to our 
 constituents. 
 
 Whether I returned my acknowledgments for the 
 pains and success of your negociation for the removal 
 of Monsieur Gentil, I am not positive. I know I ad- 
 dressed my thanks to the Vizier, and request you will 
 now accept the same for yourself on the like account. 
 
 Notwithstanding the disagreeable incidents we en- 
 counter on the intricacy of our present operations, yet 
 nothing has given us more uneasiness than the unfa- 
 vourable impressions you have admitted of our late 
 military arrangements, except it is the style of emotion 
 they are conceived in. One passage of your public 
 letter seems to imply your participation in the original 
 institution of the cavalry; but of this circumstance the 
 Board, at least I can affirm it for myself, was wholly 
 unacquainted. Whatever it might have been in its first 
 design, they never heard the cavalry spoken of otherwise 
 than as a baneful corps, and to their inutility there 
 was not one dissenting voice. Yet had the gentlemen 
 imagined they were an establishment of your projection, 
 or of your choice ; that you entertained a predilection 
 in their favour, or had they conceived an idea of your 
 objecting materially to the reform, I believe I can say 
 that there was no indisposition in one individual of the 
 administration to pay the deference due to the com-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 325 
 
 mander-in-chief in consulting his judgment on the 
 occasion. But surely you went too far in predicting 
 the Company's ruin,, from the reduction of 300 troopers 
 without your consent. The resources within ourselves 
 are not yet, I hope, reduced to so desperate a condition. 
 Your censure of the measure, however, has already gone 
 forth, and I am sorry for it, because, from the poignancy 
 of language and vehemence of argument so pointedly 
 urged against the proceedings of the Board, expressly 
 calculated to excite the resentment of the Company and 
 to awaken their passions, the Council are driven, though 
 reluctantly, to such a reply as may ensure their most 
 ample vindication. To effect this, the cavalry will 
 necessarily be described in darker colours than they 
 ever, of themselves, should have thought of painting 
 them. It cannot be avoided. The Council were 
 willing silently to obviate future abuses, without the 
 ungrateful office and odium of retrospection, and they 
 would still be concerned to bring them all to light ; 
 for if we admit the goodness of those troops, or the con- 
 sistency of their establishment, how, pray, can we be 
 justified to our principals for discarding them ? Ob- 
 servations have, in consequence, been made on the 
 paragraph of your public letter, for the sole purpose of 
 asserting our own just intentions. They are now at 
 the presidency, from whence I have been some weeks 
 in expectation of them. 
 
 I pass over the indirect reflections on myself in the 
 course of this affair, tending to provoke the resentment 
 of the directors and alarm the jealousy of the Board, by 
 representing me as the promoter of innovation. These 
 contribute in their consequences to affect me much 
 more, I am persuaded, than you meant they should do. 
 I wish they had been spared. I could well have dis- 
 pensed with them, from the propensity of my temper to 
 live in peace with all men, and the very little leisure I 
 have for controversy.
 
 326 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 When you apprized the Board of stationing cadets 
 to Shujah Dowlah's sepoys, it was not meant, I 
 imagine, to be understood by us as a permament esta- 
 blishment, but as a resolution adapted to a sudden 
 exigency, the success of the Mahrattas, and the sup- 
 position of their design to attack the Vizier. I need 
 not dwell upon the apprehensions of the Company and 
 the jealousy of our nation, in general, on proceedings 
 of this tendency, and how obnoxious any measures will 
 appear at home conducing to instruct the powers of 
 this country in that discipline wherein our superiority 
 principally consists. You will excuse, I hope, this 
 intimation. At the same time I can assure you I should 
 be heartily glad to furnish a temporary provision for 
 so many cadets. Your proposals will always have, as 
 they ought to have, their due influence with me. Yet 
 in the present instance I am at a loss to determine 
 whether it is within the compass of my authority to 
 accede to your recommendation to the full extent of 
 what may, perhaps, be expected. At all events, the 
 young gentlemen shall continue to act as officers on 
 their return, an event that I cannot resist expressing 
 my wishes may have already taken place. To super- 
 sede the cadets above them on the list, cannot injustice 
 be done. The rule I have adopted, and which I mean 
 never to deviate from but upon some conjuncture that 
 will justify me to the whole world, is to adhere strictly 
 to the Company's register of cadets, and to commission 
 them in the order in which their names stand ar- 
 ranged. The cadets, therefore, who are already ordered 
 to do duty as officers, can have no more than their 
 regular standing when the others come to be promoted. 
 The former were lucky to be selected for service, but 
 the others ought not to suffer for their good fortune. 
 
 It does not recur to me to have replied to your pro- 
 posal of offering the two troops of black cavalry in camp 
 to Shujah Dowlah. I recollect, indeed, to have regarded
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 327 
 
 it. as a circumstance entirely resting with you as com- 
 prised in the article of disbanding them. 
 
 Neither convenience nor opportunity hitherto allow- 
 ing the Board to enter on a judicial cognizance of 
 Mahomed Reza Cawn, I have not yet communicated to 
 them his clandestine correspondence with the King. I 
 was desirous to wait for the particular confirmation of 
 it, having myself received intelligence from another 
 quarter, though less authentic, of the same intercourse 
 being extended to a greater length. How far it has 
 been farther prosecuted or traced I would willingly be 
 informed before we proceed ultimately on his exami- 
 nation. 
 
 For the more regular despatch of the supernumerary 
 returns to you, strict injunctions have been issued. I 
 am, Sir, your most obedient servant. 
 
 To Sir ROBERT BARKER. 
 
 1st November, 1772. 
 
 Sir, I find myself at a loss to reply to your letter, 
 because in defending the character of Captain Harper 
 it seems to oppose an opinion which I never enter- 
 tained. My objections to his continuance with the 
 Vizier are very foreign from those which you have com- 
 bated, and have no relation to them. I believe him to 
 be a brave and active officer, a man of integrity, of 
 political abilities, and of a genius and talents suited 
 to the place which he has so long filled. These 
 qualities report gives him. Of his understanding I have 
 conceived a very high opinion from what I have seen 
 of his correspondence. I have mentioned to you the 
 reasons which urge me, which make it my duty to object 
 to his present residence. Had this point been contested 
 without any prior endeavours to force the Board into a 
 compliance with it, the motives which have been pub- 
 licly assigned for his removal might, perhaps, have been
 
 328 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 overruled. No design, at least no determination, had 
 been formed for it. 
 
 The perpetual establishment of the channel of cor- 
 respondence with the Vizier in one person had been 
 often mentioned as attended with many inconveniences. 
 I see and feel that it deprives the government of its 
 influence in that court, and of the means of conducting 
 their political operations in that quarter conformably 
 to their own ideas and principles. A cold implicit 
 obedience to the orders of his superiors, which can 
 accommodate itself to every change of opinions which a 
 change of men may give occasion to, I do not expect 
 from any man in that station who is capable of thinking 
 for himself. Personal attachments or some favourite 
 maxims will unavoidably get possession of his mind and 
 influence his conduct, and these prepossessions will 
 become more powerful in proportion to the length of 
 time in which he has acted in such a capacity. 
 
 It may, therefore, be judged necessary that, where 
 the intervention of an agent is required for the 
 management of the political system, he should be well 
 instructed in the principles on which it is grounded, 
 and have no prejudices of his own to encounter in the 
 execution of it. That the Governor, whom the Com- 
 pany have expressly declared to be the only channel 
 allowed by them of communication with the powers of 
 the country, and on whom the whole responsibility in 
 effect resides, should be denied the choice of such means 
 as he may approve for executing so important a trust, 
 and be compelled to employ an agent whom he does 
 not know, is another powerful objection, and with me 
 an insuperable one. There may be others, which I 
 now forbear to mention. None, however, were de- 
 clared ; but it had been whispered in Council that such 
 existed. The Vizier heard them. In an irregular and 
 most unbecoming manner he insisted on Captain H.'s
 
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 329 
 
 continuance, and protested against any other resident. 
 He was assured, in reply, the Board had no design of 
 sending another; that they considered Captain H. only 
 as a commander of the sepoys, which had been acci- 
 dentally stationed near his person, and not as a repre- 
 sentative of this government ; that we saw the necessity 
 for one, and desired him to permit Captain H. to leave 
 him and rejoin the corps which he belonged to. The 
 Vizier rejoined and persisted in his demand. Captain 
 H. then, and not till then, expressed his sentiments, 
 and intimated his wishes on the occasion. He had 
 hitherto remained silent, relying most assuredly (for 
 he could not be ignorant of the Vizier's requisition in 
 his favour) on the Vizier's influence for the security of 
 his post. I will not add any reflections on this subject ; 
 but I declare that I think the Board could not in 
 honour or duty have complied with a recommendation 
 of such a nature, so made, nor after their refusal and 
 declaration recall both on any remonstrances which the 
 A^izier can urge, without subjecting their resolutions 
 to the imputation of levity or timidity, or improper 
 influence. On this subject every man seems to have 
 adopted a line of his own. I want no substitute to 
 Captain H. ; I see no occasion for any. I think we injure 
 ourselves and invert the nature of the obligations 
 between the Company and the Vizier by such appoint- 
 ments, which imply nothing less than his absolute 
 dependence on us for support, and total want of im- 
 portance to our interests. 
 
 With respect to the trade carried on by Captain 
 H. and its effects on that of the Company and 
 their credit, it might lead me too far beyond the bounds 
 of a letter, which I have already exceeded. If Captain 
 Harper insists on a public inquiry into the truth of 
 the reports concerning him, I shall not oppose it; but 
 though I have declared to you that this objection has
 
 330 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 much weight with me, yet it is only an objection within 
 my own breast. I wish not to be obliged to make a 
 public one of it. I am much concerned that our senti- 
 ments on this point (and I hope on this only) differ so 
 materially, as I wish most heartily that on all occasions 
 our opinions, inclinations, and studies may unite in the 
 support of the common cause, the interest and honour 
 of our common masters. I am, with the highest esteem 
 and regard, &c. 
 
 The following contains an excellent summary of 
 the issues of these varied arrangements. I there- 
 fore insert it, as releasing me at once from further 
 consideration of this part of my subject : 
 
 To JOHN SULIVAN, Esq. 
 
 (per Hector), 2nd April, 1772. 
 
 Dear Sir, In the uncertainty in which I still remain 
 concerning your destination, I cannot write to you 
 either with the confidence or satisfaction which I felt in 
 my former correspondence. Indeed I have not much 
 to write, as every public letter is in effect an address 
 from me to you, and leaves me little to add upon the 
 subject of public affairs. 
 
 The inquiry into the conduct of Rajah Shitabroy has 
 concluded, at least little remains for decision, as I 
 expected. I never thought him culpable ; I never 
 accused him, nor did the Court of Directors express any 
 suspicion which ever glanced at his conduct. 
 
 Mahomed Rezza Cawn's examination is begun, but 
 suspended for want of time. It will be resumed imme- 
 diately, and we shall meet, I believe, every evening to 
 conclude the first charge against him, viz., the pur- 
 chase and sale of grain, by his orders, in the year of the 
 famine. The others are articles of accounts, and wil\ 
 not require so close and personal an attention-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 331 
 
 The settlement of the province on a lease of five 
 years, of which one is already past, is at length com- 
 pleted. The desolation of the province by the famine, 
 of Avhich the effects are yet evident, and perhaps more 
 than formerly, on the revenue ; the remission of the 
 Bazy Jummah, the Zimindarree customs, and the tax 
 on marriages ; and the suspension of the collections 
 while the settlement was forming (as a watch must 
 stand while you wind it), have contributed to prejudice 
 the income of this year. Yet the balance outstanding 
 is inconsiderable, being not more than the amount of 
 the charges, and I hope will realize the yearly increase. 
 
 This packet carries home a plan of the new system 
 adopted for the customs, which I recommend to your 
 perusal, I think it a most beneficial innovation, and 
 more likely to revive the commerce of the country than 
 any regulation of which I have a conception. 
 
 A plan is on foot, and nearly completed, for a public 
 bank for the purpose of transmitting money to and from 
 the different parts of the country and the presidency, 
 both for the collections and for the trade of individuals. 
 I have sent a copy of the draught as it now stands to 
 Sir George Colebrooke, and desired him to show it to 
 you, as I want time and hands to make another copy. 
 
 The last ship carried home a final adjustment of the 
 Nabob's annual expenses, which have been brought 
 within the amount of his reduced stipend, a work 
 more difficult than it will appear. The Begum still 
 objects to some articles in it, but I shall find no diffi- 
 culty in accommodating them to her satisfaction. The 
 point which I aimed at was to bring the sum within 
 six lacs, which I am resolved shall not be exceeded. 
 She conducts herself with much moderation, and has 
 hitherto shown no inclination to contest the authority 
 of our government, although, I fear, she has not wanted 
 a prompter in Nundcomar, whom I keep at as great
 
 332 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 a distance from her as I can to prevent him from making 
 mischief. In his absence from the Durbar no harm can 
 happen, as his son and son-in-law, one the Dewan and 
 the other Naib of the Nizamut, are more ready to coun- 
 teract each other's designs than join in a plot to hurt 
 our government. 
 
 The business of the new board of revenue, and of 
 the office of the calsa, go on as regularly as if both had 
 been instituted from the first establishment of Cal- 
 cutta. Our courts of justice want only time and leisure 
 in the members of the government, which must both 
 give and continue their first motion to perfect them. 
 
 In a word, the sovereign authority of the Company 
 is firmly rooted in every part of the provinces and every 
 branch of the state, nor can anything hereafter weaken 
 or affect it if your administration is well supported at 
 home. 
 
 The General returned last month to rejoin the first 
 brigade, which was ordered to assist the Vizier, with 
 permission to carry his operations into the Rohilla 
 country, lying north of Oude, and included by the 
 Ganges, if he found it necessary ; to defend Cora and 
 the province of Illahbad, for the king, and to take 
 immediate possession of it, but not to pass the boundary 
 of that district. 
 
 He has properly used the latitude allowed him in the 
 first part of his instructions, having conducted the 
 army beyond the Vizier's territories to the bank of 
 the Ganges, lying opposite Furrookhabad. The Mah- 
 rattas, by the last advices, were preparing to retire, and 
 I hope the campaign will prove a peaceable one. 
 
 I am happy in informing you that I find in all the 
 members of the Board (I know not whether I can yet 
 say without one exception) a cordial disposition to 
 support and co-operate with me. A disunion at this 
 time would be productive of certain ruin.
 
 MEMOIRS OP WARREN HASTINGS. 333 
 
 When I mention the Council, I scarce consider the 
 General a member of it I had taken much pains to 
 remove and obviate everything which might breed 
 uneasiness between him and the Board, and we parted 
 with declarations of mutual confidence, sincere I am 
 sure on my part. Long before this he had made 
 many efforts, both public and private, to obtain the 
 repeal of an order of the Board for the recall of Captain 
 Harper from the Vizier's court ; but without effect. 
 The Board persisted in their resolution, and I have 
 more than once declared it was a point which I would 
 not give up. He acquiesced, wrote to Captain Harper, 
 who was on his way down, to stay at Patna; wrote to 
 me on his arrival there, that, meeting with Captain 
 Harper on the way, he had ordered him to return with 
 him, and he has taken him back. I informed the 
 Board of this strange behaviour. They, unwilling- to 
 enter into an altercation on the commencement of the 
 campaign, contented themselves with issuing a public 
 order that Captain Harper should come to the presi- 
 dency, and that no officer of any rank should detain 
 him. They have entered into no correspondence with 
 him nor recorded more of the affair than I have men- 
 tioned, that he may, if he chooses, put an end to it ; it 
 rests with him to make it more serious. From such 
 little springs flow the rivers of discord. I have reason 
 to believe that much has been written, and much will 
 be written, on this frivolous subject, frivolous I must 
 say on one side only, as it makes a servant, and an infe- 
 rior servant of the government, a party in a public and 
 even a national contest with it. Should it be deemed 
 worth notice at home, letme entreat you to read the 
 consultations upon this subject. You will find them in 
 the proceedings of the secret department of the fol- 
 lowing dates, viz., 30th September, 1st and2d October, 
 and the select committee proceedings of the 7th of 
 January, referred to the Board at large.
 
 331 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 In two words, I wish to make the Vizier depend on 
 government and not on the military power, and I want 
 to open a free trade into the Vizier's dominions, which 
 are now subject to a military monopoly. I can do 
 neither while the military agent remains, and therefore 
 I conclude, so much intrigue and violence are employed 
 to retain him. 
 
 You will meet with a strange and uncommon pro- 
 posal delivered in by Mr. Barwell, after the despatch 
 of our last ship. It had an evident view to raise great 
 expectations at home, and to build a reputation to the 
 proposer at the expense of the members of adminis- 
 tration. The close of the last despatches is an untimely 
 season for a speculative contest ; but it has been 
 answered and the proposal condemned. It was unfairly 
 introduced at a time, too, when we were all agreed on 
 adopting some mode for reducing the Company's debt 
 by paying off the capital. Whenever it is suggested 
 that any part of the Company's interests have not been 
 duly attended to, I heartily wish you to look over the 
 bulky consultations in the three departments, and turn 
 to the names at the head of them. I have not (that I 
 recollect) missed one since my return to the presidency, 
 and have given almost every hour besides to business, 
 which I take upon me to say has rested wholly on me 
 during the late absence of the committee. I am, with 
 the sincerest and most affectionate regard and esteem, 
 dear Sir, &c.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 335 
 
 CHAPTER X. 
 
 Foreign relations of the Company Treaty of Benares Letters on various 
 Subjects. 
 
 THE judicial and financial affairs of the country 
 being thus reduced to comparative order, Mr. 
 Hastings proceeded next to consider the state of its 
 foreign relations ; of which it is not going too far 
 to assert that, taking the power of the Company 
 into account, they were in every respect disgrace- 
 ful to the British character. With the exception 
 of the King, Shah Allum, and Shujah Dowlah, the 
 Nabob of Oude, there was not a crowned head 
 throughout the length and breadth of Hindostan, 
 with whom, either for good or for evil, the Bengal 
 government maintained any settled communication. 
 The native powers, without a single exception, 
 looked indeed upon the English with a jealous eye. 
 They envied them their seeming greatness ; they 
 dreaded the spirit of encroachment by which they 
 appeared to be actuated ; and would have gladly 
 united, had there been any master hand to direct 
 them, in a common effort to drive them from their 
 shores. But nowhere was the English name held 
 in respect ; neither had they influence enough, 
 except by force of arms, either to carry a favourite 
 point for themselves, or to restrain the weakest
 
 336 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 of their neighbours from seeking to carry it. Mr. 
 Hastings was too profound a politician not to be 
 aware, that a perseverance in this system of isola- 
 tion and exclusiveness was impossible. Neither in 
 Asia nor in Europe can nations stand still, and stand 
 alone. If they fail to hedge themselves round with 
 useful alliances, they must depend absolutely upon 
 the sword for existence ; and the people which has 
 sufficient military strength to exist by the sword 
 alone, must go on continually enlarging the bounds 
 of their dominions. Mr. Hastings, therefore, felt 
 that even for the sake of that pacific policy which 
 in all the Court's letters from home was so vehe- 
 mently recommended, it would be necessary to put 
 the foreign relations of Bengal on a better footing ; 
 and he lost no time in submitting to his Council 
 his own views as to the best means of doing so. 
 
 Mr. Hastings's first object, of course, was to 
 place himself and his government in a just light 
 towards the powers with which they were already 
 connected. These were the Mogul, or Emperor, 
 or King Shah Allum, and the Nabob Vizier of 
 Oude, Shujah Dowlah ; of whose respective claims 
 upon the English, and of the causes in which they 
 originated, the following may be received as a correct 
 outline. 
 
 So early as the year 1764, Shujah Dowlah, having 
 espoused the cause of Cossim Ali, marched an army 
 into Bengal, whither he carried in his train the
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 337 
 
 Emperor Shah Allum, at that time a fugitive from 
 his own capital, and virtually a prisoner in the 
 Vizier's hands. The English at first retreated before 
 the invaders, but by and bye fought a successful 
 battle under the walls of Patna. They followed it 
 up with vigour ; and achieving a second victory 
 in the neighbourhood of Buxar, they drove the 
 Vizier back upon Benares, and reduced him to an 
 extremity. I need not describe, at length, how 
 General Carnac negociated with the fallen chief; or 
 how the Vizier surrendered both his dominions and 
 his person into the power of the conqueror. Never 
 was success more complete; while the uses to 
 Avhich Mr. Spencer, at that time President or 
 Governor of Fort William, proposed to turn it 
 were these. 
 
 While the struggle was going on, a third actor 
 had shown himself upon the stage, namely, Buhvant 
 Sing, the Rajah of Benares and Ghazepoor ; not 
 an independent prince, as the use of the term Rajah 
 might lead the ordinary reader to suppose, but one 
 of Shujah Dowlah's great vassals, or managers of 
 portions of his dominions. With the history of this 
 man's rise to power it is necessary that the reader 
 should be acquainted. For whatever the rights 
 might be which appertained to him, the same, and 
 no more, clearly descended to his successor ; whose 
 position nothing short of a royal phirman could 
 
 VOL. i. z
 
 338 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 alter, and in favour of whom no pliirman ever was, 
 as far as I know, either applied for or obtained. 
 
 Bulwant Sing was the son of one Manseram, the 
 joint holder Avith three brothers of a small zemin- 
 darry, of which the profits supplied the whole family 
 with an annual income, never exceeding in amount 
 four thousand rupees. The zemindarry in question 
 adjoined to the more extensive zemindarry of 
 Ghazepoor, which, as well as Benares, formed a 
 portion of the kingdom of Oude ; and Manseram, 
 who seems to have been a person of talent, found 
 occupation there under the Phousdar, RustanAlli. 
 This was during the reign of Shujah Dowlah's father. 
 But Rustan Alii was an indolent man ; he had, 
 moreover, fallen into arrear with his payments, and 
 gladly made over to his agent all authority in the 
 district, on the assurance that his debts should be 
 discharged, and himself saved from further trouble. 
 The latter promise was certainly kept, though not 
 in the sense on which Rustan Alii had counted. For 
 Manseram no sooner felt his own importance in 
 the district than he made use of it to crush his 
 indulgent master, and Rustan Alii died in prison, 
 while Manseram became Phousdar in his room. 
 
 To Manseram succeeded, as Phousdar of Ghaze- 
 poor, Bulwant Sing : for official occupations, equally 
 with lordships and crowns, have always tended in 
 India to become hereditary in particular families.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 339 
 
 He followed in his father's steps with such zeal, 
 that his neighbours, one after another, gave way 
 before him ; till by and bye he stood forth as one of 
 the most influential of the Nabob's vassals, having 
 obtained a confirmation of his authority, not over 
 Ghazepoor alone, but over the still more extensive 
 districts of Benares and Brudjegur. Hence when, 
 in 1764, a British army for the first time crossed 
 the Carumnassah, this man was found at the head 
 of ten thousand horse ; which he kept on foot osten- 
 sibly for his master's service, though in reality, and 
 as the event proved, with a view to employ them 
 in whatever way might appear to hold out the best 
 promise of advancing his own personal interests, 
 and enlarging his own political influence. 
 
 When nations engage in war, there is no repug- 
 nance on either side to enlist in its own favour the 
 services of any portion of the rival populations 
 which may chance to be dissatisfied with the go- 
 vernment under Avhich they live. In this spirit 
 the English gladly listened to Bulwant Sing's 
 proposals; and encouraged the demonstration 
 which he proposed to make against the prince 
 whom he was bound by his allegiance to defend. 
 They gained little, it is true, from his active friend- 
 ship for awhile, because Bulwant Sing proved 
 faithless to both parties ; but at least they detached 
 him from the service of the Nabob ; and towards 
 the close of the war he found it convenient to enter 
 
 z2
 
 340 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 into their policy. The consequence was, that when 
 hostilities terminated, Mr. Spencer found that 
 there were three separate parties with whom it 
 behoved him to treat; namely, the King Shah 
 Allum, Shujah Dowlah the Vizier, and Bulwant 
 Sing Raj ah of Benares, heretofore the vassal but now 
 the rebel, and the successful rebel, against the 
 Vizier's authority. 
 
 Mr. Spencer was exceedingly indignant with 
 Shujah Dowlah. He determined, therefore, that 
 from him further means of creating disturbances 
 should be taken away ; in other words he resolved 
 to strip him of his dominions, to allow him a small 
 pension for his subsistence and that of his family, 
 and to keep him ever after in the station of a 
 private person. With respect to the principality 
 of Oude, he proposed thus to dispose of it : to 
 Benares and the districts dependent on it, he, in 
 the name of the Company, laid claim ; while at 
 the same time, he engaged to continue Bulwant 
 Sing in the management, subject to the same pay- 
 ments, and liable to the same services which he 
 formerly owed to the Vizier. All the rest he was 
 prepared to make over to the King, whom he 
 further undertook to conduct, under a guard of 
 British troops, to Delhi, and there to establish 
 him on the throne of his ancestors. Meanwhile, 
 Nudjam ul Dowlah was to become Nabob of Ben- 
 gal, in the room of his deceased father, Meer
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 341 
 
 Jaftier, and from him the English were to receive a 
 monthly payment of five lacs, in order to cover the 
 expenses of the troops which they might find it 
 necessary to keep on foot, for the purpose of 
 maintaining him on the throne. 
 
 These were Mr. Spencer's plans ; but before he 
 could carry them into execution, Lord Clive came 
 out to take upon himself the charge of the govern- 
 ment ; and the whole device underwent a change. 
 Lord Clive entirely disapproved of the measure 
 of vengeance which his predecessor desired to mete 
 out against the Vizier. He accordingly proceeded 
 in a more placable spirit to Allahabad, where in 
 the month of August, 1765, he met the native 
 princes, and entered with them into a new treaty, 
 which has ever since been alluded to by historians 
 under the name of the place within which it was 
 prepared. By the treaty of Allahabad, then, 
 Shujah Dowlah was formally reinstated in his 
 sovereignty of Otide. Even the rajh or zemin- 
 darry of Benares was given back to him, with this 
 understanding that Bulwant Sing should continue 
 at its head ; and that his regular annual payments 
 should not exceed the amount for which he had 
 heretofore been liable. Meanwhile, that the King 
 might not go without his advantages also, to him 
 the provinces of Corah, Currah, and Allahabad 
 were made over, a narrow territory situated 
 between the Ganges and the Jumna, and up to that
 
 342 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 moment constituting a portion of Shujah Dowlah's 
 hereditary dominions. Finally, in return for the 
 phirman which conferred upon the English the 
 Duannee, or right of collecting the revenues over 
 Bengal, Bahar, and Orissa, Lord Clive undertook 
 to pay as tribute to the King the annual sum of 
 twenty-six lacs, which being calculated in English 
 money may be taken as something more than three 
 hundred thousand pounds sterling. 
 
 In pursuance of the terms of this treaty, Shujah 
 Dowlah re-entered his palace at Lucknow, Bulwant 
 Sing played the part of Viceroy at Benares, 
 while Shah Allum asserted his authority in the ceded 
 provinces. He could not, however, prevail upon 
 Clive to carry him back in triumph to Delhi ; and 
 growing impatient of further delay, he finally threw 
 himself into the arms of the Mahrattas. This act 
 of his entirely changed the nature of his connexion 
 both with the English and with the Vizier. The 
 Mahrattas were the avowed enemies of the latter ; 
 to the former they were at least not friendly ; and 
 as the English were bound to support the Vizier as 
 often as he might require their assistance, a war 
 between him and his'restless neighbours must lead to 
 an immediate rupture between them and the English. 
 For it had been part of Lord Olive's policy, while 
 he affected to deprecate all interference of his coun- 
 trymen in the quarrels or alliances of the native 
 powers, so to mix up the concerns of Bengal with
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 343 
 
 those of Oude, that the one became little else than 
 a mere dependency on the other. Thus, after pro- 
 testing against the march of a single soldier beyond 
 the line of the Carmnnassah, he consented to the 
 establishment of a whole brigade in Allahabad, the 
 payment of which drew from Fort William in the 
 course of five years not less than two millions 
 sterling. This was a ruinous drain upon the cir- 
 culating medium of Bengal, to which not a rupee 
 either in bullion or in merchandise returned ; and 
 the paltry payment by the Vizier of thirty thousand 
 rupees per month was scarcely felt as a relief, except 
 perhaps by the officers in command of the troops, 
 who reaped no trivial benefit to their private for- 
 tunes from the arrangement. 
 
 The treaty of Allahabad had not much in it 
 which was likely to meet with Mr. Hastings's ap- 
 probation ; and recent events were little calculated 
 to remove the objections which he might have 
 originally entertained to it. Every payment now 
 made to the King was, in point of fact, a payment 
 made to the Mahrattas, in whose hands he had 
 been a mere tool which they wielded without 
 scruple to their own uses. Moreover the King 
 had, in more than one way, exhibited, of late, a 
 disposition the reverse of friendly to the Company. 
 In the first place, his attempt, through Major 
 Morrison, to open a direct communication with the 
 Crown of England could not be acceptable, either
 
 344 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 to the Court of Directors, or to the local authorities 
 which represented them in India. In the next 
 place, Mr. Hastings Avas not ignorant that Shah 
 Allum had formally made over to the Mahrattas 
 the provinces of Corah, Currah, and Allahabad, 
 which the English had assigned to him, not for 
 the purpose of having established there a colony 
 of marauders, but as a territory from which he 
 might derive some means wherewith to support 
 the dignity of the crown. It was clear, therefore, 
 to Mr. Hastings, that the time had come for deal- 
 ing with the Mogul as with a shadow. Accord- 
 ingly he made up his mind, not only to withhold 
 the arrears which were due, and which the pressure 
 of the famine in 1769 and 1770 had occasioned ; but 
 to refuse in future all payments, whether claimed 
 on the ground of ancient usage, or referred to the 
 terms of the convention of Allahabad. It does not 
 appear that his view of the case met with any 
 serious opposition from the members of the Su- 
 preme Council. They, like himself, felt that every 
 saving made in the public expenditure was im- 
 portant ; and they could not, any more than he, 
 understand the wisdom of handing over to the 
 King sums which would immediately be applied 
 to their own injury, or to that of their ally the 
 Nabob Shujah Dowlah. 
 
 The King's demand for the arrear of tribute was 
 rejected, and it was plainly announced to him,
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 345 
 
 that in future he must not look to the East India 
 Company for any annual payments whatever. Far 
 be it from me to defend this proceeding on the 
 ground of abstract right. The rigid moralist is 
 justified in affirming, that having bound themselves 
 unconditionally to furnish the Mogul with three 
 hundred thousand pounds sterling, per annum, the 
 Company had no business to inquire into the uses 
 to which the money might be applied. But the 
 politician will take of this matter a different view; 
 and it is as a politician, rather than as a moralist, 
 that Mr. Hastings must, I apprehend, on the 
 present occasion, be tried. Nor is this all. Mr. 
 Hastings and his colleagues came equally to the 
 conclusion, that though they might be willing to 
 maintain the King in his sovereignty over the 
 provinces that had been ceded to him, they were 
 not bound to sanction the establishment there of a 
 people avowedly hostile. They therefore made up 
 their minds to resume the grant which Lord Clive, 
 under different circumstances, had conceded, and 
 to occupy with troops the most important posts 
 of the districts, so as to hinder it from sustaining 
 hurt from any sudden incursion of the enemy. Yet 
 there was no disposition, either on Mr. Hastings's 
 part or on the part of the Council, to lay so heavy 
 a load upon the Company's exchequer as would be 
 required to maintain these garrisons on a per- 
 manent footing. Corah, Currah, and Allahabad
 
 346 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 were too far removed from the Company's frontier 
 to be retained in the Company's possession, except 
 at a ruinous expense ; and the same forethought 
 which suggested the wisdom of excluding from 
 them hordes of Mahrattas, pointed out the means 
 of securing this advantage without any detriment 
 to the exhausted treasury of Calcutta. The idea 
 was suggested of selling them to the Vizier, whose 
 anxiety to recover so fair a portion of the domi- 
 nions of his ancestors was well known ; and the 
 project being favourably entertained, to Mr. Has- 
 tings it was left by the Council to devise the best 
 and speediest means of carrying it into execution. 
 
 While the Council at Fort William were de- 
 vising plans for the restoration to the Vizier of 
 the districts which he had lost, the Vizier himself 
 was meditating schemes of aggrandisement and 
 conquest, which in the course of a long corre- 
 spondence with Mr. Hastings he opened out, and of 
 which it is my business to explain both the origin 
 and the progress. 
 
 Adjoining to the kingdom of Oude, so as to be 
 to it, both in its geographical and political relation, 
 what Scotland was to England previous to the 
 reign of Queen Elizabeth, lay a tract of country, 
 of which the southern frontier was open, but which 
 to the west, and north, and east was bounded by 
 the Ganges and the mountains of Tartary. Into 
 that district a band of plunderers called Kohillas,
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 347 
 
 an Affghan tribe, had, about half a century prior to 
 the period of which we are now speaking, made 
 their way ; and being greatly superior in the use 
 of arms to the quiet and unoffending people who 
 dwelt there, they soon made themselves masters of 
 the country and called it after their own name. 
 There was nothing unusual either in this or in 
 the consequences that resulted from it. The sword 
 has in all ages been the arbiter of men's destinies 
 in Asia, where the right of conquest is just as 
 firmly established in five years as in five hundred. 
 But when the victorious adventurers refuse to be 
 at rest, and go on seeking continually to push 
 their conquests further ; then, indeed, the parties 
 liable to suffer from their turbulence are surely 
 not to blame if they endeavour to extirpate them. 
 Such was precisely the case in reference to the 
 Rohillas and their neighbours on every side. 
 Delighting in plunder, though seldom without a 
 view to effect a permanent extension of their sove- 
 reignty, the Rohillas carried their arms at one 
 time to the very gates of Delhi, and more than 
 once came into collision with the armies of Oude. 
 With the Mahrattas, likewise, they had frequent 
 encounters, sometimes singly, sometimes in com- 
 bination with the King and the Vizier. But 
 they were too weak, in point of numbers, to sus- 
 tain for ever such a complication of wars. They 
 therefore narrowed by degrees their circle of
 
 348 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 hostilities, and were glad in the end to find in an 
 alliance with the Vizier, protection from a power 
 which they had rashly provoked and were unable 
 to resist. 
 
 The Rohillas would have willingly drawn the 
 Vizier into an offensive war with the people whom 
 they hated. To this, however, the Vizier would 
 not agree ; partly because he knew that the Eng- 
 lish were averse to the measure, and partly because 
 he had himself nothing to gain by it. When, 
 however, the Mahrattas took possession of the 
 Dooab, Shujah Dowlah's scruples gave way, and 
 he felt that it Avas time to interfere. He accord- 
 ingly concluded with the Rohillas a treaty, by 
 which he bound himself to protect them, in case 
 the Mahrattas should make a demonstration against 
 their country ; while they agreed to assist him in 
 wresting the Dooab from the common enemy, and 
 to pay forty lacs of rupees towards defraying the 
 expenses of the war. The Rohillas complained 
 that the Vizier never rendered them any effectual 
 aid, nor of course fulfilled his engagements. Their 
 story was taken up, and repeated for party pur- 
 poses, both in the House of Commons and at Mr. 
 Hastings' s trial in Westminster Hall; but it is 
 surely without foundation. If more active mea- 
 sures were not taken, the fault lay, not with Shujah 
 Dowlah, but with Sir Robert Barker, who kept 
 his brigade on the north side of the Ganges, and
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 349 
 
 without whose co-operation the Vizier could do 
 nothing. Yet even this movement in advance, 
 sluggish as it may be called, proved essentially 
 serviceable to the Rohillas, for it hindered the 
 permanent establishment of a Mahratta force in 
 the heart of the country, and at least saved their 
 independence. The Rohillas, on the other hand, 
 were no sooner delivered from the apprehensions 
 of immediate danger, by the retreat of the Mah- 
 rattas, than they entirely forgot the serious obliga- 
 tions under which they had come. They resisted 
 all Shujah Dowlah's applications for the forty lacs, 
 and made preparations to overrun the Dooab, not 
 for him, but for themselves. The Vizier was 
 greatly irritated, as he had good cause to be, with 
 conduct so fickle, and proposed to Mr. Hastings 
 that it should be signally punished. In plain lan- 
 guage, he hinted at the wisdom, as well as the 
 justice, of displacing these Affghans altogether, 
 and annexing their territory to that of Oude. Now 
 I really cannot see upon what grounds, either of 
 political or moral justice, this proposition deserves 
 to be stigmatised as infamous. The Rohillas were 
 mere usurpers, owing, like the English, their 
 authority in Rohilcund, only to their swords. They 
 were a military body, perfectly distinct, both in 
 their manners and in their habits, from the popu- 
 lation which they governed ; and if too feeble to 
 maintain themselves in rights which were but
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 those of conquest after all, it was not to be expected 
 that the Vizier should put his own throne in jeo- 
 pardy in order to maintain them. Moreover, the 
 Rohillas had exhibited the reverse of good faith 
 towards the Vizier. They were a constant thorn 
 in his side; and tottering to their fall, the question 
 for him to decide was, whether he would submit to 
 the occupation of their country by the Malirattas, 
 or himself take possession, and convert what had 
 heretofore been a source of weakness into a source 
 of strength to himself and to the English. The 
 Vizier seems to have had neither difficulty nor 
 scruple in coming to a decision on the matter. He 
 at once demanded the assistance of the English in 
 a war to which both outraged honour, and a feel- 
 ing of self- protection, urged him; and Mr. Has- 
 tings, though he would have gladly avoided the 
 extremity, appears to have felt all along that to 
 such he might eventually be driven. 
 
 The game of politics between nation and nation 
 is, I am afraid, but a gambling transaction at the 
 best. Diplomatists may hide the real nature of 
 their designs under whatever form of words they 
 choose to select ; but they are poor masters of their 
 craft if they fail to keep the obvious truth in view, 
 that their first duty in all transactions with foreign 
 states is to secure some solid advantages for their 
 own. I am far from believing that Mr. Hastings 
 did not feel the force of Shujah Dowlah's argu-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 351 
 
 ments. Like the rest of the Indian world, he 
 beheld at that moment the growing power of 
 the Mahrattas with alarm, and was not less will- 
 ing than the Vizier himself to impose some check 
 upon it. But he was anxious, at the same time, 
 that in the benefits which the Nabob of Oude 
 expected to derive from the accomplishment of his 
 project, the East India Company should participate; 
 and as the Company was not only not desirous 
 of any extension to their territory, but positively 
 averse to it, he determined, in another and a more 
 acceptable way, to serve them. Mr. Hastings 
 resolved that the Vizier should pay in money for 
 the assistance which he craved. Moreover, the 
 point being a delicate one to settle, and Indian 
 correspondence proverbially diffuse and vague, he 
 came to the conclusion that it would scarce be 
 settled at all, at least to the satisfaction of both 
 parties, except by a personal interview. Under 
 this impression, he applied to his Council for leave 
 to meet the Vizier at Benares, and for full powers 
 to enter with him there into all manner of discus- 
 sions. The permission and powers were alike 
 granted, and Mr. Hastings went his way ; and the 
 results were such as he has himself stated in the 
 following series of letters :
 
 352 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 To Sir GEORGE COLEBROOKE. 
 
 Fort William, 12th October, 1773. 
 
 Dear Sir, I have been much disappointed in not 
 seeing your name in the new direction, but I shall con- 
 tinue to communicate to you as I have hitherto done 
 such events and transactions in this Government, as I 
 shall judge to be proper objects of your notice. 
 
 In my last I mentioned to you a project which the 
 Vizier had formed of conquering the Rohilla country 
 situated on the north of his, and annexing it to his 
 dominions, which would have been a great acquisition 
 of territory, wealth, and security, and brought all his 
 possessions within a complete natural boundary. The 
 correspondence upon this subject introduced the pro- 
 posal of an interview between us, which accordingly 
 took place. I left Calcutta for this purpose the 24th 
 June, had a meeting with the Vizier at Benares, where 
 I remained three weeks, and returned to the presidency 
 the 4th of this month. 
 
 The Rohilla expedition, to which I had offered my 
 agreement on the consideration of obtaining a saving 
 to the Company of one-third of the expenses of their 
 whole army, and thq payment of forty lacs on the con- 
 clusion of it, was suspended at the motion of the Vizier 
 himself, who feared his ability to fulfil the conditions 
 of it. 
 
 The disposal of the districts of Cora and Illahabad 
 was the next business of my negcciations. The King 
 having given them to the Mahrattas, we reclaimed 
 them as the original proprietors, on the plea that they 
 had been given to the King for his sole use, and when 
 his property in them ceased, we had a right to dispute 
 them with any new proprietor, especially with so dan- 
 gerous a neighbour as the Mahratta state. We accord- 
 ingly took possession, and it was left with me to dispose 
 of them in such a way as should be most conformable
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 35-3 
 
 to the Company's interests, and the rights of others. 
 Although the King was confessedly unable to maintain 
 them, still I wished for his concurrence in whatever 
 plan might be adopted for their disposal. I wrote to 
 him in pressing terms to send a person of confidence to 
 treat on that and other affairs in which he might be 
 concerned. He appointed a man of distinction to ap- 
 pear at the meeting, but afterwards recalled him, and 
 referred me to the Vizier, and to his Naib Moneer O' 
 Dowla, who had the government of these districts, to 
 whom the only orders which he gave were to demand 
 the arrears of the tribute due from Bengal, the punctual 
 payment of it in future, and the restitution of Cora and 
 Illahabad. 
 
 Thus circumstanced, and knowing that to give up 
 these lands to him would in reality be to give them 
 again to the Mahrattas, our enemies, and exposing the 
 dominions of the Vizier, our ally, which joined to them, 
 to almost certain ruin, I resolved to assert the right 
 of the Company to the possession of them, and to con- 
 vert them to such uses as their value and the neces- 
 sities of the Company required. I ceded them to the 
 Vizier for the consideration of fifty lacs of rupees, 
 twenty to be paid in ready money, fifteen at the expi- 
 ration of one year, and fifteen at the expiration of two 
 years from the date of the treaty (viz., the 7th of Sep- 
 tember.) 
 
 It is also stipulated in the treaty that whenever the 
 Vizier shall have occasion for the aid of our forces, he 
 shall pay for them 210,000 rupees per month, being 
 the computed amount of their whole expense. This is 
 still called an extra expense, as the treaty of 1765 
 stipulates only that he shall pay the extra expense, 
 which was fixed by General Smith at 30,000 rupees, 
 was raised in the beginning of the last year to 115,000, 
 and is now immoveably settled by treaty. 
 
 VOL. I. ^ A
 
 354 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 I have obtained a confirmation from the Vizier of 
 the zemindarry of Gauzypoor, &c., in favour of Rajah 
 Cheit Sing and his posterity, on the same tenure, and 
 with the same rights, that were granted to his father 
 Bulwunt Sing in the treaty of 1765. 
 
 I have settled with Rajah Cheit Sing an equal plan 
 of customs for all goods passing from Bengal to Mcr- 
 zapoor, which is the great mart of his and the Vizier's 
 dominions, excepting the articles of broad cloth, copper 
 and lead, bought at the Company's sales, which are to 
 pay no duties. 
 
 These are the only points of consequence which I 
 have effected. 
 
 By the cession of Cora, &c., the Company is freed 
 from the intolerable burthen of defending that country 
 for the King, and they acquire a vast sum of money for 
 parting with what they could not have kept, a season- 
 able supply to the deficient circulation of Bengal, and 
 to the public treasury, which, when I left it, had scarce 
 a rupee in it, and was loaded with a debt of a crore 
 and a half of rupees. 
 
 By the article regarding the payment of our forces 
 employed for the Vizier, we remove all the objections 
 which before attended every movement of our army, 
 and have made it the interest of the Company to give 
 him the assistance he wants, as it will prove an imme- 
 diate saving of the whole charge of almost one-third 
 of the army. 
 
 I have declared to the King that I would not con- 
 sent to let a rupee pass out of Bengal till it had re- 
 covered from its distresses, which had been principally 
 occasioned by the vast drains that had been made of 
 its specie for his remittances. The Board have con- 
 firmed this declaration by a' formal resolution that no 
 more money shall be paid him till the Company's 
 pleasure is known.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 355 
 
 I dare not enter into the reasonings on these various 
 subjects, which would be endless. My conduct has 
 been unanimously approved by the Board, the General 
 excepted, who has objected to every part of it. 
 
 I am not apt to attribute a large share of merit to 
 my own actions, but I own that this is one of the few 
 to which I can with confidence affix my own appro- 
 bation. At another time I will furnish you with the 
 voluminous materials which compose our record of this 
 transaction. I fear you will not have leisure to read 
 them. 
 
 If the Court of Directors shall think it proper to 
 disclaim what I have done, they must also point out the 
 means of undoing it. They must cancel the treaty, 
 (which God forbid ;) they must repay what they shall 
 have received from the Vizier, and relinquish their 
 claim to the rest ; they must discharge the arrears of 
 the tribute, and punctually pay the future yearly de- 
 mands of twenty-six lacs to the King. But from what 
 fund these great things are to be done, T am sure they 
 will be unable to direct. In a word, I have been hap- 
 pily furnished with an accidental concourse of circum- 
 stances to relieve the Company in the distress of their 
 affairs, by means, which, in my judgment, the most 
 partial advocate of the King cannot on their own 
 principles disapprove, but which on mine were never 
 wanting ; as I conceive, in strict political justice, the 
 King never had a right to a rupee from Bengal, nor 
 from Cora, after he had parted with it. 
 
 I do not imagine that I shall have any future occa- 
 sion to leave this presidency, until it shall please my 
 employers to put a period to my services, and shall now 
 devote my time to the reduction of the inordinate ex- 
 penses of this Government, and to the support of the 
 regulations which have already been formed. In the 
 Ibrmcr much has been done, and in justice I must say, a 
 
 2A2
 
 355 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 great deal in the time in which I was absent, but much 
 remains to be done. In the latter lie our greatest dif- 
 ficulties. A long habit of licentiousness, strong temp- 
 tations, the cursed encouragements of patronage, and 
 the sturdiness of independence, are too great evils to 
 combat with the weak powers of this Government, 
 which many possess and none can exercise. 
 
 I have the pleasure to inform you that we enjoy a 
 prospect of one year's peace. The Mahrattas arc re- 
 tired to their own country, and by the last advice from 
 Fort St. George, we hear that a revolution has been 
 made in their Government by the violent death of 
 Narrain Row their chief, and the elevation of his uncle 
 Ragonaut Row. I am not sufficiently acquainted with 
 his character and circumstances to form a conjecture of 
 the consequences which may follow this event. 
 
 The following discusses the same topics more at 
 length : 
 
 To LAURENCE SUUVAN, Esq. 
 
 Fort William, 12th October, 1773. 
 
 Dear Sir, I meet in every packet from England 
 such reverses of good and ill news that I begin to grow 
 indifferent to both, from the belief that in the instant 
 in which I read the intelligence of past transactions, 
 their effects are vanished, and new events and new 
 designs have succeeded them. This instability in the 
 affairs at home does injury to those of Bengal, and 
 weakens the authority not only of the Government but 
 of the Company. I scarce know why 1 make this 
 complaint to you, but that it w.as uppermost in my 
 mind, since it is not in the power of an individual to 
 apply the remedy to an evil which seems to run 
 through every branch of our constitution ; it adds con- 
 siderably to the weight of my difficulties. 
 
 I have already advised you, in my letter of the 2d
 
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 357 
 
 April, of the state of our affairs at that period. I 
 shall confine this to a single subject. 
 
 The loose manner in which our concerns with the 
 Vizier were conducted, and the great expense which 
 attended every movement of our army for his service, 
 first suggested the expediency of an interview with 
 him for the purpose of adjusting these and other points 
 which might furnish occasion for future discussion. 
 A new subject presented itself; The Rohilla chiefs, 
 when attacked by the Mahrattas, made an offer of 
 forty lacs of rupees to the Vizier, of which he promised 
 1o give half to the Company, for his assistance, and 
 engaged themselves to pay it by a solemn treaty. We 
 have delivered them from the Mahrattas, and the 
 Rohillas have paid nothing. The Vizier, judging this 
 a fair occasion to go to war with them, applied to us 
 for our assistance, engaging to pay fifty lacs of rupees 
 besides the extra charges of the army whenever their 
 country should be reduced. The correspondence upon 
 this subject introduced the proposal of a meeting be- 
 tween us. The Board approved of it, and Benares 
 was the place appointed for it. I accordingly set out 
 on the 24th of June with instructions and full powers 
 from the Board, and arrived at Benares the 19th of 
 August, where I found the Vizier. I had written re- 
 peatedly and pressingly to the King to request that 
 he would send a person with full powers to treat on 
 his affairs. He did not, but referred me to the Vizier 
 and Moneer O' Dowlah, whom he instructed to demand 
 the arrears of his tribute from Bengal, regular monthly 
 payments for the future, and the restitution of Corah 
 and Allahabad to his Naib Moneer O' Dowlah. 
 
 Before I proceed I must describe the situation of 
 the Rohilla country which the Vizier proposed to 
 reduce. It lies open on the south. It is bounded on 
 the west by the Ganges, and on the north and east by
 
 358 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 the mountains of Tartary. It is to the province of 
 Oude, in respect both to its geographical and political 
 relation, exactly what Scotland was to England before 
 the reign of Queen Elizabeth. 
 
 The reduction of this territory would have com- 
 pleted the defensive line of the Vizier's dominions, and 
 of course left us less to defend, as he subsists on our 
 strength entirely. It would have added much to his 
 income, in which we should have had our share. 
 
 I agreed to assist him in this project on condition of 
 his paying the Company an acknowledgment of forty 
 lacs of rupees, and the whole expense of our troops 
 employed by him, computed at 210,000 rupees for a 
 brigade. 
 
 As the King had forfeited his right to Corah and 
 Allahabad, by giving them to the Mahrattas, from 
 whom he had reclaimed and resumed them ; as he was 
 confessedly unable to keep them by his own strength, 
 and we could not afford to maintain them any longer 
 for him ; and as he had declined to send any person to 
 the conference, and thus left me unprovided with the 
 means of concerting any plan in which his interests 
 might be included, I agreed to restore this country 
 to the Vizier on condition of his paying to the Com- 
 pany forty-five lacs of rupees. 
 
 Things were thus adjusted when the Vizier, fearing 
 that he had engaged beyond his ability, desired to de- 
 cline the Rohilla expedition, to which I readily agreed; 
 but as he would have less to pay and less tp lay out, 
 the acknowledgment for Corah, &c. was increased to 
 fifty lacs, payable twenty in ready money, fifteen in 
 one year, and fifteen in two from the date of the treaty ; 
 and the payment for the monthly charge of our forces 
 employed in his service still stands an article in the 
 treaty fixed at 210,000 rupees. 
 
 This, Sir, I consider as a point gained of great inv
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 359 
 
 portance ; it will prevent the wanton requisition of our 
 aid on every frivolous occasion, and when they are 
 employed, instead of proving an addition of expense, 
 it will prove a reduction of one-third of our whole 
 military expense during the time of their service. 
 
 I was glad to be freed from the Rohilla expedition be- 
 cause I was doubtful of the judgment which would have 
 been passed upon it at home, where I see too much 
 stress laid upon general maxims and too little attention 
 given to the circumstances which require an exception 
 to be made from them. Besides this, an opinion still 
 prevails of the Vizier's great power and his treacherous 
 designs against us, and I cannot expect that my word 
 should be taken as a proof of their non-existence. 
 
 At such a distance what proofs can be given of such 
 a position? The first opinion, I conceive, to have 
 been asserted for the purpose of keeping him in a 
 state of impotence, that a military force might always 
 be wanted for his protection, and that the commander 
 of that force might have the rule both of him and his 
 country. I draw this belief from the records of former 
 transactions with him. The humiliating concessions 
 which we have required from him are instances of this 
 temper and design on our part. His compliance with 
 them are not weak proofs of the slight grounds of our 
 allegations against him. 
 
 On the other hand, the absence of the Mahrattas, 
 and the weak state of the Rohillas, promised an easy 
 conquest of them ; and I own that such was my idea of 
 the Company's distress, at home, added to my know- 
 ledge of their wants abroad, that I should have been 
 glad of any occasion to employ their forces, which 
 saves so much of their pay and expenses. 
 
 The brigade is now on its return to Bengal. 
 
 The residence of Europeans in the districts of the 
 Vizier is forbidden ; a plan of equal duties settled with
 
 360 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 Rajah Cheyt Sing from our provinces to Mirzapoor, 
 which is the only mart in his or the Vizier's territories, 
 and an exemption of duties for broad cloth, copper, 
 and lead bought at the Company's outcry. 
 
 The Rajah is confirmed in the zemindarry of Gazy- 
 poor, &c., with all the rights of his father Bulwunt 
 Sing, which are to continue unchanged to his posterity 
 for ever. 
 
 As I see no use in excuses and evasions, which all 
 the world can see through, I replied to a peremptory 
 demand of the King for the tribute of Bengal by a 
 peremptory declaration that not a rupee should pass 
 through the provinces till they had recovered from the 
 distresses to which the lavish payments made to him 
 had principally contributed. 
 
 The Board have supported this declaration by a re- 
 solution to pay him no more till they shall receive the 
 Company's orders for it. 
 
 You have already received my sentiments concerning 
 the injustice of this tribute even while he remained 
 with us. His desertion of us, and union with our 
 enemies, leaves us without a pretence to throw away 
 more of the Company's property upon him, especially 
 while the claims of our own Sovereign are withheld for 
 it. Yet he has his advocates, both here and at home, 
 Avho consider this treatment of him in the most criminal 
 light. 
 
 The Board have approved of my conduct. The 
 General has objected to it, and all my time since the 
 close of the despatches has been employed in defending 
 it. I cannot abridge either his reasoning or my own. 
 
 George Vansittart has sent a copy of all the prin- 
 cipal papers which regard these transactions to Mr. 
 Palk, who will show them to you. I am preparing a 
 longer work, which shall follow in the next packet, for 
 your inspection. I am, with the truest regard and 
 esteem, dear Sir, your faithful and obedient servant.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 361 
 
 Such were the results of Mr. Hastings's journey 
 to Benares, and of the personal intercourse 
 which he held there during the space of three 
 months with the Vizier. That they were in the 
 highest degree beneficial to the Company's in- 
 terests has never, as far as I know, been disputed. 
 There might have been fifty years ago, there may 
 still be, differences of opinion, touching the moral 
 fitness of several of the arrangements into which 
 the contracting parties entered ; but as far as Mr. 
 Hastings is concerned, one motive of action, and 
 one only, is perceptible, namely, an ardent desire 
 to execute the trust which the East India Com- 
 pany had reposed in him, by redeeming their 
 affairs from the state of absolute dilapidation into 
 which they had fallen. It is not, however, to be 
 supposed, that the attention of this great man 
 was exclusively devoted all the while to the adjust- 
 ment of the Benares treaty. The management of 
 that treaty seems, on the contrary, to have been 
 but so much additional labour imposed upon him ; 
 for his letters written while it hung in the balance 
 are innumerable ; nor is there any conceivable 
 topic, such as one in his position might be ex- 
 pected to discuss, to which they do not relate. I 
 find him, for example, writing to his colleagues in 
 council concerning questions of revenue, of civil 
 and commercial law, of military arrangements, and 
 of commerce. I see notes addressed to collectors
 
 362 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 and other detached functionaries, in which the rights 
 of zemindars and talookdars are explained. He 
 watches over the safety of the public roads ; he de- 
 vises new routes for the transmission of the post ; 
 he corresponds on these heads with Major Rennel, 
 the illustrious geographer, and communicates even 
 to him valuable information. When differences 
 arise between individuals, he comes forward as 
 umpire in the quarrel ; he advises, cautions, re- 
 bukes, and, where it is necessary, restrains. There 
 is no point, in short, so minute that he seems to 
 have passed it by, nor any so important that he 
 shrank from grappling with it. And throughout 
 the whole, one principle, and one only, seems to 
 have actuated him. He never loses sight of the 
 interests of his employers, as far as these are com- 
 patible with the just claims of the native popula- 
 tion ; he is forgetful only of himself. Moreover, 
 the temper, the discretion, the forbearance which 
 his letters display, are beyond all praise. Take, 
 for example, his mode of dealing with Sir Robert 
 Barker, a well-intentioned man, no doubt, but 
 bigoted to his own opinions, and no wise forgetful 
 of his own interests. This gentleman had already 
 taken offence, because Mr. Hastings, like a wise 
 man, substituted at the court of the Vizier his 
 own representative for a military officer, the mere 
 agent of the cominander-in-chief. He was doubly 
 offended because, in conferring with the Vizier at
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 363 
 
 tenares, Mr. Hastings had not permitted him 
 to be present at all the interviews. Accordingly 
 lie wrote to Mr. Hastings in terms which would 
 have called forth from almost any other man an 
 angry reply, and received in return the following 
 mild remonstrance. 
 
 To Sir ROBERT BARKER. 
 
 Benares, 2d September, 1773. 
 
 Dear Sir, The reproaches contained in your letter 
 are so unexpected, that I scarce know how to reply 
 to them, as I cannot recollect a single circumstance in 
 my conduct, since my arrival at this 'place, which can 
 justify them. 
 
 Before I entered on my conference with the Vizier, 
 I showed you my instructions, I desired your opinion 
 upon them, I requested your advice concerning my 
 proceedings, and had a long conversation with you on 
 every subject which occurred to me relative both to the 
 business of my commission and our mutual objects. 
 At the same time I frankly declared to you that one 
 object of my commission, as well as of my own parti- 
 cular wishes, was to establish a more immediate com- 
 munication between the administration and the Vizier 
 than had hitherto taken place, and as the responsi- 
 bility of affairs rested more on myself than on any other 
 member of our Government, to impress him with a 
 due sense of the authority which I held as the head of 
 it ; that I consider the second place as due to you, and 
 should as well in justice to yourself, as in consider- 
 ation of my own credit, which must be involved in the 
 success of your operations, use every means in my 
 power to support your authority, and add to your in- 
 fluence. I can solemnly affirm that I spoke with sin- 
 cerity, and that I have in everything which I have done
 
 364 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 which could any way affect your credit, acted to the 
 best of my knowledge in strict conformity to those de- 
 clarations. I have related to you all that has passed 
 between the Vizier and myself; I desired him to talk 
 with you upon the same subjects ; I received his pro- 
 posal for your remaining in the command with the 
 readiest acquiescence, assuring him, (as I have since 
 done yourself,) that I know no one whom I should be 
 so well pleased to have conduct of the measures which 
 might be agreed on, and that he had prevented my 
 making the same proposal to himself. 
 
 With respect to the subject of my negociations, I 
 have since informed you of the progress which I had 
 made in them, and received your opinion which I have 
 also made use of upon them. 
 
 With respect to the inattention which you charge 
 me with having paid you in my conferences with the 
 Nabob, I will candidly own that it was my declared 
 purpose, before I accepted of this commission, to 
 transact every point with the Vizier in person, and 
 without any participation or assistance. I should have 
 declined the trust, had it been thought necessary to 
 join any one with me in it, because neither could the 
 Vizier have imparted his mind with the same con- 
 fidence to me in the presence of others, or even of a 
 third person only, nor could I hope for despatch, where I 
 was to take the opinion of others on every new point 
 which might arise in the course of our conversation. 
 The Board unanimously adopted, if they did not first 
 express, these sentiments, and I was appointed their 
 sole agent in the business which I had undertaken. 
 
 I should be sorry if the other gentlemen of the 
 Board who are with me should take the like excep- 
 tions to my behaviour. 1 have been as explicit in all 
 matters to you as to them, and if a more frequent com- 
 munication has not taken place between you and me, it
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 365 
 
 has been solely owing to the distance of your quarters 
 from mine, which I have much regretted, as it has con- 
 stantly prevented my benefiting so much as I should 
 have wished by your assistance. 
 
 If in personal attention you think I have been want- 
 ing, I beg you will accept of this assurance, that it 
 has not been intentional, as my time has been wholly 
 engrossed by business. 
 
 It is scarce worth mentioning but to obviate what 
 may possibly have been misrepresented to you, that Mr. 
 Lawrell once, and Mr. Vansittart twice, were present 
 while I was conversing with the Nabob on business, 
 and each time by accident only, every other meeting 
 having been between the Vizier and myself, with no 
 one present but his confidant Mabmud Ellich Cawn. 
 
 The preparatory conferences ended, it was my inten- 
 tion to have requested both your presence and that of 
 the other gentlemen of the Council, who are here, to 
 form and draw up the articles to be agreed to. Your 
 last letter has made it an awkward circumstance for 
 me now to mention my wish in this particular. Had 
 it arrived a few minutes later, I should have written to 
 you to request that favour this evening, as I was that 
 instant going to do. 
 
 I expect the other gentlemen to be with me for that 
 purpose, and if it should not be inconvenient to you, I 
 hope no misunderstanding will disappoint me of the 
 hopes which I have of seeing you also. 
 
 You promised some days past to assist me with a 
 calculation of the separate expense of a battalion of 
 Europeans, a battalion of Sepoys, and a couple of 
 guns. Allow me to remind you of it, as it will be very 
 necessary to be inserted in the articles. I am, witli 
 esteem, dear Sir, your most obedient servant. 
 
 The following admirable letter, though a public
 
 366 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 despatch, must on no account be omitted. It 
 places in a conspicuous point of view the writer's 
 opinions respecting the extent of powers with 
 which the Governor-General ought to have been 
 entrusted, and therefore contrasts strongly with 
 proceedings which I shall by and bye be required 
 to notice. I add to it, likewise, a private commu- 
 nication on the same subject, and close with it 
 the correspondence of the year. 
 
 To the Honourable the Court of Directors for the Aft'airs of the Honourable 
 United Company of Merchants of England trading to the Indies. 
 
 Fort William, llth November, 1773. 
 
 Honourable Sirs, I have been duly honoured with 
 your letter of the 16th April by the Harcourt, and 
 duplicate of the same by the Egmont. 
 
 I am at a loss for words to convey the sense which 
 I entertain of the honourable terms in which you have 
 been pleased to express your approbation of my ser- 
 vices. While my gratitude is excited by these in- 
 stances of your kindness, I feel my zeal encouraged by 
 the assurances which you have been pleased to afford 
 me of your continued protection. My best expression 
 of thanks for both must be made by my future conduct, 
 which (if I know my own heart) will never be drawn 
 by any bias, however powerful, from the pursuit of 
 your interests, nor do I wish or aspire to any reward 
 superior to your applause. 
 
 While I indulge the pleasure which I receive from 
 the past success of my endeavours, I own I cannot 
 refrain from looking back with a mixture of anxiety on 
 the omissions by which I am sensible I may since have 
 hazarded the diminution of your esteem. All my 
 letters addressed to your honourable Court, and to the
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 367 
 
 select committee, repeat the strongest promises of 
 prosecuting the inquiries into the conduct of your 
 servants, which you had been pleased to commit par- 
 ticularly to my charge. You will readily believe that 
 I must have been sincere in those declarations, since 
 it would have argued great indiscretion to have made 
 them, had I foreseen my inability to perform them. 
 I find myself now under the disagreeable necessity of 
 avowing that inability ; at the same time that I will 
 boldly take upon me to affirm that on whomsoever you 
 might have delegated that charge, and by whatever 
 powers it might have been accompanied, it would have 
 been sufficient to occupy the entire attention of those 
 who were entrusted with it, and even with all the aids 
 of leisure and authority would have proved ineffectual. 
 I dare appeal to the public records, to the testimony 
 of those who have opportunities of knowing me, and 
 even to the detail which the public voice can report of 
 the past acts of this government, that my time has 
 been neither idly nor uselessly employed. Yet such 
 are the cares and embarrassments of this various state, 
 that although much may be done, much more, even in 
 matters of moment, must necessarily remain neglected. 
 To select from the miscellaneous heap which each day's 
 exigencies present to our choice those points on which 
 the general welfare of your affairs most essentially 
 depends, to provide expedients for future advantages, 
 and guard against probable evils, are all that your 
 administration can faithfully promise to perform for 
 your service with their united labours most diligently 
 exerted. They cannot look back, without sacrificing 
 the objects of their immediate duty, which are those 
 of your interests, to endless researches which can pro- 
 duce no real good, and may expose your affairs to all 
 the ruinous consequences of personal malevolence both 
 here and at home.
 
 368 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 May I be permitted, in all deference and submission 
 to your commands, to offer it as my opinion, that what- 
 ever may have been the conduct of individuals, or 
 even of the collective members of your former adminis- 
 trations, the blame is not so much imputable to them 
 as to the want of a principle of government adequate 
 to its substance, and a coercive power to enforce it. 
 The extent of Bengal, and its possible resources, arc- 
 equal to those of most states in Europe. Its difficulties 
 are greater than those of any, because it wants both 
 an established form and powers of government, deriving 
 its actual support from the unremitted labour and 
 personal exertion of individuals in power instead of 
 the vital influence which flows through the channels 
 of a regular constitution, and imperceptibly animates 
 every part of it. Our constitution is nowhere to be 
 traced but in ancient charters which were framed for 
 the jurisdiction of your trading settlements, the sales 
 of your exports, and the provision of your annual 
 investment. I need not observe how incompetent 
 these must prove for the government of a great king- 
 dom, and for the preservation of its riches from private 
 violence and embezzlement. 
 
 Among your servants, who for a course of years 
 have been left at large in possession of so tempting 
 a deposit, it is not to be wondered at that many have 
 applied it to the advancement of their own fortunes, 
 or that those who were possessed of abilities to intro- 
 duce a system of better order, should have been drawn 
 along by the general current, since few men are in- 
 spired with so large a share of public virtue as to 
 sacrifice their interests, peace, and social feelings to it, 
 and to begin the work of reformation on themselves. 
 
 I should not have presumed to expatiate on a 
 subject of this nature, although my own justification 
 has made it in some measure necessary, but that your
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 369 
 
 late advices have given hopes that we shall speedily be 
 furnished with your instructions for establishing a 
 system of law and polity which we hitherto want. 
 Whenever this work shall be accomplished on a 
 foundation of consistency and permanency, I will 
 venture to foretell, from the knowledge which I have 
 of the general habits and manners of your servants, 
 that you will hear of as few instances of licentiousness 
 amongst them as among the members of any com- 
 munity in the British empire. As this, whenever 
 attempted; must necessarily be a work of time, I 
 entreat your permission to submit to your consideration 
 such defects in your present system as my experience 
 has suggested to me, and I hope my intention will be 
 judged with candour, although my own ambition may 
 be gratified by the regulations which I wish to re- 
 commend. 
 
 I shall offer but two points to your notice. One is 
 the rapid succession of your governors ; the other, the 
 undefined powers of the respective members of your 
 administration. Both are productive of the same ill 
 effects, a want of vigour and consistency in public 
 measures, and a general diffidence and the consequent 
 spirit of intrigue in those whose interests or services 
 are by any mode of relation connected with our go- 
 vernment. 
 
 These well-known infirmities in our constitution 
 were frequently alluded to by the Vizier in the late 
 conferences which I had with him at Benares. He 
 lamented the perpetual hazard to which he was ex- 
 posed of losing the English friendship by the continual 
 changes of their chiefs, who were no sooner known to 
 him, and a confidence established with them, than 
 they were recalled, and others substituted in their 
 stead; whose tempers he was to study, and whose 
 affections he was to conciliate anew, and then to lose 
 
 VOL. I. 2 B
 
 370 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 them as he had lost their predecessors, and have the 
 same fruitless labour to repeat for ever. He once 
 asked me in plain terms what assurances I could give 
 him that new conditions would not be required of him, 
 or that those for which I should have pledged the faith 
 of the Company should not be eluded by a new act of 
 government, if six members of the Council should at 
 any time propose an infraction of the treaty, and four 
 only joined me in opposing it. 
 
 The powers of the governor, although supposed to 
 be great, are in reality little more than those of any 
 individual in his Council. Their compliance, his own 
 abilities, or a superior share of attention, and the 
 opinion that he possesses extraordinary powers,, may 
 give him the effect of them, and an ascendant over his 
 associates in the administration ; but a moment's con- 
 tention is sufficient to discover the nakedness of his 
 authority, and to level him with the rest. Happily I 
 find myself sufficiently secured against such effects. 
 The notice with which you have distinguished rny 
 services, the injunctions which you have laid on the 
 other members of the Board to afford me their support, 
 and the degree of responsibility which you have been 
 pleased to attribute to my particular conduct, have 
 contributed to strengthen my hands against any im- 
 proper opposition. At the same time I must do the 
 gentlemen of the Board the justice to declare that I 
 have found in them so cordial a disposition to co- 
 operate with me in every measure for the public good, 
 that I feel no want of extraordinary powers for myself, 
 nor, under such favourable circumstances, is it my wish 
 to possess them. I mention this want only as a defect 
 in the service, which is rendered still more important 
 by the false opinion that the principal authority rests 
 constitutionally in the hands of the president, when in 
 effect it is merely accidental.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 371 
 
 To draw the line between him and the other mem- 
 bers of his administration, and to define the powers 
 which may be entrusted to his charge, would not be 
 an easy task. In me it may be deemed assuming; 
 yet I conceive it to be my duty, because I am convinced 
 that the future prosperity, and even the being of the 
 Company, and of the national interests in this great 
 kingdom, depend upon it. The distant and slow 
 interposition of the supreme power which is lodged in 
 your hands cannot apply the remedies to the disorders 
 which may arise in your state. A principle of vigour, 
 activity, and decision must rest somewhere. In a body 
 of men entrusted with it, its efficacy is lost by being too 
 much divided. It is liable to still worse consequences, 
 the less the number is of which the body consists, 
 because the majority is easier formed. Fixed to a 
 single point only it can command confidence and ensure 
 consistency. I am compelled to affirm, because I 
 know not by what arguments to prove, what appears to 
 me a self-evident maxim. 
 
 On the other hand there is a danger that such a 
 power may be abused, unless powerful checks be pro- 
 vided to counteract the misapplication of it. These I 
 leave to your wisdom to form, if the modification of it 
 which I shall propose shall be found inadequate to the 
 purpose. I will not take up more of your attention 
 on this subject, but proceed to describe the points of 
 distinction which appear to me necessary for ascer- 
 taining the respective provinces of the Council, the 
 Select Committee, and the President. 
 
 1. The Select Committee shall have the power of 
 making peace and war, and of determining all mea- 
 sures respecting both, independent of the Council at 
 large. But they shall enter into no treaty of alliance, 
 whether offensive or defensive, for a longer duration 
 than two years without a special authority from the
 
 372 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 honourable the Court of Directors. Every such treaty 
 shall be communicated to the Council at large as soon 
 as it conveniently may be, that their opinion upon it 
 may be transmitted with it to the Court of Directors. 
 
 2. It shall nevertheless be allowable for the Pre- 
 sident to bring any matter before the Council at large, 
 although included within the foregoing limitations, and 
 the decision of the Council thereon shall be valid 
 and binding on the select committee. But no other 
 members of the committee shall be allowed the same 
 privilege. 
 
 3. The President shall have the privilege of acting 
 by his own separate authority on such urgent and ex- 
 traordinary cases as shall in his judgment require it, 
 notwithstanding any decision of the Council, or of the 
 committee passed thereon. On every such occasion 
 the President shall record his resolution to act in 
 the manner above specified, in virtue of the power 
 thus vested in him, and shall expressly declare that 
 he charges himself with the whole responsibility. 
 
 4. All civil appointments within the provinces shall 
 be made by the Board at large, but the President shall 
 be empowered of his own authority to prevent any 
 particular appointment, and to recal any person not 
 being a member of the Board, from his station, even 
 without a reason assigned. All appointments beyond 
 the provinces, and all military appointments which are 
 not in the regular line of promotion, shall be made by 
 the President alone. 
 
 I shall forbear to comment on the above propositions. 
 If just and proper, their utility will be self apparent. 
 One clause only in the last article may require some 
 explanation, namely, the power proposed for the go- 
 vernor of recalling any person from his station "without 
 assigning a reason for it." In the charge of oppres- 
 sion, although supported by the cries of the people and
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 373 
 
 the'most authentic representations, it is yet impossible 
 in most cases to obtain legal proofs of it, and unless 
 the discretionary power which I have recommended be 
 somewhere lodged, the assurance of impunity from any 
 formal ^inquiry will baffle every order of the Board, as 
 on the other hand the fear of the consequences will 
 restrain every man within the bounds of his duty if he 
 knows himself liable to suffer by the effect of a single 
 control. 
 
 I beg leave to return to the first subject herein offered 
 to your consideration by declaring that as I have no 
 wish in life equal to that of being useful in the sphere 
 which has been allotted me, so it is my fixed resolution 
 to devote my services to the Honourable Company so 
 long as your pleasure and my health will allow me : and 
 I offer it as my humble opinion that on whomsoever 
 you shall think fit to bestow the place which I now hold 
 in your service, it will be advisable to fix him in it for 
 a long period of time. I have already mentioned the 
 principal evils which arise from the too frequent 
 changes of your governors. I will beg leave to add 
 another, in which I shall need your candour to obviate 
 any misconstructions of it to my own prejudice. 
 
 The first command of a state so extensive as that of 
 Bengal is not without opportunities of private emolu- 
 ments, and although the allowances which your bounty 
 has liberally provided for your servants may be reason- 
 ably expected to fix the bounds of their desires, yet you 
 will find it extremely difficult to restrain men from 
 profiting by other means, who look upon their appoint- 
 ment as the measure of a day, and who, from the un- 
 certainty of their condition, see no room for any acqui- 
 sition but of wealth, since reputation and the conse- 
 quence which follows the successful conduct of great 
 affairs, are only to be attained in a course of years. 
 Under such circumstances, however rigid your orders
 
 374 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 may be, or however supported, I am afraid that in most 
 instances they will produce no other fruits than either 
 avowed disobedience or the worse extreme of falsehood 
 and hypocrisy. These are not the principles which 
 should rule the conduct of men whom you have consti- 
 tuted the guardians of your property, and checks on 
 the morals and fidelity of others. The case of self- 
 preservation will naturally suggest the necessity of 
 seizing the opportunity of present power, when the 
 duration of it is considered as limited to the usual term 
 of three years, and of applying it to the provision of a 
 future independency. Therefore every renewal of this 
 term is liable to prove a reiterated oppression. 
 
 It is perhaps owing to the causes which I have de- 
 scribed, and a proof of their existence, that this appoint- 
 ment has been for some years past so eagerly solicited, 
 and so easily resigned. There are yet other inconve- 
 niences attendant on this habit, and perhaps an inves- 
 tigation of them all would lead to endless discoveries. 
 Every man whom your choice has honoured with so 
 distinguished a trust seeks to merit approbation, and 
 acquire an eclat by innovations, for which the wild 
 scene before him affords ample and justifiable occasion. 
 But innovations of real use acquire a length of time, 
 and the unremitted application of their original prin- 
 ciples to perfect them. Their immediate effects are 
 often ^hurtful, and their intended benefits remote, or 
 virtually diffused through such concealed channels that 
 their source is not easy to be traced. Of this nature 
 are the late regulations in your revenue customs, and 
 in the commerce of the country, which have been at- 
 tended with an immediate loss in the collections, and 
 in the price of your investment ; and it will require a 
 long and intricate train of reasoning to prove that the 
 future increase of population, of national wealth, of the 
 revenue and trade, should such be the happy effects of
 
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 375 
 
 these expedients, were really produced by them. But 
 who that looks only for present applause or present 
 credit would hazard both for remote advantages, of 
 which another might arrogate the merit and assume 
 the reward ? Or who will labour with equal perseve- 
 rance for the accomplishment of measures projected by 
 others, as of those of which he was himself the con- 
 triver ? 
 
 Although I disclaim the consideration of my own 
 interest in these speculations, and flatter myself I pro- 
 ceed upon more liberal grounds, yet I am proud to 
 avow the feelings of an honest ambition that stimulates 
 me to aspire at the possession of my present station 
 for years to come. Those who know my natural turn 
 of mind will not ascribe this to sordid views. A very 
 few years possession of the government would un- 
 doubtedly enable me to retire with a fortune amply 
 fitted to the measure of my desires, were I to consult 
 only my own ease : but in my present situation I feel 
 my mind expand to something greater. I have catched 
 the desire of applause in public life. The important 
 transactions in which I have been engaged, and my 
 wish to see them take complete effect* the public ap- 
 probation which you have been pleased to stamp on 
 them, and the estimation which that cannot fail to give 
 me in the general opinion of mankind, lead me to aim 
 at deserving more ; and I wish to dedicate all my time, 
 health, and labour to a service which has been so flat- 
 tering in its commencement. 
 
 Such are my views and such my sentiments. I ex- 
 pose them without reserve, because I am conscious 
 you will find nothing unworthy in them, whatever opi- 
 nion you may form of their expediency. 
 
 I shall wait your determination with becoming ex- 
 pectation but without anxiety, nor shall I ever less 
 esteem the favours I have already received, because
 
 376 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 others are withheld which it maybe cither not expe- 
 dient or impracticable to grant. 
 
 I have the, honour to be, with the greatest respect, 
 honourable Sirs, &c. 
 
 To LAUBENCE SULIVAN, Esq. 
 
 Fort William, 18th December, 1773. 
 
 Dear Sir, I believe I informed you by the Latham 
 of a letter which I had written to the Court of Directors 
 respecting the powers of this government. I enclose a 
 copy of it for your perusal, and wish it to be confined 
 to your perusal, to Mr. Palk's, and Sir George Cole- 
 brooke's, if you think he will have a desire to see it. 
 I have already given him my sentiments upon the subject 
 in a letter of March last. If you consider my pro- 
 positions as reasonable, I am assured of a double 
 support of them in your influence from motives of 
 friendship, added to your regard for the service. Of 
 this I am certain, that at some period not far distant, 
 the powers which I have solicited, or greater, will be 
 given, whether it be my lot or that of another to pos- 
 sess them ; for it will be found impossible for a govern- 
 ment so extensive as this is to subsist in a divided 
 power, and that entrusted to persons whose views are 
 so limited as those of the members of the Council have 
 ever invariably been, and such I suppose they must ne- 
 cessarily continue while the present constitution lasts. 
 
 I believe I have read enough of your way of thinking 
 to presume that my sentiments on this point do not 
 differ materially from yours : but I must beg leave to 
 add a very bold word in my own behalf, which is, that 
 I do not know a man who may be more safely entrusted 
 with extraordinary powers than myself, or who would 
 be more likely to make a moderate use of them, as I 
 am neither vehement in the pursuit of gain, nor apt to 
 convert the authority which I possess to an instrument 
 of partial favour or enmity to others. I wish to merit
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 377 
 
 reputation, and as I am happily placed in a scene in 
 which, with the aid that I have required, I know myself 
 capable of attaining it, I would sacrifice every con- 
 sideration to so tempting an object. God forbid that 
 the government of this fine country should continue 
 to be a mere chair for a triennial succession of indigent 
 adventurers to sit and hatch private fortunes in. 
 
 If I have time for other subjects by this ship, they 
 shall form another letter. This I shall deliver to the 
 care of Colonel Chapman, whom T recommend to your 
 acquaintance, not as a candidate for future favours, but 
 as a pleasing companion and a sensible, honest man. 
 I am, with the truest esteem and gratitude, dear Sir. 
 &c.
 
 378 MEMOIRS OP WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 CHAPTER XI. 
 
 Change of Revenue System Letters carrying on the History of his Govern- 
 ment. 
 
 THERE is no production of human skill so perfect 
 but that defects may here and there he discovered 
 in it. There has never yet been created a system 
 for the management of masses of men., which has 
 not more or less failed to satisfy its authors. Mr. 
 Hastings had great reason, on the whole, to con- 
 gratulate himself on the results of his various ex- 
 periments ; yet in one, and that perhaps the most 
 important point of all, he was doomed to disap- 
 pointment. The revenue was not realized as he 
 had anticipated, and the blame was laid, according 
 to Mr. Hastings's view very unfairly, on the inability 
 or disinclination of the newly appointed collectors 
 to do their duty. Against this prejudice, had it 
 stood alone, he might, and probably would, have 
 borne up. He himself never appears to have 
 doubted that the cupidity of the natives, not the 
 remissness of the European collectors, was in fault ; 
 that the former, in their eagerness to farm portions 
 of the revenue, bid a great deal more for their 
 respective districts than the districts were worth ; 
 and hence that when pay-day came round, they 
 were unable to meet the demands of the tax-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 3?9 
 
 gatherer. But no opportunity was afforded him 
 of testing the soundness of this theory ; inasmuch 
 as there arrived positive orders from the Court of 
 Directors which he found it impossible to resist. 
 The facts of the case were these. 
 
 So early as the 7th of April, 1773, previously 
 to the arrival of Mr. Hastings's detail of the ar- 
 rangements which he had made for the future 
 management of the revenues, the Court of Directors 
 had caused a long and elaborate despatch to be 
 written, in which, after giving it as their opinion 
 that the institution of supervisors had not answered 
 its purpose, they went on to propound a plan of their 
 own, and to require, in peremptory terms, that it 
 should forthwith be carried into effect. What the 
 nature of the plan was will be best understood by 
 setting forth the immediate consequences of its 
 adoption ; for adopted it was, with the less hesita- 
 tion on Mr. Hastings's part, that he felt his own to 
 have proved, from some cause or other, a failure. 
 The changes, then, which the Court's letter intro- 
 duced into the fiscal machinery of the provinces 
 were these. ' 
 
 1 . The European collectors were recalled, and 
 in their room were appointed native dewans or 
 aumils, each of whom superintended a district cor- 
 respondent in point of extent to that over which, as 
 a collectorship, the Europeans had recently pre- 
 sided. Tiiere was, indeed, an exception made in
 
 380 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 favour of districts which were absolutely in the 
 hands of a particular zemindar or renter. Over 
 such no aumil was placed ; but the zemindar was 
 considered personally accountable to the provincial 
 council, within the limits of which his zemindarry 
 lay. In like manner the administration of civil 
 justice which had been entrusted to the collector 
 was, with the management of the revenue, trans- 
 ferred to the aumil ; from whom an appeal lay to 
 the provincial council ; and thence, under special 
 restrictions, to the Governor in Council acting as the 
 sudder dewanny adaulut. 
 
 2. A committee of revenue was formed at the 
 presidency, consisting of t\vo members of the Board 
 and three senior servants, whose business it was to 
 superintend and control the general revenue affairs 
 of the country, subject only to the Superior Council. 
 The committee had it in charge to order, from 
 time to time, visits of inspection to such districts 
 as might seem to require a local investigation ; and 
 to appoint to this duty not the senior servants 
 of the Company, but such as, by the knowledge of 
 the Persian and Hindostannee languages, and the 
 other qualifications of temper and talent, should 
 appear best fitted to execute the trust. All com- 
 plaints of the ryots or others against the dewans, 
 farmers, zemindars, or other public officers, were 
 to be finally received and decided upon by this 
 committee.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 381 
 
 3. The better to facilitate the working of the 
 system, the provinces were formed into six grand 
 divisions ; the first to be managed at Calcutta, the 
 second at Burdwan, the third at Moorshedabad, 
 the fourth at Dinagepore, the fifth at Dacca, and 
 the sixth at Patna. For each of these divisions a 
 provincial council was established, to consist of a 
 chief, four members, being senior servants, a Per- 
 sian translator, an accountant, and three as- 
 sistants. 
 
 Finally the councils received injunctions to 
 institute minute inquiry into the condition of 
 every talook, or other smaller portions of land, 
 within the limits of their respective jurisdictions, 
 so as to settle the proper localities and funds, 
 to ascertain the aumil's profits on the same, 
 and to furnish the Superior Council with such 
 information as might enable them to adjust and 
 arrange a complete system for the better ma- 
 nagement of the collections. It is worthy of 
 remark, however, that all this machinery of pro- 
 vincial councils was never meant except for tem- 
 porary purposes, because the Court's letter directed 
 that, so soon as the accounts and arrangements at 
 any of the divisions should be in a state to warrant 
 the step, the control of that division should be 
 brought down to the presidency. 
 
 Mr. Hastings, as I have already stated, did not 
 hesitate for a moment to obey the Court's orders.
 
 382 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 He appears, indeed, to have thought but meanly 
 of the construction of the machine, and looked 
 forward with some anxiety to the next that should 
 follow. But he at once attended to his instruc- 
 tions, and wrote in the following terms to his 
 friend Mr. Sulivan on the occasion. 
 
 To LAURENCE SULIVAN, Esq. 
 Fort William, 10th March, 1774, (per Resolution.) 
 
 Dear Sir, I should have thought it a duty to 
 address the Court of Directors upon the following 
 subject, if I had not the strongest reasons to believe 
 that any arguments which I may offer upon it will come 
 too late, as their last advices assured us that we should 
 be speedily furnished with complete regulations for the 
 management of the revenue, and the reports which 
 have reached us, however imperfect, of the changes 
 which have been introduced into the form of this 
 government are too circumstantial to be entirely void 
 of foundation. I should be sorry to expose myself to 
 the disadvantages which would attend the appearance 
 of an elaborate discussion of a proposition long ago 
 decided, and out of date ; much less would I choose to 
 reflect on a measure already perhaps resolved on, and 
 past recall. I shall continue, therefore, upon this, as 
 I have always done on other occasions, to make you the 
 trustee of my private opinions, being convinced that, 
 whether you are in or out of office, they will prove 
 more useful in your hands than in any in which I could 
 deposit them. 
 
 In consequence of the commands of the Court of 
 Directors, in their letter of the 7th of April last, for 
 withdrawing the collectors from the country, and sub- 
 stituting some other plan for the temporary manage- 
 ment of the collections, it was determined, after many
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 383 
 
 meetings and deliberations held by the Board upon 
 this subject, that a plan should be formed and recom- 
 mended for the future, and established regulation of 
 the revenue, at the same time that the temporary 
 one directed by the general letter was immediately 
 resolved on. The scheme of the first is briefly this : 
 to collect the revenues in the districts by the agency of 
 dewans, who shall be subject to the orders of a com- 
 mittee, or inferior council of revenue, resident at the 
 Presidency, and this to the general control of the 
 Superior Council. 
 
 I own it was with regret that I found myself com- 
 pelled to leave this plan in speculation, and to join 
 with the Board in forming a temporary arrangement, 
 which approaches too near in its principles to the 
 authority exercised by the collectors to render it eligible 
 as a permanent institution. But it was unavoid- 
 able. We were precluded from making any other than 
 a temporary plan, nor indeed would it have been 
 advisable to have attempted the immediate execution 
 of that which has been proposed. The Company's 
 interests have suffered already by the many innova- 
 tions which have been introduced into the administra- 
 tion of the revenue. The precipitancy with which 
 these have been made has contributed no less to their 
 ill effects, as every habit of any standing naturally 
 becomes rooted to the constitution, and cannot be 
 parted from it without some danger from the convul- 
 sion. Every essential change, therefore, requires to be 
 brought about gradually, with great tenderness, and 
 with every possible precaution, to supply the defects 
 occasioned by the removal of the former practice, and 
 to apply the new forms without violence to the people, 
 or a burthensome charge on the revenue. It is my 
 earnest wish to bring the superintendency of the col- 
 lections in their detail immediately to Calcutta ; but
 
 384* MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 this must be the work of time. The irregular and 
 loose state of most parts of the province ; the multitude 
 of small farms, and tealooks in single pergunnas, each 
 separately responsible for its own rents ; and the want 
 of substance in almost all the farmers of the revenue, 
 require a near and vigilant control both for the 
 security of the people from oppression, and of the col- 
 lections from embezzlement, neglect, and dissipation. 
 Jn short I found that the members of the Board them- 
 selves, and especially those who have ever shown them- 
 selves most diligent and knowing in the business of 
 the revenue, were unwilling and fearful to undertake 
 the management of it at such a distance from the 
 cucherries where the collections are immediately re- 
 ceived, until the country was brought into better 
 order. 
 
 It was therefore agreed that the provinces should be 
 formed into six grand divisions, including the pro- 
 vince of Bahar as one, and each be placed under the 
 charge of a chief and council, with similar powers to 
 those which the collectors singly possessed in the 
 smaller districts. To prevent the abuse which might 
 be made of this authority, the members of the Superior 
 Council from whom the chiefs are selected, have been 
 totally interdicted from trade, and the other members 
 of the Provincial Councils in such articles of it as are 
 most likely to prove oppressive or pernicious to the 
 country. As an incitement to the chiefs and other 
 members of the Superior Council to check any licen- 
 tious exercise of the influence enjoyed by the inferior 
 members in their private concerns, as an indemnifica- 
 tion for their own forbearance, and a pledge for their 
 faithful observance of it, it has been proposed that 
 they shall be allowed each a monthly gratuity of 
 3000 rupees, out of a fund raised for that purpose by 
 the profits arising from the sale of opium, which in con-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 385 
 
 sequence of a report made by me to the Board of the 
 state of the opium trade in the province of Bahar 
 soon after my return to the Presidency, has been made 
 a property of the Company. This, in effect, is only a 
 transfer of the private emoluments formerly derived 
 from this article of trade by the factory at Patna, from 
 them to the members of the administration; and I 
 venture to recommend it not only as a just recompense 
 for the additional labour and responsibility with which 
 the members of the Board are become charged on the 
 present system, but as a saving measure to the Govern- 
 ment itself. 
 
 I express with the more confidence my sentiments 
 upon this occasion, as I conceive myself the only mem- 
 ber -of the administration who is qualified to speak 
 disinterestedly upon it. And you will perhaps allow 
 it as a proof of my conviction of the utility of this al- 
 lowance, when you arc informed that I have totally 
 excluded myself from a participation in the benefits of 
 it, although you may easily suppose it to have been in 
 my power to take a more than equal proportion of the 
 trade itself, either for my own use or that of others to 
 whom 1 might have chosen to relinquish it, had it been 
 permitted to remain on its original footing. 
 
 If the Court of Directors should disapprove of the 
 measure, their orders may arrive in time to prevent its 
 taking place, as no division will be made till their reply 
 shall be received to our advices, which contain the first 
 mention of it. 
 
 As the institution of provincial councils for the ad- 
 ministration of the affairs of the revenue has often been 
 talked of as a useful expedient, I am afraid it will have 
 many advocates, both here and at home. For my own 
 part, I esteem it as a temporary expedient, both useful 
 and necessary, as I have declared already : but as a 
 fixed and established regulation, I am apprehensive 
 VOL. I. 2 C
 
 386 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 that it will be attended with consequences oppressive 
 to the inhabitants, prejudicial to the revenue, and 
 ruinous to the trade of the country. Each division 
 would be liable to become a separate tyranny of the 
 most absolute kind, because from its decrees there 
 could be no appeal but to the council of Calcutta, who 
 (the president excepted) would be parties in every 
 cause against the appellants, and because the people 
 would lie too much at the mercy of their rulers to dare 
 to lift up their voices against them. The trade of the 
 country would be monopolised or laid under contri- 
 bution, for who would hazard their property against 
 the combined influence of private interest and uncon- 
 trolled power? The revenues would suffer by the 
 taxes levied for private profit on the zemindars and 
 farmers, which the reiats would be compelled to pay, 
 and thereby become less able to pay the due rents of 
 government. Laws would be projected for partial and 
 insidious purposes, instead of the general good of the 
 country, or benefit of the state, and every division 
 would wear a different form of government, according 
 to the different interests or caprices of those who pre- 
 sided over them. 
 
 I have always considered the collectors as tyrants, 
 because the local advantages which they possessed, 
 added to the timidity and patience of oppression 
 which characterizes the natives of Bengal, restraining 
 them from complaining, and the chicanery and false- 
 hood for which they are equally notorious, discredit- 
 ing every complaint which they might prefer, made 
 it difficult for the Council to restrain them effectually, 
 especially as the same interest by which those offices 
 were acquired, would be always employed more or 
 less to protect them. Yet there lay an appeal to their 
 superiors, nor was it in the power of their patrons 
 to defend them in cases of notorious enormity. But if,
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 387 
 
 instead of junior servants, the members of the Board 
 are themselves to be collectors, these can be under no 
 restraint. Their judges in all complaints against them 
 will be composed of their equals, and expectants of the 
 same privileges. The president, whose more especial 
 care it will be to hear and redress the wrongs of the 
 people, will be a common object of hatred and jealousy 
 to the rest of the Council, because he will not partici- 
 pate in their common interests ; so that this system 
 would be liable not only to the worst species of despot- 
 ism in the inferior members of the government, but to 
 cause also a total anarchy at the head. 
 
 If the plan which I have recommended of leaving 
 the collections in the hands of the Dewans or native 
 officers, under the control of the committee of revenue, 
 should be judged liable to worse consequences than the 
 confirmation of the establishment of provincial councils, 
 I am still of opinion that the restoration of the collec- 
 tors would do less mischief, for the reasons which I have 
 already given. 
 
 There is indeed one way by which either might be 
 kept in awe, ; and that is, by investing the governor 
 ith full power to remove them by his own authority. 
 But this would raise such a spirit of opposition against 
 all his measures that it would be necessary to arm him 
 with still greater powers to counteract the effects of 
 the first. 
 
 This subject is too nearly connected with my o\vn 
 interest for me to pursue it with freedom. I will only 
 add that whatever system be adopted, extraordinary 
 powers must be given to the governor to enable him 
 to support the principles on which it is founded, and 
 these powers must extend in an equal degree to every 
 other part of his general authority. I am confident 
 in asserting these positions, nor have I a doubt that at 
 some time or other they will be reduced to practice, 
 
 2c2
 
 388 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 although I know very few with whom I would venture 
 to give my voice for lodging such able and tempting 
 means to do mischief. 
 
 After all I must return to my original opinion, that 
 the members of the Board be confined wholly and in- 
 dispensably to the presidency. Nothing can so effec- 
 tually strengthen the government, or secure the pro- 
 perty of the inhabitants from violence, and the trade 
 of the country from monopoly. But they must be al- 
 lowed a compensation for the restriction, and a liberal 
 one, such as will be binding on their integrity. They 
 must be wholly interdicted, as they now are, from trade, 
 and bind themselves by solemn engagements both to 
 refrain from it themselves, and to prevent, to the ut- 
 most of their power, the oppressive dealings of others. 
 Prohibitory laws and covenants may serve for good 
 grounds to institute a legal process for the breach of 
 them, but will not produce any real effect unless some 
 advantageous concessions are made at the same time to 
 the parties which will engage them by the principles 
 of gratitude and honour to the faithful observance of 
 them. This is not a maxim for the people of England, 
 who estimate the salaries and emoluments of men in 
 office in this country by no other standard than the 
 rate of exchange between rupees and pounds sterling, 
 and the comparative ranks and characters of those who 
 fill such offices, with their countrymen in the same line 
 at home, where they contentedly labour for the profits 
 of the day, and live and die in the bosoms of their 
 families and kindred. Here the administration of a 
 rich and extensive kingdom is in the hands of a few, 
 and the whole wealth of it at their disposal. The 
 distance of the supreme power on which it depends, the 
 servile habits and characters of the people, and the 
 nature of landed property, which by the constitution is 
 solely vested in the government, throw so vast a trust
 
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 389 
 
 into the hands of the members of the Council, as requires 
 adequate profits and incitements for the just discharge 
 of it, or, in default of such a provision, they will act as 
 men ever do in such cases, and carve for themselves. 
 
 I am, with the warmest sentiments of gratitude and 
 affection, dear Sir, your most obedient humble servant, 
 &c. &c. 
 
 P.S. Since writing the above, I have had some con- 
 versation with a gentleman of considerable rank in the 
 service, but who was not consulted in the late regula- 
 tions, and I was surprised to hear him complain of the 
 restriction which was laid upon the members of the 
 Board as a great grievance, and the compensatory 
 allowance of 3000 rupees per month, as no way adequate. 
 I add this to show the different ideas which people, 
 entertain on this subject. I think the compensation a 
 handsome one. The Court of Directors may possibly 
 think it too much. I regard it as the strongest proof 
 which could be given of the propriety of the restrictions, 
 that the allowance is judged unequal to the profits ac- 
 cruing from an unlimited trade. 
 
 The following seems, on various accounts, to 
 demand insertion. It gives an admirable sketch 
 of the system on which Mr. Hastings's govern- 
 ment was carried on, and of the indefatigable 
 industry with which he devoted himself to 
 business. 
 
 To LAURENCE SULIVAN, Esq. 
 
 Fort William, 20th March, 1774, (per Resolution.) 
 Duplicate (per Swallow) 25th August, 1771. 
 
 Dear Sir, I have written a separate letter to you 
 on one subject, to which I chose to confine it. I re- 
 quest you will give it your attentive perusal. I have
 
 390 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 since extracted the greater part of it in a letter to the 
 chairman. 
 
 The inquiry into the conduct of Mahommed Reza 
 Cawn is closed, and referred to the Court of Directors for 
 their judgment, which it is probable will acquit him of 
 every charge against him. In the meantime we have 
 released him on his giving an obligation that he will 
 not leave the province without leave of the Board, and 
 he has chosen Calcxitta for his residence. I in my 
 conscience acquit him of making a trade of grain in the 
 famine ; but, of the charges of embezzlement, had he 
 been an hundred fold guilty, it would have been im- 
 possible at this distance of time to have proved it 
 against him : I mean in the revenue. The accounts 
 of the Nizamut were in the hands of Rajah Goordass, 
 Nundcomar's son, whom I must suppose capable of pro- 
 ducing the most authentic proofs, if any exist, of the 
 Naib's misapplication of the money entrusted to him 
 for the Nabob's use. These ten months past I have 
 been urging the old man, his son, and the Begum, for 
 these accounts, in person, by letter, and by the means 
 of the resident, Mr. Middleton. They have been at 
 length sent, and contain nothing. A charge has since 
 followed of 262,000 rupees, said to be embezzled in the 
 article of exchange. This was produced by Goordass. 
 It was delivered to Mahommed Reza Cawn, and he im- 
 mediately avowed the fact i. e., that such a perquisite 
 did formerly exist, and was the property of the trea- 
 surers, but was converted to a fund for the payment of 
 sundry religious and gratuitous expenses of the 
 Nabob's household, by the advice and with the concur- 
 rence of Mr. Sykes, and he has shown by an account 
 in what manner it was disposed of. 
 
 Here the aifair rests, concluded, so far as it respects 
 Mahommed Reza Cawn, but I expect not to escape 
 censure in my own person for having brought it to so
 
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 391 
 
 quiet and unimportant an issue. Whatever disap- 
 pointment this may prove to the expectations of many, 
 I have the conscious reflection of having acted with the 
 strictest integrity, equally rejecting every, proposition, 
 both of his foes and his friends, that I could not recon- 
 cile to justice. I have taken every measure, by pro- 
 clamation, protection, and personal access, to encourage 
 evidences against him, and have given many valuable 
 hours, and whole days, of my time to the multiplied 
 but indefinite accounts and suggestions of Nund- 
 comar. I presided in every examination, one only day 
 cxcepted, and was myself the examiner and inter- 
 preter in each. The proceedings will show with what 
 wretched materials I was furnished. 
 
 Huzzoosymul, to whom I was also referred for in- 
 formation upon the subject of the monopoly of grain, 
 after much timid hesitation, declared he could give me 
 none. He is as upright and conscientious a man as 
 any I know, but he was either deceived by the 
 clamours of the multitude, or he feared to obtain the 
 hated character of an informer if he revealed what he 
 knew. 
 
 Mahommed Reza Cawnhas produced the attestations 
 of above 200 persons, mostly of credit, in vindication 
 of his conduct during the famine. His adversary has 
 produced a similar paper of attestations against him, 
 signed indeed by fewer names, and those little known. 
 Neither merit the smallest consideration. No honest 
 man in this country would have set his hand to the 
 latter, though he believed it to be true. Few would 
 have had the heart to refuse signing the former, 
 although he believed it to be false. We have at length 
 finished the regulation of our military expenses, and 
 almost completed that of the civil. The reduction in 
 both will be great, provided we are allowed a fair and 
 uninterrupted progress in establishing and confirming
 
 392 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 that part of it which requires time to accomplish that 
 is, provided we have no new systems to form, no super- 
 numerary servants to maintain, nor the extravagant 
 wants of China, Fort St. George, Bombay, and Balam- 
 bangan, to supply by an accumulation of our bonded 
 debt. A great saving will be immediately made. The 
 computed reduction of the civil expenses makes a dif- 
 ference of twenty-five lacs, and in the military forty. 
 (Vide P.S.) But something there will run out of the 
 former, and if we can save twenty in the latter, I shall 
 consider it as great economy. Hitherto nothing ap- 
 pears in our books which can do me credit as an eco- 
 nomist ; but for this many causes are to be assigned. 
 I have been paying the arrears of former governments. 
 Their excesses in the collections have occasioned heavy 
 losses in my time. The enormous and unchecked ac- 
 cumulation in every article of expense took its rise 
 before I came to the government ; and so universal 
 was the evil, and so ingenious were the people in the 
 practice of it, that though many useful regulations 
 have been made, they have no sooner stopped the 
 channel of one excess than it has broken out in some 
 other. They are now all closed, and I will answer for 
 the effect. 
 
 I forgot to add to the inheritance left me by my 
 predecessors a debt fluctuating between a crorc and a 
 crore and a half of rupees, the interest of which formed 
 an article of ten lacs a-year in our disbursements. 
 
 Many deductions were made by authority from home 
 from the revenue, which have since produced a pro- 
 portional increase in others, as in the customs, which 
 amount for the last ten months, since the commence- 
 ment of the new plan, to 10, 12, 893 rupees, which you 
 will better understand from the enclosed abstract. 
 
 The following abstract of the number of ships which 
 have entered this port in the last four years will like-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 393 
 
 wise show the improved state of the commerce of this 
 country, to whatever cause it may be owing. 
 
 Vessels. Tons. 
 
 In the year 1770, arrived in the river 88*, in all 22,475. 
 In the year 1771 101* 24,140. 
 
 In the year 1772 119* ti 26,184. 
 
 In the year 1773 161* 37,187. 
 
 469* 109,986 
 
 It is not easy to prove that the measures of govern- 
 ment have caused this improvement in our commerce, 
 but this improvement is a proof that our measures 
 have not lessened the trade of the country. 
 
 I have a pride in mentioning as one of the first and 
 most capital savings which I can truly claim as my 
 own, the stipulation made with the Vizier for the whole 
 estimated expense of the forces employed for his 
 service ; nor have I less satisfaction in the reduction 
 of the Nabob's stipend, in the suspension of the King's 
 tribute, and in the treaty money for Cora and Illa- 
 habad ; to which I might add the money which would 
 have been laid out in maintaining these provinces, had 
 we not parted with them. 
 
 We have been under the disagreeable necessity of 
 refusing to comply with the requisitions made on us by 
 the presidencies of Fort St. George and Bombay for 
 remittances. We have with difficulty, and a great loss 
 in the exchange, supplied the latter with 15 lacs, 
 which is 11^ lacs short of their demand. I hope 
 the necessities of Bengal, and its superior importance, 
 will be judged adequate reasons for our refusal. 
 Neither seem to want money more than we do, nor to 
 have more useful purposes for the application of it. 
 
 You have been already informed of the publication 
 
 * This is exclusive of small craft innumerable that take no 
 pilots, and pay no customs.
 
 394 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 which was issued in May or June last, forbidding the 
 use of force in engaging the service of the weavers, 
 whether for the Company's investment or the business 
 of private merchants. It has been attended with no 
 ill effect, and I fear has not been well enforced. There 
 is such a spirit of despotism and servitude rooted in 
 the dispositions of the people of Bengal, that it is the 
 most difficult point that can be imagined to check the 
 one, or prevail on the meaner orders of the people to 
 accept of their freedom. 
 
 From a conviction of the insufficiency of the com- 
 mittee of commerce to manage the investment, from 
 one cause especially, that they never met ; and in 
 order to interest the reputation and ambition of one 
 person in the success of it, it has been resolved to 
 commit it to the immediate care of one person, with 
 the title of comptroller of the investment. Mr. Alder- 
 sey has been chosen for this office, a man of business 
 and of talents particularly adapted to this department. 
 I have the greatest hopes of success from it. 
 
 Mr. Goodwin, another member of the board, has 
 been nominated to another control over the offices at 
 the presidency, with a power to audit and correct the 
 accounts, and suspend their disbursements. 
 
 The most effectual check will be in the military ex- 
 penses, through the control of the commissary-general. 
 Colonel M'Lean has unfortunately been disabled by 
 sickness from exerting himself much to this time, and 
 is gone to the coast for his recovery ; but he appears 
 amply qualified and equally disposed to answer the 
 expectations which have been formed from his ap- 
 pointment. 
 
 Our Cooch Bahar expedition has, I hope, terminated 
 in an advantageous and creditable manner. The 
 Booteas have solicited peace, offering to give up the 
 whole open country, requiring only the possession of
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 395 
 
 the woods and low lands lying at the foot of the moun- 
 tains, without which they cannot subsist, and the 
 liberty of trading duty free as formerly to Rungpore as 
 soon as the peace should be concluded. Their pro- 
 posals were received about three days ago, and orders 
 were immediately returned to Mr. Purling to accept 
 them. We shall have acquired a rich and valuable 
 country; and I believe there is little hazard of our 
 meeting with more trouble from the Booteas, who have 
 afforded many instances of a character much more 
 sincere, liberal, and polite than they were thought to 
 possess till we quarrelled with them. 
 
 The Seniassies threatened us with the same dis- 
 turbances at the beginning of this year as we expe- 
 rienced from them the last. But by being early 
 provided to oppose them, and one or two severe checks 
 which they received in their first attempts, we have 
 kept the country clear of them. A party of horse 
 which we employed in pursuit of them, has chiefly 
 contributed to intimidate these ravagers, who seem to 
 pay little regard to our sepoys, having so much the 
 advantage of them in speed, on which they entirely 
 rely for their safety. It is my intention to proceed 
 more effectually against them by expelling them from 
 their fixed residences which they have established in 
 the north-eastern quarter of the province, and by 
 making severe examples of the zemindars who have 
 afforded them protection or assistance. 
 
 The first brigade has marched into the province of 
 Oude on the requisition of the Vizier, for the declared 
 purpose of invading the country of the Kohillas on the 
 conditions before stipulated with him: but I believe it 
 will remain inactive as a guard to his province while 
 he is engaged in other designs, it being too late to 
 execute the Rohilla project. The brigade will gain 
 in its discipline by keeping the field, and its expenses
 
 396 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 will be saved, at least the greater part of them, by the 
 stipulated payment which he is to make for it of 
 210,000 rupees. As to the Vizier himself, he is busy 
 in adding the Dooab, or the country lying between the 
 rivers Jumna and Ganges, and lately occupied by the 
 Mahrattas, to his dominions. He has been successful, 
 having met with no enemy to oppose him. I have 
 appointed for my agent at his court Mr. Nathaniel 
 Middleton, a young man of a fine understanding, and 
 of a disposition perfectly suited to the employment. 
 
 The Mahrattas are in a state of the greatest dis- 
 traction. A confederacy is openly formed against 
 Ragonaut Row, their Peshwa, or head, by the majority 
 of the ministers and chiefs of that empire, headed by 
 Shawbajee Boosla, the chief of Berar. They have 
 seized the widow of the late Peshwa, Narain Row, 
 who was murdered to make way for the elevation of 
 Ragonaut Row, intending to set up the child of which 
 she is big, if he proves a boy, as no doubt he will, to 
 be their head. Ragonaut Avas before this event so far 
 advanced towards the Carnatic, as to alarm the gentle- 
 men of Fort St. George with the apprehension of an 
 invasion. They had accordingly appointed a con- 
 siderable force to take the field near the borders of the 
 Carnatic, but I suppose contrary to the inclination of 
 the Nabob, who has declared himself unable to pay 
 the expense of it, and this was the cause of their 
 applying to us for money. They are, however, in no 
 danger this year, nor ever, if my suspicions are well 
 founded, while Mahmud Alii lives. While I am upon 
 this subject, I must add, that the brothers of Jannoojee 
 are also at variance about the succession to his govern- 
 ment. Shawbajee, the eldest, is at the head of the 
 confederacy against Ragonaut, and his brother Muda 
 Jee with Ragonaut. A Vakeel from the former is now 
 at Calcutta. .*
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 397 
 
 These distractions in the Mahratta state afford us a 
 certainty of quiet in all the Company's dominions for 
 this season at least, and I cannot help lamenting that 
 we want a combination of the vast powers possessed by 
 the Company to derive some advantages from these 
 troubles. 
 
 We have had great disputes with the French on 
 occasions too frivolous to repeat, but founded on an 
 opposition of principles on points of the greatest im- 
 portance. They assert their right to a total inde- 
 pendency on this Government, and to include in the 
 same freedom all their dependants, that is, whom 
 they please. They pretend to a right to set up fac- 
 tories wherever they choose, and to exercise an uncon- 
 trolled authority over the weavers, and others, to whose 
 services they have any claim, disclaiming the authority 
 of the established courts of justice. We have desired 
 them to be quiet, and promised to avoid on our part, . 
 as much as lay in us, to touch upon these points in dis- 
 pute, till they could be decided by superior authority 
 in Europe. I wish they were decided, for their pre- 
 tensions are unreasonable and distressing, and their 
 manner of asserting them very provoking. They have 
 lately notified to us the dissolution of their Council, and 
 the nomination of Mr. Chevalier to the charge of com- 
 mandant for the King, and I suppose they will not be 
 more moderate with this new relation. 
 
 I have already, I believe, informed you of the arrival 
 of Mr. Lambert, with the first payment made by the 
 Vizier. Another of fifteen lacs will be soon due, 
 besides the monthly subsidy for the brigade. 
 
 Reports have reached us overland by the wings of 
 the Brussels Gazette of high honours conferred upon 
 me, and the appointment of my old friend, Mr. Impey, 
 to preside over our new court of justice, with other 
 circumstances too imperfectly related for me to judge
 
 398 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 whether I am to rejoice or be sorry for the change. I 
 am anxious for authentic advices, but shall continue, as 
 I have always done, to act as if no alterations were 
 expected. I am, dear Sir, your faithful and obliged 
 servant. 
 
 P.S. The savings which 1 have mentioned in the 
 second page of the second sheet, as likely to be made 
 in the military expenses., were taken from an unfinished 
 estimate. This has been since completed, and every 
 article which can swell its amount fully rated, and the 
 saving computed to be made, and which, I hope, will 
 be made by the new establishment, is 24,43,1 19 rupees. 
 
 It was not, however, on these grounds exclusively, 
 nor yet in reference to the system of manage- 
 ment generally pursued in the provinces, that the 
 individuals at the head of the Bengal Government 
 were at this time agitated by rumours of change. 
 The want of an efficient machinery for the admi- 
 nistration of justice between Europeans and 
 natives had long been deeply felt : and Mr. 
 Hastings, among others, had written many letters 
 on the subject. But Mr. Hastings, like all. who 
 were best acquainted with India and its population, 
 dreaded nothing so much as an attempt to supply 
 this deficiency by some rude and misshapen copy 
 from the laws, and the forms under which they are 
 dispensed, to the lawyer-ridden people of England. 
 Moreover, they had heard of a fresh commission 
 as about to be sent out a measure which was 
 indeed proposed, but fell to the ground while 
 some vague rumours touching the regulating Bill
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 399 
 
 of 1773, were rife among them. It was with the 
 view, if possible, of averting the evils that attend 
 the introduction of a new code into an old country, 
 that the following letter to Lord Chief Justice 
 Mansfield was written ; and I need not add that 
 the treatise spoken of so highly is now in every- 
 body's hands: Halhed's Digest of Hindoo Law 
 requires from me no word of commendation. 
 
 To Lord MANSFIELD. 
 
 Fort William, 21st March, 1774, (per Resolution.) 
 Duplicate (per Swallow) 25th August, 1774. 
 
 My Lord, I feel a very sensible regret that I have 
 not endeavoured to improve the opportunities which I 
 possessed by an early introduction to your Lordship's 
 acquaintance of acquiring a better right to the freedom 
 which I now assume in this address. The great vene- 
 ration which I have ever entertained for your Lord- 
 ship's character, and the unimportant sphere in which, 
 till lately, it has been my lot to act, were sufficient 
 checks to restrain me from such an attempt, however 
 my wishes might have impelled me to it. 
 
 I know not whether you will admit the subject of 
 this letter to merit your attention by its importance. 
 My only motive for introducing it to your Lordship is, 
 that I believe it to be of that importance, as it regards 
 the rights of a great nation in the most essential point 
 of civil liberty, the preservation of its own laws, a sub- 
 ject, of which I know no person equally able to judge, 
 or from whom I could hope for a more ready or effectual 
 support of any proposition concerning it. 
 
 Among the various plans which have been lately 
 formed for the improvement of the British interests in 
 the provinces of Bengal, the necessity of establishing 
 a new form of judicature, and giving laws to a people 

 
 400 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 who were supposed to be governed by no other prin- 
 ciple of justice than the arbitrary wills, or uninstructed 
 judgments, of their temporary rulers, has been fre- 
 quently suggested ; and this opinion I fear has obtained 
 the greater strength from some publications of con- 
 siderable merit in which it is too positively asserted 
 that written laws are totally unknown to the Hindoos, 
 or original inhabitants of Hindostan. From whatever 
 cause this notion has proceeded, nothing can be more 
 foreign from truth. They have been in possession of 
 laws, which have continued unchanged, from the 
 remotest antiquity. The professors of these laws, who 
 are spread over the whole empire of Hindostan, speak 
 the same language, which is unknown to the rest of the 
 people, and receive public endowments and benefactions 
 from every state and people, besides a degree of per- 
 sonal respect amounting almost to idolatry, in return 
 for the benefits which are supposed to be derived from 
 their studies. The consequence of these professors has 
 suffered little diminution from the introduction of the 
 Mahomedan government, which has generally left their 
 privileges untouched, and suffered the people to remain 
 in quiet possession of the institutes which time and 
 religion had rendered familiar to their understandings 
 and sacred to their affections. I presume, my Lord, if 
 this assertion can be proved, you will not deem it 
 necessary that I should urge any argument in defence 
 of their right to possess those benefits under a British 
 and Christian administration which the bigotry of the 
 Mahomedan government has never denied them. It 
 would be a grievance to deprive the people of the pro- 
 tection of their own laws, but it would be a wanton 
 tyranny to require their obedience to others of which 
 they are wholly ignorant, and of which they have no 
 possible means of acquiring a knowledge. 
 
 I cannot offer a better proof of what I have before
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 401 
 
 affirmed, than by presenting you with a specimen of 
 the laws themselves, which it will be necessary to pre- 
 face with the following brief history of the manner in 
 which it came into my hands. 
 
 A short time after my appointment to the govern- 
 ment of this presidency, the Company were pleased to 
 direct the administration here to take possession of the 
 Dewanny, or territorial government of these provinces, 
 in their name, without using any longer the intervention 
 of an officer of the ancient Mogul government under 
 the title of their Naib, or deputy, and gave them full 
 powers to constitute such regulations for the collection 
 and management of the revenue as they should judge 
 most beneficial to the Company and the inhabitants. 
 
 In the execution of this commission, it was discovered 
 that the due administration of justice had so intimate 
 a connexion with the revenue, that in the system which 
 was adopted, this formed a very considerable part. 
 Two courts were appointed for every district, one for 
 the trial of crimes and offences, and the other to 
 decide causes of property. The first consisted entirely 
 of Mahomcdans, and the latter of the principal officers 
 of the revenue, assisted by the judges of the criminal 
 courts, and by the most learned pundits (or professors 
 of the Hindoo law), in cases which depended on the 
 peculiar usages or institutions of either faith. These 
 courts were made dependent on two supreme courts 
 which were established in the city of Calcutta, one for 
 ultimate reference in capital cases, the other for ap- 
 peals. 
 
 In this establishment no essential change was made 
 in the ancient constitution of the province. It was 
 only brought back to its original principles, and the 
 line prescribed for the jurisdiction of each Court, which 
 the looseness of the Mogul government for some years 
 past had suffered to encroach upon each other. 
 
 It would swell this letter to too great a bulk were 
 
 VOL. I. 2 D 

 
 402 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 I to enter into a more minute description, although I 
 feel the necessity of making it more comprehensive to 
 convey an adequate idea of the subject. 
 
 As it has never been the practice of this country for 
 the pundits or expounders of the Hindoo law, to sit 
 as judges of it, but only to give their opinions in such 
 cases as might be proposed to them, and as these per- 
 petually occurring occasioned very great delays in our 
 proceedings, or were decided at once by the officers 
 of the Courts, without any reference, it was judged 
 advisable for the sake of giving confidence to the 
 people, and of enabling the Courts to decide with 
 certainty and despatch, to form a compilation of the 
 Hindoo laws with the best authority which could be 
 obtained ; and for that purpose ten of the most learned 
 pundits were invited to Calcutta from different parts 
 of the province, who cheerfully undertook this work, 
 have incessantly laboured in the prosecution of it, and 
 have already, as they assure me, completed it, all but 
 the revisal and correction of it. 
 
 This code they have written in their own language, 
 the Shanscrit. A translation of it is begun under 
 the inspection of one of their body into the Persian 
 language, and from that into English. The two first 
 chapters I have now the honour to present to your 
 Lordship with this, as a proof that the inhabitants 
 of this land are not in the savage state in which they 
 have been unfairly represented, and as a specimen of 
 the principles which constitute the rights of property 
 among them. 
 
 o 
 
 Although the second chapter has been translated 
 with a despatch that has not allowed time for rendering 
 it quite so correct as I could wish to offer it to your 
 Lordship's view, yet I can venture to vouch for the 
 fidelity with which it is generally executed, such parts 
 of it as I have compared with the Persian copy having 
 been found literally exact.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 403 
 
 Your Lordship will find a great mixture of the 
 superstitions of their religion in this composition. 
 Many passages in the first chapter are not to be re- 
 conciled to any rule known to us, but may be supposed 
 to be perfectly consonant to their own maxims, as your 
 Lordship will perceive that they have been scrupu- 
 lously exact in marking such cases as have received a 
 different decision in the different originals from which 
 this abstract is selected. 
 
 Upon the merit of the work itself I will not presume 
 to offer an opinion. I think it necessary to obviate 
 any misconception which you may entertain from the 
 similitude in the arrangement and style to our own 
 productions, by saying that I am assured they are 
 close and genuine transcripts from the original. 
 
 With respect to the Mahometan law, which is the 
 guide at least of one fourth of the natives of this 
 province, your Lordship need not be told that this is 
 as comprehensive, and as well denned, as that of most 
 states in Europe, having been formed at a time in 
 which the Arabians were in possession of all the real 
 learning which existed in the western parts of this 
 continent. The book which bears the greatest au- 
 thority among them in India is a digest formed by the 
 command of the Emperor Aurungzebe, and consists 
 of four large folio volumes which are equal to near 
 twelve of ours. 
 
 I have only to add that the design of this letter is 
 to give your Lordship a fair representation of a fact 
 of which the world has been misinformed, to the great 
 injury of this country, and to prevent the ill effects 
 which such an error may produce in a public attempt 
 to deprive it of the most sacred and valuable of its 
 rights. Even the most injudicious or most fanciful 
 customs which ignorance or superstition may have in- 
 troduced among them, are perhaps preferable to any 
 which could be substituted in their room. They are
 
 404 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 interwoven with their religion, and are therefore re- 
 vered as of the highest authority. They are the con- 
 ditions on which they hold their place in society, they 
 think them equitable, and therefore it is no hardship 
 to exact their obedience to them. I am persuaded 
 they would consider the attempt to free them from the 
 effects of such a power as a severe hardship. But I 
 find myself exceeding the bounds which my deference 
 for your Lordship's great wisdom had prescribed, and 
 therefore quit the subject. 
 
 I know the value of your Lordship's time, and re- 
 luctantly lay claim to so great a share of it as may be 
 required for the perusal of this letter. I assure myself 
 that you will approve my intention. My only appre- 
 hension is, that it may arrive too late to produce the 
 effect which I hope to obtain from it. I would flatter 
 myself that the work which it introduces may be of 
 use in your Lordship's hands towards the legal accom- 
 plishment of a new system which shall found the 
 authority of the British government in Bengal on its 
 ancient laws, and serve to point out the way to rule 
 this people with case and moderation according to 
 their own ideas, manners, and prejudices. But al- 
 though I should be disappointed in this expectation, 
 I still please myself with the persuasion that your 
 Lordship will receive it with satisfaction as an object 
 of literary curiosity, whatever claim it may have to 
 your attention from its intrinsic merit ; as it contains 
 the genuine sentiments of a remote and ancient people 
 at a period of time in which it was impossible for them 
 to have had the smallest connexion or communication 
 with the inhabitants of Europe, on a subject in which 
 all mankind have a common interest, and is, I believe, 
 the first production of the kind hitherto made known 
 amongst us. I have the honour to be, my Lord, your 
 Lordship's most obedient and most humble servant.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 405 
 
 CHAPTER XII. 
 
 Minor details in Mr. Hastings's Government Regulations concerning 
 Native Marriages Asylum offered to the Vizier's family Mission to 
 the Tershoo Lama Rohilla War. 
 
 THUS far we have followed in an unbroken course 
 the great stream of Mr. Hastings's administration, 
 every measure connected with which bears upon its 
 face the stamp both of an expansive intellect and a 
 solid discretion. Mr, Hastings found the provinces, 
 when he assumed the principal direction of their 
 affairs, labouring under the accumulated evils of an 
 exhausted treasury, and a government destitute of 
 influence. The revenues, collected nobody could 
 tell how, proved year by year less productive. There 
 were no tribunals to which men might appeal 
 against the oppressions of the strong, or the chica- 
 nery of the feeble. Bands of robbers wandered 
 over the face of the country, setting the resistance 
 of a \\ retched police at defiance ; while poverty 
 and sickness, the results of a terrible famine, 
 appeared to paralyze the exertions of the scanty 
 population that remained. With respect again to 
 the commerce of the country, whether we look to 
 its foreign or its domestic trade, that was totally 
 destroyed ; and partly through the misconduct of
 
 406 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 individuals, partly through the indifference of those 
 at the head of departments, the native merchant \vas 
 thrust absolutely aside, while the Company's invest- 
 ments fell to nothing, as much through the poverty 
 of the weavers and contractors from whom they 
 were obtained, as through the negligence of the 
 board whose business it was to watch over them. 
 Within the limited space of two years, Mr. Has- 
 tings entirely reversed this picture. From the 
 outrages of Deceits, and Seniassies, and other ma- 
 rauders, the provinces were grad ually delivered. He 
 hunted them down wherever they showed them- 
 selves, and in the end they ceased to be trouble- 
 some. The revenue system, if not perfect, was the 
 best which circumstances would allow him to form ; 
 for the five years' settlement could be regarded only as 
 an experiment. The establishment of district courts 
 for the administration of justice, likewise, and of 
 district officers to maintain the public peace, were 
 great steps taken towards better things. So also 
 his division of the Supreme Council into committees, 
 and his substitution of individual superintendents 
 for boards which never acted, equally contributed 
 to set the machine in motion, and to render its 
 movements certain and regular. And when we 
 take into account that all this was done, often at 
 the expense of private interests, oftener still in 
 despite of old and deep-rooted prejudices, it seems 
 impossible to deny to him who accomplished it, the
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 407 
 
 high praise of rare talent and industry such as no 
 amount of labour could break down. 
 
 Mr. Hastings accomplished all this not by 
 violence, for his powers were limited; but by 
 practising towards those with whom it was ap- 
 pointed him to act the utmost degree of forbearance 
 and conciliation. In some loose memoranda which 
 he appears to have drawn up with an undigested 
 view of becoming his own biographer, I find, for 
 example, this sentence : " I had the members of 
 the Council to conciliate all the while, and for this 
 was sometimes obliged to make sacrifices which my 
 mature judgment disapproved." Doubtless this is 
 true, nevertheless justice requires me to add that 
 the members of Council more than once yielded 
 their judgments to his ; and that too upon points 
 of no common difficulty. Among such I may 
 particularize their acquiescence in his plan of 
 erecting for the Company a monopoly in the trade, 
 first of opium, and by and bye of salt. Of the 
 condition of the opium trade under former govern- 
 ments, some notice has been taken elsewhere. 
 Originally appropriated by the native princes, it 
 became, during Clive's administration, a perquisite 
 of the Governor and Council ; from whom it passed, 
 by order of the Court of Directors, into other 
 hands; and finally was thrown open to general 
 competition. In violation of the maxims of political 
 economists, however, it began immediately to dete-
 
 408 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 riorate, and in a short time it ceased to be either 
 profitable to individuals, or a source of the smallest 
 revenue to the government. Mr. Hastings felt that, 
 if properly managed, the trade would revive. He 
 urged his colleagues to assume the care of it in the 
 name of their employers ; and offered to take upon 
 himself the entire responsibility of the measure. 
 With great difficulty he prevailed ; and farming 
 out to contractors the opium districts, he realised, 
 under extraordinary disadvantages, a revenue which, 
 continuing year by year to increase, became in the 
 end one of the most profitable sources of gain to 
 the Company. 
 
 Of this, as well as of his foreign alliances, Mr. 
 Hastings was justly proud. They were measures 
 not less advantageous to the East India Company 
 than they were creditable to their author. Yet there 
 was another, of which in the memoranda just 
 referred to he speaks with still higher exultation ; 
 and as I am sure that his reasons for so doing were 
 excellent, I shall give them in his own words : 
 "Of my foreign policy I had no cause to be ashamed, 
 but that on which I chiefly congratulate myself is 
 the abrogation of laws and usages oppressive to the 
 people, and of one most destructive to population, 
 which, though requiring little more than the stroke 
 of a pen to remove it, I particularly mention, 
 because though little known, arid perhaps forgotten, 
 it is one to which my mind ever recurs with self-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 109 
 
 satisfaction the abolition of the duties and fee on 
 marriage." Now this, though it may appear 
 trifling in the eyes of persons unaccustomed to look 
 at things, except as they are coloured by the state 
 of society in England, was no trivial boon to an 
 Asiatic population, where the Scriptural axiom 
 still holds good, and men's strength and wealth are 
 to be calculated according to the number and 
 healthiness of their children. Mr. Hastings was, 
 therefore, justified in regarding himself as a serious 
 benefactor to the people of India, by removing out 
 of the way an obstacle to marriage, which operated 
 injuriously in exact proportion to the degree of 
 advantage which fruitful marriages never fail of 
 bringing to those who from their poverty stand 
 most in need of them. 
 
 It was at this stage in his public life that two 
 events befel which led, indeed, to no important 
 results, but which, because they bear testimony to 
 
 the far-sightedness of the man as well as to the 
 
 o 
 
 degree of confidence which others were inclined to 
 repose in him, seem to demand that they should 
 not be passed by unnoticed. The Abdallies, a 
 powerful and warlike tribe from the north, threat- 
 ened to invade Hindostan, and the Nabob Shujah 
 Dowlah stood in great dread of the visitation. In 
 the valour of his own troops he seems to have had 
 little confidence ; indeed he despaired entirely of 
 the safety of his kingdom, and applied to Mr.
 
 410 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 Hastings for some place of shelter within the limits 
 of the British territories, where his own women, 
 and those belonging to the principal families at 
 Fezabad and Lucknow, might find an asylum. 
 " To this," says Mr. Hastings, " I most gladly 
 agreed, as a measure highly honourable in itself to 
 our government, and likely to add to the population 
 of the provinces, as well indirectly as directly. For 
 besides that the principals would bring with them a 
 large number of retainers and attendants, multitudes 
 of artisans would be sure to follow ; and the example 
 thus set would act as an encouragement to future 
 migrations." The Abdallies did not come, neither 
 was the migration carried out, very much to Mr. 
 Hastings's disappointment, who closes his brief 
 account of the affair with these words : " The 
 Nabob's death, and the miserable events which 
 began in 1774, rendered this plan abortive." 
 
 The other circumstance arose out of the war in 
 which the province of Bengal was engaged with 
 the Rajah of Bootan, and of which mention was 
 made in another part of this narrative. The Rajah 
 of Bootan, it will be recollected, had taken forcible 
 possession of the district of Cooch Bahar, and a 
 detachment of troops was sent to dispossess him. 
 The Rajah could make no head against the forces 
 of the East India Company ; Avhereupon Tershoo 
 Lama, one of the spiritual rulers or hierarchy of 
 Thibet, the second, indeed, in point of rank,
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 411 
 
 though acting as first on account of the minority 
 of Delai Lama, his superior, proposed himself as 
 a mediator between the contending parties. His 
 mediation was readily accepted, and at his inter- 
 cession peace was granted to the Rajah, on his 
 withdrawing from the country which he had in- 
 vaded, and engaging thenceforth to keep within 
 the limits of his own. But Mr. Hastings did not 
 stop there. With the eye of a great statesman he 
 saw that an opportunity was aiforded, certainly for 
 exploring the countries of Bootan, Thibet, and 
 Cashmere, possibly for opening through, them a 
 direct communication with China itself. He re- 
 solved not to neglect it ; and in return for cer- 
 tain civilities offered to himself by the Lama, he 
 commissioned Mr. William Bogle, a gentleman in 
 whom he reposed great confidence, to proceed to 
 Tapishudden, and there to act according to the 
 tenor of the instructions with which he was en- 
 trusted. I do not know that I should be justified 
 were I to give of this mission a detailed or par- 
 ticular account, because, though the undertaking 
 was a very bold one, and the object sought to 
 be attained of unspeakable importance, and the 
 prospects of attaining it at one period as bright as 
 the most sanguine imagination could have con- 
 ceived, the whole scheme fell eventually to the 
 ground. Still the omission on my part would be 
 quite inexcusable were I to pass the matter by un-
 
 412 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 noticed, for there is surely no criterion more unfair 
 by which to try the merits of great undertakings 
 than that of success or failure. 
 
 The facts of the case, then, were in few words 
 these: On the 13th of May, 1774, Mr. Hastings, 
 having well matured his plans, gave to Mr. Bogle 
 a letter of instructions, from which I copy the fol- 
 lowing extracts : 
 
 Having appointed you my deputy to the Tershoo 
 Lama, the sovereign of Bootan, I desire you will pro- 
 ceed to Lahassa, his capital, and deliver to him the 
 letter and presents which I have given you in charge. 
 The design of your mission is to open a mutual and 
 equal communication of trade between the inhabitants 
 of Bootan and Bengal : and you will be guided by 
 your own judgment in using such means of negociatidn 
 as may be most likely to eifect this purpose. You will 
 take with you samples, for a trial, of such articles of 
 commerce as may be sent from this country, according 
 to the accompanying lists, marking as accurately as 
 possible the charges of transporting them. You will 
 inquire what other commodities may be successfully 
 employed in that trade ; and you will diligently inform 
 yourself of the manufactures, productions, and goods 
 introduced by the intercourse with other countries, 
 which are to be procured in Bootan ; especially such 
 as are of great value and easy transportation such as 
 gold, silver, precious stones, musk, &c. 
 
 In this strain the letter went on to enumerate 
 the various objects which the mission was designed 
 to effect, considered merely as an affair between 
 two states which had heretofore been strangers to
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 413 
 
 one another ; but there accompanied it a second 
 and a private letter much more deserving of atten- 
 tion. I am sure that the reader will not blame me 
 for transcribing the latter document at length. 
 Both in matter and in style it is singularly charac- 
 teristic of the mind which dictated and the hand 
 that wrote. It is numbered into paragraphs, and 
 runs thus : 
 
 1. To send me one or more pairs of animals called 
 foos, which produce the shawl wool. If by a dooly, 
 cage, or any other contrivance, they can be secured 
 from the fatigue and hazard of the way, the expense is 
 to be no objection. 
 
 2. To send one or more pairs of cattle which bear 
 what are called cow tails. 
 
 3. To send me, carefully packed, some fresh ripe 
 walnuts for seed, or an entire plant, if it can be trans- 
 ported; and any other curious or valuable seeds or 
 plants, the rhubarb and ginseng especially. 
 
 4. Any curiosities, whether natural productions, 
 manufactures, paintings, or what else may be ac- 
 ceptable to persons of taste in England. Animals only 
 that may be useful. 
 
 5. In your inquiries concerning the people, the form 
 of their government and the mode of collecting their 
 revenues, are points principally meriting your attention. 
 
 6. To keep a diary, inserting whatever passes before 
 your observation which shall be characteristic of the 
 people, their manners, customs, buildings, cookery, the 
 country, the climate, or the road, carrying with you a 
 pencil and a pocket-book, for the purpose of minuting 
 short notes of every fact or remark as it occurs, and 
 putting them in order at your leisure, while they are 
 fresh in your memory.
 
 414 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 7. To inquire what countries lie between Lahassa 
 and Siberia, and what communication there is between 
 them. The same with regard to China and Cashmere. 
 
 8. To ascertain the value of their trade with Bengal 
 by their gold and silver coins, and to send me samples 
 of both. 
 
 9. Every nation excells others in some particular art 
 or science. To find out this excellence of the Bootans. 
 
 10. To inform yourself of the course and navigation 
 of the Burramputra, and of the state of the countries 
 through which it runs. 
 
 It will be seen from this document that Mr. 
 Bogle was about to penetrate into regions concern- 
 ing the state and condition of which our country- 
 men at that time knew nothing ; and that from 
 this general ignorance Mr. Hastings himself was 
 not free. He did not even know that the Lama 
 was not a sovereign prince, but a priest, whose 
 influence was well nigh as great at Pekin as in 
 the capital of Bootan. As the embassy went for- 
 ward, however, fresh light continually broke in 
 upon him, and he became only the more desirous 
 that it should be increased. Mr. Bogle, for ex- 
 ample, was stopped at one of the frontier towns of 
 Bootan, and his personal safety in some measure 
 compromised. He persevered, however, Mr. 
 Hastings zealously supporting him, and reached 
 at last Tapishudden, where a further delay became 
 necessary. I cannot better explain the nature of 
 Mr. Hastings's views and feelings at this juncture
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 415 
 
 than by transcribing t\vo of the private letters 
 which he wrote to his friend. 
 
 Fort William, 10th August, 1774. 
 
 Dear Bogle, Your letters have relieved me from a 
 state of great anxiety. I shall be happy to learn that 
 you are allowed to proceed, but entertain small hopes 
 of it. If it is true that you cannot pass without an 
 order from the Emperor of China, perhaps you might 
 still be allowed to leave some persons with the Rajah 
 till such a licence could be obtained. Or I should be 
 well pleased to obtain a footing even at Tassuddea 
 and make that a central point of communication with 
 Lahassa. The Rajah would find his account in it. 
 Having engaged in this business, I do not like to give 
 it up. We should both acquire reputation from its 
 success. The well-judging world will be ready to class 
 it with other wild and ill-concerted projects if it fail. 
 Make what promises or engagements you please with 
 your Rajah; I will ratify them. Leave no means 
 untried, but hazard neither your person nor your 
 health by an obstinate perseverance. If you cannot 
 proceed, return ; but, if you can, leave some one for 
 one of the purposes which I have above recommended. 
 Do not return without something to show where you 
 have been, though it be but a contraband walnut, a 
 pilfered slip of sweet briar, or the seeds of a bulte or 
 turnip, taken in payment for the potatoes you have 
 given them gratis. 
 
 In the same spirit is the following, dated 8th 
 September, 1774. 
 
 Dear Bogle, I have just received yours of the 20th 
 ultimo, and read in it with infinite pleasure that you 
 had surmounted all your difficulties, and were pre- 
 paring to proceed to Lahassa. I feel myself more in-
 
 416 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 terested in the success of your mission than in reason 
 perhaps I ought to be ; but there are thousands of 
 men in England whose good-will is worth seeking, and 
 who will listen to the story of such enterprises in search 
 of knowledge with ten times more avidity than they 
 would read accounts that brought crores to the 
 national credit, or descriptions of victories that 
 slaughtered thousands of the national enemies. Go 
 on and prosper, Your journal has travelled as much 
 as you, and is confessed to contain more matter than 
 Hawkesworth's three volumes. Remember that every- 
 thing you see is of importance. I have found out a 
 better road to Lahassa, by the way of Deggerchen and 
 Coolhee. If I can find it I will send it to you. 
 
 Be not an economist if you can bring home splendid 
 vouchers of the land which you have visited. 
 
 The superior council and judges are not yet come; I 
 expect them about November. You shall not suffer by 
 your absence ; I am your vakeel, and will take care 
 to seize every occasion for your advantage. Your 
 fellow-traveller has my good wishes, and God bless 
 you. 
 
 Mr. Bogle, as the ev r ent proved, had somewhat 
 over-coloured his own prospects when describing 
 to Mr. Hastings the kindness which was shown 
 him at Tapishudden. He never succeeded in 
 penetrating beyond that point. Yet such was the 
 good impression made by his politic and gentle 
 bearing upon the people in general, and in par- 
 ticular on Tershoo Lama, that the latter wrote to 
 Pekin in very high terms both of the English 
 nation and of their representative. The conse- 
 quence was, that two years subsequently, the
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 417 
 
 Lama was sent for by the Emperor, on which oc- 
 casion he solicited and obtained from his master 
 leave for the Bengal government to communicate 
 by letter directly with Pekin. There is no calcu- 
 lating the amount of benefit which might have ac- 
 crued from this arrangement, had circumstances 
 enabled Mr. Hastings to act upon it. Once 
 establish a friendly intercourse between our settle- 
 ments at Canton and the Imperial Courts, and 
 from the oppressions exercised by the inferior 
 authorities the British merchants would be de- 
 livered. Unfortunately, however, Tershoo Lama 
 died ere the first step had been taken towards the 
 attainment of so important an end, and there was 
 no one left of sufficient liberality as well as weight 
 to work out the scheme which he had devised. 
 For though Mr. Hastings at a subsequent period 
 sent another agent, Mr. Turner, to compliment 
 the new Lama and solicit his friendship, the latter 
 was still too young to act for himself; and the 
 whole device falling to the ground, was never 
 afterwards resumed. 
 
 Meanwhile the issues of Mr. Hastings's nego- 
 ciation with Sliujah Dowlah were beginning to 
 develope themselves in a manner which was not 
 altogether satisfactory to the author of the treaty. 
 From the first Mr. Hastings seems to have re- 
 garded a Avar with the Rohillas as probable ; yet 
 he imagined that it would not occur, at least for a 
 
 9 F 
 
 VOL. 1. 

 
 418 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 season ; and he founded his hopes, for to such they 
 amounted, on the knowledge which he possessed 
 of the Nabob's disinclination seriously to increase 
 the amount of pecuniary obligations under which 
 he already lay. A good deal to his surprise, 
 therefore, and somewhat to his mortification, it 
 was formally announced to him that so soon as the 
 rains should have ceased in the spring of 1774, 
 the Nabob intended to take the field, and that he 
 should expect to be accompanied in the invasion of 
 Rohilcund by the brigade of troops which then 
 occupied Allahabad. There was no shrinking 
 from this decision, because the faith of the govern- 
 ment stood pledged to support it. Mr. Hastings 
 therefore brought the question formally before the 
 Council, and after a long discussion it was agreed 
 that the brigade in question should co-operate 
 with the Nabob's forces, the Nabob becoming 
 bound for the pay and subsistence of the troops 
 during the war, as well as for a gratuity to the 
 Company of forty lacs of rupees so soon as it 
 should have been successfully terminated. 
 
 With the details of the military operations that 
 followed I have in this place no concern. For 
 these Colonel Champion and the Nabob Vizier 
 were alone responsible. Indeed, the absurdity of 
 endeavouring to couple them, either for good or 
 for evil, with the name of the Governor of Bengal 
 is so palpable, that it seems difficult to conceive
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 419 
 
 how the spirit of party itself could have led men 
 by any reasoning to be guilty of it. At the same 
 time, I must, as Mr. Hastings's biographer, protest 
 against the notion that, either directly or indirectly, 
 by positive sanction or wilful connivance, he gave 
 the smallest countenance to proceedings which 
 savoured, in ever so light a degree, of unnecessary 
 cruelty. He could not, indeed, himself dictate to 
 the Nabob, nor permit the commander of the 
 Company's troops to dictate, how the war was to 
 be carried on. He was the ally, not the master, of 
 the Vizier ; but here served to himself the right 
 of exercising a moral influence throughout, and 
 that right he freely exercised. The following 
 letters to Colonel Champion will show that, 
 wherever the Nabob transgressed the bounds of 
 moderation towards his enemy, he did so in despite 
 of Mr. Hastings's well known wishes; and that 
 if blame attached anywhere, it lay with Colonel 
 Champion himself, who either abstained from 
 interfering altogether or interfered injudiciously. 
 
 16th May, 1774. 
 
 Dear Sir, I received a letter this morning from the 
 Vizier, informing me of a complete victory gained by 
 the troops under your command over Hafez Ramit. I 
 cannot wait for your confirmation of the news to ex- 
 press to you my satisfaction with so fortunate a begin- 
 ning, which, I hope, will decide the issue of the re- 
 mainder of the campaign. I am happy with the 
 prospect it affords of future success : and allow me, my 
 
 2E2
 
 420 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 good friend, to say that I feel an equal pleasure in the 
 opportunity which has been afforded you of displaying 
 your abilities and acquiring an importance, at a period 
 when your merits appear to have been so much 
 neglected at home. It is from the fulness of my 
 heart I declare to you that none of your warmest 
 friends will rejoice more at every accession to your 
 reputation, or would more readily contribute to furnish 
 you the means of it. On this occasion I cannot omit 
 to take notice of the sensible and humane counsel 
 which you gave to the Vizier on the orders issued by 
 him for laying waste the Rohilla country, a measure 
 which would have reflected equal dishonour on our 
 arms and reproach on his authority had it been con- 
 tinued. You wisely judged, that to effect the conquest 
 of the country it was almost as necessary to conciliate 
 the minds of the people as to defeat the actual rulers. 
 
 To Colonel CHAMPION. 
 
 Fort William, 21st May, 1771. 
 
 Dear Sir, I am now to acknowledge the receipt of 
 your several letters, dated the 17th, 19th, 22nd, 23rd, 
 26th, and two of the 28th April, and your last, dated 
 the 2nd instant. To some parts of several of these 
 letters I have already replied, and I am now to take up 
 such subjects, both of these and some of your former 
 letters, as yet remain unanswered. 
 
 With respect to supplies of provisions for our iroops 
 cantoned in the Rohilla country, this is a subject of 
 much importance, and what you must endeavour to 
 adjust with the Vizier in such manner, impossible, as to 
 prevent any disappointment. The country of which 
 you have put him in possession appears amply qualified 
 to furnish all the supplies that can be wanted, and I 
 think you should yourself point out the measures requi- 
 site for this purpose. In case you should find him 
 dilatory or averse to such measures as you deem neces-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WAR REX HASTINGS. 421 
 
 sary, you must be under the necessity of securing 
 yourself, and you will acquaint the Vizier that he must 
 stand to the consequences which such a necessity may 
 occasion. In short, it is impossible to give positive 
 directions at this distance: it will rest with you upon 
 the spot to determine what measures to pursue, but my 
 opinion is that the Vizier will not fail you in this article, 
 which I found upon the experience of your own brigade 
 when it was cantoned one season in his country. 
 
 Hitherto every part of your conduct has met with my 
 most entire approbation. But there is one subject 
 which in some measure alarms me ; the very idea of 
 prize-money suggests to my remembrance the former 
 disorders which arose in our army from this source, and 
 had almost proved fatal to it. Of this circumstance 
 you must be sufficiently apprized, and of the necessity 
 for discouraging every expectation of this kind among 
 the troops. It is to be avoided like poison. How- 
 ever, in case any considerable capture should attend 
 your future operations, I think you cannot pursue a 
 better conduct than that which you intended, to deter- 
 mine nothing yourself, but acquaint the Board with the 
 circumstances and wait for their decision. 
 
 I repeat my congratulations to you on the conse- 
 quences of your victory, which has completely reduced 
 the Rohilla country and fully accomplished the service 
 proposed by the administration in their adoption of 
 this enterprise. Zabita Cawn, being personally secured 
 by the Vizier, I consider his country as equally subdued 
 with the rest of the Rohilla dominion, and I think you 
 should advise the Vizier to lose no time in sending a 
 part of his army to secure the possession of it, that 
 the whole of his new dominions may be in a settled 
 situation and in a condition to repel the Mahrattas, if 
 they should think of making any attack upon it in the 
 beginning of the next season, which the confusion of
 
 422 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 an unadjusted country might entice them to attempt. If 
 he take the proper measures for settling and possess- 
 ing himself entirely of his new dominions, they will be 
 as secure as his hereditary possessions from the attacks 
 of the Mahrattas. By the last advices I have received 
 from Poona, there is, indeed, very little cause of appre- 
 hension from the Mahrattas, who appear to be in such 
 a state of intestine division as will, in all probability, 
 disqualify them for some time from extending their 
 views to foreign operations. I am, with esteem, dear 
 Sir. &c. 
 
 The following relates, in part at least, to an actor 
 in certain transactions of which I have taken no 
 notice, because, bearing in no degree upon the 
 personal or public history of Mr. Hastings, they 
 would lead me, if taken up at all, into a labyrinth 
 of Indian intrigue and Indian warfare, from fol- 
 lowing which the reader would derive neither 
 amusement nor profit. I content myself, there- 
 fore, with stating that Nijeff, or Nujeff Cawn, was 
 a Rohilla chief, of great talents and singular mode- 
 ration ; that he had assisted Shah Allum with his 
 troops and with his counsel when that ill-fated 
 monarch made a last effort to deliver himself from 
 the bondage of his Mahratta connexion ; that, 
 unable to oppose the strength of the enemy, Nujeff 
 Cawn was stripped of his dominions, to which, after 
 their own intestine quarrels removed the Mahrattas 
 from Delhi, the King had restored him. Moreover 
 the King, the better to evince his sense both of the
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 423 
 
 sufferings and the services of Nujeff, had created 
 him general in chief of all his forces, and sent 
 him now to negociate with the leader of the British 
 brigade for, at least, a share in the territory which 
 the Vizier had conquered. It will be seen from 
 the tone of Mr. Hastings's letters that he entertained 
 no idea of building up the power of the King at 
 the expense of his own plighted faith, or the inte- 
 rests of the Nabob of Oude, his ally ; and for the 
 rest Mr. Hastings shall tell his own story. Colonel 
 Champion clearly forgot where the line of his duty 
 ran, and it became the business of the head of the 
 government under which he acted to remind him 
 of it. Hafez Ramit, to whom allusion is made, 
 was the last of the Rohilla chiefs who submitted ; 
 had Colonel Champion's plan heen followed up, 
 there would have been an end to all confidence 
 between the English and the Vizier. 
 
 To Colonel CHAMPION. 
 
 Fort William, 22d May, 1774. 
 
 Dear Sir, I have received your favour of the 5th, 
 which mentions the approach of Nejifcawn, near Bisooly. 
 I can hardly suppose that he is come with any design, 
 in concert with the Vizier, which may be adverse to you ; 
 but your first interview with him will, no doubt, have 
 produced a sufficient explanation of his intentions. I 
 should less dread him as a foe than as a friend, as in the 
 latter character he will, no doubt, make his court by 
 suggestions to the prejudice of the Vizier ; and as you 
 have many and large claims on the Vizier, and a very 
 delicate connexion with him, these circumstances will
 
 424 MEMOIRS OF WARIIEN HASTINGS. 
 
 unavoidably set his character in a point of view which 
 will greatly discredit it, in the comparison with a man 
 whose interest it will probably be to make himself 
 acceptable on all occasions. You are too remote for 
 advice, but I hope that the same moderation and pru- 
 dence which appear to have hitherto guided your 
 conduct towards the Vizier will have dictated to you 
 the propriety of not forming any connexion with 
 Nejifcawn, which may tend to disturb your engagements 
 with the Vizier. In opposition to these, no offers which 
 Nejifcawn may make, no pretensions which he may 
 assert, no authority which he may produce from the 
 King himself, are to be allowed the smallest consider- 
 ation. 
 
 I am sorry to find you have had so much cause to be 
 dissatisfied with the Nabob. In the last instance of it, 
 I mean his insisting upon your marching to Bisooly, 
 and cantoning on the banks of the Yarwafadar river, 
 after having appointed Barelly for your quarters, and 
 obtained the secure possession of Bisooly, I think his 
 behaviour very culpable ; and to prevent any improper 
 or dangerous use from being made of the power which 
 it was judged expedient to place in his hands, I hope 
 you will receive, in reply to your letter from the Board, 
 a discretionary reservation of an authority to act 
 according to your own judgment in cases where the 
 safety of the army shall be manifestly endangered. 
 
 His behaviour before and during the battle was 
 neither a subject of surprise, nor indeed of concern. 
 The want of personal or political courage would prove 
 a virtue in the Vizier, regarded as a security of his 
 fidelity towards us ; and his unsteadiness, although in 
 many respects it may prejudice the affairs in which we 
 are mutually concerned, is as likely to prevent his 
 attempting or executing any design which can ever 
 materially hurt us. I make no doubt but he will seek
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 425 
 
 a pretence to evade the payment of the money due by 
 his stipulation for the present service ; but it shall be 
 peremptorily demanded of him, and we have the sure 
 means in our power, which he well knows, to enforce 
 his compliance. 
 
 Your letter to the Board has been received, and will 
 be duly acknowledged, and I hope in terms that will 
 remove the difficulties of which you complain, though 
 you will allow me to observe that the channel by which 
 you have made them known was not regular, and might 
 on some occasions prove an impediment to the con- 
 sistency of our operations. I am, dear Sir, &c. 
 
 To Colonel CHAMPION. 
 
 Fort William, 27th May, 1771. 
 
 Dear Sir, I am extremely sorry that the line which 
 was drawn to separate your authority from the Vizier's 
 has been productive of such grievous consequences as 
 you mention. It never could have been suspected by 
 the Board that their orders to you would have tied up 
 your hands from protecting the miserable, stopped your 
 ears to the cries of the widow and fatherless, or shut 
 your eyes against the wanton display of oppression and 
 cruelty. I am totally at a loss to distinguish wherein 
 their orders have laid you under any greater restraint 
 than your predecessors. No authority which the Board 
 could have given could be capable of preventing the 
 effects you mention, since they could give you no 
 control over the actions of the Vizier further than the 
 weight and influence of your counsel and advice. 
 
 The orders under which you at present act leave to 
 tire Vizier the power of directing the services to be 
 performed, but leave you master of the means for per- 
 forming them. This clear distinction of your respective 
 powers was formed to prevent all disputes by removing 
 every subject of doubt. If, in the exercise of his autho-
 
 426 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 rity, the Vizier is guilty of oppression and other excesses, 
 he only, as the agent, is culpable of it. You have a 
 right, and it is your duty, to remonstrate against any 
 part of his conduct, which may either dishonour the 
 service or prove prejudicial to the common interest; 
 but I protest I do not know what you could do more, 
 or what the whole Board personally present and in- 
 vested with their full authority could do more. They 
 could exercise no coercive power over the Vizier without 
 committing a violence equal to any of these we should 
 complain of ; the picture you have given of the Vizier's 
 conduct, though general and allusive only, is shocking 
 to humanity ; but surely your advice and strenuous 
 remonstrance against acts of oppression and wanton 
 cruelty ought to prove some restraint, and if not, would 
 be a justification of your conduct. You have afforded 
 one instance, at the commencement of your present 
 operations, when the Vizier put a stop to the ravages 
 of the country at your intercession. 
 
 I have addressed the Vizier in the strongest terms 
 on the subject of his general conduct, alluded to in your 
 letters. If you will point out any other more effectual 
 remedy to such proceedings, or any addition which 
 could be given to your authority, not liable to the objec- 
 tion of establishing a divided power or an unjust 
 usurpation of his authority, I will gladly agree to it ; 
 but to take the family of Hafez Ramit immediately 
 under our protection would furnish him with a just plea 
 to refuse his compliance with the stipulation made for 
 the present service, as it would be in effect to conquer 
 the country for the Company, and not for him. The 
 ' Vizier would have cause to suspect, and the world would 
 adopt the same belief, that with the person of the here- 
 ditary claimant of the country we meant to reserve a 
 right, at some convenient period, to take possession 
 from him ; and while such an opinion prevailed, neither
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 427 
 
 could he establish his government in it, nor remain 
 steady in his confidence and fidelity towards us. On 
 better recollection, I have declined writing to the Vizier 
 myself on this subject, as intimated in the beginning 
 of this paragraph, lest the solicitude I might express 
 on account of the family of Hafez Ramit should increase 
 their misfortunes ; but I have instructed Mr. Middleton 
 to make the strongest representations on this subject, 
 which will perhaps have a better effect than anything 
 I could say from myself. 
 
 In the last letter from the Board, in answer to an 
 application you made with much impropriety to them 
 notwithstanding the occasion which by this measure 
 you gave for objections, you will have received unde- 
 niable proofs of their desire to support the credit of the 
 actual commander of their forces; and I hope the 
 addition therein given to your authority will have amply 
 provided for every case in which the safety of the army, 
 or the success of the service, can be any ways en- 
 dangered. I am, with esteem, dear Sir, &c. 
 
 To Colonel CHAMPION. 
 
 Fort William, 28th May, 1774. 
 
 Dear Sir, I have received a letter from the Vizier 
 complaining of the claim you made to search for trea- 
 sure in Pelibeet, and of the behaviour of some gentle- 
 men who were present at a conference he had with you 
 on that subject, and who took upon themselves to 
 become parties in the conversation. 
 
 I have already expressed my sentiments upon the 
 subject of prize money to the army. The only instance 
 wherein our troops in the present service could have 
 any pretensions to it by the customs of war would be 
 in the actual assault of a place by storm ; in every other 
 case it is clear that the capture becomes the sole pro- 
 perty of the power carrying on the war. In the instance 
 of Pelibeet, which made no sort of defence whatever,
 
 428 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 but fell with the whole Rohilla country into the hands 
 of the Nabob, in consequence of the victory, we had no 
 more right to search or interfere at all in the riches it 
 contained, than we had to ransack every defenceless 
 village or house in the open country for plunder. It 
 is true that oar General obtained the victory and our 
 troops bore the brunt of the action ; but such was the 
 tenor of our engagement with the Vizier, in considera- 
 tion of which he stipulated to pay a certain sum to the 
 Company, and to bear the whole expense of the service. 
 His own argument is unanswerable on this subject ; if 
 we deprive him of the fruits of his conquest, we infringe 
 the agreement upon which the expedition was set on 
 foot,, and he has a right on his side to refuse the payment 
 stipulated to us, because he depended on the fruits of 
 his conquest to enable him to make that payment. I 
 must here remark that the particulars of this transac- 
 tion, as mentioned by the Vizier, bear a very different 
 appearance from your account of it, and that when I 
 approved of the conduct you intended to have pursued, 
 it respected only your intention of delivering up what- 
 ever might be taken to the Vizier, and waiting for the 
 Board's determination. With respect to Pelibect, 
 however, and to every capture in the present service, 
 except, perhaps, in the case of plunder taken in an 
 actual assault, the right is clearly the Nabob's, and 
 will admit of no disputation. This is my positive 
 decision on the subject, which must be regarded by you 
 as an instruction for your conduct, until you receive the 
 sentiments of the select committee, in case you should 
 judge it necessary to apply to them on this subject. 
 
 With respect to the behaviour of those gentlemen 
 present at your conversation with the Vizier, of which 
 he complains, I am extremely sorry that an inattention 
 to the established customs among people of rank in 
 this country, which I am well convinced could not be
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARUEN HASTINGS. 429 
 
 intended on your part, should have been the cause of 
 so much mortification to the Vizier ; for agreeably to 
 their ideas of respect, it must have been extremely 
 mortifying to him, when he came to converse with you 
 upon a particular point of importance, to find those 
 whom he regarded as inferiors, obtrude their conversa- 
 tion upon him. To avoid every disagreeable circum- 
 stance of this kind, I have always made it a rule my- 
 self to have no person present upon such occasions, 
 except where an interpreter was necessary, and he 
 only for explaining what w r as said. I recommend the 
 same practice to be invariably pursued by you, and in 
 the present case I am in some measure necessitated to 
 prescribe this mode to you, as the means whereby a 
 free intercourse of opinions may take place between 
 the Vizier and you, and all uneasinesses and misappre- 
 hensions be avoided. 
 
 There yet remains a circumstance mentioned in a 
 former letter of yours, to which I have omitted to 
 reply, and which I am at present led to consider from 
 the nature of the subjects I have been treating of. _/ 
 formerly recommended to you to prohibit any officer 
 under your command from visiting the Vizier without 
 obtaining your previous permission, and this you ac- 
 quaint me has given much offence to Colonel Gailliez, 
 and Lieutenant- colonel Lesslie. But as it is an esta- 
 blished and a necessary rule in the service, I do not 
 sec any right these gentlemen have to be offended at 
 an adherence to it. I am rather disposed to think that 
 the manner and occasion upon which you made this 
 order public were the cause of displeasure to these 
 gentlemen, than the nature of the order itself. As it 
 'could only affect the superior officers of your army, 
 your signifying to them privately that you expected 
 their compliance with this regulation, in consequence 
 of an injunction you had received from me, would fully
 
 430 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 have answered the intention of enforcing it, and re- 
 moved the odium of the measure from yourself. But 
 to publish it in general orders to the army immediately 
 after Colonel Gailliez had made a visit to the Vizier, 
 most undoubtedly implied a public censure of his con- 
 duct, and I do not wonder that it proved to him a 
 subject of much mortification. With respect to my 
 motives for recommending this measure to you, it was 
 unnecessary for me to declare that they were directed 
 entirely to the support of your authority and dignity in 
 command. To exempt the second in command from 
 the effect of this restriction, however, in your present 
 situation, it may be unnecessary to an undesigning and 
 open disposition like Colonel Gailliez' s, yet the chief 
 intention of the regulation consists perhaps in the check 
 it might prove to the conduct of the second officer, if 
 he possessed an intriguing disposition, and an incli- 
 nation to thwart the measures of his superior : that 
 there are many such characters among mankind, your 
 own observation must have informed you. I am with 
 esteem, dear Sir, &c. 
 
 To Colonel CHAMPION. 
 
 Fort William, 28th May, 1774. 
 
 Dear Sir, Notwithstanding the discretionary power 
 which, before this reaches you, -you will have received 
 from the Board respecting the cantoning the brigade 
 during the rainy season, I must express it to be my 
 particular desire that you will not make any imme- 
 diate use of that power to oppose the Vizier's wish of 
 cantoning at Bisooly, unless some powerful necessity 
 should compel you to do so, as I confess I cannot dis- 
 approve of the reasons which the Vizier urges for this 
 change of his plan, and which I was not acquainted 
 with when your letter from the Board was written. He 
 says that he hears some Rohilla chiefs are collecting 
 forces together in the division of that country subject
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 431 
 
 to Zabita Cawn, and therefore wishes to canton at 
 Bisooly in order to act against them as soon as their 
 assembling is certainly known ; as well as to be ready 
 to oppose any attempts of the Mahrattas, which, if made 
 at all, would probably be directed against the most 
 distant parts of his new conquests. I own these ar- 
 guments appear of great weight to me ; and as the 
 objects of the campaign are upwards, I think the 
 very reason you assign of the rivers between you and 
 the province of Oude, is in favour of your cantoning at 
 Bisooly, as those rivers will then be in your rear, and 
 nothing before you to oppose your progress towards 
 any enemy who may appear. It will not materially 
 affect the question, although the Vizier's reports should 
 prove without foundation, since there will be always 
 a probability of the enemy collecting in that quarter 
 while the war continues. 
 
 I do suppose that, before you can have received the 
 orders of the Board, you must already have put the 
 troops into quarters ; and to change them in the be- 
 ginning, or it may be the very height of the rains, in 
 opposition to the Vizier, and by a movement which may 
 have the appearance of a retreat from the country 
 which is the object of the war, may not only furnish 
 occasion for constructions abroad to the prejudice of 
 our affairs, but afford him a pretence to complain of a 
 breach of our agreement with him. I understand that 
 it is his determined intention to quarter his own army 
 at Bisooly, which will be some kind of security against 
 our being distressed for provisions, for while his army 
 is supplied, ours can never want. Upon the whole, 
 though I have the greatest confidence in your prudence 
 and moderation, yet as you have received a formal 
 authority to do what, according to my sentiments, would 
 be repugnant to both, I think it incumbent upon me to 
 offer you this caution. I am, dear Sir, &c.
 
 432 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 To Colonel CHAMPION. 
 
 Fort William, 30th May, 1774. 
 
 Dear Sir, I am extremely pleased with the intelli- 
 gence you send me of the Vizier's having dismissed 
 Madoc and Gcntil from his service, but I am still 
 more rejoiced at the good understanding which you 
 say subsists between you and his excellency. I have 
 no doubt that you will use your utmost endeavours to 
 cultivate this harmony on account of the obvious ad- 
 vantages resulting from it to all our measures and 
 interests. 
 
 Since writing my letter of the 28th, in which I 
 offered reasons against your removing from Bisooly, 
 unless necessity should compel you, I learn from pri- 
 vate letters that you had begun your cantonments 
 there by the llth instant. This is so strong an argu- 
 ment in addition to those I have already urged, that I 
 am sure you will yourself apply it, and I will not there- 
 fore add anything to them, but an expression of my 
 wish that you will use the discretional power given you 
 by the Board, as your prudence and moderation may 
 induce you to think most eligible. I am with esteem, 
 dear Sir, &c. 
 
 To Colonel CHAMPION. 
 
 Fort William, 4th June, 1774. 
 
 Dear Sir, I have received a letter from the Vizier 
 acquainting me of his intentions to proceed to Fyzabad 
 for the purpose of raising the stipulated payment 
 whicji will be due to the Company on account of the 
 cession of the Corah and Allahabad provinces. He 
 also mentions that he will leave his sons and his army 
 at Bisooly with the brigade, and only carry a small 
 guard with himself, and that he will not be absent 
 longer than a month, or a month and a half. He ex- 
 presses himself as very desirous that his journey should 
 occasion no distrust in you, and requests of me to write
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 433 
 
 to you on this subject. As the reasons which the 
 Vizier assigns for his journey are very plausible, 
 and if they even were not, as he must be master of 
 his own conduct in a measure of this kind, I have 
 made no objections to his absence, and I have engaged 
 that you likewise would make none. It will be proper, 
 however, to settle the measures requisite for the regular 
 payment of the troops and the necessary supplies of 
 provision during his absence : this done, I can see no 
 inconvenience that will attend his journey. I have 
 earnestly entreated him to return to the army in time 
 to recommence your operations early in the next 
 season. I am with esteem, dear Sir, &c. 
 
 To Colonel CHAMPION. 
 
 Dear Sir, I am now to reply to your letter dated 
 the 28th of May. 
 
 The following are my sentiments on the proposi- 
 tions which have been made to you, by Abdureem Cawn 
 on the part of Fyzula Cawn. 
 
 The first is not to be listened to. It would be a 
 direct violation of our treaty with the Vizier. 
 
 The second must depend solely upon the Vizier : 
 and if it is not agreeable to him, we could neither 
 compel nor insist upon his acceding to it. 
 
 The third is exactly the same as the second, with 
 the difference only of offering money to the Company 
 for influencing the Vizier, for which reason I would, of 
 the two, prefer the second to the third, because such 
 an agreement must become public, and a conduct of 
 this kind would breed perpetual distrust in the Vizier 
 against every future advice we should give him. 
 
 These are my particular objections to the several 
 propositions; but I have one general objection to the 
 whole of them, which is, that they are diametrically op- 
 posite to the principle on which the Rohilla expedition 
 was on our part undertaken, which was not merely on 
 
 VOL. I. % F
 
 434 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 account of the pecuniary acquisition of forty lacs of 
 rupees to the Company,, for although this might be an 
 accessory argument, it was by no means the chief object 
 of the undertaking. We engaged to assist the Vizier in 
 reducing the Rohilla country under his dominion, that 
 the boundary of his possessions might be completed, 
 by the Ganges forming a barrier to cover them from 
 the attacks and insults to which they were exposed, by 
 his enemies, either possessing or having access to the 
 Rohilla country. This our alliance with him, and the 
 necessity for maintaining this alliance, so long as he or 
 his successors shall deserve our protection, was rendered 
 advantageous to the Company's interest, because the 
 security of his possessions from invasion in that quarter 
 is in fact the security of ours. But if the Rohilla 
 country is delivered to Fyzula Cawn, the advantages 
 proposed from this alliance will be totally defeated. 
 The same objections from the Vizier will take place 
 against him, as against Hafez Ilamit. He will be 
 actuated by the same principles of self-defence, and the 
 same impressions of fear, to seek the protection of other 
 powers against the Vizier, and of course will create the 
 same jealousies and suspicions in the mind of the Vizier, 
 with the additional and strong incentive to a mutual 
 animosity of an enormous debt, which probably Fyzula 
 Cawn will find no other means to get clear of, but by 
 engaging in hostilities against the Vizier. 
 
 The preceding letters, if they stood alone, 
 would, I conceive, set the question of Mr. Has- 
 tings's humanity, during the progress of the Ro- 
 hilla war, at rest for ever ; but they do not stand 
 alone. There is now lying before me a volumi- 
 nous correspondence between Mr. Hastings and 
 Mr. Middleton, by which, though I may not ven-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 435 
 
 ture largely to make use of it, two facts seem to 
 be established. First, it is quite clear, that not 
 only were Colonel Champion's charges against the 
 Vizier ridiculously exaggerated, but that they 
 sprang rather from personal hostility to the man, 
 than from abhorrence of his proceedings. Second, 
 that never was arrangement more judicious than 
 that which substituted for a military officer, as re- 
 sident at the court of Oude, a gentleman in whom 
 the head of the British Government could repose 
 unlimited confidence. I think, also, that in the 
 few extracts which the accumulation of my mate- 
 rials will alone permit me to give, sufficient evi- 
 dence is afforded, that the determination of Mr. 
 Hastings to treat the correspondence of his agent 
 as confidential was a wise one. Mr. Hastings 
 
 o 
 
 had but one object in view, namely to carry on 
 the affairs of the government with as little jarring 
 and discord among individuals as possible. But 
 jarring and discord are scarce to be avoided, under 
 any modification of the British constitution, unless 
 there be open to the executive channels of informa- 
 tion, which are not accessible to the deliberative 
 branch of the legislature. 
 
 In the letter of instructions with which Mr. 
 Middleton was supplied, and which bears date 
 28th January, 1774, I find the following para- 
 graphs : 
 
 "You will reside constantly near the Vizier, and 
 
 2r 2
 
 436 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 accompany him in the field. You will desire to see 
 him, of course, when you have business to impart to 
 him; but in visits of mere ceremony or respect you 
 will conform to his inclinations. I wish you to study 
 his temper, and endeavour to acquire his confidence, 
 shunning every appearance of mystery and intrigue, 
 and by a cautious observance of the forms of civility ; 
 but address him in plain terms, and with firmness, 
 upon every subject of business which may require it. 
 
 " If any servant of the Company, of whatsoever rank, 
 and whether civil or military, shall find his way thither 
 without my authority, you are to command him, in my 
 name, to depart immediately ; and inform me of every 
 such instance which shall happen within your know- 
 ledge, as I am resolved to put an effectual check to the 
 unbecoming intrusion which I have reason to believe 
 has been frequently practised on the Vizier, and even 
 in his hours of retirement." 
 
 In pursuance of these instructions, Mr. Mid- 
 dleton proceeded to Lucknow, where, finding that 
 the Vizier was already in the field, he followed him 
 to his camp. He thus became an eye-witness of 
 the whole of the Nabob's proceedings, his reports 
 of which certainly do not tally, in every particular, 
 with those of Colonel Champion. But with this 
 I have no concern. My business is to show that 
 Mr. Hastings never sanctioned nor approved of 
 any act of severity on the part of the Nabob to the 
 family of Hafez Rhamit, far less that he sold, 
 as he was accused of having done, the lives of the 
 unoffending Rohillas for money. I think that the 
 following extracts at once establish that point, and
 
 MEMOIRS OF WAUREN HASTINGS. 437 
 
 place the writer in the light of a just and prudent 
 ruler, anxious, indeed, to secure for his own nation 
 all that he was entitled to claim, yet not less 
 desirous of acting in good faith towards an ally. 
 
 To Mr. MIDDLETON. 
 
 27th May, 1774. 
 
 I have received your letter of the 7th instant, with 
 the Vizier's enclosed. My answer to the latter, which, 
 with an English copy, I send herewith, will, I hope, 
 satisfy his Excellency, and prevent a repetition of the 
 complaints hereafter. I have pronounced decisively 
 on the claim laid by Colonel Champion to any plunder 
 which may be found in the places taken by our united 
 operations. Should Colonel Champion think it neces- 
 sary to appeal this matter to the Board, their decision 
 upon it must necessarily supersede mine ; but my 
 orders will effectually prevent a resumption of such a 
 claim in the mean time. Be pleased to explain this to 
 the Vizier. I do not think it likely that the Colonel 
 will carry this matter further, nor that he can support 
 the pretensions of the army by any argument or pre- 
 cedent of weight. 
 
 It has been thought proper to allow fc the Com- 
 mander-in-chief a right to decline compliance with any 
 requisition of the Vizier's, which shall evidently expose 
 the army to sickness or any other unnecessary danger ; 
 and in particular he is authorized to quit the station 
 allotted for their cantonments at Barelly, if they shall 
 prove hurtful to the health of the troops, or cut off 
 their communication with the countries from which 
 they can be supplied with provisions. These orders 
 were the necessary consequence of his representations; 
 but I should not have approved of his changing the 
 quarters of the army if I had received your explana- 
 tion of the Vizier's motives earlier. I really think
 
 438 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 such a situation preferable to one less remote, if there 
 is the slightest chance of the enemy collecting in the 
 province ; and if the Vizier himself remains in the 
 same spot, every objection to it, on our part, loses its 
 principal force. Should the Colonel make use of the 
 discretion allowed him, either in this particular instance 
 or on any other occasion, I must insist on your inform- 
 ing yourself of every circumstance that may affect 
 either the reasons alleged in support of such a measure 
 or the Vizier's arguments in opposition to it. 
 
 Colonel Champion complains of the conduct of the 
 Vizier in suffering, and even ordering, his troops to 
 ravage the country, and in his cruel treatment of the 
 family of Hafez Rhamit. This is a subject on which 
 I cannot write to the Vizier. It might widen the 
 breach between him and the Commander-in-chief, and 
 probably influence the Nabob to soine private revenge 
 on the unhappy remains of Hafez Rhamit's family. 
 I desire, therefore, that you will take an immediate 
 occasion to remonstrate with him against every act of 
 cruelty or wanton violence. The country is his, and 
 the people his subjects. They claim by that relation 
 his tenderest regard and unremitted protection. 
 
 The family of Hafez have never injured him, but 
 have a claim 'to his protection in default of that of 
 which he has deprived them. Tell him that the 
 English manners are abhorrent of every species of inhu- 
 manity and oppression, and enjoin the gentlest treat- 
 ment of a vanquished enemy. Require and entreat 
 his observance of this principle towards the family of 
 Hafez. Tell him my instructions to you, generally 
 but urgently enforce the same maxims; and that no 
 part of his conduct will operate so powerfully in win- 
 ning the affections of the English, as instances of 
 benevolence and feeling for others. If these argu- 
 ments don't prevail, you may inform him directly that
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 439 
 
 you have my orders to insist upon a proper treatment 
 of the family of Hafez Rhamit ; since in our alliance 
 with him our national character is involved in every 
 act which subjects his own to reproach ; that I shall 
 publicly exculpate this government from the imputa- 
 tion of assenting to such a procedure, and shall reserve 
 it as an objection to any future engagements with him, 
 when the present service shall have been accomplished. 
 
 The following relates, in part, to the unbecom- 
 ing disposition which Colonel Champion evinced 
 to arrange, on his own account, terms of submission 
 with Fuzulla Cawn, the only Rohilla chief who 
 still held out. Like a former letter addressed to 
 Colonel Champion himself, it is designed to en- 
 force the great political maxim, that no power 
 which supports another, as the mere second in a 
 war, has the smallest right to assume a prominent 
 place in the negociations which are to conclude 
 that war. For Colonel Champion seems never to 
 have understood that his sole business was to fight. 
 He was perpetually involving himself in the intri- 
 cacies of diplomacy ; now listening to the demands 
 of Nujiff Cawn, who claimed, on behalf of his 
 master, the Mogul, a share in the conquered 
 country ; now suggesting the propriety of taking 
 the family of Hafez Rhamit under the protection of 
 the English ; and again consenting to treat with 
 Fuzulla Cawn, through the medium of his own 
 agents. The temper and good sense with which 
 Mr. Hastings interfered to put a stop to the former
 
 440 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 of these proceedings have been sufficiently illus- 
 trated in his letters to Colonel Champion ; his 
 communications to Mr. Middleton, in reference to 
 the latter, are not less marked by the same inva- 
 luable qualities. 
 
 To Mr. MIDDLETON. 
 
 Fort William, 17th September, 177i. 
 
 The subject of your letter of the 22nd has exceed- 
 ingly distressed me, as I could not quote your autho- 
 rity without weakening your influence with the Colonel, 
 which I wish to avoid ; and yet it was too dangerous 
 to admit of the continuance of the power which he has 
 hitherto permitted Collichum to exercise to the injury 
 of the public affairs and his own honour. Fortunately 
 his own letters afforded me since an occasion to repeat 
 my remonstrances on this subject, which I have ex- 
 pressed in terms that ought to produce the effect 
 intended by them. If they do not, I fear I must use 
 other means; but for your satisfaction and my own, 
 I desire that you will hereafter make a distinction 
 between such matters contained in your letters as you 
 mean only for my private information, and such as 
 you propose, or have no objection to have produced, if 
 required, on record. I have hitherto used your letters 
 with great caution, many things being requisite for me 
 to know which I could not desire you to write were all 
 your correspondence to be made public. I am as little 
 pleased with the deputation of Mr. Murray. Your 
 objections to it are strictly just, and I am surprised 
 that they failed to convince Colonel Champion. It 
 has ended as might have been expected ; and the pre- 
 sumptuous behaviour of Fyzulla Cawn fully verified 
 your observations upon it. I have written to Colonel 
 Champion, in peremptory terms, that he must not
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 441 
 
 V 
 
 employ any person in future on such deputations, but 
 leave the Vizier to make use of such means of accom- 
 modation, and such agents, as he pleases, this being 
 his exclusive province, and ours only to act in the field. 
 This I desire you will tell the Vizier, if the war is not 
 brought to an end before you receive this. I much 
 fear this will be the case, notwithstanding the weak- 
 ness and despicable state of the enemy, if he suffer 
 himself to be longer amused by negociations. He 
 ought to dictate and receive but one reply. If that be 
 a refusal, he should call upon the Colonel to proceed 
 with his forces against the enemy, and accept of no 
 subsequent terms but immediate submission, nor suffer 
 a minute's delay to take place in any overtures what- 
 soever. * * * 
 
 To Mr. MIDDLETON. 
 
 24th September, 1774. 
 
 I enclose an extract from a late letter of Colonel 
 Champion to the select committee, on the subject of 
 which I am earnestly solicitous to have the fullest and 
 most certain information. The Colonel must receive 
 every information of this kind at second hand, and he 
 may be deceived. Circumstances may be much exag- 
 gerated ; but his representation is positive and per- 
 emptory, and the Vizier must appear in the blackest 
 colours on our records, if what the Colonel affirms 
 stands uncontradicted. I wish the truth to appear, 
 neither glossed by favour nor blackened by prejudice; 
 let me, therefore, beg of you to furnish me with the 
 fullest information you can obtain of the Vizier's treat- 
 ment of the family of Hafez Cawn, and to support 
 your accounts with the strongest proofs that can be 
 produced. Hitherto the circumstances of that kind 
 which you have had to mention have been satisfactory. 
 
 It is not necessary to pursue the subject further. 
 The Rohilla war, as is well known, came to a
 
 442 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 satisfactory conclusion early in the winter of 1774. 
 Like all conquests in which half-civilised nations 
 are engaged, it was doubtless marked here and 
 there by some acts of cruelty; yet its general 
 character was the reverse of cruel, at least towards 
 the owners of the soil, over whom the Rohillas 
 had for forty years exercised a grinding tyranny. 
 The former, to the amount of two millions of 
 people, became the subjects of the Vizier, while 
 the latter, an armed band of twenty- six thousand 
 men, withdrew, under their own leaders, to seek 
 conquests and settlements elsewhere.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 443 
 
 CHAPTER XIII. 
 
 Parliamentary Proceedings concerning the Affairs of India The Regula- 
 ting Act of 1773 Arrival of the new Councillors at Calcutta Begin- 
 ning of Strife. 
 
 WHILE Mr. Hastings thus laboured to retrieve 
 the fallen fortunes of his employers, and to esta- 
 blish in the provinces an efficient system of general 
 administration, the King's government at home 
 were pressing forward their parliamentary inquiry, 
 and preparing a bill, which, after a good deal of 
 delay, resulted in the act 13 Geo. III., commonly 
 called the Regulating Act. By the law in question 
 several important alterations were effected in the 
 machinery by which the Company's affairs were 
 conducted. The Courts of Proprietors and Direc- 
 tors continued indeed in their integrity, but the 
 qualification to vote in the former body was raised 
 from 500 to 1000 stock; whilst in the latter, 
 each director, instead of being liable, as heretofore, 
 to an annual election, was entitled, when once 
 chosen, to retain office during four years, and 
 again, after an interval of one year, to be re-elected. 
 In like manner the Crown, without claiming any 
 power of direct control, asserted its right to be
 
 444 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 informed respecting the most important of the 
 Company's transactions, by requiring that the 
 directors should, within fourteen days of their 
 arrival, forward to one of his Majesty's secretaries 
 of state all such advices as might have been re- 
 ceived relative to the civil and military and political 
 affairs of British India. Meanwhile the forms of 
 the local governments, and, to a certain extent, their 
 powers, were entirely changed. Instead of a pre- 
 sident and council at each of the three presidencies, 
 all independent of one another, and therefore in 
 some sort rivals, the Regulating Act established for 
 Bengal a Governor-general with four councillors, 
 who were so far to exercise dominion both at 
 Madras and Bombay, that with them, and with 
 them exclusively, rested the power of forming or 
 dissolving alliances, and of engaging in transac- 
 tions of peace and war with the native govern- 
 ments. At the same time it is fair to acknowledge 
 that the meaning of the Act was on this head liable 
 to be misunderstood ; for the same clauses which 
 appeared to establish the supremacy of the govern- 
 ment in Bengal, secured to those of Madras and 
 Bombay their ancient privileges. Accordingly, 
 when grounds of dissension actually arose between 
 them, they seem alike to have distrusted the ex- 
 tent of their own authority ; for the one issued 
 orders, which it lacked the power or the will to 
 enforce, and the other disobeyed, though not without
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 445 
 
 the apparent consciousness that disobedience was 
 in the eye of the law a crime. 
 
 The framers of the Regulating Act were certainly 
 to blame for this. They ought to have expressed 
 themselves more clearly, if indeed they intended 
 that powers awarded by the law should be carried 
 into force ; yet was the error in this respect 
 trivial when compared with another, of which it 
 remains to speak. In the supreme government, 
 consisting, as has been stated, of a Governor-general 
 and four councillors, no superior privileges, no 
 discretionary powers were intrusted to the indi- 
 vidual at the head of the government. The Go- 
 vernor-general took his seat at the Board as pre- 
 sident of the meeting, and nothing more. Every 
 question must first be discussed, and then decided 
 by a plurality of votes, nor could he, be the case 
 ever so urgent, presume to act on his own respon- 
 sibility, much less set at nought the decision at 
 which the Council might have arrived. Now it is. 
 manifest that, as far as his means of usefulness stood 
 affected, the Governor-general, supposing him to 
 be an able and an honest man, became, under the 
 improved form of administration, even more help- 
 less than he used to be under the old. In a 
 body of ten or twelve councillors, the very num- 
 ber of the persons to be acted upon by reasoning, 
 held out at least some prospect that reasoning 
 might succeed. When the deliberative hotly
 
 446 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 consisted of no more than five members, the 
 chance of commanding majorities, if it should be 
 necessary to obtain them by force of argument, 
 was, to say the least of it, weaker. Was this 
 defect, for such it must be acknowledged to have 
 been, the result of inadvertency or of design ? I 
 confess myself inclined to believe that it was no 
 act of inadvertence. I think, on the contrary, that, 
 when we take into account the ultimate designs 
 of the King's government, we shall discover good 
 ground for assuming that the arrangement was 
 made not without design. Recommendations to 
 unanimity might go forth as numerously and as 
 earnestly as words could make them ; but unani- 
 mity in a body constituted like the Supreme Council 
 at Bengal was next to impossible. And what 
 would follow ? 
 
 It is quite certain that, from the hour when the 
 East India Company first became a great political 
 body, the King's government ceased not to aim at 
 the overthrow of their privileges, and the trans- 
 ference of the Indian patronage from the hands of 
 the proprietors to their own. Not yet, however, 
 were the people of England accustomed to treat 
 chartered rights with contempt, or to consider acts 
 of spoliation as matters which nowise concerned 
 them ; so long as the parties plundered were bodies 
 corporate, and no more. Moreover, the people of 
 England Were jealous then of the influence of the
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 447 
 
 Crown, and of its ministers, and had no desire to 
 see the patronage of the latter swelled to an 
 amount which might endanger their liberties. It 
 was, therefore, difficult for the minister, be he who 
 he might, to accomplish his darling object at all. 
 The object was clearly unattainable except by very 
 skilful management and address. I have else- 
 where spoken of the zeal with which each succes- 
 sive Cabinet laboured to impress the public mind 
 with a conviction of the unfitness of the Com- 
 pany's servants to bear rule. A wealthy nabob, 
 as the retired Indian was in those days called, 
 never returned home without being pointed to as 
 one who fattened on the miseries of his fellow 
 creatures, while it was broadly hinted that the 
 prodigious amount of treasure, which by the Com- 
 pany's misrule went only to enrich individuals, 
 might, and if properly managed would, place the 
 whole people of England in a state of comparative 
 affluence. It is marvellous how attentive mankind 
 are to such as tell them of good things which they 
 ought to possess, yet have not. By constantly 
 dunning this charge into men's ears, the Govern- 
 ment succeeded, by degrees, in gathering a for- 
 midable party round themselves, and, believing 
 that the time had come when the last touch might 
 be applied to their picture, they fell upon an inge- 
 nious, if not a very honest method of doing so. 
 Mr. Hastings was, and had been from the com-
 
 448 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 mencement of his administration, a great thorn in 
 the side of the minister. His measures, however 
 bold, had all been crowned with success, and there 
 seemed every prospect, provided he were left to 
 follow out his own projects to the end, that the 
 affairs of the Company might right themselves. 
 But the minister had no desire to witness this 
 consummation. His wishes all pointed in a con- 
 trary direction, and he therefore determined, while 
 changing the constitution of a body which he was 
 not yet strong enough immediately to overthrow, 
 so to manage matters as that the act of its o\vn 
 representatives might be received by the people 
 of England as evidence against itself. The first 
 thing to be done in order to effect this was, so to 
 arrange the machinery of the new government, as 
 that Mr. Hastings might be at the mercy of those 
 with whom he should be associated. The next, to 
 make choice of men to fill office as councillors 
 under him, who, understanding the minister's views, 
 and ready to work for their accomplishment, should 
 not be troubled with many scruples as to the best 
 means of doing so. Both schemes the minister 
 had the good fortune to carry out without exciting 
 the suspicion at least of the legislature. On Mr. 
 Hastings, of course, whom it would have injured 
 himself to recal, the nominal powers of Governor- 
 general were conferred ; but these powers the sub- 
 sequent appointments at once annulled, for out of
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 449 
 
 the four gentlemen who were associated with him, 
 there was only one, Mr. Barwell, who either from 
 previous habits, or from knowledge of the sub- 
 ject, could be expected to support his measures. 
 The remaining three, namely Lieutenant-general 
 Clavering, the Honourable George Monson, and 
 Philip Francis, Esq., were remarkable for nothing 
 so much as their subserviency to the will of the 
 existing Cabinet, unless indeed it were in the parade 
 which they had been accustomed to make, of a 
 righteous horror at the atrocities which had been 
 practised by the Company's servants on the de- 
 fenceless people of India. 
 
 It was not, however, by these means alone, that 
 the authors of the Regulating Act struck, as they 
 conceived, a heavy blow at the future existence of 
 the East India Company. The bill which gave to 
 Bengal its Governor-general and Council created 
 for it and for Bahar and Orissa a supreme court of 
 judicature, of which the jurisdiction was declared 
 to extend over all the subjects of the British crown 
 resident within these provinces, and to which ap- 
 peals from the provincial courts were appointed to 
 lie. The law to be administered in this court was 
 of course the law of England, and all offences and 
 misdemeanors tried there, were to be decided by a 
 jury of British subjects. Moreover, provision was 
 made for the establishment at Calcutta of all the 
 forms and processes of which the English people 
 
 VOL. i. 2 G
 
 450 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 are enamoured. There was to be the power of 
 attachment, vested in the judges, the right of com- 
 mittal for contempt of court, authority to issue 
 writs of habeas corpus, everything, in short, which 
 appertains to, or is characteristic of, our courts of 
 law, without any exception having been made in 
 favour of the Governor-general himself. In a 
 word, the supreme court of judicature, consisting 
 of one chief justice and three puisne judges, was 
 to wield such powers both in Calcutta and else- 
 where, as were clearly incompatible with the ex- 
 istence in British India of any authority superior 
 to itself. Hence the provinces of British India 
 ran no little hazard, sooner or later, of finding 
 their rulers and their judges struggling with one 
 another for rights, which both might claim, yet both 
 pronounce to be manifestly inconsistent with the 
 rights and privileges of the other party. 
 
 In addition to these provisions, the bill in ques- 
 tion took cognizance of a variety of points into 
 which it is scarcely necessary to enter. It was 
 determined, for example, that, in the event of the 
 death or resignation of the Governor-general, the 
 councillor next in rank should succeed to his office, 
 and that the directors should be at liberty to fill 
 up the vacancy thus occasioned in the Supreme 
 Council for the remainder of the five years, though 
 subject, as a matter of course, to his Majesty's 
 approbation. From and after the expiration of
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 451 
 
 the five years, however, the power of nominating 
 find removing all future Governors-general was to 
 l)e vested in the Directors ; a sort of saving clause 
 this, which the minister judged it expedient to 
 insert, as well for the purpose of smoothing down 
 opposition on the part of the Company and their 
 friends, as to give a show of moderation to a pro- 
 ceeding which had, in point of fact, no portion of 
 the spirit of moderation in it. 
 
 Of the proceedings of the King's government, 
 and of the results in which they were expected to 
 terminate, Mr. Hastings was not kept in ignorance. 
 Rumours, indeed, of changes even more complete 
 than those actually in preparation, from time to 
 time reached him, and his letters show that he 
 dreaded the issue, much more upon public grounds 
 than upon private. Nevertheless, when the true 
 state of the case became apparent, he braced him- 
 self to meet the probable difficulties which would 
 follow, and resolved to act in all contingencies 
 fairly, and in a spirit of frankness, as became a 
 man conscious of his own integrity, and nowise 
 diffident of his own powers. He seems without 
 doubt to have entertained but an indifferent opi- 
 nion of the fitness of the individuals selected to 
 work out the new system. He more than insi- 
 nuates as much in his confidential communications 
 with his friends. Still he not only made no dis- 
 play of these feelings, but he adopted the wise and
 
 452 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 becoming course of affecting an opposite belief, 
 and strove to win their confidence by making 
 to them at the outset a tender of his own. The 
 following letters were despatched to Madras, at 
 which place his colleagues, on their way from 
 England, were expected to touch, and I think that 
 the bitterest enemy of the writer can have nothing 
 to object to in their phraseology. 
 
 To PHILIP FRANCIS, Esq. 
 
 Fort William, 26th August, 1774. 
 
 SIR, I take the earliest opportunity of addressing 
 you on your arrival in India, and congratulating you 
 on your appointment to a share of the administration 
 of this government. I received with particular plea- 
 sure, a letter from General Clavering, wherein he 
 unites with his own intentions an assurance of your 
 disposition to co-operate in measures of public utility. 
 My hopes and wishes are equally sanguine, to concur 
 heartily in such measures as will most fully answer the 
 intention of your appointment, and reflect honour on 
 our councils. I shall impatiently expect your arrival 
 here, both from the personal satisfaction I propose to 
 myself from it, and the desire of entering upon the 
 several public measures which may be necessary for 
 the discharge of the great trust confided to our joint 
 direction. I am with esteem, &c. 
 
 To the Hon. Col. MONSON. 
 
 Fort William, 26th August, 1774. 
 
 Sir, Although I hope shortly to have the pleasure 
 of seeing you at this presidency, yet as you propose 
 touching first at Madras, I cannot deny myself the use 
 of this early opportunity of offering you my congratu- 
 lations on your appointment to a place in the new
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 453 
 
 administration of these provinces. Though I have not 
 the advantage of being personally known to you, I 
 flatter myself we shall not meet on the footing of 
 mere strangers, and I beg leave to assure you that I 
 shall seek to cultivate both your friendship and con- 
 fidence, as well from personal prepossession as from 
 a conviction of the necessity of such a mutual under- 
 standing for the conduct of the great and difficult 
 affairs in which we have been joined. To declare 
 these sentiments, and to bespeak the concurrence of 
 your's, is the motive of this address, in which if I have 
 transgressed the common forms, it is because I feel 
 myself placed in a situation which entitles me to dis- 
 pense with them. 
 
 As I understand that Lady Anne Monson is to be 
 the companion of your voyage, I beg the favour of you 
 to present my compliments to her, in the hopes that I 
 may have the honour still to bear a place in her re- 
 membrance. I am with esteem, Sir, your most obe- 
 dient humble servant. 
 
 In the same spirit of candour and manly frank- 
 ness, he addressed himself to General Clavering, 
 who, writing from London, had in some sort taken 
 the lead in the correspondence. But with Sir 
 Elijah Impey, he, of course, assumed a more con- 
 fidential tone. They were personal friends of 
 long standing, and the memory of former days 
 could not but mix itself up with anticipations of 
 the future. The following speaks for itself: 
 
 To ELIJAH IMPEY, Esq. 
 
 Fort William, 25th August, 1774. 
 
 My dear Impey, Advices from England seldom 
 afford cither pleasure or pain unmixed, but the news
 
 454 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 of your late appointment to preside over the High 
 Court of Justice, constituted by Parliament, affords 
 me every cause of satisfaction without a circumstance 
 of regret to allay it. In truth, my friend, nothing else 
 could have reconciled me to that part of the Act, which, 
 if any latitude is left to you in its first establishment, 
 may, and I am sure will, be made a source of the most 
 valuable benefits to this country. I need not say how 
 much I rejoice in the prospect of seeing so old a friend, 
 independently of the public advantages which that 
 friendship, cemented (if it required it) by the same con- 
 nexions, cannot fail to produce in the conduct of such 
 affairs as are likely to fall to our respective or com- 
 mon lot. 
 
 With respect to my own situation, I shall say no- 
 thing till we meet, but that I shall expect from your 
 friendship such assistance as the peculiar circum- 
 stances of my new office and connexions will enable 
 you effectually to afford me for the prevention and 
 removal of the embarrassments which I fear I am un- 
 avoidably to meet with. 
 
 Mr. Lane not being in Calcutta, and his house pos- 
 sibly occupied, I have taken another for your use, 
 which you will find prepared for your reception. 
 Colonel M'Lean has left his for your service, and I 
 believe will be well pleased that you find occasion to 
 take possession of it till you can be provided more to 
 your liking. This I mention only that his intentions 
 may not be wholly frustrated. I believe you will find 
 yourself more at your ease in a house of your own, 
 and therefore keep the other ready for you. 
 
 I have given a letter of introduction for you to 
 young Stuart, the son of Lord Bute. Let me beg of 
 you to take notice of him. He has hitherto had little 
 employment, either because his hopes were higher than 
 his pretensions from rank in the service, or perhaps
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 455 
 
 from the dissipation of a youthful mind. He is, how- 
 ever, ambitious of taking his share of public business, 
 and it is my desire to encourage that ambition, by 
 placing him in a situation which may give him occa- 
 sion to distinguish himself. He has a good under- 
 standing, and by conversing with him you may pick up 
 something to add to the stock of knowledge which you 
 have already acquired of Indian matters. 
 
 On your arrival at Madras, where this is expected 
 to find you, I beg you will write me a line over land, 
 to inform me when you sail from thence. I fear you 
 will be late. 
 
 I desire that you will present my compliments to 
 your lady, and believe me, dear Impey, your sincerely 
 affectionate friend. 
 
 On Wednesday the 19th day of October, 1774, 
 the new members of council, bringing the judges 
 of the supreme court in their train, disembarked at 
 Calcutta. The ship which conveyed them from 
 England had indeed anchored at Kedgeree as 
 early as Friday the 14th, and Mr. Hastings lost no 
 time, so soon as the event was communicated to 
 him, in despatching the senior member of the 
 Board then at the presidency, to congratulate them 
 on the happy termination of their voyage. But 
 it was not till the 19th that, under a salute of 
 seventeen guns, they landed, and were conducted by 
 an officer of rank in Mr. Hastings's staff, to the 
 private dwelling of the Governor-general. There 
 all the resident members of the existing Govern- 
 ment were assembled to do them honour. Care,
 
 456 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 too, had been taken to provide for them convenient 
 lodgings ; in short every disposition was exhibited, 
 both by the president and his colleagues, to mark 
 the degree of respect in which both they and the 
 office were held. Yet the event proved, that 
 whatever their desires might be, neither Mr. 
 Hastings nor the members of the Board succeeded 
 in making a good impression. The new coun- 
 cillors seem to have returned the civilities that 
 were offered to them coldly ; and their first de- 
 spatch to the Court of Directors was filled with 
 complaints of indignities which had been put upon 
 them. But this is a trifle. We can scarce sup- 
 press a smile Avhen we are told that three gentle- 
 men arrived at the years of discretion, far more 
 three persons entrusted with a large share in the 
 government of a great empire, chafed because no 
 guard of honour met them on the beach, and the 
 guns from the batteries emitted only seventeen 
 instead of twenty-one discharges. We are ac- 
 tuated by a very different feeling, so soon as we 
 discover, that, without taking so much as a day to 
 inquire, without having any local experience at 
 all to fall back upon, these same gentlemen began 
 their public life in India with a display of un- 
 mitigated hostility towards the Governor-general. 
 I shall not enter here into any disquisition on this 
 subject, far less explain in detail the grounds on 
 which this hostility rested ; for there are points
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 457 
 
 which the correspondence by and bye to be intro- 
 duced fully sets forth. But a brief detail of facts 
 as they occurred is necessary, and the following 
 will serve both the reader's purpose and mine. 
 
 Messrs. Clavering, Monson, and Francis met 
 the Governor, as has been described, at his private 
 residence, on Wednesday the 19th. On the fol- 
 lowing morning a Council was formally held, 
 when the commission was opened, which set aside 
 the old and established the new constitution, and 
 the Court's general letter of instruction was read. 
 It recommended, above all things, unanimity and 
 concord among the persons to whom the powers 
 of the government were delegated. It urged 
 them to preserve, by every means in their power, 
 the peace of India in general, and of the Com- 
 pany's possessions in particular. It required them 
 to meet in Council twice every week at the least. 
 It committed to the Governor- general the charge 
 of carrying on all correspondence with the country 
 powers ; desiring, however, that the letters pro- 
 posed to be sent by him should, in the first in- 
 stance, be approved by the Council, and that all 
 letters received by him should be submitted to the 
 Council at their first meeting. It impressed upon 
 all parties the necessity of attentively reviewing 
 the general posture of the Company's affairs, as 
 these might be affected by any connexions formed 
 at the moment, or likely to be formed hereafter, 
 with the states around the three presidencies ; and,
 
 458 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 reminding them that by the Act they alone were 
 authorized to determine in all questions whether of 
 peace or war, it exhorted them to use great care 
 in committing themselves, by alliances or other- 
 wise, not with the native governments alone, but 
 with those of other European nations. Meanwhile, 
 that they might find more leisure to attend to 
 graver matters, a Board of Trade was ordered to 
 be erected, by which the commercial affairs of the 
 Company might be conducted, but of which no 
 one employed under the Governor or Council in 
 the general management of the revenues was to 
 become a member. Then again a strict investiga- 
 tion into the causes of an enormous military ex- 
 penditure was enjoined. The reduction of the 
 bonded debt was pressed upon them as an object 
 of paramount importance. The system of letting 
 the lands in farm, as introduced by Mr. Hastings, 
 was generally approved, and the Council were 
 advised 'to continue it. Finally, the letter re- 
 commended an inquiry into past abuses and op- 
 pressions as well as the enactment of such 
 regulations as might effectually prevent their re- 
 currence ; and, exhorting the Council to give every 
 possible aid towards establishing the supreme 
 court and rendering the administration of justice 
 easy, the letter concluded, as it began, with an 
 earnest exhortation to unanimity. 
 
 Thus far matters went in their legitimate 
 channel. The new authorities were installed in
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 459 
 
 their places, the country was made aware of the 
 change that had occurred in the form of its go- 
 vernment, and the machine, not yet wound up, 
 seemed to require nothing more than the appli- 
 cation of care at the outset, in order to ensure its 
 working with regularity in all time coming. But 
 care, meaning by that expression the exercise of 
 caution and circumspection on the part of those 
 recently appointed to office, was that of which they 
 appeared neither to experience the lack, nor to 
 know the value. They had read a clause in the 
 Court's letter which desired them to inquire into 
 abuses and oppressions past ; and they seemed to 
 believe that till that order should have been 
 obeyed, there was no field open on which to 
 exercise their talents. It was, indeed, not without 
 difficulty that Mr. Hastings prevailed upon them 
 to pause even for a single day in the career on 
 Avhich they had determined to enter. He re- 
 minded them that Mr. Barwell, one of their own 
 body, was absent, and that his arrival at Calcutta 
 could not be expected earlier than the 24th. He 
 suggested that it might be prudent to receive from 
 himself, a general account of the policy of their 
 predecessors, ere they should proceed in sAveeping 
 terms either to approve or to censure ; and he so far 
 succeeded, that they consented to defer their next 
 meeting till the 25th ; but beyond this they Avould 
 not yield a jot. Accordingly, on the 25th, the 
 Council assembled for business, and then on the
 
 460 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 very first day of their meeting, in other words 
 within the limited space of six days from the 
 arrival of the new members from England, that 
 struggle of parties began, which throughout four 
 long years continued to make its baneful influence 
 felt to the remotest corners of the Company's pos- 
 sessions in India. 
 
 During the interval that accrued between the 
 proclamation of the new government and the second 
 meeting of the Supreme Council, Mr. Hastings had 
 employed himself in drawing up a minute, which 
 set forth in order, and with remarkable perspicuity, 
 the whole tenor of his own and the late govern- 
 ment's policy from the date of his appointment as 
 president in 1772, up to the hour of the arrival of 
 his new colleagues, and the changes which followed. 
 Of the opening paragraphs in this minute, the 
 Council took no further notice than generally to ap- 
 prove of the arrangements which he had made for 
 the better collection of the revenue and the dispen- 
 sation of justice throughout the provinces, and to 
 order their continuance. But towards those which 
 gave an account of the treaty of Benares, and of the 
 transactions both of war and peace to which it had 
 given rise, their deportment was widely different. 
 They condemned the treaty on the score of policy, 
 the war they denounced as alike impolitic and 
 unjust; yet they professed their inability to arrive 
 at any satisfactory conclusions respecting either, 
 on the sort of evidence which the Governor-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 461 
 
 general's minute afforded. The Governor had 
 corresponded, it appeared, with Mr. Middleton, 
 throughout the entire progress of the arrange- 
 ments. It was necessary that they should be put 
 in possession of this correspondence, and they 
 formally demanded it. Now Mr. Hastings, as I 
 have elsewhere explained, had charged Mr. Mid- 
 dleton not to confine himself in his correspondence 
 to such communications as might be submitted, 
 without reserve, to general inspection. Mr. 
 Hastings, therefore, declined to produce letters, 
 which as they were written under the sanc- 
 tion of a strict confidence, so were they filled 
 with details which could interest no human 
 being except himself. But he freely consented 
 to furnish his colleagues with every sentence in 
 these letters which might have a tendency to 
 throw the faintest light on the subject under dis- 
 cussion ; and entreated that they would not require 
 more. The new members of Council took fire on 
 the instant. They did not care what arrange- 
 ments their predecessors might have come to, they 
 could not recognize any authority in the Board to 
 give the sort of double commission under which 
 Mr. Middleton appeared to have acted ; and seeing 
 that the Governor-general refused to give up his 
 own letters, they proposed that Mr. Middleton 
 should be recalled from Lucknow, and undergo a 
 personal examination. It was to no purpose that 
 the Governor-general protested, and explained the 

 
 4-62 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 extent of injury which, from such a proceeding, 
 the public service would inevitably sustain. The 
 question was put to the vote ; and in spite of the 
 support of Mr. Barwell, who, not less than Mr. 
 Hastings, saw that a storm was brewing, the votes 
 went against the Governor, and the order for 
 Middleton's recall was passed. Yet the very men 
 who put this slight upon Mr. Hastings recorded, 
 as their opinion, that the right of selecting a suc- 
 cessor to Mr. Middleton was vested in the Go- 
 vernor-general, and that till such successor were 
 appointed, the Governor-general should be re- 
 quested to make the Vizier aware, that the Com- 
 mander-in-chief of the English troops serving witli 
 his army ought to be regarded as the proper 
 channel of communication between his highness 
 and the British government. It is scarcely neces- 
 sary to add, that of this unmeaning compliment 
 Mr. Hastings took no notice whatever. He did 
 not choose to be made the instrument of his own 
 political degradation in the sight of one whom he 
 had taught to look up to him as a protector, and 
 he was too much master of himself to acknowledge 
 as a mark of respect, resolutions which served but 
 to aggravate fourfold the insult in which they 
 originated. 
 
 The case of Mr. Middleton being thus sum- 
 marily disposed of, the Council went on to con- 
 sider both the grounds on which the Company had 
 been involved in hostilities with the Rohillas, and
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 463 
 
 the results in which such hostilities might be 
 expected to issue. It was no matter of surprise to 
 Mr. Hastings and Mi: Harwell that the war itself 
 was denounced as unjust and impolitic. Other pro- 
 ceedings of their colleagues had already prepared 
 them for all manner of perverse and wayward 
 judgments; and such a judgment as this, however 
 rashly and ignorantly formed, seemed to be but 
 in keeping with the whole of their bearing out of 
 doors. For it was not long a secret, either at 
 Calcutta or in the provinces, that to inquire rigidly 
 into past abuses with a view to their correction, 
 was, by the new members of government, consi- 
 dered as the most pressing and important of their 
 duties. Accordingly their audience chambers were 
 
 o J 
 
 speedily beset by all, whether of native or European 
 lineage, who conceived that, either in their own 
 persons, or by neglect shown to their friends and 
 relations, they had suffered wrong. They were 
 appealed to by theorists whose plans had been 
 scouted ; by peculators who had been quietly re- 
 moved from their offices ; by public servants whom 
 the mere change of system had deprived of employ- 
 ment, and by many more, who, in their eagerness 
 to make friends of new men, conceived that they 
 could not adopt a more ready method of doing so, 
 than by bringing charges against the old. When 
 I add, that among: these visitors there was none so 
 
 o 
 
 regular in his attendance or so welcome as Nun- 
 comar: that his statements were all listened to
 
 464 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 with avidity and himself encouraged to search for 
 fresh grounds of accusation wherever an opening 
 might seem to be presented, I shall have said 
 enough to place in a proper point of view the sort 
 of temper with Avhich Messrs. Clavering, Monson, 
 and Francis applied themselves to the great 
 work of reforming the system and thereby con- 
 solidating the powers of the British government 
 in India. 
 
 It excited no surprise in Mr. Hastings and Mr. 
 Barwell to find, that the same men who insisted 
 on the recall of Mr. Middleton, as a measure es- 
 sential to the formation of a right judgment con- 
 cerning the treaty of Benares and the Rohilla war, 
 should, without waiting for the evidence which he 
 might be able to supply, condemn both measures 
 in the gross. The reasons, however, which their 
 colleagues assigned for blaming the expedition into 
 Rohilcund did, indeed, astonish them. Not only 
 were the Rohillas declared to be a people brave 
 and inoffensive, and therefore cruelly wronged, but 
 their country lay so far apart from the limits of 
 the British provinces, that the new members of 
 Council were unable so much as to trace it out on 
 the map. Now, as the home authorities were op- 
 posed to all wars, except wars of defence, and set 
 their faces decidedly against distant expeditions, 
 of which the object was conquest, this march 
 into Rohilcund could appear to them in no other 
 light than as a flagrant and a positive breach of
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 465 
 
 orders, while its results, though triumphant in the 
 first instance, would surely bring evil on the Com- 
 pany, by the additional facilities which an extended 
 line of frontier must necessarily afford to invasion 
 from the Mahrattas. It was to no purpose that 
 Mr. Hastings assured them of the extent to which, 
 both as politicians and geographers, they had de- 
 ceived themselves. Men who pinned their faith to 
 a map compiled at a period antecedent to the date 
 of the Rohilla invasion, and the subsequent change 
 of name in the country which the Rohillas overran 
 and had subjected, were not likely to believe Mr. 
 Hastings when he told them that the Rohillas them- 
 selves were a mere band of Affghan adventurers, 
 whose expulsion from Rohilcund could operate no 
 other change in the condition of the rightful pro- 
 prietors of the soil than by transferring them from 
 the rule of these strangers to the dominion of the 
 Nabob of Oude, to whose dominions their country 
 adjoined. 
 
 Having come to these conclusions, the majority 
 held themselves bound to take immediate steps for 
 the repair of evils so serious and so flagrant. The 
 next best thing to avoiding a war, for which there 
 is no plea either in justice or sound policy, is to get 
 out of it with as little delay as possible ; and this 
 much they felt that they had at least the power to 
 accomplish. It was, therefore, proposed and carried, 
 that instructions should be sent off for the return 
 
 VOL. i. 2 H
 
 466 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 of the Company's brigade within the ancient limits 
 of the kingdom of Oude. The sums promised by 
 the Vizier, as the price of their aid, were not, indeed, 
 to be remitted ; on the contrary, a delay of four- 
 teen days was allowed, in order that time might be 
 afforded him for paying up his arrears. But at 
 the termination of this interval the troops were to 
 begin their homeward march, without pausing to 
 consider how the Nabob might be affected by the 
 movement. Nay, nor was their zeal to correct 
 abuses limited even by this. They considered the 
 article in the treaty of Benares which threw upon 
 the Nabob the expense of maintaining a third part 
 of the Bengal army, as in every point of view 
 objectionable. It was oppressive to the Nabob 
 when acted upon, it was delusory in its conse- 
 quences to the Company whether acted upon or 
 not. For the Nabob's payments, depending on the 
 extent of his own fears or his own caprices, could 
 never be regarded as a permanent addition to the 
 Company's resources ; who, on the contrary, were 
 tempted by them to keep on foot a larger military 
 force than was necessary for the defence of their 
 own territories ; and keeping such force on foot, 
 were never averse to find employment for it. 
 Again Mr. Hastings used his best endeavours to 
 prevent the execution of a device so well calcu- 
 lated to bring discredit, and therefore worse evils, 
 if such there be. on the British power in India.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 467 
 
 His reasoning was either not attended to, or it 
 failed to convince ; and his protest, with whatever 
 degree of solemnity uttered, availed nothing. A 
 letter was written, by order of the majority, and 
 sent off on the very day which brought from Co- 
 lonel Champion an account of the successful termi- 
 nation of the war, and of his own intention, so 
 soon as he should have put his troops in quarters 
 at Ramgaut, to resign the command to the officer 
 next to him in rank, and return himself to the 
 presidency. 
 
 Of the events which followed this most inau- 
 spicious beginning, I am not required to give a 
 detailed account. It is matter of history that the 
 contending parties, the majority of three on the 
 one hand, and Mr. Hastings and Mr. Barwell on 
 the other, made their respective appeals to the au- 
 thorities under whom they acted ; that the several 
 members of the government drew up each his 
 official statement, in which both the past and pre- 
 sent aspect of things were set forth ; and that the 
 compilation of these despatches, with the contro- 
 versies arising out of them, served but to widen 
 the breach already created, and to render the 
 chances of a reconciliation more distant than ever. 
 Meanwhile, Mr. Middleton withdrew from the 
 cou rt of Oude, making way for a Mr. Bristow, of 
 whom further notice will, in due time, be taken ;
 
 408 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 but of whom for the present it is sufficient to ob- 
 serve, that he had been one of the most constant 
 attendants on Mr. Francis's levees, ever since that 
 gentleman's doors were thrown open to the com- 
 plaints of the public. But this is not all. The 
 majority, who had objected to what they were 
 pleased to term the private and irregular communi- 
 cations that passed between Mr. Hastings and Mr. 
 Middleton, avowed their determination to main- 
 tain, not conjointly but severally, a confidential 
 correspondence with Mr. Bristow. Thus the right 
 which they had called in question, when exercised 
 by the Governor-general, the members of Council 
 claimed each for himself, of which the consequences 
 were the virtual abandonment by its nominal head 
 of all share in the government, and the undi- 
 vided exercise of its powers by the faction which 
 thwarted him. 
 
 The despatches which went home at this period 
 are accessible to all men. I will not, therefore, 
 make any extracts from them. But the following 
 private letters, addressed by Mr. Hastings as well 
 to the King's minister as to his personal friends, 
 are too valuable to be passed over. They clear 
 away the mists with which party violence con- 
 trived, at the moment, to obscure an important page 
 in our history, while they furnish an ample vindi- 
 cation of the integrity and high-minded ness of the
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 469 
 
 man whose only error, if error it deserves to be 
 called, was an unbounded and steady devotion to 
 the interests of his country. 
 
 To LAURENCE SULIVAN, Esq. 
 
 Fort William, 4th December, 1774. 
 
 Dear Sir, I have sent some papers to Mr. Palk, 
 which he will show you. These will afford you a com- 
 plete view of the state of affairs in this quarter. I am 
 afraid you will see too close a resemblance in the dis- 
 putes in which I am engaged to those between our late 
 friend (Mr. Vansittart) and his Council ; but I trust 
 that, by the benefit of his example and my own ex- 
 perience, and by a temper, which, in spite of nature, I 
 have brought under proper subjection, I shall be able 
 to prevent the same dreadful extremities which at- 
 tended the former. The violence with which the ma- 
 jority set out in the exercise of their new power has 
 produced an effect in the Vizier's mind, the very re- 
 verse of what I expected, or was, perhaps,, intended. 
 
 The first notification of Mr. Middleton's recall from 
 his court was given in a letter from me to that gentle- 
 man who immediately carried it to the Nabob, and 
 read it to him. It affected the Nabob so much that 
 he burst into tears, regarding it as the overture to a 
 train of hostilities directed against him. He imme- 
 diately declared that he saw that he had no dependence 
 but on my friendship, and that he would, in all things, 
 be entirely ruled by my advice. This declaration he 
 has since repeated by a message sent to me; and I 
 hope to avail myself of this disposition to prevent his 
 resenting any acts of this government, and to wait with 
 patience till the orders from Europe shall arrive, which 
 shall decide between me and my opponents. 
 
 Without friends, without any kind of personal in- 
 terest, I have but a discouraging prospect ; but I am
 
 470 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 prepared for the worst, and shall return quietly and 
 even contentedly to England the moment I hear of my 
 recall, for there is no room for palliatives. I hope that 
 my reputation will be spared ; but, if it is to be black- 
 ened for the sake of giving a fair colour to the severity 
 which may be exercised towards me, I will most cer- 
 tainly defend myself, and I am sure that I shall be 
 able to do it to the shame of my calumniators. My 
 actions are not to be condemned by maxims which are 
 only applicable to the wild schemes of ambition. By 
 the system which I have introduced into the political 
 affairs of the Company, every military operation which 
 was before an accumulation of expense, and undertaken 
 without an object of termination in prospect, has be- 
 come a source of economical advantages, and in every 
 progressive state of it, to its conclusion, answered ex- 
 actly to the original design of it. This is no vain 
 boast, but a fact which the late campaign, in spite of 
 many circumstances which might, if anything could, 
 have defeated it, has amply illustrated. It will have 
 brought, before the possible return of the brigade to 
 its cantonments, seventy lacs into the Company's trea- 
 sury, and added both to the power of our ally and the 
 credit of his arms. But I am running into an unne- 
 cessary discussion. Let me entreat you to read my 
 minute of appeal, &c. &c. 
 
 I hope my friends will approve the resolution I have 
 taken to remain. I believe, that in spite of all the 
 evils of a divided and contested rule, it were better 
 than leaving the Company's affairs in hands, certainly 
 not qualified by experience to conduct them. Barwell 
 has engaged most heartily in my support, although 
 much improper pains have been taken to win him from 
 me. The classical consolation of socios habuisse doloris 
 is the principal benefit I can expect from his aid or 
 friendship, since three voices for ever combined against
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 471 
 
 me, form as effectual a majority as four would. He has 
 quick parts and great abilities, which I shall endea- 
 vour to convert to useful purposes, if the others will 
 let me. 
 
 The court of justice is a dreadful clog on the go- 
 vernment, but I thank God the head of it is a man of 
 sense and moderation. In all England a choice could 
 not have been made of a man more disposed to do 
 good and avoid mischief; which, however, is not wholly 
 in his power, and I am sorry for it. 
 
 The following to Lord North takes a much wider 
 review of the condition of affairs. It is long, but 
 of its importance no doubt can be entertained. 
 
 4th December, 1774. 
 
 My Lord, I esteem it an especial duty to acknow- 
 ledge, by the earliest opportunity, the receipt of the 
 letter with which your Lordship Avas pleased to honour 
 me by General Clavering; and to mark, at the same 
 time, the strong, the unaffected feelings of my heart, 
 on the kind and handsome manner in which you were 
 pleased to notify to me the part which you took in my 
 late appointment. Being an entire stranger, without 
 either personal or political connexion with your Lord- 
 ship, I must look on the favour shown me as the most 
 incontrovertible token of your Lordship's approbation 
 of my past conduct, and it must bind me, by every tie 
 of honour and gratitude, to seek the preservation of 
 your esteem, and aim by all my actions in future to 
 justify a choice which, may I be permitted to say so, 
 on the ground in which it was made, must ever do 
 credit to your intentions, however they may be disap- 
 pointed in the event. 
 
 Till I received your Lordship's letter I own I re- 
 mained in a state of doubt as to the motives and pur- 
 pose of my appointment, whether an approbation of
 
 4-72 MEMOIRS OF WARDEN HASTINGS. 
 
 my past measures gave rise to it, or whether I was 
 included as a necessary part in a new system for the 
 purpose of connecting its operations with those of the 
 past; but your Lordship's explicit declaration effec- 
 tually dispelled those doubts, and your assurances in- 
 spired me with a zeal beyond what I had ever felt 
 before. 
 
 I hope it is not improper to express how much the 
 notice you were pleased to convey to me of the wishes 
 of the first person in the nation for my undertaking 
 the arduous employment conferred on me by parlia- 
 ment, served to decide and animate my resolutions. 
 My temper and views are moderate with respect to 
 fortune, and many of the common objects of life, but I 
 own I possess a more than ordinary degree of ambition 
 to act in an elevated sphere under the auspices of my 
 sovereign, and to recommend myself more and more 
 to his favour, by conducting the great and important 
 affairs committed to my charge to the best of my 
 abilities for his honour and the advantage of his 
 people. 
 
 A union of all the governments of the East India 
 Company under one effectual control has long been an 
 object of my wishes, and I received with double satis- 
 faction the first notice of the late Act of Parliament, 
 arising from the accomplishment of these wishes, and 
 the gratification of my pride in finding myself nomi- 
 nated to the principal share in the execution of the 
 new system. I foresaw the most important advan- 
 tages which might be obtained from a proper applica- 
 tion of the vast powers now concentered in the govern- 
 ment, to the acquisition of new resources of wealth 
 and influence to the British empire, not, my Lord, by 
 desultory schemes of conquest or extension of territory, 
 but by means which the most wary prudence might 
 allow, and on grounds of moral certainty both of safety
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 473 
 
 and success. So sanguine were my hopes, that I had 
 even taken some preparatory steps for the execution 
 of this design, long before the arrival of the members 
 of the new Council, not doubting that I should meet 
 with their hearty assistance in promoting it. 
 
 Prepossessed as I was with these sentiments of con- 
 fidence towards my new associates in the Government, 
 and with such expectations from their united labours, 
 your Lordship will readily conceive the mortification 
 I feel in acquainting you that my hopes are already 
 blasted, and a prospect opened to me of a very dif- 
 ferent kind from that which my imagination had 
 painted. 
 
 The public despatches will inform you of the divi- 
 sion which prevails in our councils. I do not mean in 
 this letter to enter into a detail of its rise and progress, 
 but will beg leave to refer to those despatches for the 
 particulars, and for the defence both of my measures 
 and opinions. 1 shall here only assure your Lordship 
 that this unhappy difference did not spring from me, 
 and that had General Clavering, Mr. Monson, and 
 Mr. Francis, brought with them the same conciliatory 
 spirit which I had adopted, your Lordship would not 
 have been embarrassed with the appeals of a disjointed 
 administration, nor the public business here retarded 
 by discordant councils. 
 
 The cause assigned for these differences, your Lord- 
 ship will observe, is the Rohilla war. I own I looked 
 for praise rather than blame from this measure, because 
 no visible consequence could be derived from it in the 
 situation which these gentlemen found it, but such as 
 was every way advantageous to the Company ; but had 
 they disapproved of it, I still think, that if their dis- 
 positions were to promote harmony and to maintain 
 the credit of Government, free from inconsistency, 
 they ought to have afforded me the means of receding,
 
 474 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 without fixing a mark of reprobation on my past con- 
 duct, and without wounding my personal consequence 
 by the recall of my public agent at the court of the 
 Vizier, or the faith of Government which had been 
 pledged for the completion of the Rohilla war, by the 
 abrupt order issued for withdrawing the brigade en- 
 gaged on that service. Had they conducted them- 
 selves on such conciliating principles, if I know my 
 own heart, I should have cheerfully joined in whatever 
 system they might afterwards have thought fit to adopt, 
 not pretending, in such a case, to set my judgment in 
 opposition to the will of the majority ; but it was not to 
 be expected that I should subscribe implicitly to a 
 direct censure of my own measures, and, what is worse, 
 to those violent resolutions by which not only the re- 
 putation of the Company, but also the benefit and ad- 
 vantages resulting from those measures were wantonly 
 exposed to hazard, for no apparent purpose. 
 
 The indignity fixed upon me by the recall of Mr. 
 Nathaniel Middleton was personal and direct. This 
 gentleman has been employed for nine months past 
 as resident at the Vizier's court, but his appointment 
 had been understood during the late Government to 
 be immediately dependent on me. The immemorial 
 usage of the service had left the whole correspondence 
 with the country powers in the hands of the Governor, 
 and Mr. Middleton in that light could only receive 
 his orders from, and address his letters to me. In 
 the course of his correspondence, I had encouraged 
 him to speak his sentiments freely, under the assurance 
 of their never becoming the subject of public record in 
 cases which I judged improper for such a communi- 
 cation. When therefore Mr. Monson moved for the 
 whole being laid before the Board, I could not, con- 
 sistently either with honour or good faith, comply ; I 
 urged these reasons, but they were overruled, and Mr.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 475 
 
 Middleton was immediately called from his station, 
 and thus a declaration made to all Indoostan, that my 
 authority was extinct, and that new men and new 
 measures would henceforth prevail. I do not know 
 what use my opponents may make of my refusal to 
 show those letters; I declare I have submitted every 
 part to their perusal, which was necessary for their in- 
 formation on public affairs, and as to those I have with- 
 held, your Lordship will, I hope, one day judge of 
 the propriety of my conduct in this respect, it being 
 my intention, as soon as Mr. Middleton arrives, to col- 
 lect my entire correspondence with him, and to offer 
 it for your Lordship's inspection. 
 
 Unwilling to encroach any more on your Lordship's 
 time, I once more refer to the public despatches for 
 my defence, and shall conclude with assurances of my 
 stedfast resolution to continue in my present station 
 attended with all its disagreeable circumstances, till 
 such time as the decision of my superiors shall either 
 remove these, or dispense with my remaining longer 
 under them. I own I have a confidence in your Lord- 
 ship's justice, and in the goodness of my own cause, 
 that leaves little anxiety on my mind for the event. I 
 have never deviated from those maxims and that line 
 of conduct which first recommended me to your Lord- 
 ship's notice, and therefore cannot doubt of the con- 
 tinuance of your favour and protection. I am sen- 
 sible how disagreeable it must be to your Lordship to 
 see the measure which you had so wisely planned and 
 steadily pursued to its accomplishment, thus thwarted 
 in its execution by the disputes of the very persons 
 whom your Lordship had charged with it, but I still 
 trust the blame will be imputed to those only whose 
 violent attacks occasioned it, and not to me whose sole 
 aim has been to defend myself against them. 
 
 Although your Lordship will receive in the regular
 
 476 MEMOIRS or WAHKEN HASTINGS. 
 
 course from the Court, of Directors, the copies of all 
 despatches from this Government to them ; yet as 
 these being official papers may not perhaps be so 
 ready at all times for your perusal, and it is of conse- 
 quence to me that your Lordship may be furnished 
 with the means of reading in an hour of leisure those 
 which contain the justification of my conduct, and a 
 minute explanation of the measures which have been 
 objected to me, I entreat your permission to lay before 
 you, with this address, a copy of my letter written by 
 this packet to the Court of Directors, and of the 
 minute containing my appeal from the acts and 
 opinions of the majority of the present Council. I 
 lament the length of these papers, which may dis- 
 courage your Lordship from the perusal of them, but 
 I have wanted time to reduce them to a smaller com- 
 pass, and I will venture to promise that they will pre- 
 sent you with a connected and just state of facts. 
 Your Lordship's penetration will detect any errors 
 which I may have committed in the reasoning upon 
 them. 
 
 An earnest desire not to overload my narrative 
 with a greater bulk of correspondence than is 
 absolutely necessary, alone prevents me from ap- 
 pending to this other letters upon the same subject. 
 They seem to me to carry upon the face of them 
 evident marks of truth, while they place their 
 writer in the light of one who, seeking no benefit 
 personal to himself, is chafed and chagrined only 
 because his views of general policy are thwarted. 
 I think, however, that the following extract from 
 a communication to his friend Mr. Palk is ex- 
 tremely characteristic, and I am sure that it is
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 477 
 
 interesting. Speaking of his coadjutors in office, 
 he says, 
 
 " I find Sir Elijah the man you describe him, and 
 much as I have always known him, moderate, sensible, 
 and, to myself, friendly. It is happy for this country 
 and for the Company that he is so, and that two per- 
 sons so mutually well inclined arc at the head of two 
 departments most admirably adapted for hostility. 
 General Clavering is, I verily believe, a man of strict 
 honour, but he brought strong prejudices with him, 
 and he receives all his intelligence from men whose 
 aim or interest it is to increase those prejudices ; and 
 he has acted a foolish part, for which I could punish 
 him, if I chose, by leaving him in the chair which he 
 has taken much pains to strip of all its consequence, 
 and to which neither his abilities nor his experience 
 enable him to give a consequence of any other kind. 
 Colonel Monson is a sensible man, but received his 
 first impressions from Major Grant, and acts in all 
 things from them. He no doubt thinks the second 
 place better than the first. As to Francis, I shall say 
 nothing of him. I shall stay out the issue of the 
 troubles which their ill humour, or whatever secret 
 motive they may have, has introduced ; and that may 
 either induce our friend George to continue some years 
 longer in India, or you will see us both together about 
 June, 1776. * * * I had formed great designs 
 to be executed by the vast powers concentered by 
 the Act of Parliament in the new Council, and had 
 even set on foot some preparatory measures to forward 
 them ; but I find that we must hazard the fate of a 
 res cfjnsilii expers, instead of aiming at flights of 
 ambition." 
 
 While Mr. Hastings was thus communicating 
 unreservedly with his friends at home, the hostile
 
 4T8 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 spirit of his Council appears to have become day 
 by day more rancorous. From the highest point 
 in his general policy, down to his right of nomi- 
 nating to offices under government, they failed 
 not, at all convenient opportunities, to thwart him. 
 Not satisfied with superseding his agent at Luck- 
 now, and taking out of his hands the right of 
 confidential correspondence with their own ; not 
 satisfied with the general censure which they had 
 cast upon treaties and military operations com- 
 pleted ere they came into power, and heartily 
 approved of by the authorities at home ; they 
 endeavoured at once to excite against him the ill- 
 will of the army, and to cover him with obloquy 
 in the Court of Directors, as a man open to bribery 
 himself, and therefore ready to connive at a similar 
 disposition in others. Having branded his nomi- 
 nation of a civil resident at the Court of Oude as 
 a gross insult to the military profession, they insti- 
 tuted an inquiry into the manner in which the Ro- 
 hilla war had been conducted, and did their best to 
 get up a case of cruelty against him, as if by his 
 sanction every outrage of which the Vizier and his 
 followers were accused had been perpetrated. Nay, 
 to such a height was this wickedness carried, that 
 General Clavering had the folly to ask Colonel 
 Lesslie, " Did the army consider the war in which 
 they were engaged as honourable to the British 
 name, or the reverse ?" Colonel Lesslie, as was to
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 479 
 
 be expected from a soldier and a gentleman, 
 replied, that he could not answer for the opinions 
 of others ; and even Colonel Champion, perverse 
 and wayward as he was, left, by his evidence, the 
 personal character of the Governor- general free 
 from an approach to stain? 
 
 Failing in this, and convinced against their will 
 that the only parties subjected to evil by the war 
 were bands of military adventurers, the Council 
 proceeded to arraign Mr. Hastings, on the ground 
 that he first encouraged the army to look for a 
 pecuniary reward from the Vizier, in the teeth 
 of the Act of Parliament which rendered the 
 acceptance of presents illegal, and then, by re- 
 quiring that reference should be made to the 
 Supreme Council at Calcutta, evinced a disposition 
 to place them in an invidious position towards the 
 troops. " We cannot but lament," said they, in 
 their curious minute, wherein they sought to set 
 forth the reasons which induced them to receive 
 seven lacs of rupees in deposit, " We cannot but 
 lament the difficult and distressing situation to 
 which the measures of the late administration have 
 reduced the present government, by placing us 
 between the strict prohibition of the law and the 
 earnest desires of the army. The unhappy conse- 
 quences of an offensive war, undertaken on such 
 principles as that against the Rohillas, must ope- 
 rate in every direction. An innocent nation, with-
 
 480 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 out offence, stripped of their property ; one part 
 of the conquering army engrosses the whole 
 plunder, the other is disgusted ; languor and de- 
 spondency succeed ; and when at last our troops 
 return home, the difficulty of deciding between 
 their claims and the prohibition of the law, is 
 thrown upon the civil government." It would be 
 hard to conceive a course of proceeding more vin- 
 dictive as well as more unrighteous than this. For 
 the men who recorded the minute knew that the 
 Rohillas were not an innocent nation, that they 
 were usurpers and plunderers, whose expulsion 
 from Rohilcund left the natives in a better plight 
 than ever ; and that the offer of a present from 
 the Vizier came in the natural course of things, 
 which Mr. Hastings could not abruptly decline 
 without doing violence to the feelings of his ally. 
 Finally, it is certain, that had Mr. Hastings 
 settled the point without reference to them, his 
 decision, be it of what nature it might, would have 
 been at once condemned as unwise and presump- 
 tuous. But we are as yet only at the beginning 
 of troubles which, as the sequel will show, go on 
 enlarging themselves from stage to stage.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 481 
 
 CHAPTER XIV. 
 
 Continuation of Discords Attacks on the private Character of Mr. 
 Hastings General Correspondence. 
 
 AMID squabbles such as these, in every respect dis- 
 creditable to those with whom they originated and 
 were carried on, the remainder of the year 1774 
 went out. There was no prospect of better things 
 in store, to throw a halo over the dawn of the year 
 that succeeded. The Benares treaty and the Ro- 
 hilla war continued still to furnish fruitful topics 
 of discussion, which, as men's passions became 
 inflamed, grew, from day to day, less reasonable 
 and less honest. To such a height, indeed, was 
 the hostility of the new members carried, that they 
 did not scruple to make an avowal of their desire 
 to blacken the character of the Governor- general, 
 be the consequences what they might. " The 
 justification of our own conduct," say they, in one 
 of their memorable despatches to the Court of 
 Directors, " must of necessity carry with it, and 
 will only be supported by a strong and deliberate 
 censure of the preceding administration." Ac- 
 cordingly, having rung the changes for a while 
 on these two flagrant offences, they turned their 
 attention next to what may be termed the internal 
 VOL. i. 2 i
 
 482 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 administration of the country ; and there, not less 
 than in his foreign politics, they saw nothing in 
 the whole bent of Mr. Hastings's proceedings, 
 except abundant ground of censure. His fiscal 
 arrangements were passed in review before them, 
 and condemned. The leasing system, on which the 
 land revenues were raised, they pronounced to be a 
 failure ; the arrangements entered into for securing 
 to the Company an increased benefit from the taxes 
 on opium, were denounced ; the bank which, with 
 so much care, he had established in Calcutta, they 
 treated as a nuisance, and its abolition was per- 
 emptorily ordered. Mr. Hastings would have 
 been more than mortal had he submitted to such 
 usage without complaining. Both he and Mr. 
 Barwell protested against the violence with which 
 affairs were conducted, and threw themselves for 
 support upon the home authorities. 
 
 Such was the state of feeling in the Supreme 
 Council, the ostensible head of the government 
 having become little better than a cypher, when 
 certain events befel of which it is necessary to 
 make mention, not more because of the influence 
 which they exercised over the whole after life of 
 the subject of this memoir, than because they give 
 its peculiar character to an important page in 
 English history. 
 
 In the month of January, 1775, died Shujah 
 Dowlah, the sovereign of Oude, alter consigning,
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 483 
 
 with all solemnity, his son and successor, Murza 
 Aumanee, to the protection of the British Govern- 
 ment. One of the last acts, indeed, of the dying 
 Nabob was to dictate a letter to Mr. Hastings, 
 in which he implored the Governor to extend to 
 his successor the same friendly feeling which he 
 had himself uniformly experienced ; without, how- 
 ever, entering at all into detail relative to any 
 dispositions which he might have made for the 
 due maintenance of his son's authority, or the dis- 
 tribution of his own accumulated wealth. I take 
 especial notice of this circumstance, because, con- 
 sidering the terms on which the Vizier had long 
 lived with Mr. Hastings, it seems difficult to be- 
 lieve that he would have concealed from the Go- 
 vernor-general the particulars of his last will, had 
 they been in any way remarkable in their bearing ; 
 and as no such written deed was ever afterwards 
 produced, the fair conclusion certainly seems to 
 be that none such ever had existence. 
 
 The death of Shujah Dowlah brought imme- 
 diately under the notice of the Supreme Council 
 at Calcutta, two points of very great importance. 
 First, a question was raised whether or not the 
 treaty of alliance which Mr. Hastings Jiad con- 
 tracted with the deceased ought to be considered 
 as binding in reference to his successor ; and next, 
 it rested with the British Government to decide 
 how far they would sanction certain claims, which
 
 484 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 the Begum, or widow of Shujah Dowlali, set up 
 to be regarded as sole heir to the treasures of which 
 her husband had died in possession. With respect 
 to the former of these points, Mr. Hastings, sup- 
 ported as usual by Mr. Barwell, declared that 
 there could be no room even for doubt. The 
 treaties of Allahabad and Benares were clearly 
 engagements between states. No change in the 
 mere persons of the individuals by whom these 
 states were governed could in any degree affect 
 them, unless, indeed, there should be on one side 
 or the other a positive violation of the terms ; and 
 hence, to speak of the voidance of the Company's 
 engagements as a consequence necessary upon the 
 demise of Shujah Dowlah, was, in their opinion, 
 to assert an absurdity. As well might Portugal 
 claim the right of setting aside the Methuen treaty, 
 on the ground that it had been contracted under a 
 sovereign long dead, as the Company turn round 
 and say to Ausuf ul Dowlah (for such was the 
 title which the young Nabob assumed), " the 
 treaty of Benares was a mere personal arrange- 
 ment with your father ; you can have no right to 
 expect the smallest benefit from it." For though 
 the sovereign of Oude owed allegiance to the 
 Mogul, such allegiance was, and had long been, 
 merely nominal ; much more so, indeed, than was 
 that of the English to the Nabobs of Bengal, 
 when they claimed, by virtue of their phinnauns,
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 485 
 
 the right to occupy Fort William, and waged war 
 against their sovereigns as often as they presumed 
 to question that right. 
 
 It may be harsh to assume that the mere cir- 
 cumstance of this view of the case having been 
 adopted by Mr. Hastings was sufficient to influence 
 the majority in the adoption of its opposite. Pro- 
 bably there were other motives at work, but how- 
 ever this may be, the majority came to the conclu- 
 sion that with the decease of Sliujah Dowlah all 
 political connexion between the Company and the 
 state of Oude ceased, and that if he desired its 
 continuance, the new sovereign must be content to 
 negociate upon a basis altogether novel. Now con- 
 sidering that in their first communications to the 
 Court of Directors they had reprobated the Go- 
 vernor-general, on the plea that his single object 
 in concluding the treaty was to bring money into 
 the exhausted treasury at Calcutta, that they 
 blamed him for the extent of his exactions, and 
 held up to scorn the miserable policy of letting out 
 a portion of the Company's army for hire ; the 
 obvious inference for the reader to draw is, that 
 having created for themselves an opportunity of 
 dissolving such a discreditable compact, they would 
 promptly and eagerly take advantage of it; and 
 marching back the brigade within the limits of 
 their own territories, leave the young prince to stand 
 or fall by his own resources. Was such their line
 
 
 486 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 of conduct? Quite the reverse. Knowing that 
 the young Nabob was beset by a complication of 
 difficulties, aware that, for reasons immediately to 
 be assigned, the withdrawal of their support would 
 tend to his immediate destruction, they directed 
 their agent, Mr. Bristow, to inform him, that 
 unless he consented to increase his monthly subsidy 
 by fifty thousand rupees, they should recall the 
 brigade in one week, and never again permit it to 
 pass his frontier. This was tolerably well for men 
 who both blamed Mr. Hastings for oppressing the 
 Vizier, and affected to hold cheap the subsidy 
 obtained, because it was brought by him to the 
 account of the Company's resources; but their 
 demands did not end there. They recollected that 
 from the province of Benares the King of Oude 
 derived an annual revenue of twenty-two lacs. 
 They felt that such a sum would make a very plea- 
 sant addition to the permanent revenues of Bengal, 
 and they boldly required that his sovereign rights 
 over the territories of Cheyt Sing should be made 
 over to them. The young Nabob protested, com- 
 plained, and mourned his hard fate ; but what 
 c'J ( <ld be do ? As a measure of self-preservation he 
 came into these harsh terms, while the majority 
 took infinite credit to themselves for having largely 
 promoted the interests of the East India Company. 
 Mr. Hastings, as he had taken up from the first 
 an opposite view of the question, so he entered a
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 487 
 
 minute, as usual, condemnatory of the proceedings, 
 and wrote home at the same time to explain his 
 views to the Directors, and to warn them against 
 the moral wrong, into the commission of which they 
 were about to be hurried. The Court could not 
 but admit that the Governor's notions were just, 
 yet while indirectly censuring by such admission 
 the proceedings of the majority, they heartily 
 approved of the result, thus exhibiting one more 
 proof to the many which are every where before us, 
 that in popular bodies moral principle is seldom 
 a match for self-interest. Nevertheless, the full 
 amount of wrong into which the Indian Govern- 
 ment ran by this transaction, seems scarcely to 
 have been understood at the moment, and is not 
 unlikely now to be forgotten. Let me, therefore, 
 state the merits of the case with all fairness, more 
 especially as the act of doing so will lead me on to 
 a consideration of the second of those points of 
 which I have spoken as having been brought by 
 Shujah Dowlah's death prominently before the 
 Council. 
 
 When Shujah Dowlah died, there were con- 
 siderable sums due from him to the British govern- 
 ment on account both of the Rohilla treaty and the 
 monthly subsidy. For these his successor was 
 clearly liable, while the pay of his own army, 
 mustering upwards of one hundred thousand men, 
 was a full twelvemonth in arrear. The native
 
 488 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS? 
 
 troops became, as usual, clamorous for their pay, 
 and were with difficulty restrained from breaking 
 out into mutiny, which the Nabob, a weak and 
 indolent prince, found himself without the means 
 of allaying. The father, indeed, had died immensely 
 rich. There were laid up in the zenana, or women's 
 apartments of the palace, treasure to the estimated 
 amount of two millions sterling, the whole of which, 
 according to every principle of right and to the uni- 
 versal law of nations, ought to have come with the 
 crown to Ausuf ul Dowlah. But here the Begum 
 stepped in, and pretending that by will Shujah 
 Dowlah had bequeathed this enormous sum to her, 
 she positively refused to advance to the Nabob one 
 rupee. Had there been common honesty and com- 
 mon vigour in the English government at this 
 moment, much future mischief could have been 
 averted. First of all, Mr. Bristow was bound to 
 demand a sight of the will. He never did this, nor 
 was evidence ever adduced that any document of 
 the kind existed ; and secondly, supposing the deed 
 to have been produced, his obvious duty was to 
 inform the Begum that not till the testator's debts 
 have been paid to the last farthing, can any legacy 
 or bequest be claimed under the authority of a will, 
 however regularly executed. In this case, how- 
 ever, all that might be due to the English, all the 
 arrears of pay owing to the army, all outstanding 
 claims for the civil administration of Oude, as well
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 489 
 
 as the funds necessary to carry on the government 
 for the current year, ought clearly to have come 
 under the head of debts, and to have been out of the 
 accumulations of the deceased provided for ; and 
 then, and not till then, the question ought to have 
 been mooted, how far, as a sovereign prince, Shujah 
 Dowlah was entitled to will away, as private pro- 
 perty, monies collected from the public taxes, and 
 meant to be applied to the exigencies of the state. 
 For not the least remarkable feature in the case is, 
 that the Begum was otherwise provided for than by 
 the treasures laid up in the zenana. The Vizier 
 had granted to her, in jaghire, a tract of country, 
 which yielded an annual income of several lacs ; 
 and of this, not less than of her two millions, she 
 kept firm possession. 
 
 It is always difficult, it is often impossible, to 
 trace back, even in a transaction like this, effects 
 to their causes. I have no desire to follow the 
 example of Mr. Francis and his friends, by ima- 
 gining motives which may. have had no existence ; 
 but the facts are sufficiently notorious, that Mr. 
 Bristow not only neglected to perform these great 
 and obvious duties towards both his own govern- 
 ment and the Nabob of Oude, but that he lent 
 himself at once to the views of the Begum. Indif- 
 ferent to the great truth for it seems impossible 
 that he should have failed to perceive it that the 
 Oude alliance would be profitable to the Company
 
 490 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 only in proportion as the reigning prince should 
 be in a condition to maintain order Avithin his 
 own territories, and fulfil his obligations, Mr. 
 Bristow permitted the grossest of all frauds to 
 be practised on Ausuf ul Dowlah, in consequence 
 of which Ausuf ul Dowlah ascended the throne in 
 a state of absolute bankruptcy, out of which there 
 appeared a slender chance that he would ever be 
 able to escape. Nay, nor did the folly and injustice 
 of the proceedings end there. As if it had been 
 resolved to preclude the Nabob from all chance of 
 afterwards retrieving his fortunes, as if it had 
 been his object to place a bar in the way of inquiry 
 and investigation at any future time, Mr. Bristow 
 took upon himself the office of mediator between 
 the young King and his mother, and prevailed upon 
 the prince, for the paltry consideration of fifty lacs 
 of rupees, to sign a deed, by which the treasures 
 claimed under the imaginary will of Shujah Dow- 
 lah were for ever secured to the Begum. For this 
 Mr. Bristow took great credit to himself in his 
 correspondence with the majority, and for this the 
 majority praised him, in the teeth of a solemn 
 protest from Mr. Hastings and Mr. Barwell, both 
 of whom denounced the arrangement as alike im- 
 politic and iniquitous. 
 
 The controversies to which the settlement of this 
 affair gave rise had no tendency to smooth down 
 the differences already existing in the Supreme
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 491 
 
 Council. The passions of the contending parties 
 became, on the contrary, day by day more inflamed, 
 till in the end that which may possibly have been 
 at the outset a sense of public duty, degenerated 
 on the part of the majority into sheer personal 
 rancour. Notice was taken elsewhere of the 
 avidity with which, on first landing, they gave ear 
 to every tale which seemed to militate against the 
 private, not less than the public, character of the 
 Governor. For a while no consequences were seen 
 to follow these secret communications ; but the 
 time was now come when Mr. Francis and his 
 friends believed their budget to be complete, and 
 they no longer hesitated to open it. Charges of 
 bribery to an enormous extent, of corruption in the 
 distribution of public employments, of a studied 
 sacrifice of the interests of the Company in order to 
 advance his own private fortunes, of double dealing, 
 and chicanery, and malversation, were all at once 
 brought against Mr. Hastings. Nay more. Mr. 
 Hastings was not only accused to the Directors at 
 home, but was required by the members of his own 
 Council to answer before them for crimes said to 
 have been committed long before they came into 
 office. .Now, though I have examined the com- 
 mission under which they acted, and read with care 
 the letter of instructions which they carried with 
 them to India, I have been unable to discover a 
 sentence, or the fragment of a sentence, from which
 
 492 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 it can be so much as inferred that Messrs. Claver- 
 ing, Monson, and Francis, were meant to erect 
 themselves into a court of inquiry upon the per- 
 sonal proceedings of their chief. Their prescribed 
 duty was, to join heartily with Messrs. Hastings 
 and Barwell in the endeavour to give to the inha- 
 bitants of British India the blessings of a good 
 government. If errors were discovered in previous 
 systems, they were required to correct them ; 
 neither were they precluded, as individuals, from 
 reporting to the authorities at home any tales, how- 
 ever unfavourable to their colleagues, which might 
 reach them. But in laying themselves out to 
 receive such tales, far more in devoting the greater 
 portion of their time and attention to inquiries 
 connected with them, they went as much beyond the 
 line of their own province as they fell short of what 
 was due to the honour and interests of their em- 
 ployers. 
 
 I have had occasion more than once in the course 
 of this narrative to introduce to the reader's notice 
 the names of Maha Rajah Nuncomar, of Mo- 
 hammed Reza Cawn, of Rajah Goordass, Nun- 
 comar's son, of Munney Begum, the widow of 
 Jaffier Ally Cawn, formerly Nabob of Bengal, and 
 of Maborck ud Dowlah, nominal Nabob of the 
 same province, whose authority came to an end in 
 1770, when the Company stood forth as the avowed 
 rulers of the dominion which their arms had
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 493 
 
 acquired. Of Nuncomar enough has been said to 
 prove that he never was regarded, either by Mr. 
 Hastings or by any other of the Company's most 
 distinguished servants, except in the light of a 
 thorough-paced scoundrel. So early as the admi- 
 nistration of Mr. Vansittart, indeed, his intrigues 
 were as palpable as their object was dishonest, 
 while in later times he seems never to have been 
 employed under the English government except to 
 the injury of his superiors and the extreme oppres- 
 sion of the people. How Mr. Hastings dealt with 
 him, from the date of his appointment as Governor 
 of Bengal, the correspondence introduced into a 
 former part of this work has shown. No confi- 
 dence whatever was reposed in him ; no employ- 
 ment of honour or responsibility was committed to 
 him ; indeed he was uniformly and with studied care 
 kept in the back ground, even while, from motives 
 of policy, his son Goordass was brought forward. 
 
 Mohammed Reza Cawn and Nuncomar seem 
 to have been from early youth bitterly at variance. 
 Both of them were of high family, and both en- 
 dowed with talents of a superior order ; they first 
 became rivals for public employment, and then 
 settled down into inveterate personal enemies. 
 Each, moreover, having his own faction among 
 the native gentry and people of consequence, it 
 was esteemed an act of good policy to balance the 
 one against the other, insomuch that when, by ex-
 
 494 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 press orders from England, Mr. Hastings put Mo- 
 hammed Reza Cawn in arrest, he found himself 
 in some measure compelled to draw from the ob- 
 scurity into which it had fallen, the family of his 
 rival. The reader cannot, however, have for- 
 gotten, that to Nuricomar himself, Mr. Hastings 
 never extended his confidence. On the contrary, 
 when Munny Begum was appointed guardian to 
 the young Nabob's person, and Rajah Goordass 
 became Devvan in his household^ care was taken 
 to prevent, as far as possible, all communica- 
 tion between the son and his father ; the latter 
 being on all occasions represented to the Court of 
 Directors as an intriguing arid unprincipled man, 
 who never took part in any matter except for the 
 purpose of promoting his own selfish interests. 
 Among other instances of this man's duplicity, Mr. 
 Hastings, in a letter written in 1772, informs the 
 Court that " Before my departure from Fort St. 
 George, when my appointment to this presidency 
 was known, a messenger, expressly deputed from 
 Munny Begum, came to me there with letters 
 from her, entreating my protection in the most 
 earnest terms, both for her house and for the people 
 of Bengal, against the tyranny of Mohammed Reza 
 Cawn ; and referring for further information to 
 Maha Rajah Nuncomar, from whom I received 
 similar addresses on the same subject, and by the 
 same hand. The Munny Begum has since
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 495 
 
 solemnly disavowed ever having written such 
 letters, or authorized such a communication." A 
 man who was capable of such a fraud as this 
 was not likely to be taken into favour by Mr. 
 Hastings. With the perseverance and cunning 
 of his nation, however, he ceased not to importune 
 for public employment ; forging papers, suborning 
 false witnesses, and adopting every conceivable 
 method of obtaining his end ; and the steady re- 
 pulses which he met with from the Governor of 
 Bengal he neither forgot nor forgave. 
 
 It was no secret to Mr. Hastings that with 
 Nuncomar among other discontented persons, his 
 rivals in the government had early entered into 
 alliance. With Mohammed Reza Cawn, on the 
 contrary, they refused for a while to communicate, 
 for no other ostensible reason than that Mr. 
 Hastings seemed to think favourably of him. But 
 even this feeling of aversion was seen by de- 
 grees to subside, and Mr. Hastings, a good deal 
 to his own surprise, ascertained that through 
 Mohammed Reza Cawn, not less than through 
 Nuncomar, they were seeking to aim a blow at 
 his character. In a word, it came out, by degrees, 
 that these two rivals for power were to be used 
 as instruments wherewith to destroy the good name 
 and undermine the influence of the Governor- 
 general ; and if the one proved less pliable than 
 the majority had reason to expect, the other
 
 496 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 entered with all his heart into their views, and 
 found more than one ally to sustain him. 
 
 On the 6th of March Nuncomar opened the 
 campaign by waiting formally upon Mr. Francis, 
 presenting to him a letter addressed to the Go- 
 vernor-general, and required him to lay it, as a 
 point of duty, before the Board. With this re- 
 quest Mr. Francis judged it expedient to comply, 
 and there was read in consequence, the same day, 
 openly in Council, such a document as, I shrewdly 
 suspect, has never before or since been brought 
 under the notice of a body similarly constituted ; 
 for Nuncomar's communication amounted simply 
 to a charge against the Governor-general of direct 
 oppression and fraud to a large extent. It accused 
 him of having connived at all Mohammed Reza 
 Cawn's embezzlements, embezzlements by the 
 way of which there had never been the slightest 
 proof; it spoke of a bribe often lacs of rupees as the 
 true cause of the culprit's unlocked for escape from 
 punishment, and specified other presents to a large 
 amount, which the writer alleged that Mr. Hastings 
 had accepted, either as the price of appointments 
 unworthily bestowed, or as the terms in which 
 delinquencies were passed over and commuted. 
 Mr. Hastings, as might be expected, was full of 
 indignation at the unworthy treatment awarded 
 him. He demanded of Mr. Francis whether he 
 had previously been aware of Nuucomar's design
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 497 
 
 of thus standing forth as his public accuser ; and 
 he extorted from his colleague an avowal, that 
 though ignorant of the precise contents of the 
 letter then read, he knew perfectly, when he re- 
 ceived it from the writer's hands, that it was full of 
 heavy charges against the head of the government. 
 
 So passed one day in fierce and stormy debate, 
 Mr. Hastings scouting the accusations of such a 
 miscreant as Nuncomar, while at the same time 
 he denied the right of the Council, under any cir- 
 cumstances, to entertain them. Two days subse- 
 quently, that is to say, on the next meeting of the 
 Board, a similar scene was enacted. A second letter 
 from Nuncomar was read, in which the writer 
 demanded to be personally heard in support of his 
 previous allegations ; and to this demand the ma- 
 jority had the bad taste, as well as the audacity, to 
 accede. Again Mr. Hastings protested against 
 the insult. He had no objection to the majority 
 forming themselves, if they pleased, into a com- 
 mittee of inquiry ; but he would not sit as the 
 president of a Council into which the dregs of the 
 community were to be introduced, that they might 
 give evidence, at the dictation of Nuncomar, 
 against his character and conduct. I confess that, 
 in my poor opinion, Mr. Hastings in yielding this 
 yielded too much, and that Mr. Harwell's view of 
 the case, who spoke of the Supreme Court as the 
 proper tribunal before which such questions ought 
 
 VOL. i. 2 K
 
 498 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 to be tried, was the right one. But the opinions 
 of Mr. Hastings and Mr. Barwell were treated, as 
 usual, with contempt, and a resolution passed that 
 Nuncomar should be called in and heard. Mr. 
 Hastings would not submit to this. In the exer- 
 cise of the powers entrusted to him by act of par- 
 liament, he declared that the Court was dissolved, 
 and quitting the room, was soon afterwards fol- 
 lowed by Mr. Barwell. But what cared the 
 majority for this? They kept their seats; they 
 determined by vote, that the proceedings were 
 irregular, and placing General Clavering in the 
 chair, they desired Nuncomar to be introduced. 
 He came, said much about his own integrity, and 
 his absence of every motive save a sense of right, 
 for the part which he had taken ; and ended by 
 producing another letter, on which a new charge 
 against the Governor-general was immediately 
 founded. The letter in question, which purported 
 to be addressed by the Begum to Nuncomar, 
 adverted to Mr. Hastings's kindness to her in 
 setting her over the young Nabob's household, 
 and then went on to state, that she had offered to 
 the Governor, as a mark of her gratitude, one lac 
 of rupees. " The Governor," continued the 
 writer, " said in reply, that he had not acted from 
 motives of private advantage, but for the satis- 
 faction of his employers. I pressed the present 
 urgently upon him, upon which he at last said,
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 499 
 
 'Very well, if you do think proper to make a 
 present, give two lacs, as Maharajah engaged ; 
 Otherwise do as you please, you are your own 
 mistress.'" Last of all, after gravely asserting, 
 that t\vo lacs were actually given, one provided in 
 cash by Munny Begum, the other by bills on 
 Nuncomar, the miscreant produced what he 
 called the conclusion of the letter, in these words, 
 " For the future let us take care in the conduct of 
 our affairs, to consult and plan beforehand, that 
 when we are called upon no difference may appear 
 in our representations and answers, and that I may 
 conform to whatever you may say. Let nothing 
 of the secret part of these transactions be known 
 to the Governor or the gentlemen of the Council, 
 or any others. The proverb is, ' a word to the 
 wise.' " 
 
 If proof had not been afforded in the result of 
 a comparison of the signature attached to this 
 memorable letter with that which authenticated a 
 communication just received from the Begum by 
 Sir John d'Oyley, that it was not written by the 
 Begum at all, even in this case it seems hard to 
 conceive how the majority could have consented 
 to act upon such information ; for whatever else 
 it might prove, the document distinctly showed 
 that there was no species of fraud to which Nun- 
 comar was not prepared to lend himself. For 
 supposing it to be fabricated, then he stood forth
 
 500 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 a convicted forger and conspirator ; supposing it 
 to be genuine, it placed him in the scarcely less 
 envious light of a participator in the Begum's 
 duplicity. But the Council, as they called them- 
 selves, paid to these considerations no regard what- 
 ever ; they resolved, with one consent, that a sum 
 of three lacs and 40,000 rupees had been clan- 
 destinely and illegally received by the Governor- 
 general ; and that measures should be taken to 
 compel, without delay, the repayment of the same 
 into the public treasury. 
 
 Nuncomar was not, it must be confessed, very 
 scrupulous as to the extent to which he charged 
 the Governor-general with having profited by his 
 habits of chicanery. The sums of money, which, 
 according to his showing, must have passed, in the 
 shape of bribes and presents, into the coffers of 
 this rapacious functionary, will be found, when 
 added together, to exceed by far the largest 
 amount of property of which Mr. Hastings ever 
 stood possessed. Yet Nuncomar was not the sole 
 witness who bore testimony to the rapacious ve- 
 nality of this venal man. The Rannee of Burd- 
 wan, with her adopted son Ram Kasheen ; Roda- 
 churn Roy, a vakeel or agent of the young Nabob 
 of Bengal ; Caumul o' Dien, the farmer of an ex- 
 tensive portion of the revenues ; and last not least, 
 three English gentlemen, Mr. Grant, accountant to 
 the provincial council of Moorshedabad,and the two
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 501 
 
 Messrs. Fowkes, all came forward and laid to the 
 Governor's door charges of most extortionate cor- 
 ruption. Of the motives which may have swayed 
 the last mentioned of these personages, it is unne- 
 cessary for me to speak. They are sufficiently 
 commented upon in the portions of correspondence 
 which it will by and bye be my business to 
 transcribe. But much that remains to be told 
 will be without meaning to the general reader, if 
 I fail to take notice of the other actors in the 
 play, though my notice must of course be brief, 
 and the issue imperfect. 
 
 With respect to the Rannee of Burdwan, it 
 may be sufficient to observe, that she was the 
 widow of one Tillook Chund, who, with the title 
 of Rajah, had owned the zemindary of the dis- 
 trict, as indeed his ancestors had done throughout 
 the entire period of the Mohammedan sway. 
 This woman, having been left guardian by the 
 Rajah to his adopted son, a youth at the time 
 of her husband's decease of nine years old, had 
 acted as zemindar till the commencement of the 
 five years' settlement, when Mr. Hastings, dissatis- 
 fied with her system of administration, set her 
 aside, and gave the control over the revenues to 
 one Delul Roy, by Avhom they had ever since 
 been farmed. Mr. Hastings did not, however, 
 leave either the Rannee or her son in a state of 
 indigence. An ample pension, on the contrary,
 
 502 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 was allowed them, more than adequate to defray 
 all the expenses of their condition ; and with this, 
 after various ineffectual endeavours to recover her 
 political influence, the Rannee appeared to be con- 
 tent. But no sooner was she made acquainted with 
 the state of things at Calcutta, than she hastened 
 to add herself to the list of the Governor-general's 
 accusers, being well aware that she could adopt 
 no surer method of ingratiating herself into the 
 good will of the majority, and thus, through them, 
 accomplishing the great object of her ambition. 
 
 The Rannee's intrigues appear to have begun 
 so early as the month of December, 1774; at 
 which time she wrote to accuse both the Dewan and 
 the British resident of gross corruption; but it 
 was not till the success of Nuncomar's devices 
 spread abroad, that she openly took the field 
 against the Governor-general. Then, however, 
 she too entered the lists, bringing charges against 
 both him and his banyan, or native secretary, that 
 the one had accepted a present of 15,000, 
 the other of 4,500 rupees, as the price of their 
 connivance at Mr. Baber's more extensive corrup- 
 tion. Nevertheless, neither she nor her agents 
 seem to have acted, in this respect, on the dictates 
 of their own free and unfettered judgment. She 
 was willing enough to plot for the recovery of her 
 lost honour, she was not quite so willing to com- 
 mit herself in a struggle with Mr. Hastings, till
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 503 
 
 certain influences were called into play, and her 
 scruples melted before them. On this point, too, 
 the correspondence, by and bye to be inserted, will 
 throw a strong and a curious light. 
 
 Of Caumul o' Dien, I have nothing to say, 
 except that he appears to have been a tool in the 
 hands of persons more designing than himself; 
 neither does Rodachurn Roy seem to have played 
 a higher part. Yet the proceedings of both were 
 not less curious than the issues in which they 
 resulted were remarkable. 
 
 Again as time passed onwards, and the designs 
 of the majority became more and more apparent, 
 fresh accusers were induced to stand forth against 
 Mr. Hastings, all of whom were caressed, flat- 
 tered, and rewarded, in exact proportion to the 
 weight of the charges which they brought against 
 the Governor-general. Thus on the 30th of 
 March a new crime was laid to the door of Mr. 
 Hastings, that he had appropriated to his own use 
 not less than two-thirds of the salary allowed to 
 the Phousdar of Hoogley. It was a heavy charge, 
 it rested only on the testimony of an obscure native, 
 it was never brought home to the party accused ; 
 yet of it, and of the Governor, the majority did not 
 scruple to write in the following terms. " In the 
 late proceedings of the revenue board, it will ap- 
 pear that there is no species of peculation from 
 which the Honourable Governor- general has
 
 504 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 thought it reasonable to abstain. We believe the 
 proofs of his having appropriated four parts in 
 seven of the salary, with which the Company is 
 charged for the Phousdar of Hoogley, are such 
 as, whether sufficient or not to convict him in a 
 court of justice, will not leave the shadow of a doubt 
 concerning his guilt in the mind of any unpre- 
 judiced person." This is a bold assertion, yet it 
 falls infinitely short of another, which I find in- 
 troduced into the same despatch I mean the 
 minute drawn up by Messrs. Clavering, Monson, 
 and Francis, bearing date the llth of April, 
 1775, when, speaking of Nuncomar,and felicitating 
 themselves on the able assistance which he had 
 afforded them, they say, " Whatever might have 
 been his motives, his discoveries have thrown a 
 clear light upon the Honourable Governor- ge- 
 neral's conduct, and the means he had taken of 
 making the very large fortune which he is said 
 to possess, of upwards of forty lacs of rupees, 
 which he must have amassed in two years and a 
 half." Forty lacs of rupees, computed by our 
 legalized standard, would amount to something 
 more than 400,000. The expenses of Mr. 
 Hastings's trial, though they fell short of 100,000, 
 and did not come upon him till after he had been 
 thirteen years in office, left him without the 
 means of supporting, with decency, his place in 
 English society as a gentleman ! ! !
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 505 
 
 Matters had proceeded thus far, when a new 
 light broke in upon Mr. Hastings, and he who had 
 heretofore acted solely on the defensive found 
 himself all at once in a condition to turn the tables 
 on his accusers. Having evidence unexpectedly 
 supplied, he instituted proceedings in the Su- 
 preme Court for a conspiracy against the whole 
 of the majority's agents, namely, Mr. Fowke, 
 Nuncomar, Rodachurn, and others ; and though 
 not quite so successful as at the outset he had 
 reason to expect, the result of the prosecution was 
 to throw absolute discredit on the veracity of the 
 accused. How all this was done, will best appear 
 from a perusal of the following letters, a very 
 small portion of the correspondence which he 
 carried on at the time, and of Avhich the bulk is 
 in my possession. 
 
 To LAURENCE SULIVAN, Esq. 
 
 Fort William, 25th February, 1775. 
 
 Dear Sir, I have sent to Graham and Mac Leane 
 a load of papers, and these must supply the place of a 
 longer letter. If you cannot aid me in my present 
 warfare, it will be a point still gained of great moment 
 to me, if the perusal of these materials shall convince 
 you that I have no way merited the malevolent attacks 
 which have been made on my reputation by the new 
 members of the new Council. I am sure they will, and, 
 if truth and reason are heard, I am positive that both 
 will loudly proclaim my integrity, my fidelity, and suc- 
 cessful vigilance for the welfare of the Company and 
 the national honour. These men began their opposition 
 on the second day of our meeting. The symptoms of
 
 506 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 it betrayed themselves on the very first. They con- 
 demned me before they could have read any part of 
 the proceedings ; and all the study of the public records 
 since, all the informations they have raked up out of 
 the dirt of Calcutta, and the encouragement given to 
 the greatest villains in the province, are for the sole 
 purpose of finding grounds to vilify my character, and 
 undo all the labours of my government. 
 
 Surely it was not for this that the old servants of the 
 Company were dismissed and the new Council formed 
 with such great and extensive powers, to be spent only 
 in defamation and mutual contention. 
 
 Nund Comar, whom I have thus long protected and 
 supported, whom, against my nature, I have cherished 
 like a serpent till he has stung me, is now in close con- 
 nexion with my adversaries, and the prime mover of 
 all their intrigues, and he will sting them too, or I am 
 mistaken, before he quits them. 1 have expelled him 
 from my gates, and while I live will never re- admit 
 him ; yet I will support his son, and the arrangements 
 formed at the city, till the Company's orders empower 
 us to dissolve them. I hear that this also is intended 
 by the majority, and at his instigation. 
 
 I have written to Mr. Harrison to solicit his support 
 in the Direction. I think I have heard you mention 
 him as your friend; if he is, may I entreat you to join 
 my request that he will take some pains to become 
 master of the subjects of the present contest. I want 
 only that they be read and known. My opponents, I 
 am persuaded, hope only that they will not be read. 
 
 I can write no more, but remember me ever, my dear 
 Sir, your sincere and affectionate friend. 
 
 The following to Lord North is extremely cu- 
 rious, not only because it furnishes a complete 
 vindication of Mr. Hastings's conduct in reference
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 507 
 
 to his correspondence with Mr. Middleton, but 
 because it gives us an insight into one of those vast 
 schemes, which even thus early in his administra- 
 tion of the affairs of British India the writer had 
 begun to mature. Might not his views have come 
 to the knowledge of individuals among the Direc- 
 tors, and may we not attribute to their jealousy 
 some portion, at least, of the hostility which the 
 Court so strangely displayed towards the man who 
 was devoting his time and great talents to their 
 service? I confess that I am not competent to 
 determine how far his vision was attainable, but 
 I am sure that it was such as would enter into a 
 great mind only. 
 
 To Lord NORTH. 
 
 Fort William, 26th February, 1775. 
 
 My Lord, This letter will be delivered into your 
 Lordship's hands by Mr. Mac Leane, to whom 1 have 
 sent a complete and literal copy of my correspondence 
 with Mr. Nathaniel Middleton, the late resident on the 
 part of this Government at the court of the ]ate Nabob 
 Shuja Dowla, with a request that he will leave it with 
 your Lordship, if you shall think proper to receive it. 
 1 mean, my Lord, no more by this proviso than to avoid 
 intruding a load of papers on your Lordship's attention 
 which you may esteem of too little importance to merit 
 it. I have declared to your Lordship my intention of 
 offering these letters for your inspection, in vindication 
 of my own character from the suggestions occasioned 
 by my refusal to expose them to the view of the new 
 Council. Perhaps, in this endeavour to exculpate my- 
 self from a criminal imputation, I may make myself
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 appear to your Lordship's judgment guilty of indis- 
 cretion. I freely confess that I think there is room for 
 such a charge. At the time in which I wrote the letter 
 to Mr. Middleton, to which this reflection directly al- 
 ludes, I had no suspicion of a possible event ever 
 taking place which should oblige me to reveal it to any 
 person. It was written in a spirit of unbounded con- 
 fidence in the honour of the person to whom it was 
 addressed, and without any guard on the expression, 
 or other aim in the style, than to make it brief and 
 intelligible. There is one passage in it relative to my 
 own situation, which I almost blush to read at this 
 time, because it bears the appearance of a vain display 
 of consequence, although calculated with a very dif- 
 ferent view, and, in fact, such as I deemed necessary 
 from an intimate knowledge of the character of the 
 man to whom it was ultimately directed. 
 
 I am and have always been of opinion that, whatever 
 form it may be necessary to give to the British domi- 
 nion in India, nothing can so effectually contribute to 
 perpetuate its duration as to bind the powers and 
 states with whom this Government may be united, in 
 ties of direct dependence and communication with the 
 Crown. This system has been adopted with respect 
 to the Nabob of Arcot, and, I believe, has met with 
 national approbation. I thought it might be adopted 
 with the same success in regard to the powers on this 
 side of India. Their confidence would be strengthened 
 by such a relation, which would free them from the 
 dread of annual changes, and of the influence of indi- 
 viduals; and their submission, which is now the painful 
 effort of a necessary policy, would be yielded with 
 pride by men who glory in the external show of vene- 
 ration to majesty, and even feel the respect which they 
 profess where they entertain an idea of the power to 
 command it.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 509 
 
 In these ideas I was desirous of introducing to a 
 direct communication with the Crown a prince of so 
 much power and consequence as the late Vizier, and 
 whose interests were interwoven with those of our 
 nation. But it was not consistent with my sense of the 
 duty which I owed to the Company, to propose or en- 
 courage such a design while they were involved in 
 distress in England, and while their rights and pre- 
 tensions in this country were in litigation with those 
 of the Crown before parliament. To have in any degree 
 withdrawn from their immediate dependence any of 
 the powers who formerly looked up to them alone as 
 the representatives of the British nation, might have 
 been construed a surrender of their rights, and an 
 injury to their cause. As soon as the legislature had 
 decided on this question, my line was clear. I conceive 
 that the late Act of Parliament, by admitting the King 
 into a participation in the management of all the Com- 
 pany's affairs, and almost the sole control of their 
 political concerns, of course makes him the principal 
 in them, and entitles him to those pledges of obedience 
 and vassalage, from the dependents of the British 
 empire in India, which the ideas of the people and 
 immemorial usage have consecrated to royalty. 
 
 These, my Lord, were the principles which influenced 
 me in the proposal contained in my cyphered letter to 
 Mr. Middleton, dated the 26th of August. Whether 
 in this instance my zeal for the honour of my sovereign, 
 and what I deem the good of my nation, may not have 
 been too officious, I will not pretend to determine. I 
 hope not. It may be thought that I should have re- 
 presented my ideas to my superiors, and waited for 
 instructions ; but neither was this a subject which could 
 admit of a reference, and the occasion was too fair in 
 the circumstances of the Vizier at that time, to let it 
 escape me. He is now gone, and the design with him.
 
 510 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 If, however, the plan is approved of establishing a 
 direct connexion between the Crown and the Indian 
 powers, the Nabob of Oude will be the principal ob- 
 ject, and may be easily included in it. 
 
 I think it necessary to add, that the transcript of my 
 correspondence, which attends your orders, was written 
 by Mr. Nathaniel Middleton entirely in his own hand, 
 and is attested by him. It contains every letter which 
 passed between us, from the time of his appointment 
 to the day of his recall. They will do him credit if 
 your Lordship shall have the curiosity to peruse them, 
 in whatever light I may appear ; and in that respect I 
 shall feel a satisfaction in having been compelled to bring 
 him before your Lordship's notice. I have the honour 
 to be, with the greatest respect, my Lord, your Lord- 
 ship's most obedient and most faithful servant. 
 
 To JOHN GRAHAM, Esq. 
 
 Fort William, 25th March, 1775. 
 
 My dear Sir, The following anecdotes are worth 
 your preserving. You may have a good occasion 
 hereafter to have recourse to them. 
 
 You may imagine that the Ranny Bowanny would 
 not miss so fine an opportunity of reviving her com- 
 plaints and pretensions. Nundulol Roy was sent 
 down for this purpose. After him Ram Kishen, the 
 Ranny's adopted son, came down, and Deleel Roy, the 
 farmer, terrified by these appearances, followed him. 
 Baber wrote me a letter on the occasion, which con- 
 tained so lively a picture of the disordered state of 
 Rajeshahee from these migrations that I laid it before 
 the Board, and desired them to order Ram Kishen 
 and Deleel Roy to return to Murshedabad. They did 
 so. Deleel Roy went back, and Ram Kishen, after 
 some impertinent expostulation, left Calcutta, and 
 remains somewhere near Hugley, from which place he
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 511 
 
 wrote an humble petition for leave to return to Cal- 
 cutta. It was refused. 
 
 In the mean time Nundoolol, the Vackeels, and 
 Ram Kishen were severally urged to produce infor- 
 mations against me and others. Nundoolol himself 
 assured me that Colonel Monson told him in plain 
 terms that if he wished to succeed in his mistress's 
 application, he must give a Beraumut. This he says 
 happened about thirty days past, and he has not been 
 near the colonel since, but emissaries are daily with 
 him, pressing him with threats and promises to become 
 my accuser. He assures me that he has employed all 
 his influence with Ram Kishen, and will continue to 
 do so, to dissuade him from engaging in so dirty a 
 business, but that the young man (who is but a species 
 of scoundrel himself) has so many villains about him, 
 that he fears his arguments will have no effect. If 
 they have not, he declares he will quit the Ranny's ser- 
 vice, and have no more to say to her. 
 
 If they fall in with the overtures made them, as I 
 expect they will, the Ranny will be reinstated in her 
 farm, have kellats and honours publicly bestowed on 
 her, and a new prosecution will be commenced in the 
 Supreme Court, from which I cannot suppose that I 
 shall be exempted. 
 
 If they persist in declining a Beraumat, the proceed- 
 ings of the late Council will be confirmed, and Deleel 
 Roy continued in his farm. 
 
 I will at any time venture to yield to the spirit of 
 prophecy where I have such good materials to ensure its 
 accomplishment. As either event hereafter turns out, 
 remember the motive which I now ascribe it to, and let 
 both speak for themselves. I do not imagine they will 
 go so far as to set aside the eventual succession in 
 favour of Ram Kishen, but it is possible, and he would 
 go to the devil on such an invitation.
 
 512 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 Some time ago I was told that Nund Comar had 
 sent his son a draft of a letter to be written by the 
 Nabob to the Board requiring to be put in full charge 
 over his own affairs, and to be freed from the oppres- 
 sive guardianship of Munny Begum. Juggutchund 
 had before told me that the General asked him what 
 was the Nabob's age, and why he was not as capable 
 of managing his own affairs as the Begum. Spelling 
 both informations together, I thought it probable that 
 there was a project for depriving the Begum of her 
 authority ; and as I was morally certain that such a 
 letter if written would produce the effect intended 
 by it, and that the Nabob was impatient to be out 
 of pupilage, I have advised the Begum to accommo- 
 date matters with the Nabob and Bubboo Begum as 
 well as she can ; to suffer him to write the letter, and, 
 if it succeeds, to dismiss Goordas and his dependents, 
 and appoint a Dewan and Scrsihtadars in whom he 
 can confide. The project is rather too fine to succeed, 
 but I cannot devise a better, unless the arch scoundrel 
 outwits himself, which is not improbable, as the Nabob 
 has discovered that he has agents with Meer Sydoo, 
 and has expressed a suspicion that Nund Comar has 
 formed the wise scheme of raising him to the Nizamut. 
 His people have told him so, for they all hate and 
 dread the power of Nund Comar. 
 
 I do not venture to prophesy what will be the issue 
 of this business, but that if the Nabob makes the ap- 
 plication in consequence of Nund Comar's advice, and 
 says he is a man, the majority will say so too, and 
 dispossess the Begum. Nund Comar, supported by 
 the powers of government, is not so easily to be dis- 
 possessed. 
 
 For other matters I refer you to your correspondents. 
 
 It is well that this year's despatches are at an end, 
 for I begin to flag, as you will perceive by my letters
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 513 
 
 to the Court of Directors by this packet. Ho\v I am 
 to work through the fatigues of another year God 
 knows. Neglect no opportunity of writing to me. 
 Take care of my papers. 
 
 God bless you, my dear friend. Believe me ever 
 most affectionately and heartily yours. 
 
 Patton may be useful to you, and I know him to be 
 heartily attached to me, that he will gladly take any 
 part in my cause that you will assign him. 
 
 To Mr. GRAHAM and Colonel MACL.EANE. 
 
 Fort William, 25th March, 1775. 
 
 The papers which I enclose with this contain all the 
 material occurrences which have happened since the 
 last despatch. I recommend them to your attentive 
 perusal, and to your care. Your own judgment will 
 direct you to any present use which may be made of 
 them. I may have occasion to appeal to them myself 
 hereafter. 
 
 So much depends on the accidental current of 
 popular opinion, that I am doubtful of the effects 
 which may be produced by the new mode of attack 
 which my adversaries have taken up against me. I 
 trust to your friendship and abilities for averting and 
 obviating the end which it is manifestly calculated to 
 effect, I mean a diversion of the public attention from 
 the conduct of my opponents to my own in respect to 
 measures which have long ago received the most com- 
 plete approval, and of which the memory is now almost 
 obliterated. The violation of the engagements of the 
 former government with the Nabob Shujah Dowla, with 
 the other correspondent acts of frenzy which began 
 their administration, and the total stagnation of 
 business during the last six months, except the very 
 little which they have allowed me to do myself at the 
 Revenue Board, are neither removed nor amended 
 by any transactions of mine in the yc.ir 177'2. I 
 
 VOL. I. 2 L
 
 514 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 solemnly declare that I do not recollect a single act 
 of theirs which was capable of producing any useful 
 purpose, and scarce one independent of me of which 
 I was not the real object. I think our rulers at home 
 have too much understanding to be the dupes of their 
 malice, or to trust the management of this valuable 
 country to men whose behaviour has been marked 
 with so much design, ill temper, and ignorance. 
 
 You will find the instructions given to Bristow for 
 the new treaty with the Nabob of Oude less inconsistent 
 than their beginning promised, but you will meet, even 
 in these, the strong prejudices of party. 1 fear the 
 conclusion will not prove of much advantage. I expect 
 as little profit from the negotiations of the successor 
 of Nat Middleton, as I do faith or wisdom from the 
 successor of Shujah Dowla. You will meet with a 
 letter from the new minister, copied by mistake in the 
 public considerations of the 20th. It is his first, and 
 worthy those whose representative he is. 
 
 You may remember the suspicions which were ex- 
 pressed in the first orders of the Council to Champion, 
 and the precautions which they enjoined him to take, 
 lest the Vizier should attempt to destroy our army by 
 treachery. We have been lately amused by the in- 
 formation of such a plot said to have been formed by 
 the young Nabob, but without the smallest shadow of 
 a foundation to support it. The people have catched 
 the characters of the new rulers of this province and 
 apply them to their own purposes in every way. 
 
 In the proceedings of the majority on the 14th the 
 examinations of Gopee Barroll and Diaram Barroll 
 deserve your attention. Had they been questioned 
 by fair examiners, I have no doubt that they would 
 have contradicted one another in every reply. I have 
 taken notice, in my letter to the Court of Directors, of 
 the extraordinary procedure of these gentlemen in
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 515 
 
 compelling Bridjoo Kichore to accuse himself on oath, 
 and convicting him on the answers thus extorted from 
 him, which they call acknowledging his misconduct. 
 I am told that he persisted for near two hours in the 
 refusal to swear. Nund Comar, who was examined 
 the day before as an accuser, neither swore nor was 
 required to swear. 
 
 The letter produced by Nund Comar as Munny 
 Begum's is a gross forgery. I make no doubt of 
 proving it. It bears most evident symptoms of it in the 
 long tattling story told with such injunctions of secrecy, 
 and a word to the wise pertinently added to the end 
 of it, when the sole purpose of the letter was to order 
 the payment of a lac of rupees, and Nund Comar's 
 son and son-in-law were with the Begum and daily 
 informing him of all that passed. 
 
 The resolution taken by me to dissolve the meetings 
 of the Board (or rather to declare them dissolved) on 
 the 13th., 14th and 17th of this month, and the orders 
 given by me to Contoo to disobey their summons, will, 
 1 hope, be thought as regular as justified by the 
 occasion. I do not recollect an instance of the Council 
 being called, or continued, without the President's au- 
 thority ; not even in the contesjb of Mr. Vansittart's 
 government. As to an adjournment, the term is 
 nonsense applied to a permanent body like the Council 
 of Calcutta, which must meet twice a week, and may 
 daily, or as often as the governor chooses to assemble 
 them. 
 
 Right or wrong, I had no alternative but to do that 
 or throw up the service. Indeed I consider this as a 
 case which supersedes all forms. Their violence had 
 already carried them to lengths which no rules of the 
 service would allow or justify, nor could I yield without 
 inverting the order of it, and submitting to a degra- 
 dation to which no power or consideration on earth
 
 516 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 could have impelled me. I beg you not to pass un- 
 noticed the disadvantages to which I am exposed in 
 being obliged to repell their concerted attacks by un- 
 premeditated resolutions extorted from me in the 
 midst of provocations, the most likely to warp and 
 disorder both my judgment and understanding. I 
 thank God I have hitherto possessed both undisturbed, 
 at least I think so. 
 
 I shall continue the practice which I have begun of 
 dissolving the meetings of the Council, that is, of 
 leaving them to themselves, as often as they propose 
 new indignities for me. Indeed, I expect lo be able 
 to do very little with them, and how the public business 
 is to be conducted I cannot devise. 
 
 The trumpet has been sounded, and the whole host 
 of informers will soon crowd to Calcutta with their 
 complaints and ready depositions. Nund Comar holds 
 his durbar in complete state, sends for zemindars and 
 their vackeels, coaxing and threatening them for 
 complaints, which no doubt he will get in abundance, 
 besides what he forges himself. The system which 
 they have laid down for conducting their affairs is, as 
 I am told, after this manner. The General rummages 
 the Consultations for disputable matter with the aid of 
 old Fowke. Colonel Monson receives, and I have been 
 assured descends even to solicit, accusations. Francis 
 writes. Goring is employed as their agent with Ma- 
 hommed Reza Cawn ; and Fowke with Nund Comar. 
 I believe you both knew before you left Calcutta that 
 it was reported and currently believed that I had 
 been many days in close counsel with Nund Comar 
 before the arrival of the transports, and carried down 
 with him a long list of malversations to present to the 
 new members. I suppose it is the same with that 
 which Nund Comar himself has since presented. 
 
 Was it for this that the Legislature of Great Britain
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 517 
 
 formed the new system of Government for Bengal, and 
 armed it with powers extending to every part of the 
 British empire in India? 
 
 Colonel Monson, with a more guarded temper, and 
 a more regular conduct, now appears to be the most 
 determined of the three. The rudeness of General 
 Clavering, and the petulancy of Francis, are more pro- 
 voking, but it is from the former only that I appre- 
 hend any effectual injury. I therefore retract the 
 exception which I before made with respect to him. 
 I cannot temporize ; and after two years of anguish, 
 I will either retain my seat in comfort, or I will not keep 
 it. I never can be on terms of ease with these men. 
 
 I have sent you copies of the proceedings relating 
 to the fees and salaries of the officers of the Supreme 
 Court, lest you should hear my conduct called in ques- 
 tion about them, for every act of mine assimilates with 
 these men into criminality. I am, with the sincerest 
 and heartiest regard, Gentlemen, your faithful friend 
 and most obedient servant. 
 
 To LORD NORTH. 
 
 Fort William, 27th March, 1775. 
 
 My Lord, I have too great a respect for your 
 Lordship's time to attempt to occupy much of it with 
 matters so personal as those which constitute the pre- 
 sent disputes between me and my opponents in the 
 Council of this establishment; but my duty impels me 
 to offer my opinion of their immediate effects, and of 
 the necessity of a speedy decision upon them. 
 
 Your Lordship will have perceived, that in the 
 endeavours of General Clavering, Colonel Monson, 
 and Mr. Francis, to condemn the measures of the late 
 administration, and in the pains taken to attribute 
 them wholly to myself, their aim was to destroy my 
 credit at home, while all their public measures served
 
 518 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 to proclaim the annihilation of my power abroad. To 
 effect both purposes in the most complete manner, 
 agents, chosen from the basest of the people and none 
 but the basest would have undertaken such an office 
 have been excited to bring accusations against me of 
 receiving presents in the course of my former govern- 
 ment. These accusations, true or false, have no rela- 
 tion to the measures which are the ground and subject 
 of our original differences ; but my opponents undoubt- 
 edly expect, that if they can succeed to lower my 
 private character in the opinion of the world, the rec- 
 titude and propriety of my public conduct will be over- 
 looked, and that their credit will rise in proportion as 
 mine is debased. How far with the people, who are 
 ever prone to receive allegations for proof, and to sup- 
 pose that everything must be criminal which is deli- 
 vered as a charge, they may prevail to raise a clamour 
 against me till the g truth be fairly known, I cannot 
 pretend to foresee, but I am confident they will not 
 succeed with your Lordship, or those who are to be the 
 effectual judges between us. On the contrary, if it 
 shall appear that my measures have never been influ- 
 enced by interested views, but have been uniformly 
 dictated by a solicitude for the improvement of the 
 country and the prosperity of the Company ; and if it 
 has been unanswerably proved (as I flatter myself it 
 has) that their affairs are in an infinitely more flourish- 
 ing condition at present than they were at the com- 
 mencement of my administration, I am satisfied that 
 your Lordship will do me justice, and allow me still to 
 retain that share in your esteem with which you have 
 hitherto honoured me, and which it is my greatest 
 ambition to merit. 
 
 The dark and illiberal manner in which these charges 
 have been introduced, and the violence and intem- 
 perance with which they have been supported, will, if
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 519 
 
 ever they come officially before your notice, for it would 
 be rudeness in me to obtrude such a load upon it, 
 speak more plainly the designs and characters of my 
 adversaries than any conclusions of mine upon them. 
 
 It surely was foreign from your Lordship's intention 
 in establishing the new system of government for these 
 provinces, and in obtaining for it such great and 
 extended powers, that they should be wholly exerted 
 in acts of personal hostility against a mere individual, 
 whose removal required less even than a positive Act 
 of the Legislature to effect it. If I might presume to 
 conjecture the design of that wisdom which projected 
 this plan, I should be led to conclude that it was 
 formed only to introduce, by an easy gradation, a more 
 perfect constitution, to which a temporary combination 
 both of the powers and agents of the former with those 
 deriving their first existence from the government 
 itself, would naturally contribute, and preclude the 
 necessity of a more instant revolution, the shock of 
 which might endanger the national interests in this 
 country. If such were your Lordship's views, if such 
 was the object of the legislature, as is apparently sug- 
 gested by an Act formed for so short a duration, 
 nothing could so effectually promote it as a cordial 
 union of the new members of the temporary adminis- 
 tration ; as, on the other hand, their mutual contests, 
 and the stagnation of all public business, inseparable 
 from the divisions of those on whom its currency 
 depends, are the most infallible means of rendering 
 it abortive. Indeed, I have been told, your Lordship 
 knows with what truth, that it was your strict injunc- 
 tions to the gentlemen of whose behaviour I complain, 
 to cultivate a good understanding with me, and to 
 shun every occasion of personal animosity ; and I can 
 with a safe conscience affirm that I made advances 
 even beyond the line of my station, to prepare them
 
 520 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 for a temper so necessary for the public good. But 
 their indisposition manifested itself on the moment of 
 their landing, and has progressively displayed itself 
 to this time in such reiterated acts of deliberate and 
 wanton persecution, as no period of time in the records 
 of this government can equal. I early foresaw a part 
 of the evils which were preparing for me; but the 
 assurances given me by your Lordship, and the flatter- 
 ing distinction with which you had been pleased to 
 honour me, outweighed every consideration of my own 
 ease or convenience, and fixed me in the determination 
 to stand the event, and to wait for the remedy which 
 your Lordship's justice might prescribe, whatever 
 troubles might be destined to fill up the long interval 
 of my time be r ore I could receive the benefit of it. 
 
 I now most earnestly entreat that your Lordship 
 for on you, I presume, it finally rests will free me 
 from the state I am in, either by my immediate recall, 
 or by the confirmation of the trust and authority of 
 which you have hitherto thought me deserving, on 
 such a footing as shall enable me to fulfil your expecta- 
 tions, and to discharge the debt which I owe to your 
 Lordship, to my country, and my Sovereign. 
 
 The meanest drudge, who owes his daily subsistence 
 to daily labour, enjoys a condition of happiness com- 
 pared to mine, while I am doomed to share the respon- 
 sibility of measures which I disapprove, and to be an 
 idle spectator of the ruin which I cannot avert. 
 
 The following deserves the reader's marked 
 attention, and I therefore entreat him to observe 
 the date, and to compare it with that of another 
 letter which he will find a few pages further on. 
 It used to be urged as a heavy charge against Mr. 
 Hastings's integrity, that after authorizing his
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 521 
 
 agent, Colonel MacLeane, to resign, in his name, 
 the Government of Bengal, he disavowed the act, 
 so soon as the death of one of the opposite faction 
 gave him a majority in the Council, and continued 
 to wield a power which did not belong to him. I 
 apprehend that no one, after perusing the subjoined 
 correspondence, will ever think of repeating the 
 charge. 
 
 Fort William, 27th March, 1775. 
 
 My dear Graham, I think it necessary to give both 
 you and Colonel MacLeane this separate notice, lest you 
 should be at a distance from each other when the 
 packet arrives, of a resolution which I have formed, to 
 leave this place, and return to England on the first 
 ship of the next season, if the first advices from Eng- 
 land contain a disapprobation of the treaty of Benares, 
 or of the Rohilla war, and mark an evident disincli- 
 nation towards me. In that case I can have nothing 
 to hope, and shall consider myself at liberty to quit 
 this hateful scene before my enemies gain their com- 
 plete triumph over me. 
 
 If, on the contrary, my conduct is commended, and 
 I read in the general letters clear symptoms of a proper 
 disposition towards me, I will wait the issue of my 
 appeals. 
 
 I have imparted this resolution to no other person 
 on your side of the water, and I leave it to your dis- 
 cretion and MacLeane's to make such use of it as you 
 think proper. I shall certainly contrive to stop at the 
 Cape for the sake of intelligence. Once more adieu, 
 your truly affectionate friend. 
 
 A more curious document than the following 
 has rarely taken its place in authentic history.
 
 522 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 The light is now breaking in upon the writer, of 
 which I have elsewhere spoken ; and his reso- 
 lutions how to steer by it are taken boldly, but 
 with due deliberation. 
 
 To Messrs. GRAHAM and MACLEANS. 
 
 Fort William, 29th April, 1775. 
 
 My dear friends, I trust to chance for the convey- 
 ance of these despatches to your hands. They contain 
 the detail of a most extraordinary event, which will 
 serv r e as a clue to the discovery of the most base and 
 infamous artifices which have been practised to ruin 
 my character and fortune, and with mine those of every 
 man connected with me. I beg you will read them 
 with attention. I do not wish you to make any other 
 use of them but to refute any false reports which may 
 have found their way to England of this affair, or to 
 obtain a suspension of the public decision on the late 
 appeals if the shameless malice of my adversaries shall, 
 beyond my expectation, have prevailed to gain the 
 credit of those who are to be our judges against me. 
 
 Mr. Graham knows the character of Cumil O' Din, 
 I do not ; but do not suppose that he is possessed of 
 a preternatural spirit of constancy or of integrity. I 
 can hardly expect, therefore, that he will hold out to 
 the next assizes. Like every other farmer he has his 
 whole fortune and future prospects involved in his 
 farm. This lays him at the absolute mercy of the 
 majority, who have only to encourage or invite com- 
 plaints against him, and order mofussel inquiries into 
 his conduct. Mr. Graham knows how effectually this 
 will ruin him without even their interposition, which I 
 am certain will not be withheld. With the arts of in- 
 timidation and caresses alternately practised upon him, 
 with his own fears and interests strongly operating
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 523 
 
 upon him, and the armed hand of power held for ever 
 over his head, I think it almost impossible for him to 
 stand firm to the truth against so many incentives to 
 desert it, and no very great hazard if he suppresses or 
 varies his evidence at the trial. You may depend 
 upon the depositions for literal copies of those in the 
 chief justice's possession. The judges first refused to 
 let them be copied, or even notes taken from them. 
 They have since granted that licence which I have but 
 in common with the other parties. The contradictions 
 in Fowke's and Nundcomar's account of the affair, 
 and in their own evidences examined upon it, are all 
 of the most essential kind ; not the errors of memory, 
 but the direct opposition of facts which could not be 
 affirmed with truth without the certainty of recollection. 
 For Fowke's defence I have the joint recollection of 
 George Vansittart, Durham, and Elliott, added to my 
 own. Mr. Graham will well remember Yar Mahmud. 
 When Cumil O' Din first came to me with his com- 
 plaint, I heard him attentively. I cautioned him 
 against a false accusation, of which I represented to 
 him all the consequences. I questioned him closely, 
 for I doubted the fact. He answered me so con- 
 sistently and steadily that I was persuaded, and then 
 referred his complaint to the chief justice. After the 
 examination I sent for him to Belvidere (having had 
 the precaution to ask the judges if I could do it with 
 propriety) on the 23d. I told him that if his charges 
 were false, it would be impossible to conceal it from 
 the penetration of the judges, the jurymen, and the 
 assistants, by whom he would be closely questioned on 
 every minute fact and circumstance ; that the conse- 
 quence of his being proved guilty of a perjury would 
 be infamy and irretrievable ruin : I conjured him 
 therefore by God and his conscience, Khodaw-kawasty 
 and Desham-kawasty, not to involve himself in de-
 
 524 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 struction, nor draw me into the prosecution of an inno- 
 cent man (innocent I mean of the zerd, for I \vas clear 
 as to the arzce.) I entreated him to tell me fairly and 
 candidly the whole truth, I promised him both pardon 
 and my future support if he would reveal the real facts, 
 even though it should appear from them that he had 
 endeavoured to injure me, as the greatest injury which 
 he could do me was to deceive me on this occasion. In 
 answer, he affirmed, with the most solemn asseverations, 
 that he had related nothing but the strictest truth; he 
 repeated the story, and again repeated it with varia- 
 tions in little circumstances, and in the mode of relating 
 it, but with a strong and undeviating consistency in 
 every material point. He said it was impossible for 
 him to call witnesses to what passed in Fowke's cham- 
 ber, where he stood alone in the midst of his enemies, 
 but he would persist to his death in what he had 
 affirmed, and relied even on the depositions of Mr. 
 Fowke's own servants for the confirmation of enough 
 
 o 
 
 of it to serve as a presumptive evidence of the rest. 
 He returned the next day of his own accord to confirm 
 the same declarations. I accordingly resolved on the 
 prosecution, and in my heart and conscience I believe 
 both Fowke and Nundcomar to be guilty. It is not 
 possible for a man to prefer an accusation with a 
 cheerful and contented mind, and without any change 
 of circumstances, without a change of place, or a friend 
 to advise with, to repent in an hour's time, and solicit 
 with such eagerness as he is described to retract it. It 
 is impossible it could have been sealed both at his own 
 house and at Fowke's. It is impossible that he could 
 have begged, and entreated and fallen at Mr. Fowke's 
 feet, that Mr. Fowke should have threatened to knock 
 hirn down with a great folio, and that three men who 
 were all the time present or within hearing, should 
 have seen nothing but cheerfulness, content, and com-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 525 
 
 posure between them. It is incontestably proved that 
 Nundcomar dictated, at least by his own confession in 
 part, the arzee. It is avowed by Fowke that Cumal 
 O' Din demanded it back, and refused his consent to 
 present it to the Board, that he showed such a repug- 
 nancy to it as amounted to a conviction of the falsehood 
 of the accusation ; yet Mr. Fowke did present it to the 
 Council without the slightest intimation of its being 
 his own act and deed, in contradiction to the will and 
 entreaty of the man whom he named my accuser. He 
 solemnly denied having any knowledge of the zerd, 
 yet in the same breath he as solemnly called upon 
 Mr. Barwell to deny on his oath the truth of it, the 
 truth of a charge which he himself affirmed had no 
 existence. 
 
 He has a long time now before him to patch up all 
 these contradictions, for I understand the assizes will 
 not be held before the 15th of June ; but whatever be 
 the issue of it, I shall fix my judgment on the evidence 
 given without premeditation, and shall carry to the grave 
 the firm and immovable belief that these men are the 
 retained instruments of a faction to excite and to forge 
 accusations against me for the purpose of working 
 their triumph on my ruin. 
 
 I have but this instant read (though it has been 
 some days in my possession) a second letter written by 
 the majority to the Court of Directors by the Anson. 
 I have not time to answer it, for I have not an hour 
 left to close these despatches : but I cannot forbear to 
 express my astonishment at the effrontery with which 
 they affirm, that the whole country joins in their con- 
 demnation of my conduct, and in representing me as a 
 monster of iniquity, and guilty of every species of 
 enormity. There are many gentlemen in England 
 who have been eye-witnesses of my conduct. For 
 God's sake call upon them to draw my true portrait,
 
 526 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 for the devil is not so black as these fellows have 
 painted me. There are thousands in England who 
 have correspondents in Bengal. I wish it were possible 
 to collect testimonies from these. If I am not deceived, 
 there is not a man in Calcutta, scarce in Bengal, un- 
 connected with Clavering and his associates, who does 
 not execrate their conduct, and unite in wishes for my 
 success against them. Once more, my good and valued 
 friends, adieu. God send this safe and speedily to your 
 hands. 
 
 The consequence of this discovery was, that 
 Mr. Hastings, after well weighing the matter, pro- 
 ceeded to seek for redress at the hands of the 
 judges of the Supreme Court, who, on the 12th of 
 April, caused the parties implicated to be brought 
 before them,, and went into a long and patient exami- 
 nation of the whole case. It appeared to them so 
 full of suspicion, that Nuncomar, Mr. Fowke, and 
 their associates, were required to give security that 
 they would appear at the next assizes, and take 
 their trial, while Mr. Hastings was in like manner 
 bound over to prosecute for a conspiracy. Yet such 
 was the temper of the majority, that they chose 
 this very season to make a formal visit of honour 
 to Nuncomar, a compliment which not only they 
 themselves had never before paid him, but which 
 he had never received at the hands of any previous 
 administration. A more flagrantly indecent act 
 has seldom, I venture to say, been perpetrated by 
 any men in office. But their indecencies were far 
 from ending there.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 527 
 
 Nuncomar was held to bail on the 19th of 
 April. On the 20th the majority waited upon him, 
 as has been described ; giving, by that act, the best 
 assurance that he had lost no ground in their favour, 
 and holding out encouragement for others to follow 
 
 O O 
 
 in his footsteps. The encouragement was not offered 
 in vain. Within the space of a few days many 
 fresh charges were brought against Mr. Hastings, 
 one of which made him a party in the misapplica- 
 tion, by the Begum, of the funds allowed by the 
 Company for the maintenance of the Nabob's 
 dignity. Now, let it be borne in mind, that the 
 Begum, by denying the authenticity of the letter 
 which Nuncomar had presented as hers, placed 
 herself at once in opposition both to him and to his 
 patrons. It became an object, therefore, with them 
 to blacken her character as much as they were seek- 
 ing to blacken that of the Governor- general ; and 
 the following was the expedient adopted for the 
 purpose of proving that she and the Governor were 
 old confederates in crime. 
 
 On the 2d of May, Mr. Grant, accountant to the 
 provincial council of Moorshedabad, produced 
 before the Board a set of accounts, stating that he 
 had received them from a clerk in his own office, 
 who had formerly been in the service of the Begum. 
 The accounts in question professed to extend over 
 a period of ten years. They were kept in the Per- 
 sian language, and showed a deficiency of expen-
 
 528 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 diture in the household, as compared with the 
 stipends received, of nearly nine hundred and sixty- 
 seven thousand, or, in gross numbers, ten lacs of 
 rupees. Now, supposing the accounts to have heen 
 genuine, what then ? So long as the Nabob's edu- 
 cation was rightly attended to, his debts paid, and 
 the expenses of his household covered, of what 
 moral crime could the Begum be considered guilty, 
 because she contrived to save, year by year, one lac 
 out of sixteen ? An unprejudiced observer would 
 be apt to imagine that she deserved praise for the 
 exercise of a virtue very little recognised either 
 then or now in the families of eastern princes ; but 
 the majority in the Council thought differently. It 
 was immediately assumed that the ten lacs must 
 have been expended in bribes and presents to 
 Mr. Hastings and his friends ; and a resolution 
 was passed, that strict inquiry should be made into 
 the whole of the Begum's financial proceedings. 
 Moreover, the majority determined to carry on this 
 inquiry through a commissioner sent expressly for 
 the purpose ; and they nominated Mr. Goring, a 
 protege of their own, to fulfil the invidious task. 
 
 While these things went on in Council, an event 
 befel elsewhere, which led both immediately and 
 remotely to very serious consequences. Nuncomar 
 was arrested on a charge of forgery, exhibited 
 against him by a native merchant in Calcutta, and 
 committed to prison. The committal took place on
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 529 
 
 the 6th ; on the 9th the majority, by a stroke of 
 the pen, removed the Begum from her office, and 
 nominated Rajah Goordass, Nuncomar's son, to 
 act in her stead. This was indeed a bold proceed- 
 ing ; the very consummation of all their atrocities. 
 Without so much as waiting to ascertain whether 
 any or what amount of criminality attached to her, 
 they deprived of all influence, and subjected to the 
 grossest humiliation, a lady whom the Court of 
 Directors had especially appointed to be head of 
 the Nabob's family; and advanced to that high 
 station the son of a man, not only lying under the 
 odium of a threatened prosecution for conspiracy, but 
 awaiting, in the common jail, his trial for a capital 
 offence. It seems difficult to conceive how personal 
 rancour, or the spirit of faction, could go further. 
 
 After having called the reader's attention to such 
 strong facts as these, it would be idle to speak in detail 
 of the many lesser annoyances to which, from day to 
 day, the object of this party spleen was subjected. 
 Mr. Hastings's confidential banyan, or native se- 
 cretary, for example, had been in the occupation 
 of certain farms ere he came into Mr. Hastings's 
 service ; and his master had neither required him 
 to vacate them nor interfered violently to prevent 
 his hiring others. Mr. Hastings's forbearance in 
 these respects was declared to be criminal, because, 
 forsooth, there was a regulation which prohibited 
 the servants and dependants of collectors from be- 
 
 VOL. I. 2 M
 
 530 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 coming themselves renters of land.But Mr. Hast- 
 ings was no collector. He had nothing to do with 
 the collection of the revenue in any shape, except 
 by taking care, as the head of the government, 
 that justice was done to all parties. It was, there- 
 fore, impossible that the same objections which 
 applied to the case of a collector's servant could 
 operate in reference to him or his banyan. Again, 
 Mr. Hastings was accused of enriching his personal 
 friends at the expense of the Company, because he 
 suffered them to act as agents between the Go- 
 
 O 
 
 vernment and the parties to whom opium might 
 ultimately be sold in the public markets. Now 
 let it be borne in mind, that till Mr. Hastings took 
 the matter up, opium, considered as a source of 
 public revenue, had been of little more than no- 
 minal value. The monopoly of the trade, as well as 
 of the trade in salt, was, by regulation, handed over 
 to certain of the Company's servants, who were bound, 
 indeed, to make up a certain fixed amount of duty, 
 but never failed, in the course of a very few years^ 
 to realize out of the residue enormous fortunes. 
 One of the earliest of Mr. Hastlngs's financial re- 
 forms was to secure this monopoly to the Company. 
 The opium was, by his directions, cultivated on 
 the public account ; it was sold, when fit for use, by 
 public contract, and a lease, if desired, granted to 
 the successful competitor, on terms advantageous, 
 no doubt, to him, though at least as much so to the
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 531 
 
 Company. For, if the contractor gained a per- 
 centage on the ultimate dispersion of the article, 
 the Government was saved the costs of bringing it 
 to market, while a steady income was secured a 
 point of no mean consequence in the arrangement 
 of the fiscal affairs both of nations and of indi- 
 viduals. 
 
 It was charged against Mr. Hastings, that he 
 threw these contracts into the hands of creatures 
 and dependants of his own, as if he had been 
 bound to reject the offers of such, when they ap- 
 peared to be more favourable than those of entire 
 strangers. 
 
 Lastly, the cause of the Rannee of Burdwan, 
 and of her treacherous and unprincipled son, was 
 warmly espoused. They no sooner stood forth as 
 accusers of the Governor-general, than all their 
 demands were acceded to. They were loaded with 
 honours, the majority even in this setting all pre- 
 cedent as well as delicacy at defiance, while ar- 
 rangements into which a previous government had 
 come, and of which the Court of Directors had 
 delivered their unqualified approval, were coolly 
 set aside. The following letters will show how 
 Mr. Hastings felt under this accumulation of insult 
 and wrong.
 
 532 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 To Messrs. GRAHAM and MACLEANE. 
 
 Fort William, 18th May, 1775. 
 
 I have not time to detail the occurrences of the last 
 month, but must entreat you to collect them from the 
 extracts of consultations now sent to you. Indeed 
 these will give you a better idea of the temper of my 
 opponents and the nature of their transactions than 
 could be conveyed by a mere narrative. What I fore- 
 told concerning the dismission of Deleel Roy and the 
 restoration of the Ranny has literally taken effect. 
 Nundoolol, having used all his efforts with Ramkishen 
 in vain to prevent his engaging in the dirty work pro- 
 posed to him, separated from him, and the majority 
 have voted him dismissed. After Nundcomar's com- 
 mitment, the young scoundrel sent an emissary to 
 Cantoo, entreating my forgiveness, and offering to reveal 
 the arts which had been practised on him by Nund- 
 comar to compel him to put his seal to the petition, if 
 I would signify my approbation of it; but the General 
 sent for him, took a second petition in confirmation of 
 the former, and he is now tied down to the party for 
 ever. 
 
 The visit to Nundcomar when he was to be prose- 
 cuted for a conspiracy, and the elevation of his son to 
 the first office of the Nizamut when the old gentleman 
 was in gaol and in a fair way to be hanged, were bold 
 but successful expedients. I doubt if the people in 
 England will approve of such barefaced declarations 
 of their connexions with such a scoundrel, or such at- 
 tempts to impede and frustrate the course of justice. 
 Neither can I suppose that the dismission of Munny 
 Begum, for the sake of carrying a point of party with 
 which she has no concern, will be thought consistent 
 with justice, honour, or common decency. 
 
 1 recommend myself and my hopes entirely to your
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 533 
 
 friendship, and remain ever, my dear friends,, your sin- 
 cerely affectionate and faithful servant. 
 
 P. S. I now retract the resolution communicated to 
 you separately in my letters of the 27th of March. 
 Whatever advices the first packet may bring, I am 
 now resolved to see the issue of my appeal, believing 
 it impossible that men, whose actions are so frantic, 
 can be permitted to remain in charge of so important 
 a trust. Good God ! what will be said, if it be asked 
 with authority what the Council of India have done 
 with the vast powers which were assigned them in the 
 course of the last seven months; they have worried 
 their chief, and kept every office and business of the 
 state wholly impeded. 
 
 I must beg that the reader will pay especial 
 attention to the postscript appended to this letter. 
 He will thus see that the discretionary powers pre- 
 viously granted to Colonel MacLeane are revoked, 
 and that Mr. Hastings declares himself resolved, 
 for his own honour's sake, to retain the powers 
 committed to him by Act of Parliament, till they 
 should, by competent authority, be withdrawn. 
 How, then, can he be said to have acted with du- 
 plicity, when, on the death of Colonel Monson, he 
 refused to resign the chair to General Clavering ? 
 But I must let him speak for himself. The follow- 
 ing will show that not all the annoyances to which 
 he was subject, ever made him forgetful of the 
 true interests and real wants of the province over 
 which he had been placed.
 
 534 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 To the Right Hon. Lord NORTH. 
 
 Fort William, 2nd April, 1775. 
 
 My Lord, The assurance which your Lordship has 
 been so obliging as to make me, that if there was any 
 thing in the present system and arrangement which I 
 might wish to have altered, you would be favourably 
 disposed to attend to it, has long prompted me to offer 
 to your Lordship my thoughts upon the general ma- 
 nagement of the affairs of this country. The subject 
 is difficult and extensive, and requires both a vacant 
 and composed mind to treat it properly. This has 
 seldom been, nor is at this time, the state of mine, yet 
 I cannot suffer the last despatches of this season to 
 depart without communicating my opinion of such 
 additional regulations or alterations in those already 
 made as may be immediately wanting for rendering 
 more complete the system which your Lordship has 
 already so happily planned. 
 
 One of the great inconveniences to which the admi- 
 nistration of this government has been till lately sub- 
 jected is the want of a sufficient distinct ion between 
 the departments of it. While the affairs of the Com- 
 pany were merely commercial, it was useful and even 
 necessary that their servants should make themselves 
 acquainted with every branch of the service. Their 
 frequent removals from one office to another were well 
 calculated for this purpose, and the prospect of rising 
 in succession to the first and most lucrative employ- 
 ments, served to excite their industry, and was of some 
 advantage to them in establishing their private credit 
 while they continued in the intermediate stations, espe- 
 cially if they appeared to have distinguished themselves 
 in these, the same qualifications being required for 
 their own mercantile concerns as for those of their 
 employers. But the vast change which has since taken 
 place in the affairs of the Company, especially since
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 535 
 
 the acquisition of the Dewanny, required the applica- 
 tion of principles diametrically opposite to the former 
 practice for conducting them. The various and mul- 
 tiplied objects which have since occupied the attention 
 of this government were too valuable to be delegated 
 entirely to the charge of others, and too weighty for 
 its immediate superintendency. The right which the 
 former rule of the service gave to every person to suc- 
 ceed to vacant offices by seniority or rotation, occa- 
 sioned continual changes in every office and much 
 embarrassment in the accounts. The offices which 
 required great labour and yielded few emoluments 
 were ill supplied ; those who were employed in them 
 either claiming as a recompense of their services, which 
 was never refused after a space of two, or at most three 
 years, the succession to places of greater profit. This 
 was chiefly the case with the offices of the accomptants 
 and secretaries, the salaries of which were small, with 
 scanty or no emoluments, and even those dispropor- 
 tioned to others of the like amount enjoyed in the 
 country, by reason of the difference in all articles of 
 expense in town. Added to a spirit of dissipation, 
 occasioned by these frequent changes, the business of 
 the service often suffered by the loss of persons re- 
 moved from employments for which their talents were 
 peculiarly adapted, and as much by the appointment 
 of others to employments for which they were unfit. 
 Both inconveniences have sometimes been experienced 
 in the transfer of the same person from one office to 
 another, and it requires little argument to show the 
 absurdity of promoting a man who had distinguished 
 himself by his knowledge of the investment, or his assi- 
 duity in the arrangement and distribution of stores, to 
 the government of the country and the administration 
 of justice. 
 
 Succession by the routine of the Company's list,
 
 536 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 particularly to the Council, was likewise attended with 
 great evils. It brought the Council too near on a level 
 with the inferior branches of the service, and proved 
 an encouragement to oppression, as few would venture 
 to complain against men destined to hold the rod of 
 power, and even the members of the Council them- 
 selves might not always be exempt from the influence 
 of the same consideration or from that of a personal 
 connexion when appealed to as judges in such 
 grievances. 
 
 These inconveniences have been in part removed by 
 the mode established by Parliament for supplying the 
 vacancies of the Supreme Council, and by the institu- 
 tion of the Board of Trade, and the necessity for com- 
 pleting the other separations is become stronger by 
 both. 
 
 I would recommend that the heads of offices should 
 remain fixed, and the views of the assistants in each 
 confined to promotion in their own departments. Some 
 exceptions to this rule may occur, especially in the 
 offices of the secretaries and Persian translators, on 
 account of the improvements acquired in both, which 
 qualify the possessors of them for the most difficult and 
 important trusts in the service. 
 
 2. There is one strong objection to this restriction, 
 namely, that it would prove a great discouragement 
 to such of the servants as were allotted to the laborious 
 and least profitable duties of the service, while the 
 places of emolument were wholly engrossed by others 
 perhaps not more deserving. The only means which 
 occur to me for the removal of this objection are easier 
 in speculation than practice. It is to proportion the 
 emoluments of every office to the labour, trust, and 
 importance of the duties dependant on it. This can 
 hardly be effected by fixed salaries. There is a dif- 
 ference in the value of money between this country and
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 537 
 
 England, arising partly from the difference of expense, 
 and more from the necessity which every man being 
 but a sojourner in it is under of providing a compe- 
 tence against the time of his return to his own country, 
 which will be for ever an insuperable obstacle to the 
 appointment of salaries really adequate to the offices 
 for which they are assigned, which would not appear 
 enormous at home, besides that fixed salaries are no 
 incitement to diligence, but are received as of course, 
 and the services due for them reluctantly performed, 
 and regarded as a dead and unprofitable labour. It 
 may appear inconsistent that I should object to large 
 salaries, and yet propose emoluments which in a less 
 public way should yield an equal amount ; but this I 
 venture to recommend, and trust to your Lordship's 
 wisdom for approving it. Exclusive of moderate sala- 
 ries., the remainder of their allowances might be made 
 up by a commission charged to the Company or Go- 
 vernment,, or by moderate fees received according to 
 stated tables from individuals, as the nature of the 
 business performed might render the application of 
 either mode most practicable or most eligible. The 
 commission would less sensibly appear in the public 
 accounts, and the fees would be cheerfully paid by in- 
 dividuals, as they would in most cases prove the means 
 of accelerating the despatch of business, the delays of 
 which are often in the best regulated offices an in- 
 tolerable oppression. I am obliged to content myself 
 in this place with laying down the general rule. The 
 specification of it would take up more of my time than 
 I can now bestow, and of your Lordship's than I could 
 with decency claim. I will only add that I think it 
 practicable and capable of such restrictions and sub- 
 sidiary regulations as might in most instances obviate 
 any inconvenience arising from it. It would undoubt- 
 edly prove the greatest spur to industry, and it would
 
 538 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 be productive of this further advantage, that it would 
 remove the pretext for prohibited or hurtful per- 
 quisites, which in spite of the wisest institutions, ,or the 
 most absolute prohibitions, will exist, and be consi- 
 dered as tacitly allowed if the authorized emoluments 
 are inadequate to the ordinary rates of expense. 
 
 3. The management of the revenues is an object of 
 so much magnitude and importance that it would be 
 imprudent to offer anything respecting it as a perfect 
 plan drawn up precipitately and without discussion, or 
 indeed without knowing under what authority they 
 will continue to be collected after the expiration of the 
 present Act ; but in pursuance of the idea with which 
 I set out, I will venture to declare to your Lordship 
 that in my opinion, under the present system, there 
 cannot be a mode better calculated to improve the re- 
 venue of the province than that of its superintendency 
 by provincial councils. I would rather wish their 
 powers enlarged than reduced, and am of opinion that 
 an intermediate board of control might be successfully 
 established at the capital, which should audit all 
 accounts, and correspond with the provincial councils, 
 referring only cases of succession to vacant zemin- 
 darries, applications for the remission or suspension of 
 rents, general ordinances, the dismission of old farmers, 
 the settlements with new, for decision or approbation, 
 to the Supreme Council. This board should meet 
 every day, which would not only promote exceedingly 
 the despatch of business, which is the life of the collec- 
 tions, and preserve an uniformity in the management 
 of the collections, but it would, by lessening the weight 
 of affairs which are, on the present footing, an into- 
 lerable burthen on the Superior Council, enable them 
 to give more attention to matters of greater and more 
 general import, and render the control more effectual 
 as it would be less interrupted.
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 539 
 
 4. The commercial branch having been so mate- 
 rially separated from the other departments, I judge 
 it will be proper to make this separation still more 
 complete. The details of commerce are not fit objects 
 of attention to the supreme administration of a state ; 
 neither can the members who compose it be supposed 
 to be equal judges of the justness or propriety of these 
 transactions with those whose sole business it is to 
 attend to and understand them. Besides, in our con- 
 stitution, as it now stands, there are two authorities 
 in the same branch, each aspiring at the exercise, but 
 endeavouring to throw the responsibility on the other, 
 which must unavoidably occasion delays and a want of 
 vigour in their proceedings. A clear illustration of 
 this appears in the proceedings respecting the freight- 
 ing of the Anson and Ashburnham. The conditions 
 of the charter parties, and the examination of the 
 bottoms of these ships, were hardly objects of consi- 
 deration at the general Board, yet they occupied a 
 large portion of their time and attention. It appears 
 also very evidently that the Board of Trade avoided 
 giving their opinion on many points, and in some ab- 
 solutely declined it, because they did not choose to 
 take upon them the responsibility of advice without 
 the power of execution. I therefore think that great 
 benefit would accrue on all sides were that department 
 to be enlarged so as to include every duty appertaining 
 to the investment or in any shape connected with the 
 commercial interest of the Company, and every office 
 depending upon either. The execution in all that 
 branch will then be theirs, and the responsibility theirs, 
 and the government will only preserve that general 
 control over them which is necessary in the administra- 
 tion of affairs. 
 
 It seems also highly necessary that the servants 
 under that department should be totally dependant
 
 540 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 on the Board of Trade. Indeed I conceive that the 
 words of the Company's instructions imply as much, 
 but it has not been so understood by others. I foresee 
 great confusion, and the seeds of anarchy and disobe- 
 dience existing in their constitution if it is allowed to 
 remain on the present footing. It appears to me that 
 the Company's servants in that line should be fixed to 
 that only, with a positive interdiction of their removal 
 to any other, and that they should be left entirely to 
 the control of their own Board in the same manner as 
 under the former system. 
 
 5. Your Lordship will doubtless be fully advised 
 from the proper channels of the proceedings of the 
 Court of Judicature. Its effects will naturally be re- 
 presented by the public as they are felt, by some as 
 hurtful and by others as of utility. All new institu- 
 tions are liable to defect, and even the most perfect to 
 ill consequences in their first operation, but I may 
 venture to say this has been generally received as 
 tending to the happiness and benefit of every British 
 subject, and carrying the most gracious intention to 
 the inhabitants of Bengal. The protection which it 
 affords to the weak against oppression has already 
 been virtually felt by many who are even unsuspicious 
 of the source from which they derive so inestimable a 
 blessing. But it has also proved in some cases the 
 unavoidable cause of distress, by the total suppres- 
 sion of the former courts of justice within the city of 
 Calcutta, which is become already very considerable 
 from the number and wealth of its inhabitants ; and 
 by the weakness of the civil courts established in the 
 other parts of the provinces, and acting under a doubt- 
 ful authority. 
 
 It appears to me defective only in the inadequacy of 
 its natural powers to the extent of its jurisdiction. I 
 much fear that it will be found scarce possible in prac-
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 541* 
 
 tice to make the distinction intended by the Act, and 
 Charter, between such persons as are employed in the 
 service of the Company, or of British subjects, and 
 other native inhabitants. The mutual concerns and 
 connexions of two classes so formed of the same people 
 will bring almost every man of property within the 
 sphere of the Supreme Court, independently of the 
 necessity to which it seems unavoidably liable of exer- 
 cising a temporary authority, even over those not sub- 
 ject to it by the Act for the purpose of ascertaining 
 their exemption from it. The geographical measure- 
 ment of the provinces of Bengal exceeds, perhaps, 
 that of Great Britain, and the number of litigible dis- 
 putes is at least as great. Judge then, my Lord, how 
 incompetent a single court, however composed, must 
 be for the effectual distribution of justice to such a 
 nation. 
 
 6. I feel the weakness of my own experience when 
 I attempt to offer a remedy for this defect, but some is 
 surely necessary, and I should hope that the Dewanny 
 Courts, that is, the courts subsisting by immemorial 
 usage for the determination of litigated suits between 
 the natives, might subsist by delegated powers from 
 the Supreme Court, and dependent on it. Neither can 
 I propose any alteration in the criminal courts, because, 
 as they are constituted, I think them better calculated 
 for the speedy correction of offences in the natives, 
 than any other species of judicature which could be 
 substituted in their room. These at present hold 
 their powers from the Nabob, and are considered as a 
 branch of the Nizamut, but your Lordship will easily 
 conceive that his name is but an ostensible sanction, as 
 it would be dangerous to trust the real power in the 
 hands of a mere pageant, who has no interest in the 
 due exercise of it. 
 
 7. I venture to submit it to your Lordship's consi-
 
 542 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 deration, whether it might not be attended with some 
 good effects in establishing a good understanding be- 
 tween the members of the Supreme Court and of the 
 Council, and in enabling the former the better to com- 
 prehend the nature and utility of many propositions, 
 to be passed into laws for the good order and benefit 
 of the country, to the knowledge of which they have 
 not any present means of access, but in which their 
 concurrence is equally necessary whenever such laws 
 shall be proposed, and also for guarding the acts of 
 the Board from any legal error, that the chief justice 
 should have a fixed or occasional seat at the Council 
 Board. Of the propriety or consequence of this pro- 
 position, in other respects, I am not a judge. 
 
 8. Many alterations appear to me necessary, both 
 with respect to the management of political affairs 
 here, and the correspondence at home. Those sub- 
 jects not being of a local nature, it would be presump- 
 tion in me to propose anything concerning them to 
 your Lordship's superior judgment. Thus much only 
 it may be permitted me to observe that the political 
 interests of this country have suffered by nothing so 
 much as by the fluctuation and uncertainty continually 
 attending them, as well from variable orders from 
 home, as from indecision here. 
 
 9. The last subject on which I wish to engage your 
 Lordship's attention, although of equal if not superior 
 importance to any of the preceding, I find my own 
 feelings too much interested in, to treat it with that 
 freedom which it deserves, although perhaps there 
 never was a time in which I could with less hazard of 
 incurring the imputation of seeking to add to my own 
 consequence, impart my own sentiments upon it. I 
 shall therefore be very brief upon it. The subject 
 which I allude to is the definition of the powers of the 
 Governor- general as distinguished from the Board
 
 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 543 
 
 at large. In whatever manner it may be judged ex- 
 pedient to determine this point, it is of the utmost 
 consequence that some clear and precise line be drawn, 
 and applicable to all possible cases, to prevent disputes 
 which will otherwise continually arise upon them. 
 The only danger to which any extraordinary degree of 
 power granted to the Governor can be liable, depends 
 on the choice of the man appointed to so delicate a 
 trust. The choice properly made, your Lordship will 
 find, and the event will justify my assertion, that some 
 kind of separate and independent authority must be 
 delegated to him to enable him to discharge the exe- 
 cutive duties of Government, and to preserve a con- 
 sistency in its measures. The length of time which 
 will be required for appeals to England, before their 
 effects can be received, which will oftener exceed than 
 fall short of two years, may produce so many variations 
 in the state of affairs which existed at the time in which 
 they were made, as to render the application of such 
 remedies as the wisdom of Government may adopt for 
 their safety of no effect, and such is the natural envy 
 attendant on the first office of Government, though 
 but ostensibly superior to the rest, that in a body so 
 small as that of the present Council, a majority will 
 almost always be formed against him, unless, by de- 
 scending to the arts of intrigue, which will be eventu- 
 ally productive of evils not much less pernicious than 
 those of total anarchy, he can find means to maintain 
 an unsteady and uncertain supremacy. 
 
 I forbear, my Lord, to enter into a detail of this sub- 
 ject, or to propose the modifications of it, but beg leave 
 to refer your Lordship (if you shall think what I have 
 already said deserving your further attention) to a 
 letter written by me to the Court of Directors, and 
 dated the llth of November, 1773, in which my senti- 
 ments will appear more at large, a"nd, though applied
 
 544 MEMOIRS OF WARREN HASTINGS. 
 
 to a former constitution of this Government, will be 
 found, if just, equally applicable to the present. I have 
 some reason to believe that the letter which I allude 
 to will have undergone your Lordship's inspection long 
 before this can reach your hands, which induces me 
 rather to refer your Lordship to it, than to take up 
 more of your time by an unnecessary repetition. 
 
 If the general rules which I have recommended 
 should receive the sanction of your Lordship's approval, 
 it is my intention at some future time to submit to 
 your Lordship a practical system formed on these 
 principles for the government of these provinces. In 
 the mean time, I hope your Lordship will judge favour- 
 ably of this imperfect attempt, which I have prema- 
 turely made in pure respect to your Lordship's com- 
 mands. I have the honour to be, with the greatest 
 respect, my Lord, your Lordship's most obedient and 
 most devoted servant. 
 
 END OF THE FIRST VOLUME. 
 
 uted 
 
 London : Printed by W. CLOWES and SONS, Stamford-street
 
 CX < [;<<.<; 
 
 -^,," < <'*<< 
 
 _c.r ' <?,<<, 
 
 C <- c <-- l( ir 
 
 < *c 
 
 :/:'" A v <?< 
 i^C<?<C7<''cc <ef.. 
 [3: cc < < < ^- 
 
 C^v <JC'-' '< *T'? 
 
 ':_ <<c ex <^ti 
 
 c'-'CC^'C <: 
 C cc < <S< 
 
 
 ;, ,.<-.C^<C 
 
 hczzC'" 
 
 < 
 
 o ..< 
 
 ; c"- ; <^ C ; 
 
 ^ -^ *" 
 
 ^c c< ' - c * 
 
 S-- ird-fcc*^ 
 ^^nag 
 
 4: : cfe^ 
 
 -' - % ^ ( 
 
 T< < r ' 
 
 < < 
 . 
 
 c C< 
 
 < c c <it< < 
 -ROC <-< ^or* 1 -' 
 
 < cr ^^ 
 c<:'c?"c<ccc scx _ 
 
 < ( "3K- 
 
 : cr^ft?^ 
 <t3K^ 
 
 i