UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA 
 AT LOS ANGELES

 
 d?-^L* t fU&jJ-, 
 
 1898
 
 
 ; CRIME OF 
 
 SYLVESTRE 
 BONNARD. 
 
 ANATOLE FRANCE 
 
 NEW YORK AND BOSTON 
 THOMAS Y. CROWELL AND 
 COMPANY 
 
 136471
 
 THE CRIME 
 
 OF 
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD 
 
 (.Member of the Institute) 
 BY 
 
 ANATOLE FRANCE 
 
 TRANSLATED INTO ENGLISH 
 BY 
 
 ARABELLA WARD 
 
 NEW YORK: 46 EAST MTH STRBBT 
 
 THOMAS Y. CROWELL & COMPANY 
 
 BOSTON: too PUKCHASB STRBBT
 
 COPYRIGHT, 1897, 
 BY T. Y. CROWELL & Co. 
 
 TYPOGRAPHY BY C. J. PRTKRS & SON, BOSTON. 
 FRBSSWORK BY ROCKWELL k CHURCHILL.
 
 c ^GES \v 
 
 CONTENTS. 
 
 PART I. 
 
 PACK 
 
 THE LOG i 
 
 PART II. 
 THE DAUGHTER OF CLEMENTINE 
 
 THE FAIRY 75 
 
 LITTLE SAINT GEORGE 104 
 
 J
 
 PART I. 
 THE LOG.
 
 THE 
 
 CRIME OF SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 
 
 THE LOG. 
 
 December 24, 1849. 
 
 I PUT on my slippers and my dressing-gown, and 
 brushed away a tear which the north wind, blowing 
 across the quay, had brought into my eyes. A 
 bright fire was burning on the hearth in my study. 
 Ice-crystals, in the form of fern-leaves, frosted the 
 window-panes, hiding from me the Seine, its bridges, 
 and the Louvre des Valois. 
 
 Drawing my arm-chair and writing-table before 
 the fire, I took the place that Hamilcar deigned to 
 leave me. Hamilcar, his nose between his paws, 
 lay curled up on a feather cushion in front of the 
 andirons. His thick, soft fur rose and fell with his. 
 regular breathing. As I approached, he gently 
 opened his dark eyes from between their half- 
 closed lids, but almost instantly shut them again, 
 as if saying to himself, "It is nothing; only my 
 friend." 
 
 " Hamilcar!" I exclaimed, as I stretched out my 
 legs, " Hamilcar, somnolent Prince, mighty Guard- 
 ian of the City of Books! Like the Divine Cat 
 that fought against the ungodly in Heliopolis dur- 
 ing the night of the great combat, thou dost pre-
 
 2 THE CRIME OF 
 
 serve from vile gnawing the books which this old 
 student has purchased at the cost of his scant sav- 
 ings and untiring patience! In this library, pro- 
 tected by thy military genius, sleep, O Hamilcar, as 
 softly as a sultana. For in thy person are united 
 the formidable aspect of a Tartar warrior and the 
 sensuous grace of a woman of the Orient. Sleep, 
 thou brave and voluptuous Hamilcar, until the hour 
 draws nigh when the mice begin their dance in the 
 light of the moon, before the Acta Sanctorum of 
 the learned Bollandists ! " 
 
 The beginning of this apostrophe must have 
 pleased Hamilcar, for he accompanied it with a 
 gurgle in his throat like the sound of a boiling 
 kettle. But as my voice became louder, Hamilcar's 
 ears began to droop, the striped skin of his fore- 
 head grew puckered, and this warned me that it 
 was unbecoming in me thus to harangue. 
 
 " This old bookworm," Hamilcar evidently mused, 
 " makes idle speeches, whereas our housekeeper 
 never utters a word that is not full of good sense 
 and meaning, containing either the announcement 
 of a meal or the promise of a whipping. Any one 
 can understand what she says. But this old man 
 strings together sounds that signify nothing." 
 
 Thus mused Hamilcar. Leaving him to his re- 
 flections, I opened a book in which I became deeply 
 interested. It was a catalogue of manuscripts. I 
 know of no easier, more pleasing, or more fascinat- 
 ing reading than that of a catalogue. The one that 
 I was reading, published in 1824, by Mr. Thompson, 
 librarian to Sir Thomas Raleigh, errs, it is true, by
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 3 
 
 an excess of brevity, and fails to show that accuracy 
 which the archaeologists of my generation were the 
 first to introduce into works of diplomatics and pale- 
 ography. It leaves much to be desired and conjec- 
 tured. This is perhaps why, in reading it, I feel a 
 sensation which in a more imaginative nature than 
 mine might be called revery. 
 
 I had given myself up to the gentle train of my 
 thoughts, when my housejceeper, in a sullen tone, 
 announced that Monsieur Coccoz wished to speak 
 with me. 
 
 In fact, some one had already slipped behind her 
 into the library. It was a poor, puny, insignificant 
 little fellow in a thin jacket. He approached me 
 with a series of little bows and smiles. But he 
 was very pale, and although still young and active, 
 he seemed ill. As I looked at him, I thought of 
 a wounded squirrel. Under his arm he carried a 
 green case, which he placed on a chair. Then, un- 
 tying the four corners, he uncovered a pile of small 
 yellow books. 
 
 " Monsieur," said he, " I have not the honor of 
 being known to you. I am a book-agent, monsieur. 
 I represent the leading houses of the capital, and in 
 the hope that you will be good enough to honor me 
 with your patronage, I take the liberty of offering 
 you a few novelties." 
 
 Ye kind and just gods ! Such novelties as the 
 little Coccoz fellow showed me! The first volume 
 he handed me was rtlistoire de la Tour de Nesle, 
 with the love affairs of Margudrite of Bourgogne 
 and Captain Buridan.
 
 4 THE CRIME OF 
 
 " This," said he, smiling, " is a book that deals 
 with true history." 
 
 " In that case," I replied, " it must be very tire- 
 some, for a history which keeps strictly to the truth 
 is extremely dull. I have written some such myself ; 
 and if ever you should be unfortunate enough to 
 offer one of them from door to door, you would run 
 the risk of keeping it all your life in your green 
 case, without ever finding a maid-servant sufficiently 
 ill-advised to buy it of you." 
 
 " Certainly, monsieur," replied the little fellow 
 out of pure good nature. And, still smiling, he 
 showed me the Amours d'Htloise et d^Abeilard; 
 but I made him understand that, at my age, I had 
 no use for a love-story. Still smiling, he suggested 
 the Regie des jeux desociett : piquet, be"sique, dcartd, 
 whist, dice, checkers, chess. 
 
 " Alas ! " said I, " if you would have me remem- 
 ber the rules of bdsique, give me back my old friend 
 Bignan, with whom I used to play cards every even- 
 ing until the five Academies bore him solemnly to 
 his grave ; or bring down to the frivolous level of 
 human amusements the grave intelligence of Ham- 
 ilcar, whom you see sleeping on that cushion, and 
 who at the present time is the sole companion of 
 my evenings." 
 
 The little fellow's smile became vague and fright- 
 ened. 
 
 "This," said he, "is a new collection of society 
 diversions, jokes and puns, with directions for chan- 
 ging a red rose to a white." 
 
 I told him that for a long time I had been put
 
 BONNARD. 5 
 
 out with white roses, and that as to the jokes, I was 
 satisfied with those which I unconsciously allowed 
 myself to make in the course of my scientific work. 
 
 The little fellow offered me his last book with his 
 last smile, saying, 
 
 " Here is the Cle_d&s Songes, with explanations 
 of ever)' possible dream, the dream of gold, tlu 
 dream of robbers, the dream of death, the dream of 
 one's falling from the top of a towei^-^the list is 
 complete ! " 
 
 I had seized the tongs, and brandishing them in 
 the air, I replied to my commercial visitor, 
 
 " Yes, my friend ; but these dreams, as well as a 
 thousand others, both joyous and tragic, are summed 
 up in a single one, the Dream of Life. Does your 
 little yellow book give me~The key to this ?" 
 
 " Yes, monsieur," replied the little man ; " the 
 book is complete ; and it is not dear, only one franc, 
 twenty-five centimes, monsieur." 
 
 I called my housekeeper, for my lodgings are 
 without a bell. 
 
 " The'rese," said I, " Monsieur Coccoz, whom I 
 beg you to escort to the door, has a book which may 
 be of interest to you. It is the ' Key to Dreams. 1 I 
 shall be glad to buy it for you." 
 
 My housekeeper replied, 
 
 " Monsieur, if one has not the time to dream when 
 awake, one has not the time to dream when asleep. 
 Thank God ! the days are enough for my work, and 
 my work for the days ; and I can say every evening, 
 4 O Lord, bless the rest I am about to have ! ' I 
 dream neither awake nor asleep; and I do not mis-
 
 6 THE CRIME OF 
 
 take my eider-down coverlet for a ghost either, as 
 my cousin did. Moreover, if I may be allowed to 
 give my opinion, we already have books enough 
 here. Monsieur has thousands and thousands of 
 them, which turn his head ; and I have two, which 
 are all I need, my Catholic Prayer-book and my 
 Cuisiniere Bourgeoises 
 
 With these words, my housekeeper helped the lit- 
 tle man to p*t his goods back again into his green 
 case. 
 
 Coccoz no longer smiled. His relaxed features 
 wore such an expression of suffering that I was 
 filled with remorse at having poked fun at so un- 
 happy a creature. I called him back, and told him 
 that I had caught a glimpse of a copy of rHistoire 
 d' ' Estelle et de Nemorin, which he had ; that I was 
 very fond of shepherds and shepherdesses, and that 
 for a reasonable sum I should be glad to buy the 
 story of these two perfect lovers. 
 
 " I will let you have this book for one franc, 
 twenty-five centimes, monsieur," answered Coccoz, 
 whose face now beamed with delight. " It is his- 
 torical, and I am sure you will be pleased with it. 
 I see now what you want. You are a connaisseur. 
 To-morrow I will bring you the Crimes des Papes. 
 It is a good book. I will bring you the Edition-de- 
 luxe with the colored plates." 
 
 I begged him to do nothing of the sort, and sent 
 him away happy. When the peddler and his green 
 case had vanished in the shadow of the hall, I asked 
 my housekeeper from where the little man had 
 dropped in upon us.
 
 SYLVESTRE BONJtfARD. 7 
 
 " Dropped is the very word," said she. " He 
 dropped from the roof, monsieur, where he lives 
 with his wife." 
 
 " He has a wife you say, The'rese? That is mar 
 vellous ! Women certainly are strange creatures. 
 This one must be a very unfortunate little woman." 
 
 " I really do not know what she is," replied The'- 
 rese; "but every morning I see her trailing down 
 the stairs in a silk gown that is covered with grease- 
 spots. She makes eyes at people too. Now, how 
 in all justice can such eyes and such dresses belong 
 to a woman who is received out of charity? For, 
 in consideration of the fact that the man is ill and 
 the wife in a delicate condition, they have been 
 allowed to occupy the attic while the roof is under- 
 going repairs. The janitress said that the woman's 
 confinement began this very morning. They must 
 have had great need of a child!" 
 
 "The'rese," I replied, "they certainly had no need 
 of one. But Nature willed that they should have/ 
 one, and they fell into her trap. Unusual precau-// \ 
 tion is necessary in order to foil the tricks of Na- \ 
 tare. Let us pity rather than blame them! As to 
 the silk dresses, there is not a young woman in the / 
 whole world who does not love them. The daugh- / 
 ters of Eve adore finery. You yourself. The'rese,/ 
 who are serious and sensible, how you do scold if 
 you have no white apron in which to wait at table ! 
 But tell me, have they all that they need in their 
 attic?" 
 
 "How could that be possible, monsieur?" an- 
 swered the housekeeper. "The husband, whom you
 
 8 THE. CRIME OF 
 
 have just seen, used to peddle jewels, so the jani- 
 tress tells me, and no one knows why he gave up 
 selling watches. You see he peddles almanacs now. 
 This, in my opinion,, is not an honest profession ; 
 and I can never believe that God will bless any one 
 who follows it. The woman, between you and me, 
 seems unfitted for anything, a lazy good-for-nothing. 
 I consider her as capable of bringing up a child as 
 I should be of playing the guitar. No one knows 
 from where they come, but I feel sure that they 
 must have come by the coach of Poverty from the 
 Land of Don't-Care." 
 
 " Wherever they have come from, The"rese, they 
 are wretched, and their attic is cold." 
 
 " Mercy ! I should think it was ! The roof has 
 cracks in several places, and the rain pours in by 
 the gutterful. They have neither furniture nor cloth- 
 ing. Cabinet-makers and weavers seldom work, I 
 think, for Christians of such a brotherhood." 
 
 "It is very sad, The'rese, that a Christian woman 
 should be less well cared for than this pa^an of an 
 Hamilcar. What does the woman herself say?" 
 
 " Monsieur, I never speak to people of that class. 
 I have no idea what she says or what she sings. 
 But she sings the whole day long. I hear her from 
 the stairs whenever I go in and out." 
 
 " Well ! the heir of this Coccoz family can say, 
 like the egg in the village riddle, ' My mother 
 brought me into the world while singing.' A simi- 
 lar thing happened in the case of Henry IV. When 
 Jeanne d'Albret was about to be confined, she began 
 to sing an old Bdarnaise canticle :
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 9 
 
 ' Our Lady from the end of the bridge, 
 May this hour bring me joy ! 
 Raise now thy prayer, 
 That God may hear, 
 And send to me a 6oy.'-' 1 
 
 It is unreasonable, on the face of it, to bring poor 
 little wretches into the world. But it happens every 
 day, my poor The'rese, and all the philosophers in 
 _the_wprld cannot reform the foolish custom. Ma- 
 dame Coccoz has followed it, and sings. That is 
 good, at least ! But tell me, The'rese, have you not 
 set the pot to boil to-day?" 
 
 " Yes, monsieur, and it is about time for me to go 
 and skim it." 
 
 " Very good ! but do not fail, The'rese, to carry a 
 good bowl of soup to Madame Coccoz, our neighbor 
 up-stairs." 
 
 My housekeeper was about to leave the room, 
 when I added, 
 
 "The'rese, first of all, be good enough to call your 
 friend thp porter, and tell him to look about our 
 woodhouse for an armful of wood for this Coccoz 
 family. Above all, see that he does not fail to put 
 in the pile a big log, a regular yule log. As to the 
 little man, I beg you, in case he returns, to show 
 him politely to the door, him and all his yellow 
 books." 
 
 Having taken these measures, with the selfishness 
 
 1 Notre-Dame du bout du font, 
 I'enez it man aide en cettt htttre I 
 I'riez It Dim du del, 
 QtSU mt tUlivre vitt, 
 Qu'U mt dottnt UH gar (on I
 
 IO THE CRIME OF 
 
 of a confirmed bachelor, I turned again to my cata- 
 logue. 
 
 With what surprise, pleasure, and pain, I came 
 upon the following words, which even now I cannot 
 copy with a firm hand : 
 
 "THE GOLDEN LEGEND" BY JACQUES DE GENES 
 (JACQUES DE VORAGINE). 
 
 Translated into French. Small quarto. 
 
 This manuscript of the fourteenth century contains, 
 besides the more or less complete translation of the cele- 
 brated works of Jacques de Voragine, i. The Legends 
 of Saints Ferreol, Ferrution, Germain, Vincent, and 
 Droctoveus ; 2. A poem on " The Miraculous Burial of 
 Monsieur Saint-Germain of Auxerre." The translation, 
 the legends and the poem, are due to the clerk Alex- 
 ander. The manuscript is on vellum. It contains a 
 large number of illuminated initials, and two beautifully 
 painted miniatures in a poor state of preservation. One 
 represents the Purification of the Virgin, the other the 
 Crowning of Proserpine. 
 
 What a discovery ! The perspiration came out 
 on my forehead, a mist swam before my eyes. I 
 trembled, I flushed, feeling that I must shout, yet 
 unable to utter a word. 
 
 What a treasure! For forty years I had been 
 studying the history of Christian Gaul, especially 
 the wonderful Abbey of Saint-Germain-des-Prds, 
 whence came the king-monks who founded our 
 national dynasty. But in spite of the culpable in- 
 sufficiency of the description, it was evident to me
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. II 
 
 that the manuscript of the clerk Alexander must 
 have come from the great abbey. Everything 
 proved it. All the legends added by the translator 
 related to the pious founding of the abbey by King 
 Childebert. The legend of Saint Droctoveus was 
 especially significant, for it was that of the first 
 abbot of my dear abbey. The poem in French 
 verse on the burial of Saint-Germain took me into 
 the very nave of the venerable basilica, which was 
 the centre of Christian Gaul. 
 
 " The Golden Legend " is in itself a vast and 
 graceful work. Jacques de Voragine, Assistant of 
 the Order of Saint Dominic and Archbishop of 
 Genoa, collected in the thirteenth century all the 
 legends of Catholic saints, and made a volume of 
 such richness, that from the monasteries and cha- 
 teaux there came the cry, "It is the Golden Le- 
 gend ! " " The Golden Legend " was particularly 
 rich in Roman hagiography. Edited by an Italian 
 monk, it was especially good in its treatment of the 
 earthly domains of Saint Peter. Voragine sees the 
 greatest saints of the Occident only through a cold 
 mist. Therefore the Aquitanian and Saxon trans- 
 lators of this good legendary were careful to add to 
 his account the lives of their own national saints. 
 
 I have read and collated many manuscripts of 
 The Golden Legend." I know those described 
 by my learned colleague, Monsieur Paulin Paris, 
 in his beautiful catalogue of the manuscripts of 
 the Royal Library. Of these, two in particular 
 held my attention. One is of the fourteenth cen- 
 tury, and contains a translation of Jean Belet ; the
 
 12 THE CRIME OF 
 
 other, younger by a century, includes the version 
 of Jacques Vignay. Both came from the Colbert 
 collection, and were placed on the shelves of that 
 glorious Colbertine library through the energy of 
 the librarian Baluze, whose name I never utter 
 without baring my head ; for even in the cen- 
 tury of the giants of learning, Baluze astonishes 
 every one by his greatness. I know a very curi- 
 ous codex of the Bigot collection. I know seventy- 
 four printed editions, beginning with the venerable 
 ancestor of all, the Gothic of Strasbourg, com- 
 menced in 1471, and finished in 1475. 
 
 But not one of these manuscripts, not one of 
 these editions, contains the legends of Saints Fer- 
 re'ol, Ferrution, Germain, Vincent, and Droctoveus, 
 not one bears the name of the clerk Alexander, not 
 one, in short, comes from the Abbey of Saint-Ger- 
 main-des-Prds. Compared with the manuscript de- 
 scribed by Mr. Thompson, they are as straw to gold. 
 I have seen with my own eyes, I have touched with 
 my own fingers, an indisputable proof of the exis- 
 tence of this document. But the document itself? 
 \ What has become of it ? Sir Thomas Raleigh 
 spent his last days on the shores of Lake Como, 
 whither he carried a part of his vast treasures. 
 What became of them, then, after the death of 
 that elegant collector of curios? Where could the 
 manuscripts of the clerk Alexander have gone? 
 
 "And why," I ask myself, "why have I learned 
 of the existence of this precious volume, if I am 
 never to possess it, never even to see it? If I knew 
 that it were there, I would seek it in the burning
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 13 
 
 heart of Africa or among the ice regions of the 
 Pole. But I do not know where it is. I know not 
 if it is guarded by some jealous bibliomaniac in an 
 iron safe, beneath a triple lock, or if it lies moulder- 
 ing in the garret of some ignorant person. I shudder 
 when I think that perhaps its pages have been torn 
 out to cover the gherkin-jars of some housekeeper." 
 
 August 30, 1850. 
 
 The heat was so oppressive that I was obliged 
 to walk slowly. I strolled along, close to the walls 
 of the northern quay; and in the sultry twilight 
 the shops of dealers in old books, prints, and an- 
 tique furniture attracted my eyes and my fancy. 
 Rummaging among them as I idled along, I en* 
 joyed a finely turned verse by a poet of the Pleiad, 
 I looked through an elegant " Masquerade " by Wat- 
 teau, I weighed with my eye a two-handled sword, 
 a steel gorget, a marion. What a thick helmet! 
 What a heavy breastplate, Lord ! The covering of 
 a giant ? No ; the carapace of an insect. The men 
 of those days were armed like beetles, their weak- 
 ness was within. Now, on the contrary, our strength 
 is within. Our armed souls dwell in weak bodies. 
 
 Here is a pastel of a lady of the olden time. The 
 face, faint as a shadow, is smiling. One hand, cov- 
 ered with an open-worked mitt, holds upon her satin 
 gown a lap-dog with a ribbon about his neck. The 
 picture fills me with a sweet melancholy. Let those 
 who have in their hearts no half-obliterated pastel 
 make fun of me !
 
 14 THE CRIME OF 
 
 Like the horse that scents the stable, I hasten my 
 steps as I near my lodgings. Here it is, the human 
 hive where I have my cell, in which I distil the 
 somewhat bitter honey of learning. With a heavy 
 step I mount the stairs. A few feet more and I 
 shall be at my door. But I imagine rather than 
 see a gown descending, with the sound of rustling 
 silk. I pause,- and draw back against the railing. 
 The woman who passes is bareheaded, she is young, 
 she is singing. Her eyes and her teeth gleam in the 
 shadow, for she has laughing eyes and a laughing 
 mouth. She is certainly a neighbor, and one who 
 knows us well. In her arms she holds a pretty 
 child, a little boy, quite naked, like the son of a 
 goddess. About his neck is a medal attached to 
 a little silver chain. I watch him as he sucks his 
 thumbs, staring at me with his great eyes, and gaz- 
 ing upon this old world, as yet so new to him. At 
 the same time the mother looks at me in a sly, mys- 
 terious way. Then she stops, blushes slightly, I 
 think, and holds out the little creature to me. The 
 baby has a pretty dimple between his wrist and his 
 arm, another in his neck, and everywhere, from his 
 head to his feet, others laugh in his rosy flesh. 
 
 The mother shows him to me with pride. 
 
 " Monsieur," she says, " my little boy is very 
 pretty ; don't you think so ? " 
 
 She takes his hand, places it on his lips, and 
 holds out his dear little rosy fingers towards me. 
 
 " Baby, throw a kiss to the gentleman," she says. 
 
 Then, folding the little creature in her arms, she 
 glides away with the swiftness of a cat, and dis-
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 15 
 
 appears down a hallway, which, judging from its 
 odor, leads to a kitchen. 
 
 I enter my own rooms. 
 
 " The'rese, who is the young mother whom I saw 
 bareheaded on the stairs with her pretty little boy ? " 
 
 The'rese replies that it is Madame Coccoz. I 
 stare at the ceiling, as if to find there some further 
 explanation. The'rese recalls to my mind the poor 
 peddler who a year ago came to sell me almanacs 
 while his wife was ill. / 
 
 " And what of Coccoz ? " I asked. 
 
 The reply was that I would never see him again. 
 The poor fellow had been laid away under ground 
 without my knowledge, and, indeed, without the 
 knowledge of many, a short time after the recovery 
 of Madame Coccoz. I learned that his wife had 
 become consoled. I followed her example. 
 
 "But, The'rese," I asked, "has Madame Coccoz 
 all she needs in her attic ? " 
 
 " You will be very stupid, monsieur," replied my 
 housekeeper, " if you give a thought to that woman. 
 They notified her to leave the attic when the roof 
 was repaired. But she is still there, in spite of the 
 proprietor, the agent, the janitress, and the bailiff. 
 I believe she has bewitched them all. She will 
 leave the attic, monsieur, when she pleases, but 
 she will leave it in her own carriage! Mark my 
 words ! " 
 
 The'rese reflected a moment, then she made this 
 remark, 
 
 " A pretty face is a curse from Heaven ! " 
 
 " I should thank Heaven, then, for having spared
 
 1 6 THE CRIME OF 
 
 me that curse. But take my hat and cane. I am 
 going to read a few pages of More'ri for recreation. 
 If my old fox scent tells me true, we are going to 
 have a delicately flavored pullet for dinner. Attend 
 to this estimable fowl, my good woman, and spare 
 your neighbors, so that they may spare you and 
 your old master." 
 
 So saying, I set about to study the gnarled 
 branches of a princely genealogy. 
 
 May 7, 1851. 
 
 I have spent the winter in a manner most pleas- 
 ing to sages, in angello cum libello ; and now the 
 swallows of the quay Malaquais find me, on their 
 return, almost as when they left me. He who lives 
 little, changes little, and using up one's days poring 
 over ancient texts is scarcely living at all. 
 
 And yet to-day I feel myself a little more than 
 ever imbued with that vague sadness that life gives 
 out. My intellectual harmony (I scarcely dare ac- 
 knowledge it to myself) has been troubled ever 
 since that momentous hour when the existence of 
 the clerk Alexander's manuscript was revealed to 
 me. It seems strange that for a few pages of old 
 parchment I should have lost sleep, but such is the 
 truth. The poor man without desires possesses the. 
 greatest of all treasures, he is master of himself. 
 The rich man who has a desire is but a wretched 
 slave. I am that slave. The sweetest pleasures, 
 that of conversing with a man of an acute, bright 
 mind, or dining with a friend, cannot make me for-
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. \J 
 
 get the manuscript which I have wanted ever since 
 1 knew of its existence. I want it by day and by 
 night. 1 want it in joy and in sorrow. I want it 
 when I work, and I want it when I rest. 
 
 I recall to mind the desires of my childhood. 
 How clearly I understand to-day all the intense 
 wishes of those early years ! I can still see with 
 wonderful vividness a doll, which, when I was eight 
 years old, was displayed in the window of a wretched 
 little shop in the rue de Seine. Why that doll 
 pleased me I have no idea. I was very proud of 
 being a boy. I despised little girls, and I looked 
 forward with impatience to the time (alas, it has 
 come !) when a prickly white beard would bristle on 
 my chin. I played soldier, and in order to obtain 
 food for my hobby-horse I made ravages among the 
 plants that my long-suffering mother tried to culti- 
 vate on the window-ledge. That was certainly a 
 manly amusement. And yet I longed for a doll ! 
 
 A Hercules has his weakness. Was the object 
 of my love beautiful? No. I can see her now. 
 She had a dab of vermilion on either cheek, short, 
 flabby arms, horrible wooden hands, and long, 
 shapeless legs. Her flowered skirt was fastened 
 at the waist by two pins. I can still see the 
 black heads of those two pins. She was a low-class 
 doll, smelling of the faubourg. I well remember, 
 little boy that I was and not yet in trousers, that 
 I felt in my own way and very strongly, that this 
 doll lacked grace and style. She was coarse and 
 vulgar. Nevertheless, I loved her, in spite of her 
 faults. I loved her for them. I loved her alone,
 
 18 THE CRIME OF 
 
 and I wanted her. My soldiers and my drums 
 were no longer of any account. I had stopped 
 putting into my hobby-horse's mouth stems of he- 
 liotrope and speedwell. That doll was everything 
 to me. I planned schemes worthy of a savage, 
 in order that my nurse Virginie might be obliged 
 to take me by the little shop in the rue de Seine. 
 I would flatten my nose against the window until 
 my nurse had to take hold of my arm and drag 
 me away. " Monsieur Sylvestre, it is late, and your 
 mamma will scold you." Monsieur Sylvestre cared 
 nothing in those days for the threatened scoldings 
 and whippings. But his nurse raised him in her 
 arms as if he were a feather, and Monsieur Sylvestre 
 yielded to force. In after years, as he grew older, 
 he became degenerate, and now yields to fear. But 
 then he was afraid of nothing. 
 
 I was wretched. An inconsiderate but irresistible 
 shame kept me from telling my mother of the object 
 of my love. Hence my sufferings. For days that 
 doll, constantly in my mind, danced before my eyes, 
 and gazed fixedly at me, and opened her arms to 
 me, assuming, in my imagination, a sort of life that 
 made her seem strange and terrible to me, and much 
 dearer and more to be coveted. 
 
 Finally, one day, a day I shall never forget, my 
 nurse took me to see my uncle, Captain Victor, who 
 had asked me to breakfast. I felt a deep admira- 
 tion for my uncle, the Captain, as much from the 
 fact of his having fired the last French cartridge at 
 Waterloo, as because with his own hands, at my 
 mother's table, he used to make crotitons rubbed
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 19 
 
 in garlic, which he then put into the chicory salad. 
 I thought that was very fine. 
 
 My uncle Victor also filled me with great respect 
 on account of his frogged coats, and especially on 
 account of the way he had of turning the house 
 topsy-turvy the moment he entered it. Even to-day 
 I do not understand how he did it; but whenever 
 my uncle Victor was in a company of twenty per- 
 sons, he was the only one seen and heard. My good 
 father, I believe, did not share my great admiration 
 for my uncle Victor, who troubled him by his smok- 
 ing, gave him friendly although hearty slaps on his 
 back, and accused him of lack of energy. My 
 mother, while she felt for the Captain all a sister's 
 indulgence, sometimes asked him to pay less atten- 
 tion to the brandy bottle. But I had no part in 
 these feelings of dislike, or in the reproaches that 
 were heaped upon him. My uncle Victor inspired 
 me with the greatest enthusiasm. 
 
 Therefore I entered his small lodgings in the rue 
 Gue'ne'gaud with a feeling of pride. The entire 
 breakfast, served oh a round table in a corner of 
 the fireplace, consisted of pork and sweets. The 
 Captain filled me with cake and pure wine. He told 
 me of countless acts of injustice of which he had 
 been the victim. He complained especially of the 
 Bourbons ; and as he neglected to tell me who the 
 Bourbons were, I somehow imagined that they were 
 horse-dealers at Waterloo. The Captain, who inter- 
 rupted himself only to fill our glasses, furthermore 
 accused a number of young men, jean/esses and 
 good-for-nothings, whom I did not know at all, but
 
 20 THE CRIME OF 
 
 whom I hated with my whole heart. At dessert I 
 thought that I heard the Captain say that my 
 father was a man whom one could twist round 
 one's little finger, but I am not sure that I under- 
 stood him. My ears were ringing, and it seemed 
 to me that the table was dancing. My uncle put 
 on his frogged coat, took his hat, and we went 
 out into the street, which seemed to me to have 
 undergone a wonderful transformation. 
 
 I felt as if a long time had elapsed since I had 
 been there. But when we came to the rue de 
 Seine, the thought of my doll came back to my 
 mind, and threw me into a wonderful state of exal- 
 tation. My head was on fire. I resolved to try a 
 bold stroke. We were passing in front of the 
 shop. There she was behind the glass, with her 
 red cheeks, her flowered skirt, and her shapeless 
 legs. 
 
 " Uncle," said I with an effort, " will you buy me 
 that doll ? " 
 
 Then I waited. 
 
 " Buy a doll for a boy ! Damnation ! " cried my 
 uncle in a voice of thunder. " Do you want to dis- 
 grace yourself? So, it is that Margot that you want, 
 is it ? I congratulate you, my little fellow. If you 
 grow up with such tastes you will never have any 
 fun at all in .life, and your friends will call you a 
 precious ninny. If you asked me for a sword or a 
 gun, I would buy it for you, my boy, with the last 
 silver crown of my pension. But buy you a doll ! 
 A thousand devils ! To disgrace you ! Never in the 
 world ! If ever I catch you playing with such a
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNAR&. 21 
 
 decked-out piece of finery as that, I tell you what, 
 monsieur, son of my sister as you are, I'll never again 
 own you for my nephew." 
 
 At these words my heart swelled so, that pride 
 alone, a diabolic pride, kept me from crying. 
 
 My uncle, suddenly growing calm, returned to his 
 ideas about the Bourbons. But I, still under the 
 lash of his indignation, felt an unspeakable shame. 
 My resolve was soon made. I inwardly swore that 
 I would never disgrace myself. I firmly and for- 
 ever gave up the red-cheeked doll. That day I felt 
 for the first time the cruel sweetness of sacrifice. 
 
 Captain, although it is true that in your life you 
 swore like a heathen, smoked like a beadle, and 
 drank like a bell-ringer, nevertheless may your mem- 
 ory be honored, not merely because you were a 
 brave soldier, but also because you showed your 
 nephew, while he still wore short skirts, the senti- 
 ment of heroism ! Pride and laziness made you 
 almost unbearable, O uncle Victor ! but a great 
 heart beat beneath the frogs of your coat. 
 
 I remember you always wore a rose in your button- 
 hole. That flower which, as I now believe, you 
 let the shop-girls pluck for you, that open-hearted 
 flower which shed its petals on every breeze, was 
 the symbol of your glorious youth. You scorned 
 neither absinthe nor tobacco, but you despised life. 
 Neither common-sense nor refinement could be ac- 
 quired from you, Captain ; but you taught me, at an 
 age when my nurse still looked after me, a lesson 
 of honor and self-sacrifice which I shall never forget. 
 You have been sleeping now a long time in the
 
 22 THE CRIME OF 
 
 cemetery of Mont-Parnasse, beneath a humble slab 
 which bears this epitaph : 
 
 HERE LIES 
 
 ARISTIDE-VICTOR MALDENT. 
 
 CAPTAIN OF INFANTRY. 
 CHEVALIER OF THE LEGION OF HONOR. 
 
 But, Captain, the inscription which you intended 
 for your old bones, so long knocked about on bat- 
 tlefields and in haunts of pleasure, is not there. 
 Among your papers we found this proud and bitter 
 epitaph, which, in spite of your last wish, we dared 
 not place on your tomb : 
 
 HERE LIES 
 A BRIGAND OF THE LOIRE. 
 
 " Thdrese, to-morrow let us place a wreath of 
 immortelles on the tomb of the Brigand of the 
 Loire." 
 
 But Thdrese is not here. And how could she be 
 near me on the "greeting " of the Champs-Elyse'es? 
 Beyond, at the end of the avenue, the Arc de Tri- 
 ornphe lifts its huge portal against the sky, bearing 
 beneath its vault the names of my uncle Victor's 
 comrades-in-arms. Under the spring sunshine the 
 trees along the avenue are unfolding their first 
 leaves, still pale and tender. At my side the open 
 carriages roll along to the Bois de Boulogne. 
 
 Unconsciously 1 have wandered into this fashion- 
 able avenue, and stop mechanically before an open 
 booth filled with gingerbread and jars of liquorice-
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 23 
 
 water, with lemons for stoppers. A poor little ur- 
 chin, clad in rags through which his chapped skin 
 can be seen, stands with wide-opened eyes before the 
 luxuries which are not for him. He shows his long- 
 ing with the shamelessness of innocence. His round 
 eyes stare fixedly at a tall man made out of ginger- 
 bread. He is a general, and bears some resemblance 
 to my uncle Victor. I take him, pay for him, and 
 hold him out to the little fellow, who scarcely dares 
 to raise his hand, for from early experience he does 
 not believe in good luck. He gazes at me with a 
 look such as we see in the eyes of a big dog, and which 
 seems to say, " You are cruel to make fun of me." 
 
 " Come, little simpleton," I say to him in the 
 gruff tone which is hajaitual with me, "take it, take 
 it, and eat it, for you are more fortunate than I was 
 at your age, and can satisfy your wishes without 
 disgracing yourself." . . . 
 
 And you, uncle Victor, now that this gingerbread 
 general brings back to my mind your manly figure, 
 come, glorious Shade that you are, and make me 
 forget my new doll. We are forever children, 
 always running after new toys. 
 
 Tlu tame day. 
 
 In the strangest possible way the Coccoz family 
 has become associated in my mind with the clerk 
 Alexander. 
 
 "The'rese," said I, as I threw myself into my 
 easy-chair, "tell me if the little Coccoz is well, and 
 if he has cut his first teeth yet, and give me my 
 slippers."
 
 24 THE CRIME OF 
 
 " He ought to have them, monsieur," replied 
 The'rese ; " but I have not seen them. The first fine 
 day of spring the mother disappeared with the child, 
 leaving behind her furniture and clothes. Thirty- 
 eight empty pomatum jars were found in the attic. 
 It is beyond belief. Latterly she began to receive 
 visitors, and you may be sure she has not entered 
 a convent. The janitress's niece said that she saw 
 her in an open carriage on the boulevards. I was 
 right when I told you that she would come to a bad 
 end." 
 
 " The'rese," I replied, " this young woman has 
 come neither to a bad nor a good end. Wait until 
 her life is over before you judge her. And be care- 
 ful not to gossip too much with the janitress. Ma- 
 dame Coccoz, of whom I caught a glimpse once on 
 the stairs, seemed to me to be very fond of her child. 
 This love should count for much in her favor." 
 
 " Oh, as to that, monsieur, the child lacked noth- 
 ing. There could not be found another in the whole 
 quarter that was better kept, better nourished, or 
 more petted. Every day she put a white bib on 
 him, and from morning till night she sang him songs 
 that made him laugh." 
 
 " The'rese, a poet has said, The child on whom 
 his mother has not smiled, is worthy neither of the 
 table of the gods nor of the couch of the god- 
 desses.' " 
 
 July 8, 1852. 
 
 Having heard that they were relaying the pave- 
 ment in the Chapel of the Virgin at Saint-Germain-
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNAKD. 25 
 
 des-Pre's, I went to the church in hopes of finding 
 some inscriptions brought to light by the workmen. 
 My hopes were not deceived. The architect kindly 
 showed me a stone which he had just raised against 
 the wall. I knelt down in order that I might see 
 the words cut on the stone ; and in a low tone, in the 
 shadow of the ancient apse, I read these words, 
 which made my heart leap : 
 
 HERE LIES ALEXANDER, 
 
 MONK OF THIS CHURCH, 
 
 WHO HAD THE CHIN OF SAINT VINCENT .AND 
 SAINT AMANT AND THE FOOT OF THE 
 
 INNOCENTS ENCLOSED IN SILVER. 
 
 IN HIS LIFETIME HE WAS EVER GOOD AND WORTHY. 
 PRAY FOR HIS SOUL.l 
 
 With my handkerchief I gently brushed away 
 the dust which covered that mortuary stone. I could 
 have kissed it. 
 
 " It is he ! It is Alexander ! " I cried ; and from 
 the vault of the church the name fell back upon me 
 with a noise as if broken. 
 
 The grave, solemn face of the beadle, whom I saw 
 coming towards me, made me ashamed of my enthu- 
 siasm : and I slipped away in spite of the two rival 
 church mice that would have made the sign of the 
 cross on me with holy water. 
 
 ' Cy-gist Alejcandre, moyne de cette fglise, q*i fitt mettrt en 
 argent It nunton de saint Vincent et de saint A mant, et le fif dtl 
 Innocent ; qui toujottrs en son vivant fnt preud 'hantme et vayllant. 
 Frit* four fame de //
 
 26 THE CRIME OF 
 
 However, it was certainly my Alexander ! There 
 was no longer any doubt of it. The translator of 
 " The Golden Legend," the author of the lives of 
 Saint Germain, Saint Vincent, Saint Ferrdol, Saint 
 Ferrution, and Saint Droctoveus was, as I had sup- 
 posed, a monk of Saint-Germain-des-Pre's. And 
 what a good, pious, and generous monk too ! He 
 had a silver chin made, a silver head, and a silver 
 foot, in order that precious remains might be cov- 
 ered with an imperishable envelope. But am I 
 never to know his work, or is the new discovery 
 merely to augment my longing? 
 
 August 20, 1859. 
 
 " /, who please some and who try all men, the joy 
 of the good and the terror of the wicked, /, who make 
 and unfold error, I take it upon myself to stretch 
 my wings. Do not take offence if in my rapid flight 
 I slide over years" 
 
 Who speaks thus ? It is an old man whom I know 
 only too well. It is Time. 
 
 Shakespeare, after having finished the third act 
 of the " Winter's Tale," pauses, in order to give 
 Perdita time to grow in wisdom and in beauty; and 
 when he raises the curtain once more he evokes 
 the ancient scythe-bearer to give an account to the 
 spectators of the long days that have weighed down 
 upon the head of the jealous Leontes. 
 
 Like Shakespeare in his comedy, I have left in 
 this diary a long interval which I have passed over 
 in silence ; and, in the manner of the poet, I will 
 summon Time to explain the silence of ten years.
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 27 
 
 For ten years I have written not one line in this 
 journal ; and now that I take up my pen again, 1 
 have no Perdita, alas ! to describe as having "grown 
 in grace." Youth and beauty are the faithful com- 
 panions of the poets. But the charming phantoms 
 visit the rest of us not even for the space of a season. 
 We know not how to keep them. If, by some curious 
 caprice, the shade of some Perdita should plan to 
 enter my brain, she would be horribly bruised there 
 against the piles of dried parchment. Happy poets ! 
 whose white locks do not frighten away the waver- 
 ing shades of Helens, Francescas, Juliets, Julias, 
 and Dorotheas ! And Sylvestre Bonnard's nose 
 alone would put to flight the entire swarm of Love's 
 famous heroines ! 
 
 Yet I, like many another, have known beauty; I 
 have felt the mysterious charm which Nature, in- 
 comprehensible in itself, has given to animate forms. 
 A living clay has made me tremble like the lover 
 and the poet. But I have known neither how to 
 love nor how to sing. Within my heart, hidden 
 beneath a pile of ancient texts and old inscriptions, I 
 can see again, like a miniature in an attic, a bright 
 face with two violet eyes. 
 
 " Bonnard, my friend, you are an old imbecile ! 
 Read this catalogue, which was sent you this very 
 morning by a Florentine bookseller. It is a cata- 
 logue of manuscripts, and promises a description of 
 several noted ones, preserved by collectors in Italy 
 and Sicily. This is what is suited to you ; this is 
 what is in keeping with your appearance." 
 
 I read ; suddenly I give a cry. Hamilcar, who,
 
 28 THE C Iff ME OF 
 
 with age, has assumed a seriousness that frightens 
 me, looks at me reproachfully, as if to ask if there 
 is such a thing as peace in this world, since he can- 
 not have it near me, who am old like himself. 
 
 In the joy of my discovery I need a confidant, 
 and I turn to the sceptic Hamilcar with the impul- 
 siveness of a happy man. 
 
 " No, Hamilcar, no," I say ; " rest does not belong 
 to this world, and the calm for which you long is 
 incompatible with the work of life. But who says 
 that we are old ? Listen to what I read from this 
 catalogue, and then tell me if this is a time to rest : 
 
 " THE GOLDEN LEGEND " OF JACQUES DE VORAGINE. 
 
 Translated into French in the fourteenth century by the 
 clerk Alexander. 
 
 A superb manuscript, ornamented with two miniatures 
 marvellously painted, and in a perfect state of preserva- 
 tion, one representing the Purification of the Virgin, the 
 other the Crowning of Proserpine. 
 
 Appended to " The Golden Legend " are the legends 
 of Saints Ferreol, Ferrution, Germain, and Droctoveus. 
 xxviij pages, and the " Miraculous Burial of Monsieur 
 Saint Germain d'Auxerre," xij pages. 
 
 This valuable manuscript, which formed part of the 
 collection of Sir Thomas Raleigh, is at present preserved 
 in the collection of Monsieur Micael-Angelo Polizzi of 
 Girgenti. 
 
 "Do you hear, Hamilcar? The manuscript of 
 the clerk Alexander is in Sicily, in the home of 
 Micael-Angelo Polizzi. If only this man is fond 
 of scholars ! I must write to him."
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 2Q 
 
 I did so without delay. In the letter I begged 
 Signer Polizzi to allow me to see the clerk Alex- 
 ander's manuscript, stating on what grounds I ven- 
 tured to believe myself worthy of such a favor. At 
 the same time I put at his disposition several unpub- 
 lished texts in my possession, which were of no 
 small value. I begged him to favor me with an 
 early reply, and beneath my name I wrote all my 
 honorary titles. 
 
 " Monsieur ! monsieur ! Where are you going 
 like that ? " cried Thdrese in fright, as she ran 
 down the stairs after me, four steps at a time, my 
 hat in her hand. 
 
 " I am going to post a letter, Thdrese." 
 
 "Good Lord ! The idea of rushing out that way, 
 bare-headed, like a crazy man ! " 
 
 "I am crazy, Thdrese. But who is not? Give 
 me my hat, quick." 
 
 " And your gloves, monsieur ! and your um- 
 brella!" 
 
 I had reached the foot of the stairs, but I still 
 heard her calling and expostulating. 
 
 October 10, 1859. 
 
 I awaited Signer Polizzi's reply with ill-concealed 
 impatience. I could not keep still. I grew ner- 
 vous. I would open and close my books. One day 
 I knocked down a volume of Morri with my elbow. 
 Hamilcar, who was washing himself, stopped sud- 
 denly, his paw behind his ear, and looked angrily at 
 me. Had he any reason to expect such a tempestu- 
 ous existence under my roof ? Had we not tacitly
 
 30 THE CRIME OF 
 
 agreed to lead a peaceful life ? I had broken our 
 compact. 
 
 " My poor friend," said I, " I am the victim of a 
 violent passion, that agitates and completely over- 
 masters me. Passion is the enemy of peace, I ad- 
 mit, but without it there would be neither industry 
 nor art in this world. Every one would sleep uncov- 
 ered on a dunghill, and you could not lie all day long, 
 Hamilcar, on a silken cushion in the City of Books." 
 
 I explained no more to Hamilcar regarding the 
 theory of passion, because my housekeeper brought 
 in a letter. It bore the postmark of Naples, and 
 ran as follows : 
 
 Most Illustrious Signor, 
 
 / have indeed in my possession the incomparable manu- 
 script of " The Golden Legend" -which has not escaped 
 your close attention. All-important reasons, however, ab- 
 solutely and tyrannically prevent my parting with it for a 
 single day, a single instant. It would be a pleasure and 
 an honor to show it to you in my humble home at Girgenti, 
 which would be embellished and illuminated by your pres- 
 ence. So, in the impatient hope of greeting you, I dare to 
 sign myself, Signor Academician, your humble and devoted 
 servant, MICAEL-ANGELO POLIZZI. 
 
 Dealer in Wines, and Arcliaeotogist at Girgenti (Sicily). 
 
 Very well ! I will go to Sicily. 
 " Extremum hunc, Arethusa, ntihi concede labo- 
 rem" 
 
 October 25, 1859. 
 
 My resolve taken and my arrangements com- 
 pleted, nothing remained but to notify my house-
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNAKD. 31 
 
 keeper. I must confess that I hesitated a long 
 time before telling her of my proposed departure. 
 I was afraid of her remonstrances, her teasing, her 
 prayers, and her tears. " She is a good girl," I 
 said to myself, " and she is attached to me. She 
 will want to prevent my going; and God knows that 
 when she wants anything, words, gestures, and cries 
 are nothing to her. In the present instance she will 
 call to her aid the janitress, the floor-polisher, the 
 mattress-maker, and the seven sons of the fruit- 
 dealer. They will all fall on their knees in a cir- 
 cle at my feet. They will weep, and they will look 
 so homely that I shall have to give in so as not to 
 see them any more." 
 
 Such were the frightful visions, the hallucinations, 
 that fear brought before my imagination. Yes, fear, 
 "fruitful fear," as the poet says, engendered these 
 monstrous ideas in my brain. For, in this private 
 diary, I will confess that I am afraid of my house- 
 keeper. I know that she realizes how weak I am, 
 and in my struggles with her this fact takes away 
 all my courage. These struggles occur frequently, 
 and I invariably give in. But I had to announce 
 my departure to The>ese. She came into the li- 
 brary with an armful of wood to make a little fire, 
 "a flame," she said, for the mornings are sharp. I 
 watched her out of the corner of my eye as she bent 
 down, her head under the hood of the fireplace. I 
 have no idea where my courage came from, but 
 I did not hesitate a moment. I rose and began pa- 
 ring up and down the room. 
 
 "By the way," said I in a careless tone, with \\
 
 32 THE CRIME OF 
 
 that swaggering manner which is characteristic of 
 cowards, " by the way, Therese, I am going to 
 Sicily." 
 
 Having spoken, I waited, extremely anxious. The"- 
 rese made no reply. Her head and her huge cap 
 remained buried in the fireplace, and I saw nothing 
 in her appearance that betrayed the slightest emo- 
 tion. She was stuffing some paper under the logs, 
 and was kindling the fire. That was all. 
 
 At length I saw her face again. It was calm, so 
 calm that I grew angry. 
 
 " Really," I thought, " this old maid has no heart. 
 She lets me go away -without even saying ' Ah ! ' Is 
 the absence of her old master of such small account 
 to her ? " 
 
 "Well, monsieur," she said at last, "go; but be 
 back by six o'clock. We have a dish for dinner 
 to-day that cannot be kept waiting." 
 
 NAPLES, November 10, 1859. 
 
 " Co tra calle vive, magne e lave a faccia" 
 I understand, my friend. For three centimes I 
 can drink, eat, and wash my face, all by means of 
 one of these slices of watermelon which you display 
 on a little table. But Occidental prejudices would 
 prevent my honestly relishing this simple pleasure. 
 How could I suck the watermelon? It is all I can 
 do to keep my footing in this crowd. How brilliant 
 and noisy the night is in the Strada di Porto ! The 
 fruit is piled lip like mountains in the shops that are 
 bright with multi-colored lanterns. On the stoves,
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 33 
 
 burning in the open air, the water boils in the ket- 
 tles, and the frying things sing away in the pans. 
 The odor of fried fish and hot meats tickles my 
 nose, and makes me sneeze. At this point I find 
 that my handkerchief has vanished from my coat 
 pocket. I am pushed, turned about, and literally 
 carried off my feet, by the gayest, the most reckless, 
 the liveliest, and the nimblest people that can be 
 imagined. Suddenly a young woman, whose mag- 
 nificent black hair I am admiring, sends me flying, 
 with a shove of her powerful and elastic shoulder, 
 three steps backward, without hurting me, into the 
 arms of a macaroni-eater, who welcomes me with a 
 smile. 
 
 I am in Naples. How I arrived here with the few 
 battered and mutilated remnants of my luggage, I 
 cannot tell, for the simple reason that I do not 
 know. I made my journey in a constant state of ter- 
 ror ; and I know that in this brilliant city I looked, 
 a while ago, just like an owl in the sunshine. To- 
 night it is much worse ! Wishing to study the hab- 
 its of the people, I came into the Strada di Porto, 
 where I am now. About me, animated groups 
 are crowding before the eating-shops ; and I float 
 like a wreck at the mercy of these living waves, 
 which, even as they carry one down, caress one 
 still. For there is something indescribably sweet 
 and gentle in the vivacity of these Neapolitans. 
 I am not rudely jostled. I am rocked ; and I 
 think that by swaying me back and forth, these 
 people want me to fall asleep while I am standing 
 hero.
 
 34 THE CRIME OF 
 
 As I make my way along the lava pavement of the 
 strada, I cannot but admire the street porters and 
 the fishermen who pass by, talking, singing, smok- 
 ing, gesticulating, quarrelling and making up with 
 wonderful rapidity. They live in all their senses at 
 once, wise without knowing it, gauging their ambi- 
 tion by the shortness of life. I approach a well- 
 frequented wine-shop, and read on the door this 
 quatrain, in the patois of Naples : 
 
 Amice, alliegre magnammo e bevimmo, 
 
 Nfui che n'ce stace noelio a la htcerna ; 
 > if t> 
 
 Chi sa s'a /' antro munno ne'e vedimmo? 
 Chi sa s'a /' autro munno ne'e taverna 7 
 
 Come, Friends, let us merrily eat and drink, 
 As long as the lamp I/urns bright ; 
 Who knows if we'll meet in the world to come, 
 Or if taverns are kept in the Realms of Light ? 
 
 Horace gave similar counsels to his friends. You 
 accepted them, Postumus ; you heard them, Leuco- 
 noe, rebellious beauty, with your craving to know the 
 secrets of the future ; that future is now the past, 
 and we know it. In truth, you were very wrong to 
 trouble yourself for so little ; and your lover showed 
 himself to be a sensible man in advising you to be 
 wise, and to strain your Greek wines. Sapias, vina 
 liques. 
 
 Thus a beautiful land and a pure sky counsel us 
 to pursue quiet pleasures. But there are souls trou- 
 bled by a sublime discontent. These are the no- 
 blest. You were of these, Leuconoe ; and coming
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 35 
 
 at the close of my life to the city where your beauty 
 shone, I respectfully salute your melancholy shade. 
 The souls like yours, who appeared in the age of 
 Christianity, were the souls of saints ; and their mira- 
 cles fill " The Golden Legend." Your friend Horace 
 left a less noble posterity ; and I recognize one of 
 his descendants in the person of the tavern-keeper 
 poet, who even now is filling the cups with wine 
 beneath his epicurean signboard. 
 
 Yet life proves our friend Flaccus right, and his 
 philosophy alone is suited to the train of events. 
 See that jovial fellow leaning against a covered 
 vine-trellis, and eating an ice as he gazes at the 
 stars. He would not stoop to pick up the old 
 manuscript for which I am going in search with 
 so much trouble. And truly, man is made rather 
 to eat ices than to pore over old texts. 
 
 I continued to wander among the drinkers and 
 the singers. There were lovers, who, their arms 
 about each other's waists, were eating ripe fruit. 
 Man must be naturally evil, for all this strange hap- 
 piness saddened me deeply. The crowd made such 
 a display of their artless delight in mere existence, 
 that all the sensitiveness which years of writing 
 had intensified in me seemed to revolt against it. 
 Furthermore, I was disheartened at not understand- 
 ing a word of the gay talk that buzzed through the 
 air. It was a humiliating ordeal for a philologist, 
 and so I was positively peevish when some words 
 uttered behind me fell on my ear. 
 
 Dimitri, that old man is certainly a Frenchman. 
 He looks so bewildered that it troubles me. Shall
 
 36 THE CRIME OF 
 
 I speak to him ? He has a good round back, hasn't 
 he, Dimitri?" 
 
 The words were spoken in French, and by a 
 woman. At the very first, it was extremely disagree- 
 able to hear myself spoken of as an old man. Is 
 one old at sixty-two ? The other day on the Pont 
 des Arts, my friend Perrot d'Avrignac complimented 
 me on my youthful appearance ; and he is a better 
 authority on age, apparently, than this young crow 
 who makes remarks about my back. My back is 
 round, is it ? Ah, ha ! I suspected as much ; but 
 now I shall not believe it at all, since it is the opin- 
 ion of a young simpleton. I will not even turn my 
 head to see who the speaker is, but I am sure that 
 it is a pretty woman. Why ? Because she speaks 
 in a capricious way, like a spoiled child. Homely 
 women would be as capricious as pretty ones ; but 
 as they are never spoiled, and as no allowances are 
 ever made for what they do, they are obliged to 
 forget their whims or to hide them. On the other 
 hand, pretty women may be as capricious as they 
 please. My neighbor is of the latter class. How- 
 ever, as I think of it, she expressed a kindly thought 
 about me, and that deserves my gratitude. 
 
 These reflections, including the last and crowning 
 one, chased one another through my brain in less 
 than a second ; and if I have taken a whole minute 
 to tell them, it is because I am a poor writer, a qual- 
 ity common to all philologists. Scarcely a second 
 after the voice had ceased speaking, I turned, and 
 saw a very vivacious and pretty little brunette. 
 
 " Madame," I said, bowing, "pardon my thought-
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 37 
 
 less indiscretion. I could not help overhearing what 
 you just said. You wished to do a kindness to a 
 poor old man. You have already done it, madame ; 
 the mere sound of a French voice is a pleasure to 
 me, and I thank you for it." 
 
 I bowed again, and was about to move away, 
 when my heel slipped on the rind of a watermelon, 
 and I should certainly haVe kissed the Parthenopean 
 soil had not the young woman raised her hand to 
 catch me. 
 
 In circumstances, even the njost trifling, there is 
 a force that one cannot resist. I resigned myself to 
 being the prottgt of the unknown lady. 
 
 " It is late," said she ; " do you not want to return 
 to your hotel, which must be near ours, if not the 
 same ? " 
 
 " Madame," I replied, " I do not know what time 
 it is, because my watch has been stolen ; but I think, 
 with you, that it is time to beat a retreat, and I shall 
 be happy to return to the Hotel de Genes in the 
 company of such kind compatriots." 
 
 So saying, I bowed again to the young woman 
 and her companion, who was a silent giant, gentle, 
 yet sad. 
 
 I had not gone far with them before I learned, 
 among other things, that they were the Prince and 
 Princess Trdpof, and that they were making a trip 
 around the world in pursuit of match-boxes, of which 
 they were making a collection. 
 
 We walked along a winding, narrow vicoletto 
 (alley), lighted by a solitary lamp burning before 
 the niche of a Madonna. 
 
 136471
 
 38 THE CRIME OF 
 
 The transparency and purity of the air gave even 
 the darkness a heavenly light, and we made our way 
 without difficulty under the limpid night. Then we 
 plunged into a small street, or, to use the Neapolitan 
 expression, a sotto-portico (arcade), which ran along 
 beneath so many arches and projecting balconies 
 that scarcely a ray of light reached us. My young 
 guide took this route, she said, because it was 
 shorter, but also, I imagine, in order to show us 
 that she was thoroughly acquainted with Naples, 
 and could find her way about. It was indeed neces- 
 sary to know the city in order to venture by night 
 within this labyrinth of subterranean alleys and 
 stairways. 
 
 If ever man was docile in letting himself be guided 
 it was I. Dante followed the steps of Beatrice no 
 more trustingly than I those of the Princess Trdpof. 
 
 This lady evidently took some pleasure in my 
 conversation ; for she offered me a seat in her car- 
 riage the next day, to visit the grotto of Posilippo 
 and the tomb of Virgil. She declared that she had 
 seen me somewhere before, but she did not know 
 whether it was at Stockholm or Canton. In the 
 former case I was a highly distinguished professor 
 of geology; in the latter, a provision-merchant, 
 whose courtesy and kindness had been greatly ap- 
 preciated. However, she was certain that some- 
 where she had seen my back: 
 
 "Excuse me," she added; "my husband and I 
 travel constantly in order to collect match-boxes, 
 and to find new forms of ennui by finding new coun- 
 tries. Perhaps it would be better to content our-
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNAKD. 39 
 
 selves with one kind of ennui alone. But all our 
 arrangements are made for travelling ; it is no trouble 
 for us, and it would be very annoying if we had to 
 stop anywhere. I tell you this that you may not be 
 surprised if my ideas are somewhat confused. But 
 when I first saw you this evening I felt, indeed I 
 knew, that I had seen you before. But where ? 
 That is the question. Are you sure that you are 
 neither the geologist nor the provision-merchant ? " 
 
 " No, madame," I replied, ' I am neither the one 
 nor the other; and I regret the fact, since you have 
 had occasion to be pleased with them. There is 
 nothing in me to arouse your interest. I have spent 
 my life among books, and I have never travelled. 
 You must have seen that from my bewilderment, 
 which you pitied. I am a member of the Institute." 
 
 "A member of the Institute! Oh, that is charm- 
 ing! You must write something in my album. Do 
 you understand Chinese ? I should so much like to 
 have you write something in Chinese or Persian in 
 my album. I will present you to my friend Miss 
 Fergusson. She travels everywhere, in order to see 
 every celebrity in the world. She will be delighted. 
 Dimitri, did you hear? This gentleman is a mem- 
 ber of the Institute, and has spent his life among 
 books ! " 
 
 The prince nodded his head approvingly. 
 
 " Monsieur," I said, trying to bring him into the 
 conversation, " there is no doubt but that something 
 is to be learned from books ; but one can learn much 
 more by travelling, and I greatly regret that I have 
 not, like you, been all over the world. I have lived
 
 40 THE CRIME OF 
 
 in the same house for thirty years, and I scarcely 
 ever go out." 
 
 " You have lived in the same house for thirty 
 years ! Is it possible ? " exclaimed Madame Trepof. 
 
 " Yes, madame," I answered. " To be sure, the 
 house is on the banks of the Seine, in the most 
 noted and most beautiful spot in the world. My 
 window looks out upon the Tuileries and the Louvre, 
 the Pont-Neuf, the towers of Notre-Dame, the tow- 
 ers of the Palais de Justice, and the spire of Sainte- 
 Chapelle. All these stones speak to me. They tell 
 me stories of the days of Saint Louis, of the Valois, 
 of Henry IV. and Louis XIV. I understand them, 
 and I love them. It is but one small corner'; but in 
 all truth, madame, is there a more beautiful one ? " 
 
 We had reached a square, a largo, bathed in the 
 soft radiance of the night. Madame Tre"pof looked 
 anxiously at me, her raised eyebrows almost touch- 
 ing her curly black hair. 
 
 " Where do you live ? " she asked suddenly. 
 
 " On the quay Maloquais, madame, and my name 
 is Bonnard. Not widely known, it is true ; but it is 
 enough for me that my friends do not forget it." 
 
 This announcement, unimportant as it was, pro- 
 duced an extraordinary effect on Madame Trdpof. 
 She immediately turned her back upon me, and 
 seized her husband's arm. 
 
 "Come, Dimitri," said she, "do make haste! I 
 am horribly tired, and you are so slow. We shall 
 never get there. That is your road, monsieur, over 
 there." 
 
 She pointed vaguely toward a dark iricolo, pushed
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNAKD. 41 
 
 her husband in the opposite direction, and called 
 out to me without turning her head, 
 
 " Farewell, monsieur. We shall not go to Posi- 
 lippo to-morrow, nor the day after, either. I have a 
 frightful headache, frightful. Dimitri, you are un- 
 bearable, you are so slow ! " 
 
 I stood petrified, trying, but in vain, to discover 
 what I could have done to offend Madame Trdpof. 
 I was lost ; and, so far as I could see, I should have 
 to wander about all night. As to asking my way of 
 any one, I should have to meet some one in order 
 to do this, and I despaired of seeing a soul. In my 
 despair I took a street at random, or, rather, a hor- 
 rible looking alleyway. It certainly resembled the 
 haunt of cut-throats; and, in fact, it was such, for 
 I had not walked more than a few moments before I 
 came upon two men using knives. They were fight- 
 ing with their tongues even more than with their 
 blades, and from the harsh words they interchanged 
 I concluded that they were lovers. I prudently 
 turned into a side alley, while the worthy fellows 
 went on with their own affair without in the least 
 troubling themselves about mine. I walked on for 
 some time at random, and sat down discouraged 
 on a stone bench, inwardly cursing the whims of 
 Madame Tre*pof. 
 
 " How are you, signor? Are you just back from 
 San Carlo? Did you hear the diva? One hears 
 such singing only at Naples." 
 
 I looked up, and recognized my landlord. I was 
 sitting against the faqade of my hotel, beneath my 
 own window.
 
 42 THE CRIME OF 
 
 MONTB-ALLEGRO, November 30, 1859. 
 
 My guides, the mules, and I, on our way from 
 Sciacca to Girgenti, were resting at an inn in the 
 wretched village of Monte-Allegro. The inhabit- 
 ants, wasted away by mal' aria, were shivering in 
 the sun. But they are Greeks, and their gayety 
 rises above everything. Some of them surrounded 
 the inn, full of smiling curiosity. A story, could I 
 have told them one, would have made them forget 
 all the ills of life. They looked intelligent ; and 
 the women, although sunburned and faded, wore 
 their long black cloaks with much grace. 
 
 Before me were ruins bleached by the sea wind ; 
 not even grass grows on them. The mournful lone- 
 liness of the desert reigns in this arid land, the 
 parched breast of which scarcely finds sufficient 
 nourishment for a few dried mimosa, some cacti, 
 and dwarf palms. Twenty paces distant, at the 
 bottom of a ravine, some stones were gleaming 
 white, like a trail of bones. My guide told me that 
 they marked the bed of a stream. 
 
 I had spent a fortnight in Sicily. As I entered 
 the Bay of Palermo, which opens between the two 
 barren and mighty mountains of the Pellegrino and 
 the Catalfano, and runs the length of the Golden 
 Conch, I was filled with such admiration that I de- 
 termined to travel in the island, so noted on account 
 of its historic memories, and so beautiful in the out- 
 lines of its hills, which reveal the principles of Greek 
 art. Old pilgrim that I was, grown white in the 
 Gothic Occident, I dared to venture on this classic
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 43 
 
 soil; and, having arranged with my guide, I went 
 from Palermo to Trapani, from Trapani to Selinonte, 
 from Selinonte to Sciacca, which I left this morning 
 for Girgenti, to find the manuscript of the clerk 
 Alexander. The beautiful things that I have seen 
 are so fresh in my mind that I consider the trouble 
 of describing them a useless task. Why spoil my 
 trip by gathering notes ? Lovers who truly love 
 never describe their happiness. 
 
 Wholly given over to the melancholy of the pres- 
 ent and the poetry of the past, my mind filled with 
 beautiful images, my eyes full of pure and harmo- 
 nious lines, I was sipping the sirup-like dew of a 
 fiery wine in the inn of Monte-Allegro, when I saw 
 two persons enter the room. After a moment's hesi- 
 tation I recognized them as Monsieur and Madame 
 Trdpof. 
 
 This time I saw the princess in the light, and 
 such a light ! When one has enjoyed that of Sicily, 
 one understands better these expressions of Sopho- 
 cles : 
 
 " O holy light .' . . . Eye of the golden day .' " 
 
 Madame Tre"pof, in brown holland, and wearing a 
 broad-brimmed straw hat, looked like a very pretty 
 woman of about twenty-eight. Her eyes were like a 
 child's, but her full chin showed a riper age. She 
 is, I must confess, a very pleasant person. She is 
 souplc and variable. She is the shifting sea; but, 
 thank Heaven, I am no sailor! I soon detected 
 that she was in a bad humor ; and this, after hear- 
 ing her utter a few broken words, I attributed to the
 
 44 THE CRIME OF 
 
 fact that she had not met a single brigand on the 
 way. 
 
 " Such things never happen except to us," she 
 exclaimed, letting her arms fall with a gesture of 
 discouragement. 
 
 She asked for a glass of iced water, and the host 
 presented it to her with a grace which reminded 
 me of those scenes of funeral offerings depicted on 
 Greek vases. 
 
 I was in no haste to show myself before the lady 
 who had left me so suddenly in the Square in 
 Naples ; but she caught sight of me in my corner, 
 and her quick frown showed me very plainly that 
 my presence was disagreeable to her. 
 
 She drank a swallow of the water ; and then, 
 either her whim changed, or she felt sorry for my 
 solitude, but she came straight to me. 
 
 " Good-morning, Monsieur Bonnard," she said. 
 " How do you do? What luck to meet you in this 
 frightful country ! " 
 
 " This country is not frightful, madame," I re- 
 plied. " This land is a land of glory. Beauty is a 
 thing so great and so dignified that it takes centuries 
 of barbarism to efface it, and even then there will 
 always remain some adorable traces of it ! The 
 majesty of ancient Ceres still broods over these arid 
 valleys, and the Greek muse who made Arethusa 
 and Mamalus re-echo with her divine accents still 
 sings in my ears on the bare mountain and in the 
 dried bed of the stream. Yes, madame, when this 
 uninhabited earth shall, like the moon, roll its pale 
 corpse in space, the soil that bears the ruins of
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNAKD. 45 
 
 Selinonte shall even in death keep the everlasting 
 stamp of beauty ; and then, then at least, there will 
 no longer be frivolous lips to blaspheme the grandeur 
 of these solitudes." 
 
 I knew very well that my words were beyond the 
 comprehension of the pretty little empty-head who 
 heard them ; but a man like myself, who has spent 
 his life over books, cannot change his tone to suit 
 every one. Besides, I was glad to teach Madame 
 Trdpof a lesson in reverence. She received it with 
 such submission and with such an intelligent air, 
 that I added, in as good-natured a manner as pos- 
 sible, 
 
 " As to whether the chance which has thrown us 
 together is fortunate or unfortunate I am at a loss 
 to say, before knowing whether or not my presence 
 is disagreeable to you. The other day at Naples 
 you seemed suddenly to grow weary of my company. 
 I can attribute your actions only to my natural dis- 
 agreeableness, since at that time I had the honor of 
 meeting you for the first time in my life." 
 
 My words seemed to cause her the most inde- 
 scribable delight. She smiled on me most gra- 
 ciously, and held out her hand, which I raised to 
 my lips. 
 
 " Monsieur Bonnard," she said vivaciously, " do 
 not refuse a seat in my carriage. You shall talk to 
 me on the way about antiquities, and I shall be 
 greatly interested." 
 
 My dear," said the prince, " it shall be just as 
 you say ; but you know the carriage is not an easy 
 riding one, and I fear that you are only giving
 
 46 THE CRIME OF 
 
 Monsieur Bonnard a chance, to suffer from a hor- 
 rible backache." 
 
 Madame Tre"pof tossed her head to show that she 
 did not hesitate at any such consideration ; then 
 she took off her hat. The shadow fell from her 
 black hair over her eyes, bathing them in a velvety 
 softness. She stood motionless, her features assum- 
 ing a far-away, dreamy expression. But suddenly 
 her eyes fell on a basket of oranges which the inn- 
 keeper had brought in ; and taking them up one by 
 one, she put them into a fold of her gown. 
 
 " They are for our drive," she said. " You are 
 going to Girgenti, and so are we. Do you know 
 why we are going there ? I will tell you. My hus- 
 band, you know, is collecting match-boxes. We 
 bought thirteen hundred at Marseilles. But we 
 heard that there was a factory of them at Girgenti. 
 We were told that it was a small factory, and that 
 its products, which are very ugly, never go outside 
 of the city and its suburbs. So ! we are going to Gir- 
 genti to buy these boxes. Dimitri has tried all sorts 
 of collections, but at present he is interested in noth- 
 ing but match-boxes. He already has five thousand 
 two hundred and fourteen different kinds. We have 
 some that were a great deal of trouble to find. For 
 instance, we knew that at Naples boxes were once 
 made with the portraits of Mazzini and Garibaldi on 
 them, and that the police had seized the plates from 
 which they were printed, and imprisoned the manu- 
 facturer. By hunting and inquiring we secured one 
 of these boxes for a hundred francs, instead of two 
 sous. That was not very dear, but we were in-
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNAKD. 47 
 
 I 
 
 formed against. We were taken for conspirators. 
 Our baggage was searched. They did not find the 
 box, however, which I had carefully hidden; but they 
 found my jewels, and took them. They still have 
 them. The affair caused some talk, and we were 
 on the point of being arrested. But the king heard 
 of it, and ordered us to be let alone. Until then I 
 thought it stupid to collect match-boxes ; but when 
 I found that our liberty and perhaps our life were 
 at stake, I developed a sudden liking for it. Now 
 I have a perfect craze for collecting match-boxes. 
 Next summer we are going to Sweden to complete 
 our collection. Are we not, Dimitri ? " 
 
 I felt (must I admit it?) considerable sympathy 
 for these intrepid collectors. No doubt I should 
 rather have found Monsieur and Madame Trdpof 
 interested in antique marbles and painted vases in 
 Sicily. I should like to have seen them studying 
 the ruins of Agrigentum and the poetical traditions 
 of the Eryx. But no matter; they were making a 
 collection, they belonged to the brotherhood, and 
 could I laugh at them without laughing at myself? 
 Besides, Madame Tre"pof had spoken of her collec- 
 tion with a mingling of enthusiasm and irony that 
 made the idea a very pleasing one. As we were 
 about to leave the inn, we saw some men with car- 
 bines under their dark cloaks, coming down-stairs 
 from the upper rooms. To me they had the appear- 
 ance of thorough-going bandits, and after they had 
 gone I told Monsieur Tre"pof my opinion of them. 
 He calmly replied that he thought as I did, that 
 they were bandits; and our guides advised us to
 
 48 THE CRJME OF 
 
 take an escort of gendarmes. But Madame Tre'pof 
 begged us to do nothing of the kind. There was no 
 need, she said, to spoil her trip. 
 
 Turning a pair of pleading eyes to me, she 
 added, 
 
 " Is it not true, Monsieur Bonnard, that nothing 
 in life is worth anything but sensations ? " 
 
 " No doubt, madame," I replied ; " but still, we 
 must understand the nature of the sensations. Those 
 that are inspired by a noble memory or a grand 
 spectacle are of course the best element of life ; 
 whereas it seems to me that those resulting from 
 threatening danger should be carefully avoided. 
 Should you think it pleasant, madame, if at mid- 
 night among the mountains the muzzle of a carbine 
 were pressed against your forehead ? " 
 
 " Oh, no," she answered ; " comic operas have 
 made carbines perfectly absurd, and it would be a 
 great misfortune for a young women to be killed 
 with an absurd weapon. But a knife-blade is an- 
 other thing. A polished, cold knife-blade ! That 
 makes one shiver." 
 
 She herself shivered as she spoke, closed her 
 eyes, and threw her head back. Then she re- 
 sumed, 
 
 "You are happy you are interested in all sorts 
 of things." 
 
 She gave a side glance at her husband as he 
 stood talking with the innkeeper. Then, leaning 
 towards me, she said in a low tone, 
 
 " Dimitri and I are both bored to death, you see. 
 To be sure, we have the match-boxes left, but one
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 49 
 
 tires even of them. Besides, before long our collec- 
 tion will be completed. What shall we do then ? " 
 
 "Ah, madame," I said, touched by the moral 
 wretchedness of this pretty woman, " if you had a 
 son, you would know what to do. The aim of your 
 life would be very apparent then, and your thoughts 
 would be at once more serious and more cheerful.' 1 
 
 ' I have a son," she replied. " He is grown now ; 
 he is almost a man. He is eleven years old, and is 
 already wearied of life. Yes, really, my George, he, 
 too, suffers from ennui. It is very distressing." 
 
 Again she glanced at her husband, who was 
 superintending the harnessing of the mules on the 
 road, and examining the girths and straps. Then 
 she asked me if, during the last ten years, there had 
 been many changes on the quay Malaquais. She 
 said she never went there, because it was too far 
 away. 
 
 " Too far from Monte-Allegro ? " I asked. 
 
 " Oh, no ! " she answered ; " too far from the 
 Avenue des Champs-Elyse'es, where we live." 
 
 Then, as if to herself, she murmured in a low 
 tone, 
 
 " Too far ! too far ! " with a dreamy expression, 
 the meaning of which I could not fathom. 
 
 Suddenly she smiled and said to me, 
 
 " I like you immensely, Monsieur Bonnard, im- 
 mensely." 
 
 The mules were harnessed. The young woman 
 picked up the oranges, which had fallen from her 
 lap, rose, and, looking at me, began to laugh. 
 
 " How I should like to see you struggling with
 
 5O THE CRIME OF 
 
 brigands ! " she cried. " You would say such extraor- 
 dinary things to them ! Do take my hat and hold 
 my parasol for me, will you, Monsieur Bonnard ? " 
 
 " Well," said I to myself as I followed her, "well, 
 she is a queer little mortal ! Nature must have 
 been unpardonably thoughtless when she gave a 
 son to such a silly creature ! " 
 
 GIROENTI, The same day. 
 
 Her manners had shocked me. I let her settle 
 herself in her lettica (litter), and I made myself as 
 comfortable as I could in mine. These wheelless 
 vehicles are borne by two mules, one in front, the 
 other behind. This style of litter or chair is of 
 ancient usage. I often used to see similar ones 
 depicted in French manuscripts of the fourteenth 
 century. I did not know then that some day I 
 should be using one of them. It is well for us not 
 to count too certainly on anything. 
 
 For three hours the mules jingled their little bells, 
 and beat their hoofs on the sunburnt soil. On 
 either side the arid and prodigious shapes of an 
 African landscape came slowly into view. When 
 we had gone half the distance we paused to let our 
 mules take breath. Madame Trdpof stepped from 
 her litter, and, coming to me, took my arm, and drew 
 me forward a few steps. Then, all at once, in a 
 voice that I could not believe was hers, she said to 
 me, 
 
 " Do not think me a bad woman. My George 
 knows that I am a good mother."
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 51 
 
 We walked a space in silence. She raised her 
 head, and I saw that she was weeping. 
 
 "Madame," I said, "do you see this soil that is 
 cracked by five months' heat? A little white lily 
 has sprung from it." 
 
 And with the end of my cane I pointed to the 
 frail stalk ending in a double blossom. 
 
 "Your heart also," I said, "however arid it may 
 be, yet bears its white lily. This in itself proves 
 that I do not think you to be, as you said, a bad 
 woman." 
 
 " Yes, I am ! yes, I am ! " she cried, with the ob- 
 stinacy of a child. " I am a bad woman ; but I am 
 ashamed of it before you, who are so good, so very 
 good." 
 
 " You know nothing about it," I said. 
 
 " Yes, I do ; I know you," she said with a smile. 
 And with a quick step she returned to her Uttica. 
 
 GIRGENTI, November 30, 1859. 
 
 The following day I awoke at Girgenti, in the 
 house of Gellias. Gellias was a wealthy citizen of 
 ancient Agrigentum. He was as noted for his gen- 
 erosity as for his opulence, andhe endowed his city 
 with a large number of free hotels. Gellias has 
 been dead for more than thirteen hundred years, 
 and there is no longer free hospitality among civil- 
 ized peoples. But the name Gellias now belongs to 
 a hotel, where, as I was worn out with fatigue, I 
 was able to get a good night's rest. 
 
 Modern Girgenti raises its narrow, closely built
 
 52 THE CRIME OF 
 
 houses above the acropolis of ancient Agrigentum, 
 and over all a sombre Spanish cathedral looks down. 
 From my windows I see, half-way down the hill 
 toward the sea, the white line of half-destroyed 
 temples. These ruins are the sole touch of fresh- 
 ness. All else is dried up. Water and life have 
 deserted Agrigentum. Water, the divine Nestis of 
 Empedocles of Agrigentum, is so necessary to life 
 that nothing lives far from streams and springs. 
 
 But a brisk trade is carried on at the port of Gir- 
 genti, three kilometers from the city. 
 
 " So," said I to myself, " in this sad city, on this 
 abrupt height, the manuscript of the clerk Alexan- 
 der is to be found ! " 
 
 I had Signor Micael-Angelo Polizzi's house pointed 
 out to me, and went there. 
 
 I found Signor Polizzi clad in white from head to 
 foot, engaged in cooking sausages in a frying-pan. 
 At sight of me he let go the handle of the pan, 
 raised his arms, and gave a cry of delight. He was 
 a small man, whose pimpled face, hooked nose, pro- 
 jecting chin, and round eyes made a remarkably 
 expressive physiognomy. 
 
 He addressed me as Your Excellency, said that 
 this was a red-letter day, and asked me to be seated. 
 The room in which we were, opened into the kitchen, 
 the parlor, the sleeping-room, the workshop, and the 
 cellar. 
 
 I saw furnaces, a bed, some canvases, an easel, 
 several bottles, some bunches of onions, and a mag- 
 nificent colored spun-glass chandelier. I glanced 
 at the pictures with which the walls were covered.
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 53 
 
 " Art ! art ! " cried Signer Polizzi, again raising 
 his arms to heaven. " Art ! What an honor ! 
 What a comfort ! I am a painter, Your Excellency." 
 
 He showed me an unfinished Saint Francis, which 
 might well have remained so without loss to art or 
 religion. Then he called my attention to some old 
 pictures of a somewhat better quality, but they 
 seemed to me to have been restored indiscrim- 
 inately. 
 
 " I repair ancient paintings," said he. " Oh, what 
 soul, what genius, the old masters had ! " 
 
 " Is it true, then ? " I asked, " are you painter, 
 antiquary, and wine-merchant all in one ? " 
 
 " At your service, Your Excellency," he replied. 
 " At present 1 have a zucco, every drop of which is 
 a pearl of fire. I will have your lordship taste it." 
 
 " I esteem the wines of Sicily highly," I answered ; 
 " but I have not come to see you on account of your 
 bottles, Signer Polizzi." 
 
 He " For my paintings, then. You are an 
 
 amateur. It is a great delight to me to receive 
 such men. I will show you the masterpiece of 
 ' Monrealese ; ' yes, Your Excellency, his master- 
 piece! 'The Adoration of the Shepherds!' It is 
 the gem of the Sicilian school ! " 
 
 /. " It will give me pleasure to see this master- 
 piece. But let us first speak of what has brought 
 me here." 
 
 His small, restless eyes, brimming over with curi- 
 osity, fastened themselves on me ; and I saw with a 
 sharp pang that he did not even suspect the object 
 of my visit.
 
 54 THE CRIME OF 
 
 Anxious, feeling the cold perspiration on my 
 brow, I pitifully stammered out something to this 
 effect, 
 
 " I have come from Paris on purpose to see a 
 manuscript of ' The Golden Legend,' which you 
 wrote that you had in your possession." 
 
 At these words he raised his arms, opened wide 
 his mouth and eyes, and showed the greatest agita- 
 tion. 
 
 " Oh ! the manuscript of ' The Golden Legend ' ! 
 A gem, Your Excellency, a ruby, a diamond ! Two 
 miniatures so perfect that they seem to give you a 
 glimpse of Paradise. What softness is there ! The 
 wonderful tints robbed from the corolla of a flower 
 are honey for the eyes ! A Sicilian could not have 
 done better ! " 
 
 " Show it to me ! " I cried, unable to conceal my 
 impatience or my hope. 
 
 " Show it to you ! " cried Polizzi. " How can I, 
 Your Excellency ? I no longer have it ! I no longer 
 have it ! " 
 
 And he seemed as if he would tear his hair from 
 his head. He might have pulled every bit of it out 
 of his hide before I would have stopped him. But 
 he grew calm before he had done himself much 
 damage. 
 
 " What ! " I cried in my wrath ; " do you mean 
 that you led me to come from Paris to Girgenti by 
 offering to show me a manuscript, and when I ar- 
 rive you tell me that you no longer have it? It is 
 shameful, monsieur. I will expose you to all good 
 men."
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 55 
 
 Had any one seen me then, he would have gained 
 a good idea of an enraged sheep. 
 
 " It is shameful ! shameful! " I repeated, shaking 
 my trembling arms. 
 
 Micael-Angelo Polizzi sank into a chair in the 
 manner of a dying hero. His eyes filled with tears ; 
 and his hair, which until then had stood on end, 
 fell in disorder about his forehead. 
 
 " I am a father, Your Excellency, I am a father ! " 
 cried he, clasping his hands. He added between 
 sobs, 
 
 " My son Rafael, the son of my poor wife whose 
 death I have mourned for fifteen years, Rafael, 
 Your Excellency, wanted to set up a business in 
 Paris. He rented a shop in the Rue Laffitte in 
 order to sell curios. I gave him everything of any 
 value that I possessed, my handsomest majolica 
 ware, my most beautiful faience from Urbino, my 
 finest paintings such paintings, signor! They 
 still dazzle me in imagination. And they were all 
 signed ! I gave him the manuscript of The 
 Golden Legend.' I would have given him my flesh 
 and blood. He was my only son, the child of my 
 poor, sainted wife ! " 
 
 "So," said I, "while I, trusting to your given 
 word, was coming to the heart of Sicily in quest 
 of the clerk Alexander's manuscript, this manuscript 
 lay in a shop-window in the rue Laffitte, not fifteen 
 hundred meters from my own lodgings !" 
 
 " It was there, that is positive," replied Signor 
 Polizzi, suddenly growing calm again ; " and it is 
 still there, or at least I trust so, Your Excellency."
 
 56 THE CRIME OF 
 
 He took from a shelf a card which he handed to 
 me, saying, 
 
 " Here is my son's address. You will greatly 
 oblige me by letting your friends know it. Faience, 
 enamels, draperies, paintings, a complete assort- 
 ment of objects of art, all at the most reasonable 
 prices, all guaranteed, on my word of honor. Go 
 and see him. He will show you the manuscript of 
 ' The Golden Legend.' Two miniatures of wonder- 
 ful clearness." 
 
 I was weak enough to accept the card he handed 
 me. This man took advantage of my weakness in 
 again asking me to mention the name of Rafael 
 Polizzi to my friends. 
 
 My hand was already on the door-knob, when the 
 Sicilian grasped my arm. He seemed inspired. 
 
 " Ah, Your Excellency," he cried, "what a city is 
 ours! It gave birth to Empedocles. Empedocles ! 
 What a man he was ! What a citizen ! What bold- 
 ness of thought he possessed ! What virtue ! What 
 soul ! Down there at the port, there is a statue of 
 Empedocles ; and whenever I pass it I uncover. 
 When my son Rafael was on the point of setting out 
 to open a shop of antiquities in the rue Laffitte, in 
 Paris, I went with him to the port of our city, and 
 at the feet of the statue of Empedocles, I gave him 
 my paternal blessing. ' Remember Empedocles!' I 
 said to him. Ah ! signor, our unhappy country needs 
 another Empedocles to-day ! Should you like me 
 to show you the statue, Your Excellency ? I will be 
 your guide to the ruins. I will show you the temple 
 of Castor and Pollux, the temple of Jupiter Olym-
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNAKD. 57 
 
 pus, the temple of Lucinian Juno, the ancient well, 
 the tomb of Theron, and the Golden Gate. Pro- 
 fessional guides are all ignorant mules ! but we will 
 make excavations, if you wish, and we will discover 
 treasures. I understand the science, the gift of 
 making treasure-troves, a gift of Heaven." 
 
 Finally I succeeded in getting away. But he ran 
 after me, stopped me at the foot of the stairs, and 
 whispered in my ear, 
 
 " Listen, Your Excellency ! I will guide you 
 about the city. I will make you acquainted with 
 some of our girls ! What a race they are ! What 
 a type ! What figures they have ! Sicilian girls, 
 signor ! the ancient beauty ! " 
 
 " The Devil take you ! " I cried in anger ; and 
 I rushed into the street, leaving him discoursing 
 in a lofty style equal to his enthusiasm. When 
 I was out of his sight I sank down on a stone, 
 and clasping my head in my hands, began to ru- 
 minate. 
 
 " Was it," thought I to myself, " was it to listen 
 to such propositions that I came to Sicily? This 
 Polizzi is a scoundrel , his son is another, and to- 
 gether they have tried to ruin me. But what plot 
 have they arranged ? " 
 
 I could not understand it. In the meanwhile, 
 was I not sufficiently humiliated and disappointed? 
 
 A burst of merry laughter made me raise my 
 head ; and I saw Madame Trdpof running in front 
 of her husband, and waving a diminutive some- 
 thing in her hand. She seated herself by my side, 
 and showed me, amid bursts of fresh laughter, a
 
 58 THE CRIME OF 
 
 wretched little pasteboard box, on which was a 
 bluish-red head, indicated in the description as that 
 of Empedocles. 
 
 " Yes, madame," I said ; " but that wretched 
 Polizzi to whom I advise you not to send Monsieur 
 Trdpof has disgusted me for life with Empedocles, 
 and this picture of him is not calculated to make 
 this ancient philosopher any more agreeable to 
 me." 
 
 " Oh," said Madame Trdpof, " it is homely, but it 
 is rare. These boxes are not exported. They have 
 to be bought on the spot. Dimitri has six others 
 just like this in his pocket. We took them in or- 
 der to exchange with collectors, you see. We were 
 at the factory at nine o'clock this morning. So you 
 see we have not wasted our time." 
 
 " I certainly do see that, madame," I replied in 
 a bitter tone ; " but I have wasted mine." 
 
 I saw then that she was a kind woman. All her 
 merriment disappeared. 
 
 " Poor Monsieur Bonnard ! Poor Monsieur Bon- 
 nard !" she whispered ; and taking my hand in hers 
 she added, " tell me about your troubles." 
 
 1 told her. It was a long story, but she was 
 touched ; for afterwards she asked me a number of 
 minute questions, which I looked upon as a proof 
 of her interest. She wanted to know the exact title 
 of the manuscript, its size, appearance, and age. 
 Then she asked me for Signor Rafael Polizzi's ad- 
 dress. I gave it to her (O fate ! ), doing exactly as 
 that wretched Polizzi had asked me to do. 
 
 It is sometimes difficult to stop. I began my suf-
 
 SYLVESTKE BONNARD. 59 
 
 ferings and imprecations all over again. This time 
 Madame Tre*pof commenced to laugh. 
 
 " Why do you laugh ? " I asked her. 
 
 "Because I am a wicked woman," she replied. 
 Then she fled away, leaving me alone and mystified 
 on the stone. 
 
 PARIS, December 8, 1859. 
 
 My trunks, still unpacked, were piled up in the 
 dining-room. I was seated before a table laden 
 with all the good things that France produces for 
 an epicure. I was eating a. pdti de Chartres, which 
 alone would make one love one's country. Thdrese, 
 her hands clasped over her white apron, stood watch- 
 ing me with kindness, anxiety, and pity. Hamilcar 
 was rubbing against me wild with joy. 
 
 The following verse of an old poet came to my 
 mind : 
 
 " Happy is he, who, like Ulysses, has made a good 
 journey." 
 
 " Well," I thought to myself, " I have journeyed 
 in vain, I have returned empty-handed, but, like 
 Ulysses, I have made a good journey." 
 
 I swallowed my last drop of coffee, and asked 
 Thdrese for my hat and cane. She handed them 
 to me with a look of distrust, fearing a second de- 
 parture. But I reassured her by asking her to have 
 dinner ready by six o'clock. 
 
 It was always a delight to me to saunter along 
 the streets of Paris, every cobble and flagstone of 
 which I worship. But I had an object in view, and
 
 6<D THE CRIME OF 
 
 I went direct to the rue Laffitte. I was not long in 
 finding Rafael Polizzi's shop. It attracted atten- 
 tion because of its great array of old paintings. 
 These, although bearing a diversity of famous 
 signatures, nevertheless showed a certain family 
 likeness, which would have given one the idea of 
 the touching fraternity among geniuses, had it not 
 betrayed rather the tricky mannerisms of Polizzi 
 senior. Enriched by these dubious masterpieces, 
 the shop was brightened by various curios, swords, 
 flagons, goblets, vases, brass godroons, and Spanish- 
 Arabian dishes of metallic lustre. 
 
 On a Portuguese armchair in embossed leather 
 lay a copy of Simon Vostre's " Hours," open at the 
 page that is embellished with an astrological figure; 
 and an old Vitruvius on a chest displayed its mas- 
 terly engravings of caryatides and telamones. This 
 seeming disorder, which concealed a wise arrange- 
 ment, this way in which the objects were thrown 
 apparently at random, and yet by which they were 
 placed in the most favorable light, would have in- 
 creased my distrust; but that, which the mere name 
 of Polizzi roused in me, could not be augmented, as 
 it was boundless to begin with. 
 
 Signor Rafael, who seemed to be the sole genius 
 of all this incongruous and heterogeneous mass, 
 struck me as a phlegmatic young man, a sort 
 of Englishman. He showed none of his father's 
 transcendental faculties of buffoonery and declama- 
 tion. 
 
 I told him the object of my coming. He opened 
 a closet, and brought out a manuscript which he
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 6 1 
 
 placed on a table, that I might examine it at my 
 leisure. 
 
 Never in my life have I felt such a sensation 
 except during a few months of my boyhood, the 
 memory of which, should I live to be a hundred, 
 will be at my last hour as fresh in my mind as on 
 the first day. It was actually the manuscript de- 
 scribed by Sir Thomas Raleigh's librarian. It was 
 indeed the clerk Alexander's manuscript that I saw 
 before me, that I touched ! Voragine's work was 
 evidently abridged, but that was of small conse- 
 quence. The priceless additions of the monk of 
 Saint-Germain-des-Pre's were there. That was the 
 great point ! I tried to read the legend of Saint 
 Droctoveus, but it was in vain. All the lines were 
 blurred before my eyes, and my ears rang with 
 the sound of a mill-wheel at night in the country. 
 I saw, however, that the manuscript offered points 
 of the most undeniable authenticity. The two 
 drawings of the Purification of the Virgin and the 
 Crowning of Proserpine were weak in design and 
 crude in color. Greatly damaged in 1824, as the 
 catalogue of Sir Thomas states, they had since then 
 regained their freshness. But this miracle was not 
 surprising to me. And, besides, what did I care for 
 the two miniatures? The legends and the poem of 
 Alexander were the treasures ! I took in as much 
 of it as my eyes could see. 
 
 I affected an indifferent manner, and asked Si- 
 gnor Rafael the price of the manuscript, inwardly 
 praying, while I waited his reply, that the figures 
 would not be beyond my small savings, which
 
 62 THE CRIME OF 
 
 already had been greatly diminished by my expen- 
 sive journey. Signer Polizzi replied that he could 
 not sell the manuscript because it did not belong to 
 him. This, with other manuscripts and a few in- 
 cunabula, was to be put up at auction in the HStel 
 des Ventes. 
 
 It was a cruel blow to me. I strove to hide my 
 feelings, and answered somewhat in this way, 
 
 " You greatly surprise me, monsieur. Your father, 
 whom I have recently seen at Girgenti, told me that 
 you were the possessor of this manuscript. You 
 surely do not want to make me doubt your father's 
 word." 
 
 "I was," Rafael replied with perfect sincerity; 
 " but it is no longer mine. That manuscript, the 
 great value of which has not escaped you, I sold 
 to a private collector whose name I am forbidden to 
 mention, and who, for reasons which I must also 
 decline to state, is obliged to dispose of his collec- 
 tion. Honored by the confidence of my client, I am 
 ordered by him to arrange the catalogue and direct 
 the sale, which will take place the twenty-fourth of 
 next December. If you care to leave your address, 
 I will take pleasure in sending you the catalogue, 
 which is now in press, and in which you will find 
 ' The Golden Legend ' described under No. 42." 
 
 I gave him my address and left. 
 
 I was as disagreeably impressed by this man's calm 
 dignity as by his father's impudent mummery. From 
 the bottom of my soul I detested the tricks of these 
 wretched traffickers. It was clear to me that the 
 two scoundrels were in league, and that they had
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 63 
 
 devised this auction sale merely for the sake of 
 raising to an exhorbitant price the manuscript I 
 wanted, and had secured the aid of an auctioneer so 
 as to avoid any recrimination. I was completely in 
 their hands. Even the noblest passions have one 
 serious drawback : they compel us to yield to others, 
 and thus make us become dependent. This thought 
 was deeply painful to me, but it did not rid me of 
 the wish to own the manuscript of the clerk Alex- 
 ander. Suddenly, while I was meditating, I heard 
 a driver swear; but not until I felt the pole of his 
 carriage in my ribs did I realize that I was the one 
 at whom he was angry. I stepped aside in time to 
 escape being run over ; and whom did I see through 
 the coupe' window but Madame Tre'pof, driving into 
 the street which I had just left. She had two spirited 
 horses, and a driver dressed in fur like a Russian 
 nobleman. She did not see me. She was smiling 
 to herself with that childish expression which still 
 gave her, at thirty, the charm of a girl. 
 
 " Well," said I to myself, " she is laughing, is she? 
 She must have found a new match-box." 
 
 And full of disappointment I reached the Bridges. 
 
 Ever indifferent, Time brought the twenty-fourth 
 of December with haste and without delay. I went 
 to the H6tel Bullion, and took my stand in Room 
 No. 4, at the foot of the desk where Boulouze, 
 the auctioneer, and the expert Polizzi were to con- 
 duct the sale. I saw the room fill gradually with 
 well-known faces. I shook hands with several old 
 booksellers of the quay ; but discretion, which every
 
 64 THE CRIME OF 
 
 great desire inspires in even the most confident, pre- 
 vented my explaining my unusual presence in the 
 HStel Bullion. On the contrary, I asked these gen- 
 tlemen what possible interest they could have in the 
 Polizzi auction, and I had the satisfaction of hear- 
 ing them speak of everything else but the object of 
 my desires. 
 
 The room filled slowly with interested and curi- 
 ous spectators; and at the end of half an hour the 
 auctioneer with his ivory gavel, the clerk with his 
 account-book, the expert with his catalogue, and the 
 crier provided with a wooden bowl fastened to the 
 end of a stick, filed in with the solemnity of .a peas- 
 ant funeral, and took their places on the platform. 
 
 The hall-boys stood around below the desk. The 
 officers announced that the sale was about to begin, 
 and for a moment there was partial silence. 
 
 First (at a reasonable price) was sold an ordinary 
 lot of Preces pice with miniatures. It is needless 
 to say that the latter were absolutely modern. 
 
 The insignificance of the bids encouraged the 
 crowd of second-hand bookdealers; and they mingled 
 with us, and began to grow familiar. The copper- 
 smiths came in their turn ; and while they were wait- 
 ing for the doors of an adjoining room to open, their 
 ribald jokes drowned the voice of the crier. 
 
 A magnificent manuscript of the Guerre des Juifs 
 stirred some interest. It gave rise to a long and 
 lively rivalry. 
 
 " Five thousand francs, five thousand ! " shouted 
 the crier; while the coppersmiths, filled with admira- 
 tion, kept still. Seven or eight antiphonaries went
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 65 
 
 at a low price. A huge bareheaded woman,' en- 
 couraged by the size of the volume and the low 
 bidding, secured one of the antiphonaries for thirty 
 francs. 
 
 Finally the expert Polizzi announced No. 42, 
 ' The Golden Legend," a French manuscript un- 
 published; two superb miniatures; started at three 
 thousand francs." 
 
 " Three thousand ! Three thousand ! " shouted 
 the crier. 
 
 " Three thousand ! " dryly repeated the auctioneer. 
 
 My temples throbbed ; and, as though through a 
 mist, I saw a crowd of serious faces turned toward 
 the manuscript, which a boy was carrying open 
 around the room. 
 
 " Three thousand and fifty ! " I cried. I was 
 startled at the sound of my own voice, and confused 
 at seeing, or thinking that I saw, all faces turned to- 
 ward me. 
 
 " Three thousand and fifty on the right ! " called 
 the crier, taking my bid. 
 
 " Three thousand one hundred ! " cried Signer 
 Polizzi. * 
 
 Then began a heroic duel between the expert and 
 myself. 
 
 " Three thousand five hundred ! " 
 
 " Six hundred ! " 
 
 " Seven hundred ! " 
 
 " Four thousand ! " 
 
 " Four thousand five hundred ! " 
 
 Then by an appalling jump, Signor Polizzi sud- 
 denly raised the bid to six thousand.
 
 66 THE CRIME OF 
 
 All I had at my disposal was six thousand francs. 
 For me it was the possible. I risked the impos- 
 sible. 
 
 " Six thousand one hundred ! " I shouted. 
 
 Alas ! Even the impossible did not suffice. 
 
 " Six thousand five hundred," was Signor Polizzi's 
 calm response. 
 
 I lowered my head, and sat with my mouth open, 
 daring to say neither yes nor no to the crier who 
 shouted to me, 
 
 " The bid of six thousand five hundred is mine, 
 not yours there on the right, but mine ! No mistake ! 
 Six thousand five hundred ! " 
 
 " That is understood," cried the auctioneer. " Six 
 thousand five hundred. That is clearly understood. 
 Well ? Is there no one who offers more than six 
 thousand five hundred francs?" 
 
 A solemn silence filled the room. Suddenly I 
 felt as if my head were bursting. It was the auc- 
 tioneer's hammer, which, with a quick, short tap on 
 the desk, irrevocably knocked down No. 42 to Signor 
 Polizzi. At the same time the clerk ran his pen across 
 the stamped paper, and registered the great fact in a 
 simple line. 
 
 I was absolutely crushed, and felt the necessity of 
 rest and solitude. Yet I did not leave my seat. 
 By degrees I began to think. Hope is tenacious ; 
 and I still had one hope. It occurred to me that 
 the buyer of " The Golden Legend " might be an 
 intelligent and liberal book-lover, who would let me 
 see the manuscript, and even allow me to publish 
 the more important "facts of it. Therefore, when
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 67 
 
 the sale was over, I accosted the expert who was 
 coming from the platform. 
 
 " Monsieur," said I, " did you buy No. 42 for 
 yourself, or on commission ? " 
 
 " On commission. I was ordered not to let it go 
 at any price." 
 
 " Can you tell me the name of the buyer?" 
 
 " I am very sorry to disappoint you, but that is 
 absolutely forbidden." 
 
 I turned from him in despair. 
 
 December jo, 1859. 
 
 " TheVese, don't you hear ? the bell has been ring- 
 ing for the last quarter of an hour." 
 
 The'rese does not reply. She is gossiping in the 
 lodge with the janitress. Of this I am sure. So 
 this is the way you celebrate your old master's birth- 
 day ! You leave me even on the eve of Saint-Sylves- 
 tre! Alas ! If good wishes do come to me on this 
 day, they must come out of the ground; for every- 
 thing that ever loved me has long since been 
 buried. I do not know of what use I am in the 
 world. There is the bell again ! 
 
 I leave the fireplace slowly, with stooping shoul- 
 ders, and open the door myself. Whom do I see at 
 the head of the stairs ? Not Cupid with dripping 
 wings, and I am not the old Anacreon : but I see a 
 pretty little boy of ten. He is alone. He raises his 
 head, and looks at me. His cheeks are rosy, but 
 his little saucy nose has a roguish expression. He 
 has feathers in his cap, and a great ruff of lace on 
 his blouse. Such a pretty little fellow ! In his arm
 
 68 THE CRIME OF 
 
 he carries a package as big as himself. He asks 
 if I am Monsieur Sylvestre Bonnard ; and upon my 
 saying that I am, he hands me the package, which 
 he says is from his mamma ; then he darts down- 
 stairs. 
 
 I descend a few steps, and leaning over the bal- 
 usters I see the little fellow flying around the spiral 
 staircase like a feather in the breeze. " Hallo ! my 
 little boy ! " I should have been so glad to speak 
 to him. But what should I have asked him? It is 
 not nice to ply children with questions. Besides, 
 the package will probably tell me more than the 
 messenger. It is a very large package, but not 
 very heavy. Returning to my library, I remove its 
 ribbons and wrappings, and find what ? A log, 
 a great log, a real Christmas log, but so light that 
 I conclude it must be hollow. In fact, I discover 
 that it consists of two pieces fastened together by 
 clasps, and opening on hinges. Pushing back the 
 clasps, I am suddenly inundated with violets ! My 
 table, my knees, the carpet, are covered with them. 
 They pour into my waistcoat, and into my sleeves. 
 I am all perfumed by them ! 
 
 " The*rese ! Thdrese ! Fill some vases with water 
 and bring them to me ! Here are some violets, 
 come I know not from what country or by what 
 hand ; but it must be a sweet country, and a gentle 
 hand. Old crow, don't you hear me?" 
 
 I have put the violets on my table, which is com- 
 pletely hidden beneath their fragrant masses. 
 
 But, there is something else in the log, a book, a 
 manuscript. It is I can scarcely believe my eyes,
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 69 
 
 yet there it is " The Golden Legend," the manu- 
 script of the clerk Alexander. Here is the Purifica- 
 tion of the Virgin, and the Crowning of Proserpine, 
 and the legend of Saint Droctoveus. I gaze at the 
 relic, which is sweet with the odor of the violets. I 
 I turn over the leaves, between which some of the 
 demure little blossoms have found their way, and 
 opposite the legend of Saint Cecilia, I find a card 
 bearing this name : 
 
 PRINCESS TKPOF. 
 
 Princess Trdpof ! You, who laughed and cried by 
 turn -so prettily under the lovely sky of Agrigentum 
 you, whom a crabbed old man took for a little 
 simpleton, have convinced me to-day of your rare 
 and beautiful folly ; and the man whom you over- 
 whelm with joy will go and kiss your hand, and 
 offer you an edition of this precious manuscript 
 in such an accurate and sumptuous form as will 
 satisfy both science and himself. 
 
 Just then TheVese, in a great state of agitation, 
 came hurrying into my library. 
 
 "Monsieur," she cried, "guess whom I have just 
 seen at the door, in a carriage bearing a coatof- 
 arms ? " 
 
 " Madame Tre'pof," I cried. 
 
 " I have no idea who Madame Trepof is," replied 
 my housekeeper. "The lady I saw just now was 
 dressed like a duchess. She had with her a little 
 boy whose clothes were all trimmed with lace. And 
 it was that little Madame Coccoz to whom you sent
 
 70 THE CRIME OF 
 
 a log when she was confined eleven years ago. I 
 recognized her instantly." 
 
 " Madame Coccoz ! " I exclaimed quickly ; " the 
 almanac peddler's widow ? You don't say so ! " 
 
 " The very same, monsieur. The coach-door was 
 wide open as her little boy was getting into the car- 
 riage where he had come from I'm sure I don't 
 know. She has changed scarcely any. And why 
 should such women grow old ? They have no cares 
 at all. Madame Coccoz is merely somewhat stouter 
 than formerly. The idea of a woman who was re- 
 ceived here out of charity coming to display her 
 velvet and diamonds in a carriage with her coat- 
 of-arms on it ! Is it not shameful ? " 
 
 " The'rese ! " I cried in a voice of thunder, " if you 
 speak of this lady in any but terms of the highest 
 respect, we shall quarrel. Bring me my Sevres vases 
 for these violets. They give to this City of Books a 
 charm it has never had before." 
 
 While The'rese with heavy sighs went for the 
 Sevres vases, I looked at the beautiful violets which 
 lay about me, spreading their perfume around like 
 the sweetness of some gentle soul, and I asked my- 
 self how I could have failed to recognize Madame 
 Coccoz in the Princess Tre'pof. But the young 
 widow who held out her little naked child to me 
 on the stairway had been but a fleeting vision. I 
 had much greater cause to reproach myself for hav- 
 ing passed by a kind and beautiful heart without 
 discovering it. 
 
 " Bonnard," I said to myself, " you know how to 
 decipher ancient texts, but you are utterly incapa-
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. J\ 
 
 ble of reading the Book of Life. . This giddy little 
 Madame Tre'pof, who you believed had no more 
 heart than a bird, has in her gratitude displayed 
 more spirit and energy than you have ever shown 
 for the sake of obliging any one. She has royally 
 repaid you for the log you sent her that day when 
 her child was born. 
 
 " The'rese, you were a magpie, but you are turn- 
 ing into a tortoise. Do come, and bring me some 
 water for these Parma violets ! "
 
 PART II. 
 CLEMENTINE'S DAUGHTER.
 
 THE FAIRY. 
 
 WHEN I left the train at the Melun station, 
 night was spreading her peace over the silent landJ 
 all day long by the blazing 
 
 the "broad sun" (gras soleil), as the expression 
 is among the harvesters of the Valley of Vire, ex- 
 haled a warm, pungent odor. A breath, laden with 
 the heavy perfume ofjjrasses, now and again swept 
 along the ground. Jl brushed off the dust of the 
 car, and exultingly drew in a deep breath. My 
 travelling-bag, which my housekeeper had packed 
 with linen and various toilet articles, Horace's tnun- 
 ditiis, weighed so little in my hand, that I swung it 
 back and forth as a boy just out of school swings 
 his strap full of class-books. 
 
 Would to Heaven I were still a little school-boy ! 
 Hut fifty years have passed since my good mother, 
 with her own hands, made me a plum tart, which 
 she put into a basket, the handle of which she 
 slipped over my arm. Thus fortified, I was taken 
 to the school kept by Monsieur Uouloir, in a house 
 that stood between a court and a garden, in a cor- 
 ner of the Passage du Commerce well-known to the 
 sparrows. 
 
 Monsieur Douloir was a huge man, who smiled 
 at us in a pleasant way, and patted my cheek, in 
 75
 
 76 THE CRIME OF 
 
 order, no doubt, the better to express the affection 
 which I immediately inspired v 'in him. But no 
 sooner had my mother crossed the court, startling 
 the sparrows as she went, than Monsieur Dou- 
 loir ceased to smile on me, and showed me no 
 further marks of attention. On the contrary, he 
 seemed to consider me a very troublesome little 
 fellow, and very much in the way. I afterwards 
 discovered that he cherished similar feelings for all 
 his pupils. He distributed ferulings with an agility 
 which one would not have expected in a man of his 
 excessive corpulence. But his early affection showed 
 itself whenever he spoke to our mothers in our 
 presence. Then he would praise our beautiful dis- 
 positions, and at the same time look down at us 
 with affection ; yet those were indeed happy days 
 that we spent on the benches at Monsieur Douloirs, 
 with the little maids, who, like myself, laughed and 
 cried by turn, with their whole heart, from morning 
 to night. 
 
 After half a century, these memories come fresh 
 and clear to the surface of my mind, under this 
 starry sky, which is forever the same. Undoubtedly 
 those calm and steady lights will look down on other 
 school-children such as I was, and see them grow 
 into men like myself, gray-haired, and subject to 
 catarrh. 
 
 Stars that have shone on eacn frivolous or serious 
 head among all my forgotten ancestors, your bright- 
 ness has caused me to feel a pang of keen regret ! 
 I would that I had a son who, when I no longer 
 could behold you, might still gaze up at you. How
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 77 
 
 I should love him ! Ah ! he would now what am 
 I saying ? he would now be twenty years old, had 
 you so willed it, Clementine you whose cheeks 
 were so fresh beneath your rosy hood ! 
 
 But you married a clerk in a bank, that same 
 Noel Alexandre, who afterwards made so many 
 millions. I have not seen you since your marriage, 
 Clementine ; yet I always think of you with your 
 golden xurls and your rosy hood. 
 
 A mirror ! A mirror ! Give me a mirror ! I 
 should like to see how I look now with my white 
 locks, breathing the name of Clementine to the 
 stars. However, it is not well to end ironically that 
 which one has begun in a spirit of faith and love. 
 Cldmentine, if your name came to my lips this 
 beautiful night, may it be blessed ; and may you, a 
 happy mother, a happy grandmother, enjoy to the 
 very end, with your opulent husband, the bliss which 
 you thought, as you had the right to think, you could 
 not have with the poor young scholar who loved 
 you! If, although I cannot imagine it, your hair 
 has grown white, Clementine, carry with dignity 
 the bunch of keys intrusted to you by Noel Alex- 
 andre, and teach your grandchildren the sweet do- 
 mestic, virtues ! 
 
 RVhat a beautiful night ! She reigns with languor- 
 ous gentleness over man and beast, freed from the 
 daily yoke; and I feel her kindly influence, though 
 from habit confirmed by sixty years. I no longer 
 feel things except by the signs which represent 
 them. There is for me in this world nothing but 
 words, such a philologist have I become. Kach
 
 78 THE CRIME OF 
 
 in his own way dreams the dream of life. I have 
 dreamed mine in 'my library ; and when the hour 
 comes for me to depart from this world, may the 
 good God take me as I stand on my ladder beforo 
 my shelves of books-! 
 
 " Why, yes, here is the man himself ! Good- 
 evening, Monsieur Sylvestre Bonnard ! Where are 
 you going, tramping over the country with your 
 light step, while I have been waiting for you at the 
 station with my carriage ? I missed you when the 
 train went out, and I was on my way back to 
 Lusance. Give me your valise, and get into the 
 carriage here beside me. Do you know it is seven 
 good kilometers from here to the chateau ! " 
 
 Who is calling to me thus in a loud voice from his 
 high-seated carriage ? Monsieur Paul de Gabry, 
 nephew and heir of Monsieur Honore" de Gabry, 
 peer of France in 1842, who recently died at Mo- 
 naco. And I was on my way to Monsieur Paul de 
 Gabry's, with my valise which my housekeeper had 
 packed. This excellent young fellow, conjointly with 
 his two brothers-in-law, had just come into posses- 
 sion of the property. The uncle, the descendant of 
 a very ancient and distinguished family of jurists, 
 had preserved, in his chateau at Lusance, a library, 
 rich in manuscripts, some of which dated back to 
 the fourteenth century. And I had come to Lu- 
 sance, in order to make an inventory and catalogue 
 of these manuscripts, at the urgent invitation of 
 Monsieur Paul de Gabry, whose father, a man of 
 honor and a distinguished bibliophile, had during
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNAKD. 79 
 
 his lifetime been on friendly terms with me. Truth 
 to tell, the son has not inherited his father's refined 
 tastes. Monsieur Paul is devoted to all kinds of 
 sport ; he thoroughly understands horses and dogs ; 
 and I believe, that of all the sciences suited to sa- 
 tiate or deceive the inexhaustible curiosity of man, 
 those of the stable and the kennel are the only ones 
 of which he is masterj! 
 
 I cannot say that I was surprised to meet him, 
 since I had an appointment with him ; but I con- 
 fess that, carried away by the natural trend of my 
 thoughts, I had forgotten the Chateau of Lusance 
 and its owners ; so that when a country gentleman 
 called out to me, just as I was starting down the 
 road, which unwound before me like un bon rttban 
 de queue, as they say, his voice fell on my ears at 
 first like an unaccustomed sound. 
 
 I have reason to fear that my physiognomy showed 
 my absent-mindedness by a certain expression of stu- 
 pidity, which it assumes in most of my social trans- 
 actions. My valise found a^ place in the carriage, 
 and I followed my valise. My host pleased me by 
 his _f rank and simple manner. 
 
 f "I know nothing about your old parchments," said 
 he, " but you will find some companionable people 
 at our house. Without counting the curate, who 
 writes, and the physician, who is very likable, 
 though a radical, you will find one who will keep 
 pace with you. I mean my wife. She is not very 
 learned, but I think there is nothing which she does 
 not get at the heart of. I hope to keep you long 
 enough so that you may meet Mademoiselle Jeanne; 
 
 '
 
 SO THE CRIME OF 
 
 she has the fingers of a magician and the spirit of 
 an angel." 
 
 " Is this gifted young lady," I asked, " a member 
 of your family? " 
 
 "No, indeed," replied Monsieur Paul. 
 
 " A friend, then, I presume ? " I asked, inanely 
 enough. 
 
 " She is an orphan, without father or mother," 
 replied Monsieur de Gabry, with his eyes fixed on 
 his horse's ears, while the hoof-beats resounded on 
 the hard road, that gleamed blue in the moonlight. 
 " Her father involved us in great trouble, and we 
 got out of it ; but it cost us much more than mere 
 fear." 
 
 Then he shook his head, and changed the sub- 
 ject. He warned me of the state of decay in which 
 I should find the park and the chateau. They had 
 been absolutely deserted for thirty-two years. / 
 
 I learned from him that Monsieur Honore" de 
 Gabry, his uncle, had been, during his lifetime, on 
 bad terms with the poachers of the country, and 
 had shot at them as if they were rabbits. One of 
 them, a vindictive peasant who had received a 
 charge of shot full in the face, one night lay in wait 
 for the seigneur, behind the trees along the mall, 
 and almost killed him, for he scored the tip of his 
 ear with a bullet. 
 
 " My uncle," added Monsieur Paul, " tried to dis- 
 cover who fired the shot, but he could not make out, 
 and he returned to the chateau without hurrying. 
 The following day he called his steward, told him 
 to close the manor and the park, and not to allow a
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 8 1 
 
 living soul to enter. He expressly forbade anything 
 to be touched, repaired, or kept in order on the es- 
 tate, or in his home, until his return. He added, 
 between his teeth, that he would return at Easter or 
 Trinity, as in the song; and, as in the song, Trinity 
 passed, and he was not seen. He died last year, at 
 Monaco ; and my brother-in-law and I were the first 
 to enter the chateau since it was abandoned, more 
 than thirty-two years ago. We found a chestnut- 
 tree growing in the middle of the drawing-room, 
 the park is still inaccessible for lack of paths." 
 companion grew silent. Nothing was heard 
 save the regular trot of the horse, and the hum of 
 the insects in the grass. In the fields, on both sides 
 of the road, the rows of sheaves, with the uncertain 
 moonlight falling on them, looked like tall white 
 women kneeling. Like a child I gave myself up to 
 the wonderful fascinations of the magic night. \ We 
 passed under the thick shadows of the mall, and 
 turning at right angles, our carriage rolled along a 
 magnificent avenue, at the end of which the chateau 
 suddenly appeared in all its massive blackness, with 
 its pepper-box towers. We followed a sort of cause- 
 way, which led to the court-of-honor, and which 
 passed over a moat filled with running water, tak- 
 ing the place, no doubt, of a drawbridge long since 
 destroyed.] The loss of the drawbridge was, I 
 think, tKe first humiliation to which the warlike 
 manor had to submit before it was finally reduced 
 to the peaceful conditions under which it welcomed 
 me. 
 {"The stars were reflected with marvellous clearness
 
 82 THE CRIME OF 
 
 in the dark water. .Monsieur Paul, being a most 
 courteous host, escorted me to my room, which was 
 in the top of the chateau, at the end of a long corri- 
 dor. Then apologizing, on account of the lateness 
 of the hour, for not presenting me at once to his 
 wife, he bade me good-night. 
 
 My chamber, painted white and hung with chintz, 
 bore traces of the sprightly grace characteristic of 
 the eighteenth century. Still glowing embers filled 
 the fireplace, and made me feel what pains had 
 been taken to dispel all dampness from the room. 
 On the mantel-piece stood a bisque bust of Queen 
 Marie Antoinette. On the white frame of the dark 
 and specked glass, two brass hooks, which once had 
 held ladies' chatelaines, offered a fitting place for 
 my watch, which I was careful to wind. For, con- 
 trary to the maxims of Thelemites, I think that man 
 is master of Time, which is Life itself, only when he 
 has divided it into hours, minutes, and seconds ; that 
 is to say, into spaces proportioned to the brevity of 
 human existence. 
 
 And I thought that life seems short to us only 
 because we foolishly measure it by our irrational 
 hopes. All of us, like the old man in the fable, 
 have a wing to add to the house we are building. I 
 want to finish, before I die, the " History of the 
 Abbots of Saint-Germain-des-Pre's." The time that 
 God gives to each of us is like a precious tissue, 
 which we are to embroider to the best of our abil- 
 ity. I have worked my woof with every kind of 
 philological design. 
 
 Thus my thoughts wandered on ; and in tying my
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 83 
 
 silk Handkerchief about my head, the idea of time 
 took me back to the past ; and for the second time 
 in the turn of the dial, I thought of you, Clementine, 
 and blessed you in your posterity, if you have any, 
 before I blew out my candle, and fell asleep to the 
 songs of the. frogs, i 
 
 II. 
 
 During breakfast I had many opportunities of 
 gaining a high idea of Madame de Gabry's taste, 
 tact, and intelligence. She told me how the chateau 
 was haunted by ghosts, and especially by the lady 
 " with the three wrinkles in her back," who in her 
 lifetime had poisoned people, and whose soul was 
 now doomed to eternal torment. I cannot describe 
 the spirit and vivacity which she infused into the tell- 
 ing of this old nurse's tale. We drank our coffee 
 on the terrace, the balusters of which, grasped and 
 torn from their stone railing by a lusty ivy, were held 
 between the knots of the wanton plant in the hope- 
 less attitude of the Athenian women in the arms of 
 wicked Centaurs. 
 
 The chateau was built in the form of a four- 
 wheeled cart, re-enforced by a tower at each corner ; 
 but it had been repaired so many times that it had 
 lost all its originality. It was a roomy, dignified 
 structure nothing more. It did not strike me as 
 having suffered much damage during its thirty-two 
 years of abandonment; but when Madame de Gabry 
 showed me the large drawing-room on the ground- 
 floor, I perceived that the flooring was heaved up,
 
 84 THE CRIME OF 
 
 the plinths rotten, the woodwork cracked, the paint- 
 ings of the piers turned black and three-quarters 
 out of their frames. A chestnut-tree had pushed 
 .through the flooring, and was growing there, its 
 broad leaves turned toward the glassless window. 
 Although the sight had a charm for me, yet 1 
 viewed it with anxiety, when I thought how Mon- 
 sieur Honore* de Gabry's rich library in the adjoin- 
 ing room had been exposed for so long to these 
 destroying influences. But as I looked at the young 
 chestnut-tree in the drawing-room, I could not help 
 admiring the magnificent force of Nature, and that 
 irresistible power which pushes every germ toward 
 the development of life. On the other hand, I grew 
 sad when I thought how painful, and yet fruitless, 
 is the effort which we scholars make to keep and 
 preserve anything that is dead. Whatever has 
 lived is a necessary aliment for new life. The 
 Arab who builds himself a hut with marble from 
 the temples of Palmyra is a greater philosopher 
 than all the guardians of the museums in London, 
 Paris, and Munich. 
 
 August ii. 
 
 Thank God, the library, situated toward the east, 
 has not suffered irreparable damage. Except the 
 shelf containing the heavy folio volumes of old 
 cotitumiers, which the mice have riddled, the books 
 are untouched in their grated cases. 
 
 I have been spending the whole day in classifying 
 manuscripts. The sun came in through the high, 
 curtainless windows; and in the midst of my read-
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 85 
 
 ing, which at times was very interesting, I heard 
 the drowsy bumblebees striking heavily against the 
 window-panes, the cracking of the woodwork, and 
 the flies, blinded with light and heat, buzzing in 
 circles about my head. Towards three o'clock their 
 buzzing became so loud that I raised my head from 
 a document that was of great value for the history 
 of Melun in the thirteenth century, and I began to 
 watch the concentric movements of these little ani- 
 mals, or bestions as they are called by Lafontaine, 
 who found the term in the old popular idiom whence 
 comes the expression " tapestry d bestions" that is, 
 tapestry with little figures on it. I had to confess 
 that heat affects the wings of a fly in a very differ- 
 ent manner from what it does the brain of a stu- 
 dent of old manuscripts; for I found it very hard 
 to think, and fell into a pleasant revery, from which 
 I had difficulty in rousing myself. | The dinner-bell 
 surprised me in the midst of my labors; and I had 
 just time to slip on my new coat, so as to appear 
 respectable in Madame de Gabry's eyes. 
 
 The meal, which consisted of several courses, was 
 naturally long. As a connoisseur of wine, I have a 
 talent perhaps above the average. My host, who 
 soon discovered the extent of my knowledge, was 
 gracious enough to uncork for me a bottle of Cha- 
 teau- Margaux of the genuine vintage of Bordeaux. 
 With real reverence I drank this wine, so royal in 
 its origin, so noble in its flavor, with a bouquet and 
 fire beyond all praise. This glowing liquid infused 
 itself into my veins, and awakened in me the spark 
 of youth. Seated on the terrace with Madame de
 
 86 THE CRIME OF 
 
 Gabry, in the twilight which now spread a soft mel- 
 ancholy over the trees of the park, and bathed even 
 the smallest objects in a mysterious light, I had the 
 pleasure of telling my lively hostess my impressions, 
 with a vivacity and fluency most remarkable in a 
 man like me, devoid of all imagination. 
 
 I described to her'spontaneously, and without the 
 help of a single old quotation, the soft melancholy 
 of the twilight, and the beauty of the mother-earth 
 that nourishes us, not only by bread and wine, but 
 by ideas, feelings, and beliefs, and which will re- 
 ceive us again into her maternal bosom, as if we 
 were little children wearied after a long day. 
 
 " Monsieur," said this good lady, " look at these 
 old towers, these trees, this sky. How naturally the 
 heroes of stories and songs came from them all ! 
 Over there is the path by which little Red Riding 
 Hood went to the woods to gather nuts. This ever- 
 changing and half-veiled sky was marked by fairy 
 chariots, and the northern tower might have hidden 
 at one time beneath its painted roof the old dame 
 whose spindle pricked the Sleeping Beauty of the 
 woods." 
 
 I was still thinking of these pretty fancies, while 
 Monsieur Paul puffed a strong cigar, and told me 
 about some action which he had brought against 
 the commune concerning a water-privilege. Madame 
 de Gabry, feeling the evening dampness, shivered, 
 though her husband had thrown a shawl over her 
 shoulders, and left us to go to her room. 
 
 I then determined that instead of going to mine, 
 I would return to the library, and continue my ex-
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 
 
 8 9 
 
 amination of the manuscripts. So, in spite of Mo ac 
 sieur Paul's protest, I went to what, in old-fashionee 1 
 language, I shall call the librairie, or book-room, ' 
 and set to work by lamp-light. 
 
 After I had read fifteen pages, which iiad evi- 
 dently been written by an ignorant and careless 
 clerk, for I experienced some difficulty in making 
 out their meaning, I plunged my hand into the open 
 pocket of my coat to get my snuff-box ; but this or- 
 dinary and, as it were, instinctive movement, this 
 time cost me some effort and fatigue. Neverthe- 
 less, I opened the silver box, and took out a pinch 
 of the odorous powder, spilling it all down my shirt- 
 front under my baffled nose. 
 
 I am sure that my nose showed its disappoint- 
 ment, for it is a very expressive nose. Many times 
 it has betrayed my innermost thoughts, and espe- 
 cially in the public library of Coutances, where, 
 under the very beard of iry colleague Brioux, I dis- 
 covered the " Cartulary of Notre-Dame-des-Anges." 
 How great was my joy ! My small, dull eyes, 
 screened by their glasses, did not betray me. But 
 at the mere sight of my broad pug-nose, trembling 
 with joy and pride, Brioux surmised that I had 
 found a treasure-trove. He saw the volume which 
 I held, noted the shelf where I replaced it, took it 
 down as soon as I had gone, copied it secretly, and 
 published it without delay, in order to play me a 
 turn. But the edition swarms with blunders, and 
 I had the satisfaction of criticising several of his 
 gross mistakes. 
 
 But to resume. I suspected that a heavy stupor
 
 86; THE CRIME OF 
 
 G?as weighing upon my mind. ^ I was looking at a 
 ajhar't, the interest of which every one can appreciate 
 when I say that mention is made in it of a rabbit- 
 hutch sold to Jehan d'Estouville, priest, in 1312. 
 But although I realized at the time its great value, 
 I did not pay it the attention that such a document 
 deserved. In spite of all my efforts, my eyes kept 
 turning to one side of the table where there was 
 nothing important as far as learning was concerned. 
 There was merely a great German volume there, 
 bound in pig-skin, with brass studs on the sides, 
 and heavy raised bands at the back. It was a fine 
 example of that compilation so well known under 
 the name of " Cosmography of Munster," valuable 
 merely on account of the wood engravings with 
 which it is adorned. The volume, with its covers 
 somewhat spread apart, stood face down on its 
 edge. 
 
 I could not say how long I had been gazing with- 
 out any apparent reason on this sixteenth century 
 folio, when my eyes were attracted by a sight so 
 unusual, that even a man totally devoid of imagina- 
 tion, like myself, would have been very much startled 
 by it. 
 
 Suddenly I noticed, though I had not seen any 
 one come into the room, a diminutive young woman, 
 seated on the back of the book, with one knee folded 
 under her, the other leg hanging down in almost the 
 same position as that taken by the Amazonian 
 horseback riders in Hyde Park or in the Bois du 
 Boulogne. She was so small that her swinging foot 
 did not reach the table, on which lay the train of
 
 SYLVESTRE BOXNARD. 89 
 
 her gown in a serpentine line. She had the face 
 and figure of a well-developed woman. Her full 
 bust and ample waist left no doubt on this point, 
 even to the mind of an old scholar like myself. 1 
 
 I may add, without fear of being mistaken, that 
 she was very beautiful and of proud mien ; for my 
 iconographic studies have long since accustomed me 
 to recognize the purity of a type and the character of 
 a physiognomy. The face of this lady, who had so 
 unexpectedly seated herself on the back of a " Cos- 
 mography of Munster," expressed a noble pride, 
 mingled with waywardness. ^She had the air of a 
 queen, but of a whimsical queen ; and I judged from 
 the glance of her eye that somewhere she exercised 
 great authority in a very capricious waj 
 
 There was a proud and ironical expression about 
 her mouth, and a disquieting smile gleamed in her 
 blue eyes, under her delicately arched black browsj 
 
 I have always understood that black eyebrows 
 are very becoming to blondes, and this lady was 
 very blond. In short, the impression she gave was 
 one of greatness. 
 
 It may seem strange that a person no taller than 
 a bottle, and whom I might have hidden in my coat- 
 pocket if it had not been disrespectful to put her 
 there, should give one the idea of greatness. But 
 in the proportions of the lady seated on the " Cos- 
 mography of Munster," there was such a proud 
 daintiness, such a dignified harmony, her attitude 
 was at once so easy and so noble, that she seemed 
 great to me. And she was great, and imposing too, 
 in her sprightliness; although my inkstand, which
 
 90 THE CRIME OF 
 
 she gazed at with an ironical attention, as if she 
 could read in advance every word that would come 
 from the end of my pen, was for her a deep ba- 
 sin, in which she would have got her pink silk 
 stockings, with their yellow clocks, black up to the 
 garters. 
 
 \13er costume, suited to her style, was very rich.! 
 It consisted of a robe of gold and silver brocade^ 
 and a cloak of nacarat velvet, lined with small vair. 
 Her coiffure was a sort of hennin, with two horns; 
 and pearls of beautiful water made it gleam as bright 
 as the crescent moon. (TiTher small white hand she 
 held a wand. This wand attracted my attention all 
 the more strongly for the reason that my archaeo- 
 logical studies had taught me to recognize with some 
 certainty the signs by which the noted characters 
 of legend and of history are distinguished. This 
 knowledge came to my mind in the midst of the 
 strange conjectures I was making. 
 
 I looked at the wand, which seemed to me to 
 have been cut from a hazel branch. 
 
 " It is a fairy wand," I said to myself, "and con- 
 sequently the lady who holds it is a fairy." 
 
 Happy at thus recognizing the lady who sat be- 
 fore me, I strove to collect my ideas, and pay her 
 a respectful compliment._j I should have felt some 
 satisfaction, I confess, in speaking to her in a 
 learned way of the part played by her compeers, 
 both among the Saxon and Germanic races, and in 
 the Latin Occident. Such a dissertation was, to my 
 thinking, an ingenious way of thanking this lady for 
 having appeared before an old scholar, contrary to
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 9! 
 
 the usual custom of her people, who show themselves 
 only to innocent children and ignorant villagers. 
 I Being a fairy does not make one any less a woman, 
 I said to myself ; and since Madame Rdcamier, if I 
 may credit J. J. Ampere, used to blush with pleas- 
 ure when the little chimney-sweeps opened their eyes 
 wide in order to see her as well as they could, the 
 supernatural little lady seated on the " Cosmography 
 of Munster" would no doubt feel flattered to hear a 
 scholar discoursing in a learned manner about her, 
 as if she were a medal, a seal, a buckle, or a token. 
 
 But such a venture, which was a trial to a man 
 like myself, became entirely out of the question when 
 I beheld the lady of the " Cosmography " quickly 
 draw from a purse at her side some nuts, smaller 
 than any I had ever seen, crack them between her 
 teeth, and throw the shells into my face^while she 
 craunched the kernels with the seriousness of a nurs- 
 iog_c_hild. 
 
 , Under such circumstances, I did what the dignity 
 of science demanded, I was silent. But as the 
 shells tickled me disagreeably, I raised my hand to 
 my nose, and to my great surprise found that my 
 spectacles were straddling the end of it, and that I 
 was looking at the lady, not through them, but over 
 them ; a most incomprehensible thing, because my 
 eyes, weakened by work on old manuscripts, could 
 not, without the aid of spectacles, distinguish a 
 melon from a carafe, even if both were held directly 
 in front of my nose. 
 
 This nose, remarkable on account of its size, 
 shape, and color, naturally attracted the attention of
 
 92 THE CRIME OF 
 
 the fairy ; for she seized my goose-quill, which rcse 
 from the ink-well like a plume, and tickled my nose 
 with the feather end of it] 
 
 I have had in society, now and then, occasion to 
 become a cheerful victim to the innocent pranks of 
 young girls, who, drawing me into their games, of- 
 fered me their cheeks to kiss through the back of a 
 chair, or asked me to blow out a candle which they 
 immediately raised out of the reach of my breath. 
 But until then no one of the fair sex had ever sub- 
 jected me to such a familiar trick as tickling my 
 nose with the feathers of my own pen. 
 
 Happily I recalled a maxim of my late grand- 
 father, who had a habit of saying that everything 
 is allowed to the ladies, and that anything that they 
 do is a favor and a compliment. Therefore I re- 
 ceived the nut-shells and the feathers of my pen as 
 if they were favors and compliments, and I strove 
 to smjje. More than this ! I spoke 
 
 r Madame," I said, with dignified courtesy, "the 
 honor of your visit you confer on no child or peas- 
 ant, but on a book-lover, who is happy indeed to 
 make your acquaintance^ a d who knows that in 
 days gone by you used to entangle the manes and 
 tailg of mares in their cribs, and to drink the milk 
 from foaming bowls, to pour prickly burs down the 
 backs of our great-grandmothers, to make the hearth 
 snap sparks into the faces of worthy people, and, in 
 a word, to fill the house with confusion and merri- 
 ment. Moreover, you can boast of having, at night 
 in the wpods, given belated couples many a good 
 fright ! I But I thought you had vanished at least
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 93 
 
 three centuries ago. Is it possible, madame, that 
 you are seen in these days of railways and tele- 
 graphs? My janitress, who in her day was a nurse, 
 does not know your story ; and my little neighbor, 
 still in his nurse's care, says that you no longer 
 exist." 
 
 " What do you say about it ? " cried she, in a sil- 
 very voice, drawing up her royal little person in a 
 cavalier-like manner, and beating the back of the 
 " Cosmography of Munster " as if it had been a 
 hippogriffe. 
 
 " I do not know," I answered, rubbing my eyes. 
 
 This reply, stamped with a profoundly scientific 
 scepticism, produced the most deplorable effect on 
 my visitor. 
 
 "Monsieur Sylvestre Bonnard," said she, "you 
 are nothing but a pedant. I have always suspected 
 it. The smallest of the little urchins who go along 
 the street with their shirts sticking out of their, 
 ragged trousers knows me better than all the spec- 
 tacled people of your institutes and your academies. 
 Knowledge is nothing, imagination is everything. 
 Nothing exists except what we imagine. I am im- 
 aginary, and that is living ! People dream of me, 
 and I appear ! Everything is but a dream ; and 
 since no one dreams of you, Sylvestre Bonnard, you 
 do not exist. I delight the world. I am every- 
 where, on a moonbeam, in the ripple of a hidden 
 spring, in the moving foliage that sings, in the white 
 vapors rising every morning from the wilds of the 
 meadows, among the pink heath, everywhere ! I 
 am seen, I am loved. There are sighing, there
 
 94 THE CRIME OF 
 
 are trembling hearts wherever my light footsteps 
 fall, causing the dead leaves to sing. I make little 
 children smile, I give humor to the dullest-minded 
 nurses. Stooping over cradles, I tease, I console, 
 I lull to sleep, and you are in doubt as to my exis- 
 tence ! Sylvester Bonnard, your warm-lined coat 
 covers the hide of an ass ! " 
 
 She became silent. Her delicate nostrils quiv- 
 ered with indignation ; and while, in spite of my vex- 
 ation, I was admiring the noble anger of this little 
 creature, she dipped my pen in the ink-well, as one 
 would an oar in a lake, and threw it at my nose, the 
 point foremost. 
 
 I rubbed my face, and felt that it was covered 
 with ink. She had vanished from sight. My lamp 
 had gone out. A moonbeam had stolen down the 
 window-pane, and lay upon the " Cosmography of 
 Munster." A cool breeze, which had risen without 
 my perceiving it, was blowing away pens, papers, 
 and wafers. My table was covered with ink. I 
 had left my window partly open during the storm. 
 How imprudent 
 
 in. 
 
 I wrote to my housekeeper, as I promised, that 
 I was well and happy. I was very careful not to 
 mention the head cold which I caught from having 
 slept that evening in the library with the window 
 open, for the good woman would have been no more 
 sparing of remonstrances than are parliaments to 
 kings.
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 95 
 
 " To be so careless at your age, monsieur . " she 
 would have said. She is simple enough to think 
 that sense increases with years. I seem to her an 
 exception to the rule. Not having the same reasons 
 for withholding my experience from Madame de 
 Gabry, I told her all the details of my dream, in 
 which she took great interest. 
 
 " Your dream," said she, " is charming. One 
 must have real cleverness to have such visions ! " 
 
 " You mean that I am clever when I am asleep," 
 I said. 
 
 " When you dream," she replied ; " and you are 
 always dreaming ! " 
 
 I know very well that in speaking thus Madame 
 de Gabry had no thought other than to make me 
 happy, but her intention deserves my warmest 
 thanks. It is with a deep sense of gratitude and 
 kindly remembrance that I copy down her words 
 in my diary ; and I shall always feel the same when 
 I read them over and over, until I die, but no one 
 be&ides myself shall read them. 
 
 //I spent the following days in completing the in- 
 ventory of the manuscripts in the library of Lusance. 
 A few confidential words which escaped Monsieur 
 Paul de Gabry caused me painful surprise, and 
 made me determined to carry on my work in a dif- 
 ferent manner from that in which I had begun it. 
 From those few words, I learned that Monsieur Ho- 
 nore* de Gabry's property had been badly managed 
 for years, and to a great measure lost by the failure 
 of a banker, whose name I do not know, and that 
 the old French nobleman's heirs received nothing
 
 96 THE CRIME OF 
 
 from 5t except hypotheticated real estate and uncol- 
 lectable accounts. 
 
 Monsieur Paul, by agreement with his joint heirs, 
 had decided to sell the library ; and I was commis- 
 sioned to arrange for the sale on the most advan- 
 tageous terms. But, as I am wholly unacquainted 
 with the methods of business and trade, I resolved 
 to ask the advice of a friend of mine, who is a book- 
 seller. I wrote to him to come to Lusance ; and 
 while waiting for his arrival, I took my hat and 
 walking-stick, and went out to visit the churches of 
 the diocese, in some of which are epitaphs as yet 
 never correctly copie_(Ly 
 
 So I took leave of my hosts, and set out on my 
 pilgrimage. Every day I explored churches and 
 cemeteries, visited curates and village notaries, 
 supped at inns with peddlers and cattle-dealers, and 
 slept between lavender-scented sheets, thus spend- 
 ing a week of calm, profound enjoyment, thinking 
 of the dead, and watching the living busy with their 
 daily labor. So far as the object of my researches 
 was concerned, I made but ordinary discoveries, such 
 as caused me no great delight ; and on that very ac- 
 count my pleasure was healthful and not fatiguing. 
 /Ideciphered some interesting epitaphs, and added 
 to this small store several recipes for country dishes, 
 which a worthy c urt was kind enough to bestow on 
 me. 
 
 With these treasures I returned to Lusance, and 
 crossed the court-of-honor with the deep satisfaction 
 of a countryman returning home. This was caused 
 by the kindness of my hosts, and the sensations
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNAKD. 97 
 
 V 
 
 which at that time I felt on their threshold proves 
 better than any argument their kind hospitality. 
 
 I reached the large drawing-room without meeting 
 any one ; and the young chestnut-tree, which spread 
 out its broad leaves there, seemed like a friend.) 
 But what I next saw on the pier-table was such a 
 surprise to me, that I adjusted my spectacles with 
 both hands, and pinched myself in order to get at 
 least a superficial idea of my own existence. Twenty 
 or more ideas came to my mind in an instant ; and 
 of them all, the most likely was that I had gone 
 mad. It seemed to me impossible that what I saw 
 was really there, yet I could not see it except as e 
 isting. The cause of my surprise, as I have said, 
 was on a pier-table beneath a dull and specked 
 mirror. 
 
 I caught sight of my own reflection in this mirror, 
 and I may say that for once in my life I saw the 
 living image of stupefaction. But I made allow- 
 ances for myself, and approved of myself for being 
 stupefied by a stupefying thing. The object, at 
 which I was gazing with an^ astonishment not di- 
 minished by reflection, accepted the examination 
 without moving. The persistency and fixity of the 
 phenomenon excluded all idea of hallucination. I 
 am absolutely free from those nervous troubles 
 which affect the sight.! This is generally due to indi- 
 gestion, and thankTTeaven I have a good digestion. 
 Moreover, the illusions of sight are accompanied by 
 peculiar and abnormal conditions, which affect the 
 victims themselves, and inspire them with a sort of 
 terror. But I felt nothing of all this. And the ob-
 
 98 THE CRIME OF 
 
 ject before me, although impossible in itself, appeared 
 to me under every condition of actual reality. I 
 noticed that it had three dimensions and color, and 
 that it cast a shadow. Ah ! How I watched it ! 
 The tears came into my eyes, and I was obliged to 
 wipe my spectacles. 
 
 /ATlast I had to yield to the evidence, and confess 
 /that I saw before me the fairy of whom I had 
 dreamed the other evening in the library. It was 
 she ! I assure you it was she ! She still had her 
 child-queen air, that proud yet supple attitude. In 
 her hand she held her wand of hazel-wood. She 
 wore the two-horned hennin, and the train of her 
 brocade robe lay in serpentine folds about her little 
 feet. The same face and figure as before. It was 
 indeed she ; and to make assurance doubly sure, she 
 was seated on the back of a heavy old volume that 
 looked very much like the " Cosmography of Mun- 
 ster." Her immobility half reassured me ; but I 
 feared that she would again draw some nuts from 
 her purse, and throw the shells into my face. 
 
 I stood there, my arms raised, my mouth open, 
 when Madame de Gabry's laughing and musical 
 voice fell on my ear. 
 
 " So you are studying your fairy, are you, Mon- 
 sieur Bonnard ? " exclaimed my hostess. " Well, 
 do you see any resemblance ? 7' 
 
 It was said quickly; but in the meantime I had 
 time to see that my fairy was a statuette modelled 
 in colored wax, with evident feeling and taste, by the 
 hand of some amateur. But the phenomenon, thus 
 rationally explained, was still a surprise to me.
 
 I ought S'ght of my own reflection in the mirror.
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 99 
 
 How and by whom had the lady of the " Cosmog- 
 raphy " come into plastic existence ? This was 
 what I had still to learn. 
 
 \ Turning to Madame de Gabry, I saw that she 
 was not alone. A young girl dressed in mourning 
 stood beside her. She had large, intelligent eyes, 
 of a gray as soft as the sky of the Isle de France, 
 and with an expression in them indicating both 
 strength and innocence. Her arms were somewhat 
 thin, her hands restless and small, and red as the 
 hands of a young girl usually are. In her merino 
 dress she looked like a young sapling. Her mouth 
 was large, indicating frankness. I cannot tell how 
 greatly this young girl pleased me at first glance. 
 She was not beautiful ; but she had three merry 
 dimples in her cheeks and chin, and her whole per- 
 son, though betraying the awkwardness of inexpe- 
 rience, had in it something strong and fine. 
 
 My eyes went from the statuette to the young 
 girl ; and I saw the latter blush, but frankly, deeply, 
 the blood rushing like a torrent over her face. 
 
 " Well," said my hostess, who, being accustomed 
 to my absent-mindedness, repeated her question, 
 " is that the lady who came in to see you through 
 the window which you left opene^Uf She was very 
 bold, but you were just as imprudent. Tell me, do 
 you recognize her ? " 
 
 !' It is her very self," I replied. " I see her once 
 more on this pier-table, just as I saw her on the 
 library table." 
 
 i " If that is so," replied Madame de Gabry, "the 
 (responsibility for this resemblance you may charge
 
 100 THE CKIME OF 
 
 first to yourself, who for a man devoid of all imagi- 
 nation, as you say you are, can describe your dreams 
 so vividly; next to me, who remembered your dream, 
 and repeated it faithfully ; and lastly, and above all, 
 to Mademoiselle Jeanne, whom I present to you, and 
 who, following out my suggestions, modelled the wax 
 figure that you see." 
 
 As she spoke, Madame de Gabry took the young 
 girl's hand ; but Mademoiselle Jeanne tore herself 
 away, and was already down in the park, darting 
 away as if on wings. 
 
 " You silly girl ! " cried Madame de Gabry as she 
 ran. " Why be so shy ? Come back to be scolded 
 ( and kissed ! "\ 
 
 But no reply came, and the frightened bird disap- 
 peared within the shrubbery. Madame de Gabry 
 sat down in the only armchair the deserted room 
 possessed. 
 
 " I should be greatly surprised," said she, " if my 
 husband had not already spoken to you of Jeanne. 
 We love her deeply, and indeed she is a good girl. 
 Tell me frankly, what do you think of the statuette ? " 
 
 I replied that it showed taste and spirit, but that 
 the artist needed study and practice. But I was 
 greatly touched because her young fingers had 
 worked out an old man's rough sketch, and por- 
 trayed with such brilliancy an old dotard's dreams. 
 
 " My reason for asking your advice," gravely re- 
 sumed Madame de Gabry, " is because Jeanne is a 
 poor orphan. Do you think she could make hen 
 living by modelling statuettes like this one?" 
 
 " No; I do not," I replied. " And it is not to be
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. IOI 
 
 greatly regretted. You say the girl is affectionate 
 and gentle. I believe you. I see it in her face. 
 An artist's life has temptations which lead generous 
 spirits beyond proper rules and limits. This young 
 creature is moulded out of loving clay. Keep her 
 for the home and fireside. There alone is true hap- 
 piness." 
 
 "But she has no dowry!" replied Madame de 
 Gabry. Then, holding out her hand to me, she 
 added, " You are our friend, and I may tell you all. 
 This child's father was a banker, and a friend of 
 ours. He tried to engineer various colossal specu- 
 lations ; and this, in fact, was what ruined him. He 
 survived but a few months after his failure, in which 
 (Paul must have told you) three-fourths of my uncle's 
 fortune was sunk, and more than half of ours. / 
 
 " We knew him at Monaco the winter that we 
 spent with my uncle. He had an adventurous dis- 
 position, but so plausible! He deceived himself 
 before deceiving others. The greatest skill lies in 
 that, does it not? My uncle, my husband, and I 
 were drawn into ".; and we risked more than a rea- 
 sonable amou t in a dangerous speculation. But 
 what matte r , as Paul says/since we have no chil- 
 dren.J Moreover, we have the satisfaction of know- 
 ing tha_t .he friend in whom we trusted was an honest 
 man.f ^ ou must know his name, it was so constantly 
 in the j.apers and on posters, Noel Alexandre. His 
 wife w is very sweet. } I did not know her until she 
 -as already faded; but she still retained traces of 
 beauU', and a taste for great style and show that 
 well became her. She was somewhat fond of excite- 

 
 IO2 THE CRIME OF 
 
 ment, but she showed great courage and dignity 
 after her husband's death. jShe died a year later, 
 leaving Jeanne alone in the world."j 
 
 " Clementine ! " I exclaimed. 
 
 Upon hearing what I had never imagined, and 
 the mere thought of which would have roused to re- 
 bellion all the forces of my soul, on learning that 
 Clementine was no more on earth, a great silence, 
 as it were, took possession of me ; and the feeling 
 which swept over my whole being was not a sharp, 
 sudden pang, but a calm and solemn sadness. I 
 felt an indescribable peace, and my thoughts sud- 
 denly rose to heights unknown. 
 
 " From where you are to-day, Clementine," I said 
 to myself, " look down on this heart now grown cold 
 wjth years, but whose pulse once beat warmly for 
 you, and tell me if it does not again waken at the 
 thought of loving all that is left of you on earth. 
 All is over since you are gone ; but life is immortal, 
 and it is this we must love in itfe constantly renewed 
 form. The rest is child's play; and I, with my books, 
 am, as it were, a little boy playing with knuckle- 
 bones. O Clementine, you have revealed to me the 
 aim of life." Madame de Gabry roused me from 
 my reflections by the words, 
 
 " The child is poor." 
 
 " Clementine's daughter poor ! " I exclaimed. 
 "How fortunate that is! None other than I must 
 provide for her, and give her a dowry. No ! Clemen- 
 tine's daughter shall not receive a dowry from uny 
 one but me ! " 
 
 I approached Madame de Gabry, who had already 

 
 SYLVESTRE BONNAKD. 1 03 
 
 risen, and taking her right hand, I kissed it, laid it 
 upon my arm, and said, " Take me to the grave of 
 Noel Alexandre's widow." And I heard Madame 
 de Gabry say to me, 
 " Why are you weeping ? "
 
 104 THE CRIME OF 
 
 LITTLE SAINT GEORGE. 
 
 April 16. 
 
 SAINT DROCTOVEUS and the early abbots of 
 Saint-Gemain-des-Pres have taken up my time and 
 attention for forty years, but I do not know whether 
 or not I shall write their history before I go to join 
 them. I have been an old man for many years. 
 One day last year, on the Pont des Arts, one of my 
 colleagues of the Institute was complaining to me of 
 the trials of growing old. 
 
 " Still," Sainte-Beuve answered him, " that is the 
 only way yet discovered of living long." 
 
 I have used this method, and I know what it is 
 worth. The pity lies, not in living too long, but in 
 seeing every one around us die. Mother, wife, 
 friends, children, Nature makes and unmakes these 
 divine treasures with calm indifference, and we find 
 that in the end we have been loving and embracing 
 mere shadows. But there are some very dear ones ! 
 
 If ever any one glided like a shadow into a man's 
 life, it was the young girl whom I loved when (how 
 incredible it now is!) I was a young man. And the 
 memory of this shadow is even to-day one of the 
 dearest realities of my life. 
 
 A Christian sarcophagus from the catacombs of 
 Rome bears a form of curse, the dreadful meaning 
 of which I have learned to understand with time. 
 It reads:
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 10$ 
 
 " If 'any wicked person violates this totnb, may he 
 die last of all his race /" 
 
 As an archaeologist I have opened tombs and re- 
 moved their ashes, in order to collect from them 
 shreds of cloth, metal ornaments, and various gems. 
 But I did this with a scientific curiosity, not lacking 
 reverence and pity. May the curse cut on the tomb 
 of a martyr, by one of the early disciples of the 
 apostles, never fall upon me ! I ought not to fear 
 lest I outlive my friends, so long as there are men 
 on earth, for there are always some whom one can 
 love. 
 
 But the power to love grows weak, and finally is 
 lost with age, like every other faculty of man. Ex- 
 ample proves it, and this is what frightens me. Am 
 I sure that I have not already suffered in this way ? 
 Certainly I should have done so, had not a happy 
 meeting rejuvenated me. The poets speak of the 
 Fountain of Youth. It exists; it bubbles under the 
 earth at our every step, and we pass without drink- 
 ing of it ! J 
 
 The young girl whom I loved, having been mar- 
 ried according to the dictates of her heart to a rival, 
 grew old, and entered into eternal rest. \\ have found 
 her daughter; so that my life, which was of no fur- 
 ther use, has once more acquired some meaning and 
 excuse. 
 
 To-day I " take the sun " as they say in Provence. 
 I take it on the terrace of the Luxembourg at the 
 foot of the statue of Marguerite of Navarre. It is 
 the sunshine of spring, as intoxicating as young 
 wine. I sit and ponder. My thoughts escape from
 
 IO6 THE CRIME OF 
 
 my head like the foam on a beer-bottle. They are 
 light, and their sparkles amuse me. I am dreaming. 
 This, I think, is allowable in a man who has pub- 
 lished thirty volumes of old texts, and contributed 
 for twenty-six, years to the Journal des Savants. I 
 have the satisfaction of knowing that I did my task 
 as well as I could, and of having fully exercised the 
 ordinary talents with which nature endowed me. 
 My efforts have not been entirely in vain, and I have 
 contributed my small share to the number of his- 
 toric works which will be an honor to this restless 
 century. I shall surely be counted among the ten 
 or twelve who have revealed to France her literary 
 antiquities. My publication of the poetic works of 
 Gautier de Coincy inaugurated a judicious system, 
 and made an epoch. The severe serenity of old 
 age makes it permissible for me to claim this de 
 served reward ; and God, who sees my heart, knows 
 whether pride or vanity has any part in the justice 
 I render myself. 
 
 But I am weary, my eyes are dim, my hand trem- 
 bles, and I see an image of myself in those old men 
 of Homer, who, by reason of their feebleness, were 
 out of the combats, and who, seated along the ram- 
 parts, raised their voices like cicalas in a bower. 
 
 Thus my thoughts were roaming, when three 
 young men sat down near T&&.-JL do not know 
 whether each came in three pal'Pd'frx, Tike La Fon- 
 taine's monkey, but the three certainly sat down on 
 a dozen chairs ! I took great pleasure in watching 
 them, not that there was anything extraordinary 
 about them, but because they had that happy, joy-
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. IO? 
 
 ous air that belongs to youth. They were college 
 men ; I was sure of it, perhaps less from the books 
 in their hands than from the character of their faces^J 
 \Fpr all who devote themselves to intellectual pur- 
 suits are recognizable at first sight by an indescrib- 
 able something which is common to all of them. |l 
 am very fond of young people ; and these pleased 
 me, in spite of certain wild and annoying ways that 
 vividly recalled my own student days. But they did 
 not wear their hair long, as we did, over velvet 
 doublets. They did not walk, as we did, with a 
 death's head, or cry out, as we did, " Hell and dam- 
 nation ! " They were correctly dressed, and neither 
 their costume nor their language was at all sugges- 
 tive of the Middle Ages. 
 
 I must add that they had keen eyes for the women 
 who passed on the terrace, and that they showed 
 their admiration of some of them in rather lively 
 language. But their ideas on this subject did not 
 go so far as to compel me to leave my seat. Be- 
 sides, when young men are studious, I do not grudge 
 them their fun. 
 
 One of them made a witty remark about some 
 girl : 
 
 " What's that ? " cried the smallest and darkest of 
 the three, with a slight Gascon accent. " Let us 
 physiologists occupy ourselves with living matter. 
 And you, Ge*lis, who, like all your archaeological 
 friends, live only in the past, why don't you occupy 
 yourself with those stone women who are your con- 
 temporaries ? " 
 
 He pointed across to thq statues of the ladies of
 
 IO8 THE CRIME OF 
 
 ancient France that rose in a white semicircle under 
 the trees along the terrace. This by-play, trifling 
 in itself, showed me at least that the one called 
 Ge"lis was a student in the ficole . des Chartes. 
 From the rest of the conversation, I learned that his 
 silent, sarcastic neighbor, light complexioned and as 
 pale as a shadow, was Boulmier, his fellow-student. 
 Gelis and the future doctor (I hope he may become 
 one some day) talked together with much liveliness 
 and wit. In the midst of the most serious specula- 
 tions, they played on words and perpetrated jokes 
 after the absurd style characteristic of wits I mean 
 they got off prodigious absurdities. I need not add, 
 need I, that they scorned to maintain anything but 
 the most colossal paradoxes.) They used all their 
 imagination to make themselves ridiculous, and all 
 their logic to support the opposite of common-sense. 
 (_Gpod for them ! ) I do not like young people to be 
 too sensible. 
 
 The medical student looked at the book that 
 Boulmier had in his hand. 
 
 "What," said he, "you. reading Michelet!" 
 " Yes," replied Boulmier seriously ; " I like novels." 
 Gdlis, who excelled the others by his handsome, 
 slender figure, his imperious bearing and ready flow 
 01 words, took the book, glanced over a few pages, 
 and said, J 
 
 " Michelet has always had a tendency for the ro- 
 mantic. He shed sentimental tears over Maillard, 
 that nice little man who introduced scribbling into 
 the massacres of September. But, as tenderness 
 leads to madness, behold him suddenly grown furi-
 
 SYLVESTKE BONNARD. 
 
 ous at his victims. What can you expect? This is 
 modern sentimentality. We pity the assassin, and 
 consider the victim as unpardonable. In his later 
 manner, Michelet has become more Michelet than 
 ever. It no longer has any common-sense in it. It 
 is amazing! Neither art nor science, neither criti- 
 cism nor narrative. [Only outbursts of anger, faint- 
 ing-fits, an epileptic seizure, on account of facts which 
 he never deigns to expound, j Infantile shrieks, wo- 
 man's unreasonable cravings, and a style, my friends, 
 with never a familiar commonplace in it ! (jj is as- 
 tonishing ! " 
 
 He returned the book to his friend. 
 
 " Their fun is amusing," said I to myself, " and not 
 so devoid of reason as it seems. This young man, 
 in his jesting way, has keenly hit the weak point in 
 the armor." 
 
 But the student from Provence declared that his- 
 tory was nothing but a despicable and thoroughly 
 rhetorical study. His idea was that the only real 
 history was the natural history of man. Michelet 
 was on the right road when he came upon the fistula 
 of Louis XIV., but he fell back almost immediately 
 into the old rut. 
 
 Having given expression to this wise idea, the 
 young physiologist rose, and joined a group of pass- 
 ing friends. The two archaeological students, having 
 fewer acquaintances in the garden, it was a long 
 distance from the rue Paradis-?u-Marais, remained 
 behind, and began talking of their studies. Ge'lis, 
 who was near the end of his third year, was prepar- 
 ing a thesis, the subject of which he told with boy-
 
 IIO THE CRIME OF 
 
 ish enthusiasm. The subject seemed to me a good 
 one, especially as I had recently thought it my duty 
 to treat a notable part of it. It was the Monasti- 
 ciun gallicanum. 
 
 The young erudite (I give him this name as an 
 omen) was planning to mention all the plates en- 
 graved about 1690 for the work that Dom Michel 
 Germain would have had published had it not been 
 for the one single obstacle that one scarcely ever 
 foresees, and never avoids. 
 
 Dom Michel Germain at least left his manuscript 
 complete and in good order when he died. Shall I 
 do as much with mine? But that is not the ques- 
 tion. 
 
 Monsieur Ge'lis, so far as I could understand, pro- 
 posed to consecrate an archaeological notice to each 
 abbey pictured by the humble engravers of Dom 
 Michel Germain. 
 
 His companion asked him if he was acquainted 
 with all the manuscripts and publications relating 
 to the subject. Then, indeed, I strained my ears to 
 listen. They spoke first of original sources; and I 
 must say that they did it systematically enough, in 
 spite of their countless and wretched puns. Then 
 they mentioned the works of contemporary criticism. 
 
 " Have you read," asked Boulmier, " the notice of 
 Courajod ? " 
 
 " Good ! " said I to myself. 
 
 " Yes," answered G^lis ; " it is correct." 
 
 " Have you read the\ article by Tamisey de Lar- 
 roque in the Review of Historical Questions ? " 
 asked Boulmier. 

 
 SYLVESTRE BONPfAJ*D>^ HI 
 
 " Good ! " said I to myself a second time". 
 
 " Yes," answered Ge'lis ; " and it is full of infdrma"^ 
 tion." 
 
 " Have you read," asked Boulmier, "the 'Picture 
 of the Historical Abbeys of the Benedictines in 
 1600,' by Sylvestre Bonnard?" 
 
 " Good ! " I exclaimed a third time. 
 
 " Mercy, no ! " replied Ge'lis. " Bonnard is a 
 fool." 
 
 I turned my head, and saw that night's shadows 
 were creeping over where I sat. The air was grow- 
 ing damp, and I thought myself very foolish to risk 
 taking cold while listening to the impertinent re- 
 marks of two young coxcombs. 
 
 " Ha ! Ha ! " said I to myself, as I rose. " Let 
 this young chatterbox write his thesis and support 
 it. He will find that my colleague Quicherat, or some 
 other professor of the school, will show him his crass 
 ignorance. I have good reason to call him a black- 
 guard ; and really, in thinking of the matter as I do 
 now, what he said about Michelet is intolerable and 
 outrageous. The idea ! To speak in such a way 
 of an old master so full of genius. It is abomi- 
 nable ! " 
 
 Afril 17. 
 
 " TheVcse, give me my new hat, my best coat, and 
 my silver-headed cane." 
 
 But Thdrese is as deaf as a coal-sack, and as 
 slow as justice. Age is the cause of it. The worst 
 of it is, that she thinks l.er hearing good and her 
 steps agile ; moreover, she is proud of her sixty
 
 I I 2 WTHE CRIME OF 
 
 yp'ars of honest housekeeping, and she serves her 
 old master with the most watchful despotism. 
 
 What did I say ? . . . Here she is unwilling 
 to give me my silver-headed cane, for fear of my 
 osing it. It is true that I quite frequently leave 
 umbrellas and sticks in the 'buses and book-shops. 
 But I have a good reason to-day for carrying my old 
 cane, the carved silver head of which represents 
 Don Quixote galloping with poised lance against 
 the wind-mills, while Sancho Panza, his arms raised 
 to heaven, begs him in vain to stop. 
 
 This cane is all that I inherited from my uncle, 
 Captain Victor, who in his lifetime resembled Don 
 Quixote rather than Sancho Panza, and who loved 
 blows as naturally as one usually fears them. For 
 thirty years I have carried this cane on every mem- 
 orable or solemn walk I have taken, and the two 
 figures of the knight and the squire inspire and con- 
 sole me. I can almost hear them. Don Quixote 
 says to me, 
 
 " Think deeply of serious things, and know that 
 thought is the only reality in the world. Lift nature 
 up to your own height, and let the whole world be 
 for you but the reflection of your heroic spirit. 
 Fight for honor this alone is worthy of a man; 
 and if you are wounded, spill your blood like gener- 
 ous dew, and smile." 
 
 And Sancho Panza says in turn, 
 
 " Remain what Heaven made you, brother ! Pre- 
 fer the crust of bread drying in your wallet to the 
 ortolans that are roasting in the duke's kitchen. 
 Obey your master, whether he be wise or foolish,
 
 1 1 
 
 and 'do not load your brain with too many useless 
 facts. Fear blows ; 'tis tempting God to seek 
 danger." 
 
 But if the incomparable knight and his unparal- 
 leled squire exist as merely figures on the head of my 
 cane, they themselves are in my innermost conscience. 
 All of us have a Don Quixote and a Sancho within 
 us, to whom we listen ; and even while Sancho per- 
 suades us, it is Don Quixote whom we must admire. 
 
 But a truce to this nonsense ! Let us go to Ma- 
 dame de Gabry about a matter which is of more 
 importance than the ordinary affairs of life. 
 
 The tame day, 
 
 I found Madame de Gabry dressed in black, and 
 just buttoning her gloves. 
 
 " I am ready," said she. 
 
 Ready ! I have always found her so, on every 
 occasion for doing good. 
 
 After a few pleasant words regarding the good 
 health of her husband, who had gone for a walk, 
 we went down-stairs, and stepped into the carriage. 
 I know not what secret spell I feared to break by 
 speaking ; but we drove without a word along the 
 wide, deserted boulevard, studying the shops where 
 crosses, gravestones, and funeral-wreaths were wait- 
 ing for their purchaser. The cab stopped at the 
 final bourn of the land of the living, before the 
 gate, on which are graven words of hope. 
 
 " Follow me," said Madame de Gabry, whose 
 height I now noticed fov the first time. We went 
 down a walk bordered by cypress-trees, then fol-
 
 114 THE CRIME OF 
 
 lowed a narrow path between the tombs. Finally 
 we stopped in front of a flat stone. 
 
 " It is here," said she ; and she knelt down. 
 
 In spite of myself I could not help noticing the 
 unconsciously graceful way in which this Christian 
 woman fell on her knees, letting the folds of her 
 gown spread about her as they chanced. With the 
 exception of two Polish exiles one evening in a de- 
 serted church of Paris, never had I seen any woman 
 kneel so unaffectedly, and in such utter lack of self- 
 consciousness. 
 
 The picture flashed through my mind like lighten- 
 ing ; and then I saw nothing but the low slab on 
 which was cut the name CLEMENTINE. What 
 I felt was something profound and intangible and 
 inexpressible, unless by the sound of exquisite music. 
 I I heard instruments of a celestial sweetness mak- 
 ing melody in my old heart. With the solemn tones 
 of a funeral hymn were mingled the muted notes of 
 a love-song, for into the same feeling my soul min- 
 gled the solemn sadness of the present and the well- 
 known graces of the past. I 
 
 I cannot say whether or not we had been before 
 the tomb of Cldmentine for long, when Madame 
 de Gabry rose. We crossed the cemetery without 
 speaking, but when we were once more among living 
 men my tongue became unfettered. 
 
 V' As I followed you," I said to Madame de Gabry, 
 " I was thinking of those legendary angels whom 
 one meets on the mysterious borders of life and 
 death. The grave to whirh you have taken me 
 and I was as ignorant of it as of almost all else 

 
 SYLVESTKE BOXKARD. 11$ 
 
 concerning her whom it covers recalled certain 
 unparalleled emotions of existence, comparable in 
 the dulness of this life to a light on a dark road. 
 The farther one goes, the farther away is the gleam. 
 I am almost at the foot of the last slope, and yet I 
 see the light as distinctly as ever every time I look 
 back.. 
 
 il You, madame, who knew Clementine as she 
 was, with white hair, a wife and mother, you cannot 
 imagine her as she was when I saw her, a fair-haired 
 young girl, with cheeks like roses and skin so white ! 
 Since you have been good enough to be my guide, 
 I think I should tell you, de^ar madame, what feel- 
 ings this grave aroused. I Recollections are crowd- 
 ing into my heart. I am like an old, gnarled, and 
 moss-grown oak, which sways its branches, and 
 awakens nests of singing birds. Unfortunately the 
 song of my birds is as old as the world, and can 
 amuse no one but myself."y 
 
 f'Tell me your recollections," said Madame de 
 GabryJ " I cannot read your books, for they are 
 written for scholars ; but I like to listen when you 
 talk, because you make the most ordinary things 
 in life interesting. Speak to me as if I were an old 
 woman. PFhis morning I found three white hairs 
 on my head."] 
 
 "Behold them come without regret, madame," M 
 said I. - "Time deals gently only with those who 
 take it gently. And when, in a few years, a light 
 silver foam will float on the ripples of your dark 
 hair, you will be clothed in a new beauty, less vivid, 
 but more touching than the first, and you will see
 
 I 1 6 THE CRIME OF 
 
 that your husband will love your white hair just as 
 much as he did the black curl which you gave him 
 when he married you, and which he wears in a locket, 
 as if it were something sacred. These boulevards 
 are wide and but little frequented. We can talk^.t 
 our ease as we drive along. I will tell you first how 
 I became acquainted with Clementine's father. But 
 pray expect nothing extraordinary, nothing remark- 
 able; for if you do you will be greatly disappointed.^ 
 ["""Monsieur de Lessay occupied the second story 
 or an old house on the Avenue de 1'Observatoire. 
 The plaster facade, ornamented with antique busts, 
 and the great rambling garden near it, were the first 
 images that stamped themselves on my childish 
 eyes, and in all probability they will be the last 
 which, when the inevitable day arrives, will fade 
 from under my heavy lids. For in this house I was 
 born. In this garden I played, and learned to feel 
 and know some fragments of this old universe. 
 Happy hours ! sacred hours ! when the pure soul 
 discovers the world revealing itself by a kindly light 
 and with a mysterious charm. For, madame, the 
 universe is but the reflection of our own soul."^ 
 
 " My mother was a being happily endowed. She 
 rose with the sun, like the birds ; and she resembled 
 them by her domestic industry, by her maternal in- 
 stinct, by the necessity which she felt to be always 
 singing, and by a sort of graceful abruptness, all of 
 which I thoroughly appreciated, though I was only 
 a child. She was the soul of the house, filling it 
 with her well-regulated and happy energy. My 
 father was as slow as she was sprightly. I well re-
 
 SYLVESTKE BONNARD. I I/ 
 
 call his placid face, over which now and then would 
 pass an ironical smile. He was weary, and he loved 
 his weariness. Seated near the window in his deep 
 armchair, he used to read from morning till night. 
 From him I inherited my love of books. I have in 
 my library a Mably and a Raynal which he anno- 
 tated with his own hand from beginning to end. 
 But it was not to be expected that he would trouble 
 himself about practical affairs. When my mother 
 strove by gentle tact to draw him out from his indif- 
 ference, he shook his head with that inexorable 
 sweetness which is the strength of weak characters. 
 He was the despair of the poor woman who had no 
 manner of sympathy with this contemplative wisdom, 
 and understood nothing of life but its daily cares 
 and the happy work of each hour. She thought he 
 was ill, and feared that he would grow worse. But 
 his apathy arose from another cause. 
 
 ' My father entered the navy department under 
 Monsieur Decres in 1801, and showed marked talent 
 as administrator. There was a great activity at that 
 time in connection with the navy, and in 1805 my 
 father became chief of the second administrative 
 division. That year the emperor, to whom he had 
 been recommended by the minister, ordered him to 
 draw up a report on. the organization of the English- 
 navy. This work was stamped with a deeply lib- 
 eral and philosophical spirit, though the writer him- 
 self was not aware of the fact. It was not finished 
 until 1807, about eighteen months after the defeat 
 of Admiral Villeneuve at Trafalgar. Napoleon, who 
 after that ill-fated day never again wished to hear
 
 Il8 THE CRIME OF 
 
 a ship mentioned, wrathfully glanced over the pages, 
 and then threw the report into the fire, crying, 
 ' Phrases, nothing but phrases. I have already said 
 that I do not like ideologists ! ' They brought back 
 word to my father that the emperor was so angry 
 that he had ground the manuscript down into the fire 
 with his boot. At all events, it was his habit when 
 he was irritated to poke the fire with his. boot until 
 the very sole was scorched. 
 
 " My father never recovered from this disgrace, 
 and the failure of all his efforts to do his duty was 
 certainly the cause of the apathy into which he fell 
 later. Nevertheless, Napoleon, on his return from 
 the Island of Elba, sent for him, and ordered him 
 to draw up, in a patriotic and liberal spirit, procla- 
 mations and bulletins for the fleet. After Waterloo, 
 my father, more saddened than surprised, went into 
 retirement, and was left unmolested. Only it was 
 generally said of him that he was Jacobin and 
 blood-thirsty, a man to be avoided. 
 
 " My mother's elder brother, Victor Maldent, cap- 
 tain of infantry, retired on half pay in 1814 and dis- 
 missed in 1815, added, by his wrong attitude, to the 
 difficulties which the fall of the emperor had brought 
 on my father. Captain Victor noised it about in 
 the cafe's and in public balls that the Bourbons had 
 sold France to the Cossacks. He showed every one 
 a tricolored cockade that was hidden in his hat- 
 lining ; he carried with great ostentation a cane, the 
 twisted handle of which had been wrought so that 
 the shadow it made was the silhouette of the em- 
 peror.
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. I 19 
 
 'Unless, madame, you have seen certain litho- 
 graphs by Charlet, you can form no idea of my uncle 
 " Victor, and how he looked in his tight-fitting frogged 
 coat, with the cross of honor and some violets on his 
 chest, as he strolled up and down the garden of the 
 Tuileries with that fierce dignity of his. Idleness 
 and intemperance had the worst possible effect on 
 his political passions. He used to insult people 
 whom he saw reading the Quotidienne or the Dra- 
 peau blanc, and force them to fight with him. In 
 this way he had the grief and shame of wounding a 
 lad only sixteen years old in a duel. In short, my 
 uncle Victor was the opposite of a wise man ; and as 
 he used every day to come to our house for his 
 breakfast and dinner, his evil reputation clung to our 
 fireside. My poor father suffered deeply from the 
 eccentricity of his guest ; but as he was kind-hearted, 
 he said nothing, and opened his house to the captain, 
 who despised him cordially in return. 
 
 " What I am telling you now, madame, I learned 
 later. At that time my uncle filled me with the 
 greatest enthusiasm, and I determined that some 
 day I would be as much like him as possible. One 
 fine morning, in order to begin the desired resem- 
 blance, I struck an attitude, my hands on my hips, 
 and swore like an infidel. 
 
 " My good mother gave me such a stinging slap 
 on my cheek, that for a moment I stood perfectly 
 stupefied, before bursting into tears. I can still see 
 the armchair, covered with yellow Utrecht velvet, be- 
 hind which that day I shed countless tears. 
 
 " 1 was at that time a very little fellow. One
 
 I2O THE CRIME OF 
 
 morning my father raised me in his arms as was his 
 habit, and smiled at me with that touch of irony 
 which gave a piquant look to his gentle expression. 
 While I sat on his knees, playing with his long white 
 hair, he told me things which I did not understand 
 very well, but which interested me deeply, simply 
 because they were mysterious. I think, although I 
 am not positive, that on that morning he was telling 
 me the story of the little King of Yvetot, as we find 
 it in the song. Suddenly we heard a great noise, 
 and the windows rattled. My father let me slip to 
 his feet, and with trembling arms uplifted, he shook 
 his fists. His face was pallid and lifeless looking, his 
 eyes preternaturally large. He strove to speak, 
 but his teeth chattered. At last he muttered, ' They 
 have shot him ! ' I did not know what he meant, 
 and I felt a vague terror. Afterwards I learned 
 that he was speaking of Marshal Ney, killed on the 
 7th of December, 1815, beneath the wall which en- 
 closed an empty lot adjoining our house. 
 
 " About this time I often used to meet on the 
 stairs an old man (he was not so very old perhaps), 
 whose little black eyes shone with wonderful bright- 
 ness from his calm, swarthy face. To me he did 
 not seem alive, or at least it did not seem as if he 
 were alive like other men. At Monsieur Denon's, 
 where my father had taken me* I had seen a 
 mummy, brought from Egypt ; and I really thought 
 that Monsieur Denon's mummy awoke when it was 
 alone, crept out of its gilded case, put on a drab- 
 colored coat and a powdered wig, and that then it 
 became Monsieur de Lessay. And even to-day, my
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 121 
 
 dear madame, although I repel the idea as without 
 foundation, I must confess that Monsieur de Lessay 
 greatly resembled Monsieur Denon's mummy. This 
 is equivalent to saying that this man was an object 
 of terror and at the same time of fascination to me. 
 
 In reality, Monsieur de Lessay was a small gen- 
 tleman and a great philosopher. A disciple of 
 Mably and Rousseau, he flattered himself that he 
 was unprejudiced, and this pretension was in itself 
 a great prejudice.} He detested fanaticism, but he 
 possessed that of tolerance. ^1 speak, madame, of 
 a contemporary of a bygone age. I fear that I may 
 not be understood, and I am sure that I do not in- 
 terest you. It is all so far away from us ! But I 
 am abridging as much as possible. Besides, I did 
 not promise you anything interesting, and you could 
 not expect to hear of great adventures in the life 
 of Sylvestre Bonnard." 
 
 Madame de Gabry begged me to go on, and I did 
 so in these words : 
 
 " Monsieur de Lessay was curt with men and cour- 
 teous to women. He used to kiss my mother's hand,j 
 [_tliough she was not accustomed to such gallantry, 
 the customs of the Republic and the Empire being 
 very different. Through him I touched the age oi 
 Louis XVI. /Monsieur de Lessay was a geographerjj 
 and no one, TbelieVe, was prouder than he to dis- 
 cuss the face of the earth. Under the Ancient Re"- 
 gime he had done something in agriculture from a 
 philosophical standpoint, and in this way consumed 
 his estates to their last acre. No longer having an 
 inch of land left to call his own, he took possession
 
 122 THE CRIME OF 
 
 of the whole earth, and made a wonderful number 
 of maps, based on the accounts of travellers. 
 
 "But as he had been nourished on the purest 
 marrow of the encyclopaedia, he was not satisfied 
 with enclosing human beings within so many degrees, 
 minutes, and seconds of latitude and longitude. He 
 looked after their happiness, alas ! It is noticeable, 
 madame, that men who have looked after the hap- 
 piness of people in general have made their own 
 household very unhappy^-?' 1 Monsieur de Lessay, a 
 greater geometrician than Dalembert, a greater 
 philosopher than Jean-Jacques,|was yet a greater 
 royalist than Louis XVIII. But his love for the 
 king was nothing in comparison to his hatred for 
 the emperor. He took part in the conspiracy of 
 Georges against the First Consul ; but the court, 
 having forgotten him, or thinking him of no conse- 
 quence, he was not included in the list of the guilty. 
 He never forgave Bonaparte for this insult ; and he 
 called him the Ogre of Corsica, to whom, he said, he 
 would never intrust a regiment, because he found 
 him such a contemptible soldier. 
 
 "In 1820 Monsieur de Lessay, who had been a 
 widower for many years, married again, at the age 
 of nearly sixty. His wife was a very young woman, 
 and he set her to work, without mercy, on his maps. 
 After a few years of marriage, she died in giving 
 birth to a daughter. My mother nursed her in her 
 short illness, and saw that the child wanted nothing. 
 This child was named Clementine. 
 
 " The relations of my family with Monsieur de 
 Lessay begin with that birth and that death. As I
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 12$ 
 
 was just then emerg'ng from the first years of child- 
 Iiood, I was beginning to grow big and stupid. I 
 lost the charming gift of insight and feeling. Things 
 no longer caused me the delightful surprise that is 
 t'.ie charm of youth. So I have no remembrance of 
 the years which followed the birth of Clementine. I 
 know only that within a few months I experienced 
 a grief, the mere thought of which still makes my 
 heart ache. I lost my mother. A great silence, a 
 great coldness, and a great shadow, suddenly filled 
 our home. 
 
 " I fell into a sort of stupor. My father sent me 
 to college, but I had great difficulty in rousing my- 
 self from my torpor. 
 
 " However, I was not altogether an idiot, and 
 my professors taught me almost all they thought 
 necessary; that is, a little Greek, and much Latin. 
 I had no acquaintances, except with the ancients. I 
 learned to esteem Miltiades, and to admire Themis- 
 tocles; became familiar with Quintus Fabius, so far 
 as any one could be familiar with such a great con- 
 sul. Proud of these lofty relationships, I no longer 
 condescended to look at little Clementine and her 
 old father ; besides, they set out one fine day for 
 Normandy, nor did I give a thought to their return. 
 
 " But they did return, madame, they did return ! ' 
 Ye Influences of Heaven, ye Forces of Nature, ye 
 Mysterious Powers that give to man the ability to 
 love, you know how I again saw Clementine ! They 
 entered our sad home. Monsieur de Lessay no lon- 
 ger wore a wig. Bald, with a few grizzled locks on 
 his purple temples, he looked the picture of robust
 
 124 THE CRIME or 
 
 old age. But the beautiful, glow ing creature whom 
 I saw on his arm, and whose presence lighted up 
 our old faded drawing-room, was not a vision no ! 
 it was Clementine ! I am telling the truth. Her 
 blue eyes, blue as the flowers of the periwinkle, 
 seemed to- me supernatural ; and even to-day I can- 
 not believe that those two living gems can have suf- 
 fered the trials of life and the decay of death. She 
 was somewhat embarrassed when she met my father, 
 for she did not recognize him. Her cheeks had 
 a soft, becoming color ; and her parted lips wore a 
 smile that made one think of the Infinite, probably 
 because it betrayed no particular thought, and ex- 
 pressed only the joy of living and the delight of be- 
 ing beautiful. Her face shone beneath a pink hood 
 like a jewel in an open casket. She wore a cache- 
 mire shawl over a white muslin dress, which was 
 plaited at the waist, and which came to the tops of 
 her reddish-brown boots. Do not smile, madame ; 
 that was the style then, and I am not sure if our 
 modern fashions have as much simplicity, fresh- 
 ness, and graceful propriety. 
 
 (^ Monsieur de Lessay told us, that, as he had be- 
 gun the publication of an historical atlas, he in- 
 tended to live in Paris once more, and would be 
 glad to re-occupy his old apartment if it was vacant. 
 My father asked Mademoiselle de Lessay if she was 
 glad to be in the capital. Yes, she was ; for she 
 smiled still more radiantly. She smiled at the win- 
 dows that opened on the shining green garden; 
 she smiled at the bronze Marius seated among the 
 ruins of Carthage on the top of the clock ; she
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 125 
 
 smiled on the old yellow velvet chairs, and on the 
 poor student who dared not lift his eyes to her. 
 From that day, how I loved her ! 
 
 " But here we are in the rue de Sevres, and soon 
 we shall see your windows. I am a poor story-teller ; 
 and if ever I were to try the impossible and under- 
 take a novel, I should never succeed. I have spun 
 out a long introduction for a story which I am going 
 to tell you in a few words ; for there is a certain 
 delicacy, a certain feeling of the heart, that would 
 be shocked by an old man calmly enlarging upon 
 the sentiments of even the most innocent love. 
 
 " Let us drive for a few moments along this bou- 
 levard, with its row of convents, and my story will 
 be finished by the time we reach that little steeple 
 yondej> 
 
 x ^* t Monsieur de Lessay, learning that I was just fin- 
 ishing my studies at the Ecole des Charles, thought 
 me capable of working with him on his historical 
 atlas. The point at issue was to determine, on a se- 
 ries of maps, what this philosophic graybeard called 
 4 the vicissitudes of empires ' from Noah down to 
 Charlemagne. Monsieur de Lessay had stored away 
 in his head every error of the eighteenth century 
 concerning antiquities. 
 
 " As to history, I belonged to the new and ad- 
 vanced school, and was at an age when one does not 
 know how to pretend. The way in which the old 
 man understood, or rather failed to understand, the 
 barbarous ages, his obstinacy in seeing in remote 
 antiquity, ambitious princes, hypocritical and cov- 
 etous priests, virtuous citizens, poet-philosophers and
 
 1-26 THE CRIME OF 
 
 others, who never existed save in the romances of 
 Marmontel, caused me great unhappiness, and in- 
 spired me at first to raise every sort of objection, 
 reasonable, no doubt, but perfectly useless, and 
 at times dangerous. Monsieur de Lessay was very 
 irascible, and Clementine was very beautiful. Be- 
 tween the two I spent hours of torture and delight. 
 I was in love ; I was a coward ; and soon I conceded 
 to him all that he demanded regarding the histori- 
 cal and political figure that this earth, destined later 
 to bear Clementine, offered in the time of Abraham, 
 Menes, and Deucalion. 
 
 "As we finished drawing the maps, Mademoiselle 
 de Lessay tinted them in water-colors. Leaning 
 over the table, she held her brush between two fin- 
 gers ; a shadow fell from her eyelashes upon her 
 cheeks, and bathed her half-closed eyes in a soft 
 shade. Occasionally she would raise her head, and 
 I saw her parted lips. There was such expression 
 in her beauty that she could not breathe without 
 seeming to sigh, and her most ordinary movements 
 filled my soul with dreamy ecstasy. As I gazed at 
 her, I agreed with Monsieur de Lessay that Jupiter 
 ruled once as a despot over the mountainous regions 
 of Thessaly, and that Orpheus was unwise in in- 
 trusting to the clergy the teaching of philosophy. 
 To this day I do not know whether I was a coward 
 or a hero when I yielded these points to the obsti- 
 nate old man. 
 
 " Mademoiselle de Lessay, I must confess, did 
 not pay much attention to me. But her indifference 
 seemed so reasonable and so natural that I did not
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 12 
 
 think of complaining about it. I suffered on ac- 
 count of it, but unconsciously I was full of hope. 
 Wewere then only at the first Assyrian Empire. 
 
 /* Monsieur de Lessay came every evening for a 
 cup of coffee with my father. I cannot understand 
 in what way they were congenial, for never were two 
 natures so completely opposed to each other. My 
 father had few admirations and a forgiving soul. 
 As he grew older, he came to hate all exaggeration. 
 He clothed his ideas with a thousand delicate shades, 
 and never stated an opinion save with all sorts of 
 reservations. 
 
 " These habits of a gentle mind roused the dry, 
 hard old gentleman whom moderation in an adver- 
 sary never disarmed quite the contrary ! I scented 
 danger; the danger was Napoleon. My father cher- 
 ished no affection for him ; but having worked under 
 his orders, he did not like to hear him abused, espe- 
 cially to the advantage of the Bourbons, against 
 whom he had deep grievances. 
 
 " Monsieur de Lessay, more of a Voltairean and a 
 legitimist than ever, credited Bonaparte with being 4 
 the source of every political, social, and religious 
 evil. Tin this state of affairs Captain Victor was my 
 greatest anxiety. That dreadful uncle of mine had 
 grown perfectly intolerable since his sister was no 
 longer there to quiet him. The harp of David was\ 
 broken, and Saul was given over to his madness. 
 The fall of Charles X. augmented the old Bonapart- 
 ist's audacity, and he did all sorts of wild things. 
 He seldom came to our house, for it had grown too 
 gloomy for him ; but occasionally at dinner-time we
 
 THE CRIME OF 
 
 t 
 
 saw him come in, covered with flowers, like a mau- 
 soleum. Usually he sat down to table swearing in 
 his deep voice, and, as he ate, boasting of the success 
 which, as an old veteran warrior, he had enjoyed with 
 the ladies. Then, when dinner was finished, he would 
 fold up his napkin in the shape of a bishop's bon- 
 net, swallow half a decanter of brandy, and take his 
 departure as hastily as if he feared to spend, with- 
 out drinking, even a moment alone with an old phi- 
 losopher and a young scholar. I knew well enough 
 that if ever he should meet Monsieur de Lessay, all 
 would be lost. 
 
 " The day came, madame ! 
 
 " On that occasion the captain was quite hidden 
 by his flowers, and looked so much like a monument 
 erected in memory of the glories of the Empire that 
 any one would have longed to put a wreath of im- 
 mortelles on each of his arms. He was in unusu- 
 ally good humor ; and the first person who benefited 
 by his happy disposition was the cook, whom he 
 seized about the waist just as she was placing the 
 roast on the table. 
 
 " After dinner he pushed aside the decanter offered 
 him, saying that he would burn the brandy in his 
 coffee. I asked him tremblingly if he would not 
 rather have his coffee at once. My uncle Victor 
 was suspicious and by no means dull. The haste 
 which I displayed seemed to him in poor taste; for 
 he looked hard at me, and said, 
 
 "'Patience, nephew. It is not the place of the 
 child of the regiment to sound the retreat. The 
 devil ! You are in great haste, Master Pedant, to 
 see if I have spurs on my heels.'
 
 SYLVESTRE BOKNARD. 12Q 
 
 " It was evident that the captain had suspected 
 that I wanted him to go. Knowing this, I was cer- 
 tain that he would stay, and he did ! The slightest 
 details of that evening are indelibly impressed on 
 my memory. My uncle was perfectly jovial. The \ 
 mere idea of his being in the way kept him in good 
 humor. He told us in fine barracks' style, ma foi, 
 about a monk, a trumpeter, and five bottles of Cham- 
 bertin a story that would be greatly enjoyed in a 
 garrison, but which I would not attempt to tell you, 
 madame, even if I had the time to recall it. When 
 we went into the drawing-room, the captain called 
 our attention to the bad condition of our andirons, 
 and discoursed in a knowing way on the use of trip- 
 oli for polishing brass. Not a word of politics. He 
 was conducting himself cautiously. Eight o'clock 
 struck from the ruins of Carthage. It was time for 
 Monsieur de Lessay to arrive. A few moments 
 later he entered the room with his daughter. The 
 evening's usual routine began. Clementine occu- 
 pied herself with her embroidery near the lamp, the 
 shade of which enveloped her pretty head with soft 
 shadow, and threw a light upon her fingers that 
 made them almost luminous. Monsieur de Lessay 
 spoke of a comet predicted by the astronomers, and 
 advanced some theories which, though they were ex- 
 travagant, showed some intellectual culture. My 
 father, who knew considerable about astronomy, ex- ^ 
 pressed a few sensible ideas, ending with his eternal, 
 * But what do I know, after all ? ' 
 
 "In my turn I gave the opinion of our neighbor 
 in the observatory, the well-known Arago. Uncle
 
 I3O THE CRIME OF 
 
 Victor declared that comets have an influence on 
 the quality of wines, and in order to uphold his the- 
 ory, cited a rollicking tavern story. I was so pleased 
 with this conversation, that, calling to my aid my 
 latest readings, I strove to prolong it by a lengthy 
 exposition of the chemical constitution of the clus- 
 ters of nebulae which, scattered through celestial 
 space for millions of leagues, could be contained in 
 a bottle. My father, somewhat surprised at my elo- 
 quence, looked at me with that calm, ironical ex- 
 pression of his. But we cannot always be in the 
 clouds. Then, while my eyes rested on Clementine, 
 I spoke of a comet of diamonds that I had admired 
 the night before in a jeweller's showcase. This was 
 a most unfortunate inspiration on my part. 
 
 " ' My dear nephew,' cried Captain Victor, ' your 
 comet was not equal to that which sparkled on the 
 head of the Empress Josephine when she came to 
 Strasbourg to distribute crosses to the army.' 
 
 " ' That little Josephine was very fond of jewelry,' 
 said Monsieur de Lessay between two sips of coffee, 
 ' and I do not blame her. There was some good 
 in her, frivolous as she was. She was a Tascher, 
 and it was a great honor to Buonaparte when she 
 married him. A Tascher is not much, but a Buona- 
 parte is nothing at all.' 
 
 /' ' What do you mean by that, Monsieur le Mar- 
 quis ? ' demanded Captain Victor. 
 
 " ' I am no marquis,' dryly replied Monsieur de 
 Lessay; 'and what I mean is, that Buonaparte 
 would have been well matched had he married one 
 of those cannibal women Captain Cook describes
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 131 
 
 in his voyages, naked, tattooed, a ring in her nose, 
 and in the habit of devouring with ecstasy decayed 
 human bodies.' 
 
 " I knew it, thought I to myself, and in my anguish 
 (oh poor human heart ! ) my first thought was to no- 
 tice the correctness of my predictions. I must say 
 that the captain's reply had in it a touch of sublim- 
 ity. Placing his hands on his hips, he measured 
 Monsieur de Lessay scornfully from head to foot, 
 and said, 
 
 " ' Napoleon, sir, 1 had another wife besides Jose- 
 phine and Marie Louise. You are not acquainted 
 with this companion, but I have seen her close at 
 hand. She wears an azure mantle dotted with 
 stars ; she is crowned with laurels ; the cross of 
 honor sparkles on her breast. Her name is Glory.' 
 
 " Monsieur de Lessay put his cup on the mantel- 
 piece, and said quietly, 
 
 " ' Your Buonaparte was a scoundrel.' 
 
 " My father rose calmly, and slowly raising his 
 hands, said very gently to Monsieur de Lessay, 
 
 " ' Whatever the man may have been who died at 
 Saint Helena, I worked ten years in his government, 
 and my brother-in-law was thrice wounded under his 
 eagles. I beg you, my dear sir, my friend, not to 
 forget this in future.' 
 
 "That which the captain's lofty and burlesque 
 impertinences could not do, my father's courteous 
 remonstrance accomplished at once, it made 
 Monsieur de Lessay furiously angry. 
 
 1 In the original the captain calls his opponent " Monsieur 
 le Vidame" (Vidamf, a sprig of nobility) in contradistinction 
 to his former use of the title marquis.
 
 132 THE CRIME OF 
 
 " ' I forgot,' cried he, livid with rage, his teeth 
 clinched, his lips foaming ; ' I was wrong. The her- 
 ring-cask always smells .of herring ; and when one 
 ha^ been in the service of scoundrels ' 
 ^At this word the captain sprang at his throat. 
 Had it not been for his daughter and me, I think 
 be would have been choked to death. My father, 
 somewhat paler than usual, stood with folded arms, 
 watching the spectacle with an indescribable ex- 
 pression of pity. What followed was sadder still 
 but of what use is it to dwell on the anger of 
 two old men ? At last I succeeded in separating 
 them. Monsieur de Lessay beckoned to his daugh- 
 ter, and went out. She followed him. I ran to the 
 stairs after her. 
 
 " Mademoiselle,' I cried, distracted, pressing her 
 hand, ' I love you ! I love you ! ' 
 
 " For an instant she held my hand in hers, her 
 lips half opened. What was she going to say ? 
 But all at once, raising her eyes to her father, who 
 was ascending the stairs, she withdrew her hand, 
 and made me a gesture of farewell. I never saw 
 her again. Her father took rooms near the Pan- 
 the"on, in an apartment which he had rented for the 
 sale of his historical atlas. He died there a few 
 months later from a stroke of apoplexy. His daugh- 
 ter, I was told, went to live at Caen with an aged 
 lady, a relative of hers. There, some years later, she 
 married a bank-clerk, the Noel Alexandre who be- 
 came so rich and died so poor. As for me, madame, 
 I live alone in peace by myself. My life, free from 
 great sorrows as well as from great joys, has been
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 133 
 
 tolerably happy. But for years I could not, with- 
 out a great pang at heart, see an empty armchair 
 near mine on a winter evening. Last year I heard 
 through you, who knew her, of her old age and 
 death. I met her daughter at your house. I have 
 seen her ; but I will not say as yet, as did the aged 
 man of the Scriptures, ' And now, O Lord, lettest 
 thou thy servant depart in peace.' If an old fellow 
 like me can be of use to any one, I should like, with 
 your help, to devote my last years to this orphan 
 girl." 
 
 I uttered these words on the vestibule of Ma- 
 dame de Gabry's home; and I was about to take 
 leave of this kind friend, when she said to me, 
 
 " Dear friend, I cannot aid you in this as much 
 as I could wish. Jeanne is an orphan and a minor. 
 You cannot do anything for her without her guard- 
 ian's consent" 
 
 "Ah ! I never thought for an instant that Jeanne 
 might have a guardian." 
 
 Madame de Gabry looked at me with ill-concealed 
 surprise. She had not expected to find the old man 
 quite so simple-minded. 
 
 " Jeanne Alexandre's guardian," said she, " is 
 Maitre Mouche, a notary at Levallois-Perret. I fear 
 that you will not get on very well with him. He is 
 a serious man." 
 
 "Ah! good Heavens!" I cried; "whom do you 
 think I should get on with at my age, if not with 
 serious people ? " 
 
 She gently smiled, with a mischievous expression 
 in her eyes, just as my father used to do, and re- 
 plied,
 
 134 THE CRIME OF 
 
 " With those who, like you, are innocent and gen- 
 erous. Monsieur Mouche is not exactly of that kind. 
 He is artful and light-fingered. Although I find lit- 
 tle pleasure in meeting him, we will go together, if 
 you wish, and ask permission to see Jeanne, whom 
 he has put in a boarding-school at les Ternes, where 
 she is very unhappy." 
 
 We appointed a day. I kissed Madame de Ga- 
 bry's hand, and we parted. 
 
 May 2-5. 
 
 I have seen Maitre Mouche, Jeanne's guardian, in 
 his office. Small, thin, and dried-up, his complexion 
 looks as if it were made of the dust of his old pa- 
 pers. He is a spectacled animal, for one could not 
 imagine him without his glasses. I have heard 
 Maitre Mouche speak ; he has the voice of a rattle, 
 and he uses carefully chosen terms. I should have 
 liked it better if he had not chosen them at all. I 
 have observed Maitre Mouche ; he is ceremonious, 
 and watches one from the corner of his eye, behind 
 his spectacles. 
 
 Maitre Mouche is happy, he tells us he is de- 
 lighted, at our interest in his ward. But he does 
 not think that we are on this earth in order to amuse 
 ourselves. No, he does not think so ; and I must 
 say, in all justice, that one is of his opinion, when 
 with him, so little enjoyment does he inspire. He 
 fears that it would be giving a false and pernicious 
 idea of life to his dear ward if he allowed her too 
 much pleasure. That is why he asks Madame de 
 Gabry to invite her but seldom to her home. 
 
 We left the dusty notary and his dusty office,
 
 SYLVESTRE BONiJARD. 135 
 
 with his consent given in due form (everything that 
 Maitre Mouche does is in due form) to see Made- 
 moiselle Jeanne Alexandre the first Thursday of 
 every month, at the home of her instructor, Made- 
 moiselle Prdfere, rue Demours, at les Ten.es. 
 
 The first Thursday in May I set out '.or Made- 
 moiselle Prdfere's, whose establishment 1 saw from 
 afar by its sign in blue letters. The blue tint was the 
 first indication I had of Mile. Virginie Prdfere's tem- 
 perament, which I afterwards had ample opportunity 
 of studying. A scared-looking maid-servant took 
 my card, and left me, without a word of hope, in an 
 icy parlor, where I noticed that stale odor charac- 
 teristic of the dining-rooms of boarding-schools. 
 The floor of this room had been waxed with such 
 pitiless energy that I stood with fear and trembling 
 even on the threshold. Happily, however, I noticed 
 some small woollen squares that lay on the floor be- 
 fore the hair-cloth chairs ; and by stepping from one 
 to the other of these carpet islands, I succeeded in 
 reaching the corner of the fireplace, where I sat 
 down out of breath. ] 
 
 Over the mantelpiece in a great gilt frame, there 
 hung an Honor List, enrolling in flaming Gothic 
 script a long list of names, among which I did not 
 have the pleasure of finding Jeanne Alexandre's. I 
 read several times over the names of those pupils, 
 who in the eyes of Mademoiselle Prdfere were 
 worthy of such honor, .and then I began to grow 
 uneasy at hearing no one coming. Had it not been 
 for the countless swarms of sparrows that had 
 chosen her court for a gathering-place where they
 
 136 THE CRIME OF 
 
 might chirp and squabble, Mademoiselle Prefere 
 would certainly have succeeded in establishing 
 within her house of learning the perfect silence of 
 the celestial regions. It was a delight to hear the 
 birds, but (I beg to ask) how could one see them 
 through th-5 ground-glass windows ? I had to be sat- 
 isfied with what I could find in the parlor, the four 
 walls of which were adorned, from floor to ceiling, 
 with drawings done by the scholars. There were 
 vestal virgins there, flowers, cottages, capitals, vo- 
 lutes, and an enormous head of Tatius, King of 
 the Sabines, signed Estelle Mouton. For several 
 minutes I had been admiring the energy which 
 Mademoiselle Mouton had spent in delineating the 
 ancient warrior's bushy eyebrows and infuriated 
 gaze, when a slight noise, like that made by a 
 dead leaf wafted by the wind, made me turn 
 /my head, jit was not a dead leaf at all ; it was 
 Mademoiselle Prefere. With clasped hands she 
 advanced across the polished mirror of the floor, 
 as the saints in " The Golden Legend " glide over 
 the crystal waters. But at any other time I think 
 Mademoiselle Prdfere would not have reminded 
 me of the holy virgins so dear to mystic fancy. 
 Her face alone would have reminded me of a pip- 
 pin apple kept over winter in the attic of a thrifty 
 housewife. On her shoulders she wore a fringed 
 pelerine. In itself there was nothing remarkable 
 about this ; but she wore it as if it were a holy vest- 
 ment, or the mark of some high civil office. 
 
 I explained to her the object of my visit, and 
 handed her my letter of introduction.
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. \IJ 
 
 " You have seen Monsieur Mouche, then," said 
 she. " Is he in very good health ? He is such a 
 worthy man, such a " 
 
 She did not finish tha sentence, but raised her 
 eyes to the ceiling. I did the same ; and I saw a 
 narrow spiral of paper lace, which hung in the place 
 of the chandelier, and was meant, I suppose, to at- 
 tract the flies, and turn them from the gilt frames 
 of the mirrors and the List of Honor. 
 
 " I have met Mademoiselle Alexandre at Madame 
 de Gabry's," said I, " and I can appreciate the 
 young girl's noble character and quick intelligence. 
 I was well acquainted with her parents, and I 
 should like to transfer to her some of the interest 
 I felt for fhem." 
 
 For answer Mademoiselle Pre*fere sighed deeply, 
 drew her mysterious pelerine closely about her, and 
 again gazed at the little paper spiral. At last she 
 said, 
 
 " Since you were the friend of Monsieur and 
 Madame Alexandre, monsieur, I am glad to believe 
 that you, like Monsieur Mouche and myself, regret 
 the foolish speculations which brought them to ruin 
 and their daughter to poverty." 
 
 As I listened to her words, I thought how deeply 
 wrong it is to be unfortunate, and how unpardon- 
 able this wrong is on the part of those who for a 
 long time were worthy of envy. Their fall avenges 
 and natters us, and we are pitiless. 
 
 After having declared in all sincerity that I'was 
 entirely ignorant of the bank trouble, I asked the 
 mistress of the school if she was pleased with 
 Mademoiselle Alexandre.
 
 138 THE CRIME OF 
 
 " The child is incorrigible," cried Mademoiselle 
 Prefere, assuming a deeply pedantic attitude in 
 order to symbolize the situation in which she was 
 placed by such a fractious pupil. 
 
 Then, returning to a calmer mode of speech, 
 
 " This girl is not without intelligence," said she, 
 "but she cannot make up her mind to learn facts 
 by principles." 
 
 What a strange woman was Mademoiselle Pre"- 
 fere ! She walked without raising her feet, and 
 spoke without moving her lips. Without dwelling 
 longer than a reasonable amount of time on these 
 details, I replied that principles no doubt were ex- 
 cellent things, and that I deferred to her intelligence 
 on this point, but that, after all, when ohe knew a 
 fact, it did not much matter whether one had learned 
 it in one way or another. 
 
 Mademoiselle Pre"fere made a slow gesture of 
 denial. Then she sighed again. 
 
 "Ah, monsieur, people who are strangers to edu- 
 cation have very wrong ideas on the subject. I am 
 sure that they speak with the best intent in the 
 world ; but they would do better, much better, to re- 
 fer such questions to those who are competent." 
 
 I dropped the subject, and asked if I might see 
 Mademoiselle Alexandre without further delay. 
 
 She contemplated her pelerine as if to read in the 
 tangle of its fringe, as in a conjurer's book, what 
 answer she ought to make. At length she said, 
 
 " Mademoiselle Alexandre has a penance to do 
 and a lesson to give, but I should be inconsolable 
 to have you make a useless trip here. I will have
 
 SYLVESTKE BONNARD. 139 
 
 her called. But allow me, sir, as a matter of form, 
 to write your name on our visitors' register." 
 
 She sat down before the table, opened a large 
 blank-book, and drawing Maitre Mouche's letter 
 from under her pelerine where she had slipped it, 
 she said, 
 
 " ' Bonnard ' has a d, has it not? Pardon my in- 
 sisting on this detail. But in my opinion, proper 
 names have an orthography. Here, sir, we have 
 dictations in proper names historical names, of 
 course, you understand ! " 
 
 She inscribed my name in a scrawly hand, and 
 then asked if she could not append a title of some 
 kind, something like retired merchant, employd, 
 stockholder, or some other. Her registry had a 
 column for titles. 
 
 " Why, of course, madame, if you feel you must 
 fill out your column, put ' Member of the Insti- 
 tute.' " 
 
 I still saw before me Mademoiselle Pre"fere's 
 pelerine, but it was no longer Mademoiselle Prdfere 
 who wore it. She was another person, pleasing, 
 gracious, wheedling, merry, and radiant. Her eyes 
 smiled ; the little wrinkles on her face (and there 
 were many) smiled ; her mouth smiled too, but only 
 in one corner. I have since learned that it was the / 
 good corngr. When she spoke, her voice was in 
 accordance with her manner, it was like honey. 
 
 " You said just now, monsieur, that our dear 
 Jeanne was very intelligent. I have noticed it, and 
 I am proud to agree with you. Indeed, this young 
 girl is a source of great interest to me. She has
 
 140 THE CRIME OF 
 
 what I call a happy disposition. But forgive me 
 for wasting your precious time." 
 
 She called the servant, who came in greater haste 
 and looked more frightened than ever, and who dis- 
 appeared with the order to tell Mademoiselle Alex- 
 andre that Monsieur Sylvestre Bonnard, a Membei 
 of the Institute, was waiting for her in the parlor. 
 
 Mademoiselle Prdfere had only time to confide to 
 me that she had a profound respect for the decis- 
 ions of the Institute, whatever they might be, when 
 Jeanne appeared out of breath, as red as a peony, 
 her great eyes wide open, her arms swinging, charm- 
 ing in her innocent awkwardness. 
 
 "How you are dressed, dear child !" murmured 
 Mademoiselle Pre"fere, with the gentleness of a 
 mother, as she arranged the girl's collar. 
 
 Jeanne, in truth, was dressed in a queer fashion. 
 Her hair was drawn back into a net, from which 
 stray locks escaped ; her thin arms were covered to 
 the elbow with lustring sleeves ; her hands were 
 red and chapped, and she seemed greatly ashamed 
 of them ; her dress was too short, showing a pair 
 of baggy stockings and shoes trodden down at the 
 heels ; a jumping-rope was wound about her waist 
 like a belt, and the entire combination made Jeanne 
 rather unpresentable. 
 
 " Crazy little thing ! " murmured Mademoiselle 
 Prdfere, this time no longer the mother, but the 
 elder sister. Then she escaped, gliding like a 
 shadow over the slippery floor. 
 
 I said to Jeanne, 
 
 " Sit down, Jeanne, and talk to me as to a friend.
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 141 
 
 Are you not more contented here than you were last 
 year?" 
 
 She hesitated ; then with a sweet smile of resig- 
 nation, she replied, ' 
 
 " Not much more." 
 
 I begged her to tell me what she did in the school. 
 She began by enumerating all sorts of studies, piano, 
 style, chronology of the kings of France, sewing, 
 drawing, dancing, catechism, good manners I 
 know not what else ! in the meantime unconsciously 
 holding the two ends of the rope with which she 
 marked off her list. Suddenly, however, she no- 
 ticed what she was doing, blushed, stammered, and 
 I had to give up further knowledge of the complete 
 list of studies in the Pre"fere Institute. 
 
 I questioned Jeanne on various points ; but, ob- 
 taining the most confused answers, I saw that the 
 rope was occupying the whole attention of the young 
 girl, and I bravely touched upon this serious subject. 
 
 "You jump rope, I see," I said to her. "It is 
 good exercise, but must not be carried to excess; 
 for then it might seriously injure your health, and I 
 should never cease regretting it, Jeanne, never." 
 
 " You are very good, monsieur," replied the young 
 girl, " to come to see me, and speak to me as you 
 do. I did not think of thanking you when I first 
 came in, I was so surprised. Have you seen Ma- 
 dame de Gabry? Tell me about her, monsieur, will 
 you ? " 
 
 " Madame de Gabry," I replied, " is very well. I 
 might say of her, Jeanne, what an old gardener said 
 of the lady of the manor, his mistress, when some
 
 142 THE CRIME OF 
 
 one asked anxiously about her, ' Madame is on her 
 road.' Madame de Gabry is on hers ; and you know 
 how good a one it is, and with what even steps she 
 walks there. The other day I went a long distance 
 with her, and we spoke of you. We spoke of you, 
 my child, at your mother's grave." 
 
 " I am very glad," said Jeanne, and she began to 
 cry. 
 
 I let the young girl's tears flow in silence. Then, 
 as she dried her eyes, I asked, 
 
 " Jeanne, will you not tell me why this rope trou- 
 bled you just now ? " 
 
 "Yes, indeed, monsieur. It was because I should 
 not have come into the parlor with a rope. You 
 know that at my age a girl does not jump rope. When 
 the maid told me that an old gentleman oh ! a 
 gentleman was in the parlor and wished to see me, 
 I was making the children jump. Then I tied the 
 rope round my waist so as not to lose it. That was 
 wrong. But I am so little used to receiving guests ! 
 Mademoiselle Pre"fere never excuses faults in good 
 manners. She will certainly punish me, and I am 
 very sorry." 
 
 " Yes, Jeanne, that is too bad." 
 
 She looked very serious. " Yes, monsieur, that 
 is too bad, because when I am punished I have no 
 more authority over the little children." 
 
 I had no very clear idea on this unpleasant sub- 
 ject; but Jeanne explained that she was expected by 
 Mademoiselle Pre"fere to dress the children of the. 
 youngest class, wash them, teach them manners, the 
 alphabet, the use of the needle, to play with them
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 143 
 
 and to put them to bed, and that she could exact no 
 obedience from these restless little ones when she 
 was condemned to wear her nightcap in the class- 
 room, or while standing to eat her food from a plate 
 turned upside down. Secretly admiring the penal- 
 ties imposed by the Lady of the Enchanted Pele- 
 rine, I said, 
 
 " If I understand you, Jeanne, you are both pupil 
 and teacher. This is no uncommon thing in the 
 world. You are punished and you punish, in turn." 
 
 " Oh, monsieur ! " she exclaimed, " I never punish." 
 
 " And I imagine that this indulgence draws the 
 reprimands of Mademoiselle Pre'fere upon you." 
 
 She smiled, and nodded her head. 
 
 I told her then that the troubles we brought upon 
 ourselves in trying to do our best, according to the 
 dictates of our conscience, should not disgust or 
 weary us, for they were helpful trials. This philos- 
 ophy appealed to her but slightly. She seemed per- 
 fectly indifferent to my sermon. And what more 
 natural ? Do I not know that only those who are 
 no longer innocent take delight in moralizers ? I 
 was wise enough to cut short my preaching. 
 
 "Jeanne," I said, "you spoke just now of Ma- 
 dame de Gabry. Let us speak of your fairy. She 
 was very well made. Do you model wax figures 
 here ? " 
 
 " I have no wax," she replied, dropping her arms, 
 " no wax ! " 
 
 " No wax," I cried, " in a realm of bees ! " 
 
 She laughed. 
 
 " And then, you see, monsieur, my littleyfg-r<rj, as 
 
 
 .
 
 144 THE CRIME OF 
 
 you call them, are not on Mademoiselle Pre*fere's 
 
 program. But I began a little Saint-George lor 
 
 Madame de Gabry, a miniature Saint-George with 
 
 a golden breastplate. A golden breastplate is fine 
 
 for a Saint-George, is it not, Monsieur Bonnard ? " 
 
 "Very fine, Jeanne. But what became of it?" 
 
 " I will tell you. I kept it in my pocket, for I 
 
 had no other place to put it and I sat down on it." 
 
 She drew a little wax figure from her pocket. It 
 
 no longer had any human shape, and its broken 
 
 limbs were scarcely held together by their wire 
 
 thread. At sight of her hero thus destroyed, she 
 
 was filled with grief and merriment. The latter got 
 
 the better of her, and she burst into a peal of 
 
 laughter, which suddenly came to an end. 
 Mademoiselle Prdfere stood at the door of the 
 parlor, smiling. 
 
 " The dear child ! " sighed the mistress of the 
 school in her tenderest tone ; " I fear she will weary 
 you. Besides, your time is precious." 
 
 I begged Mademoiselle Pre"fere to dismiss that 
 illusion, and rose to take leave, first drawing from 
 my pockets some chocolate tablets and other sweets 
 that I had brought with me. 
 
 " Oh ! oh ! " cried Jeanne ; "there are enough for 
 the whole school." 
 
 The Lady of the Pelerine interposed. 
 
 " Mademoiselle Alexandre," said she, " thank the 
 gentleman for his generosity." 
 
 Jeanne gave her a rather sullen look ; then, turn- 
 ing to me, she said with remarkable firmness, 
 
 " I thank you, monsieur, for your kindness in 
 cominr to see me."
 
 SYLVESTKE BONNARD. 145 
 
 "Jeanne," said I, holding both her hands, "be a 
 good and brave girl. Good-by." 
 
 As she ran off with her packages of chocolate 
 and her sweets, the ends of her rope hit the back of 
 a chair. Mademoiselle Pre*fere was greatly shocked, 
 and pressed both hands to her heart under her pele- 
 rine. I expected to see her scholastic soul vanish 
 in a swoon. 
 
 When we were alone, her serenity returned ; and I 
 must say, without flattering myself, that she smiled 
 on me with one whole side of her face. 
 
 " Mademoiselle," said I, taking advantage of her 
 good humor, " I noticed that Jeanne Alexandre is a 
 little pale. You understand better than I how, at 
 her age, a girl needs rest and care. Do not let me 
 give offence by asking you to watch more closely 
 over her." 
 
 My words seemed to delight her. She gazed with 
 ecstasy at the spiral in the ceiling, and clasping her 
 hands, exclaimed, 
 
 " How well these noted men understand how to 
 stoop to the smallest details ! " 
 
 I observed that the health of a young girl was not 
 a small detail, and I had the honor of bidding her 
 good-day. But at the threshold she paused, and said 
 in a confidential way, 
 
 " Excuse my foolishness, monsieur. I am a wo- 
 man, and I love glory. I cannot hide from you the 
 fact that I am honored by the presence of a Member 
 of the Institute in my humble institution." 
 
 I excused the foolishness of Mademoiselle Pre*- 
 fere ; and thinking of Jeanne, with the blindness of
 
 146 THE CRIME OF 
 
 egotism I kept asking myself as I walked along, 
 " What shall we do with this child ? " 
 
 June 3. 
 
 That day I escorted to the cemetery of Marnes 
 an old friend who, according to Goethe's dictum, 
 had consented to die. The great Goethe, whose vi- 
 tal power was extraordinary, believed that one dies 
 only when one wishes to do so ; that is, when the last 
 of the forces which resist final decay, and the total- 
 ity of which makes life itself, are entirely destroyed. 
 In other words, he thought that one dies only when 
 one can no longer live. Well, it is only necessary to 
 understand one another ; and the beautiful thought 
 of Goethe, when one knows how to take it, leads to 
 the song of La Palisse. 
 
 So my good friend had consented to die, thanks 
 to two or three persuasive attacks of apoplexy, the 
 last of which was unanswerable. I had known him 
 but slightly during his lifetime ; but it seemed that 
 as soon as he was no more I became his friend, for 
 our colleagues told me, in a solemn tone and with 
 melancholy faces, that I was to be one of the pall- 
 bearers, and speak at the grave. 
 
 Having read, very poorly, a short address which 
 I had written as well as I could, and that is not 
 saying much, I went for a stroll among the woods 
 of Ville-d'Avray, and followed, without leaning too 
 heavily on the captain's cane, a hidden path, over 
 which the sunlight fell in golden disks. Never had 
 the odor of the grass and the damp leaves, or the 
 beauty of the sky above the trees, and the great 
 stillness of all vegetable growth, penetrated so deeply
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 147 
 
 into my heart and soul ; and the sadness that I felt 
 in this silence, broken by a sort of continual tinkling, 
 weighed both on my senses and on my soul ! 
 
 I sat down in the shadow of the roadside beneath 
 a clump of young oaks. And then I promised my- 
 self that I would not die, or at least that I would 
 not consent to die before sitting again beneath an 
 oak, where, in the calm of the open country, I could 
 think about the nature of the soul and the final aim 
 of man. A bee, whose brown corsage sparkled in 
 the sun like an armor of old gold, lighted on a mal- 
 low-flower of sombre richness, in full bloom upon 
 its tufted stalk. Surely it was not the first time I 
 had seen such a common sight, but I noticed it 
 then for the first time with such affectionate and 
 intelligent curiosity. I discovered that between the 
 insect and the plant there were all sorts of sympa- 
 thies, and a thousand ingenious relations which un- 
 til then I had never suspected. 
 
 Satiated with nectar, the insect flew away in a 
 straight line, and I rose as well as I could and re- 
 adjusted myself on my legs. 
 
 "Adieu," I said to the flower and the bee, 
 "adieu. May I live long enough to know the 
 secret of your harmonies ! I am very weary. But 
 man is so made that he finds rest from one labor 
 only by another. The flowers and the insects shall 
 rest me, if God is willing, after my philology and 
 diplomatics. What sense there is in the ancient 
 myth of Antaeus ! " 
 
 I have touched the earth, and I am a new man ; 
 and here at the age of seventy new interests rise in
 
 148 THE CRIME OF 
 
 me, as one sees shoots sprouting from the hollow 
 trunk of an old oak. 
 
 June 4. 
 
 I love to look from my window at the Seine and 
 
 j\ its quays on these soft gray mornings that give 
 
 such infinite softness to ^Tthings| I have^-gaawd 
 
 {fye azure sky which umoms. Its shining calm 
 
 aopaas the Bay of Naples. '^'t)ur Parisian sky i* , 
 yvCcAJt v . -^\ f**^&ftiys*. 
 
 more animated, more kind, more intelligent. It 
 
 smiles, threatens, caresses, is sad and gay, like a 
 
 human gaze. Just now it is pouring a soft light / 
 
 , , , , . , o^e^a^^JU-t 
 
 over the men and beasts of the city as they jpewwm 
 
 J . .p-**' 1 /V*JL 
 
 their daily labors. Beyond, on the opposite bank, 
 the longshoremen of the Port Saint-Nicolas are un-/ 
 loading cargoes of cattle-horns, while a line of ^uyh 
 
 standing on a gangplank briskly toss from one to 
 tb4*tfacr, sugar-loaves w.hirVi ir^Jjnally gfowfd away 
 
 within^ the hold of a steajn^hip,. X)n the northern 
 quay the cab-horses, Jt aiming fc rowc beneath the 
 
 shadow of the plane-trees, their heads in their noso^ 
 
 r . i 
 
 bags, *ftranquilly ea^flE, their oats, while the 
 
 
 I -*s^~3w4 tc . .. 
 
 coachmen aw* Uvmlyws; before the bar of the WIIK-- 
 
 A*^^*^! 1 ii i -t< ' ' s l ' ' ' " V >'" i 'ijT 1 : ll 
 
 ohap, all the li^^lte<?ptt>g a brp leoliout-for morn- 
 ing in Hill lit. / 
 
 r TtA/ The dealers in old /books ^deposit their cases on 
 r the parapet^- Theaejlilrinerchants of knowledge 
 
 ci>n>!antly live out-of-doors, wWi blouses pluyrd 
 1 ' 
 
 'ipr> n -by pyjtry b rj ^ T " ; aod so hardened have they 
 grown by the air, the rain, the hail, the snow, the 
 fog, and the broad sun, that they come to look like 
 the old statues on cathedrals. They are all friends 
 of mine ; and I scarcely ever pass their stalls without
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNAKD. 
 
 finding some old volume which, until then, I have 
 needed without in the least suspecting it. 
 
 On my return home, my housekeeper cries out that 
 I am tearing all my pockets, and filling the house 
 with old pamphlets which attract the rats. The'rese 
 is wise on this point, and it is just because she i& 
 wise that I pay no heed to her; for in spite. of my 
 quiet manner, I have always preferred the folly of 
 the passions to the wisdom of indifference. But 
 TjecairseTTmjf jp'assions are" not such as burst forth to 
 hurt and kill, the ordinary person does not notice 
 them. However, they stir me; and more than once 
 I have lost sleep over a few pages written by a for- 
 gotten monk, or printed by some humble apprentice 
 of Peter Schoffer. And if these lively emotions are 
 dying out in me, it is~Eecause I am dying out myself. 
 Our passions are ourselves. My old books are my- 
 self. I am old and motheaten like them. 
 
 A light breeze sweeps up the dust of the road 
 with the winged seeds of the plane-trees, and the bits 
 of hay that have fallen from the horses' mouths. It 
 is nothing but a cloud of dust; but seeing it rise re- 
 calls to my mind that in my boyhood I saw a simi- 
 lar cloud of dust rise, and my old Parisian heart is 
 deeply moved by it.. Everything that I see from my 
 window, the horizon extending on my left to the 
 hills of Chaillot, the Arc de Triomphe that looks 
 like a block of stone, the Seine, river of glory, and 
 its bridges, the linden-trees of the terrace of the Tui- 
 leries, the Louvre of the Renaissance, cut like a 
 jewel ; on my right, by the side of the Pont-Neuf, 
 POHS lutetiae novus diet us ^ as we read on old prints,
 
 150 THE CRIME OF- 
 
 the ancient and venerable Paris with its towers and 
 spires all that is my life, myself ; and I should be 
 nothing without these things which are reflected in 
 me with my thousand shades of thought, and which 
 inspire and animate me. This is why I love Paris 
 with such a deep affection. 
 
 Yet I am weary ; and I realize that no one can 
 rest in the heart of this city, which thinks so much, 
 which has taught me to think, and which ceaselessly 
 urges me to think. How can one help but be excited 
 in the midst of the books which constantly rouse my 
 interest, and weary without satisfying it ? Now it 
 is a date that must be found, now a place which it 
 is necessary to determine precisely, or some old ex- 
 pression, the real meaning of which it is interesting 
 to know. Words ? Yes, they are words ; and as a 
 philologist, I am their king; they are my subjects, 
 and I, like a good king, give them my whole life. 
 
 Can I not abdicate some day ? I imagine that 
 somewhere, far from here, there is, at the edge of the 
 wood, a little cottage, where I should find the rest I 
 need, while waiting for the great irrevocable Rest 
 that will envelop me forever. I dream of a bench 
 at the door, and of fields as far as eye can see. But 
 a young face must smile beside me, in order to re- 
 flect and concentrate all the freshness about me. I 
 could imagine myself a grandfather ; then the whole 
 void of my life would be filled. 
 
 I am not a man of violent temper; and yet I am 
 easily irritated, and all my labors have caused me 
 as much pain as pleasure. I do not know why I 
 gave a thought, three months ago, to the silly and
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. !$! 
 
 impertinent remark which my young friend of the 
 Luxembourg took the liberty to make about me. I 
 do not use the word " friend " in any ironical sense, 
 for I love studious youth with its audacities and 
 mental flights. But my young friend went beyond 
 all limit. Master Ambroise Par^the first to under- 
 stand the ligature of the arteries, and who, having 
 found surgery practised by barbers on empirical 
 lines, raised it to where it is to-day, was attacked in 
 his old age by every conceited young leech. Taken 
 to task by a thoughtless youngster, who might have 
 been the best son in the world, but who lacked all 
 feeling of reverence, the aged master replied to him 
 in his treatise on The Mummy, the Unicorn, Poi- 
 sons and the Plagued " I beg of him," said the 
 great man, " I beg of him, if he desires to oppose 
 my reply, to give up personal feelings, and treat the 
 old man more kindly." 
 
 This reply is admirable from the pen of Ambroise 
 Pare* ; but had it come from a village bone-setter, 
 grown old over his work, and ridiculed by a strip- 
 ling, it would still be praiseworthy. 
 
 It will perhaps be thought that this remembrance 
 is but the awakening of contemptible resentment. 
 I thought so, too, and blamed myself for giving a 
 thought to a mere boy, who had no idea of what he 
 was saying. But my ideas on this subject turned 
 into a better channel ; this is why I note them down 
 in my diary. I remembered that one fine day, when 
 I was not more than twenty (more than half a cen- 
 tury ago), I was walking with some companions in 
 
 1 De la. Mumie, de la. Licornt, dti I 'en ins et dt la /'este.
 
 I$2 THE CRIME OF 
 
 this same garden of the Luxembourg. We were 
 talking of our old masters ; and one of us mentioned 
 Monsieur Petit-Radel, a respectable scholar, who 
 was the first to throw a gleam of light on the origin 
 of the Etruscans, but who had been unfortunate 
 enough to prepare a chronological table of the lov- 
 ers of Helen. This table caused us much merri- 
 ment ; and I cried, 
 
 " Petit-Radel is an ass, not of three letters, but of 
 a dozen volumes ! " 
 
 That youthful remark is too light to weigh upon 
 an old man's conscience. If I have hurled only 
 such harmless missiles in the battle of life ! But 
 I ask myself to-day, if, during my lifetime, I have 
 not done, though unconsciously, something as fool- 
 ish as the chronological table of the lovers of Helen. 
 The progress of sciences renders useless the works 
 which have most aided that progress. As these 
 labors are no longer of much account, youth natu- 
 rally believes that they have never been of use she 
 despises them ; and if any antiquated idea is found, 
 she laughs at it. That is why, at the age of twenty, 
 I made fun of Monsieur Petit-Radel and his honest 
 chronological table. That is why, yesterday, in the 
 Luxembourg, my young and disrespectful friend 
 
 " Look to thyself, Octavins, nor complain. 
 
 Wouldst thou hope to be spared, thou, that sparest in vain ? " * 
 
 June 6. 
 
 It was the first Thursday of June. I closed my 
 books, and took leave of the holy Abbot Droctoveus, 
 
 1 " Renlre en toi-mtme, Octave, et cesse de te plaindre. 
 Quai I tu veux yu'en flpargne et u'as rien ipargni ? "
 
 SYL VESTRE BONNARD. I 5 3 
 
 who, as he is now enjoying celestial happiness, is in 
 no haste. I think to see his name and his works 
 glorified on this earth in a humble volume by my 
 hands./ Shall I admit it? that mallow-stock that I 
 
 *" 
 
 saw the other day, and the bee that lighted upon it, 
 have occupied my thoughts much more than all the 
 old abbots with their crosses and mitres. In my 
 youth, when I read everything, I came across a vol- 
 ume by Sprengel, which contained some theories 
 about the loves of the flowers. These came back 
 to me after having been forgotten for half a century ; 
 and I am so much interested in them to-day, that I 
 am sorry that I did not consecrate my humble tal- 
 ents to the study of insects and plants. 
 
 Just now my housekeeper surprised me at the 
 kitchen window, examining, through a magnifying- 
 glass, the corolla of a gillyflower. 
 
 These reflections occurred to me as I was look- 
 ing for my cravat. But having rummaged in vain 
 through a number of drawers, I resorted to my 
 housekeeper. The'rese came limpingly into the 
 room. 
 
 "Monsieur," said she, "you should have told me 
 that you were going out, and I would have given 
 you your cravat." 
 
 " But, The'rese," I replied, "would it not be better 
 to have some place for it where I could find it with- 
 out your help ? " 
 
 The'rese did not deign to reply. She no longer 
 allows me to make arrangements about anything. 
 I cannot have even a handkerchief without asking 
 her for it ; and as she is deaf and infirm, and what
 
 154 TIIE CRIME OF 
 
 is still worse, is losing her memory, I languish in a 
 constant state of destitution. But she exercises her 
 domestic authority with such a tranquil pride that 
 I have hot the courage to attempt a stroke of state- 
 policy agVinst the government of my wardrobe. 
 
 " My cravat ! The'rese, do you hear ? My cra- 
 vat ! or if you drive me to distraction by further 
 delay, I shalK not need a cravat, but a rope with 
 which to hang myself." 
 
 " You are in\ great haste, monsieur," replies 
 The'rese. " Your\cravat is not lost. Nothing is 
 lost here, for I look \after everything. But at least 
 give me time to find it." 
 
 " Behold," I think to myself, " behold the result 
 of half a century of devotion. Ah ! if by some 
 happy chance this inexorable The'rese had once, 
 only once in her life, failed in her duty as a servant, 
 if, for an instant, she had been at fault, she would 
 not hold this despotic rule over me, or at least I 
 should have dared to resist her. But how can one 
 rebel against goodness ? People without any weak- 
 ness are dreadful. One has no hold upon them. 
 Take The'rese, for example : she has not a fault to 
 which I can take exception. She doubts neither 
 herself, nor God, nor the world. She is the strong 
 woman, the wise virgin of the Scriptures; and if 
 men do not know her, I do. In my mind's eye I 
 see her, bearing in her hand a lamp, a humble 
 household lamp, that shines beneath the joists of 
 a rustic roof, and which will never go out while 
 held by that meagre arm, as scraggy and as strong 
 as a vine-shoot.
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 155 
 
 " There*se, my cravat ! Do you not know, 
 [wretched woman, that to-day is the first Thursday 
 in June, and that Mademoiselle Jeanne is expecting 
 me? The mistress of the school will undoubtedly 
 JTavphaf^hqr floor highly wavpH I am sure that 
 already one can see one's self in it ; and it will be a 
 distraction for me when I break my bones, which I 
 certainly shall do before long, to see my sad face in 
 it, as in a mirror. Then, taking as a model the good 
 and excellent hero whose image is carved on my 
 uncle Victor's cane, I shall try not to make too hid- 
 eous a face. See the beautiful sunshine. The 
 quays are gilded with it, and the Seine smiles in 
 countless little sparkling wrinkles. The city is 
 golden a light golden dust-cloud, like a wealth of 
 hair, floats over its beautiful contours. Therese, 
 my cravat^ Ah ! I sympathize now with good mas- 
 ter Chrysal, who used to lay his neckbands between 
 the pages of a thick Plutarch. I will follow his 
 example, and hereafter I will put all my cravats be- 
 tween the leaves of the Acta Sanctorum." 
 
 The*rese in silence proceeded with her search, 
 letting me talk. At last I heard a gentle ring at our 
 door. 
 
 " The>ese," said I, "some one is ringing. Give 
 me my cravat, and go and open the door ; or rather, 
 go and open the door first, and then, by the help of 
 Heaven, you may give me my cravat. But do not 
 stand like that, I beg you, between my dressing- 
 table and the door, like, if I dare to use such a sim- 
 ile, a hackney between two saddles." 
 
 The"rese strode to the door as toward an enemy.
 
 156 THE CRIME OF 
 
 My good housekeeper is becoming very inhospitable 
 as she grows old. A stranger is a suspicious char- 
 acter to her. According to her own account, this 
 feeling comes from a long experience with men. I 
 never had the time to consider if the same experi- 
 ence made by another experimenter would produce 
 the same result. Maitre Mouche was waiting for 
 me in my library. 
 
 Maitre Mouche is even yellower than I thought. 
 He wears blue glasses, and his eyes keep shifting 
 behind them like mice behind a screen. 
 
 Maitre Mouche apologizes for troubling me at a 
 time he does not designate what time, but I think 
 that he means to say at a time when I have no 
 cravat on. But this, as you know, is not my fault. 
 Maitre Mouche, who knows nothing about it, does 
 not seem at all offended. He simply fears that he 
 has arrived at an inconvenient hour, but I partly re- 
 assure him. He says that, as the guardian of Ma- 
 demoiselle Alexandre, he has come to speak to me. 
 In the first place, he begs me to pay no attention to 
 the restrictions which at first he had thought best 
 to place upon the permission given us for seeing 
 Mademoiselle Jeanne in school. Henceforth the 
 establishment of Mademoiselle Pre'fere will be open 
 to me every day between twelve o'clock an<J four. 
 Knowing the interest I take in this young girl, he 
 thinks it his duty to tell me something of the person 
 to whose care he has intrusted his ward. Made- 
 moiselle Pre'fere, whom he has known for years, has 
 his entire confidence. According to his ideas she is 
 an intelligent woman, of sound common-sense and 
 fine manners.
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 157 
 
 " Mademoiselle Pre"fere," said he, " is a woman of 
 principles, and that is a rare thing, monsieur, in these 
 days. There has been a great change, and this 
 age is not equal to those that have preceded it." 
 
 " Take my stairway, for example, monsieur," I re- 
 plied*. " Twenty-five years ago it used to let me 
 climb it with perfect ease, and now it tires my legs 
 and makes me out of breath to mount the very 
 first steps. It has become spoiled. There are the 
 papers, and the books too, that once I devoured in 
 the moonlight without any difficulty; but to-day, in 
 the brightest sunlight, they mock my interest, and 
 show me nothing but white and black when I am 
 without glasses. I have gout in my limbs. This, 
 again, is one of the evils of the times." 
 
 " Not only that, monsieur," gravely replied Maitre 
 Mouche, " but the real evil of the present age is the 
 fact that no one is satisfied with his position. There 
 is an uneasiness, an unrest, a thirst for the comforts 
 of life in every class of society, from the lowest to 
 the highest." 
 
 " Heavens, monsieur ! " I cried, " do you consider 
 that this thirst for comfort is a sign of the times? 
 Men have at no time had a desire for discomfort. 
 They have always tried to better their condition. 
 This constant effort has produced constant change. 
 It still continues, that is all." 
 
 "Ah, monsieur," replied Maitre Mouche, "it is 
 easy to see that you live among your books, far 
 from the world. You do not see, as I do, the con- 
 flicts of interest, the struggle for money. You find 
 in the great and the small the same effervescence.
 
 158 THE CRIME OF 
 
 People give themselves up to unbridled speculation. 
 What I see frightens me." 
 
 I was beginning to wonder if Maitre Mouche had 
 come to my house simply to tell me his virtuous mis- 
 anthropy ; but soon I heard more cheering words 
 from him. Maitre Mouche described Virginie Prd- 
 ,re to me as a woman worthy of respect, of esteem, 
 and of sympathy ; the soul of honor, capable of af- 
 fection, educated, discreet, a good reader, modest 
 and skilful in the art of applying blisters! I under- 
 stood then that he had given me such a gloomy pic- 
 ture of universal corruption in order to bring out by 
 contrast the virtues of the schoolmistress. I was 
 told that the establishment of the rue Demours was 
 well patronized, successful, and highly esteemed. In 
 order to give emphasis to his statements, Maitre 
 Mouche_waved his hand with its black woollen 
 glove. vThen he added, 
 
 " In the practice of my profession I have come to 
 know the world. A notary is somewhat of a con- 
 fessor. I considered it my duty, monsieur, to tell you 
 these facts, now that a happy chance has brought 
 you into relationship with Mademoiselle Prdfere. I 
 have but one word to add. This lady, who is abso- 
 lutely ignorant of my visit to you, spoke to me of 
 you the other day in terms of the highest praise. I 
 should only weaken them by repeating them to you ; 
 moreover, I could not tell them without, in a way, 
 betraying the confidence of Mademoiselle Prdfere." 
 
 " Do not betray it, monsieur," I replied, " do not 
 betray it. To tell you the truth, I was quite una- 
 ware that Mademoiselle Prdfere had the slightest
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNAKD. 159 
 
 knowledge of me, However, since you have the ad- 
 vantage of such a long-standing friendship with her, 
 I will profit by your good will towards me, and beg 
 you to use your influence with your friend in favor 
 of Mademoiselle Jeanne Alexandre. The child, for 
 she is still such, is overtaxed with work. At once 
 pupil and teacher, she has too much to do. More 
 than this, she is punished in an absurdly childish 
 manner; and hers is a generous nature, which by 
 humiliation may be driven to revolt." 
 
 "Alas!" replied Maltre Mouche, "she must be 
 prepared for life. We are not in the world to enjoy 
 ourselves, and to have our own way." 
 
 "We are in the world," I replied with some 
 warmth, " to take pleasure in the good and the 
 beautiful, and to follow our own way when it is no- 
 ble, holy, and generous. An education which does 
 not train the will is one that depraves the mind. 
 The instructor must teach us how to will." 
 
 I imagined that Maitre Mouche thought me a 
 poor sort of fellow. He proceeded with great calm- 
 ness and assurance, 
 
 " Remember, monsieur, that the education of the 
 poor should be made with great care, and with a 
 view toward the state of dependence which they will 
 hold in society. Possibly you are not aware that 
 the late Noel Alexandre died insolvent, and that his 
 daughter is brought up almost by charity." 
 
 " Oh, monsieur ! " I cried, " do not say that. To 
 say it is to pay one's self back, and then it could 
 no longer be true." 
 
 "The debts of the estate exceeded the assets,"
 
 I6O THE CRIME OF 
 
 continued the notary; "but I have arranged with 
 the creditors in favor of the minor." 
 
 He offered to explain in detail ; but I declined to 
 put him to that trouble, being incapable of compre- 
 hending business affairs in general, and those of 
 Maitre Mouche in particular. The notary began 
 again to uphold Mademoiselle Pre"fere's system of 
 education, and said to me in conclusion, 
 " We do not learn by amusing ourselves." ' 
 " We learn only by amusing ourselves,".'! replied. 
 " The art of teaching is but the art of rousing the 
 interest of young minds in order to satisfy it later, 
 and interest is alert and healthy only in happy minds. 
 Knowledge, forced and crammed into the mind, 
 chokes and suffocates it. In order that knowledge 
 may be digested, it must be swallowed with relish. 
 I know Jeanne. If this child were intrusted to my 
 care, I would make of her not a student, for I wish 
 her well, but a girl of quick intelligence and full of 
 life, in whom everything beautiful in nature and art 
 would evoke a sweet yet brilliant response. I would 
 teach her to live in sympathy with the beautiful 
 country, with the ideal scenes of poetry and history, 
 with music that appeals to our noblest emotions. 
 I .wouldmake lovable everything thatJLwanted her 
 to love. I would gurfi distinction even to needle- 
 work, by the selection of fabrics, the choice of em- 
 broideries, and the style of laces. She should have 
 a beautiful dog and a pony, in order that she might 
 know how to govern animals ; she should have birds 
 to care for, that she might learn the value of a drop 
 of water and a crumb of bread. And in order to
 
 SYLVESTKE BONNARD. l6l 
 
 give her still another pleasure, I should want her 
 to find pleasure in being charitable. 
 
 " Then, since sorrow is inevitable, since life is full 
 of grief, I would teach her that Christian wisdom 
 which lifts us above every grief, and makes even 
 sorrow beautiful. That is how I would direct a 
 young girl's education." 
 
 " I bow before you," said Maitre Mouche, clasp- 
 ing his hands in their black woollen gloves. Then 
 he rose. 
 
 " You understand, of course," said I, as I went 
 with him to the door, " that I do not pretend to im- 
 pose on Mademoiselle Pre'fere my system of edu- 
 cation, which is essentially a home-training, and 
 entirely incompatible with the organization of the 
 best schools. I merely beg you to ask her to give 
 Jeanne less work and more play, to punish her only 
 in case of necessity, and to allow her as much free- 
 dom of mind and body as confirms to the rule of the 
 school." 
 
 Maitre Mouche assured me, with a weak and mys- 
 terious smile, that my wishes would be taken in good 
 part, and that they would have great weight 
 
 He then made me a little bow and went away, 
 leaving me in a state of worry and unrest. I have 
 had to deal in my life with various kinds of people, 
 but never with any like this notary or this school 
 mistress. 
 
 July 5. 
 
 Maitre Mouche kept me so long by his visit that-* 
 I gave up going to see Jeanne that day. ProfesA 
 sional duties detained me at home for the rest of the
 
 1 62 THE CRIME OF 
 
 week. Although I have reached the age when most 
 men retire from active duties, I am still bound by a 
 thousand ties to the life in which I have lived. I 
 preside at meetings of academies, congresses, and 
 societies. I am overwhelmed with honorary func- 
 tions. I fill as many as seven of these in one gov- 
 ernment department. The offices would like to get 
 rid of me, and I of them ; but habit is stronger than 
 they and I together. So, limpingly, I mount the 
 stairways of the state buildings. After I pass, the 
 old clerks will point me out to one another, wander- 
 ing like a shadow through the halls. When one is 
 very old, it becomes extremely difficult to disappear. 
 However, it is time, as runs the song, to retire on my 
 pension, and prepare for a peaceful end. 
 
 An old marchioness of a philosophic turn, a friend 
 of Helvetius in her early days, I used to see her at 
 my father's in her old age, received, during her last 
 illness, a visit from her curate, who came to prepare 
 her to die. 
 
 " Is it really necessary ? " she asked him. " I see 
 that every one succeeds perfectly the first time." 
 
 My father went to see her a short time after, and 
 found her very ill. 
 
 " Good-evening, my dear friend," said she, as she 
 pressed his hand ; " I am going to see if God im- 
 proves on acquaintance." 
 
 That is how the " beautiful friends " of the phi- 
 losophers used to die. Their method is not vul- 
 garly impertinent, and frivolous remarks such as 
 theirs are not begotten in the heads of fools. But 
 they shock me. Neither my hopes nor my fears are
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNAKD. 163 
 
 compatible with such a mode of departure. For 
 mine, I should want meditation-, and therefore I 
 must begin to think, in a year or two, about giving 
 myself up to myself. Without this, I should risk 
 but hush ! if He be passing, let Him not hear the 
 sound of His name and turn back! I am still able 
 to raise my burden alone. 
 
 I found Jeanne very happy. She told me that 
 last Thursday after her guardian's visit, Mademoi- 
 selle Pre*fere had excused her from the rules of the 
 school, and lightened many of her duties. Since 
 that happy Thursday she could walk freely in the 
 garden, where only flowers and leaves were lacking. 
 She had even the facilities for modelling her unfor- 
 tunate little Saint-George. 
 
 " I know very well that I owe all this to you," 
 said she, smiling. 
 
 I spoke to her of other things, but I noticed that 
 her attention wandered in spite of her. 
 
 " I see that something is on your mind," said I. 
 " Tell me about it, or else we shall be talking to no 
 purpose, and that would not be worth while for 
 either of us." 
 
 She answered, 
 
 " Oh, monsieur ! I heard you perfectly ; but it is 
 true that I was thinking of something else. You 
 will forgive me, will you not ? I was thinking that 
 Mademoiselle Pre"fere must be very fond of you to 
 have grown so good to me all of a sudden." 
 
 She looked at me in a smiling, yet frightened way 
 that made me laugh. 
 
 ' So that surprises you, does it ? " I asked.
 
 164 THE CRIME OF 
 
 " Yes, very much," she replied. 
 
 " Why ? if you do not mind telling." 
 
 " Because I do not see any reason, not the least 
 but there ! no, not the least in the world, why you 
 should please Mademoiselle Pre'fere." 
 
 " Do you think me so very disagreeable, Jeanne ? '' 
 
 She bit her lips as if to punish them for what 
 they had said ; then, opening her great soft eyes like 
 those of a water-spaniel, she continued in a wheed- 
 ling tone, 
 
 " I know very well that I have made a blunder, 
 but truly I do not see any reason why you should 
 please Mademoiselle Pre'fere. And yet you do 
 please her very, very much. She called me to her, 
 and asked me all sorts of questions about you." 
 
 " Did she really ? " 
 
 ' Yes ; she wanted to know about your home. 
 Just imagine ! she asked me how old your house- 
 keeper was." 
 
 And Jeanne burst out laughing. 
 
 "Well," said I, "what do you think about it?" 
 
 For several moments her eyes were fixed on the 
 worn-out cloth of her boots. She seemed lost in 
 deep meditation. At last she raised her head. 
 
 " I am suspicious," said she. " It is very natural, 
 is it not, that we should be anxious about what we 
 do not understand. I know well enough that I am 
 silly, but I hope you are not angry with me." 
 
 " No, indeed, Jeanne. I am not at all angry." 
 
 I confess that her surprise was beginning to affect 
 me, and I kept revolving in my old head the girl's 
 words, ' we are anxious about wht we do not un-
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 165 
 
 derstand.' But with a fresh burst of laughter, she 
 cried, 
 
 " She asked me guess ! I will give you a hun- 
 dred, I will give you a thousand guesses. Do you 
 give it up ? Well, she asked me if you liked good 
 living." 
 
 " And how did you answer all this storm of ques- 
 tions, Jeanne ? " 
 
 ' I answered, ' I do not know, mademoiselle.' 
 And then mademoiselle said, You are a little goose. 
 The smallest details in the life of a great man should 
 be noticed. You must know, mademoiselle, that 
 Monsieur Sylvestre Bonnard is one of the glories of 
 France.' " 
 
 " Nonsense ! " I cried. " And what do you think 
 about it, mademoiselle ? " 
 
 " I think that Mademoiselle Pre'fere was right 
 But I do not care (what I am going to tell you 
 is naughty!) I do not care, I don't care at all 
 whether Mademoiselle Pre'fere is right or not about 
 anything." 
 
 " Well, then, be contented, Jeanne ; Mademoiselle 
 Pre'fere was not right." 
 
 " Yes, she was, yes, she was ; she was perfectly 
 right. But I wanted to love every one who loves 
 you, without one exception, and I cannot do so; for 
 it never would be possible for me to love Mademoi-^ 
 selle Pre'fere." 
 
 " Listen to me, Jeanne," I replied gravely. 
 " Mademoiselle Pre'fere has become good to you, 
 be good to her." 
 
 She answered in a hard tone,
 
 1 66 THE CRIME OF 
 
 " It is very easy for Mademoiselle PreTere to be 
 good to me, and it would be very hard for me to 
 be good to her." 
 
 In a still more serious tone, I said, 
 
 " My child, the authority of a teacher is sacred. 
 Your schoolmistress takes the place of the mother 
 whom you have lost." 
 
 Scarcely had I uttered this solemn nonsense ere 
 I repented bitterly. The young girl's face grew 
 white, her eyes filled. 
 
 " Oh, monsieur ! " she cried, " how can you say 
 such a thing? You did not know mamma." 
 
 Ah, just Heaven ! but I had known her mother, 
 and how could I have said such a thing? She kept 
 saying over and over, 
 
 " Mamma ! my dear mamma, my poor mamma ! " 
 
 Chance prevented my becoming a perfect fool. I 
 do not know how it happened that I looked as if I were 
 crying. At my age one does not cry ! It must have 
 been a bad cough that drew the tears to my eyes. 
 It was a natural mistake. Jeanne made that mistake. v 
 
 Oh, what a fine, what a radiant smile shone under 
 her pretty wet lashes, like the sunlight among the 
 branches after a summer rain ! We took each other 
 by the hand, and stood for a long time in happy 
 silence. The heavenly strains that I had heard in 
 my heart, at the grave to which a good woman had 
 taken me, echoed again in my heart with infinite 
 sweetness. The child whose hands I held heard 
 them no doubt ; and the poor old man and the inno- 
 cent young girl, carried away from the world, saw 
 for an instant the same spirit hovering over them.
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 1 67 
 
 " My child," said I at last, " I am very old, and'N 
 many of the secrets of life which you will learn by 
 degrees are already revealed to me. Believe me, 
 the future is the outgrowth of the past. All that 
 you do in order to live a good life here, without re- 
 bellion and bitterness, will help you to live some 
 day in peace and joy in your home. Be gentle, and 
 learn how to suffer. When_pne knows how to suffer, 
 one suffers less. If some day you should have real 
 cause for complaint, I shall be there to hear you. 
 If any one offends you, Madame de Gabry and I 
 shall be offended too." 
 
 " Is your health very good indeed, my dear mon- 
 sieur ? " 
 
 It was Mademoiselle Pre'fere. She had come in 
 stealthily, and she smiled as she asked me the ques- 
 tion. My first thought was to tell her to go to the 
 devil; my second to remark that her mouth was 
 about as well adapted for smiles as a saucepan for 
 playing the violin with ; my third was to return her 
 courtesy, and say that I hoped she was well. 
 
 She sent the young girl to walk in the garden. 
 Then, with one hand on her shawl, and the other 
 raised toward the Honor List, she pointed to the 
 name of Jeanne Alexandre written in round letters 
 at the head of the list 
 
 "I see with genuine pleasure," said I, "that you 
 are pleased with this child's conduct. Nothing 
 could delight me more, and I must attribute this 
 happy result to your loving care. I have taken the 
 liberty to have some books sent to you, which may in- 
 terest and instruct the young ladies. After you have
 
 1 68 THE CRIME OF 
 
 glanced at them, you will readily see if you wish 
 to give them to mademoiselle and her companions." 
 
 The schoolmistress's gratitude went so far as to 
 become tearful, and still continued in words. In 
 order to cut it short, I said, 
 
 " What a beautiful day it is ! " 
 
 "Yes," she replied; "and if it continues, these 
 dear little girls will have fine weather for their 
 outing." 
 
 " I suppose you mean their vacation. But Made- 
 moiselle Alexandre, who is an orphan, cannot leave 
 the school. What in the world will she do in this 
 great empty house ? " 
 
 " We will give her all the pleasure in our power. 
 I will take her to the museums, and " 
 
 She hesitated, blushed, and added, 
 
 " And to your house, if I may." 
 
 " Why, of course ! " I cried ; " that is an excellent 
 idea." 
 
 We parted very good friends. I, because I had 
 obtained what I wanted. She, from no apparent 
 reason ; and that, according to Plato, places her in 
 the highest circle of the hierarchy of souls. 
 
 And yet I have a presentiment of misfortune in 
 bringing this woman into my house. I should like 
 it if Jeanne were in some other hands than hers. 
 Maitre Mouche and Mademoiselle Pre"fere are be- 
 yond my comprehension. I never know why they 
 say what they say, or why they do what they do. 
 There is a mysterious depth to them that makes me 
 feel uneasy. As Jeanne said just now, " We are 
 anxious about what we do not understand."
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 169 
 
 Alas ! at my age, we know too well how seldom 
 life is free from evil ; we know too well what we 
 lose by dwelling in this world, and we have confi- 
 dence only in youth. ^ 
 
 August 16. ~ 
 
 I was waiting for them. Indeed, I was impatiently \ 
 waiting for them. I have been exerting all the tal- 
 ent I possess in the art of pleasing and coaxing, so 
 as to wheedle The'rese into welcoming them kindly; 
 but my powers are limited. 
 
 They came. Jeanne was very smart looking in- 
 deed ! She is not her mother, of course ; but I no- 
 ticed to-day, for the first time, that she has a pleas- 
 ing face, which in this world is very advantageous 
 to a woman. I thought that her hat was somewhat 
 crooked ; but she smiled, and the City of Books was 
 illuminated. 
 
 I looked at The'rese to see if her old-guardian 
 sternness had relaxed at sight of the young girl. I 
 saw her gazing at Jeanne with her dull eyes, her 
 long face, her hollow mouth, and her pointed chin 
 that looks like that of some powerful old fairy. But 
 that was all. 
 
 Mademoiselle Pre*fere, dressed in blue, advanced, 
 retreated, skipped, trotted, cried out, sighed, raised 
 her eyes, lowered her eyes, stammered, she did not 
 dare, she dared, again she did not dare, yet she dared 
 again, courtesied in short, it was like the manoeu- 
 vres in a riding-school. 
 
 " Oh, what quantities of books ! " she cried ; " and 
 you have read them all, Monsieur Bonnard ? " 
 
 " Yes, unfortunately," I replied ; " and that is why
 
 I7O THE CRIME OF 
 
 I know nothing at all ; for there is not one of these 
 books that does not contradict some other, so that 
 when you have read them all, you know not what to 
 think. This is my case, madame." 
 
 At this point she called Jeanne to tell her how 
 she felt about it. But Jeanne was looking out of 
 the window. 
 
 " How beautiful it is ! " she said to us. " I do so 
 love to watch the river. It makes one think of all 
 sorts of things." 
 
 Mademoiselle Prdfere having removed her hat, 
 and displayed a brow adorned with blond curls, my 
 housekeeper pounced upon the hat with emphasis, 
 saying that she did not like to have clothes lying 
 about on the furniture. Then she asked Jeanne for 
 her things, calling her ma petite demoiselle (" my lit- 
 tle lady)." The little lady gave up her cloak and 
 hat, exposing to view a graceful neck and a rounded 
 figure, the lines of which stood out in beautiful relief 
 against the strong light from the windows. I could 
 have wished that she might be seen at that moment 
 by some one else besides an antiquated housekeeper, 
 a schoolmistress frizzed like a sheep, and an old 
 fossil whose life had been given to archaeology and 
 books. 
 
 " So you are looking at the Seine," I said to her. 
 " See how it sparkles in the sun." 
 
 "Yes," she said, as she leaned out with her elbow 
 on the window-ledge ; " it looks .like a running flame. 
 But see how cool it looks over there under the wil- 
 lows on the bank that it reflects. I like that little 
 nook better than all the rest."
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. \Jl 
 
 " Come," said I, " I see that the river charms you. 
 What would you say if, with the consent of Made- 
 moiselle Prdfere, we were to make an excursion to 
 Saint-Cloud by the steamboat that is sure to be 
 below the Pont-Royal ? " 
 
 Jeanne was delighted with the idea, and Made- 
 moiselle Prdfere was willing to make any sacrifice. 
 But my housekeeper would not hear of our going in 
 any such way She took me into the dining-room, 
 where I followed her in fear and trembling. 
 
 " Monsieur," said she, when we were alone, " you 
 never think of anything, and I have to think of 
 everything. Fortunately I have a good memory." 
 
 I did not think it a seasonable moment to shatter 
 this rash illusion. She continued, 
 
 " The idea of your going away without telling me 
 what the little lady likes. Girls at her age are 
 stupid; they have no special tastes; they eat like 
 birds. You are very hard to please, monsieur, but 
 at least you know what is good. It is not so with 
 these young things. They know nothing about 
 cooking. They often think that the worst is the 
 best ; and the worst seems good to them, because 
 their stomachs are not yet formed, so that one does 
 not know what to do for them. Tell me, does the 
 little lady like pigeons with sweet pease and vanilla 
 cream ?" 
 
 " My good TheVese," I replied, " get whatever you 
 think best, and it will be right. These ladies will be 
 pleased with a simple dinner, such as we usually 
 have." 
 
 TheVese answered dryly,
 
 1/2 THE CRIME OF 
 
 " Monsieur, I am speaking to you of the little lady. 
 She must not leave the house without having had 
 some good of it. As to the old frizzle-head, if my 
 dinner does not suit her, she may suck, her thumbs. 
 What do I care about her?" 
 
 I .returned with a quiet mind to the City of 
 Books, where Mademoiselle Prefere was crocheting 
 as calmly as if she had been at home. I almost be- 
 lieved she was. She occupied but a small space, it 
 is true, in a corner by the window. But she had 
 chosen her chair and her stool so well that they 
 seemed made for her. 
 
 Jeanne, on the other hand, was gazing at the 
 books and pictures with a look almost of sadness, 
 which seemed to be bidding them an affectionate 
 good-by. 
 
 " Here," said I, " amuse yourself in looking over 
 this book, which cannot fail to please you, for it con- 
 tains some beautiful engravings ; " and I laid before 
 her the collection of costumes by Vecellio. Not a 
 cheap copy, I will beg you to observe, poorly repro- 
 duced by modern artists, but a magnificent and ven- 
 erable copy of the editio princeps, which in beauty 
 equals the noble women upon its yellow pages, made 
 more beautiful by time. 
 
 Jeanne looked over the engravings with girlish 
 interest, and turning to me, said, 
 
 " We were speaking of an excursion, but you are 
 taking me on a journey. I should like to go a long, 
 long way ! " 
 
 " Well, then, mademoiselle," said I, "you must ar- 
 range yourself comfortably for travelling. You are
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 1 73 
 
 sitting on the edge of your chair, and tipping it up 
 on one leg, and Vecellio must be tiring your knees. 
 Sit down comfortably, put your chair straight, and 
 lay the book on the table. 
 
 She obeyed me with a laugh. 
 
 I watched her. At last she cried out, 
 
 " Oh ! come and see this lovely costume ! (It was 
 that of a doge's wife.) How splendid it is, and 
 what magnificent ideas it gives one ! I am going to 
 tell you something I adore pretty things." 
 
 " You must not express such thoughts, made- 
 moiselle," said the schoolmistress, lifting her shape- 
 less little nose from her work. 
 
 "^tnd yet there is no harm in that," said I ; " there 
 are sumptuous minds that have an inborn love of 
 sumptuousness." 
 
 The shapeless little nose sank down again im- 
 mediately. 
 
 41 Mademoiselle Pre"fere loves pretty things too," 
 said Jeanne ; " she cuts out paper transparencies for 
 the lamps. That is an economical form of luxury, 
 but it is luxury just the same." 
 
 Returning to Venice, we were making the acquaint- 
 ance of a patrician lady clothed in an embroidered 
 dalmatic, when I heard the door-bell. 1 supposed 
 it was some patronnet with his basket, when the 
 door of the City of Books opened, and ah, Maitre 
 Sylvestre Uonnard, you were wishing a moment ago 
 that other eyes than those that were faded and hid- 
 den behind spectacles might see your prottgie in 
 her beauty, your wishes are answered in a most un- 
 expected manner. And as to the imprudent Theseus 
 a voice calls out to you,
 
 
 174 THE CRIME OF 
 
 " Beware, my Lord, beware lest pitiless Heaven 
 Hate you enough to hearken to your prayer. 
 Oft Heaven in wratli accepts our sacrifices, 
 Its gifts are oft chastisements for our crimes." ! 
 
 The door of the City of Books opened, and 
 a handsome young man appeared, shown in by 
 The"rese. That simple old soul knows no more 
 than to open and close the door for people. 
 
 She understands nothing of the etiquette of the 
 reception-room and the parlor. In her code of laws, 
 there is nothing about announcing a caller or asking 
 a person to wait. She shoulders people out on the 
 landing of the stairs or hurls them at your head. 
 
 But there is the young man already inside, and I 
 cannot hide him like a treasure in the adjoining 
 room. I wait for him to explain his errand. This 
 he does without embarrassment ; but it seems to me 
 that he has noticed the young girl, who is leaning 
 over the table turning the pages of the Vecellio. 
 
 I look at him. If I am not greatly mistaken, I 
 have seen him somewhere before. His name is 
 Gdlis, a name I have somewhere heard. Monsieur 
 Ge"lis (since Ge"lis it is) is a nice-looking young fel- 
 low. He says that this is his third year in the cole 
 des Chartes, and that for the last fifteen or eighteen 
 months he has been working on his graduating 
 thesis, the subject of which is the condition of the 
 Benedictine abbeys in 1700. He has just read my 
 
 1 " Craignez, Seigneur, craignez que le del rigoureux 
 Ne vous haisse assez pour exaucer vas vaeux ! 
 Souvent dans sa colere il refoit nos victimes, 
 Les presents sont souvent la peine de nos crimes."
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 175 
 
 works on the Monastico n ; and he knows positively 
 that he cannot finish his thesis without my advice, 
 in the first place, and then, without a certain manu- 
 script which I have in my possession, and which is 
 no other than the register of the accounts of the ab- 
 bey of Citaux from 1 683 to 1 704. 
 
 Having enlightened me on these points, he hands 
 me a letter of introduction from one of the most dis- 
 tinguished of my colleagues. 
 
 Ah ! at last I remember who he is. Monsieur 
 GeTis is the very young man who a year ago, while 
 we sat under the chestnut-trees, called me a fool ; 
 and as I open the letter of introduction, I think to 
 myself, 
 
 "Ha! ha! you unfortunate young man. You 
 have no idea that I heard you, and that I know what 
 you think of me, or at least what you thought of 
 me then for these young heads are so fickle ! I 
 have you now, my friend. You are in the lion's den; . 
 and you came so suddenly that the old lion is taken 
 by surprise, and knows not what to do with his prey. 
 Hut you, old lion, would you be an imbecile? If 
 you are not one, you were one. You were a fool to 
 listen to Monsieur Gdlis at the foot of the statue 
 of Marguerite de Valois ; a double fool for hearing 
 him ; and a triple fool for not forgetting what it 
 would have been better not to hear at all." 
 
 Having thus reprimanded the old lion, I exhorted 
 him to be kind. He did not seem to be very reluc- 
 tant in this, and soon became so gay that he had to 
 suppress his feelings in order that they might not 
 burst forth in a joyous roar.
 
 1 76 THE CRIME OF 
 
 From the way in which I read my colleague's let- 
 ter, it might have been thought that I did not know 
 my letters. It took me a long time, and Monsieur 
 Ge'lis might have grown tired waiting ; but he was 
 watching Jeanne, and took his punishment patiently. 
 Jeanne occasionally turned her head in our direction. 
 One cannot keep perfectly still, can one ? Made- 
 moiselle Prdfere patted her curls, her breast heaving 
 with little sighs. I must say that many times I have 
 been honored by these little sighs. 
 
 " Monsieur," said I, folding the letter, " I am 
 happy to be of service to you. You are occupied 
 with researches which have been of great interest to 
 me. I have done what I could. I realize as you 
 do, and even more than you do, how much there still 
 remains to be done. The manuscript that you ask 
 for is at your service. You may take it away if you 
 wish ; but it is not of the smallest size, and I fear "- 
 
 " Oh, monsieur ! " said Ge'lis, " heavy books do not 
 frighten me." 
 
 I begged the young man to wait for me ; and I 
 went into an adjoining closet for the register, which 
 at first I failed to find, and which I even despaired 
 of ever finding, as I saw by certain signs that The*- 
 rese had been putting the closet in order. But 
 the volume was so large and so heavy that The'rese 
 had been unable to hide it completely. I raised it 
 with difficulty, and was delighted to find it as heavy 
 as I could have wished. 
 
 " Now, my boy," said I to myself, with a smile 
 which I meant to be very sarcastic, "now I am 
 about to crush you. First this will be too much for
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNAKD. \TJ 
 
 your arms, and then too much for your brain. This 
 is Sylvestre Bonnard's first revenge. We shall see 
 what next." 
 
 When I returned to the City of Books, I found 
 Monsieur Ge*lis and Mademoiselle Jeanne talking 
 together, if you please, as if they were the best ot 
 friends. Mademoiselle Pre'fere was preserving a 
 discreet silence, but the other two were chattering 
 like magpies. And about what? About Venetian 
 red ? Yes, exactly ! About Venetien red ! The 
 little insinuating Ge*lis was telling Jeanne the secret 
 of the dye with which, according to authentic ac- 
 counts, the women of Titian and Veronese's times 
 colored their hair. And Mademoiselle Jeanne was 
 giving her opinion as to the blond de miel and the 
 blond d 'or. I guessed that this rascal of a Vecellio 
 was in the conspiracy, that they had been bending 
 over the book, and that together they had admired 
 the late doge's wife, or some other patrician lady of 
 Venice. 
 
 But never mind ! I appeared with my huge old 
 book, thinking that Gdlis would make a face. It 
 was a porter's burden, and my arms ached from it ; 
 but the young man took it as if it were a feather, 
 and tucked it smilingly under his arm. Then he 
 thanked me with few words, as I like to be thanked, 
 reminded me that he had need of my advice, and 
 having made an appointment for another meeting, he 
 bowed to us with all the ease in the world, and left. 
 
 " Fine fellow, that," said I. Jeanne turned over 
 some of the pages of Vecellio without speaking. 
 
 "Well! well!" I thought 
 
 And we went to Saint-Cloud.
 
 THE CRIME OF 
 
 September-December. 
 
 The visits to the old man have been repeated 
 with such regularity that I am deeply grateful to 
 Mademoiselle Prefere. At last she has a corner 
 set apart for her in the City of Books. She says 
 now, "my chair," "my stool," "my pigeon-hole." 
 Her pigeon-hole is a shelf from which she exiled 
 the poets of La Champagne in order to make room 
 for her work-bag. She is very amiable, and I must 
 be a monster not to like her. I suffer her in the 
 literal sense of the word. But what would one not 
 suffer for Jeanne's sake ? She gives to the City of 
 Books a charm, the recollection of which is sweet 
 to me long after she is gone. She is utterly igno- 
 rant, but so gifted that when I show her a beautiful 
 thing it seems to me as if I had never before seen 
 it, and that she is the one who is showing it to me. 
 So far, I have found it impossible to make her fol- 
 low my thoughts ; but I have often taken pleasure in 
 following the bright but erratic train of hers. 
 
 A more sensible man than myself would think of 
 making her useful. But is not the faculty of being 
 pleasant in itself useful in life ? Without being 
 pretty, she attracts, and to attract is perhaps of as 
 much use as to darn stockings. Besides, I am not 
 immortal, and in all probability she will not be very 
 much older when my notary (who is not Maitre 
 Mouche) will read her a certain paper that I signed 
 lately. 
 
 I do not want any one but myself to provide for 
 her, and give her a dowry. I am not, indeed, very 
 rich, and the paternal heritage has not increased in
 
 SYLVESTKE BONNARD. 179 
 
 my hands. One does not gather crowns by poring 
 over old manuscripts. But my books, at the price 
 paid to-day for this noble kind of merchandise, are 
 worth something. On that shelf there are some 
 poets of the sixteenth century that bankers would 
 contend for with princes. And I think that these 
 Heures of Simon Vostre would not pass unnoticed 
 in the H6tel Silvestre, any more than these Preces 
 pice collected for the use of Queen Claude. I have 
 been careful to gather together and preserve all 
 these rare and curious editions of which the City 
 of Books is full, and for a long time I used to think 
 that they were as necessary to my life as air and 
 light. I have loved them well, and even to-day I 
 cannot help smiling on them and caressing them. 
 These morocco bindings are so pleasing to the eye, 
 and these vellums so soft to the touch ! There is 
 not a single one of these books that, for some par- 
 ticular reason, is not worthy of the esteem of a good 
 man. What other owner will know how to prize 
 them as they deserve? If only I were sure that 
 their next master would not leave them to go to 
 rack and ruin, or mutilate them under the impulse 
 of some ignorant whim. Into whose hands will fall 
 this incomparable copy of the Histoire de rAbbaye 
 de Saint-Germain-des-Prs, on the margins of which 
 the author himself, as Jacques Bouillard, wrote sub- 
 stantial notes with his own hand ? 
 
 Maitre Bonnard, you are an old booby ! Your 
 housekeeper, poor thing, is kept in bed to-day by 
 a severe attack of rheumatism. Jeanne is coming 
 with her chaperon; and, instead of thinking how
 
 ISO THE CRIME OF 
 
 best to entertain them, you are dwelling on a thou- 
 sand foolish thoughts. Sylvestre Bonnard, you will 
 never accomplish anything, and I tell you so myself! 
 At this moment I see them from my window, get- 
 ting out of the omnibus. Jeanne springs down like 
 a kitten; but Mademoiselle Prdfere intrusts herself 
 to the strong arms of the conductor with the mod- 
 esty of a Virginia saved from shipwreck, and re- 
 signed this time to letting herself be saved. Jean-ne 
 raises her head, sees me, and laughs ; and Mademoi- 
 selle Pre"fere checks her as she is about to wave her 
 parasol at me. There is a degree of civilization 
 which Mademoiselle Jeanne will never reach. You 
 may teach her, if you will, every art (I am not speak- 
 ing especially to Mademoiselle Pre"fere now), but you 
 will never teach her manners. Being agreeable, she ' 
 makes the mistake of being so in her own way. Only 
 an old scatterbrain like myself could forgive this. 
 As to the young scatterbrains (some of them are still ' 
 found), I do not know what they think about it ; it 
 is none of my business. 
 
 See her as she trips along the sidewalk, wrapped 
 in her cloak, her hat tilted back, the feather blow- 
 ing in the breeze like a brig adorned with flags. And 
 truly she has the graceful, proud bearing of a fine 
 sailing-vessel; so much so, that I recollect how one 
 day when I was at Havre 
 
 But must I tell you again, Bonnard, my friend, 
 that your housekeeper is in bed, and that you must 
 open the door yourself ? ' Open it, Good Old Win- 
 ter Spring is ringing the bell ! 
 
 It is Jeanne herself Jeanne, rosy red. After a
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. l8l 
 
 moment or two, Mademoiselle Pre'fere reaches the 
 landing breathless/a/id scandalized. 
 
 I explained atrourmy housekeeper, and suggested 
 dining at the restaurant ; but The'rese, all-power- 
 ful still, on her bed of pain, decided that we must 
 dine at home. Respectable people, in her opinion, 
 do not dine at restaurants. Moreover, she had ar- 
 ranged for everything. The dinner was bought, and 
 the janitress was to cook it. 
 
 Rash Jeanne wanted to go and see if the poor 
 old sick woman did not need something. As you 
 may suppose, she was sent quickly back to the draw- 
 ing-room without ceremony, but with less roughness 
 than I had reason to fear. 
 
 " If I need anything, which I don't, thank God," 
 came the answer, " I will find some one less dainty 
 than you. I need rest. This is a merchandise which 
 you do not find sold at fairs under tne sign of 'place 
 a finger on your lips.' Go back and have a good ~> 
 time, and do not stay here, for fear old age may be 
 contagious." 
 
 Jeanne told us what she said, and added that she 
 greatly liked to hear old The'rese talk, whereupon 
 Mademoiselle Pre'fere reproached her for having 
 such low taste. 
 
 I strove to excuse her by mentioning the example 
 of Moliere. 
 
 Then it happened that as she climbed up on my 
 ladder to look for a book, Jeanne let a whole row 
 fall. They made a loud crash ; and Mademoiselle 
 Pre'fere, in her affectation of sensitiveness, had a V 
 slight attack of hysterics. Jeanne quickly followed
 
 1 82 THE CRIME OF 
 
 the books to the foot of the ladder. She was the 
 kitten changed to a woman, catching mice meta- 
 morphosed into old books. One of them attracted 
 her; and she began to read, seated on her heels. It 
 was Prince Grenouille, she said. Mademoiselle Pre"- 
 fere seized this opportunity to complain that Jeanne 
 had so little liking for poetry. She could not be 
 made to recite perfectly the Death of Joan of Arc, 
 by Casimir Delavigne. It was all she could do to 
 remember the Petit Savoyard. The schoolmistress 
 did not approve of reading the Prince Grenouille 
 before knowing by heart the stanzas by Duperrier. 
 Carried away by her enthusiasm, she recited in a 
 voice that was softer than the bleating of a sheep : 
 
 " Ta douleur, Duperrier, sera done eternelle, 
 
 Et les tristes discours 
 Que te met en f esprit famitie paternelle 
 L? augmenieront toujours; 
 
 Je sais de quels appas son enfance etait pleine, 
 
 Et n'ai pas entrepris, 
 Injurieux ami de consoler ta peine 
 
 Avecque son mcpris." 
 
 Then she went into raptures. 
 
 " Oh, how beautiful it is ! What harmony ! How 
 is it possible not to admire such sweet, such touch- 
 ing verses. But why did Malherbe speak of this 
 poor Monsieur Duperrier, who was already broken 
 down from the loss of his daughter, as an injurieux 
 ami? Injurieux ami. You must admit that the 
 term is harsh."
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 183 
 
 I explained to the poetic creature that the inju- 
 rieux ami which so greatly shocked her was an 
 apposition, etc. What I told her seemed to clear 
 her head to such a degree that she was seized with 
 a great longing to sneeze. Prince Grenouille, mean- 
 time, must have been very funny ; for Jeanne, from 
 her seat on the floor, could scarcely keep from 
 laughing aloud. When she had finished with the 
 prince and princess of the story, and the innumer- 
 able children they never fail to have, she assumed 
 a beseeching expression, and teased me to let her, 
 as a favor, put on a white apron, and go into the 
 kitchen to see about the dinner. 
 
 "Jeanne," I replied with the seriousness of a mas- 
 ter, " I think that if it is a question of breaking the 
 plates, notching the dishes, denting the saucepans, 
 and staving in the kettles, the creature whom 
 The'rese has established in the kitchen is all-suffi- 
 cient, for at this very moment I seem to hear dis- 
 astrous sounds from there. However, Jeanne, I put 
 you in charge of the dessert. Go and get a white 
 apron. I will tie it around you myself." 
 
 I solemnly tied the linen apron around her waist ; 
 and she fled into the kitchen, where, as we discov- 
 ered later, she proceeded to concoct preparations 
 unknown to Vatel, unknown even to the great Ca- 
 reme, who began his treatise on fancy dishes as 
 follows: " The Fine Arts number five : Painting, 
 Music, Poetry, Sculpture, and Architecture, the 
 principal branch of which is Pastry" 
 
 I could not congratulate myself on this little 
 arrangement ; for Mademoiselle Pre'fere, now that
 
 1 84 THE CRIME OF 
 
 she was alone with me, began to behave in a very 
 alarming manner. She gazed at me with eyes full 
 of tears and strange lights, and heaved deep sighs. 
 
 " I am so sorry for you," said she. " A man like 
 you, a man of such refinement as you are, to live 
 alone with a coarse servant (for she is coarse, 
 there is no denying that). What a hard life! You 
 need rest, care, attention of every kind ; you may 
 be taken ill. And there is not a woman who would 
 not consider it an honor to bear your name and 
 share your existence. No, not one. My heart tells 
 me so." 
 
 And she pressed both hands upon her heart, 
 which, apparently, was in constant danger of escap- 
 ing from her. 
 
 I was literally at my wits' end. I strove to show 
 Mademoiselle Prdfere that I had not the slightest 
 intention of making a change in my mode of living 
 at my advanced age, and that I was as happy as I 
 could be with my disposition and circumstances. 
 
 " No ! " cried she ; " you are not happy. You 
 need a soul close by you that is capable of under- 
 standing you. Rouse yourself from your torpor, 
 and look about you. You have wide connections 
 and delightful acquaintances. One cannot be a 
 member of the Institute without mingling in society. 
 See, think, compare. No sensible woman would 
 refuse you. I am a woman, monsieur, and my in- 
 stincts do not deceive me. There is something 
 in my heart that tells me you would find happiness 
 in marriage. Women are so devoted, so loving 
 (not all, of course, but some). And then, they are
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 185 
 
 sensitive to glory. You know that at your age a 
 man needs, like CEdipus, an Egeria. Your house- 
 keeper is no longer strong. She is deaf ; she is 
 infirm. Suppose anything should happen to you 
 in the night ! The very thought of it makes me 
 shudder ! " 
 
 And she actually shuddered. She closed her eyes, 
 clinched her fists, and stamped her foot. My dismay 
 was unspeakable. With what terrifying ardor she 
 continued, 
 
 " Your health ! Your dear health ! The health 
 of a member of the Institute! I would gladly give 
 every drop of my blood to prolong the life of a 
 scholar, a writer, a man of distinction. And a 
 woman who would not be willing to do as much, 
 I should despise. Monsieur, I once knew the wife 
 of a great mathematician, a man who made long 
 calculations in blank-books, and filled the closets of 
 his house with the volumes. He had trouble with 
 his heart, and was visibly wasting away. I saw his 
 wife sitting quietly by his side. I could not help 
 saying to her one day, ' My dear, you have no feel- 
 ing. If I were in your place, I should do, I should 
 do I do not know what I should do ! "' 
 
 She paused, exhausted. I was in a terrible posi- 
 tion. It was out of the question to tell Mademoi- 
 selle Prdfere all I thought of her suggestions, for 
 if I made her angry I should lose Jeanne. There- 
 fore I took it quietly. Besides, she was my guest. 
 This thought helped me to be more courteous. 
 
 " I am very old, mademoiselle," said I ; " and I 
 fear that your advice comes a little too late. How-
 
 1 86 THE CRIME OF 
 
 ever, I will think of it. In the meantime, I beg you 
 to be calm. A glass of eau sucree would do you 
 good." 
 
 To my great surprise, my words calmed her at 
 once; and she returned quietly to her chair in her 
 corner, near her pigeon-hole, her feet on her stool. 
 
 The dinner was completely spoiled. Mademoi- 
 selle Prdfere, lost in her own thoughts, took no no- 
 tice of it. I am usually very sensitive about such 
 things ; but this one was such fun for Jeanne, that 
 after a while I, too, couldn't help enjoying it. I had 
 never known before, even at my age, that there was 
 anything funny in a chicken burned on one side 
 and raw on the other ; but Jeanne's merry laughter 
 showed me that such was the case. This chicken 
 was the cause of our making a thousand very witty 
 remarks, all of which I have now forgotten, and I 
 was delighted that it had not been properly cooked. 
 Jeanne put it back again on the spit; then she took 
 it and broiled it ; then she stewed it in butter. And 
 each time it came back to the table it was less pal- 
 atable and more hilarious than before. When we 
 ate it at last, it was a thing which had no name in 
 any kitchen. 
 
 The almond cake was still more extraordinary. 
 It was brought in in its pan, because it could not 
 be got out of it. I asked Jeanne to serve it herself, 
 thinking to embarrass her. But she broke the pan, 
 and gave us each a piece. The idea would never 
 enter any but the most innocent head that one 
 at my age could eat such things. Mademoiselle 
 Prelere, aroused from her musing, indignantly re-
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 1 87 
 
 pulsed the piece of earthenware covered with burnt 
 sugar, and took the opportunity to inform me confi- 
 dentially that she excelled in making candy. 
 
 " Oh ! " cried Jeanne, in a tone of surprise not 
 wholly devoid of mischief. 
 
 Then she wrapped all the pieces of the pan in a 
 bit of paper, intending to take them to her young 
 friends, and especially to the three Misses Mouton, 
 who are naturally inclined to gormandizing. 
 
 Secretly I was very much troubled. It seemed 
 to me almost impossible to remain long on good 
 terms with Mademoiselle Pre"fere, whose matrimo- 
 nial designs had burst forth with such fury. And 
 that lady gone, good-by to Jeanne ! 
 
 I took advantage of the moment when the gentle 
 soul went for her cloak, to ask Jeanne exactly what 
 her own age was. She was eighteen years and one 
 month old. I counted on my fingers, and found 
 that she would not be of age till the end of two 
 years and eleven months. What should we do dur- 
 ing all that time? 
 
 When she parted from me, Mademoiselle Pre'fcre 
 squeezed my hand with so much meaning that I 
 trembled in every limb. 
 
 " Good-by," I said gravely to the young girl. 
 41 Listen to me, my dear ; this friend of yours is 
 old, and may fail you. Tell me that you will always 
 be true to yourself, and I shall be easy. God bless 
 you, my child ! " 
 
 I closed the door, and opened my window to watch 
 her go. But the night was dark, and I saw only 
 dim shadows gliding across the black quay. A
 
 iCS THE CRIME OF 
 
 great, dull hum rose about me, and my heart almost 
 stopped beating. 
 Poor child ! 
 
 December 15. 
 
 The King of Thule had a golden goblet which 
 his mistress had left him as a souvenir. When he 
 was almost dying, feeling that he had drunk from it 
 for the last time, he flung the goblet into the sea. 
 I am keeping this book of memories as the aged 
 prince of the misty seas kept his golden goblet; and 
 just as he threw his love-token into the waves, I will 
 burn this book of memories. Not from any feeling 
 of haughty avarice or selfish pride shall I destroy 
 this record of a humble life ; but I am afraid that 
 the things which are dear and sacred to me may, 
 because of their being inartistically expressed, seem 
 ordinary and absurd to others. 
 
 I do not say this in view of what follows. Ab- 
 surd I certainly was when, having been invited to 
 dine at Mademoiselle Pre'fere's, I sat down in an 
 easy-chair (it was indeed such) on the right of this 
 alarming person. The table was set in a small 
 drawing-room, and I saw from the poor condition 
 of the table furniture that the schoolmistress was 
 one of those ethereal beings that soar above the 
 realities of earth. Broken plates, odd glasses, loose- 
 handled knives, yellow forks nothing was missing 
 to take away the appetite of an honest man. 
 
 I was told that the dinner had been cooked for 
 me for me alone, though Maitre Mouche was 
 there also. Mademoiselle Pre*fere must have ima- 
 gined that I had a Sarmatian's taste for butter; for
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNAKD. 189 
 
 that which she offered me, made into little thin pats, 
 was to the last degree rancid. 
 
 The roast put the finishing stroke to my disgust. 
 But I had the pleasure of hearing Maitre Mouche 
 and Mademoiselle PreTere talk about virtue. I said 
 the pleasure, I should have said the shame, for the 
 sentiments they expressed are far too much for my 
 worldly nature. 
 
 What they said showed me as clear as day that 
 devotion was their daily bread, and that self-sacrifice 
 was as necessary to them as air and water. Seeing 
 that I was not eating, Mademoiselle Pre*fere tried in 
 a thousand ways to overcome what she was good 
 enough to term my discretion. 
 
 Jeanne was not of the company ; because it was 
 said, her presence, as an exceptional favor, would 
 have been contrary to the rule of impartiality so 
 necessary to maintain among so many young girls.]] 
 I inwardly congratulated her on having escaped the 
 Merovingian butter, the huge radishes, as empty as 
 ballot-boxes, the tough roast, and the various other 
 curiosities of cooking to which I had exposed myself 
 for love of her. 
 
 The weary-looking servant served a liquid which \ 
 for some occult reason they called a " cream," and 
 then disappeared like a shadow. 
 
 Then, with great ecstasy, Mademoiselle Pre*fere 
 related all that she had said to me in the City of 
 Books, while my housekeeper was in bed. Her ad- 
 miration for a member of the Institute, her fear that 
 I might be ill and alone, the certainty she felt that 
 an intelligent woman would be proud and happy to
 
 THE CRIME OF 
 
 share my lot she made no concealment of any 
 of it ; on the contrary, she added new absurdities. 
 Maltre Mouche nodded approvingly as he cracked 
 the nuts ; then, after all this waste of words, he 
 asked, with a pleasant smile, what I had answered. 
 
 Mademoiselle Prdfere, placing one hand on her 
 heart, and raising the other toward me, cried, 
 
 " He is so affectionate, so superior, so good, and 
 so great! He answered but I could not I, a 
 simple woman, repeat the words of a member of 
 the Institute. All I can do is to give you the sub- 
 stance of them. He answered, ' Yes ; I understand 
 you. Yes.' " 
 
 Having thus spoken, she seized one of my hands. 
 Maitre Mouche, greatly moved, rose and took the 
 other. 
 
 " I congratulate you, monsieur," said he. 
 
 I have at times in my life known the meaning of 
 fear, but never before had I experienced such a 
 nauseating terror. I felt a sickening fright. 
 
 Disengaging my two hands, I rose, in order to 
 give all possible dignity to my words. 
 
 " Madame," said I, " either I made a poor expla- 
 nation at my house, or I have misunderstood you 
 here. In either case, a positive explanation is ne- 
 cessary. Permit me, madame, to make it in plain 
 words. No, I did not understand you. I am abso- 
 lutely ignorant of the match you may have in view 
 for me. if indeed you have planned any such. In 
 any case I do not wish to marry. At my age it 
 would be an unpardonable folly ; and even now, at 
 this late day, I cannot imagine how any sensible
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNAKD. IQI 
 
 woman like yourself could suggest such a thing to 
 me. I have even every reason to think that I am 
 mistaken, and that you suggested nothing of the 
 kind. If this is the case, you will forgive an old 
 man, who has become unfamiliar with the ways of 
 society, and but little accustomed to the conversa- 
 tion of ladies, and who is heartbroken over his 
 blunder." 
 
 Maitre Mouche went quietly back to his chair, 
 and, as the nuts were all cracked, began to whittle 
 a cork. 
 
 Mademoiselle Prdfere gazed at me for an instant 
 out of her small round dry eyes with a peculiar ex- 
 pression, which I had never seen there before, and 
 then resumed her usual grace and sweetness. In a 
 voice like honey she exclaimed, 
 
 " Oh, these scholars ! these cloistered men ! they 
 are like children. Yes, Monsieur Bonnard, you are 
 a veritable child ! " 
 
 Then, turning to the notary, who sat in silence, his 
 nose on his cork,. she cried in a beseeching tone, 
 
 " Oh, do not accuse him ! Do not condemn him ! 
 Do not think ill of him ! I beg you, do not. Must 
 I beg you on my knees ? " 
 
 Maitre Mouche examined his cork on every side 
 without vouchsafing any word. 
 
 I was furious ; and, to judge from the heat in my 
 head, my cheeks must have been crimson. This 
 circumstance, I suppose, must be the explanation of 
 the words which I heard through the buzzing in my 
 ears : 
 
 " Our poor friend frightens me. Monsieur Mouche,
 
 1 92 THE CRIME OF 
 
 be kind enough to open the window. Perhaps an 
 arnica compress would be good for him." 
 
 I rushed into the street with an indescribable feel- 
 ing of shame. 
 
 My poor Jeanne ! 
 
 December 20. 
 
 A week passed without my hearing a word from 
 the Prdfere Institute. Not being able to wait longer 
 without news of Clementine's daughter, and think- 
 ing, too, that I owed it to myself not to give up 
 going to the place, I set out on the road to les 
 Ternes. The parlor seemed colder, damper, more 
 inhospitable, more hateful, and the servant more 
 scared and more silent than ever. I asked for 
 Jeanne; but after the lapse of some time Mademoi- 
 selle Pre*fere herself appeared, stern and pale, with 
 drawn lips and cruel eyes. 
 
 " Monsieur," said she, folding her arms under her 
 ptterine, " I deeply regret my inability to allow you 
 to see Mademoiselle Alexandre to-day, but it is im- 
 possible." 
 
 "And why so?" I asked in astonishment. 
 
 " Monsieur," she replied, " the reasons that com- 
 pel me to have your calls here made less frequently 
 are of a peculiarly delicate nature, and I beg you to 
 spare me the embarrassment of mentioning them." 
 
 " Madame," I replied, " I am authorized by 
 Jeanne's guardian to see his ward every day. What 
 reason can you have for opposing the wish of Mon- 
 sieur Mouche ? " 
 
 " Mademoiselle Alexandre's guardian " (she dwelt 
 on the word guardian as on a firm support) "is as
 
 SYLVESTRE BONWARD. 193 
 
 anxious as I am to have your assiduities come to an 
 end." 
 
 " If this is the case, be kind enough to give me 
 his reasons as well as yours." 
 
 She gazed at the little paper spiral, and replied 
 with stern calmness, 
 
 "You really wish this? Although such an ex- 
 planation is hard for a woman to make, I yield to 
 your demand. This house, monsieur, is a respect- 
 able house. I have my responsibility. I must 
 watch like a mother over each of my pupils. Your 
 attentions to Mademoiselle Alexandre cannot con- 
 tinue without harming this young girl. My duty is 
 to see that they are stopped." 
 
 " I fail to understand you," I said ; and it was the 
 truth. She replied slowly, 
 
 " Your constant visits to this house are inter- 
 preted by people, even by the most' respectable and 
 the least suspicious, in such a way that I am obliged 
 in the interest of my school, as well as in the interest 
 of Mademoiselle Alexandre, to stop them as soon as 
 possible." 
 
 " Madame," I cried, " I have heard a great many 
 foolish things in my life, but never one that can 
 compare to what you have just said ! " 
 
 She replied simply, 
 
 <; Your insults do not affect me in the least. A 
 woman is very strong in the performance of a duty." 
 
 And she pressed her ptlerine against her heart, 
 this time not to restrain, but probably to caress, 
 that generous heart. 
 
 "Madame," said I with uplifted finger, "you
 
 194 THE CRIME OF 
 
 have roused the indignation of an old man. Act in 
 future in such a way that the old man may forget 
 you, and add no new misdeeds to those I already 
 have witnessed. I warn you, that I shall not keep 
 from watching over Mademoiselle Jeanne Alexan- 
 dre. If in any way whatsoever you harm her, it 
 will go hard with you ! " 
 
 As I grew angrier she became more calm, and 
 she put on a fine air of indifference as she re- 
 plied, 
 
 " Monsieur, I am too well acquainted with the 
 nature of the interest you take in this young girl, 
 not to do all in my power to withdraw her from the 
 surveillance with which you threaten me. Seeing 
 the more than equivocal intimacy in which you live 
 with your housekeeper, I should have prevented 
 you from ever coming into contact with an innocent 
 young girl. I shall do so in the future. If hith- 
 erto I have been too unsuspicious, not you, but 
 Mademoiselle Alexandre, can reproach me. But 
 she is too artless, too pure, thanks to me, to suspect 
 the nature of the danger to which you have exposed 
 her. You will not compel me, I presume, to en- 
 lighten her in regard to it." 
 
 " Well," said I to myself, shrugging my shoul- 
 ders, "you have had to live until now, my poor 
 Bonnard, to know exactly what a bad woman is. 
 At present your knowledge is complete in this line." 
 
 I went out without a word ; and I had the pleasure 
 of seeing, from the quick blush on the schoolmis- 
 tress's face, that she was more affected by my silence 
 than she had been by my words. I crossed the
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 195 
 
 court, looking right and left for Jeanne. She was 
 on the watch for me, and came running to me. 
 
 " If a hair of your head is touched, Jeanne, write 
 me. Good-by." 
 
 " No ! not good-by ! " 
 
 I answered, " No, no ! not good-by. Write to me." 
 
 I went straight to Madame de Gabry's. 
 
 " Madame is in Rome with monsieur. Did you 
 not know, monsieur?" 
 
 "Ah, yes," I replied; "madame wrote me about 
 it." So in truth she had done. I must have lost 
 my head to forget it. This was probably what the 
 servant thought ; for he looked at me as much as to 
 say, " Monsieur Bonnard is in his dotage," and he 
 leaned over the railing of the stairs to see if I did 
 not do something peculiar. But I walked down as 
 usual, and he withdrew disappointed. 
 
 On my return, I was told that Monsieur GeMis was 
 in the drawing-room. This young man is constantly 
 at my house. His judgment is sometimes faulty, 
 but his mind is above the ordinary. This time his 
 call brought nothing but embarrassment on me. 
 " Alas ! " I thought, " I shall certainly say some- 
 thing foolish to my young friend ; and he, too, will 
 think I am breaking down. And yet I cannot ex- 
 plain to him that I have been sought in marriage, 
 and condemned as an immoral man ; that The*rese 
 is under suspicion, and that Jeanne is in the power of 
 the most wicked woman on earth. I am in a fine state 
 of mind to discuss Cistercian abbeys with a young 
 and over-critical scholar. But come, let us go in.
 
 
 196 THE CRIME OF 
 
 TheVese stopped me, however. 
 
 " How red your face is, monsieur ! " she said in a 
 tone of reproach. 
 
 " It is the spring," I answered. 
 
 "The spring in the month of December!" she 
 cried. 
 
 True, it is the month of December ! Ah ! how 
 my head feels ! What a strong support am I to 
 poor Jeanne ! 
 
 " Thdrese, take my cane, and put it, if you possi- 
 bly can, where it can be found. Good-afternoon, 
 Monsieur Ge'lis. How are you?" 
 
 No date. 
 
 The following day the poor old fellow started to 
 rise, but the poor old fellow was unable to do so. 
 Cruel was the unseen hand that laid him low upon 
 his bed. The poor old fellow, pinned down as he 
 was, resigned himself to the inevitable, but his 
 thoughts were not idle. 
 
 He must have had a high fever; for Mademoiselle 
 Prdfere, the abbots of Saint-Germain-des-Pre's, and 
 Madame de Gabry's servant appeared to him under 
 fantastic forms, especially the servant, who leaned 
 over him, grinning like a gargoyle on a cathedral. 
 I had an idea that there were a great many people, 
 too many, in my room, j 
 
 This room is furnished in olden style. On the 
 wall hang the portrait of my father in full-dress uni- 
 form, and that of tnyNnother in a cachemire robe. 
 The wall-paper has a ofetdgn of green leaves and 
 flowers. I realize this. I even realize that it is all 
 very much faded, but an old man's room does not
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 197 
 
 need to be daintily pretty. It is enough if it is 
 clean, and The'rese sees to that. Then, further- 
 more, it is sufficiently decorated to please my fancy, 
 which is a tr\fle childish and prosaic. On the walls \ 
 and the furniture there are figures which ordinarily , 
 speak to me ami enliven me. But why are all these \ 
 things angry at me to-day ? They seem discordant ; 
 they grin at me ; ttjey threaten me. The statuette, 
 copied from one of\the cardinal Virtues at Notre- 
 Dame de Brou, unaffected and graceful as it usually 
 appears, is now making\contortions, and putting out 
 its tongue at me. And that beautiful miniature, which 
 represents one of Jehan Fouquet's most gracious dis- 
 ciples, girt with the cord pf the sons of Francis, 
 offering, on bended knee, hid book to the good Duke 
 of Angoulcme who has removed it from its frame, 
 and substituted a great cat's head, glaring at me 
 with phosphorescent eyes ? T\he designs on the 
 wall-paper have become heads tofy green and shape- 
 less. No, they are not; they are^o-day what they 
 were twenty years ago, nothing but stamped leaves 
 and flowers. No, I was right, they, are heads 
 heads with eyes, noses, and mouths K Heads ! I 
 understand ; they are heads and flowers \^t the same 
 time. I wish I did not see them at all. \ 
 
 There, on my right, the graceful miniature of the 
 Franciscan friar has returned ; but it seems to me 
 that I retain it by a superhuman effort of my will, 
 and that if I relax my effort the wretched cat's head 
 will come back, flam not delirious. I see The'rese 
 perfectly at the foot of my bed. I hear her speak- 
 ing to me, and I should answer with perfect clear-
 
 p 
 
 198 777^ CRIME OF 
 
 ness if I were not busy keeping everything about me 
 in its natural form. 
 
 Here comes the doctor. I did not send for him, 
 but I am glad to see him. He is an old neighbor, to 
 whom I have been of little profit, but whom I like 
 exceedingly. Although I do not say much to him, I 
 am at least perfectly conscious, even strangely crafty ; 
 for I notice his gestures, his looks, the smallest wrin- 
 kles on his face. But he is shrewd, and I do not 
 really know what he thinks of me. The mighty 
 thought of Goethe comes to my mind, and I say, 
 
 " Doctor, this old man has consented to grow ill, 
 but he will allow nature no further concessions this 
 time." 
 
 Neither the doctor nor The'rese smiles at my jest. 
 They cannot have understood it. 
 
 The doctor takes his leave, daylight fades, and 
 all sorts of shadows form and break, like clouds, 
 among the folds of my curtains. They pass in crowds 
 before me, and through them I see the impassive 
 face of my faithful servant. All at once a cry, a' 
 sharp cry of distress, falls upon my ear. Is it you, 
 Joanne, calling to me ? 
 
 Night has come. The shadows cluster about my 
 bed, to remain by me through the long night. 
 
 At daybreak I feel a peace, a wonderful peace, 
 about me. 
 
 Art thou opening thine arms to me, O Lord, my 
 God? 
 
 Febrrtary, 186-. 
 
 The doctor is perfectly jovial. It seems that I am 
 doing him great honor by recovering. Numberless
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 199 
 
 ills, I understand, have been poured out over my 
 old body./ 
 
 Theseills, which are the bane of man, have names 
 which iire the bane of the philologist. They are hy- 
 brid narnes>>half Greek, half Latin, ending in t/fs, 
 indicating the mfhwomatory state, and in algia, ex- 
 pressing pain. The doob>-uses them with a number 
 of adjectives ending in /V, whic*hs^erve to character- 
 ize their detestable qualities in sniart, a good half 
 of the complete copy of the medical dictionary con- 
 tained in the too authentic box of Pandora. 
 
 " Doctor, that story of Pandora is a good one. If 
 Iwere a poet, I would put it into French verse. 
 ["Shake hands, doctor. You have brought me back 
 to life. I forgive you. You have restored me to my 
 friends, and I thank you. I am all sound, you say. 
 Xo doubt, no doubt; but I have endured a great 
 deal./ I am an old piece of furniture, quite like my 
 father's armchair. It was an armchair which that 
 honest man inherited, and in which he sat from 
 morning to night. Twenty times a day, when I was 
 a little boy, I used to perch on the arm of that old 
 chair. So long as it was in good condition, no one 
 paid any attention to it ; but the moment it began to 
 limp with one leg, we said what a good chair it was. 
 After a while, three of its legs went lame, the fourth 
 squeaked, and both of its arms were half gone. 
 Then we exclaimed, What a strong armchair ! ' 
 We wondered how, being without a sound arm or a 
 firm leg, it could still look like an armchair, retain 
 an upright position, and be of use. But the horse- 
 hair came out of its body, and it gave up the ghost.
 
 200 TJIE CRIME OF 
 
 And when Cyprien, our servant, cut off its legs for 
 fire-wood the shouts of admiration increased. 'The 
 fine, the wonderful old armchair! It was used by 
 Pierre-Sylvestre Bonnard, dry-goods merchant, by 
 his son Epime'nide Bonnard, and by Jean-Baptiste 
 Bonnard, chief of the third maritime division and 
 a Pyrrhonic philosopher. What a strong and ven- 
 erable armchair ! ' In reality it was a dead arm- 
 chair. Well, doctor, such an armchair am I. You 
 think me sound because I have resisted attacks 
 which would have killed many, but which killed 
 me only three-quarters. Many thanks. Neverthe- 
 lesSjI am an irrevocably damaged article." 
 / The doctor strives, by the help of long Greek and 
 Latin terms, to prove that I am still hale and hearty ; 
 but French is too simple a language for an explana- 
 tion of that kind. However, I admit what he says, 
 and escort him to my doorj 
 
 " Good ! " says Thdrese. " That is the way to 
 put out a doctor. If you will only repeat it two 
 or three times, he will not return, and that would be 
 a good thing." 
 
 "Well, The'rese, now that I am a strong man 
 again, do not detain my letters any longer. There 
 is a good pile of them, no doubt, and it would be 
 wicked to keep me longer from reading them." 
 
 The'rese, after some delay, gave them to me. But 
 what did it matter? I looked at every envelope, 
 and not one was written by the little hand that I 
 longed to see here, turning over the pages of Ve- 
 cellio. I tossed aside the whole pile, for they no 
 longer appealed to me.
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 2OI 
 
 April-June. 
 
 The discussion has been a warm one. 
 
 " Wait, monsieur, until I put on some suitable 
 things," said The'rese, " and I will walk out again 
 with you. I will take your folding-chair as I have 
 done for the past few days, and we will go and sit 
 in the sunshine." 
 
 The truth is, The'rese thinks that I am infirm. I 
 have been ill, no doubt, but there is an end to all 
 things. Madame Illness departed long since; and 
 three months ago her pale and gentle-faced hand- 
 maid, Dame Convalescence, politely bade me good- 
 by. Were I to listen to my housekeeper, I should 
 be " Monsieur Argant," and I should wear a night- 
 cap trimmed with ribbons for the rest of my days. 
 Anything but that ! I intend to go out by myself. 
 The'rese will not hear to it. She brings my folding- 
 chair, and follows me. 
 
 " The'rese, to-morrow we will take our seat by the 
 wall of la petite Provence if you like, but to-day 
 I have important business to attend to." 
 
 Business ! She thinks I refer to money matters, 
 and explains that there is nothing important to be 
 decided. 
 
 " So much the better ! But there is other busi- 
 ness besides that in the world." 
 
 I tease, I scold, I escape. 
 
 The day is fair. By means of a hack, and by 
 the help of God, I shall accomplish my adventur- 
 ous design. 
 
 Here is the wall, bearing in blue letters the words: 
 PENSIONNAT DE DEMOISELLES, TENU IAR MA-
 
 2O2 THE CRIME OF 
 
 DEMOISELLE ViRGiNiE PREFERS. Here is the iron 
 gate which would give entrance into the court of 
 honor if it ever were opened. But the lock is rusty ; 
 and between the bars, sheet-iron has been placed, 
 as a protection against indiscreet eyes that might 
 be turned upon the young souls, whom, no doubt, 
 Mademoiselle Pre"fere instructs in modesty, sincer- 
 ity, justice, and disinterestedness. Here, indicating 
 the domestic part of the establishment, is a barred 
 window, with painted panes, like a sightless eye, 
 the sole opening to the outside world. 
 
 The narrow door by which I have entered so 
 often, and which henceforth is closed to me, is the 
 same as it was, with its barred grating. The stone 
 steps leading to it are worn ; and though the eyes 
 behind my glasses are none too good, I can distin- 
 guish little white scratches made on the stone by 
 the nails in the scholars' heels as they pass in and 
 out. Cannot I also enter? It seems to me that 
 Jeanne must be suffering in this gloomy house, and 
 that she is secretly calling me. I cannot go away. 
 I am filled with anxiety. I ring the bell ; the fright- 
 ened servant-girl answers it, looking more frightened 
 than ever. The order has been given. I cannot 
 see Mademoiselle Jeanne. I at least ask how she 
 is. The servant, having glanced to the right and 
 left, replies that she is well, and shuts the door in 
 my face. Once more I am in the street. 
 
 And since then how often have I wandered be- 
 neath that wall, before that little door, ashamed, 
 and in despair at being weaker than the poor girl 
 who has no other protection on earth but mine !
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 2O3 
 
 June 10. 
 
 I overcame my repugnance, and went to see Mai- 
 tre Mouche. I noticed at first glance that his office 
 was dustier and mustier than it was a year ago. 
 The notary appeared with his angular gestures and 
 his restless eyes behind their glasses. I made my 
 complaint to him. He replied but of what use 
 is it to note down in a diary that will be burned 
 my reminiscences of a downright scoundrel. He 
 approves of all that is done by Mademoiselle Pre"- 
 fere, whose mind and character he has for many 
 years held in high appreciation. It is not for him 
 to give an opinion on the subject under discussion; 
 but on the face of it, he must say that appearances 
 are against me. That concerns me but little. He 
 adds and this concerns me more that the pal- 
 try sum which he had in his hands for his ward's 
 education is exhausted, and that under these cir- 
 cumstances he cannot but admire the disinterested- 
 ness of Mademoiselle Pre*fere, who has consented to 
 keep Mademoiselle Jeanne with her. 
 
 A brilliant flood of sunshine, the light of a fair 
 day, pours its incorruptible waves into this sordid 
 den and illuminates this man. Without, it spreads 
 its glory over all the poverty and wretchedness of a 
 thickly populated district. 
 
 How sweet is this light with which my eyes have 
 so long been filled, and which in a short time I 
 shf.ll no longer enjoy ! 
 
 I go away, and in a dreamy state of mind, with 
 ly hands behind my back, wander along the fortifi- 
 :ations, and find myself, to my surprise, in one of the
 
 204 THE CRIME OF 
 
 out-of-the-way faubourgs where mean little gardens 
 abouncL) By the dusty roadside I come upon a 
 plant, the flower of which, at once bright and som- 
 bre, seems made to be associated with the noblest 
 and the purest grief. It is the columbine. Our 
 fathers called it Le gant de Notre-Dame. Only a 
 Notre-Dame who should make herself very small, 
 so as to be seen by children, could slip her dainty 
 fingers into the tiny capsules of this flower. 
 
 Here comes a big bumblebee, diving into it with 
 brutal energy ; but his mouth cannot reach the nec- 
 tar, and the glutton strives in vain. At last he gives 
 up, and comes out all smeared with pollen. He re- 
 sumes his heavy flight; but there are few flowers in 
 this faubourg, blackened by the soot of factories. 
 He comes flying back to the columbine ; and this 
 time he pierces the corolla, and drinks the nectar 
 through the opening he has made. I would not 
 have believed that a bumblebee would have so 
 much sense. It is wonderful ! 
 
 The more I observe insects and flowers, the more 
 they surprise me. I am like the good Rollin, who 
 found such intense delight in the flowers of his 
 peach-trees. I should like to own a beautiful gar- 
 den, and live on the edge of a wood. 
 
 A ugust-September. 
 
 One Sunday morning the idea came into my 
 mind to watch the pupils of Mademoiselle Prdfero's 
 school as they went to mass in the parish church. 
 I saw them pass two by two, the smaller ones lead- 
 ing, with serious faces. Three of them were plump,
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 
 
 short, important-looking girls, dressed exactly alike. 
 These I recognized as the Misses Mouton. Their 
 elder sister is the artist who drew the terrible head 
 of Tatius, King of the Sabines. A little aloof from 
 the line, the under-teacher, with her prayer-book in 
 her hand, was fussing about and scowling darkly. 
 The middle class, and then the big girls, passed 
 along whispering. But I did not see Jeanne. 
 
 I asked at the department of education if there 
 was not among the records something about the 
 school in the rue Demours. I succeeded in having 
 some female inspectors sent there. They returned, 
 bringing the best accounts. In their opinion the 
 Prdfere school was a model institution. If I insti- 
 gated any investigation, Mademoiselle Pre'fere would 
 surely receive scholastic honors ! 
 
 . October 3. 
 
 / This Thursday being a holiday, I met the three 
 fittle Misses Mouton near the rue Demours. I 
 bowed to their mother, and asked the eldest, who 
 might have been ten years old, how her friend 
 Mademoiselle Jeanne Alexandre was. Little Made- 
 moiselle Mouton replied without an instant's hes- 
 itation, 
 
 "Jeanne Alexandre is not my friend. She is a 
 charity pupil in the school, and so she is made to 
 sweep the class-rooms. Mademoiselle said so. And 
 Jeanne Alexandre is wicked too, and she is shut up 
 in a dark room, and it serves her right. I am good. 
 They do not shut me up in a dark room." 
 
 The three little ladies resumed their walk, followed
 
 206 THE CRIME OF 
 
 closely by Madame Mouton, who gave me a look of 
 distrust over her broad shoulder. 
 
 Alas ! I am forced to resort to questionable expe- 
 dients. Madame de Gabry will not return to Paris 
 for three months at the earliest. Away from her I 
 have neither tact nor sense. I am but a clumsy, 
 awkward, and deleterious machine. 
 
 Nevertheless, Jeanne must not be a servant in a 
 boarding-school ! 
 
 ft ft*} December 28. 
 
 v The thought of Jeanne sweeping the class-rooms 
 had become perfectly intolerable to me. 
 
 The weather was cold and gloomy. Night was 
 already beginning to fall. I rang at the little door 
 with the calmness of a man whose mind was made 
 up. As soon as the frightened servant appeared, I 
 slipped a gold piece into her hand, and promised her 
 another if she succeeded in letting me see Made- 
 moiselle Alexandre. She answered, 
 
 " In an hour, at the grated window." 
 
 And she slammed the door in my face so violently 
 that it knocked my hat into the gutter. 
 
 I waited a long hour in the midst of a whirling 
 snow-storm ; then I approached the window. Noth- 
 ing! The wind howled, and the snow fell thickly. 
 The workmen as they passed by with their utensils 
 on their shoulders, their heads bent beneath the 
 thick falling snowflakes, brushed roughly against 
 me. Nothing ! I feared that I should be observed. 
 I knew that I had done wrong in bribing a servant, 
 but I did not regret it. Evil to him who is not able 
 to overstep the social laws if need be ! A quarter
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 2O/ 
 
 of an hour passed. Nothing ! At last the window 
 was partly opened. 
 
 " Is that you, Monsieur Bonnard ? " 
 
 " Is that you, Jeanne ? Tell me in a word how 
 are you getting along ? " 
 
 " I am doing well, very well." 
 
 " But tell me more ! " 
 
 " I have been put into the kitchen, and they make 
 me sweep the rooms." 
 
 " Into the kitchen ! And you do the sweeping ! 
 Goodness ! " 
 
 " Yes ; because my guardian no longer pays for 
 my schooling." 
 
 "Goodness ! It seems to me your guardian is a 
 scoundrel." 
 
 " Ah, you know then " 
 
 " What ? " 
 
 " Oh, do not make me say it. But I would rather 
 die than be alone with him." 
 
 " Why have you not written to me ? " 
 
 " I have been watched." 
 
 At that moment my resolution was taken, and no 
 power could have made me alter it. The thought 
 came to me that I might not be acting according to 
 law, but what did I care for that ? Being deter- 
 mined, I was prudent. I acted with remarkable 
 calmness. 
 
 " Jeanne," I asked, " does the room in which you 
 are connect with the court ? " 
 
 Yes." 
 
 " Can you open the street door yourself ? " 
 
 " Yes ; unless some one is in the lodge."
 
 208 THE CRIME OF 
 
 " Go and try, and be sure not to let any one see 
 you." 
 
 I waited, watching both door and window. At 
 the end of five or six seconds Jeanne reappeared 
 behind the grating. 
 
 " The bonne is in the lodge," said she. 
 
 " Good," said I. " Have you a pen and ink ? " 
 
 " No." 
 
 " A pencil, then ? " . 
 
 " Yes." 
 
 " Hand it to me." 
 
 I took from my pocket an old newspaper ; and be- 
 tween the gusts of wind, which almost blew out the 
 street-lights, and under the falling snow which blinded 
 me, I put a paper band about the newspaper, and 
 addressed it as well as I could to Mademoiselle 
 Prdfere. 
 
 While I was writing, I said to Jeanne, 
 
 " When the postman comes along, he puts the let- 
 ters and papers in the box, does he not, rings the 
 bell, and goes on ? The bonne opens the box, and 
 immediately carries the mail to Mademoiselle Pre"- 
 fere, does she not ? That is what takes place, is it 
 not, every time the mail comes ? " 
 
 Jeanne thought it was. 
 
 " Well, we shall see. Jeanne, keep watch, and as 
 soon as the bonne has left the lodge, pull the rope 
 and come out." 
 
 So saying, I slipped the paper into the box, gave 
 the bell a vigorous pull, and hid in the shelter of an 
 adjoining doorway. 
 
 I had been there a few moments, when the small
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 2OQ 
 
 door moved, and opened part way; then a young 
 girl thrust her head out. I took hold of her, and 
 drew her towards me. 
 
 "Come, Jeanne, come." 
 
 She looked at me with uncertainty. She certainly 
 thought I had gone mad. On the contrary, I was to 
 the last degree rational. 
 
 " Come, come, my child." 
 
 " Where ? " 
 
 " To Madame de Gabry's." 
 
 Then she took my arm. We ran for some dis- 
 tance as if we were thieves. But running is not an 
 exercise suited for a man of my size ; and half-suf- 
 focated, I paused, and leaned on something which 
 proved to be the stove of a chestnut-dealer, at the 
 corner of a wine-shop where several cab-drivers 
 were drinking. One of them asked if we did not 
 want a carriage. Of course we did ! The man of 
 the whip set his glass down on the bar, mounted the 
 box, and urged his horse forward. We were saved ! 
 
 " Whew ! " I cried, mopping my brow ; for in 
 spite of the cold, I was all of a perspiration. 
 
 Strange as it may seem, Jeanne apparently real- 
 ized the enormity of what we had done more than I 
 did. She was very serious and visibly nervous. 
 
 " In the kitchen ! " I cried indignantly. 
 
 She nodded her head, as if to say, " What does 
 it matter whether I am there or anywhere else ! " 
 
 And in the light of the lamps I noticed with sor- 
 row that her cheeks were thin, and her features 
 drawn. I missed the vivacity, the spontaneity, the 
 quick change of expression, which had been her
 
 2IO THE CRIME OF 
 
 great charm for me. Her eyes were dull, her ges- 
 tures lifeless, her whole bearing dejected. 1 took 
 her hand. It was calloused, rough, and clammy. 
 The poor child must have suffered indeed. I 
 questioned her. She calmly told me that one day 
 Mademoiselle Pre*fere had summoned her, and for 
 some unfathomable reason had called her a mon- 
 ster and a little viper. 
 
 " She said, moreover, ' You shall not see Mon- 
 sieur Bonnard again. He has been giving you bad 
 advice, and has treated me shamefully.' I said to 
 her, ' That, mademoiselle, I will never believe.' 
 Mademoiselle gave me a box on the ear, and sent 
 me back to the schoolroom. The announcement 
 that I was not to see you any more was like night 
 falling about me. You know how blue and sad you 
 sometimes feel at evening, when the darkness settles 
 down upon you. Well ! imagine that feeling extend- 
 ing into weeks and months. Do you remember my 
 little Saint-George ? Until then I had worked at it 
 to the best of my ability for the mere fun of the 
 thing; but after I had given up all hope of ever 
 seeing you again, I went to work at my wax figure 
 in a very different way. I no longer used the ends 
 of matches to model with, as before, but hairpins. I 
 even used invisible hairpins. But perhaps you do not 
 know what these arc. I worked with more delicacy 
 than you can imagine. I put a dragon on the Saint- 
 George's helmet, and spent hour after hour in mod- 
 elling a head, eyes, and a tail for him. Especially the 
 eyes. I never stopped till I had given him red eyes, 
 white eyelids, eyelashes everything. I am foolish.
 
 Then she took my arm.
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNAKD. 211 
 
 I had an idea that when my little Saint-George was 
 finished I should die. I worked at it during vaca- 
 tions, and Mademoiselle Pre'fere let me alone. One 
 day I heard that you were in the parlor with made- 
 moiselle. I was on the watch for you ; we said 'Au 
 revoir 11 to each other, and I was somewhat consoled. 
 But one Thursday, a short time after that, my guard- 
 ian wanted me to go out with him. I refused to go 
 to his house. But do not ask me why, monsieur. 
 He replied very gently that I was a whimsical little 
 thing, and left me in peace. But the following day 
 Mademoiselle Pre'fere came to me with such an evil 
 look on her face that I was frightened. She held a 
 letter in her hand. ' Mademoiselle,' said she, 'your 
 guardian tells me that he has spent all the money 
 that belongs to you ; but you need have no fear, I 
 will not desert you. But you will admit that it is 
 right for you to earn your own living.' 
 
 " Then she set me to work cleaning her house ; 
 and when I made any mistake, she shut me up for 
 days in a garret. That is what has occurred since 
 we last met, monsieur. Even if I could have writ- 
 ten to you, I am not sure that I should have done so, 
 because I did not think it possible for you to take 
 me out of the school ; and as Maitre Mouche did 
 not come to see me again, there was no haste about 
 anything. I could wait in the garret and in the 
 kitchen." 
 
 "Jeanne," I cried, "if we have to flee to Oceanica, 
 this abominable Pre'fere shall never again take you. 
 I swear it. And why should we not go to Oceanica? 
 The climate is mild, and I read in a newspaper the
 
 212 THE CRIME OF 
 
 other day that there were pianos there. Meanwhile, 
 we will go to Madame de Gabry, who, fortunately, 
 came back to Paris three or four days ago. We are 
 like two children, and we are in great need of aid." 
 
 While I spoke, Jeanne's face grew pale and life- 
 less. A shadow fell before her eyes, a movement 
 of pain contracted her half-open lips, and her head 
 sank down on her shoulder. She had fainted. 
 
 I raised her in my arms, and carried her up Ma- 
 dame de Gabry's steps as though she were a child, 
 asleep. When she regained consciousness, I my- 
 self, overcome with fatigue and emotion, was on the 
 point of giving way. 
 
 " Ah, so it is you ! " said she ; " I am so glad ! " 
 In this state, we rang at the door of our friend's 
 home. 
 
 The same day. 
 
 It was eight o'clock. Madame de Gabry, you may 
 well believe, was greatly surprised when she saw us. 
 But she welcomed the old man and the child with 
 that kindness which was manifested in her sweet 
 manner. It seems, if I may use the devotional lan- 
 guage natural to her, it seems as if some celestial 
 grace flows from her hands every time she opens 
 them ; and even the perfume she wafts as she passes, 
 suggests the sweet, calm intoxication of charity and 
 good works. 
 
 Surprised she was, certainly ; but she did not ask 
 a single question, and this reticence seemed to me 
 most commendable. 
 
 "Madame," said I, "we have both of us come 
 to you for protection. And first of all, we beg for
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNAKD. 21 3 
 
 something to eat, especially for Jeanne, for she 
 fainted a moment ago in the cab from sheer ex- 
 haustion. For myself, I could touch nothing at 
 this late hour without suffering a night of agony. 
 I trust that Monsieur de Gabry is well." 
 
 " He is here," she replied ; and she called him. 
 
 " Paul ! come and see Monsieur Bonnard and 
 Mademoiselle Alexandre." 
 
 He came. I was glad to see his pleasant, honest 
 face, and to grasp his firm, square hand. All four 
 of us went into the dining-room ; and while they set 
 before Jeanne some cold meat, which she did not 
 touch, I told our story. Paul de Gabry asked if he 
 might smoke his pipe, then listened to me in silence. 
 When I had finished, he scratched the short, thick 
 beard which covered his cheeks, and uttered an em- 
 phatic sacrebleu ! But seeing that Jeanne turned a 
 pair of wide-opened, frightened eyes first on him 
 and then on me, he added, 
 
 " We will speak of this to-morrow morning. Come 
 into my library, I want to show you an old book, 
 and ask your opinion about it." 
 
 I followed him into his library where, against a 
 dark background, carbines and hunting-knives glim- 
 mered in the lamplight. Pulling me down on a leather 
 sofa, he cried, 
 
 " What have you done ! Good God, what have 
 you done ! Carrying off a minor ! abduction ! kid- 
 napping ! You have got into a pretty mess ! You 
 are simply liable to five or ten years' imprisonment." 
 
 " Mercy ! " I cried ; " ten years' imprisonment for 
 having saved an innocent girl ! "
 
 214 THE CRIME OF 
 
 " That is the law," replied Monsieur de Gabry. 
 " I am well acquainted with it, my dear Monsieur 
 Bonnard, not because I have studied law, but be- 
 cause, as mayor of Lusance, I had to read up in it 
 in order to enlighten my subordinates. Mouche is 
 a rascal, Pre"fere a vile wretch, and you a I can 
 find no word strong enough." 
 
 He opened his bookcase, which was rilled with 
 dog-collars, horsewhips, stirrups, spurs, cigar-boxes, 
 and a few books of reference, and taking down a 
 law-book, turned over its leaves. 
 
 " ' Crimes and Misdemeanors . . . Sequestration 
 of Persons' 1 . . . that is not your case. 'Abduction 
 of Minors'* . . . here we are. < Article 35 4.. Who- 
 soever, by fraud or by "violence, shall have abducted 
 or caused to be abducted any minors, or shall have 
 enticed, conveyed, or removed them, or shall have 
 caused them to be enticed, conveyed, or removed 
 from the places in which they were put by those 
 to whose aitthority or direction they were consigned 
 or intrusted, shall be liable to imprisonment. See 
 PENAL CODE, zr and 28. 
 
 " ' 21. The term of imprisonment shall not be 
 less than five years. 28. Sentence to imprisonment 
 shall involve the loss of civil rights? That is very 
 clear, is it not, Monsieur Bonnard?" 
 
 " Perfectly clear." 
 
 " Let us continue : ' Article 356. If the abductor 
 be under the age of twenty-one years, he shall be pun- 
 ished only? . . . We certainly cannot invoke that 
 article. 'Article jj/. In case the abductor shall 
 have married the girl whom he has abducted, he
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 21$ 
 
 can be prosecuted only on the complaint of the per- 
 sons iv/10, according to the Civil Code, have the right 
 to demand that the marriage be declared null and 
 void, nor can he be condemned until after the mar- 
 riage shall have been declared null and void? 
 
 " I do not know whether it is your idea to marry 
 Mademoiselle Alexandra or not. You see that the 
 law is kind, and that it offers you this loophole. 
 But it is wrong of me to jest, for your position is 
 serious. How could a man like you have imagined 
 that any one in Paris, in the nineteenth century, could 
 carry away a young girl with impunity ? We are not 
 living in the Middle Ages ; abduction is no longer 
 allowed." 
 
 " Do not imagine," said I, " that abduction was 
 allowed under the ancient laws. In Baluze you will 
 find a decree issued by King Childebert at Cologne, 
 in 593 or 594, on this question. Besides, who does 
 not know that the famous ordinance of Blois, in 
 May 1579, formally enacted that death should be 
 the penalty for those who were found guilty of ab- 
 ducting a boy or a girl under twenty-five years of 
 age, whether under promise of marriage or other- 
 wise, without the full knowledge, will, or express 
 consent of father, mother, or guardians ? And the 
 ordinance adds. ' And likewise all those shall suffer 
 condign punishment who shall have been in any 
 way implicated in said abduction, and who shall 
 have given counsel, help, or aid in any manner 
 whatsoever.' 1 Those are the exact, or almost the 
 exact, terms of the ordinance. As to the article 
 of the Napoleonic Code to which you have just re-
 
 2l6 THE CRIME OF 
 
 ferred, and by which the abductor is exempt from 
 punishment if he marries the girl he has carried off, 
 it reminds me of the law of Bretagne, where abduc- 
 tion, followed by marriage, was not punishable. 
 But this custom, which gave rise to abuse, was 
 suppressed in 1 720. 
 
 " I give you the date within ten years. My mem- 
 ory is not very good now ; and I can no longer 
 recite by heart without even pausing for breath, 
 as I once could, fifteen hundred verses of Girart de 
 Roussillon. 
 
 " In regard to the capitulary of Charlemagne, regu- 
 lating the punishment for abduction, I need not 
 speak, for no doubt you remember it. You may 
 clearly see, then, my dear Monsieur de Gabry, that 
 abduction was considered a crime deserving of the 
 severest punishment under the three dynasties of 
 ancient France. It is entirely wrong to suppose 
 that the Middle Age's were a time of chaos. On 
 the contrary, you must remember " 
 
 Monsieur de Gabry interrupted me, 
 
 " You know the ordinance of Blois, Baluze, Childe- 
 bert, and the Capitularies," said he, "yet you are 
 ignorant of the Napoleonic Code ! " 
 
 I told him that I had never read that Code, and 
 he seemed surprised. 
 
 " Do you realize now," said he, " the seriousness 
 of the act you have committed ? " 
 
 In truth I scarcely did realize it as yet. But little 
 by little, as I listened to Monsieur Paul's very sen- 
 sible words, I began to see that I should be con- 
 demned, not for my innocent intentions, but for the
 
 SYLyESTRE BONNARD. 2I/ 
 
 act itself, which is punishable. Then I lost hope, 
 and began to lament. 
 
 " What shall I do ? " I cried. What shall I do ? 
 Am I, then, hopelessly lost? and shall 1 drag down 
 with me the poor girl whom I tried to save ? " 
 
 Monsieur de Gabry filled his pipe in silence, and 
 lighted it so deliberately that for three or four min- 
 utes his kind, broad face was as red as a black- 
 smith's in the fire of his forge. 
 
 "You ask me what you shall do. Do nothing, 
 my dear Monsieur Bonnard. For the love of Heaven 
 and for your own sake, do nothing at all. Your 
 position is bad enough now. Do not become en- 
 tangled any deeper for fear of fresh trouble. But 
 promise me to approve of all I am going to do. 
 Early to-morrow morning I shall go to Monsieur 
 Mouche ; and if he is what we believe him to be, a 
 downright scoundrel, I can easily find (even though 
 the Devil himself should take his part) a way to 
 make him perfectly harmless. For everything de- 
 pends on him. It is too late this evening to carry 
 Mademoiselle Jeanne back to the school, but my 
 wife will take care of her. That frankly and plainly 
 constitutes the misdemeanor of complicity, but in 
 this way we shall avoid anything equivocal in the 
 young girl's position. And do you, my dear mon- 
 sieur, return as fast as you can to the quay Malo- 
 quais ; and if any one comes in search of Jeanne there, 
 you can easily prove that she is not in your house." 
 
 During this conversation of ours, Madame de 
 Gabry was getting a sleeping-room in readiness for 
 her young guest.
 
 2l8 THE CRIME OF 
 
 When she bade me good-night, she held on her 
 arm a pair of linen sheets perfumed with lavender. 
 
 " That is a sweet and wholesome smell," said I. 
 
 " Of course," said Madame de Gabry ; " we are 
 peasants." 
 
 "Ah!" I exclaimed; "if only I too might be a 
 peasant ! If only some day I might breathe the 
 woodland odors as you do at Lusance, beneath a 
 vine-covered roof ; and if this is too ambitious a wish 
 for an old man whose life is nearly spent, I will 
 wish, at least, that my shroud may be perfumed 
 with lavender, as is this linen which you have on 
 your arm ! " 
 
 It was decided that I should come to breakfast 
 the next morning, but they absolutely forbade my 
 appearing before noon. Jeanne kissed me good- 
 night, and begged me not to let her go back to the 
 boarding-school. We parted sad and anxious. 
 
 I found The'rese at the head of my stairs, in such 
 a condition of nervous anxiety as to make her furi- 
 ous. She spoke of nothing less than locking me up 
 in future. 
 
 What a night I spent ! I did not close my eyes 
 for a single instant. Sometimes I laughed like a 
 boy at the success of my adventure ; then, with inex- 
 pressible agony, I saw myself dragged before the 
 magistrates, and compelled to answer at the bar for 
 the crime that I had so naturally committed. I was 
 filled with terror, yet I felt neither remorse nor re- 
 gret. The sun crept into my room, and fell caress- 
 ingly across the foot of my bed. Then I prayed:
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 2 19 
 
 "O God, thou who didst make the sky and the 
 dew* as it says in Tristan, judge me in thy equity, 
 not according to my acts, but according to my in- 
 tentions, which were pure and upright Then will I 
 say, ' Glory to thee in the highest, Peace on earth, 
 Good will toward men? I leave in thy hands the 
 young girl whom I stole away. Do what I was 
 unable to do. Keep her from all her enemies, and 
 may thy name be forever blessed ! " 
 
 December g. 
 
 When I returned to Madame de Gabry's, I found 
 Jeanne transformed. 
 
 Had she, like myself, at early dawn, called upon 
 the name of Him who made the sky and the dewf 
 She wore such a sweet and peaceful smile. 
 
 Madame de Gabry called her back to finish her 
 hair, for this kind friend had taken it upon herself 
 to arrange her young visitor's locks in a becoming 
 manner. Having reached the house a little ahead 
 of time, I had interrupted the pretty toilet, and as a 
 punishment I was made to wait alone in the draw- 
 ing-room. 
 
 Monsieur de Gabry very soon joined me. He 
 evidently came from out-of-doors, for his forehead 
 still bore the mark of his hat. His open counte- 
 nance expressed joyous animation. I felt that I 
 had best not ask him any questions, and we all 
 went in to breakfast. When the servants had with- 
 drawn, Monsieur Paul, who had been keeping his 
 story for dessert, said to us, 
 
 " Well, I have been to Levallois."
 
 220 THE CRIME OF 
 
 " Did you see Maitre Mouche ? " asked Madame 
 de Gabry eagerly. 
 
 "No," he replied, studying our faces, which 
 showed the disappointment we felt. 
 
 The good man enjoyed our anxiety for a reason- 
 able time in silence; then he added, 
 
 " Maitre Mouche is no longer at Levallois. He 
 has left France. Day after to-morrow it will be a 
 week since he locked his door, and went off with all 
 his clients' money, a good round sum too. I found 
 his office closed. A woman who lived near him 
 told me the story, with many curses and impreca- 
 tions. The notary took the 7.55 train, but he did 
 not go alone. He eloped with the daughter of a 
 Levallois barber, a young girl well known about the 
 country for her beauty and her accomplishments. It 
 is said that she could shave better than her father. 
 But Mouche has eloped with her. The fact was 
 confirmed by the chief of police. And really, could 
 he have gone away more opportunely ? Had he 
 postponed his plans for a week, as the representative 
 of society, he might have sent you, Monsieur Bon- 
 nard, like a criminal, into the blackest of dungeons. 
 But now we have nothing further to fear. To 
 Maftre Mouche's health ! " he cried, pouring out a 
 glass of white wine. 
 
 I should like to live long that I might long re- 
 member that morning. We four were assembled 
 about the polished oaken table in the great white 
 dining-room. Monsieur Paul's delight was intense, 
 and perhaps a trifle boisterous in its expression ; and 
 the good fellow drained his glass again and again.
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 221 
 
 Madame de Gabry smiled at me with her gentle, 
 pure, and noble smile. Such a woman should save 
 her smiles as a reward for good deeds, that every 
 one about her might do good. As a compensation 
 for our troubles, Jeanne, who had recovered her 
 sprightliness, kept up a storm of questions for a 
 quarter of an hour, the answers to which would 
 have included, at least a dissertation upon nature, 
 man, the physical and the metaphysical, the macro- 
 cosm and the microcosm, without mentioning the 
 ineffable and the unknowable. She drew from her 
 pocket her little Saint-George, which had suffered 
 cruelly in our flight. It no longer had any arms or 
 legs, but its golden helmet with the green dragon 
 was still intact. Jeanne took a solemn vow to re- 
 store it in honor of Madame de Gabry. 
 
 I left these good friends, overwhelmed with fatigue 
 and delight. 
 
 On my return home, The'rese met me with the 
 liveliest remonstrances. She was utterly incapable 
 of understanding my new mode of living. To her 
 way of thinking, monsieur had lost his mind. 
 
 "Yes, The'rese, I am a crazy old man, I'll admit, 
 and you are a crazy old woman. There is no doubt 
 of it. May the good Lord bless us, The'rese, and 
 give us fresh strength, for we have new duties. But 
 let me lie down on this sofa, for I cannot stand up 
 any longer." 
 
 Jamutry 15, 186-. 
 
 " Good-morning, monsieur," said Jeanne, opening 
 our door for me, while The'rese, who was not so 

 
 222 THE CRIME OF 
 
 quick as the young girl, stood grumbling in the 
 shadow of the corridor. 
 
 " Mademoiselle, I beg that you will call me sol- 
 emnly by my proper title. Say, 'good-morning, 
 guardian.' " 
 
 "It's all settled, then? Oh, good!" cried the 
 girl, clapping her hands. 
 
 " Yes ; it has been settled, mademoiselle, in the 
 court-room, in the presence of the justice of the 
 peace, and you are henceforth subject to my author- 
 ity. You laugh, do you, my ward ? I see it in 
 your eyes. You have some silly idea in your head. 
 Another whim ? " 
 
 " Oh, no, monsieur my guardian ; I was looking 
 at your white locks. They fall from beneath the 
 brim of your hat like honeysuckle over a balcony ; 
 your hair is very beautiful, and I like it im- 
 mensely ! " 
 
 " Sit down, my ward ; and if you can possibly help 
 it, stop saying such silly nonsense. I have so'me- 
 thing serious to tell you. Listen ! You are not 
 absolutely bent, I suppose, upon returning to Ma- 
 demoiselle Prdfere's? . . . No? What should you 
 say if I were to keep you here in order to finish 
 your education, until but how do I know ? for 
 always, as the expression is?" 
 
 " Oh, monsieur ! " exclaimed the girl, flushing with 
 delight. 
 
 I continued, 
 
 " There is a little back room that my housekeeper 
 has cleaned and put in order for you. You will 
 take the place of the old books just as day succeeds
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 22$ 
 
 night. Go with Therese, and see if the room is 
 habitable. Madame de Gabry understands that you 
 will sleep there to-night." 
 
 She was already darting off, but I called her 
 back. 
 
 "Jeanne, listen to me further. So far you have 
 got on very well with my housekeeper, who, like all 
 old women, is naturally somewhat cross. Treat her 
 with consideration. I have thought it my own duty 
 to humor her, and to put up with her irritability. I 
 beg of you, Jeanne, respect her. And in speaking 
 in this way, I do not forget that she is my servant 
 and yours, and she will not forget it either. But 
 you should respect her great age and her great 
 heart. She is a humble creature who has grown old 
 in usefulness, and she has become confirmed in this 
 habit. Bear with the sternness of this upright soul. 
 If you command her wisely, she will obey. Go, 
 my dear girl, arrange your room in whatever way 
 may best suit your work and your comfort." 
 
 Having started Jeanne with this Viaticum on her 
 career as a housekeeper, I turned to a review, which, 
 although edited by young men, is excellent. The 
 tone of it is unpolished, but the spirit is full of 
 earnestness. The article I read surpasses, so far 
 as the strength and accuracy are concerned, all that 
 was done in my early days. The author of the 
 article, Monsieur Paul Meyer, notes every mistake 
 with clear, incisive criticism. 
 
 In those days we were not so mercilessly impartial. 
 Our indulgence was immense. It sometimes went 
 so far as to heap equal praise on the scholar and on
 
 224 THE CRIME OF 
 
 the ignoramus. Yet one should be able to con- 
 demn ; nay, it is an imperative duty. I remember 
 little Raymond (for that was his name). He did 
 not know anything, and his mind was incapable 
 of acquiring knowledge, but he was devoted to his 
 mother. We were careful not to denounce the ig- 
 norance of such a good son ; and little Raymond, 
 thanks to our indulgence, made his way to the very 
 top. He had lost his mother, but every honor was 
 lavished on him. He was all powerful, to the great 
 detriment of his colleagues and science. But here 
 comes my young friend of the Luxembourg. 
 
 " Good-afternoon, Ge"lis. You look happy to-day. 
 My dear boy, what has happened ? " 
 
 It seems that he has sustained his thesis very 
 well, and that he has taken a high rank. He tells 
 me this, adding that my works, which were dis- 
 cussed incidentally in the course of the meeting, 
 were unreservedly praised by the professors of the 
 school. 
 
 " That is good," I replied ; " and I am glad, Gdlis, 
 to see my old reputation associated with your young 
 laurels. I was greatly interested, as you know, in 
 your thesis ; but domestic affairs made me forget that 
 you were to sustain it to-day." 
 
 Here Mademoiselle Jeanne came in just in time 
 to enlighten him in regard to these domestic affairs. 
 The little madcap rushed into the City of Books like 
 a fresh breeze, exclaiming that her room was a per- 
 fect dream. She blushed deeply on seeing Mon- 
 sieur Ge*lis, but no one can escape his fate. 
 
 Monsieur Ge"lis asked her how she was, in the
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 22$ 
 
 tone of a youth who takes advantage of a previous 
 meeting, and who poses as an old acquaintance. 
 Oh! do not fear! she had not forgotten him. It 
 was apparent enough, when under my very nose they 
 took up their conversation of a year ago, on the 
 Venetian blond. They carried it on in a lively vein. 
 I asked myself what was I doing there, forsooth ! 
 In order to make myself heard, there was nothing 
 for me to do but to cough. As to talking, they 
 scarcely gave me a chance to utter a word. Ge'lis 
 spoke with enthusiasm, not only of the Venetian 
 colorists, but also of everything else relating to 
 man and nature. And Jeanne answered him, 
 
 " Yes, monsieur, you are right. . . . That is ex- 
 actly what I thought, monsieur. . . . Monsieur, you 
 express very clearly what I feel. ... I will think 
 over what you have just said, monsieur." 
 
 When I speak, mademoiselle does not reply in 
 that tone. What I say she tastes with the tip of 
 her tongue, and a good half of it she will not touch 
 at all. But Monsieur Ge'lis is authority on all sub- 
 jects. To all his chattering I hear her replies of, 
 " Oh, yes ! Oh, certainly ! " 
 
 And Jeanne's eyes ! I never saw them so large 
 and so steady ; but her glance, as always, was frank, 
 innocent, and brave. Ge'lis pleased her. She ad- 
 mired Ge'lis, and her eyes betrayed her feelings. 
 They might have betrayed it to the whole world. 
 That is all very fine, Maitre Bonnard ; but while you 
 are watching your ward, you are forgetting that you 
 are her guardian. You have been her guardian since 
 this morning, and this new function is already im-
 
 226 THE CRIME OF 
 
 posing delicate duties upon you. You should devise 
 some tactful way of keeping this young man at a 
 distance. Bonnard, you should but do I know 
 what I ought to do ? ... 
 
 I have taken up a book at random from the near- 
 est shelf. I open it, and enter with feelings of re- 
 spect into the midst of a drama of Sophocles. The 
 older I grow, the more I love the two great civiliza- 
 tions of antiquity, and I now keep the poets of Greece 
 and of Italy within arm's reach in the City of Books. 
 
 Monsieur and mademoiselle, seeing that I am not 
 bothering myself about them any more, condescend 
 to pay me some little attention. I really believe 
 that Mademoiselle Jeanne is asking me what I am 
 reading. No, indeed, I will not tell her. I am read- 
 ing of the sweet and glorious chorus that unrolls its 
 beautiful melopceia in the midst of a powerful scene, 
 the chorus of the old men of Thebes. "Epus 
 
 O Invincible Love, thou who descendest upon the wealthy, 
 Thou that makest thy couch on the soft clieeks of tlie maiden, 
 Thou tv/io passest over the seas, and entercst the shepherd 's 
 
 hut, 
 
 None either of the immortals can escape thee, 
 Or of men whose life is but a span of years. 
 And whosoever possesses thee is subject to madness. 
 
 And when I had read that delicious chant once 
 more, the figure of Antigone appeared before me, 
 in all her unalterable purity. What images, ye gods 
 and goddesses who hovered in the azure heavens ! 
 The blind old man, the beggar-king who has wan- 
 dered for years, led by Antigone, at last has received
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 22J 
 
 holy burial. His daughter, as beautiful as the most 
 beautiful pictures that the human mind has ever 
 conceived, resists the tyrant, and piously buries her 
 brother. She loves the tyrant's son, and this son 
 loves her. And as she goes to execution, the vic- 
 tim of her filial love, the old men sing, 
 
 Invincible Love, thott -who dcscendest upon the wealthy, 
 Thou -who makest thy couch on the soft cheeks of the 
 
 maiden 
 
 " Mademoiselle Jeanne, do you really want to know 
 what I am reading ? I am reading, mademoiselle, 
 I am reading how Antigone, having buried the blind 
 old man, embroidered a beautiful tapestry, on which 
 were woven joyous figures." 
 
 " Oh ! " exclaimed GeUis, laughing, " that is not in 
 the text." 
 
 " That is a scholium," I replied. 
 
 " It is unpublished," said he, rising. 
 
 1 am not selfish. I am careful. I have to bring 
 up this young girl. She is too young ; I cannot let 
 her be married yet. No ! I am not selfish; but I 
 must keep her a few years with me, with me alone. 
 Can she not wait until after I am dead ? Be not 
 anxious, Antigone, old CEdipus will in due time find 
 the holy place for his burial. 
 
 Meanwhile Antigone is helping our housekeeper 
 to clean the carrots. She says that this suits her, 
 as it is like sculpture. 
 
 May. 
 
 Who would recognize the City of Books ? There/) 1 \J 
 are flowers now on every table. Jeanne is right.
 
 228 THE CRIME OF 
 
 These roses are very beautiful in this vase of blue 
 faience. Every day she goes to market with The"- 
 rese under pretext of helping the old servant buy 
 the provisions, but she brings back nothing but 
 flowers. Flowers are indeed beautiful creatures. 
 Some day I must carry out my idea, and study 
 them in their own domain among the fields, in the 
 most systematic way I can. 
 
 And what is there for me to do here ? Why con- 
 tinue to spoil my eyes with old parchments which no 
 longer tell me anything worth while ? I used to 
 decipher these old texts with the most disinterested 
 enthusiasm. What did I hope to find in them then ? 
 The date of the endowment of some pious institu- 
 tion, the name of some monk, illuminator, or copyist, 
 the price of a loaf, of an axe, of a field, an adminis- 
 trative or judicial enactment, that and something 
 more, something mysterious, vague, sublime, that 
 roused my enthusiasm. But for sixty years I have 
 sought, and I have not found that something. More 
 worthy men than I, the masters, the truly great, the 
 Fauriels, the Thierrys, who made so many discov- 
 eries, have died without finding this something any 
 more than I have found it. It has no body, and has 
 no name, and yet without it no intellectual work 
 could be undertaken on this earth. Now that I am 
 seeking only for what I am sure I can find, I no 
 longer find anything at all ; and it is probable that 
 I shall never finish the history of the abbots of 
 Saint-Germain-des-Pre's. 
 
 "My guardian, guess what I have in my hand- 
 kerchief."
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 22<) 
 
 " To all appearances, Jeanne, it is flowers." 
 " Oh, no ! it is not flowers. Look ! " 
 I look, and see a little gray head thrusting itself 
 out of the handkerchief. 
 
 It belongs to a little gray cat. The handkerchief 
 opens. The animal springs to the carpet, shakes 
 itself, raises first one ear, then the other, and cau- 
 tiously investigates the place and the people. 
 
 While this is going on, The'rese makes her ap- 
 pearance, out of breath, her basket on her arm. 
 The kitten, evidently not over and above satisfied 
 with the result of his investigation, walks slowly 
 away from her, without, however, either touching 
 my legs or approaching Jeanne, though she calls 
 him pet names with wonderful volubility. The'rese, 
 one of whose faults is that she never dissimulates, 
 vehemently reproaches mademoiselle for bringing a 
 strange cat into the house. Jeanne, in order to jus- 
 tify herself, tells the story. As she was passing 
 with The'rese in front of a drug-store, she saw a 
 clerk kick a kitten out into the street. The kitten, 
 surprised and distressed, was in doubt whether to 
 remain in the street, in spite of the passers-by who 
 jostled against him and frightened him, or whether 
 to return to the shop at the risk of being kicked out 
 a second time. Jeanne saw that he was in a trying 
 position, and understood his hesitation. He acted 
 as if he were stupid, but she thought his appearance 
 of stupidity came from indecision. So she took 
 him up in her arms; and as he had been happy 
 neither in-doors or out, he allowed her to hold him 
 in mid air. Then, while she still kept soothing him
 
 230 THE CRIME OF 
 
 by her caresses, she said boldly to the druggist's 
 clerk, 
 
 " There is no need of kicking this .poor little crea- 
 ture, even if you do not like him. You must give 
 him to me." 
 
 " Take him," replied the clerk. 
 
 " That's the whole story ! " exclaimed Jeanne in 
 conclusion ; and she began again in a soft voice to 
 make all sorts of sweet promises to pussy. 
 
 " He is very thin," said I, examining the pitiful- 
 looking little animal ; " moreover, he is very homely." 
 
 Jeanne thinks he is not homely, but she acknowl- 
 edges that he acts stupider than ever. But now it 
 is not indecision, it is surprise, which, in her opinion, 
 gives such a disagreeable aspect to his physiognomy. 
 She wants us to put ourselves in his place. We try 
 to do so, and acknowledge that it must be out of 
 the question for him to understand what has hap- 
 pened to him. We burst out laughing at the poor 
 beast, who gazes about in a serio-comic fashion. 
 Jeanne wants to take him in her arms; but he hides 
 underneath the table, and will not come out even at 
 sight of a saucerful of milk. 
 
 We turn our backs the saucer is empty ! 
 
 " Jeanne," I say, " your prottgt is a sad-looking 
 creature. He is naturally suspicious. I trust that 
 he will not do anything in the City of Books that 
 will necessitate our sending him back to his drug- 
 store. In the meantime we must give him a name. 
 I would suggest Don Gris de Goutticre, but perhaps 
 that is a trifle long. Pilule, Drogue, or Ricin i 
 
 Pill, Drug, or Castor-OU.
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 2$l 
 
 would be shorter, and would also have the advan- 
 tage of recalling to mind his early conditions. 
 What do you say ? " 
 
 " Pilule would be good," answered Jeanne ; " but 
 it would not be kind to give him a name which 
 would constantly remind him of the troubles from 
 which we have rescued him. That would be mak- 
 ing him pay dearly for our hospitality. Let us be 
 more generous, and give him a pretty name, in the 
 hope that he will deserve it. See how he watches 
 us! He sees that we are talking about him. He is 
 not half so stupid now that he is not so unhappy. 
 I am not joking. Unhappiness makes one stupid ; 
 I know it very well." 
 
 " Well, Jeanne, if you would like, we will call 
 your prottgt Hannibal. The fitness of this name 
 does not strike you at first. But the Angora who 
 preceded him in the City of Books, and to whom I 
 was in the habit of confiding my secrets, for he was 
 a wise and discreet creature, was named Hamilcar. 
 It is natural that the one name should beget the 
 other, and that Hannibal should succeed Hamilcar." 
 We all agreed on this point. 
 
 " Hannibal ! " cried Jeanne, " come here." Han- 
 nibal, frightened by the strange sound of his new 
 name, ran and crouched down under a bookcase in 
 a space so small that a rat could not have squeezed 
 himself into it. 
 
 It was a fine way of carrying a mighty name. 
 
 That day I felt in a humor for writing, and I had 
 already dipped my pen into the ink when I heard 
 the bell. If ever any idle person should read these
 
 232 THE CRIME OF 
 
 pages, scrawled by an old man devoid of imagina- 
 tion, he would smile at the sound of the bell which 
 every moment rings out in the course of my story 
 without ever introducing a new personage or an un- 
 expected scene. 
 
 On the stage it is different. Monsieur Scribe 
 never lets a door open without some good reason, 
 without furnishing some new enjoyment for the 
 ladies, old and young. That is art. I should rather 
 be hanged than have to write a play. Not because 
 I scorn life, but because I should not be able to 
 invent anything amusing. Invent ! For that one 
 must have inspiration. The gift would be fatal in 
 my case ! Imagine if, in my history of the Abbey 
 of Saint-Germain-des-Pre's, I should invent some 
 petty monk. What would our young scholars say? 
 What a disgrace to the School ! As for the Insti- 
 tute, it would say nothing, probably it would not 
 even think about it. Although my colleagues still' 
 do a little writing, they no longer read. They are 
 of the opinion of Parny, who said, 
 
 " Une paisible indifference 
 Est la plus sage des virtus." * 
 
 To be the least possible in order to be the great- 
 est possible is what the Buddhists are striving for 
 without knowing it. If there is wiser wisdom, I 
 will go and announce it in Rome. All this because 
 Monsieur Gdlis rings the door-bell ! 
 
 This young man has undergone a great change 
 
 1 " A calm indifference 
 
 Is the wisest of virtues."
 
 SYLVESTKE BONNARD. 233 
 
 in his manner toward Jeanne. He is now as se- 
 rious as he was once frivolous, as silent as he was 
 talkative. Jeanne follows his example. We have 
 reached the phase of suppressed passion. For, old 
 as I am, I am not deceived in it. These two young 
 people are deeply and lastingly in love with each 
 other. Jeanne avoids him now. When he comes 
 into the library, she hides in her room. But how 
 well she finds him again when she is alone ! Then, 
 she speaks to him every evening in the music which 
 she plays on the piano with a quick, vibrating touch, 
 which is the new expression of her new heart. 
 
 Well, why should I not say it ? Why not acknowl- 
 edge my weakness ? Would my selfishness become 
 any the less blameworthy if I were to hide it from 
 myself? I will admit it, then. Yes, I expected some- 
 thing else yes, I hoped to keep her for myself 
 alone, as my child, my daughter, not for always, not 
 even for long, but for a few years more. I am 
 so old ! Could she not have waited ? And who 
 knows? with the aid of the gout, perhaps I should 
 not have abused her patience for long. That was 
 my desire, my hope ; but I did not take her into my 
 calculations. I did not take this silly young man 
 into my calculations. And the mistake is none the 
 less hard for me because I miscalculated. 
 
 Yet it seems to me, Sylvestre Bonnard, my friend, 
 that you are blaming yourself, quite too easily. If 
 you wanted to keep this young girl a few years 
 longer, it was for her interest as well as for your 
 own. She has much to learn, and you are not a 
 master to be scorned. When that notary Mouche,
 
 234 THE CRIME OF 
 
 who was discovered in his rascalities at such an 
 opportune moment, honored you by a call, you set 
 forth your system of education with all the enthusi- 
 asm of an adept. You have been zealously striving 
 to apply this system ; but Jeanne is an ungrateful 
 girl, and Ge"lis a very seductive youth. 
 
 But still, if I do not show him the door, an act 
 which would be detestably ill-mannered and unkind, 
 I must receive him. He has been waiting long 
 enough in my little drawing-room opposite the Se- 
 vres jars which were graciously presented to me by 
 King Louis-Philippe. The Moissonneurs and the 
 Pecheurs by Leopold Robert are painted on these 
 porcelain jars, and Gelis declares that they are fright- 
 ful ; and Jeanne, whom he has bewitched, claps her 
 hands in delight. 
 
 " My dear boy, pardon me for not seeing you at 
 once, I was finishing some work." I told the truth. 
 Meditation is work, but that is not what GeUis un- 
 derstands by it. 
 
 He supposes that I refer to archaeology; and 
 being set at ease as to the health of Mademoiselle 
 Jeanne (I said she was "very well," in a dry tone 
 which showed my moral authority as her guardian), 
 we two begin learnedly to discuss historical sub- 
 jects. We begin with generalities. Generalties are 
 a great help. I strive to inculcate into Ge"lis a lit- 
 tle respect for the generation of historians to which 
 I belong. I say to him, 
 
 " History, which used to be an art, and which 
 afforded room for all flights of the imagination, has 
 of late years become a science, in which we must 
 work in accordance with a rigorous system."
 
 SYLVESTKE BONNARD. 235 
 
 Gelis begs leave to differ with me. He says that 
 he does not think that history is a science, or that it 
 ever will become a science. 
 
 "In the first place," he says, "what is history? 
 The written representation of past events. But what 
 is an event? Is it any trifling occurrence? Cer- 
 tainly not. You say, it is an important occurrence. 
 But how can the historian judge whether the occur- 
 rence is important or not ? He judges it arbitrarily, 
 according to his taste, his fancy, his idea. In short, 
 he judges it as an artist ! For facts (from their very 
 nature) are not divided into historical facts and non- 
 historical facts. A fact is something extremely com- 
 plex. Does the historian represent these facts in 
 their complexity ? No ; that is impossible. He will 
 represent them stripped of the greater part of the 
 characteristics which made them what they were. 
 That is, he represents them mangled, mutilated, dif- 
 ferent from their original nature. As to the inter- 
 relation of the facts we need not speak. If a 
 so-called historical fact is brought out (and this is 
 possible) by one or more facts which are non-histor- 
 ical, and on this account unknown, how can the 
 historian note the relation of these facts to one an- 
 other ? And in all that I say, Monsieur Bonnard, I 
 am supposing that the historian has under his eyes 
 positive proofs, while in reality he trusts this or that 
 witness only on sentimental reason. History is not 
 a science, it is an art ; and one succeeds in it only by 
 imagination. 
 
 At this point, Monsieur Ge*lis reminds me of a cer- 
 tain young lunatic, whom I heard one day uttering
 
 236 THE CRIME OF 
 
 wild sophistries in the garden of the Luxembourg, 
 beneath the statue of Marguerite of Navarre. But 
 by a turn of the conversation, we come face to face 
 with Walter Scott, whom my scornful young friend 
 considers rococo, troubadourish, and dessus de pen- 
 dulel These were his very expressions. 
 
 " But," said I, warming up in defence of the mag- 
 nificent creator of Lucy and of the Fair Maid of 
 Perth, "the whole Past lives in his beautiful novels. 
 It is history ; it is epic poetry ! " 
 
 " It is nonsense ! " replied Gdlis. 
 
 And would you believe it ? This rattle-brained 
 youth declares that no matter how learned one may 
 be, one cannot know exactly how men lived five or 
 ten centuries ago, since it is only with great difficulty 
 that one imagines them as they were ten or fifteen 
 years ago. In his opinion, the historical poem, the 
 historical novel, the historical painting, are all abom- 
 inably false forms of art. 
 
 " In all the arts," he adds, " the artist can only 
 paint his own soul. His work, however it may be 
 clad, is his contemporary, because his spirit is in it. 
 What do we admire in the ' Divine Comedy,' if not 
 the great soul of Dante? And what do the marbles 
 of Michael Angelo show us above the ordinary, un- 
 less it be Michael Angelo himself? If a man is an 
 artist, he must give his own life to his creations, or 
 else he makes mere puppets, and dresses dolls ! " 
 
 What paradoxes and what lack of reverence ! But 
 
 ' Dessus de f>cndulc is the ornament which some years ago used to be 
 the accompaniment of French clocks; hence, anything inartistic and 
 conventional ; here, " behind the times " might express the idea.
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 
 
 boldness in a young man does not displease me. 
 Gelis rises, and sits down again. I know very well 
 what is on his mind, and what he is waiting for. 
 He speaks to me of the fifteen hundred francs he 
 makes above and beyond the small yearly income 
 of two thousand francs which he has inherited. I 
 am not deceived by these confidences. I know very 
 well that he tells me of his affairs so that I may 
 know that he is well established, steady, settled, 
 with a yearly income, fitted to marry, q. e. d,, as the 
 geometricians say. 
 
 He has risen and sat down again twenty times. 
 He rises for the twenty-first time, and not having 
 seen Jeanne, he goes out, disappointed. 
 
 As soon as he has gone, Jeanne comes into the 
 City of Books under the pretext of looking for Han- 
 nibal. She, too, is disappointed, and melancholy is 
 the tone in which she calls her prottgt to come and 
 get his milk. See her sad face. 
 
 Bonnard ! Tyrant, behold your handiwork ! You 
 have kept them apart; but the look on their faces 
 is the same, and you see from this, that in spite 
 of you they are united in thought. Cassandra, be 
 happy ! Bartholo, rejoice ! This is what it is to be 
 a guardian ? Do you see her as she kneels on the 
 carpet, holding Hannibal's head between her hands. 
 
 Yes ! caress the stupid little beast ! Pity him ! 
 Moan over him ! We know very well, you sweet 
 little pretender, the object of your sighs, the cause 
 of your complaints. Nevertheless, they make a 
 pretty picture, and I gaze at it for some time. 
 Then, glancing at my book-shelves, I say,
 
 238 THE CRIME OF 
 
 " Jeanne, all these books weary me. Let us sell 
 them." 
 
 September 20. 
 
 It is all over. They are engaged. Gelis, who, 
 like Jeanne, has neither father nor mother, made his 
 proposal through the medium of one of his profes- 
 sors, a colleague of mine, highly esteemed for his 
 character and his learning. But what a messenger 
 of love, good heavens ! A bear not a bear from 
 the Pyrenees, but a literary bear, and the latter 
 is much more ferocious than the former. 
 
 " Right or wrong (wrong in my opinion), Ge"lis 
 cares nothing about the dowry. He will take your 
 ward just as she is. Say yes, and the affair is set- 
 tled. And I beg you to make haste; for I want to 
 show you two or three rather curious tokens from 
 Lorraine, and which are new to you, I am sure." 
 
 This is literally what he said to me. I told him 
 I would ask Jeanne, and I took no small pleasure in 
 adding that my ward had a dowry! Her dowry! 
 There it is! It is my library. Henry and Jeanne 
 are a thousand miles from suspecting it, and it is 
 a fact that I am generally supposed to be richer than 
 I am. I look like an old miser. My appearance 
 belies me certainly, but it has brought me much 
 consideration. There's no kind of person whom the 
 world respects so much as a rich skinflint! I have 
 consulted Jeanne, but did I need to listen to her 
 words to know her answer? It is done now! They 
 are engaged ! 
 
 It is not in keeping either with my face or 
 with my character to play the spy upon these
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 239 
 
 young people in order to note their words and 
 gestures. 
 
 Noli me tangere is the motto of love affairs. I 
 know my duty. It is to respect the secret of this 
 innocent heart which was intrusted to my guardian- 
 ship. Let them love each other! the dear children! 
 Not a word of their love-making, not a word of their 
 frank avowals, shall be put down in this diary by 
 the old guardian whose authority was so gentle and 
 so brief ! 
 
 At any rate, I do not fold my arms ; for if they 
 have their affairs, I have mine. I am making out my 
 own catalogue of my library, with a view toward 
 selling it by auction. It is a task which both pains 
 and delights me. I linger over it perhaps some- 
 what longer than I ought to do ; and I turn over the 
 leaves in the volumes .that are so familiar to my 
 thought, to my hand, to my eyes, spending more 
 time than is necessary or best for me. But it is a 
 farewell to them, and it has ever been man's nature 
 to prolong his leave-takings. 
 
 This thick volume which has done me such good 
 service for thirty years, can I say good-by to it 
 without showing to it the respect that a good old 
 servant deserves ! And this one, that many a time 
 has comforted me by its wholesome doctrine, must I 
 not salute it for the last time as I would a master? 
 But whenever I come across a book that has led 
 me into error, that has caused me trouble by its in- 
 correct dates, its omissions, its falsehoods, and other 
 such faults, the torment of the antiquarian, 
 " Go ! " I say in cruvl joy, "go ! impostor, traitor, false
 
 240 THE CRIME OF 
 
 witness ! flee far from me, vade retro > and mayest 
 thou, ridiculously bedizened with gold as thou art, 
 and thanks to thy stolen reputation and thy fine 
 morocco covers, find a place behind the glass doors 
 in the library of some bibliomaniac stockbroker, 
 whom thou canst not deceive as thou hast me, since 
 he will never read thee." 
 
 I laid aside the books that had been given me as 
 souvenirs, with the design of keeping them always. 
 As I placed among them the manuscript of " The 
 Golden Legend," I could not refrain from kissing it, 
 in memory of Madame Tre"pof, who, in spite of her 
 high position and her wealth, remained grateful, and 
 who, in order to show her gratitude, became my ben- 
 efactress. Thus I began a system of keeping back, 
 y "^ (Then first I made the acquaintance of crime!\ 
 
 The temptations kept coming to me during the 
 night, and by dawn they were irresistible. So, while 
 the house still slept, I rose and crept stealthily from 
 my room. Shades of darkness, Phantoms of night, 
 if, lingering in my house after the crowing of the 
 cock, you saw me stealing on tiptoe about the City 
 of Books, you certainly did not cry out, as did Ma- 
 dame Trdpof at Naples, " That old man has a good 
 back ! " 
 
 I would enter the library. Hannibal, his tail in 
 the air, would come rubbing against my legs, purr- 
 ing. I would seize a volume from the shelf, some 
 old Gothic manuscript, or a great poet of the Re- 
 naissance, the jewel, the treasure, of which I had 
 dreamed the livelong night. I would take it up and 
 slip it as far as I could into the closet, where I hid
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 241 
 
 the books I was keeping back, and which was al- 
 ready full enough to burst. It is horrible to tell : I 
 was stealing Jeanne's dowry- And when the crime 
 had been committed, I would set to work again, cat- 
 aloguing industriously, until Jeanne came to consult 
 me about some detail of her dress or trousseau. I 
 never quite understood what it was, because I did 
 not know the modern vocabulary of dress-making 
 and dry goods. Ah ! if a fourteenth-century bride 
 had come by chance to consult me about her ap- 
 parel, I should have understood her. But Jeanne 
 belongs to another age than mine, and I have to 
 send her to Madame de Gabry, who is like a mother 
 to her at this time. 
 
 Night comes ! The night has come ! Leaning out 
 of the window, we watch the great dark expanse 
 covered with dots of light. Jeanne, as she bends 
 over the window-bar, holds her forehead against her 
 hands, and seems sad. I watch her, and say to my- 
 self, " Every change, even the happiest, has its sad- 
 ness ; for what we leave is a part of ourselves. We 
 must die in one life, in order to enter another." 
 4 As if in reply to my thought, the young girl says 
 to me, 
 
 " My guardian, I am very happy ; and yet I feel 
 like crying! " 
 
 LAST PAGE. 
 
 BROLLBS, Auftat at, 1869. 
 
 Page eighty-seven. Only a few lines more, and 
 mv book on the insects and flowers will be finished. 
 Page eighty-seven, and the last. ..." A s we have
 
 242 THE CRIME OF 
 
 just seen, the visits of insects are of the greatest 
 importance to plants. Their function, indeed, is 
 to carry the pollen of the stamens to the pistil. It 
 seems that the flower prepares and decks herself, 
 in the expectation of this nuptial visit. I think I 
 have shown that the nectary of the floiuer distils a 
 sweet liquid, which attracts the insect, and compels 
 it unconsciously to carry out the fertilization, either 
 direct or crossed. The latter mode is the more com- 
 mon. I have said that the flowers are colored and 
 scented in such a manner as to attract insects, and 
 so constructed as to their inner formation as to offer 
 these visitors a passage by which they may reach 
 the corolla, and so leave upon the stigma the pol- 
 len with which they are covered. Sprcngel, my 
 respected teacher, said, apropos of the down which 
 lines the corolla of the wood geranium, ' The wise 
 Author of nature did not create one ttselcss hair\ 
 I say in my turn, ' If the lily of the fields is more 
 richly clothed, as the Scriptures say, than King 
 Solomon, its purple cloak is a wedding-cloak, and 
 this rich covering is necessary for the perpetuation 
 of its life." 1 " J 
 
 Brolles ! My house is the last on the road between 
 
 1 Monsieur Sylvcstre Bonnard was unaware that some very noted 
 naturalists were making, at the same time as himself, researches in re- 
 gard to the relation between insects and plants. He was unacquainted 
 with the works of Monsieur Darwin, Dr. Hermann Miiller, as well as 
 with the observations of Sir John Lubbock. It is worthy of note that 
 Monsieur Sylvestre Uonnard's conclusions are very similar to those of 
 the three scientists above mentioned. It is less important, but perhaps 
 rather interesting, to remark that Sir John Lubbock is, like Monsieur 
 Bonnard, an arch/cologist, who began late in life to devote himself to 
 the natural sciences. Publisher's Note.
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD. 243 
 
 the village and the forest. It is a gabled house, the 
 slate roof of which shines in the sun like the breast 
 of a pigeon. The weather-cock on my roof has won 
 for me more consideration in the country than all my 
 works on history and philology. There is not an 
 urchin in the village who does not know Monsieur 
 Bonnard's weather-vane. It is rusty, and squeaks 
 shrilly when the breeze shifts. Sometimes it refuses 
 to work at all, like Thdrese, who now allows herself, 
 though grumblingly, to be helped by a young peas- 
 ant girl. The house is not large, but I am very com- 
 fortable in it. My room has two windows, and the 
 early sun pours into it. Above is the children's 
 room. Jeanne and Henry come to occupy it twice 
 every year. 
 
 Little Sylvestre had his cradle there. He was a 
 pretty boy, but very pale. When he played on the 
 grass, his mother would watch him with an anxious 
 look, and every few minutes she would lay aside her 
 sewing to take him on her lap. The poor little fellow 
 did not like to go to sleep. He said that when he 
 slept, he went far, very far away, where it was dark, 
 and where he saw things that frightened him, and 
 that he did not want to see any more. 
 
 Then his mother would call' me, and I would sit 
 down by his cradle. He would take one of my 
 fingers in his little hot, dry hand, and say to me, 
 
 "Godfather, you must tell me a story." 
 
 I would tell him all sorts of stones, to which he 
 would listen with a serious face. He was interested 
 in them all, but one in particular filled him wonder 
 and delight. It was "The Blue Bird." When I
 
 244 THE CRIME OF 
 
 had finished, he would say, " Again ! Again ! " and 
 I would begin once more ; and after a while his pale 
 little face, in which the veins stood out clearly, would 
 fall back on the pillow. 
 
 To all our questions the doctor replied, 
 
 " There is nothing much the matter with him ! " 
 
 No, there was nothing much the matter with little 
 Sylvestre. One evening, a year ago, his father called 
 me. 
 
 " Come," said he ; " our little one is worse." 
 
 I stepped to the cradle, by the side of which the 
 mother stood motionless, held there by every fibre 
 of her being. 
 
 Little Sylvestre slowly turned his eyes to me ; 
 their pupils had rolled up under his lids, and would 
 never come down again. 
 
 "Godfather," said he, "you need not tell me any 
 more stories." 
 
 No, it was not necessary to tell him any more 
 stories ! 
 
 Poor Jeanne ! poor mother ! 
 
 / I am too old to feel very deeply, but the death of 
 la child is a strangely sad mystery. 
 
 To-day the father and the mother have come 
 back to spend six weeks under the old man's roof. 
 They are just returning from the forest, arm in arm. 
 Jeanne is closely wrapped in her black shawl, and 
 Henry wears a band on his straw hat ; but they are 
 both bright with youth, and they smile gently at 
 each other. They smile at the earth which bears 
 them, at the air which plays about them, at the light 
 which each sees shining in the other's eyes. I wave
 
 SYLVESTRE BONNARD, 24$ 
 
 my handkerchief to them from my window, and they 
 smile at the poor old man ! 
 
 Jeanne comes lightly up the stairs, kisses me, and 
 whispers something in my ear, which I guess at 
 rather than hear. And I answer, " Cod bless you, 
 Jeanne, you and your husband, and your most 
 distant posterity. Et nitnc diinittis servuin tituin, 
 
 yZ&w >
 
 189S
 
 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LIBRARY 
 
 Los Angeles 
 This book is DUE on the last date stamped below. 
 
 
 LDURL r 
 
 B 
 
 373
 
 II II Illl 1 1 1 
 
 A 000 987 773 9