BRADFIEID The Redemption Of Society BiBHBBi OF SOCIETY Manuals of Fellowship, No. 12 THE REDEMPTION OF SOCIETY By Wm. Bradfield, B.A. LONDON: THE EPWORTH PRESS J. ALFRED SHARP n ofi. - UWVK-. "" SANTA - l! -A THE REDEMPTION OF SOCIETY 1. The Problem. The life of any human society, while it has many likenesses and analogies to the life of an individual, has also differences so great that the moral and spiritual problems connected with it have to be thought out over again before the great principles by which individual lives are guided can be brought to bear upon it. The question of the relation of the Christian Church to society is one that has provoked many complaints and raised many difficulties in our times. From different points of view, and in tones varying from sorrowful remon- strance to indignant denunciation, the Church has been told, not only by outsiders, but often by its own members, that it is failing gravely in the duty of applying the gospel to the life of society. Too much attention, it is said, has been given to the salvation of the individual, and shameful neglect has often been shown towards the denunciation of the sins of society and the preaching of social reform. On the other hand, there are those who think that the Church is most faithful to its own com- mission and most wise in its relation to society when it carefully avoids all matters of political and social interest upon which the opinions of people who desire the kingdom of God are seriously divided. A recent speech of the Prime Minister shows his desire that the Churches should be silent on such current topics as labour troubles and the Irish difficulty. 4 THE REDEMPTION OF SOCIETY These criticisms call for the earnest attentiorTof members of the Church. In thinking over the questions they raise one important fact ought to be faced immediately, because the ignoring of it misleads all who are either judging the Church or trying to mend it. The Church of God is no creation of its present members. They come into it as into a great inheritance. Not only its gospel, but its greatest institutions, its life of fellowship, and its evangelical commission, are all of them instituted by its great Author and Leader. We did not make them; it is ours to use them; but we are not free to lay them aside. Now we find the Church equipped for dealing with the individual. When the child is born into the world, the baptismal font is ready and the solemn service which recognizes him as a member of Christ's body, the Church. In the home, which is a true extension of -the Church, he is taught at his mother's knee to say ' Gentle Jesus.' Then the Sunday school is ready to teach him the ' sweet story of old ' ; and as the boy or girl gets to years of choice and the asser- tion of individual will, there is ' Decision Day/ or a Confirmation Service, followed by that great central gathering of the Church where the members of Christ eat the bread and drink the wine that signifies their spiritual nourishment, their con- secration pledge to be brothers to each, other and witnesses for their Master, and their great hope of His coming. Throughout life the Church provides counsel, warning, consolation, and inspiration. In its fellowship the individual learns how to realize himself as a member of Christ, till, at the end of his earthly journey, the Church assures him of the sure and certain hope, and proclaims its undivided THE REDEMPTION OF SOCIETY 5 fellowship with all who have passed behind the veil. For purposes like these, institutions, doctrines, and ' means of grace ' are provided, and while there is much reason to confess many derelictions of duty, and much shameful coldness of heart, yet the Church knows her duty with regard to these matters. If sheep wander from the fold, she understands the business of seeking and restoring them. If, however, the question of the salvation of society is brought under consideration, the whole institution of the Church seems to be inadequate and lacking in equipment, both of thought and of institution. Concerning the ' way of salva- tion ' we are, comparatively speaking, agreed, but there is no such agreement about the way of social life. There is a great paucity of institutions by means of which the mind of the Church as a whole can be ascertained or uttered, and when an attempt is made to speak to society, instead of finding itself equipped with a definite message which it has received from God, and dealing with a conscience that is already on its side, the Church is brought into the field of argument and debate and lacks its customary assurance that what it speaks is the very word of God's salvation. QUESTIONARY I. How far are our Church organizations instituted by Christ ? How far have we any right to alter them ? 2. Appeal to the Bible : the significance of prophecy. When we turn from the Church to the Bible we find something like the same difficulty. If the average man seeks in his Bible to find an answer to 6 THE REDEMPTION OF SOCIETY the question, ' What shall I do to be saved ? ' he is not likely to miss the way; but although the Bible certainly contains a large amount of social teaching, and that of the highest value, there is nothing like the same simplicity and certainty about its message as in the other case. The question of the destiny of human society is indeed not often directly dealt with except in the Apocalyptic books. In them it is true there is some quite definite teaching. The teaching of the Book of Daniel and of the Revelation has deeply influenced the thought of Christendom on this subject. The interpretation of Nebuchadnezzar's dream in Dan. ii. cannot well be mistaken, and it should be remembered that it has had a very great influence indeed upon the thoughts and beliefs of Christian men through- out the whole history of our religion. Human society is getting worse, from gold to silver, from silver to brass, from brass to iron, from iron to iron mixed with miry clay. Its destination is destruction ; a stone from the mountain, hewn without hands, breaks it all in pieces, and no place is found for it, and a new social order under the King of Peace replaces it permanently. Similarly, in the Book of Revelation, the great social order of the Roman Empire is represented as the Beast, the enemy of the Lamb, and its destiny is the lake, which burns with fire and brimstone. We cannot, however, deal with the interpretation of such teachings as these without getting first to. an understanding as to the principle underlying our interpretation. Many people regard the great prophetic and apocalyptic threats of judgement as if they were fates which must come to pass, do men will. We would plead earnestly that THE REDEMPTION OF SOCIETY 7 it is not from the Bible that this conception of the place of prophecy is learned. The outstanding evidence on the other side is that of the Book of Jonah. Jonah, compelled much against his will to give the terrible message that in forty days Nineveh shall be destroyed, is haunted by the fear that it will not really happen after all, and builds his booth that he may watch and see. The central lesson of the book is that God is glad not to carry out His own judgement when the people by their repentance make it possible for Him to forgo it. The prophet Jeremiah also insists over and over again that his stern denunciations of judgement to come are conditional. If the people will repent, God will be only too happy to withhold these judgements. He assures them that if they thoroughly amend their ways and their doings, if they Oppress not the stranger and the fatherless and the widow, and shed not innocent blood, neither walk after other gods to their own hurt, then God will cause them to. dwell in the land that He gave to their fathers (Jer. vii. 5-7). He declares that the same principle is true concerning other nations, ' If that nation concerning which I have spoken turn from their evil, I will repent of the evil that I thought to do unto them.' He follows this with the converse statement, ' At what instant I shall speak concerning a nation, and concerning a king- dom, to build and to plant it, if it do evil in my sight, that it obey not my voice, then I will repent of the good wherewith I said I would benefit them ' (Jer. xviii. 7-10). And in chapter xxvi. is a most pathetic passage where the prophet is sent to proclaim at great personal peril to himself the judgements of God upon the temple at Jerusalem, 8 THE REDEMPTION OF SOCIETY in the hope that ' it may be they will hearken and turn every man from his evil way, that I may repent me of the evil which I purpose to do unto them because of the evil of their doings' (Jer. xxvi. 3). We should not, therefore, assume that any threat of doom which the Bible contains must necessarily be fulfilled. It represents that which will assuredly happen if people continue in their evil ways. It is a great mistake to search the Bible, and to search history, with the endeavour to prove that every prophecy of judgement either has been fulfilled, or is going to be. It is to God's great glory that in so many instances this has not happened; and the fact that it has not happened is not an evidence of any unreliability in His word, but rather of the reality of His government. The great apocalyptic conception of a world that is getting worse and worse until the day of its destruction ought not then to be assumed as a terrible but inevitable fact. The question of the destiny of Society is a question of the way in which it behaves and grows, and the work of the Church for its salvation should be taken up in a spirit of earnest hopefulness that the threatened ruin may be altogether averted. QUESTIONARY 2. Contrast Paul's teaching about the Roman Empire in Romans xiii. i with that given in the Book of Revelation. 3. Give other instances of prophecies that have not been fulfilled because ' God repented Him of the evil. . . .' 3. Modern Studies of the Facts concerning Group Life. We are only just beginning to learn what are the laws of the life of the social group. Some of them, THE REDEMPTION OF SOCIETY 9 however, are becoming increasingly clear, and there are two which are of primal importance for our present quest. (i.) There is a tendency towards the preservation and continued existence of social groups which puzzles us by its persistence, even in cases when all the objects for which the groups were originally constituted have lost their value. People who are members of a tribe, of a social or religious fellow- ship, of a political party, keep on holding together, living a common group or community life when all the original purposes that drew them together appear to have vanished. In a very true sense such^ communities can and do 'lose their own soul ' without, at the same time, losing the vitality which continues to integrate them into social unities. The tendency of a social group to continue its existence appears often to be much stronger than the tendency to continue on the road of purpose which it started to explore. The history of religion and of the Churches affords us some very striking examples of ecclesiastical groups which keep on living, and fighting for life, when practically all the original meaning of the purpose which united them has disappeared. This, by the way, is one of the explanations of the present divided state of the Christian Church. The separate Methodist Churches have strong tendencies to continue living as they are when nobody can find any important reasons why they should remain apart from each other, except that the group, once formed, has this strange strong tendency to persist. (ii.) Another law of social existence is that every human society has in it a tremendous instinct of antagonism to the people and ways that threaten io THE REDEMPTION OF SOCIETY its existence. Civilized society, for instance, cannot stand thieves nor men of violence. Theft and murder, it feels, are unendurable, and the acts of dishonesty and violence that lead up to these evil deeds are sternly repudiated, more by the instinct of society than by its intelligence. It is not so much the common judgement as to what is wicked as the common instinctive sense as to what is fatal to social life which leads to the determined elimina- tion of dishonesty and violence. The evidence of this is that there are other crimes which the common conscience judges to be quite as wicked, and even more wicked, than theft and murder, about which there is by no means the same common mind that they must at all costs be stopped. Society has an instinct for self-preservation, and this instinct works with tremendous force (though often with very little help from intelligent thought) to protect it against what are felt to be its deadly enemies. The general attitude of very many English people towards pacifists during the war can only be explained by this instinct. Against every plea of common justice and legal right the nation turned away from these men, not because of any clear thought, but because of a great instinctive, unreasoning feeling towards self-protection. The best thought of the country recognized that these people might be most valuable citizens, but the common feeling that they were antagonists to the life of the British nation overpowered even the strong sense of justice which the English people generally show. The main facts, then, that we have to keep in mind, are (i.) the tremendous force of this will to live THE REDEMPTION OF SOCIETY n which every social group shows, and its continuance when the force of the original impulse that brought the group together has been misdirected or lost ; and (ii.) the awful power of the instinct which impels the social group to expel or destroy those of its members whose attitude is felt to be inimical to the social purpose and life of the group. Let us try to apply these facts to the question we have in hand. It has been the lot of most of us to find ourselves in social groups where even the very name of our Lord Jesus Christ was not welcomed. If we spoke of Him, we were made to feel that we were committing a social offence. If we continued to speak of Him we found that we were not wanted in that social group. Now if the temper that is not willing even to endure His name persists, it soon grows into antagonism, and into persecution of those who wish to be loyal to Him. Our Gospels make it very evident to us that one great motive that led to the crucifixion of our Lord was that the existing religious society simply could not stand Him at any price ; and there are not lacking signs, for those who are able to recognize them, that the same tendency is still at work. The Gospels depict to us the society of the time in the process of grouping itself into two opposite camps. In one of these camps the final conclusion is that He must be killed ; in the other, the final conclusion is that He must be worshipped and obeyed as Lord and God and Saviour. Neither party is able to ignore Him. In broad outline it may be that the question for the society of our day is just whether its attitude of ignoring Christ is to be continued up to the point of persecution and murderous antagonism, or 12 THE REDEMPTION OF SOCIETY whether He is to be received into our society as the light which illuminates its pathway, the leaven that influences the whole mass, the saving salt that pre- vents the utter corruption of the common life. The two opposing tendencies show themselves even when our society is trying to do its best hi the way of reform. If the advocate of eugenics does not possess the spirit of Christ, he seems always to arrive finally at the conclusion that his project for the benefit of the race can only be carried out at the cost of the destruction of the unfit, and a great many people who are enthusiastic for the improve- ment of the public health from other points of view appear to arrive at a similar conclusion. The Christian conscience calls this murder. The reason for the wide divergence of view is that the man with the spirit of Christ in him believes that every other living human being is a creature capable of God, a brother of the Lord Jesus Christ, and a member of the divine family. The man who has not the mind of Christ and who does not know how to help the unfit, or to get social service out of them, desires their suppression in what he believes to be the interest of the community. If St. Paul were really ' a crooked, little, humpbacked Jew,' as some historical students believe, he might have fared very badly at the hands of these people. The point for us to remember is that society still and always, by the working of its own natural laws and tendencies towards continued existence, moves either towards direct and definite antagonism to our Lord Jesus Christ, or else towards submission and loyal obedi- ence to His sway, and the question as to whether ; any society shall be broken in pieces as a potter's [.vessel, or whether it may be transformed into the " THE REDEMPTION OF SOCIETY 13 kingdom of God, is one which depends upon the ! issue whether it will growingly welcome the presence i and life of Christ in its midst, or whether it will not have this Man to reign. QUESTIONARY 4. Give instances of social groups that continue to exist when their original reason and purpose has faded away. 5. Give instances of social groups which tend actually to kill members whose individuality is not in accord with the group ideal. 6. Is there any reason to fear that the Christian religion might be exterminated by certain groups? Has this ever happened ? 4. The Need for God. There are those who think that if people will only receive and practise the second great commandment and 'love their neighbours as themselves,' they may afford, without much risk, to pass over the commandment which says they are to love the Lord God with all their heart. Now human society will always love its own life, and in that sense tend to love its neighbour as itself. The trouble is that, unless it accepts the first commandment, it does not know how to love itself. We may see cases where a social group (for instance, of young men) will accept a new comrade because they like him and regard him as a welcome addition to their fellowship ; and, because they love this new neighbour as them- selves, they will teach him all the evil that they themselves practise. He will learn the vile language, he will be shown the way to the house of the strange woman, he will be taught all manner of disobedience and defiance to the law of God, not because he is hated, but because he is loved. They practise these 14 THE REDEMPTION OF SOCIETY things themselves, and they give to their beloved what they most prize. Society cannot be trusted to go the right way, or seek the right thing, because it loves its own ex- istence, and in that sense loves its every member who has the spirit of comradeship and unity. It does not know the way, and it misses it most deplorably unless the love of God and of Chiist has the supreme place in it. It is not only that the sins of society lead it astray, but its very good-nature and goodwill and love of life become grave dangers if the spirit of Christ be absent. These are matters which deserve and claim from Christian people in our day long and earnest study. Perhaps there is nothing about which co-operative thought can be better used than in the endeavour to see and understand what are these strange and wonderful laws of life which are shaping the destinies of all our social groups, and of that great society of humanity of which they are parts. It may be an unwelcome issue to some that they should be told that none of us yet sufficiently understands the laws of social life to be able to show to others the complete truth as to the way of influencing the groups and communities in which we find ourselves. We are not left without guidance; the mind of Christ does teach us what our individual behaviour ought to be ; but the life of Christ can only be lived truly and worthily where there is most strenuous effort and earnest seeking for a knowledge and under- standing of the ways of fellowship and community life. The temper that tries to escape the trouble of thinking, on the plea that all will be well if we personally and individually follow the Master, is one which fails Him badly. He needs that we THE REDEMPTION OF SOCIETY 15 should discover, as we may through patient seeking, the secret of the great life which flows around us and carries us forward, in order that we may most effectively bring Him in and give Him His due place and power in it. The teaching of individual religion to the neglect of social issues has at the present time left us very helpless in the presence of the great social problems which confront us. With regard to economics, for instance, we know that it is our duty to ' love our neighbour as ourselves,' that it is the mind of our Master to give ' unto this last ' as unto us, and that He is the Son of a Father who makes His sun to shine and the rain to fall upon the just and upon the unjust. We know these things so far as the individual is concerned, but it cannot be pretended that we have found out how to apply them to the social life of our day. We did not make our economic system, but we haVe inherited a system which ha,