+' ' r. '& FRE1). SfiHOTTLV. <'': A' Huron St. BUFFALO, N. Y UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA. GIFT OF" Mrs. SARAH P. WALS WORTH. Received October, Accessions No. ZQ Class No. ^ THE SYSTEM OK DOCTRINES, " CONTAINED IN DIVINE REVELATION, EXPLAINED AND DEFENDED. Showing their CONSISTENCE and CONNECTION with each other. TO WHICH IS ADDED, A TREATISE ON 'THE MILLENNIUM. By SAMUEL HOPKINS, D. D. PASTOR of the FIRST CONGREGATIONAL CHURCH in Newport. IN TWO VOLUMES. VOL. II. PRINTED AT BOSTON, By I S A I A H THOMAS and EBENEZ ER T. A N D R E W S, [PROPRIETORS OF THE WORK.] At FAUST'S STATUE, No. 45, Ne*wbury Street. SOLD at their BOOKSTORE, and by faid T H O M AS, at his BOOKSTORE in Warccfter. MDCCXCIII. ' P A R T^ II. CHAPTER IV. SECT. VI. ON Saving Faith i SECT. VII. On Juftification by Faith 53 SECT. VIII. On the Covenant of Grace 95 SECT. JX. On the Manner of the Difpenfa- tion of the Covenant of Gfttfepf afhct the Preach ing of the Gofpel 108 SECT. X. On the Perfeverance of Believers 130 SECT. XL Concerning Affurance of Salvation 142 SECT. XII. On Eleftion 163 SECT. XIII. Believers not perfetly holy in this Life 193 SECT. XIV. On Death A Separate State The General Refurreftion Judgment The Eternal State of Happinefs and Mifery 213 CHAP. V. Concerning the Church of Chrift 160 SECT. I. General Obfervations concerning the Church of Chrift ibid. SECT. II. The Officers of the Vifible Church 268 SECT. III. On the Publick Inftitutions, Ordi nances and Worfhip of the Church Publick Worfhip The Chriftian Sabbath Bap tifm. The Lord's Supper 280 SECT. IV. Concerning the Di/cipline of the Church 407 CHAP. CHAP. VI. On Chriftian Praftice 424 Conclufion 465 TREATISE on the MILLENNIUM. DEDICATION 3 INTRODUCTION, $ SECT. I. In which it is fhewn from the Scripture that the Church is to enjoy a profper- ous and happy State in this World during a thoufand Years 9 SECT. II. What is .implied in the Millen nium The peculiar Happinefs and Glory of that Day. 42 SECT. III. When the Millennium will begin 83 SECT. IV. What will take place before the Millennium, to prepare the Way for the Intro duction of it 98 THE ERRATA. Pagez, line 6 from hot. for ptjjtjjes read/ro- feffes 3t 18, 19, 20, for/W/ r.jhalt. line 24, foipofjejjedr.jjrofefled jo, 23, tor beret, there 53, 17, for loving r. Jiving. ]. Z2, for lite r. life 2,7, 2 from b. forferipture r.fentence 32, 1 6, for reafwable r. remarkable Page4o,line 3 from b for myferies r. myfterlout 57, 7 from b. for ivben r. suborn 77, 8 from b. dele if 105, I4> after and r. Salvation is 314, 19, for rejetfedr.neg/efted 321, 18, for if is r. is it 434, , after diftinguiflied r.fo THE SYSTEM of DOCTRINES CONTAINED IN. DIVINE REVELATION. . . * r *M SECTION VI. Concerning Saving Faith. T HERE have been, and flill are, various and op- pofite opinions in' the chriilian world, and among Pro- teftants, refpe&ing faving faith; and very different d'ir finitions have been- given of it. Inftead of particularly defcribing thefe, and attempting to refute any of them now, it is propofed to examine the fcriptures, and en deavour from them to find what is the nature, and what are the properties of this faith. Andif in this way, which is doubtlefs the moft proper to be taken, a clear and fatis- fa&ory idea of this fubje6l may be obtained, all erro neous VOL; II. B Concerning Saving Faith. PART IL neous opinions refpedlingit^ which have been imbibed and propagated, will of courfe be dete&ed.- In this view, the following things may be obferved. I. SAVING faith is reprefented in many paffages of fcripture as confifling in a belief and aflTu ranee of the truth and reality of thofe things which are revealed and afTert- ed by God in the divine oracles. Or a conviction and allured knowledge, that the gofpel is true ; that Jefus Chrifl is the Son of God, and the Saviour of the world ; and they who have this belief, aiTurance or knowledge, are confidered and declared to be in a ftate of falvation. This is the account given of faith in the moft exprefs definition of it in the Bible. " Now faith is the fubflance of things hoped for, and the evidence of things not feen*. " Here faith is defcribed in the general nature of it ; and is faid to be that by which invifible and future things are feen as evident realities. Hence it appears, that he who realizes and is allured of the truths contained in divine revelation, has true faith, by which men believe to the faving of their fouls, which is the faith here defined, as appears from the words immediately preceding thefe, in the lad verfe of the foregoing chapter. " We are of them that believe to the faving of the foul. Novy faith, &c." When Peter faid to Jefus, " Thou art the Chrifr, the Son of the living God/* Jefus anfwercd and faid unto him, may have everlafting life ; and I will raife him up at the laft day." t Here eternal life, and to be raifed up by Chrift at the laft day, is promifed in one place to be lieving on Chrift, and in the other to eating hisflefh y and drinking his blood : therefore it is certain that thefe are not two different things, but one and the fame, which is connected with eternal life, and the condition of en joying it. But eating the flefh of Chrift, and drinking his blood, can mean nothing lefs than voluntary exer- cife, by which, from a tafte and relifti for the character of Chrift, and his excellence, the heart receives and embraces him as a fuitable and all fufficient Saviour. Calling on the name of Chrift, is fpoken of as an exer- cife of faith, or a proper expreffion of faith in him. For the fcripture faith, " Whofoever believeth on him fhall not be amamed. For there is no difference be tween the Jew and the Greek ; for the fame Lord over all is rich unto all that call upon him. For whofoever fhall call upon the name of the Lord> fhall be faved."J JMo one. who attends to thefe words can fuppofe that believing on Chrift, and calling on his name, are two diftincT: things, or doubt whether they are one and the fame exercife. To * * 1-7- f r. 4. J Rom. x. ir, 12, 13* CHAP. IV. Concerning Saving Faith. f To the famepurpofe are thofe fcriptures which repre- fent faith in Chrift by looking unto him, and trujling in him. " Look unto me, all the ends of the earth, and be ye faved."* Here looking to Chrifl, and falvation, are connected. And this is reprefented as neceffary to fal vation, and the only condition of it. But this is the fame thing with feeking him, coming to him, and accepting of him. In this paffage there is doubtlefs a reference to the direftion which God gave to the Ifraelites to fet a brazen ferpent upon a pole, in the wildernefs, with a promife that every one who being bitten of a fiery ferpent, looked upon it, fhould live : for this was a defigned type of Chrift, which our Saviour therefore applies to himfelf : and at the fame time declares that looking upon the exalted ferpent, denoted faith in him. " And as Mofes lifted up the ferpent in the wildernefs, even fo mufl the Son of Man be lifted up, that whofoever be- lieveth in him, fhould not perifh, but have everlafting life."t Trujling in God, is often mentioned in the book of Pfalms, and in other partsrof the Old Teftament, as neceflary in order to enjoy his favour, to which prom- ifes of all good are made ; in the fame manner as faith in Chrift is in the New Teftament : from whence it may be fafely inferred that they are the fame. And agree able to this, believing in Chrift is called trujling in him, by St.. Paul. " That we mould be to the praife of his glory, jvho firft trvjltjl in Chrijl."^ " Ifaiah faith, there lhall be a root of Jefle, and he that (hall rife to reign over the Gentiles, in him (hall the Gentiles trujl."\ Trujl in Chrift, implies the exercife of the difpofition or will, even the receiving and embracing of the heart : For men do not truft in any perfon or objec~l for any thing but that which to them is a GOOD, what is agree able to them, what they defire and choofe. Yea, trujl- B 4 ins Ifaiah x!v. 22. f John Hi; 14, 15. J Eph. i. 12, Rom, xv. fa. &' Concerning Saving Faith. PART II, ing is commonly ufed with refpel to fome great good upon which men fet their hearts, and depend upon it for fupport, fatisfaclion and happinefs. And that truft- ing in Chrift is the fame with looking and coming to hiii], and feeking him, will be evident from the laft men tioned paflage, by turning to the words of Ifaiah, from which it is taken : For what the Apoftle renders, " In liirn fhall the Gentiles trujl/' is in the following words in the p'ace quoted, heareth the word, underftandeth, receiveth and keepeth it, and bringeth forth fruit with patience. Upon this it may be obferved, that what is cdlcdunderftanding the word, by Matthew, is exprefTedby receiving it, by Mark. From hence it is certain, that underftanding * John v. 44. f Rom. x. 10. J Afts viii. 37, i. John v. i, 5 Matth. xiii. 23. Mark iv. 20, Luke viii. 15, l Concerning Saving Faith. PAR.T IL tmderftanding the word is the fame with receiving it ; or, at leafl, that one implies the other. But receiving the word is an exercife of heart, which appears with great certainty from the words which Luke ufes, " Which in an honeft and good heart, havi?ig heard the word, keep it." It is the honeft and good heart which underiiands, re- reives and keeps the word ; and he who has not iuch an heart,' that is, an upright and benevolent heart, does neither receive, nor underftand it. It is neediefs perhaps to obferve, that faving faith confifls in underlianding or receiving the word, the truth of the gofpel, which, ac cording to this reprefefitation, is found in an honeft and good heart, and in no other, and implies the upright, dif- interefted, benevolent excrcifes of fuch:. a heart. Before we leave this paffage, it may be ufeful to obferve, that according to this reprefentation of our Saviour, the word of truth doer, not make the evil, hard, felfifh heart, good ; but where it finds fuch an heart, it produces no faving good, but leaves it as bad as it finds it. The heart muft firft be made honeft and good ; for fuch an heart only underiiands, receives, loves and keeps the truth, and, brings forth good fruit ; as the feed takes root fo as to bring forth fruit, only in good ground. The following words of Chrift are to the fame purpofe, " If any man will do his will,hefhall know of the doctrine, whether it be of God, or whether I fpeak of myfeif."* To underftand the dodrine which Chrift tauKt, to fee the divine ftamp which is updn it, and to know that it is of God, is the defcription of faving faith, or the character of a true believer. They vyho have a heart to do the will of God, and none but fuch, have this difcerning of true faith.. Such an heart therefore, or a difpofition and will, to do the will of God, is cffential to faving faith. This is a difcerning, wife and underftanding heart, which fees the evidence of divine truth, and knows it to be of God. Whereas * John vii, 17. CHAP. IV. Concerning Saving Faith. . 13 Whereas he whofe heart oppofes the revealed will of God, which requires LOVE, remains indarknefe and unbelief. It mufl be farther obferved, III. IT appears from the fcriptures" that LOVE is im plied in faving faith, and is eflfentia! to it -, fothat where there is no holy love, there is no true faith. This is aiTert- ed by St. Paul ; by which he difiinguifhes true faith from all counterfeits, in the following words. " In Jefus Chrift, neither circumcifion availeth any thing, .nor uncircum- cifion, but : faith which worketh by love.'"* The Apof- tle does not here fay, that faith workclh love or produces it, as if faith preceded, as the caufe of love ; and that love is connected with faith, and follows it, as the certain con- fequence and effect of it. But he fays, faith worketh BY love, as fome machines move by wind or water, fprings or weights. He aflerts that love is the life and aQive nature of faying faith. By this it 15 a loving a&ive faith ; love being the life and foul of it ; fo that where there is no love, there can be no more than an inactive, dead faith. The Apoftle James fays, " As the body without the fpirit is dead, fo faith without works is dead alfo."i The operative nature of any thing, is the live of it. Things are faid to be alive, from the a6tive nature which is obferved to be in them. The aHve nature of man is the fpirit which is in him : Therefore, as the body v out the fpirit is dead, fo faith without a working nature is dead alfo. What this working nature, or alive fruit ful fpirit is, \vhich is in true faith, St. Paul tells us in the words before us : It is LOVE. Love is the fpirit and life of faith by which it a6ls, and produces all its oper ations, and is diflingnifhed from a fpurious, dead faith* Thefe two -Apo files perfectly agree in this point. Ac cording to them, that which diilinguiilies true faving faith, ?^rs^: Gal. v. 6 *4 Concerning Saving Faith. PART IL Caith, from every kind of faith which is not fo, is the life and operative nature of it, which confifts in true love. And that St. Paul is to be underftood as has been now- explained, when he faid, " Faith worketh by love/' is confirmed by .his following words. " Though I have all faith, fo that I could remove mountains, and have not love,* I am nothing. "t Here he afTerts, there can be no faith that is of any worth, where there is not love. It follows, that faving faith implies love, in the nature of it, No faith -availeth any thing, but that living, a&ive faith, to which love is eflential, and of which it is the life and a clive nature. And when he goes on to fay, " Love beareth all things, believeth all things, hopeth all things, cndureth all things,";*; the moft eafy, natural and con fident meaning of thefe words is thought to be, that love is the active nature and life of chriflian fortitude, faith, hope and patience, that thefe chriftian graces are exercifed and maintained by love, which is the foundation and foul of the whole, fo that where there is no love, there is nothing born, believed, hoped for, or endured, as chriflians do. Love Believeth all things, that is, every exercife of true faith, is an exercife of love ; and he who has love, believ eth all things which are the proper objects o faith, and ought to be believed. In this view we fee the force and propriety of his concluding words, " And now abideth faith, hope, love, thefe three ; but the greateft of thefe is love. 1 * Love is the greateft, as faith and hope are comprehended in love, as the aclive nature, life and eflence of them. That *Thewordin the original is tov.s been fo effential to faith, and fo far implied in it, that to truft or believe in God, and to love him, exprefs near th-e fame idea, and are in a meafure fynonimous. The words of Chrift to Nicodemus reprefent love as implied in faving faith, and eflential to it. " He that be- lieveth on him, is not condemned : But he that belie v eta not, is condemned already, becaufe he hath not believed in the name of the only begotton Son of God. And this is the condemnation, that light is come into the world, and men loved darknefs rather than light, becaufe their deeds were evil. For every one that doeth evil, hateth the light, neither cometh to the light, led his deeds Ihould be reproved. "+ On thefe words may be obferved the following things. 1. That our Saviour here represents men as condemn ed, or not, according as they believe on him, or not. H-e that believeth is not condemned : But he that believetli not is condemned. 2. That the ground of this condemnation is their loving darknefs, and hating the light or truth. It follows from this, that loving darknefs is the reafon and ground of unbelief; and therefore that the love of the truth is neceffary in order to believing on the Soa of God, and is * J. Gar, u. 9, f Ifaiah Ixiv, 4. J John ili. 4S, 19,70, iS Concerning Saving Faith. PART II, is implied in it. Yea, it appears from this reprefenta- tion, that lovingdarkneh rather than light, and fo refilling to come to the light, is unbelief itfelf. And therefore, coming to the truth in the love of it, or in the exercife of love, is faving faith. This is very parallel with St. Paul's account of this matter. He fays, } Other paffages of fcripture hold forth the fame truth * but it is needlefs to mention them particularly, fince thole which have been mentioned are fo clear and exprefs on the point before us. And if this were not ib, and there were no fuch fcriptures to be produced ; the truth. alTerted maybe demonflrated from what has been before proved from fcripture refpe&ing divine illumination, and faving faith, viz. That true faith implies a right tafte and exercifeof heart, which can be nothing but love : And the light and difcerning which is effential to faith, implies difinterefled benevolence, or love. And who can help feeing that approbation of the character of Chrift, and receiving and trufting in him as the Saviour of finners, which has been fhown is the fcripture account of faith, does neceffarily imply, and really is, love to him ? From all this the perfect confiftency of the fcripture on this head is apparent ; and that it is agreeable to the reafon and nature of things. IV. IT appears from the fcripture that true repent ance is included in faving faith : That repentance comes into the nature and elTence of faith, fo that where there is no repentance, there is not, nor can be, any faving faith. This will be evident to any one, who will well obferve the following things : i. The fcripture reprefents repentance as neceffary in order to pardon. We are told that John did " preach the baptifm of repentance for the remiffion of fins."* That is, he preached repentance, as neceffary in order to their obtaining forgivenefs. Jefus Chrift taught his difciples, " that repentance and remiffion of fins mould be preached in his name among all nations. "+ That i.% that forgivenefs of fins fhould be proclaimed and offered to * Mark i. 4. f Luke xxiv. 47, VOL. II, C - 1$ Concerning Saving FahL PART II, to all that fhould repent, and to none but fuch ; to which all fhould be invited and called. Accordingly, we find the Apoftles preached agreeable to this diredion. cc Re- fcnt and be baptized, every one of you, in the name of Jefus Chrift:, for the remiflion of iins."* " Repent ye therefore, and be converted, that your fins may be blotted out."i 2. As repentance is neceflary in order to forgivenefs ; fo forgivenefs of fins is promifed to repentance. The paflages mentioned under the foregoing particular are fo full and exprefs in this, that it is necdlefs to repeat them, or to turn to others which affeit the fame thing. As repentance is required, in oixler to forgivenefs, fo forgive nefs is connected with repentance. 3. Faith is reprefented in fcripture as the only condi tion of pardon and falvation by Chrift : As that without which no man mail be forgiven and faved ; and to which thefe are promifed. " He that believeth and is baptized, fhall be faved ; but he that believeth not, fhall be damn- ed." " He that believeth on the Son, hath everlafting life : And he that believeth not the Son, (hall not fee life ; but the wrath of God abideth on him." " To him give all the Prophets witnefs, that through his name, whofoever believeth in him, fhall receive remiflion of fins." 1 !! A great number of pafTages to the fame purpofe might be cited. From thefe premifes it follows, that faving faith and repentance are not two diflin6l exercifes, but imply and include each other, fo that repentance comes into the na ture and efTence of faith. There is no other poflible fuppo- fition by which the fcriptxire account of this mattercan be reconciled. If he who believes is forgiven, and fhall be faved, and he who believeth not, is condemned ; and yet no one is forgiven, or fhall be faved, unlefs he repent j and * Adlii. 38. f Aft iii. 19. Mark xvi, 16. ^ John viii. 36. f Afts x. 43. CHAP. IV. Concerning Saving Faith. l v g and pardon and falvation are promifed to repentance ; then he who believes, does alfo repent, and he who does not repent, does not believe : Which could not be true > unlefs repentance and faith imply each other, fo that there is faith in evangelical repentance, and repentance comes into the nature of faving faith, and is effential to it. Faith and repentance are not two diftinct parallel condi tions of pardon and falvation. They cannot be fo, con fident with the reprefentation of fcripture refpe&ingthis matter, which has been produced. But they are fo im plied in each other, and fo far connected, that one is not without the other. It is abundantly evident that the Evangelifts and Apof- ties viewed and treated the matter in this light. This appears not only from what has been already obferved ; but it will be farther evident by attending to the account which the Evangelifts, Mark and Luke, give of the gofpel, which Jefus Chrift directed his Apoflles to preach to all nations. In Mark, we have it in the following words 4< And hefaid unto them, go ye into all the world, and preach the gofpel to every creatures. He that believeth and is baptized, {hall be faved ; but he that believeth not, (hall be damned. "* The good news to be proclaimed is fummed up in thefe words, holding forth the condition on which eternal life is to be offered, and obtained, which is here called believing. Luke fays that Chrift directed, " that repentance and rcmiflion of fins fhould be preached in his name among all nations."! Thefe words contain the fum of what Chrili ordered to be preached, and ex* prefs the condition on which pardon and falvation were to be offered to all nations ; and therefore is parallel with the paffage juft cited from Mark, and does exprefs the very fame thing, though in different words. But what Mark calls believing, Luke calls repentance. Therefore, faving faith and repentance, are not eifentially different ; C 2 but * Mark xvi. i6. f Luke xxiv. 47, '0.e, Concerning Saving Faith. PART II, but repentance implies what is eflential to faith, and faith takes into the nature of it what is effential to true repent ance, fo that one may be put for the other confident with propriety and truth. The account we have of the Apoflles preaching this famegofpel, in the execution of their Lord's inftructions, ferves to prove that the above cited words of the Evan- gelifls are intended to exprefs one and the fame thing, and point out the only condition on which they were to offer pardon and falvation, and that the Apoftles under- llood it thus. When the hearers of Peter's firft fermon were brought folicitoufly to afk, " What (hall we do !" He faid unto them, " Repent,, and be baptized, every one of you, in the name of Jefus Chrift, for the remiflion of fins."* Here he exprefsly preached y faith toward our Lord Jefus Chrift^ he intends thofe views and exercifes of heart toward Jefus Chrifl, as a fuita- ble and all fufficient Saviour from fin, an d the curfe of the law, which are agreeable to the gofpel, 2nd to which firi- ners are invited. According to this diflin&ion, as re pentance toward God is put firfl, fo it takes place in the inind firfl, in the order of nature, and precedes faith in Jefus Chrifl. Repentance toward God, in this fenfe of it, refpects the term from which the finner turns in con- verfion, and confifls in a cordial approbation of the law of God, and felf condemnation for his fin, and hating and renouncing it in his heart. Faith in Jefus Ghrift refpeels Afts xx, 21. CHAP. IV. Concerning Saving Faith. 25 refpe&s the term to which the finner turns, viz. God in Jefus Chrift, or God manifeft in the flefh ; and confifts in believing the gofpel with all his heart, which implies receiving and trufting in Chrift, as a fufficient and fuita- ble Saviour for fuch a finner. The fame diftinSion fcems to be made between repent ance, and faith in Ghrift, in the following paflages. - " Repent ye, and believe the gofpel."* " And ye, when ye had fecn it, repented not afterward, that ye might be lieve him/'t " But fhewed unto them that they fhould repent, and turn unto God."+ But all this is confiflent with repentance being implied in faith, fo that where there is no repentance, there is no faith in Chrift ; and repentance, taken in the full fenfe of it, implying faving faith : And the whole may be confidered as'one and the fame complex acl: of the mind, viewed and diflinguifhed according to the different and oppofite objects to which it has refpecl;, viz. fin and the curfe ; and God in Jefus Ghrifl, which is a turning from fin to God, revealed in the gofpel. And therefore, when faith or repentance is mentioned without any limitation, each comprehends the whole, even active converfion, or turning from fin to God, by Jefus Chrift. To prevent miftakes, and farther to elucidate this point, it muft be obferved, that repentance toward God, which, in the order of nature, at leaft, is antecedent to faith in Jefus Chrift, implies faith in God, or a real be lief of his being and glorious perfection. For as has been obferved, God muft be feen in fome meafure in his true character, in order to fee the reafon and found ation of his law, and confequently the evil nature of fin, which can be known only by underftanding the divine law. Mark i. 15. -f- Matth. xxi. 32. J Afts xxvi. 20. $ vSee Mr. EdwarcU's Difcourfeon Juftification by Faith alone, page 103, 114, published in the year 1738. And Mr. Bellamy's Eflay on the Nature ?nd Giory of the Gofpel of Jefus Chrift- Seftion viii f 2? Concerning Saving F CHAP. IV. Concerning Saving Faith. 35 kingdom, as the firft and moft important object, is an exercife and expreflion of love and union of heart to him, and a cordial receiving him as the Son of God, and Sav iour of men. Therefore, if receiving Chrift, is the fame with believ ing on him, or comes into the effence of faving faith ; then all gofpel holinefs, as it has refpecl; to Chrift, and is a practical receiving him in his true character, is really the exercife of faving faith, and is all included in it. This is that by which faith operates, in the proper exer tions of it, and is made perfect. And we are hence led to fee the meaning and propriety of the following words, as a concife defcription of evangelical faith and holinefs. " As ye have therefore received Chrift jefus the Lord, /a walk ye IN HIM. And whatfoevev ye do, in word or deed, do all in the name of the Lord jfefas."* But a queflionmay be fuggefted in the minds of fome,, from the foregoing account of faving faith, which it will be proper to anfwer, as this may ferve to render the fub- jefc more clear and intelligible. It is as follows : QUESTION. If hope, love and repentance are faving faith ; and if every chriftian grace, and all the branches of gofpel holinefs, are implied in faith, and really are faith, why are thefe difiinguifhed, and called by thefe different names, in the fcriptures ? We find faith, hope, and love, mentioned and diftinguifhed as different graces. And we often find a particular enumeration of the feveral ehriftian graces, fuch as, faith, love, hope, joy, humility, repentance, *Col.ii., iii. 17.- "The obedience of a chriftian, fo far as it istruly evangelical, and performed with the fpirit of the Son font forth into the heart, has all relation to Chrift the Mediator ; andisbiaanexprefflonoftk^ foul's believing unitlon to Cbr'tji. All evangelical works, are works of that faith that worketh by love ; and .every fuch aft of obedience, wherein it is inward, and theac"t of the foul, is only a new, effective adt of receptioti of Chnft, and adherence to the glorious Saviour."~l > reu"deut Edwards 's I>:fcoufe on T unification by Faith alone, page 87. D 2 $6 -Concerning Saving -Faith. PART IL repentance, righteoufnefs, goodnefs, godlinefs, meekneft, patience, temperance, &c. If all thefe are faith, or in cluded in it, why are they diftinguiftied from it, as they feern to be ? ANSWER, i. It rnufl be evident to every one who will attend, that the various chriftian exercifes, which are denoted by different names in fcripture, and com monly called chrijlian graces, are not in themfelves fo diftin6l and different as not to imply each other. To fuppofe them to be diftinft, feparate and independent one of another, is manifeftly contrary to truth, and tends to confufe and miflead the mind in attending to fubje&s of this nature. True grace, or chriftian holinefs, is, in the nature of it, one and the fame thing, though as it is exerted, and ap pears in various exercifes, on different occafions, in dif ferent circumftanccs, and towards different objects, there is a diverfity, or it puts on different forms, from which it is called by different names ; while yet, in fubftance and effence, it is the fame thing. It is abundantly evident from fcripture, that love is the whole of all chriftian grace. This is all that is required of men. In this the law is fulfilled and obeyed. There fore, all chriftian holinefs confifts in this. It follows, that all chriftian graces are love in the various branches of it, exercifed and cxprefled on various occafions, in dif ferent circum fiances, and towards different ohjecls. The Apoftle Paul fays, " All the law (meaning the fecond table of it) is fulfilled in one word, even in this, " Thou .fhalt love thy neighbour as thyfelf."* Yet he denominates the various exercifes, in which men do by this love and ferve one another, by different names, fuch es goodnefs, mercy, gentlenefs, patience, mecknefs, long- fuffering, Sec. In the fame manner love to God, which is Gal. r. 14. CHAP. IV. Concerning Saving Faitk. $?> is the whole that is required in the fjrlt table of the law, is called love, faith, truft in God, fear, hope, joy, repent ance, humility, &c. according to the different views and circum fiances in which this fame love is exerciied : All which, therefore, are the exercifes of one and the fame affection, and do involve and imply each other, and are in fubflance and efTence the fame. The new creature, produced by the fpirit of God in regeneration, by which men are created in Chrifl Jefus unto good works, is that in which all chriftian holmefs con fids. This is the moral image of God; the divine nature communicated and implanted ; or Chrift formed in the foul. And this confifts in a principle of true love. And all the exercifes and obedience of a chriftian, through the courfe of a holy life, are the exertions and exercifes of this love, this new creature. It is the fame life and active- nature, by which the chriflian lives, and atls in a holy manner, on alioccafions ; the new creature living and acling : As much fo, as the various exercifes of an animal are the fame life, exerting itfelf and acling. Unlefs we have this view of the grace or holinefs of a chriflian, as it is exereifed on all proper occafions, and towards different objects, and in manifold various circum- fiances, called love, faith, hope, repentance, Sec. our thoughts on this fubjett will be attended with a degree of darknefs and confufion. ANSWER, 2. Notwithstanding chriflian holinefs is one and the fame thing in the nature and effence of it, and every branch of evangelical obedience is the exercife of the fame principle and life ; yet this fame love or holi- r.efs, as it is exereifed in different modes and forms, on various occafions, in peculiar circumflances, and with refpecl: to different and oppodte objecls, may properly be dillinguifhed by different names : Yea, this is conve nient and neceffary, in order to the moll axaft and clear D 3 communication 38 Concerning Saving Faith. PART IL communication of the ideas which are effential to the right understanding of this fubjecl;. In the courfe of a chi iftian life, the fame holy principle, the fame in kind, nature and fubftance, exerts itfelf on various occafions, and puts on different modes, and appears in different forms, as it refpe&s the different circumftanccs of the fubjecl: exercifing himfelf, and the different and oppofite objefts, which are particularly regarded by the mind : And it is proper and neceffary, in order to reprefent and cxprefs, in the befl manner, this exercife in the different modes and forms of it, to call it by different names. And none can talk or write intelligibly on the fubjecl; any other way, without a perpetual, tedious circumlocution. Right views and exercifes of heart, refpe&ing God, confidered as being what he is in himfelf, is LOVE, con- fidered in the general nature of it, as confiding primarily in difmterefled benevolence, and comprehending all holy love. This is generally meant perhaps by love, when fpoken of in fcripture, in diftinftion from other graces, fuch as faith and hope, Sec. and is the root and effence of all right exercifes of heart. The love of a (inner towards God, whom he has offend ed, fo far as it regards thofe objects which relate to his effence, exercifes itfelf in juftifying God in all his decla rations and proceedings againft the finner ; in conferring his fin with felf condemnation and abhorrence ; in hat ing fin, and turning from it. And this is true repent ance. This fame love, as it confifts in believing in, realizing and reliihing the true character of the invifible God and Saviour, as exhibited in divine revelation, is exercifed in receiving and tru fling in him as a wonderful, allfufficienr, excellent and glorious Saviour of finners. And this is faving faith, as diftinguiflied from repentance; hope and love, Love 4 CHAP. IV. Concerning Saving Faitk. 39 Lov.e, confidered as realizing and defiring the future good things, brought to light in thegofpel, as the portion of the redeemed, and relying upon the divine declara tions and promifes, is hope, as diftinguifhed from faith and love. But it rnuft be obferved and remembered, that as faith, hope, repentance, &c. partake of the nature of love, and are really love diverufied, with refpecl; to the objects and operations of it ; fo they are included in each other, and where one is, there the others are, as comprehended in that. Yea, repentance, faith, hope and every chriflian grace, may all be comprized in the famecxercife of heart. Thus, faith and repentance cannot be feparated, but im ply each other, and come into the very fame acl; of the mind, as a true fight and fenfe of the divine characler, and of the nature of fin, are implied in both, and effen- tiai to each : And a turning from fin to Chrift, is both repentance and faving faith. Hence it is that, though there is this variety and dif- tinlionin the exercifes of the new creature, which is the. proper ground of their being called by diftincl; names ; yet as what is called by thefe different names, is really involved in the fame aft of the mind, and one is implied in the other, they are often ufed to denote the whole, or the whole is often intended to be comprehended by one of thefe names. Thus love is often mentioned in the fcriptures as intending the whole of chriftian holinefs. And repentance is frequently put for the whole of aftive converfion : And the fame is often denoted by faith, as has been obferved and mown. And hope is ufed to ex- prefs the whole of faving faith. The whole of the foregoing, concerning the nature of faving faith, will lead to the following definition of it. Saving faith is an under/I an ding y cordial receiving the divine ttjtimoriy concerning jfefus Chrijl y and the way cf falvation by him ; in 'which the heart accords and con forms to. the gofpel. The 40 Concerning Saving Faith. PART II. The following obfervations may ferve to illuftrate this definition ; and farther explain and confirm what has been offered on this important fubject : I. TH E things which the gofpel contains, as peculiar to if, which relate to Jefus Chrifl, and redemption by him, and which are the objects about which chriflian holinefs is chiefly exercifed, are matters of pure revelation. The exhibition of them to us is by revelation only. And it is a revelation of fpiritual, fupernatural, myflerious and wonderful things, which without fuch revelation are wholly out of light, altogether above our fenfes and rea- Ton, and out of the reach of any created faculties, as they depend entirely on the mere good pleafure of God. In this revelation alone, are exhibited the perfon and cha racter of Jefus Chrifl, an invifible, wonderful and myfle rious perfon. And here we have our (late revealed as it refpects him, and his character and works, our need of him, and concern with him, as offering himfelf to us as 2n allfufficient Saviour. And the benefits offered by Chrifl, are deliverance from invifible eternal evil, and the beflowment of good things, which are invifible, won derful, incotnprehenfible and future, belonging to the unfeen world. II. THE gofpclisnot of the nature of a law exhibiting the fovereign authority and will of God, demanding of man what is his duty, which he is to perform and offer to him, being what he expects to receive of man, as the price of his favour : But it is of the nature of a tejlimony ; a revelation not of works to be done by us, in order to a reward, and the price of it ; but of what God has done for us ; and an offer made to us, to be received by us. It is a revelation teflifyingto us God's my fieri es, wonder ful mercy, wifdom and power, exercifed in our behalf, making ample provifion for the redemption of man, and offered CHAP. IV. Concerning Saving FaM. 4t offered to us, in order to a reception by us, anfwerable to fuch a revelation. It is a record and teftimony which God has given of invifible, fpiritual, fupernatural good things, which are provided and fluted to our circum- ftances and neceflities, and freely offered to all who are willing to receive, as a free bounty, without money and without price. This leads to obferve again, III. THIS revelation represents man as altogether, universally and remarkably dependent on God for fal- vation and happinefs : Nothing could let this in a more vifible, fenfible, ftriking light, than the gofpel does. This reprefents man as infinitely guilty and miferable, as wholly undone, helplefs and loft, and altogether depend ent on the Redeemer for that help and grace, of which he is, and ever will be, infinitely unworthy. Now, in the view of thefe observations, it appears, that the leading and principal exercife and manifeftation of a right tafte, or of the new creature, which confifts in the concord or agreement of the heart with the divine truths exhibited in the gofpel, is, in believing them, and ac- quiefcingin them as true, and as really being juft as they are reported by the word and teftimony of God. And this, as has beenfhewri, is not an act of intellect merely ; but of the whole foul, in the exercife of a right tafte and temper of mind, which is holinefs, or the new creature. And as this divine revelation, in which the things of the gofpel are exhibited, is a tefumony of good things provided by God, and freely offered to man, in order to his reception, that exercife of the heart, which is an fwerable to this teftimony, and by which theheart accords with this revelation, and embraces it as true and good, confifts in a proper and cordial reception of the good things therein offered, which is the fame with receiving Chrift, in which, as has been fhewn, chriftiaii virtue or holinefs confifts. And this alfo has been fhewn to be faving faith. And 42 Concerning Saving Faith. PART II. And as the gofpel reprefents man as {landing in in finite need of the good things therein brought to view, and offered, he being in hirnfelf altogether undone and helplefs, in an infinitely wretched and dangerous (late, that exercife or ioui which is anfwerable to this view of the cafe, by which it confents to this revelation and tefti- mony, is a renouncing all felf dependence, and looking to and trading in Chrift alone for righteoufnefs and ftrength, and complete redemption. And this alfo is faving faith. Saving faith is the proper, alive union of the foul to jefus Chrift, a$ he is revealed in the gofpel. But fuch union with Chrift, confifts in the aclual agreement of the heart with Chrift, and fuiting and adopting itfelf to him and redemption by him, or actively receiving and embrac ing the teftimony given concerning him, in exercifes conformable to this revelation, as a revelation of invifible things, which are fupernatural and wonderful, altogether beyond the notice of our fenfes, and above our reafon and comprehenfion ; a revelation of an invifible, won derful, divine Saviour, and his fupernatural, miraculous works of power and grace, and as one who was dead, and yet is alive, and lives forever; a revelation not of a law or command, as an expreflion of the authority of God, demanding fomething of us which we fhould ren der to him, as the price of his favour; but a revelation of his furEciency for us ; his wonderful grace and mercy to us, needy, helplefs creatures, infinitely unworthy and guilty: A revelation of a way of falvation confifting in deliverance from infinite invifible evil, and the poffeftion of good things which are unfeen, fpiritual, incomprehen- fible, future and eternal ; which are all freely offered to him who will receive them, however unworthy and ill deferving he be. When the foul actively conforms in its views and exercifes to fuch a revelation and teftimony as CHAP. IV. Concerning Saving Faith. 43 as this, and acquiefces in the truths and objecls revealed, as certain realities, excellent and divine, it does actively unite itfelf to JefusChrift ; and in this aclive union to him confifts. And that act, and that courfe of exercifes of the heart, which are proper and fuitable to fuch an ex hibition as this, to a revelation by God of fuch things, may moft properly be called believing, receiving, feeking, looking, trufting,. or in one word, FAITH. It may be prefumed that no word can be found which fo properly and fully expreffes thofe views and exercifes of the mind, by which it actively unites itfelf to Chrift, as he is revealed in the go.fpel, as the word Faith, according to the proper meaning of the word in the original, as it was u fed when the New Teftament was written ; or accord ing to the meaning and general ufe of the word Faith. The revelation which Cod flrft made to innocent man, was a law, or covenant of works, exprefling his will and authority in requiring of them fupreme and perfect refpect and love, which they mud render to him, as the price of his favour, and which he would reward with eternal life ; and the lea ft neglect of duty required, he threatned with his awful difpleafure. This is properly cal led a la w,or covenant of w o R K s ; and compliance with fuch a revelation and command confifts in works, working in order to a reward. Thefe are " The works of the law.'* The revelation made in the gofpel, which is the ex hibition of a covenant of grace to guilty man, is exceed ingly divers, in many refpe&s, from the other. This is not a manif citation of the authority of God as lawgiver, demanding obedience as a worthinefs to recommend to his favour and rewards ; but the revelation of a Saviour for loft man ; the unfpeakable free gift of God, as a rem edy fuited to his neceffities; the offer of free undeferved mercy and glorious grace, through a worthy Mediator ; and every one is invited to partake in this wonderful glorious 44 Concerning Saving Faith. PART II. glorious provifion, however unworthy and guilty. Here then no virtue or moral goodnefs is, or can be given, as a price of the falvation exhibited and offered ; but all the virtue and holinefs that can be exercifed in this cafe, confiftsin believing and receiving the things exhibited and offered, or acquiefcing in them as real and excellent. And this, as it is oppofed to obedience or works, as a worthinefs to recommend to favour and a reward^ is more properly called FAITH. The ApofUe Paul makes this diftin&ion, as a very im portant one. He calls the gofpel *ht law of Faith, by which he diftinguifhes it from the firft covenant, and fets it in oppofition to it, which he calls The law of works . :i Where is boafting then ? It is excluded. By what Jaw? of works? Nay, but by the law of faith."* The gofpel, or covenant of grace, is the law of faith. It is a revelation and tefUmony, a proper conformity to which, puts on that peculiar form, which is beft denominated by calling it FAITH, in diftin&ion from the obedience re- quired by the law of works. He fets this in the fame light in the following words. " Received ye the fpirit by the works of the law, or by the hearing of faith ?"f Here he fets the covenantor law of works, in oppofition to the hearing of faith, or the report or revelation of the gofpel or covenant of grace. The former requires works, perfect works, as the price of a reward : The latter brings and offers all good to him who will receive it, or which is the fame, to him who believeth. In this fame view he puts faith in oppofition to the works of the law, or obedience to a covenant of works, in the following words, " Becaufe they fought it not by faith, but as it were by the works of the law."* To feek righteoufnefs, as it were by the works of the law, is to do works, or attempt ath of obedience to law, with a view to offer this as their righteoufnefs, Rom. Hi, 27. -f Gal. iii, 2. J Rom. ix. 32. CHAP. IV. Concerning Saving Faith. 45 righteoufnefs, and worthinefs, to recommend themfelve3 hereby to acceptance and favour with God. To feek righteoufnefs by faith, is to receive and truft in the atone ment and righteoufnefs of the Mediator, or cordially to embrace the gofpel, which is evangelical obedience, and as much a work, and exercife of gofpel holinefs, as any obedience to the gofpel whatever, and is the obedience of faith, as has been proved. From the foregoing, the following queftion may arife in the minds of fome. QUESTION. The Apoflle Paul, feys men are not juflified by works : But if faving faith implies works, and cannot be diftinguifhed from evangelical obedience, and rrien are juftified by faith; they are really juftified by works, or evangelical obedience. Is there not an incon- fiftency in this ? And why is not evangelical holinefs, a righteoufnefs which recommends him who has it to the favour of God, as a moral worthinefs, and a ground of boa (ting ? ANSWER. What has been already faid, is a full anfwer to the fiift part of this qrfeftion ; and it is prefumed every one who has underftood it, will fee the queftion to be wholly without ground. By the works and deeds of the law, is meant obedience to law as a covenant of works, in order to obtain the righteoufnefs of the law, to be thereby recommended to the favour of God, as has been obferved and (hewn. This the Apoflle oppofes to faith, but does not oppofe evangelical holinefs to faith, but con- fiders thefe as implying each other ; which gofpel obedi ence, is not offered as a righteoufnefs to recommend.; but confifts in renouncing all worthinefs or claim to any favour, and receiving pardon and falvation as a free gift, to an infinitely unworthy and ill deferving finner. This. paint, Concerning Saving Faith. PART II. point, and the latter part of the queftion, will be more particularly confidered in the next fe&ion.. I M P R O V E M E N T. I. FROM the above defcription of faving faith, taken from the holy fcripture, we learn that what has been called faving faith by fome, is not fo. i. Saving faith does not confift inaperfon's believing that his (ins are forgiven, that Jefus Chrift died for him, and he mall be faved, and the like. A perfon may have a ftrong and mod confident perfuafion of this, without any good reafon for it, and all may be grofs delufion. No one can have any ground for fuch a belief, until he Las exercifed faving faith, and has evidence that he does believe in Chrift, repent, c. for hone but fuch are pardoned, or can have any evidence that they fhall be faved. Men muft Jirjl repent and believe in Chrift, in order to pardon, and a title to falvation, and therefore they cannot know or have any evidence that they are for-, given and fhall be faved, until they have exercifed faving faith. To believe they fhall be faved, from any other fuppofed evidence, is mere delufion, and contrary to the exprefs declaration of fcripture. Indeed, a perfon's faith, which confifts in true tafte and difcerning, and a cordial embracing the gofpel, may be fo ftrong and fenfible, as to be attended with a corifcioufnefs and affurance that he does believe with a faving faith ; and confequently that he is pardoned, and mail be faved. But faving faith does not coniift in this belief and aflfurance ; but muft firft exift in the mind, as the proper ground of fuch confcioufnefs and afliirance. Therefore, the former, may, and often, if not commonly, does take place, with out the latter. 2. A CHAP. IV. Concerning Saving Faith. 4% 2. A mere fpeculative belief of the truth, not including any exercife of heart, is not faving faith. This, it is pre- fumed, has been abundantly proved from fcripture. 3. Saving faith does not conuft in that belief, which includes works of the law, done in order to recommend perfons to the divine favour, on account of their moral worth and excellence. This is the faith for which Ar- minians have plead. They fay, true faith implies good works : But by good works they evidently mean, what: the Apoftle Paul means by the works of the law, done as the price of the favour of God ; and not evangelical obe dience, which ftandsoppofed to the former, as it has been defcribed above. Their faith and their works are whol ly antichriftian ; and therefore oppofed to true evangeli cal faving faith. 4. That is not faving faith which can be feparated, even in theory, from good works, and evangelical obe dience. This has been abundantly proved from fcrip ture in this fe&ion. It has been too common for thofe who defcribe faith as implying exercife of heart, even a cordial reception of Chrift, yet to fpeak of good w.orks and gofpel holinefs and obedience, as the fruit and ef- fe6l, of which faving faith is the caufe, and as if they were two diftincfc things. It is not agreeable to fcripture to make fuch a diftinftion. It is inconfiftent with their own definition of faith, and contrary to the truth ; and therefore of a bad tendency. 5. That is not faving faith which precedes regenera tion, and the new heart. Some have fuppofed that the impenitent, unrenewed perfon believes, and by this faith, his heart is renewed, and becomes penitent and obedient. This is contrary to fcripture and all reafon, which has been made evident. Faith implies aright difpolkion of heart, and therefore does not precede it, and produce it. No perfon, but a regenerate one, has faving faith. II. 4$ Concerning Saving faitji. PART II. II. THE view we have had of faving faith ferves to (how why it is reprefented in fcripture as a duty ; and men are commanded to believe on Jefus Chrift : And why unbelief is reprefented as wholly inexcufable, and a great tin. If faving faith didconfift in mere fpeculation, and the heart had no concern in it, and no degree of difpofition and exercife of that were implied in believing, it could not be required as a duty, or unbelief condemned and forbidden as a (in. For that in which the heart has no concern, and which does not imply any exercife of dif pofition or will, is neither virtue nor vice, fin nor holi- nefs : It has no moral good or evil in it ; and cannot be the fubjecl; of command or prohibition, of blame or com mendation. But whatfoever implies exercife of the heart, and depends upon the difpofition of that, and in any meafure confifls in this, is morally right, or wrong, holi- nefs or fin, and mud be commanded or forbidden. As therefore faving faith implies the whole of chriflian obe dience and holinefs, it mud be confidered not only as a duty, but as comprifing the whole of it : And unbelief mud imply the contrary, and therefore be wholly criminal. Agreeable to this, we find men are comrnanded in fcripture to believe on Jefus Chrifl ; and this faith is every where reprefented as a duty. It is needlefs to mention all the particular paffages of fcripture which prove this, to the attentive reader of the Bible ; the fol lowing are fufficicnt to eftablifh this point. cc Jefus came into Galilee, preaching the gofpel of the kingdom of God, and faying, " Repent ye, and believe thegofpd."* "Jefus anfwered and laid unto them, this is the work of God, that ye believe on him "whom he hathfent."^ " Ye believe in God, believe alfo in we."J " And this is his command ment, that ye fhould believe on the name of his Son Jefus Chritt." On * Mark i, 14, 15. f John vi, 29. J John xiv. i. i Johiyiii. 23. CHAP. IV. Concerning Saving Faith. 49 On the contrary, unbelief is confidered as a great fin* Our Saviour blames and condemns the Jews for not be- lieving on him, and afcribes it to the corrupt and wicked! difpolition of their hearts. Anrl unbelief is a (bribed wholly to an evil heart, and forbidden in the epiftie to? the Hebrews. " Take heed, brethren, left there be irt any of you an evil heart of unbelief, in departing Front the living God."* Oar divine teacher not only repre- fents unbelief as a fin of the fir ft magnitude, but as com- o * prehending all the (in of which men are guilty under the gofpel. on the contrary, if he Ihould be guilty of difobedience, all his children fhould join with him in his rebellion, as foon as theyexifled capable of moral agency, and have that in their hearts, which, at lead, would imply a full confent to his tranfgreflion, and in their hearts unite with him in it, and confequently fall under condemnation with hirru Thus, by one man fin entered into the world, and has fpread, and taken hold of all tta children of Adam ; and by (in they are involved in condemnation and the curfe.* The laft Adam, the Redeemer of men, has no fuch particular relation and union to all the human race, ei ther by nature,, or divine conftitution, as the firft Adam had. He has indeed become a man, and united himfelf to the human nature, and irLeanfequence of what he has done and fuffered, he has obtained a righteoufnefs as fufficient for the falvation of one as of another, of all as well as of one,, or of any part : He is able to fave to the uUermoft, all them who believe in him, and come to God by him.t And. confequently invites all to come unto him, and be faved ; and has ordered his^ gofpel to be preached to all nations, to every fon and daughter ofJ Adam. But there is no provifion or fecurity in any di vine confutation, or the convenant of redemption be tween the Father and the Mediator,, that all fhall believe on him and unite themfelves to him, by a cordial appro bation of his character and righteoufnefs ; fo as to render it fit and proper that they fliould be juflified and. faved by him. But in this confutation, or covenant between the Father and the Son, only a certain number,- a part o mankind, are given to the Redeemer,, and the voluntary union of thefe to him by faith, by which the church, the body, of which he is the conflituted head, fhall be formed, is * Rom. v. i2 ; 19.. f Heb. vii. 25. 64 On tie Sinner's Jujiificaiion PART II, is fecured and made certain. This is declared by Chrifi iu the mofl exprefs, unequivocal words, " Ail that the Father giveth me, (hall come to me, and him that cometh to me, I will in no wife caft out And this is the Father's will who hath fent rne, that of all which he hath given me, I fhould lofe' nothing, but mould raife it up again at the laft day. Father, I will that they alfo whom thou haft given me, be with me, where I am, that they may behold my glory, which thou haft given me."* That Chrift means by thofe who were given to him, not only his prefent difciples, but all that mould be final ly faved by him ; and that thefe are not all mankind, but a part, who are taken out of the reft of tbe ivorid, and to be united to him, and made one with him, as others are not, is evident from the following words of his. " I pray not for the world, but for them which thou haft given me, for they are thm'e 1 And all mine are thine, and thine are mine. Neither pray I for thofe alone (my prefent difciples, whom I have been particularly mention ing) but for them alfo which (hall believe on me, through their word : That they all may be one ; as thou, Father, art in me, and I in thee, that they may be one in us."f To the firft Adam, all the human race were given, to be juftified or ruined by him, in the manner explained above. To the laft Adam, only a part of mankind are given, to be redeemed and faved by him ; and their aclual and everlafting union with him is made fure, with out which union they could not be juftified and faved by him. They (hall come unto him, and fhali never be caft out, or feparated from him. Thefe who are given to Chrift, the elect, are his feed. " When thou (halt make his foul an offering for fin, he JJiallfec his feed, and fhall prolong his days, and the plea- fure of the Lord {hall pro (per in his hands. A feed fhali ferve * John vi. 37, 39. xvii. 24. f Joha xvii. 9, 10, 10, 21. CHAP. IV. ly Faith in Chrift. 65 ferve him, it (hall be accounted to the Lord for a genera tion,"* They are his adopted children. "Behold, I, and the children which God hath given me. According as he hath chofen us in him, before the foundation of the world, that we fhould be holy, and without blame before him in love ; having predeftinated us unto the adoption of children, by Jefus Chrift, to himfelf, according to the good pleafure of his will."t All mankind were the firft Adam's feed, his children. The elecl: only, who were chofen and given to Chrift; before the foundation of the world, are his feed, his children. V. Si N M E RS are thus united to Chrift by faith, or be lieving in him. It has been fhewn, in the preceding fe&ion, that faving faith con fills in a cordial approbation of Chrift, and re ceiving him in the character he fuftains, as the Redeemer of finners, by which the finner unites himfelf to Chrift, and becomes one heart, and one foul with him. It is by this faith, according to fcripture, that the heart is fo united to Chrift, that he dwells in the heart; and by faith they come into the relation of children of God, and put on Chrift. " Ye are the children of God, by Jaith * Pfalms xxii. 30. Ifaia.h liii. 10. -f- Eph. i. 4, 5. Heb. ii. 13. J From this fcriptural view of the matter, we fee how contrary to the fcripture, how unreafonable, as well as whimfical their notion is, who ad vance, that Chrift is originally fo united to all mankind, that he and they are fo one, that whatever one is and does, the other is and does alfo : ir> hat the (ins of men are the fins of Chrift, and mankind did and differed what WAS done and differed by Chrift. This they imagine is implied in the reprefentation ot'the union of Chrift with his people; by the union of the head and members, ef the human body ; of the hufband and xvife j the vine and the branches, &c. And that, on this fuppofition only,, there can be any jufticeor propriety, in the fuffering of Chrift for the fins of men, or in the juftification or falvation of men by the righteoufnefs of Chrift. And they henc<; infer, as a certain confequence, that all mankind ftull be faved. This confequence is contrary to numerous cxprefs dec larations in divine revelation, and is built on a prccar;3us fa::dy founda tion indeed. See Kelly's Doftrine of Union. VOL. II. F 66 On the Sinner's Jujlification PART II. faith in Chrift Jefus : For as many of you as have been baptized into Chrift, have put on Chrift. That Chrift may dwell in your hearts by faith."* " As many as re ceived him, to them gave he power to become the Tons of God, even to them who believe on his name."f ~" He that hath the Son, hath life."! Faith f unites the believer to Chrift, that it is fit and proper that he ihould be confidered and treated as fo far one with him, as to pardon and juftify him for the fake of Chrift, out of re- fpect to his fufFerings and obedience, by which he has merited fuch favour for all his ; for all who are thus united to him. Therefore, it is abundantly declared in fcripture, that men are juftified by faith, or through faith : that faith is counted for righteoufnefs, and imputed to the believer for righteoufnefs ; and the righteoufnefs by which they are juftified, is called, " The righteoufnefs of faith," not becaufe there is any righteoufnefs in faith J;o juftify the (inner, or do any thing towards it ; but becaufe faith receives the righteoufnefs of Chrift, and fo unites the be liever to the Redeemer, that by divine conftitution and promife, the righteoufnefs of Chrift is reckoned in his fa vour, and avails for his juftification. Faith is not con nected with justification, becaufe of any moral excellency or worthinefs, which is, or can be fuppofed to be in it ; for the believing finner cannot have any fuch worthinefs in himfelf, or in any of his exercifes, as in the leaft de gree to recommend him to favour on that account, which is to be more particularly confidered before this feftion is concluded; but men are juftified by faith, becaufe it is connected with the righteoufnefs of Chrift, and the believer is fo united to him that it is proper and fit that his righteoufnefs fliould be improved in the fin- - tter's favour, and he be juftified on that accdunt. There fore, *Gal. iii. 26, 27. Eph. iii. 17, f John i. 12, j'l John v. 12. CHAP. IV. ty Faith in Chrift. 67 fore, juflification by faith, is always oppofed to juflifica- tion by works; the works of the law, efpecially, in the writings of the Apoflle Paul, as has been particularly ob- ferved in the foregoing fe&ion, and the reafon of it given. It will be fufficient to mention the following paffages of his, omitting a great number of others to the fame pur- pofe. " But now the righteoufnefs of God, without the ]aw is manifefted, being witnefled by the law and the Prophets ; even the righteoufnefs of God, which is by faith of Jefus Chrift, unto all, and upon all them that believe. Therefore, we conclude that a man is juftified by faith, without the deeds of the law."* Knowing that a man is not juftified by the works of the law, but by the faith of Jefus Chrift ; even we have believed in Jefus Chrift, that we might be juftified by the faith of Chrift, and not by the works of the law : For by the works of the law (hall no flefh be juftified.t " That I may be found in him, not having mine own righteoufnefs, which is of the law, but that which is through the faith of Chrift, the righteoufnefs which is of God, through faith. +" SOME * Rom. iii. 22, 28. "f Gal. ii. 16. $ Phil. iii. 9. Some have fuppofed that by the fahh of Chrifl, men tioned feveral rimes in the paflages quoted, and in one or two other places, is meant Cbrijl's Jaith^ which intends the whole of the righteoufnefs of Chrift. But there does not appear any reafon for fuch a construction. This is, at beft, a very obfcureand unufual way to exprefs the obedience and righteoufnefs of Chrift. This the Apoflle often mentions, and con- ftantly holds up to view in his writings, in clear and intelligible expref- fions ; fuch as, his righteoufnefs ; his dying for finners, and giving himfelf for them ; the atonement ; his obedience ; obedience unto death, &e. And fince he always means the faith of the believer, when he fays men are juftified by faith, except in thefe few places, it feems to be doing violence to thofe, to understand them in a quite different fenfe ; efpecially, fince the exprefilon, though a little varied, may moft naturally be understood to mean faith in Chrift, or the faith by which men believe in him, and of which he is the objecl: ; and more eipecially, fince this phrafe muft be underftood fo, in a number of other places. The following are inftance.*. f it. Markxi, 32. "Have faithin God." "Evtff trtgw is Have faith F 2 f 68 On the Sinner's Jiijtification PART II. SOME have fuppofed that it was neceflfary to exclude all moral goodnefs, and confequently all exercife of heart, from the faith by which men are juftified, in order to their being juflified by free grace, inoppofition tojufti- fication by works ; and have thought, that if there be any moral goodnefs in juftifying faith, efpecially all that moral goodnefs which is comprized in gofpel holinefs, as has been reprefented in the preceding fe&ion ; they have a righteoufnefs of their own, which will recommend them to favour ; and therefore do not ftand in need, or, at molt, in fo much need of the righteoufnefs of Chrift, and of free grace, as if they had no moral goodnefs ; but have forne ground of boafting ; and that this therefore, tends to flatter the pride of man : Whereas the fcripture fays, that the way of juftification by faith excludes all boafting ; and that the ungodly who have no works, are jufliiied by faith. What has been already faid in the preceding feclion, and in this, it is thought, is fufficient to fhow, that fuch an opinion is wholly without foundation, and contrary to the truth. But as this is a point of no fmall importance, it is propofed to attend to it more particularly, by bring ing into view, and applying fome things which have been before obferved ; and introducing fome other confidera- tions, which may ferve to remove mi (lakes, and elucidate and confirm the truth on this head. To this end the following things may be obferved. i. It is impoffible, according tothereafon and nature of things, and the law of Gocl, which is founded on this, that he who has once finned, fhould, by any moral quali fication, cfGsd. As 3. i6. " Through faith in his name." In the original it is, Through the faith of his name. Rom. 3. 26. " The jultifier of him that believetli in Jefus." in the original it is, TGV tv. ZJif? 'Iff&^ H ' IY1 who is of the faith of Jefus. Jam. ii. i. " My brethren, have not the fuith of our Lord Jefus Cfrtf, with refpecl ot perfons." Rev. xiv. 12. * Here are they that keep the commandments of God, and tbefa'ab CHAP. IV. ly Faith in Chrift. 69 fication, or holinefs, render himfclf acceptable to God, or fo as to be looked upon, or treated any otherwife, than an accurfed, infinitely odious creature. The reafon. of this has been given : It is becaufe the law of God, which is mod reafonable, juft and good, does cuffe the tranfgreflbr ; let his character be otherwife what it may, either before or after his fin, this cannot, in the lead de gree, remove the curfe. " For it is written, Curfed is every one that continueth not in all things, written in the book of the law, to do them." As this is the law of God, and perfectly agreeable to unalterable reafon and truth, he will look upon the finner in the light in which the law fets him, and treat him accordingly j and therefore will not pardon him, out of refpecl: to any thing he does, or can do, as recommending him, in the lead degree, to any favour. All moral qualifications of his, however great and good, mud (land for jud nothing, and be of no avail to recommend the finner to pardon, &c. Whea- ever fuch an one is judified, it mud be altogether on the account of the atonement and worthinefs of Chrid, who was made under the law ; and fo made a curfe, that he might deliver the believer in him from the cuife. And whatever moral goodnefs there is in faith, he is not judi- fied on this account, any more than if there were no moral goodnefs in it. The believer obtains judification by his faith, not out of refpect to any moral goodnefs in it, how much foever it may contain ; but, becaufe by it he is united to Chrid, fo as that it is proper he fliould have an intered in his righteoufnefs, and be judified out of refpecl: to that, and confident with the law of God. " For Chrid is the end of the law for righteoufnefs, to everyone that believeth." It is indeed impofiible that he who has once finned, if he have any degree of virtue and true love to God, in the exercife of that, to feek or define to recommend him- F 3 felf a 70 On the Sinner's Justification PART II. felf to God by it, fo as to obtain pardon and his favour, merely out of refpeft to that ; for this would be to oppofe God, and all goodnefs ; to rife in rebellion againft his law, and holy government ; and therefore, contrary to love to God, and all true virtue, or moral goodnefs. The reafon of this has been given, viz. That it is con trary to the law of God, which curfes the (inner, that he fhould be confidered and treated any otherwife than as being accurfed. out of regard to any thing he has, or can do, and while he is not united to Chrift, fo as to have the benefit to his righteoufnefs, by receiving juftification purely out of refpecl: to that. Hence it is certain, that if a man feek righteoufnefs and juftification by the works of the law, or by any fuppofed virtue or goodnefs of his own, he does in that, at as an enemy to God, and to his law ; and his fuppofed moral goodnefs, is nothing but fin and rebellion. But if it were not fo, and he were really and perfectly holy, this could not recommend him to pardon ; and would be no reafon why he mould be pardoned, and delivered from the curfe of the law, rather than another, who is wholly deftitute of all moral goodnefs. The reafon of this has been given. There fore, whenever he who has finned, is brought to love God, and exercife any degree of moral goodnefs, he will not defire to be juflified by it, and will be fo far from offering it as a righteoufnefs to recommend him to fa vour, that he will approve of the law of God which curfes him, and condemns himfelf, as that does, as infi nitely guilty and illdeferving ; and confequently places all his hope of pardon in the atonement of Chrift ; and with Paul, not defire to be found in his own righteouf nefs, which is of the law ; but that which is through the faith of Chrift, the righteoufnefs which is of God, by faith. But of this, more hereafter. 2. Though CHAP. IV. h Faith in Chrrjl. 71 2. Though a firmer, upon his becoming perfectly obedient, after he had finned, might be juftifled by his own'righteoufnefs, which has been proved to beimpoffi- ble ; yet man is cut off from a-11 hope of acceptance in this way, becaufe every believer is, in this life, very im perfect, and finful. In every act of his, there is much fin ; fin enough to condemn him, had he never finned before. He has a great degree of oppofition in his heart to- God, and his law ; and all his exercifes, in which there is a degree of moral goodnefs, are fo defective, that 'he has reafon to be afhamed of himfelf, and of them ; for every degree of defect is iinful. He does not love God half fo much as he ought, and his heart is exceeding cor rupt and abominable, viewed in all the exercifes and defects of it. On this account the believer is unworthy of any favour, his goodnefs is infinitely far from rendering him worthy of the lead favour ; and every act of his is attend ed with fin enough to condemn him forever, if viewed and treated as he is in himfelf, and according to his prefenL character. In this view the Pfalmiit fays, " If thou, Lord, fhouldeft mark iniquities, O Loni, who (hall (land ! Enter not into judgment with thy fervant : For in thy fight, iliall no man living be juftifiecl."* And Job fays, c< I have heard of thee by the hearing of the ear : But now mine eye feeth thee : Wherefore I abhor myfelf, and repent in dufl and afhes."t When it is confidered, how much fin attends the be liever in all his exercifes ; how far he falls below his duty in every thing ; how much moral evil is conftantly in his heart ; and how greatly every thing wrong and de fective in him is aggravated, and more criminal than i: was before he believed, by the greater light and convic tion he now has, and the great, peculiar and diflinguifh- ing favours he has received from God ; and the advan- F 4 tages * PUlms cxxx, 3, cxliii. 2. } Job xlii. 5, 6. 72 On the Sinner's, purification PART II. tages and motives he now has to be holy as God is holy, by which his obligations are unfpeakably increafed : When all this is confidered ; there will doubtlefs appear reafon to conclude that he is now more criminal in the fight of God, and in this fenfe a greater finner, and more hateful and abominable, than he was before he believed, or than any unbeliever whatfoever, notwithftanding his faith, virtue, and holinefs. Surely then he has nothing in himfelf fuited to flatter and raife his pride, by becom ing a believer, and uniting himfelf to Chrifh ; but every thing is fuited to lead him to humble himfelf in the fight of the Lord, and walk humbly with God, and conftantly cry, " God be merciful to me a (inner/* This leads to another particular. 3. AH the virtue or holinefs ; all the right tafte and exercifes which are implied in faving faith, as defcribed in the foregoing fe&ion, as was there obferved, imply and confift chiefly in difclaiming and renouncing all pre tences to any worthinefs that the believer has, or can poflibly be in man, that fhould recommend him to any favour, and in coming to Chrifl, as in himfelf, infinitely, gurlty and illdeferving, and trufting in his atonement and merit for jullification. How then can this poflibly lead men to trull in themfelves that they are righteous, or flatter and encourage their pride ? It is the only thing that deflroys fuch a fpirit, and tends to pluck it up by the roots, and by which a believer humbles himfelf in the light of the Lord, and walks humbly before him all his days. The more of this faith he has, the farther he is from pride, and the more humble. And he who has not this faith, and does not live by it, his foul is lifted up in pride, and is not upright in him.* Faith, which worketh by love, difcerns the excellence of the divine character and law, and the infinite evil of fin | approves of the former and condemns the latter. In Hab. ii. CHAP. IV. h Faith in Cfirijt. 73 In the exercife of this faith the law comes, fin revives, and the (inner dies; feels himfelf undone and loll for ever, notwithftanding any help or righteoufnefs in him felf, if treated according to the righteous law of God. By this faith the fmner flies to the Redeemer for righ teoufnefs, juftification and redemption, as a free gift to an infinitely unworthy creature, who has no righteoufnefs of his own to recommend him to the lead favour, and never can have any. And the more the finner has of this faith, which implies love and repentance, and the longer he lives by it, the more he fees and feels the evil nature and ill defert of fin, and a view and fenfe of his own finfulnefs increafes; and ihe more he prizes and trufls in Chrift for pardon, righteoufnefs, fanclification, and redemption . And if he be not really a greater crim inal than he was before, he now fees much more of his fin and guilt, and a view and fenfe of this increafes, as he grows in faith and grace. Thus all boafling is mo ft effectually excluded by the law of faith, as faith itfelf difcards and oppofes all that which could be the ground of boaRing. Hence is appears, that they who exclude repentance and love from faith, take an effe&ual way to fupport boafting and the pride of man : For that uth in which there is no repentance, does not oppofe the pride of the human heart, but leaves man as proud as before, and with the fame difpofition to exalt himfelf, and truft in himfelf that he is righteous. No one who has net a heart, that is truly penitent, ana friendly to God, will humble himfelf before God, and be willing to be wholly indebted to free, fovereign grace for juftification and redemption.* 4 . if * " There is that in the nature of repentance, winch peculiarly tends to efrablifh tin? contrary of juftification by works, for nothing fo much renounces our own worthinefsand excellency, as repentance. The very pature of it is to acknowledge our own utter finfulnefs and unwoithi-nefs, and 74 On the Sinner's Jujlification PART II. 4. If faith did not imply a right tafte and difpofition, and true love to Chrift, it would not in any manner or degree, unite the finner to Chrift fo as to render it fit and proper that his righteou fuels fhould be reckoned in his favour, or L>e any reafon why fuch a believer fhould be juftified, rather than another, who does not believe. It has been (hewn, that in the fcripture the believer is faid to be in a particular relation to Chrift, to be in Chrift, and to put him on ; to be united to him as the wife is to the hufband, and the members of the body to the head ; and that this union is by faith. This gives him an intereft in Chrift, as, on account of this union, he may with reafon and propriety be confidered and treated as belonging to Chrift, fo as to have the benefit of his worthinefs and righteoufnefs, for his juftification ; and in this fenfe he is jollified by faith. That faith therefore, which does not unite to Chrift, cannot be juftifying, faving faith. No faith can do this but that which implies love, for in this all true moral union confifts. That faith which is confiftent with the finner's being at heart an enemy to Chrift, does in no true fenfe unite to him, but is confift ent with the greateft, with total alienation from him, and opposition to him. Therefore, there is no more reafon or fitnefs that the man who has fuch a faith mould be jafti-fied by the righteoufnefs of Chrift, than he who has it not, but is in every fenfe an unbeliever. It muft be ftill kept in mind, that faith does not bring into a juilified ftate, becaufe it is a good work, or out of refpeft to the moral goodnefs there is in it ; but becaufe of the natural fitnefs there is, that he whofe heart is u- nited to Chrift, as it is by believing, mould be recom mended to favour, and juftified by his worthinefs and righteoufnefs, and to renounce our own goodnefs, and all confidence in felf ; and to trufl in the propitiation of the Mediator, and afcribe all the glory of for- givenefs to him." Prefident Edwards's Difcourfe on Juftification by Faith alone, p. 114. CHAP. IV. ly Faith in Chrijl. 75 righteoufhefs, to whom he is thus united, and in whom he trufts. The believing finner is confidered, when viewed in and by himfelf, as deflituteof any thing to re commend him to favour, and as unworthy and illdeferv- ing, as if he had no faith, and no kind or degree of moral goodnefs : And mufl be viewed fo, according to the reafon of things, and the law of God ; fo that when he is juflified, he is juflified, as being ungodly, becaufe he real ly is fo ; that is, has no moral goodnefs, to recommend him, as the reafon why he mould be juftified, rather than another, who has no moral goodnefs. In this refpect all are alike, and upon equal grounds. This leads us to the true fenfe of the following words of the Apoftle Paul, " To him that -worketh not, but believeth on him that juftifieth the ungodly > his faith is counted for righ- teoufnefs."* . By him that -. worketh not, is evidently meant one who does not attempt to work, in order to recommend him felf to the favour of God by his moral goodnefs; is not of thofe who are of the works of the law, and confequent- ly under the curfe of it, notwithstanding any thing they can do ; but renounces all pretence and defire to be juf tified in this way, by his works ; but dire&ly contrary to this, beiieveth on him, and receives from him, as a free, undeferved favour, juftification, who gives it to all fuch, though they have no righteoufnefs or works to re commend them ; but are in this refpecl: ungodly. This is evidently the Apoftle's meaning; for he puts not working, and believing, in oppofition to working in or der to recommend themfelves and render themfelves worthy of a reward, fo as, in this fenfe, to bring God in to debt to them. This appears by the foregoing words, with which thofe are connefted. " Now to him that worketh y is the reward not reckoned of grace, but of debt. But to him that worketh not, but believeth on him that Romans ir. 5, 76 On the Sinner's Juftification PART II. that juftifieth the ungodly, &c." By working he means the deeds, the works of the law, of which he fpeaks, and fets them in oppofition to faith, as he does here. What is meant by working to merit a reward, has been often explained in the preceding fe&ion, and in this. Faith i3 oppofed to this, and looks to Chrift, and receives juftifi- cation, pardon and righteoufnefs, as a free, undeferved gift to the ungodly, that is, to one who has no good works, no worthinefs to recommend him to the lead favour, but is infinitely unworthy, guilty and illdeferving. All this is confident with faith, implying and confining in all that moral goodnefs, gofpel holinefs, and obedience, which, according to fcripture it does, as has been (hewn in the fe&ion on faving faith. 5. If moral goodnefs in juflifying faith, would recom mend the believer to favour, on account of the worth in it, and render a (inner more worthy and deferving, or lefs unworthy and illdeferving in the fight of God, and therefore is inconfiftent with juflification* by free grace ; and consequently all moral goodnefs mufl be excluded from it; then it is equally neceffary that the believer Ihould never have any moral goodnefs, in order to his being faved by grace. They who would exclude all moral goodnefs from faith, and fuppofe, if it involves re pentance, and love, and is really a holy exercife, this moral goodnefs, would render the finner more deferving, or lefs illdeferving; and fo would be inconfiftent with his being juflified wholly by the righteoufnefs of Chrift, and faved by free grace ; do fuppofe, at the fame time, that gofpei holinefs and obedience is fome how connect ed with faving faith, and does take place, fooner or later, in the heart of every believer. But if moral goodnefs in thofe who have finned, in itfelf confidered, recom mend to favour, and render them worthy of it ; then when they attain to this they will have no more need of the CHAP. IV. ly Faith in Chrift. 77 the righteoufnefs of Chrift, nor of free grace ; but may and muft truft in their own righteoufnefs. And when they come to be perfectly holy, they may juftly confider themfelves as worthy of eternal life, and claim it as a debt, and not receive it as a free gift. Do not they who care fully exclude all moral goodnefs from faving faith, for the reafon above mentioned, appear inconfiftent with themfelves, in this refpedl: ? It is not yet feen how thofe things can be reconciled. But if what has been proved concerning the law of God, and the true (late of the finner, viz. that no poflible degree of holinefs and obedience, continued any length of time by the (inner, can atone for one fin ; but if he once tranfgrefs the law, he falls under the curfe of it, from which no moral goodnefs afterwards attained can deliver him, but he will forever deferve to be the fubjecl: of the difpleafure of God, and condemned to eternal mifery : If this be kept in view it will appear, that what ever moral goodnefs he attains, it does not render him the lefs unworthy ; and if he be pardoned and faved, it muft be as much through the righteoufnefs of Chrift, and as really a free gift to him, and he as much the fub jecl; of free grace, as if he had no moral good ; and the believer muft receive all favours, and continue in a jufti- fied ftate, through life, however obedient he be; and forever, though perfectly holy, out of refpecl: to the righteoufnefs of Chrift, and as a gift of free grace, as much as if he received juftification at firft. And there does not appear any inconfiftence or difficulty in the matter, when viewed in this fcripture light. The redeemed, when perfectly holy in heaven, will, confidered in and by themfelves, be as deferving of the divine difpleafure and everlafting punifhment, as they ever were, and will be fo forever. They continue in a juftified ftate, and in the enjoyment of the favour of God, by 78 On the Sinner's Jujlification PART II. by continuing united to Chrift ; and were it poffible that this union between the Redeemer and them fhouid ceafe, they would, they mu ft fall under condemnation, and fink into hell. It is true, that the obedience and holinefs of believers is acceptable to God, and may be rewarded, as a teftimony of this, in confequence of their union to Chrift, and out of refpecl: to his atonement and worthi- nefs, becaufe they are united to him, and love him, who is fo infinitely worthy in the fight of God. Their perfons and their obedience, and offerings to God, are pleafing and acceptable to him for the fake of Chrift, and becaufe they belong to him, and are in him, and do all in his name. This is the account the fcripture gives of the mat ter. cc To the praife of the glory of his grace, wherein he hath made us accepted in the beloved."* " And what- foever ye do in word or deed, do all in the name of the Lord Jefus Chrift, giving thanks to God and the Father by him."t " To whom coming, as unto a living ftone, difallowed indeed of men, but chofen of God and pre cious ; ye alfo, as lively ftones, are built up a fpiritual houfe, an holy priefthood, to offer up fpiritual facrifices, acceptable to G*od y by Jefus Chrift.'"^ " Now the God of peace make you perfect in every good work, to do his will, working in you that which is well pleafing in his Jight, through Jefus Chrifl."^ The reafon of this is, that by the atonement which Chrift has made for fin, and out of refpecl: to that, their fins are all forgiven ; they are blotted out, fo as not to be remembered againft them. In this refpeft, their guilt is cancelled and done away, which otherwife would counterbalance, fw allow up, and deftroy, all their moral goodnefs. In this fenfe, God is reconciled to them in Chrift, not imputing their trefpaffes unto them. |] And by reafon of their relation to Chrift, their moral goodnefs, in the exercife of which they cleave to * Eph. i. 6. f Col. iii. 17. J i Peter ii. 4> 5- Heh. xiii. 2*-, |j z Cor. v. 1. CHAP. IV. On the Sinner's Juftifaalion 79 to Chrift, and love and honour him, is more acceptable, precious and worthy in the fight of God, than it could be in any creature not fo united to the infinitely worthy Redeemer. Their relation to him gives them a dignity and worthinefs, which they have not in themfelves, con- fidered as feparate from Chrift, and renders all their ho- linefs more acceptable and rewardable than otherwife it could be. This is expreffed by Chrift in the following words. " He that loveth me, lhall be loved of my Father. The Father himfelf loveth you, becaufe ye have loved me> and have believed that I came out from God."* But farther to explain the doctrine of juftification by faith in Chrift, now under confideration, it muft be obferved, VI. MEN are brought into a juftified ftate by one, the firft aft of faving faith. The promife of falvation is made to him who believeth. " He that believeth, (hall be faved ; he hath eternal life, and (hall never come into condemnation." He therefore who believes, and exer- cifes one aft of true faith, however imperfeft and weak, comes within the reach of this promife, is juftified^nd ihall be faved. The reafon of it is, becaufe the fir ft aft of faith as really unites the finner to Chrift, as many, or a courfe of aft s, do ; and therefore is fufficient to render it fit and fui table that he (hould have an intereft in his merit and righteoufnefs. It is true indeed, that in order to a perfon's continuing in a juftified ftate, he muft continue united to Chrift, and therefore muft perfevere in his faith, in which tfee union, on his part confifts, and by which it is maintained : And in this refpeft the faith by which a man is juftified, and obtains the promifes of life, is a per 'fevering faith. Though a man is pardoned and has a promife of eternal life, * John xiv. 21. xvi. 27 See Prdident Edwards, on Juftification by Faith alone, p. 92, 93, 8t> ly Faith in Chrift. PART If, life, upon the firft a6l of faith ; yet this firft al is not regarded by God, in his juftifying him, as the only aft ; but it is viewed as conne&ed with a continued feries of the a&s of the fame faith to the end : And the firft a6fc intitles to life, as the firft, or beginning of a continued courfe of exercifes of the fame kind, or as a perfever- ing faith. The firft aft of faith, intitles to perfeverance in faith, by virtue of a divine conftitution and promife. God has promifed that he who once believes, {hall continue to believe, fo that his faith ftiali not fail : That they fhall be " kept by the power of God, through faith unto fal vation."* If this were not the cafe, it would not be fit or congruous, that he who once believes, fhould have the promife of falvation ; and juftification to eternal life would be fufpended until the believer had perfevered in faith. In the firft acl of faving faith, the believer does vir tually and implicitly, if not exprefsly, look to Chrift and truft in him for perfeverance, together with other blefs- ings ; and fo it gives a title to this benefit, among others. In' this view, perfeverance in faith is implied in the firft aft, and asfuch, it is juftifying faith, and has the prom ife of falvation. The fcripture fets this point in the fame light. "Now the juft fhall live by faith : But if any man draw back, my foul fhall have no pleafure in him. But \ve are not of them who draw back unto perdition ; but of them that believe to the faving of the foul/'t Here, faving faith is reprefentedas perfevering faith; and perfeverance, as being that in faith, by which it becomes faving; for believing to the faving of the foul, is put in oppofition to drawing back unto perdition ; and there fore muft mean a perfevering faith. In this view it may be feen why believers are daily to pray for the forgivcnefs of the fins, which they commit after * i Peter i. 5. f I-Leb. x, 38, 39. CHAP. IV. by faith in Chrifi. 81 after they are in a juftified (late ; and why God is repre- fented as aclually forgiving them ; and that this forgive- nefs is fufpended upon their renewed a&s" of repentance and faith. The believer, upon his firft believing, has the forgivenefs of all his pad fins, and the promife that all his future fins fhall be forgiven ; fo that he fhali never corne into condemnation, but is pafled from death to life : But this juftification is, the whole of it, in fome fenfe, conditional ; it is granted upon the fuppofition that he will perfevere in a courfe of repeated ads of faith, and that his prefent union to Chrift will never ceafe, but be an everlafting union : If this fliould ceafe to exift, and this were poflible, all his pa ft fins, would be remem bered againft him, and he fall into condemnation, and under the curfe of the law ; nor could any of his fins, which he fhould commit in future, be forgiven. He has the promife of the forgivenefs of all the fins which he fhall commit, upon condition he does perfevere in re pentance and faith ; therefore upon his renewed finning, he renews ads of repentance and faith, and in the exer- cife of thefe, arks for pardon, and upon this he is actually forgiven, and not before, agreeable to the divine promife. But as his perfeverance in faith is made fure by the pro mife of God, in the covenant of grace, pardon of all his fins and eternal life, are made fure to him, upon his firft aft of faith, and his juftification. VII. IN the juflification of the believer by the righ- fceoufnefs of Chrift, it does not become his righteoulnefs, fo as that he is confidered as having actually done arid fufFered, in his own perfon,what Chrift did and fuffered ; for this is in no fenfe true, and cannot be made true. But he being in Chrift, united to him by faith, the righ- teoufnefs of Chrift, what he has done and fuffered for finners, and in their place and ftead, avails for the belie v- VOL. II. G er's 82 On the Sinner's Jujllficalion PART IL er's juftification, and he has as much advantage by it, in this refpecl, as if it were his own perfonal righteoufnefs. It would be needlefs to mention this particular, if fome had not entertained this notion of the imputation of the righteoufnefsof Chrift, andreprefented it in this very ab- furd light ; and drawn confequences from it, mod con trary to the truth, and many exprefs declarations of fcripture. VIII. IN pardoning and juRifying the believer, his fins are not fo blotted out, or covered, as not to be any more feen or remembered. When fins are once com mitted, they never can become no fins ; it will be for ever true, that they were committed. Thefe fatls, or the nature of them, cannot be annihilated or altered. And it is impoffible that they fhould be forgotten by God, or out of his fight, while he exifls the OMN i SCLENT. And the believer's knowledge that he is juftified, has no tendency to make him forget his fins ; but the contrary, viz, to fix them on his memory, to think much of them, confefs them, and humble bimfelf for them, and admire the grace of God in his forgivenefs, for the fake of Chrift. If he could forget his fins, he would forget that he was pardoned ; for the latter fuppofes the former, and is fourrded upon it. Paul, remembered and repeatedly mentioned his fins, and ranks himfelf among the chief of finners, after he knew he was pardoned, and had ob tained mercy. And if he could lofe the idea of his fin and guilt, he would have no idea of the mercy of God to him, as long as he cxifts. His fin, in perfecuting the faints, and the fins of other juflified perfons, on fcripture record, are fo far from being forgotten, covered or hid, that they are publifhed to the world, and will be eternally known and remembered. The fcripture fpeaks of for giving fin, by fuch phrafes as thefe, Not remembering them CHAP. IV. ty Faith in Chrift. 83 ihem any more -covering them calling them into the depths of the fea^ &c. Thefe are flrong metaphorical ex- preflions, to denote that God does not, and never will fuffer them to rife and be brought againfl the believer, to condemn him, or do him any hurt. In this fenfe they are annihilated,- blotted out, and never fhall be re membered any more. That thefe expreffions cannot be underflood in any other fenfe, or be literally true, ap pears from the obfervations which have been made un der this head. IX. THE juftification of the believer by the righteouf- nefs of Chrift, does in no meafure free him from obli gation to be perfectly holy in his own perfon ; but in- creafes it, and his criminality in not being fo.. He is freed from the curfe of the law, for not being prefectly and perfeveringly holy, and from obligation to perfect obedience, in order to be jufliried ; for he is already juftified, without this. In this refpect, he is not under the law, but under grace. But flili he is under obliga tion to love God with all his heart, and his neighbour as himfelf. His faith is a conformity to thefe commands, as including repentance and love, and he cannot be per fectly holy, to which he is under indifpenfible obligation, till he comes to a perfect conformity to this law : For by this only, he can be holy, as God is holy. It is im- poflible he fhould not be under obligation to obey this law perfectly ; for it is founded in reafon, and cannot be altered or abated ; and mud therefore, forever be the rule of the duty of creatures ; and every thing in them which is contrary to this law, or a difregard of it, is fin. Chrift did not come to deftroy, or make void the law, in this refpect ; but to fulfil it : And his fulfiling or obeying it, and fuffering the penalty of it, does not releafe the believer from obligation to obe- G 2 dience 84 On the Sinner's Juftification PART II. dience to it ; for this is impoflible, becaufc it would be infinitely wrong. Yet fome have been fo wild in their notions, and fo abfurd and infatuated, as to fuppofe he has done it ! Jt has been obferved, that gofpel holinefs, or the holi- nefs of faith, differs from legal holinefs, or the holinefs of man before he fell into fin, and that of the angels ; and- the difference has been particularly flated in the forego ing fe&ion. Neverthelefs the holinefs neceffary to jufti- fication by law, or the covenant of works, and that of the believer under the covenant of grace, are of the fame nature and kind, and confift in obedience and conformity to the fame law, in love to God, and to our neighbour : Though the latter may require exercifes in fome refpels different, and towards new and different objects and truths, which could have no place or exiflence, under the former, fuch as finful man, Redemption, the character of Jefus Chrift, his fufferings and works, &c. And it is worthy of obfervation here, that the holinefs of faith, and of the redeemed, fo far as, for the reafon above mentioned, it differs from legal holinefs, or that under a covenant of works, has a peculiar beauty and excellence, and renders him who poffeffes it, more happy than he could be under a covenant of works, though perfectly holy. The redeemed are raifed from the dark regions of infinite guilt and wo ; delivered from fin, in which they were totally involved ; and tranflated from the power nnd kingdom of fatan, into the eternal kingdom of Chrift, to fit down and reign with him on his throne. And this deliverance, happinefs and honour, is not from them- ielves, in the lead degree; but from the free fovereign grace, and wonderful love of God ; and by the incarna tion of the Son of God, and his taking the place of fin- ners, and dying for their redemption. All this makes an CHAP. IV. fy Faith vn Chrift. 85 an amiable and glorious difplay of the love and wifdom of God, which could not have been made, had not re demption taken place. And all this new and wonderful fcene lays a foundation for anfwerable exercifes by the redeemed, in the deepeft humility, in a fenfe and acknow ledgment of their un worthiness, and abfolute dependence on free fovereign grace for all the good, both negative and poflitive, comprifed in redemption ; and in the fweet love of benevolence, delight and gratitude, anfwer able to the divine love and holinefs manifefted in the redemption of finners, and his unfpeakable love and grace to them,- by which they are laid under peculiarly great, and the mod agreeable, everlafling obligations to gratitude and praife. In thefe refpe&s, and by their everlafting, and pecu liarly near and dear relation to Chrift, and union with him, by which they are the bride, the Lamb's wife, the redeemed church will mine in a peculiarly beautiful ho linefs, and glory, and enjoy greater happinefs and honour, than any of thofe creatures who have not been redeemed, though perfectly holy. In this refpeft, as well as others, redemption is the new creation^ the new heaven and new f&rth, far exceeding the firft and old creation. In this there is a new difplay of the divine glory ; a new mode of the exercife of holinefs by a new kind of creatures, by putting on a form in which there is a new beauty and excellence ; and a new degree of happinefs ; a new and glorious character in the Redeemer, the center of union, love and holinefs, of the redeemed church ; and, in one word, a new moral world, which could not have taken place, were it not for the apoftacy of man, and redemp tion by Chrift. In this fenfe, " Old things are palled away, Behold, all things are become new !" G 3 X. ON 86" On the Shiner 9 s Jujlification PART II. X. O N the whole, the doftrine of the juftification of fin- ners by faith in Jefus Chrift, appears to be not only agreea ble to thefcripture^but rational, when examined and un- derflood ; there being nothing abfurd or inconfiflent in it. The law of God admits of a fubflitute to obey or to fuffer for others in their room and ftead. The firft man was conftituted fuch, and he was made a type and figure of the fecond man, who was to come, the Lord from hea ven. He was able to do what the firft man could not, even to redeem finners from the curfe of the lawj by tak ing the curfe on himfelf, and fuffering it for them, as well as obeying it perfe&ly ; being made under the law, and putting himfelf in their place. Thus he has a righteouf. nefs which anfwers the law j and therefore fufficient for the juftification of all thofe in whofe favour it can be properly applied, fo as confiftently to have the benefit of it, as much as if it were their own perfonal righteoufnefs. This can be done only by the finner's being cordially united to him, approving of his character, and receiving and trading in him for righteoufnefs, and redemption, which is done by believing in him. Therefore, " Chrift is the end of the law for righteoufnefs to every one that believe th. Even the righteoufnefs of God, which is by faith of Jefus Chrift,. unto all, and upon all them that believe. " And this righteoufnefs avails to their complete jnftification ; their fins are pardoned for the fake of Chrift, who is the propitiation for their fins ; he fuffering for them, the juftfor the unjuft, has made full atonement ; and they are made heirs of eternal life, be ing recommended by the merit and worthinefs of Chrift, they being in him, and one with him, as the members and head are one body. It is agreeable to reafon, and common fenfe, that one pterfon fhould have favour (hewn to him, out of re- fpe61 to> the merit and worthinefs of another, purely on the CHAP. IV. fy Faith in Chrifl. the account of the relation the former bears to the latter, who has no worthinefs of fuch favour in himfelf, and to whom it would be improper to (hew fuch favour, were it not for his relation to fuch a worthy perfon, by which he is in fome fenfe united to him* This is really imputing the merit of one perfon to another, to recommend him to favour, who has no worthinefs in himfelf. Thus, if we have a friend who is very dear to us, and has great merit arfd worthinefs with us> and we fee a child in wretched cir- cumflances, flarving and naked ; when we are informed that he is the fon of our friend, we fliall be difpofed to fhew him kindnefs and give him relief, feed and clothe him, for the fake of his father, out of regard to his merit in our eyes. Or, if fuch a worthy perfon, who has great merit, have a friend who loves him, though he may have no worthinefs in himfelf, and has offended us ; yet if he come recommended by this worthy friend of ourSj defir- ing that we would forgive him, and fhew him all the kindnefs he wants, we fhall readily do it, wholly for the fake of the worthinefs of our friend, though otherwife it would be proper, and we fhould be difpofed to treat him with neglect and contempt ; and this appears congruous and rational. Much more is it fo in the cafe before us. The Sort of God, who is infinitely dear and worthy in his fight> has exprefTed his love to the Father, and zeal for his honour, and the honour of his law and government, and hatred of all fin againft him^ by putting himfelf in the place of flnners under the law ; and has borne the curfe of it himfelf in the fmner's Read, and by obeying it per-* fedly, hereby manifefling his love to fmful man, and de- fire of their falvation, if confident with the honour of God, and his law ; and that he might make it fo, for all thofe who believe in him, has done and fuffered ail this, and in this way has exerted himfelf to the utmoft, that G 4 they 88 On the Sinner* s Jujlification PART II. they may be pardoned and faved, and God honoured thereby : That God may be juft, and thejuftifier of him that believeth in him. And in all this, in which he has exercifed and exprefTed his love of righteoufnefs, and hatred of iniquity, in the beft manner, and to the higheft degree poflible, he has merited infinitely with the Father ; he is well pleafed for his righteoufnefs fake, and is ready to give him whatever he afks - f efpecially that, for the fake of which, he has gone through all this labour and fuffering. He afics that he would pardon and fave every guilty (inner, who unites himfelf to him by believing on him, w.ho mall love, receive, and truft in liim, that his righteoufnefs may be imputed to him, and that for his fake he will juftify and fave all fuch, whom he loves, and for whom he has done and fuffered fo much.* The Father is fo well pleafed with his righteoufnefs, and he is fo infinitely dear, honourable and meritorious in his fight, that he is ready to fhew all needed favour to thofe who love his Son, and believe on him, for his fake, and purely out of refpecl to his fuffering and merit, to juftify them, and give them eternal life, though they be in themfelves infinitely unworthy and illdeferving. Thus the rigb- teoufnefs of Chrift is imputed to all them who believe for their juftification. And who can fhew that there is any thing unreafonable or contrary to the truth in this pro cedure ? Who will fay it is not perfectly reafonable and proper? * See John xvir. IMPROVEMENT, CHAP. IV. by Faith in Chrift. 89 IMPROVEMENT. THE fubjeft of this feftion leads us to fee, and reflet upon the wonderful difplay of infinite wifdom in the fal- vation of man, by Jefus Chrift. It has beenobferved, that wifdom is a moral excellence ; it is a moral perfection of God. It is included in benev olence or goodnefs, and cannot be feparated from it. Where there is no benevolence there is no wifdom, and where there is no wifdom, there is no benevolence. And there is always, and in all inflances, as much wifdom as there is goodnefs, and vice verfa. Yet it is proper and neceflary to diftinguifh between thefe, in order to think and fpeak moft clearly of the perfection of God. And this is done in the fcripture. The goodnefs of God is a wife goodnefs, is exercifed in the wifeft and beft manner, to anfwer the beft ends. God is as wife as he is good. There is a mod bright and glorious difplay of the wif dom of God in the redemption of man. Therefore, the gofpel of the grace of God is called wifdom, the wifdom of God i And Chrift is called fo : And the Apoflle Paul, fpeaking of the redemption of man, has the following re markable expreflion. " According to the RICHES OF ins GRACE, wherein he hath abounded towards us, in ALL WISDOM AND PRUDENCE."*' And he fay s, the angels learn the manifold wifdom of God, in the redemp tion of his church by Jefus Chrift. " To the intent that now unto the principalities and powers in heavenly places, might be known by the church the manifold wif dom of God, according to the eternal purpofe which he purpofed in Chrift Jefus our Lord."i In order to lay the beft and moft ample foundation, and give opportunity and occafion for the gieateft and moft *Eph. i. t, f Chap, iii. 10. n. go On the Sinner's Jujlification PART II. / moft glorious exercife and manifeftation of the love and grace of God, it has been wifely ordered that there ihould be creatures in aftate of infinite guilt and wretch- cdnefs, from which they could not be delivered confid ent with the honour of the divine law, and the moral character and government of God, unlefs a divine per- fon, the Son of God, became a man, and took upon him the form of a fervant, putting himfelf under the law, and taking the finner's place, fo as to bear the curfe in his ftead > and die an ignominious, cruel and accurfed death for him : And having thus fuffered, and obeyed the law of God in the moft trying circumftances, he is become the author of eternal falvation to all them who obey him. And in this way of falvation by Chrift, there is no room for mere human righteoufnefs and worthineis to come into the account. The righteoufnefs by which man is accepted and juftified, is a divine righteoufnefs, the righteoufnefs of God : A righteoufnefs of which not a mere creature is the author ; and the worth of it arifes from the dignity of the divine nature, and not from any worthinefs of a mere creature. In this way man is emp tied of all worthinefs in himfelf, and greatly humbled., and brought into a (late of exceeding, peculiar depend ence on God ; and divine grace is exalted and honoured, while the believer receives from him " Abundance of grace, and of the gift of righteoufnefs.'" And the redeemed are interefted in this divine righ teoufnefs, not out of regard to any worthinefs of their own; but when they are juftified, they are confidered in thernfelves, infinitely unworthy ; and that by which they are united to this divine perfon, fo as to have the advant age of his merit, the bond of union on their part, confifts in an exercife of foul in which they difcern and acknow ledge that they are infinitely guilty, illdeferving, hateful creatures; that were there not an infinitely meritorious righteoufnefs CHAP. IV. ly faith in Chrift. $1 righteoufnefs in Chrift, it would not be proper or con- fiftent with the law and the perfe&ion of God, that they fhould b& pardoned and faved ; and that the righteouL by which they are juftified, is that of a divine perfon, the righteoufnefs of God. They therefore, afcribe every good they receive, every thing better than endlefs de^ iiruftion, to the free, fovereign grace of God, and give him all the glory of it. This is " to be juftified freely by his grace, through the redemption that is in Jefus Chrift : And it is of faith, that it might be by grace."* " By grace are ye faved, through faith/' And the Apoftle adds, " And that not of yourfelves, it is the gift of God."t This leads to obferve, that the faith by which men are united to Chrift, is the free, fovereign gift of God, in renewing their hearts, and forming them to fuch an exercife ; in which he ah as an abfolute fov- reign, and has mercy on whom he will have mercy. Every thing is fo ordered in the work of redemption, as to give the greateft occafion, and advantage, and the beft opportunity for the exercife of the infinite goodnefs and grace of God ; and in fuch a manner as to make it mod vifible to creatures : And the redeemed are put under the beft advantage to fee it in the extent and glory of it, and be properly affected with it. The emptinefs and no- thingnefs of the creature, his infinite dependence on God, the fountain of being and all good ; the infinite fufficiency for the creature, even for infinitely guilty and wretched creatures, and his free, fovereign, unbounded love and grace, are here fet in the moft advantageous and ftriking light, efpecially to the redeemed ; fo that in the final iffue of things, when redemption i* perfected, God will appear in the cleareft light poffible, to be ALL IN ALL.J And they will receive unfpeakably greater good, than they could'have wanted, or were capable of, had they not finned, and had there been no divine Me- diator * Rom. iii, 24. iv. id, f Eph, ii, 8. J i Cor. sv. 28. gs On the Sinner's Jujlification PART II. diator and righteoufnefs. And all " To the praife of the glory of his grace."* Now the wifdom of God has contrived and laid the plan for all this. Therefore it is manifefled, and glorified in this exercife and difplay of divine grace, in which God hath abounded in all wifdom and prudence. Here the wifdom of God is fet in the mod confpicuous, pleafing light, which draws the attention, raifes the admiration, influences the love, and exalts the praife of Angels. And all who underftand the gofpel will cordially join with them, and with St. Paul, in his rapture and doxology. " O the depth of the riches, both of the wifdom and the knowledge of God ! Now unto the King eternal, immortal, invifible, THE ONLY WISE GOD, be honour and glory forever and ever, Amen."t II. IN the view of this fubjeft, we fee how, and in what refpects, the law is eflablifhed in the juftification of Tinners by faith in Chrift. The Apoftle Paul fays, the law is eftabliftied in this way. " Do we then make void the law through faith ? Yea, we eftablifli the law."* And when we confider' what faving faith is, and how the (inner is juftified by faith, we may fee on what ground this is aflerted. The whole work of the Redeemer in his incarnation, obedience and fufferings, had reference to the law, in order to eftablifh that, and magnify it, and make it hon ourable, confiftent with the pardon and falvation of the firmer who believeth in Jefus. He was made under the law with this view, in order to fuffer the curfe of it, and obey it in the room of finners, as their fubflitute and fure- ty, and in this way obtain the righteoufnefs of the law, for them, that he might be " the end of the law for righ teoufnefs to every one that believeth. " That Eph, i. 6. 4 Rom. xi, 33, i Tim, i, 17, | Rosa* &~ &* CHAP. IV. fy faith in Chrijl. 93 That the law might be maintained and eftablifhed by vicarious obedience or differing, or by a fubftitute, was made known when man was firfl created, as has been fhewn. The firft fubftitute or public head, failed of obe dience, and introduced fin and condemnation, which by divine conflitution extended to all his pofterity. All mankind are by the difobedience of the firfl man, con- ftituted finners, and by finning are under the curfe of the law ; from which they cannot be delivered, without a- Lolifhing the law, unlefs it be fuffered by them, or a fub ftitute. They could not fuffer this curfe and furvive it; for the evil implied in it, and which they deferved, is in- finite. And for the fame reafon, no mere creature, in heaven or earth, could be a fubftitute, to fuffer it in their room. But the laft Adam, the fecond man, who is the Lord from heaven, is able to take the curfe on himfelf and fuffer it, and yet furvive ; and having by this made full atonement for fin> and fatkfied the threitning of the law ; and by his obedience done all that is required of man, in order to his juftification, he has introduced a complete and everlafting righteoufnefs ; fo that he to whom it may be properly imputed, and he have the ad vantage of it, as much as if it were his own perfonal righteoufnefs, and he flood perfectly right in the fight of the law, may be juftified, perfeaiy confident with the law; and the law be more eftablifhed, refpefted and honoured, by the divine righteoufnefs of the Mediator, than it would have been by the eternal fufferings of every trangreflbr, and the obedience of all creatures. But no man can be juftified by the righteoufnefs of Chnft, unlefs he unite himfelf to him by faith in him ; in which he is brought to fee and heart'ily acknowledge the law which curfes every tranfgreilbr cf ir, to be holy, juft and good, and that he may be juftly deftroyed for ever for his fin, and if he be pardoned and faved,it muft be wholly by free, undeferved fovereign grace to him, while 94 On the Sinner's Juftificatidn, &c. PA&T If. while he receives this favour purely on the account of the righteoufnefs of ChrifL And he highly approves of it, and is greatly pleafed that the Mediator has done and fuffered fo much to eftablifh and honour the lav/, fo as to become the end of the law for righteoufnefs, to him who believeth, and trufts in him, in the charader of " The Lord our righteoufnefs."* Thus the believer is a friend to the law of God, and does not wifh to be faved in any way inconfiftent with it. And by faith he is conformed to it, in the requirement of it, in a meafure, and it is written on his heart. And he feels himfelf under in- difpenfible obligation to perfect obedience to the law, as an unerring, excellent and perfedt rule, and acknow ledges that every thing in him, contrary to this law, and that does not come up to all that it requires, is inexcufa- fcle wickednefs. And he looks to Chrift and trufts in him, to bring him to a perfect conformity to the law of God, as without that he cannot be completely happy, and in which, in a great meafure, his falvation confifts. At the fame time he is watching and fighting againft fin and fatan, and prefling forward after perfect holinefs, working out his own falvation with fear and tremblingr Thus the law, both in the precepts andthreatnings of it, is every way regarded, maintained and eftablifhed, in the juftification of finners by faith in Chrift, and is much more honoured than it could have been, had there been no Redeemer, and all tranfgreflbrs of the law had per- ilhed, or had it never been trangreffcd. ,. * jer. xxiii. , SECTION CHAP. IV. On the Covenant of Grace, '95 SECTION VIII. On the Covenant cf Grace. 1 HE Covenant of Grace, when underftood in the mod extenfive fenfe, comprehends all the defigns and tranfaclions refpe&ing the redemption of man by Jefus Chrift, in oppofition to the covenant of works, or law of works, under which, man was firft made ; and is the fame with the gofpel, confidered in its original, and the form in which it is adminiflered, and the effects of it. In this view, it comprehends the eternal purpofe of God the Father, Son and Holy Ghoft, to redeem man, fixing the manner of it, and every thing that relates to it, and entering into a mutual agreement or covenant ; in which the part which each Perfon fhould perform, as diftinguifhed from the other, was fixed, and vol untarily undertaken. The Father is reprefented in fcripture, as firft in this great affair, as giving and fend ing the Son, to redeem man ; and determining the num ber and the individuals of the human race to be redeem ed, and giving them to the Son, to redeem them, and promifmg that he fhould be upheld in this work, and carried through it, and be fatisfied in his reward, and the falvation of thofe who were given to him. The Son agreed to all this, and undertook the part he was to aft, faying, <( Lo I come : I delight to do thy will, O my God." The Holy Spirit undertakes to do the great part affigned to him in this work, particularly as the agent by whom the application of redemption is made to the eleft, by fandifying them, and effeaing a union between the Redeemer and them ; and by dwelling in them, forever, as S$ Qn the Covenant of Grace, PART li as the fpirit of love and holinefs. But this covenant tranfa&ion is more particularly and often mentioned, as taking place between the Father and the Son ; though -not excluding the Holy Spirit. It is needlefs to recite the numerous pafTages of fcrip- ture which reprefent the matter in this light, and refer to this covenant, to him who is acquainted with his Bible. That fuch a covenant muft take place between the Per- fons of the adorable Trinity, is certain from the divine decrees ; and neceflarily implied in this one fentence of the Apoftle James, "Known unto God are all his work?, from the beginning of the world."* This covenant may beconfidered as including the whole of redemption of man, as every thing relating to it is hereby fixed, and they who are to be redeemed, have redemption fecured to them ; and the Mediator covenanted as the public head of his people, and their falvation was made fure j and in this refpecr, they are all included in this covenant, And this may be called a covenant of grace, as it is the effect and expreflion of fovereign love and grace, and is the foundation of all the favour and free grace which is to be given to the redeemed church to eternity, and com prehends it all. But there is a covenant tranfa&ion, which takes place between God in Chrift, and every believer, when the gofpel is cordially embraced. This is often mentioned in fcripture, and God is faid to enter into covenant with men, and believers are faid to be in covenant ; and to make a covenant with him, and enter into covenant ; and lay hold of God's covenant, &c. This is a covenant diftind and different from that which has been mentioned between the Perfons in the Trinity, or more exprefsly, between the Father and the Son ; though this eternal covenant comprehends that made in time with believers, iu the manner which has been mentioned. This dif- tin&ion * Afts xv. if. CHAP. IY* On tk$ Gww&t of Graffy tinclion therefore, mud be made, and kept in view, would we think and fpeak clearly and intelligibly on this fubjeft. They who have been fenfible of this> have diftinguiiheJ them by different names, calling the firft, the covenant of redemption, and the laft, the covenant of grace> without defigning hereby, to exclude grace from the former, or to conficier it as not comprehending the latter, in the fenfe above explained. But the difference confifts part ly in the different parties covenanting ; the former is between the divine perfons of the Godhead, or the Fa ther and the Son ; the latter between thefe divine per fons, or God in Chrift, and finful man : Partly, in the different pcomifes and mutual engagements between the parties covenanting. This may be illuftrated in fome meafure^ perhaps, by the following inftance. The fon of a great king, and the king himfelf, had companion on a poor wretched woman, who had been guilty of a capital crime, and was condemned to be put to death ; and devifed means to fave her, and bring her to the honour and happinefs of being the wife of the fon. In order to this, and to make it confident withjtheiawsof the kingdom, and the honour of the father and fon, the latter muft go through a fcene offuffering and difgrace. The fon willingly undertook this ; and the father engaged to give him ail the necef- fary affiftance and fupport through the whole : And in confequence of his doing this, and as a proper reward for his virtue, to give him a place on his throne, and tocaufe the woman to con fen t to be his wife, though fhe was now a great enemy to him ; and to grant to her a free pardon, and that the fon Ihould make her as rich, hon ourable and happy as he defired; taking her into the neareft relation and union to himfelf. This agreement and covenant being made between the father and the fon, the latter went through all the fuffering and difgrace, VOL, II, II which 98 On' the Covenant of Grace. PART II. which he had' proofed to do, and was received to the power and honour which the father had promiled. The Ton being invefted with authority and power to reclaim the "woman, and bring her to confent to marry him, applied to her, and let her know all that had been done by him, in order to her being pardoned, and re- ceived to the g'reateft honour and happinefs, upon her conferring to be his wife ; and offered himtelf to her to be her friend and hufband^and d'o all for her, which (he could want or defire, if'jht' would' confent to be his wife ; and give herfelf up to him ro be thus related and united to him. The woman freely confented to the propofal of the prince, and accepted of his kind offer; and relying on his faithfulnefs and goqdnefs, engaged to do the duty of a wife to him.' Thus a particular covenant was made and took place between them; by their mutual promifes to each other. ' When Chriit, the Mediator, had finiflied the part af- figne^ to him, and which he had engaged in the covenant of redemption/in taking upon him the form of a fervant, and becoming obedient unto death, he was raifed from the dead, and exalted to the throne of the univerfe, and made head over all things to the church, as a reward for the 'great work which he had finifhed by his obedience and fttfFerings, by which he was openly approved' and jnflified, as Mediator between God and man ; and power was" given unto him over all fiefh, that he mould give eternal life to as many as were given to him by the Father.'* And he has' ordered the gofpel to be preached to men, declaring his- character, works and 'defigns, and publifhing the way of falvation by him, and freely offering rt to all who will accept o'F it, and promiling that all who believe on him, giving themfelves to him to be his difciples and j'ervaht?, fhall beTaved. This is the furn of thecovenant of * John xvii. a CHAP. IV. On the Covenant cf Gract. 09 of grace, as it is published and preached in the gofpel of the grace of God : And every one who embraces it> en ters into this covenant ; for this is the only condition on man's part; and by this, tnen are intitled to all" the promifes of the covenant, and falvation is made fare to them. The following things may be obferved, concerning this covenant : i. All the pr-ormfed- bleffings and good things con tained in this covenant, are made fure to the believer on. his firfl believing, and entering into covenant ; bccaufe one of the promifes of this covenant, as propofed to men by God, is, that he who once believes and accepts of the offer made, fhail perfcvere in .his adherence to it, and never fall from it, fo as to fail of the blefflngs of it. It is in this .refpetfc an evcriafMg covenant, as it infurcs ever- kfting life, and can never fail, or be broken, by either party in covenant. This is the covenant defcribed in the following words, " And I will make an everlajling covenant with them, that I will not turn away from ? hem, to do them good ; but I will put my fear in their hearts, that they Jhall not depart from me"* This is the covenant of which David fpeaks, as comprifmg the whole of his falvation, and all his defire.t The tenor of the covenant of grace is ftated as follows: "This is the co venant that 1 will make with the houfe of Ifra'el after thofCjdays, faith the Lord; I will put my laws into vheit mind, and write them in their hearts : And. I will be to them a God, and they fna.ll be to me a people. And they fhall not teach every man his neighbour, and -man liis brother, faying, Know the Lord ; for nil ill all .know me, from theleafl to thegreateft. For I v/ill be merciful to their unrighteoufaefs, and their fins and their iniquities will I remember no more."* II 2 . 2. This * jer. xxxii. 40. f 2 Sam. xxiii. 5. % Heb. viii. 10, n, 12. On the Covenant of Grace. PART II. - a; This covenant is called in fcripture, a new and fc- cOrid covenant/ in ( ^ The law, as a covenant of works, was not exhibited in the. revelation made to the children of lirael b- as it has been now explained, under the notion that any. man could obtain the favour of God, and be faved by this law or covenant ; for tins was iinpoiiible.^ But tjiyj law was thus, revealed and added, that it might be known what the law was,. and that, men might be hereby con^ vinced, that no man.can.be j.ufhned by the works of the law, as by his' fiji? he is under the curfe of it ; and thaA under this- couvidion, and delpairing of ialva.uori by the covenant of works, they might be led to underhand and embrace the covenant of grace, the way of laivation by faith in. the Redeemer.. This is the light in. which this point is., fet by the Apoflle Paul. " Is the law then a- gainft the promifes of God ? God foibid. For if there had been a law. which could have given life, verily righ- teoufnefs ftiould have been by the law. 4 Bu^ t the (crip,. ture hath co;ncluded all under [fin, that the prpmife by faith of Jefus.Ch rift might be -given to them' that be- liev^e."* This was the end which the -revelation of thi^ law anfwered, to thofe who- were fave.d under that dif- penfation; and it is fuited and -defigned to anfwer this lame end to thofe who (ball be faved, to the end of the world ; For by the law, thus revealed, ( is the kno\v r - ledge of fin, and the curfe of God, under which all men are, who do not believe in Chrift. Thus St. Paul flates the matter, with regard to himfelf. e they ever fo many, even all the human race. There fore, the offer of falvation is made to all, without excep tion, and promifed to all who believe, or willingly em brace the offer, to which they are invited and command ed. The direction and command is to preach the gof pel to all nations, to every creature. But this cannot be done if the bleflings of the covenant of grace be not of fered to all, even pardon, j unification and falvation, who are willing to receive them. For it is no gofpel, no good news, to thofe to whom this oifer and invitation cannot be made. The gofpel cannot be preached to the devils, becaufe the offer of falvation cannot be made to them, on any condition whatfoever : And if there be any of mankind to whom this offer may not be made, the gofpel can no more be preached to them, than to the fallen angels. The gofpel may be preached, and all the bleffings of the covenant of grace be offered to thofe who are not willing to accept of the offer, and never will believe the report, and be faved. It is contrary to all reafon and common fenfe, to fay, that no good thing can be offered to him who is not, and never can be perfuaded to be willing to accept it; that his rejecting the thing of fered, renders it no offer to him, and annihilates the On, tTit Covenant of Grace. PART II. good will. arid kindnefs of him .who rrjade. tl>e offer : Therefore, 1 that 'there 1 can be no goodnefs manifefted or cxercifed, in making an offer of thegreatelt good, to him who does not receive it j.iand; there is really nothing, of fered. But all this is implied in faying, that falvation by .Ghrift cannot be offered to thofe'wjio by .rejecting him, lhall not.be fav'ed, but perifh forever. It is known to God, that forae to whom -the gofpel is preached, and falvation by.. (Thrift offered, will reject it, and who they are who will do fp, arid confequently fail of falvation. But if their refufing the offer, be. confident with their having it really made to them ; then the know ledge that they will refufe tp.accept it, cannot render the offer lefs real and fi>ncere. But that the bleffings of the covenant. of grace are offered to. al]> without exception ; and all to whom the gofpei comes, are'inyited and commanded to repent and believe, is as evident and certain a truth, as*. any contained in the Bible. t . When, Chrift fent his difciples to preach, he directed them to fay. to all,,/' Repent y .for the kingdom of heaven is at hand." " And they went out and preach ed, that men ihould repent."* And they offered peace and falvation to. every perfon in the houies, into which they entered. t And Chrift. himfelf " preached the gof pel of the kingdom of God, faying, The time is fulfilled, and the'kiugdom of God is at hand. Repent ,ye y arid be lieve thegofpd.^ And " Now God commandeth all men, every where to;repent.'^ That is, to comply with the condition. of the covenant qf grace, and be laved : For, as has been fhovvn, repentance is put for the whole of converfion, and implies faith, and is connected with par don and falvation. Chriit fays, " He that rejefteth me, andreceivethnotmy wordsyhathonethatjudgeth him.' > H None can rejctt him, to whom he is not offered. There* fore * Mark vi. 12. f Luke x. 5. % Mark i. 14, 15. ^ Acts xvii. 30. q John xii, 48. lV. On the Covenant of Grace. fore he, with a]l his benefits, is offered to all who' hear the gofpel. The Apoftle Paul, offered falvation to all: who were prefent and heard him preach in a fynagogu'e of the Jews, " Men and brethren, children of the {lock of Abraham, and whofoever among you feareth God, (that is, all who are not of the flock of -Abraham, but profelytes from other nations) to you is' the word of this Talvation Tent."* And when the jews contradicted him, and blafphemed, He and Barnabas (aid to them, " It was neccfTary that the word of God fhould nrft have beeri fpo'ken to you : But feeing ye put it from you, and judge yourfelves unworthy of everlafling life, lo, we turn to the Gentiles. "f But to quote any more of this kind, is needlcfs : And not fo much would have been offered on this head, were it not that there are fome who think that falvation by Chnfl cannot be offered to any but to thofe who are elected, and (hall believe, and be faved. And as no man can know who they are, fo as certainly to dif- tinguifh them from others, falvation cannot be offered to any, on any condition or terms whatever. How contrary this notion is both to the fcripture, and to reafbn, and how inconfifterit with preaching the gofper to any, will appear from the obfervatiqns which have been now made. IMPROVE M E N T. HOW great is the privilege, which all enjoy, who live under the gofpel ! Salvation is fent unto them, and laid at their feet, and Chrift is waiting for their acceptance, (landing at the door, arid knocking for admittance. Plow amazing, how inconceivably great is their folly, madnefs and guilt, who reject this, mofl benevolent coun- Tcl of God.againfl themfelves, and perifh by flighting this offer, and defpiiing the Redeemer ! How - * Afts xiii. 26. f verfe 46. to8 flit Difpcnfation of the P.ART II. How fafe and happy are they who lay hold of this covenant of grace ! By infinite wifdorn it is formed and Juited to the (late and circumftances of man, and con tains every thing he can want to eternity. They niay e(- poufe the language of St. Paul, " God hath faved us, and called us with an holy calling, not according to our works, but according to his own purpofe and grace, which was given us in Chrift Jefus, before the world began."* " Who fhall feparate us from the love of Chrift ? Neither death nor life, nor angels, nor principalities, nor powers, nor things prefent, nor things to come, nor height, nor .depth, nor any other creature, fhall be able to feparate us from the love of God, which. is in Chrift Jefus our Lord/'f * a Tim. i. 9. f Romans viii. 35, 38* 3^. SEC T I O N IX. The Manner of the Difpenfation cf the Covenant of Grace y and the Preaching of the GofpeL IN the conclufion of the preceding fe6tion, it has been obferved and fhown, that the covenant of grace, is to be exhibited and propofed to all men ; and that the bleffings contained in it, to thofe who comply with it, are to be freely offered to all to whom the gofpel is preach ed ; which Jefus Chrift has commanded to be preached to all nations, to every creature, that is, to all mankind. Jt is now more particularly to be confidered, how this is to be done , and what is implied in preaching the gofpel. IV. Covenant of Grace, &?c. 109 This fttbjeft may be ftated and illuftrated under the following, particulars. I. PREACHING the gofpel, implies a declaration of the whole fyftem of truth and duty, contained in divine revelation ; as all thefe are implied in the gofpel, and have relation to the covenant of grace. Though fome truths are more effential and important than others, and the gofpel may be faid to be preached, while fome are overlooked ; yet it cannot be fully preached, unlefs the whole are brought into view ; and mufl be in a degree defective, by oppofing and rejecting any revealed truth. Therefore, to preach the gofpel, is to declare all the coun~ felof God, as the Apoftle Paul did.* Every doctrine re vealed in the Bible, and every duty prefcribed, has a con nection with the whole ; and all make but one confid ent fyflem. The whole may be fummed up and epitom ized, in a more general and comprehensive way, by ex- prefsly mentioning only the leading and moft effential truths contained in the gofpel, while others, though not mentioned, are implied ; and every particular truth, and branch of duty, may be more particularly brought into view, and explained, as there is occafiori, and opportunity offers ; in which the lo-ngefi life may be fpent in teaching, and making advances in learning, and the knowledge of the truth. Some of the mod effential truths implied in the cove nant of grace, or the gofpel, have been brought into view- in the foregoing part of this work, and others are yet to be corifidered, in their order and connection, together with the duties which are included and enjoined. It ap pears from what has been faid in the preceding chapters, efpecially in that on the nature of faving faith, that there is fuch order and connection in revealed truth, and fuch dependence of one on another, that fome things mufl firft be taught, underftood and believed, before others can be brought xx, *7, no The . Difpcnj r ation of the PART II. "brought into view, fo as to appear in their true light.' This may be iliuftrated by the following inftances, fome of which have been already mentioned. .The being of God, his attributes arid perfections;- in which the divine character confifts, muft firft be undrf- ftood and believed ; as this is the foundation of all re ligious truth, fo that every other revealed doctrine de 1 - petids wholly upon it. Confequently, a grofs miftake refpccting the character of the Deity, will lead to error through the whole fyllem of theology, and pervert th'e gofpel. This knowledge of God is neceffary, in order to know what is the nature of his moral government, and the reafon and extent of his law, and the obligation un der which men are to obey it. And a right conception of the moral government and law of God, is neceffary, in order to know what is the moral character and flate of man, viz. wholly depraved and fmful, under the cu'rfe and difpleafure of God, infinitely guilty and wretched, according to the fentence of a moft righteous and good law. All this muft be exhibited, underftood and be lieved, before redemption by Chrift can be understood, or come into view. Thofe truths are therefore implied in the gofpel, and the covenant of grace ; and the gofpel cannot be preached without exhibiting them in a true and proper light. In the light of thefe truths, the way is prepared to difcover, and fet before men, the defign n-nd work of redemption ; the perfon, character, defign and work of the Redeemer, and the grace and lalvation opened in the gofpel ; -and to mow what is necelTary, ** order to be faved by .Chrift, and in .what- this falvatioa , rpnfifls ; and what are the duties, . and promifes, and threatnings, which are revealed in the Bible. . II. THE publishing of ihc covenant of grace, and preaching the gofpel, does not difannul the law of Gocj, or discharge men from duty and obedience ; but re- enures CHAP. IV. Covenant of -Grace ,.&c. quires and demands obedience of all to -whom it ; is preached. The law is not in the leaft abated in the extent and ftriftnefs of the precepts of it, by the 'gofpel. The obe dience of Chrift does not difcharge any man, even thofe who believe in him, from perfed obedience to the law of God ; or free them in the leaft degree, from their obli gations to be perfectly holy. " Chrift is the end of the law for righteoufnefs to every one that believeth :" So that he may be delivered from the curfe of the law, be pardoned and juftified, cOnfiftent with the law, though he has no perfonal righteoufnefs and obedience, which anfwers the demands of it. But this does not remove his ill defert in any degree, or take away, or leffen, his obligation to obey the Jaw perfectly : And it remains as much the meafure and rule of duty to him,, as ever it was. And he is no farther holy, -or does any duty, than he con forms to the law of God, and db.eys it, requiring him to love God with all his heart, foul and ftrength, and his neighbour as himfelf. Thus the preaching of the gofpel does not make void the law; but eftablifties it.* In this view, the law muft be exhibited in preaching the gofpel, not only as neceifary to fliow the Tinner his flate and character, and to lead him to underftartd the gofpel, and to fee his need of Chrift, that he may be faved by free grace ; but to fet before him what is, and ever will be his duty, and the rule and meafure of his obedience ; and that it may be known that the gofpel does not abate his obligation to perfect obedience : But when underftood in the full extent of it, carries this demand in it, and in- creafes the obligation of believers to be perfectly holy ; and cannot propofe any other or lower rule of duty. The gofpel does indeed introduce hew obj efts,' : and propofes and enjoins duties, which could have no exift- ence, had there been no redemption for man. But thefe duties, * Rom. iii. 31, The Diffcnfation of the PART II. duties, which arife'from a difpenfation of the covenant of grace, cannot be neglected without difobedience to the original law of God ; which muft be confidered as inde pendent of the gofpel, and antecedent to the apoftacy of man. For the law which requires man to love God with all his heart, binds him to comply with every inftitution, propofal or offer, which God (hall make to him ; and to obey every command, which he iliall reveal, be it what it may: And not to comply with fuch inftitution, or not to accept of any propofal or offer he (hall make ; and to difobey any command of God, is difobedience to that law. Confequently, fuch inftitutions, commands, or offers of pardon and falvatiorr, do not difannul or abate the law, but the contrary. Though the gofpel confifts mod effentially in the free of fer of mercy, on condition of a cordial acceptance ; yet it neceflarily implies ami carries in this offer, an obliga- and command to accept, the offer ; which acceptance, taken in its full extent, implies and confifts in a perfect conformity to the law of God; and every degree of com pliance with the gofpel, is an equal degree of real holi- nefs,or obedience to the divine law, as has been mown in the ie&ion on the nature of faving faith. Though obe- ence to the gofpel, or compliance with it, and acceptance of the falvation which it offers, be a different form and manner of the exercife of holinefs, which is, fo far, more beautiful and excellent, than obedience to mere law, un connected with the gofpel ; yet the former is of the fame nature and kind with the latter, and confifts in loving God with all the heart, and his neighbour as himfelf. This ha$ been obferved, and explained in the above mentioned feclion. In the preaching of the gofpel, there is an offer of a free pa*don, and complete redemption, to all who are willing to comply with it ; but men are not at liberty to rejel it, without being accountable and held guilty for fuch CHAP. IV. Covenant of Grace, fi?c. fuch conduct. They are required and commanded to accept of the offer, and conform to the gofpel ; and that upon the mod dreadful penalty for refufing to obey^ Chriil himfelf required of all to whom he preached to "Repent and believe the goipel ;" and he, and John, who came before him, declared that he who believeth not on the Son of God, is condemned ; that the wrath of God abideth on him, and he lhall be damned.* The Apoftle Paul lays, " Thou lhalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy foal, and with all thy mind. Thou ihalt love thy neighbour as thyfelf."* And they do not arrive to the full and moft perfect character of chrif- tians, of the redeemed by Chrift, nor are in the higheft and moft complete fenfe united to Chrift, until they are perfeclly conformed to this law ; which never takes place in any inflance while in the body, in this life. III. IN preaching the gofpel to Tinners, nothing is required or propofed, to be done by them, which is fhort of repentance and faith in Chrift, or which does not im ply this, in order to their obtaining falvation. This is implied in the preceding obfervations ; and the contrary is really inconftftent with them. In preaching the gofpel, falvation is freely offered to all who will ac cept of it-- and men are in-vited and commanded to do this, and inevitable deftruclion is denounced againft them who refute, and negleft the offered falvation. But a cordial acceptance of falvation, implies repentance and faith in Chrift, which is a conformity and obedience to the law of God, fo far as it takes place, and the exercife of real holinefs. If in the difpenfation of the gofpel, it were propo-ftd to Gnners to do fomething, and they were Tequired to do it, which does not imply obedience to the law of God, nor acceptance of falvation, and which they may do, confiftent with their continuing enemies to God ? and to rejeft. the offered falvation with their whole heart, it would be really to drop and lay afide all which the law requires, and fo make it void, and to fubftitute fomething in place of it, which ftands in direcl; contradiction to it j even as contrary as fin is ta holinefs. The command to lova * Matth. xxii. 37, 39. i Cor. vii. 19. ix. zn CHAP. IV. Covenant of Grace> &c. 115] love God, cannot make that a duty in which there is no love to God ; but the exercife of enmity againft him. And to require this, or any thing like it, as a duty, is to make void, and even oppofe this command. But as the contrary to this has been pra&ifed by many in preaching the gofpel, by exhorting and urging finners to do that which does not imply repentance and faith, or a cordial acceptance of the gofpel offer ; but is confident with their continuing impenitent, and rejecting and haU ing Chrift and the gofpel, and living in total difobedience to the law of God, requiring them to love him with all their hearts ; and doing that which is confident with all this, has been urged as their duty ; and a fet of duties,, and acourfe of obedience, have been prefcribed for fuch impenitent finners, to be done by them, while they conti nue impenitent enemies to Chrift and the gofpel : And fince there have been a difference of opinion, and not a little difpute on this point, of late years, efpecially in New-England ; it is thought proper to attend to this fubje61: more particularly in this feftion ; hoping that fomething may be faid which may ferve to give light, and eftablifh the truth. A careful attention to the fol- , lowing particulars, confidered together, and brought into one collected view, with their natural and juft confe- quences, may help to decide this point. FIRST. MAN is naturally, and while unrenewed, in a flate of total moral depravity. His mind, his heart, is enmity againft God, and his law : This is the nature and tenour of all his moral exercifes, while he continues an impenitent (inner, and rejects the gofpeL This will now be taken for granted, as the evidence of it has been already given, and it is fo abundantly aiTerted in fcripture.* The confequencc from this is, that im- 1 2 penitent, * Part I. Chap. VIII, 2i6? TXtf Difpenfation of the PART IL penitent, unrenewed finners, do no good thing, no, not one of them, but are in all their moral conduct, wholly difobedient : Therefore, they cannot be exhorted and commanded to do, what they actually do, while impeni tent, without being exhorted and commanded to do that which is unreafonable, wrong, and forbidden in the divine Jaw ; and fuch a command would be very abfurd, unrea fonable, and wrong. Therefore, it is certain, no fuch command can be found in the Bible ; and no man has a light to form and give fuch commands ; or to imagine that impendent Cnners, while they continue fuch, ever do any duty, or any thing, as God requires it. God commands all men every where, to repent and believe the gofpeL If at the fame time, he fhould direct and com* rnand them to do any thing, while they continue impen itent, and in unbelief,, and which implies difobedience to his command to repent ; would not one command (land in direct contradiction to the other ; and the latter be at lealt an implicit annulling or fufpending the former, and an allowance to- live for a time, at leaft, in impenitence and unbelief ? SECOND. THE moral depravity of men, and their ob- flinacy in impenitence and rebellion, however great and fhong, does not in the lead remove, or abate their obli gations to repent, believe, and obey the divine commands ;. or afford any excufe for their difobedience, or extenuate the criminality of it. This has alfo been corifidered in the former part of this work* and is indeed a felfevident proportion, as the contrary is a plain contradiction. It follows, from this propofition, that the moral depravity of man, and the oppofition of his heart to repentance,, however total and flrong, is no reafon why any thing Ihort of true repentance, mould be recommended to him., and * PAH I. Chap. VItt, CHAP. IV. Covenant of Grace, &c. and required of him, as his duty ; but is rather a reafon againfl it, as fuch propofal and requirement, would im ply an excufe for continuing impenitent, becaufe they have fuch a ftrong averfion from it and that repentance is not their immediate duty ; as fomething elfe which is confiflent with fuch averfion, and with total impenitence^ is fubflituted in the room of repentance. And it is p re lume d no one would have thought of prefcribing impeni tent, unbelieving duty, to finful men, which is confident with their total oppoution of heart, to God, and his law, to Chriil and the gofpei, had he believed the above pro. political, and kept k properly in view : And that it will appear to thofe who properly attend to this fubje6r., and the manner in which it has been treated, that they who plead for a fet of dudes to be done by men, while impeni tent unbelievers, and without conformity of heart to the law of God, or the gofpei, do really fuppofe that the moral depravity of man is attended with an inability to repent and embrace the gofpei, which does, in fome de gree at leaft, excufe him for not repenting immediately : And if their minds were wholly freed from this notion, they would no longer contend for fuch duties, or imagine they could have any exiflence. It may be proper to obferve here, that from the par ticulars now mentioned, with the arguments from them, if they be juft, it appears that it would be inconfiftent with what has been already advanced in this fyftem, to admit that the gofpei enjoins or propofcs any duty that does not imply repentance, as it has been afferted, as im portant, fundamental truths, that man is totally deprav ed ; and yet this does not diminiih his obligation to repent and embrace the gofpei, and even to be perfectly holy ; or afford the leaft excufe for one (in : And that there is no duty which does not imply conformity of heart to the law of God. 13 Ti8 The Dtfpenfation of the PART II. THIRD. ALL the law, and commands of God, refpe6l the heart or will ; and there is no obedience to any com mand, or any moral agency, in which the will is not con cerned and aftive : And no obedience or duty is done by any man, if his heart be not obedient, and comformed to the command. There is no virtue or vice, or any morality, in external actions, any farther than they are connected with the will, as the production and fruit of that. And whatever is the production and fruit of a vicious heart, or will, acting from tmreafonable and bad motives, and fora wrong and forbidden end, is not duty, but fin, whether it be in words or actions, or whatever it rnay be ; and whatever be the appearance of it in the fight of men, who cannot fee the heart. This is fo plain a cafe, and the irrefiftible dictate of the feelings and common fenfe of mankind in general, that it is needlefs to try to prove it, or fay any thing more to illuftrate it. From this it follows, that whatever is faid, or done, in external aclions, by a perfon who is wholly impenitent, and with a wicked, difobedient heart, is not duty, but fin. Therefore, it is certain, that God never commands any siian to do any thing fo ; and with a difobedient, impeni tent heart. And when only an external aHon, is men tioned, and commanded, the command has refpecl to the heart, and requires the aclion to be done in obedience to him ; and not in impenitence and difobedience. There fore, no man has a right to direct finners to any thing as duty, and as commanded by God, with an impenitent, difobedient heart ; or to flatter him that he may do fome duty, while he continues wholly impenitent, and wicked. FOURTH. THE fcripture does not afford any fuppoit to the opinion that finners are required to do dpty, which they may do while they continue impenitent, as nothing is CHAI>. IV. Covenant 'of Grace, &c. is there required as duty,, which does not : imply 'repent ance ; but the contrary. Whenever Tinners are there* addreMed, and called upon, to do, they -are commanded to repent and believe the gofpel, or to do that which im-*- plies this, and a real conformity of heart to the moral law of God. If finners were to be directed and commanded, in preaching the gofpel, to do fbme duty, in order to be iav-*- ed, which is not repentance, nor implies any love to God, or acceptance of Chrift, mod certainly Jefus and his Apofil.es, would have done this, and fome inftances of K, at leaft, would have been recorded. But as there is not one .inftance of this, nor the lead hint of it ; but many in fiances of the contrary, is not fuch a notion and praclice wholly without any warrant ? When the ApoC* ties were applied to, with the ferious, important queftion, What (hall we do ? They anfwer, " Repent, and believe on the Lord Jefus Chrift."* And this was agreeable to the example and command of Chrift : In preaching the gofpel of the kingdom of God, faying, " Repent ye, and believe the gofpel. "t He commanded his difciples to go forth, and call on men to repent. And when he gave commiflion to the Apoftles to preach the gofpel, he di rected them to preach repentance and remiffion of fin, in his name. J When the young ruler came to Chrift, and alked him what he fhould do, that he might inherit eternal life ? Jefus did not direct him to do any thing lower than keep ing the commandments, and that which implied love to him ; even to fell all that he had, and give it to the poor, and come and follow him. This was mod contrary to the reigning difpofition of his heart, and Chrift knew he was not willing to comply with it; and he went away forrowful. Why did not Chrift dire 61 him to fomething I 4 lower, * Ab ii. 38. xvi, 31. f Mark i. 14, 15. $ Luke xiv. 47. The Difpcnfation of the PART 11, lower, which h might do confident with his reigning luft, and his continuing an impenitent (inner ? If it were proper to give fuch direction to any (inner on earth, was it not fo in this in fiance ? Why was he not told, that though he could not now find in his heart to forfake all for Chrift,and heaven ; yet he might do fome, yea, much duty, which would bring him nearer to heaven, and might ifTue in that happy event ; even that which is confiRent with an impenitent, worldly mind, which it was poffibie with God only to remove ? Therefore, fince there is no in (la nee tp.be found in icripture, of directing and requiring . finners to do that as their duty, which is confident with continuing impeni tent ; but whenever they are addreHed, they are exhort ed and commanded to repent, or to do that which implies repentance, and love, and fubmiflion to God ; this ferves to confirm the reafons which have been given under the preceding particulars, to prove that impenitent fin- xiers do no duty ; and that nothing which does not imply repentance, can reafonably be propofed or required of them as their duty, in preaching the gofpel to them. - Jr> not the invariable cofidu6l of Chrift and his Apoftles iufficient to decide this mat,ter ? May not their example be fafely followed ? Is is it not wrong, and even prefump- tuous to deviate from it, and prefcribe to men, as their duty, that which they never mentioned in their addrefs to finners,* FIFTH. * Some have mentioned the following paflages, and fome others, as clireftions and calls to finners to do what is there commanded, while they continue impenitent, and in a ftate of fin. " Strive to enter in at the fb"ait gate. Labour not for the meat which perifheth, but lor that which endnreth unto everlafting life, &c." But it has been obferved, by thofe who have attended to thefe paflages, and others, which have been adduced to the fame purpofe, that when properly confidered w-ith the context, and other parts of fcripture, they do not appear to direct to duties, to be by finners, while they continue impenitent j but imply tho(e obedi ent CTIAF. IV. Covenant of 'Grace, G'cl FIFTH. TEACHING finners, that while they continue impenitent, they do no duty, nothing that God requires of them, and that he commands them to repent and em brace the gofpel ; and that they can have no excufe for not doing it immediately, has no tendency to remove or difcourage their attention to the things of the gofpel, which relate to their falvation, and to make them care- lefs and fecure in their fins ; but it has a contrary ten dency, viz. to awaken their attention, and to promote their convidion, concern and engagednefs of mind, to obtain the falvation of their fouls. In preaching the gofpel to them, they are to be told what is their flate and character, how guilty they are, and wholly inexcufable in their fins ; how infinitely dreadful and dangerous their fituation is. The gofpel is to be opened and explained to them, and what is ne- ceffary in order to their obtaining the falvation, which is therein offered to finners : And they are to be called upon to repent and embrace the gofpel as their fir ft and immediate duty ; far the neglect and refufal of whicb^ they can have no poflible excufe ; but it is a moft ag gravated and dungerous fin. The motives and encour agement to embrace the gofpel, are to be fet before them ; and the promifes to all who comply are to be urged ; and the awful-threatnings to all who refufe, and continue in their impenitence, denounced. " He that believeth, lhall be faved; but he that believeth not, fhall be damned." Surely nothing can be thought of or devifed, that would be better fuited than this, to arreft and awaken the attention ent exercifes of b*art, which are connected with falvation. No com mand or direction which is to be found in fcripture, can reafonably be underflood as prefcribing only that which finners are to do, and may do, while impenitent and difobedient ; unlefs it be exprefsiy (aid that they are to do it, and may do what is commanded, wliHc fuch.. It may be pre- fumed, no fuch paflage of fcripture will ever be produced, as it would appear to com ra &c. 127 find no heart or inclination, that they are not obliged to repent immediately ; and that their duty confifts chiefly^ if not wholly, in waiting on God, for a heart to repent and embrace the gofpel : And in this way, they continue blind to their greateft fin, and which is the chief aggra vation of all their fins, viz. unbelief / and imagine they are doing their duty, and waiting on God for his blefling, with an impenitent, rebellious heart, and while they are " abominable difobedient, and unto every good work reprobate !" It has been obferved, that it is probable, duties -to be done by impenitent, unconverted finners, while they con tinue fuch, would never have been thought of and urged> had not an opinion been entertained, that they are under an inability to repent and believe on Chrift, which does excufe them, in fome meafure, at lead, for continuing impenitent, and unconverted. From this apprehenfion and fentiment, ftnners have not been called upon to re pent and embrace the gofpel immediately ; but to do fome lower duties, which do not imply repentance, or renovation of heart ; which are required as the inftru- mental duties^ in order to obtain faving mercies ; and which they may and can do, while unconverted ; and therefore can have no excufe for negledling them. And this appears to be confirmed by facl. Moft, if not all of thofe, who have pled for fuch duties, and rnve prefcrib- ed them to finners, to be done by them, as unconverted and impenitent, have, at the fame time, either exprefsly or implicitly reprefented them as under fuch an inability to perform duties in a holy manner, which does, at leaft, in fome meafure excufe, and does not wholly confift in their having no defire or inclination to repent, and op- pofition of hean, to it ; but that there is, in their cafe, a cannot^ independent of a will not ; and that the latter is therefore diftfoft from the former ; and that the former kind 128 The Difpcnfation of the PART II. kind of inability does excufe, as it certainly muft, fo far as it does not confift wholly in the evil inclination of the will, and is independent of it. And from this opinion, many public teachers, and authors, have not called on finners and required of them, to repent immediately ; but have direded them to do many duties, while they continue unconverted ; or at leaft have infilled chiefly on the latter, as they confider them able to do the latter, though they cannot do the former. This appears to be one great and chief mean of pro moting, confirming and fpreading far and wide the doc trine, that (inners are under an inability to repent and believe on Chrift, which is a good excufe for neglecting it, and living in an unconverted Hate. Hence, when they are, in fcripture language, called upon to repent, and accept of offered mercy, it is common for them to fay, they cannot do this, and offer it as an excufe for their not turning to God, and embracing the gofpel. And as this is a fentiment fo agreeable to the hearts of finners, as it excufes their impenitence, and helps to (hield them againft a true conviction of their criminality in continu ing in an unconverted flate ; and leads them to think they have fmcere and ftrong defires to be chriflians ; but cannot, through fome infuperable difficulty, independent of their will, which cannot be removed by their inclina* tion and endeavours to do it ; they greedily imbibe it, and are difpofed to hold it faft. So long as this fenti ment is cordially embraced, it will prevent a true and thorough conviction of their own character and Hate ; and therefore, has a bad and dangerous tendency. It is an implicit denial of the total depravity of man ; and mifreprefents the nature of the (inner* s moral depravity^ and inability to do that which is holy and good ; as if it rendered him innocent and blamelef?, while he continues unholy and difohedient, Jefus CHAP. IV. Covenant of Grace, &c. 129 Jefus Chrift, indeed, fays, " No man can come to me, except the Father, who hath fent me, draw him."* And it is abundantly declared in the fcripture, that no man will repent, and do what is required of him, unlefs his heart be renewed by divine influence. But, at the fame time, their negleft and refufal to hear and obeyj is repre- fented as wholly their own fault ; and that their inability is their crime^ confiding wholly in the inexcufable wick- ednefs of their own hearts. And the requirement is not laid afide or lowered, becaufe they are unwilling to obey ; and fomething fhort of a compliance fubflituted in the room of it. When Chrift fpake the words that have been mentioned, the context fhows that he did not men tion their inability as any excufe for their not coming to him ; but considered ic as very criminal in them, and as rather an evidence and aggravation of their wickednefs. And he conftantly invited and required all to come to him ; and told them their inability confided in the flrong and fixed oppofition of their hearts to it. He faid, " Ye will not come to me, that ye might have life." We do not find him faying, Since ye are not able to come tome, I will prefcribe to you fome other duty, which you may and mufl do, while you refufe to come to me, and have fuch a Itrong oppofition of heart to me, that you cannot come. Nor has any. one yet been able to difcover any duty enjoined by him, which men may do with a heart which is wholly in oppofition to him. It is now left to the reader to judge, whether the par ticulars which have been here mentioned, confidered in their connexion and confequences, do not prove the truth of the proportion to which they relate ; and make it evident, that in preaching the gofpel, nothing is pro*, pofed and enjoined as duty, to be done by men, which is confident with their rejecting the offers of it, and con tinuing iii'penitent. SECTION * John vi. 44. If VOL. II. K P erf ever anct of PART I L SECTION X. all true Believers y do perfevere in Faith and Holinefs, to the End of Life, and cannot fail of Eternal Salvation. J. H E doctrine of the perfeverance, and final fal- vation of all who believe in Chrift, and are once inter- efted in the covenant of grace, has been repeatedly brought into view, efpecially in the three preceding fec- tions. It has been afierted, or often fuppofed, in what has been faid on faith, juftification, and the covenant of grace ; and fome fcriptures have been mentioned, which do fuppofe and aflert it. But it is proper that this point fhould be more particularly confidered and explained, and the evidence of the truth of it, be fet in as clear, and convincing light as may be. Indeed, this doctrine is fo connected with the other doctrines which have been advanced in the foregoing parts of this fyftem, and fo implied in them, or follows from them, as a natural and undeniable confequence, that they who underhand and believe them, will not he- fitate about the truth of this. They only are difpofed to deny, or doubt of the truth of this doctrine, and do not fee the evidence of it in divine revelation, who do not believe man, to be naturally fo totally corrupt, and fo abfolutety dependent on God, for a new heart, and every degree of holmefe, and for falvation ; and that all this fo wholly depends on the decree and will of God, as has been reprefented above : But imagine that the fal-. v: 'ion CHAP. IV. nil True Believers. 131 vation of men, depends on their free will and conduct, independent of God, in fuch a manner and meafure, that they turn the fcale in favour of their falvation, and not God, by any powerful influence of his, which mall determine whether they mall be faved or not. And therefore, if they do now believe, and are .in favour with God, it wholly depends on themfelves, and not on any particular, determining influence of heaven, whether they fhall perfevere or not, in faith and holinefs, to the end of life ; confequently there is no fecurity againfl their falling away, and perifliing. Therefore, if the doc-, trines which have been advanced in this fyftem, have been proved to be contained in the holy fcriptures ; and confequently, that the fcheme juft mentioned, is erron eous and unfcriptural, the doctrine now under confidera- tion, will be admitted of courfe, without any difpute. In order to explain this doctrine, and remove or obvi ate miftakes and mifreprefentations refpeling it, and flate the evidence of the truth of it, the following ob- fervations muft be made. 1. That believers never will totally and finally fall away, fo as to perifh, is not owing to the nature of true grace, or any power or fufficiency in themfelves to per fevere unto the end ; but this depends wholly on the will, and conftant influence and energy of God, working in them to will and to do. They are kept by the power of God, through faith unto falvation. It is God, who having begun a good work in them, will carry it on un til the day of Jefus Chrift.* If the holy fpirit were taken from the believer, and he left to hirnfelf to (land or fall, he would immediately ceafe to be a believer, and fall totally from a (late of grace. 2. The perfeverance of believers is confident with their being fan&ified but in part ; and guilty of much K 2 fin; * Phil. i. 6, 132 The Perfeverance of PART II. fin ; and even by furprife, and great temptations, of particular grofs outward acts of fin. 'But they never become totally corrupt and finful, as they were before, and as all the unregenerate are ; and they do not fin with their whole heart : They being born of God, do not commit fin, in this fenfe, and as others do ; " for his feed remaineth in them : And they cannot thus fin, be- caufe they are born of God.*'* By falling into fin, they may bring themfelves into great darknefs, and lofe all ienfible evidence that they are born of God ; But their faith and grace never wholly fails ; fo that they do not fall from it totally; but this fpiritual life continues in fome degree of it, at leafl, and it will fooner or later, and will doubtlefs in ordinary cafes, very foon, kindle up in renewed fenfible acts of repentance, faith and love. Peter was an inftance of this ; by which this obfervation is illuflrated. 3. The certain perfeverance of true faints in faith and bolinefs, unto falvation, does not imply or fuppofe, that they (hall be faved whether they thus perfevere or not; or that they fliall perfevere without per fevering. It would be quite needlefs to obferve, that fucfi a palpable contradiction is not implied in this doctrine, were il not that forne have feemed to underftand it fo. They ob ject to the doctrine; the tendency of it, to make thofe who believe it, carelefs about a holy life, and to lead them to indulge their lulls, and live in fin. There can be no tendency in this doctrine to this, unlefs the certain.* ty of the perfevcrance of believers in faith and holinefs,, genders it needle fs to perfevere in faith and holinefs, which is impoflible, as it is a contradiction in terms. If true believers (hall perfevere in faith and holinefs ; then fuch perfererance is absolutely neceffary to falvation, and there is no other way to b$ laved ; and he is not a true * j John iii\9. CHAP. IV. all True Believers. true believer who does not thus pcrfevere. No doctrine therefore, can more affert and eftablifh the importance and neceflity of a careful and refolute perfeverance in holy living, than this. And it affords the greateft en couragement to the believer, to work out his own falva- tion with fear ami trembling, while he relies upon the promife and grace of God, to work in him, both to will and to do.* This leads to another obfervation. 4. The certain perfeverance of the faints, in faith and holinefs, does not render their activity, conftant care and exertions, ncedlefs, or fuppofe this unneceffary ; but the contrary. It is their own perfeverance in faith and ho linefs which is made certain ; they themfelves, therefore, rnuft live by faith and in the practice of holinefs ; for they cannot perlevere in any other way, but by a conftant at tention to this matter, watching and praying, and work ing out their own falvation with fear and trembling. To neglect this, and to take a contrary courfe, is to draw back unto perdition, and not to believe to the faving of the fbul.f^ How abfurd is it then, fora perfon to fay, or think, that fince his care and activity, in living a holy life, "are "made certain, as neceflary in order to his fal vation : therefore he will exercife no care and concern about it, nor do any thing towards it, but the contrary ! It is very certain, that he who has a prevailing difpofi- tion to think and feel thus, is not only guilty of grofs contradiction, but is a flranger to true faith, and has neither part nor lot in this matter. Therefore, 5. The doctrine of the certain perfeverance of be lievers unto the end of life, is fo far from rendering the ufe of means, and fetting motives before them, in order to promote and effect, their living a life of faith ?,nd ho linefs, unreasonable or needlefs, that all this is as irnpor- K 3 taut * Phil, ii, 12, 13. f Heb. x. 39. J34 The Ptrfatrancs of PART II. tant and neceflary, as if this doctrine were not true, and their perfeverance were not made certain. If God have promifed that all who are interefted in the covenant of grace, ftali perfevere in a holy life, and in this way be faved ; this fuppofes that they fhall be tinder advantages, and have proper means ufed with them, in order for this, and that they fhall have motives conftantly fet before them, to induce and perfuade them to obedience, and live a holy life ; and tp guard them a. gainft the contrary. Hence the propriety and neceffity ofalltheinftitutionsof thegofpel, directions, inflructions, exhortations and commands, and the various and numer ous motives, to furnim believers with proper means, and to induce them to perfevere in their faith ; without which, the intention and promife of God, that they fhall perfevere, could not be effected in a proper, rational way, confiftent with the nature of man. How greatly miflaken are they then, who fuppofe, if the perfeverance of believers be made certain in the cov enant of grace, this would render all fuch means, mo tives, exhortations, promifes and threatnings ufelefs and unreafonable ! And becaufe thefe do take place, accord ing to the word of God, they infer, that this doctrine cannot be true ! 6. This doctrine fuppofes perfeverance to the end of life, in faith and holinefs, neceflary in order to falvation ; that fuch only fhall be faved : Therefore, that they who do not perfevere, will not be faved, but perifh ; whatever good attainments, faith and holinefs they may appear to have for a while ; and however confident they may be that they fhall be faved. If believers might be faved, without perfevering in faith, to the end of life, there would be no need that their perfeverance fhould be made fure ; and there would be no propriety in promifing this, as fuch a great privilege^ CHAP. IV. oil Trut Belitvcrt. 135 privilege, and as if it were, neceffary to falvation. It is abundantly declared in fcripture, that they only who overcome and keep the words of Chrift to the end, fhali be laved. " He that continueth to the end fhall befaved. If ye continue in rny word, then are ye my difciples in deed. If a man abide not in me, he is cafl forth as a branch, and is withered."* Thefe and many other dec larations in the fcripture of the fame kind, are fo far from being inconliftent with the do6lrine of the certain per- feverance of all true believers, that the truth contained in fuch palfages, is fuppofed, and implicitly afferted in this doclrine. It has been afked, why fuch declarations are made in the fcripture, if no true believer does ever fail away ; but certainly will continue to the end ? The anfwer is at hand. They are made, becaufe it is true that none can be faved, unlefs they perfevere ; and it is proper and important, that this truth Ihould be known, and kept in view, to prevent perfons flattering themfelves, that they have been, and are true believers, though they (it ftiil and do little or nothing, neglecling the work of faith, and labour of love ; and though they have fallen into a fettled courfe of apoftacy. And fuch declarations, are fuited, and even neceflary, to diflin- guifh true believers from others ; and to excite them to care and watchfulnefs, left they fhould apoftatize ; and to zeal and activity in obedience, and engagednefs to perfevere in faith and holinefs, by a patient continuance in well doing, feeking for glory, honour and immortality. If any fay, that thefe declarations fuppofe that true believers may fall away, and perim. ; and therefore arc mconfiftent with the certain perfeverance of all fuch : Anfwer. This is certainly a miftake. They neither aiTert, nor fuppofe, any fuch thing. Every true believer K 4 may *Mat. x, 26. John viii. 31, xv. f, 13.6 The Perfeverance of PART II. iriay perfevere to the end, conliflent with thefe declara tions, and they may be the means of their perfevering. It is true, that he who does not perfevere, but draws back and apoflatizes, fhall not be faved ; but it is equally true, that all fuch never were true believers ; but their faith was effentially different from true faith, and therefore* only a temporary faith ; and this is difcovered by their falling away. Therefore, the Apoftle John fays, of fuch apoftates, for he dwelleth in you, andjhall be inyou."\ Of the fame holy fpirit he fpeaks, in his difcourfe with the woman of Samaria, when he fays, " Whofoever drinketh of the water that I fhall give him fhall never thirjl : But the water that I fhall give him, fliall be in him a well of water, fpringing up into everlafting life."J By this fpirit, believers are faid to be fealed to the day of redemption. " Who hath alfo fealed us, and given the earnejl of the fpirit in our hearts."^ To be fealed, is to be fecured as the property of Chrift, and belonging to him, and a certain token of complete redemption. The earneji, is a part given, as a token and pledge that the whole fhall be granted, even eternal life. 8 t That all true believers in Chrift, fhould perfeverein faith, and none of them perifh, is confident with all other truths contained in divine revelation, and is really con tained in many of them ; and this appears every way proper and reafonable. That this doclrine is not inconfiftcnt with any thing contained in the fcripture, has been made evident; it is hoped, from what has been briefly faid, in fome of the above particulars, to obviate the objections which fome have made to it, from not underftanding it, or the fcrip- tures, on which they have grounded their objections. And if man be fo wholly dependent on God for falva- tion ; * i John ii. 27'. -f- John xiv. 16, 17. J Chap. iv. 14. ^ 2 Cor. i. 3z. Eph. iv. 30, P erf ever ance of PART IT. tion ; fo that this muft be determined by his fovereign will, as it has been made evident the fcripture reprefents him to be ; and he is brought into a ftate of falvation, by the fovereign, almighty influence of the divine Spirit, giving him a new heart, and making him a new creature, 'by which he is brought into a fpiritual, vital union to Chrift, and made a living member in his body, the Church ; and is pardoned and jaftified for Chrift's fake ; being, by this union, interefted in his atonement and rightcoufnefs ; and is conftantly dependent on God for every holy aft and right thought : Then it is unreafon- able to fuppofe, that after God has done all this, of his own fovereign will, and made the believer fo far meet to be a partaker of the inheritance of the faints in light, having delivered him from the power of darknefs, and tranflated him into the kingdom of his dear Son ;* he ihould relinquifh this work, and give him up to the pow er of fm and fatan, and leave him to periih forever : But on the contrary, it is mofl reafonable to conclude, with the Apoftle Paul, and with him, c < Be confident of this very thing, That he who hath begun fuch a good work in him, will perform it until the day of Jefus Chrift."t IMPROVEMENT. I. SEE how exaftly the blefTmgs and promifes of the covenant of grace are fuited to the circumflances, and to the heart of the believer ; and to exhibit and difplay fovereign grace. He is abfolutely dependent on God for holinefs, and pevfeverance in it, unto falvation ; he feels himfelf infinitely unworthy of any favour, and with* out flrength in himfelf. to do any good thing ; he is fur- rounded with temptations and dangers ; and fatan, that flrong and fubtle enemy, is feeking to deflroy him. He would fink into defpair immediately, were it not for the promifed Col. i. 12, 13. ) CHAP. IV. all True Believers. 141 promifed power and grace of Jefus Chrift, who has promifed he will never leave nor forfake them who trull in him : But this gives him fufficient and full fupport, and he acknowledges and admires the wifdom and grace of this covenant, as everlafting, and ordered in the bed manner, in all things, andfure ; and fays with David, " This is all my falvation, and all my defire." He knows this is no contrivance of man, no fiction, but an important, glorious reality, which has a divine (lamp up on it. He believes, and rejoices, in hope of the glory of God. II. WE hence learn, what encouragement the poor, loft, infinitely guilty, and miferable fmner, has to come to Chrift, and truft in him for every thing he can want* Chrift enfures falvation, and perfection in hoiinefs, to every one who will come to him ; and promifes he will in no wife caft them out, or forfake them. He will be their righteoufnefs, wifdom and ftrength. He will furn- ifh them with the whole armour of God, and teach their hands to war, and their fingers to fight, fuccefsfully againft fin and the devil, and lead them on to complete victory. III. THIS doclrine affords fufficient encouragement to the trembling believer, who knows his own weaknefs, to make a public profeflion, and efpoufe the caufe of Chrift before the world, and engage, by his grace and af- fiftance, to ferve him, devoting himfelf to his intereft and honour. Some, who thought they were friends to Chrift, have been afraid to make a public, chriftiari profeffion, left they fhould fail away and difhonour him, by their finful conduct. This is owing to their not well attending to the promifes-of the covenant of grace. If they have a heart Concerning Believers PART II. heart to devote themfelves to the fervice of Chrifl fin- cerely, and choofe a holy life, in obedience to him, as the greateft privilege and happinefs, they may fafely truft in him for that afTiftance by which they may live a holy life ; for he has promifed never to leave nor forfake them, but that his grace fhall be fufficient for them. SECTION XL Concerning Believers AJJurance of Salvation. JL HEY who deny the certain perfeverance of all true believers, do of courfe, not believe it is poffible that any man fhould be fare of his own falvation : And it is certain, that the latter, would not be poffible, were the former not true. But if the covenant of grace contain a promife, that all who believe, (hall perfevere in faith unto falvation ; fo that there is a certain connexion be tween the firft aft of faith and falvation ; which has been proved in the preceding fe6Hon ; then, if the believer can know that he does now believe, he may infer, with certainty, that he fliall be faved. He has jufi fo much evidence, that he (hall be faved, as he has, that he is a true believer, or is poffeiTed of any thing which implies faving faith : And if he can be fure, that he has any exercifes of this kind, he may be equally fure of final falvation. This fubjeft, may be explained, and the truth vindi cated, by attending to the following particulars. i. Affiirance of falvation, is not efifential to faving faith ; or a pcrfon may believe in Jefus Chrift, and here by be brought into a (late of falvation ; and yet not know CHAP. IV. djfarance of Salvation. 143 know that he does believe in Chrift, as they do who (hall be faved. Many have thought, that faving faith confifts in be lieving that they (hall be faved ; that God loves them,, and defigns to fave them, and Chrift died for them, &c. or that this is, at leaft, implied in faith ; that it is in this fenfe, an appropriating aft t taking falvation as their own, knowing that it belongs to them, and that they fhall be faved. But it has been fhown, in the feftion on the na ture of faving faith, that fuch a notion of faith is not agreeable to fcripture. Saving faith is a direct aft, be lieving the gofpel to be true, approving of it, and receiv ing Chrift as he is there offered. This may take place, and a man be a real believer in Chrift, without any know ledge or confcioufnefs, or even the leaft thought, that he does believe, or that his exercifes are faving faith ; for the latter confifts in reflex acts of the mind, in a view or confcioufnefs of what does, or has taken place in his heart, or what are the direct acts of it towards Chrift, &c. The knowledge or aflurance, that we do believe, is a refkx net of the mind, upon what has taken place in our hearts, by which we obtain a knowledge that we have believed, or dp now believe : So that alTurance of falvation, or that we have faving faith, is confequent on our believing ; and faving faith muft exift in the mind, and every thing cffential to it muft take place, before we can be confcious that we do believe, or have any knowledge of it, which confifis in reflecting on thole acts of our hearts, which are faving faith, or do imply it. Thefe are, therefore, two diftinct things in their nature, and are not neceffarily connected. A pcrfcn may have faving faith, and yet not reflect upon the acts of his own heart,, fo as to know or believe that they are thofe in which faith confifts. Saving faith is an appropriating act in this fenfe ; it is receiving Chrift as our faviour, taking falvation, as it is offered, 144 Concerning Believers PARt II* offered, arid laying hold of the covenant of grace y fo as to infure all the bleflings of it, to ourfelves. But this may be done without knowing that we do it, or thinking that the exercifes of our minds, in which this confifts, are of the nature of laving faith. This knowledge is ob tained by reflecting upon our own exercifes, with difcern- ing to fee of what kind they are ; and the latter is noc neceffarily connected with the former, as has been now obferved. It is granted, that faving faith, even in the firft acls of it, may be fo ftrong and clear, that it may be attended with a confcioufnefs, and affurance, that the perfon does believe, and fhall be faved ; fo that believing and affur ance of falvation, may be both together, and connected, in this refpeft j but (till they are two diftin6i things, and confift in diflincl; a6ts of the mind ; and the latter is con- fequent on the former ; though the believer may not diflinguifh them, and not know that they are not one and the fame ad. 2. Affurance of falvation, therefore, confifls in a per- fon's confcioufnefs of the a6h of his own heart, that he does believe in Chrift ; and knowing from intuition or , reflection, that lie has attained to thofe things which im ply faving faith, and do accompany falvation, being infallibly connected with it, by the promife of God a in the covenant of grace. 3. It is certain, from fact and experience, that perfons may know what the exercifes of their own hearts are ; and it is reafonable to fuppofe this may be the cafe in the inftance before us. We do know what we love, and what we hate, in many inftances at leaft ; and what kind of ex ercifes we have, refpecting many objects with which we are concerned, which are agreeable, and which are not fo. We know we love fome perfons, and that others are Very difagreeable to us. And no reafon can be given, why* we CHAP. IV. AJfurancc of Salvation. 145 we may not believe and be fure, that the gofpel k true, and that Chrift is the Son of God, and be fopleafed with his character, and the way of falvation by him, and have fuch ftrong and fervent love to him, as that we may be confcious that we have thefe exercifes, and be fure we do believe, and love the Lord Jefus Chrift, in fmcerity and truth. Peter, was fo confcious and fure that he lov ed his Lord, from an intuitive view, and reflection on the feelings and exercifes of his own heart, that he could fay, with confidence, and great afTurance, cc Lord, thou knoweft all things, thou knoweft that I love thee." And it is very unreasonable to fuppofe, that no perfon can have fuch conftant, flrong love to Chrift, as to be fure he does love him, and has all thofe exercifes which are implied in faith and love. Nothing can prevent this, but the low degree and weaknefs of thefe exercifes, and the ftrength and appearance of contrary exercifes, or miftakes with regard to the nature and operation of true grace. 4. It appears from fcripture, that many good men, were in fa 61 affured of their falvation. Job fays, " I know that my K.edeemer liveth, and that he fhall fland at the latter day upon the earth. And though after my Ikin, worms deftroy this body, yet in my flefti fhall I fee God : Whom I fhall fee for myfelf, and mine eyes fhall behold, and not another."* The Pfalmifl fays, '* Thou (halt guide me with thy counfel, and afterward receive me to 'glory. My flefh and my heart faileth ; but God is the firength of rny heart, and my portion forever. "t And it appears from the New Teftament, that the ApoPdes, and many, if not the rnoft of the primi tive chriftians, were fure that they fhould be faved. - The Apoftles fpeak in the language of affurance ; and reprefent this to be common to believers of that day, by * Job xix. 25, 36, 27, f Pfal. hcxiii. *4> *, VOL, II. L 146 Concerning Believers PART II. by ufmg fuch language in their name. The Apoflle Paul fays, c< I know whom I have believed, and I am perfuaded (or confident) that he is able to keep that which I have committed unto him, againft that day. I have fought a good fight, I have finilhed my courfe : Henceforth, there is laid up for me, a crown of righteouf- nefs, which the Lord, the righteous Judge, (hall give me, at that day."* And he fpeaks of himfelf as fure of fal- vation, in his letter to the church at Philippi. " I know that this fhall turn to my falvation, through your prayer, and the fupply of the Spirit of Jefus Chrift. To me to live is Chrift, and to die is gain. I am in a flrait betwixt two, having a defire to depart, and to be with Chrift, which is far better."f And he ufes this language of afTurance, when he fpeaks in the name of others, as well as of himfelf. " We know, that if our earthly houfe of this tabernacle were diflblved, we have a building of God, a houfe, not made with hands, eternal in the heavens, &c."J The Apoflle John, fpeaks the fame language, ff We know, that we have patted from death to life, be- caufe we love the brethren. We know, that we are of God. And we know, that the Son of God, is come, and hath given us an underflanding that we may know him that is true : And we are in him that is true, even in his Son Jefus Chrift. This is the true God, and eternal life." Thus it appears from fcripture, that believers have been in fact allured of their falvation : And therefore, that it is poflible, that others, and even all believers, may attain to this, in the fame way in which they obtained if, viz. by arriving to fuch a degree of faith and chriftian exercifes, as to produce a confcioufnefs, and certain knowledge, that they have faith, or chriftian holinefs, which is connected with falvation. This * 2 Tim. i. 12. iv. 7, 8. f Chap. i. 19, 21, 13. t 2 Cor. v. iS. ^ i John iii, 14. v. 19, 20, GHAP. IV. dffurance of Salvation. 147 This leads to another particular. 5. There is no other way of obtaining this affurancej but by having fuch high degrees of chriftian holinefs, in aftual exercife ; and accompanied with fuch fpirituai difcerning, as that it is feen and known by the perfori who has it, to be real gofpel holinefs, or true, faving faith. True grace, or holinefs", is in the nature of it, clearly dif- tinguifhable from every thing which is not fo : And if it be not diftinguifhed, by the believe^ and feen and known to be what it is, it muft be owing either to the frnall degree of it, fo that it cannot be difcerned, or to the want of fpirituai light and difcerning, or both of them. And indeed, it is always owing to both thefe, if they may be confidered as diftinft things, which they really are not; for they both go together, and are infeparable.* Holinefs is itfelf, light and difcerning ; and the more there is of this in the heart, and the flronger and more conftant the exercifes of it are, the more the mind is illuminated, and fees fpirituai things, more clearly ; and with greater cer tainty difcerns and diftinguiflies between true grace, and that which is not of that kind. Therefore, an increafe of holinefs, magnifies the object, and renders it more vifible, and eafy to be feen by the fpirituai eye, fo as to be diftinguifhed from every thing elfe ; and at the fame time, is the fpirituai eye, and increafes the fpirituai fight and ability of difcerning, fo as more clearly and with greater certainty to fee and diftinguifti truth from falfe- hood. Therefore, in proportion to the degree of holi nefs exercifed, other things being equal, there will be evidence to the mind, that fuch are the exercifes of it, and confequently that they are connected with falvation ; L 2 and * Though the exercife of holinefs, and fpirituai difcerning, are feveral times mentioned diftinfUy, in this feftion, it is not intended that they (hould be underftood as two really diftinft things. Holinefs, is fpirituai !ight and difcerning ; and fpirituai light, is holinefs. See the Section on Divine Illumination. 148 Concerning Believers PART II. and they may rife to fuch a degree, and holinefsbe a6led out in fuch ameafure and manner, as to be accompanied with great and well grounded affurance, that it is real ho- linefs, which is by the promifes of the covenant of grace connected with falvation. Therefore, this is the way which profeffing chriflians are exhorted to take, in order to have and maintain, affurance of their falvation. " And we defire, that every one of you do fhow the fame diligence, to the full affurance of hope, unto the end. That ye be not flothful, but followers of them, who, through faith and patience, inherit the promifes."* The " Affurance of Faith," is mentioned in this Epiftle,t by which is meant, an affured belief of the truth of the gofpel, which is expreffed in the following words, by Peter. " We- believe, and arefure, that thou art the Chrift, the Son of the living God."* The c.ffurancc of hope, is an affured hope of falvation, which is the fame with affur ance of their falvation. And the way to obtain this, which is here propofed, is diligence and engagednefs in the exercife and expreffion of love to Chrifl, and to his people, in opposition to floth and negligence ; which is the fame with the flrong and fruitful exercife of chrif- tian grace. Therefore, 6. The believer is wholly dependent on God for af furance of falvation. Believers are entirely dependent on God for the lead degree of holincfs, as it is his fov- ereign gift ; but they have a fpecial and peculiar favour from him, xvho are brought to fuch a degree of holy ex- erciie, and fpiritual difcerning, as to be affured that they are born of God, are his children, and fhall inherit ever- lading life. It is by the fpivit of God witneffing with their fpirits, that they are brought to fee and know, they are the children of God. This the fcripture declares. cc The Spirit himfelf beareth witnefs with our fpirit, that we are the children of God." This is done, not by * Heb. vi. II, 12. fChap. Xi22t J John vi, 69. ^ Rom. viii, 16, CHAP. IV. Afurance of Salvation. 149 by any immediate fuggeftion, revelation or teflimony to the believer, that he is a child of God, as fomehave feem- ed to imagine; but by forming the heart to that degree of holy affeftion, and fpi ritual difcerning, that the be liever is able to look on this work of the fpirit, and know* that he is born of the fpirit. Thus the fpirit of God produces this evidence and witnefs in the heart of the believer, that he is born of God, and gives that difcern ing to him, that it becomes a witnefs to his fpirit, that the fpirit of God is in him, and has formed him to holi- nefs, by which he is become a child of God, and has the fpirit of a child, difpofing him to look to God, as his Almighty Friend and Father. What the Apoflle John fays, amounts to the fame thing, and may ferve to illuf- trate thefe words of St. Paul. " Hereby we know that he abideth in us, by the fpirit which he hath given us. Hereby know we, that we dwell in him, and he in us, becaufe he hath given us of his fpirit."* 7. The affurance of falvation is not common to all chrifiians; many never attain to it, and few, or none of thofe who do, have it conftantly, without interruption. This is not promifed to all believers in the covenant of grace, as perfeverance is ; but is given, or withheld, as is mod agreeable to infinite wifdom and goodnefs, and fo as to anfwer the beft ends, and be moil for the glory of God, the beft good of his Church, and of the individual members of it. Affurance is moft common among them who are called to diftinguifhed and eminent fervice and fufferings in the cawfe of Chrift, as they feem to (land in mod need of it, to fupport and animate them, in the inidft of the greateft trials, dangers, and worldly evils. Thus, affurance of the love of God, and eternal falvation, feems to have been enjoyed, not only by the A po files, L 3 but * i John .Hi. 24. iv. 13. See Prcfideut Echvsrds, on Religion: AfFeftions, Firft Edition, p. 125 133, Concerning Believers PART IT, but by chriftians in general, in their day, as they were called to fuffering in a peculiar manner and degree, in confequence of their becoming chriftians. And thofe chriftians who have been called to the greateft labours *and fuffe rings, in all ages fince, have appeared to have, and exprefs, the greateft afTurance of their own falvation. It has been common for martyrs, to go to the flake, or to other moft cruel deaths, in the joyful affurance, that they \vere going to heaven ; as ecclefiaftical hiftory abundantly informs us. And in the times of the greateft fufferings of the church of Chrift, chriftians have appeared to be rnore generally allured of their intereft in the covenant pf grace. And this can be accounted for, from what has been faid above ; for they who are called to extraordinary la bour and fuffering in the caufe of Chrift, not only need this fupport, more than others ; but their circumftances are fuited to awaken their graces, and excite them to a higher and ftronger degree of exercife, than common ; by which they have clear evidence, that they have true grace ; and God grants his fpirit to fuch, in uncommon degrees, which is a witnefs within them, to their fpirit, that they are the children of God. And often, when chriftians are on a dying bed, and called to encounter the king of terrors, and feel themfelves going into the invifible world, they have a greater meafure of the holy fpirit, and their faith, and every grace, are in a ftronger and more fenfible exercife; and they are allured that Chrift is their Saviour, and that they are paffing into a ftate of perfe& holinefs, happinefs and glory. There are different degrees of affurance, which differ ent perfons may have, or the fame perfon, at different times. In this imperfect ftate, none, perhaps, may be properly faid to be perfeElly fure of their own falvation, fo that there can be no addition to their affurance,, They " are CHAP. IV. Afurance of Salvation. 131 are not fo fure of falvation, as they will be, when they ac tually arrive to heaven, and find themfelves in poffeflion of it ; or as they are, who are now in heaven. And one chriftian may properly be faid to have a Jlronger af- furance than another, and the fame believer may have a higher or greater degree of affurance, at one time, than at another, when he may be faid to be fure. The dif- ciples of Chrifl, fay to him, upon a particular occafion, " Now are we fure that thou knoweft all things, and needed not that any one mould afk thee : By this we believe that thou earned forth from God/'* They believed this before, and were fure that he knew all things ; but now their faith, and aflurance, were flronger and increafed. Chriftians who are not affured of their being in a (late of grace, but entertain a hope of it, may, and actually do, have a flronger hope, or more hope, at one time, than at another, according to the different degrees in which their graces are in exercife, and as different feelings and exercifes, in different circumflances, and on different oc- cafions, take place. Sometimes their hope is affaulted with great and overbearing doubts and fears, and they hardly know, whether they have any hope or not ; and are ready to conclude againfl themfelves, that all is wrong, with refpe6l to them, and they are really in a gracelefs (late. At other times their hope revives, and is ftronger, and their doubts, in a great meafure, fubfide. And one chriftian differs very much, in this refpeft, from another. The hope of one is more ftrong and conflant ; and he has not fo many doubts and fears, refpe&ing his flate : Another is generally full of doubts, and his hope is weak^ and attended with great diffidence, and does not often rife, fo as to expel his fears. This difference, is doubt- lefs owing, in many inftances, to the flronger and more L 4 conflant * John xvi. 50. 352 Concerning Believers PART IL conflanbexercife of chriftian holinefs in the former; he having more grace, and with greater fervency of fpirit, lives a watchful, prayerful life, and with more engaged- nefs and conftancy, attends on all the duties of chriftian- ity, than the latter. But it is not always owing to the different degrees of holineis, that perfons thus differ, in their hopes and con- Iidence,refpe6ting their own chriftian character : But two perfons, who have an equal degree of holinefs, may great ly differ, as to their hope and confidence, of their being real chriftians. This may arife partly, from their natur al ternperarid difpolition ; partly from other caufes, fuch as the manner of their education, and the inflruclions under which they have lived; the habitual way of thirik- u idch they have been led, by thofe with whom they afi'bciate ; or the miftakes into which, one or the other has fallen, about the nature and operation of true holinefs : The ftrong, habitual propenuty of one, to look i dark fide, and view and attend moft to the cor ruption and evil propensity of the heart, and lefs to any contrary exercifes ; being inclined to conclude againft, r than in favour of himfelf : The other is of a con trary difpolition, and looks more on the favourable fide, makes the bed of what he fees in himfelf, and is not uch difpofed to give way to doubts and fears, and iuggeftions againft himfelf. Thefe and other things, and cir cum fiances, may take place and be the caufe of the difference mentioned, in two perfons equally holy ; yea, lie who doubts the. moil of his being a real chriftian, may have more grace than the other, who doubts lefs, fup- pofmg they are both chriftians, as this difference does not arife always^ from their different degrees of holinefs, but from other caufes, fome of which have been men tioned. CHAP. IV. d/uranct of Sakuttion. 153 If he may be called an affured chridian, who rifes above all doubts or fear, with refpect to his being a real chndian, perhaps every believer has this afturance, at fome ieafons in his life, either at his firft converfion, or at other times. At lead, his mind is fo attentive to the truths of the gofpel, and he is fo pieafed and delighted with them, or with fome particular truths ; and he is fo entertained with the divine character, and that of the Redeemer, that he has no doubts or fears about his own Rate ; and perhaps, for a while, thinks little or nothing about himfelf ; and when he does, and reflects on his own views and exercifes, he is raifed above all doubt, whether he be in a (late of grace or not. But thefe views and exercifes may foon vanifh, in a great meafure, out of light, and ceafe to be fo ftrong and fenfible ; and his doubts may arifeih as great flrength as ever, and greater; and he call ail in quedion, and greatly fear he has been deluded, and never known what true holinefs is. And whatever be the degree of pofitive afiurance, to which a chriftian may arife, above a being freed from all doubts and fear?, refpecting his prefent date, and future falvation ; yet it mud be imperfect, as has been obferved, and he liable to change, and to lofe it, at any moment. The mind of the bed chridian is not fo fixed, but it may fluctuate like the waves of the fea. He is peculiarly fa voured by God, indeed, who is enabled to maintain a condant aflurance through a courfe of years, upon good evidence. He mud be eminent in grace, and live in the condant, drocg exercife of faith and love, and every branch of chriftian holinefs. But we have abundant reafon to conclude, this is not generally true of chridians. Jn this imperfect date of temptation and trial, in which the bed chridians, have fo much fin cleaving to them ; if they rife at times above all doubts, and have great afmrance^itdoesnot commonly continue, uninterrupted, a 154 Concerning Believers PART IL a long time, but often fubfides foon, and gives place to darknefs and doubts. It being built on the fight and knowledge of their holy exercifes, it mufl change and fail, as they alter, and become lefs vifible and fenfible, and the fenfible and ftrong exercife of corruption takes place. It rnufl be obferved, however, that the chriflian, through a long courfe of experience, in which, after many doubts refpetting his ftate, he has had frequent revivals of his hope, and his doubts have often entirely fubfided ; and his exercifes of grace have been fo ftrong and evi dent, that he has had a great degree of aflurance ; may hence be led to maintain a more fteady hope, and not admit doubts of his having true grace, when the exercifes of it are not fo vifible and fenfible, and much of the contrary, appears in his heart. By long experience, he has found, that though his faith and love have, at times, been out of fight, and contrary exercifes of heart, have taken place, and appeared, to an awful degree ; yet he has, after this, frequently been revived, and his exercifes of chriftian grace, have been fo ftrong and fenfible, that all his doubts have vanifhed. Hence he is more ac quainted with the life of a chriftian, and the nature of iaving grace ; and learns that he may have true grace, though it be not always fenfibly difcerned, and little or nothing but contrary exercifes, are perceived ; and fo does not give way to overbearing doubts, even at fuch times ; but maintains his hope in a more fteady manner, grounded on his paft experience. But he cannot, at fuch feafons, when gracious exercifes are not actually perceiv ed, and in fight, be ajjured, that he is a chriftian, and fhould he continue long in this fituation, great doubts and fears, muft arife. 8. Every believer would always have affurance that he is a chriilian, and (hall be faved, were it not for the imperfection CHAP. IV. AJfurance of Salvation. 155 imperfe&ion and weaknefs of thofe exercifes in which chriflianity confifts, and, which is really the fame, his fmall degree of fpiritual difcerning ; and were there not fo much fin, flupidity, and fpiritual blindnefs in his heart. The holinefs in which chriftianity confifts, is, in the nature of it, diftinguifhable from every thing elfe, and tends to difcover itfelf, in acting according to its own nature. And nothing can prevent a fight of it, and knowing that it is true holinefs, but want of attention and difcerning, together with a fmall degree of it, and that in a great meafure, hid and buried in the remaining finful diforders of the heart, which render it, in a great degree, flupid and blind to the things of the fpirit of God. The rules and directions in the fcripture, are plain and abundant, by which, true chriflian holinefs, is defcribed in the exercifes of it, and diftinguifhed from every thing, which is not holinefs : And the fpirit of God, in producing, and maintaining grace in the heart of a chriflian, bears witnefs, and produces evidence, that he is a child of God ; and if it be not difcerned by his fpirit, it mud be for the reafons juft mentioned. It therefore follows, that were it not for thofe things mentioned, which are in the way of it, every chriftian would have conftant affurance, that he is a believer, and (hall be faved. Were his graces in high and conftant exercife, and aled out in all proper ways ; and were his moral corruptions con- iequently in a great meafure fubdued, and mortified, he could not have a doubt, he muft be fure that he is a friend to Chrift, and does moft cordially embrace the gofpel ; and is interefted in that everlafting covenant, that is ordered in all things and fure. 9. It is the duty of every chriftian, to have and main tain a conftant affurance that he is a chriftian, and fhall be faved ; and it is, therefore, wholly his fault, for which he 156 Concerning Believers PART II. he can have no excufe, if he be at a lofs, and doubts whether he be a believer in Ch-rHt, or not. This follows from what has been obferved under the laft head. For if it be the duty of chriflians to live in the conflanr, vigorous exercife of every grace, and cleai difcerning of fpiritual things, and mortify all their lufts ; with which AiTu ranee is connected ; then it is their duty, conflantly to have and maintain this affurance, and they cannot fail of -it, unlefs they come vaftly fhort of their duty. It is indeed their duty to be perfedily holy, and every thing ihort of this, is fo far finful ; but the exercife of holinefs, which is greatly fhort of perfection, is TuIBcient to allure the chriiiian, that he is really holy, and fhali be faved. It has been obferved above, that the believer is entirely dependent on God, for every degree of holinefs, and efpecially for that degree which is neceffary in order to a well grounded affurance. But it cannot be inferred from this, that it is not the duty of chriflians to be holy to fuch a degree, as to render them fure they fhall be faved ; unlefs fuch dependence on God, be inconfifient with any poffible duty, or fin, which cannot be afferted, confident with reafon, or the Bible. There is no truth afferted more clearly and conflantly in the holy fcrip- ture, than thefe two, viz. Man's entire dependence on God for all moral good, or holinefs ; .and his obligation to be holy, as God is holy ; that this is his duty, and all negleci, and every thing in him, contrary to this, is his crime. lie who denies either of thofe, does fo far re* nounce the Bible. I M P R O V E M E N T. I. FROM what has been obferved, on this fubjec~r., we learn, that they embrace a great and dangerous delu- iion, who think they are affured of falvation, without the lead CHAP. IV. Affiance of Salvation. 157 lea ft evidence, that they are fan&ified, in any degree, or looking inwards to find any holy exercife ; and that to build fuch affurance upon our gootl frames, and holy exercifes of heart, is a low, kgal way of getting affurance a and is not the proper a ffurance of a chriftian. That true chriftian affurance, is built upon a more firm foundation, upon Chrift, and the word and promife of God, and not upon the uncertain and changeable feelings and impref- fions of the heart. If the affurance, for which they plead, and which they think they have, be examined, it will appear to be built on a fandy foundation, or rather upon nothing. To whom is Chrift a Saviour, and to what are the promifes of the gofpel made ? Chrift faves them who believe in him, and them only ; and the promifes are made to a cer tain character, to that faith in Chrift, which implies all the branches of chriftian holinefs ; and to no perfon who has not this character. And no man can have the leafb evidence, or reafon to believe, that he has an intereft in any of the promifes of the gofpel, or lhall be fayed by Chrift; who has not that hoiinefs which is implied in faving faith, andunlefs he has evidence of this, in his own, mind, by feeing what paffes in his own heart, and what are the exercifes of that. If affurance of falvation, be not founded upon the knowledge of our own character, it is built upon nothing, and is mere delufion. II. WE learn that no perfon can have affurance of falvation, from any thing, any circumftance or attain ment, which is merely external. Real holinefs, or fane- tification, is the only evidence that any one can have, that he (hall be faved : But this confifts in the exercifes of the heart, and not in any thing external, any farther than it comes from the heart, and is an expreilion of what takes place there. Men may make a profeffion of re ligion ; 158 Concerning Believers PART II. liglon ; attend on all the ordinances and inflitutions of Chrift;; and their whole external behaviour may be re gular and blamelefs in the fight of man ; they may be juft and beneficent in their conduct to others; yet if all this do not proceed from a holy difpofition and exercifes of heart, it is no evidence that a man fhall be faved ; and confidered as leparate from the heart, there is no real chriftianity in it. This is decided by the Apoftle Paul : " Though I fpeak with the tongues of men and angels ; and though I beftow all my goods to feed the poor ; and though I give my body to be burned, and have not charity, it profiteth me nothing, and I am no thing."* Men mud be acquainted with their own hearts, and know of what nature their internal exercifes are, in order to know whether they be chriftians or not. Indeed, if men think their hearts are right and holy, when their external conduct is not good, regulated by the commands of Chrift, they deceive themfelves ; for though a regular, and good external behaviour, be not any certain evidence of holinefs of heart, yet the want of this, and an irregular external conduct, is a good evi dence that the heart is not right. Too many feem to take all the evidence, hope and confidence they, have, that they (hall be faved, from fomething merely external, and foreign from any thing in their hearts ; either becaufe God fmiles upon them, and profpers them in his providence, or from their at tending upon the external duties of religion ; their regu lar external conduct, and the practice of juflice and beneficence towards their fellow men ; and not living in thofe vices, which many others practice. Such are ill-angers to true religion, and are wholly deceived in their hopes and expectations of the favour of God. Their character is given by Chrift, in the Pharifee, who went up to the temple to pray, and faid, " God, I thank thee 5 that * i Cor* xiii. i, a, 3. CHAP. IV. Affurance of Salvation. 159 that I am not as other men are, extortioners, unjuft, adulterers, or even as this publican. I fall twice in a week, I give tithes of ail that I poiTefs."* A chriftian may, indeed, have his hope and affurance that he does love Chrift, ftrengthened by adhering to his duty, and fteadily obeying him in his external con duct, when called to that which is difficult, and in which he muft greatly deny himfelf. When his grace is thus tried, and does not fail, it is a farther and confirming evidence, that he is, indeed, a true friend to Chrift ; but in this, the motives and exercifes of his heart, are not out of the queflion, or out of view ; but are by fuch trials, brought into view, and his holinefs of heart, fhines out more bright, and becomes more evident and vifible, not only to others, but to his own confcience ; as gold fhines more, and proves itfelf to be true gold, by being tried in the fire. Thus Abraham's ready obedience to the divine command, to offer his fon Ifaac, for a burnt offering, was a confirming evidence that his heart was truly pious. " And the Angel of the Lord, called unto him, out of heaven, and faid, Now I know that thou feareft God, feeing thou haft not withheld thy fon, thine only fon, from me."t III. FROM what has been obferved on this fubjecl:, we learn, that they have no true affurance of their falvation, but are deluded, who fay they have great and conftant affurance of this, while they live carelefsly, and in many refpe&s unbecoming chriftians. There are fuch, who do not appear to be confcientious, humble, meek, watch ful and prayerful chriftians, but the contrary ; who of ten exprefs, with the greateft confidence, their abfolute affurance of their own falvation. This is an evidence a- gainft them, in the view of the judicious, that they do not know what true religion is ; and they may reafonably be * Luke xviii. u, 12, f Gen. xxii. u, la. t6o Concerning Believers PART IJ. be confidered, as " Proud boafters, fpeaking great (wel ling words of vanity/' And fome fpeak of their not having a doubt of their being real chriflians, for a great number of years; but have enjoyed full affurance of their falvation all that time, in fuch a manner, and who have appeared to live fuch lives, as to give reafon to con clude they know not what true aflurance is. If a perfon who has lived a life eminently devoted to God, and in the conftant practice of all the duties of chriflianity, fhiriing externally in good works, and all the graces of our holy religion, mould, on proper occafions, humbly and modeftly declare to his chriflian friends, that he was raifed above all doubts about his flate, and had, for a long time, enjoyed full affurance of his falvation, no one would have reafon to call it in queilion. But when they make high pretenfions to this, whole lives are in no meafure aniwerable ; and make no proper appearance of living in the conftant and lively exercife of true re ligion, in a ftrift, confciencious, holy walk, they are to be confidered as poor, miflaken, deluded creatures. IV. WE learn that the believer's affurance of falva tion, has no tendency to lead him to live a carelefs, un godly life, but the contrary. It is not confident with fuch a life. It necefTarily fuppofes, flrong, lively ex- ercifes of holinefs, and zeal to live a holy life ; and can continue no longer than thefe continue : When ever his zeal for good works, abates, and is not perceived, and careleffnefs and floth take place, the chriflian will lofe his affurance, in a great degree at leafr, if he were be fore allured that he was a chriflian ; and doubts will of courfe arife. The affured chriflian, therefore, is the moil lively, holy chriflian, and moil engaged to crucify the flefh with the affeclions and lufls. And he fees more clearly than others, or than he did before, the ne- ccflity CHAP. IV. Afurdnce of Salvation. ceflity of perfevering in this way, not only in order to maintain his affurance, but in order to be faved ; and feels the great and peculiar obligations he is under, to this, and to love Chrift and keep his commandments, who has loved him, and given himfelf for him ; " That he mould not hence forward, live unto himfelf, but un to him who died for him and rofe again."* Every af- fured chriftian, can efpoufe the language of an eminent; ancient chriftian, who, when he had full affurance of faU vation, faid : " I run, not as uncertainly : So fight I, not as one that beateth the air : But I keep under my body, and bring it into iubje&ion ; left that by any means, when I have preached to others, I myfelf fhould be acaft away."t V. TH E doctrine of affurance, as- it has beefi now ft ate ed, and explained, may affift perfons to determine whe ther they be believers, or not, and point out the way to obtain affurance that they are fuch. i. The true believer defires no affurance of his falva- tion, but that which has its foundation in holy exercifes, and confifts in them, fo that the former cannot be obtain^ ed without the latter. Affurance of falvation would be worth nothing to him, if he could have it, without holinefs, or while he had no ftronger and more ferffible exercifes of love to Chrift, &c. than he now has. He therefore does not afk for fuch affurance, nor defire it. It pleafes him, that affurance cannot be obtained in any other way, than in the lively and fenfibleexercifeof holy affe6lion. There are fome, who earneftly defire and long for af furance that they fhall be faved, and feel, that if they could obtain this, they fhould be happy, while holinefs is not fo much the object of their defire and purfuit. Thefe are not feeking the affurance which the chriftian defires., * Gal.ii. 20. s Cor. v. 15. f i Cor. ix, 26, 27. VOL. II. M Concerning Believers A/urance, &c. PART If. defires, nor can it be true affurance, or of any real worth, were it obtained, without holinefs. Such affurance will fatisfy a felfifhperton ; becaufe^ if he can be affured that he (hall be happy, he cares for no more ; and in his idea of happinefs, holinefs is not included. But not fo the true believer. 2. From the preceding particular, it follows, that the true believer, prizes holinefs more than affurance, and is more concerned to obtain the former, th^-n the latter. To be conformed to Chrift, and obedient to him in all things, earneftly and conftantly devoted to his fervice and honour, and filled with flrong, benevolent love to God, and to man ; is a thoufand times more the objecl: of his defire, and prayer, than to be affured, that he mall be faved. Therefore, he defires no other affurance of falvation, than that which is implied in fuch holinefs, as has been obferved. Indeed, the true chriflian, in the exercife of holy affection, or difinterefled benevolence to God and man, is feeking more important objects, and events, than his own falvation, and they have the firft place in his heart. He feeks firft the kingdom of God, and his righteoufnefs. On the contrary, the felfifh perfon, defires and feeks his own peifonal intereft, his own happinefs, as the moft i important and fupreriie good ; and if he can be affured of his own happinefs, he has all he wants. Therefore, when perfons prize and defire affurance of their own fal vation, more than holinefs, it is a fign that they are not true believers. 3. The true chriflian, can have joy and peace in be lieving, or the joy of faith, without affurance of falvation. The reafon of this has juft now been given, viz. that he defires and feeks, and confequently places his happinefs in better, greater and more important objects, than his Own faivation. He rejoices in the truth. In the truths contained CHAP. IV. On the Doftrinc ofEU&ion. 163 contained in divine revelation, in the divine charafter, in infinite wifdom, re&itude and goodnefs ; in the feli city and glory of God ; in the chara&er of Chrift, and the way of falvation for man, by him, &c. The felfifh perfon, feeking nothing but his own inter- eft and happinefs, can have no religious comfort and joy, any farther than he thinks himfelf fure, or hopes that he mall be faved. Therefore, his religious light and darknefs, his trouble or comfort, arife wholly from, or confift in his fears, that he is no chriftian, and fhall not be faved ; and in his hope and confidence that God loves him, and he fhall be faved. When this appears to be true of any perfon, it is a fign he is no real chriftian. 4. The hope and confidence of the true believer, that he is a chriflian, and fhall be faved, rifes and finks, accord ing to the degree of holy exercife, in love to God, &c. This has been illuflrated in this feclion. The hypocrite, can enjoy his afTurance without any holinefs, or concern about it. Therefore, the only right way to obtain afiurance of falvation, is to prefs forward in the exercife of holinefs, in every branch of it, fo as to befenjibly a friend to Chrift, and devoted to his honour and intereft. SECTION XII. On the DoStrine of "Election. W HAT has been faid in the fourth chapter of the fir ft part, on the decrees of God, includes and eftabliflies the do6lrine of particular election and this do6lrine has been fuppofed, and in a meafure brought into view, a M 2 number a&4 On the DoSrine of Election. PART II. number of times, in the foregoing fe&ions : But it is thought expedient, and of importance, that it (hould be more particularly confidered, explained, and vindicated. And this will be moft properly done in the chapter on the application of redemption, as this limits the applica tion, and points out thefubjeh to whom it is effe&ually applied, and who, in the iffue, receive the whole benefit of redemption. The doftrine of election imports, that God, in his eter nal decree, by which he determined all his works, and fixed every thing, and every event, that fhall take place to eternity, has chofen a certain number of mankind, to be redeemed, fixing on every particular perfon, whom he will fave ; and giving up the reft to final impenitence, and endlefs deftruflion. This do6hinemay be explained, and the evidence of the truth of it produced, by attending to the following proportions. I. MANKIND are entirely dependent on God, on his determination, and fovereign mercy, for falvation. All creatures depend on God for all the good they have. Their exiftence, and all their enjoyments, are the fruit o Jiis determination and appointment, which has made the difference between one and another, in every refpeL But man is, in a peculiar fenfe and degree, dependent on the fovereign will and pleafure of God, for falvation. He is utterly loft in fin ; not only infinitely guilty, and deferving to be deflroyed forever ; but wholly inclined to rebellion, and fixed in a difpofition to oppofe God, :n every method he can take, to recover and fave him, unlefs his heart be renewed by almighty power and grace ; to which favour, none have the lead claim, or can have, but are infinitely unworthy of it. And when the way was opened for the pardon and falvation of finful man.. CHAP. IV. On the Dottrint of Eletiion. 165 man, by what ihe Mediator had done and fuffered, con fident with the divine law and righteoufnefs ; yet none could be faved, unlefs they be renewed by the fpirit of God, and made willing in the day of his power. This therefore depends on the determination and purpofe of God ; and he " has mercy on whom he will have mercy, and whom he will, he hardeneth." God being under no obligation to fave any one of mankind, it mufl depend on his fovereign will, whether any fhould be faved : And if any, whether all, or only a part of mankind : And if cnly fomeof them, how many, and the particular perfons that fhould be the fubjects of this favour. This mud be determined by God ; for there is no other being that has a right to determine it, or that can do it ; and it is impofli. ble that God fhould not determine it. He is infinitely poweiful and wife, he knew what was befl to be done, and it wholly depended on him to determine and do, that which is on the whole, wifeft and befl. It belonged to him to de- cideand fix every thing refpe&ingthis matter, "whowork- ethall things according to the counfel of his own will." II. IT is infinitely beft, and moft defirable, that this fhould be determined by God. He only is infinitely wife and good ; therefore, whatever he determines fhall be done, and take place, is perfectly right, moft wife and beft. It is therefore, infinitely defirable, that he fhould order ever thing that takes place, and all events ; but more efpecially thofe things that relate to the eternal ex- iftence and endlefs happinefs or mifery of man, whether any fhall be faved, or all loft ; and if only a part of man kind be faved, how many, and what particular perfons, lhall be included in this nnmber. This is a matter of great importance, and not of indifference, whether this perfon fhall be faved, rather than another, and it requires infinite wifdom to determine it right, fo as to anfwer the befl ends. Were any creature to determine it, in any M 3 one i66 On the Dottrine of Ehttion. PART II. one inftance, efgecially, apoftate man, the event might be undefirable, and of infinitely evil confequence. Were man to decide it, independent of God, and were this poffible, it would be mod undefirable and infinitely dreadful to the wife and good ; and they rejoice that this important affair, with all others, is in the hand of him who is infinitely wife and good ; who has a right, and to whom it belongs to decide the Hate of every man, whether he fliall be faved, or not ; and that he has done it, by an unalterable decree. III. IT is certain from the fcripture, that God has determined not to fave all mankind ; but only a part, and a particular number of them. The Redeemer himfelf has declared this exprefsly, and it is abundantly alTerted in the Old Teftament, and in the New. A number are to go away into everlafl ing punifhrhent, where their worm dieth not, and the fire is unquenchable : And the fmoke of their torment, fliall afcend up forever and ever, &c. c.* Had not God revealed this, it could yict have been known what would be the event of re demption, whether all will be faved, or not : But God has made it known. We are not told in the fcripture, the precife number that fliall be faved; nor what proportion of mankind iv ill be of this number ; but from what is revealed, re- fpecling this matter, it is reafonable to fuppofe, that many more will be faved, than 3 oft, perhaps lome thou- fands to one.t But, be this as it may, we are certain that the number that ihall be faved, is fixed, by infinite wifdom and goodnefs, and every one of thefe is known unto * This has been particularly confidered, and proved, by a number of authors. See Dr. Edwards, againft Dr. Chauncy. And an Inquiry con. cerning the Future State of thofe who Die in their Sins. f See Dr. Bellamy, on the Millennium. And the foremen tioned Inquiry. Page 167, #c, CHAP. IV. On the Dottrine of Ektfion. 167 unto Ggd, and their names are written in the book of life, before the foundation of the world. We are alfp certain, that it is not owing to the want of goodnefs in God, or the infufEciency of the atonement and merit of Chrift, that all mankind are not faved ; for the latter is as fufficient to fave the whole human race, as part of them, or one individual ; and the only reafon why all are not faved, is, becaufe it is inconfident with infinite wifdom and goodnefs ; .that is, it is not for the greatefl general good. Infinite gqodnefs, in all cafes, and forever, oppofes and forbids that to take place, which is not for the greateft general good, be that what it may ; and ap proves and effects that which will anfwer the bed ends, and produce the greatefl good, in all cafes. We are as certain of this, as we can be, that there is an infinitely wife, good, and omnipotent Being. Therefore, fince God has declared, that he has determined, not to fave all mankind, we know that this is not confident with his goodnefs ; that is, that it is not wife ft and befl, or, which is the fame, it is not for the greateft good of the whole, that all fhould be faved. God, does not delight in the deftruclion of finners, in itfelf confidered, or for its own fake ; and not one would be fufFered to perifh, if ifc were confident with wifdom and goodnefs, to fave them all ; or if this were confident with the glory of God, or the greateft good of the univerfel Nothing can be more certain, than that all will be faved, that can be faved by omnipotence, clothed with infinite wifdom and good nefs ; that is, that can be faved confident with thefe. What is inconfiftent with infinite wifdom and goodnefs, cannot be done by a Beinginfinitely wife and good, though omnipotent. It is morally impojjible ; for he cannot deny himfelf, and a6l contrary to wifdom and gocdnefs. Any man may be abfolutely fure that he {hall be faved, if it be not inconfiftent with the goodnefs ofGod, to fave him, and, M 4 in 168 On the DoSriniof Ehttion. PART II, in this fenfe, impoflible ; or if it be confident with the greateft glory of God, or the general good. And who, in his fenfes ; that is, who that is wife and benevolent, would defire to be faved, or could afk for the falvation of any of his fellow men, unlefsthis might be confiftent with the glory of God, and the greateft good of the univerfe ? As we know not what number of mankind can be faved, confiftent with infinite wifdom and goodnefs, fo we are utterly incapable of judging, what particular per- Ibns can be faved, confiftent with thefe : But God has determined this, without a poffibility of any miftake. He knows what individuals of the human race can be iaved, confiftent with his glory, and the greateft good of his eternal kingdom ; and who cannot be faved confift ent with this, and has determined, and does aft accord* ingly. In this he a&s as a fovereign, as being under ob ligation to none, or not to one, more than to another ; but not arbitrarily, without any wifdom or reafon. There is a good reafon, why one mould be faved rather than another. There is a good reafon, why every one of thole fhould be faved, who are, or fhall be faved ; and why every one of the reft fhould not be faved ; from the different natural formation, or capacity, or the different circum fiances, to us unknown, and undefcribable, which render it wifeft and beft, moft for the glory of God, and the good of his kingdom, that the former fhould be faved, and the latter loft. This difference in circurn- ftances, &c. originates in the divine decree, and is order^ cd by God, according to the infinitely wife counfel of his own will ; but it is as real a difference, as if it had not this origin. JV. WE learn from the holy fcriptures, that a partic^ plar number of individuals are chofen from among man kind. CHAP. IV. On Ike Dottrint of Elettion. 169 kind, on whom the divine love and fovereign grace are to be difplayed, in their falvation. Reafon teaches us, that this muft be fo, as has been obferved ; for it muft be determined by God, and he makes the diftinlion between thofe who are faved, and thofe who are loft, as it cannot be done by any one elfe ; and if it were poflible, not to be determined by infinite wifdom and goodnefs, it would be infinitely difagreeable and dreadful to all the wife and good : And God deter mines all his works, all he will do from eternity. Ac cordingly the fcripture afierts this moft exprefsly and a- bundantly, in the following paffages, and in many others, which it will be needlefs to mention. The Redeemer often fpeaks of thofe who were given to him by the Fa ther, to be reedeemed and faved, as being a number fe- le&ed from the reft of mankind ; and fays they (hall come to him, and he will keep and fave them ; and his words ftrongly imply, that they only (hall be faved ; and that there never was a defign to fave any, but thofe who are thus felecled and chofen, and given to him, to be faved by him. Therefore he declares, that he does not pray for the falvation of any, except thefe ele6l ones, who were given to him. He fays, " Ail that the Father givcth me, fhall come to me : And him that cometh to me, I will in no wife caft out. And this is the Father's will which hath fent me, that of all which he hath given me, I fhould lofe nothing, but fhould raife it up again at the laft day."* " I lay down my life for the fheep. And other fheep I have which are not of this fold : Them alfo I muft bring, and they fhall hear my voice ; and there fhall be one fold, and one fhepherd. My fheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me : And I give unto them eternal life ; and they fhall never perifli, neither fhall any pluck them out of my hand, My Fa-* then * John vi. 37, 39, 170 On theDoSrine of Election. PART II. ther, which gave them to me, is greater than all ; and none is able to pluck them out of my Father's hand."* *' Fa ther, glorify thy Son, that thy Son alia may glorify jthee; as thou haft given him power over all flefh, that he fhould give eternal life to as many as thou haft given him. ] pray not for the world ; but for them which thou haft given me> for they are thine. And ail mine are thine, and thine are mine, and I am glorified in them. Holy Father, keep through thine own name, ihofe whom thou hafl given me, that they may be one as we are. Father, J will that they alfo whom thou haft given me, be with me, where I am, that they may behold my glory, which thou haft given me."t Could the doctrine of election be exprefled more fully and in a ftronger manner, by any words whatever ? That a particular number, of man kind, with every individual of that number, are chofen and felefted from the reft, and in the covenant of re demption given to Chri'ft, to be redeemed and laved by him ; and that, thefe alone are to be laved ? Agreeably to this, Chrift repeatedly (peaks of the cleft, whofe falva, tion is fecured ; and for whole fake, he orders the great events in the world. " And except that the Lord had fbortened thofe days, no flefh fhould be faved : But for the eletTs fake, whom he hath chofen y he hath Ihortened the days. For falfe Chrifts and falfc prophets (hall rife, and lhall fhow figns and wonders, to fedace, if it were poffible, even the very elect. And then he (hall fend his angels, and fhall gather together his elel> from the four winds." J The Apoftle Paul, reprefents the falvation of the re- deemed, as originating in the eternal purpofe of God, by which they are felefied from others ; and who, in con- fequerice of this choice and appointment, are faved. muft be fuppofed to read it with ftrong prejudices againft the truth, or with very wrong and falfe concep tions * aThcff. ii. 13. f jPet. i. r> a. 174 n the -Doftrine of Elc&ion. PART IL tions refpe&ing the fubje6l. To obviate and remove thefe, is the defign of fome part of the following. V. THE cleft are not chofen to falvation rather than others, becaufe of any moral excellence in them, or out of refpecl; to any forefeen faith and repentance ; or be caufe their moral character is in any refpel better than others. The difference between them and others, in this refpecl, whenever it takes place, is the fruit and con- fequence of their election, and not the ground and rea- fon of it. All mankind are totally finful, wholly lofl and undone, in themfelves, infinitely guilty and illde^ ferving. And all muft periih forever, were it not for elect ing grace ; were they not fele&ed from the reft, and given to the Redeemer, to be faved by him, and fo made vefTels of mercy, prepared unto glory. This is abund antly declared in fcripture. This is ftrongly aflerted in a paffage which has been mentioned. " For the chil dren being not yet born, neither having done any good or evil, that the purpofe of God, according to election, might ftand, not^ of works, but of him that calleth." In their election, they are predeftinated to be conformed to Chrift, in true holinefs, and not becaufe it is forefeen they will, of their own accord, be holy, and chofen to falvation for the fake of this. They are elected, through fan&ification of the fpirit unto obedience. Sanftification and obedience, are the confequence of their election, and the privilege to which they are chofen ; and not that out of regard to which they are chofen to falvation. The Apoftle tells the elect at Ephefus, that ekaing love found them dead in trefpafies and fins, as fmful as others, and as much the children of wrath. " But God, who is rich in mercy, for the great love wherewith he loved us> even when we were dead in fins, hath quickened us to gether with Chrift. By grace are ye faved, through faith ; CHAP. IV, On the Doftrin of Ekftwn. 175 faith ; and that not of yourfelies, it is the gift of God. Not of works, left any man ftould boaft. For we are his workmanfhip, created in Chrift Jefus, unto good works, which God hath before ordained, that we fhould walk in them."* Election is edo&rine of grace ; it is therefore called " The eleclioi of grace." '* Even fo then at this prefent time alfo, tiere is a remnant accord ing to the e 7 ?ffion of grace. Aid if by grace, then it is no more of works : Otherwife grace is no more grace. But if it be of works, then it is no Tiore grace : Otherwife work is no more work."t VI. THE cleft are not chofen to falvation, without holinefs and obedience, or whether they be holy, and obey Chrift, or not. This is afferted in the paffages which have been quoted. Thofe who are chofen to falvation, are predeftinated, or ordained, to be conformed to Chrift. They are elected to falvation, through fane- tification of the fpirit, unto obedience. Holinefs, is part of the falvation to which they are elected, and they can not be faved without it, which confifts in activity and obedience. Therefore, no perfon can have any evidence that he is elected, in any other way, but by making it evident that he is holy and obedient. This therefore detects the great miftake and delufion, in which they are, who fay, if they be elected, they fhali be faved, let them do what they will, and live and die in a courfe of allowed fin. No propofition can be more falfe than this : It is as contrary to the truth, as it would be for a man to fay, if it be appointed that I mould live feven years, I ftiall live, though I die tomorrow. Or if it be appointed that I fhall go to fuch a city, I fhali go, though I do not go, and never move out of the place in which I now am. This * Eph. ii. i lo. f Rom. xj 5^ 6, 176 On the Dofrinc of EkSion. PART II. This doctrine, therefo e, affords no encouragement to fin, or to be indifferent ;nd carelefs about holinefs, obe dience and favation : Fcr this is as certainly the road to hell, if continued in, as if .there were none elected to falvation ; and holinefl, and care, watchfulnefs, and diligence, in active obedience, are as reasonable, import ant, and neceffary, as if tlis doctrine were not true. VII. THE ufe of proper means, is as neceffary, in order to the falvation of the deft, as it would be, were none elected to falvation. As none are elected to falvation, without holinefs, or whether they be holy or not, becaufe this is a contradiction, and impoffible ; fo none can ex- ercife holinefs, and be obedient, without means ; for this is as great a contradiction as the other ; for it is the fame, as to fuppofe that a perfon may be holy and obedient, without knowledge, attention, and activity ; or without holinefs and obedience. Means are as neceffary, in or der to convert and fave the cleft, and their perfevering in holinefs, as they would be if they were not elected. This is illuftrated in the ftory of the fhipwreck of Paul, and thofe.with him. They were all elected to be faved from being loft at fea, and to arrive fafe on fhore. God had determined this in their favour, and revealed it to Paul, and he had publifhed it to them who were with him in the (hip. Yet when the feamen were about to leave the fhip, who only had fkill to manage it, " Paul faid to the Centurion, and to the foldiers, except thefe a- bide in the fhip, ye cannot be faved.''* They were e- lected to that falvation, and it was hereby made fure to them ; but this did not render means, and their activity ufelefs, for they were elected to be faved in this way, and in no other ; and therefore, their falvation was not polTible in any other way. And if the Centurion had laid to Paul, " If we are elected to be faved, though the feamen * Ab xxvii. 1. CHAP. IV. On the Dotfrine of Eltftion. feamen leave the (hip, or if we ufe no means to get to the land, and take no care or thought about it, and though every one of us do what he can, or what he pleafe, to drown himfelf, and all the reft," he would have fpoken contrary to reafon and truth. And there is as much encouragement to ufe means for the falvation of finners, as if there were none elected to falva- tion,and much more : For there would indeed be no encou ragement to ufe any means, or to do any thing, for the fal vation of any one, if none were elected to be faved : For if that were true, there would be no falvation for any. St. Paul, therefore, took his encouragement to travel round the world and preach, and go through great la bours and fufferings, from the doclrine of election, that he might be the means of faving fome of the elecl. He fays, " Therefore, I endure all things for the fake of the: deft, that they may obtain the falvation which is in Chrift Jefus."* And the Lord Jefus Chrifl, encoui> aged him to perfevere in preaching at Corinth, be- caufe he had much people in that city ; that i.% there were many elected to falvation in that city.t And there would be no reafon or encouragement for any perfon to ufe any means, or do any thing, in order to be faved^ if none were elected to falvation. VIII. THE doftrine of election, as it has been dated, does not reprefent God as a refptclcr of pcrfons, as fome have fuppofed. To have refpecl to perfons, is to regard and treat them differently, on the account of fome fuppofed or real dif-* ference in them or their circumftances, which is no real ground or good reafon of fuch different regard and treat-* ment. As when a judge regards, juftifies and rewards, one, rather than another, becaufe he is rich and the other poor, * a Tim. ii. 10, f A&s xviii. 9, to, VOL. II. N i;S On the Dotfrine of Zltrftion. PART II. poor, or has given him a bribe, or is a near relation of his, or his particular friend ; when the other is as really wor thy of regard, and his caufe more juft. This character, ofarefpecter ofperfons, belongs rather to a judge, or one who is to regard and reward others, according to their different characters, .which are the real ground, and a good reafon of making a difference. And is not applicable to a benefactor, in his granting favours, and free, undeferved gifts, to one, rather than another, where there is no defert of fuch favour, in one more than another; and the favour is not granted under any fuch notion or pretence. The benefactor, in this cafe, has a right to do what he will with his own, and bellow his gifts in fuch a manner, and on fuch perfons, as will befl promote his own benevolent purpofes, and the general good. And he who is neglected, and does not receive any favour, as he has no claim to any, has no reafon to complain. This leads to obferve, IX. No injury is done to thofe who are not elected, by the election of others to ialvation. No one of man kind has any defert of the lead favour ; but all the hu man race might juftly have been left in a ftate of ruin, to be loft and miferable forever, and no injury would have been done to any. In this cafe, the ihowing fa vour to one, and faving him, is no injury to the other, who has no favour, and is left to perifh ; he deferves this as much as if none were faved, and his cafe is not rendered the worfe, in any refpect, merely becaufe others do not fuffer with him, whadeferve it as much as he does. And if the actually making this difference, and laving Come, and leaving others to perifh, be no injury to the latter, and they have no caufe to complain, any more than if others perifhed with them ; then the determina tion to do this, and electing fome to falvation from eterni ty, CHAP. IV. On the Doflrinc of EUtfion. 179 ty, and not ele&ing all, is in no refpe& injurious to the noneleft, and is no ground of complaint. If a king, par don a certain number of thofe criminals who are juflly condemned to be put to death, and give the reft up to be executed, they all, equally deferving to die, he does no injury to the latter; they deferve to die as much, and their execution is as juft, as if all were put to death. Mercy being fhowed to others, gives them no claim to it, and they have no caufe of complaint, that the fame un- deferved favour is not fhowed to them. And it alters not the cafe, though the king had determined long be fore it took place, to fave fome of the criminals alive, and fixed on the individuals, on whom he would bellow this favour, in diftin&ion from the reft. X. SALVATION may be offered to all men, though only a certain number of them are chofen to faivation, and will be finally faved. It is not neceffary that all mould certainly be faved, and that this fhouid be known to be the event of making the offer of faivation to men, in order to make the offer of it to them, with propriety. Men may have the offer of faivation, or of any other good thing, though they re- fufe to accept of it, and fo never obtain it. This, it is prefumed, none will deny. Salvation may be offered to men, though it be certain, and known to God who makes the offer, that they will reject it, and fo never be faved. If faivation may be of fered to men, though they .refufe to accept of it, and their rejecting it be not inconfiftent with the offer being made, or tbeir having the offer ; then fuch offer may be made, though it be known, and certain, that they will rejeci it, and perifh ; for this being known, does not alter the cafe with refpecl: to the offer ; it is as really made, and as really rejecled, as if it were not known, but it were N 2 wholly i8<5 On the DoSrlne of EltSion. PART IT, wholly uncertain what the event would be. A rjch man may offer an eftate to a poor man, though he be certain that he will reject the offer, and die in poverty, as the confequence of his refufal to accept of the favour which is offered. And if the offer of falvation may be truly and proper ly made, when it is known to him who makes the offer that it will be rejected ; then it may be fo made and re jected, though the knowledge of this imply the divine purpofe and decree, refpecting the matter, or be founded upon it. The (inner is clifpofed to reject the offer of falvation, and will certainly reject it, unlefs his heart be renewed by the fpiritofGod: But he being under no obligation to the finner to do this, in any in (lance ; and his making the offer of falvation does not lay him under any fuch obligation, or infer it ; he may determine not to doit, by which it is certain, the (inner will not accept of it, and be faved. Notwithstanding this, the offer is really made, and the finner really rejects it, and is as vo luntary and criminal, as if nothing were determined and foreknown, refpe cling the event. Though Gocl have pow er to renew every (inner's heart to whom the gofpel is preached, and bring them all to embrace the gofpei, and "be faved ; yet he has determined not to do it : And his making the offer of falvation, does not imply that he will do it. Though a rich man offer an eflate to one that fs poor, ami it is in his power by forne extraordinary means and exertions to purfuade him to accept it : Yet his making tti.e oFcr lays him under no obligation to effect it, though lie know the confequence will be his rejecting it, and dying in poverty. He may have good reafon not to make thofe extraordinary exertions, and yet be fmcere in the offer, on condition he is willing to accept it ; .and the poor man has the eftate really offered to him, and he CHAP,. IV. On thiDofirint of Election.- 18* he as really rejects it, and is as foolifli and criminal in. doing it, and as juftly fuffers the evil confequence, as if the rich man knew not what would be the conference of making the offer, whether it would be rejected or not ; and had no power by any means, to perfuade him, and make him willing to accept of it. It is wife and important, that falvation by Chrifl fhould be offered indifcriminately to all, in the publim- ing and preaching of the gofpel, whether they will hear, or whether they will forbear. It has been obfervedyXhak the gofpel cannot be preached to any, to whom the offer of falvation is not made, upon their acceptance of it. They who will comply with the offer, or the el eft, who fhall come to Ch.rift, live promifcuoufly, intermixed with others 5 and are not to be diftinguifhed by men from others, until they have the gofpel preached to them, and thereby falvation is offered to them, and they believe and embrace the offer. Therefore, the gofpel cannot be preached to them, unlefs it be preached to all. And, as it may be" properly preached to all, and falvation be real ly offered to every one, whether he will accept of it, or not; and the-provifion made for the falvation of finners. in the gofpel, is as fufficient for one as another, and it is offered as a free gift, to every one who believeth, or will receive it : And none can fail of falvation, and periiri un der the gofpel, but by conftantly rejecting it to the end of life. Therefore, it is important and neceifary, that this gffer ihould be made to all, without any diftinclion, in order to the falvation of any, even the elect. Befidcs, this is neceffary in order to fet in the cleared light, and even to difcover, the following important truths. i. That mankind are fo fixed in their rebellion, and fuch obftihate oppofers and enemies of God, and all moral good, that they are difpofed conftantly, and with all their hearts, to reject, mercy and falvation, though N 3 freely 182 On thtDoftrine of Elettion. PART II. freely offered to them. Nothing is, or perhaps can be, more fuited, effe&ually to bring out and difcover the ex ceeding wickednefs and obftinacy of the heart of man, than this. It is of great importance, that a clear and full difcovery of this mould be made, in order to manifeft to their confidences, and to all, the juftice and propriety of the awful fentence which will be pronounced againft the wicked at the laft day. 2. That every one who fails of falvation under the gofpel, perifhes by his own fault and aggravated wicked nefs, obftinately perfifted in through life : And muft af- cribe his lofs of eternal life, and his falling into endlefs deftruftion, wholly to his own folly, and conftant volun tary rejecting falvalion, freely offered to him : That he has dtjlroyed bimfclf, and nothing could have prevented his falvation, and have brought endlefs deftru&ion upon him ; no decree of heaven, nor fatan, nor any of his fel low men ; nor his outward circumftances ; poverty or riches ; honours and high ftations ; or a mean and low condition in the world ; health or ficknefs ; or any temptation and trying lituation in life whatfoever ; had he not with all his heart rejected the gofpel, and con- ftantly, through his whole life, refufed to accept of the falvation which was offered to him ; for which folly and fin he has not the leaft poffible excufe. This coincides with the preceding particular, and ferves to {how, how important and neceflary it is, that they who perifh from under the gofpel, Ihould have fal vation offered to them, as by this it will appear more clearly, than otherwife it could, that finners perifh by their own fault, and can lay the blame of it to none but themfelves ; and that they are juftly caft into endlefs de- flruclion, however infinitely awful and dreadful it be. And this will ferve effectually to confute an affer- tion which many now make,, and mow the falfehooel of CHAP. IV. On the Doctrine of Election. 183 of it, viz. that if they be not defied, they mujl be damned, whatever they may do. It will appear, when the real truth comes to light, that they perifh by reje&ing the falvation offered to them ; and that if they had believed, and been willing to be faved by Chrift, they would not have been loft. Their deftrudion is the confequence of their great, inexcufable wickednefs, in flighting Chrift, and negleding the great falvation ; by which they have brought it on themfelves ; which could not have come upon them, had they not done this ; but accepted of the kind offer which they had. 3. The offer of falvation to all, ferves more clearly to difplay and difcover to the redeemed, than otherwife could have been, the riches of that fovereign grace, by which they are faved. It is of great importance, that this fhould be feen by the redeemed, in the cleared light, and to the belt advantage, that God may have the glory of it, and they the greateft benefit poflible. While they fee others perifh under the fame advantages which they have enjoyed; they fee what they fhould have done, had they not been diftinguifhed by fovereign grace, and made willing in the day of divine power. They fee the human heart a6led out in the unbeliever, and the awful confequence in his perifhing ; and know this would have been their cafe, had not God created in them a new heart, and given them to believe on Chrift, in confe quence of his electing love. They fee this, and give all the glory to fovereign grace, and in a greater degree, are happy in the enjoyment of the love of God. St. Paul was fenfible of the importance of chriftians feeing and enjoying the great and difHnguifhing love of God to them ; and of their giving all the glory to him and therefore, labours to fet this in the ftrongeft light, in the two firft chapters of his letter to the church at JEphefus, V 4 -as- 184 On the Doftrine of Elcfiion. PART II. as he alfo does in moft of his other epiflles, w/hich the attentive reader of the Bible mud have obferved. That the offer of falvation is in fal made to all to whom the gofpel is revealed, has been before proved.* And it may be added here, to the evidence there pro duced, that if there were no other proof of this, but the parables of Chrift, recorded in Math. xxii. and Luke xiv. thefe are fufficient to put it beyond difpute. There our Saviour represents the gofpel, by a feaft which is made, to which numbers are invited, who refufe to come, and confequently never tafte of the (upper. The invitation is, " Come to the feaft, come to the marriage, for all things are ready." How can this reprefentthe gofpel, if falvation be not offered to thofe who never accept of the offer ? But to return ; faivation is in fa&, offered to all, wherever the gofpel is publifhed. Some have fup- pofed this to be inconfiflent with the doclrine of elec tion, as it has been ftated ; but it is hoped, that what has been offered, has fufSciently proved that they are both confident with each other. XL THE doclrine of election, is fo far from being a difcouraging dodnne, that it aifords the only ground of all true encouragement and hope. Many have been fo grofsly miiiaken, as to think this a gloomy, difcouraging do&rine, and that it tends to lead perfons to defpair ; whereas, it is the only well grounded iupport againfl defpair, and the fole foundation of all reafonable hope of falvation. It does indeed, tend to cut off all their hopes of falvation, who build them upon themfelves, their own good difpofition, will and exertions, independent of God ; fuppofing they ftiall determine it in their own favour, and, in this fenfe, fave themfelves. The docirine of election, dernolifhes this foundation, and deltroys fuch a hope ; as it teaches, that man is abfolutely dependent _ Sse Part I!, Sett, VIII, Page 105, &c. CHAP. IV. On the Doffrine of Eltftion* 185 dependent on God for his falvation, and he muft determine whether he {hall be faved or not. As this, therefore, is a falfe hope, and dangerous delufion, it is deurable it fhould be deftroyed ; and it affords an argu ment in favour of this do&ine, that it tends to take away all fuch hope from man. When perfons are brought to know themfelves, in fbme meafure, and fee how guilty and loft they are, how finful and obflinate their hearts are, being wholly cor rupt, and fo ftrongly indifpofed to any thing that is right, and inclined to evil, that if left to themfeives, they never fhail repent and embrace the gofpel, but hall go on to certain deftru&ion : Therefore, if God, who has mercy on whom he will have mercy', have not de termined in their favour, that he will give them a new heart, and fave them by the wafhing of regeneration, and the renewing of the Holy Ghoft, they (hall not be faved $ but be certainly loft forever. They defpair of diftinguifn- ing themfeives, fo as to render thernfelves more deferving of the favour of God, and of falvation, or lefs illdeferv- ing, than others. They know of no greater fmners than themfeives, or more deferving of endlefs definition, or farther from embracing the gofpel, than they are, and aL ways fhall be, if left to themfeives. Their only hope therefore, is in the revealed purpofe of God to favefome of mankind, without any regard to their defers of it, or their diftinguifhing themfeives from others, not being fo great finners, or being lefs uriworthy ; but has merry on whom he will have mercy : And they have no reafon to conclude, they are not of .this number ; but may hope they are eleded to falvation, though utterly loft in them- felves, and the mo ft guilty and vile of all others. It is true, that fome have abufed this doctrine, and improved it to bad purpofes to themfeives, through their ignorance, the perverfenefs of their own hearts, and the cunning i, 8$ On the Qoftrint of EleSlon. P A R T I L cunning agency of fatan, the deceiver. They have not been willing to be in the hand of God, and wholly de pendent on him ; and the thought that they are fo, has irritated and galled their fpirks ; they have been fuch enemies to God, that they have concluded he will decide againft them, if it be left to him to determine, whether they (hall be favedornot ; and knowing they have great ly offended him, they conclude they are not among the jnimber of the elect, and fo fink into defpair. It is not the doctrine of election, or the belief of it, which pro duces this defpair, or has any tendency to it ; but the oppofition of the heart to it, and drawing a wrong and falfe conclufion from it : For this doctrine has a direct contrary tendency and effect, when properly improved, as has been fhown. XII. THE do&rine of election, is perfectly confident with the greateft poflible degree of human liberty. This has been particularly coniidered, in the chapter upon the Decrees of God, and need not be repeated here. Many have entertained fuch wrong notions of this doc trine, and of liberty, or the freedom of the will, as to fup- pofe, if this were true, the nonelect are chained down to deftru&ion ; and the elect fixed in a ftate of falvation, inconfiftent with their exercifing any freedom of choice. The divine purpofe of ele&ion, does not affect the liber ty of any man, unlefs the certainty of events be inconuft- ent with it. It is certain it is not, if liberty connfls in acting voluntarily, or in volition ; which it is prefumed, has been proved ; and that there can be no other or higher liberty in nature. The elect are perfectly free, in embracing the gofpel, and in all their exercifes, and in every (lep they take, in order to obtain complete fal vation. This is neceflarily fuppofed in their election to eternal life ; for they can be faved in no other way, but by CHAP. IV. On the Doftrine cf Election. 187 by their free choice, which is, therefore, fecured in their ele&ion, that they fhall go to heaven by their own free confent, in the full exercife of perfect liberty, in oppo- fition to any compulfion. Whatever God decrees or does, refpe&ing their falvation, does not interfere with their freedom ; but infallibly fecures and eftablifhes ir. He worketh in them, to will and to do : Therefore, doei nothing inconfiftent with their willing and doing, but promotes and effeh it; in which all their freedom and moral agency confift. The non cleft, go to dedru&ion by their own choice. When falvation is offered to them, they rejedl it with their whole heart, and mod freely choofe to have no part in it. They will not come to Chrift, that they might be faved. The election of others to falvation, does no affe them, or alter their cafe, orcircumftances, in the lead. They go to dedrudion jufl as freely, and as much by their oxvn choice, as they would, or could do, were there none ele&ed to be faved ; and their dedru6lion is not made any more neceffary, or certain, by the election of fome of mankind to falvation, than it would have been, xvere there no eledion. XIII. THOUGH it be known, that a certain number of mankind are elected by God, to falvation, in didin6Hon from others ; became it is revealed, and the reafon of the thing teaches it mud it muft be fo ; yet it cannot be known to men in this world, who they are that are elect ed, and (hall be faved, any farther than there is evidence that they embrace the gofpel, and are become true chrif- tians. This is otherwife known to God alone. Ke knows them by name, and they are given to Chrift, to be faved. [< The foundation of God ftandeth fure, having this feal, The Lord knoweth them that are his."* But this cannot be known to men, nor can there be the lead real * 2 Tim. :i. 15, i88 On the Doflrine of Ekclion. PART II. real evidence, till they come to Chrift, nor any ap pearance of it, any farther than they appear to be real chriftians. In this way, the Apoftle Paul judged of the ekftion of perfons. " Knowing, brethren beloved, your election of God. For our gofpel came not unto you in word only, but alfo in power, and in the Holy Ghoft, and in much ailurance. And ye became followers of me, and of the Lord, having received the word in much affii&ion, with joy in the Holy Ghoft/'* It is in this way alone that believers can come to the knowledge of their eledlion, or get the leaft evidence of it. This evidence will be perfectly eftablifhed, when they are actually faved, and iliall abide fo forever. Every one of the redeemed will know his own eledton of God, and that of all others who are faved ; and will look to this, as the fource and foun dation of their redemption. While the ele6l are in a flate of unbelief, none in this world, neither they themfelves, nor any one elfe, can know they are ele&ed, and (hall be faved : And the non eleft cannot know that they are not elected, nor can any one elfe know this of them, while they are in this world, unlefs it be known that they have committed the unpar donable fin. IMPROVEMENT, I. THE doQrine of election, as it has now been Hated and explained, is fuited to (lain and humble the pride of man-. The pride of man, prompts him to lift himfelf above his Maker ; and he would do it, were it poflible ; and many fondly think themfelves, in a meafure, independ ent of him j efpeciaily in matters of. the greated import-. ance ; refpecling their moral character, and their eternal istereii and happinefs; that their life is in their own hands,, TheT. i. 4, 5, $> CHAP. IV. On the Dottrine of Ele&ion. i9 hcinds, fo far that they can determine whether they {hall be virtuous and holy, and be faved, or not, without any deter mination of God, refpectingit, or his unprcrnifed, un.de- ferved, fjpecial influence, or alii (lance, to turn the point iu their favour. And nothing can be more crofling and mortifying to this pride, than to be abfolutely dependent on God for all moral good, as a free undeferved gift from him ; and for falvation, fo that the whole rouil be deter mined by God, and not by man, any farther than it is the effect of the divine determination. Such afftblute dependence on Gcd, for holinefs and falvation, is impli ed, and held forth in the doctrine of election ; and no man can underftandingly, and cordially receive it, fo as to have the feelings of his heart conformable to it, with- QUt. " Humbling himfeif in the fight of the Lord.*' Every doctrine of the gofpel, and the whole fyftem of revealed truth, is levelled directly at the pride of the hu man heart, and fuited to humble man ; and when it has its proper effect, and is cordially received, this pride is Haiti and relinquished ; and what God, by Ifaiah fore told, fhould be the effect of it, takes place in a very fen- fible, confpicuous degree. " The lofty looks ol man {hail be humbled, and the haughtinefs of men (hall be bowed down, and the Lord alone (hall be exalted, in that day."* Therefore, humility, in oppofmon to pride and felf exaltation, was frequently mentioned by our Divine Teacher, as eflential to a chriflian ; ?.nd he often faid, " Every one that exalteth himfeif, (hall be abafed : And he that humbleth himfeif, (hall be exalted. "T And the Apoftle James fays to finners, " Humble yourfeives in the fight of the Lord, and he fhall lift you up."J This is an evidence, among others, that the doctrine of election, is a doctrine of the gofpel, in that it coincides, in this refpect, with all the peculiar doctrines of divine revelation, * Ifaiah ii.u, rz. f SceMatth.xviii. 4, xxiii.i*.-Luke,xiv, ir.xvm, 14, James iv. 10. igo On the Do&rine of EleEiion. PABLT II. revelation, in being fuited to humble the pride of man, : and exalt the fovereign grace of God ; and therefore muft be agreeable to the heait of every humble chriftian. In this view, it is no wonder that it fhould be fo ftrongly oppofed, and rejected with great abhorrence and confi dence, by men, with all the other moft humbling- doc trines of the gofpel ; and a fcheme of fentiments be in troduced in their room, which are really fubverfive of the gofpel, and fuited not to abafe, but to flatter and gratify the pride of man ; according to which he has lomething^ which he did not receive, even true virtue and holinefs, the higheft excellence and glory of man ; and by this has made himfelf to differ from others, without any fpeciai diftinguiming influence of God ; and in this refpecl; is independent of him ; which he therefore afcribes not to the grace of God, but to himfelf, and glories in it. The following fentence of St. Paul, is leveled at this pride and haughtinefs of man, and if properly regarded, fuffi- cient to demolifh it. tc Who maketh thee to differ from another ? And what haft thou that thou didft not receive ? Now if thou didft receive it, why doft thou glory as if thou hadft not received it ?"* The humbling doctrine of election, may be, indeed, abufed, and fo improved as to gratify the pride of man, while it is not really underftood, nor in truth cordially received. A man may be led to conclude, even from the pride of his heart, and without any reafon, that he is elected to falvation, and herein diftinguifhed by God, from moft others ; and this may be very pleafmg to his pride, while he does not underftand, and in his heart admit the only ground of this diftin&ion, when made by God : And he, at bottom, feels as if he was diftinguifhed from others, and had received this peculiar favour, out of refpecl to fome good thing in him, by which he dif fered from others. Or he attends only to the diJlinRion x Gor. iv, 7. CHAP, IV. On the Doftrine of Elcffion. itfelf, without considering the ground of it, and is pleafed with this, and becomes a zealous, proud advocate for the doftrine of election. Therefore, many of the oppofers of this doctrine fuppofe, that all who are advocates for it, are pleafed with it, only from felfiftmefs and pride, be- caufe they confider themfelves as the cleft of God, and hereby diflinguifhed and favoured above others. And there is, peihaps, no other way for pride to account for it, or to be reconciled to it. The true chriflian receives k, as glorious to God, and exalting fovereign grace, and humbling man, while he confiders himfelf as infinitely guilty and vile, and wholly loft in his (ins, and if he be faved, it muft be by the diftinguifhing, fovereign grace of God, who has mercy on whom he will have mercy, ac cording to his decree of ek&ion, which affords, the only- ground of hope to man. II. WHAT has been fa id in this fe&ion, on the doc trine of particular election, may ferve to difcover and 'ilate the character of a true chriftian, fo far as his views and exercifes relate to this do&rine, and thofe conneded with it. 1. This is not a difcouraging doctrine to him, nor difagreeable, though he do not know that he is a chrif tian, or is elected to falvation ; but has great and pre vailing doubts of this. He knows that if he were left to himfelf, he iliould not determine the point in his own favour ; but his impenitent, unbelieving heart, would reject Chrift, and he go on to deftru&ion. That he is wholly dependent on God for falvation, and if he do not determine in his favour, and have not elected him to faivation, and do not diftinguifh him from others, by granting him thofe influences, and that renovation, which they who perifh have not, he fhall not be faved, but periih forever. Therefore, the do&rine of e!eHon can On the Doftrine of Ekttion. PART II. can be no matter of difcouragement to him, it cannot render his cfefe worfe, than it would be if none were ele6fc- ed : for then he could, have no hope of falvation ; and the only hope he can have is grounded on this do&rine, and that he may be one of the ele&. And his hope rifes or links according to the evidence he has of this, by perceiving himfelf to be the fubjecl: of the regenerat ing, fanftifying influences of the Holy Spirit : Or the contrary. 2. The true believer is pleafed, with being entirely dependent on God for his falvation, and that he mould determine whether he fhall be faved or not ; and does not defire, that he himfelf or others, fhould be faved in any other way, but according to the eternal purpofe of God. It is moft difagreeable to him, that any creature fhould determine this, in any one inflance. He knows it belongs to God, to decide this important matter; that he has a right to do it, and he only is able to determine it perfectly right, agreeable to infinite wifdom and good- nefs, fo as fhall be moll fpr his glory, and promote the intereft of his kingdom. He is pleafed, that in this way, God is exalted, in the exercifeof fovereign grace, and the finner humbled, and the moft important intereft forever fecured and promoted in the beft manner. He delires no other falvation, for himfelf or others, but that which is the free gift of God, and the fruit of his electing love ; and which infinite wifdom fees will be moft for the glory of God, and the general good ; and that without knowing whether his falvation be confident with this, or not, and ivhether he be one of the cleft, or not. 3. All the chriftian's prayers and devotions are upon this plan, and agreeable to this doclrine. They contain in them, cither an exprefs or implicit acknowledgment of his entire dependence on God for falvation, and every thing, for which he prays or gives thanks ; and that all the CHAP. IV. No Man is without Sin, 6?c. 1(33 the good he defires, muft be the fruit of the determina tion of him, who changes not in his purpofe and defign ; and exprefs, or imply, an unconditional, implicit refig- nation to his wife and holy will. The oppofers of this doctrine, in heart and words, do often really acknowledge it in words, in their prayers to God for falvation, &c* But the real chriftian does it with his heart. He may indeed, through the prejudices of education, or otherwife, by not underftanding the doc trine in theory, and entertaining wrong conceptions of it, and of other points, which are connected with it, be led to oppofe it, in fpeculation ; but fo far as his heart is renewed, all his religious exercifes and devotions, are agreeable to the do6trine of election, and an acknowledg ment of it. And fo far as it appears, that any perfon is at heart an enemy to that doctrine ; there is juft fo much evidence that he is an enemy to him who worketh all things after the counfel of his own wilL SECTION XIII. Whether any of the Redeemed arrive to Perfeft Holinefs in this Life. HAT no man, whatever his advantages and at tainments may be, does arrive to finlefs perfection in this life, feems to be clearly afferted in a number of paffages of fcripture. Solomon fays^ " There is no man that finneth not. There is not a juft man upon earth, that doeth good, and finneth not. Who can fay, I have made my heart clean, I am pure from my fin ?"* Thefe are ftrong expreflions, afferting, that there is no man oii earth i Kings viii. 46. Eccl. vii. 20. ProVt xx. 9. VOL. II. Q are No Man is without Sin PAR.T If * earth fo perfect, as to be wholly without (in. Job fays, " If I fay I am perfect., it fhall alfo prove me perverfe."* How could his laying, he was perfect, prove him to be perverfe, unlefs it be on this ground, that no man is per fect in this life ? This being certain, if a man fay he is perfect, it proves that he is deceived, and knows not the truth, and therefore, is not a good man. The Apoftle Paul, who probably was the bolieft man that ever lived, declares he was not perfect. " Not as though I had al ready attained, or were already perfect ; but I follow after, if that I may apprehend that for which alfo I am apprehended of Chrifl^efus. Brethren, I count not rnyfelf to have apprehended : But this one thing I do^ forgetting thofe things which are behind, and reaching forth unto thofe things which are before, I prefs toward .the mark, for the prize of the high calling of God in Chrift Jefus."t And he gives fuch a particular and fad defcription of his own iinfulnefs, in his letter to the church at Rome, that many who are Grangers to the corruption of the human heart, and the great degree of fin attending true chriftians, and their keen fenfibiiity of it, cannot believe that he means there to defcribe his own exercifes and character, or thofe of any chriftian.J And this fame Apoflle reprefents all chriflians, as in a flate of warfare, by reafon of evil inclinations and lufts in their hearts, which oppofe that which is the fruit of the fpirir, in them, and prevents their doing what they would. *' The flefh lufteth againfl the fpirit, and the fpirit again ft the fleih : And" thefe are contrary the one to the other ; fo that ye cannot do the things that ye would." To will was prefent. When they look ed forward, they wished actually to do and be all that which chriilianity dictates, and of which they could have any idea ; but when they came to act, they always: fell ' * Job ix. 20. f Phil. iii. n, 13, 14- J See Fora. vii. 1424. ^.Gal. v^ 17. CHAP. IV. in this Life. fell fhort, and finful inclinations prevented their doing as they defired, and defiled their beft exercifes. The Apoftle James teftifies to the fame truth. He fays of himfelf, and of all chriftians, that in many things, they all offended.* And the Apoftle John fays, " If we fay, we have no fin, we deceive ourlelves, and the truth is not in us."t Here it is not only aflerted, that every chriftian is attended with fin, in all he does in this life : But that it is fo evident to the real chriftian, and fo much his fenfible burden and unhappinefs, that it is certain, that he who -fays, or thinks, he has no fin, is not only greatly deceived ; but is a ftranger to real chrif- tianity, and knows not the faving truth. Thefe paffages offcripture are decifive, and prove that it is made certain by a divine conftitution, that no man fhall be without fin in this life : For thefe are declara tions from God, of this truth. Solomon could not fay, " There is no man that finneth not There is not a juffc man upon earth, that doth good and finneth not ;" if there were not a divine conftitution, which rendered it certain, that the moft righteous, and beft of men, are not without fin, in this life : For this is affirmed of man, of every man in this world, in every age of it, from the be ginning to the end of it. How could the Apoftle Paul fay to a chriftian church, " The flefti lufteth agairift the fpirit, and the fpirit againft the flefh. And thefe are contrary the one to the other ; fo that ye cannot do the things that ye would :" And how could the Apoftles John and James fay, " If we fay we have no fin, we de ceive ourfelves, and the truth is not in us In many things we all offend ;" if this were not true of all, and common to all chriftians, at all times ? It is impoflible they fhould fay this under infpiraticn, were there not a known conftitution of heaven^ that no man Ihould be O 25 free * Jam, iii, a, i $ohn i, 8, A r o Man is without Sin PART IT. free from fin, in this life. Therefore, thefe declarations demonftate that there is fuch a conftitution : That God has determined, and made it known, that no man fhall live in the body, without finning. Hence we may be certain, that when the Apoftle John fays, " Whofoever abidethin him, finneth not : Whofo- cver finneth, hath not feen him, neither known him. Whofoever is born of God, doth not commit fin : For his feed remarneth in him ; and he cannot fin, becaufe he is born of God ;."* he does not mean to affert, that every true chriftian, or any one of them, is free from fin in this life : For then he would exprefsly contradict himfelf in this fame letter. But his meaning in the laft quoted paffages, muft be, That he who is born of God > and united to Chrift by faith, does not fin as others do > or as he did before he was born of God. He no longer lives in fin, and makes it his trade and bufinefs, as the unregenerate do ; but lives a holy life, devoted to Chrift y though attended with much imperfection and Gn. If this be not his meaning, which is a natural and eafy one, he not only contradicts what he had faid in the words quoted from the firft chapter, by aliening that chriftian* may live without fin in this world : Butafierts that every one that is born of God, does not, from that time, com mit one fin, or have the leafl degree of fin in his heart or cOnduft : Which few or none of thofe who have made ufe of thefe paffages, to prove chriflians may be perfeclly holy in this life, do believe is true ; fo that thefe words prove too much, or nothing at all, for them. Chriflians are frequently reprefented as being perfeff, in diftinction from thofe who are not real chriflians, or from other real chriftians, who are not p erf eft. This has been improved as an argument, that fome chriftians do obtain finlefs perfection, in this life, fuppofing that this is intended by being perfect. But the careful reader of the * Chap. iii. 6, 9, CHAP. IV. in this Life. 197 the Bible, will find, that to be ptrjett has a various and different meaning, when ufed with refpect to different fubjects and relations. When uied with refpect to God, it means abfolute perfection, in which fenfe it is not appli cable to any creature ; efpccially to man in this ftate. When applied to chriflians, it fometimes means real fincerity and uprightnefs of heart, or their being real chriflians, or good men, in diflin&ion from thofe who are fo only in appearance and pretence. In this fenfe Hezekiah appears to ufe it, when he fays, " Remember now, O Lord, how I have walked before thee in truth, and with a perfect heart."* And in this fenfe God fpeaks of Job as a perfect and upright rnan.t Job him- felf ufes the word in a different fenfe, when he fays, " If I fay I am perfect, it would prove me perverfe.J Other- wife he would contradict his Maker, and himfelf too ; for he held his integrity fail, and appealed to God that he was upright.^ Sometimes it means, whole and entire chriflians, acting out every chriflian grace, or every branch of chriflianity, in diflin&ion from thofe who were defective in fome chriflian attainments, while they appeared to be chiefly attentive to others. And fome times they are called perfect, who have made greater pro ficiency in the chriflian life, and are ftronger and more thorough chriflians, in diflin&ion from the weaker, and thofe of lefs attainments. He who carefully fludies his Bible, will find, that chriflians are not faid to be perfect in any higher fenfe than thefe. The Apoflle Paul, in a forecited place, fays, that he did not think himfelf perfect ; yet in the very next words fpeaks of himfelf and others as being perfect. " Let us therefore, as many as be per- fett, be thus minded. "H He mufl ufe the word in two different fenfes, otherwife he would contradict himfelf. When he fays, he does not think or pretend that he is O 3 perfect, * Ifaiah xxxviii. 3. f Job i. 8. % Chap. ix. ao. $ Chap. xxxL 6. jj Phil, jii. j;, 13, 14, 15. 198 No Man is without Sin PART II. perfect,- he means finlefs perfection. < When he fays, " As many of us as be perfect." He means thofe who had made confiderable improvement, and advances in chriftianiry ; not being, in this refpaft, babes or children, but grown men.* It is certainly the duty of all chriftians to be perfectly holy, in obedience to the law of God, requiring them to love God with ail their heart and foul and mind and ftrength ; and their neighbours as themfelves. And every thing contrary to this, or fhort of it, which takes place in their hearts or lives, is criminal. The law can not be abated, nor their obligation to obey ic perfectly, annulled in the lead degree. But it does not follow from this, that any one does, or will, come up to the rule, and do the whole of his duty, in this life. For this the chriflian depends wholly upon God. He is no farther holy, than he is made fo by the omnipotent energy of the 'divine fpirit ; and though God requires them to be perfectly holy ; yet he is under no obliga tion, by promife, or any other way, to make them per fectly holy, in this world. His requiring it of them, does not imply any fuch obligation, and the covenant of grace contains no promife of this. In that there is a divine promife, that they mail perfevere in holinefs to the end of life; and that they fliall be perfectly holy in his kingdom forever ; for this is neceifarily implied in perfect happinefs and eternal life. But it contains no promife of any particular degree of holinefs, more than is neceffary to prevent their falling totally and finally, from a ftate of grace. As to the degree of holinefs and the particular exercifes of it, in every chriflian, God or ders it as he pleafes, toanfwer his own wife and infinitely good purpoies. The Redeemer is able to make every believer perfectly holy, from his firft converfion, fo that he never fliould be * See Keb. v. 13, 14. OHAP. IV. in this Life. be guilty of another fin. And iFthis had been wifeft and bed, it. would have been fo ordered. Therefore, we are certain, it is moil wife and heft, that none of the redeemed mould be perfectly holy in this life, though we were unable to fee any reafon why it is fo. But we may now fee fome of the wife ends which are anfwered hereby, and reafons why the redeemed are in fuch an imperfect flate, and in fo great a degree finful, while in this world; a few of which will be mentioned here. 1. If they were perfectly holy, they would not be fo. fit to live in this difordered, finful world. There would not be that analogy of one thing to another, which is obferved in the works of God, and which is proper and wife. This is not a world and ftate fuited to be the dwelling place of perfedtly holy creatures. It is a proper ftate of difcipline, fuited to form and train up the re deemed from among men for a ftate of perfect holinefs and happinefs, in another world. 2. If chriftians were perfectly holy in this life, it would not be fo much a ftate of trial, as now it is. Their temptations could not be fo many and ftrong, as now they are ; and fatan could not have fo much power and advantage to tempt, and try .todiftrefs and feduce them. And their danger would not be fo great and vifible. And they would not have that opportunity or occafion of the exercife of fome particular graces, fuch as conftant humiliation and repentance for their renewed fins, loath ing and abhorring themfelves, fighting agatnft and morti fying their own lufts, longing for deliverance, and faith and patience, in thefe dark and difagreeable circum- ftances, as now they have ; by which they honour Chrift, and are preparing for greater happinefs and rewards in his kingdom. 3. Such a ftate of imperfection and fin, is fuited and ne- cefTary, more effectually to teach them, and make them O 4. know, SCO No Man is without Sin PART II. know, by abundant experience, their own total depravity by nature ; the evil nature and odioufnefs of fin ; their own ill defert ; the exceeding, inexprefiible, and incon ceivable deceitfulnefs, obftinacy and wickednefs of their own hearts ; and their abfolute dependence on fovereign grace, to prevent their eternal deftruction, and to fave them; their need of the atonement which Chrift has made ; and the greatnefs of that power and grace which faves fuch creatures. Thefe, and many other things, are more thoroughly and effectually impreffed on their minds, and they are inftructed, and learn them to better advan-*. tage, in the fchool of Chrift, in this ftate of imperfection and (in, than could be, in a flate of perfect holinefs. King David, by falling into fin, was led to reflect up on, and confefs his native depravity; the exceeding evil of fin, as againft God ; his defert of deftruction, and the juftice of God in puniQiing him ; his need of pardon, and of an atonement, and of the renovation of his heart, and his dependence on God for this. On that occafion, the following is his language. " According to the mul titude of thy tender mercies, blot out my tranfgreflions. Wafh me thoroughly from mine iniquity, and cleanfe me from my fin ; for I acknowledge my tranfgreffion, and my fin is ever before me. Againft thee, thee only have I finned, and done this evil in thy fight : That thou mighteft be juftified when thou fpeakeft, and be clear when thou judgeft. Behold ! I was fhapen in iniquity, and in fin did my mother conceive me. Create in me a clean heart, O God, and renew a right fpirit within zne."* 4. Believers, by being fanctified but in part, and at tended with fo much fin in this life, obtain a more clear view, and greater fenfe of the evil of fin, and the miferable ftate of the finner ; and are hereby prepared to know and enjoy the happinefs of a perfectly holy ftate, to a greater degree, * Pfal. li. 1,2,3,4,5,10, CHAT-. IV. MI this Life. 201- degree, than otherwife they could : The more fenfible they are of the evil from which they are delivered, the greater will the pofitive good, which they enjoy, appear to them. And their gratitude and praife for the fover- eign grace, of which they are the fubjects, will rifepro- portionably higher; by which God will be more glori fied, and they more happy forever ; fo that all this will turn to their good in the end, and they will be much more happy, than if they had been perfectly holy from their converfion ; and had not, after that, gone through a ftate of conflict with fin and fatan ; and through much tribulation, entered into the kingdom of heaven. 5. By this, the power, wifdom, goodnefs, truth and faithfulnefs of the Redeemer, are in a peculiar manner, exercifed and difplayed, as they could not be, in any other way. This gives occafion and opportunity, for the rnoft apparent and glorious manifeftation of thefe ; by which he glorifies himfelf, and the happinefs of the redeemed is greatly advanced. Therefore it is, on the whole, mod wife and bed, that the work of fanctification mould be gradual, and not perfected at once ; and that the faints mould be fanctified but in part, while in this world, and attended with much imperfection and fin to the end of life; The exceeding greatnefs of the power of God, is ex* erted and difplayed, in renewing the depraved heart of man, and forming it to true holinefs.* It is a power which fubdues the obftinacy, and ail poffible oppofition of the human heart ; and which overcomes and cafls out fatan, and all his hofl of combined enemies to God and man. Therefore, this is a greater exertion of power> than that by which the natural world was made ; for that was formed out of nothing : Therefore, there could be no oppofition and refiflance to creating power, in that inftance. And the power difplayed in creating holinefs, appears * Eph. i. 19. 202 No Man is without Sin PART II. appears as much greater, and more excellent, than that which is exerted in creating the natural world, as the . former effect is greater, more important and excellent, than the latter. But this power, is made more confpicuous and fenfi- ble, in prefei ving and maintaining a fmall degree of ho- Jinefs in. the heart of achriftian, in the midftof theoppo- lition, v/iih which he is furrounded and afTaulted, by the ftrength of evil propenftties within him, by the world, and by fatan, than it would be, in forming him to perfect holinefs at once. In this way, the weak chriftian, in the midft of firong temptations, and potent enemies, con- ftan.tl)' fecking, and exerting all their power and cun ning, to devour arid deftroy him, is .preferred and up held, through a courfe of trial, by the mighty > omnipo tent hand of the Redeemer and the liule fpark of holi nefs, implanted in the believer's heart; js continued alive and burning; while there is fo much, both within and without, tending to extinguifli it ; which is really more of a conflant miracle, and manifestation of the power of Chrift, than it would be to preferve a little fpark of fire, for a courfe of years, in the midfl of the fea, while the mighty waves are fiercely dafhing againft it, and upon it, attempting to overwhelm and extinguish it. The chrif tian is, by this fituation, and his experience, made more and more fen fi ble of this, and learns that he lives by tho power of Chrift, and repairs to this, that he may be * f Strong in the Lord, and in the power of his might,'* or his mighty power, that he may be able to ftand, and perfevere in the midfl; of enemies.* Out of weaknefs, he is made ilrong, and becomes valiant in the fphitual combat. t And Chrift, by thefe babes and fucklings, or. dains and difplays ftrength, and perfects praife. To this the Apoftle Paul attefts. " My ftrength is made perfect in weaknefs. * Eph. vi. io. f Heb. xi. 34. CHAP. IV. in this Life. 203 weaknefs. Mofl gladly therefore, will I rather glory in tny infirmities, that the power oj Chnft may rtjl upon me. 3 "' The wifdom of the Redeemer is alfo employed and manifefted, in carrying all believers, and the church mili tant in general, through this life, and to the end of the world, fafe to a flate of perfection in glory. He con- duels all things, exlernai and internal, with refpect to every chndian; and fo orders the degree, manner and time of his influence and abidance, as to keep them fjorn failing totally and finally ; and carries on the work of fan&ification in the wifeft manner, and fo as to defeat fatan in all his wiles and cunning devices, by which he attempts to feduce and -deflroy them. It requires infinite ikili and wifdom, to fanctify a corrupt b^eart, and to or der every thing fo, with refpecl; to each individual, at all times, and every moment, as effectually to prevent his falling away, though he walks upon the verge of ruin, and has fuch (bong enemies within him, and without : And fo adjufl every circuinftance, fhat even thofe things and events, which feetn to be calculated for his ruin, fliail promote his holinefs and falvation. Were there no inch perfons, weak and very imperfect; and finful, to live in a world full of enemies, and to be conducted on .through all dangers, in the mid ft of cunning enemies, having great {kill, and luccefs in deflroy irrg men, and car^ ried fafe to heaven at lad, there would be no opportuni ty f$r fuch exercife and difplay of infinite, unfearchablc wifdom, as this gives. Were not the Redeemer as wife as he is powerful, no chriilian could be faved ; but on his wiidom they may and do rely with confidence, com fort and joy. In his hands they, and the whole church, are fafe, and all adverfe things {hall work for good, and ifTue in their perfection in holinefs, and eternal falvation. And well may they, with admiration, exclaim with the Apoflle Paul : " O the depth of the riches, both of the wifdom * a Corvxii. 9. 20 1 No Ma* is without Sin PART 1L tvifdom and knowledge of God ! How unfearchable arc Jiis judgments, and his ways paft finding out !"* And in Leaven they will afcribe WISDOM to the Redeemer forever, t The goodnefs, tender love, and wonderful condefcen- fion of the Saviour, are alfo manifeft, and a&ed out, in his conftant and kind attendance on believers, though they be fo imperfect and finful, and offend in fo many things ; and are conftantly guilty of that, which would be fufficient to provoke him to give them up to fin and ruin, were he not infinitely good and kind : There is much more op portunity to exercife and difcover this goodnefs and con- defcending grace, forbearance and long fuffering, than if they were perfectly innocent and holy, from the time of their converfion. This remark is illuftrated by the charac ter and conduct of the truedifciples of Chrift, when he was on earth, in the human nature ; and his goodnefs, conde- fcenfion and forbearance, towards them. They had, and difcovered, much felfimnefs and pride, worldiinefs, ingrati tude, ilupidity and unbelief. They were flow of heart to be lieve, to learn and get underftanding, under the teaching of Chrift, and in hisfchool, while he was fo abundant in his labours with them. They were honeft, and true friends to their mafter, but did not improve the advantages which they had, as they ought to have done ; and in many in- ftances grofsly abufed them : Yet Chrift did not leave off his kindnefs to them ; but bore with them, in all their dullnefs and wickednefs, and loved them unto the end; and took effectual methods to cure all of them, of their great moral diforders, and prepare them to enter into a fiate of perfect holinefs at death ; except Judas the traitor, who never was a true difciple. Had they been perfectly holy, from the time they commenced his dif- ciples, or at any time while he was with them, there would pot have been fuch occaflon and opportunity, for Chrift to * Rom. xi. 33. f Rev. v* ia CHAP. IV. in this Life. 05 to exercife and difcover, fuch condefcending grace, and long fufFering towards them. Thus he treats all his true difciples, while in this life. Their imperfections and (ins, and froward difpo- fitions, by which they abufe him, in all his goodnefs to them, call for infinite condefcenfion, grace and forbear ance, in the continuance of his loving kindnefs to thenu They are, in fome meafure, fenfible of this, while in this world, and lament their finful defects, and great wicked- nefs, and admire the goodnefs and patience of the Re deemer, in bearing with them, and notcafting them into hell ; but dill continue very far from what they know they ought to be. But in heaven, they will fee this in a more clear light, and forever remember, and with the mod fenfible gratitude, admire and adore the condefcen- lion, and wonderful grace, which the Saviour exercifed towards them, while they were fo ftupid, perverfe and abulive. This could not take place, were real chriftians perfectly holy in this life. The truth and faithfulnefs of the Redeemer, are alfo by this, tried, and madeconfpicuous. He promifes, that- he will never leave nor forfake, or cafl out them, who come to him, and enter into covenant with him. And he fulfils his word, and is faithful to them, though they are in fuch an awful and provoking degree, perverfe and abuQve. Though they fall, they fhall not be utterly call, down ; for the Redeemer upholdeth them with his hand.* When they tranfgrefs, be often vifits their (in with a rod s and their iniquity with (tripes. He chaflifeth them, for their profit, that they may be partakers of his holinefs^ yet he will not utterly take away his loving kindnefs from them, nor fuffer his faithfulnefs to fail.t Thus the wifdom and goodnefs of God appear, in or dering it fo, that no man, eve# the greateft faint, (hall be "perfectly * Pfal. *xxvii, *4 t Pfal. Isxxix. 2 0$ No man is without Sin PART IL perfectly holy in this life ; but all the redeemed, ftiall, in this world, be very imperfect and finful, from the rea- fons which have been mentioned, and the ends which are anfwered hereby. More might be thought of and mentioned ; and there is no reafon to think, that the one half, are difcernedby us now. A clear and full view, of the wifdom and goodnefs of God, in this, is referved to the future Hate, when the redeemed will review all the difpenfations of heaven, and the wife counfel and works of him, who is " Wonderful in counfel, and excellent in working,'* towards themfelves, and the church, with wonder, gratitude, and everlafting joy, " Saying, with a loud voice, Worthy is the Lamb that was flain, to re ceive power, and riches, and wifdom, and ftrength, and honour, and glory, and blefling. Eleffing, and honour, and glory and power, be unto him that fitteth upon the throne, and unto the Lamb, forever and ever."* But though the wifdom and goodnefs of God appear, in ordering it fo, that no man in this life mall attain to fmlefs perfection ; and that the church on earth mould by paffing through a ftate of difcipline, trial and tempta tion, be trained up for a perfectly holy and happy ftate in heaven ; and that this mall be the common lot of chrif- tians : Yet for equally wife reafons, there are fome ex.. ceptionSj with refpect to the latter : Some are taken out of the world immediately, or foon after their conversion, and are made perfectly holy, without paffing through a Icene of trial, temptation, and Gnful imperfection. The thief, who was converted on the crofs, is an inftance of this : And how many are converted on their death bed, and juft before they pafs into the invifible world, cannot be certainly determined by us, while in this ftate. And all the infants who ar^ faved, are inftances of this. IT * Rev. v. i* 1. CHAP. IV. in this Life. 207 IT has been a queftion with fome, Whether chriftians ought to pray that they may be perfectly holy, in this life ? Some have thought this queftion muft be anfwered in the affirmative, and that believers may, and ought to pray for perfect holinefs, while in this world ; fince it is their duty to.be perfectly holy, and it is deferable ; and therefore ought to be defired : And confequently, they may and ought to pray for it. ANSWER. It is, in itfelf confidered, deferable to be perfectly holy ; and this muft appear defirable to all chriftians, viewed in and by itfelf. . But as God has de termined and declared this fhall not be, that no man fhall be without fin, in this life ; and therefore it is known, that it is not, on the whole, beft that any man fhould be perfectly holy, in this world ; in this view of it, it is not defirable ; nor ought any to pray for it. An event which is contrary to the known will of God, that it fhould take place, is not defirable, in this view of it, and no one ought to pray that it may take place ; for fuch a defne and prayer is oppofition to the declared will of God, and carries in it real rebellion againft him. No man ought to pray for any thing without an en tire refignation to the will of. God ; therefore, he ought not to pray for any tiling, biU on fuppofition that it is agreeable to the will of God. But no fuch fuppofition can be made, when God has already declared it is not agreeable to his will to grant it. It has been proved, that God has revealed that it is not his will, that any man fhall be perfectly holy in this life ; therefore, no man can, in this view of it, pray for perfect holinefs, while in this life, with refignation to the will of God 5 and therefore ought not to pray for it. This would be pray ing for that, which is known not to be defirable, and not wifeftand beft, that itfliould take place, and is oppofi tion to the known will of God, whjch is oppofition to God. Therefore, so8 ?V0 Man is without Sin PART IL Therefore, it is not to be fuppofed, that a chriflian does ever pray that he may be prefectly holy in this life, while he has a full conviction in his mind, that it is contrary to the revealed will of God, that this fhould ever take place, in any inftance. But a chriflian may not have attended to the evidence there is from the Bible, that no man is to be perfectly holy in this life $ or through fome prejudice, not be convinced that this is there revealed ; and confe- quently, may pray that he may be perfectly holy, while in this world, and not know or believe, that he afks for that which is contrary to the will of God to grant. In this cafe, his fin confifts in not properly attending to what God has revealed concerning this, or in not believ ing it, though the evidence be clearly fet before him. And as the chriflian is not omnifcient, and fees not every truth at once, or with equal clearnefs and conftan- cy, of which he has been convinced in theory and {pecu lation ; and one thing has a vaftly greater impreflidn on his mind, than another ; and at different times, the fame truth, may have much more of his attention, than at smother, and make a more fenfible impreflion ; It is therefore pofBble, that he mould have fuch a clear view, and great and fenfible impreflion of his own finfulnefs ; of the evil of fin, and the hatefulnefs of it ; and of the defirablenefs of deliverance from it, and of being perfect ly holy, and conformed to Chrifl, as earneflly to pray, that, if it be confident with the will of God, he may be freed from all fin, and live a perfectly holy life, for time to come ; not at that time reflecting, that God has reveal ed that no man fhall be fo, in this life, or thinking any more of it, than if it were not true : And yet he cannot be faid to dijbdieve it; for as foon as it comes into his view, and he reflects upon it, he believes it, and with draws his petition. This is doubtlefs poflible, and may have CHAP. IV. in this Life. 209 have taken place in many inftances ; and perhaps is not fmful.* IMPROVEMENT. * Perhaps the prayer of the Redeemer may well be accounted for in this way, when he faidin the garden, " O my Father, if it be poflible, let this cup pafs from me : Neverthelefs, not as I will, but as thou wilt." Matth. xxvi. 39. The human mind of Chrift, had fuch a view and fenfe of thefufferings which were before him, that it was in a degree overborne and fwallowed up with the dreadfulnefs of them, and the impoflibility of his going through them, without more divine affiftance than he then ex perienced. And it was fo ordered by God, that the abfolute neceffuy of his {uffering thus, mould not then be in view, his mind being wholly ar- refted by the view and fenfe of his fufferings, and the dreadfulnefs of the cup which was then fet before him j and the human nature did, in a fenfe, fhrink back, at the view of it. And in this fituation o*' mind, he prayed as above. It was wife and important, that the human nature of the Redeemer, mould be placed in fuch a fituation at this time, for two realons. Firft, That he might have the beft opportunity to difcover his difpofition, and how he would act under this fevere trial, when his fuffer- ings were fel before him, in all rhc greatnefs and dreadfulnefs of them. The dreadful cup was fet before him, that he might have the cleared light" of it ; and in this fituation, difcover what he chofe, and whether he was willing to drink it, if necedary for the glory of God, and the falvation of the elect ; and make the choice in the fight of all worlds, that he might be, and appear to be, perfectly voluntary, and take this fuffering upan him. felf, when he was in a fituation to have the cleareft vieiv, and greatest fenfe polfible, of the evil to be ftuTered ; of the dreadful ingredients of the bit ter cup. In this moft trying fituation, he voluntarily gave liimfelf up to this dreadful fuffering, if this were neceirary, and the will of hfs Father : The latter not being prefent, and fo impreffcd on his mind as the former, as a certain reality : And fo was in a meafure out of view, and did not de mand his particular attention ; in confequence of a particular divine in fluence on his mind, at that time. Secondly, By this, the neceQity of the Redeemer's fuffering as he did, in order to the pardon and falvation of fmners, and the impoflibility of their being faved in any other way, but by his making atonement tor their fin by his own blood, and being made a curie in their (lead, was fet in a moft clear and ftriking light. Since the infinitely worthy Redeemer, the only begotten, well beloved, Son of God, did not confent to fuffer, on any other fuppofition ; and earneflly prayed that he might not fuffer, if it were poffible for him to be rejeafed from ir, cenfiftent with the glory of God, and the falvation offinners ; his petition would have been granted, it it frere pofiible, that li fliould not fuffer, and yet thefe ends be anfwcred. VOL, II. F No Man is without Sin PART II. IMPROVEMENT. I. FROM the fubjecl: of this feftion, we may be cer-r tain, that they are not real chriftians, who fay, or think they are arrived, to fuch a perfeft Mate, as to live without fin. A cbriftian may, through the prejudices of educa- tic.j, ignorance, or otherwife, think that fome chriftian-s may, and actually do attain to finlefs perfeclion, in this life. But he can never think himfelf to be without fin. His acquaintance with the law of God, in the fpivituality and extent of it, and with his own heart, is fuch, that by keeping thefe in view, and comparing them with each other, his own finfulnefs flares him in the face ; and he condemns himfelf before God, as very far from what he ought to be, and exceeding guilty and vile. And the higher he rifes in holy exercifes, and the more eircum- fpecl: and watchful he is, the greater light and difcerning' he has to fee the defe&s and corruptions of his own heart ; and the more painful is the view of his own character, and he is difpofed to exclaim with the Apoftle Pau* t r< O wretched man that I am, who fliall deliver me from the body of this death!*'* The Apoflle John decides this point, in moil exprefs terms. He fays, " If we fay that we have no fin, we deceive ourfelves, and the truth is not in us."t He does not mean,, " If we fay we never did fin," becaufe this is contrary to his exprefs words, which are in the prefent tirm>, If we fay, we have no fin, now, at this prefent time. According to this, no man can with truth fay, at any time of his life, " I have no fin, or I am without fin, and perfectly holy/* Therefore, no real chriflian will fay it, or can think this of himfelf ; none but thofe who are deceived about fhemfelves, to fuch a degree, as is inconuflent ,* Rom. vii. 4 f i John i. 8. . IV. in this Life. 2ii inconfiftent with their being the children of light and of the day, can fay, or even think this of themfelves. This Apoftle, in the next verfe but one, fpeaks of the time pad, and fays, and the Eternal State ofHappinefs or Mifery. I. W HEN man had finned, and God had open ed to him a new conftitution, for the redemption offomeof the human race, by a Saviour, by faying to the ferpenr, * c I will put enmity between thee and the woman, and between thy feed and her feed: He fhall bruife thy head, and thou fhalt bruife his heel ;"* He faid to Adam, and in him to all mankind, that under this new conftitmtion, and from this new ftate of probation, he fhould pafs into another ftate, and go into the invifible world, by a feparatien between foul and body ; and his body fhould turn to duft, from whence it was taken. " Duft thou art, and unto duft fhalt thou return." This fentence muft refer to his body only; for this only was duft, and taken out of the ground. His fpirit or foul, was immaterial, and not duft, or taken out of the ground, but a diftin6l exiftence from the body, by which he bore the image of God. the former in a ftate of happinefs, and the latter in a ftate of mifery, immediately upon their going out of this world. And it is faid, " It is ap pointed to men once to die, but after this the judg ment, "t And if nothing were faid, relating to this point but the following words, it is fixed in them, beyond a doubt. " We muft all appear before the judgment feat of Chrift ; that every one may receive the things done in P 4 his * Gal. vi, 7, 8. f Heb, ix. 27. Concerning Death. PART II. his body, according to that he hath done, whether it be good or bad.*'* If at the final judgment, when the end- lefs flate of men will be fixed, they fhall be judged ac cording to what they have done in the body : Then this life is the only time of probation, and in the body they fix their character and ftate for eternity. 5The time of man's death, and the way and means by which the foul fhali be feparated from the body, are all hidden from man. He is expofed to death as foon as he begins to exiil in the body, and knows not how foon it may come ; and no circumflances, nor any thing he can do, or that others can do for him, can fecure him from death a moment, This is wifely ordered fo, and an- fwers many good ends, which it is needlefs particularly to mention here. Death is not a calamity, but a great benefit to the re deemed. It has no fling for them, but comes to them as a friend, by which they are delivered from all moral and natural evil, and become perfectly holy, and enter upon a life unfpeakably better than to live here in the body. Therefore, the Apoflle Paul, had a defire to de part, to die, and be with Chrifl:, which ivasjar better. And he confidered the death of his body, as his great gain.t <( Precious in the fight of the Lord, is the death of his fcints."t Which denotes that it is an important, *T and defirable change, by which he is glorified, and their good is promoted. Chrifl has taken away the fling of death to them, and gives them the vi6lory over it, which he will complete at the general refurre&ion. In the profpet~l of this, chriflians may now fay, " O death, where is thy fling ? O grave, where is thy victory ? The fling of death is fin ; and the flrength of fin is the law. But thanks be to God, which giveth us the victory, through our Lord Jefus Chrift." Death * a Cor. v. ic. -\ Phil. i. 21, 28. Pfal, cxyi. 15. < i Cor, xv, 55, 56, 57. CHAP. IV. A Separate State. 217 Death is juftly terrible, and a dreadful evil, to thofe who are in their (ins. It deprives them of all good : It puts an end to their probation Rate, and to all hope, and fixes them in a flate of fin, defpair and endlefs mifery. This is neceflarily implied in the words juft cited. " The fling of death is fin ; and the (Irength of fin is the law.'* Death could have no fling, by fin or the law, more than any other change or event in life, if it did not fix the curfe of the law upon the finner, when he dies, and put an en,d to his probation and hope. The fling of death, is the evil which fin deferves, and which the law denounces, which is the fecond death. The death of the body fixes this fling in the finner's heart, which is endlefs definition. A SEPARATE STATE. II. THAT the foul does not die with the body, but exifls in a feparate flate, till the general refurrec"lion of all the bodies of men which have died, has been fup- pofed in what has been faid on the death of the body ; and isaffertedor implied, in feveral pafTagesof fcripture, which have been mentioned under the foregoing head : But this requires a diflinft, and more particular confider- ation. And that the foul or fpirit of man does not die, or go into a flate of infenfibility, when the body is turn ed to duft, is made evident and certain, by many other paffages offcripture, which have not been yet mentioned. The promife of Chrifl, to the penitent, believing thief on the crofs, proves that the death of his body did not put an end to his exiftence or fenfibility. " And Jefus faid unto him, Verily I fay unto thee, Today malt thou be with me in paradife."* The word paradife, was ufecj * Luke xxviii. 43, A Separate State. PART II. ufed by the Jews, at that day, for heaven, or a ftate of happinefs. The foul of this man was not injured by the death of his body ; but he exifted in a ftate of greater fenfibility and enjoyment, than when united with the body, and went dire&ly to heaven ; nor is there the leaft evidence, that this is not equally true of every be liever, when his body dies. Stephen, the firft martyr, expeded and prayed for this, when his body was dying. " And they (toned Stephen, calling upon God, and fay- ing, Lord Jffits receive my fpirit."* And none can doubt that the Redeemer was as ready to grant his pe~ tition, as that of the thief. The Apoflle Paul expected the fame, and fpeaks of it as certain, that when his body died, and he fhould be no longer in this world, he fhould be in heaven with Chrift. *' For me to live is Chrift, and to die is gain. I am in a ftrait betwixt two, having a defire to depart, and to be with Chrift, which is far better. 1 't He did not conuder him- f elf as dying with the body ; but when that died, and he left this world, he expected to depart, and be with Chrift in heaven. And he could not mean his being with Chrift, after the refurreclion; for he puts his continuing in the body, and abiding longer in this world, in oppofition to his being with Chrift ; which could not be true on that fuppofition : For he would be with Chrift as foon, though he fhould live an hundred years longer in the body, as if he died immediately. And he would gain nothing, in this refpecl, by dying ; and therefore, it could not be/ar better than to live longer in the body. And Jie cxpreffes the fame fentiment, with regard toothers as ivell as himfelf, in the following words. " We know- that if jmr earthly houfe of this tabernacle were diffolved, we ha^ a building of God, an houfe not made with )iands, eternal in the heavens. Therefore, we are always confident * Aft* vii. 59. f Phil, i, ax. zj. CHAP. IV. A Separate State. 2ig confident (or courageous) knowing that while we are at home (or fojourn) in the body, we are abfent from the Lord. We are confident (courageous) I fay, and wil ling, rather to be abfent from the body, and to be prefent -with the Lord."* Here he confiders, being prefent with the Lord, or being with Chrifl, as taking place, in confe- quence of death, or being abfent from the body ; fo that when feparated from the body, they fhall be with Chrift, in a fenfe and degree which cannot take place while in the body : And thefe two dates areoppofed to each other. And he fays, they knew that when they fhould die, or their body be diflolved, they fhould be in heaven. This fame Apoflle, fuppofes he could exift, perceive, think and enjoy to a high degree, wheji out of his body, or abfent from it, when he fpeaks of the vifions and re velations which he had, when carried to heaven ; and fays he could not tell whether he was in the body, or out of it, and feparate from it : For if the foul could not exift, perceive and enjoy, when feparate from the body, he could have known that he was not out of the body, but in it, when he had thofe revelations, perceptions and exercifes.t And he fpeaks of " The fpirits of juft men, made perfect," as being then in heaven, with the holy angels, and with Jefus Chrift 5 by which he exprefsly aflerts a feparate ftate, and that the fpirits of the julr, when the body dies, are made perfeft in holinefs, and go to heaven, to be with Chrift, and the happy inhabitants of the invifible world. J The fouls of the martyrs, are reprefented as exifting in a ftate of feniibility, happinefs and honour, in a feparate ftate, after their bodies had been flain. And the dead, who die in Chrift, are de clared to be blefled, and to be received to a ftate of hapr pinefs and rewards. || The Apoftle Peter, fpeakf of the fpirits of thofe who perimed by the flood, as exifting when he * 2. Cor. y. i, 6, 8. t 2 Cor. xii. i, 2, 3. |Hcb, xii, zj, 23, 24, $Rev, vi. ?, jo, u. {j Chap. xiv. ij r ft 20 A Separate State. PART II. he wrote, and being in prifon.* And Chrift proves to the Sadduces, that the patriarchs, Abraham, Ifaac, and Jacob, had an exiftence, and were not dead, long after they had left this world, and their bodies were turned to duft.t Thefe paffages of fcripture, it is prefumed, are fufficient to convince every honed unprejudiced mind, that the foul exifh feparate from the body, in the invifible world, from the death of the body, till the general refurreclion ; iiotwithftanding the attempts which have been made, by thofe who deny a feparate flate, to put a meaning on them, fo as to make them confident with fuch denial. And the account which the fcripture gives of this mat ter, is very agreeable to reafon, and all the appearances, relating to it. It is very unreafonable to fuppofe that the Redeemer, who by his power and grace, has made them meet for the inheritance of the faints in light, or the holy inhabitants in heaven, fhould fo order it, that death fhould put an end to their exiftence, till their bodies are raifed to life, fo as to have no perception, ex- crcife, or enjoyment, during that interval of time ; and deprive them of all that holinefs and happinefs which they might enjoy, during that time, with him, in his kingdom ; efpecially fince by becoming his friends, in this world, they are formed to the gieateft averfion to falling into fuch a ftate ; and have flrong and uncon querable defires, to live, and be with Chrift ; and in the company of his friends and fervants, in the invifible world. For all true chriflians have the fame defires which Stephen exprefied, when dying, c< Lord Jefus, receive my Spirit." And which the Apoflle Paul faid, he had : " For 1 have a defire to depart, and to be with Chrift, which is far better." And this would not be Agreeable to the tender love which he exprefled to his difciples a Peter iii. 19, ao r f Matth. xxli, 37, g*. CHAP. IV. A Separate Slate. S2i difciples and friends, when on earth. He faid to them, " In rny Father's houfe,are many manfionfr. If it were not fo, I would have told you. I go to prepare a place for you. And if I go and prepare a place for you, I will come again, and receive you to myfelf, that where I am, there ye may be alfo."*