/ O *>* 'SELECTION; S^O;:-:-.^ FROM THE WRITINGS OF ^ fl ALTER SAVAGE LANDOR ARRANGED AND EDITED BY NEY COLVIN Honfcon MACMILLAN AND co* AND NEW YORK 1890 ?3 an Oxford preacher ; tells the story of young Wellerby to one of his Pupils aspiring to become a poet, ETHELBERT ! I think thou walkest but little ; otherwise I should take thee with me, some fine fresh morning, as far as unto the first hamlet on the Cherwell. There lies young Wellerby, who, the year before, was wont to pass many hours of the day poetising .amidst the ruins of Godstow nunnery. It is said that he bore a fondness toward a young maiden in that place, formerly a village, now containing but two old farmhouses. In my memory there were still extant several dormitories. Some love- sick girl had recollected an ancient name, and had engraven on a stone with a garden-nail, which lay in rust near it, Poore Rosamund. I entered these precincts, and beheld a youth of manly form and countenance, washing and wiping a stone with a handful of wet grass ; and on my going up to him, and asking what he had found, he showed it to me. The next time I saw him was near the banks of the CherwelL He had tried, it appears, to forget or overcome his foolish passion, and had applied his whole mind unto study. He was foiled by his competitor ; and now he sought consolation in poetry. Whether this opened the wounds that had closed in his youthful breast, and malig- nant Love, in his revenge, poisoned it ; or whether the disappointment he had experienced in finding others pre- ferred to him, first in the paths of fortune, then in those of the muses ; he was thought to have died broken-hearted. About half a mile from St. John's College is the termination of a natural terrace, with the Cherwell close THE FATE OF A YOUNG POET. 177 under it, in some places bright with yellow and red flowers glancing and glowing through the stream, and suddenly in others dark with the shadows of many different trees, in broad overbending thickets, and with rushes spear-high, and party-coloured flags. After a walk in midsummer, the immersion of our hands into the cool and closing grass is surely not the least among our animal delights. I was just seated, and the first sensation of rest vibrated in me gently, as though it were music to the limbs, when I discovered by a hollow in the herbage that another was near. The long meadow-sweet and bloom- ing burnet half concealed from me him whom the earth was about to hide totally and for ever. " Master Bachelor !" said I, "it is ill-sleeping by the water-side." No answer was returned. I arose, went to the place, and recognised poor Wellerby. His brow was moist, his cheek was warm. A few moments earlier, and that dismal lake whereunto and wherefrom the waters of life, the buoyant blood, ran no longer, might have re- , ceived one vivifying ray reflected from my poor casement. I might not indeed have comforted I have often failed : but there is one who never has ; and the strengthener of the bruised reed should have been with us. Remembering that his mother did abide one mile further on, I walked forward to the mansion, and asked her what tidings she lately had received of her son. She replied, that having given up his mind to light studies, the fellows of the college would not elect him. The master had warned him beforehand to abandon his selfish poetry, take up manfully the quarter staff of logic, and wield it for St. John's, come who would into the ring. " * We want our man,' said he to me, ' and your son hath /ailed us in the hour of need. Madam, he hath been foully beaten in the schools by one he might have swallowed, with due exercise.' N 1 78 NARRATIVE. " I rated him, told him I was poor, and he knew it. He was stung, and threw himself upon my neck, and wept. Twelve days have passed since, and only three rainy ones. I hear he has been seen upon the knoll yonder, but hither he hath not come. I trust he knows at last the value of time, and I shall be heartily glad to see him after this accession of knowledge. Twelve days, it is true, are rather a chink than a gap in time ; yet, O gentle sir I they are that chink which makes the vase quite valueless. There are light words which may never be shaken off the mind they fall on. My child, who was hurt by me, will not let me see the marks." "Lady !" said I, "none are left upon him. Be com- forted ! thou shalt see him this hour. All that thy God hath not taken is yet thine." She looked at me earnestly, and would have then asked something, but her voice failed her. There was no agony, no motion, save in the lips and cheeks. Being the widow of one who fought under Hawkins, she remem- bered his courage and sustained the shock, saying calmly, " God's will be done ! I pray that he find me as worthy as he findeth me willing to join them." Now, in her unearthly thoughts, she had led her only son to the bosom of her husband ; and in her spirit (which often is permitted to pass the gates of death with holy love) she left them both with their Creator. The curate of the village sent those who should bring home the body ; and some days afterwards he came unto me, beseeching me to write the epitaph. Being no friend to stone-cutter's charges, I entered not into biography, but wrote these few words : JOANNES WELLERBY, LlTERARUM QU^SIVIT GLORIAM, VIDET DEI. II. REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. RELIGION. XXXVIII. THE ORIGIN OF IDOLATRY. Dr. Glaston discourses. IN the earlier ages of mankind, your Greek and Latin authors inform you, there went forth sundry worthies, men of might, to deliver, not wandering damsels, albeit for those likewise they had stowage, but low-conditioned men, who fell under the displeasure of the higher, and groaned in thraldom and captivity. And these mighty ones were believed to have done such services to poor humanity, that their memory grew greater than they, as shadows do than substances at day-fall. And the sons and grandsons of the delivered did laud and magnify those glorious names ; and some in gratitude, and some in tribulation, did ascend the hills, which appeared unto them as altars bestrewn with flowers and herbage for heaven's acceptance. And many did go far into the quiet groves, under lofty trees, looking for whatever was mightiest and most protecting. And in such places did they cry aloud unto the mighty, who had left them, Return! return! help us! help us! be blessed! for ever blessed! Vain men ! but, had they stayed there, not evil. Out of gratitude, purest gratitude, rose idolatry. For the devil sees the fairest, and soils it In these our days, methinks, whatever other sins we may fall into, such idolatry is the least dangerous. For, I 82 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. neither on the one side is there much disposition for gratitude, nor on the other much zeal to deliver the innocent and oppressed. Even this deliverance, although a merit, and a high one, is not the highest. Forgiveness is beyond it. Forgive, or ye shall not be forgiven. This ye may do every day ; for if ye find not offences, ye feign them ; and surely ye may remove your own work, if ye may remove another's. To rescue requires more thought and wariness : learn then the easier lesson first. Afterwards, when ye rescue any from another's violence, or from his own (which oftentimes is more dangerous, as the enemies are within not only the pene- trals of his house but of his heart), bind up his wounds before ye send him on his way. Should ye at any time overtake the erring, and resolve to deliver him up, I will tell you whither to conduct him. Conduct him to his Lord and Master, whose household he hath left. It is better to consign him to Christ his Saviour than to man his murderer : it is better to bid him live than to bid him die. The one word our Teacher and Preserver said, the other our enemy and destroyer. Bring him back again, the stray, the lost one ! bring him back, not with clubs and cudgels, not with halberts and halters, but generously and gently, and with the linking of the arm. In this posture shall God above smile upon ye : in this posture of yours he shall recognise again his beloved Son upon earth. Do ye likewise, and depart in peace. XXXIX. Melanchthon. The wickedness of idolatry does not consist in any inadequate representation of the Deity, for whether our hands or our hearts represent him, the representation is almost alike inadequate. Every man does what he hopes and believes will be most pleasing RELIGION. 183 to his God ; and God, in his wisdom and mercy, will not punish gratitude in its error. Calvin. How do you know that ? Melanchthon. Because I know his loving -kindness, and experience it daily. Calvin. If men blindly and wilfully run into error when God hath shown the right way, he will visit it on their souls. Melanchthon. He will observe from the serenity of heaven, a serenity emanating from his presence, that there is scarcely any work of his creation on earth which hath not excited, in some people or other, a remem- brance, an admiration, a symbol of his power. The evil of idolatry is this. Rival nations have raised up rival deities ; war hath been denounced in the name of heaven ; men have murdered for the love of God : and such impiety hath darkened all the regions of the world, that the Lord of all things hath been invoked by all simultaneously as the Lord of Hosts. XL. DIFFERENCES OF OPINION IN RELIGION. Melanchthon. I remember no discussion on religion in which religion was not a sufferer by it, if mutual forbear- ance, and belief in another's good motives and intentions, are (as I must always think they are) its proper and neces- sary appurtenances. Calvin. Would you never make inquiries ? Melanchthon. Yes ; and as deep as possible ; but into my own heart ; for that belongs to me ; and God hath entrusted it most especially to my own superintendence. Calvin. We must also keep others from going astray, by showing them the right road, and, if they are obsti- nate in resistance, then by coercing and chastising them through the magistrate. 1 84 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. Melanchthon. It is sorrowful to dream that we art scourges in God's hand, and that he appoints for us no better work than lacerating one another. I am no enemy to inquiry, where I see abuses, and where I suspect false- hood. The Romanists, our great oppressors, think it presumptuous to search into things abstruse ; and let us do them the justice to acknowledge that, if it is a fault, it is one which they never commit. But surely we are kept sufficiently in the dark by the infirmity of our nature : no need to creep into a corner and put our hands before our eyes. To throw away or turn aside from God's best gifts is verily a curious sign of obedience and submission. He not only hath given us a garden tc walk in, but he hath planted it also for us, and he wills us to know the nature and properties of everything that grows up within it. Unless we look into them and handle them and register them, how shall we discover this to be salutary, that to be poisonous ; this annual, that perennial ? Calvin. Here we coincide ; and I am pleased to find in you less apathy than I expected. It becomes us, more- over, to denounce God's vengeance on a sinful world. Melanchthon. Is it not better and pleasanter to show the wanderer by what course of life it may be avoided ? is it not better and pleasanter to enlarge on God's pro- mises of salvation, than to insist on his denunciations of wrath ? is it not better and pleasanter to lead the wretched up to his mercy, than to hurl them by thousands under his fiery chariot ? Calvin. We have no option. By our heavenly Father many are called, but few are chosen. Melanchthon. There is scarcely a text in the Holy Scriptures to which there is not an opposite text written in characters equally large and legible ; and there has usually been a sword laid upon each. Even the weakest , TJNIVT ^ RELIGION. 185 disputant is made so conceited by what he calls religion, as to think himself wiser than the wisest who thinks differently from him ; and he becomes so ferocious by what he calls holding it fast, that he appears to me as if he held it fast much in the same manner as a terrier holds a rat, and you have about as much trouble in getting it from between his incisors. When at last it does come out, it is mangled, distorted, and extinct. Calvin. M. Melanchthon ! you have taken a very per- verse view of the subject. Such language as yours would extinguish that zeal which is to enlighten the nations, and to consume the tares by which they are overrun. Melanchthon. The tares and the corn are so intermingled throughout the wide plain which our God hath given us to cultivate, that I would rather turn the patient and humble into it to weed it carefully, than a thresher who would thresh wheat and tare together before the grain is ripened, or who would carry fire into the furrows when it is. Calvin. Yet even the most gentle, and of the gentler sex, are inflamed with a holy zeal in the propagation of the faith. Melanchthon > I do not censure them for their earnest- ness in maintaining truth. We not only owe our birth to them, but also the better part of our education ; and if we were not divided after their first lesson, we should continue to live in a widening circle of brothers and sisters all our lives. After our infancy and removal from home, the use of the rod is the principal thing we learn of our alien preceptors ; and, catching their dictatorial language, we soon begin to exercise their instrument of enforcing it, and swing it right and left, even after we are paralysed by age, and until Death's hand strikes it out of ours. I am sorry you have cited the gentler part of the creation to appear before you, obliged as I am to I 86 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. bear witness that I myself have known a few specimens of the fair sex become a shade less fair, among the per- plexities of religion. Indeed I am credibly informed that certain of them have lost their patience, running up and down in the dust where many roads diverge. This surely is not walking humbly with their God, nor walking with him at all ; for those who walk with him are always readier to hear his voice than their own, and to admit that it is more persuasive. But at last the zealot is so infatuated by the serious mockeries he imitates and repeats, that he really takes his own voice for God's. Is it not wonderful that the words of eternal life should have hitherto produced only eternal litigation ; and that, in our progress heavenward, we should think it expedient to plant unthrifty thorns over bitter wells of blood in the wilderness we leave behind us ? XLI. Melanchthon. Calvin ! I beseech you, do you who guide and govern so many, do you (whatever others may) spare your brethren. Doubtful as I am of lighter texts, blown backward and forward at the opening of opposite win- dows, I am convinced and certain of one grand immove- able verity. It sounds strange ; it sounds contradictory. Calvin. I am curious to hear it. Melanchthon. You shall. This is the tenet. There is nothing on earth divine beside humanity. Romilly. The worst of unbelief is that which regrets the goodness of our heavenly Father, and from which there springs in us a desire of breaking what we cannot bend, and of twisting wire after wire, and tying knot RELIGION. 187 after knot, in his scourge. Christianity, as I understand it, lies not in belief but in action. That servant is a good servant who obeys the just orders of his master ; not he who repeats his words, measures his stature, or traces his pedigree ! On all occasions, it is well to be a little more than tolerant ; especially when a wiser and better man than ourselves thinks differently from us. Washington. Religion is too pure for corporations : it is best meditated on in our privacy, and best acted on in our ordinary intercourse with mankind. If we believe in revelation, we must believe that God wishes us to converse with him but little, since the only form of address he has prescribed to us is an extremely short one. He has placed us where our time may be more beneficially employed in mutually kind offices, and he does not desire us to tell him, hour after hour, how dearly we love him, or how much we want from him : he knows these things exactly. Milton. Methinks thou knowest more about the poets than about the divines. Curious name ! as if the study and profession of what relates to divinity made the man himself divine, as the study and profession of physic entitles one, and justly, to be called a physician. XLV. Marvel. Never do I take the liberty to question or examine any man on his religion, or to look over his shoulder on his account-book with God. But I know that Milton and every other great poet must be reli- 1 8 8 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. gious : for there is nothing so godlike as a love of order, with a power of bringing great things into it. This power, unlimited in the one, limited (but incalculably and inconceivably great), in the other, belongs to the Deity and the poet. Bishop Parker. I shudder. Marvel. Wherefore? at seeing a man, what he was designed to be by his Maker, his Maker's image ? But pardon me, my lord ! the surprise of such a novelty is enough to shock you. XLVI. Parker. Let us piously hope, Mr. Marvel, that God in his good time may turn Mr. Milton from the error of his ways, and incline his heart to repentance, and that so he may finally be prepared for death. Marvel. The wicked can never be prepared for it, the good always are. What is the preparation which so many ruffled wrists point out ? To gabble over prayer and praise and confession and contrition. My lord ! heaven is not to be won by short hard work at the last, as some of us take a degree at the university, after much irregularity and negligence. Pi prefer a steady pace from the outset to the end,coming in cool, and dis- mounting quietly. Instead of which I have known many old playfellows of the devil spring up suddenly from their beds and strike at him treacherously ; while he, without a cuff, laughed and made grimaces in the corner of the room. XLVIT. Lord Brooke. A forced match between a man and his religion sours his temper, and leaves a barren bed. RELIGION. 189 XLV1II. THE EFFICACY OF PRAYER. Magliabecchi. Among your other works I find a manu- script on the inefficacy of prayer. I defended you to my superiors by showing that Cicero had asserted things incredible to himself, merely for the sake of argument, and had probably written them before he had fixed in his mind the personages to whom they should be attributed in his dialogues ; that, in short, they were brought for- ward for no other purpose than discussion and explo- sion. This impiety was forgiven. But every man in Italy has a favourite saint, for whose honour he deems it meritorious to draw (I had almost said the sword) the stiletto. Middleton. It would be safer to attempt dragging God from his throne than to split a spangle on their petti- coats, or to puff a grain of powder from their wigs. This I know. Nothing in my writings is intended to wound the jealousy of the Italians. Truth, like the juice of the poppy, in small quantities calms men, in larger heats and irritates them, and is attended by fatal consequences in its excess. For which reason, with plain ground before me, I would not expatiate largely, and often made an argument, that offered itself, give way altogether and leave room for inferences. My treatise on prayer was not to be published in my lifetime. Magliabecchi. And why at any time ? Supposing prayer to be totally inefficacious in the object, is not the mind exalted, the heart purified, are not our affections chastened, our desires moderated, our enjoyments en- larged, by this intercourse with the Deity ? and are not men the better, as certainly they are the happier, for a belief that he interferes in their concerns. They are persuaded that there is something conditional between them, and that, if they labour under the commission of 1 90 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. crimes, their voice will be inaudible as the voice of one under the nightmare. Middleton. I wished to demonstrate, that we often treat God in the same manner as we should treat some doting or some passionate old man : we feign, we flatter, we sing, we cry, we gesticulate. Magliabecchi. Worship him in your own manner, according to the sense he has given you ; and let those who cannot exercise that sense, rely upon those who can. Be convinced, Mr. Middleton, that you never will sup- plant the received ideas of God : be no less convinced that the sum of your labours in this field, will be, to leave the ground loose beneath you, and that he who comes after you will sink. # # * Suppose a belief in the efficacy of prayer to be a belief altogether irrational you may : I never can suppose it to be insanity itself, would you, meeting a young man who had wandered over many countries in search of a father, until his intellects are deranged, and who, in the fulness of his heart, addresses an utter stranger as the lost parent, clings to him, kisses him, sobs upon his breast, and finds comfort only by repeating "Father! father!" would you, Mr. Middleton, say to this affectionate fond creature, "Go home, sit quiet, be silent!" and per' suade him that his father is lost to him ? Middleton. God forbid. Magliabecchi. You have done it : do it no more : the madman has not heard you ; and the father will pardon you when you meet FAME, AND TRUE AND FALSE GREATNESS. XLIX. Dante. Greatness is to goodness what gravel is to pro- phyry ; the one is a moveable accumulation, swept along the surface of the earth ; the other stands fixed, and solid, and alone, above the violence of war and of the tempest ; above all that is residuous of a wasted world. Little men build up great ones ; but the snow colossus soon melts : the good stand under the eye of God ; and there- fore stand. Diogenes. The great man is he who hath nothing to fear and nothing to hope from another. It is he who, while he demonstrates the iniquity of the laws, and is able to correct them, obeys them peaceably. It is he who looks on the ambitious both as weak and fraudulent. It is he who hath no disposition or occasion for any kind of deceit, no reason for being or for appearing different from what he is. It is he who can call together the most select company when it pleases him. Plato. There are great men of various kinds. Diogertes. No, by my beard, are there not. Plato. What ! are there not great captains, great geometricians, great dialectians ? IQ2 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. Diogenes. Who denied it? A great man was the postulate. Try thy hand now at the powerful one. Plato. On seeing the exercise of power, a child cannot doubt who is powerful, more or less ; for power is rela- tive. All men are weak, not only if compared to the Demiurgos, but if compared to the sea or the earth, or certain things upon each of them, such as elephants and whales. So placid and tranquil is the scene around us, we can hardly bring to mind the images of strength and force, the precipices, the abysses Diogenes. Prythee hold thy loose tongue, twinkling and glittering like a serpent's in the midst of luxuriance and rankness. Did never this reflection of thine warn thee that, in human life, the precipices and abysses would be much further from our admiration, if we were less in- considerate, selfish, and vile ? I will not however stop thee long, for thou wert going on quite consistently. As thy great men are fighters and wranglers, so thy mighty things upon the earth and sea are troublesome and in- tractable incumbrances. Thou perceivedst not what was greater in the former case, neither art thou aware what is greater in this. Didst thou feel the gentle air that passed us ? Plato. I did not just then. Diogenes. That air, so gentle, so imperceptible to thee, is more powerful not only than all the creatures that breathe and live by it ; not only than all the oaks of the forest, which it rears in an age and shatters in a moment ; not only than all the monsters of the sea, but than the sea itself, which it tosses up into foam and breaks against every rock in its vast circumference ; for it carries in its bosom, with perfect calm and composure, the incontrollable ocean and the peopled earth, like an atom of a feather. To the world's turmoils and pageantries is attracted, not only the admiration of the populace, but the zeal of FAME, AND TRUE AND FALSE GREATNESS. 193 the orator, the enthusiasm of the poet, the investigation of the historian, and the contemplation of the philosopher : yet how silent and invisible are they in the depths of air ! Do I say in those depths and deserts ? No ; I say at the distance of a swallow's flight ; at the distance she rises above us, ere a sentence brief as this could be uttered. What are its mines and mountains? Fragments welded up and dislocated by the expansion of water from below ; the most part reduced to mud, the rest to splinters. Afterwards sprang up fire in many places, and again tore and mangled the mutilated carcase, and still growls over it. What are its cities and ramparts, and moles and monuments ? Segments of a fragment, which one man puts together and another throws down. Here we stumble upon thy great ones at their work. Show me now, if thou canst, in history, three great warriors, or three great statesmen, who have acted otherwise than spiteful children. Anaxagoras. It will appear wonderful and perhaps incredible to future generations, that what are now con- sidered the two highest gifts of man, oratory and poetry, should be employed, the one chiefly in exciting, the other in emblazoning, deeds of slaughter and devastation. If we could see, in the nature of things, a child capable of forming a live tiger, and found him exercising his power of doing it, I think we should say to him, "You might employ your time better, child 1" LIII. Lord Brooke. Merciful heaven ! and for the fruition of an hour's drunkenness, from which they must awaken O 194 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. with heaviness, pain, and terror, men consume a whole crop of their kind at one harvest-home. Shame upon those light ones who carol at the feast of blood ! and worse upon those graver ones who nail upon their escutcheon the name of great. LIV. Vittoria Colonna. There are various kinds of greatness, as we all know ; however, the most part of those who pro- fess one species is ready to acknowledge no other. The first and chief is intellectual. But surely those also are to be admitted into the number of the eminently great, who move large masses by action, by throwing their own ardent minds into the midst of popular assemblies or conflicting armies, compelling, directing, and subjecting. This greatness is indeed far from so desirable as that which shines serenely from above, to be our hope, com- fort, and guidance ; to lead us in spirit from a world of sad realities into one fresh from the poet's hand, and blooming with all the variety of his creation. Hence the most successful generals, and the most powerful kings, will always be considered by the judicious and dispas- sionate as invested with less dignity, less extensive and enduring authority, than great philosophers and great poets. Michelangelo. By the wise indeed ; but little men, like little birds, are attracted and caught by false lights. LV. Epicurus. External reverence should be paid unspar- ingly to the higher magistrates of every country who perform their offices exemplarily : yet they are not on this account to be placed in the same degree with men of FAME, AND TRUE AND FALSE GREATNESS. 1 Q 5 primary genius. They never exalt the human race, and rarely benefit it ; and their benefits are local and transi- tory, while those of a great writer are universal and eternal. LVI. Sidney. Poets are in general prone to melancholy ; yet the most plaintive ditty hath imparted a fuller joy, and of longer duration, to its composer, than the conquest of Persia to the Macedonian. LVII. Many can rule and more can fight, But few give myriad hearts delight. Marvel With the greatest rulers upon earth, head and crown drop together, and are overlooked. It is true, we read of them in history ; but we also read in history of crocodiles and hyaenas. With great writers, whether in poetry or prose, what falls away is scarcely more or other than a vesture. The features of the man are imprinted on his works ; and more lamps burn over them, and more religiously, than are lighted in temples or churches. LIX. Sidney. How many, who have abandoned for public life the studies of philosophy and poetry, may be com- pared to brooks and rivers, which in the beginning of their course have assuaged our thirst, and have invited us to tranquillity by their bright resemblance of it, and 196 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. which afterward partake the nature of that vast body whereinto they run, its dreariness, its bitterness, its foam, Us storms, its everlasting noise and commotion. LX. Cicero. How much greater would the greatest man appear, if any one about him could perceive those innumer- able filaments of thought, which break as they arise from the brain, and the slenderest of which is worth all the wisdom of many at whose discretion lies the felicity of nations ! Lord Peterborough. It is something to have an influ- ence on the fortunes of mankind : it is greatly more to have an influence on their intellects. Such is the differ- ence between men of office and men of genius, between computed and uncomputed rank. LXII. THE FAME OF MILTON. Bishop Parker. Most happy am I to encounter you, Mr. Marvel. It is some time, I think, since we met. May I take the liberty of inquiring what brought you into such a lonely quarter as Bunhill-fields ? Marvel. My lord, I return at this instant from visiting an old friend of ours, hard by, in Artillery Walk, who, you will be happy to hear, bears his blindness and asthma with truly Christian courage. Parker. And pray, who may that old friend be, Mr. Marvel ? Marvel. Honest John Milton. Parker. The same gentleman whose ingenious poem, FAME, AND TRUE AND FALSE GREATNESS. 197 on our first parents, you praised in some elegant verses prefixed to it ? Marvel. The same who likewise, on many occasions, merited and obtained your lordship's approbation. Parker. I am happy to understand that no harsh measures were taken against him, on the return of our most gracious Sovereign. And it occurs to me that you, Mr. Marvel, were earnest in his behalf. Indeed I my- self might have stirred upon it, had Mr. Milton solicited me in the hour of need. Marvel. He is grateful to the friends who consulted at the same time his dignity and his safety : but gratitude can never be expected to grow on a soil hardened by solicitation. Those who are the most ambitious of power are often the least ambitious of glory. It requires but little sagacity to foresee that a name will become invested with eternal brightness by belonging to a benefactor of Milton. / might have served him ! is not always the soliloquy of late compassion or of virtuous repentance : it is frequently the cry of blind and impotent and wounded pride, angry at itself for having neglected a good bargain, a rich reversion. Believe me, my lord bishop, there are few whom God has promoted to serve the truly great. They are never to be superseded, nor are their names to be obliterated in earth or heaven LXIII. Parker. After all, I doubt whether much of his doc- trine is remaining in the public mind. Marvel. Others are not inclined to remember all that we remember, and will not attend to us if we propose to tell them half. Water will take up but a certain quantity of salt, even of the finest and purest. If the short memories of men are to be quoted against the excellence 1 98 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. of instruction, your lordship would never have censured them from the pulpit for forgetting what was delivered by their Saviour * * * I am confident that Milton is heedless of how little weight he is held by those who are of none ; and that he never looks towards those somewhat more eminent, between whom and himself there have crept the waters of oblivion. As the pearl ripens in the ob- scurity of its shell, so ripens in the tomb all the fame that is truly precious. In fame he will be happier than in friendship. Were it possible that one among the faithful of the angels could have suffered wounds and dissolution in his conflict with the false, I should scarcely feel greater awe at discovering on some bleak mountain the bones of this our mighty defender, once shining in celestial panoply, once glowing at the trumpet-blast of God, but not proof against the desperate and the damned, than I have felt at entering the humble abode of Milton, whose spirit already reaches heaven, yet whose corporeal frame hath no quiet or safe resting-place here below. And shall not I, who loved him early, have the lonely and sad privilege to love him still ? or shall fidelity to power be a virtue, and fidelity to tribulation an offence ? LXIV. Southey. Great men will always pay deference to greater : little men will not ; because the little are fractious : and the weaker they are, the more obstinate and crooked. EtibuHdes (to Demosthenes}. In proportion as men approach you, they applaud you. To those far distant and far below, you seem as little as they seem to you. Fellows who cannot come near enough to reverence you, FAME, AND TRUE AND FALSE GREATNESS. 1 99 think they are only a stone's throw distant ; and they throw it. LXVI. Eubulides. It appears to be among the laws of Nature that the mighty of intellect should be pursued and carped at by the little, as the solitary flight of one great bird is followed by the twittering petulance of many smaller. LXVI I. Marvel. Usually men, in distributing fame, do as old maids and old misers do : they give everything to those who want nothing. In literature, often a man's solitude, and oftener his magnitude, disinclines us from helping him if we find him down. We are fonder of warming our hands at a fire already in a blaze than of blowing one. LXVIII. Barrow. Very wise men, and very wary and inquisi- tive, walk over the earth, and are ignorant not only what minerals lie beneath, but what herbs and foliage they are treading. Some time afterward, and probably some dis- tant time, a specimen of ore is extracted and exhibited ; then another ; lastly the bearing and diameter of the vein are observed and measured. Thus it is with writers who are to have a currency through ages. In the begin- ning they are confounded with most others ; soon they fall into some secondary class ; next, into one rather less obscure and humble ; by degrees they are liberated from the dross and lumber that hamper them ; and, being once above the heads of contemporaries, rise slowly and waveringly, then regularly and erectly, then rapidly and majestically, till the vision strains and aches as it pursues them in their ethereal elevation. 200 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. Barrow. No very great man ever reached the standard of his greatness in the crowd of his contemporaries. This hath always been reserved for the secondary. LXX. Leontion. The voice comes deepest from the sepulchre, and a great name hath its root in the dead body. Diogenes. The sun colours the sky most deeply and most diffusely when he hath sunk below the horizon ; and they who never said " How beneficently he shines !" say at last, " Hovi brightly he set !" LXXII. Boccaccio. Not only the fame of Marcellus, but every Other, Crescit occulto vehit arbor cevo ; and that which makes the greatest vernal shoot is apt to make the least autumnal. Authors in general who have met cele- brity at starting, have already had their reward ; always their utmost due, and often much beyond it. We cannot hope for both celebrity and fame : supremely fortunate are the few who are allowed the liberty of choice between them. LXXIII. Cicero. Everything has its use ; life to teach us the contempt of death, and death the contempt of life. Glory, which among all things between stands eminently the principal, although it has been considered by some philosophers as mere vanity and deception, moves those great intellects which nothing else could have stirred, and places them where they can best and most advantageously serve the commonwealth. Glory can be safely despised by those only who have fairly won it. DEATH AND MORTALITY. LXXIV. . Breathe, Rhodope, breathe again those painless sighs : they belong to thy vernal season. May thy sum- mer of life be calm, thy autumn calmer, and thy winter never come. Rhodop^. I must die then earlier. SEsop. Laodameia died ; Helen died ; Leda, the beloved of Jupiter, went before. It is better to repose in the earth betimes than to sit up late ; better, than to cling pertinaciously to what we feel crumbling under us, and to protract an inevitable fall. We may enjoy the present while we are insensible of infirmity and decay : but the present, like a note in music, is nothing but as it appertains to what is past and what is to come. There are no fields of amaranth on this side of the grave : there are no voices, O Rhodope, that are not soon mute, how- ever tuneful : there is no name, with whatever emphasis of passionate love repeated, of which the echo is not faint at last. LXXV. Epicurus converses with his girl pupils Leontion and Ternissc,. Leontion. It is as wise to moderate our belief as our desires. Epicurus. Some minds require much belief, some 202 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. thrive on little. Rather an exuberance of it is feminine and beautiful. It acts differently on different hearts : it troubles some, it consoles others : in the generous it is the nurse of tenderness and kindness, of heroism and self-devotion : in the ungenerous it fosters pride, im- patience of contradiction and appeal, and, like some waters, what it finds a dry stick or hollow straw, it leaves a stone. Ternissa, We want it chiefly to make the way of death an easy one. Epicurus. There is no easy path leading out of life, and few are the easy ones that lie within it. I would adorn and smoothen the declivity, and make my residence as commodious as its situation and dimensions may allow : but principally I would cast underfoot the empty fear of death. Ternissa. O ! how can you ? Epicurus. By many arguments already laid down : then by thinking that some perhaps, in almost every age, have been timid and delicate as Ternissa ; and yet have slept soundly, have felt no parent's or friend's tear upon their faces, no throb against their breasts : in short, have been in the calmest of all possible conditions, while those around were in the most deplorable and desperate. Ternissa. It would pain me to die, if it were only at the idea that any one I love would grieve too much for me. Epicurus. Let the loss of our friends be our only grief, and the apprehension of displeasing them our only fear. Leontion. No apostrophes ! no interjections ! your argument was unsound ; your means futile. Epicuriis. Tell me then, whether the horse of a rider on the road should not be spurred forward if he started at a shadow. Leontion. Yes. DEATH AND MORTALITY. 203 Epicurus. I thought so : it would however be better to guide him quietly up to it, and to show him that it was one. Death is less than a shadow : it represents nothing, even imperfectly. Leontion. Then at the best what is it ? why care about it, think about it, or remind us that it must befall us ? Would you take the same trouble, when you see my hair entwined with ivy, to make me remember that, although the leaves are green and pliable, the stem is fragile and rough, and that before I go to bed I shall have many knots and entanglements to extricate? Let me have them ; but let me not hear of them until the time is come. Epicurus. I would never think of death as an embar- rassment, but as a blessing. Ternissa. How ! a blessing ? Epicurus. What, if it makes our enemies cease to hate us ? What, if it makes our friends love us the more ? LXXVI. Marcus Tnlltns Cicero converses with his brother Qutnctus. Quinctus. Within how few minutes has the night closed in upon us ! Nothing is left discernible of the promontories, or the long irregular breakers under them. We have before us only a faint glimmering from the shells in our path, and from the blossoms of the arbutus. Marctts. The little solitary Circean hill, and even the nearer, loftier, and whiter rocks of Anxur, are become indistinguishable. We leave our Cato and our Lucullus, we leave Cornelia and her children, the scenes of friend- ship and the recollections of greatness, for Lepidus and Octavius and Antonius ; and who knows whether this birthday, between which and us so few days intervene, 204 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. may not be, as it certainly will be the least pleasurable, the last ! Quinctus. Do not despond, my brother ! Marcus. I am as far from despondency and dejection as from joy and cheerfulness. Death has two aspects : dreary and sorrowful to those of prosperous, mild and almost genial to those of adverse, fortune. Her counte- nance is old to the young, and youthful to the aged : to the former her voice is importunate, her gait terrific ; the latter she approaches like a bedside friend, and calls in a whisper that invites to rest. To us, my Quinctus, advanced as we are on our way, weary from its per- plexities and dizzy from its precipices, she gives a calm welcome ; let her receive a cordial one. If life is a present which any one foreknowing its con- tents would have willingly declined, does it not follow that any one would as willingly give it up, having well tried what they are ? I speak of the reasonable, the firm, the virtuous ; not of those who, like bad governors, are afraid of laying down the powers and privileges they have been proved unworthy of holding. Were it certain that the longer we live the wiser we become and the happier, then indeed a long life would be desirable : but since on the contrary our mental strength decays, and our enjoy- ments of every kind not only sink and cease, but diseases and sorrows come in place of them, if any wish is rational, it is surely the wish that we should go away unshaken by years, undepressed by griefs, and undespoiled of our better faculties. Life and death appear more certainly ours than whatsoever else : and yet hardly can that be called curs, which comes without our knowledge, and goes with- out it ; or that which we cannot put aside if we would, and indeed can anticipate but little. There are few who can regulate life to any extent ; none who can order the things it shall receive or exclude. What value then DEATH AND MORTALITY. 205 should be placed upon it by the prudent man when duty or necessity calls him away ? Or what reluctance should he feel on passing into a state where at least he must be conscious of fewer checks and inabilities? Such, my brother, as the brave commander, when from the secret and dark passages of some fortress wherein implacable enemies besieged him, having performed all his duties, and exhausted all his munition, he issues at a distance into open day. LXXVII. Ctzsar. To stand upon one's guard against Death exasperates her malice, and protracts our sufferings. LXXVIII. Ccesar. Life may concern us, death not ; for in death we neither can act nor reason, we neither can persuade nor command ; and our statues are worth more than we are, let them be but wax. LXXIX. Milton. We are all of the earth, earthly. They who are proud of family antiquity ought to be ashamed of beating a dog, who, we are certified, is of older creation. Probably the worms are of older still. Happily they are deaf and dumb ; if they had ears and tongues they would never so misapply them as we often do. We shall soon lie in the midst of them as quiet and mute as they are. We cause the bloodshed one of another, and often go far afield to chase the unoffending. The greediest worms are guiltless of the like ; they only exact what is their 206 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. inheritance ; we must pay them the debt we owe them ; let it be unreluctantly. LXXX. Vittoria Colonna. Before we go into another state of existence, a thousand things occur to detach us imper- ceptibly from this. To some (who knows to how many ?) the images of early love return with an inviting yet a saddening glance, and the breast that was laid out for the sepulchre bleeds afresh. Such are ready to follow where they are beckoned, and look keenly into the daik- ness they are about to penetrate. LIFE AND HUMAN NA TURE. LXXXI. Barrow. We must not indulge in unfavourable views of mankind, since by doing it we make bad men believe that they are no worse than others, and we teach the good that they are good in vain. Sidney. Goodness does not more certainly make men happy than happiness makes them good. LXXXIII. Vittoria Colonna. The beautiful in itself is useful by awakening our finer sensibilities, which it must be our own fault if we do not often carry with us into action. Barrow. Those who are quite satisfied, sit still and do nothing ; those who are not quite satisfied, are the sole benefactors of the world. LXXXV. Epicurus. Abstinence from low pleasures is the only means of meriting or of obtaining the higher. 208 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. LXXXVI, Bossiiet. There is no funeral so sad to follow as the funeral of our own youth, which we have been pampering with fond desires, ambitious hopes, and all the bright berries that hang in poisonous clusters over the path oi life. LXXXVII. LOVE OF POWER. La Fontaine. When I think, as you make me do, how ambitious men are, even those whose teeth are too loose (one would fancy) for a bite at so hard an apple as the devil of ambition offers them, I am inclined to believe that we are actuated not so much by selfishness as you represent it, but under another form, the love of power. Not to speak of territorial dominion or political office, and such other things as we usually class under its ap purtenances, do we not desire an exclusive control ovei what is beautiful and lovely ? the possession of pleasant fields, -of well-situated houses, of cabinets, of images, of pictures, and indeed of many things pleasant to see but useless to possess ; even of rocks, of streams, and of foun- tains ? These things, you will tell me, have their utility. True, but not to the wisher, nor does the idea of it enter his mind. Do not we wish that the object of our love should be devoted to us only; and that our children should love us better than their brothers and sisters, or even than the mother who bore them ? Love would be arrayed in the purple robe of sovereignty, mildly as he may resolve to exercise his power. LXXXVIII. Aspasia. We may be introduced to Power by Human- ity, and at first may love her less for her own sake than LIFE AND HUMAN NATURE. 2OQ for Humanity's, but by degrees we become so accustomed to her as to be quite uneasy without her. LXXXIX. Aspasia. Three affections of the soul predominate ; Love, Religion, and Power. The first two are often united ; the other stands widely apart from them, and neither is admitted nor seeks admittance to their society. Galileo. When Satan would have led our Saviour into temptation, he did not conduct him where the looser passions were wandering ; he did not conduct him amid flowers and herbage, where a fall would have only been a soilure to our frail human nature ; no, he led him up to an exceeding high mountain, and showed him palaces, and towers, and treasuries, knowing that it was by those alone that he himself could have been so utterly lost to rectitude and beatitude. Our Saviour spurned the temp- tation, and the greatest of his miracles was accomplished. xci. Diogenes. Great men too often have greater faults than little men can find room for. XCII. Marvel. Your conscientious men are oftener conscien- tious in withholding than in bestowing. Weak minds return men hatred for contempt, Strong ones contempt for hatred. Which is best ? P 210 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. XCIV. Pericles. Ridicule often parries resentment, but resent- ment never yet parried ridicule. xcv. Lucian. He who brings ridicule to bear against truth, finds in his hand a blade without a hilt. xcvi. Rochefoucauld. You may call every creature under heaven fool and rogue, and your auditor will join with you heartily : hint to him the slightest of his own defects or foibles, and he draws his rapier. You and he are the judges of the world, but not its denizens. xcvn. Granduke Peter Leopold. A man's vanity tells him what is honour, a man's conscience what is justice : the one is busy and importunate in all times and places : the other but touches the sleeve when men are alone, and, if they do not mind it, leaves them. XCVIII. VANITY IN WOMEN. Vittoria. Vanity in women is not invariably, though it is too often, the sign of a cold and selfish heart ; in men it always is : therefore we ridicule it in society, and in private hate it. In general, it may be apprehended, we like women little the better for excelling us even moderately in our LIFE AND HUMAN NATURE. 211 own acquirements and capacities. But what energy springs from her weaknesses ! what poetry is the fruit of her passions ! CleonZ. Take care, then, Aspasia ! do not leave off entirely all dissimulation. It is as feminine a virtue, and as necessary to a woman, as religion. If you are with- out it, you will have a grace the less, and (what you could worse spare) a sigh the more. Epicurus. Kindness in ourselves is the honey that blunts the sting of unkindness in another. Leontion. Explain to me then, O Epicurus, why we suffer so much from ingratitude. Epicurus. We fancy we suffer from ingratitude, while in reality we suffer from self-love. Passion weeps while she says, " I did not deserve this from him :" Reason, while she says it, smoothens her brow at the clear foun- tain of the heart. CII. Bossuet. An ingenuous mind feels in unmerited praise the bitterest reproof. If you reject it you are unhappy, if you accept it you are undone. cm. Vittoria Colonna. Wishes are by-paths on the declivity to unhappiness ; the weaker terminate in the sterile sand, the stronger in the vale of tears. 212 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. CIV. Wishes are by-paths to unhappiness, And in the vale of tears they terminate. CleonZ. Tears, O Aspasia, do not dwell long upon the cheeks of youth. Rain drops easily from the bud, rests on the bosom of the maturer flower, and breaks down that one only which hath lived its day. CVI. There are sweet flowers that only blow by night, And sweet tears are there that avoid the light ; No mortal sees them ; after day is born They, like the dew, drop trembling from their thorn. CVII. We often hear that such or such a thing " is not worth an old song." Alas ! how very few things are ! What precious recollections do some of them awaken ! What pleasurable tears do they excite ! They purify the stream of life ; they can delay it on its shelves and rapids ; they can turn it back again to the soft moss amidst which its sources issue. Dr. Johnson (to Home Tooke). Your former conversa- tion has made me think repeatedly what a number of beautiful words there are of which we never think of estimating the value, as there are of blessings. How carelessly, for example, do we (not we, but people) say, " I am delighted to hear from you" No other language LIFE AND HUMAN NATURE. 213 has this beautiful expression, which, like some of the most lovely flowers, loses its charm for want of close inspection. When I consider the deep sense of these very simple and veiy common words, I seem to hear a voice coming from afar through the air, breathed forth, and intrusted to the care of the elements, for the nurture of my sympathy. CIX. Milton. The sigh that rises at the thought of a friend may be almost as genial as his voice. 'Tis a breath that seems rather to come from him than from ourselves. CX. FRIENDSHIP. Pericles. The man who is determined to keep others fast and firm, must have one end of the bond about his own breast, sleeping and waking. CXI. Sidney. Friendship is a vase, which, when it is flawed by heat, or violence, or accident, may as well be broken at once ; it never can be trusted after. The more grace- ful and ornamental it was, the more clearly do we dis- cern the hopelessness of restoring it to its former state. Coarse stones, if they are fractured, may be cemented again ; precious ones never. CXII, Michelangelo. We may make a large hole in a brick 214 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. wall and easily fill it up ; but the slightest flaw in a ruby or a chrysolite is irreparable. Thus it is in minds. The ordinary soon take offence and (as they call it) make it up again ; the sensitive and delicate are long-suffering, but their wounds heal imperfectly, if at all. CXIII. TOWN AND COUNTRY. La Fontaine. The sweetest souls, like the sweetest flowers, soon canker in cities, and no purity is rarer there than the purity of delight. cxiv. Epicurus. To me there is this advantage in a place at some distance from the city. Having by no means the full possession of my faculties where I hear unwel- come and intrusive voices, or unexpected and irregular sounds that excite me involuntarily to listen, I assemble and arrange my thoughts with freedom and with pleasure in the fresh air, under the open sky : and they are more lively and vigorous and exuberant when I catch them as I walk about, and commune with them in silence and seclusion. Leontion. It always has appeared to me that conver- sation brings them forth more readily and plenteously ; and that the ideas of one person no sooner come out than another's follow them, whether from the same side or from the opposite. Epicurus. They do : but these are not the thoughts we keep for seed : they come up weak by coming up close together. In the country the mind is soothed and satisfied : here is no restraint of motion or of posture. LIFE AND HUMAN NATURE. 215 These things, little and indifferent as they may seem, are not so : for the best tempers have need of ease and liberty, to keep them in right order long enough for the purposes of composition : and many a froward axiom, many an inhumane thought, hath arisen from sitting inconveniently, from hearing a few unpleasant sounds, from the confinement of a gloomy chamber, or from the want of symmetry in it. We are not aware of this, until we find an exemption from it in groves, on promontories, or along the sea-shore, or wherever else we meet Nature face to face, undisturbed and solitary. cxv. Epicurus. Hither, to these banks of serpolet ; to these strawberries, whose dying leaves breathe a most refreshing fragrance ; to this ivy, from which Bacchus may have crowned himself ; let us retire at the voice of Discord. Whom should we contend with ? the less ? it were inglorious : the greater ? it were vain. Do we look for Truth ? she is not the inhabitant of cities nor delights in clamour : she steals upon the calm and meditative as Diana upon Endymion, indulgent in her chastity, en- couraging a modest, and requiting a faithful love. Leontion. How Temissa sighs after Truth ! Epicurus. If Truth appeared in daylight among mortals, she would surely resemble Ternissa. Those white and lucid cheeks, that youth which appears more youthful (for unless we are near her we think her yet a child), and that calm open forehead. Leontion. Malicious girl ! she conceals it ! Epicurus. Ingenuous girl ! the resemblance was, until now, imperfect. We must remove the veil ourselves ; for Truth, whatever the poets may tell us, never comes 2l6 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. without one, diaphanous or opaque. If those who differ on speculative points, would walk together now and then in the country, they might find many objects that must unite them. The same bodily feeling is productive in some degree of the same mental one. Enjoyment from sun and air, from exercise and odours, bring hearts together that schools and council-chambers and popular assemblies have stood between for years. CXVI. Epicurus. O sweet sea-air ! how bland art thou and refreshing ! Breathe upon Leontion ! breathe upon Ter- nissa ! bring them health and spirits and serenity, many springs and many summers, and when the vine-leaves have reddened and rustle under their feet. These, my beloved girls, are the children of Eternity : they played around Theseus and the beauteous Amazon, they gave to Pallas the bloom of Venus, and to Venus the animation of Pallas. Is it not better to enjoy by the hour their soft salubrious influence, than to catch by fits the rancid breath of demagogues ; than to swell and move under it without or against our will ; than to acquire the semblance of eloquence by the bitterness of passion, the tone of philosophy by disappointment, or the credit of prudence by distrust? Can fortune, can industry, can desert itself, bestow on us anything we have not here ? Leontion. And when shall those three meet? The gods have never united them, knowing that men would put them asunder at their first appearance. Epicurus. I am glad to leave the city as often as pos- sible, full as it is of high and glorious reminiscences, and am inclined much rather to indulge in quieter scenes, LIFE AND HUMAN NATURE. 217 whither the graces and friendship lead me. I would not contend even with men able to contend with me. You, Leontion, I see, think differently, and have com- posed at last your long-meditated work against the philo- sophy of Theophrastus. Leontion. Why not ? he has been praised above his merits. Epicurus. My Leontion ! you have inadvertently given me the reason and origin of all controversial writ- ings. They flow not from a love of truth or a regard for science, but from envy and ill-will. Setting aside the evil of malignity, always hurtful to ourselves, not always to others, there is weakness in the argument you have adduced. When a writer is praised above his merits in his own times, he is certain of being estimated below them in the times succeeding. Paradox is dear to most people : it bears the appearance of originality, but is usually the talent of the superficial, the perverse, and the obstinate. CXVII. LOVE OF TRUTH, Epicurus. Man is a hater of truth, a lover of fiction. Leontion. How then happens it that children, when you have related to them any story which has greatly in- terested them, ask immediately and impatiently, is it true ? Epicurus. Children are not men nor women : they are almost as different creatures, in many respects, as if they never were to be the one or the other : they are as unlike as buds are unlike flowers, and almost as blossoms are unlike fruits. Greatly. are they better than they are about to be, unless Philosophy raises her hand above them when the noon is coming on, and shelters them at 2l8 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. one season from the heats that would scorch and wither, and at another from the storms that would shatter and subvert them. CXVIII. Demosthenes. Who has ever wished to be persuaded against the grain in any matter of importance or utility ? A child, if you tell him a horrible or a pathetic story, is anxious to be persuaded it is true ; men and women, if you tell them one injurious to the respectability of a neighbour. Desire of persuasion rests and dies here. CXIX. Pollio. In one way or other (if not to you, to them- selves) most men delight in lying; all in being lied to, provided the lie be soft and gentle, and imperceptible in its approaches. cxx. Lord Brooke. Hardly anything which we receive for truth, is really and entirely so, let it appear as plain as it may, and let its appeal be not only to the understanding, but to the senses ; for our words do not follow them ex- actly ; and it is by words we receive truth and express it. CXXI. Thought fights with thought : out springs a spark of truth From the collision of the sword and shield. LIFE AND HUMAN NATURE. 2IQ Rochefoucauld. Many, indeed most people, will differ from me. Nothing is quite the same to the intellect of any two men, much less of all. When one says to another, " I am entirely of your opinion," he uses in general an easy and indifferent phrase, believing in its accuracy, without examination, without thought. The nearest resemblance in opinions, if we could trace every line of it, would be found greatly more divergent than the nearest in the human form or countenance, and in the same proportion as the varieties of mental qualities are more numerous and fine than of the bodily. CXXIII. QUICKNESS. Barrow. Quickness is among the least of the mind's properties, and belongs to her in almost her lowest state : nay, it doth not abandon her when she is driven from her home, when she is wandering and insane. The mad often retain it : the liar has it, the cheat has it : we find it on the race-course and at the card-table : educa- tion does not give it, and reflection takes away from it. cxxiv. Demosthenes. It is easier to make an impression upon sand than upon marble : but it is easier to make a just one upon marble than upon sand. cxxv. Barroi.v. That lesson which a dunce can learn at a glance, and likes mightily, must contain little, and not good. cxxvi. Cleont. The young mind should be nourished with simple 220 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. and grateful food, and not too copious. It should be little exercised until its nerves and muscles show themselves, and even then rather for air than anything else. Study is the bane of boyhood, the aliment of youth, the indulg- ence of manhood, and the restorative of age. Barrow. Do not fear to be less rich in the produc- tions of your mind at one season than at another. Marshes are always marshes, and pools are pools ; but the sea, in those places where we admire it most, is sometimes sea and sometimes dry land ; sometimes it brings ships into port, and sometimes it leaves them where they can be refitted and equipt. The capa- cious mind neither rises nor sinks, neither labours nor rests, in vain. Even in those intervals when it loses the consciousness of its powers, when it swims as it were in vacuity, and feels not what is external nor internal, it acquires or recovers strength, as the body does by sleep. CXXVIII. Cleont. I do believe, Aspasia, that studious men, who look so quiet, are the most restless men in existence. CXXIX. IDLENESS. Ternissa. Leontion said that even bad writers may amuse our idle hours. Alas ! even good ones do not much amuse mine, unless they record an action of love or generosity. As for the graver, why cannot they come among us and teach us, just as you do ? LIFE AND HUMAN NATURE. 221 Epicurus. Would you wish it ? Ternissa. No, no ; I do not want them : only I was imagining how pleasant it is to converse as we are doing, and how sorry I should be to pore over a book instead of it. Books always make me sigh and think about other things. Why do you laugh, Leontion ? Epicurus. She was mistaken in saying bad authors may amuse our idleness. Leontion knows not then how sweet and sacred idleness is. Leontion. To render it sweet and sacred, the heart must have a little garden of its own, with its umbrage and fountains and perennial flowers; a careless com- pany ! Sleep is called sacred as well as sweet by Homer : and idleness is but a step from it. The idle- ness of the wise and virtuous should be both, it being the repose and refreshment necessary for past exertions and for future : it punishes the bad man, it rewards the good : the deities enjoy it, and Epicurus praises it. LOVE, MARRIAGE, AND FAMILY AFFECTION. cxxx. Anaxagoras. Is it not in philosophy as in love? the more we have of it, and the less we talk about it, the better. cxxxi. Messala. From the mysteries of religion the veil is seldom to be drawn, from the mysteries of love never. For this offence the gods take away from us our freshness of heart and our susceptibility of pure delight. The well loses the spring that fed it, and what is exposed in the shallow basin soon evaporates. Panatius. Where Love finds the soul he neglects the body, and only turns to it in his idleness as to an after- thought. Its best allurements are but the nuts and figs of the divine repast. CXXXIII. Aspasia. The happiest of pillows is not that which Love first presses ; it is that which Death has frowned on and passed over. LOVE, MARRIAGE, FAMILY AFFECTION. 223 CXXXIV. CleonZ. The very beautiful rarely love at all. Those precious images are placed above the reach of the Passions. Time alone is permitted to efface them ; Time, the father of the gods, and even their consumer. CXXXV. LOVE'S TIMIDITY. CleonL Could Sappho be ignorant how infantinely inarticulate is early love? Could she be ignorant that shame and fear seize it unrelentingly by the throat, while hard-hearted impudence stands at ease, prompt at oppor- tunity, and profuse in declarations ! There is a gloom in deep love, as in deep water : there is a silence in it which suspends the foot, and the folded arms and the dejected head are the images it reflects. No voice shakes its surface : the Muses themselves appr&ach it with a tardy and a timid step, and with a low and tremulous and melancholy song. CXXXVI. Lord Brooke. Women have no favour t>r mercy for the silence their charms impose on us. Little are they aware of the devotion we are offering to them, in that state whereinto the true lover is ever prone to fall, and which appears to them inattention, indifference, or moroseness. CXXXVII. Lord Brooke. When a woman hath ceased to be quite the same to us, it matters little how different she becomes. 224 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. Sidney. Hush ! I will hear from you no sentiment but your own, and this can never be yours. Variations there are of temperature in the finest season ; and the truest heart has not always the same pulsations. If we had nothing to pardon or to be pardoned,, we might appear to be more perfect than we are, but we should in fact be less so. Self-love is ungenerous and unforgiving; love grieves and forgives. CXXXVIII. LOVE AND GENIUS. Michelangelo. Ah ! there is love too, even here below, more precious than immortality ; but it is not the love of a Circe or a Calypso. Vittoria Colonna. Nor were they happy themselves ; and yet perhaps they were not altogether undeserving of it, they who could select for the object of their affections the courageous, the enduring, and the intelligent. There are few men at any time whom moral dignity and eleva- tion of genius have made conspicuous above the mass of society ; and fewer still are the women who can dis- tinguish them from persons of ordinary capacity, endowed with qualities merely agreeable. But if it happens that a man of highest worth has been read attentively and thoroughly by those eyes which he has taught the art of divination, let another object intervene and occupy their attention, let the beloved be induced to think it a merit and a duty to forget him, yet memory is not an outcast nor an alien when the company of the day is gone, but says many things and asks many questions which she would not turn away from if she could. CXXXIX. MARRIAGE. Mr. Tallboys. Death itself to the reflecting mind is less LOVE, MARRIAGE, FAMILY AFFECTION. 225 serious than marriage. The older plant is cut down that the younger may have room to flourish : a few tears drop into the loosened soil, and buds and blossoms spring over it. Death is not even a blow ; is not even a pulsation ; it is a pause. But marriage unrolls the awful lot of numberless generations. Health, Genius, Honour, are the words inscribed on some ; on others are Disease, Fatuity, and Infamy. Diogenes. There are many who marry from utter indi- gence of thought, captivated by the playfulness of youth, as if a kitten were never to be a cat 1 CXLI. Marvel. Men who have been unsparing of their wis- dom, like ladies who have been unfrugal of their favours, are abandoned by those who owe most to them, and hated or slighted by the rest. I wish beauty in her lost estate had consolations like genius. Parker. Fie, fie I Mr. Marvel ! Consolations for frailty ! Marvel. What wants them more? The reed is cut down, and seldom does the sickle wound the hand that cuts it. There it lies ; trampled on, withered, and soon to be blown away. Parker. We should be careful and circumspect in our pity, and see that it falls on clean ground. Such a laxity of morals can only be taught in Mr. Milton's school. He composed, I remember, a Treatise on Divorce, and would have given it great facilities. Q 226 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. Marvel. He proved by many arguments what requires but few : that happiness is better than unhappiness ; that, when two persons cannot agree, it is wiser and more Christian-like that they should not disagree ; that, when they cease to love each other, it is something if they be hindered by the gentlest of checks, from running to the extremity of hatred ; and lastly, how it conduces to cir- cumspection and forbearance to be aware that the bond of matrimony is not indissoluble, and that the bleeding heart may be saved from bursting. Parker. Monstrous sophistry ! abominable doctrines ! What more, sir ? what more ? Marvel. * * * Milton has, I am afraid, imitated too closely the authoritative voice of the patriarchs, and been somewhat too Oriental (I forbear to say Scrip- tural) in his relations as a husband. But who, whether among the graver or less grave, is just to woman ? There may be moments when the beloved tells us, and 1 tells us truly, that we are dearer to her than life. Is not this enough? is it not above all merit? yet, if ever the ardour of her enthusiasm subsides ; if her love ever loses later in the day, the spirit and vivacity of its early dawn ; if between the sigh and the blush an interval is perceptible ; if the arm mistakes the chair for the shoulder ; what an outcry is there ! what a proclamation of her injustice and her inconstancy ! what an alternation of shrinking and spurning at the coldness of her heart ! Do we ask within if our own has retained all its ancient loyalty, all its own warmth, and all that was poured into it ? Often the true lover has little of true love compared with what he has undeservedly received and unreasonably exacts. But let it also be remembered that marriage is the metempsychosis of women ; that it turns them into different creatures from what they were before. Liveli ness in the girl may have been mistaken for good-temper ; LOVE, MARRIAGE, FAMILY AFFECTION. 227 the little pervicacity which at first is attractively provok- ing, at last provokes without its attractiveness : negligence of order and propriety, of duties and civilities, long endured, often deprecated, ceases to be tolerable, when children grow up and are in danger of following the example. It often happens that, if a man unhappy in the married state were to disclose the manifold causes of his uneasiness, they would be found, by those who were beyond their influence, to be of such a nature as rather to excite derision than sympathy. The waters of bitterness do not fall on his head in a cataract, but through a colan- der ; one, however, like the vases of the Danaides, per- forated only for replenishment. We know scarcely the vestibule of a house of which we fancy we have penetrated into all the corners. We know not how grievously a man may have suffered, long before the calumnies of the world befell him as he reluctantly left his house-door. There are women from whom incessant tears of anger swell forth at imaginary wrongs; but of contrition for their own delinquencies, not one. Milton, in writing his treatise, of which probably the first idea was suggested from his own residence, was aware that the laws should provide, not only against our violence and injustice, but against our levity and incon- stancy ; and that a man's capriciousness or satiety should not burst asunder the ties by which families are united. Do you believe that the crime of adultery has never been committed to the end of obtaining a divorce ? Do you believe that murder, that suicide, never has been com- mitted because a divorce was unattainable? Thus the most cruel tortures are terminated by the most frightful crimes. Milton has made his appeal to the authority of religion : we lower our eyes from him, and point to the miseries and guilt on every side before us, caused by the corrosion or the violent disruption of bonds which human- 228 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. ity would have loosened. He would have tried with a patient ear and with a delicate hand the chord that offended by its harshness ; and, when he could not reduce it to the proper tone, he would remove it for another. CXLII. LOVE OF CHILDREN. Princess Dashkof. Even the worst husband must have surely the recollection of some sweet moments. The stern- est must have trembled, both with apprehension and with hope, at the first alteration in the health of his consort ; at the first promise of true union, imperfect without progeny. Then there are thanks rendered together to heaven, and satisfactions communicated, and infant words interpreted : and when the one has failed to pacify the sharp cries of babyhood, pettish and impatient as sovranty itself, the success of the other in calming it, and the un- envied triumph of this exquisite ambition, and the calm gazes that it wins upon it. CXLIII. Milton. Will there never be a time when every mother will be the priestess of her children and family? Our duties are simple and learnt easily. No sunrise but awakens one or other of them into activity and growth. Boys are educated, girls are not ; yet girls should be educated first, and taught the most impressively. These slender and graceful columns are not only the ornament, but also the support, of society. Men are the braver for the reverence they bear toward them, and in them do they find their reward. LOVE, MARRIAGE, FAMILY AFFECTION. 229 CXLIV. Aspasia. We are told by Herodotus that a boy in Persia is kept in the apartments of the women, and pro- hibited from seeing his father, until the fifth year. The reason is, he informs us, that if he dies before this age, his loss may give the parent no uneasiness. And such a custom he thinks commendable. Herodotus has no child, Cleone ! If he had, far other would be his feelings and his judgment. Before that age, how many seeds are sown, which future years, and distant ones, mature successively ! How much fondness, how much gener- osity, what hosts of other virtues, courage, constancy, patriotism, spring into the father's heart from the cradle of his child ! And does never the fear come over him, that what is most precious to him upon earth is left in careless or perfidious, in unsafe or unworthy hands? Does it never occur to him that he loses a son in every one of these five years ? What is there so affecting to the brave and virtuous man, as that which perpetually wants his help and cannot call for it ? What is so differ- ent as the speaking and the mute ? And hardly less so are inarticulate sounds, and sounds which he receives half -formed, and which he delights to modulate, and which he lays with infinite care and patience, not only on the tender attentive ear, but on the half-open lips, and on the eyes, and on the cheeks ; as if they all were listeners. In every child there are many children ; but coming forth year after year, each somewhat like and somewhat vary- ing. When they are grown much older, the leaves (as it were) lose their pellucid green, the branches their grace- ful pliancy. Is there any man so rich in happiness that he can afford to throw aside these first five years ? is there any man who can hope for another five so exuberant in unsating joy ? 230 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. Aspasia. Where on earth is there so much society as in a beloved child ? He accompanies me in my walks, gazes into my eyes for what I am gathering from books, tells me more and better things than they do, and asks me often what neither I nor they can answer. When he is absent I am filled with reflections : when he is present I have room for none beside what I receive from him. The charms of his childhood bring me back to the delights of mine, and I fancy I hear my own words in a sweeter voice. Will he (O how I tremble at the mute oracle of futurity !) will he ever be as happy as I have been ? Alas ! and must he ever be as subject to fears and apprehensions ? No ; thanks to the gods ! never, never. He carries his father's heart within his breast : I see him already an orator and a leader, I try to teach him daily some of his father's looks and gestures, and I never smile but at his docility and gravity. How his father will love him ! the little thunderer ! the winner of cities ! the vanquisher of Cleones ! Cicero. The pleasure a man receives from his children resembles that which, with more propriety than any other, we may attribute to the Divinity. CXLVII. Marcus Tullius Cicero converses with his brother Quinctus. Quinctus. Proceed, my brother ! for in every depres- sion of mind, in every excitement of feeling, my spirits are equalised by your discourse; and that which you LOVE, MARRIAGE, FAMILY AFFECTION. 23! said with too much brevity of our children, soothes me greatly. Marcus. I am persuaded of the truth in what I have spoken ; and yet ah, Quinctus ! there is a tear that philosophy cannot dry, and a pang that will rise as we approach the gods. Two things tend beyond all others, after philosophy, to inhibit and check our ruder passions as they grow and swell in us, and to keep our gentler in their proper play : and these two things are, seasonable sorrow and inoffen- sive pleasure, each moderately indulged. Nay, there is also a pleasure, humble, it is true, but graceful and insinuating, which follows close upon our very sorrows, reconciles us to them gradually, and sometimes renders us at last undesirous altogether of abandoning them. If ever you have remembered the anniversary of some day whereon a dear friend was lost to you, tell me whether that anniversary was not purer and even calmer than the day before. The sorrow, if there should be any left, is soon absorbed, and full satisfaction takes the place of it, while you perform a pious office to friendship, required and appointed by the ordinances of Nature. When my Tulliola was torn away from me, a thousand plans were in readiness for immortalising her memory, and raising a monument up to the magnitude of my grief. The grief itself has done it : the tears I then shed over her assuaged it in me, and did everything that could be done for her, or hoped, or wished. I called upon Tulliola ; Rome and the whole world heard me : her glory was a part of mine, and mine of hers ; and when Eternity had received her at my hands, I wept no longer. The tenderness wherewith I mentioned and now mention her, though it suspends my voice, brings what consoles and comforts me : it is the milk and honey left at the sepulchre, and equally sweet (I hope) to the departed. 232 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. The gods who have given us our affections, permit us surely the uses and the signs of them. Immoderate grief, like everything else immoderate, is useless and pernicious ; but if we did not tolerate and endure it, if we did not prepare for it, meet it, commune with it, if we did not even cherish it in its season, much of what is best in our faculties, much of our tenderness, much of our generosity, much of our patriotism, much also of our genius, would be stifled and extinguished. When I hear any one call upon another to be manly and to restrain his tears, if they flow from the social and kind affections I doubt the humanity and distrust the wisdom of the counsellor. Were he humane, he would be more inclined to pity and to sympathise than to lecture and reprove ; and were he wise, he would consider that tears are given us by nature as a remedy to affliction, although, like other remedies, they should come to our relief in private. CXLVIII. Boccaccio. The noble mansion is most distinguished by the beautiful images it retains of beings passed away ; and so is the noble mind. MANNERS, SOCIETY, AND NATIONAL CHARACTER. CXLIX. WOMEN'S DRESS. Cleonl (writing to Aspasia at Athens}. Epimedea, it appears, has not corrupted very grossly your purity and simplicity in dress. Yet, remembering your ob- servation on armlets, I cannot but commend your kind- ness and sufferance in wearing her emeralds. Your opinion was formerly that we should be careful not to subdivide our persons. The arm is composed of three parts; no one of them is too long. Now the armlet intersects that portion of it which must be considered as the most beautiful. In my idea of the matter, the sandal alone is susceptible of gems, after the zone has received the richest. The zone is necessary to our vesture, and encompasses the person, in every quarter of the humanised world, in one invariable manner. The hair, too, is divided by nature in the middle of the head. There is a cousinship between the hair and the flowers ; and from this relation the poets have called by the same name the leaves and it. They appear on the head as if they had been seeking one another. Our national dress, very dif- ferent from the dresses of barbarous nations, is not the invention of the ignorant or the slave ; but the sculptor, the painter, and the poet, have studied how best to adorn the most beautiful object of their fancies and con- templations. The Indians, who believe that human pains OF XTTTT -' 234 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. and sufferings are pleasing to the deity, make incisions in their bodies, and insert into them imperishable colours. They also adorn the ears and noses and foreheads of their gods. These were the ancestors of the Egyptian ; we chose handsomer and better-tempered ones for our wor- ship, but retained the same decorations in our sculpture, and to a degree which the sobriety of the Egyptian had reduced and chastened. Hence we retain the only mark of barbarism which dishonours our national dress, the use of earrings. If our statues should all be broken by some convulsion of the earth, would it be believed by future ages that, in the country and age of Sophocles, the women tore holes in their ears to let rings into, as the more brutal of peasants do with the snouts of sows J CL. SCENTS AND THEIR ASSOCIATIONS. Aspasia (writing to CleonZ at Miletus}. Thanks for the verses ! I hope Leuconoe was as grateful as I am, and as sensible to their power of soothing. Thanks too for the perfumes ! Pericles is ashamed of acknowledging he is fond of them ; but I am resolved to betray one secret of his : I have caught him several times trying them as he ca'lled it. How many things are there that people pretend to dislike, without any reason, as far as we know, for the dislike or the pretence ! I love sweet odours. Surely my Cleone herself must have breathed her very soul into these ! Let me smell them again : let me inhale them into the sanctuary of my breast, lighted up by her love for their reception. But, ah, Cleone ! what an importunate and exacting creature is Aspasia ! Have you no willows fresh peeled ? None lying upon the bank, for baskets, white, rounded, MANNERS, SOCIETY, NATIONAL CHARACTER. 235 and delicate, as your fingers ! How fragrant they were formerly ! I have seen none lately. Do you remember the cross old Hermesianax ? how he ran to beat us for breaking his twigs ? and how, after looking in our faces, he seated himself down again, finished his basket, dis- bursed from a goat- skin a corroded clod of rancid cheese, put it in, pushed it to us, forced it under my arm, told us to carry it home with the gods ! and lifted up both hands and blest us. I do not wish that one exactly ; cheese is the cruellest of deaths to me ; and Pericles abhors it. I am running over trifling occurrences which you must have forgotten. You are upon the spot, and have no occasion to call to memory how the munificent old basket- maker looked after us not seeing his dog at our heels ; how we coaxed the lean, shaggy, suspicious animal ; how many devices we contrived to throw down, or let slip, so that the good man might not observe it, the pestilence you insisted on carrying ; how many names we called the dog by ere we found the true one, Cyrus ; how when we had drawn him behind the lentisk, we rewarded him for his assiduities, holding each an ear nevertheless, that he might not carry back the gift to his master ; and how we laughed at our fears, when a single jerk of the head served at once to engulf the treasure and to disengage him. I shall always love the smell of the peeled willow. Have you none for me ? Is there no young poplar then, with a tear in his eye on bursting into bud ? I am not speaking by metaphor and Asiatically. I want the pop- lars, the willows, the water-lilies, and the soft green herbage. How we enjoyed it on the Mseander ! what liberties we took with it ! robbing it of the flowers it had educated, of those it was rearing, of those that came confidently out to meet us, and of those that hid them- 236 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. selves. None escaped us. For these remembrances, green is the colour I love best. It brings me to the Fortunate Island of my Cleone ; it brings me back to childhood, the proud little nurse of Youth, brighter of eye and lighter of heart than Youth herself. These are not regrets, Cleone ; they are respirations necessary to existence. You may call them half- wishes if you will. We are poor indeed when we have no half- wishes left us. The heart and the imagination close the shutters the instant they are gone. Do not chide me then for coming to you after the blossoms and buds and herbage ; do not keep to your- self all the grass on the Mseander. We used to share it ; we will now. I love it wherever I can get a glimpse of it. It is the home of the eyes, ever ready to receive them, and spreading its cool couch for their repose. CLI. SOCIETY AND SOLITUDE. Epicurus. To be wise indeed and happy and self- possessed, we must often be alone : we must mix as little as we can with what is called society, and abstain rather more than seems desirable even from the better few. Ternissa. You have commanded us at all times to ask you anything we do not understand : why then use the phrase "what is called society"? as if there could be a doubt whether we are in society when we converse with many. Epicurus. We may meet and converse with thousands : you and Leontion and myself could associate with few. Society ', in the philosophical sense of the word, is almost the contrary of what it is in the common acceptation. MANNERS, SOCIETY, NATIONAL CHARACTER. 237 CLII. Epicurus. Dinner is a less gratification to me than to many : I dine alone. Ternissa. Why? Epicurus. To avoid the noise, the heat, and the inter- mixture both of odours and of occupations. I cannot bear the indecency of speaking with a mouth in which there is food. I careen my body (since it is always in want of repair) in as unobstructed a space as I can, and I lie down and sleep awhile when the work is over. Lucullus. To dine in company with more than two is a Gaulish and a German thing. I can hardly bring myself to believe that I have eaten in concert with twenty ; so barbarous and herdlike a practice does it now appear to me : such an incentive to drink much and talk loosely ; not to add, such a necessity to speak loud, which is clownish and odious in the extreme. Pericles. Politeness is in itself a power, and takes away the weight and galling from every other that we may exercise. CLV. Pericles. Every time we pronounce a word differently from another, we show our disapprobation of his manner, and accuse him of rusticity. In all common things we must do as others do. It is more barbarous to under- mine the stability of a language than of an edifice that hath stood as long. This is done by the introduction of changes. Write as others do, but only as the best of 238 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. others : and if one eloquent man, forty or fifty years ago, spoke and wrote differently from the generality of the present, follow him, though alone, rather than the many. But in pronunciation we are not indulged in this latitude of choice ; we must pronounce as those do who favour us with their audience. CLVI. Petrarca. Nobody ever quite forgave, unless in the low and ignorant, a wrong pronunciation of his name ; the humblest being of opinion that they have one of their own, and one both worth having and worth knowing. CLVII. Aspasia. Men may be negligent in their handwriting, for men may be in a hurry about the business of life ; but I never knew either a sensible woman or an estimable one whose writing was disorderly. CLVIII. Johnson. And pray, now, what language do you like ? Home Tooke. The best in all countries is that which is spoken by intelligent women, of too high rank for petty affectation, and of too much request in society for deep study. CLIX. Cleone. There is nothing in poetry, or indeed in society, so unpleasant as affectation. In poetry it arises from a deficiency of power and a restlessness of pretension : in conversation, from insensibility to the graces, from an MANNERS, SOCIETY, NATIONAL CHARACTER. 239 intercourse with bad company, and a misinterpretation of belter. CLX, Metastasio. False delicacy is real indelicacy. Half- educated men employ the most frequently circumlocutions and ambiguities. The plain vulgar are not the most vulgar. CLXI. MEN AND DOGS. M. La Fontaine apologises to M. de La Rochefoucauld. La Fontaine. You have been standing a long time, my lord duke : I must entreat you to be seated. Rochefoucauld. Excuse me, my dear M. La Fontaine ; I would much rather stand. La Fontaine. Mercy on us ! have you been upon your legs ever since you rose to leave me ? Rochefoucauld. A change of position is agreeable : a friend always permits it. La Fontaine. Sad doings ! sad oversight ! The other two chairs were sent yesterday evening to be scoured and mended. But that dog is the best - tempered dog ! an angel of a dog, I do assure you ; he would have gone down in a moment, at a word. I am quite ashamed of myself for such inattention. With your sentiments of friendship for me, why could you not have taken the liberty to shove him gently off, rather than give me this uneasiness ? Rochefoucauld. My true and kind friend ! we authors are too sedentary; we are heartily glad of standing to converse, whenever we can do it without any restraint on our acquaintance. La Fontaine. I must reprove that animal when he un- 240 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. curls his body. He seems to be dreaming of Paradise and Houris. Ay, twitch thy ear, my child ! I wish at my heart there were as troublesome a fly about the other : God forgive me ! The rogue covers all my clean linen ! shirt and cravat ! what cares he J Rochefoucauld. Dogs are not very modest. La Fontaine. Never say that, M. de la Rochefoucauld ! The most modest people upon earth ! Look at a dog's eyes ; and he half- closes them, or gently turns them away, with a motion of the lips, which he licks languidly, and of the tail, which he stirs tremulously, begging your forbearance. I am neither blind nor indifferent to the defects of these good and generous creatures. They are subject to many such as men are subject to : among the rest, they disturb the neighbourhood in the discussion of their private causes ; they quarrel and fight on small motives, such as a little bad food, or a little vain-glory, or the sex. But it must be something present or near that excites them ; and they calculate not the extent of evil they may do or suffer. Rochefoucauld. Certainly not : how should dogs calcu- late? La Fontaine. I know nothing of the process. I am unable to inform you how they leap over hedges and brooks, with exertion just sufficient, and no more. In regard to honour and a sense of dignity, let me tell you, a dog accepts the subsidies of his friends, but never claims them : a dog would not take the field to obtain power for a son, but leave the son to obtain it by his own activity and prowess. He conducts his visitor or inmate out a- hunting, and makes a present of the game to him as freely as an emperor to an elector. Fond as he is of slumber, which is indeed one of the pleasantest and best things in the universe, particularly after dinner, he shakes it off as willingly as he would a gadfly, in order to defend his MANNERS, SOCIETY, NATIONAL CHARACTER. 241 master from theft and violence. Let the robber or assail- ant speak as courteously as he may, he waives your diplo- matical terms, gives his reasons in plain language, and makes war. I could say many other things to his advan- tage ; but I never was malicious, and would rather let both parties plead for themselves : give me the dog, however. CLXII. Marvel. I look to a person of very old family as I do to anything else that is very old, and I thank him for bring- ing to me a page of romance which probably he himself never knew or heard about. Usually, with all his pride and pretensions, he is much less conscious of the services his ancestor performed, than my spaniel is of his own when he carries my glove or cane to me. I would pat them both on the head for it ; and the civiler and more reasonable of the two would think himself well rewarded. CLXIII. ENGLISH HOSPITALITY. The Portuguese prince Dont Miguel describes to his mother his treatment as a guest in the house of Lord Dudley. Mother. Did he treat you handsomely, my child ? Miguel. Handsomely, for a heretic. He gave me plenty of fish and eggs both Fridays and Saturdays, People say he has in his service one of the best cooks in England : yet you will laugh when you hear how he cooked things. The eggs in England are not unlike ours. They have escaped the effects of what is miscalled the Reformation. Fish, I just now told you, they have in that country : but they are somewhat deficient in the nobler species no bonita, no dolphin ;.and porpoises and seals must be ex- R 242 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. cessively dear, and the fishermen very inexpert in catching them, not a single slice having ever been offered to me at the best covered and most delicate table. They seem really to prefer the coarser kinds. The Mayor of London sent, as a present to Conde Dudeli, a prodigious fish he called sturgeon, a sort of dog-fish, but of the mastiff breed, and uncontrollable by cookery. Perhaps much of the deal timber, which bears a heavy duty in the port of London, is smuggled under the name of sturgeon. Mother. Never hint it to them : let the knaves be cheated in the customs. Poor Miguel ! so they reduced thee to eat chips and shavings and splinters and blocks ! What ! nothing more delicate ? Miguel. I once was served with what I flattered myself were surely snails, but I found they were only oysters. Another time, when I fancied I had a fine cuttle-fish before me, they put me off with a sole. Mother. Heretics ! heretics ! poor blind creatures ! little better than Moors, Jews, and Freemasons ! Miguel. I' have tasted in England eight or nine different kinds of soup ; and vainly have I sounded the most promis- ing of them for a single morsel of fat bacon or fresh pork. Mother. Have they no chestnuts and acorns, then ? or are all the pigs kept to clean the streets ? Miguel. I do not know : but neither fat bacon nor lean ever enters their soup ; nor does pork, nor sausage, nor heart, nor liver, nor caviar, nor vetch, nor gourd, nor oil, nor cheese. Mother. Ha ! ha ! I see how it is. They must trade with some nations where cheese, and oil, and caviar, and gourd, and vetch are always in great demand ; and these they export for lucre. And perhaps their animals have no heart or liver within them. But sausage, and pork, and bacon Son Miguel ! don't you smell something there ? The English are Jews in disguise : I often thought MANNERS, SOCIETY, NATIONAL CHARACTER. 243 as much. They won't have Virgin, they won't have Child, they won't have bacon. Miguel. I did not say quite that. They eat swine-flesh : bacon has been brought to me at table: I have seen them eat it, though strangely. Mother. With what forms and ceremonies ? Miguel. Little of those ; for in the mere act of eating, they really are adepts, and very explicit. Mother. How then ? how then ? I crack to hear. Miguel. Boiled, actually boiled ! hot, smoking hot ! and served up whole ! Mother. Smoking a little, but put into ice, no doubt, to render it eatable, with the radishes, figs, shalots, chives, bean-pods, green almond -shells, liquorice, and stewed prunes. Miguel. I never saw those with it all the while I was in England ; but I once observed it eaten with half-grown peas ; and another time a Minister of State was so pre- occupied by stress of business, that he forgot there was chicken on his plate, and (as I live) ate both together. Mother. And they gave you neither stewed prunes nor figs ^ith it ! My son, they slighted you out of hatred to me, who always had an eye upon them, which they never could bear. Ham before a queen's son in this naked fashion ! And forsooth they talk about alliance I Miguel. It was Friday, and there were several kinds of fish at table ; and knowing that I could eat little else, and observing that I had been helped to a slice of turbot, and had requested a trifle of assafoetida, and a few lumps of sugar and a pinch of saffron, and a radish and a dande lion, a servant brought me a lobster, well enough cut into pieces, but swimming, or bemired rather, in a semi-liquid 244 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. paste of flour and butter : and though he saw I had turbot before me, and had heard me call for oil and vinegar and grated goat -cheese, which a civiler valet had already brought, he bowed with the gravest face in the world, and offered me the two fish together, to say nothing of the butter. I took it ill, but sate silent. To appease my just resentment, the rest of the company did actually eat both at once, and some of them so heartily, it was evident they wished me to believe it is the custom of the country. Mother. Fit punishment ! though imposed by them- selves. Strange uncivilised people ! It may be, how- . ever, that this is their way of fasting : for they have some notions of religion, though erroneous and foolish. Miguel. Mother, nothing can escape your sagacity and penetration : you are perfectly right. And now I re- member another fast of theirs, kept in perverseness on Monday. Count Dudeli had partridges at table ; and I observed that he took a piece of bread poultice, brought hot to him from a hospital, and ate it with the breast of the bird. The others thought to get offices under him by doing the same ; and, although several did it, there was not one that was forced to leave the company : such strong stomachs have the English. CLXV. Alfieri. The Spaniards have no palate, the Italians no scent, the French no ear. Garlic and grease and the most nauseous of pulse are the favourite cheer of the Spaniard ; the olfactory nerves of the Italian endure any- thing but odoriferous flowers and essences ; and no sounds but soft ones offend the Frenchman. CLXV I. Boccaccio. The Frenchman is ready to truss you on his MANNERS, SOCIETY, NATIONAL CHARACTER. 245 rapier, unless you acknowledge the perfection of his humanity, and to spit in your face, if you. doubt for a moment the delicacy of his politeness. CLXVII. Alfieri. It is easier to get twenty oaths and curses from an Englishman than one tear ; but there are hot springs at the centre of his heart which bring forth perpetual fertility. He puts unhappiness down despotically, and will labour at doing good if you abstain from looking at him while he does it. CLXVII I. ITALIAN TASTE AND THE LOVE OF TREES. Landor, being at Genoa, converses "with his landlord, the Marchese Pallavicini. Landor. I am pleased by the palace opposite, not hav- ing seen in Italy, until now, a house of any kind with a span of turf before it. Like yours and your neighbour's, they generally encroach on some lane, following its wind- ings and angles, lest a single inch of ground should be lost ; and the roofs fight for the centre of the road. I am inclined to believe that the number of houses of which the fronts are uneven, is greater than of the even, and that there are more cramped with iron than uncramped. These deformities are always left visible, though the house be plastered, that the sum expended on the iron and labour may be evident. If an Italian spends a livre, he must be seen to spend it : his stables, his laundry, his domestics, his peasants, must strike the eye together : his pigstye must have witnesses like his will. Every tree is accursed, as that of which the holy cross was fabricated, and must be swept away. When I resided on the Lake of Como, I visited the 246 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. palace of Marchese Odescalchi. Before it swelled in majesty that sovran of inland waters ; behind it was a pond surrounded with brickwork, in which about twenty young goldfish jostled and gaped for room. The Larius had sapped the foundations of his palace, and the Mar- chese had exerted all his genius to avenge himself: he composed this bitter parody. I inquired of his cousin Don Pepino, who conducted me, when the roof would be put on. He looked at me, doubting if he understood me, and answered in a gentle tone, " It was finished last summer." My error originated from observing red pan- tiles, kept in their places by heavy stones, loose, and laid upon them irregularly. "What a beautiful swell, Don Pepino, is this upon the right," exclaimed I. " The little hill seems sensible of pleasure as he dips his foot into the Larius." "There will be the offices." "What! and hide the Grumello? Let me enjoy the sight while I can. He appears instinct with life, nodding the network of vines upon his head, and beckoning and inviting us, while the fig-trees and mulberries and chest- nuts and walnuts, and those lofty and eternal cypresses, stand motionless around. His joyous mates, all different in form and features, push forward ; and if there is not something in the air, or something in my eyesight, illusory, they are running a race along the borders. Stop a moment : how shall we climb over these two enormous pines ? Ah ! Don Pepino, old trees in their living state are the only things that money cannot command. Rivers leave their beds, run into cities, and traverse mountains for it ; obelisks and arches, palaces and temples, amphi- theatres and pyramids, rise up like exhalations at its bidding ; even the free spirit of man, the only thing great on earth, crouches and cowers in its presence it passes away and vanishes before venerable trees. What a sweet MANNERS, SOCIETY, NATIONAL CHARACTER. 247 odour is there ? Whence comes it ? Sweeter it appears to me and stronger than of the pine itself." " I imagine," said he, " from the linden ; yes, certainly." " Is that a linden? It is the largest, and, I should imagine, the oldest upon earth, if I could perceive that it had lost any of its branches. " " Pity that it hides half the row of yon houses from the palace ! It will be carried off with the two pines in the autumn." " O Don Pepino," cried I ; "the French, who abhor whatever is old and whatever is great, have spared it ; the Austrians, who sell their fortresses and their armies, nay, sometimes their daughters, have not sold it must it fall?" * * How many fond and how many lively thoughts have been nurtured under this tree ! how many kind hearts have beaten here ! Its branches are not so numerous as the couples they have invited to sit beside it, nor its blossoms and leaves together as the expressions of tenderness it has witnessed. What appeals to the pure all-seeing heavens ! what similitudes to the everlasting mountains ! what protestations of eternal truth and con- stancy ! from those who are now earth; they, and their shrouds, and their coffins. The caper and fig-tree have split their monuments, and boys have broken the hazel-nut with the fragments. Emblems of past loves and future hopes, severed names which the holiest rites united, broken letters of brief happiness, bestrew the road, and speak to the passer-by in vain." CLXIX. ASPECT OF TOWNS IN FRANCE AND ITALY. Marchese Pallavicini. Our towns are in much better style than our villas. Landor. They indeed are magnificent, and appear the 248 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. more so after the wretched streets of France. In that country almost everything animated is noisy, and almost everything inanimate is misshapen. All seems reversed : the inhabitants of the north are darker than those of the south : indeed the women of Calais are much browner than any I have seen in Italy: the children, the dogs, the frogs, are more clamorous than ours ; the cocks are shriller. But at worst we are shocked by no contrast, the very language seeming to be constructed upon stinks ; while in Italy we cannot walk ten paces without observing the union of stateliness and filth, of gorgeous finery and squalid meanness ; and the expressions of vice and slavery are uttered in the accents of angels. The churches are fairly divided between piety and prostitution, leaving the entrance and a few broken chairs to beggary and vermin. CLXX. RESPECT FOR THE DEAD IN ITALY. Landor. No people but the English can endure a long continuation of gravity and sadness : none pay the same respect to the dead. English Visitor. Here the common people, and not only the poorer, but householders and fathers of families, are thrown together into a covered cart ; and when enough of them are collected, they are carried off by night, and cast naked into the ditch in the burial-ground. No sheet about them, no shroud externally, no coffin, no bier, no emblem of mortality ; none of sorrow, none of affection, none of hope. Corpses are gathered like rotten gourds and cracked cucumbers, and cast aside where none could find if any looked for them. Among people in easy circumstances, wife, children, relatives, friends, all leave the house when one of the family is dying : the priest alone remains with him : the last sacrament solves every human tie. The eyes, after wandering over the altered scenes of domestic MANNERS, SOCIETY, NATIONAL CHARACTER. 249 love, over the silent wastes of friendship, are reconciled to whatever is most lugubrious in death, and are closed at last by mercenaries and strangers. Landor. My children were playing on the truly English turf before the Campo Santo in Pisa, when he to whom is committed the business of carrying off the dead, and whose house is in one corner, came up to them, and bade them come along with him, telling them he would show them two more such pretty children. He opened the doors of a cart-house, in which were two covered carts : the larger contained (I hear) several dead bodies, stark naked : in the smaller were two infants, with not even a flower shed over them. They had died in the foundling hospital the night before. Such was their posture, they appeared to hide their faces one from the other, in play. As my children had not been playing with them, this appearance struck neither : but the elder said, " Teresa ! who shut up these mimmi ? I will tell papa Why do they not come out and play till bedtime?" The " mimmi " had been out, poor little souls ! and had played till bedtime. POLITICS AND GOVERNMENT. CLXXI. Demosthenes. There is one truth above all the rest ; above all promulgated by the wisdom of legislators, the zeal of orators, the enthusiasm of poets, or the revelation of gods : a truth whose brightness and magnitude are almost lost to view by its stupendous height. If I never have pointed it out, knowing it as I do, let the forbear- ance be assigned not to timidity but to prudence. Eubulides. May I hope at last to hear it ? Demosthenes. I must conduct you circuitously, and in- terrogate you beforehand, as those do who lead us to the mysteries. You have many sheep and goats upon the mountain, which were lately bequeathed to you by your nephew Timocles. Do you think it the most advantageous to let some mastiff, with nobody's chain or collar about his neck, run among them and devour them one after another, or to prepare a halter and lay poison and a trap for him ? Eubulides. Certainly here, O Demosthenes, you are not leading me into any mysteries. The answer is plain : the poison, trap, and halter are ready. Demosthenes. Well spoken. You have several children and grandchildren : you study economy on their behalf : would you rather spend twenty drachmas for fuel, than three for the same quantity of the same material ? Eubulides. Nay, nay, Demosthenes, if this is not mys- tery, it is worse. You are like a teacher to whom a POLITICS AND GOVERNMENT. 251 studious man goes to learn the meaning of a sentence, and who, instead of opening the volume that contains it, asks him gravely whether he has learnt his alphabet. Trythee do not banter me. Demosthenes. Tell me, then, which you would rather ; make one drunken man sober for ever, or ten thousand men drunk for many years ? Eubulides. By all the gods ! abstain from such idle questions. Demosthenes. The solution of this, idle as you call it, may save you much more than twenty drachmas. O Eubulides ! we have seen, to our sorrow and ignominy, the plain of Cheronaea bestrewn with the bodies of our bravest citizens ; had one barbarian fallen, they had not. Rapine and licentiousness are the precursors and the followers of even the most righteous war. . A single blow against the worst of mortals may prevent them. Many years and much treasure are usually required for an un- certain issue, beside the stagnation of traffic, the prostra- tion of industry, and innumerable maladies arising from towns besieged and regions depopulated. A moment is sufficient to avert all these calamities. No usurper, no invader, should be permitted to exist on earth. CLXXII. Demosthenes. Every man in the world would be a republican, if he did not hope from fortune and favour more than from industry and desert ; in short, if he did not expect to carry off sooner or later, from under another system, what never could belong to him rightfully, and what cannot (he thinks) accrue to him from this. To suppose the contrary, would be the same as to suppose that he would rather have a master in his house, than friend, brother, or son ; and that he has both more con- 252 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. fidence and more pleasure in an alien's management of it, than in his own, or in any persons selected by his experience and deputed by his choice. CLXXIII. Demosthenes. Royalty is fed incessantly by the fuel of slavish desires, blown by fulsome breath and fanned by cringing follies. It melts mankind into one inert mass, carrying off and confounding all beneath it, like a torrent of ^Etnean lava, bright amid the darkness, and dark again amid the light. CLXXIV. THE FATE OF DESPOTISMS. Demosthenes.' Pythagoras adapted his institutions to the people he would enlighten and direct. What portion of the world was ever so happy, so peaceable, so well- governed, as the cities of Southern Italy? While they retained his manners they were free and powerful : some have since declined, others are declining, and perhaps at a future and not a distant time they may yield themselves up to despotism. In a few ages more, those flourishing towns, those inexpugnable citadels, those temples which you might deem eternal, will be hunted for in their wildernesses like the boars and stags. CLXXV. DEMOCRACY. Machiavelli. Republican as I have lived, and shall die, I would rather any other state of social life, than naked and rude democracy ; because I have always found it more jealous of merit, more suspicious of wisdom, more proud of riding on great minds, more pleased at raising POLITICS AND GOVERNMENT. 253 up little ones above them, more fond of loud talking, more impatient of calm reasoning, more unsteady, more ungrateful, and more ferocious ; above all, because it leads to despotism through fraudulence, intemperance, and corruption. Let Democracy live among the moun- tains, and regulate her village, and enjoy her chalet ; let her live peacefully and contentedly amid her flocks and herds ; never lay her rough hand on the balustrade of the council-chamber ; never raise her boisterous voice among the images of liberators and legislators, of philosophers and poets. CLXX VI. NAPOLEON AND PERICLES. Two powerful nations have been vitally affected by natural calamities. The former of these calamities was inevitable by human prudence, and uncontrollable by human skill : the latter was to be foreseen at any distance by the most ignorant, and to be avoided by the most unwary. I mean in the first the Plague of the Athenians ; in the second the starvation of the French. The first happened under the administration of a man transcend- ently brave ; a man cautious, temperate, eloquent, prompt, sagacious, above all that ever guided the coun- cils and animated the energies of a state : the second under a soldier of fortune, expert and enthusiastic ; but often deficient in moral courage, not seldom in personal ; rude, insolent, rash, rapacious; valuing but one human life among the myriads at his disposal, and that one far from the worthiest, in the estimation of an honester and a saner mind. It is with reluctant shame I enter on a comparison of such a person and Pericles. On one hand we behold the richest cultivation of the most varied and extensive genius ; the confidence of courage, the sedate- ness of wisdom, the stateliness of integrity ; on the other, 254 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. coarse manners, rude language, violent passions continu- ally exploding, a bottomless void on the side of truth, and a rueful waste on that of common honesty * * * So many pernicious faults were not committed by Xerxes or Darius, whom ancient historians call feeble princes, as were com- mitted by Napoleon, whom the modern do not call feeble, because he felt nothing for others, coerced pertinaciously, promised rashly, gave indiscriminately, looked tranquilly, and spoke mysteriously. Even in his flight, signalised by nothing but despondency, Segur, his panegyrist, hath clearly shown that, had he retained any presence of mind, any sympathy, or any shame, he might have checked and crippled his adversary. One glory he shares with Trojan and with Pericles, and neither time nor malice can diminish it. He raised up and rewarded all kinds of merit, even in those arts to which he was a stranger. In this indeed he is more remarkable, perhaps more admirable, than Pericles himself, for Pericles was a stranger to none of them. CLXXVII. THE DEATH OF HOFER. I passed two entire months in Germany, and like the people. On my way I saw Waterloo, an ugly table for an ugly game. At Innspruck I entered the church in which Andreas Hofer is buried. He lies under a plain slab, on the left, near the door. I admired the magnifi- cent tomb of bronze, in the centre, surrounded by heroes, real and imaginary. They did not fight, tens against thousands ; they did not fight for wives and children, but for lands and plunder : therefore they are heroes ! My admiration for these works of art was soon satisfied, which perhaps it would not have been in any other place. Snow, mixed with rain, was falling, and was blown by the wind upon the tomb of Hofer. I thought how often he had POLITICS AND GOVERNMENT. 255 taken advantage of such weather for his attacks against the enemies of his country, and I seemed to hear his whistle in the wind. At the little village of Landro (I feel a whimsical satisfaction in the likeness of the name to mine), the innkeeper was the friend of this truly great man the greatest man that Europe has produced in our days, excepting his true compeer, Kosciusko. Andreas Hofer gave him the chain and crucifix he wore three days before his death. You may imagine this man's enthusiasm, who, because I had said that Hofer was greater than king or emperor, and had made him a present of small value, as the companion and friend of that harmless and irreproachable hero, took this precious relic from his neck and offered it to me. By the order of Buonaparte, the companions of Hofer, eighty in number, were chained, thumbscrewed, and taken out of prison in couples, to see him shot. He had about him one thousand florins, in paper currency, which he delivered to his confessor, re- questing him to divide it impartially among his unfortun- ate countrymen. The confessor, an Italian who spoke German, kept it, and never gave relief from it to any of them, most of whom were suffering, not only from priva- tion of wholesome air, to which, among other privations, they never had been accustomed, but also from scantiness of nourishment and clothing. Even in Mantua, where, as in the rest of Italy, sympathy is both weak and silent, the lowest of the people were indignant at the sight of so brave a defender of his country, led into the public square to expiate a crime unheard of for many centuries in their nation. When they saw him walk forth, with unaltered countenance and firm step before them ; when, stopping on the ground which was about to receive his blood, they heard him with unfaltering voice commend his soul and his country to the Creator ; and, as if still under his own roof (a custom with him after the evening 256 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. prayer), implore a blessing for his boys and his little daughter, and for the mother who had reared them up carefully and tenderly thus far through the perils of child- hood ; finally, when in a lower tone, but earnestly and emphatically, he besought pardon from the Fount of Mercy for her brother, his betrayer, many smote their breasts aloud ; many, thinking that sorrow was shameful, lowered their heads and wept ; many, knowing that it was dan- gerous, yet wept too. The people remained upon the spot an unusual time, and the French, fearing some com- motion, pretended to have received an order from Buona- parte for the mitigation of the sentence, and publicly announced it. Among his many falsehoods, any one of which would have excluded him for ever from the society of men of honour, this is perhaps the basest ; as indeed of all his atrocities the death of Hofer, which he had ordered long before, and appointed the time and circum- stances, is that which the brave and virtuous will reprobate the most severely. He was urged by no necessity, he was prompted by no policy ; his impatience of courage in an enemy, his hatred of patriotism and integrity in all, of which he had no idea himself, and saw no image in those about him, outstripped his blind passion for fame, and left him nothing but power and celebrity. The name of Andreas Hofer* will be honoured by pos- terity far above any of the present age, and together with the most glorious of the last, Washington and Kosciusko. For it rests on the same foundation, and indeed on a higher basis. In virtue and wisdom their co-equal, he van- quished on several occasions a force greatly superior to his own in numbers and in discipline, by the courage and confidence he inspired, and by his brotherly care and anxiety for those who were fighting at his side. Differ- ently, far differently, ought we to estimate the squanderers of human blood, and the scorners of human tears. We POLITICS AND GOVERNMENT. 257 also may boast of our great men in a cause as great : for without it they could not be so. We may look back upon our Blake ; whom the prodigies of a Nelson do not eclipse, nor would he have wished (such was his gener- osity) to obscure it. Blake was among the founders of freedom ; Nelson was the vanquisher of its destroyers. Washington was both ; Kosciusko was neither ; neither was Hofer. But the aim of all three was alike ; and in the armoury of God are suspended the arms the two last of them bore ; suspended for success more signal and for vengeance more complete. I am writing this from Venice, which is among cities what Shakespeare is among men. He will give her im- mortality by his works, which neither her patron saint could do nor her surrounding sea. CLXXVIII. THE TROUBLES OF IRELAND. Archbishop Boulter, Primate of Ireland and one of the Lords Justices, converses with Philip Savage^ Chancel- lor of the Exchequer. Boulter. I trust it will ever be found convenient to appoint men of clemency to the first station, and that I shall never be forced to exercise on them the powers en- trusted to me of coercion and control. It is well when people can believe that their misfortunes are temporary. How can we apply such a term to pest- ilence and famine ? Philip Savage. Surely the violence of the evil eats away the substance of it speedily. Pestilence and famine are, and always have been, temporary and brief. Boulter. Temporary they are, indeed : brief are they, very brief. But why? because life is so under them. To the world they are extremely short : but can we say they are short to him who bears them? And of such there are thousands, tens of thousands, in this most S 258 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. afflicted, most neglected country. The whole of a life, be it what it may be, is not inconsiderable to him who leaves it ; any more than the whole of a property, be it but an acre, is inconsiderable to him who possesses it. Whether want and wretchedness last for a month or for half a century, if they last as long as the sufferer they are to him of very long duration. Let us try then rather to remove the evils of Ireland, than to persuade those who undergo them that there are none. For, if they could be thus persuaded, we should have brutalised them first to such a degree as would render them more dangerous than they were in the reigns of Elizabeth or Charles. Boulter. There will never be a want of money, or a want of confidence, in any well-governed state that has been long at peace, and without the danger of its inter- ruption. But a want of the necessaries of life, in pea- sants or artisans, when the seasons have been favourable, is a certain sign of defect in the constitution, or of criminality in the administration. It may not be advis- able or safe to tell every one this truth : yet it is needful to inculcate it on the minds of governors, and to repeat it until they find the remedy : else the people, one day or other, will send those out to look for it who may trample down more in the search than suits good husbandry. CLXXX. Washington. Look at the nations of Europe, and point out one, despotic or free, of which so large a portion is so barbarous and wretched as the Irish. The country is more fertile than Britain ; the inhabitants are healthy, strong, courageous, faithful, patriotic, and quick of appre- POLITICS AND GOVERNMENT 259 hension. No quality is wanting which constitutes the respectability of a state ; yet from centuries of misrule, they are in a condition more hopeless than any other nation or tribe upon the globe, civilised or savage. Franklin. There is only one direct way to bring them into order, and that appears so rough it never will be trodden. The chief misery arises from the rapacity of the gentry, as they are styled, and the nobility who, to avoid the trouble of collecting their rents from many poor tenants, and the greater of hearing their complaints, have leased their properties to what are called middle-men. These harass their inferiors in the exact ratio of their industry, and drive them into desperation. Hence sloven- liness and drunkenness ; for the appearance of ease and comfort is an allurement to avarice. To pacify and re- claim the people, leases to middle-men must be annulled ; every cultivator must have a lease for life, and (at the option of his successor) valid for as many years afterwards as will amount in the whole to twenty-one. The extent of ground should be proportionate to his family and his means. To underlet land should be punished by law as regretting. Washington. Authority would here be strongly exer- cised, not tyrannically, which never can be asserted of plans sanctioned by the representatives of a people, for the great and perpetual benefit of the many, to the small and transient inconvenience of the few. CLXXXI. THE GREEK WAR OF LIBERATION. What those amongst us who are affected by a sense of national honour most lament, is, that England, whose generosity would cost her nothing and whose courage would be unexposed to fatality, stands aloof. An alliance, offensive and defensive, with Greece would 260 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. render us invulnerable in the only part of the world where we have lately shown our feebleness. We should unite to us a maritime power, which within half a century would of itself be equipollent on the sea with France ; and we should attract to our merchants those advantages of commerce in the Levant which at present lean toward her. The great Chatham, if he had lived in our days, would have cast on every side around him the seeds of small maritime and small constitutional states. We may extend our dominions in many ways ; we can extend our power in this only. None of our late ministers have had clear views or steady aims. We have been hovering on the shores of Greece, until the season is going by for aiding her ; and another Power will soon have acquired the glory and the benefit of becoming her first protectress. If a new world were to burst forth suddenly in the midst of the heavens, and we were in- structed by angelic voices, or whatever kind of revelation the Creator might appoint, that its inhabitants were brave, generous, happy, and warm with all our sym- pathies, would not pious men fall prostrate before Him, for such a manifestation of His power and goodness ? What then ! shall these very people, these religious, be the first to stifle the expression of our praise and wonder, at a marvel far more astonishing, at a manifestation of power and goodness far more glorious and magnificent ? The weak vanquish the strong ; the oppressed stand over the oppressor : we see happy, not them who never were otherwise, not them who have made no effort, no movement of their own to earn their happiness, like the creatures of our imaginary new world, but those who were the most wretched, and the most undeservedly, and who now, arising as from the tomb, move the incumbrances of ages and of nations from before them, and, although at present but half- erect, lower the stature of the greatest heroes. POLITICS AND GOVERNMENT. 26 1 We appear to be afraid of the Russians : we tremble lest they should take possession of Constantinople, and march to India. The glory of Russia may be increased by conquest, which cannot be said of other state in Europe ; but her power of doing injury to the nations of the West would rather be deferred and diminished by it than promoted and increased. She would not be able in half a century to send an army into India, even if she possessed the dominions of the Turk : they would be far from affording her any great facility. In less than half a century it is probable we shall lose that empire ; but we shall lose it, like every other we have lost and are about to lose, by alienating the affections of the people. God grant that Russia may invade and conquer Turkey ! not that the Russians, or any other people on the Continent, are a better, a braver, an honester race than the Turks, but because the policy of the government is adverse to the progress of civilisation, and bears with brutal heavi- ness on its cradle. God grant that Russia may possess her ! not because it will increase her strength, but because it will enable, and perhaps induce her, to liberate from bondage more than one brave nation. She cannot hold Turkey at the extremity of such a lever ; and those who now run to help her, will slip from under her. CLXXXII. We are zealous in protecting from slavery the remotest nations of Africa, who have always for thousands of years been subject to that dreadful visitation, and who never have expected, or even heard tidings of, our generous interfer- ence. We take them away by righteous force from under the proudest flag ; we convey them to our own settlements ; we give them food, clothing, ground, instruction, morals, religion. Humanity cries out, tell them they are men ! 262 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. and we hear her. Is she silent for the Greeks? have their voices no echo in her breast? do we treat them cruelly because they have not the advantage of being barbarous ? do we spurn them because they cling to us ? is it because they trust only in us, that we reject and re- pulse them only of all mankind ? The ships of Ismael Bey repass the Mediterranean and Archipelago, laden with the sons and daughters of a half-extinguished race : half-extinguished under our eyes. Their terrors are not at death; their tears are not for captivity; their loss, though their country is Greece, is not of country. God alone can avenge it : God alone must hear it. Some- thing may surely be done, to alleviate the sufferings of the few survivors, wandering among naked rocks, or lifting up their heads from the rushes in the pestilential marsh. They require of us no land to cultivate, no suste- nance, no raiment : they implore of us permission to live under the safeguard of our laws, and to partake with the most ignorant and ferocious tribes, with murderers and cannibals, a spare moment of our attention and concern. Surely, surely this is not too much ; if you consider that the finest eloquence ever heard within your walls, was admirable only in proportion as it resembled the eloquence of their ancestors ; and that gods were bowed down to and worshipped, by the wisest and most power- ful nations, for being in form and dignity like them. CLXXXIII. General Lacy. The strength of England lies not in arma- ments and invasions : it lies in the omnipresence of her in- dustry, and in the vivifying energies of her high civilisation. There are provinces she cannot grasp ; there are islands she cannot hold fast : but there is neither island nor province, there is neither kingdom nor continent, which POLITICS AND GOVERNMENT. 263 she could not draw to her side and fix there everlastingly, by saying the magic words Be Free. Every land wherein she favours the sentiments of freedom, every land wherein she but forbids them to be stifled, is her own ; a true ally, a willing tributary, an inseparable friend. CLXXXIV. ON THE ACCESSION OF A LIBERAL POPE. Dedication of the first edition of the Hellenics (1847) to the newly-elected Pope Pius IX. Never until now, most Holy Father ! did I hope or desire to offer my homage to any potentate on earth ; and now I offer it only to the highest of them all. There was a time when the cultivators of literature were permitted and expected to bring the fruit of their labour to the Vatican. Not only was incense welcome there, but even the humblest produce of the poorest soil. Verbenam, pueri, ponite Thuraque. If those better days are returning without what was bad or exceptionable in them, the glory is due entirely to your Holiness. You have restored to Italy hope and happiness ; to the rest of the world hope only. But a single word from your prophetic lips, a single motion of your earth-embracing arm, will overturn the firmest seats of iniquity and oppression. The word must be spoken ; the arm must wave. What do we see before us ? If we take the best of rulers under our survey, we find selfish- ness and frivolity : if we extend the view, ingratitude, disregard of honour, contempt of honesty, breach of promises : one step yet beyond, and there is cold-blooded idiocy, stabbing the nobles at home, spurning the people everywhere, and voiding its corrosive slaver in the fair face of Italy. It is better to look no farther, else our eyes must be riveted on frozen seas of blood superfused with blood fresh flowing. The same ferocious animal 264 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. leaves the impression of its broad and heavy foot on the snow of the Arctic Circle and of the Caucasus. And is this indeed all that Europe has brought forth, after such long and painful throes ? Has she endured her Marats, her Robespierres, her Buonapartes, for this? God in- flicted on the latter of these wretches his two greatest curses uncontrolled power and perverted intellect ; and they were twisted together to make a scourge for a nation which revelled in every crime, but above all in cruelty. It was insufficient. She is now undergoing from a weaker hand a more ignominious punishment, pursued by the derision of Europe. To save her honour, she pretended to admire the courage that decimated her children : to save her honour, she now pretends to admire the wisdom that imprisons them. Cunning is not wisdom ; prevari- cation is not policy ; and (novel as the notion is, it is equally true) armies are not strength : Acre and Waterloo show it, and the flames of the Kremlin and the solitudes of Fontainebleau. One honest man, one wise man, one peaceful man, commands a hundred millions, without a baton and without a charger. He wants no fortress to protect him : he stands higher than any citadel can raise him, brightly conspicuous to the most distant nations, God's servant by election, God's image by beneficence. WALTER SAVAGE LANDOR. ^UNlVl *St'' LITERATURE AND LANGUAGE. CLXXXV. Porson. Clear writers, like clear fountains, do not seem so deep as they are : the turbid look most profound. CLXXXVI. Aspasia. The business of philosophy is to examine and estimate all those things which come within the cognis- ance of the understanding. Speculations on any that lie beyond are only pleasant dreams, leaving the mind to the lassitude of disappointment. They are easier than geo- metry and dialectics ; they are easier than the efforts of a well-regulated imagination in the structure of a poem. Diogenes. I meddle not at present with infinity or eternity : when I can comprehend them I will talk about them. You metaphysicians kill the flower-bearing and fruit - bearing glebe with delving and turning over and sifting, and never bring up any solid and malleable mass from the dark profundity in which you labour. The in- tellectual world, like the physical, is inapplicable to profit and incapable of cultivation a little way below the surface of which there is more to manage, and more to know, than any of you will undertake. Plato. It happens that we do not see the stars at even- 266 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. tide, sometimes because there are clouds intervening, but oftener because there are glimmerings of light ; thus many truths escape us from the obscurity we stand in ; and many more from that crepuscular state of mind, which induces us to sit down satisfied with our imagina- tions and unsuspicious of our knowledge. Diogenes. Keep always to the point, or with an eye upon it, and instead of saying things to make people stare and wonder, say what will withhold them hereafter from wondering and staring. This is philosophy; to make Temote things tangible, common things extensively useful, useful things extensively common, and to leave the least necessary for the last. I have always a suspicion of sonorous sentences. The full shell sounds little, but shows by that little what is within. A bladder swells out more with wind than with oil. CLXXXVIII. Plato. My sentences, it is acknowledged by all good judges, are well constructed and harmonious. Diogenes. I admit it : I have also heard it said that thou art eloquent. Plato. If style, without elocution, can be. Diogenes. Neither without nor with elocution is there eloquence, where there is no ardour, no impulse, no energy, no concentration. Eloquence raises the whole man : thou raisest our eyebrows only. We wonder, we applaud, we walk away, and we forget. Thy eggs are very prettily speckled ; but those which men use for their sustenance are plain white ones. People do not every day put on their smartest dresses ; they are not always in trim for dancing, nor are they practising their steps in all places. I profess to be no weaver of fine words, no dealer LITERATURE AND LANGUAGE. 267 in the plumes of phraseology, yet every man and every woman I speak to understands me. Plato. Which would not always be the case if the occulter operations of the human mind were the subject. Diogenes. If what is occult must be occult for ever, why throw away words about it? Employ on every occasion the simplest and easiest, and range them in the most natural order. Thus they will serve thee faithfully, bringing thee many hearers and readers from the intel- lectual and uncorrupted. All popular orators, victorious commanders, crowned historians, and poets above crown- ing, have done it. CLXXXIX. Barrow (to Newton}. I do not urge you to write in dialogue, although the best writers of every age have done it : the best parts of Homer and Milton are speeches and replies, the best parts of every great historian are the same : the wisest men of Athens and of Rome converse together in this manner, as they are shown to us by Xeno- phon, by Plato, and by Cicero. Whether you adopt such a form of composition, which, if your opinions are new, will protect you in part from the hostility all novelty (unless it is vicious) excites ; or whether you choose to go along the unbroken surface of the didactic ; never look abroad for any kind of ornament. Apollo, either as the god of day or the slayer of Python, had nothing about him to obscure his clearness or to impede his strength. cxc. Barrow. Never try to say things admirably ; try only to say them plainly ; for your business is with the con- siderate philosopher, and not with the polemical assem - bly. If a thing can be demonstrated two ways, demon- 268 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. strata it in both : one will please this man, the other that ; and pleasure, if obvious and unsought, is never to be neglected by those appointed from above to lead us into knowledge. Many will readily mount stiles and gates. to walk along a footpath in a field, whom the very sight of a bare public road would disincline and weary ; and yet the place whereto they travel lies at the end of each. Your studies are of a nature unsusceptible of much decora- tion : otherwise it would be my duty and my care to warn you against it, not merely as idle and unnecessary, but as obstructing your intent. The fond of wine are little fond of the sweet or the new : the fond of learning are no fonder of its must than of its dregs. Something of the severe hath always been appertaining to order and to grace : and the beauty that is not too liberal is sought the most ardently and loved the longest. CXCI. Archdeacon Hare. Wherever there is a word beyond what is requisite to express the meaning, that word must be peculiarly beautiful in itself, or strikingly harmonious ; either of which qualities may be of some service in fixing the attention and enforcing the sentiment. But the pro- per word in the proper place seldom leaves anything to be desiderated on the score of harmony. The beauty of health and strength is more attractive and impressive than any beauty conferred by ornament. CXCII. Demosthenes. Whatever is rightly said, sounds rightly. CXCIII. Epicurus. Natural sequences and right subordination LITERATURE AND LANGUAGE. 269 of thoughts, and that just proportion of numbers in the sentences which follows a strong conception, are the con- stituents of true harmony. Chesterfield. Cicero was himself a trifler in cadences, and whoever thinks much about them will become so, if indeed the very thought when it enters is not trifling. Chatham. I am not sure that it is ; for an orderly and sweet sentence, by gaining our ear, conciliates our affec- tions ; and the voice of a beggar has often more effect upon us than his distress. cxcv. Pollio. Cicero sometimes is exuberant. Conciseness may be better : but where there is much wealth we may excuse a little waste, especially when it falls not un- worthily. I confess to you I love a nobility and ampli- tude of style, provided it never sweeps beyond the subject. There are people who cut short the tails of their dogs ; and such dogs are proper for such masters : but the generous breeds, coursers of the lordly stag, and such as accompanied the steps of Hippolytus and Adonis, were unmutilated. Horne Tooke. Those only can be called great writers who bring to bear on their subject more than a few high faculties of the mind. I require in him whom I am to acknowledge for such, accuracy of perception, variety of mood, of manner, and of cadence ; imagination, reflection, force, sweetness, copiousness, depth, perspicuity. I re- 270 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. quire in him a princely negligence of little things, and a proof that although he seizes much, he leaves much (alike within his reach) unappropriated and untouched. cxcvn. Alfieri. To constitute a great writer the qualities are, adequate expression of just sentiments, plainness without vulgarity, elevation without pomp, sedateness without austerity, alertness without impetuosity ; thoughts offered ^~not abruptly, nor ungraciously, nor forced into us, nor ...stamped upon us: they must leave room for others to \ bring forward theirs, and help in suggesting them. ^"Vigorous that appears to ordinary minds which attracts the vulgar by its curtness and violence : but coarse tex- tures are not always the strongest, nor is the loudest voice always the most commanding. CXCVIII. SEDATENESS IN POETRY. Aspasia. No writer of florid prose ever was more than a secondary poet. Poetry, in her high estate, is delighted with exuberant abundance, but imposes on her worshipper a severity of selection. She has not only her days of festival, but also her days of abstinence, and, unless upon some that are set apart, prefers the graces of sedateness to the revelry of enthusiasm. Boccaccio. What is there lovely in poetry unless there be moderation and composure ? Are they not better than the hot uncontrollable harlotry of a flaunting, dis- hevelled enthusiasm ? Whoever has the power of creating, has likewise the inferior power of keeping his creations in LITERATURE AND LANGUAGE. 27! order. The best poets are the most impressive, because their steps are regular ; for without regularity there is neither strength nor state. Look at Sophocles, look at ^Eschylus, look at Homer. CC. PINDAR. Landor. We have lost the greater and (some believe) the better part of Pindar's poetry : what remains is more distinguished for an exquisite selection of topics than for enthusiasm. There is a grandeur of soul which never leaves him, even in domestic scenes ; and his genius does not rise on points or peaks of sublimity, but per- vades the subject with a vigorous and easy motion, such as the poets attribute to the herald of the gods. CCI. LATIN STYLES. Supposing the first of Virgil's Eclogues to have appeared seven years after the death of Catullus, and this poet to have composed his earliest works in the lifetime of Lucretius, we cannot but ponder on the change of the Latin language in so short a space of time. Lucretius was by birth a Roman, and wrote in Rome ; yet who would not say unhesitatingly, that there is more of what Cicero calls urbane in the two provincials, Virgil and Catullus, than in the authoritative and stately man who leads Memmius from the camp into the gardens of Epi- curus. He complains of poverty in the Latin tongue; but his complaint is only on its insufficiency in philo- sophical terms, which Cicero also felt twenty years later, and called in Greek auxiliaries. But in reality the lan- guage never exhibited such a profusion of richness as in the comedies of Plautus, whose style is the just admira- tion of the Roman orator. 272 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. ecu. VIRGIL'S DIDO. Without the sublime, we have said before, there can be no poet of the first order : but the pathetic may exist in the secondary ; for tears are more easily drawn forth than souls are raised. So easily are they on some occa- sions, that the poetical power needs scarcely be brought into action ; while on the others the pathetic is the very summit of sublimity. We have an example of it in the Ariadne of Catullus : we have another in the Priam of Homer. All the heroes and gods, debating and fighting, vanish before the father of Hector in the tent of Achilles, and before the storm of conflicting passions his sorrows and prayers excite. But neither in the spirited and energetic Catullus, nor in the masculine and scornful and stern Lucretius, no, nor in Homer, is there anything so impassioned, and therefore so sublime, as the last hour of Dido in the &neid. Admirably as two Greek poets have represented the tenderness, the anguish, the terrific wrath and vengeance of Medea, all the works they ever wrote contain not the poetry which Virgil has condensed into about a hundred verses : omitting as we must, those which drop like icicles from the rigid lips of ^Eneas ; and also the similes which, here as everywhere, sadly inter- fere with passion. ccin. If there are fine things in the Argonautics of Apol- lonius, there are finer still in those of Catullus. In rela- tion to Virgil, he stands as Correggio in relation to Raphael : a richer colourist, a less accurate draftsman ; less capable of executing grand designs, more exquisite in the working out of smaller. Virgil is depreciated by the arrogance of self-sufficient poets, nurtured on coarse fare, and dizzy with home-brewed flattery. Others, who LITERATURE AND LANGUAGE. 273 have studied more attentively the ancient models, are abler to show his relative station, and readier to venerate his powers. Although we find him incapable of contriv- ing, and more incapable of executing, so magnificent a work as the Iliad, yet there are places in his compared with which the grandest in that grand poem lose much of their elevation. Never was there such a whirlwind of passions as Virgil raised on those African shores, amid those rising citadels and departing sails. When the vigorous verses of Lucretius are extolled, no true poet, no sane critic, will assent that the seven or eight examples of the best are equivalent to this one : even in force of expression, here he falls short of Virgil. CCIV. There are four things requisite to constitute might, majesty, arid dominion, in a poet : these are creativeness, constructiveness, the sublime, the pathetic. A poet of the first order must have formed, or taken to himself and modified, some great subject. He must be creative and constructive. Creativeness may work upon old materials ; a new world may spring from an old one. Shakespeare found Hamlet and Ophelia ; he found Othello and Desde- mona ; nevertheless he, the only universal poet, carried this, and all the other qualifications, far beyond the reach of competitors. He was creative and constructive, he was sublime and pathetic, and he has also in his humanity condescended to the familiar and the comic. There is nothing less pleasant than the smile of Milton ; but at one time Momus, at another the Graces, hang upon the neck of Shakespeare. Petrarca. A poet often does more and better than he T 274 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. is aware at the time, and seems at last to know as little about it as a silkworm knows about the fineness of her thread. CCVI. Aspasia. For any high or any wide operation, a poet must be endued, not with passion indeed, but with power and mastery over it ; with imagination, with reflection, with observation, and with discernment. CCVII. It is only the wretchedest of poets that wish all they ever wrote to be remembered : some of the best would be willing to lose the most. CCVIII. Boccaccio. Good poetry, like good music, pleases most people, but the ignorant and inexpert lose half its plea- sures, the invidious lose them all. What a paradise lost is here ! CCIX. THE ORIGINS OF POETRY. Petrarca. I see no reason why we should not revert, at times, to the first intentions of poetry. Hymns to the Creator were its earliest efforts. Boccaccio. I do not believe a word of it, unless He himself was graciously pleased to inspire the singer ; of which we have received no account. I rather think it originated in pleasurable song, perhaps of drunkenness, and resembled the dithyrambic. Strong excitement alone could force and hurry men among words displaced and exaggerated ideas. Believing that man fell, first into disobedience, next into ferocity and fratricide, we may reasonably believe LITERATURE AND LANGUAGE. 2/5 that war-songs were among the earliest of his intellectual exertions. When he rested from battle he had leisure to think of love ; and the skies and the fountains and the flowers reminded him of her, the coy and beautiful, who fled to a mother from the ardour of his pursuit. In after years he lost a son, his companion in the craft and in the forest : images too grew up there, and rested on the grave. A daughter, who had wondered at his strength and wisdom, looked to him in vain for succour at the approach of death. Inarticulate grief gave way to pas- sionate and wailing words, and Elegy was awakened. We have tears in this world before we have smiles, Fran- cesco ! we have struggles before we have composure ; we have strife and complaints before we have submission and gratitude. I am suspicious that if we could collect the "winged words" of the earliest hymns, we should find that they called upon the Deity for vengeance. Priests and rulers were far from insensible to private wrongs. Chryses in the Iliad is willing that his king and country should be enslaved so that his daughter be sent back to him. David in the Psalms is no unimportunate or lukewarm applicant for the discomfiture and extermi- nation of his adversaries : and among the visions of felicity, none brighter is promised a fortunate warrior, than to dash the infants of his enemy against the stones. CCX. POETRY AND HISTORY. Aspasia. We make a bad bargain when we change poetry for truth in the affairs of ancient times, and by no means a good one in any. Remarkable men of remote ages are collected together out of different countries within the same period, and per- form simultaneously the same action. On an accumula- tion of obscure deeds arises a wild spirit of poetry ; and 276 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. images and names burst forth and spread themselves, which carry with them something like enchantment, far beyond the infancy of nations. What was vague imagina- tion settles at last and is received for history. It is diffi- cult to effect and idle to attempt the separation : it is like breaking off a beautiful crystallisation from the vault of some intricate and twilight cavern, out of mere curiosity to see where the accretion terminates and the rock begins. CCXI. THE PROVINCE OF HISTORY. Pericles. May our first Athenian historian not be the greatest, as the first of our dramatists has been, in the opinion of many. ^Eschylus was the creator of Tragedy, nor did she ever shine with such splendour, ever move with such stateliness and magnificence, as at her first apparition on the horizon. The verses of Sophocles are more elaborate, the language purer, the sentences fuller and more harmonious ; but in loftiness of soul, and in the awfulness with which he invests his characters, ^Eschylus remains unrivalled and unapproached. We are growing too loquacious, both on the stage and off. We make disquisitions which render us only more and more dim-sighted, and excursions that only con- sume our stores. If some among us who have acquired celebrity by their compositions, calm, candid, contem- plative men, were to undertake the history of Athens from the invasion of Xerxes, I should expect a fair and full criticism on the orations of Antiphon, and experience no disappointment at their forgetting the battle of Salamis. History, when she has lost her muse, will lose her dignity, her occupation, her character, her name. She will wander about the Agora ; she will start, she will stop, she will look wild, she will look stupid, she will take languidly to her bosom doubts, queries, essays, dissertations, some of LITERATURE AND LANGUAGE. 277 which ought to go before her, some to follow, and all to stand apart. The field of History should not merely be well tilled, but well peopled. None is delightful to me, or interesting, in which I find not as many illustrious names as have a right to enter it. We might as well in a drama place the actors behind the scenes, and listen to the dialogue there, as in a history push valiant men back, and protrude ourselves with husky disputations. Show me rather how great projects were executed, great advan- tages gained, and great calamities averted. Show me the generals and the statesmen who stood foremost, that I may bend to them in reverence ; tell me their names, that I may repeat them to my children. Teach me whence laws were introduced, upon what foundation laid, by what custody guarded, in what inner keep preserved. Let the books of the treasury lie closed as religiously as the Sibyl's ; leave weights and measures in the market- place, Commerce in the harbour, the Arts in the light they love, Philosophy in the shade : place History on her rightful throne, and, at the sides of her, Eloquence and War. CCXII. Bishop Parker. The Italians, who far excel us in the writing of history, are farther behind the ancients. Marvel. True enough. From Guicciardini and Machia- velli, the most celebrated of them, we acquire a vast quan- tity of trivial information. There is about them a saw- dust which absorbs much blood and impurity, and of which the level surface is dry : but no traces by what agency rose such magnificent cities above the hovels of France and Germany : none ut fortis Etruria crevit. 278 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. or, on the contrary, how the mistress of the world sank in the ordure of her priesthood Scilicet et rerumfacta est nequissima Roma. We are captivated by no charms of description ; we are detained by no peculiarities of character : we hear a clamorous scuffle in the street, and we close the door. How different the historians of antiquity ! We read Sallust, and always are incited by the desire of reading on, although we are surrounded by conspirators and bar- barians : we read Livy, until we imagine we are standing in an august pantheon, covered with altars and standards, over which are the four fatal letters that spellbound all mankind. 1 We step forth again among the modern Italians : here we find plenty of rogues, plenty of receipts for making more ; and little else. In the best passages we come upon a crowd of dark reflections, which scarcely a glimmer of glory pierces through ; and we stare at the tenuity of the spectres, but never at their altitude. Give me the poetical mind, the mind poetical in all things ; give me the poetical heart, the heart of hope and confidence, that beats the more strongly and resolutely under the good thrown down, and raises up fabric after fabric on the same foundation. Parker. At your time of life, Mr. Marvel ? Marvel. At mine, my lord bishop ! I have lived with Milton. Such creative and redeeming spirits are like kindly and renovating Nature. Volcano comes after volcano, yet covereth she with herbage and foliage, with vine and olive, and with whatever else refreshes and gladdens her, the Earth that has been gasping under the exhaustion of her throes. Parker. He has given us such a description of Eve's beauty as appears to me somewhat too pictorial, too luxuriant, too suggestive, too I know not what, i S. P. Q. R. LITERATURE AND LANGUAGE. 279 Marvel. The sight of beauty, in her purity and beati- tude, turns us from all unrighteousness, and is death to sin. The Abbe Delille. Milton is extremely difficult to trans- late ; for however noble and majestic, he is sometimes heavy, and often rough and unequal. Landor. Dear Abbe ! porphyry is heavy, gold is heavier : Ossa and Olympus are rough and unequal : the steppes of Tartary, though high, are of uniform elevation : there is not a rock, nor a birch, nor a cytisus, nor an arbutus, upon them, great enough to shelter a new-dropt lamb. Level the Alps one with another, and where is their sublimity? Raise up the vale of Tempe to the downs above, and where are those sylvan creeks and harbours in which the imagination watches while the soul reposes ; those recesses in which the gods partook the weaknesses of mortals, and mortals the enjoyments of the gods ! Marvel. He must be a bad writer, or however a very indifferent one, to whom there are no inequalities. The plants of such tableland are diminutive and never worth gathering. What would you think of a man's eyes to which all things appear of the same magnitude and at the same elevation? You must think nearly so of a writer who makes as much of small things as of great. The vigorous mind has mountains to climb and valleys to repose in. Is there any sea without its shoals ? On that which the poet navigates, he rises intrepidly as the waves rise round him, and sits composedly as they subside. 280 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. CCXV. Metastasio. It must be confessed that whatever is far removed from fashionable life and changeable manners is best adapted to the higher poetry. We are glad and righteously proud to possess two worlds, the one at present under our feet, producing beef and mutton ; the other, on which have passed before us, gods, demigods, heroes, the Fates, the Furies, and all the numerous progeny of never-dying, never-aging, eternally parturient Imagina- tion. Great is the privilege of crossing at will the rivers of bitterness, of tears, of fire, and to wander and converse among the Shades. ccxvi. Porson. You poets are still rather too fond of the un- substantial. Some will have nothing else than what they call pure imagination. Now, air-plants ought not to fill the whole conservatory ; other plants, I would modestly suggest, are worth cultivating, which send their roots pretty deep into the ground. I hate both poetry and wine without body. Look at Shakespeare, Bacon, and Milton ; were these your pure -imagination men? The least of them, whichever it was, carried a jewel of poetry about him worth all his tribe that came after. Did the two of them who wrote in verse build upon nothing ? Did their predecessors ? And pray whose daughter was the muse they invoked? Why Memory's. They stood among substantial men and sang upon recorded actions. The plain of Scamander, the promontory of Sigeum, the palaces of Tros and Dardanus, the citadel in which the Fates sang mournfully under the image of Minerva, seem fitter places for the Muses to alight on than artificial rockwork or than faery-rings. But your great favourite, LITERATURE AND LANGUAGE. 28 1 I hear, is Spenser, who shines in allegory, and who, like an aerolith, is dull and heavy when he descends to the ground. Southey. He continues a great favourite with me still, although he must always lose a little as our youth declines. Spenser's is a spacious but somewhat low chamber, hung with rich tapestry, on which the figures are mostly dis- proportioned, but some of the faces are lively and beauti- ful ; the furniture is part creaky and worm-eaten, part fragrant with cedar and sandal -wood and aromatic gums and balsams ; every table and mantelpiece and cabinet is covered with gorgeous vases, and birds, and dragons, and houses in the air. CCXVII. Landor. The heart is the creator of the poetical world ; only the atmosphere is from the brain. Do I then under- value imagination ? No indeed : but I find imagination where others never look for it : in character multiform yet consistent CCXVIII. Vittoria Colonna. The human heart is the world of poetry ; the imagination is only its atmosphere. Faeries, and genii, and angels themselves, are at best its insects, glancing with unsubstantial wings about its lower regions and less noble edifices. CCXIX. MILTON. Milton, in this Paradise Regained, seems to be subject to strange hallucinations of the ear ; he who before had greatly excelled all poets of all ages in the science and display of harmony. And if in his last poem we exhibit 282 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. his deficiencies, surely we never shall be accused of dis- respect or irreverence to this immortal man. It may be doubted whether the Creator ever created one altogether so great ; taking into our view at once (as much indeed as can at once be taken into it) his manly virtues, his super- human genius, his zeal for truth, for true piety, true freedom, his eloquence in displaying it, his contempt of personal power, his glory and exaltation in his country's. ccxx. Marvel. Good prose, to say nothing of the original thoughts it conveys, may be infinitely varied in modula- tion. It is only an extension of metres, an amplification of harmonies, of which even the best and most varied poetry admits but few. Comprehending at once the prose and poetry of Milton, we could prove, before " fit audience," that he is incomparably the greatest master of harmony that ever lived. CCXXI. MILTON AND JOHNSON. Warton and Johnson are of opinion that Milton is defective in the sense of harmony. But Warton had lost his ear by laying it down on low swampy places, on ballads and sonnets ; and Johnson was a deaf adder coiled up in the brambles of party prejudices. He was acute and judicious, he was honest and generous, he was for- bearing and humane : but he was cold where he was overshadowed. The poet's peculiar excellence, above all others, was in his exquisite perception of rhythm, and in the boundless variety he has given it, both in verse and prose. Virgil comes nearest to him in his assiduous study of it and in his complete success. LITERATURE AND LANGUAGE. 283 CCXXII. FRENCH PROSE. Salomon. Several of the French prose writers are more harmonious than the best of ours. Alfieri. In the construction of their sentences they have obtained from study, what sensibility has denied them. Rousseau is an exception : he beside is the only musical composer that ever had a tolerable ear for prose. Music is both sunshine and irrigation to the mind ; but when it occupies and covers it too long, it debilitates and corrupts it. Sometimes I have absorbed music so totally, that nothing was left of it in its own form : my ear detained none of the notes, none of the melody : they went into the heart immediately, mingled with the spirit, and lost themselves among the operations of the fancy, whose finest and most recondite springs they put simultaneously and vigorously in motion. Rousseau kept it subordinate ; which must always be done with music as well as with musicians. He excels all the moderns in the harmony of his periods. Salomon. I have heard it reported that you prefer Pascal. Alfieri. Certainly on the whole I consider him the most perfect of writers. CCXXIII. ADDISON. Home Tooke. I have always been an admirer of Addi- son, and the oftener I read him, I mean his prose, the more he pleases me. Perhaps it is not so much his style, which, however, is easy and graceful and harmonious, as the sweet temperature of thought in which we always find him, and the attractive countenance, if you will allow me the expression, with which he meets me upon every occa- sion. It is very remarkable, and therefore I stopped to 284 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. notice it, that not only what little strength he had, but even all his grace and ease, forsake him when he ventures into poetry. CCXXIV. GIBBON. Landor. Gibbon's manner, which many have censured, I think, in general, well suited to the work. In the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire^ there is too much to sadden and disgust : a smile in such a narrative on some occasions is far from unacceptable : if it should be succeeded by a sneer, it is not the sneer of bitterness, which falls not on debility ; nor of triumph, which accords not with contempt. The colours, it is true, are gorgeous, like those of the setting sun ; and such were wanted. The style is much swayed by the sentiment. Would that which is proper for the historian of Fabius and Scipio, of Hannibal and Pyrrhus, be proper, too, for Augustulus and the Popes ? CCXXV. WORDSWORTH. Landor. In Wordsworth's poetry there is as much of prose as there is of poetry in the prose of Milton. But prose on certain occasions can bear a great deal of poetry : on the other hand, poetry sinks and swoons under a moderate weight of prose. CCXXVI. PRAISE AND CENSURE. Landor. It is becoming and decorous that due honours be paid to Wordsworth ; undue have injured him. Dis- criminating praise mingled with calm censure is more beneficial than lavish praise without it. Respect him ; reverence him ; abstain from worshipping him. Remem- ber no ashes are lighter than those of incense, and few things burn out sooner. LITERATURE AND LANGUAGE. 285 Cleont. Let us enjoy, whenever we have an opportunity, the delight of admiration, and perform the duties of reverence. Archdeacon Hare. It is cruel and inhuman to withhold the sustenance which is necessary to the growth, if not the existence, of genius ; sympathy, encouragement, commen- dation. Praise is not fame ; but the praise of the intelligent is its precursor. CCXXIX. Archdeacon Hare. Opinion on most matters, but chiefly on literary, and above all on poetical, seems to me like an empty egg-shell in a duck -pond, turned on its stagnant water by the slightest breath of air ; at one moment the cracked side nearer to sight, at another the sounder, but the emptiness at all times visible. In selecting a poet for examination, it is usual either to extol him to the skies, or to tear him to pieces and trample on him. Editors in general do the former : critics on editors more usually the latter. ccxxxi. Salomon. He who first praises a book becomingly, is next in merit to the author. ccxxxn. Person. Periodical critics were never so plentiful as 286 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. they now are. There is hardly a young author who does not make his first attempt in some review ; showing his teeth, hanging by his tail, pleased and pleasing by the volubility of his chatter, and doing his best to get a penny for his exhibitor and a nut for his own pouch, by the facetiousness of the tricks he performs upon our heads and shoulders. CCXXXIII. Person. Those who have failed as painters turn picture- cleaners, those who have failed as writers turn reviewers. Orator Henley taught in the last century that the readiest- made shoes are boots cut down : there are those who abundantly teach us now, that the readiest-made critics are cut-down poets. Their assurance is, however, by no means diminished from their ill-success. CCXXXIV. Petrarca. Why cannot we be delighted with an author, and even feel a predilection for him, without a dislike to others ? Boccaccio. The eyes of critics, whether in commending or carping, are both on one side, like a turbot's. ccxxxv. Petrarca. No criticism is less beneficial to an author or his reader than one tagged with favour and tricked with courtesy. The gratification of our humours is not the intent and scope of criticism, and those who indulge in it on such occasions are neither wise nor honest. CCXXXVI. Cicero. In literature great men suffer more from their little friends than from their potent enemies. LITERATURE AND LANGUAGE. 287 CCXXXVII. Vittoria Colonna. Sometimes we ourselves may have exercised our ingenuity, but without any consciousness of spleen or ill-humour, in detecting and discussing the peculiar faults of great poets. This has never been done, or done very clumsily, by our critics, who fancy that a measureless and shapeless phantom of enthusiasm leaves an impression of a powerful mind, and a quick apprehen- sion of the beautiful. "Who," they ask us, "who would look for small defects in such an admirable writer ? Who is not trans- ported by his animation, and blinded by his brightness?" To this interrogation my answer is, "Very few indeed ; only the deliberate, the instructed, and the wise. Only they who partake in some degree of his nature know exactly where to find his infirmities." CCXXXVIII. Southey. It is fortunate we have been sitting quite alone while we detected the blemishes of a poet we both venerate. 1 The malicious are always the most ready to bring forward an accusation of malice : and we should certainly have been served, before long, with a writ pushed under the door. Landor. Are we not somewhat like two little beggar- boys, who, forgetting that they are in tatters, sit noticing a few stains and rents in their father's raiment ? Southey. But they love him. CCXXXIX. Boccaccio. The generous man, such as you, praises and censures with equal freedom, not with equal pleasure : 1 Milton. 288 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. the freedom and the pleasure of the ungenerous are both contracted, and lie only on the left hand. Petrarca. When we point to our friends an object in the country, do we wish to diminish it ? do we wish to show it overcast ? Why then should we in those nobler works of creation, God's only representatives, who have cleared our intellectual sight for us, and have displayed before us things more magnificent than Nature would without them have revealed ? CCXL. Boccaccio. Beware of violating those canons of criticism you have just laid down. We have no right to gratify one by misleading another, nor, when we undertake to show the road, to bandage the eyes of him who trusts us for his conductor. In regard to censure, those only speak ill who speak untruly, unless a truth be barbed by malice and aimed by passion. To be useful to as many as possible is the especial duty of a critic, and his utility can only be attained by rectitude and precision. He walks in a garden which is not his own ; and he neither must gather the blossoms to embellish his discourse, nor break the branches to display his strength. Rather let him point to what is out of order, and help to raise what is lying on the ground. Petrarca. Auditors, and readers in general, come to hear or read, not your opinion delivered, but their own repeated. Fresh notions are as disagreeable to some as fresh air to others ; and this inability to bear them is equally a symptom of disease. Impatience and intoler- ance are sure to be excited at any check to admiration in the narratives of Ugolino and of Francesca : nothing is to be abated : they are not only to be admirable, but entirely faultless. LITERATURE AND LANGUAGE. 289 Boccaccio. You have proved to me, that in blaming our betters, we ourselves may sometimes be unblamed. When authors are removed by death beyond the reach of irrita tion at the touch of an infirmity, we best consult their glory by handling their works comprehensively and un- sparingly. Vague and indefinite criticism suits only slight merit, and presupposes it. Lineaments irregular and profound as Dante's are worthy of being traced with patience and fidelity. In the charts of our globe we find distinctly marked the promontories and indentations, and oftentimes the direction of unprofitable marshes and im- passable sands and wildernesses : level surfaces are un- noted. I would not detract one atom from the worth of Dante ; which cannot be done by summing it up exactly, but may be by negligence in the computation. CCXLI. DANTE'S PAOLO AND FRANCESCA. Boccaccio. Ah ! had Dante remained through life the pure solitary lover of Bice, his soul had been gentler, tranquiller, and more generous. He scarcely hath de- scribed half the curses he went through, nor the roads he took on the journey: theology, politics, and that barbican of the Inferno, marriage, surrounded with its Selva selvaggia ed aspra e forte. Admirable is indeed the description of Ugolino, to who- ever can endure the sight of an old soldier gnawing at the scalp of an old archbishop. Petrarca. The thirty lines from Ed io senil are unequalled by any other continuous thirty in the whole dominions of poetry. Boccaccio. Give me rather the six on Francesca : for if in the former I find the simple, vigorous, clear narra- tion, I find also what I would not wish, the features of u 290 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. Ugolino reflected full in Dante. The two characters are similar in themselves ; hard, cruel, inflexible, malignant, but, whenever moved, moved powerfully. In Francesca, with the faculty of divine spirits, he leaves his own nature (not indeed the exact representative of theirs) and con- verts all his strength into tenderness. The great poet, like the original man of the Platonists, is double, possess- ing the further advantage of being able to drop one half at his option, and to resume it. Some of the tenderest on paper have no sympathies beyond : and some of the austerest in their intercourse with their fellow-creatures have deluged the world with tears. It is not from the rose that the bee gathers her honey, but often from the most acrid and the most bitter leaves and petals. Quando leggemmo il disiato riso Esser baciato di cotanto amante, Questi, che mai da me nonfia diviso ! La bocca mi bacib tutto tremante. Galeotlofu il libro, e chi lo scrisse. Qualgiorno piu non m leggemmo avante. In the midst of her punishment, Francesca, when she comes to the tenderest part of her story, tells it with complacency and delight ; and instead of naming Paolo, which indeed she never has done from the beginning, she now designates him as Questi che mai dame nonfia diviso ! Are we not impelled to join in her prayer, wishing them happier in their union ? Petrarca. If there be no sin in it. Boccaccio. Ay, and even if there be God help us ! What a sweet aspiration in each cesura of the verse ! three love-sighs fixed and incorporate ! Then, when she hath said La bocca mi bacio tutto tremante^ she stops : she would avert the eyes of Dante from her : LITERATURE AND LANGUAGE. 29 1 he looks for the sequel : she thinks he looks severely : she says, " Galeotto is the name of the book," fancying by this timorous little flight she has drawn him far enough from the nest of her young loves. No, the eagle beak of Dante and his piercing eyes are yet over her. " Galeotto is the name of the book." "What matters that?" "And of the writer." "Or that either?" At last she disarms him : but how ? " That day we read no more." Such a depth of intuitive judgment, such a delicacy of perception, exists not in any other work of human genius ; and from an author who, on almost all occasions, in this part of the work, betrays a deplorable want of it. Petrarca. Perfection of poetry ! The greater is my wonder at discovering nothing else of the same order or cast in this whole section of the poem. He who fainted at the recital of Francesca, " And he who fell as a dead body falls," would exterminate all the inhabitants of every town in Italy ! What execrations against Florence, Pistoia, Siena, Pisa, Genoa ! What hatred against the whole human race ! what exultation and merriment at eternal and im- mitigable sufferings ! Seeing this, I cannot but consider the Inferno as the most immoral and impious book that ever was written. Yet, hopeless that our country shall ever see again such poetry, and certain that without it our future poets would be more feebly urged forward to ex- cellence, I would have dissuaded Dante from cancelling it, if this had been his intention. Much, however, as I admire his vigour and severity of style in the description of Ugolino, I acknowledge with you that I do not dis- 2Q2 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. cover so much imagination, so much creative power, as in the Francesca. CCXLIL VERBAL CRITICISM, WITH AN EXAMPLE. Alfieri. There are those who would persuade us that verbal criticism is unfair, and that few poems can resist it. The truth of the latter assertion by no means establishes the former : all good criticism hath its foundation on verbal. Long dissertations are often denominated criti- cisms, without one analysis ; instead of which it is thought enough to say; " There is nothing finer in our language we can safely recommend imbued M'ith the true spirit destined to immortality, etc." A perfect piece of criticism must exhibit where a work Is good or bad ; "why it is good or bad ; in what degree it is good or bad ; must also demonstrate in what manner and to what extent the same ideas or reflections have come to others, and, if they be clothed in poetry, why, by an apparently slight variation, what in one author is mediocrity, in another is excellence. I have never seen a critic of Florence or Pisa or Milan or Bologna, who did not commend and admire the sonnet of Cassiani on the rape of Proserpine, without a suspicion of its manifold defects. Few sonnets are indeed so good ; but if we examine it attentively, we shall discover its flaws and patches. " Dte im alto strido, gittb ifiori, e volta A IF improvisa mano che la time, Tutta in se per la tema onde fu colta La Siciliana vergine si strinse." The hand is inadequate to embrace a body ; strinse, which comes after, would have done better : and the two last verses tell only what the two first had told, and feebly : nothing can be more so than the tema ondefu colta. LITERATURE AND LANGUAGE. 293 " // nero dio la calda bocca involta D' ispido pelo a ingordo bacio spinse, E di stigia fuligin con lafolta Barba Peburnea gola e il sen le tinse. " Does not this describe the devils of our carnival, rather than the majestic brother of Jupiter, at whose side upon asphodel and amaranth the sweet Persephone sits pen- sively contented, in that deep motionless quiet which mortals pity and which the gods enjoy ; rather than him who, under the umbrage of Elysium, gazes at once upon all the beauties that on earth were separated ; Helena and Eriphyle, Polyxena and Hermione, Deidameia and Deianeira, Leda and Omphale, Atalanta and Cydippe, Laodameia with her arm round the neck of a fond youth whom she still seems afraid of losing, and, apart, the daughters of Niobe, though now in smiles, still clinging to their parent. CCXLIII. OF IDIOM. Demosthenes. I have been careful to retain as much idiom as I could, often at the peril of being called ordi- nary and vulgar. Nations in a state of decay lose their idiom, which loss is always precursory to that of freedom. What your father and your grandfather used as an ele- gance in conversation, is now abandoned to the populace, and every day we miss a little of our own, and collect a little from strangers : this prepares us for a more intimate union with them, in which we merge at last altogether. Every good writer has much idiom ; it is the life and spirit of language ; and none such ever entertained a fear or apprehension that strength and sublimity were to be lowered and weakened by it. CCXLIV. OF QUOTATION. Lucian. Before I let fall a quotation I must be taken 294 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. by surprise. I seldom do it in conversation, seldomer in composition ; for it mars the beauty and unity of style ; especially when it invades it from a foreign tongue. A quoter is either ostentatious of his acquirements, or doubt- ful of his cause. And, moreover, he never walks grace- fully who leans upon the shoulder of another, however gracefully that other may walk. CCXLV. VULGARISMS. Home Tooke. No expression can become a vulgarism which has not a broad foundation. The language of the vulgar hath its source in physics : in known, compre- hended, and operative things : the language of those who are just above the vulgar is less pure, as flowing from what they do not in general comprehend. Hence the profusion of broken and ill-assorted metaphors, which we find in the conversation of almost all who stand in the intermediate space between the lettered and the lowest. CCXLVL GALLICISMS AND LATINISMS. Barrow. Our language bears gallicisms better than latinisms, but whoever is resolved to write soberly must be contented with the number of each that was found among us in the time of the Reformation. CCXLVII. ENGLISH ORTHOGRAPHY AND DICTION. Archdeacon Hare. In some of your later writings, 1 perceive, you have not strictly followed the line you for- merly laid down for spelling. Landor. I found it inexpedient ; since whatever the pains I took, there was, in every sheet almost, some deviation on the side of the compositor. Inconsistency was forced LITERATURE AND LANGUAGE. 295 on me against all my struggles and reclamations. At last nothing is left for me but to enter my protest, and to take the smooth path instead of the broken-up highway. Archdeacon Hare. It is chiefly in the preterites and participles that I have followed you perseveringly. We are rich in having two for many of our verbs, and unwise in corrupting the spelling, and thereby rendering the pronunciation difficult. We pronounce "astonisht," we write astonished or astonish 'd ; an unnecessary harshness. Never was spoken drop^W, or looped, or hop^W, or prop//; but dropt, etc. ; yet, with the choice before us, we invariably take the wrong. I do not resign a right to "astonis^^" or " diministof. " They may, with many like them, be useful in poetry ; and several such termina- tions add dignity and solemnity to what we read in our church, the sanctuary at once of our faith and of our language. Landor. In more essential things than preterites and participles I ought rather to have been your follower than you mine. No language is purer or clearer than yours. Vigorous streams from the mountain do not mingle at once with the turbid lake, but retain their force and their colour in the midst of it. We are sapt by an influx of putridity. Archdeacon Hare. Come, come ; again to our spelling- book. Landor. Well then, we differ on the spelling of honotir, favour, etc. You would retain the u : I would reject it, for the sake of consistency. We have dropt it in author, emperor, ambassador. Here again, for consistency and compliancy, I write " embassador," because I write, as all do, " embassy." I write theater, sepulch whether in country or town. Johnson countenanced them, and, arm-in-arm with Pope, followed them even into Jeru- salem. " Ye nymphs of Solyma," etc. Landor. Pity they ever found their way back ! 1 OF TT "XT t-T-r- - , -. 298 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. CCXLVIII. Archdeacon Hare. Unhappily for us, we are insensible of the corruptions that creep yearly into our language. At Cambridge or Oxford (I am ignorant which of them claims the glory of the invention), some undergraduate was so facetious as to say, " Well, while you are discuss- ing the question, I will discuss my wine. " The graceful- ness of this witticism was so captivating, that it took pos- session not only of both universities, but seized also on ' ' men about town. " Even the ladies, who preserve the purity of language, caught up the expression from those who were libertines in it. Landor. Chesterfield and Horace Walpole, who arb among the most refined of our senators, have at present no more authority in language than in dress. By what we see, we might imagine that the one article is to be cast aside after as short a wear as the other. It occurs to me at this moment, that, when we have assumed the habiliments of the vulgar, we are in danger of contracting their coarseness of language and demeanour. Archdeacon Hare. Certainly the Romans were togati in their tongue, as well as in their wardrobe. Purity and gravity of style were left uncontaminated and unshaken by the breath of Tiberius and his successor. The Anto- nines spoke better Latin than the Triumvir Antonius ; and Marcus Aurelius, although on some occasions he pre- ferred the Greek, was studious to maintain his own idiom strong and healthy. When the tongue is paralysed, the limbs soon follow. No nation hath long survived the decrepitude of its language. There is perpetually an accession of slang to our ver- nacular, which is usually biennial or triennial. Landor. I have been either a fortunate or a prudent man to have escaped for so many years together to be LITERATURE AND LANGUAGE. 299 "pitched into" among "giant trees," "monster meet- ings," "glorious fruit," " splendid cigars, dogs, horses, and bricks" "palmy days," "rich oddities ;" to owe nobody a farthing for any other fashionable habits of rude device and demi-saison texture ; and above all, to have never come in at the "eleventh hour," which has been sounding all day long the whole year. They do me a little injustice who say that such a good fortune is attributable to my residence in Italy. The fact is, I am too cautious and too aged to catch disorders, and I walk fearlessly through these epidemics. Archdeacon Hare. Simply to open is insufficient : we "open up" and "open out" A gentleman indues a coat ; it will be difficult to exue it if he tries ; he must lie down and sleep in it. "Foolery" was thought of old sufficiently expressive : nothing short of ^wzfoolery will do now. To repudiate was formerly to put away what disgraced us : it now sig- nifies (in America at least) to reject the claims of justice and honour. We hear people re-read, and see them re- write ; and are invited to a spread, where we formerly went to a dinner or collation. We cut down barracks tc a single barrack ; but we leave the " stocks " in good repair. We are among ambitions, and among peoples) until Sternhold and Hopkins call us into a quieter place, and we hear once again "All people that on earth do dwell." Shall we never have done with "rule and exception" tl ever and anon" " many a time and oft" ? CCXLIX. Landor. So far from innovating, the words I propose are brought to their former and legitimate station ; you have sanctioned the greater part, and have thought the 300 REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. remainder worth your notice. Every intelligent and un- prejudiced man will agree with you. I prefer high authorities to lower, analogy to fashion, a Restoration to a Usurpation. Innovators, and worse than innovators were those Reformers called, who disturbed the market- place of manorial Theology, and went back to Religion where she stood alone in her original purity. We English were the last people to adopt the reformed style in the calendar, and we seem determined to be likewise the last in that of language. We are ordered to please the public ; we are forbidden to instruct it. Not only pub- lishers and booksellers are against us, but authors too ; and even some of them who are not regularly in the service of those masters. The outcry is, " We have not ventured to alter what we find in use, and why should he ?" CCL. Mr. Hartley Coleridge, who inherits the genius of his father, is incorrect in mentioning me with a set of people (Elphinstone and Mitford at the head of them) who at- tempt to spell every word as we pronounce it. What, in the name of God, is there in common between these folks and me ? Certainly not this folly : no such idea ever entered my head. CCLI. I am radically a Conservative in everything useful ; and, during my stay at this inn called Human Life, I would trust anything to the chambermaids rather than my English tongue. III. PERSONAL AND AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL. TO IANTHE. CCLII. HOMAGE. AWAY, my verse ; and never fear, As men before such beauty do ; On you she will not look severe, She will not turn her eyes from you. Some happier graces could I lend That in her memory you should live, Some little blemishes might blend, For it would please her to forgive. On the smooth brow and clustering hair Myrtle and rose ! your wreath combine, The duller olive I would wear, Its constancy, its peace, be mine. CCLIV. There is a flower I wish to wear, But not until first worn by you Heartsease of all earth's flowers most rare j Bring it ; and bring enough for two. It often comes into my head That we may dream when we are dead, 304 PERSONAL AND AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL. But I am far from sure we do. O that it were so ! then my rest Would be indeed among the blest ; I should for ever dream of you. CCLVI. All tender thoughts that e'er possessed The human brain or human breast, Centre in mine for thee Excepting one and that must thou Contribute : come, confer it now : Grateful I fain would be. CCLVII. Pleasure ! why thus desert the hear: In its spring-tide ? I could have seen her, I could part, And but have sigh'd ! O'er every youthful charm to stray, To gaze, to touch Pleasure ! why take so much away : Or give so much ? CCLVIII. RENUNCIATION. Lie, my fond heart, at rest, She never can be ours. Why strike upon my breast The slowly passing hours ? Ah ! breathe not out the name I That fatal folly stay ! Conceal the eternal flame, And tortured ne'er betray. TO IANTHE. , 305 CCLIX. You smiled, you spoke, and I believed, By every word and smile deceived. Another man would hope no more ; Nor hope I what I hoped before : But let not this last wish be vain ; Deceive, deceive me once again 1 CCLX. So late removed from him she swore, With clasping arms and vows and tears, In life and death she would adore, While memory, fondness, bliss, endears. Can she forswear ? can she forget ? Strike, mighty love ! strike, Vengeance ! Soft 1 Conscience must come and bring regret These let her feel ! nor these too oft 1 CCLXI. I held her hand, the pledge of bliss, Her hand that trembled and withdrew j She bent her head before my kiss My heart was sure that hers was true. Now I have told her I must part, She shakes my hand, she bids adieu. Nor shuns the kiss Alas, my heart I Hers never was the heart for you. CCLXII. ABSENCE. lanthe ! you are call'd to cross the sea ! A path forbidden me I x 306 PERSONAL AND AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL. Remember, while the sun his blessing sheds Upon the mountain-heads, How often we have watch'd him laying down His brow, and dropp'd our own Against each other's, and how faint and short And sliding the support ! What will succeed it now ? Mine is unblest, lanthe ! nor will rest But on the very thought that swells with pain. O bid me hope again ! O give me back what Earth, what (without you) Not Heaven itself can do, One of the golden days that we have past ; And let it be my last ! Or else the gift would be, however sweet, Fragile and incomplete. CCLXIII. Flow, precious tears ! thus shall my rival know For me, not him, ye flow. Stay, precious tears ! ah stay ! this jealous heart Would bid you flow apart, Lest he should see you rising o'er the brim, And hope you rise for him. Your secret cells, while he is present, keep, Nor, though I'm absent, weep, Mild is the parting year, and sweet The odour of the falling spray ; Life passes on more rudely fleet, And balmless is its closing day. TO IANTHE. 307 I wait its close, I court its gloom, But mourn that never must there fall Or on my breast or on my tomb The tear that would have sooth'd it all. CCLXV. YEARS AFTER. " Do you remember me ? or are you proud ? " Lightly advancing thro' her star-trimm'd crowd, lanthe said, and look'd into my eyes. " A.yes t a. yes to both : for memory Where you but once have been must ever be, And at your voice Pride from his throne must rise." CCLXVI. No, my own love of other years ! No, it must never be. Much rests with you that yet endears, Alas ! but what with me ? Could those bright years o'er me revolve So gay, o'er you so fair, The pearl of life we would dissolve And each the cup might share. You show that truth can ne'er decay, Whatever fate befals ; I, that the myrtle and the bay Shoot fresh on ruin'd walls. CCLXVII. I wonder not that youth remains With you, wherever else she flies : Where could she find such fair domains, Where bask beneath such sunny eyes ? 308 PERSONAL AND AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL. CCLXVIII. Your pleasures spring like daisies in the grass, Cut down and up again as blithe as ever ; From you, lanthe, little troubles pass Like little ripples in a sunny river. Years, many parti-colour'd years, Some have crept on, and some have flown. Since first before me fell those tears I never could see fall alone. Years, not so many, are to come, Years not so varied, when from you One more will fall : when, carried home, I see it not, nor hear Adieu. CCLXX. Well I remember how you smiled To see me write your name upon The soft sea-sand, " O ! what a child ! You think you're writing upon stone \ ' I have since written what no tide Shall ever wash away, what men Unborn shall read o'er ocean wide And find lanthe's name again. INVOCATIONS AND REMINISCENCES. CCLXXL ON SWIFT JOINING AVON NEAR RUGBY. SILENT and modest brook ! who dippest here Thy foot in Avon as if childish fear Withheld thee for a moment, wend along ; Go, follow'd by my song, Such in such easy numbers as they use Who turn in fondness to the Tuscan Muse, And such as often have flow'd down on me From my own Fiesole. I watch thy placid smile, nor need to say That Tasso wove one looser lay, And Milton took it up to dry the tear Dropping on Lycidas's bier. In youth how often at thy side I wander'd ! What golden hours, hours numberless, were squander'd Among thy sedges, while sometimes I meditated native rhymes, And sometimes stumbled upon Latian feet ; Then, where soft mole-built seat Invited me, I noted down What must full surely win the crown, But first impatiently vain efforts made On broken pencil with a broken blade. Anon, of lighter heart, I threw My hat where circling plover flew, And once I shouted till, instead of plover, There sprang up half a damsel, half a lover. 310 PERSONAL AND AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL. I would not twice be barbarous ; on I went And two heads sank amid the pillowing bent. Pardon me, gentle stream, if rhyme Holds up these records in the face of Time ; Among the falling leaves some birds yet sing, And Autumn has his butterflies like Spring. Thou canst not turn thee back, thou canst not see Reflected what hath ceased to be : Haply thou little knowest why I check this levity, and sigh. Thou never knewest her whose radiant morn Lighted my path to Love ; she bore thy name, She whom no Grace was tardy to adorn, Whom one low voice pleas'd more than louder fame : She now is past my praises : from her urn To thine, with reverence due, I turn. O silver-braided Swift ! no victim ever Was sacrificed to thee, Nor hast thou carried to that sacred River Vases of myrrh, nor hast thou run to see A band of Maenads toss their timbrels high Mid io-evohes to their Deity. But holy ashes have bestrewn thy stream Under the mingled gleam Of swords and torches, and the chant of Rome When Wiclif s lowly tomb Thro' its thick briars was burst By frantic priests accurst ; For he had enter'd and laid bare the lies That pave the labyrinth of their mysteries. We part but one more look I Silent and modest brook J INVOCATIONS AND REMINISCENCES. 31 1 CCLXXII. ABERTAWY. It was no dull though lonely strand Where thyme ran o'er the solid sand, Where snap-dragons with yellow eyes Looked down on crowds that could not rise, Where Spring had fill'd with dew the moss In winding dells two strides across. There tiniest thorniest roses grew To their full size, nor shared the dew : Acute and jealous, they took care That none their softer seat should share ; A weary maid was not to stay Without one for such churls as they. I tugg'd and lugg'd with all my might To tear them from their roots outright ; At last I did it eight or ten We both were snugly seated then ; But then she saw a half-round bead, And cried, Good gracious / how you bleed ' Gently she wiped it off, and bound With timorous touch that dreadful wound To lift it from its nurse's knee I fear'd and quite as much fear'd she, For might it not increase the pain, And make the wound burst out again ? She coax'd it to lie quiet there With a low tune I bent to hear ; How close I bent I quite forget, I only know I hear it yet. Where is she now ? Call'd far away, By one she dared not disobey, To those proud halls, for youth unfit, Where princes stand and judges sit. 312 PERSONAL AND AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL. Where Ganges rolls his widest wave She dropped her blossom in the grave ; Her noble name she never changed, Nor was her nobler heart estranged. CCLXXIII. ROSE AYLMER. Ah what avails the sceptred race, Ah what the form divine ! What every virtue, every grace ! Rose Aylmer, all were thine. Rose Aylmer, whom these wakeful eye? May weep, but never see, A night of memories and of sighs I consecrate to thee. CCLXXIV. TO j. s. Many may yet recall the hours That saw thy lover's chosen flowers Nodding and dancing in the shade Thy And, when they see them dimly shine, Are moister than they were. Give me the eyes that fain would find Some relics of a youthful mind Amid the wrecks of care. Give me the eyes that catch at last A few faint glimpses of the past, And, like the arkite dove, Bring back a long-lost olive-bough, And can discover even now A heart that once could love. 348 PERSONAL AND AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL CCCXIII. To his young Rose an old man said, ; * You will be sweet when I am dead : Where skies are brightest we shall meet^ And there will you be yet more sweet, Leaving your winged company To waste an idle thought on me. " CCCXTV. THE THREE ROSES, When the buds began to burst, Long ago, with Rose the first I was walking ; joyous then Far above all other men, Till before us up there stood Britonferry's oaken wood, Whispering ' * Happy as thou art> Happiness and thou must part " Many summers have gone by Since a second Rose and I (Rose from that same stem) have told This and other tales of old. She upon her wedding day Carried home my tenderest lay ; From her lap I now have heard Gleeful, chirping, Rose the Third. Not for her this hand of mine Rhyme with nuptial wreath shall twine ; Cold and torpid it must lie, Mute the tongue, and closed the eye. ON THE APPROACH OF OLD AGE AND DEATH. 349 CCCXV. Various the roads of life ; in one All terminate, one lonely way. We go ; and " Is he gone ? " Is all our best friends say. CCCXVI. The day returns, my natal day, Borne on the storm and pale with snow, And seems to ask me why I stay, Stricken by Time and bowed by Woe. Many were once the friends who came To wish me joy ; and there are some Who wish it now ; but not the same ; They are whence friend can never come ; Nor are they you my love watch'd o'er Cradled in innocence and sleep ; You smile into my eyes no more, Nor see the bitter tears they weep. CCCXVII. ON HIS SEVENTY-FIFTH BIRTHDAY. I strove with none, for none was worth my strife, ' Nature I loved, and next to Nature, Art ; I warmed both hands before the fire of life, l It sinks, and I am ready to depart. CCCXVIII. ON HIS EIGHTIETH BIRTHDAY. To my ninth decade I have totter' d on, And no soft arm bends now my steps to steady ; She, who once led me where she would, is gone, So when he calls me, Death shall find me ready. 350 PERSONAL AND AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL, CCCXIX. M EMORY. The Mother of the Muses, we are taught, Is Memory : she has left me ; they remain, And shake my shoulder, urging me to sing About the summer days, my loves of old. Alas ! alas ! is all I can reply. Memory has left with me that name alone, Harmonious name, which other bards may sing, But her bright image in my darkest hour Comes back, in vain comes back, call'd or uncall 'd Forgotten are the names of visitors Ready to press my hand but yesterday ; Forgotten are the names of earlier friends Whose genial converse and glad countenance Are fresh as ever to mine ear and eye ; To these, when I have written and besought Remembrance of me, the word Dear alone Hangs on the upper verge, and waits in vain. A blessing wert thou, O oblivion, If thy stream carried only weeds away, But vernal and autumnal flowers alike It hurries down to wither on the strand. Death stands above me, whispering low I know not what into my ear : Of his strange language all I know Ts, there is not a word of fear. NOTES. 352 NOTES. THE following Table is intended to show the chronological relations of Landor to some of his contemporaries, with the dates of the chief events in his life, and of the publication of his principal works. The titles of these are printed in italics. [Chatterton died. Wordsworth born.] [Gray died. Scott born.] [Coleridge born.] [Goldsmith died. Southey born.] Born at Warwick, Jan. 30. [Charles Lamb born.] [Thomas Campbell and Henry Hallam born.] [Hazlitt born.] Goes to school at Knowle. [Johnson died. Leigh Hunt born.] Goes to school at Rugby. [De Quincey born.] [Byron born.] Removed from Rugby. Resident at Ashbourne, under Dr. Langley. Ashbourne. [Shelley born.] Enters at Trinity College, Oxford. Rusticated ; leaves Oxford ; goes to London. London ; afterwards Tenby. The Poems of Walter Savage Landor: London, Cadell and Davies. A Moral Epistle; respectfidly dedicated to Earl Stanhope : London, Cadell and Davies. [Keats born Carlyle born.] South Wales, Warwick. [Burns died.] South Wales, Warwick. [B. W. Procter born.] South Wales. Gebir: a Poem, in seven books : London, Rivingtons. Bath ; London ; Brighton. [Hood born.] Bath, etc. [Cowper died. Macaulay born.] Poems from the A rabic^ and Persian : Warwick, Sharpe : and London, Rivingtons. Bath, etc. Bath, etc. ; visit to Paris during peace of Amiens. Poetry by the Author of Gebir: London, Riving- tons. Bath, etc. Gebir: a Poem, in seven books. By Walter Savage Landor. Second Edition : Oxford, Slatter and Munday. Gebirius : Poema. Scripsit Savagius Landor : Oxford, Slatter and Munday. Bath, etc. Bath, etc. Lander's father dies. Bath, etc- Simonidea: Bath, Meyler: and London, Robinson. Bath, etc. (projects and abandons purchase of an estate at Loweswater). NOTES. 353 33 34 Bath, etc. Purchases Llanthony Abbey, Monmouth- shire ; makes the acquaintance of Southey ; goes as a volunteer to join the insurgent army in Spain (August-October). [Lord Houghton born.] Llanthony, Bath. Three Letters, "written in Spain, to D. Francisco Riguelme, commanding the Third Division of the Gallician army. [A. Tennyson, Eliz. Barrett, W. E. Gladstone, Ch. Darwin, born.] Llanthony, Bath. Llanthony, Bath. Marries Julia Thuillier. [Thackeray born.] Llanthony, Bath. Count Julian : a Tragedy: London, Murray. Commentary on Memoirs of Mr. Fox : London : Murray. [Dickens, R. Browning, J. For- ster, born.] Llanthony, Bath. Leaves Llanthony (May) ; goes to Jersey ; thence, having left Mrs. Landor in anger, to Tours ; makes the acquaintance of Francis Hare. Tours ; rejoined by Mrs. Landor ; Como. Idyllia nova quinque Heroum atque Heroidum, etc. : Oxford. Como. Como. Eldest son, Arnold Savage, born. Como ; Genoa, Villa Pallayicini. Pisa ; part of summer at Pistoia. Pisa. Idyllia Heroica decent, etc. , partim jam primo fiartim iterum atq. tertioedit Savagi^ls Landor: Pisa. Pisa; thence to Florence. Poche osservazioni, etc., di Walter Savage Landor* gentiluomo inglese ; Naples. [Keats died.] Florence; Palazzo Medici. [Shelley died.] Florence ; Palazzo Medici. Florence ; Palazzo Medici. Imaginary Conversations ofL iterary Men and Statesmen. By Walter Savage Landor, Esq., vols. i. and ii. : London, Taylor and Hessey. [Byron.died.] Florence ; Palazzo Medici. Florence ; Palazzo Medici and Villa Castiglione. Im- aginary Conversations, etc., vols. i. and ii., second edition : London, Colburn. Florence ; Villa Castiglione ; makes the acquaintance of Lord and Lady Blessington, and accompanies them on a trip to Naples. Makes the acquaintance of Mr. Joseph Ablett of Llanbedr. Florence ; Villa Castiglione. Imaginary Conversa- tions, etc., vol. iii. : London, Colburn. Fiesole ; Villa Gherardesca (purchased by help of Mr. Ablett). Lander's mother dies. Madame de Molande, formerly Mrs. Swift, the lanthe of Landor's early poetry, comes to Florence with her children. Imaginary Conversations, etc., vols. iv. and v. London, Duncan. Fiesole ; Villa Gherardesca. [Hazlitt died.] Fiesole; Villa Gherardesca. Gebir, Count Julian, and 2 A 354 NOTES. other Poems. By Walter Savage Landor, Esq. .' London, Moxon. Fiesole ; Villa Gherardesca ; with a summer and autumn trip to England, returning in company with Julius Hare and Dr. Worsley by Innsbruck and Venice. [Scott died.] Fiesole ; Villa Gherardesca. Fiesole ; Villa Gherardesca. Citation and Examina- tion of William Shakespeare, etc. : London, Saun- ders and Otley. [Coleridge diod. Charles Lamb died.] Fiesole : Baths of Lucca and England (leaving at Fiesole his wife, with whom he had quarrelled, and his children). Clifton ; Wales ; London ; Germany. Pericles and Aspasia, by Walter Savage Ijandor, Esq. : 2 vols. : London, Saunders and Ot)y. The Letters of a Conservative, by Walter Sfavage ~Landor : London, Saunders and Otley. Wales ; London ; Devonshire; Bath. The Pentameron and Pentalogia: London, Saunders and Otley. A Satire on Satirists, and Admonition to Detractors : London, Saunders and Otley. Bath. Bath. Andrea of Hungary, and Giovanni of Naples. By Walter Savage Landor : London, Bentley. Bath. [Francis Hare died.] Bath ; visit to Paris. Fra Rupert : London, Saunders and Otley. Bath. Bath. [Southey died.] Bath. [Campbell died.J Bath. [Hood died.] Bath. The Works of Walter Savage Landor; 2 yols. : London, Moxon. (Vol. i. contains all the previously published Imaginary Conversations, with additions and corrections : vol. ii., a new series of Imaginary Conversations, together with The Examination of Shakespeare, Pericles and A spasia, The Pentameron, the poems previously published in the volume of 1831, besides a number of new poems, including the Hellenics. This edition, prepared with the help of Mr. John Forster and Archdeacon Hare, was until 1876 the sole and standard collected edition of Landor's writings in prose and verse together.) Bath. The Hellenics of Walter Savage Landor. En- larged and completed : London, Moxon. Poemata et Inscriptiones novis auxit Savagius Landor : London, Moxon. Bath. The Italics of Walter Savage Landor : London , Reynell and Weight. Imaginary Conversation of King Carlo- Alberto and the Duckess Belgoioisol London, Longmans, 1848. (J. Ablett died.] Bath. 69 NOTES. 355 1850 1851 1852 1853 1854 1855 1856 1857 1858 1859 1860 1861 1862 1863 1864 76 79 So Bath. [Lady Blessington died. Wordsworth died.] Bath. Popery^ British and Foreign. By Walter Savage Landor: London, Chapman and Hall. [Madame de Molande died.] Bath. Bath. Imaginary Conversations of Greeks and Ro- mans, by Walter Savage Landor: London, Moxon. The Last Fruit off an old Tree^ by Walter Savage Landor: London, Moxon. Bath. Letters of an American, mainly on Russia and Revolution. Edited by Walter Savage Landor: London, Chapman and Hall. Bath. [Julius Hare died.] Bath. Antony and Octavius; Scenes for the Study. By Walter Savage Landor : London, Bradbury and Evans. Letter from W. S. Landor to R. W. Emerson : Bath, Williams. Bath (quarrels and scandals). Bath; Genoa; Fiesole. Dry Sticks, fagoted by Walter Savage Landor: Edinburgh, Nichol. Lawsuit con- sequent on this publication ; trial at Bristol. Landor, having in the meanwhile left England, is condemned, costs ; 1000. Fiesole ; Siena ; Florence. Having found life with his family at the Villa Gherardesca insupportable, he settles in lodgings in the Via Nunziatina. The Hel- lenics of Walter Savage Landor ; etc. New edition, enlarged: Edinburgh, Nichol. [Leigh Hunt died. De Quincey died. Macaulay died.] Florence ; Via Nunziatina. Florence ; Via Nunziatina. Florence ; Via Nunziatina. Florence ; Via Nunziatina. Heroic Idyls, with ad- ditional Poems. By Walter ' Savage Landor. [Thackeray died.] Florence ; Via Nunziatina. Dies September 17. A final collected and corrected (though not, strictly speaking, complete) edition of Landor's writings was prepared by Forster after his death, and published in 1876 with a second edition of the Life by Forster prefixed (The Works and Life of Walter Savage Landor, 8 vols. London : Chapman and Hall, 1876). This edition has, by permission of the publishers, been followed in our text, except where the reverse is expressly stated. I have adopted, how- ever, certain formal deviations from it in orthography and punctua- tion : these consist chiefly in spelling "walked," or in verse "walk'd," for Landor's " walkt," and so on in all similar cases (see Preface and Selections, no. ccxlix.), and in the substitution of the more familiar sign for the less familiar sign . . used by Landor as its equi- valent. Other departures from the text of 1876 are specified when they occur. 356 NOTES. I. DRAMATIC AND NARRATIVE. In the notes below, the references which follow the number of each selection are, first, to the place in the series of Landor's works where it first appeared ; and second, to the place where it is to be found in the final collected edition of 1876. PAGE 3- Imag. Conv.) v., 1829, p. 95. Afterwards incorporated in Conversation of Epicurus, Leontion, and Ternissa : Epicurus reciting the part of Peleus, and Ternissa that of Thetis: see Works, 1876, ii. p. 228 ff. Again, as an independent dialogue, but versified : Hellenics, 2d ed., 1859, p. 187 : Works, 1876, vii. p. 504. Such an interchange of condolences between the hero and goddess on the coming fate of their son, as Landor has here imagined, is not recorded as having found a place in any ancient treatment of the theme. 1. 17. After "words" is inserted in the later eds., " I deposit them in my bosom ; " I have preferred the original reading of 1829. 1. 9. In the later eds. are omitted the words, " twice nine have not yet rolled away," which I have retained from ed. 1829, as being essential to the sense. In this speech of Thetis, Landor seems to have forgotten, or not chosen to remember, that the wedding was held according to tradition at the cave of Cheiron on Mount Pelion, whence Peleus led his bride, not to the " halls of Tethys," but to his own palace. Imag. Con-v. Gr. and Rom., 1853, p. 3 : Works, 1876, ii. p. 3. Again, versified, Hellenics, 2d ed., 1859, p. 162 : Works, 1876, vii. p. 490. This interview of Achilles and Helen on Mount Ida belonged to the early epic traditions of the Trojan war, and had been related in the lost Kypria of Stasinus (Proclus, Chrestomath. KOLL /xerd ravra 'EXe*>?7J> eiTLdvfJieL 6ed(rapodir^ Kal G^rts 1. 8. Landor spells Kalydon, but as he was not consistent with himself in these matters (see above, p. 6, 1. 32), wavering, like other scholars, between the use of the Greek consonant and its Latin equivalent, I have for the sake of uniformity introduced the latter, both here and in 11. 32, 33, below. 1. 12. I have omitted from the beginning of this line the words, " Horrible creatures ! boars, I mean." Hellenics, 1847, p. 61 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 518. The re-capture of Helen by Menelaus, and his averted vengeance, belonged also to the early epic traditions of Greece. They were related in the NOTES. 357 'AGE NO. Lesser Iliad and the Iliugersis: the scene was figured on one of the earliest recorded works of Greek art, the chest of Cypselus (Pausan.^ v. 181), and is depicted on a number of extant vases. Accord- ing to Stesichorus, the Greeks were about to stone Helen for her crimes, but at the sight of her beauty dropped the stones from their hands. See also Aristoph. Lysistr,, 155. 17. iv. Introduced in Pericles and Aspasia, 1836, p. 266: Works ; 1876, v. p. 529. Landor represents this dialogue as the work of Aspasia herself, who sends it to Cleone at Miletus, explaining its motive thus, " I imagine Agamemnon to descend from his horrible death, and to meet instantly his daughter. By the nature of things, by the suddenness of the event, Iphigeneia can have heard nothing of her mother's double crime, adultery and murder." For Lander's opinion of the merits of this scene, see Selections, no. ccciii. He wrote afterwards several other poetical fragments on the same heroic theme. Two of these, the Death of Clytemnestra and the Madness of Orestes, were first published in the Pentalogia, appended to the Pentameron of Petrarca and Boccaccio (1837). Both were in- corporated, together with a third fragment, the Prayer of Orestes at Delphi, in subsequent editions of Pericles and Aspasia (letters ccxxv.-ccxxix., Works, 1846, ii. p. 447 ff. ; 1876, v. p. 535 ff.) These three are dramatic in form. An independent narra- tive poem on the sacrifice of Iphigeneia appeared first, Works, 1846, ii. p. 482, and in subsequent edi- tions of the Hellenics ; it is included among Lord Houghton's Selections from Landor in Ward's English Poets, iv. p. 479. All of these pieces are fine, but the first, here reprinted, is much the finest ; the second and third being in my judgment marred by an excess of the Landorian abruptness. The obvious and just criticism on the present fragment is that the disclosure, which is prepared for by such admirably conceived and beautiful approaches, is after all never made. The lyrical conclusion, sung by the chorus of Argive warriors, I have ventured to omit as not related to the emotions of the father and daughter at their re-union. 22. v. Works, 1846, ii. p. 193 : Works, 1876, ii. p. 19. A First Conversation between the same persons appears Works, 1846, ii. p. 93 : Works, 1876, ii. p. 8. This, although full of beauties, I have passed by as not needful to the understanding of the Second Conversation, of which the excellence is higher and more sustained. All details in this Conversation are of Lander's invention, beyond the mere tradition that Rhodope and ./Esop were fellow-slaves before 358 NOTES. NO. Rhodope was taken by Xanthus to Egypt; see Herodotus, ii. 134, 135, where also (and in Strabo, xvii. 808, and Athenaeus, xiii. 596) will be found dis- cussed the questions concerning her supposed real name Doricha, her relations with the brother of Sappho, and her identification with Nitocris, Queen of Egypt. 33. vi. Imag. Conv., iii., 1828, p. 133 : Works, 1876, ii. p. 309. For the facts relating to the death of Marcellus, see Polybius (x. 32, and the doubtful fragment in Suidas sub voce "I/xepos), but more particularly Appian, Hannib., 50, and Plutarch, Marcell., 30. Landor has taken several details from the last two writers. They both tell of the reverence paid by Hannibal to the fallen consul ; of the ring Hannibal took from his body ; of the escape of the young Marcellus, his son ; and how his ashes were sent home with honour to his family. But both Appian and Plutarch represent Marcellus as already dead when Hannibal came up ; and the essential idea of the dialogue, that of making him survive his death-wound long enough to speak with and learn the generosity of his conqueror, is Lander's own. 38. vii. Works, 1846, ii. p. 243 : Works, 1876, ii. p. 314. (Had been originally printed in the Cambridge Philological Museum, vol. ii., 1833, p. i.) The main authority for the heroism of Hasdrubal's wife and the forebodings of Scipio is Appian (Libyc. 130-133) : he expressly describes himself as following in his account that of Polybius, who was present. The Conversation is a very long one ; this extract and the following are its opening and concluding pass- ages. ^ Hardly any other two in Landor's works better illustrate his feeling for the genius of Rome and the genius of Greece respectively. The central part of the Conversation is taken up with a discussion on the^ causes of Hannibal's failure to achieve ulti- mate victory over Rome, and with a long monologue by Pansetius, relating a social experience of his youth : from this are taken Selections xxxi. and xxxii. below. 47. ix. Imag. Conv., v., 1829, p. 475 : Works, 1846, ii. p. 346. The authorities which Landor has in his mind are again Appian (Iber. 95-97), and Plutarch, Marius. 3. But this time he has treated them very freely. The tremendous invention of the "civic fire" and the famished sentinel are his own. The real his- tory of the siege, according to Appian, was that after enduring _eyery extremity of horror and priva- tion, the surviving inhabitants agreed to surren- der the town to Scipio, stipulating only for a day's delay, during which those who preferred death to such an issue, might put an end to themselves, which they accordingly did, some one way and NOTES. 359 PAGE NO. some another, the remainder afterwards surrendering (ot 5 TrpHora /JLV CLVTOVS, oi j3ov\b/j.voi, 5te%- puvro : oi XoiTTOt 5' e^ea-av /c.r.X.) 52. x. Imag. Conv., iii., 1828, p. 107 : Works, 1876,1!. p. 420. The historical authority whom Landor has had in his mind is Suetonius, Tib. 7: "Agrippinam [sc. Vipsaniam], M. Agrippa genitam . . . duxit uxorem : sublatoque ex eo filio Druso, quamquam bene convenientem, rursusque gravidam, dimittere, ac Juliam, Augusti filiam, confestim coactus est ducere : non sine magno angore animi, cum et Agrippinae consuetudine teneretur, et Juliae mores improbaret ; ut quam sensisset sui quoque sub priore marito appetentem, quod sane etiam vulgo existama- batur. Sed Agrippinam et abegisse post divortium doluit ; et seine I omnino ex occursri visam adeo con- tentis et tiimentibus oculis prosecittus est, ut custo- ditum sit ne unquam in conspectum ejus posthac veniret. " 53. ,, 11. 6-14. That in B.C. 6, six years after his divorce from Vipsania, Tiberius retired for a time into voluntary exile at Rhodes, is well known. In mentioning this fact Suetonius writes: " Rhodum enavigavit, amoenitate et salubritate insulae jam inde cafitus, cum ad earn ab Armenia rediens appulisset" The date of the Armenian expedition of Tiberius was B.C. 20, eight years before his divorce. In putting into his mouth this reminiscence of happy days spent by him in youth at Rhodes, Landor is working on the hint supplied by those incidental words of Suetonius. 55. ,, 1. 14. "Virtuous as I know she is." These words seem inconsistent, not only with the notorious disso- luteness into which Julia fell soon after her marriage with Tiberius, but with the opinion of her attributed to him at the time of that marriage in the passage we have just quoted from Suetonius. Landor, how- ever, might justify himself by another passage of the same writer : " Cum Julia primo concorditer et amore mut^^o vixit : mox dissedit," etc. 56. xi. Imag. Conv., v., 1829, p. 509 : Works, 1876, v. p. 215, 63. xii. Works, 1846, ii. p. 79 : Works, 1876, v. p. 232. The main fact assumed in this dialogue, the capture and honourable release of the Empress Constance by Tancred of Sicily, is historical, but not the details. Among Lander's shorter dialogues are two typical ones of mediaeval chivalry, this of Tancredi and Con- stantia, and another Qijohn ofGatint and Joanna of Kent (Works, 1876, v. p. 199). I have with some hesitation preferred to give the Sicilian dialogue rather than the English, not indeed as finer, but as briefer and simpler. 67. xiii. Imag. Conv., iv., 1829, p. 416 : Works, 1876, iii. p. 216. 360 NOTES. PAGE NO. Both this and no. xiv. following are extracts from longer Conversations ; both are introduced in order to illustrate particular strains in Lan- dor's work : his strain of Oriental romance, and his strain of satire against the fanatical and priestly character. The friendship between Mahomet and a Nestorian monk is historical : the Byzantine and Eastern writers generally call the monk Bahira or Bouhira ; the Western writers of the Middle Age called him, apparently without any authority, Sergius / see Prideaux, Life of Mahomet, p. 46. 71. xiv. Works, 1846, ii. p. 81 : Works, 1876, iii. p. 235. The story of the capture of Fra Filippo Lippi at Ancona, and his detention as a slave in Barbary, is given in full by Vasari, but being unsupported by other evidence, is now generally discredited. The fact of the painter's friendly relations with Pope Eugenius IV. is historical. Here is the passage of Vasari on which Landor has founded the episode which I have extracted from this Conversation: "E trovandosi nella marca d'Ancona, diportandosi un giorno con certi amici suoi in una barchetta per mare, furono tutti insieme dalle fuste de' Mori che per quei luoghi scorrevano presi e menati in Barberia, e messo cias- cuno di loro alia catena e tenuto schiavo ; dove stette con molto disagio per 18 mesi. Ma perche un giorno, avendo egli molto in pratica il padrone, gli venne comodita e capriccio di ritrarlo, preso un carbone spento dal fuoco, con quello tutto intero lo ritrasse co' suoi abiti indossp alia moresca in muro bianco. Onde essendo dagli altri schiavi detto questo al padrone, perche a tutti un miracolo pareva, non s'usando il disegno ne la pittura in quelle parti, cio fu causa della sua liberazione della catena, dove per tanto tempo era stato tenuto." 78. xv. Last Fmit, 1853, P- 7 : Works, 1876, v. p. 309. Here again it may be interesting to compare with Lander's treatment of his theme the text which doubt- less suggested it to him : " Si trovaya in que' giorni a Ferrara il celebre P. Francesco Panigarqla . . . Egli era in molta grazia del Duca e delle Principesse ; il che saputosi dal Tasso, che gia avea quelche dimesti- chezza con esso lui, gli scrisse pregandolo che volesse esergli cortese d'una sua visita ; giacche a lui sarebbe stato concesso agevolmente di poter venire a vederlo quando voleva. Se gli raccomando poi, % perche baciasse umilissimamente le mani in suo nome a Ma- dama Leonora, se fosse migliorata, facendola sapere, che ere molto incresciuto del suo male che non avea pianto in versi per una tacita repugnanza del suo genio ; ma che se in altro potea servirla gli com- mandasse, ch' era prontissimo, particplarmente in cose di poesia piu liete. Non so se il Panigarola NOTES. 361 PAGE NO. fosse in tempo di far questo officio ; giacche la Princi- picessa in vece di migliorare andb peggiorando di sorte, che alle 10 di Febbrajo del 1581 con santa resignazione, e co' piu ferventi segni di Cristiana pieta rese lo spirito a Dio nel quarantacinquesimo anno e quelche mese dell' eta sua" (Serassi, Vita di Torqriato Tasso, Rome, 1785). Want of space has prevented me from coupling with this admirable and touching short dialogue the earlier and closely related one of Tasso and his sister Cornelia (Works, 1876, v. p. 269). 81. xvi. Works, 1846, ii. p. 37 : Works, 1876, v. p. 220. The meeting here supposed between the virgin hero- ine and the king's mistress is imaginary. Charles VII. seems not to have come under the influence of Agnes Sorel until the victorious part of Jeanne's career was over in 1431. That influence was, however, really employed to brave him to resolute action against his enemies ; witness the well-known quatrain of Francis I. : " Gentille Agnes, plus d'honneur tu merite La cause etant de France recouvrer 8ue ce que peut dedans un cloistre ouvrer lose nonnain ou bien devot hermite." 90. xvii. Imag. Conn., ii., 1824, p. 275 : Works, 1876, v. p. 180. Equally of Lander's own invention is this scene between Henry and Anne Boleyn after her condemna- tion. His chivalrous view of the queen's character is founded on that of Burnet and the Protestant historians generally, 94. }J H. 13, 29. At these points I have reverted to the text as it stood in 1826 (Jmag. C0?iv., ii., 2d ed., p. 53), omit- ting the additional matter inserted Works, 1846, and afterwards. 96. xviii. Imag. Conv., ii., 1824, p. 49 : Works, 1876, v. p. 177. 100. xix. Appended to Exam, of Shaksfeare, 1834, p. 234 : Works, 1876, v. p. 90. In this noble scene, Landor has worked upon the bald hints of kindness shown by Essex to Spenser after his return, which are afforded by Ben Jonson, in his conversations as reported by Drummond of Haw- thornden, and by Phineas Fletcher. The words of Jonson as given by Drummond are: "That the Irish having rob'd Spenser's goods, and burnt his house and a little child new born, he and his wife escaped ; and after, he died for lake of bread in King Street, and refused 20 pieces sent to him by my Lord of Essex, and said, he was sorrie he had no time to spend them." Phineas Fletcher writes in the Purple Island, book I., stanza 20 : " And had not that great Hart (whose hpnour'd head, Ah, lies full low) pitied thy woful plight, 3^2 NOTES. PAGE NO. There hadst thou lien unwept, unburied, Unblest, nor graced with any common rite." 101. xix. 1. 5. I have ventured to omit a somewhat lengthy and coarse anecdote with which Essex at this point is made to keep the grave business of the dialogue waiting. 106. xx. Imag. Conv., iv., 1829, p. 137 : Works, 1876, v. p. 204. In no other of Lander's dialogues does he rise to such heights of feeling as in this. His clue to the cha- racters and bearing of the martyred ladies he found in Burnet {Hist, of the reign of James II. ), who writes of Alice, Lady Lisle : " She died with a great constancy of mind ; and expressed a joy that she thus suffered for an act of charity and piety ;" and of Elizabeth Gaunt : " She died with a constancy, even to a cheerfulness, that struck all that saw it. She said, charity was a part of her religion, as well as faith ; this at most was the feeding an enemy ; so she hoped she had her reward with him, for whose sake she did this service ; how unworthy soever the person was, that made so ill a return for it ; she re- joiced that God had honoured her to be the first that suffered by fire in this reign ; and that her suffering was a martyrdom for that religion which was all love." The two executions are spoken of on the same page by Burnet ; hence, no doubt, Landor's idea of bring- ing the two victims together in prison. The historical fact is that Lady Lisle was condemned and executed at Winchester during the Bloody Assize in the summer ; Elizabeth Gaunt, whose trial took place in the Old Bailey, not till several months afterwards (Macaulay, Hist, of England, i., 639 ff., 663 ff.). J part circumstances are very variously told. This fierce historical satire has its counterpart in another Russian conversation of Landor's, that of the Empress Catharine and Princess Dashkof (Works, 1876, v. p. 208). xxii. From Landor's early poem of Gebir. Gebir, 1798, p. 3 : Works, 1876, vii. p. 4. This passage was reprinted as a separate extract by the author himself in Hel- lenics, 2d ed., 1859, p. 97. During Landor's retirement in South Wales (1795- 1798) his friend Rose Aylmer (see Selections cclxxii. cclxxiii. cccxiv.) lent him The Progress of Romance, through Times, Countries, and Manners, "with Remarks on the Good and Bad Effects of it, on them respectively, in a Coiirse of Evening Con- versations. By C. R. [Clara Reeve], Author of The English Baron, The Two Mentors, etc. 2 vols. NOTES. 363 NO. Colchester : Keynor ; and London : Robinson. 1785. There are few more inane books ; but at the end of vol. ii. Landor found a tale which justly struck him as marked by magnificum quid sub crepusculo antiquitatis viz. "The History of Charoba, Queen of -/Egypt : Taken from a His- tory of Ancient ./Egypt, according to the Tradi- tions of the Arabians." In her preface the author states that she has borrowed this tale from The History of Ancient JEgypt, according to the Tradi- tions of the Arabians. Written in Arabic, by the Reverend Doctor Murtadi, the son ofGapiphus, the son of Chatem, the son of Molsem the Macdesian. Translated into French by M. Vattier, Arabic Professor to Louis the 14* h King of France, Poetical use had already been incidentally made of the tale in the History of Joseph by Mrs. Rowe, the friend of Matthew Prior. Landor has treated his materials with great freedom. The contrast be- tween the characters and fates of the warlike and the peaceful brethren is entirely of his_ own con- triving. There is a shepherd in the original who wrestles with a nymph, but he is no brother of Gebir's. Here is the rather pretty passage of Clara Reeve's text upon which Landor has founded his own treatment of this episode: "Now the chief shepherd was a beautiful person, and of a goodly stature and aspect. One day when he had committed his flocks to the other shepherds, and wandered far away from them, he saw a fair young lady rising out of the sea, who walked towards him and saluted him graciously. He returned her saluta- tion, and she began to converse with him. 'Young man,' said she, ' will you wrestle with me for a wager that I shall lay against you?' 'What will you lay, fair lady,' said the shepherd, 'and what can I stake against you ?' ' If you give me a fall,' said the lady, 'I will be yours, and at your disposal, and if I give you a fall you shall give me a beast out of your flock.' ' I am content,' said the shepherd, so he went towards her, and she met him, and wrestled with him, and presently gave him a fall. She then took a beast out of the flock, and carried it away with her into the sea. "She came every evening afterwards, and did the same, until the shepherd was desperately in love with her : So the flock was diminished, and the shepherd was pining away with love and grief. " One day King Gebirus, passing by the shepherd, found him sitting very pensive by his flocks : so he came near and spoke to him. ' What misfortune hath befallen thee, shepherd ? why art thou so altered and dejected? thy flock also diminishes, and gives less milk every day?' Upon this the shepherd took 364 . NOTES. PAGE NO. courage, and told the king all that had befallen him by the lady of the sea." 119. xxn. 1. i. Thus in the extract as given in Hellenics, 1859. In other eds. the line runs " But Gebir, when he heard of her approach." 122. ,, 11. 2-5. The white internal shell of the sepia or cuttle- fish, often found on the sea-beach. 122. 11. 24-31. This is the famous passage of "the shell," echoed by Wordsworth in the Excursion, and by Byron in the Island. See English Men of Letters ; Landor, p. 169-70 ; and for Lander's own Latin version of the lines, which was probably earlier than the English, see Poemata et Inscriptions , 1847, p. 58. 124. xxiii. From the same, book v., ad init. This scene is of Landor's invention ; the nurse figures in the prose original, but without a name ; Landor has transferred her to the name Dalica, which in the original is that of a kinswoman of Charoba's, who becomes queen after her death. t28. xxiv. From the same, book vii. 130. xxv. From Landor's early poem of Ckrysaor, in Poetry by the Author of Gebir, 1802, p. i : Works, 1876, vii. p. 456 (where the poem ought to end at p. 461, 1. 20 : what follows, by an editorial oversight, belonging to a totally independent piece, Regeneration), This poem, in its main drift obscure, contains some of the finest passages of blank verse in Landor's early high-pitched manner. This of Neptune and the nymphs, and of the overthrow of Chrysaor, is the best. The only clue to any conceivable source for such a myth as Landor seems to have had in his mind, I find in Diodorus : 5ta]3e/36?7TO yap Ka0' tiXyv T??P olKov^vrjv 6'rt Xpuo-dwp 6 AajScbj' d?r6 rov TT\OIJTOV rty Trpoayyopiav /SacriAetfei /JLCV a Traces rpeis 5' '%ei rwv (TWyadrwj/ iroXefUKois, iffras viovs, diafapoitras rats re pa^cus /ecu rats ev TOIS ciydoffiv avdpCLyadiciis. Diod., iv. 156. 131. ,, 1. 13 ff. Under the name and figure of the nymph lone, Landor here alludes, as he had previously alluded in Gebir, to one Nancy Jones, the object of one of the amourettes of his Welsh days. She died a few years afterwards, and Landor printed some lines to her memory in Simonidea, 1806, p. 14. 132. ,, 1. 2. Thirteen lines are here omitted as unintelligible without a fuller knowledge than we possess of the circumstances implied. 132. xxvi. Works, 1846, ii. p. 473: Works, 1876, vii. p. 408. This and the four next examples are from the group NOTES. 365 PAGE ^ NO. of classical poems called by Landor Hellenics. They owed their origin to the expression by Lady Bles- sington of a wish that Landor would translate into English some of his Latin Idyllia Heroica. This he did, and added to them other classical pieces (and they are the best) written originally in English. This tale of Thrasymedes (or Thrasybulus) and the daughter of Peisistratos has been expanded by Landor from the brief account in Polysenus, Stratagem, v. 14 ; see also Plutarch, Apophthegm. , Pet's. 3. 135. xxvii. Works, 1876, ii. p. 481 : Works, 1876, vii. p. 444. In writing this delightful idyl, Landor has evidently had somewhat vaguely in his mind a story to which allusion is made once by Athenaeus, and twice by Plutarch. It was in reality a story of the colonizing, not of Lemnos, but of Lesbos, and is quoted by Plu- tarch from the Lesbian writer Myrsilos. The tale ran, that an oracle had enjoined the founders of the colony to cast a virgin alive into the sea during their voyage, as an offering either to Poseidon or to Am- phitrite ; that the virgin chosen (called variously the daughter of Phineus and the sister of Smintheus) was beloved by Enalos, or Enallos ; who plunged after her into the sea, where she was cared for by the Nereids, while he was employed to watch the horses of Poseidon ; and that by-and-by both were restored to earth, being safely brought to land at Methymne in Lesbos, some said by a great wave, others by help of a dolphin (Plutarch, De solert. anim. 36, Sept. sap. conviv. 20 : Athenseus, xi. 466). 140. xxviii. Works, 1846, ii. p. 478 ; Works, 1876, vii. p. 422. It is hardly conceivable that a poem of this perfect ease and grace, this pure classical charm of imagery and narrative and sentiment, should not long ago have established itself, as it must surely one day do, as a standard favourite with all readers of English poetry. The Greek story on which it is founded was originally told by a lost writer of the fifth century B. c. , Charon of Lampsacus. Reference is made to it Schol. Theocr. iii. 14 : Schol. Apoll. Rhod. ii. 477 ; and Etym. Mag. sub v0ce*AfJiadpiJCLS. In the two places last cited, the outlines of the story are given in almost identical terms. Rhoecus (Potaos, Lander's Rhaicos is an error) finds a tree in danger of falling, and has it stayed with props : the nymph of the tree appears, thanks him, and asks him what she can do to repay him : he entreats her love : there are obstacles, but in the meantime Rhoecus agrees to avoid the society of mortal women, and a bee acts as messenger between him and the nymph. One day the bee interrupts him when he is playing draughts ; he utters an angry ex- clamation, whereat the nymph taking offence leaves him desolate. In modern English poetry, Mr. Lowell 366 NOTES. PAGE NO. 4 has among his early works given another version of the tale. 149. xxix. Hellenics ', 1847, p. 45. This sequel, to my mind well worthy of its predecessor, does not appear in the Works of 1846. Neither did Landor (for what rea- son I cannot guess) reprint it in the Hellenics of 1859. Hence it has unfortunately dropped out alto- gether from Mr. Forster's collected edition. 153. xxx. Works, 1846, ii. bis : viz. p. 389, as an episodic poem in Pericles andAspasia (letter Ixxxv. , Cleone to Aspasia), and again p. 483, independently among the Hellenics ; thence reprinted in the Hellenics of 1847 and 1859 : Works, 1876, once only in Pericles andAspasia, v. p. 384. There are several differences of reading between the poems as printed in Pericles and Aspasia and in the Hellenics ; in the text I have ventured to com- bine what seem to me the best points of both. I 53- 1-3- Hell., for veined, read slender. 153. 11. 7, 8. Hell., read instead, Away, and voices like thine own come near And nearer, and solicit an embrace. 153. ,, 1. ir. Pericl. and Aspas., for Iris stood, read Fate's shears were. 153. ,, 1. 14. Hell, for those now dim, readout now dim. 153. ,, 1. 15. Hell., for watchfulness, read wakefulness. 153. 1. 19. Perzcl.andAs#.,afterhers, read the further lines: With her that old boat incorruptible, Unwearied, undiverted in its course, Had plash'd the water up the farther strand. 154 xxxi. An episode from the narrative of Pansetius in the dia- logue of Scipio, Pansetius, and Polybius ; see above, nos. vii. and viii. 150. xxxii. From the same ; the allegory being, however, complete in itself. In the description of the figure of Hope, Landor has inadvertently repeated some phrases from the description of truth contained in an earlier allegory in the conversation of the two Ciceros (see Works, 1876, ii. p. 401). Landor excelled in this kind of composition ; for an example in which the utmost depth and tenderness of human feeling is combined with the most lucid grace of imagery, compare no. xxxvi. below. 158. xxxiii. An episode from the Pentameron of Boccaccio and Petrarca. Pentameron andPentalogia, 1837, Third Day's Interview, p. 136 : Works, 1876, iii. p. 478. 165. xxxiv. From the same, Fifth Day's Interview. 167. xxxv. From the same, Fifth Day's Interview. To my mind a masterpiece hardly matched in the whole range of imaginative prose literature. Some of the scenery and incidents of the poet's life at Naples are suggested NOTES. 367 PAGE NO. by the confessions put by Boccaccio himself into the mouth of Fiammetta in his Visione dell' amoroso. Fiammetta. 172. xxxvi. From the same, Fifth Day's Interview. Separately reprinted by Landor, in Works, 1846, ii. p. 468. 172. ,, 1. 24. A page or more of the original conversation is here omitted ; nearly as much was dropped by Lan- dor himself in the version last referred to. 176. xxxvii. Exam, of Shakspeare, 1834, p. 209: Works, 1876, ii. p. 544. This is one of the various heads of discourse which Landor makes Shakspeare quote to Sir Thomas Lucy, from the mouth of Dr. Glaston, the Oxford preacher ; see also no. xxxviii. at the beginning of next section. II. REFLECTIVE AND DISCURSIVE. The contents of this section consist for the most part of extracts selected from Landor's longer prose writings, and especially from the Imaginary Conversations, viz. From the Imaginary Conversations. Aesop and Rhodope. (ist Conv.), Works, 1846, ii. p. 93 : Works, 1876, ii. p. 8. Ixxiv. Alfieri and Metastasio. Works, 1876, v. p. 127 (first published in Frasers Magazine, 1856). clx. clxvii. cxcvii. ccxv. Alfieri and Salomon the Florentine Jew. Imag. Conv., ii., 1824, p. 257 : Works, 1876, iv. p. 265. clxv. ccxxii. ccxxxi. ccxxxi. ccxlii. Barrow and Newton. Imag. Conv., v., 1829, p. i: Works, 1876, iv. p. 348. Ixviii. Ixix. Ixxxi. Ixxxiv. cxxiii. cxxv. cxxvii. clxxxix. cxc. ccxlvi. Bossuet and the Duchesse de Fontanges. Imag. Conv., iii., 1828, . 337 : Works, 1876, v. p. 192. Ixxxvi. cii. er, Archbishop and Philip Savage. Imag. Conv., iv., 1829, p. 89 : Works, 1876, iii. p. 202. clxxviii. clxxix. Brooke, Lord and Sir Philip Sidney. Imag. Conv., i., 1824, p. 13: Worksj 1876, iv. p. 3. xlvii. liii. Ivi. lix. Ixxxii. cxi. cxx. cxxxvi. cxxxvii. Catherine, Empress and Princess Dashkof. Imag. Conv., v., 1829, p. 231 : Works, 1876, v. p. 208. cxlii. Cicero, Marcus Tullius and Quinctus. ?*'?&& Conv., ii., 1824, p. 349 : Works, 1876, ii. p. 368. Ix. Ixxiii. Ixxvi. cxlvi. cxlvii. ccxxxvi. Chesterfield, Lord and Lord Chatham. Imag. Conv., ii., 1824, p. 291 : Works, 1876, iii. p. 141. cxciv. Colonna, Vittoria and Michel Angelo. Works, 1846, ii. p. 213 : Works, 1876, v. p. 278. liv. Ixxx. Ixxxiii. xcviii. ciii. cxii. cxxxviii. ccxviii. ccxxxvii. Dante and Beatrice. Works, 1846, ii. p. 152 : Works, 1876, v. p. 249. xlix. Delille, Abbe and Walter Landor. Imag. Conv., i., 1824, p. 249: Works, 1876, iv. p. 91. cc. ccxiii. ccxxiv. 368 NOTES. Demosthenes and Eubulides. I mag. Conv., i., 1824, p. 229 : Works, 1876, ii. p. 130. Ixv. Ixvi. cviii. cxxiv. clxxi. clxxii. clxxiii. clxxiv. cxcii. ccxliii. Diogenes and Plato. Imag. Conv., iv., 1829, p. 459: Works, 1876, ii. p. 64. 1. li. Ixxii. xci. cxl. clxxxvii. clxxxviii. Epicurus, Leontion, and Ternissa. Imag. Conv., v. 1829, p. 153: Works, 1876, ii. p. 190. Iv. Ixxi. Ixxv. Ixxxv. ci. cxiv. cxv. cxvi. cvii. cxxix. cli. clii. cxciii. Galileo, Milton, and a Dominican. Works, 1846, ii. p. 234 : Works, 1876, v. p. 80. xc. cix. Johnson, Dr. and Home Tooke. (ist Conv.), Imag. Conv. ii., 1824, cliii. ; (20! Conv.), Works, 1846, i. p. 193 : Works, 1876, iv. p. 209. cviii. clviii. ccxxiii. ccxlv. Lacy, General and Cura Merino. Imag. Conv., ii., 1824, p. 67 : Works, 1876, vi. p. 41. clxxxiii. Hare, Archdeacon and Walter Landor. Last Fruit, 1853, p. 97 : Works, 1876, y. p. 97. cxci. ccxxv. ccxxvi. ccxxviii. ccxxix. ccxlvii. ccxlviii. ccxlix. La Fontaine and La Rochefoucauld. Works, 1846, ii. p. 206 : Works, 1876, v. p. 53. Ixxxvii. xcvi. cxiii. cxxii. clxi. Landor, English Visitor, and Florentine Visitor. Imag. Conv., iii., 1828, p. 375 : Works, 1876, vi. p. 205. clxx. ccxc. Lucian and Timotheus. Works, 1846, ii. p. 17 : Works, 1876, ii. p. 258. xcv. ccxliv. Lucullus and Caesar. Imag. Conv., iv. 1829, p. 23 : Works, 1876, ii. p. 350. Ixxvii. Ixxviii. cliii. Machiavelli and Guicciardini. Works, 1876, v. p. 145. clxxv. Marvel, Andrew and Bishop Parker. Wjrks, 1846, ii. p. 98 : Works, 1876, v. p. 3. xlv. xlvi. Iviii. Ixii. Ixiii. Ixvii. xcii. cxi. clxii. ccxii. ccxiv. ccxx. Melanchthon and Calvin. Works, 1846, ii. p. 221 : Works, 1876, v. p. 70. xxxix. xl. xli. Middletonand Magliabecchi. Imag. Conv., i., 1826, p. 483 : Works, 1876, iv. p. 132. xlviii. Miguel and his Mother. Imag. Conv., v., 1829, p. 445 : Works, 1876, vi. p. 384. clxiii. clviv. Milton and Marvel. Works, 1876, v., ist Conv., p. 150, 2d Conv., p. 156. xliv. Ixxix. cxliii. Pallavicini, Marchese and Walter Landor. Imag. Conv., i., 1824, p. 113: Works, 1876, vi. p. 3. clxviii. clxix. Penn, William, and Lord Peterborough. Imag. Conv., v., 1829, p. 247 : Works, 1876, iii. p. 250. Ixi. Peter Leopold, Granduke and President du Paty. Imag. Conv., i., 1824, p. 167: Works, 1876, iii. p. 45. xcvii. Pollio, Asinius and Licinius Calvus. Works, 1876, ii. p. 433. cxix. cxcv. Romilly and Wilberforce. Works, 1846, ii. p. 197 : Works, 1876, iii. p. 397. xlii. Scipio, Polybius, and Pansetius. Works, 1846, ii. p. 243 : Works, 1876, ii. p. 314. cxxxii. Southey and Landor. Works, 1846, ii. p. 57 : Works, 1876, iv. p. 427. ccxvii. ccxxxviii. Southey and Porson. Imag. Conv., 1,1824, p. 49! Works, 1876, iv. p. 1 8. Ixiv. clxxxv. ccxvi. ccxxxii. ccxxxiii. NOTES. 369 Tibullus and Messala. Works, 1876, ii. p. 407. cxxxi. Washington and Franklin. Imag. Conv. t ii., 1824, p. 19 : Works, 1876, iii. p. 107. xliii. clxxx. From Citation and Examination of Shakspeare, 1834: Works, 1876, ii. p. 455. xxxviii. See also no. xxxvii. From Pericles and Aspasia, 1836 : Works, 1876, v. p. 5. Hi. Ixxxviii. Ixxxix. xciv. xcix. cv. ex. cxxvi. cxxviii. cxxx. cxxxiii. cxxxiv. cxxxv. cxliv. cxlv. cxlix. cl. cliv. civ. clvii. clix. clxxxvi. cxcviii. ccvi. ccx. ccxi. ccxxvii. See also nos. clxxvi. ccl. ccli. From T^he Pentameron and Pentalogia, 1837, p. 3161 Works, 1876, iii. p. 546. Ixx. cxlviii. clvi. clxvi. cxcix. ccv. ccviii. ccix. ccxxxiv. ccxxxv. ccxxxix. ccxl. ccxli. From an article on the Poems of Catullus: Last Fruit, 1853, p. 237, originally printed in the Foreign Quarterly Review (then edited by Forster), July 1842 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 379. c. cci. ccii. cciii. cciv. ccxix. ccxxi. ccxxx. ccxcii. The remaining nos. in this section are as follows : PAGE NO. 209 xciii. Works ; 1876, viii. p. 174. 212. civ. Works, 1876, viii. p. 278. cvi. Works, 1876, viii. p. 2. 218. cxxi. Works, 1876, viii. p. _ 164. The above are all examples of the brief gnomic or proverbial form of verse into which Landor was accustomed to throw his thoughts, and often almost exactly the same thoughts as he puts into the mouth of the interlocutors in his prose dialogues. 224. cxxxix. From High and Low Life in Italy, a series of papers in the form partly of correspondence and partly of dialogue, contributed in 1837 to Leigh Hunt's Monthly Repository (not reprinted). 253. clxxvi. "From. Reflections on Athens at the decease of Pericles, appended to ist ed. of Pericles and Aspasia, 1836, ii. p. 297 (not reprinted). 254. clxxvii. Works, 1846, ii. p. 465 : Works, 1876, v. p. 584. Written by Landor at Venice in the autumn of 1832, on his way back from England to Fiesole. 259. clxxxi. > Extracted from the dedication to General Mina (the 761. clxxxii. ) leader of the rebellion in Spain against Ferdinand) of Imag. Conv., iv. 1829. In later eds. this dedication was afterwards suppressed, and portions of it, includ- ing the present extracts, were distributed with modi- fications among the speakers in the Conversation of Odysseus, Trelawny, and Tersitza. 263.clxxxiv. Hellenics, 1847, ad init. The recreancy of Pio Nono from the Liberal cause naturally led to the complete suppression of this dedication in later eds. I have inserted it here as the most highly wrought specimen of Lander's manner in the majestic-declamatory vein of political writing. " The ferocious animal " is, of 2 B 370 NOTES. PAGE NO. course, Russia ; the " nation which revelled in every crime," France ; and the " weaker hand," that of Louis Philippe. 300. ccl. ccli. From Letter to an Author, appended to ist ed. of Pericles and Asfiasia, ii. p. 322 (not reprinted). III. PERSONAL AND AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL. To IANTHE (see English Men of Letters ; Landor, p. 22). lanthe is Landor's classic substitute for Jane, the second name of Sophia Jane Swift. To this lady Landor's somewhat roving affec- tions during his life at Bath (about 1800-1806) were principally de- voted, and he held her in great honour and affection ever after. Her first husband, a collateral descendant of the Dean of St. Patrick's, died in 1812, and she soon afterwards married M. de Molande, a French emigre of high family. After the Restoration, Madame de Molande, who had children by both marriages, went to live with her second husband in Paris. Being left once more a widow, she spent two years (1829-31) with her children in Florence, and passed the remainder of her life between England and France, dying in Paris in 1851. A few further particulars concerning this lady will be found in a book of curious gossiping reminiscences, published anonymously by a still surviving son of her first marriage, and kindly sent me by the author, viz. Wilhehris Wanderings : an Autobiography: London, Rivingtons, 1878. I have tried to make the poems referring to her tell their own story, by arranging them in a natural sequence. The chronological order of their publication (which I have indicated in the notes that follow) is of little help towards such an attempt, inasmuch as some of the earliest written were not published till long afterwards ; moreover, it is possible that of the pieces included, one or two may not really refer to lanthe at all. PAGE NO. 303. cclii. Gebir, Count Julian, etc., 1831, p. 289: Works, 1876, viii. p. 6. ccliii. Works, 1846, ii. p. 624 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 18. ccliv. Dry Sticks, 1858^ p. 157 : Works, 1876, p. 278. cclv. Works, 1846, ii. p. 621 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 9. 304. cclvi. Gebir, Count Julian, etc., 1831, p. 312 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 8. cclvii. Gebir, Count Julian, etc., 1831, p. 292: Works, 1876, viii. p. 6. cclviii. Works, 1846, ii. p. 620 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 6. 305. cclix. Works, 1846, ii. p. 626 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 22. cclx. Gebir, Count J^tl^an, etc., 1831, p. 310 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 24. cclxi. Gebir, Count Julian, etc., 1821, p. 309 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 22. cclxii. Gebir, Count Julian, etc., 1831, p. 313: Works, 1876, viii. p. 10. 306. cclxiii. Simonidea, 1806, p. 45: Works, 1876, p. 9. cclxiv. Gebir, Count Julian, etc., 1831, p. 314 : Works, 1876, p. 24. NOTES. PAGE NO. 307- cclxv. Works, 1846, ii. p. 650 : Works, 1876, viii. p. po clxvi. Works, 1846, ii. p. 650 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 88. cclxvii. Last Fruit, 1852, p. 192 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 378. 308. cclxviii. Dry Sticks, 1858, p. 160 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 278. cclxix. Last Fruit, 1853, p. 377 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 172. -cclxx. Heroic Idyls, 1863, p. 230 : Works } 1876, viii. p. 338. INVOCATIONS AND REMINISCENCES. The selection of poems, mostly addresses to persons and places, which I have grouped under this title, all relate to Lander's personal experiences and relations, and illustrate his life as well as his art. The order in which they are arranged is that, in the main, of the circumstances to which they refer, and not the chronological order of their production. 309. cclxxi. Last Fmit, 1853, p. 444 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 229. Landor was a great lover of brooks and streams ; and this lyric, in the irregular metre of Lycidas, was written after a visit paid in old age to one which he had frequented in his school-days. 310. ,, 1. 12; see note on " lanthe " above, 11. 25 ff. Wicliflfe died and was buried in Lutterworth churchyard in 1384. In 1415 the Council of Constance decreed that his bones should be dug up and burnt : on the ex- press injunction of the Pope, this order was carried out in 1428, and his ashes were cast into the Swift. 311. cclxxii. Heroic Idyls, 1863, p. 157: Works, 1876, vii. p. 320. Abertawy is the old name for Swansea ; and in the coast about Swansea and Tenby, Landor in his early Welsh days (1795-1798) used to roam in company with his friend Rose Aylmer, the youngest daughter of Henry, fourth Baron Aylmer. She afterwards went to India, and died there in 1800. (See no. cclxxiii. following, and notes to nos. xxxii. cccxiii. and cccxiv.) 312 cclxxiii. Simonidea, 1806, p. 14: Works, 1876, viii. p. 279. This is the famous little elegy written after hearing of the death of Rose Aylmer in India. As first printed in Simonidea, 1. 4 began, "For Aylmer;" 1. 5, "Sweet Aylmer," and in 1. 7, for "memories," stood "sorrows ;" it was in the reprint of 1831 that the piece first attained its present form, and its full poetical value. 312. cclxxiv. Dry Sticks, 1858, p. 173: Works, 1876, viii. p. 279. I have not been able to ascertain to whom these beautiful lines were addressed, or at what date composed. 312. cclxxv. Gebir, Coiint Julian, etc,, 1831, p. 317: Works, 1876, viii. p. 40. I have given to this piece the title of "Fiesolan" (instead of Faesulan) "Idyl," from a I copy of the poems of 1831, with MS. corrections in 372 NOTES. PAGE NO. Lander's handwriting, p. 314 ; after L 6 there fol- lows in all the editions the lame explanatory line, (For such appear their petals when detacht) : surely a disastrous bathos ; I am happy to have the authority of the same corrected copy of the original edition for omitting it. 3i4.cclxxvi. Gebir, Count Jidian, etc., 1831, p. 366 : Works, 1876, viii. pp. 49, 315 ; 11. ii ff. allude to Landor' s sanguinely undertaken schemes of agricultural improvement at Llanthony, 1809-14. 316. cclxxvii. Works, 1846, ii. p. 673-: Works, 1876, viii. p. 153. This ode was addressed by Landor to the cultivated man and kind friend whose name it bears, after they had made a tour together in the summer of 1832 from Mr. Ablett's Welsh home to the lakes, and after Landor had returned again to Italy. It was first printed in Leigh Hunt's London Journal, Dec. 3, 1834, in a form considerably varying from that which it afterwards took, and including some lines to Cole- ridge, afterwards expunged (see English Men of Letters ; Landor, p. 143), and next in a little volume called Literary Hours, by various Friends, privately printed by Mr. Ablett in 1837, f which a few copies found their way into circulation, and which contained also the two odes next following. 320. cclxxviii. Works, 1846, ii. p. 667: Works, 1876, viii. p. 136. Written about the same time as the last. 322. cclxxix. Works, 1846, ii. p. 670 : ^ Works, 1876, viii. p. 146. Written about the same time as the last two (in Mr. Ablett's Literary Hours it bears the date 1833). 324. cclxxx. Works, 1846, ii. p. 673: Works, 1876, viii. p. 133. Written on hearing the news of Lamb's death in 1834. 324. cclxxxi. Works, 1846, ii. p. 647: Works, 1876, viii. p. 80. Written on leaving Italy after the great quarrel with Mrs. Landor in 1835. 325. cclxxxii. Pentameron and Pentalogia, 1837, p. 290 : Works, 1876, iv. p. 537. Written after reaching England on the same occasion. The poem, in its tenor undis- guisedly autobiographical, was introduced by Landor into the Fifth Day's Conversation of Boccaccio and Petrarca, where Boccaccio recites it as the work of " a gentleman who resided long in this country, _and who much regretted the necessity of leaving it ; " and Petrarca receives it with the comment, " There have been those anciently who would have been pleased with such poetry, and perhaps there may be again." " Cincirillo " is the cat. 327. cclxxxiii. Works, 1846, ii. p. 646 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 78. 328. cclxxxiv. Works, 1846, ii. p. 638 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 56. 329. cclxxxv. Last Fruit, 1853, p. 329 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 196. NOTES. 373 PAGE NO. 330. cclxxxvi. Last Fruit, 1853, p. 319 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 246. 332. cclxxxvii. Dry Sticks, 1858, p. 54: Works, 1876, viii. p. 196. 332. cclxxxviii. Last Frnit, 1853, p. 450 : Works, 1876, pp. 235, 237, 1. 3- The "wide garden," with its white and purple lilacs, is the garden of Gore House, Kensington, where Lady Blessington and Count D'Orsay lived from 1836 until the final crash of their fortunes in 1849, and where Landor was accustomed to stay for some weeks almost every year during that interval. 11. 1 6, 1 8 : Landor means Greenwich, where Elizabeth was born, and Hampton Court, where Cromwell was seized with his last illness, though he did not in fact die there, but in London. CHARACTERS AND CONFESSIONS. Under this heading I have arranged what seem to me the most characteristic passages, whether of prose or verse, in which Landor has passed judgment on his con- temporaries or on himself. 334. cclxxxix. The Conversation of Bishop Burnet and Humphrey Hardcastle appeared first in Imag. Conv., i. 1824, p. 154. This attack on Byron, clumsy in the main, but containing one or two strong and effective strokes, was written during the height of the Satanic School con- troversy. Southey, in his blundering Vision of Judg- ment, had quoted a remark on Byron from Landor's Latin essay appended to the Idyllia Heroica, pub- lished at Pisa in 1820. Byron had retorted in his Vision of Judgment, published also at Pisa in Leigh Hunt's Journal, the Liberal: this was Landor's rejoinder. 335. ccxc. Appended to the same Conversation in the next edition. Imag. Conv., i. 2d ed., 1826, p. 220. In later editions the passage is broken up, and parts of it distributed between other conversations. This, dignified palinode speaks for itself : a private letter (unpublished) written by Landor to Francis Hare on receipt of the news of Byron's death, expresses exactly similar feelings. 337. ccxci. From the Conversation of Landor, English Visitor, and Florentine Visitor, as it first appeared, Imag. Conv., iii. 1828, p. 376. Considerable changes were after- wards made in the text. 338. ccxcii. From the same Conv., same ed. In Works, 1846, the last words were altered to these : " He occupies, if not the highest, almcfet the highest, place among our poets of the present age no humble station and is among the most elegant, graceful, and harmonious of the prose writers." In Works, 1876, the passage has dropped out from the Conversation altogether. 374 NOTES. PAGE NO 338. ccxciii. From The Poems of Catullus: Last Fruit ', 1853, p. 237 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 379. 339. ccxciv. Heroic Idyls, 1863, p. 218 : Works, 1876, p. 336. ccxcv. Works, 1846, i. p. 675 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 152. ccxcvi. Works, 1846, i. p. 673 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 151. 340. ccxcvii. Imag. Conv. Greeks and Romans, 1858, ad init. ccxcviii. From footnote to Conversation of Southey and Person, Imag. Conv., i. 2d ed., 1826, p. 59. The passage was broken up, and incorporated in the Con- versation of Landor, Florentine Visitor, and English Visitor. 341. ccxcix. From Conversation of Southey and Landor, Works, 1846 : Works, 1846, ii. p. 57 : Works, 1876, iv. p. 427. 342. ccc. Works, 1846, ii. p. 652 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 95. 343. ccci. Last fruit, 1853, P- 373 Works, 1876, viii. p. 167 : Last Fruit, p. 401 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 195. cccii. Last Fruit, 1853, p. 401 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 195. ccciii. From Satire on Satirists, 1837, p. 23 (not reprinted). 344. ccciv. From Preface to Dry Sticks, 1858 (not reprinted). cccv. From Conversation of Southey and Landor. 345. cccvi. From Conversation of Archdeacon Hare and Landor. cccvii. From Letter to Lord Brougham, on the Neglect of Southey, in Last Fruit, 1853, p. 317 (not reprinted). ON THE APPROACH OF OLD AGE AND DEATH. PAGE N9. 346. cccix. Last Fruit, 1853, P- 433 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 221. 347. cccx. Works, 1846, ii. p. 665 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 132. cccxi. Works, 1846, ii. p. 674 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 156. The painter here addressed is W. Fisher, whose portrait of Landor, looking up in profile, may be seen at the National Portrait Gallery, and has been used, along with the photograph given at the beginning of Works, 1876, vol. ii., in preparing the spirited en- graving which Mr. Sherborn has executed for our title-page. The well-known portrait by Boxall gives an uncharacteristic and somewhat feebly benignant view of the " old lion ; " it is with intention that the more combative and aggressive characters of the head have been insisted in on our own vignette. cccxii. Works, 1846, ii. p. 653 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 96. 348. cccxiii. Last Fruit, 1853, P- 37 2 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 166. cccxiv. Dry Sticks, 1858, p. 115 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 288. "Rose the First" is, of course, Rose Aylmer, see nos. cclxxii. cclxxvii. The mother of this young lady, Lady Aylmer, after the death of her first hus- band, married a Welsh gentleman, Mr. Howel Price, NOTES. 375 PAGE NO. and had by him a daughter, who married Mr. D. M. Paynter. The daughter of this marriage, christened Rose in her turn, was Lander's "young Rose" and "second Rose." By his "tenderest lay "he means the lines, To a Bride, addressed to her on her marriage to Mr., now Sir Charles, Sawle, in 1846 ; see Works, 1876, viii. p. 87. "Rose the Third" is the daughter of this last marriage, and greatgrand- niece of the original Rose Aylmer. 349. cccxv. Works, 1846, ii. p. 649 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 87. cccxvi. Works, 1846, ii. p. 638 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 56. cccxvii. Prefixed to Last Fruit, 1853. For the circumstances under which the lines were first read by Landor at breakfast to his friend Miss Eliza Lynn (now Mrs. Lynn Linton), see that lady's article in Fraser's Magazine, July 1870. cccxviii. Heroic Idyls, 1863, p. 212 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 334. 350. cccxix. Heroic Idyls, p. 96 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 308, 11. 6 ff. "That name" is of course lanthe : the " other bards " are Byron and Shelley. Lander's poems to Mrs. Swift under the name of lanthe had first appeared in Simonidea, 1806 : it was in 1813 that the same beautiful name was used by Shelley in Queen Mob (also as a real name for his infant daugh- ter), and by Byron in his dedication of Childe Harold to Lady Charlotte Harley. cccxx. Last Fruit, p. 383 : Works, 1876, viii. p. 178. THE END. Printed by R. & R. CLARK, Edinburgh 14 DAY USE RETURN TO DESK FROM WHICH BORROWED LOAN DEPT. This book is due on the last date stamped below, or on the date to which renewed. Renewed books are subject to immediate recall. 1859 RECTD LD UtC 3'b3-ilAM "-"~ LI) 11 Ifl ^ - - MAY 1 9 1S6Q U.C.BERKELEY LIBRARIES ^ THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LIBRARY