sity of California 
 them Regional 
 brary Facility 

 
 Under the Harrow
 
 Under the Harrow 
 
 By 
 
 Ellis Meredith 
 
 Author of "The Master Knot of Human Fate," 
 " Heart of My Heart," Etc. 
 
 The toad beneath the harrow knowi 
 Exactly where each tooth-point goes. 
 The butterfly upon the road 
 Preaches contentment to the toad. 
 
 Pagftt, M.P. 
 
 Boston 
 
 Little, Brown, and Company 
 1907
 
 Copyright, 1907, 
 BY LITTLE, BROWN, AND COMPANY. 
 
 righti reserved 
 
 PUBLISHED, MARCH, 1907 
 
 8. J. PABKHILL <fc Co., BOSTON, U. 8. A.
 
 DEDICATED TO 
 THE HEAVENLY TWINS 
 
 AND ALL THOSE GOLDEN GIRLS AND LADS WHO CLIMB 
 
 THE HILL DIFFICULTY 
 TOWARDS MOUNT PARNASSUS 
 
 2229004
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 'T^HE rain was falling steadily, insistently, 
 and the winter night was cold and cheer- 
 less. Lorraine Townsend plodded on down 
 Broadway, the water sopping through her worn 
 shoes at every step, while her wet skirts were 
 blown and wrapped about her by the wind 
 which threatened to tear her umbrella from 
 her numbed fingers. The many lights were a 
 blur in the rain and the shops looked inhos- 
 pitable. She turned west at Twenty-third 
 Street, and sighed as she looked at the long, 
 interminable blocks, and took a fresh hold 
 upon her refractory umbrella. Presently, turn- 
 ing in at a small grocery, she bought the supper 
 supplies for herself and the two girls who were 
 waiting for her in the fourth floor back, a 
 block or so beyond. She wondered whether 
 
 i
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 they had had anything to eat that day. They 
 had finished the crackers the night before and 
 the tea that morning. She was conscious of a 
 feeling of weakness which had superseded that 
 of hunger to which she had grown accustomed 
 during the past few months, and she dreaded 
 the cold, dark room and the wan faces of her 
 companions. But there was enough change 
 left to buy some coal, and then had she not 
 glorious news ? Poor they unquestionably were, 
 but before them were glowing possibilities. 
 
 She hesitated a little, for Hope was sarcastic 
 
 1 
 
 and Bess matter of fact, and what had seemed 
 an amusing adventure might not appeal to 
 them in the same way. Lorraine held her 
 parcels tightly and tried to hurry. One more 
 turn, and she found herself stumbling up the 
 dimly lit stairway, conscious of an excited col- 
 loquy going on overhead. As she reached the 
 last turn she saw the attenuated form of their 
 landlady and heard her high, strident voice. 
 
 "I don't want to be unreasonable, and you 
 ain't much behind, with this leastways," she 
 was saying, while she examined the bill in her 
 hand, "but land sakes, what's the use of it 
 
 2
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 all ? Every day of my life I useter say to 
 Mr. Willis, 'Mr. Willis,' I says, * what's the 
 good of it all?' and up to the day he died he 
 never made no answer, and I don't know as 
 he would if he was to rise up now. Seems 
 like a man would hardly lie down an' die if 
 there was any use livin'. Here you be, a-tryin* 
 to write books and paint picturs and sech-like, 
 just as if there wasn't hundreds a-starvin' at 
 it now. So long's you pay your rent 'tain't no 
 affair of mine, but what air ye doin' it for ? 
 Some of ye has good homes, an* ye'd be a sight 
 better off in 'em. New York ain't no place 
 for young girls, and the better lookin' they 
 air the worse it is. There ain't none of you 
 to say homely enough to get out and make a 
 livin' with any comfort." 
 
 Lorraine was used to Mrs. Willis. "Is this 
 a new book of lamentations?" she asked 
 cheerfully, as she gained the landing and was 
 fallen upon by her waiting comrades in distress, 
 who relieved her of her parcels and her drip- 
 ping umbrella. She had expected to find 
 gloom and a chilly stove, but the parlor cook 
 had got over the sulks, the kettle was singing, 
 
 3
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 and the room was warm and light. Mrs. 
 Willis took her departure regretfully, with a 
 lingering look at the parcels Lorraine had 
 brought, and the girl looked around with a 
 feeling that she had been defrauded of her 
 part of good fairy. "What has happened ?" 
 she asked, surprise and grievance mingling in 
 her voice. 
 
 "It's 'many happy returns' and one of them 
 wasn't so bad," said Hope gleefully. " Can you 
 believe it ? We have a check, just a little one, 
 of course, but it did some good." 
 
 "Which did you sell?" asked Lorraine 
 eagerly, "and what has come back?" 
 
 "I sold some nonsense verses with Bess' 
 illustrations, or maybe it was the pictures that 
 sold. Anyhow, I got eight dollars, and while 
 that isn't much it was enough to 'soften the 
 heart of the cow.' I wouldn't have given Mrs. 
 Willis so much of it, but she was here when it 
 came, explaining how really sensible young 
 women do housework, which pays well and 
 requires no previous training! and no outlay 
 for clothes, so I had to convince her that 
 literature is a paying profession. I promised 
 4
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 her an immediate settlement if she would let 
 us have some coal, and then I went out and 
 got the check cashed and bought a dollar's 
 worth of stamps. I could put them in my 
 purse where she couldn't see them, and 1 gave 
 her the rest. There's nothing to eat, but it's 
 warm anyhow." 
 
 Lorraine laughed. "Isn't that just like 
 Hope?" she said, "a dollar's worth of stamps 
 and a Mother Hubbard pantry. But there's 
 plenty to eat, an' it please you. I've had just 
 a bit of luck to-day too, and we are going to 
 have supper, a real, hot supper." 
 
 "Tell us about the luck," said Hope. 
 
 "Not yet," answered Lorraine evasively. 
 " Let's have something to eat, and tell me about 
 the stories. Maybe you won't think much of 
 my piece of news." 
 
 After the supper things were cleared away, 
 the girls gathered about the stove and Lorraine 
 asked, "Where are the rest of the returns? 
 Which of mine came back?" 
 
 "I'm not sure," answered Hope; "but I 
 think this is 'Eagle Eye,'" handing over a long 
 envelope, "and this is about the weight of 
 
 5
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 'An Experiment in Polities'; that takes three 
 stamps, doesn't it ? and this looks like poetry." 
 
 Lorraine frowned. " Contemporaneous verse, 
 my child. You will never be the real thing 
 until you learn these distinctions. Call no 
 man, or woman either, a poet until after 
 death." She opened the envelopes. "Yes, 
 here's poor old 'Eagle Eye'; he's nearly been 
 the rounds. The other is 'Harriet's House- 
 hold.' Now what do you think is the matter 
 with them ?" 
 
 Hope reflected a moment. " Do you remem- 
 ber the story of the girl who makes jam and 
 wants to be a writer ? She has written one 
 story, which she can't sell, and everybody 
 advises her differently. There's a pirate in it, 
 and first she is told to take him out and send 
 it to a religious magazine, and then when it 
 comes back she puts him in again; and she 
 keeps on taking him out and putting him back, 
 until finally she rewrites the whole thing, and 
 sells it on the strength of the pirate. Then 
 she retires on her laurels and sells jam the rest 
 of her days. It's not very clear in my mind, 
 but I think if you could make the pirate motif 
 
 6
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 a trifle more couchant in 'Eagle Eye' and a 
 wee mite more rampant in 'Harriet's House- 
 hold' it would be an improvement. 'Eagle 
 Eye' is too somber. There's no relief in the 
 tragedy; can't you wash off some of the war- 
 paint, or take off a feather or two " 
 
 "It's impossible," groaned Lorraine. "The 
 only thing you can take off in that story is 
 scalps. Besides, I've told it the way it hap- 
 pened. Isn't there any publisher who cares 
 for history ?" 
 
 "That's nothing. People don't care how a 
 thing happened. They want it to happen to 
 suit them, and you know yourself you couldn't 
 sleep after reading a story like that. Do try 
 and tone it down." 
 
 "I know what Hope means," said Bess. 
 "When Dick Heldar's 'Last Shot' doesn't 
 please, he just puts the soldier in his Sunday 
 clothes and gives him a clean shave and a 
 bath and sells him for twice as much and says, 
 'If they want furniture polish, let them have 
 furniture polish, so long as they pay for it.' 
 They don't want real Indians and fresh war- 
 paint. Give your hero a diploma from Car- 
 
 7
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 lisle and a tailor-made suit instead of a blanket. 
 You can't foreshorten a picture as it is in life. 
 Nobody would believe it." 
 
 Lorraine shook her head obstinately. "Pos- 
 sibly I can leave off some feathers," she said, 
 "but it won't be true to life. As it is I didn't 
 scalp my victim, and I toned down my no- 
 menclature and called 'Hell Gate' another 
 name, which is enough to bar me from mem- 
 bership among the Daughters of the Pioneers. 
 When you have a pirate story I don't believe 
 in decorating his long, low, rakish craft with 
 pink and white pop-corn and Christmas-tree 
 candles, and serving afternoon tea. If you're 
 going to have a pirate at all, you have to have 
 grog, extra rations of it, and in spite of my 
 W. C. T. U. mother, when I go on freebooting 
 expeditions I insist on Jamaica rum." 
 
 "That may all be true," said Hope doubt- 
 fully, "but this is the twelfth venture. He has 
 only one more chance. There must be some- 
 thing wrong." 
 
 "Maybe it's the readers," sagely suggested 
 Bess. 
 
 "Darling child!" murmured Lorraine grate- 
 8
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 fully. "No, there's something the matter, but 
 I don't know what. I'll send him out West 
 somewhere; maybe they'll take to him more 
 kindly, but he's such a good Indian I thought 
 he'd stand a better show East where folks have 
 had a few hundred years to forget about 
 Indians. Then if he comes back he'll have to 
 go to the ash-barrel." 
 
 "What's the matter with the other one?" 
 asked Bess. 
 
 "Harriet'? I think Hope is right about 
 her," Lorraine admitted. "That's another true 
 story, and the end isn't dramatic enough. If 
 I could bring in the bold buccaneer long enough 
 to sing the 'Pirate's Serenade' and make off 
 with the fair but reluctant Harriet, that would 
 improve it." She looked over the typewritten 
 pages and sighed. "That means rewriting at 
 least two-thirds of it, and when I typewrite my 
 stuff I never blame the editors for declining it. 
 I don't know anything that will reduce a swollen 
 cranium so quickly. Did you get anything 
 back, Hope?" 
 
 "Oh, yes; you are not the only unsuccess- 
 ful writer in New York. Here's ' Mrs. Field's 
 
 9
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 Good Name/ with a polite note asking me to 
 send them something else like it, but different. 
 Is that sarcasm, or does the editor mean to 
 drive me to a home for the feeble-minded ?" 
 
 "You might send him 'Sara Harding,' that's 
 different but like," ventured Lorraine, looking 
 at the clock. 
 
 "Mercy, it's after ten, and you haven't told 
 us about your good luck yet," said Bess. 
 
 They had reached the hair-combing stage, 
 and Lorraine retreated behind the thick masses 
 of a chestnut mane that almost reached the 
 floor. "You know I washed my hair yester- 
 day," she said irrelevantly. 
 
 "Your efforts to put off the evil day are all in 
 vain," laughed Hope. "What has washing your 
 hair to do with this wonderful piece of news ?" 
 
 "Lots," she answered briefly; "I've rented 
 my hair." 
 
 The girls stared at her. Bess found her voice 
 first. "You're not going to have it cut off!" 
 she cried in horror-stricken tones. 
 
 Lorraine's courage had returned. "I said 
 rented, not sold," she answered. "You know 
 how dreadfully it blew this afternoon about 
 
 10
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 three ? I never can do anything with my hair 
 for a day or two after it is washed. It just 
 sifts out the pins. I felt it coming down and 
 made a wild clutch at it and took refuge in a 
 tiny drug store kept by a tiny old man, up on 
 Fortieth Street, and the whole pile of it un- 
 uncoiled." 
 
 "And you looked just like 'The Lady of 
 Shalott' in the old editions of Tennyson," said 
 Hope. 
 
 " Perhaps, but it was a blessing, not a curse, 
 that came upon me," responded Lorraine. 
 "One can't be dignified under such circum- 
 stances as that. The nice little old man 
 laughed and made some pretty speeches, and 
 I bought some hairpins with my last pennies; 
 and to make a long story short I am going 
 to sit in his window, with my hair spread 
 abroad, as an advertisement for a tonic he can 
 make for a cent and sell for a dollar a bottle. 
 It's an old prescription that my family has 
 always used, and is really good. He's going 
 to divide the profits evenly, and insisted on my 
 taking a small advance. Hence the supper. 
 His name is Peter Bright, and his customers, 
 
 ii
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 most of them, call him 'Uncle Peter/ I once 
 knew three old maid sisters," she went on, 
 "who used to prepare for death every little 
 while, so as to spare those who should be left 
 when the sad day came. They had a lot of 
 trouble to know what to do with their false 
 hair, for they had all lived in the days of 
 chignons and waterfalls, and they had waves 
 and curls and switches and frizzes; so at last 
 they bundled up the whole assortment and 
 sold it to a hair-dealer. Now if one can rent her 
 hair and keep it too, isn't that much better than 
 using it merely to keep one's hat in place ?" 
 
 "Lorraine, you certainly are a trump!" said 
 Bess. 
 
 "Besides, it will work out two ways, as I 
 figure it," went on Lorraine. "First, it will 
 give us a much-needed revenue, for if I do say 
 it as shouldn't, there's not a thin-haired woman 
 in New York but would buy a tonic that will 
 grow hair like that; and, second, it will give 
 me a subject for a good, newsy article, 
 'How it feels to be an Advertisement/ Come, 
 let's go to bed. There's something to get up 
 for to-morrow morning." 
 
 12
 
 II 
 
 ORRAINE'S business adventure proved so 
 successful that she prolonged it for several 
 weeks longer than she at first intended. A real 
 friendship sprang up between her and "Uncle 
 Peter," who took heart of grace and cleaned 
 up the shop under her direction, and indulged in 
 a fresh coat of paint for his dingy sign. In turn 
 she told him the story of their struggle, and her 
 plan to write up her experience. He listened 
 with pleased interest, and then said: "When 
 you get it done, mail it to this address. Mary 
 Deland is my niece, and she has an editorial 
 position on this paper. I'll give you a note to 
 enclose to her, and she will do the best she can 
 for you. We don't see each other often, for 
 we both work long hours, but we love each 
 other dearly. She is almost my only relative. 
 And drop in sometimes. I wish you were my 
 niece too." 
 
 It was two weeks before Lorraine heard any 
 news from her story. Then there came a note 
 
 13
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 asking her to call on Mrs. Deland. The re- 
 
 O 
 
 vulsion of feeling, the hope that her work was 
 not absolutely worthless, since it was not re- 
 turned, brought Lorraine's nerves almost to 
 the snapping point. Quite suddenly she real- 
 ized all the strain of the past few weeks, and 
 the blank misery if this hazard also proved a 
 failure. The girls cheered her as best they 
 could, and lent her whatever wearing apparel 
 they possessed that would lend any touch to her 
 costume. It is a sad commentary on human 
 nature, but they had all learned that one is 
 not more likely to obtain work because the need 
 of it is obvious. 
 
 Fortunately she did not have to wait long, 
 and as she was ushered into a small, well- 
 appointed office she was welcomed by a very 
 tall, beautiful woman who held out her hand 
 and said with a charming smile: "I am very 
 pleased to meet you, Miss Townsend; any one 
 of Uncle Peter's friends is dear to me for his 
 sake, but as a writer you are all the more 
 welcome." Mrs. Deland knew something of 
 human nature, and Lorraine's dumb and im- 
 ploring face told her all Uncle Peter's letter 
 
 1.4
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 had omitted. "Sit down, and let us have a 
 cup of tea," she said. "I always have tea 
 about this hour, and I want to hear about 
 Uncle Peter, and then we will talk about the 
 story." 
 
 Lorraine told all about her meeting with 
 Uncle Peter, and their subsequent partnership, 
 with girlish enthusiasm. It was such a relief 
 not to have to speak of herself right at first. 
 When they had reached the second cup and 
 Lorraine was quite herself again, Mrs. Deland 
 said: "We like your stuff" very much; the 
 managing editor wanted me to see you and 
 talk with you, no, I don't mean about this 
 story, for it is already being set up, but could 
 you keep on ? We want some daily human in- 
 terest stories; say half to three-quarters of a 
 column; never more than that." 
 
 Lorraine's tongue clove to the roof of her 
 mouth for the space of a half-minute, then she 
 said she thought she could; there was a little 
 more discussion, and then she found herself 
 in The Presence. She never remembered much 
 of that interview. She had a hazy recollection 
 of a tall, grizzled man, slight of form with keen 
 
 15
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 eyes and a voice so singularly cool that one 
 instinctively looked for a thermometer to see 
 if the temperature was not fall ng. 
 
 "Can you begin now, Miss Townsend?" he 
 a ked. "Our special man has gone to the 
 Herald, and we wish to replace him at once. 
 You bring a lighter touch and a new point of 
 view. That's the great thing in newspaper 
 work, the fresh standpoint." 
 
 "What hour shall I report?" answered Lor- 
 raine. 
 
 "You might report to Mrs. Deland for a 
 week or so at eight in the morning After 
 that, when you have the idea, you will find it 
 more convenient to keep a day ahead, and turn 
 in your copy by ten," he answered, turning 
 away from a look of such gratitude that even 
 he, hardened newspaper man that he was, found 
 himself remembering and smiling over it. 
 
 Lorraine took her car trying to realize that 
 her career had begun, but found herself think- 
 ing less of her own amazing good fortune than 
 of Mary Deland, gracious, wonderful Mary 
 Deland, as different from all other women as 
 if she belonged to a new type. It seemed to 
 
 16
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 Lorraine that while the ordinary New York 
 countenance might be called the face militant, 
 Mary Deland's was the face triumphant. The 
 usual face is a fighting face; the grim mouth, 
 the lines, the alert eyes, the repression, the 
 mask that slips now and then; most of us, 
 for few are non-combatants, show the signals 
 of war in our faces. The flag droops at half- 
 mast, it is shot to ribbons, it is trai'ed in the 
 dust, it is hauled down, it is reversed; sometimes 
 it is the black flag, sometimes the white; some- 
 times it is the warning yellow of the plague 
 ancf sometimes the fluttering red of the auc- 
 tioneer. Lorraine felt that she knew the fight- 
 ing face in all its moods, but this woman was 
 different. Her white forehead seemed the fit- 
 ting symbol of the lofty soul that dwelt within, 
 her sweet lips and grave eyes were full of the 
 serenity of overcoming. Thinking of her, Lor- 
 raine was carried far past the corner where she 
 should have left her car.
 
 Ill 
 
 /"\NE story does not make an author, nor 
 provide an income, save in rare instances, 
 nor one small salary insure die turning of a win- 
 try discontent into glorious summer. Though the 
 girls contrived to live upon Lorraine's wages, 
 while they sought employment on their own 
 account, they both rebelled. 
 
 "We can't go on this way, living on Lor- 
 raine," said Hope one gloomy afternoon turn- 
 ing away from her typewriter and gathering up 
 her manuscript. "It's outrageous. She could 
 get along fairly well on what she makes, but 
 this thing of taking care of two able-bodied 
 women is too much." 
 
 "I know," said Bess dismally, looking up 
 from the table that was strewn with her card- 
 board, and poising her pen in mid-air to the 
 imminent danger of her last sketch. "I sup- 
 pose I ought to go home, as Mrs. Willis says. 
 Did you hear her this morning? Anybody 
 would think we were Barn urn's ten-thousand- 
 
 18
 
 1MDER THE HARROW 
 
 dollar beauties to listen to her go on about the 
 frmpratimn ind uirfjBi Tifcirh thn rky nrniiiffi 
 for the good looking. She spent at least {fifteen 
 nunutes asajiung me that the one thing she 
 and the late LjinrjMrd ewer agreed upon was 
 that this show was not worth die pace of 
 aAnksJMij and that aD its three rings wouldn't 
 fiiiniA sawdust c noiiffi ID stnnr onr don,, and 
 after k was stuffed k would be nothing but 
 sawdust. Oh, is that you, Lorraine ?" 
 
 ** Yes, and I'm glad I amrcd in time to hear 
 that disquisition on sawdust. If there B a 
 class of people on earth lor whom I ha*r no 
 use, k*s die crowd who mourn when they find 
 dieir dofls stuffed wkh sawdust. Whfle my 
 doll has anything in k I shall not coonplam. It 
 is only when she hangs, hmp and iat, wkh 
 nothing to pin her dotfacs to and dancing 
 china limbs, that yon ait going to hear die 
 outcry of my anguished souL What do yon 
 cipcct in a fijtry~nine-cent doD ?"" 
 
 "Marked down from two eigjhiy-lour/* added 
 Hope. 
 
 "And dear at any price," said a race from 
 the doorway.
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 The girls turned in the dull twilight, and 
 Lorraine flung open the door. Their unex- 
 pected guest was a little old lady, with near- 
 sighted eyes, peering through thick-lensed 
 glasses. She was dressed in the hodden gray 
 of the Quaker, and a black and tan dog was at 
 her heels. 
 
 "I beg your pardon," she said. "I rapped 
 twice, but you did not hear me, and the door 
 was ajar, and I couldn't help overhearing your 
 conversation. My name is Brent, and I'm the 
 oldest of the Heavenly Twins. My sister Eliza 
 is only sixty, and there's just as much sawdust 
 in our dolls as there ever was." 
 
 Her manner was so quaint and her ac- 
 cent so cheery that the girls drew toward 
 her as if she were more promising than the 
 sullen stove. "Perhaps," said Lorraine, 
 politely offering her a chair, "you can tell 
 these tiresome children how to keep the saw- 
 dust in their dolls." 
 
 "Or how to keep one's sawdust and eat it 
 too," said Bess. "That's the rub, and one 
 does grow hungry now and then. Can you 
 tell us anything about a sawdust diet?" 
 20
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "Certainly," said Miss Brent. "Dear, dear, 
 but it is shameful the way the classics are 
 neglected. Have you never heard of the 
 
 * Old person of Crewd, 
 Who said, We use sawdust for food ; 
 
 It is cheap by the ton, 
 
 And it nourishes one, 
 And that's the main object of food ' ? " 
 
 "I wonder where one could find the nearest 
 carpenter shop," said Lorraine reflectively. 
 "Miss Brent, you behold before you three 
 persons of undoubted genius. One of us has 
 written a book which has been called a classic; 
 as nobody reads it, when it gets old enough it 
 may get into that category. We know we are 
 geniuses because we seldom have enough to 
 eat, while mere mediocrity goes forth and or- 
 ders steak and onions. We live in a garret, 
 never have any new clothes and, much to our 
 regret, we are devoted to art for art's sake; at 
 least we can't get anything else for it." 
 
 "That sounds like a true bill," said Miss 
 Brent. "What do you do ?" 
 
 "We do various things. Hope would have 
 liked to tread the histrionic boards, but owing 
 
 21
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 to her entire lack of vanity I can't persuade 
 her to try, and so she 'ekes out a miserable 
 existence' that's the right expression, isn't it ? 
 as a producer of 'literacheur,' which is also 
 my avocation. We have done some things of 
 great brilliance. The reason it is so dark is 
 that yesterday Hope found some stamps and 
 sent off all our efforts. Usually our apartment 
 looks like the grotto in a pantomime, lit solely 
 by the effulgence of our unpublished works. 
 We mean to keep a few on hand to save kero- 
 sene, but Hope is so extravagant." 
 
 "Never mind," said Bess, "some of them 
 will be back soon." 
 
 "The infant prodigy who has just spoken," 
 continued Lorraine, "hankers to 'paint on a 
 ten-league canvas with brushes of camel's hair/ 
 but so far her chromos usually come back, save 
 when they are sent with some soul-thrilling 
 tale of Hope's, and sold on the strength of the 
 story." 
 
 "Which do you have the best returns from ?" 
 asked Miss Brent curiously. 
 
 "The quickest? I think Harpers is about 
 as reliable as any of them. The Century is 
 22
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 prompt. Sometimes they come back from 
 McClures in two weeks, and I've had them 
 back from the Cosmopolitan in ten days. The 
 Atlantic takes a little longer, but they let you 
 down with a personal letter that encourages 
 you to send something else. The rest average 
 along from two weeks to a month. We are 
 small prophets, but we get reasonably quick 
 returns." 
 
 "I don't think so," said Hope with a dis- 
 satisfied air. "It takes over a year for a story 
 to reach the ash-barrel. Publishers have no 
 right to waste so much time. Why can't they 
 return things sooner ? At this rate my ash- 
 barrel will not be half full when I make my 
 great hit." 
 
 "I have a friend in California who says all 
 the big magazines keep agents at the Mississippi 
 River to meet his manuscript and turn it back; 
 but you'll have to explain about the ash-barrel. 
 I thought writers wanted publishers to keep 
 things," said Miss Brent. 
 
 "That's quite the old-fashioned idea," said 
 Hope. "Now the way is to get an ash-barrel 
 full of stories against the day of success. Don't 
 
 23
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 you recall that delicious fable in Life of the 
 successful author and his ash-barrel ? It tells 
 how the critic goes forth to see what is the 
 matter with literature, and he finds a plump 
 old gentleman sitting on a pile of laurels 
 selling stuff marked D. W. T. declined with 
 thanks out of a barrel he filled before he 
 grew famous. After one gets the laurels he can 
 sell anything, but it is against the rules of the 
 Amalgamated Order of Authors to put any- 
 thing into the ash-barrel until it has been sent 
 to thirteen places. Any one doing so is likely to 
 lose his working card and be fined by the union." 
 
 "But why thirteen?" asked Miss Brent. "I 
 thought thirteen was an unlucky number." 
 
 "Well, don't you think it's pretty unlucky to 
 have a story come back thirteen times ?" asked 
 Lorraine. 
 
 "Oh, yes, of course!" answered Miss Brent, 
 "it looks that way, but then that's another 
 sign of genius. 'Vanity Fair' was rejected by 
 twenty publishers, and Thackeray brought it 
 out himself. ' Sartor Resartus ' went the rounds. 
 'Tom Jones' failed until is was dramatized. 
 At least a dozen publishers refused 'Uncle 
 24
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 Tom's Cabin.' 'Innocents Abroad' was de- 
 clined by all the standard publishers and brought 
 out as a subscription book. It took two years 
 to sell 'Ben Hur,' and 'Lorna Doone' made 
 its success after it had been out a dozen years. 
 Miss Corelli's 'Romance of Two Worlds' was 
 refused by all of Bentley's readers, including 
 Hall Caine." 
 
 "I call that poetic justice," laughed Lorraine. 
 " Do you remember how Carolyn Wells brackets 
 the two of them ? 
 
 'To the masses should our classes offer Ibsen when we find 
 Mr. Caine and Miss Corelli better please the massy mind ? ' 
 
 But you must be following the literary trail 
 yourself or you wouldn't have so many of these 
 consoling facts in mind." 
 
 Miss Brent blushed a charming pink. "Yes," 
 she said bravely, "that is, I'm not, but I'd like 
 to be. That's how I come to be here. An old 
 gentleman, that I'm in the habit of pestering, 
 tells me that what my work needs is editing, 
 and he suggested that if Miss Townsend would 
 undertake this for me that I have some things 
 that might do. I shall not mind how dis- 
 
 25
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 couraging you are," she went on valiantly, turn- 
 ing to Lorraine. "Do you remember how 
 Thackeray asked Jerrold if it was true that he 
 had said 'The Virginians' was the worst book 
 he had ever written, and Jerrold answered, 
 'No, I said it was the worst book anybody ever 
 wrote' ? And then there was the lunatic I beg 
 your pardon, my dear, no offence to you who 
 called 'The Wreck of the Grosvenor' 'a cata- 
 logue of ship's furniture,' and the reviewer who 
 said Byron could never be a poet. You can 
 call my scribbling anything you like; so far 
 no one has been willing to call it at all except 
 Peter Bright, and he only reads it because we 
 used to go to school together. Can I bring the 
 articles to-morrow ? Will you really be so good 
 as to go over them for me, for a consideration, 
 of course ?" 
 
 Lorraine hesitated. "I don't know that I 
 can be of any use to you," she said honestly. 
 "I have done a good deal of reviewing, but I 
 haven't done much editorial work, and don't 
 feel that my opinion is worth much." 
 
 "I'll be satisfied," said Miss Brent. "I'd 
 like to come anyhow. I'm fond of geniuses." 
 26
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 She shook hands all round, and Lorraine saw 
 her down the dark stairway. A carriage was 
 waiting in the narrow street, to the great in- 
 terest of the neighbors. It seemed darker and 
 colder after she had gone. The girls held the 
 lamp at the top of the stairs and waited Lor- 
 raine's return. 
 
 "What do you think she is?" asked Hope. 
 " I believe she is a district visitor from a college 
 settlement, looking for a chance to improve our 
 minds and ask us to hear some good music." 
 
 "Maybe she's a city missionary," said Bess 
 doubtfully. 
 
 "She might be the committee-woman for this 
 ward," said Lorraine, who hailed from Denver, 
 "but she isn't. She is our fairy godmother. I 
 have just tucked her into a large pumpkin 
 drawn by four fat white rats and she has vanished. 
 You just wait and see. Things are going to be 
 better for us and that right early. There was 
 no condescension about her, or any effort to lend 
 us aid and comfort and the price of a meal." 
 
 "And it was Uncle Peter who sent her!" 
 added Bess, as if this alone constituted a guar- 
 antee of good faith. 
 
 27
 
 IV 
 
 TN April there came an upheaval in the office 
 where Lorraine was employed, and the new 
 city editor promptly discontinued her daily 
 story. "Come around in a week or so," he 
 said gruffly; "there may be something then, but 
 not now." 
 
 Lorraine turned to leave the office, sick at 
 heart and utterly discouraged, and meeting Mary 
 Deland in the elevator they went out together. 
 For a long time they walked in silence, then 
 turned in at Trinity Churchyard. 
 
 "It's hard," Mary said at last. "It's dread- 
 fully hard for a woman to do newspaper work, 
 if she is a real woman and feels it with her 
 heart. You've done well, Lorraine. It has 
 been really good work, with the elixir of life in 
 it, the one drop of human blood that makes 
 it vital; but Maxwell has a man he wants to 
 put on, and he has to show his authority some 
 way. He has let Hunter out, and Hunter is 
 the best political man we ever had; and Stan- 
 28
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 ley, who knows more about music than any 
 critic we are likely to get. How he had the 
 heart to discontinue your little story I don't 
 know." 
 
 "City editors are not much afflicted with 
 enlargement of the heart," said Lorraine 
 gloomily. She was thinking of the attic and 
 the parlor cook and the girls, the girls, the attic 
 and the parlor cook, and the thought was 
 bitter. 
 
 " Some of them are kindness itself," answered 
 Mary. "The first city editor I ever worked for 
 was so patient and painstaking and so consid- 
 erate in the assignments he gave me that I was 
 spoiled for all the others. But, as you say, 
 Maxwell has no heart. The boys in the office 
 say he has no stomach even." 
 
 "What!" cried Lorraine in amazement. 
 
 "Yes, they say he doesn't eat; he stokes; he 
 gets up steam in the boiler, and instead of the 
 usual heart, lungs, et cetera, he has works which 
 he winds up every week or so. He is a good 
 machine, but woe to any one who gets caught 
 among the cogs. I can't stay here any longer, 
 Lorraine; there are other reasons, and I am 
 
 29
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 going West. I have a good offer and shall 
 leave at once. Can't you go with me ? It is 
 always an advantage to have worked in New 
 York, and I think I might be able to help you 
 find an opening. We will take a few rooms 
 together, and perhaps we can find time 
 for something beside the 'demnition grind.' 
 I have a novel I want to finish. Will you come, 
 Lorraine ? There's no one else in the world 
 that I'd care to have, but I want you." 
 
 Lorraine looked up at the taller woman, her 
 guide and inspiration, and her eyes filled. She 
 longed to go, but she thought of Hope, working 
 away so faithfully; of Bess, whose drawings had 
 been accepted several times of late. Without 
 her they could not stay. The brimming eyes 
 brimmed over and the two women stole into 
 the quiet, dark church, and Lorraine had her 
 cry out on Mary's shoulder. 
 
 "Some day you will come," she said, "and 
 we will work together, and until then, if I don't 
 write often, don't think it is because I don't 
 care." She held up her shaking right hand, 
 an eloquent if silent tribute to her industry. 
 "They say it will be worse as time goes on, 
 30
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 but every Sunday there will be something in 
 my stuff that will be for you, and you must try 
 and take that as a weekly letter, just as I shall 
 look for your stories, and feel that I am hear- 
 ing from you." 
 
 " I shall write to you whether you answer or 
 not, Mary Deland, and I shall read every line 
 of yours," said Lorraine; "and when the girls 
 don't need me any more I shall come to you. I 
 shall never forget what you have been to me, 
 what you have done for me. How can you 
 understand everything so perfectly ? How can 
 I ever learn that ?" 
 
 Mary Deland's face saddened. "I hope you 
 may never learn by experience," she said. "I 
 hope you will never purchase knowledge at so 
 high a price as I, for it has been dearly bought 
 and paid for in my heart's blood. Some day 
 I will tell you. Promise me, Lorraine, that 
 every day you will write something, even if it 
 is only twenty lines, into which you put the best 
 there is in you, for some day you are going to 
 do something worth while. I know this and 
 look forward to the time when I shall be very 
 proud of you."
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 They kissed each other good-by there in the 
 somber church and separated at the gate, one 
 to pack trunks and buy tickets, the other to 
 face Mrs. Willis and the anxious faces of her 
 comrades
 
 might as well face the cold facts, Lor- 
 raine," said Hope, "and they are cold, 
 chronically, clammily cold, like this stove," 
 giving the coals a vicious poke. "You go with 
 Mary Deland and I'll go back to the farm and 
 teach school, or marry William Smith or some 
 other rural hero. I can't produce literature, or 
 if I can I can't sell it. I used to say if all else 
 failed I would start a waffle factory, for I can 
 make better waffles than anybody, but I haven't 
 the courage. If I tried it all the hens in the 
 country would strike, eggs would soar without 
 waiting to hatch wings, and I verily believe sour 
 milk would turn sweet, because I can't cook 
 with baking powder." 
 
 "But the mortgage?" asked Lorraine; "and 
 - it isn't exactly pleasant at home, is it ?" 
 
 "No," drearily. "A mortgage is like Nixon 
 Waterman's grass. 'I see it growing day by 
 day, it also grows by night,' and the interest 
 eats one out of house and home, but at this 
 
 33
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 rate I shall never be able to help lift it. All I've 
 done by coming here is to relieve them of the 
 burden of my existence, and you've borne that 
 a good part of the time, which isn't fair. The 
 rent is due for another month and we haven't 
 anything ahead to speak of, and you know 
 Mrs. Willis." 
 
 "Stand her off for a few days," answered 
 Lorraine. "Tell her that 'rent is robbery.' 
 That will give her something to think about 
 and us a little more time." 
 
 "I've had time enough," answered Hope. 
 "After more than a year I haven't made good, 
 and I have no right to keep you here when you 
 can do so much better. If Bess can hang on 
 a little longer I am sure she will succeed, but 
 I can't see anything ahead for myself. I can 
 write some things fairly well, but it is work for 
 me; I don't love it as you do. I have the 
 dramatic instinct, I can see a situation, and if 
 I could say it I could make it sound real, but 
 it slips away before I can write the words. I'd 
 starve to death at it. Who's that ?" 
 
 There was a brisk rat-a-tat at the door and 
 Miss Brent came in, Rab at her heels. "Don't 
 34
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 think me a professional eavesdropper," she said, 
 "but who is starving?" 
 
 "We haven't begun yet, at least not enough 
 to hurt," answered Lorraine; "but Hope is sure 
 she has sighted it right off our port quarter in 
 the fog. I'm delighted. It's a sure sign of 
 genius." 
 
 Miss Brent shook her head. "Don't you 
 ever believe such trash as that. Geniuses don't 
 starve because they are geniuses; they are 
 geniuses because they starve. It isn't necessary 
 to know any more about literature than I do 
 to see that it is suffering from fatty degenera- 
 tion." 
 
 "Don't try to reconcile us to our poverty, 
 Miss Brent," said Hope, laughing a trifle bit- 
 terly. "If we hanker after the flesh-pots of 
 Egypt it's only 'them spicy garlic smells' we're 
 thinking of, and our idea of riotous living is to 
 put cream on our porridge." 
 
 Lorraine adjusted a piece of paper over a 
 broken window pane and tried to stir the fire 
 to some sign of life, and Miss Brent sat in silent 
 communion with herself for several minutes. 
 "Girls," she said finally, "you are every one 
 
 35
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 of you the owner of God-given genius, and 
 genius ought always to live in the attic and 
 keep its clothes in pawn, like Goldsmith or 
 Balzac. If it lives well for three days a month, 
 like Henri Miirger, it should starve the other 
 twenty-seven, as he did, or be without a sou, 
 as Gerard de Nerval usually was. I don't like 
 to interfere with the ways of Providence or lay 
 a straw in your pathway, but the truth is, our 
 attic is full of geniuses now, and there's noth- 
 ing left but the basement. There is a kitchen 
 and a big dining-room with a closet and a 
 pantry. The furnace is on that floor, so it is 
 always warm, and if you could cook and eat 
 in the kitchen, and fix your cots in the other 
 room, you might be very comfortable. We 
 don't use that part of the house any more, and 
 you would be more than welcome if you cared 
 to come; do you think you would like it? 
 Please don't be offended at the offer." 
 
 A question like that is too palpably absurd 
 for an answer. The two older girls precipitated 
 themselves upon Miss Brent, while Bess con- 
 tented herself with nearly hugging the life out 
 of Rab. There being nothing to wait for and 
 36
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 no vast amount of household goods to move, 
 the transfer was made that very day, while 
 Mrs. Willis predicted dire disaster, and the 
 Heavenly Twins hovered over their new prote- 
 gees like two benevolent bantam hens, cluck- 
 ing encouragement and good will. 
 
 37
 
 VI 
 
 'T~ S HE girls had been installed in the Brent 
 basement for several days before they re- 
 ceived a visit from the elder of the Heavenly 
 Twins. 
 
 "We didn't want you to think we should be 
 running in every hour in the day just because 
 we want to," she explained; "but Elise does 
 make such good cookies I just had to bring 
 you some." She put a heaped-up plate upon 
 the table and the girls fell to. Fortune had not 
 yet smiled upon them, but, even if she had, 
 cookies by a pound-cake recipe, and still 
 smoking hot from the oven, are fit food for 
 Fortune herself. 
 
 "Whichever of you writes a book first, 
 mes enfants," said Miss Brent, " if it has 
 anything about geniuses in it, is hereby noti- 
 fied that I want to write one chapter. No- 
 body need read it, and you can label it To 
 Be Skipped, but I want to write just one 
 chapter." 
 
 38
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "You shall," cried Hope and Lorraine in a 
 chorus. "And I'll illustrate it, if it is the only 
 picture in the book," added Bess; "but what is 
 it to be about ?" 
 
 "The advantages of hunger," answered the 
 old lady. "No, but seriously, I mean it; and 
 while you might not think it, I know something 
 about it myself. When Elise and I went to 
 Paris the first time we exhausted our allowance 
 long before the next remittance was due. We 
 did not know any one there, we were not very 
 wealthy, and we found ourselves confronted 
 with the problem of living three weeks on ten 
 francs. First we went without our breakfasts. 
 That is quite a fad now, but it was unheard of 
 then. However, the Continental breakfast isn't 
 much to go without when you've been accus- 
 tomed to Pennsylvania Dutch cooking, ham and 
 eggs, fried potatoes, cracked wheat, 'panhaus' 
 and buckwheat cakes pour dejeuner. Then we 
 took to eating bread and nuts and apples in our 
 room. How we did want some American cook- 
 ing, but we stretched out the ten francs, and at 
 the end of our three weeks were wiser and 
 healthier! And then, what do you think we 
 
 39
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 did after all that experience ? When our money 
 came we went straight to the best restaurant 
 we knew and ate so much we were stupid for 
 two days. I've always felt certain that if we 
 had kept on short rations two weeks longer 
 Elise would have had her pictures on the line 
 and I might have achieved a place on the staff 
 of Figaro." 
 
 "Let me see, how long is it since we had a 
 wild orgy ? " mused Hope. " Last May, wasn't 
 it, Lorraine, when you sold your 'Cooperative 
 Mortgage,' and Bess, her 'Boy Fishing,' on the 
 same day ? I wanted to make them an eel pie, 
 Miss Brent. You know Sterne said he liked 
 nothing else so well, because you get so much 
 for your money. But they insisted on a tea- 
 bone, such a wasteful steak, and apple pie. 
 Now do you think geniuses ought to eat pie ?" 
 
 "Certainly not," laughed Miss Brent, "though 
 Goldsmith said rebellion would be impossible 
 if there were veal pie and whisky in every man's 
 house. Raphael and Correggio are my favor- 
 ites; they were vegetarians; and Murillo said 
 a man couldn't live on coarse food and have 
 the soul of an artist. But then, on the other 
 40
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 hand, Schubert was given to consuming quan- 
 tities of corned beef and cabbage. Fancy writ- 
 ing that Serenade after a boiled dinner; and 
 Beethoven was addicted to pumpernickel and 
 ivienerwurst. But all this is preliminary. I 
 didn't mean to write the chapter now, or turn 
 it into a sermon, but Elise sent me down with 
 a discourse divided a la all Gaul; first to pre- 
 sent the cookies, second to say you are wel- 
 come to the use of a cook-book compiled as a 
 result of that ten-franc experience, and third 
 to ask you to * come to the festal board to-night, 
 for bright-eyed beauty will be there/ This 
 does not refer to Elise or me, but to our Blessed 
 Boys who are coming down to have coffee with 
 us and spend the evening. Now, having done 
 my best to take your appetites away, I hope 
 you will forgive me and be as hungry as pos- 
 sible. Come a few minutes before six." 
 
 "Didn't I say she was a fairy godmother?" 
 said Lorraine triumphantly, as the old lady's 
 quick steps died away upon the stair. 
 
 "And now that she has conjured up several 
 princes there can be no doubt about it," con- 
 cluded Bess.
 
 VII 
 
 ' I X HE evening was a most enjoyable one, as 
 they say in the society columns. Promptly 
 at seven o'clock the young men from the attic 
 arrived; there were three of them, Theodore 
 Erskine, as yet a briefless barrister; Louis 
 Lassalle, who had drifted from story to play 
 writing ; and Paul Garreck, who played sec- 
 ond violin in one of the minor theaters. 
 The fourth attic genius, Karl Prince, gener- 
 ally called Prince Karl, was to come later. 
 He was a student at Columbia, and had a 
 lecture on for the first of the evening. 
 
 After a little music the conversation drifted 
 naturally to the struggles of the artist, and when 
 the girls told of their difficulties in placing 
 stories, Louis said quickly, " If you think it is 
 hard to sell a story, you ought to try a play. 
 There's no comparison." 
 
 "I don't see how it can be much worse," 
 said Lorraine, "except that it takes more 
 stamps." 
 
 42
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "Oh, I do!" Hope interrupted. "Doesn't 
 every leading lady want part of it rewritten, 
 and the denouement changed ? Doesn't the 
 soubrette object to her song, and the old man 
 insist on a touch of pathos ?" 
 
 "Yes," answered Louis, turning to her ap- 
 preciatively, "and the leading man doesn't think 
 the strong scene suited to him, and the villain 
 wants to know why you haven't had him say, 
 'Ha! I have it!' and the man who has been 
 hind legs in the dancing heifer of the last 
 pantomime is hurt if he is asked to say, 'My 
 lord, the carriage waits;' and the managers! 
 they tell you their sole aim in life is to en- 
 courage talent, but . I caught one of them 
 on the stage one afternoon just after rehearsal 
 and gave him my scenario. He was very fa- 
 vorably impressed, and then some one trotted 
 R. of c. and it was all u. p. with me simply 
 because he had an umbrella." 
 
 They all looked at him interrogatively, and he 
 went on: "Oh, it's unlucky! Another time I 
 had a curtain raiser that just suited a certain 
 leading lady; her manager said he knew she 
 would take it, and sent me to her. Just as 
 
 43
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 soon as she saw the manuscript she nearly 
 fainted. It was written on manila paper, and 
 yellow is supposed to be a hoodoo to theatrical 
 people." 
 
 "Tell us some more," said Hope breathlessly. 
 "I love stage gossip." 
 
 The young fellow colored warmly. " It would 
 be pleasanter telling if it wasn't so monotonous. 
 I've been amused sometimes at the way these 
 actors love one another. I had an appoint- 
 ment with one of them whose name is pretty 
 well known, and incidentally mentioned another 
 of the fraternity to whom I had submitted a 
 play. 'Yes,' she said sweetly, 'Violet is a 
 dear girl; I'm awfully fond of Violet, but 
 isn't she getting just too fat for anything?' 
 Later on, when I saw Violet, I couldn't resist 
 the temptation to get her opinion of the other 
 lady, so I spoke of her work, whereupon the 
 second lady said, 'Oh, Mary is such a clever 
 woman! Don't you think her Mrs. Alving 
 wonderful ? But isn't she a back-yard fence 
 for looks!'" 
 
 "Did either of them take your play ?" asked 
 Hope. 
 
 44
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "No. I thought Violet was going to, and I 
 had an appointment with her manager and her 
 leading man to meet us after rehearsal. As 
 they were going over the play a cat jumped on 
 the stage, and nothing could budge the lady 
 after that." 
 
 "A harmless, necessary cat,'" quoted Hope. 
 
 The young fellow named Theodore, but called 
 Ted, laughed heartlessly and hummed still more 
 heartlessly, "'Oh, I thought he was a goner, 
 but the cat came back!' Was he like the poor 
 cat i' the adage, according to Mark Twain's 
 version, ' sicklied o'er with care ' ? Is the poor 
 creature dead now?" 
 
 Louis joined in the laughter. "I don't want 
 to bring down seven more years of bad luck," 
 he said. "No, the cat went on his way rejoic- 
 ing, but when Violet got stranded I felt it 
 was a judgment on her. The cat was a warn- 
 ing not to reject my play." 
 
 "Literature is bad enough, as I know to my 
 sorrow," ventured Ted, "but the professions 
 are worse. There is a young doctor across the 
 hall from me, and we have frequently discussed 
 the singular freedom from sickness and liti- 
 
 45
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 gation enjoyed by the people of Manhattan. 
 We have a wager as to which of us will suc- 
 cumb first, and the one who makes the first fee 
 is to give a dinner, if the fee is large enough to 
 pay for it. It is awful when one thinks of the 
 number of young people who are graduated an- 
 nually and turned out to starve. We have de- 
 cided that starvation should be set down among 
 the so-called natural deaths for professional 
 people." 
 
 "Yes," said Lorraine; "while the stamps 
 hold out to burn, the manuscript may not re- 
 turn. At least we can go after the editor and 
 make the welkin ring with the tramp of the 
 postman bringing back the unavailable." 
 
 "I saw a good thing and cut it out the other 
 day," laughed Ted. "It is from Frank Leslie's, 
 telling how they submitted their prospectus 
 to 'A proud and Independent Author,' who 
 rejected the same without even one word of 
 encouragement, but only the following (type- 
 written) slip: 
 
 "I regret that the enclosed is not just suitable 
 for my purpose. It is accordingly returned to you 
 with the thanks of 
 
 THE AUTHOR. 
 46
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 ; * While Authors cannot hold themselves re- 
 sponsible for magazine advertisements received 
 by them, they will endeavor to return those they 
 do not find interesting, if stamped and addressed 
 envelopes are enclosed for that purpose.' 
 
 "The article goes on to say: 
 
 " ' We will not go so far as to say that the 
 authors are joined together in a conspiracy' to 
 keep certain magazines from getting their names 
 before the public, though sometimes we have 
 . reason to suspect that such is the case; but we 
 do claim that authors as a rule are biased and 
 narrow and arbitrary in their judgment of maga- 
 zines, and we have about given up hope of 
 receiving justice or strictly impartial treatment 
 at their hands.' 
 
 "Now isn't that richness ?" 
 
 In the general laughter Miss Brent turned 
 to Lorraine. "My dear, what was that stuff 
 you read me about the 'How to' articles in 
 the magazines ?" 
 
 "Oh, don't!" objected Lorraine; "it was such 
 a personal thing, Miss Brent. I don't mean I 
 wrote it, but I think it would hit us all. Is 
 there any one here who has never read a letter 
 beginning, 'We regret to be obliged to re- 
 turn '?" 
 
 47
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 Miss Elise broke the stony silence. "I never 
 did," she said; "but as I never could remem- 
 ber to enclose stamps, my manuscripts never 
 came back." 
 
 "That's a new way to prevent the return of 
 one's yarns," said Ted, "but let's have the 
 poem by all means;" and, amidst laughter and 
 applause, Lorraine recited the following gem, 
 long since pasted in the scrap-book of every 
 aspiring genius in the literary field : 
 
 "Now's the time the bookstore windows show a most en- 
 gaging lot 
 
 Of the 'How to' books and essays telling How and How 
 
 to Not 
 How to know the purple Pansy when you meet it in the 
 
 Wood; 
 
 How to tell the Poison Toadstool, when it Is or Isn't Good; 
 How to recognize a Sparrow, Fighting in the Garden dirt; 
 How to Pick out Proper Patterns for a Woodland Walking 
 
 Skirt; 
 
 How to feed the shining Goldfish; How to know the 
 Cuckoo's call; 
 
 How to deal with Mr. Burglar when you meet Him in the 
 Hall; 
 
 How to play at Table Tennis; How to Ping and How to 
 
 Pong; 
 
 How to do artistic Fretwork; How to Write a Funny Song; 
 48
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 How to bet on Running Horses, so you'll surely, surely Win; 
 How to walk Home in the evening after Losing all your Tin; 
 
 How to Win a timid Maiden, with a Soft Persuasive 
 Coo; 
 
 How to make her think she's got to Leave her Happy Home 
 for you 
 
 Though I've searched the bookshop windows high and low, 
 from morn till night, 
 
 I have never yet discovered How to sell the stuff I write!" 
 
 "Why dpesn't somebody write it?" sighed 
 Hope; while Ted, looking over the group, said 
 reflectively: "There are enough of us to try 
 Mark Twain's painter plot. Don't you recol- 
 lect it ? There are the usual young men study- 
 ing art in Paris, with starvation staring them 
 in the face, also as usual. They cannot help 
 seeing how much it helps a genius to die, so 
 they decide that the one who does the best 
 work must be sacrificed. Don't be alarmed. 
 They slay him for publication only and fill the 
 papers with stories of his talent and his poverty 
 until Millet and Bougereau are not to be men- 
 tioned in the same day. This enables them to 
 sell his pictures for enough to provide them 
 all with ease and comfort, and whenever they 
 get a little hard up they 'discover' another of 
 
 49
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 his immortal canvases and sell it for a fabu- 
 lous sum." 
 
 Lorraine shook her head. "I don't see how 
 we could work that out in literature," she said. 
 "Bess draws and paints too, but none of the 
 rest of us do, and I don't think it would go 
 with stories, but here is a plan of mine - 
 
 Just then the front door opened. "It's 
 Prince Karl," said Miss Elise; "bring him in, 
 Teddy, before Lorraine tells her stratagem for 
 beguiling the unwary publisher." 
 
 The young fellow who came in was younger 
 than most of the others, barely twenty, and, 
 without being in the least handsome, there was 
 something so fine about his bearing and so 
 noble in his face that one understood why it 
 seemed natural to call him Prince Karl. After 
 the introductions, Miss Brent explained, and 
 Lorraine continued: 
 
 "I want to form an authors' conspiracy; let 
 us agree on some plot that has enough merits 
 so that we can each work it out in our own 
 way. Bess can illustrate for all of us, and 
 when the stories are done send them to the 
 same editor. He might take one of them, and 
 50
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 in that way we would find out, by sending 
 them to different editors as fast as they came 
 back, the kind of story that is likely to be 
 available." 
 
 "I'd like that," said the newcomer eagerly; 
 "and I heard a story the other night that I 
 think would give a fine subject. There was a 
 man who was determined to commit suicide; 
 he had come to the conclusion life wasn't 
 worth living; he was the last of his family, in 
 poor health and with not much money. Just 
 as he was buying the poison a chance came for 
 him to practically give up his life; never mind 
 how, but it seems to me there might be a lot 
 made out of that situation. He must give or 
 be willing to give his life away. Would that 
 do, Miss Lorraine?" 
 
 "Splendidly," she answered; but Bess shiv- 
 ered. 
 
 "I don't want to illustrate your stories!" 
 she said. 
 
 "It is a bit gruesome," said Louis. 
 
 "Do you think so?" answered Lorraine. 
 "Death doesn't seem any more tragic than life. 
 Do you think it is, Miss Brent ?"
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 The old lady readjusted her glasses. "I 
 confess," she said slowly, "that death doesn't 
 strike me as particularly cheerful. Maybe you 
 could make it so in fiction. I've often won- 
 dered how we would go if we had our choice. 
 What would you choose, Ted ?" 
 
 "With the flag flying and the bugle call 
 sounding," he answered without a moment's 
 hesitation. 
 
 "And you, Paul?" 
 
 "Like Mirabeau, to the sound of exquisite 
 music." 
 
 Louis shook his head. "I'm frankly a 
 coward," he said. "I don't like even thinking 
 of it. If I can't slip away in my sleep I'd 
 rather go with some one I loved in some para- 
 lyzing disaster, flood or earthquake." 
 
 "Hope?" 
 
 "Oh, not that way," she said dreamily; "but 
 on a May morning in the country, with the 
 scent of the clover fields coming through the 
 open window, and the song of the meadow lark 
 and all the sense of the renewal of life." 
 
 Karl smiled. "Death ought to be a conflict," 
 he said. "I don't believe in dying till one has 
 52
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 to, unless one dies for something. Then it 
 wouldn't make much difference. I don't want 
 to 'easy live and quiet die.' Guillotine or rifle 
 shot, flood or flame, so one dies for a cause 
 or to save some one else, it's all the same to 
 me." 
 
 Miss Brent turned to Bess, who held her hand 
 and drew closer to her. "Like Louis," she 
 whispered, "Mr. Lassalle, I mean, with some 
 one I loved." 
 
 The old lady patted her shoulder. "Well, 
 Lorraine, I begin to see infinite possibili- 
 ties in your plan. How are you going to 
 meet the grizzly monster, if you have a choice 
 in the matter?" While she spoke lightly there 
 was an undercurrent of feeling in her voice that 
 did not escape Lorraine's sharp intuitions. 
 
 "Any way that is quick," she answered. "I 
 am a coward about pain, but I don't dread 
 death, and sometimes I rather like to look 
 forward to it, just as I do to coming home, 
 now we have a home to come to. It is the door 
 to happiness and peace, where those we love 
 are waiting for us; why should one dread it? 
 You'll see before the stories are done." 
 
 53
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 There was a general agreement, and then 
 the little party broke up, the Blessed Boys as- 
 cending to their eyrie and the God-given ones 
 to their burrow, while the Heavenly Twins laid 
 heavy wagers as to who would have the best 
 story in the contest, and laughed again over 
 the jests of the evening and then slept the sleep 
 of the just. 
 
 54
 
 VIII 
 
 "HVO or three weeks later as Lorraine, who 
 
 had been taken back on the paper, was 
 
 hurrying home through the gathering darkness, 
 
 she heard quick steps behind her that seemed 
 
 familiar. 
 
 "Can I be a friend in need?" asked the 
 boy called Prince Karl, taking her umbrella 
 and substituting his more ample one. "It's 
 a miserable night and we go the same 
 way." 
 
 Lorraine gave up her packages with a sigh 
 of relief, and Karl stowed them away in his 
 capacious overcoat. Then she tucked her hand 
 under his arm and they went on. "I seem to 
 be the friend in need," she laughed. "I need 
 everything, beginning with pockets. Have you 
 done your euthanasia story yet ?" 
 
 "I'm glad of a chance to talk to you about it," 
 he said, "for it isn't turning out as I planned 
 at all. I believe I have a story, but I can't 
 seem to lay hold of it." 
 
 55
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "That sounds as if it were alive," she said 
 encouragingly. "A real story is apt to develop 
 characteristics of its own, and go off on tan- 
 gents the author never thought of when he 
 began it. Can't you come down and read it 
 to me ?" 
 
 "I'm afraid of the others," he answered with 
 boyish shyness. 
 
 "Bess is going to an art lecture with Ted. 
 By the way, has he always been deeply inter- 
 ested in art ? And Hope is going to rehearse 
 something with Louis and Paul in Miss Brent's 
 parlor, so we shall have the coast to ourselves. 
 I'd like to have you read it to me; it makes me 
 feel so vain and self-important!" 
 
 As they turned into the infinitesimal front 
 yard, she said impulsively: "Come down and 
 have supper with us. There's plenty, for I'm 
 at work again and Hope has sold a serial and 
 Bess has some illustrating. I'm writing up 
 ' Men Who Carry Their Wards.' Coming from 
 Denver I know a ward from a precinct and 
 the relation of a caucus to a primary, which is a 
 source of never-ending amusement to the city 
 editor. Do come; the girls will be delighted." 
 56
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 They went into the basement hallway and 
 turned in at the door of the room that served 
 as a workshop and laid aside their wet things, 
 and then Karl was ushered into the kitchen- 
 dining-room combination. Bess was cracking 
 the crisp baked potatoes as she heaped them 
 on the platter; there was a jar of steaming 
 baked apples, and Hope was beating the eggs 
 for the omelet. It was a jolly supper, and when 
 it was over Lorraine, who by virtue of her 
 quarter of a century posed as a venerable 
 person, despatched Bess to her lecture and 
 Hope to her play, while she washed the dishes 
 and Karl dried them. Already she had grown 
 fond of the household; they were all dear and 
 different perhaps Prince Karl was the most 
 different. 
 
 As he sat reading by the drop-light while 
 Lorraine rested in the cozy corner, she watched 
 his fine, clearly cut face, full of enthusiasm, 
 with his whole soul in the story he was reading 
 to her. As he went on, Lorraine put the pil- 
 lows away and sat up very straight. When he 
 finished and looked up for her verdict, she was 
 leaning towards him with shining eyes. "You 
 
 57
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 mustn't try to make a short story of that," 
 she said eagerly. "No wonder it rebels and 
 refuses to be cut down to fit your Procrustean 
 requirements. You must make a novel of it, 
 and it will be a great one." 
 
 He looked at her incredulously. "A book, 
 why, I couldn't write a book," he said. 
 
 "But you can, you have, you are going to," 
 she cried delightedly. "Out West before I 
 came here to burn up the East River I used 
 to do reviews, and even if I can't make litera- 
 ture myself I know it when I hear it, and that's 
 a great story. There are plenty of ways to 
 elaborate the suicide idea in a repellent or 
 commonplace manner, but your hero comes 
 out of the shadows and makes of death a 
 shining mark, and his exit is splendid. There 
 are situations that transcend mere tragedy." 
 She paused as if ransacking her brain for an 
 illustration, and he waited silently. Finally she 
 went on: "Hugo wrote the greatest suicide 
 stories that I know of; we don't think of them 
 that way because they are so much beside, but 
 his heroes generally take suicidal risks or de- 
 liberately commit suicide. You think I am 
 58
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 mistaken, don't you ? In ' The Toilers of the 
 Sea' the hero goes to the great chair-like rock 
 and waits for the tide to cover him. In 'The 
 Man who Laughs' Gwynplaine walks off the 
 deck of the vessel into the sea. In 'Ninety- 
 three' the old count returns to rescue the 
 children from the tower when it means certain 
 capture and death, and is released by his 
 nephew who takes his place under the guillotine 
 the next morning, while his friend who has 
 voted for his execution shoots himself as the 
 knife falls. And Javert after his life has been 
 saved by Jean Valjean, and he learns that the 
 ex-galley-slave has rescued Marius at the barri- 
 cades and carried him through the Great Sewer, 
 unable to fulfil his duty by arresting Jean 
 Valjean, kills himself. Every one of these cases 
 possesses the elements of the highest tragedy, but 
 those in which the cause of the action is merely 
 a personal equation do not compare with the 
 others in grandeur. Gauvain is infinitely finer 
 than his friend, Gavroche than Gwynplaine. 
 Just as life 'persists,' as the doctors say, even 
 when there is no health in us, so there is some- 
 thing in our nature that revolts against the idea 
 
 59
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 of dying for nothing. One may die for his 
 country or for a belief or for another, and go 
 down to his long rest justified. Hugo showed 
 that he could be the heroic as well as write it 
 when he published the book that sent him into 
 exile, the old Roman alternative for death. The 
 charge of the Light Brigade was magnificent, 
 but it wasn't war; Leonidas and his three 
 hundred achieved immortality without an in- 
 terposing blunder. Thermopylae was magnifi- 
 cent, but it was war too. There are no more 
 splendid suicides in history than these, yet are 
 they to be compared with the awful heroism 
 of Father Damien going to Molakai to live and 
 die with the lepers there ? Courage like that 
 makes the greatest soldier that ever lived a 
 mere gladiator in comparison. Don't you see ? 
 Your story has this finer quality and plot and 
 imagination - 
 
 "But I haven't any style," he said, still 
 unconvinced. 
 
 "Never mind about that," she answered. 
 "Style, when you come to think of it, is like 
 the top step that one misses in the dark be- 
 cause it isn't there. Doesn't it seem foolish to 
 60 /
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 read directions to read Addison or Stevenson 
 or Ruskin to improve one's style ? Read them 
 for a lesson in the use of words, for artistic 
 proportion, for pleasure, and then write your 
 own story in your own way, and if you succeed 
 in saying what you want to say, you have 
 found the style you had to have for that par- 
 ticular story. But hurry, hurry! I do so want 
 to know a successful author, and think of the 
 fun we shall have reading the reviews!" 
 
 "I'm afraid even to think of them," he said. 
 "Do the critics read the books they review ?" 
 
 "Yes, generally. When you think of what 
 is expected of most of them I wonder they are 
 as lenient as they are. Very few of them are 
 as gentle as Bryant; you know, when the book 
 was impossible, or should have been, he used 
 sometimes to say, * but the cover is very pretty.' 
 Just try reading a book a day and you'll have 
 lots of sympathy for the critics. Besides, one 
 doesn't have to read the whole of a story to- 
 know whether the author can write English, 
 is ordinarily painstaking, and has a publisher 
 who knows something of typographical beauty. 
 Once I reviewed a story that was accounted 
 
 61
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 one of the season's successes, and yet, after 
 describing the arrival of a carriage-load of 
 people at a country inn during a pouring rain, 
 with roads almost impassable with mud, his 
 heroine trips lightly down the same road the 
 next morning and meets the villain who, after 
 staring her out of countenance, drives on 'en- 
 veloped in a cloud of dust.' A thing like that 
 prejudices the reviewer." 
 
 "I should think it would," answered the 
 boy, " but it doesn't seem as if any one 
 could make such a mistake if he re-read the 
 story." 
 
 "It doesn't follow. Homer nods sometimes, 
 you know. Who was the Chicago girl who 
 wrote the viking story a few years ago ? It was 
 gorgeously gotten up, and in the advance no- 
 tices it was said the young lady had spent 
 several years studying Norse customs, yet she 
 draped her viking halls in black velvet. How- 
 ever, when Richard Hovey dressed his Round 
 Table people in the same fabric, she might be 
 forgiven." 
 
 "Was that wrong?" he asked. "I never 
 thought anything about that sort of thing." 
 
 62
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "Yes, because velvet wasn't made until a 
 good many centuries later. According to crit- 
 ics one must be 'convincing' - -what is it Van 
 Dyke says about seeing the local color without 
 being blind to the inner light ? The local color 
 should not be laid on with a trowel, so thick 
 that the inner light can't shine through, and if 
 it is one of the strong features of the story it 
 should be correct. Otherwise it can't be con- 
 vincing. The author who has a pleasure party 
 drive to Cheyenne Mountain and over Marshal 
 Pass the same afternoon may be a master of 
 English, but he has something to learn of 
 Colorado distances." 
 
 "I don't see how I can make my story con- 
 vincing," he said, still doubtful. "The very 
 heart of it is a legend, a myth, something that 
 couldn't happen." 
 
 "That may be, but nevertheless you have 
 made it real; you have made it seem as if it 
 could happen. Now, Henry James could take 
 the legend of Mary's little lamb and make it 
 seem as if it couldn't happen. That's the other 
 kind of genius. But go on with it while the 
 spirit moves you. There's many a cake that 
 
 63
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 remains dough for the lack of turning at the 
 right time!" 
 
 The boy thanked her, and, gathering up his 
 manuscript, ascended to the attic to go to 
 work with renewed vigor and a great burning 
 of the midnight gas. 
 
 64
 
 IX 
 
 *T'M glad we're well insured," said Miss 
 Elise. " Emmy, this house fairly coruscates; 
 genius to left of us, genius to right of us 
 
 "Geniuses in front of us volleyed and thun- 
 dered," added Miss Brent, as the sound of a 
 dramatic climax and the wild screech of a violin 
 were drowned in a burst of laughter. 
 
 "I wonder if they'd mind an audience?" 
 said Miss Elise. "Karl is trying his new story 
 on Lorraine; Bess and Ted have gone some- 
 where; and I pine to do something wild and 
 riotous and exciting. Let's go hear Louis' 
 play." 
 
 "Maybe they won't want us," said Miss 
 Emma. 
 
 "I'll ask them," said Miss Elise bravely; but 
 there was no need, for Paul was already at the 
 door, with his beloved violin tucked under his 
 arm, requesting their attendance. 
 
 "We want an umpire," he said. "The man- 
 ager and the star have reached a deadlock 
 
 65
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 over a piece of business; I agree with the 
 star, but the manager says the orchestra has 
 no business to have opinions, so we'd like to 
 have you come and decide for us." 
 
 The audience, pleased and excited, took the 
 box seats on the sofa, the orchestra struck up, 
 and the little play progressed to its tragic con- 
 clusion, for does not youth always love 
 tragedy ? 
 
 The plot was simple, the old story of the 
 lover who loves and rides away; they are both 
 players; the deserted woman returns to their lit- 
 tle garret home to find the sunshine gone, and a 
 cold brief note that leaves no doubt of her fate. 
 Five years later, the player has made a Parisian 
 success when in doubt of the entire moral- 
 ity of anything set it in Paris and the for- 
 gotten woman reappears, asking for an engage- 
 ment in his company. She meets the star. 
 "Can you act ?" he asks, "do you dance ? Pos- 
 sibly you sing?" In her poverty and distress 
 he fails to recognize the girl he has betrayed 
 and left behind; spurred by the memory of 
 her love and her sorrow, she answers by pro- 
 posing a pantomime. Quickly she suggests her 
 66
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 stage setting, and then portrays the return of 
 the young woman, as she comes singing into 
 the room, and bends over the cradle, cooing to 
 her little one. Then, still talking to the baby, 
 she lays the cloth as if to prepare the supper, 
 and going to the chiffonier finds the letter that 
 tells her the end of all her hopes and dreams 
 has come. 
 
 Up to this time the man has been an inter- 
 ested spectator; then memory asserts itself and 
 conscience dashes the scales from his eyes. It 
 was at this point that the author of the play 
 and his leading lady hopelessly differed. There 
 was a stage fall, and Louis insisted that the 
 
 O * 
 
 first thought of the young mother would be for 
 her child, all she had left in the world, and that 
 she should fall with her arms outstretched 
 across the cradle, while the false lover starts 
 toward her in conscience-stricken grief. 
 
 Hope scouted the idea. "It is too soon/' 
 she said. "She has forgotten the very exist- 
 ence of the child, everything in the world except 
 the one ereat, overwhelming loss that has left 
 
 o * o 
 
 the world a blank, striking her dumb and para- 
 lyzing her brain." 
 
 67
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 " But wouldn't she turn to her child ? She is 
 a mother as well as a wife," insisted Louis; 
 "it seems to me the natural thing would be for 
 her to cling to what she had left." 
 
 "No," said Hope stubbornly, "not a young 
 woman, who loves with all the first fervor and 
 passion of her nature; perhaps an older woman, 
 with three or four children, might think of them 
 first, for it would be a common grief and shame 
 that they must share, but not a young girl 
 to whom, even yet, the child is a kind of a 
 marvel, dearer because of its father than of 
 itself. Moreover, you must remember that this 
 woman is playing her life; she is asking for her 
 place in his heart, not for a place in his troupe. 
 The appeal must be direct; nothing can come 
 between. She ought actually to faint; that can- 
 not be a part of her play, but the culmination 
 of her soul's tragedy." 
 
 Still Louis remained half-unconvinced. "I 
 don't believe a woman can forget her child," 
 he said; "and wouldn't the child itself con- 
 stitute the strongest claim she could make 
 upon the man ? Don't you think so, Miss 
 Elise?" 
 
 68
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "No," she said, shaking her head; "I believe 
 Hope is right, but I can give you better author- 
 ity than either of us. Don't you remember 
 Tennyson's poem ? 
 
 'Home they brought her warrior dead: 
 
 She nor swoon'd, nor utter'd cry: 
 All her maidens, watching, said, 
 "She must weep or she will die." ' 
 
 She never thinks of the child until 
 
 ' Rose a nurse of ninety years, 
 
 Set his child upon her knee 
 Like summer tempest came her tears 
 "Sweet my child, I live for thee.'" 
 
 "I surrender," said Louis; "I'm not only 
 outnumbered, but outclassed. I don't know as 
 much about women as Tennyson did, or about 
 anything else, for that matter. Shall we go 
 on?" 
 
 The players took their places again, the 
 audience settled back on the sofa, and Paul 
 took up the score, playing very softly the old 
 tune of "The Mill-Wheel." One could almost 
 hear the words: 
 
 " For she I love is faithless, 
 And broken is the ring." 
 69
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 The little scene of the finding of the letter 
 was well played, and then, as if it took some 
 time for her to grasp the dreadful truth, she 
 stood, holding the letter, then fell slowly, in- 
 ertly. 
 
 The sisters and the orchestra and the author 
 applauded wildly, then the sisters looked at 
 each other. 
 
 "Yes, it does remind me " said Miss Emma, 
 and stopped 
 
 "Of Mary Anderson's fall in 'A Winter's 
 Tale,'" completed Miss Elise. 
 
 They had all adjourned to the study and were 
 gathered about the fireplace. "Tell us about 
 it," said Louis. 
 
 "Oh, it was years ago; she was playing 
 Hermione, a wonderful, statuesque Hermione. 
 It was after the king has refused to believe the 
 oracle, in the trial scene, and the servant comes 
 in to tell the death of their son. It was the last 
 drop in her cup of bitterness. She raised her 
 arm, veiled her face, and seemed to melt and 
 fall like a snow image, so slowly, so quietly. 
 But you are too young ever to have seen that," 
 concluded Miss Elise. 
 
 70
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "My mother saw it," said Hope. "She said 
 it was the most effective fall she had ever seen 
 to portray a psychological grief. She taught 
 me how to do it. Of course it would not fit 
 many scenes." 
 
 "Do you know," said Miss Emma, "you play 
 wonderfully well ? If Louis could always be 
 certain of so sympathetic an interpreter he 
 need not wait long for success. Have you ever 
 thought of going on the stage ?" 
 
 "You ought to," added Louis. 
 
 "I never used to think of anything else, 
 till my mother died," the girl answered. 
 " Maybe you have seen her, Miss Brent ? She 
 was Rose Farron." 
 
 "Of course we've seen her!" exclaimed both 
 the old ladies. Then simultaneously, "Can you 
 ever forget her Peg Woffington, Emmy ? " " Did- 
 n't she break your heart as Camille, Elise?" 
 
 Hope sighed. "I think she was very good," 
 she said, "but I never saw her on the stage. 
 When she married she retired, and my father 
 was jealous of the old life. I am afraid they 
 were not always happy, for sometimes she longed 
 to go back; I was born with that longing in
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 my blood. We lived in a big, rambling farm- 
 house, and she made a companion of me, and 
 we 'play-acted' up in the garret, everything she 
 could find that had a child in it, scraps and 
 scenes from 'Odette,' 'Miss Multon,' 'Jane 
 Eyre,' 'Richard Third.' I remember how I 
 used to struggle with Arthur's appeal to Hubert; 
 it was so real that it almost gave me hysterics, 
 so after that she made little plays from fairy 
 stories, and we were happy, so happy ! She 
 set me reading and learning plays. I knew 
 most of ' Hamlet ' and 'Much Ado' and 'Romeo 
 and Juliet' and 'Richard' by heart when I was 
 twelve. Then the other two babies came, and 
 when I was sixteen she died, and I had to take 
 care of the children. I used to act and recite 
 for them, but that was the end of my hopes and 
 plans." She stopped, lost in memories both 
 sweet and bitter. "Then my father married 
 again; my stepmother didn't mind the little 
 children, but a grown stepdaughter was in the 
 way and we didn't agree about the cooking. 
 I hate salt-rising bread!" snapped Hope, with 
 the vindictive force of a sudden hateful memory. 
 "So I came to New York, with my mother's 
 72
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 books, her old plays, her clothes, and a few 
 hundred dollars, and nothing else." 
 
 "And couldn't you find any company that 
 suited you?" asked Miss Brent. 
 
 "Any of them would have suited me, but 
 remember, I had no experience; I'd never seen 
 twenty plays in my life. I had no acquaintance 
 with theater people, no money, no influence. 
 I wasn't even beautiful, nor young, not to 
 begin stage work at least." 
 
 "But you have talent," said Miss Elise. "I 
 should have thought they would have been glad 
 to have you." 
 
 "There are hundreds of girls already on the 
 stage who have not only talent, but a fairly 
 good idea of stage business," answered Hope. 
 'They know how to make their exits and their 
 entrances; why should a manager pass them 
 by to take up an utterly unknown quantity ? 
 I had written for the local papers, and sold a 
 few stories and magazine articles. I had an 
 introduction to the editor of a Sunday-school 
 paper from our rector, and I made enough 
 writing short stones and serials to keep me 
 alive. That was where I met Bess. She was 
 
 73
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 furnishing puzzle pictures for it. One night 
 while I was waiting for my bowl of bread and 
 milk and correcting proofs on the restaurant 
 table, Lorraine came in and sat opposite me. 
 Presently she took out a roll of copy and began 
 revising it, and so we fell to talking, and pres- 
 ently when her order came she made me share 
 with her, and nothing will ever taste so good 
 again as that sirloin. We used often to meet 
 after that. Sometimes I paid for the steak and 
 sometimes she did and sometimes we had hash, 
 and finally we went to housekeeping, and then 
 we took Bess in, and so we went along until 
 you found us." 
 
 "But why don't you try now?" Louis and 
 Paul asked in the same breath. 
 
 Hope shook her head. "It's too late. I 
 don't want to add one more to the list of those 
 who make a living by acting just as they might 
 by plain sewing or bookkeeping. I have gone 
 to the theater whenever I could spare the money. 
 I sat in the cheap seats, but as I forgot every- 
 thing after the curtain went up it was not such 
 a hardship to me as it would be to you. With 
 my feeling about the stage, its fineness and 
 
 74
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 dignity and mission, it seems presumption for 
 me to think of it, for I wouldn't want to act 
 unless I could do really good work; it is a 
 vocation, not an avocation." 
 
 "Have you ever thought what kind of a part 
 you'd like to play best?" asked Miss Brent. 
 
 "Yes, but it wasn't always the same. When 
 I saw Mansfield's Richard Third I thought how 
 when Garrick played the part 'the ladies ex- 
 pressed themselves almost in love with Richard,' 
 but I have never seen a possible Anne. She is 
 always played as a vain, frivolous, foolish 
 woman. My idea of that part would be taken 
 from her first speech to Richard, 'Mortal 
 eyes cannot endure the devil,' and I would 
 have her play it as if she were under a spell, 
 something like Blanche Walsh's famous scene 
 in 'Aristocracy.' Hypnotism is a new word, 
 but the thing itself is old, and Gloucester cannot 
 account for his power even by 'the aid of the 
 plain devil, and dissembling looks.' But I 
 didn't mean to take the center of the stage and 
 hold it all this time. Miss Brent, you look as 
 if you would say, 'My soul is heavy and I fain 
 would sleep/ so, as I still have 'some certain 
 
 75
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 dregs of conscience yet within me,' I'll say 
 good night." 
 
 "Well, 'God bless thee, and take meekness 
 out of thy breast," 1 responded Miss Brent. 
 "What you need is some wholesome vanity and 
 a press agent." 
 
 So the party broke up. 
 
 As Louis and Paul joined the boys upstairs, 
 Prince Karl was filling his fountain pen to 
 begin the next chapter, while Ted hung up his 
 overcoat. Louis took a jug of cider from the 
 closet and, filling the glasses, raised his own. 
 "Fellows," he said, "this house will yet appear 
 in the limelight." 
 
 "If anybody should ask you," added Prince 
 Karl, "you can say that girls like those are 
 just about out of print, and it was a small 
 edition." 
 
 "And beautifully bound," said Ted, thinking 
 of the bright-faced girl he had just left. 
 
 " I'll join you in a toast to all of them," said 
 Paul, "but first and most of all to the oldest 
 girls and the jolliest, here's to the Heavenly 
 Twins, who have made life worth living for all 
 of us." 
 
 76
 
 " TF ever there was a story that is an insult to 
 human intelligence," remarked Ted with 
 his most judicial and ipse dixit expression, "it 
 is 'The Honorable Peter Sterling." 
 
 It was Saturday night, and the geniuses were 
 gathered in the large double parlors. 
 
 "Yes, I mean it," he went on as his hearers 
 looked at him with doubt upon their faces. 
 "It's all right so far as the dirty office is con- 
 cerned, with the long crack in the plaster, and 
 the dusty books, and the solitude, but when it 
 comes to Peter's worrying along and contriving 
 to pay his rent on a paltry fifteen hundred a 
 year, it makes me tired, not to say disgusted. 
 I don't believe half the lawyers in New York 
 who have been practising for ten years are sure 
 of more of an income than that. Just give me 
 fifteen hundred dollars a year and see me come 
 splurging to the front! What I want to know 
 is, not how to live on fifteen hundred or even 
 half that, but how to get it to live on." 
 
 77
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "Or how to live without an income," sug- 
 gested Louis, "or upon the outgo." 
 
 "Or on the net deficit," said Lorraine. "The 
 Honorable Peter is a bit like 'The Duchess' 
 heroes who barely subsist on three or four 
 thousand dollars a year. When one considers 
 the number of people who go on from day to 
 day doing their work, with the wolf always 
 sitting by the kitchen stove, like a hungry 
 house dog, it speaks well for human nature that 
 they keep up the fight." 
 
 "Or very poorly for the imagination," said 
 Karl. 
 
 "That works both ways," said Hope quickly. 
 "It is the dread of something after death that 
 makes cowards of many of us, who let I dare 
 not wait upon I would. It is when the imagi- 
 nation fails and we can think of no evils worse 
 than those we already endure that resolution 
 retains its native hue. It is when we believe 
 no dreams can come so fearful as the reality, 
 that we are willing and ready to end the heart- 
 ache and the troubles that make long life a 
 calamity." 
 
 "How about those euthanasia stories ?" asked 
 78
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 Miss Brent. "How many of you have finished 
 yours ? When does the competition close ? 
 What, only two of you ? Ted, what excuse 
 have you to offer ? If you knew the Grand 
 Prix Elise and I are going to bestow upon the 
 victor you'd not be so dilatory." 
 
 "I can't write it," answered Ted. "I've 
 tried to make a brief for the defendant, but 
 before I reach the argument I always find my- 
 self going over to the prosecution. We ought 
 to fight it out. I've no use for a man who tries 
 to dodge. I can't make a hero out of that kind 
 of a fellow." 
 
 Lorraine laughed. " Let us hope you'll never 
 be assigned to defend some unfortunate, rashly 
 importunate, who has run counter to the laws 
 of this state. But if you remember Karl's 
 plan, the hero does not actually take his life; 
 he gives it away, and does not even necessarily 
 lose it, save so far as his own initiative is con- 
 cerned. Neither is it necessary to regard him 
 as a hero. The man who can't screw his cour- 
 age to the sticking point is just as available 
 for our purposes as the one who can. Wouldn't 
 it have been more heroic for Dr. Jekyll to have 
 
 79
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 made his own quietus than to wait for Hyde 
 to murder him ?" 
 
 "You never can make a lawyer see it," said 
 Karl. "He always has a picture of the corpse 
 with a stake through the body buried at the 
 crossroads, and his family disgraced, according 
 to old English law. Yet the Romans, from 
 whom we derived our law originally, always 
 recognized the right of a citizen to dispose of 
 his life as he saw fit. In fact, if a man was 
 under sentence of death his only escape from 
 disgrace lay in being his own executioner. In 
 that case he had an honorable burial and could 
 will away his property. If he waited for the 
 law to take its course, his children were dis- 
 inherited, and his body exposed to every in- 
 dignity. Wasn't it Domitian who invented the 
 idea of disgrace as an excuse for the confisca- 
 tion of the property of those he drove to sui- 
 cide?" 
 
 " Even if he did, the Antonines sustained him 
 and perpetuated the custom," interrupted Ted; 
 but Karl went on dispassionately. 
 
 "The prejudice against taking life under any 
 circumstances is largely a Christian idea, yet 
 
 80
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 few religions lay so much stress on the life to 
 come or depict it in such glowing terms. It 
 seems as if the Christian, with his belief that 
 death is gain, should hold life lightly rather 
 than the Japanese, whose future life is dreary 
 and repellent." 
 
 "I think it is the idea of duty," ventured 
 Miss Elise rather timidly. "That is the fun- 
 damental difference between the Christian re- 
 ligion and other religions. I suppose duty is 
 the basis of any religion, but I don't know any 
 other that dwells as largely upon our duty to 
 our fellow men. The question with us is what 
 is right, not for ourselves alone, but in the 
 widest possible relation to other people. The 
 Jap is guided by his worship of his ancestors; 
 his supreme duty is to the dead rather than 
 to the living. He ends his life rather than 
 endure what might be construed as an insult 
 to the shades of his great-grandfathers, even if 
 he leaves a family that will be reduced to pen- 
 ury by his action; at the worst, have they not 
 his example ? We can't judge a nation that 
 has such different ideals. The question re- 
 mains, is it right?" 
 
 Si
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "Who is to say ?" answered her sister. "Can 
 we lay down a hard and fast rule of right and 
 wrong ? Didn't we glorify the old woman who 
 killed herself that her son might feel himself 
 free to go to fight the Russians ? As Karl says, 
 we may sing about lands of pure delight where 
 saints immortal reign, but we don't take any 
 chances of getting there as long as we can 
 avoid it. We hang on, sans eyes, sans teeth, 
 sans everything, a burden to ourselves and 
 everybody else. Solomon said there was a time 
 to die, and when that time comes I have no 
 gratitude to the science that prolongs life under 
 such circumstances." 
 
 Karl nodded approvingly. "Every humane 
 society takes the life of animals when it is 
 necessary to relieve them from ceaseless pain," 
 he said; "why should we cease to be humane 
 because the sufferer belongs to humankind 
 rather than to the brute creation ? In every 
 hospital, in every asylum, lives are preserved in 
 pain and weariness that are a useless burden 
 to themselves and the community. It costs as 
 much to keep a feeble-minded child in school 
 as to give a normal child the best advantages, 
 82
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 and he can learn such a little then, not enough 
 for life ever to be a joy to him; he will never 
 be intelligently alive. If we are pagans and 
 believe this life is all, is it worth while to live 
 it in such a way ? If we are really Christians 
 and believe in the immortality of the soul, why 
 not release him and let him pass on to the life 
 more abundant ?" 
 
 "Money ought not to enter into it at all," 
 said Ted a little warmly. "We can't kill people 
 just because there are too many of them. Be- 
 sides, it is all sophistry anyhow. Go back to 
 Sparta and her plan to secure the survival of 
 the fittest, and what do we know or care for 
 Sparta ? She has left us nothing but the mem- 
 ory of Leonidas. 'The glory that was Greece ' 
 doesn't come down to us from the people who 
 would have killed their Byrons and Popes in 
 infancy. Just eliminate all the physically unfit 
 and see what will happen to art and literature 
 from Homer down to Milton and Prescott, 
 Beethoven and Schumann. There isn't one of 
 us who does not know some soul who has lived 
 on the rack of pain yet kept so sweet, so strong, 
 so sane, that we have felt more envy than pity. 
 
 83
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 Who is to be a judge, who would be willing to 
 take the responsibility of passing the death 
 sentence wholesale, and to whom are we willing 
 to intrust such power as that ?" 
 
 "I don't think you understand Karl exactly," 
 said Miss Brent. "His idea is that it is more 
 merciful to release these unhappy ones from 
 the burden of life than to exhaust every means 
 to prolong their lives. But I am inclined to 
 think that before any such action is ever taken 
 we shall have had to entirely revise our code 
 in regard to suicide. Perhaps we are not civil- 
 ized enough to get along without sickness and 
 pain; we need the schooling in patience and 
 tenderness as well as in medical science; but if 
 the sufferer himself elects to go I can see no 
 reason why we should demand that he stay. 
 What is it Montaigne says ? that 'Nature has 
 ordered one door into life, but a hundred 
 thousand out of it,' and again, that 'living is 
 slavery, if the liberty of dying be taken away. 
 God gives us leave enough when he is pleased 
 to reduce us to such a condition that to live 
 is far worse than to die/" 
 
 Miss Elise, who had disappeared into the 
 84
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 library, returned with a portentous old French 
 volume in her hands. "Now just hear me 
 crush Emmy with her philosophers," she said. 
 "Here on the very next page Montaigne says, 
 I'll translate it the best I can, ' It belongs to 
 God alone, who placed us here, not for our- 
 selves only, but for his glory and the service of 
 others, to dismiss us when it shall best please 
 him, and not for us to depart without his per- 
 mission.' And listen to this: 'It is cowardice, 
 not virtue, to lie in a furrow under a tomb, to 
 evade the blows of fortune.' Besides, who 
 knows which are the incurable diseases ? or 
 that they will be incurable to-morrow ? Think 
 of the marvels that are being discovered every 
 day. What are you thinking, Hope ? You've 
 been in a brown study for ten minutes." 
 
 The girl raised her head, and brushed back 
 a refractory lock of hair. "I was thinking," 
 she began hesitatingly, "that I shouldn't agree 
 with any of you, or any of those who are ad- 
 vocating these various plans for the elimina- 
 tion of the unfit, with or without their consent, 
 because you all limit the justification to physical 
 conditions, as if bodily pain were the most 
 
 85
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 acute in the world. That I do not believe. 
 Only 'in the infinite spirit is room for the 
 pulse of an infinite pain/ I can imagine 
 anguish that would make the rack a flowery 
 bed of ease. We all read of cases of affliction 
 in the San Francisco earthquake, where perhaps 
 but one member of a family was left, friends, 
 relatives, property all gone, nothing left to 
 begin with and no one left to work for, 
 would not life be ten times more awful after 
 such an experience than the pangs of the most 
 cruel disease ? When the fountains of the great 
 deep of one's soul are broken up, there is far 
 more excuse for finding life unbearable than 
 any physical pain can give. Can you imagine 
 Lazarus, called back from the tomb, ever find- 
 ing life quite the same again ? It seems to me 
 as if he must always have walked apart." 
 
 Miss Brent was listening intently. "But, 
 my dear," she said, "such a man can still be 
 useful, while the patient suffering from some 
 hopeless, torturing disease is of no use to him- 
 self or any one else." 
 
 "How can we say that?" said the girl ear- 
 nestly. "We are talking of one's right to end 
 86
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 his own life when it becomes intolerable to 
 him, not of our right to pick and choose and 
 take life when we see fit. If we are to issue 
 suicide permits to lepers, and I don't say we 
 should not, I can't see by what logic we deny 
 the claims of my hypothetical Californian. We 
 are not regarding him as a beast of burden to 
 be fed until he can no longer bear the burden; 
 the question is not of what use he may be to 
 the world, but of what value is life to him. 
 When he goes to sleep he lives through it all 
 again. He sees the flames and hears the crack 
 of the rifle that brought merciful release to 
 those who were doomed. He wakens suddenly, 
 feeling again the shock of closing walls and 
 sliding floors. By what curious course of rea- 
 soning would you give a release to a man suffer- 
 ing from locomotor ataxia to be a blessed 
 ghost and condemn this man to the nightmare 
 of life in death ? I don't say it isn't right to 
 give the merciful cup to the first, but if you 
 do, how can you refuse it to the second ?" 
 
 There was silence for a few moments; every 
 one was conscious of some strange, electrical 
 tension, then Ted broke it abruptly. 
 
 87
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "That's it. If you begin, where is the line 
 to be drawn ? It sounds fairly well until you 
 begin to work it out in detail, and then it falls 
 to pieces of its own weight and weakness. 
 Let's give it up, and find some less morbid 
 theme for our experiment." 
 
 "I second the motion," said Miss Elise. 
 "Let's have something cheerful and happy. 
 There's enough misery without our imagining 
 any more." 
 
 And though they changed the subject, and 
 banished the gloom it had occasioned, it re- 
 mained a vague phantom of unrest, haunting 
 the minds of Miss Elise and Hope.
 
 XI 
 
 TT is a good thing to possess ten talents, or 
 even five, or but one, but it is a bad thing to 
 overestimate the value of one's possessions. 
 Miss Brent's attic and basement specimens of 
 the genus genius struggled along as best they 
 could; and as they were about equally gifted in 
 different ways, it did not occur to them that they 
 were above and apart from the rest of their 
 fellows. The fact that there are thousands of 
 young men and women in New York who never 
 write anything, who cannot sing or play or 
 draw a picture, who do not read and to whom 
 study would be a hardship, this gigantic fact, 
 palpable and obvious as it may be, did not 
 present itself to their minds. Each one ad- 
 mired the achievements of the others more than 
 his own. Prince Karl was going to be a mining 
 engineer; he could not only write a story, but 
 he knew the secrets of the rocks, and he stood 
 high in his classes and bade fair to take all 
 sorts of honors at Columbia. And if Ted had 
 
 89
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 not succeeded in literature, and was still brief- 
 less, he was a barrister nevertheless. Louis was 
 on the highway to success, and although that 
 highway is much like the rocky road to Dublin, 
 still none of the Brent household doubted that 
 he was bound to arrive; and Paul's music and 
 verse made the cares that infest the day flee 
 without waiting to fold their tents. 
 
 Lorraine's political sketches had become 
 something of a feature, and she was on the 
 pay-roll regularly. Uncle Peter Bright had 
 found a place for Hope with a publisher, where 
 she read and read, and learned something of 
 what the public is supposed to want, which 
 helped her to dispose of some of her own ar- 
 ticles; and between Hope and Lorraine con- 
 siderable illustrating was thrown into the eager 
 hands of little Bess, who was blossoming into 
 a most beautiful womanhood. 
 
 Over them all was the unfailing faith and 
 affection of the Heavenly Twins, who would 
 not have believed it possible for one ugly 
 duckling to find a place among their young 
 swans. 
 
 As the summer came on the daily, hourly 
 90
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 struggle grew less for most of the young people. 
 Prince Karl was preparing for a trip to the 
 Rockies to geologize and see mining at first 
 hand ; Louis was in the throes of watching the 
 rehearsals of his farce, which was to go on at 
 one of the summer theaters where Paul played 
 second violin. 
 
 But things were in a bad way for Teddy. As 
 the days passed he seemed to grow a little thin- 
 ner and lankier each day. The doctor across 
 the hall suggested that erelong they might 
 open opposition stalls in a dime museum as 
 the living skeleton and the ossified man. 
 
 "Yes; we can realize Sidney Smith's wish to 
 take off his flesh and sit in his bones," he 
 answered with a rather feeble smile; "but I 
 can't say that I see much fun in it." He 
 looked across the hall at his orderly desk and 
 bleakly empty office. He had had that office 
 for two years the coming fall, ever since he 
 had been admitted to the bar, and he had 
 never been so much as retained. He had never 
 had a client, save as now and then he had been 
 appointed to defend some one. He had written 
 a weekly New York letter to his home paper,
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 and once in a while he had sold an article, but 
 the end was in sight. 
 
 He looked up at the doctor's sign, "Frances 
 Silverton, M.D.," and at her office, the coun- 
 terpart of his own, except that, being a woman, 
 hers was a little less dingy. 
 
 "Doctor," he said shortly, "let's cut it. 
 There's no use trying any longer. Let's go 
 West and grow up with the country. New 
 York is no place for poor people. Let's go to 
 some little place far out West and take our 
 chances that there will be more malaria, which 
 is good for your business, and more bad blood, 
 which is good for mine." 
 
 The doctor shook her head. "No," she said, 
 "no; who was that sage who said, 'God Al- 
 mighty hates a quitter' ? There are more people 
 who hate each other to the point of going to 
 law about it in New York than anywhere else 
 in this country. Judging from my experience, 
 nobody ever dies a natural death here, with or 
 without medical aid; yet I have faith to believe 
 my time's coming, and I'm getting plenty of 
 experience, if it doesn't bring in any money. 
 Some new bacillus will come to the rescue." 
 92
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 " But when ? Bacilli are slow and rime is 
 fleeting." 
 
 "Yes, I know," she answered; "but you can 
 be sure of one thing. There's no place where 
 there's a better show than New York. It may 
 take longer to succeed, but when success comes, 
 when it comes it is worth having, and 
 means something anywhere else you may go. 
 But succeed in any other city in America and 
 New York is still ahead of you, frowning and 
 impregnable, her harbor full of torpedoes. 
 Stay by it awhile longer. It will pay in the 
 end." ^ 
 
 "Perhaps," he answered. "At the present 
 rate I'm afraid it will not pay in rime, or 
 enough to meet the funeral expenses." 
 
 93
 
 XII 
 
 CUMMER had come in good earnest. The 
 streets fairly palpitated with the heat, and 
 the big, gloomy office building where Ted spent 
 most of his time was half deserted. The doctor 
 found plenty of occupation, if small remunera- 
 tion; the lawyers were away for their summer 
 vacations and the other tenants kept office hours 
 in a desultory fashion, if at all. Ted walked 
 home, thinking wrathfully of the stupidity of 
 fate, and the long hard climb before we can 
 even catch a glimpse of the Delectable Moun- 
 tains. 
 
 When he reached the house he went down 
 the three steps into the basement instead of 
 up the three flights to the attic. The girls \vere 
 a sympathetic lot, but he rather wished that 
 Hope would be at home; there was more in 
 common between them; they could join in the 
 hymn of the conquered. He had never minded 
 being poor so much until he met Bess. 
 
 But neither Hope nor Bess were there. In- 
 94
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 stead he was startled by the sight of Miss 
 Brent bending over a pile of Lorraine's copy 
 and wiping her tear-dimmed glasses. Lorraine 
 was walking up and down the room, her eyes 
 blazing out of her white face, and her hands 
 clenched. 
 
 "What on earth is the matter?" he asked. 
 "What has happened? Is any one hurt, is 
 Bess " 
 
 "Oh, no!" answered Miss Brent. "It's Lor- 
 raine's story. Tell him about.it, Lorraine; I 
 can't. Sit down, Teddy." 
 
 The girl went on walking up and down until 
 she gained a little more self-control. 
 
 "It's the Riordan case," she said, trying to 
 keep the quiver out of her lips. "You must 
 have read about it; the papers have been full 
 of it." 
 
 "Good Lord! They haven't put you on 
 that, have they?" he asked disgustedly. "The 
 idea of sending a woman like you to look up a 
 miserable lot of little degenerates and cut-throats 
 like those!" 
 
 "Hush!" she said excitedly. "You are a 
 lawyer; you have no business to take sjdes, 
 
 95
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 still less to 'take life without the form of jus- 
 tice.' You ought not to believe in the mission 
 of the daily press to act as judge, jury, and 
 executioner. What do you know about it 
 anyway ?" 
 
 "I know what every one knows, that this 
 gang of boys are the usual cigarette-smoking, 
 dime-novel reading little toughs; that they call 
 themselves the Jesse James gang, and that they 
 shot and murdered a playfellow in cold blood," 
 he answered. 
 
 "You mean you know what you've read," 
 she said; "is that what you call evidence? 
 Those children had never heard of Jesse James 
 until one of our enterprising newspaper artists 
 stood them up before his camera and christened 
 them so. There isn't a scintilla of proof against 
 them." 
 
 "Didn't one of the boys confess ?" he asked. 
 
 "Yes, three of them confessed," she an- 
 swered. "Three of them confessed to me, after 
 the police had 'sweated' them for hours." 
 
 "Then what more do you want?" he asked 
 a little impatiently. 
 
 "Well, you see, they all confessed to different 
 96
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 things; their stories didn't hang together," she 
 replied. "The essential facts are these: The 
 little Riordan boy was sent to bring home the 
 cow. He had to pass the place where these 
 other boys were in swimming; it was a kind of 
 woodsy little playground, not far from the 
 water. Later he was found, shot dead in 
 these woods, where the Brown boys and Roy 
 Collins had been at play. A boy named Willie 
 Hinckley says that Roy shot Patsy, and Rior- 
 dan made the complaint; the boys were all 
 arrested and taken to jail without a moment 
 to see their folks. The youngest is eight years 
 old, and the oldest seventeen. The eight-year- 
 old boy has confessed, also one who is about 
 eleven, and who is subject to epileptic attacks, 
 and the boy named Hinckley, who made the 
 charge originally, and has taken it back and 
 then repeated it twice since." 
 
 "Do you mean you think they didn't do it ?" 
 asked Ted incredulously. 
 
 "I'm perfectly certain they didn't," she an- 
 swered, "but how can they prove it ?" 
 
 "They don't have to," he responded quickly. 
 "The burden of proof is on the prosecution; 
 
 97
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 they must prove that the crime was committed. 
 The accused are not compelled to show their 
 innocence. That's as old as Magna Charta," 
 he finished conclusively. 
 
 "Nonsense," she said curtly. "Stuff and 
 nonsense. They have been sentenced already. 
 Half the papers have had leaders on the in- 
 crease of crime, and the number of arrests 
 among the young; the other half are moralizing 
 over the evil effects of novel reading, and ask- 
 ing what shall be done with these young repro- 
 bates. Every one of them has bunches of 
 scavengers out looking up evidence to send 
 these half dozen children to prison for life." 
 
 "And what have you been doing on the 
 case?" asked Ted. 
 
 " I ? Well, Maxwell sent me to write my 
 impressions, honestly, and I went, with very 
 much the same expectations as you would have 
 had, from what you have just said. I did not 
 find what I expected, but seven boys, one of 
 them crying hysterically for his mother, and 
 nothing about any of them to justify the belief 
 that they were in any way different from dozens 
 of other country boys. You know it happened 
 98
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 out in a little suburb that is just like the coun- 
 try." 
 
 Ted was beginning to look bewildered. 
 "What have you written about it ?" he said. 
 
 She picked up the first page of her copy, 
 where she had written in a bold, free hand, 
 " For the Defense in the Riordan Case." 
 
 "You don't mean it!" he said. "Oh, I sup- 
 pose the lawyer they have retained has a pull 
 with your paper!" 
 
 "No," she answered steadily. "They haven't 
 any lawyer; they are too poor to employ one. 
 They consulted Ward, but if they mortgaged 
 everything they have in the world they couldn't 
 pay his retainer fee. I suppose the court will 
 assign some one to defend them, but that will 
 amount to nothing. Public sentiment is all the 
 other way. I don't know why we should have 
 a public prosecutor any more than a public 
 defender. The defense of these boys will be a 
 mere empty formality, and the memory of their 
 mothers' faces haunts me. After I had seen 
 them I went to their homes, and I know they 
 are innocent, but how can we prove it ? and it 
 will kill their mothers!" 
 
 99
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 Her voice broke, and Miss Brent wiped her 
 glasses again and pushed the copy across the 
 table to Ted. "Read it, my dear," she said, 
 "and then, if you are willing to take the case, 
 I would like to retain your services. The boys 
 have found a defender, but they still need a 
 lawyer." 
 
 He read the long, circumstantial story care- 
 fully. There were treacherous breaks in his 
 voice and his eyes were bright as he laid it 
 aside and said slowly, "I dare hardly call 
 myself a lawyer, but such as I am, if they have 
 no one else, I will do the best I can for the 
 defense." 
 
 100
 
 XIII 
 
 r^ED was as good as his word, or even a 
 trifle better. Having undertaken the de- 
 fense of the boys, he went over the case with 
 Lorraine, point by point, making notes and 
 planning his campaign, and the next morning 
 the two set out for the prison where the 
 defendants were confined, the gravity of the 
 charge against them making the ordinary house 
 of detention for juvenile offenders out of the 
 question. 
 
 Lorraine's defense of the accused, which was 
 out in the morning edition, did not make her a 
 more welcome visitor at the prison, for prisons 
 are conducted on the belief that it is well-nigh 
 impossible to make a mistake in arresting any 
 one. Nevertheless, her daring in taking the 
 side of the under dog such a helpless, un- 
 fortunate, unromantic, yellow under dog won 
 the admiration, if not the approval, of the 
 department, and the doors swung open before 
 her. 
 
 101
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 They groped their way through the dark 
 corridors to the cell where the older and pre- 
 sumably more desperate of the criminal chil- 
 dren were confined. The oldest boy, Arthur 
 Brown, looked wistfully out from behind the 
 bars, and when the door was opened stood in 
 the narrow aperture and answered Ted's ques- 
 tions. He was rather a gentle-faced boy, be- 
 tween seventeen and eighteen, and as they stood 
 a cat walked into his cell. He picked her 
 up, with a quick, loving motion, and held 
 her against his neck, where she purred con- 
 tentedly. 
 
 "Please don't mind my hands," he said. 
 "I'd been shoveling dirt where they're making 
 an excavation, and I haven't had any chance 
 to wash." 
 
 "Arthur," said Lorraine, "I've been to see 
 your folks; they have perfect confidence in you, 
 and you must not be unhappy. This gentle- 
 man, Mr. Theodore Erskine, is going to defend 
 you. Tell him all you can, and tell him the 
 exact truth." 
 
 The boy stopped petting the cat and looked 
 at them in astonishment. "We haven't any 
 
 102
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 money," he said simply. "Father's got a cow, 
 if that would be any use to you; but we haven't 
 any money at all, because father's been sick, 
 and I was the only one that was making any- 
 thing. I don't know what they will do with- 
 out me. Roy Collins' folks can afford a lawyer; 
 but of course time is money with you, sir, and 
 we can't expect you to do this for nothing, 
 and we haven't anything; I wish we couid 
 have you." 
 
 Ted gulped and colored. Time was the only 
 thing in the world which he possessed in abun- 
 dance. 
 
 "Never mind about that," he said hurriedly. 
 "Don't think anything about the money, or the 
 cow, but tell me all you know about this and 
 help me to clear your little brothers; I think 
 from what I know that your own alibi is clear. 
 But if Roy is guilty, you cannot afford to shield 
 him; you must speak the truth to save your 
 brothers." 
 
 "My folks never allowed any of us to lie," 
 he said slowly. "My little brother, that they 
 said confessed, used the words that was put 
 into his mouth; don't I know? They tried the 
 
 103
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 same thing with me. Wasn't this so, wasn't 
 that so, didn't I know that Roy had broken 
 down and owned that he did it, and all that 
 sort of thing for hours and hours, and nothing 
 to eat, and part of the time shut in a dark cell. 
 No wonder Jimmy finally said whatever they 
 told him to. But it isn't so. Roy never had a 
 gun, except an old muzzle-loading musket that 
 burst the first time we fired it off, Fourth of 
 July. What would we have killed Patsy for ? 
 He was a nice little chap." 
 
 It was a long, hard day's work to interview 
 each of the boys and their parents, but if 
 Lorraine's views had not met with favor at 
 police headquarters she was received with bene- 
 dictions and open arms at the homes of the 
 accused. When she explained that a friend 
 who was interested had employed Mr. Erskine 
 to defend the Brown children, without any cost 
 to their parents, Miss Brent was calendared as 
 a saint at once, while Teddy was regarded as a 
 tall angel; certainly his raiment was shining at 
 every seam. The parents of Roy Collins had 
 employed an attorney named Harrison, but as 
 the cases were so closely allied, Teddy wasted 
 104
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 no time in conferring with him, and then went 
 home to draw up his first papers in his first 
 case, a case already a nine-days' wonder, and 
 destined to hold "top of column" when it 
 should come off. 
 
 105
 
 XIV 
 
 ; I V HE exigencies of the defense made it neces- 
 sary for the attorneys for the Brown boys 
 and the Collins boy to have frequent consulta- 
 tions, and a fast friendship sprung up between 
 Ted and Mr. Harrison, who, though a much 
 older man than himself, had not been in New 
 York for a great length of time, and had been 
 glad to take the Collins defense because of the 
 opportunity it afforded him to make a debut in a 
 somewhat spectacular trial. He had made his 
 terms to suit the emergency in his own affairs. 
 He was not inexperienced in his profession, 
 but merely one of those who having succeeded 
 elsewhere had his spurs yet to win in New 
 York. He was a man of fine presence, lit- 
 erary tastes, and a winning personality, though 
 at times Ted found him somewhat cold- 
 blooded. 
 
 Strangely enough, Lorraine, who had been 
 of no small service to them, took an aversion 
 to Harrison from the very first. 
 1 06
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "Don't be unreasonable," Ted argued. 
 "You're too good a fellow for such whims. 
 The Dr. Fell attitude is unworthy of you." 
 
 They were going over the case for the twen- 
 tieth time, while Bess sketched away at the 
 other end of the table, and Hope rested in the 
 cozy corner. "What are you two quarreling 
 about now?" she asked. 
 
 "Over my confrere in the defense," Ted 
 answered. "I think Maurice Harrison is all 
 right, and, without being able to give a single 
 reason, Lorraine dislikes him so she can scarcely 
 be civil." 
 
 "Maurice Harrison ?" queried Hope vaguely. 
 "What has he to do with the Riordans ? I 
 thought he was literary." 
 
 Lorraine looked up quickly. "Why, do you 
 know him?" she asked. 
 
 "Yes, no, I don't know," she answered. 
 "Is he a tall, blonde man, well built, rather 
 handsome ? I know a Harrison like that, but 
 he is a writer. He has a novel that is to come 
 out this fall or winter some time. I read the 
 manuscript, and my verdict was so favorable 
 that the firm showed it to him, and and so 
 
 107
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 we were introduced, and I've met him a time 
 or so since," rather lamely. 
 
 "I guess it's the same man all right/' an- 
 swered Ted. "He's a rattling good lawyer, 
 keeps 'clear and cool' like the weather predic- 
 tions for to-day, and is up to all the tricks and 
 dodges of the law. He has given me lots of 
 good points and is almost as much interested 
 in my clients as his own. Now, don't you 
 think that is unselfish ? Don't you like him, 
 Hope ? It's the same man, I'm sure, for he 
 told me he had a story coming out." 
 
 Before Hope could answer, for she hesitated 
 several moments, Lorraine joined with Ted: 
 'Yes, do tell us about him, Hope. To my mind 
 the one thing of which Maurice Harrison is 
 absolutely incapable is unselfishness. Of course 
 he takes an interest in Ted's clients; he has to; 
 how could he protect his own if he didn't ? 
 Besides, didn't you say it was his first case in 
 New York that is any ways striking ?" 
 
 Hope hesitated still, and Ted said encourag- 
 ingly, "'Speak, and let the worst be known, 
 speaking may relieve you,'" and, thus urged, 
 she went on. 
 
 108
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "To tell the truth, I've found him very 
 interesting; of course I haven't talked business 
 with him, for literature is not his business but 
 only a by-path. He is well read and has 
 traveled considerable. I believe the family 
 come from Philadelphia, I think his parents 
 live there now, but he has been in the West 
 for some years. Possibly if I met him when 
 he had on his professional manner I should not 
 like him." 
 
 Lorraine looked disappointed, and then said, 
 rather irritably: "I'd be willing to wager my 
 next 'exclusive' that his interest in this case is 
 largely that of the literary ragpicker. He is 
 contemplating a murder story, and he wants 
 to study the type from infancy to age. He has 
 never been really more than half sure of Roy's 
 innocence; that's one reason why I dislike him 
 so; he isn't fair to the child, but now I can 
 understand better. You'll see. His next story 
 will have a lonely wood and a corpse in it, and 
 an owl that inquires, 'Whoo, whoo, whoo/ from 
 above the mangled remains, while the blood- 
 shot moon sinks behind the black and somber 
 forest. I know his type. Has he decided yet 
 
 109
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 whether to have a snowstorm, or is the horrid 
 deed to take place under the affrighted eyes of 
 the man in the harvest moon ?" 
 
 Hope gasped, for Mr. Harrison had confided 
 to her, during one of the luncheons they had 
 had together recently, that his next story was 
 to be one of plot, and they had discussed the 
 relative virtues of snow with its enveloping pall, 
 and rain, leaving the ground in good condition 
 for telltale footprints. "Oh, don't, Lorraine!" 
 she said; "this case is getting- on your nerves, 
 and you are so anxious about it that you are 
 unduly suspicious. Mr. Harrison is very much 
 a gentleman, and has quite uncommonly fine 
 manners." 
 
 "Yes, as mild mannered a man as ever 
 scuttled a ship," muttered Lorraine under her 
 breath; adding aloud, "Well, I hope I'm mis- 
 taken, but his eyes are too close together to 
 suit me, and he's as given to moods and caprices 
 as a 'dope-fiend* or a 'Miss Flora MacFlimsy.' 
 I've no doubt he can be entertaining, but 
 well, I'll leave you two to praise him all you 
 like. I'm going to see Miss Brent; she's worth 
 a million of him." And she vanished into 
 no
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 the gloom of the hallway, annoyed with Ted, al- 
 most provoked with Hope, and more than ever 
 prejudiced against the man who had brought 
 the first shadow between her and two of her 
 best friends. 
 
 in
 
 XV 
 
 "1T7ITH the first of September Prince Karl 
 returned, and his arrival was celebrated 
 from basement to garret. He brought with him 
 a trunk of ore, a red Indian tan, and an insatiable 
 appetite, not to mention a brain teeming with 
 the romance of the hills. Lorraine almost wept 
 upon his neck for joy, for there seemed to have 
 come an intangible something between herself 
 and Hope. Louis was wholly absorbed in a 
 new play, and as it was impossible to discuss 
 Ted's chief interest in life without referring to 
 the objectionable Harrison, they had tacitly 
 shelved it. So Lorraine devoted all her spare 
 time to the Miss Brents, yet there also she felt 
 rather than saw the shadow of a cloud. Miss 
 Emma did not seem quite herself, though Miss 
 Elise was apparently happily unconscious of 
 any change. 
 
 "I think I'll give it up," said Miss Emma 
 one dark afternoon when the postman brought 
 back two of her most cherished animal stories. 
 112
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "I'm too old, or too dull, or too something to 
 get into print. I'd better be fixing my atten- 
 tion on the tomb and preparing for death. By 
 the way, how do people prepare for death ? 
 Renan once wrote a play, of which nobody has 
 ever heard except people who like digging up 
 literary curiosities, to prove that if we knew 
 the world was coming to an end next week, the 
 whole swinish multitude of us would rush vio- 
 lently down the hill and drown ourselves in a 
 sea of unlicensed debauchery. What would 
 you do if you knew your time was limited ?" 
 
 "Keep on working," said Lorraine prosa- 
 ically. "When it got down to the last few 
 days I'd burn my letters and papers, give away 
 the few scraps I have to give, and arrange with 
 the nearest crematory for the last sad rites. 
 Then, like the noble three hundred at Ther- 
 mopylae, I'd sit down and comb my hair. I'd 
 like to leave that to Uncle Peter," she added 
 reflectively. "I feel as if he has a claim on 
 it. But what a question! Even if one's manu- 
 script does come back, there is no use in being 
 snuffed out like Chatterton or slain by the lack 
 of reviewers." 
 
 "3
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "I can't seem to hit the popular fancy," 
 said Miss Brent. "I don't get anywhere with 
 all my writing, except as the papers take a 
 letter now and then. It would never occur to 
 me to record the fact that I've never seen a 
 purple cow. The singular fact that I've never 
 seen a little colt with coat as white as snow, 
 and where we get our horses white I'd really 
 like to know, has never seemed to me of suf- 
 ficiently vital importance to warrant rushing 
 into print with it, yet that is as remarkable as 
 the narrative of the lilac mooley." 
 
 "Maybe that's one trouble," said Lorraine. 
 "If you had hurried to the publisher with your 
 white colt before the lavender cow maybe you 
 would have achieved everlasting fame. Thank 
 heaven for the people who are willing to amuse 
 us; they never get any more than their due 
 when they get the best. Most of us don't dare 
 to write unless we think we have a revelation, 
 and then we complain because 'vanity is still 
 on deck and humble virtue gets it in the neck." 
 
 "Like Lewis Carroll, with his horrid old 
 arithmetics, being ashamed of Alice and the 
 Jabberwock," said the old lady. "I dare to 
 114
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 be as funny as I can, but it takes real genius 
 to be funny. Anybody can be serious without 
 being wise." 
 
 "Now here's an idea," said Lorraine, "that 
 came to me when I was reviewing, but I've never 
 worked it up and you're more than welcome to 
 it. It is a plea for a literary humane society." 
 
 "On behalf of the readers ?" 
 
 "No, for the prevention of cruelty to animals 
 in fiction. There seems to be no limit to the 
 abuse that authors are willing to permit, or even 
 encourage. I can stand what's-his-name killing 
 the aurochs, and the general gladiatorial slaugh- 
 ters in 'Quo Vadis,' but when it comes to tor- 
 turing a dog the way the vicar does in 'Jack 
 Raymond' I object. In 'The Conquest of 
 Canaan' the whole village takes a hand in the 
 persecution of a dog, and the way heroes and 
 heroines ride and drive is a caution. It's the 
 lady in 'Dorothy Vernon' and the man in 
 'None but the Brave.' You remember how 
 'Richard Carvel' exploits that horse, jumping 
 him over houses and racing him about London, 
 while in 'The Leopard's Spots' Dixon heart- 
 lessly drives a bay mare ten miles in forty-nine 
 
 "5
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 minutes, over country roads up hill and down, 
 so that she drops dead. I object to these ex- 
 amples of cruelty being placed in the hands of 
 the children of the land." 
 
 "I'll do it," said Miss Brent with much 
 gusto. "Didn't you hate the man who killed 
 Kroof's cub in 'The Heart of the Ancient 
 Wood' ? I hope she never married him, and if 
 she did I don't mean Kroof, but the girl I'm 
 sure they lived unhappily ever after. But do 
 you think I can ? I'm afraid I can never be a 
 really intellectual woman." 
 
 Miss Elise, who had come in a few minutes 
 before with the tea things, laughed and said 
 consolingly: "Never mind, Emmy. I never 
 knew but one intellectual woman who prided 
 herself on that fact. She could not keep house or 
 sew, and her flannels always showed at the wrist. 
 There comes Hope down the street. She walks 
 as if her name were Madame Atlas; suppose I 
 go and call her in to have some tea with us." 
 
 "Your sister's description reminds me of the 
 lady who said her friend was not vulgar; she 
 was not refined; she was the kind of per- 
 son who keeps a parrot. I shall never strive 
 116
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 for intellectuality again. What is the matter, 
 Hope?" for the girl had come in and dropped 
 down beside Miss Brent, the very picture of 
 despondency. 
 
 "Oh, it's 'Goliath'!" she said. "I've been 
 thinking of that story that was so good the 
 author couldn't sell anything else; 'My Wife's 
 Deceased Sister,' wasn't it ? Well, that's the 
 trouble. Those people had taken a lot of 
 things before 'Goliath,' but they've never been 
 pleased with anything since. They are as kind 
 as possible and they say different things, but 
 they all mean the same; nothing I've sent them 
 has come up to 'Goliath.' Oh, for a David with 
 his ever-ready sling to have slain my ogre!" 
 
 "Perhaps you are trying to wear the armor 
 of Saul and it doesn't fit," said Miss Brent 
 whimsically. "As near as I can figure it out, 
 that is what's the matter with me. We haven't 
 found our line yet. Don't you remember what 
 Arnold says ? 
 
 'And we have been on many thousand lines, 
 And we have shown on each talent and power, 
 But hardly have we, for one little hour, 
 Been on our own line, have we been ourselves.'
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 One of these days some publisher will discover 
 you and your fortune will be made." 
 
 "No," said Hope resolutely, "I used to think 
 that, but I know better now. I've got all the 
 chance there is and so has everybody else. If 
 one publisher doesn't like your work there are 
 dozens of others, and the way the Arthurs have 
 hung on to me, and tried to help me with all 
 kinds of suggestions, and written me every now 
 and then to send them something, shows plainly 
 enough that the publishers are just as anxious 
 to discover latent talent as any of us can be 
 to be discovered. I'm not so jaundiced by 
 defeat that I can't see that. The fault is not 
 in the publishers, but in me." 
 
 "I wish she'd fall in love," said Lorraine 
 tempestuously. "Nothing would do her so 
 much good." 
 
 "Never!" cried Miss Brent. "She'd marry 
 and the world would lose her. Fancy a God- 
 given genius attending to the family marketing 
 and mending while the ink dries in her 
 fountain pen. Anybody can get married, 
 but only a few people can write a story like 
 'Goliath'!" 
 
 118
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "Oh, I don't care anything about her getting 
 married," Lorraine answered, oblivious of the 
 fact that Hope had blushed furiously and then 
 turned pale and colored again. "It isn't in the 
 least necessary for the affair to go so far as 
 that. Kipling says, 'Next to a requited at- 
 tachment, one of the most convenient things 
 that a young man can carry about with him, at 
 the beginning of his career, is an unrequited 
 attachment.' I'm convinced if Hope once had 
 a case of heart disease of the malignant type, 
 no palpitations need apply, that she would 
 find herself." 
 
 The old lady sniffed unbelievingly. "You 
 were evidently brought up on the belief that 
 whatever hurts does good. That's orthodox, 
 but I don't believe it myself. Love isn't the 
 djinn or the Aladdin's lamp of life. Goodness 
 knows it isn't generally even the magic carpet 
 that makes easy going. It's the little old man 
 of the sea. Don't pay any attention to her, 
 Hope. Just be a genius, and don't be in a 
 hurry to take up with the good loaf of brown 
 bread prescribed for geniuses. You will arrive 
 without putting yourself under a steam-crusher 
 119
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 to hasten the good work. By the steps in 
 the hall I should say Bess and Teddy have 
 come in. If Lorraine must have a love 
 affair and can't be happy till she gets it, that 
 looks rather promising. Have some more tea, 
 Hope." 
 
 Though the girl drank her tea and tried to 
 shake off her depression, the effort was appar- 
 ent, and when they were alone that evening 
 Lorraine made her a bowl of catnip tea and 
 insisted on her going to bed. 
 
 "No, it isn't that I'm tired or sick, Lorraine; 
 but the truth is so plain that I can't deceive 
 myself any longer, and yet, don't you see ? it is 
 like giving up life itself when one resigns one's 
 whole plan and scheme of life. I had to give 
 up the stage when my heart was set on it; then, 
 because I had succeeded in amusing the chil- 
 dren, I thought perhaps it was in me to write 
 the stories I had grown used to telling, but it 
 was the instinct of the actor, not of the creator, 
 that made me tell my stories well. I don't 
 know exactly what the sting of death may be, 
 but the sting of life is to write 'Failure' when 
 one has tried with all one's heart and soul. 
 1 20
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 If I had written a euthanasia story it would 
 have been about some one who realized that 
 the light of the whole world dies with the 
 setting sun. Don't try to comfort me; not yet, 
 not yet." 
 
 121
 
 XVI 
 
 AS the time drew near that was to see the 
 beginning of the case of The State vs. Roy 
 Collins, Arthur Brown, et al., Ted grew nervous, 
 and one Sunday, not long before the momentous 
 day, he and Lorraine took the long journey to 
 the suburban town near where the tragedy had 
 taken place, and walked out to the small wood. 
 The leaves were falling, and the thickets silent, 
 the birds flown. They sat down on a log and 
 recounted the case to each other. 
 
 "There is one thing in which I have been 
 disappointed with myself," said Ted discon- 
 tentedly. " I think I have done fairly well with 
 the rest of it, but so far I haven't been able 
 to find any clue to the real criminal. In this 
 kind of an affair there is a lack of motive that 
 is baffling to begin with, and yet I am certain 
 that there was a motive; that's where Harrison 
 and I differ. He intends to dwell upon the 
 probability that it was an accident, as people 
 often went hunting about here. The Browns 
 122
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 believe it was an accident; they say people often 
 shot at targets, or made targets of the trees, 
 and they think it was a stray shot. Poor little 
 Patsy Riordan; it wasn't worth the while of the 
 detective force to track his slayer, and I'm 
 afraid I'm not a combination of M. Lecoq and 
 Sherlock Holmes." 
 
 "I don't believe it was an accident either," 
 answered Lorraine. " I've always had a theory 
 about this case, but, as in another instance, I 
 have no better reason than 'because,' and I'll 
 admit that is not much of a reason." 
 
 "Let's have it anyhow," said Ted, idly turn- 
 ing over the leaves with his foot. "We are 
 sitting on the log where the boys sat who wit- 
 nessed the murder, according to Willie Hinck- 
 ley's confession, and Patsy was lying over there 
 under that tree." 
 
 Lorraine looked at the tree curiously. It was 
 not very large, and about eight or nine feet from 
 the ground one bare branch stood out almost 
 at right angles with the tree. 
 
 " Do you respectable New Yorkers ever have 
 lynchings ?" she asked. 
 
 "Why, I don't remember," he said, racking 
 123
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 his brain to recall an instance. "I suppose 
 we have had them at some time in our career. 
 Men are brothers down under their skin, North 
 and South, East and West, same as the colonel's 
 lady and Judy. What made you think of it ?" 
 
 "The tree," answered Lorraine. "Do you 
 like ghost stories ? No ? There's no account- 
 ing for tastes. Now I do; also I once compiled 
 a scrap-book of superstitions, and one section 
 of it dealt with legends and strange tales about 
 trees. One doesn't have to believe them to 
 find them interesting. If you will look at that 
 tree carefully, you will see that it is just the 
 kind of a tree a lynching party would seek. 
 You will perceive also that while the other 
 trees are still fairly green, that one has fallen 
 into the sere and yellow leaf. One shake and 
 it would stand denuded of even its last leaf." 
 
 "I don't see the ghost," said Ted. 
 
 Lorraine sank her voice to a sepulchral 
 whisper. "When a tree has been made ac- 
 cessory before or even after the fact, particeps 
 criminis, I believe you call it, in a crime, it 
 never gets over it. Its nature is too fine to 
 withstand the shock. There is a haunted apple 
 124
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 tree in a Massachusetts town under which a 
 murder was committed; the apples it bears are 
 streaked with crimson to the core, and any 
 Southerner can tell you that the tree that has 
 served as a gallows dies and stands a blasted 
 monument to the evil that men do." 
 
 "I've often thought," Ted answered, "what 
 it would mean if inanimate nature had a voice. 
 In France they believe it has, to a certain extent. 
 You know no one can be convicted of a crime 
 without being confronted with his prey, and 
 the victim is kept in the morgue for a year or 
 so, perhaps, just as he is found, that the * con- 
 frontation,' as they call it, may be possible. 
 When there is a very awful murder they repro- 
 duce the scene of it: if it was in a room, they 
 take all the furniture and make another room 
 just like it, and when they have the man they 
 believe guilty they take him down into this 
 horrible subterranean place, and suddenly con- 
 front him with the scene and the victim, just 
 as he left it. Miss Brent was telling me about 
 such a room that she saw in the morgue in 
 Paris when she was there. They say nine- 
 tenths of the criminals will break down and 
 125
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 confess under these circumstances. Now that 
 tree could tell the truth if it could speak, for 
 whatever was done, was done under its very 
 branches." 
 
 "The tree isn't dying for nothing," said Lor- 
 raine. "It knows more than it tells." 
 
 "Naturally, since it knows all and tells noth- 
 ing. Let's go and consult the dryad, if she 
 hasn't fled." 
 
 They walked across the dry, hard ground, 
 with its litter of rustling leaves and yellowing 
 grass, and Lorraine leaned against the trunk 
 of the tree while Ted caught the branch and 
 with a quick jerk swung himself up amidst 
 a shower of yellow leaves. Lorraine turned 
 toward him, her face pale and startled. 
 
 "Something dropped inside the tree," she 
 said in a frightened voice. 
 
 "What?" he cried excitedly, clinging to the 
 branch. 
 
 "Reach over to the crotch," she said, "and 
 see if there isn't a hollow." 
 
 He slid along the drooping branch until he 
 reached the trunk of the tree. "Yes," he said, 
 "there's a small hole." He thrust his hand 
 126
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 into it, and the arm to the elbow. "The whole 
 trunk must be hollow," he said; "I might have 
 known it by looking at it." 
 
 Lorraine was looking at the tree fixedly. 
 "That tree holds your clue," she said. "When 
 you shook it something heavy fell. Don't you 
 remember the inquest showed that the wound 
 was made with a thirty-two caliber cartridge, 
 and one of the things that struck me first was 
 that the boys all told different stories about the 
 gun, and none of any kind was ever found ? 
 The detectives didn't even find a gun in Rior- 
 dan's house, though the neighbors say he used 
 to shoot at the mark too." 
 
 "You don't mean oh, but if it was a gun, 
 why didn't it go off when it fell ? Why didn't 
 whoever put it here take it away ? Why 
 didn't it fall to the bottom in the first place ? 
 It must have been just a piece of rotted wood." 
 
 " No," she insisted. " It fell heavily. It did- 
 n't go off because the trigger had been pulled 
 and the hammer was down on an empty car- 
 tridge. Whoever put it there couldn't reach 
 it to take it away; it probably slipped from his 
 fingers and caught midway on wood that has 
 127
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 rotted since, so that when you shook the tree it 
 gave way. At first he did not dare come to 
 this spot, haunted both by the detectives and 
 his child's blood " 
 
 "You don't think Riordan did it ?" Ted cried. 
 
 "I don't think," she answered quickly. "I 
 don't think anything, except that this tree can 
 tell us what we want to know, but not being 
 Indians we don't carry tomahawks with us, 
 and how are we to find out ? We may have 
 been watched. We can't both leave to go find 
 a hatchet, even if we could account for such a 
 singular request. How about your knife ? The 
 bark on this side looks thin, and as if the trunk 
 under it might be rotten." 
 
 Ted drew out his knife a rough-handled, 
 strenuous looking affair, reminiscent of his 
 youth and set to work. First he cut off a 
 piece of the bark, large enough to allow his 
 hand to pass through, and placed it carefully 
 on one side. "We'll hide our tracks if we 
 can," he said, and then began hacking away. 
 It was slow work, and the sun had set and the 
 moon was rising before the sound wood was 
 carved away and his knife struck through. In 
 128
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 a minute more he had thrust in his hand and 
 brought out what they expected, a rusted re- 
 volver, thirty-two caliber. As they bent over 
 it in the growing moonlight, two initials rudely 
 carved in the handle were plainly visible, - 
 "P. R." They looked in each other's faces in 
 silence. Then Ted carefully put the chips he 
 had made inside the tree, slipped the bark back 
 in place, fastened it with a few tiny wedges, 
 and they started homeward. 
 
 "Still, it doesn't prove anything," said Ted. 
 
 "No," she admitted, "it doesn't, but it gives 
 a clue. Now we must find the motive." 
 
 "I've got the motive," he answered slowly. 
 "I never told you or any one, but I have the 
 same feeling about Riordan that you have, and 
 I tried to learn all I could about him. This is 
 his second wife. Patsy's mother died over a 
 year ago; her life had been insured in Patsy's 
 behalf. It was only a small sum, say five hun- 
 dred dollars, but to a man like Riordan it would 
 have been enough. Besides, he had an un- 
 governable temper. He had the name of treat- 
 ing his family badly, and Patsy's body bore the 
 marks of his anger when it was buried. But I 
 129
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 couldn't get any further. There was no evidence 
 against him, and he was a wreck of misery 
 
 "Or fear," suggested Lorraine. 
 
 at the preliminary hearing; I'll have to talk 
 this over with Harrison, and try to figure it out." 
 
 Lorraine grew frigid at once. "I hope you 
 will do nothing of the kind," she said. "Don't 
 you see here is your chance for a 'confronta- 
 tion ' scene of your own ? You've got as much 
 at stake as he has in this case; don't give him 
 the best dramatic situation in it to make copy 
 out of, and a reputation for himself. Keep 
 still, and see what more you can learn; find 
 out if Riordan doesn't intend to leave here as 
 soon as- this trial is over." 
 
 "Well, since this is mostly your contribution 
 to the case, and but for you I wouldn't have 
 had it at all, I think I ought to regard you as 
 senior counsel, and if you don't want anything 
 said, I'll say nothing. But what a fearful thing 
 it is; can you realize it ?" 
 
 "From battle, murder, and sudden death,'' 
 half whispered Lorraine, and they finished to- 
 gether in hushed voices, "'Good Lord, deliver 
 us!'" 
 
 130
 
 XVII 
 
 ~*HE Riordan case had been nearly forgotten 
 long before it was reached on the docket. 
 Lorraine's article had taken some of the spec- 
 tacular features away from it, from the jour- 
 nalistic standpoint, and if the prosecution had 
 developed anything new or sensational it had 
 kept it out of the papers. The poverty of the 
 families concerned made it a foregone con- 
 clusion that the accused would be summarily 
 disposed of and hustled off to prison and re- 
 formatory with that through-train speed that is 
 apt, in such cases, to offset the usual law's delays. 
 There were other capital cases involving repu- 
 tations, property, what not, defended by men 
 who had established professional positions. 
 The curious found more interesting criminals 
 than the half-dozen frightened children. 
 
 The courtroom was large, dingy, and bare, 
 and when the Riordan case was called the 
 spectators' seats were nearly empty. A few 
 scholarly looking men were present, evidently
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 prepared to make a psychological study of the 
 accused, who sat at one side of the door, just 
 within the railing. The younger children had 
 little comprehension of the occasion, but as 
 often as the accustomed smile came to their 
 faces one glance at their parents, sitting by 
 them in stony, white-faced misery, drove it 
 away, leaving in its place an expression of 
 mingled surprise and fear. 
 
 Roy Collins was deadly pallid and emaciated. 
 His mother, a nervous little woman, sat by him, 
 holding his slim, white hand in hers, the same 
 awkward paw that used to be so brown and so 
 seldom clean. There was a hard, defiant glitter 
 in her eyes, and scarlet spots burned on her 
 cheeks. The boy's father, on the other side 
 of him, looked broken and worn. 
 
 Mrs. Brown, seated by Arthur, with the little 
 boys about them, or sitting on their father's 
 knees, made no attempt to keep back the tears. 
 Some neighbors who had come with them 
 looked about curiously, and then turned back 
 to the pathetic little group with sympathetic 
 faces. 
 
 Farther away from the railing that shut out 
 132
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 the spectators sat Peter Riordan, haggard of 
 countenance, his head bowed on his hands. 
 
 As soon as the case began it was evident that 
 the acting district attorney did not believe in 
 killing flies with a steam-hammer. He felt sure 
 the case was to be an easy victory, and re- 
 garded Harrison with disdain and Ted as a 
 mere babe in arms, who knew little and would 
 not dare to do anything, even if he did not 
 forget the small amount of legal lore at his 
 command. It was not until Ted had chal- 
 lenged the third juror "for cause," because he 
 admitted a scientific interest in penology, that 
 the prosecution realized that Ted was not quite 
 so young as he looked. 
 
 True, Teddy had never had a case, but his 
 knowledge of court practice was not wholly 
 gleaned from the printed page. Having no 
 suits of his own to attend to, he had made it 
 a practice to spend hours every week in the 
 different courts of the city, watching the con- 
 duct of any trial of importance that might be 
 going on. Fresh from his books he appre- 
 ciated nice points as they arose, and the prac- 
 tical determination of moot questions, before 
 133
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 his eyes, was worth much. Nevertheless, the 
 morning the Riordan case began he was on an 
 extreme tension that was well-nigh intolerable. 
 He had ideas of his own of the sympathy to be 
 accorded to the younger members of his pro- 
 fession, and also a firm belief that no lawyer 
 should lose his first case; he should not take a 
 case for his debut in which he could not believe 
 with all his mind and strength that justice and 
 equity, which are legally quite different, be- 
 longed to his client. He had seen men of 
 experience lose, simply for lack of preparation; 
 a man with unlimited time, he thought, should 
 not fail from this cause. While he believed 
 he would succeed in clearing the accused boys, 
 he could not fail to recognize that this was not 
 at all the kind of a case upon which he had 
 relied to prove his theory; there was so little 
 law and so much fact in it. Neither did he 
 trust to the indifference with which district 
 attorneys often prepare and try their cases. 
 Nash's term of office was nearing its conclu- 
 sion, and is not a prosecuting attorney known 
 by the number of convictions he makes ? How- 
 ever unique the suit might be from a senti- 
 134
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 mental standpoint, he knew that the formalities 
 of the trial would present little beyond the 
 usual routine, saving the one feature upon 
 which, more than anything else, he was re- 
 lying. 
 
 When the case was called for trial Harrison 
 was absent, and Ted secured a brief delay, 
 and sent a messenger after him. It had been 
 reached sooner than was expected, still he was 
 a little annoyed that Harrison should have taken 
 any chances, and after half an hour proceeded 
 to trial without him. 
 
 In the selection of the jury he took extraor- 
 dinary care. The district attorney was inclined 
 to ridicule his close examination of some of 
 the panel, and Harrison, when he hurried in 
 an hour late, was a little impatient aho, but 
 Ted went on in his own way. He exercised 
 the right of peremptory challenge in several 
 cases where he believed that the would-be 
 juror had more interest in proving theories than 
 in judging mankind, and also excused several 
 young, unmarried men. He was after the milk 
 of human kindness, and he believed it would 
 be more likely to be found among those who 
 135
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 had boys of their own. When the twelve good 
 men and true were chosen, he was quite sat- 
 isfied. 
 
 As the prosecuting attorney warmed to his 
 work, his voice rang out through the halls of 
 the courthouse and some of the reporters 
 straggled in. He dwelt upon the enormity of 
 the crime, and the degeneracy of the accused, 
 who, he said, had been the bane of the neigh- 
 borhood. Their bodies had been ruined by 
 cigarette smoking, and their imaginations in- 
 flamed by reading pernicious books. Though 
 young in years they were old in vice, and Patsy 
 Riordan had incurred their ill will by the very 
 fact that he was a more than ordinarily good 
 child. True to their vicious instincts, they had 
 murdered him in cold blood. He called atten- 
 tion to the father of this victim of youthful de- 
 pravity, a mere wreck of his erstwhile manhood, 
 and dilated upon his suffering when he found 
 his only child foully murdered. He set forth 
 what he expected to prove with such certainty 
 that Walter Davis, a Herald reporter sitting 
 next to Lorraine, whispered, "Well, it's all over 
 with your young friends, the Jameses, except 
 136
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 sending for the hurry-up wagon and giving 
 them some new clothes." 
 
 Teddy wanted Harrison to make the opening 
 address for the defense; but Harrison, who 
 wished to have the close, insisted that he, as he 
 had been there from the beginning, should do 
 this. The young man felt the dirty floor of the 
 courtroom roll under his feet like the ground- 
 swell of an ocean steamer. The judge and 
 jury were an indistinct blur, his mouth felt like 
 an advertisement of some one's liquid glue, and 
 his voice was gone beyond recall. He saw a 
 white blotch over by the door, and as he strug- 
 gled to his feet a suppressed sob broke the still- 
 ness of the room. The white blotch turned 
 into the face of Mrs. Collins, and the sob from 
 Mrs. Brown was the bugle call that brought 
 Ted to his feet and his senses, his wits and his 
 voice, all at once. Contrary to the expecta- 
 tions of the district attorney, he did not go into 
 an extended speech, but contented himself with 
 a general denial of the guilt of his clients, and 
 a few sarcastic references to the charge of the 
 prosecution that the children were homeless 
 vagabonds. He called the attention of the 
 137
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 jury to the fact that the parents of the boys 
 were in court, suffering as much, perhaps, on 
 account of the unjust accusation of their chil- 
 dren, their months of imprisonment on an un- 
 founded charge, as even the unhappy father of 
 the murdered boy. When he sat down again, 
 Walter Davis remarked to Lorraine, "This 
 case may be worth as much as eight lines; I'll 
 pass the word along for the fellows to play it 
 up a little. Your young friend isn't such a fool 
 as he might be, judging from his being so hand- 
 some. We'll just casually remark that he's on 
 earth;" and thus Ted received his first rec- 
 ognition from the Fourth Estate. The court 
 adjourned until the next day. 
 
 138
 
 XVIII 
 
 TX/HHEN the court reconvened the next morn- 
 ing there was some question in regard to 
 swearing the children. Willie Hinckley, the 
 boy who had confessed to being a witness of the 
 murder, and who had rescinded his confession 
 afterward, was the first witness produced by the 
 prosecution. 
 
 The judge called the lad to him, and got 
 from him a fragmentary statement of his views 
 concerning the nature of oaths. He did not 
 permit the boy to be sworn. Ted looked at the 
 judge attentively. He remembered that some 
 one had told him that the judge had once 
 been compared to Abraham Lincoln, and from 
 that good hour that he had been trying to live 
 up to and increase the resemblance. He was a 
 very tall man, with a rather shambling frame, 
 and shoulders that had a charitable, earthly 
 stoop. The resemblance ended there; other- 
 wise the judge was distinctly handsome, and his 
 manner was so patient that Ted found himself 
 139
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 wondering whether by any chance the judge 
 had some not over-saintly boys of his own. He 
 decided that he was glad to have his case before 
 a judge who wanted to be like Lincoln. 
 
 Hinckley was a lad of twelve, and having told 
 his story and taken it back several times, he 
 now retold it concisely and clearly. Lorraine, 
 sitting at the reporters' table, looked over at Ted 
 anxiously. Harrison conducted the cross-ex- 
 amination; it seemed to her prejudiced mind 
 that his manner was perfunctory. As the boy 
 was about to leave the stand, Ted stopped him 
 a moment. 
 
 "You say that Patsy was lying down when 
 he was shot ?" he asked. 
 
 "Yes, sir, with his arm thrown over his head," 
 answered the boy. "Roy, he stood at his feet 
 and fired." 
 
 " How far was the muzzle of the gun from his 
 head?" 
 
 "Not more than a foot." 
 
 "Oh, it was a gun then; can you tell us what 
 kind of a gun it was ? I mean did it have a long 
 barrel or was it a revolver ?" 
 
 "It was an old shotgun," said the boy, 
 140
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 pleased with the sensation he was making. 
 "We often played with it." 
 
 "Did it belong to Roy?" asked Ted. 
 
 "Why yes, I suppose so; he always had 
 it." 
 
 "Do you remember seeing him load the gun ? 
 What did he load it with and how ?" 
 
 "He had some shot and a paper wad; he 
 loaded it from the muzzle." 
 
 "And tamped it down with a ramrod ?" 
 
 "I don't remember." 
 
 "You would know the gun if you saw it 
 again ?" 
 
 "Oh, yes, sir!" 
 
 "That's all." 
 
 The witnesses brought to the stand on behalf 
 of the prosecution were chiefly those who had 
 testified at the coroner's inquest. Ted expected 
 and found little new in their evidence. The 
 trial had not lasted long before Ted was con- 
 vinced of the determination of the prosecution to 
 convict. Residents of the Riordan neighbor- 
 hood were put on the stand to prove the boys 
 incorrigibles, and they naturally made some 
 impression on the jury. Harrison did his best 
 141
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 in the cross-examination, but it could not be 
 denied that the state had a strong case. To 
 be sure, it rested on the statement of a boy 
 who had shown himself capable of perjury, 
 and was backed up by circumstantial evidence 
 only; but even so, Ted knew that it more than 
 offset the meager amount of direct evidence he 
 could present, were he compelled to put wit- 
 nesses on the stand, a contingency which he 
 hoped to prevent. He felt that success lay in 
 showing that the prosecution had indicted the 
 wrong persons. 
 
 Next to Hinckley's statement, nothing told 
 so heavily against the accused as the statements 
 of several members of the police department 
 concerning the confessions alleged to have been 
 made by Tommy and Jimmy Brown, and the 
 attempt of the prosecution to introduce them as 
 evidence led to a heated discussion. These 
 depositions had been published with sensational 
 headlines at the time of the arrest of the boys, 
 and the prosecution made an herculean effort 
 to have them admitted. 
 
 When Ted cross-examined the official who 
 had sworn that he had received the confessions, 
 142
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 he began by asking, "How long did you have 
 these children in jail before they 'confessed' ?" 
 
 "About three days," the man replied. 
 
 "Had to sweat them several times, and several 
 hours at a time ?" 
 
 "Yes a little." 
 
 "Isn't it a fact that you told Detective Howe 
 that you 'spent three hours over that rickety 
 young one, and were as limp as a rag, but you 
 had it' ?" asked Ted. 
 
 The man colored angrily, but controlled him- 
 self. "Not that I remember," he said inso- 
 lently. 
 
 " Both of the boys told you Roy Collins shot 
 Patsy?" 
 
 "Both of them." 
 
 "Isn't it a fact that the sick boy said he had 
 a musket, a single-barreled musket?" 
 
 "I don't recall exactly." 
 
 "Here is your sworn affidavit, in which one 
 boy makes that statement." 
 
 "Well, he might have," said the detective. 
 
 "But isn't it also a fact that Tommy Brown 
 said Roy had a revolver, a little revolver that 
 belonged to his mother ? Allow me to refresh 
 H3
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 your memory;" hafiding him the typewritten 
 statement. 
 
 "They all agreed oh a gun, an* the shootin'; 
 the particular kind don't cut no ice." 
 
 Ted turned to the jury. "I trust the jury 
 will remember that statement," he said. "If 
 the court please, it seems to me this testimony 
 is entirely incompetent. Here we are told of 
 three kinds of guns used to assassinate this 
 unfortunate child. There isn't a man in this 
 courtroom who owned a gun in his boyhood 
 who couldn't describe it accurately, to the kind 
 of sights, the maker's name and the wood in 
 the stock. Boys have not changed so much in 
 the past quarter of a century as all that. If 
 the prosecution intends to rest its case on a 
 gun that may have been a toy cannon, a blun- 
 derbuss, or a Sharp's rifle, we want to know 
 it." 
 
 "Never you mind about the prosecution," 
 said the district attorney. "We'll attend to 
 that. Your Honor, do I understand the ob- 
 jection to the introduction of these affidavits is 
 overruled ?" 
 
 "Objection sustained," said the judge. 
 144
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 Ted leaned back in his chair for the first 
 time. 
 
 "Mr. Riordan," said the district attorney, 
 "you will be sworn and take the stand." 
 
 The man who shambled forward, held up 
 his hand and then dropped heavily into the 
 chair on the witness-stand, was. of about middle 
 age. His hair was grizzled at the temples, and 
 his face haggard and wretched. He had the 
 instant sympathy of the spectators, and the 
 newspaper people looked at his miserable face, 
 listened to his low, strained voice and began to 
 make copy. The district attorney was a past 
 master in the art of extracting evidence, and 
 under his skilful questioning Mr. Riordan told 
 a story that sent many a hand upon a surrep- 
 titious search for a handkerchief. When the 
 bundle of clothing was placed on the stand, 
 and the torn trousers, faded shirt, and the cap 
 laid on his knee, the man broke down and, 
 hiding his face in his hands, the tears fell upon 
 the pathetic little heap of garments. At that 
 moment the prosecution had it all its own way. 
 
 A sob so hard and dry that it seemed to have 
 wrenched itself free from the very soul of the 
 H5
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 man broke from the father of Roy Collins. 
 He turned this way and that, as if to escape 
 from this torture chamber, but the room was 
 crowded. He sat down again and bent his 
 white face on the shoulder of the little woman 
 beside him, and, reaching his hand across her 
 lap, caught that of his 'boy. She patted the two 
 hands gently and smiled. 
 
 It was an instant's glimpse into the terrible 
 drama of life, but it was a reminder that all 
 the sorrow was not confined to the prosecu- 
 tion's side of the case, nor all the woe endured 
 by one parent. "Like as a father pitieth his 
 children,'" said Lorraine to Walter Davis. 
 
 "I suppose that's Bible," he answered. 
 "Anything later would have been, 'Like as a 
 mother." 1 
 
 Up to this time the prosecution had proved 
 that many of the neighbors did not consider 
 the accused boys beyond suspicion. Ted had 
 tried to show that they were no more mischiev- 
 ous than boys usually, and was prepared to 
 put witnesses on the stand, including teachers 
 and Sunday-school teachers to show that there 
 was nothing about them to justify these senti- 
 146
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 ments, but the value of negative testimony is 
 slight. Hinckley's story had made a profound 
 impression, which had not been destroyed by 
 his subsequent confusion. Mr. Riordan's tes- 
 timony was brief but conclusive. His evident 
 suffering prompted the district attorney to ask 
 no more questions than necessary. He told his 
 story brokenly. Patsy had gone after the cow, 
 as usual. He did not return, and when supper 
 time came he went to look for the child, and 
 found him cold and dead under the tree. There 
 was a shot in the back of his head and some 
 bruises on his body. He had notified the police, 
 and the day of the inquest Willie Hinckley had 
 come forward and told his story. 
 
 As he sat nervously stroking the clothes which 
 he had identified as those worn by Patsy, Ted 
 almost feared for his theory. Either the man 
 was a consummate actor or he was innocent. 
 Possibly remorse might account for this atti- 
 tude. Any attempt to badger the witness 
 would cost Ted's clients dear. 
 
 Ted began his cross-examination very con- 
 siderately. Riordan admitted that the boy and 
 his stepmother did not get on well, and that
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 he was often late to meals, which was a cause 
 of friction. Yes, Patsy had known and played 
 with the Brown boys and Roy. No, he had 
 not objected. Where had they lived before 
 moving to the flats ? 
 
 "If your Honor please," said the district attor- 
 ney, "this has no bearing on the case; I object 
 to the question as irrelevant and immaterial." 
 
 The judge looked at Ted kindly. "I am 
 sure," he said, "that in his anxiety to serve his 
 clients the lawyer for the defense will not waste 
 time. The witness may answer the question." 
 
 Something had come over Riordan. There 
 was an ugly, wolfish look in his eyes. "In 
 Illinois," he snarled. 
 
 "How did you come to leave there ?" 
 
 "I don't know as I have to say," he answered. 
 
 Ted's voice was almost caressing, it was so 
 gentle. " I have here a newspaper that I would 
 like to have marked 'Exhibit D,'" he said; "it 
 contains an interesting account of the white- 
 capping of Peter Riordan by his neighbors, in 
 return for his habitual abuse of his wife and 
 child, Patsy. Have you anything to say, Mr. 
 Riordan?" 
 
 148
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "It's a damned lie," shouted the man; "I 
 might have slapped, but I never beat her." 
 
 "But you were white-capped; you do not 
 deny that ?" 
 
 The man sat in sullen silence. 
 
 "Mrs. Riordan died shortly before you moved 
 to the flats ?" 
 
 "Yes." 
 
 "Isn't it a fact that the insurance company 
 made some objection to paying the policy on 
 her life?" 
 
 "Have I got to answer all these fool ques- 
 tions?" asked Riordan. 
 
 " You will answer the question." The judge's 
 voice was stern. 
 
 "I don't remember," he said. 
 
 "No? Your memory is bad at times; well, 
 if necessary I can prove by members of the 
 company that they did object and demanded 
 an inquest." 
 
 "Yes, and what did it prove?" snapped 
 Riordan. 
 
 "It proved that your abuse of your family 
 was so habitual that all your neighbors knew 
 of it; if I remember rightly the company took 
 149
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 the case into court, and when the money was 
 paid over it was not paid to you, was it ?" 
 
 "It was for Patsy," answered Riordan, con- 
 trolling himself with a mighty effort, while the 
 attorney came to his rescue with an objection 
 which was overruled. 
 
 "Say, the old judge is all right," whispered 
 Davis to Lorraine. "Here's a chance to help 
 Nash get re-elected, and instead of that the old 
 fellow's just a-ladling out justice." 
 
 "Then Patsy was heir to this insurance 
 money?" persisted Ted. 
 
 "Yes." 
 
 "Was his life insured, too ?" 
 
 "Yes." 
 
 "Has that policy been paid yet ?" asked Ted. 
 
 "Not yet," said Riordan. 
 
 Ted gave him a few minutes to recover him- 
 self, asked some inconsequential questions, and 
 then said, "Mr. Riordan, hasn't it seemed 
 strange to you that all these witnesses have 
 described different kinds of guns ?" 
 
 "Yes no; I don't know. It's all seemed 
 strange." 
 
 "Willie Hinckley says that Roy and the 
 150
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 Brown boys and Patsy often shot at the target 
 with Roy's gun; did you ever see them ?" 
 
 "No, sir." 
 
 "Did Patsy ever speak of their having a 
 gun?" 
 
 "Not that I remember; he might." 
 
 The night was darkening down, and the 
 courtroom was in half twilight. The man had 
 stopped caressing the dead boy's clothing, and 
 clutched it with fierce, bony hands. 
 
 "These boys tell of a musket and a shot- 
 gun; do you remember that the inquest said 
 death was caused by a thirty-two caliber ball; 
 how do you account for that ?" 
 
 "I suppose the boys made a mistake. They 
 might." 
 
 "Don't you think that would be a singular 
 mistake ?" 
 
 "Oh, I don't know; all guns are pretty much 
 alike." There was an attempt at jocularity 
 that was ghastly. 
 
 "Did you ever happen to have a gun ?" Ted 
 asked quickly. 
 
 "Yes; I had a revolver once, back in Illinois," 
 said the man.
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "You left it there, I suppose, leaving in a 
 hurry as you did ?" 
 
 "Yes," sullenly. 
 
 "But you could identify it, in spite of its 
 being like thousands of others?" said Ted. 
 
 "Yes," said Riordan, "I could, because it 
 had my initials cut in the handle, and a groove 
 filed in the barrel." 
 
 Ted rose and stepped close to the witness, 
 holding something not plainly visible in the 
 half-light. "Is that it?" he asked. 
 
 At that instant, when the hush was death- 
 like, the bailiff turned on the lights, and the 
 change in the witness' face was too evident 
 and too appalling for any one to doubt its 
 meaning. 
 
 "Take the pistol in your hand," commanded 
 Ted sharply. "Take it in your hand, and tell 
 this jury whether it is a thirty-two caliber, 
 marked P. R., with a groove filed in the barrel; 
 tell them whether it is your revolver, and how 
 you hid it in the tree, where Patsy's dead body 
 was found." 
 
 Riordan looked at it, dumb and fascinated; 
 his staring eyes starting from his head, the beads 
 152
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 of sweat on his white forehead. The weapon 
 fell from his shaking fingers and the light of 
 reason faded slowly from his face. "I didn't 
 go to do it!" he said querulously; "I didn't go 
 to do it." His voice rose to a shriek and he 
 fell forward. 
 
 The scene in the courtroom was indescrib- 
 able. In the midst of the excitement the dis- 
 trict attorney, who was too shrewd a man not 
 to rise to the occasion, stepped to the bar. 
 
 "If your Honor please," he said, and the 
 sound of his voice brought an instant hush, 
 "from the evidence just produced I am con- 
 vinced that these defendants are not guilty of 
 the crime with which they are charged, and I 
 believe it to be the duty of this court to dismiss 
 them. I therefore desire to enter a plea of 
 nolle prosequi, and to file an information against 
 Peter Riordan, and upon my own motion re- 
 quest the court to hold him until I can file 
 additional information against him." 
 
 Then he stepped over and congratulated 
 Ted. 
 
 153
 
 XIX 
 
 ~\HE announcement of the engagement of 
 Hope and Maurice Harrison was a shock 
 to Lorraine, but as she found herself in a hope- 
 less minority she said nothing. Bess and the 
 boys were delighted to have a romance under 
 the same roof, and the Heavenly Twins were 
 mildly pleased. Louis set his under jaw and 
 said little. Louis had never before stood so 
 high in Lorraine's good graces. 
 
 "What's the matter with the man?" asked 
 Miss Brent, when Lorraine took refuge with 
 her. "Isn't he good enough?" 
 
 "Of course he isn't," answered Miss Elise. 
 "Hardly any man is good enough for hardly 
 any woman. Don't expect that." 
 
 "It isn't that," said Lorraine; "besides I 
 don't feel that way about men; I've known lots 
 of them good enough for the best women. If 
 only Louis were a few years older! Any of 
 the Blessed Boys are good enough, but there's 
 something about this man that makes me dis- 
 
 154
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 trust him. He is too suave, too smiling, too 
 apparently sincere, not to be hiding some- 
 thing." 
 
 "Well," said Miss Brent philosophically, "the 
 best of men always remind me of Dooley's 
 description of the Filipinos: 'simple an' 
 kindly be nature, but crool an' bloodthirsty in 
 their instincts.' It's all a lottery, with few 
 prizes and many blanks. When I visit my 
 married friends I'm glad to get back to Elise 
 and Rab; and since we have had the boys up- 
 stairs and you down, I don't know a family I'd 
 change with." 
 
 "Don't go and borrow trouble, Lorry," said 
 Miss Elise kindly. "He has plenty of money, 
 hasn't he ? and he can make her life easier; 
 besides, you might just as well make up your 
 mind to it; your friends will never in this world 
 marry the people they obviously ought to marry. 
 There's nothing on earth so surprising as the 
 matrimonial misfits who think they can't be 
 happy without each other. All the rest of us 
 know they'll never be happy together, but other 
 people's experience never does any good." 
 
 "I know it," admitted Lorraine; "but Hope 
 
 155
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 is so quiet, so intense. She'll never get over it 
 if things go wrong." 
 
 "Didn't you like his novel when she brought 
 it home and read it to you?" asked Miss 
 Brent. 
 
 "Yes, I did," said Lorraine honestly. "It 
 is a beautiful novel, and it keeps reminding me 
 of some one who is as different from him as 
 daylight from darkness. The story doesn't 
 square with him at all. It is full of deep things; 
 sometimes it is almost inspired, and I have 
 listened to him when he has been talking with 
 Ted, or with the girls, and he has never said 
 anything worth remembering. He is shallow; 
 his bright things are borrowed or superficially 
 clever. He doesn't ring true," she finished 
 desperately. 
 
 "It's too bad," admitted Miss Brent; "to 
 tell the truth I can't imagine Hope resolving 
 herself into a mere hatisfrau; she has always 
 complained that she was the three-cornered 
 block in the round hole, but I'm afraid she 
 will find the square hole doesn't fit much 
 better." 
 
 "I suppose when a manuscript is accepted 
 156
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 there's no way of getting it back, is there?" 
 asked Miss Elise. 
 
 "I'm afraid it's already in type," answered 
 Lorraine. "Yet that is one of the things I 
 don't like about him. He wants to keep it a 
 secret. His parents live in Philadelphia, yet 
 he has never suggested that his mother would 
 come up to see Hope." 
 
 "Perhaps she is old or an invalid," said Miss 
 Elise. 
 
 "In that case he might ask Hope to waive 
 conventionality and go to see her," answered 
 Lorraine. 
 
 "Maybe he thinks his people will oppose it," 
 the little sister ventured. 
 
 Miss Brent laughed this to scorn. "I agree 
 with Lorraine on that point," she said. "They 
 ought to be proud to have Hope for a daughter- 
 in-law, and he ought to want to spread the glad 
 tidings to the four quarters of the earth. If I 
 was going to marry a beautiful young man, 
 with real genius, and wit and culture and all 
 that Hope has, I'd send a bellman out to cry 
 'boy lost,' so all the other New York women 
 could realize their loss and die of envy. But 
 157
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 I wouldn't worry over it any more. Just turn 
 your hand to hemming these napkins, and try 
 and find out how she would like to have her 
 silver marked. We don't have to marry him. 
 Besides, some very uncomfortable shoes turn 
 out well and wear a long time."
 
 XX 
 
 "^HE coming of the postman is always a 
 matter of vital interest, but with geniuses 
 it is of supreme importance. Almost any day 
 he may bring a summons to the higher seats in 
 the synagogue, and the really industrious ap- 
 prentice in literature counts upon at least one 
 unhappy return a week. No one but a writer 
 can fully appreciate the sinking of heart pro- 
 duced by a long, thick envelope, or the ecstatic 
 fear that accompanies a short, thin one, with 
 the publisher's name in the corner. Other 
 letters may have their value, but it is the thin, 
 flat letter that causes rejoicing among the 
 writer-folk. 
 
 Yet it was a plain, heavy envelope that made 
 Lorraine exclaim for joy. 
 
 "It's from Mary Deland," she explained 
 delightedly in answer to the questioning looks 
 of the girls. "She is coming to New York - 
 Then consulting the letter, "She is here now! 
 Where are my things ? Lend me your unbrella, 
 159
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 Hope, please. She is stopping at a respectable 
 hotel, and I don't want to be distinguished 
 from the other lions, like Daniel, by my green 
 cotton affair. Don't look for me till you see 
 me!" and she was gone. 
 
 It was a dreary day, the beginning of winter, 
 and the rain was falling disconsolately as if it 
 didn't find cloud-life worth living. Lorraine 
 took the L and hurried away up town. Mary's 
 note had been very brief, and there was nothing 
 to tell whether she had come on a flying visit 
 or for a more protracted stay. 
 
 She was in, however, and Lorraine was 
 shown to her room. After the first excitement 
 of meeting was over the two women stood and 
 looked at each other and exclaimed simultane- 
 ously, "How thin you've grown!" Then they 
 laughed and sat down by the radiator. 
 
 "You begin," said Mary. "What are you 
 doing to make yourself thin ? I understand 
 you are succeeding; why, then, this interesting 
 pallor ? Is it a love affair that is gnawing like 
 a worm i' the bud ?" 
 
 "Yes, it is," admitted Lorraine; "but not 
 mine. I don't have them. My political stuff 
 160
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 is taking fairly well, and while men think, or 
 say they think, women can't understand politics, 
 they all of them prefer that topic to anything 
 more personal when they're conversing with 
 me. That is, if they belong to the class who 
 take an interest in the pool. This may be a 
 crushing admission, but it is the truth." 
 
 "But the love affair," insisted Mary. "Is 
 it one of the Blessed Boys you have written 
 about, or has one of the Twins suddenly fallen 
 a victim after all these years of immunity ?" 
 
 "Worse," said Lorraine. "It's my chum, 
 Hope. It isn't the usual veally affair, either. 
 She's over twenty, and it's a bad case and he's 
 a bad case, and I know she is going to be 
 unhappy, and I can't do anything about it." 
 
 Mary smiled rather sadly. "No, under the 
 circumstances all one can do is to hope that 
 she may prove a false prophet," she said. "If 
 matrimony were an employment it would prob- 
 ably be classed among those labeled 'extra 
 hazardous/ But don't worry. It will do no 
 good." 
 
 "And your trouble?" asked Lorraine; "I 
 hope it is a proxy one too." 
 161
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 Mary's white face grew whiter, and she rose 
 and walked up and down the room a time or 
 so. "No," she said, "my trouble is my own. 
 I never told you, Lorraine, in fact I never 
 told any one in New York, except Uncle Peter. 
 I have lived and worked under my old name, 
 my newspaper name; it is nobody's business. 
 I was married ten years ago; three years after 
 that my little girl was born, and when she was 
 two weeks old my husband left us. Everything 
 had been mortgaged, even the bed she was born 
 in, and when he went away, without one word 
 of explanation, I did the one thing I knew how 
 to do, went to work in a newspaper office. I 
 was very weak still, and the city editor was kind 
 to me; he made me copy-reader. When my hus- 
 band found I had gone to work he swore that 
 I had disgraced him, and he would never speak 
 to me again so long as I earned my living." 
 
 "But how did he expect you to live?" asked 
 Lorraine. 
 
 "I don't know; the mortgage was foreclosed, 
 
 and the home and everything in it went. Then 
 
 I took my baby and lived in lodgings. My 
 
 landlady was very good to me, and let her little 
 
 162
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 girl take care of the baby." She stopped to 
 gather self-control, and then went on: "The 
 child did the best she could, but my little 
 one needed me. Oh, when people blame women 
 for leaving their children and going out to 
 make a living, do they never think of the heart- 
 break of it! Do they never realize that it is 
 a choice between going out and seeing them 
 starve ? That winter poor little May had 
 diphtheria, and when the doctors said she 
 would die I wrote her father; he sent me 
 twenty-five dollars by his attorney. If I had 
 had time I should have begun to hate him 
 then, but I was fightin'g for my baby's life. 
 Inch by inch we drew her back from the very 
 brink of the grave; then the doctors said she 
 must have a change, so I went to the lawyer 
 and asked him what arrangements my husband 
 was willing to make for her. I asked nothing, 
 wanted nothing for myself. For a few months 
 he sent me a little money now and then, noth- 
 ing I could depend upon. My mother came 
 and took May home with her, and I went to 
 work to get the money to pay the debts that 
 had accumulated during her long illness." 
 '63
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "And haven't you seen her since?" asked 
 Lorraine. 
 
 "My baby? Yes, often then; but when the 
 New York chance came I had to give her up. 
 It meant so much, but you can never guess 
 what it was to me to live here those two years 
 and only see her for a few weeks. That was 
 one reason why I went to Chicago when I had 
 the offer; I could see her every week or so. I 
 haven't seen her father since he left us, and 
 I loved him, oh, I loved him so!" 
 
 She seemed to drift far away for a few min- 
 utes, and Lorraine asked, "Do you love him 
 still, in spite of it all ?" 
 
 Mary shook her head. "No; but it seems 
 as if a part of me had died, rather than my 
 feeling for him. I never want to see him again, 
 yet I am here for that purpose." 
 
 "What was the trouble, dear? Why did he 
 go?" asked Lorraine, the tears coming to her 
 eyes. 
 
 "I think he well, he used to take opium 
 sometimes, and he was not always account- 
 able; then he speculated, and lost heavily. He 
 was a queer combination of moods and emo- 
 164
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 tions, and he could be charming when he wished. 
 I think he really felt that I had disgraced him 
 when I went back to the desk. Don't you 
 know there are people who think it more hon- 
 orable to owe bills than to pay them by the 
 sweat of one's brow ? He was like that. Since 
 then he has made some rather good invest- 
 ments, and has quite a little sum of money." 
 
 "Is he here?" asked Lorraine timidly. 
 
 "Yes; he has been here some time. That 
 was another reason why I left a year and more 
 ago; I learned quite accidentally that he had 
 come here. Now he has brought suit for di- 
 vorce. That's what brings me here." 
 
 "You don't mean to say you are going to 
 fight it?" asked Lorraine in amazement. 
 
 "I must, dear," answered Mary. "I am 
 willing enough to let him go, but if the case 
 goes by default I could never compel him to 
 pay a penny of alimony. Don't look so hor- 
 rified, Lorraine. Do you think I am doing 
 this for myself, or that I could ever spend a 
 cent of his for my own needs ? Food bought 
 with his money would choke me; clothes would 
 sting like nettles " 
 
 165
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 She sprung to her feet and clenched her hands. 
 "I won't cry," she half sobbed, "I will not cry." 
 
 "Do, dear," mourned Lorraine; "it will do 
 you good." 
 
 "No," she said, "not yet. Several years ago 
 I had a fearful illness; I had cried myself half 
 blind and the brain fever left some kind of a 
 weakness. Anyhow the doctors told me that 
 tears might cost me my life at almost a min- 
 ute's notice. And some day I shall break down. 
 I must make some provision for little May 
 against that time when she will not have me 
 any longer. And, who knows ? Perhaps she 
 may redeem her father and lead him back to 
 his better self. He used to be so gentle, so 
 lovable. When I am dead I have no right to 
 deprive him of that one chance. He can't help 
 being a better man for being compelled to re- 
 member now and then that he is a father." 
 
 She stopped, exhausted, and threw herself 
 upon the bed. "Don't be afraid," she said, 
 
 "don't be afraid, Lorraine. I shall not cry 
 until May's future is secure." 
 
 But Lorraine, with her arms around her, was 
 crying for two. 
 
 166
 
 XXI 
 
 "*HE Saturday before Christmas was to be a 
 day of jubilation and celebration. The 
 geniuses had arranged quite a program, and 
 Uncle Peter Bright and a few others of the elect 
 had been invited to be present. Louis and 
 Hope were to give the curtain raiser they had 
 been working upon so long, Paul was to furnish 
 the music, and, to Lorraine's great joy, she had 
 been able to prevail upon Mary Deland to give 
 a reading from the advance sheets of her new 
 book, which was to be on the market early in 
 the year. 
 
 There had been a flurry of snow early in 
 the afternoon, just enough to give the proper 
 Christmas atmosphere, and then the weather 
 had cleared, and the night was sparkling and 
 cold. Everybody was in the highest possible 
 spirits. Lorraine was happy because Mary was 
 coming; Bess, because well, just because, 
 sometimes there is no better reason; Hope, be- 
 cause Mr. Harrison, who had seemed rather 
 167
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 shy, had promised to drop in late in the even- 
 ing; and the Heavenly Twins, because all their 
 ducklings seemed likely to eventually turn out 
 swans. 
 
 The big double parlors were festooned with 
 Christmas greens, and the log fire crackled and 
 sparkled. Every one came early, and Ted was 
 patted on the back and congratulated till a less 
 modest youth would have been spoiled; all the 
 garret geniuses rejoiced in his success as whole- 
 heartedly as if it had been their own. There 
 was not in all New York a happier party. 
 
 The play went off admirably, and the play- 
 wright and his leading lady won applause that 
 might well have appealed to and warmed the 
 cockles of the heart of any professional. Then 
 there was a little music, a duet sung by 
 Bess and Teddy, an encore, and then Mary 
 was introduced by Miss Brent and began her 
 story. She had taken a few scenes and ar- 
 ranged them so as to give a plan of the novel, 
 and ended with a climax so strong and dra- 
 matic that it left her hearers breathless, all of 
 them figuratively so, two of them literally. As 
 she proceeded with the reading in her exquisitely 
 168
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 trained voice, Hope and Lorraine exchanged 
 puzzled glances. Before she had finished crim- 
 son spots were burning on Hope's cheeks, and 
 her eyes were flashing with an angry light. 
 Lorraine was as white as a ghost. First she 
 had been startled, then frightened, then the 
 light of a sudden, awful conviction broke upon 
 her confused mind. 
 
 The close of the story, strongly dramatic as 
 it was, held the audience. No one had heard 
 the bell or noticed the advent of Mr. Harrison, 
 who stood by the curtains in the back parlor, 
 as if uncertain whether to go or remain. No 
 one except Hope, who had risen like an aveng- 
 ing Nemesis and was demanding in ringing 
 tones : 
 
 "You say this is from your story, Mrs. 
 Deland, a book already published ?" 
 
 "Yes," said Mary gently and a little sur- 
 prised at the evident hostility of the speaker. 
 "I have just finished all the revises; the book 
 will be on the market by February." 
 
 "And you wrote it when ?" Hope's voice 
 was vibrant with wrath and indignation. 
 
 "In the forests of Michigan years ago," Mary 
 169
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 answered, troubled at the meditated offense of 
 the question; and turning to Lorraine for ex- 
 planation, her glance fell upon the colorless face 
 and rigid form of Maurice Harrison, standing 
 as if turned to stone, and gazing at her with a 
 malignant glare of hatred. 
 
 No one in the room ever forgot that moment. 
 Even Hope followed the eyes of the woman she 
 had risen to denounce, until she also had turned 
 and was facing her lover. Her lover ? This 
 shrinking, cowering creature ? Her lover, whose 
 eyes did not dare meet hers ? 
 
 "Speak!" she cried. "Who is this woman, 
 what is she doing with your story ?" 
 
 The wretched man wet his parched lips and 
 tried to answer; then with something between a 
 snarl and a curse he would have flung himself 
 out of the room, but for Ted's long fingers on 
 his collar, and the iron sinewed right arm that 
 Prince Karl put out to bar his passage. 
 
 "Not yet, my friend," Ted said sternly. 
 "When your affianced wife asks you a question 
 you will do well to answer it, yes, and answer 
 damn quick too," with sudden anger. " An- 
 swer! Do you hear ?" 
 
 170
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 " His affianced wife," said Mary slowly, 
 "his affianced " 
 
 "Yes," said Hope hotly, "and who and what 
 are you ?" 
 
 The older woman looked at her with infinite 
 compassion. "God help us both," she said. 
 *I am his wife." 
 
 "You won't be in ten days," he said impu- 
 dently; but Hope shrank away. 
 
 "It is true then?" she said. "You have 
 asked me to marry you when when you were 
 already married ? And I believed in you, oh, I 
 believed in and trusted you so!" She turned 
 from one to the other piteously, "And the story, 
 did you lie about that too ?" 
 
 All the flush had gone from her face, the light 
 from her eyes. She put out her hands as if 
 groping in the dark for something gone forever. 
 "Lorry," she said faintly, "Lorry!" 
 
 But it was Louis who caught her in his strong, 
 young arms, Louis whose face was as pale as 
 her own. 
 
 171
 
 XXII 
 
 * I V HE holidays were long gone by before 
 Hope emerged from the darkened room 
 where she had been carried that eventful night. 
 Fragile and worn with the anxiety, hard work, 
 and disappointments of the last few years, the 
 girl was in no condition to stand such a shaft 
 from the blue sky of love and hope. Nature 
 always takes her reprisals, sooner or later, and 
 she is a merciless creditor, compounding her 
 interest. 
 
 Worn and hollow-eyed, the girl crept down- 
 stairs one day, for the Twins had taken her 
 into their ampler fold during the days when 
 it seemed as if her life might flicker out. She 
 had never mentioned Harrison's name, and he 
 had never dared Lorraine's wrath, but once 
 he had stopped Bess and asked after the woman 
 he had wronged. Through Ted they knew he 
 had left town immediately after the divorce pro- 
 ceedings. None of them ever saw him again. 
 
 Hope stopped with her hand on the knob. 
 172
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 Miss Brent and Lorraine were talking, and she 
 heard her name. 
 
 "I can't go and leave Hope," Lorraine was 
 saying. "I just can't. I couldn't do my work if 
 I tried. I'd be worrying about her all the time." 
 
 "There's not a bit of use in your staying," 
 Miss Brent answered just as decidedly. "Do be 
 sensible; you can't do a thing for her. Poor 
 child, no one can. You've never been in love, 
 you're too sensible for that, and then you hated 
 him from the very first; and for all you'll never 
 say, ' I told you so,' every time she sees you she's 
 going to be reminded that you did tell her so. 
 You just go to Albany with your horrid old 
 legislators, and leave her to me; it will be better 
 all around." 
 
 Lorraine seemed doubtful. "Do you really 
 think so?" she said. "Is this going to come 
 between us, after all these years when we've 
 gone through so much together?" 
 
 "I know," answered the old lady. "It does 
 seem too bad that a mere man should be able to 
 come between friends, but they do sometimes. 
 Go away, my dear, and let her have a little time 
 to get over it." 
 
 173
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 Hope crept back to her bedroom upstairs, 
 wondering how the getting over it process is 
 accomplished. When Miss Brent came in, she 
 was lying on the couch, so white and still that, 
 but for her wide, tearless eyes, she might have 
 been still forever. 
 
 "How am I going to get over it ?" she asked; 
 and the older woman sat down by her and patted 
 her hand as if she were a little child. 
 
 "I don't think you will 'get over it/ dearie," 
 she said, " but you'll live through it. Yes, you 
 will live through it." There was a touch of 
 bitterness in her voice. "There are troubles 
 one does not live through," she added. 
 
 The girl dropped back on her pillows. ' ' ' Men 
 have died and worms have eaten them.' Oh, 
 don't you see that that is just the worst of it ? 1 
 shall live through it, and through all the long, 
 long years heavy and savorless as unleavened 
 bread. The tortures of the inquisition were 
 kinder than this. One knew that death must 
 come reasonably soon, but there is no such 
 fortune in store for me; I have to go on and 
 on and on till I live through it." 
 
 The elder woman looked out at the gray sky 
 174
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 and flying flakes of snow. "And I love life," 
 she said, half to herself. " Once it took so much 
 to make me happy, and now, as I draw nearer 
 and nearer to its close, I think I could be quite 
 content to sit by the window and watch the 
 snow, the rain, the sunshine, the children in the 
 streets." 
 
 "Science is stupid, blind, futile," Hope said 
 wearily. "Why can't I give you my life ? Why 
 must I live on when all desire of life is past ? 
 I'm so young, so terribly young; 1 may have to 
 live for forty or even fifty years. Miss Brent, 
 do you think one must live, whether she wants 
 to or not, whether life is worth living or not, 
 whether it is one long-continued misery or not ?" 
 
 Miss Brent's face looked gray and drawn in 
 the fading light, and she hesitated. "I think 
 so, my dear," she said at length. " I don't see 
 any way; no, I don't see any other way out 
 of it." 
 
 After she had gone Hope found herself re- 
 membering her last words. "She said it as if 
 she wanted to see some other way," she said to 
 herself. " And she spoke as if she were thinking 
 of some one else. I wonder who she meant ?" 
 
 175
 
 XXIII 
 
 TV/riSS BRENT sat alone in her study. Elise 
 had gone to visit one of their multitudinous 
 cousins, at her sister's earnest request. Her ab- 
 sence was a relief and a sorrow at the same time. 
 
 "What am I going to do?" said Miss Brent 
 to herself, after looking into the fire for an hour. 
 "What am I going to do?" Rab came and 
 laid a troubled nose upon her knee, and Miss 
 Brent patted him on the head. "You're a 
 great comfort, Rabsey, old man," she said, 
 "but even you can't help me now. It's the 
 Valley of the Shadow, and my faithful dog 
 can't bear me company. You must stay and 
 take care of Elise, poor little Elise. She'll need 
 you worse than I; but how am I ever going to 
 tell her ? Rabsey, my dear, I think the chil- 
 dren must help me out. Will you take a note 
 to the top floor?" 
 
 The dog danced appreciatively until she had 
 finished writing, and, taking the note in his 
 intelligent little mouth, fairly flew upstairs. 
 176
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "And I want a girl," continued the old lady. 
 " I don't like to lay my woes on Lorraine, but 
 Hope has more than enough of her own, and 
 Bess wouldn't understand. It's hard lines, but 
 friends are made for adversity." 
 
 Ted followed Rab's scampering feet down- 
 stairs, and the dog was despatched with a sec- 
 ond note, and Lorraine appeared a few seconds 
 later. Neither of them was surprised. The 
 dog-express was an old and honored institution, 
 but when they entered the room something told 
 them that it was a different errand that had 
 brought them there than any of the exigencies of 
 a literary existence, or the whims of a patron saint 
 of aspiring youth. Ted asked almost in the first 
 breath, "What is the matter?" and Lorraine 
 made the same query the moment she entered. 
 
 Miss Brent had herself well in hand. "I 
 want you to draw my will, Theodore," she 
 said, "and Lorraine can act as a witness." 
 
 He drew a breath of relief. "Oh, is that all ? 
 Well, that's a simple matter. Do you want me 
 to actually do it now, or do you want to talk 
 about it, and let me get it up in proper shape 
 on the typewriter, with duplicate copies ?" 
 177
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 She motioned him to a chair at the big table, 
 with its litter of pens, papers, magazines, and 
 books. "Now, please," she said. "I want to 
 have it off my mind; you'll find legal cap in the 
 right-hand drawer and blotters and everything 
 you need." He sat down obediently and un- 
 capped his fountain pen. Lorraine walked to 
 the window, with a sense of bewildered anxiety, 
 and then back to the fire, where she sat down 
 at Miss Brent's feet. 
 
 Ted wrote the date, and then asked, "Do 
 you want to begin in the usual way: I, Emily 
 Brent, being sound in mind and body " 
 
 "Not exactly," she said; "write, I, Emily 
 Brent, being sound in mind " She stopped, 
 and he wrote it down and waited. The pause 
 grew ominous. Lorraine flung her arms about 
 Miss Brent and looked up with something like 
 terror in her eyes. "Sound in mind," repeated 
 the old lady firmly, "but assured that I have 
 but a short time to live " 
 
 Ted dropped the pen, and Lorraine's arms 
 tightened around her. 
 
 "Yes, my dears, I mean it," said Miss Brent. 
 "I've known it for some time, but I couldn't 
 178
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 make up my mind to admit it. The world is 
 so beautiful I can't bear to leave it. I'm 
 I'm afraid I'm a worldly old woman. I've 
 always enjoyed being alive, and I've never fixed 
 my thoughts on the future life. I've been so 
 busy, there's been so much to do, and so many 
 to do for, that I have had no time to think 
 about dying; and now it has come quite sud- 
 denly, and I can't seem to get used to the idea. 
 'Truly the light is sweet, and a pleasant thing 
 it is for the eyes to behold the sun. But if a 
 man live many years and rejoice in them all, 
 it is hard to remember that the dust must 
 return to the earth as it was, and the spirit 
 I can't quite seem to realize it, now that it is 
 almost here - 
 
 Lorraine had hidden her face in Miss Brent's 
 lap and was crying. "But what makes you 
 think it is here?" cried Ted impetuously. 
 "What is the matter ? You are thinner, but - 
 who says it is hopeless ?" 
 
 "It is carcinoma, my dears," she said. "That 
 
 doesn't sound quite so hateful as cancer. It's 
 
 the slow kind. I went to an awful place where 
 
 they profess to burn them out. I was there a 
 
 179
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 year, and it was a year of hell; they claimed 
 that I was cured, and I came home. A few 
 months ago it recurred. I have seen some of 
 the best surgeons there are. They give me six 
 months at the outside, possibly not so much; 
 I pray it may not be so long, and there will be 
 unspeakable pain, though Dr. Powers has prom- 
 ised that it shall not be more than I can bear. 
 Oh, he has been an angel to me! I I think I 
 couldn't stand it, but for his promise that I 
 shall not suffer any more as I have." 
 
 Ted and Lorraine looked at each other de- 
 spairingly. 
 
 "Does your sister know?" he asked. 
 
 "No; she knew before, but she doesn't know 
 it has come back. What's the use of troubling 
 her until I have to ?" 
 
 "But she ought not to be away even for 
 twenty-four hours," objected Lorraine. "She 
 will begrudge every minute away from you. 
 She just lives in you, Miss Emma. Oh, are you 
 sure ? It doesn't seem possible; are you sure ?" 
 
 "Haven't you noticed how I clung to the 
 summer?" she asked. "I went to the park 
 every day, because I hardly expect to see it 
 1 80
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 green again, at least I hope not. Even if I 
 last that long I shall be in too much agony to 
 see anything. Isn't it wicked," she said sharply, 
 "isn't it cruel and wicked to think that just 
 because I am a human being I must be treated 
 with less kindness than a dumb brute ? If it 
 were Rabsey we would put him out of his 
 misery. It isn't just, Lorraine, you know it 
 isn't just, let alone doing as we'd be done by." 
 
 "It's against the law to anticipate death in 
 this state," said Ted, "no matter what a curse 
 life may be." 
 
 "Yes; a foolish law, enacted by a foolish 
 legislature," said Miss Brent curtly. "Pagan 
 peoples are kinder and more humane. I can't 
 understand why a Christian nation, that lives 
 in the belief of immortality and the hope of 
 glory, should expend every possible effort to 
 prolong life when it is an intolerable misery. 
 When life is a burden too great to be borne, 
 when one has done all that can be done, why 
 not end the agony ? Why not be gathered to 
 one's fathers in peace, instead of dragging on 
 from day to day, to go shrieking out, half in- 
 sane with the torture of a hideous disease? 
 1*1
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 The day is going to come when our present 
 system will be looked back to as a species of 
 civilized barbarism." 
 
 Again the quick flash of understanding passed 
 between the young people. 
 
 "Oh, don't say that to Hope!" sobbed Lor- 
 raine. "There is a grief that eats one's heart 
 out as as the cancer does physically. The 
 mind can suffer pain as excruciating as the 
 body. I suppose if we have the right to escape 
 from one we have the right to escape from the 
 other, and I have been so afraid Don't you 
 remember, she said it would be the mental 
 pain from which she should shrink, that night, 
 when " 
 
 "She is young," said Miss Brent; "she doesn't 
 believe it now, but the sun will shine again. 
 It is different with her; breaking the slate does 
 not solve the problem, but for me the sun 
 has set. Why must I grope on in darkness ?" 
 
 "Because we can't spare you yet," answered 
 Lorraine; "and perhaps the doctor can really 
 save you from much of the suffering. He will 
 try." 
 
 "Remember, not one word to the other chil- 
 182
 
 dren; not half a word to Elise," said Miss 
 Brent. 
 
 Ted took up his pen and flung it down again. 
 "I can't do it to-day, Miss Emma; I just 
 can't;" and he buried his face on his arms on 
 the table. Rab whimpered plaintively, and 
 Lorraine caught him in her arms. Down the 
 street a hand organ jangled painfully the notes 
 of the once popular song, "Silver Threads 
 Among the Gold," and Lorraine seemed to 
 follow them and recall the forgotten words up 
 to the line, "Life is passing fast away." 
 
 She raised her face, blotted and tear-stained. 
 "Miss Brent," she said softly, "nobody in the 
 world has ever done for me what you have; 
 but for your help and encouragement and belief 
 we might all of us have given up. Now I will 
 try to be strong for your sake and help you bear 
 it; but, oh, if sometimes I can't be amusing or 
 good company any more, remember that it is 
 because I cannot reconcile myself to letting 
 you go, I can't seem to think of any life worth 
 living without you." 
 
 Miss Brent stroked her hair. "It isn't as if 
 it were for always," she said. 
 183
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "No," said Lorraine quickly; "and even in 
 the Delectable Mountains you will not forget 
 us, toiling up the sheer steeps of the Hill 
 Difficulty. You will not forget us, Miss 
 Emma." 
 
 184
 
 XXIV 
 
 IV/riSS BRENT would not hear of Lorraine's 
 giving up her legislative work, and the 
 night before she left for Albany she had a long 
 talk with Hope. They were alone, and had 
 been silent for some time before Lorraine found 
 courage to say, "Hope, I want to give you 
 just a little, little piece of advice. I'm not 
 heartless, and I'm not cold, and I don't mean to 
 be unkind, but I want to say something that 
 may seem all three." 
 
 Hope braced herself mentally, as we all do 
 when our friends serve notice that they are 
 about to say something for our own good. 
 
 "Do you remember the parable of the woman 
 who had ten pieces of silver, and how, having 
 lost one of them, she lit her candle and swept 
 the whole house until she found it ? Now sup- 
 pose, after all her pains and trouble, when she 
 found what she had thought her tenth piece 
 of silver, it had turned out to be a cleverly 
 executed counterfeit, worthless lead or pewter. 
 185
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 Do you think she would have wasted many 
 tears over it ? Would she not have been glad 
 that she learned the truth herself, instead of 
 having her spurious coin rejected in the market- 
 place ? Wouldn't she have looked on her nine 
 remaining pieces of silver, tested their weight, 
 and tried them one by one to see that each 
 had the true ring, and would she not have 
 rejoiced over the good coin that was left, in- 
 stead of grieving over what was worthless ?" 
 
 Hope's sensitive mouth quivered for an in- 
 stant. "Perhaps she had planned to buy cer- 
 tain things with the tenth coin, things none of 
 the other coins would purchase," she said. 
 
 "That's what I mean exactly," answered 
 Lorraine. "Don't you see she never could have 
 bought anything with it, because it was coun- 
 terfeit ? It was better for her to know it before 
 she went out to buy." 
 
 "Nevertheless, she must go without what it 
 would have bought," said Hope wearily. 
 
 "No, because it wouldn't have bought any- 
 thing," insisted Lorraine. "She thought it 
 would, but it wouldn't. It would have brought 
 her nothing but humiliation and misery. It 
 1 86
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 was counterfeit. The real coin, even of the 
 same date, is in existence, and will buy her all 
 she desires, all she dreamed of. If she had 
 lost the real coin, her loss would have been 
 irretrievable " Lorraine paused a moment; 
 possibly she was remembering, then went on, 
 "But the loss of a counterfeit, something that 
 is nothing, not even the phantom of false morn- 
 ing, that is not a loss; it is a good riddance." 
 
 Hope leaned back in her rocking-chair and 
 closed her eyes. "She had only so many 
 candles," she said, "and she burned one to the 
 candlestick looking for the silver piece " 
 
 "And got dust in her hair sweeping under a 
 lot of furniture that hadn't been moved since 
 the spring cleaning," supplemented Lorraine; 
 "but her hair needed washing anyhow, the 
 house was spotlessly clean, she had nine good 
 pieces of silver left, and as she swept at night 
 she had all the day left for other things. Hope, 
 you have ten talents. One of them is the talent 
 for happiness. You were going to put the 
 others away while you gloated over this one. 
 Now you think you have lost it, but you haven't. 
 You have lost something that gave a promise 
 187
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 of it. Suppose some one wishes to wrong me 
 and make me unhappy, and I put it all out of 
 my mind. He is disarmed. If I brood over it 
 and make myself moody, bitter, and suspicious, 
 he has accomplished his purpose. The poisoned 
 arrow has gone home instead of glancing off." 
 
 "He jests at scars that never felt a wound," 2 
 said Hope a trifle bitterly. 
 
 "Because one refuses to wear his heart upon 
 his sleeve is no sign he has none," answered 
 Lorraine. "It is because I was a fool, such a 
 motley fool once on a time, that I am trying 
 to make you spare yourself. Let me tell you 
 it is no small thing to sacrifice a good com- 
 plexion to an idol with clay feet, and get round- 
 shouldered burning joss-sticks before an altar 
 that hasn't a thing in the world on it save your 
 own imagination. Sometimes I think the French 
 saying that when a woman loves first it is the lover 
 that is all important, and after that she only 
 loves love, is quite as true when it is reversed. 
 A woman, especially a serious, intense woman, 
 is awfully apt to love the great god of Love 
 himself, and hang all his attributes upon a 
 most unworthy representative the first time her 
 188
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 heart is ever engaged. Indeed, it is hardly 
 true to speak of her heart; it may be nothing 
 more than her imagination that is involved. 
 Don't you see, dear?" 
 
 Hope rose, trembling a little, and the women 
 caught each other's hands and stood looking 
 into each other's eyes. 
 
 "You're a real gold piece," said Hope feel- 
 ingly. " I'll go back to work to-morrow." 
 
 "You're another," responded Lorraine; "we'll 
 both go to work, and, Hope, remember I 
 leave Miss Brent in your care. I want you 
 to cultivate her and amuse her, if you can; 
 the boys are so busy, and Ted and Bess so 
 absorbed in each other, I'm afraid she will 
 miss me. You will find her a tower of strength." 
 
 "Is she in trouble, Lorraine?" asked Hope. 
 "I fancied the other day, from something she 
 said, that she was ill and worried." 
 
 Lorraine hesitated. "She'll tell you herself, 
 dear; just be very good to her, and never let 
 Miss Elise notice anything. Now go to bed, 
 like a good child; we must be up early." 
 
 189
 
 XXV 
 
 * I S HE gentle art of minding one's own busi- 
 ness, without losing the ability to know 
 when to rejoice with those that do rejoice and 
 mourn with those who are afflicted, is a rare 
 gift, but the little company gathered together 
 under the roof of the Heavenly Twins possessed 
 it. When Hope crept back into what was left 
 of the charmed circle there was kindness and 
 consideration and a complete ignoring of the 
 unpleasant episode that had wrecked her air- 
 castle and the temporary peace of the household. 
 If one has set his heart upon a pasteboard 
 crown, glittering with tin-foil and brilliants, it 
 doesn't make it any easier for his disillusion- 
 ment to take place on coronation day, before 
 the assembled multitude. To wear a gilded 
 sorrow gracefully, before the curious eyes of the 
 world, makes letting concealment prey like a 
 worm in the bud seem an easy and even agree- 
 able process. 
 
 Pride will do much, but work will do more, 
 190
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 and Hope returned to her labors with a kind 
 of inarticulate fury. She was absorbed, not in 
 her grief, but in a headlong flight from it. 
 Lorraine scolded on her weekly visits; Louis 
 entreated. She did not seem to understand 
 them, and the two who helped her most were 
 Miss Brent, fighting her own grim, always losing 
 battle, and Bess, still so young that she be- 
 lieved "the setting of a great hope is like the 
 setting of the sun," and forgot that the sun has 
 never failed to rise. She assumed charge of their 
 tiny me'nage, and saw that Hope had a good 
 breakfast, and dragged her out to luncheon, 
 and told her the perplexities that beset her, 
 and showed her all her sketches, and saw that 
 she wore her rubbers and took her umbrella. 
 The girl who had been called "the Infant" 
 became the mainstay and did the mothering 
 herself. Hope brought much of her work 
 home, and read to Miss Brent, whose keen 
 criticisms were always amusing and often help- 
 ful. Finding sleep unwilling to knit up the 
 raveled sleave of care, she pulled out her 
 mother's plays and read them and acted scenes 
 for the Twins and Louis. She left not one 
 191
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 single moment open for repining, and Bess 
 began to feel that her efforts were rewarded. 
 
 Ted watched Bess approvingly, yet felt it a 
 duty not to let her sacrifice herself too far, and 
 with that end in view he took her many even- 
 ings for long, apparently cheerless walks up 
 and down the romantic streets of that suburb 
 of Arcadia, New York City. 
 
 While one swallow does not make a summer, 
 one straw will show the direction of the wind, 
 and Ted's success in the Riordan case had 
 brought the young man some business and 
 recognition from quarters where recognition 
 may be figured on as cash capital. More than 
 once he had almost needed a "This is My 
 Busy Day" sign, and his typewriter lived in 
 the hope of an indefinite supply of new ribbons. 
 
 One day he received a call from the Honorable 
 Michael Cahill. Ted had the advantage of his 
 caller in several things beside birth and educa- 
 tion. The Honorable Michael was one of the 
 gentlemen "written up" by Lorraine among the 
 heroes who carry their wards. As it was an 
 article of faith with the geniuses to read each 
 other's published works, Ted knew that his 
 192
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 caller was a Tipperary man, that he had taken 
 out his first papers the day he landed, and 
 offered his services to the Volunteer Fire De- 
 partment the next week, and that he had re- 
 ceived a medal from the city for services rendered 
 in connection therewith. He knew that Michael 
 was one of the few surviving privates of the Civil 
 War, and that the one decoration he prized more 
 highly than his fireman's medal was the small 
 brown Grand Army button. Michael had the 
 reputation of being square. He was not above 
 buying votes that he believed would stay bought, 
 but he kept his promises to his committee-men, 
 remembered the widows and orphans of trusted 
 lieutenants, saw that his ward got its share of 
 political favors, and made a specialty of keeping 
 track of young men who might be useful. He 
 had happened to be in court the day of Ted's 
 victory, and learning that Ted's office was 
 located in his ward and that Ted shared his 
 political predilections his heart warmed to him. 
 He foresaw possibilities in the not too distant 
 political future, and dropping a word here and 
 there he steered some business into Ted's office, 
 and took him some of his own. The promptness 
 193
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 with which it was attended to assured him of 
 what he already guessed, that the young man 
 was not driven to death with the rush of busi- 
 ness. For several reasons this suited him. 
 
 Late one wintry afternoon he dropped into 
 the office, where Ted was typewriting a letter 
 to Lorraine, who had not been able to come 
 down the preceding Sunday. 
 
 "If ye're busy," said Mr. Cahill politely, 
 "111 wait till 'tis finished." 
 
 Ted knew it would be more dignified to pre- 
 tend he was pressed for time, but he also knew 
 that honesty was the only policy likely to win 
 with Michael Cahill, and so he answered 
 frankly, "Your time is worth a whole lot more 
 than mine, Mr. Cahill. What can I do for 
 you?" 
 
 "Have ye kept much track of the legislative 
 proceedin's ?" asked the old man cautiously. 
 
 "Fair," said Ted with equal caution; for in 
 addition to reading the papers, Lorraine had 
 sent him copies of bills in which he was likely to 
 be interested, and he had written considerable 
 legislative gossip in his letter to his home news- 
 paper. Yet he might not even know the num- 
 194
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 ber of the bill in which Mr. Cahill was interested. 
 That there was such a measure he did not doubt. 
 
 "Ye haven't read House bill one hundred and 
 seventy-eight, have ye ?" ventured Mr. Cahill. 
 
 "Lawton's gerrymander, you mean?" asked 
 Ted quickly. 
 
 "The same. If it should pass the Sinit - 
 
 "How did it ever get through the House?" 
 asked Ted. 
 
 "Money," answered Cahill briefly. "We 
 thought 'twas safe; it only passed by wan 
 vote." 
 
 "Well, it's gone to the Sinit," he continued, 
 "and has been referred to th' elictions com- 
 mittay,"- Cahill still put the accent on the first 
 and last syllables of the word, "and what I'm 
 wantin' to know is whether it's like to die there, 
 or be reported out." 
 
 The two men sat and looked at each other in 
 silence. Ted knew the bill well. It was an- 
 other of the many attempts to wrest away 
 some part of the representation of the city of 
 New York and give it to other sections of the 
 state. The merits of the bill were largely 
 according to the point of view. The chairman 
 195
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 of the committee to which the bill had been 
 referred was a country member, from the 
 district in which Ted had been born, and the 
 lad was well acquainted with him. He knew, 
 among other things, that he expected to move 
 to the metropolis when the session was over. 
 It remained to be seen whether the future or 
 his present constituents would guide him in his 
 course in regard to this bill. 
 
 "Ye haven't a stenographer, have ye ?" asked 
 Cahill irrelevantly. 
 
 Ted reddened. "My business hasn't war- 
 ranted it," he said briefly. "If you want any- 
 thing written, I can do it for you.'* 
 
 "It might be betther to have wan," said 
 Cahill reflectively. "Now, if ye should be 
 called out of the office suddenly, it looks bet- 
 ther and more businesslike. I know a handy 
 boy who's taken a course at a business college. 
 He's dead anxious to git into a place where he 
 can study law; the wages manes little to him. 
 He's the son of Danny Martin in the Fift Pre- 
 cint. 'Tis a nice lad that he is. Do ye think 
 ye could thry him, and then if ye was called to 
 Albany ye could leave him in the office." 
 196
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 Ted's brain was working fast. "Why do 
 you want me to go? I'm an unknown man; 
 you must have plenty of people with more 
 experience ?" 
 
 "There's reasons," said the old man. "They 
 mean to push this bill through on the quiet. 
 Nobody knows you yet and nobody'll ever 
 think av putting ye and this bill together. You 
 come from Herkimer county; mayhap ye know 
 Hillis?" 
 
 Ted nodded assent. 
 
 "There's no cryin' need for him to report the 
 bill out if it isn't demanded," said Cahill; "it 
 might be better fer him if he didn't." 
 
 Ted looked embarrassed. "You don't want 
 me to to " 
 
 "No," answered Cahill shortly, "neither to 
 bribe nor blackmail, but to keep thrack of it." 
 
 Ted picked up Lorraine's last letter. "It 
 won't be reported unless there is a demand," he 
 said slowly. 
 
 Cahill jumped. "How d' ye know ?" he asked 
 eagerly. 
 
 "It wouldn't be exactly professional to tell," 
 answered Ted; "but I do know as well as 
 197
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 one can know anything that hasn't happened. 
 Hillis will not send the bill out unless it is de- 
 manded, and if he does it will come under the 
 adverse reports, and have to go over. What 
 we have to look out for is Lawton; he's trying 
 to make a record. Fortunately he has incurred 
 the ill will of several of his own party in the 
 upper house in doing it, and that won't help his 
 bill any if it does come up." 
 
 It is a peculiarity of politicians, shared by 
 several other kinds of people, never to be able 
 to understand how any one in another line of 
 business may yet have some comprehension of 
 their own. Cahill sat looking at Ted, lost in 
 admiration and wonder. He believed him, but 
 he could not account for the knowledge pos- 
 sessed by this country boy, inexperienced in 
 politics. 
 
 "Ye think 'tis not necessary to go to Albany 
 then?" said Mr. Cahill, rising; he wondered, 
 too, that a young man in Ted's position should 
 give up the chance of so pleasant and presuma- 
 bly profitable a trip. 
 
 "Not now," answered Ted. "We could do 
 nothing, for Hillis is no more anxious to have 
 198
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 the bill come up than we are. I can get a wire, 
 and know at least a day sooner than any one else 
 if it is to be reported; that will give us at least 
 three days to act. I'd like to go well enough, 
 but I don't believe in spending a client's money 
 for nothing, or when it isn't necessary." 
 
 "I don't believe it will ever be asked for," 
 said Mr. Cahill. 
 
 Ted hesitated. "I do," he said, "but I may 
 be wrong. I would advise getting a line-up 
 against it, and tying up some of the other fellows 
 who have important bills, so as to have some 
 hold over them, but we ought to be ready for it 
 when it does come. Be sure and have at least 
 six of the most important bills from the House 
 and from his party tied up. And, Mr. Cahill, if 
 you think Mr. Martin's boy would be willing to 
 come here for the pittance I can pay, and take 
 it out in experience and reading law with me, 
 I'd like to have him." 
 
 "Terry'll be here in th' morning," said Mr. 
 Cahill, beaming. 
 
 199
 
 XXVI 
 
 ' I V HE exigencies of politics kept Lorraine in 
 Albany; and persuading her paper that her 
 stuff would be greatly improved by thumb-nail 
 sketches, she had descended upon the basement 
 and taken Bess away with her. The fate of the 
 gerrymander bill called for immediate action, 
 and at the earnest solicitation of Mr. Cahill, Ted 
 also departed for the capital city. 
 
 Before going he had a final interview with 
 Mr. Cahill, who gave him much good advice. 
 
 " Ye may meet Baumgarten," he said. " He's 
 the Rapublican committee-man from this pre- 
 cinct, an' a good fella, barrin' his politics. 
 But this time we have th* same interests and 
 ye can talk to Baumgarten." 
 
 "I'd prefer to have him do the talking," 
 said Ted. 
 
 "'Tis the best way," admitted Mr. Cahill. 
 
 "An' don't be sparin' with telegraph tolls. 
 
 There's ither ways of economizing will be more 
 
 appreciated. If ye need help bad and quick, 
 
 200
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 telephone. There's reasons why we prefer to 
 keep our known men out av this." 
 
 "Are you perfectly sure of Baumgarten?" 
 asked Ted. 
 
 "I am, son; in politics 'tis this way; this is 
 the way it is. 'Tis a wheel; what goes up may 
 stay up a long time, but 'twill come down, and it's 
 this that makes it interestin' the struggle be- 
 tween thim that'd keep it up and thim as is pray- 
 in' and, what's more, pullin' to make it come down. 
 No man that lives in the city of New York can 
 afford to lave go wan ripresentative. We must 
 hold what we've got, 'tis none too much as it 
 is, Rapublican or Democrat. No man has anny 
 business in politics, son, who if he's a Rapubli- 
 can doesn't look forward to carryin' Georgia, 
 and th' ither way about. Have no fears of 
 Baumgarten. Now, is there annything I can 
 do fer ye personally, while ye are away, beside 
 seeing that Terrence is behavin' himself, an' 
 givin' him the father an' mither av a batin' av 
 he doesn't ?" 
 
 Ted hesitated. Then he remembered the 
 coat of arms of the geniuses and their motto, 
 "One for all, all for one," -and caught a 
 201
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 glimpse of the sign that still swung idly and 
 hopelessly across the hall. An epidemic of an 
 unusual form of meningitis was prevalent, and 
 he remembered that the board of health had 
 decided upon a commission of physicians to 
 learn the cause; he remembered also Dr. 
 Silverton's prediction of almost a year ago: 
 "some new bacillus will come to the rescue." 
 Probably Mr. Cahill would not take kindly to 
 a woman physician, but he was not too old to 
 live down a prejudice. 
 
 "Yes; there is one thing," answered Ted. 
 "There's a doctor who is a friend of mine, who 
 has an office across the hall. If you could get 
 her an appointment on this special inquiry the 
 health board has decided on, it would be a real 
 favor." 
 
 Michael Cahill's face darkened. "A woman 
 is ut, did ye say ?" 
 
 "Yes; Dr. Frances Silverton," answered Ted. 
 "She lives in this ward." 
 
 "Tis little difference what ward a woman 
 lives in," said Mr. Cahill stiffly. "But I'll see 
 what can be done." 
 
 His tone was not promising, and Terry, who 
 
 202
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 had been a silent listener, judged that the time 
 had come for him to pay his debts. 
 
 "Is it Dr. Frank you're speaking of, begging 
 your pardon for the question?" he asked. 
 "She's a lady, and a doctor too. She set me 
 dog's leg, and she saved the Murphy baby. 
 She's the best ever." 
 
 "Castlereagh Murphy?" demanded Mr. Ca- 
 hill. 
 
 "Naw, Dennis Murphy; she's wastin' no 
 time on them that's rich. But when the vet. 
 said I'd better kill me dog that the cart run 
 over, she done up his leg like a Christian, and 
 he's a good dog this day. Dennis Murphy 
 swears by her." 
 
 Dennis Murphy was a worker in his precinct, 
 and seventeenth cousin of the aristocratic and 
 wealthy Castlereagh. 
 
 "The young lady'll have the place in the 
 morning," he said to Ted; and having con- 
 sented to be introduced to her, Michael Cahill 
 went off to attend to the appointment and Ted 
 took the next train for Albany. 
 
 Mount Parnassus was fairly deserted, but 
 those who remained drew closer together, and 
 203
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 Hope tried in some measure to brighten the 
 lives of the two women so sorely stricken. 
 Miss Brent rarely left the house now, but one 
 sunny afternoon the early spring tempted her, 
 and she accepted the invitation of some friends 
 and went for a drive, leaving Hope and Elise 
 alone. Miss Brent's secret was no secret to 
 either of them, but so long as it pleased her to 
 cherish the hope that she was deceiving the 
 patient little sister who was suffering hardly 
 less than herself, they respected her wishes and 
 kept up the delusion. 
 
 Left alone, the two women fell into each 
 other's arms and cried together. 
 
 "Is there no hope at all?" asked little Miss 
 Elise. "She won't tell me anything, but she 
 has been to Dr. Powers, the best cancer special- 
 ist in this city. I found his prescriptions. Has 
 she told you anything, or Lorraine ? Don't 
 answer if I am right, and I shall know by your 
 silence." 
 
 The brave, frail little woman looked at her 
 
 with a face that showed the struggle of hope 
 
 and despair, but Hope's tear-stained face gave 
 
 no reassurance, and she went on. "I knew it; 
 
 204
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 I've known it ever since it recurred, but if it 
 makes her happier to think I don't, why she 
 must think so, and we must help her to deceive 
 herself. Do you know how long about how 
 long it will be now?" 
 
 "Not very long," Hope answered; "and we 
 must not be sorry, though she does not suffer 
 so much as I feared she would. It may be 
 several months yet. She has such wonderful 
 vitality, but the doctor did not expect it would 
 have been so long as this. Oh, I ought not to 
 have told you!" as Elise sank down, a miser- 
 able little heap in the old rocking-chair. 
 
 "How am I to go on living!" she said. 
 "How am I to go on without her!" 
 
 "We do go on somehow," answered Hope; 
 "and there is this one comfort for you, it can't 
 be long. There is that blessing about not 
 being young any more." 
 
 They sat together until they heard the sound 
 of wheels, and Rab's joyful bark. In an in- 
 stant Miss Elise jumped up, smiling and alert. 
 
 "Will she see the tears?" she asked anx- 
 iously. "Oh, my dear, you mustn't go out 
 now; she will know you have been crying!" 
 205
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 Hope was busily dabbing rose water on Miss 
 Elise's face. "You go out," she said, "and 
 I'll run upstairs and let you in. Even if she 
 does see that I've been crying it won't hurt, 
 because I'm a blighted being; she will prob- 
 ably scold you for wasting time trying to com- 
 fort me." 
 
 Miss Elise fled up the basement steps and 
 Hope went to the front door, her heart so 
 heavy that it seemed to weigh down the soles 
 of her shoes. 
 
 206
 
 XXVII 
 
 again '" said Miss Brent "never 
 again while I have the breath of life will 
 I waste it advising any one to fall in love, by 
 way of arousing latent talent. Look at Hope." 
 
 "As I remember it, you didn't advise it; that 
 was Lorraine's charming idea," answered her 
 sister; "but then, on the other hand, look at 
 Louis. That last play of his is worth all the 
 rest put together. There's more feeling and 
 power than in anything he has ever done. 
 Making ladders of our dead selves, our broken 
 hearts, and our blasted ambitions may be a 
 hard way to rise in the world, but it's effective. 
 Speaking of angels, there comes the boy now. 
 How pale he is!" 
 
 "That's excitement as well as a broken 
 heart," answered Miss Emma. "I hope he'll 
 come in and tell us about it." 
 
 The turn of the key was followed by a quick 
 tap at the door, which Miss Elise flung hos- 
 pitably open. Louis was distinctly her favor- 
 207
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 ite. "What is it?" she said. "You look as 
 if you had seen a ghost, and it had thrice 
 offered you a kingly crown. You're not going 
 to reject it, I hope." 
 
 The boy subsided into a chair, with a gest- 
 ure of utter despondency. 
 
 "Have they refused it?" said Miss Elise 
 breathlessly. 
 
 "Have they taken it ?" asked Miss Brent. 
 
 "Both," he said. "When I submitted it to 
 Mr. Raymer he said at once that he wanted 
 to star Mrs. Campbell in it, but it should be 
 rewritten in several scenes to suit her. He ar- 
 ranged for me to meet her, and she read the 
 play and professed to be delighted, but wanted 
 at least one more act. Well, I wrote it over 
 twice more before I was satisfied. Then I 
 learned that Mrs. Campbell was to be in 
 Chicago, you know she's been starring all 
 winter, so I wrote and made an appoint- 
 ment, and went on to see her. She was ill. I 
 waited a week; and you know what that 
 means to a lean and hungry pocketbook like 
 mine. Finally she sent me word that any 
 arrangement I made with Mr. Raymer would 
 208
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 be satisfactory to her, and I've just come from 
 an interview with him." 
 
 "Well?" cried both old ladies. 
 
 "Well," with a sigh, "he wants it cut to 
 three acts again, and the leading man given a 
 little more work. The company is to be re- 
 organized. He'll take the play as it is, and 
 have Weston cut it, or he'll allow me to cut it 
 myself; but inasmuch as my whole future is 
 involved, I'd prefer to be my own Shylock. 
 Weston ? Oh, he's a kind of general utility 
 man, a kind of human call-board; I guess they 
 have them in all theaters. It is their business 
 to telescope plays, pull them out or shut them 
 up to the required length. If * Richard the 
 Third' wasn't long enough they'd write an- 
 other act; and if 'Hamlet' could be improved by 
 leaving Hamlet out, out he'd go; and if the 
 rose garden in 'If I Were King' would appeal 
 to the galleries by tethering a spotted calf at 
 the right of the stairway, the spotted calf would 
 go in." 
 
 "If that's the way they do, it's no wonder 
 the managers have a hard time to find plays," 
 sniffed Miss Elise. 
 
 209
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 " I remember well when Mr. Palmer retired," 
 said her sister. "We were all so sorry; it 
 seems to me the stage has never been the same 
 since; he said at the time that he gave it up 
 because he 'found it impossible to secure new 
 and attractive material for his theater/ But 
 don't take it too much to heart if you have 
 to rewrite and revise; all those things are 
 sure signs of genius. Don't you remember 
 Sheridan had to take 'The Rivals' off and cut 
 it square in two ? Let me read you a scrap 
 out of his preface; I think it will encourage 
 you." 
 
 She fumbled around for her spectacles, and 
 pulled down a richly bound, but much worn 
 volume. "Now listen to this," she said, "and 
 if you don't say 'here's richness,' I miss my 
 guess. 
 
 '"In the dramatic line it may happen that 
 both an author and a manager may wish to 
 fill a chasm in the entertainment of the public 
 with a hastiness not altogether culpable. The 
 season was far advanced when I first put the 
 play in Mr. Harris' hands. It was at that 
 time at least double the length of any acting 
 210
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 comedy. I profited by his judgment and ex- 
 perience in the curtailing of it, till I believe 
 his feeling for the vanity of a young author 
 got the better of his desire for correctness and 
 he left many excrescences remaining, because 
 he had assisted in pruning so many more. 
 
 Many other errors there were, which might 
 in part have arisen from my being by no means 
 conversant with plays in general, either in read- 
 ing or at the theater. Yet I own that, in one 
 respect, I did not regret my ignorance, for as 
 my first wish in attempting a play was to 
 avoid every appearance of plagiary I thought 
 I should stand a better chance of effecting this 
 from being in a walk which I had not frequented, 
 and where, consequently, the process of inven- 
 tion was less likely to be interrupted by starts 
 of recollection; for on subjects on which the 
 mind has been much informed, invention is 
 slow of exerting itself. Faded ideas float in the 
 fancy like half-forgotten dreams, and the im- 
 agination in its fullest enjoyments becomes 
 suspicious of its offspring, and doubts whether 
 it has created or adopted/ Now, isn't that 
 some comfort ?" 
 
 211
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 Louis bowed. "I cannot do better than 
 answer by the book,'* he said, with a half 
 laugh. "Here's Bob Acres for you: 'Your 
 words are a grenadier's march to my heart! 
 I believe courage must be catching! I cer- 
 tainly do feel a kind of valor rising as it were, 
 a kind of courage' ; but I'm so tired of 
 all this uncertainty. I can't go on with any- 
 thing else, and I can't cut this play. I've 
 worked over it till what's that he says ? 
 'faded ideas float in the fancy like half-forgotten 
 dreams.' My mind's all hazy with it, if you 
 can understand that." 
 
 Miss Brent looked at Elise and hesitated a 
 minute, until she nodded acquiescence. "Show 
 it to Hope," she said. " Just give it to her 
 and ask her to cut mercilessly. She knows 
 more about plays and players than any- 
 body I know. We'll send Rab down for 
 her." 
 
 Louis turned a shade paler, walked up and 
 down a time or so, and then gave the manu- 
 script to Miss Brent. " I'll leave it with you," 
 he said. "If she will be so kind, I believe now 
 her judgment would be better than mine." 
 212
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 He left the room abruptly, and a few minutes 
 later Rab trotted downstairs with a tiny note. 
 
 "Poor boy," soliloquized Miss Elise, "he's 
 hard hit, but he is bearing it like a man, and 
 maybe things will end right." 
 
 213
 
 XXVIII 
 
 T TOPE came upstairs and listened to Miss 
 Brent's explanation. She took up the 
 beautifully typewritten pages and looked at 
 them absently. 
 
 "You have such good judgment and dra- 
 matic insight, and you have read so many 
 plays," said Miss Brent, "and the poor lad is 
 in such trouble about it. See if you can't 
 make some suggestions." 
 
 "'Sure if I reprehend anything in this world 
 it is the use of my oracular tongue, and a nice 
 derangement of epitaphs,"' answered Hope 
 with an assumption of Mrs. Malaprop that 
 sent both old ladies off into ecstasies; "but it 
 doesn't seem fair for me to pass on other 
 people's work when I'm such a failure my- 
 self, and as Lydia Languish says, 'have come 
 to you with such an appetite for consola- 
 tion/" 
 
 "Poor dear," said Miss Elise. "Stay and 
 have tea with us, and read the play aloud, if 
 214
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 you're not too tired. Maybe we can all help. 
 Will Lorraine be down Saturday?" 
 
 "She doesn't say," answered Hope; "but I 
 hardly think so; she said she had wired Teddy 
 that House bill one hundred and seventy-eight 
 would be reported Monday, and she evidently 
 expects he will come up post haste." 
 
 "What's that?" asked Miss Elise. 
 
 "The bill? I haven't the slightest idea. 
 Lorraine has a natural gift for politics; she can 
 keep track of more bills in her head than I 
 could on both sides of a slate, and she is act- 
 ually interested in it all. I can't seem to see 
 any difference. When we have a Republican 
 mayor the streets are dirty and wet, and when 
 we have a Democratic mayor they are wet and 
 dirty. Whoever is out of power tells how well 
 that party would do if it were in, and whoever 
 is in tells of the vast improvements it has made. 
 I can't see what good legislation is going to do, 
 but to hear Ted and Lorraine when they get 
 together, one would think election day was the 
 earth's axis, upon which turns the fate of na- 
 tions." 
 
 "Sometimes it does turn the fate of nations," 
 215
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 answered Miss Brent gravely. "I remember 
 election day in 1864." 
 
 "Why, was that election anything to be 
 compared with that of 1860?" asked Hope. 
 
 The old lady threw up her hands in mock 
 despair. "What a pity it is," she said dryly, 
 "that American history is not taught in the 
 public schools! You of the younger generation 
 seem to have an idea that Lincoln was always 
 revered as his memory is now. I suppose you 
 think all he had to do in 1864 was to write his 
 letter of acceptance and prepare his second 
 inaugural address. As a matter of fact in 
 August of that year he did not expect to be 
 re-elected. Thurlow Weed told him it was 
 impossible, and I know of nothing finer in 
 history than his statement written at that time, 
 pledging himself, in case of his defeat, to co- 
 operate with the President-elect to save the 
 Union. He sealed it up, and had it indorsed 
 by each member of his Cabinet, and did not 
 tell them its contents until after his election. 
 Do you know that there were people who were 
 proud to be called 'Copperheads' and 'Butter- 
 nuts,' and wore those insignia as emblems of 
 216
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 their opposition to the President ? Do you re- 
 member those banners, Elise, with the words, 
 'The War is a Failure,' and Lincoln pictured 
 as a baboon ? Why, the governor of this very 
 state said that Lincoln couldn't save the Union 
 if he wanted to. Good gracious, child, you 
 may think the election of 1864 unimportant, 
 but they didn't so regard it in the South. 
 Jefferson Davis said the real issue was the con- 
 tinuance or cessation of the war, in which, for 
 once, he entirely agreed with Lincoln. Don't 
 forget that if Washington had his Valley Forge, 
 Lincoln had the draft riots and the peace-at- 
 any-price party at home in addition to the foe 
 in the field. History is pretty much all of it a 
 battle and a march, and most of our heroes 
 have worn the crown of thorns for years be- 
 fore we were willing to give them the laurel 
 wreath." 
 
 "Well, I agree with Hope," said Miss Elise. 
 " I'm glad Lorraine is interested and successful, 
 but I can't see how she and Ted can be so 
 bound up in it, or believe anything one man 
 can do is going to make much difference. I've 
 lived long enough so I don't think the state 
 217
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 or the country is going to the dogs, no matter 
 who is elected." 
 
 "It's you 'don't care' people who may prove 
 the destruction of this nation," said her sister 
 severely. "If I'd had a vote it would always 
 have gone for the Republican party, but I'd 
 a great deal rather people voted the Democratic 
 ticket than that they didn't care enough to 
 vote at all." 
 
 "I'm a mugwump," said Miss Elise. "I'd 
 vote for the best man, and I don't think either 
 party's got all of them." 
 
 "You'd agree with Lorraine then," said Hope. 
 "She says she can't stand the Senate chaplain 
 because he always prays as if he thought the 
 Lord was a Republican. But it's their vital 
 interest that I envy her and Ted. They're 
 completely absorbed in their work, and they 
 look upon politics as a high and lofty calling, 
 instead of a 'pool.' I can't understand it." 
 
 "It is or it ought to be a high and lofty 
 calling," said Miss Brent, "and one man can 
 do much if he wants to; in fact ail history is a 
 record of the accomplishments of the one-man 
 power. Look at the work done right in this 
 218
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 city by men with the courage of their convic- 
 tions. Look at Nast with his lead pencil, at 
 Henry Bergh, at Abraham Lincoln. One man 
 can do almost anything if he sets his mind to 
 it and says, 'This one thing I do." 
 
 "Louis is just as bad in his own line," said 
 Miss Elise. "In politics one must be a good 
 bit of an altruist to be a reformer; but one may 
 have noble aspirations, even when his achieve- 
 ments would redound principally to his own 
 honor. Louis believes that the stage has never 
 begun to occupy the place in our lives which it 
 should. He believes in holding the mirror up 
 to Nature until she changes the pictures she 
 does not like. Besides, it is not Nature that is 
 so ugly, but the artificial part of our lives." 
 
 "Yes," Hope assented. "Don't you see it 
 is this that makes me so discontented ? Lor- 
 raine is satisfied, though she knows her work 
 is absolutely ephemeral; it has its moment and 
 that moment's influence, and then is gone. Ted 
 has learned already something of the power of his 
 profession; Prince Karl is going out into the 
 world armed cap-a-pie; Paul pours his very soul 
 into his music; Bess already dreams of Rome 
 219
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "Of home," corrected Miss Brent in an aside 
 to Elise. 
 
 "And Louis sees his work before him, real, 
 living; and if it struts but a little hour upon 
 the stage, it is nevertheless instinct with life 
 itself. Don't you see how out of tune I am ? 
 Music ? I don't pretend to understand it; I 
 can only love it. Art ? I can admire, that is 
 all. Books ? I do fairly well as a critic, but 
 what an ungracious part, and the more so 
 because when I attempt to write it is as if I 
 had climbed to some lofty peak where I beheld 
 the broad earth as a map before me, and if I 
 could lift up my voice and chant my hymn of 
 praise then and there it might be worth the 
 hearing, but by the time I have descended to 
 the valley the glow and the glory have departed. 
 If I find my ideas at all they are drowned in 
 the inkstand." 
 
 "The real artistic type must always dwell on 
 the heights," said Miss Brent. "Didn't you 
 see 'The Sunken Bell'? That is the lesson; 
 you must be willing to leave the valley and live 
 alone upon the height." 
 
 "Didn't I see it?" cried Hope, her eyes 
 220
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 shining; "do you remember the lines when 
 Rautendelein looks at the tear upon her finger, 
 and how the Nickelmann says: 
 
 'A wondrous gem! 
 
 Within that little globe lies all the pain, 
 And all the joy, the world can ever know. 
 'Tis called a tear!' 
 
 And yet, I think one should always read 
 'Peer Gynt' as an offset to 'The Sunken Bell.' 
 There the lesson is that the great joy of all his 
 life, which he has sought all round the world, 
 is the joy he left upon the mountainside. Oh, 
 I mustn't talk about those things; it only makes 
 things harder! In a few weeks I am going 
 back home to apply for the summer school. If 
 they refuse me, as they probably will, I shall 
 take summer boarders. Maybe they will ap- 
 preciate me." 
 
 "Never," said Miss Brent solemnly. "Don't 
 throw yourself away so; no one on earth but 
 Edith Wharton or Henry James could ever 
 possibly do justice to the delicate subtlety of 
 your waffles. They would be wasted on or- 
 dinary humanity. Come, let's have the play - 
 221
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 'The play's the thing,'" acquiesced Hope, 
 taking the low chair under the drop light, and 
 gathering up the loose pages; "but in the mood 
 Fm in to-night, I think, if I were Louis, ' I had 
 as lief the town crier had spoke my lines." 1 
 Nevertheless, she read it rarely well. 
 
 222
 
 XXIX 
 
 BRENT had heard the hours and the 
 half hours strike as she lay in her big 
 four-poster bed and fought her never-ceasing 
 battle with pain. It was half past twelve, and 
 the fire that always burned in the old-fashioned 
 fireplace had smouldered down to a few brands 
 gleaming dully through the white ashes. Save 
 for this the room was in darkness. The old 
 lady crept painfully out of bed, feeling about for 
 her bedroom slippers, and drew her dressing- 
 gown about her. The room was chilly and she 
 shivered, partly with cold and partly with ex- 
 haustion, as she lit the candle and looked for 
 her medicine. 
 
 "I wish Lorraine were here," she said im- 
 patiently, "or that I hadn't let Elise go. I 
 can't see why Catherine has to take it into her 
 head that Elise is a specific for neuralgia. I 
 don't mean to break down and be sick and 
 keep people trotting up and down waiting on 
 me, but there's no denying that I'm awfully 
 223
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 bad company for myself. I suppose I ought 
 to have a nurse," she rambled on, still search- 
 ing for the medicine among the assortment of 
 cleanly litter that covered her table. " My poor 
 old eyes are not good for much. Why can't 
 things stay where they are put ? Oh, here it is ! " 
 
 She took up the bottle. It was almost empty. 
 "That means I've got to go out into that 
 drafty hall for some more of it. I never had 
 to take so much before, and it hasn't done any 
 more good than water." 
 
 She sat down to rest for a moment as a 
 paroxysm of pain came over her, still clutching 
 the vial in her hands. As the agony of suffer- 
 ing subsided for a moment and she sat huddled 
 over in the chair, too weak to rise, her atten- 
 tion seemed to fix itself upon the bottle in her 
 hands, and slowly the light of a desperate 
 determination dawned upon her face. "Why 
 not?" she said grimly. "It's got to come, 
 sooner or later; God knows it ought to have been 
 sooner than this. The doctor promised me it 
 wouldn't be long, and every day is a year. What 
 use is there in suffering like this ? Nobody will 
 know just a little more than usual " 
 224
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 She stood up and drew her robe about her, 
 and taking up the candle went to the medicine 
 closet midway in the hall. "I don't want to 
 get carbolic acid by mistake," she said, fumbling 
 among the bottles and peering at the labels 
 with her near-sighted eyes. As she stood in 
 the long, dark hall, the dim gas-light near the 
 front door and Egyptian darkness at the other 
 end, her candle making grotesque shadows, she 
 heard a strange sound, half a groan, half a long- 
 drawn sigh, and then the bell in a near-by 
 steeple tolled one. 
 
 "I'm getting nervous," she said. "Oh, it's 
 quite time to be going when one gets to seeing 
 phantoms and hearing ghostly noises what's 
 that?" she said sharply as it came again. 
 She put down the vial and stood listening in- 
 tently. Rab, who had followed her, whined 
 and ran to the bedroom door at the far end 
 of the hall and came back, whimpering and 
 frightened. She caught up her candle and 
 hurried down the dim passageway, but the door 
 was fastened on the inside and her feeble 
 strength was not sufficient to stir it. The 
 sounds which came from within were growing 
 225
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 fainter. With that clearness of mental vision 
 that often accompanies extreme physical debil- 
 ity a dozen ideas flashed through her brain and 
 she remembered that the doorway leading from 
 the hall bedroom to Elise's room, long ago 
 metamorphosed into a closet by hooks and 
 portieres and unused for its original purpose, 
 had never been nailed up; Elise had merely 
 turned the key when she gave up her dressing- 
 room to some unfortunate pensioner years ago. 
 Hurrying back through her own room and that 
 of her sister, she found the key still in the lock 
 and, turning it, wrenched the door open. Hope 
 was lying upon the narrow bed, her long black 
 hair streaming over the pillows and her face 
 concealed beneath the folds of a thick towel. 
 The fumes of chloroform were overpowering. 
 With the energy of terror Miss Brent snatched 
 the towel from the girl's face and threw up the 
 window. She lay white and still, no sound 
 coming from her lips, and if her heart beat at 
 all the poor old lady was too agitated to find 
 the feeble pulse. Painfully she hurried back 
 to the medicine closet and, finding a bottle of 
 brandy, returned to her patient, but her teeth 
 226
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 were set. "What shall I do?" wailed Miss 
 Brent, vainly trying to force the rigid jaws 
 apart. She threw open the door into the hall, 
 determined to call for aid, and the night wind 
 blowing through the open window, her candle 
 flickered and went out. At the same moment 
 she heard a latch-key, the front door opened, 
 and Louis entered. 
 
 "Thank God!" she cried. "Come here. Oh, 
 hurry, or you will be too late!" 
 
 The young man stood bewildered, the hall 
 lamp being too dim for him to see clearly, and 
 then as he distinguished her in the darkness 
 hurried forward, throwing off his hat and over- 
 coat as he did so. As he lit the gas one glance 
 told him the whole story. 
 
 "Leave the door open," he said; "the cold 
 wind blowing on her may revive her." He took 
 the pillow from under her head, and put his 
 hand on her heart. "Have you any brandy ?" 
 he asked. "Let me have it and a spoon." He 
 pried the close-shut teeth apart and poured a 
 little brandy down her throat, then caught up 
 her hands and chafed and beat them, but she 
 showed no sign of life. 
 
 227
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "Is she gone?" whispered Miss Brent. 
 "Can't we send for a doctor?" 
 
 He held a hand-mirror over her face. There 
 was a faint shadow on its bright surface. " We'll 
 save her yet," he said. "There isn't time to 
 go for a doctor, but I must make her breathe." 
 Taking her arms in his firm grasp, he moved 
 them outward and then across her body much 
 as one would to resuscitate the drowned. 
 
 "Bring her into my room," said Miss Brent. 
 "The scent of the chloroform is still sickening 
 here, and maybe the warmth will help - 
 
 A faint sigh came from the pallid lips. 
 "Quick, the brandy." He poured the burning 
 liquid down her throat and she stirred a little 
 as if too weak to resist. "Now I can move 
 her, I think," he said, and gathering her up 
 very tenderly, he carried her into the other 
 room and put her on Miss Brent's bed. He 
 made up a bright fire in the grate and, wheeling 
 Miss Brent's couch before it, made her lie 
 down, for she was exhausted with all the con- 
 flicting emotions of the last hour. "It isn't 
 best to bring her out of it too quickly," he said, 
 after watching beside the patient a little longer. 
 228
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "While she continues to breathe as regularly 
 as she does there is no danger. In fact the 
 only thing I dread is heart failure, and her 
 pulse seems strong, though it is very slow." 
 As she stirred restlessly he drew back into the 
 shadow. "She may sleep; the drug relaxes all 
 the nervous tension, and if she can, so much 
 the better," he went on presently. "I am 
 going to lie down on the couch in the hall 
 where I shall hear even a whisper if you need 
 me, but she is likely to rouse at any time and 
 it will be better for her to find no one but you 
 when she wakens." He turned and took both 
 Miss Brent's hands. "If there is the slightest 
 change, you will call me ?" he entreated. 
 
 "What else would I do ?" the old lady asked 
 reassuringly. "You have saved her life. I 
 never could have managed by myself." 
 
 The girl slept fitfully until morning, but as 
 the gray half light crept through the closed 
 blinds, she struggled slowly back to conscious- 
 ness of the past as well as the present. 
 
 "Why did you bring me back!" she cried; 
 "why did you!" 
 
 "We couldn't spare you yet, Hope," the old 
 229
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 lady said, bending over her, and putting back 
 the loosened hair. "I, who am so near the 
 end of my journey, beg you to stay. Some- 
 thing tells me that life will yet be worth living 
 for you. I do not know why, but we are apt 
 to think that those who have passed to life 
 eternal are wiser than we, with a mysterious 
 second sight. Standing as I do at the very 
 limits of life, where its western horizon is dark 
 with night, I seem to see the dawn come in the 
 east. Life has not been easy for me, but it 
 has been interesting and worth living, and after 
 a while it will be so for you. Think, dear, of 
 the heavy hearts in this house if you had left 
 us so. Lorraine would always have reproached 
 me for not taking better care of you." 
 
 "She made me promise to take care of you," 
 sobbed Hope, "and I did mean to, I did try 
 to be strong, and put myself into my work ; but 
 oh, Miss Emma, you don't know, you don't 
 know the pain that seems eating my very heart 
 out!" 
 
 Miss Brent hesitated a moment. "Yes, I 
 think I know," she said slowly. "I don't say 
 that the pain I bear is worse; perhaps it is not 
 230
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 so bad, but oh, my dear, it is eating into my 
 heart! For months and months it has been 
 creeping nearer and nearer like slow fire. I have 
 prayed that this stout old heart of mine might 
 fail and let me escape some portion of the long- 
 drawn agony, but it does not lose a beat, and 
 every day I wonder whether it is possible for 
 me to endure another twenty-four hours. Prom- 
 ise me, Hope, that you will be brave, or I 
 must write Lorraine." 
 
 "Don't tell her," said the girl. "She could 
 not understand, for all she talked as if it might 
 be right that evening so long ago. I knew she 
 didn't really mean it." 
 
 "No one shall know," answered Miss Brent; 
 "and some time you will be glad you did not 
 succeed, though that may not seem possible 
 now. Oh, my dear, my dear! The mortal pain 
 that body and soul can bear before they part 
 company. We know it, you and I. Help me 
 to bear these last few months, Hope, for I 
 cannot bear them alone." 
 
 231
 
 XXX 
 
 \X7TIETHER or not Hope's suggestions met 
 Louis' approbation, they suited Mr. Ray- 
 mer, and the much revised play was put on for 
 rehearsal. With it was to be played the curtain 
 raiser already familiar to the geniuses. It had 
 been the play that Saturday night, the last 
 Saturday they had ever celebrated, and it was 
 the first bit of his dramatic work that Louis had 
 ever shown to Hope. It was a slight thing, 
 depending wholly upon the art of the player for 
 its success; but since the play had been cut to 
 three acts again, something else was needed to 
 round out the evening. 
 
 Now, the actress who was to take the leading 
 part had sprained her ankle and could not 
 appear; there were but two days to find a 
 substitute and the understudy was terribly 
 wooden. After fifteen minutes, Mr. Raymer 
 called the rehearsal to an end. 
 
 "She is impossibly execrable in the part," he 
 said. "You must see, my dear Lassalle, that 
 232
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 it is better to give it up than to take chances 
 of spoiling the play itself, and losing you a 
 success by prejudicing people beforehand." f 
 
 "But the play isn't long enough. It won't 
 fill an evening," objected Louis. 
 
 " Perhaps you know some one who can take 
 this part on ten minutes' notice." Mr. Raymer 
 was coldly sarcastic. 
 
 Louis' heart gave a leap and stopped. "Yes, 
 I do," he said. 
 
 Mr. Raymer almost jumped. "Where is she 
 playing? Can we get her?" he asked. 
 
 "She isn't an actress," Louis answered, 
 something of the other's excitement communi- 
 cating itself to him, "but she has played this 
 and knows every syllable of it, and does it 
 better than Miss Trevyllyn ever has. Oh, if 
 she would do it; if she only would!" 
 
 "Go, get her," answered the manager 
 brusquely. "We'll wait; take a cab and hurry. 
 Who is she?" 
 
 Louis' mind was working fast. "Mr. Ray- 
 mer," he said, "I'll go for her on one con- 
 dition. She doesn't know that you have taken 
 this play or ever heard of it. If I tell her 
 233
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 the truth it will frighten her and she will think 
 she can't do it. If I tell her you have given 
 me this chance to present the play to you, 
 she won't think of herself at all and can do 
 her best." 
 
 "And if she fails, as she probably will," Mr. 
 Raymer said to himself, "it will let me out of 
 a scene. Well, go on. Clyde can read his 
 lines as if he'd never seen the part before. Go 
 get her. What did you say she was ?" 
 
 "She is a reader for one of the big publish- 
 ing houses; her name is Hope Lloyd. I'll be 
 as quick as I can;" and he was off. 
 
 Hope hardly understood the nature of her 
 errand until they were in the cab. Then the 
 one point clear to her mind was that a great 
 manager might take Louis' play if he were 
 favorably impressed with it. She knew too 
 little of theaters and the ways of managers to 
 see how improbable this was, and, taking her 
 part, began going over it once more to refresh 
 her mind. Alas, there was no need! Every 
 incident connected with that Saturday night 
 was indelibly fixed upon her memory. But 
 now the words took on a new meaning, and 
 234
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 grew instinct with a feeling unknown before. 
 As they entered the great, gloomy theater that 
 soft spring day, she was living over again that 
 night in December. She acknowledged the in- 
 troductions rather dully, and with a lack of 
 comprehension that argued ill for her. Mr. 
 Raymer would hardly think with much favor 
 of a mere amateur who could appear in his 
 presence with so little embarrassment. Mr. 
 Clyde, the leading man, shared in the feeling 
 of wonderment, not unmixed with disdain, but 
 obediently sat at one side of the dark stage, 
 with his lines in his hand, and without further 
 preliminaries the little play began. 
 
 "If you can't sing," said Mr. Raymer, "never 
 mind about that on your second entrance." 
 
 Hope looked a little puzzled, but answered 
 quite innocently, "Oh, enough for that; will you 
 play the accompaniment we are used to, Louis ?" 
 And as he seated himself at the piano she left 
 the stage, until her cue came. The scene with 
 
 o * 
 
 the actor lover was played with much restraint. 
 Mr. Raymer, watching like a hawk, said in a 
 quick aside to Louis, "Is she really so frozen, 
 or does she assume it ?" 
 235
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "It is her conception of the part," Louis 
 answered; "you'll see in a moment." 
 
 The star asks insolently, hardly looking at 
 the young woman who stands before him ask- 
 ing for a chance to join his company, "Can 
 you act? Have you any experience?" and the 
 young woman proposes the little scene, portray- 
 ing the return of the discarded girl, to which 
 he gives a languid assent. In an instant the 
 restraint vanished, the iceberg thawed. For 
 her second entrance she came dancing on the 
 stage singing in her blithe young voice that 
 inimitable little chanson that seems fairly bub- 
 bling over with gladness: 
 
 "Dites moi, ma jeune belle, 
 Ou voulez-vous aller ?' ' 
 
 There was a little rush to the supposed 
 cradle, and then the gay preparations for the 
 return of Francois after a month's absence, 
 interspersed with apostrophes to the baby, and 
 fragments of the sparkling song. Then came 
 the discovery of the letter. The song stopped 
 in the middle of a bar with a sudden minor 
 discord. Unbelievingly she tries to decipher the 
 236
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 letter by the failing light ; so far it is disappoint- 
 ment alone. She approaches the table, the 
 little table set for two, and half mechanically 
 goes through the form of lighting a candle, 
 and stoops to read the sheet of paper in her 
 hand by its rays. There can no longer be any 
 doubt; the paper flutters to the floor, and with 
 a strange, white face in which the horror grows 
 she stands facing straight front. Then as if 
 all life and strength and hope had left her she 
 sank to the floor. It was not the usual heavy 
 fall, but rather as if every bone in her body 
 were broken with the blow that has come upon 
 her. So she lay, a disconsolate little heap, 
 while the player forgot his lines and the man- 
 ager stared at Louis, who stood stricken with 
 the knowledge that for his sake she had lived 
 anew her own tragedy, smitten with the recol- 
 lection of her words, "She is living, playing, if 
 you like, her own life." 
 
 Mr. Raymer recovered himself first, and gave 
 the cue to Clyde, and in a moment it was all 
 over, and Hope was listening to words she 
 hardly understood. 
 
 "A reader, a critic, you!" he was saying. 
 
 237
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "Any fool can read and write and cavil. You 
 were born to act, to live, to feel, not to mull 
 over a typewriter, telling other people how to 
 do things. Where have you studied acting ? 
 Why hasn't your idiot of a teacher put you on 
 before?" 
 
 And still she stood, absolutely inarticulate. 
 
 "Lassalle, my boy," he cried, "she doesn't 
 believe it; she looks as if she would say, 
 'WTiat fire is in mine ears?' Are you quite 
 dumb ?" 
 
 "Oh, do you mean it ?" she said, coming back 
 from a personal pain almost beyond belief to 
 a personal joy far beyond expression. "I never 
 thought of the acting; Louis said if you liked 
 the play Oh, you are not you could not 
 say it unless you were in earnest, could you ? 
 I have longed all my life to act and never 
 dreamed I could." 
 
 "And why?" asked Mr. Raymer, half irrita- 
 bly; "are real actresses so numerous that 
 you need hesitate ? With whom have you 
 studied ?" 
 
 A softer light came into her eyes. "With 
 my mother," she said. "She taught me to love 
 238
 
 UNDER THE .HARROW 
 
 Shakespeare and Sheridan and many of the old 
 writers and plays that are forgotten now. She 
 taught me to use my voice so as to make it 
 carry, and made me learn whole acts by heart. 
 If she had lived she meant to have given me a 
 chance, but she died when I was sixteen and 
 there were the other children, so I gave it up, 
 and now I am twenty-two. Isn't that too 
 old to begin ? Oh, don't let me hope, unless 
 you know I can make the old dreams come 
 true!" She put back a refractory lock of 
 hair, with a little gesture familiar to her 
 friends. 
 
 "Any good thing can come to Rose Farron's 
 daughter," he said, taking her hands gently. 
 "I beg your pardon for not knowing you at 
 once; why didn't you brush back that stray love- 
 lock before ? I see now how very like her you 
 are. Now try and understand this; you have 
 much yet to learn, but I offer you a place in my 
 company to take this part as nearly as you have 
 done it this afternoon as possible, and you can 
 trust me to give you all the chance you need. 
 If you will work as I believe you will, you are 
 certain to make a name; I believe you may be 
 239
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 a great actress, but it will mean harder work 
 than you have ever done in your life." 
 
 It was Hope's Mount of Transfiguration, 
 but Louis was even happier than she. 
 
 "I must go and wire Lorraine!" she said. 
 
 240
 
 XXXI 
 
 "*HE Legislature completed its labors and 
 adjourned sine die, and the gerrymander 
 bill died with it, though there was a sharp fight, 
 during which Ted took his first lesson in the 
 great American system of circumlocution, or 
 how not to get things done. Michael Cahill 
 had come up to be in at the death, and he and 
 Ted took the late, or early, train home. 
 
 "Ye have done well," said Cahill. "M'anin' 
 no reflection on ye, I think ye have the makin' 
 av a legislator in ye. Ye are honest, but ye are 
 not foolish. Ye do not take it for granted that 
 a stove will not be stolen because it is hot. 
 When a man goes into a place where there's a 
 large number of ither men, it makes no differ- 
 ence if it is a penitentiary or a Sunday-school 
 convention, he should always raymimber there's 
 some there that is not what they seem to be." 
 
 Lorraine and Bess followed the next day by 
 boat, glad and sorry it was over, and enjoying 
 the peaceful beauty of the Hudson after the 
 241
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 rush and confusion and wrangles of the As- 
 sembly. As Bess sat on a low camp-stool, her 
 arm on Lorraine's knee, she looked up after a 
 long interval of silence with an expression of 
 hesitation on her lovely face. 
 
 "Tell me about it," responded Lorraine; and 
 for answer she held her left hand up, with Ted's 
 ring shining upon it. "Really?" said Lorraine, 
 an amused look creeping into her face. 
 
 But for the absurdity of it, one would have 
 said the girl's face was anxious. "Don't you 
 mind, Lorraine, honestly now, don't you mind ?" 
 asked Bess. 
 
 Lorraine kissed her. "I am honestly de- 
 lighted," she replied. "I'm not going to say 
 'this is so sudden,' because not being blind, 
 I've seen it coming for a long time. Ted is a 
 dear; this is one of the few cases where it will 
 be correct to congratulate both bride and groom, 
 for indeed, Bess, he is one in ten thousand." 
 
 " But but," faltered Bess, " I thought you 
 didn't approve of getting married and and 
 giving up one's career. Or, perhaps, you did 
 not believe I had any career?" She looked up 
 wistfully. 
 
 242
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "What a little imitation of an idiot you 
 can be," said Lorraine cheerfully. "Of course 
 I believe you might have had a career, and I 
 hope you will not entirely forget how to hold a 
 pencil, or that blue and yellow make green, or 
 devote all your artistic ability to making paper 
 dolls; but what you give up isn't worth half or 
 a tenth of what you will gain. Well, go on and 
 say it." 
 
 The girl hesitated. "Isn't it funny, Lor- 
 raine ?" she said finally. "But I really thought 
 you would despise me for capitulating so easily. 
 You and Miss Brent always talk as if there were 
 no use in getting married so long as one can do 
 anything else." 
 
 "Well, is there?" said Lorraine. "Just so 
 long as there is anything else that one would 
 rather do, under any circumstances, she has no 
 business to get married. That's what we mean. 
 But don't you think marriage is something of a 
 career ? You will find that art is simple and 
 success easy compared to being a good wife and 
 a perfect mother. Isn't it strange, my dear, 
 that we think only a few so talented that they 
 may be entitled to work in clay or marble, and 
 243
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 treat lightly, sometimes almost profanely, the 
 unspeakable gift of molding human clay into 
 flesh and blood, heart and mind and soul ? To 
 my mind, being a mother calls for more genius 
 than anything else in the world, and for more 
 whole-hearted consecration." 
 
 "But you were so happy over Hope's rinding 
 herself," said Bess, still half unconvinced. 
 
 "Oh, yes, more than happy, but don't you see ? 
 Hope is an exemplification of the hard saying, 
 that 'he who loseth his life shall find it.' And 
 there is this to be said for a career, especially 
 such a one as hers promises to be. Work is like 
 charity, or love, if you prefer the revised version, 
 as you doubtless do. 'Whether there be proph- 
 ecies, they shall fail; whether there be tongues, 
 they shall cease; whether there be knowledge, 
 it shall vanish away,' but work suffereth long 
 and is kind; we may fling it aside and forget it, 
 but it awaits our return, ready to supply an 
 interest when all other interests have fled; it 
 ministers to a mind diseased and, together with 
 time, can pluck a rooted sorrow from the brain. 
 Love may fail, youth will pass, but if one does 
 the thing he loves to do he has one unfailing 
 244
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 source of joy. That is the reason why I am so 
 thankful for Hope; she has found, you would 
 not believe it if I said 'the joy of living,' but the 
 greatest blessing of life. Even death, that robs 
 us of all else in time, cannot rob of this, our con- 
 solation and relief. I am trying hard to realize 
 this now, when the shadow of death is upon 
 our home." 
 
 "You mean Miss Brent ?" said Bess. 
 
 "Yes; she thinks she has kept it from us all, 
 but we are the deceivers ourselves, and since it 
 makes her happier to keep up the innocent 
 pretense we must not appear to notice any 
 change, though Hope writes me she has broken 
 very much the last two weeks since we have seen 
 her. Tell her the funny things, show her some 
 of your caricatures and amuse her if you can." 
 
 " It seems heartless," said the girl. 
 
 "No, I don't think so," answered the older 
 woman. "She is going not to suffer any 
 more. We ought to look on death as a resur- 
 rection, not a burial. It is 'with the morn those 
 angel faces smile.' I know this and I say it 
 over and over, and for her I can be sincerely 
 thankful, but oh Bess, when I think of poor 
 245
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 Miss Elise, and of going on without that cour- 
 ageous, helpful spirit, I am ready enough to 
 admit that words are useless! I want you and 
 Ted to go to them and ask their blessing; surely 
 they have been our guardian angels ever since 
 dear old Uncle Peter sent Miss Emma to us; 
 and then talk over your housekeeping arrange- 
 ments with Miss Elise. It will do her good to 
 feel that we still need and depend upon her and 
 love her very much. You have no idea what a 
 fine, strong, brave little soul she is, and we must 
 do all we can to help her now. I didn't mean 
 to sadden you with this to-day, when you are so 
 happy, and I am so happy for you " 
 
 "Don't speak as if I were a child," said Bess, 
 "or as if my heart were so narrow that one 
 love must crowd out all others. I am glad you 
 have told me. We are almost home, Lorraine! 
 Doesn't it seem good to be home ! " 
 
 246
 
 XXXII 
 
 you think Miss Emma would like 
 to have a quiet little gathering next 
 Saturday night, Miss Elise?" asked Hope. 
 "Would it be too much for her, or would she 
 be pleased ?" 
 
 Miss Elise looked up quickly. They had 
 not foregathered in one of the old-fashioned 
 Saturday nights since Hope's trouble had come 
 upon her. " I think Emmy would like it of all 
 things; she has been lamenting our dulness, but 
 couldn't we have it Sunday night instead ?" 
 replied thoughtful little Elise. 
 
 "Sunday will be the best for Prince Karl," 
 answered Hope. "He is studying so hard I 
 doubt if we could get him any other day, and 
 a week from Monday is the day of days for 
 Louis and me. Can I help Gretchen about 
 anything?" 
 
 "You are rather busy yourself, aren't you ?" 
 said Miss Elise; "but if you can come in Sunday 
 morning or afternoon and make the sandwiches 
 247
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 I shall be glad to have you, and be sure and 
 tell the children that they are to come just as 
 usual, and talk and be merry. They can be 
 as attentive as they like, but they mustn't ask 
 Emmy how she is feeling, or so much as look 
 sympathetic. She is so morbid over being ill, 
 and so afraid of being a damper, that nothing 
 you can do will please her so much as for you 
 just to be liie your old selves." 
 
 "We'll try," said Hope obediently; "and if 
 any of us seem inclined to be tearful, just give 
 us a look and we'll remember. Oh, Miss Elise, 
 when I think how bravely you have played your 
 part all through, I fear I shall never be half so 
 good an actress as you!" 
 
 The young folks gathered early that Sunday 
 evening, conscious that there had been many 
 changes since they separated, and that greater 
 changes were not far from them, for the slopes 
 of Mount Parnassus were to be depopulated. 
 Immediately after his graduation Prince Karl 
 was to start for South Africa; Bess and Ted 
 were to be married and spend the summer 
 with his people on the Herkimer county farm. 
 Mary Deland was going abroad, her book 
 248
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 having been one of those rare instantaneous 
 successes that bring wealth and fame at the 
 same time, and she had asked Lorraine to go 
 with her. As before, Lorraine had refused. 
 "I can't leave them now; later I will come and 
 bring Miss Elise with me," she had promised; 
 and Mary had already sailed. As for Miss 
 Brent it was evident that her feet were already 
 set upon the shadowy pathway that leads down 
 into the valley. For a little time there was a 
 feeling of constraint, then Lorraine came to 
 the rescue and, improvising a gavel, she ham- 
 mered on the table. 
 
 "The joint assembly will be in order," she 
 commanded, "that we may listen to the gov- 
 ernor's address. Your Excellency has the 
 floor;" and she turned and bowed to Miss 
 Brent. 
 
 The old lady rose. She was feeble, but her 
 face had kept its cheeriness, in spite of the lines 
 that pain had graved upon it. 
 
 "I want your help and advice," she said, 
 "upon a plan that has long been in my mind; 
 it is not very well outlined, but I think Lor- 
 raine can explain it, and I want you all to feel 
 249
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 free to offer suggestions, because but for you 
 all of you it would never have entered 
 my mind. You tell about it, Lorraine." 
 
 It was evidently an effort for her to remain 
 standing or to talk, and Lorraine had to 
 struggle with a cough and a lump in her throat 
 before she could go on. Finally she resumed, 
 as lightly as she could: "As we all know, we 
 are in the presence of two of the most devoted 
 of the patrons of the arts and sciences, and more 
 especially of those neophytes thereof who are 
 floundering around, lost in the swamps of toil, 
 with never a helping hand to haul them out 
 and set them on the hard, well-trodden path 
 that leads to a loaf of bread. They believe, 
 these Heavenly Twins of ours, that the best 
 way to help people is to help them to help 
 themselves. In fact it is the only way. We 
 none of us believe much in charity as it usually 
 is exercised." 
 
 "Tell 'em that thing Roosevelt said about 
 charity," interrupted Miss Brent. 
 
 "Oh, yes; I'm glad you reminded me! 
 He says, 'The soup-kitchen style of philan- 
 thropy is worse than useless, for in philan- 
 250
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 thropy, as everywhere else in life, almost as 
 much harm is done by soft-headedness as by 
 hard-heartedness.' ' 
 
 "Hear, hear!" cried Ted; and there was a 
 ripple of applause. 
 
 "In short," continued Lorraine, "the Heav- 
 enly Twins wish to found a Genius Fund; 
 something along the plan of scholarships, ex- 
 cept that it is to be a loan fund to be repaid 
 by the genius when he arrives. Any young 
 person who can show more than ordinary 
 ability in any of the fields of art or science, and 
 satisfy the trustees that he is a worthy follower 
 thereof, is to be allowed to draw on the fund 
 to a certain amount, giving his promise to repay 
 the money advanced to him during the lean 
 years of study and preparation, when the fat 
 years come." 
 
 "Is there to be no security ?" asked Ted. 
 
 "None save the honor and good faith of the 
 young people asking assistance," answered Miss 
 Brent. "We must believe that there is no 
 higher security than the youth and the youth- 
 ful ideals of a nation, or rank ourselves among 
 the most pessimistic of pessimists." 
 251
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "The trust will not be abused if we have the 
 right kind of a board of trustees," said Lor- 
 raine, "but that is almost as important as the 
 fund itself. They must be people who will 
 carry out the spirit as well as the letter of the 
 trust, and that is one of the things about which 
 the founders wish to consult you." 
 
 "You are going to find one trouble to begin 
 with," said Louis. "If you get professional 
 people on the board they are all going to say 
 the same thing, with variations according to 
 species. Don't act, don't sing, don't write, 
 don't study law or medicine, don't paint, or 
 try to let the angel out of the marble with your 
 chisel. If you haven't two or three degrees 
 and half the alphabet after your name, you 
 cannot cope with the English language. If you 
 haven't studied abroad don't attempt to sing 
 for the American public that fancies itself 
 musical because it whistles 'Bedelia.' You 
 may be a second Jenny Lind; it makes no dif- 
 ference, the Door of Don't will be slammed in 
 your face just the same." 
 
 "That's true," said Lorraine, "with certain 
 shining exceptions. I have long understood 
 252
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 that no one should go on the stage who is not 
 at least five feet five inches tall; this would 
 let Hope scrape through, but it would bar out 
 about the most successful American actress we 
 own. Mrs. Fiske is a genius, but her best 
 friend wouldn't claim that she is tall only 
 about as tall as Rachel, at least." 
 
 "And you can't get into the army unless you 
 are half a head taller than Napoleon," said 
 Prince Karl disgustedly. "I hope the Japs 
 have taught the world a thing or two in that 
 regard. I missed my physical examination for 
 West Point by four pounds. You have only 
 to look at the average policeman to know 
 that in this country valor and fat are synony- 
 mous." 
 
 Miss Brent laughed. "There's a lot in that," 
 she said. "We are a great people, we Ameri- 
 cans, but we are young yet. We won't go into 
 the international copyright agreement because 
 we want to pirate foreign books, and we won't 
 put art on the free list because it is an infant 
 industry, though we have no welcome for our 
 infant artists until they come sailing up to Ellis 
 Island. Hand me that book over there, Elise." 
 253
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 She adjusted her glasses, found her place, and 
 looking up said, "Just let me read you this; 
 Mrs. Ward says, not Mrs. Humphry, but she 
 as was a Phelps: 'Make shoes, weed cabbages, 
 survey land, keep house, make ice cream, sell 
 cake, climb a telephone pole, be a lightning- 
 rod pedler or a book agent before you set 
 your heart upon it that you shall write for a 
 living. . . . Unless you are prepared to work 
 like a slave at his galley, for the toss-up chance 
 at a freedom which may be denied him when 
 his work is done, do not write. There are 
 some pleasant things about this way of spend- 
 ing a lifetime, but there are no easy ones. 
 There are privileges in it, but there are heart- 
 ache, mortification, discouragement, and eternal 
 doubt. Had one not better have made bread 
 or picture frames, run a motor, or invented a 
 bicycle tire ?' ' 
 
 "That's all very fine," said Bess, "but if 
 she'd tried making ice cream or selling cake 
 she might have learned that those pleasant 
 callings have their drawbacks also; there has 
 always been an eternal doubt about my loaf- 
 cake. My favorite of all her heroines confesses 
 254
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 to making very sour bread, but she paints real 
 pictures, nevertheless." 
 
 "As for the joys of being a book agent, and 
 finding signs in all the big buildings to warn 
 you to keep out and dogs loose in all the small 
 yards for the same benevolent purpose," said 
 Lorraine, "while I may never amass wealth by 
 writing books, I'll enjoy it more and probably 
 make quite as much as I would selling them 
 for other people. However, I can almost for- 
 give her the rest of the paragraph, because she 
 says 'had better' in the last sentence. That 
 from a Bostonian does my heart good, even if 
 I am convinced one hadn't better." 
 
 There was a general laugh, and Prince Karl 
 rejoined: "That's the way with the average of 
 the artistic and professional crowd. Never hav- 
 ing done anything with their hands, they think 
 everybody else had better stick to manual 
 labor; that is the easy road to a competence. 
 You must all have noticed the large number of 
 successful blacksmiths who live in their vine- 
 clad cottages in the most exclusive sections of 
 town and ride in automobiles, while they con- 
 sent to shoe the horses of the humbler ranks 
 255
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 of society. As a rule, we have all seen that 
 lightning-rod agents electrify the world. All 
 the people who are on top insist that the only 
 place that isn't crowded to suffocation is to be 
 found at the bottom. But there's one sugges- 
 tion I'd like to make. The idea seems to me 
 one of the finest imaginable, but couldn't there 
 be some other object beside just helping a lot of 
 young people ? Couldn't there be some kind of 
 an obligation on their part beside the mere return 
 of the money advanced to them ? It seems to 
 me, if I were a beneficiary of such a fund, I 
 should be more contented if I felt that I could 
 do something to show my appreciation of those 
 who had founded it. I can't make myself quite 
 clear, but I think sometimes it is a good thing 
 to feel that there are benefits that can never be 
 repaid in money." 
 
 The old, whimsical smile lit Miss Brent's 
 thin, drawn face. "Good boy; you've exactly 
 struck it," she said. "I've been thinking it 
 out while you have been talking, and I have a 
 burden to lay upon my geniuses. Perhaps you 
 have heard the old superstition about finding 
 one's mission, though I believe this only applies 
 256
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 to women, in the thirty-first chapter of Proverbs, 
 in the verse corresponding to one's birthday. 
 Mine is this, and all my life I have been trying 
 to live up to it: 'Open thy mouth for the dumb 
 in the cause of all such as are appointed to 
 destruction.' My geniuses must be willing to 
 do something once every year, so long as they 
 live, for the sake of those that suffer in silence. 
 If the musician can do no more, he can sing or 
 play for the children in some hospital, or for 
 the old in some poorhouse, or for those in 
 prison. If the artist cannot paint like Landseer, 
 he can still devote the price of a picture to 
 paying dog licenses for the poor children of 
 his town or city. The lawyer can try to secure 
 the passage and enforcement of laws for the 
 protection of. children and animals; and the 
 doctor can set himself as flint against vivisec- 
 tion." 
 
 "Why wouldn't it be as well to make it a 
 fund for the protection of animals in the first 
 place?" asked Ted. "It would be very much 
 simpler and more easily administered." 
 
 "Perhaps I might have done so," she an- 
 swered, "if I had not had the experience of 
 257
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 having all you young folks with me. It has 
 been a great lesson to me, mes enfants. I used 
 to like almost any kind of animal better than 
 the human kind, but I don't any more. Be- 
 sides, as Karl has pointed out, I wanted some- 
 thing more than a temporary relief and a tem- 
 porary benefit. This will be an ever-widening, 
 an always-growing crusade against cruelty. Do 
 you think war would be possible if Verastcha- 
 gin's picture, * Forgotten,' were exhibited in 
 every village and city ? Put a photograph of it 
 over every notice of the recruiting officer, the 
 wounded boy with arms outstretched towards 
 the batteries that are disappearing in the dust 
 far down the mountainside, as his life ebbs 
 away from hideous wounds, while a vulture 
 hovers over him in greedy expectation. That 
 is war. Do you recall Mark Twain's story of 
 the vivisector's dog ? That is the kind of trib- 
 ute I want from my geniuses. They will not 
 be Verastchagins or Twains, but they can add 
 their protest; they can do their best to lighten 
 the burden of cruelty and stupidity." 
 
 The old lady sank into her chair, exhausted 
 with the excitement of the moment, and with 
 258
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 quick tact and comprehension Lorraine and 
 Hope put the subject by, and bringing in the 
 little tables served the dainty refreshments, in 
 the old informal way, and after some music 
 there was a general good-night. 
 
 259
 
 XXXIII 
 
 T TP to the great day of the great First Night, 
 Louis and Hope and Miss Brent had all 
 tried to believe that she would be able to occupy 
 the box reserved for the occasion. When she 
 finally gave it up, it would have been hard to 
 say which was the most disappointed. 
 
 "Elise shall go," she said; "she will enjoy it 
 and bring you good luck and a blessing as she 
 has me all these years." 
 
 But Elise was unwilling to leave her sister. 
 Finally at an appealing look from Miss Brent, 
 Lorraine spirited Miss Elise away. "Do go," 
 she said, "and let me stay. I wouldn't tell 
 Hope for anything, but I should absolutely 
 suffer through it, in a cold fear lest she should 
 forget a syllable, or some stupid actor spoil 
 Louis' masterpiece. They have taken me to 
 see the dress-rehearsal, and it is great, but I 
 should be on tenter-hooks to-night. It will be 
 a mercy to me if you will go, and leave me with 
 Miss Emma. And besides, they are your own 
 260
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 particular swans. I know that there have been 
 ever so many times when they have been going 
 disconsolately away to die as mere ugly duck- 
 lings under the first currant bush, when you 
 have made them believe in their future. They 
 will be unhappy if you don't go why, of 
 course, they must have one of you; what would 
 any of us be without you ? Please go, Miss 
 Elise, and let me take care of Miss Emma." 
 
 Even then she might have refused, had not 
 Miss Emma hobbled in and added her en- 
 treaties. "Do go, Elise," she said. "It won't 
 be long, and I shall like to think that you are 
 there. Have you made all the arrangements ? 
 We want to give the swans a supper when they 
 come back, for of course it is going to be a 
 triumph; Lorraine and Elise and I want to 
 drink to you all and pledge your futures in 
 some very harmless punch." 
 
 So it was settled, and the two friends were 
 left alone, the one so frail and near the end, 
 the other so strong and self-reliant with all the 
 best of life before her. When the house was 
 quite silent Lorraine knelt beside Miss Brent 
 and took her hand. 
 
 261
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 "You wanted to tell me something?" she 
 said. 
 
 "Yes, my dear," answered Miss Brent. "I 
 have told Elise, and we had a consultation with 
 the doctor to-day. He says it may be soon; 
 and yet, I have lasted so much longer than he 
 thought possible, that he will not be surprised 
 if the release does not come for some time yet. 
 Is it not terrible ? Even if I could endure the 
 pain myself without wincing, it is almost as 
 bad to watch little Elise suffering with me, and 
 knowing neither she nor any power on earth 
 can help me. I cannot feel that I ought to put 
 her to this torture. It is not right, Lorraine, 
 you must feel in your heart of hearts that it is 
 not right. If there were anything to be gained, 
 or if I might suffer alone and add to her happi- 
 ness by remaining here, perhaps I should be 
 strong enough to bear it, but it seems to me a 
 useless sacrifice." 
 
 Lorraine's self-control was gone, and she 
 buried her face in the brown silk lap. 
 
 Miss Brent stroked her rumpled hair. "I 
 wanted to tell you that I have seen my lawyer 
 too, and explained to him about the fund, and 
 262
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 he understands everything and will arrange 
 with you and Ted and Elise. I didn't feel 
 quite strong enough to bother with all the 
 details myself, and Elise will know just what I 
 would wish. 
 
 "I have tried to be patient and strong, Lor- 
 raine. I have tried as I watched Louis struggle 
 with his hopeless heartache, and Hope battling 
 against her bitter grief and humiliation, and 
 little Elise trying to put from her the misery 
 and dread of the years to come. I do not 
 think I have altogether failed, but there comes 
 a time when it is weakness to fear convention 
 so much that rather than defy it we suffer 
 unnecessarily ourselves and thrust suffering on 
 others. I wanted to say this to you, Lorraine, 
 though no one else must ever know that I have 
 said it. Perhaps Death himself may be merci- 
 ful, at last. Kiss me, my dear, and know that 
 if the dead return I shall be often near you. 
 Now go and play something slow and drowsy 
 and dreamy, and I'll try to sleep so as to be 
 rested when they come. You are a dear girl, 
 Lorraine, and have been a comfort to me; you 
 will be to little Elise when she needs you, I 
 263
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 know, without your telling me so. Go play 
 any little ballad thing you know the music 
 I like." 
 
 Lorraine played on in the half light that 
 streamed in from the hall, and Miss Brent 
 dropped asleep or into a half doze that left 
 her faintly conscious of the peaceful hush and 
 the soft, tender music stealing over her senses. 
 Lorraine was playing "Solvejg's Song" when 
 the wheels of the returning carriages roused 
 Miss Brent. 
 
 "Quick," she commanded, "turn on the 
 lights and strike up something appropriate, 
 'Hail to the Chief,' or something " 
 
 Lorraine sprang up, turned on all the lights 
 and was playing "Lo, the Conquering Hero 
 Comes" with grace notes and accidentals not 
 to be found in any arrangement of it, when they 
 all came in together, pell-mell, all talking and 
 laughing at once, save Hope and Louis, and 
 trying to explain how Racine and Rachel, 
 Moliere and Mrs. Siddons, had all been put 
 to rout. 
 
 Lorraine drove them all into the dining-room, 
 where Louis was seated at Miss Elise's right 
 264
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 and Hope by Miss Emma, and there were toasts 
 and more toasts, and Miss Emma seemed to 
 forget that there was such a thing as pain, while 
 she pledged first one and then another. 
 
 "I am sure we ought to feel honored," she 
 said, "for I know the lions were wanted and 
 expected elsewhere. But you were wise to come 
 straight home. When 'The School for Scandal' 
 was put on, Sheridan celebrated so vigorously 
 that he woke up in jail the next day. I'm glad 
 to have you emulate his success without drown- 
 ing your pleasure in the flowing bowl. You can 
 drink endless quantities of this punch without 
 fear of a headache. All success to you, my 
 boy, but if discouragement comes, remember 
 that Shakespeare never, no never wrote one of 
 the six best-selling books!" 
 
 They drank the toast standing, and then Miss 
 Elise led Louis to the head of the table, so that 
 the Heavenly Twins stood together, Louis on 
 one side and Hope on the other, both of them 
 happy, confused and blushing at the honors 
 heaped upon them. But in spite of vociferous 
 demands they could not speak. Louis stam- 
 mered words of incoherent gratitude and affec- 
 265
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 tion to the Heavenly Twins and all the dwellers 
 on Mount Parnassus for the faith and inspiration 
 that had never failed him on the weary upward 
 climb, and then he turned to Hope. "Of the 
 play," he said brokenly, "if I cannot claim that 
 it is so good as to need no epilogue, then I must 
 confess like a dull actor now, I have forgotten 
 my part. Whatever success has come to me I 
 owe to you, who have believed in me and most 
 of all to her," he bowed to Hope, "whose 
 very name is a bugle call to the drooping spirit 
 and whose genius has wrested victory from 
 defeat!" 
 
 "Make him your best bow, Hope, and prom- 
 ise to spring eternal whenever the cue comes," 
 said Lorraine laughing. "Hope is a lover's 
 staff,'" she whispered in an aside to Miss Emma. 
 "I wish we were sure that he might 'walk hence 
 with that.' Come, Hope, say something for 
 us to remember when the great world claims 
 you, and we have become only part of the crowd 
 that stand in line before the box office." 
 
 But Hope turned first to the Heavenly Twins 
 and then to Louis with something upon her face 
 that none of them had ever seen before, and the 
 266
 
 UNDER THE HARROW 
 
 voice that had thrilled the great audience an 
 hour or two ago was low and tremulous with 
 feeling. 
 
 "There are no words to thank you," she said. 
 " For you, Louis, the world will bring its tribute. 
 But I, what can I say ? I that was dead and am 
 alive again, I who was lost and am found ?" 
 
 There was a moment's hush, then Miss Brent 
 said quite gayly, "If I remember it, the rest of 
 that verse is, 'And they began to be merry!' If 
 these geniuses of ours refuse to let us burn in- 
 cense, here's to the bride! Teddy, we congratu- 
 late you on acquiring a genius all for your own. 
 Bess, we hope you will be happy, though mar- 
 ried. Here's to the geniuses, may you live long 
 and prosper; God bless you all, God bless you 
 
 every one." 
 
 ***** 
 
 When the morning dawned the greatest bless- 
 ing to those who sink to slumber in pain, and 
 waken in suffering, had brought release to 
 Miss Brent. 
 
 267
 
 A Novel that Mirrors Washington Society 
 
 THE IMPERSONATOR 
 
 By MARY IMLAY TAYLOR 
 
 Illustrated by Ch. Grunwald. 12mo. Cloth, $1.50 
 
 An exceedingly fascinating story. Atlanta Constitution. 
 
 Not only a most absorbing story, but the ranking novel 
 of those whose scenes are laid in Washington. Lilian 
 Whiting in Times-Democrat. 
 
 The humor and satire with which social life in the cap- 
 ital is described gives the book a deserved popularity even 
 if the charming love story and surprising denouement did 
 not add an exceptional degree of interest. Washington 
 Star. 
 
 A pretty girl art student in Paris is induced by a 
 homely girl art student to go to Washington as the 
 substitute for the homely one, who has been invited to 
 visit a rich aunt whom she has never seen. From first 
 to last the interest is skilfully maintained. SL Louis 
 Post Dispatch. 
 
 Clever both in conception and execution. ... A tale 
 of Washington society reflecting with accuracy certain 
 aspects of the semi-fast life of the nation's capital. . . . 
 The characters are all strongly individualized and the 
 action is as swift as it is natural. The impersonator her- 
 self is admirably drawn. Boston Transcript. 
 
 LITTLE, BROWN, & CO., PUBLISHERS 
 254 WASHINGTON STREET, BOSTON
 
 A Novel with a Problem to Solve 
 
 THE MASTER KNOT 
 OF HUMAN FATE 
 
 By ELLIS MEREDITH 
 Author of " Under the Harrow," etc. 16mo. Cloth, $1.25 
 
 A remarkable book ; original in action, conception, de- 
 velopment, treatment, and the mystery of the " unguessed 
 riddle." Buffalo Commercial. 
 
 An admirably conceived and well written story, in 
 which the interest is maintained up to the tantalizing 
 end. Philadelphia North A merican. 
 
 A remarkably powerful and remarkably fascinating 
 story. . . . The reader will enjoy " The Master Knot " 
 for its rare imaginative power and its novel situation. 
 Boston Journal. 
 
 Since Olive Schreiner wrote that oddly fascinating 
 "Story of an African Farm," with its unanswerable 
 queries, there has been nothing to compare with it until 
 this riddle of Ellis Meredith's. Los Angeles Herald. 
 
 An intensely human book. The play of human passion, 
 the movement of human experience, the force of human 
 love, all combine to give us a story of which the length is 
 all too short. Baltimore Sun. 
 
 LITTLE, BROWN, & CO., PUBLISHERS 
 254 WASHINGTON STREET, BOSTON
 
 A Delightful New Blue Grass Country Character 
 
 AUNT . 
 JANE OF KENTUCKY 
 
 By ELIZA CALVERT HALL 
 Illustrated by Beulah Strong. 12mo. Cloth, $1.50 
 
 This book, a picture of rural Kentucky life, will evoke 
 the deepest sympathy from every human heart with 
 which its characters come in contact. Aunt Jane is a 
 philosopher in homespun and in her " ricollections " we 
 see the beauty, the romance, and the pathos that lie in 
 humble lives. 
 
 The humor of the book is softened and refined by being 
 linked with pathos and romance, and the character draw- 
 ing is done with a firm hand. Nancy Huston Banks, 
 the well known author, says it is " a faithful portrayal of 
 provincial life in Kentucky, but something more than 
 that too ; for the universal note which marks the value of all 
 creative writing sounds on every page." 
 
 Every one is sure to love Aunt Jane and her neighbors, 
 her quilts and her flowers, her stories and her quaint, 
 tender philosophy. 
 
 LITTLE, BROWN, & CO., PUBLISHERS 
 
 254 WASHINGTON STREET, BOSTON
 
 " Something absolutely new" Chicago Record-Herald 
 
 THE WIRE TAPPERS 
 
 By ARTHUR STRINGER 
 
 Illustrated by Arthur William Brown. 12mo. Decorated 
 Cloth. $1.50 
 
 The oddest love story in current fiction. Kansas 
 City Star. 
 
 Mr. Stringer is at his best in this novel. Hartford 
 Courant. 
 
 Really a fine specimen of the fiction of excitement done 
 by a skilful hand. New York Globe. 
 
 Worked out with an amazing cleverness. New York 
 Herald. 
 
 Far removed from sensational fiction by its character 
 drawing, which is excellent. A sincerely worthy work, by 
 far the best thing Mr. Stringer has yet produced. Boston 
 Transcript. 
 
 This story of a young man and young woman thrown 
 into a criminal environment, through force of circum- 
 stances, throbs with virility. An underworld story with- 
 out sordidness. New York Dramatic Mirror. 
 
 LITTLE, BROWN, & CO., PUBLISHERS 
 254 WASHINGTON STREET, BOSTON
 
 University of California 
 
 SOUTHERN REGIONAL LIBRARY FACILITY 
 
 305 De Neve Drive - Parking Lot 17 Box 951388 
 
 LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90095-1388 
 
 Return this material to the library from which it was borrowed. 
 
 1
 
 A 000128082 5
 
 University of (|li