L-f UC-NRLF B 3 5E1 Sfi3 V UNIVH :3ITY OF Education and Industrial Efficiency REPORT OF ALBERT H. LEAKE, Inspector of Technical Education, * To the Minister of Education _ MM , MHM ON RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN THE SCHOOLS OF THE EASTERN STATES. ISSUED AS AN APPENDIX TO THE REPORT OF THE MINISTER OF EDUCATION FOR THE YEAR 1905 PRINTED BY ORDER OF, THE LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF JDNTARIO TORONTO: Prfokai and Pubkshod by L. K. CAMERON, Printer to the King's Most EW!. 17 16 13 13 13 17 2.... 15 15 12 15 15 15 3.... 20 16 9 10 10 16 4.... 20 17 12 10 10 18 . I \ CO*,DOK 1 1^21 PtHQltMM I'ExM.Uoonl M__^______^_ K *^__, -L : II .^ II : ID ?A "srr ^::;r J Cl./NS5D^V^ 10 EDUCATION AND No. 12 The school is admirably planned and laid out. Boys are admitted from the gram- mar (public) schools without examination. The equipment of the shops is of the highest character. A feature of the shops here, as in most of the other schools visited, is a demonstration gallery. In front of this gallery are placed appli- ances such as are used by the student in that particular shop. Before any exer- cise or piece of work is attempted the teacher gives a demonstration of the processes involved and the tools used. All through the grades of the Public Schools constructive work is taken and manual training is taken in the sixth, seventh, eighth and ninth grades so that the boys who enter the Technical School have some elementary knowledge of mechanical processes and the use of tools. M. TIChniCAL MIGH OCHOOL .VW t. C A unique feature of the school is the Evening Trade School, held in the same building and using the same equipment. This was organized in 1898, and was the first attempt made in the United States to teach trades at the public expense. The first classes were for tool making and plumbing, meeting for three evenings per week, and lasting for a period of five months for three years. Classes are now held in machine shop practice, tool making, wood turning and pattern-making, plumbing, mathematics and electricity. It is the opinion of all in Springfield that this development of the educational system is the most suc- cessful and far-reaching effort that has yet been made to make education and 1905 INDUSTRIAL EFFICIENCY. 11 life synonymous terms. The attendance is now 500 and is remarkably constant' a percentage of 84.4 being reached. Tuition is free and preference is given to those actually engaged in the trades. The certificates granted by the school have a recognized value in the community. The opinion was expressed that in no part of the school system does a dollar go so far as here. Altogether this school in its building, equipment, organization, and general method of work offers a very good model for the City of Toronto to adopt and adapt for both evening and day school work Plans of the general arrangement are attached. 2. THE MECHANIC ARTS HIGH SCHOOL, BOSTON. This school was not in session but we were carefully shown over the building and equipment, and gathered much useful information from our inspec- tion. The usual practice is followed of admitting boys from the Public Schools without examination. The school is so crowded that it is necessary to reject all applications from non-residents. The courses are three and four years in length, and very few electives are offered, owing to the necessity of keeping the entire equipments of the mechanical departments in constant use. The mechanical subjects embrace the following : Drawing, carpentry, joinery, wood carving, wood turning, pattern making, forging of iron and steel, chipping, filing, fitting, and machinist's work with hand and machine tools. 12 EDUCATION AND No. 12 For each department a carefully graduated series of models, the construction of which illustrates every fundamental principle or process, has been chosen. These are made by all the members of a class, while a series of supplementary models are undertaken by those who have completed the class work. Round the walls of the corridors and rooms are displayed the various courses worked in the different shops. In the mechanical departments the students are carefully taught how to judge and criticize their own work. The school is overcrowded, shows a constant growth and has a large waiting list, showing that it is providing a kind of education that is in demand. A large addition has been planned which it is hoped by the authorities of the school will soon be commenced. An analysis of Mechanic Arts High School, Boston. the course of study shows the following comparison of the time spent upon academical and mechanical work in hours per year : Academic. Mechanical. 1 400. 600. 2 600. 500. 3 700. 300. 4 600. 500. An evening trade school was established in this building in September, 1904= the subjects taught being machine drawing, elementary and advanced wood 1905 INDUSTRIAL EFFICIENCY. working, forging and machine shop practice. The cost of the present building, site and equipment was about $320,000. In addition to the Mechanic Arts equipment in this school, an up-to-date wood working equipment is being installed in every academic high school. In Wood Turning. Mechanic Arts High School, Boston. addition to this 90% of the boys in the [three upper grades of the grammar (public) schools are also provided with educational woodwork in 43 specially fitted rooms, while those in the lower grades are given work in clay, cardboard, etc., so that handwork forms an integral part of the curriculum from the kinder- garten to the end of the High School period. An order of the Board passed July, 1904, provides, " that the course of study for High Schools be amended by 14 EDUCATION AND No. 12 adding the subject of Manual Training to the elective studies ; provided, that not more than fifteen points for drawing, household science and arts and manual training combined be allowed to count towards a diploma." Wood Turning Demonstration Lesson. Mechanic Arts High School, Boston. Proposed extension of Mechanic Arts High School. 3. RINDGE MANUAL TRAINING HIGH SCHOOL, CAMBRIDGE, MASS. This School was founded and supported for ten years by the gentleman whose name it bears but is now a municipal school in affiliation with Harvard University. Two buildings are occupied, one for the academic work and the other for the 1905 INDUSTRIAL EFFICIENCY. 15 mechanical departments. The average age of admission is fourteen or fifteen. The building devoted to mechanic arts has two wings. One of these contains the two departments of wood working and the other two departments of iron working. These rooms measure 55 by 60 feet. In the main part of the build- ing are the offices, a tool room, 34 by 70 feet, the boiler room and a room for moulding which was being fitted up. The second story of this main part con- tains rooms for drawing. In the basement there is a spacious lunch room in which are served hot lunches. About one-third of the time of each student is devoted to the manual arts and the remainder to the subjects usually taught in the High School with the exception of Latin and Greek. 4. THE MANUAL TRAINING HIGH SCHOOL, BROOKLYN. This school is one of the latest of this particular type as well' r as one of the largest. The lot is 200 by 300 feet and the building itself, Turning and Pattern Making Shop, Brooklyn. 200 by 215 feet, built in the form of a hollow square, and five stories- high including the basement which is entirely above the ground. There- are now 2,20$ students on the roll, of which number two-thirds are girls. The class unit is 30. There are four freehand drawing rooms, four mechanical drafting rooms, a large auditorium having accomodation for 1530 people, and a gymnasium having a floor space of 84 by 66 feet. The apparatus, is so arranged that the whole floor can be easily and quickly cleared. In the basement are three laboratories a steam engine and dynamo laboratory, an electric testing laboratory and an assay and analytical laboratory. There are four joinery shops each fitted with thirty benches, band saw, turning lathe, grindstone, teacher's bench, demonstration gallery, a tool room, five or six hand basins, and 150 lockers for students. The benches are four feet long and twenty inches wide fitted with a Towles quick action vise, and have a larg& 16 EDUCATION AND No. 12 drawer for general tools and six small ones for individual students. The pat- tern shop is fitted similarly to the joinery shop but each bench is also fitted MANUAl/TRAINM-ROOM' WINDOWS ON THIS SIDE | 1 5 TEACHER^ DESK " u MdN! TRATIdl < frtWCH SfocK ROOM AREA to Q FT OR. MORE to D D D D D D A D D D D D D a: v> > D D D D D D b v o G> Z i D D D D D D >- D D D D D D j TEACHERS CLOSET PLAN OF MAN UAL TRAINING ROOM . ;j r " r V/ToP Row TO COMPARTMENTS -/o TIERS PAlNTEP ON HIGH- > 3 PQ 3 OS B 1 7. THE MANHATTAN TRADE SCHOOL FOR GIRLS, NEW YORK. This is probably the most interesting and successful effort that has been made in Educational practice in the New World. This was my second visit to the school and proved even more useful than the first. It depends for its support entirely on voluntary contributions. In 1905 22 EDUCATION AND No. 12 it expended nearly $30,000. Its aim is to fit girls for the actual needs of trade. The departments are based on the use of the needle, the sewing machine, and the paste brush. Three hundred and fifty students are in attend- ance. A new building has been purchased at a cost of $1 20.000. The course generally lasts for one year, and whenever a girl has acquired some degree of skill she is sent for a month into some business house to prove her efficiency. bo '3 bO She returns to the school with the comments of her employer, and these assist the faculty in deciding whether or not she is approaching the demands of her trade. The Director of the school is Professor Mary Scheneck Wool man, Director of Domestic Art, Teachers' College, Columbia University, and never before has such a close connection been made and maintained between education and practical life as is to be seen here. Every one of the teachers has been 1905 INDUSTRIAL EFFICIENCY. 23 actually engaged in the trade she is teaching, and conversations with them and inspection of their methods show that they have a thorough grasp of the re- quirements of their students. Academic work and physical culture are properly attended to. It is the aim of the school'to make the training given, an enlightened apprenticeship. Trade work is taken at regular market prices, and in 1905 orders to the amount of $2,3S7.76 were filled. The practice work is not sold but 13 I I 2 *4H 60 C " P the seconds (work just below the trade s tan lard) are disposed of to the children or their families at prices slightly above the cost of materials. A remunerative position is lound for every girl who successfully accomplishes the work given. The tuition is entirely free, and where wages are an absolute necessity to the family, aid is given to enable a girl to attend the school. In every case the wage earning power of the girls has been materially increased. That the in- EDUCATION AND No. 12 strucbion given is of the right kind is shown by the fact that the demand for its workers is greater than the supply, and those firms which have tried them even offer a premium for obtaining more. The possibilities of a school of this type seem almost endless, and the work being done here is receiving much atten- tion from every part of the world. to 8. PKATT INSTITUTE, BROOKLYN, Is a private institution established in 1887. The main building is 100 feet by 86 feet, and six stories high. A trades school building recently erected is 32 feet by 110 feet and four stories high. Under the present plan of organization the work of the institute is divided among the fol- lowing departments : High School, Fine Arts, Domestic Art, Domestic Science, 1905 INDUSTRIAL EFFICIENCY. 25 Science and Technology, Kindergarten, Libraries and Physical Training. The Domestic Science Department differs from Drexel and other institutions of the same type in being much plainer, and the authorities contend more useful. It is the opinion of the Director of this Department that it is a mistake to equip with luxurious apparatus that is not found in the average kitchen. The department of Science and Technology takes in all the courses especially' fitted for men. These are divided, into three classes. First, the day school provides technical courses in mechanical and electrical work, which cover a period of two years. Second, evening technical courses in physics, chemistry, applied electricity, mechanical drawing and machine design, steam and the steam engine, and strength of materials. Third, evening trade classes in carpentry, pattern EDUCATION AND No. 12 making machine work, mechanical drawing, plumbing, sign painting and fresco painting. Most of the instructors are graduates of colleges or scientific schools and many of the Technical instructors were educated in the Institute. In the trade work the teachers are men who have gained prominence in their several trades, and are for the most part self-educated or were trained in the Insti- tute. Space will not allow of any further description. Suffice it to say that here and at the Drexel Institute, Philadelphia, which was visited on a previous occasion, may be seen almost every department of practical education which has ever found a place in educational systems, and each repays prolonged investigation. 1905 INDUSTRIAL EFFICIENCY. 27 9. THE NEW YORK TRADE SCHOOL. This was the second of the three purely trade schools visited. It was founded in 1881 for the purpose of providing young men, who have a bent for mechanics, the opportunity of acquiring the knowledge of some trade that will be to its possessor a means of livelihood. The work given is such as will be met with in actual practice at the trade. The teachers are all mechanics who have gained their knowledge in the shops. The plan of the building is unique and so arranged asto secure large floor space and ample light and ventilation. The plan attached shows the general arrangement. Day and evening classes are provided in the following trades : plumbing, house painting, fresco painting, sign painting, brick-laying plastering, steam fitting and electrical work, carpentry and cabinet making Amongst the students in the session just closed were youths from New Bruns- wick, Prince Edward Island, Nova Scotia, Newfoundland, Ontario and Quebec. The school, year extends from October to April. Though 800 students were New York Trade School. trained last year only about one-fourth of the applicants could be received. The land, buildings and equipment cost $300,000, and the school is supported by fees and an endowment fund. 10. NORTH-EAST MANUAL TRAINING HIGH SCHOOL, PHILADELPHIA. This school occupies a new building costing about $467,000 and I had the honour of being presented with the first copy of the prospectus ever sent out. The course given lasts for a period of three years. The auditorium is a feature of the school with its pipe organ, costing $3,000, raised by private subscription. On the library table I counted sixteen technical magazines relating to the various branches taught in the school, and they bore every evidence of much use. The head of each department receives a salary of $2,500. The curriculum is based upon the usual High School courses in English literature and language, German, French, Spanish, history, mathematics, science and drawing. To these are added courses in the use of tools for working wood and metal. An average of one period per day is given to drawing, two periods to work in the manual depart- ment, and three periods to the academic studies. The tool instruction includes joinery, pattern making, wood turning, wood carving, forging, soldering, orna- mental iron work, moulding, casting, vise work, sheet metal work and steam engineering. 28 EDUCATION AND No. 12 11. THE CENTRAL MANUAL TRAINING HIGH SCHOOL, PHILADELPHIA, Impressed me as being one of the best organized schools of its class I have ever seen. The purpose of the school as expressed by the Principal is " to bring thought and labour together to make the thinker a worker and the worker^ thinker." Provision has been made that the boy shall be trained in 1. Practical English The language of clear and forcible expression. 2. Practical Government The basis of good citizenship. 3. Practical Mathematics For business, construction, engineering. SHEET METAL CORNICE WORK. ASSEMBLY DRAWING. STEAM ANDHOTWATER FITTING, ^^ SIGN PAINTING CARPENTRY AMD WOOD PATTERN MAKING, New York Trade School. 1905 INDUSTRIAL EFFICIENCY. 29 4. Practical Science The active working knowledge of the facts and forces of nature. 5. Practical Hand Culture. Plastering Department Students at Work, New York Trade School. As in most other schools of this type chipping, filing, and fitting is taken in the first year, but the Principal here does not consider the results achieved com- Brick-laying Department Students at Work, New York Trade School. mensurate with the time spent and intends transferring it to the third year. Tne connection between art and manual training is very closely kept up. The 30 EDUCATION AND No. 12 drawing comes first, then the object is modelled in clay, then in wood, and some- tine es in iron and if time allowed the principal is of opinion that much good North East Manual Training High School, Philadelphia. would result by a continuance of the study in stone and marble. The build- ings in which the school is held are old and unsuitable. The criticism cannot Wood-working Department, North East Manual Training High School, Philadelphia, be brought that money has been spent in bricks and not brains. The excellent work that is being accomplished is owing to the ability, enthusiasm, and organ- 1905 INDUSTRIAL EFFICIENCY. ization of the principal and the staff, and not to any facilities offered by the building. All kinds of ingenious expedients are resorted to, to overcome diffi- 265' Floor -to b *'be/ow street /eve/ 1st Floor P/crn. Quac/rang/e 'xsj' -A 3s' xso' + //o'xss' F/oor to be 4' a/>o\s?? street Proposed Manual Training High School, Philadelphia. 32 EDUCATION AND No. 12 culties, e. g. } in one of the wood-working shops the benches can be converted into wood-turning lathes in half an hour. A particularly efficient mechanical drawing u ^ Germafj French 38x24-' 38'x24' <* ,Y ,..-. -^ mmm , , lt "* v & Wires y ~/ectr/'ca/ j* \j X. T! in 1C s' m S' ) H/S tory 28*38' \ Intermediate Wood 'Shop S6'x38' L K ^r 7 Literature, 1 > w~p .i v . /y ^HIIIIII mm/^ Cn em is try v: b vs ^PB Fres/tmdn TffllH Ma the- MaturaJ 1 Facuty tnat/cs Science / n riQOm S5x38' SS~'x3Q' ^a'KZQ JP Labor- Lecture. . crtofy Room 28*20' SS'X3B' SS\38' frjo//et\ / > C/o. I V \ / r */ 3rd Floor Plan / ^J^cA ^5 Freehancf Dr ay/ing -F>>pts & y \ ^" Constructive ^ / ^1 i r J Ma the- ^ (Freshman 28'x38' / Wood ( Mode ting" 2.8X36' frtermcJ^ ^ Shops / rreshmon ^ C/os. ^ ^ IO' ' ^ ^C/oj. - 1 (I 6^ 1 ^ Platform (lit 1 / j Gyrnncrs/um \ S5'*9S' xv ey lit > |5 c ^cv/ \A7/>er 1 25^^o' ^ Ph0tO-f>'t$ , Boys I ^ C/u6\ 55*9S ^8'*Zo\ Seats for SCO Proposed Manual Training High School, Philadelphia. 1905 INDUSTRIAL EFFICIENCY. table designed by one of the staff, is in use. The ornamental iron work done by the boys is particularly good and is accomplished with very simple appli- ances. The third year boys take a course in practical surveying. Another dis- tinct feature is the course given in mechanical construction. This is worked out in tin plate and the various mechanical appliances applied to construction in building and engineering are demonstrated by the manufacture of working models. In the wood-working departments much stress is laid upon the boy understanding the mechanical principle of every tool used. The teacher here has many original ideas, and unique and effective ways of carrying them out. Plans which are attached have been prepared for a new building. 12. GIRLS' COMMERCIAL HIGH SCHOOL, PHILADELPHIA. The North East and Central Manual Training High Schools (10 and 11) are for boys only. The girls are provided for in a separate building under separate management, as far as commercial education is concerned. This school is held in three separate buildings and has an enrollment of 1300 girls from fourteen to eighteen years of age. The cpurse of study is four years in length. Students are admitted from the grammar schools without examination. The Principal and faculty of the school are much pleased at advertisements that have recently appeared in the local papers stating, " Commercial High School graduates pre- ferred." 13. SPRING GARDEN INSTITUTE. PHILADELPHIA, Is an art, mechanical and electrical school supported by fees and endowment. Day schools are maintained in the three departments and each department has night classes for apprentices, boys learning trades, and boys and girls still attend- 2 T.E. 34 EDUCATION AND No. 12 ing the public schools. The courses are three years in length in both day and evening classes. In the mechanical and electrical departments the students spend eight hours a day in the shops. 14. JAMES FORTEN ELEMENTARY MANUAL TRAINING SCHOOL, PHILADELPHIA, Is situated in one of the slum districts of the city. It was originally a school for coloured children, but owing to the character of the locality changing it is now essentially a Jewish school. I visited it on a Jewish holiday but was shown through the building, had a long conversation with the principal and saw several voluntary classes at work. Each child spends some portion of the day at hand work of various kinds, varying from the kindergarten to advanced woodwork. There are nine hundred children in attendance. Sewing is provided for girls all the way through, with household science for the girls of the upper grades. In the third grade the sewing consists in making a set of doll's clothing on just the same principles as would be followed in making a set for a grown-up person. The cookery room and the woodworking room are also used for classes from neighbouring schools. An experiment is being tried in drawing toys. Each child is provided with a toy as a model and this is drawn and coloured. Some of the results I saw were very creditable. The character of the district is shown by the popularity of a certain model in the wood work course a shine box. that is a box in which is contained materials for shoe polishing, that being the method by which a large number of the boys earn their living at an early age, The school is particularly fortunate in its principal, Miss Hannah Ashley Fox, a woman of high enthusiasm, excellent judgment, admirable tact, and special training in managing children of unfortunate home influence. 15 TEXTILE SCHOOL AND SCHOOL OF INDUSTRIAL ART, PHILADELPHIA. Textile schools in the United States owe their beginning to the Philadelphia Textile Association. Last year this school was attended by 1018 students, of whom 637 were men and 381 women. Since my last visit to the school a kiln has been added ; so that now all modelling done in the school is fired on the premises by the students. The present organization of the school is as follows : 1. School of Applied Art : Drawing, applied, design, normal art instruction, wood work and wood carving, decorative painting, illustration, decorative sculp- ture, architectural drawing and design, metal work, pottery. 2. Textile School : Fabric structure and design, cotton, wool, worsted and silk, warp preparation and weaving, colour harmony and figure design, chemistry, dyeing and printing, wool yarn manufacture, worsted yarn manufacture, cotton yarn manufacture, hosiery knitting, finishing. 3. School of Modern Languages. The quarters in which this school is housed are palatial and the equip- ment installed to carry out the curriculum above specified, consists of the most modern machinery in every department and no expense has been spared. The school is supported by grants from the State Legislature, by a liberal endow- ment, and the fees of the students. The museum attached to the school, enriched by many priceless specimens of the arts and industries taught, is invaluable for the purpose of study. 1905 INDUSTRIAL EFFICIENCY. 35 16. WILLIAMSON FREE SCHOOL OF MECHANICAL TRADES. This was the last school visited. It is situated about sixteen miles out of Philadelphia. Its aim is to teach certain trades, and the author- ities claim that the school can make a better mechanic in three years than could possibly be done in the shops. The problem of trade instruction Administration Building and Campus . seems to be to get boys at the proper age and to keep them long enough. This school solves the difficulty by taking them at sixteen or seventeen and feeding and clothing them for a period of three years, the pupils being bound by articles of apprenticeship. As showing the efficiency of Instruction in Carpentry. the instruction given, the Pennsylvania Railway Company takes one-third of the product of the school. Seventy-five per cent, of the boys graduated follow mechanical employments. The teachers of the academic work are ladies. Only one applicant in five can be accepted. There are about 300 boys in the school 36 EDUCATION AND divided into families of twenty-five, each presided over by a matron. The dis- cipline is excellent. An accidental ringing of the bell in the dining hall brought instant response. The trades taught are as follows : Carpentering, bricklaying, including range, furnace and boiler setting, etc., machine trade in all its usual Instruction in Machine Work. details., pattern making, steam and electrical engineering, steam fitting, etc. Each pupil takes but one of the trades named, and his instruction in mechanical and freehand drawing tends in the general direction of his particular trade. The courses are systematic and thorough. Three-quarters of the expense is School Barn Erected by Students. incurred in housing the boys. The grounds are 230 acres in extent, occupied by twenty-four buildings. The class unit is twenty- five. The founder is buried under the school. The capital consists of $2,160,000 in securities. The plant cost $500,000 and by the trust deed only 80% of the income is allowed to be 1905 INDUSTRIAL EFFICIENCY. 37 spent annnally. The machine shop is fitted with various types of machines so that students may gain varied experience. The school has its own water and power plant. The city of Philadelphia has just appropriated a large sum of money lor the establishment of a trade school as part of its general educational system, and the tendency in the United States seems to be more and more in the direction of definite trade teaching. I shall be glad to answer any questions that this necessarily brief report may suggest. Your obedient servant, ALBERT H. LEAKE, Inspector of Technical Education. U.C. BERKELEY LIBRARIES 0023713213 M533358 T13 L 4