i%. m i Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2008 with funding from IVIicrosoft Corporation http://www.archive.org/details/coinsofancientsiOOhillrich COINS OF ANCIENT SICILY Frontispiece SYRACUSAN 'MEDALLIONS' COIN ANCIENT 'Y r liLL, MA. i'UOOK OF GREKK AVO ROMAN .Uol 8q (.vdo ,nonii3) mriDBibBoab : aauDBi^S .i .I1o18q V ,, ) u u 'i: I •f _ _ • , ., , ,, "C •UoTtQQ^". . . . I . ) ,, . .d ilol £OI Kot\-i^\\oO FRONTISPIECE PAGB i'^'Syracuse : decadrachm (Cimon, obv.) 98 foil. 2. „ „ {Cimon). Paris, Btblioiheque Nationale 98 foil. 3. „ „ ( » ) 98 foil 4. „ „ (Euaenetus) 99 foil 5- ,, ,> ( » ) 99 foil 6. ,, „ ( ,, ) 99 foil. 7. „ „ (Unknown Artist). Thompson Yates Collection 103 foil. COINS OF ANCIENT SICILY BY G. F. HILL, M.A. OF THE DEPARTMENT OF COINS, BRITISH MUSEUM AUTHOR OF 'a HANDBOOK OF GREEK AND ROMAN COINS,' ETC. WITH SIXTEEN COLLOTYPE PLATES OF COINS EIGHTY ILLUSTRATIONS IN THE TEXT AND A MAP WESTMINSTER ARCHIBALD CONSTABLE & CO., Ltd. 2 WHITEHALL GARDENS 1903 RfFSE i OXFORD HORACE HART, PRINTER TO THE UNIVERSITY PREFACE It can hardly be denied that the popularization of archaeological studies is not from certain points of view a desirable undertaking. The disadvantages which every specialist must perceive in any but a rigidly scientific treatment of his subject are as patent in the case of coins as elsewhere ; and I may therefore be expected to apologize for adding to the number of books which increase the bulk of the literature of numismatics without bringing grist to the mill of science. I have no apology which will not appear to halt in the eyes of the profes- sional numismatist; but the archaeologist who is not specially trained in the study of coins will, I hope, be more merciful. The technicality of the study — a necessity if that study was ever to advance beyond the stage of dilettantism in which it once lingered — is rapidly increasing. The classification and arrangement of coins are being effected with extraordinary minuteness, made possible by recent progress in methods of mechanical reproduction. vi PREFACE Only those who are in daily touch with the litera- ture which is being produced in growing quantities can hope to keep abreast of the advance, and that in the sense not of actually possessing information on more than one branch of the subject, but merely of knowing where to look for it. It is a conviction of the high interest, to all students of antiquity and lovers of art, of many things in the history of Sicilian coinage which are hidden away in special, highly technical publications, that has suggested the compilation of this book. Even if archaeologists feel that its treatment of the subject is too slight, they will perhaps find the illustrations useful. As regards those who are not skilled in any branch of archaeology, it is fair to say that no beginner of the study of Greek art can afford to neglect Sicilian coins, and no traveller in Sicily who cannot appre- ciate their beauty and historical value deserves the privilege of visiting the island. Possibly this volume may serve to whet the appetite for something more substantial and worthier the subject, for the works of Evans, Gardner, Head, Holm and Imhoof-Blumer — to mention some of the names most intimately connected with the study of Sicilian coins. Where these chapters are tedious, and degenerate into a mere list of types, the reader will find that the matters inadequately dealt with here acquire interest PREFACE vii when studied in greater detail under the guidance of writers such as I have named. It would be impertinent in me to express my obligations to their works. They are the foundation on which all later comers must build. So much so, that many passages in this book, to those familiar with their writings, must read like sheer plagiarism. But I may be pardoned for not always acknowledging the source of a view which, thanks to the authority of its propounder, has become one of the commonplaces of numismatic criticism. If, on the other hand, I have ventured occasionally to differ from the ex- pressed opinion of any one of them, it has been in many cases with the support of another, and in all, I trust, with becoming modesty. With some hesitation I have adopted the sugges- tion of a friend, and inserted in the Introduction a brief sketch of Sicilian History down to the begin- ning of the Imperial period. Such sketches are seldom satisfactory, nor can I allege any reason why the present one should not be ignored by those who have by them Freeman's little volume on Sicily in the ' Story of the Nations ' series, not to mention the greater works of the same writer, of Holm and of Pais. I desire to express my gratitude to the Trustees of the British Museum for the generous loan of viii PREFACE many of the woodblocks originally cut for the British Museum Catalogue of the Greek Coins of Sicily. These have enabled me to illustrate in the text a large number of coins which would else either have been excluded themselves, or have ousted others from the plates. The woodcuts, though they cannot be expected always to do justice to the originals, may yet serve as a rough indication of the types. For permission to use the woodblocks of Figs. 23, 24, 27, 34, and 42, my thanks are due to their owners, the Council of the Numismatic Society of London, and Mr. Arthur Evans, whose articles in the Numis- matic Chronicle they were made to illustrate. I am also deeply indebted to many who, in the case of coins not well represented in our national collection, have supplied information or impressions, or per- mitted the use of casts already accessible to me; more especially I may mention the official staff of the Cabinets of Berlin and Paris, and — among private collectors— Dr. F. Imhoof-Blumer, Messrs. Arthur Loebbecke, S. A. Thompson Yates, John Ward, and Sir Hermann Weber. The British Museum series of electrotypes of rare coins has been drawn upon with the object of making the illustrations as com- plete as possible. Where the illustrations are not taken from the British Museum collection, I have PREFACE ix indicated in the key to the plates the collection to which the specimens belong. All the coins, unless otherwise described in the key, must be regarded as being of silver. Finally, I must not omit to record my debt to Mr. Warwick Wroth, and especially to Mr. George Macdonald, who have bestowed great pains on the reading of my proofs, and made suggestions which in almost every case I have been glad to adopt. G. F. HILL. British Museum, Dec. 1902. TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE Preface v List of Plates xii List of Illustrations in the Text . . . xiii Introduction i Chapter I : The Earliest Coinage ... 36 „ II : From Himera to the Assinarus . 53 „ III: The Fine Period .... 97 „ IV: The Decline 149 „ V: From Hiero II to Tiberius . . 186 Appendix: The Maltese Group and Pantellaria 227 Select Bibliography 231 Index I : Subjects 237 Index II : Greek 253 LIST OF PLATES Syracusan ' Medallions ' Plate I . . , II . . , III . . . IV . . , V . . VI . , . VII VIII IX X XI XII XIII XIV XV . Map of Sicily . Frontispiece face p. 48 58 >> 66 » 76 j> 82 106 M 122 >» 130 )> 142 »; 148 >j 160 >> 174 >> 196 )■) 218 >f 226 }i 256 LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS IN THE TEXT FIG. PAGE 1. Zancle : Drachm 38 2. Camarina : LiTRA 51 3. Himera: Obol 69 4. HiMERA : LiTRA . 69 5. Catana-Aetna : Litra or Obol .... 74 6. Camarina : Didrachm 80 7. Gela : Didrachm 83 8. Segesta : Didrachm 86 9. Segesta : Didrachm ....... 87 10. Eryx : Litra 89 11. Eryx: Litra 90 12. Galaria : Litra or Obol 90 13. Henna : Litra 91 14. Hipana : Litra 92 15. Stiela : Half-Drachm 92 16. Panormus : Tetradrachm 93 17. Panormus: Obol ....... 93 18. Panormus : Didrachm 93 19. Panormus : Litra 93 20. MoTYA : Tetradrachm 94 21. Motya: Didrachm 94 22. Motya : Obol 95 23. Syracuse : Decadrachm by the ' New Artist.* A. J. Evans Collection 103 24. Syracuse : Tetradrachm 108 25. Syracuse: Gold iii XIV LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS FIG. 26. 27. 28. 29. 32. 33- 34. 35- 36. 37- 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43- 44. 45- 46. 47. 48. 49. 50- 51- 52. 53- 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62. . Chron. 1891, p. 362 Syracuse : Bronze Litra Syracuse : * Pegasus ' (Num. Chron. 1891, p. 362) Syracuse : Electrum Gela : Gold Gela : Bronze Camarina : Obol Camarina : Litra Camarina : Obol Leontini : ' Pegasus * [Num Segesta : Tetradrachm Nacona : Bronze Morgantina : Litra Abacaenum : Litra MoTYA : DiDRACHM Solus : Bronze . Ras Melkart : Tetradrachm . SicuLO-PuNic Tetradrachm Syracuse : Bronze Syracuse : Gold of Agathocles Syracuse : Gold of Agathocles Syracuse : Bronze AcRAGAs : Litra . Acragas : Bronze Half-Litra AcRAGAS : Bronze of Phintias Gela : i^ Obol . Gela : Bronze Messana-Mamertini : Bronze Tyndaris : Bronze 'Alliance* Bronze . 'New* Coinage: Bronze . Hadranum : Bronze . Hadranum : Bronze . Agyrium : Bronze Agyrium : Bronze Centuripae : Bronze . Lipara : Bronze . Lipara : Bronze . LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS xv FIG. PAGE 63. Entella : Bronze 183 64. Campanians (?) : Litra 184 65. Campanians (?) : Bronze Litra .... 185 66. Syracuse: 'Pegasus' of Hiero II . . . . 187 67. Syracuse : 16 Litrae 196 68. Syracuse : 10 Litrae 196 69. AcRAGAS : 4 Litrae 19^ 70. Acragas : Bronze 199 71. LiPARA : Bronze Semis 203 72. Agrigentum : Bronze of Augustus . . . . 211 73. LiPARA : Bronze 215 74. Cephaloedium : Bronze 216 75. Solus : Bronze 219 76. Hybla Megala : Bronze 220 77. Petra : Bronze ... .... 220 78. AssoRus : Bronze 221 79. Haluntium : Bronze 222 80. Uncertain Bronze 223 COINS OF ANCIENT SICILY INTRODUCTION Among the many students of ancient life, and the many who, though they cannot be called students, are yet aware that there is much in ancient life worthy of their attention, there are not a few to whom Greek antiquities of any kind, in the concrete sense, are an unknown quantity. There are also many who, familiar as they may be with other branches of archaeology, are somewhat bewildered by the complexity and technicality with which numismatic studies are encumbered. It may therefore not be out of place to devote a few introductory pages to explaining such technicalities as are unavoidable even in the most superficial treatment of Greek coins. We need not here concern ourselves to find an adequate definition of the thing 'coin,' or to delimit the province of the study of numismatics. It is suffi- cient to understand that the coins which we shall meet with are pieces of metal adjusted to certain weights, issued with a distinguishing mark by the -^^ 2 INTRODUCTION authorities of various independent states, to serve as a medium of exchange. The metals which will concern us are in the first instance silver, in the next gold, bronze, and a mixture of gold and silver known as electrum. The order in which we have mentioned these metals is practically the order of their appearance in Sicilian coinage ; but it must be remembered that, long before the invention of coins, gold, and in many cases bronze, circulated by weight as uncoined metal. And so we come to the second point in our rough definition, and to the question of weight standards. The brief excursion into the thorny byways of metrology made in the first chapter will probably be amply sufficient for the taste of most readers. It will, however, give an indication, though slight, of the fact that coin-standards often throw considerable light on the commercial and political relations between the different states of antiquity. But it was not enough that the coins should be of a certain weight; some guarantee was necessary to show that the metal was good, and to save the trouble of weighing each coin whenever it changed hands. Such a guarantee was afforded by the mark of the issuing authority. The piece of metal was given a certain shape and design by one of two methods. Either it was cast in a mould, which was of the right size to produce a cast of the required MATTER AND FORM OF COINS 3 weight, and which imparted to it the desired form and design ; or else a piece of metal of the right weight (known as the flan or blank) was first cast, and then the required designs were impressed on it in relief by means of metal dies, in which the designs were engraved in intaglio. The former, or casting process, was in use in Central Italy in the earliest period of the coinage, when the currency consisted of large pieces of cast bronze. The second process (called 'striking,' although that word only describes the latter stage of it) was almost universal throughout the Greek world. Now this process of first casting the blank or flan, and then striking it with dies, produces many peculiarities, according to the different methods adopted in various parts of the world; and these peculiarities go to make up what the numismatist calls the ' fabric ' of the coin. The form given to the blank by the initial process of casting was naturally obliterated by the pressure of the dies; only on the edge of the struck coin may there be preserved a relic of the original form, in the shape of a little projection. The mould, in most early Sicilian coins, was apparently spherical, and made in two equal halves. The projection was formed by the metal flowing into the joint between the two halves of the mould ; on the faces of the B 2 4 INTRODUCTION coin it was of course obliterated by the dies, but on the edge it escaped destruction '. This feature is more prominent in SiciHan coins than in those of any other part of the Greek world. The Greeks, indeed, took little trouble about the shape of their coins, as long as the weight was right and the design recognizable. They were excessively care- less about the process of striking. They used no collar to hold the mqtal in place and preserve the circular shape of the coin ; and the pressure of the dies caused the flans to spread irregularly, and often to split. The blank or flan was placed — as a rule, in a heated condition— on the lower die, which was let into an anvil; the upper die was held over it, and struck with a hammer. Very often the coin moved slightly between the first and the succeeding blows, and the later blows did not efface all traces of the first impression, so that what are called double-struck coins were produced. Some- times the coin is struck to one side, so that a good part of the design is ' off" the flan.' It is, in fact, an exception to find the design absolutely complete. ^ If the blank was placed on the anvil in such a position that the ridge was in a horizontal plane, then the ridge would be preserved all round the edge of the coin. But this would have produced a thin ragged edge to the coin ; more usually, therefore, the plane of the ridge was inclined, or even vertical, so that only two small projections remained after striking. FABRIC 5 The dies themselves were probably made of com- paratively soft metal, and broke and v^ore out easily. To this fact we owe the enormous variety of repre- sentations of the same type which is characteristic of Greek coins. The lower die, which was let into the anvil, pro- duced what is called the obverse side of the coin. The upper die produced the reverse. Down to the fourth century B.C., the reverse die was made smaller than the surface of the blank, so that it left an incuse impression, the edges of the blank rising up around it. In most parts of the Greek world the upper die was at first square in shape, so that the incuse impression was also rectangular. But the Sicilians, almost from the first, adopted a circular die, with the result that the ' incuse square ' is hardly seen on Sicilian coins. One or two early coins, such as the first issues of Himera, Zancle, Syracuse, and Selinus, have it. In later times, the upper die was made so large that it covered the whole surface of the blank, and the reverse was then only differentiated from the obverse by a slight concavity of surface. Numismatists have become accustomed to use the terms ' obverse ' and ' reverse ' without regard to their technical significance. Strictly speaking, the head on such a coin as the Damareteion (PI. II. 6) is on the reverse^ although it is almost universally spoken 6 INTRODUCTION of as the obverse type. The reason for this laxity of expression is that on most later coins the head (divine or human) stands on the obverse. Since the head was usually treated in higher relief than the re- verse type, the strain on the die was correspondingly greater, and the die with the head was therefore placed where it would receive the greater support from the anvil below it and around its edges. Most numismatists have thus formed a habit, difficult to discard, of thinking of the side of a coin which bears the head as necessarily the obverse, unless the incuse impression is very deep; and in Sicily it is usually shallow. In this volume, the technical significance of the terms obverse (anvil- side) and reverse (upper-side) has been borne in mind. The dies produced on the blank what as a whole is included in the term 'design.' This consisted essen- tially of a 'type,' which could be accompanied by symbols and by an inscription ; and the whole could be enclosed in a border. The whole space enclosed in the border, or, when there is no border, the surface of the coin, is, so far as it is not occupied by the type, regarded as the 'field'; but from the field itself a subsidiary portion, the segment of the circle below the type, is sometimes cut off" by a line ; this segment is known as the ' exergue.' I ■ DESIGN AND TYPE 7 As regards the type, it is unnecessary here to embark on a classification, or to discuss the primary reasons which inspired the selection by a particular city of a particular type; to ask whether the type was selected because it was the badge of the city, or the emblem of the chief deity, or the representation of a commodity, a certain amount of which was equal in value to the coin. Different answers would have to be returned in the case of different cities. The one point which we have to grasp is that, even where the origin of the types may have been commercial, these types yet became, in the time with which we are concerned, connected with the religious cults of the state. To the ordinary person, who knew nothing and cared less about origins, the types had then nothing but a religious significance. Now, to the historian, the light in which a people regard a fact is of more importance, in discovering the springs of action, than the scientific truth about that fact; and for the student of numismatics who works from the standpoint of history, art, or religion, it is more essential to know that the Naxians regarded the bunch of grapes as a symbol of the wine-god, than to know, or assume, that the coin originally represented the value of a certain quantity of wine indicated in some way by the bunch of grapes. This may be" admitted without in any way depreciating the value 8 INTRODUCTION of the study of the origins of primitive coin-types, as apart from their significance in the period with which we are concerned. The field of the coin, and the exergue, some- times contain what in the language of numismatists are known as ' symbols \' These minor elements of the design fulfil various purposes. They must in the first place be distinguished from the adjuncts which are directly related to the type, such as the panther which accompanies a Dionysus, or the eagle in the hand of Zeus. Such adjuncts are distinguished from the true symbol, in the numism- atic sense, by the fact that the person or thing of which they are the attributes is represented as the type in the same design ; whereas the true numism- atic symbol belongs not to the main type, but to something not otherwise represented. It may be the sign of the monetary magistrate who issued the coin, or of the ruler of the state — as I have tried to show in the case of the triskeles in the coinage of Agathocles ; ^ The word ' symbol ' will of course be found used in numismatic literature in a wider sense also ; the caduceus used as a type by itself, for instance, may be explained as the ^symbol' of Hermes. But no mystic meaning is supposed to be inherent in such 'symbols.' Some of them may have been worshipped in the place of the gods they represent, as the thunderbolt certainly was. But, in thus describing them, the numismatist merely means that these objects are figured with the aim of caUing up to the mind the deity, local or other, with whom they are locally associated. SYMBOLS AND INSCRIPTIONS 9 or it may represent some historical event, as possibly does the pistrix on the coins of Hiero. Sometimes, however, it is so drawn into connexion with the main type that it loses its separate symbolism and becomes an essential part of the main design ; thus the panoply on the ^ medallions ' of Syracuse gives significance to the otherwise commonplace type of the victorious chariot and four. The study of coin-inscriptions is an important de- partment of numismatics. The forms of the letters, the use of this or the other alphabet, may be of the utmost value in determining the date of a coin. These are questions which we shall have, for the most part, to ignore, as leading us into the obscurest corners of the subject. It is necessary, however, to warn the uninitiated that the alphabet and ortho- graphy which they find on early coins are not those made familiar by modern texts. Down to the last years of the fifth century E may be used for e, h, and ei, and O for 0, co and ou, although the long vowel signs H and A begin to make their way into the alphabet, sometimes with curious results, some twenty or thirty years earlier. In the meaning of the inscriptions there is great variety. They may consist of the 'ethnic' adjective, used either in agreement with a suppressed word for 'coin,' as FEAAION (jeTpabpaxMov) i. e. ' Geloan tetradrachm ' ; or in the lo INTRODUCTION genitive plural, to show that the coin belongs to the people or the ruler who issued it, as ^YPAKO^IAN 'coin of the Syracusans/ or lEPANO^ 'coin of Hiero/ In the period before the introduction of the long vowel signs, it is often difficult to decide in which of the two cases the word is meant to be understood. Again, we may have the name of the city, 1vV^ 38 THE EARLIEST COINAGE meant to represent the shape of the harbour. This is the type of the obverse; the reverse of the earliest coins shows merely the same type incuse. At first sight unremarkable, this last fact attains historical import- ance when we remember that the only Greek coins that represent incuse on the reverse (the type which is given in relief on the obverse) belong to a federal coinage issued by certain cities in southern Italy, under some sort of commercial agreement. It follows therefore that the Chalcidian Zancle, the nearest to Italy of Sicilian cities, was obliged in some degree to come into line with Rhegium and the powerful Achaean colonies, Croton, Metapontum, and others. These incuse coins of Zancle were soon, however, replaced by a more ordinary sort (Fig. i), which have Fig. I. Zancle: Drachm. for reverse type a small scallop-shell. On some of them (PI. I. 2) the sickle-shaped object on the obverse is broad, and adorned at intervals with projections. That these are meant to represent towers or buildings on the edge of the harbour, as Mr. Arthur Evans has suggested, we may hesitate to admit; but no better ZANCLE. NAXOS. HIMERA 39 explanation has been given. The compHcated arrangement of spaces on the reverse of the coins is probably without special significance; the end of the die with which the reverse was struck was cut up in order to give it a firmer grip on the blank, and this disposition of areas served the same purpose as the 'mill-sair incuse square, which we shall meet with presently. The earliest types of Naxos (PI. I. 3) are connected with the wine-god Dionysus, whose worship, while naturally important in this vine-producing district, was probably in the first instance brought from the Aegean island of Naxos (where coins with the wine-cup type prove that it flourished). We find on the coins of the Sicilian port an exceedingly archaic head of Dionysus with pointed beard, wreathed with the Dionysiac ivy. On the reverse is the inscription N AX I ON, and a vine-twig with a bunch of grapes. Finally, Himera (PL I. 4) has a type — the cock — which by a not very satisfactory conjecture is usually explained as a pun on the name of the place, the cock being the bird that ushers in the day {hemera). Since the healing baths near Himera were famous, it is perhaps more reasonable to explain the cock as the bird sacred to the healing- god who must have been worshipped there. The 40 THE EARLIEST COINAGE cock, we know, was sacred to Asklepios. The reverse of the eariiest coins of Himera has the 'mill-sair incuse' impression, so-called from the treatment of its four quarters so as to represent the sloping sails of a windmill. Slightly later, but still within our first period, are the coins on which a hen appears as the reverse type (PL I. 5). The earliest coins are uninscribed, or else have one or two letters, which have not been adequately explained, but which do not seem to represent the name Himera. On the later coins with the hen the town name is generally written HI ME, but this is sometimes replaced by an inscription which has long been a puzzle. Mr. George Macdonald has recently shown that there is no substantial founda- tion for the usual reading lATON, and that the letters seem, in part at least, to represent the legend 50TEP ('Saviour'), written backwards. This word, which appears on later coins of Himera (PI. IV. 5), may be an epithet of the chief deity worshipped at the place, or more probably of the local nymph or personification of the city — for we find it written beside her on the later coins, and Aeschylus and Sophocles give evidence that this masculine form can be used as a name of the goddess Tyche, the Fortune of the State. The weights of the coins described above are HIMERA. COIN-STANDARDS 41 peculiar among the standards in use in Sicily, and we may pause here for a moment to consider them in connexion with the question of Sicilian standards in general. The weights, which correspond to those of the coins of Cyme and Rhegium on the Italian coast, appear to belong to the system known as Aeginetic, from the fact that the coins of Aegina are the most important currency conforming to it. The drachm of this standard weighs about 90 grains troy — the weight in our period of the largest coins of the three Sicilian cities just mentioned ^ But the silver of the other Sicilian cities belongs to another system, called the Euboic-Attic, because the early coins of Euboea and Athens are among its chief representatives. Now the four-drachm piece in this system weighed about 270 grains troy, and contained 24 obols. It follows that three Aeginetic drachms of 90 grains each were equiva- lent to one Euboic-Attic tetradrachm of 270 grains, while each Aeginetic drachm contained about 8 obols ol the Euboic-Attic standard, the two systems thus working conveniently into each other. It is true that Dr. Imhoof-Blumer regards these ^ A curious specimen of Zancle in the Ward Collection (no. 202) weighs 146-3 grains troy. As it is much worn, it may once have represented an Aeginetic didrachm ; but the loss by wear (about 33 grains) seems excessive ; and it is best to await the discovery of a better preserved specimen. 42 THE EARLIEST COINAGE apparently Aeginetic drachms as really thirds of the Euboic-Attic tetradrachm, or Euboic- Attic octobols; the division of the large coin into thirds instead of halves and quarters being in his view suggested by a similar divisional system at Corinth. But the weights of certain small coins which do not fit into the Euboic-Attic standard have been shown to be unfavourable to this theory. Whatever be the solution of the difficulty, so great was the import- ance of the cities which used the Euboic-Attic standard, that by the clo^e of our first period the three Chalcidian cities^had abandoned their original standard and fallen into line with their rivals. But before the advent of the Greeks, Sicily had possessed a standard of its own, based on the pound or litra of bronze. For bronze was in Sicily, as in Italy, the standard metal of native commerce. The litra of bronze corresponded in value to about 13J grains troy of silver, and a silver coin of this weight was consequently known as the silver litra. Even during the ^incuse' period of the Zanclaean coinage, silver litrae were issued, as the Aeginetic could not be harmonized with the native system. On the other hand, since this silver litra was just one-twentieth of the Euboic-Attic tetradrachm of 270 grains, it was easy for the Greeks to bring the Euboic-Attic system into harmony with that of COIN-STANDARDS. SYRACUSE 43 the Sicel natives. The union of the tv^ may be conveniently expressed in the following table : — Euhoic- Attic name. Sicel name. Wt. in grains troy. Decadrachm 50-litra piece (>is Tetradrachm 20-litra piece 270 Didrachm lo-litra piece 135 Drachm 5-litra piece 675 Litra 135 Obol 11-25 The three Chalcidian cities having once adopted a coinage of their own, it was inevitable that their friends and rivals should follow suit. Syracuse above all, but also Acragas, Camarina, Catana, Gela, Leontini, and Selinus were coining, most of them plentifully, before the end of our first period; even the half barbarous Eryx in the far West has left us coins with Greek inscriptions of this early date. I The first issue of Syracusan coins is placed by Mr. Head in the time of the Gamori. Holm on the other hand is inchned to think that such an important innovation must have been introduced by the democracy after the expulsion of the oligarchs. Whatever its date, the Syracusan coinage begins with designs (PI. I. 6), which are the prototypes of the composition of the famous Syracusan 'medal- lions' of later times. On the obverse is a four-horse 44 THE EARLIEST COINAGE chariot, the horses walking slowly ^ By a con- vention betraying the inability of the engraver to represent in so small a space all four horses, only two are really delineated, their outlines being doubled. The chariot is one of the racing-cars with which so many Sicilians, tyrants or private citizens, gained victories at the Greek games. {/Above the chariot are the letters 5VPA^or IVPA- [^90^ION. ' The earliest tetradrachm has on its reverse merely the square mark of the die, divided into four quarters. This issue is as yet represented \ (^ by a unique specimen in a private collection. On the reverse of the next issue is a female head treated in a style a good deal more advanced than that of the Naxian Dionysus, and placed in the centre of an incuse square which is treated in the 'mill-sair manner. Whom does the head represent? Arguing from later coins we might say that it is the goddess of Victory; or < the nymph Arethusa, whose fresh waters rose up in the island of Ortygia, on which the original Syracuse was founded ; or even the goddess Persephone, ^ In addressing Hiero in his fifth ode as evfioipe SvpaKoo-tW itttto- 8tv>jTo)v o-T/aaraye, Bacchylides of course refers to the Syracusan devotion to horse-racing. It has been thought that the chariot- group of the coins was in the poet*s mind ; but it was not until after his time that the treatment of the group on the coins became lively enough to justify his epithet ' whirled along by horses.' SYRACUSE 45 whose worship was so prominent in Sicily. Yet another suggestion is Artemis, who from primitive times had been worshipped in Ortygia. Of these interpretations the second and the fourth are the more probable, but none is certain. As time goes on, and the artist's hand gains in cunning, a great change is perceptible in the style of the Syracusan coins (PL I. 7). The treatment of the horses is less wooden ; but, what is more significant, the head, which fills so modest a place on the earliest coins, is increased in size, and generally attains importance. It will be long indeed before it is promoted to the obverse side of the coin, except on the smallest denominations ; but on pieces struck toward^ the end of our present period it already attracts as much attention as the obverse type. The head, as representing the goddess or nymph wor- shipped on the island of Ortygia, is surrounded by dolphins. It is also encircled by a faint line along which the heads of the dolphins, and the letters of the inscription are ranged. / The inscription stillX yi^ preserves the archaic sign 9 (koppa), which towards the end of our period is superseded by the K (kappa). On the obverse the chariot is marked as victorious by the addition of a figure of Victory, hovering above the horses, and about to place a crown on their heads. ci^ 46 THE EARLIEST COINAGE The obverse-type of the two-drachm piece (PL I. 8) represents not a four-horse chariot, but, more appro- priately, two horses, one of them led by a man riding the other. The drachm (PI. I. 9) has, as we should expect, a single horseman. On this and on the smaller coins, the litra and the obol (none of which, probably, is older than about 485 b. c), the dolphins are dispensed with. Further, on the litra (PI. I. 10) and obol (PI. I. 11) the head is transferred to the obverse, which is seldom, if ever, the case on the larger coins until the end of the century. The obol has for its distinguishing type the chariot-wheel; while the litra has the sepia or squid. This last type — having nothing to do with the chariot or horses — at once marks out the coin on which it occurs as belonging in reality to a different system from the others. We may now pass from Syracuse— where by this time the old democracy had been replaced by the brilliant rule of Gelo — to some of the other cities. In 494 there was a sudden change in the affairs of Zancle. Much is obscure in the history of this period; but the best explanation seems to be that Anaxilas, the tyrant of Rhegium across the straits, induced certain Samians, who were on their way to find a home in Sicily, to seize by treachery the city of Zancle ; that he colonized it with a mixture of SYRACUSE. ZANCLE-MESSANA 47 j ] Samians and Messenians (from his old home of Messene in Greece), and gave the name of Messene \ to the new settlement. Consequently, the types of i a lion's head facing, and of a calf's head in profile i (PI. I. 12), both of which remind one of Samos, ^ appear on coins struck in this city, together with the inscription MESSENION, which by its form be- t> trays the Ionian origin of the majority of the -j^ inhabitants. But suddenly there comes a change ; j new coins are struck, with the types of a racing- ! car drawn by mules, and a hare (PL I. 13) ; and very shortly afterwards, the second vowel in the name of the people is changed from e to a, so that we have the inscription MESSANION (PI. I. 14). In other words the Ionian inhabitants are no longer allowed to have their way and say as op- posed to the Dorians. The types are the types of Anaxilas, who is said by Aristotle to have intro duced hares into Sicily, and, having won the mule- car race at Olympia, to have placed the mule-car and the hare on the coinage of Rhegium. What he himself did at Rhegium he made his dependants do at Messene. Then, a few years before the close of our period, occurred a breach with the Samians in Messene ; they were expelled, and the Doric element in the new population became prepon- derant, not without exerting an influence on the 48 THE EARLIEST COINAGE dialect in which the inscription on the coins was written. Of the other Chalcidian colonies, Leontini can only have begun to issue coins towards the end of our period. Perhaps, being an inland cit}^, it did not rise to importance so early as its neighbours on the coast. The obverse type of the tetradrachm (PL I. 15) is a chariot, usually proceeding at a slow pace, Victory flying above the horses ; on the reverse, the badge of the city, a lion's head with open jaws, is surrounded by four barley-corns, significant of the fertility of the Leontine plains. The inscription is AEONTINON. Whether the lion's head was merely suggested by the name of the city, as is the case with canting types in modern heraldry, or whether it was adopted because the animal was sacred to Apollo, of the importance of whose worship at Leontini the later coins give ample evidence, is a question which cannot be discussed with much profit. The smaller coins oi Leontini are mostly of later style, and fall into the next period. The issues of Catana begin with some remarkable pieces struck towards or perhaps just after the close of our period. Their style (PL I. 16) is so advanced that we should be tempted to date them later, did we not happen to know that the Catanaeans were expelled from their city in 476 B.C. by the tyrant Hiero. The ^ ^ PLATE I PAGE 1. Zancle: drachm 37 2. „ „ (obv.) 38 3. Naxos: „ 39 4. Himera : „ 39 5- » yy (""ev.) 40 6. Syracuse : tetradrachm 43? 44 7- >» » 45 8. „ didrachm (obv.) 46 9. „ drachm 4^ 10. „ litra 46 11. „ obol (rev.) 46,111 12. Zancle- M e ssana : tetradrachm 47 13. „ „ didrachm 47 14. „ „ tetradrachm. Ward Collection ... 47 15. Leontini : tetradrachm 4^ 16. Catana: „ 4^ 17. Acragas : didrachm . . 49> 5*^ •ascnp^ was halcid' a only oj^ our id not ao-h .-^ V6 8e QE «£ Oj. 4^^. :^. 24^ di. d^. d|. Ill t'-r bccausL . iroportanf 8|. (oins- giv . (.Tdo) „ ■[' inidge of . T.vdf) the„ fertility o| the ;M:^o)JMisi^6ifa;^^ig^estec| by he casc^#^. c:\vMng t^pes . BiJil „ .hi V .-• ,whe|1^|o^ was^ adoj^tod - v.ol^.^..^u .m.i.£.Di..i3i oVitini;;the ;|ater iBnBifiD .di ftirioBibib raB^BioA .ri /1^ IV^ V> V. pelled Plate I ^— ' ^^^'^-^ CHAPTER II FROM HIMERA TO THE ASSINARUS B.C. 480-413 As the starting-point of the second chapter in the history of SiciHan coinage, we choose the epoch-making victory of the Greeks, led by Gelo of Syracuse and Thero of Himera, over the Cartha- ginian Hamilcar near the latter city. This victory was the Salamis of Sicily, and Gelo was regarded, and justly, as the saviour of Greek civilization in the West. From this time onwards the city which he ruled easily took precedence over all other Sicilian cities, and its political predominance is paralleled by the enormous preponderance of its coinage as compared with that of the rest of the island. The most remarkable of all Syracusan coins, it may be said without much hesitation, are the large ten-drachm pieces known as Damareteia^Ph II. 6). The name is connected with Damareta, the wife of the tyrant Gelo. One ancient authority fDiodorus)- 54 FROM HIMERA TO THE ASSINARUS says that the coins were struck out of a present made to the queen by the defeated Carthaginians, for whom she had obtained somewhat easier terms than they could have expected. -Others -(as Pollux) sa y th a t- the coins were struck out of treasure provided by Damareta and the Syracusan women in aid of the cause of the Greek against the barbarian. We may reconcile the two statements if we suppose that after the war the sacrifice was recompensed by a portion of the treasure obtained by Damareta from the Carthaginians; the new Damareteia, in which such a compensation would be made, would thus be con- nected in the memory of men not only with the gift made to Damareta, but also with the sacrifice which she and the women of Syracuse had shown them- selves ready to offer to their country. In any case it is fairly certain — although a distinguished histo- rian, who is not a numismatist, takes a different view — that none of the Damareteia could have been struck before the battle of Him era. The obverse type of the Damareteion is the vic- torious four-horse chariot. The long robe of the driver has generally caused his sex to be mis- taken by those who are unacquainted with the peculiarities of Greek dress; but the discovery of the bronze charioteer at Delphi should go some way to dispel this error. As for the horses, these SYRACUSE 55 coins without doubt represent a very great advance beyond what we have seen accompHshed hitherto. But still, in his attempt to attain that quality which the Greeks called charis — our word 'grace' does not well express it — the artist has revolted a little too far from the sturdy forms of his predecessors. The proportions of both charioteer and horses, for instance, are too slim. In the exergue he has placed a 'wild lion racing/ — emblem, as without undue fanci- fulness it is interpreted, of the subdued and fleeing forces of Africa. The ' reverse has a superb design. The head of a goddess (probably Victory), wearing a simple earring and necklace and crowned with a laurel-wreath, her hair caught up behind by a plain cord and hanging in a heavy loop on the neck, is surrounded, first with a faint circular line ; next by the letters of the inscription ^lYI^AKOCION the {koppa- has now finally disappeared from the inscription)- arranged in groups of two and three letters ; then by four dolphins, whose ample proportions contrast curiously with the reduced dolphins of the later Syra- cusan issues. Finally, the rising up of the metal round the edges of the die gives a kind of natural, unconventional border to the whole design. When we consider the detail of the head, we see that all the exaggerated characters of the more archaic art are softened. The eye, it is true, is not yet shown in ^ 56 FROM HIMERA TO THE ASSINARUS profile, and the ear is a little too high up ; there is still a trace of what was once the 'archaic grin/ due to an unskilful attempt to show the modelling of the cheek and mouth. Here the attempt has resulted in a smile, a little prim, perhaps, but not unpleasing. The linear circle, which we have already seen on a predecessor of the Damareteion, has been well explained by Evans as the survival of the circular margin enclosing the small head on the early Syracusan tetradrachms, ' partly, no doubt, preserved because it served a useful purpose in defining the outlines of the head,' and, we may add, in giving a line to which the letters of the inscription should be ranged. It would be difficult to find any monu- ment which conveys a better idea than this coin of the grace and refinement, the faithful and careful workmanship, the combination of formality with the promise of freedom, which are characteristic of the best archaic art of Greece. Less striking than the ten-drachm piece is the ordinary denomination of four drachms, of exactly the same types] (PI. H. 7)^ When we re- member that the various denominations were usually accompanied by varying types, it seems curious that some specially distinctive design was not invented for the Damareteion. But the novelty of the piece, the general interest its issue SYRACUSE 57 must have excited, and especially its great size, * made it quite unnecessary to differentiate it in this way. The same phenomenon presents ^ itself in !^ (y the case of the large English gold coins of \ modern times, which bear the same types as the sovereign. We pass from Gelo and the Damareteion — his- torically the most interesting, and at the same time one of the most fascinating, of all Sicilian coins — to Hiero and the coins of his reign. Now, and more especially after the fall of the tyrants, we meet with an extraordinary succession of variations in the standard types of female head and four-horse chariot. The improvement in the art can be traced by a series of fine gradations, each stage occupying but a few years'! (PL II. 8 foil). ■ Life and vigour gradually find their way into the delineation of the horses; the charioteer's figure acquires character — although as often as not he is 'off the flan,' thanks to the careless striking of the coin ; and, above all, the difficult task of representing the flying figure of Victory is eventually solved, so far as it is possible to solve it in art. On the reverse the head con- tinues to increase in size, and the dolphins become smaller. One of the early tetradrachms of this period (PI. II. 8) shows excellently most of the weaknesses of the archaic art; but it is worth /lfrl^' 58 FROM HIMERA TO THE ASSINARUS noting that in the treatment of the eye the artist has attempted, if he has not quite mastered, the representation of the profile view. In the exergue is a sea-monster, known as the pistrix. Its appear- ance as a symbol on these coins has been explained by Mr. Head as an allusion to the great sea-victory won by Hiero over the Etruscans in 474. We r have, it is true, already seen (p. 49) that the pistrix / occurs as a symbol on coins of Catana which ( cannot be later than 476. But at Catana the y symbol is isolated, whereas at Syracuse it is found T^ K on a great number of issues spreading over a series of years. We are justified therefore in accepting Mr. Head's explanation on the ground that at Syracuse the symbol seems to have some historical significance, whereas at Catana no such significance can be proved. Although introduced on the Syracusan coins by Hiero, the symbol did not disappear with his death ; for there is good reason to suppose that some of the more advanced coins displaying it belong to the period of the democracy. The head-dress of the nymph or goddess on this coin is comparatively simple — a mere diadem of pearls, with the ends of the hair caught up within it; and the hair itself is treated as if it were wire. The engraver has realized the inadequacy of the PLATE II I. 2. 3- 4- 5- 6. 7- 8. 9- lO. II. 12. 13- 14. 15- 16. 17- Acragas : didrachm .... Eryx: drachm Selinus : didrachm (rev.) Gela: tetradrachm . . . . Selinus: didrachm . . . . Syracuse : decadrachm (Damareteion) tetradrachm (rev.) (rev.) PAGE 49,50 5^ 52 50 52 53 f. 56 57,58 59 59 59 59 59 59 59 59 59 VRUS rcr\\ n II 3TAJ4 «a'n , Qe- . Ql . ^V .roduc ibol-.d i beibib : : j ^:.y 31^ mri^Bi bib ; gj/n^Ja^ |.^ i - ■ ibsij3t isJbO 4 i ' ncccptiip : iistoricffl v (.^3«)r:o sych sign\fican£f^ u .£1 • „ yr^fiisan coins by eated Plate II SYRACUSE 59 old-fashioned dotted lines, but his attempt at the new method is unsuccessful. Our next coin (PI. II. 9) shows a more pleasing result. Here the artist has caught the soft effect of the mass of hair ; but he still has considerable diffi- culty with the lips, and in attempting to give cha- racter to the lower part of the face has added an element of coarseness. He has also made another experiment in representing the eyelashes. His model may have had beautiful eyelashes, but there are limits to the representation of minute features in art, and most of the later engravers wisely pro- nounced this experiment a failure. We must be content merely to illustrate (PI. II. 10 foil, and III. 1-5), without describing in detail, some of the long series of coins which bring us down to about 440 b.c, when a new feature (the signed coins) will attract our attention. Most people unacquainted with Greek art, as well as those to whom only its monumental side is familiar, are astonished at the modernity— as it is called — of these heads. As a matter of fact the coins do but show that the Greek artist knew how to give a life-like representation of his model when he had the chance. ' Extreme simplicity, unpre- tending vigour of work, which claims no admira- tion either for minuteness or dexterity, and suggests 6o FROM HIMERA TO THE ASSINARUS no idea of effort at all ; refusal of extraneous orna- ment, and perfectly arranged disposition of counted masses in a sequent order, . . . this is all you have to be pleased with ; neither will you ever find, in the best Greek Art, more.' These words of Ruskin^ are, in their general bearing, the most instructive of commentaries on Sicilian art of the middle of the fifth century. With all its faults, its lack of ideal beauty, the healthy work of this period is in some ways more satisfactory than even the magnificent -(V achievements of the age of Cimon and Euaenetus, \^^^^ because we cannot trace in it the foreboding of decay. x^ The Syracusan coins of the last third of the fifth century, and of the early years of the fourth century, in other words of the finest period of Syracusan art, are distinguished by the fact that the artists employed to engrave the dies were allowed to introduce their signatures. To this fact alone we owe our knowledge of the names of the men who produced the most beautiful series of coins in the whole history of coinage. Among the earliest to sign his name on a coin was the artist Eumenes. A glance shows the im- provement, as regards the treatment of the head, on the work of earlier engravers. His signature is sometimes placed {irv the form EVMHNOV) over ^ Aratra Pentelkt, § 119. r SYRACUSE: EUMENES; SOSION 6i the forehead on the band which confines the hair 4Pl7-fflv-6). On other coins he signs in the field (PHH. 7, 9) or in the exergue. In the treatment of the horses he has attempted a further advance. He represents them in high action instead of walking or standing still; but the result is a some- what primitive composition in which the parallelism of the four sets of legs is anything but pleasing. In fact the clumsiness of the animals contrasts strikingly with the skilful handling of the flying Victory and of the driver. The exergual space formerly filled by the pistrix is, on Eumenes' coins, sometimes left vacant, sometimes occupied by opposed dolphins, a dolphin and fish, a scallop shell, or his signature. — ' We find the dies engraved by Eumenes combined with those of other artists ; but before dealing with the most important of these new engravers, his younger contemporary Euaenetus, we may consider the work of another less famous engraver. Sosion (^A^IAN) is represented by some rare tetradrachms (PI. III. 8). The signature^ is placed on the front- let of the head, as in the case of the early head by Eumenes, and the affinity between the styles ^ Dr. Regling, who has kindly examined the coin at Berlin, assures me that the name is Sosion, not Soson, as the Aberdeen specimen appears to read. p\' ;-i i^ ^■ 62 FROM HIMERA TO THE ASSINARUS of the two artists is striking. The chariot group on the obverse of these specimens is probably by Eumenes himself. The work of Euaenetus marks a great step for- ward in the treatment of the horses. As indicated above, we find him working first on dies which are combined with those of Eumenes. Thus we have (PI. Illr-g)- a head signed EYMENOY combined with a most skilfully composed chariot group from the hand of the future artist of the ' medallions ' 1<^ The furthest horse has broken his rein, which is tangled round his foreleg. Over the whole floats Victory, holding in her hands an oblong tablet, on which is written the name of Euae- netus (EYAINETO). The pride of the artist in his work may seem to us to have conquered his good taste; but the naivete of the method which he adopts to record his name is fully in accordance with the Greek habit of mind. In the exergue are two dolphins opposed, a symbol which is common at Syracuse in this period -(it already occurs on the ^x:oin by Eumenes and Sosion); and is also met with at Catana, where we shall subsequently have to consider its significance. — ^ The specimens of this coin are mostly ill-preserved on the obverse. A better impression of the same obverse die is found on the coin (PL III. lo) with the reverse also by Euaenetus. SYRACUSE: EUAENETUS 63 Another early specimen of the work of Euaenetus (PI. III. 10) is a pretty head, wearing a frontlet on which is a dolphin leaping over waves. The artist's signature- is placed in tiny letters on the belly of the dolphin before the lips of the nymph. The obverse is similar to that of the coin just before described. On a slightly later obverse signed by Euaenetus (PL III. 12) the horses are in higher action; and in the exergue the artist has placed a chariot-wheel, which we may suppose to have come off some defeated chariot. The artist's signature is written in microscopic characters along the exergual line. Here again we have the broken rein. The motif of the broken rein is thus a favourite fancy of Euaenetus in his early period. It would be hypercritical to suggest that, since such an accident would inevitably bring about disaster, the figure of Victory is hardly appropriate. Another artist whose dies are combined with \ ^ ^ ^^ £:/JTH< those of Eumenes signs himself EVO. He is inferior as an engraver to Euaenetus, and perhaps . somewhat his elder. But on the other hand he shows a decided taste for innovation; he has made the driver of his chariot -(PI. III. 11) a winged figure, apparently male, crowned by Victory, and in the exergue he has placed a beautiful 64 FROM HIMERA TO THE ASSINARUS figure of the sea-monster Scylla, with her fish's tail and the girdle of dogs around her waist. She holds her trident over her left shoulder, and extends her right hand towards a fish which swims away from her clutches; above her tail is a dolphin. The symbol has been not im- probably explained as an allusion to the naval success of the Syracusans and their allies over the Athenians in B.C. 425. In that year the latter lost ships in the engagements in the straits of Messana, which the sea-monster was supposed to haunt. It is easy to see the inferiority, in the composition of the group of horses on this coin, to the work of the great master Euaenetus. Phrygillus ^ho signs his name 4>PYriAA or 4>PY) is represented by two sets of coins. On the one -{PL III. i4)j his reverse die (a head of Persephone crowned with corn) is combined with an obverse by the artist Euth . . ., which has been already described. On the others (PL III. 13), which appear to be rather later in style, and may indeed date from the next period, we have the usual female head, with the hair in a 'sling'; and the locks which might hang down on the temples are brushed back so as to break the line of the band which comes "round the front of the head. The chariot group (Persephone, holding a torch. SYRACUSE. ACRAGAS 65 drives the car) on the reverse of this second group of coins by Phrygillus is an admirably balanced composition, apparently by the artist Euarchidas. All the signed coins which we have described above, with the probable exception of the later coins of Phrygillus, may be dated approximately between the years 430 and 415. We may now leave Syracuse and turn to the other cities and their coinage. Throughout this period the types of Acragas (eagle and crab) con- tinue the same, with very slight modifications ; and the coins must have been plentifully struck, for the prosperity of the place was enormous, both during the period succeeding the victory of Himera, while Thero was still tyrant, and after the establishment of a democracy in 472. Symbols, such as the rose (PI. III. 15); barley-corn, dolphin, now occur in the field of the reverse. The tetradrachms and didrachms of this period are supplemented by a number of smaller coins. The drachm (PI. III. 16), a^ being also a piece of five litrae, is inscribed P-EN, i. e. pentalitron. Some of the smaller denomi- nations have types differing from the larger — an eagle's head, a tripod, or merely five or two pellets to denote the value of the coin. Of greater interest than the coins of Acragas are those of Himera, the city of which the Acragantine fk 66 FROM HIMERA TO THE ASSINARUS Thero was in possession at the time of the defeat of the Carthaginians. During his possession of the city, which ended in 472, and presumably during the very short time that the incompetent Thrasy- daeus filled his dead father's place, coins were issued which neatly illustrate the relation of dependency in which Himera stood to Acragas ; for on the didrachms (PI. IV. i), while the cock and the name of Himera (HIMERA) stand on the obverse, the crab of Acragas serves as the reverse type. On the drachms with similar types the city-name is trans- ferred to the reverse. Another drachm (PL HI. 17), which belongs to the same period, has as its reverse-type, in place of the Acragantine crab, a knucklebone (astragalos), with the inscription HIMEPAION. The knucklebone and two pellets are the types of a tiny hexas or two-ounce piece of the same time. The use of the knucklebone in antiquity for the purpose of divination or the consulting of oracles, as well as for gaming, is well known; and it is possible that some such custom was connected with one of the Himeraean shrines. Gabrici has suggested that the use of astragaloi may have been widely pre- valent in Himera, since we know that one of the throws was named after the poet Stesichorus, a native (by most accounts) of the city. It would, PLATE III 6. 7. 8. 9- 10, II. 12. 13. 14. 15- 16. 17. Syracuse : tetradrachms (reverses) . tetradrachm (Eumenes) . ( „ rev.) PAGE 59 61 61 Acragas Himera drachm (Sosion, rev.). Aberdeen Universiiy {for- merly in the Davis Collection) (Eumenes, rev.) (Euaenetus) . . . . .63, (Euth . . ., Eumenes) .... (Euaenetus, obv.) (Phrygillus, Euarchidas) .... (Phrygillus, rev.) 61 61 99 63 63 64 64 65 65 66 ilMERA s'ARUS did/ f r Id Id umably during Tirtont Thrasy' . , ^ :-.^ issued -lation of dep^rir^pncy HI HTA.m \rr;!cr,T. - for .... Uie d the name (asei^v^i) ararfjBifafiiJa^i :-3a'.jo^Q .grab ^ " '-^M.)' 'jA^''''^^^«^v5 «^?fe^a6k' .(,V^-*iXioi2b» k ^)^•^he -igririt^.. Id. Id" ' fid (.V31 ^g9n3mij3) „ (e^naQiua ^ ^. . . dni3) ,_ „ (.Vdo ,81/lOi " .i;"plac6^ of The knsfcklefebne ,, afigBioA .gi fnrfiB-feny^hexa^ or . rpose of '^ well possible h one of ^^' d that / pre- ..c... v.-ne of y-.^i Stesichorus, ^< named after Plate III HIMERA 67 however, be fanciful to see in this fact an explana- tion of the coin-type. After the expulsion of the tyrants, an entirely new set of types appears at Himera. First, on the obverse (PL IV. 2), comes the familiar type of the four-horse chariot. But on the reverse (PI. IV. 3)! is a composition full of interesting local colour. A female figure, probably the local nymph, clad in a chiton and peplos, the folds of which are rendered with characteristic formality, stands pour- ing a libation from a libation-bowl over an altar; her unoccupied hand is raised, as she pronounces the invocation which accompanies the sacrifice. Balancing the altar, on the other side of her, is a pretty group of a small Silenus standing in front of a fountain, from the lion's mouth of which a stream of water falls on his body. He is obviously enjoying himself in the warm baths near Himera which were so famous in antiquity, and to the neighbourhood of which the inhabitants removed after the destruction of their city in 408. Hardly less interesting than this coin is another tetradrachm (PI. IV. 4), on which is represented Pelops (PEAOt); standing in his chariot. The appearance of the hero at Himera is unexplained, but we shall find a later coin suggesting a connexion between the Sicilian city and the Olympian festival of which F 2 V \ 68 FROM HIMERA TO THE ASSINARUS he was the founder. On the reverse, the nymph Himera-(iM£PA^is occupied with her peplos, which she is putting on over her chiton. The type is probably a mere study in the draped female figure. . On another coin — a didrachm (PL IV. 5) — we have a horseman riding sideways on a galloping horse. This represents a feat of horsemanship in which the anabates^ as he was called, leapt from his steed in full course, and ran beside it. The- 4nscription is fMEPAION; On the reverse of the same ^\ coin is the nymph Himera sacrificing)?^ she 4s-here- , ^called ^OTHP (instead of by the more usual feminine X — ^form of the epithet). The smaller coins have puzzling types. The half drachm (PI. IV. 6) shows a nude youth riding on a goat, holding a herald's wand or caduceus, and blowing a conch, while on the reverse is a figure of Victory (sometimes inscribed NIK A) flying, and carrying an aphlaston^ the ornament which decorated the stern of the ancient ship. There must be a reference to some victory in this type : not im- probably it alludes to the burning of the Cartha- ginian ships at the battle of Himera. Very possibly, toe, the pair of greaves (Kg.- 3) and helmet of the obols represent spoils from the same victory. The litra, again (Fig. 4), represents on one side a youth riding on a he-goat ; on the other, a strange beast, HIMERA. MESSANA 69 compounded of a bearded human head with goat's horns, Hon's feet, and bird's tail. It might be Fig. 3. Himera: Obol. Fig. 4. Himera : Litra. discreet to waive all attempt to explain this fantasy;^: b«^-we shall return to the subject in a- later- cbapterv Of even greater historical value than the coinage of Himera is that of Messana. That city was not freed from the power of Anaxilas and his house until the time of the general liberation in 461. It is probably to one of the episodes in the struggles with Rhegium in the second quarter of the century that we have to assign a coin of the usual types and legend, but with the syllable AO added on the reverse, in large letters, above the hare. Mr. Evans has shown that in all probability this syllable indi- cates the Italian city of Locri, in which, as the enemy of Rhegium, the Messanians would find a cordial ally. In the course of the democratic period a slight but significant variation is made in the type of the obverse. The male charioteer, who might be regarded as driving the chariot of the tyrant, is replaced by the personification of the city itself. 70 FROM HIMERA TO THE ASSINARUS She is, on some of the later coins (PlrHtV. 7), actually named ME^^ANA. Mr. Evans has shownj- f ^ 'jj hewm^^hstt me most important coin of th io peri od^ '/^ ^ ^historically speaking, is a remarkable tetradrachm fPt . IV. 0) which, if style and analogy with types of other cities furnish any criteria, cannot be dated much earlier than the middle of the fifth ; century. There stands, on the obverse, a vigorous figure of a god, with his chlamys or short cloak . arranged over his shoulders and arms in the , manner usual with the sea-god Poseidon, and brandishing in his right hand the thunderbolt — , a weapon not confined to Zeus, but sometimes wielded by the earth-shaking sea-god. Before him is an altar. On the reverse is a dolphin, with a scallop-shell beneath it, and above is the inscription DANKUAION. It is clear 'that, in this city of nicely balanced factions and perpetual revolutions, a turn of the wheel about that time gave the old Zanklaean element once more for a moment the upper hand' — hence the change in type and legend, and the reappearance of the dolphin as the main : type together with the sea-god of which it is but the symbol. r There exists another piece which bears out the i ^ ' theory that about the middle of the fifth century I Messana for a time changed its name to Zancle. MESSANA 71 This is a coin (PL IV. 9) struck at the ItaHan city of Croton, bearing the type of that city (the Apolhne tripod) on both sides, and the usual in- scription 9^^ o^ the obverse. But beside the reverse type is written DA, which, on the only probable interpretation, must stand for Zancle. The Zanclaean revolutionaries, therefore, sought help against their opponents from Croton, as the Messanians had found it in Locri. - — Mr. Evans has sought to detect political signi- fj^ ficance in the appearance at Syracuse and at Messana (PI. IV. 7) of the exergual symbol of two opposed dolphins, and to show that it was intro- duced by way of allusion to the alliance which was cemented between the two cities in 425 in face of the Athenian danger. The number of coins with this symbol in the exergue is so considerable that, on this hypothesis, their issue must, as Mr. Evans recognizes, have "continued for some time after the conclusion of peace between Messana and Athens in the next year — perhaps even after the advent of the Athenian expedition. But to judge from the comparatively stiff style of many of the coins of Messana with two dolphins, it seems more probable that in that city at least the symbol was adopted earlier than 425. The Chalcidian city of Naxos lost its indepen- 72 FROM HIMERA TO THE ASSINARUS dence early in the fifth century, arid while under the dominion first of the Geloan Hippocrates, and then of the Syracusans Gelo and Hiero, seems to * have struck no coins of its own. The pieces with which we have now to deal, although showing distinctly archaic features, can hardly be earlier than 476, when the inhabitants of Naxos were transferred to Leontini. We must therefore regard them as having been issued very soon after the expulsion of the tyrants in B.C. 461. The types continue to be connected with the worship of Dionysus, and the head on the tetradrachms of this period is amongst the most remarkable, although not the most pleasant representations of that god (PI. IV. 10). He is crowned with ivy, and his features still retain an archaic cast, which is in- tensified by the formal neatness of the whole rendering. But in the care with which the different qualities of the hair of the head, the moustache, and the beard are rendered, and in the way in which the border of dots is broken to allow parts of the design to escape beyond it, we see the marks of an original and thoughtful artist. The later representations of Dionysus tone down, as a rule, the sensual character of the god so well expressed in this head, or modify it in the direction of effeminacy. NAXOS 73 The reverse is very striking. A Silenus, one of the minor creations with which Greek fancy filled the train of the wine-god, is squatting on the ground. -We — have already -seen his fellow^ J^thing in the fountain at Himerar His snub- nosed, bestial features, with his pointed ear, rough hair, and equine tail, mark his position halfway between beast and man. Supporting himself on his left hand, he raises to his lips a two-handled cantharus full of wine. But most interesting is the treatment of the anatomy. The whole body is a study in muscle, not entirely suitable when the subject is a half-drunken Silenus in repose. All the muscles of the breast and abdomen are rendered in an almost exaggerated state of strain, a strain which, in this position, is only justified in the legs. The artist, in fact, has endeavoured to display all his knowledge of the anatomy of the human frame. It is instructive to compare with this coin the tetradrachm with similar types struck towards the end of our period (PI. IV. ii). All the formalism has disappeared from the treatment of the head of Dionysus. The hair is handled freely, its curling locks suggesting indeed the free use of unguents; the features .reproduce admirably the effects of sensuality before it destroys the beauty of the face. 74 FROM HIMERA TO THE ASSINARUS On the reverse we can see just the same advance in the body of the Silenus, with its softly rounded ^ forms. Note too the introduction of ornamental i details in the ivy and thyrsus. Vj The legend on the earlier issues of this period is N AXIOM, while on the later the third letter has the \ form Z. 'he coins of Catana during this period are of great historical importance. A small coin struck just before 476 B.C., or, possibly, just after the -restoration 0^461, shows a bald head of Silenus, and, on the reverse, a thunderbolt of rather unusual shape, with two curled wings (PL IV. 12). The coin is inscribed KATANE. Now we know from various historical references that in 476 Hiero expelled the inhabitants of Catana, and placed in the city a colony of Syracusans on whom he could depend for support in case of trouble arising in his own city. He changed the name of Catana to Aetna, and this name it retained until the restoration of the exiles in 461. To fill this gap come some remarkable coins. First there are small pieces with similar types to those just described, but reading A I THAI >^ l^^j 1 (^^g- S)'! B^^ much more ex- ^^^^ traordinary is a unique tetra- FlG. S- CaTANA-AeTNA. j 1 /t^i t\t \ ' J.-L. ^ drachm (PI. IV. 13), now m the collection bequeathed by Baron Hirsch to the Brussels CATANA-AETNA 75 Museum. On the obverse, which has the inscrip- tion AITNAION, is a vigorous head of a bald Silenus, with the usual semi-bestial features, and a full beard; an ivy-wreath, treated in a manner more decorative than naturalistic, Hes on his bald pate. Below is a scarabaeus-beetle, of the kind which an ancient commentator on Aristophanes says was found of great size on Mount Aetna. On the reverse is the figure of Zeus, under whose tutelage the city was placed. He is seated, holding in his left hand a thunderbolt of shape similar to that found on the small coins just described ; his right hand rests, not on an ordinary sceptre, but on a natural branch, probably — as the district was so rich in wine — taken from a vine. A lion's or a panther's skin — the panther is an attendant of the wine-god — covers his seat. Before him is his sacred eagle, perched on the summit of a pine — again a touch of local colour, seeing that in antiquity pine-forests covered the slopes of Aetna. There are few coins which so completely fit in with all that history tells us of the circumstances of the period when they were struck, as does this curious coin of Hiero's short-lived colony. The expelled Hieronians retired to Inessa, another spot on the slopes of Aetna, to which they again gave the name of the volcano. We shall meet with \ b'" 76 FROM HIMERA TO THE ASSINARUS their coins at a later period. The restored Catanaeans now produced, among other less important pieces, a fine series of tetradrachms, reading katanaiON or l75 14. Catana: tetradrachm -i^jjjjat^J^ 15. „ drachm (Euaenetus). Ward Collection . ^^»^ ti SINARUS nVi^C tptradrarhins t' 8d VI 3TAJ^i '' similar h.....^ . the coiinter- ;rb-1lBd „ ,d ....... r ■ ■■ 'm^M -^^ S% '. . . . . • . -.' ; a) *^Rr?^SBte:^ ligraver's uid the *-"ntion. fu^M girlish r i^ f linked Plate IV L^N . CATANA. LEONTINI 77 and a crayfish. The bell, which we know to have been used in the cult of Dionysus, may perhaps have a religious significance here; but it is more probably the private signet of a magistrate. Another fine head (PL IV. 15) also produced by Euaenetus at Catana represents the river-god Amenanus, in almost purely human form. Unlike the monster of Gela, the Amenanus is represented as a youth with his hair confined by a fillet; but just above his forehead sprouts a little horn. Around are two river-fishes and a crayfish. Leontini, like most cities in the neighbourhood, was during the time of Hiero forced under the 1 (V^ power of Syracuse. One of its earliest coins, issued during the period of subjection, must be considered in connexion with the Damareteia. On those deca- drachms, and on the corresponding tetradrachms, we have seen in the exergue the running lion, which is generally supposed to have reference to the defeated forces of Africa. On the tetradrachm of Leontini issued about the same time (PL V. 4), .we have a lion repeated as symbol in the same subordinate position on both sides of the coin. On the obverse is a victorious quadriga^ in the exergue, a lion running, very much as on the Damareteia. The main type of the reverse is an archaic head ( I?rf r^ 78 FROM HIMERA TO THE ASSINARUS of Apollo, wreathed with laurel, with stiff, formal ringlets hanging over his temples, and a long lock down his neck — an admirable example of the style of about 480 B.C. Around are three leaves of his sacred tree, and below a springing lion, in a somewhat different attitude from the symbol on the obverse. Now, remembering the significance of the city's name, and the fact that its usual type and badge on the succeeding coinage is a lion's head, we must be careful how we interpret these symbols. The parallelism between the obverse and the Damareteion type is so striking that we can hardly deny them the same significance. On the other hand, the lion of the reverse may justly be interpreted as the badge of the city. Another tetradrachm (PL V. 5)]^ which shows quite as strongly the influence of Syracuse, bears a female head, the hair confined by a wreath, and surrounded by four barley-corns. The coin is almost certainly from the same hand that wrought the piece we have just described, and also the Damareteion. The approximation to the latter is carried out even to the omission of the lion under the head on the reverse, so that but for the inscription AEONTINON (retrograde) we should take this coin to be Syracusan. Two specimens of the later tetradrachms of LEONTINI 79 Leontini must suffice us here. The head of Apollo on the former (PI. V. 6) belongs to about the middle of the century. On the reverse the lion's head badge is surrounded by the usual four corn-grains. On some varieties (mostly of later date), we find one of the grains replaced by another symbol, usually connected with Apollo : his sacred tripod, his lyre, a laurel-leaf, and the like. The second coin (PL V. 7), at present in the col- lection of Mr. John Ward, is chosen because of the extraordinarily fine style of the head, which re- sembles the head of Apollo on the coins struck at Olynthus in Macedon, rather than those on any other Sicilian coin. It cannot be much earher than 422 B.C. (when Leontini was once more reduced by Syracuse), and one is tempted to date it even later. The fourth symbol on the reverse is a river-fish. All the smaller Leontine coins of this period bear on the one side a lion's head ; on the diobol and obol it is represented facing. A horseman is the other type of the didrachm (PI. V. 8) and of the earlier drachm; the later drachm has a head of Apollo I (PL V. 9); barley-corns, or else a varying number of pellets indicating the value, serve for the still smaller denominations. As we have already seen, the Syracusan colony of Camarina had issued a few small coins with the 8o FROM HIMERA TO THE ASSINARUS types of Athena and a flying Victory during the brief period between 495 and 485 b.c. It was destroyed in the latter year by Gelo, but, being restored as a colony of the city of Gela in the year of the liberation (461), it began to issue coins on a larger scale. The earliest piece of the period is a didrachm, with a helmet on a shield for its Fig. 6. Camarina : Didrachm. obverse type, and, on the reverse, a dwarf-palm between two greaves. It can hardly be jnuch later than 461. Like the somewhat similar types at Himera, these types may be meant to allude to the defeat of the Carthaginians. Towards the close of our period were issued tetradrachms with a head of Heracles, bearded, and wearing the lion's skin, with the muzzle over his forehead, and the forelegs tied round his neck. On the obverse is a victorious four-horse chariot, driven by the goddess Athena, the chief deity of Camarina. The inscription is KAMAPINAION. The specimen illustrated here (PI. V. 10) is curiously double-struck. Whether the chariot has special reference to any >i victory at Olympia or other of the Panhellenic CAMARINA. GELA 8i ^ ^Jlii^ festivals, it is difficult to say. It is more probable that the type appears simply because it is the favourite type of all Sicilian cities. An attempt has, it is true, been made to connect it with the victory of Psaumis of Camarina at Olympia in 452, • celebrated in Pindar's fourth Olympian^ and in the ode — by v^hatever author — which follows it. At Gela, the next great city of the southern coast, \ ^^iv§ • '^^ (rev.). Ward Collection . . .;? . 79 „ didrachm 79 „ drachm 79 Camarina: tetradrachm ^ Qela . ^^ (rev.). Brussels {formerly in the Hirsch Collection) . . ... • 81 81 jj " Brussels ( formerly in the Hirsch Collec- //o«) ...... 83 (rev.) 81 Brussels (formerly in the Hirsch Collec- //o«) 82 30AT 82 '^ ■.:^.:. ;ng the wards irds tb beautiful acing slov large wreath. he iiR'^h^Jcf'A? the river-god Gelas, but ;i(e bull-nature removed, excepting ^ loms on his forehteWP^^rf^^^M^hf^^iB^Xrhich dr , ..IrtenkASv '■ '■:;' . Mac'Hvehess ^ which. Scg(^t.i w Three- fini : > w^^>v^^ Vv^iW-t .(tv«i) ^rjal, .^ith ^ a detail of fin and - "^^atcH' r^^n <* scnted in the reproductioii • Hiiio^bsi}9tr:Lyffi4i\^j5>5koilor ,8 ihtrl^^f^^^ curious td-Wbdtrn '8 nund^, but is. thoroughly characteristic of the ntlet of the band ^ wears )n the^VfSv^^f^'ls ^^ . ■ • ^ Below life gre ; *-*h-*hf>r^e ^•' ^'ro;y^t,ilib^i^^. whi|i MiS • In the e}^^*?^-*s oQ relief t i i l^iiiif f j'^niJAesipAfti fc^ r se produced , even ., fyv' ^ ^ .Irtish. . Enthusiasm htttfoBiBB^ er„ bc )j 118 Acragas: decadrachm. Munich 119 „ tetradrachm . 121 „ „ Formerly m the Ashhurnham CoUeciion 122 •> }, ........ 121 gold . . . 122 ^0 122 given by the radrac the two Scylta type formerly in the Ash- ':-. although the design ol HO :r} of the first raiik. '^r.. ,-^^^./t). ^g,, figun* put i»{ 5e<" .... i'5"T) ,>onmo-p Juc^' 111 . ■•'■•^^- • ^" - '^ %' (3fiililai) „ , .Q ^^W' lAaJler siTvci^^miiLs, 'noting^ c^^jy that, on .the, drachm the artist f4ii>8i^|i««n the sen?f^ l»in( -human- face, to the cAra|W??^of th^* craff.' sji . " tt 41 ]^9r nc: 'inq:er over j\lt{Miubi:Mia^bifife«>]i:%BswiAcij ^ihave as ts] ^»](- and thiPl^S^'^^pre^ente^' vqriou.^ 1 hf' prettiest q} tlxei f thk :>fe^^(Ph VIR' ame of the Acr-agas •hen the city . cirthaginians in 406, The inhabii urned to their deso- lated homes wen use their old coins. Plate VII ACRAGAS. GELA 123 We shall find them issuing new money in the next period. Like its neighbour Acragas, Gela enjoyed but a brief existence during this period, for it too was destroyed by the barbarian in 405. Immediately after the Athenian disaster there followed a few years of great prosperity, resulting in an increased output of coins. To this time belong a variety of types, which we shall not attempt to arrange in exact chronological order. In the first place we find the old types treated in a fresh and highly-developed style. A fine tetradrachm (PL VIII. i) shows the horses in high action; above the chariot an eagle flies away holding a serpent in its talons, as on the Acragantine decadrachm. A stalk of barley in the exergue of the obverse bears witness to the fertility of the territory of Gela, as does the grain in the field of the reverse. The features of the bull-god have become more humane, and the horn is made small and hardly perceptible. No doubt some of the savagery of aspect which is perceptible in the earlier representation of this river-god is due to the archaic artist's lack of skill in combining the human and the animal forms; nevertheless we feel that he conceived of the river-god as a dreadful monster, whereas his successor (as we have already 124 THE FINE PERIOD seen from the tetradrachm with the young male head struck towards the end of the last period) thinks of him as a benign and fertilizing power. The type of the horseman, which we found on the earlier didrachms, is now developed into a more elaborate scheme (PL VIII. 2); armed with a lance, he strikes downward at a fallen hoplite over whom he rides. Holm ingeniously finds in this type an allusion to the part which the Geloan troopers took in the contest with Athens; for we know that the Geloans helped the Syracusans with cavalry, whereas the force of the Athenians was strongest in hoplites. Of gold there are three denominations, the weights of which are to each other as 6:4:3. The two heavier both have the forepart of the river-bull as one of their types. On the heaviest piece (27 grains) the other type is a helmeted horseman (Fig. 29); on the next denomination (PI. VIII. 4) it is the head of the goddess Sosi- polis, already known to us from earlier tetradrachms. The smallest Fig. 29. Gela : Gold. ^[^^^^ which is extremely rare, has a similar head; its other type is the forepart of a bridled horse. We note, in fact, that Gela lays rather more stress on the horseman-type than do other cities. GELA. CAMARINA 125 A type which is new to the Geloan coinage ap- pears on the silver litra and on some of the small bronze pieces struck at this time; it is the head of Heracles, bearded on the bronze, youthful and wearing the lion's skin on the silver (PL VIII. 6). The river-god Gelas is also sometimes represented (PI. VIII. 6) as a bearded head wearing a wreath of barley-leaves. But the prettiest of the bronze coins is the piece with the head of Demeter, facing and crowned with barley- leaves. The two types just described are combined in the piece illustrated in Fig. 30. ^^^- 3o. Gela : Bronze. We have already mentioned that the early chariot-types of Camarina have been supposed to commemorate the victory of Psaumis. Whether this be so or not, the Pindaric odes which cele- brate Psaumis are interesting to the student of the coins issued by Camarina in the years imme- diately preceding the removal of its inhabitants to Syracuse in 405. Of the two the more important is the fifth Olympian, with its intimate allusions to the local cult of Athena, the nymph Camarina, her sacred lake, and the rivers Hipparis and Oanis. The tetradrachms (some of them signed by the engraver Exakestidas) have now a beardless head of Heracles, and the style of the horses is more 126 THE FINE PERIOD spirited and varied than on the eariier coins (PL VIII. 3). In the exergue of some specimens we see two amphorae, jars for wine, or perhaps, as Athena drives the chariot, for oil. They are very probably prize vases. The signature of E^AKE^TIAAC is written on the exergual line. The most interesting pieces, however, are the didrachms with a horned head of the river-god Hipparis, and a representation of the nymph Camarina borne on a swan over her lake, while the wind inflates her veil and the fish leap around. On some specimens (probably the later) the river-god's head is represented facing (PI. VIII. 8); on others it is in profile, and on these his name (\PPAP\Z) is sometimes given. The waves of his stream are treated conventionally so as to form a border, and a fish is seen on each side of the head. Some of these didrachms are signed by Euaenetus, others by Exakestidas. The drachms (PI. VIII. 5), half-drachms (PI. VIII. 9), and litrae represent the head of the nymph Camarina (lfAJ4^^ the exergue dates from Uiat the treatment ....... iiv m^mm^M'}i \o":) ^*m«\a->poi\w5i 1^ m ^^ft««vn\3, Kt'^»^j /^.mrfa^iijnules -feeing (jtOt\'»\ ^ctradrac}ft^qs:/Bpp .J,rin. .vcfo) rarfoBTib : -"i 0£t you 11 ears lypc; 1 ap'(Pl. -VlIL • • Ixirlcy-^int witlrlliree . mdoRibib :9Bfm3rfT .st duced .in ,contt.^^5^3ivijg;^^4ij|f ^^a: :- e-mi/st*^^^" h type, however, oPthis -vtteL Trorii the early style oT the d (A tli^^?^^ccdmg jp^Hod, hich he has ; left iwing-stick, while Plate VIII MESSANA. NAXOS 131 been able to bring himself to reduce the city symbol to its proper size, so that it is disproportionately large in relation to the figure of the god. Other Messanian types (PI. VIII. 16) represent the nymph Pelorias (PEAAPIA^:), personification of the promontory which runs out to the north of the city, and the hero Pheraemon (^EPAIMAN, repre- sented like Leukaspis at Syracuse), a legendary ruler of northern Sicily. The mint of Messana, which closed with the disaster of 396, opened again about the time of Dion's expedition ; but we may leave the description of the later coins to a subsequent chapter. At Naxos, as at too many other Sicilian cities, the mint enjoyed but a short span of activity in this period ; for Dionysius crushed the city in 404. The tetradrachm has a new development of the older types, the god Dionysus being represented as youthful and beardless (PI. VIII. 17). On the reverse is Silenus seated beside a vine, holding wine-cup, ivy-branch and wine-skin. More remark- able is the didrachm, of which some specimens (PI. IX. i) are signed by the artist Prokles (nPOI illustrated. To do so with any success is the more \ difficult in proportion to the smallness of the scale ; ' and it is probably for this reason that he has made | the head disproportionately large. Of the other Naxian coins, there is but one which i we need mention, a half-drachm (PL VIII. 18), com- , bining the Silenus type with the head of a river- \ god Assinus (A^SIINOs:)— either the river Acesines ^ (sometimes called Asines), the Cantara of to-day, or else the little stream S. Venera, which is even i nearer to Naxos. The inscription on all the coins ! of this period (when complete) is NAZI AN. Two or three artists besides Euaenetus signed i their names on the coins of Catana. Among them \ is Prokles, whom we have already found at Naxos ; ■ but a more remarkable artist is Herakleidas j (HPAKAEIAA^). The profile head of Apollo (PL IX. 3) ! with the powerful development of the cranium, and | the singularly portrait-like features, ranks with the ; most individual of Syracusan heads, and, though not signed, probably comes from this engraver's hand, i Both he and another artist, Choerion (XOIPIAN), also ' represented Apollo's head facing (PL IX. 2, 4)— not, : if we compare the similar subjects on Syracusan ; coins, with very much success. Choerion's head of \ Apollo (PL IX. 4) is crowned not with laurel, but i NAXOS. CATANA 133 with an oak-wreath, and flanked by his attributes, the bow and the lyre. The god's name (APOAADiN) is placed under the head, and the artist's own name at the left side. Other types of this time are the lank-haired head of the river-god Amenanus (PL IX. 5), and the head of Silenus, facing, on silver drachms and half-drachms — a remarkable study of a bald-headed wine-bibber (PI. IX. 6). The bronze coins of Catana (which ceased to issue money in 403, when it was enslaved by Dionysius) need not detain us from passing on at once to Leontini. This city, as we have seen, fell from its former greatness in 425. But it enjoyed a short period of revival, when in 405 it was once more recognized as independent, only to have its in- habitants transported to Syracuse in 403. Of this brief span of existence there is a little monument, a unique silver half-drachm (PI. IX. 7), which had long been known, but remained unappreciated until Mr. Evans pointed out its significance. On the obverse is the head of Apollo with the inscription AEON, on the reverse l--iT>ly the tetradrachms Persephone a^ i^Vaji scribed but for the Punic > )eI6ng alS5ve- the vain. • ^^^^^^ '^f^^^ lav . cfem- (.vdo) ,. „ .8 d^cnbcd— take- .«ofe,tto-:).«s^4lo4'^'^,.st-«''es with^ h^d of Ap' 'm^ a8fePegas). .• '.adBTttt;iati0as,oi i^b latter clxn -hafdlv -i-'^b^^ before" Qis^-j's, aud i^ very.pc . uiMiisH 9snoid i^zisobH .£i ^Ppssin.^ over a coin of Pv - • • >h^^fe-T^.?M(-;^' ■ . . j; 'IdJ :?2uIo3 .JI .^ come to the (.vdo) mdVfn: ::.s5lbM^^)5H^«^I ^cribed Melkart/ or 'sually be .^as; l>iu t Cephal- inallv He tetradrachms surround Plate IX PUNIC: ERYX; RAS MELKART 143 (Fig. 41); others a female head also accompanied by dolphins, but without a wreath (PL X. i); others again a bearded head wearing a laurel Fig. 41. Ras M elk art : Tetradrachm. wreath — probably Melkart, the Tyrian Heracles (PL IX. 16). The coins are as a rule poor in style, showing clearly the barbarian hand striving to imitate Syracusan work. If the attribution to Cephaloedium is correct, the coinage must have come to an end when the place was betrayed to Dionysius early in the fourth century; and the style of the coins is consistent with this conclusion. The silver coins of the second class fall into three groups, according as they are inscribed (or have the same types as those which are inscribed) with the Punic letters : Krtchdsty i.e. Kartchadsat^ for 'New City (of Car- thage)'; Ammchnt, i.e. Ammachanat, (or variant forms) for ' the Camp ' ; 2CCi^Mchsbm, i.e. Mechasbim, for 'the Paymasters.' 144 THE FINE PERIOD Such are the interpretations now generally ap- proved; and yet they do not carry us very far towards the aim of every numismatist, which is in the first place to find out where a coin was struck. Closely connected with these coins are two groups, one of gold coins, another of bronze, which bear no inscription at all. The types of the silver coins are interesting, partly as imitations of the types of the Greek cities, some- times evidently by a Punic hand, and not by that of a Greek engraver working for the Carthaginian ; partly also for their African allusions. The head of Kora which we find on many of the ' Carthage ' and ' camp ' coins (PL X. 5, 6) is obviously a copy — and usually a poor one — of Syracusan work. The forepart of the horse (Fig. 42; cp. PI. X. 3) on Fig. 42. SicuLo-PuNic Tetradrachm. another was, it is thought, suggested by a gold coin of Gela. The free horse, again (PL X. 4), is of Syracusan origin. A head of Heracles in the lion's skin (PL X. 8) on a 'camp' coin shows clearly the influence of the coins of Alexander the Great, and PUNIC: UNCERTAIN MINTS 145 the coins of this type must therefore belong to the last decade or so of the Carthaginian occupation. Even so, it is a strong testimony to the importance which Alexander's coins at once acquired in Greek trade that they should have been imitated in Sicily before he had been dead ten years. The types of the palm-tree, and the horse or lion with a palm- tree in the background (PL X. 2) 4, 5), are on the other hand inspired by Africa; and the bust of a horse (PL X. 6, 8), which is often treated with much spirit, reminds us of the omen which decided the choice of the site of Carthage : quo primum, iactati undis et turbine, Poeni effodere loco signum, quod regia luno monstrarat, caput acris equi. Vergil, Aen. i. 442. The fine head of a woman (PL X. 7) wearing a 'Phrygian' cap — i.e. the headdress of an eastern ruler— with a diadem over it, is generally regarded, because of the royal attire, as representing the legendary foundress of Carthage. But the identi- fication is purely conjectural. The genuineness of a tetradrachm with these types, but with AEONTINON replacing the Punic inscriptions, is open to considerable doubt. The gold coins which belong to this series are uninscribed, and their types show nothing new. The Phoenician ' sign of Baal ' which occurs on one 146 THE FINE PERIOD variety (PI. X. 9) over a free horse is also found on some of the silver tetradrachms. We now come to the large series of coins in- scribed Ziz, The most important are the not un- common imitations of the Syracusan coins with a chariot-group (PL X. 10-12). Some of them repre- sent coins which were issued at Syracuse in the previous period; others are obviously taken from the decadrachms of Euaenetus. Even the best of these heads, it should be noticed, fall far short of the work of the Greek coins in point of execution, and we must hesitate before we admit that Greek artists worked for the Cartha- ginians. There is a hardness and lack of feeling and spirit about the treatment of the heads which we do not find even in the most careless work of Syracuse at this time; one feels instinctively that these designs are copied from others. Over the remainder of the types of this coinage we must not hnger; but a bare list of some of them, which may be consigned to a footnote \ shows ^ Youthful male head with dolphins, and free horse (PL X. 13); female head, and hound with murex-shell (PI. X. 14) ; dolphin with scallop-shell (marked with 5 pellets), and eagle with hare ; female head (swastika behind), and forepart of man-headed bull ; head of young river-god, and same reverse as preceding ; cock, and crab head of Apollo, and Pegasus ; head of Athena, and swan on waves, etc. etc. PUNIC: ^ZIZ' 147 that they have no significant relation to any one mint. A complete list would present subjects which, it has been shown, are reminiscent of Syracuse, Messana, Gela, Catana, Himera, Acragas, Leontini, Thermae, and other places. Whatever Ziz may mean — and it is unnecessary here to mention the various con- jectures — we may accept the view that the coins were struck, chiefly in the West of Sicily, and more especially at Panormus, the larger coins for general circulation wherever Punic armies went, the smaller with very definite local types for local use. It is quite clear from their style that these coins extend nearly to the end of the fourth century. As to their upper limit, it has been suggested by Mr. Evans that the sea-horse in the exergue of the coins engraved by the artist Mai . . . (PI. VIII. 10) at Himera is inferior to, and was inspired by, the same symbol on the Siculo-Punic tetradrachms (PI. X. 12); and that, since Himera was destroyed in 409, these pieces must have been struck by the Punic cities, or more especially by Panormus, just before, and with a view to the great invasion. The possibility of the imitation having taken place the other way about must, however, be carefully con- sidered before we accept this ingenious hypothesis. Apart from the difficulty of estimating the com- parative stylistic merits of minute symbols in the L 2 148 THE FINE PERIOD exergue, it seems less likely that the Greek artist of Himera should have been induced to adopt the symbol placed on the Punic coins about a year before, than that, when the Carthaginians took Himera, they should have imitated on their coins the last issues of that mint. 5. 6. 7- 8. 9- lO. II. 12. 13- 14. RasMelkart: tetradrachm I^^^^S ^43 Siculo-Punic ' Camp ' : tetradrachm (obv.) . ^^^H| 145 ♦New City' . ^^* . 144 „ 'New City— Camp*: tetradrachm (obv.) . 144,145 ' New City ' „ „ • i44» i45 „ tetradrachm 144, 145 „ ♦ Camp ' : tetradrachm . , . . . 145 >j J) )> ..... 144, 145 » Gold 145 ,, ' Ziz ' : tetradrachm 146 ,, „ „ ...... 146 M ?) 5> 146, 147 „ „ didrachm 146 j> J) )> ....... 146 14^ seems le: )v artist should iduced to adopt the placed oi coins about a year Carthaginians took h imitated on their coins tlv X 3TAJq aoAi 84^1 mriDBibBiJaJ : JiBjibM zsfl .1 e^i (.vdo) mthBibBii9i : ' qmsD ' oinu^-oIuoiS .s HI . . . , „ 'Y)DW9^> t» 8 l\^i ,H^ (.vdo) mdoBihsiisi I'qrnfiD— yliD waVI ' u 4 ei^i i .-j^^i «t (? tt .8 e^i • bloO (t Q d^i . rnriDBibfiiiai : ' siX ' ft .OI dfi « M «l .11 V^i ,d4.i «• tf „ .SI d^t . . mrioBibib ,^ «< £1 d^i . ff : Fig. 44. Syracuse : Gold of Agathocles. may perhaps attribute the extension of its signifi- cance. 154 THE DECLINE The best known gold coin of Agathocles' first period is the imitation (Fig. 44) of the ' PhiHppus/ the gold stater issued by Philip II of Macedon in enormous quantities from the output of his famous gold mines at Philippi. The types are the same as on the model, a laureate male head, representing either Ares or Apollo, and a two-horse chariot ; but the name of Philip is replaced by £YPAI<0£IAN, and the symbol in the field, which indicated the place of mintage, by the triskeles. The / Philippi ' were an even more important element in the cur- rency of the ancient world than the Corinthian staters or the tetradrachms of Alexander, and we have already seen how these left their mark on Sicilian coinage. These Philippean types were used by Agathocles for two gold coins, one of sixty, the other of forty litrae (PI. XI. 7). A still smaller gold coin of twenty litrae has the head of Persephone and a bull with lowered head (PL XI. 6). When we come to the silver coinage, we find the 'Pegasi' still being issued, but distinguished (PL XL 8) by a more elaborate helmet (ornamented with a griffin) for Athena, and by the triskeles symbol on the reverse. The tetradrachms, however (PL XL 9), are more characteristic of the period; the head of Persephone still shows the influence SYRACUSE: AGATHOCLES 155 of Euaenetus, soon to disappear, and the falling off in the composition of the reverse is patent \ The drachm belonging to this series (PI. XL 10) has a head of Ares (or Apollo) similar to that on the gold coins, and a triskeles with wings attached to the feet and the head of the Gorgon in its centre. This elaboration of the symbol strengthens our view that, at this time, it can hardly have been meant merely to indicate the three-cornered island. The bronze coins {e.g. PL XL 11) belonging to this series are of little importance; the time of the large bronzes is past. The second series of Agathocles' coins ranges from 310, when he avenged on Carthage the invasion of Sicily made just a century before, to the time of his assumption of the royal title, about 304 (not, as is usually stated, in 307). ' The gold and silver coins now bear his name; and with good reason, since he must have required to strike them in large quantities for his military chest. But the less important bronze is still issued in the name of the Syracusans. The gold coin (PL XL 12) is a stater with remarkable types. On the obverse is a youth ^ The monogram of AN, which frequently occurs on these tetradrachms and on other coins of Agathocles, may possibly be the signature of the tyrant's brother Antandrus. 156 THE DECLINE ful head wearing an elephant's skin, probably the personification of Africa. On the reverse, which bears the tyrant's name in the genitive (AFAOO- l • thov 8di . ^^:. membe irSyracu iciiian politics. i h m... -j < the bioiize (dBiJil od) blo^ :8J5i9DiH j9aif3M^8.,i anisra oplo aoaiq „ #• .* ' ', y, ^ : . :>een issucu (.vdo) asfioid „ „ .g ^VA^^ rnajprit^'idof .. ) {esrtiil od) bfog Xjuhj 1 /<:•' grerfter 8 (.vdo) ge wh . mrfbirtb.^Ififf^2L^W^v'^'us (.vdo) „ rinitiamsM .gi ]Lu tit to ^ ... ^ J. , \ ,"''^'' ^b" ^'^ "^va^ non(!^\o 071 -...., \ . \.vdo) asnoid „ .81 i^ttaud beside .Timok . (.v5i) h^ was a fqfeignQ^x-- 071 .. (.v^>a!S^i4^:,mrhafaaMi .0^^,. £^i asnoid : ariBbn'^T .is the he lies. -^yracu obvers verse, One series ot th< ea-star or then) 'stinguished absence of any mint-name, and hy the presence of the inscription SIYMMAXIKON (Symma Plate XII TIMOLEON'S L 175 chtkoUy 'coinage of the alliance'). Their type is either (PI. XII. 22) a torch between two ears of barley, or a thunderbolt (Fig. 54). One of them, it Fig. 54. 'Alliance' Bronze. is true, adds the name of the people of Halaesa (AAAI^INAN) to the 'alliance' inscription; but we have no reason to conclude therefore that all the others were also issued from Halaesa. The obverse types of these pieces are the heads of the Zeus of Freedom (IEY£ EAEYGEPIO^), of Sicily (^ll ^93 12. „ )) » ^93 13. Siceliotes : 8 litrae i93 14. Syracuse, Hieronymus : gold (30 litrae, obv.) .... 194 15. » » 24 litrae 194 16. „ gold (60 litrae). Paris, Bihliotheque Nationale . . 195 17. „ 8 litrae 196 18. „ gold (40 litrae) i95 19. „ 6 litrae (obv.) i97 'ping U ;. r.c (Fig. 67) ] victory in a gal- ! ■:. ; ■ ! ! i2-litrac ' 8^1 081 d8r qBi IQI OQI IQI IQI epi ^QI dQi cQi 7QI 3TAjq ...,■■. . . (.V9l) 0:w._.,4vj . «^i*^.ifi§10M .1 l-)YKACi .-.; : .1'; Li iiwi:. . (.V9i) ssnoid : BnbnB^ioM .£ H) has !P^ head of Pcrseptione 8 obO (.V9i) asnoid iffi \.v«Ky^9inJiI 0£) blog : aum\[noi: .01 .11 .fii oiZ .gi DBTfa 41 .51 .di tZrusTfpcr- 3BiJiIo|.) bios ,, „, ^l , Then conic winged tispired ^!uaenetus, lot by igathocles .)u Victory driving ni 17). On the Plate XIII SYRACUSE: WAR WITH ROME 197 6-litrae piece the bearded head of Heracles, in Hon*s skin (reverse, Victory in two-horse chariot), is a good specimen of the treatment of the demi-god in this period of art (PL XHI. 19); we are on the verge of the brutahty of the Roman type. The coin of 4 htrae (PL XIV. 2) has a long-haired head of Apollo, and Victory carrying trophy and palm. All these coins, both gold and silver, bear the name of the people in the genitive, ^YPAKOCIAN; and we shall find the same form on the bronze. Most of the coins are also inscribed with the abbreviated names of officials responsible for the issue of the money. A small group of silver coins is distinguished by the nominative form ^YPAKO- ^101. These are, in the first place, a piece of 2^ litrae : obverse, head of Apollo ; reverse (PL XIV. 3), a figure, perhaps of the Fortune of the City, her veil blown out by the breeze, holding a branch and a roll on which an inscription is suggested by dots. Next, the i^ litra (PL XIV. 5) has the head of Artemis and the owl of Athena. Last comes a litra with the head of Athena, and the inscription CYPAKOSIIOI .-Xlll, which implies that the silver Htra was now worth 13^ copper litrae, instead of 12 as formerly. The use of the nominative may have been suggested by its use on the coins of Gelo the younger, but it is difficult to see how it can be 198 FROM HIERO II TO TIBERIUS regarded, as Holm regards it, in the light of a protest against the legend ^YPAI