110 AMERICAN MANURES. The reader can see at a glance the lack of sul- ' phuric acid in the above soil. This is the reason that the application of plaster had such a beneficial effect. Every other element of fertil- ity was present, but without sulphuric acid it was impossible for plants to come to maturity. Hundreds of analyses of different soils might be given, both fertile and barren, but they would only prove the one great fact, that soils, to be properly adapted to the growth of plants, must contain every element that enters into their composition. Plants must have the necessary food to live oil, the same as animals, as they cannot create an atom of any substance to sup- port themselves. Hence, when there is a falling off in the productiveness of a soil, the farmer should first ascertain what element is necessary to restore it, and then add that substance, in a definite quantity, because it is only a waste of money to apply what is not required. Such a course would lead to an economy both of the money of the farmer, and also of the ele- ments of fertility. How many farmers buy ex- pensive manufactured manures, when perhaps the very things they need lie wasting at their own doors. The application of lime, marl, muck, wood and even coal ashes, is sometimes attended with better results than the most ex- pensive phosphates. When these expensive CHARACTER OF SOILS. Ill manures are applied where something else is needed, the farmer loses the money invested, the labor of applying them, and oftentimes his crop, by not using the substance really required. The bulk of all soils consists of sand and day. These are general terms, and have no reference to the chemical properties of the different parts, as all granulated bodies in soils are termed sand, and all tenacious substances easily pulverized are termed clay. Two specific terms are in use to denote the character of soils, viz : — alluvial and diluvial. Soils that have been washed from hills and mountains are termed alluvial, but if they can- not be traced to such a source, and are elevated plains, or the tops pf hills and mountains, they are termed diluvial, and must be traced to the action of glaciers or the gradual disintegration of rocks by the action of the elements. A knowledge of the chemical composition of the rocks, from which the sand and clay are formed, will enable us to judge correctly of the kinds of minerals to be found in the soil ; and of their adaptability to the wants of agriculture ; hence, the study of these rocks is quite as im- portant as the study of the soil itself. The rocks essential to the formation of fertile soils, and from which they are usually produced, are Granite, Felspar, Limestone, Gypsum, M^mAMW /^ llnmersttg sf l^alifantia REFERENCE. No /l/Jl Division ..^ Range . ' ' , : ^....:^ Shelf \\:.. 1 :...:..J-:-l- Received f^ee^uJe.'^ ^^^ i gyCT" Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2007 with funding from IVIicrosoft Corporation http://www.archive.org/details/americanmanuresfOObrucrich AMERICAN MANURES AND FAEMEKS' AND PLANTERS' G- U I D E. COMPRISING A DESCRIPTION OF THE ELEMENTS AND COMPOSITION OF PLANTS AND SOILS— THE THEORY AND PRACTICE OF COMPOSTING— THE VALUE OF STABLE MANURE AND WASTE PRODUCTS, ETC., ETC., ETC. ALSO, CHEMICAL ANALYSES OF THE PRINCIPAL MANUFACTURED FERTILIZERS— THEIR ASSUMED AND REAL VALUE— AND A FULL - EXPOSE OF THE FRAUDS PRACTISED UPON PURCHASERS. BY WILLIAM H. BRUOKISrEE, PH. D., ANALYTICAL AND CONSULTING CHKMIST, AND J. B. CHYNOWETH. PHILADELPHIA : WILLIAM H. BKUCKNER, 1872. 3^ y.rtered according to Act of Congress, in the year 1872, by WILLIAM H. BRUCKNER, In the Office of the Librarian of Congress, at "Washington, D. C. ///c// NO. I. From Philadelphia's distinguished Lawyer, Theo. Guyler : I have examined the several pages of the book entitled " American Manures and Farmers^ and Planters' Guide," pub- lished at Philadelphia, by Chynoweth and Company, 1871, to which you asked my attention. These pages are numbered 214, 216, 227, 238, 240 and 244. I have also examined the book at large sufficiently to enable me to form an idea of its general scope and tenor. Assuming .the statements of the book to be true at the pages indicated, they do not in my opinion transcend the bounds of legitimate criticism and are not libellous. The language, though severe and strong, is not more strong and severe than such facts justify in a book devoted to the useful instruction of the people in a preeminently important depart- ment of practical knowledge. I could much more easily under- stand, that silence and the suppression of such information on the part of those possessing it, would be an offence against society, than I could that its utterance would be a legal offence against the rights of an individual engaged in the perpetration of such deceptions. No man has a legal right to mislead and deceive the public. If he does so and injury to any individual results therefrom, he is liable in damages. If he does so and is exposed, he who exposes him has performed a duty, and not committed a wrong. (Signed,) THEO. GUYLER. NO. II. From the Author of ''''American Or ape Growers^ Guide^^'' etc. : Your book ''American Manures and Farmers' and Planters' Guide," supplies, most effectually, a want that has long existed, and, no doubt, will save millions of dollars to the agricultural community, not only from the fearless manner in which you have exposed the frauds of the manufacturers of special fertilizers, but, also, by the lucid and scientific, yet practical and readily iii IV COMMENDATIONS. understood explanations given. You have brought the chemis- try and general science of agriculture down to so fine a point that the most illiterate cultivator, if he can only read the English language, cannot help but know what is wanted to improve his land, and suj)ply that want at a fair money value. Forty years ago, I was just arriving at manhood, and since that time, have been actively employed in practical farming and horticulture, and can truly state, from actual experience, that many of your deduc- tions are perfectly correct. In fact, you have brought before the public a greater amount of reliable information, in condensed form, than is to be found in Liebig and Johnson combined, or any other work of the same kind which I have yet seen. (Signed,) WM. CHORLTOK NO. III. From the North American and Tlnited States Gazette, the leading Commercial Paper of Philadelphia : The authors premise that strictly scientific writers on the use and composition of fertilizers are usually too technical for the comprehension of practical men, and the merely practical writers record results without elucidating causes or opening the philoso- phy involved. They essay to unfold the frauds of manufactured manures, of w^hich, it is said, 500,000 tons are sold annually in this country, at a cost of $25,000,000, to the farmers. One chap- ter is surrendered to an exposition of the elements of manures and plants, and the action of one on the other ; another to the kind and amount of fertilizer different plants need ; one to the composition of soils, and others to the values of fertilizers in money. The last chapter is filled with analyses. There is enough in almost any ten pages treating of the patent manures and fertilizers to ground as many libel suits. One fertilizer after another is shown to be deficient in value, or over-priced, or otherwise undesirable, and the authors state how they secured the material from which their analyses w^ere made. So far as the chemistry of agriculture is involved, the work is admirable. "We hesitate only over the exposition made of special articles so long and highly commended. But conceding the truth of the statements, every farmer should use fertilizers, and telescopes endless in selecting them. We fail to notice any apparent com- mendation of one at the cost of the others, but do see that the German fertilizers have a double per cent, of phosphates over the best of our ow^n. The book proposes to enable every farmer to compost for himself, and so secure a reliable fertilizer. The importance of the subject cannot be over-estimated, and th( capital at issue will certainly advertize this work in one way oi another strongly. It seems to be thoroughly fair and reliable. COMMENDATIONS. V NO. ly. OUR HOME PHOSPHATES. From the Charleston, S. (7., Courier: The manufacture and sale of Superphosphates under theii many different names and varied experimental value have become of such importance in this country as to warrant steps being taken, not only to protect the planter from injustice, but also iu the interest of the honest dealer who does give value received for money paid. The diff"erent Governments of Europe whom we are in the habit of calling slow, have long ago said that parties selling these articles shall afSrm the constituents of their compounds and guarantee their proportions, in order that parties, whose general knowledge of chemistry may be sufficient for ordinary purposes shall, when they wish to use an organic or mineral constituent as the food of their crop, get what they pay for, or have the means of redress. Our attention has been forcibly called to the subject by a care- ful perusal of a book laid upon our table purporting to be Amer- ican Manures, their moneyGalue, by James Bennett Chynoweth, late Superintendent of Fertiliser Works, and William H. Bruck- ner, Ph. D., Analytical and Consulting Chemist, Philadelphia. A careful perusal will repay the planter aiid farmer, also those interested in the sale of Superphosphates. It is written in plain language and devoid of the symbols and technical character of the terms of Science. It is especially due from our Charleston manufacturers of Superphosphates that they give as wide a cir- culation as possible to the public of the valuable information conveyed in this publication. If one-half of what is told of the many subterfuges and false proportions put upon our planting community by our Northern manufacturing friends is true, the market of the United States is in our hands, and w^e only need to use the resources which Provi- dence has committed to us and their proper development, which ordinary intelligence should give, in order to obtain that con- trolling influence in our markets, which the possession of in- exhaustible beds of Native Bone Phosphate entitle us. In any event, the natural course of trade ought in time to give us this control ; but with the impetus which this description of facts, properly ventilated, should produce, Charleston ought at one T)ound to step to the front rank, in the United States at least, as a manufacturer of fertilizers. We have taken the money value to the consumer of fourteen of the fertilizers mentioned in this publication, the names of which were most familiar to us, and some of whom are as house- hold words over the Cotton States, and to find it to vary from four 96-100 dollars for the lowest value up, with variations to thirty-six 93-100 dollars. These fertilizers are sold at the place of manufacture at from forty-five to fifty-six dollars per ton of VI COMMENDATIONS. 2000 pounds. !N"ow if our planting friends experienced so much benefit as their many flattering encomiums show, from so small a value received in proportion to the outlay made, how much more favorable would have been the reports, and how much more satisfactor}^ the state of their money resources, had they received a fair value for the amount paid ? These writers state that there is consumed in the United States to-day five hundred thousand tons of fertilizers at a cost to the consumers of twenty- five millions of dollars. How bright a vista of future prosperity looms up in future for us if we only use our best efforts to cen- tralize this trade, so immense in its young proportion, and direct its regenerating influences over our much divided low country of South Carolina. The larger proportion of our community do not realize how large an influence the possession of these phosphate beds, properly developed, will have on our commercial position, and it will well become us in the future to use some efforts for home prosperity, and devote some time and capital for the proper management of our home institutions. NO. V. From the Journal of Applied Chemistry^ publisJied simultane- ously in New Tork^ Philadelphia and Boston : They carry a steady lance and strike pretty hard blows, and we should advise every farmer who proposes to buy fertilizers to read this book before he makes too large an investment. An accurate knowledge of the scientific part of this book would save every farmer the time and expense of many useless experiments. There is a large amount of information condensed into a small space, and so far as we have been able to detect from a hasty perusal, this information is carefully selected and correctly given according to the latest and best authorities. Some controversial portions of the work might, perhaps, have found a better place in the columns of influential newspapers, but we do not object to them as they add piquancy and spice to the feast the authors have aff'orded us. It is a pity that a few dishonest manufacturers of fertilizers have brought the business into such ill-repute, and the only remedy would appear to be just such an exposure of the tricks of the trade as is here given. We commend the book to the notice of our agricultural readers. The work will be sent by mail, postage paid, to any address, by remitting the price, $1.50. Address, WILLIAM H. BRUCKNER, Monroe, Michigan. J gents wanted in every Township in the United States. Liberal inducements offered. PREFACE TO THE SECOND EDITION. Mr. Chynoweth's connection with ^^American Ma- nures '^ having ceased, it aifords the author pleasure in announcing that the first edition of the work has been exhausted, and thanking the public for their kind patronage of the same. While he is conscious that certain parties put forth all their energies to suppress the work in its infancy, he is glad to say that success has not crowned their efforts, as is evinced by this revised edition. And it is hoped, not only by him, but he trusts by all who have the welfare of their fellow- beings at heart, that subsequent editions may follow in quick succession. It is the writer's intention to embrace in future editions of the work analyses, not only of manures re- presenting those w^hich have been examined, but of others ; and judging from the following quotation of a letter from a manufacturer of fertilizers, dated Nov. 29th, he will not be surprised to find a marked improve- ment in the quality of the former. ^' The book has exercised a great influence on the fertilizing business, and has put thousands of dollars Vlll PREFACE. into the pockets of the farmers. Every manufacturer has increased the quality of his article. The State of Delaware employs a State Chemist, and all manufac- turers must have their fertilizers analyzed by that chemist before they are allowed to sell in that State, so that there was a fair chance to observe the rise of the Phosphate Business.'^ Immediately after the publication of "American Manures/^ Messrs. Wattson & Clark, manufacturers of Superphosphate of Lime, No. 135 North Water street, Philadelphia, ichile candidly admitting the correctness of analyses and fairness of criticism of their product, informed the writer that they manufacture a superphos- phate of lime (never found in the market in bags), which they warrant to contain 10 per cent, of soluble phosphoric acid (anhydrous), and which in quantity they are willing to sell at the price laid down in this book, namely, 12 J cents per pound, for soluble phos- phoric acid; or, in other words, they charge for the above superphosphate, $25 per short ton. This statement is made, because justice demands it; and farmers desirous of getting the worth of their money, would do well to club together to purchase such an article in quantity. Subsequent division to meet the wants of each purchaser could easily be eifected. ^ . WILLIAM H. BRUCKNER. March, 18^2. PREFACE TO THE FIRST EDITION. Knowledge is indispensably necessary to better the condition of mankind. The posses- sion of the information that will enable us to procure what we need, is oftentimes more valu- able than the possession of the same without such knowledge; the advantages of the latter are temporary, those of the former are perma- nent. To be warned of danger is better than to be armed to resist it. When the wrongs and im- positions practised on communities are fully exposed, they have no one to blame but them- selves for their continuance. It has ever been considered the duty of each member of a com- munity to do all in his power to expose and i^edress existing wrongs, especially when those wrongs affect the vital interests of all. From these considerations we feel it a duty, and we claim the right of giving freely the knowledge 4 PREFACE. we possess on the subjects treated in this book. We shall unmask practices that have been backed up by favorable reports, and artfully designed statements, falsely claiming to be bene- fits conferred on the community, and which, from a want of knowledge to distinguish real from imaginary good, have passed currently as such. We shall not attempt to disprove the statements of dishonest manufacturers of fertilizers by mere reasoning; we only desire the reader closely to scrutinize and compare the focts as given, and make his own deductions. We challenge the parties assailed to disprove them. We expect to offend some : when wrongs are exposed, thi« is inevitable; and those parties may endeavor to refute the statements made. Our justification is written down in the following pages. In the language of Cicero, we shall " Neither dare to say anything that is false, nor fear to say anything that is true." Philadelphia, May Ut, isn. CONTENTS. CHAPTER I. rMPOJRTANT PRELIMINARY OBSERVATIONS. (Page 11-31.) 11, Importance of our work. — 12, Two kinds of works on farming. — 13, 1st kind, and remarks — 14, 2d kind, and re- marks. — 15, Operations of the farm may be intelligently per- formed. — 16, Farming may be made scientific — Book knowledge necessary. — 17, Progress of other arts. — 18, Terse, sayings — Negligence and indifference of farmers. — 19, Effect of knowledge — What we intend to show. — 20, Effect of this upon farmers — Object of concentrated manures — Remark. — 21, Analyses of Dr. Bruckner — How samples were obtained — Other fertilizers to be examined — Made manures a special study. — 22, Secrecy and frauds of manufacturers. — 24, Lying circulars. — 25, Detecti(m difficult — Immense profits. — 26, Object of book. — 27, Necessity of inspection. — 28, Agricultural Department at Washington re- miss.— 29, All interested in agriculture. — 30, Practical experi- ments to be made. CHAPTER II. ELEMENTS OF MANURES AND PLANTS. (Page 31-77.) 31, Definition of manure — Two objects to be effected — A per- fect manure. — 32, Loss of manures — Materials abundant. — 33, Gaseous elements — Elements with oxygen forming acids — Bases — Alkalies — Elements unite in definite proportions. — 34, Defini- 5 6 CONTENTS. tion of element — A compound — An oxide — A salt — Chemical affinity. — 35, Cohesion. — Gaseous Elements. — 35, Oxygen — Its properties, etc. — One-fifth of the atmosphere — Half of animals and plants — Source of, in plants — Exhaled by plants. — 37, Hy- drogen — Its properties — -How existing in nature — In plants and animals — Its weight — What it forms — How assimilated by plants. — 38, Garhuretted Hydrogen — Where found — Marsh gas — Fire damp — Present in soils. — 39, Sulphuretted Hydrogen — How formed — Its properties — In marshy places — Hurtful to vegetation — Effects in soils. — 41, Nitrogen — Its properties — Forms nitric acid with oxygen — Forms ammonia with hydrogen. — 42, Plants do not absorb it from atmosphere. — 43, Experiments of Lawes and others on rain water — Conclusion therefrom. — 44, Chlorine — Its properties — Sources, etc. — 45, Elements forming Acids — Silicon — Its appearance — Forms silicic acid — Silicates of pot- ash, lime, and magnesia — Their use. — 45, Silica — Crystallized and amorphous— Its properties. — 46, Soluble silica — How formed, and uses of. — 47, Value of soluble silica — Sources of it. — 48, Gar- hon — Its properties. — 48, Garhonic Acid — How formed. — 49, Its uses to plants — Uses of humus or mould. — 50, Phosphorus — Its properties, QiQ,.-^Phosphoric Acid — Its composition and proper- ties — 50, J^one Phosphate of Lime— It's, composition, etc.-— 51, Neutral Phosphate of Lime — Its composition, etc. — 51, Super^ phosphate of Lime — Its composition— How formed. — 52, Its ac- tion in soils, and Ronna's report on its action. — 57, Sulphur — Its properties, etc. — 58, Sulphuric Acid — Its composition and uses — Cheapest source to farmer. — Elements fokming bases. — 58, Galcium — Its properties, etc. — 59, Oxide of Galcium^ or quick lime— Its composition. — 59, Garhonate of Lime — Its composition, etc. — How made quick lime, etc. — 59, Hydrate of Lime — Its com- position.— 60, How lime should be slacked. — Marls rich in carbo- nate of lime — Quick lime more valuable than carbonate. — 61, Neu- tralizes acids in soils — Liberates ammonia. — 62, Effect on iron pyrites — On silicates of soda and potash — On salt — Its physical effects. — 63, What soils need lime. — 64, How and what quantity should be applied. — 65, Sulphate of Lime — Its composition — At- tracts little moisture. — 66, Its benefits due to sulphuric acid — Why but little required. — 66, Magnesiuin — Its properties. — 67, Magnesia — Its composition — Its action — Cheap sources of — Too much hurtful. — 68, Iron — Forms two oxides— Protoxide injuri- CONTENTS. 7 ous to vegetation. — 69, Peroxide of Iron — Its composition — Uses in soils — Effect of too much — How to correct it, and effects. — 70, Sulphate of Iron — How formed — Too much hurtful — How corrected — Iron pyrites useful. — 70, Potassimn — Its properties^ Oxidizes readily — Forms caustic potash. — 71, Potash — Its proper- ties — Importance to plants — How and where found in nature — 72, Potash from plant and wood ashes — Wood ashes as manure. — 78, Sodium — Its propertFes — Forms caustic soda — Soda now made from common salt. — 74, Nitrate of Soda — Where found — Its uses in soils — Soda in plants — Cheapest source of it — Common Salt — Its composition. — 75, Action of salt in soils— Injurious to some plants and trees — Exterminates insects and worms — How much wheat requires. CHAPTER III. COMPOSITION OF PLANTS, AND KINDS AND AMOUNT OF MANURES REQUIRED. (Page 77-104.) 77, Elements vary but little in plants of same kind — Effects, if not so — First lesson of farmers — Popular idea of action of ma- nure. — 79, Potash^ Silicon^ and Lime Plants. — 80, Remarks on. — 81, Importance of studying the tables. — 82, Ta])le of composition of plants. — 83, Albumen and Gluten — Their uses — >S'to?'c7i and Gum — Their uses and mode of action. — 84, Woody fibre — Of no use as food — Theory of fattening. — 85, Table of inorganic ele- ments of plants— A key to application of fertilizers — Remarks on table.— 86, Composition of wheat and straw— Remarks — Asli of plants uniform, — 88, Crops on ordinary land. — 89, English far- mers. — 89, Wheat — Analysis of grain and straw — Remarks.— 90, Indian (7(?r7i— Analysis of — Remarks. — 91, Rye — Analysis of — Remarks. — 92, Oats — Analysis of — Remarks. — 93, Barley — Analysis of — Remarks, — 94, Buckwheat — Analysis of — Remarks. — 94, Potatoes — Analysis of — Remarks. — 95, Clover Hay — An- alysis of — Remarks. — 96, Tobacco and Cotton — Analysis of — Re- mai*ks. — 98, What should be applied to each crop — Average crop "In thirty States — In Pennsylvania — In South Carolina. — 99, Re- marks. — 100, What reader should have learned. — 101, What has been raised in four years — What was taken from the soil— * What will re'store it. — 102, Bad effects of overcropping in United States and West Indies. 8 CONTENTS. CHAPTER IV. ORIGIN AND COMPOSITION OF SOILS, ETC. (Page 104-123.) 104, Knowledge of soils necessary — Usual considerations in purchasing a farm — The true test of value. — 106, Analysis of soil near the Zuyder Zee. — 107, Amount of elements in this soil — Last how long — How long cropped. — 109, Analysis of a sterile soil — Remarks. — 109, Analysis of supposed barren soil — How benefitted. — 110, What plants must have — What farmer should do. — 111, Sand and clay the bulk of soils — Alluvial soils — Dilu- vial soils — Rocks that form fertile soils. — 112, Granite, quartz, felspar, mica, how these become soils. — 113, Potash in felspar. — 114, Carbonate of Lime — Its composition and origin. — 114, Sul- phate of Lime — Its office and where found. — 115, Phospliorite — Its importance — Its source in soils — Found in rocks, etc. — 115, Sandstones — What is found in them — Easily disintegrated. — 116, Soils — How named and why — Deep red soils. — 117, Mould — How formed — Remarks. — 118, A complete manure — Waste must be supplied. — 119, Humus — Its office — Water and carbon the bulk of vegetation — Carbon not furnished by the soil. — 120, Car- bon furnished by atmosphere. — 121, Importance of heat and moisture. — 121, How to benefit sandy soils. CHAPTER V. THE MONEY VALUE OF FERTILIZERS, ETC. (Page 123-163.) 124, How prices should be rated. — 125, Exorbitant prices — How to lower them. — 126, Effect of high prices. — 127, No return for the money. — 128, Farmers think manures must be bulky — Not so. — 128-9, Poorness of some fertilizers — Insincerity of manufacturers — Money made from sale of w^ater. — 130, Dishon- esty and ignorance of manufacturers — Their lamentations. — 131, The good old times — Eft'ects of their frauds. — 132, Our duty. — 133, Poor state of agriculture — Fertilizers in England — In United States. — 134, Report of an English manufacturer. — 135, State of manufacturers in United States. — 135-6, Mode of estimating value in England and Germany — Not applicable to United States. —137, Basis of value. — 138, Analysis of cattle bones, and amount of phosphoric acid. — 139, Two sources of phosphoric acid — 1st source — 2d source — Its extent. — 140, Report of Dr. Pratt on CONTENTS. 9 mineral phosphates of South Carolina. — 142-3, Analysis of— - Prices — Profits when merely ground— Of no value in this state. — 144-5, Soluble phosphoric acid — How produced — Too little sul- phuric acid used. — 146, Amount required — Amount for 100 lbs. ox bones — The compounds produced. — 148, Cost of materials for a ton, and the value. — 149, Profits to manufacturers — Kmd sold. — 150-1, Cost and value if made of mineral phosphate — Profits when sold at $50 per ton — Kind sold. — 152-3, A bogus super- phosphate — Insoluble phosphoric acid no value to farmer. — 154. Soluble bone phosphate fraud. — 154, Ammonia and Nitrogen — Actual and potential ammonia — Actual of most value — Manufac- turers make no distinction in giving analyses. — 156, Value of each. — 157, Crude sulphate of ammonia — Nitrogen as pot. amm. and how changed to actual. — 158, Cost of nitrogen in bones. — 159-60, Value of potash with tables — Deceptions of manufactu- rcrs. — 161, Catechism for manufacturers. CHAPTER VI. NATURE AND VALUE OF NATURAL MANURES, COMPOSTING, ETC. (Page 163-192.) 163, Natural manures. — 164, These not sufficient. — 155, Stable Manures — Their composition and value. — 167, Analysis of excre- ment and value — City Stable Majiure — Its value — Frauds and profits of dealers. — 169, Rotted and dried stable manure — Use of rotting. — 170, Analysis of hquid excrement and value. — 171, Total value and remarks. — 172, Swamp Muck — Its composition, etc. — 173, Eff'ects of application. — 174, Composting of muck — mud — dried earth. — 175, Leaves of Trees — Their value — Analysis of, etc. — 175, Wood and Coal Ashes. — 176, Analysis of— Phos. acid and potash in ashes — Eff*ect of coal and peat ashes. — 177. Soot — Its value — Analysis of — 177, Marl — Its composition, kinds and value. — 179, Green Manuring — Its value, and better than what — Long root plants. — 180, How and when to green manure — Benefits limited — Rest does not restore land. — 181, Liquid M:e. But when he has once tried the experiment, and noted its effects on future crops, he will find not only the value of the crop plowed under returned to him, but a large percentage in addition. Besides all this, the previous plowing is paid for, in making subse- quent cultivation easier, and in rendering the soil in a more finely divided state, which is a very important consideration in growing all kinds of crops. To derive the most benefit from green manur- ing, the plowing should be performed before the formation of the blossom, or seed, as the blossoms give ofi* nitrogen, and the seeds may become a subsequent source of trouble ; also, the plowing should be shallow, so as to keep the vegetable matter near the surface, and within easy access of the oxygen of the atmosphere. But the reader must not think for a moment that green manuring alone is sufficient to keep his land in a fertile condition. The benefits derived from this treatment of the land can exist only for a lim- ited period, and the subsoil must eventually be- COMPOSTING. 181 come exhausted as well as the surface. The prudent farmer must anticipate this state of things^ by the application of other manures. Finally, we may remark that mere rest, with- out plowing ; or the non-production of any vege- table substances on a soil, does not benefit it. It is growing vegetation that effects the needed chemical changes in the soil. Hence the farmer should endeavor by all means to promote the growth of as many plants as possible, on the land he intends to plow under for the production of another crop. Liquid Manures are held in high repute in some countries, on the principle that it is better to manure the plant than the soil. It may be employed advantageously in truck farming, but is not at all suited to the general agriculture of this country. If the farmer has a valuable liquid or semi-liquid fertilizing substance, it is much better to mix it with dried muck, or mould, and apply it in as dry a state as possible ; thus di- vesting its application of its disagreeable features, and preventing the escape of the most valuable portion of it — the ammonia. Composting. This highly important operation is too often neglected by our farmers. This ne- glect very probably results from ignorance of the great benefits that can be derived from it. The reader has acquired a knowledge of the value of * 182 AMERICAN MANURES. the waste substances accessible to the farmer, and which can be economically applied as mar nures. He has also been informed of the neces- sity of having these substances in a decomposed state, in order to make them ellicient. To be successful in composting, it is necessary for the farmer to have correct ideas of the chem- ical changes and effects to be produced, and of the means and appliances by which these changes can be economically effected; he should also know the conditions that promote or impede these changes. In the proper management of a compost heap, two leading points are to be at- tained ; First, the hastening of the decomposition of the substances used ; Second, the fixing of the fertilizing gases as they are formed. No offensive odors should escape. When such escape, some substance should be applied at once to check it. Some persons have recommended making the heap in a circular conical shape, wdth a well in the centre to catch the drainage, and with a common w^ooden pump set in it, so that as the drainage collects, it can be pumped up and al- low^ed to trickle over the top of the heap, and thoroughly permeate it. There are two vital disadvantages attending this method, which we will point out : First, the amount of heat produced is a correct index of the rapidity wdth wdiich the decomposition is being effected; and any applica- COMPOSTING. 183 tion of water operates to diminish the heat already generated, and consequently to retard the decompo- sition. All the substances commonly used in com- post heaps, contain a much larger amount of water than is needed to aid decomposition ; it is the oxygen of the atmosphere, not water, that is most needed. The second disadvantage attend- ing this pumping and sprinkling operation, is the loss of the free ammonia contained in the water, which escapes into the atmosphere. This should not be assisted by agitating the water, but should be prevented by the proper agencies. We recommend the following mode of opera- tion, which obviates all the disadvantages of the former method, and which will recommend itself by saving a great deal of labor in the subsequent working : — An elevated piece of ground, as near to the materials as convenient, should be select- ed — the side of a gradual incline, if possible. The intended compost heap should be from ten to fifteen feet wide at the base, with both sides regularly inclining toward the centre, like the roof of a house; the heap to extend lengthwise, as far as needed, up and down the incline. This arrangement prevents any accumulation of water around the heap, and also lessens the labor of turning over, as the heap may be turned down- hill. The next consideration is to prepare the bottom, or the drainage. Of course none of the 184 AMERICAN MANURES. fertilizing moisture contained in the material should be lost, neither should there be any addi- tions to it in the shape of rain water. To effect this, a ditch should be dug lengthwise of the in- tended heap. This drain, at the lower end, should extend several feet beyond the heap, and be six inches below the level of the ground. It should have a gradual ascent of one or two feet, according to the length of the heap. The bot- tom should incline towards the ditch, the dirt taken from which will generally be sufficient for this purpose. The following plan is an end view of the compost heap, showing the shape of the bottom, and the ditch for drainage : The sides and bottom of the centre drain should be boarded, and the top covered with any rough pieces of board or wood, with apertures close enough to prevent the compost from falling through, and still give free passage to the drain- COMPOSTING. 185 age water into the ditch. The farmer would also consult his interest by having the floor of the heap covered entirely with boards. Everything being prepared for constructing the heap, we will make a few suggestions about the collection and depositing the materials pre- paratory to mixing. Barn-yard manure and muck are the principal ingredients. Every cart load of barn-yard manure should be mixed with two cart loads of swamp muck, or with any other deposit that contains plenty of vegetable matter, except weeds that have gone to seed. The muck should be dug in a dry season, and spread out, so that it may be deprived of a great deal of its water, which will greatly lessen the labor and expense of hauling it to the compost heap ; and when there, it will be in much better condition for fermentation and consequent de- composition. The materials should be hauled to the heap in the proper proportions, so that they can be thoroughly mixed, and the work of piling up be commenced at one end, and the heap be finished to the top as fast as sufficient material is procured. The advantage gained by this course, over that of putting layer upon layer over the whole ground plan of the heap, is that if the heap is finished as you proceed, fer- mentation sets in sooner; and as the pile gradu- ally lengthens^ the ferijienting process passes 186 AMERICAN MANURES. the whole length of it; so that by the time the farmer has collected all his material and finished the heap, that part of it which was first com- pletedj will probably be ready to turn over. The heap, when finished, should be covered with a temporary roof, to keep out the rain. When the fiirmer is collecting material for his compost, nothing should be overlooked. In addition to his stable manure, his hog pens should be thoroughly cleared, and all the night soil, chicken dung, wood and coal ashes, saw- dust, leaves, corn-stalks, straw, soap suds, fish or meat brine, and even old mortar, should be thoroughly mixed together in the heap ; and to every load of material, 20 to 25 lbs. of plaster or gypsum should be added, for reasons that will be presently shown. When the farmer has brought all together, he will astonish even him- self by the amount he has procured ; and if he attends to our directions, he will be far more astonished at the results, as shown in greatly increased crops. The most valuable substances contained in the material of the compost heap are Silicate of Potash, Phosphate of Lime, and Nitrogen as Potential Ammonia. The chemical changes effected on these substances by fermentation may be briefly stated, as follows : Fermentation and putrefaction are generally considered dis- SOLUBLE PHOSPHORIC ACID. 187 tinct processes, but the chemical operation of each is precisely the same ; it is simply a union of the carbon contained in the dead vegetable or animal matter, with the oxygen of the atmos- phere, or the oxygen of the water present in the substance. This chemical union of oxygen and carbon produces carbonic acid gas, the properties of which have been fully explained. The action of this gas' on the silicate of potash, separates the potash from the silica and forms carbonate of potash, the silica being liberated, as hydrated silica. This change renders both substances immediately available, as food for plants. Before the change, they were in an insoluble condition, and, if contained in unrotted straw, might remain in the soil a year or more, without benefiting growing vegetation. As the phosphate of lime contained in plants is in the most finely divided state, the carbonic acid attacks and decomposes this compound, forming carbonate of lime, and liberating the phosphoric acid in a soluble condition, for the use of the plant. There is a remarkable chemical law, namely : that some elements have no affinity for each other, and hence will not form compounds unless one or the other is present in what is termed the nascent state^ that is, the state in which it ex- ists at the moment it is separated from a pre- 13 188 AMERICAN MANURES. vious state of combination. For example; the two gases, nitrogen and hydrogen, the elements of ammonia, may be mechanically mixed, but no chemical combination will ensue. But should nitrogen be present when water is being decom- posed, the hydrogen being in the nascent state, actual ammonia will at once be formed. As sulphate of lime or land plaster — which is a compound of sulphuric acid, lime and water — is present in the heap, the carbonate of ammonia formed, decomposes the above compound, pro- ducing carbonate of lime and sulphate of am- monia, which is a stable compound, very soluble in water. The formation of this salt prevents loss from the volatilization of the ammonia. This is the object in applying it in the heap. From this the farmer can realize the importance of applying plaster to his compost heap. Still, it must be added with discretion, and not in larger quantity than we have recommended ; if too much is added, it will check the fermenta- tion, and thus defeat the object to be attained by composting; 100 lbs. of ordinary unburnt ground gypsum will fix nearly 20 lbs. of ammonia. The sulphuric acid of the gypsum will also act beneficially, in decomposing the mineral sub- stances contained in the vegetable remains. The ammonia formed in the compost heap often- times undergoes another change, which may be THE COMPOST HEAP. 189 termed oxidation ; being changed from an alkali to an acid, forming nitrates of potash, soda, and lime, if these bases are present. Some chemists hold the opinion that the nitrogen contained in these compounds, is far more valuable than as it is presented in ammonia ; but this is a difficult matter to decide, and more extended experiments are required, to enable us to give a positive opinion on the subject. As far as our present knowledge of the matter goes, they are equally valuable, although it is proved that the ammo- nia is more permanent in the soil than nitric acid. A valuable addition to the compost heap, is ground bones. This substance furnishes both phosphoric acid and nitrogen ; and if the bones are mixed with an equal weight of finely ground gypsum, and fully incorporated with the heap, the farmer will produce his own soluble phos- phoric acid, at less than half the cost he would have to pay for it, if purchased from the manu- facturers. Again, when the pile is turned over — an operation that must be attended to in order to produce good results — should the farmer de- tect the smell of escaping ammonia, another light sprinkle of plaster must be applied. The time required to produce fermentation, varies with the season ; in summer, the heap may commence heating in from six to ten days ; but in winter, it will require as many weeks. 190 AMERICAN MANURES. When it sets in, the heat gradually increases until it has reached a certain point; then it decreases, until it is imperceptible. The pile should then be shovelled over, and a second fer- mentation will take place as before ; this cooling of the pile being caused by the exhaustion of available oxygen in the mass. If the farmer has attended to applying gypsum as directed, there will be no loss or damage produced by overheating. A great deal of vapor is formed during the fermentation, and a part of it escapes into the atmosphere. The farmer should be careful to note whether it contains any ammonia, which he can do by the smell. If it does, a light sprinkle of gypsum, with a little dry earth, will prevent loss. Part of the vapor condenses as it approaches the surface of the heap, and will gradually find its way into the drain ; and as it flows out, it can be mixed with earth or muck, and a little plaster, and thrown on the heap. One great mistake commonly made by our farmers, is in not allowing the compost heap a sufficient time to become thoroughly decomposed, before applying it. The time required to effect complete decomposition is from one to two years ; and should it be used before decomposition is completely accomplished, the farmer does not get that return for his labor in collecting, mix- ing, and turning over, that he w^ould realize if BAD COMPOSTING. 191 he waited until the mass is in the most efficient condition. The practice of mixing up a mass of hetero- geneous materials, and letting it stand three, four, or six months, and then applying it to the soil, will not pay for the labor and expense; rather than compost in that manner, it would be better to apply the materials at once to the soil. This quick method of composting — necessarily followed by unsatisfactory results — has brought composting into discredit and disuse by many farmers, who might derive great benefit if they complied with the conditions necessary to suc- cess. A still more reprehensible practice than that above stated, is that of using quicklime in compost heaps ; it should never be done. It has the effect to dissipate the nitrogen and am- monia ; besides, it absorbs the carbonic acid, and leaves the organic substances in their ori- ginal insoluble condition. It is very necessary that the farmer should know the value of the compost, and the amount that should be applied to an acre. * In order to know this, he should keep an account of the loads of barn-yard manure and other substances used ; and then, the Tables we have given in this book will enable him to approximate very nearly to the value of the heap, and the amount that should be applied to an acre to produce a given crop. CHAPTER VII. GENERAL REMARKS ANALYSES OF COMMERCIAL FERTILIZERS, WITH COMMENTS AND CRITICISMS METHODS OF ANALYSIS CONCLUSION. The general reader, and particularly far- mers, should carefully note what is contained in this chapter, as it vitally affects their interests. It will show how unprincipled men, from selfish motives, and by dishonest practices, are stripping them of the hard-earned fruits of honest in- dustry ; and will give a limited idea of the extent of the frauds that have been unblushingly practised for years, unchecked and almost un- heeded. We have already indicated the cure for these wrongs; and now, when we picture them in their true colors, thinking men, we doubt not, will at once apply the remedy by preparing their own fertilizers, and leaving those of dishonest manufacturers alone. We have fully proved the justice of the values assigned to the fertilizing constituents of com- mercial manures by us, and have also shown that the best authorities in this and other coun- 192 GENERAL REMARKS. 193 tries have set their valuations lower than we have done. It is possible that manufacturers may object to our allowing them nothing for the insoluble portion of the phosphoric acid contained in their so-called superphosphates. But we have shown by the best authorities, that phosphoric acid as contained in mineral phosphate (the chief in- gredient in their phosphates), or even in bones, is not available as plant food for many years, — ten, twenty or more, — and the statements of the manufacturers themselves on this subject show that they are right in theory, if not in practice. The most limited knowledge of finance will show that no value should be assigned to it, because if it takes only 10 years to make it available as plant food, the interest would amount to as much as the purchase money; and if it takes 15 years to make it available, the interest with the purchase money amounts to more than the value of phosphoric acid in soluble form. Be- sides, no farmer would knowingly purchase a fertilizer that requires 10 to 20 years to give him a return for his money. The loss by the use of such a manure is not confined to the loss of the interest on the purchase money, but, in addition, the farmer loses his time and the profitable use of his land, which of itself involves many other losses. Independent of all this, such 194 AMERICAN MANURES. inert substance should manifestly have no place in a high-priced fertilizer, the very name of which implies that it does not contain it. The products of the farm are closely scrutin- ized, and the quality graded, when they are brought to the market, and from this cause many a farmer has not realized from his produce as much as he anticipated. No farmer is allowed to sell the chaff with the wheat, nor portions of the cob with the corn. Butter must be properly made, as the quality fixes the price ; and should there be an extra amount of salt used, dishonest motives are at once attributed to the farmer, as intending to make up weight; and should the same butter be found a little deficient in weight, it is at once confiscated. " It is a bad rule that wont work both ways." Hence, should the far- mer want crude mineral phosphate, it should be sold to him as siicJi^ at a cost of $12 to $20 a ton, and not be palmed ujDon him under the false name of superphosphate at $40 to $60 per ton. We have hitherto dealt in generalities. Having spoken of frauds practised, in the mass, we shall now treat them in detail, and we hope the reader will examine the analyses, and carefully compare them with the statements of these manufacturers. If this be done, our re- marks about their frauds will add no additional force to the damning testimony which they themselves have furnished. ANALYSES. 195 ANALYSES OF WATSON & OLAKK'S SUPER. PHOSPHATE. Percentage, or amount contained in 100. Water(expelled at "I 2120 Fall.) J Nitrogen. Nitrogen in or- ] ganic matter. J Potash. Phosphoric Acid^ (anhydrous), I soluble in water { atCOOto 70OF. J Insoluble Phos- phoric Acid(an- hydrous.) 1st Sample. 2d Sample. 12-67 12-89 0-17 0-19 057 0-62 trace trace 5-61 5-56 7-22 7-18 Mean. 12-78 0-18== 0-22 0-60 trace of Actual Ammonia. C of Super- 5-59= 9-21 -< phosphate (^ of Lime. r of Bone 7-20=15-72 -] Phosphate ( of Lime. From the mean of the above analyses, we de- duce the following amounts contained in a ton, or 2000 lbs. 5 together with the value of a ton to the farmer : 255-60 lbs. Water. @ $0.00 per lb. $0.00 4-40 *' Actual Ammonia @ 0.25 " 1.10 12-00" Nitrogen in organic mat. @ 0.15 " 1.80 111-80 lbs. Soluble Phos. Acid @ 0.12^ " 13.97 144-00 " Insoluble " " .... (^ 0.00 "• 0.00 Total value as Superphosphate $16.87 Yalue of bags (say) 2.00 Total value to farmer $18.87 The above phosphate is sold at $45 per ton, involving a loss of $26.13, or 138 per cent., to the farmer on ever}^ ton he purchases. He pays for it very nearly 2 J times what it is worth. 196 AMERICAN MANURES. WATSON & CLARK'S SUPERPHOSPHATE. The above fertilizer, from which the samples for analyses were selected, was purchased from the manufacturers at their office in Philadelphia. It is put up in 200 lb. bags ; the one purchased weighed 201 J lbs. Its mechanical condition was good; the mineral phosphate from which it was manufactured had been finely ground, and there were no hard lumps to interfere with its. application by drilling. The circular of these manufacturers is a model of its kind. They frankly state the kind of material used, and the source from which it is procured. They give no analyses of their article, which they should do, but say they manufacture a superphosphate of lime — "Under the supervision of Prof. James C. Booth of the U. S. Mint, and every parcel made is analyzed by him or his partner, Dr. Garrett, in order to ascertain if it comes up to the required standard." They do not inform us what this standard is, but as they profess to manufacture a super- phosphate^ the required standard should be that. The analysis shows by the Insoluble Phosphoric Acid how far they fail. But if we take the price at which it is sold into account, it is one of the cheapest fertilizers in the market; i. 6., the farmer gets more of what he needs for his money than in many other fertilizers more strongly recommended. ANALYSES. 197 ANALYSES OF ERODES' SUPERPHOSPHATE. Percentage, or amount contained in 100. Ist Sample 7-67 2nd Sample. 7-79 Mean. Water (expelled at^ 212° Fahrenheit).) 7-73 Nitrogen trace trace trace trace trace trace Nitrogen in organic | matter. j Potash, soluble in | acidulated water, j trace trace trace •Phosphoric A c i d "^ (anhydrous), sol- [ uble in water at 60° to 70O F. 3-63 3-40 r S u p e r phos- 3-52=:5-80 \ phate of (^ Lime. Insoluble Phospho- \ C Bone Phos- ric Acid (anhy- v 15-16 15-34 15-25=33-29 J phate of drous.) 3 II (_ Lime. From the mean of the above analyses^ we de- duce the following amounts contained in a ton, or 2000 Ibs.j together with the value of a ton to the farmer : 154-60 lbs. Water @ $0.00 per lb. $0.00 Trace Nitrogen @ 0.15 ** 0.00 70-40 lbs. Soluble Phos. Acid @ 0.12^ " 8.80 305-00 *' Insoluble '' " Ccb 0.00 " 0.00 Total value, as Superphosphate $8.80 Yalue of bags (say) 2.00 Total value to farmer $10.80 The above phosphate is sold at $50 per ton, involving a loss of $39.20, or 363 per cent, to the farmer on every ton he purchases ; or, in other words, he pays for it 4| times as much as it is worth. 198 AMERICAN MANURES. EHODES' SUPERPHOSPHATE. The above fertilizer, from which samples for analyses were selected, was purchased from Messrs. Yarnall & Trimble, Philadelphia. It is put up in bags, marked 200 lbs; the one pur- chased weighed 201 lbs. The mechanical con- dition of the fertilizer was good. The manu- facturer's circular gives the following analyses, said to be furnished by Prof Johnson in 1859. RHODES' SUPERPHOSPHATE OP LIME. Water (expelled at 2120) 22-25 22*34 Matter volatile at red heat 20-17 20*00 Sand and insoluble matters 1*82 2*57 Lime 14-90 15-85 Phosphoric Acid, soluble in water 13*78 13*85 " insoluble " -64 '67 The above analyses of Prof Johnson widely differ from our analyses of Rhodes Superphos- phate. We do not question the correctness of the analyses given by Prof Johnson in 1859, but there is evidently a marked falling off in the quality since that time ; and to publish these analyses with his or any other eulogistic state- ment, at the present time, is a great injus- tice to the Professor, and shows an evident disposition on the part of the manufacturer or agents to deceive and defraud their customers. As the fertilizer is now manufactured, in con- nection with the price demanded for it, we cannot characterize it as being anything short of a fraud and a cheat-. ANALYSES. 199 ANALYSES OF BERGER & BUI^Z'S EXCELSIOR SUPERPHOSPHATE OP LLME. Percentage, or amount contained in 100. Mean. :} Water (expelled at 2120Fahrenheit) Nitrogen. Nitrogen in organic " matter. Potash soluble in " acidulated water. Phosphoric Acid (anhydrous)j sol- uble in water at 60O to 70O F. Insoluble Phos-"^ phoric Acid (an- hydrous). 1st Sample. 9-15 2n(i Sample. 9-08 trace trace 1-42 1-46 trace trace 5-23 5-18 8-19 8-36 9-12 trace== Actual Ammonia 1-44 trace I Superphos- phate of Lime. (BonePhos- phate of Lime. From the mean of the above analyses, we deduce the following amounts, contained in a ton, or 2000 lbs., together with the value of a ton to the farmer. 182-40 lbs. Water @ $0.00 per lb. $ 0.00 28 80 *' Nitrogen in organic matter @ 0.15 " 4.32 104-20 " Soluble Phosphoric Acid.. @ 0.12^ " 13.03 165-60 " Insoluble Phosphoric Acid. @ 0.00 '' 0.00 Total value as fertilizer $17.35 Yalue of bags (say) 2.00 Total value to farmer $19.35 The above phosphate is sold at $50 per ton, involving a loss of $30.65, or nearly 159 per cent, to the farmer, on every ton he purchases ; or, in other words, he pays nearly 2| times as much for it as it is worth. 200 AMERICAN MANURES. BERGER & BUTZ'S EXCELSIOR SUPER PHOSPHATE or LIME. The above fertilizer, from which samples for analyses were selected, was purchased at the manufacturer/ office, Philadelphia. It is put up in bags marked 200 lbs. ; the bag purchased weighed 201 lbs. Its mechanical condition was bad, the mineral phosphate from which it is made had seemingly been ground fine, but the finished product had dried in hard lumps in the bag, which would be a great inconvenience to the farmer if he wished to apply it with a drill. It is strange that these manufacturers do not see the importance of reducing their fertilizers to a powder, before sending them to the farmer, who naturally expects it fully prepared to apply to tlie soil, either by drilling or by hand. When the farmer has to reduce these lumps to a pow- der, he is doing the work of the manufacturers for Avhich he pays, and which could be done by them at far less cost. Messrs. Berger & Butz issue a very modest circular. They give no analysis of their fertilizer, which every manufacturer should do, as it alone is the only guarantee of its quality. The amount of soluble phosphoric acid and nitrogen it con- tains, is far more than in some other fertilizers that are more strongly recommended. ANALYSES. 20] ANALYSES OF ''THE MAGNUM BONUM SOLUBLE PHOSPHATE," DUGDALE & GIRVIN SOLE PRO- PRIETORS, BALTIMORE, MD. Percentage, or amount contained in 100. Mean. Water (expelled at 1 2120 Fahrenheit), j Nitrogen Nitrogen in organic 1 matter. j Potash, soluble in | acidulated water. J Phosphoric Acid (anhydrous), sol- uble in water at 60O to 70O F. J Insoluble Phospho- ric Acid (anhy- drous). 1st 2nd Sample. Sample. 12-57 12-48 0-15 0-17 0-72 0-73 0-84 0-82 4-45 4-48 6-95 6-62 12-53 0-16=0-20 ( Actual Am- 0-73 683 r S u p e rphos- 4-47=7-37 -I phate of (^ Lime. C Bone Phos- 6-79=14-82-5 phate of (^ Lime. From the mean of the above analyses, we de- duce the following amounts contained in a ton, or 2000 lbs., together with the value of a ton to the farmer : 250-60 lbs. Water @ 4-00 " Actual Ammonia @ 14-60 " Nitrogen in organic matter. @ 16-60 '' Potash @ 89-40 '' Soluble Phosphoric Acid . . @ 135-80 " Insoluble " '' . . @ $0.00 per lb. $0.00 0.25 0.15 0.08 0.12i 0.00 1.00 2.19 1.33 IL17 0.00 Total value as fertilizer $15. 69 Value of bags (say) 2.00 Total value to farmer $17.69 The above named fertilizer is sold at $52 per 202 AMERICAN MANURES. ton, involving a loss to the farmer of $34.31, or 194 per cent, on every ton he purchases, or, in other words, he pays for it very nearly 3 times as much as it is worth. "THE MAGNUM BONUM SOLUBLE PHOSPHATE." The above fertilizer, from which samples for analyses were selected, was purchased at the office of Messrs. Dugdale & Girvin, Baltimore, Md. It is put up in bags, marked 167 lbs. ; the bag purchased weighed 170 lbs. Its mechanical condition was very bad, being composed almost entirely of coarse, hard lumps, that, were pul- verized with considerable difficulty, and we should think it would cause considerable trouble to the farmer to prepare it for drilling. Messrs. Dugdale & Girvin are comparatively modest in recommending this fertilizer. They furnish an analvsis as follows : 1/ ANALYSIS. Made hy Prof. W. LeRoy Broun, formerly of Va. Soluble Bone Phosphate 13*79 Bone Phosphate, soluble in the soil 27-94 Ammonia 382 Potash 4-24 Soda and Magnesia 2*79 This article contains the most valuable constituents in large proportions, and I have no doubt will prove a very valuable Fertilizer. W. LeRoy Broun. December 3c?, 1870. ANALYSES. 203 We would characterize the above as a garbled analysis, calculated to deceive the purchaser. There is no such compound as " Soluble Bone Phosphate ;" the term is absolutely hypothe- tical. There is Bone Phosphate of Lime, 13*79 parts of which contain 6*32 parts of Phospho- ric Acid. But perhaps 6*32 per cent, might not so favorably impress the buyer as 13*79 would ; and '^ Bone Phosphate/' with the prefix " Soluble/' is used by the dealer to favorably im-. press the farmer (unacquainted as he generally is with scientific terms) that he is getting more than twice the value he actually receives. Our analyses and that of Prof W. LeEoy Broun differ widely. We do not say his is not conscientiously made, because there is a possi- bility, not to say probability, that manufacturers and dealers submit a sample of one quality to the chemist for analysis^ and palm off a greatly inferior quality upon purchasers. Certain it is, that the bag we bought shows no such result as that given by Prof W. LeEoy Broun. The Professor's analysis gives 27*94 per cent, of " Bone Phosphate, soluble in the soil/' he does not say in how long, whether it requires ten, twenty, or thirty years. These indefinite state- ments are calculated to deceive any one who is not fully informed on the subject, and the motives for giving them cannot be too strongly repre- hended. 14 204 AMERICAN MANURES. This fertilizer is represented to be composed of Dissolved Bones, Ammonia and Potash ; and " entirely free from any adulterative matter." The analyses show that it contains a great deal of something that is not accounted for. The large percentage of water might seem unneces- sary to the uninitiated. The reader will notice that there is for more of this substance than Superphosphate of Lime, and if he compares the price of this fertilizer with the value, he will naturally come to the conclusion that it is the " Magnum Bonum " {the great good) to the manufacturers and dealers, and the " Magnum Malum " {the great evil) to the farmer. Messrs. Dugdale & Girvin say that this " Mag- num Bonum is the great Generator and nour- isher of Corn, Oats, Grass, Wheat, Tobacco, and other crops and plants." This must be a most won- derful property of this fertilizer, the inference being that the farmer need not use any seed to pro- duce the above crops — the manure itself being a generator. There might, however, be a great disadvan- tage connected with its use ; the farmer naturally would have a desire to raise a specified crop, the generator might beget corn when he wanted wheat, or oats when he wanted tobacco, or might produce them all heterogeneously. We make these suggestions for the benefit of Messrs. Dug- ANALYSES. 205 dale & Girvin, so that in future they may be more careful or more specific in giving the quali- ties of this wonderful manure. " Consistency is a jewel ;" and to show that the proprietors of this wonderful fertilizer are slightly lacking in this virtue, we give the fol- lowing analysis of the " Magnum Bonum/' as given in Messrs. Dugdale & Girvin's advertise- ment in the "Journal of the Farm/' which an- alysis the reader is requested to compare with the analysis furnished by Prof W. LeRoy Broun, formerly of Va. Soluble Bone Phosphate of Lhne 15*33 Bone .Phosphate of Lime 19*64 Ammonia (equal to 12 per cent, of Sulphate)... . 3*16 Potash 4-62 The laws of the State of Maryland require an analysis of every fertilizer to be plainly marked on each package. The bag of " Magnum Bonum" purchased by us had some blurred and half obliterated marks^ which we charitably supposed were intended for an analysis, but we failed to decipher it after expending considerable time endeavoring to do so ; this showing conclusively that the intention was to conform with the letter and not the spirit of the law of Maryland. We would suggest to Messrs. Dugdale & Girvin the propriety of using larger letters and figures, thus saving considerable trouble to their customers, as well as saving their own credit. 206 AMERICAN MANURES. ANALYSES OF AVHANN'S RAW BONE SUPER- PHOSPHATE. Percentage, or amount contained in 100. Water (expelled at 2120 Fahrenheit). Nitrogen. Nitrogen in organic 1 matter. j Potash, soluble in ] acidulated water. J Phosphoric Acid ^ (anhydrous), so- I luble in water at ( 60O to 70O F. J Insoluble Phos- phoric Acid (an- hydrous). l8t Sample. 2d Sample. 9-92 10-06 0-37 0-42 0-91 0-98 0-21 0-19 3-47 3-25 14-30 14-46 Mean. 9-99 0-40-0-49|^^^"^^^"^- 1 monia. 0-94 0-20 r Superphos- 3-36 = 5-54 \ phate of (. Lime. C BonePhos- 14-38:==31-39-< phate of (^ Lime. From the mean of the above analyses, we deduce the following amounts contained in a ton, or 2000 lbs., together with the value of a ton to the farmer : 199-80 lbs. Water @ $0.00 per lb. $0.00 9-80 " Actual Ammonia @ 0.25 " 2.45 18-80 " Nitrogen in organic matter. @ 0.15 " 2.82 4-00 " Potash @ 0.08 " 0.32 67-20 " Soluble Phos. Acid @ 0.12^ " 8.40 287-60 " Insoluble *' *' @ 0.00 " 0-00 Total value as Superphosphate $13.99 Yalue of bags (say) 2.00 Total value to farmer $15.99 The above Phosphate is sold at $52 per ton, involving a loss of $36.01, or 225 per cent., to the farmer on every ton he purchases ; or, in other words, he pays 3i times what it is worth. ANALYSES. 207 WHANN'S RAW BONE SUPERPHOS- PHATE. Tlie above fertilizer, from which samples for analyses were selected, was purchased from the manufacturers' agents, Messrs. Cruft and Young, Philadelphia. It is put up in 200 lb. bags ; the one purchased weighed 203 lbs. The mechanical condition of the fertilizer was only middling ; it had not that homogeneous appearance that a first- class fertilizer should present. This condition may be caused by a portion of the Charleston Guano, or other mineral phosphate, of which it is largely composed, being treated with sulphuric acid, and then mixed with another portion of phosphate in its crude state ; and the superphos- phate, taken as a whole, did not present the ap- pearance of being prepared from substances of "animal oriylnr For the benefit of our readers we have collated the following extracts from the circulars of the manufacturers of this super- phosphate. No. 1. *' Plants during- their germination and development require a constant supply of food, and it is necessary that tliis nourishment be furnished in such a form as to be at once as- similable, and capable of being immediately useful in sustaining their growth." No. 2. '' The experience of the most capable agriculturists throughout the civilized world points to the use of concentrated manures ; those which afford all the elements of plant food in a readily soluble form." No. 3. "The phosphate of lime, as it exists in bones, is in- 208 AMERICAN MANURES. soluble in water, although when placed in the soil it becomes soluble to a very limited extent." No. 4. '' Quick manures increase the business capital of the farmer.'' No. 5. *' Unlike Peruvian Guano, it (Whann's Raw Bone Superphosphate) does not exhaust the soil, but, on the con- trary, it insures a supply of valuable nutriment lasting through several seasons." No. 6. *' The ingredients which enter into the composition of Whann's Raw Bone Superphosphate (raw bones, guano, sulphuric acid, potash and soda), are all subjected to thorough chemical analysis before they are purchased. No inert sub- stances are used. The phosphate is warranted free from adulteration." No. 7. " With the exception of the sulphuric acid, potash, and soda, every ingredient entering into its composition is of animal origin." No. 8. "• Our works are under the daily control and super- vision of an experienced chemist, and are furnished with a completely appointed analytical laboratory, where analyses are made of every ingredient used in the phosphate." No. 9. "Dollar for dollar, Whann's Raw Bone Phosphate will go nearly twice as far as Peruvian the first year." No. 10. "Instead of resorting to indiscriminate pufiBng for the purpose of forcing sales, the manufacturers have contented themselves with allowing it to speak for itself." The reader is aware that the qualifying name of this fertilizer is " Raw Bone." We are anxious to know how much of this substance is used by the manufacturers. On a careful examination we found what might be styled a sprinkling of hone^ but not sufficient for the most limited excuse for giving it the name of " Raw Bone Phosphate." From the amount of soluble phos- ANALYSES. 209 phoric acid present in a ton, the amount of sul- phuric acid used must be very small. Mr. Whann says, that guano is used, but he does not state the kind or kinds, or the propor- tions. We hazard the assertion that there is a large amount of Charleston, with a very small amount of Peruvian. He also notifies us that potash and soda are used. The reader will notice by the analyses, that a ton of his superphosphate contains 4 lbs. of potash, worth 32 cents. The benefits result- ing from such an amount cannot be very marked, as it requires 40 lbs. of potash for 25 bushels of w^heat with the straw. No adulteration is said to be practised in preparing this superphosphate, but Mr. Whann admits to using soda. We pre- sume he means salt cake or sulphate of soda, usually sold for $10 per ton, or he may apply salt or chloride of sodium. In either case, when Mr. Whann can prove the necessity of the use of soda in any^ form in a superphosphate, or that a large amount of crude mineral phosphate, which when ground could not possibly cost him over $17 per ton, should be found in a high-priced fertilizer represented to be made from '" Raw Bone," and sells for $52 per ton, we will admit that there has been no adulteration practised ; and when he can satiefactorily account for the presence of 267*60 lbs. of insoluble phosphoric 210 AMERICAN MANURES. acid in a ton of his " Superphosphate," and prove that this large amount is of immediate benefit to the farmer or to his crops, we will give Whann's Raw Bone Superphosphate all the merit chiimed for it ; until then we shall consider our- selves as cheated in our purchase of this fertilizer, and claim the right of expressing our opinion freely. Our farmers should take a lesson from Mr. Whann, and use a little of his caution in making their purchases, by assuring themselves of the quality of what they buy. As Mr. Whann says he keeps a chemist, we think it is due to him- self, and to the public, that he should publish a full analysis of his " Superphosphate." Were the manufacturers of fertilizers who re- sort to indiscriminate puffing to push forward their products, to inform the farmer as to their quality in a frank manner, by analysis we mean, a different state of affairs would now exist. And if the parties professing to make a Superphos- phate from Raw Bones, had fully informed the farmer of the value of Mineral Phosphates, and candidly admitted to using the latter as a raw material, they would at the present time have little occasion to blush, perhaps, over their petty deceits and subterfuaes. ANALYSES. 211 ANALYSES OF SOLUBLE PACIFIC GUANO. Percentage, oi' amount contained in 100. Water, (expelled at ") 2120 Fahrenheit). J Nitrogen. Nitrogen in organic ") matter. j Potash, soluble in | acidulated water. J Phosphoric Acid ^ (anhj^drous), so- luble in water at 60O to loo Y. Insoluble Phos- phoric Acid (an- hydrous). 1st Sample. 2d Sample. 14-20 14-26 0-83 0-87 1-58 1-44 0-46 0-49 3-87 3-74 11-03 11-23 14-23 0-85 = 1-03 I ActualAm- monia. 1-51 0-48 f Superphos- 3-81 = 6-28 J phate of I Lime. ( BonePhos- 11-13^24-30 \ pliate of [ Lime. From the mean of the above analyses^ we deduce the following amounts contained m a ton, or 2000 lbs., together with the value of a ton to the farmer : 284-60 lbs. Water @ $0.00 per lb. $0.00 20-60 " Actual Ammonia @ 0.25 '* 5.15 30-20 " Nitrogen in organic mat. @ 0.15 *' 4.53 9-60 " Potash @ 0.08 " 0.77 76-20 *' Soluble Phos. Acid @ 0.12J '* 9.53 222-60 *' Insoluble '' '' @ 0.00 " 0.00 Total value as a fertilizer $19.98 Value of bags (say) 2.00 Total value to farmer $21.98 The above fertilizer is sold at $50 per ton, in- volving a loss of $28.02, or 128 per cent, to the farmer on every ton he purchases ; or, in other words, he pays more than 2i times as much as it is worth. 212 AMERICAN MANURES. SOLUBLE PACIFIC GUANO. The above fertilizer, from which samples for analyses were selected, was purchased at the office of the agent of the manufacturers, Phila- delphia. It is put up in bags marked 200 lbs. ; the one purchased weighed 195 lbs., being 5 lbs. deficient Aveight on the bag, or 50 lbs. on the ton. Farmers in purchasing fertilizers should pay particular attention to this matter ; as this fertilizer is sold at 2 J cents per lb., this de- ficiency in weight is a direct loss of $1.25. We have estimated the value of a ton of 2000 lbs. ; this shows a greater value than the deficient weight could demand. As there is a deficiency of 2i per cent, in the weight, to be just, we should deduct the same from the value. The mechanical condition of the fertilizer was good as regards fineness, and can be easily applied with a drill. It contains a large percentage of water, which is a very objectionable feature; every ton contains 284*60 lbs., which the farmer pays 2} cents a pound for, amounting to $7.11 ; to which if we add the $1.25 paid for deficient weight, would make $8.36 paid for what is a direct loss. As this company is represented to sell 20,000 tons yearly, the reader can readily calculate what is made from the sale of the water alone. But this is not a strictly correct i;ho\vin^' of what the fanner pays for the water. ANALYSES. 213 We have shown what 136-60 lbs. of the ton is worth to the farmer, as ammonia, nitrogen, pot- ash, and soluble phosphoric acid. Hence, he pays $28.02 for 1863-4 lbs. of water, sand, and other inert substances, which is over li cents per lb. We give the following quotations from the circular of the wholesale agents of this Fertilizing Company 1. **A beneficent Providence has aggregated the crude ele- ments of fertility/ in exhaiistless quantities all over the world — upon islands of-the sea, and in the sea and elsewhere. Nature, however, does not yield her treasures without an equivalent. Coal is found embedded in mountains ; the precious metals are held bound in the quartz rock, and are adapted to the uses for which nature designed them, only at the cost of labor, enterprise and capital. So also these deposits in their natural state are not in condition for practical utility, but modern science has developed methods by which they are capable of the highest utility to the most important of all interests. Hence, v/hile nature furnishes the crude material, and science the method^ still capital, skill, enterprise and labor are required to adapt them to the purposes designed by nature." 2. " An intelligent pursuit of this business requires a know- ledge of the science of chemistry, especially as applied to agriculture; a knowledge of the physiology of plants, their vital forces, their structure and organism ; a knowledge of the con- stituent elements of vegetable nutrition, of their natural sources of supply, as to whether they be of organic or inorganic origin ; a knowledge of the constituents of the atmosphere and their relations to cultivated plants, of the nature of soils and the conditions in which the elements of fertility may exist; a knowledge of the nature and character of the elements which should enter info the composition of a concentrated fertilizer, their relative proportion etc, ; .a knowledge of the difference 214 AMERICAN MANURES. and value and quality of certain elements which professional chemists call by the same names ; for example, phosphate of Hme, whether mineral or organic, is called phosphate of lime ; potash, whether supphed from felspar or in soluble form, is called potash. In making a report of analyses, chemists are not expected and do not make note of these important differ- ences. They take no note of the fact as to whether ammonia in a fertilizer be in the form of salts, or bo generated from ani- mal organic matter ; hence, published analyses may not give a correct basis of value, for all these questions enter in the consideration." 3. '' If the business be pursued without these proper qualifica- tions it becomes the subject of quackery, as is the case in other professions. A quack is he who pursues a profession under the guidance of rules and examples, without knowledge of laivs or principles, and is therefore liable to constant blunders and mis- takes. No business partaking of the nature of a profession has been more subject to the intrusions of quackery than this very business of manufacturing fertilizers ; hence it is, that so many fertilizers have been placed upon the markets which have proved so nearly worthless, as on the one hand to involve loss of money and time to the consumer, and on the other to create distrust in their minds of those articles that are brought into market by parties possessing all the requisite qualifications as to knowledge of principles involved, and the facilities afforded by ample material resources." Little need be said on these stilted quota- tions, they speak for themselves; and if the reader will compare them with the analyses of their fertilizer, he will be satisfied that they know their duty, but do it not — hence the greater the condemnation. Eival manufacturers should feel obliged to this company for showing them the qualifica- tions requisite for a successful prosecution of ANALYSES. 215 their business ; and, of course, rather than be stigmatized as quacks^ they will at once qualify themselves accordingly, and then we hope they will feel the additional accountability they have imposed on themselves, and make a better use of their knowledge than the Soluble Pacific Guano Company. Their remarks on the practices of Anlytical Chemists are very exceptionable, and demand a few words of explanation. We don't wish to be considered apologists for these chemists — they are getting all they deserve — but it is not right that their profession should be made disreputa- ble on their account. In too many instances they have made willing tools of themselves to advance the interests and further the dishonest practices of these manufacturers ; but after it is done, these manufacturers, in common with other leading swindlers, shoulder all the re- sponsibility on their subordinates. No honest chemist, in rendering an analysis of a fertilizer, would confound the potash as existing in the sulphate or muriate with that of felspar, or with felspar itself; neither would he make use of the combining numbers of gaseous ammonia with one equivalent of water, nor of the com- bining numbers of hydrate of ammonia for those of gaseous ammonia without an explanation, or use such a term as " Soluble Bone Phosphate of 216 AMERICAN MANURES. Lime/' per se ; when this is done, it is the manu- facturer or his agent, not the chemist, that should be accountable. This Company can very properly be styled the ^^ Veneering s^^ of the fertilizing business. The large resources of the Company ($1,000,000) are prominently placed before the public; they breathe in every line of their circular ; they are reflected from the plate glass and gilt letters of the luxurious oflBce of their principal agent ; they shine on the face of the porter that handles the bags ; they are on the tongue of every one em- ployed by the Company. But with all these re« sources, these men defraud the farmer of the fruits of his labor. In speaking of the potash used, they say : ''Although the existmg war between France and Prussia may interrupt commercial intercourse, supplies already re- ceived by the Company are sufficient to meet its wants. "This additional element of value is made at considerable additional cost, but in pursuance of the policy to furnish the best article at the lowest possible cost to consumers, there will be no advance in the price of the Guano." "A great cry, but little wool." If the reader will refer to the analyses, he will see that each ton contains a little over Qi lbs. of potash, worth 77 cents. This is only a sample of the high- sounding representations of these men, and shows the margin that should be allowed on their state- ments. It is due to the public that they furnish an analysis of their fertilizer. ANALYSES. 217 ANALYSES OF BAUGH & SONS' EAW BONE SUPERPHOSPHATE. Percentage, or amount contained in 100. 1st Sample. 2.1 Sample. Mean. Water (expelled at | 2 120 Fahrenheit).} 7-71 7-50 7-61 Nitrogen. 0-21 0-22 0-22 :- 0-27 J ^''*''^^^'^- \ monia. 1-00 Nitrogen in organic ) matter. j 0-95 1-04 Potash, soluble in | acidulated water, j trace trac« trace Phosphoric Acid"] / Ruperphos- (anhydrous), so- 3-36 3-34 3-35 = b -52] P^^^® ^^ luble in water, ( Tjime. at 60O to 70O F. Insoluble Phospho- Y / Bone Phos- ric Acid (ax-ihy- >• 9-25 9-46 9'36^20-43] pirate of drous). J ( Lime. From the mean of the above analyses, we de- duce the following amounts contained in a ton, or 2000 lbs., together with the value of a ton to th<> farmer : 152-20 lbs. Water @ $0.00 per lb. $0.00 5-40 '* Actual Ammonia @ 0.25 " 1.35 20-00 " Nitrogen in organic mat. @ 0.15 ** 3.00 (< Trace Potash @ 0.08 " 0.00 67-00 '' Soluble Phos. Acid @ 0.12^ " 8.38 187-20 *' Insoluble " '' @ 0.00 " 0.00 Total value as a fertilizer $12.73 Yalue of bags (say) 2.00 Total value to farmer $14.73 The above Superphosphate is sold at $50 per ton, involving a loss of $0 5. 2 7, or more than 239 per cent, to the farmer on every ton he pur- chases ; or, in other words, he pays more than 3i times what it is worth. 218 AMERICAN MANURES. BAUGH AND SONS' RAW BONE SUPER- PHOSPHATE. The Superphosphate, from which the sam- ples for analyses were selected, was purchased at the manufacturers' office, Philadelphia. This fertilizer is put up in bags marked 160 lbs. ; the bag purchased weighed 158 lbs. The mechani- cal condition of this fertilizer was bad ; it had formed in hard lumps in the bags, requiring con- siderable force to pulverize. We make the following quotations from the circulars of the manufacturers, and from the " Journal of the Farm," published also by them : 1 " That the standard of our Eaw Bone Superphosphate has never been hnpaired, but that we have constantly sought to improve its vakie as a •permanent Bone Manure by every facility at our command." 2. " It is better than Peruvian Guano, because it does not over-stimulate the soil. It has less Ammonia than Peruvian, but it has Ammonia enough for all the purposes of a crop, and more Ammonia than this does more harm than good." 3. '*It is>better than any Guano, or mixture of Guanos, or any Superphosphate we are acquainted with, because being made of Bone, it remains active in the soil, and continues to produce crops year after year, which farmers well know is not the case with other • quick-acting and easily exhausted Phos- phates." 4. "It has never been the policy nor aim of the manufactu- rers of Baugh's Raw Bone Phosphate to push forward their article by any extraordinary means, nor by disparaging any of the other excellent manures and guanos in the American market." — Journal of the Farm. ANALYSES. 219 5. '' Bone is the natural fertilizer, intended by Provi- dence to keep up the fertility." 6. " The best manure is the cheapest. ... At the present high price of all kinds of fertilizers, it is very poor economy to remain uninformed of the quality and character of the manures used." 7. "The price of the article, at the present rate of the raw material, is placed as low as it is possible to afford a manure of like standard ; the constant desire of the manufacturers being to furnish to farmers an article of a high quality, at as low rate as the most prudent and economical could not object to." 8. " It is the cheapest fertilizer now before the public. — This is substantiated by the careful experiments of thousands of practical farmers in the United States, and the same con- clusion may be arrived at by those who will compare the per- centage and price of any fertilizer ofiered in the market." 9. ''It must be borne in mind, however, in making this cal- culation, that Phosphate of Lime is valuable only in such form or combination as will act directly and effectually upon the soil. There are many fertilizers said to contain a large per- centage, which are almost useless or inoperative, by reason of this insolubility or connection with deleterious substances." 10. *' In Baugh's ' Kaw Bone Phosphate,' the Phosphate of Lime is in its purest and most effective form, and acts imme- diately and directly without any counteracting influence." 11. •' The reason of this is, -that it is made fvoin pure bones ; the original animal matter being present, and not having been extracted by burning, steaming, or any of the processes to which nearly all the bones sold to farmers are subjected." 12. . . "In the process of manufacturing, the animal mat- ter of the ' Raw Bone ' is converted into Ammonia, and the Phosphate of Lime which it contains is rendered sufficiently soluble to act upon the growing plant." 13. "And these two important agents begin to act at once, tho Ammonia making the leaf and stalk, and the Phosphate of Lime making the grain." 14. " Neither * Stable Manure' ' GuanOy nor any ' Super- phosphate,' or other preparations with which we are acquainted, 15 220 AMERICAN MANURES. will at all compare with ' Baugh's Raw Bone Phosphate ' in its lasting effects, as a crop producer and permanent improver of the soil." Messrs. Dugdale and Girvin, of Baltimore, are the wholesale agents for Baugh's Raw Bone Phosphate. We quote the following from their circular in relation to this fertilizer : " In again offering to the agricultural community this well known Fertilizer, it is only necessary for us to say that it is HIGHLY IMPROVED AND BETTER THAN EVER." " The basis of its manufacture is, as formerly, pure Raw Bone." ** It has more Soluble Phosphate — hence is quicker in its action.'^ " Although second to none, and superior to many other Ferti- lizers, its price is lower than most articles of similar valued ANALYSIS! Soluble Bone Phosphate 14-10 Sol^ble i^ the soil 19-64 Aifln^onia 3-16 The reader will notice that the chemist's sig- nature is wanting; and as no honest, capable chemist would make use of such terms as " Solu- ble Bone Phosphate/' or " Soluble in the soil " without an explanation, the above " analysis " is open to very grave suspicion. Note. — One of the authors having been in the employ of Messrs. Baugh & Sons for a number of years, the authors, from a feeling of delicacy, forbear criticising or censuring either their circular or product ; otherwise, they might do so with great propriety. ANALYSES. 221 ANALYSES OF E. FRANK COE'S SUPP^RPHOS- PHATE OF LIME. Percentage, or amount contaiyied in 100. Water (expelled at ] 2120 Fahrenheit), j Nitrogen . . Nitrogen in organic matter Potash, soluble m acidulated water, Phosphoric Acid (anhydrous), sol- uble in water at j 60Oto70OF J Insoluble Phospho-") ric Acid (anhy- V drous) ) lie I 1st Sample. 2(i S'luiple. 13-00 13-11 0-55 0-51 1-35 1-43 trace trace 6-39 6-53 8-29 8-32 Mean. :0-64 j Actual Am- 1 monia. 1306 0-53= 1-39 trace f Superphos- 6-46-=10-64S phate of I Lime. [ Bone Phos- 8-31=18-14 j phate of I Lime. From the mean of the above analyses we de- duce the following amounts contained in a ton, or 2000 lbs., together with the value of a ton to the farmer : 261-20 lbs. Water >• . . @ 12-80 " Actual Ammonia. @ 27-80 " Nitrogen in organic mat. (^ 129-20 " Soluble Phos. Acid @ 166-20 " Insoluble " " ..,, (a) $ 0.00 per lb. $ 0.00 0.25 " 3.20 0.15 " 4.17 0.12i '* 16.15 0.00 " 0.00 Total value as fertilizer $23.52 Value of bags (say) 2.00 Total value to farmer $25.52 The above Superphosphate is sold at $52 per ton, involving a loss of $26.48, or nearly 104 per cent, to the farmer on every ton he pur- chases ; or, in other words, he pays more than twice as much as it is worth. 222 AMERICAN MANURES. E. FRANK COE'S SUPERPHOSPHATE OF LIME. The above Superphosphate, from which sam- ples for analyses were selected, was purchased from Graham, Emlen & Passmore, the manufac- turers agents, Philadelphia. Its mechanical con- dition was good, and we should think it could be easily applied with a drill. We select the fol- lowing analyses from the manufacturer s circu- lar ; the first was made by Dr. G. A. Liebig, Bal- timore, dated August 3d, 1854. The second was made by Professor S. W. Johnson, of Yale Col- lege, dated May 23d, 1865. If the reader will compare these analyses with the analyses of this Superphosphate as purchased by us, he will see how this celebrated fertilizer has gradually de- teriorated in value ; comment is unnecessary : ANALYSIS BY -DR LIEBIG, GIVES : Phosphoric Acid contained in Biphosphate of Lime, 12-11 Pliosphoric Acid free (anhydrous) 4*80 Total Phosphoric acid (soluble) 16*91 Phosphate of Iron and Ammonia 0*34 Alkaline Salts -41 Organic matter capable of producing Ammonia 3-65 "Water as Moisture and Loss 15-87 ANALYSIS BY PROFESSOR JOHNSON, GIVES : Water expelled at 212° 12-18 Soluble Phosphoric Acid 9-43 Insoluble Phosphoric Acid 1-G5 Ammonia in organic and volatile mutters 2-76 ANALYSES. 223 ANALYSES OF MORO PHILLIPS' PHUINE. Ferceyitaqe, or amount coniawed in 100. Water (expelled at|^ 2120 Fahrenheit). I Nitrogen Nitrogen in organic matter. Potash, soluble in acidulated water, Phosphoric Acid (anhydrous), sol- uble in water at 60O to 70° F. Insoluble Phospho- ric Acid (anhy- drous). :} 1st 2iid Sample. Sainpltt. 7'88 7-7G 017 0-18 0-93 0-95 0-94 0-88 2-71 2-65 13-89 13-97 f Actual Am- 1 monia. 7-82 0-18-=0'22 0-94 0-91 Super phos- 2-68=4-42 \ phate of Lime. Bone Phos- 13-93^=30-41-^ phate of Lime. From the mean of the above analyses^ we de- duce the following amounts contained in a ton, or 2000 lbs. ^ together with the value of a ton to the farmer : 156-40 lbs. Water 4*40 " Actual Ammonia 18*80 *' Nitrogen in organic mat.. .. 18-20 *' Potash 53-60 " Soluble Phos. Acid. 278-60 '' Insoluble " " . 50.00 per lb. $0.00 0.25 " LIO 0.15 " 2.82 0.08 *' 1.46 0.12^ " 6.70 0.00 " 0.00 Total value as fertilizer $1-2.08 Yalue of bags (say) 2.00 Total value to farmer $14.08 The above Fertilizer is sold at $50 per ton, in- volving a loss of $35. 92, or 255 percent., to the far- mer on every ton he purchases; or, in other words, he pays for it 3i times as much as it is worth. 224 AMERICAN MANURES. ANALYSES OF MORO PHILLIPS' GENUINE PROVED SUPERPHOSPHATE OF LIME. Percentage, or mnount contained in 100. IM- Water(expelledat 2120 Fah.) Nitrogen. Nitrogen in or- ganic matter. Potash, soluble in ) acidulated water J Phosphoric Acid ^ (anhydrous), I soluble in water f at 60O to 70O F. J Insoluble Phos- phoric Acid (anhydrous). l8t Sample. 2d Sample. 12-40 12-42 0-26 0-21 0-39 0-42 0-80 0-74 4-63 4-54 13-21 13-40 Mean. 12-41 0-24: 0-41 0-77 =0-29 I Actual Am inonia. C Superphos- 4*59= 7*56 < phate of (^ Lime. TBonePhos- 13-31=:2906 -] phate of (^ Lime. • From the mean of the above analyses, we de- duce the following amounts contained in a ton, or 2000 lbs., together with the value of a ton to the farmer : 248-20 lbs. Water @ $0.00 per lb. $0.00 .5-80 8-20 15-40 91-80 266-20 Actual Ammonia Nitrogen in organic mat.. Potash Soluble Plios. Acid Insoluble " " @ Co) 0.25 0.15 0.08 0.12^ 0.00 1.45 1.23 1.23 11.48 0.00 Total value as fertilizer $15-39 Yalue of bags (say) 2.00 Total value to farmer $17-39 The above Superphosphate is sold at $50 per ton, involving a loss of $32. 61, or 188 per cent, to the farmer on every ton he purchases ; or, in other words, he pays for it nearly 2tV times as much as it is worth. ANALYSES. 225 MORO PHILLIPS' GENUINE IMPROVED SUPERPHOSPHATE OP LIME. The above Superphospliate, from which the samples for analyses were selected, was j)urchased from the manufacturer at his office in Philadel- phia. It is put up in bags marked 200 lbs. ; the one purchased weighed 200 lbs. The Phuine was purchased at the works of the man- ufacturer in Camden. It is put up in bags marked 200 lbs. ; the one purchased weighed 196 lbs. The mechanical condition of both the Superphosphate and the Phuine was very good, and we should judge that they could be easily ap- plied with a drill. We give the following quo- tations from the circular of the manufacturer, showing what he modestly claims for his " Genu- ine Improved Superphosphate of Lime." Of the Phuine, he says nothing. Our analyses of the latter will fully show its claims, " l^Calling the attention of buyers to this highly concen- trated genuine Superphosphate, I guarantee it to be as repre- sented." ''I CLAIM, " First. — That it contains less moisture than any other in the market. The ingredients of this Superphosphate are Bone Phosphate, Sulphuric Acid and Ammonia." "Second. — It is more uniform in quality, one bag being a fair sample of 10,000 tons." "Third. — It contains more agricultural value than any other Superphosphate of Lime in the market." " Fourth. — The desire of the manufacturer to maintain his 226 AxMERICAN MANURES. high reputation as a manufacturer of acids and other ch ?mi cals, as well as the manufacturer of the best Superphosphate, is a safe ground of assurance that it will ahvays be uniformly excellent ; and a further guarantee of uniformity is, that it is always made in the same way from one source, and that its ource is unlimited in extent, and under his entire control." " Fifth. — The consumer can depend upon always receiving a uniform article." "I recommend this article with confidence, because T know what it is, and have experience as to its effects. The value of a real Supherphosphate of Lime as a fertilizer is well known, both in this country and Europe. In England alone, more than ONE HUNDRED thousand tons are annually sold. I intro- duce this article to farmers in general as a staple and standard article, intending to make it a permanent trade." " Examine carefully the brand on each barrel and bag ; by paying attention to this you will never be deceived into buying a worthless article." ■ *' The proprietor had to overcome at first the great predju- dice existing to Superphosphates in general, as there had been so many spurious articles in the market of late years ; but he is happy to say, he has succeeded in doing so, and the only way now to retain the returning confidence of agriculturists, is to keep true to his promise and keep his Superphosphate to its standard." " Caution to Buyers, '* Observe that my name and place of manufacture are on each and every package, none other being genuine. I will guarantee the quality of every package sold by me, and if any manufacturer or dealer should be induced, by the reputation of my article, to palm a spurious imitation of it on the public, it will be my business to detect and punish him. Should this book reach any parties who have sold or used, or who may hereafter use my Superphosphate, and should it not fulfil all it professes to do, they have full liberty to contradict my assertions, and I will cheerfully bear all the expenses of tlie same." '• Moro Phillips, *' Sole Froprietor and Manufacturer," ANALYSES. 227 This manufacturer makes great pretensions of the quality and standard of his Superphos- phate ; but unfortunately he has not stated in his circulars what this quality and standard is, or given an analysis; consequently, we are com- pelled to take our analyses of his Superphosphate as our guide in deciding this matter, from which showing we feel compelled to state that the standard is low and the quality bad, and at the price at which it is sold, is a shameful imposi- tion on the farmer ; and also that the manufac- turer should look at home, instead of censuring rival manufacturers, or, in other words, ^^ He should take the beam out of his own eye, to ena- ble him to see clearly to take the mote out of his brother's eye." And we think the agricultural community will consider it the duty of the manu- facturer to elevate the standard and improve the quality of his Superphosphate, if that be pdssible^ rather than keep it at its present grade. When he does this, he will discover that it is not necessary to blow his own trumpet as long and as loud as he has done. Little need be said of the Phuine ; it is sold at the same price as the Superphosphate, and hence, the reader can see by the analyses, that it is even a greater swindle than the latter. 228 AMERICAN MANURES. ANALYSES OF ''THE EXCELLENZA AMMONIATED SOLUBLE PHOSPHATE." Percentage, or amount contaiiied in 100. Water (expelled at | 2120 Fahrenheit) j Nitrogen Nitrogen in or- ] ganic matter . . J Potash, soluble in ) acidulated water. ) Phosphoric Acid ^ (anhydrous), sol- | uble in water at j 60Oto 70OF... J Insoluble Phos- phoric Acid (an- hydrous) 1st Sample. 2d Sample. 13-86 13-79 0-55 0-57 2-41 2-31 trace trace 9-71 9-84 1-68 1-57 Mean. 13-83 0-56 -=0 2-36 trace 9-78==16' -68 I Actual Am- monia. ■"{ 1-63 =-3-56 Superphos- phate of Lime. Bone Phos- phate of Lime. From the mean of the above analyses, we de- duce the following amounts contained in a ton, or 2000 lbs., together with the value of a ton to the farmer : 276-60 lbs. Water. 13-60 47-20 195-60 32-60 Actual Ammonia (db Nitrogen in organic matter. @ Trace Potash @ Soluble Phosphoric Acid.. @ Insoluble '' " (cb )0.00perlb. $ 0.00 0.25 " 3.40 0.15 " 7.08 0.08 '' 0.00 0.12i " 24.45 0.00 '' 0.00 Total value as fertilizer $34.93 Yalue of bags (say) 2.00 Total value to farmer $36.93 The above fertilizer is sold at $56 per ton, in- volving a loss of $19.07, or 52 per cent, to the farmer on every ton he purchases ; or, in other words, he pays for it more than li times as much as it is worth. ANALYSES. 229 THE EXCELLENZA AMMONIATED SOLUBLE PHOSPHATE. The above phosphate, from which samples for analyses were selected, was purchased from Messrs. Dugdale & Girvin, Baltimore. It is put up in bags marked 200 lbs. ; the one purchased weighed 198 lbs. Its mechanical condition was good. Messrs. Dugdale & Girvin state in their circular that : " We have been at special pains in the manufacture of the ' Ex- cellenza,' to produce a greater amount of soluble material for the price, than any other fertilizer with which we are acquainted." They also give an endorsement and analysis of Professor Chandler, as follows : ** School or Mines, Columbia College. '' New Yokk, September 26, 1870. "I have examined the 'Excellenza' ammoniated superphos- phate of lime, and find it to be an excellent article, containing from 14 to 15 per cent, of soluble phosphoric acid, which is a veri/ unusual percentage. It also contains a very good percentage of ammonia, or ammonia-producing materials. li {s one of the best fertilizers in the market, and is superior to most of the other superphosphates. " C. F. Chandler, Ph. D., '^Prof Analytical and Applied Chemistry ^ CP]RTIFICATE OF ANALYSIS. New York, August 11, 1870. The sample of "Excellenza Ammoniated Soluble Phosphate," submitted to me for examination, contains, Ammonia (N.H. 4-0) 4;16 Soluble Phosphoric Acid 14*45 Equal to Soluble Bone Phosphate 31*50 Insoluble Phosphoric Acid 0*26 Equal to Insoluble Bone Phosphate, . . 0*62 Respectfully, your obedient servant, (Signed), C. F. Chandler, Ph. D., Prof. Analytical and Applied Chemistry, 230 AMERICAN MANURES. We are at a loss to know whether the Pro- fessor, in rendering the soluble phosphoric acid, has reference to the hydrated or the anJiydrous acid. If we regard it as hydrated' phosphoric acid, and compare the Professor's analysis with our analyses, the similarity is quite striking, for 14*45 per cent, of hydrated phosphoric acid correspond to 10*47 of the anliydrous acid, and 10*47 oi anliydrous phosphoric acid, or 14*45 of the hydrated^ are equal to 22*86 of bone j)hosphate of lime rendered soluhle^ not "31*50" (31*54). If the 14*45 per cent, represent anliydrous phos- phoric acid, then 31*54, representing the amount of bone phosphate of lime rendered soluble^ is correct, and the three analyses show conclusively how the " Excellenza " during the few months of its existence has depreciated in value as re- gards its phosphoric acid. Messrs. Dugdale & Girvin are deserving of all credit in manufacturing and introducing this fertilizer ; and there should be no necessity of any subterfuge in recommending it to the public. Truthful, candid statements are all that is needed ; and if Messrs. Dugdale & Girvin will conform to these, and discard the trickeries of the fertilizing business as it now is, we doubt not that their efforts will be crowned with success, and they themselves will be convinced that ^^ honesty " in this business, as well as in all others, " is the best policy." ANALYSES. 231 ANALYSES OF BOWERS COMPLETE MANURE. Percentage, or amount contained in 100. Water (expelled at ] 2120 Fahrenheit)] Nitrogen Nitrogen in or- ] ganic matter . . i Potash, soluble in -j acidulated water j Phosphoric Acid^ (anhydrous), sol- i able in water at ( 60O to 70O F . . . J Insoluble Phos- phoric Acid (an- hydrous) l8t Sample. 2.1 Sample. 7-30 7-22 0-21 0-18 0-60 0-70 0-95 0-90 2-07 1-91 20-42 20-28 7-26 0-20 == 0-24 j 0-65 0-93 1-99 ==3-28 20-35^44-43 Actual Am- monia. Superphos- phate of Lime. Bone Phos- phate of Lime. From the mean of the above analyses, we de- duce the following amounts contained in a ton, or 2000 lbs., together with the value of a ton to the farmer : 145-20 lbs. Water @ $0.00 per lb. $0.00 4-80 " Actual Ammonia @ 0.25 " 1.20 1300 " Nitrogen in organic matter. @ 0.15 " 1.95 18-60 " Potash.. @ 0.08 '' 1.49 39-80 " Soluble Phosphoric Acid . . @ 0.12i " 4.98 407-00 '' Insoluble " " . . @ 0.00 " 0.00 Total value as fertilizer $ 9.62 Value of bags (say) 2.00 Total value to farmer $11.62 The above manure is sold at $52 per ton, in- volving a loss of $10.38, or 348 per cent, to the farmer on every ton he purchases ; or, for manure alone, he pays 5i times as much as it is worth. 232 AMERICAN MANURES. BOWER'S COMPLETE MANURE. The above manure, from which samples for analyses were selected, was purchased from Messrs. Dixon, Sharpless & Co.. Philadelphia. It is put up in bags marked 200 lbs. ; the one pur- chased weighed 190 lbs., being 10 lbs. less than it sliould have weighed, or a deficiency of 100 lbs. to the ton. The mechanical condition of the manure was good. The following quota- tions from the manufacturer's circular will be valuable to the reader, from which he can make his own deductions No. 1. " All will of course agree that farm-yard or stable manure is a good fertilizer, yet unless it is properly rotted or prepared, and kept from the washing rains, its good qualities may be much impaired, and within my own experience but few farmers pay enough attention to the important point of having the manure in such a place as to prevent being leached out by rains. Take the best stable manure, however, and make a com- parison by analysis of its virtues with that of an artificial fertil- izer, as the ' Complete Manure,' it is found, estimating the cost (delivered) of farm-yard manure at $5.00 per' ton, and the * Complete Manure ' at $60.00, (delivered,) that the actual value of the ' Complete Manure ' to the farmer is more than double its cost, when compared with the very best farm-yard manure." No. 2. "It must be borne in mind, that in order to achieve the results obtained by the ' Complete Manure,' a consider- able proportion of the constituents must be in a form to make them be taken up at once by the rootlets of the plant ; that is to say, they must he easily dissolved in the water contained in the soil. It is true, that Nature, among all her other wonders, has provided means to render soluble these constituents, but the process has wisely been made a slow one ; the chemist can ANALYSES. 233 provide the means to make sufficient for the growing crop dissolvable, the balance remaining in the soil to be acted upon by the air and water of the soil to provide food for future crops.' No. 3. " A benefit derived from the use of a powerful man ure, such as the ' Complete Manure,' is that it forces the young plant forward by reason of the large amount of soluble matter it contains. 'J'he importance of this cannot well be overesti mated, as the plant soon reaches that degree of strength and toughness which will prevent an early frost from injuring, or some insect from devouring it ; hence it may be said to be par- ticularly applicable to cotton, tobacco, wheat, corn, potatoes, and other root vegetables, as all the young plants of these are subject to the ravages of the insect, or the blight of the frost.* No. 4. " In manufactured manures, much of their agricultural value depends upon the mechanical condition in which they are supplied, the extent to which the component parts have beer, pulverized and intermixed ; the richest manure, chemically speak ing, will be of little use unless it is moderately dry, reduced to fine powder, and its constituents thoroughly incorporated. This must be borne in mind in judging of the value of a manure, and a proportionate price ought to be allowed for the degree of com- pleteness with which these matters have been attended to. Al- though in theory the production of an artificial fertilizer is a very simple matter, in practice it is found somewhat trouble- some, from the difficulty of producing a manageable article, and a great deal of experience and skill are required to prepare a manure of the requisite chemical strength, and mechanical condition." No. 5. " In speaking with farmers during the past season, many complaints have been met with of the inefficiency of some superphosphates, prepared guanos, poudrettes, and other so- called manures, some of them with high-sounding titles, having failed to produce the results their manufacturers claimed they would give. This has, no doubt, in some instances been the re- sult of a bad season, or bad farming, or some untoward cause which is unaccountable ; but there is good reason to fear that it has been the result of adulteration.^' No. 6. "'J'he adulteration of manures, as indeed of all other articles of commerce, is a practice that cannot be too strongly 234 AMERICAN xAIANURES. condemned ; and it is much to be regretted that the laws of this country afford too many chances for successfully carrying on this species of fraud." No. 7. " In the case of manures their adulteration is attended with several evils besides the more direct one of robbing those who purchase the adulterated article. The fact of manures being known to be extensively adulterated tends to restrict their use, and to withhold the good that a more extended use of these materials is calculated to confer both on the farmer and on the community. For the same reason the trade of honest manufacturers is injured and confined. Under the name of manures all kinds of mixtures are sold, often worth but a fraction of the price paid for them, and in too many instances altogether worthless. The frauds practised by dishonest man- ure dealers consist of diluting or weakening of standard man- ures — by the admixture of less valuable or worthless material, as tanner's bark, road or street scrapings, old mortar, spent wood-ashes, coal ashes, or other material ; and in order to give them apparent value, animal matter with a horrid stench is mixed with these in some instances (many persons are induced to think that a manure, in order to be good, must have a vile smell, than which there can be no greater mistake). Such mix- tures are brought into the market as new compounds under all sorts of high-flown names, which often indicate properties in every way the reverse of those possessed by the so-called man- ures they represent." No. 8. '• By a rudimentary knowledge of Chemistry, manures can be tested with sufficient accuracy to assure their genuine- ness ; various operations upon the farm can be wonderfully im- proved by studying Nature's processes, for in these we see the working of the Divine hand, at once so wonderful, so simple, and so well adapted to the wants of mankind. In Mechanics, we have a help which is daily being increased, by the genius of our people, and the farmer can, by devising various simple changes in machines, no doubt increase their usefulness, or the uses of them." No. 9. " I do not forget that science is in its infancy; there are numerous secrets which Nature refuses to give up, and which, with all the chemical and mechanical aids available, the ANALYSES. 235 most arduous researches have not been able to get from her, except by degrees ; as fresh discoveries come to Hght, I will make every effort to take advantage of them in improving the * Complete Manure,' while farmers can at all times rely upon receiving ' the worth of their money ' when purchasing it." After the above, a brief breathing pause should be allowed to our readers. Such an extensive knowledge of Chemistry, as applied to Agricul- ture, should enable Mr. Bower to produce a " Complete Manure." But if our readers will compare these remarks of Mr. Bower with our analyses of his " Complete Manure," the ap- plication of the Fable of the mountain in labor^ when '^ itascitur ridiculas mus'' (a miserable mouse was brought forth), will be appreciated. TESTIMONIALS. No. 1. " Messrs. Booth & Garrett, of Philadelphia, Chemists of high respectability, say, in speaking of the ' Complete Ma- nure,' in a note to Messrs. Dixon, Sharpless & Co., dealers in fertilizers : " The constitution of the above indicates a decided advance in the composition of a fertilizer, by the introduction of a con- siderable percentage of Potassa, and countenances the claim in- volved in the name ' Complete Manure.' " No. 2. " The report upon the ' Complete ManurS,' made by Messrs. "Williams & Moss, of Philadelphia, Chemists of large experience in the analysis of fertilizers, says : '* We find from an analysis of your ' Complete Manure,' that the name you have given it is certainly warranted by its chemical composition ; in addition to thus cordially recommend- ing your fertilizer from a chemical stand point, we should state that its mechanical condition is most excellent, being such as to admit of its use in the drill without further preparation." 16 236 AMERICAN MANURES. No. 3. "Mining and Assay Office and Chemical Labora- tory, No. 57 Broadway, opposite Exchange Place, New York, October 10th, 1867. " Henry Bower, Esq., Philadelphia. " Dear Sir: — Eaclosed please find results of an analysis of a sample of yonr ' Complete Manure,' taken from Dixon & Sharpless' warehouse, September 25th. " These results show at a glance the great merit your article possesses as a fertilizer, and warrant the opinion that it will take a leading rank among manures. The liberal proportions of soluble phosphoric acid, ammonia and potash, afford to soil a large amount of nutriment immediately available to growing crops, while the remainder of the phosphoric acid, becoming gradually soluble through atmospheric influences, assures a lasting supply of plant food. " The introduction of potash, and the nice adjustment of the proportions of the- above ingredients, render the name you have given your fertilizer particularly appropriate, as it con- tains all the elements necessary to insure success, and I am confident that wherever it is used its reputation will rapidly extend. " Kespectfully yours, " C. Elton Buck." No. 4. " Office State Geological Survey, New Brunswick, N. J., July 15th, 1869. *' Dear Sir : — Your letter of May 20th was duly received. The five bags of your * Complete Manure ' so generously sent to the College Farm were also duly received. For this donation I desire to tender the thanks of the Trustees of the College, and to say that it was immediately used in trials upon corn, beets, and carrots, and on potatoes ; and also it has been subjected to chemical analysis. The results of these will be given in the annual report upon the farm, which is made to the Legislature, and is printed and circulated extensively throughout the Slate. An earlier acknowledgment ought to have been made, but it has been delayed so as to send the chemical analysis, and that, though long expected, has but recently been completed. The crops upon which the ' Manure ' was tried are looking well. The results of the analysis show it to be a valuable fertilizer, and aH ANALYSES. 237 that I have heard of it is in its favor. I hope to send you fur ther reports of it in the course of the season. " Eespectfully yours, *' George H. Cook, " To Henry Bower, Esq. State Geologist." No. 5. "Laboratory of thr Medical College, Queen STREET, Charleston, S. G., December 9th, 1869. ** This article certainly deserves the name it bears, i. e., of a Complete Manure — furnishing to the plant all the important elements of its food. " Cfiarles U. Shepard, M. D. Inspector of Fertilizers for South CarohnaJ* No. 6. 'Savannah, Ga., February 1st, 1870. " I take pleasure in saying that the accompanying analysis of Bower's Complete Manure, made for Messrs. Hacker & Molony, Savannah, Ga., warrants our confidence in its fertilizing proper- ties. Its amount of Ammonia, and its excellent supply of Phosphoric Acid, in a soluble state, will ensure the early growth and development of the plant, together with a fine fruitage, to which the Phosphoric Acid mainly contributes, and these re- sults may be expected for the first year, while the amount of in- soluble Phosphate remaining in the soil will, by slow chemical reaction going on during the suceeding Fall and Winter, pre- pare the land for a better crop during the year. "A Means, Inspector." The farmer after reading the above testimo- nials and comparing them with the analyses of the ^^ Complete Manure " furnished by lis, would naturally be induced to ask the following ques- tions : Where are the analyses of the '^ Complete Manure " furnished by these gentlemen ? Is it excessive modesty, or some other motive, that prevents Mr. Bower from publishing them 2 Was 238 AMERICAN MANURES. the "Complete Manure " made of a hettei' quality^ at the time these testimonials were given, than it is at present ? If it was not, what are we to characterize these chemists, who knowingly allow their names to be used to encourage the perpetra- tion of such a great fraud ? If these chemists gave candid and honest statements at the time, and its present deterioration is due to Mr. Bower, we think it is due to those of them that are honest and capable, and most of whose opinions should have weight with the community, and also to Mr. Bower himself, if he desires to he con- sidered an honest man^ at once to withdraw these testimonials, and modify his circular so as to bring its statements within the bounds of truth ; or, if this be distasteful to him, let him make reparation to his customers, and in the future manufacture a better article than was sold to us ANALYSES. 239 ANALYSES OF THE PATAP8C0 GUANO COM- PANY'S AMMONIATED SOLUBLE PHOSPHATE! Percentage, or amount contained in 100. Water (expelled at ] 2120Fahrenheit). J Nitrogen. Nitrogen in organic | matter. j Potash, soluble in ") acidulated water. J Phosphoric Acid (anhydrous), sol- uble in water at 60O to 70O R Insoluble Phos- phoric Acid (an- hydrous). 1st Sample. 14-97 2ncl Sample. 15-06 0-73 0-82 1-54 1-58 0-62 0-65 8-43 8-21 6-56 6-69 15-02 0-78 =0-95 .^^«*"=''^n'- I monia. 1-56 0-64 8-32 r 6-63 = 14-47 I Superphos- phate of Lime. [ BonePhos- phate of Lime. From the mean of the above analyses, we deduce the following amounts, contamed in a ton, or 2000 lbs., together with the value of a ton to the former : 300-40 lbs. Water @ $ 0.00 per lb. $ 0.00 19-00 " Actual Ammonia @ 0.25 " 4.75 31-20 " Nitrogen in organic matter. @ 0.15 " 4.08 12-80" Potash @ 0.08 '* 1.02 1G6-40 " Soluble Phosphoric Acid... @ 0.12J *' 20.80 132-60" Insoluble " " ...@ 0.00 " 0.00 Total value as fertilizer $31.25 Value of bags (say) ^. 2.00 Total value to farmer $33.25 The above phosphate is sold at $55 per ton, involving a loss of $21.75, or nearly 66 per cent, to the farrher on every ton he purchases ; or, in other words, he pays for it nearly I3 times as much as it is worth. 240 AMERICAN MANURES. PATAPSCO GUANO COMPANY'S AMMO- NIATED SOLUBLE PHOSPHATE! The above fertilizer, from which samples for analyses were selected, was purchased at the company's office, Baltimore. It is put up in bags marked 167 lbs.; the bag purchased weighed 170 lbs. Its mechanical condition was very bad. We found hard lumps in it, as large as a 504b. cannon ball; as the manufacturers recommend this article to be drilled, we are in doubt whether they meant the drill of the farmer, or the drill of the quarryman. From our experience in pul- verizing the article, we incline to think it was the latter. This is a very objectionable feature of this fertilizer, and must necessarily give the farmer considerable trouble. In an attempt to conform with the laws of the State of Maryland, there were some lettering and figures on the bag, which we are charitable enough to concede were intended for an analysis. After considerable trouble, we set down the following, which if not correct, we shall feel under obligation to the com- pany if they will notify us : Soluble Phosphates 24-00 Insoluble Phosphates 18'00 Ammonia 4'00 Salts of Potash 7-00 This, to say the least, is a garbled analysis. It states that this superphosphate contains 24 ANALYSES. 241 per cent, of " Soluble Phosphates/' but as to the amount of phosphoric acid in the " Soluble Phos- phates " we are left entirely in the dark. Again, we are informed that the superphosphate con- tains 7 per cent, of " Salts of Potash/' but as to the amount of potash we remain uninformed. By referring to our analyses, the reader will no- tice less than one per cent, of potash, and by converting this potash into the sulphate or mu- riate, he will obtain less than two per cent., which shows a great discrepancy in the analyses. We quote the following from the circular of these manufacturers : " With their increased facihties, improved machinery, and skilled workmen, under the superintendence of DR. G. A. LIEBIG, who personally selects and tests every article used in its manu- facture, and is constantly present at the works and directs every department, is a sufficient guarantee that its manufac- ture can be relied upon as being equal to anything which can be produced. " The company continues to use the celebrated NAYASSA PHOSPHATE, (the richest phosphatic guano now known) which, together with the other ingredients, and its careful preparation, produce those prompt and permanent effects which have uniformly been shown upon all crops upon which it has been applied." 242 AMERICAN MANURES. ANALYSES OF NEEDLES' TMPROYED SUPERPHOS- PHATE OF LIME. Percentage, or amount contained in 100. 1st Sample. 2a Sample. 5-59 0-19 0-63 Mean. AVater (expelled at ") 2 12° Fahrenheit)] Nitroo'en 5-63 0-17 0-60 5-61 0-18 = 0-62 _ Q.22 1 Actual Ara- 1 monia. Nitrogen in org. ) matter .' J Potash, soluble in ) acidulated water ) trace trace trace Phosphoric Acid' (anhydrous), sol- uble in water at trace trace trace 60O to 70° F . . . J Insoluble Phos- -j r Bone Phos- phoric Acid (an- I 22-43 22-55 22-49=- ^49-10 J phate of hydrous) J l Lime. From the mean of the above analyses, we de- duce the following amounts, contained in a ton, or 2000 lbs., together with the value of a ton to the farmer : 112-20 lbs. Water @ 4-40 " Actual Ammonia @ 12-40 " Nitrogen in org. matter @ Trace Potash 449-80 Trace Soluble Phos. Acid . . @ Insoluble Phos. Acid @ $0.00 per lb. $0.00 0.25 ^' LIO 0.15 " 1.S6 0.08 « 0.00 0.12i *^ 0.00 0.00 '' 0.00 Total value as fertilizer $ 2.96 Value of bags (say) 2.00 Total value to farmer 4.96 The above Phosphate is sold at $47 per ton, involving a loss to the farmer of $42.04, or 847 per cent, on every ton he purchases ; or, taking the manure alone, he pays for it nearly 16 times as much as it is worth. ANALYSES 243 NEEDLES' IMPROVED SUPERPHOS- PHATE OF LIME. The above fertilizer, from which samples for analyses were selected, was purchased at the manufacturer s office, Philadelphia. It is put up in 200 lb. bags; the one purchased weighed 187 lbs., being 13 lbs. less than it should be with the bag included, or 130 lbs. on a ton. The mechani- cal condition of this fertilizer was good, and could be easily applied by a drill. When we have said that, we have said all that is possible for us to say in its favor. Therefore we make the following selections from Mr. Needles' circu- lar, which show conclusively that even tritth, which costs nothing but an honest intention, is too valuable to waste on his worthless product : 1. "It is always of the same pure quality." 2. " It is a permanent enricher of the soil." 3. •' It loses none of its strength by exposure to the air." 4. " It is the cheapest Phosphate in the country." 5. " We were the originators of the preparation of this well known manure in Philadelphia, our house having been engaged for over twenty-one years in the manufacture and sale of Con- CExN'TRATED FERTILIZERS." In commenting on this fertilizer, and the above remarks, only a few words are necessary, as the fertilizer can only be characterized as a scanda- lous cheat and an unmitigated swindle on the community. 244 AMERICAN MANURES. The reader will notice from the analyses that it contains only a trace of Soluble Pliosphoric Acid ; consequently, it has not the least preten- sion to be called a " Superphosphate." It is a fraud in weight as well as in quality, and if Mr. Needles has been manufacturing a similar arti- cle, and giving such deficient weight for the past twenty-one years, common justice, and common law, should have sufficient power to restrain him from continuing his criminal practices, and pun- ish him according to his deservings. And if twenty-one years have been devoted to such practices, the remainder of his life should be de- voted to making a partial atonement for the wrongs perpetrated on his customers. The article is simply ground mineral phos- phate, with a possible scattering of bones, and if there was any Sulphuric Acid used in its prepa- ration, there was not a sufficient quantity to liberate but a trace of Soluble Phosphoric Acid, so that it may only be considered a raw mate- rial for the manufacture of a Superphosphate. Such outrageous frauds as these are calculated to excite the indignation of all the community. The fact that such frauds can be successfully practised for twenty-one years, proves conclu- sively the necessity of just such information as is given in this book ANALYSES. ANALYSES OF TPIE BROMOPHYTE FERTILIZER. Percentage, or amount contained in 100. 1st Sample. 2d Sample. Mean. Water (expelled at ) • 2120 Fahrenheit), J Nitrogen. Nitrogen in organic | matter. j 13-02 0-18 0-75 13-20 0-17 0-83 1311 0'18 = 0-79 . 0-22 1 ^^*"^^-^^- 1 monia. Potash, soluble in | acidulated water, j 0-23 Phosphoric Acid ^ (anhydrous), sol- 1 uble in water at trace trace trace 60O to 70° F. J Insoluble Phos-'\ phoric Acid (an- (- 1-51 .... • • • ■ hydrous). J From the analyses, we deduce the following amounts, contained in a ton, or 2000 lbs., together with the value of a ton to the farmer : 262-20 lbs. Water @ 4'40 " Actual Ammonia @ 15-80 " Nitrogen in organic mat. @ 4-60 " Potash @ Trace Soluble Phos. Acid @ 30-20 '' Insoluble '* " . ® ;0.00perlb. $0.00 0.25 " 1.10 0.15 " 2.37 0.08 " 0.37 0.12J '' 0.00 0.00 '' 0.00 Total value as fertilizer $ 3.84 Value of bags (say) 2.00 Total value to farmer $ 5.84 The above fertilizer is sold at $40 per ton, in- volving a loss of $34.16, or 585 per cent, to the farmer on every ton he purchases ; or, for the manure alone, he pays $36.16, which is more than 9 times as much as it is worth. 246 AMERICAN MANURES. THE BROMOPHYTE FERTILIZER. The above fertilizer, from which samples for analyses were selected, Avas purchased at the company's office, Philadelphia. Its mechanical condition Avas good, which is almost the only good thing it can conscientiously boast of We make the following selections from the circular of this company, with the analyses of the Bro- mophyte by Prof Blaney : ** In the inaDiifacture of Bromophyte, the most scnipulous regard is paid to the laws of chemistry ; and to distinguish this fertilizer from all others — which we neither endorse nor con- demn — we have called it Bromophyte. This term is taken from two Greek words, which signify /oocZ for plants." " The farmer and planter will see at once that his interest is our interest. We cannot hope to succeed unless we make good our promises. Nothing is surer than our failure if we do not give the farmer the worth of his money. We can, therefore, have no motive in deceiving any one." " We otfer this fertilizer at about one-half the cost of guano, while its value, we are led to believe, is equal to if not better than the best Peruvian." "The attention of the Fruit Growers' Association of Wash- ington was lately called to this Bromophyte, and a member of the Association, Professor Thomas Taylor, a well-known chemist, at a meeting held August 3, 1869, read a paper upon the subject, from which we make several extracts :" " Mr. President and Gkntlrmen : — I have here a sample of a valuable fertilizer, which is attracting much attention at this time. It is known by the name of Bromophyte, which signi- fies j^Zant /ood. Its base is human excreta, including urine, and is submitted to a process of deodorization by which it is deprived of its smell. "The efficacy of peat, which is used, is due to the soluble salts which it contains, and to its property of absorbing am- monia from the atmosphere — having an absorbing power of seventy-two times its own bulk. ANALYSES. 247 " Marl, one of the constituents of Broraophyte, is valuable for various reasons — it is a composition of clay and shells, the clay being the more important substan.ce of the two. Its very valuable properties were first pointed out by Professor Way, Chemist of the English Royal Agricultural Society. He says that clay will decompose the salts of ammonia, potash and soda, and retain their bases." "At the close of Mr. Taylor's remarks, Mr. William Saun- ders, of the Agricultural Department, proposed a vote of thanks to Mr. Taylor for his valuable remarks, which was unanimously carried. *' The following statement has been received from Professor Blaney, of Chicago, relative to the merits of Bromophyte : '' Chicago, Odoler 26, 1870. "This is to certify that I have examined the specimens of Bromophyte submitted to me, and have found the same to be composed as follows : Volatile matter, organic matter, water and a trace of free ammonia 59*05 Inorganic matter 40*95 The Bromophyte contains of salts 40*95 per cent., namely : Sulphate of Lime 17*6765 Phosphate of Lime 1*4922 Phosphate of Magnesia 1*1335 Carbonate of Magnesia 2*2613 Chloride of sodium 2*0540 Sesquioxide of Iron and Alumina 5*0790 Insoluble Silicates 11*2690 Chloride of Potassium, a tra'^e. Total 40*9655 Gain -0155 40*9500 " The Bromophyte was found by organic analysis to contain nitrogen, 3*92 per cent., equivalent to ammonia, 4*76 per cent. " James V. T. BiiANRY, ^^ Analytical and Consulting Chemist." " P. S. — It will be seen, by comparing with analysis of guano, that Bromophyte is two per cent, the stronger." 248 AMERICAN MANURES. After making an analysis of this " Bromo- PHYTE," and knowing its composition and value, we doubt whetlier the writer of the circular, or even Professors Taylor and Blaney were in earnest in their encomiums of this article. We rather think these gentlemen have endeavored to perpetrate a practical joke on the farmers. That any chemist (and Prof Taylor is represented to be one), should seriously recommend the use of peat and marl, clay and shells in a high-priced fertilizer that sells for two cents per lb., is almost incredible ; or that Prof. Blaney should seriously say that it is two per cent, stronger than guano, is certainly beyond belief. The farmers who have used the article seem to have been in the same vein of humor, so pal- pably exhibited by the facetious Professors Tay- lor and Blaney, as the following specimens of their certificates will show : GREAT ON TURNIP TOPS. ''AVashington, D. C, April 1, 1869. *' Randall Fish, Esq. ^^Sir: — In reply to your note, inquiring about your fertilizer, I am happy to say that it will work wonders. " I tried it last season on some turnips as late as the 1st of October, and I never saw such a crop of tops in my life. Of course, it was too late to fetch a full crop, yet some were as large as hens' eggs. " I do not hesitate to say that I think it superior to any ferti- lizer in the market, as it will benefit the ground while it stimu- lates the present crop. I have used it with the greatest suc- cess, and have found it to be better than any other, having ANALYSES. 249 used it side by side with the Patapsco and other fertilizers, and it far exceeds them. It has proven satisfactory to Dr. Nichols, the Superintendent of the Insane Asylum, as lie has this spring purchased five tons of it. " Samuel A. Smith, ** Gardener at the Insane Asylum" We should expect just such a certificate from an Insane Asylum. GREAT ON CUCUMBERS. " Washington, D. C, August 18, 1870. " Randall Fish, Esq. " Dear Sir : — I have used your fertiHzer, called Bromophyte, on three acres of cucumbers, on my farm at Mt. Yernon, and can say that I beheve it to be a first-rate article. A few rows I left without any fertilizer, on some I put Peruvian Guano, and on some Patapsco Guano. Those without any fertilizers are very poor, but where your fertilizer v^as used they are very fine, and much better than the vines that were fertilized with the Peruvian or Patapsco Guano. " Dr. E. P. Howland, " iVb. 27 Four-and-a-Half Street.'' DODGE ON BROMOPHYTE. "Washington, D. C. "I have seen the effects and examined the character of the fertilizer manufactured by Randall Fish, and am satisfied it is among the best now offered to the public. I have used it on my strawberries and other plants, and find the effect upon their growth superior to that of any other fertilizer I have ever used. I shall want more. " It effects wonders on every kind of vegetable to which I have applied it, making vegetation grow on barren soil. " Yery respectfully, "A. T. C. Dodge." ThiSj we think, is a very good specimen of " dodge." As it makes vegetation grow on bar- ren soil^ Bromophyte must contain the essence of strawberries. Who will eat strawberries after this? 250 AMERICAN MANURES. GASS ON BROMOPHYTE. " Gelen, Washington Co., August 26, 1869. " Mr. Randall Fish : *' I have used your Bromophy te on tomatoes, squashes, cucum- bers and on corn, and must say that it exceeds my expecta- tions. I believe that it is better than any fertilizer now in use. I have tried most all kinds in the market, and this is the best I have ever found. I have examined the corn to-day, and find, where your fertilizer was used, it was a deep green, and where other fertilizers were used beside it, the great drought had turned the leaves yellow, and the stocks were much smaller. " Yery respectfully, " John Gass." We fear the corn was not so green as the buyer of the Bromophyte. Taken altogether it is a very gassy certificate. A 20,000 POUNDER CERTIFICATE. {The biggest gun knoion.) " Alexandria, Ya., March 15, 1870. ** Randall Fish, Esq. " Dear Sir : — Please send me ten tons of your Bromophyte, the most economical manure, which insures the quickest and best returns of any I have ever used. Rely on me as a custo- mer while I have any land to cultivate. " Yours, very respectfully, *' J. Millard.'* If the Bromophyte Mr. Millard purchased was no better than that sold to us^ and he con- tinues to go it so strong on Bromophyte, he will soon have no land to cultivate — it will be in the hands of the sheriff. A CERTIFICATE FROM THE " LAND OF DREAMS." ''Norfolk, Ya., May 13, 18Y0. '' C. C. Brown, Esq. '' Dear Sir : — I have been e.xpprimenting last fall and this spring with your Bromophyte. It beats any fertilizer I know iiNALYSES. 251 of. For early truck of all kinds it is all that can be desired. It is destined to take the place of nearly all the so-called fertili- zers, now so numerous. For radishes, it beats all I ever dreamed of. I do not dare to tell how short a time it took to produce for me the finest radishes I ever saw. '' Yours, etc., *' George S. Oldfield, ^^ Formerly Judge of County Court." Query, — Does the Judge often dream of radishes — it must be an interesting subject for a Judge. We shall next expect to hear of the Judge dreaming of '^ turnip tops." FISHING FOR DODGE. *' Washington, D. C., June 29, 1870. " Randall Fish, Esq. " Dear Sir : — In reply to your favor of to-day, I would say that I have used the Bromophyte — Fish's — in my garden in this city for two years, and do not desire anything better for straw- berries. In fact, it seems to impart a remarkably strong and healthy growth to any and every vegetable to which I have applied it, and I believe it is superior to any fertilizer in the market, not excepting the Peruvian. " Respectfully, yours, etc., " A. T. C. Dodge." Another specimen of '' dodge ;" being better than Peruvian GuanOj, we think it slightly '' fishy." The reader will notice that these certificates are given by farmers in the vicinity of Wash- ington. The Bromophyte to which they have reference being prepared there. We do not say that excreta at Washington are richer than at Philadelphia ; but it is possible that the Wash- 17 252 AMERICAN MANURES. ington manufacturers may be more honesty and make a better article than their Philadelphia brethren — it is almost impossible that they could make a worse. The use of these certifi- cates by the Philadelphia Company is literally stealing the thunder of the excreta of Wash- ington. METHODS OF ANALYSIS. The methods of analysis employed to deter- mine the amount of nitrogen, actual ammonia, and potash, and of phosphoric acid in the several manures, of which analyses are given in this chapter, are of too intricate a nature to be un- derstood by the general reader. Hence we state the methods only in general terms, with such remarks and particulars as will enable profes- sional chemists, into whose hands our work may fall, to estimate the carefulness with which they have been made. METHOD FOR TOTAL NITROGEN. From about 30 grammes of the finely pul- verized and intimately mixed substance 1 to 2 grammes were taken for analysis, which was made according to Varrentrapp and Wills' me- thod. We remark, that the actual amount of Nitrogen was calculated from the actual amount of metallic platinum obtained, and not from the METHODS OF ANALYSIS. 253 weight of the precipitate, as is sometimes done : the former being considered the most reliable. METHOD FOR ACTUAL AMMONIA AND POTASH. Substance = 50 grammes. Fluid = 250 c.c. Fluid taken = 25 c.c. = 5 grammes substance. The substance in an evaporating dish was treated : first, with small quantities of water at 60° to 70°; then boiled successively in water acidulated with hydrochloric acid'; and finally, washed on a filter with boiling water, till the filtrate measured nearly 250 c.c. The ammonia was determined according to SOHLOESING'S PROCESS. strength of Soda Solution, 3.06 c.c. = 1 c.c. Normal Sulphuric Acid. The potash was determined as potassio-bichlo- ride of platinum. METHOD FOR TOTAL PHOSPHORIC ACID. Substance = 20 grammes. Fluid = 1000 c.c. Fluid taken = 50 c.c. = 1 gramme substance. The hydrochloric acid solution, with the addi- tion of several drops of concentrated nitric acid, was evaporated completely to dryness^ and the residue treated with dilute hydrochloric acid. To the solution thus obtained, there was added; first, citric acid, in quantity sufficient; then ammonia ; then, acetic acid, each slightly in ex- cess ; and finally, to the nearly boiling solution, 254 AMERICAN MANURES. oxalate of ammonia was added. The precipitate obtained was collected at once on a double filter, and to the cool and strongly ammoniacal filtrate, were added, 6 to 10 c.c. of an ammoniacal ammo- nio-sulphate of magnesia solution — each c.c. of which corresponds to 0.0358 gramme anhydrous phosphoric acid. The filtrate and wash water measured 250 to 300 c.c, and for every 54c.c. of the same, 0.000637 gramme phosphoric acid was allowed. METHOD FOR SOLUBLE PHOSPHORIC ACID. Substance = 20 grammes. Fluid = 1000 c. c. Fluid taken = 100 c. c.= 2 grammes substance. The substance was triturated in a mortar with distilled water, at 60° or 70°,^ the powder allowed to settle, and the fluid decanted. This operation was repeated till S litre of fluid was obtained, when the powder was collected on a filter and washed with distilled water till the filtrate mea- sured one litre. The phosphoric acid, as in the previous instance, was determined gravimetri- cally. Note. — In one or two instances, instead of 1 to 2 grammes, 10 grammes of the substance were taken for the phosphoric acid determination. CONCLUDING REMAEKS. Manufacturers of fertilizers attach great im- portance to the certificates of farmers, and it is considered a strong point as an evidence of the CONCLUDING REMARKS. 255 superior quality of their products; hence they procure as many of them as possible. Two ad- vantages are thus gained : First. It effectually closes the farmer's mouth for subsequent unfavor- able criticism. Second. Every farmer's opinion has weight in the circle in which he moves^ and his favorable report of a fertilizer induces others to give it a triah Thus the business of these manufacturers is increased, and the farmer un- wittingly becomes a party to their frauds, and when his neighbors find that they are cheated, he receives his share of blame. Hence farmers should be very careful in giving these loosely worded recommendations, which benefit no one but the manufacturers. Those who have given these certificates know how they have been pro- cured ; personal friendship for the manufacturer or dealer^ has led many to give favorable re- ports, we doubt not against their better judg- ment, while with others, perhaps, the desire of seeing their name in print has its influence. Certificates are a part of the stock in trade of qiiaclceryj and no honestly conducted business needs them. Besides the certificates given to different manufacturers when taken collectively do not amount to anything, because each man- ure sold is represented by the certificates to be the best. Such conflicting statements are with- out value as evidence ; consequently, the farmer 256 AMERICAN MANURES. is as much puzzled in the selection of a good manure, as he would be without seeing the certificates. If this business had been legitimately con- ducted, and the price regulated by the quality and condition of the valuable constituents of the fertilizer, manufacturers would have no occasion to resort to customers' certificates. There is another class of certificates that, un- fortunately, do not meet the public eye, namely : The complaints of those who have realized that they have been swindled in the purchase of these manures. These certificates would present an interesting sequel to the others, and in number as well as in force^ would completely overshadow them. If time and space j)ermitted, we could give a long list of these negative certificates that would be anything but interesting reading for the manufacturers. An illustration of the un- reliability of certificates is seen in the samples we have given from the users of the Bromophyte, a manure that is almost worthless. Some of its users certify that it is better than Peruvian Guano, or the Patapsco Ammoniated Phosphate, the latter, according to our analyses, being one of the best superphosphates now made in this country. Many certificates are given before the crop is harvested ; such premature statements must be verj^ unreliable. Farmers should realize CONCLUDING REMARKS, 257 the importance of knowing the source of the benefits realized before giving certificates. It may be due to a favorable season, to substances already in the soil, or to the manure, or to all three combined. If the farmer sees a favorable ap- pearance in his crop, he is too apt at once to attribute it exclusively to the bought fertilizer, forgetting what he must have frequently seen, when using stable manure alone, that one year a good crop may be raised, and the next time, though equally well cultivated and manured, a poor one. It has been shown that the amounts required of the valuable constituents of crops are very small. Hence, if the so-called concentrated fertilizers contain but a little of what is really needed, its effect on the crop would he apparent. But our farmers should bear in mind that they pay exorbitant prices for the benefits received. If they apply 400 lbs. of a fertilizer costing $50 per ton, it would be $10 to the acre, and they should have clear views of the amount of any crop that should be expected from such an out- lay. As an illustration, 25 bushels of wheat with the straw requires : 27-95 lbs. of Phosphoric Acid @ $0.12 J per lb $3.49 39-65" "Potash @ 0.08 " .... 3.17 46-60" "Nitrogen @ 0.15 " .... 6.99 '%i^\ $13.65 Hence, if an outlay of $13.65 on an acre should 258 AMERICAN MANURES. produce 25 bushels of wheat with the straw, an outlay of $10 to an acre should produce over 18 bushels of wheat with the straw, in addition to what could be produced without the application of fertilizers, or if we allow half of the nitrogen to be represented by actual ammonia at 25 cents per lb., an outlay of $10 to the acre should pro- duce 14 J bushels. This calculation can be readily applied to other crops from the same data, and from it the farmer can see how small the amount of benefit, in increased crops, he has derived from the use of these fraudulent manures in proportion to the money invested. We are quite sure if the farmer had correct views on the subject, he would no more think of giving certificates to these manufacturers, than he would of giving a certificate of good character to the burglar who had broken into his house and stolen his money, but spared his life, or to the thief who had stolen his horse and failed to set fire to his barn. The reader should now be fully convinced from the facts stated and analyses given, of the absolute necessity of National and State legisla- tion to protect the farmers and the public from the rapacity of manufacturers of fertilizers. There are Grain, Flour, Liquor, Tobacco, Lea- ther, Oil, Drug and other Inspectors, appointed to protect purchasers and honest manufacturers CONCLUDING REMARKS. 259 and dealers. Fertilizers are equal in importance to any of those commercial articles mentioned, while there are greater facilities for fraud. In England and other European countries, the prices of these fertilizers are fixed by the amount and value of the fertilizing elements contained in them, according to the manner in- dicated in this book ; and in this matter, we are far behind those countries we are accustomed to style slow. In those countries, concentrated fer- tilizers are inspected by government officials. As the result of the rigid inspection laws of Ger- many, purchasers are protected. We quote from the circular of George Charles Zimmer, at Man- heim, one of the largest manufacturers of fer- tilizers in Germany, and give three analyses of the superphosphates manufactured by him, to show the operation of the law : These fertilizers are always sold and delivered of an ap- proved, uniform, superior quality, and their ingredients war- ranted ; samples of the same are deposited with the Central Agricultural Department of the Grand Duchy of Baden, at Carlsruhe, under whose control the products of the factory are placed by law. The monthly official analyses of supplies on hand in the manufactory, are published from time to time in the Weekly Journal of the Agricultural Society of the Grand Duchy of Baden, and every purchaser of at least half a ton at one time of one of these superphosphates, has the privilege to transmit (free of charge) with enclosure of the original invoice, a sample of the same to Doctor J. Nessler, the President of the Experimental Station, at Carlsruhe, in order to be analyzed, )ree of expense, to the purchaser. Furthermore, these fertilizers are subject to the control of the Agricultural Societies of Hes- 260 AMERICAN MANURES. sen on the Rhine, Rhenish Prussia, etc., and the results of their investigations are communicated to the public from time to time, in their respective agricultural papers. No. 1 — Analysis of Coprolite Scperphosphate. Percentage. Equal to Soluble Phos-| ta +^ n i^ +^ to (Superphosphate phoric Acid, I ^^ ^^ ^^ - ^^ *^ 1^ I of Lime. Insoluble Phos- 1 o +^ ^ c +^ o f Bone Phosphate phoric Acid, I ^ to 4 - b to 8 I ^^ ^-^^^^^ No. 2 — Analysis of Bone Meal Superphosphate. Percentage. Equal to Soluble Phos- 1 -, o +^ i^ oo +^ o/i (Superphosphate phoric Acid, I ^^ ^^ ^^ — ^^ ^^ ^^ I of Lime. Insoluble Phos- "I o +^ ^ ^ +^ o ( Bone Phosphate phoric Acid, I 3 to 4 ^ 6 to 8 I ^f Lime.^- Nitrogen 0*5 to 1 No. 3. — Analysis of Baker Guano Superphosphate. Percentage. Equal to phoric IS; } 18 to 20 = 30 to 32 { «TLt?'^'' Insoluble Phos- "I o a o a 4. a ( Bone Phosphate phoric Acid, I 2 to 3 = 4 to 6 I ^^ Lime. On comparing the above analyses of super- phosphates made in Germany, with those made by our boastful manufacturers, the reader will notice that their lowest grade superphosphates contain more soluble phosphoric acid than our best^ and that the insoluble phosphoric acid (3 to 4 per cent.) contained in those made at Man- heim, is about equal to the average amount of soluble phosphoric acid, in American commercial manures. THE END. RETURN CIRCULATION DEPARTMENT TO^^^ 202 Main Library LOAN PERIOD 1 HOME USE 2 3 4 5 ( b ALL BOOKS MAY BE RECALLED AFTER 7 DAYS RE^i^//AL^ .•.^•; ":::: • ■• : -.mor to DUE DATl LOAN P£»iiODS At