9Q4yn 
 
 5 779 
 
 UC-NRLF 
 
 III III |iliiliilili|ililll|llii|ii|ii Mill illll III III 
 B 2 VSfl :35c' 
 
 •X) 
 CO 
 
 o 
 
 i'Q 
 
GIFT OF 
 
 ^^ ^r- 
 
 « 
 
 J 
 
 1:1: 
 
OWr ifs of fh^i Author 
 
 /"N 7 mi ,;:■ 
 
 [Reprinted from The American Mataematical Monthly, Vol. XXXV,' Apri!,M9l? |'\ J *? ' 
 
 NOTE ON SOME APPLICATIONS OF A GEOMETRICAL TRANS- 
 FORMATION TO CERTAIN SYSTEMS OF SPHERES.^ 
 
 By dr. henry W. STAGER, Fresno, California. 
 
 Ill a paper in Volume VI of the Proceedings of the Edinburgh Mathematical 
 Society, Professor Allardice considers the transformation in piano: 
 
 Let I be a fixed straight line, C any plane curve, t a tangent to C meeting / 
 in X and making an angle 6 with /; then C, the transformed curve of C, is the 
 envelope of a straight line t' through X making an angle with I, where 6 and 
 are connected by the relation 
 
 tan |0 = k tan ^6. 
 
 The length of the tangent from any point in I to C remains unaltered by the trans- 
 formation. A similar method is applicable in space and the following paper 
 gives some of the results in its applications to certain systems of spheres. The 
 method of transformation is as follows: 
 
 Let a be a fixed plane, S any surface, and ^ a plane tangent to S intersecting 
 a in the line i and making with a an angle 6. If (3' be a plane through i making 
 with a an angle 0, determined by the relation 
 
 (1) tan ^(f) = k tan hd, 
 
 then the envelope of j8' will be defined as the transformed surface of S, or, more 
 simply, the "transform of S." ^.. 
 
 From the given relation, tan ^0 — k tan |0, and the identity, 
 
 _ 2 tan (/)/2 
 
 we find that 
 
 2k tan d 
 
 (2) tan (j) 
 
 ± (1 - F) Vl + tan2 d + 1 + F ' 
 
 It is evident from the nature of this relation that for every value of k there are 
 two values of tan 0, according as we consider the angle afi as d or (6 -{- ir). 
 
 For simplicity, we will use Cartesian coordinates to find the equation of the 
 I transform of a given sphere from its equation, and we will take the .r^-plane as 
 the plane of transformation, a. Let 6 be the angle formed by the .r?/-plane and 
 the plane ux + vy + ivz — 1 = 0, and be the angle formed by the a-z/-plane 
 and the plane ux + vy + 2^12 — 1 = 0. (Since the intercepts of both planes on 
 the .T-axis and on the y-ax\s are equal, respectively l/u and l/v, they intersect 
 the .T2/-plane in the same line, as required by the transformation.) 
 
 ' Presented to the San Francisco Section of the American Mathematical Society, April 
 12, 1913. 
 
' 1*55 •' APPUCATIONS OF A GEOMETRICAL TRANSFORMATION. 
 
 From the formula for the angle between two planes, 
 
 _ (J?(7^ - B'Cf + { CA' - CAY + {AB' - A'Bf 
 tan- - ^^j, _^ ^^, _^ ^^,^2 
 
 we have 
 
 *?/ ■ I ■ ill" 97 I I -i*** 
 
 tan- = ^ — and tan^ (b = , — . 
 
 Substituting these values in equation (2) and solving for w, we obtain 
 
 (1 + /r)wi ± (1 - F) a/m2 _^ ^^+^2 
 (3) ^. = 2^ , 
 
 or, 
 
 ,^^ , 2(1 + A;4)Wi2 + (1 - F)2(W2 + ^2) _i. 2^,(1 _ Jt4) Vw2 + ^2 _|. ^^2 
 (4) ^2 = _^^ , 
 
 Now, let the center of the sphere lie in the 2-axis and its equation will be 
 
 (5) x^+y''+z'' + 2nz+ d= 0. 
 
 Expressing the condition that the plane ux -\- vy -\- wz — 1 = he tangent 
 to this sphere, we have 
 
 (6) (d - 71^1^ + (d - n^y + dw'^ + 2nw +1 = 0, 
 
 which is the tangential equation of the sphere. 
 
 Substituting the values of w and w- found in (3) and (4) and then simplifying 
 and factoring the result, we have the equation of the transform of the given sphere 
 
 [{(F + lyd - 2n^{¥ + 1) + 2n{h^ - 1) -in^ - d]{iv' + v") + Ulc^w^- 
 
 + 4F + 4/j{n(P + 1) + (F- - 1) 4n^ - d]wA X [{(/r + l)-(i 
 
 (7) , 
 
 - 2n\k' + 1) - 2/t(/.-' - 1) V/i2 - d^iv" + r) + Ukhci'^ + 4^^ 
 
 + 4/j{n(F + 1) _ (/,2 _ 1) V^i^ _ d]ic?[ = 0. 
 
 This equation breaks up into two equations which are the tangential equations 
 of two spheres, and may be written in the form 
 
 (8) yli(w2 ^ ^2) ^ Q^^,2 _^ 2NiWi + D = 0; 
 
 (9) ^2(^2 + v"") + Cwi" + 2A^2Wi + D= 0. 
 The Cartesian equations of these forms are 
 
 (10) {CD - Ni')x^ + (CD - iVi2)7/2 + AiDz"" + .4iC + 2yli.Yi2 = 0; 
 
 (11) {CD - N2V + {CD - N.})y'' + AnDz- + J-.C + 2/I2.V02 = 0, 
 where, from the actual values of the coefficients involved. 
 
TO CERTAIN SYSTEMS OF SPHERES. 156 
 
 (CD - Ni") = AiD, and {CD - Ni") = A^D. 
 Simplifying and substituting, we have finally 
 
 (12) 4F(.t2 + 2/2 + S-) + ik{n(F" + 1) + (/v- - 1) Vw^ - d}z + 4<fF = 0; 
 
 (13) 4F(a:2 + r + S") + ^k{n{k'' + 1) - (F - 1) ^^-^}z + 4dA;2 = Q: 
 
 the equations of two spheres whose centers lie in the z-axis. Hence, in general, 
 a sphere is transformed into two spheres whose centers lie in a line perpendicular 
 to the plane of transformation and passing through the center of the given sphere. 
 Now, let p represent the radius of the given sphere and 5 the distance of its 
 center from the plane of transformation; also, let r' and r" and d' and d" repre- 
 sent respectively the radii and distances from the plane of transformation of the 
 centers of the transformed spheres. The equations of the latter may then be 
 written 
 
 (14) x' + 2/2 _^ .2 _^ [_ 5(^. + 1//,) ^ (/, _ i|^.)^], + d=0; 
 
 (15) x^ + r + 2' + [- 8{k + l/k) - {k - \lk)p\z + (i = 0: 
 whence the resulting relations: 
 
 (^' 4- / = (5 - p)k; d" + t" = (5 + p)k; 
 
 (16) 
 
 d' - r' = (5 + p)lk; d" - r" = (5 - p)lk. 
 
 We will next consider for what values of k the transformed spheres will 
 degenerate into points. It is evident that we must consider each case separately. 
 In the first case we have 
 
 r' = 
 
 -^{(5+p) -kH8- p)}\=0, 
 
 whence 
 
 (17) 'F- = (5 + p)/(5 - p). 
 
 Here we have two real values for k, provided the given sphere does not cut the 
 plane of transformation; and a zero or infinite value for k if the given sphere is 
 tangent to that plane. The corresponding values of the distance are 
 
 d' = T V52 - p 
 
 2 
 
 or in terms of the original coefficients, 
 
 (18) d' = q= V^. 
 
 In the second case, by similar methods, we find that 
 
 (19) P = (5 - p)/(5 + p), 
 and 
 
 (20) d" = =F V52 - p\ or, d" = T V^. 
 
157 APPLICATIONS OF A GEOMETRICAL TRANSFORMATION, 
 
 It follows that, in general, a sphere may be transformed into a point for any 
 one of four values of k, the points being the same in pairs, and all four being equi- 
 distant from the plane of transformation,, ope pair on each side. It is to be 
 especially noted that while each of the two transformed spheres may degenerate 
 into points, both spheres cannot become points at the same time, unless either 
 p = 0, or 5 = 0; i. e., when the given sphere is itself a point and this point may 
 be transformed into its image with respect to the plane of transformation, or 
 when the center of the given sphere lies in the plane of transformation and the 
 points are imaginary. We may also note that a point can be transformed into 
 only one sphere. 
 
 We have already seen, equations (12) and (13), that for the same value of h 
 a given sphere may be transformed into two distinct spheres. These two spheres 
 evidently result from the two values of 0, according as we consider the angle 
 a/3 as d or {B-\- -k). In case the angle is B we will say that the transformed 
 sphere is traced out by a direct movement, and where the angle is {Q + tt) we 
 will say that it is traced out by an indirect, or inverse, movement. It is evident 
 that if we transform two spheres, hoth directly, or both inversely, the direct 
 common tangent planes to the two spheres become common tangent planes to 
 the transformed spheres, while if one sphere is transformed directly and the 
 other inversely, the transverse common tangent planes become common tangent 
 planes to the transformed spheres. 
 
 Forming the equation of the radical plane of the given sphere and either of 
 its transforms, we have 
 
 z = 0, 
 
 which is also the plane of transformation. It follows that the plane of transforma- 
 tion is the radical plane of the given sphere and its transforms, and that the 
 length of a tangent line from any point in the plane of transformation to the 
 sphere is unaltered by the transformation. Hence the distance between the 
 points of contact of common tangent planes to two spheres remains unaltered. 
 This is the important property of the transformation. By transforming several 
 spheres into points at the same time, relations and properties of spheres may be 
 obtained directly from known relations between points. 
 
 For two or more spheres to be transformed simultaneously into points, it is 
 evidently sufficient that the values of Ic- be equal. Considering the case of two 
 spheres with radii p' and p" and with the distances of their centers from the 
 plane of transformation, 5' and 5", respectiveh', we have 
 
 p = (5' - p')/(5' + p') and P = (d" - p")l{h" + p"); 
 whence 
 
 (5' - p')/(5' + p') = (5" - p")l{b" + p"), or 575" = p'lp". 
 
 This is the condition that the plane of transformation pass through the direct 
 center of similitude of the two spheres. Using the reciprocal values for k"^ we 
 obtain the same result. Finally, let 
 
TO CERTAIN SYSTEMS OP SPHERES. 158 
 
 F = (5' - p')/(5' + p') and P = (5" + p")/(5" - p")\ 
 whence 
 
 575" = - p'Ip": 
 
 the condition that the plane of transformation pass througli the inverse center 
 of simihtude of the two spheres. We conclude that two spheres may be trans- 
 formed simultaneously into points if the plane of transformation contain a 
 center of similitude of the two spheres. Likewise, if the plane of transformation 
 contain any one of the four axes of similitude of three spheres, these spheres will 
 all be transformed into points by the same transformation. Further, if the plane 
 of transformation be any one of the eight planes of similitude of four spheres/ 
 the four spheres may be transformed into points simultaneously; and, finally, 
 any number of spheres which have a common plane of similitude may be so 
 transformed. Two spheres on the same side of the plane of transformation will 
 be transformed, either both directly, or both inversely; while of two on opposite 
 sides, one will be transformed directly, the other inversely. 
 
 By giving k every possible value a given sphere may be transformed into an 
 infinite series of spheres which, by virtue of the properties of the plane of trans- 
 formation as the radical plane of a sphere and its transforms, is cut orthogonally 
 by a system of spheres. Then, since the given sphere is one of the series, if we 
 transform the whole system for the same value of h, it will transform into itself. 
 
 It may be noted at this point that the results here obtained by analytic 
 methods may readily be obtained by synthetic methods, and in the sequel they 
 will be interpreted in accordance with the particular problem under consideration. 
 In all problems which follow it w^ill be necessary to associate only those common 
 tangent planes and distances between points of contact of common tangent 
 planes to two spheres which determine the centers of similitude in the planes 
 of similitude used as planes of transformation. Thus we will associate with the 
 plane of similitude passing through the six direct centers of similitude of four 
 spheres the external common tangent planes of each pair of spheres, and only 
 the external common tangent planes of these spheres. 
 
 Some Applications of the jNIethod. 
 
 1. The condition that four planes passing through a point should be tangent 
 to the same sphere is given by the equation 
 
 tan \ (j)' tan ^ </>" = tan ^ d' tan ^ 6", 
 
 where 0', cf)", 6', 6" are the angles formed by the given planes and the plane 
 determined by the lines of intersection of the two pairs of opposite planes. 
 
 1 The twelve centers of similitude of four spheres lie in sets of six in a plane: the six direct 
 centers lie in a plane; the three direct centers of any three spheres lie in a plane with the three 
 inverse centers not paired with them; and any two direct centers, using each sphere only once, 
 lie in a plane with the four inverse centers not paired with them. Thus there are eight planes 
 of similitude, one containing all the direct centers; four containing three direct and three inverse 
 centers; and three containing two direct and four inverse centers. 
 
159 
 
 APPLICATIONS OF A GEOMETRICAL TRANSFORMATION. 
 
 Transform the sphere into a point with the external diagonal plane as the 
 plane of transformation, and let the angles of the transformed planes with this 
 plane of transformation be and 6, corresponding respectively to the angles 
 4)' , (f)" and 6', 6". We then have the following relations: 
 
 tan I = A- tan \ <^'; tan \ d = k tan h 6'; 
 
 tan I (0 + tt) = /.• tan | (j>"; tan ^ (d + t) = k tan | d". 
 
 Eliminating cj), 6, h frdin these equations, we have the given condition. 
 
 2. If five spheres have a common plane of similitude they may be transformed 
 into five points by the same transformation. Therefore the distances between 
 the points of contact of the common tangent planes of each pair of spheres satisfy 
 the relation connecting the ten straight lines joining five points in space. 
 
 Let di, do, dz, • • ■ f/io be the distances. Then the relation is given by the 
 determinant^ 
 
 
 
 rfr 
 
 d-z' 
 
 ^3^ 
 
 d:~ 
 
 
 di' 
 
 
 
 d/ 
 
 d,' 
 
 d^' 
 
 
 d,' 
 
 d,' 
 
 
 
 de 
 
 d<f 
 
 
 dz' 
 
 d,' 
 
 ds' 
 
 
 
 d,o' 
 
 
 d^ 
 
 d,' 
 
 d,' 
 
 d,^ 
 
 
 
 
 1 
 
 1 
 
 1 
 
 1 
 
 1 
 
 
 
 0. 
 
 3. If, in addition to the conditions of No. 2, the five spheres also touch a 
 sixth sphere, the ten distances will satisfy the additional relation connecting five 
 points lying on the surface of a sphere. 
 
 Transforming the five spheres into points as above, they must lie on the 
 surface of the transform of the sixth sphere and will therefore satisfy the addi- 
 tional relation given by the determinant^ 
 
 
 
 d^ 
 
 d-f 
 
 d^ 
 
 d^ 
 
 d,' 
 
 
 
 d^ 
 
 d,' 
 
 d,' 
 
 di" 
 
 d,' 
 
 
 
 di 
 
 d,-^ 
 
 d,' 
 
 d,' 
 
 ^8^ 
 
 
 
 did 
 
 d,' 
 
 d,' 
 
 d,' 
 
 c/io^ 
 
 
 
 = 0. 
 
 4. The radius 11 of a given sphere S tangent to four given spheres may be 
 found in terms of R, the distance 5 of the center of iS from the plane containing 
 the six direct centers of similitude of the four spheres, the distances between 
 the j)oints of contact of common tangent planes to pairs of spheres, and the 
 
 ' Cayluy, "CuUcclcd Mathematical Papers," Volume I, p. 1 et seq. 
 
::• 
 
 :\' 
 
 TO CERTAIN SYSTEMS OF SPHERES. 160 
 
 radius and distance from its center to the plane of similitude of any one of the 
 given spheres. 
 
 If we transform the four spheres into points by the same transformation, 
 these four points will lie on the transform of S. Hence 
 
 ^ _ 1 / (2aa')[n(- aa' + bh ' + cc')] 
 
 ^' ~ 2 \l.Wa'\W + c2 - a2 + h''' + c'^ - a'^)] - {cC-W - i:a'b"c") ' 
 
 where a, a', etc., are the distances between the points of contact of the common 
 tangent planes of two pairs of spheres with no sphere in common, and where 2 
 and TT represent cyclo-symmetrical functions only. But 
 
 R' = 
 where 
 
 ^ {5(P-1)T(F+1)/^} 
 
 21c 
 F = (^^ _ ri)l(di + n), or P = (di + ri)l(di - n), 
 
 from equations (17), and (19). 
 Hence 
 
 R=\- 5(ri/(^i) ± 2{(^dx'-r,')fd}W\. 
 
 5. The locus of the center of a sphere S such that the distances between the 
 points of contact of the common tangent planes to S and four fixed spheres are 
 equal is a straight line perpendicular to a plane of similitude of the four spheres. 
 
 Transforming the fixed spheres into points, the transformed spheres S' will 
 form a system of spheres Avith a common center; namely, the center of the 
 sphere determined by the four points. INIoreover, all the spheres S' with real 
 tangents to the four points lie within this sphere; consequently the distance 
 between the points of contact cannot exceed the radius of this sphere, and hence 
 it is a maximum when S' becomes a point; i. e., when the four fixed spheres and S 
 have a common plane of similitude. The theorem follows directly from the fact 
 that the system S' is a system of concentric spheres. There are eight cases for con- 
 sideration corresponding to the eight planes of similitude of the four fixed spheres. 
 
 6. The centers of the spheres tangent to four given spheres lie in pairs on 
 eight straight lines passing through the radical center and perpendicular to one 
 of the planes of similitude of the four spheres. 
 
 This is only a special case of the preceding. It is evident that the radical 
 plane of any pair of the tangent spheres is the plane of similitude, which is 
 perpendicular to the line joining the centers of the two spheres. The results 
 of this theorem can be employed in the construction of the spheres tangent to 
 four given spheres. 
 
 7. If >S is a sphere tangent to four given spheres, which are tangent to one 
 another, the five spheres have common planes of similitude. 
 
 Transforming the four spheres into points, the points will coincide, since each 
 sphere touches one of the others. But the four points must lie on S', the trans- 
 
161 APPLICATIONS OF A GEOMETKICAL TRANSFORMATION. 
 
 form of S, and therefore S' must also reduce to a point simultaneously with the 
 other four; hence the result. 
 
 8. The locus of the centers of all spheres which touch a given sphere and 
 have a common plane of similitude with it is an ellipsoid of revolution. 
 
 Let r be the radius and d be the distance from the common plane of similitude 
 of the center of the given sphere, and let p and 8 be the radius and distance 
 respectively of the variable sphere. Transform the spheres into points for the 
 same value of k and we have 
 
 7 (J 
 
 d' = ^ (k + lA) -lik- l/k) • 6' = 2 (/. + 1/^) - 2 ^^' ~ ^'^'^' 
 
 But, since all the spheres are tangent to the given sphere, the points into which 
 they transform are coincident, and therefore, d' = 5'. Hence 
 
 {k - HMr +p) = (^d+b- Y^^^ {k + m, 
 
 or, (r + p)/(5 + c) = e, where e and c are constants. 
 
 Therefore, the locus of the centers of the spheres is the locus of a point, 
 the ratio of whose distances from the center of the given sphere to its distance 
 from a plane parallel to and at the distance c from the common plane of similitude 
 is constant; i. e., an ellipsoid of revolution. 
 
Caylord Bros. 
 
 Makers 
 
 Syracuse, N. Y. 
 
 MI. IMI. 21, 19« 
 
 ^U US^Od 
 
 lii 
 
 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LIBRARY