L E AVE S 
 
 O S E 
 
 5 
 
 u 
 
 *- 
 

 LIBRARY 
 
 UNIVERSITY 
 CALIFORNIA 
 
 B. H. BI.ACK\VI,I .1., 1 
 
 Hook-, tiler, 
 SQ& 51, Hr..t<l St.. Oxford. | 
 

 
 Tl 
 
LEAVES OF PROSE 
 
LEAVES OF 
 PROSE 
 
 BY ANNIE MATHESON 
 WITH TWO STUDIES 
 BY MAY SINCLAIR 
 
 STEPHEN SWIFT 
 
 AND COMPANY LIMITED 
 TEN JOHN STREET 
 ADELPHI MCMXII 
 
BALLANTYNE & COMPANY LTD 
 
 TAVISTOCK STREET COVENT GARDEN 
 
 LONDON 
 
PAGE 
 
 CHRISTMAS DAY i 
 
 LONDON IN SPRING 2 
 
 SORDELLO AT THE EAST END 7 
 
 GEORGE FREDERICK WATTS, R.A. 17 
 
 FEBRUARY FAIR-MAIDS 18 
 
 PHILOSOPHY, POETRY AND THE LABOUR PARTY 22 
 
 ELECTION OF THE LONDON COUNTY COUNCIL 29 
 
 THE SOUL OF THE PEOPLE 30 
 
 LOAVES 39 
 
 THE CHILDREN OF THE STATE 41 
 
 SNOWDROP-TIME 44 
 
 DAFFODILS 45 
 
 THE FEEDING OF NECESSITOUS SCHOOL CHILDREN 49 
 
 THYRSIS IN A LONDON SQUARE 55 
 
 THE MEMORIAL TO MRS. BROWNING 60 
 
 A FLOWER FOR MRS. BROWNING'S GRAVE 66 
 
 MRS. BROWNING AS A SOCIAL REFORMER 71 
 
 A SONG OF NOBEL THOMSON 79 
 
 THE GLEAM 80 
 
 A FRAGMENT 83 
 
 THE OXFORD PAGEANT AND RUSKIN HALL 89 
 NOTE ON " SILAS MARNER " FROM THE TEMPLE 
 
 CLASSICS 96 
 
 THE PROFFERED SHIPS 106 
 
 IN MID-MAY'S GLORY 108 
 
 INTRODUCTION TO " SAYINGS FROM THE SAINTS " 1 1 1 
 
 THE LADY OF THE LAKE 117 
 
 AN EASTER REVERIE 131 
 
 FORGOTTEN BOOKS 135 
 
 ROSES 144 
 
 BETWEEN THE RAINS 145 
 
 NEIGHBOURING GARDENS 148 
 
 APPRECIATION OF "SCENES OF CLERICAL LIFE" 154 
 
 v 
 
 ' " 437 
 
PAGE 
 
 " GOING INTO THE SILENCE" 169 
 
 A HOLIDAY ON DARTMOOR 177 
 
 L'ENVOI TO THE THREE FOLLOWING SONNETS 183 
 
 To THE PEACEMAKER'S MEMORY 184 
 
 AN EARLY VICTORIAN NOVEL 186 
 
 THE CHILDREN IN GEORGE ELIOT'S STORIES 219 
 
 THE WORDS AND WAYS OF CHILDREN 224 
 
 IN EARLY AUTUMN 232 
 
 THE OPEN WINDOW 234 
 YOUNG ART AND MY LITTLE RED RIDING 
 
 HOOD 237 
 CHILDREN OF THE LONDON AND SOUTH WESTERN 
 
 RAILWAY 242 
 
 FROM A COTTAGE WINDOW 246 
 
 His SOLILOQUY 250 
 
 CHRISTINA GEORGINA ROSSETTI 251 
 THE IDEAL WOMAN AS WORDSWORTH AND 
 
 SHELLEY SAW HER 257 
 
 FOR THE COMMON CAUSE 261 
 
 A RECURRENT QUESTION 263 
 
 SNOW-WHITE 269 
 
 IN PRAISE OF "ADAM BEDE " 274 
 
 ST. PAUL'S CHIMES 283 
 
 TWO STUDIES BY MAY SINCLAIR 
 
 A SERVANT OF THE EARTH 289 
 
 GEORGE MEREDITH 301 
 
 VI 
 
THE publishers desire to thank Mr. Henry Frowde, 
 Messrs. Methuen, and Messrs. J. M. Dent, for 
 permission to reproduce Miss Matheson's essays 
 from the World's Classics, The Temple Classics, and 
 the Little Library ; and Mr. Eveleigh Nash for 
 allowing them to reprint her Introduction to 
 Sayings from the Saints ; and to acknowledge the 
 courtesy of the Contemporary Review, Athenaeum, 
 Journal of Education, Pall Mall Gazette, Westminster 
 Gazette, Mothers in Council, Guardian, Queen, 
 Weekly Sun, and Torkshire Post, for permission to 
 reprint many of her poems and articles ; as well 
 as the living authors from whom she has made 
 occasional brief quotations in her essays; also 
 such holders of copyright as Messrs. Smith, Elder, 
 Messrs. Burns & Gates, Messrs. Constable, 
 Messrs. Chatto & Windus, and Mr. David 
 Douglas, for the right to use such quotations 
 as those from The Ring and the Book, from 
 Arthur O'Shaughnessy, from Swinburne, from 
 George Meredith, and from the Diary of Sir 
 Walter Scott. 
 
 They further desire to thank Miss May Sinclair 
 for permitting them to append to this volume two 
 
 vii 
 
essays by her which had originally been intended for 
 By Divers Paths* a companion volume about to be 
 re-issued by the said publishers of Leaves of Prose, 
 who further wish to acknowledge the courtesy of 
 the periodicals in which Miss Sinclair's articles first 
 appeared. If in the above acknowledgments there 
 has been any oversight, it is inadvertent and will 
 be much regretted. 
 
 * " By 'Divers Paths " edited by Miss Matheson> who con- 
 tributes 42 of the essays and poems contains two fine sonnets by 
 Miss May Sinclair, several charming studies of South African 
 life by Miss Eleanor Tyrrell, poems by Mrs. Maude Egerton King, 
 and essays by <Dr. C. //. Herford, T>r. Greville MacT>ona/d, and 
 Mr. C. C. Cotlenll. 
 
 Vlll 
 
CHRISTMAS DAY 
 
 THERE is no word save One to tell 
 The secret of this world of pain ; 
 
 Its flame of love that conquers hell, 
 Its anguished loss that yet is gain. 
 
 One only Word since time began 
 May utter what we dumbly feel, 
 
 And thro' the infinite in Man 
 The infinite in God reveal. 
 
 He is our Christmas Joy, our Hope, 
 Our Immortality, our Strength 
 The Word of God, for whom we grope 
 Thro' all the stumbling journey's length. 
 
 Oh, when at last unveiled we see 
 
 The Face for which till death we long, 
 
 Then shall we know that Word to be 
 Our Life, our Rapture, and our Song ! 
 
LONDON IN SPRING 
 
 commotion of the spring is in heaven and 
 earth," wrote John Addington Syrnonds, u a rest- 
 lessness like the approach of some great delivering 
 passion " ; and what Symonds felt among the 
 snowfields of the High Alps, we, with diversities 
 of manifestation, have been feeling here in London. 
 Full of smoke and din is the great city ; defaced, 
 even on the surface of it, with hideous placards, 
 foul breathing-blots of underground railways, 
 squalid ruck-heaps of poverty and ruin ; but how 
 possessed with the great poem and pageant of life, 
 how thrilled and penetrated by the pathos of our 
 struggling and baffled humanity, comedy and 
 tragedy jostling one another, yet with barely time 
 to laugh or weep in the incessant contest for bread 
 and standing-room. No artist, though he starve 
 there, can fail to perceive something of the strange 
 and touching fascination of this sombre and alluring 
 city, stained, disfigured, blackened, yet beautiful 
 with a beauty that moves the heart and haunts 
 the mind, and reaches the deep hiding-places of 
 the soul. It has in it some undefinable quality 
 of sweet unexpectedness, some paradoxical charm 
 of old and new commingling, some mystic hint of 
 the eternal and the divine in communion with the 
 human and the sorrowful. There, in the midst 
 of the hurrying, tramping feet of the thousands 
 of eager wayfarers who encircle with their un- 
 heeding processions the ever-open church of 
 2 
 
St. Paul's, the great dome keeps a heart of silence 
 and of rest in the midst of the noise of noon, and, 
 in the sky of sunset or of sunrise, lends emphasis 
 to the loveliness of the glowing clouds by some- 
 thing nobly human in its unembarrassed outline. 
 There, the pigeons, with their soft yet opal-tinted 
 plumage, fly about the steps of the cathedral, and 
 haunt the ancient Guildhall. There, past the feet 
 of the old Abbey, the shrine of literature and art 
 and a thousand historic memories, past the Houses 
 of Parliament and the Temple Gardens, the ancient 
 river the river sung by Chaucer and by Milton, 
 and by Shakespeare himself flows dreamily 
 onward in the midst of all the restless sorrow and 
 sin and hope flows under its succession of en- 
 chanted bridges, consecrated anew by the poets 
 and the novelists of this complex, hurrying cen- 
 tury, till it reaches the thronging ships in the 
 docks, where Labour toils unceasingly under its 
 heaviest burdens. There, in the graveyards and 
 the parks and the open spaces, the little children 
 take joy of the flowers that they may not pluck, 
 and the birds make their lovely jargoning, and 
 the grass grows green again. 
 
 London is always beautiful, but never, surely, 
 so pathetically beautiful as in spring. And the 
 spring is coming is coming at last. The u com- 
 motion " that precedes her coming has long been 
 making noisy prelude to the coming melodies, 
 like the half-irritating tuning of the instruments 
 in some great orchestra. Sleet and rain we had, 
 and wind and sunshine, after the long frost-bound 
 winter ; and many days ago now the fragrance of 
 
 3 
 
OF 
 
 the palm-willows was already on the air, floating 
 in from the railway sidings at Child's Hill and 
 Hendon, where they scatter their sweets as lavishly 
 as in distant country lanes. Soon the travellers 
 between London and Richmond will find them- 
 selves speeding through seas of white blossom, in 
 the orchards on which they look from their rail- 
 way windows. Already, the great commons of 
 Chislehurst and Wimbledon and Wandsworth 
 must be loading their breezes with the delicious 
 scent of growing trees and reawakened turf and 
 tiny flowers hidden in the grass ; and in the deeps 
 of Epping Forest the fairy wood-sorrel must be 
 once more carpeting whole acres with its frail 
 bewitching loveliness. The uplands of High 
 Barnet and the great beeches in the Hadley 
 Woods must be stirring with new life and colour, 
 and merry with the song of birds. And here in 
 town the joy goes on apace ; already the lilacs are 
 a mist of green leaf, and from my top-floor 
 window at the back of a little thoroughfare among 
 London shops, I look through the bare branches 
 of an ancient mulberry-tree in the garden of my 
 neighbour the haberdasher, and see that the young 
 "forest tree" behind it is aglow with April 
 verdure. The leaves of the sycamore have broken 
 their pink sheaths, and many of the laburnums 
 at Belsize and Hampstead have unfolded their 
 button-like buds in neatly cut leaves. For a full 
 week the almond trees have been out along the 
 Bayswater Road, and the fairest of them all is one 
 which grows within a corner of area-railing, where 
 such a tree might seem impossible. They are mostly 
 
 4 
 
wan and pale this year ; but perhaps their lovely 
 sisters on the south side of Kensington Gardens 
 may blush in rosier buds and petals against that 
 pearly blue of sky which is their true background. 
 Nor is it only in Kensington Gardens that this 
 dainty and lustrous blossom clothes the bare black 
 branches with colours of heaven. In the garden 
 of many a suburban street, in many a sordid and 
 smoky corner, by many a forgotten grave in 
 London's vast outlying burial-grounds, the almond 
 tree is blossoming, and He who " is the perfect 
 Poet" is speaking to the hearts He has fashioned. 
 It is in its symbolism like that other earliest 
 blossom of which Browning wrote : 
 
 " The blackthorn boughs, 
 So dark in the bare wood, when glistening 
 In the sunshine, were white with coming buds, 
 Like the bright side of a sorrow." 
 
 In the lanes where the woodbine leaves are 
 showing the brown bloominess on the backs of 
 their unfolding leaves, where the little green buds 
 of the hawthorn are swelling among the newly 
 opened foliage, and, like a miniature dandelion- 
 clock, the coltsfoot is making patches of white 
 down in the wayside grass, spring breathes a 
 thousand tender memories of the days that are 
 gone. The white violets will soon be budding in 
 their leafy coverts, the celandines already are 
 starring the fields ; but it seems that the gaiety 
 of the celandine and the fragrance of the violet 
 have a sorrow in them, now that death has stolen 
 from us so many of those " dear familiar faces " 
 
 5 
 
OF 
 
 that were with us in the meadows and the byways 
 of our vanished youth. 
 
 Yet when the springtime comes to us amid the 
 heart-throbs of a great city, where human needs 
 and aspirations are crying to us on every side, 
 then is there new hope in the sunlight, new 
 vitality in the blossom-laden wind, new love in 
 the very whispering of the churchyard grass. 
 That great and ancient river which, through the 
 long frost, lay bound and deadened under huge 
 blocks of ice, while the sea-gulls hovered hungrily 
 above it, is once more bearing its accustomed 
 freight, and flowing more genially eastward under 
 the bridge which George Eliot has made immortal. 
 The sunshine is upon it, the warm, common, 
 life-giving sunshine. The brotherhood of the 
 world is in the air, and every sense is quickened 
 with the joy of a welcome release from the 
 captivity of a long and bitter winter. 
 
 " Once more the Heavenly Power 
 Makes all things new." 
 
 In such a mood we ask no idle sentimental 
 dreaming over the cherished past : our hearts 
 echo Tennyson's song of wages we demand no 
 other guerdon than " the glory of going on, and 
 still to be." 
 
SORDELLO AT THE EAST END 
 
 BROWNING says of Bordello : 
 
 " He felt 
 
 An error, an exceeding error melt 
 While he was occupied with Mantuan chants, 
 Behoved him think of men, and take their wants, 
 Such as he now distinguished every side, 
 As his own want which might be satisfied, 
 And, after that, think of rare qualities 
 Of his own soul demanding exercise." 
 
 Some such motto might well be written above 
 the hearth of the University Settlements. 
 
 This indeed is the idea which Westcott ex- 
 pressed in his own forcible prose when he said : 
 " The question which we must always be striving 
 to answer is, * How shall I do my part in this 
 common life in which I share ? ' Sooner s or later 
 here or hereafter when our eyes are opened, I 
 believe that we shall see that all the sorrows and 
 sins, which fill us with grief and almost with 
 despair, touch ourselves nearly, and are indeed 
 parts of our own life for which we in our measure 
 are responsible/' 
 
 And it is with a certain pleasant sense of 
 paradox that we note how a poem often derided for 
 its obscurity has for years been teaching, despite 
 the bewilderment of its gorgeous Italian colouring 
 and the complex harmonies which half conceal its 
 concentrated unity of meaning, a doctrine which 
 
 7 
 
OF 
 
 might well be made the text of a popular move- 
 ment of the day, a movement of which its enemies 
 have said that it is in danger of losing its true out- 
 line in the clouds of talk which encircle it. 
 
 But as far as the east is from the west is the 
 temperate enthusiasm of the University Settlers 
 from the imitative sentiment of the gossips who 
 discuss it, and who, without any actual expendi- 
 ture of time, or strength, or money, yet wrap 
 themselves in a vague philanthropic intention. 
 
 The paradox, like other paradoxes, is exactly 
 what all but the narrow-minded would desire. 
 That the purpose of such a movement should be 
 in accordance with the teaching of a great poet 
 who through years of popular neglect patiently 
 preached his gospel to the few who would listen, is 
 precisely what a believer would wish and expect. 
 
 The author of " Obiter Dicta " assured us that 
 " Faith may be well left alone, for she is, to give 
 her her due, our largest manufacturer of good 
 works, and, whenever her furnaces are blown out, 
 morality suffers." 
 
 Happily this commercial island of ours has 
 never been quite without the poets and prophets 
 who rekindle such furnaces and tend them with 
 unconscious passion. Nor is it always those 
 faggot-pilers who are popularly regarded as the 
 briskest workmen who really do the most to keep 
 the flame at a white heat. 
 
 Who shall say how many poets of lower rank 
 have been illumined in some crucial moment by 
 the burning truths which now and then flash 
 from Browning's "Sordello"'? Who shall say into 
 8 
 
SO^DSLLO <A<r me e^tsr 
 
 how many towns and cities these lesser men have 
 carried the sacred flame which they borrowed 
 from a book the world has not cared to read ? It 
 is a story of the temptations, disciplines, failures, 
 through which Sordello, the young Italian versifier, 
 is taught at last, and just too late for this life, to 
 recognise the mission of every true poet as that 
 of a God-inspired friend of the people, a divinely 
 kindled lover of humanity. That it should seem 
 obscure to many English readers is at once 
 accounted for by the fact that it presupposes 
 an intimate knowledge of Italian history. To 
 Browning the typical reader is what the typical 
 school-boy was to Macaulay. He credits him 
 with his own encyclopaedic knowledge, his own 
 powerful and emotional intellect, his own faculty 
 for seeing round corners without moving an inch 
 from the central standpoint, his own vivid over- 
 leaping mode of reasoning, at once so elliptical, 
 parenthetical, and cautiously questioned. 
 
 That " Sordello" can at moments be musically, 
 convincingly lucid no one can doubt who 
 remembers the few master touches by which the 
 artistic temperament is made to breathe before 
 the reader in the following passage : 
 
 "a soul fit to receive 
 Delight at every sense ; you can believe 
 Sordello foremost in the regal class 
 Nature has broadly severed from her mass 
 Of men, and framed for pleasure, as she frames 
 Some happy lands, that have luxurious names. 
 
OF 
 
 You recognise at once the finer dress 
 
 Of flesh that amply lets in loveliness 
 
 At eye and ear, while round the rest is furled 
 
 (As though she would not trust them with her 
 
 world) 
 
 A veil that shows a sky not near so blue, 
 And lets but half the sun look fervid through. 
 How can such love ? . . . 
 . . . fresh births of beauty wake 
 Fresh homage, every grade of love is past, 
 With every mode of loveliness : then cast 
 Inferior idols off their borrowed crown 
 Before a coming glory. Up and down 
 Runs arrowy fire, while earthly forms combine 
 To throb the secret forth ; a touch divine 
 And the scaled eyeball owns the mystic rod ; 
 Visibly through his garden walketh God." 
 
 More touching to some of us than the just- 
 quoted description of a youthful poet are the 
 powerful lines in which Browning himself, speak- 
 ing for once in his own person, chooses, as the life- 
 long mistress of his heart, Humanity in its most 
 hungry, tattered and forlorn aspect, declaring that 
 it is just the supreme need, the unsatisfied craving, 
 the forlorn wretchedness, which have won his love. 
 
 " Peasants, queens, 
 
 Take them, made happy by whatever means, 
 Parade them for the common credit, vouch 
 That a luckless residue, we send to crouch 
 In corners out of sight, was just as framed 
 For happiness, its portion might have claimed 
 As well." 
 10 
 
SOT^DSLLO 
 
 It is impossible to quote at length the marvel- 
 lous passage in which he symbolises the suffering 
 he yearns over, pausing at last to say how the 
 miserable, tired out, despised existence of the 
 Many 
 
 " seems to fall 
 
 Toward me no wreath, only a lip's unrest 
 To quiet, surcharged eyelids to be pressed 
 Dry of their tears upon my bosom. Strange 
 Such sad chance should produce in thee such 
 
 change, 
 My love ! warped souls and bodies ! " 
 
 Well may the lover of " warped souls and bodies " 
 passionately remind us of the need of a Power 
 above us and beyond us, and add, with profound 
 significance : 
 
 4 'But of a Power its representative 
 Who, being for authority the same, 
 Communication different, should claim 
 A course, the first chose and this last revealed 
 This Human clear, as that Divine concealed 
 What utter need ! " 
 
 That is a need which the founders of the 
 University Settlements did not fail to recognise 
 a need which was present to the mind of him 
 with whose memory Toynbee Hall must ever be 
 associated, as well as to the preacher who wrote 
 concerning the Oxford House : " We find that 
 a lot of men at Oxford, while perfectly recogni- 
 sing the preference of others for a work wholly 
 cut off from a particular religious tie, yet for 
 
 ii 
 
OF 
 
 themselves feel that the secular work has its best 
 background in a * foyer' of worship and prayer." 
 There are some who seem to fear that these 
 Settlements are not secular enough for their pur- 
 pose, as though the ruling out of the world into 
 " sacred " and " secular " were not of itself a kind 
 of profanity. 
 
 " All service ranks the same with God," 
 
 and, if to clean a window for His sake be often 
 better than to preach a sermon, then why should 
 there be these futile divisions and distinctions ? 
 To assume that churches and parishes are all very 
 well for the West, but that agnosticism is the only 
 straight road to the hearts of costermongers, and 
 that nothing is so damning to work in the East as 
 any positive belief that is a theory which shall 
 not here be admitted. No, if the Settlements die, 
 it will not be because they are wrecked on religious 
 controversies, but because they sink for want of 
 religious faith. 
 
 Well might Westcott say at the meeting which 
 united Oxford and Cambridge in one " indissoluble 
 bond," not " to baffle God who loves the world," 
 but to try at least to put themselves at His 
 service : 
 
 44 1 certainly cannot forget how can I forget ? 
 that the central fact of my faith of our faith 
 brings before us with a power that nothing 
 could surpass, the supreme truth that all that is 
 noblest in life is common to men as men. I 
 cannot forget that the crowning sign of the 
 Christ was not the restoration of lost powers, was 
 
 12 
 
not even the temporal conquest of death, but that 
 a gospel is preached to the poor. I cannot forget 
 that we believe and profess our belief in one 
 Church in which all diversities of class and en- 
 dowment are only provisions for the fulfilment 
 of diversities of office." 
 
 The work of the Settlements must, it is true, 
 often include drudgery, friction, weariness ; but 
 how true it is that 
 
 " This work is a work which has the special 
 qualities of mercy it is twice blessed, and, if 
 the blessing prove greater on one side than on the 
 other, it will be on the side of those that go there 
 rather than on the side of those to whom they 
 go." 
 
 This paper has touched on Browning's eloquent 
 description of that artistic temperament, allathirst 
 for beauty, sensuous and spiritual, with which 
 Sordello was gifted for blessing or for cursing. 
 Nowhere perhaps are the special dangers of such 
 a nature and Browning is ever emphasising 
 their perils more likely to be fostered than in 
 life at Oxford or Cambridge. Which of us, 
 feeling in ourselves those very possibilities, does 
 not shudder in reading of how, in this world, 
 Sordello failed 
 
 " As one content to merely be supposed 
 Singing or fighting elsewhere, while he dozed " ? 
 
 If there be any who realise the good which the 
 University Settlements may do in strengthening 
 the moral fibre and spiritual earnestness of the 
 
 13 
 
OF 
 
 workers, but doubt on the other hand whether 
 there will be any practical result in the neighbour- 
 hood which they try to help, there are two facts 
 of which they may be reminded. First, let them 
 consider that the whole system of local admini- 
 stration in England is based on the tacit assump- 
 tion that there exists everywhere " a resident 
 leisured class " able and willing to do the work of 
 Vestries, Poor Law Boards, and the like ; and 
 then reflect that in the East of London such a 
 class is ruinously absent. 
 
 In the second place, let them remember all the 
 harm that has been done by a fussy patronising 
 benevolence on the one hand and a cold mechani- 
 cal officialism on the other; and ask themselves 
 whether there be any gift more certain to be 
 fruitful of good than that deep, patient, individual 
 love which we are taught to pray for as the very 
 bond of peace and of all perfectness, the love 
 which seeks intimate knowledge, frequent inter- 
 course, individual relationship. Surely the in- 
 ference is not far to seek. The residents at the 
 Settlement ought to supply at least a few of that 
 class of much-needed municipal workers who in 
 the past have been too often only conspicuous in 
 the East End by their absence. They ought also, 
 by the mere fact that they are neighbours in a 
 literal sense, and have a right to share in the 
 common needs and sympathies of the community, 
 to be able to enter into relations of simple friend- 
 ship and brotherhood with those among whom 
 they dwell. What is sometimes called friendship 
 is often as great a sham as what is sometimes 
 
 H 
 
SO^DSLLO vfr rne e^sr 
 
 called brotherhood, but that does not change the 
 fact that the true friendship and the true brother- 
 hood are divine boons. Never are they more 
 divine than when they overleap class distinctions, 
 forget traditional prejudices, ignore sectarian 
 divisions. A great compeer of Browning's has 
 given us a very lovely and perfect lyric, in which 
 the two voices sing of the love of lovers that it is 
 
 " Love that can shape or can shatter a life till the 
 
 life shall have fled ? 
 
 Nay, let us welcome him, Love that can lift up 
 a life from the dead." 
 
 And may it not be said of all unselfish passion, 
 above all of that enthusiasm of humanity which 
 is neither more nor less than divinely inspired 
 love, that it may be vital enough to kindle into a 
 more vivid and beautiful existence even the dull 
 unbeautiful deadness of East London ? 
 
 " Nay, let us welcome him, Love that can lift up 
 a life from the dead." 
 
 In an article in Time, in which Canon Barnett 
 gave a clear and detailed account of the plan and 
 aim of "A University Settlement/' he reminds us 
 that 
 
 "Vain will it be to get good houses, clean 
 streets, and universal comfort, if at the same time 
 men do not find delight in service. It would be 
 safe indeed to go a step further, and add, vain is 
 the gospel which makes a man anxious to save his 
 own soul, if at the same time he is not made more 
 anxious to give his soul to save his friends." 
 
 15 
 
OF 
 
 Surely that is a truth not very unlike the truth 
 expressed in that quotation from " Sordello " with 
 which this paper opened. 
 
 Canon Barnett rightly tells us that " Happily 
 there is no need to rouse public feeling as to the 
 way in which the poor that is, the majority of 
 Englishmen live. Unnoticed influences have 
 brooded like spirits over the chaos of politics and 
 trade, and directed the thought of men to one 
 end." 
 
 How many thousands of men and women in 
 England have been stirred at the eleventh hour to 
 a really energetic resolve that Lazarus shall no 
 longer lie untended at the gate ! The filth and 
 squalor of our large towns have not, alas, come 
 suddenly and recently into existence. How is it 
 that, only suddenly and recently, the question has 
 become a burning question, and at last, thus late 
 in the day, there seems likely to be some little 
 outcome of good work ? 
 
 Why is it ? It is because at last faith's furnace 
 has waxed hot enough to melt even callous and 
 stupid hearts to shame. Not Browning only, but 
 scores of inspired workers, known and unknown, 
 have been ready to immolate their very souls and 
 bodies in this furnace rather than fall down and 
 worship the eyeless golden image of the dwellers- 
 at-ease, and at last, after long waiting, there has 
 been a vision of God. 
 
 16 
 
GEORGE FREDERICK WATTS, R.A. 
 
 UNMOVED by changing forms of many a creed, 
 He served the Altar with a toil divine, 
 Filled Christ's own chalice with the sacred wine 
 And broke the bread for sacramental need, 
 Stooped low the sad and hungry souls to feed 
 Who make their life the dungeon where they 
 
 pine, 
 Through their dim grating called the stars to 
 
 shine, 
 
 And wrought for Him who is the Light indeed. 
 Now, past deep waters that he crossed dry-shod, 
 Beyond Philistia, quit of Amalek, 
 
 In joy of artistry and honour increast, 
 He does the bidding of the beautiful God 
 
 An acolyte of the Eternal Priest, 
 After the order of Melchizedek. 
 
FEBRUARY FAIR-MAIDS 
 
 THEY are here, the February Fair-Maids, and we 
 think of the great poet, not dead, but ever speak- 
 ing to our hearts, who enshrined for us in words of 
 welcome the quaint country name of these " first- 
 lings,"doubtless the name they bore in that Lincoln- 
 shire village of his boyhood where " the little glen 
 in the neighbourhood called by the old monkish 
 name of Holywell " he remembered " white with 
 snowdrops in their season " that village of which 
 he wrote in sweet Miltonian cadences in his " Ode 
 to Memory " : 
 
 <c Come from the woods that belt the grey hill- 
 side, 
 
 The seven elms, the poplars four, 
 That stand beside my father's door, 
 And chiefly from the brook that loves 
 To purl o'er matted cress and ribbed sand, 
 Or dimple in the dark of rushy coves . . . 
 O ! hither lead thy feet ! 
 Pour round mine ears the live-long bleat 
 Of the thick-fleeced sheep from wattled folds, 
 Upon the ridged wolds." 
 
 There is something in the cool tranquility of 
 the pastoral and sylvan picture, the woods, the 
 running water, the " wattled folds," that seems a 
 fit setting for the glen of snowdrops, those white 
 " fair maids " of February, snooded with that 
 delicate and vital green which makes them the 
 18 
 
very promise and type of stainless purity and 
 eternal spring. 
 
 But, after all, their loveliness appeals to us with 
 a more moving charm, perhaps, as they come forth 
 in their dazzling hopefulness from the sooty 
 mould of old flower-pots on London window- 
 sills, " innocent whitenesses " (to steal and reverse 
 Charles Lamb's pretty name for the little chimney- 
 sweeps) as yet unspotted by the bleak and wintry 
 world. Before our London almond tree, our wild 
 "flow'r o' the peach," puts forth the delicate 
 rose-flush of heaven in stony corners of our sordid 
 streets, before the chestnut buds begin to glisten, 
 or the birds to make their sweet springtide 
 "jargoning "in grimy London gardens and in 
 smutty London squares, the snowdrops lift their 
 heads in graceful hardihood, as unsullied as Pom- 
 pilia, as unconscious as Pippa. 
 
 Is it an accident that our English country-folk 
 have rechristened so many of our white flowers 
 with such especial felicity ? The pheasant-eyed 
 narcissus is the Sweet Nancy, the white flower of 
 the Italian painters is the Mary Lily, the snowdrop 
 is the Fair Maid of February. But, after all, for 
 the last of these three, the name by which it is most 
 widely known is the loveliest and most appropriate. 
 White as the driven snow it is, hung upon its 
 smooth stem, tipped with the heavenward-point- 
 ing spear, as if it had indeed dropped there, with 
 the inimitable poise of clinging rain or pendent 
 dew, instead of having in truth arisen, after the 
 divinely human fashion, through slow processes 
 of struggling development, extracting beauty from 
 
 '9 
 
OF 
 
 ugliness, and purity from "a handful of poor 
 earth." 
 
 This brief paper was suggested by the haunting 
 music of that one line in Tennyson's unrhymed 
 poem to a snowdrop from which its title is taken ; 
 but it is in his far more perfect lyric of " Early 
 Spring," a lyric which must surely last as long as 
 the English language lasts, that the snowdrop and 
 the crocus speak to us most : 
 
 66 O Heart, look down and up 
 
 Serene, secure, 
 Warm as the crocus cup, 
 Like snowdrops pure." 
 
 It is in a lyric even briefer, and for once as 
 simple and as musical, that Browning has be- 
 queathed to us a line about our February 
 flower : 
 
 " For each glance of the eye so bright and black, 
 
 Though I keep with heart's endeavour, 
 Your voice, when you wish the snowdrops back, 
 Though it stay in my soul for ever ! 
 
 "Yet I will but say what mere friends say, 
 
 Or only a thought stronger ; 
 I will hold your hand but as long as all may, 
 Or so very little longer ! " 
 
 That is simple enough for a dullard, and it 
 breathes the magic which cannot be defined ; in 
 a word, it is poetry. 
 
 But loveliest magic of all, passing even this of 
 language, is in the snowdrop itself, in silent and 
 
 20 
 
natural ways, transmuting the black earth of 
 London into a flower fit for the angels, and yet 
 more fit for men and women : 
 
 Like to life's poetry that comes not by 
 A poet's dreams, but blossoms in the dust 
 Of lowly deeds and patient-handed toil. 
 
 21 
 
PHILOSOPHY, POETRY, AND THE 
 LABOUR PARTY 
 
 "IN reply to the just and urgent claims of the 
 workmen suddenly deprived of their means of 
 livelihood, and unable in a day to find another," 
 cried Auguste Comte I quote from M. Levy 
 Bruhl's summary " our economists can only re- 
 peat with merciless pedantry their barren aphorism 
 about absolute industrial liberty. To all com- 
 plaints they dare to answer that it is a question 
 of time ! And this to men who require food 
 to-day ! " 
 
 But Comte was not of those who content 
 themselves with quack remedies or cheap social 
 nostrums. He liked to say "that the considera- 
 tion of duty is bound up with the spirit of the 
 whole." . . . "Every one," he taught, "has 
 duties, and towards all. No one has any right 
 properly so called. ... In us the intellect is only 
 a means. Love is the principle, action is the end." 
 
 This is calming and bracing doctrine, after 
 utterances of a blatantly selfish kind, published 
 under the heading of "The Liberals and the 
 Labour Men," glorifying self-interest as the 
 pivot of human life. 
 
 Who can doubt that Comte is right and that 
 Love, not the lower motive just named, is at 
 the heart of all true communal progress and 
 evolution ? 
 
 It is the hidden spring of that self-control 
 
 22 
 
TOSTRT <^NT> THS L^BOU T<AR<TT 
 
 which a well-known poet and essayist has pro- 
 claimed as the most valuable of all habits, and 
 goes even deeper than the desired intercourse 
 between labour and academic knowledge so con- 
 vincingly advocated by Canon Barnett. 
 
 Like all vital and noble forces, Love, as the 
 principle of action, needs and demands the 
 widest and deepest knowledge attainable within 
 the boundaries of Love's own limiting obligations. 
 Shelley, whose sympathy with labour was pas- 
 sionate, wrote : 
 
 "The wise want love, and those who love want 
 
 wisdom : 
 
 And all best things are thus confused to ill 
 Many are strong and rich and would be just, 
 But live among their suffering fellow-men 
 As if none felt ; they know not what they do." 
 
 But Shelley's Demogorgon, in a vision that 
 passes beyond the horizon of our mortal day and 
 yet includes it, sees that 
 
 " Love from its awful throne of patient power 
 In the wise heart, from the last giddy hour 
 
 Of dread endurance, from the slippery steep, 
 And narrow verge of crag-like agony, springs 
 And folds over the world its healing wings. 
 Gentleness, Virtue, Wisdom, and Endurance, 
 These are the seals of that most firm assurance 
 Which bars the pit over Destruction's 
 strength." 
 
 It may be that there is no perfect art, even of 
 
 23 
 
OF 
 
 living, no absolute loveliness, even of creation, in 
 which there is not a fine self-restraint. 
 
 But Labour, the mighty Cyclops, long prisoned 
 yet ever of close kinship with Olympus, must 
 needs draw strength and beauty from more 
 elemental sources than mere social conventions, 
 or traditional orthodoxies of intellectual scribes 
 or wrangling pharisees. 
 
 May not Labour in this be like the poet-girl 
 who, in that romance of social reform which 
 Ruskin is said to have honoured as the greatest 
 poem of the nineteenth century, tells us that she 
 
 "... had relations with the Unseen, and drew 
 The elemental nutriment and heat 
 From nature, as earth feels the sun at nights, 
 Or as a babe sucks surely in the dark." 
 
 I have had the high honour of living in the 
 closest intercourse with labouring people, and I 
 know that their lives, which in pathos are ever on 
 the edge of tragedy, often breathe the very spirit 
 of the deepest poetry. 
 
 The burden that the Cyclops must bear in city 
 streets and slums, where the very soap and water 
 have to be paid for, indirectly in time and 
 strength if not in money, is a load that only the 
 hardest heart can realise without shame and grief, 
 when once the sense of corporate responsibility 
 and practical brotherhood has been permanently 
 awakened. 
 
 But even there, and still more here, in the 
 country, where some measure of lovely vision and 
 decent living are within reach of many labouring 
 24 . 
 
me 
 
 homes, there is a pagan joy of living, a fatalistic 
 acceptance of the inevitable lot, an underlying 
 faith, not in churches or shibboleths, but in all 
 that Dolly Winthrop trusted to as "Them 
 above" a heart not far from the eternities, and 
 eyes that look at moments towards the everlasting 
 hills. 
 
 Yet I cannot deny that the labourer whom I 
 know best a skilful workman, upright, loyal, 
 tender-hearted is, or at all events was, when he 
 first crossed my path, deeply seared and embittered 
 by our unjust and unchristian social conditions, 
 and only too ready to respond to such a dastardly 
 cry as that here reprinted as a cruel misrepresenta- 
 tion of the intentions of the Labour Party that 
 Labour Party from which we look for a battle-cry 
 ennobled by the awful sufferings which Labour has 
 endured. 
 
 Here is the terrible line which made me suffer 
 shame for the mighty Cyclops whom I love and 
 reverence, and on whose weary shoulders rest the 
 very foundations of society : 
 
 " Self-interest is the strongest motive in human 
 nature. Look after your own interests. Stand by 
 your own class.'' 
 
 To write that upon the Labour programme 
 would indeed be to sink to the level of degrading 
 class feeling and class distinctions. It is not only 
 unworthy of a great cause, it is also suicidal ; for 
 any section of the community that founds conduct 
 upon the selfish pedantries of the old, already 
 
OF 
 
 superseded, political economy is writing upon 
 itself a sentence of death. 
 
 Besides our own island poets, there is one bard 
 of world-wide fame who has especially avowed 
 himself the poet of Democracy. He, Walt 
 Whitman, looks not to self-interest, but to love, as 
 the moving power of the world, and sees round 
 every human heart that divine halo, though our 
 our eyes are often blind to it. 
 
 When he bids you, 
 
 " Whoever you are ! claim your own at any 
 hazard," 
 
 he speaks not of the poor toys of the moment, 
 but of that which neither time nor death can 
 wrest from you. He bids you be 
 
 " Master or Mistress in your own rights over 
 Nature, elements, pain, passions, dissolution." 
 
 There are creeds and crowns that are merely 
 political, of which he would say with Mr. 
 Swinburne through the lips of Hertha 
 
 " A creed is a rod 
 
 And a crown is of night ; 
 But this thing is of God, 
 
 To be man with thy might, 
 To grow straight in the strength of thy spirit, 
 And live out thy life as the light." 
 
 He believes with Wordsworth that Life 
 
 " . . . is energy of love 
 Divine or human, exercised in strife, 
 26 
 
me 
 
 In pain or tribulation and ordained, 
 If so approved and sanctified, to pass 
 Through shades of silent rest to endless joy." 
 
 Shelley wrote of love : 
 " It makes the reptile equal to the God." 
 
 But Browning gives to the same thought an 
 expression at once juster and more daring : 
 
 " For the loving worm within its clod 
 Were diviner than a loveless god 
 Among his worlds, I will dare to say." 
 
 The crawling of the worm is not for man 
 least of all for " Labour men," dear to the Eternal 
 Craftsman who chose the shed of a carpenter as 
 the nursery on earth of Divine Love. 
 
 Shelley, who defied the horrible travesties of 
 Christianity too often current under its name, yet 
 wrote concerning the true symbol of sacrificial 
 love that 
 
 " . . . blazoned, as on Heaven's immortal 
 
 noon, 
 The Cross leads generations on/' 
 
 And M. Levy Bruhl reminds us that Comte 
 towards the close of his life read every day in 
 that little book of " The Imitation " which bears 
 the name of one who lived a hard and self- 
 renouncing life. 
 
 They have both moved the world and be- 
 queathed, to us who love and labour, thoughts to 
 strengthen that invaluable habit of self-control 
 from within, whereby labour may achieve some of 
 
 27 
 
OF 7*3088 
 
 the mighty victories so finely suggested by Mr. 
 Frederick Rogers, who has hope that " the 
 horrible conditions of so much of our factory life, 
 the tragedy of the aged in industry, the long hours 
 of labour for some, and the difficulty of obtaining 
 labour for others," may at last be immediately 
 and energetically grappled with. 
 
 Year by year the great army of Labour must 
 count its maimed and slain upon the battlefield. 
 It is on their behalf that the mighty host has now 
 become articulate. It is a great moment. May we 
 not say to Labour, as Mr. George Meredith said 
 to Age, when speaking of that Nature whereby, 
 as he teaches, " the gloomy Wherefore of our 
 battlefield" is solved " in the Spirit," 
 
 " But hast thou in thy season set her fires 
 To burn from Self to Spirit through the lash, 
 Honoured the sons of Earth shall hold thee 
 
 high: 
 
 Yea, to spread light when thy proud letter I 
 Drops prone and void as any thoughtless 
 dash " ? 
 
 28 
 
ELECTION OF THE LONDON 
 COUNTY COUNCIL 
 
 Now let your great traditions guard your heart, 
 Brave city of Milton, Shakespeare's capital ! 
 Where good and evil still hold carnival 
 
 And in your civic contests bear a part ! 
 
 Let proud philosophy and love and art 
 Call forth artillery from their arsenal 
 To thunder for your rights municipal 
 
 And sweep corruption from your crowded mart ! 
 
 No slave of party ever can be free ; 
 
 Oh, learn of charity from that Saint Paul 
 To whom you dedicate your central dome, 
 
 A citizen of no mean city, he, 
 
 And keep your altar-hearth aglow for all 
 To make, amid your many mansions, Home ! 
 
THE SOUL OF THE PEOPLE 
 
 A PLEA FOR DIVERSITY IN UNITY 
 
 WE hear much on all hands of physical deteriora- 
 tion, and whatever may be the precise ultimatum 
 on this matter, it is at all events certain that to 
 multitudes of our fellow-citizens the conditions of 
 a sound physical life and a home fit for the rearing 
 of children seem to be not only unattainable, but 
 almost beyond hope. It is true that every man 
 must first bear his own sufficient load of individual 
 responsibility, in the effort to live honestly and 
 nobly in this world of harassing conflict and sordid 
 competition. But he who can impotently stand 
 unhelpingand unmoved, while the souls and bodies 
 of his own people and kindred go down under 
 burdens too heavy to be borne, must be dead to 
 the essential verities by which we claim to be a 
 Christian nation. For such a nation takes upon 
 itself the name of a Master in social ethics who 
 taught that, although the suffering inherent in the 
 discipline of this transient outward body must not 
 even weigh in the scale against the education of 
 an eternal and beautiful spirit, yet the sons and 
 daughters of men should be fair and healthy as the 
 glorious lilies of the field ; taught that for necessary 
 food and clothing it is not His will that they 
 should lack ; taught that to close the heart 
 against the physical needs of any human creature 
 was to court a worse fate than drowning with a 
 millstone round the neck ; and left, as a vital part 
 
 30 
 
<THe SOUL OF THS 
 
 of His tradition, the daily consecration of the body 
 as a temple of His own transcendent Presence. 
 
 But the problem of physical deterioration must 
 be attacked at its source and centre as well as 
 through its environment. Our whole social 
 structure demands gradual rebuilding after a 
 diviner plan until there be given to every man the 
 birthright of such an outward lot as shall leave 
 the life of the soul unshackled and unimpaired. 
 Nevertheless it is impossible even to glance at 
 modern therapeutics without perceiving that in 
 all national uplifting the sou! of the people reacts 
 upon the body, and the highest level of racial 
 efficiency will never be attained where there is 
 spiritual flaccidity and blindness and corruption. 
 
 Without ever wholly separating the two con- 
 siderations, or regarding the claims of the spirit 
 to the exclusion of the claims of the body, it may 
 be permissible, on non-controversial and non-party 
 lines, to touch upon one cardinal error which seems 
 to permeate official dissensions in the so-called 
 religious life of our unchristian Christian empire. 
 
 I am a woman. I believe in those profound 
 distinctions of sex wherein lies much of what is 
 highest and most godlike in the nature made in 
 the image of the Eternal. 
 
 " Everywhere 
 
 I see in the world the intellect of man, 
 That sword, the energy, his subtle spear, 
 The knowledge which defends him like a shield 
 Everywhere." 
 
 But when Robert Browning thus defined the 
 
OF 
 
 masculine prerogative, through the lips of the old 
 Pope in "The Ring and the Book," he was far 
 indeed from denying to woman that share in the 
 guidance of the imperial hearth which even Ruskin 
 claimed for her at the very moment when he 
 warned her against cheap feminine effrontery in the 
 direction of theological disputations. There is 
 much that I gladly leave to the masculine sword 
 and spear and shield, for I know well that 
 
 " The woman's cause is man's : they rise or sink 
 Together." 
 
 But I cannot forget that on woman rests the 
 crowning responsibility of motherhood, and no 
 true woman, whether married or unmarried, can 
 wholly ignore the needs of the children who 
 surround her, even though those children may not 
 be her own. Therefore women may in all modesty 
 and charity have a word to say, on behalf of the 
 children in our schools and churches, on whom the 
 offence of our quarrelsome literalism reacts with 
 deadening and disastrous result. And, since women 
 are popularly supposed to be religious reactionaries, 
 it is perhaps not unfitting that the many English- 
 women who believe that the Church needs reform- 
 ing from within should, by finding a spokeswoman, 
 however unworthy, utter their plea for a sane and 
 progressive religious unity, a unity strengthened 
 and deepened by the catholic diversity which it 
 includes. 
 
 It must be clear to the meanest understanding 
 that, unless the entire historic ideal of the Ecclesia 
 be a stereotyped and depraved futility, the eccle- 
 32 
 
me SOUL OF rne TSOTLS 
 
 siastical cannot be wholly separated from the 
 theological and the ethical. 
 
 The magnification of orthodoxy by subservient 
 selfishness and narrow bigotry has been once for 
 all branded with scorn by the Master's scathing 
 denunciation of self-seeking and self-righteous 
 dignitaries as vipers and hypocrites, but that de- 
 nunciation was perfectly consonant with his choice 
 of an honest and orthodox bigot for that sudden 
 heart-stirring illumination which made of a man, 
 proud at once of his civic liberties and his eccle- 
 siastical education, the most catholic and humbly 
 self-sacrificing of His ambassadors. 
 
 There can be little doubt that those who regard 
 themselves as the responsible leaders of Christianity 
 in England stand just now in a crossway pass of 
 extreme peril and have a right to remind their 
 followers everywhere that England in this matter 
 also expects every man to do his duty. On the 
 one hand a hard, literal, fossilised interpretation 
 of the creeds daily turns away thousands from 
 altars to which " the feast's own Founder " 
 would welcome every earnest heart. On the 
 other hand, the very foundation of all that makes 
 for home and peace and brotherhood in our 
 rotten social fabric is being undermined by a tide 
 of neo-paganism, a tide which, held at bay for a 
 time by that rock whereon the ancient Church 
 was built as the citadel of mutual reverence and 
 steadfast covenant in man's daily intercourse with 
 his fellows, now seeks to sweep away everything 
 beneath the iridescent foam of its self-indulgent 
 pseudo-philosophy, except the shifting sands of 
 
 c 33 
 
OF 
 
 animalism, emotionalism, and blatant sentimental 
 rhapsody. 
 
 "The laws of marriage," of which Tennyson 
 long since wrote that they were, in his ideal woman, 
 
 " charactered in gold 
 Upon the blanched tablets of her heart/' 
 
 are openly mocked at, or treated with a scarcely 
 veiled contempt ; and one of the sincerest and 
 most distinguished of our sociological writers in 
 the present day has indicated with sufficient plain- 
 ness in his recent utterances concerning education 
 that, in his opinion, stimulus is more important 
 than discipline or so-called " morality," and that 
 the teachers of our boys need not be over-nice or 
 sternly pure-hearted if only they will call forth 
 in every possible direction the dormant energies 
 of slowly awakening manhood, forgetting that, 
 while apathy is indeed the most hopeless of 
 deadly sins, yet there is, as in the vision of 
 Coleridge's "Ancient Mariner," a ghastly Life- 
 in-Death of lurid sensationalism that throws the 
 dice against Death-in-Life with a perpetual risk 
 of an even deeper perdition. 
 
 Between these two extremes of ecclesiastical 
 idolatry and hysterical materialism, regarding as 
 beyond present cavil the vast multitude of the 
 so-called Free Churches, and considering only the 
 form of religion hitherto chosen by the State for 
 self-expression, since, for those of us who are 
 Anglicans, criticism should begin at home, we 
 have the three labelled companies within the visible 
 national shrine, too often more desirous of keeping 
 34 
 
THS SOUL OF THS TSOTLS 
 
 their own phylacteries intact than of realising 
 that eternal fraternity in the universal Father- 
 hood, to which the Founder of their religion 
 sought to redeem the souls and bodies of men. 
 
 Everywhere, both within and without the 
 Church, there are good men and true who lay 
 down their lives daily for the faith that rules their 
 conduct through the Spirit of Truth. But not 
 the less is it certain that the tares still grow 
 among the wheat, sown by the Power that walks 
 in darkness and delights to scatter maleficent seed 
 wherever there are divisions and wranglings within 
 the sacred precincts. And therefore is it still pain- 
 fully evident that each of the three controversial 
 groups within the consecrated edifice seeks eagerly 
 to legalise its own exclusive interpretation of the 
 great charter, and is too much occupied in pro- 
 claiming that it is not as other men to have time 
 for that ever-present kingdom into which none 
 may enter save through the doorways of love. 
 Ail alike are guilty of the same primary mistake, 
 whether it be those of us who demand above all 
 else the externals of a beautiful and ancient 
 symbolism, as a witness to that divine Self-sacrifice 
 in which the veriest "Low Churchman" does, 
 though he would find for it some other form of 
 expression, in his heart devoutly believe ; or those 
 who ask chiefly for legalised freedom and a faith 
 that lives by works ; or those who, in their eager- 
 ness to glorify what has come to them through 
 the crude formula of an illiterate age, forget how 
 the mystery of sacrificial redemption and the un- 
 speakable humility of Love, may be blasphemed 
 
 35 
 
OF 
 
 and distorted by the inadequacy of crude language, 
 or by the squalid forms of an irreverent familiarity. 
 "High," and "Broad" and "Low" alike lose 
 sight too often of that height and breadth and 
 depth of the Divine Love to which all alike 
 should witness, and through whose power all 
 social and religious progress must ever proceed. 
 If they really believed, as they think they believe, 
 that the Divine Spirit is present in the Church to 
 guide into all Truth, then they would fear no 
 multiplicity of opinion, no variety of intellectual 
 belief, in a Church that would be unmistakable in 
 its ethical unity and would find ample expression 
 in the simple yet mystic sacraments of the Water 
 and Bread and Wine. If, cleaving the wood, we 
 find the Eternal there, and partaking of the broken 
 loaf we find Him present also in that symbol of 
 our fellowship with the whole family in heaven 
 and earth, and, bowing our heart to that cup of 
 sorrow which is the privilege of our common 
 humanity, we share in His sacred chalice, can we 
 not forego the petty and vulgar clamour which 
 seeks to prescribe to other citizens of the Holy 
 City the precise shape of their vesture or the suit- 
 able ritual for their communion ? 
 
 Can we not trust all details to the informing 
 and inspiring Spirit ? Must we fetter the Body 
 that we name His temple, lest superstition should 
 creep in, or Truth should walk waywardly, or 
 Love should fall to baseness ? 
 
 There was One, the son of a Jewish peasant 
 maiden, who, when He was asked how and where 
 men should worship, discovered to His questioners 
 
 36 
 
me SOUL OF rne 
 
 His true Divinity when He answered : " God is 
 a Spirit, and they that worship Him must worship 
 Him in spirit and in truth." 
 
 He was right who taught that men will receive as 
 
 much of the Divine Life as they are able to receive 
 
 neither less nor more ; and what is true of the 
 
 individual soul must be true also of that corporate 
 
 fellowship which history has named the Ecclesia. 
 
 But that will best be attained by absolute free- 
 dom of religious teaching in accordance with the 
 wish of each child's parents, giving to each religious 
 or " secularist " contingent in the great army the 
 choice of its own teachers, the control, by that 
 section of the people and for that section of the 
 people, of its own religious or ethical teaching, 
 while securing under the popular control of the 
 whole united kingdom the intellectual and physical 
 efficiency of each. 
 
 The highest and most vital unity, both in the 
 realm of what we call "Nature "and in the world 
 of human affairs, is correlative with expansion, 
 development, complexity. Uniformity, on the 
 other hand, is always deadening and retrograde in 
 its influence. In national education in imperial 
 education there can be no fundamental and pro- 
 gressive unity which does not include perfect free- 
 dom of diversity and rest upon absolute equality 
 of opportunity. No Education Bill and no new 
 Rubric can be of enduring value unless this double 
 condition be fulfilled. 
 
 Of this at least we may be certain, that if a day 
 ever come in which Christianity in Church and 
 State shall have ceased all useless wrangling and 
 
 37 
 
s OF 
 
 morbid self-analysis, and, like her Master, shall 
 have given herself up entirely to feeding and 
 healing, educating and redeeming, the bodies and 
 the souls of men, in that day degeneration and 
 deterioration will be stayed at their source and we 
 shall see new heavens and a new earth. 
 
LOAVES 
 
 TO THE LOAF-MAKER 
 
 BY A SONG-MAKER 
 
 [The Archbishop [of York] . . . mentioned that he was 
 very much touched the other day by receiving from a 
 journeyman baker towards the building of a church in his 
 parish the sum of $oo, the savings of a lifetime, along 
 with a letter in which he said he gave the amount as a 
 small thank-offering for the benefits God had given him ever 
 since his baptism* YORKSHIRE POST, April 21, 1910.] 
 
 OH, my brother, my brother, I would I could do 
 
 as much ! 
 
 Every day thro* the heat and stress 
 You made your loaves for the Lord to bless 
 
 Loaves you could see and touch 
 To feed the hungry or help the faint, 
 Bring needed life to sinner and saint, 
 Like the sun, who thro' all the journey's 
 
 length 
 To the just and the unjust giveth strength ! 
 
 Oh, my brother, my brother, I would I had always 
 
 made 
 
 At daily cost of the oven's heat 
 Such holy loaves for the folk to eat 
 
 Served as the Master bade 
 Still counting even the counter-pelf 
 A trust from the Lord of Life Himself, 
 And feeding the folk with the best of good 
 Made quick in the fires of brotherhood ! 
 
 39 
 
OF 
 
 Oh, I have striven, have striven, to earn my right 
 
 to my bread, 
 
 Were it only to lift with joyful song 
 The bitter days that should make men strong, 
 
 Or give, in love's own stead, 
 A call to battle, a passing breath 
 Of courage and hope in face of death ! 
 I made the loaves, but the loaves were few, 
 And I often failed, as the Master knew. 
 
 You, my brother, my brother, were crowned with 
 
 a ceaseless toil, 
 
 Till out of your faithful, labouring life 
 The furnace flush of your oven-strife 
 
 You won a thrifty spoil, 
 You, who have laid on the altar-stone 
 A double gift for the Lord to own 
 The daily bread that is life-bread good, 
 And the Bread of the Spirit's Brotherhood ! 
 
 You who have fed men's bodies to work the will 
 
 of the soul 
 
 Faithfully serving, won in the end 
 To helping the soul itself, my friend, 
 
 The body's life to control, 
 Soul-hunger's agony to redress, 
 And man with the Bread of Life to bless, 
 So heartening singers, who with bent head, 
 Have wrought, in the mills of God, man's 
 bread. 
 
 40 
 
THE CHILDREN OF THE STATE* 
 
 THE wise care of the children of the State is a duty 
 beyond all party question, and the conciliatory, 
 statesmanlike energy of the State Children's Aid 
 Association will do much to strengthen the hands 
 of men on both sides of the House in any measures 
 of reform which come before Parliament touching 
 this great and perplexing responsibility. Among 
 our Poor Law Guardians are men and women 
 whose self-denial and devotion put to shame many 
 of their critics ; but Guardians cannot move in 
 advance of the national verdict, and it is a part 
 of the work of this society to enlighten unofficial 
 opinion. 
 
 If we understand the Association aright, more 
 individual care for the children of the State is 
 the very heart of its contention more home-life, 
 with all its variety of give and take and rough and 
 smooth; less of that safe, machine-like, inflexible 
 institution-routine, which, from its very per- 
 fection and inevitableness, deadens character, 
 crushes spontaneity, and injures health. Courage, 
 resource, originality what chance is there of 
 these where childhood is governed in the aggre- 
 gate and humanity is adjusted to the average ? 
 What though the great and tender humourist 
 who wrote " Oliver Twist " has taught this over 
 and over again with tragic and reiterated emphasis ? 
 
 * A portion of an article which appeared in the Guardian 
 in April 1898. 
 
 41 
 
OF 
 
 Unhappily it needs to be hammered at still, in- 
 cluding as it does the other terrible truism that 
 in such a uniformity of process it is usually the 
 finest nature that suffers most. On the other 
 hand, if ordinary children need constant and dis- 
 cerning care, how much more the children who 
 are born into the world with a physique weakened 
 by parental poverty or vice, even when the character 
 bears no hereditary taint of parental feebleness 
 or despair. 
 
 Education, while reckoning with heredity, may 
 often take courage from the possibility of a healthy 
 atavism, and seek to evoke the moral beauty of 
 some forgotten ancestor, if the nearer forebears 
 have been less promising. Nor dare we forget 
 that in the most unattractive child there is ever 
 latent the divine ideal of the unseen angel. And 
 yet once more, it cannot be too often repeated, 
 in regard to much that is most tender and lovely 
 in the earliest unfolding of human identity, that 
 the more delicate and sensitive it is, the more 
 easily may it be smitten and warped ; so that it is 
 likely to be precisely those children whose future 
 citizenship might have most enriched the State 
 with noble refinement and subtle wisdom who, if 
 bred up in huge institutions, will, for the term of 
 their mortal life, be stunted and debased by the 
 necessarily unvarying commonplaces formalised 
 to meet the requirements not of the particular 
 child, but of a whole herd of children. If any 
 objector reply that nothing is so healthy as the 
 normal and the commonplace, that is but an 
 evasion after all. It might indeed have force if 
 42 
 
rns CHii/De$ OF me 
 
 originality were, as in the gospel of the Decadent, 
 merely synonymous with unreality and morbidity ; 
 but no one who cares for children with a love 
 which gives insight can escape the feeling that 
 childhood, even when it is most normal and 
 vigorous, is, in its very buoyancy and simplicity, 
 full of ever new surprises of individual charm. 
 Alas ! charm is not the word associated in any 
 memory with that name, in itself a brand, which 
 is happily being banished from the tongue of 
 decency, now that the undeserved and unasked 
 burden of dependent poverty no longer labels as 
 a " pauper " that " child of the State " who, like 
 every other child ever born into this wicked world, 
 is also a "child of God." Instead of the old 
 " pauper spirit," which was only another word for 
 apathy, we want, by means of home life, to develop 
 in every child more of that vigour and strenuous 
 personality of which. Chapman wrote so bravely : 
 
 " A spirit that on life's rough sea 
 Loves to have his sails fill'd with a lusty wind, 
 Even till his sail-yards tremble, his masts crack, 
 And his rapt ship run on her side so low 
 That she drinks water, and her keel ploughs air. 
 There is no danger to a man that knows 
 What life and death is." 
 
 43 
 
SNOWDROP-TIME 
 
 The author wishes to acknowledge her debt, since she wrote 
 these lines when haunted by "E. Nisbcfs " beautiful poem 
 " Little Brown Brother" 
 
 66 IT'S rather dark in the earth to-day," 
 
 Said one little bulb to his brother ; 
 
 " But I thought that I felt a sunbeam ray 
 
 We must strive and grow till we find the way ! " 
 
 And they nestled close to each other. 
 
 Then they struggled and toiled by day and by 
 
 night, 
 
 Till two little snowdrops, in green and white, 
 Rose out of the darkness and into the light, 
 And softly kissed one another. 
 
 44 
 
DAFFODILS 
 
 IT is a late spring, but one flower has sprung up 
 and blossomed with fairy-like rapidity first the 
 blade, then the bud, after that the full flower in 
 the sun. It is here, not singly, but in troops and 
 companies. In the avenue to the great beautiful 
 house hard by, it stars the turf on either hand in 
 wild, unstudied profusion, though more resplendent 
 on that side of it which is sheltered from the east 
 wind than on those other levels where the cutting 
 north-easter blows. In our own cottage gardens 
 the bright yellow blossoms are already gay. They 
 seem to bring incarnate sunshine into the wintry 
 borders the one bit of colour that can rival in 
 its brilliance the glorious red and pink of japonica 
 and ribes, starring with gold the dull garden- 
 beds, under the windows and 
 
 " beneath the trees, 
 Fluttering and dancing in the breeze." 
 
 They laugh for joy, and justify Wordsworth's 
 epithet of " jocund " as their inevitable right and 
 title. They were barely in time this year to 
 
 " take the winds of March with beauty 
 Before the swallow dares," 
 
 but the April showers are much to their liking, 
 and indeed it is in the " Shepheard's Calendar " for 
 April that Spenser bids us 
 
 45 
 
OF 
 
 " Strowe the ground with daffadowndillies, 
 And cowslips, and kingcups, and loued lillies." 
 
 Did not Broome write long ago : 
 
 " The joyous spring draws nigh ! Ambrosial 
 
 showers 
 
 Unbind the earth, the earth unbinds the flowers, 
 The flowers blow sweet, the daffodils unfold 
 The spreading glories of their blooming gold '' ? 
 
 That they have always made merry " beside the 
 margin of a lake/' Spenser had noted long before 
 the days of Wordsworth, for he tells us that when 
 news was brought to the mother of Marianell that 
 Britomart had killed him, the messenger found her 
 
 " Among her watry sisters by a pond, 
 Gathering sweete daffadillyes, to have made 
 Gay girlonds from the Sun their forheads fayr 
 to shade." 
 
 Old Richardson gives many spellings of this 
 flower's name a name which seems at first to 
 have been daffadils : through the French Aspodille 
 and the Italian Asphodelo he traces back to the 
 Greek Ao-^o&Ao?. 
 
 The old daffadil spelling recalls at once 
 Constable's charming song, of which the first two 
 verses run : 
 
 " Diaphenia, like the daffa-down-dilly, 
 White as the sunne, faire as the lilly, 
 
 Heigh ho, how I doe love thee ! 
 I doe love thee as my lambs 
 Are beloved of their dams, 
 
 How blest were I if thou would'st prove me ! 
 46 
 
" Diaphenia, like the spreading roses, 
 That in thy sweetes all sweetes encloses, 
 
 Faire sweet how I doe love thee ! 
 I doe love thee as each flower 
 Loves the sunne's life-giving power. 
 
 For dead, thy breath to life might move me." 
 
 Was it that white and gold are the Easter 
 colours and splendour was a part of the transient 
 pomp of Death, the divine messenger, or was it 
 a healthy delight in its very mirthfulness a sense 
 of tragic contrast, mingling with the glowing joy 
 of hope, that made the older poets not infrequently 
 strew this flower of sunshine above the beloved 
 dust of their dead ? In a pastoral masque by 
 Hughes we find the lines : 
 
 " On his lovely body shower 
 
 Leaves of roses, virgin lilies, 
 Cowslips, violets, daffodillies, 
 And with garlands dress the bower." 
 
 And does not Milton 
 
 " Bid amarantus all his beauty shed, 
 And daffadillies fill their cups with tears, 
 To strow the laureat herse where Lycid lies " ? 
 
 Our later poet T. E. Brown, in writing of the 
 death of a child, touches a simpler and perhaps 
 more modern note: 
 
 " O God, to Thee I yield 
 
 The gift Thou givest most precious, most divine ! 
 Yet to what field 
 I must resign 
 
 47 
 
His little feet 
 
 That wont to be so fleet, 
 
 I muse. O, joy to think 
 
 On what soft brink 
 
 Of flood he plucks the daffodils, 
 
 On what empurpled hills 
 
 He stands, Thy kiss all fresh upon his brow, 
 
 And wonders, if his father sees him now ! " 
 
 But indeed every spring garland intertwines 
 the flower of love with the secret promise of some 
 far-off goal. 
 
 "The dusky strand of death enwoven here 
 With true Love's tie, makes Love himself more 
 dear " ; 
 
 and if even the pagan Eros seemed, though but 
 
 " a trifler gay, 
 
 The prodigal of an immortal day 
 For ever spending, and yet never spent,'' 
 
 the great living poet who wrote that fine descrip- 
 tion of him wrote also : 
 
 " For what is Beauty, if it doth not fire 
 The loving answer of an eager soul ? 
 Since 'tis the native food of man's desire, 
 And doth to good our varying world control ; 
 Which, when it was not, was for Beauty's sake 
 Desired and made by Love, who still doth make 
 A beauteous path thereon to Beauty's goal." 
 
THE FEEDING OF NECESSITOUS 
 SCHOOL-CHILDREN 
 
 [ Lunacy is rapidly increasing ; poverty does not lessen ; while 
 degeneracy and crime have got entirely beyond control. 
 We are very near a precipice^ requiring only a " heave- 
 over" to go to pieces. ALBERT WILSON, M.D., " Edu- 
 cation, Personality, and Crime."] 
 
 THE virtuous person who refuses to undermine 
 parental responsibility by feeding necessitous 
 school-children forgets that we have already in- 
 terfered with parental responsibility by compel- 
 ling thousands of fathers and mothers to send 
 their children to school, whether they wish it or 
 not, and that having done this it is at least our 
 clear duty to take care that no slow murder or 
 mutilation result. There is an overwhelming 
 mass of evidence to prove that these terrible con- 
 sequences have not infrequently ensued where 
 undeveloped brain-machinery has been at the 
 same time whipped up and starved. The dis- 
 tinguished author of " Education, Personality, and 
 Crime," himself a physician who has had twenty- 
 five years of wide experience, writes that a we 
 are killing mentally and physically hundreds and 
 thousands of [these] our best national assets. . . . 
 The compulsion to attend school tells very heavily 
 on the starving poor, and the injury to the badly 
 nourished and defective children spells ruin for 
 their future careers. . . . Thousands of children 
 are growing up with slightly damaged brains, who 
 attract no special notice from the casual observer. 
 It is, however, just the little damage, sometimes 
 
 D 49 
 
OF 
 
 curable, which turns the scale against an indi- 
 vidual in the struggle for existence. ... If the 
 child be starved, delicate, or neurotic, the State 
 inflicts untold mental suffering and injury, which 
 may wreck the future career, and even thereby 
 make criminals. ... It is as hopeless to expect 
 mentation and brain development from a starving 
 child as to move the Cornish express if there is 
 no fuel underneath the engine boiler." 
 
 The writer of this grave indictment is not a 
 sentimentalist. He boldly advocates eugenic re- 
 form of a very stringent character, and cuts clean 
 through a great many fanciful cobwebs. Nor, on 
 the other hand, does he share the dogmatism of a 
 crude agnostic denial ; for he remarks that " to 
 deny the influence of the Spirit on mind and 
 character is to limit science." 
 
 But he does not disguise the fact that our 
 present manufacture of criminals and lunatics is a 
 wasteful folly, in which the overpressure of ill- 
 nourished bodies plays a part so disastrous as to 
 need quite as much attention as ethical neglect or 
 the multiplication of the feeble-minded and the 
 unfit by means of ill-advised marriages. Nay, he 
 even goes so far as to say that "it seems as if 
 environment were more important than heredity 
 in the life of the individual." He tells us that, 
 although in his opinion there are to be found 
 among the poor some of the finest potentialities 
 of the race, yet among the boys in prison many 
 of them only sixteen "a great amount of de- 
 terioration in face and form is to be seen . . . 
 malnutrition is their ruin'' 
 
 5 
 
rne FSSVI^G OF 
 
 This assertion with regard to malnutrition he 
 supports with striking and detailed figures in 
 regard to the under weight of boys in reformatories, 
 where the unsatisfactory boys were progressively 
 subnormal in weight as compared with the "good" 
 ones. It has been shown by careful facts and 
 diagrams in the book already quoted that the 
 most important part of the brain, that " pyramidal 
 layer of the prefrontal," of which Shaw Bolton 
 has spoken as " the last to develop " and " the 
 region concerned with the general orderly co- 
 ordination of psychic processes," is incomplete at 
 birth and may be only gradually built up when the 
 child is well nourished and cared for. If young 
 children are so ill-nourished during education as 
 to leave this " master of the house " of thought 
 in infantile incapacity, it is not only they who will 
 suffer ; the agony may fall upon their children's 
 children in ever-increasing ratio. If we make it 
 illegal for the poor to withdraw exceptionally 
 sensitive and fragile children from public edu- 
 cation, it is no mere charity to lessen the risk 
 by insisting on proper food, but, on the contrary, 
 an act of bare justice. For let it always be re- 
 membered that instruction is but a small part of 
 education education is the evoking and unfolding 
 of all that is highest and best in the whole nature, 
 body and soul, as well as mind, and is not the out- 
 come of mental processes alone. 
 
 Without entering on controversial ground 
 regarding the Majority and Minority Reports, it 
 may be worth while to answer one statement, in 
 a leaflet now lying before me, which urges against 
 
 5' 
 
OF 
 
 the present methods of feeding school-children that 
 an increase in pauperisation is indicated by the 
 greatly increased number of free meals during the 
 iforegoing year there estimated as an advance 
 from 4,546,771 to 7.702,506. 
 
 In reply, there are two obvious facts which may 
 be incisively urged. 
 
 In the first place, this feeding of necessitous 
 children, where, as at Bradford, it is supported out 
 of the rates working out at \d. in the pound does 
 but fulfil in another form the obligation of the 
 Guardians to permit no starvation, in accordance 
 with a statute now embodied and strengthened in 
 the Children's Act, a statute to which attention 
 was drawn by the late Rev. B. Waugh, who 
 emphasised its bearing on prevailing conditions by 
 a gruesome story of seven children at Swindon 
 who were dying under the very nose of the 
 relieving officer. By means of the Children's 
 Care Committees, which include much voluntary 
 help of an expert and humane order, the tendency 
 of public meals under a competent Education 
 Authority is to bring careless parents to their 
 duty and increase their sense of responsibility. 
 At Bradford, for instance, in the year ending 
 March 31, 1909, there were 194 parents paying 
 full cost, besides an average of 67 children each 
 day purchasing tickets at full price ; and 59 
 parents paying part of the cost, the total number 
 of individual children coming within this category 
 throughout the year being 610. 
 
 The statistics there show that, after deducting 
 rent, the income per head of the 5 182 persons, in 
 52 
 
rne FSSVI^G OF 
 
 the households sending children to the free meals, 
 only amounted to is. ^\d. (presumably per week), 
 and that is not an allowance on which any child can 
 be properly clothed and nourished, at a time when 
 the growing brain is especially in need of sustenance. 
 That more children are fed means, therefore, that 
 there is less destructive starvation, less public and 
 private neglect, more compulsion of lazy or greedy 
 parents to do some small part at least of their duty. 
 
 Secondly, even more stress must be laid upon 
 the fact that the maintenance and restraint of 
 criminals and unemployables is a more expensive 
 item to the country than free meals in our midst. 
 Estimating our criminal population on Dr. Albert 
 Wilson's figures at 150,000 and the number of 
 lads passing yearly through our prisons at 16,000, 
 it only remains to be reiterated that in the opinion 
 of this expert, as well as in that of Dr. Arkle, 
 want of nutrition while at school is one chief cause 
 of degeneracy and crime. 
 
 With regard to girls, the plea is even more 
 urgent, for they are in a special sense the custodians 
 of the future, and if by overpressure and under- 
 feeding we overstrain or atrophy their capacity 
 for what Browning finely named "the Trust of 
 trusts," then we may expect physical deterioration 
 to go on apace. The study of the facts recently 
 tabulated will show that such deterioration is 
 already dangerously rapid, and in speaking on 
 this subject of child-degeneration it has been 
 well said by one well-known neurologist that 
 our Empire is bleeding to death at its heart. 
 Religious effort does somewhat staunch the wound, 
 
 53 
 
s OF 
 
 but there is tragedy in the position of many a 
 young life, thrown upon the world with an affec- 
 tionate nature and right aspirations, yet either a 
 " born tired," to quote one doctor's nomenclature, 
 or one of those unfortunates to whom apply the 
 same doctor's terrible words regarding arrested 
 brain development through lack of nourishment, 
 when he writes that " the will is to them as a 
 withered plant that might have developed, but 
 has died of starvation soon after birth." 
 
 Are thousands of our young lives to find this 
 their fate, or shall we realise in time that, if the 
 State has a right to punish, the State has also a right 
 to protect, and to use, under official guidance and 
 organisation, the help of all those skilled.volunteers, 
 women as well as men, who are experts in education 
 and in social amelioration and have escaped the 
 cramping influence of lives bound up in red tape ? 
 
 Shall we be content that English children, and 
 their children after them, shall in ever-increasing 
 ratio degenerate and decline, or shall we do our 
 best that they may become what Mr. Robert 
 Bridges has so finely imaged for us in his poem 
 entitled "The Fair Brass 7 *: 
 
 " Heirs of our antique shrines, 
 Sires of our future fame, 
 Whose starry honour shines 
 In many a noble name 
 
 " Across the deathful days, 
 Link'd in the brotherhood 
 That loves our country's praise, 
 And lives for heavenly good." 
 54 
 
THYRSIS IN A LONDON SQUARE 
 
 IT is that " sweet season " beloved of Chaucer and 
 of all the poets, the beginning of the blossoming 
 time which Matthew Arnold has associated for 
 all lovers of " Thyrsis " with Oxford and with 
 Clough. 
 
 Browning's lines descriptive of the cuckoo's 
 music have become classic, but, even while we 
 quote them, to some of us the thought of a very 
 different poet is present, one less robust, less opti- 
 mistic, with more of the minor third in his voice, 
 yet, like Browning, a lover of men, one who faced 
 all doubts with guileless sincerity, and drew his 
 daily inspiration of help and comfort for the human 
 brotherhood from the " only Source of all our 
 light and life." Who can hear 
 
 " the word 
 In a minor third 
 There is none but the cuckoo knows," 
 
 without thinking of that " quick despairer," of 
 whom the cuckoo was to Matthew Arnold the 
 symbol, who vanished too soon from our midst 
 before the promise of the golden year had un- 
 folded to his sight, and while still his heart was 
 aching at the thought of human inequalities ? 
 
 " Some life of men unblest 
 He knew, which made him droop, and fill'd his 
 head. 
 
 55 
 
OF 
 
 He went; his piping took a troubled sound 
 Of storms that rage outside our happy ground ; 
 He could not wait their passing, he is dead. 
 
 " So have I heard the cuckoo's parting cry, 
 
 From the wet field, through the vext garden- 
 trees, 
 .Come with the volleying rain and tossing 
 
 breeze : 
 The bloom is gone and with the bloom go I ! 
 
 " Too quick despairer, wherefore wilt thou go ? 
 Soon will the high Midsummer pomps come 
 
 on, 
 Soon will the musk carnations break and 
 
 swell, 
 
 Soon shall we have gold-dusted snapdragon, 
 Sweet-William with his homely cottage- 
 smell, 
 
 And stocks in fragrant blow ; 
 Roses that down the alleys shine afar, 
 And open, jasmine-muffled lattices, 
 And groups under the dreaming garden- 
 trees, 
 And the full moon, and the white, evening star." 
 
 For us to-day the hedges are still white, and new 
 fronds of fern are still uncrumpling 
 
 "And blue-bells trembling by the forest ways." 
 
 We have not come yet to the " scent of hay new- 
 mown," but already we see the approach of that 
 
 56 
 
" tempestuous morn in early June, 
 When the year's primal burst of bloom is o'er, 
 
 Before the roses and the longest day 
 When garden-walks, and all the grassy floor, 
 With blossoms red and white of fallen May, 
 And chestnut-flowers are strewn." 
 
 The chestnut-flowers are for us but now be- 
 
 ? inning to fade and the may to fall. London in 
 une is wont to gleam with a strange beauty. 
 Full at all times of a deep and tragic poetry, for a 
 brief space she puts on a wreath of joyous promise 
 that wafts its fragrance hither and thither into her 
 darkest and most poverty-stricken corners, on the 
 wings of a liberal, wide-reaching spring breeze that 
 dips into parks and squares for the healthy sweet- 
 ness that it carries for a moment into squalid 
 streets and sordid alleys. 
 
 One of the loveliest of dough's lyrics, " In a 
 London Square," is said to have been suggested by 
 a tree in Berkeley Square. It fits the season well, 
 and it breathes of a certain hard-won and gentle 
 fortitude, very characteristic of Clough, who, in 
 his sensitiveness to every vagrant sympathy and 
 every influence of his stormy and perplexed century, 
 blent as it was with a strenuous determination to 
 be true to his own individual sense of right and of 
 truth, was necessarily a man of sorrows. 
 
 The plane-tree, with its daintily fashioned tassels 
 and wide, cool leaves, grows well in the midst of 
 all the smoke and care and struggle of sad-hearted, 
 fain-to-be-gay, paradoxical London ; shares its 
 rainbow sunshine and sudden gleams of springtide, 
 
 57 
 
s OF 
 
 and, to those who know the lyric, echoes ever the 
 admonition to a patient and hopeful self-restraint : 
 
 "Put forth thy leaf, thou lofty plane, 
 
 East wind and frost are safely gone ; 
 With zephyr mild and balmy rain 
 
 The summer comes serenely on ; 
 Earth, air, and sun, and skies combine 
 
 To promise all that's kind and fair : 
 But thou, O human heart of mine, 
 
 Be still, contain thyself, and bear. 
 
 December days were brief and chill, 
 
 The winds of March were wild and drear, 
 And, nearing and receding still, 
 
 Spring never would, we thought, be here. 
 The leaves that burst, the suns that shine, 
 
 Had, not the less, their certain date : 
 And thou, O human heart of mine, 
 
 Be still, refrain thyself, and wait." 
 That is one side of Clough, but we find in him 
 the verve and energy also which breathe through 
 those other lines of his : 
 
 " Go from the east to the west, as the sun and the 
 
 stars direct thee, 
 Go with the girdle of man, go and encompass 
 
 the earth. 
 Not for the gain of the gold ; for the getting, the 
 
 hoarding, the having, 
 
 But for the joy of the deed ; but for the Duty to do. 
 Go with the spiritual life, the higher volition and 
 
 action, 
 With the great girdle of God, go and encompass 
 
 the earth." 
 58 
 
That impulse of world-wide service and un- 
 grudging gifts may well be echoing through many 
 obscure lives to-day in the after-glow of those 
 celebrations of " Empire Day" which we have 
 dedicated to the memory of England's greatest 
 Queen and to the recollection of those vast and 
 humbling responsibilities which unite the Mother 
 Country with her colonies. The way to righteous- 
 ness and peace is often a strait and difficult path, 
 where it is only too easy to be blinded by our own 
 arrogance, or trapped by our own prejudice. The 
 message of joy, of progress, of universal kinship, 
 has too often been stained, and torn, and debased. 
 It has been blotted by many tears and marred by 
 many cancellings. But Clough was right in those 
 last words he wrote when he bade us remember 
 that every noble effort avails, though its results 
 may be to our own eyes and those of our own 
 generation invisible. Every advancing wave falls 
 back a little. Every year has its winter, but in 
 the new beauty and resurrection of each year's 
 springtide there is ever a symbol of that 
 
 " far-off divine event, 
 To which the whole creation moves." 
 
 And the last word remembered to-day shall be 
 from the lips of Thyrsis, found in a pencilled line 
 or two beneath his pillow when he died : 
 
 " For while the tired waves, vainly breaking, 
 
 Seem here no painful inch to gain, 
 Far back, through creeks and inlets making, 
 Comes silent, flooding in, the main." 
 
 59 
 
THE MEMORIAL TO 
 MRS. BROWNING 
 
 IT has been said that we are a nation of shop- 
 keepers, though the shopkeeper will naturally 
 reply that he may be as noble as any man. But 
 it may be asserted with juster poignancy that too 
 many of our so-called leaders are now a company 
 of fashion-mongers, who are constantly running 
 after some new mode of thought or novel literary 
 type, leaving the stolid majority to take out their 
 moral and intellectual tape-measures for the 
 purpose of testing conformity with what may be 
 called the ancient sartorial rule of thumb, while 
 a small, rather youthful, contingent cut out old 
 ethics to suit new conventions, and, in their own 
 estimation, sanctify folly itself with the sacred 
 word " advanced." 
 
 Fifty years after Mrs. Browning's death, among 
 the slaves to passing fashion, she was already out 
 of fashion. There seems to have been a difficulty 
 in collecting the required funds for the Ledbury 
 Memorial in her honour. It is true that her 
 noblest memorial lives in the hearts of that vast 
 unliterary throng described in our Authorised 
 Version as " the common people " ; and also 
 in the work of the great poet-theologian, whose 
 influence was the more masculine from the fact 
 that he was too passionate to be sentimental, too 
 many-sided to forget the claims of this homely 
 human life of ours, even when most absorbed in 
 60 
 
TO 
 
 the eternal problems, and who wrote of his own 
 proudest achievement : 
 
 " If the rough ore be rounded to a ring, 
 Render all duty which good ring should do, 
 And, failing grace, succeed in guardianship, 
 Might mine but lie outside thine, Lyric Love, 
 Thy rare gold ring of verse (the poet praised) 
 Linking our England to his Italy ! " 
 
 The " posy " to that ring is too well known to 
 need quoting, and he must indeed be dull of ear 
 who does not feel the passionate music of the 
 opening lines : 
 
 " Oh, Lyric Love, half-angel and half-bird, 
 And all a wonder and a wild desire," 
 
 but it is not in these haunting lines, nor in the 
 last words of "Prospice," nor the married melo- 
 dies of " By the Fireside/' that Mrs. Browning's 
 influence is most coercive and penetrating for the 
 outside world, nor even, perhaps, in the "One 
 Word More." It is rather in the whole fabric and 
 texture of Browning's later work, and especially 
 of that marvellous poem of which Pompilia is the 
 light and joy. 
 
 No one who knows Mrs. Browning's " Aurora 
 Leigh " intimately will be likely to come to any 
 real intimacy also with the poems Browning 
 wrote after his marriage, and especially " The 
 Ring and the Book," without a sense of deeply 
 wedded kinship here and there between the two. 
 
 There is a delightful line of George Meredith's 
 in which he speaks of certain kinds of song as 
 
OF 7*]{pse 
 
 free from "taint of personality." That certainly 
 cannot be said of either of the Brownings. In 
 spite of his wide range and extraordinary diversity 
 of subjects, the author of " Bishop Blougram " 
 and " Rabbi Ben Ezra " is everywhere unmistak- 
 able : and in almost all his multitudinous poems 
 his robust and salient personality is recognisable 
 at a glance. That of Elizabeth Barrett, even 
 before they were man and wife, had probably 
 touched his mind and heart the more poignantly 
 because of a vivid and delicate, and almost over- 
 balancing, emotional quality in it, which might 
 well seem opposed to Browning's own more 
 reticent and humorous storm and stress, though 
 both are distinguished by the like vitality or 
 enthusiasm, the like catholic open-mindedness 
 and unbaffled reverence. In both there is the 
 same boldly questioning yet entirely unswerving 
 faith, the same untiring affection for man as man, 
 the same sense of the sacredness of the body as 
 well as the soul, the same worshipping delight in 
 the beauty of ideal womanhood, the same un- 
 conquerable belief, so finely expressed in " Aurora 
 Leigh," that 
 
 " Earth's crammed with heaven, 
 And every common bush afire with God/' 
 
 And, it may be added, the same humour to 
 perceive that 
 
 " Only he who sees, takes off his shoes ; 
 The rest sit round it and pluck blackberries." 
 
 Of that poem which Ruskin is said to have 
 62 
 
ro <MI{S. 
 
 named as the greatest of his century benighted 
 Philistines have occasionally asserted that it is 
 * coarse." Such people, if they met the Angel of 
 Pity, radiant with divine fire and beauty, would 
 merely complain that it was indecent of him to 
 go barefoot. They need to be reminded, through 
 the lips of Mrs. Browning herself, that what they 
 consider the " coarsest " part of this wonderful 
 life of ours is sacred and vital until the divine 
 breath is withdrawn from it : 
 
 " Flower from root, 
 
 And spiritual from natural, grade by grade 
 In all our life. A handful of the earth, 
 To make God's image ! the despised poor earth, 
 The healthy odorous earth, I missed with it 
 The divine Breath that blows the nostrils out 
 To ineffable afflatus, ay, the breath 
 Which love is. Art is much, but love is more. 
 
 Art symbolises heaven, but Love is God 
 And makes heaven." 
 
 Mrs. Browning did her work so well that her 
 truths have become our truisms. We are, after 
 all, an ungrateful host. In all social reform we 
 have adopted her ideas so completely that half of 
 us forget they are hers. In a bygone day, when 
 courage was needed, this modest and brave 
 woman, out of the deep joy of her own happy 
 love and ideal marriage, took to herself the out- 
 cast and forgotten, and, in the power" of her great 
 poem, moved a smug and pharisaical world to 
 rescue the fallen, to redeem the poor, and to face 
 
 63 
 
OF 
 
 with some degree of honesty social problems 
 which had been selfishly ignored. 
 
 Let it be once more conceded without hesitation 
 that her best memorial lives on in her husband's 
 work and in her own, and in that change in 
 the theology and social ethics of England, a 
 change that might almost be called a revolu- 
 tion, in which both the Brownings have had a 
 deeper share than is ordinarily recognised. But 
 when the country of her birth is asked for a 
 visible token of gratitude it were shameful to 
 haggle about the price or complain that there is no 
 money in the national purse. We are a cold and 
 stolid people, and occasionally it is to be feared 
 that the slowness of emotion, which we secretly 
 vaunt as indication of faithfulness, does not by 
 any means stand the test of adversity and of time, 
 so that it is not wonderful that Mrs. Browning- 
 was sometimes angry with England in the deep 
 wrath of wounded affection. There are certain 
 lines in her " Summing up in Italy (inscribed to 
 intelligent publics out of it) " which hit us hard 
 in our moods of political selfishness and cowardice. 
 Even in remembrance and in constancy we seem 
 to have fallen behind "her Italy." Long ago 
 the municipality of Florence placed on Casa 
 Guidi their noble memorial to Elizabeth Barrett 
 Browning, of whom they wrote there, in the 
 words of Tommaseo, "Che in cuore di donna 
 conciliave scienze di dotto, e spirito di poeta." 
 We cannot equal the beauty of the Florentine 
 inscription, of which only a fragment is given 
 here. Of her it may be said with truth, as 
 
TO Jti'QS. 
 
 indeed is witnessed by her own words, that "her 
 Christianity was not confined to church and 
 rubrics it meant civilisation." There has been 
 no attempt here at any critical appraisement of 
 Mrs. Browning's precise standing as an artist, 
 though, whatever may be the deductions and 
 admissions demanded by such an appraisement, it 
 is only necessary to remember that she wrote the 
 so-called " Sonnets from the Portuguese " in 
 order to ensure her unassailable place among the 
 poets. But there are many who are careless of 
 poetry and who yet owe her a debt of lasting 
 gratitude for her work in the cause of social and 
 political reform. 
 
A FLOWER FOR MRS. BROWNING'S 
 GRAVE 
 
 THERE is one flower which cannot be laid too often 
 on Mrs. Browning's grave, for it is her husband's 
 own gift. It blooms perennially, and there may 
 well be surprise that there are not more hands tearing 
 down the sprays of blossom to do her honour. 
 
 On this day, the anniversary of her birth, such an 
 offering may well be wreathed about her memory. 
 
 In the many disquisitions on " The Ring and 
 the Book" one subject of deep interest may not 
 impossibly have escaped many of the learned com- 
 mentators, because it is not a point of scholarship, 
 but of elementary human interest. I refer to 
 what I cannot but believe to have been Browning's 
 reason for choosing so extraordinary and terrible 
 a story, as his basis of fact, in the great dramatic 
 poem dedicated to his wife's memory the essential 
 metal in that elaborately wrought " guard ring " 
 wherewith he protected the golden circlet of love 
 and poesy that had claimed his wife in an eternal 
 marriage. 
 
 We have his own explicit authority for his un- 
 bounded admiration of " Aurora Leigh," that 
 dramatic romance in which a happy wife and 
 mother wrote with all the courage of virtue and of 
 love, on behalf of her outcast sisters on the one hand 
 and of her noble ideal of marriage on the other. 
 
 No so-called love was to Mrs. Browning worthy 
 of the name unless it was that supreme and 
 66 
 
irrevocable passion which is of its own nature 
 divine, and therefore divinely pure and enduring 
 and unselfish. But she perceived that, in the out- 
 cry of society against moral debasement and 
 corruption, the vengeance not seldom fell with 
 vulgar and indiscriminating severity on one who 
 was often the victim rather than the culprit, and 
 in the name of the Highest she cast her stainless 
 shield upon the innocent while plunging her fiery 
 sword into the guilty not only those guilty in 
 the eyes of convention, but those guilty of the 
 greedy frivolity, the sanctimonious crookedness, the 
 petty hypocrisies, for which her religion reserved 
 its most scathing denunciation, the immorality not 
 of the " sinner," but of the Pharisee. 
 
 In that old law case recorded by the little yellow 
 book which Browning picked up on the Florentine 
 bookstall, he found just the weapon he wanted 
 for a worthy continuation of her holy crusade ; 
 for the events of which he read there made up a 
 tragedy of blood and fire upon the pages of human 
 history. The murder was an actual murder of 
 the most sanguinary description, the fire was that 
 divine fire which lights the temple of humanity 
 with a Presence more beautiful than anything that 
 can be fully manifested under conditions of time 
 and space. 
 
 Human love was to the Brownings no less ideal 
 in significance than what, in our ignorance, we 
 may assume to have been the symbolism of the 
 sacred flaming rose, in the mystic lore of the Rosi- 
 crucians. Aurora Leigh describes that highest 
 human love as the reflection of divine mystery, 
 
OF 
 
 " Sweet shadow-rose, upon the water of life, 
 Of such a mystic substance, Sharon gave 
 A name to ! human, vital, fructuous rose, 
 Whose calyx holds the multitude of leaves, 
 Loves filial, loves fraternal, neighbour loves, 
 And civic ... all fair petals, all good scents, 
 All reddened, sweetened from one central 
 Heart ! " 
 
 And Pompilia, when she is dying far away from 
 the man from whom she seems to the onlooker to 
 be hopelessly separated, knows well that in so 
 profound a love neither death nor distance can 
 divide, and that even in the life beyond she will 
 feel the comfort of his hand. Neither for him 
 nor for herself does she ask anything more of 
 earth. It is in the face of death that she says : 
 
 " No work begun shall ever pause for death ! 
 Love will be helpful to me more and more 
 F the coming course, the new path I must tread, 
 My weak hand in thy strong hand, strong for 
 
 that! 
 
 Tell him that if I seem without him now, 
 That's the world's insight ! Oh, he under- 
 stands ! 
 
 So let him wait God's instant men call years ; 
 Meantime hold hard by truth and his great soul, 
 Do out the duty ! " 
 
 Browning might well feel and not least in 
 those first years of his bereavement that here 
 indeed was the rosemary which he desired to twine 
 about the beloved name. 
 68 
 
An essay necessarily limited with regard to 
 space does not allow detailed examination of the 
 interweaving thought and feeling which make the 
 hidden pattern, in the very warp and woof of the 
 two poems, such as I hope to indicate more fully 
 elsewhere. 
 
 But the main contention of this brief article is 
 so broad and simple as to appeal even to the pro- 
 verbial " man in the street." Nowhere can it be 
 more fittingly emblazoned than on the pages of a 
 paper devoted to the cares and hopes of the com- 
 monalty, and to the civic interests of a great 
 thronging city like our own. 
 
 The words of Caponsacchi's Shepherd-Judge, 
 when speaking of himself as an ancient gardener 
 who is talking concerning the flowers in his en- 
 closure, the women among whom he exercised his 
 pastoral office, may doubtless be echoed by many 
 a twentieth-century preacher, who finds amonghis 
 gay congregation a less exalted beauty of character 
 than in some low-born injured woman, of whom, 
 it may be, Pompilia was the prototype and fore- 
 runner, while herself the typical successor of Mrs. 
 Browning's daring imaginative conception as em- 
 bodied in Marian Erie, notwithstanding that 
 Pompilia's motherhood had been legalised by a 
 form of marriage, which to her childish ignorance 
 had conveyed no meaning. Marian Erie may 
 have been solely a puppet of the poet's brain ; 
 Pompilia was a living, breathing woman, the 
 creation of that Master from whose hand we all 
 must needs learn 
 
OF 
 
 " Hints of the proper craft, tricks of the tool's 
 true play." 
 
 Yet of both the Angel of the earthly garden might 
 have said, as did the old Pope of Pompilia : 
 
 " Those be the plants, imbedded yonder South 
 To mellow in the morning, those made fat 
 By the master's eye, that yield such timid leaf, 
 Uncertain bud, as product of his pains ! 
 While see how this mere chance-sown, cleft- 
 nursed seed, 
 
 That sprang up by the wayside 'neath the foot 
 Of the enemy, this breaks all into blaze, 
 Spreads itself, one wide glory of desire 
 To incorporate the whole great sun it loves 
 From the inch-height whence it looks and longs ! 
 
 my flower, 
 My rose, I gather for the breast of God." 
 
 Well might Browning say of Pompilia's history 
 that here was a story straight to his hand, for it 
 gave him the very sword and ring and posy 
 wherewith in his wife's name he might strike 
 many a ringing blow at the social corruption 
 which she had fought so nobly on behalf of the 
 defenceless, a fight in which her own unsullied 
 name and ideal love had strengthened the efficacy 
 of her championship. 
 
 Well also might he write of her in his immortal 
 dedication as of one "half-angel and half-bird," 
 who, borne aloft on the wings of divine poetry, 
 was ever ready at the call of suffering or abase- 
 ment to come down to earth 
 
 " To toil for man, to suffer or to die." 
 70 
 
MRS. BROWNING AS A SOCIAL 
 REFORMER 
 
 THE vital quality of Mrs. Browning's work is 
 the more impressive when brought with all its 
 trenchant variety in prose and verse within the 
 convenient compass of three small volumes. 
 Without going so far as one of our greatest writers, 
 who is said to have named " Aurora Leigh " as 
 the greatest poem of the last century, it is hardly 
 possible to doubt that Aurora, through whose lips 
 Mrs. Browning spoke, did change, imperceptibly 
 yet profoundly, the whole attitude of the insular 
 English mind with regard to one social question, 
 so that forgetfulness of the unmeasured debt 
 which we owe to her is only an indication of its 
 lasting reality, inasmuch as what was most 
 courageous and amazing to her own generation 
 now astonishes few save the ignorant or the un- 
 reasoning, and may be said to leaven all enlightened 
 Christian ethics, whether of thought or of action. 
 In his characterisation of the highest woman- 
 hood as essentially differing from the highest 
 manhood, in a royalty always shared by both and 
 always correlative, Ruskin reminds us, in words 
 too memorable to be either paraphrased or for- 
 gotten, that " what the woman is to be within her 
 gates, as the centre of order, the balm of distress, 
 and the mirror of beauty, that she is also to be 
 without her gates, where order is more difficult, 
 distress more imminent, loveliness more rare." 
 
 71 
 
OF TROSS 
 
 And looking back through the Victorian age of 
 literature on those who fulfilled this ideal in the 
 world of letters, it is hardly possible to be alto- 
 gether blind to the distinguished services rendered 
 by the collected poems just reissued. For, in 
 gazing closely on the nineteenth century, and 
 especially on the middle half of the nineteenth 
 century, amid the splendid toil and ever-fructifying 
 harvest of those masculine forces in philosophy, in 
 science, and in history, which by the hands of 
 men have given to our race new powers of social 
 economy, intellectual freedom and material wealth, 
 while echoing Ruskin's ascription of the highest 
 powers of knowledge and discretion to man, as the 
 ruler, the inventor, the defender, we find a rein- 
 forcement also of his belief in woman's province as 
 that of sovereign guidance at the very heart of 
 life. The writings of a handful of high-minded 
 and fearless women, among whom Mrs. Browning 
 stood facile princeps, have had a primary share in 
 the reawakening of the dormant national con- 
 science on questions of practical religion, and have 
 broken down those cold artificial traditions which 
 straitened compassion and shut out the visible 
 presence of the Master. It is true that, in this, 
 woman did not stand alone : 
 
 "The woman's cause is man's they rise or sink 
 together." 
 
 Scott and Thackeray and Dickens to mention 
 only three out of the many names that throng to 
 mind each in his several way, did much to 
 make the ice-bound hedges less thorny in rigid 
 72 
 
SOCIAL 
 
 obstructiveness. But a man would have to be 
 either more or less than a man before he could 
 penetrate the inmost defences of feminine vanity 
 and self-deception with the piercing weapons and 
 unsparing zeal of such a Britomart as Mrs. 
 Browning. There are some subjects on which 
 only a woman could so poignantly and un- 
 answerably appeal to women themselves. 
 
 Mrs. Browning's stainless name and high and 
 noble character lent an added brightness to the 
 sword which always has "the strength of ten" 
 for one whose " heart is pure." Moreover, her 
 crusade was all the more powerful, and the more 
 moving, because even the basest mind could not 
 in her case represent it as the outcome of any 
 personal bitterness. For her life was crowned 
 with the " ecstasy " and 
 
 " mystery of love, 
 
 In which absorbed, loss, anguish, treason's self 
 Enlarges rapture." 
 
 The sanctity of marriage was to her no mere 
 article of faith, though it was that too, but a 
 part of 
 
 "Love, the soul of soul, within the soul, 
 Evolving it sublimely. First, God's love. 
 And next, [he smiled,] the love of wedded souls 
 Which still presents that mystery's counterpart." 
 
 Supremely happy in her own married love, she 
 was overwhelmed with compassion for those who 
 had met such anguish of treason as had never 
 approached her own life. 
 
 73 
 
OF 
 
 Even if Browning had not written his " Posy to 
 the Ring," it would still not have been difficult 
 to understand the singular appropriateness of such 
 an offering as "The Ring and the Book "to her who 
 had, with brave and unmistakable clearness, taught 
 that women who stood high in their own order, 
 for virtue and piety, were blinding themselves to 
 the corporate responsibility of all womanhood 
 and degrading their own protected liberty, by 
 ignoring, with that most scathing contempt of 
 all, which declines even to see, the ignorance, the 
 danger, the deadening agony, of many of those 
 who, less guarded than themselves, were yet of 
 like flesh and blood, members of the same great 
 human family. 
 
 Careful reading of "The Ring and the Book" 
 will emphasise the special significance of such a 
 votive offering to her who, crowned with ideal 
 wifehood and rejoicing motherhood, had been the 
 champion of women and children for her own time 
 and for all time, and whose Marian Erie had felt 
 as Pompilia did about her own little son, that 
 beyond her, his mother, her child had no claimant 
 except God. Through certain lines from " Aurora 
 Leigh," uplifted and transfigured in "The Posy," 
 Browning makes us feel anew, of the poet who 
 taught and laboured through Aurora's lips, that it 
 was in her tender ardour of service that to him she 
 was most divine. And has she not herself reminded 
 us that 
 
 " The man most man, with tenderest human hands, 
 Works best for men, as God in Nazareth " ? 
 
 74 
 
SOCIAL 
 
 "How sound of heart and clear of head," how 
 replenished with heavenly common sense, is the 
 best and most potent of Aurora's wisdom, and how 
 delightful often in its salient sense of laughter as 
 well as tears ! It is difficult to choose where there 
 is such wealth, but it is pleasant to find her hitting 
 out squarely at one modern fashion of cant in the 
 lines : 
 
 " Mere passion will not prove a volume worth 
 Its gall and rags even. Bubbles round a keel 
 Mean nought, excepting that the vessel moves. 
 There's more than passion goes to make a man 
 Or book." 
 
 The pungent humour is insistent everywhere, 
 whether it be in the graphic touch which describes 
 how certain good men drew back their chairs when 
 they shrank away from the utterance of a coarse 
 and unchivalrous personality, 
 
 " As if they spied black-beetles on the floor," 
 or in that description of the other sort of man who 
 
 " Sets his virtues on so raised a shelf, 
 He has to mount a stool to get at them, 
 And meantime lives on quite the common way 
 With everybody's morals." 
 
 But there is abundant power of another kind, as 
 in that prayer to the "Supreme Artist" for those 
 who 
 
 " sit by solitary fires 
 
 And hear the nations praising them far off" ; 
 
 75 
 
s OF 
 
 or in those other lines which flash upon us the 
 first moment of a perfect understanding between 
 soul and soul : 
 
 " As when the sudden finger of the wind 
 Will wipe a row of single city-lamps 
 To a pure white line of flame, more luminous 
 Because of obliteration ; more intense, 
 The intimate presence carrying in itself 
 Complete communication, as with souls 
 Who, having put the body off, perceive 
 Through simply being." 
 
 Few can doubt that, although such living verse as 
 "Cowper's Grave" and "The Sleep" and " Con- 
 fessions " will echo down the centuries in the 
 power of a vital faith and a poet's intensity of 
 simple human feeling, Mrs. Browning's most 
 certain claim to a permanent place in English 
 literature a claim more certain even than that 
 won by such poems as "A Musical Instrument" 
 and " My Kate," or by the throb of a world-wide 
 patriotism in her flaming and beautiful lyrics for 
 Italy will rest upon those " Sonnets from the 
 Portuguese " which never existed in any language 
 save the language of the heart, until she wrote them 
 and hid them away, where Browning afterwards 
 found them and urged that the world should have 
 the joy of them. The sonnets alone would have 
 secured her immortality. But, had she written 
 nothing else, notwithstanding that their intrinsic 
 value as sonnets would have remained the same, 
 yet without her work as a social reformer on 
 behalf of suffering women and children, they 
 76 
 
M1(S. B%pfr$yp(G SOCIAL 
 
 would have lost an added charm as part of the 
 expression of a noble personality. She who wrote 
 " Aurora Leigh " and " The Cry of the Children " 
 sowed a multiplying harvest in many widely differ- 
 ing fields. It would be impossible to enumerate 
 all the unselfish battles and redeeming labours into 
 which her spirit has crept. Through many a 
 heart there rings ever the refrain of her words : 
 
 " Patient children think what pain 
 Makes a young child patient ponder ! 
 Wronged too commonly to strain 
 After right, or wish, or wonder." 
 
 Marriage and birth and death all were to Mrs. 
 Browning the revelation of the Divine in the human. 
 We think instinctively of her to whom "The 
 Ring and the Book " was dedicated when Pom- 
 pilia, whose son was born at this season, blissful in 
 the new-born human light, kindled in the Divine 
 Light, tells us : 
 
 " Christmas before me was not that a chance ? 
 I never realised God's birth before 
 How he grew likest God in being born. 
 This time I felt like Mary, had my babe 
 Lying a little on my breast like hers." 
 
 And in the name of the Divine Love, whose 
 festival we keep, she pleads with us for every little 
 human child to-day, most of all for every child 
 who is grieved or injured or forgotten. 
 
 If some, who are children no longer, are sad 
 because this Christmas there seems to be one child 
 missing, she has a message for them also. In the 
 
 77 
 
OF <p%pse 
 
 same volume that contains "Aurora Leigh" she 
 tells us of God : 
 
 " He lends not ; but gives to the end, 
 As he loves to the end. If it seem 
 That he draws back a gift, comprehend 
 
 'Tis to add to it rather amend, 
 And finish it up to your dream. 
 
 So look up, friends ! You, who indeed 
 
 Have possessed in your house a sweet piece 
 Of the Heaven which men strive for, must need 
 Be more earnest than others are, speed 
 
 Where they loiter, persist where they cease." 
 
A SONG OF NOBEL THOMSON 
 
 For a moment when the mind of the singer is at play 
 
 "Never mind!" or "No matter!" old dis- 
 putants said. 
 Now, " mind is all matter " " all matter is 
 
 mind" 
 
 The myriad electrons will never be dead, 
 For now Nobel Thomson has nobly defined 
 Their name, that of corpuscles well underlined ! 
 Altho' the great riddle of earth be unread, 
 No negative answer can crush us with dread, 
 
 The old mocking " Nay" is to limbo assigned ; 
 
 The " negatives " now are with " positives" wed, 
 
 And all things are fashioned by Life, Love, 
 
 and Mind ; 
 
 For even the blankest " material " creed 
 Proclaims omnipresent, fulfilling our need, 
 
 The Force in our dust that has moulded 
 
 mankind, 
 Wrought Beauty, Truth, Goodness, for man's 
 
 daily Bread ! 
 
 The great veil is trembling: ah, what lies 
 behind ? 
 
 79 
 
THE GLEAM 
 
 WINTER has not yet vanished, but to-day there is 
 a foreboding of spring. The aconites are up. 
 The woodbine leaves are unfolding their soft, 
 delicious green. The spears of daffodil and lily- 
 of-the-valley have already pierced the mould. 
 Although, at this sunny noonday hour, the birds 
 are quiet, save for a sweet twittering amid the 
 gay tumult of the south-west wind, there have 
 been joyous bursts of melody at evening and in 
 the morning, and already Little Bo-peep's " lambs' 
 tails " are hanging on the boughs of the hazel- 
 trees. The skies are full of a strange mystic 
 beauty pearly bars through which the pale azure 
 of infinite distances may at moments be seen to 
 gleam translucently, and at other moments a 
 nearer and more earthly brilliance, though still of 
 the heavens, a blueness, vivid as nemophila flowers, 
 looks laughingly. The funereal beauty of the 
 dark pines, with their plume-like enrobing and 
 red-brown stems, does but emphasise the light 
 and colour of the surrounding world, the rich 
 warmth of the ploughed fields, the peculiar fawn- 
 like brown of last year's oak-leaves, which seem 
 to cling to the boughs expressly to catch every 
 passing vibration of the cool and delicate sunlight, 
 the mossy tints of the fragrant arbor vitae, the 
 shining silver of the birch-stems that re-echo the 
 silvery tints of the harmless low-lying clouds. 
 
 Already I have heard the lambs calling to their 
 80 
 
rne 
 
 mothers, in a field just out of sight beyond the 
 pine-copse ; and long ago the tiny buds have been 
 showing on my youthful mountain ash that is 
 hardly much taller than a maid of sixteen summers, 
 a prim, yet graceful, tree, whose upward-forking 
 branches, that still show clustered stalks where 
 the birds have bared them of every scarlet berry, 
 make a favourite perch for my redbreasts when 
 they come to remind me that it is their lunch- 
 time. 
 
 It is a day of swiftly chasing lights and 
 shadows, a day that shows the lovely under-side 
 of the leaves blown backward by the wind, and 
 emphasises the amazing glossiness of the laurels 
 a day when it is not difficult to realise for once 
 that we are sailing gaily through the circum- 
 ambient air, with the dear old earth as our flying- 
 boat, and all the stars for our companions. Petty 
 cares and ambitions are put to flight. There is a 
 moving Presence in wood and field. 
 
 " Heard melodies are sweet, but those unheard 
 Are sweeter," 
 
 and on the invisible ladder, 'twixt the lower and 
 the higher, " young angels pass." The thoughts 
 of the young poet and the old intermingle the 
 thought of Keats, who gave us the famous line 
 about music that is " unheard " in the sense in 
 which God is unseen, and the thought of Tenny- 
 son, who in his last years wrote, in his perfect 
 lyric of the spring, those childlike and beautiful 
 words about the " young angels " that ascend and 
 descend amid the unfolding ecstasy. It is a day 
 
 F 81 
 
OF TfiOSS 
 
 when the " Gleam " of which Tennyson sang 
 enters many a heart, that does not know itself for 
 a poet, yet arises to " follow the Gleam " at 
 once tranquillised and inspirited by the touch of 
 some infinite possibility beyond the credence of 
 the mere senses, a possibility of which Beauty, 
 Truth, and Love are but differing aspects a day 
 when in many a soul there wakes, however 
 dumbly, something of the fine courage that 
 breathes through the verses of that later poet who 
 has written : 
 
 " I will not doubt, though all my ships at sea 
 Come drifting home with broken masts and 
 
 sails ; 
 
 I shall believe the Hand that never fails, 
 From seeming evil worketh good for me ; 
 And though I weep because those sails are 
 
 battered, 
 Still will I cry, while my best hopes lie shattered, 
 
 <I trust in Thee/ 
 
 
 " I will not doubt ; well anchored in the faith, 
 Like some staunch ship, my soul braves every 
 
 gale; 
 
 So strong its courage that it will not fail 
 To breast the mighty unknown sea of Death. 
 Oh, may I cry, when body parts with spirit, 
 ' I do not doubt,' so listening worlds may hear it, 
 
 With my last breath." 
 
 82 
 
A FRAGMENT 
 
 WAS it of love or of spring-time that Caponsacchi 
 was speaking when he said : 
 
 " I paced the city : it was the first Spring. 
 By the invasion I lay passive to, 
 In rushed new things, the old were rapt away " ? 
 
 He had just seen Pompilia, the woman whose 
 noble simplicity and purity were to be among the 
 regenerating forces which awakened him to the 
 fact that he had been a " fribble" and "cox- 
 comb " ; but it is with a quite literal meaning also 
 that he tells us that " it was the new Spring." 
 
 Love and spring-time what new thing can be 
 said of either, except that the eternal parable is 
 rewritten every Easter, sealed with the profound 
 significance of the most joyous fact in the world's 
 history, and prophesying "some far-off divine 
 event," in which shall be consummated that 
 deepest and purest love of all, which is, we are 
 told, even more enduring than faith and hope ? 
 
 Once again the earth is putting forth her 
 symbols and unfolding her beautiful hieroglyph, 
 not only in field and lane and woodland, but even 
 in the byways and corners of town and city. 
 Already the rosy splendour of the almond-trees 
 has glowed and paled again, and the leafless elms 
 have shown their clusters of dusky red blossoms, 
 and now I have seen one of them opening its green 
 buds. Lilacs are rapidly unfolding their leaves, 
 
 83 
 
OF 
 
 and here and there the hawthorns are showing a 
 bright verdure. 
 
 In London the spring must always carry with 
 it a certain charm of surprise and incongruity. 
 The exquisite cleanness of the new leaves and 
 flowers, the stainless splendour of the vernal tints, 
 the exhilarating purity of the early perfumes 
 who would look for these in the midst of so much 
 smoke and grime, so much that is sordid, or 
 worldly, or poverty-stricken ? Yet here they are, 
 unsullied as an angel's wing and sweet as the airs 
 of heaven. Already I have seen the loveliness of the 
 budding trees at the back of the Marylebone Work- 
 house ; already, after an early shower, I have met 
 the penetrating and delicious odour of the sweet- 
 poplar in St. James's Square so unmistakable 
 a fragrance that, though I have not discovered the 
 tree, which may be hiding in a back garden or 
 round an area corner, I know that it is there, as 
 we know the sun is shining when we feel the light 
 in our eyes. There are sheltered bits in Kensington 
 Gardens which are already "a mist of green, and 
 nothing perfect," and the little blue scyllas seem 
 to be blooming this year even more fully than 
 usual in outlying garden plots. As I stood 
 last Sunday morning in St. Paul's Churchyard, 
 watching the crowd of pigeons that walked about 
 tamely and companionably round the feet of the 
 children who were feeding them, I saw that the 
 crocuses were at their most perfect moment of 
 blooming, and recalled a charming letter from 
 Mr. G. D. Leslie to his friend Mr. Marks, in 
 which he evolves a theory of his own as to why the 
 
gold crocus is generally smaller than the purple or 
 the white. 
 
 I know of one town in the Midlands, full of 
 hot and noisy factories, where, at this time of year, 
 the little windows of the back streets in the slums 
 used to be adorned with glasses of the purple 
 crocus, plucked by the eager flower-loving factory 
 "hands" and their children, down in the flat 
 meadows by the winding Trent. In those fields, 
 in bygone days, the wild anemone, which generally 
 is found in the woods, was wont to grow with a 
 special grace and vigour, the witchery of its deli- 
 cate outline enhanced by the deeper pink in its 
 pencillings, which it owed probably to the lavish 
 moisture. 
 
 Here in the south only the plane-tree, our 
 London tree par excellence, still remains bare, 
 except for the three little fairy-like balls of last 
 year, which hang here and there from the branches, 
 and mark it out almost as distinctively as the 
 peeling of the bark. On the north side of London 
 the coltsfoot is in full bloom, and I have seen it 
 also in Kent, where the earliest fruit trees are 
 beginning to be snowy. The grey and gold of 
 the sunset on Sunday evening was hardly more 
 beautiful than the later sky which followed, when 
 the moon and stars looked down through fleecy 
 clouds and far-away azure deeps. And there has 
 been more than one afternoon since, when the Law 
 Courts and National Gallery, in the very heart of 
 our great thoroughfares, have gloomed forth 
 grandly against a pale gold background, touched 
 with diaphanous cloud-ripples. 
 
 85 
 
S OF <piiose 
 
 London owes much of its supreme fascination to 
 the river and to the birds which fly above it. 
 Sea-gulls and swallows are among the most beauti- 
 ful birds in the world, and there are a host of 
 others that, when the swallows are here with the 
 May-time, will be sharing London festivities with 
 them. It is wonderful how many singing-birds 
 seem to make themselves happy in suburban 
 gardens. But it was further afield that I this 
 year heard the skylark most jubilant, some three 
 weeks ago, beyond Eltham, one sunny, windy 
 morning, when I watched two English girls on 
 horseback taking their ditches very prettily, in 
 company with a young brother, whose horse at first 
 refused to follow for all the urging in the world. 
 The lark was pouring forth his " harmonious mad- 
 ness " above a bit of grass-land, such as may often 
 be found just outside London. It is surprising 
 what a variety of field and woodland and wild, 
 blossomy common, surround this huge, struggling 
 city. We owe much to those hard-working en- 
 thusiasts who have secured to us open spaces within 
 our borders, and turned ill-kempt burial-grounds 
 into cheering gardens. It is a moment when every 
 one wishes success to the hard-worked people 
 who are doing their best to save the glories of 
 tree and moorland from the hand of the artificial 
 spoiler. 
 
 Among London schemes which appeal to all 
 hearts alike, apart from party prejudice or theo- 
 logical wrangling, there are two or three which 
 seem to make a stronger appeal than usual in these 
 first days of sunshine and fresh air. There is the 
 86 
 
delightful enterprise lately set on foot for secur- 
 ing to outworn labouring women, and especially 
 mothers, an occasional breath of sunshine and 
 sweet air before they break down under the 
 perpetual strain of their daily burden. Not to 
 speak of the Children's Country Holidays Fund, 
 which every one knows and delights in, and the 
 State Children's Aid, which has done so much to 
 give our State children a more natural environ- 
 ment than was possible in the old barrack schools, 
 there is the Children's Invalid Aid Association, 
 which seeks to give to every crippled child in 
 London a helpful and understanding friend, and 
 yearly does so much in arranging for needed rest 
 and change in convalescent homes. On the chil- 
 dren of the nation depends the future of the race, 
 and nothing must be allowed to rob them of that 
 precious vitality and enjoyment of life which 
 make sunshine doubly welcome and spring-time 
 an added joy.* 
 
 The beauty of London in the spring-time is at 
 all times the more poignant from its mingling of 
 the infinite and the impossible, its conflict between 
 the lavish blossoming of Nature and the straiten- 
 ing greed of man ; but, if the ideal of civic 
 responsibility fulfil the promise which has been 
 slowly and gradually unfolding for more than 
 
 * The addresses to which helpers and sympathisers may 
 write are : Children's Invalid Aid, 13 Buckingham Street ; 
 Women's Holiday Fund, 47 St. James's Square ; Children's 
 Country Holidays Fund, 1 8 Buckingham Street, Strand ; 
 State Children's Aid Association, 61 Old Broad Street, E.C. 
 " Omnia vincit amor " is the motto of the Children's Invalid 
 Aid Association. 
 
 87 
 
Lefres OF 
 
 nineteen hundred years on behalf of the poor 
 and the sorrowful, then, century by century, the 
 world may draw nearer to that spring-time of the 
 Golden Year when at last there will be written 
 upon the walls of our cities: " Omnia vincit 
 
 amor." 
 
 88 
 
THE OXFORD PAGEANT AND 
 RUSKIN HALL 
 
 I AM tempted to quote from the prologue to the 
 published "Scheme of the Oxford Historical 
 Pageant,'' which begins as follows : 
 
 "It is no long time now to the unfolding of 
 one of the most beautiful and stately scenes that 
 Oxford has seen for many a long day. The 
 latter days of June and the earlier days of July 
 will witness such a wealth of historical renaissance 
 and such a pomp of picturesque ceremonial as 
 cannot fail to add new and wonderful charm even 
 to a city which has already so many potent spells 
 within the circle of her dreaming spires, She has 
 gazed calm-eyed on many a gallant scene, this 
 ancient mother of men ; she has watched the 
 deeds of kings and nobles, bishops and warriors, 
 courtiers and academics ; she has seen them 
 carried to their triumphs and to their graves. 
 And now she has cast about in the dim recesses 
 of her memory and bethought her of the brave 
 companies that she has viewed of old ; and here, 
 amid the fair lawns and streams, she will set forth, 
 brilliant and unclouded as when they first met 
 her gaze, the noblest memories of a thousand 
 years." 
 
 To those of us who are not among the fortunate 
 crowd privileged to be present at this pageant, 
 Oxford is nevertheless always, and through all the 
 
OF 
 
 changing seasons, full of pageantry and the glamour 
 of historic memories. Now, as at all times, youth 
 and music fill the ancient chapels with their ioy ; 
 eager young spirits, in whom mind and body seem 
 fitly mated, throng the pavements, hold comrade- 
 ship in the gardens, weave new and everlasting 
 memories, lay quick, persistent fingers upon the 
 doorways of knowledge, urging the well-worn 
 keys in the old locks, and, in rare moments of 
 intimate talk or unspoken companionship, looking 
 through the eyes of some fellow-wayfarer into 
 that <c Glory of God " that makes manhood, 
 behold for an instant the unspeakable Wisdom, 
 veiled and mysterious, yet radiating a power and 
 purity beyond all written words. 
 
 Dull must he be of heart who could pass by 
 unmoved the continual procession of unfolding 
 life and destiny, in this centre of immemorial 
 tradition and unresting development, this city of 
 unconscious paradox and sacramental heritage, 
 where the very old and the very new are so 
 mysteriously at one, and the outward ritual of 
 education, bracing and uplifting though it be, is 
 instinct with an eternal grace that overleaps, 
 and creates to ever new vicissitudes, the ideal it 
 embodies. 
 
 This wide bay-window in a tutorial house where 
 these jottings are written down, looking out on 
 tower and dome and spire, with a foreground of 
 delicious greenery and old-world garden, is all a 
 part of the educational hospitality and ordered 
 life, that help to give poise and recollectedness to 
 the lives that pass through the gateways of this 
 90 
 
OXFOT^D 
 
 majestic University ; but even more moving in its 
 symbolism was that rough, bare room, now yearly 
 coming into closer touch with the University, 
 where a day or two ago I talked with some of the 
 fifty residents of Ruskin Hall, twenty of them 
 miners who will later return to their mining work 
 men who win intellectual luxury through 
 physical deprivation, and to whom " plain living 
 and high thinking " are alike a passion and a 
 necessity. Spirited, independent, earnest, some 
 of them are said to be among the best debaters at 
 the Union, and on one and another of the faces 
 it is impossible to mistake the intellectual distinc- 
 tion, or that still higher distinction of character, 
 that transcends and turns to scorn all those mere 
 externals and trapperies of lifewhichTeufelsdrockh 
 characterised as " clothes." 
 
 Ruskin Hall has wide-reaching Imperial possi- 
 bilities, and the national potentialities of its 
 modest beginnings are indicated by the fact that 
 95,000 working men, members of the Amalga- 
 mated Society of Engineers, have made four 
 levies of one penny each to help the work of the 
 college. Of the amount (^300) produced by the 
 first levy, which was made in 1903, 250 was 
 devoted to the fund for purchasing the present 
 buildings, and with the remaining ^50 one of 
 their fellow-members was in residence at the 
 college for the whole of the year 1903. 150 of 
 the amount provided by the second levy went to 
 the fund for the new buildings, and with the 
 remaining 150 three of their fellow-members 
 came into residence for the whole of 1904. By 
 
s OF 
 
 their third levy six of their fellow- members were 
 at the college for the whole of 1905. By their 
 fourth levy nine of their fellow-members are at 
 the college for the whole of this year.* 
 
 My first vision of Oxford, more than a quarter 
 of a century ago, was a dreamland of all that is 
 most perfect in youthful friendship and human 
 fellowship ; of days when among those who took 
 part in that charmed circle through which for a 
 few fleeting days I passed spellbound, were men 
 who have since taken a distinguished part in the 
 service of their compatriots overseas as well as 
 nearer home, but who had then scarcely closed their 
 University career, of whom indeed the impression 
 given was that of thinkers rather than men of 
 action, though doubtlesss those who knew more 
 intimately the " iron will " and untiring executive 
 ability on which their fellows would lean in a 
 great crisis, may in one instance have understood, 
 better than a passing visitor, the force behind that 
 simplicity and charm. Others there were also 
 a brilliant group of friends and comrades, just 
 about to leave their undergraduate days behind 
 them and bid farewell to Balliol and to Oxford 
 who as scholars and men of letters and helpers 
 of the poor, have more than fulfilled the promise 
 of those days, and have through life been loyal 
 to those old attachments. Among their seniors, 
 the men whose widely differing influences most 
 potently converged, in this particular coterie, to 
 make life a disciplined art from which nothing 
 
 * These statistics were taken verbatim from the report 
 published in the year of the Oxford Pageant. 
 9 2 
 
rne 
 
 intrinsically high or beautiful should be absent 
 Jowett, T. H. Green, Lewis Nettleship, Walter 
 Pater, Arnold Toynbee have all passed beyond 
 our mortal vision, though they have left their 
 mark enduringly in many a noble life. It is 
 possible that among these influences, Arnold 
 Toynbee's may have been deepest of all. But it 
 must not be forgotten that Clough's Oxford 
 pamphlet on Retrenchment had preceded Toyn- 
 bee's work and that of Leonard Montefiore in 
 paths that led straight towards the movement of 
 which Ruskin Hall is one manifestation among 
 many, long before the days of the actual road- 
 mending by Ruskin's followers. 
 
 Clough was known to that generation chiefly 
 through his poems, but in "that serene, that 
 earnest air," which alternated with a very pretty 
 wit and went hand in hand with old-world 
 courtesy and charm, at many an undergraduate 
 breakfast table and supper party, the good 
 tradition remained, quickened and deepened 
 doubtless by the present and living influence of 
 Arnold Toynbee and the men and women who 
 admired and loved him. 
 
 It is only in looking back that I realise how 
 those days were making the future of to-day. 
 At the moment the pageant of life and spring 
 caught the hours in their uplifting whirl, and, 
 though much was felt and divined, the outward 
 eyes were too much dazzled to see clearly or 
 remember fully. 
 
 It was a wondrous May- time on the edge of 
 June, when the days were all one long succession of 
 
 93 
 
OF 
 
 eager conversation and stimulating companionship, 
 and "the Master" who was Jowett in those 
 days flitted rosy-cheeked and smiling through 
 those fragrant gardens, all sweet with syringa 
 and lilac and may, where we spent such moments 
 as were not engrossed with chapels and breakfast 
 parties and cloistered wanderings through ever- 
 new delights of sunshine and conversation. 
 
 To-day the place is full of thoughts and 
 memories and hopes, and that glamour of 
 delicious sunlight which comes next to health 
 and youth and love in its vitalising joy. If I 
 have dwelt for a moment on the pathos and the 
 promise of those rough, brave lives at Ruskin 
 Hall, I do not forget that the faery background, 
 which, year by year, is woven by new generations 
 of those who come here drinking deeply of all 
 the best that wealth and culture can give, is to 
 those very lives an influence and a romance which, 
 if rightly used, may be a part of Oxford's gifts to 
 them. With a faith that approaches certainty, I 
 look to the successors of Arthur Hugh Clough 
 and the group that followed him, and to the sane 
 generosity of all great literature, to achieve in 
 time, for those born into a straitened heritage, a 
 less stinted measure for their cup of intellectual 
 joy, their share in the beauty and uplifting of our 
 common lot. For these last, during their brief 
 sojourn at Ruskin Hall, each day may bring its 
 own pageantry, whether they be present at the 
 Historical Pageant or not. 
 
 Having begun with the opening words in what 
 may be called the prologue to the book of the 
 94 
 
rne OXFOT^D 
 
 Pageant, it may be worth while to add a quota- 
 tion from " Q's " final paragraph in what may 
 not unfittingly be named its epilogue: 
 
 " I say confidently, therefore, that the Historical 
 Pageant of 1907 can never divulge the secret of 
 Oxford. It may do better, though. Merely by 
 being youthful, ardent, gay ... it may pass 
 into the secret itself and be of a piece with it. 
 
 " ' Tower tall, city wall, 
 
 A river running past ; 
 Youth played when each was made, 
 And shall them all outlast.' " 
 
 That is a verse of enchantment ; but finer still, 
 perhaps, is the closing stanza of "An Invitation 
 to the Pageant," by Robert Bridges : 
 
 " Farewell ! for whether we be young or old, 
 
 Thou dost remain, but we shall pass away ; 
 Time shall against himself thy house uphold, 
 
 And build thy sanctuary from decay ; 
 
 Children unborn shall be thy pride and stay. 
 May earth protect thee, and thy sons be true, 
 And God with heavenly food thy life renew, 
 
 Thy pleasure and thy grace from day to day." 
 
 95 
 
NOTE ON "SILAS MARNER" 
 FROM THE TEMPLE CLASSICS 
 
 \lncludedbere by the courtesy of the publishers.'] 
 
 ASSOCIATIONS are "chancey" and unreasoning 
 things. I seldom find myself thinking of " Silas 
 Marner " without hearing a line of Browning with 
 which it has no definite or obvious relation, a line 
 which even now is murmuring, with a steady and 
 unexpected claim upon attention : 
 
 "One star, its chrysolite " 
 
 So haunting and insistent is this caprice of 
 memory that it seems impossible to write even 
 the briefest " appreciation " of the book without 
 finding it somewhere upon the page. 
 
 Is it that in this long-ago story there is a flaw- 
 less and crystalline unity, as pure and illuminating 
 as it is convincing, and touching the recollection 
 with that same sense of divinity in everyday things 
 which is felt sometimes in the coming of the stars 
 at evening or the quivering music of the aspen- 
 leaves at noon ? 
 
 Certain it is that we find in this homely tale a 
 quaint humour, a tender religious charm, which 
 Mrs. Ewing in after-days might rival, in her own 
 very different and much more limited field, but 
 which even she could hardly surpass, and of which 
 Thackeray himself to name no other might 
 have been justly and modestly proud. There 
 
may well be a lifting of eyebrows at the juxta- 
 position of Thackeray's name in such a com- 
 parison. Yet for true and intimate seriousness in 
 the primal relations of life the great satirist had 
 a master-touch, and, while he differed from 
 George Eliot as widely as each differed from their 
 contemporary, the great humourist who gave us 
 " Oliver Twist/' there was in both in him who 
 wrote " Philip " and " Esmond " and " The New- 
 comes,'' no less than in the creator of Dinah 
 Morris a gentleness of heart, a generous ampli- 
 tude of nature, a sanity and fine restraint, which 
 made it impossible to treat either their ethical ideals, 
 or their spirit of worship and of faith, with any 
 touch of mockery or of disrespect. Perhaps it 
 would be difficult to find any two novels, both, like 
 " Silas Marner " and " Vanity Fair," representing 
 life in England at the beginning of the nineteenth 
 century, which differ more than do these two 
 works of fiction, in material and in method ; but 
 both embody powerfully one part at least of the 
 meaning of that great seventeenth-century allegory 
 from which " Vanity Fair " took its name. And in 
 this story of peasant life it is driven home, with 
 a perfection of masterly self-effacement, worthy of 
 those immortal lines of George Meredith in praise 
 of the music that is 
 
 " free 
 Of taint of personality." 
 
 Full of sunshine and of neighbourly love, yet 
 enfolding at the outset the tragedy of a soul 
 which has lost faith in God and man, it evolves, 
 
 G 97 
 
OF 
 
 unswervingly and inextricably, that far-reaching 
 discipline of life and self-created retribution, 
 which elude the crude methods and coarse reckon- 
 ing of the time-server and the hypocrite. It 
 faces wrongs and inequalities which might well 
 fill even the strongest with despair, were it not 
 for that Power, whose Love and Guidance, full 
 of sympathy with ordained renunciation, Dolly 
 Winthrop believed men ought to " trusten " 
 through all the perplexity of what, to a gross 
 and limited perception, so often looks like pur- 
 poseless and inequitable sacrifice. Dolly's un- 
 conscious philosophy is wide enough and deep 
 enough to support the whole burden of our 
 earthly mystery. It is through her unlettered 
 wisdom that the weaver's mournful early story 
 and ever-mellowing happiness of later life are 
 beheld, in that clearly mirrored divine radiance 
 which exalts and purifies human drama, whether 
 of tragedy or comedy. And it is not men and 
 women alone who live and move before us in that 
 wondrous light. What is it that enables George 
 Eliot by a few brief, sober touches to evoke with 
 such extraordinary vividness, not only certain 
 features of the landscape, but the very spirit that 
 breathes through them ? Is it that, in her long 
 country drives with her father, these English lanes 
 and hedgerows, these quiet pools and silvery 
 " runlets" and deep, delicious meadows, gave to 
 her some effluence of their very being, such as 
 enabled her to write of them ever afterwards with 
 the delicate reserve and divining magnetism of a 
 lifelong love ? It is, for instance, no mere 
 
description which enchants us in that singularly 
 beautiful passage in which she speaks of " a 
 certain awe . . . such as we feel before some 
 quiet majesty or beauty in the earth or sky 
 before a steady glowing planet, or a full- 
 flowered eglantine, or the bending trees over a 
 silent pathway." 
 
 With no forgetfulness of her reluctant sur- 
 render of the ancient creed, it must yet be main- 
 tained that George Eliot was at once too rational 
 and too religious too humbly and exaltedly 
 conscientious in every task she undertook to 
 have anything to do with that pseudo-romance of 
 over-strained fancy, against which our modern 
 "laughing philosopher'' of a later generation 
 serious and ardent under his ironical mask is 
 for ever running a-tilt. The naturalness and 
 inevitableness of that often-quoted scene at the 
 Rainbow, in which slow bovine vanity and sheer 
 ineptitude so nearly lead to a quarrel, give to the 
 villagers there a fitting niche beside the classic 
 Dogberry. The humour of that scene as indeed 
 of the whole book " too animate to need a 
 stress " is as different as possible from the self- 
 conscious epigrammatic sparkle of many later 
 imitative scenes among nineteenth-century novels 
 of agricultural life. 
 
 The weaver himself is a triumph of delicate 
 insight on the part of the author a triumph 
 the more subtle because his character is built on 
 such apparently simple lines. He for whose 
 hoarded gold is substituted a better treasure in 
 his golden-haired foster-daughter, touches us with 
 
 99 
 
s OF 
 
 the same deep affection as that forsaken father 
 described by Balzac as of much the same period 
 of time, though of another country who was 
 never a miser except of the looks and words of 
 his cruel children, and to whom, in his torture- 
 chamber of gallant self-deception, there came no 
 heavenly deliverance except the deliverance of 
 death. Was there in Marner's admirably chosen 
 name any half-conscious reminiscence of another 
 earthly voyager whose way to " the dear God who 
 loveth us" lay through a hell of isolation that 
 ancient " Mariner " whose title only differs from 
 his own by the interposition of a single letter ? 
 This poor hungry-hearted craftsman had learned 
 very early that " the wedding feast " at life's table 
 is not for all in this world ; and though, unlike 
 the weird sailor in Coleridge's poem, he had never 
 willingly injured one of God's creatures it was 
 they who had injured him yet it seemed that for 
 long he must needs meet the waves of a buffeting 
 adversity, with almost as deep a solitariness of 
 soul as he who cried 
 
 " This soul hath been 
 Alone on a wide wide sea : 
 So lonely 'twas, that God himself 
 Scarce seemed there to be." 
 
 He, too, is won back to fellowship divine and 
 human by the " beauty " and the " happiness " of 
 one of the "happy living things " about his path, 
 though to him as well he deserved came a 
 messenger lovelier and more loving than the little 
 water-snakes of whom the " Ancient Mariner" 
 
 100 
 
told "the Wedding Guest" that he "blessed 
 them unaware." 
 
 There came a day when he too, he, Silas Marner, 
 who had seemed shut out from that conscious 
 presence of Love which of itself is heaven, as he 
 looked into the eyes of a little laughing child, 
 could feel vaguely and inarticulately something of 
 what Swinburne's exquisitely simple lines have 
 made articulate for all men everywhere concerning 
 children : 
 
 "Earth's creeds may be seventy times seven 
 
 And blood have defiled each creed : 
 If of such be the kingdom of heaven, 
 It must be heaven indeed." 
 
 But with what an ideal realism in the true, not 
 the modern and debased, use of the word does 
 the incessant interaction of character and circum- 
 stance, with its gradual unforeseen development 
 and self-recording Nemesis, unfold itself! As 
 one vindication of the sense in which the word 
 "realism" has just been used, take, for example, 
 the inimitable drawing of Mr. Macey, always such 
 an entirely credible human creature, even when 
 he contrives to interpolate in his well-intended con- 
 dolences with Marner the gratifying information 
 that " you were allays a staring white-faced creatur, 
 partly like a bald-faced calf! " 
 
 Or consider the character of Nancy Lammeter. 
 Her portrait is touched in with a precision, a dainty 
 care and individuality of colouring, that impress 
 themselves vividly on the memory. Her singularly 
 limited ideal would in any less beautiful soul have 
 
 101 
 
OF 
 
 been written down as narrowness. Her rectitude of 
 purpose, in details of conduct in which she was as 
 determined as she was mistaken, would in a smaller 
 nature have been hated as obstinacy. But, although 
 George Eliot does not conceal these characteristics, 
 Nancy's exquisite sincerity of intention, " clear 
 as the flower-born dew," her self-forgetting 
 steadfastness of affection, have been pourtrayed 
 also, with such a faultless reality as to make 
 her primness a part of her fascination, and her 
 " set ways " as restful as the conventionalised 
 blossom- line of some perfect bit of decorative art. 
 Rarely does George Eliot permit herself, in rela- 
 tion to any of her dramatis -personce, the use of 
 that hard-worked and sometimes meaningless 
 adjective "sweet"; but to Nancy's name she 
 does prefix it ; and, indeed, this daughter of a 
 farming squire calls up to the reader the image 
 of those starry pheasant-eyed flowers, sheeny in 
 their snow-white, stainless exactitude, and fragrant 
 with a message beyond that of earth, to which 
 the Lancashire folk give Nancy Lammeter's 
 " christen " name. Of her, as of Mrs. GaskelPs 
 last and most perfect achievement, Molly Gibson, 
 we think, as among the people we have known, 
 rather than those of whom we have merely read. 
 
 But even Nancy, whose life is nobly in accord 
 with her belief that nothing in this world is 
 " worth doing wrong for," does not touch a 
 deeper or a higher note than Dolly Winthrop. 
 And Dolly's is in some ways a larger mind, 
 notwithstanding she was "no scholard," and a 
 nature touched with that best kind of sainthood 
 102 
 
SIL^IS 
 
 which lies, not in the negative virtues virtues 
 which in such a life spring up of themselves but 
 in the cleansing drudgery of ever-repeated and 
 ever-chosen toil, for the world's humblest, coarsest 
 needs. Dolly lives so entirely in the joys and 
 sorrows of others, that to her the whole com- 
 munity is a family needing her maternal care. 
 Was there ever, even in Mrs. Poyser herself, a 
 more delightful creation than this excellent woman, 
 who, as mild and patient as she was hard-working, 
 viewed "the stronger sex in the light of animals 
 whom it had pleased Heaven to make naturally 
 troublesome, like bulls and turkey-cocks " ? It is 
 like feeling the sunshine only to thiflk of her ; 
 "good-looking, fresh-complexioned," and "never 
 whimpering," and, when she was not tending her 
 jovial husband, or "that apple-cheeked youngster of 
 seven, with a clean-starched frill that looked like 
 a plate for the apples," never so happy as when 
 she stood by a sick-bed, or gave kindly help in a 
 house of mourning ! 
 
 Besides, it is Dolly, with her practical faith and 
 pagan phrasing, who brings Marner the first spoken 
 word of comfort from what she calls " the right 
 quarter," and reminds us that "if we'n done our 
 part it isn't to be believed as Them as are above 
 us'll be worse nor we are, and come short o' 
 Their'n." More characteristic still is that later 
 saying of hers : " It's the will o' Them above as 
 a many things should be dark to us ; but there's 
 some things as I've never felt i' the dark about, 
 and they're mostly what comes i' the day's work." 
 Perhaps we love her most for her delicate tact and 
 
 103 
 
OF 
 
 magnanimity in that surpassing scene in which 
 Silas, " leaning forward to look at Baby with some 
 jealousy, as she was resting her head backward 
 against Dolly's arm, and eyeing him contentedly 
 from a distance "- made his little confession of 
 jealousy "But I want to do things for it myself, 
 else it may get fond o' somebody else, and not 
 fond o' me." 
 
 In this, as in all her novels, it is in her wonderful 
 mother-hearted touches in relation to the children 
 that George Eliot's inspiration is most striking of 
 all. Eppie, when she blossoms into womanhood, 
 is as real and as " taking " as a briar-rose, one of 
 those " dillicate-made " flowers, with their ineffable 
 perfume, as of sweetness wafted from far away, 
 which, with their heart-shaped petals, and colour- 
 ing of sunset cloudlets, grow by thousands in the 
 dusty lanes, to transfigure with their unconscious 
 symbolism at once ethereal and earthly the 
 possibilities of man's homeliest lot. But it is in 
 the pictures of Eppie's childhood that the novelist 
 attains her highest distinction. What could be 
 more absolutely perfect in irresistible humour 
 than the story of the " toal-hole " discipline, 
 with its atmosphere of tender and growing love 
 between the lonely old man and the little way- 
 ward, winsome child. Other writers have given 
 us children to love and to remember, in whom 
 there is often an element of the subtle or the 
 exceptional, but I venture to think that the main 
 attraction of George Eliot's children and herein 
 lies her greatness is in a kind of divine com- 
 monplaceness, as of daisies and buttercups. And 
 104 
 
in the music that their voices make such music 
 as brings comfort and strength to many lonely 
 hearts there is not one false or self-conscious 
 note. To draw such children as that is only 
 possible to the highest genius of all. And they are, 
 as they should be, just taken for granted, as are 
 all the divinest things in life never insisted upon, 
 never " shown off," or dragged in. " In old days," 
 as the author of " Silas Marner," reminds us, " there 
 were angels who came and took men by the hand 
 and led them away from the city of destruction. 
 We see no white-winged angels now. But yet 
 men are led away from threatening destruction : 
 a hand is put into theirs, which leads them forth 
 gently towards a calm and bright land, so that 
 they look no more backward ; and the hand may 
 be a little child's." 
 
 105 
 
THE PROFFERED SHIPS 
 
 WHY do they thrill us those ships that we dream 
 
 about, 
 
 Ships they will build us, far over the sea, 
 Ships that all fill us with welcomes that gleam 
 
 about 
 
 Timber and shrouding with noble elation, 
 Ships from each stalwart self-governing nation 
 Born of our Mother and born to be free ? 
 
 See them come floating, majestic and glorious, 
 Dreams that for beauty and strength are 
 
 delight 
 
 Comrades devoting young sinews victorious, 
 Sister to sister and brother to brother, 
 One in the love of the Homeland, the Mother, 
 One in the justice immortal in might ! 
 
 Not for the passion of warfare and vanity, 
 
 But for the Kinship that cannot forget 
 Love that can fashion the bonds of humanity 
 Into the grace of an armour celestial, 
 Love that uplifts out of all that is bestial, 
 Love, whereon light, tho' it rise, cannot 
 set! 
 
 Brothers, the Homeland is proud at the thought 
 
 of you, 
 
 Hearts overflow to your generous words ; 
 106 
 
SHITS 
 
 Heaven is the dome to the temple that's wrought 
 
 of you, 
 Arching the hearth that, in world-wide embrace 
 
 of you, 
 Glows with the courage and champion grace of 
 
 you ! 
 
 Send us your ships then bright messenger 
 birds ! 
 
 Oh, may the God of our fathers bestow on us 
 
 Disciplined peace, without panic or strife ! 
 But, should the rod of His chastisement throw 
 
 on us 
 
 Duties of war on behalf of the trampled, 
 May we, with oneness and strength unexampled, 
 Fight to the death for the Master of Life ! 
 
 Dear far-off lands, our own ships will respond to 
 
 you ; 
 
 We will be loyal and true to our trust 
 Pledge we our bond thro' this life and beyond to 
 
 you, 
 
 Forge we our way thro' a tempest's commotion, 
 Ride we at ease on a billowless ocean, 
 Stand to attention, or crimson the dust ! 
 
 107 
 
IN MID-MAY'S GLORY 
 
 SUMMER in May ! The buttercups are here and 
 the sorrels have begun to redden. The fragile 
 stellarias along the lane's edge are beginning to 
 pass away, and the loveliest of the pale blue speed- 
 wells are laughing through the dewy grass in 
 many a meadow as the sun goes down. The 
 white Montana with a grace of the angels is 
 clambering over porches and sunny walls, and the 
 broom yellow and white and primrose-coloured 
 overlooking dazzling beds of pansies, neighbours 
 the sweet golden azaleas, in a garden where one 
 who loves Switzerland and Italy has now deep 
 blue gentians in full bloom. Hawthorns are out, 
 the Spanish chestnuts are in full leaf, and the old- 
 fashioned ribbongrass and forget-me-nots in the 
 cottage borders are in their glory. The buds of 
 pinks and carnations are still closed, but white 
 butterflies are sporting with one another and with 
 the flowers, and yesterday a queen-bee sailed into 
 my front sitting-room almost as unexpected an 
 apparition as the big tropical-looking moth, with 
 gorgeous torn wings, that I once found lying dead 
 outside one cottage porch not far away, or the 
 little grass-adder, a pretty creature, 28 inches 
 long, that last year glided past our kitchen door, 
 charming a little robin as it went, and met its 
 death at the hand of a neighbour before we learned 
 how harmless it was. Thus do I add to my 
 country experiences. Little fluffy rabbits I have 
 108 
 
seen in many a bygone year, scuttling across our 
 woodland paths, but not till yesterday had I 
 watched the swift, graceful movements of a tiny 
 field-mouse, running swift as a lizard through the 
 undergrowth. Or was it some other creature 
 whose little lithe body I mistook for his ? Wis- 
 taria in lavish blossoming has succeeded red and 
 pink japonica, and the pungent smell of the ribes 
 is already over, though there is a little plant akin 
 to the borage, now full of deep blue jewel-like 
 blossoms, in careful gardens. The swallows are 
 flying low, as if they expected yet more rain ; but 
 the finches are full of music, and the nightingales 
 most melodious. I have not yet happened to 
 hear the call of the owls, though the cuckoo seems 
 to mark the refrain of the whole blossoming 
 world, that is full of the scent of the lilacs and of 
 the beautiful pheasant-eyed narcissus. Even the 
 lilies-of-the-valley are in bloom, and the yellow 
 banksia. What a wondrous county this is, and 
 how deeply it was beloved by its own great poet 
 and novelist who died here twelve months ago ! 
 
 It is just a year since the ashes of George 
 Meredith were laid to rest, the flames having 
 burned to utmost purity the beautiful, outworn 
 garment he had laid aside. Do not his words 
 breathe along the meadow and the woodland in 
 the sweet south wind of our enchanting Surrey 
 wilds ? 
 
 " And song of England's rush of flowers 
 Is this full breeze with mellow stops, 
 That spins the lark for shine, for showers ; 
 
 109 
 
s OF Titos e 
 
 He drinks his hurried flight, and drops. 
 The stir in memory seem these things, 
 Which out of moisten'd turf and clay, 
 Astrain for light push patient rings, 
 Or leap to find the waterway. 
 
 So hard was earth an eyewink back ; 
 But now the common life has come, 
 The blotting cloud a dappled pack, 
 The grasses one vast underhum. 
 
 A burly joy each creature swells 
 With sound of its own hungry quest : 
 Earth has to fill her empty wells, 
 And speed the service of the nest.'* 
 
 no 
 
INTRODUCTION TO "SAYINGS 
 FROM THE SAINTS" 
 
 [Reprinted here by the kind permission of the publisher, 
 Mr. Eveleigh Nash.'} 
 
 THIS little book is dedicated to one who gave, 
 and doubtless made doubly sacred by thoughts 
 that were prayers, a rosary made of shells from the 
 Bay of Salamis, which from Athens reached a shy 
 child of nine some forty-six years ago, in memory 
 of a meeting that was also a parting. It asks no 
 higher privilege than to be just such a gift from 
 heart to heart, a rosary in which the beads are of 
 God's making, gathered and polished by other 
 hands than those that have sought to string 
 them on the enduring, yet invisible, thread of 
 human friendship and love. Friendship and love 
 whereof the Saints in this volume have written as 
 the gift and the revelation of Him to whom with 
 one accord they cry: " Thou hast made us for 
 Thyself, and our hearts are restless till they rest 
 in Thee." 
 
 From hand to hand and from heart to heart, 
 as a parting gift, a salutation on birthdays and 
 festivals, it asks a place in life to uplift and help 
 in those moments of meditation that come some- 
 times unforeseen as well as of set purpose, and 
 offers up a many-voiced harmony of that praise 
 which all the saints utter, "not only with their 
 lips, but with their lives/' a harmony attuned 
 to one triumphant note, through all diversity, 
 
 ill 
 
OF 
 
 in its catholicity of Truth and Wisdom and 
 Love. 
 
 The stringing of beads is the humblest of offices 
 in the making of a beautiful thing, yet only under 
 orders could so unscholarly a hand have been 
 dipped into the treasury of the ages to find what 
 was needed for the fashioning of this memorial, 
 and it is well that he who set me this lowly but 
 illuminating task restricted me to the sayings of 
 saints within the canon, for otherwise, with freedom 
 to quote from the words of all good men and 
 women, the choice would have been too vast, and 
 I might have been still groping helplessly among 
 half-dug mines. Nevertheless, the magnificent and 
 practical testimony, of those whose sayings are 
 transcribed in this book, does but gain in weight 
 and in cogency from the sense of that surrounding 
 multitude of uncanonised saints whose thoughts 
 are seldom recorded, except in obscure and un- 
 selfish deeds, and in that Book of Life where the 
 last shall be first men and women who for the 
 sake of others have drudged heroically and suffered 
 silently and rejoiced evermore, and whose messages, 
 though scarcely heard in the fields of literature, are 
 vocal in the invisible choir. 
 
 At the suggestion of the same wise taskmaster, I 
 have so intermingled the jewels on my rosary that 
 the greatest and clearest are therein supported by 
 the lesser gems ; and the sayings of no saint, how- 
 ever great, can be found on many continuous pages 
 unsurrounded by those of others. Here and there 
 some glorious passage that cannot be broken is 
 left supreme and uninterrupted. But wherever it 
 112 
 
THE 
 
 is possible, the wisdom of one is complemented or 
 echoed by another and yet another, leading as by 
 a natural transition to a new aspect of the same 
 truth, or to some apparently opposite view which 
 is its safeguard or its culmination, in the mighty 
 paradox of that wider truth which includes both. 
 
 If it be objected that such interwoven fragments 
 can never make a book properly so called, I reply 
 that it matters little what it is named, whether 
 day-book or rosary or sacred patchwork, so long 
 as it serve its purpose for wholesome invigoration 
 in daily care and toil, holy comfort and courage 
 in hours of darkness, a burnishing of the soul's 
 armour for mortal combat, and an assurance of 
 that communion of spirit with spirit which is 
 found in Him who is the All-embracing and the 
 Eternal. 
 
 With regard to the limitations laid upon me, I 
 have been rigidly obedient ; even the writer of the 
 " Imitation '' has not been included, nor the recluse 
 of Norwich, since neither of them appears in the 
 Calendar. Herein also has been gain, for we all 
 love Thomas a Kempis already ; and had I been 
 allowed to quote at will from the " Imitation," 
 the austerity of an ideal wholly personal and con- 
 templative might have dimmed the almost dazzling 
 testimony of the canonised saints, whose many- 
 sided activity and inspired common sense are only 
 equalled by the heights of their mystic communion 
 and the profundity and universality of their love. 
 While they recognised, as the Catholic Church 
 has always recognised, those ever-present gifts of 
 healing and of miracle which have been neglected, 
 
 H 113 
 
OF 
 
 forgotten, disused, their essential ideal is not the 
 negation of emotion, any more than the " pure 
 light unbroken by the prism " is devoid of those 
 qualities which, when it meets the refracting edges 
 of grief and discipline and renunciation, break 
 forth in all the glories of the prismatic colours 
 from seraphic red to deep celestial blue. Less 
 familiar, and therefore more stimulating to de- 
 votional exercise than even many of the tender and 
 love-inspiring passages of the " Imitation," is 
 that splendid saying of St. Teresa, that it mattered 
 comparatively little whether her soul was carried 
 to hell or to heaven, since, wherever she went, the 
 Supreme Good was present ; and the assurance 
 of St. Francis that "all we perceive materially in 
 this world of the Most High is the Body and 
 Blood of our Divine Lord, and the mysterious 
 words by which we were created and redeemed." 
 
 Amid the agony of a creation that " groaneth 
 and travaileth " toward diviner perfection, where 
 the Faith is still blasphemed by the horrors per- 
 petrated in its most holy name, there are problems 
 which embrace much that is beyond the reach of 
 our finite Reason, even though we are taught to 
 use its light as the light of God. Yet even now 
 we learn, through what is most enduring in human 
 affection and human loyalty, that the transitory is 
 but a mode of the Eternal, and the words education 
 and redemption, which are too often used chiefly 
 as controversial weapons, are symbols of infinite 
 suggestiveness and unutterable consolation. 
 
 The " Sayings" here recorded are untainted by 
 a danger which lurks in the latest revival of that 
 114 
 
rne 
 
 ancient mystical heresy which is to some of us the 
 more ensnaring from the intermingling of vital 
 truth whereby it lives. Possibly that heresy is 
 never a more dividing influence in its self-centred 
 quietism than when, asserting that we are the 
 Universe, and essentially the God to whom we 
 pray, it reckons up righteousness by success and 
 virtue by freedom from pain. 
 
 The saints here quoted, though on many subjects 
 they use the very language and share the very 
 thoughts of the modern mystics, to a degree that is 
 almost startling, yet on this question divide from 
 them in a manner equally striking. St. Teresa, 
 St. Augustine, and St. Francis, and all their blessed 
 company, never said "we do not suffer"; but, 
 while they valued joy and health as divine gifts, they 
 welcomed, as the highest privilege, their share in the 
 wounding and the battle, whereby Love sacrifices 
 what is dearest for the uplifting of others, even 
 though they accounted all the anguish as nothing in 
 the presence of the Glory that is Eternal, that Glory 
 which is but another name for unconquerableTruth, 
 invincible Beauty, undying Love the Divine Love 
 that for them is the First and Last of all things, 
 round about whose throne the rainbow is unbroken. 
 And because the great Reality is beyond the power 
 of mortal utterance, their words are less arrogant 
 than the simpler and shallower assertions of those 
 modern opinions which think to have solved all 
 mysteries by maintaining what is, after all, but a 
 small part of the complexities of truth. 
 
 Longing passionately not only for a united Chris- 
 tendom, but for the day when the East and the West 
 
s OF 7>%ose 
 
 shall join hands in the one worship to which both 
 through the centuries have brought such ineffable 
 foreshadowings, there is much here to remind us, 
 amid those transcendental treasures of the Orient 
 which have of late been thrown open to the world, 
 that while out of the East came all the mystic 
 lore of India, out of the East also came u the 
 deathless legacy of Isaiah and the practical mys- 
 ticism of that apostle who wrote of the Divine 
 One that ' in Him we live and move and have 
 our being.' ' 
 
 116 
 
THE LADY OI< THK LAKK 
 
 i; Lady of tli< ''was first published in 
 
 1810, and in his introduction to the edition of 
 1830 twenty years later Scott tells us how Ci 
 
 i, the action of which lay among scenes so 
 beautiful and so deeply imprinted on col- 
 
 lections, was a labour of love, and it was no less 
 
 II the manners and incident/. 
 duced. The frequent custom of James IV., and 
 particularly of James V., to walk through their 
 kingdom in disguise, afforded " him, he adds, 
 "the hint of an incident, which never fails to be 
 interesting if managed with the slightest address 
 or dexterity." Every autumn for many years 
 Scott was in the habit of spending some time in 
 that "romantic country " where the plot urif< 
 itself country of which he had read and seen 
 much, but heard traditionally even more and, 
 indeed, it is not difficult to divine that this stirring 
 and beautiful romance was interwoven with the 
 very texture of his earlier life. " Oddly enough," 
 as he himself remarked, "it was in all the dignity 
 of danger, with a front and rear guard, and loaded 
 arms,' 7 that he first entered the enchant itry 
 
 that surrounds Loch Katrine when, as a very 
 young man, " a writer's apprentice " or, as we 
 should phrase it this side the Korder, a solid: 
 clerk he was entrusted with the execution of a 
 legal instrument against certain Maclarens, re- 
 fractory tenants of Stuart of AJ I fe was 
 
 117 
 
OF 
 
 accompained by a sergeant and six men from a 
 Highland regiment near Stirling, " with directions 
 to see that the messenger discharged his duty 
 fully, and that the gallant sergeant did not exceed 
 his part by committing violence or plunder." The 
 sergeant, it seems, had known Rob Roy and was 
 full of stories about him, but, as it turned out, 
 the Maclarens, against whom the expedition was 
 directed, had already fled, and there was nothing 
 in any way out of tune with the making of 
 pleasant memories. Lockhart seems to think it 
 probable that this warlike excursion was not only 
 Scott's first entrance to the Loch Katrine country, 
 but was also a part of his first visit to the veteran 
 Invernayhle himself, a friend to whom he owed 
 endless stories of Highland adventure a notable 
 visit, for it was then, as a boy of fifteen, in quite 
 the early days of his legal apprenticeship, that he 
 first beheld the Vale of Perth, with the deep and 
 eager delight in its loveliness which he has himself 
 described. "I recollect," he says, " pulling up 
 the reins, without meaning to do so, and gazing 
 on the scene before me as if I had been afraid 
 it would shift, like those in a theatre, before I 
 could distinctly observe its different parts, or con- 
 vince myself that what I saw was real. Since that 
 hour, the recollection of that inimitable landscape 
 has possessed the strongest influence over my 
 mind, and retained its place as a memorable thing, 
 while much that was influential on my own for- 
 tunes has fled from my recollection." 
 
 It was many a long year afterwards that, when 
 writing u The Lady of the Lake," he went into 
 118 
 
rne LAT>T OF me 
 
 Perthshire to verify the possibility of King James's 
 ride from the banks of Loch Vennachar to Stirling 
 Castle within the time allowed for it in the poem, 
 and, to his great delight, satisfied himself that it 
 could be done. He was the more anxious and 
 careful over every such detail because, as he him- 
 self tells us, Miss Rutherford, the aunt who was 
 so near his own age as to have grown up with 
 him in comradelike and cousinly friendship, had 
 warned him against risking a fall by issuing yet 
 another romance in verse after the immense 
 popularity and success of " The Lay of the Last 
 Minstrel " and " Marmion." " You stand high,' 1 
 she had said ; " do not rashly attempt to climb 
 higher ... a favourite will not be allowed even 
 to stumble with impunity." To which he replied 
 in the words of Montrose 
 
 " He either fears his fate too much, 
 
 Or his deserts are small, 
 Who dares not put it to the touch, 
 To win or lose it all." 
 
 In his own introduction to the edition of 1830 
 he follows this up with his charming story of the 
 friend, bred up a farmer, to whom, knowing his 
 " powerful understanding, natural good taste, and 
 warm poetical feeling," he read, loner before 
 publication, the first canto of "The Lady of the 
 Lake." This good fellow, " a passionate admirer 
 of field sports," followed the account of the stag- 
 hunt with rapt attention till it reached the point 
 at which the dogs plunged into the lake to follow 
 their master, who had stepped into the shallop 
 
 119 
 
OF 
 
 with Ellen Douglas, when he started up, struck 
 the table, and declared indignantly that " the 
 dogs must have been totally ruined by being 
 permitted to take the water after such a severe 
 chase." Scott was naturally delighted to find 
 that so good a sportsman should thus reassure 
 him by the complete illusionment. with which he 
 had followed the whole incident as though it had 
 actually happened. The author was, however, 
 somewhat disconcerted by the quickness with 
 which the same friend discovered the main secret 
 of the romance directly Fitzjames wound his 
 horn, helped probably by an old ballad in which 
 it is said of that personage, whose identity he 
 divined so readily: 
 
 " He took a bugle from his side, 
 
 He blew both loud and shrill, 
 
 And four-and-twenty belted knights 
 
 Came skipping owre the hill.'* 
 
 " This discovery," remarks Scott, " as Mr. Pepys 
 says of the rent in his camlet cloak, was but a 
 trifle, yet it troubled me ; and I was at a good 
 deal of pains to efface any marks by which I 
 thought my secret could be traced before the 
 conclusion, when I relied on it with the same 
 hope of producing effect with which the Irish 
 postboy is said to reserve a ' trot for the avenues.' ' 
 To the admirable little biography of Scott by 
 Mr. Adamb nothing need here be added, except 
 a few touches bearing directly or indirectly on 
 " The Lady of the Lake " touches which can 
 but add warmth and colour to our realisation of 
 1 20 
 
rne LAT*T OF rne 
 
 the brave, tender, vivid personality of one who 
 was man first and author afterwards, yet in whom 
 man and author were never at variance, the life 
 he lived, the aims he followed, being wholly in 
 accord with the high-hearted ideals of his romances 
 and novels. Born on August 15, 1771, to the 
 time of his death on September 21, 1832, his life 
 overflowed with noble energies and achievements 
 and untiring human fellowship. Every one knows 
 the main events of his career; his early years in 
 the office of his father, a writer to the Signet, his 
 eager devotion to literature, his long hours of 
 creative toil in the early morning before the tasks 
 of the lawyer's office could claim him, his marriage 
 in December 1797, following closely on the 
 mastery of all selfish elements of pain in an early 
 romance which left a deep mark upon his life, his 
 growing fame, his entanglement in the affairs of 
 the Ballantyne publishing house, his heroic and 
 persistent literary labours in the determination to 
 retrieve his bankruptcy. Permanently lamed as 
 the result of a fever when a mere baby, one of 
 his earliest recollections was of what happened to 
 him in his grandfather's house at Sandy Knowe, 
 where, some one having suggested that every time 
 a sheep was killed the lame baby should be swathed 
 in the warm sheepskin, he well remembered lying 
 on the floor in this odd garment while his white- 
 haired grandfather tried to coax him to crawl, 
 and an old kinsman who had been colonel of the 
 Greys a picturesque figure in cocked hat, em- 
 broidered scarlet waistcoat, light-coloured coat, and 
 milk-white locks tied in military fashion knelt on 
 
 121 
 
LEAVES OF 
 
 the floor beside him, dragging his watch, trying 
 to induce the child to creep after it. His sur- 
 roundings, like his ancestry, were quite appro- 
 priate to the makings of a Border minstrel of 
 high degree. The influences went much deeper 
 than pictured memories of grey-haired military 
 kinsmen. Mr. Adams reminds us that he was 
 descended from " Auld Watt of Harden " and his 
 wife " the Flower of Yarrow," and we may add 
 that, distant kinsmen of his own having fallen at 
 Culloden, his Jacobite feeling was deepened by 
 the stories told in his childish hearing of the cruel 
 executions at Carlisle which followed. 
 
 From his grandmother, as well as from the old 
 books that lay in the window-seat at Sandy Knowe, 
 he learned many a stirring tale of Scottish 
 brigandry and adventure, while at the same time 
 his own outdoor life, in company with flowers 
 and birds and beasts, doubtless strengthened his 
 sense of kinship with those gentle, though not 
 human, brothers and sisters ; for he tells us he 
 " was usually carried out and laid down beside 
 the old shepherd, among the crags and rocks 
 round which he fed his sheep," and, in spite of 
 his shrunk and contracted limb, this fine ''open- 
 air treatment " made of him a healthy, high- 
 spirited, and, apart from his lameness, even a 
 "sturdy child." 
 
 No reader of " The Lady of the Lake " will be 
 surprised to find that his love of horses was 
 hereditary and that in manhood he told Miss 
 Seward he regarded the horse <c as the kindest and 
 most generous of the subordinate tribes," and 
 
 122 
 
rne LAT>T OF rne 
 
 went on to say : " I hardly even except the dogs ; 
 at least they are usually so much better treated 
 that compassion for the steed should be thrown 
 into the scale when we weigh their comparative 
 merits." But his passionate feeling for animals 
 extended far beyond horses and dogs. He never 
 forgot his grudge against one distinguished 
 kinsman concerning whom he writes : 
 
 " When I was four or five years old I was 
 staying at Lessudden House, an old mansion, the 
 abode of this Raeburn. A large pigeon-house 
 was almost destroyed with starlings, then a 
 common bird, though now seldom seen. They 
 were seized in their nests and put in a bag, and I 
 think drowned, or threshed to death, or put to 
 some such end. The servants gave one to me, 
 which I in some degree tamed, and the brute of 
 a laird seized and wrung its neck. I flew at his 
 throat like a wild cat, and was torn from him with 
 no little difficulty." 
 
 In observing the place which Lufra holds in 
 the poem, it is not without interest to note that 
 Lockhart thinks "The Lady of the Lake" was 
 probably begun at Ashiestiel in the autumn of the 
 year 1809, though not published till the following 
 May, and that it was in the January of that same 
 year that Camp had died, the brave old dog who, 
 even in his last illness, would leave his mat by the 
 fire and go as far as failing strength would let 
 him to meet his beloved master, when the servant, 
 as he laid the cloth for dinner, roused him with the 
 news, u Camp, my good fellow, the Sheriff's coming 
 home by the ford," or " by the hill/' Scott's 
 
 I2 3 
 
OF 
 
 daughter said she had never seen her father look 
 so sad as when he was smoothing down the turf 
 over Camp's grave while the whole family stood 
 round in tears. He was to have dined out that 
 night, but excused himself on the ground of " the 
 death of a dear old friend." 
 
 Scott's virtues were of the high and passionate 
 order, and far removed from the mere negations 
 of a weak or small nature. Integrity, purity, 
 honour these were with him the knightly rule 
 of life, the daily affirmations through those deeds 
 which wove the poetry of life itself in that 
 strenuous career of his. He early wrote : " ' My 
 mind to me a kingdom is.' I am a rightful 
 monarch, and, God to aid, I will not be dethroned 
 by any rebellious passion that may rear its standard 
 against me." That mind, which was indeed his 
 well-ruled kingdom, was stored to overflowing 
 with tales of Border chivalry and romance. He 
 had no need for research when he sat down to 
 write u The Lady of the Lake " in those early 
 morning hours at Ashestiel which provoked Miss 
 Rutherford's questioning. 
 
 In the measure of "The Lay of the Last Min- 
 strel," suggested, he tells us, by Coleridge's 
 " Christabel," he had now become a familiar and 
 practised rhymer. And if mind and hand were 
 ready, it is certain that his heart also leapt to the 
 congenial effort. We know where the scene of 
 the poem is laid, and it is interesting to remember 
 that Lockhart, commenting on a letter from one 
 of his friends who feared it might go ill with 
 Scott when the woman he had long loved and half 
 124 
 
<THS LAT>T OF me 
 
 hoped to win became the wife of another, remarked 
 that "Scott had, however, in all likelihood, digested 
 his agony during a solitary ride in the Highlands." 
 That was thirteen years earlier, and when Scott 
 wrote " The Lady of the Lake " he had long been 
 a happy husband and father. At the time when 
 destiny withdrew from him what had been the 
 hope of so many years, he had not permitted any 
 bitterness to hold dominion over him, and had 
 thrown himself eagerly into all that could healthily 
 absorb every leisure moment outside his daily 
 tasks translations, poems, Border minstrelsy, 
 militia duties, and all " the little nameless unre- 
 membered acts of kindness and of love" that 
 marked his career at all times ; and within a year 
 after the destruction of his long-cherished dream, 
 he had met the lady of his final choice and pledged 
 to her that faithful devotion which blessed the 
 married life of both. Yet perhaps it is not 
 fanciful to find in the romance of " The Lady of 
 the Lake " not only the charm of buoyant happi- 
 ness, but also of a certain self-mastery and 
 chivalrous apprehension of moral strength, all the 
 more vital for 
 
 " A tinge it may be of their silent pain 
 Who have longed deeply once and longed in 
 vain/' 
 
 No appreciation of "The Lady of the Lake" would 
 be complete which could fail to note Ruskin's 
 quotation in " Sesame and Lilies " of two lovely 
 descriptive lines concerning Ellen Douglas, and the 
 flower which she herself chose as her emblem : 
 
 125 
 
OF 
 
 " Even the light harebell raised its head, 
 Elastic from her airy tread." 
 
 <c But it is little," adds Ruskin, " to say of a woman 
 that she only does not destroy where she passes. 
 She should revive : the harebells should bloom, 
 not stoop, as she passes." It is interesting, by the 
 way, to note the intermingling of influences at the 
 close of the eighteenth and the beginning of the 
 nineteenth centuries. In Scott's early childish 
 days Dr. Duncan almost the only visitor in his 
 grandfather's house at Sandy Knowe, a visitor 
 who was very impatient of the child's shouting 
 recitation of his favourite ballad, " Hardyknute," 
 and on one occasion exclaimed, "One may as well 
 speak in the mouth of a cannon as where that child 
 is " was old enough to remember having seen 
 Pope and many of his distinguished contemporaries. 
 Scott was in his fifteenth year when he met 
 Burns, who died in the same year as that in which 
 his own first volume of ballads was published. 
 The meeting occurred in the house of Professor 
 Ferguson, in the presence of Dugald Stuart and 
 other literary folk, one evening when Burns was 
 deeply moved "by a print of Bunbury's repre- 
 senting a soldier lying dead on the snow, his dog 
 sitting in misery on the one side, and on the other 
 his widow, with a child in her arms." Scott was 
 a warm friend and literary admirer of Joanna 
 Baillie, and exchanged letters with Coleridge, as 
 well as with Goethe. On one occasion he quotes 
 Coleridge in support of his own belief that locality 
 plays a considerable part in the individual appeal of 
 126 
 
LAT>T OF rne 
 
 much modern verse. Coleridge's name naturally 
 calls to mind that of Southey, and the fact that 
 Scott's earliest contribution to the Edinburgh 
 Review dealt with some of Southey's work. Sir 
 Walter's intercourse with the Wordsworths in 
 1 803 is full of the deepest interest. Space forbids 
 anything but the most cursory mention of his 
 friendship with Rogers and the two Hebers, and 
 of all that he did for James Hogg, " the Ettrick 
 shepherd," nor is it possible to make more than a 
 brief allusion to Crabbe's exclamation when he 
 read " The Poacher " in imitation of his own 
 heroic couplet : " This man, whoever he is, can 
 do all that I can do, and something more." 
 Scott's analysis of the character of Byron, whom he 
 knew well, both directly and through their common 
 friend Tom Moore, is very shrewd. In remem- 
 bering that he was the contemporary not only of 
 Cowper, but also of Keats and Shelley, to say 
 nothing of Leigh Hunt, though he lived so much 
 longer than any of them, there is a whimsical 
 pleasure in the coincidence that in one of the 
 letters in " Red Gauntlet," published a few years 
 after that exquisite lyric of Shelley's beginning 
 
 " One word is too often profaned 
 For me to profane it," 
 
 " Green Mantle " writes : " I will not use the name 
 of love on this occasion : for I have applied it too 
 often to transient whims and fancies to escape 
 your satire should I venture to apply it now. For 
 it is a phrase, I must confess, which I have used 
 a romancer would say, profaned a little too often" 
 
 127 
 
OF 
 
 Scott's modesty about his own work came out 
 in a very amusing way in relation to " The Lady 
 of the Lake." James Ballantyne remembers 
 coming into his library soon after its publication 
 and asking his daughter : " Well, Miss Sophia, how 
 do you like ' The Lady of the Lake ' ? " Her answer 
 was given with perfect simplicity : " Oh, I have not 
 read it ; papa says there's nothing so bad for 
 young people as reading bad poetry.'' It was 
 about the same time that his little boy came home 
 from school after a fight which had been pro- 
 voked by his indignation at being, as he thought, 
 compared to a girl, his companions having dubbed 
 him " The Lady of the Lake," a title which to him 
 meant nothing. Indeed it was the same child 
 who, having been asked why people showed to his 
 father more reverence than to his uncles, after 
 considering for a minute or two, replied very 
 gravely: "It is commonly him that sees the hare 
 sitting." 
 
 It may be interesting to add, on the authority 
 of Mr. Robert Cadell, that "from the date of the 
 publication of ' The Lady of the Lake ' the post- 
 horse duty in Scotland rose in an extraordinary 
 degree, and indeed it continued to do so regularly 
 for a number of years, the author's succeeding 
 works keeping up the enthusiasm for our scenery 
 which he had thus originally created." 
 
 Mr. Cadell also supplied Lockhart with the 
 following details: "The quarto edition of 2050 
 copies disappeared instantly, and was followed in 
 the course of the same year by four editions in 
 octavo, viz., one of 3000, a second of 3250, and 
 128 
 
THS LAT>T OF THS 
 
 a third and a fourth each of 6000 copies ; thus, 
 in the space of a few months, the extraordinary 
 number of 20,000 copies were disposed of. In 
 the next year, 1811, there was another edition of 
 3000; there was one of 2000 in 1814; another 
 of 2000 in 1815 ; of 2000 again in 1819; and 
 two, making between them 2500, appeared in 
 1825 : since which time * The Lady of the Lake,' 
 in collective editions of his poetry, and in separate 
 issues, must have circulated to the extent of at 
 least 20,000 copies more. So that down to the 
 month of July 1836 the legitimate sale in Great 
 Britain had been not less than 50,000 copies." 
 
 " The Lay of the Last Minstrel " is by many 
 set higher than "The Lady of the Lake," but un- 
 biased criticism is perhaps scarcely possible from 
 the present writer, who in days of earliest child- 
 hood fell in love first with " The Lady of the 
 Lake," and yielded to the enchantment of its 
 romantic verse a childish loyalty, which preceded 
 and in some degree awakened the love of poetry 
 in the stricter sense. It is easy here and there to 
 find fault with the occasional jog-trot or jerkiness 
 of the octosyllabic verse, but it has been well said 
 that in a stirring gallop over open country what 
 is most needed is the sense of vitality and verve, 
 and there can be no doubt that the sympathetic 
 reader is effectually carried away. Paradoxical 
 though it may seem, possibly the poem owes 
 somewhat of its gaiety and recklessness to the 
 complete mastery of rich and varied lore which 
 lay behind it. For the absence of mental effort 
 or strain may well have added to its limpid clear- 
 
 i 129 
 
OF 
 
 ness and spontaneity, which are fresh and sweet 
 as the pure laughter of children, or of a Scottish 
 mountain stream as it sparkles among the flashing 
 pebbles. Yet to say this is to express but little 
 of its deeper charm. 
 
 Clearly as the mountains which surround Loch 
 Katrine are mirrored in its lucid depths, in this 
 enchanting little romance are reflected the noblest 
 characteristics of Sir Walter Scott. Men loved 
 him, not for his pardonable ambition to give an 
 added glory to a family already rich in high and 
 quixotic traditions, still less for his boyish deter- 
 mination to embody at Abbotsford some semblance 
 of his feudal dreams, but for his large-hearted 
 chivalry, his high integrity, his warm, quick- 
 beating heart of passion, his essential purity and 
 magnanimity. 
 
 Well may Swinburne say of him, in his essay 
 on that last published edition of his journal from 
 which we have here quoted : " While the language 
 in which he writes endures, while the human nature 
 to which he addressed himself exists, there can be 
 no end of the delight, the thanksgiving, and the 
 honour with which men will salute, aloud or in 
 silence, the utterance or the remembrance of his 
 
 name." 
 
 130 
 
AN EASTER REVERIE 
 
 THOUSANDS who are not of the Christian faith feel 
 year by year the Earth's Easter parable, and that 
 faith is the richer in significance for those beauti- 
 ful myths, of many ages and many races, that have 
 now been crowned and consummated in our story 
 of the risen Master. 
 
 Deep within the heart of man lies the key to 
 the divine hieroglyph whereby he reads of a beauty 
 above and beyond and about him. Some may read 
 at leisure whole chapters at a time. Others must 
 drudge so hard that the messages reach them in 
 instantaneous flashes between heavy tasks : the 
 vision of the year's first golden blossom, perhaps, 
 as they wash the doorstep with hands benumbed by 
 the bitterness of winter and soul still drowsy from 
 the sleep of exhaustion ; or a sudden glory of the 
 river when the noonday sky leans its brightness on 
 its heaving bosom, as they toil for hard-won bread 
 in the docks. 
 
 Happy are they who, at morning, when the sun 
 goeth forth as a bridegroom, can pause for awhile 
 to read the sentence enscrolled in the heavens, and 
 at eventide can once more pause in the temple when 
 
 " A certain moment cuts 
 The deed off, calls the glory from the grey : 
 A whisper from the west 
 Shoots ' Add this to the rest, 
 Take it and try its worth : here dies another 
 day.' " 
 
OF 
 
 The sunsets here in the south have of late been 
 of extraordinary beauty, and of a delicate, austere 
 charm that befits the leafless trees, the early twi- 
 light, the ascetic inclemency of the hard-fought 
 days. Again and again has it happened of late 
 that the sky, after the first going down of the sun, 
 has been a sea of wondrous pale green, on which 
 the apple-bloom clouds of rare pale rose-colour 
 have made long peaceful lines far above the horizon, 
 to the north-west of the clear golden splendour 
 above the vanished light. The bare trees and fields 
 do but emphasise the solemn loveliness, and seem 
 to await in grave stillness the rising of the moon 
 and the coming forth of the stars. 
 
 " Come, blessed barrier between day and day ! " 
 
 What, in that haunting and perfect line, Words- 
 worth has said of sleep, is what many a strenuous 
 spirit has felt about the last sleep of all. "The 
 New Mysticism" hints at the abolition of earthly 
 death, but perhaps in the innermost heart of us 
 we shrink back a little from that thought. Dear 
 and beautiful is the earth, full of sights and sounds 
 and old familiar faces that we love with steadfast 
 passion and cling to, as more to us than any unseen 
 heaven ; but, even as we gaze at them, they are 
 subject to the law of change, and we know that to 
 remain unchanged, among the ever changing, would 
 be a loneliness far deeper than that mysterious 
 change which can but deepen our consciousness of 
 the reality we sought in them, and, with them, shall 
 thereafter more completely behold. There is a 
 small butterfly, with wings of celestial azure, which 
 132 
 
haunts warm coast-lands and is a veritable type of 
 Psyche. If the chrysalis from which it awoke 
 were capable of thought, it would be hard to 
 believe that it would desire the endless exist- 
 ence of a glorified and perfected chrysalis. Some 
 strange foreboding there would be that 
 
 " The ends of being and ideal grace " 
 
 would be missed, if the chrysalis, qua chrysalis, did 
 not die. 
 
 " The New Mysticism ! " that is the title of an 
 eloquent volume which suggests many uplifting 
 thoughts even to those who regard a part of its 
 " new " doctrine as an old and dangerous heresy. 
 " If Being and Existence are one,'' writes the 
 author, " one and indivisible ; if man's soul is the 
 expression of Eternal Spirit ; if our life does 
 depend upon * every word that proceedeth out of 
 the mouth of God/ is it any wonder that we perish 
 when we feed our minds as we do on words that 
 have no Spirit or Life in them, on words which 
 have only a spurious vitality of defective thought 
 and feeling ? When we come to examine the kind 
 of stuff we try to live on, we are surprised that we 
 should be able to last as long as we do. It literally 
 is 'such stuff as dreams are made of shadowy, 
 ghostly stuff of appearances, the picture of the 
 world of effects, the reflection of sense experience 
 with no substance in it." 
 
 It has been well written, "The eyes that see the 
 King in His beauty will see nothing else, for every- 
 thing will reflect that beauty." Nothing else? 
 Nothing but the beauty of that Presence, even in 
 
 133 
 
OF 
 
 our darkling lives here on earth? If that be so, 
 then indeed was Tennyson right when he wrote 
 that they who have attained to that open vision 
 behold us, whom they still love, 
 
 " With larger other eyes than ours, 
 To make allowance for us all." 
 
 We weep that we seem to be divided from them ; 
 
 "And yet, this may be less so than appears, 
 This change and separation. Sparrows five 
 For just two farthings, and God cares for each. 
 If God is not too great for little cares, 
 Is any creature, because gone to God ? " 
 
 134 
 
FORGOTTEN BOOKS 
 V. A PASTORAL 
 
 ARTHUR HUGH CLOUGH is not forgotten. His 
 immortality is secured, not only by the haunting 
 and individual sincerity of such lyrics as " Qua 
 Cursum Ventis," "A London Idyll," and " Qui 
 Laborat Orat," but also by Matthew Arnold's 
 " Thyrsis,'' in which the unanswerable pathos is 
 the more moving because it breathes through the 
 fragrance and blossoming of the year's loveliest 
 season. For, taking to heart the storms and 
 sorrows that raged outside his peaceful Oxford, 
 and the "life of men unblest," is he not tenderly 
 reproached for leaving the world too soon, like 
 that "too quick despairer," who flies away before 
 the fulness of the summer has come : 
 
 "So, some tempestuous morn in early June, 
 When the year's primal burst of bloom is o'er, 
 
 Before the roses and the longest day 
 When garden-walks, and all the grassy floor, 
 With blossoms red and white of fallen May 
 
 And chestnut-flowers are strewn 
 So have I heard the cuckoo's parting cry, 
 
 From the wet field, through the vext garden- 
 trees, 
 Come with the volleying rain and tossing 
 
 breeze : 
 
 The bloom is gone, and with the bloom go 
 I!" 
 
 '35 
 
OF 
 
 Time has not conquered Clough, but only 
 given him a more recognised place among the 
 nineteenth-century poets. 
 
 Nevertheless, as a social reformer and prose- 
 writer, he is not much remembered, and, to most 
 of the men and women who throng our London 
 streets, the most fascinating and humorous of his 
 longer poems, that " Long Vacation Pastoral " to 
 which he gave the name of " The Bothie of 
 Tober-na-Vuolich '' is indeed a book either for- 
 gotten or unknown. Yet how it brims with 
 practical philosophy and sweet laughter and sound 
 common sense ! 
 
 It may well be open to discussion how far, in 
 the strictest sense of the word, it is a " poem " at 
 all. It certainly does not pretend to the exquisite 
 melody and precision of lyric touch which dis- 
 tinguish " Ite Domum Saturae, Venit Hesperus," 
 that mountain cattle-song in which, through all 
 its spontaneity and music, there breathes the same 
 open-eyed and paradoxically childlike acceptance 
 of life's ironic possibilities and insouciant charm, 
 and of the fact that 
 
 " work we must, and what we see, we see. 
 And God he knows, and what must be, must 
 be." 
 
 Clough's courage is almost always the fortitude 
 of endurance rather than the reckless dash of 
 bravado. He faces, in all directions, the com- 
 plexities of life and the fact that man's finite under- 
 standing is but a clumsy foot-rule, after all, for 
 the measuring of immeasurable spaces. He never 
 
 136 
 
BOOKS 
 
 makes that a reason in favour of shirking the plain 
 mandate for its use, in so far as it can be used, 
 but only against imagining that there ever can be 
 a moment at which it has passed beyond its own 
 boundaries. In much of-his best work there is a 
 ceatain half-melancholy grace of patience, of self- 
 command, of hope that is never an unreasonable 
 hope a grace enlivened often by humour so 
 delicate as to be akin, not to mere ordinary 
 laughter, but to that wistful jesting which may 
 give the hint of coming tears. 
 
 Perhaps one reason why his simplest lyrics touch 
 us so deeply and haunt us so effectually is found 
 in a certain economy not only of language but of 
 feeling ; for, in the memoir edited by his wife, we 
 read that " His absolute sincerity of thought, his 
 intense feeling of reality, rendered it impossible 
 for him to produce anything superficial, and 
 therefore actually curtailed the amount of his 
 creations." 
 
 In a review which he wrote on the poems of 
 Alexander Smith and on those two volumes of 
 Matthew Arnold which appeared under the title 
 of " Poems by A./' he says of the former : " These 
 poems were not written among books and busts, 
 nor yet 
 
 " ' By shallow rivers, to whose falls 
 Melodious birds sing madrigals.' 
 
 They have something substantive and lifelike, 
 immediate and first-hand about them. There is a 
 charm, for example, in finding, as we do, con- 
 tinual images drawn from the busy seats of 
 
 137 
 
OF 
 
 industry ; it seems to satisfy a want that we have 
 long been conscious of, when we see the black 
 streams that welter out of factories, the dreary 
 lengths of urban and suburban dustiness, 
 
 " ' The squares and streets 
 
 And the faces that one meets,' 
 
 irradiated with a gleam of divine purity. 
 
 |C There are moods when one is prone to believe 
 that, in these last days, no longer by ' clear spring 
 or shady grove,' no more upon any Pindus or 
 Parnassus, or by the side of any Castaly, are the 
 true and lawful haunts of the poetic powers ; but, 
 we could believe, if anywhere, in the blank and 
 desolate streets, and upon the solitary bridges of 
 the midnight city, where Guilt is, and wild Temp- 
 tation, and the dire Compulsion of what has once 
 been done there, with these tragic sisters around 
 him, and with pity also, and pure Compassion, 
 and pale Hope, that looks like despair, and Faith 
 in the garb of doubt, there walks the discrowned 
 Apollo, with unstrung lyre ; nay, and could he 
 sound it, those mournful muses would scarcely 
 be able, as of old, to respond and 'sing in turn 
 with their beautiful voices.' " 
 
 How discerning is this also from the same 
 forgotten essay : 
 
 " The lessons of reflectiveness and the maxims 
 of caution do not appear to be more needful or 
 more appropriate than exhortations to steady 
 courage and calls to action. There is something 
 certainly of an over-educated weakness of purpose 
 in Western Europe not in Germany only, or 
 
 138 
 
BOOKS 
 
 France, but also in more busy England. There 
 is a disposition to press too far the finer and 
 subtler intellectual and moral susceptibilities : to 
 insist upon following out, as they say, to their 
 logical consequence, the notice of some organ of 
 the spiritual nature ; a proceeding which, perhaps, 
 is hardly more sensible in the grown man than it 
 would be in the infant to refuse to correct the 
 sensations of sight by those of touch." 
 
 Just as his plea for action comes with special 
 weight from one who must have had all the 
 impeding difficulties of subtle self-analysis to 
 contend with, so the very fact of his honest 
 scepticism adds profoundly to the value of that 
 unconquerable faith to which he won through 
 many-sided doubt. 
 
 His sense of brotherhood was too deep and 
 strong to find facile expression, but, turning to 
 his speeches at Oxford, we find that, when the 
 subject of debate was that " the character of a 
 gentleman was in the present day made too much 
 of," "Clough spoke neither for nor against the 
 proposition ; but for an hour and a half well on 
 two hours he went into the origin of the ideal, 
 historically tracing from mediaeval times how much 
 was implied originally in the notion of a ' gentle 
 knight ' truthfulness, consideration for others 
 (even self-sacrifice), courtesy, and the power of 
 giving outward expression to those moral qualities. 
 From this high standard he traced the deteriora- 
 tion into the modern Brummagem pattern which 
 gets the name," and then he added : " I have 
 known peasant men and women in the humblest 
 
 139 
 
OF 
 
 places in whom dwell these qualities as truly as 
 they ever did in the best of lords and ladies, and 
 who had invented for themselves a whole economy 
 of manners to express them, who were very * poets 
 of courtesy.' ' 
 
 This takes us by a natural transition to his 
 " Bothie of Tober-na-Vuolich." 
 
 The Bothie of Tober-na-Vuolich is the Scotch 
 farmhouse to which Philip Hewson, Radical and 
 poet, is invited, as an incidental result of his 
 ironical allusion to the Game Laws, in a speech 
 made at a dinner given to the Highland peasantry, 
 to which he and his fellow-Oxonians had been 
 welcomed as guests while out on a reading party. 
 But, though the young Radical is the hero of the 
 " pastoral " (which is, by the way, a skilful experi- 
 ment in English hexameters), the poem turns 
 not so much on politics, in the narrow sense 
 of the word, as on social ethics in general, and 
 especially on the ethics of marriage : 
 
 " Stately is service accepted, but lovelier service 
 
 rendered, 
 
 Interchange of service the law and condition of 
 beauty." 
 
 Those two lines strike the keynote of the whole, 
 but it is far indeed from being a mere sermon, 
 and mingles the joy of wild mountain scenery 
 cool tarn and mountain torrent and golden-chang- 
 ing autumn trees with the peculiar charm of 
 Oxford and the brimming gaiety of undergraduate 
 life. Philip had to buy practical wisdom at the 
 140 
 
BOOKS 
 
 usual price in the market, and to learn that the 
 romantic charm of poverty may be as factitious 
 in its way as the dazzling glamour of wealth or 
 the far more dazzling glamour of passion ; but, 
 in the end, he finds his mate in a woman as strong 
 and good as she is beautiful, the daughter of a 
 peasant, of clear and bright intellect and intuitions 
 full of the tender refinement of a high and noble 
 nature, as well as of that deep and faithful affection 
 without which no wisdom is really wise. It is in 
 the Bothie of Tober-na-Vuolich that he finds her, 
 but we are tempted to give in his own words his 
 earliest vision of what love is and how it rebukes 
 the lackadaisical fancies of mere fashion : 
 
 '* Oh, if they knew and considered, unhappy ones ! 
 oh, could they see, could 
 
 But for a moment discern, how the blood of true 
 gallantry kindles, 
 
 How the old knightly religion, the chivalry semi- 
 quixotic 
 
 Stirs in the veins of a man at seeing some deli- 
 cate woman 
 
 Serving him, toiling for him, and the world ; 
 some tenderest girl, now 
 
 Over-weighted, expectant, of him, is it ? Who 
 shall, if only 
 
 Duly her burden be lightened, not wholly re- 
 moved from her, mind you, 
 
 Lightened if but by the love, the devotion man 
 only can offer, 
 
 Grand on her pedestal rise as urn-bearing statue 
 of Hellas ; 
 
 141 
 
OF 
 
 Oh, could they feel at such moments how man's 
 
 heart, as into Eden 
 Carried anew, seems to see, like the gardener of 
 
 earth uncorrupted, 
 Eve from the hand of her Maker advancing, an 
 
 help meet for him, 
 Eve from his own flesh taken, a spirit restored 
 
 to his spirit, 
 Spirit but not spirit only, himself whatever 
 
 himself is, 
 Unto the mystery's end sole helpmate meet to 
 
 be with him ; 
 Oh, if they saw it and knew it ; we soon should 
 
 see them abandon 
 Boudoir, toilette, carriage, drawing-room, and 
 
 ball-room, 
 Satin for worsted exchange, gros-de-naples for 
 
 plain linsey-woolsey, 
 Sandals of silk for clogs, for health lackadaisical 
 
 fancies!" 
 
 One of the finest passages, though too long to 
 quote, is that which begins u But as the light of 
 
 day enters some populous city ," in which the 
 
 redeeming power of dawn is used as an image 
 of the redeeming and unifying power of love in the 
 midst of modern life : 
 
 " So that the whole great wicked artificial civilised 
 
 fabric 
 
 All its unfinished houses, lots for sale, and rail- 
 way out-works 
 Seems re-accepted, resumed to Primal Nature and 
 
 Beauty ! " 
 142 
 
Singularly beautiful also is Elspie's vision of 
 what Philip is to her in her ideal and her work. 
 
 She has been describing the laborious upbuilding 
 of her own life, as of one side of a bridge : 
 
 u Sometimes I find myself dreaming at nights about 
 
 arches and bridges, 
 Sometimes I dream of a great invisible hand 
 
 coming down, and 
 Dropping the great key-stone in the middle : 
 
 there in my dreaming, 
 There I felt the great key-stone coming in, and 
 
 through it 
 Feel the other part all the other stones of the 
 
 archway 
 Joined into mine with a strange happy sense of 
 
 completeness/' 
 
 It was Clough who wrote : " To earn his own 
 bread honestly in the strictest sense of the word 
 honestly to do plain, straightforward work or 
 business well and thoroughly, not with mere eye 
 service for the market, is really quite a sufficient 
 task for the ordinary mortal." 
 
 But what to this man was included in the day's 
 u plain straightforward work " is implied in the 
 fact that he once walked for four days over a rough 
 country to get medicine for the sick child of a 
 peasant stranger in the Highlands ; and that he 
 seems to have regarded this as a simple act of 
 elementary duty. 
 
ROSES 
 
 GIFTS for a lover, most exquisite roses ! 
 
 Love, who uncloses 
 Your leaves, to uncover 
 
 Summer's own sweetness, uplifts far above her 
 Messages brought by her, brought by the summer : 
 (Ah, tho' she brought them, He only, He wrought 
 
 them /) 
 Love made the roses, not any chance comer. 
 
 Crimson of burning, your heart- petals fashion- 
 Whiteness of passion 
 To blushes returning, 
 
 Gold of the sunset and dim divine yearning, 
 Pale as the dawn-star when day dawns above him ! 
 (Fragrance, the soul of them, breathes thro 1 the 
 
 whole of them ) 
 Roses, the Rose-maker wants us to love Him ! 
 
 144 
 
BETWEEN THE RAINS 
 
 IT seems that the earth is thankful and the trees 
 rejoice. The nights of soft refreshing rain have 
 quieted the dusty ground, and now the south 
 wind swings her censer thro' the fir-woods, and 
 even the alabaster box once broken by a woman's 
 hands can scarcely have poured forth a fragrance 
 more celestial or more penetrating. The rain we 
 still ask for rain and yet more rain gives 
 promise of descending speedily from the brooding, 
 dove-coloured skies that earlier in the day have 
 been white and blue and pearl-colour, with delicious 
 April-like changes of passing showers, on this 
 May morning. But the sweet outpouring of the 
 clouds through many an hour of this week's 
 nights and days has already wrought miracles. 
 May-flowering tulips, crimson and white, have 
 unfolded. The mountain ash is full of blossom, 
 and I have just seen a whole border of self-sown 
 nemophila in full glory of heavenly azure, while, 
 hard by, the pansies and violas in my friend's 
 garden looked on the graceful white Italian sun- 
 dial, near the climbing passion-flower, as yet only 
 in leaf. The lupins, blue and white, are in bud, 
 and in the same bed, bordered by the golden 
 Alison, now in full splendour, I noticed, to my 
 amazement, that some of the rhododendrons are 
 already shedding their bloom ! Nay, more, the 
 sycamore, which a fortnight ago was full of 
 blossom, is now dangling its little bunches of 
 
 K 145 
 
OF <pi{pse 
 
 keys. The laburnums are showing their pale 
 gold, and the white lilac is at the height of its 
 beauty. Its homelier neighbour, with its clean 
 country smell, is very lavish this year in bloom 
 and in sweetness, now that it is no longer dried 
 up with thirst, and it adorns the gardens of rich 
 and poor alike, 
 
 " With many a pointed blossom, rising delicate, 
 
 with the perfume strong I love, 
 With every leaf a miracle." 
 
 The red and green blossoms of the arbor vitae 
 have long ago turned to fruit, but the chestnuts 
 have lighted their lovely lamps among the green, 
 and many of the roses are in bud, though the 
 " heaps of the guelder-rose" are most of them 
 still but half out. The limes have scattered the 
 tiny, dainty pink spathes that held their freshly 
 unfolded leaves, and before we know we shall have 
 June standing in the doorway, and be haunted by 
 Browning's Garden Fancies : 
 
 " Where I find her not beauties vanish ; 
 Whither I follow her, beauties flee ; 
 Is there no method to tell her in Spanish 
 
 June's twice June since she breathed it with 
 me ? " 
 
 I have heard the wood-pigeons making love in 
 a little copse just off the common, but the robins 
 are quieter than usual, and thrushes and black- 
 birds seem still for a while to have lowered their 
 jubilant outpourings in a pause, whether of bliss 
 or of expectancy, while we wait for the further 
 146 
 
plenitude of the coming rain. As I left a cottage 
 where Death had just taken by the hand one of 
 the children who used to come running to meet 
 me when I passed along the lane, the " wandering 
 voice" of the cuckoo seemed to echo with a 
 mellower and more plaintive sweetness than its 
 wont from the far horizon, and thinking of the 
 boy's mother and how cold and frozen had seemed 
 all that I could strive to say to her of my own 
 certainty that " it is well with the child," I longed 
 for that " fountain of tears " whereof Arthur 
 O'Shaughnessy wrote before he entered the " un- 
 discovered country " : 
 
 " You may feel, when a falling leaf brushes 
 
 Your face, as though some one had kiss'd you ; 
 Or think at least some one who miss'd you 
 
 Had sent you a thought, if that cheers ; 
 Or a bird's little song, faint and broken, 
 May pass for a tender word spoken : 
 
 Enough, while around you there rushes 
 
 That life-drowning torrent of tears. 
 
 u But the floods and the tears meet and gather ; 
 The sound of them all grows like thunder : 
 O into what bosom, I wonder, 
 Is pour'd the whole sorrow of years ? 
 For Eternity only seems keeping 
 Account of the great human weeping : 
 May God, then, the Maker and Father 
 May He find a place for the tears ! " 
 
NEIGHBOURING GARDENS 
 
 THEY are all -parterres in Allah's Garden ; for His 
 garden embraces the blossoming of the rose as well 
 as the mystic splendour of the desert. In every 
 unbrutalised heart that poet finds an echo who 
 wrote that 
 
 " A garden is a lovesome thing, God wot." 
 
 There are three gardens here that neighbour one 
 another, and, though all are well loved and toiled 
 for, some who know them might almost maintain, 
 perhaps, that the smallest of the three betrays 
 the most cherishing care, the most thoughtfully 
 fastidious choice of effects. It lies embosomed in 
 trees and greensward, and crowds an amazing 
 variety of precious things into its tiny rock-garden, 
 in which the straight, narrow paths are hardly more 
 than six feet long in their miniature mazes. 
 
 The Norwegian pine in the further corner of the 
 lawn seems to have come straight out of Hans 
 Andersen's fairy tales, and the garden itself is 
 tended by a maiden worthy of his legends, fearless, 
 and regardless of the winds of our English climate, 
 waking with the sun all the year round, a skilled 
 musician, an experienced bee-keeper, and the owner 
 of one of the best herbariums in the county. But 
 she is only chief of the staff to the owners of the 
 garden, and its master makes of it all a love-offer- 
 ing to its mistress, a chatelaine still often in the 
 " land of pain " an exile from her beloved garden. 
 148 
 
Therefore it is full of sweet perfumes and rare 
 colours : celestial blue in the borders, scarlet 
 and flaming orange here and there among the 
 dark foliage, white and delicate yellow and all 
 shades of madder and brown in its masses of 
 viola. 
 
 But the heart of the garden is its rosery. Roses 
 of every form and hue, from purest white and 
 creamy gold and pale pink, to the deepest, most 
 delicious crimson and the sunset glow of rosy, 
 transparent lemon-colour. Tea-roses especially are 
 the glory of this garden ; and, now that the season 
 is late and their blooming less abundant, exquisite 
 shades of crimson make an open glory in their 
 midst,where elect pentstemons have been cunningly 
 planted among them, to defeat all idea of formality 
 or primness, in one large, luxuriant rose-bed. The 
 sweet, poignant odour of the white jasmine floats 
 down to them from that sunny wall of the house 
 where wistaria has bloomed before it ; and all about 
 the fruit-beds hide lovely things with learned 
 names ivory white and dimmest blue while the 
 purple clematis flaunts it about the windows that 
 look on the lawn. 
 
 But the big garden, that runs this charming 
 demesne very close, possesses the overmastering 
 charm of great stately elms and beeches not to 
 mention one magnificent cedar-tree the charm, 
 too, of winding shrubberies and lovers' walks ; 
 benches from which to watch the sun set over the 
 orchard or behind the distant village spire ; a great 
 sense of space and u retired-leisure," and the 
 antiquity that has seen many generations come 
 
 149 
 
OF 
 
 and go, and hides within its depths endless romances 
 and joys and sorrows. Ah, well ! no small modern 
 garden, however alluring, can ever have quite the 
 fascination of these fields of poetry that have 
 grown up half of themselves and take the heart 
 back to that garden where Jane Eyre talked with 
 Rochester, or that glorious mingling of flowers 
 and fruit-trees where Hetty Sorrel picked red 
 currants, or that other garden where Vernon Whit- 
 ford fell asleep. 
 
 The roses on which its mistress spends so much 
 loving labour, glorious and generous though they 
 be in fragrance and in colour, may perhaps be 
 rivalled, though the Gloire de Dijon on the loggia 
 would be hard to beat, and the daintily pencilled 
 salpiglossis, in which she takes such pride, may 
 find competitors in newer gardens. But the garden 
 itself, as it stretches out behind the dazzling scarlet 
 and green where geraniums and begonias flash 
 their brightness, has all the glamour of "im- 
 memorial elms '' and half-forgotten days and 
 bygone dreams. 
 
 Yet the third garden, embraced by one of the 
 loveliest and most peaceful estates in the Midlands, 
 equally old and spacious, and presided over by 
 three lovely young goddesses worthy alike of the 
 " lovesome spot " and of their father, the ideal 
 country rector all enchanting and each one 
 different from the other this third garden is a 
 Garden of Eden without any forbidding sword. 
 
 Its tall hollyhocks and spreading cedars have 
 their counterparts in the other garden ; but the 
 smell of its yew-hedges in the sun, and the sweetness 
 150 
 
of the big lavender-bush, which holds a story 
 characteristic of the rector's kind heart, the close 
 neighbourhood of the homely and ancient village 
 church, the mingling of all estates and orders of 
 men and women among those who find its gates 
 ever open to them and its simple hospitality 
 always at their service all these things leave in- 
 describable memories in those hidden places of 
 the soul that, Jong afterwards, like Wordsworth's 
 daffodils, help to make the bliss of many a 
 solitude. 
 
 Of all the three gardens it may be said that half 
 their beauty lies in the fact that they give Nature 
 a little of her own way and have not been pruned 
 to death. Old Quarles would have loved them ; 
 for in his " Hieroglyphs on the Life of Man," 
 beginning with the folly of over-zeal in such 
 matters, he goes on to touch on the deep mystery 
 on which many a wise modern physician is begin- 
 ning to rely a mystery which holds the attention 
 of all those who grope after the idea that the true 
 remedy for human withering and weakness may lie 
 deep in that well-spring of being which is but 
 another name for the divine sonship of man. Of 
 flowers and flames he makes his imagery, but in 
 the main he is not hard to follow. 
 
 No brief is held for Quarles, or for what may be 
 but a half-truth at the best, but he clothes it in a 
 quaint bit of rhyme, of which a snatch will make 
 a pretty tag to this string of holiday recollections, 
 even though it be quoted but in fragmentary and 
 skipping fashion ; and those who like it not may 
 yet smile at the conceit : 
 
OF 
 
 "Always pruning, always cropping, 
 Is her brightness still obscur'd ? 
 Ever dressing, ever topping ? 
 Always curing, never cur'd ? 
 
 You that always are bestowing 
 Costly pains in life's repairing, 
 Are but always overthrowing 
 Nature's work by over-caring : 
 
 Nature worketh for the better, 
 If not hinder'd that she cannot ; 
 Art stands by as her abetter, 
 Ending nothing she began not ; 
 
 But to make a trade of trying 
 Drugs and doses, always pruning, 
 Is to die for fear of dying ; 
 He's untun'd, that's always tuning. 
 
 Hold thy hand, health's dear maintainer 
 Life, perchance, may burn the stronger : 
 Having substance to sustain her, 
 She, untouch'd, may last the longer : 
 When the artist goes about 
 To redress her flame, I doubt, 
 Oftentimes he snuffs it out." 
 
 All the little gardens of earth, said the writer, 
 are a part of Allah's Garden ; but so, indeed, are 
 the wildernesses ; and in the midst of them is that 
 152 
 
true Pierian spring of which Quarles and his 
 fellow-poets have quaffed deeply, but where every 
 wayfarer and fool may quench his thirst a well- 
 spring which may have stood for much more, 
 perhaps, than we fancy the Greeks dreamed of, 
 until Plato came, and a greater even than Plato 
 one of the many dim visions of the Fountain of 
 Living Water, the Well of Life. 
 
 '53 
 
APPRECIATION OF "SCENES OF 
 CLERICAL LIFE " 
 
 [Here reprinted from " The World's Classics " by Mr. Henry 
 Frow de 1 s kind permission .] 
 
 WHEN George Eliot began to write these " Scenes 
 of Clerical Life," though she was already thirty- 
 six, and had done much valuable work in the way 
 of translation and editorial routine, she was still 
 very diffident of her own powers, and thought she 
 was lacking in certain qualifications necessary to 
 the novelist. 
 
 We have to thank George Lewes, and also, we 
 must add, Mr. Blackwood, the publisher to whom 
 Lewes submitted these first anonymous stories, for 
 the warm encouragement and sympathy which led 
 her to enrich the world by a gift so much greater 
 than she, or her friends either, had at first divined 
 in her. 
 
 Those who have not leisure to read Mr. Cross's 
 deeply interesting biography, yet desire authentic 
 knowledge of her life in relation to her work, 
 can find all they need, very succinctly and sympa- 
 thetically given, in Sir Leslie Stephen's charming 
 volume. 
 
 The setting of the three stories now before us 
 lay in that Warwickshire which George Eliot knew 
 and loved so well, the county into which her 
 father, Robert Evans, who was, as we know, more 
 or less the prototype of Adam Bede and Caleb 
 Garth, had moved his home, when he became 
 
scenes OF CLS^IC^L LIFS 
 
 agent for the Arbury estate under Francis Newdi- 
 gate, on the death of that Sir Roger Newdigate of 
 Arbury Park who was the original of Sir Chris- 
 topher Cheverel in " Mr. Gilfil's Love-story.'' 
 Harriet Poynton, Robert Evans's first wife, who 
 had died ten years before George Eliot's birth, 
 had been for many years a trusted servant and 
 friend of the Newdigate family at Arbury Park, 
 in the parish of Chilvers Coton, better known to 
 us under its pseudonym of Shepperton. Milly 
 Barton seems to have been the wife of a Mr. 
 Gwyther, curate of Chilvers Coton, who died when 
 George Eliot was sixteen years old, and had been 
 a friend of Mrs. Robert Evans, the latter being 
 the original, by the way, of Mrs. Hacket. We 
 learn also that Mr. Tryan's persecution was sug- 
 gested by an actual experience, the details, of course, 
 being altered. In " Mr. GilfiPs Love-story " the 
 excellent plot was of George Eliot's own con- 
 struction, though a certain Sally Shilton, the 
 daughter of a collier, transformed by the novelist 
 into Catharine Sarti, had really been adopted by 
 the Newdigates; and their young heir, Charles 
 Parker, did, like Captain Wybrow, die suddenly, 
 this girl, who gave promise of musical gifts, being 
 at that time a little over twenty. The musical 
 training given to her did not avail for the career 
 the Newdigates had intended for her, inasmuch as 
 her health proved too delicate, and she married 
 a Mr. Ebdell, who was the vicar of Chilvers Coton. 
 Out of these facts and her own vivid memories 
 and creations George Eliot wove this beautiful 
 trilogy which made her first volume of fiction. 
 
 '55 
 
OF 
 
 It was no haphazard collection of short stories ; 
 for when she first showed to Lewes in the Sep- 
 tember of 1856 the scenes in "Amos Barton," 
 with which these stories began, she expressed a 
 hope that she might be able to write a series of 
 tales embodying her impressions of the country 
 clergy who had come her way, and these studies 
 breathe the very atmosphere of English country 
 life, as she knew it, in the early half of the nine- 
 teenth century. They are at once simple and 
 complex, elementary and profound. For they 
 touch the deepest realities of life itself, with all its 
 hidden complexities and apparent simplicities ; 
 turning, like the noblest Greek tragedy, on those 
 primary emotions which are our essential heritage, 
 emotions which, while linking us with what is 
 highest and most tender in the animals as part of 
 our family, link us also with the Divine Love 
 wherein we are born, and toward which the whole 
 creation "groaneth and travaileth." 
 
 Strikingly diverse, despite their common setting, 
 they nevertheless all turn upon the educating 
 power of that Infinite Love, manifested through 
 transcendent human affections "loves" that 
 " in higher love endure," affection and loyalty 
 through which the Most High often teaches us 
 that, as has been well said, " our hearts are restless 
 till they rest in Him," and find that love His 
 dwelling-place. 
 
 They are all stories of love and sorrow. Nor 
 is the leit-motif which unites them merely what 
 Tennyson has expressed, in the well-known lines 
 of Maud," 
 156 
 
OF CLST^IC^L LfFS 
 
 "The dusky strand of Death enwoven here 
 With dear Love's tie, makes Love himself more 
 dear." 
 
 It is much more than that ; for it suggests that 
 through death as well as through life the Divine 
 Love educates and redeems. Even when death 
 comes, not as Walt Whitman's gentle " Mother " 
 and " Deliveress,'' but seeming, as death often 
 does, a cruel and unwelcome guest, snatching the 
 young mother from husband and children when 
 we think they need her most, or leaving a May- 
 nard Gilfil bereft of his heart's desire on the very 
 verge of its apparent consummation, we are yet 
 made to feel, as in all highest art, that in the 
 uttermost grief, as well as in profoundest rapture 
 and joy, human lives are lifted into unseen possi- 
 bilities, and are confronted with a vaster outlook, 
 a more unquenchable hope, than our little cur- 
 tained stage of earthly existence can ever hold 
 or express ; so that the protagonist in the conflict 
 is found at the moment of death crowned with 
 promises no human words can formulate, no 
 mortal vision pursue to their fulfiment. The 
 love of Amos Barton, too absolute to dream that 
 any fool could doubt its loyalty, was not crushed 
 or embittered by the bereavement which robbed 
 him of his chief outward joy and comfort, but 
 was consecrated to higher issues which, through 
 his grief and loneliness, lifted this poor " mongrel," 
 whose " very faults were middling," into fellow- 
 ship with the loftiest and noblest souls, and gave 
 to Milly's children a heritage that was far beyond 
 
 157 
 
OF 
 
 ordinary wealth. The tragedy in which Maynard 
 Gilfil was involved forbids any cheap glibness on 
 the part of the critic. I may indeed well be 
 warned off by some sneering and cynical person, 
 who will inquire at this point whether it is pro- 
 posed to analyse the wit and wisdom of these 
 beautiful stories on the level of a Sunday school 
 tract. But is there any admirer of this clean- 
 limbed, candid young chevalier sans reproche who 
 does not find him vastly nearer to all we worship, 
 after he has passed through his mortal anguish with 
 the courage of self-surrender and unmurmuring 
 self-abnegation, than when he is merely an untried, 
 charming young parson very deeply and unselfishly 
 in love ? 
 
 George Eliot had, doubtless, a special know- 
 ledge of timber through her long, intimate 
 drives with her father over the estates for which 
 he was responsible, and her imagery is especially 
 telling when she compares " the dear old vicar,'' 
 Mr. Gilfil, to a tree. "The heart of him was 
 sound, the grain was of the finest ; and in the 
 grey-haired man who filled his pocket with sugar- 
 plums for the little children, whose most biting 
 words were directed against the evil-doing of the 
 rich man, and who, with all his social pipes and 
 slipshod talk, never sank below the highest level 
 of his parishioners' respect, there was the main 
 trunk of the same brave, faithful, tender nature 
 that had poured out the finest, freshest forces of 
 its life-current in a first and only love the love 
 of Tina." 
 
 We are told that Mr. Blackwood was dis- 
 
scenes OF CL&RJGJL LIFS 
 
 satisfied with the first part of "Janet's Repentance," 
 when it was sent to him for publication as part of 
 "the series/' and I must admit that it seems to 
 me the least satisfactory part of the volume before 
 us. But the middle and end are so masterly and 
 so moving that the story as a whole is surely one 
 of the greatest of George Eliot's gifts to her fellow- 
 men. Here, as in "Silas Marner " and "Adam 
 Bede,'' she fearlessly drew for us the story of a 
 soul not only restored and redeemed, but far 
 stronger and more beautiful at the end of the 
 battle than in the smooth days of untroubled 
 youth. 
 
 And how full of sane, quick-beating charity are 
 all these studies of human nature ! All alike lead 
 to the equipoise not of 
 
 " that false calm which many feign, 
 And call that peace which is a dearth of pain," 
 
 but to that deep and vibrating peace which passeth 
 understanding, that secret home and temple of the 
 heart, which 
 
 " For its very vestibule doth own 
 The tree of Jesus and the pyre of Joan." 
 
 " Ideas," as George Eliot truly says, " are often 
 poor ghosts ; our sun-filled eyes cannot discern 
 them ; they pass athwart us in thin vapour, and 
 cannot make themselves felt. But sometimes 
 they are made flesh ; they breathe upon us with 
 warm breath, they touch us with soft responsiv 
 hands, they look at us with sad sincere eyes, and 
 speak to us in appealing tones ; they are clothed in 
 
OF 
 
 a living human soul, with all its conflicts, its faith, 
 and its love. Then their presence is a power, then 
 they shake us like a passion, and we are drawn 
 after them with gentle compulsion, as flame is 
 drawn to flame." 
 
 We have already been reminded that " while we 
 are coldly discussing a man's career, sneering at 
 his mistakes, blaming his rashness, and labelling 
 his opinions ' Evangelical and narrow,' or 
 ( Latitudinarian and Pantheistic,' or * Anglican 
 and supercilious ' that man, in his solitude, is 
 perhaps shedding hot tears because his sacrifice is 
 a hard one, because strength and patience are 
 failing him to speak the difficult word, and do 
 the difficult deed." 
 
 We all know the dangers of indiscriminate 
 giving, but Mr. Jerome's open-handedness was 
 not indiscriminate, and modern selfishness, as well 
 as certain forms of modern philanthropy and 
 stultified communism, might well ponder deeply 
 on Mr. Jerome's assurance that " I'd rether give 
 ten shiliin' an' help a man to stand on his own 
 legs, nor pay half-a-crown to buy him a parish 
 crutch ; it's the ruination on him if he once goes 
 to the parish. I've see'd many a time, if you help 
 a man wi' a present in a neeborly way, it sweetens 
 his blood he thinks it kind on you ; but the 
 parish shillins turn it sour he niver thinks 'em 
 enough." 
 
 Here is practical wisdom of the best, that 
 practical wisdom which is born of the heart where 
 Wisdom and Love are one. 
 
 Colonel Newcome himself is not more finely 
 1 60 
 
scenes OF CL&III&AL LIFS 
 
 drawn than Mr. Tryan, who, dwelling among the 
 squalid homes of the saddest and most poverty- 
 stricken, " wants to mek himself their brother, 
 like ; can't abide to preach to the fastin' on a full 
 stomach." 
 
 There is not space here to quote the description 
 of Mr. Tryan's study, but there is a fine passage 
 in which George Eliot remarks that u the man 
 who could live in such a room, unconstrained by 
 poverty, must either have his vision fed from within 
 by an intense passion, or he must have chosen that 
 least attractive form of self-mortification which 
 wears no haircloth and has no meagre days, but 
 accepts the vulgar, the commonplace and the ugly, 
 whenever the highest duty seems to lie among 
 them." 
 
 Sir Leslie Stephen has laid his finger on the 
 true vindication of George Eliot's work from the 
 charge of a too pedantic didacticism and philo- 
 sophic seriousness, when he reminds us that it is 
 absurd to expect an author steeped in philosophic 
 ideals to present us in fiction with a world 
 entirely devoid of their influence, and elsewhere 
 remarks, with a certain mordant incisiveness : " If 
 anybody holds that morality is a matter of fancy, 
 and that the ideal of the sensualist is as good as 
 that of the saint, he may logically conclude that 
 the morality of the novelist is really a matter of 
 indifference. I hold myself that there is some 
 real difference between virtue and vice, and that 
 the novelist will show consciousness of the fact in 
 proportion to the power of his mind and the 
 range of his sympathies." 
 
 L 161 
 
OF 
 
 Even George Eliot's detractors are wont to 
 make an exception in favour of these early stories 
 and of " Silas Marner." I am of the other school. 
 By this I do not mean that I set these stories 
 lower, for I believe them to be masterpieces of 
 their kind and their kind is of the best but 
 only that I set the other work high also am, in 
 fact, in no sense a detractor, but a born admirer. 
 It is, doubtless, an idiosyncrasy of temperament, 
 and one which I am not insistent to defend, that 
 while I confess the later novels are more open to 
 criticism than the earlier, yet for sheer enjoyment 
 " Middlemarch " and "Daniel Deronda" have 
 been' to me quite as enthralling as any ; and even 
 the much-criticised "Felix Holt" has given me 
 especially keen delight. 
 
 In all George Eliot's work, if I except " Brother 
 Jacob" and "The Lifted Veil" and "Theo- 
 phrastus Such," I find power, humour, reality, 
 indestructible charm. Yet, seeking to adjust the 
 relative claims of her first fiction and her latest 
 volumes, I confess that Milly Barton is to me a 
 more vivid reality than some of the later heroines, 
 Mr. Bates has to my thinking more verisimilitude 
 than certain subsidiary characters in "Deronda," 
 and Mr. Jerome is a more familiar acquaintance 
 than Mirah : but that is possibly the result of my 
 own limited vision, whereby I fail to recognise 
 Gwendolens and Mirahs when I meet them, or find 
 the salient oddities of a Mr. Bates more lifelike 
 than the cruel emptiness and obstinacy of a 
 Rosamond Vincy, whose blonde loveliness would, 
 I fear, effectually blind me to her baleful character, 
 162 
 
scenes OF CLSI^IC^L LTFB 
 
 What does seem incontrovertible is the almost 
 overwhelming force with which the earlier novels 
 bring home to the heart the joys and sorrows of 
 people whom our commonplace souls would, if 
 we met them in the flesh, be likely to pronounce 
 rather uointeresting ; and the genius with which 
 the value and significance of the individual lot 
 and of the individual soul, is intertwined with 
 the realisation that each is but one unseen drop 
 in the rushing torrent of wider events, that 
 torrent itself being but an infinitesimal incident in 
 the cycle of a vaster cosmos. 
 
 Those of us who believe with Browning that 
 
 "each of the Many helps to recruit 
 The life of the race by a general plan ; 
 Each living his own, to boot," 
 
 must be grateful for the superb art which never 
 leaves either the " each " or the " many " out of 
 account, and, while indicating the power of even 
 human qualities to react upon environment and 
 insensibly modify circumstance, invigorates and 
 uplifts the spirit with a faith deeper than any 
 circumscribing formula or narrowing logic of 
 mere words faith which enabled Janet Dempster 
 to say in the moment of parting with her earthly 
 deliverer, " God will not forsake me," and to 
 walk " in the presence of unseen witnesses of the 
 Divine Love that had rescued her, of the human 
 Jove that waited for its eternal repose until it had 
 seen her endure to the end." 
 
 There is a resplendent passage which I had 
 marked for possible quotation, but since Sir 
 
 163 
 
OF 
 
 Leslie Stephen has forestalled me in his chapter 
 on " Scenes of Clerical Life," I will content 
 myself with pointing out the exquisitely simple 
 word of comfort that follows close on this 
 same passage, which, but for that, might have 
 seemed to imply the loneliness of a world from 
 which God was absent. Tina, who is likened by 
 Bates to his darling flowers, the " nesh and 
 dilicate " cyclamens, is here, as often throughout 
 " Mr. GilfiTs Love-story," compared to a little 
 fluttering bird ; and the thought of the sparrow 
 that cannot fall to the ground "without our 
 Father " would seem to be implicit in the allusion 
 to her "torn nest," when, on the very next page 
 to that which writes those terrible words which 
 say she and her trouble were " hidden and uncared 
 for," we read that, when she knelt down to say 
 the little prayer of her childhood, she added the 
 words, " O God, help me to bear it," and " that 
 day the prayer seemed to be heard." 
 
 In " Amos Barton," the first of the three stories 
 now before us, which, in the poignant simplicity 
 of its unsentimental pathos, and its awakening of 
 our sympathy for the dullest and most common- 
 place of men, is from one point of view the 
 author's supreme triumph, it is easy to admit 
 faults of construction. It is much less perfectly 
 welded than some of George Eliot's later work, 
 and even betrays here and there a certain stiffness 
 and awkwardness in its transition from scene to 
 scene. Its unfolding is less organic and inevitable 
 than that of " Adam Bede," for instance. Yet I 
 am not at all sure that what at first appears a 
 164 
 
scenes OF CLS^IC^L LIFS 
 
 defect may not be an obscure source of added 
 power in the grip which the story takes of the 
 imagination, whether it does not for that very 
 reason hold the reader with a more impressive 
 sense of actuality, as though some unaccustomed 
 narrator were recalling vividly remembered facts 
 which require a certain effort to marshal them in 
 their due order. And it would be difficult to 
 find one of George Eliot's stories more vital with 
 the natural humour of life's delightful absurdities 
 and incongruities, its mingling of the heroic with 
 the trivial, the Divine with the homely. Of wit 
 also it has more than its share. 
 
 In this quiet story of a village town, in which 
 there are no sensational incidents, no swift sur- 
 prises, no men or women in any way remarkable 
 except for simple goodness, the very laughter 
 provoked by the author's scathing sallies against 
 those petty egotisms and self-deceptions, which 
 we are apt to treat more leniently in ourselves 
 than in others perhaps, not only relieves the strain 
 of what would otherwise be a sense of grief too 
 heavy to be borne, but at the same time really 
 deepens the probing influence of its noble pathos 
 a pathos which is always finely restrained, and 
 therefore the more moving. It stands for ever to 
 the honour of Charles Dickens, whose most vaunted 
 pathetic scenes lacked precisely that quality of 
 self-restraint, that he was among the first to recog- 
 nise and extol, in the then unknown writer, " the 
 exquisite truth and delicacy both of the humour 
 and pathos." In "The Sad Fortunes of the Rev. 
 Amos Barton," a story in which the closing scenes 
 
 165 
 
OF 
 
 touched with that economy of language, that 
 wise control of feeling, which makes them the 
 more profoundly touching from the absence of 
 any emotional flourishes or rhetorical exaggeration, 
 the children around Milly's death-bed are not 
 likely to be forgotten by any one who, in imagina- 
 tion, has once stood beside them. Indeed, in 
 her presentment of children, George Eliot always 
 stands supreme, and her supremacy lies in the 
 very fact that her children are as normal and 
 delightful as hedgerow flowers. They are just 
 such children as cross life's daily path, cheering 
 as daisies and buttercups, or those dainty, fragrant 
 bindweeds that bear a star in their pale blossom- 
 ing and do not despise even the kerbstones of the 
 village roadway, or the hillocks of the village 
 graves. In the early stories they are especially 
 bewitching, and it is not only Patty Barton who 
 warms the memory with a loved, caressing presence s 
 but a whole troop of merry boys and girls who 
 are never obtruded on the reader's attention, yet 
 add to the sunshine and the sweetness of a world 
 where there is much suffering, but also much 
 innocent though transient delight, as well as more 
 enduring joy. 
 
 Among the fine qualities incontrovertibly recog- 
 nised in George Eliot's work, dramatic situation 
 is not, as a rule, very strikingly in evidence, but 
 there is a moment in " Mr. Gilfil's Love-story " 
 which must in this regard satisfy the most exacting 
 critic : 
 
 " c Yes, Maynard,' said Sir Christopher, chat- 
 166 
 
scenes OF CLST^JC^L Lite 
 
 ting with Mr. Gilfil in the library, * it really is 
 a remarkable thing that I never in my life laid a 
 plan, and failed to carry it out. I lay my plans 
 well, and I never swerve from them that's it. 
 A strong will is the only magic.' ' 
 
 There follows an allusion to the happy marriages 
 he has planned for Anthony, who is already beyond 
 the reach of earthly planning, and for two others 
 dear to the old man's heart, but all tangled in a 
 sorrowful destiny beyond his unravelling. And 
 then . . . 
 
 "The door burst open, and Caterina, ghastly 
 and panting, her eyes distended with terror, rushed 
 in, threw her arms round Sir Christopher's neck, 
 and gasping out ' Anthony . . . the Rookery 
 . . . dead ... in the Rookery,' fell fainting on 
 the floor." 
 
 As a finished work of art, " Mr. Gilfil's Love- 
 story " is, undoubtedly, the finest of the " Scenes 
 of Clerical Life," though "Amos Barton" is my 
 own favourite; but at is in " Janet's Repentance" 
 that we have perhaps the most perfect expression 
 of the wise and loving philosophy which underlies 
 them all. It is there that we are reminded that 
 " the only true knowledge of our fellow man is 
 that which enables us to feel with him which 
 gives us a fine ear for the heart-pulses that are 
 beating under the mere clothes of circumstance 
 and opinion. Our subtlest analysis of schools and 
 sects must miss the essential truth, unless it be lit 
 up by the love that sees in all forms of human 
 
OF 
 
 thought and work, the life and death struggles of 
 separate human beings/' 
 
 If it be asked, how it was possible that one 
 who had renounced what is ordinarily called Chris- 
 tianity, could yet indicate with such sincerity, as 
 in these sketches of clerical life, the very source 
 and secret of its power, may we not reply that 
 her own faith was, doubtless, wider and deeper 
 than ever found full expression either in her words 
 or her life ? Mr. Gilbert Murray's beautiful 
 translation of Hecuba's prayer in "The Trojan 
 Women " seems to me to sum up what, consciously 
 or unconsciously, was the prayer that breathes 
 through all George Eliot's work, and must lead 
 many a soul to Him who is the Light of Light : 
 
 "Thou deep Base of the World, and thou high 
 
 Throne 
 
 Above the World, whoe'er thou art, unknown 
 And hard of surmise, Chain of Things that be, 
 Or Reason of our Reason ; God, to thee 
 I lift my praise, seeing the silent road 
 That bringeth justice ere the end be trod 
 To all that breathes and dies." 
 
 But there were moments who can doubt it ? 
 when the great novelist, passing beyond the barriers 
 of " surmise " and of that which limits our finite 
 share in the infinite Reason, entered into the Love 
 " which passeth knowledge," and, perceiving with 
 the eyes of the soul that " the end " is not in this 
 life, attained to those secrets which the intellect 
 cannot reach. 
 
 168 
 
"GOING INTO THE SILENCE" 
 
 You will have bathed in stillness. CHARLES LAMB. 
 
 IT is easy to exaggerate the " sentimental emotion- 
 alism " of our grandmothers to forget that they 
 were often protected from hysterical fashions of 
 feeling and behaviour by a saving sense of humour 
 and a delicate wit. No doubt they had their 
 dangers, but the very quietness of their lives 
 tended to self-restraint, dignity, and reserve. 
 Among highly educated women and there were 
 many such, even though they were not all a Mrs. 
 Somerville or a Mrs. Browning, a Mrs. Gaskell or 
 a Miss Yonge the long hours of manual occu- 
 pation gave opportunity for original and reflective 
 thought and for a certain deepening of character, 
 such as only the finest natures gain in that opposing 
 stress of modern bustle and noise, by which too 
 frequently the weak and flimsy ones are frittered 
 away or ruinously disintegrated. 
 
 There is a verse of Matthew Arnold's " Fare- 
 well," in which he speaks of women as 
 
 " things that live and move, 
 Mined by the fever of the soul." 
 
 And the fever is likely to increase alarmingly with 
 the increase of complicated responsibility in our 
 modern life, and is likely also to tell most severely 
 on the tenderest and the bravest. If the women 
 of the past were sometimes, we are told, engrossed 
 in trivialities, through the lack of a wide intellec- 
 
 169 
 
OF 
 
 tual outlook, the women of to-day may be in 
 danger of shallowness, through the very multi- 
 plicity of their interests and cares, or, on the 
 other hand, through their self-satisfied absorption 
 in the one person who is the centre of their lives. 
 
 But the door of salvation from this lowering 
 process is even now not shut to them, and there 
 are many ways in which some of the busiest may 
 still " buy oil for their lamps." If a woman be 
 ever so unfortunate as to be unable to enter the 
 temple of art for heavenly merchandise, or to 
 gather the flower of peace in her own garden plot, 
 or even, through some unhappy doubt, may feel 
 unable to join in the ancient liturgy, with its 
 joyous and tranquillising effects, there are yet 
 moments of enforced waiting and monotonous toil, 
 when the touch of unseen Love will meet all honest 
 effort after secret converse, by a rekindling of the 
 light that had gone out. 
 
 It sounds like a paradox to say that those 
 who are most vividly in touch with their fellow- 
 creatures most crave solitude ; but it is a para- 
 dox by no means so paradoxical as it looks. To 
 crave solitude is not to wish to be lonely nor to 
 desire continued isolation ; a solitude which was 
 perpetual would, indeed, lose all its charm. The 
 highest peak of a mountain-top is a heavenly 
 place; but who would choose to dwell there 
 always, unless, indeed, it proved that meeting- 
 place of souls, that " paved work of a sapphire 
 . . . When they ate and drank and saw God also," 
 which Browning took as the symbol of the most 
 satisfying of all human companionships ? 
 170 ' 
 
rne 
 
 The soul that has never felt " life's fretful 
 fever " has never truly longed for solitude. And 
 though anything so unhealthy as " fever " may be 
 incompatible with the highest, purest love, and 
 with that " enthusiasm of humanity " which is the 
 most catholic of affections, yet even a perfectly 
 unselfish passion (and who is so perfect as to be 
 absolutely unselfish ?) may crave an occasional 
 withdrawal from the material presence of the 
 dearest of fellow-creatures, if only to realise its 
 own reality and find renewed strength and joy in 
 its own validity. Milton's Adam exclaims in his 
 own Eden : 
 
 " For solitude is sweet society, 
 And short retirement urges swift return." 
 
 One of Browning's loveliest lyrics asserts the con- 
 verse of this, and speaks of the dual solitude as 
 never so intense as when 
 
 " Up and down amid men, heart by heart fare we ! " 
 
 But if this be true of the love of lovers, there 
 is a larger, deeper reason why those who renounce 
 themselves for the good of the race must, if their 
 sympathies be quick, meet the revitalising presence 
 of Love in solitude as well as in the crowd. Un- 
 doubtedly the women of to-day stand in special 
 need of that occasional solitude which it is often 
 so hard for them to secure. For many a noble- 
 hearted woman the only certainty of this calming 
 and bracing remedy for irritation and exhaustion 
 lies in the steadfast adherence to the practice of 
 setting apart out of the long, active, unselfish days, 
 
 171 
 
s OF 
 
 one daily half-hour in which there is literal 
 obedience to the Master's command, not only to 
 enter into a room where others are not passing to 
 and fro, but also to " shut the door " to gain, in 
 fact, the quiet peace of what the Society of Friends 
 rightly names "going into the silence," a silence 
 wherein, as in Charles Lamb's " Quakers' Meet- 
 ing," " the mind " has often " been fed " as well 
 as the soul. 
 
 To live incessantly for others, and in others, is 
 to live a hundredfold ; and this multiplex activity 
 may doubtless be far less perilous, even physically, 
 than the maddening strain of a carking self- 
 regard ; yet it can only be healthily sustained by 
 the invigorating renewal of individuality in solitary 
 communion with that angel of Love and Light 
 with whom Israel wrestled till daybreak, and who 
 since the days of Israel has revealed His name 
 more fully. 
 
 To be alone is not to be lonely ; the deepest 
 loneliness of all is found in uncongenial company. 
 
 Doubtless a man feels this in proportion to the 
 vividness and sensitiveness of his sympathies. But 
 it was another side of the question which suggested 
 the paradox. The quick sense of human kindred 
 is a daily delight ; yet how precious must be ac- 
 counted those hours of joy in which it is untouched 
 by pain ! In that " star Rephan '' of which 
 Browning writes it may be otherwise. But that 
 thought stultifies itself at the outset, and merely 
 proves what has here been asserted, as by a sum 
 in subtraction you prove a sum in addition. For 
 we are met by the poet's implied suggestion that 
 172 
 
i^ro rns 
 
 we have passed beyond that sphere where there is 
 no unhappiness, no sense of discord or of aspira- 
 tion, into a life where each is bound to all and no 
 sorrow is wholly individual, and wherein the old 
 French proverb becomes true in a deeper sense than 
 is intended, arid " il faut souffrir pour tre belle/' 
 If character is to become beautiful, with an ever 
 widening and deepening sympathy, the fire of 
 fellow-feeling must at times scorch and shrivel 
 many easeful, self-indulgent tendencies which 
 cannot vanish without a little salutary hurting. 
 As for the just punishment of that paltry self- 
 seeking and greed of admiration felt by the poor 
 thin-skinned wretches who call themselves sensi- 
 tive and are known as "touchy," it is not of their 
 self-centred pain that beauty can be born. To 
 such there is here no briefest allusion, for in no 
 large sense are they wont to excel in sympathy, 
 being much more likely to see all things refracted 
 and distorted through their own self-regarding 
 fantasies. On the other hand, all self-renouncing 
 regard for the just claims and true interests of 
 others tends to robustness of character. 
 
 To rejoice with those who rejoice, and to weep 
 with those who weep, with 
 
 " a heart at leisure from itself, 
 To soothe and sympathise," 
 
 must doubtless involve pain as well as joy, even 
 though it meet Romola's definition of happiness, 
 as that to be chosen above all else, and though, 
 like all merging of self in greater and diviner 
 interests, it must necessarily ennoble and in- 
 
 173 
 
s OF 
 
 vigorate ; yet even the suffering which there will 
 be may result in a deepening of that calm and 
 joyous energy which is, like all virtue, its own 
 crowning reward. 
 
 But energy, in proportion to the strenuousness 
 and reality of its effort, demands at intervals a 
 counterbalancing and regenerating repose. We 
 know from the lives of all men in all ages that 
 when the ear is very sensitive to the " still, 
 sad music of humanity," so that the sound of its 
 laughter and its tears, its joy and grief and hope 
 and failure, reverberate unceasingly through the 
 frail human brain of the listener, the tension at 
 times demands a withdrawal into the great silence, 
 where He who " fashioneth all the hearts of 
 them " may " cover them with His Presence from 
 the strife of tongues." 
 
 And if it be impossible to be alone with the 
 woods and hills or to go into a desert place apart, 
 a moment with a picture of Turner or a poem of 
 Wordsworth may take the soul into the stillness 
 in which the nearness of the Great Companion is 
 realised. Is not this the debt that we owe to all 
 great art ? Art may be what men call secular 
 surely a crass distinction, since the whole universe 
 is sacred but if it be noble art, it will always 
 draw aside the veil from that mysterious presence 
 chamber, the Temple of Rest. 
 
 The Divine Peace that abides there will seldom 
 permit either man or woman to remain long in 
 inactivity, for it is a part of the mystery that the 
 love which breathes such penetrating repose into 
 the out-wearied spirit is yet that energy of love 
 
rns 
 
 of which Wordsworth wrote, as the very life of 
 life, when he said : 
 
 "Life, I repeat, is energy of love." 
 
 It is the other side of the paradox (which is in 
 itself by no means paradoxical) that they who 
 best love the Presence found in solitude will best 
 love their fellow-creatures. 
 
 If we seek solitude, cherishing hatred in our 
 heart, the solitude will certainly be odious to us, 
 and, though it may have been sought, it can 
 hardly be said to be loved. But for the servant 
 and the friend of Love, the wilderness will blossom 
 as the rose, and the solitary place will rejoice and 
 sing. 
 
 Perhaps to a woman longing to carry blessing 
 to the hearts and lives of others it may be in the 
 pressure of the crowd who will throng her return 
 that she will most vividly feel and touch the kindly 
 recreating Presence who, whether in the desert or 
 the market-place, is so perpetually waiting to renew 
 our humanity, that " Closer is He than breathing, 
 nearer than hands and feet." She will come back 
 into that multitudinous throng which constitutes 
 human life, with a new radiance on her face and 
 in her heart ; a look of courage for the downcast, 
 a tender smile for the sad, an electric silence of 
 sympathy for those who can bear no word. Her 
 own soul will kindle others with the joy of fellow- 
 ship and the anguish of pity. Life will be to her 
 one long poem, in which the sorrowful and sordid 
 details, the madness, the despair, are all trans- 
 
 175 
 
S OF 
 
 figured and redeemed by fellowship Divine and 
 human ; and at the end of life she will ask no 
 better guerdon than to be able to say of Love : 
 
 " He rushes on my mortal guess 
 
 With his immortal things. 
 I feel, I know him. On I press 
 He finds me 'twixt his wings." 
 
 176 
 
A HOLIDAY ON DARTMOOR 
 
 To most people the sound of " the moors " 
 will at once suggest Scotland. To them "the 
 moors " mean a great waste of fragrant heather, 
 where through the long days, knee - deep in 
 the hardy, purple-blossomed twigs, they taste 
 the clear, invigorating air, and industriously 
 shoot. 
 
 But in England too there are moors. In York- 
 shire there are wide reaches of upland where the 
 brown grass waves among the purple ling and 
 the air is pure and sweet and fine. 
 
 And, to say nothing of Exmoor, in the northern 
 half of Devonshire, here in the midst of South 
 Devon there is a great moor, where gorse and 
 heather are breaking into bloom, where the wild 
 ponies cry to one another from the hills, and the 
 white-bosomed swallows fly hither and thither, 
 and the mountain streams are ever rushing and 
 leaping and making their sweet, cool noises among 
 the moss and fern. This moor is no wild desert, 
 no lofty, monotonous level. Sometimes it is 
 broad, rocky upland, all heath and gorse ; but 
 oftener it is broken here and there by cornfields 
 and green meadows. 
 
 Here on its edge, in the valleys and clustering 
 round the churches on the hills, are human habita- 
 tions, grey stone houses, thatched cottages, and 
 mills. But these have a comfortable woodland 
 air, as if they had come with the boulders or 
 
 M I 77 
 
OF 
 
 grown with the trees. The blue smoke, as it 
 curls from their chimneys, brings no reminder 
 of towns or cities ; it does but emphasise the 
 tranquil solitude of the surrounding country. 
 
 Near to Princetown, in the heart of the moor, 
 still lingers a fragment of the primeval oak 
 forest where in old days the Druids celebrated 
 their mysterious rites. Memories cling round its 
 name. Wistman's Wood it is called. But even 
 the name is not so weird as the place. Ferns 
 grow on the mossy boughs of the gnarled and 
 ancient oaks. Often one of the trees will wreathe 
 its twisted branches with those of its neighbour in 
 fantastic entanglement. Luxuriantly leafy, but 
 crooked and dwarfed, are these oaks. Shoulder- 
 deep in bramble and bracken, they are half buried 
 also by slabs and pyramids of lichened rock and 
 time-worn stone. It is a fine place for twisted 
 ankles ; stepping into what looks like innocent 
 fern, the unwary explorer stumbles over a jagged 
 boulder or falls into a treacherous hollow or grassy 
 bog. 
 
 Below the lower edge of this elfin wood flows 
 a babbling, sobbing stream ; and, crowning the 
 slope above, wild, rocky slope, where the delicate 
 bell-heather is budding, and tiny orange-brown 
 butterflies are wandering, rise rugged masses of 
 granite, very like the tors which mark the sur- 
 rounding hills, though on a much larger scale. 
 Very different is this fortress of stone from the 
 cairn on the top of Snowdon and other Welsh 
 mountains. This is not a cone of heaped-up 
 shingle, but a pile of formidable slabs built up 
 
 178 
 
cxf HOLID^T 
 
 one above the other, now jagged and irregular, 
 now shaped like a rude altar. 
 
 The loneliness even here is broken by the lowing 
 of the cattle beautiful red Devonshire cattle that 
 come for shelter from sun and wind beneath the 
 shadow of these rocks. There are sheep too, but 
 they have been shorn and cannot pretend to any 
 snowy whiteness, though in this part of the 
 county there is no warm-coloured loam to give 
 them the ruddy tinge to which the eye is accus- 
 tomed in the sea-coast valleys. As they wander 
 bleating over the hills they are but grey and 
 ordinary sheep. 
 
 August is not here a sultry month. There are 
 days when the sky is a deep, cloudless blue and 
 the air heavy with languid heat and sunshine. 
 But how many are the days when the pearly clouds 
 chase one another across the azure space, when 
 the hills are dappled with brilliant light among 
 the ever-shifting shadows ; days when the air is 
 pure and quickening, and the little red-breasted 
 wind^chat flies from twig to twig of the peach- 
 perfumed gorse, that is even now blossoming into 
 its August splendour of billowy gold. 
 
 On such a day should Wistman's Wood be 
 seen, and then from those granite boulders what 
 a glorious landscape rolls itself out ! Beyond the 
 open moorland the hills lie fold on fold, now 
 illumined by a distant flash of radiance to a bright 
 and delicate verdure, now almost golden in the 
 sunlight, now again dusky with fir-trees or 
 shadowed by those rounded blocks of snow-white 
 cloud that sail across the stainless blue overhead. 
 
 179 
 
OF 
 
 The heather is very late this year ; nor can this be 
 called exactly a heather country, though the 
 common purple heath grows well among the 
 gorse, and the bell-heather blossoms in the boggy 
 part of the moor, and ling will soon be tolerably 
 abundant. But the hue of the tiny heather-bells 
 has not yet darkened from the tint of the foxglove 
 to bluish purple, and is mingled here and there 
 with the russet of the reddening whortle-twigs. 
 Sometimes there is a glowing patch upon the 
 far-off hills, but the chief variety of colour is 
 given by the luxuriant woodland, which clothes 
 the lower slopes on the edge of the moor and 
 follows the courses of the streams. There also 
 the ash almost loses its sameness, and assumes 
 a certain statelinesss and wealth of foliage which 
 come near to beauty. Beech-trees are always 
 lovely, though in the wilder valleys they grow 
 too closely to develop that splendid strength and 
 symmetry which give to them so perfect a grace 
 in well-planted avenues. The oaks also are small, 
 and their stems seem to have caught the silvery 
 glimmer of their neighbours, the birch-trees. 
 The berries of the graceful mountain ash are not 
 yet scarlet ; and, though wild raspberries drop 
 their pink fruit into the sedgy undergrowth that 
 borders the woodland streams, and nuts have 
 taken the first touch of brown upon the hazels, 
 the lilac-tinted blackberry blossoms are not yet 
 over, and the wild strawberry is still plentiful. 
 The harebell does not grow here, but a dainty pale 
 blue campanula springs from the mossy turf under 
 the trees beside the brooks. Meadowsweet and 
 1 80 
 
of HOLID^T 
 
 wood-betony and wild thyme grow plentifully, 
 and innumerable ferns, from the common poly- 
 pody to the royal osmunda. And everywhere in 
 the woods are sweet-smelling fir-teees, everywhere 
 the clear and sparkling rills are musical among 
 the stones, and fragments of rock peep out 
 through the undergrowth, clothed with ivy, and 
 lichen, and moss. These rocky, river-haunted 
 woods recall those lines of Keats in which Lorenzo 
 describes to Isabella the secret place where his 
 murderers buried him : 
 
 4 'Saying, moreover, * Isabel, my sweet ! 
 
 Red whortleberries droop above my head 
 And a large flint-stone weighs upon my feet ; 
 
 Around me beeches and high chestnuts shed 
 Their leaves and prickly nuts ; a sheep-fold bleat 
 
 Comes from beyond the river to my bed : 
 Go, shed one tear upon my heather-bloom, 
 
 And it shall comfort me within the tomb.'" * 
 
 It only needs the orange-winged butterflies and 
 the yellowing bracken to make the picture 
 complete. 
 
 You will say this is not moorland scenery. 
 But it is all a part of Dartmoor just as truly 
 as the less frequent hut-circles and bogs, does 
 indeed follow the course of the Dart, and is in its 
 way characteristic : moreover, here we are on the 
 edge of the moor rather than in its central strong- 
 hold. Nevertheless, let us go forth again to the 
 wild, fenceless gorse-country, and breathe a more 
 
 * It is interesting to note that Keats writes his preface from 
 Teignmouth. 
 
 181 
 
OF <p%pse 
 
 mountainous air, and scan a wider horizon, and 
 count the multitudinous heights and valleys that 
 lie beneath us ; and, southward, where the hills 
 roll more gently towards the coast, let our eyes 
 rest upon the level line of the distant sea. There 
 is a magical charm in this south country, not 
 least in these waste places. The air, though 
 exhilarating, is balmy ; the sky, though breezy, is 
 blue. There is a soft glamour and enchantment. 
 It is a land of dreams. Are we for once rid of 
 all painful realities, all torturing problems ? May 
 we construct a world of our own imaginings, an 
 idyllic world into which neither sin nor sorrow 
 can enter ? 
 
 What is that ugly blot upon the moor, that 
 dreary range of unbeautiful buildings ? It is a 
 prison. The world is not idyllic, and it is better 
 to face its ugly facts than to pretend a comfort- 
 able blindness. It is well for the soft effeminacy 
 of a self-indulgent age that it cannot always 
 escape the sight of suffering. The swallows fly, 
 the sun shines, the wild flowers unfold their gay 
 petals. The young rabbits are so tame that the 
 village children can catch them. This heathery 
 moorland suggests the wildest, sweetest freedom. 
 Yet even here there is a prison. Even here we 
 are reminded " what man has made of man." 
 
 182 
 
L'ENVOI TO THE THREE 
 FOLLOWING SONNETS 
 
 Written in the week following King Edward's death, at 
 the moment of the terrible mining accident which called 
 forth Queen Alexandra? s help and sympathy in the midst 
 of her oivn grief. 
 
 OH, dear Queen-Mother, now we kiss your hands 
 For writing words that let us share your pain ! 
 Would we might comfort you ! But not in 
 
 vain 
 
 Shall be your trust : the Empire understands 
 This day her duty, and through all her lands 
 True to that great commission shall remain, 
 Seeing in your son your " Dearest " once again 
 And deeply loyal to his least commands. 
 We bless you too for help to those poor wives 
 From whom the pitiless earth has swallowed up 
 The men they loved. Oh, may the God above, 
 Who visiteth " souls in prison," to such lives, 
 From the inscrutable depths that filled their cup 
 And yours, dear Mother, give Himself, who is 
 Love ! 
 
 183 
 
TO THE PEACEMAKER'S MEMORY 
 THREE SONNETS 
 
 I LIVE secluded and since life began 
 
 Had never once set eyes upon the King ; 
 Yet from my soul his praise I learned to sing 
 
 As one who built love's faithful artisan 
 
 A Palace of Pity : in his mortal span 
 
 Lay duties that might break an angel's wing 
 And crush a king thus human. Wondering, 
 
 I saw how he achieved them he, a man ! 
 
 He shared his people's pleasures and withstood 
 The caste-conventions that might hold apart 
 A King and People. The great Architect 
 
 Blessed this Grand Mason of the Brotherhood 
 Who worked with generous toil of hand and 
 
 heart 
 In that vast temple love and peace erect. 
 
 VITAL and simple, scorning empty pride, 
 
 Duty to him was ever dominant. 
 
 He never scamped his work ; no touch of cant 
 Obscured this kingly heart that, far and wide, 
 Loved, pitied, wounded wastrels that abide 
 
 In a dark hell : on those poor lives that pant 
 
 For help and healing, he bestowed no rant, 
 But deep compassion with true deed allied. 
 God bless him, God who blesseth quick and dead, 
 
 Who hath the peacemakers His children called ! 
 This man refused from work for us to cease 
 184 
 
ro rne *P&>fceM*fKe3S 
 
 While breath was in his body. Disenthralled 
 Of that laborious crown which tires the head, 
 The faithful servant hath at last release. 
 
 WHO, who can boast when Death is standing by 
 To level king and commoner and call 
 An emperor as roughly as a thrall ? 
 
 Would God, when we poor labourers come to die 
 
 And our disrobements in their coffins lie, 
 
 Such well-earned peace as his might crown us all ! 
 When on our little stage the curtains fall. 
 
 Will our small tasks show nothing left awry ? 
 
 He loved the suffering, and, untiring, sought 
 The nations of the earth with peace to crown. 
 No king could hold regalia more sublime 
 
 Than a world's love and peace by friendship 
 
 wrought 
 
 This jewelled circle is undying renown, 
 Not death, but coronation for all time. 
 
AN EARLY VICTORIAN NOVEL 
 
 NEXT in discernment to the criticism of sympathy, 
 which is the most divining of all, is that unex- 
 pected and incisive appreciation which is the 
 criticism of antithesis, when those who stand at 
 the opposite pole of intellectual aspiration or 
 spiritual belief, by formulating some crying need, 
 or emphasising some contrary aspect of the truth, 
 unconsciously urge the fulfilment of the one or add 
 importance to the complement of the other. 
 
 And it would be difficult to find anywhere 
 phrases, or attitudes of mind, suggestive of a more 
 just discrimination of the precise and individual 
 value of such a novel as " John Halifax " than are 
 those to be found in Mr. Frederic Harrison's 
 Essay on Victorian Literature,* an essay in which 
 neither the book nor its author is even so much as 
 named. " Every one is afraid," says Mr. Harrison, 
 "to let himself go, to offend the conventions, or 
 to raise a sneer.'' 
 
 It is because Miss Mulock feared none of these 
 things, but cared only to speak her message with 
 clearness and obedience, while earning an honest 
 day's wage by an honest day's work, that the book 
 not only went straight to its mark just where its 
 simple poetry was most profoundly wanted, but 
 has also retained an ever-widening popularity 
 wheresoever " the English tongue " is spoken ; 
 
 * " Studies in Early Victorian Literature " (Edward Arnold). 
 
 186 
 
and has become, to many a draughtsman, trades- 
 man, and hard-handed toiler, on both sides of the 
 Atlantic, a dear companion and a household name. 
 
 Mr. Harrison also points out how many of our 
 great prose-writers of the century have occasion- 
 ally fallen into " bombast " or "fustian," turgidity 
 or elaborate self-consciousness ; and, if not too 
 " precious," have now and then been in danger of 
 descending to " limelights and coloured lenses " ; 
 or, avoiding the jerkiness of the great novelist 
 whom he wittily names as "a prose Browning/' 
 and following Matthew Arnold when he bade them 
 " flee Carlylese as the very devil," have, in the good 
 company of " Culture itself," fallen into " the trap 
 in the very act of warning others/* On the other 
 hand, he praises the " pure, natural, and most 
 articulate prose," of a conventional yet popular 
 writer who was a friend of his own, and there- 
 by unwittingly lays his finger on one secondary 
 excellence of the novel before us. 
 
 " Romance," he says, "finding little of romance 
 in the real world, has taken two different lines in 
 the desperate effort to amuse us somehow. The 
 virtuous line is the phonographic reproduction of 
 everyday life in ordinary situations. The dis- 
 reputable line is Zolaesque bestiality, and forced, 
 unreal, unlovely, and hysterical sensationalism." 
 Both these dangers has "John Halifax" escaped 
 in the region of that " social romance " which the 
 same writer describes as " the true poetic function 
 of women." The book has sometimes been claimed 
 as the precursor and antetype of the ordinary 
 middle-class novel, of which it was supposed to set 
 
OF 
 
 the fashion. But it was hardly a novel at all in 
 the ordinary sense of the word. It was a romance, 
 at once homely and " poetic " ; and that fact may 
 suggest some of its most obvious deficiencies and 
 many of its most striking merits. 
 
 " It is felt on all sides," says Maeterlinck, " that 
 the conditions of workaday life are changing, and 
 the youngest of us already differ entirely in speech 
 and action from the men of the preceding gene- 
 ration. A mass of useless conventions, habits, 
 pretences, and intermediaries, are being swept into 
 the gulf" ; and it may be fairly added that among 
 the unseen forces making in that direction has 
 been the far-reaching influence of this modest and 
 humane story of John Halifax the tanner, a study 
 from the life, in which Christianity stands sponsor 
 for the finest breeding, and claims as its own for 
 ever the dignity and simplicity of work. 
 
 The author " believed," writes a sympathetic 
 critic, " in the nobility of man as man, and looked 
 upon condition, circumstance, or birth, as an acci- 
 dent which ought not to determine his ultimate 
 position. Her ideal man, John Halifax, carried 
 about with him an old Greek Testament, in which, 
 after the name of an ancestor, was the inscription 
 ' Gentleman.' Such a charter she held to be the 
 inalienable possession of every human being." 
 
 Another friend of Miss Mulock, who is at once 
 a man of letters and a man of affairs, said lately in 
 speaking of her : " I once asked an American why 
 his people thought so much of President Grant, 
 since his democratic ideals, excellent though they 
 might be, were, after all, shared by thousands of 
 188 
 
his fellow-countrymen. *That may all be true,' 
 was the reply. ' But he was the first to figure it 
 out ! ' Well," he continued, " of the author of 
 6 John Halifax ' it may be said, ' She was the first 
 to figure out that ideal of manhood and of chivalry 
 before which the most inveterate class-prejudice 
 hid its silly face and was ashamed.' ' 
 
 The social order is constantly falling out of tune : 
 she struck a true note which others were quick 
 to perceive and take up. She struck the note ; but 
 it may be added that it was characteristic of her 
 admirable reticence that, having once struck it, 
 she never forced or overlaboured it. Nor is she 
 responsible for every flat street-melody which gives 
 a false rendering of the new harmony. 
 
 If I may rephrase and intermingle thoughts 
 finely put by both the writers already quoted, 
 at the same time venturing to add a sequence or 
 two of resulting choice and amplification ; the 
 tree of life is of a unity so complex and incessant 
 that its most effulgent blossoming, though attri- 
 buted perhaps only to the few, is in reality put 
 forth by its soul as what Maeterlinck has called 
 the " Flower of the multitude " ; so that, even in 
 this more actual " fraternity," which bears the 
 deepening hue of our own century, it may be 
 difficult to disentwine cause and effect, or to say 
 from which particular bough of Igdrasil the pollen 
 was first wafted that touched the heart and petals 
 of every corolla with a new and more heavenly 
 colour. So little is this a question of mere 
 intellect, or eloquence, or solitary power, that we 
 find the same fragrant promise of advancing per- 
 
 189 
 
OF 
 
 fectibility in such divergent names and utterances 
 as those of Wordsworth and Walt Whitman, 
 Carlyle and Pater, Ruskin and George Meredith ; 
 in the arch-destroyer of" Bumbledom who wrote 
 " Oliver Twist," and the writer of " The New- 
 comes " and of " The Book of Snobs " ; in Swin- 
 burne's "Songs before Sunrise" and Christina 
 Rossetti's " Royal Princess," Thomas Hardy's 
 " Gabriel Oak," George Gissing's " Thyrza " and 
 Miss Thackeray's " Reine " ; in the poets of 
 "The Earthly Paradise" and "The Burden of 
 Nineveh," and in that most Christian poet who 
 gave us the divine Pompilia, the child of the 
 gutter. We find it in Keble, who touched with 
 immortal grace " the trivial round, the common 
 task,'' and in Rudyard Kipling, who has written 
 of all tasks, national and individual, a consecration 
 earnest, versatile, and actual. It is as truly pre- 
 sent in the " Ecce Homo" of Professor Seeley 
 as in Robert Louis Stevenson's "Portraits and 
 Memories." And it is strikingly incarnate in the 
 early novels of Mrs. Gaskeil, in the songs and 
 social romances of " Parson Lot," in the demo- 
 cratic hexameters and the satirical " New Deca- 
 logue" of that Thyrsis who was commemorated 
 by the scourger of the Philistine ; and for there 
 is no question of great or little in George Eliot's 
 "Adam Bede," in Tennyson's "Enoch Arden," 
 and in Miss Mulock's "John Halifax." Nor 
 must it be forgotten that, as a matter of fact, 
 "John Halifax" preceded that almost perfect 
 novel, George Eliot's masterpiece. Before either 
 " Adam Bede" or "Enoch Arden" had enriched 
 190 
 
an unimaginative Church with studies of those 
 very callings of carpenter and fisherman which 
 that Church had professed to revere in her 
 Founder and chief Apostle, while she trampled 
 and patronised them among her own u common 
 people," Miss Mulock, in this beautiful and un- 
 affected story of one who, working with his hands, 
 was also the servant of a trade, had already 
 redeemed, from the accretions of the prim and 
 artificial eighteenth century, 
 
 "The grand old name of Gentleman." 
 
 There are novels, such as Mrs. Gaskell's " Cran- 
 ford " and " Wives and Daughters," or Thackeray's 
 " Philip," which, in a quite peculiar degree, win 
 the heart of the reader to the man or woman who 
 wrote them. Such a book is "John Halifax." 
 It cannot boast the inimitable pathos and humour 
 of " Cranford," nor the mastery of the hand that 
 wrote " Philip " ; but it has all the qualities of its 
 defects, and perhaps full justice has never yet been 
 done to that mingling of austerity and passion, 
 that single-minded economy of language, which of 
 themselves go far to justify its extraordinary and 
 lasting popularity. It is a fine and womanly bit 
 of work in the best sense of the words. 
 
 It may, indeed, be said to miss no essentially 
 feminine grace except the crowning grace of 
 humour, that surpassing and Shakespearian gift 
 of creative humour which has for ever given to 
 George Eliot her pre-eminent place. Its very 
 limitations are an intrinsic part of its success. 
 Only in work of the very highest quality, such 
 
 191 
 
OF 
 
 work as the plays of Shakespeare or the novels of 
 Sir Walter Scott, can the bizarre incongruities and 
 ironies of life be amply included without disturb- 
 ing that sense of harmony and repose so necessary 
 to the highest art. From "John Halifax" it 
 may almost be said that humour, in the widest 
 sense of the word, is absent. The atmosphere 
 being more or less that of romance, the elements 
 are few and easily fused ; and so it comes to pass 
 that artistic unity is instinctively and lightly 
 attained, without that constant triumph over 
 obstacles which is the part of commanding 
 genius. Its charm is that of a noble and single- 
 minded sincerity, and of that untutored poetry 
 which, never seeking to pass its boundaries or to 
 strain after effect, has its own distinction of fine 
 and simple phrasing, and achieves what more 
 complicated and ambitious efforts could not have 
 touched. It is a pastel sketch in which the colours 
 are translucent and delicate, rather than an elabo- 
 rate oil-painting on a crowded canvas. 
 
 Yet it is significant that Miss Mulock, who as 
 a rule wrote with extreme ease and rapidity what 
 met the need of the moment, and, having fulfilled 
 its purpose, may be forgotten, spent much more 
 than her usual pains over this the most enduring 
 of her novels, and was content to write and re- 
 write again and again, rather than risk a blurred 
 or imperfect impression of the truth which she 
 desired to make concrete. Possibly this may 
 have been one reason, among others, why "John 
 Halifax " was always her own favourite among 
 her books. Dr. Garnett has spoken of it as " a 
 192 
 
very noble presentation of the highest ideal of 
 English middle-class life," and that ideal has since 
 entered so closely into the very warp and woof 
 of customary thought and action that its truths 
 sometimes seem to us to have become truisms. 
 It has doubtless done its work the more inwardly 
 and irrevocably, because it was singularly free 
 from the one-sided cant that sometimes flaunts 
 itself under a democratic name. Miss Mulock 
 evidently agreed with Clough that many men and 
 women of lowly birth, and yet more lowly calling, 
 are sometimes the very " poets of courtesy," yet 
 she made Phineas Fletcher admit, with her evident 
 approval, what a writer merely playing to the 
 gallery would have been careful to ignore, though 
 it is a fact in which lies much of the deepest 
 pathos of poverty's daily restrictions. " My 
 father," said Phineas, " tanner as he was, and 
 pertinaciously jealous of the dignity of trade, yet 
 held strongly the common-sense doctrine of the 
 advantages of good descent ; at least, in degree. 
 For since it is a law of nature, admitting only 
 rare exceptions, that the qualities of the ancestors 
 should be transmitted to the race, the fact seems 
 patent enough, that even allowing equal advan- 
 tages, a gentleman's son has more chances of 
 growing up a gentleman than the son of a 
 working man." 
 
 Phineas was right when he said " common- 
 sense " ; a certain sweet reasonableness and sound 
 common sense were especially characteristic of the 
 author of this book. But to say that, is not by 
 any means to account entirely for its popularity 
 
 N 193 
 
OF 
 
 and staying power. For may not as much be 
 said of many kindly souls who have written only 
 platitudes, and have quickly wearied their audi- 
 ence ? What then was the real reason why its 
 success was so rapid and so lasting ? If it be said 
 that the true explanation is twofold, and lies as 
 much in the terse poetic directness of expression 
 as in the power of the elemental truth expressed, 
 it may well be answered that such a twofold 
 answer is essentially one, since it is a common- 
 place, as true as it is trite, that language, if it be 
 not self-condemning in affectation, is always shaped 
 by that which lies beneath it ; and indeed the 
 exception is no exception, but only the most 
 glaring example of all, for who would not suspect a 
 pose under the garb of an attitudinising verbiage ? 
 There is in "John Halifax" no such histrionic 
 posing, but, on the contrary, a singular unity of 
 form and feeling. The appreciation of motive 
 and of style, therefore, in this instance necessarily 
 intermingle, though they must, in this as in every 
 careful analysis, be momentarily disentangled. 
 
 Without going so far as one recent critic, who 
 has even ventured to hint that the book might be 
 placed in the same category with the " Imitation " 
 of Thomas a Kempis and "The Pilgrim's Pro- 
 gress " of John Bunyan, it may at least be near 
 the truth to maintain that it endures by reason 
 of something more vital than mere choice and 
 mastery of words. 
 
 It accords with the fashion of our age to deny 
 that there is any reality above or beyond literature ; 
 but literature is the fruit of that covenanted effort, 
 194 
 
which, though a part of the world's testament, 
 is not of itself the immortal heritage testified. 
 Sincerity and inevitableness give distinction to any 
 writing destined to live upon that record ; and 
 that this charming idyll of the tanner's apprentice 
 does bear the essential sign-manual can hardly be 
 doubted, except by a criticism so shallow and 
 supercilious as to overreach its own justification. 
 
 Its outward presentment has a certain classic 
 grace of unadorned plainness, not deficient either 
 in force or in sweetness, but the secret of its 
 immediate welcome and lasting charm lies in the 
 soul of the book, and is of its very substance. 
 It answers to those deepest needs of the human 
 heart which are the same everywhere and always. 
 It is a response to the question asked anew with 
 fuller and deeper meaning in each succeeding 
 generation : " How can I so obey the Master 
 as to live the eternal life of Love and Beauty, 
 amid all the thwarting elements of time and space 
 and mortality, and find in the divine brotherhood 
 of all men a daily fact which shall transfigure the 
 lowliest labour to the highest poetry, and shine 
 through the darkest grief with illuminating joy ? " 
 
 Here we touch the very heart of the world's 
 debt to the author of "John Halifax," and, 
 through her, to one in whose teaching she, like 
 Kingsley, delighted, one who, through his deep 
 influence on a chosen few, is influencing an ever- 
 widening multitude, and whose faith was as child- 
 like and practical as it was mystic and scholarly 
 that most catholic and chivalrous of prophets, 
 Frederick Denison Maurice, among whose disciples 
 
 195 
 
OF 
 
 in Vere Street and Lincoln's Inn Miss Mulock 
 was frequently to be found. 
 
 But the story of John Halifax is very far indeed 
 from being merely didactic, It is as remarkable 
 for its simple passion as for the sanity and delicate 
 courage of its high and pure ideal. 
 
 From this verdict many will dissent. Much of 
 the criticism of to-day is so eager to be " modern " 
 that it makes the word " passion " a word of 
 high tradition and noble usage a mere synonym 
 for corruption and lawlessness ; but such a view 
 may almost be said to be Puritanism turned inside 
 out, and as narrow as the bigotry which mistakes 
 coldness for innocence and confounds negation 
 with divinity. 
 
 That emotion, the most profound and vital and 
 enduring, is also the simplest and the most reticent, 
 and that the silent Cordelia thrills to an intense 
 and heartrending tragedy, of which slighter and 
 more voluble natures are incapable, may or may 
 not be true ; but classic art has always leaned in 
 the direction of that belief, and to the faith that 
 such feeling is at once strong enough for renun- 
 ciation and vivid enough to strike the chords of 
 passion and of deathless hope. 
 
 There is a notable passage in " Modern Painters'* 
 in which Ruskin expounds that quality of chastened 
 art which touches the highest possibility of our 
 nature by a note of temperate self-restraint, im- 
 plying an infinite reserve of power and a rigor- 
 ous choice of expression. He reminds us that it 
 is perhaps akin to that hint of a divine refraining 
 from any monotony of splendour or reckless and 
 196 
 
unvaried gorgeousness, whereby the lily-of-the- 
 valley may exceed in exquisite loveliness many 
 flowers more exuberant in their blossoming and 
 more magnificent in their tints. 
 
 And that the absence of complexity and of much 
 very vivid dramatic colour was in " John Halifax " 
 more or less deliberate, becomes strikingly evident 
 to any one who has any acquaintance with the 
 somewhat florid style of Miss Mulock's previous 
 novel, "The Ogilvies," published by Messrs. 
 Smith and Elder in 1849, and among the most 
 successful of her previous stories. The latter, 
 though full of warmth and vigour, is as rhetorical 
 as it is earnest, and even somewhat girlish in the 
 unchecked ardour of its rhapsodies and the appeals 
 to Heaven and to the reader in its unreserved 
 soliloquising. Interesting it undoubtedly is, and 
 to readers of "John Halifax" especially interest- 
 ing ; for it shows clearly that already the central 
 idea of the later novel was unconsciously shaping 
 itself in the mind of the writer, as, for instance, 
 when she speaks of Mr. Frederick Pennythorne as 
 " too ordinary and vulgar-minded for a gentleman, 
 and far oh, far too mean in heart and soul for 
 the noble title of a man." But the advance made 
 in the book by which she is mainly remembered, 
 and with which we are chiefly concerned, is little 
 short of amazing ; and it is an advance almost 
 entirely in the direction of self-restraint and 
 brevity. 
 
 It is just another instance of what Pater long 
 ago insisted upon, the fact that beauty of style is 
 simply the outcome of beauty in the thought 
 
 197 
 
OF 
 
 to be expressed, such as includes high-minded 
 veracity, and a literary conscience pledged to regard 
 no scruple as too minute for consideration and no 
 faintest shade of difference as unimportant, in the 
 service of a many-sided truth. Tawdry language 
 or reckless elaboration would have been peculiarly 
 out of place in a literary venture which aimed at 
 the expression of a truth at once primitive and 
 fundamental. In claiming integrity for commerce, 
 and dignity for manual labour, it was a wise in- 
 stinct that opposed itself to all the facile wordiness 
 of the typical demagogue. 
 
 So quietly and successfully has the book done its 
 work in the forty-two years which have elapsed 
 since publication, that we at this day fail to realise 
 the strength of illogical and social prejudice which 
 in the preceding century so successfully ostracised 
 every form of trade. Jane Austen, who preceded 
 Miss Mulock by more than one generation, has 
 given us a vivid and convincing picture of the 
 society in which she moved. Her creations are 
 real men and women, and they are always either 
 amusing or interesting, but, whether they be as 
 silly and vulgar as Mrs. Bennet, or as sensible and 
 well-bred as the clear-headed and warm-hearted 
 Elizabeth, they all of them play their cards in polite 
 drawing-rooms to which the Apostle Peter himself 
 would never have been admitted as an equal guest 
 if he had happened to carry a few nets over his arm, 
 and where the angel who took the place of Theocrite 
 might for hours have knocked vainly for admission 
 if he had chanced to be seen mending shoes or 
 standing behind the counter. 
 198 
 
VICTOR A3^ ^OFSL 
 
 Perhaps, to speak the whole truth, our appre- 
 ciation of Jane Austen's admirable workmanship 
 and delightful personality is so devout, and we 
 love her Anne Elliot, her Elizabeth Bennet, and 
 her Emma par excellence^ with so tender a regard, 
 she is herself at once so human and so refined, so 
 sensible and so high-minded, that we shrink with 
 an unconfessed cowardice from noting the limi- 
 tations of her horizon. In dramatic skill and 
 verisimilitude Miss Mulock cannot for a moment 
 compete with her ; but, though Jane Austen was 
 so good and sweet a woman, in spiritual imagina- 
 tation she stands easily surpassed ; and it may even 
 be doubted whether the excessive adulation that is 
 sometimes bestowed upon her may not be partly 
 the effect of our decadent fashion of regarding a 
 too definite idealism as priggish and obsolete. 
 The patronising air with which "John Halifax" 
 is handed over to Sunday schools does probably, 
 unconsciously, owe something of its supercilious- 
 ness to the influence of a literary clique, by whom 
 an anarchical pessimism is regarded as the hall- 
 mark of culture, and a too definite Christianity is 
 treated as the last resort of fools. 
 
 When this time of transition has passed, it is 
 possible that a more impartial justice will be done 
 to the precision and beauty of language which 
 mark the opening chapters of this fascinating 
 story. Here and there the conversations are 
 touched perhaps with a certain quaint bookishness 
 of which Ibsen has excellently rid the plays and 
 novels of our own time, but that was an occasional 
 characteristic which the writer shared with almost 
 
 199 
 
s OF 
 
 all her contemporaries, and even Ethel Newcome 
 now and then " talked like a book " ; nor can it 
 be contended even to-day that we all scatter bril- 
 liant aphorisms in our ordinary talk quite so 
 frequently as the men and women in George 
 Meredith's romances. But this slightly self- 
 conscious correctness of conversation, though at 
 the very opposite extreme from the epigrams of 
 " The Egoist " or of " Diana," is not a very serious 
 fault, if it be indeed the worst that can be urged. 
 Though no one can accord to the second half of 
 the story the same degree of admiration that is 
 given to the first, it must be remembered that the 
 achievement at which it aimed was one of peculiar 
 difficulty. To express the beauty of Christianity 
 through all the complexities of social and of 
 family life, and, with all the details of an ordered 
 domesticity, to draw the ideal husband and father 
 and citizen without ever missing the note of 
 reality, on the one hand, or the canons of an 
 exacting art upon the other, was a task that might 
 well tax such commanding genius as Mrs. Craik's 
 best friends have never claimed for her. The 
 second part of " John Halifax " has not the ex- 
 quisite charm which in " Marius the Epicurean, " 
 for instance, irradiates every detail of life with a 
 beauty which is of itself a note of disciplined 
 idealism, and should be an especial note of Chris- 
 tianity, but it may well be borne in mind that "John 
 Halifax " has entered deeply into the life and work 
 of innumerable men and women who would have 
 turned with impatience from a single page of 
 Walter Pater. How wide and incalculable its 
 200 
 
influence has been is suggested by the fact that 
 Americans who in visiting England make their first 
 pilgrimage to Stratford-on-Avon, often make their 
 second to the home of John Halifax at Tewkesbury. 
 
 Mrs. Craik's own birthplace of Stoke-upon- 
 Trent was a much less delightful town. It is in 
 the heart of the "Potteries"--" the Black Country " 
 as it has sometimes been called, though it may 
 have been a little less black perhaps in those early 
 days of the century than in these. This so-called 
 " Black Country," however, which kindles grim 
 imaginings by its great furnaces, where the kilns 
 spit flames upon the darkness, has here and there 
 many fine bits of country, where wildflowers 
 grow lavishly in the intervening oases amid the 
 monotonous desolation. 
 
 Stoke is not very far from the beautiful grounds 
 of Trentham Hall, where such a practical and 
 necessary protest has been made against the 
 murderous and crippling lead-poisoning of the 
 neighbourhood ; the Duchess of Sutherland, with 
 a good sense worthy of John Halifax himself, 
 having led the movement in favour of earthenware 
 manufactured without the poisonous glaze which 
 has hitherto been eating into the brain-power and 
 nerve-power of the poor blinded pottery folk. 
 When " John Halifax " was written, this injury to 
 health and life had not yet been laid bare by the 
 advance of medical knowledge, nor had purchasers 
 to say nothingof employers of labour awakened 
 to a sense of their responsibility in such matters. 
 
 It was eleven years after the battle of Waterloo, 
 and six years before the passing of the Reform 
 
 201 
 
OF 
 
 Bill, before Chartism had yet been heard of, when 
 hardly a decade had passed since Miss Austen's 
 death, and when Queen Victoria and George Eliot 
 were both little girls of seven years old, Charlotte 
 Bronte a child of ten, and Thackeray a boy of 
 fifteen, that, in the little town of Stoke-upon- 
 Trent, in the home of an obscure and somewhat 
 eccentric minister named Thomas Mulock, the 
 heart of a burdened and sorrowful wife was cheered 
 by the coming of a daughter, a little brown-haired, 
 grey-eyed daughter, who was named Dinah. 
 Thomas Mulock was a man of considerable gifts 
 and literary attainments, and he wrote and preached 
 with effect, but he had little idea of providing for 
 those of his own house. His daughter grew up 
 to be her mother's dauntless and tender protector, 
 at once nurse and breadwinner, and finally carried 
 that mother off, with her two boys, to make a new 
 home for her in London, where she faced honest 
 poverty with the pride and silence of the true 
 " gentylnesse '' and the high-spirited courage which 
 perhaps came to Dinah Mulock as a part of the 
 maternal heritage. It will be noted that the 
 writer who claimed for the tanner's apprentice a 
 refinement above all charlatanry, and pictured him 
 as the nobler for his honest trade, and as finding 
 his highest opportunities in the calling which was 
 his hardest daily sacrifice, could make her protest 
 with the better grace from the fact that she her- 
 self had never come under the silly coldness, or 
 vulgar patronage, with which it was in those days 
 too much the fashion to alienate mercantile 
 pursuits. 
 
 202 
 
Mrs. Craik, then Dinah Mulock, seems to 
 belong so entirely to our own time that we are 
 a little apt to forget, perhaps, how different was 
 the England of her childhood from the England 
 of to-day. 
 
 She was already four years old before any rail- 
 way had yet cut into the heart of the leafy green 
 country or defiled that valley of the silver Trent 
 in which lay her home, and the canals which 
 intersected Stoke must have been the scene of 
 much peaceful coming and going of heavily laden 
 barges. She was only two or three years old when, 
 in two succeeding years, the Test and Corporation 
 Acts and Roman Catholic disabilities were repealed. 
 These were the days of Daniel O'Connell's agita- 
 tion for the repeal of the Union; and the passing 
 of the Reform Bill, the Abolition of Slavery, and 
 the new Poor Law, all came soon afterwards in 
 rapid succession, before Dinah was nine years 
 old, and probably were of more influence on her 
 environment than the accession of William IV., 
 in 1830, when she was still a very little child, or 
 even the opening of the first railway in the same 
 year. She was thirteen when the penny post was 
 introduced, and still a girl of twenty when in the 
 year of the Irish Famine the Corn Laws were 
 abolished. Eleven years later came the horror of 
 the Indian Mutiny, close upon the heels of the 
 Crimean War ; and she lived through the ferment 
 of the second and third Reform Bills, the passing 
 of the Education Act, the Abolition of the 
 University Tests, and the proposal for Home 
 Rule made by Mr. Gladstone, in a word, it may 
 
 203 
 
OF 
 
 be said that, with the one important exception of 
 the French Revolution, her life was touched by 
 almost all that was most eventful in that eventful 
 century, that Victorian Age which has been 
 summed up as "the age of sociology." Her own 
 life was not uneventful, and not wanting in the 
 practical poetry which is better than mere romance; 
 but it can only be given in barest outline, for she 
 held that the world at large had no right to cross 
 the threshold of a woman's home for any other 
 reason than that of personal friendship, and that 
 gratitude for her writing, if she happen to be a 
 writer, is best shown by respecting the modesty 
 of her reserve. To quote words lately spoken 
 by one who knew her intimately : " There never 
 was a more tender or domestic nature, or one that 
 would shrink more from anything like ' making a 
 life of her.' ' And perhaps at this point it may 
 be permissible to add the dictum of her friend 
 Dr. Garnett, who wrote in the " Dictionary of 
 National Biography" : " She was not a genius, and 
 she does not express the ideals and aspirations of 
 women of exceptional genius : but the tender and 
 philanthropic, and at the same time energetic and 
 practical, womanhood of ordinary life has never 
 had a more sufficient representative." 
 
 To those who know the difficulty of such a 
 career, it is amazing to think of a simple, untried 
 girl as coming up from the country to London 
 with three others dependent on her pen (her mother 
 and two young brothers), and facing the world 
 for them without any assured income, though one 
 of the three was an invalid and needing special care. 
 204 
 
But from the first she wrote easily and rapidly, 
 and working not for fame but in the determination 
 to bear her own burden and the burden of those 
 she cared for, she won the reputation for which 
 there had been no petty struggle or selfish striving ; 
 and from a single-minded desire to deliver her own 
 earnest and unaffected message, she achieved a much 
 wider and more lasting recognition than many who 
 have aimed at distinction and toiled for immortality. 
 Mrs. Oliphant, who was her friend and con- 
 temporary, tells how Miss Mulock was only 
 twenty-three at the time of her first important 
 publication, and how it was long before that age 
 that her independent career had begun, and that, 
 having rescued the frail mother from the father 
 " of brilliant attainments," she had, as by a miracle, 
 in the great desert of London, managed to keep 
 the little household going, through magazine work 
 of various kinds, from the fashion-books upwards. 
 Another lifelong friend has whispered to the 
 writer of this article that the bread she was able 
 to win for them all at first was sometimes, very 
 literally, only bread. Perhaps that was one reason 
 why later in life, when after her marriage she had 
 her own spacious home and sufficent wealth, in all 
 her delicate generosities and endless piottings for 
 the pleasure of those less rich than herself, she 
 always knew just where the poverty pinched, and 
 used her carriage for the very people who needed 
 it most ; to the last using an omnibus for herself, 
 whenever that was possible, that she might the 
 oftener have the luxury of choosing for more 
 ailing people more luxurious chariots. 
 
 205 
 
OF 
 
 Through all her life her generous kindness knew 
 no bounds, and often was the more touching from 
 the fact that it was not the careless giving of the 
 spendthrift but the hard-won privilege of economy, 
 foresight, self-denial. Like Mrs. Ewing's Madam 
 Liberality, she hoarded the plums in her cake for 
 other people, and managed her affairs with order 
 and precision that she might never be hampered 
 by sordid anxiety or petty selfishness. 
 
 Through a wise carefulness, she attained more 
 and more to what has been called <c the higher 
 carelessness," and, in her later years in the midst 
 of a methodically managed household which owed 
 its smoothness and comfort to her forethought, 
 never suffered herself to be fretted by trivial 
 worries or unforeseen details. 
 
 She was an excellent woman of business, and it 
 is interesting to learn, from the friends of her youth, 
 that these gifts of exactness and order and method 
 were developed gradually as life went on, and that 
 the very people who testified to them would, in 
 her girlhood, have described her as somewhat 
 " happy-go-lucky." 
 
 Her memories of her earliest home made any 
 form of debt seem to her the one impossible in- 
 dignity, and in her resolute unflinching avoidance 
 of it, through the first years of struggle for those 
 she loved, she attained the new powers and faculties 
 which eased the strain of existence, and the ad- 
 mirable poise and harmony of her life lent itself 
 more and more to all that surrounds a woman 
 with beauty and with peace. 
 
 But to go back for a moment to the days when 
 206 
 
Mrs. Oliphant describes her as a " young heroic 
 creature writing her pretty juvenile nonsense of 
 love and lovers, in swift, unformed style, as fast 
 as the pen could fly, to get bread for the boys 
 and a little soup and wine for the invalid over 
 whose deathbed she watched with impassioned love 
 and care a tragic, tender picture, to be associated 
 by ever so distant a link with inane magazines of 
 the fashions and short-lived periodicals unknown 
 to fame." * 
 
 She lived then in Mornington Crescent, in the 
 north of London, towards Camden Town, until, 
 after her success as an author was assured, she 
 moved to Wildwood, a cottage at North End, on 
 the Golder's Hill side of Hampstead. 
 
 She was surrounded by friends, and one who 
 had known her from the time when she was herself 
 a girl of fifteen, Miss Mulock being a year or two 
 older, has pretended a little playful resentment at 
 what, to her thinking, was not quite accurate in 
 some of Mrs. Oliphant's allusions to the " bevy of 
 attendant maidens " who seemed to make a kind of 
 guard of honour about her. ' c Many friends indeed 
 she had," says this old friend, " but the friendship 
 was in many cases an equal one, ' the true reci- 
 procity,' implying no patronising airs on the one 
 hand, no excessive dependence on the other." 
 And then she went on to say that, at the time 
 when "John Halifax" was being written, she and 
 another of these old comrades, no longer then 
 in their first girlhood, were at that time sharing 
 a home with Miss Mulock, and teased and criticised 
 * Macmillan's Magazine, December 1887. 
 
 207 
 
OF 
 
 her and "her dear John" most unmercifully as 
 the " proofs" of the book came in, themselves 
 helping with the corrections. No one knew then, 
 of course, whether it would succeed or not. 
 
 But what does seem to have been true in Mrs. 
 Oliphant's picture, and what, after all, dwells most 
 happily in the reader's mind, is that it was of the 
 " talents and accomplishments " " of other am- 
 bitious and admiring girls " that " Miss Mulock 
 had always tales to tell, with an enthusiasm not 
 excited by any success of her own." She was 
 always a centre of sympathy, of help, and of 
 counsel. And while her own talk was so full of 
 the charms and interests of others, Dr. Garnett 
 tells how charming she was herself, and how 
 her " simple cordiality, staunch friendliness, and 
 thorough goodness of heart perfected the fas- 
 cination." The sweetness of her singing was a 
 great pleasure to her friends, and her voice lasted 
 well. She was of the musical temperament, and 
 delighted in the best music, but the circumstances 
 of her life had prevented her from gaining the 
 accomplishment of finished playing. More than 
 one of her friends has noted that she had that 
 " taking " gift in a woman, a beautiful hand. 
 Very capable hands they were too, though it was 
 later in life that she became, like George Eliot and 
 many other able women, an exquisite needle- 
 woman ; in the early days of struggle there was 
 no time for that. Her handwriting was small and 
 delicate and neat. Like many others who have 
 written much, she never sat at a table to write. 
 She just held a little block in her hand, as near to 
 208 
 
 
vfy^ SA^LT 
 
 her eyes as she could, and scribbled away in any 
 convenient corner. She was not among those who 
 make a fuss about their " work." In one sense it 
 came to her very easily, and always had done; but 
 she was untiringly diligent, as her very numerous 
 volumes of prose and verse will at once suggest. 
 There seems to have been in her character a certain 
 self-reliance and sureness of touch, a modest self- 
 dependence, or even self-confidence, which is cer- 
 tainly at the very opposite pole from egotism or 
 vanity. If she played or sang or entertained, she 
 merely did her best, and gave herself no petty 
 anxiety as to the effect produced. This may 
 have been one reason perhaps why, without being 
 a brilliant talker, when she did speak, what she 
 said was always neatly turned and to the point. 
 Possibly this attitude of mind was made the easier 
 from the fact that she had not that painfully quick 
 sense of the ridiculous which often makes a more 
 complicated nature self-critical and self-torturing. 
 This freedom from self-regarding regrets, together 
 with her constant consideration for others, and 
 thoughtful common sense, must have made her a 
 singularly restful companion. 
 
 She first came to London about 1846, and she 
 had been fortunate in the fact that one of her 
 friends, Charles Edward Mudie, came up at about 
 the same time, and another, Alexander Macmillan, 
 rather later. One created " Mudie's Library," 
 and the other became the head of the great firm 
 which still bears his name, and in which Mr. Craik 
 was for many years a partner. Both, as Dr. Garnett 
 points out, were able to help her. 
 
 o 209 
 
OF 
 
 It was, however, through another friend, no 
 other than Mrs. Oliphant herself, that, at a little 
 dinner-party given for that purpose, she was 
 introduced to Mr. Henry Blackett as a possible 
 publisher for "John Halifax." That novel was 
 published on generous terms by Messrs. Hurst 
 and Blackett in 1857, and proved an instantaneous 
 success. It was warmly welcomed throughout 
 England, and in America (as has been pointed 
 out in an appreciative introductory note to one 
 of the many editions) its "rare qualities and their 
 actual significance were more clearly understood 
 and appreciated than they have ever yet been in 
 England/' 
 
 In this " appreciation " we have a most interest- 
 ing and succinct account of how the book came 
 to be written. The success of the three previous 
 novels " The Ogilvies," " Olive," and "The 
 Head of the Family " had opened to the author 
 all doors " in all grades of English life," and, 
 though herself an earnest Churchwoman, it seemed 
 to her at that day that among the Quakers she 
 could best find that type of simple and ideal 
 Christianity lived " in the spirit of Paul the Tent- 
 maker," which was what she now wished to por- 
 tray. She had already " found her models and 
 sketched her characters, 5 ' " she always said that 
 Ursula was the only copy from nature she ever 
 made" when, while visiting some of her friends 
 in the neighbourhood of Cheltenham and Stroud, 
 she happened to drive over to Tewkesbury, and 
 of that eventful afternoon, as described by 
 Mrs. Oliphant from the notebook of one of the 
 
 2IO 
 
friends in question, we are permitted by the cour- 
 tesy of Messrs. Macmillan to give the following 
 account : 
 
 "In the summer of 1852," said this friend, 
 " she one day drove over with me to see the quaint 
 old town of Tewkesbury. Directly she saw the 
 grand old Abbey and the mediaeval houses of the 
 High Street, she decided that this should form 
 the background of her story, and like a true artist 
 fell to work making mental sketches on the spot. 
 A sudden shower drove us into one of the old 
 covered alleys opposite the house, I believe, of 
 the then town clerk of Tewkesbury, and as we 
 stood there, a bright-looking but ragged boy 
 also took refuge at the mouth of the alley, and 
 from the town clerk's window a little girl gazed 
 with looks of sympathy at the ragged boy oppo- 
 site. Presently the door opened, and the girl 
 appeared on the steps, and beckoned to the boy 
 to take a piece of bread, exactly as the scene 
 is described in the opening chapters of c john 
 Halifax.' We had lunch at the Bell Inn, and 
 explored the bowling-green, which also is minutely 
 and accurately described, and the landlord's state- 
 ment that the house had once been used by a 
 tanner, and the smell of tan which filled the streets 
 from a tan-yard not far off, decided the trade 
 which her hero was to follow. 
 
 "She made one or two subsequent visits to 
 further identify her background, and the name of 
 her hero was decided by the discovery of an old 
 gravestone in the Abbey churchyard, on which 
 was inscribed 'John Halifax.' She had already 
 
 211 
 
OF 
 
 decided that the hero's Christian name must be 
 John, but the surname had been hitherto doubtful." 
 
 It may be added that Longfield is drawn from 
 Detmore House, near Cheltenham ; and we are 
 assured that Rose Cottage and Enderley Flat were 
 " copied exactly from Amberley Common, near 
 Stroud." 
 
 In all talk with those who were intimate with 
 Mrs. Craik, such talks as have been a necessary 
 preparation for this slight introduction to " John 
 Halifax," always the most touching and beautiful 
 facts were those which might not be written of her, 
 though they have necessarily coloured the whole 
 tone of the article. One such fact especially has 
 impressed itself indelibly on the memory, an act 
 of tender and generous maternal thoughtfulness 
 for a young mother and child, involving detailed 
 effort on the part of Mrs. Craik, and of him who 
 was her other self in such matters, and continued 
 daily for many months. This was after her 
 marriage with Mr. Craik in 1865, when she was 
 living in her beautiful home at Shortlands and 
 had adopted a little daughter, so that her heart 
 was brimming over with ever-deepening affection 
 towards all mothers and all children. 
 
 It is a pity that because of her extreme reserve 
 in such matters, so many instances of her friendly 
 helpfulness can be only thus distantly alluded to, 
 and must be held as secret as though they were 
 crimes instead of the most gracious of deeds. 
 But an old friend, now a silver-haired grand- 
 father, though the youngest and most energetic 
 of men, has added a pretty touch to this paper 
 
 212 
 
by telling, with due permission to use it, a little 
 incident of a much more trivial kind, which he has 
 long remembered as characteristic of Mrs. Craik's 
 kindliness, a kindliness always free from self-con- 
 sciousness, and almost maternal in its quick and 
 delicate consideration for others. She was no 
 longer a girl at the time when he knew her, but 
 full of charm not beautiful, yet of a haunting 
 delightfulness no hard angles in the softly sweep- 
 ing curves of the tall, slim, graciously rounded 
 figure, the face lighting up sweetly with every 
 passing thought or emotion that flashed its wild- 
 rose colour into the blonde fairness, or glowed in 
 the clear-shining, eagerly responsive eyes, 
 
 " Eyes too expressive to be blue, 
 Too lovely to be gray," 
 
 and with a certain firmness in the moulding of the 
 warm red lips, and in the calm brow beneath the 
 soft brown hair just touched with silver. 
 
 He, the friend who tells the story, was much 
 younger than she was, and perhaps seemed to her 
 hardly more than a boy in those days, though he 
 admired her greatly. He used to meet her in the 
 house of a well-known novelist and poet, her friend 
 and his. She knew all about his wooing and the 
 betrothal that followed, though neither of them 
 could know then to what ever-deepening joy it 
 led through all his life. It was in the first flush 
 of that happiness that by chance he found himself 
 in the same railway carriage with her on the North 
 London Railway between Camden Road and 
 Richmond, each bound to the same wedding, to 
 
 213 
 
OF 
 
 which they were both invited guests not his own 
 wedding this time, though all weddings were of 
 extraordinary interest to him just then. He is 
 a prosperous man now, but he was then at the 
 beginning of life with his way still to make, as 
 no doubt she very well knew ; and lavender gloves 
 such gloves as he had bought for the occasion 
 did not hang on every hedge ; they were a shade 
 too small, and he was in danger of ruining them 
 by the plunging in of a good strong masculine 
 hand. Miss Mulock's own hands were not quite 
 so large as his, and she undertook, quite frankly 
 and simply, to try the gloves on herself first, and 
 thereby stretch them to the necessary width. She 
 was then in the heyday of her modest fame, and 
 the pretty good-nature with which it was done 
 made it all a bit of pride and pleasure to the young 
 man ; for even friendship has its " trifles light as 
 air " that cling long in the remembrance. When, 
 some years later, he heard of Miss Mulock's 
 own marriage in 1865 with Mr. George Lillie 
 Craik, one of the partners in the house of Mac- 
 millan and Co., every detail of the romance was 
 to him of vivid interest. 
 
 This marriage, which crowned her life with ever- 
 increasing happiness, made no break in Mrs. Craik's 
 relations with her own publishers, Messrs. Hurst 
 and Blackett, relations which seem to have consti- 
 tuted a very long and pleasant business connection, 
 an instance, as their common friend Mrs. Oliphant 
 has pointed out, of Mrs. Craik's " fidelity to every 
 bond." 
 
 In conversation with others of her old friends 
 214 
 
VICTOR A^ 3(0 rSL 
 
 before writing this paper, two points were especially 
 and repeatedly touched upon. First, the modest 
 and businesslike way in which she treated her 
 writing, never talking about it, but when her house 
 was full of guests guests well cared for in every 
 detail just slipping out of their ken during the 
 mornings while she achieved her daily stint of 
 work, and then giving herself up to them wholly 
 in the afternoon and evening ; and secondly, the 
 endless delight she took in using her carriage for 
 the convenience of those who had no carriage of 
 their own, plotting and counter-plotting sometimes 
 to help three and four sets of people on the same 
 afternoon, till the intricacies of the arrangements 
 made it quite a triumph to bring all to a successful 
 conclusion. 
 
 In the possession of more than one of these 
 friends there is a portrait of Mrs. Craik, taken 
 not long before her death. It is a good, sensible, 
 trustworthy face, suggestive of a character entirely 
 free from anything tawdry or meretricious; the 
 hair under the soft lace she was very fond of 
 lace is parted smoothly above the wide, tranquil 
 forehead, and the eyes look straight onward with 
 a certain clear steadfastness. Nose, mouth, and 
 chin add to the impression of courage and 
 veracity, a forcible and well-balanced directness 
 of nature, and complete an aspect of gentle 
 dignity and repose. 
 
 One of her lifelong friends remarked lately: 
 " It was characteristic of her simplicity that she 
 used to say of the little girl adopted soon after her 
 marriage, and who lived to grow up and marry 
 
 215 
 
OF 
 
 into a home of her own : ' I love Dorothy more 
 even than if she were a child of my own ' ; just as 
 though," added the friend in question, " she could 
 possibly know what her love for a child of her 
 own would have been ! " 
 
 During all the time of her married life her 
 pension from the Queen was religiously and 
 silently set aside for the service of those who 
 needed it more than herself. For nearly twenty 
 years she lived at Shortlands, beloved and re- 
 spected by rich and poor. 
 
 Mrs. Oliphant, from whose article in their 
 magazine Messrs. Macmillan have kindly per- 
 mitted me to quote the following paragraph, has 
 written that in 1887 " her medical advisers had 
 enjoined a great deal of rest, with which the 
 pleasant cares of an approaching marriage in the 
 family, and all the necessary arrangements to make 
 the outset of her adopted daughter in life as bright 
 and delightful as possible, considerably interfered. 
 In one attack of breathlessness and faintness some 
 short time before, she had murmured forth an 
 entreaty that the marriage should not be delayed 
 by anything that could happen to her. But even 
 this did not frighten the fond and cheerful circle, 
 which was used to nothing but happiness. On 
 the morning of the twelfth of October, her 
 husband, before going off to his business, took a 
 loving leave of her, almost more loving than his 
 wont, though without any presentiment, pro- 
 voking a laughing remark from their daughter, to 
 which Mrs. Craik answered that though so long 
 married, they were still lovers. These were the 
 216 
 
S^RLT 
 
 last words he heard from her lips, and no man 
 could have a more sweet assurance of the happiness 
 his tender care had procured. When he came 
 home cheerfully in the afternoon to his always 
 cheerful home, the sight of the doctor's carriage 
 at the door, and the coachman's incautious ex- 
 planation that ' the lady was dying,' were the only 
 preparations he had for the great and solemn 
 event which had already taken place. He found 
 her in her own room, lying on her sofa, with an 
 awestricken group standing round dead. She 
 had entertained various visitors in the afternoon. 
 Some time after they were gone, she had rung her 
 bell, saying she felt ill ; the servants, alarmed, 
 called for assistance, and she was laid upon the 
 sofa. A few minutes' struggle for breath, a 
 murmur, ' Oh, if I could live four weeks longer : 
 but no matter no matter,' and all was over. 
 Thus she died as she had lived her last thought 
 for others, for the bride whose festival day must 
 be overshadowed by so heavy a cloud, yet of 
 content and acquiescence in whatever the supreme 
 Arbiter of events thought right. An ideal ending, 
 such as God grant us all when our day comes." 
 
 One who has been already quoted in these 
 pages has himself quoted Claude de Saint-Martin, 
 " the great unknown philosopher," as saying : 
 " Have we advanced one step farther on the 
 radiant path of enlightenment that leads to the 
 simplicity of men ? ' We answer that it may 
 at least be claimed for the author of " John 
 Halifax " that her footprints led that way. 
 
 By public subscription a monument was placed 
 
 217 
 
OF 
 
 in Tewkesbury Abbey to commemorate her name. 
 Most appropriately, as indicating her reverence 
 and her faith, these words from the close of " John 
 Halifax "have been inscribed on the memorial: 
 " Each in his place is fulfilling his day and passing 
 away, just as that sun is passing only we know 
 not whither he passes : whither we go we know, 
 and the Way we know the same yesterday, to- 
 day, and for ever." 
 
 218 
 
THE CHILDREN IN GEORGE 
 ELIOT'S STORIES 
 
 THERE are few more charming scenes in George 
 Eliot's novels than that in which little Job Tudge 
 plays an important part. " Job was a small fellow 
 about five, with a germinal nose, large round blue 
 eyes, and red hair that curled close to his head." 
 Having wept copiously over his own cut finger, 
 and been taught that such was not the part of a 
 brave Briton, he relieves the tension of that 
 sweetly difficult moment for the two lovers, who 
 have not yet learned how dear they are to one 
 another, when Felix Holt's strong hand has been 
 laid in unspoken comfort on Esther Lyon's 
 delicate fingers, while she tries to falter forth 
 her sense of what has seemed to her his forgetful 
 aloofness 
 
 The graceful, self-centred Miss Lyon was 
 trembling with tears in the presence of Felix 
 Holt's smothered stress of feeling and calm re- 
 straint, when little Job looked up by way of 
 attracting attention to himself, exclaiming, " She's 
 tut her finger," and, amid the laughter and with- 
 drawal of hands that followed, re aied to Esther's 
 confession that she was a coward : " Zoo souldn't 
 kuy." 
 
 Job is only one out of the many delightful 
 children who are found in George Eliot's novels. 
 Either by accident or design, they are often in the 
 near distance in some critical scene, even when, as 
 
 219 
 
OF 
 
 in this instance, they do not actually occupy the 
 foreground. 
 
 Milly Barton's children are drawn with such 
 delicate realism, so chary a touch upon the deep 
 well-springs of sacred emotion, that the story 
 leaves in the mind of the reader such an imprint 
 as only a great artist could have achieved. And 
 the same master-hand has drawn for us Marty 
 and Tommy and Tottie in "Adam Bede," who, 
 despite the knee-breeches of the period, are just 
 such children as may be found in country farm- 
 houses to-day. 
 
 c< ' Mind what the parson says, mind what the 
 parson says, my lads/ said Grandfather to the 
 black-eyed youngsters in knee-breeches, conscious 
 of a marble or two in their pockets which they 
 looked forward to handling a little, secretly, 
 during the sermon. 
 
 " 'Dood-bye, dandad,' said Totty ; f me doin* 
 to church, me dot my netlace on. Dive me a 
 peppermint.' . . . 
 
 " And when they were all gone, the old man 
 leaned on the gate again, watching them across 
 the lane along the Home Close, and through the 
 far gate, till they disappeared behind a bend in the 
 hedge. For the hedgerows in those days shut out 
 one's view, even on the better-managed farms ; 
 and this afternoon the dog-roses were tossing out 
 their pink wreaths, the nightshade was in its 
 yellow and purple glory, the pale honeysuckle 
 grew out of reach, peeping high up out of a 
 holly-bush, and over all an ash or a sycamore 
 220 
 
SLiors 
 
 every now and then threw its shadow across the 
 path. . . . 
 
 " The fact was that this Sunday walk through 
 the fields was fraught with great excitement to 
 Marty and Tommy, who saw a perpetual drama 
 going on in the hedgerows, and could no more 
 refrain from stopping and peeping than if they 
 had been a couple of spaniels or terriers. Marty 
 was quite sure he saw a yellow-hammer on the 
 boughs of the great ash, and while he was peep- 
 ing, he missed the sight of a white-throated stoat, 
 which had run across the path and was described 
 with much fervour by the junior Tommy. Then 
 there was a little green-finch, just fledged, flutter- 
 ing along the ground, and it seemed quite possible 
 to catch it till it managed to flutter under the 
 blackberry bush. . . ." 
 
 And then there is Tommy Bond, who had 
 " recently quitted frocks and trousers for the severe 
 simplicity of a tight suit of corduroys, relieved by 
 numerous brass buttons. Tommy was a saucy 
 boy, impervious to all impressions of reverence, 
 and excessively addicted to humming-tops and 
 marbles, with which recreative resources he was in 
 the habit of immoderately distending the pockets 
 of his corduroys. One day, spinning his top on 
 the garden walk, and seeing the vicar advance 
 directly towards it, at that exciting moment when 
 it was beginning to ' sleep ' magnificently, he 
 shouted out with all the force of his lungs 
 ' Stop ! don't knock my top down, now ! ' 
 From that day ' little Corduroys ' had been an 
 
 221 
 
OF 
 
 especial favourite with Mr. Gilfil, who delighted 
 to provoke his ready scorn and wonder by putting 
 questions which gave Tommy the meanest opinion 
 of his intellect. 
 
 " < Well, little Corduroys, have they milked the 
 geese to-day ? ' 
 
 " ' Milked the geese ? Why, they don't milk 
 the geese, you silly ! ' 
 
 " ' No ? dear heart ? Why, how do the goslings 
 live, then ? ' 
 
 " The nutriment of goslings rather transcend- 
 ing Tommy's observations in natural history, he 
 feigned to understand this question in an ex- 
 clamatory rather than an interrogatory sense, and 
 became absorbed in winding up his top. 
 
 " * Ah, I see you don't know how the goslings 
 live. But did you notice how it rained sugar- 
 plums yesterday ? ' (Here Tommy's face be- 
 came attentive.) 'Why, they fell into my 
 pocket as I rode along. You look in my pocket 
 and see if they didn't.' 
 
 " Tommy, without waiting to discuss the 
 alleged antecedent, lost no time in ascertaining the 
 presence of the agreeable consequence, for he had 
 a well-founded belief in the advantages of diving 
 into the vicar's pocket. Mr. Gilfil called it his 
 wonderful pocket, because, as he delighted to tell 
 the c young shavers ' and ' two shoes ' so he 
 called all little boys and girls whenever he put 
 pennies into it, they turned into sugar-plums or 
 ginger-bread, or some other nice thing. Indeed, 
 little Bessie Parrot, a flaxen-headed ' two shoes,' 
 very white and fat as to her neck, always had the 
 
 222 
 
SLIOTS sroi^res 
 
 admirable directness and sincerity to salute him 
 with the question, ' What zoo dot in zoo pottet?" 
 
 Tina, the heroine of " Mr. GilnTs Love-story," 
 and that enchanting sprig of apple-blossom, the 
 Hetty Sorrel of Adam Bede's earlier love, before 
 sin had darkened and awakened in her the con- 
 sciousness of a soul within, are both almost as 
 truly children in their dawning and dangerous 
 womanhood as was the immortal Maggie Tulliver 
 herself, in those early days when she inquired 
 anxiously whether Mrs. Stelling was "a cross 
 
 woman/ 1 
 
 Tessa's children are remembered for the wise 
 words they drew from Romola about the happi- 
 ness that sometimes lies in a difficult choice, and 
 the Garths are altogether normal and delightful 
 children, but it is in the exquisite skill with which 
 George Eliot brings home to us the charm of such 
 everyday babies as Mrs. Poyser's Tottie, and the 
 little grandchild of the Jeromes, in " Janet's 
 Repentance," that this author herself childless 
 stands indisputably supreme. 
 
 223 
 
THE WORDS AND WAYS 
 OF CHILDREN 
 
 A HARD-WORKED London artist told his friends 
 with great glee one evening that he had had three 
 pieces of luck that day : he had sat opposite to a 
 beautiful face in the Underground Railway ; he had 
 been assured by a stranger that he was a good- 
 hearted fellow ; and, best of all, he had overheard 
 a little ragged girl saying to herself, over and over 
 again, " Two silver shillings ! Two silver shil- 
 lings ! " having come into possession of that magic 
 treasure. 
 
 No one was commonplace enough to ask him 
 why the little girl's words should have so tickled his 
 fancy. Silver shillings are common enough, but 
 they may, like other current coin, be transmuted 
 by the glamour of childhood into symbols of 
 happiness itself. 
 
 Children have no language which will adequately 
 describe the slowly moving miraculous panorama 
 of their inward visions. Walter Bagehot has 
 expressed this with delightful humour, where he 
 says of this interior existence : " You have war- 
 like ideas, but you cannot say to a sinewy relative : 
 ' My dear aunt, I wonder when the big bush in the 
 garden will begin to walk about ; I'm sure it's a 
 Crusader, and I was cutting it all day long with 
 my steel sword. But what do you think, aunt ? 
 for I'm puzzled about its legs, because, you see, 
 aunt, it has only one stalk ; and besides, aunt, 
 224 
 
OF 
 
 the leaves.' You cannot remark this in secular 
 life, but you hack at the invincible bush till you 
 do not wholly reject the idea that your small garden 
 is Palestine, and yourself the most adventurous of 
 knights." 
 
 The sense of humour in boys is only equalled 
 by their healthy hatred of all cant and affectation. 
 But perhaps the morbid desire of the senti- 
 mentalists to "dee and do nought ava " is begin- 
 ning to taint even the childhood of this artificial 
 age, for a little boy, lately promoted to knicker- 
 bockers, professed at last to have found something 
 to live for. "Nurse," he said, "I don't want to 
 die now" 
 
 4 'No, Master Frank, I suppose not; but what 
 makes you say that ? " 
 
 " Why, Nursie, because of my braces ! " 
 
 Even to healthy-minded children, death, so long 
 as it leaves their own immediate circle untouched, 
 is not seldom an attractive mystery, though I know 
 of one child of five who wept bitterly when the 
 trees in the park near her home were blown down 
 by the wind, and from whom the death of birds 
 and other favourites had to be carefully hidden. 
 Perhaps the loneliness of her childhood increased 
 this sensibility. It was natural that so loving a 
 heart should long for brothers and sisters. She 
 was overheard on one occasion praying : " O 
 God, give me a little brother if it is necessary ! " 
 "necessity" being to her commensurate with 
 the Divine will. 
 
 There are beautiful touches in the religion of 
 children. A certain little dark-eyed boy was stay- 
 
 p 225 
 
OF 
 
 ing, a while ago, in the same house with a little 
 fair-haired girl called Beatrice, who was several 
 years older than he. She, in her superior wisdom, 
 was to him as a guardian angel, and he, with 
 watchful chivalry, made himself her most patient 
 and lowly servant. He was one of a Sunday class 
 where the children were asked one day what things 
 they should ask God for, the mistress expecting, 
 of course, that they would reply : "For bread, for 
 raiment, for a roof to cover us." A great light 
 came into this boy's black eyes and flashed over his 
 pale face. " For Beatrices," he said. 
 
 A well-known writer, who had a special sym- 
 pathy with children, quotes with approval an 
 essayist, of whom she says : " He considers that 
 children are defective in sensation, that all their 
 perceptions of outward things are far less vivid 
 than those of a grown person, and that they live 
 almost altogether in a world of phantasmagoria, 
 which is much more important to them than any- 
 thing outward, and which cuts them off from the 
 grown-up people's world." 
 
 There is one strong believer in this doctrine 
 who can still remember vaguely now that she is 
 a child no longer how, one day, when she had 
 begun to make pot-hooks and round O's, there 
 came over her a dumb, passionate desire to embody 
 in these hieroglyphic signs, which she had seen 
 her elders use on paper, though she was quite 
 unable to express it in spoken words, some record 
 of a lovely pastoral vision which was haunting 
 her. Whether it had come to her in a dream or 
 as a peculiarly vivid waking phantasy, or whether 
 226 
 
OF 
 
 it was the memory of some previous existence 
 before the " shades of the prison-house " had begun 
 to close about her, she cannot to this day feel 
 sure. But she can still see in imagination the long, 
 somewhat bare upper room, with its three little 
 white beds, where there came to her the desperate 
 impulse to dash down in lines and circles what she 
 was too shy to express in audible speech, and what, 
 indeed, altogether transcended such possibilities of 
 language as were within her reach. And this 
 shyness was mixed with a scarcely defined belief 
 that this peaceful other-world vision, which was so 
 far removed from her daily experience that it 
 would be treated as idle tales if uttered in her 
 blundering child-language, might possibly gain 
 credence if it could only get itself embodied in 
 written symbols ; and then how surprised the 
 elders would be who had not shared with her the 
 fair sights and sounds, and had no idea of the 
 secret treasure which was locked within her 
 memory ! 
 
 It is all vague and dim to her, like those recol- 
 lections gathered from yet earlier babyhood, of 
 how one day, when she was crying over a midday 
 siesta, which was at that time prescribed to all 
 children, a companion child, some years older than 
 herself, advised her, in a tone of gentle patronage, 
 to suck her thumb, an anodyne for all troubles, 
 which the young counsellor had found unfailing ; 
 or how, on a like melancholy occasion, a kind hand 
 dropped into a little wooden crib, where she lay 
 sobbing, a lovely cowslip ball, its golden blossoms, 
 in their pale green setting, all cool and sweet, and 
 
 227 
 
OF 
 
 smelling of the meadows ; or how, when she was 
 nearly three years old, a neighbour made an epoch 
 in her history by giving her, over the low iron 
 railing which divided the two grass plots, a bright 
 blue corncockle from her own garden. 
 
 This love of flowers was a strong bond of 
 sympathy between the child and her father. It 
 was he who took her in the early spring-time to 
 the one field down by the river where the wood- 
 anemones grew. It is not often that they are 
 found away from the woodlands, but Twilight's 
 father (that was the nickname he gave her once, 
 though it quickly dropped into disuse) knew one 
 such magical spot where they were as common as 
 cuckoo-flowers. And later more joyous adven- 
 ture still ! down by the brown canal, with its 
 endless locks and fairy waterfalls, were found the 
 first dog-roses. Before Twilight could pluck 
 them she must cross a narrow plank over the 
 foaming water ; but all was safe in her father's 
 presence ; and then there followed the delight of 
 gathering with her own hands, out of the hedge, 
 one of the sweet pale pink buds. 
 
 Twilight and her brothers and sisters were not 
 taught theology, but I have heard that when she 
 was asked one day who would take care of her doll 
 while she was away on a visit she replied quite 
 simply : " Oh, dear God, of course." 
 
 This doll seems to have been a very lively 
 personage ; for Twilight, who had once been 
 dosed with homoeopathic medicine, when she was 
 restless in her sleep, is said to have knocked at 
 her mother's bedroom door one morning, and 
 228 
 
OF 
 
 when asked what was the matter, said Dolly had 
 been kicking so all night that she must have 
 some " tamomilla." It was only as Dolly grew 
 older that her beautiful blue satin gown was cut 
 up to make a banner for the rifle corps in which 
 her mistress was a volunteer. 
 
 It is to be feared that in those days the said 
 mistress was a very boisterous and rather domi- 
 neering little person, and had to be constantly 
 admonished that she was " not a little boy." She 
 must have been an odd mingling of the mystic 
 and the torn-boy, for about the time when she was 
 given to dressing up as Masterman Ready, playing 
 at pirates, performing circus tricks, and other 
 various and indescribable naughtiness, she em- 
 ployed her quieter moments in drawing imaginary 
 portraits of the fairies who dwelt in the diverse 
 flowers, and on one occasion, when she was un- 
 happy, she comforted herself with the idea that 
 she was visited by an angel. Her parents would 
 scarcely have approved had they known of the 
 elaborate system of penances which she drew up 
 for herself. 
 
 She had been reading " Settlers at Home," and 
 she seldom went up and down stairs without a 
 terrible feeling that " Roger," the bad genius of 
 the book, was at her heels. Her self-ordained 
 punishments, therefore, were chiefly journeys up 
 and down the house : for one offence ten runs 
 upstairs, for two faults twenty, and so on. 
 
 The first memory of pain in her childhood is 
 of a very curious kind, and may remind us how 
 absurd it is to expect children to appreciate 
 
 229 
 
OF 
 
 the importance of the more serious events of 
 life. 
 
 A near relative, who had been very kind to the 
 child, had suddenly died. But the word " death " 
 was only a name to her, and gave no pain. In- 
 stead of realising that she would never see again 
 the face she loved, or hear the dear familiar voice, 
 that life would thenceforth be a poorer, blanker 
 thing to her, she felt an odd kind of excitement, 
 and almost elation, at having come in contact 
 with one of the "grown-up" experiences of this 
 troublesome world. But when she rushed into 
 the drawing-room with some trivial remark about 
 black clothes, she perceived, with a pang which 
 has left its memory to this day, that she appeared 
 to her elders to be guilty of a strange heartless- 
 ness. The news that her friend was dead the 
 bright lad who gave her her first book, and was 
 always ready to play with her that caused her 
 no real suffering ; it was not until long afterwards 
 that she understood the sorrow of death. But 
 the discovery that she had wounded and dis- 
 appointed those she loved by her want of feeling 
 that gave her unspeakable pain. 
 
 To most people the self of to-day is no very 
 ideal person. They realise painfully enough its 
 ignorance and folly. But the self of childhood 
 that is quite a different matter. 
 
 That dream- haunted, high-spirited little romp, 
 far away among the shadows and the blossoms of 
 the past, that is the soul to laugh and cry over 
 an altogether absurd, loving, grotesque little 
 figure. As we look back, half doubting our own 
 230 
 
OF 
 
 identity, we are like a rough workman I know of, 
 who, meeting a mother and child in the streets 
 one day, whispered audibly : " I wish I was as 
 innocent as yon child looks ! " We wish we 
 were as free from the hard and selfish spirit of the 
 world as those earnest little souls seem to us to 
 have been. 
 
 231 
 
IN EARLY AUTUMN 
 
 AT summer dawn, that makes the world anew 
 
 In primal loveliness of Eden's birth, 
 And bathes the blossoms with the heavenly dew 
 That gives a daily childhood to the earth, 
 When beauty pierces like a beckoning cry, 
 Oh, let the children share the earth and sky ! 
 
 Oh, send them here before it is too late, 
 
 While still the swallows dip their wings in light 
 And every day the sunset's golden gate 
 
 Throws wide the splendours of the summer 
 
 night ! 
 
 Ok, send the children here : the days go by ; 
 Oh 9 send the frailest quickly y ere they die ! 
 
 Snapdragons now are laughing in the hedge, 
 And thrush to fellow-thrush is jargoning ; 
 The little river running through the sedge 
 Sings on, while reeds bend over, answering : 
 Earth garners loveliness ; the days go by : 
 Leave death for age ; the young buds must not 
 die. 
 
 The harebell leans upon the passing breeze, 
 And honeysuckles weave their fairy bowers ; 
 
 Oh, think what joy, among the leafy trees, 
 For London waifs to pluck the lavish flowers ! 
 
 Oh, send the children here : the days go by ; 
 Oh, sena the frailest quickly, ere they die ! 
 232 
 
The pine-tree, bathed in sunshine, softly sways 
 
 A fragrant censer that will scatter health 
 To strengthen wanderers in the woodland ways, 
 And give them store of Nature's living wealth : 
 Oh, send the children here : the moments fly ; 
 And, while you pause to think, some child may 
 die. 
 
 The corn has fallen now in sheaves of gold ; 
 
 The noonday spaces melt in sapphire deeps : 
 The distant hills are dreaming, fold on fold, 
 In dim blue distance where a young moon sleeps. 
 Oh, send, the children here : the days go by ; 
 Oh, send the frailest quickly, ere they die ! 
 
 At eve yon moon, a drifting snowflake yet, 
 Will rise a silver sickle o'er the Rose 
 That scatters petals when the sun hath set ; 
 And then a million flowers in sleep will close. 
 Oh, send the frail flowers here who tossing lie 
 In crowded cities ! Save them, ere they die ! 
 
 233 
 
THE OPEN WINDOW 
 
 LET us by all means build sanatoria for the con- 
 sumptive patients whose health we have ruined, 
 and found schools of hygiene for teachers whose 
 constitutions we have undermined ! So long as 
 there is still hope of cure or of reform, we shall at 
 least have improved a little on the time-honoured 
 practice of giving handsome burial to the prophets 
 conveniently done to death. But, setting aside the 
 patent fact that consumption and degeneration are 
 likely to claim their victims, so long as thousands 
 of overworked people are denied a living wage, 
 there is, even in the present distress, one initial life- 
 saving reform which costs nothing except common 
 sense and courage, and need not be delayed for the 
 reconstruction of society. The atmosphere of 
 many of our offices, shops, and churches, is often 
 so fetid that any one with a keen sense of smell, 
 entering from the pure air outside, experiences a 
 sense of foulness indescribable ; and still more is 
 this true of overcrowded, unventilated trains and 
 omnibuses. Such a person, if he has an even 
 elementary knowledge of the conditions favour- 
 able to disease, feels no longer any wonder at the 
 authorised computation in 1906 that, in London 
 alone, no fewer than 80,000 people are stricken with 
 one form or another of tuberculosis, and u 16,000 
 persons die every year whose valuable lives might be 
 saved with proper treatment, to say nothing of the 
 thousands who are slowly moving to their doom." 
 234 
 
The grim humour of it all is beyond words. 
 The one means of life which can be neither taxed 
 nor paid for, the one pure element which makes 
 for beauty and vigour and longevity, is treated on 
 all hands as a dangerous enemy to be shut out at 
 all costs throughout the whole of our long winter. 
 Everybody poses on occasion as a devotee of fresh 
 air, but the man, or the woman either, who dares 
 boldly to open a window wide in any public place 
 of resort, is eyed askance and treated with a 
 smothered resentment, a polite hostility, which 
 opens fire with significantly conscious sneezes and 
 coughs, the pulling up of coat-collars and drawing 
 on of mantles, and usually ends by a determined 
 raid upon the offending window which, with an air 
 of virtuous and collective indignation, is too often 
 hastily and decisively closed again. Yet, even 
 apart from the extreme danger to health involved 
 in this worship of stuffiness, had the worshippers 
 only enough knowledge and imagination to picture 
 for an instant the nature of the filth they are 
 swallowing, their disgust would be so overwnelm- 
 ing that they would probably not only open every 
 window, but in many cases make an instinctive 
 rush for the door. 
 
 There is tragedy in the accusation so lightly 
 thrown at " the great Unwashed '' ; for those who 
 make it forget to ask themselves how many of the 
 very poor, in their day-long scramble for bare 
 bread and roof and raiment for their children, 
 have, under existing social conditions, either suffi- 
 cient bath-rooms or sufficient leisure for civilised 
 grooming. But many of their so-called " supe- 
 
 235 
 
OF 
 
 riors," who plume themselves on their continual 
 tubbing and general devotion to external soap and 
 water, are content to swallow unboiled, not only 
 water from a sewage-polluted river, but air from 
 other people's polluted lungs. Whether or no 
 John Bull continues, with an air of bravado, to 
 drink, without any sufficient precaution, the milk 
 and the water which are seldom technically clean, 
 it is certain that his first step towards the prevention 
 of tuberculosis ought to be a reform of his dirty 
 habits in relation to unclean and noxious air. Such 
 air is almost always germ-laden, but what is em- 
 phasised here is not so much its danger to life as 
 its loathsome impurity. Yet at the same time it 
 cannot be wholly forgotten that, for reasons not far 
 to seek, our national scourge of tuberculosis feeds 
 upon the filth of bad air. 
 
 236 
 
YOUNG ART AND MY LITTLE 
 RED RIDING-HOOD 
 
 I HAVE seen " Young Art " again to-day, after 
 a long interval, and there was a look in his grave 
 little face that seemed as appropriate as a Christmas 
 carol to the inner meaning of our great festival. 
 There is usually a kind of holy joy about Young 
 Art, even when, as to-day, he has evidently the 
 cares or sorrows of his family much on his mind. 
 I am not sure of his exact age, but it is somewhere 
 between seven and eight, I take it, and even in his 
 " old-fashionedness " he is essentially a child, one 
 of the little ones to whom the " Christ-masse '' is 
 especially dedicated. His father " Art," without 
 the prefix is beyond the region of my acquaint- 
 ance, and his mother, who was like the Old 
 Woman who lived in a Shoe, is also outside my 
 circle. With daily work to do it is impossible to 
 know every one, even among the very poor, who 
 have certainly a deeper claim upon time and 
 attention than many of their fortunate neighbours, 
 and perhaps also more vital lessons to teach to 
 those of us who trade mainly in words. Young 
 Art that is the name by which I hear his family 
 designate him, though I divine that his true 
 patronymic is that of the great Pendragon of the 
 Round Table Young Art has been bred from 
 babyhood in that saddest, deepest poverty of all 
 which is the result of some one else's wasteful self- 
 indulgence. Already it is plain that he tries to 
 
 237 
 
OF 
 
 guard and cherish his heroic young foster-mother, 
 a woman with a face that in its first youthful 
 contour must have resembled the pure outline of 
 Dinah Morris's gentle countenance. She is his 
 father's sister, and her married life has been one 
 long martyrdom in the cause of ideal womanhood, 
 the continual kindler of the faggots about her 
 burning feet being tied to her by the law of 
 wedlock, and tied equally fast to his own favourite 
 and money-squandering vice. She has no children 
 of her own ; Young Art, who was begged from 
 " the Old Woman who lived in a Shoe " one or 
 a family of fourteen, I think he told me is the 
 idol of her affections. At her poor, well-brushed 
 hearth, there has always been a welcome also for 
 his brave, handsome young cousin, who has been 
 starving of late in silence with her baby and her 
 " unemployed " husband at a fireless hearth of her 
 own, as I discovered by accident, this bitter cold 
 day ; to say naught of the feckless ne'er-do-well 
 nephew, to whom every other door except that 
 of the prison has long since been closed. To these 
 last she is pathetically, unwearyingly kind ; but 
 Young Art is the one joy of her meagre and other- 
 wise joyless treadmill. For him she slaves early 
 and late, spending long hours at the wash-tub and 
 the ironing-board, to earn the wherewithal, and 
 keeping the child himself exquisitely neat and, like 
 herself, looking always " clean as a snowdrop.'' 
 He is never fantastically or gaudily dressed, yet 
 his quaint, smiling gravity and elderly daintiness of 
 perfectly mended apparel, give him somehow the 
 air of a child out of a picture-book, even apart 
 
 238 
 
from the singular home-made barrow on which, 
 out of school hours, he is so often wheeling home 
 a modest burden of carefully got-up lingerie. His 
 manners are distinguished, and quite unlike those 
 of the small rabble with whom he mixes at the 
 Board school, whither, with the other child 
 inhabitants of this hamlet, he daily wends his way. 
 His foster-mother's love is so great that it is itself 
 an education and gives him a kind of royalty, so 
 that he has all the fearless, quiet savoir-faire of a 
 gentleman, and, without analysing it to himself, 
 feels somehow that his attentions are welcome. 
 When all the children in our lane, some sixty of 
 them, came for tea in our little backyard, and 
 adjourned with me to the pine-woods afterwards, it 
 was Young Art who quietly managed to reach 
 high enough to slip his little arm through mine 
 and tow me along protectively. 
 
 My other guard-of-honour on that occasion was 
 my Little Red Riding-Hood. I think of her as 
 that, because, though she does not wear scarlet, 
 her exquisite beauty would be so perfectly set off 
 by a red cloak and hood, and even more than 
 Young Art she suggests a child out of a Christmas 
 volume. The liquid dark eyes look forth from a 
 little white face, like a delicately cut cameo, where 
 the only touch of colour is in the pretty red lips 
 that are always bravely smiling. The black hair 
 that frames this charming vision is itself a charm, 
 and the child seems to be one of those whose 
 pinafores are always clean. It is her wonderful 
 smile that wins the heart ; it seems to bubble up 
 perpetually from some hidden fountain of love and 
 
 239 
 
OF 
 
 light. Even on that saddest morning, when Red 
 Riding-Hood's own hunger was forgotten in that 
 of her starving little gray dog, her smile had not 
 quite vanished. By a happy chance I espied them 
 together, that bitter day, the child and the dog, 
 lingering a moment in wistful silence outside my 
 garden railing. It was then that our real friend- 
 ship began. Dogs and I are almost always on 
 more or less comradely terms, and when I clapped 
 eyes on the poor little four-legged gray skeleton 
 that piercing winter morning last year, it was for 
 the dog's sake even more than the child's that I 
 rushed away for a bone. Oh, the joy of that bone 
 to all three of us ! The poor half-perishing dog 
 never forgot it, nor did the child, nor did I. 
 When the hard time was over, and the poor little 
 bag of skin and bone began to look a real dog 
 once more, he came back again and again alone, 
 without his mistress, to thank me. You say it 
 was for more bones ? I shall not be believed, but 
 when I fetched food he withdrew in a dignified 
 manner as much as to say, " You quite mistake 
 me!" 
 
 Red Riding-Hood told me soon afterwards, in 
 reply to persistent questioning, that she had had to 
 part with him a great sorrow, poor little maid ! 
 She has many brothers and sisters, and even dogs 
 have mouths when the weekly wage is hardly a 
 " living " one for a family. And the next I heard 
 of him was his death. Only with tears in her eyes 
 could Red Riding-Hood tell me of the horrid 
 disease that compelled his new owners to shoot 
 him, and this tragic explanation of his disease I 
 240 
 
had supposed at first that he died a natural death 
 she did not give me until we attained to the 
 intimacy of afternoon tea in my own little study, 
 after she had brought me dahlias, velvet dark and 
 golden bright, in a carefully arranged posy of 
 alternating tints from her own cottage garden. 
 
 I had met her a few days earlier carrying a basket 
 of cabbages that looked half as big as herself. 
 When I took it out of her hand and accompanied 
 her to her gate she merely seemed amused, smiling 
 more rapturously than ever. At our parting I 
 rather fished for a " Thank you " ; but she re- 
 served that till the afternoon, when she brought 
 the flowers to accompany her sweet dimples and 
 shining eyes as an expression of what she felt. 
 
 The labouring people in our lane occasionally 
 make me feel, as this child did, that in matters of 
 neighbourly friendship my methods are coarse in 
 comparison with their delicacy of feeling. 
 
 241 
 
CHILDREN OF THE LONDON AND 
 SOUTH-WESTERN RAILWAY 
 
 " HE just said good-night to me, and he gave me 
 a kiss, and said he was coming back to do the 
 garden. But when he got to work an express 
 train came along the line and knocked him over, 
 and I never saw him again alive." A grave, fair- 
 haired little girl it was who, sitting beside me in 
 the matron's bright, cosy sitting-room at the orphan- 
 age our orphanage par excellence at Woking thus 
 summed up the epoch in her own history which 
 had opened to her the doors of orphanage hospi- 
 tality. It was told quite simply, and without any 
 emotional pose, though by no means without a 
 sense of its heartrending pathos, a certain quiet 
 dignity, as of those who have passed through deep 
 sorrow without being embittered. The little 
 garden had sweet-peas in it, I learned- one of the 
 small gardens on the edge of the line near the 
 child's home at Andover and there leaped to 
 the eyes visions of the home-life, the mother and 
 children watching eagerly for the return of one 
 whose poor broken body was to be carried back 
 by his mates, but never again to come striding up 
 the staircase of the little house to kiss his small 
 daughter good-night. The child was one of six 
 little girls, of whom two were at the orphanage. 
 I had been interested in hearing about one of the 
 boys in another family, whose father had been run 
 down by an express, when hastening to help a young 
 242 
 
porter in difficulties with a truck of luggage which 
 had overbalanced ; therefore the matron had sent 
 for this child and her sister, and also for another girl, 
 one of ten children, whose breadwinner had been 
 killed in like manner while cleaning down a truck. 
 We think much of the great catastrophes that 
 swallow up passengers, but too little perhaps of 
 the yearly toll of lives among brave and faithful 
 public servants of the rank and file, who meet 
 their summons as a matter of course in the 
 ordinary round of their daily tasks. 
 
 Some of the children here lost their fathers in 
 the wrecks of the St. Hilda and the Stella, both in 
 the company's service; others in ways less striking 
 to the imagination, but not less sad for those who 
 are left behind. 
 
 The men themselves understand well enough 
 the uncertainties and perils of their chosen work, 
 and it is by them that the orphanage is mainly 
 supported and managed, 
 
 It is interesting to see that the Archbishop of 
 Canterbury and Lord Meath are among the vice- 
 presidents, and that Lord Aberdeen heads the lists 
 of life-governors, for these are all names which 
 carry with them a guarantee of efficiency and good 
 faith, as apart from mere title ; but it is more 
 interesting still to glance through the names on 
 local committees throughout that part of the 
 country which is served by the London and South- 
 Western, and to note that they consist largely of 
 very lowly workers engaged in the actual drudgery 
 of the railway. In making this honourable pro- 
 vision for their children, it was perhaps hardly 
 
 243 
 
s OF 
 
 surprising that they had to concentrate upon 
 obvious necessities rather than on the thought of 
 their playtime. The excellent bath-rooms, first- 
 rate sanitation, and abundant space and air in the 
 sleeping-rooms, might well put to shame many a 
 public school. The wise arrangements for edu- 
 cation and the apparent capacity and humanity of 
 the staff may account for the individuality and 
 vigour of the children, and the happy absence of 
 that deadened institutionalised air which is often 
 so depressing where children are herded together 
 in a large " home." Nevertheless, until recently, 
 there had been one serious gap in the beneficent 
 plan of life the children did not know how to 
 play. In their spare time they sat within four 
 walls in their spacious rooms, without books or 
 toys or occupations, until one day Mr. Cecil Smith 
 opened the door upon them, and stood aghast. at 
 the deadly dulness of the scene before him. 
 
 His visit inaugurated a new era, for he never 
 rested until he had not only collected a varied and 
 delightful "children's library" and provided out- 
 door and indoor games, but had also organised the 
 Children's Fund, of which the working expenses 
 are privately met, with the happy result that every 
 penny subscribed goes to benefit these orphan boys 
 and girls. 
 
 I found it a very pretty sight to watch the 
 children drilling, and I hear that Mr. Cecil Smith, 
 " the Children's Friend," as their annual report 
 names him, is already dreaming of a gymnasium, 
 where such training will be extended and amplified 
 directly the fund allows of it. I need hardly say 
 244 
 
-WSSrSRat <I(AILW<Ar CHILD^SN 
 
 how glad he will be to give full particulars of all 
 the work of the fund to any one who writes to him 
 at the orphanage, where he is continually in and 
 out. This fund maintains and equips the orphanage 
 boy scouts' and lads' brigade, arranges small enter- 
 tainments and lantern lectures given monthly 
 throughout the winter, keeps library and games up 
 to the mark, making good the necessary wear and 
 tear, and providing the children with stationery, 
 magazines, and prize awards. We read that it is 
 proving of the utmost value, and is sensibly and 
 carefully administered. It has, moreover, given 
 to rooms that were somewhat bare and formal a 
 touch of home and of the varied interests in which 
 happy school-fellows and comrades may take part. 
 Perhaps as we whiz by on the railway lines, looking 
 out on the orphanage and remembering that it is a 
 solid monument of co-operative thrift on the part 
 of the railway-men to whom we constantly entrust 
 our lives, we may well ask ourselves whether we 
 owe no debt either to the children of our hard- 
 worked brothers or to Him who said : " Inasmuch 
 as ye have done it unto one of the least of these, 
 my brethren, ye have done it unto me." 
 
 245 
 
FROM A COTTAGE WINDOW 
 
 STRAY oak-leaves, brown, and light as a feather, 
 still now and then whirl one by one past my 
 window, but for the most part the trees have 
 already lost all their foliage and attained to the 
 beauty of " glorious nakedness." The ivied bank, 
 that overleans the other side of the lane opposite 
 my little sitting-room, still casts a shadow, but 
 the two ancient trees that stand guard beside it 
 are now already bare, except for their ivied stems, 
 and the unclothed boughs begin to leave the over- 
 shadowed rooms more air and light. The swing- 
 ing sign of the little inn is already visible in the 
 distance, and, beyond it, the silvery birches and 
 black pines, and a space of south-western sky, 
 whence the golden sunsets are mirrored from the 
 west on " soft " evenings and the stars look down 
 in blessing. 
 
 The dahlias are all gone, and the chrysanthemums 
 which have done finely this year will soon be 
 following them. 
 
 By strange chance, just as that sentence was set 
 down on paper there came a rhythmic rat-tat on 
 the cottage door, and a messenger from Hoe Place 
 brought accompanied by a basket of apples, 
 themselves a picture as though to tell me that 
 chrysanthemums must not be banished before their 
 time, a great bunch of the beautiful creatures, 
 more perfect, in their air of stately quietude and 
 lavish yet delicate tints, than any that have entered 
 246 
 
FROM <A corr^fge 
 
 my room this season; whole sprays of snowy- 
 white, and pink things of paler hue on the under- 
 side of the lovely curling petals all with that 
 graceful drooping curve so different from the 
 rigidity of their old-fashioned forerunners and 
 others of pale yellow, a clever effect in the colour- 
 scheme, leading up to what is the crowning note 
 of the harmony, an upright blossom, in the vivid 
 gold of its plume-like aspect much like a colt's- 
 foot, side by side with a cluster of prim daisy- 
 shaped beauties with wide yellow bosses rayed 
 round with petals of sea-shell pink, a sort of 
 glorified Michaelmas daisies. There they all are, 
 looking at me now from the great blue and white 
 pot that was the gift of a friend just come back 
 from the edge of the " Undiscovered Country." 
 And if they were not grown out of doors, they 
 are still unmistakable chrysanthemums. Against 
 my whitewashed walls and the black-brown of my 
 stained deal bookshelves they are superb. There 
 seems to have been a convergence of gift-bringing 
 influences upon this spot of earth to-day, for only 
 half an hour before, the village policeman, our 
 chief gardening enthusiast of the neighbourhood, 
 whose fairy triangle at the road-corner is bare at 
 last of all its fiery blooms and has been patiently 
 dug over for the winter, came modestly to the 
 back door on the other side of the cottage with 
 a great handful of precious bulbs, and we had a 
 little talk about the slips of sweet-briar that had 
 withered in the summer sun through being set too 
 early : November, this learned man tells me, is 
 the right month. 
 
 247 
 
OF 
 
 The gardens just now have a very appealing 
 aspect ; poor Psyche has come to the long trial of 
 sorting the seeds, and soon will be falling asleep. 
 But the skies of evening look down with miraculous 
 beauty. Never are sunsets more mystically glorious 
 than when the golden light looks through the bare 
 tree-branches, as through the bars of some heavenly 
 window, only to be flashed back again by the 
 depths of a brimming stream brown and tranquil 
 after the autumn rains. Down at Hoe Place, two 
 days ago, just such a sunset as that looked in 
 through the wide drawing-room windows as I 
 ceased reading that fine passage from Lord Lytton's 
 " Letters " in which he sums up the meaning of 
 tragedy as " the highest expression in art of that 
 which in life itself . . . compels us to understand, 
 not as an abstract proposition, but as a truth 
 delivered through our strongest emotions, that 
 Divine justice is not concerned about bringing 
 things to a comfortable conclusion at the end of 
 this poor little five-act play of ours that its theatre 
 is Infinity, and its last word here ' Beyond.' " 
 
 It is a good message to have by heart before 
 those benumbing days come of which Mr. Robert 
 Bridges writes : 
 
 " The long dark night, that lengthens slow, 
 Deepening with Winter to starve grass and tree, 
 And soon to bury in snow 
 
 The Earth, that, sleeping 'neath her frozen stole, 
 Shall dream a dream crept from the sunless pole 
 Of how her end shall be." 
 
 But in the darkening days the birds just now 
 248 
 
FROM c/f corr^ge 
 
 are full of charm to eye and ear. We are only 
 twenty-four miles from London. In the morning 
 yesterday I watched the quiet little grey-bosomed 
 bird that was tame enough to sit on the leafless 
 topmost twig of my little plum-tree, looking in 
 through my upper window, about half a yard from 
 my observing eyes, as I listened to the fluting, 
 Mozart-like melodies of a hidden robin ; and in 
 the afternoon, as I crossed Waterloo Bridge, I 
 gazed on the restless sea-gulls, making poetry with 
 their great white wings, hovering and sweeping 
 above the dark river. On the return journey the 
 birds had gone, but a new token of hope had taken 
 their place, for the lights above the Southern Wharf 
 were golden in the autumn mist and made a glowing, 
 burning radiance in the Thames below. And there 
 came back to me the words of a brave symbolist 
 whom I knew in my youth, an arch-heretic whose 
 fame is now blazoned by the orthodox forces that 
 cursed him before they built his tomb, and I 
 murmured to myself those lines of Thomas Toke 
 Lynch that are welcome with the coming of winter : 
 
 " While the root, locked in slumber fast, 
 Rests through the weary winter-tide, 
 The world speeds on, that God at last 
 
 His summer's heartsease may provide, 
 And all love's tender prophecies 
 In tenderer blooms may realise." 
 
 249 
 
HIS SOLILOQUY 
 
 (A "Dramatic Lyric) 
 
 HUSH ! it is night, 
 And the stars 
 
 Look down thro' the prison-bars 
 That hold us a world apart 
 You in the infinite light, I in my darkened heart. 
 Is there a gulf we may cross 
 
 To win a moment again, 
 You to your terrible loss, I to my exquisite pain ? 
 
 Is there a gulf we may cross, 
 Or has our love been in vain ? 
 I live for you, die for you, daily, you who are 
 
 pure and good ! 
 But not with a touch will I stain 
 
 Your flower-white womanhood, 
 I who have soiled my life, soiled and spoiled my 
 
 life, 
 
 While you, in the sun and rain 
 The joy, the sorrow, the strife 
 Unfolded your lily-bloom 
 
 With its midmost golden dart. 
 Ah, no ! We are worlds apart. 
 Yet even here in the night, 
 
 In a life that's a prison-room ; 
 You, the child of the light, 
 
 You dwell in my darkened heart, 
 Heaven in the hell of my doom. 
 
 250 
 
CHRISTINA GEORGINA ROSSETTI 
 
 IN a candid and deeply interesting memoir Mr. 
 William Michael Rossetti has brought home 
 to us with added tenderness and reality the 
 vision of " a soul as pure, duteous, concentrated, 
 loving, and devoted as ever uttered itself in prose 
 or verse." These words, from the closing sentence 
 in which Mr. Rossetti sums up his tribute to that 
 sister of whom he had such intimate and lifelong 
 knowledge, come as a relief to the pent-up admira- 
 tion of his readers at the end of this memoir, a 
 finished and impressive monograph, beautiful with 
 such homely and untold reverence as forbids any 
 language not simple, any overstrained or self- 
 conscious adornment. 
 
 These pages enhance our knowledge of Christina 
 Rossetti's devotion to her kindred most of all to 
 her mother and in all the details of her daily life, 
 as well as in the moving story of her earthly love, 
 here for the first time fully told a love not with- 
 out its heavenly joys and qualities even in re- 
 nouncement they are a continual attestation, an 
 attestation not needed and yet delightful, to the 
 profound sincerity of her devotional poems. 
 Built in the Living Rock and smitten to the inner- 
 most depths, her life was " hid with Christ in 
 God," and that which she gave so freely to the 
 world was itself a Divine gift, an overflowing 
 energy of faith and love, sometimes thrilled through 
 and through with the very bitterness of grief, yet 
 
 251 
 
OF 
 
 quick with praise through all suffering, and spring- 
 ing ever from that Source of joy which she knew 
 to be at the heart of pain. It is sometimes 
 childlike in its rippling happiness of kinship with 
 birds and beasts and children, but at other times, 
 and much more frequently, it is dazzling in its 
 leaping purity and rainbow-tinted sacrificial passion 
 as it triumphs over all obstacles on its way to the 
 great deep, and not seldom it is when touched with 
 sorrow that it is most full of mystic healing and 
 cleansing power. Do we not all come thirsting to 
 dip our tiny cups in it and bless this well-spring of 
 living water springing up unto eternal life ? 
 
 Christina Rossetti's deep and fastidious veracity 
 added the final note of distinction to her most 
 enduring verse, verse of which the word " dis- 
 tinction " may be used in a special and primary 
 sense, for she is so " distinct in individualities" 
 that to class her with others, even the greatest, 
 would be to lose sight of one of her most striking 
 attributes ; and especially, perhaps, of her religious 
 poems is this true. Here and there we may be 
 reminded of her in Richard Crashaw's " Shepherds' 
 Hymn " and his " Saint Teresa " poems, or in 
 Christopher Smart's splendid " Song to David," 
 and to name her with Henry Vaughan, George 
 Herbert, and William Blake, is to do honour to 
 them as truly as to her ; but no one who is in- 
 timate with her singing is likely to mistake it for 
 theirs, or for any but her own. To take rank 
 with such poets as these on the one hand, and 
 with the greatest singers of the nineteenth century 
 on the other, is to hold a high and immortal place ; 
 252 
 
yet the absolute spontaneity of Christina Rossetti's 
 symbolism, the sense of sweet surprise and in- 
 evitableness in her cadences, as of a nightingale's 
 improvisation, with nevertheless that just economy 
 of language and metaphor characteristic of what is 
 final and unfathomable in feeling, must make her 
 appeal a wider and more varied one than that of 
 the Silurist or the author of " The Temple " ; 
 while for melody and passion, so married as to be 
 absolutely one, in such poems as " The Convent 
 Threshold," "A Royal Princess," and "The 
 Prince's Progress," it would not be easy to find a 
 lyrist beside whom one need fear to name her, 
 whether among living writers or the mighty dead 
 who preceded them. 
 
 In criticising this volume of her " poetical works " 
 from childhood upwards, no one can fail to ad- 
 mit that its contents are extraordinarily unequal, 
 both in outward music and in inward quality ; but 
 to say that she numbers among her enthusias- 
 tic admirers that great master of melody, who 
 wrote that "consummate mastery of [the poet's] 
 instrument " is " the one indispensable test of 
 poetic triumph," is to give a high authority indeed 
 for the perfection of her workmanship at its best. 
 Yet for her work the word " workmanship " seems 
 misleading; when that work is most perfect it 
 bears rather the impress of a transcendent and 
 irresistible creation than of any clumsier process. 
 Take, for instance, the two brief lyrics by which 
 she is perhaps most widely known " When I am 
 dead, my dearest," and " Does the road wind up- 
 hill all the way ? " who shall analyse their haunt- 
 
 253 
 
OF 
 
 ing and satisfying beauty, except to say that their 
 soul and body are absolutely one, and their bareness 
 of redundant loveliness, in word or image, the 
 crowning loveliness of all ? In contradistinction 
 from these in its flowing wealth of measure and 
 imagery, though less inscrutable in charm, is the 
 " Amor Mundi." It is interwoven throughout 
 with echoing rhymes and cunning assonances and 
 timely roughnesses of deterrent sound ; all breath- 
 ing the symbolism of a deeper music than that of 
 any audible human voices. It is almost trite to 
 say that Christina Rossetti had her limitations, but 
 it may be added that, by a kind of proud humility 
 if the paradox be permitted she seems to have 
 recognised them, and never attempted to pass 
 beyond them into regions not her own. Be that as 
 it may, her brother at once arrests our attention and 
 probably wins our acquiescence, when in writing 
 elsewhere of Augusta Webster's finest play, which 
 was greatly admired by Christina Rossetti, he says 
 of the latter : " The very suggestion of her writing 
 any tragedy, much more any such tragedy as ' The 
 Sentence/ would be preposterous." 
 
 " Goblin Market " is a marvel of subtle music 
 and of outpoured sunshine and colour, its " fine 
 fairy-lore " all brimming with such stuff as goes 
 to the making of mortal suffering and heroic 
 tenderness ; but it may well indicate something of 
 the width of the poet's range to compare its un- 
 fettered methods, as of some heavenly intuition, 
 with the very diverse rhythms of her other and 
 even greater poems more restricted in form, such 
 as " The Convent Threshold " already named, of 
 254 
 
which Mrs. Meynell has said the supreme and 
 incomparable word of uttermost praise. 
 
 No woman who is familiar with Christina 
 Rossetti's poems can read her life, without a con- 
 viction that the agony of renunciation, to so 
 intense and passionate a nature, deepened the 
 inspiration of what was highest and most searching 
 in her power. 
 
 Among her Christmas verses it is impossible 
 not to love the childlike gladness and exquisite 
 simplicity of such carols as the one beginning 
 " The Shepherds had an Angel," and the still more 
 beautiful one which includes the lines : 
 
 " What can I give Him, 
 
 Poor as I am ? 
 If I were a shepherd 
 I would bring a lamb." 
 
 Yet it is probably not to these carols that a sorrow- 
 ful world will turn most often, but rather to the 
 delicate reserve and divine hope of such lyrics as 
 tc My love whose heart is tender," the pleading of 
 the Man of Sorrows in " Despised and Rejected,'' 
 the glorious inspiration of "Advent," the humility 
 and trust of " Sursum Corda," and of that wonder- 
 ful double " Sonnet of Sonnets," " Later Life," or 
 to such poems as the one which holds the lines : 
 
 " Not in this world of hope deferred, 
 This world of perishable stuff." 
 
 If space were less limited, it would be interesting 
 to compare the widely varying genius of women 
 already gone from our midst who have written 
 
 255 
 
OF 
 
 enduring poetry in the bygone century all lifting 
 their gift high above stain, all strong in their fervour 
 of womanliness, brave with the plain-spoken courage 
 of a holy and untarnished goodness ; all, in their 
 life as well as in their song, " true to the kindred 
 points of Heaven and Home." In their art they 
 differed widely, but the greatest of them have at 
 least one memorable gift in common, inasmuch as 
 they have left us sonnets not easily to be surpassed. 
 With one such sonnet by Christina Rossetti, cha- 
 racteristic in its white fire of love and faith, this 
 short causerie must end. It is one of the " Monna 
 Innominata " series : 
 
 " If I could trust mine own self with your fate, 
 Shall not I rather trust it in God's hand, 
 Without Whose Will one lily doth not stand, 
 
 Nor sparrow fall at his appointed date ; 
 Who numbereth the innumerable sand, 
 
 Who weighs the wind and water with a weight, 
 
 To Whom the world is neither small nor great, 
 Whose knowledge foreknew every plan we 
 planned. 
 
 Searching my heart for all that touches you, 
 I find there only love and love's goodwill 
 
 Helpless to help and impotent to do, 
 
 Of understanding dull, of sight most dim ; 
 And therefore I commend you back to Him 
 Whose love your love's capacity can fill." 
 
 256 
 
THE IDEAL WOMAN AS 
 WORDSWORTH AND 
 SHELLEY SAW HER 
 
 IT is not surprising that poets of such opposite 
 temperament and divergent ethics as W<~vdsworth 
 and Shelley should both alike have drawn for us a 
 vision of womanhood in which each poet is com- 
 pletely in accord with the other. There are truths 
 so fundamental and convincing in their primary 
 importance that, although they may be coloured 
 by the mind that reflects them, as though one 
 showed the rose-coloured and the other the violet 
 or the gold, they appeal to all alike in proportion 
 to the vividness with which they are presented. 
 And in moments of transient agitation or political 
 stress, it is salutary to turn to such primary realities, 
 on a day of party conflict to think the more of 
 Imperial responsibilities, and duties in which wider 
 issues are involved, and in the clamour between 
 suffragists and anti-suffragists to look for an instant 
 at those high aims and ideals which both alike 
 recognise and acclaim to forget for an hour what 
 women should do and have, in the thought of what 
 women should be. That one prosaic couplet in 
 Wordsworth's beautiful poem to his wife in which 
 he tells us, 
 
 " And now I see, with eye serene, 
 The very pulse of the machine," 
 
 is finely suggestive of that inner power and 
 
 R 257 
 
OF 
 
 guidance which befit a being described in the two 
 lines which follow as " a traveller between life and 
 death," and is at one with Shelley's more quietistic 
 image of a " well of sealed and secret happiness." 
 In neither is the source of beauty and of joy to 
 remain unshared, though its inmost sanctity lie deep 
 and unrevealed. That " pulse " of radiant being 
 which controls and inspires 
 
 " The reason firm, the temperate will, 
 Endurance, foresight, strength and skill," 
 
 is in Wordsworth's poem the very pivot on which 
 turn all holy and tender activities, all patient and 
 lowly domestic joys is, indeed, the very mainspring 
 of life in 
 
 " A perfect woman, nobly planned, 
 To warn, to comfort and command." 
 
 That " well of sealed and secret happiness " of 
 which Shelley sings in "Episychidion" is no treasure 
 of self-centred brooding ; for he tells us in the very 
 next line that it "vanquishes dissonance and gloom," 
 and, lest even that should not be clear enough, he 
 adds that his ideal is not a Star which moves alone 
 in the moving heavens, but is as a smile among 
 frowns, a gentle tone amid rude voices ; and then 
 he crowns the whole passage with that consummate 
 line, still descriptive of all that a restless world 
 should find in the sanctuary of a woman's soul : 
 
 " A Solitude, a Refuge, a Delight." 
 
 That " well " is to be filled with the sunbeams of 
 the eternal 
 
 258 
 
rne 
 
 " The sunbeams of those wells which ever leap 
 Under the lightnings of the soul too deep 
 For the brief fathom-line of thought or sense." 
 
 Sidney Dobell said that goodness in a woman was 
 not enough it must be beautiful goodness. This 
 is not the place to discuss that* wonderful inter- 
 mingling in our day of the religious traditions of 
 the East and of the West which reveal beneath the 
 ancient symbols of both the same everlasting 
 mysteries, but there is one part of the teaching 
 which he who runs may read teaching which is 
 confirmed by the discoveries of the scientist, as 
 well as by the experience of the obedient spirit in 
 man. It is the simple fact that the vital force 
 which shapes the universe and moulds the lives of 
 men has entrusted to Woman the first pre-natal 
 guardianship of the highest form of perceptible life 
 upon this planet. And it may be that, as compen- 
 sation to the many women to whom this highest 
 grace is not accorded, the privilege of sacrificial 
 service may make of them also, in Shelley's words, 
 
 "A lute, which those whom love has taught to 
 
 play 
 Make music on, to soothe the roughest day." 
 
 The world has advanced beyond that barbarous day 
 in which those who preferred the hardships of lone- 
 liness to the second best of a marriage imperfectly 
 mated, were ridiculed as the wastrels of womanly 
 ambition, and the great army of women-workers 
 grows yearly happier in the honest comradeship of 
 earnest-minded men. In this world of joy and 
 
 259 
 
OF 
 
 sorrow and continual combat, voluntary and 
 efficient work stands second only to love, as a 
 means of strength and solace, if only it be not 
 work so mechanical or brutalising, or beyond the 
 powers of the worker, as to involve on the one 
 hand the deadening of faculty or on the other the 
 overstrain of nervous power. 
 
 Men desire to save women from both these 
 extremes, but under present conditions it is often 
 beyond a possibility. 
 
 They desire also with a passion, not the less deep 
 because it is often inarticulate, to find in women a 
 breath of the spiritual repose and intellectual 
 quietude, which can only be attained by those who 
 determinately secure, in the midst of a bustling 
 and overcrowded age, a practice of inward medita- 
 tion with its enshrining silence, in which the Truth 
 can be heard and character be calmed and 
 strengthened, for that daily ordeal in which it may 
 be said of every noble life, as Wordsworth said of 
 Milton, that its soul " the lowliest duties on itself 
 doth lay." 
 
 260 
 
FOR THE COMMON CAUSE 
 
 [A Dramatic Study] 
 
 NOT for ourselves, O God, but those poor things 
 Who have no time or strength to grow their wings 
 And needs must crawl in dust the whole day long 
 To make their fellow-creatures rich and strong 
 For women fair as flowers, all choked in filth 
 That will enrich some other's garden-tilth ! 
 
 Give us a voice, ten thousand voices, God, 
 That we may be for them Thy staff and rod, 
 And never rest in helping Thy brave men 
 To cleanse the sins of this Augean den, 
 Till all the Empire, whereof we are part, 
 Holds no more hells, but is love's Home and 
 Heart ! 
 
 Help us to help the children, give us grace 
 To adorn all workrooms, light each darkened place, 
 And, by the shrewdness of a woman's wit, 
 Helping the forces of all manly grit, 
 Unlock the doors that now are shut so fast 
 Till law and liberty join hands at last. 
 
 On us, on us, is laid the heavy load 
 
 Of standing by to see a cruel goad 
 
 Plunged deep each day in other women's flesh 
 
 To see Thy wounds bleed every day afresh ! 
 
 Increase our humbleness, increase our powers, 
 
 That we may fill the wilderness with flowers 
 
 261 
 
OF 
 
 That all the desert where thy millions lie 
 
 Half choked with earth and toiling lest they die, 
 
 May wake and blossom like one heavenly rose 
 
 That shall its sweetness out of earth unclose, 
 
 And all the world's unutterable pain 
 
 At last, at last, O God, be not in vain ! 
 
 This do we ask, tho' we thereby be slain. 
 
 262 
 
A RECURRENT QUESTION 
 
 IF we mistake not, it was Sir John Cockburn, 
 whose views upon one aspect of the fiscal question 
 have recently been much quoted, who, some years 
 ago, opened a discussion in London Opinion on a 
 subject hardly less complicated, though at the first 
 glance perhaps less controversial and more ob- 
 viously suited to these pages : the question whether 
 emigration is desirable for women. Excellent 
 common sense distinguished many of the letters 
 contributed. 
 
 " Youth and health and capacity ot endurance 
 they should have as capital to start with," wrote 
 one of those who entered on the debate. In this 
 she agreed with another and even more forcible 
 correspondent, who, unlike herself, believed that 
 the outlook for middle-aged women in England 
 promised a severe struggle for existence, much 
 more severe competitively than in Canada and the 
 States, but who added that 
 
 44 The Englishwoman who thinks of emigrating 
 should have at least ^50 as capital ; but, above all, 
 she should satisfy herself that she has the three 
 essential qualities for Canadian and American life. 
 She must have : (i) A sound physique to stand the 
 strain of extremes in climate and the c rush ' of 
 American business life ; (2) an adaptable tempera- 
 ment which will not fret and fume because things in 
 Kansas or Winnipeg are not as they are in Clapham 
 
 263 
 
OF 
 
 or Nottingham ; and (3) a plucky soul to help her 
 to face any initial adversities." 
 
 Mr. Havelock Ellis wrote that in the four years 
 which he spent in " one of the most prosperous of 
 our colonies " he knew 
 
 " many women who had come out from the 
 Home Country; some were happy, others not. It 
 may be said of women," he observed, " as of 
 men, that those who succeed here will probably 
 succeed still better in the Colonies ; those who fail 
 here will fail still worse there." 
 
 He summed up a cogent and illuminating letter 
 with a reminder that 
 
 "As regards the Colonies as a cure for moral 
 infirmities, [we must] not forget the saying of the 
 wise Roman that they who run across the sea 
 change their climate, but do not change their souls." 
 
 In this he was at one with the correspondent 
 quoted above, who said bluntly and sensibly : 
 
 " Girls who contemplate emigrating merely in 
 search of husbands, girls who are afraid of genuine 
 hard work, girls who fancy that life was meant for 
 pleasure only, girls who have merely a smattering 
 of music or a capacity for giggling as their social 
 accomplishments all these girls ought to stay at 
 home. They are better off in England, not 
 because England needs them or appreciates them, 
 but because young and rapidly developing countries 
 will not harbour deadheads." 
 264 
 
It may be mere platitudinarian commonplace to 
 labour the point that happiness in the highest 
 sense of the word is dependent upon character 
 rather than environment. That is self-evident. 
 But it would also be a very shallow and dangerous 
 touch of cant to ignore the equally self-evident fact 
 that in many environments such happiness will 
 always include a large element of conquered pain. 
 
 Mere exercise of faculty, for instance, is often 
 a legitimate delight which in some directions 
 many women have to renounce, and those of us to 
 whom this source of enjoyment lies open would be 
 Pharisaical indeed if, being unshackled ourselves, we 
 were to write or speak in such a way as to bind on 
 the shoulders of others burdens too heavy to be 
 borne. We shall do well to remember that even 
 in the twentieth century there are many homes where 
 the strongest capabilities and gifts, possessed by 
 one or more of those who dwell about the hearth, 
 are quietly stifled or surrendered, in the spirit of 
 a noble loyalty and obedience, and sometimes also, 
 it must be confessed, through a weak desire to 
 give to those most loved, not so much what they 
 need or what is good for them, as what they 
 exactingly and unjustifiably claim. 
 
 How can the women we have in mind be best 
 helped to freedom and usefulness by release from 
 those cramping grooves and circles, in which there 
 is a wasteful sacrifice of faculty, even though their 
 initial readiness to waste themselves in a moral 
 treadmill has had in it elements of great nobleness 
 and supreme love ? There are homes where four 
 or five daughters, all middle-aged women, will 
 
 265 
 
OF 3*3088 
 
 continue to starve themselves in body and soul 
 rather than grieve some near and dear relation 
 father or mother, or elder brother, it may be by 
 breaking the family tradition and saying frankly, 
 " We are poor, we must divide. Our parents shall 
 be tenderly cared for always, but that can in reality 
 be better done if we do not all herd together ; there 
 must be division of labour ; some of us will stay, 
 some of us will go." 
 
 In some such cases the suggestion of emigration 
 may undoubtedly lessen the difficulty of such a 
 rupture, for there are many parents and guardians 
 who will listen to that particular appeal, but who 
 would be deaf to the idea of an independent pro- 
 fessional career for their daughters or their wards 
 in England. And, indeed, it does appear that 
 emigration may in some instances offer a healthier 
 and more natural field for women than much of 
 the over-strenuous tension of our great English 
 towns. Only there is always the question, " Who 
 is the woman and where does she purpose going ? " 
 If she is unhandy, vacillating, prejudiced, weak, the 
 most ignorant of us can perceive that she may cross 
 the seas only to deepen her own misery and create 
 new misery for others. If, on the other hand, she 
 is capable, prompt, and in the deepest and widest 
 sense of the word womanly, then, if she be 
 equipped also with health and abundant vitality, 
 it is not difficult to imagine for her a wide and 
 delightful kingdom. Yet even for such a woman 
 as this, and granting that she goes forth unpledged 
 and free of soul without which proviso there may 
 be good material for tragedy yet even for her 
 266 
 
the outlook is more complicated than might at first 
 be supposed. It may be true that she will command 
 a higher income than in the British Islands, though 
 frequently expenses will be higher also ; but, as 
 regards marriage, the risks may be multiplied rather 
 than lessened, for the mere fact of a superfluity of 
 men in the Colonies is but one factor in the problem, 
 and occasionally a very deceptive one ; it does not 
 by any means follow that the woman who has grown 
 up under quite other surroundings, and suddenly 
 comes into their midst, will find among them her 
 true mate. They have been educated, perhaps, 
 under conditions quite alien to her own life, these 
 men, and the noblest of them so weak is human 
 nature may fail to touch her heart, even if they 
 wish to win her a wish that the mere fact of their 
 majority in point of numbers does not always make 
 a foregone conclusion. The comradeship offered 
 may be healthy, inspiriting, delightful ; but, because 
 wives are needed, it by no means follows that the 
 emigrant's own small round of acquaintance a 
 round limited, in some instances, by the isolation 
 of " up-country" life, or of a small provincial 
 settlement will include the man who can uplift 
 her that one individual woman in particular to 
 the ideal wifehood and motherhood which might 
 seem likely best to complete and ripen all that is 
 finest in her. There are men in our colonies who 
 are strong, chivalrous, upright the very salt of 
 the earth. But is it not equally true that the 
 wastrel and the hollow-hearted, the tinsel that is 
 not gold, may not seldom have been shipped there 
 as a last resource ? Good and bad, coarse and fine, 
 
 267 
 
OF 
 
 will be found there, as here, among the men as well 
 as among the women, and many, doubtless, all the 
 world over, who are a little of both. 
 
 If it were certain that a happy marriage or a 
 successful career would await even nine-tenths ot 
 the women likely to emigrate, then, indeed, who is 
 there among us who would not hurry her sisters 
 down to the ships ? But it is not so simple, though 
 doubtless the risks may often be amply worth taking. 
 In other words, the question of emigration for 
 women is one which cannot be answered in general 
 terms, but must be carefully weighed and inquired 
 into in each particular instance. And as for the 
 deep, underlying joy and peace which may make 
 any woman's life beautiful, whether in youth or 
 age, these are not dependent on latitude and longi- 
 tude, or even on social and professional liberty, but 
 on surrender, moment by moment, to the guidance 
 of the Highest. 
 
 268 
 
SNOW-WHITE 
 
 AMID the dazzling whiteness now surrounding my 
 cottage, weighing down the branches of the tall 
 pines that make a charming bit of woodland across 
 the roadway, I think of the magic wrought on far- 
 away buildings, transmuting all grimy and squalid 
 outlines to peaceful splendour, and I turn to those 
 wondrous lines of Mr. Robert Bridges which 
 describe a snowfall in London : 
 
 " When men were all asleep the snow came flying, 
 
 In large white flakes falling on the city brown, 
 
 Stealthily and perpetually settling and loosely 
 
 Hushing the latest traffic of the drowsy 
 
 town; 
 
 Deadening, muffling, stifling its murmurs failing ; 
 
 Lazily and incessantly floating down and down : 
 
 Silently sifting and veiling road, roof, and railing ; 
 
 Hiding difference, making unevenness even, 
 Into angles and crevices softly drifting and 
 
 sailing. 
 
 All night it fell, and when full inches seven 
 It lay in the depth of its uncompacted lightness, 
 The clouds blew off from a high and frosty 
 
 heaven ; 
 And all woke earlier for the unaccustomed 
 
 brightness 
 
 Of the winter dawning, the strange unheavenly 
 glare : 
 
 269 
 
OF 
 
 The eye marvelled marvelled at the dazzling 
 
 whiteness ; 
 
 The ear hearkened to the stillness of the solemn 
 air." 
 
 The outward universe is, as man knows it, one 
 vast symbolic scroll, of meaning too deep to be 
 uttered ; and if we turn symbols to hackneyed uses, 
 that is the fault of our platitudes and not of the 
 great original. The '" stillness of the solemn air," 
 that almost always accompanies the newly fallen 
 snow, is one attraction of that particular hiero- 
 glyph, as though it were the stainless peace of 
 an unutterable purity, and when the sky overhead 
 is of that radiant, unfathomable blueness, which, 
 to our cousins across the Atlantic, is the familiar 
 background to such a foreground as this, and 
 even here in England is now and again vouch- 
 safed, then the great page of the illuminated 
 missal is easy to read. If there be added, in lady's 
 redingote or the " pink " of a huntsman, that 
 touch of scarlet that the Queen in the old fairy- 
 tale of Snowdrop beheld in the white snow when 
 she pricked her thimble-finger, then indeed the 
 supremacy of contrast is a splendour not easily for- 
 gotten. But even without the blue and the scarlet, 
 the celestial whiteness of the untrodden snow has, 
 like the first brave snowdrop, a message for every 
 childlike heart, a message that is only less moving 
 than the sight of a snowy cloud sailing silently 
 across the midsummer sky, or the fragrant star of 
 a Mary-lily in the June sunshine. 
 
 Is it not a priceless symbol and possession, a bit 
 270 
 
of knowledge which every man may hug with joy, to 
 have learned that whiteness is not a negation, but 
 the sum of all those delicate and brilliant hues which 
 are the very ecstacy of art, the very language of 
 rapture, that 
 
 " Pure light unbroken by the prism " 
 
 of which Browning wrote in a lyric of self-effacing 
 passion ? Ah, Browning, the great optimist, under- 
 stood sorrow and bitterness, though he saw through 
 the agony of darkness to the light behind it all. 
 He never ignored ugly facts. It was in a sordid 
 and hideous murder trial that he found and limned 
 for all time that beautiful soul u perfect in white- 
 ness " of whom he makes the old Pope say : 
 
 " Yet if in purity and patience, if 
 In faith held fast despite the plucking fiend, 
 Safe like the signet stone with the new name 
 That saints are known by, if in right returned 
 For wrong, most pardon for worst injury, 
 If there be any virtue, any praise, 
 Then will this woman-child have proved who 
 
 knows ? 
 Just the one prize vouchsafed unworthy me." 
 
 It was an awful story in which the child of an 
 outcast played her part, and the poet who drew 
 Pompilia in all the beauty of immortality knew 
 well that this, which is " not our continuing city," 
 is full of tragedy as well as of redeeming love, and 
 that, as he wrote elsewhere, 
 
 27 1 
 
OF 
 
 " It is by no breath, 
 
 Turn of eye, wave of hand, that salvation joins 
 issue with death ! " 
 
 It is part of our debt to him that, like many 
 another great poet, he has brought home to us the 
 mystic reality of that unfathomable love, which 
 utters to all the agony of the world, from the heart 
 of God, what we mean when we say to some beloved 
 and sorrowing friend, " My heart bleeds for you," 
 and our friend bathes in the warm tide of outpoured 
 sympathy and strength. 
 
 Between Christmas and the New Year many a 
 North-Country shepherd out in the snow will have 
 thought of Him who thus gave Himself for us, 
 and of whom Henry Vaughan has reminded us 
 that there were many reasons why He should call 
 the shepherds to Him first 
 
 " To see their soul's great shepheard who was come, 
 To bring all stragglers home ; 
 Where now they find him out, and, taught before, 
 That Lamb of God adore, 
 That Lamb whose days great Kings and Prophets 
 
 wish'd 
 
 And long'd to see, but miss'd. 
 The first light they beheld was bright and gay, 
 And turn'd their night to day ; 
 But to this later light they saw in him, 
 Their day was dark and dim. 
 
 Ah, why fret that there be graves beneath the 
 snow, as well as snowdrops, when Love that 
 " beareth all things " is omnipresent, and all souls 
 272 
 
not only the souls of the righteous are " in the 
 hand of God " ! 
 
 " Eternal Father, who didst all create, 
 In whom we live, and to whose bosom move, 
 To all men be Thy name known, which is Love. 
 
 By Thee in paths of peace Thy sheep be led, 
 And in the vale of terror comforted/' 
 
 It is fitting that the lines with which this little 
 snow-reverie ends should be from that great living 
 poet with whose description of London snow it 
 began, but to realise their beauty and their mean- 
 ing to the full, not only should the entire sonnet 
 be read, but also the whole series, entitled "The 
 Growth of Love," of which it is the culmination. 
 
 2 73 
 
IN PRAISE OF "ADAM BEDE " 
 
 [Reprinted from the " Temple Classics " by the courtesy 
 of the publishers] 
 
 GEORGE ELIOT was far too great an artist to stoop 
 to that kind of obvious, yet superficial, portraiture 
 in fiction which lends itself to precise identification : 
 she is known to have disliked extremely that vulgar 
 spirit of trite misapprehension which attributes to 
 creative genius a kind of mental snapshot, scatter- 
 ing photographs of places and people, to which the 
 would-be critics give large-type labels. We know, 
 from what she has herself told us, how far re- 
 moved from any cheap reduplication of that sort 
 was her presentment of "Adam Bede," and she 
 has warned us that, though there were, in her 
 sketch of him, traits of her own father, and, in his 
 story, two incidents connected with the latter, yet 
 he was by no means to be regarded as a portrait, 
 any more than Dinah is a portrait of that " Aunt 
 Samuel " whose visit to a condemned prisoner, " a 
 very ignorant girl, who had murdered her child," 
 did, as a matter of fact, suggest the germ out of 
 which the story of " Adam Bede " arose. But all 
 this is best told in the author's own words, and will 
 be found on pp. 254 and 255 of the one- volume 
 edition of Mr. Cross's " Life of George Eliot." 
 
 To annotate a work of art is always a perilous 
 undertaking, and especially would that be true of 
 so supreme an achievement as " Adam Bede " at 
 once an idyll and a tragedy, absolute in its simple 
 274 
 
OF 
 
 unity and self-restraint, most moving in its beauty, 
 passionate in its suffering, yet calm and uplifting 
 as a great symphony or a fine sunset. There is 
 nothing to explain, nothing to add ; for hardly 
 anything is more striking to a careful and sympa- 
 thetic reader than the perfect critical judgment with 
 which everything likely to mar artistic unity and 
 clearness has, by a kind of divine instinct, been 
 avoided, while everything vital to the drama, even 
 to the smallest detail, unfolds with the inevitable- 
 ness of fate. 
 
 It may satisfy a transient curiosity to know that 
 Mr. Irwine's " Foulis ./Eschylus," alluded to on 
 p. 214, was published at Glasgow in 179 5, and that 
 there was a handsome edition from the text of 
 Stanley, corrected by Professor Person, and illus- 
 trated with Flaxman's designs. And although it 
 in no way affects our enjoyment of that inimitable 
 description of Mr. Casson, on p. 13, and the sleek 
 healthiness of the small upper sphere in his genial 
 and rotund person, it may possibly please some 
 stray lover of English verse to note that it was in 
 the first book of " Paradise Lost" (line 291) that 
 " Milton has irreverently called the moon " " a 
 spotty globe." 
 
 In classic verse there are many descriptions of 
 English landscape which would finely companion 
 the noble prose in which, by half a dozen masterly 
 lines, George Eliot has again and again given us the 
 very poetry of Midland scenery. Without attempt- 
 ing any elaborate reference to these, it may be 
 permissible to recall the words of another great 
 Englishwoman of the nineteenth century : 
 
 275 
 
OF 
 
 " (As if God's finger touched but did not press 
 In making England) such an up and down 
 Of verdure, nothing too much up or down, 
 A ripple of land ; such little hills, the sky 
 Can stoop to tenderly and the wheatfields climb ; 
 Such nooks of valleys lined with orchises, 
 Fed full of noises by invisible streams ; 
 And open pastures where you scarcely tell 
 White daisies from white dew, at intervals 
 The mythic oaks and elm-trees standing out 
 Self-poised upon their prodigy of shade, 
 I thought my father's land was worthy too 
 Of being my Shakspeare's." 
 
 The oak and the elm here have the pre-eminence ; 
 but the beech-tree unsurpassed for symmetry of 
 line and translucent beauty of colour is more 
 frequent in Adam Bede's country, and, in organic 
 unity of force and grace, might stand as no unfitting 
 symbol of the form and endurance given to his 
 story. 
 
 George Eliot has not been afraid to give an exact 
 date to the novel. It was published in 1859, and 
 the story opens in 1799, sixty years earlier. But, 
 just as she has avoided any lessening of charm 
 which would have resulted from mere multiplicity 
 of detail, in those pretty touches of bygone costume 
 which make the final spell of grace, of colour, of 
 vividly picturesque reality, in her descriptions of 
 Hetty, or Arthur, or the Irwines ; so also in the 
 more important features of her background, while 
 the setting of the story is found to be strikingly 
 accurate and appropriate, yet jarring amplification 
 276 
 
OF <ADtAM BSVS 
 
 and sentimental embroidering have throughout 
 been skilfully excluded. 
 
 1799 was a critical and eventful year, and with 
 admirable art George Eliot makes use of the dis- 
 turbed condition of Ireland as an occasion for 
 Arthur Donnithorne's absence from England with 
 his regiment when Hetty arrives at Windsor 
 admirable art, because the point is taken for granted 
 and not even explained, lest the idyllic setting of 
 the tragedy a setting which can only enhance its 
 inexorable pathos and terror should be diverted 
 to political controversy or detailed national history. 
 
 It is the year in which " the Moving Finger " of 
 a self-made destiny wrote the frightful nay, out- 
 rageous story of the abuse of the Indemnity Acts, 
 upon a page of Irish history blotted by torture and 
 corruption, and in which the Irish Parliament signed 
 its own death-warrant in its proceedings against 
 suspected rebels; a year in which the bigotry 
 against Irish Roman Catholics seems to have 
 equalled in spirit the worst stories of the Spanish 
 Inquisition, since there are many men and women 
 to whom torture and brutal flogging would be a 
 worse kind of suffering than death at the stake. 
 Any one interested in the subject may find it worth 
 while to turn to the fourth volume of Massey's 
 " History of England." The stirring history, that 
 was a-making in the wider European story of 
 Buonaparte's increasing power and Nelson's vic- 
 tories, is indicated, with the same incidental brevity, 
 in the remarks of the villagers. Any writer less 
 inspired might have been inclined to labour the 
 point, but never once in " Adam Bede " did 
 
 277 
 
OF 
 
 George Eliot swerve from the austere self-discipline 
 and economy of the highest achievement. 
 
 Again, it is impossible not to admire the critical 
 instinct which forbade any dissertation on the 
 history of Dinah's co-religionists. There is no 
 mention of them, beyond what was necessarily and 
 dramatically included in the story. Perhaps the 
 keenest temptation to impertinent digression likely 
 to assail the writer of this note is the inclination to 
 touch on Dinah's divinely simple re-statement of 
 eternal truths. It can scarcely be doubted that, 
 precisely through the absence of all polemical in- 
 tention, all weak sentimentalism, all inclination to 
 " improve the occasion," the story of " Adam 
 Bede " must have entered deeply into that widen- 
 ing and regenerating of religious thought so 
 characteristic of the nineteenth century, and that 
 the music of thousands of toiling lives may owe 
 much to that thrilling chord, struck by the hand of 
 her who gave to our heart and imagination so fair 
 an ideal in this gentle servant of the poor, of whom 
 Adam said that she had "a face like a lily," and 
 whom his mother likened to the angel in his Bible 
 that had rolled away the stone from the tomb. 
 Herself following in the steps of Charles Wesley, 
 Dinah Morris holds the memory with the same 
 warm, white radiance as that other unlettered girl 
 whose presence has transfigured the dark atmo- 
 sphere of the " Ring and the Book " with a halo of 
 purity and grace. 
 
 There is an incense of the Morn to which some 
 are more alive than others. George Eliot was very 
 sensitive to odours, and has used their influence in 
 278 
 
OF 
 
 61 Adam Bede " with as penetrating a magic as 
 Milton has done in " Paradise Lost." Twice is 
 Dinah associated with the fragrance of sweet-brier : 
 what could better haunt the recollection of such a 
 presence than this exquisite dewy sweetness, un- 
 sullied as the clear, fresh air of a world beyond our 
 mortal dust, yet equally suggestive of the village 
 altar and the village hearth ? 
 
 Certain it must be that this tragic idyll, of which 
 Dinah is the life and soul, will not only last as long 
 as the English language lasts, but will purify, uplift, 
 and strengthen, every heart and mind into which it 
 enters, and the more lastingly because the author 
 has never once obtruded her own personality ; she 
 has simply held up the mirror to life, and this no 
 great artist can do without reflecting something of 
 the ineffable Presence. The sacredness of work, 
 the sense of the God-given inspiration which should 
 inform and transfigure handicraft, the subtle rela- 
 tion between thoroughness in duty and solidity of 
 character, the divine value of lowly tasks ; seldom 
 indeed have these struck more warmly and con- 
 vincingly on the listening mind than in this en- 
 thralling story of human love and passion. But 
 this sterling philosophy of life, this unflinching 
 ideal of ardent obedience and uncalculating self- 
 surrender to the command that lies nearest, could 
 hardly have made so poignant and salutary a mark 
 upon the memory, had they left their legitimate 
 everyday drama and descended to self-conscious 
 teaching, or had they missed their converse in that 
 self-delighting, easy benevolence which, in the slowly 
 grinding mill of Life, learned its own desolating 
 
 279 
 
s OF 
 
 possibilities, and spoke its own bitter loss of youth 
 and joy, in Arthur's last recorded words. 
 
 Looking at " Silas Marner " and "Scenes of 
 Clerical Life," to say nothing of " The Mill on the 
 Floss '' and the later novels, it is a bold thing to 
 say that " Adam Bede " is George Eliot's master- 
 piece, yet the more it is studied, the more likely is 
 that belief to be confirmed. The story hardly seems 
 to be fold it lives. So inspired is its intuitive 
 perfection that even the few out-of-the-way words 
 of Midland dialect seem to make no passing ob- 
 scurity, their meaning being intervoven with the 
 context in such a way as to be implicitly obvious. 
 And with what mastery of genius has the novelist 
 given us the simple poetry of peasant imagery and 
 peasant speech ! There is a beautiful passage in 
 dough's " Bothie of Tober-na-Vuolich/' in which 
 Elspie says to her lover : 
 
 " I have been building myself up, up, and toilfully 
 raising, 
 
 Just like as if the bridge were to do it itself 
 without masons, 
 
 Painfully getting myself upraised one stone on 
 another, 
 
 All one side I mean ; and now I see on the other 
 
 Just such another fabric uprising, better and 
 stronger, 
 
 Sometimes I dream of a great invisible hand 
 
 coming down, and 
 Dropping the great keystone in the middle : there 
 
 in my dreaming, 
 
 280 
 
OF 
 
 Feel the other part all the other stones of the 
 
 archway, 
 Joined into mine with a strange happy sense of 
 
 completeness. . . ." 
 
 In a single phrase, pathetic in its bare simplicity, 
 Lisbeth Bede, Adam's mother, the narrow, queru- 
 lous old woman, "clean as a snowdrop," and one 
 of the most vivid of the minor creations in literature, 
 gives that image its complement of grief. " When 
 one end o* th' bridge tumbles down,' 1 she says, 
 " where's th' use o' th' other stannin' ?" Mrs. 
 Poyser's renown has overshadowed that of Lisbeth, 
 but the latter is quite as epigrammatic as the 
 other notable housewife ; and what a true touch 
 it is to make these two most " practical " women 
 the most daringly poetic in their turns of speech ! 
 It is Mrs. Poyser who says of Dinah that she is 
 ''one o' them things as looks the brightest on a 
 rainy day, and loves you the best when you're most 
 in need on't," and Lisbeth who describes herself 
 after her husband's death as being " no better nor 
 an old haft when the blade is gone." 
 
 Language, as George Eliot herself uses it in 
 " Adam Bede," has become so finished and flexible 
 a medium of thought that it may be said to have 
 attained to that highest perfection which effaces 
 itself, so that the reader forgets that there is any 
 medium at all, in his active and immediate realisa- 
 tion of that which it conveys. 
 
 As for the humour that breathes through the 
 whole novel, Shakespeare himself has not surpassed 
 it in unaffected actuality. The drama unfolds 
 
 281 
 
s OF 
 
 itself in all its terrible beauty and pathos with the 
 awful inevitableness and naturalness of life itself. 
 
 " The Moving Finger writes ; and, having writ, 
 Moves on : nor all thy Piety nor Wit 
 
 Shall lure it back to cancel half a Line, 
 Nor all thy Tears wash out a Word of it." 
 
 But for the sense of encircling and redeeming 
 Love, which comes home to the reader, not only 
 through the words and deeds of Dinah, but in 
 every passing heart-throb, every obscure footstep, 
 throughout the whole story, the burden of fate 
 would become too overwhelming a load, so insistent 
 throughout is the passionate verification of Adam's 
 words, " Life's a reckoning we can't make twice 
 over," and those earlier words of his, already 
 referred to, as having been quoted by Arthur at the 
 close of all, " There's a sort of wrong that can 
 never be made up for." 
 
 282 
 
ST. PAUL'S CHIMES 
 
 IN London's heart, the home of toil and love, 
 
 Where, round the cross, the silver- breasted dove 
 
 Is circling to the music of your chime 
 
 Or brooding in the golden mist above 
 
 The docks and shipping and unresting river, 
 
 A little height beyond the smoke and grime 
 
 That veil the haunts of love and grief and crime 
 
 Still, day and night, your message you deliver, 
 
 To point the record of unpausing time : 
 
 Reflecting on your dial, 
 
 For watchful man's espial, 
 
 Earth's tale of hourly movement on through space ; 
 
 On, round her axis turning, 
 
 About a splendour burning, 
 
 With punctual inexorable pace : 
 
 While, daily, like some bird on slanting wing, 
 
 She holds incessantly the wondrous poise 
 
 That will secure recurrent vernal joys ; 
 
 The perfume, colour, music of the Spring ! 
 
 Still drawn to him she never will embrace, 
 
 Who warms her winter into summer grace, 
 
 As if reluctant, yet persistent, goes 
 
 Repelled and drawn enriched with human freight, 
 
 Made glad with winged and footed fellowship 
 
 Of beast and bird, and finny-ocean deep, 
 
 And fair wild things, from holly-berry to rose 
 
 Nor out of her ellipse with random slip 
 
 Has ever fallen, nor flown with random leap 
 
 To swift destruction and abysmal fate ! 
 
 283 
 
OF 
 
 Still dost thou mark unerring, how she moves 
 In that vast cosmic order where she proves 
 One influence, small and incommensurate, 
 In that wide universe whereof man knows 
 No certain boundary, where the mystery glows 
 Magnetic with unseen, unknown vibrations 
 Of ancient stars and ever- new creations, 
 The sanctities of endless constellations, 
 Which human thought can never violate. 
 
 For what are days and hours and months and years, 
 
 While seasons come and go 
 
 And lives move to and fro, 
 
 But rhythmic interwheeling of the spheres 
 
 Whose balanced flight in everlasting chase, 
 
 Which man recalls upon your homely face, 
 
 Are no true measure of his hopes and fears, 
 
 His joys divine, his agonies and tears ; 
 
 Though you, two-handed, made to measure time, 
 
 Through day and night the mystic numbers chime ! 
 
 Yet man, while onward faring 
 
 Through many an age and clime 
 
 From light to darkness, back through dark to light, 
 
 With dawn forever following after night 
 
 Will note your solemn chime, 
 
 And set his clocks to rhyme 
 
 With our small earthly wheel 
 
 In that most wondrous, universal Clock, 
 
 Whereon the Source of Law has set His seal 
 
 Through darkness, light preparing, 
 
 For life, through death, still caring, 
 
 That timepiece none may alter or unlock 
 
 Save One Who made it. 
 
 284 
 
ST. TvtUUS CHIMSS 
 
 Men may gaze and mock 
 Its pendulum will rock 
 
 Through all aeonian change and temporal shock, 
 'Mid cycling evolution, 
 Or sequent devolution 
 And starry revolution, 
 On to the end of time ! 
 
 And when the Master shall the heavens roll 
 At last together, like a finished scroll. 
 To give us welcome at the " Marriage-feast" 
 Which will the dual riddle perchance resolve 
 That man has ever vainly yearned to solve 
 Beyond the caravanserai of earth, 
 With all its dream of human death and birth, 
 Love having slain the dragon and the beast ! 
 Then, if we see no more the Clock august 
 That shall have vanished with the starry dust 
 And all the bodies breathing mortal breath, 
 We shall not much remember it, nor care, 
 When hope's fruition faltering memory shrives ! 
 
 Oh, then at last, when all division's over 
 
 And joy has come to every faithful lover, 
 
 While those " twice-born," beyond the reach of 
 
 death, 
 
 Gaze on the Face they longed for all their lives, 
 All earthly love immortal, bright or dim 
 Fulfilled and found again in finding Him ; 
 Unless their heaven be hell because they read, 
 In one long answering look that will not spare, 
 Of strength they wasted whereof love had need, 
 They will be thankful Life of time is bare ! 
 
 285 
 
TWO STUDIES 
 
 BY MAY SINCLAIR 
 
A SERVANT OF THE EARTH 
 
 BY MAY SINCLAIR 
 
 His name was Elisha Bole, and he lived in the 
 little village of Harford, in South Devon. He was 
 a farm-labourer, fallen in his old age on evil days 
 and the parish. With him these things had come 
 ten years before their time, for Bole was a young 
 man that is to say, not much more than sixty 
 at the time of the great trouble. Bole was out 
 hedging with the best of them, when he slipped 
 from a high bank, and the stake he had just planted 
 went through his ribs, doing incurable hurt to his 
 lungs. 
 
 That was how Bole came to embrace the con- 
 templative life. Not willingly. It may seem hard 
 to believe it of a Devonshire man, but Bole, with 
 only breath enough to take him to the end of his 
 garden and back, panted for the life of action. 
 Yesterday he had range of the soil for at least 
 seven miles round his village. To-day a garden 
 and a cottage were all his world. 
 
 A pleasant place enough, that garden, when it 
 was not scourged by rain from heaven, or hidden 
 under mist from the river, or blotted out by fog 
 from the sea. There the year rang its changes in 
 a happy sequence of scents, violets, roses, chrysan- 
 themums, and the rich earthy smell dear to a son 
 of the soil. There the slow movement of the 
 seasons stirred his intelligence to processes more 
 slow. 
 
 T 289 
 
OF 
 
 A porch of trellis-work, flanked by tall bushes 
 of chrysanthemums, led straight from the open air 
 into the dwelling-place, an inner world where all 
 was vague, indistinguishable. At first you saw 
 nothing there but layers upon layers of darkness 
 and the figure of Bole moving on the face of the 
 darkness like a shadow. Then gradually, because 
 of a certain light and movement in them, his eyes 
 and his smile detached themselves from the sur- 
 rounding gloom . Presently, after stumbling against 
 it, perhaps, you made out a table heaped with dark 
 objects (I never knew what these were till long 
 afterwards), or, guided by its furious ticking, an 
 eight-day clock in the far corner, and in the 
 twilight of the window pots of geraniums half 
 buried under primeval dirt. At least, you may 
 call it dirt I would rather think of it as a gentle 
 fusion of Bole and his geraniums with the earth 
 from which they came. 
 
 After all, when you got used to it, there was 
 something restful in these obscurities which made 
 Bole so profoundly one with his world. It was a 
 shock when I found one warm Sunday that Bole 
 had developed a sudden individuality by washing 
 his face. It seemed to disturb that serene, abiding 
 sense of unity. How often have I found him 
 crouching over his low fire, or seated at his table, 
 motionless, staring into the darkness. Then he 
 seemed to me not so much Bole the labourer as 
 Bole the dreamer, the philosopher, the mystic. 
 Who knows whether in that lapse of all sensation, 
 all idea, Bole may not have touched the supreme 
 Nothingness ? I used to ask myself whether I did 
 290 
 
OF 
 
 well to rouse him from those beatitudes of vacuity 
 to the painful life of thought, whether our friend- 
 ship might not have interfered with some merging 
 of Bole in the Infinite. 
 
 For it came on him suddenly, when he was un- 
 ready for anything of the kind. Bole had not 
 learned the uses of friendship, and strange faces 
 annoyed him. His life had been split in two : 
 there was the time before and the time after his 
 accident, and one knew nothing of the other. 
 And if Bole was morose as well as unsociable, 
 circumstances had helped to make him so. He 
 lived alone, having neither friends nor kindred in 
 the village, save Radley, his brother-in-law, and 
 Radley he hated. Radley, once a policeman, was 
 a sordid man who lived on a pension in obtrusive 
 affluence. Fortune, who had smiled on Radley, 
 had treated Bole with feminine malignity. Many 
 years before the accident some of the villagers 
 had formed themselves into a club for support in 
 times of sickness. This club was looked on by 
 the greater part with extreme disfavour, and only 
 a few of the more revolutionary spirits belonged 
 to it, Bole, among their number, risking all his 
 little savings. The club might have flourished to 
 this day, but for the inconsiderate behaviour of 
 one of its members, whose ill-timed sickness and 
 death broke the bank. Of him Bole always spoke 
 as of one who had indeed greatly erred, but had 
 not therefore forfeited all claim to pity and forgive- 
 ness. But Radley well, Bole was the creature of 
 prejudice. 
 
 Bole being as he was, his friendship was not 
 
 291 
 
OF 
 
 to be won without infinite sleight and cunning. 
 Many a time my hand was on the latch of his 
 garden gate before I could bring myself to open 
 it. I had thought out a plan, bold, but somewhat 
 crude. Attracted by his fame as a gardener, I 
 was to come to him and humbly beg for advice as 
 to the best way of preserving crocuses from field- 
 mice. A custard pudding was then to be offered him 
 as an informal acknowledgment of his services. 
 But at our first meeting if it could be called a 
 meeting when Bole's back was immovably pre- 
 sented to me on his threshold my courage for- 
 sook me, and I fled, bearing the pudding. 
 
 Our second meeting was happier. This time I 
 had come to buy of his parsley. It was cut and 
 handed to me in silence, and I tendered a shilling 
 in exchange. He looked at it darkly. 
 
 " That bain't tiipence," said he. 
 
 "N-no. It's no matter." 
 
 He held out the coin shining in the palm of his 
 grimy hand. 
 
 " Tiipence, I zaid. There's no chailnge i' my 
 plaace." 
 
 And I had no pennies, so I had to take a 
 shilling's worth of parsley ; his flowers he would 
 not sell. 
 
 On my third visit I turned again to my original 
 plan. I laid my difficulty before him. For full 
 five minutes Bole looked at his hands as if to 
 bring back a sense of the earth they had worked 
 in ; he seemed to plunge and lose himself in depths 
 of thought, of memory. He rose darkling to the 
 surface. 
 292 
 
OF rue 
 
 " Crocusses, crocusses yii diggies a ring mebbe 
 one voot round, mebbe tii. Yii vills 'em wi' 
 zinder. Yii zets the crocuss i' the midst. They 
 zay the mouse wunnut win droo the zinder." 
 
 He smiled, and by that smile I came to know 
 him. I took heart from it, and asked if I might 
 come again. He answered me with an air of 
 extreme abstraction : " Zo dii, zo dii, ef yii plaze, 
 
 nuzz." 
 
 I went again. We had not much to say, so 
 many subjects were delicate. 
 
 In time I learned to know his ways, and steered 
 clear of the more prominent rocks of offence ; but 
 to this day I blush with shame to think of the 
 mistake I made almost at the very outset, thereby- 
 undoing the work of many weeks. I offered to 
 read aloud to him. It is very terrible to look 
 back upon, but I was young, and so many of his 
 neighbours liked being read to that I thought he 
 would be sure to share this taste. Not a bit of it. 
 The very suggestion was an insult to his sense of 
 scholarship. From that moment I often came upon 
 him with a book in his hand (generally the Bible 
 or the Book of Common Prayer), when he would 
 detain me, filling up the pauses in the conversation 
 by reading to himself in a slow, soft whisper, lay- 
 ing firm hold on each word with his thumb-nail. 
 A lengthy process ; but why should he care for 
 time who was so sure of a blessed eternity ? 
 
 His tongue once loosened, Bole gradually un- 
 bent. We talked topics ranging from the 
 weather and the crops to the more intimate deal- 
 ings of Providence with his creatures. No gossip. 
 
 2 93 
 
OF 
 
 Bole did not care enough for his neighbours to 
 talk about them ; the little world of the village 
 had ceased to exist for him. But there were 
 still difficulties, limitations. For instance, on the 
 subject of Bole's health there was a certain etiquette 
 against which you gravely sinned by telling him 
 that he <c looked better." The right thing was to 
 begin thus : 
 
 " You seem to be wheezing a great deal to-day ; 
 I'm sure your chest must be worse." 
 
 " I be tur'ble bad wi' the whazing, as yii zee. 
 Doctor never comes nigh me." He chuckled 
 maliciously. " Like as not my complaint's a bit 
 tii masterful fur 'e." No discomfort could subdue 
 his pride in a disorder that had outwitted the 
 faculty. And Bole knew how to return a compli- 
 ment. This visit was my first after being kept 
 indoors with some illness ; suddenly remembering 
 this, he exclaimed with well-feigned horror : " My ! 
 Zit yii down on thiccy cheer. Yii be green i' the 
 faace ! " (This was a polite fiction.) 
 
 I waived the delicate flattery. " I'm all right 
 
 now." 
 
 " Don't yii tell me. Better or wuss, yii be 
 tur'ble bad still, I can zee, sure 'miff." 
 
 Once launched on personalities, Bole grew 
 rapidly intimate. He went back to the days 
 before the accident ; his voice softened, and he 
 told of his dead wife dead seventeen years. 
 " 'Tis strange. Somehows I zeems t' remember 
 her now better'n ever I dii. 'Er wur a good 
 'ooman. 'Er couldn't bide long wi' that Radley 
 Arr-r-r ! " 
 294 
 
OF 
 
 His brother-in-law naturally suggesting his 
 brother, whom he had not seen since they were boys 
 together, Bole wandered further afield. " 'Er be 
 gone tu Canada this zixty year 'tis a laa'ge plaace 
 they zay. 'Er be varmer there, gotten's ownvarm 
 and's own land." A visionary look stole over 
 his face as he spoke of that brother who had 
 realised the labourer's eternal dream. " 'Is zon 
 writes and tells me's vather's growed se vat, er 
 'ad t' 'ave a special cheer carpenter-maade vur 
 en tu zit down in." 
 
 This was said with pride, as a convincing proof 
 that his brother was a man of substance. That I 
 too had a brother in Canada was thought by Bole 
 to be something more than a startling coincidence. 
 
 After that day I was free to come and go as I 
 pleased, till, if I let a fortnight pass without seeing 
 him, he would receive me with mild reproach and 
 always the same saying : 
 
 " I wur veared as yii wur tuk bad again." 
 
 As if nothing but illness or death could have 
 excused such neglect ! 
 
 But if this delightful footing had only been won 
 by cunning, it needed still greater art to make 
 Bole accept the smallest offering. Bole did not 
 want chanty ; he wanted to get to work u i' the 
 vields the vields again ! " Moreover, he deemed 
 that it is more blessed to give than to receive. He 
 never let me go now without a bunch of flowers 
 or cuttings from his best geraniums. He would 
 approach mysteriously a certain gloomy drawer, 
 and, opening it in a large and leisurely manner, 
 show me stowed away in a corner an apple which 
 
 295 
 
s OF 
 
 he had saved for me on account of its preternatural 
 size. Never shall I forget the smile of underhand 
 delight with which, in the first winter of our ac- 
 quaintance, he announced, " I've got a Chrizmizz 
 box for yu," displaying a huge cauliflower carefully 
 wrapped in the most abandoned of red pocket- 
 handkerchiefs. And when it was put to him that 
 as he delighted in giving, so it might be that what 
 he called " charity J) was also a form of self- 
 indulgence on my part, he accepted the gloss. 
 He confessed that barley-water and lemon-juice 
 was an excellent thing for " the whazing." On 
 this new drink Bole experimented in all the spirit 
 of a natural philosopher. He would hide it for 
 days in dark places ; anon he would set it in the 
 sun till it fermented and exploded in his face, to 
 his perpetual surprise and delight, when he would 
 maintain against all argument that the effervescent 
 state was the only right and proper one for barley- 
 water. 
 
 Happily Bole seemed aware that a man who 
 has once accepted barley-water cannot consistently 
 refuse any other trifle you may wish to offer him. 
 And now his strength revived, but only for a 
 season. Worse than parish fare were the darkness 
 and the dirt of Bole's dwelling. Even stocks and 
 oak-leaved geraniums were powerless against the 
 ungovernable smells that rose from the ground 
 where the damp oozed through the imperfect 
 concrete. In stormy weather I have seen the rain 
 beat in from the threshold and form a small pool 
 in the middle of the floor. And when a cholera 
 scare came upon us I felt that steps must be taken. 
 296 
 
OF me 
 
 Therefore I sought out a woman with strong arms, 
 and stronger nerves, fit for the Herculean labour, 
 and broke it very gently to Bole that, with his 
 leave, it would please me to have his cottage 
 thoroughly cleaned and whitewashed. 
 
 He refused politely but firmly : " Let en bide, 
 let en bide." Still more gently I touched on the 
 kinship of disease and darkness (you couldn't say 
 *' dirt " for fear of hurting his feelings). Still 
 more politely he rebuked my impiety. " I've no 
 vaith i' zoap an 1 water. I puts my trust Else- 
 where." 
 
 All the same he looked furtively at my gown as 
 I got up to go. It had been fresh when I started ; 
 now, sure enough, there were dark streaks on its 
 freshness. To my sorrow he whipped out the 
 red pocket-handkerchief, sought to remove them, 
 and shrank back appalled by his own deed. 
 
 4< My ! I've maade en worser'n 'twas. 'Tis 
 the dirt. But there yii know what 'tis ! " 
 
 Not many days afterwards I found him sunning 
 himself at his door and smiling softly. He laid a 
 detaining hand on the latch, saying, with a look of 
 indescribable slyness: "I've got a surprise vur 
 yii." He then threw open the door. 
 
 It was a surprise, not to say a shock. The 
 room had been whitewashed from floor to ceiling, 
 and everything in it thoroughly scoured and 
 cleaned. The tin canisters on the chimney-piece 
 gleamed like silver. A brass warming-pan flashed 
 from the wall. On the table by the door shone a 
 white and gold tea set. This was the collection of 
 dark objects which had excited my curiosity in the 
 
 297 
 
OF 
 
 beginning. Bole broke into a low but triumphant 
 chuckle. In a fit of remorse he had planned this 
 scene for my delight, even employing a friend of 
 Radley's for the job. 
 
 I remember I was pleased with the transforma- 
 tion. But I have wondered since whether, Bole 
 being so one with that familiar darkness, its re- 
 moval may not have helped to loosen his hold on 
 life. A day or two later I found him for the first 
 time busy and in high favour with himself. 
 
 " Yii'll be surprised to see what I be a-doing of. 
 I be tailoring I be ! " 
 
 I was invited to sit down and watch him. He 
 was patching his old fustian coat on an entirely new 
 plan. His way was beset with difficulty. First 
 there was the thread. Bole held it like a lance in 
 rest, and, pursing his mouth with determination, 
 tilted blindly at the needle's eye. Then there was 
 the stuff. Bole was cutting out pieces the exact 
 size of the hole, fitting each into the other, and 
 sewing the raw edges together. When I tried to 
 explain the superior advantages of legitimate 
 patching he shook his head with grave dis- 
 approval, and went on in his own fashion, looking 
 up nervously from time to time as the stitches 
 perpetually gave way and the patch fell out. In 
 silence I handed him a large patch, cut out when 
 he was not looking. There was a moment of 
 suspense. At last in silence he took it, and applied 
 it according to instructions, which he pretended not 
 to hear, putting his head very much on one side, 
 like one liberally indulgent to a doubtful innova- 
 tion. He completed his task with wonderful 
 
OF THS 
 
 success, but the triumph left him trembling and 
 exhausted. 
 
 And now, though it was yet six weeks from 
 Christmas, the weather was unusually bitter, and I 
 brought him a warm Cardigan jacket. It was a 
 thought too tight ; and though he insisted on try- 
 ing it on, he was much shaken by the effort. 
 Politely he denied the misfit. " Er'll dii vinely, 
 er'll dii vinely, mizz '' ; but there was disappoint- 
 ment somewhere. On being implored to unburden 
 his mind, he confessed that the desire of his heart 
 was for a new white coat. " Zlops, some calls 'em 
 zame as yii zee me a-tailoring at." 
 
 I was ashamed at not having anticipated this 
 obvious want, and a white coat was procured with 
 all possible speed. But when I saw him next he 
 still wore the tailored garment, and I asked 
 anxiously if his new one was a misfit too. He 
 shook his head. No, he was "zaving 'er till th' 
 owld en wur dirty 'nuff to be laaid tii-zide." 
 Only one who had seen " th' owld en " could 
 appreciate the ideal nature of his ambition. 
 
 Strangely enough it was on this day that Bole 
 showed the first sign of any interest in his neigh- 
 bours. One half of Harford is virtuous, the other 
 half is not. I had told him I had just come from 
 the house of one Martha Pile, where a young girl 
 was dying of a terrible form of consumption. He 
 shook his head gravely. " Martha Piles's is no 
 plaace fur yii, mizz. They zaay 'tis a bad house." 
 
 " I don't know what they say Lizzie's dying. '' 
 
 " Dying ? Dying ? " He crouched closer to the 
 fire. " Well, Martha's a bad en, but I never knew 
 
 299 
 
OF 
 
 no harm to the pore maaid. Dying, be 'er ? " He 
 shivered. 
 
 It was but a week later when a message came 
 up from the village that my friend was very ill. 
 I hurried down to the cottage. The droop- 
 ing chrysanthemums, bitter-sweet on the keen 
 November air, the hoarse ticking of the eight-day 
 clock, had a hint of dissolution in them, and my 
 heart was heavy as 1 passed through the dwelling- 
 place, so strangely bright and clean, to the low 
 room above. 
 
 He did not know me. Radley was with him ; 
 he did not know Radley. Radley was grieved at 
 his painful discourtesy in not recognising me 
 through the mist of death : he explained many 
 times over that he was " a bit light i' th' 'ead, 
 like." And all the time Bole moved his head from 
 side to side, and babbled of I know not what ; but 
 it seemed that even now, on the borderland of 
 death, he was lost in some shadowy struggle for 
 the means of life. Earth-bound ? Who knows ? 
 
 A little while and he had done with earth ; the 
 servant was freed from his master. As I left the 
 room I saw the new white coat lying neatly folded 
 on a chair. It had never been worn. 
 
 300 
 
GEORGE MEREDITH 
 
 BY MAY SINCLAIR 
 
 GEORGE MEREDITH was born before his time, and 
 he has died before it, as a young man dies. For 
 fifty-five years he laboured, bringing forth the long 
 and splendid procession of his masterpieces, from 
 "The Ordeal of Richard Feverel," a novel of 
 absolute and incomparable greatness, to " The 
 Amazing Marriage," which would alone have 
 proved greatness in a lesser man. And he has not 
 yet come into his own. He is king to the kings and 
 the great lords of literature, but he can in no way 
 be said to reign by the voice of the sovran people. 
 After a long period of obscurity he has passed into 
 the eternal possession of the few. But although 
 by a dreadful fate he became for a time the prey of 
 the cultured, who are fairly numerous, the great, 
 heavy mass of people who read, or think they read, 
 cannot stand Meredith. 
 
 And to-day, among the cultured and the critical 
 who do read him, there is a reaction against him. 
 Nobody doubts his greatness nor the divinity of it. 
 Nobody dares suggest that he did not produce great 
 literature. The tendency is to complain that it 
 was literature that he insisted on reproducing, and 
 not life. Some of us deny that he was either a 
 great novelist or a great poet. 
 
 The younger generation of novelists are all for 
 a conscientious realism, and we have a few young 
 critics who are conscientious too. And Meredith 
 
 301 
 
s OF 
 
 is peculiarly baffling to these. He eludes all their 
 attempts to catch and label him. He seems to 
 them now a realist of considerable piety, and now 
 a romanticist of the kind they most abhor. Al- 
 ready before his death they were trying to place 
 him. They are painfully anxious, elaborately care- 
 ful, not to place him wrong. And he refuses to 
 be placed. 
 
 He did away with their preposterous labels once 
 for all twenty-three years ago, when, in the first 
 chapter of " Diana of the Crossways," he pro- 
 claimed himself a prophet of " the Real," and 
 at the same time told us that our Realists were 
 our " castigators for not having yet embraced 
 Philosophy." 
 
 He defined fiction as " the summary of actual 
 Life, the within and the without of us." It was 
 as a novelist that he came forward for judgment, 
 and it is as a novelist that they arraign him to-day, 
 allowing him to be a philosopher, and, perhaps, as 
 it were by the skin of his teeth, a poet. 
 
 Now, to measure his greatness, not as a philo- 
 sopher, nor yet as a poet, but as a novelist, we 
 must remember the position of the novelist in the 
 Victorian age. He found himself between the 
 devil of realism and the deep sea of sentiment, a 
 horrible position. It distorted his whole attitude 
 to life and his view of the Real. Meredith was 
 the first to deliver the English novel from that 
 degradation. He was the first to see that it is 
 sentiment and not conscience that makes novelists 
 cowards. He recognised Sentimentalism for what 
 it is, the u fine flower of sensualism," and through 
 302 
 
its very fineness the subtlest source of spiritual 
 corruption. He knew that Sentiment early 
 Victorian Sentiment piled to its height topples 
 over into the mire. He saw it as the mother of 
 all shams and all hypocrisies, the nurse of mon- 
 strous illusions. Thackeray, the greatest novelist 
 of his time, who stood nearest to Meredith in 
 sincerity and fearlessness and hatred of shams, 
 Thackeray was afraid, and put it on record that he 
 was afraid, to tell the truth about a man. He 
 said it in his preface to " Pendennis," and he laid 
 his cowardice to the account of the Society which 
 had brought fiction to this pass. 
 
 Meredith knew nothing of that fear. " Imagine," 
 he said, " the celestial refreshment of having a pure 
 decency in the place of sham ; real flesh ; a soul 
 born active, wind-beaten, but ascending. Honour- 
 able will fiction then appear ; honourable, a fount 
 of life, an aid to life, quick with our blood. Why, 
 when you behold it you love it and you will not 
 encourage it or only when presented by dead 
 hands ! " 
 
 His message to his generation was : " Follow the 
 Real. Do not be led by the tainted sentimental 
 lure. Trust yourselves to Nature, though she 
 make havoc of your sentiment.'' For at the heart 
 of Nature he discerned the fiery spiritual pulse, 
 through and beyond Nature the purifying, libera- 
 ting flame. Thus he escapes his captors who would 
 hold him to pure paganism. 
 
 The unity of Nature and Spirit and the return to 
 Spirit through Nature is Meredith's philosophy. 
 He found his generation sickly, and for the cure 
 
 33 
 
OF 
 
 of its sickliness he prescribed Philosophy. By 
 Philosophy he did not mean anything abstract, 
 anything the least metaphysical, anything really 
 incomprehensible to our arbiter of letters, the man 
 in the street. Meredith's philosophy is brain-stuff, 
 thought that makes up half of the fabric of the 
 world. " Idea," he said, " is vital." He was an 
 idealist only to that extent. Brains, to be any good, 
 must have blood in them, and that is where the heart 
 comes in. No man, no writer, had a greater and 
 a fierier heart at the service of his brain. And so 
 again he escapes the grasp of those who would 
 place him among the unhumanised, inaccessible 
 exponents of the cold Idea, who say that his appeal 
 was not to the universal human heart, but to the 
 by no means universal human intellect. 
 
 Now our conscientious young critics have no 
 quarrel with Meredith's philosophy as a philosophy. 
 Their contention is that, as a novelist, he had no 
 right to have any philosophy at all. They resent 
 it as an unwarrantable interference with his drama, 
 an irritating interruption to his story. They 
 attack it on artistic grounds, and because of it they 
 persuade themselves that Meredith was not a great 
 novelist. Which only proves that they have 
 forgotten their Meredith. Nobody who reads his 
 novels with any care will find his philosophy 
 intruding where it can do harm. You will not 
 come across it at any of the intenser psychological 
 moments, in any of the great dramatic scenes, or 
 in any of his inspired passages. It is at its height 
 in " Diana " and " The Egoist," but even there it 
 is confined to the prologue and the interludes. 
 304 
 
Except by way of comment it is almost entirely 
 absent from "Richard Feverel," "Rhoda Fleming," 
 " Evan Harrington," " Harry Richmond," and 
 " Beauchamp's Career." 
 
 For Meredith was before all things a great 
 dramatist and a great psychologist, if he was not 
 always a straightforward teller of his tale. And 
 to be those two things is, I take it, to be a great 
 novelist, even if a man happens to have at the 
 same time an irritating philosophy. 
 
 Other and more serious charges have been 
 brought against him by our cautious and yet 
 irritable young men. We are all tired of hearing 
 that Meredith is obscure, that he sins by excess, 
 by a vice of temperament, by all sorts of exuber- 
 ance and eccentricity. It tires us and it annoys us 
 too, for we feel that there is a certain truth in it. 
 But we are also told that he is not a great novelist, 
 not a novelist at all, for the simple reason that he 
 is a poet. And that is interesting. To be a poet, 
 it would seem, is even more disastrous than to be 
 a philosopher. For, after all, Meredith's philo- 
 sophy embraced the real. But his poetry, they 
 tell us, spoils all that. Because, you see, his lyrical 
 passages express his own emotions, and not the 
 emotions of his characters, and this is why he fails 
 to produce the " illusion of reality." 
 
 It sounds plausible ; it looks as if there might 
 be a certain amount of truth in it. But that is 
 only at first sight. Meredith's lyric passages are 
 there precisely because they do express, as nothing 
 else could, the emotion of his characters. For 
 emotion, at its climax, is powerless to express 
 
 u 305 
 
OF 
 
 itself or anything. Lucy in love, Richard in love, 
 are dumb, but all heaven is sounding through 
 them, and it is that sound of all heaven which 
 Meredith's prose gives us. True, his method 
 destroys the spectacular illusion for a moment, but 
 it does so that it may preserve the illusion of emo- 
 tion, of passion, of reality at its highest intensity. 
 Compare him with Dickens in this matter of emo- 
 tion. Dickens, working himself up into blank 
 verse over the death of Little Nell, is Dickens 
 feeling something about Little Nell and trying to 
 express his feeling. But Meredith in his " Diversion 
 Played on a Penny Whistle " is rendering the song 
 of the souls of Richard and Lucy. They, poor 
 dears, can only say : 
 
 " ' Lucy, my beloved ! ' 
 " < Oh, Richard ! > " 
 
 It is all part of his art, his very perfect art. 
 
 And it is the same with the " Comic Spirit." 
 The Comic Spirit is not Meredith. It is the Spirit 
 immanent in the world and akin to Mr. Hardy's 
 immortal Ironies. It is part-creative. Even in 
 " The Egoist," where it is rampant, its play is not 
 the play of the author intoxicated by his own wit, 
 making merry over the behaviour of Sir Willoughby 
 Patterne. It is not doing anything over or about 
 or around Sir Willoughby. It is really in him, 
 though he knows it not. The Comic Spirit is an 
 aspect of the cosmic reality in which Sir Willoughby 
 has his being. For the essence of Sir Willoughby 
 is to be absurd, and the Comic Spirit, exposing his 
 absurdity, is the revealer of the eternal verity in him. 
 306 
 
Meredith never destroys the IC illusion of reality." 
 It is the illusion of actuality that he tampers with. 
 It may be conceded at once that he had not a 
 very keen sense of the actual, or of local atmo- 
 sphere and surroundings. His characters appear to 
 be surrounded only by the cosmic spaces. He 
 does not present them circumscribed by any 
 parochial or urban or suburban boundary. He 
 seldom, if ever, paints an interior. His scenic 
 effects we remember best are always of the open 
 air. At the same time he has a profound sense of 
 the bonds, restrictions, distinctions of society and 
 race and class. For these things work in the flesh 
 and blood of a man, they are part of the drama of 
 his soul. That is what Meredith shows us in 
 " Rhoda Fleming," in u Beauchamp's Career," in 
 " Harry Richmond," and in " Evan Harrington," 
 all masterly reproductions of English social and 
 provincial life in the Victorian age. 
 
 But they tell us that it is not Meredith's method 
 only that is all wrong. Art, they say, is concerned 
 only with the average, the normal (let it pass), and 
 Meredith wrote of extraordinary people in an ex- 
 traordinary way. This, we are to believe, applies 
 especially to his women. They are all goddesses, 
 or, if not goddesses, all women six feet high. In 
 this, they tell us, his art is inferior to that of Mr. 
 Hardy. If he desired immortality, he should have 
 written about simple people in a simple way. He 
 should have chosen for his tragedies the elemental 
 passions and treated them elementally. He should 
 have written, in short, like Mr. Hardy. 
 
 On the other hand, we also hear that, setting 
 
 307 
 
OF 
 
 out as he does to be subtle, he is not half subtle 
 enough. He should, to produce the perfect 
 illusion of reality, have written more like Mr. 
 Henry James. As it is, he is a victim to the 
 fallacy of the master passion, the dominant note 
 in character, and thus he gives us bare types in- 
 stead of the rich, intricate web of inconsistencies, 
 the splendid irrelevances and surprises which make 
 up individuality in real life. Sir Willoughby 
 Patterne, for instance, is an egoist, always an 
 egoist, and nothing but an egoist ; and no man 
 ever was nothing but one thing. 
 
 This is a strange criticism of a man who knew 
 more than any other how to reproduce the very 
 accent and gesture of the soul. What justice there 
 is in it applies only to " The Egoist." There 
 Meredith comes perilously near to the artificial 
 comedy of Moliere, where the Misanthrope is 
 always a Misanthrope, and Tartuffe forever 
 Tartuffe. In real life that is to say, in the eyes 
 of the Omniscient or of Mr. Henry James Sir 
 Willoughby Patterne would not, perhaps, appear so 
 manifestly and invariably the Egoist he is. It is 
 equally true that in real life if a man is an egoist 
 he will behave and he will feel remarkably like 
 Sir Willoughby Patterne. 
 
 And our critics have forgotten Clara Middleton, 
 Cecilia, and all the irrelevances and inconsistencies 
 of the divine Diana. Mr. Henry James would be 
 the first to take off his hat to them. 
 
 As for the everlasting comparison with Mr. 
 Hardy, it is futile as any comparison must be 
 between two masters equally supreme in their 
 308 
 
separate territories. But it raises interesting 
 questions : Are their territories, after all, so 
 separate? Is it true that Meredith did not under- 
 stand elemental men and women ? It is certainly 
 true that he wrote mostly about people in whom 
 either breeding or education or the possession of 
 a restless intellect obscures the working of the 
 large tragic passions. The modern world is full 
 of such, full, above all, of such women. And 
 Meredith claimed to have discovered the modern 
 woman, u animated . . . with the fires of positive 
 brain-stuff.'* He was the first to see that the 
 sentimentalism (again !) of his time was degradation 
 to its women. 
 
 Even Thackeray, with his exceeding tenderness 
 and chivalry, Thackeray, who owned himself afraid 
 to tell the truth about a man, did not know, as 
 Meredith knew, the truth about a woman. Or 
 perhaps he knew it and was still more afraid. 
 Meredith knew the truth and the whole truth and 
 dared to tell it, dared to give the leading role to 
 those large-brained, large-hearted women of his 
 Diana and Clara and Ottilia and Cecilia Halkett 
 and Rose Jocelyn, Aminta and Carinthia Jane. 
 Charlotte Bronte's Shirley and the great women of 
 George Eliot Maggie Tulliver, Dorothea Brooke, 
 and Dinah Morris are small beside them. They 
 are modern women, and we cannot complain of 
 their stature as abnormal, for modern women are 
 often six feet high. 
 
 These are his extraordinary women. But when 
 he chose he could draw very ordinary women, and 
 men too, and draw them as the masters draw. 
 
 309 
 
OF 
 
 Look at Ripton Thompson, Algernon Blancove, 
 Mrs. Lovell, " Emmy '' and Sir Lukin, Jenny 
 Denham ; even Nevil Beauchamp is not extra- 
 ordinary in our critics' sense ; and the list could 
 be extended indefinitely. 
 
 As for the elemental and the simple people, 
 Tess is not more elemental in her tragedy than 
 Claire Doria Forey or Dahlia Fleming, or even poor 
 Juliana in "Evan Harrington." And Thomasin 
 Yeobright is not more divinely simple than Lucy 
 Feverel, nor is Rhoda Fleming less captivating in 
 her moral beauty than Marty South. For the rest, 
 Hardy's women and Meredith's women are " sisters 
 under their skin." 
 
 Still, it is inevitable to place Hardy and Mere- 
 dith side by side, for they are the last of the great 
 Victorian novelists, and in many ways they are akin. 
 Both are philosophers, both poets, and in both philo- 
 sophy is, like their poetry, the result of tempera- 
 ment. Mr. Hardy's genius is bound to make for 
 the simpler and the larger tragedy, seeing that he 
 regards the lives of men and women as so many 
 sacrifices to the eternal, insatiable lust of Nature, 
 and they themselves as the playthings of an im- 
 placably ironic Destiny. 
 
 But, to George Meredith, Nature, for all her 
 darkness and austerity, is the mother of all joy, of 
 all the sanities and sanctities. The natural love of 
 men and women was to him of all things the sanest 
 and most sacred. Their tragedy is not their sub- 
 servience to Nature, but their falling from her, 
 their sins against her immanent deity. 
 
 His poems sprang from this joy of his genius in 
 310 
 
Nature, its adoration of all the robust and splendid 
 energies of life. Our young critics, more con- 
 scientious than ever as they approach this divinest 
 side of him, have suggested that his philosophy 
 spoils his poems as it spoils his novels. They cite 
 " The Reading of Earth " and The " Woods of 
 Westermain." To be sure, in all his great Nature 
 poems, there are aisles and dells of darkness, inter- 
 minable secret mazes, lost ways of " The Questions" 
 traversing the Enchanted Woods. Yet every way, 
 faithfully followed, leads us into almost intolerable 
 light. Something happens, and we find the Mere- 
 dithian philosophy (which was, after all, more an 
 instinct than a philosophy) transmuted into the 
 Meredithian mysticism as by fire. His message 
 rings clear : 
 
 " Then your spirit will perceive 
 Fleshly seed of fleshly sins 
 Where the passions interweave. 
 How the serpent tangle spins 
 Of the sense of Earth misprised, 
 Brainlessly unrecognised, 
 She being Spirit in her clods, 
 Footway to the God of Gods." 
 
 But besides " The Woods of Westermain " and 
 " The Reading of Earth " Meredith wrote " The 
 Lark Ascending," that continuous, lucid, liquid 
 song of rapture : 
 
 " Shrill, irreflective, unrestrained, 
 Rapt, ringing, on the jet sustained 
 Without a break, without a fall, 
 Sweet-silvery, sheer lyrical." 
 
 3" 
 
OF 
 
 He wrote " Love in the Valley," and that pro- 
 foundest, subtlest, most concentrated of human 
 tragedies, " Modern Love." There are lines there 
 that gleam and cut like steel, dividing the intri- 
 cate web of soul and body. It is the dissection of 
 heart-nerves and brain-cells, a lacerating psychology 
 masquerading in a procession of linked quatrains. 
 
 Yet the same genius, so delicately analytic, 
 brought forth with a stupendous and Titanic energy 
 the " Ballads and Poems of Tragic Life." Among 
 these is " The Nuptials of Attila," where the 
 verse rushes downwards in tumult and in torrent 
 like the hosts of the armoured Huns, a poem 
 barbaric, superb, resonant with the clangour of 
 battle. There is " King Harold's Trance," a 
 masterpiece of grim and terrible simplicity. And 
 there is " The Song of Theodolinda," that 
 supreme hymn of the passion of martyrdom, of 
 divine ecstasy in torture, of torture perishing in 
 ecstasy. 
 
 The most perfervid passages of Crashaw's Hymn 
 to St. Teresa are cold beside Meredith's fire. 
 And the art of it is transcendent. Every line 
 glows with furnace-heat, and beats in its terrible 
 assonances with the strokes of the hammer : 
 
 " This that killed Thee, kissed Thee, Lord ! 
 Touched Thee, and we touch it : dear, 
 Dark it is ; adored, abhorred, 
 Vilest, yet most sainted here. 
 Red of heat, O white of heat, 
 In it hell and heaven meet. 
 
 312 
 
" Brand me, bite me, bitter thing ! 
 Thus He felt, and thus I am 
 One with Him in suffering, 
 One with Him in bliss, the Lamb. 
 Red of heat, O white of heat, 
 This is bitterness made sweet. 
 
 " Now am I who bear that stamp 
 Scorched in me, the living sign 
 Sole on earth the lighted lamp 
 Of the dreadful day divine. 
 White of heat, beat on it fast, 
 Red of heat, its shape has passed, 
 
 " Kindle me to constant fire, 
 Lest the nail be but a nail ! 
 Give me wings of great desire, 
 Lest I look within and fail ! 
 Red of heat, the furnace light, 
 White of heat, fix on my sight. 
 
 " Never for the chosen peace ! 
 Know, by me tormented know, 
 Never shall the wrestling cease 
 Till with our outlasting Foe 
 Red of heat to white of heat, 
 Roll we to the Godhead's feet ! 
 Beat, beat ! White of heat, 
 Red of heat, beat, beat ! " 
 
 If he had written nothing else, that one poem 
 would be enough to ensure his immortality. 
 
 And some of the younger generation, which is 
 so conscientious and so cautious, are wondering 
 whether Meredith will live. Posterity, they think, 
 
OF 
 
 is hardly likely to tolerate what his contemporaries 
 cannot endure. There is much in him, they say, 
 which is intolerable. 
 
 Well, there is much in Fielding, in Scott, in 
 Thackeray, which is intolerable. And yet they 
 live. We still read Fielding, in spite of his per- 
 petual digressions, and the essays with which he 
 dislocates his chapters. We read Scott, in spite 
 of his interminable descriptive passages ; and 
 Thackeray, in spite of his digressions, and of his 
 mortal tendency to moralise in all places of his 
 narrative. It is only reasonable to suppose that 
 Meredith will be read in spite of everything, even 
 of his obscurity. For nothing can kill the novelist 
 if the novelist is there ; and in all Meredith's novels 
 the novelist is supreme. Who, when he thinks of 
 " The Egoist," really remembers anything but the 
 sublime performances of Sir Willoughby Patterne 
 or the ways of Clara Middleton ? Who would 
 dream of judging the terrible and poignant tragedy 
 of Richard Feverel by fragments from " The 
 Pilgrim's Scrip"? Who, as he sees Diana keeping 
 her watch by her dead friend, or kneeling by the 
 hearth of Crossways House, will be unchivalrous 
 enough to remember her as a woman who 
 attempted more epigrams than she ever brought 
 to perfection ? And there is Emmy under the 
 surgeon's knife, and Sir Lukin raving in his 
 remorse. There is Emilia forsaken and Dahlia 
 betrayed, and they are flesh and blood that no 
 a Idea," no philosophy, can destroy. And flesh 
 and blood they had need be to stand in the presence 
 of their creator. Meredith's personality is so over- 
 
 3?4 
 
powering that at times it comes between us and 
 his creations. He has not, as lesser men have had, 
 the habit of detachment. No novelist has it com- 
 pletely, nor can have it. He betrays his own 
 nature more subtly or more inevitably than any 
 other artist, for he handles directly the stuff of life, 
 and we know him by the manner of his handling. 
 It is impossible to read Meredith without seeing 
 him to be before all things clean-souled and 
 courageous and passionately sincere. We divine 
 that there is no greatness and no splendour in his 
 work that had not its match in him. His powers 
 were finely mingled. His intellect was blood- 
 warm and had a heart in it, beating like a pulse of 
 flame, and emotion in him was a spiritual thing, 
 as if the courses of his blood flashed light. To 
 feel, with him, was to see more and not less clearly. 
 It is not conceivable that he will not live, he 
 who had more life, more virile, fertilising energy, 
 than any writer of the two generations that he saw 
 rise round him and pass away before him. Our 
 own generation will return to him, weary of the 
 lucid excellences of the lesser men, their finished 
 perfection within the limits of the little. He was 
 too great for us. If some of us have lost sight of 
 him, it is not because they have left him behind 
 them with the Victorian era ; it is because they 
 have not yet " caught up." He was too swift 
 for us. He has passed us by, and only thus 
 can we conceive of him as passing. He has not 
 yielded up his fire to any one of us. He is on far 
 ahead with his torch, holding high for us the 
 inextinguishable flame. 
 
PRINTED BY 
 
 BALLANTYNE & COMPANY LTD 
 
 TAMSTOCK STREET COVENT GARDEN 
 
 LONDON 
 

 BOOKS 
 
 that 
 compel 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 For him was /evere have at his beddes heed 
 Twenty bakes, clad in blak or reed . . . 
 Than robes riche, orjithele^ or gay sautrye. 
 CHAUCER. 
 
 Telegrams Telephone 
 " Lumcnifer, 6223 
 London " City 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 STEPHEN StflFT fcf CO., LTD. 
 10 John Street^ Adelphi 
 LONDON 
 
INDEX TO TITLES OF 
 SWIFT BOOKS 
 / THAT COMPEL 
 
 PAGE 
 
 PAGE 
 
 Bosbury People, The . 
 
 20 
 
 Modern Mysticism 
 
 25 
 
 British Battle Books . 
 
 4 
 
 More Peers 
 
 28 
 
 Caricatures 
 
 II 
 
 Motley and Tinsel . 
 
 17 
 
 Celtic Temperament, The , 
 
 27 
 
 New Psychology, A , 
 
 10 
 
 Civil War. 
 
 30 
 
 Parisian Portraits 
 
 27 
 
 Daughters of Ishmael 
 
 21 
 
 Party System, The . 24, 
 
 28 
 
 Eight Centuries of Portu- 
 
 
 Passing of the American, The 
 
 5 
 
 guese Monarchy . 
 
 31 
 
 Philosophy of a Don, The . 
 
 3i 
 
 Englishman in New York, 
 
 
 Poems .... 
 
 16 
 
 An . . 
 
 12 
 
 Prince Azreel . 
 
 '3 
 
 Eye-Witness, The 
 
 32 
 
 Rector of St Jacob's, The . 
 
 29 
 
 Gordon at Khartoum . 
 
 8 
 
 Revoke of Jean Raymond, 
 
 
 Humour of the Underman, 
 
 
 The . 
 
 22 
 
 The . 
 
 6 
 
 Roll of the Seasons, The . 
 
 14 
 
 In a German Pension 
 
 15 
 
 Sir Edward 
 
 30 
 
 La Vie et les Hommes 
 
 7 
 
 Some Neighbours 
 
 2 9 
 
 Lonely England 
 
 3i 
 
 Tory Democracy 
 
 23 
 
 Love in Manitoba 
 
 19 
 
 Triumphant Vulgarity 
 
 30 
 
 Maids' Comedy, The 
 
 29 
 
 Valley of Shadows, The . 
 
 26 
 
 Mastery of Life,' The 
 
 9 
 
 Woman without Sin, The . 
 
 18 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., ioJohnSt., Adelphi 
 
INDEX TO AUTHORS OF 
 SWIFT BOOKS 
 THAT COMPEL 
 
 PAGE 
 
 ABBOTT, G. F. 
 The Philosophy of a Don 31 
 
 BEERBOHM, MAX 
 
 PACK 
 
 GRIERSON, FRANCIS 
 Parisian Portraits . . 27 
 The Celtic Temperament 27 
 The Valley of Shadows . 26 
 
 Caricatures 
 
 ii 
 
 Modern Mysticism . 25 
 
 BELLOC, HILAIRE, and 
 
 
 The Humour of the 
 
 CECIL CHESTERTON 
 
 
 Underman ... 6 
 
 The Party System . 24, 
 
 28 
 
 La Vie et les Hommes . 7 
 
 BELLOC, HILAIRE 
 More Peers . 
 
 28 
 
 JUVENAL 
 An Englishman in New 
 
 British Battle Books- 
 
 
 York .... 12 
 
 Blenheim . 
 
 4 
 
 KAUFFMAN, REGINALD 
 
 Malplaquet 
 
 4 
 
 WRIGHT 
 
 Tourcoing . 
 
 4 
 
 Daughters of Ishmael . 21 
 
 Waterloo . 
 
 4 
 
 KENNEDY, J. M. 
 
 The Eye- Witness . 
 
 32 
 
 Tory Democracy . . 23 
 
 BLUNT, WILFRED SCAWEN 
 
 
 LYNCH, ARTHUR, M.P. 
 
 Gordon at Khartoum 
 
 8 
 
 Prince Azreel . 13 
 
 BRAGANC.A CUNHA, V. DE 
 Eight Centuries of Portu- 
 guese Monarchy . 
 
 3i 
 
 A New Psychology . 10 
 Maids' Comedy, The . . 29 
 MANSFIELD, KATHERINE 
 In a German Pension . 15 
 
 DESMOND, G. G. 
 The Roll of the Seasons . 
 
 M 
 
 PROTHERO, J. K. 
 Motley and Tinsel . .17 
 
 DUKES, ASHLEY 
 
 
 RANSOM, ARTHUR 
 
 Civil War 
 FORD, MAY 
 
 30 
 
 The Bosbury People . 20 
 The Rector of St Jacob's 29 
 
 The Revoke of Jean 
 
 
 ROYCE, MUNROE 
 
 Raymond . 
 
 22 
 
 The Passing of the Ameri- 
 
 GILL, E. A. WHARTON 
 
 
 can .... 5 
 
 Love in Manitoba . 
 
 IQ 
 
 Sir Edward . . . 30 
 
 
 
 SMITH, PHARALL 
 
 COLORING, MAUDE 
 
 
 The Woman without Sin 18 
 
 Lonely England 
 
 31 
 
 WHITBY, CHARLES J., M.D. 
 
 GRANVILLE, CHARLES 
 
 
 Triumphant Vulgarity . 30 
 
 Some Neighbours . 
 
 29 
 
 WRENCH, G. T., M.D. 
 
 Poems .... 
 
 16 
 
 The Mastery of Life . 9 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
lllustrated 
 
 BRITISH 
 
 BATTLE 
 
 BOOKS 
 
 BY 
 
 HILAIRE BELLOC 
 
 2^ cap Sv0, cloth, is. net ; leather, 2S. 6d. net 
 
 HISTORT IN WARFARE 
 
 The British Battle Series will consist of a number of 
 monographs upon actions in which British troops have 
 taken part. Each battle will be the subject of a separate 
 booklet illustrated with coloured maps, illustrative of the 
 movements described in the text, together with a large 
 number of line maps showing the successive details of the 
 action. In each case the political circumstances which 
 led to the battle will be explained ; next, the stages 
 leading up to it ; lastly, the action in detail. 
 
 1. BLENHEIM 
 
 2. MALPLAQUET 
 
 3. TOURCOING 
 
 4. WATERLOO 
 
 Later volumes will deal with Crecy, Poitiers, Corunna, 
 Talaveras, Flodden, The Siege of Valenciennes, Vit- 
 toria, Toulouse. 
 
 London : STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
THE PASSING OF 
 THE AMERICAN 
 
 BY 
 
 MONROE ROYCE 
 
 Crown 8w. Cloth. 5*. net 
 
 MODERN AMERICA UNVEILED 
 
 Mr Monroe Royce is a fearless and discerning critic, 
 and The Passing of the American is no ordinary book. 
 
 With refreshing candour the author reveals the 
 prevailing conditions of his own race to-day, not in 
 the spirit of a carping cynic, but of one who would 
 arrest the downward trend of the national character. 
 
 Not since " Henry George " wrote Social Problems 
 has a more powerful, brilliant, and startling presentation 
 of the industrial, social, political, and religious life of 
 the American people been written and much of it 
 applies with equal force to all Western civilised nations. 
 
 Sparklingly written, acutely interesting and thought- 
 provoking, the book is full of a truth which impresses 
 itself upon the reader. It is probably the keenest 
 analysis of the modern American that has ever appeared. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
THE HUMOUR OF 
 THE UNDERMAN 
 
 And Other Essays 
 
 BY 
 
 FRANCIS GRIERSON 
 
 F'cap 8vo. 3*. 6d. net 
 
 CHARACTERISTICALLT INCISIVE 
 
 This volume contains the latest work of the greatest 
 Essayist of our time. Maurice Maeterlinck has said 
 of the Author, " He has, in his best moments, that 
 most rare gift of casting certain shafts of light, at once 
 simple and decisive, upon questions the most difficult, 
 obscure, and unlocked for in Art, Morals, and 
 Psychology . . . essays among the most subtle and 
 substantial that I know." 
 
 This opinion has been endorsed by every critic of 
 note in the British Isles and in the United States of 
 America. Indeed, in the latter country a veritable 
 Grierson cult has sprung into existence. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St.. Adelphi 
 
LA VIE ET 
 LES HOMMES 
 
 BY 
 
 FRANCIS GRIERSON 
 
 Fcap. Svo. 3*. 6 net 
 
 PENS&ES PIQU ANTES, 1NDEPENDANTES 
 
 SULLY PRUDHOMME (de 1' Academic Frangaise): 
 " J'ai trouve ces meditations pleines d'apergus profonds 
 et sagaces. J'ai ete frappe de 1'originalite puissante de 
 la pensee de 1'auteur." 
 
 JULES CLARETIE (de 1'Academie Frangaise): "J'ai 
 ete charme par les id6es originales et justes." 
 
 L'Abbe JOSEPH Roux : " II y a la des vues originales, 
 des appreciations neuves et frappantes." 
 
 FREDERIC MISTRAL : " Ces pens^es m'ont paru 
 neuves et piquantes, et independantes de cette ambiance 
 de pre'juge's a laquelle il est si difficile d'e*chapper." 
 
 Le Pere P. V. DELAPORTE, S.J. (Rdacteur des 
 Etudes Religieuses) : " J'ai admire dans ces pages 
 dedicates 1'artiste, le penseur et 1'ecrivain, et j'ai ete 
 singulierement touch6 de la fagon dont vous appr^ciez 
 le ge*nie frangais. Vous avez su le comprendre et vous 
 avez dit votre pense*e franchement, je pouvais ajouter 
 franfatsement." 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St. , Adelphi 
 
GORDON AT 
 KHARTOUM 
 
 BY 
 
 WILFRED SCAWEN BLUNT 
 
 15^. net 
 
 PRIVATE AND INTIMATE 
 
 This book follows the lines of the author's works 
 on Egypt and India, consisting mainly of a private 
 diary of a very intimate kind, and will bring down his 
 narrative of events to the end of 1885. 
 
 The present volume is designed especially as an 
 answer to Lord Cromer's Modern Egypt^ in so 
 far as it concerned Gordon, and contains several 
 important and hitherto unpublished documents throw- 
 ing new light upon a case of perennial interest. 
 
 It also includes an account of the author's relations 
 with Lord Randolph Churchill, Sir Henry Drummond 
 Wolff, Mr Gladstone, Mr Parnell, and other political 
 personages of the day, as well as of the General 
 Election of 1885, in which the author stood as a 
 Tory Home Ruler. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
THE MASTERY 
 OF LIFE 
 
 BY 
 
 G. T. WRENCH, M.D. LOND. 
 
 Demy Svo. 15*. net 
 
 OLD VALUES RE-VALUED 
 
 This book is a review of the history of civilisation 
 with the object of discovering where and under what 
 conditions man has shown the most positive attitude 
 towards life. The review has been based not so much 
 upon scholarship as upon the direct evidence of the 
 products and monuments of the different peoples of 
 history, and the author has consequently travelled 
 widely in order to collect his material. The author 
 shows how the patriarchal system and values have 
 always been the foundation of peoples, who have been 
 distinguished for their joy in and power over life, and 
 have expressed their mastery in works of art, which 
 have been their peculiar glory and the object of 
 admiration and wonder of other peoples. In contrast 
 to them has been the briefer history of civilisation in 
 Europe, in which the paternal and filial values of 
 interdependence have always been rivalled by the ideal 
 of independence from one's fellow-man. The con- 
 sequences of this ideal of personal liberty in the 
 destruction of the art of life are forcibly delineated in 
 the last chapters. 
 
 London : STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
PRINCIPLES OF A 
 
 NEW SYSTEM OF 
 
 PSYCHOLOGY 
 
 BY 
 
 ARTHUR LYNCH, 
 
 M.A., C.E., L.R.C.P., M.R.C.S.E., M.P. 
 AUTHOR OF "HUMAN DOCUMENTS," ETC., ETC. 
 
 Two Vols. Demy &vo. IQS. 6d. net each 
 
 A BASIC WORK OF ANALTSIS 
 
 This book is dynamic. It is new in the sense in 
 which Schwann's Cell Theory was new to Physiology, 
 or Dalton's Atomic Theory to Chemistry. The author 
 has faced the problem in its widest extension : Can the 
 entire realm of knowledge, and the whole possible scope 
 of mental acts, be so resolved that we may formulate the 
 unanalysable elements, the Fundamental Processes of the 
 mind ? This problem is solved, and thence the manner 
 of all synthesis indicated. The argument is closely con- 
 secutive, but the severity is relieved by abundant illus- 
 trations drawn from many sciences. The principles 
 established will afford criteria in regard to every position 
 in Psychology. New light will be thrown, for instance, 
 on Kant's Categories, Spencer's Hedonism, Fechner's 
 Law, the foundation of Mathematics, Memory, Associa- 
 tion, Externality, Will, the Feeling of Effort, Brain 
 Localisations, and finally on the veritable nature of 
 Reason. A philosophy of Research is foreshadowed. 
 The work offers a base on which all valid studies may be 
 co-ordinated, and developments are indicated. It pre- 
 supposes no technical knowledge, and the exposition is 
 couched in simple language. It will give a new impetus 
 to Psychology. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St.. Adelphi 
 
CARICATURES 
 
 BY 
 
 MAX BEERBOHM 
 
 FACSIMILE REPRODUCTIONS IN COLOUR 
 
 Crown Folio. Cloth. 2 is. net 
 
 HUMOUR, SATIRE, ART 
 
 "A beautiful quarto page where a neat rivulet of text 
 shall meander through a meadow of margin." 
 
 SHERIDAN, School for Scandal, Act I, Sc. I. 
 
 These drawings constitute a "John 
 Bull" series, and, though their satire is 
 directed against political situations and 
 national characteristics rather than personal 
 frailties, they yet retain that quality of 
 mordant criticism that is so prominent a 
 feature of this well-known artist's work. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
AN ENGLISHMAN 
 IN NEW YORK 
 
 BY 
 
 JUVENAL 
 
 Crown Sv0. 5.7. net 
 
 ORIGINALITY 
 
 In these notes and studies on life in New York, 
 Juvenal, by his vivid originality and his masterly 
 deductions, has surpassed all other writers who have 
 written on the same subject. 
 
 Mr Eden Phillpotts writes of the Author : " The 
 things seen are brilliantly set down. He writes with 
 great force and skill." 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
A Poem 
 
 AZREEL 
 
 PRINCE 
 
 with 
 
 BY 
 
 ARTHUR LYNCH 
 
 Crown 8v0. 5$. net 
 
 DIRECT INSPIRING COMPELLING 
 
 The cry for something new in literature, the 
 indefinable, the unexpected, has been answered. 
 Prince Azreel comes to claim his place, not as one 
 who has sounded the depths and shoals of the current 
 modes of the day, but as one entirely careless of these 
 things, discoursing freely of life, easily throughout its 
 whole purport and scope. 
 
 The Devil comes into the action, but he also is 
 new rather the Spirit of the World, "man's elder 
 brother." His methods are those neither of Faust nor 
 of Paradise Regained. His temptations are suasive, 
 his lures less material. 
 
 In the search for the Ideal of statesmanship Azreel 
 and the Devil come to our own Parliament, Azreel 
 tilled with warm enthusiasm, high conceptions. They 
 see, they learn ; they discover "types," and discuss 
 them. We find the Devil at length defending the 
 Commons, supplying the corrective to Azreel's strange 
 disillusions. This part will not be the least piquant. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
THE ROLL OF 
 THE SEASONS 
 
 Nature Essays 
 
 BY 
 
 G. G. DESMOND 
 
 Crown %vo. Cloth. $s. net 
 
 A NATURE BOOK FOR TOWN POLK 
 
 This book for all Nature-lovers appeals perhaps 
 most strongly to those in cities pent, for whom a word 
 in season can call up visions of the open moor, the 
 forest, the meadow stream, the flowered lane, or the 
 wild sea-shore. The extreme penalty for reading one 
 of these spring, summer, autumn, or winter chapters is 
 to be driven from one's chair into the nearest field, 
 there to forget town worries among the trees. The 
 author does not spare us for fog, rain, frost, or snow. 
 Sometimes he makes us get up by moonlight and 
 watch the dawn come " cold as cold sea-shells " to the 
 fluting of blackbirds, or he takes us through the woods 
 by night and shows us invisible things by their sounds 
 and scents. The spirit, even if the body cannot go 
 with it, comes back refreshed by these excursions to 
 the country. 
 
 London : STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
IN A 
 
 GERMAN 
 PENSION 
 
 BY 
 
 KATHERINE MANSFIELD 
 
 Crown 8w. Cloth. 6*. 
 
 DELIGHTFUL LITERARY NOVELTY 
 
 Never before have Germans, from a social stand- 
 point, been written about with so much insight, or 
 their manners and habits described with such malicious 
 naivet and minute skill. Miss Mansfield's power of 
 detailed observation is shown in numerous little touches 
 of character painting which enable us to realise almost 
 as visibly as the authoress herself, the heart, mind, and 
 soul of the quaint Bavarian people. The occasional 
 cynicism and satiric strokes serve to heighten but not 
 to distort the general effect. The one or two chapters 
 which might be called Bavarian short stories rather than 
 sketches are written in a most uncommon indeed 
 thoroughly individual vein, both in form and sub- 
 stance. Miss Mansfield's style is almost French in its 
 clearness, and her descriptions will remind the reader 
 of Russian masters like Turguenieff. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LtD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
POEMS 
 
 BY 
 
 CHARLES GRANVILLE 
 
 F'cap tfo. 5*. net. 
 
 REAL POETIC TALENT 
 
 The present volume is composed of a selection from 
 the previous poetical works of the Author, who is also 
 well known as a writer of prose. The distinctive 
 feature of the poems in this collection the feature, 
 indeed, that marks oft" and differentiates the work 
 of this poet from the mass of verse produced 
 to-day is their spiritual insight. Mr Granville is 
 concerned with the soul of man, with the eternal 
 rather than the transitory, and his perception, which 
 is that of the seer, invests his language with that 
 quality of ecstasy that constitutes the indisputable 
 claim of poetry to rank in the forefront of literature. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., xojohn St., Adelphi 
 
 16 
 
MOTLEY A 
 
 AND TINSEL thetage 
 
 BY 
 
 J. K. PROTHERO 
 
 Crown &vo. Cloth. 6s. 
 
 A BOOK WITH DISTINGUISHED NAMES 
 
 This story in serial form was the subject of an 
 action for libel founded on the coincidence of the 
 plaintiff's name with that of one of the characters. As a 
 protest against the absurd state of the law, the author, 
 in revising the novel for publication in book form, has 
 used the names of distinguished writers and journalists 
 who have kindly given their consent. George Bernard 
 Shaw represents a stage door keeper. George R. 
 Sims, in consenting to drive a hansom, fears there may 
 be cabbies of the same name. Edgar Jepson is dis- 
 guised as an irascible old gentleman of seventy, while 
 Robert Barr officiates as stage manager, with Pett 
 Ridge as call-boy ! Hilaire Belloc is a benevolent 
 entrepreneur, and Cecil Chesterton a fiery tempered 
 lover. We meet Frank Lamburn, the editor of 
 Pearson's Weekly^ as a distinguished actor, while Barry 
 Pain has kindly divided his name between an aged 
 man of weak intellect and his dead son. 
 
 This by no means exhausts the list we find ; we 
 meet the names of well-known journalists and men of 
 letters on every page. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., icJohnSt., Adelphi 
 
THE WOMAN 
 WITHOUT SIN 
 
 BY 
 
 PHARALL SMITH 
 
 Crown %vo. Cloth. 6s. 
 
 ORIGINAL AND UNCONVENTIONAL 
 
 The central idea of this novel is that in those cases 
 in which the love of a man and a woman is sincere and 
 genuine it is of necessity sinless, and consequently that 
 they should be free to indulge it, the consequences 
 being faced by the State. Original and full of force, 
 this novel, containing as it does those elements of 
 bigness so rare in these days, is a refreshing change to 
 the ordinary run of fiction. With a pen which is as 
 powerful as it is restrained, the writer attacks con- 
 vention and upholds his own ideas of freedom between 
 the sexes. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St., Adelphf 
 
LOVE 
 IN MANITOBA 
 
 BY 
 
 E. A. WHARTON GILL 
 
 Crown &vo. Cloth. 6s. 
 
 A FRESH FIELD IN FICTION 
 
 The writer has opened a fresh field of fiction 
 and has presented a striking picture of life in 
 the Swedish settlements of Western Canada 
 a district hitherto largely neglected by novelists. 
 The Author is intimately acquainted with the life 
 of these colonists, and has studied his characters 
 on the spot ; while his local colour is in every 
 way admirable. He knows the West and its 
 people. And the people in his story are typical 
 of those to be met with in every settlement 
 throughout the West. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
THE 
 BOSBURY PEOPLE 
 
 A Novel 
 
 BY 
 
 ARTHUR RANSOM 
 
 Crown %vo. Cloth. 6s. 
 
 COMEDY AND SERIOUS CRITICISM 
 
 This book opens with the appearance of three young 
 cyclists an Anglican priest, a Dissenting minister, and a 
 young squire with Agnostic proclivities who collide at a 
 spot where three roads converge. They are discovered here 
 by Sir Samuel Boulder, who, in his carriage, is returning 
 from the railway station whence he has sent his daughters 
 to the seaside. The baronet insists on taking the wounded 
 cyclists to his Hall at Bosbury, and afterwards insists upon 
 keeping them there until their wounds are healed. The 
 situation is complicated by the unexpected return of " the 
 girls." The comedy of the story is derived in part from 
 the relations between the Priest, the Dissenter, and the 
 Agnostic, and in part from the relations between the guests 
 and the " girls." Not only does the expected happen, but 
 the unexpected in the betrothal of the Dissenter with one 
 of the baronet's daughters. Even the Rector's wife consents 
 " to swallow the Dissenting parson." Beneath the lighter 
 comedy of this study of English country life runs a stream of 
 serious criticism of rural conditions. The time is A.D. 1900. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., lojohn St., Adelphi 
 
DAUGHTERS 
 OF ISHMAEL 
 
 BY 
 
 REGINALD WRIGHT KAUFFMAN 
 
 Crown Svo. Cloth. 6s. 
 
 FRANK, DELICATE, SINCERE 
 
 In this book the Author has handled a difficult 
 subject with the utmost of delicacy consistent with 
 perfect frankness. While telling his story fearlessly, 
 he does so without sensationalism. With nobility 
 of manner and passionate sincerity he relates one of 
 the sordid tragedies common to our great cities 5 but 
 the story is told with such reserve and such impartiality 
 that the zeal of the sociologist is never allowed to 
 destroy the delicacy of the artist. Throughout the 
 book there predominates the Greek idea of Fate j 
 but there is also something better, the hope of the 
 ultimate amelioration of the evils that the book so 
 aptly describes. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO,, LTD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
THE REVOKE OF 
 JEAN RAYMOND 
 
 BY 
 
 MAY FORD 
 
 Crown 8v0. Cloth. 6s. 
 
 INTERESTING, CULTURED, MODERN 
 
 This is an arresting story of the psychological 
 development of a modern woman. The problem of 
 marriage is presented at a new angle and treated with 
 the touch of modernity. A character more interest- 
 ing than Jean it would be difficult to find ; cultured 
 and broad-minded, a woman who has achieved mental 
 and spiritual freedom by a vigorous search for the 
 truth, she devoted her life to manifold practical 
 activities in which her healthy nature found the 
 utmost enjoyment. It was then that her tragedy 
 befell her a tragedy of temperaments and the 
 manner in which Jean revoked makes a strangely 
 fascinating story. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
TORY 
 DEMOCRACY 
 
 BY 
 
 J. M. KENNEDY 
 
 Crown &vo. Cloth. 35. 6d. net 
 
 LORDS, GOVERNMENT, LIBERALISM 
 
 There are unmistakable indications that the system of 
 politics at present pursued by the two chief political parties 
 is not meeting with the approval of the electorate as a whole, 
 though this electorate, as a result of the Caucus methods, finds 
 it increasingly difficult to give expression to its views. In 
 his book on Tory Democracy, Mr J. M. Kennedy, who is 
 already favourably known through his books on modern 
 philosophical and sociological subjects, sets forth the principles 
 underlying a system of politics which was seriously studied 
 by men so widely different as Disraeli, Bismarck, and Lord 
 Randolph Churchill. Mr Kennedy not only shows the 
 close connection still existing between the aristocracy and 
 the working classes, but he also has the distinction of being 
 the first writer to lay down a constructive Conservative 
 policy which is independent of Tariff Reform. Apart from 
 this, the chapters of his work which deal with Representative 
 Government, the House of Lords, and " Liberalism at 
 Work " throw entirely new light on many vexed questions 
 of modern politics. The book, it may be added, is written 
 in a style that spares neither parties nor persons. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
THE 
 
 PARTY SYSTEM 
 
 BY 
 
 HILAIRE BELLOC 
 
 AND 
 
 CECIL CHESTERTON 
 
 Popular Edition, is. net. Cloth, 35. 6d. net 
 
 AN IMPORTANT BOOK FOR VOTERS 
 
 Mr Belloc, after sitting for five years in the 
 House of Commons, resigned his seat at the last 
 election in protest against the unreality of Party 
 Politics. In this book the secret collusion between 
 the two Front Benches is demonstrated, and it is 
 shown how they have captured the control of 
 Parliament. The method of their recruitment and 
 the close ties between them are described, and their 
 reliance upon secret Party Funds, largely obtained 
 by the sale of honours and of legislative power, is 
 made manifest. The machinery by which the two 
 Caucuses control elections, the increasing impotence 
 of Parliament, and the elimination of the private 
 member are carefully analysed. The book concludes 
 with an examination of certain suggested remedies. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO. ; LTD., loJohnSt., Adelphi 
 
MODERN 
 MYSTICISM 
 
 And Other Essays 
 
 BY 
 
 FRANCIS GRIERSON 
 
 F^cap 8v0. 2s. 6d. net 
 
 ORIGINAL, INCISIVE, SUBTLE, ACUTE 
 
 " All lovers of literature will be glad that Modern 
 Mysticism has now been restored to the currency of 
 the book world. ... At heart it is c merum sal ' 
 the true essence of literature. . . . The secret of 
 Mr Grierson's work is its deep sincerity. Eschewing 
 all conventional standards, accepting no hypothesis 
 which he has not proved for himself, Mr Grierson 
 pierces to the heart of his themes with a keenness 
 which is almost disconcerting. . . . No situation is 
 too familiar to be illumined by one of his sudden 
 flashes of insight. The poise of his sentences has 
 something of Gallic precision about it ; and it is 
 not surprising that the savants of contemporary 
 French literature have praised his work with generous 
 emphasis. . . . Such an influence, working like leaven 
 in the lump, can hardly fail to make its presence 
 appreciated." Daily Telegraph. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
THE VALLEY OF 
 SHADOWS 
 
 BY 
 
 FRANCIS GRIERSON 
 
 Second Edition. Demy 8vo. 6s. net 
 
 MEMORIES OF LINCOLN'S COUNTRT 
 
 In this book Mr Grierson recalls in vivid memories 
 the wonderful romance of his life in Lincoln's country 
 before the war. "The Valley of the Shadows is not a 
 novel," says Mr W. L. Courtney in the Daily Tele- 
 graph) " yet in the graphic portraiture of spiritual and 
 intellectual movements it possesses an attraction denied 
 to all but the most significant kind of fiction. . . . 
 With a wonderful touch Mr Grierson depicts scene 
 after scene, drawing the simple, native characters with 
 bold, impressive strokes." 
 
 " Told with wonderful charm . . . enthralling as any 
 romance . . . truth, though often stranger than fiction, 
 is almost always duller ; Mr Grierson has accomplished 
 the rare feat of making it more interesting. There 
 are chapters in the book . . . that haunt one afterwards 
 like remembered music, or like passages in the prose 
 of Walter Pater." Punch. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
TWO BOOKS 
 
 BY 
 
 FRANCIS GRIERSON 
 
 A Profound Thinker and Delightful Stylist 
 
 THE CELTIC 
 TEMPERAMENT 
 
 And Other Essays 
 Third Edition. 2S. 6d. 
 
 "I place these essays among the most subtle and substantial that I know." 
 MAURICE MAETERLINCK. 
 
 " I find the 'Celtic Temperament' charming and full of wisdom. The essay 
 that has happened to strike me most is the one on ' Hebraic Inspiration.' 
 The pages of ' Reflections ' also have found their mark in me." Prof. WILLIAM 
 JAMES. 
 
 "Mr Grierson gives us original and intimate aperfus of things . . . subtle 
 things, and, as I say, ' intimate ' things deep down below the surface of 
 conventional thought and Mr Grierson's book is full of them. ... I shall keep 
 Mr Grierson's book on the same shelf as 'Wisdom and Destiny,' and 'The 
 Treasure of the Humble.'" A. B. WALKLEY. 
 
 PARISIAN 
 PORTRAITS 
 
 25. 6d. net 
 
 The Times says: "He not only recalls what is the most valuable essential 
 of every real memory, the atmosphere, the emotional outlook, the general 
 effect, but has also retained the harvest of a busy, critical and very alert eye. 
 ... He aims at giving an edge to all he says. . . . His touch is light and easy, 
 his insight sure and his choice of subject exclusive. ... A finished, skilful, 
 and richly-laden book." 
 
 Daily Express. " Amazingly clear and acute." 
 
 Westminster Gazette. "Living memories of famous people made unusually 
 real by Mr Grierson's vivacious art of writing and his premeditated frankness." 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., icjohn St., Adelphi 
 
TWO 
 BRILLIANT COLLABORATIONS 
 
 1. "A Laugh in Every Line." 
 
 2. " The Thoughts of Thinking Men." 
 
 MORE PEERS 
 
 VERSES BY HILAIRE BELLOC 
 
 PICTURES BY B.T.B. 
 
 Price 2s. 6d. net 
 
 " There is a laugh in every line of the verses and illustrations." Dmily 
 Express. 
 
 " Those who have not already tasted the peculiar humour which these 
 collaborators imported into 'Cautionary Tales for Children" and the 
 ' Bad Child's Book of Beasts," should by all means study the life history 
 of various peers as recorded in these brief verses." Times. 
 
 2 THE PARTY SYSTEM 
 
 BY HILAIRE BELLOC 
 
 AND 
 
 CECIL CHESTERTON 
 
 Library Edition. Crown 8v0. 35. 6d. net 
 
 No bookof thepresentseasonhas been so much praised and 
 so much reviled : reviled by most of the Party organs, praised 
 by independent papers. And yet mark the agreement of the 
 following, as wide asunder as the poles often in their views. 
 
 " Embodies the silent thoughts of almost all thinking men of to-day." 
 The Evening Times. 
 
 The Star says : " Says in plain English what everybody in touch with 
 reality thinks." 
 
 LORD ROBERT CECIL, in the Morning Post, says : " So far the authors 
 of ' The Party System ' only say in plain terms what everyone who has 
 been in Parliament knows to be in substance true." 
 
 " A complete proof of the necessity of restoring power to the people." 
 The Daily Express. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
 33 
 
THREE EXCELLENT 
 WORKS OF FICTION 
 
 1. " Clever Characterisation'' 
 
 2. "A Prodigy of Age" 
 
 3. " Unique Comedy" 
 
 SOME 
 NEIGHBOURS 
 
 BY 
 
 CHARLES 
 GRANVILLE 
 
 STORIES, SKETCHES, AND STUDIES 
 znd Edition. Crown %vo. 6s. 
 
 "A pleasant book . . . prettily conceived 
 and told. . . ." The Times. 
 
 " The stories are always interesting, both as 
 studies of odd aspects of humanity and for the 
 curious modern reticence of their art." The 
 Scotsman. 
 
 "'Some Neighbours' deserves the highest 
 commendation." CLEMENT K. SHORTER in 
 The Sphere. 
 
 "The treatment is invariably fresh and 
 individual . . . thoroughly readable." The 
 Morning Leader. 
 
 THE RECTOR 
 OFST JACOB'S 
 
 BY 
 
 ARTHUR 
 RANSOM 
 
 A NOVEL OF PHENOMENAL 
 
 INTEREST 
 Crown Zvo. 6s. 
 
 "... Could only have been written by one who 
 knows the outs and ins of the latest ecclesiastical 
 controversy. Our wonder is heightened when 
 we learn that it is the first book of one who 
 will shortly enter his eightieth year." West- 
 minster Gazette. 
 
 4 ' We can recommend this book to all who are 
 interested in religious differences." English 
 Review. 
 
 14 It has life and power." Observer. 
 
 THE 
 
 MAIDS' 
 COMEDY 
 
 A CHIVALRIC ROMANCE 
 IN THIRTEEN CHAPTERS 
 Crown 8vo. 35. 6d. net 
 
 "The Author of this highly entertaining, 
 and indeed delicious, ' Chivalric Romance ' 
 does not give us his name, but we trust that he 
 will be encouraged to give us more stories in 
 the same delicious and fantastic vein." Daily 
 Telegraph. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., icJohnSt., Adelphi 
 
COMPANIONS IN MERIT 
 
 1. "Excellent Irony" 
 
 2. " A Fine Play." 
 
 3. "Irresistible Satire." 
 
 TRIUMPHANT 
 VULGARITY 
 
 BY 
 
 CHARLES J. 
 WHITE Y, M.D. 
 
 A WARNING TO DREAMERS 
 
 Crown Zvff. y. 6ct. net 
 
 " Even if he did not happen to be endowed 
 with a forceful and dignified literary style and 
 a distinct if rather acrid sense of humour, Dr 
 Whitby would have made good his claim to a 
 place apart from the ordinary run of disgruntled 
 Jeremiahs." Daily Mail. 
 
 " We have read few books on similar or kin- 
 dred themes with such a sane and level-headed 
 treatment." A cadetny. 
 
 CIVIL 
 WAR 
 
 BY 
 
 ASHLEY 
 DUKES 
 
 A PLAY IN FOUR ACTS 
 Crown Zvo. 2s. net 
 
 " A play of unusual merit. " Manchester 
 Guardian. 
 
 " The characterisation is excellent, the dia- 
 logue appropriate and easy. " Daily Express. 
 
 SIR 
 EDWARD 
 
 BY A FELLOW 
 
 OF THE LITERARY 
 
 SOCIETY 
 
 A BRIEF MEMORIAL OF A 
 NOBLE LIFE 
 
 " The Author has earned our gratitude for 
 this whimsical study." Spectator. 
 
 " A very pretty piece of satire." Observer. 
 
 "A most polished essay." Morning Leader . 
 
 " We have still a few humourists left and 
 one of them is Sir Edward." Scotsman. 
 
 " One of the drollest satires of the day." 
 Pall Mall Gazette. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
COMMENDABLE AND 
 DISTINCT BOOKS 
 
 1. cc Workmanlike History" 
 
 2. " Successful Prose and Metre" 
 
 3. " Unflagging Vivacity" 
 
 EIGHT 
 CENTURIES 
 
 of 
 
 PORTUGUESE 
 MONARCHY 
 
 BY V. DE BRAGANCA CUNHA 
 Demy Bvo. 14 Pencil Portraits. 15*. net 
 
 " Such a book as this, throwing an illumi- 
 nating light upon the evolution of events, . . . 
 should appeal especially to the British reader." 
 Glasgow Herald. 
 
 " Frank and critical study." The World. 
 
 "A vigorous, straightforward narrative . . . 
 a workmanlike and rapid survey." Morning 
 Leader. 
 
 "... Carried out his idea with care and in 
 the most excellent English." Contemporary 
 Review. 
 
 LONELY 
 ENGLAND 
 
 BY 
 
 MAUDE 
 COLORING 
 
 THREE-COLOUR ILLUSTRATIONS AND PEN- 
 AND-INK SKETCHES. BY AGNES PIKE 
 Crown Zvo. $s. net 
 
 " A book that will appeal to all who love the 
 country or who take an interest in the people 
 who dwell on the land." Pail Mall Gazette. 
 
 " Her work is always sincere, always inter- 
 esting, and not without great beauty." The 
 World. 
 
 " Charming." The Times. 
 
 " Restful and engaging." The Scotsman. 
 
 "A very charming volume of essays." 
 Morning Leader. 
 
 The 
 PHILOSOPHY 
 
 of a 
 
 DON 
 
 BY G. F. ABBOTT 
 Crown 8vo. $s. net 
 
 " A series of particularly smart and dramatic 
 dialogues . . . caustic and candid, sympath- 
 etic, satirical and subtle in turn, and always 
 diverting." Vanity Fair. 
 
 "It pays Mr Bernard Shaw the compliment 
 not merely of introducing him as ' Shav,' but 
 of imitating his arrogant egotism." Truth. 
 
 " Brilliant papers. "-Nottingham Guardian. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
THE 
 
 EYE-WITNESS 
 
 EDITED BY 
 
 HILAIRE BELLOC 
 
 Weekly 6d. 
 Quarterly JS.; Half-yearly 145.; Yearly 28*., post free 
 
 BRILLIANT, DEMOCRATIC, ANTI-PARTT 
 
 " The slightest glance at any number of this vigorous 
 production must convince one that a new idea has come 
 into existence, so far as that is possible. Not everyone, and 
 perhaps at present very few, will agree with the precise 
 and emphatic outlook of this new weekly review ; but there 
 will be very few, even amongst those most violently opposed 
 to its policy, who will not admit that The Eye- Witness is 
 a masterly production." T.P.'s Weekly. 
 
 Mr Hilaire Belloc has gathered round him many of the 
 brightest intelligences in modern letters, including 
 
 G. K. CHESTERTON 
 MAURICE BARING 
 G. S. STREET 
 W. H. HUDSON 
 H. G. WELLS 
 A. C. BENSON 
 CECIL CHESTERTON 
 
 As well as a number of younger writers who are winning 
 or have just won their spurs. 
 
 London: STEPHEN SWIFT & CO., LTD., 10 John St., Adelphi 
 
 PRINTED BY NEILL AND CO., LTD., EDINBURGH. 
 
USE 
 
 WHICH BORROWED 
 
 AN DEPT. 
 
 This 
 
 is due on the last date stamped below, or 
 on the date to which renewed. 
 Renewed books are subject to immediate recall. 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 ' 
 
 
 AUG 18 1967 
 
 
 
 
 T 
 
 
 INTER 
 
 
 
 
 *..-. , 
 
 
 , : y Q 1! 
 
 
 SENT ON ILL 
 
 
 DEC 8 1998 
 
 
 U. C. BERKELEY 
 
 
 LD 21A-60m-7 '66 General Library 
 
 ( Gr4427slO ) 4TuB R**rlr*1#v 
 
YC149265 
 
 / 
 t