A 
 
 
 
 
 
 A 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 JO 
 
 
 
 9 
 
 
 
 1 
 
 -r» 
 
 
 2 
 
 
 
 
 
 9 
 
 
 
 
 3 
 
 -n 
 
 
 3 
 
 
 
 ^
 
 REMARKS 
 
 ON TRANSPORTATION, 
 
 AND ON A RECENT 
 
 DEFENCE OF THE SYSTEM 
 
 SECOND LETTER TO EARL GREY. 
 
 RICHARD WHATELY, D. D, 
 
 ARCHBISHOP OF DUBLIN. 
 
 LONDON: 
 B. FELLOWES, LUDGATE STREET, 
 
 MDCCC XXXIV.
 
 U. CI-AV, llllN 11,11, UKKAD-hlKKtl-iULl.,
 
 C O N T E N T S. 
 
 A 2 UJ5S 
 
 TACE 
 
 Recent Defence of the System 1 
 
 Discrepancy between its Advocates 4 
 
 Incompatible Objects aimed at 11 
 
 Reformation and Prevention 41 
 
 Demoralizing Effects of the System 48 
 
 Vindication of Authorities referred to 58 
 
 Alledged Omission of Religious Motives 67 
 
 The System condemned by its Advocates .... 80 
 
 Vague Supposition of Advantages 85 
 
 Apparent Benefit to Individuals 8(5 
 
 Interests of the Colony preferred to ours 93 
 
 Proposed Substitutes misrepresented 9() 
 
 Indefensible Character of the System 105 
 
 Commissioners for Inquiry recommended Ill 
 
 Objections urged against Commissions 114 
 
 Fallacies relative to humane Conduct 125 
 
 Advantages to be expected from a Commission . . . 130 
 
 Requisite Qualifications of Commissioners .... 133 
 
 APPENDIX— No. 1 143 
 
 No. II ; . 145 
 
 No. Ill 119 
 
 No. IV 153 
 
 No. V IGl 
 
 No. VI IGS 
 
 No. Vli. . . , 170 
 
 13135'r5
 
 REMARKS ON TRANSPORTATION. 
 
 My Lord, 
 
 Having lately received from Van Dieman's 
 Land some pamphlets published there, (by 
 Col. Arthur, and others,) containing strictures 
 on my Letter on Secondary Punishments, I am 
 induced to take the liberty of again addressing 
 your Lordship on the same subject. 
 
 If indeed the measures recommended by 
 Col. Arthur had been altogether and avowedly 
 unthought of and untried, I should not have 
 deemed any reply from me necessary : since, 
 without any disparagement of that gentleman's 
 character or talents, it^nay safely be said that 
 there is not the smallest probability of any 
 totally new scheme being undertaken by Govern- 
 ment (at the present day) on the strength of 
 
 B
 
 2 Bemarks on Transportation. 
 
 such arguments as he adduces. If therefore I 
 had been, in the present instance, the defender 
 and not the assailant, of an existing system, I 
 should have considered that enough had been 
 already said to make good my position. 
 
 But I have undertaken the unpleasant office 
 of pointing out — what no one willingly believes 
 of himself, — that we have been for many years 
 proceeding on an erroneous system ; — that we 
 have been throwing away much time, toil, and 
 capital, in pursuit of an object which we shall be 
 still the further from obtaining the longer we 
 persevere, and that it is only by retracing our 
 steps, that we can hope even to cease producing 
 positive evil. 
 
 Now men are in general so easily satisfied 
 where they earnestly wish to be satisfied, that I 
 cannot but fear a great portion of the public 
 who have not even read, or at least read with 
 close attention, my former Letter to your Lord- 
 ship, may be inclined to set their minds at rest, 
 on the mere report, that, that Letter has been 
 answered by a person on the spot, supposing no 
 reply should appear. They may perhaps be 
 disposed to take for granted, that an attempt
 
 Recent Defence of the System. 3 
 
 at least has been made (though none in fact has 
 been made) to disprove my statements, and to 
 refute my reasonings ; and that a person in the 
 Colony must have a better knowledge • of all 
 matters connected with it, than any one in this 
 country, whatever he may adduce in the way of 
 arguments, can pretend to. That the pamphlets 
 in question rest their conclusions almost entirely 
 on conjectures respecting the future, (which is 
 the province not of knowledge but of reasoning) 
 is indeed apparent on the slightest glance ; but 
 even this slight glance is probably more than 
 will be bestowed on them by many, who may 
 yet be disposed to admit those conclusions with- 
 out inquiry. 
 
 Col. Arthur (whose courtesy of language I am 
 bound to acknowledge) transmitted to me, along 
 with the pamphlets, a MS. Letter, in which he 
 gives me to understand, not, that the system 
 hitherto pursued has led to beneficial effects, 
 but that he hopes more favourable results may, 
 hereafter, ensue from a material change of 
 measures. 
 
 My errors therefore, as he is pleased to desig- 
 nate them, appear to consist chiefly in speaking 
 
 B 2
 
 4 RemarhH on Transportation, 
 
 of things as they have been, and as they are, 
 instead of substituting sanguine anticipations for 
 actual existences. 
 
 A pamphlet by Archdeacon Broughton, ap- 
 pended to that by Col. Arthur, coincides with it 
 so far, that both relate principally to expecta- 
 tions of the future, and indulge largely in what 
 Dr. Johnson denominates, " the triumph of hope 
 over experience." But here the coincidence 
 ceases ; for unfortunately the measures these 
 two gentlemen recommend with a view to the 
 realizing of their bright anticipations, are in the 
 most important points completely opposed to 
 each other. They agree in both expecting to 
 reach the desired port, though they are for 
 steering in contrary directions. I myself agree 
 with each of them only in condemning the 
 course recommended by the other : but at all 
 events it is impossible to pursue both. 
 
 This discrepancy, which I shall presently pro- 
 ceed to point out to your Lordship, is the more 
 remarkable from its occurring in two pamphlets, 
 one of which the author of the other appends to
 
 Discrepancy between its Advocates. 5 
 
 his oze!?i : " I shall annex," says Col. Arthur 
 (p. 80), " a letter addressed to me, at my request, 
 by the Archdeacon of New South Wales, con- 
 taining the substance of his remarks during his 
 present visitation, upon the Convict discipline of 
 this Colony. His opinions and statements do not 
 entirely coincide with those I have advanced; 
 your Lordship," he proceeded to say, (his pam- 
 phlet being in the form of a letter addressed to 
 myself) " will therefore be enabled to compare 
 the results arrived at by individuals, viewing the 
 same object through different media." 
 
 I made accordingly, with the utmost care, the 
 comparison to which I am thus frankly invited ; 
 and the result of it was to remind me forcibly of 
 the story told of the Irish culprit, who was so 
 excessive in his anxiety to clear himself of the 
 charge by establishing an alibi, that he brought 
 forward witnesses to prove two alibis. For (to 
 omit minor differences) one of these writers 
 builds his hopes on the system of precluding 
 Convicts from the power of acquiring property ; 
 and the other, on that of conceding to them this 
 power. 
 
 The fact is, that the objects which the two
 
 6 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 writers respectively had in view, are, as I shall 
 presently shew, not the same, but two, distinct, 
 advantages ; the benefit of the Mother-Country ^ 
 and that of the Colony; both of which, con- 
 jointly, we are taught to expect, on the system 
 of transportation, which is defended on that 
 ground ; but which are, in fact, by the reluctant 
 confessions of its advocates, totally incompatible 
 with each other. 
 
 But though it does not very unfrequently hap- 
 pen that opinions and statements which are at 
 variance and mutually destructive, are put for- 
 ward, separately, by different advocates of the 
 same cause, it did strike me as something novel, 
 to find them thus avowedly and designedly 
 brought into juxtaposition. I feel certain that 
 the Colonel would not, in his own profession, 
 have been guilty of so great a mihtary blunder, 
 as that of calling in the support of a body of 
 auxiliaries, who should, in the hope of annoying 
 the enemy, keep up a cross fire on his own 
 troops. 
 
 It may perhaps be thought by some of my 
 readers that I might safely have left the different 
 advocates of transportation to refute each other.
 
 ' Discrepancij between its Advocates. 7 
 
 And I should probably have done so, if I could 
 have been assured that the pamphlets in question 
 v^rould be read and carefully compared with my 
 former publication, by a large portion of those 
 persons in this country who are anxious for 
 repression of crime, and the welfare of the 
 British empire. Any one who, on such a peru- 
 sal and comparison, should conclude that my 
 first Letter to your Lordship is in any degree 
 refuted, must be beyond the reach of any argu- 
 ments that I can devise or conceive. But, as I 
 have already observed, the mere rumour of any 
 thing that professes to be an answer to a book 
 containing uiiwelcome positions, will often be 
 sufficient, unless met by an immediate reply, 
 to satisfy the minds of many, that all is well. 
 Indeed so easy is it to convince those who are 
 prepared and desirous to be convinced, that I 
 remember seeing in an article on the present 
 subject, in some Review, a cursory remark that 
 " We suspect Dr. Whately's representation to be 
 exaggerated;" and the writer then proceeds, 
 without even pretending to adduce any argu- 
 ment or evidence whatever, to assume that by 
 the expression of this suspicio?t, the whole of
 
 8 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 what I had brought forward was at once and 
 for ever overthrown. 
 
 To meet a multitude of plain arguments — if 
 not unanswerable, at least hitherto unanswered, 
 — and these, based on a mass of the most un- 
 impeachable testimony, some drawn from official 
 documents, and the rest from the statements 
 of men whose opportunities of knowing are 
 indisputable, and whose bias, if they had any, 
 was in an opposite direction — to meet all this 
 by the bare assertion of " We " {i. e. some 
 unknown individual) not that he knows, or is 
 convinced, but that he suspects exaggeration 
 — would have been on most subjects regarded 
 as perfectly ridiculous. But the writer pro- 
 bably in this case calculated rightly enough 
 as to the disposition of many of his readers ; 
 with whom the mere hint of a suspicion of some- 
 body might outweigh any amount of evidence 
 in support of what they were unwilHng to 
 believe. And considering how strong a bias 
 is thus produced in the mind, it is possible that 
 some may be found who may even rise from the 
 perusal of the pamphlets now before me, satisfied 
 that at least something may be said on both
 
 Discrejmncy hetiveen its Advocates. 9 
 
 sides ; and that therefore it is keeping on the 
 safe side to leave things as they are; i. e. to 
 persevere in a system which, if it cannot be 
 satisfactorily vindicated, must be not only not 
 removing, but yearly and almost daily augment- 
 ing, evils of the most frightful magnitude. 
 
 I would not however be understood as dis- 
 paraging the merit of Col. Arthur's pamphlet, 
 considered as the composition of an advocate ; 
 especially when I consider that (as he informs 
 me in his MS. Letter) he was officially called 
 on to reply to my statements and arguments, 
 in consequence of the impression made by them 
 on the public mind. I can estimate the diffi- 
 culty of " giving a reason on compulsion." And 
 I am far from charging him with incompetency 
 to the task thus imposed. On the contrary, I 
 think that he, and Archdeacon Broughton, and 
 Dr. Ross, the author of another publication on 
 the same subject, have done full justice (taking 
 each of the works separately, and not as one 
 whole) to the cause they have undertaken. 
 They have omitted no topic that is likely to 
 have the smallest degree of influence ; and if 
 their attempt to vindicate the system of trans-
 
 10 Remarks on Transportation, 
 
 portation be, as it appears to me to be, a total 
 failure, I would attribute this to the totally 
 untenable character of their position, rather than 
 to any fault of its defenders. 
 
 Col. Arthur indeed apologizes for inaccuracies, 
 on the score of haste : but in point of language 
 I do not observe in his Letter any such incorrect- 
 ness as to call for censure even from the most 
 fastidious critic. In point of matter and arrange- 
 ment indeed, it might at first sight be com- 
 plained that his assumptions are hasty, and his 
 arguments still more so ; and that various diffe- 
 rent topics are confusedly thrown together in 
 bewildering disorder : but I am inclined to think 
 that in reality (whatever may have been the 
 author's design) to have avoided this perplexing 
 confusion and apparently hurried inaccuracy, 
 would have deprived the whole work of every 
 approach towards plausibility that it may possess. 
 '* Then are xve in order," says Cade to his men, 
 " when we are most out of order." It will be 
 found, on examining the several statements, and 
 rejecting all that are either unsupported or irre- 
 levant, — erasing the arguments that are falla- 
 cious, and arranging the remainder distinctly
 
 Incompatible Objects aimed at. 1 1 
 
 and perspicuously under their separate heads, 
 that all three of the puhlications in question 
 (either considered separately, or, still more, 
 taken conjointly) will afford, as far as they have 
 any force at all, the most decisive confirmations 
 of all I had advanced. 
 
 In confirmation of the remark I have been 
 compelled to make, I would invite particular 
 attention to one circumstance, which is also of 
 great intrinsic importance, from its general bear- 
 ing on the present question. It will be found 
 that, not only in the publications I have now 
 been alluding to, but in all vindications of the 
 system of Transportation that have appeared, 
 there is a perpetual confused intermingling of 
 two different questions, and whether from con- 
 fusion of thought, or from sophistical artifice) a 
 perplexing transition backwards and forwards 
 from the one to the other : I mean, the question 
 as to the benefit of Transportation as a mode 
 of punishment, and as a mode of Colonization. 
 Each ground of defence is occupied alternately, 
 as soon as the advocate is driven from the
 
 12 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 other ; and this continual shifting to and fro, 
 from the one topic to the other, hke the tricks 
 of a juggler with cups and balls, distracts the 
 attention, and sometimes wearies the mind into 
 acquiescence. 
 
 At one time the advantages of Transportation 
 as a punishment are set forth : then, when the 
 objections to it in this point of view begin 
 strongly to present themselves, — its defectiveness 
 as a discipline for the reformation of criminals, 
 and its still greater inadequacy for the more 
 important object of deterring from crime, the 
 advocate shifts his ground, and pleads the benefit 
 to the Colony from this compulsory emigration. 
 When the unfitness of such a mode of coloni- 
 zation, — the absurd, as well as ** shameful and 
 unblessed" character (as Bacon designates it) 
 of crowding an infant community with fresh 
 and fresh relays of the scum of mankind, 
 begins to strike the reader, immediately his 
 attention is recalled to the compensating con- 
 sideration of the mode of punishment thus 
 afforded ; and from this topic again, he is 
 called back to the other ; and so on, without 
 end ; till there is a chance that, if not con-
 
 Incompatible Objects aimed at. 13 
 
 vinced, he will at least be bewildered, and his 
 attention exhausted. 
 
 To exemplify adequately what I have been 
 saying, would be to transcribe the greater part 
 of each of the works in question. The error, 
 or artifice (whichever it may be) which I have 
 described, will be found to pervade almost the 
 whole of every one of them. Indeed the perusal 
 of them strongly recalled to my mind a well- 
 known story which, though probably a fiction 
 invented and related merely for the joke's sake, 
 yet conceals, like many of the fables with which 
 childhood is diverted, an instructive moral, from 
 the close resemblance of many of the fallacies 
 which mislead men in the serious affairs of life, 
 to those which are repeated as jests. 
 
 An Oxford scholar, as the tale goes, in taking 
 a country walk, stepped into a rustic ale-house 
 for some refreshment, and, judging from the 
 physiognomy of the landlord that he was some- 
 what dull in intellect, resolved to make trial of 
 his own logical acumen. He called for a pot of 
 beer, which was brought; and, on asking the 
 price of it, which he was told was two-pence, 
 he said to the landlord, " Well, I have changed
 
 1 4 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 my mind : you shall take back the beer, and 
 bring me instead of it, a penny roll, and a penny- 
 worth of cheese." " Very well, sir." The bread 
 and cheese was brought ; which the scholar ate 
 and was departing. " Stop, sir, stop ! you have 
 forgotten to pay." " Pay !" said the scholar, 
 with affected surprise ; *' why what should I 
 pay for ?'' " Why for the bread and cheese 
 you have had, to be sure, sir." " My good 
 friend, you forget yourself ; you know I gave 
 you a pot of beer for it." " True sir, but you 
 never paid for the beer." " Why my good man 
 you must be out of your wits ; pay for the beer 
 indeed ! you know as well as I do, I did not 
 drink it." 
 
 " Quid rides ?" (one might say to one of the 
 New Holland advocates) 
 
 " mutato nomine, de te 
 
 Fabula narratur : " 
 What compensation do you offer for the evil 
 produced by maintaining a system of punish- 
 ment so inadequate, inefficient, and pernicious, 
 as Transportation ? Oh, the advantage of found- 
 ing and maintaining a Colony ! But the Colony 
 is by this means settled and stocked in the
 
 Incomipatihle Objects aimed at. 15 
 
 worst possible way. Aye, but then you should 
 consider the advantage of having a place of 
 punishment for Convicts !* 
 
 I suspect however that the notion which is 
 lurking in the minds of those persons, is, that 
 these two parts of the system, which are thus 
 brought in to support each other, though sepa- 
 rately indefensible, yet conjointly may afford 
 sufficient advantages to justify it : — that though 
 neither the Penitentiary part alone, nor the 
 Colonial part alone, is worth the expense and 
 trouble and the numerous incidental evils, which 
 they cost, yet possibly the combination of the 
 two may produce a sum of benefit that may 
 compensate for the evils. 
 
 It happens unfortunately in the present case, 
 that the measures thus combined for the pur- 
 pose of supplying each other's deficiencies, and 
 affording mutual compensation for their respec- 
 tive inconvenience, are of such a character as 
 most decidedly to interfere with each other. 
 Of the two objects proposed, almost every step 
 that can be taken with a view to either, tends 
 
 * See Appendix A.
 
 16 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 in an equal or greater degree to defeat the 
 other ; so as to render the combined result of 
 the whole even a still more signal failure than 
 each part of the scheme separate. A Colony 
 stocked with worthless vagabonds, is in itself 
 bad, as a Colony : a Penitentiary again, in a 
 young settlement at the Antipodes, is, for many 
 reasons, likely to be, in itself, a bad Penitentiary ; 
 but each of them becomes incomparably worse, 
 when they are combined ; because in the most 
 important points, two not only different, but 
 even opposite, systems of management will be 
 dictated, by a regard for the promotion of this 
 object or of that. And thus, besides the other 
 evils inevitably consequent on the pursuit of 
 incompatible advantages, we might also have 
 anticipated (and experience shews with how 
 much reason) the evil of a course of perpetual 
 vacillation, and reiterated change of measures, 
 under different governors, according as each 
 may be inclined to look more to the welfare of 
 the Colony, or to the efficiency of Transportation. 
 Each accordingly has, to a certain extent, good 
 grounds for censuring and reversing the mea- 
 sures of his predecessor, as at variance with a
 
 Licowpatible Objects aimed at. 1 7 
 
 part of what are, in truth, the contradictory 
 orders given to all. 
 
 Of the justness of what I have been now 
 saying, any man of candour and common sense 
 may convince himself, not from my reasonings 
 and reflections, or from his own, but from a 
 reference to the very advocates of the system 
 themselves. By their oiv?i shezdng it aims at 
 objects which are mutually inconsistent, and 
 each of which can be promoted only at the 
 expense of the other. I will extract, as one 
 specimen out of several, the following passage 
 from Archdeacon Broughton's Letter : — 
 
 " There is one consideration which appears to 
 *' me not to have attracted due attention, al- 
 " though by legislating without reference to 
 " it, we are exposed to all the inconsistencies 
 ** which arise from acting without settled prin- 
 ** ciples. It is most evident, that upon all 
 '* propositions which may afifect the condition 
 '* of prisoners after their arrival in the colonies, 
 " the mother- country and the colonies have 
 " separate interests. The interest of the for- 
 " mer is, that transportation should operate as 
 " a punishment, principally that it may act as
 
 18 Reviarl's on Travsportation. 
 
 " a warning and a restraint. This is to render 
 *' it ' formidable/ not desirable, in the eyes of 
 " the nation at large. To effect this, it is 
 " evidently the policy of the mother-country 
 ** not only to provide that the prisoners, while 
 " under sentence, should be under a course of 
 " punishment ; but also, that after their sen- 
 " tence has expired, they should at least not 
 " find readier means of rising in credit, wealth, 
 " and station, than under any circumstances 
 " they could have aspired to, if they had re- 
 " mained at home. Every instance to this effect 
 *' does prove that whatever suffering transpor- 
 " tation may cause, it affords to the individual 
 " an advantage which, but for transportation, 
 " he could not have enjoyed ; and it thus far 
 " undoes the designed effect of that punishment, 
 " and operates accordingly against the interest 
 " of the country which is seeking thereby to 
 " deter from and diminish crime. On the other 
 '^ hand, when we look at the interest of the 
 " community to which offenders are transported, 
 " we find that, for its advancement we ought 
 *' to hold out to prisoners an encouragement 
 "exactly the reverse of that which the state
 
 Incompatible Objects aimed at. 19 
 
 " from which they are banished would approve. 
 
 * To call forth the resources of a new country 
 
 * like this, it is plain that every man should 
 
 * be encouraged to exert his utmost skill and 
 
 * industry ; which he will never do but in the 
 ' hope of acquiring property. And if a pri- 
 ' soner is in a capacity to acquire property, 
 ' he must from the force of circumstances be 
 
 * able, in proportion to his endowments of 
 ' mind and body, to acquire it more easily 
 ' than he could in England. In the recent 
 ' act which incapacitates the holders of tickets- 
 ' of-leave from acquiring or holding property, 
 ' the legislature has acted very advisedly no 
 
 * doubt, in furtherance of Enghsh objects; but 
 ' the operation of that act will be to take away 
 
 * a great stimulus to industry and enterprise, 
 
 * and thereby to retard colonial improvement. 
 ' So again, if we look exclusively to the interest 
 ' of the colonies, it is plain that the prisoner 
 ' whose sentence has expired, should be en- 
 ' couraged to apply his utmost energies to 
 ' the acquisition of property, by the prospect 
 ' of sharing those civil and political distinctions 
 
 * which, unless a prohibitory law intervene, it 
 
 c2
 
 20 Remarhi on Transportation. 
 
 " is the natural effect of property to confer, 
 " But on the other hand, if the road to honour 
 " as well as wealth be laid open to those who 
 " have been prisoners, it is evident that such 
 " exaltation will appear very enviable in the 
 " eyes of those honest people at home, who 
 " find that they cannot rise to the hke ; and 
 " thus again, what is good for the colony will 
 " be detrimental to the parent state. Their 
 " interests in this respect must ever remain 
 " opposed ; and therefore it is incumbent on 
 " those who legislate for both countries, to de- 
 ** cide at once which of these interests shall be 
 '* preferred, and in all their measures to act 
 '* upon the principle of making the other give 
 " way."* 
 
 * Dr. Ross (p. 58) concurs with Archdeacon Broughton in 
 reprobating the recent alterations in the law by which it is 
 attempted to render transportation efficient as a punishment : 
 " The second section of the act of parliament recently passed 
 " for abolishing the punishment of death for certain ofFenceSj 
 " and substituting transportation instead, by depriving pri- 
 " soners, if we understand it right, of all power to hold pro- 
 " perty of any kind, and thus removing the main spur to 
 " reform, has already paved the way to obtain this most 
 " wretched end. To connect the sentence in England in a 
 " more intimate way than has hitherto been done with the
 
 Incompatible Objects aimed at. 21 
 
 I fully concur with what the Archdeacon has 
 here said ; and have only to add the expression 
 of my unfeigned wonder, that he should not 
 have drawn the obvious conclusion from his own 
 premises ; viz. that the only thing to be done is 
 immediately to abandon a system which professes 
 
 " punishments to be undergone in Van Dieraan's land is both 
 " proper and commendable, but it must be done with discretion, 
 " not by legislating in the dark, and subverting, as if by acci- 
 " dent, the whole machinery of prison discipline formerly esta- 
 " Wished. If the section of the act alluded to had been framed 
 " to prevent persons who had been convicted of obtaining money 
 " by theft, forgery, fraud, swindling, or other false pretences, 
 " from possessing or enjoying it when transported to this 
 " colony, though that by the existing laws and regulations was 
 " already prevented, it could at least have done no harm. But 
 " when it goes on prospectively to deprive the convict of all 
 " future incentive to honest industry, or good conduct, by 
 " stripping him wholly of its fruits, the most superficial ob- 
 " server will discern how positively injurious it must. be. Be 
 " this, however, as it may, it points out the method by which 
 " the home authorities can, if they see fit, carry the rigour of 
 " punishment with regard to transported convicts to any length." 
 And again, (p. 61,) "What productive labour could prisoners 
 " in such a situation perform, that would in any way meet the 
 " expense of provision, clothing, superintendents and guards ? 
 " Besides, the circuitous or indirect advantages which Britain 
 " now derives in return for what the government expends on 
 " the colony, would, by the removal and dispersion of the
 
 22 Remarks on Trcmsportation. 
 
 to aim at the mutual benefit of the mother 
 country and the colonies, on a plan which sets 
 the two in direct opposition. Instead of this, 
 however, he concludes his letter by expressing 
 sanguine hopes founded on the adoption of mea- 
 sures just opposite to what he himself recom- 
 mends ! 
 
 " The course to be pursued therefore is to 
 " render transportation * something far beyond 
 " ordinary hard work ; and to cut off the hope 
 " of those advantages which have been indis- 
 
 " settlers, be gradually sapped away. By the custom-house 
 " return for the quarter endmg the 1 0th Oct. last, it appears 
 " that British manufactured goods were imported to Hobart 
 " Town from the ports of Great Britain alone, to the amount of 
 " 34,415/. sterling. If to this be added the imports at our 
 " other port of Launceston, with the amount of goods, the 
 " produce of other British colonies, on which duty is paid, we 
 " have an aggregate of imports for the whole year, of about 
 " 320,000/. Exports in colonial produce to the amount of 
 " about two-thirds of this value are sent to England. It would 
 " be needless for us to stop here, in order to point out to the 
 " intelligent reader the fiscal and commercial advantages which 
 " this reciprocal intercourse must confer, and which would be 
 " speedily swept away by the desperate and uncompromising 
 " species of prison discipline which we have imagined." Ac- 
 cording to these gentlemen, the interests of the colony and of 
 the mother country, arc antipodes to each other.
 
 Incompatible Objects aimed at. 23 
 
 ** creetly suffered in some instances to result 
 *' from it : detracting from its proper terror, 
 '* and leading many to covet it as a boon, rather 
 " than dread it as a punishment. When this is 
 *' done, transportation will operate as effectually 
 " as any instrument of mere punishment can do, 
 " in discouraging crime and reforming criminals." 
 
 " When this is done" which I expect will only 
 be " ad Grwcas Calendas," the author will have the 
 satisfaction of contemplating the beneficial effect 
 of setting at defiance all his own principles. 
 
 The astonishment with which I first read 
 the above extracts, became greater and greater 
 every time I recurred to them. Is it then pos- 
 sible, — I have several times asked myself — 
 almost distrusting the evidence of my own 
 senses, — that these passages should occur in a 
 pamphlet sent me, professedly, for the purpose 
 of " disabusing me of my errors " in respect of 
 Transportation and of vindicating the system ? 
 Or can it be that the whole is a piece of inge- 
 nious irony, sent to me by way of sport, to try 
 whether I can detect its true character, and 
 written by persons who, in the assumed charac- 
 ter of advocates, intend to hold up the system
 
 24 Remarhs on Transportation. 
 
 to scorn and derision? I have several times 
 been half- inclined to take this view of the 
 matter ; recollecting the ridicule which Bishop 
 Warburton incurred by setting about seriously 
 the work of refuting the " Vindication of Natural 
 Society," by Burke, under the character of 
 Bolingbroke. I have resolved however, at the 
 hazard of being laughed at for credulity, to treat 
 the pamphlets as serious compositions ; though 
 I could almost pardon such of my readers as 
 may not have these publications before them, 
 should they entertain a momentary doubt whe- 
 ther I can have made a faithful extract. Perhaps 
 too, they may think it an affront to their under- 
 standing, that I should deem it necessary to 
 proceed any further, in exposing the absurdity 
 of a system which is thus condemned by its own 
 advocates. But besides that to a great part of 
 the public, these pamphlets (as I have already 
 observed) are likely to be known only by vague 
 hearsay, I should add, that, wiih the exception 
 of that frank avowal which I have cited from 
 page 99 of Archdeacon Broughton's Letter, both 
 he and the other defenders of the system, 
 generally keep out of sight the inconsistency I
 
 Incompatible Objects aimed at. 25 
 
 have alluded to, and present to the reader 
 separately and alternately the supposed advan- 
 tage of "getting rid" (as it is called) of criminals, 
 and that of encouraging a growing Colony ; so 
 as to withdraw the attention from the real in- 
 compatibility of the two. 
 
 In other subjects as well as in this, I have 
 observed that two distinct objects may, by being 
 dexterously presented, again and again in quick 
 succession, to the mind of a cursory reader, be 
 so associated together in his thoughts, as to be 
 conceived capable, when in fact they are not, 
 of being actually combined in practice. The 
 fallacious belief thus induced bears a striking 
 resemblance to the optical illusion effected by 
 that ingenious and philosophical toy called the 
 Thaumotrope ; in which two objects painted on 
 opposite sides of a card, — for instance a man, 
 and a horse, — a bird, and a cage, — are by a 
 quick rotatory motion, made to impress the eye 
 in combination, so as to form one picture, of the 
 man on the horse's back, — the bird in the cage, 
 &c. As soon as the card is allowed to remain 
 at rest, the figures, of course, appear as they 
 really are, separate and on opposite sides. A
 
 26 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 mental illusion closely analogous to this, is 
 produced, when by a rapid and repeated trans- 
 ition from one subject to another alternately, 
 the mind is deluded into an idea of the actual 
 combination of things that are really incom- 
 patible. The chief part of the defence which 
 various writers have advanced in favour of the 
 system of penal Colonies consists, in truth, of 
 a sort of intellectual Thaumotrope. The pros- 
 perity of the Colony and the repression of 
 Crime, are, by a sort of rapid whirl, presented 
 to the mind as combined in one picture. A 
 very moderate degree of calm and fixed atten- 
 tion soon shews that the two objects are painted 
 on opposite sides of the card. 
 
 In aid of this and the other modes of defence 
 resorted to, a topic is introduced from time to 
 time in various forms, which is equally calcu- 
 lated to meet all objections whatever on all 
 subjects : — that no human system can be ex- 
 pected to be perfect; — that some partial incon- 
 venience in one part or in another must be 
 looked for ; and that no plan can be so well 
 devised as not to require vigilant and judicious 
 superintendence, to keep it in effectual ope-
 
 Incompatible Objects aimed at. 27 
 
 ration, and to guard against the abuses to which 
 it is liable, &c. &c. 
 
 All this is very true, but does not in reality 
 at all meet the present objections. Though we 
 cannot build a house which shall never need 
 repair, we may avoid such a misconstruction 
 as shall cause it to fall down by its own weight. 
 Though it be impossible to construct a time- 
 piece, which shall need no winding up and which 
 shall go with perfect exactitude, we may guard 
 against the error of making the wheels neces- 
 sarily obstruct each other's motions. And though 
 a plan of penal legislation, which shall unite 
 all conceivable advantages and be liable to no 
 abuses, be unattainable, it is at least something 
 gained if we do but keep clear of a system 
 which by its very constitution shall have a con- 
 stant and radically inherent tendency to defeat our 
 jjrincipal object. 
 
 Now such is the case (as I have endeavoured 
 to shew, in my former Letter, and in this) with, 
 — what may be called our great Penitentiaries, — 
 those on which we chiefly rely, — the Convict- 
 settlements. The very system of a penal 
 Colony contains in itself, considered as a mode
 
 28 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 of punishment, a principle of self-destruction : 
 because it not only aims (as I have already 
 pointed out, and as one of its present advocates 
 acknowledges) at two objects essentially at variance 
 with each other, but also has a constant ten- 
 dency, in practice, to sacrifice the more im- 
 portant of these two objects, to the incidental 
 and subordinate one : I mean the efficiency of 
 the Penalty, to the prosperity of the Colony. 
 
 That this is and must be the case, is a matter 
 of complete moral demonstration. It is not 
 only what we might have had every reason to 
 expect, from the nature of the case alone, with- 
 out having tried the experiment ; but it is 
 also evinced by experience alone, independent 
 of all calculations of probability ; and lastly, 
 it is over and over again confirmed by the 
 admissions of those who wish to defend the 
 system. 
 
 I am the more anxious to press this con- 
 sideration on the minds of my readers, because 
 I cannot but think that any man of candour 
 and sound judgment, who will but sufficiently 
 attend to this one point, need hardly trouble 
 himself to examine any of the other numberless
 
 Incompatible Objects aimed at. 29 
 
 arguments against Transportation. Let every- 
 thing else that has been said on that question, 
 in my former pubhcation, or in the present, be 
 supposed to be waived and to go for nothing ; 
 and the single circumstance I am here adverting 
 to, would, alone, be perfectly decisive. 
 
 For let any one but calmly reflect for a few 
 moments on the position of a Governor of one 
 of our penal Colonies, who has the problem 
 proposed to him of accomplishing two distinct 
 and in reality inconsistent objects ; — to legislate 
 and govern in the best manner with a view to 
 1st. the prosperity of the Colony, and also 2dly. 
 the suitable punishment of the Coiivicts. It is 
 well known that slave labour is the least profit- 
 able ; and can seldom be made profitable at all, 
 but by the most careful, difficult, troublesome, 
 and odious superintendence. The most obvious 
 way therefore of making the labour of the Con- 
 victs as advantageous as possible to the Colony, 
 is to make them as unlike slaves as possible ; 
 to place them under such regulations and with 
 such masters, as to ensure their obtaining not 
 only ample supplies both of necessaries and 
 comforts, but in all respects favourable and even '
 
 30 Remarks on Transportation, 
 
 indulgent treatment; in short to put them as 
 much as possible in the comfortable situation 
 which free labourers enjoy, where labour is so 
 valuable, as from the abundance of land, and 
 the scarcity of hands, it must be in a new set- 
 tlement. 
 
 And the masters themselves may be expected, 
 for the most part, to perceive that their own 
 interest (which is the only consideration they 
 are expected to attend to) lies in the same direc- 
 tion. They will derive most profit from their 
 servants, by keeping them as much as possible 
 in a cheerful and contented state, even at the 
 expense of connivance at many vices, and of 
 so much indulgence as it would not, in this 
 country, be worth any master's while to grant, 
 when he might turn away an indifferent servant 
 and hire another. The master of the Convict- 
 servants would indeed be glad, for his own 
 profit, to exact from them the utmost reasonable 
 amount of labour, and to maintain them in a 
 style of frugality equal to, or even beyond that 
 of a labourer in England : but he will be sure 
 to find that the attempt to accomplish this, 
 would defeat his own object ; and he will be
 
 Incompatible Objects aimed at, 3 1 
 
 satisfied to realize such profit as is within reach. 
 He will find that a labourer who does much less 
 work than would be requisite, here, to earn 
 the scantiest subsistence, and who yet is 
 incomparably better fed than the best English 
 labourer, does yet (on account of the great value 
 of labour) bring a considerable profit to his 
 master; though to employ such a labourer on 
 such terms, would, in England, be a loss instead 
 of a profit. It answers to him therefore to 
 acquiesce in any thing short of the most gross 
 idleness and extravagance, for the sake of keep- 
 ing his slave (for after all it is best to call things 
 by their true names) in tolerably good humour, 
 rather than resort to the troublesome expedient 
 of coercion,* which might be attended with 
 risk to his person or property from an ill- 
 disposed character, and at any rate would be 
 
 * " To give some idea of the serious loss of time, as well as 
 " of the great trouble caused by being far removed from a 
 " magistrate alone, I need only state, that when a convict 
 " servant misconducts himself, the settler must either send the 
 " vagabond to the nearest magistrate, not improbably some 
 " thirty or forty miles distant, or he must overlook the 
 " o^ewQe:'— Excursions in New South Wales, hy Lieutenant 
 Breton.
 
 32 Bemarks on Transportation. 
 
 likely to make such a servant sulky, perverse, 
 and wilfully neglectful. 
 
 It may easily be conceived therefore what 
 indulgent treatment most of the Convicts are 
 likely to receive, even from the more respectable 
 class of settlers. As for the large proportion 
 who are themselves very little different in cha- 
 racter, tastes, and habits, from their Convict- 
 servants, they may be expected usually to live 
 (as the travellers who have described the Colony 
 assure us they do) on terms of almost perfect 
 equality with them, associating with them as 
 boon-companions. But to say nothing of these, 
 the more respectable settlers will be led, by a 
 regard for their own interest, to what is called 
 the humane treatment of their servants ; that is, 
 to endeavour to place all those in their employ 
 who are not much worse than such as, in this 
 country, few would think it worth while to 
 employ at all, in a better situation than the most 
 industrious labourers in England. 
 
 Now it is evident that the very reverse of 
 this procedure is suitable for a House of Correc- 
 tion, — a place of 'punishment. And it is no less 
 evident that a Governor must be led both by
 
 Incompatible Objects aimed at. 33 
 
 his feelings, — by his regard for his own ease, — 
 and by his wish for popularity with all descrip- 
 tions of persons around him, as well as by his 
 regard for the prosperity of the Colony, to 
 sacrifice to that object, the primary and most im- 
 portant one, of making Transportation, properly, 
 a penalty. We can seldom expect to find a 
 Governor (much less a succession of Governors) 
 wilhng, when the choice is proposed of two 
 objects at variance with each other, to prefer 
 the situation of Keeper of a House of Correction, 
 to that of a Governor of a flourishing Colony. 
 The utmost we can expect is to find now 
 and then one, crippling the measures of his 
 predecessors and of his successors, by such 
 efforts to secure both objects as will be most 
 likely to defeat both. But the individual 
 settlers, to whom is entrusted the chief part of 
 the detail of the system, are not (like the 
 Governor) even called on by any requisition 
 of duty, to pay any attention to the most im- 
 portant part of that system. They are not 
 even required to think of any thing but their 
 own interest. The punishment and the re- 
 formation of Convicts are only incidental results.
 
 34 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 It is trusted that the settler's regard for his 
 own interest will make him exact hard labour 
 and good conduct from the servants assigned to 
 him. But if indulgence is (as we have seen) 
 likely to answer his purpose better than rigid 
 discipline, he cannot even be upbraided with 
 any breach of duty in resorting to it. 
 
 Of the many extraordinary features in this 
 most marvellous specimen of legislation, it is 
 one of the most paradoxical, that it entrusts 
 a most important pubhc service, in reference to 
 the British nation, to men who are neither 
 selected out of this nation on account of any 
 supposed fitness to discharge it, nor even taught 
 to consider that they have any pubhc duty to 
 perform. Even in the most negligently-governed 
 communities, the keeper of a house of correction 
 is always, professedly at least, selected with some 
 view to his integrity, discretion, firmness, and 
 other qualifications ; and however ill the selec- 
 tion may be conducted, he is at least taught to 
 consider himself entrusted, for the pubhc benefit, 
 with an office which it is his duty to discharge on 
 public grounds. 
 
 However imperfectly all this may be accom-
 
 Incompatible Objects aimed at. 35 
 
 plished, few persons would deny that it is, and 
 ought to be, at least, aimed at. But this is not 
 the case in the land of ornithorhynchus paradoxus 
 and of other paradoxes. There each settler is, 
 as far as his own household is concerned, the 
 keeper of a house of correction. To him, so far, 
 is entrusted the punishment and the reformation 
 of criminals. But he is not even called upon to 
 look to these objects, except as they may inci- 
 dentally further his own interest. He is neither 
 expected nor exhorted to regulate his treatment 
 of convicts with a view to the diminution of 
 crime in the British Isles, but to the profits of 
 his farm in Australia. 
 
 It is true, the settler may sometimes be, like 
 other men, actuated by other feelings besides 
 a regard to profit : but these feelings are not 
 likely to be those of public spirit. When the 
 comict does suffer hard usage, it is not much to 
 be expected that this will be inflicted with a view 
 to strike terror into offenders in Great Britain, 
 or to effect any other salutary end of punish- 
 ment. His treatment is hkely to depend not so 
 much on the character of the crime for which 
 he was condemned, as on the character of his 
 
 d2
 
 36 Remarks on Transportation, 
 
 master. Accordingly Colonel Arthur, (p. 3,) in 
 enlarging on the miseries to which a convict is 
 subjected, makes prominent mention of this, that 
 " he is conveyed to a distant country, in the 
 " condition of a slave, and assigned to an un- 
 " known master, whose disposition, temper, and 
 " even caprice, he must consult at every turn, 
 " and submit to every moment." 
 
 It is observed by Homer, in the person of one 
 of his characters in the Odyssey, that " a man 
 " loses half his virtue the day that he becomes 
 '' a slave :" he might have added with truth, that 
 he is likely to lose more than half when he 
 becomes a slave master. And if the convict- 
 servants and their masters have any virtue to 
 lose, no system could have been devised more 
 effectual for divesting them of it. Even the 
 regular official gaolers, and governors of peni- 
 tentiaries, are in danger of becoming brutalized, 
 unless originally men of firm good principle. 
 And great wisdom in the contrivance of a peni- 
 tentiary-system, and care in the conduct of it, 
 are requisite to prevent the hardening and de- 
 basing of the prisoners. But when both the 
 superintendant and the convicts feel that they
 
 Incompatible Objects aimed at. 37 
 
 are held in bondage, and kept to work by him, 
 not from any views of public duty, but avowedly 
 for his individual advantage,"^ nothing can be 
 imagined more demoralizing to both parties. 
 
 Among all the extravagancies that are re- 
 corded of capricious and half insane despots in 
 times of ancient barbarism, I do not remember 
 any instance mentioned, of any one of these 
 having thought of so mischievously absurd a 
 project as that of forming a new nation, consist- 
 ing of Criminals and Executioners. 
 
 But had such a tyrant existed, as should not 
 only have devised such a plan, but should have 
 
 * Colonel Arthur (p. 2 3.) falls into an inaccuracy of language 
 which tends to keep out of sight a most important practical 
 distinction. He says : " With regard to the fact that convicts 
 " are treated as slaves, any difficulty that can be raised upon 
 " it must hold good whenever penitentiary or prison disci- 
 " pline is inflicted." If by a " slave" be meant any one who 
 is subjected to the control of another, this is true. But the 
 word is not in general thus applied. It is not usual to speak 
 of children as slaves to their schoolmasters, or to their parents ; 
 or of prisoners being slaves of the gaoler ; or soldiers, of their 
 officers. By slaves we generally understand persons whom 
 their master compels to work for his own benefit. And in 
 this sense Colonel A. himself (p. 2.) applies the term (I think 
 very properly) to the assigned convict-servants.
 
 38 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 insisted on his subjects believing, that a good 
 moral effect would result, from the intimate 
 association together, in idleness, of several hun- 
 dreds of reprobates, of various degrees of guilt, 
 during a voyage of four or five months, and 
 their subsequent assignment as slaves to various 
 masters, under such a system as that just 
 alluded to, it w^ould have been doubted whether 
 the mischievous insanity of wanton despotism 
 could go a step beyond this. Another step 
 however there is ; and this is, the pretence of 
 thus benefiting and civilizing the Aborigines! 
 Surely those who expect the men of our hemi- 
 sphere to believe all this, must suppose us to 
 entertain the ancient notion of the vulgar, that 
 the Antipodes are people among whom every 
 thing is reversed. The mode of civilization 
 practised, is of a piece with the rest. 
 
 *' They have been wantonly butchered ; and 
 " some of the Christian (?) whites consider it a 
 " pastime to go out and shoot them. I ques- 
 " tioned a person from Port Stephens concern- 
 " ing the disputes with the aborigines of that 
 " part of the colony, and asked him, if he, or 
 " any of his companions, had ever come into
 
 Incompatible Objects aimed at. 39 
 
 " collision with them, as I had heard there pre- 
 *" vailed much enmity between the latter and 
 " the people belonging to the establishment ? 
 " His answer was, * Oh we used to shoot them 
 " like fun ! ' It would have been a satisfaction 
 " to have seen such a heartless ruffian in an 
 " archery ground, with about a score of expert 
 " archers at a fair distance from him, if only to 
 " witness how well he would personify the 
 " representations of St. Sebastian. This man 
 " was a shrewd mechanic, and had been some 
 " years at Port Stephens : if such people con- 
 " sider the life of a black of so little value, how 
 " is it to be wondered at, if the convicts enter- 
 " tain the same opinion ? It is to be hoped that 
 " the practice of shooting them is at an end, but 
 " they are still subjected to annoyance from the 
 " stock-keepers, who take their women, and do 
 " them various injuries besides." — ^r^ifow, p.200. 
 But to waive for the present all discussion of 
 the moral effects on the settlers, likely to result 
 from the system, let it be supposed that the 
 labour of convicts may be so employed as to 
 advance the prosperity of the Colony, and let it 
 only be remembered that this object is hkely to
 
 40 Remarks oji Transportation. 
 
 be pursued both by governors and settlers, at 
 the expense of the other far more important 
 one, which is inconsistent with it, the welfare of 
 the mother country, in respect to the repression 
 of crime. This one consideration, apart from 
 all others, would alone be decisive against trans- 
 portation as a mode of j^unishmeni ; since even if 
 the system could be made efficient for that object, 
 supposing it to be well administered with a view to 
 that, there is a moral certainty that it never will 
 be so administered. 
 
 If there be, as some have suggested, a certain 
 description of offenders, to whom sentence of 
 perpetual exile from their native country is 
 especially formidable, this object might easily 
 be attained, by erecting a penitentiary on some 
 one of the many small, nearly unproductive, 
 and unoccupied islands in the British seas ; the 
 conveyance to which would not occupy so many 
 hours, as that to Austraha does weeks. 
 
 But as for the attempt to combine salutary 
 punishment with successful colonization, it only 
 leads, in practice, to the failure of both objects, 
 and, in the mind, it can only be effected by 
 keeping up a fallacious confusion of ideas.
 
 Reformation and Prevention. 4 1 
 
 It is not, however, merely in respect of these 
 two points, the interest of the Colony and that 
 of the Mother Country, that this thaumotropic 
 blending of distinct pictures is needed and is 
 resorted to, in order to withdraw the attention 
 from the incompatibility of the several objects 
 proposed. The penal portion of the system, 
 considered alone, proposes to combine irrecon- 
 cileable advantages, each of which is, by turns, 
 represented as aimed at, and as attained. Each 
 objection, as soon as brought forward, is eagerly 
 met by such statements and representations as 
 the case may seem to call for, supported as 
 strongly as bold and vehement assertions can 
 support any thing ; and then the advocates 
 seem to calculate on the reader's not only being 
 perfectly satisfied with what is said, but im- 
 mediately afterwards forgetting the whole of it ; 
 so as to be prepared to receive from the same 
 pen representations the most opposite to the 
 foregoing, calculated to meet some different 
 objection. 
 
 At one time we find the situation of the con- 
 vict painted in the most favourable colours, as 
 one of considerable present comfort, and full of
 
 42 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 cheering confidence of speedy and complete re- 
 storation (on the supposition of tolerably good 
 conduct) to a respectable place in society, with 
 such advantages, in respect of worldly pros- 
 perity, as the individual could not elsewhere 
 have hoped. This is to shew the utihty of the 
 system as a mode of reformation. Then, to 
 shew its utility as a mode of deterring from 
 crime by terror, the picture is reversed, and the 
 same convict is represented as undergoing the 
 most galling and degrading slavery — as suffering 
 the most unmitigated misery, and branded with 
 the most indelible disgrace.* This latter repre- 
 
 * *' I think you will be constrained to admit that a punish- 
 " ment by which the offender is stripped of all his property — 
 " deprived of his liberty — shut out from intercourse with his 
 " family, totally separated from them, — denied every comfort, 
 " according to the idea entertained of that word by the lowest 
 " class — placed on board a transport — subjected there to the 
 " most summary discipline — exposed to ill usage from 
 " criminals still worse than himself — conveyed to a distant 
 " country in the condition of a slave — then assigned to an 
 " unknown master, whose disposition, temper, and even 
 " caprice he must consult at every turn and submit to every 
 " moment, or incur the risk of being charged with insubordi- 
 " nation, which if proved before the magistrate, will be followed 
 " by corporal punishment, or removal to the service of the
 
 Reformation and Prevejition. 43 
 
 sentation, conveyed in the strongest and most 
 pathetic language, I found in a Hobart-Town 
 newspaper, which was lately transmitted to me. 
 
 " Crown, where his lot will be still more severe according 
 " to the degree and nature of his offences. He has indeed, 
 " by the regulations of the government, sufficient food and 
 " clothing, but the dread of his master's frown is to him, 
 " what the drawn sword was, over the head of Dionysius's 
 " courtier !" — Arthur's Secondary Punishments, p. 3. 
 
 Dr. Ross (p. 56.) adverts, apparently (for I do not very 
 clearly understand him) to some supposed objections to the 
 system such as I should never have suspected any one of 
 urging, and then proceeds to describe the vindictive severity 
 of the punishment. " Is it objected then to the system of 
 " Transportation that it produces in nineteen cases out of 
 " twenty the reform of the convict ? — that it opens the door 
 " for the recovery of character ? — that it converts a body of 
 " men into useful and industrious members of the community, 
 *' honestly obtaining their own support, and contributing their 
 " share to the general stock, whose crimes and propensities 
 " were otherwise a disgrace to their nature and a burden to 
 " the state ? Are we not to urge them to reform, because 
 " reform benefits their condition, and therefore Transportation 
 " will have no terrors to the ill-disposed in England ? Forbid 
 " it reason — forbid it state policy — forbid it common sense — 
 " forbid it humanity ! Virtue when embraced will benefit the 
 " condition of any man — much more that of the wretched 
 " convict whose misery is engendered and aggravated by 
 " vice. And yet we see punishment exists even upon the 
 " reclaimed convict. The weight of condemnation never till
 
 44 Remarks on Transpo?'tation. 
 
 The editor, however, had mcautiously admitted 
 into the sa?ne newspaper an extract from an 
 Enghsh one, containing (what is not unfre- 
 quently met with) an account of some persons 
 who had committed offences purposely for the 
 sake of being transported, because they under- 
 stood that they were hkely to be better off in 
 New South Wales than they could hope to be 
 in England.* I would by no means be under- 
 stood to say that this amounts to a contradiction 
 of the preceding statement. It is certainly con- 
 ceivable (and such is Col. Arthur's distinct and 
 
 " the hour of his death leaves the unhappy man. When 
 " the judge passes the sentence of Transportation he opens 
 " an ulcer in the heart that neither time nor penitence itself 
 " can wholly heal. Nay, the unfortunate heing who has been 
 " innocently convicted (and we have reason to believe there 
 " are many such) still bears the shame upon his head, 
 " though a free pardon should reach him. The royal cle- 
 '• mency may mitigate or wholly emancipate the bondage of 
 " the body, but the liberation of the mind that is once 
 " enthralled by crime and its consequences, is beyond the 
 " reach of mortal means to accomplish. In a word, we can- 
 *' didly assure those in England who are ignorant of the real 
 " condition of the convict in these colonies, that his punish- 
 " ment is as complete as the most severe or even the vindictive 
 *' and unfeeling could desire." 
 * See Appendix, No. II.
 
 Reformation and Prevention. 45 
 
 repeated declaration) that in England comfort 
 and enjoyment are anticipated, and in New South 
 Wales real misery is endured. If such be indeed 
 the case, our system of punishment is, so far, the 
 very consummation of absurdity, as well as inhu- 
 manity. The ground on which, principally, if not 
 exclusively, the infliction of pain is resorted to, ot 
 can be justified, being the prevention of crimes, 
 through the terror of punishment, our system, 
 if its advocates are to be believed, inflicts pain 
 which is even worse than gratuitous ; by sub- 
 jecting convicts to a treatment which, though it 
 is real suffering to them, yet is so much misap- 
 prehended at home, as to invite, instead of deter- 
 ring, those who are at all disposed to follow 
 the same courses. Nay more, the greater the 
 misery actually endured in the colony, the more 
 alluring, it seem.s, is the picture held out in 
 England. If such be the humane systeni of 
 punishment which these gentlemen so earnestly 
 recommend, surely the less we have of such 
 humanity the better. I subjoin some extracts, 
 lest it should be thought absolutely incredible 
 that such statements should have been made by 
 any advocate of Transportation.
 
 46 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 " Convicts, there can be no doubt, occasion- 
 " ally send home flattering accounts of their situ- 
 " ation ; but, in almost every instance within 
 " the last seven years, these have been prompted 
 *' more by the misery of the writers, than from 
 " any undue alleviation of punishment, or other 
 " circumstance affecting them favourably." 
 
 And again : — 
 
 " Many [favourable accounts] have been trans- 
 " mitted by convicts in a very miserable con- 
 " dition, with a view to induce their families to 
 " join them, in the hope that having decoyed 
 " them into a state of much wretchedness, 
 " they might thus excite the compassion of the 
 " government, and, as they selfishly expected, 
 " be assigned to their wives. Some very re- 
 " markable instances of this description have 
 " lately come under my notice." 
 
 And yet according to this very same author, 
 the remoteness from the mother country of these 
 penal settlements, of which such fallacious and 
 favourable accounts are sent home, — this very 
 remoteness is " a great advantage," and tends to 
 increase the terrors of transportation. I should 
 have thought the nearer home the place of
 
 Reformation and Prevention. 47 
 
 punishment was situated, the more difficult it 
 would be to gain credit for these false accounts, 
 and the easier to disprove them. 
 
 " With regard also to the distance of Van 
 " Dieman's land from England, which you sup- 
 " pose renders transportation to it an ineffectual 
 " punishment, I regret that I am obliged to 
 " differ with your Grace, and to assert that it 
 " is, on the contrary, a very great advantage. 
 " Familiarity is the parent of contempt, and if 
 " secondary punishments be inflicted within view 
 " of the community, that part of the population, 
 " on account of which such examples are alone 
 " necessary, will soon learn to disregard them, 
 " however severe they may be. But if, as is 
 " complained by every one, severity is not at- 
 " tributable to them ; and if in many instances 
 " convicts would be better off in the peniten- 
 " tiaries than in their own homes, and if many 
 " persons would in consequence be glad to 
 " change place with criminals undergoing their 
 " sentences, the more secondary punishments 
 " are withdrawn from the public gaze, and the 
 " less intimate the knowledge of them possessed
 
 48 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 " by the community, the greater will be the 
 " chance of a beneficial result." 
 
 I must confess I am myself not disposed to 
 give full credence to these assurances of the 
 miseries endured by the convicts, and of the 
 falsity of their own accounts of their condition. 
 If however Col. Arthur's representation is to be 
 fully relied on, it is hard to imagine any more 
 decisive condemnation of the whole system. If 
 Capt. B. Hall, or any other traveller disposed 
 to take an unfavourable view of the American 
 penitentiaries, could have reported of them that 
 the prisoners suffered such extreme misery as 
 induced them to transmit to their friends (like 
 the fox in the fable) flattering pictures of their 
 comfort and happiness, so as to induce others to 
 endeavour to partake of the same lot, this would 
 have been, I imagine, triumphantly brought 
 forward as a proof that the system was alto- 
 gether a failure. 
 
 One portion of the misery inflicted on a Con- 
 vict (according to Col. Arthur's description in
 
 Demoralhing Effects of the System. 19 
 
 a passage I have already extracted) is his being, 
 on board a transport, " exposed to ill-usage 
 **' from criminals still worse than himself." If a 
 native of this island had ventured to give such 
 a description, he would probably have been 
 asked, whether he intended it to apply to every 
 convict ; and if so, how it could happen that 
 each one of them should meet with " criminals 
 *' worse than himself" 
 
 But though (even when writing in Ireland) 
 I did not go such a length as to suppose that 
 every convict could find a worse, yet I was fully 
 aware that some of them are better than the 
 generality ; and that these would suffipr severely 
 and in more ways than one, by their inter- 
 mixture with "criminals worse than themselves." 
 If Col. Arthur will look to my first Letter to 
 your Lordship, (pp. 15, 16,) he will find that I 
 have by no means overlooked this circumstance, 
 though the inferences I have been led to draw 
 from it are, on the whole, far from bein^ 
 favourable to the system. 
 
 Not however that I would reckon this par- 
 ticular portion of suffering, among those that 
 have no tendency, in any case, towards the 
 
 E
 
 50 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 great object, of prevention. On the contrary, 
 I have no doubt that there are persons, not alto- 
 gether proof against temptation, but of tolerably 
 decent habits, who may be occasionally deterred 
 from crime, by a dread of the disgrace, disgust, 
 and discomfort of being for four or five months 
 in a transport with the most abandoned society. 
 And persons of such a description, who do 
 endure this, suffer nq, doubt very great misery ; 
 so great that some might be disposed to say, it 
 would be, every way, a mercy to hang them 
 instead. The moral death which in all pro- 
 bability must result, is a heavier punishment 
 than physical. And (which is a strong objec- 
 tion to such a kind of punishment) the mischief 
 done far exceeds the pain suffered. The crimes 
 therefore which are in this way prevented (as 
 I have no doubt some few crimes are) will have 
 been prevented at an enormous cost. For it is 
 implied in the very character of the penalty de- 
 nounced, that the majority of the convicts who 
 crowd the transports shall be abandoned ruffians; 
 and that the miseries of this society shall be 
 such as each will feel the less in proportion as 
 his own character is the more depraved, and
 
 Demoralizing Effects qftlie System. 51 
 
 consequently the more needing the restraint of 
 fear to deter him from crime. 
 
 One might indeed almost imagine that a kind 
 of perverse ingenuity had been exercised to 
 devise a system of (so called) penal law, which 
 should combine almost every possible disadvan- 
 tage. Nothing certainly could have been more 
 skilfully contrived to prevent a penalty, in most 
 instances, from either deterring from crime, 
 through the dread of disgrace, or again, re- 
 forming offenders through the influence of good 
 example. Suppose on the one hand, that a 
 criminal were placed in some situation in which 
 he should be constantly surrounded by such 
 as naturally regard him with scorn and abhor- 
 rence ; there would then be this disadvantage 
 indeed, in regard to the individual, that he 
 would be likely to become permanently har- 
 dened, from having been so openly disgraced as 
 to have irretrievably lost his character ; but 
 then, the dread of such disgrace would operate 
 favourably in regard to the prevention of crime. 
 If again, instead of this, he were placed in the 
 society of respectable persons who did fiot know 
 of his delinquency, then, there would indeed 
 
 E 2
 
 52 Remarks on Transjjortation. 
 
 be this disadvantage, that the absence of dis- 
 grace, and the comfort of sympathy and of 
 social intercourse on equal terms, would tend 
 to render such a situation no very formidable 
 punishment : but the reformation of the indi- 
 vidual, who would thus have an opportunity 
 of establishing and maintaining a good cha- 
 racter among his new associates, might be hoped 
 from this plan, if from any. The one in short 
 of these methods, tends to prevention without 
 reformation ; the other to reformation without 
 prevention. 
 
 Now if the problem were proposed, how to 
 combine in the greatest degree, the disadvan- 
 tages, and exclude the advantages, of both these 
 plans, the solution I think would be found in 
 our system of Transportation. 
 
 The convict is shielded as much as possible 
 from the chance of reformation, by unrestricted 
 intercourse with multitudes who are setting him 
 in every possible way, the worst possible ex- 
 amples : who do know his delinquency, but 
 whose sympathy he must earn, — nay, whose 
 ridicule he must escape — by a display of expert 
 roguery and of hardened profligacy ; and again.
 
 Demoralhing Effects of the System. 53 
 
 the terror of disgrace is as much as possible 
 done away, by the offender's removal from the 
 presence of any reputable persons for whom 
 he may feel respect, and placed in a society 
 in which there are abundantly enough to keep 
 him in countenance ; in which not only vice, 
 but convicted criminality, is the rule, and inno- 
 cence the exception. 
 
 No way could I think have been devised 
 more effectual for diverting the penalty, both 
 in prospect of the terror of disgrace, and, in 
 infliction, of all tendency towards reformation. 
 When Shakspeare made the soldier (in *• All's 
 Well that Ends Well,") say to Parolles, " If you 
 *' could find a Country where but women were 
 " that had received so much shame, you might 
 " begin an impudent nation," he little thought 
 probably that in the nineteenth century the 
 experiment would be actually going on. The 
 inipudent nation has been begun some time, 
 and there are abundantly enough in it of 
 ''women who have received so much shame" 
 as to stamp and perpetuate its character : 
 though, for fear it should not increase fast 
 enough, we send out occasionally a few ship-
 
 54 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 loads of young girls not yet corrupted, to supply 
 the deficiency, and to become mothers to the 
 offspring of thieves ! By Lieutenant Breton's 
 account, who (like almost all the authorities I 
 have appealed to) is one of those rather dis- 
 posed to favour the present system, this last- 
 mentioned object seems to be the only benefit, 
 such as it is, likely to be attained by our recent 
 exportations : — 
 
 " Good servants, (says he,) especially those of 
 *•' the gentler sex, are in great request ; those 
 " free women sent out not long since by the 
 " government, have proved no great acquisition, 
 " except by increasing the population. This 
 " is, perhaps, a bold assertion ; but my infor- 
 '* mation proceeds from highly reputable sources. 
 
 " Of the children who were also sent out, 
 " some have conducted themselves well, but 
 " most of them indifferently. 
 
 " It is really inconceivable how difficult it 
 " is to procure steady servants, or work people ; 
 " as they all seem to be of opinion that the 
 " great charm of fife consists in getting drunk 
 " as often as possible ; and unfortunately spirits 
 ** are so cheap that they can constantly indulge
 
 Demoralizing Effects of the System. 55 
 
 " themselves in their inchnation. There are 
 " servants, who, though in every other respect 
 *' most commendable in their conduct, were yet 
 " entirely untrustworthy through this abomin- 
 " able propensity. Such too is the case with 
 " a large proportion of the mechanics, men who 
 " have it in their power to lay by considerable 
 " sums from the profits of their labours, and to 
 " make no contemptible provision for their 
 " famihes ; but who prefer instead, to waste 
 " their substance in inebriation at the public 
 " houses : they seem determined to take no 
 " heed of the morrow, eating and drinking as 
 " much as possible on the one day, for fear, I 
 " presume, of dying on the following !" 
 
 It is perhaps fortunate, if we will but use the 
 lesson before us, that the errors of the present 
 system are so very gross and palpable as they 
 are : — that the rocks on which we have hitherto 
 struck, are above water. We have hence some 
 reason for hoping that we may obtain some 
 different results from steering a different course 
 hereafter. And we have also, to a certain 
 degree, a direction pointed out for that course. 
 A chart of shoals and quicksands is not without
 
 56 Remarhs on Transportation. 
 
 its use ill navigation ; and the plan we have 
 hitherto been pursuing, may, by the rule of 
 contraries, be made to furnish a profitable ex- 
 ample. For there is scarcely a feature in the 
 whole system, — scarcely a part, portion, or 
 circumstance, in the convict's life, which it 
 would not be requisite entirely to reverse, in a 
 well-regulated penitentiary. 
 
 And in no particular does this hold good 
 more strongly than (as I formerly observed) in 
 all that relates to the intercourse of convicts 
 with each other ; which, if left unrestricted 
 during their hours of relaxation, cannot fail to 
 lead to a variety of ill consequences.* 
 
 Under the present system these " hours of 
 *' relaxation " comprehend, in the first instance, 
 the four or five months of the voyage ; in which 
 multitudes are crowded together without em- 
 ployment. Col. Arthur indeed seems to suppose 
 that I attribute some specific effect to the 
 influence of the sea. He observ^es (in p. 2 1 .) 
 " Why, it may be inquired, should association 
 " in a ship be more injurious than association on 
 
 * Sec Appendix, No. III.
 
 Demoi'alhing Effects of the System. 57 
 
 " shore?" Now as I never gave the least hint 
 that I supposed this to be the case, I am not 
 at all ashamed to confess that I know no reason 
 why it should be so. But I will take leave to 
 ask a converse question, which I apprehend is 
 rather more to the purpose ; Why should asso- 
 ciation in a ship be less injurious than on shore ? 
 No one in his senses, I conceive, would doubt 
 that the association of several hundreds of de- 
 praved characters, but of various kinds and 
 degrees of depravity, closely crowded together 
 in a small space, in a building on shore, with- 
 out any employment whatever, for four or five 
 months, but to talk over together their past 
 feats of villany, must be the most corrupting 
 process, to all of them who were not past cor- 
 ruption, that could possibly be devised. It is 
 therefore for the advocates of the present system 
 to shew why the evil should be less on board a 
 ship ; not for me to prove it greater. I advert- 
 ed to the evil tend('!'cy of the voyage, merely 
 because this involves ttie necessity of encoun- 
 tering this evil, which is what no one I suppose 
 would be so insane as to propose introducing 
 gratuitously.
 
 58 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 But this, it seems, is a case in which we are 
 to trust neither reason nor testimony. The 
 statements to which I have referred for the 
 existence of a state of things, such as might 
 have been fully expected from the nature of the 
 case, even independent of any testimony at all, 
 are, we are told, unworthy of credit. Mr. Cun- 
 ningham's work in particular, from which copious 
 extracts are given (though far short of what I 
 might have extracted to the same purpose), in 
 the Appendix to my former Letter, is charac- 
 terised (pp. 22, 23,) in terms which sound indeed 
 exceedingly mild, but which involve a charge of 
 the most wanton, deliberate, and mischievous 
 calumny. 
 
 *' Not having had an opportunity of witness- 
 " ing the condition and conduct of convicts 
 *' previous to their embarkation for this colony, 
 " I am of course unable to institute any com- 
 " parison betwixt their state before their voyage 
 '* and after its conclusion, but I have always 
 " been strongly impressed with the conviction 
 " that very considerable improvements generally 
 " take place. The Surgeons Superintendent are 
 " usually intelligent and experienced officers.
 
 Vindication of Authorities referred to. 59 
 
 " who observe the men under their charge 
 " assiduously, keeping them under the strictest 
 " surveillance ; and Mr. Cunningham's obser- 
 *' vations which your Grace has honoured with 
 " your notice, appear to have been dictated by 
 " a desire rather to produce effect and enliven 
 " his work, than to convey correct information. 
 " His inclination to listen to and relate the 
 " marvellous stories to which he refers, and 
 " his fear lest by coercion he should make 
 " the convicts ' hypocrites,' and his opinion that 
 " it was better to allow them to remain ' open 
 " downright rogues/ seem to indicate that the 
 " discipline which he exercised was not cal- 
 '* culated to produce the very best results, and 
 '' that the men under his charge were not likely 
 " to afford an average example of convicts 
 " when under more serious and more prudent 
 '* management." 
 
 So Mr. Cunningham, it seems, wrote false- 
 hoods for the sake of producing an effect ! 
 Most people I conceive write whatever they 
 do write, with a view to some effect. But let 
 us be permitted to inquire in the present in- 
 stance, what effect? To raise a prejudice against
 
 60 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 the system of Transportation for which he is a 
 decided advocate ? Or was it to gratify and 
 entertain his readers? He must have calculated 
 on readers of a strangely depraved taste, who 
 could take so little interest in being told of the 
 success of measuies designed for the most im- 
 portant and best purposes, and of " very con- 
 " siderable improvements" taking place in a class 
 of men most needing improvement, that it was 
 necessary to fabricate, for the amusement of the 
 public, details of the most abandoned and re- 
 volting villany. 
 
 I have used the word " fabricate," because in 
 the present case the plea of mere exaggeration 
 is of no avail. Let it be supposed that Mr. 
 Cunningham's representation is exaggerated ; — 
 though every conceivable motive would have 
 led him, if not perfectly correct and impartial, 
 to extenuate rather than exaggerate, the evils 
 of the system he advocates : — but let it be sup- 
 posed, in defiance of all probability, and on the 
 strength of Col. Arthur's unsupported accusation, 
 that the picture is overcharged : and then let 
 any one read, both what is extracted in my 
 former Letter from the work in question and from
 
 Vindication of Authorities referred to. (> 1 
 
 others, and also, the other portions of these 
 works that are there referred to ; and let him 
 ask himself whether my conclusions are not 
 fully borne out, if even the half of these state- 
 ments be credited. 
 
 There may be found persons indeed (though 
 not so many I conceive now, as a few years 
 back) who suspect that in all points the un- 
 favourable representations of the penalty of 
 Transportation have been overcharged ; — that 
 its effect in deterring offenders has been ex- 
 tenuated, and the temptations it holds out, and 
 the corruption it produces, exaggerated. To 
 such persons it might indeed fairly be replied, 
 that I have every reason to believe I have 7iot 
 misrepresented its advantages and disadvantages; 
 having not only made careful inquiries, but ab- 
 stained from giving as shocking a picture of the 
 operation of the present system as I believe 
 might be given consistently with truth ; choosing 
 to confine myself chiefly to the testimony of 
 those who not only have had the best oppor- 
 tunities of observation, but also are avowedly 
 favourable to that system. This, I say, might 
 fairly be urged in reply to the objection ; but I
 
 62 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 am content to waive that plea. The case is so 
 strong that it can well aiford it. We need not 
 join issue on the question, whether the picture 
 presented be minutely accurate or not. Let any 
 one be left to allow for all the exaggeration that 
 can be thought conceivable, and to suppose the 
 evils of the system to be considerably less than 
 they are represented, and the advantages greater. 
 The conclusion, I think, would still be, to any 
 candid and considerate mind, the very same. 
 There are extreme cases, and this I think is 
 one of them, in which no allowance that can 
 reasonably be made for want of strict accuracy, 
 will perceptibly affect the result. It would not 
 be the "easier for a camel to go through the 
 "eye of a needle" if the camel were half the 
 usual size, and the needle's eye double. And 
 in this case the evils which I have pointed out 
 (though I have passed over no small part) are 
 so multifarious and monstrous, and the ad- 
 vantages so extremely minute, that if the one 
 were only half what they are and the other 
 double, I could not hesitate about coming to 
 the same conclusion. 
 
 Indeed I have sometimes been disposed to
 
 Vindication of Authorities referred to. 63 
 
 doubt whether the number and variety of the 
 arguments on this question which are comprised 
 in the former Letter and in this, may not pre- 
 vent their being by some minds, duly appreciated. 
 For there are persons who when an accumu- 
 lation of reasons is presented to them, are apt 
 to take for granted that all, or nearly all of 
 them together, are necessary to establish the 
 conclusion ; and consequently if one or two of 
 these shall have been apparently refuted, they 
 regard this as a sufficient answer : though per- 
 haps (as in the present case) there may be 
 several other reasons, each of which would, 
 alone, establish the conclusion. — Sometimes 
 also even the very weight of the reasons urged, 
 will, with some minds, diminish their effect. If 
 a system, for instance, which has been adopted 
 and persevered in (as that of Transportation) 
 shall be proved not merely to be objectionable, 
 but to involve the most extravagant absurdity, 
 many are apt to infer that there must be some 
 (they know not what) strong recommendations 
 to counterbalance these ; or some lurking fal- 
 lacy, though they cannot perceive any, in the 
 arguments against the system, since a mere tissue
 
 64 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 of palpable errors could never, they think, have 
 obtained any countenance : forgetting that the 
 errors become palpable, only when clearly pointed 
 out ; and that there is no absurdity so gross 
 which even intelligent men have not readily ac- 
 quiesced in, when their attention has not been 
 directed to the question. 
 
 But so sensible are the defenders of the 
 system of the overvvhelmino; mass of evidence 
 against them, that they ieei it necessary, instead 
 of descending to particulars, and attempting 
 disproof, boldly to deny the whole, by sweeping, 
 unsupported assertions. The sixth, out of no 
 less than eleven statements drawn up in formi- 
 dable array (in pp. 3, 4, 5, of Col. Arthur's Let- 
 ter) is that *'the atrocities to which you have 
 " referred do not exist." For a iwooj of this and 
 of several other no less bold assertions, I have 
 turned over every page, again and again, in vain. 
 And this being the case, I should perhaps have 
 thought it unnecessary to notice it, could I have 
 been sure that no one would glance at that page 
 on opening the pamphlet, or perhaps meet with 
 it along with some other such extracts in a 
 newspaper, and then inquire no further, but take
 
 Vindication of AutJwrities referred to. Gb 
 
 for granted that the evidence for so bold a state- 
 ment at the opening of the work, must be sup- 
 plied in the subsequent pages. 
 
 Had I given an ideal picture of atrocities such 
 as I conceived likely to exist, without any evi- 
 dence beyond antecedent conjecture, a simple 
 denial might have been admitted as an answer. 
 But besides Mr. Cunningham's testimony (and 
 that of several others) I adduced that of Mr. 
 Rutherford, who had sailed seven times in con- 
 vict-ships in the same capacity as the former, — 
 that of Superintendant Surgeon. " These are" 
 (says Col. A. himself,) " usually intelligent ex- 
 " perienced officers, who observe the men under 
 "their charge assiduously," &c. — P. 22. Was it 
 wonderful then that I should give some credit to 
 the statements of such men, when every proba- 
 bility was in favour of its correctness ? I will 
 take leave to add, that I still give credit to their 
 evidence, because it was uncontradicted till there 
 was a 'particular purpose to be served by the 
 denial. 
 
 It is about four years since the article ap- 
 peared, in the London Review, on the second 
 edition of Mr. Cunningham's book. Other 
 
 F
 
 66 Remarks on Traiwportation. 
 
 evidence to the same effect had been still longer 
 before the public. Why then did no one, long 
 ago, step forth to denounce these witnesses as 
 pernicious slanderers ; which they must be, if 
 their statements are untrue? Why did those 
 wiio had the best opportunities of knowing the 
 truth, suffer such malicious misrepresentations 
 to circulate, all that time, uncontradicted ? The 
 answer is obvious : Because the inferences from 
 these had not from the first been insisted on, 
 and pressed on the public attention. As soon 
 as the conclusions are drawn, then it is that it is 
 found out, for the first time, that the premises 
 are false. The evidence, it seems, might have 
 remained for ever uncontradicted had not I 
 and others pointed out the obvious deductions 
 from it. 
 
 And, why again, is there, even now, no dis- 
 proof offered of this evidence ? — no attempt to 
 impugn it except by bare unsupported denial ? 
 The obvious answer is. Because it is true ; too 
 true to be disproved ; and yet too conclusive to 
 be admitted. 
 
 Some of these denials do in themselves sound 
 rather strangely : — " That little additional con-
 
 Alledged Omissioti of' Religious Motives. 61 
 
 " tamination is contracted by any at that time is 
 " almost proved by the circumstance that the farm 
 " labom'ers sometimes sent out for rioting and ma- 
 " chine breaking retain for the most part on their 
 "arrival their original simplicity, and a dispo- 
 " sition to conduct themselves honestly." — P. 22. 
 That the " original simplicity " which consists in 
 a disposition to riot and outrage, is retained, I 
 have little doubt : of the general honesty of the 
 convict-servants Capt. Breton and others give 
 a different and I should fear a more correct 
 account. 
 
 My exposure however of the demoralizing 
 effects of our present system, both on the Co- 
 lony and on the Mother Country, Archdeacon 
 Broughton meets (p. 85.) by an answer which 
 greatly surprised me : — an insinuation that I 
 deprecate or overlook the moral effect of reli- 
 gious principle, in diminishing crime ; and that I 
 am proposing a system of punishments to super- 
 sede the fear of God ! At least if such be not 
 his meaning (though the general courteous and 
 candid tone of his Letter is greatly at variance 
 
 F 2
 
 GS Remarks on Transimrtation. 
 
 with it) I cannot conceive what it is he does 
 mean. 
 
 After premising (p. 84.) his view of " the 
 " substance of my argument, that crimes have 
 " increased because Transportation has lost its 
 " terrors " (which by the way is totally unlike any 
 thing I ever did say ; for I have never implied that 
 it ever had any terrors to lose) he proceeds: — 
 " At the risk of being thought to make the 
 '' observation out of place, I will, nevertheless, 
 " state my opinion, that the very prevalent decay 
 " of faith in the truths of religion, and a propor- 
 " tionate abatement of its influence, are the 
 '' chief causes of that rapid increase of crime 
 " which we witness and deplore. 
 
 *' I do not introduce this as a mere customary 
 "■ common-place remark, which it might be un- 
 " becoming my situation to omit : but because 
 " I sincerely feel the subject in this point of 
 '' view has not been duly pressed upon the 
 " attention of those whose office it is to con- 
 "■' suit for the public security ; and that the 
 " theory of the Archbishop of Dublin has a 
 " tendency to sanction and confirm the pre- 
 " vailing error. His Grace appears to maintain.
 
 AUedged Omission of Religious Motives. 69 
 
 " that all our distress arises from our having 
 " chosen the wrong preventive ; but that, by 
 ** trying various experiments in secondary pun- 
 '* ishments, ' there can be little doubt that in 
 " the course of a very few years we should be 
 " enabled, by attentive observation, to ascertain 
 " what system worked best:' assuming that there 
 " is a system of mere legal coercion discoverable, 
 " which may greatly abate if not wholly eradi- 
 " cate the disease. Now, whatever may be the 
 " deserved character of transportation, and ad- 
 " mitting it for argument's sake to be as excep- 
 " tionable as it is represented, I have the 
 '' strongest conviction on my mind that no 
 '' substitution of another mode of punishment 
 " will operate perceptibly in lessening the amount 
 " of crime ; but that the same result will con- 
 " tinue if that substitution be the ojily change. 
 " In common with the Archbishop of Dublin, 
 " I have been in charge of parishes in Eng- 
 " land, and my experience has taught me that 
 " the relaxation of morality prevailing there 
 " has arisen, not from the inefficiency of any 
 " particular mode of punishment, but from a 
 " diminished prevalence of the fear of God.
 
 70 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 " So long as that fear governed the general 
 " mind of the nation, the dread of legal inflic- 
 " tions, coming in as a secondary restraint in 
 '' aid of that which was more prevalent and 
 " formidable, was quite sufficient to curb vio- 
 " lence and dishonesty, and to enforce a tole- 
 " rable regard for hfe and property. But so 
 ** soon as the barriers of the law are exposed, 
 " as is the case at present, to the whole rush 
 " and pressure of men's unruly appetites, those 
 '* barriers will inevitably bend and give way ; 
 " and the wave, if excluded at one point, will 
 '' come pouring through with greater impetu- 
 " osity at another. I candidly confess, that the 
 " absence of all regard or reference to this cause 
 " of the prevalence of crime, appears to me the 
 " leading defect of Archbishop Whately's publi- 
 " cation. It is an omission which could not 
 " have been looked for in the work of a di- 
 " vine ; and unless it be taken into consideration, 
 " he will greatly mislead those who follow him 
 '' as a jurist and a politician." — P. 85 — 87. 
 
 This most extraordinary passage contains 
 some positions and insinuations which to say 
 the least are extremely rash. To the British
 
 Alledged Omission of Religious Motives. 7 1 
 
 Public, and I may add, the American, (though 
 probably not the Australian) I have been for 
 about twelve years, not unknown as a writer ; 
 chiefly on religious subjects ; and those treated 
 practically and popularly. I have been occupied 
 chiefly, not in abstruse dissertations on points 
 interesting only to deep theologians, but on the 
 application of religion to moral conduct. And 
 especially I have laboured to counteract the bad 
 impression that such weak and absurd views of 
 rehgion as are often to be met with, may make 
 on the minds of ordinary readers ; not only of 
 those who reject but of those also who admit 
 such views. For I have long been convinced 
 that nothing tends so much to bring Christianity 
 into contempt, as the representations which some 
 of its professors give both of its doctrines and 
 of its application. Sceptics are apt to forget, 
 that where the generality of men are Christians, 
 it must be expected that a considerable portion 
 of Christians (and not a few even of Christian 
 writers') should be weak men ; whose religious 
 views will naturally partake of their own con- 
 fusion of thought. To judge therefore of the 
 character of the Religion itself, from the repre-
 
 72 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 sentations given of it, by such feeble advocates, is 
 no less unreasonable than to estimate the bright- 
 ness of the sun by viewing it through a smoked 
 glass. 
 
 Although, however, I could hardly expect to 
 be much known as an author, in a colony so 
 distant, (and, I may add, so constituted,) it 
 ought to have been supposed, in charity, that 
 I should not have omitted any religious topic 
 that might appear relevant to the question I was 
 treating of. But what would be thought of a 
 physician, who, in treating of some disease, — 
 suppose cholera, — and defending the practice of 
 a particular hospital against objections, should 
 reply, — " At the risk of being thought to make 
 the observation out of place, I will nevertheless 
 state my opinion, that a very prevalent decay of 
 health, and the proportionate abatement of the 
 injluence of the vital principle, are the chief 
 causes of that rapid increase of disease which 
 we witness and deplore ? " He would be 
 answered (if at all) by saying, that his obser- 
 vation was indeed quite ''out of place:" the 
 question being, by what mode of treatment 
 we were to increase or restore the influence
 
 Alledged Omission of Religious Motives. 73 
 
 of the vital principle, — prevent or remedy the 
 decay of health, — and stop the progress of in- 
 fection. 
 
 If I had introduced some observations analo- 
 gous to the above, either " as a mere customary 
 " common-place remark, which it might be unbe- 
 " coming my situation to omit," or as solemnly 
 announcing the discovery, that the relaxation of 
 morality arises from a diminution of the fear of 
 God, I might have been answered, " How are we 
 the wiser for your telling us of the disease, without 
 suggesting a remedy ? That men who fear God 
 as they ought will not commit crimes, we knew 
 before ; but are you proposing an act of parlia- 
 ment to compel men to fear God ? Or have you 
 any plan for so promoting religious faith as to 
 do away all need for punishment ? Or do you 
 hold that all kinds of punishment are equally 
 efficacious, or equally inefficacious, in promoting 
 or in discouraging such conduct as religion for- 
 bids ? If all punishments are useless, let all be 
 abolished : if all are equally proper, let things 
 remain as they are : or if it is possible the system 
 may be improved, let inquiries and suggestions 
 be made with a view to improvement : but do
 
 74 Remarks on Transjyortation. 
 
 not pretend to have set at rest a practical question 
 of legislation, by solemnly pronouncing a truism 
 on which you do not yourself propose to found 
 any legislative measure." 
 
 Your Lordship may remember that I began 
 my former Letter by complaining, in the capacity 
 of a religious and moral teacher, of the injury 
 done to morality, by a system which tends 
 rather to encourage than to deter criminals, by 
 holding out no penalty calculated to counter- 
 balance the force of temptation. And I subse- 
 quently dwelt on the several parts of that 
 system, shevv^ing, both from reason and from 
 experience, its tendency to corrupt rather than 
 reform convicts, and to demoralize both the 
 Colony and the Parent-state. I was well aware, 
 indeed, that there are persons whose rehgious 
 principle will preserve them from being led into 
 crime by external circumstances ; and others, 
 whom no external circumstances will deter from 
 it when opportunity offers. But surely it will 
 not be maintained that all mankind belong to 
 one or other of these two classes. It is with 
 a view, almost entirely, to those of an interme- 
 diate character, and consequently capable of being
 
 Alleclged Omission of Religious Motives. 75 
 
 deterred from crime, and needing to be deterred, 
 that every community has had recourse to the 
 denunciation of penalties. 
 
 But though the demorahzing effects of our 
 system are what I have been so far from over- 
 looking, that I have chiefly dwelt on them, it 
 may be expected that a defender of that system, 
 who charges me with looking solely to the 
 " dread of legal inflictions," and disregarding 
 the influence of rehgion, — that such a defender 
 should see in the system, (however defective in 
 other points,) at least an efficient provision for 
 producing and keeping up the fear of God. Let 
 us hear what he himself says on this point. 
 
 " Upon the whole, I must say, that if there 
 ** be no more serious objection to transportation 
 *' than the moral injury which the voyage occa- 
 " sions to the prisoners, very little stress can be 
 " laid upon this. Under the care of a vigilant 
 " and judicious surgeon, or of a clergyman, if 
 " there be one on board, they may not only be 
 '* restrained from going deeper into vice, but 
 " some of the number may be even instructed 
 " and improved."— P. 103. 
 
 It seems, then, that if there be a clergyman
 
 76 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 on board the transport, or if the surgeon be 
 vigilant and judicious, some of the convicts may 
 possibly improve. " Your IF is a great peace- 
 maker." * 
 
 But let us follow the convicts to the settle- 
 ment. There at least, we may expect to find 
 ample means provided for the religious improve- 
 ment of all classes. 
 
 " You will remember the occasion, not long 
 
 * To any one who wishes to know, without " ifs " or 
 " mays," something of the actual condition of convicts on 
 board a transport, I would recommend, if he be not resolved 
 to set testimony at defiance, to peruse an account, subjoined 
 in the Appendix, No. IV., of the wretched beings wrecked in 
 the Amphitrite. But the Archdeacon himself gives the sum of 
 what is there more fully detailed, in a brief statement of his 
 own. " I have conversed very extensively with the more 
 " respectable among the prisoners, and from a comparison 
 " between their statements, I am led to believe, that even 
 " while the outward conduct is brought to a forced regularity, 
 " great depravity does prevail in that class of prisoners : such 
 " as to render the association to which they are condemned 
 " exceedingly painful to men who have any sentiment of 
 " religion, or any remaining decency of character."— rP. 108. 
 In fact there is hardly a statement I have made or a conclusion I 
 have drawn in my former Letter that is not, after having been 
 vehemently denied by one or more of these authors, fully and 
 distinctly confirmed by their own testimony.
 
 Alledged Omission of Religious Motives. 77 
 
 " passed, of our visiting a very numerous road 
 " party, before whom I performed divine service, 
 '' and you will testify, I think, that there could 
 " not possibly be a congregation displaying more 
 " fixed attention than these men, who continued 
 " standing during the prayers and sermon. I 
 " have not myself any such suspicion, but it 
 " mif^ht enter the minds of others, that the 
 " knowledge of your being present produced 
 " all this seriousness. But the many scores, 
 " perhaps hundreds, of occasions in which, in 
 '' travelling through the country, I have offici- 
 " ated with exactly the same result, to prisoners 
 " belonging to private estabhshments, or to 
 " pubhc road parties, and when there could be 
 *' no such cause assigned for their attentive 
 " demeanour, forbid my thinking it other than 
 " sincere and unaffected. 
 
 " The general lament among road parties in 
 " the interior of New South Wales, I have found 
 " to be the infrequency with which they are 
 " visited by a clergyman. In every such assem- 
 '' blage I have observed many who evidently 
 " prayed with inward fervency ; and my per- 
 " suasion is, that some good is effected, and
 
 78 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 " some comfort administered, on every such 
 " occasion ; nor can I despair of the condition 
 " of men among whom I find so much thank- 
 " fulness to the preacher for his services, and so 
 " much respect shown to him in consequence. 
 " It is not possible that visits so rare and casual 
 *' should generally produce any other than a 
 " transient impression. Indeed the best im- 
 " pressions, in every case, are produced, not by 
 " a clergyman preaching once and then going 
 *' on his way, but by his living and abiding 
 " among the people, and affording them oppor- 
 " tunity of seeing his life, and knowing how 
 " far he practises what he preaches. I feel 
 " assured, that if it were possible to have 
 " among the prisoners a number of clergymen 
 " stationed, so that every large assemblage of 
 ** them might know their own minister, and see 
 " him day by day labouring for their improve- 
 " ment, the effect would be truly beneficial. It 
 " would be difficult, but surely not impossible, 
 " to find men duly qualified, both by piety and 
 " discretion, who would devote themselves to 
 " this work. And, indeed, when I reflect that 
 " the nation which discharges annually so many
 
 Alledged Omission of Religious Motives. 79 
 
 " thousands of offenders from its shores, makes 
 " not the shghtest direct effort for their rehgious 
 " instruction in the colonies, I can find no argu- 
 *' ment which satisfies me, that such omission 
 " does not amount to even a national sin." — 
 Pp. 109, 110. 
 
 The Archdeacon then is aware, it seems, how 
 little opportunity is offered, even to those who 
 may be the most ready to receive religious in- 
 struction ; and how " transient must be the 
 " impression " produced by any means now in 
 operation : but, then, he thinks that " if it were 
 *' possible" completely to change the existing 
 state of things, good would result. 
 
 Just so, / think. 
 
 But is this, then, let us ask, — is this the best 
 conclusion we can arrive at, by " duly pressing 
 " on the attention," as the chief cause of crime, 
 the decay of religious faith and fear ? If I, it 
 seems, had sufficiently attended to this point, 
 I should have kept clear of the danger of " mis- 
 " leading those who follow" me, and should have 
 advocated a system, which does indeed leave the 
 rehgious condition of the convicts, and of the 
 colony generally, in the most deplorable state ;
 
 so Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 but which might, if it were quite different from 
 what it is, or has any prospect of becoming, be 
 made " truly beneficial." 
 
 As I feel persuaded of the sincere good inten- 
 tions of the Archdeacon, I trust he will pardon 
 my regretting that he did not read over the 
 earlier part of his letter, (which, in that case, 
 I feel sure he would have erased,) before he 
 permitted the latter part to go to press. 
 
 Enough, your Lordship will perhaps think, if 
 not more than enough, has been already said, 
 in this and in the former Letter, to convince all 
 who are not resolved never to be convinced, of 
 the mischievous tendency, in all points of view, 
 of our present system. But I cannot refrain 
 from appealing to one authority on my side, 
 which is entitled to more weight in the present 
 question than that of Bacon, or of any of the 
 illustrious of sages besides ; — that of Col. Arthur 
 himself : who has pronounced the most decided 
 condemnation of the whole of our scheme of 
 colonizing with convicts. 
 
 This assertion may startle many of my readers.
 
 The System condemned hy its Advocates. 8 1 
 
 and perhaps none more than the Colonel him- 
 self, who is evidently quite unconscious of the 
 tendency of his own admissions. But I will 
 proceed to make good my words : — 
 
 "Lord Bacon's declaration, to which I have 
 " already referred, has much force in it, as ap- 
 " plicable to the period in which he wrote. It 
 " is, as your Grace quotes him, ' a shameful and 
 " unblessed thing to take the scum of people 
 " and wicked condemned men to be those with 
 " whom you plant.' There was in his time an 
 " abundant field for labour in England, and the 
 " inducements to commit crime were not power- 
 " ful. The citizen and the husbandman could 
 " by industry bring up their families in inde- 
 " pendence and afford them an honest example. 
 ** If they were compelled to obtain their bread 
 " by the sweat of their brows, they were also 
 " happily enabled to mingle with every drop of 
 " that sweat, blessed ideas of virtue and inde- 
 " pendence. The population had not then out- 
 " grown the means of employment, and he who 
 " committed crime, and persevered in it, could 
 " not plead as his excuse the cravings of hunger 
 " or the effect of habits derived from the example
 
 82 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 " of his parents, and the teaching of his fel- 
 " lows. To plant new lands with such charac- 
 " ters, would therefore, it was reasonable to 
 " suppose, be unsuccessful. The change effected 
 " by transportation, so far as they were con- 
 " cerned, would be one merely of place, not of 
 " circumstances. The advantages of labour 
 " would not be much greater in the colony than 
 *^ at home, and they therefore who had acted 
 " unblessedly there, were likely to continue so 
 " to do in their new places of abode." — P. 41. 
 
 Bacon's decision, then, against Colonies thus 
 stocked, is admitted to be just, in respect to the 
 state of things, hi his time. Let this be kept in 
 mind. 
 
 He would (Colonel Arthur conceives) have 
 judged differently in respect of a country less 
 prosperous, as far as regards the situation of the 
 labouring classes, than England then was. Had 
 he lived to see a great change for the worse 
 in this point, he might, it is supposed, have 
 approved of the system he then condemned. 
 I myself do not think he would. But let it be 
 supposed : for it is not at all material to the 
 argument. The average condition of an indus-
 
 The System condemned by its Advocates. 83 
 
 trious labourer in England is not worse, but 
 better than in Bacon's time ; so that whatever 
 reasons justified, in Col. Arthur's opinion, his 
 disapproval of Convict Colonies then, exist in 
 at least equal force now. 
 
 As to the fact, Col. Arthur has been misled, 
 apparently, by looking only to the absolute 
 increase of population ; which is indeed greater 
 in proportion to the size of the country, than 
 when Bacon wrote ; but (which alone is the 
 important point) less in proportion to the na- 
 tional loealth. In particular that portion of it 
 which constitutes the fund for maintenance of 
 labourers, is greatly increased in proportion to 
 their numbers, since that period. Estimated 
 even in wheat, the week's wages of a common 
 labourer seems to have been, in Bacon's time, 
 equal to about from three to four pecks ; now, 
 to about five to six. In articles of clothing and 
 most other manufactured commodities, the dis- 
 parity is well known to be very much greater, 
 in consequence of the improvements in ma- 
 chinery. 
 
 Since then, a Convict Colony was, as Col. 
 Arthur admits, " a shameful and unblessed 
 
 G 2
 
 84 Remark,'} on Transportation. 
 
 thing " in the days of Lord Bacon, much more 
 so must it be in these days. 
 
 I myself believe Bacon's objection to have 
 been of much greater extent than is supposed 
 by Col. Arthur : but, even according to his own 
 view of it, he is driven unconsciously to give 
 sentence of utter condemnation on the system 
 he advocates. 
 
 A still more strange mistake however, relative 
 to a matter of fact, seems to have been made by 
 Capt. Basil Hall, if his evidence before a Com- 
 mittee of the House of Commons be correctly 
 reported. That gentleman, who is described 
 by Col. Arthur (p. 9.) as taking " rather a favour- 
 ** able view of the prison-discipline in America," 
 but who is generally considered as rather lean- 
 ing towards an w/zfavourable view of all American 
 institutions, is reported as having heard many 
 Americans regret their zvant of penal colonies, 
 and as describing the " evil arising out of this 
 " singular state of things." So the Americans, it 
 seems, are singular in the absence of penal 
 colonies ; I had always thought the singularity 
 lay with us. If Capt. Hall really did persuade 
 any of the back-wood settlers in the United
 
 Vague Sup2)osition of Advantages. 85 
 
 States, that all the nations of Christendom, ex- 
 cept themselves, had penal colonies, he must 
 have used the traveller's privilege v^^ith a boldness 
 and a success truly astonishing. 
 
 The intelhgent Commissioners whom the 
 French Government sent out to inspect the 
 American system of secondary punishments, 
 have made some brief remarks (which I subjoin in 
 the Appendix, No. V.) in a very calm and tempe- 
 rate tone, on our singular state of things. From 
 what they say, and from other considerations, 
 it may, I think, be anticipated, that if we per- 
 severe much longer in adhering to a system 
 which has of late been so fully exposed, our 
 legislature will become, not undeservedly, the 
 scorn of the civihzed world. 
 
 But the present system has sometimes, I am 
 inclined to think, been even the more readily 
 tolerated in the minds of some persons, from 
 the very enormity and the palpable character of 
 the mischiefs and absurdities which it involves ; 
 which must, it is thought, be counterbalanced 
 by some very great advantages : and these
 
 86 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 accordingly are taken for granted as existing, 
 even by many who would be at a loss to de- 
 scribe and estimate them ; but who conclude 
 that it is impossible a scheme should have been 
 persevered in for near half a century, in spite of 
 so many and such monstrous attendant evils, 
 were it not found to produce some important 
 benefits as a compensation. 
 
 And perhaps they are right in thus conjec- 
 turing that there are advantages ; but I would 
 caution them not to rest satisfied with this 
 consideration, till they have ascertained to whom 
 the advantages accrue : — to the public, or to 
 individuals, at the expense of the public. A 
 conflagration is a benefit — to firemen : a ship- 
 wreck is a benefit — to those on whose shore the 
 wreck is cast : a general mortality is an advan- 
 tage — to undertakers and sextons : and I have 
 no doubt that our system of Transportation has 
 its advantages (in the way of present projii) — to 
 many who are engaged in the agriculture and 
 commerce of New South Wales, or, in other 
 ways, employed in connexion with our penal
 
 Apparent Benefit to Individuals. 87 
 
 colonies. And this, I suspect, constitutes one 
 great obstacle to our immediate abandonment 
 of the system. 
 
 I do not mean to impute to its advocates a 
 deliberate design to sacrifice the public good to 
 the private interests of themselves or their 
 friends. But it is proved by all experience 
 (especially in the history of every monopoly) 
 that in such cases men are apt to impose on 
 themselves, as well as on others, by confounding 
 together and identifying their own interests or 
 those of the class they belong to, with the 
 interest of the community. Whatever is a profit 
 or loss to themselves, they would be glad to 
 think must be the same to the nation ; and they 
 therefore endeavour (generally with success) to 
 convince both the nation and themselves that 
 this is the case. 
 
 Accordingly we find Col. Arthur (pp. 58, 59,) 
 placing at the end of a long list of the advan- 
 tages of the Transportation-system, those sup- 
 posed commercial benefits, which I believe to 
 have, in practice, the most weight in the defence 
 of that system. The other heads relate to 
 matters already discussed, and which therefore
 
 88 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 T need not again notice more particularly : such 
 as the utility of Transportation in the prevention 
 of crime, by the dread of the penalty — by the 
 removal of criminals (viz. from one part of the 
 empire to another,) — by the reformation of offen- 
 ders, &c. &c. ; in all which points he meets the 
 arguments and the testimonies already adduced 
 in my former Letter, by unsupported assertions. 
 But the enumeration of advantages concludes 
 M^ith — 
 
 " 7. An extension of the empire by the crea- 
 " tion of colonies possessed by free men, whose 
 " emigration is encouraged by convict assign- 
 " ment, and for whom the convicts have acted 
 " as pioneers." 
 
 " 8. An increase of the exports and imports 
 " of England." 
 
 " Aye, there's the rub!" Besides the great 
 object of extending the empire (like the exten- 
 sion of a human body by the growth of some 
 wen or other morbid and monstrous excres- 
 cence) there is the encouragement of settlers, by 
 the advantage of convict-assignment; and the 
 increase of commerce. 
 
 No doubt agriculture and commerce are good
 
 Apparent Benefit to Individuals. 89 
 
 things : but gold may be bought too dear. Let 
 any one but take the pains to calculate the 
 total net profits of the " increased exports and 
 " imports of England," and compare this sum 
 with the mere cost to the nation (waiving all 
 other evils) of keeping up the whole establish- 
 ment for the supply of this slave-labour ; and 
 then let him compute how far the one over- 
 balances the other. 
 
 In this, and in numberless other cases, the 
 paradoxical appearance which such computa- 
 tions will often present, is explained by the 
 consideration, that the loss goes to one party, and 
 the gain to another. It is Government that 
 bears the expenses; they fall on the commu- 
 nity : the profits go to the individual settlers, 
 traders, &c. and the total gain thus occurring 
 to the nation, may be utterly inadequate to 
 the outlay, and yet may be a very important 
 and desirable object to individuals on whom 
 this outlay does not fall.* 
 
 * And yet it seems the expenditure is not sufficient, even 
 in Col. Arthur's own judgment, to render Transportation effi- 
 cacious, for its professed primary object as a penalty. " I 
 " admit that the condition of these men, (the educated
 
 90 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 But surely those who are deliberating with a 
 view to the public good, ought in all cases to be 
 very cautious in admitting the evidence of inte- 
 rested individuals, whose private advantage is 
 not (though they wish to persuade both others 
 and themselves that it is) necessarily coincident 
 with advantage to the public. Much greater 
 however should be our caution in respect of 
 individuals whose interest (as in the present 
 
 " convicts and specials) though by no means so desirable as 
 " it has been represented in England, has not heretofore cor- 
 " responded with that of other convicts. In fact the only 
 " hindrance in the colony to the perfecting of Transportation, 
 " as a measure of prevention, has had reference to expendi- 
 "' ture. The economy so much insisted upon in the present 
 " day, has led to the employment of educated convicts as 
 " clerks in public offices, and of expirees and emancipists as 
 " inferior overseers, an incidental not necessary adjunct of the , 
 " transport system, originating in motives of economy, but 
 " attended by injurious consequences — consequences which 
 " however have been much exaggerated." — Pp. 52, 53. 
 
 That a little less attention to economy would remove " the 
 " only hindrance to 'the perfecting of Transportation," is 
 indeed a most rash conjecture : but many plans of wasteful 
 expenditure (like that of the penal colonies) are conducted 
 in detail with a penurious spirit which vainly seeks to re- 
 medy, by petty savings the ruinous extravagance of the 
 system.
 
 Apparent Benefit to Individuals. 91 
 
 case) is manifestly and avowedly opposed to that 
 of the public. 
 
 The Australian settlers conceive themselves 
 to derive a very great advantage from the 
 convict-labour.* Any thing whatever that may 
 tend to diminish this source of profit, they 
 
 * *' In the Swan River settlement," says Col. Arthur, " the 
 " scarcity of labourers arising from the absence of convicts will 
 " compel all but the most opulent to work for themselves. 
 " Many an educated man and delicate female will have cause 
 " to regret the arrangement which deprives them of the 
 " advantage of having convicts assigned to them. It is to 
 " deficiency of labour that the rusticity of the Americans, 
 " most remarkable in the states where there are no slaves, is 
 " to be attributed, rather than to the thin sprinkling of gen- 
 " tlemen of birth among the first emigrants. And the great 
 " progress in the arts of life and in that decent and orderly 
 " way of living which is so generally to be observed in this 
 " colony, may with everj- truth be attributed to the advan- 
 " tage derived from its being a penal settlement." — P. 45. 
 
 As for the superior gentility of the New South Wales set- 
 tlements there may be different opinions. I should myself in 
 choosing a residence prefer the " rusticity " of a country in 
 which slavery of all kinds is unknown. • But those who are 
 accustomed to be served by slaves, probably think otherwise. 
 Surely this is a reason for us to receive with suspicion their 
 testimony in favour of a system, which secures to them ad- 
 vantages highly prized by them, but which may be purchased 
 at the expense of too great sacrifice on our part.
 
 92 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 naturally deprecate ; whatever tends to increase 
 the number of convicts is for their gain. Here 
 then is a class of men (we will suppose them 
 to be, individually, as respectable characters as 
 other settlers elsewhere) who have avowedly an 
 interest in keeping up, not whatever may appear 
 the best system of secondary punishment, but 
 the best for them. Nay, they have a direct 
 and manifest interest in the increase of crime. ^ 
 And is it on the evidence of these men that we 
 are implicitly to rely, in an inquiry as to the 
 
 * The leading article in the " Sydney Herald" of May last, 
 in adverting to my former Letter, expresses apprehensions 
 that my " view of prison-discipline, which is diametrically 
 *' opposed to the present system, may probably operate against 
 " the advantages of 'prison-labour which we have hitherto 
 " enjoyed" 
 
 I should be sorry to interfere with their enjoyments, how- 
 ever I might differ in point of taste, were I not convinced 
 that they are purchased at too great a cost of evil as well as 
 expense to this country. 
 
 The projected new settlement in the southern part of New 
 Holland is on a plan designed to obviate some of the evils, 
 from which that at Swan River has suffered, without intro- 
 ducing those far heavier ones resulting from the introduction 
 of convicts or any other description of slaves. I have sub- 
 joined in the Appendix, No. VI. an extract from the Pro- 
 spectus.
 
 Interests of the Colony preferred to ours. 93 
 
 most efficient system of punishments ? " For 
 fortifying a city," said the tanner, *' there is 
 nothing hke leather." 
 
 I repeat, that I am not attributing dishonest 
 motives to any individual. All who have 
 written on this question, may, for aught I know, 
 be as unconscious of any undue bias as I am 
 myself. But it is undeniable that there is, in 
 interested persons, a liability to such a bias ; and 
 that we are bound in prudence to make allow- 
 ance for its existence. 
 
 I am very far myself indeed from thinking, 
 that real, ultimate good, in the most compre- 
 hensive sense, accrues to the Colony from its 
 being stocked with " wicked condemned men ;"* 
 but present gain to many individuals does : and 
 this most men are apt to pursue in preference 
 to the ultimate and permanent benefit of them- 
 selves and their posterity. 
 
 The settlers accordingly, and others con- 
 nected with the Colony, led by a sort of pa- 
 triotic feeling for that Colony, to plead the cause 
 * See Appendix No. VII.
 
 94 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 of what they consider its good, (which, if it were 
 real, ought not to demand the sacrifice of our 
 good) are perpetually losing sight of that which 
 is, naturally, a very subordinate object at least 
 to them, though to us it ought to be primary, — 
 the efficacy of Transportation in the diminution 
 of crime, here. They feel called on indeed to 
 say something from time to time, in its defence 
 in that point of view ; shifting their ground 
 backwards and forwards, between the reforma- 
 tion of criminals and the prevention of offences ; 
 but it is evidently the prosperity of the Colony 
 that really occupies the chief part of their 
 attentk>n. One out of many indications of this, 
 is their strong and often repeated disparage- 
 ment of the judgment of all who have not been 
 on the spot. We, it seems, cannot possibly be 
 acquainted with the details of the system: — we 
 are destitute of experience : — our knowledge 
 must be imperfect and inaccurate : — in short, we 
 ought to have no voice in the question. 
 
 Now admitting all this ; — which would be 
 admitting far too much ; since I have stated 
 nothing but on the evidence of those who have 
 been there, confirmed by the admissions of the
 
 Interests of the Colony preferred to ours. 95 
 
 advocates themselves ; — but admitting all this 
 local ignorance, it is evident that the whole 
 argument proceeds on the supposition, that the 
 Colony is the only thing to be attended to. The 
 settlers, we will suppose, must know best what 
 benefits the Colony ; but they cannot surely be 
 the sole judges as to what are the secondary 
 punishments that operate best for this country. 
 
 One of the writers before me recommends 
 Transportation, not on the ground of what it 
 has hitherto been, but of what it may hereafter 
 become, under the operation of some new regu- 
 lation. The others also recommend it, depre- 
 cating these very regulations, and reverting to 
 what it has been, but is likely to be no longer. 
 Neither party seems to speak in the present 
 tense, but the one in the past and the other in 
 the future. But supposing these advocates were 
 agreed in their views, as much as they manifestly 
 disagree, still, xoe also should be allowed to form 
 our own judgments on the system, as far as 
 relates to this country. It is only by making 
 the Colony the primary, and indeed sole object, 
 that they can maintain their exclusive claim to 
 practical knowledge and experience.
 
 96 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 When the advantages of any foreign com- 
 merce, that to China for instance — are discussed, 
 British manufacturers and tradesmen are accus- 
 tomed to speak of their experience respecting 
 the demand in England for Chinese commodities, 
 and the demand for ours as exports to China. 
 Now would it not be strange for any one to put 
 them all to silence, by saying, " You can know 
 nothing about the matter, because you have 
 never been in China ?" They would answer, 
 *' The residents in China may be the best judges 
 of the benefit of the trade to that country, but 
 we must surely know something of its effects at 
 home : and, to the British nation, this is the 
 important point." 
 
 So in the present case also, it is the effect of 
 Transportation, here, as a mode of secondary 
 punishment, that is confessedly the important 
 consideration. 
 
 And in this point of view, its advocates seem 
 so conscious of the weakness of their cause, that 
 their chief resource is to contrast it with other 
 plans which either have been actually tried, or
 
 Proposed Substitutes misrepresented. 97 
 
 are attributed to me as my proposals by way of 
 substitute. Dr. Ross does, indeed, in one place, 
 break out into a florid description of the situa- 
 tion of a transported convict (which he had, a 
 little before, characterised as a " purgatory" 
 (p. 58), and as a punishment of " extreme seve- 
 rity," (p. 59), especially to the " unseared," — 
 the least hardened offenders) as greatly preferable 
 to that of persons sentenced to the tread-mill. 
 " How far more reclaiming than the tread- 
 " wheel is exercise of the very hardest kind 
 " among the works of nature ! Can the eye of 
 " the most wicked — most viciously inclined, 
 '' look upon the wide spreading lawns — the 
 " rising hills and mountains — the hanging, in- 
 " structive and eloquent forests — the flowing 
 " river or the trickling streamlet clothed with 
 *' the sweetest and most enchanting shrubs and 
 " flowers of this island, without self-reproach, 
 " without some sting of remorse ? * Can I,' he 
 " will say, ' be thus criminal, be thus so basely 
 " ungrateful, while nature with beneficent hands, 
 " with outstretched arms thus draws me to 
 "repentance?"'— P. 83. 
 
 Now when I consider how large a portion of 
 
 H
 
 98 Remarks on Transjmrtation. 
 
 the labouring population of these islands are 
 compelled, not by their crimes, but by their 
 wants, to pass the day in mechanical toil, in 
 close workshops, in the midst of a crowded and 
 smoky town, I cannot but rejoice in the thought, 
 that the beauties of the New Holland scenery 
 are not likely to be so strongly felt by them, as 
 they are here warmly described. Otherwise, 
 there might be a danger of their being so dis- 
 gusted with the comparative closeness and 
 monotony of the scenes around them, as to be 
 weary of their life of honest industry, and envy 
 the picturesque punishment of the convict : 
 unless indeed they suspected some covert mean- 
 ing in the words " hanging forests." 
 
 But I am compelled to say there is an appear- 
 ance (arising perhaps from his having inadver- 
 tently confounded one author with another) of 
 disingenuous proceeding in Colonel Arthur's 
 representation of what I propose in the way 
 of secondary punishment, as a substitute for 
 transportation. He all along proceeds, as far 
 as I am able to understand his meaning, on the 
 supposition, that I recommend the present plan 
 to be superseded by one which shall maintain
 
 Proposed Substitutes misre'presented. 99 
 
 the convicts at an expense of between 50/. and 
 60/. per annum, in a condition far preferable, in 
 respect of diet, clothing, and comforts, to that 
 of an ordinary labourer. " But if the trans- 
 ' ports to Ireland were fed in the same man- 
 
 * ner as men in the penitentiaries are, how 
 ' would their lot be envied by the half-clad, 
 ' starving peasantry of that ill-fated country ! 
 ' and if to this were superadded, the antici- 
 ' pation that after the period of their servi- 
 
 * tude had expired, each was to be rewarded 
 ' with a gratuity for his labour, in order that 
 
 * he might associate with it the notion of inde- 
 ^ pendence, or, in other words, that in return 
 ' for his services he was not only to be fed 
 ' and clothed, but also to be enabled to * save 
 
 * money,' the competition to obtain admission 
 ' into the gangs would doubtless be very great, 
 ' and an incentive to crime would be brought 
 
 * into operation, far more efficacious than even 
 ' the prison and penitentiary discipline of Eng- 
 ' land."*— Pp. ^^, 57. 
 
 * In my former Letter I expressed my apprehension that it 
 would not be possible completely to effect, in Europe, the 
 defrayal of the whole expenses of a penitentiary by the pi'o- 
 
 h2
 
 100 Remarks on Ti'ansjwrtation. 
 
 And his argument turns almost entirely on 
 the superiority of the existing system to that 
 with which he compares it, as the only alterna- 
 tive. " The maintenance and discipline (he had 
 " before observed) in the penitentiary is stated 
 '* to cost about SQL per annum." 
 
 Surely any of his readers, who had not seen 
 my first Letter, would conclude from these 
 passages, that " the Penitentiary" meant some 
 particular establishment, either proposed, or at 
 
 ceeds of the prisoners' labour; as it appears is the case with 
 some of those in America. I have since learned, however, 
 that this object has been accomplished in Belgium. 
 
 In the Dublin Mendicity Institution the average cost per 
 head of the diet, together with lodging, fuel, attendance and 
 (partly) clothing, of adults (who are all kept at work as far as 
 they are capable of it) is less than three-pence a day. And 
 their food, though coarse, is wholesome and nutritious. Of 
 course, from the nature of this institution, able-bodied and 
 expert workmen will always form a smaller proportion to the 
 numbers, than may be expected in a penitentiary. But let 
 the inmates of a penitentiary be supposed to cost, over and 
 above the whole value of their labour, three-pence halfpenny 
 per day, or about 51. or (M. per annum ; even according to 
 this computation a convict would be maintained, for five 
 years, for less than the mere cost of the voyage alone to New 
 South AVales, independent of all the other expenses incurred 
 in the colon v.
 
 Proposed Substitutes misrepresented. 101 
 
 least referred to, and recommended by me ; and 
 that the system of diet and treatment, and the 
 scale of expenditure, here alluded to, had re- 
 ceived my distinct approbation. But why did 
 not Col. Arthur refer to the precise page of my 
 Letter, in which this recommendation is to be 
 found ? Because (I am constrained to say) 
 there is no such page ! The whole system of 
 feeding and clothing, at such lavish cost, the con- 
 victs whose lot is to be so enviable, is, as far as 
 I am concerned, purely imaginary, and fathered 
 upon me without the slightest foundation. 
 
 It has indeed been shewn, on undeniable 
 evidence, by the Poor-Law Commissioners, that 
 the diet of a convict is superior to that of a 
 pauper, — and this, to that of a soldier, and still 
 more, to that of an independent labourer. But 
 where have / recommended an adherence to 
 this preposterous system ? It is possible, how- 
 ever, and I sincerely hope it will be made to 
 appear, that Col. Arthur has inadvertently con- 
 founded a portion of some other work with mine. 
 
 But not only is it untrue that I have recom- 
 mended the substitution for transportation, of 
 precisely such a penitentiary system as has been
 
 102 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 attributed to me : it is incorrect, altogether, to 
 represent me as advising the immediate adoption 
 of any particular system as a substitute. On 
 the contrary, I distinctly declared my conviction 
 of the impossibility, in the present state of our 
 knowledge on the subject, to come to any 
 well-warranted immediate decision, as to what 
 substitute would be the best. I recommended 
 accordingly, investigation and experiment, by 
 means of a commission appointed for the pur- 
 pose. I did, indeed, suggest some principles 
 which I thought it would be useful for such 
 a commission to keep in view, and some experi- 
 ments which they might, perhaps, think it worth 
 while to try. But if I had made up my mind as 
 to the expediency of at once fixing on a certain 
 specific system, what could have been the object 
 of the commission, ■ or of inquiry, or of experi- 
 ment f And yet both Col. Arthur and Archdeacon 
 Broughton (taking no notice of the commission, 
 which is what I did recommend,) refer again and 
 again to " the system which I propose ;" when it 
 is not only not true that I proposed any one, but 
 impossible that I could have done so, without a 
 palpable self-contradiction.
 
 Proposed Substitutes misrepresented. 103 
 
 " I am inclined to think, therefore, that the 
 *' confidence with which several persons have 
 '' advocated each his favourite plan of prison 
 " discipHne as preferable to all others, must be 
 " somewhat premature. It is but of late years 
 " that the subject has engaged any large share 
 " (and it still engages much less than it de- 
 " serves) of the attention of active and intelli- 
 " gent men, at once philosophical, and practically 
 " observant : and I am convinced we have still 
 " much to learn, which experience, aided by 
 " careful reflection, can alone teach. In the 
 *' present state of our knowledge, therefore, it 
 *' would perhaps be our wisest and safest course 
 '* to establish, in different places, several peni- 
 " tentiaries, on different plans, such as may 
 " seem to have the most to recommend them ; 
 " and after a trial of a few years, to introduce 
 " modifications as experience shall suggest, and 
 " remodel the less successful on the pattern of 
 " those which may be found to answer their 
 " purpose better. 
 
 " I do not, of course, mean that we should 
 " try experiments at random, or adopt every 
 " suggestion of the wildest theorists : but if
 
 104 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 " we made trial of those plans in favour of 
 *' which sound reasons could be offered, and 
 " were careful to guard in every case against 
 " such errors as might plainly be shewn to be 
 " such, and to tend towards the defeat of our 
 " object, there can be little doubt that, in the 
 " course of a very few years, we should be 
 " enabled, by attentive observation, to ascertain 
 " what system worked best. And we might rest 
 " assured, in the mean time, that none could be 
 *' more exceptionable than the existing system 
 " of transportation." 
 
 " I will take the liberty, therefore, of most 
 *' earnestly recommending the appointment of 
 *' a Board of Commissioners, analogous to that 
 " which is now occupied with the no less im- 
 *' portant subject of the Poor-laws, and from 
 " whose labours every one, who is acquainted 
 " with the character of the individuals com- 
 '* posing it, must hope for the most favourable 
 " results. 
 
 " Whether the legislature is constituted in 
 "one way or in another, it is clearly impossible 
 " that it should be capable of going through, 
 ** with proper care, all the necessary details of
 
 Indefensible Character of the System. 105 
 
 ** that vast and heterogeneous mass of business 
 " which belongs to its decision. And those 
 " who are at all acquainted with parliamentary 
 " proceedings, have no need to be reminded 
 " how much slovenly legislation has resulted 
 " from the non-adoption, or very slight and 
 '' imperfect adoption, in the highest department 
 " of all, of that important principle, division of 
 *' labour ; but for which, even the humblest arts 
 " could never have been brought to any degree 
 " of perfection."* 
 
 It will be plain, from the above extracts, how 
 utterly at variance with what I really did recom- 
 mend are the representations that have been 
 made of it. 
 
 But one point I certainly did consider as 
 already settled. The experiment of Transporta- 
 tion I considered as not only tried, but per- 
 severed in beyond the reasonable bounds of 
 experiment ; and to have proved a complete 
 and most mischievous failure. And if I had 
 had any lingering doubts on this point, they 
 
 * Thoughts on Secondary Punishments, pp. 10 — 12, 43, 44.
 
 106 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 would have been completely removed by the 
 publications now before me ; in which, besides 
 the many mutual contradictions, and the many 
 admissions fatal to the cause advocated, which 
 I have here extracted, there are many more of 
 a like character (as every reader of them may 
 easily perceive) which I have left unnoticed for 
 fear of wearying my readers with superfluous 
 refutation. 
 
 One more instance will suffice. These authors 
 agree in thinking the experiment of Transporta- 
 tion has not yet been sufficiently tried, but as 
 to the way in which it should be tried, they are 
 quite at issue : — The Convicts, Colonel Arthur 
 informs us, (p. 25.) " are made to work out their 
 *' bondage either in assignment, in the service of 
 *' Government, in the road gangs, in the chain 
 " gangs, in the penal settlements, or in the 
 " chain gangs in the penal settlements. This 
 " distribution is regulated by character and con- 
 " duct, and by no means by an arbitrary dis- 
 " posal. Of all the conditions in which they 
 " can be placed, that of private assignment is 
 " the most desirable, and that of being placed 
 " in a chain gang in a penal settlement, the
 
 Indefensible Character of the System. 107 
 
 " most harassing, degraded and miserable !" And 
 again (p. 32), " Persons who for occasional pur- 
 poses obtain men from the loan gang, are 
 much more apt to abuse the trust confided 
 in them than ordinary assignees, and this is 
 an important objection to the system of con- 
 tracts, which has lately been brought into 
 operation in the colony. Contractors for 
 public works generally stipulate for a certain 
 number of men from the loan gang, as on 
 account of the scarcity of free labourers they 
 could not otherwise complete what they under- 
 take. And it is almost invariably found that 
 the convicts who have been put under their 
 charge, have by no means derived any benefit 
 from it." 
 
 And now what says Archdeacon Broughton? 
 I am no admirer of a state of servitude by assign- 
 ment, or of the exercise of summary jurisdic- 
 tion. I cannot hesitate in thinking that they 
 are in themselves great evils; and, when all 
 attendant mischiefs, direct and indirect, which 
 result from them, are taken into consideration, 
 I think that the community in which they 
 exist is paying a very heavy tax for the
 
 108 Remarhs on Transportation. 
 
 " financial advantages which the convict system 
 " may confer." — P. 104. 
 
 Such is the mutual co-operation of these 
 brother advocates ; w^hose discrepancy extends 
 to almost every possible point, from the most 
 general view of the whole system down to the 
 minutest details in the working of it. *' Call 
 " you this backing your friends ? a plague of 
 " such backing ! " 
 
 Our present situation reminds me of that of 
 one of the unfortunate dupes of the projectors 
 in Alchemy, of whom there were so many, two 
 or three centuries back. One of these, eagerly 
 listening to promises held out of converting lead 
 into gold (which I believe will be effected when 
 convicts are transmuted into useful settlers) 
 pursued perseveringly his search after the philo- 
 sopher's stone, and in spite of repeated and 
 lamentable failures clung with unsubdued fer- 
 vour to the dreams of boundless wealth in which 
 his imagination revelled. Crucible after crucible 
 was broken ; his actual wealth melted away 
 before his eyes in his pursuit of ideal : yet 
 still the moment of projection was anxiously 
 looked for : and if at length, heart-sick from
 
 Indefehsihle Character cf the System. 109 
 
 hope deferred, impoverished and disheartened 
 by the blowing up of one laboratory after an- 
 other, he seemed verging towards despair, the 
 insatiable transmuters rallied his hopes with 
 fresh and more confident assurances. They had 
 certainly been on the very eve of the discovery ; 
 and if he should now desist, all his past trouble 
 and expense would have been thrown away : every 
 failure could be accounted for : one said the 
 furnace had been too hot ; another, too cool ; 
 but all agreed that if he would but persevere, 
 and go the right way to work (though at variance 
 with each other as to zohich was the right way) he 
 would be sure of ultimate success. 
 
 To me, I must confess, it does appear that 
 we have been deluded by the dreams of this 
 legislative Alchemy quite long enough, and that 
 it would be our wisest plan to demolish at once 
 the whole apparatus, and begin, immediately, 
 some better course, while we are deliberating 
 and inquiring which is the best. But at any 
 rate, let us inquire. Should it be thought that 
 the question respecting Transportation is not 
 fully settled, let that be included in the inquiry : 
 let it be added to the list of other systems of
 
 110 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 secondary punishment, actual or proposed, that 
 shall form the subjects of examination and com- 
 parison by a Commission. But at least let us 
 not resolve, at once, in blind confidence, to 
 persevere at all hazards in a system whose ad- 
 vantages are, confessedly, prospective only, and 
 contingent on the successful adoption of new 
 and untried modifications ; for the very plea 
 of the advocates themselves is, that the experi- 
 ment has not yet been tried in the proper way. 
 If therefore we are resolved to admit of no 
 changes in any thing, but to go on, right or 
 wrong, in the course once adopted, then. Col. 
 Arthur's projected modifications must be aban- 
 doned : if, on the other hand, we think it right 
 to inquire at all, what plans will answer best, 
 let us inquire thoroughly ; and not take for 
 granted that we must, at all events, retain 
 Transportation, and have only to consider how 
 to make the best of that ; but compare together, 
 that, and other plans of a different character. 
 
 To concede that the Transportation-system 
 may be admitted, along with others, as a matter 
 for further inquiry, instead of being at once 
 rejected, is surely conceding a great deal ; con-
 
 Commissioners for Inquiry recommended. Ill 
 
 sideling that by the unconscious admission of 
 its advocate, it is, at the present day " a shame- 
 " ful and unblessed thing," and that such a vast 
 amount of evils resulting from it have been so 
 long before the pubHc, in statements which were 
 then only denied, when there was a particular 
 object in denying them. But to cast aside all 
 doubt, — reject all proposals for further inquiry, — 
 and proceed confidently with the present system, 
 as if clear of all suspicion, would be a rashness 
 which might be characterised by a still stronger 
 term. 
 
 But since the main feature of my recom- 
 mendation — the appointment of a commission 
 for inquiry, — does not involve the immediate 
 abolition of Transportation, nor even its abo- 
 lition at all, should it appear, on a fair com- 
 parison with other plans, worthy of being 
 retained ; — since, in short, such a Commission 
 could not be inconsistent with the existence of 
 any plan that should be proved salutary, — why 
 have none of those who have undertaken to 
 defend the cause, attended to this circumstance ?
 
 112 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 why does neither Col. Arthur nor either of the 
 others suggest a modification of my proposal, 
 that penal colonies, as well as oilier peniten- 
 tiaries, should be subjected to the investigation 
 of the Commission alluded to : adding that 
 though such an investigation might perhaps be 
 superfluous, it would, at least, throw additional 
 light on the superiority of their system to the 
 rest ? And why, in short, have they never 
 alluded to the proposed inquiry at all? 
 
 I cannot but think we have good grounds for 
 suspecting a reason for this suppression ; viz. a 
 secret consciousness, that the system would not 
 stand the test of inquiry; — that it would not 
 hear investigation ; — and that the only hope of 
 maintaining it, was in deprecating inquiry and 
 persuading the public, by confident assurances, 
 to acquiesce blindly in things as they are. If 
 such a suspicion be unfounded, it is they who 
 have given a colour to it. 
 
 Be this however as it may, the fact of the 
 omission is before us. No reason is adduced 
 why the proposed inquiries and experiments 
 should not be made, under such a commission 
 as I ventured to recommend — inquiries and
 
 Commissioners for Inquiry recommended. 113 
 
 experiments whose results must be to 'prove the 
 superior advantages of the present system, if 
 they have any real existence. 
 
 To accede to such a proposal would not (we 
 should remember) necessarily imply an imme- 
 diate condemnation of the system, but only bring- 
 ing it to trial : to reject the proposal, and refuse 
 inquiry, would imply an immediate and decisive 
 approbation. It would imply that there is not 
 even any prevailing doubt on the subject in 
 the public mind, nor any ground for doubt. 
 And which would be the more rash and which 
 the more cautious procedure, let any one 
 judge. 
 
 I am anxious therefore that it should be dis- 
 tinctly perceived what is the present state of the 
 question between the advocates of the system 
 and its opponents. If our conclusions be fully 
 admitted, the practical result must be, a reso- 
 lution, as the first step, to abolish at once the 
 system of Penal-colonies. If theirs be admitted, — 
 or rather some of them, to the rejection of others, 
 since they are mutually contradictory, — if we 
 fully make up our minds to acquiesce with un- 
 hesitating confidence, in Col. Arthur's views, 
 
 I
 
 114 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 in spite of what is urged by his auxiharies, — 
 then, we must persist in the system, without 
 further inquiry. But if a doubt remains in the 
 mind of any reader, whether they or we are in 
 the right — if he is not quite certain, which 
 party has the better of the argument, then it 
 is plain, he should decide in favour of the 
 investigation, and merely require that Trans- 
 portation should be included along with other 
 subjects of inquiry. 
 
 But against commissions of this kind a far 
 different class of objections have been urged, 
 and from a different quarter. The whole sys- 
 tem of appointing a commission to examine 
 into a particular class of subjects, — to digest 
 the evidence collected, — and to suggest le- 
 gislative measures, founded on the knowledge 
 thus acquired, — has been loudly condemned, 
 as tending to supersede the powers of Par- 
 liament. A cursory reader of these com- 
 plaints, in some distant country, would be apt 
 to conclude that such commissioners were in- 
 vested, or intended to be invested, with power
 
 Objections urged against Commissions. 115 
 
 to enact laws. But what would be the astonish- 
 ment of such a reader, on learning that the 
 utmost legislative power given or proposed to 
 be given, to commissioners, amounts only to the 
 recommendation of laws ? — A power with which 
 the right of petition has long since invested everi/ 
 individual in the realm ! And whatever weight 
 their recommendations can possess with Par- 
 liament must depend on the opinion which 
 Parliament itself may form of the dihgence, 
 uprightness, and good sense of the persons 
 employed, and of the soundness of the reasons 
 they may assign. As well therefore might it 
 be said that the authority of a General is sus- 
 pended by the aid-de-camp whom he may 
 despatch to procure intelligence : or that the 
 powers of a jury are destroyed by the pleadings 
 of the counsel on both sides, and by the judge's 
 summing up. If a jury were left to examine, 
 for themselves, all the witnesses, — to ascertain 
 unassisted all the points of law, — and to suggest 
 to themselves all the arguments for plaintiff 
 and defendant, — and if they were left to try, 
 on such a plan, a vast variety of causes of the 
 most heterogeneous kinds, in a short space of 
 
 I 2
 
 1 1 6 Remarhs on Transportation. 
 
 time, they would then be in a situation analogous 
 to that in which Parliament is often left ; and 
 it might be expected that their decisions would 
 often be of that crude and hasty character 
 which, it cannot be denied, has but too often 
 been justly complained of in Acts of Parliament. 
 One striking instance, — or rather a long series 
 of instances, — of this defective legislation is 
 afforded by the case of the numerous acts — 
 amendments — repeals — and re-enactments, in 
 reference to the poor-laws. 
 
 The commission appointed to inquire into 
 this subject, (adverted to by way of example 
 in my former Letter,) has not hitherto dis- 
 appointed, but rather surpassed, any reason- 
 able hopes ; having even already laid before 
 the public more information, on points con- 
 nected with the inquiry, than had ever been 
 collected before. Indeed, one of the complaints 
 against this commission is, that it has obtained 
 us too much knowledge ; for even the specimen 
 already published, in one thick octavo, has been 
 censured as voluminous ; a censure which must 
 have reference to the quantity of matter com- 
 prised in the volume, not to its being verbose ;
 
 Objections urged against Commissions. 117 
 
 as it evidently compresses into a comparatively 
 very small space a mass of evidence, which, in 
 the ordinary form of the Parliamentary Reports, 
 vi^ould have tilled several folios. And so great 
 is the advantage of merely enabling all to ob- 
 serve the immensely different consequences of 
 the different modes of administering even the 
 existing laws, and of shewing how each abuse 
 or improvement has been introduced, that even 
 if the whole benefit were to stop there, and no 
 legislative changes were to be made, still I am 
 convinced, that the spontaneous changes for 
 the better which would be introduced, merely 
 through increased knowledge, would be (though 
 far short of what I trust may be looked for,) yet 
 well worth all that the commission has cost. 
 There are even single parishes, in each of which, 
 (looking to pecuniary advantage alone, which is 
 far less important than moral improvement,) the 
 saving in poor-rates, through the adoption of 
 such improved management as other parishes 
 are thus taught to copy, would nearly, if not 
 quite, equal the whole expense of the com- 
 mission. And I fully anticipate, that the next 
 returns of the total amount of poor-rates will
 
 118 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 prove that the benefit of such examples has not 
 been entirely lost. 
 
 Such a statement will probably startle those 
 who have been taught to believe, that one great 
 objection to commissions of this kind is the 
 ruinous expense of them. We have heard com- 
 plaints, in reference particularly to the Poor- 
 Law-Commission, of '' an adequate quantity of 
 " salary and patronage." A two-fold evil has 
 thus been brought before the public mind ; not 
 only the actual pecuniary loss, but also the 
 probable danger that such lucrative situations 
 should be filled by incompetent men, selected 
 with a view to their own benefit, more than 
 to the public service ; in short, that the whole 
 business should have been made a job. And 
 " it is proved," we are assured on the same 
 authority, " that the commission was appointed, 
 " not for the investigation of truths but expressly 
 " for the purpose of finding only a preconcerted 
 *' class of facts, and recommending a predeter- 
 " mined line of opinions ; " and one suflfiicient 
 proof, it is added, of this, is, that one specified 
 individual was appointed the " chief acting man" 
 of the commission.
 
 Objections urged against Commissions. 119 
 
 What must the nation think of those who 
 are believed to be thus squandering the public 
 money for such iniquitous purposes ? But what 
 will it think of the authors of this charge, 
 when it appears that the whole of it, from 
 first to last, is neither more nor less than 
 an absolute falsehood ? The salaries of the 
 Poor - Law - Commissioners, amount — as your 
 Lordship well knows, and as the pubhc ought 
 to know, and will know, — to nothing at all. 
 The coin in which they are paid consists in 
 the hope of benefiting their country, — in the 
 applause of the wise and good, — ^and in the 
 clamorous attacks of anonymous calumniators, 
 whose censures are the only honour they can 
 bestow. And as for patronage, it has consisted 
 in their inducing some of the most respectable 
 gentlemen in the community, in point of know- 
 ledge, talents, character, and station, to carry 
 on laborious and difficult inquiries, without any 
 remuneration, except the mere payment of their 
 travelling expenses ! 
 
 Such is the dependence to be placed on 
 the statement oi facts by the assailants of this 
 commission ! I cannot but think that if such
 
 120 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 writers had resided but a few days among the 
 Houyhnhnms, they would have constrained that 
 innocent people to enlarge their vocabulary. 
 
 It is also false, that the individual whom these 
 unblushing calumniators designate, (or, I may 
 add, any one else,) ever was appointed the 
 " chief acting man " in the commission, or in 
 any way entrusted with any different office from 
 the rest of the members : as false as that the 
 commission was appointed, ** not for the investi- 
 " gation of truth ; " or that, if such a corrupt and 
 fraudulent design had been entertained, the re- 
 spectable individuals (including two distinguished 
 prelates of the established church) would have 
 taken a part in it. 
 
 But when it is considered what a multitude 
 of cases have been brought before the public, 
 each with the names of places and persons, and 
 all the particulars, distinctly specified, so as to 
 enable any one with ease to make such inquiries 
 as will verify or refute the accounts, it must be 
 admitted that there is something very curious in 
 the charge brought against the Commissioners, 
 of seeking '' not for truth, but for a precon- 
 " certed class of facts." As \i facts of any given
 
 Ohjections urged against Commissions. 121 
 
 character, and that too to such an amount as to 
 be complained of as voluminous, were easily to 
 be found by any one who wished for them ! The 
 conduct either of the Commissioners, if their 
 statements are false, or else of their accusers, 
 exhibits an instance of audacity or falsehood 
 that is hardly to be paralleled. 
 
 When the opponents of a commission are 
 driven to resort to such foul slanders as these, 
 for want of better topics, may it not be fairly 
 suspected that their real objection is a fear lest 
 the commission should be found to woj'k too well, 
 and to reflect more credit than they wish, on the 
 advisers of the measure ? So great, it seems, is 
 the alarm felt, that further attacks on the Poor- 
 Law-Commission are threatened ; and, indeed, 
 I know not why they should not be carried on 
 to any extent that may be thought requisite ; 
 since such assailants need be at no loss for 
 matter of accusation, till their powers of inven- 
 tion are fairly exhausted. 
 
 And yet it is possible (for I would gladly 
 make the most favourable supposition) that the 
 propagators of these statements may not have 
 actually knoxon them to be false ; and may, on
 
 122 Remarks on Ti-ansporiation. 
 
 their next return to the charge, retract them. 
 It is possible they may have proceeded merely 
 on conjecture ; not thinking it necessary to 
 verify by inquiry the conclusions drawn from 
 their experience of human nature ; that is, of 
 their own nature, and that of the persons they 
 may have been accustomed to act with. If 
 none of these have ever evinced such public 
 spirit as to undertake a troublesome office with- 
 out " adequate salary and patronage," or such 
 uprightness as to make the " investigation of 
 " truth" and the public good their object, instead 
 of some personal or party-advantage, it is but 
 natural they should take for granted that all 
 others are of like character, and should attri- 
 bute without hesitation similar views to such 
 men as the members of the Poor-Law-Commis- 
 sion :* 
 
 * The names of those individuals (which I suhjoin) would 
 furnish alone a sufficient answer to the calumnies with which 
 they have been assailed. 
 
 C. J. London. Henry Bishop. 
 
 J. B. Chester. Henry Gawler. , 
 
 W. Sturges Bourne. W. Coulson. 
 
 Nassau W, Senior. H. Traill.
 
 Objections urged against Commissions. 123 
 
 " Non vivitur istic 
 " Quo tu rere modo : domus hac nee purior ulla est 
 " Nee magis his aliena malis." 
 
 Painful as it is to contemplate the existence 
 of malignant detraction and party virulence, 
 those engaged in a good cause ought not only to 
 feel no discouragement at being so assailed, but 
 to congratulate themselves on finding such wea- 
 pons (which in the end are always hurtful to 
 the cause they support) employed against them, 
 rather than on their side. And in particular, 
 every one who is engaged in exposing and en- 
 deavouring to rectify any existing abuse, should 
 be prepared to encounter, from those whose 
 interest or prejudices enhst them on its side, 
 with opposition the more strenuous in propor- 
 tion as his efforts are the more likely to succeed. 
 So far, therefore, from being intimidated, he 
 ought rather to be encouraged by such opposi- 
 tion, as in some degree a favourable sign. And 
 if assailed with calumny and insult rather than 
 with calm and courteous reasoning, he should 
 consider that this furnishes, to a certain extent, 
 an indication which party is on the side of
 
 124 Remarks on Transportatio7i. 
 
 sound reason, truth, and justice ; and should 
 regard it as an advantage when an adversary 
 of these hoists his true colours, and proclaims 
 himself such, by his language and demeanour. 
 
 Accordingly, in reference to the present sub- 
 ject, I observed in my former Letter, that 
 " that person is more truly and properly com- 
 *^ passio/iate (to waive all other considerations), 
 " who sets himself to devise means for the pro- 
 " tection of the unoffending, than he whose 
 " kindly feelings are bestowed chiefly on the 
 "■ violators of the law. And yet the former 
 " must prepare himself to expect from the un- 
 " thinking, who are, in most places, the majo- 
 " rity, to be censured as hard-hearted. In 
 ** pleading the cause of the innocent in opposi- 
 ** tion to the guilty, — in urging the claims to 
 " protection of the peaceable and inoffensive 
 " citizen, against the lawless plunderer or incen- 
 ** diary, — and in wishing that honest men may 
 " be relieved from the misery of perpetual terror, 
 ** by transferring that terror to the evil-doer, I 
 " am sensible that I expose myself (such is the
 
 Fallacies relative to humane Conduct. 125 
 
 ** strangely perverted state of many men's feel- 
 '' ings) to the charge of inhumanity." — Pp. 33, 34. 
 And never is the very existence of such a state of 
 feeling, as I there adverted to, likely to be more 
 strenuously and indignantly denied, than when 
 it is most prevalent. Whenever there happen 
 to be many who, either from a fellow-feeling 
 with the guilty, — from confusion of thought or 
 from a generally depraved state of moral senti- 
 ment, are disposed to deprecate the punishment 
 of offenders, and to compassionate them more 
 than innocent sufferers, and when there are 
 others who, from their own interested or ambi- 
 tious views, labour, for the sake of popularity, to 
 excite and keep up this depravation of the public 
 judgment, then it is that the exposure of it is 
 the most likely to raise an outcry, as a " hbel on 
 " the national character." Those who are them- 
 selves infected with this perversion of sentiment, 
 are of course unconscious of it ; and those who 
 seek to foster it, are the last that are likely to 
 acknowledge it. 
 
 In this accordingly, as well as in several other 
 points, the approbation, and the vituperation, 
 with which my views have been received, are, —
 
 126 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 considering the quarters they respectively come 
 from, — equally acceptable. 
 
 With respect to the share I have myself had 
 in calling public attention to the subject of 
 secondary punishments, and especially Trans- 
 portation, I need only remark, that though it 
 is no more my concern than that of many other 
 members of the legislature and of the commu- 
 nity, who feel an interest in the public welfare, 
 but who have not turned their thoughts to this 
 particular point, still, it must be admitted (with- 
 out casting any blame on others) that if no one 
 were ever to pay attention to any public object, 
 that did not officially fall within his own peculiar 
 province, and which therefore he could not 
 individually be censured for neglecting, many 
 more evils would remain unremedied, and many 
 more benefits to society unattained, than under 
 the prevalence of a more comprehensive public 
 spirit. My own attention was turned and often 
 strongly recalled to the subject, by several acci- 
 dental occurrences, which brought under my 
 notice facts connected with it ; chiefly, while rec- 
 tor of a parish in a populous district. And if to 
 reflect and inquire as to the means of remedying
 
 Fallacies relative to humane Conduct. 127 
 
 or alleviating important moral and political evils, 
 be officious and indecorous for any one on 
 whom that particular duty does not officially 
 fall, I must plead guilty to the charge. 
 
 But the odious subject of punishments, it may 
 be said, is one which a person in my station and 
 profession, ought as much as possible to shrink 
 from. However productive of misery and of 
 demoralization, any practice connected with this 
 subject may be, I ought, it seems, to avert my 
 eyes from a painful spectacle, in order to obtain 
 credit for humanity. 
 
 I adverted, in my former Letter, to the mise- 
 rable sophistry that is afloat in reference to what 
 is considered as humane conduct. " Humanity 
 " in punishment, i. e. care to avoid the infliction 
 " of any useless suffering, is one of the points 
 " which I have mentioned as claiming our atten- 
 " tion : but though no one can have, strictly 
 " speaking, too much humanity, it is very pos- 
 " sible to be led by an injudicious and mis- 
 " directed humanity. Neither compassion, we 
 " should remember, nor any other feeling of 
 " our nature, is, in itself, either virtuous or 
 " vicious, but only so far as it is or is not under
 
 128 Remarhson Transportation. 
 
 " the control of sound principle, and under the 
 " guidance of right reason. But the word ' hu- 
 " manity,' being applied loosely and indiscrimi- 
 " nately to the feeling, and to the virtue, leads, 
 " in many cases, to such conduct as is absurd 
 " and pernicious." — Pp. 13, 14. 
 
 Now the real state of the case is, that the 
 truth of the above maxim is either denied, or 
 doubted, or more or less clearly perceived, in 
 proportion, generally speaking, to the deficiency, 
 or greater or less endowment, of a benevolent 
 disposition in each individual. Those in whom 
 that disposition is not strong, but who are 
 accustomed to act on principle, are disposed to 
 regard benevolence only in the light of a virtue ; 
 because with them, every manifestation of it, is 
 a virtuous effort directed against their natural 
 selfishness. They are perhaps startled at being 
 told of benevolence ever being, by any possibility, 
 in whatever way indulged, a weakness ; because 
 they are not prone to any weakness of that 
 description. They find themselves called on 
 to guard against a deficiency, but seldom or 
 never, a misdirection, of kindly feelings. And 
 their indiscriminate approbation of such feelings.
 
 Fallacies relative to humane Conduct. 129 
 
 which is in fact the result of their scanty endow- 
 ment with it, they not iinfrequently regard as 
 a proof of their superiority in this point, over 
 others who judge differently, in consequence of 
 the very circumstance of their having a more 
 benevolent disposition. 
 
 For, those whose temper is the most humane, 
 and who are at the same time accustomed to 
 study ^their own character, and to act on prin- 
 ciple, are sensible that their feelings, in this 
 as well as in other points, will be an unsafe 
 guide, except under the direction of a well- 
 regulated judgment. " But those (I added) who 
 " act from feeling, and not from principle, are 
 " usually led to show more tenderness towards 
 " the offending than the unoffending : i. e. to- 
 " wards the culprit, who is pj-esent, and the 
 " object of their senses, and whose sufferings 
 " or apprehensions they actually witness, than 
 " the absent, unknown, and undefined members 
 " of the community, whose persons or property 
 " have been endangered by him. We feel for 
 " an individual, especially if before our eyes, 
 " even though guilty ; for the public no one has, 
 " or can have, any feeling. Public-spirit, there- 
 
 K
 
 130 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 " fore, implies a benevolent habit ; and that com- 
 bined 
 -P. 14. 
 
 bined with something of reflective abstraction. 
 
 With regard, again, to the mode of proceeding 
 recommended, — the proposed appointment of a 
 Commission, the benefits even already apparent, 
 resulting from the labours of some of those 
 that have been appointed, and, much more, the 
 benefits which may be fully anticipated, when 
 their reports and suggestions shall be laid before 
 the public complete, will supply a much stronger 
 and more popular argument, in favour of such 
 a mode of proceeding, than any reasoning from 
 probabilities could afford. I am content to stake 
 the whole question, as to the reasonableness of 
 this portion of my conclusions, on the success 
 of the experiments, which, partly, have been 
 tried, and partly, are now in progress, as to the 
 utility of the Commissions which have been 
 hitherto appointed on a similar principle. 
 
 I am not without strong hopes that such a 
 Commission may succeed in devising some modes 
 of secondary punishment, even preferable to any 
 that have anywhere hitherto been in use. That
 
 Advantages expected from a Commission. 131 
 
 they will be able to point out several, each far 
 superior to Transportation, I have the fullest 
 confidence. That they will find any, quite 
 unobjectionable, and combining -all conceivable 
 advantages, without any drawback, I have little 
 hope. Where do we find a law on any sub- 
 ject, — a tax, — form of government, — or human 
 institution of any kind, of which this can be 
 said ? And yet it is common for the advocates 
 of Transportation, when hard pressed on the 
 evils of that system, to ask what you would 
 substitute for it : and when any substitute is 
 suggested, to raise objections (often valid) 
 against that ; and require that till these are 
 removed, the present system should continue. 
 It seems modest to ask only that we should 
 go on as we are, not, for ever, but only, till 
 some plan perfectly free from all objections shall 
 be fixed on ; which is, in fact, " for ever." If 
 we were to proceed universally on this principle, 
 we should enact no laws, — no punishments, — 
 no taxes, — no mode of government at all ; since 
 none ever has been or can be devised, against 
 which there are not objections. The fair 
 requisition is, to suggest some system less 
 
 k2
 
 132 RemnrJi's on Transjwrtation. 
 
 objectionable than the present. Whenever this 
 cannot be done, I admit that the presumption 
 against a change holds good. But in the 
 present case, the difficulty would be to find 
 any system that should not be less objectionable 
 than Transportation. 
 
 On the grounds here stated then, and on 
 those briefly set forth in my former Letter to 
 your Lordship, I feel justified in earnestly re- 
 peating my recommendation of the measure of 
 appointing a commission, for such purposes and 
 with such powers as I there described ; viz. to 
 inquire into the nature, apparent effects, and 
 all other circumstances, of the various modes of 
 preventing crime, that are now in operation, — 
 whether by punishments of different kinds, or by 
 police-regulations; — to introduce such changes 
 as may promise to lead to advantage into the 
 detail of the management of any of the existing 
 penitentiary-estabHshments, or other systems of 
 penal labour and confinement; — and to recom- 
 mend such legislative enactments for the im- 
 provement of any portions of our preventive, 
 penal, and corrective system, as may appear, 
 from the inquiries made, to be called for.
 
 Requisite Qtialifications of Commissioners, 133 
 
 To recommend that the persons appointed to 
 act under such a commission, should be men 
 of uprightness, activity, and inteUigence, looking 
 rather to the public good than to " salary and 
 patronage," would be superfluous. And it might 
 seem no less superfluous to point out that they 
 should be honestly devoted to the " investi- 
 gation of truth ;" not to the promotion of some 
 " preconceived scheme " for the advancement 
 of party purposes. But, strange as it may seem, 
 an ardent entire devotion to the cause of truth, 
 has been held up to suspicion, if not to repro- 
 bation, as a dangerous quality. I myself in 
 particular have been denounced as a person 
 hardly fit to be trusted in such a station as I 
 occupy, on Recount of (what I certainly am not 
 disposed to disclaim) an uncompromising zeal 
 in seeking for and maintaining truth ; a quahty 
 which must render, it is said, my alledged errors 
 the more dangerous. And such a principle, it 
 should be remembered, is applicable, not to the 
 case of a single individual only, but universally. 
 For since no man, unless claims to infalUbility 
 be admitted, can be exempt from liabihty to 
 some errors, and these, it seems, become more
 
 134 Remarks on Tranaportation. 
 
 mischievous in proportion to his sincerity, it fol- 
 lows, that, universally, a thorough devotedness 
 to truth is to be regarded with distrust as a 
 pernicious and dangerous endowment. 
 
 But notwithstanding any plausibility this rea- 
 soning may possess, I cannot but heartily wish 
 that such a love of truth were much more 
 prevalent than it is. And I feel convinced that 
 if those who think otherwise, would but agree 
 fairly and fully to try the experi?nent, they would 
 find the dangers they apprehend from that 
 quarter to be much less than they suppose. 
 For, in the first place, it should be recollected, 
 that the sincere lover of truth is somewhat the 
 more likely, from this circumstance, to attain 
 truth. Though by no means exempt from 
 liability to mistake, he will at least (in propor- 
 tion as he is of the character supposed) be 
 guarded against one class of delusions ; —those 
 which are so apt to bias the judgment of the 
 insincere. For it is notoriously common for 
 those who persevere in maintaining any false- 
 hood, to bring themselves at length to believe it. 
 This indeed is described in Scripture as the 
 appropriate punishment, according to the course
 
 Requisite Qualificaliotis of Commissioners. 1 35 
 
 of providence, inflicted on insincerity. On 
 those who ** do not Hke to retain truth in their 
 hearts," God " sends a strong delusion, that 
 they should beheve a lie." 
 
 In the next place it must be remembered 
 that a real lover of truth will at least maintain 
 710 errors but his own ; whereas men of an 
 opposite character, besides any errors of their 
 own judgment, (to which they are as liable, we 
 should remember, as other men,) are ready to 
 maintain other errors also, which they perceive 
 to be such, but on the side of which their in- 
 terests or passions may enlist them. 
 
 We should consider likewise that he who 
 honestly proceeds on conviction, is the more 
 likely to be open to conviction ; and if satisfied 
 by fair proofs that his opinion is erroneous, will 
 at once abandon it. But a person of a contrary 
 character, is, — by argument at least, — incurable. 
 He who even happens to believe any false 
 notion he may be maintaining, yet maintains it 
 not because he believes it, but because it suits 
 his purpose, will be never a step the nearer to 
 removing it for all the reasons that can be 
 adduced. It is lost labour to attempt shaking
 
 136 Remarhs on Transportation. 
 
 his conviction, even if real, when that conviction 
 is not so properly the cause of the course he 
 pursues, as the effect of it. This observation 
 indeed is so trite as to be embodied in the 
 Proverb : 
 
 " He that's convinced against his will 
 " Is of his own opinion still." 
 
 I would further observe, that one sincerely de- 
 voted to the cause of truth, though he has in 
 some sort an advantage, even in pleading the 
 cause of an error, in that air of sincere behef 
 which it is so difficult to assume, yet, on the 
 other hand, is so far the less dangerous when 
 he happens to be on the wrong side, that he 
 feels himself debarred from the use of one whole 
 class of weapons, which are so often found ser- 
 viceable in the cause of falsehood ; — from all 
 the dishonest artifices, of suppressing, disguising, 
 and inventing facts, or employing fallacious ar- 
 guments whose unsoundness he himself perceives. 
 All such arts are indeed hurtful in the end' to 
 the cause, at least, of truth ; but they often 
 produce a temporary effect ; and are often avail- 
 able for the support of such errors as could not
 
 Requisite Qualifications of Commissioners. 137 
 
 otherwise be maintained at all. Accordingly I 
 should say, that, as far as my own observations 
 have extended, those most sincerely devoted to 
 the pursuit of truth, are, though in that cause 
 the most powerful advocates in the end, yet 
 not on the whole the most formidable defenders 
 of any mistaken views. 
 
 And I would add, lastly, that I have also 
 observed in those who are the least scrupulous 
 in respect of truth, a much greater degree of 
 malignant bitterness of hostihty towards op- 
 ponents. It is a matter of common remark, 
 that the opposition arising out of passion of 
 any kind, or self-interest, is incomparably more 
 fierce, than that which proceeds from mere 
 difference of judgment. And hence, each in 
 proportion as the principles which he upholds 
 are adopted rather from the dictates of passion, 
 or of interest, than from a sober conviction of 
 their truth, is liable to increased feelings of 
 rancour against those who differ from him. 
 And the more forcibly the falsity of any thing 
 he maintains is brought home to his under- 
 standing, the more will his half-stifled con- 
 sciousness of being in the wrong, incense him
 
 138 Remarks on Tratisportatioji. 
 
 against those who excite this inward feehng of 
 self-reproach, by detecting to himself his own 
 sophistry. There is something pecuHarly pro- 
 voking in being required, on what we feel to 
 be good grounds, to abandon some position 
 which yet we have resolved at all events not 
 to abandon. Those, on the contrary, who agree 
 in their love of truth, and honestly differ in 
 a matter of judgment only, are not usually such 
 acrimonious opponents of each other : and 
 each, in proportion as his opinions on any sub- 
 ject have been formed on the more diligent and 
 cautious investigation, is the better qualified to 
 estimate the causes of mistake, and the readier 
 to make allowance for others who may have 
 fallen into such mistakes. It is only towards 
 the manifestly insincere, — and towards them 
 with more of disdain than of acrimony,^ — that 
 the feelings of those devoted to the cause of 
 truth are usually excited. But to that per- 
 turbation, and agitating alarm, which commonly 
 lead to intemperate violence, or malignant bitter- 
 ness, they are less and less liable, the longer 
 and the more earnestly they are devoted to 
 the cause. For to him who is engaged in that
 
 Requisite Qualifications of Commissioners. 139 
 
 cause, it is one of the rewards of unflinching, 
 undeviating, unwearied perseverance in it, that 
 he will obtain more and more of a full and calm 
 confidence in its ultimate success : he will be 
 more and more satisfied, that though sophistry 
 and calumny will often, for a time, overlay and 
 disguise the truth, as snow-drifts and frost-work 
 do the surface of the earth, they are no less 
 certain, if we wait patiently, sooner or later, to 
 melt away. 
 
 In defending, even thus briefly, a quahty 
 which I regard as so important, from the charge 
 of being pernicious or dangerous, I shall per- 
 haps appear to many of my readers to have 
 undertaken a superfluous task. I have only to 
 add my most hearty wish, that in thinking so 
 they may be in the right. But fully expecting, 
 as I do, that the proposed Commission, if ap- 
 pointed, will be assailed, from various quarters, 
 with unsparing obloquy of various kinds, I could 
 not but thus proclaim my conviction that its 
 defence must be sought in a strict adherence 
 to the cause of truth ; and that, that cause will, 
 in the end, prove triumphant. That Commis- 
 sioners of undeviating uprightness and intrepid
 
 140 Remarks on Transportation. 
 
 public-spirit must be sought for, and that such 
 may be found, I am fully persuaded. That 
 they may be censured by some as not being 
 devoted to the " investigation of truth," and 
 by others, perhaps, as advocating some erroneous 
 conclusions, the more dangerous on account of 
 their devotion to truth, and that they will be 
 exposed to every other reproachful imputation 
 that the factious, the prejudiced, and the selfish 
 can heap upon them, is highly probable. But 
 I can have no doubt that if they persevere 
 undaunted in the discharge of such duties as 
 I have supposed entrusted to them, they will 
 bring about the most important public be- 
 nefits, and obtain, sooner or later, the nation's 
 gratitude. 
 
 I fully trust that his Majesty's ministers will 
 not be intimidated by declamatory and ground- 
 less vituperation, from perseverance in any 
 course of measures which calm reason may 
 dictate and experience sanction, as beneficial. 
 And I trust they will be deterred neither by 
 vehement, but unproved assertions, nor by the 
 clamour of those who are either interested in 
 the support of abuses, or courting by the lowest
 
 Requisite Qualifications of Commissioners. 141 
 
 means the lowest kind of popularity, from fully 
 and fairly investigating a subject, which, in the 
 opinion of a large and intelligent portion of the 
 community, calls loudly for inquiry ; or from 
 adopting boldly whatever measures may seem 
 best adapted to remove or to alleviate evils 
 which have been already too long submitted to 
 in thoughtless apathy. 
 
 I have the honour to be. 
 My Lord, 
 Your Lordship's faithful • 
 
 and Obedient Humble Servant, 
 
 R. DUBLIN. 
 
 Dublin, 
 
 January 25, 1834.
 
 APPENDIX, No. I. 
 
 At the end of my former Letter I extracted, among 
 other passages, from the Report of the Committee of the 
 House of Commons (1832) on Secondary Punishments, 
 the following: — 
 
 " The punishment of mere transportation to New 
 " South Wales, as they will hereafter have occasion to 
 " show, is not sufficient to deter from the commission of 
 " crime, and as yet no means have been suggested of 
 " inflicting adequate punishment in the penal colonies 
 " without entailing a very great additional expense on 
 " the country. It is therefore necessary, that the more 
 " exclusively penal part of the sentence of criminals con- 
 " demned to transportation, should be inflicted before 
 " they are sent to New South Wales." 
 
 On this passage an intelligent writer in the Law 
 Magazine [No. XIX. pp. 10, 11,] remarks: — 
 
 " In other words, because transportation is sometimes 
 " a reward, and never a punishment, therefore it is to 
 " be used as a means of punishment : because transpor- 
 " tation is not formidable, therefore it must be added to 
 " imprisonment, which is formidable, in order that the 
 " legislature may not too much discourage the commission 
 " of crime in England ; that it may found a colony with
 
 146 Appendix, No. \. 
 
 ** the dregs of a large nation, to be a spectacle of licen- 
 " tiousness and crime, such as the world never saw ; that 
 ** the thieves may be drafted in order to injure the colony 
 " by the indulgence of their vicious propensities, and the 
 " mother country by the example of their prosperity. 
 " Such an arrangement would be like that of a shipowner, 
 *' who, finding his vessel to be leaky and unsound, should 
 " purchase a new one, but continue to perform half the 
 " voyage in the old and dangerous bottom : or of the 
 " madman, who constantly put on the clean linen which 
 " his servant prepared for him, but resolutely refused to 
 " part with the dirty linen which he had already worn. 
 " When we consider the manifold evils which the trans- 
 " portation of convicts necessarily occasions, both to the 
 " society which sends, and that which receives them ; 
 " the incurable corruption caused by the close association 
 " during the voyage, the long delay arising from the dis- 
 " tance of the colony, the impossibility of punishing 
 " persons at large, the uncertainty and inequality of the 
 " lot of convicts quartered upon different persons in town 
 *' and country, the remoteness of the pilace of punishment 
 '' from the persons on whom the example is to work, the 
 " disproportion of the sexes on account of the greater 
 " number of male convicts, the necessity, in governing a 
 " convict-society, of making the maintenance of order 
 " and the avoiding of expense, primary objects, and the 
 *' punishment of convicts only a secondary object ; the 
 " necessity of establishing subsidiary Penal Settlements, 
 *' in order to punish convicted convicts : when we con- 
 " sider all these and many other mischiefs, inseparable
 
 From the "Examiner'' 145 
 
 " from every shade and modification of this pernicious 
 " system, we cannot forbear from entertaining the strong- 
 " est conviction, that nothing short of its entire aboHtion 
 " ought to be acquiesced in, or from expressing a most 
 " anxious hope, that the legislature of this country will 
 " never be persuaded merely to add, instead of substitu- 
 " ting, a real infliction of pain and suffering for this 
 " shadow and mockery of a punishment." 
 
 The addition proposed, of an efficacious to an ineffi- 
 cacious sentence, reminds one of the well-known tale of 
 the man who pretended to make good soup of pebbles, 
 by boiling them a sufficient length of time, along with 
 sundry other ingredients, among which was a neck of 
 mutton. In this case, however, the pebbles had at least 
 the merit of doing no harm. 
 
 APPENDIX, No. II. 
 
 {From the " Examiner," Sept. 15th, 183,}.) 
 
 Surrey Sessions. — Tuesday, Sept. 10th. 
 
 A Candidate for Transportation. — George Jones 
 was indicted for stealing a telescope, and a trifling amount 
 of money, the property of an old man named Stevenson. 
 The prosecutor was in the habit of attending fairs, and 
 at the late fair at Mitcham he employed the prisoner, 
 who was in a destitute condition at the time. On the 
 
 L
 
 146 /Ippendix, No. 2. 
 
 last day of the fair the prisoner, taking advantage of the 
 confidence reposed in him, broke open a box, from which 
 he took the property mentioned in the indictment. 
 
 The Jury returned a verdict of GuiUy ; and, it being 
 the first offence, the Chairman sentenced the prisoner to 
 six months' imprisonment. The prisoner implored the 
 Court to send him out of the country. " There is no 
 use," added he, " in locking me up in prison for a little » 
 time, for I shall come out worse than I went in, and 
 must then, in earnest, be compelled to seek my bread by 
 plunder. I therefore entreat the Court to transport me ; 
 for I shall do better in a foreign land than here." The 
 prisoner's father here ascended the witness-box, and 
 urged his son's request with great earnestness ; at the 
 same time saying, that the lad could not obtain work, 
 and that he (the father) being unable to support him, he 
 was therefore desirous that he should be sent to the 
 Colonies, where he would have some chance of doing 
 well. 
 
 The Chairman told the prisoner's father, that if the 
 Court had sentenced his child to transportation for the 
 offence, his life abroad would be that of slavery, in every 
 sense of the word. The Chairman then inquired, if it 
 was not the first time the prisoner had been tried, and 
 the answer being in the affirmative, he said that the 
 sentence could not be reversed ; and added, that when 
 the prisoner had undergone the punishment of his im- 
 prisonment, it was the duty of his parent to obtain 
 employment for him, and keep him out of bad company.
 
 Fro7n the ''Examiner.'' 147 
 
 {From the " Examiner" Oct. 6th, 1833.) 
 
 Marlborough Street. 
 
 A Candidate for Transportation. — A labouring man, 
 named Golding, nearly blind, was charged with having 
 committed an act of felony. 
 
 A policeman said the defendant came up to him on 
 Saturday, in Regent Street, and told him he had just 
 stolen two pieces of sponge, which he produced. The 
 policeman asked where he took them fi-om, and he 
 pointed out the shop of a tradesman in that street. The 
 prisoner told him, that if he did not take him into 
 custody, he would do something worse, for he was in 
 such a state of destitution, that he wanted to be trans- 
 ported. The sponges, when produced, could not be 
 identified ; upon which Mr. Chambers said, the prisoner 
 would, perhaps, find some difficulty in getting his wishes 
 accomplished, as the law was not now so accommodating. 
 The Magistrate thought the best way of ending the 
 matter was by selling the sponges, and giving the prisoner 
 the money, to help him to his parish at Carlisle. One 
 of the officers gave five shillings for them, which were 
 handed over to the prisoner, and he left the office very 
 much astonished at his good luck. 
 
 {From the " Exatniner," Sept. 8th, 1833.) 
 Old Bailey. — Friday, Sept. 7th. 
 
 W. Higan, a private in the first regiment of Guards, 
 was convicted of stealing a small bag, containing two 
 
 L 2
 
 148 ^ppendir, No. 2. 
 
 shillings and sixpence, and some halfpence, from a 
 woman whom he accosted in the street. 
 
 He cross-examined the prosecutrix very sharply, as 
 to her habit of attending the barracks, and the degree of 
 intimacy that existed between her and the soldiers. The 
 Common Sergeant having sentenced him to seven years' 
 transportation, he coolly answered, — " Thank you, my 
 Lord ; transportation is better than soldiering." 
 
 {From the " Exaumier,'' Oct. 20th, 1833.) 
 Marlborough Street. 
 
 The Condition of a Convict jtref erred to that of a 
 Soldier. — Robert Blakie was charged, on Tuesday, with 
 having stolen a silver watch, belonging to Ann Lamb. 
 When the prisoner was first taken into custody, on Tuesday 
 week, the prosecutrix betrayed such evident reluctance 
 to press the charge, and prevaricated so grossly in her 
 account of the transaction, that Mr. Conant directed he 
 should be remanded until Tuesday last, in order that 
 a full investigation should take place. When brought 
 up for re-examination, the prosecutrix admitted that the 
 statement she had made on the previous day was entirely 
 false ; and, in fact, that the prisoner, Robert Blakie, had 
 stolen her watch. Policeman A. 77, who took Blakie, 
 said he had every reason to believe that his prisoner was 
 a deserter from the 90th Regiment of Foot, as he found 
 a description in the Hue and Cry which exactly applied 
 to him. Blakie said he was willing to save all further 
 trouble, by confessing to the felony. He had taken the
 
 Report of the Prison Discipline Society. 149 
 
 watch, in the hope of being sent out of the country. 
 Some time ago he had enhsted as a soldier, but he had 
 lately got disgusted with the profession, and in order to 
 make himself clear of the army, he preferred being sent 
 to trial, and transported as a felon. Mr. Conant asked 
 him if he had really committed the offence from a dis- 
 taste to the military profession? The prisoner replied 
 that it was really the case. While he was a soldier he 
 felt himself little better than a slave ; but if sent to 
 New South Wales, he hoped in time to get his living 
 at the trade he had been bred to, and, as a mechanic, to 
 become a useful member of society. The prisoner was 
 fully committed. 
 
 APPENDIX, No. III. 
 
 Extract from Report of the Prison Discipline Society. 
 
 An agent of the Prison Discipline Society, at the 
 request of the warden of the prison, visited Montpelier, 
 during the session of the Legislature, and, at the request 
 of the governor, urged the importance of the measure 
 upon the members of both branches of the Legislature, 
 in joint meeting in the Representatives' Chamber, by a 
 disclosure of many appalling facts from the interior of 
 prisons, showing the necessity, in all such establishments, 
 of solitary dormitories. A law was passed within a fort-
 
 150 Appendix, No. 3. 
 
 night, with almost entire unanimity, in favour of the 
 measure. 
 
 As soon might you expect to turn from his wanderings 
 an unfortunate youth, by introducing him into the com- 
 panionship of a den of thieves, as into a penitentiary, in 
 which opportunities for social intercourse, either by day 
 or night, is admitted. The old offender takes delight in 
 relating to his companions his cunning devices, his daring 
 exploits, and his hairbreadth escapes ; and the young, 
 ever ready to seize upon the marvellous, rather than to 
 nurture wholesome maxims, commit to memory lessons 
 of depravity, as the foundation of their practice and 
 future destiny. It has been very justly observed, that 
 " our penitentiaries are so many schools of vice. They 
 *' are so many seminaries to impart lessons and maxims 
 '' calculated to banish legal restraint, moral consideration, 
 " pride of character, and self-regard. They have their 
 " watch-words, their technical terms, their peculiar lan- 
 " guage, and their causes and objects of emulation. Let 
 " us ask any sagacious observer of human nature, 
 " acquainted with the internal police of our prisons, 
 " to suggest a school where the commitment of the most 
 " pernicious crimes can be taught with the most effect; 
 " could he select a plan more fertile in the most per- 
 *' nicious results, than the indiscriminate society of 
 " knaves and villains of all ages and degrees of guilt?" 
 " It is in the cells that every right principle is eradicated, 
 " and every base one instilled. They are nurseries of 
 " crime, where the convict is furnished with the ex- 
 " pedients and shifts of guilt, and, with his invention
 
 Report of the Prison Discipline Society. 151 
 
 " sharpened, he is let loose upon society in a ten-fold 
 " degree a more daring, desperate, and effective villain ! " 
 
 It is not yet four years since the passing of the law, 
 providing for the present organization of the prison, and 
 not quite two years since the completion of the new 
 building, enabled the government to carry into full ope- 
 ration the system contemplated by that law. Even in 
 this short period, the success of the system is obvious to 
 the most careless observer, and is more and more con- 
 spicuous as the institution is more closely scrutinized. 
 The nature and extent of the improvement can be 
 realized only by comparing the former with the actual 
 condition of the prison. Formerly, the facilities for the 
 intercourse of the convicts with each other, and even 
 with strangers, their controul of the money allowed them 
 under the name of over-stint, and, above all, the confine- 
 ment of several in the same cell, without superintendence 
 during the night, gave them means and opportunities, for 
 corrupting each other, for evading the regulations, and 
 defeating the objects of the prison, and for endangering 
 the public peace. They were constantly engaged in plots, 
 not only for their own escape, but for the perpetration 
 of felonies by associates without the walls, or by those of 
 their own number who were about to be liberated ; so 
 that many of the most flagitious crimes committed in this 
 vicinity, were contrived or suggested within the prison 
 itself; and it was by no means uncommon, immediately 
 after the discharge of a convict, to hear of some new 
 atrocity in the neighbourhood. 
 
 The recent and not yet hardened criminal, being here
 
 152 Ap2)enclix, No. 3. 
 
 exposed to the steady influence of the worst intercourse 
 and the worst example, and far removed from every 
 moral restraint, soon became familiar with every species 
 of guilt, reckless of punishment, and the slave of vices 
 which at once brutalized his intellect and prostrated his 
 strength, till all were brought down nearly to a level 
 with the most abandoned. At the same time, their 
 various offences exposed them to frequent punishment, 
 and kept them in perpetual apprehension of being de- 
 tected by some officer, or betrayed by some companion. 
 Devoted to such pursuits, and absorbed by such feelings, 
 they seemed to regard themselves as the irreconcileable 
 enemies of society, and became entirely inaccessible to 
 all human sympathy, and to all moral or religious im- 
 pressions. Obduracy was to them manliness, and every 
 thing like compunction was a subject of ridicule. This 
 state of things was not peculiar to our own prison ; it 
 belongs to all which are conducted on the same principles 
 by which that was then regulated — to all in which the 
 controul of money, a ready communication by day with 
 each other, and unrestrained intercourse with several of 
 their companions by night, are allowed to persons guilty 
 of every crime not capital. 
 
 On the other hand, by the system now in operation 
 here, the convicts are precluded from all intercourse with 
 each other or with strangers, and are confined each in 
 his solitary cell at night.
 
 153 
 
 APPENDIX, No. IV. 
 
 To the Editor of " The Times" 
 
 Sir, — I have been urged to give publicity to the facts 
 contained in the following paper ; and if it be calculated 
 to excite in others the same profound interest and pity 
 which led me to record them, it is, perhaps, my duty not 
 to withhold them from the public; for among your readers 
 there must be some who have the power to give some- 
 thing better than tears and sympathy to the unhappy 
 beings whom England is, or believes herself to be, com- 
 pelled to drive from her bosom. If any such read these 
 details, it is possible that the abandonment of these poor 
 offenders to all the desperation of inevitable and reckless 
 vice, may in time become less absolute. If so, the hun- 
 dred victims who perished in the Amphitrite, before my 
 eyes, will not have perished wholly in vain. 
 
 It is, perhaps, necessary that I should say something 
 as to the credibility of the evidence on which the sub- 
 joined statements are founded. What I can say is this : 
 from the time that Owen and Rice, the two rescued 
 seamen, were taken into the Marine Hotel, the one 
 insensible, the other nearly so, to the time the former 
 embarked for England, exactly a month, he was much 
 within my sight or hearing. Having written to his 
 friends at his dictation, and rendered other little services 
 to him and his shipmate, it is natural that they should
 
 154 Appendix, No. 4. 
 
 have talked with greater freedom before me than before 
 most other persons. Expressions which they let fall 
 incidentally aroused my curiosity as to the condition of 
 the women, which I saw had strongly excited the com- 
 miseration and disgust of both those men, — commiseration 
 of the youthful, the penitent, the decent, and quiet, — 
 disgust at the atrocious and the hardened. Even to these 
 two young men, with no better lights than those of 
 nature and humanity (the one having lived on the sea 
 from five years old, and having taught himself to read 
 and write, the other not having even that degree of in- 
 struction,) it was evident that there was cruelty and 
 injustice in thus binding together half-extinguished virtue 
 and inveterate vice, in this fore-dooming of female in- 
 fancy to foulness and destruction. To those acquainted 
 with men of their class, I need not say that this sentiment 
 was not expressed in any general propositions, but was 
 obvious from the manner of relating individual facts. 
 Both told me that nothing on earth would induce them 
 to sail again in a female convict vessel. 
 
 For my own satisfaction (if I may use the word) I 
 therefore requested Owen to let me write down his 
 answers to some questions on the subject, which he 
 willingly did. What follows is the sum of his answers ; 
 my questions I did not write, they may be inferred. I 
 am bound to add, and I am glad of any occasion to do 
 justice to these poor men, that I never saw reason, in any 
 one instance, to doubt their veracity, — that Owen's state- 
 ments, particularly, from his superior intelligence and 
 experience, had the greatest distinctness, and never, on
 
 Loss of the Amphitrite. 155 
 
 any one point, varied or conflicted, — that of the nume- 
 rous inhabitants of the Marine Hotel, there is not one 
 who will not gladly bear testimony to his constant 
 sobriety, good conduct, and honourable feeling. Your 
 English readers will pardon me for talking of the honour 
 of a poor man, of which I could cite more than one in- 
 stance, known to few besides myself. I think, therefore, 
 such a man, having no conceivable interest to falsify the 
 facts, may fairly be regarded as a credible witness, par- 
 ticularly as his evidence is confirmed by his shipmate. 
 It will be sufficiently obvious, that I wrote down what he 
 said nearly verbatim. 
 
 There is one passage which I hesitated to publish, 
 from the fear that it might wound the most excellent lady 
 mentioned in it; not for her own sake, for ingratitude 
 can wound her only as an indication of failure in her 
 benevolent attempts at the culture of virtuous feelings, 
 but for the sake of the unhappy beings whom habitual 
 vice has steeled against such cares as her's. But till we 
 know the extent of the evil, we cannot resort to new 
 remedies with any chance of success ; till we see how 
 and why one system had failed, it is pains thrown away 
 to look for another. It is therefore right that this excess 
 of depravity, in one class of convicts, should be known 
 through its peculiar symptoms. 
 
 I have only to add, that no individual whatever has 
 
 had the least share in the preparation of the following 
 
 paper, and that whatever of blame may attach to it, is 
 
 due solely to myself. I am, Sir, yours obediently, 
 
 Boulogne-sur- Mer, Oct. 7.
 
 156 Appendix, No. 4. 
 
 P. S. I ought to have mentioned that Owen said he 
 had a Ust of the women's names, the places they came 
 from, and, I think, their offences. This, with every 
 thing he possessed, was lost. 
 
 Facts relating to the Condition and Treatment of Female Con- 
 victs, on their Passage to Botany Bay ; collected from the 
 Mouth of John Oiven, Boatswain of the Amphitrite Female 
 Convict Vessel, wrecked off Boulogne, Aug. 31, 1833, and 
 confirmed by John Richard Rice, Seaman of the same. 
 
 There were 108 female prisoners on board the vessel : 
 twelve of these women had children with them. The 
 ages of the prisoners were from about twelve to about 
 fifty ; those of the children, from about five weeks to 
 about nine years, excepting one girl of fourteen. 
 
 The children were always with the women ; there was 
 no attempt at separation ; they were all together. The 
 women slept three in a bed. The beds ran the whole 
 length of the ship, fore and aft. Between every three 
 beds was a board. The women who had a child had 
 two other women also in their beds. The women all 
 seemed very tender mothers, with the exception of one 
 old Scotchwoman, who treated her child very cruelly ; it 
 was a boy of three years old. Owen remembers only one 
 woman who instructed her child — a boy of seven or 
 eight. She used to teach him to read regularly every 
 day. He was a natural child. The woman had been a 
 prostitute, and came from Ratcliflfe-highway. Her name 
 
 was . The language and behaviour of some 
 
 of the women was outrageous and disgusting beyond any
 
 Loss of the Amphitrite. 157 
 
 thing the men had ever heard. Owen has frequently 
 been obhged to throw pails of water over them, as the 
 only means of keeping them at a distance from the crew. 
 All this language and behaviour the children were ex- 
 posed to hear and see night and day. He believes it to 
 be the general rule on board female convict vessels, that 
 there should be no communication between the prisoners 
 and the crew, and that the former do not go to the fore 
 part of the ship. The women on board the Amphitrite 
 had the range of the deck. The doctor let them go 
 where they liked; he never took any notice if they did 
 not make a riot. The doctor had the sole management 
 of them ; never heard him expostulate, advise, or in any 
 way converse with them. There was no attempt at 
 restraint, instruction, or government of any kind ; only, 
 if one was riotous, he had her brought upon deck, and 
 put into a thing like a watch-box, in which they could 
 not sit, and could only just stand upright. It was very 
 strongly built: no opening, except some small holes 
 at the top to admit air. The women were sometimes 
 shut up in this for hours at a time. This was the only 
 punishment. There was no reward or encouragement 
 for good conduct: no attempt to keep them employed. 
 The captain never interfered with them in any way ; it 
 was not his business. The only order he ever gave them 
 was, to bring up their beds on deck every fine morning. 
 That was the only thing they were ever set to do : all 
 their other employment was at their own pleasure. The 
 doctor's wife never spoke to any of them, nor took any 
 notice of them, except to call Poole, the woman who
 
 158 Appendix, No. 4. 
 
 attended upon lier. There was no divine service on 
 board. Each woman had a Bible given her at Wool- 
 wich, by Mrs. Fry, and two other Quaker ladies. Most 
 of them could read and write. Those from Newgate 
 had been taught in the school there. Mrs. Fry and the 
 other ladies came on board at Woolwich four or five 
 times, and read prayers. Most of the women sewed a 
 good deal. Almost all had a trunk or box of clothes. 
 Part of these were furnished by Government, or by the 
 counties from which they came. 
 
 In reply to my inquiries as t& the previous life and 
 habits of the women, the sum of Owen's answers was as 
 follows : — Forty of the women were from Newgate. 
 Most of these were very young; the oldest did not 
 seem above thirty. Many of them were from Ratcliffe- 
 highway and from Westminster ; some from Chelsea. 
 Most of them had been prostitutes : some were very 
 hardened and outrageous. Those who had been in New- 
 gate the longest were the worst. It was Owen's place, 
 as boatswain, to sling the chair for Mrs. Fry and the 
 other ladies, when they came on board. He heard the 
 Newgate girls wish she might fall overboard and be 
 drowned. Some of them appeared very well disposed. 
 He thinks if they had been kept from the bad ones, and 
 taken pains with, they would have behaved very well. 
 All the girls on board, under the age of fifteen or sixteen, 
 were from Newgate. 
 
 There were eighteen women from Scotland. These 
 were the worst, and most ferocious and hardened on 
 board. They wei'e almost all above forty : only one
 
 Loss of the Amphitrite. 159 
 
 young woman among them. There was not one tolerably 
 decent. Then* language was the most disgusting that 
 can be conceived, and they were always quarrelling and 
 fighting, and stealing from the other women. Owen 
 does not remember what were their offences. Several 
 of them had children. One had a daughter on board, 
 fourteen years of age ; she had been in the hospital 
 nearly from the time they sailed, and was not expected 
 to live. 
 
 Owen does not recollect how many Irish women there 
 were. The number was not great. There were none 
 remarkably bad among them. None of them had 
 children. 
 
 The best behaved of the women were from the coun- 
 ties of England, particularly three from Worcestershire. 
 They were all young. They had all been prostitutes at 
 Worcester, and were transported for some acts of violence 
 towards the police. The eldest was twenty-three. Her 
 
 name was . She was extremely beautiful. These 
 
 three girls always kept together, and did not associate 
 with the others. They were always quiet and well 
 behaved. They used to sit together constantly, reading 
 the Bible and other books, sewing, and singing hymns 
 When they sailed, two of them were put into the same 
 bed with one of the Newgate women. The next morn- 
 ing they complained to the doctor, that they could not 
 bear to sleep with her, her language and behaviour were 
 so indecent and offensive to them. They were then 
 allowed to sleep with the other Worcester woman. Two 
 were enceinte, and would have been brought to bed on
 
 160 Appendix, No. 4. 
 
 board. When the ship struck, was the only one 
 
 who did not go down to fetch a bundle of clothes. They 
 expected to go ashore in the boats. Owen asked her 
 why she did not ; she said, if she could save her life, she 
 did not mind the rest. He fetched her bonnet for her. 
 After this he saw no more of her. 
 
 There was one woman, of about twenty-eight, from 
 Nottingham ; she was very quiet and steady ; she used to 
 wait on the doctor's wife ; her name was Poole ; she had 
 a great quantity of clothes. There was one from Hull, 
 of about twenty-two, very quiet. Several from Man- 
 chester and from Norwich. Remembers nothing remark- 
 able about them. Two from Liverpool, extremely bad; 
 never saw more abandoned girls ; the eldest was not 
 more than seventeen. Does not remember any from the 
 west of England. There was one Welch girl, not above 
 nineteen ; she could not speak a word of English : the 
 others robbed her the first day she came on board. She 
 was the most dejected of the whole. She used to stand 
 at the gangway from morning till night, looking on the 
 water, and crying. For a fortnight they could not get 
 her to eat ; she would take nothing but a drink of cold 
 water, or now and then an apple or a pear. Owen thinks 
 she was from Beaumaris. Forgets what was her crime. 
 She was perfectly quiet. 
 
 Owen observed very little kindness among the prison- 
 ers. They did not generally seem to be dejected, nor to 
 regard transportation as a punishment. A great many 
 said they never meant to go back to England. Only 
 three were transported for life. One of them was from
 
 Appendix, No. 5. 161 
 
 Newgate, and one from Scotland ; foi'gets where the 
 other came from. Some had been in Newgate four or 
 five months : these were the worst. 
 
 APPENDIX, No. V. 
 
 Extracts from Remarks of the French Commissioners on 
 the American System of Secondary Punishments. 
 
 The pmiishment of Transportation intimidates no one, 
 and emboldens many in the path of crime. To avoid the 
 immense expense incurred by keeping the convicts under 
 guard in Australia, England, as we have just seen, re- 
 stores a great number to liberty, soon after they set foot 
 in the penal colony. 
 
 ******* 
 ******* 
 
 It is true, that from this combination of efforts, it 
 sometimes results, that the man, rejected by the mother- 
 country, becomes a useful and respected member of 
 society in the Colony ; but we still more frequently see 
 him, whom the fear of punishment would have forced to 
 lead a regular life in England, infringing the laws which 
 he might have respected, because the punishment with 
 which he is threatened, has nothing to terrify him, but 
 often rather flatters his imagination, than checks him in 
 his career. 
 " Numbers of convicts," says Mr. Bigges, in his Report 
 M
 
 162 Remarks of the French Commissioners 
 
 to Lord Bathurst, "are detained in Australia much more 
 " by the facilities for subsisting, the chances of gain they 
 " there meet with, and the freedom of manners which 
 " prevails, than through the vigilance of the police, — a 
 " singular punishment, we must allow, from which the 
 *' condemned fear to escape! In fact, to many English- 
 " men, transportation is little more than an emigration 
 " to the Austral settlements at the expense of the state." 
 This consideration could not fail to occur to a people 
 justly renowned for skill in the art of governing the 
 community. 
 
 We also find, in an official letter, written by Lord 
 Bathurst, on the 6th of January, 1819, this declara- 
 tion, — " The terror at first inspired by transportation 
 " gradually diminishes, and crimes increase in the same 
 *' proportion." They have increased beyond all calcu- 
 lation. The number of those condemned to transpor- 
 tation, which in 1812 was 662, had, in fact, successively 
 risen to 3,130, in the year 1819, the period of Lord B.'s 
 letter ; and in 1828 they amounted to 4,500. 
 
 The partisans of the system of transportation cannot 
 deny these facts ; but they say that the system has, 
 at least, this result, — the rapid foundation of a Colony 
 which quickly returns to the mother-country in riches 
 and power more than it has cost her. Thus considered, 
 transportation is no longer a penal system, but a method 
 of colonization. In this point of view it deserves to 
 occupy, not only the attention of the friends of hu- 
 manity, but of statesmen, and also of all those who 
 exercise any infiuence over the destiny of nations.
 
 on Secondary Punishments in America. 163 
 
 We do not ourselves hesitate to say, the system of 
 transportation appears to us as ill appropriated to the 
 formation of a colony, as to the suppression of crimes 
 o at home. Without doubt it pours into the country 
 they wish to colonize, a population who would not, 
 perhaps, of themselves, have gone there ; but the state 
 gains little from these precocious fruits, and it might 
 have been desirable to leave things to follow their own 
 course. And first, if the colony really increases with 
 rapidity, it soon becomes difficult to maintain the penal 
 establishment with little expense. The population of 
 New South Wales, in 1819, consisted only of about 
 29,000 inhabitants, and the care of them was already 
 become difficult ; already the idea of erecting prisons 
 to shut up the convicts has been suggested to the govern- 
 ment, being precisely the European system, with its 
 vices, at the distance of 5,000 leagues. 
 
 * 
 
 * 
 
 * 
 
 * 
 
 * 
 
 * 
 
 * 
 
 * 
 
 * 
 
 * 
 
 * 
 
 * 
 
 The colonies of Australia will be the more ready to 
 renounce their connexion with England, as there exists 
 in the hearts of the inhabitants little good-will towards 
 her. And this is one of the most fatal effects of the 
 system of transportation applied to the colonies. In 
 general nothing is more tender than the feeling which 
 binds the colonists to the soil which has given them 
 birth. In spite of the ocean which divides them, early 
 recollection, habit, interest, prejudice, all still unite them 
 to the mother - country. Many European nations have 
 derived, and continue to derive both strength and glory 
 
 M 2
 
 1G4 Remarks of the French Commissioners 
 
 from these distant connexions. One year before the 
 American revolution, the colony whose fathers had, a 
 century and a half back, left the shores of Great Britain, 
 still spoke of England as their home. But the name of 
 the mother-country only recalls to the memory of the 
 transported the remembrance of miseries sometimes un- 
 merited. It is there that he has been unfortunate, 
 persecuted, guilty, dishonoured. What ties unite him 
 to a country, where, most generally, he has left no one 
 who is interested in his fate? How can he wish to 
 establish commercial or friendly connexions with home ? 
 Of all parts of the globe, that in which he was born 
 seems to him the most odious. It is only the place 
 in which his history is known, and where his shame 
 has been divulged. 
 
 We can scarcely doubt but that these hostile feelings 
 of the colonist are perpetuated in future generations ; 
 and in the United States, we may still recognize the 
 Irish, among this rival people of England, by their hatred 
 to their former masters. The system of transportation 
 is, then, fatal to mother-countries, as it enfeebles the 
 natural ties which ought to unite them to their colonies ; 
 it also prepares for these infant nations a futurity of 
 storm and misery. 
 
 The partisans of penal colonies do not fail to cite the 
 example of the Romans, with whom the conquest of 
 the world was preceded by a life of plunder. But the 
 facts of which they speak are remote ; others more 
 conclusive have passed almost under our own obser- 
 vation ; and we cannot think it necessary to refer to
 
 on Secondary Punishments in America. 165 
 
 examples given at the distance of 3,000 years, when 
 the present speaks so loudly. 
 
 Some few sectaries landed, towards the beginning of 
 the seventeenth century, on the coasts of North Ame- 
 rica; they there formed almost in secret a society 
 founded on liberty and religion. This band of pious 
 adventurers has since become a great people, and the 
 nation created by them has remained the freest and 
 most faithful in the world. In an island depending on 
 the same continent, and almost at the same epoch, a 
 band of pirates, the scum of Europe, came to seek an 
 asylum. These depraved, but intelligent men, also esta- 
 blished there a society, which soon forsook the predatory 
 habits of its founders. It became rich and enlightened, 
 but remained the most corrupt people in the world, 
 and its vices prepared the bloody catastrophe which 
 terminated its existence. In fine, without seeking the 
 examples of New England and St. Domingo, it would 
 suffice us, in order to make our view of the subject 
 better understood, to expose what passes in Australia 
 itself. 
 
 Society in Australia is divided into different classes, 
 as distinct and inimical to each other as the different 
 classes of the middle age. The criminal is exposed to 
 the contempt of him who has obtained his liberty ; he, 
 to the outrage of his own son, born free ; and all, to the 
 pride of the colonist whose origin is without blemish. 
 They resemble four hostile nations meeting on the same 
 soil. We may judge of the feelings which animate these 
 different members of the same })eople, by the following
 
 1 66 Remarks of the French Commifi si oners 
 
 extract from the Report of Mr. Bigges : — " As long as 
 " these sentiments of jealousy and enmity subsist," says 
 he, "the introduction of trial by jury into the colony 
 " must not be thought of. In the actual state of things, a 
 "jury composed of former criminals cannot fail to combine 
 " against an accused person belonging to the class of free 
 " colonists; in the same manner, juries chosen from among 
 " free colonists, will always think they show the purity of 
 " their own class in condemning an old convict against 
 " whom a second accusation should be directed." 
 
 In 1820 only an eighth of the children received any 
 instruction in Australia. The government of the colony, 
 however, opened public schools at its own expense ; 
 knowing, as Mr. Bigges remarks, that education only 
 can overcome the fatal influence exercised by the vices 
 of their parents. In fact, what is most wanting in the 
 Australian society, is purity of manners. And how can 
 it be otherwise? In a community composed of simple 
 elements, the force of example, and the influence of 
 public opinion, can scarcely restrain human passions. 
 In 1828, out of 36,000 inhabitants of Australia, 23,000, 
 or nearly twb-thirds, belonged to the class of criminals. 
 Australia was then placed in this singular position, that 
 vice had the support of the majority. The women also 
 had lost those traces of modesty and virtue which cha- 
 racterize their sex in the mother-country, and the greater 
 part of its free colonies ; though the government en- 
 couraged marriage as much as possible, and often at the 
 expense of discipline, the fourth part of the children 
 were bastards. There is also a cause, in some degree
 
 on Secondary Punishments in America. 167 
 
 material, which is opposed to the establishment of good 
 manners in penal colonies, and which, on the contrary, 
 facihtates irregularities and prostitution. 
 
 In all countries women commit infinitely fewer crimes 
 than the men. In France, women only form a fifth of 
 the condemned ; in America, only a tenth. A colony 
 partly founded by the aid of transportation, necessarily 
 presents a great disproportion in number between the two 
 sexes. In 1828, out of the 36,000 inhabitants of Aus- 
 tralia, they could only reckon 8,000 women, or less than 
 a fourth of the whole population. Now we may easily 
 conceive, and experience also proves, that if the manners 
 of a people are pure, the two sexes will be found pretty 
 nearly on a level with each other. But not only in- 
 fringements of moral precepts are frequent in Australia ; 
 more crimes are there committed against the positive 
 laws of society, than in any other country. The annual 
 number of executions in England is about sixty, while in 
 the Australian colonies, which are governed by the same 
 legislation, peopled with men belonging to the same 
 race, and which yet contain only 40,000 inhabitants, 
 they reckon from fifteen to twenty executions every 
 year. 
 
 In fine, among the English colonies, Australia is the 
 only one deprived of that precious civil liberty which 
 has constituted the glory of England, and the strength 
 of her children in all parts of the world. How could 
 the functions of a jury be confided to men who have 
 just been condemned in an English court ? And can 
 the direction of public affairs be entrusted without danger
 
 168 A2)j)endix, No. 6. 
 
 to a population harassed by its vices, and divided by 
 a mutual hatred? 
 
 We must allow that transportation may succeed in 
 rapidly peopling a desert country ; it may form free 
 colonies, but not solid and peaceful communities. The 
 vices which we thus remove from Europe are not de- 
 stroyed, they are only transported to another soil ; and 
 England only expels a part of her refuse to bequeath 
 them to her children of her Austral dominions. 
 
 APPENDIX, No. VI. 
 
 Extract from the Prospectus of the South Australian 
 Association. 
 
 It will be proposed for the consideration of His 
 Majesty's Government, that the Charter of Incorporation 
 shall contain provisions (amongst others) to the following 
 effect : 
 
 I. The Colony to be erected into a Province under the 
 name of South Australia, extending from the 132d to 
 the 141st degree of East longitude, and from the South 
 coast including the adjacent islands northward to the 
 tropic of Capricorn. 
 
 II. The whole of the territory within the above limits 
 to be oi)en to settlement by British subjects.
 
 South Australian Association. 169 
 
 III. Provided that within the said limits, no waste or 
 public land shall become private property, save by one 
 means only ; viz. by purchase at a fixed minimum price, 
 or as much above that price as the competition of public 
 auction may determine. 
 
 V. That the Trustees be empowered, within certain 
 limits, to increase the minimum price of land from time 
 to time, so as to adjust the ratio between the appropriated 
 land and the population of the colony, as experience may 
 dictate. 
 
 VIII. That the whole of the purchase money of waste 
 or public land be employed in conveying labourers, natives 
 of the British Isles, to the Colony. 
 
 IX. That the emigrants conveyed to the Colony with 
 the purchase-money of waste land, be of the two sexes in 
 equal numbers, and that the Corporation be bound to 
 give a preference amongst the applicants for a passage 
 cost free, to young married persons not having children ; 
 so that for any given outlay of their money, the pur- 
 chasers of land may obtain the greatest amount of 
 labour to cultivate the land, and of population to enhance 
 its value. 
 
 X. That until the Colony be settled, and the sales of 
 waste or public land shall have produced an emigration 
 fund adequate to the want of labour in the Colony, the 
 Corporation of Trustees have authority to raise money 
 on loan by the issue of bonds or otherwise, bearing 
 colonial interest, for the purpose of conveying selected 
 labourers to the Colony ; so that the first body of emi- 
 grating capitalists going out to buy land, may, from the 
 
 N
 
 170 A])j)endix, No. 7. 
 
 first, be supplied with labour. And that until such loan 
 or loans be repaid with interest, the Corporation be held 
 bound to apply all the net proceeds of the sales of land 
 in repayment of such loans. 
 
 APPENDIX, No. VII. 
 
 The sentiments of Bacon on this point are probably 
 what a writer in the Law Magazine thus expresses : — 
 Colonies are subordinate political societies belonging 
 to the society which is their mother-country, si^^ject 
 with her to one sovereign power, and equally entitled 
 to its protection and consideration. To establish a 
 colony, therefore, in order to serve as a drain for the 
 impurities of the mother-country, is to do an act which 
 no casuistry can defend ; nor has any one a right to 
 complain if, as unquestionably must happen, it redounds 
 to the mischief of the mother-country. Even if it 
 were possible, by founding a new society with the 
 worst outcasts of a large nation, to exterminate or 
 greatly reduce the body of persons who live by the 
 commission of crime, nothing could, in our opinion, 
 justify such a measure. In a large nation, the dis- 
 charged convicts, whether criminals or not, could 
 never, under a tolerable penal system, make a large 
 part of the whole population ; and if criminals are
 
 Law Magazine. 171 
 
 ** mischievous when they form a small part of the com 
 " munity, what must they be when they form the whole? 
 *' The fable of the old man and the bundle of sticks, it 
 " should be remembered, is as true of the union of bad 
 *' as of good men ! But it is not possible to reduce the 
 " number of criminals by drafting off convicts to a place 
 " of reward; and we may say of transportation without 
 " punishment, what has been said of emigration without 
 " amendment of the poor laws, that ' to attempt to dimi- 
 " nish crime by removing a portion of criminals, and yet 
 " leaving in full force the most powerful machinery ever 
 " applied to the increase of crime, is to attempt to ex- 
 " haust by continual pumping the waters of a perpetual 
 *' fountain.' There is no doubt that wicked men, intent 
 *' oiiFthe commission of crime, whether they have been 
 " convicted or not, are an evil to a country ; nevertheless 
 *' they are a less evil in the mother-country than in a 
 *' penal colony. Poisons which are almost harmless, 
 " when extenuated and diffused in a large mass, work 
 " with a fatal vigour if taken in a concentrated and 
 *' separate form. Nor is it a simple question of nume- 
 " rical proportion, whether a bad man is more mis- 
 *' chievous with ninety-nine good men or ninety-nine 
 " bad men ; but the future increase of the one bad mqji 
 *' is likewise to be considered. In the midst of a large 
 " society, discountenanced by the general opinion, 
 *' neglected and shunned by their relations and friends, 
 " outstripped by the industrious, opprest with the sense 
 " of disgrace, blighted in all their prospects by the 
 " knowledge of their dishonesty, rarely marrying on
 
 172 Ajypendix, No. 1 . 
 
 " account of their bad character and irregular habits, 
 " criminals commonly terminate by an early death their 
 " career of riot, dissipation, debauchery, wretchedness, 
 " and outrage, and sink into the great ocean of society 
 " ' without a grave, unknelled, uncoffined, and unknown.' 
 " Such is the way in which the propagation of vice is 
 " hindered in the regular order of society ; we, however, 
 " in our wisdom, thinking to improve on this arrange- 
 " ment, and too impatient of the presence of the vicious 
 " to await their natural extinction, save them from this 
 '* moral shipwreck, and collect them into one spot, where 
 '* there is no example to deter, no virtuous public opinion 
 " to discountenance, no honest industry to compete with 
 " them, no odious comparisons to be undergone ; and 
 " then insuring always a regular supply of additional 
 " recruits from the gaols of the mother-country, like the 
 " physical philosophers of antiquity, from this corruption 
 " we generate a new society." 
 
 THE END. 
 
 'i(. CLAY. ."KINTICK, liUKAD-STU I'.KT-III 1,1..
 
 University of California Library 
 Los Angeles 
 
 This book is DUE on the last date stamped below. 
 
 ; ■ ■- ■ C-' t ( 
 
 Biomedical Liana^j 
 RECEIVED 
 
 ■' ; ■• V
 
 HV 
 
 3 1158 00967 6262 §950 
 
 UC SOUTHERN REGIONAL LIBRARY EACILITY 
 
 AA 000 912 933 9 
 
 m 
 
 I