s % ;^: \= :^V 5^!GE f 1 1 ^ r-n ^ ^-f^ -"^ rp ..LiBRAR •^- ;*rb^^ I my djr v/ /%u V u U 1 1 i ' Jf xVA' ,Wi9 i • •sinSANCEl \ 1^ ■ .^jOFCAllFC^ s §^ ll < V 1"*— - ^ -n <_< ^ «i^ c-> g ^^ P^ v^ i ?2 :5jrtEUNWER%. A^clOSANCEt o ,^mmv'' . r I ni!\ 1 iA\^ i :5 c^ .«»**v ■V. O ^ it 33 .^1" "■"" 5, f 5o cc '^. ^ - >5^, A' Jk # t^' '■:£■ !5 "^ v^ '/-- J3. "5 y g ■t5 Oc LA- ^^, ri, > ^ i> -2. ■.■3: ■■• TSO-T-I" 745-73^ 787-8&-. 722-721 Reign of Jeroboam" II. Preaching of Amos. Work of Hosea, Work of Isaiah. jDapture of Samaria. 686-641 Reactionary Eeign of Manasseh. ^''^ ' Ashurbanipal's Capture of Thebes. Earlier Sermons of Zephaniah and Jeremiah. Great Reformation of Josiah. The First Captivity. Work of Ezekiel. ^^' The Final Captivity. ^^ E xpulsion of Foreigners from Egypt. 538 Capture of Babylon by Cyrus. 520-51-! Rebuilding of the Temple. Reorganization of Persian Empire. 520-516 4 Til 33r'. 217 165 Battle of Marathon. "Battles of Thermopylae and Salamis. Expulsion of Persians from Europe. Rebuilding the Walls of Jerusalem. Nehemiah's Second Visit. Adoption of the Priestly Law by the Judean Community. Devastation of Palestine by Ochus. Conquest of Sjria by Alexander. Battle of Ipsus. Death of Pyrrhus. Beginning of Translation of Greek 0. T. Battle of Raphia. Conquest of Palestine by Seleucids. Persecution of the Jews. Rededication of the Temple. 1^» Election of Simon High Priest, General, and Governor of the Jews. Renewal of Treaty with Rome. Subjugation of Moab and Ammon. Seizure of Judea by Rome. Ji(*v ^-foRres ^<'.*KI.v .Saui. Stories x,;^ ~T KTEm&AVip SroR' i ,AV1> T>i\'n> ''•r.H?. vTfVF_5 Popular Jude.'LN Latek Ephbaimite ! T>ivn^ >»Ti)iiik> / T z^EKY Late 1 1 FIRST EDITION OP I. II SAMUEL FLNAL BEYIStON C / —f- \ MIDHI / THE BOOK I i / OF ISRAEli \ / V— - BOOKS OF CHRONICLES } CH»n I MACCABEES Kaowv ovtT TBSouoH QcotATiova. EXPLANATION ( REFERRED TO BY^ ILD TESTAMENT AND APOCRYPHAL HISTORICAL BOOKS 1 ■ ' ■ ' HON EaKLV A lEMPUE KHORI'S A / 'AM X / ' ;^ N rp / — r — / ■St r 7^ TTfP APT^ \ Early Ei"" >"-' EuSHA Na / SOLOMON \ ,. ■T \ « N, \ R ,< y / Samaria Cycle / "P EttsHA Stories - L, X 4'' / CHRONICLES QF THE KINOS OF ISRAEL , iAH -v._. ,, ,. \i/ CHRONICLES 'o'f'THE KINGS OF JVDAH FIRST EDITION OP I. II KINGS aUEL AND KINOS HAGGAI 1 BOOK OF JEREMIAH ^ -** J^KHtiH.-. _ \ OF \ IE' KINGS 1 JUDAH \ / ^- 1 'iVR I.ER'S ECCLESIASTICAL HISTORY { EZ RA— N^UEMIAH B( >0K OF ESTHER BISTORT OF THE MACCABEAN STRUOOLE BY JASON OF CYRENE _ ■ ■ — ' _ _ \ PE AND COLOR; \sB BUT NOW LOST. BOOKS STILL EXTANT. C6e ^tunent's 2DID Cestament ISRAEL'S HISTORICAL AND BIOGRAPHICAL NARRATIVES FROM THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE HEBREW KINGDOM TO THE END OF THE MACCABEAN STRUGGLE BY CHARLES FOSTER KENT, Ph.D. Woolsey Professor of Biblical Literature in 7'ale University WITH MAPS AND CHRONOLOGICAL CHARTS HODDER AND STOUGHTON LONDON TORONTO NEW YORK •,u., ..; • V PREFACE It is a significant fact that nearly half of the entire Old Testament con- sists of historical and biographical narratives. These represent the oldest, the simplest, and the most concrete record of God's revelation of Himself "through life to life." That revelation is real ana iiiteiiigiblc, and the faith that grew up about it possesses a permanent and universal value, because its foundations were the actual experiences of men who lived and struggled, amid trying circumstances, with the ever-recurring problems of human existence. In a very true sense Israel's unique faith was the substance of things seen and felt. Not in the garden of Eden but in the fiery furnace of adversity were the rude, primitive Hebrew tribes trained and given that divine message which made them Jehovah's chosen people— his witnesses, called to conquer the world, not by the sword but by unselfish service and the compelling power of truth. Their later historians were inclined to invest the earlier periods and char- acters with a halo and to ignore the evidence of their elemental barbarity; but embedded in Judges, Samuel, and Kings are found extracts from older narratives that faithfully reflect those conditions which are the true back- ground, and which make clear by contrast the real nature and significance of that marvellous development and revelation, the consummation of which is recorded in the later chapters. Israel's faith and ethical standards grad- ually unfolded under the divine teaching in the school of national experience, as did its political and social institutions. It is because they were con- stantly developing that they are significant. Along the same paths each individual must proceed from the comparative ignorance and barbarism of childhood to the maturity and strength of manhood. The Old Testament histories are unique, not merely because they record important events, but because the causes, the meaning, and the consequences of these are con- stantly interpreted by Israel's inspired historians. Hence the narratives, which begin with Samuel and end with I Maccabees, are the natural gateway through which to enter the broad fields represented by the Bible. Because of their vividness and concretene-ss the stories of Samuel, of Saul, and of David at once attract and hold the attention of young and old alike. Studied in their logical order ^which is the order of events— the historical narratives introduce the student in succession and in their true relations to the sig- nificant characters and factors in Israel's remarkable history. Thus a definite, systematic basis is established for all subsecjueiii study. In the light of this knowledge, the noble work and messages of Israel's teachers at once become real and possessed of a vital, personal interest and value. illl?.rr"^^^"^^ PREFACE The remarkable success that has attended the few initial experiments is convincing evidence that the time is not far distant when elementary, as well as advanced, Bible classes will abandon the unsystematic and largely fruitless methods still in vogue and enter upon a graded, unified course of study, which will in the end give a complete and thorough knowledge of the contents of both Testaments. In one year of systematic study it is possible to become acquainted with the essential outlines and facts of Israel's history; in another with the strong personality and noble messages of the prophets; then, intelligently and with greatest profit the fascinating narratives of the beginnings of Hebrew history, which come largely from the pens of the early prophets, can be studied, with the assurance that the intricate problems which they present will vanish when viewed from the vantage-points already gained. Similarly, as in succeeding years the great messages of the psalmists, priests, and sages are considered, they will each yield their wealth of in- spiring truth, and in the end the entire Old Testament will be as familiar ground as the Gospel of Luke or the twenty -third psalm. This is not a distant ideal, but an easily attainable goal, provided our Bible teachers will set it definitely before their classes and inspire zeal and enthusiasm in steadily advancing toward it. They will soon find that various parts of the Old Testament are of very different values; but each stage in the study will reveal unsuspected beauties and vital truths which will kindle interest and arouse the sense of definite work and conquest and personal growth. Also, when they pass at times from the Scriptures which Jesus studied so deeply, and from which he and his apostles drew those truths and illus- trations and expressions which they wove into all their teachings, to the New Testament, they will find that it has an entirely new meaning and significance. Modern scholarship furnishes most valuable aid in restoring the original text, in explaining the obscurities and contradictions, in interpreting events in the light of universal history, and in supplementing the often meagre biblical narrative by the testuuony of contemporary monumental literature; but modern Old Testament histories, however excellent, should never be substituted for that vivid, clear, dramatic history, written by Israel's own historians. It has been said, with much truth, that the Bible was never moi;e studied and less read than to-day. Knowledge of its history, structure, and contents is essential; but it cannot without great loss take the place of per- sonal acquaintance with the exalted ideas and records of the original writers, expressed in their own unrivalled literary form. The supreme aim, there- fore, in this volume, as in the series of which it is a part, has been to facili- tate the intelligent reading and personal study of the Bible itself. Introduc- tions and foot-notes are simply intended to indicate the chief reasons for the faith that is rapidly becoming the common possession of all Bible students. Fortunately, wlaile the Hebrew text of Samuel, Kings, and Ezra-Nehemiah is in many places obscure or defective, the Greek and other early versions have preserved a large number of original readings and in some cases long passages, so that it is now possible to place at the disposal of English readers a much more lucid and complete text of these important books. In adding vi PREFACE a new translation of I and II Maccabees, it is also felt that a real and growing need will be met. Through the generous and efficient co-operation of the publishers it has also been possible to furnish within the compass of this volume an unusually complete equipment for the study of Old Testament history. The debt which I owe to the hundreds of scholars who have made this work possible is too great to acknowledge in detail; the classified list of books of reference in Appendix I gives the titles of those most often used. I am under deep obligation to mv colleasues, Professor Torrev for suggestions m connection with chapters V and ^ I of the Introduction, to the Reverend Frederick Lent, M. A., for important collaboration in the translation of I Maccabees, and to the Reverend George D. Castor, M. A., in the translation of II Mac- cabees. The Reverend A. A. Madsen, M. A., has also placed at my dis- posal the valuable results of his detailed investigations in the fields of biblical geography and chronology, while Professor McFadyen, of Knox College, Toronto, has generously contributed at each point his most admirable criti- cisms. Last of all I wish to acknowledge the large debt which I owe to the members of my biblical and Hebrew seminars, whose practical discussions and sane conclusions have thrown clear light upon many difficult problems. C. F. K. Yale College, Easter, 1904. vu CONTENTS AND CLASSIFICATION INTRODUCTION THE HISTORY OF ISRAEL'S HISTORICAL AND BIOGRAPHICAL NARRATIVES PAO.J I. The Origin and Present Literary Form of the Old Testament His- torical AND Biographical Narratives 3 II. The Earlier Histories and Biographies Incorporated in Samuel and Kings 10 1. The Early Judean Saul and David Narratives 10 2. The Later Ephraimite Samuel Narratives 12 3. Very Late Popular Prophetic Traditions 13 4. Popular Judean David Stories 14 5. The Book of the Acts of Solomon 14 6. The Israelitish and Judean Royal Chronicles 16 7. The Early Ephraunite Elijah Stories 17 8. The Gilgal Cycle of Elisha Stories 18 9. The Samaria Cycle of Popular Elisha Stories 19 10. The Isaiah Stories 20 11. The Final Editing of the Books of Samuel and Kings 20 III. The Chronicler's Ecclesiastical History of Judah and the Temple. . " IV. The Original Sources and Historical Value of Ezra-Nehemiah 'z^ V. The Records of the Maccabean Age 35 VI. The Recovery of the Original Text of the Historical Books 41 IX CONTENTS AND CLASSIFICATION THE UNITED MONARCHY I. The Work of Samuel and the Es- ^ TABLISHMENT OF THE KiNGDOM. § 1. The Birth and Consecration of Samuel S 2. Doom of the House of Eli and the Call of Samuel § 3. Capture of the Ark and the Fall of the House of Eli § 4. Fortunes of the Ark among the Philistines § 5. Secret Anointing of Saul by Samuel § f) Events Connected with Saul's Election as King § 7. The Great Deliverance from the Philistines § 8. Saul's Disobedience and Re- jection § 9. Smnmary of Saul's Reign . . . . CLASSIFICATION Earhj Judean Saul Narratives ISam. 4ib. 2b,3a, 4a, 5a, c, 6b, 7b, 9b, 10a, c 52-lla (llb_6l), 2- 4 /5^ 6-14 /15) 16 /17, 18a\ 18b_72a_ 91 -8 (9)^ 10_io7. 9- 16 1027b, lll-8a (8b)^ 9-11 (12-14\ 15 13 (1)^ 2-4a, 5a, 6, 7a, 15b-18 (•19-22') 23_i436a r36h\ 37- 46,52 (108, 134b- 5b, 7b 15a\ (1447-51) OF THE SOURCES Later Ephraim- ite Samuel Narratives PAGE I Sam. 11-5(0),* 7a /7b\ 7c-28, 211.18-21 51 3I2-I7, 22a /22b) 23-31 (32a) 32b (33a) ^ 33b-35a (35b, 36)^ 3I-2I (41a) ..'......' 4.1c, 2a, 3b, 4b, 5b, 6a, 7a, 8, 9a, 10b, 11-14 (-15)^ 16-18a (18b) 19-21 (22) 51..'. .' 54 57 59 62 715-87 (8), 9-22^ 1017-24, ] 21-11 (12a) 12b-14 (15) 16- 20a (20b, 21) 22-25 (l025-27a) 65 >^2b-13a (13b) 14 79 jgla ('lb'\ lc-35a. yg 79 * References in parentheses are to later additions to the earlier narratives. Minor additions of a word or short clause are not indicated. CONTEXTS AND CLASSIFICATION II. The Decline of Saul axd the Rise OF David. § 10. David's Introduction to Pub- lic Life § 11. His Growing Popularity and Saul's Insane Jealousy § P2. David as a Fugitive § 13. Saul's Vengeance upon the Priests of Nob § 14. Saul's Pursuit and David's 3Iagnaniiiiity § 15. David and Abigail § 16. David among the Philistines. § 17. David and the Philistine In- ^ vasion § 18. His Pursuit and Defeat of the Amalekites § 19. Saul's Visit to the Medium of Endor § 20. Defeat and Death of Saul and Jonathan III. D.wid's Reign A.S King oveu Judah AND OVKR ATX IsR.VET.. § 21. David's Reception of the News of the Death of Saul and Jonathan. CLASSIFICATION Earhj J ltd eon Da- vid Xarratives I Sam. 1614-1711 32-40, 42a (^42b-\ 43- 4Sa, 49, 51-54 jg6-8a (^Sb-s 9, 12a C12b'\ 13-16, 20, 21a ('2 lb-) 22-26a (26b \ 27-29a'^ 191 (2, 3)' 4-17 20lb-39 (40-42)^ 21 1-9, 221-4 (5) 226-18 nQ\ 20-23 _ _ 23I-5 (6)^ 7-14a (14b), 26 25lb-26a (2Cb)^ 27- 44 27 281 • 2, 29 301-4 (5)^ 6-18a nSh\ 19-31 31 II Sam. 11-4(5-10), 11, 12 (13-lC) 17 (18a)^ 18b-27 OF THE SOURCES Popular David Stories (lo35b-16l3), 17 12-31, 41, 4Sb, 50, p^^j. 55-58 80 l<^l-5, 17-19, 29b, 30,10,11 85 23 (15)^16-18 (1918_ 20ia) 89 94 23l9_244a, 6, 7a, 4b,5,7b-22 95 100 2110-15 (1 ciir. 121-22) 102 105 106 Late Popular Pro- phetic Narratives 25l^ 283-16 (17. 18), 19-25 109 (IChr. 10) 110 . .- 112 XI CONTENTS AND CLASSIFICATION III. David's Reign as King over Judah AND OVER ALL IsRAEL — Continued. § 22. David King at Hebron and Ishbaal at Mahanaim § 23. Hostilities between the Two Kingdoms §24. Abner's Disaffection and Deatli § 25. Assassination of Islibaal .... § 26. David's Election as King of all Israel § 27. War with the Philistmes § 28. Capture and Establishment of Jerusalem as the Capital § 29. Establishment of the Ark and the Davidic Dynasty at Jerusalem . § 30. David's Family and Court . . § 31. Public Execution of the Sons of Saul § 32. David's Treatment of the Son of Jonathan § 33. Census and Preparations for the Temple § 34. David's Illustrious Warriors . § 35. His Wars of Conquest § 36. His Double Crime § 37. His Condemnation and Pun- ishment § 38. Birth of Solomon § 39. Crime of Amnon § 40. Absalom's Revenge § 41. Pardon and Return of Absa- lom CLASSIFICATION Early Judean Da- vid Narratives 11 Sam. 3I-9 (loa), lOb /11\ 212-31 3(6a),6b-16(17-19)^ 20-29 (30 \ 31-39_ _ 4.1, 2a (^2b, 3\ 5-12 _ 5 (1.2), 3 (4.5).. 517 (2313-17)^ 5I8- 25 (2115-22^ gl) . . 56a (6b -\ 7a (7b \ 8a (8b\ 9-12 6l.2a (2b)^3-23 (7) (32-5, 513-I6, 815- 18,3023-26) 311 (2), 3-6 (7), 8-14 4*, 9 24I-I6 (17)^ 18-25. . 238-12, 18-39 (82), 101-19, 8 (3-6), 7-10 (11, 12\ 13, 14a (14b), 111, 1226-31 112-27 12 (l-15a-\ 15b-23 1324, 25 . ; ■ ; I3I-8 (9)_ 10-17 (18a)^ 18b-22 1323-39 I4I-24 (25-27) 28-33 OF THE SOURCES Chronicler s Ec- clesiastical History PAGE 114 115 116 118 I Chr. Ill 3, 1223-40 119 1115-19 148-17 181,20^-8 120 114-9 141,2 . 123 13, 151-167. 37_ 1727 124 3I-9, 143-7, 1814- 17, 3725-34 .... 131 132, 133 21, 22 134 1110-14, 20-47^ 27 i 1-24 139 182, 19^ 183-13^ 20I-3 142 _ 144 146 148 148 150 151 xn CONTENTS AND CLASSIFICATION David's Reign as King over Judah AND OVER ALL IsRAEL — Continued. § 42. Absalom's Rebellion § 43. David's Return § 44. Sheba's Rebellion and the Murder of Amasa § 45. Adonijah's Attempted Usurpa- tion and Solomon's Establish- ment on the Throne Early Judean David Nar- ratives § 46. David's Fmal Injunctions and Death The Splendors AND Building En- terprises OF Solo- mon's Reign. § 47. Removal of His Opponents . . . §48. His Wisdom. § 49. Organization and Glories of Solomon's King- dom § 50. Preparations for His Building Enterprises CLASSIFICATION Early Judean Da- vid Narratives 151-1832 . . 1833-1943 . . 301-22. . . .^ I Kgs. 1 . . . Popular Solomon Traditions 2l, 2a (2b-4'\ 5-9 (10. II) I Kgs. 2 (12), 13- 27a (27b) 28-46 Annals of Solomon IKgs. 4i-4a(4b)^ 5-19,27, 28, 22,23 (24, 25, 20, 21)^ 31, 9I6. 17a 51. 2 (3. 4)^ 5a (.5b), 6 (7), 8-11 (12a), 12b-18 I Kgs. 3 (3. 2), 4-6a(6b),7(8), 9-12a (12b), 13a (13b, 14),' 15a (15b) 16-28 (429- 34) Temple Records OF THE SOURCES Chronicler's Er clesiastical History VaUK 153 160 .' 162 I Chr. 33I 164 281-3930 167 II Chr. li 12-13 171 174 114-17, 176 178 xin CONTENTS AND CLASSIFICATION rV. The Splendors AND Building Enter- prises OF Solomon's Reign — Continued. § 51. Building tlie Temple § 52. Ornamenta- tions and Fur- nishings of the Temple § 53. Dedication of the Temple § 54. So lomon' s Palace § 55. H i s Re- sources and Wealth § 56. Visit of the Queen of Sheba. § 57. Solomon's Idolatry Annals of Solomon 6 20 4 5 6 Aramaic Document Ezra 4 (7), 8a, 9, 10, 8b, 11-23 N ehemiah" s Memoirs Xeh. 1^-'"^ 12 (27-30-) ^ 31 , 32 (33- 36N 37-40 (41-43y I^A, 5a (.5b N 6-13a (13b -j^ 13C-21 (22a\ 22b-3l' Ezra Narrative Ezra 7" -26 727_8l9 (20^ 21-36^ Xeh. 7'0-7^ Q^^) . .' xxiii Chronicler^ s Ec- clesiastical History PAGE 349 350 Xeh. 3 352 354 355 357 358 111- 2 360 361 1244_i33 362 Ezra 7 1-10 367 CONTENTS AND CLASSIFICATION Ezra Narrative III. The Work of Ezra and the Institution of the Priestly Law — Cont inned. § 161. Public Reading of the Law and the Observation of the Feast of Tabernacles .... § 162. Ezra's Crusade Against Mixed Marriages § 163. Public Confession of Guilt § 164. The Covenant and its Terms IV. Organization of the Restored JuDEAN Community. § 165. Census of the Jews in Palestine § 166. Population of Jerusalem and the Villages § 167. Genealogy of the Priests and Levites Neh. 773b (73c) ^ gi- 6 (7-9aN 9b-I8 Ezra 9, 10 . Neh. 91-37. , 938, 10 (l-28a)^ 28b- 39 Chronicler's Ec- clesiastical History PAGE 369 371 374 377 Neh. 76-69 (Ezra 2^- 67) 379 Neh. 113-36 382 131-26 383 THE MACCABEAN STRUGGLE I. Causes of the Maccabean Struggle. § 168. Alexander and his Suc- cessors § 169. Seleucus's Futile Attempt to Rob the Temple § 170. Atrocities of the Jewish Hellenizing Leaders § 171. Repeated Sackings of Je- rusalem by Antiochus Epiph- anes § 172. Antiochus's Measures to Root out Judaism § 173. The Martyrs for the Law. § 174. The Uprising of Matta- thias and his Sons § 175. Fortunes of the Fugitives § 176. Death of Mattathias History of the Hasmoneans I Mac. 11 9. 31-28. 329-48. 349-70 Traditional History of the Maccabean Struggle PAGE 387 II Mac. 3 388 390 394 397 398 402 403 405 527,81-7. XXIV CONTENTS AND CLASSIFICATION 325-37^ , 338_427, 428-35 _ ^ 436-6 1_ II. The Wars and Achievements OF Judas Maccabeus. § 177. Judas's Victory over ApoUonius § 178. Departure of Antiochus Epiphanes for Persia and his Appointment of Lysias as Regent § 179. Defeat of the Syrian Generals § 180. Victory over Lysias at Bethsura § 181. Purification of the Tem- ple and the Restoration of its Service § 182. Successful Campaigns against the Surroundmg Na- tions § 183. Death of Antiochus Epiphanes and the Accession of Eupator § 184. The Disastrous Battle of Beth-zacharias § 185. The Treaty Establishmg Religious Freedom § 186. Appointment and Rule of Alcimus as High Priest § 187. Defeat and Death of Ni- canor § 188. The Treaty with Rome. . § 189. Death of Judas III. The Attainment of Political Independence under JON.VTHAM. § 190. Jonathan's Contests and Final Treaty with Bacchides § 191. Concessions by the Syrian Rivals, Demetrius I and Ale.vander Balas § 192. Honors Bestowed upon Jonathan by Alexander Balas § 193. Jonathan's Victory over ApoUonius § 19 1. Overthrow of Alexander by Ptolemy and De- metrius U History of the Hasmoneans I Mac. 31 24. Traditional History of the Maccabean Struggle PAGE 406 408 II Mac. 88-36 408 III-I3I 413 101-9. 415 1014-38^132-45 417 9, 109-13 425 131-22 429 1323-26 432 I4I-14 433 I415-I536 435 441 443 History of the Hasmoneans PAGE I Mac. 923-73 444 101-47 447 1048-66 449 1067-89 450 111-19 451 XXV CONTENTS AND CLASSIFICATION III. The Attainment of Political Independence under Jonathan — Cont inued . § 195. Jonathan's New Honors and Privileges under Demetrius II I 196. Jonatlian's Transfer of Allegiance from De- metrius II to Antiochus § 197. Jonathan's Alliances, Victories, and Building Operations § 198. Tryphon's Treacherous Capture and Murder of Jonathan IV. Simon's Prosperous Reign. § 199. Peace with Demetrius and the Capture of Gazara and the Citadel at Jerusalem § 200. Peace and Prosperity under Simon § 201. Renewal of the Treaty with Rome § 202. Honors Conferred upon Sunon by the Jews. . § 203. Early Promises and Later Demands of An- tiochus Sidetes § 204. Defeat of the Syrian Army § 205. The Treacherous Murder of Simon History of the Hasvioneans PAGE I Mac. 1120-40 452 1141-74. 453 131-38 455 1339-1330 457 1331-53 459 I4I-15 461 I4I6-24 461 1425-49 462 I5I-37 464 1538-1610 465 1611-24 466 THE LIFE OF THE JEWS OF THE DISPERSION The Story of Esther. § 206. Repudiation of Queen Vashti by Ahasuerus § 207. Choice of Esther as Queen and Mordecai's Service to King Ahasuerus § 208. Haman's Purpose and the King's Permission to Put to Death all the Jews in the Empire .... § 209. Esther's Successful Efforts to Avert the Ca- lamity and the Ignominious Death of Haman . . . § 210. The Royal Decrees for the Protection of the Jews §211. Destruction of the Enemies of the Jews . , . - § 212. Institution of the Feast of Purim § 213. The Greatness of Mordecai Book of Esther PAGE Esth. 1 471 3 473 3 474 4-7 475 8 478 9I-I6 480 917-32 480 10 4«2 XXVI TABLE OF CONTENTS APPENDIX PAGE I. Selected Bibliography and Detailed References 485 II. Hebrew Chronology 492 III. Shishak's List of Palestinian Cities 494 IV. The Moabite Stone 494 V. The Western Campaigns of Shalmaneser II 496 VI. Tigl.\th-Pileser Ill's Conquests in Palestine 497 VII. Sargon's Capture of Samaria 498 VIII. The Siloam Inscription 499 IX. Sennacherib's Inv.\sions of Judah 499 X. The Babylonian Chronicle (B) 502 XI. Contemporary Accounts of the Conquest of Babylon by Cyrus... 503 XII. The Gadatas Inscription 505 XIII. The Hebrew, Babylonian and IVIacedonian Months 506 CHRONOLOGICAL CHARTS AND MAPS Sources, Growth, and Approximate Dates of the Old Testament and His- torical Books Frontispiece The Hebrew Empire under David Opposite page 49 Restoration of Solomon's Temple Opposite page 180 Plan of Solomon's Palace Opposite page 193 Hebrew and Contemporary Chronology from the Division of the Hebrew Empire to the Babylonian Exile After page 199 The Assyrian Empire Opposite page 248 Israel and Judah after the Division of the Hebrew Empire .... Opposite page 255 Jewish and Contemporary Chronology from 597 to 165 b.c After page 335 The Jerusalem of Nehemiah Opposite page 349 The Empires of Babylonia, Persia and Alexander Opposite page 365 The Jewish Community in Palestine during the Persi.\n and Greek Periods Opposite page 379 Palestine during the Maccabean Period Opposite page 385 INDEX OF BIBLICAL PASSAGES Pages xxix, xxx Explanation of Typographical Symbols and Abbreviations Page xxxi xxvii INDEX OF BIBLICAL PASSAGES I Samuel CHAPTERS PAGES li-72a 51-62 72b-i4 70-74 715-822 65-67 91-10^ 62-64 108 76,77 109-16 65 10i'-24 67, 68 1025-27a 70 102"b-lli5 65-68 12i_134a 68-71 13^b 77 135a 71 135b 77 136. "a 71 13"b-i5a 77, 78 13i5b_i446 71-76 14-*"-5i 79 1452 76 15i-35a 76-79 1535b-l6l3 80-82 16i-»-19i7 80-88 19i8-20ia 92,93 20ib_2i9 89-93 2110-15 102, 103 22I-2314 92-97 2315-I8 91,92 2319-25^4 95-102 26 97-100 271-282 102-105 28'^-25 109, 110 29,30 105-108 31 110, 111 II Samuel II-3I 112-116 32-5 131 36-43 116-118 4^* 133 45-55 118, 119 56-12 123, 124 II Samuel CHAPTERS PAGES 513-I6 131 5i"-25 120-122 6,7 124-130 8i 122 82-14 142-144 815-18 131 9 133, 134 101-1225 142-148 1226-31 144 I3I-2022 148-164 2023-26 131 211-14 132^ 133 2115-22 122 238-12 139^ 140 2313-17 121 23I8-39 140 24 134-138 I Kings 1,2 164-173 3I 178 32-419 174-177 420.21 178 422-25 177^ 178 427.28 177 429-34 176 5,6 178-184 71-12 193 713-99 184-192 910-15 193, 194 9I6. 17a 178 9l7b-23 194 924 193 925 192 926-28 194 lOi-io 195, 196 1011-12 194 1013 196 1014-29 194, 195 11 196-199 xxix I Kings CHAPTERS PAGES I2I-I420 203-209 I42I-I524 257-265 1525-1921 209-217 20 219-223 21 218,219 221-40 223-225 2241-46 .'265,266 2247-50 270 2251-53 225 II Kings 1 226 2 227-229 3I-3 227 34-27 234-236 4I-7 229 48-37 230-232 438-44 229,230 5 232-234 6l-7 230 68-720 236-239 8i-6 232 87-15 240 816-29 271-273 91-1036 241-246 11,12 274-280 I3I-13 246,247 I314-21 240,241 1322-25 247 I4I-7 280,281 I48-I6 247,248 I4I7-22 282,283 1423-29 248 I5I-7 282,283 158-31 249,250 1532-1620 284-289 17 250-253 181-3 289 184-6 293 187' 8 294,295 INDEX OF BIBLICAL PASSAGES II Kings CHAPTERS PAGES 189-12 250,251 1813-1937 297-303 301-19 295-297 20-0-24" 303-314 348-352 319, 320 353-21 325-327 3522-26 328,329 3527-30 335 I Chronicles 10 110, 111 III-3 119 11^-9 123 1110-14 139 1115-19 120, 121 1120-47 140 131-22 103-105 1323-40 119^ 120 13 124-128 141-2 123, 124 143-7 131 148-17 121 151^167 126-128 1637-1727 128-130 18i 121 182-13 142, 143 1814-17 131 I9I-203 143, 144 204-8 122 31,33 134-139 33I 164 371-24...: 141 3725-34 131, 132 38,29 . .167-171 II Chronicles li 171 12-722 -174-192 81-10 193, 194 811 193 812-16 192 817-18 193, 194 9I-9 195, 196 II Chronicles CHAPTERS PAGES 910.11 194 912 196 913-28 194,195 929-31 199 10 203-205 11^-179 257-266 I8I-I93, 223-225, 267, 268 194-11 267 201-368 268-314 369-16 319,320 3617-21 325-327 3622.23 339 Ezra ' 1 339-341 21-67 379-381 268-3I 369 32-46 342-344 47-23 358-360 424 344 5I.2 344,345 53-622 345-348 71-836 365-369 9, 10 371-374 Nehemiah 1-6 349-358 7I-5 360 76-69 379-381 770-8I8 369-371 9, 10 374-378 111.2 360 113-1326 382-384 1327-1331 361-364 Esther 1-10 471-482 Isaiah 36, 37 298-303 381-8.21,22 295,296 39 296, 297 Jeremiah CHAPTERS PAGES 36 315, 316 34 320,321 37,38 322-325 39I-14 325-328 3915-I8 325 40I-4430 328-335 53I-5 319 536-30 325-327 5331-34 335 Haggai 1 344,345 I Esdras 447a, 48, 51-56, 62, 63 5I-6 341,342 I Maccabees II-9 387, 388 110-15 391,392 116-64 394-398 21-617 402-428 618-1624 429-467 II Maccabees 3I-526 388-397 527 403, 404 6I-742 397-402 8l-7 404, 405 88-36 408-412 9I-29 425-428 IOI-8 415-417 109-13 428 1014-23 417,418 1024-38 421,422 III-I2I 413-415 122-25 418-421 1226-45 422-425 I3I-I536 429-440 XXX EXPLANATION OF TYPOGRAPHICAL SYMBOLS AND ABBREVIATIONS Text in roman type. Supplemental and editorial additions to an older section in smaller type. Superscriptions iv small capitals. Poetical passages are distinguished by smaller type and broken lines. Explanatory clauses, found in the original, in ( ). English equivalents of the more significant Hebrew proper names in [ ]. Words implied by the context or supplied to restore the original narratives, where these have been abridged in the process of editorial fusion, in italics. Foot-notes, presenting the reasons for the analysis and classification of the mate- rial, significant alternate readings, and explanatory material, in small roman tjTe- Interpretative side-headings, giving a condensed summary of the accompanying text, on the margins in small roman type. Chapter numbers in arable figures. Verse numbers in small figures placed above the line. Successive portions of a verse indicated by "■ ^ or •=, placed after the verse number. Thus, Genesis II. 4 (second part of the verse) to IV. 6 (first half) inclusive is written 2^^-4^^\ Complete stories or literary units (with their parallels, if any) are numbered with arable numerals successively throughout the entire volume and are referred to as sections. Thus, § 2 refers to § 2, The Primitive Story of Man's Creation and Fall, pp. 53-^6, AmRV = American Revised Version (1901). AV = Authorized Version (1611). Apocr. = Apocrypha or apoc- ryphal. Aram. — Aramaic. Assyr. = Assyrian. Bab. ~ Babylonian. cf. = compare. e. g. = for example. f. = and following. Gk. = Greek B (Vatican) text of the O.T. General Abbreviations Gk.A = Alexandrian Gk. text of the O.T. Gk. S = Sinaitic Gk. text of the O.T. Heb. = Hebrew, i. e. = that is. .fos. = Josephus. Lat. = Latin (Vulgate) text of Jerome. . Lit. — literally. Luc. = Lucian's Recension of the Greek O.T. N.T. = New Testament. Old Lat. = Old Latin Version of the O.T. Origen = Reading found in Origan's Hexapla. O.T. = Old Testament. Pent. = Pentateuch. RV= Revised Version (1885). Sam. = Samaritan Version of the Pent. Sem. = Semitic. Syr. = Syriac Version of the O.T. Targ. = Targum. Vs. = verse. Abbreviations for the Old Testament and Apocryphal Books Gen. = Genesis. Is. = Isaiah. Esdr. = Esdras. Ex. = Exodus. Jer. = Jeremiah. Wisd. Sol. = Wisdom of Solo- Lev. = Leviticu.s. Lam. = Lamentations. mon. Num. = Numbers. Ezek. = Ezekiel. B. Sir. = Ben Sira or Ecclesi- Dt. = Deuteronomy. Dan. = Daniel. asticus. Josh. = Joshua. Hos. = Hosea. Bar. = Baruch. Judg. = Judges. Am. = Amos. Sg. of Three — Song of tha Sam. = Samuel. Ob. = Obadiah. Three Children. Kgs. = Kings. Jon. = Jonah. Sus. =: Susanna. Chr. = Chronicles. Mic. = Micali. Pryr. of Man. = Prayer of Neh. = Nehemiah. Nah. = Nahum. Manas.ses. Ksth. = Esther. Hab. = Hahukkuk. Mac. = Maccabees. Ps. = Psalms. Zeph. = Zephaiiiah. I'.nooh = Book of Enoch. Pr. = Proverbs. Hag. = Haggai. Ps. of Sol. = Psalms of Solo- Ecc. = Ecclesiastes. Zech. = Zccliariah. mon. 8g. of Sg3. = Song of Songs, Mai. = Malachi. XXXI THE HISTORY OF ISRAEL'S HISTORICAL AND BIOGRAPHICAL NARRATIVES INTRODUCTION THE ORIGIN AND PRESENT LITERARY FORM OF THE OLD TESTAMENT HISTORICAL AND BIOGRAPHICAL NARRATIVES Israel's national and literary history begins with the establishment of The the Hebrew monarchy under Saul. LTp to this time the only records of the nfngs" past appear to have been disconnected popular traditions, recounted be- of isra- side the camp fire, in the secret of the harem, at marriage feasts, at the tional local sanctuaries, diuing the annual feasts, at the wells, or beside the city "'*'^°'"^ gates, wherever men or women were gathered together and the story-teller could find an audience (cf. Vol. I, p. 13). These early stories, many of which are found in the first eight books of the Old Testament, undoubt- edly preserve a great number of significant historical facts, but they do not constitute a national history, for the oldest and most authentic stories originated before the Israelitish tribes had yet crystallized into a nation, and the narratives furnish only occasional pictures of the more important acts and actors in that great drama which later unfolded on the soil of Pales- tine. They represent rather the prologue to the subsequent history, since they record the movements of the nomadic ancestors of the Hebrews and the early struggles of the individual tribes to secure and maintain possession of the much-contested land of Canaan. Through these varied traditions the historian is able to trace in outline at least the beginnings of Hebrew history. Before there can be a history in the generally accepted sense of that term, Con- there must be historians possessed of the facilities for recording their facts and 'f^y^^y^ events worthy of record and calculated to inspire them to write. In ancient aWe for Israel these two conditions were first met and then fully supplied during willing the brilliant reigns of David and Solomon. The assimilation of the highly tory* developed civilization of the Canaanites and the diplomatic and commercial relations with other centres of literary culture, such as Egy])t, Phoenicia, and Damascus, gave the Hebrew historians their system of writing and also precedents to follow. From the days of David recorders and scribes figure among the court officials. The dramatic, epoch-making events of the reigns of Saul and David gave them themes well worthy of the pen of patri- otic historians. The national pride, and splendor, and comparative peace of the reign of Solomon also afforded them the atmosj)here and op|)ortunity which undoubtedly gave rise to the earliest Hebrew historical records. 3 ISRAEL'S HISTORICAL RECORDS Liter- These were either very brief annals of important events, such as the suc- ?orinof cessions of kings, wars, building enterprises, treaties, and alliances, or else 'iie oral traditions which recounted the deeds of important religious or military tecords leaders, like Samuel and Saul and David. Both of these very different types of sources underlie the narrative of Samuel and Kings. As the his- tory unfolded, the tendency became marked to weave these various sources into a continuous narrative. Naturally, later historians would also further supplement the older records with current traditions regarding the earlier period. Thus it is that the narratives of Samuel and Kings have all the literary characteristics — absence of technical details, the few characters, the striking contrasts, the vividness, and the dramatic action — of the primi- tive traditions regarding the beginnings of Hebrew life. The story of David's family history, for example, is presented in II Samuel 9-20 in a literary form that suggests the great tragedies of Greece. The dramatic dialogue is also effectively employed, as in the more primitive traditions, to make the history realistic. The result is that the characters live and move and speak before the awakened imagination of the reader. The in- When the Hebrew prophets became preachers and statesmen, swaying tlon"''" public opinion by the power of their voice and by the divine messages which ofser- they proclaimed in the form of public addresses, the historians also intro- and ad- duced sermons and long orations into their narratives. This literary form dresses j^ common to all literature. Mark Antony's famous address in Shake- speare's Julius Cccsar is perhaps the most familiar modern example. This effective form of narration was in Hebrew literature but the natural out- growth of the ancient oracle, as for example Jacob's blessing in Genesis 49, and of the dialogue. It appears first and most prominently in the writings of the later Ephraimite school, which bore the stamp of Hosea's strong, in- spiring personality, and was still further developed by its Judean heir, the late prophetic or Deuteronomic school (cf. Vol. I, Introd., pp. 37-42). The most striking examples in the opening books of the Old Testament are the farewell addresses of Moses in Deuteronomy and Joshua in Joshua 23 and 24. In Samuel and Kings there are also many examples : Samuel's long sermons in I Samuel 8 and 12, Nathan's in II Samuel 7, Solomon's speech at the dedication of the temple in I Kings 8, and Ahijah's warnings in Ip'-'^ and 14'"'^ In each case the language and ideas indicate that these are from the later schools of writers. In the didactic stories in Chronicles, which are based on the earlier narratives of Samuel and Kings, these hortatory ad- dresses are still more common. They are in fact the favorite literary form of the later Jewish writers, as is shown by the long prayers in Ezra 9 and Nehemiah 9, and even by the speeches attributed to Judas and his fellow- leaders in the more strictly historical books of I and II INIaccabees. Promi- Israel's historians were always more interested in individual men than of per- iu movements. Since their chief sources were also current traditions re- sonal garding popular heroes, the texture of their histories largely consists of per- phies sonal biographies, which they have woven together into a larger whole. Remove from the historical books the biographies of Samuel, Saul, David, Solomon, Jeroboam, Ahab, Elijah, Elisha, Jehu, Hezekiah, Isaiah, Jere- 4 THEIR ORIGIN AND PRESENT LITERARY FORM miah, Nehemiah, and Ezra, and little besides bare statistics and the record of three or four important events in the history of the temple remain. It is this prominent personal element that constitutes the chief charm of the narratives; while their vital touch with actual men and real life is the main source of their permanent and practical value. The prominence of the biographical element is likewise due fo the fact Domi- that the authors of the so-called historical books were not primarilv his- ahn*not torians, but rather religious teachers seeking apt and familiar illustrations bistori- of the spiritual truths which impelled them to write. From Israel's history reiig-" as a whole they drew many valuable lessons, but even more from the life of ^°"^ a hero like David, or of an intrepid chamj^ion of righteousness like Elijah. Hence the Old Testament records lack historic proportion. David's final epoch-making victory over the Philistines is only meagrely described, while to his private family history many chapters are devoted. Omri's important reign is dismissed with a few verses, while four chapters are given to de- scribing the work of the Tishbite prophet. This fact is the basis of the com- mon assertion that there is strictly speaking no real history in Hebrew literature until we reach the Maccabean period. The books which are des- ignated as historical are either collections of historical illustrations, which enforce prophetic principles, or else traditions regarding the temple and the origin of its later ceremonial institutions. The amount of authentic data which such books as Samuel, Kings, and Indi- Ezra-Nehemiah contain at once place them in the first rank among the his- that'"^ torical records coming from antiquity, but the historical facts are neverthe- the ear- less incidental, although for this reason none the less valuable. It is ex- torical ceedingly important, therefore, always to remember the higher ethical and p^n^i^t religious purpose which determined the form and contents of these books, chiefly This, as well as the fact that they consist largely of quotations from earlier tations works, explains their lack of unity and the presence of occasional contradic- tions. These are but the guide-posts which point the way back to the original sources and make it possible to trace the complex literary history of these composite books and thus to do the work of reconstruction which is necessarA^ before they can be fully appreciated as literature, as history, and above all as illustrations of those eternal principles which regulate the life of nations and men. The fact that the aim of Samuel and Kings was primarily prophetic rather History than historical was recognized by the Jews who formed the Old Testament Cookl canon, for thev classified them, together with Joshua and Jiulffes, as The "f Sam- xiel and Former Prophets. In reality the two books of Sanniel, together with those Kings of Kings, constitute one continuous narrative, bound together by closest bonds. The Greek translators .so treated them, calling them the Books of the Kingdoms, dividing flicm into their present divisions. Jerome gave them the title of Kings, and in the case of the seconil two he has been fol- lowed by the English translators, while the first two retain their Hebrew title. The books of Samuel trace the history of the Hebrews from the latter Con- part of the period of the Judges to the accession of Solomon, and therefore I'^'nfin represent approximately one century. In the present form they consist of Sanmcl 5 ISRAEL'S HISTORICAL RECORDS five general divisions: (1) Samuel and Saul narratives, I Samuel 1-15; (2) stories regarding the rise of David and the decline and death of Saul, 16-31; (3) the account of David's rule first over Judah and then over all Israel, II Samuel 1-8; (-i) David's family history, 9-20; (5) an appendix, 21-24. Prin- In I Samuel the principle of arrangement is in general chronological. In of'ar- 1-15, however, two very different portraits of Samuel are given: in the one range- (Q^ jQ) he is the local seer of Ramah, who finds Saul and encourages him I Sam- to become king, but in the other (7, 8, 12), the prophet-judge, who protest- ingly at the demand of the people turns over the supreme authority to their first king. In the one also (13, 14), the Philistines are defeated by Saul in a fierce engagement, but in the other (7) they are miraculously smitten in response to Samuel's prayer. The duplicate versions in 16-31 of certain of the more important incidents also indicate that the book is composite through- out, and that its literary unity and chronological arrangement are due to the careful work of the editor. In II In II Samuel the material is grouped according to subject matter. In 1-8 the most important political events in David's reign are briefly out- lined, beginning with his accession to the throne of Judah and concluding with a summary of his foreign wars. The events recounted in 9-20 are in part contemporary with those recorded in 1-8, but they trace the series of crimes in his family and court which so sadly dimmed the lustre of his reign. Their natural and probably original sequel is found in I Kings 1 and 2. The last division contains a heterogeneous group of narratives, which were evidently taken from various sources, and probably added to the original book of Samuel after it was separated from Kings. It includes an account of the fate of Saul's sons (21'"'^), which is closely related in theme to 9, a description of the exploits of David's heroes, 21'^"-^ 23^"^", into the midst of which at a comparatively late date Psalm 18 and David's traditional "Last Words" were introduced, and finally the record of a census, which appears to belong to the period of David's foreign wars. In the character of its contents, and in their relation to the narratives in the rest of the book this appendix closely resembles that found at the end of Judges (17-20). Unlike Judges and Kings, the books of Samuel have received few editorial addi- tions. Aside from a few chronological notes, the earlier material has simply been grouped without being fitted into an editorial framework. Con- In the books of Kings the work of the editor is much more prominent. tents of I3eginning with the accession of Solomon and the death of David about books 97j B.C., he traces the double thread of Hebrew history to the Babylonian Kings exile and Jehoiachin's liberation in 561 B.C. ; the books therefore represent a period of about four centuries. The principle of arrangement is prevail- ingly chronological, although groups of stories, as for example the Elisha traditions (II Kgs. 2'-8'^), are introduced as a unit. Three general divi- sions may be distinguished: (1) the records of Solomon's reign, I Kings 1-11; (2) the parallel history of Israel and Judah, I Kings 12-11 Kings 17; (3) the history of Judah, II Kings 18-25. In the first division the editor's contributions appear chiefly in 11, where he condemns Solomon's foreign marriages and the toleration of heathen 6 THEIR ORIGIN AND PRESENT LITERARY FORM cults in Israel. Beginning with the history of the two kingdoms after the The division, he incorporates his data regarding each reign in a regular frame- rjaf**" work, consisting of an introductory and concluding formula. The opening <''ame- one always defines the synchronism with the neighboring kingdom and the length of the reign (cf. Appendix II for a fuller treatment of Hebrew chro- nology). To tliis is added in the case of the kings of Judah the name of the queen-mother. It concludes with a general judgment upon each king. Upon the rulers of Israel this is always adverse, for the basis of the con- demnation appears to be the ruler's attitude toward the religion of Jehovah, and in the opinion of the editor the northern cult was altogether wrong because it centred about the high places selected by Jeroboam I to rival the temple at Jerusalem (I Kgs. l^-**"^^). Occasionally detailed reasons for the condemnation are also given (cf. I Kgs. 14^^"", 15""'^ 16^°"^^). The concluding formula includes a reference to the editor's source and a record of the death of the king and the name of his successor. To this is added, in the case of the kings of Judah who did not come to a violent end, the statement that, he slept with his fathers. Parallel to the narrative of Kings and for the most part simply quoted Histor- from it are the historical sections in the book of Isaiah (36-39). Far uonsTn more important are the corresponding passages in Jeremiah (26, 34, 36- Isaiah 45), for they richly supplement the narrative of Kings, which unfortu- Jere- nately has only a brief account of the events immediately preceding and ""'^ following the fall of Jerusalem in 586 B.C. These historical sections in Jeremiah are doubly valuable because they appear to be taken from a prac- tically contemporary biography of Jeremiaii, probably written by his faithful scribe liaruch. It is a striking and fortunate fact that with few exceptions the most im- Parallel portant events and epochs in the biblical history are recorded in two or ^'^^° more distinct books. The beginnings of Israel's history and the work and teachings of the Founder of Christianity are presented in four parallel strands of narrative. For the period beginning with Saul and extending to the Babylonian exile there are two, and at certain points three distinct records. The .second continuous history of Israel is found in the books of Chron- Con- iclcs. They begin with a group of genealogical tables, which goes back to ^f^l ® ° Adam, and carry the history down to the decree of Cyrus permitting the books Jews to return after the Babylonian exile. Their dependence upon the older Chron- books of Samuel and Kings is clearly shown by the presence of many ver- "^ °^ butim (|Uotations. To these are added long sections which give this later history its distinctive form. Although it traces the genealogy of the race back to Adam, the narrative really begins with the death of Saul and hence- forlh focusses the attention on Judah, the temple, and especially the religious institutions which grew up about it. The books of Chronicles consist of four general divisions: (1) An introduction containing genealogical lists, in- terspersed with brief narratives, I Chronicles 1-9; (2) the history of David's reign, 10-29; (3) an account of Solomon's reign, II Chronicles 1-9; (4) the history of Judah to the fall of Jerusalem, with an appendix containing the decree of Cyrus, 10-30. 7 ISRAEL'S HISTORICAL RECORDS History The immediate sequel to Chronicles is found in the books of Ezra and Ezra- Nehemiah. In the original Jewish and Greek canon they form a single Nehe- book. The separation of the book of Nehemiah under its distinct title was probably the work of Alexandrian scholars, and was adopted by Jerome. This division is not only artificial but also misleading, for as will be shown later (p. 32) parts of the original Ezra narrative are also found in Nehe- miah. The original book therefore is best designated as Ezra-Nehemiah. It begins with the decree of Cyrus in 538 B.C., and traces the priestly gen- ealogy down to the close of the Persian rule in 332, and therefore represents a period of a little over two centuries. Tts A satisfactory analysis of it in its present form is impossible, for its con- tents stituent parts have evidently been disarranged. Thus for example, the con- clusion of the Ezra narrative is found in Nehemiah 7^0-10^° in the midst of Nehemiah's account of the rebuilding of the walls, which begins in 1-6 and is concluded in 12""^^. Nehemiah 12^'^* also contains a list of the priests and Levites wJio went uj) tvith Zcrubhahel and Jeshua, which has no ob- vious connection with its context. As it now stands Ezra-Nehemiah con- sists of six general divisions: (1) an account of the events which resulted in the restoration of the temple, Ezra 1-6; (2) a description of the expedition of Ezra and his preliminary reforms, 7-10; (3) Nehemiah's history of his work in rebuilding the walls of Jerusalem and restoring the Judeah com- munity, Nehemiah V-7^^; (4) an account of the reading of the law by Ezra and the public confession which was followed by the acceptance of the new code by the Jewish community, 7'''-10^*; (5) a census of the Jews in Palestine, with a list of the priests and Levites, 11^-12^*; (6) Nehemiah's description of the dedication of the walls and of his later reform measures, 12"-13^^ Period The narrative of Israel's history is taken up where Ezra-Nehemiah leaves covere jj. ^^ j Maccabees, which begins with Alexander's Asiatic conquests in I Mac- 333-332 B.C. and ends with the death of the Hasmonean ruler Simon, in 135 B.C. Like Ezra-Nehemiah it, therefore, represents a period of about two centuries. The events preceding the reign of Antiochus Epiphanes (176 B.C.) are passed over briefly, but from this time on they are recorded in chronological order and with a fulness and historic proportion unsur- passed in any other Jewish narrative. Its ?on- It consists of four general divisions- (1) an introduction briefly describing the origin of the Seleucid empire and the attempt of Antiochus Epiphanes to abolish the Jewish religion, 1 ; (2) the history of the successful struggle for religious freedom led by Judas Maccabeus, 2-6; (3) the record of the wars and alliances by which the Jews finally secured political independence, 7-12; (4) the history of Simon's benign rule, 13-16. Period Second Maccabees is parallel to I Maccabees, but deals with a much by briefer period. It begins with the accession of Antiochus Epiphanes and cabees°" ^^^^^^ wiih. the restoration of the temple service and the death of Nicanor in 161 B.C. It pictures in great detail the horrors of the religious persecu- tion and the bravery of the martyrs for the law. The parallels with I Macca- bees are closest in the accounts of the wars of Judas, which occupy the second half of the book (8-15). 8 tent THEIR ORIGIN AND PRESENT LITERARY FORM In its present form it contains five general divisions: (1) two letters pur- Its con- porting to have been sent by the Jews of Palestine to the Jews of Egypt urging ^^^^^ them to observe the feast of Dedication, l'-2'*; (2) the author's preface, 019-32. ^3^ jj description of the events which led up to the persecution, 3-5; (4) an account of the persecution and the endurance of the faithful, 6, 7; (5) the history of Judas's wars and victories, 8-15. Although it is a popular story rather than a history, the book of Esther Theme may also be included with Israel's historical and biographical narratives, char- because it reflects the pride and hatred with which the Jews during the ^^^er of Maccabean period regarded their heathen neighbors, with whom they were book of constantly brought into close and painful contact. Like the apocryphal ^®*"®'" book of Tobit, which also belongs to the same class of literature, it throws light indirectly upon the life of the Jews of the dispersion, among whom were probably to be found in the later centuries fully half of the members of that persecuted race. The story is a closely knit literary unit, is viv- idly told, and abounds in dramatic contrasts and the effective dialogues which constitute the charm of the earlier Old Testament narratives. Viewed as literature, the historical and biographical narratives as a whole General constitute an exceedingly attractive and important department of the Old acfer of Testament library. They are concrete, vivid, realistic portraits of the com- J^e Old plex life of ancient Israel. Their literary forms are almost as varied as ment their themes. Brief annals, genealogical lists, personal memoirs, impas- ical°'' sioned orations, songs of lamentations, popular traditions, didactic stories, ''J^""- and historical romances are all represented. Viewed as the record of nine centuries of Israel's national experiences they are unique among the writings of antiquity because of the relative completeness and exactness of the picture which they present. The important events and epochs are usually portrayed with great fulness, while the unimportant are passed over rapidly or in silence. The duplicate narratives make it possible to study the vital facts from very different points of view. The significant characters in the history and their acts also stand out in clear relief. Intimate acquaintance with the men who made Israelitish history discloses the dominant tendencies of each age and the forces which influenced it. Above all, these Old Testa- ment narratives at every f)oint call attention to the divine guidance and purpose which moulded Israel's history and made it not merely the record of the life of an insignificant race, but a transccndently important chapter in the history of humanity, for through the life of that race God was reveal- ing his character and will to the world. II THE EARLIER HISTORIES AND BIOGRAPHIES INCOR- PORATED IN SAMUEL AND KINGS The The historical value of the great prophetic record in the books of Samuel growth ^^^ Kings is due to the fact that it consists for the most part of verbatim Sam- quotations from earlier histories and biographies. The determination of Kings their character and date is therefore not only interesting but also absolutely essential before they can be used in reconstructing the true outlines of Israei- ilish history. The growth of these books was gradual and the process nearly as complex as in the case of the opening books of the Old Testament. No sharp hne of demarcation sejjarates the one group from the other. Con- temporaneously and as the result of similar forces, each took form. They drew their data from the same fund of common tradition, and doubtless in many cases the same authors or at least school of authors contributed to each. The following chapter aims simply at giving a clear outline of the conclusions presented in this volume regarding the nature of the sources which underlie Samuel and Kings, and their literary history. The detailed reasons and analyses will be given in connection with the text (for a graphic representation of the different sources and their relations to each other and to the completed book, compare the Frontispiece to this volume). I. The Early Judean Saul and David Narratives The The original book of Judges closed abruptly in chapters 13-16 with an stories account of the Philistine advance and Samson's ill-organized and futile counter-attacks. The original sequel to these in the early Judean pro- phetic narratives appears to be embedded in I Samuel 4, which tells of the repeated defeats of the Israelites by the Philistines and of the loss of the ark. The subsequent fortunes of this sacred palladium, which already has figured most prominently in the Judean narratives (cf. Vol. I, §§79, 86), and which found its final resting place in the southern capital and sanctuary, are re- counted in 5'-7^ Possibly these popular narratives were once taken from a cycle of stories which centred about the ark itself, but their present lan- guage, picturesque literary form, and natural representation, reveal their relationship to the products of the early Judean prophetic school. Saul From the same point of view and in the same literary style are written sfories°^the vivid stories in 9'-10'^ II'-"' l^^ 13^~U*\ They also assume precisely the conditions pictured in 4-6. They tell of the natural steps whereby Saul was made king and wrested from the Philistines the independence lost when the ark fell into the hands of those strong foes. These Saul stories constitute a closely knit literary unit. The character and work of Israel's 10 EARLIER HISTORIES IX SAMUEL AND KINGS first king are presented sympathetically and appreciatively. Samuel does not oppose, but rather works earnestly for the establishment of the kingdom. Circumstances force the people to take the successive steps which ultimately led to union and national independence. As in the case of the different groups of the patriarchal stories (Vol. I, pp. 22, 23), these traditions were probablv found originally in the form of a Saul cycle and then incorporated in their larger history of Israel by the early Judean historians. They may therefore be appropriately designated as the earhj Judean Saul narra- tives. With 16'^--^ the point of view perceptibly changes. Henceforth David EarL is the central object of interest and Saul suffers by contrast. The facts and narra- conditions, however, presented in the preceding early Judean narratives ti^'es are assumed. The same vivid style and picturesque words and expressions recur. The representation is natural and the historical motive is prominent. Again the conviction deepens that the group of stories which from this point run through II Kings 2, picturing realistically the fortunes and achievements of David, is the sequel of the preceding Judean narratives, but that originally thev were drawn from that largest and most important cycle of stories in the Old Testament, which gathered about the character of Israel's popular hero and conqueror-king. They may therefore be designated as the early Judean David narratives. These narratives are found in I Samuel lG'^-17"' ''-'°' «""■ ='-^ 18«-«' Their 12-16. :o-29:.^ 191-17^ 201-39^ 2V'\ 22'~23''\ 2.3=-28% 29-31, II Samuel l^"*' "• '"- Hlf^ i7_3i.7_5i3. 17-24^ g^ g7-io^ 9'-21'*, 23'-^^ 24, I Kings 1, 2'^-^^ Many of them unity stand alone by themselves as complete stories, and it is possible that, as is maintained by some scholars, those found in II Samuel 9-20 originally con- stituted an independent group, but the unity of the David stories as a whole is very marked. Not only are they written in the same style and char- acterized by the same familiar idioms, but the same conceptions of the events of the history and of the chief characters constantly recur. David in his declining years, overshadowed by his great sin, is not so attractive as the hero of the earlier struggles, but he is still the object of the nation's love, the great king whose earlier achievements the people cannot forget (II Sam. 19). The Joab of II Samuel 18 and 20 is identical with the bold, unscrupulous general of II Samuel 3. The unique friendship between David and Jonathan and its dark background, the hatred and jealousy of the house of Saul, run through and bind together all these stories. A'iewed either as literature or as historical sources, the early Judean David Their narratives are unsurjiassed by any others in the Old Testament. The acter pictures which they give of the actors and events in this epoch-making period j'fjjg^y in Israel's history are not only interesting and full of life and local color, but they may be accepted as substantially true, even in detail, to the histor- ical facts. They and the related Saul stories prol)ably represent the first extensive Hebrew writings. The impressions which the stirring events recorded made upon the p()f)nlar mind were exceedingly vivid. It was dr)ii})fless because of their great iiiiporlance and universal interest that the iiiijjulse to commit them to writing was first felt by Israel's patriotic his- 11 date ISRAEL'S HISTORICAL RECORDS torians. This conclusion is fully confirmed by their character. As the earliest product of the Judean prophetic school, they naturally have certain characteristics pecuhar to themselves, partly due to their priority and partly to the nature of the original traditions which they embody. They appear to have shaped the ideas, determined the methods, and given the inspiration to the early Judean writers, which led them subsequently to collect the traditions regarding the period of the Judges and then of each preceding period, until they traced their history back to the first man in the Garden of Eden (cf. Vol. I, pp. 18, 19). Their From their themes and literary character, as well as from their relation to the longer Judean narrative, it may be fairly inferred that the Saul and David histories were written not very long after, if not before, the division of the Hebrew empire at the death of Solomon. There is in them no reflec- tion of the hostility between the North and South which immediately fol- lowed that event. The later reign of Jehoshaphat (876-851 B.C.), when the armies of the two kingdoms again fought side by side and when the polit- ical, commercial, and probably the intellectual life was very active, furnishes a most natural background for the work of the prophets who gleaned them from the mouth of the people and committed them to writing. 2. The Later Ephraimite Samuel Narratives Ab- In view of the division of the Hebrew empire at the death of Solomon oMlfe ^^"^ ^^^^ bitterness engendered in the North against the house of David, early the Northern or Ephraimite historians had little desire or incentive to record imite the glories of the united kingdom. These belonged in a peculiar sense to tiveTin ^^^^ South. Moreover, the Judean records were so complete that there was Samuel no necessity for the late prophetic editors to draw from the traditions of the North, which perhaps presented the darker side of these reigns in a manner not altogether agreeable to the conceptions of later Judean editors. Whatever are the real reasons, there is no clear evidence of citations in Samuel and Kings from the early Ephraimite prophetic narratives. With the accounts of the achievements of the northern heroes recounted in Judges, the quo- tations in the Old Testament from this early source apparently cease, except as the stories of Elijah (corresponding to the Saul and David stories in their relation to the Judean narratives) probably represent the prototype of the writing of this school (cf. p. 18). The Side by side, however, with the Judean account of the establishment of narra-^* the monarchy is a connected series of narratives which have all the character- tives istics of the later Ephraimite source. They recount the deeds of a prophet — Samuel of Ramah in the North. In these later narratives he is conceived of as judging the people, as did Moses according to the related tradition of Exodus 18. Like his great predecessor, he rules as Jehovah's regent over all Israel (cf. Vol. I, pp. 38, 39). TMien the people confess their sin (7^ 12'"; cf. Num. 14", Judg. lO'"' '^), Samuel intercedes for them (7^ 8"; cf. Gen. 207. 27. ]S[um. ll^ 21"), and Jehovah miraculously delivers them from their powerful foes. 12 EARLIER HISTORIES IN SAMUEL AND KINGS In the early Judean narratives the kingship is regarded as so desirable Evi- that Samuel persuades Saul to assume the leadership, and in the late pro- ^^°j® plietic or Deuteronomie as a necessary institution, the abuses of which must ^^^y be carefully guarded against (Dt. IT^^-^"). In I Samuel 8 and 12, how- from ever, it is absolutely condemned in almost the same terms as were the kings Ephra- of his day by the Ephraimite prophet Hosea (cf. I Sam. 8 and Hos. 8*\ '^"jj^^j 13''). Many other minor indications, as for example, the reference to a sacred stone or pillar (I Sam. 7'-), still regarded as I'-gitimate in the Ephraim- ite narratives (Vol. I, p. 40), but sternly forbidden in the late prophetic, leave little doubt that this peculiar conception of the history and the work of Samuel originated in the Northern prophetic guilds. These narratives are found in I Samuel V-5\ T^^-S", W'', 12 and 15. Their The interest throughout is rehgious rather than political. The purpose is 1°^l^ didactic rather than historical. The whole is a popular biography of Samuel and^^ rather than a parallel history of the period. It begins with the account of his birth, consecration, early life at Shiloh, and call to be a prophet; but throughout the stories, the attention is focussed on Samuel, the man of God, rather than on Samuel, the individual. That all Israel was led by a prophetic representative of Jehovah, as in the days of Moses, is assumed. The super- natural is prominent. The same peculiar conceptions and point of view reappear in the Elijah and Elisha stories of I Kings 20-11 Kings 15. The kinship of these three groups of traditions is clearly very close. They were undoubtedly cherished in the same prophetic circle in the North — probably many of them at the sanctuary of Gilgal near Shiloh, which appears to have become the inheritor of its traditions when the older shrine was destroyed by the Philistines (Jer. 19\ cf. note § 3). Some time after the days of Hosea and before Josiah's reformation in Their 621 B.C. the cycle of Samuel stories, together with kindred products of the ^^*^ later Ephraimite prophetic school, was committed to writing. Whether or not it originally existed independently for a period is a question which can never be absolutely decided, and which is of only secondary importance. 3. Very Late Popular Prophetic Traditions In I Samuel 1535b_i6i3, 19'»-20'% I Kings W-}3'\ 20''-'\ II Kings p-'" char- are found certain stories which are related in many ways to the preceding f^fj"' groii{)s. They illustrate the later belief in the dominant, almost supernatural and position assumed by the earlier proi)hets in the life of the nation. They the late were evidently retold for generations in i)rophetic circles. While related, {^",',1"''^'' this group evidently reflects a still later conception of the proph(>ts than phet^c the Samuel cycle. Their real ethical and religious work is almost forgotten tions and the men of God are conceived of as mere wonder-workers. Thus for example in I Samuel 19'^-" the messengers of Saul, and later the king him- self, fall down in ecstasy before Samuel, or in II Kings l^-'" the military com- panies sent by Ahaziah are consumed by fire from heaven at the command of VAi'y.ih. Evidently the popular iinaginalion has contributed nuicli to the stories. They recall the midrashim or late Jewish didactic tales (cf. p. 26). 18 ISRAEL'S HISTORICAL RECORDS While it cannot be maintained that they are all from the same school or date, they reflect the same very late point of view. 4. Popular Judean David Stories Con- From the lips of the people also doubtless came the variant versions of and*'' the more important incidents in David's early life, as for example, his con- history ^psj ^y[i\i Goliath, his marriage with Saul's daughter, the king's futile attempt popular to kill him, and his magnanimity in sparing Saul's life. A comparison shows l^vici'^ that they are clearly duplicates of the corresponding early Judean narratives, stones })ut here the stories are told with slight variations; details and names are usually forgotten, the coloring is heightened, and the language illustrates the effects of their having been retold from generation to generation. The same love and admiration for David are revealed, only he has been so com- pletely idealized that his faults and sins have been forgotten. The scenes are most of them laid in Southern Judah. It is difficult to conceive that they originally came from any other source than the memories of his fellow- clansmen in the South. The popular version of the story of his contest with Goliath, which was probably added to the Hebrew text at a very late date, since it is not found in the earliest Greek version, may well have been cherished at Bethlehem in Judah. Their The popular David stories are found in I Samuel IT'^-^^' "■ ="• ^^-^\ 18'-'- date ,0. u. 17-19. 29b. 30^ ^V'-'"', 23"^-24", II Samuel P"^". Most of these were evi- place dently committed to writing before the late prophetic editor compiled his books history of the period — that is before the first capture of Jerusalem in 597 b.c. Samuel ^^ his zeal to preserve everything known regarding David, he made the early Judean narratives the basis of his history from I Samuel 16 on, and then supplemented them by the popular traditions, not welding the dupli- cates closely together as is often done by early editors in the first seven books of the Old Testament, but giving each a different setting. The one excep- tion to this rule is found in I Samuel 17 and 18, and is clearly the work of a still later editor. 5. The Book of the Acts of Solomon The With the reign of Solomon a new era in Hebrew history opened. The acti'vity alliances with neighboring peoples, and especially the Phoenicians, intro- in Sol- (Juced foreign culture. The ambition of the king was to brine; his people omon s .... .. reiga and kingdom into line with those of contemporary Semitic potentates. The emphasis was placed on the development of his court and capital rather than upon conquest. Literature, as well as art, was probably encouraged by him. In addition to the chancellor or recorder, two scribes were counted among the important officials of his court (I Kgs. 4'). Their duty was probably primarily to conduct the royal correspondence, but for diplomatic reasons, if for no other, a record of the most important events of each reign would also be needed for reference. Hence from the days of Solomon it appears that the Hebrew historians were not dependent upon popular memory and tradition, but had access to brief contemporary annals for the more 14 EARLIER HISTORIES IN SAMUEL AND KINGS important political facts. Here, therefore, the Judean prophetic history properly ends, for the task of its authors was to collect and put in literary form the inherited traditions regarding the period antedating that of con- temporary records. At the same time it is clear that the connection Avas very close between the work of the southern annalists and that of the Judean historians, for the one was the virtual successor of the other. The compiler of Kings refers his readers for further details to what ap- Refer- pears to have been three distinct historical works. They must have been earfy *^*' extant and accessible in his day, and, we may infer from the form of his Hebrew references that they were well known. They are the Book of the Acts (or tories Events) of Solomon (I Kgs.ll"), the Chronicles (lit.. Book of the Acts of Days) of the Kings of Israel, and the corresponding Chronicles of the Kings of Judah. It is reasonable to conclude that these histories, to which he frequently refers, were also among the chief sources from which he him- self drew his political facts regarding the earlier periods. The character and aim of his work and the form of his allusions to them further indicate that he simply quoted from them that which was adapted to his more dis- tinctively religious and pragmatic purpose. That these older histories were more than mere annals is clearly indicated. Their The reference in I Kings 11" is to the point: Now the rest of the acts of acter Solomon and all that he did and his wisdom, are they not recorded in the Book of the Ads of Solomon? The same inference is confirmed by the al- lusions to the contents of the Chronicles (cf. p. 16). The term Book in this connection also implies a continuous, more or less expanded history. The Chronicles recorded the events of many different centuries. Their his- torical value depended upon the fact that they were compiled from older sources. The work of other authors appears to have been simply to com- bine and expand the earlier material. The state annals appear to have been the basis of their work and the expansion at important points to have been accomplished by introducing long ciuotations from existing histories of important kings and reigns like those of Jeroboam, Ahab, and Jehu. For the Book of the Acts of Solomon, two and possibly three sources ap- Earlier pear to have been utilized. The detailed, annalistic material, for example fn^or-^^ i^ 41-19. 22. 23, 26-28^ 5i_7i2^ 910-29^ iQiu 12-1125^^^8 prcsumably taken from the P^\^^'^ annals of his reign. Only written records would preserve many of the rec- Acts of ondite facts there found. From the same source may have come the detailed ^o°" data regarding the ornamentation, furnishing, and dedication of the tem- ple in 7"-8'\ but they would more naturally be kept in the temple records, citations from which appear later in Kings (cf. p. 17). With these may be comf)ared the Babylonian temple accounts which come from a very early period (cf. Johns, Bab. and Assyr. Laxcs, Contracts, and Letters, p. 295). Finally there are found in I Kings 3^"^^ and lO'"'"- ^^ certain po[)ular tradi- tions, evidently of early origin, which illustrate Solomon's wisdom. If the reference to the record of the king's wisdom in 11" is original it would strengthen the conclusion that those traditions were found in the Book of the Acts of Solomon, although these, like the popular David stories, may well have been added by the late prophetic editor. 15 ISRAEL'S HISTORICAL RECORDS Its In I Kings 3-11 are found also many late prophetic passages evidently acfer riot from the Book of the Acts, but the original quotations from it suggest ^^'^ its general character. It was a reasonably comprehensive history dealing with the political and religious events of Solomon's reign. Its primary aim was not religious but rather to record facts. The tendency, however, to idealize Solomon and his reign, which became very marked in later genera- tions, is apparent. The author was evidently a Judean and probably lived not earlier than 800 B.C. He may well have belonged to the early Judean prophetic school. His purpose was to carry the Judean history down to the division of the Hebrew kingdom. Repetition of the same notices in different settings further suggests that his work was supplemented and pos- sibly rearranged before it was used by the late prophetic editor. 6. The Israelitish and Judean Royal Chronicles Char- The author of the present book of Kings always refers to the Chronicles the ° of the Kings of Israel and the Chronicles of the Kings of Jiidah as if they chron- ^^^^ distiiict books. Their titles also suggest that they were originally in- icles dependent. This conclusion is confirmed hj the fact that the same events, as for example the campaign of Hazael (II Kgs. 10^-, 13^ cf. 12'^' ^'), are recorded twice in quotations apparently taken from these histories, each describing the invasion as it affected one of the two Hebrew kingdoms and ignoring its effects upon the other. The character and contents of the Chronicles appear to have been very similar to those of the Book of the A cts of Solomon. Their exact title, Book of the A cts of Days of the Kings, sug- gests that they were histories containing detailed records of events, arranged in chronological order, and that their chief sources were the older annals of the two kingdoms. The thirty-one references which the editor of Kings makes to them and their contents and the quotations which he evidently cites from them establish their character. In the first place they included a continuous and complete history of all the difi"erent reigns. In the case of all the kings except Jehoram, Ahaziah, Hoshea, Jehoahaz, Jehoiachin, and Zedekiah, who met untimely fates, the editor explicitly states that the Chronicles recorded the deeds of each. Their For twenty-three distinct items the reader is referred for information or tents fuller details to the Chronicles. Some of these facts are: Jeroboam's wars, the mighty deeds of Baasha, the treason of Zimri, Ahab's ivory house, the cities built by Asa, Hezekiah's construction of the pool and conduit, and Manasseh's sin. They deal chiefly with secular subjects, such as the wars, building enterprises, successes, and the material splendors of each reign. Their attitude toward most of the kings appears to have been commenda- tory — in striking antithesis to the adverse judgment passed upon them for religious reasons by the author of Kings. The implication of his references to these histories is that they contained many more details than he saw fit to introduce in his brief summaries. Like the A cts of Solomon, they doubt- less contained quotations from older sources. These were, as in the Acts of Solomon, the independent annals of the two kingdoms. The citations 16 E.\RLIER HISTORIES IN SA:MUEL AND KINGS were probably in most cases transcribed verbatim and, having been again quoted by the editor of Kings, found a place in our present books. They can be recognized by their brief sententious form and by their use of certain expressions, as then or at that time, and the pecuhar use of the personal pro- noun (for the corresponding Babylonian synchronistic chronicle, compare Appendix X). The author of the Chronicles of tJie Kings of Judah appears also to have Their had access to temple records. Extracts from these are found in IJ Kings 11, tempfe 12, IG*"-!* and 22^-23^^ In these passages the attention is focussed not on records the king and the fortunes of the kingdom, but upon the temple and its ritual. As in ancient Babylonia, many of the priests were probably scribes, and that they would keep a record of the more important events in the temple history was most natural. The desire to expand these brief records into fuller narratives would also later be felt. They represent the antecedent? of the much later temple and institutional history found in Chronicles and Ezra-Nehemiah. That quotations from the temple records had already been incorporated in the Chronicles, to which the editor of Kings refers as his main source, is at least probable, although not certain. It is also significant that the citations in II Kings 16 are joined immediately to material taken from the state annals, with no trace of the harmonistic or introductory clauses which the editor usually adds when he himself unites quotations from different sources. The authors of the Chronicles of the Kings of Israel, on the other hand. Also appear to have drawn from the older private histories of important kings ^[gj^ ® Hke Jeroboam (I Kgs. iP^-^i. ", 12i-'^), Ahab (20'-'\ 22'""), Jehu (II Kgs. tories 9'-10-'). These personal histories correspond very closely to the early Saul and David histories in Samuel. They were probably not written during the lifetime, but a generation or two after the death of the given king. They give a natural and at the same time sympathetic and favorable portrait of him and the events of his reign. The resulting picture is often in striking contrast to the very different estimates found in the prophetic sources and in the epitomes of the editor of Kings. Quotations from the Chronicles and references to them cease with the Period reign of Jehoiakim (II Kgs. 24''). They contain none of the expressions ^y^fhe*^ and ideas peculiar to the late prophetic school which dominated the thought (y'ron- of the exile. It would seem, therefore, that they were composed some time not long after 597 B.C., between the first and second captivities. Possibly the work was begun earlier, and the data regarding the later reigns added as appendices by subsequent writers. The Chronicles of the Kings of Israel probably attained their final form shortly after the fall of Samaria in 722 B.C. Together fhey carried the two great histories of the North and South practically down to the final destruction of both kingdoms. 7. The Early Ephraimite Elijah Stories With I Kings 17 is suddenly introduced a unicpie form of narrative. The brief quotations and annalistic style of the preceding chapters are supplanted 17 ISRAEL'S HISTORICAL RECORDS Char- by a picturesque, detailed story. Interest is centred not in the kings of acter and Israel, but in Elijah the Tishbite; not in the insurrections and wars, but in date of the religious and social life of the nation. Towering above the king and EUjah dominating the history is the commanding personahty of the great prophet stones ^j£ Gilead. As the spokesman of Jehovah, hke Moses in the early prophetic or Samuel in the later Ephraimite narratives, he moulds the history. At the same time there is a freshness, a concreteness, a directness in the lan- guage, and a naturalness and reserve in the representation which stamp the stories as comparatively early. The worship at the public shrines like Bethel and Dan, with their golden calves, receives no censure, as it does in the sermons of Amos and Hosea. The toleration and popular identification of the Baal-cult with that of Jehovah are the chief objects of attack. They therefore clearly antedate 750 B.C., when Amos appeared at Bethel with his revolutionary message. On the other hand, the character of Elijah has begun to be clothed with a certain mystery. The tone of the narratives suggests that the traditions which they embody were not committed to writing until a generation or two after the great prophet had passed away. Their approximate date may accordingly be fixed not long after 800 b.c. Their The stories were doubtless treasured in prophetic circles and later kept history -^^ written form. The spirit and point of view, as well as the direct refer- ence to Judah in 19^ as a foreign nation, demonstrate that they came from Northern Israel. Occasional expressions, like ajter these things {W\ 21'), the designation of the sacred mountain as Horeh (19-), and above all the commanding role attributed to the prophet proclaim the kinship of these with the early Ephraimite prophetic narratives in the opening books of the Old Testament (cf. Vol. I, 37-40). Of the two, however, the Elijah stories seem to be the more primitive. They were probably the nucleus about which gathered the similar narratives which ultimately traced the history of the theocratic people back to the days of Abraham. In their light it is for the first time possible fully to understand why this school conceived of the earliest prophets as clothed with almost omnipotent authority and, like Elijah and Isaiah of a later and very different age, shaping from the first the history of the Israelitish race. Their In the Greek version the narratives of 17-19 are continued immediately exte'nt^ by 21, and in this order they probably stood in the original text. Extracts from the same source appear in II Kings 1. That they are but extracts from a more complete biography of Elijah is clearly shown by the abruptness with which he is introduced in 17 — many facts being assumed which are nowhere stated in the fragments which have been preserved — and by the incompleteness of the biography as it stands. Following his usual method only those sections were quoted which conserved the broad purpose of the prophetic editor of Kings. 8. The Gilgal Cycle of Popular Elisha Stories In II Kings 2'-8'', 13'^-^' is found a collection of narratives which centre about Elisha. They have all the characteristics of stories long transmitted 18 EARLIER HISTORIES IN SAMUEL AND KINGS from mouth to mouth. Details regarding the exact setting and the names De- of the reigning kings have been lost. The supernatural elements are promi- p®"*^ nent and the ethical motives are often obscured. In these Elisha figures of the as the man of God, the great wonder-worker. That they are later and storie; modelled after the early EHjah narratives is demonstrated by the fact that ^1^°^ the same elements and in some cases almost the identical stories reap- Elijah pear in enlarged proportions. Thus for example, the story of the widow's ^^°^^ meal and jar of oil that failed not (I Kgs. 17-""') reappears in the account of the widow's pot of oil which did not fail until she had, at Elisha's command, drawn enough from it to defray all her debts (II Kgs. 4'"'). Closely similar to the account of the reviving of the widow's son by Elijah (I Kgs. l?"-^^) is the story of his resuscitating the Shunamniite's son (II Kgs. 4*"^'). It would seem that just as the same tale of deception regarding his wife was twice told about Abraham in different settings and once about I.saac (cf. Vol. I, §13), so in popular tradition, not only the mantle, but also the repu- tation of Elijah fell upon his chief disciple. The Elisha stories are not as closely knit together as are the Elijah narra- The tives. They are rather a bundle of anecdotes, each complete in itself. Minor (iYc.°inct inconsistencies also indicate that they were originally taken from at least two cycles distinct groups. Thus for example in 5" Gehazi is a leper and therefore Elisha an outcast, but in 8^ he is introduced conversing with the king and is still ^*"''"^ the trusted ser\'ant of the man of God. There is not the slightest reference to the incurable disease with which, according to 5", he was afflicted. In one cycle of stories Elisha is represented as residing at Gilgal. This is evidently not the Gilgal near Jericho but the sanctuary southeast of Shiloh (cf. 2'"^). There he lives in close association with the guild of the sons of the prophets which was located at that place (4'*""). In this cycle there are frequent references to these sons of the prophets and their wives. Furthermore, the stories without exception all relate to the events of private life, and they re- semble most those found in the early Elijah group. Evidently they were treasured on the lips of the people living in the West Jordan valley, not far from Elisha's home at Abel-^Ieholah, and were probably first collected by some member of the pro{)hetic guild at the neighboring town of Gilgal. In the Gilgal cycle may be included II Kings 2, 4'''' ^'*"", 6''. It is im- Date of possible to fix their date exactly. Several generations have evidently trans- oUsal mitted them orally. They have the Northern Israelitish stamp, but since ''y^^^ the fall of Samaria in 722 B.C. did not mean the deportation of the bulk of the inhabitants of Israel, it is possible that they were not put in literary form until after that event. This later date also best accords with their general character. 9. The Samaria Cycle of Popular Elisha Stories In the ofluT cycle, whicli included the reinniiiirig stories in II Kings .3-8'*, to which may be added 14**'", Elisha is conceived of as residing at Samaria, the capital (5^, 6^*- ^^), and as being in close touch with the king and court (3", 4", 5", a"- ^^). Mo.st of the .stories reflect his activity not in private but in public life, and especially in the wars with Moab and Aram. The 19 ISRAEL'S HISTORICAL RECORDS Con- Arameans in fact figure in six out of nine stories belonging to this cycle. No and^ references are found to the sons of the prophets, but instead Gehazi is the acfer servant, ever attendant upon the prophet (4'-' "• "-36^ 520-27^ gis^ 8^). Like a of the king, Elisha is usually represented as simply giving directions or else sending maria his servant with his potent staff to work the wonders recorded. The earlier cycle stories here reflected are found not only in the Elijah group but also in the early Ahab history. Thus for example the parallel between I Kings 22 and II Kings 3 extends even to similar scenes and language (cf. II Kgs. 3'" and I Kgs. 22^"^). Close analogies may also be traced with certain of the pa- triarchal stories, as for example the prediction that the Shunammite woman should have a son before a year had passed (cf. 4'^ and Gen. 18'^). Its It is difficult to determine which of these cycles is the older. They doubt- less grew up contemporaneously. The Samaria group, however, clearly embodies more historical data and probably was committed to writing before the fall of that city in 722 e.g. The fact that Samaria was a literary centre would facilitate the process. These tvvO cycles of popular Elisha stories were apparently combined — citations being taken alternately from each — before they were incorporated as II Kings. The fact that they are all introduced together and have received practically no editorial revision probably indicates that they were among the latest additions to the book. It is more than possible that they came into the possession of the late prophetic editor as a result of the conquests and reforming expeditions of Josiah, which, according to II Kings 23'^' ^"j extended to the sanctuaries of Samaria. ID. The Isaiah Stories Con- It was most natural that in later generations among Isaiah's disciples and there should also grow up a cycle of stories associated with him and preserv- '^'^f''" p ing in traditional form the memory of his work. Three stories from such the a group are found in II Kings 18''-20^^ (cf. ^§ 122, 124). They are again stories quoted by the editor of the book of Isaiah in 36-39, with the further addition of a psalm which is attributed to Hezekiah (SB'"'-"). The first of these narratives is evidently a duplicate of the extract in II Kings IS'^-IO^""' 36. 37^ which was apparently taken from a Hezekiah history. In popular transmission the details of the incident have been partially forgotten ; while in the expansion of the story in 20^"", Isaiah like Elisha is conceived of as a wonder-worker. The references to the Babylonian exile in 20'^' " indicate that these stories were committed to writing after 586 b.c II. The Final Editing of the Books of Samuel and Kings Work This brief study of the sources of Samuel and Kings has sufficed to show pre- that many very early elements enter into these composite books, and that editors ^^eir growth was gradual, representing a period of fully four centuries. Their real author or authors selected the quotations from the older annals, biographies, and temple records, arranged them in their present order and, in the book of Kings, fitted them into a stereot^-ped framework (cf. p. 1 j- 20 EARLIER HISTORIES IN SAMUEL AND KINGS The language, the expressions, and the distinctively rehgious ideas of these editorial sections are those of the late prophetic group of writers who were inspired by the book of Deuteronomy and the great reform of Josiah in 621 B.C. (for a detailed list of their words and expressions, cf. Driver, LOT, pp. 200-203, Hast. DB II, pp. 859-861). The original editor of Kings carried his history down to the reign of Jehoiakim, but apparently writes from the point of view of Palestine, and while the Judean state was still standing (cf., e.g., to this den/, II Kgs. 8=^ 16^ W'-''). The exile, which quickly followed, transformed the thought of Israel's Work religious teachers so completely that a later editor, writing probably in Baby- final Ionia not long after 561 B.C., gave to the book of Kings its final form. He ^''"'o"" likewise belonged to the late prophetic school, so that it is not always easy to distinguish his work from that of his predecessor. He certainly added the account of the final destruction of Jerusalem and the liberation of Je- hoiachin in 561 B.C. The conception of Jehovah in I Kings 8"'^° and of the temple as a place of worship for all peoples is closely akin to that found in Isaiah 40-56. Also ^^' ^* seem to imply the point of view of the exile. This is also true of II Kings 21'"^'. It is probable that in their present form the prophetic addresses in I Kings 8'^-9'' and II Kings 21 ^-'\ as well as certain other minor additions, are from the latest editor. Later priests and scribes added occasional notes, but by 540 B.C. the prophetic historical books of Samuel and Kings were practically complete. SI Ill THE CHRONICLER'S ECCLESIASTICAL HISTORY OF JUDAH AND THE TEIVIPLE Con- Excepting in the three or four quotations from the temple records, the of'ifhe books of Samuel and Kings are throughout national and prophetic in their late interests. Their final editors were clearly prophets, and to the same group siasti- of religious patriots belonged the authors of most of the older sources which Mstorv ^^^ quoted. It was natural that the other prominent class of Israel's teachers, the priests, whose interests were distinctly ritualistic and ecclesiastical, should also write their own version of the history. Closely corresponding in spirit and purpose to the late priestly narratives in the Pentateuch is the parallel history of Judah found in the books of Chronicles and their direct contin- uation Ezra-Nehemiah. Identity in literary style and point of view, as well as the repetition of the opening verses of Ezra (1''^) at the close of Chron- icles (36-^' ^^), leaves no doubt that the books are all from the same author or editor, and originally constituted one continuous narrative, beginning with Adam and concluding with the account of the great priestly reformation associated with Ezra (about 400 B.C.). Its The fact that the author of this extensive history speaks of the days of Nehemiah and Ezra as though they belonged to the distant past (Neh. J228. 47^ g^j^j l^jjg kings of Persia as though he lived under a different rule (Ezra !'• ^' '' 3') at once suggests that he wrote at least from the point of view of the succeeding Greek period. Nehemiah 12" ■ ^^ also mentions Jaddua who was high-priest in 332 b.c, when Alexander conquered Pal- estine. The awkward Hebrew which he used, and the highly developed ceremonial institutions with which he is familiar, as well as his general point of view, indicate that he wrote not earlier than 300 B.C., probably about the middle of the third century. Method Again the historical value of the work turns largely upon whether the author author depended for his facts merely upon the traditions current in his own day or upon written sources, and also whether he recast the information, which he collected, in his own language, or quoted it practically verbatim from much earlier sources. An examination of his work at once demonstrates that his method, like that of the editors of Samuel and Kings, was primarilj/ compilation. Nearly half of the books of Chronicles consists of exact or slightly variant quotations from the Old Testament books of Samuel and Kings. Variations in style, point of view, and even minor inconsistencies in representation clearly indicate that the greater part of Ezra-Nehemiah, and probably certain of the remaining portions of Chronicles, were taken bodily from older written sources. The real work of the writer of Chronicles and Ezra-Nehemiah was therefore not primarily that of an original author 22 THE CHRONICLER'S ECCLESL\STICAL HISTORY but of a compiler and editor. An appreciation of this fact is essential to an understanding of his unique history. It also tends to enhance its historical value, for it is obvious that in general the nearer the records stand to the events the greater their accuracy and authenticity. Since his name is not known, the final editor of this extensive history may Point be conventionally designated as the Chronicler. From his modifications of and *^^ the older narrative of Samuel-Kings, from his systematic omissions, as well pequl- as from the jiassages which came originally from his pen, it is possible to de- of the termine definitely his point of view and distinctive peculiarities. Like the f ig°°' writers of the late priestly school, his interests are ecclesiastical rather than national, ritualistic rather than prophetic, and didactic rather than historical. He was interested in Judah, because in it was the temple, and in the temple, because about it gathered the ceremonial institutions which he regarded as the beginning and end of existence. History was to him important simply because it gave the background and recorded the beginnings of these insti- tutions, and because it furnished apt illustrations of the peculiar ethical and religious principles which were uppermost in his mind. In common with that post-exilic Judaism whose point of view is likewise reflected in the non- canonical writings, which he quotes, he was dominated by the natural and irresistible tendency to idealize the past and project back into it the conditions and institutions existing in his day. Thus a comparison with the older parallel narratives of Samuel and Kings at once shows that num- bers are often raised from hundreds to thousands (cf. I Chr. 22'^ II Chr. 133. 17^ 148. 9^ 17H-19, gS"' *), gold takes the place of brass, the priest of the warrior, and a miracle of the victory won by the swords in the hands of Israel's gallant defenders. David is regarded by him as the founder of the post-exilic guilds of singers and the organizer of the elaborate temple ritual, even though the sanctuary itself was not built until the days of Solomon and did not attain its dominant religious prestige until centuries later. In I Chronicles 2G he ajjy^ears even to have forgotten this fact and refers to the gates of the temple (designated by their Persian name) as already existing in the day of David. The Chronicler lived in an age when zeal for the ritual had almost com- Mo