WIGSTOW Discoveries in the Bacon Problem DISCOVERIES IN THE BACON PROBLEM W. F. C. WIGSTON, AUTHOR OF "BACON, SHAKESPEARE, AND THE ROSICEUCIANS ; " "HERMES STELLA; "FRANCIS BACON, THE COLUMBUS OF LITERATURE." PRINTED BY TURNBULL & SPEARS, EDINBURGH FROM WHOM COPtKS MAY UK MAI) LIBRARY UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA SANTA BARBARA PREFACE. In publishing this little pamphlet, I am in the position of a man who is in pursuit of thieves who have robbed him. Indeed, I am told it is useless my trying to recover my stolen property, for the modern literary thief, having robbed an author of his labours, is at liberty to blow out his victim's brains with the weapon he has stolen. It is a peculiarity of the Bacon-Shake- speare problem that it affords endless opportunities for the malice of private enemies, and the latest form of literary persecution is to extinguish a writer by means of his own discoveries and writings. This is very easily effected by unscrupulous persons, who, oblivious of the rights of private property, would pluck out even the heart of Hamlet's mystery by prying into his port- manteau or papers. To lovers of fair-play I must leave the judgment, whether I have been robbed of the discoveries which form the argument of the following chapters, and which, by word of mouth, have been handed about London some little time 1 I lay claim to these discoveries, and everybody knows whence they came from. It is very easy to cut a man out by means of his own labours. It may not, be a very pleasant process for the sufferer, but it can be borne, for is it not his own work after all? The truth of being and the truth of knowing are all one. CHAPTER I. POLLIO AND EUPOLIS IN BACON'S "HOLY WAR." The persons who speak in Bacon's "Holy War," which is cast in the form of a dialogue, are Eusebius, Gamaliel, Zebedseus, Martius, Eupolis, Pollio. Bacon opens the piece thus : " There met at Paris (in the House of Eupolis) Eusebius, Zebedaeus, Gamaliel, Martius ; all persons of eminent quality, but of several dispositions. Eupolis himself was also present. And while they were set in conference, Pollio came into them from court. And as soon as he saw them, after his witty and pleasant manner he said : — " Pollio. Here be four of you, I think were able to make a good world ; for you are as differing as the four elements, and yet you are friends. As for Eupolis, because he is temperate, and without passion, he may be the fifth essence. "Eupolis. If Ave five (Pollio) make the great world, you alone, may make the Little." (Bacon's "Holy War," 1G22). In examining this dialogue, the first thing thai strikes one (throughout the entire writing) is the prominence given to Pollio and Eupolis. In the first place the meeting is in the house of Eupolis. The next point to notice is the importance of Pollio, who opens the dialogue and is described as coming from court and as a wit. Hut, in the description of Pollio, as the Little World, or Microcosm, of which Eour others are described as the Great World, or Macrocosm, it is remarkable to find Eupolis left out, and Pollio playing as it. were a representative part, in himself. A POLLIO A VD EC/Pi '//.s l have already pointed out in my last work wa a drnn i roll known. Eupolis was the name oi a Comic right who was born B.C. 146. Like Pollio, he seems fond of bringing <>ut his pieces anonymously or under •• In lii- \ - ■ - he ridiculed the handsome pancratiasl of thai name." Eupolis is Baid i" have ;it tlii- piece under the name of Demostratus, probably the -.inn' as Demopseetus, .1 comic ]><»-\ mentioned by Suidas (v. Uhen. \. 216 D.). I Donaldson's "Theatre of the i ■ Eupolis, ch. \ i. sect, i.) hanes in the parabasis "t his Nubes, accuses Eupolis pying his Maricas from the Equites, which bad 1 n repre its before : — . . . a, : i name, An — (Nubes, i Eupolis was a Comic playwright nearly of the same ;i,u r <' as Aris- tophanes. The titles of more than t unity of his Comedies have been collected by Meursius. U<- was a bold and severe satirist of bis day and city. Es Eupolis introduced by •i for Shakespeare by parallel, or for himself? Eupolis is intei ecause as Comedist, Athenaeus ascribes to him a play, called y.u.-j.- -■ ■ . which was, according to Elerodian -■• Eustathius f ourselves (especially us it hits off the readily) that jest, that 'water-drinkers ami wine-drinkers cannot ly tliink alik<-.' For all other men, both ancientB and moderns, have in drunk a crude liquor like water, either springing spontaneously Uect nr drawn ap by logic, as by wheels from a well. But iik and pledge our neighbours in a liquor made from countless grir/»s, ivd gathered by clutters : CKF8HET) intiti: wine- am- LASTLY, PIKED AXD CLARIFIED in Tin: vat. And so no wonder if we I - ich in common with others" (exxiii. Book I., "Aphorisms on the Interpretation of Nature." " Novum Organum."). SYMBOLS OF DRAMATIC INSPIRATION. 7 355. It is very worthy of note that Bacon introduces again this story in his "Novum Organum " (i. 123), expressly for the purpose of illustrating how his own method or philosophy (which he compares to wine), and the philosophy of his own times differ. Dionysus or Bacchus as God of the Vine, grape and wine, was the originator of the vintage and Goat-songs, which gradually from choruses became the arts of Comedy and Tragedy. Bacon writes : " Wherefore I do conclude this part of moral knowledge, concerning the culture and regiment of the mind; wherein if any man, considering the parts thereof, which I have enumerated, do judge that my labour is but to collect into an art or science that which hath been pretermitted by others, as matters of common sense and experience, he juclgeth well : but as Philocrates sported with Demosthenes, ' You may not marvel, Athenians, that Demosthenes and I do differ, for he drinketh water, and I drink wine.' And like as we read of an ancient parable of the two gates of sleep — Sunt geminre sonini portffi, quarum altera fertur Cornea, qua veris facilis datur exitus umbris : Altera candenti perfecta nitens elephanto, Sed falsa ad coelum mittunt insomnia manes : so if we put on sobriety and attention, we shall find it a sure maxim in knowledge, that the more pleasant liquor of wine, is the more vaporous, and the braver gate of ivory sendeth forth the falser dreams" (p. 215-216, xxii. 16, Book II. "Advance- ment of Learning," Aldis Wright). This is a most important passage, so important that, indeed, if there existed no other indication of Bacon's mind save this, it would suffice to prove he was profoundly conversant with the Mysteries of the Ancient Poets, and had discovered some secret relationship between Virgil's "Georgics" and the sixth hook of the " Aineid," from which Bacon quotes, because Bacon's " Cul- ture and regiment of the Mind," which he terms Db GrEORGICIS ANIMI, is clearly borrowed for its title from Virgil's " Georgics." AND WINE AS And the double reference t" Wink, with which the passage is mint, i- undoubtedly ;i profound hint for the Theatre or [ins, the li 1 '• ots using the word Wine frequently nym for poetic inspiration and dramatic enthusiasm. The stud. m will also observe the important and Btriking fact that the Philocrates and Demosthenes touching water and is introduced with purpose by Bacon. Aldis Wrighl points out in his ni'tr- thai this Btory is made use of by Bacon in the "N< ■ ■■ Organum"(i. 123) for illustrating th differenct bet ■In/, which li> compares to wine, and the philosophy which was current in his time (p. 32 1-322, notes, A. Wright, " Two 1'" of ] ■ aj ning "). The passage cited from Demosthenes is closely connected with the Theatre, for it was in the Theatre of Dionysus thai Demos thenes was to accept the crown. ' " Athenians," 1 said, " it' any of this comes true, be sure you praise and honour and crown men, and not m ; but if it turns out differently, lei them ntment. lam out of it altogether." "Don't be out of it now," said J'.srliinr-, interrupting; "mind yon don't want to !»■ in it another time ''Certainly," said 1, "or 1 should be acting unfairly." At which Philocrates rose in a flippant manner and said. " No wonder, men of Athens, thai 1 and Demosthenes agree nol in opinion, for he drinks water, I drink mm " and you laughed.' ("De Falsa Legati ]>. 355, and Bohn, vol. ii. 133.) "It i> to Wine," says Athenaeus, "thai the invention of matic pieces is due; they were attributed to Icaria during the vintagi Athen., lib. ii. cap. 3). According to Rolle, al Athens, in the Temple of Rhea, there was a spot consecrated under the name of Olympias, where a hole was shown through which it was supposed the waters of the deluge of Deucalion ped, and where every year honey was poured. It was added that Deucalion built this temple, and it was believed Deucalion had been at Athens. Close to this temple the tomb of Deucalion pointed out (" Diod. Sic," lib. v. p. 223). It is well to point SYMBOLS OF DRAMATIC INSPIRATION. o out one of Bacon's fables of the Wisdom of the Ancients is upon Deucalion (Rolle, p. 159, 160, vol. iii.). Another is upon Icarus. Aristotle assures us that tragedy derived its invention from the Dithyrambs which were sung in honour of Bacchus. There was no species of poetry more ancient than Dithyrambie poetry. It was a kind of poetry which was supposed to be composed in the intoxication inspired by the God Bacchus, whom it cele- brated, and Bacchic fury was indispensable for its composition. Athenseus quotes this passage from Archilochus : — " Oui, je sais entonner un brillant dithyram.be en l'honneur de Bacchus, lorsque jai'le cerveau foudroye par le vin." And this other passage of Epicharmus in his Philoctetus : — " II n'y a pas de dithyrambe ou Ton ne boit que de l'eau." — (Rolle, p. 511-513, vol. iii., vide "Athen. Deipnos.," lib. xiv. cap. 6). Rolle writes : " La tragedie etoit uniquement consacree a Bacchus " (" Schol. Arist. Rom." v. 406 ; Tacitus, lib. ii. ; Rolle, p. 195, vol. iii.). Even the Actors were consecrated to Bacchus : " Les acteurs appeles," riyj7rai biovuftaxoi (artists or workmen of Bacchus), " formoient a Athunes un corps nombreux et im- portant." When they quitted the theatre they laid their masks in the temple of Bacchus — Quisnam dixerit puer ? Quod Baccho teniplum, ulii personam adpenduntur. Horace invokes Bacchus as the God of Poetry. In the " Knights " of Aristophanes we read : — Nicias. It is best for us to drink bull's blood, for the death of Themistooles is preferable. Dem. No, by Jove, but pure xoinc to tlic good genius;* for possibly we may hit upoa some good thought. Nicias. "Pure Wine" — see now ! Are your thoughts, then, on the wine ! How could a mau when drunk hit upon any happy device ? Dem. Is it so, fellow ? You are a trifling, bubbling water-drinker. Have you the audacity to abuse wiue as an enemy to the intellect? What than The "good genius" was Bacchus {vide Potter, vol. ii, p. 379). (< , 7;7'.s AND WINE AS ... < tame, 1 t'll you, oaf bubbling -\ bumper of pure wine, \ i! • tiki' tin' cup of libatien, and offer it in tin' name of tin' 1' \ Rolle writes in his " Recherches sur le Culte de Bacchus": '• , ilit Athcnee, que I6n doit Vinvention des pieces • •lies fluent imaginces .1 [carie, bourgade de I'Attique, pendant les vendanges" (p. 160, vol. iii., vid< Athen., lil>. ii. cap. •">!. "Lea partisans d'Euhemere pr<5tendoien1 que bus avoil lui-mdme invente les Theatres «'t Lee pieces dramatiques, qu'il avoil ■ t .i l >1 i des ecoles de musique, <|u'il ptoil de boutes fonctions militaires dans bos armies " (76. '• Diod. Sic." iv. 2). B cchus was surnamed Maroneus, after the wine: — uravi tantum Marona, nee bibi. Vi< : i M irom o fo datus lumina Baccho. (Tibull. lib. iv. . Eleg. i. v. 57.) Rolle writes: "Les fetes de Bacchus cele'brees par les poetes, . toienl aussi solennelles que celles qu'ils ce'le'broienl <•]] I'honneur d'Apollon, mais avec cette difference, qu'ils Be couronnoient de lierre au lieu de laurier, et qu'ils faisoienl des libations de vin .-in- ses autels. Tu tamen •'• sacris bederse cultoribua unum Numine debueraa Bustinuisse tuo. (OvH. Eleg. iii. lib .">, v. 15.) "Perse, dans son prologue, abandonne les deites de la pfile ne, les habitans de I'Helicon, a ceus donl un lierre flexible jse les images. On placoil dans les bibliotheques les statues (.11 les bustes des poetes illustres, el ils etoient couronnes de lierre. tels Etoient ceuxqui ornoienl le beau portique qu' Anguste avoit fuit construire dans le temple d'Apollon, sur le monl Palatin. I.- pontes chantoient en I'honneur de Bacchus un hvinne Bolennel. lis le cel/'broient Burtoul pa/rce que le rin issi Bacchus avait-il le Burnom de A/oatrxa?.o; (pp. 212-213, voL iii, Rolle). 5 YMBOLS OF DRAMA TIC INSPIRA TION. 1 1 Bacon's profound distinction between Water and Wine is fully explained and illustrated by the poet Horace : — Nulla placere din nee vivere carmina possunt Qua; scribuntur aqua; potoribus. (Horat., lib. i., Epist. 19.) Martial, in the same sense, writes : — Possum nil ego sobrius : bibenti SuccuiTunt mihi quindecim poetse. ("Epig.,"lib. ii.) In the "Anthology ": — Yinum est instar equi gestat tollitque poetas. (" Antbol. Grrec.," lib. i.. Epig. Soter.) Pindar writes : — Audax est ad poculum senno. Lucian : — Pariter cum vino ingrediente loquendi accedit tiducia. The name Bacchus is derived by some from the Eolian word fta.Ti.yia, ftorpvg, a bunch of grapes, and the Athenians, according to Hesychius, called Bacchus Theoinios, and his festivals Theonia. The prize of Comedy was a jar of wine and a basket of figs. In Bacon's Essay upon Judicature, he writes : " Qui fortiter emungit elicit sanguinem, and where the wine-press is hard wrought, it yields a harsh wine, that tastes of the grape stone." The following is Mr ttpedding's translation of a passage in the De Augm. : " Certainly as we find it in wines, that those which flow freely from the first treading of the grape are sweeter than those which are squeezed out by the wine-press, because the latter taste somewhat of the stone and the rind ; so are those doctrines most wholesome and sweet which ooze out of the Scriptures when gently crushed, and are not forced into controversies and common places." This throws light upon Bacon's epithet of Vintages in the "Novum Organum." This proves he understood and applied the word and its connotations to the extracting of doctrines or interpretation out of his own writings. Applying as it does to Bacchus and the drama, nothing could be more apposite for the Theatre. CHAPTER III. BACON An All \ \\m R I in i . i : I \ l. Bai >n writes: "Bui if any ono of ripe age, unimpaired sen and purified mind, would apply himself bo Experience and bo Particulars anew, better hopes might be entertained of him. A n< 1 herein we promise ourselves the fortune of Alexander the • -. and let no one charge us with vanity before he hears the result, which has in \ iew the putl ing off of all vanity. •• Foi concerning Alexander and his exploits -iEschinea spoke thus : • We certainly do not live the life of mortal men, bul are born t'> the end thai posterity may relate and declare wonders concerning us "' (Aph. xcvii. bk. L, "Nov. Org."). Alexander the Great, in his conquesl of India, proposed Bacchus as his model, and during >i.\ days his soldiers cele- brated bhe feasts of thai God with all the excesses of intoxica- tion. Alexander the Great imitated Bacchus. For the latter, having collected an immense army, consisting both of men and women, Bet out for the conquest of India. Instead of spears and shields, his broops were armed with drums and bhyrsuses. This riotous broop spread universal consternation, but bhe intention of [Bacchus being only bo beach the cultivation of the vine, he was everywhere received as a benignant deity. Bacon writes : " When a youth, he first introduced the cultivation and dressing of vines, the method of preparing wine— whence be- coming famous, he Bubdued the world, even to the utmost bounds of the Indies" (Dionysus). Bacon's self-comparison bo Alexander the Great is again made upon pa-.- 55 (mispaged ■<:',)><{ tin- "Advancement of Learning" oi 1640. In his Distribution Preface, he declares : "Wecome not a.- Augurs bo measure countries in our minds, butas Captains BACON AS ALEXANDER THE GREAT. 13 to invade them for a conquest." I am convinced Bacon's self- parallel with Alexander is intended as a side hint for Alexander's 'pomp of Bacchus, — that is the Theatre, and its presiding God or genius. Plutarch writes : — " With much difficulty Alexander traversed this country in sixty days, and then arrived in Gedrosia. There he found provisions in abundance ; for besides that the land is fertile in itself, the neighbouring princes and grandees supplied him. After he had given his army some time to refresh them- selves, he marched in Carmania for seven days in a kind of bacchanalian procession. His chariot, which was very magnifi- cent, was drawn by eight horses. Upon it was placed a lofty platform, where he and his principal friends revelled day and night. This carriage was followed by many others, some covered with rich tapestry and purple hangings, and others shaded with branches of trees fresh gathered and flourishing. In these were the rest of the king's friends and generals, crowned with flowers and exhilarated with wine. "In this whole company there was not to be seen a buckler, a helmet, or spear ; but, instead of them, cups, flagons, and goblets. These the soldiers dipped in huge vessels of wine, and drank to each other, some as they marched along, and others seated at tables, which were placed at proper distances on the way. The whole country resounded with flutes, clarionets, and songs, and with the dances and riotous frolicks of the women. This disorderly and dissolute march was closed witli a very immodest figure, and with all the licentious ribaldry of the bacchanals, as if Bacchus himself had been present to carry on the debauch." — (Alexander.) It has been truly said of Alexander the Great, " Not less in art than by his wonderful undertakings has he acquired the title of 'The Great.' He was the greatest promoter of ail that the Avorld has ever seen, and all the artists of his time shared his munificence." The mother of Alexander the Great is said to have wandered about at the foot of Pieria, with the Mimalloncs .; V AS ALEXANDER THE GREAT. of Bacchus, and of her son it was Baid, "thai he would make the statue of * hrpheua to -w eal ." Hence may be -rru the reason Bacon introduces the fable of Pan in his " De lugmentis " on the heels <>i' Stage Plays. The expedition « » t" Bacchus, ;it the head <>t an army, into the East, is described as <>t' men and women armed with thyrsuses and cymbals, accompanied by Pan, Silenus, and ;ill the Satyrs, In the history of Pan is t" be found a myth thai goes back i«> \ idia, and is closely related to that of Silenus, for the Satyrs sometimes called Sileni. Midas pretended thai Silenus instructed him in the orgies <>t Bacchus. K. < >. Muller writes, "The Bwarms n page 53, "Merry Wives of Windsor," we find the line : — Hang-Hog is latin for Bacon, I warrant you. Upon page ^ v . " King Henry the Fifth," we find Alexander called a pig: — . What call you the town's name where Alexander tin pig was I •. Alexander the Grea . Why. I pray you, is not pig great! The pig, or the great, or the mighty, or the huge, or the magnanimous, are all one reckonings, save the i . . little variation. p. I think Alexander the Great was born in Macedon. This is, I consider, a case of Induction, of which the plays are full, [f Hog is Latin for Bacon, and Alexander is a pig (or Hog), then Bacon stands for Alexander, and vice versd. 1 should nol dream of suggesting such an apparently inconsequenl deduction, if I did nol | abundanl evidence that otic of Bacon's ids of opening up the plays (or Instauration as an entire duction by analogy. The student will find, on il collation, this sort of relationship <>r identity by a middle term most frequent in the plays, if he uses a Concordance. APPENDIX FOR PAGE 8. In the De Corona, the decree of Ctesiphon respecting the crowning of Demosthenes, directs, that the Crown should be pro- claimed in the theatre at the Dionyxia — or festival of Bacchus. ./Eschines reproached Demosthenes with being too vain to be content with the applause of his own fellow citizens, since he must needs have the crown decreed him proclaimed at the great Dionysia when all Greece was present ("Contra. Ctesiph.," vol. iii. p. 469, Orat. Att., Oxford). It is there- fore very easy to perceive that Philocrates made a smart hit at Demosthenes when he exclaimed: "He chinks water and I drink wine " — implying Demosthenes had no right to be crowned at the Dionysia. For ./Eschines and Philocrates were colleagues, the former belonging to the theatrical profession, and when Demosthenes says: "If any of this comes true, be sure you praise and honour and crown these men, and not me, I am out of it altogether " — he is inviting the smart letort : " No wonder, men of Athens, that I and Demosthenes agree not in opinion; for he is out of it altogether, and does not drink wine" — i.e., does not belong to the theatrical profession at all. To under- stand all this properly, it must be understood that the great rival of Demosthenes, ^Eschines, objected on these grounds to the crowning of Demosthenes in the Theatre of Bacchus, as if he were a dramatic writer, who had won in the contests the ivy wreath or crown given. In the Oration on the Crown, ./Eschines is ridiculed by Demosthenes as playing third parts, and assisting his mother in the rites of l'>.uclni>. Syracuse, N. Stockton, Co 3 1205 03058 e UC SOUTHERN REGI0NA 1 ^|H l |ij|fj| ™ 001 403 04'