MR 
 
 msM> 
 
 mm 


 
 AUTOBIOGRAPHY 
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 
 
 WITH AN INTRODUCTORY ESSAY 
 
 BY R. JEFFERY. 
 
 SHELDON AND COMPANY. 
 
 BOSTON: GOULD AND LINCOLN. 
 
 1868.
 
 Entered, according to Act of Congress, in the year 1868, by 
 
 SHELDON AND COMPANY, 
 In the Clerk's Office of the District Court of the Southern District of New York. 
 
 Stereotyped at the Boston Stereotype Foundry, 
 No. 19 Spring Lane.
 
 PREFACE. 
 
 AFTER Elder Jacob Knapp had concluded to go to Cali- 
 fornia, and spend the winter in holding protracted meetings 
 in that distant State, he engaged me to revise and pre- 
 pare his manuscripts for publication. In the mean time he 
 was called away from home, and I have been unable to 
 consult him, even by letter. This fact has enhanced the 
 delicacy and responsibility of my undertaking. It was not 
 intended that I should prepare an original work, but simply 
 edit the papers which the Elder might place in my hands. 
 
 I have, therefore, aimed to restrict myself to this service. 
 I have not sought to express my views, to use my illustra- 
 tions, to present my style, but his. Knowing that his long- 
 continued and widely-extended ministry had given him an 
 established reputation for originality in thought and ex- 
 pression, I have endeavored to allow him to state his own 
 views in his own way. Especially have I refrained from 
 making serious modifications of his sermons, because in 
 them the reader will look for illustrations of those char- 
 acteristics of power which, under God, have made his 
 
 (iii) 
 
 2054881
 
 iv PREFACE. 
 
 pulpit effort's so effectual in attracting and fixing the at- 
 tention of the throngs that have waited on his ministry. 
 
 It is possible that in the mention of dates, and the 
 spelling of proper names, the work will contain some 
 mistakes, as in these particulars I have followed the 
 manuscripts before me, except in those cases where my 
 own knowledge of the references has enabled me to act 
 independently. For the statements of occurrences and the 
 views of doctrine I do not hold myself responsible. 
 
 I regret that the limited time allotted me has not per- 
 mitted me to execute my task more satisfactorily ; but 
 I bring my labors to a- close with the conviction that the 
 services of Elder Knapp deserve an elaborate presentation, 
 and with the prayer that the perusal of this book may 
 make him a blessing to those who have never seen his 
 face or heard his voice. 
 
 E. JEFFERY. 
 
 CHICAGO, ILLINOIS, December, 1867. 

 
 CONTENTS. 
 
 EDITORIAL PREFACE iii 
 
 iNTRODUCTORr ESSAY ELDER KjTAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. . . T 
 
 AUTOBIOGRAPHY. 
 INTRODUCTION 11 
 
 CHAPTER I. 
 
 Birth, Parentage, and early Religious Instructions. Experience of 
 Conviction and Conversion. Backsliding. Removal West. 
 Attending School in the East. Ball-room and Prayer-meeting. 
 Re-consecration. Baptism 13 
 
 CHAPTER II. 
 
 Return Home. Neighborhood Efforts. Choice of a Calling. 
 Return East to obtain an Education. School at Masonville. 
 Visit to Columbia County, and Journey back. Academy at Gil- 
 bertsville. Economy. A Revival. School-teaching in New- 
 Lisbon. Conflicts as to Duty. Hamilton Institution. Li- 
 censed to preach. Marriage and Pastorate at Springfield. 
 Second Pastorate at Watertown, N. Y. Reflections on Ministe- 
 rial Worldliness 19 
 
 (3)
 
 4 CONTENTS. 
 
 CHAPTER III. 
 
 Protracted Meetings a Novelty. Eesolution to become an Evan- 
 gelist. Counting the Cost. Resignation of Pastorate. Re- 
 sults of the Labors of eighteen Months among the Churches. 
 Trials. Opposition. Pecuniary Losses. Application to the 
 State Convention. Application rejected. Mortification of Feel- 
 ings. Fasting and Prayer. God's Presence and Direction. 
 Blessed Results. Trust in God for Support. Method of pre- 
 paring Sermons. Re-conversions needful 28 
 
 CHAPTER IV. 
 
 Forty Years ago. No Sunday Schools. No Missionary Enter- 
 prise. Few Educational Institutions. No Liberality. Anti- 
 nomianisro. Elder Benedict. Influence of Evangelism. Op- 
 position of Hyper-Calvinism. Spurious Conversions. Sudden 
 Conversions. A doubting Piety. Jealousy. Men-pleasers. 
 Early Discipline. Consolation. Success. Sympathizers. 
 Change of Public Opinion 36 
 
 CHAPTER V. 
 
 Union Meetings. Why discontinued. Duty of Baptists. Bless- 
 ed Meetings. An Answer to Prayer. Departed Worthies. 
 NORTH RUTLAND : " The Bower of Prayer." Deacon Wood- 
 ward and the Young Men. TURIN : Universalism. A Univer- 
 salist Mother. Threatened Suit. Mr. P. CONSTABLEVILLE : 
 Barn and Pork-house. Colonel M. A Drunkard's Wife. 
 A Vision 48 
 
 CHAPTER VI. 
 
 RUTLAND HILL : Holding On. Great Results. An alarmed Pro- 
 fessor. A good Conscience. "Old Fogies." A new Church. 
 
 LORAINE : Suspension of Business. Three Meeting-Houses. 
 
 A Mother's Command. HANNIBAL CENTRE : A cold Begin- 
 ning. Universalist Reporters. A drunken Apostate. OSWE-
 
 CONTENTS. 5 
 
 GO : Peter S. Smith. Power of Earnestness. A real Eeligion. 
 Kestitution CO 
 
 CHAPTER VII. 
 
 AUBURN : A Disturber. Opposition. Cowards. Stage Ride. 
 A Surprise. PHOSNIXVILLE : Church organized. ITHACA : 
 Conversion of Mr. M. BKOOME STREET, NEW YORK CITY : 
 Hyper-Calvinism. REMOVAL TO HAMILTON : Reasons. ... 68 
 
 CHAPTER VIII. ' 
 
 BRIDGEWATER : A Lawyer. A Ball. A Case of Prejudice. 
 The Presbyterian Minister. BENNINGTON, VT. : Thirty-one 
 Years afterwards. WATERVILLE : Distilleries. Liquor Deal- 
 ers. Proposed Attack 76 
 
 CHAPTER IX. 
 
 HAMILTON : Fear of Men. Co-laborers. Results. Day of 
 Small Things. PENNYAN : Large Accessions. Commotion 
 among the Infidels. Meeting-house paid for. A Cass of Con- 
 viction. A Legacy of Ministers 80 
 
 CHAPTER X. 
 
 UTICA : Bethel Church. The First and Second Presbyterian 
 Churches. Conversions. Baptist Cause. A new Church. 
 Universalists. SCHENECTADY : Union of Christians. Union 
 College. Conversion of Students. SENECA FALLS : A Re- 
 conversion of all the Churches. BROOKLYN : Baptist Cause, fee- 
 ble. Pillars in the Church. John N. Wilder. Conversion 
 of an Atheist. Sisterly Remonstrance. Deacon Colgate. 
 General Results 85 
 
 CHAPTER XI. 
 
 ROCHESTER : Gamblers. The Mob. Arrest. Councils of the 
 Wicke,d brought to Nought. BALTIMORE : General Interest.
 
 CONTENTS. 
 
 / 
 
 Church strengthened. Washingtonian Temperance Movement. 
 Threatenings. A later Meeting. Letter from Dr. Fuller. . 
 
 CHAPTEE XII. 
 
 ALBANY : Apprehensions. - Cooperation. Instances of Conver- 
 sion. Liberality and Kevival. A Prodigal Son. A Stranger. 
 
 The Shad Story. Preparation of the Grounds. State Street 
 Baptist Church. Unsuccessful Pastorate. NEW YORK CITY : 
 Baptist Tabernacle. A Wonderful Work. A Devoted Mer- 
 chant. New York Herald. An Infidel converted. A Mag- 
 dalene. The Church in Perplexity. Kesults. Statement of 
 W. W. Everts. HARTFORD : South Baptist Church. A Can- 
 did Universalist. The Fiddler at a Ball. Zaccheus at a Bap- 
 tism. The Infidel Mocker. The Rum-seller and his Victim. 
 
 NEW HAVEN : Union Meetings. Yale College. A Gam- 
 bling-house. Plets, and God's Interpositions. The Billiard- 
 room Keepers. Students' Ball. Church Caution. Baptist 
 Progress 104 
 
 CHAPTER XIII. 
 
 NEW BEDFORD : A Revival in the Summer. A Caviller. Power 
 of Endurance. Earnestness. PROVIDENCE : Want of Coop- 
 eration. Dr. Wayland. Trial of Faith. Increase of Inter- 
 est. Lawsuit. Results. BOSTON : Five Churches united. 
 Arduous Labors. Plain Preaching. Opposition. Anxiety. 
 Protests. A Mob. A Passage of Scripture. Eagerness 
 for Salvation. Closing Meetings. Disparagement. Per- 
 sonal Detraction. J. D. Fulton's Account. . 120 
 
 CHAPTER XIV. 
 
 LOWELL: A Universalist Covenant Meeting. A Cotton Mill an 
 Inquiry-room. Fifteen Hundred Converts. A Challenge to 
 Universalists. Its Acceptance, and the Result. Physical Ex- 
 haustion. An Aged Convert. A Farewell Scene. An Infi-
 
 CONTENTS. 7 
 
 del Observer. CONCORD : Excitement among Christians and 
 among Scoffers. An Illustration. Conversion of a Univer- 
 salist Preacher. Penitent Scoffers. A Refusal to baptize. 
 Regrets. Baptist Influence. The Second Advent. State- 
 ment of E. E. Cummings ...... 138 
 
 CHAPTER XV. 
 
 SALEM AND MARBLEHEAD : Enlargement. Conflict over a Soul. 
 A Universalist Prayer-meeting. Leaving Town. WASH- 
 INGTON : A small Band. Cooperation. Dance-hall. Pro- 
 Slavery. A Remarkable Conversion. College Students. 
 E Street Church. RICHMOND : Conditional Invitation. Re- 
 spect for Ministers. An unhealthy Piety. Slavery Abomina- 
 tions. A Slave Prayer-meeting, and Bloodhounds. Remon- 
 strance. Departure 148 
 
 CHAPTER XVI. 
 
 ERIE : A Universalist Meddler and his Pate. An Irish Lad. 
 Nineteen Years afterwards. OWEGO : Philetus Peck. Dews 
 of Grace. A model Church. A defiant Infidel. Wilfulness. 
 Departed Worthies 157 
 
 CHAPTER XVII. 
 
 CHICAGO : First Church in 1849 ; in 1857. Conversions. Invi- 
 tation to a Ball. Wabash Avenue Church. Worldliness. 
 ROCKTORD : Removal to, in 1849. A Year's Labor in Rockford. 
 CANTON: In 1851. A Mind to Work. The Zeal of one 
 Man. Immediate Baptisms. " Hell upon Earth." .... 1C3 
 
 CHAPTER XVIII. . 
 
 ST. Louis : Sparks from the One Altar. Disparagement. Great 
 Ingathering. Giving the Hand of Fellowship. A new Church 
 formed. Its Dismemberment. MIDDLETOWN: Pecuniary In-
 
 8 CONTENTS. 
 
 ducements. Hesitation about going. Prayers for the Devil. 
 Obeying Orders. Kesults. Meeting in 1864. Youngest Son 
 converted. LOUISVILLE: Sensitiveness of the People concern- 
 ing Slavery. Apprehensions. Signs of Success. A Dream, 
 and its Interpretation. Notice to leave 1G8 
 
 CHAPTER XIX. 
 
 BOSTON : Baldwin Place Church. Changes in Nineteen Years. 
 Self-Examination. Discouragements. Union Church. Great 
 Work. A genuine Convert. Presence of God. Tremont 
 Temple Church. Sinless Perfection, and the Lack of it. Con- 
 version of a Universalist Preacher. Farewell Sermon in Bow- 
 doin Square Church. A working Church 175 
 
 CHAPTER XX. 
 
 WILMINGTON ; A former Visit. Present Meeting of great^ Power. 
 A new Church started. PHILADELPHIA : The Bethel. A 
 floating Church. Many Conversions. The Fourth Baptist 
 Church. A happy Birthday. Great Results. Interesting 
 Conversions. Valuable Accessions. NEWARK: Harmonious 
 Churches. General Interest. Union Prayer-meeting. ELIZ- 
 ABETH : A Threefold Call. A divine Answer. NEW YORK 
 CITY : A Contrast. Business and Religion. A Farewell Ser- 
 vice. Labors in other Places. TRENTON: Baptism of Chil- 
 dren. Numerous Conversions. A blessed Season. Reflec- 
 tions. Going to California 181 
 
 CHAPTER XXI. 
 
 Numbers converted. Baptized. Answers to Questions. Num- 
 ber of Meetings held. Of Sermons preached. Of Converts 
 who became Ministers. Amount of Compensation 190
 
 
 CONTENTS. 
 
 VIEWS ON VARIOUS SUBJECTS. 
 
 I. HONORARY TITLES . 193 
 
 II. THOUGHTS ON MINISTERIAL POWER 196 
 
 III. HOW TO GET UP A REFORMATION 202 
 
 IV. COMPLAINTS AGAINST SPEEDY ADMISSIONS 
 
 CONSIDERED 208 
 
 V. THE UTILITY OF ANXIOUS-SEATS 214 
 
 VI. HOW TO INSTRUCT INQUIRERS 217 
 
 VII. ADVICE TO YOUNG CONVERTS 222 
 
 VIII. ACTIVE BENEVOLENCE 228 
 
 IX. RESTRICTED AND MIXED COMMUNION. . 237 
 
 SERMONS. 
 
 I. LESSONS TAUGHT BY THE OX. Isa. i. 3 251 
 
 II. ENTHUSIASM. Acts xxvi. 24 272 
 
 III. THE CALLS OF THE GOSPEL. Matt, xxiii. 37. . . . 284 
 
 IV. WHY THE WICKED LIVE. Deut. xxxii. 85 301 
 
 V. THE NEW BIRTH. Ezek. xviii. 31. Ps. li. 10. . 323 
 
 APPENDIX. 
 
 STATISTICAL RESULTS OF ELDER KNAPP'S LABORS 
 IN MASSACHUSETTS. . 335
 
 INTRODUCTORY ESSAY. 
 
 ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. 
 
 EVANGELISM, in the strict sense of the word, means the 
 preaching of the gospel to the destitute in regions where its 
 ordinary ministrations are not enjoyed. 
 
 But, in modern times, the term has acquired a modified 
 application. It is now generally used to designate those efforts 
 in connection with, or in excess of, the ordinary services, by 
 which a church puts forth extraordinary exertions for the salva- 
 tion of men, in its own immediate vicinity. These extraordinary 
 services consist, for the most part, of continuous exercises of 
 preaching and prayer for several successive weeks, during which 
 time the members of the church are urged to unusual exertions, 
 in order to awaken the interest of the unconverted around them 
 to the concerns of their everlasting well-being ; while the public 
 ministrations are intended to bring men, by every consideration 
 and motive which the gospel can present, to an immediate sur- 
 render of their hearts to the authority of Christ as Lawgiver 
 and Savior. 
 
 Experience has enabled the people of God to correct many 
 abuses which the excitement incident to such continuous ap- 
 peals to their religious sensibility might naturally produce ; but 
 the practicability and desirableness of such an order of appoint- 
 ments is no longer an experiment. Its consistency with the es- 
 tablished doctrines of grace is no longer a problem. Events 
 have proven that God has wonderfully honored this instrumen- 
 
 (V)
 
 VI ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. 
 
 tality ; and now the system of ''protracted meetings" is a recog- 
 nized agency in the kingdom of God. 
 
 Prior to the institution of this peculiar system of measures, 
 there had prevailed throughout the Southern States the custom 
 of holding " meetings of days" These, however, consisted, 
 more especially, of a convocation of the brethren from a dis- 
 tance of several miles, for the purpose of enjoying a season of 
 spiritual refreshing in connection with a series of doctrinal, 
 denominational, and emotional sermons. They were not pri- 
 marily intended as a means of religious awakening among the 
 impenitent. 
 
 Forty years ago the institution of protracted meetings was 
 comparatively unknown. It took its rise amid the suspicions 
 and denunciations of men who conscientiously believed the 
 innovation to be a presumptuous inconsistency with the di- 
 vinely appointed methods of promoting the spread of the gos- 
 pel. The tendency of such measures was deplored as disas- 
 trous to the true interests of the churches, and the grounds on 
 which they were advocated were repudiated as positively antag- 
 onistic to the standards of doctrinal orthodoxy. Many of our 
 fathers passed away sighing out their lamentations over the 
 departing glories of Israel. 
 
 The opposition which was then manifested to protracted 
 meetings, was not based on those excesses in the methods of 
 conducting them which experience could correct, nor on usages 
 the propriety of which time would determine, but on the high 
 ground of the utter inconsistency of special human exertions for 
 the conversion of men with the sovereignty of God in the pur- 
 poses of redemption. Regeneration being a divine work, it was 
 concluded that the conjunction of human agency in promoting it 
 was a needless and arrogant presumption. The salvation of 
 each sinner being an act of electing grace, therefore it could 
 not be affected by human efforts. The gathering in of God's 
 elect being according to his purpose and will, it was thought 
 that his purpose and will would be accomplished independently 
 of means and measures. God was able to achieve his own
 
 ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. vii 
 
 intentions without our agency ; he knew who would be saved, and 
 who would not be saved, and how to secure the salvation of 
 those who were ordained unto eternal life ; and in his own time 
 he would bring his purposes to pass. The strength of God's peo- 
 ple was to " lie still " in regard to all questions concerning the 
 dissemination of the knowledge of Christ ; and the chief concern 
 of each disciple was, by processes of introspection, metaphysical 
 analyses, and spiritual experiences, to settle, if possible, the 
 great question of his own ordination unto salvation. 
 
 Such was the system of theology itself a perversion and 
 abuse of the doctrines of grace which prevailed throughout 
 the Baptist denomination half a century ago. As a matter of 
 course, it wrought out its logical results in producing a state of 
 conscientious apathy concerning the spiritual condition of the 
 great mass of mankind. No wonder that there were no Sunday 
 schools in connection with churches, the theology of whose mem- 
 bers forbade them to pray even for the conversion of their own 
 children ; and who studiously avoided giving any suggestions or 
 instructions to them, lest the workings of the Spirit should be 
 interfered with and grieved, and thereby the sovereign and 
 elective purpose of God should be defeated ! No wonder that 
 missionary enterprises in behalf of the heathen world were dis- 
 approved of, by Christians whose theological views taught them 
 the needlessness of using any means for the conversion of their 
 nearest neighbors ! No wonder that institutions for the training 
 of young men for the ministry were scouted at as " minister- 
 making machines," by a people who deemed it a chief evidence 
 of a man's call to preach, if he could step from the workshop 
 or the plough into the pulpit, and descant for an hour on some 
 religious topic, especially a doctrine of grace, without previous 
 discipline or special preparation! No wonder that measures 
 . looking to a successive and persistent pi'essure of the claims of 
 salvation on the attention of men were repudiated, as an outrage 
 on the order of the gospel, by men who denied the right of a 
 minister to call on sinners to repent ! In that day it was more 
 than a minister's position in a church was worth, to presume on
 
 Vlii ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. 
 
 a course of urgency in behalf of the salvation of the unconverted ; 
 and even they, whose zeal for souls could not be restrained by 
 their Procrustean theories, ventured to reach the doctrine of 
 " works " by the slow and guarded approaches of qualifying 
 explanations and repeated asseverations of their soundness on 
 the cardinal doctrines of grace. And finding at length that the 
 strongholds of their cherished dogmas were being assailed, their 
 advocates found themselves unconsciously roused to a state of 
 activity, in their zeal to denounce those who would not let 
 them be " at ease in Zion." 
 
 But while, as might be supposed, these doctrinal perversions 
 of great truths bore their legitimate fruits, in repressing the ardor 
 of Christian sympathy and effort, in inducing an indifference to 
 the spread of the gospel and the salvation of men, and in dry- 
 ing up all the springs of benevolent action, yet there were some 
 who proclaimed their inconsistency by violating the logic of 
 their creeds, and who braved the suspicions and denunciations 
 of their brethren by their earnest and laborious endeavors for 
 the conversion of the impenitent. Holcombe, in Philadelphia, 
 amid a storm of abuse which scrupled at no outrage, persisted 
 in preaching a free salvation, and in urging men to repent. 
 Benedict, in the city of New York, ceased not for many years 
 to warn sinners day and night with tears ; but he was called to 
 encounter the silent reprobation or the open protest of brethren 
 who prided themselves on their soundness in the faith. 
 
 When, however, in the lapse of years, it became a demon- 
 strated fact that sinners could be "soundly" converted, as the 
 result of special efforts ; when the churches which were com- 
 posed of these " man-made converts " became numerous and in- 
 fluential, while the churches which maintained their opposition 
 to new measures began to die out ; when from the ranks of 
 those converted in protracted meetings there went forth a new 
 order of ministers in full sympathy with such instrumentalities, 
 it was easy to predict that the stone which the builders rejected 
 would soon become the head of the corner ; that the very meas- 
 ures which at first were repudiated as God-dishonoring pre-
 
 ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. ix 
 
 sumptions, would come to be recognized as an important and 
 almost indispensable agency in promoting the glory of God. 
 
 Instances are now rare in the Baptist denomination, in this 
 country, of a church specially committed against seasons of 
 protracted effort. On the contrary, they have come to be re- 
 garded as among the established means of grace ; and in numer- 
 ous instances the conducting of them is considered among the 
 regular services of the pastor, and his own acceptability, in 
 great measure, is determined by his success in carrying them on. 
 The great proportion of our present membership has been brought 
 into the church in connection with some form of protracted 
 effort ; and despite the many instances of falling away, it may 
 be confidently asserted, that the proportion of apostates is not 
 greater than formerly ; while nearly all those who are promi- 
 nent and reliable, on whom the responsibilities of church affairs 
 now devolve, were converted in connection with these special 
 instrumentalities. 
 
 Nor is this all. The marked difference which distinguishes 
 the type of modern piety from that of a former generation, may 
 be confidently ascribed to the influence of this system of meas- 
 ures. Formerly, the proofs of piety were drawn from subjec- 
 tive experiences ; now the value of these experiences is very 
 greatly determined by the fruits which they objectively produce. 
 It is now not so much a question, What does a man feel for 
 Christ ? as, What does he do for him ? It is now more thoroughly 
 understood that the love of Christ in the heart will constrain the 
 life, not merely to acts of sobriety, temperance, and godliness, 
 but to a self-sacrificing zeal in good works. Men are now 
 generally converted in the atmosphere of prayers, anxieties, and 
 labors in their behalf; and thus their first impressions of con- 
 secration to Christ are associated with the idea of active and 
 self-sacrificing endeavors for the salvation of their fellows. They 
 know that they owe their own conversion to the blessing of 
 God on the efforts of others for them ; and they very naturally 
 conclude, either that their hopes are vain, or that similar ex- 
 ertions for others may result in bringing them to the enjoyment
 
 X ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. 
 
 of the same glorious hopes. So that this has come to be an age 
 of Christian activities. 
 
 The several agencies for the dissemination of the gospel, 
 which are at present sustained by Baptists in this country, have 
 only quite recently begun to enter upon an era in their develop- 
 ment which indicates their permanent hold on the convictions 
 of the churches, and which gives an assured earnest of the 
 mighty influences they are destined to exert. Heretofore they 
 have been compelled to fight their way into a positive existence, 
 against the hinderances of false views of the laws of the king- 
 dom of Christ, inveterate prejudices, and the absence of well- 
 conceived and fairly-tried methods of organization. But these 
 obstacles are now removed. The churches give a ready re- 
 sponse to the various appeals that are made upon their sympa- 
 thies, efforts, and contributions. The great necessity is no 
 longer to convince Christians of the consistency of human efforts 
 with divine purposes, but to carry them forward to that measure 
 of endeavor which is demanded by the logic of their present 
 convictions of the relation that God has established between his 
 purpose and our use of means for their accomplishment. 
 
 We do not say that this marvellous change in the spirit of our 
 denomination is due solely to the influence of protracted meet- 
 ings, because it is well known that missionary endeavors, Sun- 
 day school instruction, and ministerial education found their 
 advocates long before the era of " special efforts." Many of 
 the earliest and most distinguished friends of these institutions 
 did not look with favor on protracted meetings. But it is also 
 true that these several movements of Christian benevolence were 
 stoutly resisted as unwarrantable innovations on the methods of 
 grace ; and until the time when the system of protracted meet- 
 ings came to be fairly recognized, they were able to maintain 
 only a feeble existence, and found but little favor with the people 
 among whom they 'Were introduced. But in proportion as the 
 churches came to recognize the desirableness of protracted meet- 
 ings, and to be composed of persons converted in such meetings, 
 the opposition to such institutions began to disappear, and their
 
 ~ ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. XI 
 
 frieucls and supporters began to increase ; so that now facts may 
 be adduced in sufficient numbers to justify the assertion, that the 
 warmest supporters of missions, of Sunday schools, of institu- 
 tions for the education of young men for the ministry, are men 
 who have been led to appreciate the importance of protracted 
 meetings, who cordially cooperate in carrying them on, and who, 
 in many instances, were themselves brought to Christ through 
 their influence. And it is a matter of common observation, that 
 never is it so easy to induce a church to make large contributions 
 for a benevolent object, never so easy to pay off a debt, to im- 
 prove a Sunday school, to contribute to missions, to furnish 
 support for indigent students, to endow colleges, or to do any 
 other work of active and sacrificing service for the cause of Christ, 
 as when it is in the full tide of a religious revival ; and none are 
 so willing to respond to these appeals as those who are most 
 deeply interested in the progress of such a special work of grace. 
 
 Now, among the agents whom God has employed for the 
 bringing about of this marked and blessed change in the spirit 
 of our churches, Jacob Knapp occupies a place of indisputable 
 prominence. 
 
 It is too soon to write a just estimate of the value of his 
 services among the churches. He is still living ; his work is not 
 yet done ; the estimate of his contemporaries is necessarily 
 affected by their familiarity with the details of his history ; and 
 he has not altogether outlived the prejudices which the assaults 
 of a former generation of enemies created against him. The 
 time will come, however, when these things will be forgotten, 
 or be mentioned as matters of curious comment. Posterity will 
 speak of Elder Knapp as the pioneer and champion of modern 
 evangelism. At the present day few know of the reproaches 
 that were heaped on the heads of Wesley, of Whitefield, of How- 
 ard, or of Payson ; but all men recognize them, as leaders in the 
 Zion of our God, whose services and names will be held in 
 everlasting remembrance. 
 
 There are several facts in the history of Elder Knapp which 
 conspire to give him a place of enduring reputation in Delation
 
 xii ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. 
 
 to the system of modern evangelism, especially among Baptists. 
 He was perhaps the first man, at least in the Northern States, 
 who devoted himself exclusively to the work of conducting pro- 
 tracted meetings. He ventured on the providence of God in 
 making the experiment at a time when the results were prob- 
 lematical. He continued in his course despite the accumulations 
 of every form of persecution. His labors were crowned with 
 wonderful success in the conversion of thousands to Christ. He 
 has outlived many other evangelists who began after him, and 
 still continues in the work, "his eye undimmed, and his natural 
 force unabated." He is permitted to witness the triumph of the 
 system which he has done so much to inaugurate ; to rejoice 
 that even churches which might not wish to secure his individual 
 services, rely, nevertheless, upon his methods for their increase 
 in power and usefulness ; and to know that when the memory 
 of his assailants will be forgotten, or remembered chiefly because 
 of their opposition to him, the system with which his name and 
 life are associated will continue to operate as a potent agency 
 in hastening on the latter-day glories of the Lamb. His de- 
 clining years are cheered by the retrospect of a useful life ; 
 and the hardships he has endured, are made to appear as 
 " light affliction^" in view, of the anticipated rapture of receiv- 
 ing the plaudit of his Savior, and of recognizing at the judgment- 
 day thousands on thousands of souls, who, redeemed through his 
 instrumentality, will constitute the jewels in the crown of his 
 everlasting rejoicing. 
 
 It is quite probable that, in the present day, a man of Elder 
 Knapp's abilities, attainments, and style, starting forth as an 
 evangelist, would not acquire any marked distinction, nor 
 achieve any wonderful success. The characteristics of John the 
 Baptist, and his manner of preaching, were eminently adapted 
 to fit him for his peculiar position as the herald of the coming 
 Messiah ; but he might not have been so well suited for a later 
 age in the development of the kingdom of God. Men of differ- 
 ent qualifications were needed to meet the exigencies that were 
 presented by the advancing demands of the mission of Christ.
 
 ELDEB KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. xiii 
 
 Luther was specially raised up and qualified for the work unto 
 which God had called him in inaugurating the era of the Protes- 
 tant reformation. Calvin was better adapted to analyze and 
 adjust the grand doctrinal formulas which were to constitute the 
 confession of faith of succeeding generations of the church ; 
 while Wesley could do a work which neither Luther nor Calvin 
 could have performed, in awakening Christendom to the neces- 
 sities of organized forms of spiritual activity. 
 
 And, in like manner, the accomplished facts of history show 
 that Providence called Elder Knapp to a peculiar service, and 
 a knowledge of his traits proves his personal adaptation to the 
 mission unto which he was called. 
 
 The work to which, about the year 1832, he felt himself con- 
 strained to consecrate his life, was one involving peculiar trials. 
 He was about to enter on an experiment. He was about to 
 challenge the conscientious scruples of nearly airthe leaders in 
 that portion of the American Zion to which he belonged. He 
 was about to excite the opposition of inveterate prejudices. He 
 was about to cut loose from all stated sources of support, and 
 rely on the voluntary contributions; , of people who, at the best, 
 were accustomed to do but little for the support of ministers, and 
 whose opposition to his undertaking would prompt them to con- 
 tribute less to him. He expected to present views of doctrine 
 which he knew many Christians would deem subversive of the 
 gospel of Christ, and which would arouse the intensest hatred 
 of the great mass of the unconverted. And when at length his 
 labors should come into demand, he was destined to undergo 
 exhaustive draughts on his powers of physical and mental en- 
 durance. 
 
 A man with the prospects of such a life needed to possess, in 
 an eminent degree, the force of strong convictions, an unyielding 
 purpose, patient forbearance, great boldness, clear perceptions, 
 versatile genius, simple tastes, economical habits, imperturbable 
 self-possession, ready wit,* a good knowledge of human nature, 
 
 * As an instance of Elder Knapp's quickness in repartee, it is related 
 that, while holding a meeting in the Mulberry Street church, in the city
 
 xiv ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. 
 
 an adaptation to persons of different tastes, an iron constitu- 
 tion, a humble spirit, and a firm reliance on the sustaining grace 
 of God. 
 
 All these characteristics Elder Knapp has exhibited to a re- 
 markable degree. Perhaps there is no minister of the gospel 
 living who has toiled harder, has been opposed more, has com- 
 plained less, and has accomplished so much. 
 
 True to the spirit of his mission, he has seemed to regard 
 himself the subject of God's special providence. He has en- 
 deavored to follow its indications, and has accepted its allot- 
 ments. His pastorates were with a rural population, and he 
 began his work as an evangelist in a sparsely settled community, 
 and was glad to devote his services to churches which were too 
 poor to sustain a stated pastorate, and withal had very crude 
 notions of the duty of doing much for the support of ministers. 
 Now, the fact that such was the condition of the churches with 
 which Elder Knapp's earliest labors were associated, furnished 
 a favorable opportunity of testing the strength of his own faith 
 in the willingness of God to provide for the support of his fam- 
 ily, and to give success to his labors for the salvation of men. 
 Churches that were unable to support pastors were glad to avail 
 themselves of his temporary aid, even though they might doubt 
 the advisability of his method. Churches that had pastors 
 were unprepared to appreciate the importance of his labors, and 
 the pastors themselves were either opposed to his mission, or 
 unwilling to encounter the opposition which a proposition to 
 invite his aid would provoke. 
 
 But soon it became a matter of observation, that the churches 
 which had secured the services of Elder Knapp were beginning 
 to enjoy a degree of prosperity which suggested the desirable- 
 ness of invoking his labors with churches which had hitherto 
 stood aloof from him. At length the ministry of Elder Knapp 
 became the theme of general comment. Despite the early 
 
 of New York, a young man rose in the presence of a vast congregation, 
 and requested prayers for the devil. Elder Knapp quietly remarked, 
 "Brethren, this young man has asked you to pray for his father."
 
 ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. XV 
 
 prejudices that prevailed against this order of measures, de- 
 spite the criticisms which his plain and somewhat eccentric style 
 awakened, it became evident that God was with him, and 
 through him was doing wonders. His services ere long came 
 into general demand, and churches distinguished for their 
 wealth, influence, and refinement, called him to labor among 
 them. In these new and more trying positions the ministry 
 of Elder Knapp was attended with still greater success than, 
 elsewhere or before. During the few weeks of his presence in 
 any of the principal cities of the Union, the community was 
 convulsed. Crowds on crowds thronged to hear this plain, 
 outspoken man of God ; churches were roused to new and 
 unthought-of measures of action ; and thousands of impenitent 
 men and women, from all classes of society, were converted 
 to God. 
 
 About the years 1841 and '42 his ministry appears to have 
 culminated. God permitted a cloud to come over him ; but 
 while this trying dispensation of Providence seemed to divert 
 the consideration of the churches from the workman, it did not 
 impede the progress of the work. Protracted meetings, as a 
 system of measures, had acquired a permanent place in the 
 agencies to be henceforth employed by the people of God. 
 
 Nor was Elder Knapp himself to be set aside. But in other 
 regions he was destined to continue his labors. During the 
 last twenty years he has devoted the greater part of his time 
 among the feeble churches of the growing West, many of which 
 he has lived to see assume positions of great promise for the 
 spread of the gospel in this wonderful portion of our vast 
 republic. 
 
 Another element in the ministry of Elder Knapp and one, 
 too, which qualified him to be a leader of the people during the 
 last forty years was his earnest sympathy with the spirit of 
 philanthropy. It is impossible to say what would have been 
 the measure of his influence, if he had stood aloof from all 
 the enterprises of modern reform, or lent to them his opposition ; 
 but, as a matter of fact, he has stood in the front rauk of every
 
 XVi ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. 
 
 movement which contemplated the elevation of humanity, and 
 has rejoiced in every undertaking that proposed to give the gos- 
 pel to the world. Many men in his circumstances would have 
 thought that, in order to success in one peculiar mission, they 
 must keep silence on every other topic which divided the senti- 
 ments of community ; but he shunned not " to declare the whole 
 counsel of God," and has provoked storms of opposition, which 
 would not have arisen, if he had not lashed the waves of popular 
 passion into fury by his fearless denunciations of all manner of 
 sin, and his earnest advocacy of every measure of right. 
 
 He was among the pioneers in the temperance movement. 
 He acted as an officer in several such organizations, demanded 
 of those converted in his meetings abstinence from everything 
 that could intoxicate, and was permitted, in the providence of 
 God, to start that mighty wave of temperance reform known 
 as the Washingtonian movement, which nearly thirty years ago 
 swept through the land. 
 
 He was known as an avowed anti-slavery man, at a time 
 when the utterance of such sentiments invoked reproach and 
 persecution, and dared to lift up his voice in behalf of the slave 
 in the very citadel of the slave power, and in a church whose 
 congregations could hear the cries of the victims of the slave 
 mart mingling with their own songs of devotion. 
 
 He has always been the consistent friend of missionary en- 
 terprises and ministerial education. Many indigent students 
 at Hamilton are indebted to his sympathizing aid for the means 
 of carrying on their studies ; and on one single afternoon, dur- 
 ing the progress of a meeting in Albany, he raised seven thou- 
 sand dollars for Madison University. 
 
 Though disapproving at one time of some measures adopted 
 by the Board of Foreign Missions, he did not allow his opposi- 
 tion to their policy to weaken the ardor of his devotion to the 
 cause itself; but during the three years in which he was most 
 open in the expression of his disapprobation, he paid to the 
 society out of his scanty income the sum of eight hundred 
 dollars.
 
 ELDER KNAPP AND rilS MINISTRY. XV ii 
 
 Withal he has maintained an inflexible devotion to his con- 
 scientious convictions of denominational truth. Being a Baptist 
 from a firm persuasion that the cardinal views held by this people 
 were taught in the "Word of God, no amount of persecution 
 could alienate him from cooperation with his brethren in the 
 faith, and no measure of inducements could allure him to cast 
 his lot with the people of another name. At one time a lady 
 of great wealth, in Syracuse, connected with the Episcopal 
 church, offered to provide for the support of his family during 
 his lifetime, in order that he might the more fully devote him- 
 self to his calling ; but considerations of delicacy, and a desire 
 to remain entirely free to utter his convictions, prompted him to 
 decline the generous proposal. 
 
 It is hardly to be supposed that any man could enter upon a 
 career of such marked antagonism to the prejudices of his con- 
 temporaries, could undertake to do battle against the conscien- 
 tious convictions of good men, and to denounce the hypocrisies 
 and flagrancies of bad men, without provoking decided opposi- 
 tion and creating for himself malignant enemies. And it is a 
 still greater marvel that he should be able to hold on to such a 
 policy throughout the long period of nearly forty years. Yet 
 such is the fact in regard to the history of Jacob Knapp. 
 Despite the fearful forms of opposition which he has been 
 called to encounter, the perils he has been compelled to meet, 
 not the least of which have been "perils among false brethren," 
 he has held on to the even tenor of his way. To-day he 
 preaches the same gospel that he preached forty years ago ; 
 to-day he is the same plain, fearless, quaint, and pungent ex- 
 pounder of the truths of God as he was when he first began. 
 Flattery has not cajoled him, abuse has not intimidated him, 
 ingratitude has not embittered him, misrepresentation has not 
 angered him, and, at nearly the age of threescore years and 
 ten, in the review of these trials, he is able to exclaim with 
 Paul, " None of these things moved me ; neither counted I my life 
 dear unto myself, so that I might finish my course with joy, and 
 the ministry which I have received of the Lord Jesus." Though 
 2
 
 XVlii ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. 
 
 keenly appreciative of the confidence and sympathy of his 
 brethren, though deeming the disfavor of any an affliction, yet 
 regarding himself called to this peculiar work, he has not dared 
 to be disobedient to the heavenly vision, and his sustaining con- 
 solation has been the conviction that the Lord was with him, 
 " working mightily." 
 
 Doubtless this persistency of purpose, this undaunted courage, 
 this patient endurance, are among the elements of his history, 
 which explain his power. But in addition to these, much is to 
 be ascribed to the strength of his thoughts, the plainness, sim- 
 plicity, and quaintness of his style, and, when before a congre- 
 gation, the eloquence of his earnestness, the aptness of his 
 illustrations, the directness of his appeals, and the freshness 
 of his utterances. 
 
 Undoubtedly, to many minds, some of Elder Knapp's ex- 
 pressions have been distasteful, and, brought to the standard 
 of a cultured criticism, are open to censure ; but to this it may 
 be said that these eccentricities in Elder Knapp's preaching 
 have always borne the air of naturalness. They have not 
 seemed oddities in his mind, but the words of truth and sober- 
 ness. They have fittingly expressed the shades of his thought, 
 and have conveyed to the minds of his hearers clear and 
 forcible presentations of the truth. Besides, his singularity 
 of style has given distinctness and reputation to his min- 
 istry. Thousands, perchance, have been attracted to hear him 
 preach from motives of curiosity, whom a tamely correct and 
 an exquisitely fine preacher could never have interested, and 
 to whom these peculiarities of utterance have proved arrows 
 shot at a venture ; while hundreds of others, in the exercise of a 
 noble charity and a wise discretion, have overlooked what they 
 regarded as minor defects, because they clearly recognized the 
 great amount of good the Lord was pleased to accomplish 
 through him, because of the great amount of truth he was 
 preaching, and because of the evident sincerity of the motives 
 which inspired him. 
 
 But the real secret of Elder Knapp's power with men has
 
 ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. 
 
 been his power with God. It is an ungracious task to say ful- 
 some things about the piety of any living man. Elder Knapp 
 has his faults ; he has made mistakes ; but that he is a man of 
 God, those only can doubt who do not know him, or whose 
 inveterate prejudices should awaken suspicions of their own 
 want of the grace of charity. If it had been possible to fasten 
 reproach upon the personal integrity and Christian consisten- 
 cy of Jacob Kuapp, it would certainly have been done. The 
 effort to blast his reputation, to destroy his influence, to 
 drive him from the ministry, to make his name a byword and 
 a reproach, has been formally, persistently, and perhaps con- 
 scientiously made. But at every point the undertaking has 
 failed. 
 
 Being so conspicuously before the public for so many years, 
 compelled to sojourn in so many different families, called to 
 come in contact with such a countless variety of characters, 
 his conduct has necessarily been exposed to the closest scrutiny. 
 And if there had been furnished the occasion, there have been 
 bad men who with hawk-like avidity were waiting to seize 
 upon his slightest defects ; and there have been good men who 
 have watched him with painful expectations of making the sad 
 discovery. 
 
 But through these many years, amid so many vicissitudes, 
 God has mercifully preserved him. In purity of deportment, 
 in gentleness of spirit, in quietness of behavior under fearful 
 provocations, in magnanimity towards enemies, in constant 
 habits of communion with God, the hundreds of families with 
 which he has sojourned bear unanimous testimony. And when 
 at one time the attempt was formally undertaken to investigate 
 his conduct, the verdict in these particulars, his enemies being 
 judges, was emphatic in his behalf. 
 
 It is, perhaps, too soon, or too late, at the present, to enter 
 upon a detailed account of the investigation to which we allude 
 too soon, because something is due to participants in it who 
 are still living, or are only recently dead ; too late, because 
 what ought to be said should have been said at the time. Yet
 
 XX ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. 
 
 the fact that nothing was said then is a reason why something 
 should be said now. 
 
 It is not proper for us, neither is it our purpose, to attempt a 
 partisan defence of Elder Knapp. Nor is it necessary. The 
 investigation was conducted by men of tried integrity and clear 
 judgment men who enjoyed and commanded the confidence 
 of the denomination. To their verdict Elder Knapp was willing 
 to submit his case, and by their verdict he has ever since been 
 content to abide. But unfortunately, for reasons beyond his 
 control, that verdict was never published to the world ; and 
 Elder Knapp has been compelled, for the last twenty years, 
 to suffer, in silence, the disadvantages which their silence occa- 
 sioned, and to meet the suspicions and hinderances which the 
 busy and untrammelled action of his enemies created agaiost 
 him. 
 
 Shortly after the season of his marvellous successes in New 
 England, a reaction set in on several of the churches with which 
 he had labored. This reaction was partly natural, partly pro- 
 duced by the mismanagement of the churches themselves, 
 and partly by the anxiety of the enemies of revivals to prove 
 them failures and disasters. The result was, that a wide- 
 spread impression was created, not only that the measures of 
 Elder Knapp were unfortunate, but that his motives were sinis- 
 ter. Rumors became rife that the course he pursued, especially 
 in Boston, was designedly calculated to create the impression 
 that he was very poor, in order to induce the people to dispense 
 contributions of unwonted liberality. Reports of these -rumors 
 reached Hamilton, where Elder Kuapp resided, and a vigorous 
 correspondence was maintained between certain parties with 
 regard to the actual state of his finances and the measures he 
 had taken to increase them. 
 
 On returning from holding a protracted meeting, Elder Knapp 
 came home, on one occasion, to find the community agitated with 
 conflicting rumors ; and finding that these rumors were likely to 
 spread and hinder his usefulness as an evangelist, he called at 
 once for an investigation. The matter by mutual consent was
 
 ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. 
 
 at first referred to a private committee. This committee, in an 
 enlarged form, finally met in the month of June, 1844. It was 
 composed of brethren, the mention of whose names is a guar- 
 anty of the justice of the decision they would be likely to reach, 
 to wit, Dr. Nathaniel Kendrick, Dr. G. W. Eaton, Deacons S. 
 B. Burchard, William Cobb, and A. Pierce, to whom were added, 
 prior to the June meeting, Kev. B. N. Leach, Pastof of the 
 Baptist Church at Hamilton ; Professor S. W. Taylor, Clerk ; 
 Deacon William Colgate, of New York City ; and Deacons 
 Sage and Barton, of Rochester, N. Y. 
 
 " The brethren of the committee,* having thoroughly exam- 
 ined the whole matter, united (we believe no one dissented) in 
 the deliberate opinion that there was ' nothing in the case which 
 ought to interrupt Elder Knapp's connection with the church, or 
 his labors as a minister of the gospel' THIS WAS A DECISION 
 TJPON THE MERITS OP THE CASE ] not an important particular 
 was left out of the case. 
 
 " After this main result was attained, the next inquiry was, 
 ' What particulars are there concerning which suggestions can 
 be made, with probable advantage to the brethren?' Every 
 such particular was carefully selected, and one of the committee 
 was appointed to speak to parties touching these particulars, and 
 to announce to them the committee's general conclusion. This 
 he did with a clearness, a pathos, a faithfulness, and an effect 
 which cannot be adequately described. Elder Knapp, inter- 
 rupted with irrepressible emotion, expressed his thanks to the 
 brethren for their kindness, their patience, and their faithful- 
 ness. [The other party to the trial] expressed himself in a 
 most feeling and appropriate manner to the individual members 
 of the committee, and expressed his happiness in what had been 
 accomplished. 
 
 " The closing scene can never be effaced from the memory 
 of the brethren present. Every heart was warm and tender. 
 
 * I quote from an explicit and detailed account of the trial, prepared 
 at the time by Professor Taylor, and certified to by several witnesses. 
 
 R. J.
 
 ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. 
 
 It was a scene of Christian embraces and tears of joy ; the 
 brethren all rejoiced in what they fondly regarded as the end 
 of a matter of most painful and intense interest, likely, if long 
 agitated and mismanaged, to jeopard the interests of the Ham- 
 ilton Literary and Theological Institute, the peace and prosperity 
 of the Hamilton church, and of Zion still more extensively ; and 
 especially the good name and usefulness of the two brethren 
 whose difficulties had been removed. The brethren reckoned 
 the great and good work accomplished. Nothing remained ex- 
 cept to prepare such an account of the adjustment as the parties, 
 together with the members of the committee, would be willing 
 to subscribe, and such a one, likewise, as might serve to allay 
 public excitement, and satisfy the candid Christian public. 
 
 " This was thought to be the work of a few minutes. It was 
 only to give a short and general account of the settlement ; and 
 this was immediately attempted : but the form not proving en- 
 tirely satisfactory, and Elder Knapp and Deacons Colgate, Sage, 
 and Barton being obliged to leave town immediately, the com- 
 mittee, having directed four of their number to prepare for the 
 public eye the requisite account of the settlement, adjourned 
 sine die." 
 
 The want of the few additional minutes needed to frame the 
 account of that settlement, has been fraught with results of 
 momentous import to the kingdom of Christ; Many of these 
 results, we believe, have proved and are destined to prove great 
 blessings to the church and the world ; but to Elder Knapp per- 
 sonally the results have been an entail of intense mortification 
 and severe discipline. 
 
 Shortly after the adjournment of the committee, side issues 
 arose, outside influences obtruded themselves, much time was 
 lost by correspondence with the different members of the com- 
 mittee, and finally, when, after the lapse of months, the form 
 of the report was agreed upon, one of the principal parties to 
 the trial refused to subscribe his name. This party was not 
 Elder Knapp. 
 
 In this way Elder Knapp was deprived of all the benefit
 
 ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. XX111 
 
 which he had hoped to derive from the publication of the ver- 
 dict ; nay, more, the withholding of the report from the public 
 was being construed to his injury, and he was finding his access 
 to the churches hedged up by the suspicions, surmises, and scan- 
 dals which these uncontradicted rumors had produced. 
 
 Finding at length that he should not be able to derive any 
 benefit from the verdict of the committee, Elder Knapp resolved 
 to appeal to the Baptist Church at Hamilton, of which he was 
 a member. Of this church he asked a formal and thorough 
 investigation of all the rumors affecting his reputation. 
 
 With this request, after some discussion as to the necessity 
 of it, seeing that no formal charge had been preferred against 
 Elder Knapp, the church complied ; and a large committee 
 was appointed to investigate all matters, and report the evidence 
 and their conclusions to the church. 
 
 In due time this committee made a full and exhaustive report, 
 and presented their conclusions, which were adopted by the 
 church. This report covered some matters of investigation 
 which were incidental to the main charge, and had arisen since 
 the adjournment of the committee. Without going into these 
 details, it will suffice to -give here the verdict of the church 
 regarding the great question at issue. There were five reso- 
 lutions adopted. The second, and third, and fourth pertain to 
 these incidental affairs, and exonerate him in regard to them ; 
 the other two read as follows : " I. Resolved, That it is the 
 opinion of this church that Elder Knapp's language or form of 
 expression in regard to his property was not so definite as might 
 be desirable, and that we can conceive that it might be easy for 
 individuals to receive from it an erroneous impression ; but still 
 we do not think we have evidence that he intended that it should 
 have such an effect." 
 
 The last resolution is, "Finally, in view of the whole matter, 
 this church is prepared to state its opinion, that there is in the 
 case, as it now stands, nothing which ought to interrupt Elder 
 Knapp's connection with the church, or interfere with his labctrs 
 as a gospel minister."
 
 XXIV ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. 
 
 In the charges that were preferred against him, it was not 
 alleged that he had ever asked the churches for a cent of com- 
 pensation, or, except in one or two private conversations, had 
 made any allusions to his finances. But his appearance before 
 Boston audiences in plain and somewhat rural attire created 
 the impression that he must be very poor, and prompted some 
 kind-hearted people to contribute money and presents to him, 
 under that supposition. The sufficient answer to such a charge 
 is, that matters of dress are matters of taste. What may seem 
 extravagance to one may not appear to be such to another, and 
 what one would regard good enough may seem uncomely to 
 another. Elder Knapp, from early life, was economical in his 
 habits, and very plain in his tastes ; and he avers that the pros- 
 pect of going to Boston tempted him to indulge in unusual 
 expenses, in order to appear before a Boston audience in be- 
 coming attire. 
 
 It was in no instance shown that he had made direct repre- 
 sentations of poverty ; but the investigation proved that he had 
 given in an over-estimate of his property. It was shown that 
 he had accumulated some property, but not from his income as 
 an evangelist, but that his income from that source had been 
 inadequate for the support of his large family ; and several 
 members of the committee expressed their unwillingness to 
 purchase his property at four fifths of the price at which he had 
 estimated it to be worth. 
 
 The decision reached by the church was not altogether satis- 
 factory. The resolutions had evidently been prepared in the 
 spirit of compromise. Many thought that justice to Elder 
 Knapp demanded a more unequivocal expression of sympathy 
 and approval ; a few thought that a more explicit tone of cen- 
 sure ought to have been expressed. The community had been 
 agitated for months, opinions had become divided, friends had 
 become alienated, issues had been made, and pride had been 
 roused. 
 
 The consequences followed. Professor Taylor was induced 
 to remove to Lewisburgh, Penn., and there lay the foundations
 
 ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. XXV 
 
 of that noble institution now known as Lewisburgh University, 
 Professor Maginnis lent himself vigorously to the attempt to 
 remove the Madison University from Hamilton to Rochester. 
 The agitation of this question ensued ; and finally two institu- 
 tions of learning were secured to the Baptist denomination, 
 one in Hamilton and one in Rochester, each well endowed, 
 manned by an able corps of teachers, and filled with students. 
 Elder Knapp removed to Illinois, and in this western world 
 continued his work as an evangelist, in communities where the 
 churches were too poor to give him much compensation, and 
 in communities in which there were no churches at all, and 
 where the only remuneration he could receive was the satisfac- 
 tion of doing good, without reward from men. 
 
 In the review of this whole matter, it seems to be just and 
 proper to say, good men differed. " The contention between 
 them was so sharp, that," as in the case of two good men cen- 
 turies ago, " they departed asunder, the one from the other ; " 
 and that the contention in this case, as in that, has turned out 
 to the furtherance of 'the gospel. In these results let all 
 rejoice, even those who have personally suffered the most. 
 
 At the same time, the retrospect of this unfortunate affair 
 cannot fail to bring great consolation to Elder Knapp. He has 
 learned many valuable lessons and gained much rich experience, 
 the realization of which must fill his heart with humble grati- 
 tude to God. A scrutiny into his life-long conduct, invigorated 
 as it was by personal animosities, was able to fix upon no 
 greater fault than a foible, and was able to make no sufficient 
 ground of complaint even on such a point. The brethren who 
 were participants in the investigation, and unanimously attested 
 his integrity, were men whose eminent and widely-known repu- 
 tation for probity and sagacity challenges the confidence of the 
 public. God has graciously kept him from sinking under the 
 trial, and retiring from the ministry. By reason of his removal 
 to the West, the sphere of his influence has been enlarged. He 
 is still enabled, at an advanced age of life, to labor for the 
 salvation of souls, and finds his declining years cheered with
 
 XXVI ELDER KNAPP AND HIS MINISTRY. 
 
 numerous expressions of the cordial sympathy and confidence 
 of his brethren. He is comforted by the reasonable expecta- 
 tion that his name will be cherished in the hearts of coming 
 generations. He is nerved to still greater efforts in honor of the 
 Savior, by the hope that when he shall rest from his labors, his 
 works will follow him, in the adoption of his measures as per- 
 manent instrumentalities for promoting the cause of Christ. 
 And the few years yet remaining to him on earth are cheered 
 by the joyous anticipation of meeting, in the final gathering, 
 multitudes who will forever ascribe their position in the blood- 
 washed throng to the blessing of God on the preaching and 
 prayers of JACOB KNAPP.
 
 INTRODUCTION. 
 
 IN the early part of my ministry as an Evangelist, I had no 
 intention of publishing anything myself concerning my labors, 
 nor of leaving anything for others to publish after I was dead. 
 Consequently I kept no journal, and wrote nothing with that 
 end in view. 
 
 As time rolled on, and important events continually multiplied, 
 I was advised by friend after friend to be preparing something 
 which might be useful after my decease. I began to write some- 
 what, but was heartless about it, and finally destroyed all I 
 had written, lest it might minister to an unholy ambition, and 
 come in conflict with my determination to " crucify the flesh, with 
 the affections and lusts." 
 
 At length many persons urged the subject of my publishing, 
 as a matter of duty. They assured me that a history of my 
 labors would be of great benefit to those who would come after 
 me. This view had great weight with me. I therefore began 
 to write again, but only occasionally ; not thinking that what 
 I might prepare would be made public while I was in the land 
 of tlje living. In the year 1866 I consulted many eminent 
 brethren, in whose judgments I had more confidence than in 
 my own. They advised me to prepare a history of my minis- 
 try for publication at once. They assured me that my hesita- 
 tion to do so arose from the dictates of false delicacy, that the 
 rising ministry and the present age ought not to be denied the 
 benefits of my long experience.
 
 12 INTRODUCTION. 
 
 On reflection I could see that I was outliving my generation, 
 and that another had already risen, which knew not Jacob. I 
 realized that soon those who would be most interested in this 
 work, by reason of their personal relations to my ministry, would 
 be gone, while many who could bear witness to the truth of 
 the marvellous things I might relate, would be where their 
 testimony could not be had. 
 
 In view of these considerations I went to writing an account 
 of the different meetings, and of the remarkable incidents which 
 occurred in them, as best I could from recollection. There will 
 be, doubtless, some mistakes in the accounts given, as many 
 years have elapsed since several of the occurrences related took 
 place ; but I am confident that they are substantially correct, 
 and not overdrawn. If I had kept a strict account of all the 
 incidents of my life as they transpired, the work would have 
 been far more comprehensive and interesting ; but the details of 
 many events have faded from my memory, while of others I 
 think it well to say nothing, because, at this distance of time, 
 their verity could not be easily corroborated. 
 
 The peculiar nature of my ministry, covering, as it does, a 
 period in which I was called to encounter the opposition of deep- 
 seated prejudices, has necessarily brought me in conflict with 
 many, who, more or less conscientiously, have set themselves to 
 hinder the success of my labors and disparage my influence. 
 Many of these are now dead ; a few are still living ; but in refer- 
 ence to none do I wish to perpetuate unkind memories, and there- 
 fore have purposely avoided mentioning such by name, except 
 wherever fidelity to truth and an intelligible statement have com- 
 pelled me to do so. In the language of the lamented Lincoln, 
 I do sincerely say that " with malice towards none, and charity 
 for all," I submit my book to the prayerful and candid consid- 
 eration of the Christian public. 
 
 JACOB KNAPP.
 
 AUTOBIOGRAPHY 
 
 OF 
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 
 
 CHAPTER I. 
 
 Birth, Parentage, and early Religious Instructions. Experience of 
 Conviction and Conversion. Backsliding. Removal West. 
 Attending School in the East. Ball-room and Prayer-meeting. 
 Re-consecration. Baptism. 
 
 I "WAS born in Otsego County, in the State of New York, 
 on the 7th day of December, 1799. My father was in 
 moderate circumstances. I lived with my parents during most 
 of the period of my minority. 
 
 My parents and grand-parents on my father's side were Epis- 
 copalians ; consequently I was brought up to attend the church, 
 and was taught the Creed and Catechism from my infancy. My 
 mind was early, and at times deeply, impressed with divine 
 truth. From the first of my remembrance I had seasons of 
 secret prayer, and of deep anxiety about the future welfare 
 of my soul ; but I was not led to hope in Christ as my Savior 
 until the summer of my seventeenth year, when it pleased God 
 to take from me my dear mother. 
 
 This sad bereavement led me, more than ever before, to feel 
 my need of a Comforter and Friend which this world could not 
 afford, and to see the emptiness and vanity of all terrestrial 
 enjoyments. I separated myself for a time from rude company, 
 
 (13)
 
 14 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF 
 
 and betook myself to the Bible, hymn-book, prayer, and the 
 bouse of God. My health declined in consequence of ray dis- 
 tress of mind ; so much so, that I remember that, coming one 
 day from the woods where I had been to pray, my father 
 remarked, that as my health was so poor,- he should have to 
 put me to a trade. I thought to myself, " Little does my father 
 guess my disease, or the kind of treatment which the nature of 
 my case demands." I often repaired to the barn or the grove in 
 the silent hours of the night, and poured out my soul in prayer 
 to God. 
 
 At length, one Lord's day morning, I took my Bible and 
 hymn-book, and repaired to the woods, with a determination 
 never to return without relief to my soul. I went some dis- 
 tance from human sight or hearing, laid myself down on a 
 grassy knoll, and prayed and read, and read and prayed. All 
 the promises seemed beautiful, and of more value than all the 
 world besides ; the hymns appeared glorious ; but, " Ah," 
 thought I, " I can never sing them in heaven ; this happiness is 
 for another." I felt my vileness ; all my sins rose before me 
 like mountains. I thought I had prayed, read the Bible, at- 
 tended meetings, and done all that was in my power to do ; and 
 yet I seemed to grow worse and worse, more and more despi- 
 cable in the sight of God. Not as yet understanding the way 
 of salvation, but trusting to my own righteousness, and now 
 discovering that to be worthless and an offence to a holy God, I 
 felt myself sinking down into despair. I saw clearly the right- 
 eousness of God in sending me to the lowest hell. At this 
 moment the earth seemed to open beneath me, and hell appeared 
 to be yawning for my reception. I closed my eyes, fully expect- 
 ing to open them no more until I opened them in hell, and lifted 
 them up with the rich man in torment. 
 
 But, to the joy and rapture of my soul, after a short space of 
 time passgd in this condition, my load of guilt was gone. I 
 rose up quickly, turned my eyes towards heaven, and thought I 
 saw Jesus descending with his arms extended for my reception. 
 My soul leaped within me, and I broke forth into singing praises 
 to the blessed Savior. The sweet melodies of the birds seemed
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 15 
 
 to make harmony with my songs, and, as I looked around me, 
 the sun shone with a lustre not his own, the majestic trees, 
 swaying to the gentle breeze, appeared to bow in sweet submis- 
 sion to the will of Heaven. All nature smiled, and everything, 
 animate and inanimate, praised God with a voice (though 
 unheard before) too loud and too plain to be misunderstood. 
 At this moment I lost all concern about heaven or hell ; my 
 soul was wholly absorbed in loving and praising Him whom 
 angels adore and all nature magnifies. I then knew the peace 
 there was in believing in Jesus, and I saw that he had borne 
 the guilt of my sins, and " become the end of the law for right- 
 eousness to every one that believeth." 
 
 Soon after this I was led to examine the word of God, to 
 know what he would have me to do. I found very shortly that 
 God commanded me to repent and be baptized. Nor was I at 
 a loss to find out what baptism was. Though but a youth, and 
 always taught that sprinkling was baptism, and that infants were 
 proper subjects, yet I saw that in the days of the apostles the 
 candidates were required to bring forth fruits meet for repent- 
 ance, to believe with all the heart, and that when they had 
 repented and believed they went down into the water and came 
 up out of the water, being buried. This procedure I could not 
 think necessary in order merely to sprinkle a person. 
 
 About this time, in Masonville, Delaware County, near which 
 place my father then resided, there was a revival among the 
 Baptists. I attended the preaching, and saw some converts 
 baptized. The scene produced a powerful impression on me. 
 " This," thought I, " is the way in which John the Baptist, 
 Philip, and all the apostles baptized ; " and the more I read the 
 more I was confirmed in my convictions that my having been 
 sprinkled in infancy would not answer the commands of God, to 
 believe and be baptized. Nor could I find food for my hungry 
 soul iu the forms and ceremonies of the Episcopal church, 
 though heretofore I had ever held her in such, high veneration 
 as the Holy Catholic Church. 
 
 For a long time I felt it both a duty and a privilege to be 
 " buried with Christ in baptism," but inasmuch as I was under
 
 16 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 age, and my father and grand-parents were very much unrecon- 
 ciled to my joining the Baptist church, and I could in con- 
 science join no other, I remained out of any, designing when 
 of age to arise and follow my Lord. I continued to enjoy the 
 presence of Jesus for some length of time, say ten or twelve 
 months. But beginning about then to enter into the ranks of 
 young company, and joining heartily in many of their amuse- 
 ments, I found myself yielding to the temptations that sur- 
 rounded me, and' experienced a serious decline in spirituality : 
 like Peter, I began to follow Jesus " afar off." 
 
 The summer of 1817 I spent in Cayuga County, N. Y., during 
 which time I lived far from God. I became so exceedingly 
 rude that I often delivered orations and made speeches concern- 
 ing religion for sport. One day, I remember, I was sent for by 
 a wild set of young men to preach the funeral sermon of a 
 horse. This request shocked me, and served to open my eyes as 
 to my condition. During all this period of criminal wildness I 
 frequently had seasons of secret prayer and of weeping and 
 bitterness over my course of living, and as often resolved to re- 
 form. I never could, even in my most distant wanderings, hear 
 religion ridiculed, or the name of Christ profaned, or his people 
 reproached, without great pain. Such allusions would pierce 
 my heart like a dagger, and become the occasions of great com- 
 punction. 
 
 About this time, I removed with my father, into a new country, 
 on the head waters of the Ohio River. There I was cutoff from 
 all religious privileges. During the first year of my residence 
 I did not hear a single sermon. There were no religious meet- 
 ings whatever in the neighborhood. At first the sense of 
 these deprivations served to quicken within me an appreciation 
 of those opportunities and blessings which I had so sadly 
 neglected and abused, and I formed a determination to lead a 
 new life. For a while I succeeded in carrying out my resolu- 
 tion, but very soon I found my need of the appointed means of 
 grace, and again I, wandered far from God. 
 
 In December, 1818, assisted by my father, I returned to 
 Delaware County, N. Y., for the purpose of attending school.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 17 
 
 I was overjoyed to see my young companions again ; and. after 
 being urged somewhat, I consented to attend with them a New 
 Year's ball, for which they were then busily making prepara- 
 tions. I yielded, however, to their importunities with reluc- 
 tance, excusing myself on the ground of my long absence, and 
 resolving that this should be the last in which I would engage. 
 Shortly before the time fixed upon, I learned that the Baptist 
 church had appointed a prayer-meeting for the same night in 
 the school-house across the way from the ball-room. This 
 coincidence disturbed me very much. I thought of the lan- 
 guage of Christ, " He that is not for me is against me." I 
 repented of my engagement, but thought I could not go back. 
 I prayed and wept in secret places and in the silent hours of 
 the night. The Spirit seemed to say to me, " Here are two 
 meetings ; one in which to worship God, and for what is the 
 other?" The answer was forced from my lips, " To serve the 
 devil. It is against Christ." Then I exclaimed, with tears 
 streaming down my cheeks, " Hast thou done so much for me, 
 O thou blessed Jesus, and am I against thee ? Am I scattering 
 abroad ? " And straightway I resolved that instead of attending 
 the ball, I would go to the prayer-meeting ; that I would desert 
 the devil, and serve him no longer. I found him to be a cruel 
 master, and Jesus to be full of kindness and tender mercy. 
 
 God, in his infinite goodness, had impressed the minds of 
 some other of my companions in a similar manner ; and two 01 
 three of them, who had designed to attend the ball, went with 
 me to the meeting. While this band of praying disciples was 
 engaged in songs and supplications, we could hear the music of 
 the fiddle, and the company of dancers could at the same time 
 catch, the sound of voices in prayer and songs of praise. The 
 exercises of the meeting discovered no unusual amount of 
 religious interest ; but my own feelings were deeply moved, 
 and I covered my face in order to conceal them. ' With diffi- 
 culty did I withhold an expression, and my heart almost burst 
 within me. At length the meeting was brought to a close ; and 
 as the brethren rose up to depart, I opened my mouth, and gave
 
 18 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 vent to the burden of my heart. This done, the devil was 
 vanquished. All fell on their knees, and I attempted to pray 
 in public for the first time ; others followed me. From that 
 moment a revival commenced, which resulted in the conversion 
 of sixty young people, who were added to the church that win- 
 ter. Of this number, nine were convicted on that same evening, 
 while in the ball-room, under the voice of prayer which they 
 heard from across the street. 
 
 At this time I began to be strongly impressed with the con- 
 viction that it was my duty to be baptized and unite with the 
 church. The command, " Arise and be baptized," kept ringing 
 in my ears night and day. But 1 was under age, more than 
 two hundred miles from home, and well knew the unwillingness 
 of my father to my joining a Baptist church. I hesitated to 
 take this important step without informing him of my wishes 
 and obtaining his consent. After much prayer and many tears, 
 I sat down and wrote him a letter, telling him all my heart, and 
 begging his permission to do what I felt God in his word re- 
 quired of me. Week after week did I wait for an answer ; but 
 none came. As the time drew near when I was to return to 
 my home in the west, knowing that there was no church with- 
 in many miles of it, I made up my mind to confer no longer 
 '" with flesh and blood," but to obey God rather than man. 
 
 Accordingly, I told my experience to the Baptist church at 
 Masonville, and was received as a candidate for baptism. This 
 was in the month of February, 1819. On the next Lord's day 
 the great desire of my heart was gratified : I was buried with 
 Christ in baptism. My soul experienced an ecstasy of delight. 
 I had suffered so much in consequence of neglected duties, and 
 had overcome so many obstructions in the path of duty, that 
 the consciousness that I was permitted to follow the example 
 of my precious Savior seemed to make this day the happiest of 
 my life. I wondered how I could have neglected this beautiful 
 ordinance so long. For some time after this I never came near 
 the spot without thinking, what a pleasure it would be to be 
 buried again in the same symbolic grave.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP, 19 
 
 CHAPTER II. 
 
 Return Home. Neighborhood Efforts. Choice of a Calling. 7?e- 
 turn East to obtain an Education. School at Masonville. Visit 
 to Columbia County, and Journey back. Academy at Gilbertsville. 
 
 Economy. A Revival. School-teaching in New Lisbon. 
 Conflicts as to Duty. Hamilton Institution. Licensed to preach. 
 
 Marriage and Pastorate at Springfield. Second Pastorate at 
 Watertown, N. Y. Reflections on ministerial Worldliness. 
 
 WAS now nineteen years of age. It being the custom of 
 my father to give his sons their time when they were twenty 
 years old, I returned to my father's house, and remained sub- 
 ject to him during the appointed time. All this while I was 
 thirsting for knowledge and better qualifications for usefulness. 
 My mind was greatly impressed with the duty and the desire 
 of preaching the gospel. But how to obtain a suitable educa- 
 tion I did not know. I was poor, had no friends who could or 
 would help me, and was not aware of the existence of any 
 ministerial education society. I labored, as God gave me oppor- 
 tunity, according to my ability. Realizing the great religious 
 destitution of the country where my father resided, I appointed 
 prayer-meetings in the neighborhood, gathered together the few 
 scattered sheep in this portion of the western wilderness, and 
 was encouraged to continue in these efforts, and strengthened 
 in my convictions concerning preaching the gospel, because it 
 pleased God to crown these humble efforts with success in the 
 conversion of several souls. 
 
 When the time came in which I was to choose my path in 
 life, my father offered to assist me quite liberally, considering 
 his means, in buying a farm and clearing up land. My broth- 
 ers were doing so with flattering prospects. But farms and
 
 20 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 earthly possessions were nothing to me. A nobler ambition 
 urged me on ; and yet, pressed down with a sense of my own 
 insufficiency, I knew not how to achieve it. Still I felt my suf- 
 ficiency to be of God ; in him I put my trust, and resolved to go 
 forward. I believed that God called me to the work of the 
 ministry, and had full confidence that he would provide a way 
 in which I should be the better fitted to enter upon it. 
 
 In this simple faith I went forth, like Abraham of old, not 
 knowing whither I was going, or how I should be able to reach 
 the end of my journey. I merely felt that in case I could get 
 back into Delaware County, some way would be opened in 
 which I could prosecute my desire for an education. In this 
 spirit I shouldered my pack, took leave of my friends, and set 
 my face towards the east. As I passed a new clearing of my 
 elder brother, I sat down on a log and lifted up my heart to God 
 in prayer that," during my absence, my own mind might undergo 
 as great an improvement as his farm promised to present. Hav- 
 ing but few clothes beyond those I had on my back, only five 
 dollars in money, and a journey of two hundred and ten miles 
 to perform, I resolved to save every penny possible, and yet p.'iy 
 for everything I received. When hungry and fatigued, I would 
 seek out a spring of water, and, sitting down by its side, would 
 refresh myself with provisions from my knapsack. In this man- 
 ner I accomplished my journey at a cost of only fifty cents, 
 having saved four dollars and fifty cents with which to com- 
 mence my education for the ministry. 
 
 When I reached Masonville I found a place at once, where I 
 could obtain board and lodging by doing the chores of the family. 
 Here I continued, pursuing my studies, for a short time ; when 
 one of my uncles, residing in Columbia County, invited me to 
 go home with him and attend school there. I did so, and re- 
 mained with him till about the breaking up of winter. By this 
 time I was at a loss to know what to do, for I was nearly out 
 of clothing, and had no means wherewith to buy more. I con- 
 cluded to return to Delaware County, and engage in the work 
 of rafting lumber, until I could earn sufficient for the renewal 
 of my wardrobe and the expenses of another winter's tuition.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 21 
 
 I started on my journey of one hundred and twenty miles on 
 foot, with but twenty-five cents iu my pocket. It rained severely 
 all day ; but I trudged on, till I reached the Hudson River. Here 
 I paid one half of my twenty-five cents for ferriage across. With 
 one half of the remainder I paid for my night's lodging. Through- 
 out the next day I continued on through a drenching rain, for I 
 could not afford to wait over. Towards night I fell in with a man 
 in a wagon who asked me to ride. But this apparent relief turned 
 out to my greater disadvantage ; for while we were stopping to 
 feed the horse, a dog stole the bundle containing my few clothes 
 and provisions. Here, then, I was, tired and hungry, among 
 strangers, with no money, and no one to befriend me. I inquired 
 for a chance for labor, but could learn of none. I went on my 
 way until ten o'clock at night. I then called for lodgings, for 
 which I paid my last sixpence, going to bed hungry and getting up 
 hungry. On the next day I pursued my journey till about twelve 
 o'clock, when I reached the house of a friend, by whom my 
 necessities were relieved. During all these distresses my confi- 
 dence in God remained unshaken, and I counted them as nothing 
 if I could only accomplish my purpose. 
 
 I then hired myself -out to a man, with whom I was to raft 
 and run lumber to Philadelphia. The water fell and left us on 
 the way. He failed, and I lost the principal part of my wages. 
 
 Shortly after my return from this adventure, I heard of an 
 academy at Gilbertsville, Otsego County ; and trusting in God 
 to direct my steps and help me on, I arrived at this place 
 near the end of April, 1821, with but few clothes for the sum- 
 mer, and about money enough to pay for one quarter's tuition. 
 I called on Mr. Collins, the principal of the Institution, and 
 made known to him my situation and my wishes. He seemed 
 to take an interest in my case, and recommended me to several 
 families, who, he thought, might be willing to let me do work 
 about the house for my board. But after making several fruit- 
 less applications, Mr. Collins told me that I might board with 
 him, do what few chores he needed to have done, and pay him 
 iu full whenever I was able to do so. I felt extremely grateful
 
 22 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF 
 
 for his kindness, but yet I could hardly endure the thought of 
 running in debt. However, I concluded to accept the offer, and 
 accordingly commenced my studies. 
 
 Not being accustomed to study closely, my mind being alto- 
 gether undisciplined, I made only slow progress in acquiring 
 knowledge. I was often reminded of the remark of my father, 
 as I was leaving home, that he feared, if I went off among the 
 Baptists with a notion of preaching, I would spend two or 
 three years making out nothing, and would come back poor and 
 disgusted. Daily did I repair to the grove north of the acad- 
 emy, and pour out my soul in prayer to God to strengthen my 
 memory, discipline my mind, and aid me in my studies. In 
 this grove I shed many tears and enjoyed many seasons of com- 
 munion with God. I applied myself to study with diligence, 
 and practised a rigid economy, going in my shirt sleeves in order 
 to save my coat for the winter. 
 
 At the close of the first quarter I went to work through 
 harvest season, by which means I was able to provide for the 
 expenses of the ensuing term, and as the evenings lengthened I 
 chopped wood by moonlight to obtain articles I could not do 
 without. 
 
 During the second term I attended the Baptist meeting on the 
 hill ; and as they had no minister, I was called upon to take 
 charge of the meetings. It pleased the Lord to pour out his 
 Spirit gloriously. When I first went there, there was but one 
 youth in the place who professed religion, and within about two 
 months nearly all the young people in the place were converted 
 to God. Towards the close of this quarter I began to feel more 
 than ever straitened as to what course to pursue. I was not 
 able to earn enough during vacations to meet the necessary ex- 
 penses of term time, nor did I feel myself competent to teach 
 school in that vicinity. While I was thinking and praying 
 about it, the Lord inclined the hearts of the good sisters of the 
 place to prepare me a suit of clothes for the winter ; besides, I 
 had several invitations from brethren, both Baptist and Presby- 
 terian, to board a few weeks in their families. In this manner, I
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 23 
 
 was enabled to pursue ray studies until some time in January, 
 when I received and accepted a request to take charge of a 
 school in New Lisbon, Otsego County. Here the Lord was 
 pleased to bless my efforts for the conversion of the children 
 connected with my school. In particular do I remember one 
 instance in which a son of a Romanist professed his faith in 
 Christ, even though taken from school because prayer and reli- 
 gious instruction were maintained there. During this winter I 
 spent my evenings in holding meetings in different neighbor- 
 hoods (Jhough I did not pretend to preach), and God was with 
 me, and many souls were converted. 
 
 But as the winter began to wear away, I felt it to be necessary 
 for me to decide whether I should preach the gospel, or abandon 
 the thought of it altogether. A sense of my insufficiency Avas 
 ever bearing upon my spirits, and, yielding to the impression 
 which it produced, at length I concluded to give up the idea, 
 and turn my attention to some other pursuit. But no sooner 
 had I reached this decision, than trouble rolled in upon ma like 
 a flood. I was well nigh driven to despair. One night, es- 
 pecially, I remained concealed behind the seats of the school- 
 room, while being occupied for purposes of worship, lest I 
 should be called on to take part in the exercises, and so con- 
 tinued unobserved till the meeting was dispersed. I staid all 
 night in the school-house, and all the next morning till the hour 
 for school arrived. My mind was in no fit condition for the 
 proper discharge of the duties of my station, and I could not 
 refrain from tears in the presence of my scholars. I dismissed 
 the school with a determination to remain in the building all the 
 next night, although thirty-six hours had then elapsed since I 
 had tasted food. But about dark one of the brethren came 
 after me, concluding, from a statement of one of the children, 
 that something was the matter with me. I dared not, however, 
 open my mind to any one respecting my impressions, so that I 
 could gain but little relief from the sympathies of friends. 
 
 But " man's extremity is God's opportunity." On the next 
 day, on going to the post-office, I found a letter, which proved to
 
 24 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 be from Hamilton, Madison County, inviting me to visit the 
 Institution,* which had been recently established there for the 
 purpose of educating young men desirous of entering the Bap- 
 tist ministry, and encouraging me to attempt a regular course 
 of study. I then saw that God, in his providence, was opening 
 the way for me, and that all I had to do was to trust him and 
 move forward. 
 
 I also felt greatly rebuked for my past distrust and unbelief. I 
 wept and prayed ; " thanked God and took courage." Yet there 
 was one thing that still troubled me. Before I could be admit- 
 ted into the Institution at Hamilton, it was needful that I obtain 
 from the church of which I was a member a formal license to 
 preach. To proceed in this matter myself seemed a formidable 
 undertaking. In those days the prevailing opinion among Bap- 
 tists was, that if a young man was truly called of God to preach, 
 
 * In the year 1812, Rev. Daniel Hascall, pastor of the Baptist church 
 at Hamilton, and Rev. Nathaniel Kendrick, pastor of the church at Eaton, 
 in mutual conference, conceived the idea of an Education Society, in 
 aid of indigent young men desirous of studying for the ministry. The 
 Society was organized in 1817, and chartered in 1819 under the name 
 and style of the Baptist Education Society of the State of New York. 
 Under the auspices of this Society, Hamilton Literary and Theological 
 Institution was founded in 1820. Hascall was appointed the classical 
 and Kendrick the theological instructor. Hascall continued sixteen 
 years, and resigned ; Kendrick, twenty-eight years, and died. The Bap- 
 tist denomination will hold the names of these venerable men of God in 
 everlasting remembrance. 
 
 For a considerable period the course of instruction comprised four 
 years, afterwards six, and finally eight. About 1846, the Institution was 
 chartered as Madison University. In addition to sending out multitudes 
 of young men into the Christian ministry, this noble Institution is 
 identified with the founding of Rochester University, New York, and of 
 Lewisburg University, Pennsylvania, besides being the grand pioneer in 
 the culture of that zeal for ministerial education which now constitutes 
 one of the glories of the Baptist denomination. 
 
 Madison University still maintains her educational prestige, and her 
 hold on the gratitude and confidence of the denomination, whose present 
 greatness is owing, under God, so much to agencies which have made her 
 name illustrious.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 25 
 
 he would be unable to restrain the expression of his convictions. 
 It was deemed a sort of interference with the work of the Spirit 
 for any of the brethren to introduce the subject, and afford any 
 encouragement. But my views of my own insufficiency were 
 so oppressive, and my dread of being rejected so intense, that it 
 was with the greatest difficulty that I could bring my mind to 
 broach the matter, and ask the church to grant me a license. 
 
 At length, however, I concluded to do so. Accordingly I 
 closed my school, and, going to Masonville, opened my mind to 
 one of the deacons. He named it to others of the brethren, 
 and the church invited me to preach before them. And in com- 
 plying with this invitation, I made my first formal attempt at 
 sermonising. This was in the spring of 1822. The church, 
 after hearing me once, gave me a license, and recommended me 
 to the Institution at Hamilton, informing me (to my surprise) 
 that it had long been the opinion of the brethren that I ought to 
 devote myself to the work of the ministry. Immediately, I 
 started on foot for Hamilton, a distance of about fifty miles. 
 
 Shortly after my entrance into the Institution, Professor Has- 
 call requested me to preach in a neighboring school-house. 
 Overwhelmed with a sense of my inability, I took the stand 
 and announced my text. But no sooner had the words passed 
 from my lips, than my eye fell on the form of my venerable 
 instructor. His presence entirely unmanned me. I man- 
 aged amid much confusion of thought, to get through the dis- 
 course, fully expecting that he would advise me to give up the 
 thought of preaching, and leave thei Institution. After wait- 
 ing some time, and hearing nothing from him, I ventured to call 
 upon him, and unburden my heart of its apprehensions and 
 misgivings. Instead, however, of discouraging me,. he bade me 
 go on. Shortly after this I was sent to preach, on the Sabbath, 
 to the church in Morrisville, the county seat. This was the first 
 instance in which I had been asked to preach in a meeting- 
 house. The thought of doing so filled me with fear and trem- 
 bling. But the Lord strengthened me, and gave me liberty. 
 
 As I had not been accustomed to study in early life, I found 
 4
 
 26 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF 
 
 it very difficult for a time to keep up with some of my class- 
 mates in the lessons. Yet I applied myself with diligence, and 
 as I was blessed with a good constitution, and maintained 
 vigorous exercise, I was enabled to go through the course 
 without impairing my health. In the month of June, 1825, I 
 received my diploma, and accepted a call from the Baptist 
 church in Springfield, Otsego County, N. Y. On the first day 
 of the September following I was married to Electa Payne, 
 of Hamilton. One week previous to my marriage I was or- 
 dained. 
 
 During my studies at the Institution my spirituality declined, 
 and I entered quite deeply into the spirit of a man-pleasing policy. 
 I fancied that the gospel might be so preached as not to give 
 offence. It seemed to me that it might be made attractive 
 to men by means of its external appointments. I imagined 
 that fine meeting-houses, tall steeples, good bells, and smooth 
 sermons were calculated to make the religion of Christ 
 popular. Alas ! I did not then realize that the prophets and 
 apostles, John the Baptist, and Jesus Christ himself, were not 
 able to preach the truth without causing many to be offended. 
 Nor did I understand that in every age in which the church had 
 striven to make herself acceptable to the world, to the same 
 degree had she been deprived of her beauty and her power. 
 O ! when will ministers and Christians learn that the " carnal 
 mind is enmity against God," and a true presentation of the 
 gospel consists not in flattering the natural taste of the unsancti- 
 fied heart, but by " manifestation of the truth, commending it 
 to every man's conscience in the sight of God " ? 
 
 During the first year of my pastorate, I devoted my time 
 wholly to my work ; nor were my labors entirely devoid of God's 
 blessing. The numerous difficulties which had long existed in 
 the church were settled, and the number of members and attend- 
 ants increased. After a while, however, under the advice of 
 my brethren in the church, and influenced by the example of 
 other ministers, I was induced to purchase a small farm, suppos- 
 ing that I could carry on the work of farming without detract-
 
 ELDER JACOB KXAPP. 27 
 
 ing from the efficiency of my services as a pastor. Nor did I 
 really find out my mistake during my stay with this people. 
 Though there was no general breaking forth of God's power, 
 yet there was a prevailing state of harmony, and about sixty 
 conversions. These results I tried to accept as grounds of en- 
 couragement, and evidences that I was in the path of duty. 
 
 After serving this church five years, I accepted a call from 
 the Baptist church in Watertown, Jefferson County, N. Y., and 
 entered upon my labors there in the month of September, 1830. 
 My family being at that time small, I did not for the first year 
 keep house, and was, therefore, free from household cares, and 
 enabled to devote myself exclusively to my pastoral work. The 
 Lord was with me. A revival of religion marked the very be- 
 ginning of my labors, and continued for about one year. The 
 church being small and poor, they failed to give me enough for 
 the current support of my family. And it will be>a matter of 
 life-long regret that I did not trust more implicitly in God for 
 my sustenance, and concern myself only about my Master's busi- 
 ness. Had I done so, I have no doubt but that my family would 
 have suffered no lack, and my ministerial work would have been 
 attended with much greater success. Instead of doing this, I 
 again bought a farm near the village, thinking that I could su- 
 perintend it without any serious disparagement of my usefulness. 
 But the experiment proved to be a great hinderance, alike to my 
 own piety and the growth of the church. Though, during a min- 
 istry of three years with this people, I baptized into the fellow- 
 ship of the church about two hundred converts, yet towards 
 the end of that time I began to feel that I was unfaithful to my 
 trust, that I was entangling myself with the affairs of this life, 
 and that God was displeased with my course.
 
 28 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 CHAPTER III. 
 
 Protracted Meetings a Novelty. Resolution to become an Evan- 
 gelist. Counting the Cost. Resignation of Pastorate. Results 
 of the Labors of eighteen Months among the Churches. Trials. 
 Opposition. Pecuniary Losses. Application to the State Con- 
 vention. Application rejected. Mortification of Feelings. 
 Fasting and Prayer. God's Presence and Direction. Blessed 
 Results. Trust in God for Support. Method of preparing 
 Sermons. Re-conversions needful. 
 
 ABOUT this time, 1833, Ihe practice of holding protracted 
 meetings began to enter in amongst the Baptist churches. 
 These were of rare occurrence, and generally looked upon 
 with distrust and opposition. There prevailed among Bap- 
 tists, views of the sovereignty of the Holy Spirit in the con- 
 version of men, which led to a practical denial of the necessity 
 of all human agency in bringing sinners to consider the claims 
 of the gospel. The theology of that day was, that God evinced 
 his sovereignty independently of means, rather than through 
 them ; that human agencies were interferences with the divine 
 purposes, and that all experiences that might result from the use 
 of means were to be rejected as " man-made " conversions. 
 
 As might be expected, such teachings worked out their results 
 in the spiritual apathy of professors of religion, in the absence 
 of any great concern for the salvation of men, and in the paucity 
 of the numbers that were being added to the churches. But as 
 the news of the outpouring of God's Spirit in connection with 
 these " protracted " efforts, reached me, my own soul was set on 
 fire with zeal for the spread of the kingdom of Christ. I looked 
 upon the past eight years of my ministry as comparatively wasted. 
 I felt that I had turned aside for " filthy lucre." My motives
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 29 
 
 seemed to have been impure. I thought I would have given 
 worlds for the lost opportunities which I had failed to improve. 
 And regarding the care of my farm as a burden and a hin- 
 derance, I embraced the first opportunity of selling it, in the fol- 
 lowing spring, at great pecuniary sacrifice. Thus I broke from 
 all worldly concerns, and consecrated myself anew to the service 
 of God. I viewed the unconverted as toppling on the brink of 
 hell, and many of the churches, and ministers too, as sleeping at 
 their post. I felt a special moving of soul that God called me to 
 devote the remainder of my life to the direct work of an evangelist 
 among the churches ; striving to awaken them to the necessity of 
 a higher standard of active piety in laboring directly for the im- 
 mediate conversion of men. This conviction became the neces- 
 sity of my nature, and I could not resist it. I saw no alterna- 
 tive. God clearly bade me go forth into fields already white for 
 the harvest, and I was not disobedient to the heavenly vision. 
 
 Yet it is proper to state, that I did not reach this conclusion 
 without counting the cost. I saw that I should be cutting my- 
 self loose from any certain and regular source of support. Many 
 of the churches were so feeble as to find it a matter of great dif- 
 ficulty to raise the meagre salaries they had promised to their 
 pastors ; and, at the best, very few had even approximate con- 
 ceptions of the duty and blessedness of liberality in supporting 
 the gospel ; and, withal, I knew I must meet with great opposition 
 from many in the churches, who would denounce my endeavors 
 as " new-fangled measures ; " and much ridicule from ungodly 
 men, who would make common cause with these Sanballat sort 
 of Christians in hindering the work of God. But " none of 
 these things moved me." I resolved to forsake houses and 
 lands, wife and children, and go forth, trusting in God for the 
 support of my family, and relying on his promises of grace to 
 help in every time of need. 
 
 On the first Sabbath in September, 1833, I preached my 
 farewell sermon to the dear people of my charge, and found it 
 no small trial to tear myself away from their endearments, 
 aud especially from the precious lambs which had been brought
 
 30 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 to hope in Christ through my labors. Leaving my family in 
 Watertown, I spent the following eighteen months in visiting 
 the churches of Jefferson and Lewis Counties, and laboring 
 with them in protracted meetings. God was with me, and con- 
 verts were multiplied. His Spirit was poured out plenteously in 
 nearly every place in which I labored. My services were not 
 confined to Baptist churches, but in Presbyterian and Methodist 
 churches I preached repentance and faith as God gave me op- 
 portunity. It was thought by some, who were counted reliable 
 judges, that not less than two thousand souls were converted 
 during these eighteen months. As near as I can now remem- 
 ber, I baptized over four hundred converts into the fellowship 
 of churches which were at the time destitute of pastors. 
 
 But notwithstanding all these powerful attestations of God's 
 approval, I was called on to encounter great opposition, alike 
 from professed Christians and the avowed enemies of Christ ; 
 ay, even from ministers of the gospel. My motives were im- 
 pugned ; my sermons were dissected, and detached sentences 
 were taken from their connection and set forth in distorted 
 forms ; and the religious journals were closed to any accounts 
 of the " wonderful works of God." About this time, also, I met 
 with several severe losses in pecuniary matters, so-as to render 
 my reliance for support still more precarious. Altogether the 
 occasions of my rejoicing in view of my successes in laboring 
 for the conversion of sinners, was challenged by a series of con- 
 flicts and trials which hitherto I had not dreamed of, and which 
 I found to be exceedingly distressing. It seemed as though all 
 the devils in hell were let loose upon me, until I could almost 
 say with Dr. Payson, " The Lord has taken from me one thing 
 after another, until there remains no more to be taken, and dis- 
 appointed me in one way after another, until I am no longer 
 capable of disappointment." 
 
 At length I was advised, by Dr. Nathaniel Kendrick,* to 
 take an appointment from the Board of the Baptist Missionary 
 
 * Then, and for many years afterwards, the revered Principal of the 
 Hamilton Literary and Theological Institution.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 31 
 
 Convention of the State of New York,* as an evangelist in Jef- 
 ferson and Oswego Counties. I thought favorably of this 
 suggestion, imagining that such an appointment would increase 
 my influence and tend to silence my opposers. I therefore went 
 to the meeting of the Convention, about a hundred and forty 
 miles distant. I had not mingled with the brethren long, before 
 I found that some, whom I had counted as friends, were disposed 
 to treat me with coolness. Though indorsed by such a man as 
 Dr. Kendrick, whose weight of personal influence was every- 
 where recognized, yet my application was instantly met by a 
 decided opposition. One must tell what he had heard, another 
 explain his views of the gospel method, until, after a lengthy 
 debate, in which some cried one thing and some another, it 
 was resolved to refer the question of my appointment to a com- 
 mittee. This committee made an adverse report, and my 
 application was rejected. Overwhelmed with grief and morti- 
 fication, I started to fill an engagement to preach in Loraine, 
 a distance of about one hundred and fifty miles. The Lord 
 brought me safely on my way some fifty miles, when my horse 
 sickened and died. I got a brother to take me to Oswego, and 
 then I went on board a boat for Sackett's Harbor. Shortly 
 after we had started, " there arose a mighty tempest," and for 
 a while there appeared but little chance for any of our lives. 
 But my own spirits were so depressed that I seemed to have 
 little choice between life and death. I thought myself " in perils 
 by sea, in perils by land, and in perils by false brethren." But 
 God preserved me for greater joys and greater sorrows than 
 any I had hitherto experienced. 
 
 For a short time the effect of my rejection by the Board of 
 the Convention was very disheartening. I had hoped to secure, 
 by an appointment, greater influence among the churches, the 
 more positive countenance of some of the ministers who hitherto 
 had been sitting on the fence, hesitating as to which side to get 
 down on, and also to silence the active opposition of those who 
 
 * The object of this Convention is the raising and furnishing of funds 
 in aid of feehle churches throughout the State.
 
 32 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 had avowed their hostility to my course ; but it was not long 
 before I found that my difficulties in these directions were on 
 the increase. The non-committal became outspoken against 
 me, and those heretofore opposed became violent and abusive. 
 My soul was in deep trouble, and I knew not which way 
 to turn. 
 
 But in my distress I cast my burdens on the Lord. I sought 
 to know the will of God. I cried unto the Lord ; and, blessed 
 be his name, very soon he made known his ways, and lifted 
 upon me the light of his countenance. After spending one whole 
 day in fasting and prayer, and continuing my fast till midnight, 
 the place where I was staying, was filled with the manifested 
 glory of God. His presence appeared to me, not exactly in 
 visible form, but as really to my recognition as though he had 
 come in person, and a voice seemed to say to me, " Hast thou 
 ever lacked a field in which to labor?" I answered, "Not a 
 day." "Have I not sustained thee, and blessed thy labors?" 
 I answered, " Yea, Lord." " Then learn that henceforth thou 
 art not dependent on thy brethren, but on me. Have no con- 
 cern but to go on in thy work. My grace shall be sufficient 
 for thee." 
 
 From that night I felt willing to sacrifice the good opinion of 
 my brethren, as I had previously sacrificed the favor of the 
 world, and swing off from all dependences but God. Up to this 
 time I had concerned myself too much about the opinions of 
 other and older brethren, distrusting my youth and inexperience. 
 But the Lord taught me that he was my only infallible guide. 
 I joyously acquiesced in his will ; and from that day to this have 
 rested in this divine manifestation. Ah ! how reluctant we are 
 to cleave to the Lord ! How prone to cling to creature de- 
 pendences ! Since I have endeavored to seek divine direction 
 as to all my fields of labor, I have learned that it is possible for 
 me, generally, to gain as clear impressions of the will of God 
 concerning my duty as though it was announced in audible 
 tones. 
 
 In this manifestation of God's presence to me, he cast no re
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 33 
 
 flections on those of my ministerial brethren who differed from 
 me, but, in the most tender manner, bade me leave them to pur- 
 sue their own way, and cleave only to him. Thus was I, cured 
 of all yearnings for denominational promotion, led to make an 
 unreserved consecration of all my powers to the one end, the 
 conversion of men to Christ ; and made willing to labor on, 
 through evil and good import, leaving my vindication till the 
 day of judgment. 
 
 A year did not elapse before I saw plainly that God's plan 
 was much better than mine. I found it far more delightful 
 and profitable to my soul to be directed by God's providence, 
 where, and by his Spirit, how to labor, than to be prescribed in 
 my field, and dictated to as to how to conduct my ministry, by 
 others. The Lord carried me from place to place, even where I 
 had the least expectation of going. In my perplexities, I was 
 driven to God in prayer for him to direct my steps, and mark 
 out every inch of my path. And I have been led to under- 
 stand since, that had not the furnace been heated seven times 
 hotter than it was wont to be, the dross would never have been 
 separated from the gold. My kind and heavenly Father did 
 not give me one blow that was not needful, nor one thorn that 
 was not required to keep me from being exalted above measure, 
 through the abundance of my success in winning souls, and 
 the many flattering expressions of those who sympathized with 
 my work. 
 
 The churches with which I labored were, for the most part, 
 poor, and not well informed in relation to their duty of support- 
 ing the ministry. Sometimes I would receive thirty or forty 
 dollars at the close of a protracted meeting, and sometimes 
 nothing. I made up my mind, when I started, to make no 
 demand, to do nothing, to say nothing, in reference to the matter 
 of compensation, but to leave it entirely with God and the peo- 
 ple. Sometimes, after a hard, long, and laborious campaign, I 
 would return home to my increasing family with little or noth- 
 ing ; and find the means I had previously accumulated fast 
 wearing away, and my wife toiling day and night in taking care
 
 34 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 of our little ones. But I found good things mixed with these 
 apparently evil things. My wife made no complaints, but 
 cheerfully acquiesced in my convictions of duty. Besides, I 
 was comforted in the remembrance of the charge and promise, 
 " Trust in the Lord and do good, and verily thou shalt be fed." 
 " Thy bread shall be given thee, and thy water shall be sure." 
 I felt that I would prefer to live on bread and water, and do 
 the work of an evangelist, thus making full proof of my 
 ministry, than to have all the good things of this world. I 
 expected soon to wear out, and to be called to render my 
 account. I realized, more and more, how deficient I was in 
 knowledge, and prayed daily for wisdom rather than riches and 
 long life, that I might honor God, and become wise to win souls. 
 I often read God's offer to Solomon, and 1 believed that he would 
 deal in the same way now as then, if his servants would plead 
 in faith. 
 
 I prayed for the right text, for the best divisions of it, and a 
 true understanding of it ; and I have always found those sub- 
 jects which I studied in those days, and arranged while on my 
 knees, have been the most powerful for good ; and I now be- 
 lieve that there is a kind of inspiration about sermous thus 
 gotten up, which makes them " mighty through God to the 
 pulling down of the strongholds." And knowing, as I did, at 
 the beginning of my labors as an evangelist, that I lacked every- 
 thing, I pleaded the promise, "If any man lack wisdom, let 
 him ask of God, who giveth liberally." I made up my mind 
 to preach against sin everywhere, in every form, and in every- 
 body, and take the consequences. I knew I had no reputation 
 to lose, and thought I had none to gain ; hence I intended to 
 stand up for Jesus everywhere, on all occasions, and suffer 
 shame for his sake, bear the reproach of his cross, and count it 
 all joy that I was thought worthy to* suffer for his name. 
 
 I soon found that the state of a man's heart had much to do 
 with his judgment, and to a great extent controlled his senti- 
 ments. A cold-hearted or proud-spirited minister could not be 
 in sympathy with one who was led by the Spirit. I therefore
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 35 
 
 never attempted to lead into the light by argument those who 
 opposed themselves. Their eyes must be touched a second 
 time, before they can see clearly. Jesus said to Peter, " When 
 thou art converted, strengthen thy brethren ; " and evermore, it 
 seems that most persons need re-conversions, in order righlly 
 to understand the triths of God's word, or the plans of his 
 providence.
 
 36 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 CHAPTER IV. 
 CONDITION OF THE CHURCHES THEN AND NOW. 
 
 Forty Tears ago. No Sunday Schools. No Missionary Enter- 
 prise. Few educational Institutions. No Liberality. Antino- 
 mianism. Elder Benedict. Influence of Evangelism. Oppo- 
 sition of Hyper-Calvinism. Spurious Conversions. Sudden 
 Conversions. A doubting Piety. Jealousy. Men-pleasers. 
 Early Discipline. Consolation. Success. Sympathizers. 
 Change of Public Opinion. 
 
 AT this point, perhaps, better than at any other, I may pause 
 in my narrative to invite my readers to a consideration, 
 more at length, of the condition of the churches and their spirit 
 at the time when I began to labor as an evangelist, and of the 
 contrast which the state of religious sentiment in this age pre- 
 sents. Truly, as I look back forty years, and think of the 
 marvellous change that has come over the churches, I am 
 ready to exclaim with wondering gratitude, " What hath God 
 wrought ! " 
 
 Forty years ago there were no Sunday schools. The mighty 
 train of agencies and influences which now move along the 
 track of Sunday school efforts, had no place in the programme 
 of Christian enterprise. Now such institutions are regarded as 
 indispensable appointments in every church ; the noblest talents 
 of the church are consecrated to the instruction of the teeming 
 throngs of youth that crowd the gates of Zion ; and by far the 
 greater proportion of those who join the church are gathered 
 from the ranks of the Sunday school. Among Baptists this 
 blessed agency was almost unheard of, nor was there any other 
 appointment designed to take its place. 
 
 Forty years ago the cause of foreign and home missions had
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 37 
 
 scarcely place in the arrangements or sympathies of the vast 
 proportion of our churches. As a matter of course, there was 
 scarcely a missionary or a conversion among the heathen, and 
 but little money raised with which to send them. The mis- 
 sionary enterprise was then in its infancy, and battling its way 
 through prejudice and ignorance to the consciences of Christian 
 men. Since then our denomination has leaped to a front rank 
 in the grand instrumentalities for the world's conversion. Our 
 missionaries, home and foreign, are dotting the world. Multi- 
 tudes of souls at home, and in heathen lands, have been led to 
 Christ. Churches all over our western territory, and amid the 
 valleys, mountains, and jungles of India, are monuments of our 
 missionary zeal ; and every year our churches are sending up 
 increasing sums to the treasury of the Lord. 
 
 Forty years ago there was not more than one or two institu- 
 tions of learning under the auspices of our denomination, and 
 societies for the education of young men for the ministry were 
 just struggling into life. Now both colleges and education 
 societies are multiplying in numbers, or increasing in power in 
 the older states, and springing up as by magic in the new. 
 
 Forty years ago the churches had no idea of the obligations 
 and blessedness of Christian liberality. The ministers were 
 compelled, for the most part, to engage in farming or other 
 business pursuits, in order to eke out the beggarly salaries on 
 which the churches were willing to starve them ; and, in short, 
 the entire spirit of Christian enterprise was wanting. 
 
 As we contemplate the amazing differences in these regards 
 at the present time, and try to imagine the bearings of the 
 mighty forces now in operation on the future of the world's 
 conversion, I ask, Is there one intelligent Christian who would 
 wish to annihilate these grand agencies, obliterate this glorious 
 history, and place the churches and the denomination back into 
 the condition it occupied forty years ago ? It is not difficult to 
 imagine what would have been the history of the denomination 
 by this time, had the opinions then prevalent continued to main- 
 tain their ascendency. The history of these results is already
 
 88 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 written in the fate of those churches where the blight of reli- 
 gious apathy remained undisturbed. In the beginning of this 
 century there were numerous Baptist churches in Maryland ; a 
 few years ago there were only seven, and of these outside of 
 Baltimore it might truly have been said, " They have a name 
 to live while they are dead." In certain parts of Eastern New 
 York, the territory once held by Baptists has been taken up by 
 other denominations, and the Baptist name itself has become a 
 byword and a reproach. 
 
 In looking for an explanation of this wide-spread apathy and 
 inefficiency among the churches in former years, it is readily 
 found in the fact that they, nearly all, had drank in the spirit of 
 Antinomianisrn. Opposition to works, as the name itself indi- 
 cates, was a cardinal dogma, held with unflinching tenacity by 
 the ministers and the leading members of the churches. This 
 error, so fatal in its practical bearings, was the logical result 
 of those hyper-Calvinistic tenets which constituted the staple 
 of pulpit ministrations. Resolving all questions of religious 
 experience into the decrees of divine sovereignty, believing 
 that the salvation of the elect was 'determined by an eternal 
 purpose, irrespective of agencies, our fathers taught that an 
 attempt to instruct an inquirer, or plead with an impenitent 4 
 person, would be a presumptuous interference with the inscru- 
 table purposes of God. When God wanted to convict or convert 
 a sinner, he knew where to find him, and how to do it, without 
 the intervention of human effort ; and in his own u good time " 
 he would, in his own way, bring his elect into the fold. Accord- 
 ingly, it was held to be wrong to exhort sinners to repentance, to 
 exert any influence by way of encouragement to troubled hearts. 
 It was counted an excellent sign of being led by the Spirit, if 
 a person remained under silent conviction for years ; and to 
 indulge in constant doubts and fears of being accepted, was 
 thought to be one of the brightest evidences of personal elec- 
 tion. Parents studiously avoided religious conversation with 
 their children ; family prayer was rarely observed. In many 
 instances the logic of the creed made parents doubt the pro*
 
 Ik 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 39 
 
 priety of praying for the conversion of their children, while the 
 idea of teaching an unregenerate child to pray few himself was 
 deemed an approach to sacrilege. The grand argument in all 
 such cases was, If my child, or neighbor, or friend is one of 
 the elect, God will regenerate him without human intervention ; 
 and if he is not one of the elect, no human efforts will avail. 
 These views prevailed throughout the States of New York, New 
 Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware, and Maryland; 
 
 As a matter of course, in the scheme of such a theology, 
 Sunday schools, missionary enterprises, and protracted meetings 
 could find no place. In our day Christians have learned that 
 Antinomianism is a caricature of the cardinal truths of the 
 gospel. It is not necessary to deny the grand doctrines that 
 are co-related to the central truth of the divine sovereignty, in 
 order to justify the use of means. Let us understand only that 
 it is a part of the divine plan, that his purposes are to be 
 accomplished in answer to the prayers of his people, and as a 
 blessing upon their efforts, and we enter at once into the mind 
 of God, and find our highest inspiration in the confidence that 
 " qur labor will not be in vain," because the purposes of God 
 cannot fail of being accomplished. 
 
 > It is true there were some noble exceptions to this general 
 condition of denominational sentiment. There were a few- 
 ministers who began to discern the connection between " the 
 means and end." These noble men have nearly all passed 
 away, but their memories are blessed. They come down as 
 precious legacies, and their works do follow them in the ac- 
 cumulating forces which are now hastening on to usher in the 
 latter-day glories of the Lamb. Elder Benedict was preaching 
 in New York city all the Bible doctrines practically and suc- 
 cessfully. His labors were abundant, and he reaped a plentiful 
 harvest. Hundreds were converted under his ministry, and 
 two large churches grew directly out of the results of his 
 endeavors. He labored to the last, and fell in the midst of the 
 harvest field, and went to his reward with sweat-drops of toil 
 un wiped from his brow.
 
 f . . - ' 
 
 * -4 * 
 
 40 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP "^ 
 
 % 
 
 Many of the more intelligent ministers of the denomination 
 began, along from 1820 to 1830, to take an interest in mis- 
 sions, Sunday 'schools, and temperance and anti-slavery reforms. 
 These latter movements, as might be expected, found their bit- 
 terest opponents in those who affected such zealous anxiety for 
 the undisturbed decrees of God. They were startled from their 
 lethargy only by their hostility to the enci'oachments of these 
 new measures. They became active, not to save souls, and 
 elevate society, but to oppose those who had set themselves to 
 promote " every good word and work. But as they had no 
 conversions, and scarcely any additions to their churches, except 
 as they were recruited by those who left churches where the 
 leaven of Christian effort was beginning to work, they were 
 soon destined to die out from exhaustion. And, as they exer- 
 cised themselves mainly in finding fault with those who " had a 
 mind to work " for God, they made me think of a goose who 
 would sit all summer on a few round stones, hiss off any who 
 might propose to supply her with eggs, and finally get up with- 
 out hatching a gosling. 
 
 Now, I do not think that I am claiming too much when I say, 
 that among the agencies which God has specially honored "in 
 breaking up this apathetic state of the churches, inv bringing^ 
 into the ranks of the ministry men earnest in winning souls, 
 and into the ranks of the laymen men zealous in supporting all 
 our benevolent enterprises, in laboring in Sunday schools, and 
 in working for the conversion of sinners, the early efforts of 
 evangelists, of men specially devoted to holding protracted meet- 
 ings, are to be recognized as preeminent. 
 
 Shortly before I started as an evangelist, the Lord had raised 
 up among the Presbyterians Charles G. Finney and Jedediali 
 Burchard. And God, as we all know, has crowned the labors 
 of these devoted men with marvellous success. They went 
 forth weeping ; but they have already returned rejoicing, bring- 
 ing the sheaves of an abundant harvest with them. In addition 
 to the number of individual souls that have been converted 
 through their labors, who can fully estimate the influence wMch
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 41 
 
 they have exerted in breaking up the set forms, the stereotyped 
 prayers, which once characterized the Presbyterian denomina- 
 tion, and turning it out of the old ruts in which it had been 
 heretofore content to trudge along? 
 
 It was impossible that men of this stamp could invade estab- 
 lished usages, and assail cherished opinions, without encounter- 
 ing opposition and persecution. Men who. preach the same 
 sentiments, and adopt the same measures to-day, find them- * 
 selves borne along on the current of popular sympathy ; but 
 this was not the case then. Besides, talk as we may about the 
 eccentricities of some of these earlier evangelists, it required 
 men of marked individuality of character and unwavering pur- 
 pose, in order to attract public attention, and bear up under the 
 fearful persecutions which every innovation must invariably 
 encounter. 
 
 Among Baptists, at the time when I started out, there was 
 no one man who stood forth as the champion and exemplar of 
 revival measures. I felt that I was entering upon a path that 
 had not been trodden before me. Since then and shortly after- 
 , God raised up others, such as Jabez Swan, A. C. Kings- 
 wis Raymond, men of God, who have done valiant things 
 
 r the truth, and who, amid much obloquy, have toiled on, and 
 until those who survive can to-day rejoice with me in beholding 
 that grand revolution in the sentiments of the Baptist denomi- 
 nation which recognizes the preeminent value of that very 
 agency which we ventured to employ when it cost us many 
 sacrifices and sorrows. 
 
 One source of opposition to revival measures arose from con- 
 scientious misgivings as to the scripturalness of *the system. 
 The hyper-Calvinistic notions which had been instilled into the 
 churches had wrought out a wide-spread misapprehension of the 
 way in which God purposed to fulfil his own promises. The 
 idea that God's people could do anything as a means of pro- 
 moting a revival was scouted as an impiety. The ministers 
 taught that the strength of the church consisted in " lying 
 still ; " that, inasmuch as regeneration was the sovereign work 
 5 
 
 - .. --. 
 *
 
 42 
 
 '* * ^ 
 
 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 of the Holy Spirit, God would in his own good time effectually 
 call those whom he purposed to save, and that the only duty of 
 the church was to wait. If a church proposed to meet, and 
 spend a season in fasting and prayer for the outpouring of 
 God's Spirit, it was said that they were interfering with the 
 divine prerogative ; and the use of any special overtures to 
 induce sinners to repent and give their hearts to God, was 
 denounced as attempts at " man-made conversions." 
 
 It was not understood that God also was waiting to bless 
 his people, and waiting, too, to " be inquired of by the house 
 of Israel to do this thing for them.'' It was not understood 
 that the way in which God would have his people wait upon 
 him, was as the apostles waited at Jerusalem for the descent of 
 the Holy Spirit, with prayer and supplication. Christians 
 seemed to have forgotten that " faith cometh by hearing," and 
 that the apostles besought men to " be reconciled to God," even 
 day and night, and " with tears." Thus the people of God had 
 lost sight of the obligation of every disciple to do all he could 
 to present the gospel to every man, and satisfied themselves with 
 offsetting the untiring activity of the devil and his emissaries 
 to compass the ruin of men, by harping on the inscrutable and 
 unchangeable purposes of God. 
 
 Many thought me crazy when I urged the members of the 
 church to go from house to house, and compel sinners to come 
 in to the services of the sanctuary. The first persons whom I 
 succeeded in starting out in this work, in the city of New York, 
 went forth under the inspiration that this was God's method, 
 and returned at night with their faces beaming with light and 
 love, amaz*ed at their success, and wondering what they had 
 been dreaming all their lifetime before. 
 
 I remember an interesting incident in which a devoted ser- 
 vant of Christ one, too, active and successful in winning souls 
 in spite of his creed was affected at one of my meetings in 
 the city of New York during the year 1835. As I was prepar- 
 ing the way for the inquirers to come forward to be prayed for, 
 brother Duncan Dunbar stepped up to me, and whispered in
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 43 
 
 my ear, " Brother Knapp, it will not do to call sinners to the 
 anxious seats in this city ' the prejudices of the people will not 
 admit of it." I replied, " I am not going to be crowded into 
 the gutters by the prejudices of the people ; I am going straight 
 through, let the consequences be what they may." The invi- 
 tation was then given ; upon which some thirty souls came for- 
 ward, weeping and begging for mercy. Brother Dunbar, seeing 
 this expression, at once arose and seconded the appeal, when 
 several others came forward. 
 
 Although the meetings which I held were crowned with the 
 conversion of many souls, yet there were not a few good people 
 who were afraid that these conversions were not genuine.. It 
 was said that the people were excited into professing religion, 
 without understanding its meaning or feeling its power. For 
 my own part, I never could see why men might properly be- 
 come excited on other subjects, but must invariably approach the 
 momentous question of salvation with all the proprieties of au 
 imperturbable deliberation. It seemed to me that the record 
 of the acts of the apostles is a history of excitements, under 
 which the world was verily turned upside down. 
 
 Others, again, were opposed to sudden conversions. They 
 said the seed must have time to germinate. They forgot that 
 the word of God " was quick and powerful," and overlooked 
 the facts by which God has illustrated the operations of the 
 Holy Spirit. I preferred to- take my examples of God's 
 methods of converting men from his own inspired account," 
 rather than to accept, as a specimen, the fossilized mummies 
 which Antinomianism had embalmed. And in the New Tes- 
 tament records I learned that three thousand persons were 
 " pricked in their hearts" under the preaching of one sermon, 
 and were converted and baptized in one day ; that the eunuch 
 received the truth as soon as it was presented to him, and was 
 baptized at once ; that Paul was stricken down in a moment, 
 and in a moment gave his heart to Jesus, and after three days' 
 delay was remonstrated with for his tardiness in not being 
 immediately baptized ; that the jailer and his household re-
 
 44 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 pented, believed, and were baptized in one night. Believing 
 that God was unchangeable in the laws of his grace, I did not 
 see why similar manifestations of the power of God would not 
 attend similar exercises of faith, prayer, and effort now. I 
 saw nothing in the Bible which led me to believe that it was a 
 part of the plan of God that in our generation men were to rest 
 under silent convictions for six months, or six years, in order to 
 make genuine and thorough their final conversion to Christ. 
 
 It was also very common, in those days, to teach that doubts 
 and fears of being converted were marked proofs of sound 
 piety. If a man spoke of " peace in believing," and was dis- 
 posed to " rejoice with joy unspeakable and full of glory," he 
 was looked upon as spiritually proud, and giving premonitions of a 
 speedy fall. All such expressions were discouraged, and it was 
 thought that the grace of God was specially magnified by doubt- 
 ing the willingness of God to bestow it. As a matter of course, 
 therefore, young people, on coming into the church, felt them- 
 selves under a restraint, and it was no unusual thing for a 
 recent convert to find his remarks or efforts the subject of cau- 
 tionary animadversions from some of the brethren who were 
 reputed for their soundness in the faith. Alas ! in how many 
 instances has the ardor of a young Christian been dampened, 
 and his entire character dwarfed, and his influence deadened, 
 by the croaking of some of these fearful Malaprops, whose only 
 zeal seemed to consist in assuring the converts that " they must 
 not expect to feel so happy or so interested always." In fact, 
 the attitude of the church was that of distrust as to the gen- 
 uineness of anybody's conversion. It seemed to be taken for 
 granted that every applicant at the doors of the church must 
 be either a hypocrite or the victim of self-delusion ; and the 
 main business of these wiseacres, these men who assumed to 
 steady the ark of God, was to keep them out until one's piety 
 could be demonstrated by its ability to survive all their refusals 
 to encourage it. In this way were the lambs of the flock cared 
 for, and this was the kind of nurture by which it was proposed 
 to " feed the church of God."
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 45 
 
 Another class opposed me from feelings of jealousy. As my 
 success increased, their hostility to my work gathered strength. 
 Their own want of pulpit power, the absence of conversions 
 under their preaching, made them envious of the blessings that 
 rested on the labors of others, and they sought vent for their 
 vexation by calling in question the reality and permanency of 
 results in which they could claim no share. They feared that 
 a powerful presentation of the truth, and a large increase of 
 members as a consequence, would beget a distaste for their own 
 ministry, and they loved themselves, their ease, their pride, 
 more than the salvation of souls. 
 
 Others opposed my ministry because they disliked my peculiar 
 methods of presenting the gospel. They thought the better way 
 was to give no offence to any man, but to study to please all. 
 The prejudices, the errors, the vices of men must not be assailed. 
 It was better to charm with smooth words and fair speeches, to 
 keep the more offensive truths of the Bible out of sight, to say 
 but little about total depravity and hell torments, and not to 
 make too free a use of the name of the devil, lest his Satanic 
 majesty might be displeased, and get up a persecution. 
 
 I do not pass judgment on the sincerity or piety of many who 
 would have preferred to pursue a more man-pleasing policy. I 
 can only say that God had cast me in a different mould, and I 
 felt that he had called me to do a work which men of that 
 plastic type would not be adapted to perform. Besides, I re- 
 garded the tendency of the doctrine of expediency as dangerous, 
 and subversive of the great truths of the gospel. Whenever 
 Christianity shall become palatable to the tastes of unregenerate 
 men, the " offence of the cross " will have ceased. The triumphs 
 of the cross are not to be achieved by getting on the right side 
 of men, but by keeping on the right side of God. Christianity 
 is not a doll, that is to be dressed up in fine clothing, with silv.er 
 slippers and gold rings, but is a stern and uncompromising 
 assailant of all forms of worldliness, and gaining the good will 
 of men only as it subdues them to the power of godliness. The 
 gospel can never adapt itself to the preferences of sinful men.
 
 46 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 Conquests for Christianity, on this principle, are practical sur- 
 renders of its principles to those it undertakes to oppose. This 
 is essentially the policy of Romanism, which, in seeking to con- 
 vert pagans to Christianity, transferred the rites of paganism to 
 the services of the church, and thus converted Christians into 
 pagans. 
 
 For my own part, I felt that, if I sought to please men, I 
 should not be a servant of Christ. I thought it was as true to- 
 day as of old, that " he who would live godly in Christ Jesus 
 muat suffer persecution." I continually hBard a voice ringing 
 in my ears, u Woe unto you when all men speak well of you." 
 Under these convictions, I felt constrained to call things by their 
 right names, to use most simple language, the most direct argu- 
 ments, and most matter-of-fact illustrations. I went forth, 
 therefore, placing no reliance upon literary pretensions, beau- 
 tiful sermons, fine meeting-houses, large organs, and splendid 
 choirs, but trusting in the willingness of the Holy Spirit to 
 make effectual the simple, plain, and straightforward presenta- 
 tion to the understandings and consciences of men of his own 
 revealed truths. 
 
 Such were some of the difficulties with which I was called to 
 contend in entering upon the work of an evangelist. I was not 
 surprised, nor disappointed, nor discouraged, as they continued 
 to present themselves in my path. My early discipline prepared 
 me to bear up under trials, and had taught me that it was " bet- 
 ter to trust in the Lord than to put confidence in princes." I 
 had nothing to hope, and nothing to fear, from man. All 
 expectations or desires for honors from men were crucified ; and 
 I constantly prayed that I might not be left to the influence 
 of such considerations. I took counsel of no man, but daily 
 sought God as the guide of my ways. My labors, though 
 ignored by the religious press for many years, resulted in the 
 conversion of more during a given number of years than all the 
 conversions reported by our missionaries in the home field. 
 
 In addition to the consolation of knowing that my labors for 
 souls were not in vain, I had the satisfaction of receiving the
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. '47 
 
 cooperation aad confidence of the ministers and churches with 
 whom I held meetings, and, as a general thing, they became 
 my fast friends. In this way, as I went over the country, 
 public opinion was gradually changed. I shall carry to my 
 grave the remembrance of very many warm-hearted brethren, 
 who laid themselves on the altar with me, and wept, and prayed, 
 and toiled for the conversion of the world. Many of these are 
 now in heaven. Nor were those who gave me their counte- 
 nance men of our own denomination only ; but among others 
 there were not a few who said, "It is the work of the Lord." 
 Among these I may make special mention of the Episcopal 
 bishop in Maryland, Dr. Taylor of Yale College, and Dr. Nott 
 of Union College. Dr. Nott was an enthusiastic friend. His 
 whole moral nature was moved by the power and simplicity 
 of the truth. 
 
 In the mean time, as I continued to labor, other ministers 
 caught the spirit of evangelism. Pastors began to preach with 
 more power, and sought to do all they could for the salvation 
 of their people ; and God, who is faithful to his promises, gave 
 them marked success. Many of them went forth from their 
 own immediate fields to assist neighboring pastors, and adopted 
 the measures which had proved so successful with evangelists. 
 Thus the work extended all through the United States. Con- 
 verts were multiplied by tens of thousands ; while those churches 
 which did not sympathize with these new measures died out, 
 and those ministers who opposed the progress of evangelical 
 effort are forgotten, or are remembered only as men who mis- 
 interpreted the signs of the times. 
 
 And at the present day, I am permitted, as I look over the 
 increased ranks of the Baptist ministry, to recognize scores and 
 hundreds of honored and successful laborers in the vineyard 
 who were converted in protracted meetings ; and to count by 
 thousands, laymen, now active, benevolent, and laborious in 
 every good word and work, who were brought to Christ in 
 connection with special efforts and revival measures.
 
 48 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 CHAPTER V. 
 
 ACCOUNTS OF PROTRACTED MEETINGS. 
 
 (1832-4.) 
 
 Union Meetings. Why discontinued. Duty of Baptists. Blessed 
 Meetings. An Answer to Prayer. Departed Worthies. NORTH 
 RUTLAND : " The Bower of Prayer." Deacon Woodward and the 
 Young Men. TURIN : Universalism. A Universalist Mother. 
 Threatened Suit. Mr. P. CONSTABLEVILLE : Barn and Pork- 
 House. Colonel M. A Drunkard's Wife. A Vision. 
 
 DURING the period between the years 1832 and 1834, I 
 held meetings in all the principal towns in the Counties of 
 Jefferson, Lewis, and Oswego, and in many towns in Cayuga 
 County. Throughout these two years I usually called in the 
 aid of all evangelical denominations, namely, the Baptist, 
 Methodist, Presbyterian, and Congregational. All labored to- 
 gether, and I was content to leave the division of the spoils 
 with the pastors and churches after I had gone. But I found 
 this method fraught with serious evils. 
 
 In the first place, the different churches were almost always 
 sure to quarrel about their respective share of the converts. 
 The churches, in these small country villages, were generally 
 more or less feeble ; and each felt that its very existence 
 depended on these accessions. This contention would stop the 
 revival, the wicked would triumph, and devils hold a jubilee 
 in hell. 
 
 In the second place, my conscience was not at ease. I was 
 commissioned to go and " teach all nations, baptizing them in the 
 name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit." I 
 asked myself, " How can I give a good account of my steward- 
 ship, if I do not fully carry out my commission ? "
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 49 
 
 I loved all God's children ; I delighted to labor with them. 
 Everything calculated to divide or interrupt our union was 
 painful to my feelings, and for a long time my mind was un- 
 settled. I thought much on the subject, and prayed for wisdom 
 from above. At length the subject came up before me in this 
 form : " Suppose I should die to-night, and at the judgment 
 Jesus should call me to him and say, ' My servant, Jacob, have 
 you carried out your commission, preached my gospel, discipled 
 and baptized ? ' I should be compelled to reply, ' I have preached 
 thy blessed gospel as faithfully as I knew how ; have made 
 many disciples ; sometimes I have baptized, and sometimes I 
 have not.' ' Why did you sometimes not baptize ? ' I imagined 
 my Savior to ask ; and I supposed myself obliged to say, ' Well, 
 Master, my Pedo-Baptist brethren had adopted the recent 
 custom of sprinkling, and I could not carry out thy commission 
 without giving offence.' " I concluded that it were better for 
 me to go to the stake, than be under the necessity of meeting 
 my Lord and Savior with a lame reply like this. What if Jesus 
 should answer me, " He that loveth father and mother, husband 
 and wife, more than me, is not worthy of me " ! 
 
 I therefore made up my mind to carry out my commission 
 regardless of all consequences ; nor do I love my Pedo-Baptist 
 brethren any the less, nor do I value Christian union any the 
 less. ^But I have become convinced that the true way in which 
 to bring about Christian union, to incorporate all Christians in 
 one body, is to do away with all the errors which now divide 
 them ; and when we have one faith, then we can have one 
 church, one baptism, and one communion. All attempts to 
 bring antagonistic elements together have been, and must ever 
 be, abortive. " How can two walk together, except they be 
 agreed ? " In the meantime we should harbor no sectarian feel- 
 ings, no prejudice against those of other names, see to it that 
 no selfishness mingles in our devotions, appreciate all that is 
 good in those who differ from us, and, as far as we can, work 
 together for the conversion of the world. 
 
 And I think that if all Baptists would carry out the commis-
 
 50 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 eion in the right spirit, and turn not to the right or to the IcfV 
 in all revivals, and on all occasions ; baptize converts as fast as 
 they believe ; never cringe, never exult, and be a little more 
 patient, all the children of God would soon be led to see their 
 errors ; abandon infant baptism, and adopt immersion ; then 
 we are all substantially one. Other minor differences might 
 exist for a while, but in process of time they would vanish 
 away, and the great end, for which so many pious hearts are 
 yearning and praying, would be reached. 
 
 Although during this period I baptized comparatively few of 
 those who were converted under my preaching, yet I baptized 
 over eight hundred ; being about the same number as was re- 
 ported to have been baptized by all the Baptist missionaries of 
 the home field within the same length of time. Notwithstand- 
 ing this success, my work was looked upon with suspicion, and 
 scarcely alluded to in the public prints. I was forty years 
 ahead of the times. 
 
 I have never witnessed, before nor since, such exhibitions of 
 divine power, such earnest holding on in prayer. Not unfre- 
 quently the people of God would continue till the break of day 
 in supplication for the outpouring of the Spirit, or the conversion 
 of particular persons. There were many remarkable instances 
 of answers to prayer. The ministers, and many of the leading 
 members, seemed to be filled with the Spirit of God ; and in 
 many instances, when brethren knelt around a convicted sin- 
 ner, they would not rise until his soul had been set at liberty, 
 and was rejoicing " in hope of the glory of God." 
 
 I remember one occasion in which a company of sisters re- 
 paired to a grove to pray. Three hardened young men followed 
 them with the intention of disturbing their devotions ; but as 
 they drew near to the spot, the one in advance fell to the 
 ground, then the next, and then the next. A company of 
 brethren, apprehending trouble, had followed them, and came 
 upon them as they lay prostrate and helpless. They lifted them 
 up, and took them back to the anxious meeting, where they 
 continued in great agony of soul, until they were converted to
 
 ELDER JACOB KXAPP. 51 
 
 God. One of them tried hard to resist the strivings of the 
 Spirit, but at length, crying out, " O, my knees ! must you bow 
 for the first time? " knelt in prayer, and made a complete sur- 
 render to the sceptre of Christ. I ought to have mentioned, 
 when these sisters saw these young men coming, they cried" out 
 mightily to God that he would smite them to the earth with his 
 convicting power. Their prayers were answered. This oc- 
 currence took place in Orleans, Jefferson County, N. Y., in 1832. 
 
 At the close of this meeting I baptized sixty persons in thirty 
 minutes. 
 
 By this time (1867), all the ministers, and many of the 
 brethren, who labored with me in those days, are dead. Among 
 them I may mention Elders Little, Warner, Clarke, Free- 
 man, Cooke, Waters, Wedge, and Horr. Some of them prayed 
 and toiled themselves to death. They died on the field of bat- 
 tle, with their armor on. How strange it seems that I am 
 permitted to outlive them all, when I was expecting to be 
 among the first to cross over Jordan, as I did more of the 
 preaching, and performed the hardest part of the labor ! 
 
 NORTH RUTLAND. 
 
 Strictly speaking, an account of the meeting held in North 
 Rutland, Jefferson County, does not belong to a summary of my 
 labors as a formal Evangelist. " A meeting of days " was held, 
 in 1832, with the Baptist church in this place, then under the 
 pastoral care of Elder Little. Several neighboring ministers 
 had been invited to attend, and preach by turns. I was among 
 the number. 
 
 The spirit of the meeting was very precious ; and I, especial- 
 ly, have reason to remember it, because the impressions made 
 on my mind while here, went very far towards bringing me to 
 a decision to devote myself henceforth to the work of an Evan- 
 gelist. At that time, I was in a great conflict between inclina- 
 tion and conviction. I was feeling that God was calling me to 
 go forth into the field, } ut the sacrifices appeared too great. I
 
 52 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 could not bring myself to consent to leave the endearments of 
 home and depend for support on the precarious contributions of 
 the churches with which I might be called to labor. 
 
 While being agitated with these reflections, I went to one of 
 these meetings, and heard, for the first time, the brethren and 
 sisters sing the hymn called " The Bower of Prayer." As I 
 listened to the sweet fulness of this hymn, the tears fell thick 
 and fast down my cheeks. I requested them to sing it a second 
 time, and my tears continued to flow. One verse in particular 
 seemed so appropriate to my case, and awakened so many recol- 
 lections of my struggles, that I was completely melted into ten- 
 derness, and at the same time was exalted into the ecstasy of a 
 precious and entire acquiescence in the will of God. 
 
 " To leave my dear friends, and with neighbors to part. 
 And go from my home, it affects not my heart 
 Like the thought of absenting myself for a day 
 From that blest retreat where I've chosen to pray." 
 
 At the end of the first week the pastors returned to their 
 homes ; and as yet there had been no special work among the 
 unconverted. The brethren of the church were unwillin- to 
 
 O 
 
 have the meetings close without more marked results, and they 
 continued to " wait on the Lord." In the course of the week 
 following I returned to Rutland, and found a work of grace in 
 the church and community of marvellous power. 
 
 During this meeting one incident occurred, so remarkable, 
 that I would scarcely venture to relate it if I did not know it 
 to be true. Deacon Spencer Woodward, of Bellville, a man 
 of strong faith, and " full of the Holy Spirit," fell in with a 
 company of hardened scoffers, as they were standing on the 
 village " green," mocking the saints of the Most High. One 
 of them had a cane, the head of which consisted of a piece of 
 deer's horn : and as the deacon was passing, in order to cast 
 derision on the services of religion, he was asking his young 
 companions, to whom he was extending his cane, to come for- 
 ward and lay hold on " the horns of the altar." 
 
 Father Woodward stopped, and turning to them, remarked,
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 53 
 
 " Young men, if you knew what you were about, I should think 
 your damnation sealed, and should not think it worth while to 
 waste my breath on your account ; but you are ignorant of the 
 things of the kingdom of God. On this evening you will be 
 made to see the power of the Almighty." 
 
 He induced them to enter the meeting-house, though it was 
 some time before sundown and there was no service as yet, and, 
 leading them into a pew, and shutting the door (it was an old- 
 fashioned pew with a straight back and a high door), told them 
 that nobody would disturb them. " Now," said he, " brace your- 
 selves, for God is about to come down in great power." Pie then 
 knelt in prayer in the aisle at the pew door. He got hold truly 
 of " the horns of the altar," and the " Holy One came down from 
 Teram." The young men trembled like Belshazzar when he 
 saw the hand writing on the wall. Some of them got down on 
 the floor, and their knees knocked against each other and against 
 the sides of the pew. Soon one of them sank down to the floor 
 utterly helpless. One of his companions reached over and 
 whispered to father Woodward, " Uncle Spencer, Jim is a dy- 
 ing." " Get some water," said father W., " and fetch him to ; 
 don't let him die." One of them ran for water, but his hands 
 trembled so that he spilt half of it out of the pail before he 
 reached the prostrate man. The deacon told them to lift him 
 up, adding, " I told you that God was coming down ; now prepare 
 to meet him." Two of the stoutest of the young men took hold 
 of him, but they could not lift him ; their strength failed them. 
 The deacon raised the young man up, his consciousness soon 
 returned, and very shortly afterwards he was converted. 
 
 Some of the others, also, were led by this event to seek and 
 find salvation. One of them, however, by the name of Coburn, 
 was smitten down during the meeting that evening, and carried 
 to Elder Little's house, where he remained till midnight, insen- 
 sible. When he had sufficiently recovered his strength, he went 
 home, swearing that he would not submit to God, even though 
 he was sent to "hell" before morning. About a year after this 
 he was found among the scoffers, during a meeting of days that
 
 54 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 was being held iu the same town. Again he was stricken to 
 the floor by the hand of God, while sitting in a prayer-meeting, 
 and again he resisted the Spirit. Some time in the course of 
 the following year I received information that this hardened 
 young man was smitten down the third time, and in this 
 instance was smitten by the hand of death. He was " driven 
 away in his wickedness " a fearful example of the possibility 
 and danger of striving against God. 
 
 TURIN. 
 
 In the course of these two years, 1832-1834, 1 was called, in 
 the providence of God, to attend a meeting of days in Turin, 
 Lewis County, N. Y. At that time there was no church of 
 any denomination in the village. The town was called " Satan's 
 seat." The people had built one meeting-house, which was free 
 for anybody to preach in, whether they preached truth or error. 
 
 A number of Christian people of different names combined 
 together to get up a meeting, and then extended to me an invi- 
 tation to preach. When I arrived I found a number of minis- 
 ters of the gospel of different names there, praying together, 
 and ready to lend a helping hand for the conversion of the place. 
 Most of the men of business were infidel or Uuiversalist in sen- 
 timent. I commenced preaching day and night, and opened 
 prayer-meetings in different places. The people came in. The 
 Spirit began to manifest his power, and sinners were converted. 
 
 But opposition soon began to arise and develop itself more 
 and more. When speaking on the tendency or effects of Uni- 
 versalism one evening, I related the following fact which took 
 place in that village : 
 
 A boy, whose mother was a Universalist, stepped into a store 
 one day, in the absence of the merchant, and took from the 
 drawer all the money it contained. As he was going out at the 
 front door, the merchant was coming in at the back door, and 
 recognized him. The merchant, knowing him to be a bad boy, 
 followed and caught him, and accused him of having stolen 
 money from his drawer. The boy denied the charge, calling
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 55 
 
 on God to witness his innocence ; but the money was found in 
 his pocket. The merchant asked him what he thought would 
 become of him if he continued to steal, and lie, and call on the 
 name of God. The boy looked him impudently in the face, and 
 replied, " I don't care if I do lie and steal ; there is no hell ; 
 mother tells me so." The Universalists did not fancy such a 
 naked, unvarnished application of the tendency of their doctrines. 
 So they stirred up the wicked, set the town in an uproar, and 
 got out a summons for me, with the intention of breaking up the 
 meeting and of being revenged on me. Squire P. agreed to 
 carry on the suit free of charge ; others subscribed five dollars 
 each to meet expenses, and it was reported through the town 
 that " Kuapp had lied ; had slandered a poor widow, and was 
 going to be prosecuted." 
 
 I called a council of war, and after praying over it and con- 
 sulting together, we unanimously resolved to go on, regardless 
 of what any one might say or do, and trust events in the hands 
 of God. I was then young, and had had but little experience in 
 such matters. I entered the pulpit, told the brethren that pos- 
 sibly the sheriff might call for me before I had finished my dis- 
 course, and that if he did I should go to jail, and I wished them 
 to go on with the meeting ; and that, if I could get bail on the 
 limits, I would open a protracted meeting there, and we would 
 kindle a fire on both sides of the devil, and burn him out. 
 These remarks aroused the brethren, and seemed to carry them 
 back to the days of the apostles, and they cried unto God 
 mightily. 
 
 But no sheriff" appeared. On that afternoon, however, I 
 received a note from my persecutors, stating that if I would 
 make a handsome apology they would pass the matter over ; if 
 not, that the suit should go on ; and that they would all come 
 out that evening to the meeting in order to hear my apology. 
 That night the house was crowded to its utmost capacity. All 
 were excited to the highest pitch ; some were praying and look- 
 ing beyond all creature aid ; some were cursing, and some were 
 smitten in their hearts. I think my text for that evening was,
 
 56 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 *' And thou mourn at the last, when thy flesh and thy body are 
 consumed, and say, How have I hated instruction, and my heart 
 despised reproof" (Prov. v. 11, 12) ; and if I ever felt that I 
 stood between the living and the dead, I felt so that night. 
 The solemnities of the eternal world gathered around us, and 
 settled on the whole congregation ; some sank .down in their 
 seats, helpless, before I had finished my sermon. Not a dog 
 moved his tongue. We spent a season in prayer, and several 
 were converted on the spot ; others were unable to get home 
 without assistance. Colonel F., a dry goods merchant, could not 
 stand on his feet ; several of the brethren helped him to his 
 house, and staid with him aH night. He was brought into light 
 and liberty before morning. Strange to say, his wife contin- 
 ued hardened, and was heard to say, repeatedly, that she would 
 rather that her husband lose all his property than to have lived 
 to become a Christian. If I am not mistaken, she was, not- 
 withstanding, brought to give her heart to Christ some time 
 afterwards. 
 
 From that hour the work rolled on until the most of the vil- 
 lage was converted to God. The lawyer who offered to carry 
 on the suit was among the converts. A Dr. D. and wife 
 were converted. A wealthy man by the name of P., a con- 
 firmed Universalist, who had subscribed five dollars towards 
 the suit, and who laid his hand on the Bible, and swore that he 
 would cowhide any man who should darken his door to talk 
 with him or his family on the subject of religion, was made a 
 signal trophy of redeeming grace. His family likewise shared 
 in the blessing. He stated before a large congregation, that 
 when he was a tlniversalist he was angry with God because he 
 would not let him live in this world forever. He said he knew 
 God might if he would, but now he could rejoice in the hope 
 of a better life beyond the grave ; and he added, " Should it 
 please God to call me from this stand, I could go rejoicing, 
 without even returning to take leave of my dear wife and 
 children." 
 
 The victory of the people of God in this place was complete.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 57 
 
 The devil was vanquished. Error was driven like chaff before 
 a mighty wind ; and I learned, from experience, that it was 
 " better to trust in the Lord than to put confidence in princes." 
 
 CONST ABLE VILLE . 
 
 Shortly after this meeting, I held another in Constableville, 
 in the same county. This is a beautiful village, nestling among 
 the mountains, in a fertile valley. The only house of worship 
 in this place, at that time, was an Episcopal church ; but into 
 this, of course, I could gain no admittance. But the Christian 
 friends in the community turned out, and fitted up a large, 
 newly-built barn, and built a bower on each side, so that two 
 thousand people could be accommodated. Here we conducted 
 an anxiods-meeting, separate from the congregation which was 
 listening to the preaching. As fast as one was brought under 
 the influence of the Holy Spirit, and could be induced to go, 
 he was led to the inquiry-meeting. The ungodly called it " the 
 finishing-off-room." 
 
 "While we were in waiit of such a room, Colonel Miller, a 
 wealthy gentleman, offered the use of his old store, which he 
 was then occupying for the purpose of packing pork. It was 
 thankfully accepted ; and he politely sent his hired man to 
 assist in cleaning and fitting it up. Though a perfect gentle- 
 man, he would sometimes indulge in a sly joke with his friends, 
 in a pleasant way, about the ministers taking the anxious to his 
 " pork-shop " in order to get them converted. But it pleased 
 God to touch his heart, and that of his noble wife. They were 
 brought into great distress. They continued to attend the meet- 
 ings at the barn ; came forward, and rose, and asked for prayers. 
 I, with one or two others, went to their house, and spent the 
 whole night with them in reading the Scriptures and prayer ; 
 but no relief could they obtain. Others were being converted, 
 and they began to deem themselves forsaken of God. 
 
 One afternoon, as I was about to preach, he arose, and 
 begged prayers for himself and wife, and stated that they were 
 6
 
 58 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 nearly in despair. The suggestion was made, that perhaps he 
 had set up his will against going to the pork-room ; if so, that 
 room lay between him and the kingdom of God. He saw the 
 force of the remark, and turning to his wife, said, "If you are 
 willing to go down to the pork-room, I will go with you. It is 
 a bitter pill, but we may as well die in one way as another ; we 
 cannot live so." She took him by the arm, and they walked 
 down to the pork-room, bowed in prayer, and both, there and 
 then, found peace, and returned to their home rejoicing. "We 
 had in this meeting a blessed time. Very many souls were con- 
 verted ; I cannot say how many. 
 
 I remember the case of a poor woman, the daughter of a silk- 
 merchant in India, who had married against her parents' wishes. 
 Her husband had become a drunkard, and removed to this 
 country. Here he became a sot, neglected his family, spent all 
 his earnings in strong drink, and left his \tffe and children to 
 shift for themselves. She came six miles to -attend the meet- 
 ing, with a babe in her arms, leaving the other children at home 
 with only potatoes and salt to eat. She felt that all of her pros- 
 pects for this life were blighted, and that there was the more 
 reason why she should have a good hope for the next. She 
 soon found Jesus precious to her soul, and went home with a 
 light heart, rejoicing in the love of God. 
 
 Another circumstance occurred in this meeting, which I will 
 relate, leaving the reader to make his own comments. There 
 was, in an obscure part of the town, a pious woman in lowly 
 circumstances, who had been longing for the consolation of 
 Israel, and praying for the outpouring of the Spirit. In the 
 visions of the night, she saw two men come into the town, and 
 with long poles stir up the pond, which lay on the outskirts of 
 the place, until the water became quite muddy ; that then a 
 wind arose, and swept, with mighty power, over it, driving off 
 all the disturbed sediment which had been brought to the sur- 
 face ; then the face of the water became pure and calm. When, 
 this meeting commenced, she saw two men whom she distinctly
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 69 
 
 recognized as those whom she had beheld in her dream. And 
 when she perceived that they were engaging in the work of the 
 Lord, she interpreted her vision as a prediction of a visitation 
 from God, which would stir up the depths of wickedness in the 
 place, and purify and bless it with the winds of his gracious and 
 resistless love.
 
 60 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 CHAPTER VI. 
 
 ACCOUNTS OF PROTRACTED MEETINGS. 
 (1832-4.) 
 
 RUTLAND HILL : Holding on. Great Results. An alarmed Pro- 
 fessor. A good Conscience. " Old Fogies." A new Church. 
 LORAINE : Suspension of Business. Three Meeting-Houses. A 
 Mother's Command. HANNIBAL CENTRE : A cold Beginning. 
 Universalist Reporters. A drunken Apostate. OSWEGO : Peter S. 
 Smith. Power of Earnestness. A real Religion. Restitution. 
 
 RUTLAND HILL. 
 
 ABOUT this time I attended a meeting at Rutland Hill, Jeffer- 
 son County, preaching in the Congregational church. I 
 labored ten days, 'and was blessed with only five converts. The 
 place was overrun with infidelity and Universalism. In the even- 
 ings all turned out and filled the house. Many were somewhat 
 affected, but they did not break down. In those days, ten days 
 were thought to be a long time in which to protract religious 
 services. Three days' meetings were considered all that could 
 be profitably sustained. 
 
 During these ten days we had all worked very hard, and were 
 greatly worn down. We had not husbanded our strength. I 
 had preached three times every day ; and the brethren prayed 
 as long and as loud as they could, and some half dozen of them 
 had kept it up day and night. We were all either hoarse or 
 suffering from sore throats. 
 
 We took counsel of ourselves and of God, as to what course 
 to pursue. We remembered the promise, " In due time we 
 shall reap if we faint not." So we concluded to take God at 
 his word, and " go forward." I went to the pulpit, and the
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 61 
 
 helpers went to the anxious-room. About twenty inquirers 
 were present. They induced them all to kneel down ; one of 
 the inquirers summoned courage to open his mouth in prayer. 
 He was at once set at liberty, and broke forth into earnest 
 prayer for the salvation of others ; these, in turn, went to pray- 
 ing for themselves, and as " God turned their captivity," they, 
 too, prayed for their friends, until the whole twenty were brought 
 to rejoice in the Savior. 
 
 After I had concluded the preaching service, many of the 
 unconverted, attracted by the voice of prayer, went into the 
 anxious-room. Several of them fell on their knees, and cried 
 aloud for mercy. The converts began to plead with the anxious 
 until until all in the room were led to surrender their hearts to 
 Christ. The brethren could only " stand still and see the salva- 
 tion of God." The good work went on with increasing power, 
 much as on the day of Pentecost. Infidelity turned pale, and 
 Universalism gave up the ghost. It was a time of deep heart- 
 searching among Christians. 
 
 One lady, a member in good standing in the Congregational 
 church, came to me, and said she thought she was not a Chris- 
 tian, and wanted to know what she should " do to be saved." 
 I told her to go to God and cry for help. She went to her 
 chamber, in the same house in which I was boarding, and, fall- 
 ing on her knees, continued in prayer for the space of two 
 hours, when a sister came to me, and expressed her fears that 
 the lady was dying, and asked me to go up to her room, and see 
 what could be done. I found her still in a pleading posture, 
 agony depicted on her face, and her eyes turned towards heaven. 
 She could scarcely speak above a whisper. At first I was 
 alarmed, fearing that she might die, and that her death would 
 be attributed to me. I was on the point of requesting her to 
 cease her supplications ; but this text broke upon my ears as in 
 peals of thunder, " The bruised reed he will not break, and the 
 smoking flax he will not quench, till he send forth judgment 
 unto victory." 
 
 I then said, " God will not break the bruised reed, and God
 
 62 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 forbid that I should quench the smoking flax ; let judgment 
 come forth unto victory." In a few moments her countenance 
 changed, a heavenly smile came over her whole face, and she 
 began to whisper, " Blessed Savior ! sweet Jesus ! all is well ! 
 all is well ! " From that day, to the last of my knowledge of 
 her, she testified her conviction that never till then had she seen 
 the preciousness of Christ as her atoning Savior. 
 
 Soon afterwards, while standing by the water where I was 
 baptizing, she began to tremble and weep, and turning to a 
 sister, said, *' This ordinance never appeared so beautiful to me 
 as now. O that I could be buried with Christ in baptism ! " 
 Being informed of her remark, I replied, that " her wish can be 
 gratified now, if she desires ; " and one of the sisters putting 
 on a robe that had been already used, I led her down into the 
 water, and she was baptized straightway, and she went on her 
 " way rejoicing." 
 
 The Congregational brethren in this place were " old fogies." 
 They would invite neither Finney nor Burchard to labor with 
 them : nor did they get reconverted during this meeting. They 
 did not believe in young converts speaking or praying, for fear 
 they might become proud. They thought the more doubts a 
 person cherished, the better evidence he gave of being a Chris- 
 tian. I left all the converts to go where they pleased. But 
 they had no encouragement to work in this church. The " old 
 fogies " went poking along like an old lazy yoke of oxen, keep- 
 ing a little ahead of the converts, and hooking them back lest 
 they should go too fast. 
 
 Finally, most of the converts went down to South Rutland 
 (called Tylerville), and commenced a meeting by themselves. 
 At their request, I went to their help, and began to blow the 
 gospel trumpet. I found an old Baptist church there, with 
 scarcely " a name to live." We got the old brands together, 
 and besought God to kindle them once more with the fire of 
 his Spirit. I commenced baptizing the converts (about one 
 hundred), and soon went to another field. As I was leaving 
 them, I urged them to continue the work. The revival kept on
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. Od 
 
 for nearly six mouths, and a great number professed faith in 
 Christ. 
 
 There was a physician in the place, who stood out against all 
 the means of grace, and became so uneasy and unhappy, that 
 he sold out his property, at a great sacrifice, and went to Cana- 
 da. He said that " he could not go to his barn, but some one 
 Avas praying in the hay-mow ; he could not go to the woods, 
 but some one was praying behind every brush-heap ; that the 
 women pestered his life out of him, tormenting him Avith their 
 religion, so that he would rather live in purgatory." Well may 
 Ave ask, "How could the wicked be happy in heaven?" 
 " Verily, ye must be born again." 
 
 LORAINE. 
 
 In the autumn of 1833, I was invited to labor in Loraine, 
 Jefferson County, N. Y. On my arrival, I called together the 
 three churches of the place, namely, Baptist, Presbyterian, and 
 Methodist, and told them that, in view of other pressing calls, I 
 could not remain in the place long, and would not remain at 
 all, unless they would agree to lay all their business aside, and 
 attend day and night, and work for God as they would work for 
 themselves in harvest time. The response to my appeal was 
 quite cordial and unanimous. " The people had a mind to 
 Avork." They suspended all business, and waited on the Lord 
 in his courts. We had meetings three times a day morning, 
 noon, and night. On some occasions we continued all night, 
 the lamps not being put out till daylight. While some left for 
 a time, others came in, and in this way a steady stream of 
 prayer was kept up all night long. 
 
 Farmers took their teams through their respective neighbor- 
 hoods, and brought all to meeting who wished to come. Days 
 of fasting and prayer were observed, and great searching of 
 heart Avas instituted. Some gave up their former hopes, and 
 sought Christ aneAV. When one meeting-house was filled, 
 another was opened, until all three were thronged Avith eager 
 congregations. In many instances, the saints resorted to the
 
 64 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 groves, and to private houses, to pray, in order that they might 
 make room for sinners, who came " like doves to their windows" 
 to hear the preached word. One meeting-house would be filled 
 with the unconverted to hear preaching ? another would be 
 crowded with praying saints ; and a third would be thronged 
 with inquirers, for whose benefit an inquiry-meeting was con- 
 ducted every day by Deacon Tenman, of the Congregational 
 church, and brother Horr, a licentiate. Both these brethren 
 accompanied me for several years after this, praying and con- 
 ducting meetings for inquiry. These men were filled with 
 faith and the Holy Spirit, and were " helpers " in the Bible 
 sense of the word. It was difficult to tell in which of these 
 meetings there was the greatest interest, for the presence and 
 power of God were manifested in them all. 
 
 There were numerous displays of God's marvellous grace 
 during this meeting. 
 
 A widow lady, living in the village of Adams, six miles off", 
 had a son fourteen years old, who was serving an apprenticeship 
 at French Creek. While on a visit to his home he heard of 
 our meetings, and of his sister's conversion there. His mother 
 desired him to go over to Loraine ; he replied, " Mother, I did 
 not come home to go to meeting ; I came to visit you, and 
 must soon return to my employer." She told him that his 
 trade would do him but little good, if he should lose his soul. 
 She finally commanded him to go, urging him to make himself 
 known to Elder Knapp or Deacon Tenman. God prepared 
 his heart as he journeyed on the way ; and reaching the steps of 
 the church, he stood by the door, weeping. At that moment the 
 deacon was passing by, and noticed him. Putting his hand 
 very kindly on the shoulder of the lad, he asked him what was 
 the matter. He told his errand, and the deacon, taking him by 
 the hand, led him .into the inquiry -room, and asked all to pray 
 for him. 
 
 After an affecting season had been spent in prayer, the lad 
 rose up, and going to the deacon, told him that he wanted to go 
 home. " What," said the deacon, " are you tired of the meet-
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 65 
 
 ing so soon?" " No, sir," he replied, " but I must see my 
 mother ; I will come back again." He hastened home with a 
 light heart, and rushing into the house, he fell on his mother's 
 neck, and kissing her, exclaimed, " O, my dear mother, I thank 
 you a thousand times, that you compelled me to attend that 
 meeting ! I have found the blessed Savior, and all my sins are 
 forgiven me." This mother was like unto "Abraham, who 
 commanded his house after him." 
 
 HANNIBAL CENTRE. 
 
 During this same year, I held a meeting in Hannibal Centre, 
 Oswego County, N. Y. On entering the Baptist meeting-house, 
 I found the building cold ; the wood that had been brought in 
 was covered with snow, and would not^burn. The congregation 
 was small, and their hearts as cold as the weather. A brother 
 some time afterwards reminded me (though I had forgotten it), 
 that after a few of them had prayed as well as they could, I 
 rose up and remarked, that " such prayers as these will freeze 
 us all to death." 
 
 But we held on to the promises, and the blessing came. The 
 people soon began to flock to hear the word, and the house was 
 filled. I pitched into Universalism as usual. And after all 
 supposed I had exhausted my thoughts and my vocabulary, I 
 announced that on a given night I should preach another sermon 
 on Universalism. Two of the leading members of that sect 
 came in to take notes for their newspaper. The power of God 
 confounded his enemies, and vindicated the truth. Both of 
 these reporters were converted. Elder Woodin was the pastor 
 of this church. 
 
 A man by the name of K., with whom I had boarded in 
 Springfield before my marriage, was then living some eight miles 
 from this place. He had given way to the use of strong drink ; 
 his property was squandered, his family were reduced to want, 
 his wife was dead, and he was excluded from the church. I 
 had not seen them for years ; and now that I was so near to 
 them, it seemed to me that the departed spirit of sister K. was
 
 66 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 continually saying to me, " Look after my poor motherless 
 children." This impression became so strong, that I induced 
 Captain Bullen, an excellent brother, with whom I was board- 
 ing, to send a sleigh after them, and bring them to me. 
 
 While brother Luther Myrick was preaching, a daughter of 
 sister K. came into the church. Though she had grown up, 
 and was then married, I knew her in a moment, and began to 
 plead with God for her soul. After the sermon was finished, 
 and the anxious were invited forward, she rose up at once, and 
 was converted before she left the house. 
 
 The son I did not see, but I sent for the father. I brought 
 all my power to bear on him to persuade him to reform. I 
 reminded him of his former respectable standing ; of his loving 
 companion, whose heart he had broken. I told him of the 
 crucified Savior, whose blood he had trampled under foot, and 
 warned him of the hell that awaited him ; but all to no purpose. 
 The devil had made such a cowardly sneak of him, that he 
 dared not meet his drunken associates, and tell them of his' 
 reformation. This was where the shoe pinched. So the poor 
 fellow went over the dam. 
 
 During this meeting scores were converted. To God be all 
 the glory. 
 
 OSWEGO. 
 
 While I was living in Watertovvn, a messenger came from 
 Oswego, N. Y., to urge me to go to that town, and assist 
 brother Myrick, a Congregationalist minister, in a meeting 
 already begun. There were some indications for good before I 
 reached there, and the work continued to increase in interest 
 aud power. 
 
 Among many others, who bowed at the feet of Jesus, was 
 Mr. Peter S. Smith, a brother of Gerritt Smith.* He was a 
 splendid man at the bar, and a member of the vestry of the 
 Episcopal church. When this man took a stand for Christ, the 
 
 * Gerritt Smith has been widely known, and will ever be remembered 
 and honored as a champion of anti-slavery, and an exemplar of noble 
 philanthropy.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 67 
 
 tide of salvation seemed to' sweep on with mighty power ; many, 
 who had hitherto ignored the work as mere excitement, began 
 to think that there was a divine reality in it, and multitudes 
 believed, both of men and women. 
 
 Of course here, as elsewhere, some, even professed Christians, 
 opposed this way of laboring for God, and " some doubted." 
 All was new to them. Nevertheless, it was impossible that 
 earnest prayers should be constantly offered, that solemn and 
 sometimes vehement sermons should be preached, and that the 
 most touching appeal^ should be made, and the most awful 
 warnings given, together with personal overtures to individual 
 consciences, without producing an excitement and making au 
 impression. I remember well a remark made by Judge Hart 
 to a friend of his (neither of them professors of religion). I 
 was walking behind them, one dark and dreary night, and heard 
 the strange gentleman say, " Judge, what do you think of this 
 excitement? " The judge replied, " I like it ; it makes religion 
 a reality." This was a word of great encouragement, and it 
 implied a great deal. 
 
 A dry goods merchant, whose wife was a member of the 
 Baptist church, was brought to see his lost condition ; his dis- 
 tress increased daily until sleep departed from him. His agony 
 became unendurable. At a late hour, one night, he sent out 
 for brother Savage, the pastor, and myself to come over and 
 pray for him. It was soon discovered that, in a business trans- 
 action, he had defrauded a man out of one hundred and fifty 
 dollars. As soon as he had made mention of this, and of his 
 purpose to make restitution, he found peace to his soul. 
 
 The number of converts at this meeting was counted by 
 hundreds ; they were scattered among the different churches, 
 never to be gathered together again until the morning of the 
 resurrection.
 
 68 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 CHAPTER VII. 
 
 ACCOUNTS OF PROTRACTED MEETINGS. 
 (1834-5.) 
 
 AUBURN : A Disturber. Opposition. Cowards. Stage Bide. A 
 Surprise. PHCENIXVILLE : Church organized. ITHACA : Con- 
 version of Mr. M. BROOME STREET, NEW YORK CITY : Hyper- 
 Calvinism. REMOVAL TO HAMILTON. Reasons. 
 
 AUBURN. 
 
 IN the year 1834, I conducted a protracted meeting with the 
 Baptist church in Auburn, Cayuga County, N. Y. I felt 
 somewhat embarrassed for a time in this place, because I had 
 not been accustomed to preach in such a large town, nor such a 
 fine church. But as I went on in my work, thoughts of these 
 things vanished out of my mind. The new method of present- 
 ing the gospel captivated some and repelled others. Deacon 
 Daniels, of Scipio, came into town on business, and coming in 
 to hear a sermon, was so deeply interested, that he remained a 
 whole week, and told his friends that he would not take the 
 best farm in the town of Scipio for what he had learned during 
 that week. 
 
 But the work was no sooner well under way, than the devil 
 began to be disturbed. Opposition, not only in words, but in 
 action, became stronger and stronger. One man, who declared 
 that his damnation was sealed, always began to rave whenever 
 a season of religious interest began to prevail in the place. He 
 would go up and down the streets cursing and swearing, and 
 doing all in his power to break up the meeting. He would 
 constantly make a noise in the vestibule, thumping against the
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 69 
 
 wall, and stamping up and down the stairs. On one of these 
 occasions, a deacon stepped out and requested him to be quiet, 
 or leave the house ; immediately this son of Belial laid violent 
 hands on him, and forced him headlong down the steps, and 
 instantly ran off and swore out a warrant against the deacon for 
 assault and battery. On the next morning the deacon was 
 summoned to trial. 
 
 In the mean time the wicked had organized their forces, and 
 began to threaten to ride me on a rail. They went so far as to 
 go into the woods and cut a pole, and put it up on a corner 
 which they knew I was accustomed to pass. This demonstra- 
 tion alarmed many of my friends, and some of them began to 
 remonstrate with me ; but I replied, " Don't be concerned ; if 
 they intended to do anything of the kind, they would have kept 
 the pole out of sight." On the same night some of them came 
 into the meeting, were smitten down by the power of God's 
 truth, and had to be carried to their homes. 
 
 In addressing the congregation the next evening, I indulged 
 in a little irony (as did Elijah before the priests of Baal). I 
 told them that it was a hard thing to fight against God ; that 
 they were a faint-hearted set of fellows ; that if they had even 
 succeeded in getting me on their pole, they would have probably 
 fainted, and let me fall and break my neck ; and then, in a 
 more solemn manner, I proceeded to press the inquiries, " Who 
 hath contended with Him and prospered?" and, "If the foot- 
 men have wearied thee, how canst thou contend with the horse- 
 men ? " 
 
 When the time for the mock trial of the deacon had arrived, 
 a party of fellows, of " the baser sort," started, in company 
 with the deputy sheriff, to arrest me, pretending that they 
 wanted me as a witness. On reaching my boarding-house, 
 Squire Burgess, the gentleman with whom I was staying, told 
 them that they could not see Mr. Knapp, and, finding that they 
 insisted on forcing an entrance, called to him a large, savage 
 dog, and informed them that he gave them just five minutes in 
 which to leave his premises, and that at the end of that time,
 
 70 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF 
 
 if they were not gone, he would set his dog on them. The 
 faithful creature seemed to understand the demands of the 
 occasion, and impatiently awaited the signal from his master ; 
 but before the time had expired, the cowardly crew thought 
 discretion to be the better part of valor, and withdrew. Of 
 course the suit amounted to nothing. 
 
 A goodly number were converted in this meeting, though it 
 lasted only about three weeks. In those days we had learned 
 the importance of holding on until we not only " carry the bat- 
 tle to the gates of the city, but until we go up and possess it." 
 
 When I took the stage for Oswego, where I was at that time 
 residing, I found myself seated with six gentlemen, five of whom 
 were Christians. With them I had a delightful season of 
 religious conversation ; but on turning to the other, and intro- 
 ducing the subject of religion to him, I was met by a very frank 
 request to " mind my own business." I replied that I was 
 doing so ; that it was my business to look after the salvation 
 of souls, and that I meant to attend to it faithfully, and stick to 
 him like a brother. I soon found that he was a confirmed 
 Universalist. I finally suggested to him, that " if a few hours' 
 conversation with Christians in a stage-coach was unendurable, 
 how did he think he would stand it in heaven, where there 
 would be millions of saints, much holier than we were then, and 
 where all would be absorbed in holiness." He answered that 
 he did not care to trouble himself on the subject. It was 
 not long, however, before he called out to the driver to stop and 
 let him get out, saying he would rather lose his fare, than ride 
 in a coach with saints and be bored with their talk. 
 
 I was relating this circumstance, a few years afterwards, to 
 a congregation in Schenectady, when, to my astonishment and 
 delight, a gentleman arose, and stated that he was the man 
 referred to ; and he went on to say, that, from that hour, he had 
 no peace until he renounced his Universalism, and found " peace 
 in believing" in Jesus. As he trudged on in the mud, the 
 questions which I had propounded began to ring in his ear. 
 He began to realize that heaven must, of course, be a religious
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 71 
 
 place, aud the inhabitants of it must be engaged in speaking 
 and singing of the praises of Jesus ; that there would be no 
 business, nor amusements, nor worldly conversation there ; and 
 that if he got in there, he would not be able to get out as easily 
 as he had got out of the stage ; and if he could get out of 
 heaven, where else would he want to go? He saw the sinful- 
 ness of his nature, and his need of a regenerating change, in 
 order to enter the kingdom of God. 
 
 PHCENIXVILLE. 
 
 In the autumn of 1834 I attended a meeting at Phoenixville, 
 N. Y. At that time there was no Christian church in the 
 place, and scarcely a person who professed the Christian name. 
 I put up at the public house kept by Colonel Richards, who 
 was a Universalist. The meeting was called by a few Chris- 
 tians of different denominations, who resided in the vicinity. 
 The Spirit of the Lord came down with power, and in about 
 eight days more than one hundred souls were hopefully con- 
 verted, among whom were Colonel Richards, his wife, and 
 daughter. I baptized fifty-nine, and, aided by neighboring 
 pastors, organized them into a church. 
 
 ITHACA. 
 
 In the year 1835 I held a meeting with the Baptist church in 
 Ithaca, N. Y. It continued forty days, during which time I 
 preached night and day. The Baptist church was small, and 
 in a low condition. In consequence of long-standing difficulties 
 and violent contentions, the community was generally prejudiced 
 against the church, and many who otherwise would have been 
 disposed to attend on its worship, had turned away in dis- 
 gust. 
 
 This meeting was gotten up at the instance of our beloved 
 brethren, Thomas and Bronson,* who, at that time, were sup- 
 
 * Eev. J. Thomas was killed by the falling of a tree across his boat, 
 just as he came in sight of the city to which he had been designated as 
 the field of his future labors. Kev. Mr. Bronson is still living, and labor- 
 ing in Assam, a veteran in the missionary service.
 
 72 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 plying the church, and afterwards went as missionaries to 
 Assam, India. It commenced on the first day of January. 
 God was pleased to bless our efforts. The Holy Spirit was 
 poured out on the entire community. Saints were humbled, 
 differences were reconciled, and the hearts of many, who had 
 been alienated from each other, were subdued and reunited 
 under the power of Christian love, and the impenitent were 
 brought to repentance. I baptized into the fellowship of the 
 church one hundred and twenty converts. Among those who 
 professed their faith in Christ were some noted infidels. One 
 instance of this class of conversions is worth relating. The 
 wife of Mr. M. had been converted during the meetings. 
 When she came out, and avowed her faith, he became exceed- 
 ingly enraged. The providence of God cast him in my way 
 one morning as I was about to leave the village. I commenced 
 conversation with him concerning the interests of his soul. He 
 did not hesitate to abuse me with his tongue, and withal 
 threatened to cowskin me. I treated him kindly, broke him 
 down on every position he took, and as I rose to go, offered 
 him my hand. He refused to take it, putting his behind him. 
 I, however, stepped round him, took hold of his hand, and 
 gently squeezing it, said, " Take care, friend M., lest you lose 
 your immortal soul." God was pleased to cause these words to 
 sink down into his heart like melted iron, and he began to walk 
 the streets in great agony of mind. At length he went into the 
 prayer-meeting, and unable longer to control his feelings, fell 
 down on his knees, and begged the prayers of those whom he 
 had despised and reviled. Casting his all on the mercy of God 
 through Christ, he rose up rejoicing in hope, and shortly after- 
 wards sent forme to return, a journey of seventy miles, and bap- 
 tize him. 
 
 THE CITY OF NEW YORK, 1835. 
 
 In the spring of 1835 I was invited to preach in the Broome 
 Street Baptist Church in the city of New York. Their house 
 of worship was a small building located near the East River. I 
 found the condition of the Baptist churches there to be, for the
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 73 
 
 most part, in a low state. The blighting influence of hyper- 
 Calvinism seemed to spread the palsy of inaction on all their 
 desires to serve God. This church had been organized ten 
 years, and though located in the midst of a large population, it 
 had, at the time I visited them, only thirty-seven members. 
 The themes to which they wished to listen were the decrees of 
 God, particular redemption, personal and unconditional election, 
 eternal justification, perseverance of the saints (going backwards 
 or forwards) , and baptism. The presentation of any other topic 
 from the pulpit was deemed a heresy ; and the most guarded 
 pleas for Christian effort in the salvation of sinners was 
 denounced as Arminianism, and more to be dreaded than infi- 
 delity. 
 
 The meetings soon became quite interesting. The Lord was 
 in our midst. Many were reconverted, and entered into the 
 work. But some, even of those who had been praying for the 
 revival of God's work, began to be alarmed at the way in which 
 he was answering their petitions. One good brother, fearing it 
 was the work of man rather than of the Spirit of God, made up 
 his mind to come out publicly and oppose it ; but after making 
 the matter a subject of special prayer, was induced to acquaint 
 himself more intimately with the experiences of those "who were 
 seeking or professing salvation. And when he found that the 
 inquirers ascribed their sadness and anxiety to their discoveries 
 of their own sinfulness and helplessness in the sight of the 
 violated law, and that they readily acknowledged the justice of 
 God in their condemnation, and when he heard the converts 
 ascribe their peace, and joy, and love to the all-sufficiency of the 
 perfect righteousness of Christ, he saw that they were taught of 
 God, and led by his Holy Spirit ; and instead of rising before 
 the people to oppose and denounce, he broke forth into strains 
 of joyful approbation, and gave his soul up to an unreserved 
 and practical sympathy with the work. The protracted meet- 
 ings continued about four weeks ; and as the church had no 
 pastor, I remained with them a few months longer. The num- 
 ber that were baptized, during my stay with this people, was 
 about two hundred. 
 7
 
 74 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 But though urged to accept the pastoral charge of the church, 
 with fair prospects of increase in numbers and influence, yet the 
 condition of the world at large was ever before me. Millions 
 were crowding their way to hell, and churches seemed to be 
 sleeping over them. And though rny wife was afflicted with 
 feeble health, and my family was increasing in numbers, and 
 in claims on my attention, yet I felt constrained with the over- 
 mastering conviction that God had called me to go forth among 
 the churches, and I dared not be " disobedient to the heavenly 
 vision." 
 
 REMOVAL TO HAMILTON. 
 
 Until this time I had, for the most part, kept my family some- 
 where in the region of country where I was laboring. At 
 length it became apparent that it was my duty to secure them a 
 comfortable and permanent home in some central location. 
 After praying and reflecting for some time on the subject, I 
 concluded to select the village of Hamilton, Madison County, 
 N. Y. 
 
 Several considerations operated in bringing me to this con- 
 clusion. In the first place, the Baptist Literary and Theologi- 
 cal Institution was located there. And I hoped that my style 
 of preaching, and methods of presenting subjects, would be of 
 some service to the students for the ministry, in enabling them 
 to combine the simple and plain presentation of the Gospel with 
 the advantages of literary culture and systematic training. In 
 the second place, I knew that Hamilton was the seat of a strong 
 prejudice against me, and one which, unless dissipated, would 
 seriously affect the after ministry of the young men who would 
 go forth from the Institution as the instructors and overseers of 
 the churches. For a while after I took up my residence there, 
 I was studiously denied access to the pulpit, and nearly every 
 sign of denominational recognition. In less than two years, 
 however, this prejudice was swept by the board, by the rising 
 tides of public sympathy and confidence. In the third place, 
 the village was reputed for its healthiness and the excellence 
 of its schools.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 75 
 
 My family was now pleasantly settled, and I was free from 
 domestic anxiety, for God opened the hearts of his people, from 
 time to time, so that we lacked for nothing that was needful for 
 our comfort. Thus I was enabled to devote my entire time to 
 the work of preaching, and laboring in protracted meetings. I 
 was also highly favored in the matter of health and the power 
 of endurance, so that I was able to preach from two to three 
 times a day almost constantly, besides attending anxious and 
 prayer-meetings. , 
 
 I continued holding meetings both summer and winter, seed 
 time and harvest, for some two years, principally in the middle 
 section of the State of New York. And notwithstanding all my 
 weakness and unworthiness, God abundantly blessed these 
 meetings, and in each of them many souls were converted. A 
 short account of a few of them may be interesting and prof- 
 itable.
 
 76 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 CHAPTER VIII. 
 
 ACCOUNTS OF PEOTRACTED MEETINGS. 
 (1836.) 
 
 BRIDGEWATER : A Lawyer. A Ball. A Case of Prejudice. 
 The Presbyterian Minister. BENNINGTON, VT. : Thirty-one 
 Tears afterwards. WATERVILLE : Distilleries. Liquor Dealers. 
 Proposed attack. 
 
 BRIDGEWATER. 
 
 IN 1836 a meeting was arranged in Bridgewater, N. Y., in 
 which I was to preach alternately in the Baptist and Presby- 
 terian churches. "We began with encouraging prospects, and 
 went on well. The interest increased day by day. Both 
 churches worked harmoniously. 
 
 Among the converts was an eminent lawyer, who stated that, 
 for the last eight years, remorse of conscience, and the un- 
 avoidable evils of this life, had been more than enough to 
 counterbalance all the happiness which he had ever enjoyed, so 
 that he had come to regard a state of non-existence preferable to 
 that of conscious being. But since he had believed in Jesus, he 
 declared that he had found true happiness, and he could say 
 that it was a blessing to live even in this world, while his soul 
 was made to rejoice beyond expression in the hope of living 
 forever. 
 
 When this revival was at its height, the young people of the 
 place arranged to hold a ball. On the night appointed, the 
 people of God held an all-night prayer-meeting. They danced 
 while we prayed. But the ball was not a succ'ess. They ad- 
 journed at a very early hour. Nobody seemed to be in a mood
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 77 
 
 for sport. Many came over to the prayer-meeting, and several 
 were converted before it closed. 
 
 There were connected with the congregation of the Baptist 
 church a well-known gentleman and lady, who had not at- 
 tended any of the meetings since I had begun to .preach. 
 Brother Simmons and Deacon Allen called upon them, and 
 learned that they had heard, that Mr. Knapp had refused to 
 come to preach in the place until a certain amount of money 
 had been raised for him ; and they thought, that if he preached 
 for money, his preaching would do them no good. These 
 brethren informed them of their mistake ; that they had cor- 
 responded with Mr. Knapp concerning his visit, and had asked 
 him to state how much he would expect for his services, and 
 how his family was supported, and that Elder Knapp had 
 replied, " that he made no charges ; that he went wherever 
 the Master called. If his labors were blessed, and anybody 
 was disposed to contribute anything for the support of his 
 family, it would be thankfully received ; that no demand was 
 made for compensation, not even for travelling expenses." 
 
 They expressed themselves very much mortified at being so 
 greatly imposed upon by the devil's pedlers, and came at once 
 to hear me preach. At the close of the first sermon they heard, 
 the wife came crowding her way along the aisle, and, reaching 
 out her hand to me, the tears streaming down her cheeks, she 
 said, " Mr. Knapp, I wish to make a confession to you." I re- 
 plied, " My dear woman, why do you wish to confess to me? 
 I do not know you." She replied, " I have cherished wicked 
 and unfounded prejudices against you, and I would not hear 
 you preach ; and now, under the first sermon I have heard you 
 preach, God has broken my heart." 
 
 In consequence of his deep anxiety and exhaustive labors in 
 this meeting, the excellent pastor of the Presbyterian church 
 lost his health, and for a time it was feared that his reason 
 would be destroyed. Sometimes he would preach when border- 
 ing on the verge of insanity ; and never, in my life, did I hear 
 from mortal lips the realities of eternal truth portrayed in
 
 78 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 
 
 language that seemed so inspired by the breath of God, and 
 visions of the world to come. O, thought I, that ministers 
 would always preach under such a near sense of the judgment, 
 heaven and hell, and with less regard to the feelings, the 
 frowns, and the favor of men ! 
 
 BENNINGTON. 
 
 In the autumn of 1836 I held a meeting in Bennington, Vt. 
 The place being small, Christians of all denominations united 
 in giving interest to the services. The word preached was 
 made " the power of God unto salvation." The Spirit of God 
 came down on the youth in great power. Sometimes fifteen or 
 twenty would cry aloud for mercy at a time. The converts 
 united with the different churches. 
 
 Thirty-one years afterwards I met a number of them iu 
 Elmira, who gave an interesting account of many who were 
 converted at that time, and who have since been active and 
 prominent laborers in the cause of Christ. Some became 
 eminent business men, others judges, others teachers and 
 preachers. 
 
 During this meeting the devil was disturbed. Accordingly, 
 he stirred up a company of persons to do all they could to 
 hinder the progress of the work. One night some one went up 
 into the steeple of the church and took out the tongue of the 
 bell. Much prayer was offered for the persons who were 
 engaged in this transaction ; and I ventured to utter a predic- 
 tion that within one year from that time the young men, who 
 had thus attempted to silence the voice of God, would be in hell. 
 It was afterwards ascertained that two young men did the deed ; 
 and surely enough, in less than a year afterwards they both 
 died, and died without hope. One of them arose from his bed 
 in the night, and opening a door in the dark, fell headlong and 
 broke his neck. 
 
 WATERVILLE. 
 
 During the same year I conducted a meeting in the Whis- 
 key-mill village of Waterville, N. Y. Here there were four
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 79 
 
 or five distilleries in full blast. I came out decidedly against 
 this soul-destroying business, and told the people that the only 
 way in which they could save their capital, would be to wind up 
 those concerns, and invest their money in enterprises that con- 
 duced to their moral and religious well being. One of them 
 took my advice. The others kept on until they failed and sank 
 into poverty. 
 
 Much opposition was manifested to my ministry here by the 
 retail dealers in this damning traffic. They organized a club, 
 and pledged their fidelity to each other to break up the meeting, 
 cost them what it might. One night a gang came into the 
 church with clubs and missiles of different kinds, such as pokers 
 and crowbars, and seated themselves in a body. I had been 
 informed that they intended mischief, and this bold and defiant 
 bearing confirmed the rumor. 
 
 After the sermon was concluded I dismissed the congrega- 
 tion, and requested all who wished to pray to remain. Nearly 
 all the Christian people tarried, and we continued in prayer 
 until near morning. The gang of intended disturbers made no 
 offensive movement, and finally, being " convicted in their 
 consciences, they went out one by one." There was no further 
 talk of disturbance. Large accessions were made to all the 
 churches, and the public sentiment became changed from opposi- 
 tion to sympathy with the preacher and his measures. I had 
 long before this learned that ministers could as easily control 
 public opinion, as to allow it to control them. All that is 
 needful is that they take a bold stand for the right, and trust 
 in God for strength to maintain it. 

 
 80 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 CHAPTER IX.'* 
 
 ',' .- ' '-- . t ' 
 
 ACCOUNTS OF PROTRACTED MEETINGS. 
 
 (1837.) 
 
 HAMILTON : Fear of Men. Co-laborers. Results. Day of Small " 
 Things. PENNYAN : Large Accessions. Commotion among the 
 Infidels. Meeting-house paid for. A Case of Conviction. A 
 Legacy of Ministers. 
 
 HAMILTON. 
 
 IN the winter of 183*7 I held a meeting with the Baptist 
 church in Hamilton, N. Y. I felt considerable embarrass- 
 ment in undertaking to preach in this place. Here I had been 
 educated, and here I had married. Withal, I was not insensi- 
 ble of the fact that in my congregation would be those whose 
 habits of thought and feeling inclined them to criticise sermons. 
 
 As to their literary and intellectual merits, I knew that I was 
 not punctilious as to my modes of speech, and more anxious to 
 reach the consciences of men, than to please their fancies or 
 their love of display. Yet, after I had got well under way, I 
 lost sight of all these things. The great things of God, and 
 God and eternity, rolled'up before me in such a light, that I was 
 determined to kftow nothing among them save " Jesus Christ 
 and him crucified." 
 
 The church was soon ajcoused. The students generally came 
 in and took hold of the work with warm hearts. Several of 
 the professors in the Institution were greatly enlisted. Espe- 
 cially may I make mom ion of^the venerable Dr. Nathaniel Ken- 
 drick. He was a warrrf-ljteated, devoted servant of Christ, and 
 was then ripening for heaven. Squire Payne, Deacon Payne, 
 and Judge Olmstead were all in their element, entering with a 
 holy zest into this their last revival season on earth. Very
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 81 
 
 W " 4|| - '. 
 
 many souls were converted. All-night prayer meetings were 
 held. The atmosphere seemed impregnated with a divine 
 influence. 
 
 Among those whom it was my privilege to baptize as the 
 fruits of this meeting, were my eldest daughter, now the wife 
 of A. J. Bingham ; J. R. Kendrick, now the pastor of the 
 Tabernacle Baptist Church, in the city of New York ; Samuel 
 C. Griggs, then a poor boy, but now a successful book publisher 
 in Chicago, 111. ; Mr. Kendall, now a well-known business man 
 in St. Louis and Alton ; Dr. Douglass, then a practising physi- 
 cian, and afterwards a professor in the Medical College at 
 Cleveland, Ohio. 
 
 It was a very common remarkramong those who opposed me, 
 that " Mr. Knapp was adapted to reach only a certain class, 
 and that they were only the poorer and less influential." 
 Such people did not seem to know that the poor of one genera- 
 tion become the rich of the next. If it were possible to enumer- 
 ate all who were converted under my ministry, and afterwards 
 became eminent in the various walks of life, and who have 
 consecrated their attainments to the cause of Christ, they would, 
 perhaps, learn the folly of despising the day of small things. 
 
 PENNY AN. 
 
 In August, 1837, 1 was called to attend a meeting in Pennyan, 
 Yates County, N. Y. The Baptist church in this village was 
 young and small, consisting of about thirty members. Through 
 assistance furnished them from abroad, they had built a good 
 brick house of worship. Their plea' being urgent, I felt a strong 
 inclination to comply, notwithstanding I was under engagements 
 for every month in the year, except the month of August, which 
 I had reserved for rest. But as I must go then, Or not at all, I 
 concluded to trust in God for ' strength, ^and to*comply with their 
 request. 
 
 Our beginning was small, and for a long time the prospects 
 were dark! During the first eight days we did not hear of a 
 single conversion. The unconverted began to rejoice over the 
 

 
 82 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 certain prospects of our failure. Nevertheless the congregations 
 kept on increasing daily, until the house was too strait for us. 
 Soon it became apparent that multitudes were under conviction, 
 and conversions followed by scores. Many of all classes were 
 brought to bow at the Savior's feet. During the meeting, 
 which continued five weeks, it was estimated, after careful 
 inquiry, that about four hundred souls were hopefully converted 
 to Christ. At the end of the fourth week, I baptized fifty-three 
 persons ; and at the close of the fifth week, there were baptized, 
 by the pastor and myself, sixty-five more. Brother Ira Bennett, 
 the pastor, after the meetings had closed, baptized twenty-nine 
 more, making, in all, an addition to the church of one hundred 
 and forty-nine. Besides these, many of those who were con- 
 verted joined other Baptist churches in that region, while a 
 large number united with churches of other denominations. 
 
 Pennyan was the seat of infidelity for that entire region, and, 
 as might be expected, I soon encountered the opposition of 
 persons who imbibed such sentiments. My life was fre- 
 quently threatened, and I learned, after the danger had passed, 
 that a drunken Universalist, armed with a knife and pistol, had 
 sought to waylay me for three successive nights ; but God de- 
 livered me out of his hands, by leading me to go to my lodgings 
 by a different route each night, though, at the time, I did not 
 recognize any particular reason for doing so. 
 
 One man, a hardened and abandoned infidel, left the meeting- 
 house one night cursing God, and swearing that he would have 
 nothing to do with religion, and that he would fetch his wife 
 out, if he had to go through hell after her. Shortly after he 
 had reached home he was taken ill. His skin turned as yel- 
 low as saffron ; his tongue became so swollen that he could not 
 speak a word, nor keep it within his mouth. On the second 
 day after he was seized, he died. This remarkable event seemed 
 to strike terror throughout the community. Nearly every per- 
 son accepted it as a judgment from God. Consternation spread 
 through the ranks of infidelity, and many of its open advocates 
 came to me, pale and trembling, begging for the prayers of 
 Christians, and were converted to God.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 83 
 
 One incident, illustrating the special providence of God, ought 
 to be mentioned. In the spring previous to our meeting, an 
 infidel, from the State of Ohio, came along in the character of 
 a temperance lecturer. After getting possession of the Baptist 
 meetiug-house for the purpose of advocating the cause of 
 temperance, he made an appointment to lecture on animal 
 magnetism, and in the course of his remarks on this subject, he 
 took occasion to assail the Christian religion, and to extol the 
 beauties of infidelity. At the close of this lecture he made 
 another appointment ; but on going to the house the next even- 
 ing, he found the doors locked against him. The infidels of 
 the town became furious ; and knowing that the Baptists were 
 owing three thousand dollars on their house, and were poor, 
 they vowed that they would buy up the mortgage, and turn the 
 building into an infidel hall. This threat awakened the sym- 
 pathy and zeal of the Christians of other denominations, and 
 they stepped forward at once with such liberal contributions, 
 that the Baptist church was enabled to free itself from debt. 
 In order to do this, however, notwithstanding this outside help, 
 nearly every male member of the Baptist church pledged one 
 half of all he was worth in order to clear the indebtedness. 
 The protracted meeting followed, truth triumphed, hundreds of 
 persons were converted, and infidelity was swept by the board. 
 Among the incidents illustrating the manner in which some 
 persons strove against the Holy Spirit, I recollect the instance 
 of a young lady, who, during the early part of this meeting, 
 resorted to violent measures in order to drive away the convic- 
 tions that troubled her. She was a person of considerable 
 culture, and of high social position. At first she declared she 
 would not attend the meetings any more ; yet she continued to 
 come, but, lest she should be recognized, sought to disguise 
 herself in the clothing of one of the servants of the family. As 
 her convictions increased, her proud heart became more and 
 more rebellious, and she determined to exhibit her unwilling- 
 ness in forms of decided opposition. On one occasion she told 
 the hired man to array the horses with flowers and evergreens,
 
 84 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 and taking with her a company of thoughtless girls, in this 
 style she rode up and down the streets, passing the church, and 
 waving her handkerchief at me in the streets. When she re- 
 turned home, she found the servant girl reading the Bible, and, 
 snatching it from her, threw it with violence across the room, 
 bidding her not to touch it. On the next day, as she was 
 dusting the room, her eye fell on the book as it lay where she 
 had flung it, and in her rage seized the broom, and struck this 
 precious volume as it lay on the floor. At this moment a re- 
 action set in, and unable longer to resist the striving of God's 
 grace, she was at length constrained to yield her heart to Christ. 
 Among the converts at this meeting in Pennyan were two 
 young men, who afterwards studied for the ministry, and 
 became successful laborers in the Savior's vineyard. One of 
 these was J. B. Tombes, who is now pastor of the Baptist 
 church at Carbondale, Pa. ; the other was S. M. Bainbridge, well 
 known in Western New York, who, after preaching Christ with 
 great success for nearly thirty years, fell asleep in Jesus, 
 bequeathing the mantle of his service to his son, who has re- 
 cently been ordained pastor of the Baptist church at Erie, Pa.
 
 ELDEE JACOB KNAPP. 85 
 
 CHAPTER X. 
 
 ACCOUNTS OF PEOTEACTED MEETINGS. 
 
 (1838.) 
 
 UTICA : Bethel Church. The First and Second Presbyterian 
 Churches. Conversions. Baptist Cause. A new Church. 
 Universalists. SCHENECTADY : Union of Christians. Union 
 College. Conversion of Students. SENECA FALLS : A Re-con- 
 version of all the Churches. BROOKLYN : Baptist Cause feeble. 
 Pillars in the Church. John N. Wilder. Conversion of an Athe- 
 ist. Sisterly Remonstrance. Deacon Colgate. General Results. 
 
 UTICA. 
 
 A LTHOUGH there had been much prejudice against me in the 
 .LA. city of Utica, I was at length invited to preach in this place. 
 I began in the Bethel at West Utica. It was a small building, 
 capable of holding about four hundred persons. I commenced* 
 in February, 1838, and continued preaching night and day for 
 about two weeks, during which time there were some con- 
 versions ; many were awakened, and Christians were aroused to 
 action. 
 
 The place becoming now too small to contain the crowds that 
 thronged to hear the word, we were invited to the Broad Street 
 Baptist Church, and to the First and Second Presbyterian 
 Churches. After much prayer and deliberation, it was deter- 
 mined to take the Second Presbyterian Church. This selection 
 was made because of its central location, and because it was not 
 so large as to make a fair-sized congregation seem small. But 
 the power of God came down, and the house was immediately 
 filled to its utmost capacity. Salvation rolled on like a mighty 
 river.
 
 86 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 After continuing here for about three weeks, it was found 
 necessary to remove to the house of the First Presbyterian 
 Church. This vast audience-room was thronged every night ; 
 sometimes every inch of standing-room was occupied. Here I 
 remained two weeks, making the period of my stay in Utica 
 seven weeks. I preached one and twenty sermons, besides 
 attending prayer and inquiry meetings. 
 
 The cases of pungent conviction were so numerous that we 
 could seldom close our evening services before eleven o'clock, 
 although as many as wished to retire at an earlier hour were 
 seasonably dismissed. Throughout these arduous, constant, 
 and abundant labors, my health was graciously preserved. At 
 the close of the meeting, all who had experienced a hope during 
 the revival were seated in a body, making a congregation of 
 nearly eight hundred persons. Nor did this assembly comprise 
 all who had been led to the Savior during the meeting ; many 
 there were who lived in the surrounding villages. . 
 
 Up to this time the Baptist cause had been struggling along, 
 able only, with difficulty, to maintain an existence. I had fixed 
 my mind on the formation of another Baptist church from the 
 very beginning of the meeting ; and although many of the 
 "Baptists opposed the measure, yet there were some who were 
 willing to make almost any sacrifice to accomplish this result, 
 believing it would be for the glory of God. 
 
 Accordingly, towards the close of the meeting, these brethren 
 met together, invited me to be present, adopted articles of faith, 
 and took all other steps needful for their organization as a 
 church of Christ. It began with only thirteen constituent mem- 
 bers. I then baptized into their fellowship about seventy con- 
 verts ; and in about eighteen months' time, this church obtained 
 a commodious house of worship, and have continued to this day 
 a blessing and a glory. 
 
 Among the converts in this meeting were persons of all 
 classes ; many of them were merchants, doctors, lawyers, 
 judges, and city officials. There were four attorneys who pro- 
 fessed conversion in a single day. Many of the experiences
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 87 
 
 were clear, striking, and marvellous. Religion was the serious 
 topic of conversation in the market-places and along the streets. 
 Hitherto Universalism had held a strong hold in Utica. The 
 sect had quite an influential congregation, a good meeting- 
 house, and an able paper, edited by Rush Skinner*, a man of 
 considerable intellectual power and notoriety. I undertook to 
 unmask the hypocrisy and expose the nakedness of the system. 
 Shortly after this revival, the Universalists sold their meeting- 
 house, and Skinner left the city. They have not been able to 
 accomplish much since. 
 
 SCHENECTADT. 
 
 In the month of June, 1838, I was called to hold a meeting 
 of days in Schenectady, N. Y. I began preaching in the 
 Baptist meeting-house, but very soon the throng so greatly 
 exceeded its capacity, that I removed to the Presbyterian Church 
 edifice. Throughout the session of this meeting there prevailed 
 a remarkable union of feeling and action between Christians of 
 all denominations. Baptists and Presbyterians, Dutch Reformed 
 and Methodists, and also Episcopalians, became deeply inter- 
 ested. Dr. Nott. and all the Faculty of Union College, were 
 constantly in attendance and actively engaged. The Lord was 
 pleased to bless his truth, not only to the salvation of many of 
 the citizens, but also to the hopeful conversion of about eighty 
 of the students, many of whom have since " addicted themselves 
 to the ministry " in different denominations. 
 
 There were thought to have been between three hundred and 
 four hundred instances of conversion, during this meeting ; and 
 though the Baptist church was destitute of a pastor, yet about 
 fifty persons Avere baptized into its fellowship. This meeting 
 continued about four weeks. 
 
 By this time my throat became so seriously affected that I 
 was advised by several physicians to abstain from public speak- 
 ing. But the calls for help were so numerous and so pressing 
 that I could not see any stopping-place. I therefore continued 
 011 preaching day and night, that is, fifteen sermons per week,
 
 88 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 until by praying, preaching, and drinking freely of cold water, 
 my complaint was broken up. 
 
 SENECA FALLS. 
 
 After this I attended meetings in Clinton, Fay^tteville, Elmira 
 and Seneca Falls, in all of which I was greatly blessed in see- 
 ing many sinners turning to God. The meeting in the last- 
 named place was especially fruitful in bringing about a new era 
 of religious feeling in the village. Up to this time the churches 
 were comparatively feeble and inefficient. Infidelity was stalk- 
 ing unblushingly through the streets. Its corrupting, blighting, 
 and damning influence was felt throughout the entire vicinity. 
 This meeting was blessed to the re-conversion of the churches, 
 the arresting of the tide of infidelity, and the immediate salva- 
 tion of many souls. More than one hundred were added to the 
 Baptist church, and a considerable number to other churches. 
 
 BROOKLYN. 
 
 I commenced a meeting of days in the city of Brooklyn, N. Y., 
 in connection with the First Baptist Church, on the first day 
 of December, 1838. The Baptist interest in Brooklyn was at 
 that time quite feeble. The meeting-house was not more than 
 half filled by its ordinary congregation. Shortly after I had 
 commenced preaching, the congregation greatly increased, the 
 members of the church took hold with great zeal, backsliders 
 were reclaimed, and converts were greatly multiplied. It pleased 
 the Lord to cause the truth to take hold of the consciences of 
 several men of wealth and influence, and several of this class 
 were converted. Still the city was not at first moved to any 
 remarkable extent, nor was the house filled until I had preached 
 nearly four weeks. 
 
 By this time, however, the work of the Lord had not only 
 extended throughout the city, but began to be powerfully felt 
 among the churches in the city of New York. During this meet- 
 ing I baptized, in connection with the pastor, Rev. S. Illsley, two 
 hundred and ten persons, and subsequently brother Illsley bap-
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 89 
 
 tized one hundred more, as the fruit of this effort. The meet- 
 ing continued seven weeks, and I preached one hundred sermons. 
 
 Since that time this church has had an eventful history. As 
 the city has extended its boundaries, many have gone from this 
 church to assist in forming other Baptist churches. At times 
 it has been in this way greatly reduced in numbers and deprived 
 of its strength ; but in its darkest hours there have been a few 
 faithful onesji. who held on to the ship, until now she again 
 occupies a position of great prominence in the religious agencies 
 of Brooklyn. And the few to whose untiring and self-sacri- 
 ficing zeal the maintenance of the church is to be, under God, 
 ascribed, were for the most part brought in during this revival. 
 
 Among the interesting incidents that were crowded into this 
 meeting, I will mention a few. 
 
 A Mrs. Wilder and her daughter, Mrs. Smith, requested 
 prayers for their son and brother, John N. Wilder. He was a 
 gay and worldly young man, boarding at the time at a hotel in 
 the city of Albany, and had just fallen heir to a, fortune reputed 
 to be worth one hundred and twenty thousand dollars. This 
 devoted mother and sister, believing that God heard the prayers 
 of his people, preferred their request that the Christians 
 in Brooklyn would pray that he might be speedily con- 
 verted. Day after day would this request be made, and as 
 often was it remembered in our petitions to the throne of 
 grace. In the mean time his mother and sister were writing 
 him letters full of earnest entreaty. Though there was no 
 religious interest in Albany, this young man soon began to feel 
 the influence of the special strivings of the Holy Spirit. He 
 struggled to dissipate the feelings that were overpowering him. 
 He took a trip to Providence and mingled in gay society, and 
 afterwards took the stage to Rochester ; but all this while prayer 
 was going up in his behalf, and still his soul was troubled. His 
 sins were ever before him, and he found no rest. Returning to 
 Albany, he called first on Dr. Sprague, and then on Dr. Welch, 
 and by these servants of Christ he was led to see his lost con- 
 dition, and to put his trust in the righteousness of the Savior. 
 8
 
 90 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF 
 
 He united with the Baptist church, and devoted himself and his 
 wealth to the service of Him who had redeemed him. Shortly 
 afterwards he gave me one thousand dollars for Madison Uni- 
 versity. He identified himself with the various denominational 
 enterprises, and was specially active in promoting the founding 
 of Rochester University, subscribing ten thousand dollars towards 
 its endowment. A few years since, he died, quite suddenly, 
 widely known and highly esteemed as a zealous laborer in the 
 vineyard of the Lord. 
 
 I remember a striking instance of the power of God in the 
 conversion of an avowed atheist. He came to the meeting to 
 hear me preach on atheism. In the course of my sermon, I 
 remarked that " atheism was the little end of nothing whittled 
 to a point. Since the atheist denied everything and admitted 
 nothing, it was itself the little end of nothing." This remark ar- 
 rested his attention and mortified his pride. He had regarded 
 himself as specially intellectual, and capable of refuting all the 
 ministers in the land. He could not brook the thought that he, 
 a free-thinker, should be represented as a fool, and his creed 
 reduced to less than nothing. So, in order to be revenged, he 
 requested a Christian neighbor to ask prayers for the little end 
 of nothing. The request was complied with ; nor was it over- 
 looked amid the multiplicity of claims upon our prayers. 
 
 On the evening of the third day, as we repaired to the lec- 
 ture-room for the purpose of spending a season in prayer, who 
 should rise up but this infidel? Pale and haggard, not having 
 slept for three nights, and borne down by deep despair, he broke 
 the silence of the spell-bound congregation by saying, " My 
 fellow-citizens, you see before you the greatest sinner which 
 God ever suffered to live. I have denied the existence of my 
 Creator. I have ridiculed his Son Jesus Christ, calling him a 
 bastard. I have studied the word of God in order to pick flaws 
 and make out contradictions. I have cursed my Maker more 
 times than there are hairs on my head ; and as for you 
 Christians, there has been nothing too bad for me to say about 
 you ; and all I ask in return is, that you will not treat me as I
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 91 
 
 have treated you." He took bis seat. I said to him, " My 
 dear sir, do you not wish the prayers of God's people ? " He 
 answered, " No. Prayer can do me no good ; I must be lost." 
 I told him, " God is merciful ; Christ has died to save the 
 chief of sinners." He replied, " I know that ; and this knowl- 
 edge will be the keenest part of my sufferings. I have sinned 
 against infinite goodness and unparalleled mercy. J deserve to 
 le damned, and I must be damned. All directions to Christ as 
 a Savior avail nothing. I have not made the first attempt 
 at prayer, under the full conviction that prayer will do no 
 good." 
 
 He passed another sleepless night, walking his floor, and con- 
 templating his fearful doom. To him it was a night of terrors. 
 But just as the gray of the morning began to dawn, some 
 mysterious agency whispered in his ear, " Whosoever will, let 
 him come and take of the waters of life freely." For the first 
 time in his life he dropped on his knees, and pleaded for mercy 
 through Jesus Christ. In a few moments his load was gone, 
 and his soul felt the peace of believing, and unspeakable joy 
 beamed in his face. He rose from his knees, clapped his hands, 
 and shouted, " Glory, glory to God ! " and but for the fear of 
 making his neighbors think he was crazy, he said he should 
 have sung out at the top of his voice. 
 
 Much complaint in those days was made because I ventured 
 to cross the ancient landmarks, and got betimes out of the old 
 ruts. I sometimes made remarks which did not always accord 
 with every person's notions of propriety. Such expressions as 
 the one just named, which arrested the attention of the atheist, 
 were deemed highly objectionable. In consequence of this feel- 
 ing, early in this meeting a couple of well-meaning sisters, find- 
 ing themselves tried with my course in this regard, and thinking 
 such expressions calculated to do much harm, came to me one 
 day in the spirit of remonstrance. They assured me and I be- 
 lieved them that they were not of those who peddle for the 
 devil, talking against ministers and their measures behind their 
 backs. They opened their minds freely to me, and to me only.
 
 92 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 I listened patiently, and thanked them for their good intentions, 
 but told them that if they would keep on doing their duty, and 
 working for souls, they would find out, before the meetings 
 closed, that I understood what was the best way in which I 
 could work for the Master. After two weeks they came to me 
 again, and candidly acknowledged that the very things to which 
 they took exceptions had " fallen out for the furtherance of the 
 gospel," and that this would be the last time in which they 
 would undertake to dictate to a minister who was zealously and 
 successfully laboring for souls. 
 
 During this meeting the wife of the lamented Deacon "William 
 Colgate attended quite constantly, crossing the ferry from New 
 York back and forth in the cold and piercing winds. Her soul 
 became especially concerned for the conversion of her children, 
 and before the effort closed, some of them were brought to 
 Christ. Thus was opened the way for the great meeting in the 
 Baptist Tabernacle in 1840, where the rest of her children found 
 the Savior. On one morning the deacon requested me to go 
 and see his eldest son. I found him trembling under a sense 
 of his sinfulness. He told me that he could withstand anything 
 but his father's prayers and tears. Before that day closed he 
 yielded his heart to Jesus, and found peace and joy. 
 
 It would be impossible to trace all the results of this meeting. 
 When it commenced the Baptist cause was weak and small ; 
 and it is not too much to claim that from this meeting sprang 
 directly those agencies which contributed to the enlargement of 
 Baptist influence, and the multiplication of Baptist churches in 
 Brooklyn. Men of business, and wealth, and culture were 
 brought into the fold, besides a host of young persons, who 
 have since become pillars in different churches. The work ex- 
 tended through the city, entered the navy-yard, and rolled over 
 into the city of New York. Brother Illsley, the pastor, labored 
 to the last extent of his ability, and was a " true yoke-fellow." 
 Deacons Corning and Lewis, and, I believe, all who then were 
 deacons in the church, have long since crossed over Jordan, 
 and the remembrance of their earnest and untiring cooperation
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 93 
 
 is among my sweetest recollections. Never before, nor since, 
 have I passed such a night as that in which I preached my 
 farewell sermon to this people. It was a night made sleepless by 
 reason of the ecstasy of my soul. It is not enough to say, that 
 it was to me " the gate of heaven," for I seemed to have passed 
 its threshold, and entered into the fulness of the glory that shall 
 be revealed.
 
 94 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 CHAPTER XI. 
 
 ACCOUNTS OF PROTRACTED MEETINGS. 
 
 (CONTINUED.) 
 
 ROCHESTER : Gamblers. The Mob. Arrest. Councils of the 
 Wicked brought to Nought. BALTIMORE : General Interest. 
 Church strengthened. Washingtonian Temperance Movement. 
 Threatenings. A later Meeting. Letter from Dr. Fuller. 
 
 ROCHESTER. 
 
 rpO WARDS the close of the month of January, 1839, I com- 
 JL menced a meeting with the First Baptist church in Rochester, 
 N. Y., under the pastoral charge of Pharcellus Church. Many 
 of the saints of different denominations soon became interested 
 in the work, and continued to lift up united supplications to God 
 for a plentiful outpouring of his Spirit. Salvation began to 
 flow. The house soon became too small for the congregations, 
 and hundreds went away, night after night, unable to gain 
 admittance. After hundreds had been converted, the Lord was 
 pleased to break into the ranks of a gambling club, which held 
 its rendezvous at one of the hotels of the city. They gambled 
 night and day, and throughout the Sabbath. They practised 
 deception in their games, and were banded together to decoy the 
 unwary and fleece the inexperienced. They not unfrequently 
 took as much as three thousand dollars in one night. A horde 
 of lewd women was kept at this house, who were supported by 
 this gambling fraternity. Young men by scores were being 
 drawn into this whirlpool of destruction, and ruined in health, 
 in pocket, in reputation, and in morals ruined for time and 
 eternity. 
 
 One or two of this company were converted, who felt it to be 
 their duty to expose the secret machinations of this club (for
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 95 
 
 their abominations were not generally known, as they occupied 
 a dark room with double partitions) . I considered it to be my 
 duty to make known to the public the facts which had been dis- 
 closed to me. Accordingly, I gave notice to that effect. At 
 the appointed time the whole city seemed to have gathered 
 together. Thousands collected who could not enter the meet- 
 ing-house. Most of the leading gamblers managed, however, 
 to get in, having previously arranged, in case any secret was 
 likely to be disclosed, to break out in open contradictions and 
 blaspheming, until they should drown the voice of the speaker, 
 and disperse the meeting. Prayer-meetings were appointed at 
 different places, to be held at the same time, and earnest sup- 
 plications went up to God from many believing hearts. 
 
 My text was, "'The love of money is the root of all evil." 
 "When I came to speak on the subject of gambling, and began 
 to make some disclosures of the diabolical schemes of this soul- 
 destroying business, one of the leading gamblers rose up, and, 
 in distinct tones, exclaimed, " That is a d d lie." I immedi- 
 ately replied, " If you had kept still, sir, we should not have 
 known that you belonged to the gang ; a hit bird always flat- 
 ters ! " A gentleman, well known in the community, mentioned 
 the name of the gambler so audibly as to be heard by the entire 
 congregation. All eyes were fixed upon him. One of his com- 
 panions, sitting by his side, began to pull his cloak, saying, in a 
 low tone, " Sit down I sit down!" He sat down in the midst 
 of a profound silence, and covering his head with his cloak, 
 raised it no more until the service was closed. 
 
 I continued my sermon, and, with still greater pointedness 
 and force, exposed the enormity of this enterprise, and poured 
 forth the awful threatenings of Jehovah against evil doers. A 
 few evenings afterwards, notices were placarded in all the pub- 
 lic places, and on the corners of the streets, calling a meeting, 
 to be held on a certain evening, in front of the Baptist church, 
 for the purpose of considering the expediency of restraining " a 
 certain Mr. Knapp." " All the friends of order are invited 
 to be present." Evidently it was the design of the originators
 
 96 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 of this call to get together a lot of people of " the baser sort," 
 for the purpose of creating a riot. No arrangements were 
 made by the children of God to prevent it, beyond the appoint- 
 ment of prayer-meetings in various places. The evening 
 arrived ; the meeting-house was crowded to suffocation. From 
 the basement earnest prayers were offered unto v God, and from 
 the pulpit his word was preached to a solemn and deeply- 
 affected congregation. 
 
 In the mean time, a crowd of about a thousand men had 
 gathered around the building in separate groups. One company 
 was stationed in a back yard, armed with stones. At three 
 minutes before eight o'clock, a stone came whizzing through 
 the window towards the pulpit. Simultaneously with its pas- 
 sage came a flash of lightning, followed by a peal of thunder 
 (this was in the month of February, and snow was on the 
 ground). In about a minute afterwards, another stone came 
 through the window, accompanied by another flash of lightning, 
 and followed by a still louder clap of thunder. Scarcely had 
 another minute elapsed before another stone entered the build- 
 ing, when instantly the heavens pealed out its thunder more 
 terribly than before. The house where the people were assembled 
 was shaken, and the earth trembled beneath their feet. Fear 
 seized hold on the ungodly crew, and dropping their missiles, 
 they hastened from the spot, as if they would hide themselves 
 from the presence of God, lest he should " cut them off with a 
 stroke." 
 
 Shortly after I had retired for the night, the house of Deacon 
 Sage, where I lodged, was assailed, and several of the windows 
 were broken, but no one was injured. The work of the Lord 
 went on with increasing power ; and though the ungodly raged, 
 their counsels came to nought. A writ was served on Deacon 
 Sage because he had said that what I had asserted about these 
 gamblers was true. 
 
 The meeting at length came to a close, and I supposed that I 
 should be enabled to leave the city without annoyance. A large 
 company of friends had gathered at the house of Deacon Sage,
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 97 
 
 between eight and nine o'clock, for the purpose of spending a 
 season in farewell exercises of singing and prayer. Just as 
 myself and a few others, who were to accompany me, were 
 about to enter the stage, the agent called to inform us that 
 arrangements had been made by these landsharks to insult me 
 as I passed through the city. It appeared that it had been 
 arranged that a band of music in a carriage, drawn by six 
 horses, and a company of twenty men, headed by the chief 
 gambler as marshal, who, rigged out in regimentals, was to ride 
 a Avhite horse, should follow us out of the city playing and sing- 
 ing " The Rogue's March " as a special compliment to me. 
 They were already assembled in the yard of one of the hotels 
 by which we were to pass as we went to the stage office, and 
 on a given signal they were to sally forth. 
 
 The agent offered to convey us in a private wagon some ten 
 or twelve miles out of the city, but after a moment's reflection, 
 I told the company that I would not leave the city in any 
 evasive manner ; that I had done nothing of which I was 
 ashamed, and that if these wicked men saw fit to sing " The 
 Rogue's March," we would sing " Old Ship Zion." After sing- 
 ing and praying, and many tears, we entered the stage. As 
 we came round the corner on which stood the Monroe House, 
 the large gate was thrown wide open, and forth issued the 
 crowd of desperadoes, striking up their favorite tune. While 
 pausing in front of the stage office, a fierce, rough-looking man 
 stepped up to the stage, and asked if Mr. Kuapp was inside. 
 I replied, " I am the man." He then ordered me to get out of 
 the stage, without intimating in any way that he was a civil 
 officer, or had a civil process to serve on me. I gave him to 
 understand that I did not see any reason why I should comply 
 with his request. He became enraged, and his gang, rushing 
 round him, cried, " Hustle him out." 
 
 In a very few minutes thousands of persons had gathered to 
 the scene. The city was in an uproar. Many were my friends, 
 while others, who did not particularly sympathize with me, 
 were indignant at this great outrage against public order and
 
 98 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 decency. The man who had thus accosted me became furlong 
 at my resistance and the remonstrances of the citizens, and 
 putting one foot on the step and the other on the hind wheel of 
 the stage, reached into the coach, and seizing me by the throat, 
 attempted to drag me out. At this demonstration the uproar 
 beqame indescribable. Some encouraged him in his violence, 
 and some denounced him, while a company of pious women 
 called for a room in the hotel, and fell on their knees in prayer 
 to God. 
 
 At length some one informed me that my assailant was the 
 deputy sheriff. I thereupon informed him that I knew not that 
 he was a civil officer, and that if he would stand back and 
 behave himself like a man, I would get out of the stage and go 
 with him. He stepped back, and, getting out, I took his arm 
 and walked with him to his office. The crowd rushed along 
 with us, some before and some behind, some weeping and some 
 cursing, and some praying. On our way I took occasion to 
 warn the sheriff of the value of his soul, and entreated him to 
 be prepared for the summons which would soon call him before 
 the judgment seat of Christ. When we had reached the office, 
 I suggested that before "we proceed any further I thought we 
 had better spend a season in prayer. I fell on my knees, and 
 poured out my soul to God for this man and all his company. 
 The room was full of people ; some remained standing, some 
 knelt ; all were silent and solemn as eternity. 
 
 After serving the process upon me, Deacon Sage and Mr. 
 Smith (the mayor of the city) stepped forward and became 
 bail for my appearance at court. By this time the indignation 
 of the people had become so intense, that the owner of the 
 horses returned them to the stable, and thus the company was 
 broken up. I went back to the stage, and started quietly on my 
 way, counting it all joy that I was thought worthy to suffer for 
 the name of Christ. In all this scene of uproar and confusion 
 I felt calm, and enjoyed a sweet sense of the presence of God. 
 I was excited only by a feeling of tender compassion for the 
 poor deluded men who had sold themselves to the service of 
 Satan.
 
 ELDEU JACOB KNAPP. 99 
 
 In the October following, when my case was to be tried, I 
 had an engagement to attend a meeting in Baltimore. Some 
 thought I ought to meet my appointment, and some thought I 
 ought to meet the suit ; but after praying over the matter, I 
 concluded to leave the suit in the hands of the Lord, and to pro- 
 ceed on my Master's business. Accordingly, I went to Balti- 
 more ; and when it became known that I might not attend the 
 trial, my persecutors boasted great things, and entered into 
 secret combination to suborn testimony against me. Before, 
 however, the case came up, the judge was taken sick, and ad- 
 journed the court ; and before the next court sat, the plaintiff 
 was laid on a bed of sickness. Death stared him in the face ; 
 his conscience became troubled, and sending for Deacon Sage, 
 he confessed that my statements were true, and that the half had 
 not been told. About this time another of the company died an 
 awful death. The suit went by default, this company of gam- 
 blers was broken up, and many of its members left the city. 
 
 BALTIMORE. 
 
 The meeting in Baltimore was commenced on the 3d day 
 of October, 1839, in the Sharp Street Baptist church, under the 
 pastoral care of S. P. Hill. The number then professing the 
 Baptist faith in this city was small. Indeed, throughout the 
 State of Maryland, Baptists were very few and feeble. The 
 blighting curse of Antinomianism had well nigh effaced the 
 visibility of the Baptist name. The meeting had not been held 
 many days before the tokens of God's favor became manifest ; 
 still the interest did not rise very high until about the third 
 week. By this time, the waves of salvation began to sweep 
 with power along the tracks of the high and the low. During 
 seven weeks I preached two sermons every week day, and three 
 times on the Sabbath, and attended a prayer and inquiry meet- 
 ing in the morning and evening of each day. 
 
 The influence of this meeting was not confined to the city of 
 Baltimore. A new impulse was given to the Baptist denomina- 
 tion throughout the entire state ; so much so, that, according to
 
 100 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 the statistics reported at the next association, the number of 
 Baptists in the state had been doubled. Revivals broke out in 
 all parts of the surrounding country, and the tide of religious 
 feeling swept on even to Pittsburg, Pa., where, as I was after- 
 wards informed by letter, more than three hundred souls were 
 converted through agencies that had originated in this meeting 
 in Baltimore. 
 
 The Baptist church in Sharp Street, at the commencement of 
 the revival, was in debt for their house of worship to the 
 amount of twenty thousand dollars ; but very soon after the 
 meeting closed, such had been the strength of their increase, 
 that the indebtedness was at once removed, the edifice improved, 
 and for several years afterwards the contributions of the church, 
 for benevolent purposes, averaged over ten thousand dollars per 
 annum. 
 
 While in Baltimore I was invited to address the Young 
 Men's City Temperance Society. The lower part of the church 
 K'as crowded with men, and the galleries with ladies. In the 
 audience was a liquor dealer, who had come into the city for the 
 purpose of renewing his stock. He had purchased his supplies, 
 and his wagons were loaded ready for a start on the ensuing 
 morning. As he listened to my discourse, the awful character 
 of the business in which he was engaged was so profoundly 
 impressed on his conscience, that he returned the purchases he 
 had made, sent his teams back empty, and resolved henceforth 
 never to traffic in this business, so destructive of the well-being 
 of his fellow-men for this world and the next. 
 
 Another very peculiar providence of God occurred during this 
 meeting, illustrating the way in which God can make the wrath 
 of man to praise him. During the progress of the revival, 
 several well-known drunkards had been converted. This fact 
 had enraged the rum-sellers. On the evening in which I 
 preached on temperance, two men, named Mitchel and Hawkins, 
 together with other hard drinkers, were present. From the 
 church they went to a grog-shop, whose proprietor began to 
 indulge in outbursts of rage and cursing against me and my
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 101 
 
 preaching. After a while Mitchel got up, and declared that he 
 would not hear Mr. Knapp abused any longer ; that he believed 
 he was doing a great deal of good in the city ; and turning 
 towards the rum-seller, he remarked, " If you keep up this abuse 
 any longer, I will never drink another drop in your house, nor 
 anywhere else, as long as my name is Mitchel." But the enraged 
 proprietor continued to deal out his anathemas ; whereupon 
 Mitchel, true to his word, then and there solemnly pledged him- 
 self to absolute and total abstinence thenceforth through life. 
 Hawkins and others joined with him in the pledge. This was 
 the origin of the Washingtonian temperance movement, which 
 swept over the country with such wonderful power, and by 
 which tens of thousands of drunkards were reformed, and 
 thousands of families were made happy for this life and the life 
 to come. To God be all the glory ! 
 
 Throughout this revival my whole soul and my entire time 
 were absorbed, yea, wholly engrossed, in my work. I had but 
 little assistance. Brother Hill, the pastor, labored as exhaus- 
 tively as his enfeebled health would permit ; and besides him 
 there were only four brethren who engaged heartily and effi- 
 ciently in the movement. One of these passed to his rest while 
 in the midst of his toil. But " the Spirit of the Lord God was 
 upon me," and he made my strength equal to my day. My 
 mind was fruitful, my health was perfect, the weather was 
 favorable for the assembling of congregations, and the g )spcl 
 was " as a fire shut up in my bones." Never before did I so 
 fully understand the words of the Psalmist, " By thee I have 
 run through a troop, and by my God have I leaped over a v. all." 
 After laboring incessantly from early dawn till nearly midright, 
 when my day's work was finished, and my responsibility was 
 rolled off from me for the time being, I would feel as light as a 
 feather and as nimble as a deer. In fact I had to restrain my- 
 self, lest people should fail to understand the spirit that moved 
 me, as the daughter of Saul failed to understand David, when he 
 leaped and danced before the ark of the Lord. 
 
 After I had been preaching for some time in the city, anl the
 
 102 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF 
 
 entire people had been moved by the power of the truth, I began 
 to throw out allusions to the subject of slavery. The public 
 mind grew uneasy and feverish. One day a number of gentle- 
 men called at my boarding-place in my absence, and inquired 
 of the lady of the house, whether I was not " a downright 
 red-hot abolitionist from New England." She told them that 
 she presumed that Mr. Knapp was opposed to slavery, but was 
 not of that kind of abolitionists who would advise the slaves to 
 rise and cut the throats of their masters. 
 
 On going to the church that evening, I found the house 
 crowded at an early hour, and the yard and street filled with an 
 excited people. As I was about to ascend the pulpit stairs, a 
 good and influential brother took me by the arm, and asked me 
 if I could not satisfy mjt conscience by passing the subject of 
 slavery in silence, adding that there was much feeling on that 
 subject in the community. I told him that I thought not. It 
 was a warm night for the month of October ; the windows were 
 all up, and the mob was staring with piercing eyes on the 
 pulpit. A number of ministers were in the pulpit when I 
 entered it ; and two of them were skulking down behind the desk, 
 lest they should be hurt by any missiles that might be sent at 
 me. I gave one of them a jog, and told him to sit up, for he had 
 not religion enough to make him worthy of martyrdom yet ; 
 and then, turning to the mob, told them that when I entered the 
 ministry I pledged myself solemnly to preach up Christ and 
 preach down the devil ; to bear testimony against all evil in 
 everybody, and without respect of persons ; and that I should 
 do my duty if I knew they would kill me before I left the pul- 
 pit, and cut me into inch pieces, and roast every piece on a red- 
 hot gridiron ; and then I informed them of the mob which their 
 master had gotten up in Rochester, which God had scattered by 
 sending his thunder and lightning. They all quailed, and, 
 dropping their missiles, heard the sermon in quietness, and 
 went away peaceably. Had I taken this stand at the beginning 
 of my ministry there, they would have driven me out of the 
 city, or taken my life.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 103 
 
 In the winter of 1857 I was called to Baltimore again to 
 assist Dr. Fuller, and was then informed that about ten thou- 
 sand souls had been converted as the direct result of the former 
 revival ; that four hundred were added to the Sharp Street 
 Baptist church, and that five Baptist churches sprang from this 
 meeting ; that sixteen hundred were united to the Methodist 
 churches ; that hundreds of others joined the Episcopalian and 
 Presbyterian denominations. In fact persons, in whose judg- 
 ment I had confidence, assured me that nearly ten thousand 
 souls were supposed to have been converted in connection with 
 the agencies that took their rise from this revival. 
 
 On the occasion of my second visit in 1857, my success was 
 not so marked ; nevertheless, much good was done. Over one 
 hundred and fifty persons were baptized by Dr. Fuller during 
 the two months that I was there. 
 
 At this point it may be interesting to insert a letter from Dr. 
 Fuller, in which he kindly refers to my labors in Baltimore. 
 
 " BALTIMORE, November 23, 1866. 
 " REV. JACOB KNAPP. 
 
 " My dear Brother : I was in South Carolina during the 
 period of the blessed work of God in 1839 ; but some of the 
 noblest and most devoted children of God in the city, I know 
 from personal intimacy with them, were brought to Christ dur- 
 ing that revival. 
 
 " At a much later day you spent some weeks here, laboring 
 with the church of which I am pastor, and the Lord then blessed 
 your work and labor of love in the conversion of many souls. 
 
 " I found great spiritual enjoyment and profit from my 
 cooperation with you ; and all the church loved and esteemed 
 you most sincerely for your earnest, humble, and devoted piety, 
 and for your unwearied consecration to Jesus and his precious 
 truth. 
 
 " With sincere affection, 
 
 " Your friend and brother in the Lord Jesus, 
 
 "R. FULLER."
 
 104 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 CHAPTER XII. 
 
 ACCOUNTS OF PROTRACTED MEETINGS. 
 (CONTINUED.) 
 
 ALBANY : Apprehensions. Cooperation. Instances of Conversion. 
 
 Liberality and Revival. A Prodigal Son. A Stranger. 
 . The Shad Story. Preparation of the Grounds. State Street 
 
 Baptist Church. Unsuccessful Pastorate. NEW YORK CITY : 
 Baptist Tabernacle. A Wonderful Work. A Devoted Merchant. 
 
 New York Herald. An Infidel converted. A Magdalene. 
 The Church in Perplexity. Results. Statement of W. W. 
 Everts. HARTFORD : South Baptist Church. A candid Uni- 
 versalist. The Fiddler at a Ball. Zaccheus at a Baptism. 
 The Infidel Mocker. The Rum-seller and his Victim. NEW 
 HAVEN : Union Meetings. Yale College. A Gambling-house. 
 Plots, and God's Interpositions. The Billiard-room Kcepei's. 
 Students' Ball. Church Caution. Baptist Progress. 
 
 A T the close of my meeting in Baltimore, I commenced one 
 J\. with the Pearl Street Baptist church, Albany, N. Y., then 
 under the pastoral care of Elder B. T. Welch, for many years 
 acknowledged as preeminent among the eloquent preachers of 
 the country. The policy which this church had pursued differed 
 somewhat from mine. It had placed a value on the external ap- 
 pointments of a church, which I did not ; and I therefore had 
 some apprehensions whether my plain, outspoken style of 
 presenting the truth would be acceptable to such a congrega- 
 tion. 
 
 Very soon, however, the power of the Spirit of God was 
 made manifest, and the brethren entered heartily into the work. 
 Brother Welch labored with all the enthusiasm of his earnest 
 nature ; so much so, that sometimes I deemed it necessary to
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 105 
 
 restrain him, lest he should overtask his strength. Converts 
 were multiplied rapidly ; many of them were wealthy and 
 influential. 
 
 Among the trophies of grace then gathered, I may mention 
 the names of William Newton, James Wilson, Clark Durant, 
 Mrs. Governor Marcy ; and though the governor himself did not 
 openly profess religion, yet I have learned facts which satisfy 
 me that he was deeply impressed, and, I hope, really brought to 
 experience a change of heart. I heard that on one occasion, 
 while in a large company, a young man was berating me, when 
 Governor Marcy took up my defence, and, rising to his feet, 
 repeated the substance of one of my sermons with such effect, 
 that the tears flowed down his own cheeks and the cheeks of 
 many of his hearers. 
 
 As near as I can ascertain, about fifteen hundred persons 
 were added to the different churches of the city as the result of 
 this meeting. 
 
 While the meeting was in progress, I received a letter from 
 Dr. Nathaniel Kendrick, askiug me to raise some money in aid 
 of the Institution at Hamilton. I devoted a part of one after- 
 noon to this object, and obtained seven thousand dollars. As 
 an evidence of the relation of a revival to liberality, I may state 
 that I called on seven persons, asked each for one thousand 
 dollars, and was not refused in a single instance. 
 
 On one occasion, as I closed my sermon on " The Prodigal 
 Son," a well-known lawyer, Salem D., arose, faced the congre- 
 gation, and spoke substantially as follows : " I am that prodigal 
 son. I have spent my substance in riotous living. I am in 
 want. I will arise and go to my Father -not next week, nor 
 to-morrow, but now ! " and falling on his knees, he called on 
 God for mercy. And his heavenly Father " ran and fell on his 
 neck, and kissed him." 
 
 Another lawyer, from Greene County, being in the city, 
 
 came to hear me preach. He was deeply affected, though 
 
 he struggled to conceal his feelings. But his compunctious 
 
 followed him home. His wife noticed that something was 
 
 9
 
 106 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 the matter with him, and finally induced him to tell her of 
 the burden of his heart. Her heart responded to his, and they 
 both knelt in prayer to God. While they were calling on 
 him, he answered them, and they both rejoiced in the hope of 
 salvation. While I was preaching in New York city, some 
 time after this, he came to see me, and told me that when the 
 light of God's love first burst upon him, only the fear of being 
 thought crazy restrained him from going among his neighbors, 
 shouting, " Glory to God ! " 
 
 I learned some interesting facts concerning this meeting, of 
 which I was ignorant at the time it was in progress. 
 
 There was, in the outskirts of the city, a shop containing 
 some sixty or seventy men ; one of them came to hear me 
 preach, and, being somewhat of a wag, reported to his comrades 
 that a man was preaching in the Pearl Street Church, who had 
 said, that " it was as impossible for some sinners to go to 
 heaven, as it was for a shad to come up the North River tail 
 foremost, or climb up a greased barber's pole with a loaf of 
 bread in its mouth, and a barrel of mackerel under its fin." 
 This canard excited their curiosity, and so they resolved to 
 come and hear a man who talked in that strain. But they 
 heard nothing about shad. They heard God's truth, and before 
 long thirty of the men professed their faith in Christ. My 
 authority for this statement is Deacon Richardson, of Elizabeth 
 City, N. J., who was himself one of the number. 
 
 As the results of this revival, about five hundred persons 
 were added to the two Baptist churches of the city. Afterwards, 
 brother- Raymond and brother Swan held meetings in the city, 
 and God greatly blessed their labors. I do not claim exclusive 
 credit as the sole agent whom God was pleased to employ iu 
 bringing about these precious blessings. Brother Welch had 
 gathered about him many families of high standing, who, though 
 attracted at first by his wonderful eloquence, had received per- 
 manent impressions of gospel truth. This class my ministry 
 would never have drawn ; but being there, and prepared to 
 receive the truth, God was pleased to make my preaching
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 107 
 
 effectual to the salvation of many of them. Thus God works 
 by different agents, and accomplishes one kind of result by one 
 man, and a different one by another. 
 
 Not long after the revival in this city had closed, S. M. Fish 
 and William Newton proposed to build another meeting-house, 
 on condition that I would promise to open it with a protracted 
 meeting. I consented to do so. The building was at once 
 erected. It was located on State Street, near the Capitol. I 
 preached the dedication sermon, and commenced a protracted 
 meeting. The Master smiled on the effort. I baptized about 
 two hundred converts, who, together with a few from the other 
 churches, were organized, and recognized under the name of the 
 State Street Baptist church. 
 
 The new church was very anxious to have me become its 
 pastor. In compliance with their request, I subsequently re- 
 moved my family to Albany, and remained in charge of the 
 church one whole year. But I soon found that I could not do 
 justice to the work of a pastor and of an evangelist at the same 
 time. Moreover, God did not seem to smile on the undertaking. 
 The church did not continue to prosper under my pastoral 
 services as much as the blessings, which had attended my labors 
 as an evangelist, had led it to expect. I have always thought 
 since, that God intended to drive me out of the pastorate, and 
 to shut me up to the one work of an evangelist. 
 
 NEW YORK CITY. 
 
 As soon as my meeting in Albany, in the winter of 1840, 
 closed, I went to the city of New York. I preached in the 
 Baptist Tabernacle, a building erected for Dr. Maclay, in 
 Mulberry Street, near Chatham Square. This church was 
 then in its infancy, and had just called W. W. Everts to 
 become its pastor. I boarded with Deacon William Colgate, 
 who became my warm and fast friend. He was a good man, 
 full of faith and of the Holy Spirit. The house of worship 
 being very large, and being centrally located, I had a fine op- 
 portunity of reaching the masses of the city. Very soon tie
 
 108 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 house was filled to its utmost capacity, the aisles being crowded, 
 the porches jammed, and the sidewalks overrun with people. 
 
 The power of God came down on the people wondrously. 
 The old stereotyped prayers gave place to the most earnest and 
 solemn pleadings with God for the salvation of souls. The 
 ancient traditions of having converts come before a committee, 
 and wait a mouth before they could be baptized, was made to 
 yield to the apostolic example. For a considerable time the 
 members of the church would meet in the basement for the 
 purpose of listening to experiences, while I was up stairs talking 
 with the anxious. As fast as they found peace in believing 
 with all their hearts, I sent them below to present themselves 
 to the church. Sometimes there were thirty or forty persons 
 who thus presented themselves on an evening. On one occa- 
 sion, the lamented Deacon Colgate, in his humorous way, took 
 me to task for sending the converts faster than the church could 
 receive them. Brother Everts and myself baptized ninety-six 
 in one day ; and so the work went on for ten weeks, day and 
 night, without any cessation. 
 
 I generally preached at three o'clock P. M., and half past 
 seven o'clock in the evening. The time from four to five 
 o'clock, and from nine to ten and a half o'clock, was spent in 
 prayer and conference exercises. 
 
 The whole city was moved. Business men would come in 
 during the day and spend a little while, and come again in the 
 evening. Very many of them were converted. More than 
 four hundred persons were baptized into the fellowship of this 
 church ; and when it was fourteen months old, it had seven 
 hundred members. Very soon the church bought the Presby- 
 terian Church in Laight Street, and set off a colony. The 
 pastor went with the new interest. 
 
 A lady persuaded her husband, who "was a wealthy merchant, 
 and an attendant on the Episcopal church, to come one evening 
 to the meeting. During the sermon he became so deeply 
 interested, that at its close he repaired to the lecture-room, roso 
 for prayers, and went to his house rejoicing in the hope of
 
 ELDER JACOB KXAPP. 109 
 
 pardon. lie was soon afterwards baptized and added to the 
 church. This man was so completely absorbed in the great 
 things of the kingdom, that he gave up all attention to his 
 worldly business for one year, and devoted himself to the one 
 concern of saving souls. 
 
 The New York Herald sent a reporter to our meetings, who 
 pretended to furnish an account of the services for each morn- 
 ing's issue. Anxious to make a sensation, so as to procure 
 sales of the paper, he would give caricature accounts of all 
 that transpired, making burlesque descriptions of the person of 
 brother Everts and of myself, and of the administration of the 
 ordinance of baptism, and setting forth perverted and distorted 
 statements of my language. The boys would " hawk " the 
 paper through the streets, crying, " Elder Knapp and the tariff." 
 In this way the meeting was advertised among a class who 
 otherwise might have never heard of it, for at that time this 
 paper circulated very widely, if not exclusively, among persons 
 who never attended, the house of God. But by this means 
 infidels, gamblers, drunkards, and libertines were excited with 
 curiosity to see and hear a man, concerning whom the Herald 
 was making so much ado. Many of them, who " came to 
 scoff, remained to pray." 
 
 I recollect an instance of an infidel, who had not attended 
 a church in ten years, and had taken an oath that he never 
 would, ratifying it with a wish that, if he ever should, the roof 
 might fall on him and kill him on the spot. But despite his 
 oath he was constrained to come. He was seated well forward 
 in the middle aisle ; the house was packed, and the audience as 
 quiet and solemn as eternity. The speaker, instead of saying 
 the funny things that had been reported of him, presented the 
 truths of God and a future life with warnings and entreaties. 
 The man looked on either side of him, and found the people 
 melted iuto tears ; he looked up to see if the roof was falling in ; 
 he looked back to see if there was a possibility of getting out, 
 but the jam was too close. He was compelled to remain. His 
 sins rolled up before him, and he sat trembling like an aspeu
 
 110 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 leaf. At the close of the sermon, he went down into the lecture- 
 room, rose for prayers, and was converted before he left the 
 house. Thus we see why the devil and wicked men live. 
 Their wrath is made to praise God ; but for the devil and the 
 service of the New York Herald, hundreds who were converted 
 would not have been reached. No religious notices, no en- 
 treaties of Christian friends, could have brought them to the 
 house of God. 
 
 One woman of ill repute professed conversion in this meeting, 
 and presented herself to the church for admission. Mauy voted 
 against receiving her, especially the sisters. A committee was 
 appointed to wait upon her. They became satisfied of the 
 genuineness of her conversion. In reporting the case to the 
 church, Deacon Colgate, who was on the committee, remarked, 
 " Brethren, we have got ourselves into difficulty, and I do not 
 see how to get out of it. We have been praying the Lord to 
 convert sinners ; we did not tell him whom to convert, and he 
 has converted one whom we do not want." All felt themselves 
 rebuked, and voted unanimously to receive her. She proved to 
 be a consistent and exemplary follower of Christ. 
 
 Deacon Colgate very justly remarked, that " under my 
 labors thousands were converted from among a class of the 
 wicked who belonged to families in which were no helps to 
 piety. Rather, such converts were exposed to every influence 
 calculated to draw them away, while those who professed faith 
 under ordinary means, were usually those whose education had 
 been moral and religious ; whose families were pious, or, at 
 least, attended church, while they themselves, perhaps, had 
 been nurtured in the Sunday school." 
 
 I am unable to give an accurate account of the numbers who 
 professed piety in this meeting. Hundreds united with other 
 churches, Baptist and Pedo-baptist. But among the trophies of 
 grace were quite a number of prominent merchants and young 
 persons, who are now pillars in the church of God. Several 
 young men gave themselves to preparation for the ministry ; 
 among whom I remember brother H. Harvey, since eminent
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. Ill 
 
 as' a pastor aud a professor of biblical literature ; brother A. C. 
 Buckbee, now a secretary of the American Bible Union ; brother 
 James 8. Dickerson, now pastor of the First Baptist church iu 
 Pittsburg. 
 
 Under date of November 29, 1866, brother W. W. Everts, 
 of Chicago, wrote me the following statement regarding the 
 meeting in the Tabernacle church in New York : 
 
 " Elder Jacob Knapp commenced his labors in the Tabernacle 
 Baptist church in February, 1840, at a crisis in the history of 
 the Baptist denomination iu New York, and his labors con- 
 tributed much to mark that crisis. 
 
 " The revival measures that had obtained throughout the 
 state for many years, and especially since 1830, had been 
 distrusted, especially by the leading Baptist churches of the 
 city. The late Deacon Colgate, studying with great interest 
 the revivals of the country, became increasingly anxious to take 
 more effective means to promote them in the city. A chief 
 reason for uniting with others in founding the Tabernacle church, 
 out of the old Mulberry Street church, was, to try more vigorous 
 means to promote revivals, and bring the gospel to bear upon 
 the masses. 
 
 " After a few mouths of supplies, the writer was called as 
 the first pastor of the Tabernacle Baptist church, and became at 
 once connected with the spirit and aims of the new movement. 
 Considerable interest was at once awakened. Through the 
 autumn aud early winter considerable numbers were added to 
 the church, both by letter and baptism. 
 
 u In these circumstances, and to carry out views entertained 
 in the constitution of the new church, Elder Knapp commenced 
 his labors. In the course of that meeting, continuing several 
 weeks, hundreds were added to the church. Nr r did any serious 
 reaction or discouragement follow that revival. Large numbers 
 \vere added the following years ; so that in three years the 
 membership of the church rose from over three hundred to over 
 nine hundred.
 
 112 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 " This progress of the Tabernacle church encouraged revival 
 measures and church extension throughout the city. The 
 Laight Street church grew out of the Tabernacle church. 
 Fruits of that revival are now recognized as leading members 
 of many churches in New York and vicinity, and throughout 
 the country. * The old church herself has continued in the 
 direction and greatness of her influence from the impulses of 
 that period and revival. And the most efficient membership 
 of that church, from that day to this, have looked back to that 
 time, as the period of ' the right hand of the Most High.' 
 
 " W. W. EVERTS." 
 
 HART-FORD. 
 
 In the month of December, 1840, I visited Hartford, Ct. 
 As soon as I had stepped out of the stage-coach, and put my 
 foot on the pavement of its streets, I felt myself moved by a 
 strong conviction that the Lord had " much people " to be 
 gathered in this place, and that he intended to make my labors 
 effectual in the accomplishment of a great work. 
 
 I commenced services with the South Baptist church, and 
 boarded, during most of my stay, in the family of brother Albert 
 Day. The power of God was very soon made manifest amongst 
 us. Saints got up out of the way of sinners, and sinners came 
 rushing into the kingdom. Brother Eaton, pastor of the North 
 Baptist church, came and labored with us, and large accessions 
 were made to both of the churches. 
 
 Hartford, at this time, was a stronghold of the Universalists, 
 many of whom were converted. Among these I may make 
 mention of the case of Mr. B. He was a candid man, and 
 enjoyed the respect of the community. He came quite fre- 
 quently to hear me preach. He was present on the evening on 
 which I preached on the subject of IJniversalism ; and so im- 
 pressed was he with the statements I made, that he went home 
 and promised the Lord that he would reexamine the subject 
 more thoroughly, and that if he found his views to be false, he 
 would renounce them. He opened his Bible at once, and spent
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 113 
 
 most of the night in reading afresh those passages which he had 
 been accustomed to regard as proof-texts of the Universalist 
 doctrine. He was astonished to find that they failed utterly to 
 support the theory. He came to church on the following even- 
 ing. My text on that occasion was, " Choose ye this day whom 
 ye will serve." At the close of the sermon he arose, and turn- 
 ing round to the congregation, he exclaimed, " As for me and 
 my house, we will serve the Lord." As he spoke, a wonderful 
 change came over his countenance, and his face became radiant 
 with joy. Turning to me, he said, " Last night I hoped that 
 some one would throw you into the river, or get you out of the 
 way somehow ; but to-night I feel as though I could hug you ! " 
 Shortly afterwards he was baptized. He proved to be a con- 
 sistent and useful member of the church. 
 
 The person who had been engaged to play on a bass viol at 
 the opening of the services, was expecting, on one occasion, to 
 leave the church during service for the purpose of performing 
 on the fiddle at a ball. It was known to us that this amuse- 
 ment was set down for that evening, and much prayer was 
 offered that God would arrest its progress. At the appointed 
 time the musician left the church, and entering the ball-room, 
 lie informed the manager that Elder Knapp had just been pray- 
 ing that " the right arm of the fiddler might be palsied, and 
 that the music might sound like the shrieks and groans of the 
 damned in the vaults of hell." The fiddler took his stand, and 
 the company arranged themselves on the floor ; but before the 
 first set was half through, the fiddler was seized with a tremor, 
 and his arm fell palsied by his side. The music ceased, and 
 turning to the manager, he exclaimed, " I am under conviction. 
 My restoration doctrines will not serve me. I am resolved to 
 seek the salvation of my soul, and I advise you all to do the 
 same." The ball was broken up. The fiddler and the manager 
 came directly over to the church. The musician made known 
 his case, and was converted on the spot. Many of the young 
 people came from the ball-room also, and very soon found tha 
 Savior.
 
 114 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 Whenever a professed Universalist was converted, the other 
 Universalists were accustomed to say that he was not a real 
 Uuiversalist. Finally, the brethren challenged them to select 
 out one whom they would acknowledge to be sound in their 
 faith. They made choice of one, and instantly the brethren 
 united in making him a subject of special prayer to God. The 
 result was, that he too came out and renounced Universalism, 
 and gave his heart to God. 
 
 On one occasion, as I was baptizing some converts in the 
 river, a young man climbed up a tree, and took his position on 
 a branch that stretched out over the spot where I was standing 
 with the candidates. I prayed that God would speak to that 
 " Zaccheus," and make him come down, and that he would 
 abide in his house. On the following Lord's day he was bap- 
 tized in the same place. 
 
 At one time, as I was preaching, a young man began to draw 
 my portrait on the back of a pew. All of a sudden his hand 
 was seized with* palsy, so that he was unable to lift it. He 
 came out for prayers, and was hopefully brought to Christ. 
 
 A company of infidels were chopping wood near the city, and 
 every evening one of them would come to meeting, and report 
 the proceedings to his associates on the next morning, as a 
 matter of amusement and ridicule. Once, as he repeated the 
 sermon with comments, and was about to go through a prayer, 
 something seemed to speak to him in audible tones, saying, 
 " You wicked wretch ! " His axe dropped from his hands, and 
 he fell helpless to the ground. He was carried to his home, 
 and brother Eaton was sent for to pray for him. He became a 
 penitent and pardoned man. 
 
 One day, as I was passing by a rum-shop, the keeper of the 
 establishment was dragging a poor, drunken creature out of his 
 cellar, and kicking him into the gutter. I turned round, looked 
 the rum-seller in the face, and exclaimed, " Where am I? Is 
 this hell, and are these devils? Is this the way they treat each 
 other?" I related this circumstance in public. The rum-seller 
 was enraged, and swore that he would be revenged. He was
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 115 
 
 about to be married, and the arrangements were all made for 
 the ceremony. He collected a crowd, and started for the church 
 with the avowed purpose of breaking up the meeting. On his 
 way he was taken sick ; he lingered a short time, and on the 
 day appointed for his wedding, he was a corpse. 
 
 During my stay here, the South church called brother E. 
 Turney to be its pastor. I preached his ordination sermon. 
 
 NEW HAVEN. 
 
 I closed my meeting in Hartford on one evening, and com- 
 menced another in New Haven on the next. There was then 
 only one Baptist church in the city, and it was small and feeble. 
 Brother T. C. Teasdale was its pastor. 
 
 The Lord owned and blessed his truth during this effort, and 
 made the gospel the power of God unto the salvation of very 
 many. Christians of all denominations came in, and took a 
 deep interest in the progress of the work. Dr. Taylor, pro- 
 fessor of theology, attended, and was heard to say, that he 
 " thanked God that the gospel was being preached so faithfully." 
 The students of Yale College were quite constant in their at- 
 tendance ; of these, seventy-one were converted. At the close 
 of the meeting, they sent me a letter containing all their names, 
 and one hundred and twenty dollars as a personal testimonial. 
 
 At first some thought that the interests of the cause would 
 be better promoted by holding an additional meeting in connec- 
 tion with, and for the sake of, the students. Accordingly, the 
 services of Dr. Kirk were obtained. But he had scarcely 
 reached the ground, before he recognized the importance of 
 maintaining an undivided interest. He, therefore, together with 
 nearly all the professors, came to my meeting, and rendered 
 hearty cooperation in conducting it. And I am bound to say, 
 that seldom, if ever, have I found a more noble, unsectarian 
 class of Christians, than were the Congregationalists of New 
 Haven. Their piety, liberal-mindedness, p^d intelligence, won 
 my highest admiration and affection. 
 
 In this city there was a noted gambling-house, to which, as I
 
 116 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 learned, many of the ungodly students resorted ; especially the 
 high bloods from the South. I regarded it my duty to expose 
 this den of iniquity, and warn all against it. This exposure 
 brought out several of the students, and all the hard characters 
 of the city. Thirty-eight of the students entered into a solemn 
 covenant that they would break up the meeting at the risk of 
 their lives. 
 
 Arming themselves with clubs, bowie-knives, and other instru- 
 ments of death, they came into the church, and stationed them- 
 selves in different parts of the house some in the gallery and 
 some below. As soon as the congregation was dismissed, they 
 undertook to keep the people from going out. They blocked up 
 the aisles, and refused to give way, resisting the pressure by a 
 display of clubs and threats of assault. 
 
 I requested them to stand aside and let the people pass ; but 
 they stood their ground, and brandished their weapons. I then 
 called for the tithing-men (as the law of the state required). 
 As soon as these officers began to appear, the -students cried 
 out, "Yale! Yale I " (the sign word agreed upon), when 
 instantly those in the galleries threw themselves over its breast- 
 works, and slid down the pillars into the crowd below. A 
 sharp scuffle ensued, and very shortly law and order prevailed. 
 Some of the mob were carried off to the watch-house, were 
 tried the next day, and fined. 
 
 After this, for four or five nights in succession, a mob would 
 form on the college-green, and come down to the church about 
 the time of dismissing the congregation. They avowed their 
 purpose to kill me, and on several occasions I went to my 
 lodgings surrounded by a body-guard. On one evening I ex- 
 changed cloaks with a brother, and passed out before many of 
 the congregation had left the church. On my way home alone, 
 I met several hundreds of the mob. Those in advance asked 
 me if the meeting was out. I replied, " Yes ; and unless you 
 look sharp, Knapp will be gone." They started on the -run, 
 and I went quietly to my room. 
 
 The mob was finally broken up by the following remarkable
 
 ELDER JACOB KXAPP. 117 
 
 providence. One of them, had sent me -an abusive letter, 
 threatening my life if I did not leave the city. On the evening 
 of the day in which I received it, a number of the desperadoes 
 came into the sanctuary, and seated themselves in the gallery. 
 Shortly after I had commenced preaching, a rifle-ball was 
 thrown at me ; but hitting the shade of the lamp, it was turned 
 out of its course. Some thought that it had been shot from an 
 air-gun, but the possibility is, that it was thrown by hand. 
 Brother Teasdale immediately arose, and read to the congrega- 
 tion the letter referred to. This letter called me " the 
 prince of liars," because I had related publicly how God had 
 broken up the mob in Rochester by sending thunder and light- 
 ning ; and challenged a repetition of the scene. Deacon Sage, 
 of Rochester, who was providentially present, rose and corrobo- 
 rated my statement. No sooner had silence been regained, 
 than a flash of terrific lightning blazed through the house, fol- 
 lowed by awful peals of thunder and torrents of rain. This 
 marvellous coincidence effectually dispersed the mob. 
 
 Nevertheless, the thirty-eight who had banded themselves 
 together to break up the meeting, did not abandon their purpose. 
 They changed their tactics. They arranged to gain access to 
 my lodgings, and, disguised, to seize me, gag me, and putting 
 me into a carriage, to carry me into the woods, and there 
 deliberate as to what further course should be pursued. But 
 one of their number was seized with convictions, which led him 
 to reveal to me the plot. Several of the brethren resolved to 
 stand guard each night. The desperadoes, learning -that the 
 house was well protected, resorted to stratagem. One night, 
 after I had retired, the footsteps of a man were heard clamping 
 on the sidewalk. In a moment the door-bell was pulled with 
 great violence. Occupying a front room, I opened the window, 
 and asked what was wanted. A man at the door replied that 
 he wanted to see Mr. Knapp. I said, " I am the man." He 
 remarked that " a person, some little distance off, was under 
 deep conviction, and wanted Mr. Knapp to come right away 
 and pray for him." I tcld him to " tell the man that he must
 
 118 AUTOBIOG2APHY OP 
 
 pray for himself, or he would go right down to hell." I under- 
 stood the plot at an instant, and learned, on the day following, 
 that a carriage was in readiness, and a company of men, to 
 carry me away, and that this man had been paid one dollar to 
 decoy me out of the house. 
 
 After this, two of the gang were converted, and one of them 
 told me that " it seemed to him that he could not be happy even 
 in heaven, in view of the many souls he had already sent to 
 hell." He had kept a depository for the sale of infidel 
 books, and had -engaged actively in every effort to disseminate 
 the poison of error. 
 
 The two men whose billiard-i-oom I exposed, soon became 
 interested in the meeting. One of them, T., came forward for 
 prayers, in the spirit of derision, having been hired to do so. I 
 had been told of his intention, and kneeling down near to him, 
 I prayed for him very earnestly. In my prayer, I described 
 the character of a gambler, and spoke of him as one " who, 
 though once having a kind heart, could harden himself until he 
 got past all feeling until he could even gamble on the grave 
 of his father, or on the coffin of his wife." This allusion 
 troubled him, for he had recently buried his wife. At the close 
 of the service he came to me, and asked " how much I wanted 
 for my prayer," and offered to pay me handsomely if I would 
 give him a report of it. This poor man was undoubtedly under 
 serious impressions, and alarmed by apprehensions. When I 
 took the boat for New York, he came to the wharf to bid me 
 good by, and wept when I gave him my hand. 
 
 The other partner, Mr. B., professed conversion, and gave 
 me a history which went to my heart. When he came to New 
 Haven his family stood high in social position, being on inti- 
 mate terms with that of Dr. Dwight. But yielding to his 
 passion for gambling and strong drink, he had dragged his wife 
 and children down to poverty and disgrace. How painful, alas ! 
 ihat we cannot retrace our steps, nor rid ourselves of the conse- 
 quences of our wrong-doing ! These consequences are not con-
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 119 
 
 fined to the wrong-doer, but they involve his family from genera- 
 tion to generation. 
 
 While the meeting was in progress, the time arrived for 
 holding the annual ball of the Junior Class in college, but 
 owing to the great interest on the subject of religion, it was 
 put off. Soon after I left, however, a meeting was called, and 
 arrangements were made, and the time appointed for it. It 
 was said by one of them, that " the ball should come off in 
 spite of Knapp, the devil, or the Almighty ! " But one of the 
 managers was taken sick suddenly, and died. On the day 
 appointed for the ball, his schoolmates followed him to the 
 grave. 
 
 The Baptists in this place had fallen into the habit (quite 
 common elsewhere) of requiring their candidates for member- 
 ship to undergo a sort of probation before being baptized. 
 They must first go before the deacons, or a committee, for ex- 
 amination, and then must wait a while before they related their 
 experience to the church. Multitudes of converts were thus 
 kept waiting for baptism. 
 
 Finding that the church were disposed to cling to their usage, 
 brother Teasdale and myself came to the conclusion to tell them 
 that we should carry out our commission, and that they could 
 take them into their church, or leave them to go to other 
 churches, as they might choose. Whereupon the church an- 
 nulled their former resolution, and voted to receive the candi- 
 dates on their experience. Several hundred candidates were 
 baptized ; though how many I am unable to state, as no record 
 Avas kept. As the result of this work of grace, the Baptist 
 cause was greatly strengthened ; and socially, numerically, and 
 financially, the Baptist interest has been much greater in this 
 stronghold of Pedo-baptist Congregationalism since, than it ever 
 was before.
 
 120 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 CHAPTER XIII. 
 
 ACCOUNTS OF PKOTEACTED MEETINGS. 
 (CONTINUED.) 
 
 NEW BEDFORD: A Revival in the Summer. A Caviller. Power 
 of Endurance. Earnestness. PROVIDENCE : Want of Coopera- 
 tion. Dr. Wayland. Trial of Faith. Increase of Interest. 
 Lawsuit. Results. BOSTON: Five Churches United. Arduous 
 Labors. Plain Preaching. Opposition. Anxiety. Protests. 
 
 A Mob. A Passage of Scripture. Eagerness for Salvation. 
 
 Closing Meetings. Disparagement. Personal Detraction. 
 J. D. Fulton's Account. 
 
 IN the month of June, 1841, I visited New Bedford. The 
 Baptist church was then under the care of brother Henry 
 Jackson. 
 
 It was sneeringly remarked by some one, that we could do 
 nothing in the summer ; that our God was the God of the 
 winter, and not of the summer. But the meeting had not pro- 
 gressed far before the pastor and myself were sent for to pray 
 for this same person. We found him in deep distress, in view 
 of his guilt and danger, for he had found out that our God was 
 not only God of the summer and of the winter alike, but also 
 the Judge of the quick and the dead. We remained with him 
 for some time, and poured out our souls in prayer, and left him 
 with a trembling hope in the pardoning mercy of God. His 
 love and light continued to increase, and he became a professed 
 follower of Christ. 
 
 Our meeting went on day and night, in increasing power, for 
 about six weeks. Many were converted. Only a very little 
 opposition was manifested, and all denominations took part in 
 the good work.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 121 
 
 Mr. and Mrs. Howard, wealthy members of the Episcopal 
 church, invited rny eldest daughter to spend a year in their 
 family, and attend the Female Seminary with their daughters. 
 The invitation was gratefully accepted. 
 
 During this meeting a gentleman of marked independence of 
 character was awakened by the death of his wife. Shortly 
 before her last moment, she was told that she could not recover. 
 Immediately she sprang from her bed resisting all efforts to 
 restrain her and falling on her face, cried, with her expiring 
 breath, " O Lord Jesus, have mercy on my poor soul ! " This 
 man came into our meeting, anxious to become a Christian, but 
 could not be induced to take the seat assigned to the inquirers. 
 I asked him " why he declined." He said " it would do him 
 no good." I told him " it might help to subdue his pride, and 
 overcome the fear of man." He answered, " There is not the 
 man on earth of Avhom I stand in fear." I replied, " Friend R., 
 I will give you a problem to solve : you find a strong reluctance 
 to taking this step, and you say it is not pride nor the fear of 
 man that keeps you back : please tell me, to-morrow, what 
 it is that restrains you." The next day he told me he had 
 solved the problem ; that I was right ; that he did fear man 
 more than he feared his Maker. That evening he came out for 
 prayers, and found Jesus at once. 
 
 The weather was warm, and my labors intense. The people 
 were amazed, and wondered how I met the demands made upon 
 my strength. But I have always found the truth of the promise, 
 " As thy days are, so shall thy strength be." Worldly people 
 have been often at a loss to know how Christian women, for 
 instance, can attend to all their household affairs, keep every- 
 thing in order, take care of company, and go to meeting day and 
 night for months together, and yet keep as bright and cheerful 
 as a lark. It is really surprising what a small amount of 
 sleep and food we can get along with, and how much we can 
 endure, when we are filled with the Spirit. Machinery well 
 oiled can be run day and night for years together with but 
 little friction. 
 
 10
 
 122 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 While preaching one Sunday morning in this meeting, I 
 became so absorbed in my subject, and so earnest in its delivery, 
 that my daughter rose up in her seat, extending her arms to 
 catch me, as she thought I was surely coming over the pulpit. 
 At the same time I ruptured a blood-vessel near the centre of 
 the eye, and a blood spot remained in sight for a considerable 
 time. 
 
 I found brother Jackson a kind-hearted, generous man, who 
 entered into the spirit of the meeting with all his heart. 
 
 PROVIDENCE. 
 
 I began my labors in the city of Providence, R. I., about the 
 1st of November, 1841. I was called to the field by the Third 
 Baptist church, of which brother T. C. Jamieson was then 
 pastor. The other Baptist churches did not, as a whole, cooperate 
 with us in this effort. But different brethren of the various 
 churches came in gradually, one after the other, until the pre- 
 judices of nearly all were overcome. Some held out to the last ; 
 and in this regard, I felt the difference between the treatment 
 I received here from persons of high distinction, and that which 
 I had received from persons in similar positions in Schenectady 
 and New Haven. In Providence I had no cooperation nor 
 favor from such. 
 
 Dr. Wayland came in and heard me preach once ; but I suspect 
 that he was not very favorably impressed ; for I was merely 
 giving a sort of talk to the church, and withal his presence 
 embarrassed me. Nevertheless, I was glad to learn that, in his 
 instructions to his pupils as to the right kind of preaching, his 
 views came nearer to my style of sermonizing, than to that of 
 any other man. And, certainly, many of his published writings 
 are in perfect harmony with what I have preached for thirty- 
 five years ; especially do I consider his sermon on The Apostolic 
 Ministry as a model presentation of the gospel method of dis- 
 seminating the truths of salvation. I have rarely come across 
 the writings of any man from which I have derived more 
 pleasure and profit.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 123 
 
 For a time everything looked dark. Our faith was put to a 
 severe test. I remember that one evening as brother Jamieson 
 and I stood on the hill which overlooks the city, we recon- 
 noitred the forces that seemed to be against us. There were 
 in sight of us the First and Pine Street Churches, with their 
 great resources of influence, if not openly opposing, at least 
 withholding their sympathies, and practically giving us the cold 
 shoulder. And in positive array, on the devil's side, were the 
 Unitarian and Universalist churches, together with that motley 
 crowd of the ungodly who disclaimed association with any 
 religious society. I felt the cold chills running up and down 
 my back, and hastened to my room, and sought a renewal of 
 my strength in prayer. My constant cry was, " O Lord, gird 
 us up for this conflict , let not our faith fail ; put the whole 
 sacramental host in battle array against the powers of darkness, 
 and let thy great name be honored in the salvation of thousands 
 of souls ! " 
 
 I soon found that as long as my eye was fixed on Christ, 
 there was no danger of my sinking ; but as soon as it was 
 turned on the waves that pressed around me, I began to go 
 down. It was not long before the work broke out with great 
 power. New conquests were made every day, and public 
 opinion began to change rapidly in my favor. The doors of the 
 Pine Street Baptist church were at length thrown open to me, 
 and the house became thronged at once with the multitudes who 
 were eager to hear the words of life. Many of the members of 
 Congregational and Episcopal churches came in with us, and 
 the work extended over the city. 
 
 The Universalists, as usual, became very much enraged. A 
 good brother gave me some information, which I repeated from 
 the pulpit, concerning a woman in that city, which further inves- 
 tigation proved to be incorrect, to the extent that they related to 
 her husband instead of to herself. A wealthy and revengeful 
 Universalist took the matter up, and induced the woman to 
 commence a suit against me. It was privately arranged among 
 " the fellows of the baser sort " to have the summons served on
 
 124 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF 
 
 me in the church, after the people had mostly gone, so as to 
 give me no opportunity to get bail, in order that they might 
 have the satisfaction of sending me to jail over night. Accord- 
 ingly, on the appointed evening, just as we were dismissing the 
 second service, the deputy sheriff, in company with a ruffianly 
 crowd, came in. As they attempted to force their way up the 
 aisles, through the congregation that was going out, great con- 
 fusion and uproar ensued. The sheriff was summoned to take 
 care of his own company, and keep the peace. In the mean 
 time I quietly slipped out, and went to my lodgings. On my 
 way I met a gang of rowdies, and I experienced a repetition of 
 the scene which occurred, under similar circumstances, in 
 New Haven. In a short time I was called upon by the sheriff, 
 in company with several Baptist and Congregational brethren, 
 who went my bail. Afterwards I regretted that I gave bail : 
 it would certainly have been more apostolic to have gone to 
 jail, and I should have been brought into closer sympathy with 
 the experiences of Paul and Silas, who had blessed seasons of 
 meditation, prayer, and pjaise. 
 
 When the time came for the case to be tried I was doing a 
 great work in Salem, Mass. I wrote to my friends that I 
 could not leave it to attend the suit, unless they felt it to be 
 imperatively important, but that I would leave the matter in 
 their hands, and hold myself responsible for any settlement 
 they might make. The affair was finally settled by the pay- 
 ment of one hundred dollars. 
 
 Before I left Providence scores of souls were converted to 
 God. Twenty-three husbands, whose wives were members of 
 the Third Baptist church, were converted and baptized. 
 
 < 
 BOSTON. 
 
 In the latter part of December, 1841, I went to Boston, in 
 response to the invitation of nearly all the Baptist pastors in 
 the city. I preached in the First Baptist church, then and 
 now under the pastoral care of brother Rollin H. Neale ; in 
 the Baldwin Place Baptist church, of which brother Baron
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 125 
 
 Stow was then pastor ; in the Bowdoin Square Baptist church, 
 whose pastor was brother R. W. Cushman ; in the Harvard 
 Street Baptist church, brother Robert Turubull, pastor, and in the 
 Tremont Street church, over whose services brother Nathaniel 
 Colver presided. The people of brother Colver's church mingled 
 their prayers and tears with us, but their audience-room was, at 
 that time, so small, that we could use it only for inquiry-meet- 
 ings. I preached uniformly twice every day, afternoon and 
 evening, and a portion of the time in South Boston before day- 
 light. Even at this early hour the house was crowded, for the 
 religious interest was so intense in the community, that almost 
 any sized house could have been filled at almost any hour in the 
 twenty-four. I conducted inquiry-meetings at ten o'clock, A. M., 
 and continued in prayer and conversation until noon ; and at the 
 close of the evening sermon I held another inquiry-meeting of 
 one hour or more in length. In this way I went on, day in and 
 day out, preaching to great crowds, often an hour at a time. 
 It is easy to see that my labors were without cessation, and very 
 severe ; nevertheless the Lord strengthened me for the work 
 he had given me to do. I closed my labors in Providence one 
 night, and -began them in Boston the next ; and preached, 
 without intermission, three months, and in all one hundred and 
 eighty sermons. 
 
 At the end of the first week there were two hundred inquirers 
 in the seats for prayers. But it pleased God to reduce the size 
 of the army, as in the case of Gideon, before he gave us the 
 city. 
 
 I came out, as. I had done elsewhere, against Unitarianism 
 and Universalism, and all similar systems of error. I called 
 things by their right names, and bore down heavily on the 
 manufacture, sale, and use of all intoxicating liquors ; nor did 
 I pass over the open infidelity of the city. The consequence 
 was a grand rally against the progress of the meetings. The 
 first public assault appeared in the columns of a paper, whose 
 editor was a man of intemperate habits. He denounced the 
 meetings, and was especially hard on the preacher. This
 
 126 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 movement emboldened all the powers of darkness. Many 
 Christian people ordered the paper to be stopped, but the un- 
 godly rallied to his encouragement. 
 
 The opposition at length culminated in the gathering of a vast 
 mob in Bowdoin Square, in front of the church, with the 
 avowed purpose of breaking up the meeting. This movement 
 had been anticipated, for it was publicly announced. Some 
 well-meaning, but cowardly people, withdrew from the meet- 
 ings, but the faithful held on in prayer. For a short time it 
 seemed uncertain which way the scale would turn ; but the 
 prayers of that eventful night a night never to be forgotten 
 brought the victory. The brother with whom I was boarding, 
 unable to sleep, came into his.- parlor about midnight, and not 
 knowing that I was there, knlt$down, and in doing so, placed 
 his knees on my prostrate form, as I lay on the floor in the 
 agony of supplication to God. I .afterwards ascertained that 
 very many others had been passing* that night in sleeplessness 
 and in prayer. 
 
 A number of gentlemen, not professors of religion, who had 
 contributed to the erection of the beautiful and spacious church 
 on Bowdoin Square, not relishing my style of preaching, sought 
 to intimidate the trustees into shutting the doors against me by 
 threatening to give up their pews. They were not prepared to 
 listen to such plain, outspoken, sin-killing, and devil-binding 
 truths. Deacon Asa Wilbur at once stepped forward, and 
 bought the pews of all who wished to dispose of them. A few 
 came into his hands, but before the meeting closed more were 
 in demand than had been given up. 
 
 A distiller, who had paid liberally towards building the house, 
 as an expression of his contempt for the meetings, took all his 
 family, one night, to the Museum ; on returning home he was 
 seized with a pain in the hollow of his foot, and before the 
 doctor reached him he was dead. One of Paine's disciples sat 
 up all night preparing clubs with which to break my head, but 
 coming in to hear me, God broke his heart. The chief officer, 
 who called out the Lancers to quell the riot and disperse the
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 127 
 
 mob, confessed that his heart was in sympathy with the mob, 
 and that he hoped they might succeed, though at the same time 
 he was resolved to discharge the duties of his office. He was 
 convicted of his sins, and became an inquirer after salvation. 
 
 The man who drew the plan of the house, and who was 
 mingling sympathiziugly with the mob, suddenly broke away 
 from them, came into the prayer-meeting, and begged the 
 prayers of God's people. On the last night in which the mob 
 made a demonstration, they followed me to the house of Deacon 
 Wilbur, and stood in the street in front of it. The deacon 
 walked up to them, and addressed them as follows : " Gentle- 
 men, Mr. Knapp is in the house ; walk in ; he will treat you in 
 a gentlemanly way ; or, if > you wish it, I will invite him out 
 here, and he will address ydutw They took off their hats, and 
 waving them gracefully, responded, " Good-night, Mr. Wilbur," 
 and quietly retired. From this point public opinion began to 
 react in our favor, and the word of the Lord " grew mightily/' 
 
 When the conflict of public opinion was at its height, and 
 some were saying of me, " He is a good man," and others were 
 saying, " Nay, but he deceiveth the people," a circumstance 
 occurred of singular interest. Mrs. D., a refined and pious 
 lady, called upon me one day when I was absent. While wait- 
 ing for my return, she took up a Bible which lay on the table, 
 and prayed that she might be directed to some passage of 
 Scripture which would indicate my real character. She opened 
 the Bible at random, and her eyes instantly fell on Psalm xci. 
 15, 16 : " He shall call upon me, and I will answer him : I will 
 be with him in trouble ; I will deliver him, and honor him. 
 With long life wity I satisfy him, and show him my salvation." 
 When I came in she told me of the circumstance, and read the 
 passage in my hearing. Under these peculiar circumstances, 
 the passage afforded me great comfort and encouragement. It 
 melted me to tears. . I knew that many of those who stood 
 aloof from me, and looked askance at me, were my superiors in 
 intelligence, culture, and .ability. I felt myself to be a child, 
 and unable to stand up against the multitudes, and their mani-
 
 128 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 fold influences of opposition, unless the Lord should uphold 
 me. But with the conviction that he was on my side, I had 
 no fears. 
 
 It will never be known, until the day of judgment, how many 
 were converted in this revival. Two thousand persons were 
 added to the churches composing the Boston Baptist Associa- 
 tion during that year. Hundreds were added to churches of 
 other denominations, and many came in from the surrounding 
 villages and were converted. Indeed, there were instances of 
 persons coming from distant parts, and taking rooms at board- 
 ing-houses, for the sake of attending the meetings, in order that 
 they might obtain salvation. One lady, residing in New York 
 city, came with this end in view. Some of her friends ex- 
 pressed surprise at her course, especially as she had a family. 
 Her reply was, " If I had supposed that there were any means 
 in Europe which were better adapted to bring me to Christ 
 than there are here, I would have left husband and children, and 
 have hastened there as quickly as steam could carry me ; " 
 adding, " What are all these little sacrifices, in comparison with 
 eternal life ? " I need hardly remark that this dear woman went 
 back to her home a new creature in Christ Jesus. 
 
 Near the. close of these delightful meetings we spent two 
 days in special thanksgiving one day in the Bowdoin Square 
 church, and one day in the Baldwin Place. From ten o'clock 
 until dark each day the time was taken up in the review of 
 God's wonderful mercy and grace. Almost every heart was 
 surcharged with gratitude to God for some particular blessing : 
 parents, because their children had become the children of 
 God ; husbands, because their wives, and wives because their 
 husbands, had given their hearts to the Savior ; teachers, because 
 so many of the scholars had become disciples of Christ ; and 
 pastors, because so many of their congregations had been added 
 to the company of those who would " be saved." 
 
 An Episcopalian missionary from Africa, on hearing a man 
 give thanks for what " God had done for his soul," rose up, and 
 remarked that this very man had been a rum-seller in Africa,
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 129 
 
 and had stood much in his way in laboring for the conversion 
 of the natives ; he desired to lift up his voice in thanksgiving 
 that this man had now become " a fellow-helper to the truth." 
 The churches were greatly strengthened in numbers and means 
 of usefulness. Several of the places of amusement were closed, 
 the attendance on them not being sufficient to pay expenses. 
 Billiard-tables and bar-rooms were neglected ; and you could 
 scarcely meet a man in the market or on the street whose 
 countenance did not indicate seriousness, and whose language 
 was not subdued. The Spirit of God was poured out on the 
 whole city, and all the people seemed to be affected by the 
 power of his presence. The streets at midnight were deserted, 
 and the stillness of the hour was disturbed only by the voice of 
 prayer or the song of praise, as they were wafted from counting- 
 house, garret, or parlor. It was during the progress of these 
 meetings that the Tremont Theatre was offered for sale aud 
 converted into a Temple. In this enterprise Timothy Gilbert 
 was the prime mover. 
 
 I have often said to myself, " O, if Christians were always as 
 devoted aud earnest, how soon would the world be converted to 
 Christ ! " But shortly after my departure a sad and disastrous 
 reaction set in. I know that assiduous attempts have been 
 made to hold me responsible for all the unfortunate scenes that 
 followed these meetings ; but it seems to me that it would be 
 just as reasonable to charge on Paul's zealous aud untiring 
 labors at Ephesus, the blame of all the havoc which wolves 
 made among the flock after he had left them. 
 
 In this instance the opposition to my ministry arose, not from 
 without, but from within. Jesus was " wounded in the house 
 of his friends." It did not culminate while I was on the 
 ground, but broke out after I had gone to another field. The 
 very men who had given me their countenance while laboring 
 to give strength to their churches, enlisted their sympathies 
 against me, as an apology for their want of success in taking 
 care of the increased flocks committed to their charge. 
 
 The assault that was made against me was of a two-fold
 
 130 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 character. In the first place, the value of the work itself was 
 disparaged. It was alleged that the converts brought in under 
 my ministry did not hold out. Now I know full well that it is 
 in the order of God's kingdom that the chaff shall grow with 
 the wheat, and I doubt not that many who have been brought 
 into the church under my labors will not be admitted into the 
 church in heaven. But in this respect I believe that a careful 
 and statistical investigation would show, that the proportion of 
 apostates and worthless professors has been no greater under my 
 preaching than it has been under the labors of stated pastors. 
 And it should be borne in mind that very many of those who 
 had been brought in during the protracted meetings, had 
 never received any previous religious culture, and found them- 
 selves embarrassed when brought into the atmosphere of refine- 
 ment and culture. These persons needed of the pastors, and the 
 older church members, solicitous watch-care ; but, alas ! in too 
 many instances they were neglected, and made to feel the 
 chilling repulsions with which aristocratic bearing and suspicious 
 reserve met them as they crossed the threshold of the Christian 
 church. If there is one thing which pains me more than 
 another, that awakens in my heart anxiety as to the future of 
 Zion, it is the growing desire of ministers and churches to 
 gather their converts from the ranks of the wealthy and the 
 intelligent. The church of Christ is no place for caste. There, 
 if any where, the rich and poor should meet together; and 
 there, if any where, if any discrimination exists, it should be 
 an intenser anxiety to gather into the fold of Christ those who, 
 by reason of poverty, neglect, and vice, are tempted to exclaim, 
 *' No man cares for our souls ! " 
 
 But instead of a redoubling of diligences lest any of these 
 lambs should " fail of the grace of God," measures were im- 
 mediately inaugurated which practically left them to perish. 
 Two of the pastors went off to Europe, and were gone several 
 months. One church was closed, during most of one season, for 
 enlargement and repairs ; while the leader of another part of the 
 flock, either from sympathy with my enemies, or from a want
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 131 
 
 of personal adaptation to the work before him, let slip the 
 opportunity of retaining the crowds that thronged his house 
 when I left ; and brother Colver's edifice was too small to accom- 
 modate a large congregation, and his brethren were straining 
 every nerve to convert the Tremont Theatre into the Tremont 
 Temple. 
 
 No wonder then if, in view of these discouragements, many 
 fell away. And yet a somewhat careful calculation, by Deacon 
 Asa Wilbur, has shown that during the four years succeeding 
 my ministry in Boston, the five churches with which I labored 
 excommunicated only " fifteen per cent, on their baptisms, 
 and all the other churches in the Boston Association, taken 
 together, excluded nearly nineteen per cent, on their baptisms ; " 
 while the " two churches in the city where Mr. Knapp did not 
 labor, baptized (during these four years) one hundred and 
 twenty-two, and excluded thirty-six, or twenty-nine per cent, oil 
 their baptisms." * 
 
 In the second place, a wicked and deliberate attempt was 
 made, by some in high standing in the denomination, to destroy 
 the public confidence in my Christian integrity. The leaders 
 in this conspiracy are now dead, and I pass over their names 
 in silence. Unable to fix the shadow of suspicion on my 
 personal purity and truthfulness, these men set themselves to 
 the task of investigating the quality and texture of my garments. 
 It is very true, that neither myself nor my family, while in 
 Boston, arrayed ourselves in costly and fashionable attire. All 
 the habits of my life were based on a theory of rigid economy : 
 my early necessities had schooled me into it. My income from 
 the churches, on which I had a right to rely for the support 
 of my family, did not warrant lavish expenditures, and, withal, 
 having spent most of my time in the country, I was not up to 
 the demands of Boston fashions ; so that it is possible that in 
 some regards my toilet, though always whole and cleanly, was 
 
 * See " An Examination of the Comparative Statistical Results of the 
 Labors of Elder Jacob Knapp in the State of Massachusetts, by 
 A. Wilbur," in Appendix I.
 
 132 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 not in keeping with the tastes of many of the people who came 
 to hear me preach. 
 
 Now these wiseacres affected to make the wonderful discovery 
 that I dressed thus plainly for the express purpose of creating 
 the impression that I was desperately poor, and wanted, by this 
 means, to excite public sympathy and contributions. Where- 
 upon learned doctors of divinity set themselves busily to work 
 to find out how many pairs of stockings, and how many changes 
 of underclothing, and how many pocket-handkerchiefs I brought 
 with me into Boston, and how many I carried with me when I 
 left. 
 
 No one was found who could say that I had ever asked for a 
 penny of compensation, or begged the favor of a single garment. 
 It is true, that when my wife and I were getting ready to come 
 to Boston, we were so far affected with a regard for the reputa- 
 tion of the people there for fastidiousness, that we thought we 
 were making unusual preparations for our visit ; it is further 
 true, that in some cases, finding further purchases needful, we 
 did sometimes make inquiries where certain articles could be 
 bought ; and it is further true, that instead of always telling us, 
 many kind-hearted persons would anticipate our intentions, by 
 procuring them for us. At the time, I accepted such presents 
 as spontaneous expressions of genuine good feeling, and never 
 dreamed that any would lend themselves to an attempt to con- 
 strue them into evidences that my main reason for becoming ail 
 evangelist was a desire to make money.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 133 
 
 NOTE. 
 
 The following interesting account of Mr. Knapp's labors in Boston, 
 are to be found in the "Life of Timothy Gilbert, by Kev. J. D. Fulton, 
 Pastor of Tremont Temple : " 
 
 " In Providence there was determined opposition to his efforts, on the 
 part of several distinguished ministers. On the other hand, a document, 
 speaking of him in the highest praise, was signed by over three thousand 
 individuals, and forwarded to Boston, where an effort was being made to 
 destroy his influence. On or about the 1st of January, 1842, he began 
 his labors with the First Church, Rev. Rollin H. Neale, pastor, and 
 preached there in the afternoon, in the evening at Baldwin Place, Rev. 
 Baron Stow, pastor. On Monday, January 9, Mr. Knapp commenced 
 at Bowdoin Square Church, where he preached both afternoon and even- 
 ing. It was while here that he met his fiercest oppositions. Mobs 
 gathered about Bowdoin Square as they gathered in the olden time 
 about the synagogue in Lystra, and would have stoned Jacob Knapp, and 
 have dragged him through the city, as the Jews persuaded the people 
 of Lystra to do unto the apostle to the Gentiles. Never did chieftain 
 bear himself more bravely, never did martyr walk more in humble reli- 
 ance upon the promises of a covenant-keeping God, than did this fearless 
 preacher. Citizens were stirred by his appeal and awed by his sublime 
 courage. William Ellery Channing said, concerning him, ' Let the 
 minister alone ; a man who can stir Boston like that will do good.' 
 
 "Day after day the excitement grew more fierce and intense. At 
 length it was reported throughout the city that Mayor Chapman had 
 eaid that the preacher was imprudent, and might take the consequences 
 of his own conduct. Immediately Rev. William Hague, though not a 
 supporter of his measures, called upon the mayor, and informed him of 
 the report, saying that the occasion made its appeal to every lover ot 
 religious liberty, and in such an emergency he should feel it to be his 
 duty to stand beside the preacher, and share the consequences. The 
 mayor replied, ' Sir, the report is not true, and all the power I have at 
 my command shall be concentrated at Bowdoin Square to-night in 
 defence of freedom of speech.' The crowds were dispersed. 
 
 " To the honor of the secular press be it said that with united voice 
 they sustained the action of the mayor, and supported the ambassador 
 of Christ through the terrible ordeal. 
 
 " There was no hesitation on the part of his friends. The church at 
 Baldwin Place unanimously invited Mr. Knapp to preach in their meet-
 
 134 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 ing-house. The tide continued to flow in, and indications of the divine 
 approval abounded. The spiritual strength of Mr. Knapp seemed 
 literally renewed. He fired no blank cartridges, but delivered broadsides 
 at close range into the ranks of the foe. The opposition roused him and 
 encouraged him. The attendance upon theatres waned, that upon 
 churches increased. On February 9, 1842, the ' Reflector ' says, ' It is 
 our privilege to do something more than merely report progress. The 
 work has now attained to a degree of prevalence and power that renders 
 it utterly impossible for us to convey to our more distant readers an 
 adequate conception of what God is permitting his people to witness and 
 enjoy in Boston. Every day brings to light facts and scenes of the most 
 thrilling interest. Among the converts, which now amount to hundreds, 
 there are persons from every class and of every description of moral 
 character old men with thin and silvered locks, with deeply -furrowed 
 cheeks, and voices tremulous and feeble, who were long since given up 
 by their friends as hopeless cases, are, like little children, praying and 
 weeping, and talking of the infinitude of God's mercy and the love of 
 Christ; and young men, glowing with energy and ambition, strong with 
 health and hope, are proclaiming, with apostolic fervor, the truths which 
 to some are a stumbling-block, and to others foolishness ; children are 
 in many instances rejoicing over their parents' conversion, and in many 
 others, parents are blessing God for the conversion of their children. 
 A family in which father and mother and five adult children were con- 
 verted were led to Christ through the instrumentality of a single young 
 lady. Her importunity led them to the meetings ; her kind and correct 
 endeavors dissuaded them from dropping the subject or avoiding the 
 influence which was now creeping over them. She rested not till God 
 and conscience had done their work, and the souls she loved were loved 
 of Heaven. 
 
 " On Tuesday evening of last week, brother Knapp made ' Uni- 
 versalism ' the theme of his discourse, and for two hours and a half held 
 a vast and crowded auditory in almost breathless silence, while he tore 
 up the foundations of the system, and scattered the whole fabric to the 
 winds. Never did we hear such an array of facts authentic, astound- 
 ing, withering facts. We thought that even his Satanic Majesty himself, 
 had he appeared there as a Universalist, must have quailed under them, 
 and hung his head in shame.' 
 
 " A young man, a member of Mr. Skinner's congregation, led by 
 curiosity, found his way to Baldwin Place. Strong in the faith of Uni- 
 versalism, he listened with candor, as one inquiring after truth ; and the 
 result was, that Mr. Knapp swept away every vestige of his Universal- 
 ism, and, to use his own language, ' took away every shingle and clap-
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 135 
 
 board of the building left nothing but the falling rafters, exposing his 
 naked soul to the peltings of the pitiless storm.' The revival was 
 characterized by the apparent genuineness of the conversions. The 
 converts exhibited a clear understanding of the evil of sin, the holiness 
 of God's laws, the doctrine of justification by faith, and the necessity of 
 entire consecration to God topics on which Mr. Knapp dwelt with 
 great frequency and power. Though some of the ministers treated Mr. 
 Knapp coolly, the majority of the churches were heart and soul with 
 him. 
 
 " On the first Sabbath in February, forty-two united with the First 
 Church, fourteen with Bowdoin Square, nineteen with Baldwin Place, 
 and twenty-two with Tremont Street. 
 
 " On March 2 this announcement is made under the head of ' Thea- 
 tres : ' ' The friends of morality and religion will rejoice to learn that 
 the great theatre of Boston, the Tremont, is closed, and that noble 
 granite edifice is offered for sale, and is likely to be converted into a 
 house of worship. At the conclusion of a late entertainment, the mana- 
 ger announced that the theatre would be closed, and stated that within 
 the last three months they had lost ten thousand dollars by keeping it 
 open.' The rush was in a different direction. The churches were 
 thronged, and Mr. Knapp went from place to place, like a general on 
 the field of battle, giving aid where needed. A writer in the ' New York 
 Evangelist ' says of him, ' He preaches in his own style, saying some 
 things that are not in good taste, yet no doubt doing execution.' A 
 professor in one of our theological schools attended upon his preaching 
 a whole Sabbath since he has been here, and on being asked his opinion, 
 replied, ' He is a man of genius and power, and though his preaching is 
 not always in good taste, yet no thief, or profane swearer, or drunkard, 
 or adulterer, can sit and listen to him a great while without feeling that 
 the constable is after him.' 
 
 " The work goes on in increasing power. New and striking cases of 
 conviction are daily occurring among persons of every faith, and class, 
 and character ; wholesale dealers in ardent spirits have yielded to the 
 Spirit of God, and abandoned the cursed traffic. A large distiller was 
 found beside a vendor among the inquirers. Baptisms are occurring in 
 the different churches every Sabbath, and the work is spreading through 
 the commonwealth. March 9 the ' Puritan ' has taken sides against Mr. 
 Knapp, and three eminent divines of the straitest sect declare ' the senti- 
 ments of Mr. Knapp are substantially sound, so far as they go, but his 
 violation of good taste is the great secret of his notoriety.' 
 
 " The ' Reflector ' speaks of Sabbath, March 6, as furnishing a scene 
 upon which angels would look with delight. ' Picture to yourself a
 
 136 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 crowded sanctuary, with its long centre aisle occupied from end to end 
 with a dense double column of " new recruits " to the army, fighting 
 under the banners of our King, and then receiving, one after another, 
 the significant pledge of Christian affection, and passing round, one to 
 the right hand and another to the left, until the last young soldier was 
 greeted, and all duly enrolled with the sacramental host of God's elect. 
 The work has been more powerful in the First Church, during the last 
 week, than at any time before. It seems as if not a single soul among 
 them all was to be left in a state of unreconciliation to God. Baptisms 
 reported: First Church, fifty-eight; Baldwin Place, fifty-two; Free 
 Church, forty ; Bowdoin Square, twenty-seven ; Federal Street, twenty- 
 eight ; Boylston Street, twenty-four ; Charles Street, six ; Independent, 
 nineteen. Notwithstanding these results, the " New England Puritan " 
 ridicules the labors of Mr. Knapp, saying, " The operations after the 
 sermons are more objectionable than anything in the sermons them- 
 selves." Calling forward to the anxious seat is characterized by declar- 
 ing that " the congregation is put into a rambling state and some fifteen 
 minutes of confusion." " Against such machinery, so productive of 
 wholesale delusion, so destructive to the modesty becoming women and 
 children, and so calculated to lead all impenitent men to the conclusion 
 that religion is promoted by trick and artifice, we feel bound -to enter 
 our solemn protest ; " and all this because Mr. Knapp, at the conclusion 
 of the sermon, was accustomed to come down from the pulpit and exhort 
 the impenitent to come to Christ, and converts to tell what God had 
 done for their souls. The third week of March closed his labors in 
 Boston, with the blessings of thousands ready to perish resting upon 
 him, and following him to Lowell, his next field of labor. 
 
 " In accordance with the request of the leading citizens of Boston, he 
 repeated the Temperance Sermon in Marlboro' Chapel, which, two years 
 before, in Baltimore, led to the reformation of J. H. W. Hawkins, and 
 initiated the Washingtonian reform. At the conclusion of the address, 
 all who had signed the total abstinence pledge, or were determined to 
 sign it, were asked to rise ; and the whole of that immense assemblage 
 sprang to their feet. It was a thrilling scene, and proved the potency 
 of the religion of Christ to promote a spirit of reform. 
 
 " The time of his sojourn drew to a close. In the ' Reflector ' of 
 March 23 there was a description of the closing scenes. ' The mornings 
 of Thursday and Friday, March 17 and 18, were occupied with meetings 
 devoted to expressions of gratitude . for the distinguishing mercies of 
 Heaven. These meetings were full of interest. Thursday evening he 
 preached to converts in Bowdoin Square. Friday afternoon he preached 
 to Christians at Baldwin Place; and though it was a week day, and in
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 137 
 
 the hurry of spring, such was the enthusiasm, that every standing place 
 in the house was taken, and multitudes went away. In the evening he 
 preached to the impenitent at Bowdoin Square, and the solemn service 
 was concluded with the parting and farewell of those parties who had 
 labored with him.'" 
 
 " This was a most wonderful period in denominational history. The 
 laity that upheld the- hands of the ministry were unsurpassed in char- 
 acter, in talent, and in devotion. Every church was strong, because 
 each church might, like the Sultan of the East, point to her stalwart 
 men as the walls of her defence and the implements of conquest. It 
 was at this period Daniel Safford introduced Rev. E. N. Kirk, D. D., to 
 Boston. It was a remarkable happen-so, even if it were a happen-so, 
 that Mr. Kirk followed Mr. Knapp so frequently. One was the John 
 the Baptist, preaching repentance, and the other was the reaper. One 
 was the blacksmith, the other the silversmith. Said Dr. Kirk, 'I 
 delighted to follow Mr. Knapp, because he stirred the conscience, and 
 made a great number ready to listen to the truth, presented in a milder 
 form. They were too mad to hear him, they were under too deep con- 
 viction to rest content ; so, many gladly came to listen to me who might 
 have gone, unmoved, to perdition, had it not been for the sledge- 
 hammer style of Mr. Knapp,' For this reason he followed him, in 
 Baltimore, in New Haven, and in Boston." 
 11
 
 138 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 CHAPTER XIV. 
 
 ACCOUNTS OF PKOTKACTED MEETINGS. 
 (CONTINUED.) 
 
 LOWELL : A Universalist Covenant Meeting. A Cotton Mill an 
 Inquiry-Boom. Fifteen Hundred Converts. A Challenge to 
 Universalists. Its Acceptance, and the Result. Physical Exhaus- 
 tion. An Aged Convert. A Farewell Scene. An Infidel Ob- 
 server. CONCORD : Excitement among Christians and among 
 Scoffers. An Illustration. Conversion of a Universalist Preacher. 
 Penitent Scoffers. A Refusal to baptize. Regrets. Baptist 
 Influence. The Second Advent. Statement of E. E. Cummings. 
 
 LOWELL. 
 
 I CLOSED my meetings in Boston on one night, and began 
 my meeting in Lowell on the next. The wonderful work 
 of God in Boston prepared the minds of the people in this neigh- 
 boring city to expect a similar manifestation of the Divine 
 Presence among them. 
 
 The Universalists took the alarm from the start ; and even 
 before I arrived, their congregation had been convened, and 
 asked to pledge themselves that they would not go to hear me 
 preach at all. Since they expected to get to heaven by lying 
 as easily as by praying, their pledges did not hold good. I was 
 no sooner on the ground than they went to hear me in great 
 numbers. 
 
 The Lord came down in power, and the work rolled on 
 mightily. It very soon assumed such vast proportions that in 
 one of the cotton mills the superintendent, who was a Univer- 
 salist, found it necessary to stop operations. The operatives 
 were nearly all on their knees, in prayer for themselves, or for 
 their unconverted associates. In fact, the entire factory was an 
 anxious-room.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 139 
 
 It was afterwards estimated that about fifteen hundred were 
 converted, as the result of this meeting of five weeks. The 
 interest was shared among Methodists, Cougregationalists, and 
 Episcopalians, as well as Baptists, and all reaped largely of its 
 benefits. 
 
 At the close of one of my sermons, I remember calling upon 
 all in the congregation who were willing to live and die by 
 Universalism, and risk their eternal all upon it, to rise up. One 
 woman arose ; but fear seized hold of her while she stood ; a 
 sense of her awful temerity overwhelmed her. She sank down 
 on her seat, convicted by the Spirit of God. Shortly after- 
 wards she confessed her sins, renounced her errors, and became 
 a believer in Jesus as her only refuge. 
 
 During this meeting I found myself greatly reduced in 
 strength. I had been preaching twice a day, for two weeks, in 
 Providence ; from thence I had gone directly to Boston, and 
 there had preached twice and three times a day, besides attend- 
 ing inquiry-meetings, for the space of three months ; and had 
 gone thence, without intermission, to enter upon a similar siege 
 in Lowell. In this way I had spent nearly seven months in 
 unceasing toil, taxing my physical and mental powers to the 
 utmost. Towards the close of my labors here, I would go from 
 the pulpit to the lounge, and from the lounge to the pulpit ; and 
 yet, though growing consciously weaker every day, I was enabled 
 to preach, apparently with as much effectiveness as ever. 
 
 Among those who came forward for prayers was an old man, 
 of over seventy years of age, who stated that he had been 
 brought up in " the land of steady habits," had lived a moral 
 life, and had depended on his morality for the salvation of his 
 soul. Now his eyes were opened ; he saw his guilt and danger, 
 but could see no remedy, and felt that he must be lost. Days 
 passed, and he found no relief. He had not as yet summoned 
 strength to make the first attempt to pray; finally he was 
 induced to kneel, and call on God to have mercy on him, for 
 the sake of Jesus. Christ appeared to him, in the greatness 
 and fulness of his redeeming love, and his soul was brought
 
 140 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 into the liberty of the gospel. "When he went down intj the 
 baptismal waters, he walked with the sprightliness of youth ; 
 and coming up out of the water, " he went on his way 
 rejoicing." 
 
 When I came to take my departure from the place, the 
 people flocked in crowds around me, each eager to give me a 
 farewell grasp pf the hand. The throng became so great that 
 the track was blockaded, and the cars were unable to venture a 
 start, lest they should crush the people who were crowding 
 about them. As fast as the track was cleared in one place, it was 
 covered in another by the surging crowd ; and yet the greatest 
 order and decorum prevailed. The air resounded with the 
 songs of the rejoicing and weeping multitudes. 
 
 An infidel, who had not attended the meeting, riding along 
 on horseback, looking on the scene, seemed to hear a voice, 
 saying to him. " Behold how these Christians love one another." 
 " How good and how pleasant it is for brethren to dwell to- 
 gether in unity." He trembled, and had he not held on to his 
 horse's mane, would have fallen to the ground. He went home, 
 asked for the prayers of God's children, and was converted 
 to God. 
 
 CONCORD. 
 
 In September, 1842, 1 commenced meeting in Concord, N. H. 
 The Baptist church was then under the pastoral care of brother 
 Cummings. The interest rose quite rapidly, and went on with 
 increasing power for some six weeks. The excitement became 
 intense. The Universalists, Unitarians, and infidels became 
 wild with the excitement of denouncing our excitement. A 
 shrewd infidel had published an article before my arrival, in 
 which he predicted that " Knapp would whip them all out ; " 
 and the reason he assigned was, that they " had no hell in their 
 creeds." While this outcry against our meetings was at its 
 height, I gave the people an account of an occurrence which 
 took place in their own community, illustrating the propriety of 
 strong excitement on the part of those who believe in the truth of 
 Christianity. A short time before I had commenced the meet-
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 141 
 
 ing, the beloved son of the Unitarian minister had met death 
 under circumstances peculiarly distressing. During his vacation 
 from college, he, together with several of his companions, had 
 repaired to the Merrimac River in order to bathe ; shortly after- 
 wards one of them came back, running with the utmost speed, with 
 the cry that the minister's son had plunged into the river, and had 
 not risen to the surface. The father, with all possible speed, has- 
 tened to the spot, screaming along the way, " Help, help, help ! " 
 and stripping off his coat, leaped into the stream, diving now in 
 one place and then in another, until he came in contact with the 
 body of his drowned boy. Seizing it, he brought it to the 
 shore, and instantly physicians and friends were eager in their 
 attempts to resuscitate animation. But all was in vain. In 
 the mean time the news had spread like wildfire, and the people 
 from their dwellings, schools, stores, and workshops had rushed 
 to the scene of the disaster. Sympathy and anxiety were 
 depicted in every face ; and as the wails of the agonized family 
 broke on their ears, stout hearts beat thick and fast, and eyes 
 unused to tears, were suffused with signs of genuine sorrow. 
 All sorts of business, for that day, were banished from every 
 mind. In short, the whole town was wild with excitement. I 
 used this fact as the basis of an appeal to the congregation. 
 Who would presume to say that these manifestations of excited 
 feeling were not justifiable? I do not say excusable, but de- 
 manded by the exigency of the case ? What would have been 
 thought of any one, if, during the prevalence of this intense 
 omotion, he had gone among the excited crowds with the sneer 
 of a cynic on his lips, had ridiculed this ebullition as a ridicu- 
 lous excitement, and denounced the anguish of the smitten 
 parents as the ravings of insanity, and the tears of the sympa- 
 thizing throng as the snivellings of folly? Such a man would 
 have been looked upon as a cold-blooded wretch, whose only 
 impulse was the malignant misanthropy of a devil. O, then, 
 what more reason for excitement on the part of those who real- 
 ize the lost condition of their fellow-men, and view them sinking 
 into the depths of an endless hell ! All seemed not only speech- 
 less, but for the moment breathless.
 
 142 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 While I was conducting this meeting, the Universalists were 
 busily engaged in completing their meeting-house they were 
 specially excited, lest everybody would be converted before they 
 had got it ready for use. One day, while two of their leading 
 men were talking about forming themselves into an organized 
 church, one of them said, " When we form our church you 
 shall be one of the deacons, and I will be the other. I swear 
 I will." In one of my sermons I repeated this conversation 
 before the whole congregation. The next day the Universalist 
 minister, with one of their prominent men, called on brother 
 Cummings and myself, to remonstrate with us for u abusing 
 them." We received them kindly, and after a very brief con- 
 versation, I proposed that we spend a season in prayer. I 
 called on each of them to pray, but they both refused. Thea 
 brother Cummings prayed, and I followed. Like Felix of old, 
 they both trembled. The minister came out, publicly renounced 
 his errors, professed conversion, and united with the Presby- 
 terian church. 
 
 On one evening, while the anxious were coming forward for 
 prayers, my eye caught sight of a tall, fine-looking gentleman, 
 who was standing near the door. He seemed to be looking on 
 the scene with an apparent air of mingled contempt and de- 
 fiance. I said to myself, " I should like to see your proucl 
 knees bend at the feet of Jesus." I stepped up to him, and asked 
 him if he would take a seat among the inquirers ? He replied 
 that he had " no objection," and at once went forward, asking 
 me, at the same time, to pray especially for him call him 
 out by name. I learned that he was the son of Governor H., 
 and the editor of one of the political papers in the town. I 
 bowed in prayer, requesting all to unite with me at the mercy- 
 seat (for, what he meant in sport, we meant in earnest). 
 When we rose from our knees, the sweat was rolling off" of him 
 like rain, and his knees smote together like Belshazzar's. The 
 moment the benediction was pronounced, he shot out of the 
 door and disappeared. On the next morning he came into the 
 prayer-meeting, and stated that, while prayer was being offered
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 143 
 
 for him on the preceding night, his sins rose up before him like 
 mountains ; he realized the necessity of meeting the great ques- 
 tion of his salvation immediately. Instead of joining his com- 
 rades, and repairing to a saloon, to drink champagne, as he 
 had been in the habit of doing, he hastened at once to his room, 
 and locked the door. He felt that the crisis moment had come, 
 and that if he yielded that night to the convivial overtures of 
 his companions, the Spirit of God would leave him, and his 
 damnation would be sealed. He had been spending the night in 
 prayer, and he had come into the meeting to say that " another 
 day was dawning." He had made a full surrender of his heart 
 to Christ, and was now rejoicing in the hope of pardon and 
 eternal life. 
 
 After making this statement, he turned to Squire B., a 
 young lawyer, who edited the other paper, and an intimate 
 friend of Mr. H., and entreated him to go forward for prayers. 
 He arose at once, and took his seat among the inquirers. He 
 then beckoned to me, and offering me a five-dollar bill, said he 
 had a confession to make. I said to him, " I do not want your 
 money, but your soul." He replied, that he had stated in his 
 paper that I " was preaching for money," knowing better when 
 he said it. He insisted that it would be a relief to his feelings 
 if I would accept his overture. Lest he should . think I was 
 needlessly sensitive, I yielded to his request. I then bowed 
 in prayer. Very soon he made a surrender of his soul to the 
 sceptre of Christ. 
 
 The conversion of these young men introduced the subject 
 of personal religion into a large circle of the leading families 
 of the place. Many of this class were led to indulge hopes of 
 salvation. I was waited upon by three or four of these persons, 
 and informed that some twelve or fourteen of their number 
 wished me to immerse them, with the understanding that they 
 intended to join the Episcopal church. I endeavored to con- 
 vince them that it would be better for them and their influence 
 if they would join a church whose sentiments on this subject 
 harmonized with their own convictions. They inferred that
 
 114 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF 
 
 I .did not wisli to immerse them, except on condition of their 
 uniting with a Baptist church ; and they finally submitted to the 
 ceremony of sprinkling at the hands of the Episcopal minister. 
 I have always regretted that I did not yield to their request. 
 If I had immersed them, I should have helped them to per- 
 form the initiatory and symbolic rite required by Christ of 
 his disciples, and have devolved the responsibility of their future 
 associations on their own consciences. Their influence, even 
 though indirect, would nevertheless have been more in favor of 
 the true baptism, and their own minds would have been satisfied 
 that they had at least obeyed the Savior's first command, and 
 had symbolized the great truths that make distinctive and glori- 
 ous the Christian system, namely, death to sin, and resurrec- 
 tion to newness of life ; faith in a buried and risen Redeemer, 
 and a hope of a blessed resurrection from the dead.* 
 
 I am unable to state the number of those who were converted 
 or baptized as the result of this meeting. But all the churches 
 received numerous accessions. Before this, the Baptist cause 
 had been weak. There was only one church, and that a small 
 one. Soon afterwards a second church was formed, and brother 
 Cummings became its pastor, and continued such until quite 
 recently (1867). Very many in this town had never wit- 
 nessed the administration of a primitve baptism ; and as they 
 stood on the banks of the river, and saw score after score buried 
 in the likeness of the Savior's death, they were constrained 
 to acknowledge the beauty and scriptural simplicity of the 
 ordinance. 
 
 About this time there prevailed throughout New England 
 great excitement concerning the second coming of Christ. 
 Brother Miller sincerely believed that the world would come 
 to an end, and that the Savior would appear in personal glory 
 some time during the year 1843. He was going from place to 
 place proclaiming his views, and many good people adopted 
 
 * Christ has commissioned his ministers to baptize men, on condition 
 of their faith in him ; not on condition of their joining a Baptist church, 
 and conforming to all its usages of polity and worship.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 145 
 
 them. In some cases the peace of the churches was disturbed 
 by reason of divisions on this question. The believers in this 
 new doctrine of the special and immediate time in which Christ 
 would appear, were very zealous in asserting their convictions 
 in all the church meetings, and making demands on the ministers 
 to preach the doctrine. In lukewarm churches this pertinacity 
 of zeal was resisted and resented with acerbity ; but where the 
 Spirit of Grod was enjoyed, those brethren who did not adopt 
 the view, were nevertheless willing that those who did might 
 sing, and pray, and talk about the coming of Christ without 
 hinderance. The subject itself is a glorious one at all times, and 
 the errors as to date, though deplored, were not allowed to be- 
 come a root of bitterness. 
 
 I was accustomed to dispose of all approaches on this subject 
 in my meeting, as I did in theirs, by reminding the people that 
 the spiritual presence of Christ was an existing fact, and one 
 which they could all enjoy at present, and was more desirable 
 than simply his corporeal presence, under the circumstances in 
 which we were placed. Were he to come in person, all oppor- 
 tunity Tor repentance would be at an end ; and that it was of the 
 utmost importance that all Christians labor with all their might 
 to bring sinners into the ark of salvation, especially as they 
 believed they saw " the day approaching." 
 
 So far from being annoyed by the presence of these people, I 
 found them of much service. They formed themselves into 
 singing clubs, and they would sing and pray with great earnest- 
 ness. A number of them accompanied me from Concord to 
 Boston, singing in the cars on their way. 
 
 These were golden days, sunny spots, heavenly seasons. 
 The memory of them is precious ; and the recollection of them 
 will be among my unspeakable joys when I shall have passed 
 over Jordan. 
 
 My dear brother Cummings has furnished an account of this 
 meeting, which I take pleasure in subjoining to mine : 
 
 " The first century after the settlement of Concord was not 
 marked by any very extensive revivals. During most of this
 
 146 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 period the ' standing order ' held almost undisputed possession ; 
 there was but one church, and one place of meeting. 
 
 " The Baptist church came into existence in a very feeble 
 condition, and for nearly ten years held meetings in school- 
 houses, remote from the centre of the town. At length a house 
 of worship was built in a most favorable location ; and though 
 the church was then feeble, it continued gradually to increase, 
 and enjoyed, in the mean time, some most precious revivals. 
 But the Baptists had not a commanding influence in the town. 
 The state of religion, and the position of the Baptist church, 
 rendered the labors of an evangelist both desirable and hope- 
 ful. In the winter of 1841-2 my people enjoyed a very precious 
 revival, and the Spirit continued in the church through the 
 season. 
 
 " Rev. Jacob Knapp commenced his labors in Concord, Sep- 
 tember 14, 1842. My people, I believe, were in a good degree 
 prepared to enter into the work, and the community at large 
 were anxious to hear the man about whom so much had been 
 said. Our meetings were full from the first, and inquirers 
 began to multiply. The meetings continued every afternoon 
 and evening for six weeks. The work spread through my 
 entire congregation, leaving but one family unblessed. It also 
 extended through the entire town, including many in each con- 
 gregation, and some who were not connected with any religious 
 society. 
 
 " Indeed, the whole community was shaken ; and persons who 
 were supposed to be the farthest from the kingdom of heaven, 
 were brought to bow at the foot of the cross. Some rum-sellers 
 came forward, and confessed their deeds, and gave up the 
 nefarious traffic. The Universalist minister first attempted to 
 ease his conscience by submitting to the ordinance of baptism 
 in a distant town ; but afterwards renounced his heresies, pro- 
 fessed to be converted, and united with the Congregational 
 church. There were some very interesting cases of conversions, 
 among which was a young lawyer, of marked ability, who gave
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 147 
 
 very clear evidences of a change, and who, now in the midst of 
 worldly distinctions, still retains the hope he then cherished. 
 
 " The work spread through all the regions. Persons attended 
 the meeting from adjoining towns, and returned filled with the 
 Spirit, and God worked through them in the communities 
 where they belonged. Almost every church in the association 
 was revived, and had large accessions to their number. 
 
 " It was estimated that over five hundred were converted dur- 
 ing the meeting ; of whom one hundred and twenty-six united 
 with the Baptist church, and about two hundred with all the other 
 churches in town. Brother Knapp preached the plain, simple 
 gospel " Jesus Christ, and him crucified." There was nothing 
 in the doctrine or illustration to which I could object. There 
 was constant reference to our dependence on divine influence. 
 This was the key-note in the closet, in the family, in the in- 
 quiry-meeting, and in the pulpit. God's power was sought, and 
 it was manifested from beginning to end. It was a gracious 
 display of matchless grace ; and I can bear witness to the 
 endurance of the fruits. It is true some went back, and walked 
 no more with Jesus ; but many have gone home to glory, and 
 many remain to bless the church of Christ to this day. 
 
 " As the results of the meeting, the church was enlarged and 
 strengthened, secured a commanding influence in the town, 
 and in eleven years after this meeting a colony went out from 
 the church, built a new church edifice, and are enjoying a good 
 degree of prosperity. The Baptists now have two churches, ia 
 a good condition, and have as much influence among the people 
 as any denomination in the city ; and the protracted meeting in 
 1842, under God, had much to do in giving them this standing. 
 To Him be all the praise."
 
 148 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 CHAPTER XV. 
 
 ACCOUNTS OF PROTRACTED MEETINGS. 
 (CONTINUED.) 
 
 SALEM and MARBLEHEAD : Enlargement. Conflict over a Soul. 
 A Universalist Prayer-Meeting. Leaving Town. WASHINGTON : 
 A small Band. Cooperation. Dance-Hall. Pro- Slavery. A 
 remarkable Conversion. College Students. E Street Church. 
 RICHMOND : Conditional Invitation. Respect for Ministers. 
 An unhealthy Piety. Slavery Abominations. A Slave Prayer- 
 Meeting, and Bloodhounds. Remonstrance. Departure. 
 
 SALEM AND MAKBLEHEAD. 
 
 ABOUT the beginning of the year 1843, I commenced my 
 labors with the Second Baptist church in Salem, Mass., 
 of which brother Banvard was pastor. The house of worship 
 soon became too small for us. The First Baptist church was 
 unwilling to open their doors to me, so that we were compelled 
 to go to a public hall. At once this place became thronged. 
 In a marvellous manner did God display the power of his grace. 
 Hundreds on hundreds professed conversion, embracing persons 
 of every class and condition : men, women, and children, rich 
 and poor, high and low, all came together under the common 
 impulse of a desire for salvation. 
 
 I spent a portion of the time at Marblehead, preaching there 
 in the morning at half past nine o'clock, and returning in time 
 to preach in the afternoon and evening at Salem. I conducted 
 the inquiry-meetings as usual. 
 
 At Marblehead a hardened Universalist came forward for 
 prayers, weeping, and begging for mercy. He continued all 
 night in distress. His old Universalist friends came in to aliay
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 149 
 
 his fears, and dissuade him from his anxiety, but all was to no 
 purpose : the load of sins weighed down his soul in grief. In 
 the mean time he was visited by some Christian friends, who 
 prayed with him and for him. Thus it seemed as if the con- 
 flicting agencies of good and evil were set to secure possession 
 of his soul. One company was striving to save him from 
 destruction, the other to compass his destruction. But towards 
 morning judgment came forth unto victory ; the prayers of 
 saints, the sympathies of angels, and the Spirit of the Lord, 
 prevailed over the combined assaults of wicked men, lost spirits, 
 and the arch-fiend. The man found peace in believing, and 
 shouted aloud, and gave glory to God. 
 
 Many Universalists were converted during this meeting. The 
 minister and many of his members became alarmed, and, to 
 save their sinking ship, they opened a prayer and conference- 
 meeting. They invited everybody, of all denominations, to come 
 and take part, and feel free to express their views on the sub- 
 ject o'f religion. Among those who responded, was a man who 
 was under powerful conviction. He rose up to express his feel- 
 ings ; he confessed his sins, and invited others to seek the Lord 
 with him. While he was yet speaking, the burden of guilt was 
 rolled from his heart, the love of God filled him with joy in- 
 describable, and he began to speak forth, with such thrilling 
 eloquence, that he was soon requested to take his seat. He 
 reminded them of their unlimited invitation to all to come and 
 speak what was in their hearts ; but they persisted in their 
 purpose to silence him, and finally put him out of the house. 
 Many others, indignant at this treatment, followed him, came 
 over to our meeting, and found salvation. In this instance 
 Satan cast out Satan. 
 
 The whole city of Salem was shaken by the power of God. 
 Bar-rooms, ball-alleys, and haunts of vice were deserted, and 
 those who had frequented them turned their feet to the place of 
 prayer, and sought and found salvation. 
 
 When the time came for my departure, a company of Chris- 
 tians chartered a train of cars and accompanied me to Boston,
 
 150 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 Immense crowds from the city and the regions round about 
 gathered around the depot, covered the track, and blocked up 
 the cars. All the adjoining streets were thronged with a sea 
 of human beings. An hour was spent in attempts to clear the 
 track, and the voice of singing and of prayer resounded through 
 the air. In this way we continued our journey. On reaching 
 Boston, I made a few farewell remarks. Amid many tears and 
 parting greetings I turned from them, they and I weeping 
 because we might never see each other's faces again ; and 
 joying, because very soon we should meet where 
 
 " No farewell sound is ever heard, 
 Not e'en the word Good-bye." 
 
 As soon as I reentered the cars for Providence I took my 
 seat in a corner, closed my eyes, and gave myself up to the 
 ecstasy of silent prayer and praise to God. 
 
 WASHINGTON. 
 
 Near the close of the year 1843, 1 was invited by a little band 
 of brethren and sisters in Washington, D.C., consisting of eleven 
 persons, eight women and three men, who had formed 
 themselves into a church, to hold a series of meetings with 
 them. The only other Baptist church was a small, inefficient 
 affair, exerting no moral power in the community. 
 
 This small company hired a hall, agreeing to pay one hundred 
 dollars per month for the use of it, with the understanding that 
 we were to vacate it two evenings in every week, on which 
 nights it was engaged for holding balls. M. B. Anderson, 
 now President of Rochester University, was then acting as their 
 pulpit supply. He continued with me nearly through my meet- 
 ings, but was at length compelled to return to his studies. Dr. 
 Chapin and Professor Douglass, of Columbian College, took a 
 deep interest in the work. Some Christians of other denomina- 
 tions came in, and lent a helping hand. 
 
 This dance-hall proved to be well adapted to our purposes ; 
 the side-rooms served us for holding female, inquiry, and
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 151 
 
 young people's meetings. The Spirit of God soon began to 
 move on the souls of men, and the hall itself seemed to be 
 pervaded with the divine presence. We had to vacate it two 
 nights for the service of the devil, but the balls proved miserable 
 failures. One lady, who had paid three hundred dollars for a 
 dress to wear on one of these occasions, said that she was never 
 so wretched in all her life as on that night. The managers 
 called on the proprietors, and told them that if they did not get 
 Knapp out of the hall they would never hire it again. But 
 our brethren had taken the precaution to secure, in writing, a 
 lease for a given time, and in this case the children of light 
 were wiser than the children of this world. We had got the 
 start of the devil, and we kept in the advance. During the two 
 evenings in which we were out of the hall, we were invited to 
 occupy the Presbyterian Church, and did so. By this means 
 we gained new recruits, and gathered increased strength to re- 
 new the battle on the devil's ground. 
 
 After I got well under way, I came out against the sin of 
 slavery ; denounced it as an institution of the devil ; and advocated 
 the equality and universality of human rights. Dr. Chapin called 
 upon me, and tried to dissuade me from alluding to " the 
 peculiar institution ; " and informed me that if he had known 
 I was going to preach against slavery, he would not have 
 given me his influence ; that it would not have been safe for 
 himself, nor for the college, nor for the church. I replied that 
 I could not help it ; he must pursue such a course as he thought 
 duty required, but that I should not, and could not, change my 
 course. I was bound to preach up Christ, and preach down the 
 devil. 
 
 Happily the work had, by this time, come to such a pitch, 
 and gone on to such an extent, that the doctor did not dare to 
 set his influence against it ; nor would it have availed if he 
 had, for it was not in the power of all the pro-slavery D. D.'s, 
 nor of all the devils in hell, to stop the mighty tide of salvation 
 which was then sweeping through the city. 
 
 One man, who had prosecuted a gentleman from New England
 
 152 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 for having an anti-slavery tract in his trunk, and cast him into 
 prison, where he took cold and died, came forward for prayers. 
 He was in great distress of mind. A number of us continued 
 in prayer for him, though at first the idea of such a man being 
 converted taxed our faith ; nevertheless, we knew he belonged 
 to the human family, and that Christ had died for even such as 
 he. And, sure enough, he gave us hopeful signs that he became 
 truly penitent and believing ! 
 
 Several of the students in the college were brought under the 
 power of the gospel ; some of them are now ministers. 
 
 Our baptismal services were usually scenes of great interest. 
 On one occasion I formed twenty men in a line on the banks of 
 the Potomac, and locking arms, they walked with me abreast 
 down into the water, the congregation on the shore singing as 
 they went. On reaching suitable depth, I commenced baptizing 
 them ; and each one standing in the water till all had been 
 " buried with Christ ; " we then locked arms again, and returned 
 to the shore amid the greetings of song from the congregation 
 who had witnessed the scene. Among the spectators were 
 members of Congress, and several foreign ministers ; some 
 were standing, some were sitting in their carriages, but all were 
 deeply affected, and many of them to tears. 
 
 While baptizing one day, a young man, who had imbibed 
 infidel views from his father, rode his horse into the water 
 close by where I was ' administering the ordinance, in order, as 
 he said, that he might have a fair view. As he witnessed the 
 calm and joyous expression of the faces of the candidates as 
 they came up, one after another, out of the water, a sudden 
 sensation of trembling seized him, so that he was compelled to 
 hold himself on his horse by main force. Pie went from the 
 scene to his home, and did not leave it for three days. On the 
 evening of the third day he came to the meeting and related 
 the above, and besought the prayers of God's people. On the 
 following Lord's day he was baptized in the same place. 
 
 I remained in Washington about seven weeks, preaching day 
 and night. As the result of this meeting, movements were
 
 ELDER JACOB KXAPP. 153 
 
 inaugurated before I left, for the erection of the Baptist Church 
 on E Street. The number of persons brought into the church 
 in consequence of this effort, including those gathered in 
 by brother Sampson after I had gone, amounted to about two 
 hundred. 
 
 RICHMOND. 
 
 While I was preaching in Washington, I was waited on by 
 Elder Jeter and Deacon Thomas, of Richmond, Va., and invited 
 to visit that city. They wanted me, however, to give them a 
 pledge that I would keep silence on the subject of slavery. 
 They remained at my lodgings till near midnight, arguing this 
 point, but to no purpose. I had never made such a pledge, 
 and I could not be persuaded to put on a muzzle simply 
 because of the prejudices of that people in favor of slavery. 
 They left me, as I supposed, with the intention of letting the 
 matter drop. But shortly afterwards I received a letter from 
 them, asking me to come on, and saying that I would be left to 
 take my own course in regard to that particular subject, ex- 
 pressing the belief, however, that when I got on the ground, 
 and learned the state of things, I would see the propriety of 
 abstaining from any interference with their " peculiar institu- 
 tion." I concluded to go to Richmond. 
 
 On going on board the steamer we found the table covered 
 with gambling cards, and the preparations completed for be- 
 ginning a game. But very soon it was whispered around that 
 " Elder Knapp and his wife were on board." The cards were 
 gathered up and put out of sight, and Bibles and hymn-books 
 \vere set in their place. I began to think that I had never seen 
 ministers of the gospel treated with greater respect on the 
 waters of the Eastern or Western States, and I imagined that 
 I could guess the reason. I knew that the devil was an old 
 philosopher and a wise manager, and that as long as he could 
 keep ministers under his control, and induce them to indorse 
 slavery, rum-drinking, and the like, he would treat them 
 politely. Rum-sellers will not object to wearing out two or 
 three hats a year in bowing to ministers, provided they will 
 12
 
 154 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 keep silent, and let them carry on their work of death. Slave- 
 holders will be very complaisant and respectful to God's ser- 
 vants if they will but apologize for their system of iniquity, 
 occasionally come out with a defence of the practice, and allow 
 them to prescribe the topics which shall constitute the staple of 
 pnlpit ministrations. 
 
 When we reached Richmond we were met by a number of 
 the brethren, and accompanied to the house of Elder Jeter, with 
 whom we boarded. He was the pastor of the First church, 
 Elder Magoon of the Second, Elder Taylor was preaching in 
 the Third, and spending a part of his time in the service of the 
 Missionary Society. 
 
 I commenced with the First church, preaching day and 
 night to large congregations. The prospects continued to 
 brighten, and very many were beginning to yield to the power 
 of the truth. As soon, however, as I began to elevate the 
 standard of piety, and to labor to bring the church up to the 
 Bible idea of a devoted, working, holy people, I found that I 
 was bringing my batteries to bear against an impregnable 
 forfress of prejudice and error. They did not want a reforma- 
 tion ; they desired merely a revival, a season of religious sensa- 
 tionalism. I felt that the Lord bade me proclaim a fast ; but 
 they had no idea that it meant the breaking of every yoke, and 
 letting the oppressed go free. All of their fasting seemed to 
 me like solemn mockery. 
 
 I could hold my peace no longer ; the pastor was raising 
 boys and girls for market, like so many calves and pigs ; the 
 slave-pen was within the city corporation, and there men, and 
 women, and children, some of them members of the church, 
 were bought and sold every day ; husbands and wives were 
 torn asunder ; little children were dragged from the arms of 
 their mothers ; womanhood was denuded of its modesty, and 
 girls were sold for lust. The whipping-post was close to the 
 house of God, and the crack of the lash and the cries of the 
 slave victims mingled with the songs of devotion and the voice 
 of prayer
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 155 
 
 While I was there a band of colored brethren and sisters, 
 moved by the Spirit of God, met together in order to sing 
 praises and unite in supplication to the Lord. They were* 
 surprised by a set of devils (called officers of the peace !), and 
 those who could not escape were dragged to the whipping- 
 post, and lashed to laceration, for no other offence than daring 
 to meet without the presence of a white man. Throughout the 
 night the slave-hounds were on the scent for these victims, and 
 the hours were made hideous with their bowlings. It seemed 
 as if I was in Pandemonium. 
 
 How could I ask God to hear the prayers of such a people : 
 I knew that the churches and the ministers were involved in 
 this system of iniquity. I kept verging out gradually on thfs 
 great evil. I found those who had been brought up in New 
 England, and other Northern States, among the most strenuous 
 and bitter advocates of slavery. As I continued to preach, with 
 increasing plainness, the Bible doctrines concerning human 
 rights, and those which cut up this system root and branch, the 
 leading members became more and more uneasy. Some would 
 plead with me to pass over this subject, assuring me that, with 
 this exception, my preaching was popular with the community, 
 and that I might do great good if I would not dwell on this one 
 theme. But I could not refrain. 
 
 At length, after having preached about three weeks in the 
 First church, and about two weeks in the Second, I preached 
 a sermon on the moral government of God, in which I showed 
 that all the misery in the world arose from the violation of 
 God's laws. Our failures to love God supremely, and our 
 neighbors as ourselves, were infractions of his holy law ; and 
 that if we did love our neighbor as ourselves, we should not, 
 for example, be willing to enslave him, any more than we 
 should be willing to have him enslave us. The feeling through- 
 out the congregation was intense ; many came forward for 
 prayers, and the work was rolling on with increasing power. 
 
 On reaching my room, I was visited by a committee, and re- 
 quested to preach no more, unless I would promise to keep
 
 156 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF 
 
 silent on the subject of slavery. They professed fears for my 
 safety, and thought that the house would be burned down. I 
 told them that I would risk my life if they would risk their 
 house. I knew where the shoe pinched. The slaveholding 
 members were afraid that their non-slaveholding brethren would 
 get light and influence, and render the position of the slave- 
 holding party uncomfortable ; besides, they were in love with 
 their darling sin. The issue, however, was squarely made. I 
 had no choice, except to submit to their terms or leave. I 
 decided to leave. We sent for our clothes, which were out to be 
 washed, packed them up, wet from the tub, and started from 
 the place by six o'clock the next morning. We shook the dust 
 of the city from off our feet as a witness against them, and I 
 have not seen Richmond since.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 15 T 
 
 Jt 
 
 CHAPTER XVI. 
 
 ACCOUNTS OF PROTKACTED MEETINGS. 
 (CONTINUED.) 
 
 ERIE : A Universalist Meddler, and his Fate. An Irish Lad. 
 Nineteen Tears afterwards. OWEGO : Philettis Peck. Dews of 
 Grace. A model Church. A defiant Infidel. Wilfulness. 
 Departed Worthies. 
 
 ERIE. 
 
 IN the month of June, 1847, I arrived at Erie, Pa., then 
 comparatively a new town. The Baptist church was 
 struggling into existence, and was weak in every sense of the 
 word. I reached there on a Saturday, and began preaching on 
 the next day. There was a remarkable expression of interest 
 at the stai't. On the close of the evening sermon the Uni- 
 versalist minister arose, in the presence of the congregation, and 
 began to contradict what I had said. I spoke to him kindly, 
 reminding him that as that service was not of his appointment, 
 he had no right to interrupt its exercises, and requested him to 
 be seated. He replied, that he had as good a right to speak as 
 I had, and would speak as much as he pleased. Finding that 
 simple remonstrance was of no avail, I dropped on my knees, 
 requesting all the congregation to unite with me in prayer. I 
 prayed very earnestly, and specially asked God that, " if this 
 servant of the devil was within the reach of mercy, he might 
 be converted on the spot ; but if he was never to be converted, 
 that his mouth might be closed, so that he would not be able to 
 lead others down to hell." As soon as I arose from mj knees 
 he began to speak again, and I dismissed the meeting. The
 
 158 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 choir struck up a hymn, and I signified to the congregation to 
 retire. 
 
 He followed me to my lodgings, and declared " that he would 
 attend my meetings every night, and that I could not help 
 myself." I merely said, " There is a God in heaven who can 
 help me," and entered the house. I neither saw nor heard 
 more of him during my stay in the place. I was somewhat 
 surprised, and so were others, at his sudden subsiding. It was 
 generally supposed that he had left town ; but after my return 
 home, I received a letter from brother Smith, the pastor of the 
 Baptist church, stating that this Universalist minister lost his 
 power of speech on the very night on which I turned from him ; 
 that he had remained concealed, and that the Universalists had 
 sought to keep these facts from the knowledge of the com- 
 munity ; and that at the date of that letter, he was able to 
 speak only just above a whisper. I have inquired after him 
 occasionally, and have learned, from time to time, that he has 
 remained speechless for at least fifteen years. I have recently 
 heard that his power of speech is somewhat improving, but he 
 has never since, I believe, attempted to speak in public. This 
 statement can be corroborated by reference to some of the older 
 residents of the town. 
 
 This man was a great talker, and was very flippant in his 
 advocacy of his favorite dogma. And as the people were then 
 in a plastic taste, he was capable of doing much harm in leading 
 the youth astray. He was fond of challenging ministers to 
 debate with him, using " great swelling words," and making a 
 tumult ; like the Philistine of Gath, he defied the armies of 
 Israel. 
 
 Our meeting went on quietly after we had got rid of this 
 troubler, and large accessions were made to the Baptist church, 
 and also several additions to other denominations. 
 
 Among the converts was a poor Irish lad, whom, on a visit 
 nineteen years afterwards, I found to be a man worth a large 
 property, and devotedly engaged in promoting the interests of 
 the Savior's cause, and in all things proving himself to be a
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 159 
 
 pillar in the Baptist church, and zealously cooperating with his 
 pastor, brother Bainbridge, whose father I baptized in Pennyan 
 many years ago. The father was a faithful minister of Christ, 
 and who, after serving his generation, dropping his mantle on 
 the shoulder of his son, went up to his reward. O, how 
 earnestly I pray that God will uphold and honor the steps of the 
 son ! 
 
 OWEGO. 
 
 Near the close of 1848, brother Philetus Peck, son of Elder 
 John Peck, and the pastor of the Baptist church at Owego, 
 N. Y., was summoned to the bedside of his mother, who was 
 dying, the victim of an epidemic. His brother, Linus, then 
 preaching at Hamilton,. N. Y., was with him. In a few days 
 the two brothers were smitten down with the same disease, and 
 died. Linus was the younger of the two, had recently been 
 married to the daughter of Dr. Nathaniel Kendrick, and was 
 beginning his ministry under circumstances full of promise. 
 Philetus had been for several years pastor of the church at 
 Owego, and was beloved of all, having proven himself to be an 
 able preacher, a great-hearted man, and a sincere and humble 
 Christian. While the life of their beloved pastor was trembling 
 in the balance, the church was holding meetings of prayer for 
 his recovery. At one of these assemblings, the sad news came 
 upon them that their pastor was dead. Overwhelmed with the 
 grief that was inspired by the sincerest affection, the church 
 prostrated themselves before God, and besought him to 
 strengthen them to bear their great sorrow, and to sanctify it to 
 their greater devotion. 
 
 The gracious dews of heavenly grace began to fall on them 
 at once, and they sent a messenger for me to come among them 
 immediately. I had just returned from a long tour in the east, 
 and needed rest, but my heart went out to this smitten flock. I 
 could not understand the meaning of Providence in taking awaj- 
 a man in the midst of his days and of his usefulness, who, by 
 reason of his advanced views, was so eminently fitted to be a 
 leader of the people. I went at once, and found the field white
 
 1GO AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 for the harvest, and waiting only for the reaper's sickle. The 
 interest of the meeting was overwhelming. The church as a 
 body seemed to lay their all on the altar of God. I was 
 specially struck with the utter absence of social distinctions 
 among the brethren. The rich and well provided were careful 
 to invite their poorer brethren, and those living at a distance, 
 to their houses, in order that all might have opportunity to 
 share the blessings of the meetings. Never did I see elsewhere 
 such an exemplification of the command, " Have not the grace 
 of our Lord Jesus Christ with respect to persons." 
 
 The minds of the different brethren were as the mind of one 
 man. They came together " with one accord ; " they all pulled 
 one way ; they delighted to honor each other ; they worked 
 with all their might. 
 
 I preached day and night for some six weeks, and nearly three 
 hundred persons were added to the church, most of whom I 
 baptized before I left. 
 
 I remember that a hardened infidel, who had been accustomed 
 to curse ministers and churches, followed me to my lodgings 
 one night, keeping up an incessant tirade of abuse. As I was 
 stepping into the door, I remarked, " Well, my friend, I expect 
 to see you on the anxious-seat before long." He turned away, 
 exclaiming, " Never ! no, never." On the evening of the third 
 day after this conversation, whom should I see in the seats be- 
 fore me but this same man ! As I approached him, he asked, 
 "What shall I do? lam in deep trouble." I told him to 
 pray. He said, " I cannot pray ; / dare not pray." I replied, 
 " God is merciful ; go to Jesus, and ask him to forgive you." 
 He replied, " I have damned him to his face, and how can I 
 ask him for mercy. It seems to me, that the moment I 
 attempt to pray, the devil will take me right down to hell." I 
 told him to begin, and keep on praying, and the devil would not 
 carry him far, for he wanted no praying souls in hell. He 
 knelt, and made the attempt to pray. He would open his 
 mouth, and as he was about to speak his courage would fail 
 him, and he would sink down again. Throughout that night,
 
 ELDEB JACOB KNAPP. 161 
 
 and during a part of the next day, he continued in this horrible 
 condition ; at length he cried out to God to have mercy upon him 
 for the sake of Christ. God came to his relief, and he broke 
 forth in strains of joy as the consciousness of pardon and of 
 hope beamed on his soul. 
 
 A young lady, educated in the Congregational church, talented 
 and respected, but strong in her prejudices, was awakened to a 
 sense of her lost condition. After much hesitation she came 
 forward for prayers ; but when asked to rise, and express her 
 feelings, she replied, " I do not think it proper for women to 
 speak in public." A colored brother, who was within hearing, 
 remarked, " Well, I guess when you git the lub o' God in yer 
 heart, you'll be willin' to speak." She darted out of the seat, 
 and out of the house, remarking, " I am not going to be lectured 
 by negroes." She left us, and went to the Presbyterian and 
 Methodist meetings ; but at the end of a week she came back, 
 still burdened with anxiety and beclouded with darkness. She 
 summoned strength to rise and speak, still something held her 
 back. She told me that she was afraid that if converted in a 
 Baptist meeting, she would have to join a Baptist church. 
 Under this pretext she was allowing Satan to deceive her. 
 With this frivolous, sectarian excuse, she was trying to think 
 ' she had a reason why she should not give her heart to God. 
 At length she saw that her pride was her great hinderance. 
 She let go her sectarianism and her prejudices, and made an 
 unreserved surrender of herself to the will of Christ ; and in 
 the joy of her heart she sprang to her feet, and proclaimed, 
 in thrilling words, what the Lord had done for her soul. She 
 wanted to go down into the river and be baptized at once, 
 and could hardly wait till the church had voted to receive 
 her. 
 
 Among the precious memories of those days, I recall the 
 faces of father Pinney, and his dear wife and their sons, and 
 brother Tenman, and many others. How earnestly these aged 
 saints labored in the good work ! how lovingly they loved all
 
 162 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 who loved Christ, and sympathized with all classes of men ! 
 They have gone home, and " rest from their labors, but their 
 works do follow them." Ah, how short is life ! " It is even as 
 a vapor, which appeareth for a little time, and then vanisheth 
 away." How pertinent the admonition, " Whatsoever thy 
 hand findeth to do, do it with thy might."
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 163 
 
 CHAPTER XVII. 
 
 ACCOUNTS OF PKOTKACTED MEETINGS. 
 (CONTINUED.) 
 
 CHICAGO: First Church in 1849; in 1857. Conversions. Invi- 
 tation to a Ball. Wabash Avenue Church. Wbrdliness. ROCK- 
 FOKD: Removal to, in 1849. A Year's Labor in Bockford. CAN- 
 TON : In 1851. A Mind to Work. TJie Zeal of one Man. Im- 
 mediate Baptisms. " Hell upon Earth" 
 
 CHICAGO. 
 
 IN the month of June, 1849, for the first time I visited the 
 "West. I spent a few weeks in Chicago, 111., preaching to 
 the First Baptist church. They were without a pastor at the 
 time. I baptized about fifty persons, and searched out, and 
 gathered into the church, several who had been members of 
 eastern churches, but who had not identified themselves with 
 the cause in this place. Among these were some who are now 
 recognized among the most valuable of its members. 
 
 Subsequently I held two other meetings in this city, both of 
 which proved great blessings to the community. The third 
 meeting was held with the Wabash Avenue Baptist church. 
 
 The second meeting with the First church, about 18o7, 
 resulted in the conversion of many young men, among whom 
 were the children of the late Judge Thomas,* of Dr. Boone, 
 then mayor of the city, and of Hon. Charles Walker. 
 
 While this meeting was in progress I received a ticket from 
 the manager of a ball which was soon to come off. When I 
 entered the pulpit, I remarked that I had received an invitation 
 
 * One of whom is now the beloved pastor of the Pierrepont Street 
 Baptist churchf Brooklyn, N. Y.
 
 164 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF 
 
 to attend a ball that evening ; and inasmuch as I had not 
 attended one for more than thirty years, I thought I would go ; 
 that I would preach a short sermon, and wanted the brethren 
 to continue in prayer till my return. 
 
 Some wag in the gallery slipped out, and went over tQ the 
 ball-room, and told them that I was coming over there. One 
 of the company said, " O, you are joking." " No," replied 
 the young man, " I heard him say that he was coming at the 
 close of a short sermon." I took brother Walker with me. 
 Before we had reached the place some had left j and as we got 
 there, some were going into the yard, and some were running 
 up and down stairs. The young ladies were begging the gen- 
 tlemen to take them home. Several, however, made a show 
 of determination to keep up the dance. But they made bad 
 work of it. There was music enough in the fiddles, but the 
 fiddlers could not get it out. Their limbs trembled, and the 
 dance was not up to time. I made a few remarks, spent a 
 season in prayer, and invited them to come and hear me preach 
 on the subject of dancing on the next Friday evening. Very 
 many of them did so ; and I hope that they were made wiser 
 and better. I think that about seventy persons were baptized 
 into the fellowship of the First church, as the result of this 
 meeting. 
 
 Brother Edwards was preaching at the same time to the 
 Second church, and a good work was done there. 
 
 My meeting in the Wabash Avenue church took place in 
 1862. The war excitement was running high, and the spirit 
 of speculation higher. Many brethren of business could not 
 find time to attend except on the Sabbath. Even brethren who 
 had been converted under my ministry, or whose children had 
 been, and who personally felt a great interest in me, were so 
 engaged in their worldly pursuits, that they felt justified in 
 excusing themselves from the work of the Lord. As might be 
 expected, the work was not general. Still our labors were not 
 without considerable fruit, and seed was sown that may yet 
 bear a plentiful harvest.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 165 
 
 ROCKFORD. 
 
 la the month of October, 1849, I reached Rockford, 111., 
 with my family, and located them about four miles from the 
 town. 
 
 The Baptist church in Rockford was quite small. They had 
 a little wooden building, which might, by crowding, hold two 
 hundred persons. Yet this was larger than the size of the con- 
 gregation ordinarily required. The pulpit was being supplied 
 by Professor S. S. Whitman, who lived in Belvidere. But his 
 health was failing, and in a short time " he fell on sleep." I 
 felt a deep interest in this little church, and consented to preach 
 for them during the fall and winter. In the winter I preached 
 forty sermons, in nightly succession, and rode home after each 
 sermon. 
 
 In a short time we were crowded out of our small quarters, 
 and secured the use of the Court House until the present com- 
 modious stone edifice was completed. I baptized eighty persons 
 into the fellowship of this church. I remained with them nearly 
 a whole year, until the new house was finished, and then they 
 secured the services of Elder Ichabod Clarke, and I resumed 
 my labors as an evangelist. 
 
 CANTON. 
 
 In the autumn of 1851, I commenced a meeting in Canton, 
 111. The Baptist church was under the pastoral care of brother 
 W. G. Miner. There was no special religious interest in the 
 community when we began, but the pastor and brethren took 
 hold with a hearty good will, and the Spirit of God came down 
 with great power. We gave the trumpet a certain sound, and 
 the people prepared themselves for battle. Some squirmed 
 under the truth, and quailed before the grape-shot which flew in 
 every direction ; sinners cried out for mercy, and crowded round 
 " the anxious seats." The weather was very unpleasant, the mud 
 being almost knee deep, and the roads nearly impassable ; never- 
 theless the people met, and men and women kf.pt pouring in from
 
 166 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 all the surrounding region. Two brethren kept their teams 
 constantly engaged in carrying the people to and from the 
 meeting. The house soon became too small for the throngs 
 that gathered to hear the word. In one single day lumber was 
 brought on to the ground, and addition made to the building, 
 so that the crowd at night found the borders of our habitation 
 enlarged for their accommodation. 
 
 As an instance of the zeal of the brethren, I will mention 
 the case of an aged saint, who lived some distance from town, 
 and became so interested that he built a little room in the place, 
 so that he and his wife might enjoy all the services. He 
 became so greatly concerned on account of his children and 
 grandchildren, that he started on a journey, eighteen miles, in 
 order to talk with them on the concerns of their souls. He in- 
 duced many of them, and of their neighbors, to come to the 
 meetings, and about twenty persons were brought to Christ in 
 that neighborhood as the reward of his fidelity. How easy it 
 is to do good, and how much good can be done by the feeblest 
 instrumentalities ! 
 
 It was our custom to follow close upon the heels of the 
 apostles in the baptizing of converts. When one rose up, re- 
 joicing in the blessed Savior, the church would vote him right in, 
 and we baptized him. In one week brother Miner and myself 
 baptized seventy persons, who, during the same week, professed 
 to have experienced a change of heart. Before the work 
 ceased, three hundred were " added to the church," and the 
 number of communicants amounted to six hundred. This sea- 
 son was a memorable epoch in the history of Canton. 
 
 At its close, when my mind was wrought up to the height 
 of a blissful experience of communion with God and heaven, 
 I was compelled to pass a night, on my return home, at a little, 
 low grog-shop of a shanty, which was the only lodging-place the 
 spot afforded. Drunkards and sweai'ers were congregated in 
 the room where I was obliged to sit, and they made the night 
 hideous with their cursings and obscenities. It seemed as if 
 they were exhausting the vocabulary of blasphemy. Their Ian-
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 167 
 
 guage was the dialect of perdition, and the scene formed such 
 a contrast with the rapture with which I had been exalted, that 
 it seemed to me to be itself a hell upon earth. Twice, as I fell 
 into a doze, I was awakened by their carousals, and for the 
 moment I thought I was verily in hell ; and I opened my eyes, 
 expecting to see the devil himself. When fully restored to 
 wakefulness, I lifted up to God the prayer, " Gather not my 
 soul with sinners."
 
 168 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 CHAPTER XVIII. 
 
 ACCOUNTS OF PROTRACTED MEETINGS. 
 (CONTINUED.) 
 
 ST. Louis : Sparks from the One Altar. Disparagement. Great 
 Ingathering. Giving the Hand of Fellowship. A new Church 
 formed. Its Dismemberment. MIDLETOWN : Pecuniary Induce- 
 ments. Hesitation about going. Prayers for the Devil. Obey- 
 ing Orders. - Results. Meeting in 1864. Youngest Son convert- 
 ed. LOUISVILLE : Sensitiveness of the People concerning Slavery. 
 Apprehensions. Signs of Success. A Dream, and its Inter- 
 pretation. Notice to leave. 
 
 ST. Louis. 
 
 IN the winter of the year 1858, I was invited to hold a meet- 
 ing in the Second Baptist church, in St. Louis, -Mo., then 
 destitute of a pastor. Though the church was in a low estate, 
 I found much excellent material in it. As soon as prayer and 
 preaching were maintained day and night, the members began 
 to be interested, and came up to the work with zest. Converts 
 were multiplied. The other churches began to catch the spii-it ; 
 especially was this true of the Third church, where a blessed 
 outpouring of the Spirit was enjoyed. 
 
 Some one wrote an article in the Christian Times, in which 
 he announced that other churches were enjoying a precious 
 visitation of grace almost as great as that with which the Second 
 church was being favored. The tone of the article was impli- 
 edly calculated to insinuate disparagement on my labors. He 
 did not, or would not, see that other altars had been kindled 
 from sparks from off the altar before which we were ministering, 
 and that others were reaping a harvest which had resulted from 
 the breaking up of the fallow ground in the first instance. We
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 180 
 
 made no reply ; for the work was all of God, and to him be- 
 longed all the glory. He that planteth and he that watereth 
 are nothing ; but God, who giveth the increase, is all and in all. 
 
 On the last day of my labors with the Second church I 
 extended the hand of fellowship to one hundred and fifty per- 
 sons. The scene was admitted to be among the most soul- 
 stirring that had ever been witnessed in the city. In the first 
 place, after arranging the candidates along the outside aisle, 
 the members sitting in the centre pews, I gave to each the hand 
 of welcome, and made to each person a few appropriate remarks ; 
 then the members of the church formed into line, and passed 
 along the line, and shook hands with each of the converts ; all 
 singing beautiful revival tunes as they went through the cere- 
 mony of greeting. The house was crowded, and many shed 
 tears, and many were pricked in their hearts. 
 
 Many of the members of the church, both old and new, were 
 strongly impressed with the conviction that the time had come 
 in which to form a new church. There was wealth and talent 
 sufficient to warrant it, and souls enough to demand it. After 
 I had left, and had entered on another field, a delegation came to 
 solicit my presence and counsel in the enterprise. Though the 
 Second church, as a body, did not seem to favor the movement, 
 yet it seemed to me that the general interests of the cause would 
 be promoted if its forces were divided (for I never did think 
 it best to plant all the corn in one hill) ; besides, the necessities 
 of that growing city made the starting of another church a duty. 
 Brother Nelson had secured a good church building, in a good 
 location, at a very great bargain. I therefore went, and called 
 together all who were willing to embark in the enterprise. A 
 church was organized at once. I remained with them some 
 four months, and at the end of that time the additions, by letter 
 and baptisms, numbered two hundred persons. 
 
 On my departure, I helped them to secure the services of a 
 
 well-known and highly-esteemed brother for six months. At 
 
 the expiration of that time, the demands made on him from other 
 
 quarters seemed to call him away. Then followed seasons of 
 
 18
 
 170 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 discouragement and difficulty, which finally led to the disband- 
 ing of the church, and the return of the members into the other 
 churches. 
 
 MIDDLETOWN. 
 
 In the month of March, 1859, I visited Middletown, Ohio. 
 A good brother, more than twenty years before, had urged me 
 strongly to hold a meeting in this town. He had offered to give 
 me one hundred dollars over and above what the church might 
 do, if I would only come. But on that account, as well as for 
 other reasons, I would not go, lest I might, even unconsciously, 
 be actuated by a mercenary spirit. For the same reason I 
 declined a call to another place, where I was offered one hun- 
 dred and sixty acres of good land in the State of Illinois by one 
 man. I never answered his letter. I have always been anxious 
 to go where I thought I could do the most good, without any 
 regard to my compensation ; and I have often found that where 
 there has been the least prospect of being well compensated I 
 have fared the best. 
 
 But at length I felt it to be my duty to go to Middletown. I 
 found this dear brother's heart, house, and purse all open to do 
 anything for Jesus. At the beginning of the meeting, I re- 
 marked, that I wished all to suspend their judgments about the 
 preaching until they had heard twenty sermons ; that I did not 
 always preach alike, and often did not like my own preaching ; 
 and that, if at the end of that time they did not feel themselves 
 profited, I would excuse them. 
 
 A man of distinction in the town, and professedly an infidel, 
 said, as also did many others, that my request was quite reason- 
 able, and that he would comply with it, and attend steadily. 
 While many were sending in requests for prayers, he sent in 
 one, to the effect that " the devil might be converted," adding, 
 that he thought that if the devil was converted, others might be 
 more easily reached. I read the request, and gave notice that, 
 on a given night, I would preach a sermon, showing " why it 
 was necessary that there should be a devil." The night came, 
 and the house was crowded. This infidel lawyer was on hand,
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 171 
 
 and beginning to give signs of a concern which he could not 
 conceal. A few days afterwards, I said to him, " Mr. D., you 
 are a lawyer, and I am a minister. If I had an important case 
 to be tried before a civil court, I should commit it into your 
 hands, and follow your advice, because I know that in such 
 matters your judgment would be better than mine. Is it not 
 reasonable that you should take my advice in religious matters, 
 seeing they have been the study and business of my life?" His 
 answer was, " Well, that looks reasonable ; I will do it." 
 " Now," said I, " come out, and take the seat for prayers." 
 He did so. At the close of the meeting that evening I begged 
 him to pray with his family before he retired. He agreed to 
 do so. As he sat by the side of his wife, who was a Christian, 
 before the fire, the cross seemed like the weight of a mountain. 
 He afterwards told me, that if he could have chosen between 
 kneeling in prayer and throwing a thousand bank bills into the 
 stove, he would gladly have done the latter. But, true to his 
 promise, he bowed himself in prayer for the first time in his 
 life, and there Jesus met him. His burden left him, and he 
 rejoiced in the Savior. He has made a useful Christian from 
 that day to this. 
 
 There were between seventy and eighty persons converted, 
 and added to the church, during this revival. In a meeting 
 with this church, at a later period (1864), about the same 
 number were again brought into the church.. In each of these, 
 persons joined who were influential members of society. And 
 now the church is a strong and able body. 
 
 This people, as have many other, became very dear to me, by 
 reason of the precious seasons I enjoyed with them ; especially 
 because it was here (1864) that my youngest son, Luther, was 
 born again. 
 
 LOUISVILLE. 
 
 Shortly after the settlement of brother W. W. Everts, as 
 pastor of the Walnut Street Baptist church, in Louisville, Ky., 
 I was sent for. This was in the year 1856. 
 
 I knew that, Kentucky being a slave state, I should be ex-
 
 172 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 posed to serious liabilities of difficulty. The prejudices of the 
 people were very strong, and their sensitiveness quickened by 
 reason of the political excitement that was then beginning to 
 rage all over the country on account of this subject. But the 
 remembrance of the blessed seasons that I had enjoyed with 
 brother Everts, in Mulberry Street, New York city, kindled 
 within me a desire to renew my intercourse with a brother 
 whom I so highly esteemed. I persuaded myself that perchance 
 the way would be smoothed before me, so that I should share 
 in a marvellous display of God's grace. I therefore resolved 
 to go. 
 
 Very soon there appeared to prevail throughout the city a 
 seriousness on the subject of religion, and very many, especially 
 the young, came forward for prayers, and converts were be- 
 ginning to be multiplied. 
 
 I found the membership of this church to be composed of 
 two classes, earnest pro-slavery, and strong anti-slavery men ; 
 who, however, had come to the mutual agreement that noth- 
 ing should be said on the subject of slavery, either for or 
 against. A former pastor a northern man had sought to 
 conciliate the people by preaching in favor of slavery ; but the 
 church, consistent with itself, had dismissed him. Brother 
 Everts and myself, after consulting together, in view of this 
 peculiar state of things, concluded that it would not be wise 
 for me to come out against slavery at once. The attempt might 
 jeopardize the meeting, and fail to do as much good as the 
 same remarks might effect when I had gained a better hold on 
 the people. Still I could not bring my conscience to consent to 
 an entire silence on the subject. So I concluded to say nothing 
 about it till near the close of the meeting, when God had given 
 me many souls as seals of my ministry. I purposed to preach 
 on the subject in one discourse only, and give such advice as my 
 age and experience would qualify me to give and prepare them 
 to receive. 
 
 By some means, however, my intentions got whispered around. 
 The devil rallied all his forces among the slaveholding mem-
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 173 
 
 bers, and excited the prejudices and fears of the people. They 
 became uneasy, and were expecting that in my " next" sermon 
 I would open my batteries on their peculiar and pet institution. 
 On one occasion, I merely quoted the simple text, " Think not 
 that I am come to send peace on the earth ; I came not to send 
 peace, but a sword." Instantly their pro-slavery sympathies 
 took the alarm. 
 
 A change, which I had felt to be coming over the people, 
 now became more marked than ever. A studied reserve and 
 avoidance seemed to characterize the deportment of many ; a 
 cloud appeared to hang over the meetings ; the wheels of salva- 
 tion were clogged. My soul was bowed down. I prayed and 
 fasted often. I sought to know the mind of God as to what 
 course I should pursue. At length, one night I had a sort of 
 dream, or vision. I saw myself standing on the edge of a race- 
 way, filled with all kinds and sizes of fish. I stepped into the 
 water, and found them so plentiful, and withal so tarne, that 
 they gathered around and touched my limbs. I was able to 
 take up and throw them on the bank as fast as others could take' 
 care of them. While thus engaged, some one, whom I did not 
 clearly recognize, went below and shut down the gate, when, in 
 an instant, the whole school of fish turned round, and moved up, 
 and glided into the main stream, and went off beyond my reach. 
 I had caught but few, and my hopes were blasted. I awoke 
 with a feeling of sadness ; a premonition of trouble. 
 
 On the next night, after the sermon, a paper was handed to 
 me, which contained a communication, signed by some of the 
 deacons and leading members, expressing the opinion that the 
 work was now well under way, and requesting me to retire, and 
 leave the meetings in the hands of the pastor. Of course the 
 gate was shut. I remembered my dream, and saw the interpre- 
 tation thereof. 
 
 My indignation at the injustice with which I was treated, 
 yielded to my grief at their own blindness and insensibility to 
 the blessings which God was willipg to bestow upon them. I 
 thought of the many souls that might have been saved ; and as
 
 174 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 I realized how easily they might have been reached, and that 
 now they were thrown off into the broad stream of death, my 
 heart was melted in grief. The everlasting well-being of mul- 
 titudes, the honor of the cause of Christ, had been deliberately 
 sacrified to the Moloch of slavery. 
 
 Many of the church were indignant, and even some of the 
 old Kentucky families wept like children, as they thought of 
 this unkindness. The next day was rainy and gloomy. I 
 crossed the river, feeling myself forsaken, sad, and desolate. I 
 remained standing on the opposite bank in the rain, deliberating 
 whether or not I should go back and open a meeting in some 
 other part of the town, and see if God would not come to my 
 help, and shake the city ; but finally concluded to shake the 
 dust off my feet, and turn my back on the place. I understood, 
 better than ever before, the feelings of the Savior when he wept 
 at sight of Jerusalem, and uttered his lament over its inevitable 
 fate.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 175 
 
 CHAPTER XIX. 
 
 ACCOUNTS OF PROTEACTED MEETINGS. 
 (CONTINUED.) 
 
 BOSTON : Baldwin Place Church. Changes in Nineteen Tears. 
 Self-Examination. Discouragements. Union Church. Great 
 Work. A genuine Convert. Presence of God. Tremont 
 Temple Church. Sinless Perfection, and the lack of it. Con- 
 version of a Universalist Preacher. Farewell Sermon in Bowdoin 
 Square Church. A working Church. 
 
 BOSTON. 
 
 IN the autumn of 1860, I was again invited to visit Boston, 
 Mass. The request came from the Baldwin Place and 
 Union churches. 
 
 I began with the Baldwin Place church. I preached day and 
 night, and had good, but not crowded congregations. The 
 lapse of nineteen years had wrought many changes. In the 
 first place, the tide of population had set in on the South End ; 
 the surroundings of Baldwin Place were occupied by stores and 
 warehouses, and foreigners. In the next place, many of those 
 whose cooperation I had enjoyed had passed to their reward. 
 Again, others had become lukewarm, and many had imbibed 
 prejudices against protracted efforts, especially if conducted by 
 outside agency ; while others, though sympathizing with me 
 and my work, had become too old and feeble to render me 
 much assistance. Among these I may mention brethren 
 Wilbur, Gilbert, and Hill. Withal the church itself was very 
 much reduced in numbers and efficiency, having only two or 
 three who were earnest and available co-workers ; and these
 
 176 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 few faithful men were embarrassed by reason of the serious 
 faultiness of one who occupied the position of a leader in Israel, 
 but failed sadly to come up to the help of the Lord, and 
 whose inconsistencies were beginning to awaken anxiety and 
 alarm. 
 
 The contrast between this and my former visit brought great 
 sorrow to my soul, but I resolved to consecrate myself un- 
 reservedly to God. I fasted and prayed day and night; I 
 instituted a new and strict self-examination ; scrutinized my 
 motives ; reviewed my whole course of labors, and prayed to 
 know all my defects. I asked God to show me if the tone of 
 my preaching had been too severe ; whether I had indulged in 
 a censorious spirit in my remarks concerning ministers or the 
 people, especially concerning those who had opposed me. In 
 short, I inquired of the Lord to show me what change in my 
 course would be agreeable to his will, or was demanded by the 
 different state of public feeling. I think I sincerely desired to 
 know and do the will of God. 
 
 After trying to accomplish something at Baldwin Place, I 
 became satisfied that it was not my duty to continue there any 
 longer. I therefore gave them notice of my intention to leave, 
 and forthwith began a series of meetings with the Union church 
 in Merrimac Street. 
 
 Here the work of the Lord broke out with great power. 
 " The people had a mind to work." Brother Chipman paid the 
 salary of a brother, whom he engaged to devote his entire time 
 in going from house to house, talking and praying with the 
 people, and inducing persons to attend the meetings and seek 
 salvation. He was also quite prominent in providing the sup- 
 port of a brother who preached in Globe Hall, and labored 
 among the most degraded classes of the city. 
 
 The interest extended over to Cambridgeport and Charlestown. 
 Very many of the most hardened sinners were converted, 
 especially as the result of the meetings held in the hall. One 
 man, who had been a pirate, and others, whose lives had been 
 given up to unrestrained wickedness, were converted. There
 
 ELDEK JACOB KNAPP. 177 
 
 was one marked case. A man of more than ordinary talent, 
 and of natural generosity, one whom we could call " whole- 
 souled," and who had been a rum-seller for twenty years, 
 and, as might be supposed, a confirmed Universalist, came into 
 our meetings. Once he was in comfortable circumstances and 
 respectable, but now his family were reduced to want, and he 
 became a sot. He was deeply convicted, and on one occasion 
 took three glasses of brandy in order to put an end to his misery. 
 He went home, laid himself on the floor, and waited for death ; 
 but the distress of his mind was more powerful than the brandy. 
 At length he was constrained to send for some one to come and 
 pray for him. He became a very humble and earnest Christian, 
 and was especially successful in bringing his former associates 
 to listen to the preached word. He spent his whole time among 
 tipplers, drunkards, and drunkard makers, striving to lead them 
 to Jesus. He rose up early in the mornings, and went on from 
 day to day. One day his wife told him that there was nothing 
 for dinner. His faith in God was such, that he assured her 
 that God would provide for those who were intent on doing his 
 will. As he turned to leave, he espied a five-dollar bill which 
 some one had thrust in under the door. On another occasion, 
 his wife reminded him that the rent was due. He gave her a 
 similar answer, and a few minutes afterwards a friend sent to 
 the house money enough to meet the rent. In this trustful way 
 he worked all winter. His daily wants were provided for, and 
 he was busy in winning souls. It is needless to say that his 
 labors were crowned with great success. 
 
 During this meeting I enjoyed very much of the presence of 
 God. The brethren would set apart special days of consecra- 
 tion, and pray for the descent of the Spirit on those particular 
 days ; and on those occasions the very atmosphere seemed 
 impregnated with the divine influence.^ No one could come 
 into the room where we were without recognizing the presence 
 of God. At times it seemed as if I was overwhelmed with the 
 gracious fulness of God, and that my poor and limited faculties 
 coukl bear no more. The tide of salvation rose higher and
 
 178 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 higher. Converts were multiplied by scores and by hundreds. 
 Our place of worship became too small for us, and it was 
 thought best for me to move to some other part of the city. I 
 remember, with great satisfaction, the warm-hearted coopera- 
 tion of brother D. M. Crane, the pastor. I labored with the 
 Union church about ten weeks. 
 
 After some consultation I concluded to go to the Tremont 
 Temple. The pastor of this church was about to be absent for 
 several months, and the location being central, and accessible 
 from all parts, rendered the opportunity very desirable. On 
 Sundays I preached in the main avidience-room, and during the 
 week in the Meionaon, a hall in the building, which will hold 
 eight hundred persons. Many of the brethren and sisters who 
 had worked in the Union church came with me to the Temple. 
 Enough remained behind to keep the work going on there. 
 
 At this place I met with some who thought they had reached 
 a state of entire sanctification. As for myself, I was never 
 troubled with too much holiness ; my difficulty has rather been 
 the want of it. I encourage all to believe in the doctrine as 
 much as they please, and practise it all they can. I have 
 believed, for many years, that there was no law of God that 
 we were obliged to break ; no command that we could not 
 keep ; and, for months together, I have thought that my entire 
 will was swallowed in the divine will, and my soul was filled 
 " with joy unspeakable, and full of glory ; " still, at times, I 
 could detect in myself some lurkings of ambition for the honors 
 of men, or of more regard to my own indulgence or interest 
 than was compatible with a state of sinless perfection. In 
 short, I have never reached a condition in my religious experi- 
 ence wherein I have come to regard the repetition of the prayer, 
 " Forgive us our sins," as a superfluous or inappropriate utter- 
 ance. 
 
 A man who had been preaching Universalism, and lecturing 
 on temperance throughout New England, came into the Temple 
 full of a resolution to expose my errors ; but he had not been 
 in the room long before he began to perceive his own. He
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 179 
 
 resisted, for a time, his convictions, and though " almost," was 
 not quite " persuaded " to renounce his former views. While 
 in this vacillating condition his eyesight became dim ; his 
 strength began to fail him ; he started for his boarding-place, 
 and when he reached the house he was so bewildered, and his 
 sight had so failed him, that he was compelled to call for help 
 He passed a sleepless night, and made a solemn promise to the 
 Lord, that if he would preserve his life until morning, he would 
 publicly renounce his errors, and devote his life to trying to 
 undo the evil he had done. He continued to be blind, or nearly 
 so, during all the next day ; in the evening he was in the meet- 
 ing, and he arose, confessed his sins, renounced his false 
 doctrines, and begged for prayers. He remained, however, in 
 a despondent state of mind for two or three days. He seemed 
 to think that even if God were to forgive him, he could never 
 forgive himself on account of the injury he had done in leading 
 so many astray. This reflection was the great sorrow of his 
 heart. He could neither think nor talk of anything else. 
 Even after he had obtained a sense of pardon, through the 
 atonement of Christ, the prevailing state of his mind was that 
 of self-reproach. 
 
 After preaching one evening on the subject of " Parkerism," 
 I called on him to relate his experience, but the infidels in the 
 congregation would not listen to him. Their master, the devil, 
 dare not risk them under such an exposure. I was compelled 
 to close the meeting. As he thought how much he had done 
 to fit men for destruction, he " wept bitterly." 
 
 I preached in the Temple five weeks, and those who took 
 note of the progress of the work, told me that, as the result of 
 the two meetings, there had been five hundred souls con- 
 verted. 
 
 I preached my farewell sermon in the large house in 
 Bowdoin Square, in which, nineteen years before, I had been 
 permitted to proclaim the truth of God, though surrounded by 
 an infuriated mob.
 
 180 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 Since then the Tremont Temple and Union churches have 
 united, and now meet in the Temple. A noble band of devoted, 
 self-sacrificing servants of God are there, devising liberal things 
 for the spread of the gospel, and cordially cooperating with 
 their beloved pastor, brother J. D. Fulton, in every good word 
 and work.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 181 
 
 CHAPTER XX. 
 
 ACCOUNTS OF PROTRACTED MEETINGS. 
 (CONTINUED.) 
 
 WILMINGTON: A former Visit. Present Meeting of great Power. 
 A new Church started. PHILADELPHIA : The Bethel. A floating 
 Church. Many Conversions. The Fourth Baptist Church. A 
 happy Birthday. Great Results. Interesting Conversions. 
 Valuable Accessions. NEWARK : Harmonious Churches. General 
 Interest. Union Prayer-Meeting. ELIZABETH : A Threefold 
 Call. A divine Answer. NEW YORK CITY: A Contrast. 
 Business and Religion. A Farewell Service. Labors in other 
 Places. TRENTON : Baptism of Children. Numerous Con- 
 versions. Ablessed Season. Reflections. Going to California. 
 
 WILMINGTON. 
 
 IN the year 1844, I held a meeting with the Second Baptist 
 church in Wilmington, Del., then under the care of the late 
 Morgan J. Rhees, in which about two hundred souls were con- 
 verted. 
 
 Near the beginning of January, 1865, I was again invited to 
 the same church, at the instance of the pastor, brother James 
 S. Dickerson. Brother Dickerson was converted under my 
 ministry twenty-five years before, in the Mulberry Street meet- 
 ing, New York. 
 
 I had not preached long before the meetings became very 
 interesting. Every night witnessed new cases for prayer, and 
 new instances of conversion. After dismissing the meetings the 
 people were loath to leave, and all seemed intent in talking with 
 the convicted and encouraging the converted. 
 
 At first the conversions occurred mostly among the women,
 
 182 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 especially among the young ladies connected with the Suivduy 
 school. But very soon the young men began to be interested, 
 and finally many from the ranks of the more advanced in age, 
 both men and women, were brought to bow to the power of the 
 cross. 
 
 This blessed work went on until two hundred were baptized 
 into the fellowship of the church ; and before I left the place 
 preparations were made for starting another church, and a lot 
 was secured with that end in view. Since then the new church 
 has been constituted, and has a pastor. 
 
 PHILADELPHIA. 
 
 On the 22d day of October, 1865, I commenced a meeting 
 with the Bethel Baptist church in Philadelphia, Pa. I found 
 the pastor, brother J. M. Perry, to be a warm-hearted man, 
 ready to do anything for the salvation of sinners. The church 
 had a small congregation, because so many of the members did 
 " business on the great waters." In fact it may be termed a 
 floating church : its members are to be found in every part of 
 the globe. Many of them belong to the United States navy, 
 and are liable to be called away in the service at any moment, 
 and likely to remain away for years at a time. Still there 
 seems always to be a few on land, who are ready to labor to keep 
 up the organization, and continue the power of the church to do 
 good. 
 
 I preached in the Bethel five weeks, during which time 
 seventy-five persons were baptized ; and after I left the work, 
 it went on under the labors of brother Perry, until nearly two 
 hundred converts were added to the church as the fruit of this 
 revival. Several of these were officers in the military and 
 marine service. 
 
 On the Lord's day, December 3, 1865, I commenced a 
 meeting in the Fourth Baptist church, under the care of brother 
 R. Jeffery. Here I preached every night, at half past seven 
 o'clock, having a prayer-meeting before and after the sei'mon. 
 
 In my journal, under date of the 7th of this mouth, I
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 183 
 
 say, " This is my birthday, and also the day of national 
 thanksgiving. I preached in the afternoon on the ' Goodness 
 of God,' and in the evening on ' God's love to man.' This 
 has been truly a blessed day to my soul the most happy 
 birthday I have ever enjoyed. Have had great liberty in 
 preaching. Three souls were converted the first fruits of the 
 meeting. All day long my heart has been overflowing with 
 gratitude to God : first, for a good constitution ; second, because 
 I was born in a Christian land ; third, for a fair education ; 
 fcmrth, for the experience of the new birth ; fifth, because God 
 has ' counted me worthy ' putting me into the ministry ; sixth, 
 for the great success which has attended my efforts to win souls 
 to Christ." 
 
 I preached in this church seven weeks. On the last Sabbath 
 of my stay the pastor gave the hand of fellowship to ninety- 
 three persons, eighty-seven of whom had been baptized during 
 the month ; and the work continued for several weeks longer, 
 until two hundred souls were converted, and added to the 
 church. 
 
 There were numerous instances of interesting conversions. 
 One fine-looking German rose in one of the meetings, and in 
 broken language, but eloquent in earnest simplicity, related how 
 he had been educated a Romanist, but had been induced to read 
 the Bible at the solicitation of his servant girl, a member of 
 that church, and had from her learned of the way of salvation 
 through Christ, and that he had come to that meeting with a 
 determination to profess Christ at once. He came out clearly 
 into the light, and remains to this day steadfast in his zeal for 
 Christ. 
 
 A young man related that he had been a drunkard, and 
 addicted to every vice, but had recently been led, by the preach- 
 ing of Elder Knapp, to reform, and seek forgiveness of the 
 Savior. Since then he had computed the amount which he had 
 been accustomed to spend in drink, and resolved to dedicate 
 that sum to the cause of Christ. He used to spend fifty cents 
 a day for liquor, and he thought lie ought now to devote as 
 much for the spread of the gospel.
 
 184 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 Among the accessions to the church in connection with this 
 meeting were several persons of education ancf influence in the 
 community, and in working power the church received great 
 strength. 
 
 When I came to Philadelphia I was strongly in hopes that 
 the way would be opened for my remaining until the whole city 
 was roused up, and at least twenty thousand souls were con- 
 verted. But I found the people of Philadelphia slow to move, 
 tenacious of their own way of doing things, and satisfied tc 
 trudge along " in the way their fathers trod." Some other of 
 the churches talked somewhat of asking me to visit them, but 
 were so long in coming to a decision that I was unable to wait 
 their movements. I closed my labors with the Fourth church, 
 Philadelphia, on one day, and commenced on the next with one 
 of the churches ill 
 
 NEWARK, N. J. 
 
 There are five Baptist churches in this city. All move on in 
 delightful harmony with each other. The several pastors agreed 
 to unite in the effort, as far as their distances from each other 
 would permit. I commenced preaching in the First church, 
 brother H. C. Fish, pastor, and in the evening at the church of 
 which brother J. M. Levy is pastor. This arrangement was 
 continued for two weeks. I preached one week in the Fifth 
 church, and four weeks in brother Levy's church. In all, there 
 were converted, and added to the Baptist churches, between 
 three and four hundred souls. Besides, the truth of God took 
 hold of all the people, and churches of other names opened their 
 doors, and commenced extra meetings, at which hundreds of 
 persons were brought to Christ. 
 
 In the progress of this meeting all the Baptist churches met 
 together, " with one accord, in one place, to make prayer and 
 supplication." The Spirit came down with Pentecostal power. 
 The pastors led the way, confessing their sins. The entire day, 
 until three o'clock in the afternoon, was spent in mutual con- 
 fessions and earnest prayers. At that hour I preached a sermon 
 about breaking up the fallow ground. I preached again in the
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 185 
 
 evening, having abstained from food all day. I felt no in- 
 convenience by reason of my abstinence, but great elevation 
 of soul in my communions with God, and great satisfaction in 
 eating of the manna which fell from heaven. 
 
 While laboring in this place, I received a peculiar call from 
 the people of the neighboring city of 
 
 ELIZABETH. 
 
 I was invited, first, by a unanimous call from the church and 
 pastor ; second, from a company of unconverted young men ; 
 third, from a circle of young ladies who had not yet professed 
 Christ. Though pressed with invitations to go to other places, 
 these singular coincidences impressed me with the conviction 
 that I ought to recognize this call. I therefore went, and 
 preached two weeks, night and day. Nearly all the young 
 gentlemen and ladies referred to were converted, besides many 
 others. The faithful little band of God's people in this place 
 were greatly strengthened. 
 
 NEW YORK CITY. 
 
 On the 24th day of March, 1866, I found myself about 
 to commence, once more, a campaign in the city of New 
 York. 
 
 I began in the Laight Street church, brother R. McDougal, 
 pastor. 
 
 My return to the city, after an absence of more than twenty 
 years, was very cordial. Fifteen ministers came to hear me 
 preach on the first afternoon, and to bid me welcome. Several 
 of them had been converted under my ministry, and three of 
 them had been baptized by me. During my stay here, I was 
 called upon daily by very many Christians from all parts of the 
 city and state, who ascribed their conversions, under God, to my 
 labors. 
 
 My heart was very much affected by these soul-stirring 
 interviews. The goodness of God shone before me with a new 
 lustre. I remembered the time when I first came to the city, 
 14
 
 186 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 and the distrust with which my labors were regarded, and the 
 purposed neglect with which I was treated ; and as I felt the 
 contrast, my heart was melted in gratitude to God for the 
 change, and that he had permitted me to live to see it. The 
 entire order of things is changed. Nearly all the ministers 
 who now occupy the pulpits of the city, and, in fact, of the 
 denomination throughout the country, were converted in pro- 
 tracted meetings, or in connection with revival measures. If 
 all things in the churches had continued as they were in 1834, 
 I wonder where the supply of ministers would have come from. 
 Rather, I may ask, would there have been churches enough to 
 have engaged the few ministers that would have remained to 
 us ? I do not claim that the change is owing to my labors, but 
 I do say, that the very measures which I introduced, and on 
 account of which I suffered persecution, are now almost uni- 
 versally adopted and relied upon as those on which the blessing 
 of God is most likely to rest. As these thoughts were revived 
 in my mind by these kind assurances, I felt like appropriating 
 the prayer of good old Simeon : " Lord, now lettest thy servant 
 depart in peace, for mine eyes have seen thy salvation." 
 
 I continued preaching, every afternoon and evening, for four 
 weeks. I preached, also, a few sermons in several of the other 
 churches the McDougal Street, Jersey City, Forty-second 
 Street, and also for brother S. Corey. 
 
 Beginning, as I did, in the spring, just as business was 
 becoming active, I found it difficult to engage the attendance of 
 the merchants and of the clerks. As a consequence, the results 
 were not as extensive as they might have been otherwise, for 
 now, as in Paul's day, " faith cometh by hearing." Never- 
 theless our labors were not in vain. About ninety souls pro- 
 fessed conversion, fifty of 'whom united with the Laight Street 
 church, and the rest with the different churches in the city. 
 
 At the close of this meeting arrangements were made for a 
 farewell service. It so happened that the day was stormy ; 
 rivers of water ran down the streets, and the wind blew a 
 hurricane ; nevertheless, a large congregation assembled at the
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 187 
 
 church. After a sermon from myself, remarks were made by 
 brethren Westcott, Corey, Weston, and Graves. Brother 
 Westcott, in behalf of his brethren in the ministry, invited me 
 to return the next autumn for a winter's campaign. 
 
 I will not attempt to recount the many kind utterances that 
 came from the lips of these brethren ; but if an angel had told 
 me, thirty-two years ago, that in 1866 such a scene would have 
 occurred, I should have inquired for a sign from heaven to 
 confirm his testimony. Yet I gratefully bless God that he 
 has permitted me to have so great a share in producing 
 the changes that have come over the spirit of the ministry and 
 the churches ; and even if my name were to be blotted out 
 of the record, and the memory of me fail from the earth, I 
 could labor just as earnestly for the triumph of the truth as it 
 is in Jesus ; and in its progressive triumph I could rejoice, yea, 
 and greatly rejoice, for Christ is all, and what are we but his 
 ministers ? I say this in all humility, for I know my weaknesses 
 better than my brethren do, and feel daily the need of the grace 
 of God to keep me from falling. 
 
 I ought to add, that I received a cordial and sympathizing 
 cooperation from brother McDougal. the pastor of the church. 
 
 During the remainder of this year I spent considerable time 
 with the churches in Cohoes, Bloomingdale (New York City), 
 Waverly, Elmira, and Homer, N. Y. In each of these places 
 I was permitted to rejoice over several converts ; but none of 
 the meetings were marked with incidents that were different 
 from those which I have related as having occurred elsewhere. 
 
 TRENTON. 
 
 On the 7th day of February, 1867, I entered upon my 
 labors with the Central Baptist church in Trenton, N. J., brother 
 T. S. Griffith, pastor. I found the church prepared for my 
 coming. Conversions occurred every day. On a certain Sab- 
 bath, brother Griffith baptized seventeen children belonging to 
 the Sunday school, and an invitation was given to all the 
 Sunday school children to be present. A vast congregation
 
 188 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 assembled. The candidates were dressed in white, and the 
 solemn impression made on the minds of the youthful spectators 
 will never be effaced. 
 
 On the Sabbath following seventy persons received the hand 
 of fellowship, and the material and moral power of the church 
 was greatly increased. 
 
 The meetings continued throughout seven weeks, the interest 
 gradually increasing to the last. I enjoyed the labors with this 
 dear people greatly. There was no friction, no complaining 
 about measures, no disposition to find fault with the plain and 
 outspoken presentation of the gospel. As the result of my 
 labors here about two hundred persons were added to the 
 Central church, and about one hundred to the First church. 
 
 REFLECTIONS. 
 
 In the foregoing accounts I have made mention of only some 
 of the many meetings which I have held during the past thirty- 
 five years. It would have required volumes to contain a 
 history of them all. I have omitted to allude to some, because 
 the memory of distinct incidents has faded from my mind ; I 
 have passed over others, because the incidents, though interest- 
 ing, did not differ materially from those which I have related 
 as occurring in other places ; and I have remained silent con- 
 cerning others, because I could not give a fair statement without 
 alluding to circumstances which would reflect on others, some 
 of whom have passed beyond the reach of human censure. 
 
 I am now an old man. I have outlived the generation of my 
 early associates. Multitudes of those who have professed con- 
 version under my labors have gone to the judgment before me, 
 and the influence of my labors will be projected into the future 
 after I' shall have gone to my account. I realize that my life 
 has been burdened with fearful responsibilities. The destinies 
 of multitudes, dead, living, and yet unborn, are linked with the 
 influences I have exerted. 
 
 As I have commended others to the mercy of God through 
 Christ, so I look to the same source for the pardon of my sins,
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 189 
 
 and the overruling of all my mistakes. And though deeply 
 conscious of my failings and errors, I am, nevertheless, sustained 
 with the conviction that God has made me the agent for the 
 accomplishment of great good ; and I trustfully look forward 
 to the gracious recognition of my Savior when the results of my 
 life-work shall be summed up. 
 
 I thank God that he has permitted me to live to my present 
 age, and continued me in good health, my " eye not dimmed, 
 nor my natural force abated." At my advanced stage of life 
 many ministers have felt themselves compelled to retire from 
 active service, and guard themselves against their increasing 
 infirmities, but through the goodness of God I am permitted to 
 labor for souls a little longer. Of late I have felt constrained 
 to go to California, and it may be that I shall not be spared 
 to return ; but before the eyes of the reader will fall on these 
 pages I expect to reach those distant shores, and be preaching 
 the gospel to the people of the setting sun.
 
 190 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OP 
 
 CHAPTER XXI. 
 
 MISCELLANEOUS FACTS. 
 
 Numbers converted. Baptized. Answers to Questions. Number 
 of Meetings held. Of Sermons preached. Of Converts who 
 became Ministers. Amount of Compensation. 
 
 NUMBER OF CONVERSIONS. 
 
 FOR a time I endeavored to keep an approximate account 
 of the number of persons who professed conversion in my 
 meetings, but after my reckonings took in more than one 
 hundred thousand cases I gave up the attempt. They came 
 in such crowds, from all denominations ; so many united with 
 other churches, and so many were reported in meetings com- 
 menced by me after I had left, and so many were strangers 
 from distant towns and states, sojourning for a few days or 
 weeks where I was preaching, and so many other meetings 
 sprang from those I was holding, that I found the attempt to 
 number Israel an impossibility, and suspected that it might be a 
 sin. I must, therefore, refer the answer to this inquiry to the 
 statistics of the Judgment, which will be more accurate than 
 my most careful endeavors could possibly make it. I aban- 
 doned the effort to reckon numbers more than twenty years ago. 
 
 NUMBERS BAPTIZED. 
 
 I have baptized only a small proportion of those who have 
 been added to the churches in connection with my labors. 1st. 
 Because many united with other denominations. 2d. Because, 
 as a general thing, it seemed desirable and proper that the 
 pastors with whom I labored should administer the ordinance.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 191 
 
 3d. Because, specially, I have always felt that " Christ sent 
 me, not to baptize, but to preach the gospel." 
 
 Up to the year 1845 I had baptized about four thousand 
 persons, and since then about a thousand more. 
 
 ANSWERS TO CERTAIN QUESTIONS. 
 
 A bi-other, who had heard that I was thinking of preparing 
 an account of my life, has requested me to give a statement in 
 regard to certain inquiries. I indicate his questions, and give 
 such answers as I am able. 
 
 1. Number of meetings which I have held to this date, 
 July, 1867. 
 
 Answer. About one hundred and fifty. 
 
 2. Number of sermons which I have preached. 
 Answer. About one thousand three hundred and sixty. 
 
 3. Number of persons converted under my labors who have 
 entered the ministry. 
 
 Ansiver. I cannot speak with accuracy on this subject. 
 Many young men, whose names I have forgotten, have come 
 to the conclusion to become ministers months and years after I 
 have lost sight of them. I am constantly meeting persons, now 
 preaching the gospel, who inform me that they were brought 
 out in meetings which I have held. I can recall several. 
 
 There were six young men, converted in the Tabernacle 
 church, New York, at my meeting, who became ministers : broth- 
 er A. C. Buckbee, now Secretary of the American Bible Union, 
 in California ; James S. Dickerson, now pastor of the First 
 Baptist church, Pittsburg, Pa. ; Sidney A. Corey, now pastor of 
 a Baptist church in New York city ; H. Harvey, formerly Pro- 
 fessor of Biblical Literature in Madison University, and lately 
 pastor of the Baptist church in Dayton, Ohio. Of the names 
 of the other two I am not sufficiently certain to justify me in 
 reporting them. 
 
 Besides these, I remember the names of brother J. R. Ken- 
 drick, now pastor of the Tabernacle Baptist church, New York 
 city, who was converted at Hamilton ; J. B. Tombes, pastor
 
 192 AUTOBIOGRAPHY. 
 
 of the Baptist church in Carbondale, Pa. ; S. M. Bainbridge, well 
 known in Central New York, now deceased ; H. Hutchins, for 
 many years, and yet a pastor in Brooklyn ; B. Griffith, Corre- 
 sponding Secretary of the American Baptist Publishing Socie- 
 ty, Philadelphia ; Franklin Wilson, of Baltimore ; J. B. Jack- 
 son, now Professor of Biblical Literature in Chicago College 
 of Theology ; Professor Roberts, of Burlington University. 
 Iowa. Besides these, I remember the names of Raymond, now 
 of Kansas ; Clark, of Newark, New Jersey ; By water, of 
 St. Louis ; Wilbur, of Iowa ; Fisher and Waterbury, of 
 New York. 
 
 A student in Union College told me that he knew the names 
 of twelve young men, converted in my meetings in Schenectady, 
 who had entered the ministry. I have been informed that 
 about this number of converts in Yale College, during my meet- 
 ings in New Haven, became ministers. There were five young 
 men converted in the Utica meeting who became ministers. 
 
 I can speak of about forty, converted in five meetings, who 
 entered the ministry: In Schenectady, 12; New Haven, 12; 
 Tabernacle church, New York, 6 ; Utica, 5 ; Baltimore, 5. 
 Total, 40. 
 
 4. Amount of compensation. 
 
 Answer. During the first seven years of my labors as 
 
 an Evangelist my salary averaged $300 per annum, $2,100 
 From 1839 to 1843 (four years) it averaged $2,000 
 
 per annum, ' . 8,000 
 
 During sixteen years of labor in the West it aver- 
 aged $380 per annum, 6,080 
 
 During the remaining ten years it averaged $500 per 
 
 annum, 5,000 
 
 In all, during thirty-six years, it has amounted to . . $21,180 
 
 Divide this amount ($21,180) by thirty-six years, and 
 
 my annual compensation has averaged .... $588.31 
 
 Deduct, for annual travelling expenses, say .... 88.31 
 
 and I have realized, per annum, $500.00
 
 VIEWS ON VARIOUS SUBJECTS. 
 
 I. 
 
 
 
 HONORARY TITLES. 
 
 I CONSIDER the custom of conferring titles of distinction 
 on ministers of the gospel to be wrong. 
 
 1. In the first place, the explicit language of Holy Scrip- 
 ture forbids it. Elihu said, " I know not to give flattering 
 titles ; in so doing my Maker would take me away." When 
 there arose a dispute among his disciples as to who should be 
 greatest in the kingdom of heaven, " Jesus called a little child 
 unto him, and set him in the midst of them, and said, Verily, I 
 say unto you, except ye be converted and become as little chil- 
 dren, ye shall not enter into the kingdom of heaven. Whosoever 
 therefore shall humble himself as this little child, the same is 
 greatest in the kingdom of heaven." Matt, xviii. 1-4. Again, 
 Jesus said unto his disciples, " Whosoever will be great among 
 you, let him be your minister ; and whosoever will be chief 
 among you, let him be your servant." Matt. xx. 26, 27. Christ 
 presented his own example as the model, after which all his 
 followers should copy. " I am among you as he that serveth." 
 Luke xxii. 27. 
 
 How much more dignified and godlike is the spirit hei'e in- 
 culcated and insisted upon as the condition of our entering into 
 the kingdom of heaven, than the foolish strife and unholy rivalry 
 among men as to who shall be the greatest. The very spirit 
 of emulation involved in this anxiety, is essentially contrary to 
 that spirit of humility and meekness which the gospel enjoins. 
 
 It is said that the title, D. D., only means a doctor or teacher 
 of divinity ; then why not confer it on all who teach divinity,
 
 194 HONORARY TITLES, BY 
 
 and thus make no distinction? But many desire it because' it 
 makes a distinction, and many experience heart-burnings and 
 jealousies because they do not get it. Thus the practice is a 
 double-edged sword ; it cuts those who receive the honor, and 
 those who feel themselves slighted because they do not receive 
 it. The church of Christ should discountenance whatever tends 
 to foster such states of mind. 
 
 2. In the second place, no body of men have the right to 
 confer it. Christ never gave such authority. None of the 
 apostles did. Their example is against it. Who ever heard 
 of Rev. Mr. Paul, D. D., or of the Riglit Rev. Simon Peter, 
 D. D. ? These titles originated, not in the apostolic church, but 
 in the spirit of vaulting ambition, which culminated in the blas- 
 phemous assumptions of the church of Rome. 
 
 3. In the third place, the reception of the title is unworthy of 
 the dignity of the ministerial office. Our ministers need not come 
 down from the sacred hill of Zion, and kneel before the sceptre 
 of civil or literary power in order to receive titular distinctions, 
 whereby they may be known as ministers of the meek and lowly 
 Jesus. This practice is virtually a repudiation of the authority 
 of Christ, and a weak and wicked subserviency to the maxims 
 of this world. It is well known that, in many instances, these 
 titles are bought and sold, as were the pardons and indulgences 
 of the church of Rome ; and it has come to be regarded no 
 longer a sign of the worth or learning of its recipient. In nu- 
 merous cases the very association of this title with certain 
 names involuntarily excites the mental inquiry, How did they 
 get it? In some cases ministers of the gospel have fallen so low 
 as to solicit the Board of a College to bestow on them the title. 
 In other cases the minister resorts to indirection. His friends 
 move in the matter. Nor will it be denied that in many cases 
 the College Board have as much regard to pecuniary returns 
 as they do to the deservedness of the candidate. There are 
 many D. D.'s in modern times who cannot preach a sermon 
 without murdering the queen's English, and whose chief dis- 
 tinction in the ministry is their want of success in winning souls.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 195 
 
 I know there are many on whom the title has been conferred 
 to whom these remarks do not apply, and who would prefer to 
 dispense with it, if they know how to get rid of it. I am 
 aware that there are many ahle and worthy men who have 
 been dubbed with this title, and these are the very men who 
 care the least about it. 
 
 For my own part, I consider it more honorable to a minister 
 of Jesus Christ to be pelted with stones, smitten with clubs, and 
 hooted through the streets, as were Whitefield and Wesley, 
 than to receive all the titles which civil governments or schools 
 of learning can get up or confer. 
 
 Finally, it is my heart's desire and prayer to God, that the 
 time will soon come when all Christians, and all Christian 
 churches, will be content to stand on one common level ; to 
 esteem each other better than themselves, and seek honor only 
 from God, and lay what he bestows at the Savior's feet.
 
 196 THOUGHTS ON MINISTERIAL POWER, BY 
 
 II. 
 
 THOUGHTS ON MINISTERIAL POWER. 
 
 IN order to become successful, a minister of the gospel 
 must be possessed of an ardent love of the work. He must 
 have such an appreciation of it, as a high and holy calling, that 
 he will look with indifference upon every other pursuit. His 
 love of Christ and of souls must serve as a magnet to draw- 
 away his interest from all worldly callings. It must be an in- 
 spiration to propel him forward under all discouragements, and 
 to lead him to " count not his life dear unto himself, that he 
 may finish his course with joy, and the ministry which he has 
 received of the Lord Jesus." He must be able to say to all 
 worldly allurements, as did Robert Hall when urged to accept a 
 position of greater emolument than that of a Baptist preacher : 
 " As for your honors, I desire them not ; and as for your riches, I 
 despise them." 
 
 2. To be successful, a minister must seek for immediate suc- 
 cess. It is a favorite method with some ministers, in order to 
 account for their failure to a achieve anything for Christ, to say 
 they are sowingthe seed, the fruit of which another will gather. 
 But he that would accomplish much for his race must " serve 
 his own generation." He must know that sinners are dying, 
 and, unless converted, going to hell. The men of this genera- 
 tion must be brought to Christ through existing agencies, and 
 the minister must specially feel that he is concerned with the 
 care of the individuals whom God has put under his charge. 
 
 A man who has no success in saving the souls of those to 
 whom he ministers, or in gathering in the people of the place in
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 197 
 
 which he preaches, may seriously question whether God has 
 called him to the work. It does not seem reasonable that God 
 would give a special call to a man to go and labor in a field dur- 
 ing the harvest, who had no elements of adaptation to do the 
 thing unto which he thinks himself called. I am sometimes: 
 asked, " What are the evidences that a man is called to preach 
 the gospel ? " I answer, first, a single and strong desire for the 
 work ; second, indications that he knows how to preach ; third, 
 evidence that he can get any body to hear him ; fourth, success 
 in winning souls to the Savior. 
 
 3. Another condition of a minister's power, is an exclusive 
 devotion to the specific duties of his calling. In this way his 
 profiting shall appear unto all. His work is too important to 
 admit of a rival, and his time too short to be made still shorter 
 by wasting it in matters foreign to his calling. What would 
 be thought of a foreign minister of state who should turn aside 
 from, and neglect the interests of his government, in order to 
 amuse or profit himself? If the apostles had taken such a 
 course they would have insured the failure of Christianity, and 
 perverted its entire spirit. They could not find time to attend 
 to the distribution of the charities of the church, and referred 
 the charge of that matter to others, in order that they might 
 devote themselves wholly " to prayer and the ministry of the 
 word." 
 
 It is true that they sometimes worked at business callings in 
 order to provide for their daily wants ; but this they did only in 
 subordination to their high calling, and in order to insure the 
 preaching of the gospel, and the preaching of it with greater 
 effect among the people whose salvation they sought. But they 
 tell us that they were naked and hungry, and suffered the loss 
 of all things, lest they should hinder the gospel of Christ. 
 
 I have now been in the ministry forty years, and in looking 
 back, can see clearly that if I had never lifted my finger in order 
 to promote my worldly interests, it would have been better for 
 me and for my family. I could have escaped many occasions of 
 personal unhappiness, and have greatly added to my power to
 
 198 THOUGHTS ON MINISTERIAL POWER, BY 
 
 do good. If a minister of Christ have faith in God, and make 
 it his whole concern to serve him, God will take care of him. 
 At times his faith may be tried, but if it does not stagger under 
 the pressure, he will find God to be as good as his promises : 
 " Trust in the Lord and do good, and thou shalt dwell in the 
 land, and verily thou shalt be fed." " Thy bread shall be given 
 thee, and thy water shall be sure." And if we are sometimes 
 brought into close quarters, we shall be enriched by the experi- 
 mental knowledge that the " the trial of our faith is more 
 precious than gold." 
 
 4. If a minister would have power, he must aim in his 
 preaching to reach the consciences of his hearers. If he 
 preaches so as to improve the literary tastes, or quicken the 
 intellectual faculties, or gratify the aesthetic tendencies of his 
 hearers, he may succeed in accomplishing the end in view, but 
 he will not succeed in saving souls. If he aims at saying 
 smooth and beautiful things, he may be able to do so, and thus 
 gain the admiration of men who value culture in the preacher 
 more than they do pungent presentation of truth ; but while 
 ministering to the literary gratification of his hearers, he may, 
 at the same time, be making their damnation more sure. 
 
 Some preachers pride themselves on their metaphysical 
 acumen and theological accuracy. They have more to say 
 about the philosophy of religion than about its facts ; and the force 
 of their ministry is expended in theorizing about the methods 
 of truth, rather than in enforcing the reality of it. They demand 
 a faith based upon the apprehensions of reason more than upon 
 the testimony of God. The result is, that they talk about things 
 they do not understand, and their hearers either become listless 
 or sceptical. The devil is well satisfied with such kind of 
 preaching. He is willing that men's minds should become 
 mystified about theories so long as they allow him to control 
 their hearts. 
 
 The successful preacher must be practical. He must make 
 religion appear to be a thing that has something to do with the 
 moral convictions ; that appeals to them, and demands the 
 immediate consecration of them to the claims of God.
 
 ELDER JA'JOB KNA'/P. 109 
 
 5. Tae preacher must study adaptation. It is seldom that 
 preaching produces saving results, except it takes effect at the 
 time, and brings a person to speedy action. Consequently the 
 preacher cannot appreciate too highly the importance of timing 
 his subjects. It would be very unwise to come out on a cold 
 church and congregation with a sermon on the awful terrors of 
 everlasting damnation. Their feelings would be shocked, and 
 their pride would array itself in rebellion ; but let him first re- 
 mind them of their " first love," and call on them to return 
 unto it ; let him inquire why Jesus has been to them as a way- 
 faring man that turneth aside for a night, and tell them much 
 of the greatness of God's love to them. In this way, if they are 
 Christians indeed, the hearts of his hearers will be melted. 
 Then let the preacher speak of the terrors of the law, and the 
 Christians will be aroused to labor for souls, and the wicked 
 will quail under its power. 
 
 6. The power of the pulpit depends very much on the style 
 of language employed in the presentation of the truth. A plain, 
 clear, correct, and common-sense way of " putting " the thing 
 before a congregation is the only effective method of interesting 
 and reaching the masses. The apostle says expressly that he 
 did not " come with excellency of speech, which man's wisdom 
 teacheth ; " and " if I seek to please man, I am no more the 
 servant of Christ." The language employed by the holy 
 apostles is the model of all succeeding preachers. It is the 
 language which the Spirit of God has seen fit to employ as the 
 vehicle of divine truth. Smooth and ornate diction is not in 
 keeping with the gravity of the great truths contained in the 
 Bible ; and a highly-wrought style is unworthy of their dignity, 
 and evidence of the utter want of appreciation on the part of 
 the preacher of the momentous issues involved, and the impend- 
 ing danger of those who do not receive them. From all such 
 stilted, or dry, or tinsel displays, the common people will ever- 
 more turn away unimpressed if not disgusted. To many 
 persons much of the language of the pulpit is an unknown 
 tongue ; and Paul says, " I had rather speak five words with
 
 200 THOUGHTS ON MLNISTERIAL POWER, BY 
 
 the understanding (that is, to the understanding of others) , than 
 ten thousand words in an unknown tongue." 
 
 7. The man who has power in the pulpit is a man of strong 
 faith. There are many preachers and churches who are afraid 
 to venture on the promises of God. They are afraid to go to 
 work for the salvation of souls unless a sign be given them, 
 lest they should be mortified by a failure. Thus they let months 
 and years pass on, and souls go down to death while they are 
 waiting for indications. God honored Abraham above all men 
 because of his great faith. Paul, in speaking of the different 
 gifts, says " one has the gift of faith." For the want of faith 
 the Israelites were doomed to drag out forty years in the wilder- 
 ness, and not one of the unbelievers was permitted to enter into 
 the promised land. All of the mighty conquests recorded in 
 Scripture were achieved by faith. But unbelief cuts off com- 
 munication with God. It shuts up heaven, and paralyzes all 
 our efforts to do good. " Let such an one know that he shall 
 receive nothing at the hands of the Lord." 
 
 8. In order to have power as a preacher the minister must 
 have knowledge. First of all he must know God ; must be in 
 sympathy with his plans, and in communion with him. 
 Secondly, he must know himself, so as neither to overrate nor 
 underrate himself. He must know somewhat the direction in 
 which his own power lies. Thirdly, he must be well vei'sed in 
 the Bible, so as to prove himself to be " not a novice," but " a 
 workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the 
 word of truth." Fourthly, he must have a good knowledge of 
 human nature. 
 
 If a man is well versed in these things he will not fail to 
 make his mark. He will become powerful for good, even 
 though he may not have much of that knowledge that puffeth 
 up. Nevertheless mere scholastic knowledge is good, and the 
 more a preacher has of it the better, provided always he have 
 the other kinds of knowledge and grace, and sense enough to 
 make his attainments subordinate and illustrative of his conse- 
 cration to the one aim of winning souls.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 201 
 
 A man who does not study, but spends his time in ministerial 
 gossiping and loafing, can never excel, however great his 
 genius or brilliant his intellect. All of our powers are strength- 
 ened by their use. 
 
 9. Another element of ministerial power is the spirit of love. 
 No amount of learning, no degree of genius, nor measure of 
 eloquence, will atone for the lack of that genuine spirit of 
 sympathy which has its origin in love. A people will bear 
 plain dealing from one who can rebuke with much long-suffer- 
 ing and kindness. They will overlook many defects in execu- 
 tion on the part of one of whose sincere affection for them they 
 feel assured. There is eloquence *ra* love : it lights up the 
 face with its radiant beams, and transmutes the glistening 
 tear into a precious pearl. It magnetizes, enkindles, and sub- 
 dues. 
 
 10. Finally, the preacher that would have power with men 
 must have power with God. He must be filled with the 
 Spirit ; and so greatly filled, that all other rivals for the control 
 of his being shall be expelled. Much is said in the New 
 Testament of " being full of the Holy Spirit." The apostles 
 gave thanks to God, who always made them to triumph. 
 Luther was powerful only as God was with him and in him. 
 Wesley and Whitefield were eloquent and powerful because 
 they were crucified to the world, and because " Christ lived 
 in them." I know of no reason, in the divine economy, why, 
 if there be an equal degree of seeking for it, there should not 
 be marked and numerous evidences of divine effectiveness in 
 ministers now as in former times. God is as willing to give 
 the Holy Spirit to them that ask him now as he was formerly. 
 And the promise still holds good, " If any man will do His 
 will, I and my Father will come to him, and make our abode 
 with him." 
 
 15
 
 202 HOW TO GET UP A REFORMATION, BY 
 
 III. 
 
 HOW TO GET UP A REFORMATION. 
 
 I USE this phraseology, because it is the very language of 
 those who are novices concerning this subject, and make so 
 many complaints against special measures. 
 
 God works by means, and by appointed and established 
 means. His Spirit is hovering over all of our cities, towns, 
 nnd country places, ready to respond to a faithful use of the 
 means at all times. " The set time " in which to favor Zion is 
 always when " her sons take pleasure in her stones, and favor 
 the dust thereof." 
 
 Is it not proper to excite an enthusiasm on the subject of 
 foreign or home missions? And would not God be pleased to 
 have us get up a revival in the interest of education or of tem- 
 perance? Why, then, is it not equally proper to put forth 
 special efforts to promote the salvation of souls ? 
 
 But how shall a revival be brought about? Not, as some 
 would imagine, by a resort to eccentricities and sensational 
 appeals. It is probable that some such agencies may conduce 
 to bring people to listen to the truth of God, but of themselves 
 they are powerless and hurtful. 
 
 The great necessity in promoting a revival is the outpouring 
 of the Spirit of God. Until the Spirit be poured out from on 
 high, the most pungent truths, the most tender appeals, and the 
 most attractive manner, are in vain. Everything will remain as 
 hard and as dead as a stone wall (and sinners are dead) until 
 infused by the quickening influence of the Spirit's power. 
 
 Consequently, our first work is prayer. Earnest, importu-
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 203 
 
 nate, believing prayer, must be made. The history of the first 
 protracted meeting after the ascension of Christ, was doubtless 
 designed as a pattern for all succeeding ages. There was not 
 a sermon preached until after the Spirit had descended ; but 
 then, under the preaching of a single sermon, three thousand 
 souls were " pricked in their hearts." If we preach at all be- 
 fore the direct influences of the Holy Spirit are felt in the hearts 
 of the church, our preaching should be directed to the church ; 
 we should labor to have them see wherein they have sinned and 
 departed fi;om the living God, and to induce them to return unto 
 their first love. In short, the people must sanctify themselves 
 before the Lord. Caleb and Joshua said, " If the Lord delight 
 in us, he will give it us ; " and if we would go up and possess a 
 town or a city, we must become so humble, and so penitent, and 
 so holy, that God will delight in us. 
 
 " If I regard iniquity in my heart, the Lord will not hear 
 me." It is our sins which separate us from God ; and it is our 
 iniquities which hide his face from our sight. 
 
 When the Holy Spirit comes down in power, it visits the 
 hearts of the community, and they are inclined to come in and 
 hear the preached word. It was not the preaching of Peter 
 which brought together the crowds, but the Holy Spirit, which 
 came down in answer to prayers, continuously and unitedly 
 offered by the waiting disciples. 
 
 The Holy Spirit likewise indites the prayers and sermons. 
 "When God's ministers are filled with the Spirit, there is a kind 
 of inspiration about their sermons, which makes them " mighty 
 to the pulling down of the strongholds ; " a sort of inspiration 
 in the conception and expression of their thoughts, and in the 
 method of their delivery. Those who have imagined that I 
 have depended for effect on eccentricities of speech, or tactics 
 of management, have utterly misapprehended me, and done me 
 great injustice. My reliance has been upon the power of God's 
 truth, made effectual by his own Spirit, and the hearty cooper- 
 ation of the church, as " workers together with him." 
 
 I can conceive of a difference between a revival and a refor-
 
 204 HOW TO GET UP A REFORMATION, BY 
 
 mation, and desire only the former. But in all my efforts I 
 have labored assiduously to bring about a reformation. I have 
 sought to do a work which should abide a permanent element 
 of power and blessing after I had passed on to other places. 
 Accordingly, I have earnestly sought to pour all of God's truth 
 upon the consciences of men ; to bring up the church to a proper 
 understanding of the Bible standard of Christian character and 
 Christian effort. I have found many who like the excitation of 
 a revival, but have no relish for the labor of a reform. Such 
 want a pastor or an evangelist who leaves them in the undis- 
 puted enjoyment of their sinful indulgences. They prefer sons 
 of consolation to sons of thunder, and want the minister to say 
 soft things softly. They have no idea of having the gospel 
 plough driven through the church, breaking up the fallow ground, 
 cutting all the ligaments that bind them to the world and to the 
 service of Satan. Their religion is a white-gloved religion. It 
 can attend sociables, donation and surprise 'parties, and enjoy a 
 good religious time generally, in which they can outdo the 
 world, and keep close upon the heels of the devil. They like 
 to feast, but not to fast ; they are delighted with singing, but 
 have no taste for prayer. 
 
 But this is not the apostolic sort of revival. The practices of 
 church members who dance, and frolic, and are absorbed in 
 worldliness, have been as much in my way of promoting a ref- 
 ormation as drunkenness, profanity, or infidelity ; yes, as all 
 put together. In laboring for reformation, it has been my cus- 
 tom to expose all the sins of God's people. He says, " Lift up 
 thy voice like a trumpet ; cry aloud ; spare not. Show unto 
 my people their sins, and the house of Israel their trans- 
 gressions." 
 
 If the work drags, I preach on some subjects which are appli- 
 cable to both saints and sinners ; appoint a fast, requiring all 
 who join in it to abstain from all business and all food duriug 
 the twenty-four hours. Sometimes we have held three or four 
 such seasons in one meeting. Thus, by prayer and fasting, by 
 preaching and exhortation, by humiliations and confessions, we
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 205 
 
 have sought the Lord, until he has " come and rained righteous- 
 ness upon us." 
 
 The church needs to be stimulated as well as depleted, or 
 else they will sink and become despondent. They must be en- 
 couraged to take God at his word, and to hope in his rnercy, and 
 expect the fulfilment of all his promises ; so that they must be 
 taught to use at once all means to bring in sinners, and labor 
 and look for their conversion. The sooner and the more they 
 work, the sooner and the more they will be in sympathy with 
 Christ, and be filled with the Spirit. That pastor who is the 
 most successful in securing and keeping up the cooperation of 
 the church, will be most successful in producing and keeping up 
 a perpetual reformation. This was the secret of the success of 
 John Wesley. 
 
 When tffe church is aroused and consecrated, and the pres- 
 ence of the Spirit realized, then pour on God's truth, hand 
 over hand ; now thundering out hell and damnation, until the 
 mountain is covered with fire and smoke, and the people trem- 
 ble ; then ascend Calvary's bloody summit ; bid the smitten 
 people " Behold the Lamb of God^who taketh away the sin of 
 the world." Preach Christ crucified ; knock out every prop on 
 which sinners lean. Sometimes the prop is one thing, some- 
 times it is another. It may be Universalism, or Unitarianisin, 
 or morality. No matter what it is ; let not one remain, and 
 see to it that the soul build on no other foundation than that 
 which is already laid, which is Christ Jesus. 
 
 This is a momentous work, demanding the utmost exertion 
 of the laborers for God. It behooves them to keep alive and 
 active the conviction of the solemn fact, that all who are not 
 reached soon, will very soon be beyond the reach of all the 
 means of grace. It is now or never. " Knowing the terrors 
 of the Lord, we persuade men." " When the commandment 
 came, sin revived and I died." So said Paul. And Jesus 
 asks, "How can ye escape the damnation of hell?" Human 
 sinfulness, helplessness, and danger must be plainly enforced in 
 order to give effect to the arguments of the cross.
 
 206 HOW TO GET DP A REFORMATION, BY 
 
 Men in all ages are liable to go to extremes ; and though the 
 present generation of ministers have made many improvements 
 on the past, yet I think the tendency now is to make the gospel 
 pleasing to the tastes of unconverted men ; and as the result of 
 this desire is to give " none offence," the doctrines of human 
 depravity, of the enmity of the carnal mind against God, the 
 necessity of the new birth, and the certainty of eternal punish- 
 ment to the finally impenitent, are not made as prominent, or 
 dwelt upon as much as formerly. ^Tndeed, I find some churches 
 which do not wish to hear anything about them. But the truths 
 of the Bible are adapted to the condition of man in all ages 
 and circumstances, and any deviation from this standard is 
 dangerous. 
 
 There are two methods of carrying on a successful .ftyival of 
 religion. One is, by calling in the aid of an evangelist, and mak- 
 ing a special effort to enlist and arouse the entire community. 
 
 But when this plan is not practicable, let the pastor of a 
 church, in connection with his most spiritually-minded brethren, 
 seek in prayer the outpouring of the Spirit. Then let them seek 
 out the most seriously disposed persons in the congregation ; 
 when one person is converted set him to work to win others, and 
 endeavor to give every member of the church something to do. 
 The more each one works the more he will have a mind to work, 
 and the more he will find to do. Let there be a short lecture 
 from the pastor, followed by-prayer and pertinent remarks by 
 the brethren and converts. In this way the whole leaven of 
 grace will continue to Vrork until the whole lump is leavened, 
 and an entire church or community is permeated with the power 
 of the gospel. 
 
 Formalists and hypocrites may say what they please against 
 excitement, but from the earliest days of God's communication 
 with men there have been seasons of religious refreshing and 
 declension. There was a declension before the flood, and a re- 
 vival under Abraham ; a declension in Egypt, and a revival 
 under Moses ; a declension before the days of John the Baptist, 
 and a revival shortly after Christ. And so it has been from
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 207 
 
 that day to this, and so it will continue to be, so long as man 
 is what he is, the devil is what he is, and God does not 
 change. 
 
 Indeed, the history of the apostles is a history of excitement ; 
 deeper, stronger, and more lasting than we have ever had since. 
 The history of the church is the history of strong and purifying 
 excitements. .<? * . 
 
 t
 
 208 SPEEDY ADMISSIONS CONSIDERED, BY 
 
 IV. 
 
 * * > 
 
 COMPLAINTS AGAINST SPEEDY ADMISSIONS 
 CONSIDERED. 
 
 LET it be distinctly understood that the word of God and the 
 example of the apostles are our only guides in this matter. 
 No creeds, catechisms, laws, by-laws, usages, or customs of 
 modern churches, ought ever to be allowed to come into compe- 
 tition with the teachings of Holy Writ. It is always safe to 
 follow its directions and examples as to the method of promoting 
 the advancement of the kingdom of God. " To the law and 
 the testimony ; if they speak not according to this word, it is 
 because there is no light in them." 
 
 2. What was the custom of the apostles on this subject? 
 Peter, on the day of Pentecost, commanded sinners to " repent 
 and be baptized;" "and they that gladly received the word, 
 were baptized ; and the same day there was added unto them 
 about three thousand souls." Now it is evident to any un- 
 biased mind, that all who believed on the Lord Jesus Christ on 
 that occasion, were baptized the same day ; yes, before they left 
 the spot. Acts ii. 38-41. The jailer was not only baptized on 
 the same night in which he was converted", but in " the same 
 hour." Acts xvi. 33. 
 
 When Philip opened his mouth and preached unto the eunuch 
 Jesus, as they were riding along in the chariot, the eunuch said, 
 " Here is water, what doth hinder me to be baptized? " Philip 
 said, " If thou believest with all thine heart, thou mayest." 
 And on the declaration of his faith, " they went down into the 
 water, both Philip and the eunuch, and he baptized him." Acts
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 20D 
 
 viii. 38. Now it is evident that in this case baptism was not 
 delayed until the eunuch reached home, but he was baptized 
 immediately on the declaration of his faith. 
 
 In the case of Cornelius and his house, we read that while 
 Peter was preaching the Holy Spirit fell on those that heard, 
 and that Peter immediately commanded that they should be 
 baptized in the name of the Lord Jesus. Acts x. 47, 48. 
 
 Likewise it appears when the Lord had opened the eyes of 
 Lydia, as she was praying on the banks of the river, that she 
 was baptized therein, before returning to her home. 
 
 The case of Saul of Tarsus is the only one recorded in the 
 New Testament of a person whose baptism was delayed after 
 conversion. He was not baptized till three days had elapsed ; 
 but there were reasons which make his case evidently excep- 
 tional. 1. There was no administrator at hand when he was 
 converted. 2. Jesus bade him go into the city, and await 
 further instructions. 3. As soon as Ananias was informed of 
 the case, he sought out Saul, and as soon as Saul was told that 
 his next duty was to be baptized, he instantly obeyed. 4. 
 The delay of three days seems to have been an occasion of 
 regret to Ananias ; and, 5. As it was, Saul did not either eat 
 or drink, after his conversion, till he had been baptized. 
 
 It is very evident that the apostles in no instance demanded 
 of a candidate a probationary trial, nor even a metaphysical 
 analysis of the workings of their minds under conviction, as 
 prerequisites of baptism. They simply required a sincere 
 expression of repentance of sin and faith in Jesus Christ. 
 
 But it may be said that the apostles, being inspired men, 
 could tell who were converted and who were not. To this I 
 answer, there is no evidence that their inspiration related to 
 this subject. On the contrary, it seems that they did not ground 
 the reception of members on any such supernatural recognition. 
 They confess themselves to have been disappointed in some 
 cases, and allusions are frequent to those who fell away. 
 
 Again, it is urged that there was little danger of persons 
 confessing Christ in times of persecution. I ask, what reason
 
 210 SPEEDY ADMISSIONS CONSIDERED, BY 
 
 had the three thousand to expect persecution, and what evidence 
 is there that they recognized an apprehension of it? .On the 
 contrary, it is more probable that multitudes, in view of the 
 marvellous descent of the Spirit, were inclined to think that the 
 new religion was about to become immediately popular. 
 
 If ever there was a time in which extra precautions should 
 be taken against immediate receptions, it was at the Pentecost. 
 1. It was a time of great excitement, in which the fanatical 
 would be very likely to show themselves. 2. There was little 
 or no time or opportunity for reflection ; so that the impulsive 
 could be easily betrayed. 3. It was a time of great ignorance 
 of the real nature of Christianity. Multitudes were less in- 
 formed of the elementary principles of Christ's kingdom than 
 are the simplest of modern Sunday-school children. 4. Many 
 of the converts were from all parts of the world, sojourners in 
 Jerusalem only for a few days, destined to go back among 
 peoples who knew not Christ, and where they could not enjoy 
 the privileges of an organized church. Notwithstanding all 
 these incentives to precaution, the apostles understood the com- 
 mission to require of them the instantaneous baptism of all 
 who professed their faith in Christ. 
 
 The caviller may say again, there is no harm in their wait- 
 ing. So say Pedobaptists, when convicted of the unscriptural- 
 ness of infant baptism, " There is no harm in the ceremony." 
 But I think that every deviation from the divinely-prescribed 
 method of building up the kingdom of Christ is full of harm. 
 In this particular case, the habit of delay is injurious to the 
 piety of the convert, grieves the Holy Spirit, by calling into 
 question the genuineness of his work, begets a spirit of unbelief 
 in our prayers, and opens up a wide door for innumerable de- 
 partures from the word of God. If in one instance we may 
 depart from, and attempt to improve upon, the pattern given us, 
 we may do so ad libitum. And yet there are many Baptists 
 (thank God their number is diminishing every year) with 
 whom usages and customs are everything, and the authority of 
 God nothing. The laws and by-laws of some such churches aro
 
 ELDER JACOB KN.iPP. 211 
 
 all in all ; but the laws of Jesus Christ and the apostles are of 
 no account. They seem to think that the apostles were very 
 imprudent, and those who seek to copy after them are danger- 
 ous men. 
 
 And especially ought it to be remarked, that this agitation 
 about receiving members invariably retards a revival. Every 
 baptism imparts new courage to the church, and becomes an 
 element of conviction to the unconverted. But when this duty 
 is deferred, all these good influences are retarded. Suppose, 
 when Peter heard the three thousand cry out, " What must we 
 do?" he had said, " Don't get excited ; keep cool ; go home and 
 read your Bibles : " and then suppose that the rest of the disci- 
 ples had set in with their admonitions, " Examine yourselves ; 
 don't be deceived ; ascertain whether you can hold out ; and, 
 above all, remember you won't always feel as you do now : " 
 suppose some such procedure, and I leave it to the men who 
 advocate this policy to compute how long it would have taken 
 for Christianity to have achieved the triumphs which made the 
 first Christain era so illustrious. 
 
 3. Baptism is the act of putting on Christ. " As many of 
 you as have been baptized into Christ have put on Christ." 
 When we have renounced the world, the flesh, and the devil, 
 why defer putting on Christ ? Why not put him on at once ? 
 As did the primitive Christians in this matter, so let us do. A 
 new-born soul is a babe, whose mother is the church ; and where 
 is the place for the babe, but in the warm and fostering bosom 
 of its mother ? What would you think of the policy of putting 
 the tender infant up garret for a week, a month, or six mouths, 
 in order to see whether it would hold out? If there is ever a 
 time when the child needs nursing and tender care it is when 
 it is just born. 
 
 This hesitancy to receive newly-born souls is an evidence of 
 something wrong in the churches, disqualifying them to extend 
 a fostering care to the babes in Christ, and thus rendering them 
 unwilling or unable to bear the labor and risk of receiving those 
 who are genuinely converted, on account of the risk of taking in 
 the few who may not be.
 
 212 SPEEDY ADMISSIONS CONSIDERED, BY 
 
 la this way converts are discouraged at the start, and instead 
 of finding cordial welcome, they find themselves to be objects of 
 distrust. The very consciousness of being distrusted depresses 
 the ardor of effort, makes them afraid to express their difficulties, 
 turns them to seek that sympathy in the world which is refused 
 them in the church, and furnishes them a relief from the re- 
 straints which they wt>uld feel in the church,' and an excuse 
 for yielding to temptation. It rarely happens that persons 
 who have been kept off from the privileges and responsibilities 
 of the church relation for a period of several mouths, or 
 even weeks, are ever brought into the church at all ; partly 
 because the church loses sight of them, and partly because they 
 themselves become either indifferent about uniting with the 
 church, or fearful of a rebuff if they should make the attempt 
 to do so. 
 
 4. It is not uncommon for churches to ascribe the backslid- 
 ing of newly-received members to the wrong cause. They say, 
 " It is because they were taken into the church too soon." I 
 say, it is because they are not taken care of when they are in. 
 
 In the first place, converts experience a chill from coming 
 into contact with cold, formal, and worldly members. Every 
 spirit begets its own likeness. Let me know the character of 
 the church, and I can tell what prospects there are of the converts 
 holding out. If the older members are running off to the theatre, 
 or the dance, or flirting about at parties, or think more of attend- 
 ing religious festivals than church prayer-meetings, ought it to 
 be a matter of surprise if the new members become like unto 
 them? 
 
 I have always observed that those in the churches who have 
 the least piety affect the most care about receiving members. 
 They act as if they were hoping to atone for their sins by their 
 extreme conservatism. They will ask as many questions of a 
 candidate as if they were examining him for ordination. I 
 have also noticed that those who were the most zealous in saving 
 souls generally receive the converts with greater cordiality, and 
 are more ready to take upon themselves the burden of watching
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 213 
 
 over and encouraging them than are those who exhaust their 
 zeal in trying to keep them out. 
 
 In the next place, churches frequently kill off the converts by 
 not giving them a chance to work. In many churches there 
 are no organized plans of Christian effort, and the members 
 have no church help to " exercise themselves unto godliness." 
 The convei't is thrown upon his own individual resources. In 
 many cases, however willing to work, in his inexperience he 
 does not know what to do, or how to set about doing anything, 
 so that he is timid, and hesitates, lest he shall be deemed fro- 
 ward. Besides, much time need not elapse before he can fiud 
 out that a few are not indisposed to monopolize the offices and 
 honors, while others seem to find their chief exercise in repress- 
 ing the ardor of any who might wish to do more than them- 
 selves. Converts are usually in a plastic state, and are peculiarly 
 sensitive to first influences that are exerted on them on join- 
 ing the church. Multitudes receive a set back then, from which 
 they never recover. 
 
 Very many make much of the kind of experience a candidate 
 may be able to relate ; but facts abundantly prove that " ex- 
 periences " are uncertain reliances. Many who told bright 
 experiences live inconsistent lives, and many who stumbled 
 and bungled in their narration prove, by consistent conduct, 
 that the root of the matter was in them. 
 
 Many are also much opposed to the baptizing of children. I 
 know of one little girl, converted in the Sunday school, whose 
 parents refused their consent to her being baptized on account 
 of her youth, who one day brought her Testament to her pastor, 
 and asked him to mark out the passage which tells how old a 
 person must be before he could be baptized. The only answer 
 that can be given to such a question is one which admits that a 
 child who is old enough to repent and believe is not too young 
 to be baptized.
 
 214 THE UTILITY OF ANXIOUS-SEATS, BY 
 
 THE UTILITY OF ANXIOUS-SEATS. 
 
 fTVHERE is no intrinsic virtue in an " anxious-seat." There 
 JL is no merit in taking it. There is nothing in the thing 
 itself that can place God under obligation to save. Nevertheless 
 there are advantages in the use of this institution. 
 
 1. It serves as a test of character. Many people think that 
 they are not ashamed of Christ, but when called upon to give a 
 public expression of their feelings, they recognize and evince a 
 strong unwillingness to expose themselves to such an avowal. 
 They are afraid of the comments of the ungodly ; and besides 
 this, they become conscious of a resistance to the overtures of 
 the gospel, that springs from a hatred to Christ, an unwilling- 
 ness to make the surrender, of which they were hardly con- 
 scious before. Thus many have become amazed at the dis- 
 covery of their carnal enmity, and have been brought to realize, 
 more fully than ever, the necessity of their being born again. 
 
 2. It is a public committal. When once the step is taken, it 
 is more dishonorable and more mortifying to go back than it is 
 to go forward. The more obstacles that can be put in the way 
 of receding the better. God frequently helps men to a right decis- 
 ion by bringing them to a crisis, in which the retreat is more 
 disastrous than a forward movement. Thus was it with the 
 children of Israel, as they came to the Red Sea, with the hosts 
 of Pharaoh behind them. Consequently all the barriers that 
 can be put in the way of the anxious, to prevent their going 
 back, should be piled up behind them ; and all inducements to 
 strengthen their resolutions, and to make them strive to enter
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 215 
 
 in at the strait gate, should be employed, for " the kingdom of 
 heaven is taken by violence, and the violent take it by force." 
 
 3. It is a convenient way of making a public acknowledg- 
 ment of our. need of Christ. The language of the Savior is 
 emphatic : " Whoso shall confess me before men, him will I 
 confess before my Father and his holy angels." " He that shall 
 deny me before men, him will I deny beftre my Father and his 
 holy angels." The blind man not only prayed publicly to Christ 
 for the opening of his eyes, but was called upon to answer this 
 question : " What wilt thou that I shall do unto thee? " Why 
 did the Savior ask that question ? Clearly, he wished him to 
 ask again, in order to make him emphasize his wants before 
 all the people, that all might know that Christ had opened his 
 eyes. 
 
 In like manner all sinners must come out and confess their 
 need of the healing virtue there is in Christ. The woman who 
 secretly touched the garment of Christ was brought out before 
 all the people, and rebuked for her hesitancy to appeal to the 
 Savior publicly. 
 
 4. The effect of such an example is an encouragement to 
 other convicted souls. A man who thinks he is willing to do 
 something for Christ, can do no less than this simple service. 
 He may not have the tongue of eloquence to exhort, he may not 
 have abundance of wealth to pay missionaries, but can quietly 
 and humbly take a position before a congregation, which evinces 
 his sincerity and earnestness. Thus one can be the means of 
 bringing others to a right decision by the force of example. 
 
 5. The effect of taking such a step is also an encouragement 
 to the minister and the church. By this means they know that 
 their labors are not in vain. They see that their prayers are 
 being answered. 
 
 It may be asked, however, " What authority have we in the 
 teachings or examples of the Bible for anxious-seats ? " 
 Answer : I have shown that the principle of publicly avowing our 
 desire for salvation is recognized by Christ. -I am not tenacious 
 about the way of carrying out the principle, whether an inquirer
 
 216 THE UTILITY OP ANXIOUS-SEATS, BY 
 
 rise on his feet and speak, or whether he take a seat assigned 
 for those in his condition. I prefer the latter course on several 
 accounts. Some persons are timid (especially ladies), and 
 shrink from speaking for the first time before a large and 
 pi-omiscuous assembly. They can quietly walk forward to au 
 assigned seat much more readily. Again, the interest of the 
 meeting is ascertained and concentrated. Scores may rise from 
 their seats and sit down again, and be unnoticed, and the church 
 fail to appreciate the extent of the feeling. Besides, the anxious 
 become more accessible to the acquaintance, sympathy, and 
 instruction of the minister and brethren. In many cases the 
 mere act of coming forward has brought no relief; but once 
 forward, the anxious soul comes in contact with some one who 
 takes an immediate interest in his case, prays for him, converses 
 with him, follows him up, and thus he is saved. 
 
 It should be borne in mind that while the means of grace are 
 divinely appointed, such as the preaching of the gospel, prayer, 
 singing, baptism, and the Lord's supper, the measures in detail 
 which are to be adopted in applying these agencies are left to 
 be determined by the varying circumstances and exigencies of 
 the time, and place, and people. 
 
 Hence, while the act of preaching is an imperative duty, it is 
 a matter of discretion or circumstance whether we preach in a 
 dedicated building, an ordinary dwelling, a barn, or the open 
 field. We may preach throughout one hour or two hours, fast 
 or slow, loud or low. 
 
 It is the duty of Christians to pray, but the style or method 
 of our praying need not be the same in all cases. We must 
 baptize, but it is left free to decide, according to circumstances, 
 whether we shall baptize in a river, a lake, the sea, or a fount. 
 Only in all cases let it be remembered that we are to " let all 
 things be done decently and in order."
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 217 
 
 VI. 
 
 HOW TO INSTRUCT INQUIRERS. 
 
 ON this subject the Bible is our guide. Peter said to those 
 who asked " What must we do? " " Repent and be bap- 
 tized." When the jailer asked a similar question, Paul an- 
 swered, " Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ." Jesus said, 
 " Come unto me, all ye that are weary and heavy-laden, and I 
 will give you rest." These directions are substantially alike. 
 No man repents without believing. No man believes in Christ 
 without repenting, and no man comes to Christ without doing 
 both ; and baptism is the symbol and profession of this moral 
 experience. 
 
 Thirty-five or forty years ago, Baptists, Presbyterians, and 
 Congregationalists would tell inquirers to go home, read their 
 Bibles, reflect upon their condition, look within, dig deep, and 
 be not deceived. They enforced a process of introspection, rather 
 than the idea of looking out from themselves unto Jesus. The 
 Methodists would tell them to put their names on the " class " 
 paper, and become probationers for six months. In many cases 
 they would find a kind of relief in the notion that they had a 
 period of six months in which to become Christians ; but before 
 the allotted period had expired their interest would die out, and 
 they would find themselves where they started, with this 
 difference, that they were more hardened, and less likely to 
 make another effort. 
 
 In contradistinction from all such usages of delay and 
 hesitancy, the apostles called upon men to make an immediate 
 surrender of their hearts to God. They required the exercise 
 16
 
 218 HOW TO INSTRUCT INQUIRERS, BY 
 
 of repentance and faith on the spot. They made no provision 
 for delays, and clearly implied that this very hesitancy was a 
 resistance of the Holy Spirit, and an act of hostility to God. 
 Any other instruction seems like tolerating impenitence, unbelief, 
 and a rejection of Christ. 
 
 Is it not amazing that ministers of the gospel should betray 
 such ignorance of the Sacred Scriptures, and be so regardless 
 of inspired directions and apostolic examples? Yet despite 
 such bad counsels, many made out to stumble into the kingdom ; 
 while others would guess their way along in darkness for years, 
 and after a while would get some glimmers of light. I am 
 amazed that while the other denominations named are coming 
 nearer to the Bible standard, that our Methodist friends should 
 hold on to their old tradition of putting all of the inquirers on a 
 probation of six months. I think it is the worst thing in their 
 whole system, and have been hoping and praying that they 
 would correct the evil. 
 
 There are numerous influences which operate on inquirers to 
 embarrass their efforts after salvation. Some are holding on to 
 their companions, and are unwilling to give them up for Christ. 
 Others are depending on something which they have done, or 
 intend to do, instead of depending on Christ alone. Some are 
 unwilling to abandon an unlawful business, or to give up their 
 unlawful gain. Others again have contracted bad habits, such 
 as the use of tobacco, wine, rum, whiskey, or dancing. Every 
 person is willing to give up something, but not the particular 
 idol which they worship. They make reservations, and say, 
 " Pardon, O Lord, thy servant in this one thing." But Christ 
 says, " Whosoever doth not forsake all that he hath, cannot be 
 my disciple." 
 
 If persons, who have been converted, are in a backslidden 
 state, now hoping and now doubting, it is safe to bring them to 
 the same test that you do an inquirer. The great necessity is 
 to bring every soul to trust in Christ solely and implicitly, and 
 to serve him unreservedly, and leave all consequences with Him, 
 who, with Christ, freely giveth us all things. It is ours to 
 serve God ; it is his to save.
 
 ELDER JACOB KN'APP. 219 
 
 We are all directed to pray. The apostle told Siinou to 
 " pray God, if perhaps the thought of thy heart may be for- 
 given thee." God " will have all men to pray everywhere." 
 The mercy-seat should be the sinner's first resort. O, how 
 strange it is that the soul should be so loath to come to Jesus, 
 the sinner's friend, and his only " helper in time of trouble " 
 to him who has done for him more than any other being, and 
 stands ready to save ! 
 
 No two persons under conviction are exercised precisely 
 alike. There are diversities of operations, but the same God 
 " worketh all in all." This passage refers not only to the 
 diversity of gifts dispensed among his people, but it refers also 
 to the diversity of operations in converting sinners. 
 
 There is a difference in the times when the Spirit begins to 
 work on the hearts of men. Some are moved upon when very 
 young. I have no doubt some are born again at the age of three 
 or four years. The sovereignty of God cannot be called in 
 question. The Spirit goeth " where it listeth." But these 
 early conversions are the result, to some extent, of early instruc- 
 tions, and in answer to the earnest prayers of parents. Some 
 such persons often doubt the genuineness of their conversions, 
 because they have not experienced such decided convictions as 
 others speak of who have lived longer in sin. Perhaps, how- 
 ever, like Samuel, they have been called before they were old 
 enough to recognize the voice of God. They have no re- 
 membrance of the time when they did not love God. They 
 must be instructed accordingly ; and it is a great mistake to 
 attempt to judge of their experience by some other person's 
 standard. 
 
 There is a difference to be observed in the kind of truth to be 
 presented to different persons with a view to awakening them. 
 Some can be moved by the constrainings of the love of Christ ; 
 others may be aroused by the terrors of the law. It is common 
 for most persons to place a great estimate on the value of that 
 particular class of truths that interested them, and to think the 
 method which secured their attention preferable to any other.
 
 220 HOW TO INSTRUCT INQUIRERS, BY 
 
 There is a difference in the length of time in which the 
 Spirit strives with men. Some persons he follows after for 
 years ; others may never have more than one distinct call. If 
 that is rejected, they are forever lost. 
 
 These differences of operations are owing, in part, to the way 
 in which the Spirit is treated. If it is rejected deliberately, he 
 may leave the soul at once. But in other cases men sin 
 ignorantly : seeking the truth, but unconsciously submitting to 
 some unrecognized influences which hinder the Spirit's opera- 
 tions ; and God forbears. All these cases are to be treated 
 differently. 
 
 There is also a difference in the degree or depth of conviction 
 in different persons. Some need only to know the will of God 
 concerning them, and they yield at once. Others are more 
 stubborn in the natural disposition, and will not yield unless 
 God puts the screws to them and almost kills them. Our in- 
 structions to the anxious must make " a difference " according 
 to the different conditions of the person with whom the Spirit is 
 striving. 
 
 There is a difference in the manner in which relief comes to 
 persons. Some find it gradually, hardly knowing how or when. 
 Others find the relief at once, and never forget the time or 
 place when the burden rolls off from their minds. The con- 
 version may be as genuine in the one case as in the other. 
 Two men may be going up a long, steep hill, each with a bag 
 of sand on his back. In one of these bags there is a hole, and 
 the sand gradually falls out, and the man hardly perceives the 
 lessening of the load, but soon it is all gone ; the other carries 
 his load, and it seems to grow heavier and heavier. All at 
 once the straps break, and the bag falls to the ground. He 
 knows the moment when the burden fell. But in the one case 
 the relief is as actual and real as in the other. Each has got 
 rid of his burden. 
 
 So also there is a difference as to the way in which light 
 comes into the soul. Some see but a very few rays at first. 
 Conversion is to them like the dawning of day. They never
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 221 
 
 see any great light ; can hardly tell whether any change has 
 come over them or not ; and because they have not felt, as some 
 say they have, they are tempted to doubt the reality of their 
 hopes. Still they love God, and love his people, and love his 
 service. Others experience a divine illumination. All at once 
 light is poured into their souls. The change is so great that 
 they never forget the time. These persons need to be taught 
 that the genuineness of their conversion does not depend on the 
 degree of light they have enjoyed, but on the state of their affec- 
 tions ; whether they love God and keep his commandments ; 
 whether they are in sympathy with Christ, his service, and his 
 people. There was a difference between the conversion of the 
 eunuch and that of Paul. But Paul never bases the reality of 
 his conversion on the mere miraculous circumstances which 
 attended it. 
 
 But I am constrained to say that I have never depended as 
 much as some have on instructions to the anxious. Rather I 
 have insisted on immediate decision on instantaneous repent- 
 ance, and faith in the Lord Jesus. In the anxious-room I 
 depend more on prayer, on prevailing supplication with God, 
 than on all the instructions which can be given. Everything is 
 dark to the sinner until enlightened by the Spirit ; and no 
 coaxing, no teaching, no driving will compel or induce the 
 devil to leave his palace in the human soul, until the stronger 
 than the strong man armed comes upon him and binds him. 
 Then the work is done, and done effectually. Hence I get all 
 on their knees, and set them to crying to God (both saints and 
 sinners), till he sends down salvation. I have known fifty souls 
 to be converted in one season of prayer, that is, before we have 
 risen from our knees.
 
 222 ADVICE TO YOUNG CONVERTS, BY 
 
 VII. 
 
 ADVICE TO YOUNG CONVERTS. 
 
 THE first duty required of a new-born soul is to be baptized 
 into Christ. They are dead to sin, dead to the world, and 
 dead to the penalty of the law. These great facts in their spirit- 
 ual condition they are enjoined to symbolize, by being " buried 
 with Christ in baptism." 
 
 They also believe in the death and resurrection of Christ, 
 and are required to express that faith in baptism. When they 
 go down into the liquid grave, they say they believe that Christ 
 *' died for their sins, and was buried ; " and when they come up 
 out of the water, they set forth their belief that he rose from 
 the dead ; that he liveth, liveth forever, and that all his believers 
 will be raised from the grave, and exalted to a share in the 
 glory of Christ forever and ever. 
 
 The New Testament makes no provision of a moment's delay 
 between the exercise of faith and the act of baptism. 
 
 2. Be careful to maintain secret prayer. Jesus says, " Enter 
 thou into thy closet, and when thou hast shut to thy door, pray 
 to thy Father, which is in secret, and thy Father, which seeth 
 in secret, shall reward thee openly." It is blessed, indeed, to 
 retire from all the world, to be shut up with God, when no 
 human eye sees, and no human ear hears.- The thought that 
 God will listen to our cries, will sympathize with our trials, 
 and assist and deliver us in all our perplexities, is itself full of 
 comfort. 
 
 In the matter of prayer, great care should be taken to estab- 
 lish regular seasons of prayer. Let nothing interrupt your
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 223 
 
 engagements with God. If you only visit your closet when it 
 is convenient, you will be tempted to neglect the privilege of 
 prayer, from time to time, until it is dispensed with altogether. 
 The man who does not take pains to wind up his watch at 
 stated seasons, will seldom have correct time. 
 
 3. If it is in your power to do so, maintain family prayer. 
 Joshua said, u As for me and my house, we will serve the 
 Lord." 
 
 If the husband and father are absent, the wife and mother 
 should lead in the service. It is desirable, in cases where the 
 husband is not a Christian, that the pious wife maintain the 
 appointment. - 
 
 4. Study the word of God. " Search the Scriptures," said 
 Jesus. And the Bereans were complimented as being more 
 noble than those of Thessalonica, in that "they searched the 
 Scriptures daily." The words which Jesus speaks are " spirit, 
 aud they are life." 
 
 Do not read the Scriptures in the spirit of controversy, but of 
 candid aud prayerful self-application. 
 
 Read the word of God frequently. It will bear reading over 
 and over again. Let not a day pass without reading a portion 
 of this precious message of God to your souls. 
 
 The perusal of this sacred book will improve the intellect and 
 purify the heart. A person who has a good knowledge of the 
 Scriptures has a good education. It is said that many of the 
 children of the early Christians could repeat the entire Bible, 
 from the beginning to the end. The Bible is the chart to direct 
 us to heaven ; a lamp to light us through this dark world to the 
 better land. 
 
 5. Make the service of God your business for life. Let 
 everything else bend to that. " Seek first the kingdom of 
 God, and all these things shall be added unto you." Do all 
 things " to the glory of God." Engage in nothing on which 
 you cannot ask the blessing of God. Make all other claims 
 secondary and subservient to religious duties. Thus you will 
 fill your places in the church, in the prayer-meeting, and bear
 
 224 ADVICE TO YOUNG CONVERTS, BY 
 
 your share in the support of the ministry and the spread of the 
 gospel at home and abroad. 
 
 Never shrink from the performance of duty in social wor- 
 ship. Be ready to speak, to pray, and to engage in every good 
 word and work. The Savior has given us the test and the 
 standard : " If any man will come after me, let him deny him- 
 self, and take up his cross, and follow me." 
 
 In this connection, I may add, that it is of the first im- 
 portance to aim at a symmetrical development of character. 
 Some men will talk in meeting, but will give little or nothing 
 to support the gospel ; others will give freely as the Lord has 
 prospered them, but will neither speak nor pray in public. 
 Every grace and every talent must be cultivated, that we may 
 grow up unto " the perfect man, unto the measure of the fulness 
 of Christ." When only some graces and gifts are cultivated and 
 others are neglected, the character grows out of shape, and be- 
 comes a deformity. Sometimes we meet with a man who prays 
 and talks like a saint, and is as penurious as a miser ; another 
 man deals out his money freely for Christian purposes, but never 
 has a word to say for Jesus, nor a prayer to offer for the con- 
 version of a " world lying in wickedness." Some people tell us 
 that they have no gift to pray or speak in the prayer and con- 
 ference meeting, but you will generally find them ready to take 
 part in the business meeting, especially if there is quarrelling 
 going on ; on such occasions they can speak with the vehemence 
 of a Demosthenes and the fluency of a Cicero. 
 
 6. " Exercise yourselves unto godliness." Without exercise 
 you will experience the evils of spiritual dyspepsia. A Christian 
 cannot safely allow a single day to pass without seeking to do 
 something specially with a view to doing good to others, or 
 overcoming sin in himself. As every part of the body is 
 strengthened by use and exercise, or weakened for the want of 
 them, in like manner our spiritual natures grow in grace by 
 reason of the active devotion of our powers to the service of 
 Christ. 
 
 7. Guard yourselves against the liabilities of your own
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 225 
 
 weaknesses. Satan knows what they are, and will tempt you 
 accordingly. 
 
 If in former times you have been accustomed to the use of 
 strong drink, your safety requires that you " touch not, taste 
 not." " Look not thou upon the wine when it is red, when it 
 giveth his color in the cup." 
 
 Do as did a man in the State of Illinois, who had cultivated 
 a thirst for strong drink. At the time of his conversion he was 
 owing a bill at a rum-shop, but he did not dare to trust himself 
 across the threshold ; so he put the amount of his indebtedness 
 in an envelope, and fastening it to the end of a pole, stuck the 
 pole into the window, and ran off as if all the devils in hell 
 were after him. 
 
 Have any of you been addicted to the use of tobacco ? Wage 
 a war of extermination with this wretched practice. Tobacco 
 was made to kill insects, not human beings. There is none 
 of the brute creation that will eat it, except the long-haired 
 goat, that climbs the side of the mountains of the East. 
 
 Tobacco softens the brain, weakens the intellect, enfeebles 
 the body, vitiates the appetite, and hurries its victims to the 
 grave. 
 
 The use of tobacco is a filthy habit. A person who is a 
 great smoker can be scented wherever he goes. He taints the 
 very atmosphere with the poisonous odor that exhales from 
 his breath and pervades his clothes ; and he must either be 
 accommodated with a spittoon wherever he goes, or be running 
 to the door, or window, or fire-hearth, to keep himself from 
 the disgusting alternative of spitting on the carpets of his 
 friends. 
 
 Some of you, perhaps, have been novel readers. If so, I beg 
 you to do as did the heathen who. were converted in the days of 
 the apostles. They brought their books together and burned 
 them before all the people, and counted the price of them, and 
 it amounted to fifty thousand pieces of silver. "When I closed 
 my meeting in the Baptist Tabernacle, New York city, I called 
 upoia the congregation to bring together all their novels and
 
 228 ADVICE TO YOUNG CONVERTS, BY 
 
 other pernicious books. A great heap of books was collected, 
 which for once were made useful in furnishing material for a 
 brilliant bonfire. 
 
 I warn you against all light reading, for the following 
 reasons : 
 
 a. It involves a waste of precious time. 
 
 b. It weakens the mental powers. A person can read novels 
 from morning till night, without exercising his powers of think- 
 ing. It promotes intellectual indolence, and disqualifies a per- 
 son for close application and original thinking. 
 
 c. It gives false views of life. Its scenes are unreal. They 
 rarely find their counterpart in the actual world. The imagina- 
 tion becomes disordered, and the mind loses its relish for the 
 matter-of-fact duties and realities of life. 
 
 It is rarely the case that a woman who has given herself up 
 to the practice of reading novels makes a good housekeeper. 
 The temptation to read " the last novel " is stronger than her 
 sense of obligation to her husband and children. The novel 
 must be devoured, even though her husband goes without his 
 meals and her children are compelled to wear unmended gar- 
 ments. 
 
 d. I need hardly enter into an argument to prove that the 
 practice of reading novels is a serious hinderance to growth in 
 grace. It begets a distaste for the duties of prayer, reading the 
 Bible, and seeking out opportunities of doing good to the many 
 objects of Christian sympathy which abound in the walks of 
 real life. A person who has tears to shed over scenes of fancied 
 sorrow, rarely has any to spare when called to look on the 
 scenes of actual woe. 
 
 e. Remember that Christianity is a radical principle. A 
 Bible Christian cannot be a conservative. Christianity is pro- 
 gressive in its nature. It aims to overthrow the kingdom of the 
 devil, and to oppose and remove everything which is opposed 
 to God and holiness. 
 
 The world and the devil are evermore in favor of com-
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 227 
 
 promise. This truth relates alike to religion and politics. But 
 "what fellowship hath light with darkness? or Christ with 
 Belial?" In regard to all subjects, take your position on God's 
 eternal truth, and stand there, though earth and hell oppose. 
 Christ resisted unto blood, striving against sin. 
 
 Let your influence always be decided and open against 
 slavery, intemperance, and oppression, and in favor of all 
 reforms which tend to elevate the condition of the race ; and 
 be willing to suffer, and, if need be, die for your conscientious 
 convictions. " He that seeketh his life, shall lose it, and he 
 that loseth his life, for my sake and the gospel's, shall find it."
 
 228 ACTIVE BENEVOLENCE, BY 
 
 VIII. 
 
 ACTIVE BENEVOLENCE. 
 
 BENEVOLENCE is in the nature of all holy beings. Love 
 to God and love to man are the legitimate expressions of 
 this principle. Man, in his primeval estate, was possessed of a 
 nature that did love God supremely, and could have loved his 
 neighbor as himself. But when he fell, the governing principle of 
 his soul was changed from this holy impulse to that of a supreme 
 love of self. In conversion, however, this original outgoing of 
 his nature reasserts itself, and in the supremacy of this restored 
 principle he becomes a new creature. 
 
 All the Christian graces spring from love. And as this love 
 towards sinful and suffering creatures takes the form of an ear- 
 nest and practical sympathy^ Christians find themselves having 
 the same yearning mind after their fellows which was also in 
 Christ Jesus. 
 
 Consequently we all lay all of our earthly possessions on 
 God's altar, and consecrate our time, our talents, our money, 
 and, if need be, our lives, to the work of doing good of glori- 
 fying God in laboring for the salvation of the world. Self, 
 which is the great law of our fallen natures, is now ignored ; 
 we are restored to our original condition of communion with 
 God, and fellowship with angels, and sympathy with men. 
 
 We propose to show the duty of exercising the grace of 
 Benevolence. 
 
 1. The duty of benevolence is taught by the voice of nature. 
 
 The sun does not shine for itself, but for others. The clouds 
 do not pour down their refreshing showers for themselves, but 
 for others. The earth does not yield its great variety of delicious
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 229 
 
 and golden fruits fjr itself, but for others. God did not fill the 
 earth with beautiful and fragrant flowers, and wrap the earth in 
 its green carpet, for himself, but for man ; nor did he make the 
 various orders of the brute creation subordinate to man's au- 
 thority, and subservient to him, for his own gratification or 
 necessity, but for man's. 
 
 The selfish man has no sympathy with God in these regards ; 
 nor is he in sympathy with angels and good men. All nature 
 is breathing forth the spirit of benevolence. We see it with our 
 eyes ; we hear it with our ears ; we inhale it in every breath ; 
 we partake of it with every morsel of food we eat ; and if we 
 do not reciprocate it, but remain selfish, cold, dead, and senseless 
 to all the obligations these exhibitions of his goodness impose, 
 we are worse than blanks, or drones ; we are fit for nothing 
 but to be cast out and trodden under foot. 
 
 2. God enjoined the duty of active benevolence upon his 
 covenant people, the Jews, and without it they could not be 
 numbered among his people. Every man must pay one tenth 
 of all for the support of the ministry, and one tenth for their 
 sacrifices, or burnt-offerings, which made twenty per cent. ; then 
 they had to build and rebuild their temple, observe all of their 
 feasts and fasts, attend all of their protracted meetings, which 
 were frequent and sometimes long continued ; in addition to all 
 of these, once in seven years debtors were all released, servants 
 all set free, and their lands were allowed to rest. Moreover, 
 they were required, when gathering their harvest, to let fall 
 some hands full for the poor, and to leave more or less of all 
 kinds of fruits for those who had none. 
 
 Their zeal for the Lord of Hosts was so great, that on some 
 occasions they mortgaged their lands and all they had to main- 
 tain their worship ; yet this people rose rapidly in wealth, intel- 
 ligence, refinement, and power among the nations of the earth ; 
 and when the honor of their divine Master required it, they 
 brought forth their tithes and offerings so freely and so abun- 
 dantly that they had to be restrained.
 
 230 ACTIVE BENEVOLENCE, BY 
 
 3. We have the example of holy angels to enforce the duty 
 of active benevolence. 
 
 All of their visits to the children of men, for six thousand 
 years, have been visits of mercy and benevolence. During all 
 these thousands of years no angel ever came down to set up a 
 kingdom for himself, or to gather up silver, gold, pearls, or 
 precious stones, with which to enrich himself, but always for 
 the sake of doing something for others ; now confirming the 
 wavering, now strengthening the feeble-minded, and ever attest- 
 ing their profound interest in the several phases of Christ's 
 ministry for the redemption of man. 
 
 4. The holy apostles taught and carried out this principle of 
 benevolence. 
 
 They consecrated themselves, their all, to the work of Chris- 
 tian benevolence, the good of mankind, and the glory of God. 
 They neither faltered nor turned aside from this work. They 
 lost sight of all self-interests. They had but one object in living. 
 " They counted not their lives dear unto them." 
 
 Paul said, " I am ready not only to be bound, but also to die 
 at Jerusalem, for the name of the Lord Jesus." Again, " I am 
 determined to know nothing among you, save Jesus Christ and 
 him crucified." Their love to God and man was so great, their 
 benevolence so unabating, that it led them to endure imprison- 
 ment oft, and stripes above measure. They were beaten with 
 rods, stoned, in perils oft, perils by the heathen, in perils in the 
 city, ia perils among robbers, in perils among false brethren, in 
 weariness and painfulness, in hunger and thirst, in fastings 
 often, in cold and nakedness, homeless and houseless ; yet, 
 prompted by pure benevolence, they went on, until they sealed 
 their testimony for the truth with their lives. O God, how 
 ashamed I feel when I contrast my benevolence with theirs ! 
 If the apostles had pursued the course which some persons in 
 modern times do, it would have overthrown the whole kingdom of 
 Christ. But none could doubt their sincerity ; none could ques- 
 tion their motives ; all must have been convinced that they were 
 prompted by a disinterested spirit. Their benevolence was not
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 231 
 
 an abstract principle, confined to creeds and books, but an active, 
 controlling, propelling power, which made them omnipotent 
 for good. 
 
 5. But the crowning example of benevolence is furnished in 
 the mission of the Sou of God. His errand to this world was 
 purely an errand of love for us. He came not to be ministered 
 unto, but to minister. " God commendeth his love toward us, 
 in that while we were yet sinners Christ died for us." Paul 
 calls the coming of Christ to save us, God's " unspeakable gift," 
 and presents his spirit as the model and inspiration of true 
 Christian benevolence. " Ye know the grace of our Lord Jesus 
 Christ, who, though he was rich, for our sakes became poor, 
 that we through his poverty might be rich." We are exhorted 
 to " let the same mind be in us which was also in Christ Jesus." 
 and are solemnly reminded, that " if any man have not the 
 spirit of Christ, he is none of his." 
 
 6. The whole of God's word breathes and enforces the duty of 
 benevolence. The book itself is a benevolent gift from God to 
 man. The ends which it designs to accomplish are all benevo- 
 lence, and the duty of benevolence is taught on almost every 
 page. Let us listen to a few sentences. 
 
 " Whatsoever we would that men should do unto you, do ye 
 even the same unto them." 
 
 " Freely ye have received, freely give." 
 
 " He that hath two coats, let him impart to him that hath 
 none ; and he that hath meat, let him do likewise." 
 
 " Sell that ye have and give alms. Provide yourselves bags 
 which wax not old, a treasure in the heavens that faileth not." 
 
 u And I say unto you, Make unto yourselves friends of the 
 mammon of unrighteousness, that when ye fail they may re- 
 ceive you into everlasting habitations." 
 
 " Therefore, as ye abound in everything, see that ye abound 
 in this grace [benevolence] also." 
 
 " As we have therefore opportunity, let us do good unto all 
 men ; especially unto them who are of the household of faith." 
 
 " Charge them that are rich in this world that they be not
 
 232 ACTIVE BENEVOLENCE, BY 
 
 high-minded, nor trust in uncertain- riches, but in the living God, 
 who giveth us all things richly to enjoy ; that they do good ; 
 that they be rich in good works, ready to distribute, willing to 
 communicate ; that they may lay hold on eternal life." 
 
 7. Benevolence does not improverish us. God delights to 
 make happy the poor and the needy, and to have his gospel 
 preached and his word extended to every creature ; and wher- 
 ever he sees an agent who will dispense to the poor, and give 
 liberally to spread the gospel, he delights to furnish him with 
 the means. He can bless all around him. Hence unto him that 
 hath shall be given, and he shall have more abundantly. 
 
 " Cast thy bread upon the waters, and thou shalt find it after 
 many days." 
 
 " He is ever merciful, and lendeth, and his seed shall be 
 blessed." 
 
 " A good man showeth favor and lendeth ; surely he shall 
 not be moved forever. The righteous shall be held in everlast- 
 ing remembranc'e." 
 
 " There is that scattereth and yet increaseth, and there is that 
 withholdeth more than is meet, but it tendeth to poverty." 
 
 " The liberal soul shall be made fat," a.nd " he that watereth 
 shall himself be watered." " Honor the Lord with thy sub- 
 stance and with the first fruits of thy increase ; so shall thy barns 
 be filled with plenty, and thy presses burst out with .new wine." 
 
 " There is that maketh rich, .yet hath nothing ; and there is 
 that maketh himself poor, and yet hath great riches." 
 
 " But the liberal deviseth "liberal things, and by liberal things 
 shall he stand." 
 
 " Give and it shall be given unto you, good measure, pressed 
 down, shaken together, and running over." 
 
 Now, if we believe these sentiments, expressed by men in- 
 spired by the Holy Spirit, we must admit that benevolence is not 
 the road to poverty, but the way to prosperity. 
 
 8. Benevolence makes both the giver and the receiver happy, 
 and the former more than the latter. 
 
 " It is more blessed to give than to receive."
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 233 
 
 " Blessed [or happy] are the merciful, for they shall obtain 
 mercy." 
 
 " The blessing of him that was ready to perish came upon me, 
 and I caused the widow's heart to sing for joy." 
 
 The more closely we conform to the laws of God's moral 
 government, the more effectually we secure our own happiness, 
 and every deviation from those laws must produce misery. 
 
 Man is so constituted, that he must practise benevolence to 
 his fellow-man, or not only suffer in his moral character, but 
 jeopardize his immortal soul. 
 
 The falling under the controlling power of self-love and its 
 constant gratification, with no ventilation by benevolence, is like 
 the constant increase of steam without ventilation, until the 
 frightful explosion takes place. In these times of great worldly 
 prosperity, we do well to keep our eye upon the safety-valve, 
 and to ventilate by benevolence, or we may burst our boilers, 
 and go to perdition. 
 
 9. Benevolence is pleasing to God. The apostle says, " I 
 am full, having received of Epaphroditus the things which were 
 sent from you, an odor of sweet smell, a sacrifice acceptable, 
 well-pleasing to God" 
 
 " God loveth a cheerful giver." 
 
 " To do good and to communicate forget not, for with such 
 sacrifices God is well pleased." 
 
 If, then, benevolence is well pleasing to God, the want of it 
 must be very offensive to him. The selfish, penurious, hide- 
 bound soul must be an offence to him, and a disgusting object 
 to all benevolent, holy beings, in the universe. The good things 
 of this life are designed for three distinct objects: 1. To feed 
 and clothe the body ; 2. To educate the intellect ; and, 3. To 
 cultivate the heart, or to educate men for heaven. When they 
 are used for either of these objects they are a blessing ; but 
 when turned into another channel they become a cuvse. If 
 hoarded up, they feed and strengthen the root of all evil. If 
 laid out for display, for vain-glory, for sinful and foolish amuse- 
 ments, they strengthen all of the vile passions of our fallen 
 17
 
 234 ACTIVE BENEVOLENCE, BY 
 
 nature, which must be crucified, or they will destroy our 
 souls. 
 
 " If ye live after the fleshy ye shall die." 
 
 These passions are the thorns which choke the word and ren- 
 der it unfruitful. These riches and carnal indulgences rear 
 the dam, and raise the pond which drowns men in destructiou and 
 perdition. What, then, can we do with the surplus avails of our 
 industry better than to exercise the principle of benevolence, 
 and give, it full scope in pleasing God, making our fellow-men 
 happy, and producing a God-like peace and bliss within our own 
 souls? 
 
 But the great anxiety of many is to lay up for their children. 
 They seem to think that, though Jesus ha,s said, " Lay not up 
 on earth treasures for yourselves," yet they may lay up treasures 
 on earth for their children. 
 
 It is, undoubtedly, the duty of all parents to see that their 
 children are comfortably fed and clad ; that all of their cor- 
 poral, intellectual, and moral necessities are met ; that they are 
 trained for the highest possible degree of usefulness and happi- 
 ness : but to put them in a condition of ease and affluence, where 
 neither their brain, their bones, nor their muscles will be taxed, 
 is to do them the greatest possible injury. Piety never outlives, 
 the third generation in the midst of abounding wealth, and sel- 
 dom the second. We who are parents can see that it is not 
 easy to induce our children, even in the absence of the means of 
 cultivating the carnal propensities of their fallen nature, to start 
 in and persevere in the way to heaven ; and how much more 
 difficult when they abound in all the means to gratify their 
 ambition, their pride, their vanity, their love of pleasure ! The 
 stream against which we all have to struggle to reach heaven 
 is mighty ; but, in their case, the influences by which they are 
 surrounded set in like a flood, and become almost irresistible. 
 The Savior, fully understanding all these things, exclaimed, 
 " How hardly shall they that have riches enter into the kingdom 
 of God ! " " It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of 
 a needle than for a rich man to enter into the kingdom of
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 235 
 
 God ' Borne along by this current, they may at times look 
 heavenward, and think of their parents, who have gone before 
 them, and make some feeble efforts to reach the promised land. 
 But, alas ! the current is too strong for them to resist, the temp- 
 tations too great for them to overcome, and they go down, one 
 after another, until they are all destroyed. 
 
 Many parents may look down from heaven, and see the;obstar 
 cles which they have placed in the way of the salvation of their 
 dear children, by not conforming to the divine rule in carrying 
 out the principle of active benevolence. They now understand, 
 as they never did before, " They that will be rich fall into temp- 
 tation and a snare, and into many foolish and hurtful lusts, 
 which drown men in destruction and perdition." 
 
 Even if we had no regard to the future, it is a bad policy to 
 lay up riches for our children. It is well known that the most 
 of our successful business men began with nothing. Our most 
 able preachers of the gospel, our lawyers, physicians, and states- 
 men, are self-made men, who are indebted to the heavy tax upon 
 their own efforts for success. Viewing the subject in this light, 
 it is not strange that John said, " Love not the world, neither 
 the things which are in the world ; " " If any man love the world, 
 the love of the Father is not in him." 
 
 Nor is it strange that Jesus pronounced the man a fool " who 
 layeth up treasures on earth, and is not rich towards God." 
 Well might the wise man say, " Give me neither poverty nor 
 riches." The man who is not a benevolent man cannot be au 
 honest man ; because all we have and are belong to God, and 
 not to ourselves. 
 
 God commands us to " do good unto all men as we have oppor- 
 tunity," to " love our neighbor as ourselves," to " deal our 
 bread to the hungry," to " go into all the world, and preach 
 the gospel unto every creature." Can we shut up the bowels 
 of our compassion against the needy, hoard up God's money, 
 withhold the gospel from the perishing, and be honest? It is 
 impossible. We defraud the needy ; we embezzle our Lord's 
 goods, pervert the end of our being, and shut up the kingdom
 
 236 ACTIVE BENEVOLENCE, BY 
 
 of God against men. In fact the faithful discharge of our duty, 
 in the best use of everything committed to our care, can hardly 
 be regarded as benevolence ; it is but discharging a duty which 
 we owe to God and man. When we have done all, we have 
 done no more than that which it was our duty to do, and are 
 unprofitable servants. 
 
 What will Jesus say, in the day of reckoning, to him who 
 has wasted or withheld his Lord's money? Will he not be 
 more likely to say, " Bind him hand and foot, and cast him into 
 outer darkness," than to say, "Well done, good and faithful ser- 
 vant " ? May God enable us so to live, and so to occupy, as that 
 when he comes to call us to an account, he may say to us, one 
 and all, " Ye have done what ye could." " Enter ye into the 
 joy of your Lord."
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 237 
 
 IX. 
 
 RESTRICTED AND MIXED COMMUNION. 
 
 [It is believed that much of the unkind feeling, among all denomi- 
 nations, and uncharitable remarks about each other, proceed from a mis- 
 conception of each other's sentiments ; and there is no one thing more 
 generally censured than restricted communion, as practised by the 
 Baptist denomination, and that because it is BO greatly misapprehended 
 or so little understood. The design, then, of this little Tract, is not 
 only to direct all candid inquirers after truth to the apostolic practice, 
 but also to rectify mistakes, to remove prejudice, and to promote Chris- 
 tian union.] 
 
 BY mixed communion, I mean the custom of inviting mem- 
 bers of all denominations to the communion table ; and by 
 restricted communion, I mean confining the invitation to the 
 members of the same denomination. 
 
 MIXED COMMUNION. 
 
 1. It has no tendency to increase brotherly love. The truth 
 of this statement is obvious, from the well-known fact, that 
 notwithstanding Pedobaptist churches have, to some extent, 
 practised mixed communion ever since they have existed, and 
 Baptist churches have never done it, yet there is no more union, 
 no more brotherly love, between any two Pedobaptist churches 
 than there is between the Baptist churches and any one of the 
 Pedobaptist churches ; and I think all observing men, who 
 have travelled and mingled to some considerable extent with 
 Christians of all denominations, will bear me out in saying, 
 that there is more unanimity of feeling, more concert of action,
 
 28 RESTRICTED AND MIXED COMMUNION, BY 
 
 between Baptists and Presbyterians, than there is between 
 Methodists and Presbyterians ; or between Baptists and Meth- 
 odists, than there is between Presbyterians and Methodists. 
 Hence there can be nothing in partaking of the bread and wine 
 by members of different and distinct bodies which tends to in- 
 crease Christian affection or Christian fellowship. 
 
 2. It has no tendency to bring the different denominations 
 together. 
 
 The ground of separation lies farther back it is found in 
 an honest (to speak with all charity) difference in sentiment, in 
 different views of church building ; and reason teaches there 
 can be nothing in an occasional interchange of communion 
 among some of the floating members of these different bodies 
 which tends to do away their difference in sentiment, or to bring 
 them all into one body. I would ask, Has it ever done it in one 
 single instance since these bodies have existed as such? I 
 challenge the world to produce one nor is there a prospect 
 that it ever will, for it has already been shown that there is no 
 more union between Pedobaptist churches, which have practised 
 mixed communion ever since they have existed as distinct 
 bodies, than there is between Baptist and Pedobaptist churches. 
 
 3. Mixed communion, like the fifth wheel in a carriage, is 
 uncalled for. Each church or denomination have their own 
 regulations, and all may commune at home as often as they 
 think proper ; and if they are located, in the providence of God, 
 where there is no church of their own denomination, and there 
 is one of another, if they wish to commune with it, why not first 
 become a member of it, and then walk with it, and act in keep- 
 ing with their profession ? And if there is a reason why they 
 cannot in conscience become a member of such a church, the 
 same reason must be in the way of their communing with it. 
 It is but seldom that even the greatest sticklers for mixed com- 
 munion ever commune with any other denomination. Scarcely 
 a leading, stable, prominent member of an open communion 
 church can be found who ever communes out of his own 
 denomination. Ask a man, How long have you been a member
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 
 
 of an open communion church ? Twenty years. How many 
 times did you ever commune with any other denomination? 
 Why, I do not Jcnotv as I ever did. Well, how great a 
 privilege can that be which you never wish to enjoy ? 
 
 4. Mixed communion compels a church to commune with its 
 excommunicated members. It is not an unfrequent occurrence 
 for persons excluded from one denomination to become members 
 of another ; and if members in good standing in any Christian 
 churches are invited to sit at the table, then these excommuni- 
 cated members may come back without any reparation, and 
 take their seat at the table of the church from which they have 
 but just been expelled. Should it be said that they are an- 
 swerable for such conduct, and not the church ? I would ask 
 if it is not an awkward position for a church to place themselves 
 in, to put all power out of their own hands to exclude a man 
 from their communion? A wicked, subtle, designing man may 
 bid defiance to the church, the ruling elders, the presbytery, 
 and the synod, or all combined, to prevent his claiming and 
 occupying a seat at their communion table. The principle of 
 mixed communion, then, annihilates the authority of the church, 
 and gives Satan an opportunity of trampling it, with all of its 
 officers, under foot. An occurrence of this kind is now fresh 
 in my mind. It took place in the town of Henderson, Jeffer- 
 son County, N. Y. A devoted and conscientious deacon of a 
 Congregational church commenced a , labor with a member of 
 the same church for unchristian-like conduct, but could obtain 
 no satisfaction. He then took one or two brethren with him, 
 spread out all the circumstances before them ; but he still justi- 
 fied himself, and abused his best friends, who were laboring for 
 his good. The church was at length compelled to exclude him. 
 He then went to a neighboring Methodist church, shed a few 
 crocodile tears, and told them he had been persecuted because 
 he had honestly changed his sentiments, and he was unanimously 
 received. The next communion season which this Congrega- 
 tional church enjoyed (or would have enjoyed, but for mixed 
 communion) , he comes forward, and with great care takes his
 
 240 RESTRICTED AND MIXED COMMUNION, BY 
 
 seat at the table by the side of the deacon who 'took up the 
 labor with him, for the express purpose of aggravating his 
 feelings. The deacon says to a member of a Baptist church 
 present (with whom he was very intimate), Brother Cole, what 
 shall I do ? I do not feel as though I could commune with that 
 man. Brother Cole answered, I pity you, deacon, from the 
 bottom of my heart, but I cannot relieve you ; this is the effect 
 of your wrong views of communion. The church was thrown 
 into such a state of perturbation as to disqualify them to receive 
 so holy an ordinance with pleasure or profit. 
 
 5. Mixed communion compels us to commune with those who 
 are guilty of crimes for which we should feel ourselves bound to 
 exclude our own members. For instance, suppose a Baptist 
 church practised mixed communion, and one of its members 
 should be guilty of attending balls, or a dancing-school, and the 
 church should pursue a gospel course of labor, and could not 
 reclaim her ; she says she will go where she pleases, justifies 
 herself and condemns them ; they would now feel themselves 
 solemnly bound to exclude her from the church, and no more 
 admit her to the table of the Lord. But suppose, upon their 
 invitation to all in good standing in other churches, a member 
 of an Episcopal church, who had repeatedly attended balls and 
 dancing-schools with this excluded member of the Baptist 
 church, should take her seat at the table, the church would be 
 compelled to commune with her, though guilty of the same 
 crime for which they had just expelled one of their own mem- 
 bers ; the church has no power over her to call her to an 
 account. She says, I belong to another body ; my church 
 tolerates me in choosing my own amusements, and pursuing 
 them at my pleasure. In view of all these difficulties con- 
 nected with mixed communion, I ask the candid and unbiased 
 reader if it would not be best, all things considered, for each 
 denomination to commune by itself, even if we were not bound 
 by Bible rule and apostolic examples. 
 
 6. If the communion is extended out of the denomination, it 
 is more difficult to find a stopping-place than to stop at the
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 241 
 
 boundary line of the denomination. There is almost an endless 
 variety of Christian denominations in the world, and all embrace 
 more or less truth in their creed, and the most of them may 
 have some true Christians among them. Doubtless there are 
 some true Christians in the Papal church, for God says, Come 
 out of her, my people ; and they could not come out, if not 
 there. Some true Christians may be found among the Arians 
 (called Christians) ; but to open the door to all these denomina- 
 tions, would be no better than to open it to all the world ; and 
 to open it to a part, and not to all, is to exclude some whom 
 Christ loves, and that upon more uncharitable grounds than 
 those taken by the Baptist denomination, because the Baptists 
 make a distinction between church-fellowship and Christian- 
 fellowship ; and others unchristianize all whom they exclude 
 from the table. 
 
 RESTRICTED COMMUNION. 
 
 It may be seen from the apostolic example that no person, 
 however pious, has a right to participate of the Lord's supper 
 until baptized. Baptism is everywhere required immediately 
 after repentance or faith in Christ, and there is not a single 
 instance recorded in the word of God where the communion 
 was administered before baptism. See Acts ii. 38 : " Then 
 Peter said unto them, Repent, and be baptized every one of you." 
 41st verse : " Then they that gladly received his word were bap- 
 tized ; and the same day there were added unto them about three 
 thousand souls." Here we see the order of the Christian church 
 at its establishment; they, 1. repented; 2. they were baptized, 
 and after that they were admitted to the communion ; see the 
 46th verse. The same order is marked out in 1 John v. 8 : 
 " There are three that bear witness in earth, the Spirit, and the 
 water, and the blood." Here it may be seen the Spirit (which 
 indicates the new birth) comes first ; the water (which is 
 baptism) comes second ; the blood (which is the communion) 
 comes third ; and we are charged, in 1 Cor. xi. 2, by the 
 inspired apostle, to keep the ordinances as they delivered them
 
 242 EESTRICTED AND MIXED COMMUNION, BY 
 
 to us. And who dare reverse this order? And to show still 
 further that the apostles uniformly and invariably required all 
 first to repent, and then to be baptized before they were ad- 
 mitted to the Lord's -table, look at Acts viii. 12 : " But when 
 they believed Philip, preaching the things concerning the kingdom 
 of God, and the name of Jesus Clmst, they were baptized, both 
 men and women." 13th verse : " Then Simon himself believed 
 also : and when he was baptized he continued with Philip." 
 It is equally clear that the eunuch did not commune until after 
 being baptized. See Acts viii. 35, 36, 37. The jailer and 
 his house likewise were baptized the same hour of the night in 
 which they believed. Note Acts xvi. 31, 32, 33 : "And they said, 
 Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ, and thou shalt be saved and 
 thy house ; and they spake unto him the word of the Lord, and 
 unto all that were in his house, and he took them the same hour 
 of the night and washed their stripes, and was baptized, he and 
 all his straightway." I also direct the candid inquirers after 
 truth, to Acts x. 47 and 48 : " Can any man forbid water, that 
 these should not be baptized, who have received the Holy -Ghost 
 as well as we? And he commanded them to be baptized in the 
 name of the Lord." 
 
 All, therefore, who take the Bible for their guide, follow the 
 apostolic example, and keep the ordinances as they were 
 delivered unto them, must insist upon every one's being baptized 
 before he is invited to the Lord's table. 
 
 Now it may be seen that all who believe sprinkling, pouring, 
 or plunging, is baptism, can commune, without violating con- 
 science, with all Christian denominations, though, as has been 
 shown, there is nothing gained by the practice, but much lost. 
 And it is equally clear that those who believe sprinkling or 
 pouring is not baptism ; that none are baptized but such as have 
 been immersed on the profession of their faith ; cannot commune 
 with any but those who have thus been baptized, without vio- 
 lating their conscience ; yea, more, without a palpable violation 
 of Bible rule, and the subversion of the apostolic example. 
 Eyery candid and intelligent person then must see, that the
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 243 
 
 Baptist denomination act consistently with themselves : that is, 
 if their views of baptism are correct, their action in relation to 
 communion is right ; and the moment they invite those to the 
 communion table who have not been immersed, they are 
 chargeable either with dishonesty or insincerity dishonesty, in 
 not acting in keeping with their sentiments ; or insincerity, in 
 what they profess to'believe.* 
 
 That there is no gospel baptism short of the immersion of a 
 believer in Christ, is quite certain from the following facts : 
 
 1. The meaning of the word. The word baptize is a Greek 
 
 * See the candid testimony of a Presbyterian minister, taken from the 
 American Presbyterian : 
 
 " Open communion is an absurdity, when it means communion with 
 the unbaptized. I would not, for a moment, consider a proposal to admit 
 an unbaptized person to the communion ; and can I ask a Baptist so to 
 stultify himself and ignore his own doctrine as to invite me to commune 
 with him while he believes I am unbaptized? I want no sham union 
 and no sham unity ; and if I held the Baptist notion about immersion, I 
 would no more receive a Presbyterian to the communion than I would 
 now receive a Quaker. 
 
 " Let us have unity, indeed, but not at the expense of principle; and 
 let us not ask the Baptist to ignore or be inconsistent with his own 
 doctrine. Let us not, either, make an outcry at his " close communion," 
 which is but faithfulness to principle, until we are prepared to be ' open 
 communists ' ourselves ; from which stupidity may we be forever pre- 
 served. Let us war not with his close communion, but with his doctrine 
 that immersion is baptism. 
 
 "It has been quite the fashion of late years for commentators, who 
 were ambitious to be thought candid and liberal, to concede to the 
 Baptists that baptism is immersion. The volumes thus far issued of 
 Langc's Commentary assume this, or assert it wherever the subject is 
 presented. Dean Stanley, in his charming books, does the- same ; and 
 so with others ; and these men continue to practice both sprinkling and 
 infant baptism. Such inconsistencies I am utterly unable to compre- 
 hend. If I believed what they teach I would be under the water before 
 a week should pass by. My faith in such men is shaken men who do 
 not follow their beliefs. 
 
 "No, let us have no unity and strive to have none that cannot 
 be in consistency with our doctrine. How can two walk together unless 
 they are agreed ? Let the unity stop where the agreement ends."
 
 244 RESTRICTED AND MIXED COMMUNION, BY 
 
 word ; it cannot mean everything to dip, pour, and sprinkle : 
 the Greek word rantize, means to sprinkle, and baptize, to dip. 
 This word is translated dip in the German tongue, and in some 
 instances in our version, where it does not refer to the ordinance 
 of baptism. " He to whom I shall give the sop, when I dip it ; " 
 the word rendered dip he're, is baptize. " He whose vesture is 
 dipped in blood." " That he may dip the tip of his finger in 
 water." The word rendered dip in all of these cases is baptize. 
 That the word baptize, or bapto, its root, cannot fairly and 
 honestly be translated so as to express anything short of 
 immersion, is admitted by the most profound linguists in 
 Germany ; by all learned authors, both ancient and modern ; 
 by the Edinburgh Encyclopedia ; and by the Greek church, 
 who understand their own language, and never call sprinkling 
 baptism, or who never call baptizing rantizing, or rantiziug 
 baptizing. What action, then, can be more plainly expressed, 
 more clearly defined, than Christian baptism, if the word were 
 translated? The following passages would read thus : " Repent 
 and be immersed." " Go teach all nations, immersing them." 
 " He that believeth and is immersed shall be saved." 
 
 2. That baptism is nothing short of immersion, is obvious, 
 from its being called a burial. See Rom. vi. 4 : " Buried with 
 him by baptism into death." Col. ii. 12. : " Buried with him 
 in baptism, wherein also ye are risen with him through the 
 faith of the operation of God, who hath raised him from the 
 dead." All can see that neither sprinkling nor pouring is a 
 burial. How would it read, Buried with him by sprinkling ? 
 Buried with him by pouring f 
 
 3. That sprinkling it not baptism, is certain, because it does 
 not represent the thing signified. Baptism is designed to show 
 forth our death to sin and the world, and our faith in the death, 
 burial, and resurrection of Christ ; it also shows to the world 
 that Christ, having been raised from the dead, has become the 
 first fruits of them that slept, and that he will enable us to ex- 
 claim, O death, where is thy sting? O grave, where is thy 
 victory? See 1 Cor. xv. 29: "Else what shall they do who
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 245 
 
 are baptized for the dead, if the dead rise not at all ? Why are 
 they then baptized for the dead ? " Here the apostle is speaking 
 upon the resurrection, and argues that the ordinance would be 
 without meaning if there be no resurrection. 
 
 4. That Christ and the apostles required immersion, and not 
 sprinkling, is obvious from the circumstances recorded in the 
 New Testament. They came from Judea and Jerusalem, and 
 from the region round about, to be baptized in Jordan. " John 
 baptized in Enon, near to Salem, because there was much 
 water there." They went down into and came up out of rivers, 
 which never would have been done, never is done, to sprinkle 
 persons. 
 
 OBJECTIONS. 1. It is said the Greek preposition eis means 
 unto, and that there is no evidence that the baptized went 
 "into" the water, or "came out" of it. I need not say a 
 word on this subject to the Greek scholar ; but let the English 
 reader bear in mind that this rendering of eis in other passages 
 where it occurs, would destroy all the miracles recorded in the 
 Bible, and overthrow the whole system of Christianity. We 
 are told the three Hebrew children were cast into the fiery 
 furnace, and there was not the smell of fire on their garments. 
 What miracle is there in this, if they only went to the furnace ? 
 
 In like manner, we are informed that Daniel was thrown into 
 the den of lions, and that they did not attack him ; but if he 
 was merely taken to the den, of course the lions could not get 
 hold of him. And again, how easy to say that the swine merely 
 went to the sea. Were we thus to resort to such a wicked and 
 dangerous perversion of the several accounts contained in the 
 Sacred Scriptures, we could easily explain away many of its 
 recorded wonders. 
 
 The same mode of cavilling will overthrow the future punish- 
 ment of the wicked. God says the wicked shall be cast into 
 hell ; but who knows, according to this wonderful invention, 
 but that they will be carried only to hell? Then, worst of all, 
 there is no evidence that any of us will ever enter into heaven.
 
 246 RESTRICTED AND MIXED COMMUNION, BY 
 
 We may go to heaven, but into what place or condition we shall 
 enter God only can tell. 
 
 2. It is said that there were not , water conveniences in 
 Jerusalem sufficient for the immei'sion of the three thousand 
 persons who were converted on the day of Pentecost. But all 
 who are acquainted with the history of that city, aud many who 
 have visited it, know it contained five pools of water, in either 
 one of which that number of persons could have been con- 
 veniently immersed. 
 
 3. It is said, also, that three thousand persons could not have 
 been immersed in one day. I beg my dear readers to bear in 
 mind that there were present on this occasion at least eleven 
 apostles, and these alone could have immersed the whole of 
 them in less than three hours. I have myself immersed in the 
 Crooked L^ke, N. Y., sixty persons in twenty-eight minutes, by 
 the watch, and that too without undue haste. Besides, it is 
 altogether probable that the seventy disciples were also there ; 
 and these, added to the number of the apostles, could have ren- 
 dered the administration of the ordinance to so many a matter 
 of perfect ease. Indeed, in the matter of time, we are of the 
 opinion that it requires scarcely any more time to immerse a 
 given number of candidates than it does to sprinkle water upon 
 them. So that nothing important is gained in time by supposing 
 the three thousand to have been sprinkled, unless we imagine 
 that the rantism was performed on them en masse; and there is 
 as much reason for imagining this latter method as for imagin- 
 ing that they were sprinkled at all. 
 
 4. It is thought by many that the jailer must have been 
 sprinkled. This notion rests upon the supposition that he was 
 rantized in the cell where Paul and Silas were confined. The 
 record^ as contained in Acts xvi. 33, is, that he took them the 
 same hour of the night, and washed their stripes ; and was bap- 
 tized, he and all his straightway. The account itself implies 
 more of service and preparation than could be conveniently per- 
 formed within the narrow limits and unfurnished apartments of a 
 prisoner's cell ; besides, it is hardly to be supposed that the jailer
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 247 
 
 would have subjected his household to the inconvenience of pass- 
 ing from the house to the cell in order to be sprinkled. But when 
 we remember that in the East the prison yards contained pools, 
 or tanks, for the purposes of ablution, it is easy to see how readily 
 they could have been immersed. Besides, the account further 
 states, that after they had been baptized, he brought the apostles 
 into his house, so that the family must have gone out of the 
 house to be baptized ; whereas, if sprinkling had been the mode, 
 it is more reasonable to suppose that the apostles would have 
 been taken into the house for the purpose of performing the 
 ceremony. 
 
 From this view of the subject, it may be seen that the Bap- 
 tist denomination, in the practice of restricted communion, are 
 not bigoted nor uncharitable ; that they are conscientiously 
 keeping the ordinances as the apostles delivered them unto us, 
 adhering strictly to Bible rule ; making the word of God the 
 rule of action, and not the consciences and traditions of men. 
 It should be understood that those \vho practise restricted 
 communion, do not say by it that they do not fellowship Pedo- 
 baptists as Christians, but that they do not fellowship Pedo- 
 baptism, or sprinkling ; nor do they say that they do not love 
 them as much as they love themselves. They could not com- 
 mune with themselves had they been sprinkled, and not baptized ; 
 and we are not commanded to love our neighbor better than 
 ourselves, but are strictly forbidden to love ourselves, or our 
 neighbors, more than we love God. There may be in a com- 
 munity hundreds of young converts who have not been baptized, 
 and are not yet members of any church ; and however dear these 
 converts might be to the church, and to the Savior too, no 
 consistent church would feel themselves justifiable in inviting 
 them to the communion table. Why not? Because they have 
 not been baptized, nor have they been regularly inducted into 
 the church ; for the same reason a consistent Baptist church 
 cannot invite a Pedobaptist to the table of the Lord, and yet 
 they may love them as they love these yc.ung converts, and
 
 248 RESTRICTED AND MIXED COMMUNION, BY 
 
 Christ may love them too ; yea, as they love themselves, and 
 treat them just as they would be treated in like circumstances. 
 When Christ took the twelve apostles into an upper room, and 
 broke the bread to them, there were many other true Christians 
 in Jerusalem, who were not invited to participate with them, be- 
 cause not yet regularly admitted into the church ; because some- 
 thing more than faith in the Lord Jesus Christ was requisite to 
 their being admitted to the Lord's supper. 
 
 From what has been said, it may be seen that the Christian 
 world is divided upon the subject of baptism, and that this is 
 the cause of their separation at the communion table. And two 
 things are worthy of note in this matter : one is, should they 
 commune together, the Baptist must violate his conscience, and 
 nothing would be gained by it ; they would still remain distinct 
 bodies, and the whole ground of controversy would remain 
 unsettled. The other is, however desirable it may be for all 
 divisions to be done away, and all the members of Christ's fam- 
 ily to be harmonized in one body, the Baptist cannot go over to 
 the Pedobaptist churches without violating conscience, or going 
 contrary to his honest views of Bible rule and apostolic example, 
 because he does not, he cannot believe sprinkling is baptism, or 
 that unconscious babes have any right to the ordinance. But 
 the Pedobaptist can come over to the Baptist denomination 
 without violating conscience, because he does believe immersion 
 is baptism, and that true believers are proper subjects for that 
 ordinance. 
 
 I would now ask the convert, who is not yet a member of 
 any church, to consider, that if you remain where you are, you 
 exclude yourself from communion with all Christian churches ; 
 and if you join a Baptist church, you are excluded by Bible rule 
 from communion with Pedobaptist churches ; and if you join a 
 Pedobaptist church, you exclude yourself from communion with 
 the whole Baptist denomination, and that too when the Baptist 
 denomination are bound by conscience and by Bible rule to 
 maintain the stand they have taken, and Pedobaptist churches 
 can come over to them without violating their conscience, and.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 249 
 
 all practise one way, and have " one Lord, one faith, and one 
 baptism," and one communion table, one church, and all striving 
 for one and the same things. 
 
 It may be asked, How can they commune together in heaven, 
 if not on earth ? We answer, there will be no bread and wine 
 administered in heaven. Christian fellowship we all have on 
 earth ; all Christians will have it in heaven. Church fellowship 
 is interrupted here by our different views of* church building ; 
 but in heaven there will be no difference of opinion all errors 
 will be done away. Had infant baptism, and all other errors, 
 been kept out of the church from the apostolic day down to the 
 present period, there had been no schisms, no breach of com- 
 munion on earth. The sin, then, of our separation at the Lord's 
 table on earth lies at the door of those who introduced, and 
 those who still practise, infant sprinkling. Let this corruption 
 of the Papal church be done away, and all Protestant churches 
 may come together. 
 
 1 may be asked, Can Baptist churches commune with a person 
 of good standing in a Pedobapttist church, who has been im- 
 mersed upon the profession of his faith in Christ ? I answer, in 
 my opinion they can do it without violating any Bible rule, 
 though it has been made to appear that mixed communion is 
 attended with many difficulties and no advantages. I say it can 
 be done without violating any Bible rule, and that, because, 
 notwithstanding there is an inconsistency in a baptized believer 
 remaining in and communing with an unbaptized church, yet wo 
 are not positively required by the word of God to exclude from 
 our fellowship a brother for every inconsistency. But as God 
 does require in his word that all persons should be baptized before 
 they come to the communion table, and as the primitive church did 
 comply with this requirement, we cannot extend the communion 
 to an unbaptized person without violating this Bible rule, and 
 going counter to the apostolic example. Lastly, I would ask, Is 
 there anything more unfriendly or exclusive in restricting the com- 
 munion of each denomination to itself, than there is in restricting 
 any other church act to itself ? such as the reception, discipline, 
 18
 
 250 RESTRICTED AND MIXED COMMUNION. 
 
 and exclusion of members, the consecration, or setting apart of 
 the officers of the church, or their deposition? It is not the 
 practice of mixed communion churches to invite persons belong- 
 ing to other denominations to participate with them in these 
 things. And why ? Because they belong to another body. Nor 
 do we complain of 'them for it, by calling them bigoted and un- 
 charitable ; and yet I see no reason why we might not as well 
 complain of bigotry in this thing, as they in our choosing to 
 commune by ourselves. We think, inasmuch as theje is a dif- 
 ference of opinion, and this difference of opinion has caused or 
 produced different denominations, that the best course we can 
 pursue is to go together as far as we think alike, then part in 
 friendship, and let each denomination pursue its own course, 
 without aspersions or abuse, until the errors which separate us 
 are removed ; and then these distinct organizations may be dis- 
 solved, and all enter one body, drink into one spirit, and rejoice 
 in one Lord, one faith, and one baptism; and then all can sit 
 down at one communion Itable. And that the Lord would 
 hasten this glorious period, l&Pall who love Zion most sincerely 
 ud devoutly pray.' 'A^toen, and Amen.
 
 SERMONS. 
 
 L* 
 
 LESSONS TAUGHT BY THE OX. 
 
 "The ox Jcnoweth his owner, and the ass his master's crib; 
 but Israel doth not know, my people doth not consider." 
 ISAIAH i. 3. 
 
 I 
 
 N this connection the Lord is urging a very just and grievous 
 complaint against his own people for their stupidity and for- 
 getfulness in matters of daty ; and' ae carries this complaint 
 first to the heavens^and says, " Hear, O heavens ! " because the 
 heavens are more faithful in answering the end of their being 
 than man. The sun has never Refused to shine, for one mo- 
 ment, since God separated the light from the darkness ; the 
 moon has always been faithful, and reflected her pale rays upon 
 the pathway of the traveller ; and the stars have never ceased 
 to twinkle. They all answer the end of their creation. But 
 man has become an opaque body. Man is as a wandering star. 
 He has left his orbit, and he passes on and on, and withholds 
 the light which God appointed him to reflect, and which he is 
 capable of reflecting upon his fellow-men. And then he carries 
 this complaint to the earth : " Give ear, O earth ! " implying 
 that the earth even is more faithful to answer the end of its 
 
 * Delivered Sunday morning, November 25, 1866, in the Blooming- 
 dale Baptist church, New York city. 
 
 (241)
 
 252 SERMONS BY 
 
 creation than is man ; for the earth has never withheld its 
 increase from the time God made it until now. The sun no 
 sooner melts away the banks of snow, breaks up the frosty 
 fetters of earth and warms its bosom, than vegetation springs 
 forth, the fields are covered with green, and the trees with 
 foliage ; and in a little time wefin,d the earth burdened with 
 the precious fruits of abundanrand varied vegetation. Even 
 where there is no root or seed planted, we find the mushroom 
 springing up in the walks of men. The earth, will not be 
 barren or unfruitful ; it will answer the end of its creation. 
 But, alas, how many barren souls there are in the human 
 family ! how many there are who utterly fail to bear the fruits 
 of the spirit of love, meekness, faith, and joy in the Holy Ghost, 
 humility, and all the graces of the Christian, which we "ought to 
 produce in abundance ! In fact there are many who utterly 
 fail to produce a single one of these fruits. 
 
 What extreme barrenness and unfruitfulness there is even on 
 the part of many of the children of God h And I do, not wonder 
 that God says, " Hear, O heavens, and .give ear, O earth ; " 
 and he adds, " I have nourished and brought up children, and 
 they have rebelled against me." What a^ pathetic appeal is 
 this ! "I have nourished and brought up children, and they 
 have rebelled against me." Perhaps some of us who are 
 parents feel the force of this complaint. We have reared our 
 children from their infancy, we have watched over them by 
 night and by day, we have toiled early and late, and to the ex- 
 tent of our capacity, to provide for their necessities and their 
 comfort, and to make them respectable in the world ; and they 
 turn their backs upon us, they trample our precepts under their 
 feet, and some hard-hearted miscreant has more influence over 
 them than the father who begat them, or the mother who 
 brought them forth, and watched over them from tender infancy 
 up to womanhood or manhood. So God says, " I have nour- 
 ished and brought up children, and they have rebelled against 
 me." He has brought us up from infancy, and fed us with 
 the fulness of wheat, with milk, with butter, with oil, and with
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 253 
 
 honey, and supplied all our wants ; and we, his children, 
 have turned our backs upon him, have trampled his precepts 
 under our feet, and have followed in the way of darkness and 
 death. And so^Ciod may <welj complain of the children of 
 men, and cry oiit, "Ah,. sinful nation, a people laden with 
 iniquity, a seed of evil, doers. '^ And then he says, " The 
 whole head is sick, andj,he .whole ;heart is faint. From the 
 sole of the foot even unto the head there is no soundness in it, 
 but wounds, and bruises, and putrefying sores ; they have 
 not been closed, neithe'r bound up, neither mollified with oint- 
 ment." 
 
 The figure is this : The father is castigating the wayward 
 son who sets up his will against his father's ; and the father lays 
 on the rod, again and again, until his whole person may be 
 gored with blood, and show the marks of the rod ; and the father 
 pauses, and says to the son, " Why should ye be stricken any 
 more? Why stand out against your father, and put him to 
 the painful necessity of laying on the rod? " He would rather 
 receive thfe stripes on his own back than lay them on his son, 
 if it would answer the same purpose ; but the son stands out in 
 rebellion, and the father is compelled to chastise him. So God 
 deals with the children of men. He deprives them of their 
 earthly possessions ; he lays those who are near and dear to 
 them on the bed of death ; one after another of their friends is 
 borne to the grave, and God chastises them ; and yet they 
 stand out, and utterly fail to answer the end of their being. 
 And then he says, " The ox knoweth his owner " (the stupid, 
 lowly ox knoweth his owner), " and the ass his master's crib ; 
 but Israel doth not know, my people doth not consider." 
 
 Now the doctrine of the text is simply this : The ox, the 
 stupid, lowly ox, and the stubborn, refractory ass, have more 
 sagacity in their sphere, and more submission to the will of 
 their owner, than man has in his sphere to the will of his 
 Owner. This is the doctrine of the text. 
 
 1. Now notice in the first place, u the ox knoweth his owner." 
 There is not an ox in all this world, which has long been owned,
 
 254 SERMONS BY 
 
 fed, and driven by one man, but knoweth that man from every 
 other man ; and very often he becomes very much attached to 
 him. He knows the sound of his voice, his coming in and 
 going out, and understands what he wants him to do ; but, 
 alas ! how many of the human family know not their rightful 
 owner God. 
 
 How many there are who are ignorant of the very being of 
 God. The fool hath said in his heart, There is no God. He 
 shuts his eyes, and can see no God ; he closes his ears, and can 
 hear no God ; and he says, " I am determined to acknowledge 
 no God ; " and he goes blindly on, and never knows his Owner. 
 Yet the evidences of God's existence are all around him, on 
 every hand ; and so plain as not to be gainsaid or resisted for 
 a moment. God has displayed his existence in every blade of 
 grass that grows, in every leaf that flutters in the wind, in every 
 stream that softly murmurs through the landscape, and in the 
 sunbeam, and in the sky. Around us, on every side, we see the 
 work of Almighty God ; and yet men shut their eyes against 
 these evidences, and cry out, " There is no God." They do not 
 know God. 
 
 Why do not acorns grow on pumpkin vines, and pumpkins 
 on oak trees, if everything happens by chance ? If things were 
 left to chance, and pumpkins grew on oak trees, it would be 
 dangerous to stand under them on a windy day, and have 
 pumpkins, weighing one hundred pounds each, tumbling down 
 and striking you on the head. And yet you say there is- no 
 God. 
 
 Would to God this infidelity were confined to those who 
 openly profess infidelity ; but, alas ! there is too much of it to 
 be found in the church among the professed children of God. 
 When God is chastising us for our rebellious spirit, and for our 
 waywardness, and is laying on the rod more or less severely, 
 as the case may be, how many are all the time ascribing their 
 afflictions to chance and luck ! They say, " It so happened," 
 " It was their luck," and act as though their owner was not 
 chastising them, but all their misfortunes were the result of
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 255 
 
 blind chance. They do not know God. They do not see or 
 recognize the hand of God which is dealing with them, and 
 laboring to bring them to terms of submission to his will. 
 Hence we see that God may well complain, and say, " Israel 
 doth not know ; my people doth not consider. Ah, sinful 
 nation." I knew, in my experience, a deacon of a Christian 
 church who had a dairy of ninety-nine cows, and who wanted 
 to have the round number of one hundred cows. He had a 
 poor neighbor who had but one cow in the world with which to 
 supply the wants of a large family of children with milk and 
 butter, and this wealthy deacon, in order to secure a debt which 
 the poor man owed him, took his only cow. Well, all through 
 the summer he complained of having very bad luck. His butter 
 would not come, skippers got into his cheese, and the murrain 
 broke out amongst his cows. He did not know God ; " it so 
 happened " that he had very bad luck. He probably lost a 
 hundred times more than the amount of the debt his poor 
 neighbor owed him. God was chastising him in this way ; he 
 was laying his rod upon him, but he did not know God did it. 
 
 And so when God chastises us, and lays his rod upon us ; 
 when we find sickness and death entering our families, and we 
 are compelled to sustain heavy losses in our fortunes ; when he 
 is thus dealing with us to make us wiser and better, how many 
 of us fail to see God, to hear his voice, and to recognize him in 
 all his dealings with us ! And hence God says, " Israel doth 
 not know ; my people doth not consider." There never was an 
 ox or ass so stupid as not to know when his master was chastis- 
 ing him. When Balaam arose and saddled his ass, and started 
 off to curse Israel, and the angel of God came a*nd stood in the 
 way, and the ass saw the angel and turned aside, and Balaam 
 smote him, the ass knew who smote him. He did not think 
 that he had had very bad luck and a most unfortunate trip. No ; 
 poor stupid man, who does not know his Owner, would have 
 reasoned thus ; but the ass knew from whom he received every 
 single stripe, and when God opened his mouth he rebuked the 
 mad jess of the prophet.
 
 256 SERMONS BY 
 
 There are many thousands who never understand that till 
 their stripes come from God, their rightful owner. Very often 
 God lays the rod of affliction upon a family who are irreligious, 
 and will not come to Jesus. No sermons, no prayers, no 
 tears, no tender expostulations can melt their hearts or subdue 
 their wills, and bring them to the feet of their dear Redeemer, 
 to know their owner, until God lays on the rod, works against 
 their worldly interests, and brings them low down in the dust. 
 Then they are moved to pray for grace from our Lord Jesus 
 Christ. I have labored in some towns where certain families 
 could not be reached ; and after years had rolled round I have 
 returned to find those very same families reduced from wealth 
 to poverty ; to find that they had suffered sickness, the loss of 
 friends, and distresses of every kind ; and that through the 
 special providence of God they were now ready to come to 
 Christ, and recognize him as their rightful owner. So God 
 chastises the children of men, but they do not know him, and 
 they stand out and revolt more and more. Squire S., a splendid 
 man and able lawyer, in Athens, Cherry Valley, N. Y., said, 
 " I would never submit my heart to God. I never knew my 
 Creator until God entered my family and took my two little 
 boys. lie called them away ; and when they were laid side by 
 side in the grave, I was completely broken down and subdued. 
 I went to my room and bowed down on my knees, and called 
 on God for mercy ; and God, for Christ's sake, forgave my 
 sins." So God chastises the children of men in order to bring 
 them to submission to his will, and to make them know their 
 owner. 
 
 2. But we itmark again, they do not know enough to come 
 at the bidding of their owner, and yet the ox does. You go 
 out to yoke a pair of oxen, and you find them lying down, 
 chewing the cud. Go inside the yard, and speak to them, and 
 they will rise up and bow their necks to receive the yoke. 
 They know you are about to yoke them, but they do not lie 
 still and refuse to rise, and say, " If you want to yoke us come 
 here ; " or, " We do not want to work to-day ; " or, " We fear
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP 257 
 
 that if we bow our necks to the yoke we may change our minds, 
 and run off and break up the team." They do not stand out, 
 and cavil and parley, like many sinners, but they obey the 
 command of their owner, and bow their necks to the yoke in 
 submission. But God comes and calls for sinners, and he says, 
 u Come unto me, all ye that labor and are heavy-laden, and I 
 will give you rest. Take my yoke upon you, and learn of me ; for 
 I am meek and lowly of heart, and ye shall find rest unto your 
 souls." But sinners will not come. They say " We dare not 
 promise ; we dare not resolve ; we fear we shall not hold out : 
 if God wants to convert us, why cannot he convert us as we 
 are? why must we go to him?" Thus they stand out, and 
 .cavil and parley ; and God may well say, " Israel doth not 
 know ; my people doth not consider." 
 
 I remember that on one occasion in Jefferson County, in this 
 State, a Uuiversalist, named R., came six miles to hear me preach. 
 He had not heard a sermon for ten years ; but having received 
 strange reports about thfe speaker, he was moved by curiosity to 
 see what kind of a being I was. Before he came to the meeting 
 being a man of bad temper, and having no grace to control 
 his temper he had beaten one of his oxen most unmercifully ; 
 the ridges stood out over its whole body, and it was scarcely 
 able to stand on its feet ; and as God would have it, I preached 
 from this very text that day. I spoke of God's goodness ; 
 what a kind owner he was ; that he never gave an unneces- 
 sary blow, and yet men rebelled against him ; while the ox 
 very often had a bad master, who beat him unmercifully, 
 yet the creature would obey his owner, and do just as he bid 
 him. The man became very uneasy, and thought that some 
 one had told me about his beating the ox. He said to himself, 
 " If I could find him out, I would cowskiu him." Soon after, 
 he said, he resolved to cowskin me for dragging him out and 
 exposing him before so many people. He thought of leaving 
 the house, but said, " If I go they will all look at me, and 
 know that Kuapp means me ; " so he kept his seat, and sweat it 
 out. After the sermon he went home, and said, " Wife, I
 
 258 SERMONS BY 
 
 have not heard a sermon before for ten years, and I got preach- 
 ing enough to-day to last me another ten years." He retired, 
 but could not sleep ; he could not help thinking what a kind 
 owner God was, and that he had never served him, had never 
 loved him, had never done a single thing to please him ; while 
 he had been cruel and unkind to his oxen, and yet they had 
 served him and obeyed him in all respects. In the morning he 
 went out to yoke his oxen, and it so happened that it was the 
 near one which he had beaten so badly the day before ; and as 
 he approached them, holding the bow in one hand and the yoke 
 in the other, and called to them, the near one rose up and came 
 to him, and bowed its neck to the yoke. At this evidence of 
 submission to his will, the man, remembering the sermon he 
 had heard, dropped the yoke, started back, and cried, " O God ! 
 thou hast ever been a kind owner, and a merciful God to me, 
 and I have never obeyed thee in the first thing ; this ox has 
 had a cruel and hard master in me, and yet he will do every- 
 thing I tell him. God have pity upon me." He was so over- 
 come by his feelings that he could do no work, and he went 
 into the house, and said, " Wife, if you have a mind to go to 
 church again, I will go down with you ; " and they cauie and 
 reached there at the commencement of the nine o'clock meeting. 
 When he rose up to state these facts, and ask for our prayers, 
 he fell his whole length on the carpet, and was converted to 
 God before he left the house. Now see what a powerful 
 preacher the ox is ! The stupid, lowly ox evinces more sagacity 
 and more submission to the will of his owner than man in his 
 sphere, and hence God sends us to learn wisdom of the ox. A 
 strange pass we have come to, when we must be sent to school 
 to the ox and ass to learn wisdom ; and yet God sends us to 
 this school, and to this school we must go. 
 
 3. Then we observe again, that the ox knows that his owner 
 has a yoke for his neck, and yet men do not know that God has 
 a yoke for their necks, as Avell as a crown for their heads ; and 
 that if they will not wear the former, they never can the latter. 
 If you ask me, " How do you know the ox has so much
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 259 
 
 discernment?" I answer, approach an ox with a yoke on your 
 shoulder, and frequently he will rise up to receive it. He knows 
 it is for his neck. How many of the human family there are 
 who never seem to understand that God has a yoke for their 
 necks, who are not willing to be bound, or to make any sacred 
 and solemn vows to their owner, but who only care to study 
 their own pleasure, and to have their own will and way, rather 
 than be united with people who love God, and who have given 
 a solemn pledge to serve him all the days of their life ! And 
 hence it is that God says, " The ox knoweth his owner, and 
 the ass his master's crib : but Israel doth not know ; my people 
 doth not consider." 
 
 4. We may observe again, the ox knows for what the yoke 
 is designed ; that it is designed to capacitate him for hard ser- 
 vice ; and that he understands this, is cei'tain from the fact that 
 when you lay the yoke on his neck he will frequently begin to 
 loll. This is the result of an association of ideas. An ox will 
 loll when he is doing very hard service in the heat of the sun, 
 and when the yoke touches his neck he associates it with hard 
 service, and the sensation is for the moment produced ; and yet 
 how many are there in the church who, when they unite them- 
 selves with the church, do not understand that it is to qualify 
 them for hard service in the cause of religion that God is 
 putting his yoke upon them ! They only come out and profess 
 religion in order to secure peace of mind, to quiet conscience 
 while they live in pleasure, knowing that they will have some- 
 body to help them to the kingdom of Jesus. What would you 
 think of an ox who reasoned thus : " I will bow my neck to the 
 yoke, and if I get too lazy to do my share of the work, the 
 other ox can draw me along too ; " thus consulting his own in- 
 dolence and interest, instead of the interests of his owner? The 
 truth is, my beloved friends, God has called us away from the 
 affairs of this world unto the kingdom of his dear Son, that we 
 may work for him, that we may be workers together with him, 
 not co-workers, for that implies partnership in the stock. God 
 says, " Go thou into my vineyard, a ud work to-day." Suppose
 
 260 SERMONS BY 
 
 an ox, after you had yoked him, in order to capacitate him for 
 work, should lie down in the sun, or range around the green 
 pasture and enjoy himself? you would knock such an ox in 
 the head ; but the ox understands that the yoke is intended to 
 capacitate him for hard service, and he bows to it, and obeys 
 the commands of his owner. And we ought to understand, 
 when we identify ourselves with the church of the living God, 
 that it is to qualify us to work for the kingdom of the Lord 
 Jesus Christ, that we may be laborers together with him, and 
 go forth everywhere, doing good and striving to win souls to 
 the dear Redeemer. It is good for a man that he wear the 
 yoke, and that he wear it in his youth. 
 
 5. But, again, the ox seems to understand that the yoke is 
 so constructed as to divide the burden according to the strength 
 of the team. For instance, if the oxen be of equal strength, 
 the point of draft comes in the centre of the yoke ; but if one 
 of the oxen be stronger than the other, the staple is removed 
 nearer one end than the other, so that the strongest ox shall 
 have more than half of the burden to bear. And when the yoke 
 is laid upon their necks, and they are ready for work, they do 
 not, when commanded to move forward, shriuk back, and one 
 or the other find fault because he has the heaviest share of the 
 burden to bear, or complain that the load is unequally divided, 
 or slip his neck out of the yoke ; but he settles down to his 
 work, and moves forward. 
 
 Now understand that Jesus Christ has constructed his yoke 
 on the same principle. No one is required to do more than he 
 or she is able to do. In reference to moral influence, every one 
 is required to love the Lord his God with ail his heart, and with 
 all his mind, and with all his soul, and with all his strength. 
 Now God never commanded that little boy there to love him 
 with all the mind, the heart, the soul, and the strength of an ex- 
 perienced and disciplined Christian. He could not do it if God 
 demanded it of him. He may be able to do it by and by, but 
 he cannot do it now. So God requires every one to love him 
 with all the heart he has.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 201 
 
 And, in like manner, we are required to give, so far as our 
 fortunes are concerned, according to our several ability. Each 
 is required to give according to what he hath, not according to 
 what he hath not ; but every one should give something, and 
 should do something, to sustain religious worship, and to extend 
 the kingdom of our dear Redeemer throughout the world. 
 Where God has given a great deal, he expects more than where 
 he has given but little ; but he requires something from us all ; 
 and we should settle in his yoke, which is lined with love, and 
 galls no man's neck, and work with all our strength for the 
 honor and glory of our divine Owner. We should not shrink 
 back, and complain that the burden is greater than we can bear. 
 O, think of the burdens Jesus bore for us ! And is it not enough 
 for the servant that he be as his master, and for the disciple that 
 he be as his Lord? 
 
 6. It may be observed still further, that men do not seem to 
 know that their owner will not overload them ; yet the ox duly 
 considers this. When a man drives a team of oxen up to a 
 pile of stones, or boxes, or barrels, or anything which he wishes 
 to remove from one place to another, he considers the strength of 
 the oxen, and he puts the burden on according to their strength ; 
 he also takes into consideration the state of the road, and every 
 advantage or disadvantage which they will have to encounter. 
 When all things are in readiness, he gives the command, and 
 they move on and on. They do not look back at the load, and 
 say that is too great a load for any team to draw, and we are 
 not going to draw such a burden as that, and lie down and try 
 to get their necks out of the yoke, but they settle in the yoke, 
 and strive again and again and again, until, if it be within 
 their power, they move on. 
 
 But how unwilling His people are to draw ! How unwilling 
 they are to work for the conversion of the world ! How often 
 they shrink back, an 1 fail to draw the burden that God lays 
 upon them ! The Spirit of God may move upon your mind to 
 induce you to go to a certain family, and talk and pray with 
 them on the subject of religion They have no light on the
 
 2G2 SERMONS BY 
 
 subject, and are groping their way in midnight davkuess down 
 to the pit, and the tender Spirit of God is urging you to visit 
 that family, and talk, and pray with them ; but you say, " Lord, 
 I cannot do it. Lord, I am but a poor, weak brother ; and what 
 will they think if I go to them, and talk to them on the subject 
 of religion ? I pray thee have me excused. Let some one else 
 go, who is more worthy and capable than thy servant." They 
 refuse to go, and will not draw a single pound. Now I want 
 you to understand that whenever God moves you to go and pray 
 and plead with a sinner, that the Spirit is at the same time striv- 
 ing with that being. When the eunuch was riding along in his 
 chariot, the Spirit of God was striving with him, and bringing 
 the words of the prophet to bear upon his mind. The same 
 Spirit told Philip to go that way. He went, not knowing why ; 
 and when he came within sight of the chariot, the Spirit told 
 him to join himself to the chariot, and he did so ; and Philip 
 said, " Understandest thou what thou readest?" and he an- 
 swered, "How can I, unless some one teach me?" and Philip 
 got up into the chariot, and opened his mouth, and preached unto 
 him Jesus. The Spirit that moved Philip was at the same time 
 laboring with the eunuch, and striving to bring him into the king- 
 dom of God's dear Sou. I remember many striking incidents 
 of the kind in modern times. While I was preaching in Boston, 
 a brother felt himself impelled to visit one of his neighbors, and 
 converse with him on the subject of religion ; and his wife also 
 desired to go and converse with that neighbor's wife, although 
 they had not conferred together before. At length the brother 
 went to see his neighbor, and he found this man, who had been 
 very sceptical, under deep and pungent convictions. He greeted 
 him cordially, and told him that he was grateful that he had 
 come, for he had long desired to see him and converse with him 
 about the state of his soul. This brother also found his wife 
 there, conversing with his neighbor's wife, and the two were 
 speedily converted to God. 
 
 When the Spirit comes, and moves on your mind to go and 
 talk and pray with the sinner, go. Do not shrink back, and
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 263 
 
 say, " It is a greater load than I am capable of bearing." I 
 would have you understand, my beloved, that God has said, 
 " My grace shall be sufficient for you," and " As thy days are, so 
 shall thy strength be." We shall always find the truth of these 
 passages if we try the experiment. I cannot tell what God 
 would have done for me if I had always bowed my neck to his 
 yoke, and had never shrunk back, in one single instance, from 
 the time I was converted until now. Thirty-five or six years 
 ago a brother said to me, " How long do you expect to live, 
 brother Knapp?" "Well," said I, "I may live five or six 
 years." At that time I was preaching two or three times a 
 day ; preaching and praying night and day, and delivering fif- 
 teen or sixteen sermons a week, and it was wearing upon me. 
 I had not then -learned to husband my strength as I have since. 
 " Well," says he, " you will not live two years." Little did I 
 think that God would sustain me to preach on for thirty-five 
 or six years to come, day and night, and permit me to witness 
 what I have as the effects of his truth, through all the United 
 States of America. If any one had told me then what God Avas 
 about to accomplish by such an unworthy worm, I might have 
 said, " If the Lord should make windows in heaven, then these 
 things might be." 
 
 In order to let you see, that as our days are, so shall our 
 strength be, I will refer you to a striking incident, which came 
 under my own observation when I was pastor of a church iu, 
 Watertown, N. Y. Brother O. was one of my deacons, 
 a devout, conscientious, godly man, and his wife a pious woman. 
 His father had consecrated him by prayer to the work of foreign 
 missions. He was a printer by trade, and the Board of Foreign 
 Missions, about the time to which I refer, were in want of some 
 one to print the Bible in the Burmese language some one who 
 nad faith, and who would labor to do good wherever the provi- 
 dence of God should direct him ; and they called on Deacon O. 
 He then had but one child, a sweet little daughter eighteen, 
 mouths old ; and the question revolved itself in sister O.'s miud, 
 over and over again, " Can I leave this dear child, and never
 
 204 SERMONS RY 
 
 see it again until we meet at the judgment seat ? " for it was 
 understood that you could not bring up children in Burmah, as 
 the sin and corruption of the heathen might prove their ruin. 
 Finally, she said, " Send by whom thou wilt, only excuse me : 
 I cannot give up my babe ;" and they declined the appointment. 
 God came and took her child away by death speedily. A few- 
 years rolled around, and she embraced another daughter ; and 
 when this child had reached an age when it could be safely left 
 by its mother, a second call came from the Board of Foreign 
 Missions, and again the question arose, " Will you go and 
 preach the word to the heathen ? ". Sister O. looked at her babe, 
 whom she loved with all the love of a mother, but she answered 
 this time, " Lord, I will go. Thou hast said, My grace shall 
 be sufficient for thee. I will venture. Lord, I will go." 
 
 In the mean time I had removed my family to Oswego ; and 
 when they started for Boston, from which point they designed 
 sailing, they came by way of Oswego, and called on my wife in 
 my absence. Sister 0. told my wife, that as she gave the child 
 a last embrace, and imprinted on its lips a last kiss, she turned 
 her face towards the heathen world, and towards Jesus for the 
 fulfilment of his promise. God filled her soul with a joy un- 
 speakable. " Why," said she, to my wife, " I have enjoyed 
 more real happiness in sailing from Sackett's Harbor to Oswego, 
 than I ever enjoyed in my life before. God has filled my soul, 
 and I feel that I can rely upon his promise, ' As thy days are, 
 so shall thy strength be.' " 
 
 Sister B., when the companion of her youth was buried in a 
 foreign land, having toiled his life away, and when she was left 
 a lone widow, far away from relatives and friends, wrote that 
 she gathered consolation by repeating this passage : " No man 
 hath left father or mother, house or land, for my sake and 
 the gospel's, but he shall receive a hundred fold in this present 
 time, and in the world to come life everlasting." She said, 
 " Whether I have come up to that stipulation or not, I have 
 realized the fulfilment of the promise a hundred fold. I have 
 had more enjoyment in the heathen land, in the service of God,
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 265 
 
 than I ever bad in the world before." Yes, God means just 
 what be says ; and if you bow your neck to the yoke, he will 
 reward you a hundred fold here, and in the world to come give 
 you life everlasting. And " as thy days are, so shall thy 
 strength be." 
 
 7. It may be observed again, that we do not consider how 
 much we cost our Owner. The ox costs but little. He is fed 
 upon straw and provender, and soon comes to maturity, and a 
 very few dollars will purchase a good yoke of oxen ; but God 
 has raised us up as his children ; his holy angels have watched 
 over us ; he has clothed us, and fed us, and supplied our 
 wants ; his guardian care has been round about us day and 
 night. And then look at the price of our souls' redemption. 
 Nothing less than the life-blood of God's dear Son could save 
 the soul. Yet " Israel doth not know, my people doth not 
 consider," how much they cost their owner. 
 
 8. Then, again, they do not seem to consider that the strength 
 of every one is called for. No doubt many of you have seen a 
 number of oxen yoked together to draw a building or an un- 
 usually heavy load, and have observed the order and the steadi- 
 ness with which they have settled down to their work when the 
 word of command was given, and how they have all pulled 
 together until the burden moved. Now, when God requires us 
 all to take hold and work for him, how few there are who 
 settle with the yoke, or even straighten the chains. They want 
 somebody else to draw. The ox does not reason in this way : 
 " What little I can draw will make no difference ; I will stand 
 still and let the others, who are stronger and abler than I am, 
 do the work ; " but each ox knows, when the command is given, 
 what he is expected to do, and he does it. Now, suppose that 
 every member of this church, to say nothing about other Chris- 
 tians, had taken hold at the beginning of this meeting, and all 
 had done what they could for Jesus : had gone to see their 
 neighbors, and prayed with them ; had visited them in their 
 parlors, in their stores, and in their kitchens, and had made an 
 effort to win their souls to Christ, who knows what might not 
 
 19 

 
 266 SERMONS BY 
 
 have been accomplished by this time? Converts might r /ave 
 been made by hundreds. How few there are who do anyt mng 
 to help move on the ark of God. And God says, " Tl * ox 
 knoweth his owner, and the ass his master's crib : but J arael 
 doth not know ; my people doth not consider." 
 
 9. And then they do not know when their strength ij most 
 needed ; and yet the ox seems to know. Often, while trav lling, 
 I have noticed the husbandman with his team of oxen ; jnd I 
 have observed that when they came to the foot of a hi 1 they 
 would straighten themselves, and prepare to exert the ad Uional 
 strength that was necessary to draw the load up the hill. How 
 many church-members there are who will draw down liiLJ like 
 a yoke of unbroken steers ; who are always ready and milling 
 when there are no burdens to bear and no hardships to be 
 endured ; but when the times are dark and lowering, when 
 there are debts to pay, and it is evident there must be & great 
 struggle or else the church will languish or die, they fall off; 
 they absent themselves from church ; they have nothing to give, 
 no assistance to render : they will not draw a single pound. 
 
 Just so it is when there is any great reform to be accom- 
 plished, such as the temperance reform, or the abolition of 
 slavery, or the removal of any other blighting and sweeping 
 curse that may exist among the people. When all is dark, and 
 public opinion is on the wrong side, there will only be now and 
 then an individual who will come right out and face it, and 
 play the man for God. The mass of the church are cowed, and 
 quail before public opinion. They look only to their selfish 
 interests and reputation among men, instead of looking at 
 principle and working for God. I remember very well when 
 we formed the first temperance society in America We had 
 the opposition of deacons and church-members, as well as the 
 opposition of the masses of the wealthy, and thoso who were 
 indifferent to religion. We had to preach, and pray, and toil 
 on early and late, and struggle to get the load up the hill ; but 
 these same men were all ready to jump on when we had reached 
 the top, and all wished to share in the honor and the spoils of
 
 ELDER JACOB XNAPP. 267 
 
 the glorious victory we had achieved by divine assistance. 
 They were all willing to ride down the hill, but they were not 
 so willing to help us to draw up the hill. It was so with the 
 cause of Abolition. I remember very well when even here in 
 the Northern States the mass of the people were apologists for 
 slavery. The minister could not lift up his voice against this 
 great and crying sin of the nation without being met with 
 scowls from scores, and sometimes hundreds, of the church- 
 members. Their politics would be touched, and they would 
 hold back, and would not draw a single pound. We had to 
 struggle and toil on and on until we had got the load to the top 
 of the hill, and then they jumped on. Then all were abolition- 
 ists, and had always been abolitionists, and if it had not been 
 for us radicals, they would have succeeded in abolishing slavery 
 long ago ! Poor souls ! the Lord pity you ! The devil knows 
 better than that. The fact is, if it had not been for those who 
 were more earnest than these conservatives, the end would 
 never have been reached. But come on ; better late than never ; 
 and give all glory to God who has achieved the victory. 
 
 Elder Leland, who used to hunt foxes and deer over the 
 mountains of Massachusetts, used to say, that on the start, when 
 the hunter set out with his hounds, nothing could be heard but 
 the sound of the hounds baying over the mountain top, or ring- 
 ing through the valley ; but when they caught sight of the 
 game, every little whiffet set up a yell, and the voice of the 
 hounds was drowned by their noise. This is true of reformers. 
 A good brother in Pennsylvania, now in heaven, had been a 
 faithful and thorough-going anti-slavery man for years, but 
 when the war broke out, and converts to anti-slavery principles 
 were multiplied, he seemed to grow silent, and have nothing to 
 say. A friend asked him, " Why, brother Aaron, how is it 
 you are so still now, when you have all along been such an 
 ardent advocate of the abolition of slavery ? " and he replied, 
 " I cannot be heard for the noise of the converts !" Let them 
 come. 
 
 It is well for us to understand where our strength is most
 
 268 SERMONS BY 
 
 needed ; and when we see any reform, which should be brought 
 about for the good of the world, we should settle in the yoke, 
 and help to pull at the foot of the hill. Well, we are now 
 struggling at the foot of the -hill with the word of God. We 
 are laboring for the salvation of tens and hundreds of souls, and 
 I would to God that before next spring hundreds of thousands 
 might be converted in the city of New York ; but only a small 
 band is engaged in this struggle. There are very few who are 
 willing to make the required sacrifices, and settle in the yoke, 
 and exert all the strength which God has vouchsafed to them, 
 in order to win souls to Christ, and carry the work to perfection. 
 
 10. But, again, it may be observed that the ox knows enough 
 to draw in the dark ; and yet many Christians will not draw a 
 single pound in the dark. As long as they see their way clear, 
 and feel like it, they go along very well ; but as soon as a 
 cloud comes over their minds, they stand as still as a stone. 
 They will not draw in the dark, but the ox will ; and if night 
 overtakes him before his owner has reached his destination 
 with the load he is drawing, the ox will draw as well as if it 
 was day. So we, as Christians, ought to work for God, trust- 
 ing in him, and moving right on in the performance of every 
 Christian duty. 
 
 11. So, again, it maybe remarked the ox knows were to find 
 water. You turn an ox or an ass into a hundred-acre field, and 
 if there be water in that field he will not suffer from thirst long. 
 They are sure to find it. They will not perish under the heat, 
 of a summer's sun while there is water in the enclosure. But 
 how many men there are who, though God has opened a great 
 Fountain for Judea and Jerusalem, and hath said, " If any man 
 thirst, let him come unto me and drink ; " and though the water 
 is as free as the air, yet wander about, and cannot find this liv- 
 ing stream ! There are sinners who are thirsting and inquiring 
 for the water of salvation in this congregation to-day, who act 
 as though they could not find it. They go around in the dark 
 hours of the night, in their secret chamber ; they come to the 
 meetings, and converse with one and another ; but after all that
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 269 
 
 is said and done, they fail to find this Fountain of living waters ; 
 they fail to slake their thirst, and cure the fever of the mind. 
 
 The ox, if you cut a hole in the ice, will almost tumble in, if 
 it is necessary, to reach the water ; and he will reach it and 
 slake his thirst, if it is possible, before he leave the place. The 
 difficulty with the sinner is, he is looking too high, and he 
 stumbles over the simplicity of the gospel of Jesus Christ, and 
 fails to be lowly enough to have his wants supplied. 
 
 The truth is, my friends, the difficulty lies in the want of 
 disposition on your part it is not a want of sagacity. You 
 certainly know as much as the ox or the ass, but your heart is 
 in opposition to God and to religion, and you are unwilling to 
 come to God's terms, and receive the waters of life. Here, 
 then, is the grand difficulty. You have seen swine break into 
 a garden, and if you try to drive them out, and set the dog ou 
 them, they will run round and round, and by the place they 
 came in, as though they could not see it ; but get them out 
 once, and the moment they want to come back they will make 
 a bee-line for the place. I have many a time taken a sinner, 
 and have shown him the way to God ; have resolved all his 
 doubts, and made the way as plain as the alphabet ; but when 
 I would bring him to the point, and, with God's help, try to 
 drive him through, he would pass by as quick as thought. 
 They do not wish to go to heaven. They do not wish to come 
 down to the feet of Jesus, and slake the thirst of their souls in 
 the waters of eternal life. 
 
 12. Then, again, we find that the ox knows enough to pray. 
 When he is in want, when he has been fasting all night, and 
 the manger or crib is empty, when the owner walks into the 
 yard in the morning all the live stock are up, and all begin to 
 pray : the ox begins to loo, the horse to whinny, and the sheep 
 to bleat ; they all pray, and pray in their own native language. 
 There is no restraint. The ass does not say, " If I only had as 
 smooth a voice as some animals I would pray to my owner, and 
 ask him for what I want ; but I have such a hoarse, uncouth 
 voice, that if I should pray I would frighten the sheep out of
 
 270 SERMONS BY 
 
 the yard." Each one has his own way of expressing his wants, 
 and cares not for the opinions of others. And their owner un- 
 derstands them, and supplies their wants. If the sinner would 
 lift up his voice, and cry, " Lord save me, or I perish ! " if the 
 backslider would cry unto the Lord, and every human soul 
 would cry aloud in sincerity, God would open the windows of 
 heaven, and pour out his blessings upon them. It is pride which 
 dooms millions of souls. They will not pray to God because 
 they fear man more than they fear their Creator. 
 
 13. Then, again, it maybe observed the ox and the ass know 
 their respective and appropriate places. The term rendered 
 "crib" here, means stall the place where he is cribbed, or the 
 stall where he belongs. Every good farmer will have a particu- 
 lar stall for each animal, and each animal soon comes to know 
 its place, and always occupies it. I remember more than thirty 
 years ago, when I was preaching in this city, that I was invited 
 to go out to Long Island, and lecture one evening in the village 
 of Newtown. I passed the night with a gentleman who kept 
 one hundred cows, and brought milk to the city. In order to 
 have the milk ready in season, the men brought the cows up to 
 the stable in the afternoon. I noticed that each cow knew its 
 particular stall, and went right along until it came to it, and 
 then turned into it. I looked on with amazement, and thought, 
 if I could find a church where all the members knew their 
 places, and kept them like these cows, I would like to be its 
 pastor. But, alas ! " the ox knoweth his owner, and the ass 
 his master's crib : but Israel doth not know ; my people doth 
 not consider." They get into the wrong stalls ; one member 
 gets into his neighbor's stall, and they commence hooking, 
 goring, and crowding one another. Very often a long-horned 
 deacon gets into the minister's stall, and commences goring 
 him ; others get into the deacons' stalls, and all is clashing and 
 confusion ; and God may well say, " The ox knoweth his 
 owner, and the ass his master's crib : but Israel doth not know ; 
 my people doth not consider." Alas ! some church-members 
 eeem to think that all the minister must do is simply to preach
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP 271 
 
 to please the people. He must have no voice in the business 
 of the church, no voice in its government, and no voice or 
 control in its affairs ; and that when he does not please the con- 
 gregation they may set him adrift. Now this is subversive of 
 the whole arrangement of the church of God. The minister is 
 his overseer. He is placed, in the providence of God, at the head 
 of the church, and he is to rule over its affairs with all the 
 influence that God's grace shall secure to him. The congrega- 
 tion ought to honor him, and rejoice, and feel blessed if their 
 leader is capable of leading them on from strength to strength, 
 and building them up in the faith of our Lord and Savior Jesus 
 Christ. But, alas, the confusion that follows their not knowing 
 their places, and keeping their places ! and this arises from the 
 depravity of poor fallen human nature. God may well say, 
 *' The ox knoweth his owner, and the ass his master's crib : 
 but Israel doth not know ; my people doth not consider." 
 May God add his blessing, for his Son's sake. Amen.
 
 272 SERMONS BY 
 
 II 
 
 ENTHUSIASM. 
 
 *' Thou art beside thyself; much learning doth make thee mad" 
 ACTS xxvi. 24. 
 
 I PROPOSE, on this occasion, I. To prove that all con- 
 sistent Bible Christians have, in all ages, been looked upon 
 by unbelievers and formalists as " beside " themselves, enthusi- 
 asts, or possessed of the devil. 
 
 Paul was speaking forth " the words of truth and soberness," 
 when Festus cried out, "Paul, thou art beside thyself; much 
 learning doth make thee mad." 
 
 On the day of Pentecost a similar charge was preferred 
 against the apostles. In fact they " were filled with the Spirit," 
 but they were accused of being " filled with new wine." 
 
 The Pharisees said, concerning Christ, that "he hath a 
 devil." 
 
 In like manner were the ancient prophets regarded ; and 
 from the days of the apostles to the present, men of earnest 
 conviction, undoubting faith, and fearless courage, have been 
 denounced, in their own generations, as madmen, fanatics, 
 and fools. 
 
 The reasons are obvious. To true Christians religion is a 
 living reality. Its truths are ever before them. They believe 
 all that God has said about heaven and hell ; all things else are 
 as trifles, compared with the solemn realities of eternity. They 
 regulate the affairs of time, its prospects and its pleasures, and 
 personal gratifications, according to the demands of this profound 
 conviction. With them time, talents, honors, pleasures, money,
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 273 
 
 life itself, are nothing in comparison with the worth of the soul, 
 or with the sufferings of Christ in dying to save it. 
 
 The dead formalist, the careless unbeliever, behold their 
 enthusiasm with feelings of contempt. They see no occasion 
 for it, and account for it on the theory of mental delusion, or, 
 perchance, of hypocritical pretension. Alas ! their vision is dim. 
 The god of this world hath blinded their minds, so that " having 
 eyes they see not." They do not realize any necessity for strong 
 feelings, for zeal and energy in prosecuting the cause of salvation, 
 and so they cry out, "Animal excitement I " "Enthusiasm!" 
 
 The different views which these two classes take of this sub- 
 ject may be illustrated by the following circumstance : A 
 clergyman, riding along in the northern part of the State of 
 New York, saw a woman coming out of her house in great 
 haste, and screaming, with the air and tone of the wildest ex- 
 citement, " Help, help ! " Rushing on to the bank of a river, 
 she leaped into the stream, and sank out of sight. The minister 
 put spurs to his horse, and hastened to the spot, thinking that 
 she was surely insane ; but as he reached the bank, he beheld 
 the woman rising to the surface, and grasping the form of her 
 little boy, who had fallen into the water a few minutes before. 
 At once the clergyman changed his mind. Instead of regarding 
 her as mad, he lookt , upon her as very rational and heroic, 
 and considered her exr'temont as a fitting expression of a just 
 estimate of the importance of the occasion. Just so formal- 
 ists, hypocrites, and worldlings. They do not aj^reciate the 
 great motive-power by which the spiritually living Christian is 
 prompted. " He *hat is spiritual judgeth all things, but he 
 himself is judged of no man." Hence the "carnal" think of 
 the "spiritual" that their ze'l, their earnestness, their haste, 
 their sacrifices for the salvatioa of souls, is a sort of madness, 
 tin uncalled-for excitement. 
 
 What could an unbelieving world have thought of Noah, 
 who was spending a fortune, toiling night and day, in building 
 an ark for the salvation of himself and his family, in the day 
 when floods should overwhelm the earth? His neighbors had
 
 274 SERMONS BY 
 
 no faith in the testimony of God concerning the threatened vis- 
 itation. Suppose a traveller coming along where the ark wag 
 being constructed, at a time when it was nearly completed ; 
 pulling up at the inn, he asks the keeper, " What is that great 
 structure I saw up the road ? It is so huge that no team can 
 draw it, and no water can float it?" 
 
 Innkeeper. " Why, that is an ark." 
 
 Traveller. " An ark ? What is that for ? " 
 
 Innkeeper. " Well, an old man, by the name of iNoah, in 
 this neighborhood, has a notion in his head that the great God 
 is going to drown the world, and he is building this ark for the 
 preservation of his family and a pair of every kind of animal." 
 
 Traveller. " Is this man a fool, or is he crazy, or a hypo- 
 crite?" 
 
 Innkeeper. "Well, there are different opinions about him. 
 Some think him crazy ; others say he is a downright hypocrite, 
 desirous of making a stir in the world. Others surmise that he 
 has some great speculation in view ; but most people give him 
 the credit of being sincere, but laboring under a delusion. He 
 certainly warns the people of the approaching flood, sometimes 
 with tears ; and I know that he has expended a fortune in the 
 enterprise, and is up early and late." 
 
 The people in the day of Paul doubtless talked about him in 
 the same way. We can imagine how some of his old associates 
 spoke of him. One said, " I really thought that Paul would 
 amount to something." Another remarked, " He might have 
 been somebody if he had not got excited about these miserable 
 followers of the Nazarene." " Yes," said another, " he might 
 have occupied a high place among both the Jews and the Ro- 
 mans, and commanded a high salary, and been one of the first 
 men of his age, but he has completely thrown himself away by 
 joining this illiterate set of fishermen. He has made a fool of 
 himself." But how little did they know of the weighty con- 
 siderations and mighty power that were actuating him ! How 
 little they realized the unseen influences that were inspiring the 
 apostle Paul to count all things as loss and dross for the excel-
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 275 
 
 leucy of the knowledge of Christ Jesus the Lord ! And how 
 little do they, who are enveloped iu the atmosphere of worldly 
 honors, ease, and emolument, know the motives by which those 
 are actuated who lay their all on God's altar ! " We are to look 
 not on the things that are seen, but on the things which are not 
 seen ; for the things which are seen are temporal, but the things 
 which are not seen are eternal." 
 
 Before we proceed further, it must be understood that souls 
 are saved by a faithful use of the means which God has ap- 
 pointed to that end, and lost for the want of such a use of the 
 means ; just as our natural lives are maintained by a timely 
 attention to the means of self-preservation, and are lost for the 
 lack of that attention. Parents have no more reason to expect 
 that their children will be saved, if the means which God has 
 appointed to that end are neglected, than they have a right to 
 suppose that they will be fed, and clothed, and educated, unless 
 the means appropriate and necessary to these results are duly 
 observed. 
 
 Now it is easy to see in which matter we ought to feel the 
 greater concern, and by which consideration we ought to be 
 the more excited. The necessities of the soul are as much 
 greater than those of the body as eternity is longer than time, 
 or as the soul itself is of more value than the body. 
 
 II. But let us define Enthusiasm. I use the term in its most 
 popular acceptation. In this sense it stands opposed to the idea 
 of consistency or propriety.. An enthusiast is one who exhibits 
 more interest in a subject than its importance demands ; whereas 
 a sober-minded man is supposed to display no greater interest 
 in a subject than is in proportion to the value of the end in view. 
 To illustrate : Suppose, as you are riding along on horseback, 
 a woman comes rushing out of her house, and with the aspect 
 of horror and agdby, and in tones of piteous anxiety she calls 
 on you for help, immediate help. Her boy has fallen into the 
 well and will drown. You leap from your horse and hasten 
 to the rescue. All right. You pass on, and befgre long an- 
 other woman comes rushing out of her house in the same plight,
 
 276 SERMONS BY 
 
 crying, " Help ! help ! " You ask yourself, " What in the 
 world is the matter now?" You put spurs and whip to the 
 horse, and riding up to the gate, spring from your horse, and 
 inquire the cause of this great alarm, and she explains, " Why, 
 sir, I came to draw water, and dropped my pitcher, and broke 
 it all to pieces ! " You feel provoked enough to apply the whip 
 to her. And why so ? Because iu this case the woman was au 
 enthusiast, and in the other case the woman acted consistently ; 
 and yet they both, in deportment, acted alike. In the one case, 
 however, the occasion demanded or justified the excitement ; 
 in the other, it did not. 
 
 Now let us contrast the interest which men feel in the sacri- 
 fices which they put forth to save souls, with the interest which 
 they manifest, and the efforts which they make, to secure 
 worldly ends. 
 
 1. Notice the efforts of men to accumulate wealth. They 
 rise early, sit up late, toil hard, encounter all ihe perils of the 
 deep, expose themselves to all the miasmas and epidemics of 
 every clime. They will leave home and loved ones, and rush 
 on to California, or into the wilderness of "the oil regions ; ex- 
 pend millions of money as an experiment, in the hope of obtain- 
 ing more, and often sink all they have ; and yet all these won- 
 derful expressions of anxiety excite no complaints on their part, 
 because they see an object in view. 
 
 But let ministers and Christians open their eyes upon the 
 condition of millions of human souls ready to perish, liable 
 every moment to come short of that " rest which remains for 
 the people of God ; " to fail of durable riches and righteousness ; 
 let them see them standing " on slippery places, while fiery 
 billows roll below," and feel and act accordingly ; let them 
 " cry aloud and spare not ; " lift up their voice like Paul, or 
 Luther, or Whitefield ; lay their money upon God's altar, and 
 be in earnest to save souls, and the cry is heard, "Thou art 
 be' ide thyself : much learning, or much religion, doth make 
 thee mad ! " The cry of " Animal feeling," " Enthusiasm," 
 resounds through the air.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 277 
 
 2. Notice tl.3 interest manifested in politics. Our country 
 is divided into two standing political parties, and sometimes a 
 third party comes up. Each party has its regular sets of 
 candidates for office, and each is over-anxious to succeed, and, 
 as election draws near the anxiety increases ; and yet, as a 
 matter of fact, there may be little or no choice in the candidates. 
 Both may be good men, or more likely neither of them fit for 
 the statiop. But the whole country is moved : a mighty 
 moral earthquake convulses the whole land. Men, women, and 
 children are all excited, from the shores of the Atlantic to the 
 shores of the Pacific. Millions of money are paid out to publish 
 and disseminate partisan documents. Hundreds of thousands 
 of dollars are staked on the results of the election. Log-cabins 
 and liberty-poles are erected, and flags are flung to every breeze. 
 Farmers, mechanics, merchants, doctors, lawyers, and some- 
 times ministers, all join in one universal chorus. And when 
 the contest is ended, and one party has come out victorious, a 
 mighty shout is heard throughout the whole United States of 
 America ; the telegraph wires are all electrified ; balls and 
 parties are multiplied, and the booming cannon roars along 
 through the valleys, and comes thundering over all the moun- 
 tains. Millions more of money are expended in parades and 
 festivals ; but all this is well in the eyes of the world. Formal- 
 ists, hypocrites, and worldlings have nothing to say against ex- 
 citement or animal feeling. 
 
 But let there be a contest between the friends and the enemies 
 of Jesus about the coming of Jesus into every heart, and through 
 all the world, and the dethroning of Satan ; and let them mani- 
 fest half the zeal, expend half the money, make half the sacri- 
 fices, to accomplish this end, and all these unbelievers will cry 
 out, " Enthusiasm ! " " Wild-fire I " "Animal feeling I " " Thou 
 art beside thyself: much religion doth make thee mad." 
 
 3. Notice the interest excited on account of bodily sickness. 
 Let any member of the family be taken sick. How soon the doc- 
 tor is called ! The messenger is sent in post haste, by day or by 
 night, and at any or all hours. No one talks about late hours,
 
 278 SERMONS BY 
 
 or of being disturbed of their rest. The wife or mother bends 
 over the sick bed for days and weeks together ; scarcely lays 
 aside her garments for months ; and if the loved one is taken 
 away, all the family are bathed in tears ; the neighbors all 
 come in to weep with them, and on the funeral occasion all the 
 congregation are proud to weep. But if we see the great mass 
 of sinners on the brink of ruin, dying the death that never dies, 
 and cast our eyes towards Calvary and see Jesus bleeding, 
 extending his arms towards them, and hear him saying, " Look 
 unto me, all ye en.ds of the earth, and be ye saved," and ex- 
 claim, with good old Jeremiah, " O, that my head were waters, 
 and mine eyes a fountain of tears, that I might weep day and 
 night, for the slain of the daughter of my people," the whole 
 infidel world chimes in with those who " are at ease in Zion," 
 crying out, " Animal feeling I " "Excitement ! " " Thou art lie- 
 side thyself" 
 
 4. Look at the money expended, and the interest taken upon 
 the subject of education. Think of all the schools of every kind, 
 from the infant school up to the college : district, private, family 
 schools, academies, seminaries, all in full blast the year round, 
 and the mass of the rising generation spending from twelve to 
 twenty years in attaining mental culture. Many study half of 
 the night, and some all of it, and in many instances break 
 down their healths, and come to a premature grave. But no 
 Universalist, no Unitarian, no infidel, no formalist, complains 
 of all this expense of time, money, health, and life. All think 
 they see an end to justify it. But when a school is opened in 
 which to educate men for heaven, and lectures, prayers, ex- 
 postulations, and appeals are multiplied, and the servants of 
 God become more and more earnest in the matter, the worldling, 
 the formalist, the infidel, and the devil, all cry out, " Thou art 
 beside thyself: much religion doth make thee mad." 
 
 5. Let a fire break out in a city. The bells are rung, the 
 engines rattle and thunder along the streets, and the cry of 
 Fire ! Fire ! Fire ! is shouted from street to street. Men, women, 
 and children turn out at a late hour of the night, and rush to
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 279 
 
 the scene. And what, after all, is the matter? An old black- 
 smith shop is on fire ! And yet no one goes round picking up 
 the evils of this general turn out, complaining of being out at a 
 late hour in the night, and that such a one got run over and 
 badly injured, and such a one got wet through and through by 
 the carelessness of the firemen, and another lost' his life in the 
 burning building. 
 
 But when God's watchmen discover that the fire of God's 
 wrath is kindled, and that it burns to the lowest hell, and call 
 on all " to flee from the wrath to come," to. turn to the strong- 
 hold until his indignation be over, they are charged with 
 enthusiasm ; with being unduly excited. 
 
 Suppose a man is sinking a well. After getting forty feet 
 below the surface of the ground the sides cave in, and he is 
 buried beneath the fallen earth ; but, by means of some timbers, 
 air enough reaches him to keep the breath of life in him for a 
 time, and by putting your ear at the mouth of the cave you can 
 just faintly hear him cry, " Help ! Save ! For God's sake, 
 save ! " But while some hasten on with spades and shovels, 
 some throwing the dirt one way and some another, all working 
 on without regard to rules of propriety in the handling of their 
 shovels, suppose a set of lookers-on should gather around, stand 
 aloof, and find fault, saying, " This man throws his dirt very 
 carelessly ; that man ought not to take off his coat, he will get 
 cold ; it is now after nine o'clock, and they ought to go home ; 
 ' too much excitement ; ' " what would you think of these cool- 
 blooded croakers? If the man buried alive was your son, 
 brother, or husband, you would denounce them as heartless, 
 inhuman, murderous wretches. 
 
 6. Let our country be invaded, our liberties threatened, and 
 our government in danger of being overthrown. See, then, 
 what an excitement ! As in the case of the Revolutionary 
 struggle, or as during the recent Rebellion. In such events, 
 our husbands, brothers, and sons turn out by the million. Our' 
 treasures are poui-ed out like water, and our blood flows like 
 rivers. No sacrifices are too great to make, no suffering too
 
 280 SERMONS BY 
 
 intolerable to be endured. All this is patriotism ! But when 
 we proclaim to the world that Satan has rebelled against the 
 government of God, and has involved this world in the conflict, 
 and that the struggle is now going on, and that infinite conse- 
 quences depend on the issue, even the eternal destiny of millions 
 for weal or for woe, and we bestir ourselves accordingly, call- 
 ing for men, for treasures, on all to pray, to labor, and to come 
 up to the " help of the Lord, the help of the Lord against the 
 mighty," the world thinks we are distracted, and cries out, 
 " Thou art beside thyself!" 
 
 III. We proceed to show that the deepest interest we can 
 feel, the greatest sacrifices we can make, and the most mighty 
 efforts we can put forth to glorify Christ, and to save souls, are 
 consistent and proper. 
 
 1. There is no caution in the word of God against feeling 
 too much, or giving too much, or doing too much. But, on the 
 other hand, God is, and always has been, urging his people to 
 bring " their tithes into the store-house ; " to " pray without 
 ceasing ; " to " seek first the kingdom of God, and his righteous- 
 ness ; " to go into his vineyard and work. Jeisus says, " jjfo 
 man hath left father or mother, brother or sister, husband or 
 wife, houses or lands, for my sake and the gospel's, but he shall 
 receive an hundred fold in this present time, and in the world 
 to come life everlasting." 
 
 2. Jesus always defends those who do and feel the most for 
 his cause, and rebukes those who complain of them. When the 
 woman came to anoint him against his burial, and broke the 
 box of precious ointment and poured it on his head, a heartless 
 Judas charged her of waste, of undue excitement. But the 
 Savior replied, " Let her alone. The poor ye have always with 
 you. and ye may do them good when ye will, but me ye have 
 not always ; " and adds, " Wherever this gospel is preached, 
 this shall be told as a memorial of her." A monument has 
 thus been erected to her memory more durable than any of the 
 monuments of Greece or Rome. The formalist, the unbeliever, 
 thinks all that is done to honor Christ, and to save souls, is a 
 perfect waste.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 281 
 
 When Jesus was riding on his way to Jerusalem, a holy 
 enthusiasm came over his d sciples, and the whole multitude of 
 them broke out, crying with loud voices, and began to rejoice 
 and praise God for all the mighty works which they had seen, 
 saying, " Blessed is he that cometh in the name of the Lord." 
 But some in the multitude said, " Master, rebuke thy disciples " 
 (those formalists thought them unduly excited) ; but Jesus 
 replied, " I tell you, if these should hold their peace, the stones 
 would cry out." 
 
 When the poor widow cast her two mites, even all her living, 
 into the treasury of the Lord, the formalist and the unbeliever 
 thought her enthusiastic and extravagant ; that it was her duty 
 to save it for sickness and old age. But Jesus defends and ap- 
 plauds her, and declares that she had cast in more than all the 
 rich, who of their abundance had cast into the treasury of the 
 Lord, for she had of her penury cast in all of her living. Here 
 is a monument erected to her memory. And whilst the for- 
 malist, the hypocrite, and the worldling complain of excite- 
 ment, and of undue anxiety on the subject of religion, Jesus 
 stands and weeps over Jerusalem, exclaiming, "O Jerusalem, 
 Jerusalem, how often would I have gathered your children to- 
 gather as a hen doth gather her chickens under her wings, and 
 ye would not." The big tears rolled down the manly cheeks 
 of the Son of God. His great soul was stirred to its depths by 
 the madness and folly of that city in turning their backs upon, 
 and rejecting their best friend, and their only Savior. 
 
 Paul felt his spirit stirred within him when he saw a city 
 " wholly given to idolatry." 
 
 Jeremiah cried out, " O, that my head were waters, and mine 
 eyes a fountain of tears, that I might weep day and night for 
 the slain of the daughter of my people." And again : " Rivers 
 of waters run down mine eyes because they keep not thy law." 
 
 God complains of these hypocrites in Zion because they 
 
 " eat the calves from the stall, and the lambs from the flock, and 
 
 drink wine from golden bowls, and stretch themselves upon 
 
 beds of ivory, and are not grieved fo the afflictions of Joseph." 
 
 20
 
 282 SERMONS BY 
 
 
 
 3. No one regrets, at the hour of death, that he had felt 
 too much, given too much, or done too much for Christ, or to 
 save souls. Such a regret was never felt by a sane man. It 
 never fell from human lips. It was never written in a book : 
 moreover it never will be. All the regrets are on the other 
 side. How many, on their death-bed, have expressed the 
 deepest regret that they had done no more for the honor of 
 Christ, and to benefit their race ; to reclaim this fallen world, 
 and to bring rebellious man back to God ! How many have 
 been burdened with the one desire to live their lives over again, 
 in order that they might correct their mistakes in these respects ; 
 devote themselves to the service of God with the zeal that fired 
 the hearts of prophets and apostles, and of the hosts of good men 
 who counted not their lives dear unto them ! 
 
 4. The consciences of wicked men justify the exercise of the 
 most intense interest on the subject of religion. During White- 
 field's absence in this country, a graceless bishop called on 
 Lady Huntington for the purpose of remonstrating with her 
 because of her enthusiasm. She had expressed her dissatisfac- 
 tion with his cool, heartless, and perfunctory performances, 
 and he hoped to dispel her prejudices, and reconcile her to the 
 proprieties of the service of the Church of England. Finding 
 his efforts to be vain, he began to upbraid himself for having 
 lain ordaining hands on the head of Whitefield. Lady Hun- 
 tington replied, " Reverend and dear sir, permit me to say, that 
 when you come to your death-bed, the remembrance of your part 
 in the ordination of Mr. Whitefield will be the occasion of your 
 least regrets." The prediction was fulfilled ; for when brought 
 to the bed of death he sent his servant to Whitefield to ask his 
 prayers for the dying bishop. 
 
 While I was in Boston, in the year 1842, laboring day and 
 night, and exerting every energy of body and mind" to save 
 souls, a Universalist came from Salem to hear me preach, and 
 remained for a few days in attendance on the meetings. He 
 went home and told his friends that " Knapp was the only 
 consistent ' hell-and-damnation ' preacher he knew of."
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 283 
 
 
 
 A Universalist minister in Auburn, N. Y., when I was labor- 
 ing there, said he " did not blame Mr. Knapp for his course ; 
 that if he believed as Mr. Kuapp does, he would leave his 
 family, and go forth preaching day and night, from place to 
 place, until his voice faltered in death." 
 
 Thousands of unconverted persons are amazed at the stoical 
 indifference of- professed Christians. They know that if religion 
 is anything it is everything. 
 
 5. Who can doubt but that the millions of the departed dead 
 look down with astonishment at the comparative indifference of 
 the Christian world concerning the subject of religion? The 
 waves of worldly cares, business, and pleasures of every kind, 
 are sweeping the teeming millions of earth into eternity. Soon 
 they are forgotten. Some look back from heaven, some from 
 hell ; and the latter mingle, with the wails of despair, the re- 
 proachful lamentation, " No man cared for our souls ! " and the 
 former are utterly amazed that they should have cared so little 
 about themselves or their fellow-men. From their point of 
 view the things of time and sense dwindle into utter insignifi- 
 cance, and the great things of eternity become all and in all. 
 
 O, ye slumbering saints ! ye formalists ! Rouse ye from your 
 lethargy. Brave the ridicule of the world. Be it your glory 
 that you bear this reproach : " Ye are beside yourselves in your 
 zeal for the glory of God and salvation of men."
 
 284 SEBMONS BY 
 
 III.* 
 
 THE CALLS OF THE GOSPEL. 
 
 "0 Jerusalem, Jerusalem, thou that killest the prophets, and 
 stonest them which are sent unto thee, liow often would I have 
 gathered thy children together, even as a hen gathereth her 
 chickens under her wings, and ye would not ! " MATT. 
 xxiii. 37. 
 
 4 
 
 WE should all bear in mind that Jesus Christ, so far as his 
 human nature is concerned, was the son of Abraham, 
 and was especially identified with the Hebrews. " He came 
 unto his own, but his own received him not ; but as many 
 as received him, to them gave he power to become the sons of 
 God." Beyond all question he felt a very warm attachment 
 to that people ; and who, I ask, that is at all familiar with the 
 Scriptures of the Old Testament, and with the history of the 
 Jews as a people, does not feel an overwhelming interest in their 
 condition and final destiny? 
 
 Jesus, on this occasion, was nearing Jerusalem, and from 
 Mount Olivet looked down upon the city, over which he had often 
 wept and prayed, and upon the ears of whose inhabitants he 
 had often poured forth volumes of burning and affectionate 
 truth. He saw their destiny. They were turning their backs 
 upon the Savior, their best friend ; they would have none of 
 him ; they were about to reject the gospel of Jesus Christ, the 
 true Redeemer. His omniscient eye ran along the track of the 
 future, and viewed their whole history, not only down the stream 
 of time, but their prospects beyond the narrow limits of time. 
 As he looked, the tears rolled down his cheeks, and he broke 
 
 * Preached in New York, November 26, 18G6.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 285 
 
 out, in the language of pur text, and said, " Jerusalem, 
 Jerusalem, thou that killest the prophets, and stonest them 
 which are sent unto thee, how often would I have gathered thy 
 children together, as a hen gathereth her chickens under her 
 wings, and ye would not." Now here we see that Jesus loved 
 the people. He bewailed their folly. He looked back upon 
 their, former history, and he saw that they had been killing the 
 prophets, and stoning those who were sent unto them ; for it 
 had been death to any man, in all ages, to receive a commission 
 from the great God, and carry that commission out with fidel- 
 ity and in the fear of God, regardless of what men might say 
 or think of them. Hence he says, "Thou that killest the 
 prophets, and stonest them which are sent unto thee, how often 
 would I have gathered thy children together, as a hen gathereth 
 her chickens under her wings, and ye would not. Behold, your 
 house is left unto you desolate." 
 
 We propose, this evening, to take up the care and kindness 
 of Jesus Christ for the souls of men, under the beautiful and 
 significant figure of the care and kindness of a hen for her 
 chickens. A more striking and forcible figure could not be 
 found in all the works of creation. It far surpasses and utterly 
 casts into the shade all the figures drawn from the stars or from 
 history, or from the arts and sciences. It is a living portrait, 
 or figure, to all who understand it, through all succeeding ages, 
 down to the end of time. 
 
 I. We remark, in the first place, that the hen hath a call that 
 we denominate a common call. By this she calls to her brood, 
 and clucks them along in her pathway, and by it she pre- 
 vents them from rambling away among the corn and standing 
 grass, and from being lost. Hence she repeats this call over 
 and over again, from morning until evening. Scarcely an hour 
 or a moment passes but that she repeats this common call 
 calling after her brood. Hence we denominate it the common 
 call, because it is repeated over and over and over, again and 
 again. And so Jesus has a call to the children of men, which 
 may be denominated the common call, " Unto you, O man, I 
 call, and my voice is unto the sons of men."
 
 286 SERMONS BY 
 
 This common call may embrace the voice of nature. The 
 stars are all calling upon the children of men. The sun, in all 
 its splendor and glory, answering the end of its creation, is call- 
 ing upon the human family to reflect that love which they are 
 capable of reflecting, with as much fidelity to God and man as 
 it reflects its natural light. 
 
 God speaks to the children of men by all these, the work- 
 manship of his hand, and continues to call, not only day after 
 day, but night after night. How beautifully the Psalmist speaks 
 of the voi<je of nature, when he says, " The heavens declare the 
 glory of God, and the firmament showeth his handy work. Day 
 unto day uttereth speech, and night unto night showeth knowl- 
 edge. There is no speech nor language where their voice is not 
 heard." Mark that. There is no people or tribe under the 
 whole heavens who cannot hear of the goodness of God as uttered 
 by the voice of nature. So that the heathen themselves are with- 
 out excuse. But for their blindness and depravity, their love 
 of sin and waywardness, and opposition to God and holiness, 
 they would hear the voice of God through all the works of 
 creation, and be constrained to bow down and worship him. 
 
 This common call is heard in everything which God has pre- 
 sented to our consideration as the workmanship of his hands. 
 His voice is heard in the roaring of the distant winds, and in the 
 stillness of the calm ; in the rumbling of the thunder, and in 
 the forked lightning ; in the rolling of the distant ocean, and 
 in the gentle murmur of the little rill that flows on down the 
 landscape ; All call upon the children of men to love and 
 serve God, the Author of their being, and to receive Jesus 
 Christ as their Savior. 
 
 This common call likewise embraces the word of God in this 
 Christian land. For God has given us his word to enlighten 
 our understanding, and direct our footsteps through this vale of 
 tears to the promised land. This may be included in the com- 
 mon call, because it is a common privilege to the entire human 
 family, so far as the gospel has yet been extended. Whether 
 you give heed to the voice of God, as it may be heard from 

 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 287 
 
 his word or not, that word is continually speaking. Awake or 
 or asleep, at home or abroad, the voice of the Lord is uttered 
 and reiterated again and again. God is calling calling unto 
 the children of men by his precious words, that they may live, 
 and not rush on down, and perish in eternal death. 
 
 But observe still further, that this common call likewise em- 
 braces the common means of grace; such as the stated ministry 
 of God's holy word, and such as the usual social meetings iu 
 which we worship the living and the true God, and by which 
 the children of men are invited to embrace Jesus Christ and 
 live. In fact, God has thrown open the doors of the sanctuary, 
 through all our cities and through all our country towns and 
 places ; and wherever human beings live, there the voice of God 
 this common call may 'be heard. This is true, not only upon 
 the Lord's day, but in many places on every single day and 
 night in the week. As if it were not enough that he should 
 call all day long upon the Sabbath, but Jesus, by his care and 
 kindness, would follow them up, and beckon or call after them, 
 and cluck them along, as it were, and keep them under his 
 wings, that they may not ramble away, and lose sight of their 
 only Friend and Protector, and perish forever, for want of the 
 grace and mercy he is willing to impart. He gives the children of 
 men repeated and continued opportunities of salvation. Just 
 think of the faithfulness of God in this respect ! I have thought 
 of it many a time. In ranging the world round and round, I have 
 never found a place where a faithful messenger has not gone 
 before me. Some man of God, some messenger of Jesus Christ, 
 has gone before me, and has lifted up his voice in Christ's stead 
 to the people, beseeching them to be reconciled to God. Mis- 
 sionaries of the cross have climbed the mountains, threaded the 
 valleys, and gone among the highest and the lowest, among the 
 rich and among the poor. Thus God is calling after the chil- 
 dren of men day after day, year in and year out. But, after 
 all, Jesus may say to you, " How often would I have gathered 
 thy children together, even as a hen gathereth her chickens 
 under her wings, and ye would not I "
 
 288 SERMONS BY 
 
 II. But the hen has another call, which we denominate the 
 the special call. It is only given when she has found some food 
 or drink which her brood needs, and invites them to participate 
 in the provision she has made for their wants. She then changes 
 her dialect, and speaks in another language. They all under- 
 stand the language, every one of them, before they are twenty- 
 four hours old, and they come running in from every direction, 
 in obedience to this special call, and receive the food to which 
 they are invited. They do not stand back and parley, as sin- 
 ners do, and say, " If you intend to feed me, old hen, why don't 
 you come here and feed me? " and " Isn't one place as good as 
 another?" and "I went two or three times, and did not get 
 anything. Some other one stepped in before me, and took it 
 all. You picked out all the speckled chickens and gave to them, 
 and won't give anything to me." But, satisfied with these cav- 
 ils, sinners starve to death or perish, as the result of their rash- 
 ness and imprudence ; chickens, however, come again and again, 
 and keep on coming until by and by they get something. 
 
 Now mark, that Jesus Christ has a special call, and this 
 special call may be regarded as embracing the special means of 
 grace ; for there are common means, and there are special means 
 of grace. Look at the parable of the marriage supper. The 
 king sent out his servants at supper-time to tell all that were 
 bidden to come, for all things were ready ; but they all, with 
 one consent, began to make excuse. And the servants reported 
 accordingly, and the question was asked, " What shall we do ? " 
 Shall we keep on uttering the old common call, the old appeal, 
 cling to the old course, persevering in the use of old measures ? 
 No. Let us change our measures. " Go out into the highways 
 and byways and compel them to come in, that my house may 
 be filled." 
 
 Some people tell us, in modern times, that they are opposed 
 to special means of grace ; opposed to protracted meetings, to 
 special efforts, to earnest, long-continued, persistent efforts to 
 rescue sinners from threatening danger, and bring them into the 
 liberty of the sons of God. But not so was Jesus. Not so
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 289 
 
 were any of his apostles. When one coprsc of measures 
 failed, they introduced another, and another still. When all 
 common or ordinary means failed to bring them into the mar- 
 riage supper of the Lamb, they went out into the highways 
 and hedges, that is, where a great many roads cross each 
 other, where there are masses of human beings gathered to- 
 gether. They were to go into these places, and compel them 
 to come in. 
 
 But you will understand that compulsion was not exercised 
 by the ruler of the feast, only by his agents whom he sent out. 
 It does not mean to compel them by physical force, but it means 
 to compel them by the strongest possible power of persuasion. 
 We are to compel, or constrain them, by all the motives drawn 
 from heaven, and by all the motives drawn from hell ; by all 
 the motives of our obligation to God and to his Son Jesus Christ ; 
 by all the motives drawn from the enduring compassion of the 
 blessed Son of God, who wept over Jerusalem, and said, " O, 
 Jerusalem, Jerusalem, thou that killest the prophets, and stonest 
 them which are sent unto thee, how often would I have gathered 
 thy children together, even as a hen gathereth her chickens under 
 her wings, and ye would not." We are to bring all these mo- 
 tives to bear upon the human family, and, if possible, compel 
 them, or constrain them, to come in. 
 
 You are to understand that these special means of grace were 
 all gotten up by Jesus Christ. You need not give this church or 
 its pastor the credit of getting up< these meetings. It was God 
 that moved upon them to get up these meetings. It was God, my 
 dear hearers, that influenced your unworthy speaker to come 
 some fifteen hundred miles in answer to your request, to aid you 
 in constraining sinners here in this city to come and feast their 
 souls upon hidden manna. The Lord Jesus Christ is employing 
 these means for the express purpose of inducing you to come 
 and feed upon his love, and receive the waters of eternal life 
 freely, without money and without price. We are told to " seek 
 the Lord while he may be found, and to call upon him while he 
 is near." When the hen utters this special call, she always has
 
 200 SERMONS BY 
 
 something right at hand for her brood ; and when God utters his 
 special call, and stirs up his saints to pray, and inspires his 
 ministers to preach with more point, with more power, with 
 more affection, with more cogency than usual, he is uttering the 
 special call, and that special call implies that the bread of heaven 
 is right here, at the door ; you have only to come and partake, 
 to eat that which is good, and let your soul delight itself 
 in fatness. 
 
 I want you to remember that ministers cannot always preach 
 as they do in times of revival. It would not be possible. 
 Perhaps they could not live and preach so all the time. If 
 Christians felt as they do in revivals, continuously, as some 
 argue that they should feel, they could not live. It would be 
 utterly impossible. I have known many a wife, under the 
 special influence of the Holy Spirit, to feel a special anxiety 
 for her husband, and many a mother to feel a special anxiety 
 for her children, that would keep her awake nights and days 
 together ; and had she lived in that state of mind for six months, 
 she would probably have sunk into an untimely grave. This 
 anxiety is a special solicitude, aroused by the Holy Spirit, for 
 the express purpose of reaching your souls, and bringing you 
 into the kingdom of God and of -his Son. Look at the sainted 
 sister Colgate Deacon William Colgate's wife. When I was 
 in Brooklyn, laboring night after night, she was there, linger- 
 ing until a late hour ; she came again and again, weeping, and 
 laying her interesting group of children on the altar, and solicit- 
 ing the prayers of the saints, until God came and brought 
 salvation to her house. She could not have lived very long 
 in that state of feeling. God was stirring up that mother to 
 utter the special call. And when, at the request of the father, 
 I went to see his eldest son, Robert, one morning, I had not 
 said three words to him before the tears started, and he said, 
 " I can endure anything else but the tears of my father, and the 
 prayers, of my mother." 
 
 I tell you, my beloved hearers, it is Jesus Christ that calls 
 to you, uttering his special call through father, or mother, or
 
 ELDER JACOB ENAPP. 291 
 
 brother, or sister, or child. Thus God stirs them up to utter 
 this special call, which is directly from God. While others 
 may deride their tears, and make light of their emotions, and 
 talk against excitement and animal feeling, they are but the 
 agents of the devil to shut the kingdom of heaven against men ; 
 and Jesus, inspired by all of these things, urges his people on 
 and on, by uttering the special call, and manifests the strength 
 and purity of his love for the souls of the children of men. 
 
 III. But then we pass to speak of another call, which we 
 denominate the call of alarm. The hen is all the time on the 
 lookout for danger. She is ever watching for the safety of her 
 brood. When a boy, I used to wonder why a hen could discover 
 a hawk, an eagle, a weasel, or a fox, so much quicker than I 
 could, and I solved the matter by coming to the conclusion that 
 she was all the time looking out for birds of prey, or for some 
 danger. When danger threatened, she changed her dialect, and 
 spoke in another language altogether, and sent out a call of 
 alarm, until every chicken had found a hiding-place somewhere. 
 And how amazed I have been in riding over the Western prai- 
 ries, when the cry of alarm was given by the prairie hen, to 
 notice that as quick as you could think, every single one was 
 hidden, add so hidden that it would be difficult to find them. 
 They understood the call of alarm, and availed themselves of 
 it, for the purpose of preserving themselves from danger and 
 death. 
 
 Ever since the fall of man, not only have every species of an- 
 imal in all God's world had their enemies, but the human family 
 have also had their enemies. God has furnished the whole of them 
 with some means of self-defence. Some depend upon the supple- 
 ness of their limbs to bear them away beyond the reach of their 
 pursuers. Others use their wings to fly from their enemies, and 
 thus escape the ravages of their pursuers, who are hard upon 
 their track. Others betake themselves to the rocks and dens of 
 the earth. I learn from old hunters that the deer never takes 
 more than one or two bites of grass without raising his head to 
 see if there is any danger or enemy near. They are all the time
 
 292 SERMONS BY 
 
 on the look out. I have noticed that the canary bird that dwells 
 in the house, and is reared in a cage, and watered and fed from 
 the hand of an attendant, never picks up more than two or three 
 seeds without lifting up its head to see if there is any danger 
 near. God has given us to understand that we have our ene- 
 mies, and he says, " Watch and pray, lest ye enter into tempta- 
 tion." Your adversary, the devil, is going up and down the 
 earth, like a roaring lion, seeking whom he may devour. God 
 hath put us on guard against him, and told us to watch and 
 pray, lest we enter into temptation. 
 
 But, alas ! how much more careless are a great many human 
 beings than the brute creation ! When the hen utters the cry 
 of alarm, the brood betake themselves quickly to the coop ; but 
 when God sends out the call of alarm to the wicked, they seem 
 to give it no heed. They talk against being frightened into re- 
 ligion ; they doubt whether there really is any devil, because they 
 have not seen him, and do not know that the devil is at their 
 heels. They fancy they are perfectly secure, and avail them- 
 selves of no refuge, no hiding-place from the wind, no covert 
 from the storm, no resting-place in that Rock which Avas cleft for 
 thee and for me ; but they rush right on, down into the very 
 clutches of their enemy, and are taken down into eternal night, 
 as the result of their stupidity and folly. 
 
 But what is this call of alarm? I answer, the word of God 
 contains some very startling passages, which are designed by 
 God as a call of alarm, to startle sinners back from the rocks 
 upon which they are liable to split. I will quote two or three : 
 " He that, being often reproved, hardeneth his neck, shall sud- 
 denly be destroyed, and that without remedy." One would 
 think that such a passage as that, coming from God himself, 
 would be enough to startle every human being, and induce all 
 to fly to Jesus Christ, the Rock of Ages. Another : " Now 
 consider this, ye that forget God, lest I tear you in pieces, and 
 there be none to deliver." An awful text ! 
 
 Luther Merritt, with whom I have labored in protracted 
 meetings, once told me that a friend of his preached on that
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 293 
 
 text one night to a crowded audience, in which were infidels, 
 and scoffers, and Universalists. At the close of the sermon, he 
 said, " If there is any man in this congregation who is willing to 
 meet his God to-night, and to measure arms with the Almighty ; 
 who doubts Christianity, let him rise up." A young man rose 
 in the gallery, and said, "I am prepared to meet the Christian's 
 God to-night. I fear him not. I am ready to measure arms 
 with your God before the dawning of another day." That young 
 man came down from that gallery on that bright, cold, moon- 
 shiny night, mounted a young and furious steed, and started for 
 home. On the way the horse became frightened, and threw 
 him upon a stick, that ran through his body, and tore his vital? 
 out of him. When his friends found the horse in the yard iu 
 the morning, they went in search of the rider, and found him 
 dead and ghastly his disfigured body proclaiming the violence 
 of the judgment that God had visited upon him. I will quote 
 it again. " Consider this, yet that forget God, lesf I tear you 
 iu pieces, and there be none to deliver." God tore his vitals 
 out of him in the silence of the night, when there was none to 
 deliver, and he went to meet his Judge, whom he had challenged 
 to combat, and found that no man could contend with his Maker 
 and prosper. 
 
 There are a great many passages of Scripture that God has 
 given us as calls of alarm ; but they are the expressions of his 
 love. There is just as much love and kindness in the heart of 
 the hen when she utters this alarm as when she utters the 
 special call, though it may not be so pleasant to the chickens. 
 It is all done from the best and highest regard for their good. 
 In fact, if there be any difference, there is a stronger expression 
 of love iu the call of alarm than in the special call. She utters 
 this call as if their very lives were in danger, as they really are. 
 There is just as much love in the heart of Jesus Christ when 
 he says, " He that believeth not shall be damned," as when he 
 says, " He that believeth and is baptized shall be saved." 
 It is only another way of expressing the same love, the same 
 regard for the interests of the children of men. He would
 
 294 SERMONS BY 
 
 apprise you of your approaching danger, that you may find a 
 refuge in his bleeding side, and be safe in the promised land, 
 where no danger can approach. 
 
 But, alas ! you will not heed the call of alarm. You say, 
 " I do not like to hear so much about hell and damnation ; the 
 ministers are trying to frighten us into religion." Why doesn't 
 a chicken reason thus, and say to its mother, " I do not like to 
 hear such warnings and such alarming preaching as this. Why 
 don't you tell us smooth and beautiful things, and dwell upon 
 some pleasing themes ; and what harm have we little chickens 
 done, that there should be anything to tear us limb from limb? 
 We don't believe in such themes as this, by which you are striv- 
 ing to frighten us." 
 
 What would you think if you were to hear a hen calling her 
 brood of chickens along after her, seeking to hide them in a 
 great ledge of rocks, and near the base of which there was a 
 cavity running twenty or thirty feet into the rock ; an eagle is 
 sailing along, and turns his piercing eye down on the hen, and 
 she spies him and sends out a cry of alarm. What would you 
 think, I say, if the chickens did not run, but stood still, and com- 
 plained of being frightened? We have a better opinion, say 
 they, of our Creator than to think that he has made us to be 
 torn to pieces and devoured when we have done no harm. 
 And thus they remain cavilling, until the eagle fastens upon 
 them and carries them away. You would think that the chick- 
 ens had no common sense ; no instinct at all. But the fact is, 
 that on the cry of alarm, almost as quick as you can think, every 
 single one of them will have fled into the cleft of that rock. 
 Here is Jesus, the Rock of Ages, cleft for thee and me. He sends 
 out the call of alarm "Flee ye into the mountains!" and' 
 "Turn ye, turn ye, for why will ye die ? " but instead of fleeing 
 to Christ, until his indignation be passed by, ye go right on in 
 sin, and perish, as ye fall into the hands of your enemy, the devil, 
 who goeth about, like a roaring lion, seeking whom he may 
 devour. 
 
 Kence we find this call of alarm uttered over and over again ;
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 295 
 
 but many there are who will not avail themselves of this ex- 
 pression of kindness. Then Jesus says, " O Jerusalem, Jeru- 
 salem, thou that killest the prophets, and stonest them which 
 are sent unto thee, how often would I have gathered thy chil- 
 dren together, even as a hen gathereth her chickens under her 
 wings, and ye would not ! " 
 
 This call of alarm embraces also alarm in preaching. God 
 calls some ministers to dwell upon terror more than others. 
 We have gifts differing one from another. Some men have a 
 peculiar gift to dwell upon the terrors of God's law. The 
 apostle Paul said, " Knowing the terrors of the law, we per- 
 suade men." And those men whom God calls to excel in that 
 kiud of preaching, to startle people, to alarm their fears, 
 to excite their interest, and thus secure the salvation of their 
 souls, must do it, or God would smite them. They are 
 bound to do it by the love they bear to the Savior, to the truth, 
 and to the souls of men. Now, I say, that when you are resist- 
 ing all these things, and complaining, you are resisting the 
 Spirit of the living God, and complaining of those who would 
 do you good. 
 
 Observe further, that this call of alarm embraces also striking 
 and alarming providences. I will give you a few. Deacon 
 Colgate, more than twenty years ago, told me a fair instance. 
 As a vessel was about to sail from this port, the officers made 
 a farewell supper. As the canvas was being spread to the 
 breeze, the captain arose, and passing the brandy round the 
 board, called on the company to drink to the following utter- 
 ance : " Now, boys, in twenty days, Liverpool or hell." They 
 sailed on and on over the Atlantic for nineteen days. On the 
 twentieth day they struck a rock and the vessel filled, and on 
 that twentieth day they were not in Liverpool ! 
 
 Sometimes God steps aside from his ordinary course and 
 smites presumptuous sinners dead, that they may stand as 
 beacon-lights to warn others to shun the rocks on which they 
 struck. During the Black Hawk war, in Illinois, at the time
 
 296 SERMONS BT 
 
 when God sent the cholera among the people, an officer cursed 
 God for sending the cholera into their midst. With an awfully 
 blasphemous oath he opened his mouth, and God smote him 
 down even as the oath trembled on his lips. Sydney Dyer, 
 whom I baptized nearly forty years ago, who was a drummer-boy 
 in that army, told me that the statement was correct. He saw 
 the very man whom God smote down while uttering that blas- 
 phemous oath against the King, Immortal and Invisible. So 
 God sometimes smites the wicked by these special providences, 
 which are calls of alarm. 
 
 When I was preaching in Watertown, in this State, a com- 
 pany of lads, on starting to skate, called at a hotel and took each 
 a dram, and one lad said, as he started, " I will skate to hell in 
 five minutes." He sprang off, struck an air-hole, and went out 
 of sight within five minutes, and never has been seen from that 
 day to this. God utters the call of alarm when he says, " Con- 
 sider this, ye that forget God, lest I tear you in pieces, and 
 there be none to deliver." 
 
 IV. We remark again, that there is another call, which we 
 denominate the brooding call. You who live in the city have 
 noticed, I presume, when you have been visiting the country, 
 that when the hen comes off with a brood, how artfully she man- 
 ages, and how diligently she toils along from place to place, 
 during the day, uttering her " cluck, cluck," all day long ; and 
 by and by, when the evening shades begin to gather, and the 
 dark night is coming on, and the chilling damps of the evening 
 dew begin to settle, she hastens away to the coop, or to some 
 place where she may rest quietly with her flock until the dawn- 
 ing of another day ; then it is that she changes her dialect, and 
 speaks in another language altogether. As she spreads her 
 wings, the brood all understand her language, and huddle around 
 her, and cover themselves with her feathers as she spreads her 
 wings over them. I suppose that the Savior had the words of the 
 Psalmist in his mind u He covereth them with his feathers " 
 when he uttered the words of my text. How cheerful and bright
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 297 
 
 the little brood are when they come out in the morning, after 
 having been kept all night Long by the heat of the body, and 
 protected from all harm ! 
 
 So, sinner, let me tell you that there is a dark night coming 
 on the dark night of eternity, when the cold, clammy sweat 
 of death will fall upon your brow ; when your eyeballs shall no 
 more turn in their sockets ; when your pulse shall beat fainter 
 and fainter, and your spirit will take its flight through the dark 
 valley of the shadow of death. Who can be with you, and 
 cover you there ? Jesus ! Yes, Jesus would give you to under- 
 stand, as he utters the brooding call, " Come unto me, all ye 
 that labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest." Yes, 
 " Jesus can make a dying bed feel soft as downy pillows are." 
 Jesus can warm and comfort your soul when the king of terrors 
 is doing his strange work ; and none but Jesus can do the help- 
 less sinner good when he is urged on through this dark and 
 dreary valley ; and if he has no hope in God, his condition is 
 terrible beyond conception. But how happy and cheerful is the 
 soul that has taken refuge in Jesus? 
 
 I remember a lady, whom I baptized in Watertown, in this 
 State, whose husband was an infidel, who sickened and died. 
 On the last night of her stay on earth my wife watched with 
 her. She lived in a large stone house. She revived just before 
 her death, and was able to talk sufficiently loud to be heard 
 through all the apartments of that building. After taking her 
 leave of her mother and sisters, she turned her attention to her 
 husband, and took him by the hand, and begged of him to pre- 
 pare to meet her in heaven, and told him how the love of God 
 was filling her soul ; and then she began to sing, and sweetly sung 
 until her soul took its upward flight. On the next day, that 
 husband said to me, " Mr. Knapp, I would give everything in 
 the world if all my infidel and Universalist associates had been 
 here to see my wife die ! It was enough to confound any man, 
 and compel him to throw his scepticism overboard. Nothing 
 but the love of God could support a person, and make him 
 happy when dying, and enable him to triumph over the king 
 21
 
 298 SERMONS BY 
 
 of terrors, as my wife was happy and triumphed when her soul 
 passed away in peace." 
 
 Yes, none but Jesus can warm, and cheer, and protect, and 
 make happy your soul when you are passing through this valley 
 of death, through which we must all, sooner or later, pass i 
 
 You have noticed, sometimes, the hen with her brood, late in 
 autumn, when the chilling winds are beginning to whistle about 
 on every side, and a dark cloud is rising in the west, that when 
 the rain or hail begins to fall, if she cannot find some shelter or 
 refuge where her brood can be protected in peace and safety, 
 elie will stand out in the storm, and spread her wings to protect 
 them, and save them from the storm and danger. This makes 
 me think again of Jesus. O, when the scalding drops of Je- 
 hovah's wrath shall fall upon the wicked, who but Jesus can 
 protect their souls? Who but Jesus can spread out his wings 
 to protect them from the rattling hail from heaven that shall fall 
 upon the ungodly, who call not upon his name ? 
 
 Yes, Jesus seems to utter tbe brooding call, as if he would 
 not only be up to, but go beyond, every figui-e that can be em- 
 ployed to represent the compassion of a covenant-keeping God. 
 " O Jerusalem, Jerusalem, thou that killest the prophets, and 
 stonest them which are sent unto thee, how often would I have 
 gathered thy children together, even as a hen gethereth her 
 chickens under her wings, and ye would not." The Savior 
 would have saved your souls from the wrath to come, from the 
 avenger of blood that is on your track, from the eternal con- 
 demnation that awaits the ungodly, but you would not. Yes, 
 the compassion of God is without a parallel. 
 
 Then, I observe again, after the hen has reduced herself to a 
 mere skeleton in order to bring her brood into existence, and 
 moves through the field, digging and toiling on, to provide food 
 for herself and family, her love for her chickens is such that she 
 takes food out of her own mouth for them, even when her 
 own nature craves that food. This makes me think of Jesus 
 again. Though he was rich, yet for our sakes he became poor,, 
 that we through his poverty might be rich. Jesus has bared his
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 299 
 
 bosom to the spear. He has tasted death for every man. lie 
 sacrificed all the riches and glory of heaven, and became a man 
 of sorrows and acquainted with grief. He became poor, that we 
 might be rich. O, the compassion of Jesus is beyond a parallel 
 in the universe of God. He loves us with an everlasting love. 
 He thirsted, and hungered, and had no certain dwelling-place 
 while going about and doing good, and whispering the accents 
 of peace and mercy upon the ear of the poor sinner as he was 
 moving on towards the eternal world. Yet sinners harden their 
 hearts, and stiffen their necks, and stand out against the mercy 
 and goodness of God. 
 
 Again, I have noticed that when the eagle or hawk approached 
 near the hen, if she has not time to provide a place of refuge for 
 herself and brood, she will stand out in the open field r and pitch 
 battle with that which is too mighty for her to save her brood, 
 and thrusts herself into the talons of the eagle or hawk, and the 
 eagle bears her away, and upon the limb of a distant oak tears 
 her flesh from her bones, and limb from limb, and thus she lays 
 down her own life to save her brood. And this makes me think 
 of Jesus. When Justice iron-hearted and stern Justice came 
 and demanded the death of every human being, Jesus said to Jus- 
 tice, " What are your demands? I will meet them." And he 
 laid down his life as a ransom in due season. He is taken by 
 Justice and borne away to the cross nailed to the tree, and 
 crucified ; and when his Father hides his face, he cries out in 
 agony of soul, " My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken 
 me ? " and drops his head upon his bosom, and yields himself 
 up to the claims of justice, that he might become the end of the 
 law for righteousness to every one that believeth. 
 
 Here we see the compassion of the Lord Jesus, the Kin<; of 
 Glory. And yet sinners harden their hearts and stiffen their 
 necks against him. 
 
 My dying hearers, let me implore you to yield to the call of 
 God. Be induced to yield to these calls of your loving Savior, 
 before you have gone beyond the reach of hope forever. Will 
 you stand out in rebellion, and perish, perish eternally,
 
 800 SERMONS BY 
 
 because you scorn the message ; because you stop your ears 
 against the voice of the charmer, though he charm never so 
 wisely ? 
 
 May God constrain you by his Spirit, and by the power of 
 his truth, and the love of Jesus Christ, to end the controversy, 
 and come and be reconciled to God by the death of his Son, 
 that your souls perish not.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 301 
 
 IV* 
 
 WHY THE WICKED LIVE. 
 
 "Their foot shall slide in due time." DEUT. xxxii. 35. 
 
 WE propose, this evening, to show you why the wicked live, 
 and why the devil lives. God being good, and opposed 
 to sin and misery, and to everything that produces misery 
 among the world of mankind, and foreseeing the end of the 
 wicked, the query may start in our minds, Why does he suffer 
 the wicked to live ? Why does he allow one man to enslave 
 another, and require him to perform unrequited and hard 
 service? Why does he allow another man to convert a good 
 and nutritious substance, provided for man and beast, into a 
 deadly poison, to waste away a man's constitution, to ruin his 
 family, to beggar his children, to break the heart of the wife of 
 his youth, to send the delirium tremens to so many families, 
 and hurry so many to premature graves? 
 
 If God is good, why does he not cut these wicked men down, 
 and send them to their long homes, and prevent all the misery 
 which they will produce by living here upon his footstool? 
 There are reasons why. 
 
 Many also wonder why God permits the devil to live, and why 
 he does not either kill him outright, or chain him down in the 
 pit, rather than permit him to go up and down the earth like a 
 roaring lion, seeking whom he may devour. Yet the devil has 
 just as good a right to live as you have ; and if age is any 
 recommendation, he has a stronger claim, for he is a great deal 
 older ; and if knowledge is any claim, he has a stronger claim 
 
 * Preached in New York, November 27, 1866.
 
 802 SERMONS BY 
 
 than you, for he knows more than a million of you. He is a 
 subject of God's moral government, and there are reasons why 
 God suffers the devil to live, and there are reasons why he 
 suffers wicked men to live. We are told in the text, " Their 
 foot shall slide in due time." 
 
 Look at the real position of the human family. The figure 
 of the text represents the whole surface of this earth as a vastly 
 extended inclined plane, and at the base of this inclined plane 
 there is a great gulf, or lake, burning with fire and brimstone, 
 rolling and tumbling in awful grandeur. On this inclined plane 
 there are some twelve millions of human beings, some dancing, 
 some gambling, some drinking, and some carousing, and some 
 praying, and some serving God, and some serving their lusts 
 and their master the devil. Away up at the head of this 
 inclined plane there is a beautiful landscape stretching on and 
 on, farther than the human eye can reach. Those who are so 
 happy as to reach the head of this inclined plane, and enter 
 through the gates into the New Jerusalem, take up their harps 
 and sing as they pass on and on over the green and flowery 
 plains into the world of eternal day. Others are now and then 
 sliding down and making a fatal plunge into the gulf beneath. 
 
 Why does God let the wicked live? The text says, " Their 
 foot shall slide in due time." That is, when the due time 
 comes their foot shall slide. And you will understand that the 
 " due time " is when God has accomplished all the good that 
 can be wrought by letting the wicked live. When God sees 
 that by letting a wicked man live any longer there would be 
 more evil than good resulting in the universe from the prolonga- 
 tion of that man's life, then his time comes, his foot slides, and 
 he is dashed into the burning lake beneath. 
 
 1. We observe that God lets the wicked live because he is 
 good and merciful, and loves his creatures, and does not delight 
 in misery, but in the happiness of the human family ; and he 
 cannot bear to see a man sliding and sliding, and making that 
 fatal plunge, just so long as he can, consistently with the greatest 
 good of all, keep him out. He watches over him by night and
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 803 
 
 by day, and keeps his heart beating and his lungs heaving, and 
 his guardian angel round about him. God is waiting and 
 waiting to be gracious, and lets that man live on, inhaling the 
 atmosphere, and drinking the water, and eating the fruits of the 
 earth, and listening to the gospel's cheerful sound, and in the 
 midst of all the means of grace. God lets him live on just so 
 long as he possibly can and not have the prolongation of that 
 man's life produce more evil than good. 
 
 Now, to illustrate this point, I will give you a fact. Deacon 
 Sage, late of Rochester, but now in heaven, told me that there 
 was an infidel living in Brockport, in this state, who was a gam- 
 bler, a hard drinker, and, of course, a very rough, wicked man. 
 One night, in the midst of a revelry, while shuffling cards 
 around the board, he spoke of his wife, and said that he had 
 the best wife in the State of New York. " Anything and every- 
 thing that she can do to promote my happiness, she will do ; 
 and," said he, " she is a Christian, and she will serve her God 
 and love her religion. Any sacrifice that she can make, on her 
 part, to promote my happiness, she will make with cheerful- 
 ness. She never murmurs nor complains." Said he, " There 
 is not her equal in this state ; and I will bet five dollars now, 
 that if you will go home with me to-night, and I order her to 
 arise and prepare a supper, she will do it without one single 
 complaint." 
 
 " Well," said one of the company, " I will take the bet ; " and 
 the money was put into the hands of another man of the 
 company, and he took them home with him between twelve and 
 one o'clock at night. His wife was in bed and asleep. He 
 seated his company, awoke her, and ordered her to arise forth- 
 with and prepare a supper for himself and his company. 
 " Well, husband," said she, " leave the light in the room, and 
 your wishes shall be complied with." She arose immediately, 
 and dressed herself for the kitchen, and prepared them as good 
 a supper as the house could afford. She sat down at the table, 
 and waited upon the company with as much care, and attention, 
 and kindness as if they had been the President and his Cabinet.
 
 304 SERMONS BY 
 
 And when they got through with the meal, she retired to her 
 room, and the company looked one upon the other in amaze- 
 ment. The man who had the money at stake handed it over, 
 and said that he never saw the like before. The husband him- 
 self was affected by it, hard-hearted and wicked as he was. 
 After the company had all retired, he sat down, and said he, 
 " Wife, now I want you to tell me why it is that you treat me 
 as you do, when I treat you as I do. I receive nothing but 
 kindness in return for unkindness. Anything and everything 
 in your power, that you can do to contribute to my happiness, 
 you are willing to do. I cannot understand it." " Well, 
 husband," said she, " I will tell you. I made up my mind, 
 years ago, that all the happiness you will ever have will be in 
 your lifetime, during the short space between the cradle and 
 the grave, and then you will be tormented. But I expect to 
 have my good things in the world to come. And all that I can 
 do, all that I can suffer, and thus add to your scanty pittance 
 of enjoyment, I will do with all the cheerfulness in the world." 
 It went through and through him like electricity. He was 
 bathed in tears. He bowed down and begged her prayers ; and 
 that man was converted to God. 
 
 Now, there was the principle of Christianity carried out in 
 that woman. She understood, she had made up her mind, 
 that, so far as she could judge from the evidence that she had, 
 her husband would never repent ; that he would live on in 
 sin, and die in his sins ; and in the world to come would have 
 an ocean of misery. And all that she could do to increase the 
 scanty pittance of his enjoyment she was willing to do ; to make 
 any sacrifice for him, no matter what, as, she looked at the 
 ocean of happiness, beyond the narrow limits of time, that was 
 in store for herself. 
 
 In like manner God sees that all the happiness you will ever 
 have will be while you are passing over this narrow isthmus 
 'twixt two unbounded seas. He sees this of you who will not 
 turn and believe in and love and serve the Lord Jesus Christ. 
 He sees that your foot will slide in due time, and all that he
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 305 
 
 cau do to lengthen out the brittle thread of your life, and extend 
 the time of your enjoyment, he delights to do ; and hence he 
 watches over you awake and asleep. All the time, while 
 Justice is crying, u Cut him down ; why cumbereth he the 
 ground?" Jesus wards off the execution, f,nd you are spared 
 until the due time comes. 
 
 But there is a point beyond which the forbearance of Jesus, 
 though long continued, ceases to be a virtue ; and when that 
 time comes, and God sees that by letting that man live any 
 longer, his existence will be productive of more misery than 
 happiness, and be destructive of the greatest good of the whole 
 human family, then the due time has come, and he must strike 
 the fatal blow ; and his foot slides, and he is dashed into a 
 burning hell. He has then put God under the necessity of 
 cutting him down, and sending him to his long home. 
 
 I have often thought of a certain judge, who, after a criminal 
 had been tried before him and been found guilty, would rise up, 
 address the criminal, and expatiate very eloquently upon the 
 willingness of the jury, and of his own desire, to show him 
 favor, and let him go free, if they could. " But, sir," he would 
 Sa 7 " y ou must understand that there is a point beyond which 
 forbearance ceases to be a virtue, and when you have reached 
 that point, it is necessary that the terrible blow should fall ; " 
 and then he would proceed to pronounce the sentence of the 
 law. As an officer of the government, from which he received 
 his commission, he could do no otherwise. So, if a sinner will 
 not repent ; if he will live in sin ; if he loves sin, and rolls it as 
 a sweet morsel under his tongue, and tramples God's laws 
 under his feet, and crucifies the Lord afresh, and puts him to an 
 open shame ; if he dashes the cup of salvation from his lips, 
 and pushes his way downward to the chambers of eternal night, 
 then a time comes in which God must execute wrath upon 
 him ; then that due time comes, and his foot slides, and he is 
 gone. 
 
 2. God lets the wicked live, lest by pulling up the tares he 
 should also root up the wheat. You remember the parable
 
 306 SERMONS BY 
 
 given by our blessed Savior. It seems that a certain man had 
 sown good seed in his field ; but his servants, going out upon the 
 field, found tares springing up here and there in the field. 
 They returned, and said to their master, " Did you not sow 
 good seed in the field? Whence, then, are all these tares? ' 
 He said, " An enemy hath done this ; while we slept he has 
 sown these tares." You will remember that always, when 
 Christiana sleep, the enemy is sowing tares. Atheism, Deism, 
 Universalism, Mormonism, and all other " isms " that are con- 
 jured up by the devil, are then being sown broadcast over the 
 community. " Well," asked the servants, " shall we go and 
 pull up the tares? " " No," said the master ; " let them both 
 grow until the harvest comes, lest by pulling up the tares you 
 root out the wheat also." 
 
 To make this perfectly plain, we will suppose that you are 
 looking on a surface of ten acres. You sow the whole surface 
 to wheat. An enemy comes and sows tares all over thia 
 ten-acre lot. They come up all through the wheat. If you 
 undertake to pull them out, with every tare you pull one, two, 
 or three roots of wheat. Their roots are all entwined together, 
 and so, by the time that you have gone over the surface of the 
 wheat and pulled up the tares, you have completely destroyed 
 the whole crop of wheat. Let both grow until the harvest, 
 which is explained to be the end of the world, and then he says 
 that he will gather together the tares, and bind them in bundles, 
 and they shall be cast into the fire which is unquenchable, but 
 the wheat he will gather into his garner ; he will separate the 
 wheat from the tares, the righteous from the wicked ; the 
 righteous will be received into heaven, the wicked will depart 
 to hell to that fire which is unquenchable. You see at once 
 the force and beauty of this parable. I once knew a man who 
 was an infidel, but whose wife was a member of the church 
 of which I was pastor. They had sixteen children ; but all 
 of those sixteen children were converted before I left the 
 town. One of the number entered the gospel ministry, and 
 became a minister of the gospel of the New Testament. The
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 307 
 
 family moved on in a sphere of usefulness and activity in the 
 kingdom, and I have reason to hope that all, in due time, will 
 reach the promised land, with many more souls won to Christ, 
 and saved through their agency ; how many eternity alone can 
 determine. If God had cut that infidel down in his youth, he 
 would have destroyed and rooted up all that wheat ; not only 
 the sixteen children, whose souls will reach the paradise of 
 God, but hundreds and thousands who, through their agency, 
 may be brought to Christ, and enter heaven to go out no more 
 forever. Hence God lets the infidel live, and gathers all the 
 good that he can from that man's existence, and overrules 
 everythiug for the accomplishment of the greatest amount of 
 good, until the due time comes ; when God sees that more harm 
 than good will result from the prolongation of his life, then his 
 foot slides, and he is dashed into the roaring gulf beneath. 
 " The wrath of man shall praise him, and the remainder will 
 he restrain." 
 
 3. God lets the wicked live for the purpose of showing forth 
 his long suffering. If God cut every sinner down for the very 
 first offence, and executed wrath upon him that doeth evil, and 
 showed no mercy, nor forbearance, nor long suffering, who 
 would ever know the character of God? Who would ever 
 understand the mercy, forbearance, and long suffering of our 
 covenant-keeping God? This perfection in Deity must be 
 developed to the admiration of all heaven, and earth, and hell. 
 We read much of the long suffering of God in the Holy 
 Scriptures. We witness the long suffering of God in the days 
 of Noah, when the ark was preparing. God had pronounced 
 judgment upon the whole world, and yet his mercy extended 
 over them ; he gave them time and space for repentance. He 
 called after them, and warned them by his servant Noah ; but 
 by and by his long suffering could continue no longer. By and 
 by justice, as a principle of God's moral government, must 
 have its demands answered ; and the flood came and swept them 
 all away. 
 
 The long suffering of God is exhibited very strikingly in the
 
 308 SERMONS BY 
 
 history of his ancient people, the Jews. He appealed to that 
 hard-hearted, stiff-necked, and rebellious people for year after 
 year. Yet century after century rolled on, and they rebelled 
 against him more and more. Their heart was fully set in them 
 to do evil. But when the time was come, when he could no 
 longer forbear, he cried out, " O, Ephraim, how shall I give 
 tliee up?" 
 
 The long suffering of God waited while they killed the 
 prophets, and stoned them that were sent unto them, and 
 beheaded John the Baptist, and crucified the Son of God. 
 When the long suffering of God had been protracted as long as 
 all the circumstances in the case would permit, he was com- 
 pelled to say, " Ephraim is joined to his idols ; let him alone." 
 And Jesus may be compelled to say of you, O sinner, " He is 
 joined to his idols ; let him alone." " She is joined to her 
 idols ; let her alone." " Plead no longer ; waste no more 
 tears ; waste no more prayers ; spend no more breath in tender 
 expostulation. The long suffering of God is sufficiently de- 
 veloped ; now the due time has come ; cut her down ; 'for why 
 should she cumber the ground?" It is on this principle that 
 God says, " My word shall not return unto me void ; it shall 
 accomplish the end whereunto I sent it." What is that? A 
 sweet savor of God in Christ. And a sweet savor of God in 
 Christ of life unto life to them who embrace the gospel, and of 
 death unto death to them who reject it. In either case it is a 
 sweet savor of God in Christ both unto those who are saved and 
 rise, and sing and shout, and magnify the riches of God's grace 
 forever ; and to those who sink down into dark despair, weep- 
 ing and wailing, and gnashing their teeth, and gnawing their 
 tongues for pain. 
 
 God's long suffering will be magnified in the condemnation 
 of the wicked. All the heavenly hosts will look on and see how 
 long God waited to be gracious ; how long suffering he was to 
 those who finally went down to hell ; how his mercies extended 
 from childhood to old age, or until the due time came when 
 their foot slid, and they made the fatal plunge.
 
 ELDEB JACOB KNAPP. 809 
 
 Ministers may stand up and preach the truth of God from 
 day to day, from night to night, from year to year, and rejoice 
 over every soul that repents and turns to God ; and if they 
 repent not, but sink to hell, they know that their preaching will 
 not be in vain. God will be honored ; Jesus Christ will be 
 glorified ; the gospel of the dear Redeemer, in all its beauty, 
 and forbearance, and love, will be understood by all the 
 assembled hosts when God shall judge the quick and the dead. 
 But when the long suffering of God has been protracted as long 
 as the case will permit, then the due time comes, your foot 
 slides, and you are gone. Then there is no more hope. 
 
 4. In the next place, the wicked live in order that God may 
 give sinners time and space for repentance. God is sincere in 
 calling upon all men, everywhere, to repent. God is waiting 
 and waiting to be gracious. He is unwilling, as the Bible says, 
 that any should perish, but would that all should be saved, and 
 come to the knowledge of the truth. God delighteth not in the 
 death of him that dieth, but would that he should live. Do 
 you suppose that, because the wicked will be cut down and 
 perish in hell, and through all eternity, such is the choice 
 of the great God ? If so, you might suppose that God chose 
 that every drunkard should be a drunkard ; and every cruel, 
 wicked man should whip his wife ; and every knave should 
 overreach his neighbor in trade ; and that all the wicked and 
 abominable things that are done under the penalty of eternal 
 damnation should be committed. You must understand that 
 God delighteth not in the death of him that dieth. It would be 
 agreeable to the heart of Deity, to the heart of the Father, 
 Son, and Holy Spirit, to see every sinner repent to-night ; to 
 see the entire world fall down and worship the Lamb ; to see 
 in every human body a broken heart and a contrite spirit ; 
 and to witness the pure, earnest devotions of the millions of 
 the human race ascending to God like holy incense. But they 
 will not do it. 
 
 So God gives men time and space for repentance. He gave 
 the old world one hundred and twenty years in which to repent.
 
 310 SERMONS BY 
 
 He gave the Ninevites time and space for repentance. They 
 repented, and were saved. By crying mightily unto the God 
 of heaven, God heard their cries, and waived his judgment, and 
 prolonged the lives of the people of that wicked city. He gave 
 the Jews time for repentance, even after he had foretold their 
 doom. John the Baptist, who was a faithful and truthful 
 preacher, went everywhere, preaching and crying, " Behold the 
 Lamb of God, that taketh away the sin of the world." God gave 
 them time and space for repentance, and all that did repent 
 were pardoned and saved ; and if all had repented, they all would 
 have been pardoned, and sanctified, and saved; What else did 
 Jesus mean in the text from which I preached to you last night ? 
 " O Jerusalem, Jerusalem, thou that killest the prophets, and 
 stonest them which are sent unto thee, how often would I have 
 gathered thy children together, even as a hen gathereth her 
 chickens under her wings, and ye would not ! " Does he not tell 
 us here, that he was willing to gather that very people, those 
 incorrigible Jews, who betrayed and crucified the Son of God, 
 and cried out, " Away with him " ? He was as willing to gather 
 them together, and to save their souls, as a hen was to gather her 
 chickens under her wings. And the reason why they were not 
 gathered, and not saved, was because they " would not." 0, 
 that damning "would not " ! " Ye will not come unto me, 
 that ye might have life." " Turn ye, turn ye, for why will ye 
 die?" " O that they were wise," saith God ; " that they knew 
 this ; that they would consider their latter end ; that it might be 
 well with them and with their children forever." 
 
 God lets you live on, sinner, in order to give you time and 
 space for repentance ; and you will see, if you keep on, and 
 wake up at last in hell, that you might just as well have been in 
 heaven as anybody else. Somebody else has taken up your 
 harp, and received your crown. You, like Esau, have sold 
 your birthright. God spares your life from year to year ; the 
 Spirit strives ; ministers preach ; the church pleads ; all the 
 agencies that God possesses are moving around in your midst, 
 and beckoning you on towards the celestial regions ; but you will
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 311 
 
 not go. Suddenly the due time comes; your foot slides; you 
 are gone ; you are irrevocably lost ! 
 
 5. But, again, the wicked live in order that God may spread 
 the gospel through their agency. He prolongs their lives even 
 for the good of the righteous. We often look upon our perse- 
 cutors as a great evil. We often look upon worldly, sensual 
 members of the church, who are not satisfied with a. faithful 
 gospel ministry, who want a man-pleasing preacher, one who 
 shall give them smooth words and fair speeches, and who, instead 
 of preaching against their pride, and vanity, and worldly-mind- 
 edness, shall minister to their passions, and pamper their pride, 
 and flatter their vanity, and help them on in the consummation 
 of their carnal and selfish purposes. We look upon this class 
 as a great calamity ; but yet God overrules the existence of such 
 persons for very wise and important ends. God maketh the 
 wrath of man to praise him, and the remainder he restrains. 
 We are enabled, when we see these classes, to distinguish be- 
 tween him that serveth God and him that serveth Mammon ; to 
 distinguish between the sons of Levi and those who are such in 
 word and not in deed and truth. It draws the faithful to the 
 mercy-seat, and they pray the more earnestly ; they call upon 
 God out of a pure heart, and all the persecution they endure only 
 makes the gold shine the brighter. It is just so in reference to 
 the wicked. We hear of the opposition of infidels, of the sneer- 
 ing of Universalists, of the persecution of wicked, ungodly men 
 in every day and in every age of the world, and we think they 
 are very serious evils ; but after all they may be of very great 
 service to the children of God ; but I tell you that we never 
 find a true, earnest, apostolic religion, except in times of per- 
 secution. 
 
 When Christianity appears in silver slippers, and glides along 
 upon the soft carpet, when everything goes on smoothly, and 
 we have smooth and beautiful preaching, and no opposition from 
 the wicked, we have a sickly piety. Real piety then dies out. 
 There is then no real soul in religion. There is nothing but 
 mere form when we deny the power. But when we have ene-
 
 812 SERMONS BY 
 
 mies to oppose us, we are driven near the mercy-seat ; we then 
 know in whom we trust. We are constrained to take the word 
 of God as a lamp to our feet and a light to our path, and to make 
 straight paths for our feet as we lead the way on to heaven. 
 So it is necessary for the wicked to live for the benefit of the 
 righteous. We have not half enough persecution in the church. 
 If you could only start the devil once, we would have something 
 done. I was thinking of this as I came on the cars from Albany 
 here looking at the river, as I sat on the river-side, and watch- 
 ing the vessels. There was a little, gentle wind, and as the sails 
 of the vessels filled, they moved on ; a good wind in the direc- 
 tion in which they are moving carries them on in good speed ; a 
 side wind answers a very good purpose ; and even a head wind 
 is of more service than no wind at all, for they make some head- 
 way then ; but in a dead calm, when the sails do not flutter, but 
 hang down limber, there is no progress at all to be made. The 
 object of the devil is to take all the wind out of our sails ; to 
 allay all public and open opposition, and produce a dead and still 
 calm ; to lull the church to sleep, and then to send out his em- 
 issaries and sow tares broadcast over the land, until the wheat 
 is choked with tares, and there is no fruit produced as the re- 
 sult. I have always found, so far as my experience goes, that 
 the greatest exhibitions of divine power have been where there 
 was the greatest persecution. Amidst mobs, and threats of my 
 life, and every conceivable effort on the part of the wicked to 
 break up meetings and stop the work of God, I have always 
 found that God then comes down and works like himself. When 
 the enemy comes in like a flood, then it is that God works. 
 During the mob in New Haven, I was waylaid, night after night, 
 by those who thirsted for my blood ; but God carried me right 
 through, and I never lost a hair of my head. Had you been 
 there then, you would have seen the workings of God Almighty's 
 power. If you had been in Boston when I was preaching there, 
 and witnessed the mobs that filled the square, and the infidels 
 sitting up all night, making clubs to knock my brains out with, 
 but God knocked on their hearts, broke them, and saved their
 
 ELDO JACOB KNAPP. 313 
 
 souls, you would then have seen an exhibition of the power 
 of the Great Eternal that you never will see in times when there 
 is no opposition. 
 
 God through the devil, and the devil through wicked men, 
 scattered the disciples of Christ who huddled up in Jerusalem, 
 and they went everywhere preaching the gospel. More than 
 half of our churches in cities originate in the agency of the 
 devil. When churches will not branch off, start out, begin 
 new interests, go up and possess the city, God always has a 
 schismatic devil on hand to let out upon them, and compel 
 them to do that which they ought to have done from better mo- 
 tives. A few years since, every church, of all denominations, 
 from the Episcopalians up to the Baptists, in Elmira, N. Y., was- 
 divided into two churches, each one building a new house of 
 worship, and thus doubling the amount of labor and their 
 power for good. God says, "The wicked are my sword," and 
 through this sword God has opened the way for the spread of 
 the gospel among all nations. If there is any quarrelling to be 
 done, or fighting, the devil is always on hand. 
 
 We must have wicked men, and we must have devils. We 
 need them both. They drive us nearer to God. They make 
 us pray more earnestly. They make us feel our dependence 
 upon God more intently. They nerve up our souls to the work 
 of serving God, and thus render very essential service in help- 
 ing on the work of the Holy Ghost. Yes, we may well say, 
 when the question is asked, "Why do the wicked live?" they 
 live to serve God ; or, rather, that God may serve himself by 
 them, and make the wrath of man to praise him, while he re- 
 strains the remainder. God overrules all that the wicked do 
 for some good purpose. Every good thing that can be reached 
 by the infinite wisdom and power of God will be reached, and 
 thus God will make the wrath of man to praise him, and he will 
 restrain the remainder. I have been in meetings where men 
 could not swear without converting somebody. I have known 
 men, and Universalists, to get up in the midst of a congregation, 
 and curse the minister to his face, and throw stones at him ; 
 22
 
 814 SERMONS BY 
 
 but God Almighty converted sinners just by those oaths. Sin- 
 ners began to ask themselves, " Is this the company I am to 
 have in hell ? Have such outrageous miscreants in human form 
 got to be endured through all eternity in hell? Then I won't 
 go there ; " and they fell right down and began to beg for mercy, 
 and were converted to God. I have often thought that my 
 enemies did me more good than my friends. No thanks to 
 them, though, for it. There was a Judas Iscariot for the be- 
 trayal of our Lord and Master. I do not know where I should 
 have landed ere this, if I had had no enemies, if all had been 
 friends^ and all been smooth sailing. I might have been exalted 
 above measure, and fallen into condemnation. But my enemies 
 are always watching for me. If there is a stain anywhere, they 
 are sure to see it. If there is a spot upon anything in my course 
 of operation, they are sure to detect it. They are all the time 
 watching for us : hence we must be on our guard ; we must set 
 a double guard upon our lips in the presence of the wicked, lest 
 the uncircumcised should triumph. God overrules all these 
 things for our good and for his own glory. 
 
 6. Again : we need the devil and wicked men in order to 
 test character. When God made this world, and placed Adam 
 in it, you know that he placed him under the law, and laid a 
 prohibition upon one single thing. He prohibited him from eat- 
 ing the fruit of one tree in the garden ; but Adam, under the 
 temptation of the enemy, and under the influence of his wife, 
 plucked the fruit and ate thereof. The crown fell from his head, 
 and he was driven out of the garden, and the flaming sword 
 guarded the way to the tree of life. So God does not mean 
 to let anybody into heaven until their characters are tested. It 
 is not as easy a thing as many men think for God to keep a race 
 of moral agents in obedience and subjection to his moral law. 
 We have knowledge of but two kinds of moral agencies 
 angels and men. We know that many angels have fallen ; they 
 have risen up in rebellion against God, and been cast down into 
 hell, and reserved in chains of darkness until the judgment of 
 the great day shall come.
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 815 
 
 "We know that the entire family of man have fallen. It 
 seems as if it was not a very easy thing for even God himself 
 to preserve a race of moral agents in a state of sinless perfection. 
 Do you suppose thai our first parents knew anything about the 
 connection between sin and misery before the experiment had 
 been tried ? Not at all. Do you suppose that Adam and Eve 
 had a conception of the tremendous results that would follow a 
 violation of God's law ? Do you suppose that they imagined 
 that their son Abel would fall a victim to the rage and envy of 
 another son, Cain ? that they would look upon the manly form 
 of their own son, with all the pangs of sorrow that racked their 
 frame and continued to chafe them through life ? They had no 
 such conception. Do you suppose that they had any idea that 
 millions and millions of their posterity would become demons, 
 weeping, and wailing, and gnashing their teeth, and gnawing 
 their tongues in pain, while the smoke of their torment should 
 roll up from the depths of hell? They had no such thought. 
 They knew nothing about the connection between sin and 
 misery. It was not possible that they could know. 
 
 God does not mean to have any human soul or rebel in 
 heaven until he is fully reformed, and his character fully 
 tested. He knows the wickedness of man. You know that we 
 are forbidden to lay hands suddenly upon any man ; that we 
 are not to ordain a novice, lest he should be lifted up in pride 
 and fall into condemnation. It is not safe to introduce men into 
 the ministry until they are tested ; and if it is inexpedient to 
 introduce men into the ministry until their characters have 
 been tested, do you think that any one will ever be introduced 
 into the paradise of God without having his character tested ? 
 Never ! Never ! This world, my friends, is a world of trial, 
 and we need the devil to tempt and try the children of men, that 
 their characters may be fully and thoroughly tested. We need 
 the devil ; we must have the devil to work with all deceitful- 
 ness and unrighteousness to tempt every character ; and you 
 find sometimes a great hoard of these miserable, filthy, impure 
 spirits sweeping along through the community, bearing numbers
 
 816 SERMONS BY 
 
 away to the bottomless pit. They could not stand the test, and 
 away they went. One will falter here, and another there. 
 One is tempted away to the theatre, another to the gaming 
 table, another to the accumulation of wealth, "hoarding it up to 
 gratify his pride, instead of doing good with it. Their char- 
 acters are all tested, and such as stand the test, and resist 
 temptation, and cling to Jesus, will finally be fitted and prepared 
 for heaven, and will reach the promised land in due time, and 
 never rebel against God again. 
 
 They have been led through much tribulation, for such is the 
 way to glory. They can say, " I have fought the good fight, I 
 have kept the faith, and there is henceforth laid up for me a 
 crown which a righteous Judge shall give." All the temptations 
 of hell can never draw them into rebellion again. It is a great 
 thing to have escaped the pollutions of the world, and been 
 washed in the blood of the Lamb, and entered heaven, where 
 there is no more sighing, and no more temptation, and be per- 
 -mitted to dwell in the sunshine of God's glory forever. We 
 must be tempted. The trial of our faith is more precious than 
 gold. You remember that the barren fig-tree must be tried, 
 and dug about until all hope of its bearing fruit becomes extinct, 
 and then it shall be cut down as a cumberer of the ground. So 
 the due time comes at length when the sinner has accomplished 
 all the ends that God can reach by letting him live, and then 
 he cuts him down. 
 
 7. Then, again, God lets the wicked live to spread the gospel 
 negatively. I will give you a few instances. I will refer you 
 to one in ancient days. You know that there was a time when 
 the apostles of Jesus Christ were all poor, illiterate men. 
 Luke, it is true, was a physician, and Paul was brought up at 
 the feet of Gamaliel ; but most of the disciples were poor. They 
 had but little money. There were no missionary societies in 
 those days. When God wanted to send missionaries away 
 down to Rome, so as to spread the gospel as rapidly as possible, 
 there were no missionary societies nor missionary vessels ready 
 to send or take them. The devil had a terrible inkling after
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 317 
 
 Paul ; he wanted to get hold of him. Paul was then making 
 inroads upon the devil's kingdom wherever he went, and the 
 devil laid hold upon him and put him in irons. When Paul 
 appealed unto Caesar, said the king, " Thou shalt go." The 
 devil took him down to the port, and bore his expenses all the 
 way. Here God made the wrath of man to praise him, and 
 restrained the remainder. God wanted the gospel preached -in 
 Rome, and would have it preached there. God owned all the 
 money that was in the devil's pocket, and made the devil hand 
 it over. He took this missionary down to Rome, and kept him 
 there for three years and six months preaching the unsearchable 
 riches of Christ. 
 
 Look at the case in more modern times. In 1839, as I told 
 the friends in a temperance meeting the other night, God sent 
 me to Baltimore to preach. God began the work, in the first 
 place, among drunkards. The rum-sellers became very much 
 out of patience because they were losing their customers. They 
 became very much filled with wrath and malice towards the un- 
 worthy Baptist preacher whom God employed in leading on the 
 sacramental host from conquest to conquest, and they swore 
 vengeance upon him. The young men constituted a temperance 
 society, and invited me one night to preach a sermon on temper- 
 ance. I agreed to do so. The rum-sellers had a meeting, and 
 appointed a delegation to go and hear my sermon, and report. 
 They came in and sat down behind the door, and as the ser- 
 vice went on, and solemn, pointed, and pungent truths were 
 preached, they began to feel the power of God's truth. After 
 the service, they went back to make a report, and the old rum- 
 seller, standing behind the counter, said, " What report have 
 you to make ? " " Well," said one, " we "heard a great deal 
 more truth than poetry." "But what did the elder say?" 
 asked another. " I wish that you had been there and heard 
 for yourselves," said one of the delegation. " But what did 
 he say? " " Well," replied one, " he said, if you will mark, 
 you will find the rum-seller dressed in fine broadcloth, and a 
 fine shirt, and silk hat, and beautiful boots, carrying his head
 
 318 SERMONS BY 
 
 high, and living in ease and affluence ; but you will see that 
 you have on an old coat out at the elbows, old pants in strings ; 
 and you see," said he, " that it is just as Mr. Knapp says. 
 There you sit with your broadcloth and fine shirt, while here I 
 stand in all my rags. I begin to get my eyes opened. More- 
 over, he said that the rum-seller's wife will be dressed like a 
 ]g,dy : she wears her silks and satins, and her beautiful hat ; 
 while your wife has on an old calico dress, rent and patched, 
 and old shoes on her feet, and without a bonnet decent enough 
 to appear in any congregation under heaven. And these things 
 are all true," said the delegation. 
 
 The rum-seller began to feel indignant and vindictive, and 
 poured out his anathemas on Knapp. " I won't hear that 
 man abused," said Mitchel, one of the men ; " I believe that he 
 is a good man, and that he is doing good in the city. If you 
 abuse him any more, I will leave your house ; and you are 
 afraid of losing your custom." He began to see through these 
 landsharks. But the rum-seller felt so badly, that he kept 
 all the time heaving up, heaving up, and pouring forth his 
 invectives upon the preacher. Mitchel was as good as his 
 word. He rose up, put on his hat, and said, *' I will never 
 drink another drop in your house so long as my name is 
 Mitchel," and left. On the way home, said he, " Why can I 
 not resolve never to drink another drop anywhere? I will 
 do it," said he ; and that night they got up a pledge of total 
 abstinence from intoxicating drinks ; and there began the Wash- 
 iugtouian reform that rolled over the Eastern States, and con- 
 verted hundreds and thousands of inebriates. 
 
 Thus you see how God made the wrath of man to praise him. 
 If it had not been for that old rum-seller damning Knapp, and 
 cursing the Baptists, that great Washingtonian reformation 
 would never have commenced, so far as we can see ; and if so 
 much good could be brought about by their heaping their 
 anathemas upon your unworthy servant, I say, let them curse. 
 
 The God whom we serve, who can turn the hearts of the 
 children of men as the rivers of water are turned, can overrule
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 319 
 
 everything that occurs, for his own glory, and for the best 
 interests of the human family. 
 
 Take an illustration in your own city. When I was preach- 
 ing in the Baptist Tabernacle, in 1840, we felt very desirous, 
 as the house was very capacious (the gallery would seat more 
 than twelve hundred), that all should come and hear the gospel 
 of Jesus Christ preached. We were conscious that circulating 
 handbills, and putting notices in the paper, would avail but 
 little, as men seldom notice these things, or pass them by, and 
 they are soon forgotten. But at length God instigated the devil 
 to go and move on Bennett, and get him to publish a notice of 
 the meeting ; and Bennett sent a reporter into our meetings, 
 and he reported the speeches, and turned them " every which 
 way," and mixed the sentences pell-mell, and made them appear 
 very ludicrous, and some of them very ridiculous ; and Bennett's 
 paper circulated all through the city among all the infidels, and 
 among all the Tammany Hall folks, who took that paper (and 
 they were almost the only ones who did take it). We thus had 
 an advertisement of our meetings. The devil advertised them 
 at his own expense. And when we went over into Jersey City 
 to baptize, we chartered a ferry-boat, and went over by thou- 
 sands ; and Bennett sent over his reporter, and there he got 
 brother Everts pictured out like a clown, and myself like some 
 old chuckle-headed drunkard, and between us two we took the 
 candidates for baptism down into the water, and dipped them in 
 horizontally. The newsboys sold the papers from street to 
 street, and the infidels kept pouring in and pouring in to the 
 meetings to gratify their curiosity. They read such very strange 
 things that they thought that they must come and hear the 
 preacher, and see whether he was an elk or a moose, and how 
 long his horns were. And on they came. 
 
 Among the number was an infidel, who had not been to a 
 meeting in ten years, and who had sworn with an oath that he 
 never would enter the house of God again ; and connected with 
 the oath a wish that, if he did, the roof might fall in and 
 kill him on the spot. He read in the paper what was said
 
 820 SERMONS BY 
 
 about God saving the people by scores and hundreds, and bring- 
 ing them into the glorious liberty of the sons of God. He 
 thought to himself, " I must go once ; I must hear the man 
 once ; " and he came and took a seat in the body slips. Very 
 soon the house was filled to a jam, above and below. Every 
 standing-place was filled, and they were as thick as they could 
 squeeze in. The porch was full full even out into the streets. 
 He sat there, and when the speaker arose and announced his 
 text the house was very still and solemn. He looked upon the 
 right, and saw all around him weeping ; then upon the left, and 
 they were all weeping ; and he began to feel a strange sensation 
 coming over him. Pie looked towards the door, as if he would 
 like to escape, but there was no getting through that crowd. 
 He then looked up to see if the roof was coming down, but the 
 roof moved not. There he sat, as we spoke God's truth from 
 the fulness of our soul. He was melted down and subdued, and 
 induced to come to the seats at the close of the sermon, and 
 was converted to God before he left that house. 
 
 We could not have done th*at but for the devil and wicked 
 men. Though all the rest of the papers in the city had pub- 
 lished our meetings, these infidels would not have come ; but 
 Avhen their old master, the devil, began to advertise them, they 
 thought that it was time to see what was going on. They kept 
 pouring in and pouring in, until there were hundreds and 
 thousands converted throughout the entire city, and the city was 
 convulsed from centre to circumference. Hence God makes the 
 wrath of man to praise him, and restrains the remainder. We 
 see why God lets the wicked live, and why he lets the devil 
 live. 
 
 I can look back upon the time when we, as Christians, really 
 felt grieved when we read about slavery. I had never seen a 
 slave, or a slaveholder, up to the time that I left the Institution 
 at Hamilton. When I read the account, my heart was stirred 
 within me. We prayed and preached, and lectured and wrote, 
 and circulated tracts. We did everything that we could to 
 break their bonds, and let the oppressed go free. We did all
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 321 
 
 that we could to establish the broad principle that all men are 
 free and equal ; that all men had a right to life, liberty, and the 
 pursuit of happiness, according to the laws that God had made 
 for the benefit of the human race. But by all that was said and 
 done we could not reach the slave ; we could not break his 
 bonds. The church and the abolitionists went to the extent of 
 their power, but, in spite of all said and done, slavery was 
 striking its roots down deeper and deeper into the soil, and its 
 dark branches were stretching over all the United States. The 
 government could not stir. We were bound by the constitution, 
 and by the clamors of the Southern people. Between the two, 
 the people of the North were completely hampered. Were it 
 not for the devil and wicked men it would not have been 
 abolished, perhaps, at all. But when Jefferson Davis, Mason 
 and Slidell, and all those leading rebels, stirred up by the devil, 
 sought to extend slavery all through the United States of 
 America, and make all the territories slave territory, when 
 they sought to hold the reins of this republic until they could 
 establish a vast aristocracy, and keep all the power in them- 
 selves, then it was that these leading men accomplished what 
 all the saints in Christendom could not do. God, of course, 
 was standing behind the curtain and pulling the wires, and 
 seeing them dance ; and they danced until they trampled off the 
 chains of the slave. God let them work ; but he overruled this 
 mighty, gigantic rebellion for the accomplishment of a vast 
 amount of good. Eternity alone can tell how much. I rejoice, 
 and I will rejoice, over the terrible conflict, although one of my 
 dear sons fell on the field of battle. 
 
 O God, how majestic are thy ways ! They are a great deep. 
 Who by searching can find out God to perfection? It is a 
 fearful thing to fall into the hands of the living God. Sinner, 
 when you have served your master, the devil, and gone your 
 length, and God has accomplished all the good that he can 
 reach by letting you live, and you fail to repent, the due time 
 comes ; then your foot slides, and you are gone down to the 
 depths of dark condemnation. Then there is no hope.
 
 322 SERMONS BY 
 
 But mark our position. Here we are upon this vastly ex- 
 tended inclined plane ; and at the base of this inclined plane 
 there is a lake burning with fire and brimstone, rolling high 
 and thundering loud. Every now and then one slips in and is 
 dashed into eternity. Away along at the head of this inclined 
 plane the landscape stretches on. Angels look down upon us. 
 Our friends, who have gone before, look down upon us. " I 
 have a father in the promised land." There is a mother in the 
 promised land ; here, a tender-hearted wife, who watered her 
 couch with tears in intercessions to God for her husband ; there 
 are little babes that fell asleep in Jesus, all looking back 
 wistfully, and beckoning us to come up to the promised land. 
 But, alas ! one refuses, and another refuses ; they go on down to 
 the termination of this inclined plane, and are there hurled into 
 perdition. But while standing on the verge of eternal ruin, 
 Jesus condescends to come down from heaven. He passes 
 around on this inclined plane, and says to one and to another, 
 " Will you come to the promised land? Will you come to the 
 land radiant with glory, beaming with liglit ? " He offers you 
 his hand to conduct you up to the promised land. One goes ; 
 another refuses, and perishes. O, my friends, how quickly we 
 shall all be in heaven or in hell ! May God in heaven lead 
 you to see how long his goodness and mercy have endured for 
 you ; but if you despise or neglect, your foot will slide in due 
 time. We call upon you to make haste to turn and be saved. 
 
 We now invite all who wish the prayers of Christians to take 
 these seats. Let all who profess religion, who feel that they 
 need prayer, and wish the prayers of their brethren, come up. 
 Let backsliders come, too. I tell you we are in a dying world ; 
 we are passing away rapidly ; our destiny may hang upon the 
 decision of a single night. I pray you all to come right up and 
 fill these seats.
 
 ELDEJJ JACOB KNAPP. 823 
 
 V. 
 
 THE NEW BIRTH. 
 
 "Make you a new heart and a new spirit" EZEKIEL xviii. 31. 
 
 " Create in me a clean heart, God, and renew a right spirit 
 within me." PSALM li. 10. 
 
 is no discrepancy between these two passages. God 
 JL creates within us a clean heart, and we make to ourselves 
 a new heart. There is both a divine and human agency in 
 every case of conversion. Sometimes greater prominence is 
 given to the divine element in the account of the change ; some- 
 times greater prominence is given to the human element. 
 
 I. Our first inquiry relates to the import of the phrase 
 " new heart," or " clean heart." What is to be understood 
 by it? 
 
 The term " heart" describes the moral activities of the soul, 
 including the affections and the will. The command of God to 
 us is, " Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, 
 mind, might, and strength." And herein he requires us to give 
 to him the supreme and unreserved exercise of our affections 
 and wills. 
 
 Now every unconverted man loves self supremely, and wills 
 to serve, and does serve, self entirely. Whether he gives for 
 religious purposes or withholds, whether he prays or swears, 
 God is left out of his reckoning : self is the supreme object of 
 his affections. If he does a good act, it is not because he loves
 
 324 SERMONS BY 
 
 God, but because he desires to be seen of rnen, or to merit re- 
 ward from God ; if he refrains from performing a good deed, it 
 is because he is under the control of a selfish impulse ; if he 
 swears, it is to gratify a depraved passion ; if he prays, it is 
 from fear of personal suffering. He would, if he could, make 
 himself the moral centre, around whom God, men, and devils 
 should revolve, as planets around the sun. His precious, 
 beloved self is the centre of moral gravity. The glory of God, 
 the interests of his kingdom, the greatest good of the universe, 
 are all overlooked or set aside ; self reigns supreme. 
 
 If unregeuerated sinners were to be admitted into heaven, 
 there would be as many petty kingdoms, and as many little 
 sovereignties, as there were unconverted hearts ; and heaven 
 would be worse than Mexico or South America, where faction 
 is rising up against faction, and demagogues are plotting against 
 and destroying each other. Every man would set up for him- 
 self, and all would unite only in one purpose of assailing and 
 overthrowing the absolute, but righteous " throne and majesty 
 of God." 
 
 Hence we see, then, before God and man can be reconciled, 
 man must have " a new heart." He " must be born again." 
 
 II. In what does the change contemplated consist? 
 
 It does not consist in the creation of any new faculty of the 
 soul. The original properties or elements of the moral nature 
 remain unchanged in those things that are essential to their 
 entity or being. Before regeneration man has the power of 
 understanding, judging, loving, and choosing ; and he has them 
 after regeneration. But the new creature finds that these 
 faculties of the soul have new objects, and take new directions. 
 " Old things have passed away, and, behold, all things have 
 become new." The things he once loved he now hates, and 
 the things he once hated he now loves. 
 
 The word " create," when used to describe regeneration or 
 the new birth, simply means the production of a new character. 
 Thus God says, " Behold, I create Jerusalem a rejoicing, and 
 lier people a joy." He has given her people to understand that
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 325 
 
 he would bring about such a change in their character and con- 
 dition as would make them another people a joy and a 
 rejoicing, instead of a scandal and reproach. 
 
 I defy any man to tell what creation there is, in regeneration, 
 other than the constitution of a new character. A regenerate 
 man is, in his moral identity, the same conscious moral agent ; 
 but in his character, in the drift of his affections, pursuits, and 
 pleasures, he is a " new creature." He loves new objects, is 
 influenced by new motives, is enlightened by new views, 
 delights in new associations, is subject to new laws, rejoices in 
 new joys, and is inspired by new hopes. To all these he was 
 once dead, but now he is alive. His heart was once a heart 
 of stone, now it is a heart of flesh. 
 
 The governing purpose of the soul is changed from supreme 
 love of self, to supreme love of God. It is now in harmony 
 with the laws of God's moral government. It can unite in 
 sympathy and accord with all holy beings in heaven and in 
 earth in expressing holy impulses, obeying the will of God, 
 doing good to his fellows, and praising God and the Lamb. 
 Once self reigned supreme, but now self is lost in God, and 
 God in the soul is " all in all." 
 
 We may enumerate the elements that enter into and consti- 
 tute this change which is called " regeneration" or " new birth. 1 ' 
 First, a change of affections ; second, of purpose ; third, of 
 sentiments ; fourth, of views and feelings ; fifth, of all our 
 relations to God, to man, to the world, and to the devil. 
 
 III. Our third inquiry relates to the manner in which this 
 change is brought about. How is it produced? 
 
 1. I remark, negatively, this change is not brought about, as 
 some suppose, by the irresistible power of the Holy Spirit. I 
 know of no passage in the Bible whose phraseology requires to 
 be construed so as to teach the doctrine that the influences of 
 the Spirit cannot be resisted ; but I know of several which teach 
 very clearly the doctrine that they can be resisted. The Savior 
 said to the Jews, " Ye do always resist the Holy Spirit ; as did 
 your fathers, so do ye." What need is there of the cautions
 
 326 SERMONS BY 
 
 against quenching and grieving the Spirit, if the Spirit cannot 
 be resisted? 
 
 One writer (Toplady, I think) remarks that the sinner can 
 " no more resist the Holy Spirit than he can resist a stroke of 
 lightning." He, like all those who have taken this extreme 
 view, seems to have overlooked entirely the great fact of the 
 combination of the divine and the human agency in the act of 
 regeneration. Those who hold the view of this writer suppose 
 that God regenerates men by the use of arbitary power. 
 
 It is true that God might apply hydraulic or steam power to 
 man, but it would not convert him. Nor would the lightnings 
 of heaven, nor its thunders, convert him. Physical exertion 
 itself is no more adapted to move mind, than moral power is to 
 move matter. But who would thiuk of making a powerful 
 speech, eloquent in arguments, illustrations, and pathos, in 
 order to knock down a stone wall, or to start the sturdy oak 
 from its fastenings. Yet this would be no more unreasonable 
 or absurd than to think of turning mind by physical force. 
 
 Mind can only be moved by motive by moral considerations. 
 Consequently God has filled the Bible with motives to induce 
 men to repent and serve him. Yea, the whole world is teeming 
 with motives, and God has appointed agencies, in all periods, 
 to keep these motives before the people to induce them to break 
 off from their sins and turn to him. Now is it reasonable to 
 suppose that all these motives are to be dispensed with when a 
 soul is to be converted, and the soul is to be wrenched around 
 by merely physical power? by an irresistible force that makes 
 no appeal to the moral faculties of our nature ? 
 
 Why are not souls converted where no Bibles are circulated, 
 no gospel preached, or where no motives are urged? One 
 error always leads to others. Hence those who believe that 
 men are converted by physical force, think that if the sinner 
 can resist the Holy Spirit, it makes him stronger than the 
 Almighty. But it must be understood that in a moral govern- 
 ment the weaker can resist the stronger. Let us suppose that 
 we wish to turn an inebriate from his cups. We send for
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 327 
 
 John B. Gough to try all the powers of his mirthful eloquence 
 upon him, but he cannot move him. We try the skill and 
 moral power of a Spurgeon, or any other distinguished speaker, 
 in order to bring to bear upon him all the motives drawn from 
 heaven, earth, and hell, to induce him to abandon his cups ; but 
 none of all these appeals can move him. But does this fact 
 prove that this inebriate is stronger than any of these men, or 
 all of them together? No. What, then, does it prove? It 
 proves that the subject upon whom they have plied their power 
 was so debased, so much under the power of his cups, that he 
 could resist all arguments, from all sources, however powerful. 
 In like manner the sinner is so depraved, so much under the 
 control of the love and power of sin, that he can resist the 
 Holy Spirit ; a straw will carry him on in the current of his 
 own debased inclinations, but neither the pleadings of his wife, 
 the eloquence of his children, the arguments of the minister, the 
 influence of the Spirit, the hope of heaven, or the fear of hell, 
 will induce him to turn ; " he loves darkness rather than light, 
 because his deeds are evil." " Ye will not come unto me that 
 ye might have life." 
 
 2. This change is not wrought by the Spirit's tucking some- 
 thing into the sinner, back of his will, to give direction to it. 
 This would take all obligation to repent from the sinner, until 
 this certain something was put within him. 
 
 But it is said, though the sinner has lost his ability to obey 
 God, that God has not lost his right or power to command. I 
 reply, that if the sinner has lost his ability to repent, and can- 
 not repent until God restores that ability, then the sinner is 
 tinder no obligation to repent without a capacity to do so ; and 
 God, as a reasonable being, would not require it. It would 
 not be possible to make an intelligent being feel guilty for not 
 doing that which was out of his power to do. 
 
 Suppose a man sent his servant for a pitcher of water, and 
 that the servant, from mere ugliness, breaks the pitcher, and 
 thereby incapacitates himself to bring the water ; would the 
 master be justifiable in demanding the water unless he supply
 
 328 SERMONS BY 
 
 some vessel in which to bring it? Sin-ely not. He might be 
 justifiable in punishing the servant for breaking the pitcher, but 
 not for refusing to bring the water when it was out of his 
 power to do so. So God might punish the sinner for all 
 violations of law ; but if he has lost his capacity to repent or 
 believe, or to come to Christ, or submit to God, then neither 
 God nor any reasonable moral agent would blame him for not 
 doing so. 
 
 But this capacity is not lost. Hence God commands all men 
 everywhere to repent ; and their guilt in not believing in Christ, 
 and not coming to God through him, is so great, that it is the 
 damning sin of the world. It casts all other sins into the 
 shade ; "of sin, because ye believe not in me." God comes 
 out in his word and addresses all men as moral agents capable of 
 obeying him, and pleads, commands, and threatens them in case 
 they do not obey. 
 
 When I came out of the Institution at Hamilton, N. Y., in 
 which I studied theology under the instruction of the lamented 
 Dr. Nathaniel Kendrick (a better man than whom seldom lived), 
 I went to work with the old theory of physical regeneration, 
 and would often come in contact with an intelligent man who 
 had been religiously educated, who would take ground like 
 this : " I want to be a Christian ; I desire it above all things ; 
 but the prayers of the wicked are an abomination in the sight 
 of the Lord ; and as no good thing can come out of a bad 
 heart, I cannot repent nor believe until God changes my 
 heart." There he was, waiting for God to come and convert 
 or regenerate him. I could not meet this honest and intelligent 
 inquirer with my erroneous views of the new birth. Hence I 
 was compelled to investigate, analyze, and search the Scriptures 
 more critically, until the subject became as clear as a sunbeam. 
 
 3. Nor is there any miracle in making a new heart. It is 
 mysterious, and to us incomprehensible ; but there is no 
 suspension or counteraction of any of the laws of nature. God 
 moves upon the human soul in accordance with the laws of 
 mind, and in accordance with the distinctive laws of each
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 329 
 
 individual mind, and makes the sinner willing not able in 
 the day of his power. The will surrenders, the heart yields, 
 the conflict ends, sin is pardoned, and the soul is saved. 
 
 IV. By what agencies is this work accomplished ? 
 
 We answer, " The Spirit and the bride say, Come." Nor is 
 the agency of the soul itself dispensed with in a single instance. 
 The bride embraces the whole sacramental host of God's elect. 
 
 The ministers of the gospel are commissioned to go and teach, 
 i. e., disciple, or convert, all nations. Nor are they sent out 
 alone. This one agency of itself would not be sufficient to con- 
 vert a single soul ; hence Christ says, " Lo, I am with you 
 alway, even unto the end of the world." 
 
 The sinner is so dead to all spiritual things that man cannot 
 quicken him into action ; so blind that man cannot lead him to 
 see ; hence Christ Jesus, by the Holy Spirit, accompanies the 
 faithful ambassador, and both agencies are combined ; and then 
 the sinner is required to use his agency to repent, to believe, to 
 come to Christ, to submit to God ; and without this repentance, 
 this receiving of Christ by faith, this exercising of his own 
 agency, he cannot make a new heart, cannot be converted. All 
 these agencies are employed in the conversion of the soul. It 
 is proper, therefore, for God to say, in the language of my text, 
 " Make unto you a new heart ; " and it is right for us to pray, 
 " Create in me a clean heart, and renew a right spirit with- 
 in me." Inasmuch as all these agencies are employed in the 
 conversion of the soul, the change is sometimes ascribed to one 
 of them and sometimes to another. 
 
 How often the new birth is ascribed to human agency ! 
 " Whom I have begotten in Christ Jesus." " I have begotten 
 you through the gospel." 1 Cor. iv. 15. Paul speaks of Timothy 
 and Onesimus as his own sons, whom he had begotten ; that is, 
 God had used his agency in begetting and giving birth to 
 these souls, and that, too, through, or by, the gospel, as the in- 
 strumentality. 
 
 Conversion is sometimes ascribed to the agency of the sin- 
 ner himself. " Seeing ye have purified your souls in obeying 
 23
 
 330 SERMONS BY 
 
 the truth." 1 Pet. i. 22. In the text the wicked are commanded 
 to make unto themselves a new heart ; and all the directions to 
 repent, to turn, to believe, to submit, to come to Christ, are 
 proofs positive that the sinner's agency is not suspended in con- 
 version that his eternal destiny turns upon his will. "Who- 
 soever will, let him come unto me and take of the water of 
 life." " Ye will not come unto me that ye might have life." 
 " How often would I have gathered your children together, but 
 ye would not ! " This damning will not keeps millions out of 
 heaven, and is all the time populating hell. 
 
 Then this change is still more frequently ascribed to the 
 Spirit, because the agency of the Spirit is more prominent, 
 more efficacious, than all the other agencies put together. It is 
 not possible for man so to illumine the mind, so to soften the 
 heart, and convince of sin, as to bring the sinner into subjection 
 to the divine will. It is not possible, without the influences of 
 the Holy Spirit, to bring all the motives presented in the word 
 of God to bear with sufficient clearness and cogency upon tho 
 heart of the sinner to induce a full surrender. 
 
 Hence the Spirit is given to convince " of sin, of righteous- 
 ness, and of judgment to come." Consequently we are told 
 of the " washing of regeneration, and the renewing of the Holy 
 Spirit." " Born of the Spirit." " You hath he quickened who 
 were dead in trespasses and sins." 
 
 Now, to harmonize all these agencies, and make the subject 
 perfectly plain to all, we will suppose a man walking along, in a 
 dark night, upon the brink of a precipice, unconscious of his 
 whereabouts or his danger. He nears the verge ; it is five hun- 
 dred feet to the bottom : just as he raises his foot to step off, a 
 voice rings along the abyss and breaks upon his ear " STOP ! " 
 At the same moment a man opens a lantern, and pours a stream 
 of light upon his path, by which he discovers his danger : he 
 springs back, and is saved. 
 
 The next day he steps into a store, and relates his marvellous 
 escape, and says, " Just as I was taking the fatal step, a light 
 shone upon my footsteps, by means of which I discovered my
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 831 
 
 danger, and I was saved. Blessed be God for that light." 
 Here he ascribes his deliverance to the light. In relating the 
 circumstance to another person, he says, " Just as I had raised 
 my foot, and was about taking the fatal step, a voice broke upon 
 my e ar ' STOP, STOP ! ' Thank God for that word. O, how 
 it rings in my ears now ! But for that word I should have been a 
 dead man." Here he ascribes his deliverance to the word stop. 
 The neighborhood is excited, and keep coming in, and want to 
 hear all the circumstances over again. He proceeds to repeat 
 them ; when he comes to his approach to the very verge of the 
 precipice, he says, " My left foot stood on the edge of the rock, 
 and as I had raised my right foot, and was about to take the 
 fatal step, a light shone on my path, a voice cried ' Stop ! ' and 
 I sprang back in an instant. I had well nigh lost my balance ; 
 but if I did not use the muscles and springs in my body once, 
 why then I never did ; and I am safe." 
 
 Now, that sinners all stand on a dangerous precipice is cer- 
 tain ; and it is equally certain that they are not conscious of their 
 danger. " They stand on slippery rocks, and fiery billows roll 
 below." 
 
 The man of God lifts his warning voice, and cries, " Stop ! " 
 The Holy Spirit sheds the light of truth upon his benighted 
 mind, and shows him his condition ; but all this will not save 
 him if he fails to put forth his own exertion ; but if he em- 
 ploys his own agency and turns, he is saved. Now it is obvi- 
 ous that he saved himself ; it is equally true that the minister 
 saved him, and that the truth saved him, and his salvation is 
 all of the Lord. God furnished the truth, commissioned all the 
 agencies, and made them successful by the illuminating and con- 
 straining influences of the Holy Spirit. God says, " Make you 
 a new heart, and be conscious of your weakness and dependence." 
 Cry out, " Create in me a clean heart, and renew a right spirit 
 within me." 
 
 It may be asked, How can an enemy of God, a hater of 
 holiness, a lover of sin, on this principle become a lover of 
 holiness, a hater of sin, ajd the fast friend of God? I answer,
 
 332 SERMONS BY 
 
 God, by all the agencies and instrumentalities referred to above, 
 leads the sinner to see his guilt and apprehend his danger ; to 
 discover that in all this conflict God is right, and that he is 
 wrong ; that God is too mighty for him to contend with and 
 prosper. He may stand out and perish, or he may lay down 
 his weapons, and surrender all into God's hands, and abide his 
 pleasure. 
 
 When sinners make this surrender, God pardons. They now 
 see that God has been their best Friend ; has only opposed them 
 in a course of sin, which was likely, yea, certain, to prove their 
 ruin ; that he has so loved them as to give his only-begotten 
 Son to die for them, that they might not perish, but have ever- 
 lasting life. They love him. They adore him. All the graces 
 of the Christian spring up in the soul. They are new creatures. 
 This is conversion. They have a new heart. Take an illus- 
 tration in the late rebellion. The mass of the Southern people 
 vindicated slavery ; almost made themselves believe that it was 
 right. They hated the Northern people, because they opposed 
 them in this thing. Their opposition and enmity to the North 
 continued to increase until it culminated in open rebellion. They 
 took up arms, and went into the terrible conflict, for which they 
 were not equal. At length they found that they must surrender 
 or do worse : they laid down their arms ; they gave themselves 
 up to the government which they had opposed, and some of them 
 became truly penitent. Many of this latter class were led to see 
 that slavery was a system of iniquity which God meant to over- 
 throw, and that the North were right, and that they were wrong. 
 Now, where this conversion was thorough, their penitence was 
 genuine, and they became truly loyal. Every man at the North 
 or South, or the world over, who is worthy to be called a man, 
 could forgive with all his heart, and receive them to his bosom. 
 It would be perfectly safe to pardon all such persons, and re- 
 store them to confidence and to office ; and the more these once 
 haters of the government and its policy see and know of its 
 clemency and uprightness, the willingness, nay, the desire, of 
 our lamented President, as well as the government as a whole, to
 
 ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 333 
 
 show them all the mercy and favor in their power, Avith safety 
 to the country at large, the more will they love and admire the 
 character and conduct of the government. But we must bear 
 in mind that God's character and government are perfect ; all 
 others human, and consequently imperfect ; and that God has 
 done infinitely more for us than any earthly government has 
 done or can do, and, as a matter of course, our love to him is 
 supreme. 
 
 REFLECTIONS. 
 
 1. This view of conversion makes God the author of salva- 
 tion, and man the author of damnation. 
 
 God gave his Son to die as an atonement for sin, and has 
 furnished all the motives to induce men to repent, and called 
 and commissioned all the agencies of men and angels to keep 
 these motives before the people, and has given the Holy Spirit - 
 to make these motives effectual. And if they turn and live, God 
 has turned them ; and if saved, God has saved them ; and be- 
 cause the sinner turns voluntarily, and accepts the gospel, he 
 merits nothing, any more than a starving man merits something 
 because he eats voluntarily when his benefactor sets food before 
 him, and invites him to eat without money and without price ; 
 or than does the condemned prisoner merit his freedom because 
 he accepts the pardon when offered to him. 
 
 On the other hand, man is responsible for his destruction. 
 He is not lost because he was brought into the world with a 
 sinful nature, nor because God did not take him by physical 
 force and wrench him around, but because he wilfully rejected 
 the offer of pardon ; because he neglected the great salvation ; 
 because he stood up against all the motives and all the agencies 
 employed by God to save him. After God had provided the 
 feast, and given out the invitation, he made light of it, and is 
 lost ; not, I say, because he is a sinner, but because he rejected 
 the Friend and Savior of sinners. 
 
 2. This theory of conversion is as much more beautiful than 
 the old theory, and reflects as much more glory upon Deity, as
 
 834 SERMONS BY ELDER JACOB KNAPP. 
 
 a moral government is superior to that government which con- 
 trols the material world, or as mind is superior to matter. If 
 mind were controlled by force, there would be no more happi- 
 ness or worth in serving God, than the water-wheel experiences 
 or possesses when it yields to the hydraulic power, or the grind- 
 stone when turning under the pressure of the crank. Nor 
 would the praises of the millions on earth and in heaven reflect 
 any more glory upon God than the millions of worlds by which 
 he is surrounded. 
 
 3. This view of the subject strikes sceptics dumb, and knocks 
 out the underpinning of Universalism. 
 
 The old theory represents God as an arbitrary being, saving 
 one because it is his pleasure to do so, and damning another 
 for the same reason, without any regard to their character or 
 conduct. This view of the subject represents him as a kind and 
 merciful Father, delighting not in the death of him that dieth, 
 but doing all that can be done, upon the principles of a moral 
 government, to save all, and as sending the wicked into hell 
 because they cannot be reformed, because they will not come to 
 Christ, that they might have life. 
 
 It seems as if almost any person of ordinary capacities could 
 not help seeing the absurdity of the distinction between the 
 saved and the lost, if this distinction arises not from their char- 
 acter x but from the arbitrary pleasure of Deity. And when this 
 sentiment is taught, the Universalist concludes that if the salva- 
 tion of any turns upon the arbitrary pleasure of God, without 
 any regard to character or conduct, it will be the pleasure of 
 God to save all, and that all will be saved. But when they are 
 led to see that man is a moral agent, accountable for every 
 action, capable of obeying or of disobeying God, and that he 
 cannot be forced into subjection, but must turn voluntarily, 
 and that the only reason why they are not saved is because they 
 will not be saved, because they will not submit to the only 
 terms upon which it is possible for them to be saved, they are 
 speechless. Their underpinning gives way, and they must 
 settle down upon the Rock of Ages, or go down amid the sink- 
 ing sands, and confess that their damnation is just.
 
 APPENDIX. 
 
 STATISTICAL RESULTS OF ELDER KNAPPS LABORS IN 
 MASSACHUSETTS.* 
 
 THE following examination and calculations on the results of the labors 
 of Elder JACOB KNAPP, in the State of Massachusetts, were made in the 
 autumn of 1846 ; at which time there seemed to prevail a general im- 
 pression, at least in the Baptist denomination, that the effects of his labors 
 with the churches were anything but salutary. The pulpit and the press 
 proclaimed the "disastrous results," such as "spurious converts," 
 "excommunications," "unsettling ministers," "dividing churches," and 
 the like. The spirit so prevailed with the clergy, that it was rare to hear 
 an occasional sermon or an addresser even a Sabbath school essay^ but 
 it would contain a direct or indirect missile at " the revival," or its 
 " measures." We conscientiously believe ministers and writers were 
 not aware to what extent their minds were led by the spirit of the 
 times. 
 
 While these things were thus passing, it occurred to us, " Is it so ? " 
 Are these statements and representations facts, or are they spectres of 
 the imagination? Instead, therefore, of following the multitude, and 
 crying, " Away with such a fellow from the earth," we quietly retired 
 to our domicile, and examined our documents carefully, " whether these 
 things were so." And we are compelled to say, we were surprised at 
 the results. We found our own mind had been borne away by the tide 
 of public influence to an extent we could hardly have believed. 
 
 Our examinations then extended to four years inclusive ; commencing 
 with the Associational year of the Evangelist's labors in each church ; 
 
 * An Examination of the Comparative Statistical Results of the Labors of Elder 
 Jacob Knapp in the State of Massachusetts. By A. WILBUR. Boston. 1855. 
 
 (335)
 
 3-36 APPENDIX. 
 
 including that and the three successive years. The following was the 
 result : 
 
 Mr. Knapp commenced his labors in Massachusetts with the Baptist 
 church in New Bedford, in the Taunton Association, in the summer of 
 1841. That church, during the four consecutive years, baptized 262, 
 and excommunicated in the same time 28, or about 10 per cent, on her 
 baptisms. All the other churches in that Association, taken together, 
 in the same four years, baptized 488, and excommunicated 105, or 
 nearly 22 per cent, on their baptisms. 
 
 At the end of the four years, the church in New Bedford had gained 
 in numerical strength 205, or 80J per cent, on her former number. All 
 the other churches in the Association had gained in the same time 284, 
 or 18^ per cent, on their former number. 
 
 The church in New Bedford, separately, and the other churches, col- 
 lectively, have excluded annually about an equal proportion, compared 
 with their numbers, viz., averaging about l per cent, on their whole 
 number. 
 
 His next labors in the state were in the Boston Association. Here 
 they were mostly confined to five churches in the city of Boston. Two 
 of the city churches did not invite him into their pulpits. One of these, 
 with its pastor, was decidedly unfriendly to the whole movement, from 
 beginning to end. 
 
 Those five churches where Mr. Knapp labored, baptized, during the 
 four years, 1054 persons, and excommunicated 158, or 15 per cent, on 
 their baptisms. 
 
 All the other churches in the Boston Association, taken together, bap- 
 tized in the same time 1775, and excluded 336, or nearly 19 per cent, on 
 their baptisms. 
 
 The two churches in the city where Mr. Knapp did not labor, baptized 
 122, and excluded 36, or 29 per cent, on their baptisms. 
 
 The church that was unfavorable, and took no interest in the move- 
 ment, baptized 22, excluded 12, or 54i per cent, on her baptisms. All 
 these churches, thus separately classed, have excommunicated, on an 
 average, annually, within a fraction of li per cent, on their whole 
 numbers. 
 
 The five churches where the Evangelist labored have gained in nu- 
 merical strength in the four years 904 members, or 51 per cent. All 
 the others in the Association, together, have gained 670, or a little over 
 13-i per cent. 
 
 The two churches in the city, above named, taken separate, in the 
 same time have lost in number 72, or 8| per cent, on their former 
 numbers. 
 
 The next labors of this Evangelist in the state were in the Salem
 
 APPENDIX. 337 
 
 Association. Here also they were mostly had with five churches, viz., 
 three in Lowell, the Second Church in Salem, and the church in Mar- 
 blehead ; although Ms labors in Marblehead were small compared with 
 those of the other four churches. These five churches, during four 
 years, commencing with the year of his labors, baptized 817, and ex- 
 cluded 143, or a little over 17 per cent, on then* baptisms. 
 
 All the other churches in that Association in the same time baptized 
 669, and excommunicated 207, or 31 per cent, on their baptisms. These 
 five churches also have excluded annually, on an average, about 1J per 
 cent, on their whole numbers. The other churches a mere fraction over. 
 
 The five churches have gained in the four years 608 members, or 26 
 per cent. The other churches gained in the same tune 198, or a frac- 
 tion less than 6 per cent. 
 
 These examinations, aa before said, were made after the close of the four 
 years ; and they show to every candid mind, that the constantly reiter- 
 ated complaints of " spurious converts," " numerous exclusions," &c., 
 having reference to the Evangelist's labors, were without a shadow of 
 foundation. But, on the contrary, the churches where he did not labor 
 excluded many more, in comparison with their receptions, than those with 
 whom he did, and each class about an equal proportion to their whole 
 numbers. 
 
 We stated these facts, at the time, to several brethren, who said the 
 public ought to have them ; and at one time we fully concluded to pub- 
 lish them, but were deterred for reasons that will be given hereafter. 
 
 A few months since, a friend, who learned we had some facts relating 
 to Mr. Knapp's labors, asked the loan of them. Our attention being 
 thus again called to the subject, we concluded to extend the comparison 
 throughout the state ; and although the examination absorbed more time 
 than we knew how to spare, yet we pursued it, and arrived at the follow- 
 ing results : 
 
 It will be remembered Mr. Knapp labored with eleven churches in 
 this state ; one in the Taunton Association, five in the Boston, and five 
 in the Salem Associations. The results of these labors were reported 
 in three Associations! years, viz., 1841, '42, and '43. In making up the 
 aggregate of baptisms, &c., of the other churches in the state, the inter- 
 mediate year of 1842 is taken as the year of commencement. 
 
 The eleven churches, then, where he labored, commencing in these 
 churches with the year of his labors, as will be seen above, baptized 
 in four years 2133, and excluded 329, or a little over 15 per cent, on 
 their baptisms. All the other churches in the state, taken together, 
 baptized in the same time 6746, and excommunicated 1578, or 23J per 
 cent, on their baptisms. 
 
 Having recently showed the above to a brother, he suggested the ide
 
 338 APPENDIX. 
 
 of extending the comparison still farther. Wishing to make our exam- 
 inations as satisfactory and conclusive as possible, we concluded to con- 
 tinue them for four years more, so as to include eight years ; supposing 
 any further calculations would be needless, as all influences for good or 
 for evil would not extend beyond this. 
 
 In the eight years there had been added to the Associations in the 
 state 42 churches, containing 3394 members. These are mostly new 
 churches ; some few are churches of some years' existence, but have 
 recently united with the Associations. These 42 churches are not in- 
 cluded in the following calculations, only the churches which existed 
 at the commencement of 1842. The propriety of this will be seen when 
 it is remembered these new churches are made up from all the churches 
 in the state, assisted in some instances by members from other states ; 
 and if their statistics were included, their whole influence would be 
 thrown on the side of the churches in the state in 1842. Leaving out 
 the new churches, and deducting the eleven in which the Evangelist 
 labored, there remained in the state, at the commencement of 1842, 193 
 churches. Between these and the eleven the comparison is made. 
 
 We find then, in eight years inclusive, the eleven churches baptized 
 2625, and excommunicated 613, or 23 per cent, on their baptisms. The 
 193 other churches in the state, in the same time, baptized 8673, and 
 excommunicated 2456, or 28J per cent, on their baptisms. The original 
 number in the eleven churches was 3984. They had gained in the eight 
 years 1266, or nearly 31 per cent. 
 
 The original number in the 193 churches was 21,432. They had gained 
 in eight years 254, or a little more than 1 per cent. 
 
 This discrepancy of gain being so great, it occurred to us, perhaps the 
 193 churches had been more largely drawn upon to form new churches. 
 So, again, we betook ourselves to the task of examining the dismissions, 
 and found the following result : 
 
 The eleven churches, in the eight years, have dismissed to other 
 churches, and to form new ones, 1543 members, or nearly 33i per cent. 
 on their average numbers. 
 
 The other churches in the same time have dismissed 6403, or nearly 
 30 per cent, on their average numbers. 
 
 So we found the eleven churches had done their full share, according 
 to their numbers, in contributing in membership to build new churches. 
 
 We have given the facts ; let them speak for themselves. They have 
 been gathered from official documents, examined and compared with 
 much care and labor, and, we think, may be relied on. 
 
 Any way one may look at the eleven churches, compared with the 
 others, either of their Associations or of the whole state, they show 
 themselves on the advantage ground.
 
 APPENDIX. 839 
 
 Now, suppose the result to have proved just the reverse, us has 
 been represented, and is to this day supposed to be the fact by the com- 
 munity. "We say, suppose these eleven churches had appeared com- 
 paratively to as great disadvantage as they do to advantage ; what might, 
 with propriety, nay, what would be said? We offer no comments. 
 
 But, it will be asked by some, why bring these things out at this late 
 period ? (and we shall look for censure from a certain class) why 
 were they not given to the public while the subject was before the peo- 
 ple's mind ? To this we answer, first, as before said, when the examina- 
 tion of the first four years was finished, we showed the results to several 
 brethren, who strongly advised to publish them. We concluded to do 
 BO, but took occasion to show them to two brethren who were unfriendly 
 to the revival movement, and spared not to speak against it. We chose 
 to see what effect it would have. 
 
 After carefully reading our document through, they handed it back, 
 saying, "Well, what of all that? IT PROVES NOTHING. If they (the con- 
 verts) are not excluded, there are hundreds who ought to be." 
 
 It appeared to have no effect to suggest to their minds the possibility 
 that they might be in an error. We were convinced that the public 
 mind generally, at least in our denomination, was BO fixed, that evidence 
 on this subject, however conclusive, had lost its power. 
 
 Second, our attention has recently been called to the subject, as we 
 said, It was again suggested that " these facts ought to be given to the 
 public." We concluded also that the public mind, generally (not in all 
 cases), is now so unbiassed that men can look at facts impartially, and 
 give them their due weight. 
 
 Another incentive to publish was, that probably these lines would fall 
 into the hands of many desponding disciples, who, for some years past, 
 have been exercised somewhat as probably most of Christ's numerous 
 disciples were, when the news spread over Palestine that " Jesus of 
 Nazareth was crucified." Their meditations have been, " What did all 
 this mean ? " " We verily thought we were exercised by true religion." 
 " If this is spurious, is not all religion spurious? " " If these converts 
 are mostly spurious converts, am not I such ? and are not all such ? " 
 or " Where is the evidence of the true? " and the like. We met with 
 many such, and endeavored to comfort them, by assuring them that the 
 generally received reports concerning those revivals were not true, and 
 that, so far as our knowledge extended, the converts of those revivals 
 were, considering their numbers, as true and lasting as any converts of 
 any revival we ever witnessed. We have sometimes thought, perhaps, 
 for the sake of such disciples, it was a mistake not to have published 
 before.
 
 APPENDIX. 
 
 We will now propose a question to the reader of this pamphlet in 
 Massachusetts. 
 
 Admitting that the revivals in 1841 and 184:2 were as really the genu- 
 ine operations of the Holy Spirit as have been any revivals since the 
 apostles' days, and let the same course be pursued as was pursued by 
 the ministry, the press, and the laity, towards the means, the measures, 
 and the converts ; might we not reasonably suppose it would legitimately 
 produce precisely the state of things in the churches as was found in 
 1844, '45, and '46? 
 
 There is something unaccountable in men, good men, pious men, with 
 reference to evidence of the operations of the Holy Spirit. No matter 
 how judicious, candid, or pious (or all of these combined) a man may 
 be, and no matter how the Spirit may be operating, if from any cause 
 his mind happen to take a turn against those operations, there seems to 
 come over him a moral mist or darkness that wholly disables him to 
 receive evidence in favor of the Spirit's power. Evidence that would 
 be abundant and conclusive in any other case, is no evidence in this ; or 
 it is sometimes perverted, and becomes evidence against instead of in 
 favor. We think we have observed this in many instances in the course 
 of our pilgrimage, and in several have detected it in ourself. Never 
 have we seen this indefinable, what shall we call it? delusive mys- 
 ticism ! no, that does not convey our idea ; and we know no words in 
 our circumscribed vocabulary that will. It is an indescribable some- 
 thing that comes over the mind and perverts the judgment on this par- 
 ticular subject, and affects no other. We say, we never saw it prevail 
 in our denomination as it did in 1844, '45, and '46, in regard to. the re- 
 vivals of 1842. Inferences were drawn from false premises, and given 
 forth to the public as true. Statements were made, and sent out, directly 
 contrary to facts. Reports, almost innumerable, were circulated, which 
 had no shadow of foundation ; and some of the above were from good, 
 well-meaning men, who intended no misrepresentation, but verily thought 
 they spoke and wrote truth. Our charity for the Jewish Council which 
 sat in Jerusalem in the year 29, with Caiaphas in the chair, was enlarged 
 fifty per cent. ; and never before did we so fully understand the spirit 
 of that prayer, "Father, forgive them; they know not what they do." 
 It would be endless and useless to revert to these statements and rumors, 
 and then show their unreliableness ; but for the sake of showing how 
 easily a good man may slide into an error, and unintentionally misstate 
 things, perhaps we may be permitted to name one fact. 
 
 In 1844 (it might have been in '45), a pastor in this city wrote to a 
 distant body, that the people of his charge " had so lost their confidence 
 in him (Mr. Knapp), that not twenty of his church would hear him 
 preach unless he was a reformed man." We heard that such had been
 
 APPENDIX. 341 
 
 written. It so happened, a short time after this, Mr. Knapp was to 
 preach on a Sabbath evening in the Tremont Temple ; we attended the 
 lecture, and sat on the side of the hall, where we could see to reccgnize 
 about half of the congregation ; and seeing quite a number present from 
 that church, we had the curiosity to count them, and we saw fifty-two 
 from that church whom we knew. As the congregation was passing 
 out, a prominent member of that church came by, whom we asked if 
 there were not more than twenty members of his church present. " Yes," 
 said he, " more than a hundred." And we verily believe he spoke the 
 truth. 
 
 We have named this circumstance only to show facts. We well know 
 that pastor, and will say no one holds a higher place in our Christian 
 affection than he. Further, we are ready to bear testimony that he will 
 not intentionally misrepresent. But such was the general impression, 
 and he imbibed it so strongly that he felt assured he stated the truth. 
 
 May we venture an opinion? and whether correct or not, we are 
 confident it would be supported by a large proportion of that church. 
 Our opinion is, that there has not been a time since he labored in Bos- 
 ton, that any other man in the United States could call together a greater 
 number of that church, to hear a sermon, than Mr. KNAPP.
 
 STANDARD AND MISCELLANEOUS BOOKS. 7 
 
 & 
 
 Classical Manual. By JAMES S. S. BAIKD, 
 F.C.D. One vol., 16mo. Price, cloth, 90 cte. 
 
 It is an epitome of Aacient Geography, Greek and Roman 
 Mythology, Antiquitit^ and Chronology. 
 
 Croquet as played jj "The Newport Croquet 
 Club." By ONB, OF THE MEMBERS. 16mo. Price, 
 paper, 25 cts. ; cloth, 50 cts. 
 
 " This manual is the only one which really grapples with 
 a difficult case, and deals with it as if heaven and earth 
 depended on the adjudication." Atlantic Monthly. 
 
 Jlelps to the ^Pulpit. Sketches and Skeletons of 
 Sermons. One vol., large 12mo. Price, $2.00. 
 
 "Here is a work that may be a help by its proper use, or a 
 hindrance by its abuse." Christian Messenger. 
 
 Pulpit Themes and Preacher's Assistant. 
 
 By the author of " Helps to the Pulpit." One voL, 
 large 12mo. Price, $2.00. 
 
 " We have no doubt but that it will be a welcome book to 
 every candidate for the ministry, and also to pastors in almost 
 every congregation." Lutheran Herald. 
 
 A Text-33oofc of the ITistory of Christian 
 ^Doctrines. By K. E. HAGENBACH, Professor of 
 Theology in the University of Basle. The Edin- 
 burgh translation of C. W. Buch, revised, with 
 large Additions from the fourth German Edition, 
 and other sources, by HENBY B. SMITH, D.D., Pro- 
 fessor in the Union Theological Seminary of the 
 City of New York. Two vols., octavo. Price, 
 cloth, $6.00. 
 
 " It exceeds, in point of completeness, every other treatise, 
 English as well as German, and we have, therefore, no hesi- 
 tation in calling it the most perfect manual of the History of 
 Christian Doctrines which Protestant literature has as yet 
 produced." Methodist, N. T.
 
 SHELDON 4 COMPANY'S 
 
 jBibtical Commentary on the New Testament. 
 By Dr. HEBMAKH OLSHAUSEN. Continued after his 
 death by Ebrard and Wiesinger. Carefully revised, 
 after the last German Edition, by A, C. KZXDEICS, 
 D.D., Greek Professor in the University of Koch- 
 ester. Sis vols., large octavo. Price, cloth, $18.00. 
 
 " I regard the Commentary as the most valuable of those 
 on the New Testament in the TgngHah language, happily 
 combining the religious spirit of the English expositors with 
 the critical learning of the German. The American editor 
 has evidently performed his task well, as might be expected 
 from his eminent qualifications." President Seart, of Brown 
 University. 
 
 The Annotated Paragraph JBibte. According 
 to the authorized version, arranged in Paragraphs 
 
 and Parallelisms, with Explanatory Notes, Prefaces 
 to the several Books, and an entirely new Selection 
 of References to Parallel and Illustrative Passages. 
 An issue of the London Religious Tract Society, 
 republished. Complete in one royal octavo volume, 
 with Maps, &c. Price, library sheep, $8.00. 
 
 2%e Annotated Paragraph New Testament* 
 In one octavo volume, uniform style. Price, mus- 
 lin, $2.50. 
 
 I have carefully examined a considerable portion of the 
 work, and consider it eminently adapted to increase and dif- 
 fuse a knowledge of the Word of God. I heartily recommend 
 it to Christians of every denomination, and especially to 
 teachers of Bible Classes and Sabbath Schools, to whom it 
 will prove an invaluable aid." -Rev. Dr. Wayland. 
 
 2ho?uc& on the Gospel of John. Translated by 
 CHAELES J. KP.AUTH, D.D. One vol., octavo. Price, 
 $3.00. 
 
 " We hail with much pleasure the appearance of Kraath's 
 translation of ' Tholuck on the Gospel of John.' We trust 
 the work, in this its English dress, will find a wide circula- 
 tion." BOblwthcea Sacra.
 
 STANDARD AND MISCELLANEOUS BOOKS. 
 
 Neander's ^Planting and Training of the 
 Christian Church by the Apostles. Trans- 
 lated from the German by J. E. RYLAND. Trans- 
 lation revised and corrected according to the fourth 
 German edition. By E. G. ROBINSON, D.D., Pro- 
 fessor in the Rochester Theological Seminary. One 
 vol., octavo, cloth. Price, $4.00. 
 
 "The patient scholarship, the critical sagacity, and the 
 simple and unaffected piety of the author, are manifest 
 throughout. Such a history should find a place in the library 
 of every one who seeks a familiar knowledge of the early 
 shaping of the Christian Churches. An excellent index adds 
 to its value." Evangelist. 
 
 Ziible Illustrations. Being a Store-house of Simi- 
 lies, Allegories, and Anecdotes with an introduc- 
 tion by RICHARD NEWTON, D.D. One vol., 12mo. 
 Price, $1.50. Every Sabbath School teacher should 
 have this book. 
 
 " It is impossible not to commend a book like this." Ed- 
 itor of Encyc. of Religious Knowledge. 
 
 " We think that Sabbath School teachers especially would 
 be profited by reading it ; and many of the anecdotes will 
 help to point the arrow of the preacher." Christian Herald. 
 
 SPURGEON'S WORKS. 
 
 Sermons of the Her. C. IT. Spurgion, of Lon- 
 don, in uniform styles of binding. 
 
 First Series. With an Introduction and Sketch of his Life, by 
 the Rev. E. L. MAGOON, D.D. With a fine steel-plate Por- 
 trait. One vol., 12mo., pp. 400. Price, $1.50. 
 
 Second Series. Revised by the Author, and published with 
 his sanction. Containing a new steel-plate Portrait, engraved 
 expressly for the volume. Price, $1.50. 
 
 Third Series. Revised by the Author, and published with his 
 sanction. Containing a steel-plate view of Surrey Music 
 Hall, London, engraved expressly for the volume. Price, $1.50.
 
 10 SHELDON & COMPANY'S 
 
 SPURGEON'S WORKS.-Continued. 
 
 fourth Seines. Revised by the Author, and published with 
 his sanction. Containing twenty-six Sermons, pp. 450. 
 Price, $1.50. 
 
 Fifth Series. Revised by the Author, and published with his 
 sanction. Illustrated with a fine steel plate representing the 
 Rev. C. H. Spurgeon preaching in Surrey Music HalL One 
 vol., 12mo. Price, $1.50. 
 
 Sixth Series. Revised by the Author, and published with his 
 sanction. Illustrated with a fine steel plate of Mr. Spurgeon's 
 new Tabernacle. One vol., 12mo. Price, $1.50. 
 
 Seventh Series. Containing some of Mr. Spurgeon's later and 
 more brilliant Sermons. One vol., 12mo. Price, $1.50. 
 
 Eighth Series. Containing Spurgeon's celebrated Doctrinal 
 Discourses, which made a most profound impression through- 
 out England. One vol., 12mo., cloth. Price, $1.50. 
 
 Morning by Morning, or 1)ai2y Bible lead- 
 ings. By Rev. C. H. SPUBGEON. One vol., 12mo. 
 Price, $1.75. 
 
 " Though no printed sermon can give a perfect representa- 
 tion of the same thing spoken by an eloquent and impas- 
 sioned orator, yet the reader of these will not wonder at their 
 author's popularity. Though he may not sympathize with 
 Mr. Spurgeon's theological opinions, he can not fail to see 
 that the preacher is really in earnest, that he heartily believes 
 what he says, and knows how to say it in a way to arouse 
 and keep alive the attention of his hearers." Boston Adver- 
 tiser. 
 
 The Saint and JSTis Saviour. By the Kev. C. H. 
 SPUBGEON. One vol., 12mo. Price, $1.50. 
 
 This is the first extended religious work by this distin- 
 guished preacher, and one which in its fervid devotional 
 spirit, the richness of its sentiments, and the beauty of its 
 imagery, fully sustains his high reputation.. 
 Spurgeon's Gems. Being Brilliant Passages from 
 the Sermons of the Kev. C. H. SPUBGEON, of Lon- 
 don. One vol., 12mo. Price, $1.50. 
 
 " The Publishers present this book as a specimen of Mr. 
 Spurgeon's happiest thoughts, gems from his discourses, 
 which will glow in the mind of the reader, and quicken in 
 him a desire to read and hear more of this remarkable youth- 
 ful preacher.
 
 STANDARD AND MISCELLANEOUS BOOKS. 11 
 
 jBunyan's (Pilgrim's 'Progress from this World 
 to that which is to come. One vol., 12mo., 
 Illustrated. Price, $1.50. 
 
 IBunyan's 2?o2y War. One vol., 12mo., Illustrated. 
 Price, $1.50. 
 
 "Each of the books has six full-page Illustrations. The 
 type is large and clear, and they are altogether the cheapest 
 and best editions of Banyan's great works now in the market. 
 
 2~he (Pastor's JETandboofc. Comprising Selections 
 of Scripture, arranged for various occasions of Offi- 
 cial Duty; Select Formulas for the Marriage Cere- 
 mony, &c. ; Rules of Order for Churches, Ecclesias- 
 tical and other Deliberative Assemblies, and Tables 
 for Statistical Eecord. By Eev. W. W. EVERTS, D.D. 
 One vol., 18mo. Price, 75 cts. 
 
 !The Baptist Church directory. A Guide to 
 the Doctrines, Discipline, Officers, Ordinances, and 
 Customs of Baptist Churches. Embracing the 
 questions of Baptism and Communion. By EDWARD 
 T. Hiscox, D.D. One vol., 16mo. Price, 90 cts. 
 
 Grace 2"ruman / or, LOVE AND PRINCIPLE. By SAL- 
 LIE ROCHESTEB FORD. With a steel-plate Portrait of 
 the Authoress. One vol., 12mo. Price, $1.50. 
 
 ZBunyan, THE DREAMER'S BLIND DAUGHTER. A 
 Tale of Religious Persecution. By Mrs. S. ROCH- 
 ESTER FORD, of Louisville. Illustrated. One voL, 
 12mo., pp. 488. Price, $1.50. 
 
 Young (Parson. One voL, 12mo. Price, cloth, 
 $1.50. 
 
 " There is a rich vein of genuine humor running through 
 the work, whilst many of its scenes are described with great 
 tenderness and pathos. It is a pleasant and profitable book, 
 and will everywhere find readers." Evangelical Review,
 
 12 STANDARD AND MISCELLANEOUS BOOKS. 
 
 The JBoofc of Nature. An Elementary Introduc- 
 tion to the sciences of Physics, Astronomy, Chem- 
 istry, Mineralogy, Geology, Botany, Zoology, and 
 Physiology, by F. SCHOEDLEE, PH.D., and HENRY 
 MEDLOCK. One vol., octavo. Price, $3.00. 
 
 3Poems of Sorrow and Comfort. Edited by Prof. 
 FRANCIS J. CHILD, editor of "The British Poets," 
 " The English and Scottish Ballads," &c. One vol., 
 crown octavo. Price, cloth, gilt top, $1. 75 ; morocco, 
 $4.00. 
 
 from Jesus. By Rev. W. P. BALFERN, 
 author of "Glimpses of Jesus." One vol., 16mo. 
 Price, $1.00. 
 
 Cr2impses Of Jesus / or, CHRIST EXALTED IN THE 
 AFFECTIONS OF His PEOPLE. By Rev. "W. P. BAL- 
 FEBN, of England. 16mo., pp. 267. Price, $1.00. 
 
 The Scripture Text-Soote and Treasury. 
 
 Forming a complete Index to the Doctrines, Duties, 
 and Instructions of the Sacred Volume. By Rev. 
 W. W. EVERTS, D.D. 12mo. Price, $1.25. 
 
 The 'Power of Illustration / an Element of Suc- 
 cess in Preaching and Teaching. By JOHN DOWLING, 
 D.D. 18mo. Price, 38 cts.
 
 University of California 
 
 SOUTHERN REGIONAL LIBRARY FACILITY 
 
 405 Hilgard Avenue, Los Angeles, CA 90024-1388 
 
 Return this material to the library 
 
 from which it was borrowed. 
 
 . .j 3
 
 A 000 028 885 2