*. Digitized by tine Internet Arciiive in 2008 witii funding from IVIicrosoft Corporation littp://www.archive.org/details/bookoforatorynewOOmarsricli THE BOOK OF ORATORY: A NEW COLLECTION OF EXTRACTS IN PROSE, POETRY, AND DIALOGUE, CONTAINING SELECTIONS FROM PISTIKGUISIIED AMEEICAN AND ENGLISH OSATOES, DIVINES, AND POETS ; OF ■VTHICU MANY ARE SPECIMENS OF THE ELOQUENCE OF STATESMEN OF TUB PRESENT DAY. 'OR THE USE OF COLLEGES, ACADEMIES, AND SCHOOLS. BY EDWARD C. MARSHALL, M. A. ia.TE INSTRrCTOR IN A MILITARY SCHOOL AT "WEST POINT, IN GENEVA COLLEOB, AND IN THE NEW YORK UNIVERSITY. Nemo est orator, qui so Deniosthenia similem esse nolit. CiCKRO, de Optimo genere Oratorunu NEW YOPtK. D. APPLETON & COMPANY, 90, 92 & 9-4 GRAND STREET. 18T0. EDUCATION DEPT. according to Act of Ctongresa, in the year 1851, 3iY D. APPLETON & COMPANY In the Oerk's Office of the District Court of the United Stales for the SouUiem District of New York. TO HO 11 AGE WEBSTEE, LL. D THE ABLE HEAD OF THE NEW YORK FREE ACADEMY, WHO HAS BEEN, FOR MOKE THAN A QUARTER OF A CENTURY IDENTIFIED WITH SOUND COLLEGIATE EDUCATION IN THE STATE OF NEW YORK, ®l)io bolitmc iS BESPECTFULLY INSCRIBED. MS084S8 PREFACE. An experience of eiglit years as an instructor of elocution, as well as of otlier branches, in a military school at West Point, in Geneva College, and in the discharge of duties, among which is the teaching of oratory in the department of History and Belles- Lettres of the New York Free Academy, having induced the belief that the selections in the leading books upon this subject are mostly too hackneyed to be used with great benefit in our colleges and schools, the determination was formed to prepare a collection of newer material, and the present volume is ofiFered as the result of that undertaking. A great part of the selections which are here submitted to the public, appear for the first time in a book of this character ; and an important feature of the work is to present specimens of the eloquence of the more recent living as well as deceased statesmen from all parts of the Union, which has not been attempted, it is believed, in any other siuii- lar collection. The compiler's experience in the use of otlier works has been, also, that most of the articles arc too long for the wants of stu- dents, and he has endeavored to digest the material here pre- sented with great care, omitting all parts of the extracts which are unnecessary to the development of their leading ideas, or which would render them too prolix. Many of the best speci- mens of our literature will therefore be found so abridged, with special reference to their convenient length as exercises in ora- tory in colleges and schools, and, it is believed, without essen- tially marring their beauty. He trusts that his labor in select- 6 PllEFACE. ing, abbreviating, and arranging the extracts, will be appre- ciated by instructors and students, as it is his own opinion that brevity, adaptation, and variety are the main requisites in a work like the present. As to the amount of instruction in oratory which is generally given in our seminaries of learning, there can be but little doubt that the subject does not receive the attention which it merits. Very much can be done, by careful teaching in youth, in culti- vating the habit of expressing one's ideas well by the lips ; and oratory is a more important branch of study, and more efl&cient means of educational training, than it has of late been consid- ered. The greatest masters of eloquence whom the world has ever seen, flourished among the ancients, with whom education consisted so much in the study and practice of oratory, that it formed, in their schools, almost the main object of instruction. Other studies, indeed, as philosophy, mathematics, science, and history were pursued, but they were chiefly subordinate to ora- tory. The most accurate division of labor prevailed in oratori- cal instruction, one rhetorician giving his whole attention to vocal force, another to modulation, and another to inflections. No man could hope for distinction among them, in the camp or forum, without oratorical skill. Their generals ruled as w^ell by the rhetorical talent they had acquired in youth, as by militaty sway. All their great men submitted to long and laborious discipline to attain a mastery of this art. They practised fre- quently before their equals, and before their teachers, who criticised, reproved, rebuked, excited emulation, and left nothing undone which perseverance could accomplish.* Cicero passed nearly thirty years in the study of oratory under the chief mas- ters of his time. The story of Demosthenes is well known ; and Cicero, Quintilian, Isocrates, Aristotle, and others have left treatises upon the best modes of oratorical instruction, which give evidence of the attention bestowed upon it. * See an article by William Wirt, p. 157. PliEFACE. 7 Such was the importance ascribed by the ancients to practice in expressing their own thoughts in their mother tongue as a means of education ; but, in later times, other subjects have been cultivated at the expense of a proper attention to our own language. The recent discussions, however, in the leading re- views of England, and the popular demand in this country, show that the study of the English language, in its origin, its synonyms, and, above all, by practice in its use in writing and speaking, is destined henceforth to become an important feature in education. Such study will make practical, ready, and think- ing men in a greater degree than is possible under other sys- tems. Of this practice in the use of the English language, ora- tory forms a valuable part. Exercises in oratory, under the criticism of an instructor, tend even more than the study of mathematics and the languages to discipline all the mental fac- ulties in harmonious proportion. Such exercises impart powei of thought, cultivate enunciation and pronunciation, store the memory with a rich fund of words, develop a knowledge of our own language, and in every manner give a readiness in originating and expressing ideas. The system of rehearsals adopted in the Free Academy is, it is believed, unlike any which prevails in our colleges, and, for excellence, is probably surpassed by no other. The instructor gives each student, individually, careful disciphne upon the speech which he is to recite, explaining its meaning, correcting his faults of enunciation, pronunciation, emphasis, gesticulation, or other errors, and imparting a delivery which shall give the most per- fect expression of the ideas that are to be conveyed. During the first part of his period of study the pupil gives recitations of extracts, which exercise receives a searching criticism at the rehearsals ; and in the latter portion of his course, he delivers original orations and discussions, subject to the same discipline. There can be but little doubt that if this system shall be fully carried out, it will furnish more finished speakers and writers 8 PREFACE. and well-disciplined thinkers than can be produced if undue prominence is given to other branches of study. The compiler of this volume acknowledges his indebtedness to the Honorable Messrs. Cass, Benton, Berrien, Butler, Hunter, Seward, Dickinson, Winthrop, Jefferson Davis, Hilliard, and Mayor Seaton, of Washington, for valuable assistance in furnish- ing and collecting speeches for his use, of which he has fully availed himself. For an able discussion of the principles of oratory, he refers to the work of the Rev. Henry Mandeville, D. D., which may be obtained froni the enterprising publishers of this collection. An abridgment, styled " The First Book of Oratory," con- taining about one-half of the extracts here presented, has been prepared for the use of schools, and of those persons who wish a volume of moderate price. New Yoek Fuke Academy, Atkii^ 1861 M / CONTENTS. SELECTIONS IN PROSE. PASS 1. The perfect orator Anonymous. 17 2. Reply to the Duke of Grafton Thurlow. 18 3. Oratoiy, an art Knowles. 18 4. The value of oratory Knowles. 19 5. "Vindication from calumny : Emmet. 20 6. The same.— Part Second Emmet. 21 7. The same.— Part Third Emmet. 22 8. Defence of Smith O'Brien Whiteside. 23 9. Vindication from treason Meagher. 24 10. The same.— Part Second Meagher. 25 11. The Indian, as he was, and is Sprague. 20 12. Sorrow for the dead Irving. 27 13. The same.— Part Second Irving. 28 14. The destiny of America Story. 29 15. The responsibilities of America Story. 30 16. The Indian tribes Humphrey. 31 17. The memory of the good Humphrey. 32 18. The patriot's ambition Clay. 33 19. The consequences of disunion Clay. 34 20. The Union Clay. 35 21. Taxation for war Calhoun. 35 22. State rights Calhoun. 36 2.3. Eulogy upon John C. Calhoun Webster. 37 24. Free discussion Webster. 39 25. American institutions Webster. 39 26. America - Webster. 40 27. The murderer's secret Webster. 41 28. The same.— Part Second Webster. 42 29. Supposed speech of John Adams Webster. 43 30. The same.— Part Second Webster. 44 31. Encroachments on the Constitution Webster. 45 32. The sentinels of Uberty Webster. 46 33. Bunker Hill Monument Webster. 47 34. The character of Washington Webster. 48 35. The responsibility of Americans Webster. 49 36. The voyage of the Mayflower Everett. 50 37. The laud of our fathers EvereU. 51 38. The same.— Part Second Everett. 52 39. The influence of Lafayette Everett. 53 40. Man made to labor Everett. 54 41. What good ? Everett. 54 42. Adams and Jefferson Everett. 56 43. Civil war Wirt. 57 44. The poor Indian Wirt. 58 45. Suspension of relations with Austria Cass. 59 1* 10 CONTENTS. PAOK 46. Suspension of relations with Austria Hunter. GO 47. The President's protest Benton. 62 48. The rigiit to discuss presidential acts Preston. 64 49. British influence Randolph. 65 50. War with France Buchanan. 66 (' 51. War with France Crittenden. 68 52. The Mexican war Berrien. 69 53. The Union Butier. 71 54. The South and the Union Evans. 72 55. The Union Dickinson. 74 56. A defence of Daniel Webster Clayton. 75 57. The war with Mexico Corwin. 77 58. The exploits of General Taylor Davis. 79 50. Obedience to the (institution Douglas. 81 60. Thedeath of O'Connell '. Seward. 82 61. The Oregon territory Hannegan. 83 62. The heroism of the pilgrims Choate. 85 63. Popular excitement in elections McDuffic. 86 64. The destiny of the United States Hilliard. 88 65. The famuie in Ireland Prentiss. 89 66. Republics Legare. 90 67. A monument to Washington Winthrop. 91 68. The dissolution of the Union Stewart. 93 69. Free discussion Burgess. 95 70. Northern laborers J^aylor. 97 71. The destiny of America Hilliard. 93 72. California Tyng. 99 73. The development of our country Henry. 100 74. Profaueness Chapin. 101 75. Washington, a man of genius Whipple. 102 76. The death of Washington Paine. 103 77. The death of General Harrison McLaren. 104 78. The death of General Taylor Stevens. 105 79. A religious spirit in education Kelly. 107 80. Mental diligence Benedict. 108 81. A good book Milton. 109 82. Trutli and falsehood Milton. 110 B3. The institutions of England Peel. 110 84. The Irish distmbance bill O'Connell. Ill 85. The miseries of Ireland Shiel. 112 86. The vanity of learning Watson. 114 87. The miseries of war Chalmers. 115 88. The benevolence of God Chalmers. 116 89. The power of temptation Chalmers. 117 90. Speech of Caius Marius Sallust. 118 91. The progress of liberty *. Webster. 119 92. Our country's origin Webster. 120 93. The spirit of human liberty Webster. 121 94. The patriot's courage Clay. 121 95. The survivors of the Revolution Everett. 122 96. Territorial extension Everett. 123 97. The experiment of self-government Everett. 124 98. Revolutionary struggles Everett. 125 99. War with Fjunce Calhoun. 126 100. The preservation of the Union Cass. 127 101. Agriculture Dickinaov-. 129 CONTENTS. 11' PAGK 102. An appeal for union Berrien. 130 103. The State of Virginia Butler. 131 104. Suspension of diplomatic relations with Austria Hunter. 132 105. The South Jefferson Davis. 134 106. The California gold mines Benton. 136 107. The federal compact Morris. 137 108. Peace and national honor Morris. 138 109. The triumphs of science Dix. 139 110. The influence of Christianity Dix. 140 111. Intelligence a national safeguard Woodbury. 141 112. The pei-manence of American liberty McDvffie. 142 113. New England,and the Union Prentiss. 143 114. The true reformers Greeley. 144 115. Self-sacrificing ambition Orecley. 145 116. The admission of California Winthrop. 146 117. New territories Winthrop. 148 118. Ignorance and superstition Barnard. 149 1 19. The light of knowledge Barnard. 151 120. Ignorance a crime in a republic Mann. 151 121. Popular education the concern of every citizen : Randall: 152 122. Classical studies Story. 153 123. The freedom of the press Story. 154 124. The fate of the Indians Story. 155 125. The example of our forefathers Sparks. 156 126. Oratory in Greece and Rome Wirt. 157 127. The Declaration of American Independence Bradish. 158 128. The noble deeds of the Revolution Bradish. 159 129. The disinterestedness of Washington Paine. 160 130. Classical and Christian literature Sumner. 162 13 1 . American literature Orimhe. 163 132. The end of the world Taylor. 164 133. Party spirit Qaston. 165 134. The warfare of truth Upham. 165 135. Our obligations to the pilgrims Whelpley. 166 136. Woman's influence Carter. 167 137. The freedom of science in America Verplanck. 168 138. Practical scholarship Verplanck. 169 139. Independence of thought in America Verplanck. 170 140. American scholars independent of a nobility Verplanck. 171 141. Free institutions ennobling Verplanck. 172 142. The evils of political parties Verplanck. 173 143. Military glory Channing. 174 144. False courage Channing. 175 145. Tru«^ courage Channing. 176 146. Military courage Channing. 176 147. The moral character of war Channing. YTl 148. Truth Channing. 178 149. Thought the privilege of all men Channing. 178 150. The capacity of the people for knowledge Channing. 179 151. The nobility of mind Channing. 180 152. Social changes Channing. 181 153. The value of books Channing. 182 154. Hard work Channing. 183 155. The dignity of human nature Dewey. 184 156. Attention, the soul of genius .' . . . Dewey. 185 157. The nobility of labor Dewey. 13S 12 CONTENTS * rAan 158. Howard, the philanthropist Wayland. 187 159. The emptiness of human gloiy Wayland. 188 160. The mission of the Saxon race Tyng. 180 161. Political demagogues Henry, 190 162. The pacific age Sprague. 191 163. Language Hale. 1 92 164. The Bible friendly to Uberty. HaJ.e. 193 165. The political knave Beecher. 193 166. Address to a missionary Red Jacket. 194 167. Address to Gen. Street Black Hawk. 196 168. Conciliation with the colonies Burke. 197 169. Reform in Parliament Brougham. 198 170. Refonn in the elections Brougham. 199' 171. Sympathy for man around the throne of God Chalmers. 20O 172. The British constitution PhilpoUs. 201 173. Autumn jilison. 202 174. Charity St. Paul. 203 175. The rights of the i>lebeians Canuleius. 204 176. Brutu»(m the death of Caesar Shakspeare. 204 »77. Hamlet to the players ^Mkspearc. 205 COMIC AND AMUSING SELECTIONS. 1. One good turn deserves another Oilman. 207 2: The dilatory scholar Oilman. 207 3. Orator Puff .anonymous. 208 4. The Jackdaw Cowper. 209 5. Nose vs. Eyes Cowper. 210 6. Conversation Coujper. 211 7. The removal Anonymous. 212 8. My aunt Holmes. 213 9. The features A-nonymous. 21 4 10. Morning meditations Hood. 215 11. Major Brown Hood. 210 12. The duel Hood. 219 13. John Day Hood. 221 14. The troublesome wife Anonijmous. 222 15. The cold-water man Saxe. 224 16. Youthful precocity Saxc. 225 17. The conflagration Ejected Addresses. 220 18. Follow your nose Anonymous. 228 19. Economy Jrolcot. 22S 20. Shamus O'Brien .*. Anonymous. 230" 21. The same.— Part Second Anonymous. 231 22. Tlie same.— Part Third Anonymous. ^Ji 23. The rhyming apothecary Caiman. 236 24. Brown Stout Anonymous. 238 25. The farmer's blimder Anonymous. 239 26. Hasty pudding Barlow. 241 27. Song of the Speaker Anonymous. 243 28. Editorial musiugs Anonymous. 244 29. The alarmed skipper - Fields. 245 30. A Yankee IjtIc..., ,,.., Peters. 247 UONTENTS. 15 31. Village greatness Ray. 248 32. Old Grimes Oreenc. 249 33. The poet Clarke. 251 34. The world's a stage Anonymous. 2.52 35. Improvement Dow, Jr. 253 36. Despair Dow, Jr. 254 37. Nature Dow, Jr. 255 3a Slumber Dennie. 25G 39. The same— Part Second Dennie. 2&7 SELECTIONS IN POETRY. 1. The soldier's tear Bailey. 259 2. The veteran BaUey. 260 3. The deserter BaUey. 260 4. The pilot Bailey. 261 5. The old man's revery Bailey. 262 6. Oft in religion's name Bailey. 262 7. The mibeliever Bailey. 263 8. The dream of darkness Bacon. 264 9. I remember, I remember Hood. 265 10. Gold Hood. 266 11. Avenged honor Colman. 266 12. Posthxxmous fame Colman. 267 13. Monterey Hoffman. 268 14. Buena Vista Pike. 269 15. Darkness Byron. 270 16. Solitude Byron. 272 17. Mazeppa Byron. 272 18. The ocean Byron. 274 19. Belshazzar's vision Byron. 276 20. The shipwreck Byron. 277 21. The battle of Albuera Bijron. 278 22. Brutus reproaching Cassius Shakspeare. 279 23. Cardinal Wolsey's soliloquy Shakspeare. 280 24. Cardinal Wolsey's address to Cromwell Shakspeare. 280 25. Soliloquy of Henry IV Shakspeare. 281 26. Soliloquy of Richard III Shakspeare. 282 27. The seven ages of man Shakspeare. 283 28. Despair Shakspeare. 284 29. The advice of Polonius to his son Shakspeare. 284 30. Mercy Shakspeare. 285 31. Mark Antony's oration Shakspeare. 28G 32. Address of Marullus to the mob Shakspeare. 287 33. Richmond's address to his soldiers Shakspeare. 288 34. Soliloquy of Hamlet's uncle Shakspeare. 2P8 35. Cheerfulness Shakspeare. 2t J 36. Hamlet's soliloquy Shakspeare. 290 37. Royal ceremony Shakspeare. 291 38. Soliloquy of Henry VI Shakspeare. 292 39. Clarence's dream , Shakspeare. 203 40. Martnion and the Douglas Scott. 294 14 CONTENTS. TAOm 41. The death of Marmion Scott. 296 42. The love of country Scott. 297 43. Rienzi'a address to the Romans Mitford. 298 44. Speech of Sempronius for war Addison. 299 45. Speech of Lucms for peace Addison. 299 46. Speech of Cato Addison. 300 47. The Baron's last banquet Oreenc. 301 48. Bernardo and King Alphouso Lockhart. 302 49. The taking of Warsaw Campbell. 304 50. The song of Marion's men Bryant. 305 51. The village blacksmith Bryant. 307 52. Alaric, the Visigoth Everett. 308 53. Woodman, spare that tree Morris. 310 54. The Chieftain's daughter Morris. 311 55. The mothers of the west Oallagher. 311 56. The Indian council Hosmer. 313 57. The pioneers of America Hosmer'. 314 58. The Indian tribes Hosmer. 315 59. Death's mission Everest. 316 60. Death's triumphs Everest. 318 61. The aged prisoner Whittier. 319 62. The Semuiole's reply Patten. 321 63. Beauty everywhere Marshall, 322 64. Our country Marshall. 323 65. Work Marshall. 324 66. The dram-drinker Rockwell. 325 67. The death-flre Stephens. 326 68. The battle of Ivry Macaulay. 327 69. The angel of death s Bailey. 329 70. The madman «. Jtf. C. 331 71. A fever dream Harney. 333 72. Thoughts in a library Lynch. 335 73. The old man in December Hcrrman. 330 74. Rome Anonymous. 337 75. The poor-liouse Crabbc. 338 76. The hermit Home. 339 77. Speech of Caius Gracchus Knowles. 340 78. BeJshazzar's warning Croly. 340 79. The death of Napoleon McLellan. 342 80. The Roman soldier Atherstone. 343 81. The same.— Part Second Atherstone. 344 82. Thought without utterance Tupper. 345 83. The power of eloquence Tupper. 34G 84. Trifles Tupper. 34? 85. The good man , Tupper. 34fc 86. Equality Tupper. 349 87. Books , Tupper. 349 88. Beauty Tupper. 350 89. Cruelty Tupper. 351 90. The Chamois hunter Tupper. 352 91. Dreams Tupper. 354 92. Arminius '. Praed. 355 93. Alexander and Diogenes Praed. 356 94. What makes a hero ? Taylor. 358 95. The landing of the Pilgrims Hemans. 359 96. Drones ^. . . Shelley. 360 CONTENTS. 15 PAGH 97. Thanatopsis Bryant. 3G1 98. The same.— Part Second Bryant. 362 99. The murdered traveller Bryant. 303 100. The heroes of Seventy-six Bryant. 364 101. The African chief Bryant. 365 102. The hm-ricane Bryant. 367 103. The tweiityrsecond of December Bryant. 368 104. A Psalm of life Longfellow. 369 105. The leper Willis. 370 106. Nature Street. 371 107. The poor Indian Street. 373 108. The Six Nations Street. 374 109. A forest nook Street. 376 110. The poor and the rich Lowell. 377 111. The fight of Paso del Mar Taylor. 378 112. Lament of the Indian Chieftain Hosmer. 380 113. Origin of the crow Hosmer. 382 114. Watchwords Cox. 383 115. The American flag Drake.. 384 116. Old Ironsides Holmes. 385 1 17. The pilgrims Sigourncy. 386 118. Time Prentice. 387 119. The Yankee ships Fields. 388 120. Press on Benjamin. 389 121. The marmers Benjamin, 390 122. What the end shall be Jlnon7jmou3. 391 12.3. Rest. Marshall. 392 124. Another life Marshall. 393 125. The flight of the Nundowagas Marshall. 394 120. Iron Hale. 396 127. Rome Bacon. 397 128. The last revolutionary Dow. 399 129. The shipwreck McLaughlin. 400 130. Cold Pollok. 401 131. The storming of Vera Cruz Jlnonymous. 402 132. Ambition, ftdse and true inonymous. 403 133. The oaken bucket fVocdworth. 404 134. The gladiator .Tones. 405 133. The Kaiser Howitt. 407 136. Albuquerque Dawes. 408 137. Look aloft Lawrence. 409 138. The ocean Cornwall. 409 139. The charnel ship Anonymous. 411 140. The phantom sliip Anonymous. 412 141. The serpent of the still Anonymous. 415 142. Washington Cook. 416 143. The seventh plague of Egypt Anonymovs. All 144. Friends separated by death » Montgomery. 420 145. The charge Percival. 420 146. The Bunker Hill Monument Pierpont. 421 147. The Marseilles Hymn De VIsle. 422 148. Speak not harshly Crosby. 423 149. The death of Major Ringgold Crosby. 424 150. The death of Colonel Clay Crosby. 42.5 15L General Scott Crosby. 425 152. The death of General Taylor Crosby. 426 16 CONTENTS. 153. Tipperary ..Davis. 428 154. The vow of Tipperary Davis. 423 155. The battle of Limerick Davis. 429 156. Paddies evermore .Anonymous. 431 157. The song of the poor Anonymous. 432 158. The O'Kavanagh Shea. 433 159. Woman's sufferings JVorton. 434 160. The power of dreams J^Torton. 435 161. The fallen leaves J