EXERCISES IN MEMORY OF LEVI COOPER LANE E> EXERCISES IN MEMORY OF LEVI COOPER LANE S HELD AT LANE HALL OF COOPER MEDICAL COL- LEGE ON SUNDAY AFTERNOON THE NINTH DAY OF MARCH IN THE YEAR NINETEEN HUNDRED AND TWO PRINTED FOR THE FACULTY OF COOPER MEDICAL COLLEGE BY THE STANLEY-TAYLOR COMPANY SAN FRANCISCO 1902 100 EXEGI MONUMENTUM ^ERE PERENNIUS, REGALIQUE SITU PYRAMIDUM ALTIUS; QUOD NON IMBER EDAX, NON AQUILO IMPOTENS POSSIT DIRUERE, AUT INNUMERABILIS ANNORUM SERIES ET FUGA TEMPORUM. HORACE, ODE xxx OF BOOK in. EXERCISES IN MEMORY OF LEVI COOPER LANE HELD AT LANE HALL OF COOPER MEDICAL COLLEGE ON SUNDAY AFTERNOON THE NINTH DAY OF MARCH IN THE YEAR NINE- TEEN HUNDRED AND TWO DR. LEVI COOPER LANE, the founder of Cooper Medical College and of Lane Hospital, and the founder and endower of the Lane Course of Medical Lectures, died in San Francisco at a quarter to eleven o'clock in the evening of the eighteenth day of February, 1902. At two o'clock in the afternoon of the ninth of March following, a large audience assembled at Lane Hall of the College for the purpose of doing honor to his memory, the Hall having been profusely decorated with greenery and flowers appropriate to the occasion. The exercises were opened by the rendering of Mozart's " Lacrymosa " by a quartet of mixed voices. DR. HENRY GIBBONS, JR., the Dean of the College, then spoke as follows: " Over forty years ago I heard Dr. Lane deliver his first lecture in this city, in the lecture room of the medi- cal department of the University of the Pacific. He 8 INMEMORYOF had recently resigned from the Navy, and had spent some time in Europe in study preparatory to accepting the chair of physiology in that college, of which his uncle, Dr. E. S. Cooper, for whom the present college is named, was the leading spirit. My recollection is almost as clear as though it were yesterday a slender man, dressed in the conventional suit of black, much the same as he dressed in all the succeeding years concise in speech, clear and accurate in statement, master of his subject, as he was of everything he undertook. During all the following years I have been proud to call him ' guide, philosopher and friend,' and surely no man had a better. For over thirty years it was my pleasure and profit to be associated with him in the affairs of this medical college and its predecessor; and while others will give a detailed account of his life, his aims and his achievements, I cannot let the opportunity pass without a few personal recollections and a more than willing tribute to the many elements of character that raised him above his fellow men. Dr. Lane was the most indefatigable, painstaking and thorough student I have ever known. There was scarce a field of learning that he had not to some extent explored, and his knowledge was accurate and full. One was often surprised at his wide range of information. Studious habits had been formed in youth. German and French were to him familiar tongues. His knowledge of Latin was scholas- tic. Even late in life it was his custom to read daily a page from some favorite Latin author. His impromptu LEVI COOPER LANE 9 thesis, when under examination for the navy was, to the surprise and consternation of his examiners, written in Latin. Remarking once to a surgeon of the navy that Dr. Lane had been in that service, he replied, ' I am well aware of it. It is a tradition in the navy that Dr. Lane passed the best examination of any man who ever entered the service.' "For many years Dr. Lane devoted a number of the morning hours to reading, investigation and writing. This employment, together with his professional work, was his business, his occupation, his pleasure, his vaca- tion. He needed nothing outside. A year ago, having suggested a vacation and referred to Coronado as a most restful resort, especially in a mental sense, he replied, f I have never needed recreation to escape work. My work has always been a pleasure to me.' On another occasion he said : f I once wrote eight pages every day ; then I wrote six, then four, then two, then one, and now none.' This told the sad story of his gradually diminishing physical powers, for his mind was as clear and his memory as faithful as ever. It has been a marvel to me that with a far from vigorous physique, he was enabled to accomplish so much. A few months since, referring to a recent work on surgery by Dr. Senn, he remarked that it indicated an immense amount of work. Upon my suggesting that be, Dr. Lane, had also accomplished a great amount of work, he replied, deprecatingly, f Yes, for a man who has never been entirely well. In my childhood,' added he, ' I was io INMEMORYOF .subject to attacks of asthma, and I remember my mother calling me into the house, when running briskly, and saying, "You will pay for this tonight.'" Yet the half is not thus told, for like a stoic he rarely spoke of him- self. Who has heard him complain? Who knew how often with him the mind triumphed over the body ? "As a surgeon, Dr. Lane realized his own statement of Sir Astley Cooper, that he never operated on an im- portant case without previously performing the operation on the cadaver. Having a fine memory, this assisted in making him an accurate and thorough anatomist. In his knowledge of these two branches he had not his superior on this Coast, and I doubt if he had his equal. He was easily the best read surgeon. As an operator he was competent for any undertaking resourceful to a degree, and with that admirable courage and self-com- mand that comes of perfect knowledge. Dr. Lane's interest in medical education was persistent and untiring. For at least a decade he had in contemplation the endowment of a college, and I look upon it as one of the most remarkable features of his character that through these years he could have bent his energies to the accu- mulation of means for that purpose, have matured all plans and even erected the building without the knowl- edge of his colleagues that he had such a plan in con- templation. This was characteristic of the man. He was absolutely without ostentation ; free from all desire of parade or display. " Dr. Lane was as great in his declining days as in his LEVI COOPER LANE u prime. In the days of his greatest activity the necessity of economizing time in consequence of his very large practice had imparted a certain brusqueness of manner, almost a necessity in the transaction of much business. And yet in all my experience I never saw him hurried ; I never saw him excited; I never heard him raise his voice. His manner was uniformly calm, dignified and impressive, indicative of great reserve force. His deci- sion was remarkable. There was no wavering. A col- league said that he could say f no ' more easily than any man he ever knew. And yet he was never obstinate. No man could have been more reasonable. But now, as he withdrew from more active work, a lessening con- tact with the world and a greater leisure softened his sharp decision and replaced it with a more indulgent humor, a more genial spirit, and a more reminiscent mood. " Thus my years of close association with Dr. Lane have shown him to be a man of vigorous and untiring intellect and high attainments ; of sturdy, upright char- acter, rigid in his ideas of right, noble in his aspira- tions, wise in counsel, clear in prevision, prompt and decisive in judgment, steadfast in purpose, firm and unyielding in action, and withal modest and unostenta- tious, as becomes a wise man. These are attributes of greatness, and like Hamlet I say, with all my heart, " ' He was a man, take him for all in all, I shall not look upon his like again.' " No memorial column reared in some city of the dead shall mark his final resting-place for a time, then iz INMEMORYOF crumble into dust and be forgotten, but these stately edifices, which through his energy, self-denial and munifi- cence have been erected for the stimulation and better- ment of the noblest of professions and the better care of the sick ; the lecture courses that he has inaugurated ; and above all, the grand example of a useful, well-spent life these will be his monuments more enduring than marble. "Peace be unto his ashes! His spirit has risen with the immortals." At the conclusion of Dr. Gibbons's introductory, MR. WILLIAM FORD BLAKE of the class of 1902 spoke on behalf of the students of the college as follows: "It is eminently gratifying to us as students to be able on this occasion to give some expression of our sorrow over the passing of this great man. His death has been a common bereavement to us all, and we deem it a privilege to offer our tribute of admiration and affec- tion to his memory. " It has not been our good fortune to know him intimately, to feel the inspiration that comes with close association with so great a man. Nor has it been our good fortune to enjoy that gentle fatherly guidance in the class room that our predecessors in these halls received from him and hold in affectionate memory. " It has rather been our painful experience to see him gradually failing with the passing months, to realize LEVI COOPER LANE 13 that his physical strength, so incommensurate with his vigorous mind, was slowly raising a barrier between him and us. " But while we have seldom had the opportunity of seeing him in the operating room or of listening to him from the benches, we have known that his thoughts were with us, that his interest in our welfare never flagged. " We were ever present in his life, in his plans, and our success and our development into honored members of his noble profession were ideals he hoped we might attain. " What a monument he has raised to his memory ! What an example of self-abnegation and self-sacrifice is this college with its hospital, its laboratories, its library and the ground on which it stands! "When we stop to think of all he has done for us, how throughout a lifetime he has worked untiringly that this heritage might be ours, our appreciation of the great- ness of the man becomes a real presence to us, our obli- gation surges upon us, and our hearts go out to him as a child's to an indulgent parent. " It pleases us to think that it was for us and for the advancement of his profession that all this has been done, that our success and the futherance of his noble work was the labor of love to which he devoted the energies of a lifetime. It pleases us to think that he received us into his presence as his children, that he took us at that form- ative stage in our lives when by his example and his teachings he could mold us as he would have us grow. H INMEMORYOF " Had Dr. Lane left us no other remembrance than that of a life nobly planned and successfully carried to a glorious end, his example should have proved a stimulus to each one of us. But, when in addition to this, he has left to us all the fruits of his life's work, then his precepts become a sacred duty, his example a moral obligation. "As we have honored and loved him while he was yet with us, as we looked upon him then as a public bene- factor and as a foster parent who had received us into the circle of his affection, now when the sense of our loss is heavy upon us, we appreciate as never before the splendid manhood and scholarly attainments that won for him a place of pre-eminence among his colleagues, and we realize as never before the tender paternal feelings he bore us and the noble motives that actuated his life." DR. CHESTER ROWELL was to have spoken on be- half of the alumni of the college but was unavoidably detained at his home in Fresno. Could he have been present he would have made the following remarks: "As one of the early graduates of the parent school of Cooper Medical College and in behalf of the alumni, I offer a word of tribute to the memory of Dr. Lane. The occasion is not one for expression of grief, for death came to him calmly in ripe old age, his life's work accomplished, his ambitions satisfied, his hopes realized. His physical body, grown old by years of labor, no longer served the purposes of an intellect that never tired even to the end. LEVI COOPER LANE 15 He went to sleep. His body was cremated in accord- ance with his wish and in approval of this method of disposing of the dead. His intellect, bright and un- wavering till the moment of dissolution, still lives in these noble educational monuments dedicated to medical science and the healing arts, lives in the record of his work, in the lasting impression of his teaching upon the many who have been his students, and in the silent but most im- portant influence of his example upon all who knew him, and upon the profession at large. "He was the friend of every student who manifested the spirit of the true physician and sought knowledge for its beneficient rather than its selfish uses. He was the associate, adviser and defender of every physician, how- ever deficient or unfortunate, who gave to his work his best efforts with pride in his profession and an unselfish desire to help his patients rather than himself. Yet, while he led gently, guided wisely, judged charitably, dealt kindly, his dislikes were as intense as his friendships were strong, and he frowned upon the student who dedi- cated but half his soul to the profession he proposed to enter, as he spurned the physician who selfishly betrayed his brother physician. His example was one of lofty devotion to pure science and high art as exemplified in his profession, tempered by that most human of all human impulses, a feeling of charity for the unfortunate and of interest in the welfare of humanity. He said to me, after an operation, which, at the time was marvellous in its re- sults, ' The patient got well, that is pay enough.' 16 INMEMORYOF He added, ' Whoever wants my surgery may have it, whether they have money or not.' He was charitable. Every day of his long life of labor he did something for the afflicted with no thought of a money recompense. He recognized his obligations to the poor as he recog- nized his obligations to deal fairly with, as well as treat properly, every patient. His charities were a part of his every-day work. Upon every student and upon every class he impressed the obligation to deal honorably with patients and to be kind to the poor. He was solicitous for the character and the welfare of his graduates long after they left the lecture halls, and felt keenly every evi- dence of their successes or failures. He entrusted the reputation of the school he had builded to its graduates, and he cherished the good will and kind remembrance of those graduates as much as his reputation in the profession at large. "These were some of the personal characteristics that attracted students no less than his great skill and wonder- ful knowledge, and for these he will be remembered by the alumni. His generous endowment of this school and hospital for medical education will remain his visible monument, constantly reminding his successors of the names and the work of his venerated uncle, Elias Cooper, and his own. His contributions to surgical knowledge are the property of the profession. His teaching, his in- fluence, his cherished memory, are his legacy to the alumni." LEVI COOPER LANE 17 Following MR. BLAKE'S address, Mendelssohn's anthem/' Be Thou Faithful unto Me," was sung as a tenor solo, after which, on behalf of the Faculty, DR. C. N. ELLINWOOD, President of the College in succession to DR. LANE, delivered the following address : " The guiding hand of the master has gone from us ! " Our kindly counselor, arbiter and ultimate referee in all our perplexities is no longer here ! "Sad, indeed, are these days when we have to part fellowship with Dr. Levi Cooper Lane a good man, a great man, whose noble heart lovingly embraced the universe, the mysteries of which it was given his pene- trating vision largely to see. "In speaking of Dr. Lane I shall speak of him as we, his co-workers and his college faculty, knew him in his daily work, in his life work, in his singleness of purpose, in his exalted ambition for the advancement of medical education and the welfare of human life, and finally, I shall speak of his achievements. "In essaying an analysis of his strong character we note his early associations with kindly and gentle kins- folk, in sympathy with all goodness, honesty and manly uprightness, maturing in him a supreme love for truth and justice which has grown stronger and deeper as his horizon expanded in his added years of thought and experience. " His great attainments as a scholar, as a scientist and surgeon ; his achievements of distinction in all these i8 INMEMORYOF and also in the practice of his profession, brought him rewards which enabled him to do what his beneficent inspiration prompted, the founding of a great school of medical education for the improvement of his loved profession and the good of his fellow men. " The exacting conditions of his early life, imposed upon a youth of extraordinary mold, developed a man of great courage, self-reliance and strong will. " He could fight like a lion for the oppressed and never surrender to wrong. " Apparently insurmountable obstacles in his early education were overcome by industry, careful economy, self-denial, a well disciplined mind and an unswerving purpose to get an education and to do what he planned to do. " LEVI COOPER LANE Was born in Ohio, on a farm thirty-four miles north of Cincinnati, May 9, 1830. His grandparents were Jesse Lane, born in North Carolina; Hannah Huddeston Lane, born in Nantucket, Mass. ; Jacob Cooper, born in South Carolina; Elizabeth Walls Cooper, born in South Carolina : all orthodox Quakers. His parents were Ira Lane, born in North Carolina in 1803; Hannah Cooper, born in Ohio in 1811. They were married in Friends' Meeting (Quakers), West Eberton, Ohio, in June, 1829. Their first-born was called Levi, Biblical names being common in the family and usual among the Quakers. He had two homes in his childhood, being nurtured and cherished by his grandparents as well as LEVI COOPER LANE 19 by his parents, and his childhood and youth would seem to have been divided between the two. " His early education was chiefly in private, being taught by his mother, but chiefly by his aunt, Ruth Cooper, who is yet living at the age of 85, with a heart full of affection and tender reminiscences of her nephew and pupil. Later he worked on his father's and his grandfather's farms and attended the common district schools. At the age of 16 he became a teacher and taught in the district schools of Butler County, Ohio, during three years. " All through these years of childhood and youth his uncle, Jacob Cooper, a few months younger than himself, was his close companion and loving friend. They were playmates and schoolmates ; both nurtured by the same kindly parents and exacting circumstances, both became great students, and the uncle, Jacob Cooper, is now and has been for many years a professor distinguished for his learning in Rutgers College, New Jersey. It is to his affectionate and painstaking care that we are indebted for these details in Dr. Lane's biography. "After teaching three years the young man of 16, Levi Lane, began his college training in the spring of 1 847 by a six months' course at Farmer's College, for- merly called Gary's Academy, and, secondly, after an interval, six months at Union College, Schenectady, N. Y., in the autumn and winter of 1849-50, where he boarded himself and lived on twenty-five cents per week, but paid his college bills. Union College subsequently 20 INMEMORYOF gave him the Master of Arts degree, and in 1877 con- ferred on him, with pride, the honorable distinction of LL. D., Doctor of Laws. " HIS MEDICAL EDUCATION "As was the custom in those days, Dr. Lane com- menced his medical education by reading medicine with his two uncles, Drs. Esaias and Elias Samuel Cooper, as preceptors, and later he entered Jefferson Medical Col- lege in Philadelphia, where he studied one year and graduated there M. D. in March, 1851, and in the same year he was appointed an interne or resident physician in the large New York State Hospital on Wards Island, where he remained an earnest worker with his hands and brain four years, until 1855, wnen ne entered a competi- tive examination with thirty-one others for the position of assistant surgeon in the United States navy. He passed the examinations higher than any of his competitors and secured the appointment which he held four years. " During this time, the ship to which he was assigned cruised in many waters, and on one of its voyages to Europe and in the North Sea Dr. Lane obtained a fur- lough and passed two months in study at the University of Gottingen. He pursued his studies in medicine and surgery with unremitting vigor while in the navy, and continued, as a recreation, the study of the Latin and Greek in which he became thoroughly proficient. He also taught himself the German, French, Spanish and Italian, in all of which he became able not only to read LEVI COOPER LANE 21 and write these tongues, but had a ready command of them in speaking. ADVENT IN SAN FRANCISCO "In the year 1861 Dr. Lane having resigned from the navy was induced by his uncle, Dr. Elias S. Cooper, to join him here in the practice of his profession, in teach- ing in his medical school which he had already started as early as 1 858, the first medical school on the Pacific Coast, and also aid him in editing the journal of medicine which he was then publishing, 'The Medical Press. "Dr. Lane became thoroughly identified in spirit and action with his uncle; he rendered him the most efficient aid. He gave him his confidence and love and received in return all that a rich, warm and energetic nature could bestow. "This cordial and mutually helpful relation con- tinued until broken by the early death of Dr. Cooper on October 13, 1862, and since that premature severance of these bands, Dr. Lane has followed up the memory of his uncle with superhuman zeal and affection. " Opportunity was there ! and Dr. Lane was there ! with all fitness and capacity for the arduous work before him. " Early in the year 1875 Dr. Lane, ever thirsting for all the knowledge to be obtained in his profession, deter- mined to further pursue his studies in the great centers of learning in Europe, and taking his wife, his helpmate then and always the devoted sharer in all his aspirations, he visi- 22 INMEMORYOF ted London, Edinburg, Paris, Vienna and Berlin, spending two years more in diligent student work. After some months, in attendance upon the college courses in Lon- don, he was granted the M. R. C. S., England, and won many warm friends among the then distinguished profes- sors of the schools. In Berlin he regularly matriculated as a medical student at that great university, and after six months' instruction in its laboratories, clinics and hospi- tals, he passed the examinations and received the doctor of medicine degree, Summa Cum Honor F-CALIFO ALIFOMf