SOME ASPECTS MODERN SOCIALISM. BY A. A. DENISON. “Socialism is a moral reform.”—Johnson's Encyclopedia. " A Socialist is one who looks to society organized in the State for bringing about a more perfect distribution of economic goods and the elevation of humanity.”—Prof. Richard T. Ely. Socialism is already a fact to be reckoned with, not a theory to be discussed.”—Marshall's Principles of Economics. A Paper read before the Oakland Nationalist Club April 3, 1891. Published by Request. Wh JO ENQUIRER PUBLISHING HOUSE, 416 AND 418 TENTH STREET, OAKLAND, CAL. RE Sprc Х :72 ,046 7891 LABD 147 396490 vei ve [3] MODERN SOCIALISM. | lected for his wisdom or his prowess in arms-was made chief. If we could imagine the first human be- This paper, presented before the Political ing sta" ding alone like some primeval | Crusoe upon the shore of time, surveying Science Section of the Starr-King Fraternity, the universe, he might exclaim, "I am subsequently revised and read at a meeting monarch of all I survey and my right there of the Oakland Nationalist Club and pub is none to dispute.” But the moment that lished by request of members of both these a second man or a woman appears upon the scene that right is challenged, a part organizations, is reprinted from the Oak- of that supremacy must be surrendered, land ENQUIRER of April 18, 1891. and an obligation is imposed by human so- ciety. Mankind has been a long time in recognizing the restrictions which the social From the time when our first parents state in poses upon the individual. With were dispossessed of Paradise and it was the advance of civilization the points of decreed that in the sweat of his brow man contact of man with man have become sbould earn his bread, philosophers have i more intimate. From the tribal relation. speculated upon ideal states and dreamers springing out of the family or clan, to an have dreamed of fair Utopias. Seers and alliance for protection or conquest, from poets have caught inspired visions of realms the government of force to the state organ- where perfect law and love shall reign and man be restored to his lost estate, "Some been long stages in human experience. sanguine spirits still hope to see these lofty Government has gradually becorue more ideals realized in a regenerated earth, and complex and highly organized-as new point out that the surging tide of events forms have succeeded discarded systems ever moves forward and that however dis- and the earlier types have been modified or couraging the present may be the future is have disappeared. fraught with promise for humanity. . Sometimes the pages of history have been Whether we regard human society as di- illumined by the stories of states in which vinely instituted under ideal conditions government seemed to have been developed and degenerated by man's disobedience of to its highest good, but like fruit ripened law, or evolved by a slow process, through through before its season there was rottenness at 911ccessive stages, from the savage tribal re- the core and they have gone out in the Tation to the organized government, it is an darkness of succeeding ages. Such were the interesting and profitable subject for our earlier republics of Greece, and Rome in investigation. the days of her vigor before wealth, luxury Thomas Carlyle said, "study history, for and vice had destroyed the yirtue of her it is philosophy teaching by example." But citizens and broughton the era of her decline closer still to us is the science of sociology, let us compare two periods in the his- underlying history and dealing with the tory of Rome. The first is that elder dav: human forces which modify society. His- “When none were for party, When all were for the state, tory in the past has been made up largely When the great man helped the poor, of the chronicles of the kings, Sociology And the poor man loved the great; comes down to the history which the peo When lands were fairly portioned, ple are making each day, and in which When spoils were fairly sold, every one of us has a part. In the study For the Romans were like brothers of sociology, however, we must take into In the brave days of old.”. consideration the fact that the evolution of Contrast with this the picture of the de. | generate days when rights of the people forms of government is conditioned by the had been trampled and the wicked ten ever changing status of human intelligence or so called public sentiment. This is par- bare swav,'' as drawn by Macaulay in his ticuiarly so in a republic where there is no I poem of Virginia.” When addressing the deference for that “divinity which doth patricians the plebeians exclaim: hedge a king” and where the government Exult, ye proud patricians, the hard fought fight is o'er; is popularly regarded as a mere institution We strove for honor-twas in vain; for free- of utility for conserving the public welfare, dom--'tis no more." the prevailing principle, the crystalization Then recounting how “their foul usance of public opinion upon certain theories as bad eat away the substance of the poor" embodied in the dominant party... and their lust and avarice knew no bounds, Among primitiva man the principles of the commons call a halt with these desper- isolation and of individual will might per-ate words: haps obtain, but even in the brute creation "Spare us the inexpiable wrong, the unutter- there is a tendency to association, and the able shame beasts of the field gather themselves to. That turns the coward's heart to steel, the slug- gether in flocks and herds. Man, being gard's blood to flame; a social animal, naturally early congregated Lest, when our latest hope i 4 fled, ye taste of p our despair, in communities, in which some patriarch-|And learn by proof, in some wild hour, how the head of a numerous family or one se- much the wretched dare." In the luxury and vice of the most | spirit of Socialism to-day than John splendid period of the Roman Empire we Brown's raid of the sentiment of abolition discover the causes of her decline in the or the “Messiah craze of Christianity. It corruption of her citizens, so that it has ought not to be necessary to disabuse the been truly said, "in the sun burst of minds of an intelligent audience at this Rome's glory were ripening the seeds of day of the accusations brought against her decay." Of some of the early republics some of the early Socialists, of adyocating one of our poets has written: community of goods and community of “There were communities, scarce known by wives. Against this the disciples of Saint- name Simon, the earliest apostle of pure Social- In these degenerate days, but once far-famed, Tism in France, defended themselves in a Where liberty and justice, hand in hand, statement published as early as 1830, in Ordered the commonweal; where great men which they distinctly announce that they grew Up to their natural eminence, and none reject the system of community of goods, Saving the wise, just, eloquent, were great; for this would be a manifest violation of Where power was of God's gift to whom he gave the first of all the moral laws which it is Supremacy of merit-the sole means their mission to teach, viz: that in the And broad highway to power, that ever then future each one should rank according to Was meritoriously administered, While all its instruments, from first to last, his capacity and be rewarded according to The tools of state for service high or low, | his works. In regard to woman they de- Were chosen for their aptness to those ends clare: “Christianity has released woman Which virtue meditates.” from servitude, but has condemned her to The cause of the decline of these states is religious, political and civil inferiority. a fruitful subject for the speculation of the The Saint-Simonians have announced her student and the philosopher and the emancipation, but they have not abolished thoughtful consideration of the statesman. the sacred law of marriage proclaimed by It is not my purpose in this paper to trace Christianity. On the contrary they have the progress of these changes. It is enough given a new sanctity to this law. Like the to say that it is the philosophy of history Christians they demand that one man shall that from the wreck and ruin of the em- be married to one woman, but they teach pires of the past haye been evolved the that the wife ought to be the equal of her higher forms of government, and in a di- husband, and that in accordance with the vinely implanted principle of discontent peculiar grace given to her sex by the Crea- with present conditions is the prophecy tor, she ought to be associated with him in of hunian progress. In considering politi the triple function of temple, state and cal theories, however, we should bear in family, in such a manner that the social in- mind that we are come upon a time to dividual, which has hitherto been man which history can show no parallel, which alone, should hereafter be man and presents economic problems under condi- woman." tions new to the experience of humanity. Edward Bellamy derived much of the The subject to which I more especially inspiration of the scheme of Nationalism desire to direct your attention this evening from the system of Saint Simon, and of is political and social movement of mod. woman's position under Nationalism, so ern times. While the principles which distinguished a champion of her sex as uncierly Socialism are as old as civilization Frances E. Willard writes: “As a worker itself, their application to political methods in the difficult reform which has social vir- is of comparatively recent date. The word tue as its outcome, I have been driven to Socialism was first introduced into econ-believe that the core of Edward Bellamy's omic discussion in a work published by L. plan, which is the industrial disenthrall- Reybund in 1840. Since then it has been ment of woman, is tbe way out of the wild- used by many writers and with widely dif- erness for woman, and through her for ferent meanings. Exact definition is es. man.!' sential to intelligent discussion and in the Richard T. Ely in his “French and Ger- consideration of Socialism it will be well to man Socialism in Modern Times'' says: have its meaning clearly understood that “Socialism, strictly speaking, denotes the we may not drift from the topic. The social system. It is the opposite of individ- term Socialism has been subject to much ualism. A Socialist is one who looks to misconception, and in the popular mind it society organized in the state for aid in has been identified or confounded with va- | bringing about a more perfect distribution rious forms of Communism and extreme of economic goods and an elevation of hu- revolutionary political theories, or the vis-manity. * * * While the Socialist as- ionary schemes of religious enthusiasts. As cribes to the state numerous functions, the a great movement in human society it has individualist admonishes the government had various expositions under different to do as little as possible. To the one the social and political conditions and by differ- state is a necessary good, to the other a ent advocates, but the transitory pbases of necessary evil. But Socialism is also used its manifestation and the ephemeral vapor- in a popular sense which makes it nearly ing of yisionary enthusiasts are no more to equivalent to Communism, although the be regarded as representative of the true two ought to be distinguished. The central idea of Communism is economic equality. | Egyptians reserved the mysteries of their It is desired by Communists that all ranks ancient faith ard the science of that age as and differences in society should disappear its exclusive prerogative, and Popes and and one man be as good as another, to use ecclesiastical hierarchies, whatever their the popular phrase. The distinctive idea of creed, have asserted an absolute domain in Socialisin is distributive justice. It goes things spiritual. It has been the motive of back of the processes of modern life to the the aristocracy and the plutocracy of all fact that he who does not work lives on the times in aggregating to themselves super- labor of others. It aims to distribute econ- ior political rights. It has persecuted omic goods according to the services ren- those who dared to oppose its dictates in dêied by the recipients. Thus we see that religion, science or government. It was the word Socialist is the most inclusive. the inspiration of Saul of Tarsus, of Leo Every Communist is a Socialist, but not the Tenth, of George III. It set task- every Socialist is a Communist. We might masters Over the children of Israel; sold call a Communist an extreme Socialist and serfs as chattels with the soil; enslaved in thus include under Socialists both Socialists America three millions of black men, and and Communists, though it is best to make would to-day reduce to a condition of sery. the distinction. We could not include So.itude millions of the wage earners of the cialists under Communists." world. one of the clearest and most i Individualism is not to be utterly con- comprehensive definitions of Socialism is demned, nor is it likely that it will ever to be found in an article by Clemens Peter- be entirely eradicated, but absolute individ- sen in Johnson's Encyclopedia. This ualism must be checked by a sense of re- writer says: “Socialism holds an interme sponsibility, and this is the spirit of Chris- diate position between pure Communism tianity as taught by the Carpenter of Naza- and simple co-operation. Unlike Commu- reth, which illuminates the sermon on the nism it dees not advocate the absolute abo | mount and characterizes the new com- lition of property, but aims simply at a mandment which arends the decalogue of more just and equitable distribution of it. Mt. Sinai, “that ye love one another." It Every man according to his capacity and is the divine law by which all men shall be every capacity according to its work,' is the tried when the Great Judge shall say, “in- great maxim laid down by Saint Simon, asmuch as ye did it to the least of these and to carry out in its reality this maxim my brethren, ye did it unto me.” is the goal of all Socialistic movements. On An eminent and philosophical historian the other hand it does not confine itself, says: "The prelates of the fifteenth cen- like co-operation, to a mere regulation of tury, and Cardinal Bembo among the rest, the relations between capital and labor, re-i no more foresaw Luther and Calvin than stricting or even excluding competition, the courtiers of Louis XIV foresaw the transferring the profit from capital to la French revolution.” It may be that there bor, etc., but attempts a complete recon- are those who are equally blind to the great struction of society. With the ideas of co- reactionary movement in the economic operation for its basis of operation, it ap- i system of our own time. proaches Communism partly by extending As the reformation of Martin Luther the compass of these ideas, but chiefly by brought about freedom of conscience and employing them as means to a moral end. the American and the French revolutions. Communism is a religious tenet, co-opera-made political liberty possible throughout tion an economical scheme, Socialism a the world, so Socialism seeks to establish moral reform. It is the vices of mankind economic justice by destroying special privi- and the miseries resulting from these vices, lege, affording equal opportunity, so far as to which Socialism wishes to put an end, possible in the struggle for existence, and and it seeks its means not in a new religious extending the spirit of common humanity. issue, but in a new social organization, In the consideration of the comparative hence its name.' merits of the two systems the one which The vice of selfishness and self seeking makes pre-eminent the individual, allow- is one of the evils which Socialism seeks to ling him the largest freedom of action and remedy. It is a vice born of the nature of the other which magnifies the function of man that has not yet been eradicated in the State, let us listen to the language of M. the evolution of the race from that savage Guizot, Minister of Public Instruction of state where self preservation was the first France, in his lectures upon the history of law and the survival of the fittest the pre- civilization. He says: “It is upon the in- vailing principle. It was voiced by the tellectual state of man that the visible fratricidal Cain in the reply, "am I my form of society depends. * * * Where brother's keeper?' This imperious indi- individualism reigns nearly absolute, vidualism has asserted itself through | wherever man considers but himself, every stage of the development of human wherever he yields obedience only to his society, blocking the wheels of progress, own passions, there society-that is to say, combatting every effort for freedom of society in any way permanent-becomes thought and political liberty. It was the almost impossible." Again the same au- spirit in which the priestcraft of the early 'thority declares: “The progress of society 161 consists pre-eminently in substituting, on York City is 41 cents, which makes the cost tbe one hand, public authority for private of living thirty-five years $5138, but in New will; and on the other, legal resistance for York the cost of living is probably above individual resistance. This is the great the average throughout the United States. end, the chief perfection of social order; Perhaps $5000 is a fair estimate and I am a large field is left for personal liberty but informed that in some States this is fixed as when personal liberty offends when it be- the limit of the amount which a widow or comes necessary to call it to account, our the dependents of a person killed may re- only appeal is to public reason; public rea-cover from a corporation liable for his son is placed in the judge's chair to pass death. Judging from recent verdicts in sentence upon the charge which is pre- our courts this is a higher valuation than ferred against personal liberty. Such is some juries set upon human life. Upon the system of legal order and of legal resist- this basis the $15,125,000 distributed in prof- ·ance." its in one year by twelve corporations in The existing economic system is arraigned Pittsburg represents the subsistence for before the bar of public reason for violating life of 3025 human beings. the spirit of humanity; for conspiring Multiply this by a hundred cities and re- against the stability of Republican govern- peat it through one generation and the re- ment in fostering class distinctions, special | sult of the computation is appalling. privileges and so-called "vested rights" by ! There is a suggestion of something radi- which the few are permitted to lay tribute cally wrong in a system which enabled the upon the many through a monopoly of the Duke of Bedford, who has just died one of gifts of nature, the common heritage of hu. the richest men of Great Britain, to enjoy manity; by absorbing through an unjust an income which some years ago he ad- system of distribution of the increment of Imitted to be equivalent to $1,500,000 a year, capital, labor and natural resources, the lof whom a recent observer of events in Jion's share of the wealth produced; by London wrote: “He was an eccentric man seeking to lower the social condition of the land a mean man. He stood for years in masses of the people, upon whose intelli- the way of local improvements and was gence the stability of society depends. recognized as the bitterest foe to the prog- Many thoughtful students of political ress which London is beginning to feel is economy are coming to the conclusion that necessary to her salvation." His heir and the monopolists and not the Socialists are the successor, Lord Tavistock, is described as a dangerous class in the republic to-day. narrow minded individual, purse proud, It is not strange that there are loud mur- selfish and egotistical to the degree of ab- murings of discontent at an economic sys- surdity. Yet this kind of creature is per- tem which enabled in 1890 twelve leading mitted to have the disposal every year of iron and steel firms of Pittsburg, according the means whereby 300 of his fellow beings to a reliable trade review of that city, to I might be maintained during their natural lives and that, tov, in a city where one per- distribute $15,125,000 in profits, and two es- tablishments, in which Andrew Carnegie is son in thirty is said to live on charity with the principal owner, to net nearly $5,000,- a tendency to crime and in a nation of 000. Let us consider for a moment what I which Lord Derby recently pointed out these figures mean. By laying aside $10 a that the population is increasing at the day a man should live 1000 years to ac- rate of 400,000 a year and said: "Neither cumulate in round numbers $3,500,000, British manufactures nor British agricul. which is probably less than Mr.' Carnegie's ture can supply work and sustenance for individual profits in one year. Economists such an increment and relief must come in place the point of independence at $12 per immigration.' week, at which it is believed a family may "When we read on the same day that a be supported and leave a margin. The av.shivering child stood at the door of a great erage duration of life in Europe is stated in manufacturing establishment with only a the Encyclopedia Brittanica to be thirty slice of mouldy mush in its little dinner four years and in the United States it is bucket to sustain it during a day of toil; and probably somewhat in excess of this limit. a wealthy sport who never knew what it is to Upon this basis the monetary representa-earn an honest dollar paid $10,000 for a dog, tion of the life subsistence of a family may is it to be wondered at that Socialism is be stated at $21,840, or in round numbers spreading in this country as well as in Eu- $22,000. The average family is usually cal- | rope ? culated at five but under the present social It is not possible in a brief paper to system this is probably a liberal estimate. speak of the progress of the Socialistic Dividing the cost of maintenance of the movement, but the most casual observer family by the number of persons we have cannot mistake the tendency of political $4400 as the average absolute cost of the thought in this direction. Professor A. subsistence of an individual for life. These Marshall in his new work on Principles of results from my own calculations I find Economics, Volume 1,' discussing parti- very nearly confirmed by a statement re- cularly the situation in England says: cently published that the average cost of "When municipalities are expected to pro- substitence a day per individual in New vide baths, wash houses and libraries for [71 the people and when the State is not only movement of the wage earner, however in- conveying letters and dispatching telegramstimately all classes of society may be inter- but carrying parcels for the people, and ested in its results. However blind one when the State and local authorities are not may be to the spread and influence of So- merely providing schools, but on the eve of cialistic teachings there is little excuse for enacting, under the auspices of a Conser- cherishing the idea that the wage yative ministry, that the education in them earner has no cause for dissatisfaction with shall be gratuitous it is too late to consider bis situation and prospects, or that bis whether Socialism is or is not desirable. proper duty in life is to imitate the excel- Socialism is already a fact to be reckoned lent example of the pious shepherd of with, not a theory to be discussed. Nor is Salisbury plain, wbo derived supreme con- it easy to see where the movement which tentment from the fact that a kind Provi. has thus begun can be logically ar-dence had vouebsafed bim salt to eat with rested." | his potatoes. Since the French revolution It is impossible to take up a leading jour- of 1793 there has been a steady and of late nal, magazine or review without noticing a rapid growth in tbe Socialistic movement. discussions upon Socialistic questions. The More general education, a free press, and remarkable demand for literature upon the organization for resistance or aggression topic of Socialistic reforms is evidenced by have been the agencies by which the work. the sale of edition after edition of "Progress ing classes have gained clearer ideas of their and Poverty," “Looking Backward,” Gron-powers and opportunities. The dull de- lund's "Co-operative Commonwealth,” and spair of medieval servitude has given place similar works; the space given to articles to an intelligent and profound discontent upon these questions in such periodicals as with a situation which every year seems to the Century, Arena, Forum, North American make more and more hopeless. Blind Review, and the establisbing of the New Na- Samson stands chained but if he shall bend tion by Edward Bellamy for the discussion himself upon the pillars against which be of Nationalism, a movement that in itself is leans in sullen silence the whole structure deeply significant. 'The Farmers' Alliance, of society will come crashing to the ground which has become an important factor in and nothing will restrain his purpose American politics, presents another inter- should the mood seize him, even though esting phase of the same question and is an that be destroys must invariably fall upon organization strongly Socialistic in its ten- and crush bin, dencies. The powerful organizations of It is fortunate for those who have what labor are but an extension of the principie tbey are pleased to consider svested of Socialism and embody the maxim an in-rights" that labor has not yet found an an- justice to the weakest is an injury to the swer to its own question. Socialism, using wbole. the term comprehensively, bas thus far In a note in the Arena of February, 1891. represented many and widely different par- under the head of "Deplorable Social Con- poses, immediate and ultimate, often at ditions we read: "Social problems are variance one with another. When its assuming great proportions. The relations forces sball focalize upon one idea, we may existing between capital and labor are daily be certain ihat, right or wrong, that idea growing more strained. The stream of will for the time being uominate human misery grows broader as colossal fortunes thought and action. When it shall direct rise skyward. The poverty in all our great its energies at the attainment of a fixed centers of civilization as well as throughout purpose, practicable or impracticable, it the landlord and mortgage-cursed frontiers will move with relentless power." is, year by year, growing more terrible and Happily for humanity we live in an age more general. There have been 2650 fore- when political revolution is possible by closures of farm mortgages in Kansas dur- peaceful means. When the people hold in ing the past six months. In the city of their own hands theremedy for tbe wrongs New York there are over 150,000 people which exist and the greater evils which are who earn less than sixty cents a day. threatened through the ballot which as vet, Thousands of this number are poor girls thank God, every citizen is free to exercise who work from eleyen to sixteen hours a unawed by federal interference or corpora- day. Last year there were over 23,000 fam- tion espionage. ilies forcibly ejected in that city, owing to It remains with the voters of this nation their inability to pay their rent. One per- to determine whether the government shall son in every ten who died in New York in be administered for the many or the few; 1889 was buried in the potters' field. These whether special privileges shall be fostered are facts which may give rise 10 anxious and corporations, trusts and monopolies thoughts.” The words I quote are not licensed to tax the industrial masses and from a Socialistic organ but are the sober reap the profits due the producers, or an editorial utterances of a leading review equitable system of distribution devised published in conservatiye Boston--the upon the basis of co-operation throngh the "Cradle of Liberty." I enlarged function of the State. In a recent address a lecturer of Cornell Freemen who are worthy of their birth- College said: "Socialism is essentially a right must maintain the principle promul- [8] gated in the preamble to the Constitution and government supervision of private that this Government was instituted "to schools; the extension of governmental establish justice” and “to promote the control over railroads, telegraph and ex- general welfare." press business and corporations, furnish- Will the manhood of this nation assert ers of light, water and heat, preparatory to itself, cast off the scales of blind party prej- municipal ownership or nationalization of udice and demand these reforms, or sink- these enterprises. ing into servility suffer corporations to con Mr. Bellamy enumerates the first five tinue to control legislation by the corrun- steps toward nationalization to be: tion of voters? The spirit of a patriotic First. Government operation of telegraph people is easily aroused when any overt service. act is committed against the flag or the Second. An extension of the present dignity of the nation assailed, but citizens postoffice business by the establishment of of republics are sometimes slow to resist the a parcel express service. insidious attack of enemies within, who Third. National assumption of control would subvert their liberties and poison the over the railroads of the country. springs of patriotic impulse. The republics Fourth, Government control of coal of antiquity did not fall from enemies with mines; municipal supply of light, heat, out until they had been weakened by cor- water, means of transit, etc.. ruption within. Fifth, Compulsory public education of “For what more oft in nations grown corrupt, children up to the age of seventeen. And by their vices brought to servitude, However we may question the expedi- Than to love bondage more than liberty; ency of some of these measures it must be Bondage with ease than strenuous liberty." admitted that the object of the advocates of Conscious that they are born for a higher Socialism is the amelioration of the condi- destiny than drudgery and an incessant tion of mankind by replacing the evils of struggle from the cradle to the grave for tbe present competitive system by a co- mere existence, the mass of mankind will operative civilization. The ideal of co-op- not submit much longer to an industrial eration has been well defined as “the vol- system so manifestly founded in injustice. untary, conscious participation of each sep- A wise statesmanship should seek to reme-l arate element of society in preparing, dy these inequalities in the economic sys- maintaining and increasing the general tem and avert any conflict of the classes well-being, material, intellectual and emo- and the masses. tional." It is asked what remedy Socialism pro- To reiterate in conclusion, Socialism poses for the evils complained of. It pre- demands that the principle of representa- scribes no sudden, Violent changes, its tive government embodied in the free bal- reforms are reasonable and moderate. The lot in which the voter shall be secure from demands of the German Socialists as ex-surveillance or intimidation shall be main- pressed in their platform are for extension tained. As the highest citizenship demands of the right of suffrage and a secret ballot; intelligence to judge and independence to free high schools for the children of the act, it demands the perpetuation of the free working classes; laws regulating the hours system of public education, but that all of labor and the employment of women may have the opportunity to avail them- and children in factories; a decrease of the selves of its advantages, Socialisni de- standing army; a readjustment of the mands and its supreme contention is the burdens of taxation by a graded income establishment of an economic system under tax. which there shall be such an equitable The organization of Christian Socialists distribution of the proceeds of the aggre- in this country advocates the preservation gated productive agencies of the nation of a free ballot by the adoption of the Aus- that every man shall have the leisure and tralian electoral system in its original form; the means to qualify himself for the obli- State and municipal boards of relief for the gations of citizenship and for the complete unemployed, so that they may be made development of all the faculties of his be- self-sustaining and every man willing to ing, that he may discharge his highest work shall have the opportunity; concen- duties to himself, his country and his God. tration of taxation upon the rental value Then shall we be able to answer by exam- of lands, mines and natural resources, espe-l ple: cially land held for speculation, that all “What constitutes a State! mines hereafter opened shall be the prop-! Men who their duty know, erty of the Government; the enforcement But know their rights, and knowing, dare main- of eight hours as a day's labor; a Saturday tain; half holiday and a Sunday rest for all; the | And sovereign law, that State's collected will enfranchisement of women: the suppres. | O'er thrones and globes elate sion of the saloon: free technical education | Sits empress, crowning good, repressing ill,