1ſm (INemoriam 3.03epb |\rice iſ emington ir £i, uorºs 2. 2. ..Tº 3 Iy gº, 3oseph price Remington Born (Darch 26, 1847 Pieb 3.anuary 1, 1918 Reprinted from THE AMERICAN Journal OF PHARMACY, February, 1918, by the PHILADELPHIA COLLEGE OF PHARMACY PRESS OF THE NEW ERA PRINTING COMPANY LAN CASTER, PA. 2.3.* -:*- Memoir: Professor Joseph Price Remington. By Charles H. LaWall, Ph.M. . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A Letter to Editor Eugene G. Eberle Relating to Professor Joseph P. Remington. By John Uri Lloyd . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Funeral of Professor Joseph Price Remington . . . . . . . . . . The Memorial Meeting to Professor Remington. . . . . . . . . . . . . Letter of George M. Beringer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Resolutions of the Pennsylvania Pharmaceutical Association. Resolutions of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy . . . . . . . Resolutions of the Faculty of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • * * * * * * * * * * * Tributes * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * e º e º se e s m e º 'º e g º e º e º ºs e º e º 'º e º is º ºs Professor Emeritus Samuel P. Sadtler. President, Howard B. French. Professor J. W. Sturmer. Dr. Harvey W. Wiley. Prof. J. A. Koch. Mr. J. L. Lemberger. Prof. H. V. Arny. Mr. Samuel L. Hilton. Mr. Caswell A. Mayo. Dr. H. C. Wood, Jr. Prof. E. G. Eberle. Dr. F. E. Stewart. Prof. Charles H. LaWall. Dr. C. B. Lowe. Prof. E. Fullerton Cook. Dr. S. P. Stout. Prof. F. X. Moerk. Telegrams Received by the College and Mrs. J. P. Remington. Communications Received after the Meeting . . . . . . . . . . . . Action Taken by the National Drug Trade Conference . . . . An Appreciation of Professor Joseph P. Remington by George M. Beringer, Ph.M. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Read at the Meeting of the New York Branch of the American Pharmaceutical Association. A Tribute to Joseph P. Remington. By Joseph W. England, Ph.M. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Read at the Meeting of the New York Branch of the American Pharmaceutical Association. $ Editorial: A Great Leader Has Passed Away. American Jour- nal of Pharmacy PROFESSOR JOSEPH PRICE REMINGTON. By CHARLEs H. LAWALL, PH.M. “He who influences the thought of his time influences the thought of all the time that follows. And he has made his impress upon eternity.” Professor Joseph Price Remington is dead. On January I, 1918, Atropos severed the thread of a life which has meant much to pharmacy. Clothos' distaff bore the unsullied skein which Lachesis had measured for more than seventy years. It is difficult, indeed, to correctly estimate the value of a man's services to the world before time has developed the true perspective, but there will be none to challenge the statement that for a period of at least twenty-five years, Professor Joseph P. Remington was the foremost figure in American pharmacy. Genial and eloquent, a keen student of human nature, a lover of the beautiful in art, music and literature, possessed of a fund of scientific knowledge of unusually broad scope, and with it all a consciousness of power that made him an acknowledged leader among men—these are some of the qualities that were combined in him to make a great teacher, a capable executive and a Christian gentleman, clean-minded and clean-hearted. He was the descendant of early Philadelphia Quaker stock, his ancestors for three generations having been residents of that city and members of the Society of Friends. His father was Dr. Isaac Remington, a well-known Philadelphia physician. His mother was the daughter of John Hart, who was a descendant of Townsend Speakman, an apothecary in Philadelphia early in the eighteenth century, and the sign from this old store was given a prominent place in Professor Remington's private office at the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy. 2 Josep H PRICE REMINGTON. He inherited a liking and an aptitude for scientific study, and when but a small boy had equipped a chemical laboratory in which most of the apparatus was of his own devising and construction. In the collection at the College is a Liebig condenser made by him at the age of twelve, out of a tin roll-plaster case, two heavy rubber washers and several pieces of glass tubing, which has done service in lecture counter experiments for more than fifty years. His father died when Joseph Remington was but fifteen years of age. The plans which had been made for him to obtain an academic college degree were abandoned. He received his pre- liminary education in private schools, and in the Philadelphia Cen- tral High School. At the time of his father's death, the members of his family wished him to take up the study of medicine, but he decided that he preferred to study pharmacy instead. It was a decision purely his own and tis wisdom is confirmed by his subse- quent brilliant career in the profession of his choice. January 1, 1863, exactly fifty-five years before the day of his death, he entered the establishment of Charles Ellis, Son & Co., a prominent firm of wholesale and retail druggists of that time in Philadelphia. He was guided in his choice of a preceptor by his brother-in-law, Henry M. Troth, the son of one of the founders of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy. His experience at the Ellis store covered an unusually wide range, even at that time, for the firm was one that did a great deal of manufacturing on what was then considered a very large scale. He was fortunate in the fact, too, that Mr. Charles Ellis, the head of the firm, and at that time the president of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy, took a more than ordinary interest in him and encouraged him to attend the lectures at the college during the years of his apprenticeship. The lectures at that time were given in the evenings and the course was of two years’ duration. At the commencement exercises held in I866, Joseph P. Remington was graduated from the institution in whose service he was destined to spend so many useful years and was awarded the degree of Ph.G. Curiously enough and prophetic in its significance, the title of his graduating thesis was “Our Alma Mater, Its Rise and Progress.” In January, 1867, Professor Remington left Philadelphia to enter the employ of Dr. E. R. Squibb, then the foremost manu- facturer of chemicals and pharmaceuticals in the United States. Josep II PRICE REM INGTON. 3 His experience with Dr. Squibb afforded an unusual opportunity for him to amass that fund of technical knowledge which gave him such an advantage over many of his contemporaries who were not similarly favored by fortune. Dr. Squibb's reputation for pains- taking and conscientious scientific work and his high standard of ethics were universally conceded and the influence of this period upon Professor Remington's future work must have been very great. He lived as a member of Dr. Squibb's family and was thus brought into close touch with a master in the profession. After three years of experience under Dr. Squibb he was re- called to Philadelphia by the death of his mother and, remaining in his home town, entered the employ of Powers & Weightman, with whom he remained for two years, during which period he added still further to his practical knowledge of manufacturing operations. While with this firm, in 1871, he first became associated with the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy in an active way, by accepting an invitation to become the assistant to Dr. Edward Parrish, who was at that time Professor of Pharmacy. In 1872 he left the employ of Powers & Weightman to establish himself in the retail drug busi- ness at the northeast corner of 13th and Walnut Streets. In this same year, Professor Parrish died and was succeeded by Professor William Procter, Jr., who retained Professor Remington as the assistant in that department. In 1874 Professor Procter's death occurred and in the spring of that year, Joseph P. Remington was elected to the full professor- ship in pharmacy, a position held by him for a period of forty-four years, or until his death. The period from 1874 until 1885 was one of steady development for the young professor. The thirteen years that he remained in active retail drug practice (1872 to 1885) proved him to be pos- sessed of keen business ability as well as professional attainments of a high order. In 1868 he had become a member of the American Pharmaceutical Association and was honored by that body in 1876 by being made chairman of the committee in connection with the famous Centennial Exhibition of 1876, commemorating the hun- dredth anniversary of American Independence. This was an im- portant post for a young man of twenty-nine years, but he filled it well and paved the way for the future honors which were to come to him at the hands of this Association. 4 Joseph PRICE REMINGTON. At this period of Professor Remington's life he was a man of quite different personal appearance from that which distinguished him in later years, for he wore a full beard of a reddish-brown color, and one of the most interesting paintings in the valuable col- lection on the walls of the college museum is one of the Professor Remington at about that time. In 1874 he married Miss Elizabeth Collins, also of Quaker an- cestry, and in the early 80's established a summer home on the then almost unpopulated beach below Atlantic City known as Longport, at which place he did most of his most valuable literary and revision committee work, and took an active part in the growth and develop- ment of the Borough. } In 1877 he aided and encouraged the establishment of labora- tory instruction in the college and was elected director of the phar- maceutical laboratory in that year. In 1878 he became one of the organizers and charter members of the Pennsylvania Pharmaceutical Association and in 1879 he be- came one of the associate editors of the United States Dispensatory, a position held continuously until his death. In this same year he developed the methods of laboratory teach- ing in pharmacy which have been so successfully followed in later years by all teachers of pharmacy. The first operative pharmacy laboratory of about 60 desks in the Philadelphia College of Phar- macy was equipped by him at his own expense. In 1885 he gave up his retail business at 13th and Walnut and purchased the home at 1832 Pine Street, where he lived until his death, except during the summer months, which were spent at Long- port. It was in 1885 that his great work, the “Practice of Phar- macy,” was first issued. This is probably the most widely known textbook of pharmacy in the world and is now in its sixth edition. His first connection with pharmacopoeial revision work was in 1877, when he was appointed upon an auxiliary committee of revi- sion by the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy. In 1880 he was a member of the United States Pharmacopoeial Convention, was chosen as a member of the revision committee and served as first vice-chairman. This honor was again conferred upon him by the Decennial Convention of 1900. In 1886–7 Professor Remington received his first honors from abroad in his election to Fellowships in the Chemical, Linnaean and JOSEPH PRICE REMINGTON. 5 Royal Microscopical Societies of Great Britain. These honors were later succeeded by honorary membership in the Pharmaceutical So- ciety of Great Britain, the British Pharmaceutical Conference, Pharmaceutical Gesellschaft zu St. Petersburg, Instituto Medico Nacional Mexico, Societé de Pharmacie d’Anvers, Societé Royale de Pharmacie de Bruxelles. He has also been the recipient of many honorary degrees, in- cluding Ph.M. of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy, Phar.D. of the Northwestern University of Chicago. Of American scientific societies he is an honorary member of the College of Pharmacy of the City of New York and of the State Pharmaceutical Associations of New York, New Jersey, New Hampshire, Nebraska, Ohio, Colorado, Virginia, Georgia, Minnesota and others. He was proud of his honorary membership in the New York Deutscher Apotheker Verein and the Chicago Veteran Retail Druggists' Association. He was an active member of the American Pharmaceutical As- sociation, American Philosophical Society, the American Chemical Society, the American Geographical Society, the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia, the Historical Society of Penn- Sylvania, the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy, the Pennsylvania Pharmaceutical Association, the Chemists’ Club of New York, and others. His literary ability brought him recognition in membership in the Franklin Inn Club of Philadelphia and the Authors’ Club of London. He was the official representative of the United States at the Eighth International Pharmaceutical Congress at Brussels in 1896 and in 1913 at the Hague, was a delegate to the Pan-American Medical Congress in 1893 and again in 1896. In 1893 he was elected dean of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy, succeeding Prof. John M. Maisch, who died during the Summer of that year. This position he held until his death. In 1893 he had the honor of occupying the presidential chair in the American Pharmaceutical Association, at what was probably the most important meeting in its history up to that time, it being held in Chicago during the World's Fair of that year, and there was held at the same time and place an International Pharmaceutical Conference, over which he also presided. His influence in shaping the policies and promoting the success 6 * Joseph PRICE REMINGTON. of the A. Ph. A. had been shown when in 1887 he elaborated a plan for reorganizing this Association and establishing several of the Sections which have been so valuable in the work of the Association, all of its work having previously been done by the entire body. In 1880 he had aided in the establishment of the council as the govern- ing body of the A. Ph. A., and served as chairman of that important executive body for seven years altogether, some of which were in its earlier period and some later. In 1896 he was elected president of the Pennsylvania Pharma- ceutical Association. In 1897 he became pharmaceutical editor of Lippincott's Medical Dictionary, a standard reference work which has passed through many subsequent editions. In 1887 he attended the American Medical Association meeting as a delegate from the A. Ph. A. and induced that body to establish a section on materia medica and pharmacy, which later became the Section on Pharmacology and Therapeutics. He was often a dele- gate from pharmaceutical to medical organizations in later years and has done more than any other single man to promote cordial relations between the professions of medicine and pharmacy. In 1901 occurred the death of Dr. Charles Rice, then chairman of the U. S. P. revision committee. Professor Remington was first vice-chairman, but instead of automatically succeeding to the chairmanship, he called for a special election to fill the vacancy and was himself elected by a vote of 22 to 4. The difficulties encountered in accomplishing the Eighth Decen- nial Revision were very great, and a number of the most prominent officers and members of the committee died during the period in which the revision was being done. The work was handled so well, however, and the demonstration of his great executive and harmoniz- ing abilities was so convincing, that when the Convention met in I9IO to select the committee for the Ninth Decennial Revision, he was the member receiving the largest number of votes cast for any individual as a member of that body and when the newly elected revision committee was organized for work he was immediately and unanimously chosen its chairman. Of the work on this later revision, issued a little more than a year ago, nothing need be said. It stands as a monument to his ability, the last and greatest work of his hand and brain. In 1912 he presided over the Pharmaceutical Section of the JOSEPHI PRICE REMINGTON. 7 Eighth International Congress of Applied Chemistry at New York City. The foregoing chronological survey of more than fifty years of Professor Joseph P. Remington's professional activities reveals a wealth of accomplishment that would suffice for a number of ordi- nary individuals. His was no ordinary nature, however. One of his secrets of success, which was really no secret at all, but an exhibition of that wonderful common sense which after all is so uncommon in application, was his system of combining work and play in such proportions as enabled him to do twice as much work as if he had devoted his entire time to work alone. His power of concentration, his passion for careful attention to details, his in- sistenc upon the same standards in those who worked for him, are all evidences of a master mind. Early in his life, Professor Remington and his wife were both members of the Society of Friends, but about 1880 he joined the Episcopalian Church and was for many years intimately associated with Holy Trinity Church as a Sunday-School worker, a member of the Brotherhood of St. Andrew and as a vestryman. His deep interest in church work was shown by the fact that he deeded the land and contributed generously to the finances of the Church of the Redeemer at Longport, which was under his im- mediate supervision while he lived and which was directed in his will to be turned over to the Diocese of New Jersey at his death. His simplicity in his habits of life, his innate cleanness of thought and speech, his “camaraderie 5 3 6 3. and “gemüthlichkeit" were qualities that made him loved and respected. His loyalty to his alma mater and his constant thought and service in her interests can be attested by thousands of “his boys’ as his students loved to hear him call them. His deep abiding faith in the nobility and dignity of pharmacy as a profession was his strongest trait. No task was too difficult to perform, no expense was questioned when he saw a chance to be of service to a profession of which he was so proud. He prob- ably has attended more meetings and taken an important part there- in, than any other professional man of our time. His diplomatic power and his harmonizing influence were wonderful. Time and time again has he stepped into the breach when discord seemed to reign supreme and by his compelling 8 Joseph PRICE REMINGTON. personal magnetism brought about a condition of harmony. He has been justly called a great stabilizer. Equipped by nature with a winning personality, a gift of elo- quence and of diction of unusually appealing quality, he has charmed thousands as a speaker upon various subjects, professional and otherwise. His gift of imparting knowledge and enthusiasm to others was marvelous. He has justly been called a teacher of teachers, for the land is filled with those who have sat at his feet and then have gone forth to carry the torch of knowledge to other generations. His keenness and cleanness of wit, his qualities as an ex- temporaneous speaker have made him a toastmaster without a peer and he was much sought after upon occasions requiring such service. He was honest and conscientious to a degree that some- times was inimical to his own interests. During his three decades of service in revision committee work he was ever careful to see that the U. S. Pharmacopoeia was entirely finished and out of his hands before doing a particle of work on the revision of either the “Practice of Pharmacy” or the U. S. Dispensatory, lest it should be said that he took advantage of his advance knowledge to reap financial gain. His family has lost a husband and a father, his college has lost a dean and a professor, his profession has lost its most shining light, and the world has lost a man—a man of whom it can be truly said that he conformed to Huxley's definition of one who had a liberal education, to wit: “That man, I think, has had a liberal education who has been so trained in youth that his body is the ready servant of his will, and does with ease and pleasure all the work that, as a mechanism, it is capable of ; whose intellect is a clear, cold, logic engine, with all its parts of equal strength, and in smooth working order; ready like a steam engine to be turned to any kind of work, and spin the gossamers as well as forge the anchors of the mind; whose mind is stored with a knowledge of the great and fundamental truths of nature and of the laws of her operations; one who, no stunted ascetic, is full of life and fire, but whose passions are trained to come to heel by a vigorous will, the servant of a tender conscience; who has learned to love all beauty, whether of nature or art, to hate all vileness, and to respect others as himself.” Such a man was Joseph P. Remington. Generations of pharma- cists shall not look upon his like again. LETTER FROM JOHN URI LLOYD. 9 A LETTER TO THE EDITOR RELATING TO PROF. JOSEPH P. REMINGTON." I have been informed that Professor Remington is very low, and that possibly we may never have the opportunity of another visit together. One may be excused, in a case like this, for addressing a mutual friend, even though the subject be painful to both, and thus I take the privilege of writing you, who, now residing in the city home of Professor Remington, as editor of the Journal of the American Pharmaceutical Association, will be in affiliating sym- pathy with persons like myself, afar off. These many years ago Professor Remington and I met first in Indianapolis, Ind., at the meeting of the American Pharmaceutical Association, 1879. Professor Remington was then in the vigor of his early manhood. I studied him as a hero, because even at that date his magnificent Services to pharmacy had led everyone to con- sider him as perhaps the most conspicuous incoming American engaged in pure pharmacy in all its outreaches. A professor in the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy; a successful conductor of a drug store in the city of Philadelphia; schooled as he had been with such men as Procter, Parrish and Maisch, with the practical experi- ence that came from personal effort under that Nestor of American pharmacy, Dr. Edw. R. Squibb, in whose laboratory Professor Remington, close to Squibb, served an apprenticeship, this, too. years after he began his apprenticeship opportunity with the estab- lished house of Charles Ellis Sons & Co., of Philadelphia. One can but comprehend that to the present writer the chance, to one whose opportunities had not been great, of meeting this celebrated pharmacist, was an epoch, an event. May this writer not add that possibly but for Professor Rem- ington he might not himself have been long in the service of phar- macy? Remington it was who championed his cause in a personal way at Indianapolis, even volunteering and reading the paper pre- pared by the writer for that occasion, “On the Conditions Neces- sary to Successfully Conduct Percolation.” * From the Journal of the American Pharmaceutical Association, Jan- uary, 1918. * See Proceedings of the American Pharmaceutical Association, 1879, p. 682. IO LETTER FROM JOHN URI LLOYD. Close together have we been since that date, each serving in the field of pharmaceutical opportunity, these fields often seemingly separated, and yet united as a whole. In my praise of Remington, I voice what seems sure to me to be the sentiment of thousands of pharmacists who, in separated sections of the country, have been in close touch with this leader of us all, Professor Joseph P. Reming- ton, in Philadelphia. My dear Mr. Eberle: May I not, in the frankest way possible, express to you these thoughts, and may I not accept that in express- ing them, as a lingering member of the associates of Professor Remington who have passed away, as well as thousands of pharma- cists in America who may not feel at liberty, as do I, to takeſ that privilege, that I may add to the foregoing even yet a further word? Among the past close friends of Professor Remington, none of whom are now with us, I recall Professor Saunders, of Canada, a bosom friend of Remington; they attended the National meetings and roomed together. Together they visited England, ovations marking their course in that country. So very close were they that the terms Joseph and William only were used in conversation. That very talented man, Professor John M. Maisch, a teacher-com- panion of Remington, attended always in Remington's company the meetings of the American Pharmaceutical Association; together they came, never a word of discord between them; companions were they, until came the announcement at our Chicago American Phar- maceutical Association meeting (1893) that Professor Maisch had passed away. Dr. Charles Rice, that remarkable man whose biog- raphy has never yet been written, and in my opinion never can be, was to Professor Remington, as to all others, an inspiration. Of Edw. Parrish, to whom Remington was an assistant, Professor Rem- ington always thought and spoke with the utmost veneration, which was also true of Professor Wm. Procter, Jr. And be it said that the wealth of pharmaceutical opportunity that came to Professor Remington from these teachers and companions was distributed by him to the world-at-large. To thus name all the companions of the olden time, made by Professor Remington, would be to mention every teacher who had accomplished or contributed to the cause during the period of Remington's early activity. But not alone with such as these did Prof. Remington fraternize. Not a student, within forty years, has been graduated from the LETTER FROM JOHN URI LLOYD. I I College of Pharmacy in Philadelphia, but feels that he is a close friend of sympathetic Professor Remington. It has been my privi- lege to meet many hundreds of these graduates of that long-estab- lished institution, and never, so far as I can recall, did a discussion connected with pharmacy occur but that the name of Professor Remington came in as that of one of whom the speaker knew per- sonally. This, I will say, is literally true, because every member of the class of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy for decades has been to Professor Remington a personal charge, and Remington being in the department of pharmacy is naturally very close to any student whose life work is to be pharmacy. But what of other companions? To my mind's eye they arise, everywhere. Wherever there was to be an event in pharmacy that would bring together men imbued with the cause of pharmacy, Remington was sure to be present, and not alone was he present, but actively so. A leader among them all was he. If an address was to be made, Remington was the one selected for the purpose, in whatever direction it may have been necessary. And, Remington never failed. At alumni meetings and college reunions held by pharmaceutical organizations Remington was considered one of the members, as much so as though his college course had been in their college. Be it known, to Professor Remington the cause of pharmacy was cosmopolitan, and he considered himself to be concerned in every phase of pharmaceutical effort. Whoever was teaching, whoever was studying, whoever was contributing in any direction, and from any direction, was in his circle. -> Perhaps the most enjoyable of all occasions at the various meet- ings of pharmaceutical associations that it came my privilege to attend were those of the alumni of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy, and in these always Professor Remington was not only an integral part, but a cherished guest; a representative of the world-at-large, as well as of the college to which he devoted his special time. And not alone with those concerned in manipulative pharmacy such as becomes the charge of the apothecary, but of men engaged in pharmaceutical activities on a very large scale, such as came into the field with the entrance of the factory manufacturer, “the manu- *- I 2 LETTER FROM JOHN URI LLOYD. facturing pharmacist,” did Professor Remington affiliate, by right of education. His personal experience with Dr. Squibb, the con- nection his preceptors, Procter and Parrish, held with such as Tilden and Company, Charles Ellis Sons and Company, Wm. R. Warner and Company, Hance Brothers and White, Charles Bullock, Sharpe and Dohme, Frederick Stearns, of Detroit, and others of the struggling pioneers of those days, led Professor Remington to a kindly affiliation with those establishing and conducting such in- dustries as these. He appreciated that they had become a part in American pharmaceutical evolution, and that in their activities the factor of pharmaceutical education of the individual should domi- nate. And hence we note his kindly affiliation and helpful services to those who came in later, principal among whom may be men- tioned Parke, Davis & Co., of Detroit, and Eli Lilly & Co., of Indianapolis. Well do I remember how, when Mr. Eli Lilly, founder of the house, gave a home banquet on a special occasion two decades or more ago, Professor Remington made the journey from Philadelphia to Indianapolis. And surely Remington would have made that journey if for no other reason than to please his pupil, J. K. Lilly, whose pharmacy instruction was taken under Professor Remington in the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy. Well do I remember that happy occasion, which it was also my privilege to enjoy. As would be supposed from the congenial nature of Professor Remington, which so impressed everyone he met, his family rela- tionship is most delightful. To touch this phase of his life is a very delicate subject, even in a letter to a mutual friend, but yet I cannot refrain from expressing to you the pleasures that have come to me in the visits to and from Professor Remington's family, and mem- bers thereof. To enter that home is like entering one's own, be- cause of the whole-souled hospitality of each and every member. To this it may be added that Professor Remington's love and affec- tion for his wife and children, as shown to his personal friends, is only paralleled by a reciprocity from themselves. Taken all in all, a very happy and a very charming family is the Remington family I have in mind. My dear Mr. Eberle: I feel that this letter is much too long, and yet its space would be much too short were one to attempt to LETTER FROM JOHN URI LLOYD. I 3 present even the high lights of a biography of Professor Joseph P. Remington. I have recorded but a touch of what came to me in the passing along of a discursive letter, as thought crushed upon thought, event upon event, opportunity close following opportunity in the direction of what I felt needs be said, and yet for lack of space, could not be said. Painful though it is to think that I am writing this letter during what may possibly be the closing period of the life of this companion and friend, it is yet a melancholy pleasure to feel that I am not passing the bounds of prudence. All I have said and more will be felt by others who were more fortunate, others who were in daily touch with Professor Remington, as it was not my privilege to be, and who may not, as do I, assume the responsibility of intruding a personal letter. Strange how insidiously Time moves us in and out. Of those close in the companionship of Professor Remington and myself in days long gone by, very, very few are living. May I not close this letter with a sentence from “The Code of Manu ’’- “As drifting logs of wood may haply meet On ocean's waters surging to and fro, And having met, drift once again apart, So, fleeting, is the intercourse of men. “E’en as a traveller meeting with the shade Of some o'erhung tree, awhile reposes, Then leaves its shelter to pursue his way, So men meet friends, then part with them forever.” Sincerely yours, JOHN URI LLOYD. CINCINNATI, O., December 29, 1917. I4 FUNERAL OF PROF. REMINGTON. THE FUNERAL OF PROFESSOR JOSEPH PRICE REMINGTON. Professor Joseph P. Remington’s body was laid in its last rest- ing place on Friday, January 4, 1918. There was a private service conducted at his late residence, 1832 Pine Street, by his youngest son, Rev. Wm. P. Remington, who officiated in the uniform of an army chaplain. The public services were held in Holy Trinity Episcopal Church at 19th and Walnut Streets, and the services here were conducted by the Rector, Rev. Floyd W. Tomkins. { The honorary pall-bearers were Dr. Harvey W. Wiley and Sam- uel L. Hilton, of Washington, D.C.; Dr. William Jay Schieffelin, of New York; Samuel C. Henry, of Chicago; Joseph L. Lemberger, of Lebanon; and the following Philadelphians: Prof. Charles H. LaWall, Prof. Frank X. Moerk, Prof. E. Fullerton Cook, Howard B. French, Dr. Richard V. Mattison, Dr. Adolph W. Miller, Dr. Charles A. Weidemann, Warren H. Poley, C. Stanley French, George B. Evans, George M. Beringer, Joseph W. England, Walter A. Rumsey, Richard M. Shoemaker, Jacob M. Baer, Aubrey H. Weightman, Otto W. Osterlund, Prof. Samuel P. Sadtler, William L. Cliffe, Henry K. Mulford, Edwin M. Boring, Theodore Camp- bell, Charles Leedom, Jacob S. Beetem, of the College; Morris Earle, J. W. Townsend, Samuel Hinds Thomas, William West Frazier, Henry H. Collins, George R. Yarrow, Carroll S. Tyson, Charles F. Gummey, Dr. John B. Roberts, Carl N. Martin and C. C. Morris, of Holy Trinity. Church. The coffin was carried down the center aisle of the church upon the shoulders of four young men and deposited in front of the chancel, the railing of which was banked with many handsome floral tributes from friends and organizations all over the United States. The vested choir sang some of Professor Remington’s favorite hymns during the service, which was the brief, beautiful and im- pressive one of the Episcopal Church. That part of the service usually conducted at the grave was completed in the church. The interment was private and was attended by only the members of the family and four of the closest friends from among the honorary pall-bearers. The burial took place in the Friends' Burying Ground amº MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. I 5 just across Cobb's Creek, a short distance south of Market Street. No services were held at the grave but just as the body was being lowered into its last resting place, his son, Rev. Wm. P. Remington, stepped to the head of the grave and offered a beautiful prayer. The only flowers accompanying the body to the grave were those presented by the Faculty of the College. All of the others were sent to various hospitals in the city, to bring joy to the sick and suffering. This was in recognition of a practice which he was known to favor. THE MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON.1 A very impressive memorial meeting to Professor Joseph Price Remington, dean of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy, who died January 1, 1918, was held January 4, immediately after the funeral services, in the library of the college he loved so well and in whose service he spent so many years of his life. The room was filled with the Philadelphia friends, associates and former students of the dean, and a surprisingly large number of men from other cities, considering the weather and the condition of the train service. Men prominent in all pharmaceutical activities paid tribute to the memory of this international figure in pharmacy, either personally or by telegram and letter. These tributes were sincere and came from the heart, as the emotion of the speakers testified. The meeting was called to order promptly at 3 o'clock by Presi- dent Howard B. French, who said: - This meeting has been called as a memorial meeting to the late Professor Joseph Price Remington. The college held a special meeting on Tuesday, January 2, and adjourned until to-day, so that due and proper honor could be paid to the memory of one of the greatest pharmacists that ever lived.” He then asked the secretary of the college, Dr. C. A. Weidemann, to read a letter received from Mr. George M. Befinger, chairman of the board of trustees, who was prevented from being present by a broken ankle, the result of an accident. Mr. Beringer's letter was as follows: In the midst of the overshadowing sorrow at the passing away 1 Prepared by Mrs. Charles H. LaWall. I6 MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. of this illustrious friend and foremost American pharmacist, my thoughts revert to that time, nearly forty years ago, when I entered the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy as a student and came under the tuition of that trio of master teachers, Professors Maisch, Rem- ington and Sadtler. Each of these, by a personality as noteworthy as their ability, won the esteem and affection of their students. The moral influence that Professor Remington during the last fifty years has exercised in molding the characters and lives of his numerous students, while imparting to them technical and pro- fessional instruction, has been no small part of his life's work. The value of this preceptorship can be attested by many pharmacists and by their example this influence will continue to extend to the oncoming generations of pharmacists. In later years as a member of the college and as a trustee thereof and especially as the chairman of the committee on instruc- tion, it was my privilege to become more closely allied with him and better acquainted with his work as a teacher and his services as the dean. Likewise, in the American Pharmaceutical Associa- tion and as a member of the Committee of Revision of the Pharma- copoeia of the United States, our interviews were frequent and our correspondence voluminous. In these I often obtained a closer view of the character and determination of Professor Remington and learned of his remarkable knowledge of men and their mental peculiarities. Above all, I learned of his ability as a leader, which enabled him to enthuse others and obtain their best efforts. It was this latter qualification that made him so successful as chairman of the committee of revision of the Pharmacopoeia. In the Eighth and Ninth Decennial Revisions of the U. S. P., we have an established record of his efficiency as chairman, and the progress made and the advanced scientific standing of these revisions can be very largely attributed to the ability and indefatigable efforts of the chairman. Following the illustrious examples of Procter and Parrish, Professor Remington nobly carried on the work that they had com- menced and has established the teaching of pharmacy on a solid foundation. His monumental literary works, “The Practice of Pharmacy” and the pharmacy of the United States Dispensatory, mark his preeminent position as an author in this, his chosen field. Professor Remington has left a record replete with accomplishments for pharmacy. MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. 17 To know him was but to admire; to work with him was an inspiration, and to carry on his plans for the advancement of pharmacy becomes now a sacred duty. GEORGE M. BERINGER. CAMDEN, N. J., January 4, 1918. Resolutions from the Pennsylvania Pharmaceutical Association were read as follows: The PENNSYLVANIA PHARMACEUTICAL ASSOCIATION, through the undersigned committee, begs leave to present the following resolutions to the Memorial Meeting in honor of Professor Joseph Price Remington at the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy, January 4, 1918. WHEREAs our Heavenly Father has called from our midst Joseph Price Remington, one of the founders and a former Presi- dent of the Pennsylvania Pharmaceutical Association, and WHEREAs, Professor Remington, through his loyalty and devo- tion to the interests of pharmacy generally and the Pennsylvania Pharmaceutical Association in particular, endeared himself to all of our members, and WHEREAS it is felt that pharmacy, through his passing away, has lost one of its greatest men who, as a teacher, author, associa- tion worker and adviser, left the impress of his character with thousands of students, pharmacists, chemists, physicians and other men of affairs; therefore, be it Resolved that the Pennsylvania Pharmaceutical Association expresses its keenest regret and sorrow at his passing and extends the sincerest sympathy to the members of his family in their hour of sorrow ; and be it further Resolved, that a copy of these resolutions be spread upon the minutes of the Association, and a copy be sent to the members of his family. \ W. H. KNOEPFEL, Scranton, President, J. A. Koch, Pittsburgh, W. L. CLIFFE, Philadelphia, J. L. LEMBERGER, Lebanon, C. C. CAMPBELL, Pittsburgh, Respectfully submitted, (Signed) ROBERT P. FISCHELIS, Secretary. 1 S MIEMORIAL MEETING TO TROFESSOR REM INGTON. Then followed the reading of the resolutions prepared by a com- mittee appointed by the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy, pre- sented by Joseph W. England, chairman of the committee. IN MEMORIAM Joseph PRICE REMINGTON, 1847–1918. WHEREAs, In the demise of Joseph Price Remington, American pharmacy has lost its foremost figure and the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy its most distinguished son, therefore be it Resolved, that we, the members of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy, in special meeting assembled, express our deep sorrow at his passing and pay tribute to his work and worth. As a pharmacist, he labored in all the branches of pharma- ceutical practice, retail, wholesale and manufacturing, acquiring an unusually wide experience. He was graduated from the Phila- delphia College of Pharmacy in 1866, the subject of his thesis being “Our Alma Mater, Its Rise and Progress,” little dreaming, perhaps, that he was destined to become a most important factor in its de- velopment during the next fifty years. As an educator, he was trained by Edward Parrish and Wil- liam Procter, Jr., two of the greatest pharmacists that American pharmacy produced in the last century. In 1874 he was elected to the chair of theory and practice of pharmacy of his alma mater, later becoming also professor of operative pharmacy and director of the pharmaceutical laboratory (1877) and then dean of the college (1803). He has taught thousands of students. He was an impressive teacher, presenting his subjects in a logical and practical manner; his language was clear and forcible and his voice distinct and penetrating. He had a magnetic personality and his lectures made a deep and lasting impression. He was the students’ friend, beloved by all. He may have been said to have been a teacher of teachers, for most of the successful teachers of pharmacy in America to-day have been pupils of his at some time in their careers. Not only this, but he exercised a potential influence upon phar- maceutical education, generally, being most active in developing many improvements and important changes in methods of teach- ing. His method of instruction in operative pharmacy led to the creation of a pharmaceutical laboratory in the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy, the first of its kind in this country, the essential features of which have been adopted by nearly all of the colleges MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. I9 of pharmacy in the United States, and he was the first to visualize the importance and necessity of teaching commercial pharmacy in schools of pharmacy and to establish such a course. As an author of pharmaceutical textbooks, he had a national and international reputation. He was the author of the ‘Practice of Pharmacy, first issued in 1885, used in every college of pharmacy in this country, and widely known abroad, the associate editor of the United States Dispensatory since 1879, the fifteenth edition of which was published in 1883. This edition and the later ones have proved to be the most successful ever issued. Prior to 1883, the work was edited entirely by physicians; since then American pharmacy has been honored by having placed upon the title page of this book the name of a pharmacist as one of its editors and has been properly recognized in its relation to medicine. As a member of the American Pharmaceutical Association he was most active. Joining in 1867, he served the Association in many capacities, being a regular attendant at the annual meetings, taking a leading part in the discussions and presenting papers on many important subjects, as the volumes of the Proceedings and Journal since 1868 bear ample testimony. His good judgment and safe advice were constantly in demand. He was chairman of many important committees. He proposed the plan which was adopted for the establishment of the council in 1880 and was its chairman for seven years. In 1887, he elaborated a plan for the reorganiza- tion of the Association, dividing the scientific work into sections, and secured its adoption. He was president in 1892–93 and permanent secretary in 1893–94. - In 1887, the American Pharmaceutical Association appointed him as a delegate to visit the American Medical Association, and he induced that Association to establish a section of materia medica and pharmacy, which has since become the Section of Pharmacology and Therapeutics. He was chairman of delegations subsequently sent to this Association, and on such occasions rendered valuable service in bringing the professions of medicine and pharmacy into closer relationship. Not only in national pharmaceutical affairs was he active, but he took a deep interest in the growth and development of state asso- ciations, frequently attending their annual meetings, making ad- dresses and presenting papers. He was one of the charter members 2O MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. of the Pennsylvania Pharmaceutical Association in 1878 and its president in 1890. As an executive and leader of men he had international fame. He was president of the Seventh International Pharmaceutical Con- gress (1893), a delegate to the Pan-American Medical Congress (1893) and to the Second Congress in Mexico (1896); represented the United States in the Eighth International Pharmaceutical Con- gress at Brussels (1896) and was president of the Pharmaceutical Section of the Eighth International Congress of Applied Chemistry (1912). He received the honorary degree of Master in Pharmacy from the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy and from the North- western University of Illinois the honorary degree of Doctor of Pharmacy, Phar.D. He was a Fellow of the Chemical, the Linnaean and the Royal Microscopical Societies of Great Britain; honorary member of the Pharmaceutical Gesellschaft zu St. Peters- burg, Institute Medica Nacional of Mexico, Societé Royal de Phar- macie de Bruxelles, Societé de Pharmacie d’Anvers; an active member of the Philosophical Society, American Chemical Society, American Geographical Society, Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia, Historical Society of Pennsylvania; honorary member of the Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain, British Pharma- ceutical Conference; member of the Federatione Internationale Pharmaceutique of The Hague, Franklin Inn Club of Philadelphia, Chemists’ Club of New York and Authors’ Club of London. But his greatest work probably was as chairman of the com- mittee of revision of the Pharmacopoeia of the United States of America, a work which has become of vast importance by reason of its legal standing under the Federal and State Food and Drug Acts. His connection with the U. S. Pharmacopoeia began in 1877, when he served on an auxiliary committee of revision. In 1880, I890, and 1900 he was sent as a delegate of the Philadelphia Col- lege of Pharmacy to the national conventions and in these served as first vice-chairman of the final committee of revision. Upon the death of the chairman of the committee in 1901, Professor Remington was made chairman, and was again elected in 1910, holding the position until his death. The Ninth Revision, issued in 1916, may be truly called his monument, since the whole work is stamped with his personality. As a man, ‘we ne'er shall look upon his like again.’ ‘Genial, MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. 2 I eloquent, clean-hearted and clear-minded,’ possessed of unusual natural ability coupled with rare executive capacity, he served his day and generation, loyally and enthusiastically, and left a record of achievement that may well serve as an example to future generations. Just a personal note: Professor Remington was gifted with a charming personality. His courtesy, his tact, his ability to adapt himself to all types of people, made friends of all those he met, while his strong, clean intellect served to inspire them. The mean- ing of his departure from life may be expressed in the following lines from S. Weir Mitchell’s beautiful poem, ‘Evening': “I know the night is now at hand, The mists lie low on hill and bay, The autumn sheaves are dewless, dry, But I have had the day. Yes, I have had, dear Lord, the day: When at Thy call I have the night, Brief be the twilight as I pass From light to dark, from dark to light.” Resolved, that this appreciation be entered upon the minutes of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy, and a copy sent to the family of the deceased. J. W. ENGLAND, Chairman, SAMUEL P. SADTLER, CHARLES H. LAWALL, JULIUS STURMER, HARRY K. MULFORD, Committee. PHILADELPHIA, January 4, 1918. After the reading of the above resolutions of the College, the president announced that a motion to adopt was in order. Pro- fessor Eberle moved an amendment, as follows: I would like to move a recognition of the appropriate words in which these resolutions have been presented and that we acknowl- edge the sentiments as our own views by a rising vote. The motion was unanimously carried by a rising vote. The following are the resolutions adopted and presented by the Faculty of the College: 2 2. MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. & PHILADELPHIA, January 4, 1918. At a meeting of the faculty of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy held this day, the following resolutions were unanimously adopted: WHEREAs, Providence has seen fit to end the earthly career of one of our number and has taken from our midst our beloved associate, Professor Joseph P. Remington, our senior member, and one endeared to us all by years of association, we would Resolve that we hereby express our sense of the loss which is brought home to us personally as his associates, assistants, and colleagues of many years, during which his friendship, counsel and kindly help were constantly at our command. We would also express our sense of the great loss which the College has suffered in the death of one who was not only its most distinguished alumnus, but who stood for years as a tower of strength, as its most eminent representative among the educational forces of the pharmaceutical profession. Not only did he, as a pharmaceutical author and writer, do credit to our institution throughout the world by the international reputation he developed, but he worked incessantly as official and unofficial delegate and visitor to further the interests of pharma- ceutical education and advancement, as illustrated in the work of our College. We would also call to mind the sense of loss which will be felt by hundreds of his former students to whom he was not merely a memory but had continued a personal friend and frequent helper and advisor. t Resolved that we tender to his family our deep sympathy in their hour of bereavement and express the hope that they be com- forted by the belief that he has gone to his eternal reward. (Signed) SAMUEL P. SADTLER, CLEMENT B. Lowe, FRANK X. MoERK, Committee. President French then called on various friends and associates to give expression to their appreciation of and esteem for Professor Remington, the first being Professor Emeritus Samuel P. Sadtler, who has been connected with the college for many years and asso- ciated with Professor Remington in many activities. He spoke as follows: MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. 23 Mr. Chairman and Gentlemen, Friends of the College, Friends of the late Professor Remington: It is, of course, a very personal and therefore a very hard matter for me to talk this afternoon. I became acquainted with Joseph Price Remington first in 1878, when I was called here to assist the late Dr. Bridges in the lectures on chemistry. We became very intimately acquainted, shortly there- after, as we both worked from 1880 on at the U. S. Dispensatory, and from that time our association was very close and we came to know each other very well. Independently of that work, our con- stant association in the teaching work of the College and later on the U. S. P. Revision Committee brought us into closer contact. All this threw me constantly into association with him. Therefore I feel a great personal loss. The feeling of that loss will be a re- current one, not to-day alone, but repeatedly. I want to speak more particularly of the loss which this college and pharmacy generally will sustain in the death of Professor Rem- ington. He was not only the most widely known and honored pro- fessor of this college and the dean of the college, but we may properly say that he took the whole burden of looking after the name and interests of the college throughout the world. Wherever pharmacists were gathered he was looked upon as the typical repre- sentative of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy. His loss will be felt, not only to-day, but through succeeding years. American pharmacy has suffered a great loss. Many of the gentlemen here will testify, from personal knowledge, that he was in touch with every phase of these varied activities probably more than any other man in the United States, not only in the teaching of pharmacy but in presenting pharmacy and its achievements to the public, and later in making up that great summary of pharmaceutical teaching for the medical and pharmaceutical professions, the United States Pharmacopoeia, which has moreover, since the passage of the Food and Drug Act, become the legal standard for the purity of drugs and medicinal preparations. The work that he did on the U. S. Dispensatory and his own ‘Practice of Pharmacy,” beginning in 1883, must also be remembered. In all of these lines he was active and foremost, taking the work of several men on his own shoulders. He had reached the age of three score and ten and any years that remained after that must be considered as a gift of Providence. While he could not 24 MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. have continued to work with the same energy it would have been well if he could have been spared as a counsellor. Of course, when people reach that age we do not expect much more of activity, but the man who retains his faculties can be a valuable aid and adviser to younger men. I have said that I have a sense of personal loss and I have tried to point out the loss which the profession of pharmacy and the teaching of pharmacy will experience in his death. We shall only begin to realize this as succeeding years roll by. - President French then said: You will pardon the chair for giving a personal experience. My first acquaintance with Professor Remington started in 1855 or 56. Possibly I have known him longer than anyone in this room, as we started our friendship play- ing together as boys. - His loyalty to the college has always been an inspiration to me and for many years we have worked together for the benefit of this old institution. He and I looked forward with great interest to the centenary of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy, which will take place in March, 1921. I presume that I have been connected with this institution possibly as long, or perhaps longer than any man living to-day—50 years last October; and during this association and connection I came into close contact with Professor Remington, and I have learned to respect and honor him. He was a strong character, firmly believing that he was doing the best, by his devotion to the college, for pharmaceutical learning throughout the world. His loss to us is a serious one and I realize what a burden has fallen upon the shoulders of those who are left. We shall have to do our best to follow his example and emulate the loyalty he so frequently expressed for the institution. He then called upon the following to pay tribute to Professor Remington in the order given: - Professor J. W. Sturmer, Associate Dean of the College: PROFESSOR REMINGTON, THE TEACHER. Man is a bundle of many attributes—some of them reciprocally synergistic, some of them seemingly incompatible; and while it may be difficult to sum up a great man's work in a few brief words, it is more difficult still to explain how he achieved his results and to MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. 25 name those personal characteristics of his which made them pos- sible. But it is not my purpose to marshal in review the many achievements of Professor Remington and to disclose the secret of his success. I desire merely—with a sad heart—to lay my humble twig of laurel upon his grave. And I will speak, Mr. Chairman, of Professor Remington, the teacher, for whatever else he was and whatever else he accom- plished, he was primarily and fundamentally a teacher, a teacher of the first rank. What qualifications are necessary to a great teacher? We are informed that a teacher of pharmacy should have acquired a certain sum of knowledge, should have attained to cer- tain scholastic degrees. But a pool of water, even though it be a large one, does not necessarily constitute water power; and a man who is a great reservoir of knowledge is not necessarily a great teacher. Professor Remington was a great teacher because he possessed, in addition to the requisite learning, that fine altruistic spirit which made him desirous to help others, to give, to give to his students of his knowledge, of his time, of his energy. of his wisdom. Further, he had a keen insight into human nature. He understood men, knew the youthful mind, could sense the attitude of his classes. He appreciated that students are not uniform units which could be dealt with en masse, but that each represented a distinct individual, a distinct personality. Hence his great success in establishing those cordial relations, indeed personal friendships, which did not cease with the students’ college days. When I–a youth of twenty-one—had been appointed an assistant in a distant university, my preceptor, a graduate of this college, told me about a visit he had just paid to his former teacher, Professor Remington, who received him with a warmth of welcome which came from the heart and which made of this visit an instance to be treasured in the memory. ‘Young man’ Said my preceptor, “make your students like you, as Professor Remington makes his students like him, and you will succeed as a teacher.” A strange coincidence, that fortune associated me on the same faculty, during the past few years of his life, with the great teacher who had been pointed out as an exemplar. Nature had endowed Professor Remington splendidly. He had a commanding presence, a clear, pleasing voice, and a smile which was infectious. In his discourses, he ran the gamut of didactic exposition, humorous anecdotes, and thrilling bursts of im- passioned oratory. 26 MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. Is it any wonder that he was a great energizing force, a catalytic agent, who stimulated his students to study and to work, not only during their college days, but for life? And to-day, thou- sands of his graduates throughout this broad land are performing worth while work in this work-a-day world, dispensing, compound- ing, manufacturing, inventing, writing, teaching. What Huxley did for biology and Tyndal for physical science, Professor Remington did for pharmaceutical science; he popularized it, gave it a human interest, gave it life. His activities have now ceased; he has laid away the crayon and the pointer of the class room and folded his hands for the long, mysterious rest. But the fruits of his labors will grow through the years. As long as illness and pain are the common portion of the sons of men, there will be need for the makers of medicine. Pharmacy therefore, will endure, and so will also the fame of its great teacher—Professor Joseph Price Remington. Dr. Harvey. W. Wiley, President of the U. S. Pharmacopoeial Convention spoke as follows: Mr. President, Ladies and Gentlemen: I am here in two capaci- ties to-day. I am here to represent, first of all, the Pharmacopoeial Convention and the board of trustees thereof, and secondly, in my private capacity. I want to speak first of Professor Remington's work in a professional way. I think very few of you realize, except those who have worked with him, the magnitude of the work which he undertook. Fortunately, he came to the Ninth Revision with a very valuable experience which he gained in the Eighth Revision, so that he was the ideal person to head the great revision committee, both in professional ability and experience. I learned a great deal of the magnitude of the work during the past eight years, and I have often wondered how he could physically and mentally endure the great strain that was placed upon him. He did not. I doubt not at all that his death was very much hastened by his labor on the Ninth Decennial Revision. But he would not withhold his hand in fear of death, although I have asked him to do so, because, in my opinion, he considered the one place to die, of all others, is in harness, and if Professor Remington had known that he could have prolonged his life by declining the burden. I am sure he would not have done so. As I look back upon the last eight years, I have more MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. 27 and more come to realize that Professor Remington was the great stabilizer. You know they are using the gyroscope now to stabilize ships upon the sea. The tendency of the gyroscope is to remain, by reason of inertia, in statu quo, and when it revolves it remains in that position and it takes great force to push it aside, one way or the other; so if you have a gyroscope in full action it will hold the ship in position. The effect that Dr. Remington had upon the great work of revision was that of the gyroscope. He held it true to its course, and no one knows more than I the forbearance he had to exercise to hold it so. There were very many intricate questions to decide, and if there had been a man of less ability than Professor Reming- ton at the helm, he could not have steered the ship clear of all dangers and brought the revision committee through. That alone stamped him as a man of great character and force. No one who took any part in these deliberations would fail to recognize his strong guiding power and resistance to pressure. One of our great authors, Emerson, I think it was, has de- scribed character as the grass, which is flexible and not firm; every wind moves it. As it grows up it will not yield as it did before. So with human character. It is not so much education and heredity, but the result of experience, and when guided by a heart which is always true and a brain which is always clear, every experience of life builds character. No wonder that Professor Remington ap- proached the end of his life with such a character; his great care was always to avoid the wrong and uphold the right. This is the view I have gained of him during the years of association with him. One of his great monuments is the Ninth Revision of the U. S. Pharmacopoeia. It is his book. Louis XIV spoke of the state and said ‘C'est moi’—‘It is I.’ So, in speaking of the U. S. Pharmacopoeia, we can say ‘C'est lui'—‘It is he.’ And so, as the official head of the organization which produced this book, I have come to pay tribute to his memory. “That I can do rather easily, but when I come to the second part of my theme I feel it almost impossible to say what I should like to say, and that is about Professor Remington as a friend. I have known him considerably over a third of a century. His was a. friendship which grew upon one, as one knew more and more his Worth and loyalty, and I could have shown no better illustration of 28 MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. my friendship than in the christening of my first boy. My wife kindly permitted me to choose the godfathers and I chose Joseph P. Remington and John Uri Lloyd, and I am glad to know that my boy, now approaching his sixth year, will realize (he does realize now) his loss at the death of his godfather and realize it more and more as he grows older. What a blessing he had in two such godfathers! There is nothing in my personal history that I prize more than that event. And so I have learned to prize Remington more and more as the years go by. I do not quite agree with Professor Sadtler in saying that when a man is seventy, he perhaps is not of much more use in life. If I had quit at seventy I would not be here to-day; I am seventy-four. I feel that it is hardly a compensation for our loss to think of Pro- fessor Remington as having lived his whole life. No good man ever lives his whole life. The old adage says that the good die young. I have seen a clever addition to that saying—‘The good die young, no matter how long they live,’ and Remington would have died young had he lived to a century, because he had in him the spring of eternal youth. No man grows old whose heart is young. The beautiful words of one of your local poets, Dr. S. Weir Mitchell, have already been quoted here, and may I return to one of my friends of 2000 years ago in endeavoring to express to you the feeling I have to-day? The old Latin poet said ‘Nil ego contulerim jucundo Sanus amico’—‘As long as I am in my right mind I shall never prefer anything to a delightful friend’; and so I say that as long as I am in my right mind I shall never prefer anything to the delight I have had in the association with this friend. Prof. J. A. Koch, dean of the Pittsburgh College of Pharmacy said: I have come to pay tribute to the memory of my friend, Pro- fessor Remington. I do not know when I first met him, but I do remember when I first learned to know him. It was here in this building, twenty years ago, just after I first took up my duties at the Pittsburgh College of Pharmacy. I came to see Professor Rem- ington and the advice he gave me and the goodness of heart with which he took up my case were overwhelming. I have, from that time on, felt that I had in him a friend. It has been my good fortune to meet him very frequently and I was especially fortunate MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. 29 in being able, in 1913, to spend seven weeks with him when we were together as delegates to the International Pharmaceutical Congress from the American Pharmaceutical Association, and I then learned to know him as I never would have learned to know him in any other way. I felt very much pleased to think that he liked me and liked to have me with him; that was what he told me. I feel very proud of that. I have simply come to pay tribute to his memory and to mourn with you your loss. Mr. J. L. Lemberger, Lebanon, vice-president of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy: I have had in my heart the last few days a feeling of the greatest sadness of my life, the parting with my dear friend, Pro- fessor Remington. We had known each other intimately for perhaps thirty years or more. We were as intimate as two brothers almost. I had his confidence in many things; he had my confidence in many things. There was but one side to Professor Remington— he was all around right. He was moved to do right by a con- scientious desire to do so. Can I say anything better of our de- parted friend? I knew him well enough to know that it was a principle of his life. In the many things we had in common, American Pharma- ceutical Association, Pennsylvania Pharmaceutical Association, this dear old college, our alma mater, when we came to sift down to what we would call the bottom facts of the thing (his name is Joseph and my name is Joseph; we knew each other as “Joe”), our conclusion always was, ‘Joe, we must do right in this matter.” Can we have a pleasanter memory of a good man than to think of him as having been conscientious in all matters of life, moved by a desire to do right? “I went out to the cemetery and looked into the open grave and said ‘Farewell’; not good-bye forever, but “Farewell.’ The memory of his life will come to me every time I enter this college and every time I go to an association meeting, and we shall think of Reming- ton; what a great delight it will be to have such a memory of a friend. He lived a good life, a useful life, and he had a joyous disposition, a magnetic disposition. He filled the room with his presence, whether in the college or in the circle of that dear home of his. His end came peacefully indeed, very peacefully. His end k. 3O MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. was such as we might desire to be ours, when the time comes, and a hallowed thought is ‘May our lives be as fruitful as his was; when we come to the end may our end be as was his.' We think of him now, not as a loss to us, but as living on, on, on, in that world, where ‘Eye hath not seen nor ear heard, neither has it entered into the heart of man to conceive, the joy that our dear Brother Rem- ington is now enjoying. Prof. H. V. Arny, professor of organic chemistry in the New York College of Pharmacy: Mr. Chairman: I am here in more than one capacity, not merely in the rôle of a student mourning the loss of his great teacher, but also as the official representative of the New York College of Pharmacy. Dean Rusby asked me to express particularly to the sister institution the profound feeling of sympathy in the loss of your dean and the great regret that his college duties prevented him from coming himself. I wish, however, to particularly emphasize the feeling of personal loss. In Mr. Beringer’s letter, mention was made of the great triumvirate of teachers; I will add a fourth to the list—Maisch, Sadtler, Remington and Trimble. These four men, I think, exercised a greater influence upon pharmacy than any other four men ever did, standing as disciples not only of true pharmacy, but also of sceince, and of these four there was none that we recognize as greater than our departed friend. I will even go so far as to say that all the success I have had in teaching I attribute very largely to Professor Remington. I owe him a debt of eternal gratitude. He had a way of taking a dry fact and of connecting it with an anecdote that impressed it on the mind, as no other teacher I know of could do. It has been my privilege to hear many great teachers, but in my opinion, there was none superior to Professor Remington as far as beauty of diction or interest is concerned. My heart is too heavy to say more, except that it is not merely as a teacher, but as a personal friend of Professor Remington that I wish to say a word. He was always courteous, even when he differed from a man; he was always the same sweet, gentle, kindly man. I am here chiefly as a mourner; I have lost one of the dearest and best of friends. MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. 3 I Mr. Samuel L. Hilton of Washington, D. C., treasurer of the board of trustees of the U. S. Pharmacopoeial Convention: Mr. President, Ladies and Gentlemen: It was my privilege some thirty years ago to become acquainted with Professor Rem- ington. I now consider it a privilege to have the opportunity to pay tribute to his memory. The acquaintance of such a man was an inspiration to me. It led me to follow his advice, his counsel, and to look upon many subjects from the point of view of what is right and what is wrong, so that I feel I made few mistakes in con- sidering questions pertaining to pharmaceutical subjects when I looked upon them from the viewpoint of Remington. I have been associated with him in various kinds of work for years. We frequently called on each other and I have learned to love him. In the loss of Professor Remington, American pharmacy has lost its brightest light. It has lost a man who has done more for the advancement of pharmacy than any other man for the past twenty-five years. My heart is full; I do not possess the words that are necessary. There is no one in American pharmacy for whom I had greater respect. On many occasions I have called at this institution to seek his advice and I have always found him correct and wise in his judg- ment. I have differed with him and he has always taken it in the proper spirit. This is an occasion when every one connected with pharmacy feels his loss. In U. S. P. work during the last two decades, Professor Remington has been the man upon whom every- one in connection with that work has depended. Dr. Wiley has said that he had the faculty of bringing divergent views together in a way that was best for medicine and pharmacy. Is there any higher tribute that can be paid to the memory of Professor Remington? His name will go down in history with that of Procter and Maisch. Mr. Caswell A. Mayo, editor of the American Druggist, New York: For many years it has been my great privilege to have known Professor Remington. I knew him first as a teacher. I came here, a callow youth, from the state of Mississippi, with a little knowledge of pharmacy and science, called here by the great reputation my alma mater enjoyed as a teacher of men. I think that Professor Remington had, to an extent which I have never seen equaled, the peculiar capacity which is required of a successful teacher. 32 MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. Many teachers are wise, many have many attainments, but no ability to inspire in their students that zeal for study, that desire to avail themselves of all the opportunities which the institution offers, which he possessed in so eminent a degree. I think one of the best monuments of his life is in the teachers he taught. Others have spoken of him as being preeminently a teacher of teachers. I think there is hardly an institution of pharmacy in the United States where you will not find teachers made by him. After I had progressed somewhat in my pharmaceutical career, I became an observer of men, and next a critic and writer. In the latter capacity I had an opportunity to study Professor Remington's work in every phase. As an editor he was remarkably successful. One of his peculiar characteristics was brought out in a conversa- tion which I had with him about his new ‘Practice of Pharmacy.’ He had been very kind to me and knowing that I was going into journalism, was discussing the various phases of it, and said, ‘Now, Mayo, I have been criticized and people said that I did not write the “Practice of Pharmacy,” but that A. B. Taylor wrote it. A man’s personal capacity is limited; he must enlist the intelligent coöpera- tion of other men if he wants to make a success. The Philadelphia idea (this was thirty years ago) has been that a man does not do a thing if he does not actually do it with his own hands. It is a mis- take, he must do it with his brains. My book is a success inasmuch as I have directed the making of it.’ He has had throughout his life the faculty of directing and showed it in a remarkable degree in the U. S. Pharmacopoeia. As an association worker I became associated with him, and I have always been impressed by his quality of being a stabilizer, as Dr. Wiley says. I have heard, at meetings, the most bitter vituperation and people have come to the pass when they called each other names. Professor Remington would step in and stabilize the discussion and point out the moderate ground where all could meet, in a way that would lead the entire discussion, by his superior insight, into the real crux of the questions. I have seen him in his home, his de- lightful home, especially at Longport. He had a genius for friend- ship. I only wish that my words were equal to my thoughts and my disposition to do justice to him. As a teacher he was un- equaled; as an association worker he was the great organizer; as an editor he was careful, accurate and painstaking; as a friend he was kind, cordial and helpful. MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. 33 Dr. H. C. Wood, Jr., vice-chairman of the U. S. P. committee of revision, Philadelphia: My father was an associate and friend of Professor Reming- ton and I cannot remember the time when I did not know Professor Remington. I have seen him at various associations and I have wondered at his diplomatic skill in difficult situations, to which Mr. Mayo has referred. I have read his books and have sat at his feet and have marveled at the breadth of his scientific knowledge. I have visited in his home and have been charmed by his genius for hospitality. I have had the privilege of working with him for fifteen years on the U. S. Dispensatory and have more recently been associated with him in the work of the U. S. P. revision committee— privileges which I highly esteem. He was a great educator, states- man, scientist and friend. He is not gone; his spirit remains with us and will remain to inspire us as long as we are left. Prof. E. G. Eberle, editor of the Journal of the American Pharmaceutical Association, Philadelphia: It is difficult to speak of Professor Remington now ; he is too near for the full worth of the man to appear. We who have known him intimately for many years have suffered a bereavement that we cannot speak of in words that are adequate, but time will bring this loss into evidence. What now might seem fulsome eulogy will be found insufficient to wholly express the true character and inex- pressible loss to pharmacy by his death. Frederick M. Davenport said, ‘Let none suppose that any crowd of American college boys ever sat for one year or two years at the feet of a college professor without knowing the substance of that man. There is nothing human that I know of so near infallible as the final estimate that college men put upon an instructor.” The graduates of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy, with few, if any, exceptions, revere Professor Remington; there are not very many teachers who retain the continued friendship of the alumni as did Professor Remington. I knew him as a teacher and almost adored him, and soon after my graduation it fell to my lot to be associated with him in one way or another, and I greatly re- spected him; further years brought me into closer touch and I loved him as a friend. At this time we can speak of him best by a survey of his 34 MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. activities, his relations with others, his leadership in pharmaceutical endeavor, which will give us a more unbiased judgment of the man than personal expressions that may be influenced by our deep sorrow. For half a century Professor Remington was identified with the de- velopment of pharmacy and during many years of this time, on account of his prominence, he was subject to the most critical judg- ment of his confreres and collaborators, and he stood the qualify- ing test of a competent leader and great man, which speaks more than any encomium possibly could. Professor Remington was genial, most hospitable, amiable, for- giving. His happy humor, his kind and loving sentiments added charm to his wise, practical thoughts. A great American pharma- cist has left our ranks; we have profited by his works and endured a loss by his death which will be more deeply recognized as time passes. Dr. F. E. Stewart, chairman of the committee appointed from the Philadelphia Branch of the American Pharmaceutical Associa- tion, read the resolutions from that body, as follows: IN MEMORIAM WHEREAS, Almighty God, in his eternal wisdom, has taken from our midst our beloved brother, Professor Joseph Price Rem- ington, we, the members of the Philadelphia Branch of the Ameri- can Pharmaceutical Association, express our deep sorrow at his loss, Professor Remington, whose death we mourn, was an inter- national figure in the pharmaceutical circles of the world; in his death, pharmacy has lost its most prominent chieftain. As presi- dent of the American Pharmaceutical Association and one of the founders of the Philadelphia Branch; as president of the Penn- Sylvania Pharmaceutical Association; as chairman of many im- portant delegations; as a member of numerous scientific bodies in this country and abroad; as professor of pharmacy in the Phila- delphia College of Pharmacy and for many years its dean; as author of “Remington's Pharmacy,’ a textbook wherever pharmacy is taught; as chairman of the committee of revision of the United States Pharmacopoeia; as joint author with Professors Sadtler and Wood of the United States Dispensatory, he occupied a position of unique distinction and influence. No man left a more helpful im- MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. 35 pression upon the pharmacy of the entire world than Professor Remington. In foreign countries, when the king dies the people cry, “The King is dead; long live the King!' It is for us to cry, ‘The King is dead; who shall reign in his stead?’ Resolved, That we spread this memorial upon the minutes of the Philadelphia Branch of the American Pharmaceutical Associa- tion, and send a copy of the same to his family in testimony of our Sympathy and appreciation. } (Signed for the Committee) F. E. STEwART, M.D., Phar.D., Chairman. Dr. Stewart then added his personal appreciation of Professor Remington in these words: I desire to express my personal feelings, not only representing the Philadelphia Branch of the American Pharmaceutical Associa- tion, but also representing the class of 1876, this class being the one to which Professor Remington gave his first course of lectures. During the many years since that time, there has hardly been a year that I have not had an occasion to personally confer with Pro- fessor Remington, and I was always received with courtesy and consideration. His loss is a great blow to us as members of the college and members of the faculty. Prof. Charles H. LaWall, Professor Remington's associate in the department of the theory and practice of pharmacy at the Col- lege, then spoke as follows: I am filled with such emotion in consequence of the events which have preceded this meeting that I can do but feeble justice to the feelings in my heart at the present time. I have been asso- ciated with Professor Remington for eighteen years, probably in a closer way than many of those who have preceded me. I have worked with him, I have traveled with him, and I have played with him, because he was one of those few men who knew how to play. So few men realize that to work well one must also take a certain amount of recreation. I have learned to know, love and respect him in a higher degree than I have had a respect and love for and knowl- edge of any other man in the world. I have been associated with him in a teaching capacity and during those eighteen years I have been 36 MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. a student at his feet, because one could always learn from him; he had such a boundless fund of information on almost every subject. They say that he who influences the thought of his own time influences all eternity. Therefore, we know that the influence of Joseph P. Remington will go on forever, so long as pharmacy is a science. There is another phase of his character that has not been dwelt upon, and which I knew very well. That is his cleanness of heart and soul. I never knew a man who had that innocent view of things for a man of mature years to such a degree as he had. He had that kind of cleanness that is contagious. I have observed him in gather- ings of men and I have seen him enter the smoking compartment of a Pullman car, where sometimes stories are told that are somewhat risque, and without apparently exercising any conscious influence on the conversation, direct it into healthful channels, by his personal magnetism introducing a clean tone into the atmosphere. There- fore, I have always felt that he exemplified Kipling's phrase “In simpleness and gentleness, in honor and clean mirth,’ because if there ever was a man who was clean it was Professor Remington. So far as his personal magnetism was concerned, everyone must pay tribute to that; it was his outstanding characteristic. He had the faculty of making friends of his enemies. ‘Every pilot can steer the ship in calms but he performs a skilful task who can manage it in storms.” In piloting an association over the shoals of some apparently insuperable difficulty or some committee over the reefs of personal differences, he exercised his powers to the fullest extent. Then followed Dr. C. B. Lowe, professor of materia medica at the college: I have been pleasantly associated with Professor Remington for a third of a century, and during that time I have found him a kind friend whom I shall miss very much. I should like to para- phrase an author's lines, as follows: “Dear friend, we’ve lived long together, Through sunshine and through cloudy weather; Say not “Good night,” But in some brighter clime, Bid me ‘Good morning.’” MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. 37 Prof. E. Fullerton Cook, associate director of the pharma- ceutical laboratory of the college, voiced his appreciation as follows: In paying tribute to the memory of my friend, Joseph Price Remington, I need not cite his achievements or his services to pharmacy. These you know. I might speak of his affable manner, his keen insight into character and motives, his courage in standing unwaveringly for what he thought to be right, his infinite pains to attain perfection in the work in hand, his strong sense of duty when responsibility was accepted, and of other notable qualities; but these are to-day builded into permanent record, into this college he loved, into the U. S. Pharmacopoeia of four decades, into his own publica- tions, and best of all, into the memories we hold. They speak for themselves. The world I wish to give, therefore, is more personal ; the im- pressions from an intimate relationship of many years, almost as close as that of father and son. One of the outstanding facts soon recognized was that Professor Remington was deeply religious. His Quaker training had left a lasting impression. In deciding small or large questions, he would frequently speak of ‘waiting for the voice,” with perfect faith in its right guidance. This belief powerfully influenced his action and kept it true to high ideals. Another quality which I believe I may speak of here, espe- cially since at times he was misunderstood, was the entire absence of a spirit of revenge. He was not small in his dealings with men. Yet he was not weak or afraid, for if he believed a policy pursued by someone or a group of men was not for the best interests of the profession he did not hesitate to attack it, but he did it openly and without underhand or political pressure methods. To have it insinuated that he was unfair or had taken advantage of his posi- tion, hurt him keenly, and he would frequently go far out of his way to show special consideration to those who seemed to want to believe him unfair and in his official positions he voluntarily set for himself a standard of action which was above reproach and even considered extreme and unnecessary by Some of those who knew his customs and convictions. One of the charms of his personality was his appreciation of humor and his stories are repeated broadcast, but those who came into intimate contact with him were soon impressed by the elevated 38 MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. and moral plane upon which he kept his stories and his thought. He never sought nor liked it when tainted and never passed it along. The passing of this brilliant life has left a vacancy hard to fill, yet one of his life passions and greatest pleasures has been to teach others and he went without a fear for the future of pharmacy, for he knew that thousands all over the world, “his boys,' would carry on the work he loved. Thus his last and probably greatest lesson to us is that by giving one's self one may attain immortality. Dr. S. P. Stout, a graduate of the college, spoke as follows: I met Professor Remington frequently, especially during col- lege days, but during the last three or four years I met him as man to man. The last time I saw him was in his home last spring. After we had finished our business, I said, ‘I expect to go to war.’ His face lighted up and he said, ‘I would like to go with you. When I get rid of this “plumbago.” (he jokingly called it that) perhaps I will be all right again.' I told him I was going in the Roosevelt Division, and he gave me a wonderful insight into Roose- velt’s character. I came to-day because I have a telegram in my pocket direct- ing me to one of the military camps in a few days. I want to add my tribute. Such men as he have done and are doing a great deal to keep the professions of medicine and pharmacy on a high stand- ard where they belong. President Wilson said we are entering this war to make the world safe for democracy. These men have toiled to make the world safe for professional men. There are too many charlatans and quacks who are trying to make gain out of the misfortunes of others. Many of you have to-day spoken of Maisch, Remington, Wood and Trimble. In the immortal words of Lincoln: ‘It is for us, the living, to be here dedicated to the great task remaining before us, that from these honored dead we take in- creased devotion to the cause to which they gave the last full measure of devotion.’ Lastly, Professor F. X. Moerk, professor of analytical chemistry of the college, paid his tribute to Professor Remington: My personal knowledge of Professor Remington dates back to the session of 1880–81, when Mr. Charles F. Kramer, then a senior student, took me to the college one evening, and I first saw Pro- MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. 39 fessor Remington and later Professor Sadtler, the lecturers of the evening. A few months later, a prescription was brought to the store in which I was employed, calling for an ointment of unknown formula, and I was sent to Professor Remington's store at 13th and Walnut Streets, for information regarding the same. While walk- ing along I3th Street, my attention was drawn to a gentleman coming toward me, who I thought might be Professor Remington, if he had had a full beard. I addressed the gentleman and sure enough it was he. Upon explaining my errand, he stated that Mr. Charles Frederick Zeller, his assistant, would be pleased to give me the desired information. In the fall of 1881, I entered the college and during my student career frequently consulted Professor Remington at the college and at the store and felt that he always took an interest in me. Since graduation, I have continuously held some position in the college, but during the past few years, since my appointment as assistant dean, I have been in close touch with Professor Remington, and during the many, many conferences which were necessary, not a harsh or cross word was uttered. I gladly join the other speakers in paying tribute to one who always upheld the interest of the college. After the telegrams given below, which had been received by the College and Mrs. Remington, were read, the meeting adjourned, with Sad hearts and a feeling that there was a vacancy in the scheme of things pharmaceutical that will be felt for many many years to come. TELEGRAMS RECEIVED BY THE COLLEGE AND MRS. J. P. REMINGTON. The Secretary of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy: The President and members of the Nova Scotia Pharmaceutical Society desire you to convey their sympathy to Professor Remington's family and friends. We have pleasant recollections of the Pro- fessor's visit to Halifax a few years ago, when we learned to esteem his personal qualities as highly as his professional. We unite with you in mourning his loss. G. A. BARBRIDGE, Secretary. President Howard B. French: For the American Conference of Pharmaceutical Faculties, I express the sympathy of the colleges of pharmacy in the United States to you and the members of the P. C. 4O MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. P., in the death of Professor Remington. He was the most mag- netic personality of the century in American pharmacy. HENRY KRAEMER, President. TO THE FACULTY AND MEMBERS OF THE PHILADELPHIA COLLEGE OF PHARMACY : Dear Sirs: I hereby express my sincere sympathy on the death of your dean, Professor Joseph Price Remington, a man who ex- emplified pharmacy in the United States as Hager did in Germany, and who always placed the interest of pharmacy above his own interest, and whose work will be a living monument to those who are inclined to follow his footsteps hereafter, and who personally always practiced and followed the Golden Rule, namely, “Do to others as you expect to be done by,” and without being vindictive to those who differed with him at times. In Professor Remington's death a teacher has been lost who will be very hard to replace. Again expressing my sincere sympathy, I remain, Respectfully, GEORGE DECKER, representing The German Apothecaries’ Society of New York, N. Y. State Pharmaceutical Association, Alumni of the New York College of Pharmacy. Prof. S. P. Sadtler: Serious illness prevents my leaving. COBLENTZ. G. M. Beringer: I regret that indisposition prevents my paying my respects to the memory of Professor Remington, who was my tutor in 1873 and my esteemed and respected friend for nearly forty-five years. His death is a sad loss to the pharmaceutical pro- fession and to me a personal Sorrow. SAMUEL W. FAIRCHILD. Mr. G. M. Beringer: The whole world grieves at the loss of its greatest pharmacist. The Atlanta College of Pharmacy will re- main closed on Friday, the day of the funeral, as a token of grief and sorrow. Have notified all our papers. GEO. F. PAYNE. MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. 4 I The Northwestern Branch of the A. Ph. A. express deepest sympathy in your bereavement. CHAs. H. Rogers, Minneapolis, Minn. Mr. Charles H. LaWall: I want to thank you for the informa- tion regarding Professor Remington's death. It grieves me greatly that I am unable to be present at the memorial services of this really great man. Our alma mater has lost a faithful and potent son, whose geniality and influence brought her much renown. May the seed he has sown ever bring bountiful harvests. * LOUIS EMANUEL. Mrs. Joseph P. Remington: The Meyer Bros. Druggist joins other pharmaceutical publications in extending you sympathy in your bereavement. Your late husband, Professor Joseph Price Reming- ton, worked throughout his long life in promoting the welfare of pharmacy. This is a common cause with the pharmaceutical press. HENRY M. WHELPLEY. Mrs. Joseph P. Remington: The officers, board of trustees and faculty of the St. Louis College of Pharmacy direct me to express their sincere sympathy in your bereavement. Professor Remington was a personal and valued friend of this institution. The Professor honored us with addresses on several occasions. HENRY M. WHELPLEY. Mrs. Joseph P. Remington: The Minneapolis Retail Druggists' Association extend you our heartfelt sympathy in this time of your bereavement in the loss of your husband and father. The memory of Professor Remington will be cherished by pharmacists of the world, the fitting monument of his long and useful career as an educator. HENRY RAUCH, Sec. M. R. D. A. Mrs. Joseph P. Remington: The Minnesota State Pharmaceutical Association extends deepest sympathy to you and family during your hour of sorrow. E. L. NEWCOMB, Sec. 42 MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. Mrs. Joseph P. Remington: We loved and admired Joseph P. Remington, both for his splendid abilities and his personal charm. The world has lost its greatest pharmacist and we one of our most beloved friends. GEO. F. PAYNE. Mrs. Joseph P. Remington: With extreme sorrow announcement of your loss is received. A life full of good works, the death of our professor will be mourned by and mark a serious loss to Ameri- can pharmacy. H. LIONEL MEREDITH, Hagerstown, Md. MRS. Joseph P. REMINGTON. Dear Mrs. Remington: I am advised by the National Drug Trade Conference that owing to the fact of a very important meeting going on at the present time it will be impossible for these delegate mem- bers of that organization to attend the funeral of Professor Rem- ington. Dr. A. R. L. Dohme has named as a Committee from the American Pharmaceutical Association to attend the funeral, Messrs. H. P. Hynson, John F. Hancock, S. L. Hilton, H. M. Whelpley and E. G. Eberle. The National Drug Trade Conference and Dr. A. R. L. Dohme desire me to express their great sorrow and deep regret over your bereavement and to extend to you and all of your family these ex- pressions of sympathy. Respectfully, E. G. EBERLE. Mrs. J. P. Remington: My sincere sympathy. A great man has passed away. FRANK G. RYAN, Detroit, Michigan. Regret I cannot attend services owing to serious illness of wife. Both greatly moved over loss. V. CoBLENTz, Long Branch, N. J. Our deepest sympathy is with you in this hour of sorrow. May He whose love endureth forever solace you. | MEYER BROS. DRUG Co., St. Louis, Mo. MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. 43 Mrs. J. P. Remington: Extend to you and each member of your family heartfelt sympathy at this hour of bereavement. Regret that conditions of travel make it impossible for me to attend funeral. ' Have ordered a suitable wreath on behalf of American Conference of Pharmaceutical Faculties. HENRY KRAEMER, President. Mrs. J. P. Remington: Kindly accept the sympathy of the boys in the twin cities, who were students under Professor Remington at the P. C. P. Our hearts go out to you in this sad hour of your bereavement. Dean Remington is no more; the sympathetic voice which we all knew and loved is no more, but his spirit lives and breathes an inspiration to us all. The warmth of his last hand- shake will linger like a benediction until in that realm revealed to us by faith, we again join the hands of the spirit in the light of the morning that shall have no end. Sincerely your friends, E. L. NEwcom B, F. J. WULLING, C. M. McCoy, H. H. GREGG, C. T. HELLER, W. D. KELLY, F. E. ALLEN, G. M. RUSSELL, J. W. SMELTZER. sº Mrs. J. P. Remington: Please accept my deepest sympathy in your sad bereavement. & CHAS. E. CASPARI, St. Louis, Mo. 44 MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. CoMMUNICATIONS RECEIVED AFTER MEETING. Prof. E. Fullerton Cook: Desire to extend most sincere expression of condolence death of Professor Remington. •º FLORENTINO LOPO FUNDORA. Havana, Cuba. DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE, BUREAU OF CHEMISTRY, WASHINGTON, D. C., January Ninth, 1918. THE TRUSTEES AND FACULTY, PHILADELPHIA COLLEGE OF PHARMACY, Philadelphia, Pa. Gentlemen: In behalf of the Bureau of Chemistry, and of myself personally, permit me to express to you the sympathy of the Bureau in the great loss that has come to your institution through the death of Professor Joseph P. Remington. We, here in the Bureau, who have been working with him in his fundamentally important revision of the pharmacopoeia have an adequate appreciation of his great services to pharmacy, to medicine, and to the country, generally. His loss will be felt far beyond the circle of his personal friends and colleagues. Yours sincerely, CARL L. ALSBERG. NEW YORK, January 4, 1918. MR. HowARD B. FRENCH, President of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy, Philadelphia, Pa. Dear Mr. French: May I just at this moment send a word of personal tribute to the memory of a man for whom I have had the personal regards of a friend and pupil for these many years. For it was my good for- tune to have been a student at the beginning of Professor Rem- ington’s work, and to have been present at his first lecture. MEMORIAL MEETING TO PROFESSOR REMINGTON. 45 In Professor Remington's passing, pharmacy has lost its most distinguished teacher, professor and author, who has given Service to pharmacy from every angle, Substantial, brilliant and enduring. This is too well known and too varied to make any adequate men- tion of it here. It will also bring a sense of personal loss to very many men who will miss him, his friendly and gracious personality, the consideration and moderation which happily tempered his judg- ment and gave influence to his counsel in the many personal rela- tions in which he served his alma mater and his profession. Sincerely yours, BENJAMI IN T. FAIRCHILD. HAVANA, CUBA, January 14, 1918. MR. How ARD B, FRENCH, President of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy, Philadelphia, Pa. Dear Sir: . The Cuban Branch of the American Pharmaceutical Association, in a meeting held on the IOth of this month, resolved to express our feelings of condolence for the irreparable loss suffered by the Col- lege in the death of Professor Joseph P. Remington. With profound sorrow I transmit this action to you. Respectfully yours, José P. ALACAN, Secretary, VEDADO, CUBA, Jan. 14, 1918. MR. HowARD B. FRENCH, President of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy, Philadelphia, Pa. Dear sir: I have learned with profound sorrow of the death of Professor Joseph P. Remington which occurred at his residence, 1832 Pine St. in that City on January Ist. With the death of Professor Remington the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy loses a great teacher, and we all lose a good friend and pharmacy loses a great man. I tender to the College my heartfelt sympathy in the loss which you have sustained. Very cordially yours, José P. ALACAN. 46 ACTION OF NATIONAL DRUG TRADE CONFERENCE. ACTION TAKEN BY THE NATIONAL DRUG TRADE & CONFERENCE. IN MEMORIAM PROFESSOR Joseph PRICE REMINGTON. The funeral of the late Professor Joseph Price Remington oc- curred at Philadelphia, Friday, January 4, 1918, at one o'clock P.M. The National Drug Trade Conference, then in session at Baltimore, adjourned for two hours, out of respect to the eminent deceased; and upon reconvening at three o'clock adopted the following reso- lutions reported by the committee named by a standing vote. WHEREAs, In His wisdom it has pleased Almighty God to take from our midst our distinguished and highly esteemed friend and fellow pharmacist, Joseph Price Remington, and WHEREAs, The services which Joseph Price Remington has ren- dered the people of this entire country, the profession of pharmacy, the entire drug trade and the many thousands of young men who have enjoyed the privilege of being his pupils have been of unusual prominence, extent and excellence, and WHEREAs, The Revision Committee of the United States Phar- macopoeia has been especially benefited and assisted by his eminent qualities as leader and chairman during a period of over twenty-five years, and the American Pharmaceutical Association has enjoyed his wise counsel and sincere help and support as member, councillor and president, and WHEREAs, The International Pharmaceutical Conference has for many years enjoyed the advantage and benefit of his varied ex- perience and advice, and WHEREAs, All the many interests and branches of pharmacy and the drug trade have by his demise suffered a great and irreparable loss, and his many thousands of friends in this country and abroad have lost and will sadly miss that ever-present and always encour- aging smile and pleasant word which was so characteristic of Pro- fessor Remington and has smoothed over so many rough and stony spots in the life and career of his pupils and friends, and WHEREAs, It seems incredible and difficult to conceive that his AN APPRECIATION OF PROF. REM INGTON. 47 many friends, associates and pupils will never in this life again see the genial countenance and grasp the warm friendly hand of our departed friend, now be it therefore Resolved, By the National Drug Trade Conference in meeting assembled on this the day on which his mortal remains shall be transferred to their last resting place in that city of brotherly love in which he has spent practically all his many useful happy years, that in his death, pharmacy and the drug trade and this Conference have lost one of their most prominent and distinguished represen- tatives and friends, and be it further Resolved, That this National Drug Trade Conference hereby gives expression to its feeling of sorrow at the loss it has sustained through his death and of sympathy with his family in their great bereavement, and be it further Resolved, That a copy of these resolutions be spread upon the minutes of this Conference and as well that a copy be sent to the family of our deceased friend and to the pharmaceutical press. Respectfully submitted, DR. A. R. L. DoPIME, Chairman, SAMUEL C. HENRY, R. C. STOPER, John C. WALLACE, FRANK E. HollTDAY. AN APPRECIATION OF PROFESSOR JOSEPH P. REMINGTON. By George M. Beringer. In the death of Professor Joseph P. Remington, American pharmacy has lost its most renowned advocate and its most prominent teacher. No man has exerted a greater influence in pharmaceutical circles during the past quarter of a century than has this illustrious pharmacist whose earthly career ceased with the first day of the year. - Joseph P. Remington was in the truest sense of the term a “self-made man.” Gifted by nature and with a laudable ambition, by personal effort and study he overcame the handicap of having been compelled, because of the decease of his parent, to leave the Central High School of Philadelphia without having completed the four years' course. His practical pharmaceu- tical training was under such prominent men as Charles Ellis and Dr. E. R. Squibb. His association during the formative period of his early manhood 1 Read at the meeting of the New York Branch of the American Pharma- ceutical Association, Monday evening, January 14, 1918. 4S AN APPRECIATION OF PROF. REMINGTON. with many of the leading pharmacists of that time undoubtedly had a decisive influence upon his future career. g . As the assistant of those pioneer teachers of pharmacy, Professors Procter and Parrish, he received an inspiration and as the successor of these eminent men it became his duty to develop their plans and ideals and to him must be accorded the credit of having firmly established the teaching of the theory and practice of pharmacy. As a teacher Professor Remington was justly celebrated for his ability and success in that field of labor. During the nearly fifty years that he devoted to teaching pharmacy, he has instructed more students than have listened to any other teacher in that profession. His presentation of the subject matter of his lectures was always clear, the experiments and illustra- tions appropriate and very commonly the facts were driven home by some apt story or anecdote that made their retention more easy. He never missed an opportunity of impressing upon his classes the responsibility of the pharma- cist and his students were thoroughly imbued with the ethics of their calling. Not the least important service that Professor Remington has rendered to pharmacy was through his personal contact with students. By his personality he won their esteem and enjoyed their confidence in a very large extent and was thus able to help them and to guide many over troublesome situations. His genial, kindly, fatherly advice has been of incalculable value to many who are now engaged in the drug business and by their example his influence will continue to be exerted on the oncoming generations of students. Professor Remington's literary works are recognized as standard au- thorities. His editing of the pharmacy of the United States Dispensatory has been very satisfactory and his “Practice of Pharmacy,” of which the sixth edition has recently been published, is deservedly the most popular text- book on pharmacy. - Possibly the most valuable public service of Professor Remington has been as chairman of the committee of revision of the United States Pharma- copoeia. The advances made in the Eighth and Ninth Revisions were indeed marked, and a large portion of the credit for this is due to his indefatigable labors as the chairman. To fill this responsible position was no easy task and the trials and worriment associated therewith have doubtless shortened the life of the chairman. - He possessed to a remarkable degree the faculty of judging the character and ability of men and to understand their peculiarities and preferences. It was this ability to judge men and his study of his associates as well as his students that was in a measure the secret of his influence. It enabled him to enthuse his colaborers and to obtain their best efforts and therein was largely his success as chairman of the revision committee. It was my privilege to enter college as a student under the professor in 1878, and later, as a trustee of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy, I be- came more intimately acquainted with his work as a teacher. Later as a member of the committee of revision of the Pharmacopoeia and in numerous other ways we were thrown much together and so I became even better acquainted with the work and spirit back of the man. It is a great satisfaction to know that he lived to complete these great life works and to learn of the TRIBUTE TO PROF. REMINGTON. 49 appreciation of the world of his labors thereon. We can at this time feel only the great loss that we have all sustained in the decease of our captain. “My Captain does not answer, his lips are pale and still, My father does not feel my arm, he has no pulse nor will, The ship is anchor'd safe and sound, its voyage closed and done, From fearful trip the victor ship comes in with object won ; Exult O shores, and ring O bells | But I with mournful tread, Walk the deck my Captain lies, Fallen cold and dead.” A TRIBUTE TO JOSEPH P. REMINGTON.1 By Joseph W. England. When a man of the prominence of Joseph Price Remington passes into the Great Beyond, the impulse of those who knew and loved him is to pay tribute to his worth and work. The first is easy, because “out of the heart the mouth speaketh" and love finds ready expression; the second is difficult, because it takes time, and a long time, to properly estimate the full value of a life's work. It is very much like viewing a beautiful painting. Its real beauty can only be seen by standing at a certain distance from it and getting the proper focus. So it is with the work of a human soul. The future his- torian is best qualified to sense human values; the present-day observer is too close, too much influenced by the lights and shadows of personal rela- tionship. Therefore, I would speak of the worth of our departed friend, rather than of his work and its dominating influence upon American pharmacy. To know him was to love him. His charming personality, his fine tact, and his ability to make all those who came within the magic circle of his influence feel that here was a man and here a true friend—these were striking charac- teristics of him and they all “rang true.” They did not spring from motives of policy. They came from a soul reared in a Quaker atmosphere full of love of humanity. He had his faults; we all have ours. To use an Irishism, the man who has no faults is not faultless; he has the fault of inertia. The strong, positive man is intensely human, and being human, cannot be perfect. The big thing is that such a personality inspires others to be kind, to be gen- erous, to be considerate, to be friendly, to be helpful; and what is more, makes life better worth the living to countless thousands, as the influence of such a life spreads far and wide, like the ever-widening circles of a stream into which a stone is cast. The outstanding features of Professor Remington's personality were, it seems to me, three in number—his unusual ability, his unusual force of char- acter and his unusual courage. 1 Read at the meeting of the New York Branch of the American Pharma- ceutical Association, Monday evening, January 14, 1918. 5 O TRIBUTE TO PROF. REMINGTON. His ability was inherited and acquired. He had a keenly retentive mem- ory, and a fine, discriminating judgment in appreciating the relative values of facts. He was exceedingly painstaking in his consideration of details. He had a deep knowledge of the science of his profession coupled with rare executive capacity, an unusual combination of scientist and executive; and he knew, as no other, the possibilities and limitations of every active research worker in American pharmacy. He had practical experience in all the branches of pharmaceutical practice—the retail, wholesale and manufacturing, and acquired thereby unusual breadth of view. His force of character was unusual. Strong and positive in his opinions, he was not hasty in forming them, and was tolerant of the opinions of others, and exceedingly patient. His anxiety was to be right in his decisions and to play fair with his opponents. He believed that might may win for the mo- ment, but that right, eternal right, which is only another name for Truth, triumphs through the centuries. He never grew “stale.” He always kept young by associating with young people. He had unusual courage. At a meeting of the board of trustees of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy held last spring, I asked Professor Rem- ington as to his physical condition and expressed my sympathy. He replied: “I am near the end of my lifel ” He said this calmly and with a smile. He was “At the End of the Trail,” as exemplified by the wonderful statue of that title at the San Francisco Exposition, typifying the final extinction of the Red Man—the Indian on a pony, both “all in,” utterly exhausted, inca-. pable of going further, at the brink of a precipice overlooking a dark valley. And the point is, he spoke of his “passing ” without a trace of fear—with a smile on his lips and immortality in his eyes. He was unabashed and un- afraid of Death, ready to go down into the Dark Valley and face his Maker This was courage, real courage, unusual courage. And such a courage he exhibited time and time again in the crises of his life. And now he is gone. “We ne'er shall look upon his like again.” But the world’s work must go on. American pharmacy has grown more during the past fifty years than ever before and it must grow still more during the coming years, or perish. Therefore, let us catch inspiration from the lives of such men as Procter, Parrish, Squibb, Rice, Maisch and Remington, and let each one of us do our utmost to promote the growth of American pharmacy in its best estate. We cannot all be leaders, nor need be, but we all can be workers, and if each one works to his fullest possible limitations—and no man really knows his own possibilities—God only knows—the future will be safe for sick humanity. A GREAT LEADER HAS PASSED A WAY. 5 I A (; REAT LEAD [...R II AS P \SSED AWAY.” In any calling comparatively few men reach the exalted position of national leadership. When such, however, has been attained, no matter what the sphere of activity, the world is ready to recognize superiority and to pay homage. True leadership carries with it great responsibility and the opportunity to accomplish some things noteworthy in the line of the leader's achievements and to add to the welfare and progress of the world. America with its great natural resources, as yet, but incidentally developed, has been called the country of golden opportunities and offers in numerous avenues unequalled possibilities for achieve- ments. Coupled with these possibilities there has been the pioneer spirit of “do and dare" unbridled by the conventional lines of caste and prestige that have been so prominent in the European nations. Consequently, we have had in this country many notable examples of success, evidenced by rapid accumulation of wealth or the achievement of influence, which we designate as leadership. Amer- ica has developed her great men under different conditions and training than has held in any other country. Nevertheless, in every line of human activity our nation has developed some truly great men. Our statesmen, our military and naval commanders, our scholars, authors, and teachers, our physicians, Surgeons, lawyers, and preachers, our scientists, inventors and discoverers, our artists, our actors, our captains of agriculture, industry or trade have all taken their places in the forerank with the leaders of other nations and by their work have added not only glory and renown to the United States, but have materially increased the sum of human knowledge and achievements and stimulated world progress. American pharmacy, although associated with peculiar surround- ings and conditions of medical practice that at times appeared to be hampering scientific progress, has, nevertheless, made noteworthy advances and is to-day holding up its end with the other branches of the medical profession. There has been developed a corps of pharmaceutical leaders whose professional labors and standing are universally acknowledged. In the recent years, death has exacted an unusually heavy toll from among the leaders of pharmacy. No profession can well with- stand the loss of men of the type of Hallberg, Wilbert, Caspari and Holzhauer and not suffer severely from the resulting disorganiza- ! Editorial: A MERICAN Jou RNAL or PII AR MACY. 52 A GREAT LEADER HAS PASSED AWAY. tion. More appalling the loss, greater the disorganization, that will result from the decease of Professor Joseph P. Remington, who for many years has been recognized both at home and abroad as the commanding figure in American pharmacy. Great leaders are not born as such. It is true that certain in- nate qualifications are essential, but to personal ambition and to personal efforts and developments must be attributed that success of an individual that continues to lead to advanced standing and greater influence until the goal of preeminence and acknowledged leadership is achieved. Back of all of these there must be ideals, predominant personal characteristics that point the path of prog- ress, some perpetual spring of incentive as a guiding influence. In the great leader whose recent decease we mourn and whose influence will extend through many generations of oncoming phar- macists, there were strong personal characteristics, some of which have been dwelt upon by his eulogists. There was, however, another well-spring upon which Professor Remington greatly relied that has scarcely been touched upon by his many sorrowing friends. His faith in the power of prayer and his reliance upon Divine guidance and support was beautifully illustrated in an incident that occurred some years ago. We had been together one afternoon in a conference on an important question. That night, with the weight of the responsibility on his mind, he wrote to me from Longport: “I am writing this in the “sma wee” hours, but I must write you my impressions of the meeting this afternoon. You and I have a grave responsibility; we must work together. I know that you are accus- tomed to bear loads and that you do not trust to your own strength in your trials; neither do I; if I did, I would have been sponged out long ago. . . . Let us unite in prayer about this—I know that you look for strength from above—and this may sound strange from one whom you may have associated in your mind as thinking and believing in nothing but pharmacy—but I have for many years be- lieved in special and definite supplication for guidance and I know that you do also.” This is only a glimpse at the inner man, the true Christian char- acter, that shows the power that gave to him strength and endurance under most trying circumstances, and made him preeminent. This additional tribute to the purity of his thought is due to that great leader of pharmacy in America who in obedience to the will of the Divine ceased his earthly career with the commencement of the vear. G. M. B. y App 16 1070 * : * UNIVERS! TY OF MICH |GAN | Syracusº, N. Y. PAI. JAM 21, 1908 3 9015 07865 5506 ----- ---: • • • …...)--~ ~~** · · · * * * ... :::---º-º §¶√≠√≠√∞∞∞- `--~~~~ ~~~~t-№ſ-!·--...--~~~… • ... * <!!!!!!!!!!!§ =- „...--~~~~*~*** „ … ••• - *** JT..… ~~~~*~* - **