2170 i 2684 AQTES LIBRARY VERITAS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN | FROM THE LIBRARY OF Professor Karl Heinrich Rau OF THE University OF HEIDELBERG PRESENTED TO THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN BY Mr. Philo Parsons OF DETROIT 1871 : יד 3. } HJ 8624 A 25 t 3. All Parlament THE DE BA UPON THE La EX TASA To LIBRARY PARSONS University of MICHIGAN ESTABLISHING A FUND FOR THE DISCHARGE OF THE NATIONAL DEBT, WEDNESDAY, MARCH 29, 1786. TO WHICH IS ADDED, THE REPORT FROM THE SELECT COMMITTEE, RELATING TO THE PUBLIC INCOME AND EXPENDITURE, MARCH 21, 1786. LONDON: PRINTED FOR JOHN STOCKDALE, OPPOSITE BURLINGTON HOUSE, PICCADILLY. MDCCLXXXVI. [ PRICE ONE SHILLING AND SIX-PENCE. ] DE B A TE ON THE + DISCHARGE OF THE NATIONAL DEB T. TH WEDNESDAY, March 29, 1786. HE Houſe having refolved itſelf into a Committee of Supply, to take into confide- ration that part of his Majeſty's Speech which re- lated to the neceffity of providing for the dimi- nution of the National Debt, and the fame being read accordingly, The Chancellor of the Exchequer proceeded to open his long-expected propofition on the fubject. -To follow him accurately through his various arithmetical ſtatements, but much more through his brilliant arguments and political deductions, is a taſk not eafily performed. The Reader muſt, therefore, be contented with a faint and mutilated ſketch of a ſpeech, which, from the great and au- ſpicious importance of its ſubject, as well as from the maſterly ſtyle in which it was arranged and delivered, deſerves a more lafting and authentic A 2 11877 record [ 4 ] record than it is poffible to give it. The object in view was, he faid, one, on the great and urgent neceffity of which, he apprehended there would not in that Houfe, any more than abroad among the people, be any difference of opinion. Every body faw, and every body felt how much it was the duty of thoſe, to whom the interefts of the country were intrufted, to dedicate their moſt ſe- rious efforts towards the eſtabliſhment of a fund for the reduction of the public debt, as the only poffible means of holding out to the people any hope of a relaxation of their burthens, or any pro- ſpect to the nation of ever again regaining that pre-eminence among her neighbours, to which, in many points of view, fhe was fo highly intitled. It was not only his Majefty, as appeared from that part of his Speech that had juſt been read; it was not that Houſe, nor the people alone, that were looking forward with anxious expectation to the event of that day's deliberation: furrounding na- tions were equally intent on our proceedings, fully convinced that the queſtion then to be difcuffed was one, on which the ftrength, the vigour, and even the independence of our empire was to reft. The expediency, nay, the indifpenfible neceffity of the meaſure was agreed on by all manner of per- fons; and if there could, in any, be a difference of opinion, it could not be on the principle, however gentlemen might poffibly diffent from the mode propofed, to be adopted for carrying that prin- ciple [ 5 ] ciple into effect. As to the fum to be applied, there was, he believed, alfo a general agreement on that head, and all parties feemed to concur in the propriety of appropriating a million of money yearly to that purpoſe. After recalling the re- collection of the Houſe to the calamitous fituation to which this country had been fo recently reduced by a tedious and deftructive war, in the fupport of which, the reſources of the country had nearly failed, and which had rendered it neceffary to in- creaſe, in an almoſt incredible degree, the bur- thens of the people, in order to diſcharge the in- tereſt of the debts incurred in the profecution of that war, he congratulated them, and the public, that the time was at length arrived, when they might venture to look the ſtate of the nation in the face; and when, inſtead of being overcast by gloomy defpondence and defpair, the profpect was brightened with hope and the faireft expectations. In the profecution of this great object, it was ne- ceffary, first, to confider what the means of the country, for carrying it into effect were; and, fe- condly, how thefe means might be most effectually applied. The whole ftate of the national finance was before them-they could fee, at one view, not only the income, but the expenditure of the ftate. The whole was arranged, in fuch a men- ner, as to afford the moft clear and fatisfactory in- formation to any gentleman who had examined it; and he hoped, and believed, there were few who 7 had [ 6 ] had neglected to inform themſelves on fo very intereſting a ſubject. He was happy that the Houſe had not the fpeech or opinion of a ſingle member of Parliament to direct them; they had the Report of a Committee, who had examined all the neceffary documents fubmitted to them by the Houſe itſelf, and that Report was as re- markable for its clearness and perfpicuity, as the Committee, who drew it up, were remarkable for ability and diligence. The Committee had made a moft candid and explicit Report. It would be found from that Report, that they had taken two periods by which to aſcertain the amount of the annual revenue-the one the year ending at Michaelmas 1785, the other the year ending on the 5th of January, 1786.—In the former of thofe periods, the whole income was 15,379,1821. and upwards; in the latter period, 15,397,4711. He enumerated the dif ferent articles from which this revenue aroſe, ftating, from the Report, the payments into the Exchequer up to the two feveral periods which the Committee had taken for a criterion, which, in the latter, viz. that ending the 5th of January, 1786, amounted to 12,499,000l. from which was to be deducted a fum of 401,000l. that had been paid by the Eaft-India Company, as refpited duties, which, though received within the year, ought not to be confidered as part of the yearly income, being only a contingency, and not to be [ 7 ] be paid in future years; and alfo the fum of 56,000l. which had been paid on the old win- dow duties, but which, from an aleration in the affeffiments, would ceafe to be paid any longer. Thoſe two fums, amounting to about 457,0001. being deducted from 12,499,000l. would leave a remainder of about 12,042,000l. To this fum then, which had been paid into the Exchequer, and which was to be confidered as part of the national yearly income, each article of it being 'payable yearly, there were feveral other fums to be added, in order to the underſtanding accu- rately the whole ftate of the public income; thoſe fums were branches of revenue, which, though payable yearly, had not yet been received into the Exchequer; but many of them being levied by affeffment, could be as well afcertained from the affeffments, as if they had been actually received. Of theſe laſt, the chief was the addi- tional duties arifing from window-lights, by the Act commonly called the Commutation Act, on which there remained to be received about 380,000l. for the former period, and 253,5341. for the latter; another was the new Tax on Male Servants, which would amount to 26,cool. for the former, and 42,4441. for the latter period.- Befides thefe two fums, there were to be calcu- Jated the further produce on the two and four- wheel carriages, calculated at 59,2811. for the former, and 107,1861, for the latter period; and alfo [ 8 ] year alfo the further produce of the duty on horfes, carts, and waggons, at Michaelmas, 1785, amounting to 56,8291. and on the 5th of Janu- ary, 1786, to 73,610l. There was alfo to be added the further produce to be derived from the taxes impoſed in 1784, amounting to 103,000l. at Michaelmas laft, and to 22,000l. at January, 1786; as alfo from thofe of the year 1785, in- cluding the improvements of the medicine duty, amounting to 265,000l. at Michaelmas, and to 242,000l. on January 5, 1786; alſo the fum paid on account of the Civil Lift of 14,000l. at the Excife and Alienation office; together with the Land and Malt Tax, amounting to 2,600,000l. All thofe fums added, would amount in the ending at Michaelmas, 1785, to about 3,365,000l. which, added to the receipts for that year, viz. 11,874,000l. would produce above 15,379,0001, but in the year ending in January laft, they made the fum 3,354,000l. which, added to the money actually received in that year, would produce 15,397,000l. Thus the Houfe would fee the whole ftate of the annual income of the nation; the next thing therefore for them to confider, was the expenditure;-this the Committee had alfo reported upon, and it would appear from them, that it amounted to 14,478,000l.-He went over the items of which this intire fum was compoſed, dividing them into fuch as were capa- ble of being clearly afcertained, and fuch as were Aluctu- [ 9 ] fluctuating. In the former defcription, he in- cluded the intereft of the national debt, including the Exchequer bills, amounting to 9,532,7691. the Civil Lift 900,000l. the charges on the Ag- gregate fund 64,600l. and appropriated duties 64,5381. The latter clafs comprehended the different eſtabliſhments for the public defence, as the Navy, the Army, and the Ordnance, ſervices which it was impoffible perfectly to aſcer- tain the expence of; and alſo Miſcellaneous Ser- vices, which from their very name, were liable to great fluctuation and uncertainty. The charges for the Navy, as calculated in the Report, amounted to 1,800,000l. a fum equal to an eſtabliſhment of 18,000 men, one infinitely greater than this country had ever kept up in times of peace; but it was to be obſerved, that the Committee did not fit for the purpoſe of pointing out the fums neceffary to the different eſtabliſhments, but to make a computation of the furplus likely to arife, after fulfilling every de- mand of the public fervice. They had confe- quently very prudently avoided to eſtimate the expenditure on a contracted fcale, as if they were anxious to make appearances as promifing as poffible, for the purpoſe of indulging a fa- vourite project, but had taken care to go as far in their Report, as the moft extravagant eſtabliſh- ments could poffibly amount to :-they had been equally cautious in their Report of the expence B of [ 10 ] J of the Army, which they had put down at 1,600,000, though it was highly probable, it would not amount to fo much in a fhort time, having never been fo high in time of peace, even before the late calamitous war had fo greatly narrowed and confined the limits of the Empire. In this department, therefore, it was to be hoped, that the expence might be lefs than that ſtated in the Report. The Ordnance they had alſo eſtimated on an enlarged ſcale (at 348,000l.) but, in fact, in this branch there had accrued an addition of expence by increaſing the number of artillery, a thing extremely neceffary, and the omiffion of which had been feverely felt in the commencement of our laft war, and which, if poftponed to the very hour of neceffity, it might, and probably would, as had already hap- pened, be too late to remedy. The Mifcellane- ous Services were ftated by them as nearly as was poffible to be done on an average of a few years paſt, but even fo they were probably rated at a higher fum than they would in the end appear to amount to. They arofe partly from the Addreffes of that Houfe to the King for particular grants, and partly from the eftablishments of our colo- nies, and the bills of exchange drawn by our Governors abroad on the Treafury. In thefe laft there would probably be a confiderable reduction for the future, as it was refolved to obferve the moſt rigid and ſtrict ceconomy in all thoſe de- 2 partments, [ 11 ] partments, and in that particular member of our foreign poffeffions, where this expence had hither- to been the greateft, namely Canada and the northern American Provinces of Nova Scotia, and New Brunſwick; it was to be expected that a confiderable faving would be made, efpecially when it was remembered, who the officer was, to whom the Adminiftration and Command in Canada was to be committed,-Sir Guy Carle- ton; an officer who united the more fplendid ta- lents of a great General, with that no lefs necef- fary, though not ſo common virtue in a military character, œconomy; and economy was a duty not lefs incumbent on a General, than on any other fervant of the public. The whole of this article of expence was eſtimated at about 74,000l. Thus, according to the Report of the Committee, the whole of the expenditure was, 14,478,000l. which, deducted from fifteen million, three hun- dred and ninety-feven pounds, the annual in- come, would leave about 900,000l. a furplus to- wards the diſcharge of the debt. In order, there- fore, to make up the remaining 100,000l. to complete the million which feemed to be univer- fally received as the fum adviſable to be applied to this purpoſe, it would be neceffary to raiſe freſh taxes to that amount. He was happy that in propofing thoſe taxes he had it in his power to felect objects for them that would in no degree add to the burthens of the public. In the first B 2 place [ 12 ] place he fhould propofe an additional duty on fpirits. He apprehended that there were but two confiderations that ought to weigh in determin- ing on the propriety of this tax, the one whether it would be likely to reſtrain the confumption, and fo injure the manufacturer, the other whe- ther it might not hold out temptation to fraud and illicit practices; for he imagined no man could think it any national injury that fpirits fhould be fold at a dearer rather than a cheaper rate. There had been by a late Act of Parlia- ment a reduction in the duty on ſpirits of 5 d. per gallon calculated on the waſh, which, together with 2d. that had before been taken off, made the whole duty 7 d. lefs than it had formerly been. He ſhould not however reſtore the former duty wholly, but would add one penny to the duty as it at prefent ſtood, from which a fum of 60 or 70,000l. annually might be expected. The next refource was rather to be regarded as a regulation than a tax, and was an alteration of the mode of admeaſurement of deals and battens, by which certain abuſes in the prefent method would be avoided, and a fum ariſe to the public of 20, or from that to 30,000l. The third and laſt tax was, on an article infignificant in itſelf, and the produce of which could not eaſily be calculated- it was on perfumery and hair powder, and might be expected to bring in from 10 to 15, or per- haps 30,000l. By this means, according to the ſtatement [ 13 ] } ftatement of the Committee, there would be a clear million a year for a Sinking Fund; but to this he would propofe to add the amount of fuch annuities or funds as fhould fall in for a certain limited time, which he ſhould particularize be- fore he fat down. It was, however, to be ob- ferved, that the amount of the expenditure, as ſtated by the Committee, ample, and even ex- aggerated as it was, on the head of the three military eſtabliſhments as they might be expect- ed to ſtand hereafter, did yet fall confiderably short of what was the actual expenditure for the prefent year, and would continue a year or two to come. To explain this, it would be neceſſary for him to point out firft, what were the reafons for thoſe extraordinary expences exifting for the prefent, and next by what reſources they were to be anſwered, fo as to prevent them from falling with fuch a weight upon the revenue as to render the preſent ſcheme abortive, except by means of freſh impofitions on the people. First then the annual expence of the Navy as only ftated was 1,800,000l. whereas the actual charge of it for the preſent year was 2,400,000l. The reafons, however, for its exceeding the very liberal peace eſtabliſhment of 1,800,000l. were fufficiently ob- vious to fuch as would confider the effects of the late tedious and moft expenfive war, and that thoſe effects in a great many inftances had not yet ceafed to operate-that it had left behind it many [ 14 ] 1 many very neceffary demands on the National Purfe, which it would be highly impolitic not to comply with; that befide the naval half-pay and penſion lift, which he would ſpeak of by and by, in common with the army, it had rendered it neceffary to begin the building of feveral fhips which were now on the ſtocks, and which, if we were to omit completing, would be in fact waft- ing the money they had already coft, but which, if we were to finish them, would give us the fineſt navy that this kingdom, in the moſt flouriſhing period of its exiftence, had ever poffeft. In the army there were alfo for the preſent great ex- ceedings, beyond that which was ftated to be the regular amount of the expence; thofe exceedings were about 260,000l. but to this additional ex- pence, for the prefent, it could not be, but Gen- tlemen muſt be more reconciled when they confi- dered that it was applied in a way in which alone, of all others, the voice of œconomy could not be fully attended to; the relief of thoſe who had ſpent the best part of their lives, who had loft their limbs and their health in our fervice, and of the widows and orphans of thoſe who had died, fighting for their country.-Thofe expences ftill were fuch as muft of courfe gradually diminiſh, and in time be entirely at an end. As to the Ordnance and the expence of that department, as ftated by the Committee, that was a fubject on which there was fome degree of doubt, as it was as [ 15 ] * as yet uncertain, what Parliament would propofe to do on the ſubject of Fortifications. Having already rejected one plan, it was to be expected they would in proper time determine on another, fomething of the kind being by all thought neceffary, but to what extent, it was impoffible at preſent to forefee, and therefore the expence could not be preciſely eſtimated. Another fource of revenue would arife from the Crown Lands. He was fenfible that much could not be fuddenly grafped from this object; the ad- vantage would be gradual and permanent; but, perhaps, the wifdom of the Committee might di- rect them to look in that quarter for a provifion for thofe men who had facrificed their fortunes to their loyalty. Befides thefe, there was another article of ex- penditure not touched on in the Report-this was the fubject matter of the King's Meffage, which he had the honour of preſenting on that day, and on which he would then take an opportunity of faying a few words. a few words. The impoffibility of bringing the real expences of the Civil Lift, within the eſtabliſhment allowed by Parliament, proceed- ed from the circumftance of that fund's being mortgaged for the payment of certain Exchequer Bills, by annual payments of 50,000l. which re- duced it from 900,000l. to 850,000l. Of theſe Exchequer Bills there remained due about 180,000l. and there was befides an arrear against the Civil Lift [ 16 ] Lift of 30,000l. more; in order, therefore, to free the Crown from any farther embarraffment on that ſcore, he ſhould, on that day fe'nnight, when the Meffage came to be taken into confideration, move for a fum of 210,000l. for his Majefty to diſcharge the incumbrances on his Civil Lift. He obferved, that the whole of thofe exceedings in the army and navy on their prefent eſtabliſh- ments, above their amount, as ſtated in the Report to be the regular expenditure, was about 750,000l. and was to laft for only four years, which made a fum, upon the whole, of 3,000,000l. For this fum, of courſe there ought to be a pro- vifion made, but from the ftate of the country there would, for the preſent at leaſt, be no necef- fity for recurring to any fresh burthens on the people, and there was great ground to expect that the whole of thofe extraordinary expences might be defrayed by certain extraordinary refources which we were poffeffed of, but which could not be arranged under any head of revenue. The firft of thoſe extraordinary refources was the furplus on feveral funds, together with army favings, partly already paid back into the Exchequer. Thofe amounted to about 450,000l. There was beſides an immenfe arrear ftill due by former Pay- Maſters, part of which might ſhortly be expected to be paid in. He entered pretty largely into the abuſes that had been formerly practifed in the Pay-Office, but faid, that there was every reafon to [ 17 ] to expect all the out-ftanding balances would be afcertained and recovered as foon as the Commif- fioners, appointed to examine and ſtate the public accounts, ſhould have gone through the whole of their enquiry; they had to inveſtigate the accounts of 118 regiments of foot, and many regiments of dragoons, fome of whofe non-effective funds had not been accounted for 20 years paft-of theſe regiments the commiffioners had as yet only gone through one, in which, however, they had been able to make out a balance of 22,000l. in favour of Government. He faid, he was not fo fanguine as to expect any thing nearly equal to this in the other regiments; but he thought, on the whole account, there might be, including contracts, and other articles of abuſe, 1,000,000l. to be refunded, thoſe two ſums made 1,450,000l. In this account he had not yet mentioned a lottery, becauſe it was not determined to be adopted; but he was afraid, the fpirit of gambling was fo very deeply rooted in the minds of the people, as to make it always a certain refource for at leaſt 140,000l. per year, and therefore in four years it would produce a confiderable part of the fum to be made good. There were, befides, great refources ftill to be expected from the means already adopted, and that were further to be uſed, for the fuppreffion of fmuggling-in the cuftoms, thofe means had already been attended with fuch fuccefs, as had exceeded the warmest hopes of the moſt fanguine, C [ 18 ] fanguine, and given fpirit and vigour to the moft defponding, and that even during the period of a fingle year; but it was not to a year alone, that their fuccefsful operations had been con- fined; they had continued to increaſe the re- venue in a conſtant progreffion, ever ſince they had been put in execution, and there was every reaſon to expect that they would ftill farther in- creaſe it;no preventive againſt fmuggling could be expected to accomplish it's intire object on the inftant-the capital that had been em- ployed in that trade, could not be fuddenly with- drawn, and the party would for a time carry on a lofing trade, rather than at once give up their old habits and occupation: it might therefore reaſonably be expected, that though there had already refulted the moft extraordinary benefit to the revenue from the fteps that had been taken for the fuppreffion of fmuggling, there were ftill greater advantages to be expected. There were, he faid, at the prefent moment, feveral treaties going forward, which muft neceffarily make fome alteration in the rate of the cuftoms; but he hoped that alteration, if not favourable in point of revenue, would make ample amends in com- merce; and he defired the Houfe to recollect, that even pending thoſe treaties, a thing in itſelf likely for the moment to deprefs the fpirits of trade, the Cuſtoms had received a confiderable addition, and of courſe muſt be expected to in- creafe [ 19 ] 1. creaſe ſtill more confiderably, when that ſuſpence fhould be at an end.-There were befides farther regulations to be adopted, and particularly with re- gard to the diſtillery, by which confiderable frauds in that branch would be prevented. But the greateſt of all was in the article of wine, the revenue arifing from which, was extremely, and almoft incredi- bly deficient of what it ought to be. This he illuftrated by an obſervation, that although it was probable, that the confumption of wine had much more than doubled fince the year 1746, yet upon an average ending at that period, the revenue on that article did not at prefent, not- withſtanding the addition both of duty and con- ſumption, exceed what it produced at that time. Exclufive of thofe refources, there were others. that afforded a great promife of affiftance, if it fhould be found neceffary to recur to them.- Another thing of the greateſt importance would be the confolidation of the cuftoms;-this, how- ever, though a thing by no means to be aban- doned, was not at prefent in immediate contem- plation. From all thoſe circumſtances, it was highly probable, that the growing refources of the country, together with thoſe accidental receipts of the fums he had mentioned, would enable us to diſcharge the 3,000,000, which our eſtabliſh- ments would, during the enfuing two or three years, require beyond their permanent allowance, without having recourfe to a loan for that pur- pofe; N C 2 [ 20 ] A pofe; but if it fhould be otherwife, then by all means money ought to be borrowed for the dif charge of thofe demands, rather than either poſt- pone for the preſent the inftitution of a finking fund, or infringe upon it hereafter, if infti- tuted. In the plan he meant to propofe, all imagin- able care would be taken to fortify the fund as much as poffible against any poffibility of being diverted from its object, and to fecure to it its regular quarterly fupplies, in fpite of any acci- dents or misfortunes whatſoever. He should therefore propoſe to appoint a certain fet of Com- miffioners for the management of it, and to in- veft them with full power to difpofe of it in the purchaſe of ſtock, as if for their own ufe, and in their own names, that fo the fanctity of private property might be an additional check on the Crown and on Parliament, to refrain from any attack upon it. He would moreover have it fo ordered, that every quarter of a year 250,000l. fhould be paid out of the Exchequer, into the hands of thoſe Commiffioners, and that before any other money ſhould be iffued, except for the intereft of the debt. From thefe provifions, it would follow, that no neglect of that Houſe could poffibly affect the fund, unleſs at the fame time it neglected every other branch of the public fer- vice. And alfo that there could no covert, or fudden attack be made upon it by a Minifter, or by * [ 21 ] by Parliament, but on the contrary, if any fuch be meditated, it must be executed deliberately, and with their own eyes open to what they were doing, and the eyes of the public alfo upon them, each of which, he hoped, would operate as pow- erful reſtraints againſt any invafion on this facred bulwark of the public credit. He would briefly ftate to the Houſe the effect of a calculation he had made on the accumulation to be expected from a million a year, applied quarterly, with its accruing intereft, together with the annuities that were to fall into the ufe of the fund. The whole would, in a period, not of great length, when compared with the life of man, but fcarcely an hour, when eftimated with the duration of a great Empire, in a period of 27 or 28 years, it would amount to fuch a fum as to leave four millions annually, free, to be applied, if ne- ceffary, to any exigence of the State, and from that time he would leave the annuities, that fhould have fallen in, either to go to the public fervice, or to the relief of the people. The perfons who ſhould be appointed to this commiſſion, ſhould be of a rank and eftimation that fhould fecure, as far as perfonal character could do it, a faithful and diligent diſcharge of their truft. In the first place, he would have at the head of them, that refpec table Commoner, whoever he might be, that ſhould fill the chair of that Houſe. Parliament, in in- ftituting a commiffion of fuch importance towards the [ 22 ] [ the ſupport of the national credit and profperity, could not more folemnly, nor more pointedly, promulgate its high ſenſe of the duty, by which that commiffion was bound, than by appointing the firſt Member of that Houfe to be at the head of it. He thought alfo, that it would be proper that the perfon exercifing an office fo intimately connected with the fubject of finance, as the Chancellor of the Exchequer, for the time being, fhould be a Member of the Committee. There was another perfon alfo, who, from his high rank and confequence, as well as from his virtues and reputation, was a proper perfon, he meant the Maſter of the Rolls.-The Governor and Deputy Governor of the Bank of England ought likewiſe to be appointed, having been long in a fituation fo fimilar in itfelf;-as alfo the Accountant Ge- neral of the High Court of Chancery, who, by virtue of his office, was already employed in veft- ing the money of all the fuitors, and of wards, in the funds, and increafing, by that means, the ca- pital by the accumulation of compound interefts. Such perfons as thefe he fhould propofe to the Houſe when the Bill came before the Committee. There might, he ſaid, be fome difficulty in deter- mining how to regulate the conduct of the Com- miffioners in their purchaſe of ſtock, as chiefly with regard to what fort of stock they fhould pur- chafe; but, perhaps, this might be left to their own difcretion-but there was another part af their [ 23 ] their duty which he would not leave to their dif cretion, which was, the times on which they were to make their purchaſes: this fhould not be op- tional, but at regular periods, viz. on every transfer day in the quarter, on each of which they were to make purchaſes of an equal mag- nitude. The Right Honourable Gentleman then ſtated the annual account of the Supply and Ways and Means.--The actual and probable receipt under the head of Ways and Means, he stated to a- mount for the current year, to The amount of the expenditure for the preſent year would be no more than 13,362,480 12,477,000 Surplus of receipt, 885,480 From which take the fum to be paid to the Commiffioners, 750,000 135,480 And there would ftill be a furplus of To which the Committee would think it reaſonable to add a further fum of favings, which he ftated the probability of their procuring by re- gulations of revenue, 313,620 And there would be a furplus of receipt after the operation, of 449,100 After [ 24 ] After many obfervations on the neceffity of a- dopting this meafure, and expreffing his fatif- faction that he had then a taſk to perform fo dif- ferent from what had fallen to the lot of any of his predeceffors, and fo far more agreeable than that which he had been hitherto obliged to un- dergo, viz.-the contriving the means of dimi- niſhing inſtead of encreafing the burthens of the people, he concluded with a repetition of his former words, that "The eſtabliſhment of fuch an inftitution as that which he was about to pro- pofe, was effential not only to the credit, the ftrength and vigour, but even to the indepen- dence of the nation," He then moved, That the fum of One Million be annually granted to certain Commiffioners, to be by them applied in the purchaſe of Stocks, by the appli- cation of 250,000l. every quarter for that pur- pofe, the firſt payment to be made the quarter immediately after the paffing of the Act, towards diſcharging the Public Debt of this country, which money fhall arife out of the Surpluffes, Exceffes, and Overplus Monies, compofing the Fund commonly called the Sinking Fund. Sir Grey Cooper rofe immediately after the Re- folution had been read from the Chair, and faid, it required no great argument to explain in what degree money at compound intereft would accu- mulate. Baron Mafferes had written upon the fub [ 25 ] fubject, and a great deal had been faid about a Propofition perfectly fimple, and obvious to every capacity. He rofe, therefore, not to ſay a word upon that circumftance, but to remark that the Committee had proceeded to form their Report on principles extremely novel, and directly op- pofite to thofe that the wifeft men in former times had thought the most certain guides to their judg- ment, and the moſt to be depended upon as lead- ing to the true ftate of the object of enquiry. The Committee had founded their Report on the preſent year's amount of the receipt of the pub- lic income, becaufe it had proved a remarkably favourable year, and they had not ſtated the real expenditure of the year, becauſe that oppoſed to the receipt would not certainly have afforded any furplus on the balance. On former occafions the rule had been, invariably to proceed in a dif- ferent road, and by a fair average of a number of years income and expenditure, taking good and bad years together, to ftrike a balance upon fuch an average, and confider that balance as a footing not likely to prove fallacious, but as a footing that was firm and that might be relied on with fecurity. He held a publication, that came out two years after the end of the war before laft, and which, it was well known, was printed un- der the protection, and corrected with his own hand, by a great Minifter of that day--he meant Mr. Grenville. The pamphlet was entitled, D Con- [ 26 ] Confiderations on the State of the Finances of the Nation. In that pamphlet the oppofite doctrine to that on which the Report on the Table was founded, was laid down and maintained. Sir Grey ſtated the inftance, and argued upon it to prove how differently Mr. Grenville had reafon- ed, compared with the Right Honourable Gen- tleman who had juft fat down. [There being a great noife in the Houſe, occafioned by a con- fiderable number of the Members being on the floor in their way to the door] Sir Grey faid, it .would perhaps procure him fome favour with the Houfe, when he declared, that the Right Hon. Gentleman himſelf was not a more fincere friend to the idea of diminiſhing the national debt, nor more anxious to have its diminution effectually fecured, than he was; but it was his duty to examine the means by which the Right Hon. Gentleman wished that Houſe to proceed, and to point out the particulars, in which he thought thofe means premature or inadequate. When the Right Honourable Gentleman had introduced the queſtion of the Fortifications, he remember- ed, he had talked in the fame fanguine manner of his certainty of accomplishing a fpeedy and effectual reduction of the national debt, that he had done that day. He had faid, the wifh of his heart was to have his name infcribed on a pillar, to be erected in honour of the man, who did his country the effential fervice of effectually reduc- [ 27 ] reducing the national debt.-This was, Sir Grey faid, a magnificent idea; it was, however, his duty not to be dazzled with its fplendor, but when the firſt ſtone of its bafe was going to be laid, coolly and carefully to examine the ground on which it was propofed to be erected, to ſee whether it was firm, folid, and ſtable, or looſe, hollow and uncertain. With this view he had rifen, and if it was not laid down by the Houſe as a rule, that nobody was to be heard in reply to any thing ſaid by the Right Honourable Gen- tleman (The Houſe had at that moment been fo diſorderly, that Sir Grey could ſcarcely be heard) he would endeavour to convince the Com- mittee, that it behoved them proceed with cau- tion; and great, important, and neceffary as the buſineſs recommended to them was, to take no one ſtep farther in it, before they were certain that they were proceeding on good ground, and that the path they were adviſed to purſue, would lead to fuccefs. Sir Grey then went into a va- riety of remarks on the different ſtatements in the Report, reaſoning with great acuteneſs and per- fpicuity upon each diſtinct ſtatement. He par- ticularly touched upon the manner in which the Right Honourable Gentleman had talked of the Exchequer Bills, (Mr. Pitt having faid, the three millions of Exchequer Bills to be paid off need not be taken into the account, as they made an article under each diftinct head of Supply, and Ways D 2 Į [ 28 ] Ways and Means, thofe to be paid off ranging under the head of the former, and three millions more, that were to be iffued in diſcharge of them, ranging under the head of the latter) declaring, that it appeared to him a little extraordinary, that the Honourable Gentleman fhould mention Ex- chequer Bills in fo light a way. Was he aware, that they would be a great inconvenience, and materially deprefs the market, under certain cir- cumftances, at leaft poffible? There were at pre- fent more Exchequer Bills unfunded, he ſaid, than ever were left unfunded by the noble Lord in the blue ribband during the whole courfe of the war. After arguing for a confiderable time, in proof that the data given in the Report were unfafe for the Houfe to act upon in fo important a particular, he put a cafe in familiar life, to illuſtrate his reaſoning.-Suppoſe, ſaid he, a man has a hop ground, and wants to raiſe a fum of money; he has a fortunate year, and has netted a profit of 500l. that feafon; he goes to a neigh- bour, and offers his hop ground at a mortgage. He tells the neighbour his profits, and fhews him his books. The neighbour naturally fays, "this is a very good account, but how am I fure, the fame fuccefs will attend the ground and its produce another year; the feafon may be un- propitious, a variety of incidental and unavoid- able circumſtances may occur?" In vain would the owner of the hop ground boaſt of his fuperior ſkill [ 29 ] ſkill in the cultivation of hops; that he had manured his ground, and prepared his bines, fo as to defy the accidents of chance, and that he had put the harveft and its confequences beyond a hazard, by fecuring the integrity of his pickers, and the care of his fervants employed in the cul- tivation and management of the hops, both be- fore and after picking; his neighbour, if he had common fenfe, would fay, "No, I won't lend my money on any ſuch riſque as the ſucceſs of a fingle year; prove to me by the average of a number of years, fome good, fome bad, that the profits yielded by the hop ground, communibus annis, are fufficient to fecure me from danger, and you ſhall have the money you want." This çafe, Sir Grey faid, would apply to the fubject in queſtion; one favourable year's receipt was not a fufficient ground for the Committee to pro- ceed upon, Greatly to be wifhed, therefore, as it must be by every man prefent, that the na- tional debt could be effectually reduced, for it was a common cauſe, and no party confideration, he had his fears, that if they proceeded prema- turely, and upon the plan ſuggeſted, they would do harm and not good; they would mar their own intentions, and add to the embarraffments, inſtead of relieving the diftreffes of the country. Mr. Fox faid, after the Committee had heard fo much from the Right Hon. Gentleman oppo- fite him, he did not mean to intrude long upon their [ 30 ] their patience; but in the out-fet of what he had to fay, he begged leave to declare that no man in exiſtence was, or ever had been a greater friend to the Sinking Fund than he was, and ever had ſhewn himſelf from the firft moment of his politi- cal life. He agreed moft perfectly with the Right Hon. Gentleman in his ideas of the neceffity of eſtabliſhing an effective Sinking Fund, for the purpoſe of applying it in diminution of the nati- onal debt, however much he might differ with him in refpect to the moſt prudent and uſeful mode of making the application, and however much he might differ with him as to many parts of his Speech, and a variety of the obfervations it contained. Having premifed this, Mr. Fox pro- ceeded to animadvert on the conduct of the Com- mittee to whom the papers had been referred, and to comment on their Report, declaring that their mode of taking averages had been not only dif ferent from that of every former Committee, but totally the reverſe of that which had ever been deemed the faireft mode of taking an average.- In illuftration of this remark, he inftanced the produce of the Tax on Malt, in averaging which, for fix years, the Committee had ſtated, that a par- ticular year, the year 1782, was uncommonly de- ficient; now the ufe of an average had ever been fuppofed to arife from the averaging a number of years produce, among which years there might be years of extraordinary deficiency, or years of ex- traordinary [ 31 ] traordinary plenty. He next pointed out the fallacy of ſtating the receipt of the prefent year, which happened to be a year of uncommon rife of revenue, and oppofing to it not the actual ex- penditure of the prefent year, grounded on the votes of that Houfe, but the probable expendi- ture of the year 1790. He aſked whether that was a fair compariſon of the annual receipt with, the annual expenditure, and whether as the Right Hon. Gentleman had admitted, what indeed no perfon could deny, that 600,oool. more had been voted for the Navy, and 400,000l. more for the Army, this year, than appeared in the lift under the head of expenditure, it was not manifeft, that fo far from there being a furplus of 900,000l. this year, there was not a deficiency? He reminded the Committee of the difference laft year be- tween him and the Right Hon. Gentleman, re- ſpecting their reaſoning upon the balances of cer- tain quarters, which had been ſelected as the moſt- favourable quarters; and faid, it now appeared, that if he at that time had calculated the balances that would refult upon the whole of the four quarters, when the year fhould be completed, fomewhat too low, the Right Hon. Gentleman, it was evident, had calculated them much more too high. He reminded them alfo, that when he had faid in argument, on one of thoſe occafions, that he believed there would be fome balance, the Right Hon. Gentleman had echoed the words, 8 Some [ 32 ] Some balance, with an air of difdain, as if be (Mr. Fox) had talked with ridicule, or with contempt of a matter, which it was certain would turn out to be a monftrous balance. The fact was now before the Committee, and he begged leave to aſk whether it was not true, that ſo far from there being even ſome balance for the preſent year, there was any? He dwelt upon theſe two points for fome little time, and declared, though it had turned out to be in both particulars, exactly as he had ſtated that it would turn out, he mentioned them not with any view to triumph over the Right Hon. Gentleman, but merely to fhew that he had been in the right before. He particularly ani- madverted on Mr. Pitt's having faid that 1,800,000l. for the Navy, included 18,000 fea- men, a larger number than had ever been known in a permanent peace eſtabliſhment in the moſt flouriſhing ſtate of this country. He asked what the Right Hon. Gentleman faw in the fituation of the affairs of Europe, that could induce him to imagine that a lefs numerous eſtabliſhment of feamen would be fufficient, or a more contracted Navy than 1,800,000l. could provide? For his part, he ſaw much, that ferved to prove that a ftill greater naval Eſtabliſhment was neceffary, for much had of late happened, which looked as if all Europe was combining to form engagements hof- tile to this country, and detrimental to its inte- refts at prefent, and its efforts in cafe of a future war ; PARSONS LIBRARY [ 33 University of MICHIGAN war, while no tranfaction that had lately taken place in any of the foreign Courts wore a favour- able afpect. Under fuch a period, to fay we had a more powerful Navy than had ever been known in time of peace, in the moſt flouriſhing of for- mer periods, was faying nothing: Had we a Navy fufficient to cope with the combined marine of other maritime powers? If we could not effect fuch a purpoſe, we fell fhort of what was, in his opinion, indifpenfably neceffary to our immediate fafety, and our future fecurity and well-being as a Naval Power. Having added other remarks on the Report and its ftatements, he declared, that he agreed nevertheleſs in the propriety of dedicating the furplus fund to the diminution of the national debt; and that whether the whole of the Report was true, or whether it was erroneous, he fhould ſtill be of opinion, that it was right to pay off a part of the National Debt; and highly proper to begin doing it immediately, even if the confe- quence were, that the Sinking Fund was not found equal to it; in which cafe, he held it to be the duty of that Houfe to make good the fum fo appropriated to that important fervice, and to continue fo to do, even if they were annually obliged to impofe new Taxes on the fubject. When he faid this, however, he begged to be rightly understood, as to how far he agreed in reſpect to the prefent plan; it was merely to the commencement of fome plan; and a better one, E than [ 34 ] than that propoſed, he thought might eafily be adopted. The parts of the plan that he diſap- proved were two-fold, the one, making the fum appropriated unalienable in time of war, the other, making the obligation to pay off the Debt general, and not pledging or binding it clofer. Mr. Fox entered into a good deal of reafoning on theſe two objections.-He pointed out various diſadvantages that might reſult from tying up the fum in time of war; and affigned many reaſons to prove, that as the Committee and the object of their inftitution were not bound down to any Tpecific point, both were liable to be annihilated by a future Parliament. He reminded the Houſe of the mode of the original inftitution of a plan for paying off a part of the National Debt, which had been by a fubfcription of individuals, to whom the faith of Parliament had been pledged to pay off certain fpecific portions at ftated periods. He dwelt on the difference between the two modes, obferving, that when the nation, or when Parlia- ment ſtood bound to individuals, the pledge was held as facred as the pledge to pay the intereft of the National Debt at prefent, or the annuities now payable; and undoubtedly, nothing short of a National Bankruptcy would prevent the fums engaged to be paid to individual fubfcribers: whereas upon the conditions on which the Com- mittee would ftand, what fhould hinder a future Miniſter in a future war, when the exigency of affairs [ 35 ] affairs might require additional burthens to be impoſed on the fubject, coming down to that Houſe and propofing to repeal the Act authorif- ing the inſtitution of the Committee, and enabling Government to apply all the Money and Stock in their hands to the public fervice? What ſhould hinder the Houſe from agreeing to the propofition; or was it at all likely that under the exigency of the moment, they would not immediately agree to it, when fo much money could eaſily be got at, and when they could fo readily fave them- felves from the odious and unpleaſant tafk of im- pofing new taxes on themſelves and their confti- tuents? With regard to the Chancellor of the Exchequer being one of the Commiffioners, Mr. Fox faid, he thought it perfectly right, that who- ever held that office, fhould be one at leaſt in fuch a commiffion. The Chancellor of the Ex- chequer was an officer in whom that Houfe necef- farily repofed great confidence in reſpect to mat- ters of finance, and who certainly ought to have an immediate connexion with the diminution of that debt, the creation of which had unavoidably been an act of his own, in the neceſſary diſcharge of his official duty. From the various guards which the Right Honourable Gentleman had fug- gefted it to be his intention to put upon the Committee, it was obvious that he faw the fuf- picions to which it would be liable; and there- fore Mr. Fox declared, the more guards put upon E 2 it [ 36 ] it the better. Unfortunately, however, the more the guards, the lefs the economy of the ſyſtem. He expreffed fome doubt whether the compelling them to lay out the money on certain days might not rife the market; and whether it might not happen, that on fome of thofe days when they might be obliged to buy, there might be no fellers, and confequently the Committee be com- pelled to force the market, and by fo doing, raiſe the price fo high, that in fuch inftances all the benefit would be loft to the public. He ob- ſerved, however, that the Right Hon. Gentleman had talked of ſpreading the money into ſeveral fums, and by that means reducing each fo fmall, as to avert as much as poffible the effects he had ftated as probable to happen. Of that he ap- proved, but he could by no means agree that the Committee were to act a public part: the fact was, they were to become private ftock-brokers with the public money. He defcanted on this, and ſtated his reafons for withing their acts to be as public as poffible, which were, he faid, the only means that he knew of to fave them from a good deal of that fufpicion which it was eaſy to fee they would be expofed to. After dwelling for fome time on this, Mr. Fox again adverted to the Report and the ſtatements made by Mr. Pitt in his ſpeech, feveral of which he combated, and endeavoured to difprove. He mentioned the neceffity of providing new Taxes in lieu of fuch as [ 37 ] as had failed, that ſhould produce the fums for which they had been given, and by that means preſerve the Sinking Fund whole and entire. In order the more amply to point out the neceffity for this, he animadverted for fome time on the actual produce of the different Taxes of the laſt year. The Shop Tax, for instance, which he faid he ſhould ever hold to be an odious, op- preffive, and unjuft perfonal Tax, had been no- minally given for 120,000l. whereas it appeared from the affeffments, that if they were all paid, (which undoubtedly was not likely to be the cafe,) the produce would amount to no more than 70,000l. and when the modifications lately made to it, came into operation, that 70,000l. would be reduced to 50,000l. fo that a Tax given for 120,000l. would produce no more than 50,000l. In that cafe, and in all caſes like it, he held it to be the duty of a Chancellor of the Exchequer, to propofe either a new Tax that would be efficient for 120,000l. and repeal the Shop Tax, or a Tax that would be efficient for the 70,000l. the fum the produce of the Shop Tax fell fhort of pro- ducing. During the war, he had repeatedly held language urging the neceffity for the deficiencies of the new Taxes being made good by other Taxes; and the anſwer of the noble Lord had al- ways been, that during the war, they muſt get on as well as they could; but that when peace fhould come, that would be the fit opportunity for [ 38 ] for making good the deficiencies on the War Taxes. In that anfwer there was fome reafon ; but the Right Honourable Gentleman had not the fame excufe, and yet all his Taxes did not produce much more than the one half of the fums for which they had been given. Mr. Fox fpoke of the Commutation Tax, and defired to aſk the Right Honourable Gentleman, if the greater con- fumption of Tea that it had occafioned in this kingdom, as well as the greater confumption of a far greater proportion upon the whole than ever of teas of the higher fort, quality, and price, which neceffarily increafed the neceffity of the Eaft India Company to fend out to China, and expend confiderably more in the purchaſe of teas, than ever had gone to China, was any matter of folid fatisfaction to him, as the guardian of the Commerce and Revenues of Great-Britain? Was it by fuch extenſions of trade, that he wished to be confidered as a friend to the Revenue or Com- merce of the kingdom? Or would he affume any merit for having extended a trade, before fo dif- advantageous to this country, in reſpect to exports and imports? Mr. Fox faid, he thought it fair to warn the Right Hon. Gentleman on fo im- portant a confideration, and he would leave it to himſelf to draw the neceffary conclufion from the circumftance. The Right Hon. Gentleman had faid, he obſerved, that our reſources were near cracking juft before the war was brought to a con- clufion. [ 39 ] clufion. For his part, he never had been of that opinion, nor never had ſtated that he was; but what fort of melancholy reflection was held out to the public, by his Committee, when it was the clear deduction from their ſtatements, that the permanent peace eſtabliſhment was not to be ex- pected before the year 1791, eight years after the conclufion of the war! He made feveral pointed remarks on this, and declared it as his opinion, that with good management, the expences of the war might have been ſooner wound up. Before he fat down, he recapitulated his principal ob- jections to the plan propofed, and faid, he thought they were confiderably weakened by not making the fund unalienable in time of war. He entered into a good deal of argument to prove, that twenty- ſeven years was too long a period to look for- ward to for the effect of the plan: before that pe- riod, it was not improbable that we might have another war; and a variety of circumftances might occur, that would operate as temptations to a fu- ture Chancellor of the Exchequer, to propoſe to a future Houfe of Commons to repeal the act, annul the inftitution, and divert the appropriation of its ſtock to the immediate fervices of the year: he, therefore, again, on very forcible terms, re- commended the other mode of proceeding, by individual fubfcription. In the courfe of his Speech, he entered largely into the detail of the argument of Mr. Pitt, affuring the Houſe, that 2 how- 6 [ 40 ] however difficult they might think the fubject, and therefore be loth to liften to it, or to endea- vour to make themſelves mafters of it, nothing was more eafy; there was not the ſmalleſt conju- ration in it, and he that ran might read. Mr. Fox ſpoke rather loofely, but he difplayed, as ufual, on budget days, great ingenuity, and a wonderful familiarity with the ſubject of finance in all its various branches. The Chancellor of the Exchequer faid, after hav- ing ſo much, he feared, fatigued the Committee before, he would not again take up much of their time; and it was the lefs neceffary for him to do `fo, from all that had been faid; fince it was evident, little or no objection had been urged againſt the Motion, or the plan of following it up and carry- ing it into execution, that had been ſtated and propofed. There were two or three things that had fallen from the Right Hon. Gentleman, ne- ceffary for him to fay a very few words to and firſt, in regard to the ftatement of the balances of the quarter's amount of receipt, about which they had differed laſt year, and refpecting which, the Right Hon. Gentleman had now been fo good as to fay, the Report proved that he had been in the right, but that he forbore to affume it as a matter of triumph to himſelf. For this forbear- ance, Mr. Pitt faid, he was much indebted to the Right Hon. Gentleman, but ftill more for his having put him in mind of the difference, becauſe upon [ 41 ] upon a reference to the Report, it would be found, whether the Right Hon. Gentleman had, as he had himſelf that day declared, ftated the amount of thofe balances fomewhat too low, or whether he (Mr. Pitt) had ſtated them a great deal more too high. The Chancellor of the Exchequer then reminded the Committee, that he had stated the probable amount of the balances, when the four quarters fhould have been completed, in four dif- ferent modes; upon one mode, he had, at the time, declared he was not fanguine enough to place much reliance-upon the next mode, he had calculated that the amount would be the fpe- cific fum of 12,600,000l.-upon the third mode, a fmaller fum; and upon the fourth, a ftill ſmaller. The fecond was the amount, to which he had been now tied down by the Right Hon. Gentle- man; and upon reference to the Committee's ſtatements of the actual receipt, it would be found that the amount was twelve millions, five hundred and odd thouſand pounds, which, in a matter con- fifting of fuch various and complicated fums, and amounting to fo much, was furely coming as near the real total of the year's receipt, as it could rea- ſonably be expected any man fhould come by un- certain calculation. Having ftated this, he pro- ceeded to take notice of that part of Mr. Fox's Speech, in which, paying off a part of the debt by fubfcription of individuals, was recommended, and faid, he hoped the Right Hon. Gentleman F would [ 42 ] would not confider it as any diſparagement of him, if he declared, that the fame idea had been fug- geſted to him by many others, and that he him- felf approved it, but would not adopt it, on ac- count of certain inconveniencies to which it was liable. With regard to preferving the fund to be invariably applied in diminution of the debt unalienable, it was of the effence of his plan to keep that facred, and moſt effectually fo in time of war. He affigned a variety of reaſons for holding this opinion, and contended, that to fuf- fer the fund at any time, or on any pretence, to be diverted from its proper object, would be to ruin, defeat, and overturn the whole of his plan; he hoped, therefore, when the Bill he fhould introduce, ſhould pafs into a law, that Houſe would hold itſelf folemnly pledged, not to liften to a propoſal for its repeal on any pretence what- ever. Mr. Pitt replied to feveral other of the. arguments of Mr. Fox, and gave that Right Honourable Gentleman credit, for having fhewn great candor. Mr. Fox rofe to explain. He began with go- ing over the hiftory of the difference in debate of laſt ſeſſion on the ſubject of the balances, and maintained that he had ftated the matter fairly at first. He next went again into a detail of reafons, in fupport of his advice to commence paying off part of the debt by individual fubfcription; and faid, he would at another opportunity, ftate the out- [ 43 ] outlines of a plan, by which the diminution of the debt might be fo commenced, without being liable to the objections hinted by the Right Ho- nourable Gentleman. Mr. Fox alfo went into a good deal of argument refpecting the propriety of beginning, as Mr. Pitt had propoſed, to pay off the 4 per cents. firft, and then the 3 per cents. a mode which he faid was undoubtedly right. He mentioned the reaſoning upon the fubject which they had formerly heard, in defence of beginning to pay off the 3 per cents. firſt, and ſo proceed- ing to pay the others in regular progreffion up- wards, upon the idea, that if the 3 per cents. were at par, it would coft the public 301. every 100l. and therefore the greater the lofs upon that ſtock, the wifer would it be to get rid of it firft. Mr. Sheridan laid in his claim to go through the Report fome other day, obferving for the prefent only, that it was fully admitted, that his affertion had been correct; that there was, in point of fact, no furplus whatever on the prefent year; a circumſtance evinced not only by the Report itſelf, but by the whole of the Right Honourable Gentleman's ſpeech that day. Mr. Sheridan further obferved, that the day had commenced in a very inaufpicious manner, and when he uſed that phrafe, he meant no difrefpect to his Majeſty, but merely to hint at the royal meffage relative to the Civil Lift, which was an extraor- F 2 dinary [ 44 ] dinary introduction, furely, to a buſineſs, the event of which the public had been taught to look forward to, with the pleafing expectation of finding a furplus in their favour. He declared, he was a little furpriſed that the Right Honour- able Gentleman, who, when he two years ago afked for 60,000l. to clear the debt then due on the Civil Lift, had in a manner pledged himſelf to the Houſe, that no farther debts fhould ariſe, and that the Houfe fhould not again be applied to for farther grants on the fubject, fhould come again fo foon, for fo large a fum of public money. [The Chancellor of the Exchequer faid acroſs the Houſe, Oh no, I never faid any fuch thing.] Mr. Sheridan faid, the Right Honour- able Gentleman muſt excufe him, words faid at ſome diſtance might be forgotten, but he was clear in his recollection of the circumftances; and indeed it was evident he muſt have uſed ſome ſuch argument, or elfe why fhould the Right Honourable Gentleman have afked only for 60,000l. two years ago, and come down again then and claim grants for an arrear of fo large an amount as 210,000l.? The Chancellor of the Exchequer roſe once more, in order to make fome reply to what he termed the moſt extraordinary attack that ever had been made upon him. The Honourable Gentleman had faid words might be forgotten after they had been faid; it was undoubtedly true, but it was alfo [ 45 ] alfo true, that words might be miſrepreſented; and if ever he had heard a grofs miſrepreſentation of his words, it had been the charge ftated by the Honourable Gentleman. He never had pledged himſelf not to come again to that Houſe for any debts on the Civil Lift. When he aſked for the 60,000l. two years ago, he had exprefsly faid, there was a further arrear, but that he had not been in his office long enough to afcertain what the amount was, and therefore he would aſk for no more, till he was certain what the whole of the debt was. But it was evident, not only that words delivered two years ago might be miſrepreſented, but that words ſpoken a very few hours fince, were alſo capable of miſrepre- fentation. He was in the recollection of the Houſe, whether he had ever faid, there was now an arrear of 210,000l.? He had faid the Civil Lift was in arrear 30,000l. and he had at the fame time ftated, that 180,000l. was wanted to pay off the remainder of the Exchequer Bills, for which 50,000l. a year of the Civil Lift was mortgaged. Mr. Sheridan faid, the Right Honourable Gen- tleman might indulge himſelf as much as he pleaſed in throwing out charges of miſreprefenta- tion, but he had ſpoken what in his opinion, and in the recollection of feveral Gentlemen in that Houſe, was a true ſtatement of the Right Hon. Gentleman's own words. If 60,000l. was afked for, [ 46 ] for, as the debt two years ago, how came it that 210,000l. was now wanted? As to the idea of redeeming a mortgage of 50,000l. a year on the Civil Lift, why had not that been regularly paid, fince Government were anfwerable for it? Mr. Roſe anſwered that it had been paid, and that regularly; but that there ſtill remained 150,000l. of it to pay, and that the Civil Lift had ran in arrear 60,000l. in the laſt year, which to- gether made up the 210,000l. now afked for. Lord North aſked the amount of the total of the Supplies, and total of the Ways and Means, for the year 1786. The Chancellor of the Exchequer ftated their amount, and alſo the amount of the Surplus up- on the whole, exclufive of the 750,000l. to be paid this year, by way of eſtabliſhing a permanent fund of a million a year, to be applied unaliena- bly in diminution of the National Debt, The Motion was then put and agreed to, The Chancellor of the Exchequer afterwards moved the following Refolutions: I. That towards carrying the before-mentioned into execution, the following duties fhall be laid in addition thereto : That all perfons dealing in, or vending per- fumery goods fhall be obliged to take out licences, which licences fhall be charged with a ftamp duty 7 of [ 47 ] of five fhillings, if fuch perfons fhall live in Lon- don, Weſtminſter, or the Borough of Southwark, or within the limits of the Penny-poſt: But if fuch perfon fhall live in any other part of Great-Britain, then fuch licences to be fubject to a ſtamp duty of two fhillings and fixpence. That upon all perfumery goods fold by per- fons, there ſhall be paid the following duties: (that is to fay) Where the price of fuch goods ſhall not exceed the fum of eight-pence, there ſhall be paid a ſtamp duty of one-penny; where the price of fuch goods fhall exceed eight-pence, and not exceed one fhilling, there fhall be paid a ftamp duty of one-penny halfpenny; and where the price of fuch goods fhall exceed one shilling, and not exceed one fhilling and nine-pence, there fhall be paid a ftamp duty of three-pence :-And where the price of fuch goods fhall exceed one fhilling and nine-pence, and not exceed two fhil- lings and fixpence, there fhall be laid a ftamp duty of fixpence :-And where the price of fuch goods fhall exceed two fhillings and fixpence, and not exceed five fhillings, there fhall be paid a ſtamp duty of nine-pence :-And where the price of fuch goods fhall amount to five fhillings and upwards, there fhall be paid a ftamp duty of one fhilling. II. That the prefent rates, whereby Deals and Battens are chargeable, fhall ceafe. And [ 48 ] And that five pounds fhall be the rate whereby the duties fhall be computed on one hundred Deals. That two pounds twelve fhillings and fixpencè fhall be the rate whereby the duties fhall be com- puted on one hundred Battens. III. That the prefent duties upon Waſh, uſed in the diſtillation of Corn Spirits, fhall be in- creaſed one penny, according to the rates of the former duties on Wafh. REPORT REPORT FROM THE SELECT COMMITTEE TO WHOM IT WAS REFERRED TO EXAMINE AND STATE THE SEVERAL ACCOUNTS AND OTHER PAPERS, PRESENTED TO THE HOUSE IN THIS SESSION OF PARLIAMENT, RELATING TO THE PUBLIC INCOME AND EXPENDITURE: AND ALSO, TO REPORT TO THE HOUSE What may be expected to be the ANNUAL AMOUNT of the faid INCOME and EXPENDITURE in future. (March 21, 1786.) LONDON: PRINTED FOR JOHN STOCKDALE, OPPOSITE BURLINGTON-HOUSE, PICCADILLY. M DCC LXXXV. REPORT, &c. The COMMITTEE appointed to examine and ſtate the ſeveral Accounts and other Papers preſented to the Houſe in this Seffion of Parliament, relating to the Public In- come and Expenditure; and alſo to report to the Houſe what may be expected to be the Annual Amount of the faid Income and Expenditure in future, H AVING proceeded to the Confideration of the Matters referred to them by the Houfe, have arranged the ſeveral Papers relating thereto under diftinct Heads, containing the dif- ferent Articles of the Public income and Expenditure. But before they enter on the First Part of their Report they think it neceffary to premife, that they have confined their Exa- mination to the prefent State of the Revenue, as it appears ei- ther from the Amount actually received in the Periods contain- ed in the Papers referred to them, or from the beſt Eſtimates which they could form of the Produce of fuch Articles as had A 2 not [ 4 } ] not been brought to Account in thofe Periods, but compoſe, nevertheleſs, a Part of the prefent Income of the Public. The large amount of Taxes impofed fince the Commencement of the late War, in Addition to the then ſubfifting Revenue; the Dif- ficulties under which the different Branches of our Commerce laboured during the Continuance of that War; and the great and increaſing Prevalence of Smuggling previous to the Mea- fures recently adopted for its Suppreffion, appeared to Your Committee to render any Averages of the Amount of the Re- venue in former Periods in a great Degree inapplicable to the preſent Situation of the Country: On the other Hand, they did not think themſelves competent to diſcuſs the various Contin- gencies which may in future operate to the Increaſe or Diminu- tion of the Public Income. A Revenue fo complicated in its Nature, and depending fo much on the various Branches of an extenſive Commerce, muſt always be liable to temporary Fluc- tuations, even although no Circumftances fhould arife to occa- fion any permanent Alteration in its Produce. Your Commit- tee have, therefore, judged it proper to ſubmit to the Wiſdom of the Houſe this extenfive Confideration, and to ftate in this Report the preſent Amount of the Public Income, as refulting from the Papers before them. SI. THE [ 5 ] $ I. THE net produce of the different branches of Revenue, paid into the Exchequer in the year ending at Michaelmas 1785, appears to have been as follows, viz. Cuftoms Excife Stamps Incidents Total £•4,520,820 £..5,282,342 £.1,157,549 £1,360,809 12,321,520 But your Committee find, that in this period there had been paid by the Eaft India Company a fum, for refpited arrears of Cuſtoms, amounting to . 401,118; which fum, as not refult- ing from the regular courfe of the Revenue, is to be deducted from the total above ſtated. The average net payment into the Exchequer, for ten years, ending at Michaelmas 1785, of the duties impofed by the 6th of his prefent Majefty on houſes and windows, amounted annually to £. 418,497, nearly It appears, however, that the grofs charge, according to the account laid before the houſe, of the laft affeffment for England, was only But this account not including the returns from the Surveyors of eight diftricts, your Committee have added a fum propor- tioned to the amount of the returns for thoſe diſtricts in 1784 making in the whole From which must be deducted the falaries of the Commiffioners, Clerks, and Surveyors, and the incidental expences of this and all the other duties under the fame manage- ment; the whole being charged to the account of this duty And alfo the charges of management on this duty, amounting at 61d in the pound, to £.401,397 £. 12,805 £414,202 £. 19,916 £. 11,218 £. 31,134 The [ 6 ] ] The remainder will be To this muſt be added the produce of the faid duty, which may be expected from Scotland; the net payments of which amounted, on the average of 10 years. ending Michaelmas 1785, to Making in all But the fum received on this head, in the year ending at Michaelmas 1785, appears to have been The difference therefore between that fum and the amount at which the preſent pro- duce of this duty is eſtimated above, muſt be further deducted from the amount of taxes received in the year ending at Mi- chaelmas 1785. This difference is £. 383,068 5,871 nearly: £. 388,939 435,128 £. 46,189 It ſhould be obſerved, that this account is framed on the aſ- ſeſſments for the laſt year; and that no credit is taken for the furcharges, which will probably be much more than fufficient to balance the amount of diſcharges, or other accidental de- ficiencies. Theſe two fums of £.401,119, and £.46,189, being de- ducted from the total receipt above ftated, will leave a ſum of £.11,874,213. To this are to be added the further fums which have accrued, or may be eſtimated to be the produce of any part of the preſent revenue, not brought to account in that period. § II IT [ 7 ] § II. IT appears that the amount of the affeffment on all inha- bited houſes in England, for the year ending on the 5th of April 1786, under the Act of the 24th of his preſent Majeſty, £. 492,555 was But the returns from the Surveyors of eight diſtricts not being included in this account, your Committee have added a fum proportioned to that af- feffed upon thoſe diſtricts in the half year ending 5th April 1784 Total To this muſt be added the affeffment for one year in Scotland, which your Committee have eſtimated, on the af- feffment for the half year ending 5th April 1785, at £. 15,000 £.. 507,555 £. 16,533 Making in the whole £. 524,088 From which must be deducted the charges of management; which at 61d. in the pound, amount to The remainder will be No credit is here taken for furcharges. The whole fum paid to the Receiver General of the Cuftoms, on this head, and by him paid into the Exchequer, in the year ending at Michaelmas 1785, was The difference therefore between that fum and the eſtimated produce of this duty, as above, muſt be added to the amount of taxes received for the year ending Michaelmas 1785. This difference is £. 14,194 £• 509,894 £129,838, nearly. £: 380,056 § III. IT } [ 8 ] § III. IT appears that the amount of the affeffment on two wheel and four wheel carriages, under the new mode of collecting thoſe duties, was, for three quarters of a year, ending the 5th of April 1786, £. 107,849 35,949 Add one-third Affeffment for one Year But the account of theſe affeffments not including 14 returns, your Commit- tee have eſtimated their produce (not thinking the affeffments for the houſe Tax proper for this compariſon) by the proportion which the affeffiments for the fervants tax in thoſe diſtricts bore to the whole affeffments for that tax, when for- merly under the fame management under which the carriage duty is now placed : This proportion gives a fum of And the whole will then be From this are to be deducted the charges of management, at 6 d. per pound, amounting to £. 143,798 £• 7,818 £. 151,616 £. 4,106 nearly: Which leaves the eftimated net produce at £. 147,510 And the produce to be expected from Scotland, taken at the average of three years net produce, under the manage- ment of the Excife, upon which however there may probably be fome increaſe under the prefent mode of collection, as is the caſe in England Total eſtimated produce of this duty for one year £. 8,500 £. 156,010 The fum paid on this account into the Exchequer, be- tween Michaelmas 1784 and Michaelmas 1785, appears to have been To which must be added, for three 5 per £. 84,113 cents. payable thereon, purſuant to feveral Acts of Parliament £. 12,616 Total paid in that period £ 96,729 I The 1 [ 9 ] The difference, therefore, between that Sum and the eſtimated net produce of the tax for one year, under its prefent management, must be added to the Produce, as above ſtated, of all the taxes in the year ending Michaelmas 1785: This difference amounts to £. 59,281 It is to be obſerved, that in this account alfo no credit is tak en for furcharges. § IV. IN the Act of the 25th of his preſent Majefty, for repealing the duties on fervants, and for impofing new duties in lieu thereof, it was provided, That 51,000l. of the produce of the duties fo impoſed ſhould be carried to the account of the du- ties impofed in 1777; from the nature however of the affeff- ments under that Act, and the period of their commencement, no payment had been made on this account in the year ending at Michaelmas laft; but there had been received under the old mode of collection Which fum, together with three five per cents. thereon, amounting to about makes There remains therefore to be added on this Ac- count to the produce of the exciſe, for the year ending at Michaelmas laſt £. 21,041 3,156 £. 24,197 £. 26,803 $ V. THE Aſſeſſment of the duties on Horfes, under the Act of the 25th of his preſent Majefty, if taken for a year, amounts to And that of the duties on waggons and carts, un- der the Act of the 25th of his prefent Majefty, if taken for the fame period, amounts to Making together B £. 134,230 £. 29,546 £. 163,776 To [ 10 ] To which may be added, for 14 Districts not re- turned, but eſtimated, on the proportion above ſtated with reſpect to the carriage tax The whole will then be From which muſt be deducted, for charges of management, at 6d. in the pound £. 8,904 172,680 1 £ 4,677 Which reduces the eſtimated net produce to £. 168,003 Add for Scotland The aſſeſſments not being yet come in, and that fum being nearly in the proportion of the pay- ments on the carriage tax from that part of Great Britain, computed as above; Total And as it appears that there had been paid into the Exchequer, on this account, in the year ending at Michaelmas 1785, for the duty on Horfes And for the duty on waggons and carts Making together (nearly) 10,000 £. 178,003 £. 106,853 14,321 £. 121,174 The difference muſt be added to the produce, as above ſtated, of all the taxes for that year. This difference amounts to £. 56,829 VI. IN examining into the produce of the taxes impoſed in the year 1784 (exclufive of the horſe tax) your Committee ob- ferve that they had produced, in the year ending at Michaelmas 1785, the fum of £. 482,042 But that in the year ending January 5th 1786 the fame taxes had produced £. 563,220 As [ 1 ] As it appears reaſonable, in this inftance, to confider the latter period as affording a jufter ground for eſtimating the probable annual produce of taxes fo recently impofed, they have added on this account, to the general amount received in the year ending at Michaelmas, a further fum of £.81,178, being the difference between the two fums above stated. Many of theſe taxes can perhaps hardly yet be fuppofed to have paid a complete year's produce into the Exchequer. Parti- cularly it appears to your Committee, by an account from the Stamp Office, that in confequence of the Act of laſt feffion for better collecting the duty on game licences, there has been actually received by the Stamp Diftributors, between 5th Ja- nuary 1785 and 5th January 1786, the fum of £. 50,889 From this fhould be deducted the charges of col- lection (which your Committee find cannot be yet accurately afcertained, but which may be efti- mated at rather more than 5 per cent.) making about The remainder will be fomewhat above £. 2,500 £ 48,000 But in the foregoing comparative ſtatement, only £. 25,953 is included in this account as paid into the Exchequer in the year ending 5th January 1786. The difference therefore, being about £.22,000 is to be added to the fum of £.81,178 above ftated; making in the whole about £. 103,000 3 VII. YOUR Committee next proceed to ſtate ſuch eſtimates as they are enabled to form on the information which they have procured refpecting the produce of the taxes impofed in the year 1785. It was naturally to be expected that a very ſmall part of fuch produce could have been received at the Exchequer previous to Michaelmas laft; whatever therefore may appear to be the further annual amount of thoſe taxes, must be added to the other articles of annual receipt, B 2 The [ 12 ] The amount of the affeffment in England to the Shop Tax, for three quarters of a year, ending on the 5th of April 1786, is Add one third for the remaining quarter Affeffment for one year Add for 14 diſtricts not returned, but taken at the proportion which thofe diftricts bore to the re- mainder of the affeffments for 1784, under the Window Duty 6 Geo. III. Total for England Deduct charges of management, at 6d per pound Remains £. 55,481 £. 18,494 £. 73,975 4,100 £. 78,075 2,114 £. 75,961 Add for Scotland, on the proportion taken above, under the article of the Window Duty 6 G. III. £. 1,164 Total produce of the Shop Tax, no credit being taken for furcharges £. 77,125 But if the reduction which has been propofed this Seffion on different parts of this duty fhould be carried into Effect, Your Committee apprehend that it will diminiſh the above fum by about a fixth part thereof: They have therefore taken this article only at £. 64,271 The Affeffments on Male and Female Servants for three quarters of a year, ending 8th April 1786, amount to £. 91,424 Add one third as above Total Add for 14 diftricts on the proportion which thofe diftricts bore to the whole Affeff- ments on Male Servants in 1780 Total Affeffment for England Deduct charges of management, at 61 per Pound Remains 30,475 nearly: £. 121,899 £. 6,627 £. 128,526 £ 3,481 £125,045 Add [ 13 ] Add for Scotland, on the proportion of the average remittance, for three years under the excife Total Deduct, for what is ordered by Act of Parlia- ment to be carried to the account of the taxes of 1777, and for which credit is taken above ( §. 4. ) Remains, net produce of this tax 9,803 £. 134,848 £51,000 £. 83,848 It is more difficult to form any eſtimate of the amount of the remainder of the taxes impofed in 1785. They are not collected by the mode of affeffment; and the fums which they have hitherto produced, in the fhort period fince they became payable, afford a very imperfect ground for judging of their future amount; eſpecially as they are, for the most part, ftamp duties, and as a confiderable time always intervenes between the actual receipt of thofe duties in the diftant parts of the country, and the time of their being remitted to the head office in Lon- don. It will obviouſly occur to the Houſe, that this circumſtance muft render accounts of this nature particularly defective, when they relate to taxes fo recently impofed. Your Committee, having pointed out the imperfection of theſe accounts, will proceed however to ftate the beft computations they have been able to form thereon. The Duty on Pawnbrokers confifts in an annual licence for ex- ercifing that trade, and took place on the 5th July 1785. There was paid at the Stamp Office in Town, and remitted from the country, on this account, in the period between July 1785 and February 1786, both inclufive, being eight months, a fum of Your Committee have added, as an allowance for money to be received in town, and remitted from the country, in the remainder of the year And have taken the produce of this Duty at £. 3,740 £. 1,260 £• 5,000 The [ 14 ] The Tax on Attornies confifts in part of an annual licence for the perfons exercifing that profeffion, and in part of a duty on warrants for licence to fue. 1 The tax took place on the 1ft November 1785, and in the month of November 1785 there was paid on this account, at the office in town, the fum of £. 8,996. In the three following months there was paid in town, on an average, the fum of £. 979 per month. Nothing was remitted in the month of November from the country on this account. In the three following months there was remitted, in all, the fum of £. 1,080. Of the payments in town it appears that about £. 6,315 arofe from the produce of the annual licences in London, and about £ 1,283 from that of annual licences for Attornies in the country; amounting together to £ 7,598. The remainder, amounting to about £. 4,301 was paid for the duty on warrants to fue. If, therefore, the whole amount of annual licences to be received in town is taken at £. 8,000, and from £. 8,000 to £. 10,000 be allowed for the annual amount of warrants to ſue, the whole produce in town would be from £. 16,000 to £. 18,000. With reſpect to the payments in the country, the accounts. do not diſtinguiſh how much of them has been received for the Two different branches of this duty; nor is there fufficient ground to eſtimate the future remittances on the average of thoſe in the three months included in thofe accounts; as it ap- pears that the remittance in the laſt month is nearly equal to thoſe in the two others. Your Committee however conceive that the whole of this duty, including the remittances from the country, may not improperly be taken at about £. 20,000. On account of the Glove Duty there was paid at the Head Office in London, in feven months, ending February 1786 Which gives an annual produce of £• 3,410 5,845 There [ 15 ] There was remitted from the country in the four laft of thoſe months Which gives an annual produce of Total £ 1,075 £. 3,225 9,070 Which your Committee conceive, may be ſtated at £. 10,000, making allowances for the remittances not received from the country, and from Scotland. In the Act of the laft Seffion for reducing the allowance for wafte on Salt, it was directed that . 12,000 fhould be anually ſet apart under that head; your Committee have not the means of judging, from any accounts which they could procure, what may be the future amount of this duty under the new regula- tion, but have ſtated it at the fum taken in the Act, which is £. 12,000. For the purpoſe of ſtating more accurately the produce to be expected from the additional duty on poft horſes impoſed in the haft feffion, as well as the old duty on poft horſes, and that on ftage carriages (both of which were then confolidated with the new duty) your Committee called for the annexed return from the Stamp Office of the produce of the poft horfe duty impofed in 1780, from its commencement to the year 1785 inclufive. From theſe returns it appears, that the total produce in Lon- don of the poſt horſe duty impofed in 1780 was nearly £.144,705; and that the ſum of £. 408,143 was remitted from the country in the fame period. Д. The total produce of the new confolidated duty in London, for the fix months, appears to have been . 22,187, which is at the rate of £. 44,374 a year; the annual produce of the fame including the country, according to the proporion above ſtated, would be . 169,536; as, however, in the year ending at Michaelmas, . 96,000 nearly appears to have been received under the old duty on poft horſes; and as in the fame period it appears that about £. 23,000 was received for the duty on ftage carriages, theſe two fums, amounting to .119,000, are to be deducted from £. 169,536, in order to give the ex- pected future produce, and will leave £. 50,000. I Your [ 16 ] Your Committee think it right farther to obferve, that an improvement has alſo been made in the revenue, in addition to the produce of rhe taxes of 1785, by the operation of the Act of the laſt feffion for the better collection of the duty before ſub- fifting on medicines. It appears that the produce was no more than 1,5921. in London, in the year ending the 1ft Auguft 1785, and that the produce in the fame diftrict was 6,0881. 18. 9, between the 1ft September 1785, when the new law took effect, and the 11th inftant; which is at the rate of 13,2741. a year. year It alſo appears, that the whole amount of the duty, in the ending ift Auguft 1785, was 3,860l. of which 1,5921. was paid in London, and 2,2681. in the country; fuppofing, therefore, the produce in town and in the country to bear the fame proportion, the fum of 18,940l. nearly may be expected to be raiſed in the latter, which, added to the fum of 13,2741. expected in London, will amount to 32,1851. from which deducting 51. per cent, for the eſtimated charges of collection, the remainder will be fome- what above 30,000l. The Difference between this fum and 3,860l. (being the for- mer produce) is about 26,00ol; this fum, if added to the taxes of 1785, as already ſtated, will make the whole amount to about 271,000l. from which is to be deducted 6,1751. fo much having been paid in on account of the taxes of 1785, pre- vious to Michaelmas in the fame year. The remainder will be 265,000l. nearly. § VIII. IT further appears, by an Act of the 1ft of his prefent Ma- jefty, C. I. that the part of the fum affigned by Act of Parlia- ment for the fupport of his Majefty's houſehold, to the amount of 12,000l. is paid by the Receiver General of the Excife be- fore the net produce of that revenue is paid into the Exchequer This fum is therefore to be added to the head of receipt. And [ 17 ] And a fum of 2,000l. paid by the Alienation Office is, for a fimilar reaſon, to be included in like manner. They amount together to 14,000l. $ IX. THE duties on land and malt, although they are annual grants, and form therefore no part of the fettled revenue of the country, appeared to your Committee to be proper to be in- cluded in this Report, efpecially as the fervices for which they are uſually granted, are hereafter inferted under the different heads of expenditure. It appears that the whole produce of the Land Tax, for feven years, ending at Lady Day 1782, being the laſt complete years of a four fhillings aid, was £. 13,380,599 To which is to be added, being the amount paid on account of the Militia in thoſe years, pre- vious to the payment of this duty into the Ex- chequer, the fum of £ 392,954 1,967,650 Total £13,773,553 Average of one year The produce of the Malt Duties for the fame period was 4,319,0691. which would give an average of 617,010l. But in this period is included the year 1782, in which the produce of Malt was uncommonly deficient. If the average were taken on the preceding fix years, it would amount to above 657,000l. but if it is ftated as low as 632,350l. the whole amount of Land and Malt would be 2,600,000l. The foregoing accounts of the Public Reventie are formed on the ground of the actual receipts in the year ending at Michaelmas 1785, with fuch alterations and additions as the different circumſtances which have been ſtated relative to them appeared to your, Committee to require. But as it was thought important that the Houſe fhould be informed what difference would have arifen in the refult, if the calculations had been grounded C [ 18 ] grounded on the receipts of the year, ending in January 1786, your Committee have inveſtigated thofe accounts, proceeding by the fame ſteps, and on the fame principles, which they have detailed to the Houſe in ftating the particulars of the former period. But they think it neceffary to remark, that the account to Michaelmas 1785, includes fifty-three days of weekly payment, and that fifty-two only are included in the account, ending on the 5th of January 1786. The Houfe will however obferve, that as far as the reſult of theſe accounts differ, which they do not in any confiderable degree, that difference is in favour of the Revenue in the latter period. Your Committee, having thus inveftigated the amount of the ſeveral articles of the public Revenue, proceed to ſtate, in like manner, the ſeveral branches of expenditure. 1 $ X. THE annual intereſt, and other charges payable on the public debts, as they ſtood at the receipt of his Majeſty's Ex- chequer on the 5th of January 1786, amounted to 9,266,9401. In addition to this, the intereft at 3 per cent. on 1,000,000l. charged on the 6d per pound on Penfions, by the Act 12 George I. and the charges of management thereon, amount to 30,3601. The charges of management on 10,990,6511. 5 per cent. annuities, funded in 1785, were computed at 6,182 1.-Theſe fums amount in the whole to 9,303,4821. But it appears to your Committee, that, fince the time of making up the accounts which have been laid before the Houſe on this fubject, a diminution has taken place in the charges of management payable to the Bank of England, to the amount of 24,853 1. If a fimilar reduction may be expected in the charges of that part of the public debt which is under the management of [ 19 ] · of the South Sea Company, the total faving will amount to 27,7131. Which being deducted from the above fum, leaves a remainder of 9,275,7691. It is to be obſerved, that a part of the annual payment to the public creditors confifts of Annuities, which will gradually fall in at the expiration of the terms for which they were granted. Your Committee think it not improper to obferve particularly, that Annuities, to the amount of 25,3511. will determine on the 5th of April 1787. $ XI. YOUR Committee called for an eſtimate of the expence likely to be incurred under the head of Exchequer Bills from the Lords Commiffioners of His Majefty's Treaſury. The future charge on this article, after the preſent year, is eftimated at 258,0001. § XII. THE fum charged on the Aggregate Fund, and payable at the Exchequer, for the fupport of His Majefty's Houfhold, is 886,000l. and there is further paid, for the fame purpoſe, a fum of 12,000l. at the Excife, by an act of the firft of His prefent Majefty; and a fum of 2,000l. is paid at the Alienation Office, and makes part of the Civil Lift. Thefe fums amount in the whole to 900,000l. C 2 § XIII. [ 20 201 ] § XIII. EXCLUSIVE of any part of the intereft, and of the charges of the public debts, and of the fum paid towards the Civil Lift, there are other payments charged upon and payable out of the Aggregate Fund. They confift in part of annuities which will gradually ceafe; but your Committee, not judging it proper to form any eſtimate of fuch diminution, have taken the whole at the prefent amount thereof, which is 64,600 l. } $ XIV. IT appeared by the Papers referred to your Committee, re- lative to the feveral fervices of the navy, army, and ordnance, that the average of thofe fervices refpectively, for the years 1766, 1767, 1768, and 1769, were as follows: For the Navy, including the Expence of Ordnance for Sea Ser- vice For the Army For the Land Service of the Ordnance £. 1,660,218 1,516,631 287,165 The expence on theſe feveral heads for the prefent year ap- pear, by the eſtimates now before the Houfe, to be confiderably larger; but your Committee obferving that thefe expences may be expected to vary, and that many particulars thereof muſt ne- ceffarily be reduced in future, have called for additional ſtate- ments from the feveral offices; according to thoſe ſtatements, which are annexed to this Report, the expected average expence of the feveral fervices above mentioned, on a permanent peace eftabliſhment, appears to be as follows: For the Navy, including the Expence of Ordnance for Sea Ser- £. 1,800,000 1,620,009 vice For the Army But as in this eftimate no credit is taken for the expected di- minution therein ſtated, in the article of Bills of Exchange drawn from the colonies and plantations, and in the half-pay and Chelſea * [ 21 ] Chelfea out-penfion, your Committee conceive themfelves juftified in taking the average expence of this department £. 1,600,000 at It is proper however to obferve, that nothing is here allowed for the expence arifing from the regiments in India; on which account, in the extraordinaries prefented this feffion, there is charged a fum of 77,9441, which is not included in the fum above ſtated The East India Company being to pay a certain fum for every regiment in India, by an Act of the 21ft of His prefent Ma- jefty, this charge is in fact only a temporary advance, for which the public will have credit to an equal amount hereafter, whenever remittances are made from India, and the demands under that Act are brought to account. The eſtimated expence for the land fervice of the ordnance is 348,000 1. In ftating the total of theſe fervices, your Committee think it neceffary to take notice, that various charges are included, on account of half-pay, Chelſea out-penfioners, and other allowances of a fimiliar nature, amounting in the whole to 683,325 1. $. XV. THE annual charge incurred on account of the militia, for the years 1775, 1776, and 1777, the last three years of peace in which the militia was trained and exerciſed, appears by the accounts referred to your Committee, to have been, on an average, 128,000l. nearly. But they conceive that, if the reductions which have been propoſed in this feffion in the expence of this branch of the national fervice fhould be carried into effect, the whole will amount in future only to about 91,000l. at which fum they have accordingly taken it, fubject however to fuch variation as may arife from any alterations in the plan which is now under the confideratian of Parliament, §. XVI, [ 22 ] §. XVI. THE expence of the different articles ufually included un- der the head of miſcellaneous fervices is ſtated in the annexed eſtimate thereof (which has been received by your Committee from the Lords Commiffioners of his Majefty's Treaſury) at 74,2741. : §. XVII. IT appears that a part of the annual produce of the pulic revenue is not applicable to the payment of any part of the intereft of the national debts, or of the general fervices of the country, but it is appropriated to certain ſpecial purpoſes, not included under any of the foregoing heads of charge. The amount of the taxes fo appropriated forms therefore another article of expenditure. They appear to have produced, in the year ending at Michaelmas 1785, 66,5381. There are ſome charges on the Poft Office, and other offices of revenue, arifing from different Grants and Acts of Parlia- ment, by which certain annuities are made payable thereon: but, as theſe are iffued at the different offices of collection, pre- vious to the payment into the Exchequer, your Committee have not brought them to account under the head of public expen- diture; the fums by which they are defrayed not being ſtated on the other fide as any part of the public receipt. The total of the feveral articles above ftated, compofing the whole of the annual expenditure of the country, amounts to 14,478,181 1. There are fome additional articles, both of expenditure and receipt, of which your Committee think it right to take notice, though they have not inferted them in their Abstract, as con- fidering them improper to be included in accounts of the perma- nent peace eſtabliſhment of the country, and of its preſent annual revenue. The first article of this defcription, and probably the moſt confiderable, confiſts of the additional demands which may be made for the fervice of the Navy, before it is put com- pletely on the footing on which the future peace eſtabliſhment is $ [ 23 ] is calculated thefe cannot be ftated with precifion; but it ap pears, from the account delivered by the Navy Board, that the probable amount may be from 1,200,000l. to 1,600,0001. In this article no proviſion appears to be made for the prefent outſtanding debt of the Navy: your Committee find that on the 31ft of December 1785, it did amount to 2,537,7641. towards the fatisfying which there remained to be applied 825,2751. re- mainder 1,712,4891. But it is ſtated that from the delay in call- ing for payment of many of the charges of which it is compofed, a floating arrear to this extent may generally be expected to ſub- fiſt; and, as it neither bears intereſt in its preſent ſhape, nor will require to be funded, it cannot occafion, either in prefent or in future, any addition to the annual charge upon the public. Under the head of Miſcellaneous Expences, there may alfo arife fome temporary exceeding beyond the annual amount ſtated by the Committee. Thefe, however, they conceive, will, for the most part, either be occafional, or at leaſt of ſhort duration; but, from the nature of this head of expence, it is impoffible to foreſee with certainty the particular demands. The only article to which your Committee think it neceffary, ſeparately, to call the attention of the Houſe, is that of the Re- lief of the American Sufferers; but it is not for the Committee to determine what fum Parliament may think proper to allot for this purpoſe, either as temporary relief, or when the inveftiga- tion of the feveral claims fhall have been completed. From what has been ftated, the Houſe will obferve, that no accurate eſtimate can be formed of the total fums which may arife beyond the average amount of the expences before ſtated, and which may therefore require a ſeparate proviſion. But, upon the whole, your Committee conceive, that the means of defray- ing the expences (exclufive of the average income above ftated) may be expected to be fufficient for the purpoſe. In the first place, your Committee have taken no credit in the foregoing ſtatements, for the profits which may annually be expected from Lotteries, whenever Parliament fhall think proper to avail itſelf of that mode of raifing money. It appears that the profit on the Lottery of laſt year was nearly 140,000l. this alone would be an addition to the annual in- 2 come, [ 24 ] come, probably greater than the fum which would be added to the annual expenditure, even on the fuppofition of its being ne- ceffary to provide funds for the whole amount of the contingent expences above ſtated. A further fum may alfo be expected to arife for fome years to come, under the head of army favings. It appears, by the Acts of Appropriation in feveral feffions, that a variety of mifcellaneous articles of this deſcription, amounting in the whole to a very large fum, were brought in aid of the army ſervices for ſeveral years after the conclufion of the war before the laft. From the extent of the grants for army fervices in the courſe of the late war fimilar favings may naturally be expected, and probably to a larger amount, as provifion has recently been made for a more ſpeedy inveſtigation of all the depending accounts. A balance is alfo due from the Eaft India Company, for the fubfiftence of troops in India, and on account of the victual- ling of the Navy, purſuant to the 21ft of His prefent Majefty, C. 65. The propriety of applying to public purpoſes a portion of the unclaimed dividends of the funds (confiftently, with the ftrictest regard to the fecurity of the creditors of the nation) and the means of rendering the crown lands more beneficial than at preſent, are alſo objects which feem to fall under this confideration. But, independent of the articles which have here been ſtated, your Committee truft that they ſhall not be thought to exceed the limits of the duty preſcribed to them by the Houfe, in ob- ferving, that the prefent fubfifting taxes, if the due collection thereof could be fecured by meafures adequate to the purpoſe, would probably afford an ample provifion for any deficiencies which may at any time be found, either in theſe reſources, or in the particulars which compofe the general income of the public; and would inſure a parmanent annual furplus, applica- ble to the reduction of the National Debt, in ſuch manner as the wiſdom of Parliament ſhall direct. ABSTRACT соколоколонокококоно L 25 ABSTRACT of the feveral Articles of Public Receipt and Expenditure. RECEIP PT. § I. Total net payments into the Exchequer, from Mich³ 1784 to Mich' 1785 Deduct therefrom The reſpited duties paid by the Eaſt India Company Excess beyond the future amount of the window duties § I. Total net payments into the Exchequer, from 5th January 1785 to 5th January 1786 от околоколокола Deduct therefrom The refpited duties paid by the Eaft India Company Exceſs beyond the future Amount of the window duties II. Further produce of the Window Duty impoſed by the 24th Geo. III. III. Further produce of the Duty on Two Wheel and Four Wheel Carriages IV. To compleat the former Duty on Male Servants V. Further produce of the Duties on Horfes, Waggons, and Carts VI. Further produce of Taxes impofed in 1784 From Michaelmas 1784 * From 5th Janry. 1785 to Michaelmas 1785. to 5th January 1785. £. 12,321,520 £. 401,118 46,189 447,307 12,499,916 £. 11,874,213 £. 401,118 56,101 457,219 £. 12,042,697 380,056 59,281 253,534 107,186 26,803 42,444 56,829 73,610 22,000 242,000 14,000 14,000 2,600,000 £. 15,379,182 15,397,471 VII. Further produce of Taxes impofed in 1785, including the improvement of the Medicine Duty VIII. Paid at the Excife and Alienation Office, in part of Civil Lift IX. Produce of the Land and Malt 103,000 265,000 2,600,000 X. Intereft and charges of the Public Debts XI. Exchequer Bills XII. Civil Liſt XIII. Charges on Aggregate Fund XIV. Navy XIV. Army XIV. Ordnance XV. Militia XVI. Mifcellaneous Services XVII. Appropriated Duties 1 EXPENDITURE. £. 9,275,769 258,000 900,000 64,600 1,800,000 1,600,000 348,000 91,000 74,274 66,538 AAnnual Surplus £. 14,478,181 £.14,478,181 90г,001 919,290 NEW BOOKS printed for JOHN STOCKDALE, oppofite Bur- lington Houſe, Piccadilly. This Day is published, in One large Volume Quarto, with an elegant Engraving of the Author, Price 11. 75. in boards, T HE HISTORY of the UNION between ENGLAND. and SCOTLAND; with a Collection of Original Papers relating thereto. By the celebrated DANIEL DE FOE. With an Introduction, in which the Confequences and Proba- bility of a like Union between this Country and Ireland are confidered, by JOHN LEWIS DELOLME, Author of the Work on the Conftitution of England. To which is pre- fixed a LIFE of the AUTHOR, and a copious INDEX. The Union between England and Scotland, being an extremely interefting Event, has led the Publifher to imagine, that a New Edition of this Work of De Foe, which is grown very ſcarce, would be acceptable to the Public, eſpecially at the preſent Time, when the Situation of Affairs in Ire- land induces many Perfons to wifh, that a fimilar Union between Great Britain and that Kingdom, may take place, as it may cauſe ſuch an Union, if not to be effected, at leaſt to be propofed, and to become, for a Time, the Subject of Debate in both Countries. "I was," fays De Foe himself, in his Appeal to Honour and Juftice, p. 50. "from my first entering into the Knowledge of Public Matters, and have ever been to this Day, a fincere Lover of the Conftitution of my Country; zealous for Liberty, and the Proteftant Intereft; but a conftant Follower of moderate Prin- ciples, a vigorous Oppofer of hot Meaſures in all Parties: I never once changed my Opinion, my Principles, or my Party; and let what will be faid of changing Sides, this I maintain, that I never once deviated from the Revolution Frinciples, nor from the Doctrine of Liberty and Property, on which it was founded." N.B. A few Copies are printed on Royal Paper, Price 11.11s. Od J. STOCKDALE, having purchased the remaining Copies of the following beautiful and ufeful Work, propojes to jell them at the reduced Price of 8s. 6d. in Boards. FR RANCISCI GODWINI primo Landavenfis dein Here- fordenfis Epifcopi de Præfulibus Angliæ Commentarius, omnium Epifcoporum necnen & Cardinalium ejufdem Gentis Nomina, Tempera, Seriem, atque Actiones maximè memora- biles, ab ultima Antiquitate repetita complexus. Ad Fidem Monumentorum in Archivis Regiis, Lamethanis, &c. &c. re- cognovit, New BOOKS printed for JOHN STOCKDALE. cognovit, plurimis in locis (adjectis Annotationibus) ad verita- tem reduxit, & perpetuâ demum Serie ad præfens ufque Sæcu- Jum continuavit GUL. RICHARDSON, S. T. P. Coll, Emman, Cant. Magifter, & Eccl. Lincoln. Canonicus. Cantabrigiæ, Typis Academicis excudebat Jofephus Bentham, 1743- Just Published, In two large vols. 4to. elegantly bound in calf, gilt, and lettered, price 21. 2s. A COMPLETE GEOGRAPHICAL DICTIONARY ; or, UNIVERSAL GAZETTEER, of Antient and Modern Geography, containing a full, particular, and accurate defcription of the known World in Europe, Afia, Africa, and America; comprifing a complete fyftem of geography, illuftrat- ed with correct maps and beautiful views of the principal cities, &c. and chronological tables of the Sovereigns of Europe. The geographical parts by JOHN SEALLY, A. M. member of the Roman academy; author of the Hiftoire Chronologique, facrée et profane; Elements of Geography and Aftronomy, &c. &c. interſperſed with extracts from the private manufcripts of one of the officers who accompanied Captain Cook in his voyage to the Southern Hemifphere. The aftronomical parts from the papers of the late Mr. ISRAEL LYONS, of Cambridge, aftrono- mer in Lord MULGRAVE's voyage to the Northern Hemisphere. Price Is. 6d. A SHORT ADDRESS to the PUBLIC on the Pay of the British Army. By an OFFICER. Price 28. fewed in Marble Paper, THE ARMS, CRESTS, and SUPPORTERS of the pre- fent BARONETS of Great Britain, engraved by B. Longmate. TH Price 2s. 6d. HE Prefent POLITICS of IRELAND: Confiſting of I. The Right Hon. Mr. Hutchinfon's Letter to his Con- tituents at Cork. II. Parliamentary Difcuffions on the Iriſh Arrangements; by Mefits. Connolly, Grattan, and Flood, Against them. Fitzgibbon, Mafon, Forster, Hutchinfon, For them. III. Mr. Laffan's Obfervations on the relative Situation of Great Britain and Ireland; with Notes thereon by an Engliſh Editor. Price New BOOKS printed for JOHN STOCKDALE. THE Price 8s. 6d. 'HE LONDON CALENDAR for the Year 1786, printed on a fine large Paper and Type, bound up with Stock- dale's New Companion to the London Calendar, for 1786, Fielding's new-engraved Arms of the Peers of Great Britain, Arms of the Baronets, and an Almanack, the Whole bound together. +++ Be careful to afk for the LONDON CALENDAR, &c. which may be had feparate, price bound 2s. Price 158. or 12s. each on taking fix copies, STOCKDALE's EDITION O F SHAKSPEARE; Including, in ONE VOLUME 8vo. the WHOLE of his DRAMATIC WORKS: With explanatory NOTES, compiled from various Commen- tators. To which are prefixed his LIFE and WILL. "Nature her pencil to his hand commits, "And then in all her forms to this great mafter fits." ADDRESS TO THE PUBLIC. A NEW edition of SHAKSPEARE, and an edition of fo fingu- lar a form as the prefent, in which all his plays are compre- hended in One Volume, will perhaps appear furprifing to many readers; but, upon a little reflection, their furprife will, the Editor doubts not, be converted into approbation. Much as SHAKSPEARE has been read of late years, and largely as the admiration and ſtudy of him have been extended, there is ftill a numerous clafs of men to whom he is very imperfectly known. Many of the middling and lower ranks of the inha- bitants of this country are either not acquainted with him at all, excepting by name, or have only feen a few of his plays, which have accidentally fallen in their way. It is to fupply the wants of thefe perfons that the prefent edition is principally undertaken; and it cannot fail of becoming to them a perpetual ſource of entertainment and inſtruction. But the inftruction that may be drawn from SHAKSPEARE is equal to the entertainment which his writings afford. He is the greateſt maſter of human nature, and of human life, that, per- haps, ever exifted; fo that we cannot perufe his works without having L > 3 3 23 י. New BOOKS printed for JOHN STOCKDALE. having our understandings confiderably enlarged. To promote, therefore, the knowledge of him, is to contribute to general improvement. Nor is the utility of the prefent publication confined to per- fons of the rank already defcribed; it will be found ferviceable. even to thoſe whoſe ſituation in life hath enabled them to pur- chaſe all the expenſive editions of our great dramatift. The book now offered to the public may commodiously be taken into a coach or a poft-chaife, for amufement in a journey. It is a compendium, not an abridgement, of the nobleft of our poets, and a library in a fingle volume. The Editor hath endeavoured to give all the perfection to this work which the nature of it can admit. The account of his life, which is taken from Rowe, and his laſt will, in reality, comprehend almost every thing that is known with regard to the perfonal hiftory of SHAKSPEARE. The notes which are fubjoined are fuch as were neceſſary for the purpoſe of illuftrating and explaining obfolete words, nuſual phraſes, old cuftoms, and obfcure or diſtant alluſions. In fhort, it has been the Editor's aim to omit nothing which may ſerve to ren ler SHAKSPEARE intelligible to every capa- city, and to every clafs of readers. Gentlemen in the country, finding a difficulty in procuring the above valuable work, by directing a line to Mr. STOCKDALE, oppofite Bur- lington Houſe, Piccadilly, (appointing the payment thereof in London,) fhall have it immediately forwarded (carriage paid) to any part of Great Britain. SANDFORD and MERTON, Vol. II. In the Prefs and speedily will be publiſhed, Embellished with a beautiful Frontifpiece, reprefenting a Bull-Baiting, THE A HE HISTORY of SANDFORD and MERTON: Work intended for the Ufe of Children. Vol. II. London Printed for JOHN STOCKDALE, oppofite Burling- ton Houſe, Piccadilly. Of whom may be had, FOUR TRACTS, by THOMAS DAY, Efq. in One Volume Octavo, price 10s. 6d. bound. Alfo by the fame Author, The Hiſtory of Sandford and Merton, Vol. I. price 3s. bound.