Production Note Cornell University Library produced this volume to replace the irreparably deteriorated original. It was scanned using Xerox software and equipment at 600 dots per inch resolution and compressed prior to storage using CCITT Group 4 compression. The digital data were used to create Cornell's replacement volume on paper that meets the ANSI Standard Z39.48-1984. The production of this volume was supported in part by the New York State Program for the Conservation and Preservation of Library Research Materials and the Xerox Corporation. Digital file copyright by Cornell University Library 1994.ERNEST WENDE: A MEMOIR BY ADELBERT MOOTERNEST WENDE. M- D. Erom the painting by E. Berenice, presented to the Buffalo Historical Society by Grover Wende, M. D.ERNEST WENDE: A MEMOIR1 BY ADELBERT MOOT Dr. Ernest Wende was born July 23, 1853, and died in this city February 11, 1910, with an established interna- tional reputation as a master in the application of the principles of modern, scientific, preventive medicine to human life in a great city. Over thirteen years of his pro- fessional life he was the Health Commissioner of Buffalo, his first term beginning in 1892, and ending in July, 1902, and his second term beginning in 1907 and ending with his death in 1910. "When he first took office, under one of our most efficient and respected mayors, Charles Bishop, in 1892, under our revised charter, as the first health commissioner installed under it, he took office in a city in which up to that time the doctor appointed to take charge of medical matters in the city had always been appointed for political reasons, and the natural consequence was that the office had been treated more or less as a political sinecure. Because this had been so, in the revised charter it was provided that, for the munificent salary of $4,000 a year, the Health Com- missioner was to give his whole time to the reorganized Health Department of the City of Buffalo. Had not the then Corporation Counsel officially advised the Mayor that the true construction of the full time condition did not require the appointed Health Commissioner to give up private practice altogether, but all that it required was that he should give the first place to the demands of his office, 1. Paper read at a meeting of the Buffalo Historical Society, Tuesday evening, April 18, 1916. 127128 ERNEST WENDE: A MEMOIR even if it should take his full time to discharge the duties of the office, so that there would be no time left to continue his private practice, it would have been impossible for Mayor Bishop to have obtained the consent of Dr. Ernest Wende, or any other first-class doctor, to become Health Commissioner; for Dr. Ernest Wende was seeking the ap- pointment of another prominent doctor, and that prominent doctor was opposed by still another doctor, equally promi- nent, with such vigor that Mayor Bishop, with the assent of all concerned, except Dr. Wende, suggested that the ap- pointment of Dr. Wende would end all factional differences in the medical profession, and would at the same time give the city a first-class, up-to-date Health Commissioner. At first, Dr. Wende strongly demurred to this suggestion, but ultimately the Mayor and his friends among the doctors from both sides finally induced him to withdraw his oppo- sition and to consent to take the office, on the basis of the official full-time opinion of the Corporation Counsel, as stated. While there has been a general appreciation of the won- derful preventive medical work done by Dr. Wende in his two terms of office, perhaps there has been no statement of it as a whole that has given an adequate view of the per- manent results of putting this extraordinarily capable and efficient man and doctor into this office nearly twenty-five years ago. Few even of his professional brothers in this city realize that the almost revolutionary, but thoroughly scien- tific, methods he introduced into the office, the thoroughly non-political and efficient organization he made of it back in 1892, and the extraordinary vigor he then injected into it, have continued to dominate it, in the main, during all these years. It is unfortunately true that, for purely political reasons, he was not reappointed in 1902, although the best citizens of all parties urged his reappointment, and since his death, in recent years outside politicians and officialsERNEST WENDE: A MEMOIR 129 have successfully brought great pressure, even official pres- sure from his superiors, to bear upon his present successor in office to find places in the department for their friends or political adherents. But even today the Commissioner of Health and the chiefs of bureaus in the main are men selected and trained by Dr. Wende. His scientific methods are still employed, and generally the results are still good, although the unnecessary 'addition of some unfit political men and women has added to the expense; the expense for the last fiscal year under Dr. Wende, which ended July 1, 1909, being $91,392.42, while the expense for the fiscal year ending July 1, 1915, was $195,134.09. In spite of like political and personal requests in his day, Dr. Wende rigidly adhered to the Civil Service Law, and took the first man on the list, regardless of politics. It is true, the bad preference clause of the Civil Service Act once compelled Dr. Wende to take the second man, a vet- eran, with the result that he had to discharge him for good cause within two years. Still his present successor in office, and all those under him, when let alone, so thoroughly appreciate the soundness of the organization first given the office by Dr. Wende, that they, in turn, are solicitous to maintain, and even increase, its reputation for efficiency, a thing that can only be done by rigidly excluding all personal and political considerations from its administra- tion; for such considerations have no place when the health of people is concerned. The year before Dr. Wende took office, the death rate of the city was nearly 24 per 1,000, and so efficient was Dr. Wende’s attack upon diseases along the line of scientific medicine, that within one year he had substantially reduced this death rate to about 14 per 1,000, and from that time down to the last full year Dr. Wende held office as Health Commissioner, the death rate of Buffalo was firmly held to from some fraction above 13 per 1,000 to 15 per 1,000.130 ERNEST WENDE: A MEMOIR \ In other words, upon the basis of the last census before he took office, the deaths among 255,664 people were 6,001, or about 23% per 1,000, and the deaths the last year he held office were 6,111 for 415,532 people, or 14.7 per 1,000. How did Dr. Wende so suddenly bring about such a groat decrease in the death rate of Buffalo, and how did he con- tinue, and how have the men and methods he installed con- tinued, to maintain such a favorable death rate, in spite of a very large foreign population, a majority of whom are very ignorant of laws of health and their application to caring for human life, when they come to this city? So generally was it recognized from the beginning that Buffalo was not a city in which it was probable that any such great change could be brought about in the health of the city, that at first statisticians of great universities challenged these three unrivalled American figures in cutting down the death rate of a great city; but Dr. Wende gladly wel- comed such criticisms and arguments, because they gave to him and his scientific assistants the opportunity to demon- strate the effectiveness of their scientific methods and the correctness of their statistical records. Going over these figures, I have reached the conclusion that on any reasonable basis of calculation for the substan- tially twenty-five years since these scientific medical methods were introduced, they have saved the citizens of Buffalo substantially 75,000 premature deaths, and have given to the children since bom, as well as adults, an in- creased expectancy of life averaging several years in the case of every citizen. The people in particular who have profited by this great change have been the great masses of our population who have not sufficient wealth to employ the most expert physicians, or to avail themselves of the most expert nursing in their own homes. To these masses of people, the reorganized Health Department brought and has continued to furnish scientific medical treatment andERNEST WEN BE: A MEMOIR 131 advice generally as good as, and often better than, that enjoyed by wealthy people who have not always shown as good judgment as the head of the Health Department showed in selecting medical and nursing aids and applying modem, scientific, medical methods to the treatment of disease. In considering Dr. Wende’s life, I want to point out now that it was no accident that he accomplished these results, but that they were the natural result of the most thorough scientific preparation of a naturally able young man for the practice of his profession along the most modem and scientific lines, and the faithful adherence of that man in office to the principles of Civil Service Reform. Had not Dr. Wende had natural ability of a very high order, had he not been thoroughly prepared along the most advanced scientific lines for his task, and had he not entered upon the discharge of his official duties with the desire to do his utmost for the public health of the City of Buffalo, and with political intelligence enough to know he could not do that unless he appointed his assistants and subordinates for merit alone, and, above all, had he not had indomitable courage and persistence in his great task, the results he accomplished would have been absolutely impossible for him or any other man in the same high position. Dr. Wende’s inheritance, his early life, his education, and his early professional training and experience, all alike fitted him most naturally and completely to do for Buffalo the great and permanent work he did for Buffalo in his Health Department. His father was a comparatively short hut sturdy man, who had had a superior education, and who, preferring the freedom and independence of the country to any occupation in the city, had become the owner of a large farm some miles east of Buffalo, at a place on the New York Central Railroad still known as Wende Station. The father was of the philosophical, far-sighted,132 ERNEST WENDE: A MEMOIR broad-minded type, who thoroughly appreciated the impor- tance of giving each of his children a good education and a good chance in life. He was not a man to worry over trifles, although he was not a man who would neglect important matters. The mother, bom, reared and edu- cated at a time when there were no colleges for women, and when anything more than an ordinary education was thought quite unnecessary for a woman, had not had the father’s educational advantages. Nevertheless, this mother, tall, lithe, straight, and possessed of dynamic energy and in- domitable will, was a woman of very strong character. Self-reliant, industrious, energetic, frugal, resourceful, and a person who drove work instead of letting work drive her, it was natural that the children of this mother should in- herit qualities that would be invaluable to them in after life, when we add to these qualities the development they received in the home of such a father and such a mother. Dr. Ernest Wende was the eldest of their ten children, nine boys and a girl, all of whom grew to adult years, the mother and seven of her children still surviving. These children have all become citizens of unusual character and value in the communities in which they live. In considering educa- tional advantages, too often the advantages of such a home on a large farm in the country are quite overlooked. Much is now made, and properly made, of vocational education and training, but I have yet to see any vocational school equal to a large and busy farm, presided over by the right father and. the right mother, as a school in which to de- velop courage, resourcefulness, industry and capacity. The enervating effect of riches and luxury is entirely removed from such a farm, and upon it are produced no false dis- tinctions as to labor, or classes, or either vested or Divine rights. In the days of Dr. Wende’s boyhood, many changes that have since taken place on the farm to make life easier wereERNEST WENDE: A MEMOIR 133 entirely unknown. Then, as soon as the boys were large enough, they were called, in the busy season from early Spring until early Fall, at four, or five, or six o’clock, as the case might be, to get an early start to Buffalo with the farm produce, or it might be they were even started the night before, that they might be there in time for the opening of market in the morning. The market thus gave them good schooling in salesmanship and business methods, and then at home there were wood fires to build, cows to be fed and milked, horses and other live stock to be fed and cared for, stables to be cleaned, wood to be cut and brought in, other chores to do, horses to harness, or oxen to be yoked, fields to plow or harrow or sow, fields to plant or cultivate or hoe, hay and grain to be gathered into barns or stacks, threshing to do, potatoes to dig and crops to market, fences to build or mend, sugar bushes to tap, sap to gather, syrup or sugar to be prepared and marketed, fruit trees to be trimmed, fruit to be picked and gathered to cellars or carried to market, farm animals to be cared for in sickness or accident, colts or steers to be broken and trained for service, additional buildings erected, buildings to be re- paired, ox-bows to make, plow-points to be sharpened, har- nesses to repair or to oil, and other things, great and small, to do, small enough for the smallest hands, and large enough for full physical and mental power. A boy who is trained in such a school, who knows what it is to contend with a high- strung colt, not yet fully trained, or how to drive a team of oxen so they will not pull down a gate, or how to handle a flock of stupid sheep so as to finally land them in the enclosure intended, not to mention many other difficult tasks imposed on him by storm and wind and severe seasons where he must act alone upon his own courage, resourceful- ness and responsibility, has learned lessons of self-control, courage and resourcefulness that are fully equal to any-ERNEST WENDE: A MEMOIR 134 thing he will afterwards learn in school, high school or college. Without recounting the things to be done in a farmhouse equally numerous and equally helpful in the days when farm produce brought but a small price, and when a farmer owning a large farm had need of a frugal wife if he was to raise and educate a large family, it is sufficient to say that Dr. Wende had this invaluable training in his home and upon the farm until he entered the Medical School in Buf- falo. Incidentally, of course, he went to the district school, which is one of the best schools ever known for children, or one of the worst, according to the teacher employed. As soon as he was ready for the city high school, he came to the only high school in this city, from which he was graduated in due season. From the high school he went to the Buf- falo Medical School, which then required only two years, two comparatively short sessions, and would now be con- sidered so inadequate that it would not be permitted to exist in a vast majority of the States of this country, al- though it was then as good as or better than the majority of medical schools of this country. But Dr. Wende even then understood that its training was not sufficient, and consequently he took a post-graduate course for more than a year at one of the best medical schools in the country at that time, the School of Physicians and Surgeons in the City of New York. Then he came back to Erie County, went into the practice of medicine with Dr. Cornwell, a fine old-school physician, in the village of Alden. At that time, Dr. Wende married a real helpmate, and he soon prospered in his country practice. After a few years of this practice and prosperity, considering his medical and other training still insufficient, he went to Pennsylvania University, where he greatly distinguished himself in sci- entific and also medical work in two different Departments of that University, from which he received an M. D. in 1884,ERNEST WENDE: A MEMOIR 135 the degree of B.S. in 1885, and in addition the George Woods’ Alumni prize of $500 upon his work and thesis upon the geology of Western New York. But he was not content with even that, and he, therefore, took his wife and went to Germany to spend the balance of what they had laid aside by frugality, while he studied the most scientific methods of medicine, under such masters as Koch, who was then the leader of the medical world in applying in medicine Pasteur’s discoveries concerning bac- teria in the vegetable and domestic animal world. As the result of more than a year spent in studying with Koeh and other masters in Berlin and Vienna in the then developing field of the germ theory of disease, Dr. Wende returned to this country and opened his office for the practice of medi- cine in Buffalo, in 1887. Down to that time, the vast majority of the medical profession knew nothing of bac- teria or germs, and spoke with derision of bug doctors; indeed, for many years later this was true of the great majority of the medical profession. But all this affected Dr. Wende not at all, for he was sure of his foundation, and always had the courage of his convictions. At that time, it is very certain there was no doctor in or near Buffalo so thoroughly or scientifically trained in the modern history of disease as was Dr. Wende. It was after practicing his profession in Buffalo from 1887 to 1892, and after showing in the Medical School and in his hospital connections and consultation work how practical and valuable his ideas were, that Mayor Bishop chose him for the important work of Health Commissioner. At the time he was chosen for this work, his reputation was such that eminent authorities in Europe were from time to time sending their patients who came to this country to Dr. Wende, for consultations and continued treatment, some of these eminent patients journeying from New York to Buffalo for the express purpose of consulting Dr.136 ERNEST WENDE: A MEMOIR Wende, because they were told to do so by their doctors in Europe. But how did Dr. Wende so suddenly and so quickly reduce the death rate in Buffalo l He at once installed Dr. Bissell as bacteriologist, in spite of the ridicule of aldermen and others, and when an epidemic of typhoid fever commenced in the early Spring, he consulted our imperfect records and found that there had been an epi- demic of typhoid fever every Spring for many years. His training told him the water was probably at fault, and he had Dr. Bissell analyze the water for bacteria and discov- ered that it was unfit to drink; that it was no better than the water procured from the harbor, when analyzed; in fact, water from the harbor and water from the faucets seemed to be exactly the same water. Being advised by a legal friend as to the course to pursue, he talked with the then head of the Water Bureau, discovered that it was the custom in the Spring to open the Bird Island Inlet, because of difficulty with anchor-ice in the river tunnel in the Spring of the year, and thus he learned that the people were, in fact, drinking harbor water at the time typhoid fever became epidemic every Spring, for he found this had been done every Spring. He insisted that this should be discontinued at once, no matter what the cost because of anchor-ice, and the Mayor and head of the Water Bureau, being somewhat reluctant to follow his advice, were more or less coerced into doing so by his suggestion that he must appeal to the public through the newspapers, if necessary, to effect this reform. Not only was the Bird Island Inlet closed, but it was sealed for all time, and thus disappeared the cause of a great number of deaths from typhoid fever each Spring because of this practice, due to ignorance of medical facts then just becoming generally known. To make certain that it would disappear, Dr. Wende had the water turned off in each of the then reservoirs of the city,ERNEST WENDE: A MEMOIR 137 and had these reservoirs most thoroughly cleansed and dis- infected with most powerful disinfectants before he would again permit water to be stored in them for drinking purposes. But he did not stop here. He knew that all over the city down to that time were wells, public and private, that were in common use, that were more or less contaminated from privy vaults and other sources of disease, and he knew, furthermore, that there were immense numbers of privy vaults in use that had no connection whatever with sewers. The result was, he labored with the Aldermen, the Council and the Mayor until he got through an ordinance to correct this state of affairs, and then, inside of the first year, he caused to be inspected and discontinued more than 15,000 private privy vaults; a necessary part of the work being putting in and connecting sewers or plumbing, as necessary, to take the place of the privy vaults. All wells, public and private, were discontinued at the same time, that the people might not drink dangerous water. If scarlet fever, typhoid fever, or any such disease, ap- peared anywhere, it had to be reported at once, the house to be placarded, its plumbing and surroundings to be in- spected, and, if necessary, an inspector went far into the country to examine into the conditions under which the milk was produced that was sold along the milk route where the scarlet fever or other disease he knew likely to follow contaminated milk, had been discovered. If diphtheria was discovered, his inspectors were at once at the place where it was discovered, to ascertain its prob- able cause, and changes in the premises or plumbing were required, even if the citizen was as prominent as Mr. Mil- burn was; for when diphtheria was discovered in Mr. Milburn’s home, Mr. Milburn facetiously remarked to a friend that Dr. Wende was a perfect little czar in the way lie took charge of such matters and in the requirements he138 EBNEST WENDE: A MEMOIR made. In one case a leading church was the offender as to the condition of premises owned by it, and its priest, used to having his own way, appeared at the Commissioner’s office to turn his requirements aside. The Doctor listened patiently and good naturedly, and then asked the priest whether he would obey his requirements. The priest answered “No.” The Doctor quietly turned to an assist- ant present and asked if he had heard what the priest said in answer to the Doctor’s question. The assistant answer- ing in the affirmative, the Doctor quietly directed him, in the presence of the priest, to swear out a warrant for the priest’s arrest. Instantly, the priest, discovering that he had a type of official quite out of the ordinary to deal with,, became respectful and obedient, as is the custom of his church, and began to inquire of the Doctor if they could not reach some reasonable adjustment of the matter ; the end naturally being that the priest was convinced the Doc- tor’s requirements, to begin with, were reasonable; and, therefore, the priest promised to comply with them within a reasonable time. There is not time to go into all the incidents that tell so* well the common-sense, directness, courage, and sound medi- cal judgment involved in the reforms that Dr. Wende brought about, but a few were of such a far-reaching char- acter that they should be mentioned. When the Honorable Tom Johnson was Mayor of Cleve- land, and in the zenith of his popularity and power there,, it was well known that he was an anti-vaccinationist, the anti-vaccination doctrine having made great headway at that time. In due time it became known that there was a good deal of smallpox in Cleveland during Mayor Johnson’s, administration, and Dr. Wende thought the matter so seri- ous that he went there himself to see if the rumors were well founded. He had a good deal of difficulty in getting Mayor Johnson’s permission to investigate for himself, butBENE ST WENDS: A MEMOIR 139 the suggestion that he would have to quarantine against Cleveland unless he was permitted to investigate, finally caused the Mayor to assent to his investigation. He found the health officer of Cleveland to be a very good doctor, but a man quite as lacking in backbone as many such men are. After Dr. Wende had discovered many, many cases of small- pox, the Doctor admitted their situation, but confidentially said he was powerless to do anything with the Mayor. Thereupon, Dr. Wende returned to Mayor Johnson and told him what he had seen with his own eyes, and that they had at that time undoubtedly hundreds of cases of smallpox in Cleveland; for it was discovered afterwards that during this epidemic Cleveland had over 2,000 such cases. Still, Mayor Johnson suggested to Dr. Wende that he was not Health Commissioner of Cleveland, and the matter was not within his jurisdiction. To this Dr. Wende answered that if that was the view that was to be taken in the matter, he would at once place inspectors on the docks and in the depots in which trains from Cleveland would arrive; that he would turn back people, or even boats or trains, if neces- sary if a clean bill of health could not be given; that he would himself telegraph to the health officers of other neighboring cities, like Detroit, what he found the situation to be; that he would give a full statement of the matter to the Associated Press, and Cleveland would soon find out that she could not ignore the rest of the world, if she was keeping secret the fact that she had smallpox, or yellow fever, or any other contagious disease dangerous to human life. Dr. Wende did not find it necessary to do these things, because Mayor Johnson at once saw the point and agreed in all Dr. Wende *s reasonable requests about vaccination, local quarantine, and everything else, to save his city from such a fate; his anti-vaccination theories going into a state of suspended animation for the time being.140 ERNEST WENDE: A MEMOIR Dr. Wende was an expert in the use of the microscope, and he made much use of it in his work. It was through the microscope that he first learned that it was impossible to properly cleanse the tube of the long-necked nursing bottle then so popular and so universally used. Having found out another source through which the lives of great numbers of small children were lost, through milk contami- nated from the infected long rubber neck of such bottles, he paid out a considerable sum of his own money to have slides made from which he could make it perfectly clear to legislators that the use of such bottles should be pro- hibited. Of course the manufacturers of such bottles, and the druggists who sold them, did not view this attack with complacency, but the Doctor had such a reputation for understanding his business, and his pictures were so effect- ive, that he carried the day, and obtained the legislation he wanted. By this time the germ theory of disease had ceased to be a novelty, bug-hunting doctors were no longer sneered at, and the result was that within six months from the time the Doctor carried his point in legislation, not a single long-necked nursing bottle could be found in any drug store in the City of Buffalo, after the most careful and well-planned attempt of the Doctor to find one. This reform was not only a local and a State reform, but in a very short time it was a National, if not an international, reform, and I dare say it is many years since any person has seen a long-necked infant’s bottle anywhere for sale. At first, Dr. Wende encountered opposition from not only the politicians and the uninformed public, but often a great majority of his own profession vigorously opposed his proposed reforms. All this made no difference to him, for he was absolutely impersonal in his fighting, and friend or foe had to get out of the way sooner or later, if Dr. Wende began to push a reform, for he got his material first, and soon demonstrated that it was of such a scientificEBNEST WENDE: A MEMOIB 141 character that no one could successfully withstand his attacks. One of the last of his reforms was that with reference to contagious diseases. At the time this last reform was com- menced, no hospital in Buffalo had any accommodations of any size for contagious diseases. The Doctor, therefore, began to agitate for a city hospital that would treat nothing but contagious diseases. He soon got a majority to agree with him that there should be such a hospital, but when he began the location of it, whatever ward he proposed it for, the Aldermen and residents of that ward at once rose up in all their might and opposed it, on the real ground, of course, that it would be destructive to the value of their property, although other grounds were quite as often urged, while nothing was said about this one. Then it occurred to Dr. Wende that the schoolhouse of School 41, at Broadway and Spring Street,- a schoolhouse that had been abandoned as unfit for school purposes, could be made over into such a hospital, and an epidemic of scarlet fever occurring at just this time, gave the Doctor the power to take possession of this schoolhouse and convert it into a temporary hospital of the character he wanted. At that time he did not intend to make this a permanent hospital, but only intended to clean it and repair it so that it could be used for this tem- porary purpose. The opposition from the various Aider- men, however, making it impossible to locate such a hos- pital anywhere else, the Doctor improved, repaired, and rebuilt as he could; and the result is, that continuing his methods to the present day, this old school building, which remains only as to its walls, has been converted into one of the most up-to-date contagious-disease hospitals to be found anywhere in this country. It has beds for 150 patients; was opened February 19, 1909; and since that time 5,008 eases of contagious diseases have been there treated. The result is that the people generally, and the masses in par*142 ■ERNEST WENDE: A MEMOIR ticular, now have a hospital to which a member of the family can be sent, thus saving the rest of the family, or a . school, it may be, from the danger incident to permitting a contagious disease to be at large. Transients in hotels, or wealthy people, too, can go to this hospital, have a pri- vate room, and receive proper care for a reasonably moder- ate amount. The various diseases are scientifically isolated from each other, and now no one on the outside would think of suggesting that this hospital for contagious diseases affects the value of property about it. Most appropriately, since Dr. Wende’s death, his hospital has been named “The Ernest W'ende Hospital, ’ ’ and in it we have a fitting monu- ment to his last permanent reform of conditions for the benefit of the masses of his beloved city. Of course Dr. Wende’s family and friends will realize how many important incidents, and even reforms, remain unmentioned by me, but no one will know better than his family and friends that to mention them all might require a volume. Nor have I more than hinted at the way he carried the duties of his office with him, in season and out of season, night and day, week days and Sundays, when he went to other cities, and when he was at home. His ambi- tion always was to keep Buffalo in the very front of the procession of great cities in its healthfulness. His constant study was to prevent premature death, and save more and more of human suffering and human life. Even when he knew an as yet incurable malady had seized him, because the as yet only known remedy, surgery, had been tried and had failed, he continued to have daily reports made to him, and he continued to supervise the work of his public office from his room of sickness. Nor did he abate his interest or his work for his city until he was removed by death. This bare sketch of Dr. Wende’s life has been necessarily confined to a few more or less well-known incidents in his thorough education and training for his profession, and hisEWE ST WEN EE: A MEMOIB 143 career as a public official that af terwards came to him. The permanent value of his scientific and often pioneer work for the health of the public was the natural result of thoroughly trained native ability working unselfishly along true scien- tific lines. His methods and his work were soon well known and often repeated in large cities and towns all over the civilized world.* In particular, in Germany, where so much of his valuable scientific training was obtained, his name, like that of his neighbor and friend, Dr. Park, became well known to his profession. In this country, in particular, many of the scientific methods first employed here by him have been used by other large cities with such success that many of them, being otherwise favored, are now sometimes a little ahead of Buffalo in their death rate. It is doubtful if any of our citizens, even the two distin- guished citizens who became Presidents, have done public work of more permanent value, certainly no citizen has done public work of more permanent value for the masses of our city. With Dr. Wende, as with all other men, his true monument is this public work he did to help mankind. In this sketch I have but barely suggested his scientific work with the microscope, his helpful work in our Medical School, his hearty co-operation in the work in our hospitals, and his learning, skill and judgment in consultations and private practice. An outline of the chronology of his life, prepared by Dr. Wende himself for a friend a few years before his death, outlines his training and career thus: Ernest Wende, physician; born at Mill Grove, N. Y., July 23, 1853; son of Bernard A. and Susan W.; graduate of the University of Buffalo, Medical Department, 1878; •special course, Columbia, 1881-2; married Aug. 25, 1881, Frances Harriet Cutler; graduate of University of Pa., M. D., 1884, B. Sc., 1885; special course, Berlin, Vienna, 1885-6; Prof. Dermatology Medical Dep’t, Univ. of Buffalo; "botany and microscopy, Coll, of Pharmacy, same; Health144 EENEST WENDE: A MEMO IE Commissioner, Buffalo, 1891-1902; member Am. Micros- Soc., Pan-Am. Med. Assn., Am. Public Health Assn.; Pel- low Electro-Therapeutic Assn. (Pres. 1901); Koyal Micros- Soc., England; N. Y. State Med. Soc.; Supreme Pres. Order of the Iroquois. This sketch of his life is necessarily quite inadequate, but I have at least hinted at the worth of the man and his work- in private life, Dr. Wende was a man of simple, unpre- tentious habits, of direct purpose and method. He was a genial, loyal son and brother; an affectionate, devoted and loyal husband and father; a loyal, patriotic and public- spirited citizen. He might have made a fortune in money, but he cared so much for his profession, his city, and the welfare of mankind, and was so intent on bettering human conditions and human healthfulness, that money never seemed to be any object to him. To his family and his friends he left, however, a memory and a reputation that transcends any money value.