CIHM Microfiche ({Monographs) ICIUIH Collection de microfiches (monographles) Canadian Institute for Historical Microraproductions / Institut Canadian da microraproductlons historiquas Technical and Bibliographic Notes/Notes tachniquas et bibliographiques The institute has attempted to obtain the best original copy available for filming. Features of this copy which may be bibliographically unique, which may alter any of the images in the reproduction, or which may significantly change the usual method of filming, are checked below. L'Institut a microftlme le meilteur exemplaire qu'il lui a ete possible de se procurer Les details de cet exemplaire qui sont peutetre uniques du point de vue bibliographique, qui peuvent modifier une image reproduite. ou qui peuvent eiiger une modification dans la m^thode normale de fllmage sont indiquAs ci-dessous. □ Coloured covers/ Couverture da couleur Coloured pages/ Pages da couleur ! I Covers damaged/ Couverture endommagee Pages damaged/ Pages endommagees I i Covers restored and/or laminated/ I I Couverture restaur^e et/ou pellicul^e C Pages restored and/or laminated/ Pages restaurees et/ou pelliculees □ Cov< Le ti Cover title mis tre de cou. nque pT' Pages discoloured, stained or foxed/ liLJ Pages decolorees. tacheteas ou piquees □ Coloured maps/ Cartes g^ographiqc . 4vt'rvif(n sway and mnKterdoni,' and he dw« no l>y reaxoii of bin thoroughnexd. hi» practical good Hen»e, iiii.i hin familiarity with the himinem an well 8» the leifHl side of hii« "ubject."— taw Qtiai'terly Jin-inc. " Mr. I'almer'H work« on Companv Law are all Iwvond iritii-ism. He kiiow« more ot tlie Kubjtrt than, i)erhapM, any other member of the loffal profeiwiou. HIh boolu have for iiany practical purposen lieeu treated an beintf, in fai-t, the very law itself. It in a Niibject for conifratiilation of all concerned that thi» book ban been bnmirht up to date. ' AN APPENDIX CONTAINING ACTS AND RULES. ELEVENTH EDITION. UY SIR FRANCIS BEAUFORT PALMER. Beneher of Ike Imier TrmpU; AS8ISTEI) BT The Hon. CHARLES MACNAGHTEN, K.C., EDWARD MANSON, Of the Uidiilr Temple, Bairinlrr-al-Lau-. ^ 7' • LONDON : STEVENS AND SONS, LIMITED, 119 & 120, CHANCERY LANE. TORONTO: CANADA lAW BOOK COMPANY, LIMl O. PHILADELPHIA: OROMAP.TY LAW BOOK COMPANY. 1912. wm BY THE SAME AUTHOR. Twenty-Savanth Edit. D«my lamo. 1911. Pric. a..ed. n.t, Cloth. THE SHAREHOLDERS, DIRECTORS, AND VOLUNTARY LlQl'lDATORS' LEGAL COMPANION. A Manual of Everjday Law and Praotioe for rromofn, Shan-hoUer. Din-'on, S«;ret8ri«., Credituw, 8..1idtoT., an.l Voluntary Liqui.latun. uf Comp«n"e» under the Comi«iuie>. (C«n»olidation) Act, ia()H, wit], App'odix of uiwful Furnu. • TnTilumbl. to rtarehoWer..dlreo'o.ii,iecn!t.ri»..«nd Partnerahipa. '•rramnied from end to md with knowledge unefnl to the partie. to whom it ii. ■peciaUyaddiemied."— *'i« mciins t,,r(-;iw the future of the work. He trusted tha' t \vo\ild ■ be f. und practically useful to members o' both bi ..oIk-" ■ he Profession," and the outcome lias surpassfl hi,M Kst suiiguine expecta- tions. Many judges, law ottifcr of the High Court, aiul nuiu^ branches of the I'rofessiou, testified to the utility of tlu editions, and thousands of ustn clients of the Author. flui Ci .vti. ofHciaU ■emlors of both a^rain and again ik, in its various f it have become Moreover a large proporti-ii registered since the publication of their constitution, regulations, com and proceedings, the influence of ti hand of the Author, and often the vi advocated in the work have prevailed in i When the work was first publish* paid-up capital of companies under the to 1877 was about 307,000,000/., when capital under the Companies (Const 1908, now exceeds 2,222,000,000/. (a), • ^he 'Tipanie* =v<)rk siiow. m >e< urities H he r.- . .M, Ik' Itfl-I^ Act, idc vhich («) The late Viscount Goschen in his Etuuiys i. i Addrofweo. 19(»5, refers to the wonderful deTelopment of the company system betwoen 1K77 VI PREFACE TO ELEVKNTH EDITION. the (lebentureH uiid dcb-turo stock of such com- pnnioH r»>j»re«ent, it i« bolio* J, a further sum of 50(>,00(»,000/. The Author took part in tho various Committees ap|H)inted by the Board of Trade, which resulted in tlie Companies Acts of 1000 ai.d li)07, and in the Consolidation Act of 1908. It has been a pleasure to bring this part of the w«>rk up to dak>, and the Author trusts that the result of his labours will merit that kindly consideration which has beet w liberally accorded to former editions. Cordial thanks are due from the Auilioi *o rho Honourable Charles Macnaohtei'', K.C., . Mr. Edward Manson. and to Mr. RoBt •' Morris, uil of the Chancery Bur, for kind assistance in passing the work through the press, and preliminary thereto, and to many members of both branches of the Profession, as well at home as abroad, for valuable communica- tions and suggestions. F. B. P. fi, New Square, Lincoln's Inn, May, 1912. aiid 1903, when the paid-up capital amounted to 1,850,000,000/., and says, "Surely such stupendous amounts are instructive, as showing by thuir magnitude how large a proportion of the business of the country is concentrated in the hands of joint stock companies. . . . The number of shareholdors has grown even in a much larger ratio than the colossal growth of the aggregate capital ; the profits and risks of nearly every kind of business have been spread from year to year over fresh thousands of individuals, and the middle class with modenito incomes are more and more participating in that accumulation of wealth, from busin'.- ■ of every description, which formerly built up the fortunes of individua. traders, or of bankers, or of single families." ( vii ) TAHLi: OF FORMS. Chaptbk I.-l'RRT^MlNARY (pp. 1— U9) [">-.<«...< ,w for,,,,-]. Chaptbk II.-I'BOMOTEES (pp. 181-188). r«ni p»o» 1. Agreeiiiont by pr«nioter« to puy pn-liminary p'penBes in tun NiileratioD of vendor'* Hharcii . . . 8. Agrei>inent to pay preliminary oxponsng in eon.Hidoration of com missiong . . . . ■ 8. Agreement for sale of concession to promoter who is to form company . . . . - 4. Agreement to contribute to a preliminary expanses fund 8. Syndicate agreement for purchaao and ro-sale of mines 8. Agreement by sharehc'derw to pool their »haro« and have sold by trustees .... 7. Another ..... 1S:{ IM 156 187 leo 163 riiAFiEK 111.— PR08PECTUSKS (pp. 168-874). 8. Skeleton prospectus ..... 247 9. Application for shares ..... 257 10. Bankers' receipt ..... 257 11. AdT-ertisement as to prospectus .... 258 12. Resolution to xign nud file pro8pectu^ . . 260 18a. Notice ayoiuing allotment in contravention of .sect. 4 of the Act of 19(K) . . . '261 Statement in lieu of prospectus .... 264 Chapter IV.-UNDERWBITINa (pp. 876-319). 13. Underwriters' application .... Z96 14. Underwriting letter with signed application and deposit . 300 14«. Acceptance of underwriting proposal . . . 302 16. Sub-underwriting letter .... 302 16. Underwiiting letter to trustee for company about to be formed. 303 17. UndcrwritiDg lottor where application not to be made till list closed ...... 304 VUl TABLE OF FORMS. 18. Underwriting contract with the company where oommismon paid out of profit 10. Agreement to procure underwriting for a lump sum 20. Underwriting of :i debenture issue 21. Another . • • • 21a. Certificate of right to call for allotment of shares 22. Underwriting clauses in memorandum of association 23. Authority to subscribe . . • 24. Agreement for underwriting shares : A. for underwriters, and B. for ])ropo»ed company . • • • 28. Agreemeut to allot paid-up shares in satisfaction of commission 26. Underwriting contract as to . Mituro stock before company formed . • • ■ 27. Agreement to undeiTfrite debenture stock . 28. Notice to underwriters . 29. Ueading to draft prospectus 80. Another 3U5 306 307 309 311 312 313 313 314 315 317 318 318 31» Chafteb V.-AGREEMENTS (pp. 321-446). 31. Agreemout to sell business to new company. General form . 32. Guarantee of profits by vendor . • • 33. Vendors' shares deferred . • • ■ 84. Another .•••■' 88. Option to vendor to subscribe for shares at par 36. Exclusion of objectionable assets . • • • 37. Vendor may pay promoter syndicate 38. Arbitration .••••" 39. Guarantee of certain assets . . • ■ 40. Agreement with agent or trustee for intended company 41. Agreement by company adopting contract made on its behalf before its incorpf)ration . • • 42. Agreement by company adopting with modifications contract made before its incorporation . ■ • • 43. Agreement by company for sale of its entire business as a going concern ..•••• 44. Memorandum of ratification . . . • 46. Agreement for transfer of life assurance business 46. Clauses upon transfer of assurance business for special funds in hands of the transferee company 47. Agreement forsale of patents. Consideration: Cash and founders' shares ...••■ 48. Agreement to grant license to company to manufacture goods for licensor ...••• 49. Agreement for sale to company of foreign mines 60. Option to buy concession . . . . 61. Agreement for sale of ship to single ship company . 52. Satisfaction of part of price in paid-up shares 34S 303 365 365 365 366 366 367 367 367 369 370 371 373 374 377 378 382 :W4 388 387 3H8 TABLE OF FOKMS. IX Form 63. Ifwue of paid-up shares to Tendor 8 nominees 84. Agrc'inoiit to iss\u< paid-up shares in satisfaction of dot)t duo by rompany . . • • ■ SB. Aprt'omt' nt by subscriber to momorandum of association to w^U his share and hold in triist . . ■ • 56. Contract to take qualifii-ation in proposed company. Sect. 72 of Act of litOS ... • ■ 66a. Contract with trustee to take (jualification in proposed company 66b. Agreement to take quulification shares by director not appointed by articles but uame 120 4->l 42.5 42H 4;{o 431 432 432 433 434 436 4!i» TABLE OF FORMS. Chaptir VI. -memoranda OF ASSOCIATION (pp. 447—590). Tom 79. 80. 81. 8S. 83. 84. Memorandum of company limit0 per cent, paid . . ''**•'' 224. .Special voting power to holders of founders' shares . 226. Ee.serve capital . ■ • • • 226. Statement of capital and shares where compiiny formed to acquire mining property in France (Stamp duty lessened) PAOB 678 579 379 oS(> . 580 .>80, 581 581, 582 . 5sa . 583 . 584 58K .787 589 58!> CiiAPTEK VII.-UN THE t'OXSTKUCTION OU INTERPRETATION OF MKMORANDl'M ANIJ AUTICLKS OF A.SS0('1AT10N (pp. 691—604). Sect. 8" I CHAPTER VIII.-REGISTRATION OF CcmPANIES-CONTRACTS MORTGAGES -NOTICES, &c. (pp. 606-627) 227. Statutory declaration on registration of company 228. Consent to act as director 229. Consent to act and be named in prospectus as director 230. Consent to name in prospectus merely 231. List of persons consenting to bo directors . 832. Application to registrar when no directors named 232a. Statutoiy declaration before commencing business of Act of 1908 . . • 233. Another where statement in lieu of prospectus is tiled 233a. Return of allotments ... 234. Notice of situation of office 234a. Notice of change of name 236. Notice of increase of capital 236. Copy of special re8olution(8) 236a. Copy of extraordinary resolutions 237. Report to be sulnnitted to statutory meeting. Stect Act of 1908 ... 888. List of memb.is to be submitted to statutory meeting Sect. 65 of Act of 1908 6." of the 005 006 007 607 607 608 608 609 filO 612 612 61» 6i:t 614 614 615 xu TABLE OF FORMS. Form 939. Particulars of mortgages and chargeit 340. ParticulurB of debentures or debenture stock S41. First isttue . . . • 34S. Certificate of registration of debentures . S43. Registration under sub-sect. 3 of sect. 93 of Act 243a. Certificate of registration of trust deed . 244. Memorandum of satisfaction 246. Copy of register of directors or managers . 246. Annual summary and list 247. Kesolution for registration of existing company 248. Application for registration with limited liability 249. Ajipliciition for registration as unlimited company 260. List of persons holding shares, &r. 260a. .Statement of capital, &c. 260b. Stitutory declaration on registration 260c. Resolution for registration with provisions for increawi capital .... 260d. Resolutions for filing of PAQB 61» 619 619 620 620 620 021 621 622 624 624 H-'6 625 626 626 627 627 I Chapteu 1X.-A1{T1CL'':s ok ASiSOiIATION (pp. 629-908). 261. Articles of a company limited by .shares (general form) 262. Whore Table A to apjdy .... 253. Articles of association of a company limited by guarantee without share capital. Council 264. Articles of association of society limited by guarantee without a share capifcil. Committee of management 266. Company limited by guarantee (no share capital) . 266. C^>mpany limited by guanintoe and not having a capital divided into shares. Participation certificates to be iosued to members ..... 267. Articles of association of uii unlimited company not having a capital divided into shares . . • • 268. E'rovision in articles of an unlimited company as to member- ship ...... 269. 260. Power to acquire business 261. Capital divided into cumulative preference shares and ordinary shares (simple form) .... 262. Non -cumulative dividend with no right to participate in surjdus .... 263. Preference and ordinary shares (non-cumulative preference shares) ...... 264. Preferred ordinary shares and deferred ordinary shares 266. Preference shares with further right* 266. Preference dividend c d quarter surplus reducible . 267. Guarantee preference a id ordinary shares. Contingent ter- mination oi pref"ronce .... 268. 289, 370. Clauses providing for appropriution of profits . S23, 271. Percentage of directors, &c. .... 642 78!> 798 801 802 8(H 810 810 811 820 820 821 821 822 822 823 , 824 824 TABLK OF FORMS. Xlll '72! Special form aa to division of part of profits to some members only . • • • 873. Conversion of preference into ordinary shares S73a. Power of holders of certain shares to convert others into preference shares a74. Conversion of preference into ordinary shares and ricf rerm 274a. Provision for securing British control a74b. Shares to bo transferred to company's nominees 376. Management of one comiuiny by another company 276a. Another 276,277. 1 )ebi;nture direct*>rs fl73. Power for trustees of a will of a former owner of the biismess taken over by company to appoint a permanent direct 837 837 838 , 839 840 841 841 842 842 843 843 843 843 CUAPTKR X.-PEIVATE COMPANIES (pp. 900-1016). 306. Agreement by partners to conve-. t their business into a private company (simple form) . ■ • • " 306, 307. Agreement for sale of business . . .956 308. Introductory note to articles ot association . • 960 309, 310. Restriction on issue of shares . . »««). 961 ^1 XIT TABLE OF FORMS. VOTK 311. Clauie in article* aii to d«en . ■ ■ ■ 388. What time directors to give 866. '^"ntinuancc of directorx in offico 887. voting at ilirectors' mi'ctingH 388. (^hainnun ami deputy chaimian . 880. When chairman abgont from mectinff 860, 361. How (i\iostion8 at board meetings decided 388. Another. I'rovision for votes aa per xhareN 368. Provision for ])roxiow . . . • 364. .\l)sence from hoard mi»'titig« .... 868. I'owerw of directors limited . • ■ • 366. Interest on unpaid shares . . . • 867. Italance sheet . . • • • Minutes of first meeting of directors Minutes of second meeting .... Power in will for tnistoes to convert testator's business into a company . . . • • Special clauses whore sanction of Court requisite Originating summons to obtain sanction of Court to conver- sion . . • • • 873, 374. 374a. Forms of originating summons to obtain sanction of Court to conversion . • • KHM, UK)5 378. Affidavit in support of application for sanction of reconstruc- tion ....•• "HW 376. Another affidavit in support of a scheme of conversion . 1008 377. Order . ■ 1"'" 878. Proposal taken into chambers for conversion of business . 1011 379. Order on above originating summons . . • 1012 380. 380a. 381. Orders for the sanction of a conversion . 101'2- -1015 368. 860. 870. 871. 37S. nam ms 99» 993 993 994 994 !K)4 995 99« 997 , 997 . 997 . 997 . 998 . 999 1002 1004 CiiAFrEKXI.-EMl'I-OYES- BENEFITS (pp. 1017- 1046). 382. Employes' shares . . • • • 383. Co-operativo fund . • • • • 384. Provision in articles as to deposits made by employes with a company ..•••• 388. Acquisition of shares by employes out of earnings . 386. Profit sharing scheme . . • • • 887. Agreement by employe for re-transfer of shares 388. Participation certificato, aa if payee were the holder of a specified number of shares . . . • 380. Trust deed constituting superannuation fund 300. Miscellaneoiis clauses in articles as to empioye directors 301. Trust deed constituting pension fund 308. Trust deed constituting guarantee fund {re a banking com- pany) ...••• 383. Bond for faithful service . . . • 1027 1028 1028 1030 1031 1033 1034 103» 1039 1040 1041 1044 XVI TABLE OF F0RM8. VOTB 394. 895. 396. 397. 398. 398a. CilAPTEK XII.— N(»TICKH(pp. 1047-1090). Allotment letter Lt'tter of rofjret AUotnu'iit (by wuy of uflers ut a premium) Kructiciniil cortificuto . Uu(|uost to allot Allotment liv way of offer 399. Ciroulur uifeiing shares (tenders) 400, 401. Applicntion annexed to above 405. Tender for nhures 403. Application for debcutureB 404. Application for debenture Btock . 406. Letter of allotment of debentures 406. Minutes as to bonun shares 407. Allotment litter of Ihhiuw shares pursuant to aboye 408. Fraetionul eertiticatc I's above 400, 410. Instiilmeiit reminder . KHJO, 411. Notice thut certificate is ready . 4ia, 413, 414, 41S. Notice uf call 416. 417. Receipt of call ... 418, 419. Uaukers' receipts 480. Notice under mt. «6 of Act of 1908, avoiding allotment 421. Notice avoiding allotment whore contract induced by mis representation 423. Circular when misrepresentation discovered 428. To Im! used with the above 424. Another, in lieu of reminder 425. Notice with a view to investigation 426. Receipt on deposit of transfer . 427. Notice of pres. uition of transfer 428. Balance ticket 420. Notices where shareholder dead 429a. Other notices where shareholder dead 430. Ijetter to executors 431. liOtter from executors . 432. Notice before fnrfeituro for non-payment of call 433. Notice of ordinary general meeting 434. 438. Notice of extraordinary general meeting 436. Notice of extraordinary general meeting for passing special resolution 437. Notice of meeting to confirm special resolution 438. Notice of ordinary and extraordinary general meetings to be held on same day . 430. Notice of meeting to alter articles 440. Notice of confirmatory meeting 441. Rciiuisition of members for a general meeting 442. 443, 444. Notice of members calling meeting 446, 446, 447, 448. Notice of ilividuud and warrant U)S5 440. -Dividend .notice and warrant PAOB lOAK 1053 1053 1055 1055 1056 1058 1059 1059 lOflO KMil 1061 l(Mi3 10(H 1065 1007 lOtiH 1068 1070 1071 1072 1073 1073 1074 1074 1075 1076 1076 1077 1078 1078 1078 1078 1079 1080 1080 1081 1082 1082 1083 1083 1083 1084 , 1036 1085 TABLE OF FORMS. xni Vdftt 450, 451. Direction l>y shuroholder to pay divi(lcnili< into a bank 458. l)i>bonturo stock intorent 458. Authority to bank to pay diTidontls to a third party 454. Power of attorney to re<>i'ivo dividend!4 4S4a. Notice an to the appointment of a receiver or manaf^'r 465. Conitent to now company naints name of old 456, 457. Advertiaomentu as to liiot certificate . ruam lORS l(W9 t09(> , inm> Chapter XI11.-UE.S0LUT10NS (pp. 1091-1138). 458. Alteration of iirticlofi . • • • • 459. New regulations . • • • • 460. Modification of Table .\. . • • • 460a. Increased capital . . • • ■ 461. Ordinary sharen iit a premium . . • • 462. New shares ut par and Imjiius to l)e paid . 463. Contingent power to directors and advonturt>rs 464. Preference shares. Cumulative 466. Another form. Non-cumulative 466. Another f -rm . . • • • 467. Variaticm ..•••• 468. Preference shares ; power to issue more . 469. Second preference shares . . • • 470. Conversion of preference into ordinary shares 471. Another. {As soon us aggrepite dividends amount to nominal value of preference shares.) . . • • 472. Preference shares ; power to issue further 472a. Authority to directors to convert into preferred and deferrt-d stock ..•■•' 478. Converting ordinary shares into preferred ordinary and creating new ordinary . . . • 474. Capitalisation of profits (bonus and corresponding new shares) . 476. Creation of debentures and special preference shares. Deben- tures offered to members ut discount subject to their subscribing now shares . . . • 476. Conversion of shares into stock . . • • 477. Another ...••• 478. Consolidation of shares . ■ ■ • 470. Division of shares . . ■ " . . . " 480. Subdivision ami reduction. Renumbering and further division into preferred and deterred shares 481. Division of existing shares into classes (Power in memorandum. Preference shares free from restrictions in articles as to transfer^, ...-•• 1102 no;{ 1103 tl(M IKM 1105 1105 110ft 1I0«> 1107 U0» llOS no!» tllO lll(» nil lUl 1112 1112 ni:( 1114 1114 1114 lll.> Ulft p. /. XVUl TABLK OF KOKMS. retm 48fl. Another . • • • ' 483. »'iinvt)r»iQii "f Khiircn into profernil and 633. To apiMiint (•ominittiM' 634. To ai'popt offor li:»J 636. To olTpr 11. ■« 636, 637. To Heal aKri>oniRnt ItlU 638. To call mwtiiig li:):( 689. To pay iuti'rim dividend • iiAi lEK XIV.— CEBXIFK'ATEH pp. 1139-1164) 643. Ordinary sharo cortittcati' • .114:1 644. < 'ertificato of proforenwi «haro» .... 1144 646. 646. Provisional cprtiticatpd whero inHtalment . 1144, 1144 647. CortiBcate of stock • 1H« 648. Certificate of dobcnturo stock . .1146 649. Pertificat*! to boamr, (provihional) debenture ^tock . . 1 146 649a. Form of interest coupon . . " • 1147 550. Provisional certificate— di'bcntui-e stock to rtigicterod holder . 1147 851. Provisional certificate to iKiarur for debentures to boarrr . 1147 558. Certificate in f.ivour of linuidatorK . 1149 653. Fomi of share warrant . -1 1 JO 554. Coup EngUiiJ to purchuKw projierty Power to locttl boiinl in colony (wiilf) • " , <. J Pow.i from the n-cmver un.l mauuKi-r under onler of Lourt for carryinn on the bu-ine.« of the ooiupany ubn^d (de- Ix'nturo holdiTii' uction) . • • " Power from liciuidator nppointinK thr... i«r-..n. to carry on the liUHinotw in Bombay . • • . ' Powor from shun-holder for att..mi.v to appoint pn.xwH at mitttingM • • ■ . ■ pow.r from shun'hoUlor to fill up blank* in proxies N'oturj'H fcrtiticutc of exet-utiou . • 876a. Notiir\'«ccititiiato cf dwluratioii . • Notary-^ statutory .leclaration of oxwution "f l-o'--'- "' attomtn' rxom IIW Uri» 1170 1172 1174 1176 1176 117ft 1177 1177 Chapter XVI. HAXKINO AND A1.VAN( K sFCUUITll-^s (pp. 1179-1363). 678. ABre..n,t.nt tor deponit subj.ct to bank".- u^ual cluu^e^ (>«t out) [applicable to land] . • • ' 679. Memorandum in shape of Ittttr . . " ,. vi . 680. Agreement for deposit similar t.. I'onn 57H. but applicable to rtgistcred Hharea, Btocks, debentures. &o. 681. Affidavit for distringas 682. Distringux uotice annexed to atlidavit 683. Notice iw to addrOHs . • • • " 683a. Withdrawal notiii' • ' 884. Proposal for dep 123* 123S 1236 1239- i TABtK or roKMS. XXI ttm »98. 699. 600. eoi. eoa. 003. eo4. «0A. MortKi»K« of dccuritip* for X>r,%> . fiitur* advancr- l)..benturoii to n-uiiitP ■' : by xurcty . . • • • I^jtter on uIkjvi- oonilitiiiim . • • • l)w(l of inili«ny to bank Uooolutiuii approving of propoowl det-tl of indi-mnity 1241 1244 1244 124t 12A0 12.M> IJ51 li.V1 600. 607. 608. 600. 610. 611. 6ia. 614. 615. 616. 618. 619. 620 621. 633. 623. 634. 62S. 626. 627. 627a 628. 620. 630. 631. 633. 633. 634. 63S. 636. 637. 638. .'lUPTKK XVll.- WKTITIOXHd)].. 1366-18381. I'otitioii for 1 oinpiiny'.- niiuclliit'ou of lupital lost or -nropr"- wnti'd ...••• Di»iR'ni«ttion ord '?i!<;iiit^ '.apit'.' . • .-.in ,i(ii' I under .Vet of ,i!i<>i:tedl ■I.I-, A. Affidavit by socr. 0:der confinnini Advertisement ol KeasonH for iwi. Petition to con'. ' i i [where creditt • ■• Sunimoiih for diret Order for inijuiry an • , Heduction of capital. ' • tion, list of creditors, is.. Advertisement of petition Sp«K-ial notice Affidavit where no creditors- Affidavit verifying Unt of creditors Notice to creditors Hunimons for order to serve by advortiHoinent Advertisement as to list of creditors Notice where no crinlitors Af,.drvit of it-sult Notice to prove Affidavit proving debt . IHtiT lebtrt, notice of presentn- V2m vi'.a 1271 1272 1273 1272 1273 1274 1275 1277 1277 I'.'SO 12W0 I2M1 12«1 1-283 12H-J 12»N I2!M) 12WI 1290 1291 1291 1292 1292 r.'92 1292 1292 1293 1294 1294 1294 zxu TABLE OF FOKMS. Wtim fAuE 689. MusUts certificate ..... 1296 640. Certificate whove no creditoi'M .... I'Z'M 641. Note that loitificuto has liocomo bindiu}; . . . 1296 648. Advertisoiui'iit of day fixed for heariug . . . 1296 643. Notice of intention to aj>])ear and opjiose . . . 1297 644. Order tonfirmiug leductiou .... 1297 645. Order where uHsots dLstributeil — payment inti> bank foi' secu- rity of nou-eonsenting creditors . . . 12'.>T 646. Another lodgment in court where creditor.s do not uonseut . l;«K) 647. Rediution of capital by cuncfllation (if paid-up sliaros and substitution of debnuturev for same . 13(iO 647a. Redeeming' ti>undei>' shares .... l.'fOl 647b. Order eonfirminfr reduction (A'< "/'»/.-, IJmlil. . . VMi 648. .Vdvertisement of order, cScc. . l:Slt6 648a. Article providing for issue of surjilus certilicatos on reduction of capital ..... l:t06. l.JdT 649. Order on abandonment of procoe 663a. Advertisement of order made on petition . 1328 663b. Certilicat« of registration .... 1328 664. Petition to confirm transfer of life assurance business . 1332 666. Petition for restoration to register under sect. 242 of Act . 1335 687. Order on petition of restoration .... 1337 ■H" tmmmmmtuti Mmjumaum wm TABLK OK FORMS. xxni (-"iiAi-TKK XVIII - WlilTS OV SUMMONS (pj,. 1339—1364; Form 668. Common form of writ ..... 689. Spocial for call ..... 670. Coiii|iatiy'.>i claim f.ir cull- and iiitei(>>t 671. Claims whore whaics forfpitcil .... 672. ( 'laim for call • • . . . 673. Notion by advortiHomcnt to dofondant 874. Claim for recovery of deposit wlicri' appliintion for >«harcs withdrawn 1 .for" allotment . . . . 678. liOscis.sion of contract to take shares 676. RcHcisfsion and damajreH (fraud alle);cd 677. Damapcs for fraud • • . . . 678. Compensation under the Directors' Inability Act, l."S!t(l 679. Damafjes under sect. (SI of the Act 680. Specific performance of af;rt>ement to allot shares . 680.1. liescission of contract for salo of mine to company. 681. Uribe to directors 682. Promoter's sectret profit • . . . 683. Debenture foreclosur'' ■ . . . . 684. Ultra cir'.t agreement ■ . . . . 684a. Action against personal rejaescutative of deciased .shareholiler who has transferred jiroperty to avoid jiaymc'it of calK 685. Debenture trust deed . 686. I'lfni n'na resolution • . . . . 687. Cltni rirr!* business .... 888. Dividend iji prejudice of preference shui-es 689. J>ividend out of capital • . . . 690. Eecovery of dividends improperly paid 691. To enforce residutiou of company 692. E.Kclusion of director ..... 693. To restrain (/(■/irr^. directors from actiu},' . 694. Tnterroffatories ..... i.'ni) 13:19 1343 i:i»3 1343 i:u) l.HJ 1345 i:i43 I34!» 13,)(> 1.150 135» 13.)1 1352 1352 1352 13.-)2 13.)3 1354 13.54 1354 1355 1355 13.)(i 1356 1357 1357 13)14 Chaitek XIX. -1'U;ADINOS(pp. 1366—1386). 698. Action for calls. Htutemeiit of claim 696. Defence to action for calls 697. Defence to action for calls. Sinjcially indorned writ 698. Another . . 699. Misstatements in prospectus. Claim to rescind contract take shares .... 700. Defence to action for rescission . 701. Summons for further particulars 708. Action for rescission .... 708. Another, framed under sect. 10 of the Companies Act, IWMI 704. Defence to 703 .... 706. Sect. 84 of Act to 13ti5 1367 1.368 I.'ITO 1372 1373 137* 1375 1.377 1378 137(» XXIV TABLE OK FORMS. Tom 706. 707. 708. 709. 710. 7H. Action under Hwt. :W of the Companie.- Av Directors' Lin>..lity Act, 1H90 Dofonce to the n' jve . Action to recover bribe f»iven to directors . Defence to T()8 . Ottra rirra contract. Injunction Defence to 710 1867, and under 712. Action for iiltrn nrm p\irchu.-c of shares PAGB 1378 1381 1383 1383 1384 1385 13Nd »;HAPrERXX.-JUDGMENT.S AXD ORDERS (pp. 1387- 1426). . 1392 713. Usual ' 'Tin- to rectify 714. Koticc of motion to rectify register . ■ • '392 716. Order rectifying register of members . . • 1393 716. Rectification where invalid forfeiture . . • 1393 717. Motion to be placed in non- witness list . . • 1394 718. Whe'-e contract not filed under sect. L'o of Act of 1«67 . 1394 710. Another . . ■ .1395 720. Order rescinding contract to punhase shares from compiiny . 1395 781. Another . . • • 139B 722. Test action order • • . 1 397 723. Judgment sotting aside sale of concession and ordering repay- ment ...... 1398 724. font-act for sale of mine set aside . • 1399 786. Setting aside < )ntract for sale and conveyance where liqui- dator sold to company in which he was largely interested . 1400 726. Director ordered ;. J pay value of shares . . . 1401 727. Order for directors to pay over moneys to company . . 1401 728. Directors ordered to make good broach of trust . . 1402 720. Another .1403 730. Order against promoters to refund illegal profit . . 1403 731. Itestr.ilning threatened forfeitures . . 1404 732. Injunction restraining forfeiture of shares . . 1404 733. Judgment granting periK'tual injunction against forfcitui-e . 1405 734. Injunction to restrain exclusion of director . . 1406 736. Order restraining directors from holding meeting at improper period ...... 1406 Restraining directors from improperly rejecting votes . 1407 Restf . ^ confirmation of irregular resolution . . 1407 ( )ri? . I- on appeal from restriiiuing order. Costs only to bo paid 1407 11 736. 787. 738. 730. Amalgamation declared ultra rirts and restrained . . 1407 740. Sale of assets declai-ed "/»« and restrained . . 1408 741. Order restraining issue of preference shares . . 1408 748. Rights of preference stockliolders dcolartid and infringements restrained ..... 1409 748. Declaration as to rights of founders" shares . . 1409 744. Payment of dividend out of capital restrained . . 1410 748. Payment of dividends out of capitJil . .1410 M TABLt: OF FOKM>4. XXV Fonn 746. Injunction refused . . . . . 747. Ordur resti-aining cumpauy from purchuoing ita own !«hareH . 748. Order restraining presontatiuu of winding-up petitionA 749. Order restraining bankruptcy prococdiii,^ agtiiust company in France ...... 760. Injunction against infringement of patent 781. Order restraining use of name . . . . 782. Perjietual injunction against running omnibus 783. Another ...... 764. Perpetual injunction. Infriiigerai-nt of trade iiiark, sale of goods, imblishiiig illustrations 784a. Injunction — trade .secret .... 766. Injunction against telephonic trespass and obstruction 766. Injunction against publishing libel on bank 767. Injunction against breach of covenant giving option 788. Interim order restraining company from enforcing regulation as to transfer of bankrupt's shares 789. Order for plaintiff company to give security 760. Order for plaintiff company to furnish security for costs 761. .Vnother, more modern .... 762. Anothi r. Fund to be paid into a bank 763. Order dismissing ..... 764. Order of foreclosure of ordinary mortgage 766. Appointment of receiver and manager of theatre 766. Liberty to add word " limiton of mortgage or charge ...... 769. Order extending time ..... 770. Extension of time under sect. 1,> of .-Vet of l9 1417 1417 1417 1418 1418 1419 1419 1420 1424 1426 1426 CiiAPTEK XXI.— APPEALti TO HOUSE OF LORDS (pp. 1427—1429). 770a. Form of petition and case 1427 IHAPTER XXII.— HEt'ONSTUlJCTION (pii. 1431—1480). 77\. Agreement with a v'ew to reconstruction . '< ^"J. Special provision as to distribution of shares 7V3. Power to rescind subject to a consideration 774. Notice and resolutions with a view to reconstruction 776. Circidar ..... 776. Scheme ..... 777. Another ..... 778. Supplemental agreement — specifying shares 14o9 1466 1463 1463 1467 1467 1468 1469 XXVI TAIF KORMS. Form 779. Liquidators' dimction to allot 780. Circular .... 781. Notice of allotment 788. Reply to last 7?3. Fractional certificate . 7c.'i. Bequest for allotment of shares in exchange for certificates 786. Request for allotment to »i>ecified periions 786. Letter of allotment 787. Resolution for sale of uiulei'takin^ 788. Notice of dissent pursuant to sprt, Kil 780. Reconstruction on 8p<'ci:il lines . 700. Affreement for exchange of shares 701. Circular as to distribution in specie 708. Fonn of request for allotment fractional PAOB 1469 1470 1471 1472 1472 1472 147» 147a 1474 1474 M74 M7« 147N 14S0 Chapter XXlll. - AMALOAMATKJN (pp. 1481-1401). AERANQEMENT^^ AND COMPROMI.'=iES (pp. 1408—1680). 703. Agreement with a view to amalgamation . . 148t* 704. Resolution for amalgamation .... 148» 706. Resolution for the amalgamation of two companies with a thii-d ...... 1491 706. Resolution for amalgamatiou to be effected by the foimation of a new company ..... 1491 707. Summons for meetings .... 1505 708. Scheme of arrangement .... ISOo 700. Another . . .1506 800. Another . .1507 801. Order for meetings . .1508 808. Another . . .1509 803. Notice of meetings . .1510 804. Resolution ...... 1511 806. Form of proxy . 1511 806. Report of chairman .... 1512 807. Petition (skeleton) .... 1513 808 -810. Orders confirming scheme . 1514— lolK APPENDIX. ( xxvii ) TABLE OF CASES. A. A— A^g PAUK A. Company, i,lNit4) 2 t'h. ;J4}« .... -1411 A 1 UiHcuit Co.. W. N. (l)Sit9) llj - - - - . 724 Aaron's Reels, Ltd. c. Twiss. (1S96) A. t". 273, 2N4; «o I,. J. l>. 0. o4 : 74 I.. T. 704 - 143, 144, 174, 177, UH. 1S8, 19«, 19H, 20a, 204, 212, 224, 240, 241, «til, l;JH(i A. 1!., Ji^. W, N. (1899) 2;« - - - - - 949 Abbotsford Hotel -•. Kingham, 102 I,. T. 108 (C. A.) - UN, (i»J6, 1408 Abbott V. Middleton (1858). 7 H. I,. ('. 8S - - . :,9h, 1158 Abbott .". Stratten, -i Jo. & Ijit. 013 - - - - 11,58 Abel Morrcll. Ltd. -•. T. ItcMsin * Co., 19 U. }'. C. dB7 - - 4.54 Aberaman Ironworks Co. 1; Wirkonx, 4 Oh. 1(H • 20 I, T 89- 17 W. P. 211 - - - - - . ■ . 14(M» Abordoen Hail. Co. ,-, ISlaikic. 1 Macq. 401 ; 23 I,. T. 315 ; 2 Vai. K. 1281 l;j8. Abraham & Sons, (19021 1 Cli. fiO.') : 71 I,. .1. Ch. 307 • S6 L.T. 290- 50 W. H. 284 - - Abrath <•. O. K. Eail. Co., U A. C. 247 ; 32 W. K. .lO; Accidental In*. Co. r. Va.vU, 15 T,. T. 182 - Acland >: t^cwis. 1 K. & O. 334 ; 30 f,. C. P. 29 ; 9 C. 1!. N. S. 32 - Actiessolnkabt Damskl Hercules r. Orand Trunk Pacific Rail. Co. 732 617. 018, 1423 i-> I,. T. 63 - .38 - 656 28 28 T. L. H. 28 ; 105 L. T. 695 Adair v. Young, 12 C. I>. 13 : 41 1,. T. 361 ; 28 \V. H. 85 - Adams c. G. W. Rail. Co., 6 H, & N. 404 ; 4 I;. & 8. 326 - Adams r. Newbigging, 13 Ann. Ca«. 308 ; 57 1.. J. Ch. 1066: L. T. 267 ; 37 W. B. 97 Adamson's Case. 18 Eq. 670; 44 L. J. Ch. 125; 22 \V. B. 820 - Addie >:. The Western f. mk of Scotland. 1 H. L. Sc. 143, 167 Addinell's Case, 1 Eti. 225; .35 L. .1. I'h. 75: 13 L. T. 436 • W. R. 72 •- Addison v. Nos.s. 9 T. I.. It. 607 - - - - Addlestonc linoleum Co., /le, 37 C. D. 191 ; 36 W. B. 57 - Aerators, Ltd. --.Toilit, (1902)2 Ch. 319; 71 L. J. Ch. 727 ; 86 L. T. 631 ; .W W. R. 584 451, 4,i2 African Association >: Allen, (1910) 1 K. H. .'i!"; ; 102 I.. T. 129- 79 L. J. K. H. 259 - - . . . . - 441 Agar !'. Atheneeum Societv, 3 C. It. N. H. 725 : 27 L. J. C. P 95 • 4Jiir.N.S. 211 ■ - - - . . ■ 79,761 Agoncy fAnd and Fiiianee Co. t.f Australia, 20 T. L. R. 41 - (j58 Agge 1: Nicholson, 1 H. & N. 165 : 25 L. J. Ex. 348 - - :i.34 86, 1341 - .-wi - 8ft 59 - 1400 732, 733 - 41 14 - .50 - 364 60, 478 »-« XXVlll TABLE OF CA8E8, y :! I ▲grr— Aim Moc Agra and Ma.stennan'« Hank, Rr, Er jmrtf Asiatic Hanking Ciirporu- tion. 12 Va\. ^m■. 2 Oh 397 ; 30 I.. .1. (Ti. 222 ; IH L. T. 162; 15 W. P.. 414:^8 L. T. 114 - . - - -1452 Airey, Re, Airey ". StnpLton, (1H97) 1 Ch. \M\ 6»! T,. J. Ch. 152: 76 Ti. T. 151 ; 45 W. E. 280 - - - - -1159 Ajello ('. W„..sley, (1898) 1 Ch. 274 ; 77 I-. T. 783 ; 46 W. H. 245 - 445 Alabama New Orleans Co.. (1891) 1 Ch. 24.i - 1493, 1496, 1497, 1500, 15(11, 1502 Albion Artsuranco Society. .Sw Winston's Case. Albert I li - _ . . l'J(i6, 12(i»i Amalgunmted Hyndicatos, Jir, (1NH7) 'i Ch. 600 ; (Itt L. J. Ch. 7S.t ; 77 L. T. 431, 432 ; 4 Mansou, 30« - - 470, 600. (i02 Amborgate l{ail. Co. v. Noroliffo, 6 Kx. 629 ; 20 L. J. Ex. 234 - V,o!i Ambrotw Lako Tin Co., 14 C. D. 3it0; 2S \V. F.. 7«3 : 42 1-. T. «(M ; 49 L. .r. Ch. 457 .Vuieriniu Puxtoral Co., 62 L. T. 625 American Surety Co. m. WrijfhtHon. 27 T. L. R. 01 Ameritiin Thread Co. <•. Joyce. 2H T. L. R. 233 Amor V. Tesson, 9 A. & K. 34N Amos r. Chiidwick. 4 C. I). 8(i9 Anderwm's Case, 7 C. T). 73. 102: 26 W. R. 442: L. J. Ch. 273 - - - . Anderson'H (^ase, 17 C. D. 373 Anderson c. Auder8 W. K. 212 (C. A.I - - 142, 71.'>. 720, 721, 722 Anliujf f. l-«)max(lHM), 24 I.. J. Ex. SO - - - 442 Argus l.ifo Ass. Co., 39 C. U. 671 ; r,H I,. .1. Cli. Ititi: M I.. T. i!H!t; .•17 W. K. 215 - - - - 7H, .511, •!;»i. r,;i9, (iio, i;k9 Argylp, &c. Co., /?»■. 54 I,. T. 2."J7 - - - - 17. 484 Arizoim CoppiT Co. -•. Smil.s, '29 I,. R. Sc. l:i4 - - - lOO Arkwri-ht r. Nowlxaa, 17 C. D. 1)22; 2N W. H. V.Ml; 29 W. R. 153; 44 r.. T. 393 • .W T.. .1. Ch. 372 - 172, 189, 190, ^203, '204. 208, 215, 228 Annitaffi- -■. Oani.itt, /{< Armitugo, (1893) 3 Ch. 337; «i3 1.. J. Ch. 110; fiO 1.. T. 019; 7 U. 2iM) - - - - 754 Annitape «•. Moore, (IPOO) 2 tl. I!. 303 . - - - Army mid Navy Co-operative Society r. Aniiy, Navy, and Civil Service Co-operative Society of South Africa, 19 R. 1'. C. 575 - .\nny. &c. Soc. r. Craig, N T. L. 11. 227 - - - 227 Amisou ,: .Smith, 40 C. I>. 50" ; 41 C. I). 348, :i72 ; 01 L. T. 03 ; 37 \V. R. 739 ; 1 .Meg. 3NS - iS9, 190, 192, 193, 195, 203, •2.'i7 - Att.-O.-ii. I-. ("orporiition nf I*i«Mtor, (lltlo' 2 Cli. .I")!! Att.-O.ii. ,: Duy. 2 Atk. 212 - '. . . Att.-Gen. /•. Oii» Lijj-ht untl Coko Co., 1,> T. I.. 1!. .'in Aft.-(ieu. /■. O. E. Rail, (^i., 11 C. I). U9; :, .\pi.. (',.«. K.J; 27 W. H 73!»: 2K W. 1{. 7«9; 10 I,. T. 2»i5 : 42 I.. T. NIO; 4K I,. J. Ch. 42i»: 49 I,. J. Ch. .Ho - - - 41(0. 461, 4«7. 471, K34 Att.-Oon. i: (i. X. Rail. Co., I Dr. & Sm. 21:t .Vft.-fJon. c. Cii'orfto (Smith. I,til.. (IDOK) 2 Ch. 5:14 - .\tt.-(!cii r. IlanwiU I'. I). C,, (llioil) 2 Ch. 377 - .Vtt.-(i<>ii. r. Jameson. (l!t(H) 2 Ir. R.p. K. I!. I>. ti44 - 927 Att.-Oon. r. LnckwiMxI. 9 M. & \V. :i7N .... Att.-Oon. '•. Manchistoi- Corporation. (IIMM)"! I Ch. «4:j : J4 \V 1! a07 ; 22 T. I.. 1{. 201 ■-'-..'. Att.-Oi'n. '•. Mayor of Ilnvon, IOC, 1 ». ;;()4 ... Att.-(h'n. r. Now York Urowcrifs Co.. 'IH'.IH\ I H. U. ;juj • 07 I, ,| U. M. Mi; 7N L. T. 01 ; 40 W. !{. 19;! -' - '- 40. (J7s Att.-Oon. ?•. N. K. Rail. Co., (19(Mn I Ch. 07 j • !l,-i L T .»1'>- •>■> T. L. R. 09,-) - - . . . '. ■■ " .Vtt.-(ion. r. North Metropolitan Tnimwavs Co., i'lMn2) :( Cli 7o ■ 01 I,. .1. Ch. 09:J: 72 I.. T. .140- "- '- . 1 Att.-Oon, «■. Ray, 9 1 'h. App. 402, n. - - . . Att.-Oeu. f. Ronont'« Canal and Dork Co.. (1904) 1 K. R. ''OH- 73 L. J. K. n. oO ; 52 W. R. 211 - - - . ' . Att.-Oen. c. Swansea Corporation, (189S) 1 Ch. d.» Fubrik A. C. 200 Wai{l«>hol.-, A'x /«ir/f , 1 Rose, 43'J - - ' ^' .„, I,"** B..KnalU..^CaHton. « C. ... .7, ; .« W. H- «3 = ,3^ VJ. ^<.H. =^47^^^^ onappottl (Dec.. 1901). IH T. L. R. 161 : (19»«) 1 CL .(> ;j2'i, ;j8i •>5»a B. jH4; 37 L .J. Ch. HI; 77 I.. T. 323 147 323, 290, J. - «"4 - 0A5 335. ;J36 46 49, 73. 200 - 442 J. ("h. ..ahi.i uis I'lanbitioii^ -•. Griffin, 14 T. I,. R. 139 B'lhitt iind Sail Francixco Rail. Co., li. R. 3 d U. B. 176 ; 1« 1- T. 467 : 16 W. R. S62 Bailey -•. Birkenhead Co.. 12 Beay. 433 : 19 I.. J. Ch. 377 Bailey v. Hweoting. 9 C. B. N. S. B43 Baillio's Cast-. (18!W) 1 Ch. UO ; (17 I- W. R. 1N7 : 4 Mans. 393 Baillio r. Koll, 4 lling. N. C. ti3« - - - " Bain-bridge ... Sn.ith, 4. C. D. .H2 ; 60 U T. 879^37 ^^^■^^^.^^. ^^ Raines ,•. Geary. 35 C. D. 154 ; 36 I. J. Ch. 935 ; 56 L. T. 567 : 36 W. B. 98 : 51 J. P. 628 - - - BaineH v. Swaiuscu, 4 B. * S. 270 - Baird'8 Case, (1899) 2 Ch. 593 ; 68 L W. R. 695 ; 5 Ch. 725 - Baker v. Iledgecock, 39 C. I). 520 - B»ker i: I'laskit, 5 C. B. 262 Balaghat Gold Mining Co., (19()1) 2 70 L. J. K. B. 866 ; 85 L. T. 8 ; 49 W. R. <.25 (t. A.) Balchin .'. Ebury (Lord). 22 L. T. R. 60 - 357 - 1208, 1209 J. Ch. 521; SOL. T. 870; 47 - 58, 495, 520, 678. 913, 919 - 358 - 122 K. B. 665; 17 T. L. R. 660; 1, 688, 771 - 1022 124B 749 669 Balfour V. Crace, (1 ")'l Ch. 733 ; 86 L. T. 144 ; 71 L. J. Ch. .358 - Balgoolie Distillery Co., 17 Irish L. R. Kq. 263 Balkis Co.. W. N. (1888) 3 ; 38 L. T. 300 ; 36 W. R. 392 - Balkis (New) Kersteling Randt Gold Mining Co., (1904) A. C 165 ; 73 L J. K. B. 3> I ; 90 L. T ^94 ; o2 W. R. 561 (U. L., L.) - Bangor, &c. Co., Be, 20 Eq. 5P .2 L. T. 389 ; 23 W. R. 785 ^^ - ^ ^^ Bank of Airica v. Salisbury Gold Mining Co., (1892) A. C. 281 ; 61 L. J. 1'. C. 34 ; 66 L. T. 237 ; 41 W. R. 47 - Bank of Bengal r. Macleod, 7 Moo. P. C 35, 74 - Hank of England -. Cutler, (1907) 1 K. U. nm-.{^'^»J ^?t"'i^"r 96 L. T. 636; 98 L. T. 336; 23 T. L. R. 3.4; 24 T. L. K. 518 ----- ■ " ' Bank of England r. Vagliano, (18911 A. C. 144 ; 60 1,. J. U- H. 145; 64 L. T. 353; 39 W. R. 657 - - - " ^*^ Bank of Hindustan v. Alison, U R. 6 C. P. 73 ; 19 W. R '.05 ; 23 L. T. 616; 40 L. J. C. P. I Bank of Ireland c. Evans' Trustees, 5 H. \j. C. 389 Bank of London -•. Tyrrell, 10 li. L. C. 26 ; 31 L. J. Ch. 369 ; 8 Jur. N. S. 849 663 578. 664 1158 1159 . 1204 28 83 1.">T TABLE OF CASES. ZXXIU -Bftr Hunk of Mexico i'. Apothnriw, (>4 I,. T. 41H Blink of Now «<.iith Walo-. -. (JouUKiiirn Valley Co.. (1902) A. ('. M3-, 71 I-. J. I'. ('. IIJ; H7 I,. T. HH; HI W. K. ;«i7 (P. ('.) - lUink of (tuotlunil >: Morriiion (1911), S. ( '. 3!t;( (Vt. of .'^om. ) Hunk of South AiiHtralia, /Ir, (\H\tr,) 1 Ch. .i7s ; m I,. J. «'h. aU7 • 72 l~ T. •.•7.1; -IJI W. R. ;i.i!t; U' 11. IWl - . '. Hank of Hjriu. /(>, (19(M() •> Ch. 21 i : Ki I^ T. Iti... 547 ; i'J W. R. urn -.-..... PjIOE I19:i IIWI 1439 Hank of Tiiikoy r. Ottoman Co., 2 Ki|. Mi'.t : 14 W. U. sl!» ; 1 1 1,. T. .54 j. SS4 - . . . - '_ .iio r 714 34 C. 1». :i!t, 74(« •.'H7 ; .'1.5 W. 11. - HIS. N7!». 111!». 1238 R. H44; 41 I,. T. IWO: .W • 141 719. 738 14S7 11H4 733 j(»7 603 140 759 759 5S .lO, 545, SH4 Hannatvno r. Pirwt Spanish CaWo Co 125:35 I,. T. 71«; 5tl I.. .1. Ch. 1(>7 Hanner i'. H.-rriilK«, IN C. I>. 251 ; 2!l W I,. .1. Ch. (l.M» - Harbcr'.-! Cbmo, 5 C. D. (Xi.l ; 2ti W. It. 3 Harin);-(}(>ultl /•. Shjirpin^ton C,iniliin MuiiH. 171 B. PAdl •2 Ex. 239 ;i(i, 4U, 41 - 7il lltttanl -•. lluwe., 'i K. & H. 2n7 ; a 11. 4 It. '^77 ; W 1-. J. U. »• 44:« : 17Jur. 11J4 ilatimun r. Mid-WuloM Kuil. C... I- U. 1 f. !'• ^90: " W. U. «7-.'; ;r. I,. J. ('. 1'. -'"J ; la Jur- N- ^- •*•' - ■ ' ' Httth« CuM). N !■. 1). ;i:t4 ; it} W. U. 441 ; M U. T. ;J«7 : 47 1.. J. Vh. 001 - - - - •'■'• *^^- ••*^'> ■•*'''• ■'"^' "*"• Uiith r. Stuii.Uia UhhI Co., (lltll) 1 til. tils Buty «•. KcKwkk, H3 L. T. H ll.w.lei. ,■. l.-.ii,l.m. Kainburuh and Olan^'ow ('..„ (1N!>J) 2 Q. B. 534 - Bum. r . . I• 210 : H Si-. N. IJ. 1019 Buxter f. HoUUworth, (1899) 1 U. 11. 266 ; ON I,. J. Q. li 1''4 ; 47 W. H. 17!t (C. A.) Baxter , . Uiidon iind C'oimty I'rintii.s Work^ (1H99) 1 Q. 1«. !MI1 - BuyU-y-VVorthiugton and Coht-n'H Contract, (11K)9) 1 Ch. 048 ; W. N. (liH«t)68 ...---- Boar.l <■. I.wulon GcM.oral Omiiibti. Co.. (IIHK)) 2 (i. B. -ViO; 09 I,. J. a. H. H9J ; s;) I,. T. ;102 ; 48 W. U. fiSS (C. A.) - .17, 41 Ik^utti... r. I...r.i Kbury, 7 ih. 777 ; 20 W. U. 994 ; 27 K. T. U-JS; 41 1, J, Ch. K(I4 - Itramort (Uuke of) f. Neidd. 12 CI. & Fiii. 24.S Bichuanaluud Exploration Co. r. J^>udon Trading Hank, (1898) 2 U. B. 058 ; 07 L. J. Q. B. 986; 79 1.. T. 270 B«M;kett c. Addyman (1882), 9 «. B. D. 783 Beckct I'. Towt^r Bridge AsKCsstueut Committee, (1891) 1 Q. B. 638 ------ " Bc( kford i: Wade, 17 Ve». 9" - - - " " Beckwith, AV ,,artf, (1898) 1 Ch. 324 ; 46 W. R. 376; 07 f;. J. Ch. 104 ; 78 L. T. 135 ; 3 Mans. 108 - - 441, 630, 724, 739 Beer v. I/)ndon and Paris Hotel Co., 2(t E.]. 412 ; 32 L. T. 713 - 334 Beenton I'noumutic Tjro Co.. 14 T. L. U. 378; W. N. (1898) 34 - 1442 Belfast Banking Co., 1 Ir. C. h. R. 693 - - - - 1247 elhaveu'n (Urd) Case, 3 D. J. & 8. 41 - - - - "•!« Bell Itrothers, He, 03 L. T. 245 ; 7 T. I.. R. 689 (Chitty, J ) - 071, 672 bell r. National Provincial Bank of England, (1904) 1 K. B. 149 ; 73 L. J. K. B. 142; 90 L. T. 2; 52 W. R. 106; 20 T. L. R. 97 (C. A.) - 103 Bellairs v. Tucker, 13 Q. B. D. 562 - - - 187, 192, 195, 203 B.;llamy v. Brickenden, 2 J. & U. 137 - - - 1^16, 1217 Bellerby v. Rowland and Marwood'» Steamship Co., (1902) 2 Ch. 14 (C A.); (1901) 2 Oh. 265; 17 T. L. R. 510; 70 L. J. Ch. 016; 84 L. T. 051 - - - 515, 749, 750, 1389, 1390, 1411 Bellhou«e i'. Mellor. 28 L. J. Ex. 141 - - - - 718 Beuett r. Wyndham. 4 Do O. E. & J. 259 - - - 787,921 Bennett v. Brumfit, L. R. 3 C. P. 28; 10 W. R. 131 ; 17 L. T. 218; 37 L. .1. 0. P. 35 ; 1 H. & P. 407 - - - 781.1047 Bennett r. Cooper, 9 Beav. 252 H"^ Bennett Bros., Ltd. o. I^wis, 48 8. J. 14 - - "l". "28. 736 Bennett-Clarke .'. White. (1899) 1 Ch. 316; 68 U J. Ch. 104; 47 W. R. 406 **'* 149 510 751 712 289 42 27 1362 442 ;t54 187 293 1243 1246 1248 141 u.. TABLE OF CA8E8. XXXV B«n— Bia rMa Ik-mi.-tt r. I/.rd Bury. S C. P. I», :J39; Pun. Hi. Pr. 7th od. IfllO; S.ton, fith fd. N:t3 ...... i:(97 HfMu-tt, ffr, MitHonic and Oenoral Ijfn Afwumnrp To. c Shiirpp, (IHBJ) 1 Ch. I.'>4; «I I,. J. Ch. l».l; 8,^ I,. T. SIKI; III \V. |{. lill (P. A.) Wi, H7I UrniiPtt c. StoiiP. il(Mt.1) 1 Ch. .-lOtt; 72 I,. .T. fTl. '.'10; NM I.. T. :!.') : .'; i ch. '."Jii ll.'rithiim Mills S|iiiiiuiiK (',,., /,V, 11 C, O. 90(); UN W. R. 20; M .•).'>4 J,. T. 10; 18 I., .r. {'h. (171 H'litiiick i: Fi'iiM, 12 App. Cuh. (i.VJ t«72, <179 1.17, 13H lt.iitiiick .-. I/.u.loii .loiiit Stock Honk, (1893) 2 Ch. 120; 02 I,. .I,('h. :i.>H; «M I,. T. ;nj; 42 W. H. NO; 3 K. 120 lltntley r. Uliick, 1» T. I,. 1{. ,-|H0 - 11N7 ins. li»3 ll-iitloy (Heni'j) .\: (\)., «!» I,. T. 204 - - - - KM H; s;i I,. T. (»;:>: m \V. li. itn . - . . pjiit HiTtit' i: Wiiltlmmstow Ovni*oi>i. OS .1, 1>. ^^.•, ; 2 I.. O. R. 1 17S - I((j» ll.'th.'ll -■. Tri'Mih Tiitwl.'si Co., (IWMl) 1 Ch. 40S ; 09 I,. .1. Ch. 213; S2 1.. T. 247; 4S W. R. 310 (C. A.) - - 693, (».-.. 849 lU'tU ,: (iibbinM, 2 A. & K. .-17 ; 4 N. & M. 04 - . - 226 licttx, r-td. '■. Macnaghtou. (1910) 1 Ch. 430; 2D T. I.. R. o.52 - 692, 7(K», 849, 1097, 1449 Rfctt« 11. Wilmot, I,. R. 6 Ch. 239 . . - - - 381 li, (iythers, I,iniit«d, (1893) 1 Ch. 003; 62 L. .1. Ch. 349; 68 I-. T. .342; 41 W. 1!. 363; 3 R. 377 - - - 699, 1098 liiggiTstiiff i: Rowatt's Wharf, (1896) 2 Ch. 93; tij L. J. Ch. 536; 74 1,. T. 473; 44 W. R. j.{6 . . - 79, 81, 686, 710, 739 l'.ij.'g'« Case, 1 K(|. 309; 14 W. U. 244 ; 13 L. T. 627 - . O.V) Hinnt'.v i-. luce Hall Coal Co., 35 li. J. Ch. 363; 14 li. T. 392 - 651, 754, 871 Hirch i: Cropper, 14 App. Ca». 545 - - 578, 578, 588, 704, 783, 784, 816, 843, 1439 liiiil i: Hird's Patent Deodori.sing, &c. Co., 9 Ch. 358 ; 30 I,. T. 281 ; 43 I-. J. Ch. 399 1408, 14.39 Rirkbtwk Permanent Building Soi'inty, 28 T. I/. R. 46 - - 1201 Ilirmingham Hanking Co., 36 I.. J. Ch. 150 ... 7S2 Birmingham lirowerios v. Janu -on, W. N. (1898) 15 ; 46 W. R. 375 ; 67 \,. J. Ch. 403 ; 78 L. T. 512 - - - - 359 Bisgood I). Henderson's Tninsvaal Estates Co., (1908) 1 Ch. 743; 98 L. T. 809; 24 T. L. R. 510 (C. A.) .373, 457, 511, 786, 1434, 1445, 1454, 1455, 1457, 1458, 1483 Bidgood r. Nile Valley Co., (1906) 1 Ch. 747; 94 L. T. 304; 51 W. B. 397 Bishop V. Balkis Co 25 Q. U. D. 512; 59 L. J. Q. B. 566; 63 h.T. - 1457 601 ; 39 W. 1*9 ; 2 M( eg. _ J« Bishop V. Smyrna and Cassaba Rail. Co., (1896) 2 Ch. 266 ; 72 L. T. - 676 773 784 XXXVl TABLE OF CASKtJ. Bla— Boo Bliick r. Ilomorshuu., 4 Ex. U. 'H : 48 I,. .». Ex. 79 ; :J9 (.. T. (>71 ; 27 \V. I!. 171 Black ('. Mttlluluf, J Jur. N. S. 1018 ; 7 W. B. 303 ; 33 I,. T. -Hil - 687. 73'i lilutkbuin lluildiuK 8uc-. -■. ( unliffe, llrooks &C(j., 9 App. C'as. 857 ; '>■> Ch. I), til ; 31 M". E. 98; 48 I,. T. 33: J2 1.. .1. Oh. 92: 33 W. E. 309 lilackbuin '. Vif?(>is. 12 Ajip. ('as. ."i31 Hlurkfonl '■. Davix, 4('h. 304 Ulackic .-. Osiiiaston. 28C. 1). 123 - - - - Hlttibiiffaiul Al.iahiims. /^, (1899) 2 Vh. 340 HlaiK-rj; -■. Keuv.-s, (1900) 2 Ch. 17.5: 9.j 1,. T. 412: 54 W. li. 4.-.1 HlakoV Ciisc. 34 I'.raiv. ti39: 13 W. H. 4S() - lllak.- -•. White, 1 Y. & < '. li.xch. (i20 liliikfkv, A'., 9 Morr. li. R. 173 - Itlak.ly Ordnance Co.. /fr, 3('h. 159: 1(! W. H. 5.33; 18 I,. T. 132 68 (i8, 33 Heav. 529a - - - • 48,898 liodipi Co., (1904) 1 Ch. 276; 73 I,. .). Ch. 198 ; N9 L. T. 694 : .•»2 ■\V'. E. 249 ----- 662, 727, 728, 731 Eoden & < o. v. Overseers of Chard, and Oifford, Fox & V<>. r. Same, 7 T. L. E. 431 (July. 1890) ----- 1*'" Uoehm r. Goodall, (1911) 1 Ch. 135 »■»» Helton Partners -•. l^mbert, 41 V. D. 295: .58 I,. .1. Ch. 425: 60 L. T. 687 ; 37 W. E. 434 - - - - 644, 741 Holton I-. Uiukincham, (1891) 1 U- H. 278; 60 I.. .1. Q. 1!. 261 : 64 L. T. 778 ; 39 W. E. 293 (C. A.) - - - -»-■*' lloltou .-. Natal, &c. Co., (1892) 2 Ch. 124 : 61 I.. .1. Ch. 281 : 65 L. T. 786 '^•'■' Holton .•. Salmon, (1891) 2 111. 48; 60 L. .1. Ch. 239 : 64 1.. T. 222 ; ;i9 W. E. 589 ------- !-•*•' ISombav Ituiinah Trading Corporation r. Dorabji Cursetji Shroff, (1905) A. C. 213 (1'. C); 91 L. T. 812; 12 Manson, 169, !>.('.- - - - - - - - ''"^ Homoi".- lioad (No. 9), ll.. (1H06) 1 Ch. 359; 94 L. T. 408 ; 54 W. B. ;„.2 ...---- 112, 1328 liompas i: King, 33 C. D. 279 '-l" llond, /tf. I'aroH r. Att.-Oen.. (1901) 1 Ch. 15 - - 112 Hond r. Harrow Ha-niatite Co., (1902) 1 Ch. .353. 362 - 588. 754. 765, 765, 766, 814, 840, 866, 872, 874, 884, 889, 89,> Honomi r. Hackhouse, 9 U. J-. C. 503 . - - - 221 Itonser r. Cox, 4 Iteav. 379 - - - - - - l^"*** Uonzi r. Stewart, 4 M. & G. 295 . . , - -1212 iUiurtl r. Aliicttii Consolidated, &c. Co^ (lS9b) 1 Ch. 596; 77 L. T. 653 : 46 W. E, 160 71,688,771 ,«! , TABLE OF CASES. XXXVll Boo^Bra paqb fl..(.th r. Xow Afrikander Mininff Co., (1903) 1 Th. 293; 72 L. J. f'h. 12.5; 87 I,. T. .509; .51 W. I!. IPH (O. X.) - 12. H, 280, 28;5. 2S,S, ,511. 048, 1449, 14.50 l$iK)th ' . Wiilkdeii Spinning Co., (1909) 2 K. 1!. ;i(iS - . 1498 liontlc Cold Storiific, W. N. (1901) 54 - - - -142:i ISootlc OvcrsTOiw '■. Ijvi'rpool Waichousinjr Co.. 8.5 I,. T. 1.5; ().5 ■'• !'■ 740 --..-- ]o,s. 109 IJonix Co.. /iV, Fostoi- r. liorax Co., (1901) 1 Ch. :!2ti; 70 I,. .1. <'h. 1li2 ; 8;{ 1,. T. 638 : 49 W. H. 212 (C. A.) - Hi8, .511, .51 1 liiirliuiir.sTrustci's i: Stvol IJros. & Co., (1901) 1 Cli. -.'79; 70 I,. .1. Ch. .51 ; 49 W. 1!. 120 - - (i,51, (179, 949, 902, 9(>9, l'7;i, 1410 ]iovonpli ( 'oiiimcicial mid Uiiildiiij; 8or., (1H9.1) 2 ( 'li. 242 ; 02 I.. .1. Ch. 4.50; 69 I,. T. 9li ; 41 \V. R. .{IJi. .i R. :i.i9 - 407, .51,5, ,5.51. 810 Hosr. ll.Wiam, I,. R. 2 Ex. 72 : 1.5 W. R. 2.59; 1.5 I,. T. 481 : .il! 1.. .1. Kx. 20; 4 II. & C. 642 ----- ;J49 lk)s;iiuiii.t, &c. i: St. .John dtd Rov (1897), 77 I,. T. 207 - 766, .St(4, 889 Hoschook rroprictiiiy (^>. .•. Kiike, (1906^ 1 Ch. 148; 91 I,. T. .•i98 : J4 W. R. ;i.59 - - - -091,720.725,727,741,744 Bo.stoii licip.S(u Co. /•. AnscU. :!9 C. I). .■i:i9; .59 I.. T. ;!45 - '.17, .•i70, 442, 71 ■. 722, 7.12, 7.i;i Boston -■. .ViiM-ll. .(9 c. It. .■i;{9 - - - . i:i.-,2. 1400 Bonch .-. Sproiilc, 12 A])p. Ciis. .185; ;{;i W. It. 621 ; .57 I.. T. .•i4.5 ; .56 I,. .J. Ch. 10;{7 - - . . 4C)_ 7-,4 -(;- -f-g Boiiltor .-. I'oplow. 9 V. li. 493 - - . . . ] (9 Bound ' . Uwremi', (1892) 1 U- R. 226 ; 61 I,. J. M. C. 21 ; 65 I,. T. 844 ; 40 \V. R. 1 : 56 J. 1'. 118 (C. A.) - - - - Kt^l BoviU 1: Endle. (1896) 1 t'h. 648; 65 I,. J. Ch. 512; 44 W. R. 523 -----... i|;,3 Bowater and Sou.h i: Mirror of Life Co., 50 W. R. 381 - - .347 Bowen '•. Dofrios iV Co., (1904) 1 Ch. ;!7 ; 73 I,. J. Ch. 1 : 52 W. R. ^J3 ------ - 618, 1124 Bowfn r. Hall, 6 Q. 1!. P. 339 ; 29 \V. R. .367 ; 44 I,. T. 75 ; 50 I,. .1. Q. M. 305 ----... 144 Bowor '■. Marris, 1 Cr. & Ph. 351 ----- n92 BowcH. /,'., 33 C. I). 586 ---... 1194 Bowes •-. Shand. 2 App. t'as. 468 - - - - .-,95. 596 Bowles ,: Att.-Oen., (1912) 1 Ch. 123; Tinii's, December, 1911 - 104 Bowles -•. Mayer, 19 C. I!. X. .'«. 7(> - - - - l-.)47 Bowy.T .■. I'erey .'or Plantations, (1911) 1 Ch. 4'25 - 127, 130, 134, 148. 152. 178. -I-lo. 231. 3'Jfi, 3(12. 044, 645. 710, 713, 714, 748. 788 Brazilian Siibinarino Telegraph Co.. Limited, /?«'. 63 L. T. 275; 39 W. li. ,-)5 "58 Hreav /•. Roval liritish Nurses' Ass., (1897) 2 Ch. 272: 66 L. J. <'h. .W7 : 7(i I,. T. 7:t5 ; 46 W. I?. 86 ... - 469 Un-tt r. East In.li... &c. C... 2 H. & M. 404; 12 \V. R. .-.!I6: Id I.. T. 1.S7: 3N. R. 68,s - - - - - -HI Hrirk ami Stcno Co.. /!>: W. N. (1878^ 140 : 22 S. .1. 625 - 691, 717. 737, 1098 lirickw(H)d /■. R.'vnoMs, (189K) 1 Q. H. 95; 77 I<. T. 456; 46 \V. R. 130 - ■ - BiiJtrei's Cas R. 5 Ch. 305; 39 1,. J. Ch. 478 ; 22 I.. T. 737 ; IM \V. R. 412 - 55 BriilfTcr ami NeiirrCasos( 1869), L. R '66 - - - 661 Hiidffewatoi- Xavif.'ation Co., (1891) 1 ( .2 Ch. 317 ; 64 I.. T. 576l,C. A.) - - - - - 755,784 Bridpuit liivworv Co., /!<■, 2 Ch. 191; .- \V. R. 291: 15 [.. T. (H3 . ■ . - - - - - 692,722 Brigps, Er i.nrtf. 1 E<(. 4H;i ; 14 I.. T. .39 ; :i5 1.. J. Ch. 320 ; 12 .riir._ ;J22 - - - - - - - ^"' '-^ Brin's Oxygon Co., W. N. (1899) 44 . . - - 1315 Briusnicad (T. E.) & Sons. (1897) 1 Ch. 406: 66 T,. J. (^h. 290; 76 I.. T. 100; 4Mans. 70: 13T. 1-. R. 3 - - - - 602 Bristol Unitod Breweries .. Abbot, (1908) 1 Ch. 279; 98 I.. T. 22: 24 T. L. 11. 91 - - "15 BritanmaMillsCo.. W.N. (1888)103 - - - -1283 British and Amcriian Trustee. &c. Corporation v. Couper, (1894) A. C. ;199; 63 T-. J. Ch. 425: 70 L. T. 882: 42 W. R. 632; 1 Manson, 256: 6 R. 652 (11. L.) - 30, 405, 482. 515, 6:17, 684, 731, 1117, 1119. 1256, 1259, 1260, 1305, 1495 British Asbostos <^o. ■•. Bovd, (liK)3) 2 Ch. 4.39 - 691, 728, 729, 730, 740, 744 Britisli Assoc, of Glass Bottle Manufacturers i\ Nettlefold, 27 T. I,. R. 527 26,116 British Building Stone Co., (1908) 2 Ch. 450; 99L.T.608; 77 L. J. Ch. 752 I'*'" British Burmah Co., W. N. (1887) 101; 56 I,. T. 815; 4 T. L. E. (j31 . . . - - 190, 194, 195, 200, 213 British Columbian Exploitation and Gold Estates, W. N. (1899) 32 - 1388 British Empire Match Co., 39 L. T. 292 - - - 728, 740 British Equitable Assurance Co. i: Baily, (1906) a.. C. 35 ; 94 L. T. 1 : -22 T. li. R. 152 ... - - 639, HI 8 British and Fonign Cork Co. See l^ifchild's Case. British Guiana Bank <•. British Guiana Ice Co., 104 L. T. 754 - 1192 British India Steam Navigation Co. v. f^lie, 17 T. L. K. 104 - 100 British I-and and Mortgage Co. of America, W. N. (1885) 205 - 1270 British Marine, &c. Co. v. Jenkins, (1900) 1 U. B. 299 - - "96 British Mutual Co. v. Chamwood Forest Bail. Co., 18 Q. B. D. 714 ; 33 W. R. 590 : 55 L. J. Q. B. 399 ; 36 L. .1. Q. B. 449 - 37, 41, 739 British National Life Assurance Association, Ex parte, 8 C. D. 679 ; 27 W. B. 88 ; 39 L. T. 136 ; 48 1.. J. Ch. 118 - 456, 465, oOT TABLE OF CASKS. XXXIZ Pidl Bri— Bro British SoainlesH Paper Hox Co., ffr. 17 (". D. 4(i7 ; 29 W. K. i>W; 44 I.. T. -IHS; ,j() L. J. Ph. 497 - i;!5, t)45, 8:i!>. 909, 1384, 1402 Mritixli .■'hiireCo., /Ji-. I,. T. -Jl,. ----- 701 liriti-h South Afri.a C. ,: ]),■ |!,...rs. (litlO' 2 Ch. Mi - M. ;i44 liriti^h Sugar l{ftinin<; To., /?-•, 3 K. & .1. 40S - - - f)!t2 I!riti-i W. 1{. 'J'JJ - - - - - - •'-• •"-• "**" bniiiswick, &c. Co. ''. MuKgeridgo, 1 Dr. & Sm. ;i83 - - IHJ Brussels I'lilace, &c. v. PnK.-kter, 13 T. h. R. 72 - - 294, 297 Bruttonand liurnev. Limited, lie. (1901) 1 Ch. 037; 70 L. J. Ch. 309; Hi I.. T. l"30; 49 W. 1{. 360 (C. A.) - - - 1421 Brvaut .-. liaiKiuodu reuplo, (1M93J A. C. 170; 02 L. J. P. C. 6H; " tiS L. T. 34H; 41 W. R. «(«); 1 U. 3;j(i(ll. I,.) - (iHfi, 1157, 1159 - 1099 173, J09 - 678 - 1460 - (iSO - 1J06 - 63 76 734, 829 - 768 - 1298 - jlO Brjnmawr Coal Co., W. N. (1877) 45 l!ry.>ii r. Metropolitan, &c. Omuibus Co.. 3 Do G. & J. 123 - I'.uihan'B Case, 4 App. Cas. 580 . - - - Buckland i . Papillou, 2 Ch. (i7 - - - - Buddeu ,: Roberts, 12 C. D. 288 . - - - But'uos Ayres Water Co., 66 D. T. 408 . . - Burs' .s Case, 2 Dr. & Sin. 4.59 - - - - Bulawayo Market Co., (1907) 2 Ch. 458; 23 T. I,. R. 714; L. J. »'h. 073 ------ Bulkeley '■. Stephens, (1896) 2 Ch. 241 Bull Hotel Company, liimited, 27 S. J, 134 Bull >•. Morrell, 12 Ad. & E. 745 - - - - Bullock i: Jxjndon Vr. O. Co., (1907) 1 K. li. 264 ; 95 1.. T. 905 ; 23 T. L. R. 62 Bultfontein Sun, &c. Mine, 12 T. L. R. 461 Burihell I'. Wilde, (1900) 1 Ch. 551 - Burdott-Coutts r. True Blue (Hanuan's) Gold Mine, (1899) 2 Ch. 616- 68 I,. J. Ch. 692: 81 L T. 29; 48 W. R. 1 (C. A.) - 1440, 1444, 1457 Burdetti'. Standard Exploration Co., 16 T. L. R. 112 - 634,653 Burfiess's Case, 15 C. D. 307 ; 28 W. R. 792; 43 L. T. 45; 49 I>. J. Ch. 541 - Burke c. Amalttamated Society of Dyers, (1906) 2 K. It. 583; 75 L. J. K. B. 533 Burkinshaw i: NichoUs, 3 App. ( as. 1(K)4 ; 2(i W. R. 819; ,39 I>. T. ;i08; 48 L. J. Ch. 179 . - - - 42,1140,1141 Burland -•. Earlo, 85 L. T. 553 (P. C. 1901) ; (1902) A. C. 83 - 29, 75, 137, 588, 633, 640, 703, 712, 715, 724, 7.34, 754, 755, 766, . 14, 86!;, 1355, 1358, 1360 Burn V. London 4 S. Wales Coal Co., W N. (1890) 209; 7 T. I,. R. 118 771,772 Bume.s .-. PounoU, 2 H. L. Cm. 497 ; 13 Jur, 897 - 668, 766, 857, 872, 873 Burnley Equitable Society v. Casson, (I'.'li) 1 Q. B. 73; 60 L. J. M. C. 59 ; 63 L. T. 632 ; 39 W. R. 124 ; 55 J. P. 166 - - .36 Bunows V. Matabele Gold Reefs, (1901) 2 Ch. 23 ; 70 D. J. Ch. 434 ; 84 L. T. 478 ; 49 W. R. 428 (C. A.) - - 13, 280, 284, 1450 Burton -•. Bevan, (1908) 2 Ch. 240 ; 99 D. T. 342 ; 15 Mans. 272 - 11. 13, 18, 19, 22, 23, 69, 258, 261, 648, 1072 Burton r. Gray, 8 Ch. 932 1186 Burton r. St. Gilea-in-the-Fields, (1901) 1 K. B. 630 - 106, 109 Bury 1'. Famatina Co., (1909) 1 Ch. 764 - - - 63, 466 Bush's Case, 6 Ch. 246 ; 19 W. R. 393; 24 L. T. 1 ; 40 L. J. Ch. 205 - 672 Bute's Case, 13 E3 W. R, 40S •u2 1!. (i43; tiS 1.. J. H Asp. M. ('. 51« 12(1.'), 12(17, I'JtW Ciiekott i: Keswick, (1902) 2 (.'h. 4.)(i ; (1901), .")0 W. K. 10 ; «j 1.. T. 14 ----- " " Cadf /•. Daly, [1910) Ir. R. UO(i Cudiz Waterworks Co. '•. Itarnott, 19 E(|. 1S2; I-. T. 040; 44 L. J. Vh. ,->29 I'udogau, &v. Co., W. X. (ISMi) 91 - Cahn c. Pockott'a Itristol, &c. Co. (i. H. jlj; 80 I,. T. 209; 47 (C.A.) - - Caledonian Railway Co. r. Solway Junction, 49 L. T. 520 ; :i2 W. li. I(i4 ; 2.1 W. R. Iu4 - Calpiry -■. lldmonton Umd Co., oO S. J. 120 : (1900) 1 Ch. 141 l;«>4, Calluo Urn Co., /.'., 42 C. Div. 109 ; oS I.. J. Ch. 826 ; fil 1,. T. i5;t4 ; ;}8 W. R. 21 ; 1 Mef<. 201 ; W. N. (1900) 44 - Callao His Miniuj; Co. o. Ronaldson. \V. N. (18K7) 170 Cullanl .-. Tayloi, 3 T. I,. R. 698 - Callo c. Mrounclear, 4 C. & 1'. jl8 - Caloric Engine Co., /iV, 52 Ij. T. 84() Calthorpo c. Trechmanu and Macl.oay I.. T. 68 ; o4 W. R. 305 Calthrop, B ■■' Ch. 252 - - - - Calton II. 1 „', 15 East, 223 ... - Cl.^.v I. utordon, 3 Man. & Ry. 124 Cambeford v. Chapman, 19 U. li. I). 229 - - . Camberwell Assessment Committei" r. Ellis, (1900) A. C. 510 L. J. (J. R. 828 ; 83 L. T. 201 (II. L., E.) ; affimiinK 48 W. R 162 (C. A.); 10 T. L. R. 504; i,'l9(K)) 1 Q. U. 68 Cambrian Co., /le, 48 h. T. 114 Cambrian, &c. Co., W. N. (1875) 0; 31 1,. T. 773; 23 W. R. 405 ---..- (i98, 708, 1095, CammoU, /■> piirte (l"rinting Telegraph, &c. Co. of Agonce Ilava.s), (1894) 2 Ch. 392; 63 L. J. Ch. 536; 70 E. T. 705; 1 Maiison, 274 ; 7 R. 191 (C. A,) - - . - 083,719,720 Campbell's Cas.', 9 Ch. 1 ; 22 W. R. 113; 29 L. T. 519 ; 43 E. J. 512 1305 Tail, (1906) A. C. 24 : 51, 1461 - 1461 - 368 - 442 - 699 94 227 . 230 - 751 - IlWl - 1246 - 1250 69 R. - 108 - 1452 1096 723 Ch. 1 78, 240, 694, 1048, 1097, Campbell's Case, 4 C. D. 470 ; 25 W. R. 299 ; 35 E. T. 900 - Campbell r. E'leming, 1 A. & B. 40 - Campbell v. Maund, 5 A. & E. 865; 1 N. & P. 558; 2 H. * 457 ------ - Cann r. WiUson, 39 C. D. 39 .... Oauuing Jarruh Timber Co., (1900) 1 Ch. 7tt8 Cannock v. Edwards, (1896) 2 Ch. 679 - Cannon v. Trask, 20 Eq. 669 ; 44 L. J. Ch. 772 103, 1104 - 687 - 201 W. 700 . 701 - 213 - 1503 - 112 i6«i. i4(m zlii TABLE OF CAOES. i'l Cap— Oat Cape lireton Co., Rr, 29 0. I). 795; 3.i W. H. 788; 33 L. T. 181 ; .M I,. .1. rh. H-2-i (f. A.) ; 12 App. Cus. e52 (II. L.) - 133, 137. 713, 732, 1247 Capel i: Ilutler, 2 S. & 8. 437 1247 Capcl i: Sims" Ships' Composition Co., W. N. (1888) 97 ; 57 L. J. Vh. 713; 3(i W. It. G89; 58 L. T. 807 - 153, 183, 191, 192, 228 Capital und Counties Hank (The) v. Tho Governor and Company of the Uank of England, 61 L. T. 31(i - - . - Capital Fire Insuranoo Association, te, 24 C D. 408; 32 W. K. 2(H); 49 1,. T. t>97 ; 53 L. J. Ch. 71 - Capper's Case, 3 Ch. 458 - - - - 45, 57, 072 Caratal New Mines, Ltd., (1902) 2 Ch. 498; 71 Ti. J. Ch. 883; 87 953 771 I,. T. 437 ; 50 W. R. Cardiff Workmen's I'ottago, (1900) 2 Ch. 027 T. L. H. 7!«» - - - - 700, 1100 95 !i. T. 069; 22 017 43 788 Carez, J{>, Rep. I'at. Cas. 532 - - - - - Cargill r. Hower, 10 C. I). .502 - - - 203, 714 Caridad Copper Mining Co. c. Swallow, (1902) 2 K. li. 44 ; 71 I.. J. K. li. iOl; 86 T,. T. 099; 30 W. R. 505 - - - 7:'i Carlill r. ( arbolic, &c. Co., (1893) 1 U- H- 250 ; 02 L. J. Q. B. 257 : 67 L. T. 837 ; 41 W. H. 210; 57 J. P. 325 : 4 R. 176 - 51, 290, :{38, 1182 Carling's Ca>e, 1 C. D. 115 ; 24 W. B. 165 ; 33 L. T. 645 ; 45 L. J. Ch. 5 - - - - - - 68, 722, 733, 1352 Carliug r. Ix)ndon and l^eeds Liunk. 3(i L. J. Ch. 321 ; 56 \i. T. 115 ; 35W. R. 344 .... - 191, 19.>, 199, 205 Carhsh v. Salt, (1906) 1 Ch. 335 - . - - - 331 Carmichael, Ex jxirte, lie Ilannau's Empress, &c. Co., (1896) 2 Ch. 643; 65 L. J. Ch. 902 ; 73 L. T. 43 - - 292, 293, 29» Carpenter <•. Patent lioat Co., 1 Meg. C. R. 26 - - - 1338 Carriage Co.operative Association, 27 C. D. 322 - - 714, 841 Carriage Sujiply Association, 27 C. 1), 322 ... 715, 722 Carter >: Rigby, (1896) 2 Q. B. 113; 65 L. J. Q. B. 537 ; 74 h. T. 744 ; 44 W. R. 566 ; 60 J. P. 581 (C. A.) - - - 1347 Carter v. St. Mary Abbott's Vestry, (1900) 64 J. P. 548 - . 204 Carter r. Wake, 4 C. U. 605 - - - - -1188 Carter f. White, 25 C. D. 666 - - 292, 298, 708, 1138, 124. Cartmell's Case, !i Ch. 691 . - - - - 37, 739, 833 Cartwright v. Sculcoates Union, (1900) A. C. 150; 69 L. J. Q. 13. 403 ; 82 L. T. 157 : 48 W. R. 394 ; 64 J. P. 229 (II. I-., E.) - 108 Cams. Wilson, He, 18 Q. 1' D.I: 56 L. J. Q. B. 530 ; 55 L. T. 864 ; 35 W. R. 43 - - - - - - . 349 Cary.Elwes Contract, He, (1906) 2 Ch. 143 ; 94 L. T. 845 ; 54 W. K. 480 . . - . . - - .694 Casey e. Bentley, (1902) 1 I. B. 376- . - - - 66ft Cash (J. & J.), Ltd. v. Cash. Times, May '26, 1900; 82 !i. T. 655 ; 86L. T. 211 . - . - . . .451 Clastcll and Brown. Ltd., Re, (1898) 1 Ch. 315 ; 78 L. T. 109 ; 46 W. H. 248 . . . . . . - - 401 CasteUain .'. Preston, 11 a R. D. 380 . . . .361 Castelli c. Middleton(1901), 17T. L. R. 373 . - .358 Castlehow, He, (1903) 1 Ch. 352 - - - - . 911 Catt V. Tourle, 4 Ch. App. 655 ; 38 L. J. Ch. 663 ; 21 L. T. 188 . 339, 441 Cattewater Harbour v. Plympton Union, 63 J. P. 297 - - 106 TABLE OF CABK8. xliii \o L. Cst-Oit MM Cattle.'. Thorpe. W. N. (1U0O)h;J .V'S f'avei'. t'ave, isr. D. «i:f9'- ... - 111, lO'il Cavondi-h i». (rrcaves, 24 Heav. IfiJi- .... 123.> CawUn- & Co.. 4i C. I). 209; .>N li. J. Ch. ti:i;t ; .">■'>, tiOi, (iiH!, ml, liT.i, "2'.', lUtW Central De Kaap Gold Milieu, W. N. (1N99) 216; 69 I-. J. Ch. 18; 7 Minis. «2 ------ - 72« Coiitial Klondyke Qold Co., Thomson's Case, o Mans. 282 - - 199 Ceiitnil Kail. ("«.. of Vonozuola r. Kisch. I.. R. 2 II. L. 9!»: 1.5 W. U. 821 ; 16 I,. T. o(M); Mi L. .J. Ch. 849 - T;t, ISj, UIO, l!i:f, 106, 197, 198, 200. 2:i!l, 240 Cerclo IJi'stauraiit v. Ijivnny, 18 Ch. I). o57 . . - HU Cesicna Sulphur Co. i: Nicholson, 1 K.\. D. 428 (1876) - - 93 Coylon I-ind and Produco Co., 7 T. I,, li. <>92 - - - 672 Chuc 'Paraguay) Ijind Co.. \V. N. (1901) 124 - - - l;W7 Child k V. Uritish Honth Africa Co., (1896) 2 (i. B. l,j:J; 6i 1,. J. (. !. 6:i,j ; 74 I,. T. 7.W ; 44 W. U. ()J8 (('. .\.) Chaiiitierlain \Miarf y. Smith. (1!K)2) 2 Ch. 60.i ; 69 1.. J. \ TiulorV I,. <'. Mi-ri', ard «d. 1 , i.j - - - - - IHM Clayton r. I,w(h, 41 C. D. loa - . . . . Cli'Sj; I- lIiiudH, 44 C, I>. 50a - - - . . Ckfjf,' i: Rowland, a K74 ----- 117 Colli«>n -'. Wairon, (liH)l) 1 Ch. 812; 7ll I.. .1. fh. ;tM2 ; H4 1,. T. 482 (C. A.) ------ - I3T3 Colman <•. K. C. R«il. Co., 10 IWav. 1 ; 8 I,. T. (». S. ,j;«); Ifi 1,. J. (N. S.) Ch. 73; 11 .lur. 74 : 4 Ry. Ca». J13 - - 4-.!t, 4(i5 (^hner, l,t.l. (James), (1897) 1 Ch. 524 - - . 65 ----- 46* Coltness Iron Vo. v. Hlaok, 6 App, Cas. 329; 29 W. R. 717; 43 I,. T. 143; 40 J. P. 20 - - - - UK), 103, 881 Columbian Firoprooflns Co., (1910) 2 Ch. 120 - - - 616 Combo c. Woidfo, 1 M. & S. 241 ; 8 Bin};. 156 - - - 1247 Commercial Bank of Tasmania i'. Jones, (1893) A. C. 313; 62 1j. J. I'. C. 104; 68 I,. T. 776; 37 J. P. 37, 1464 Common Petroleum Ensiue I o., (1895) 2 Ch. 739 ; 63 L. J. Ch. 70 ; 73 h. T. 338 ; 2 Munson, 398 ; 13 R. 840 - - - (W Compat^io QeneraleTransatlantique, (1899) A. C. 431 - - 1311 Compania Sansiuena r. Houlder, (1910) 2 K. 1!. 334; 79 h. J. K. li. 1094 ; 103 I,. T. 333 (C. A.) . - - - 1349 Components Tube Co. v. Naylor, (1900) 2 I. E. 1 - - 186, 192 Concessions Trust, ^1896) 2 Ch. 737 - - - - - 676 Connolly Hros., (1911) 1 Ch. 731 1419 Conquest's Case, 1 C. Div. 334 : 43 L. J. Ch. 336 ; 33 L. T. 7(>2 - 311, 1448 Cousett Iron Co., (1901) 1 Ch. 236 ; 70 L. J. Ch. 198 ; 84 h. T. 258 - loll* lollfi Consolidated Telephone Co., 33 W. E. 408 - - - -1271 Consort Deep U-vel Gold Minw, (1897) 1 Ch. 573; fit! T.. J. Ch. 122 ; -iC L. T. 300 ; 45 W. E. 227 - 275, 289, 290, 293, 297, 303, 1311, 1312, 1313, 1389 xlvi TABLE OP CASES. i' ' ; l 1 " ,: n \l H i ': \ :■ i . .1 1 * ■! i Oon-Oou ,4„ Coiitiiioiitil Union flan Co., 7 T. I,. B. 4!W - - . . (139 Cook I'. North Metropolitan t^o., H ti. 11. I). ti8.') - . 1021 «'<".k r. Waril, 'J C. I'. I>. W3 - . . . . 74.3 <'(M.kf p. Midland G. W. Bly. of Ireland, (1909) A. U. 22»: W. N. (IWHt) J«> ----... ;|7 (.'ooku i: Welby, UJ C. D. 709 - - - . - 11J8 t'o,.lpiir(lio, *c. Miii.,'» {1W»7), 70 I,. T. 269 ; 14 T. L. R. 2'H - 470, «100 . 17 Copper Mines Tinplato Co., \V. N. (1897) 20 Corlwtt c. Gfni'ral Steam Navisntion Co.. 4 H. & N. 482 - Cordova Union (!oId Co., /.'., (1891J 2 Cli. 580; 60 L. J. Ch, 64 L. T. 722 ; 39 W. B. 536 - - - . Cork and Bandou Bail. Co. v. Ooode, 13 C. B. 826; 22 L 198; 17 Jnr. 600 - - . ' . Cork and Youghall Bail. Co., 4 Cu. 748 - Com brook v. Law Debenture Corporation, (1904) 1 Ch. 103 L. J. Ch. 121; 89 L. T. 680; 52 W. B. 242; 20 T. L. B. (<-'. A.) Cornell V. Hay, L. B. 8 C. P. 328; 21 W. B. 580; 28 L. T. 475 li. J. C. P. 136 - Cornford .■. Carlton Bank. (1899) 1 Q. B. 392 ; 68 L. J. Q. B. 196 ■ and affirmed, (1900) 1 Q. B. 22 ; 68 L. J. Q. B. 1020 ; 82 L T •♦'^(C. A.) 3^,548 Cornish v. Hark. 14 Eq. 184 - . . . . 1334 Cornwall Minerals Co., (1897) 2 Ch. 74 ; 66 L. J. Ch. 361 ■ 76 L T 832 ; 46 W. R. 5 ^^0 \ (|M9I) 1 Ch. W.»; fX) I,. J. Ch. 1W(C. A.) --.'-.- 48 Covoutry'«Cuw. U C. I>. (HHI .... . l.J,i7 Covintiy, vli'. Co. c Ornit Ka«firn [luil. Co., 11 H. li. D. 77tl - Vi Covi iitrv ami Dixon's Caw, 1 1 C, D. Blit); 2H W. R. 77'>; 42 I.. T. .).•)!»" ........ 720 Cowl.'y /■. Ncwmarkut l/)cal Hoard, ^1N!»2) A. C. :i4J - - 176 Cowi«T r. Smith, 4 M. & W. ,M» 1247 Cox <•. Bishop, N Ih- (i. M. & G. si,-. ; .j W. K. 437 ; 2'J I,. T. H ; .t Jur. N'. S. 4!l!»; 2t> I,. .1. Ch. :1SI» .... 328 Cox and Nevo's CiOf, (l«!»l) 2 Ch. 1()!»; fM 1,. T. 733; MtW. I!. 412 - 3.-iO Coxoii i: C.orst. (ISltl) 2 f'h. 73: lio 1,. .1. Ch, :m2: •>4 L. T. 114; 3. »!;H : J!» I,. .1. Ch. 7;ti» . (12 L. T. H'l'A; .(N \V. 1!. (>(>(i - - - . . 470. (MM), |;),v', <'ri>wii l,i(iw' I'niprii'tury Co., 14 T. I.. I!. J. - . 21»1. iiM Crfiwthir .-. TIloiI. V, .12 \V. U. -lao: .)ti I.. T. (.1 - - - 111 rniiii I. niiklwiik Co. s Ainp. Cii.'-. (ij: -IS 1,. T. .i.t; - 631. N1& Cuff r. UmilimiinilC.iiiity I^iiiiil, '1!»12) 1 C. I). 440 ; aS W. R. JIS . 777 Ciillfu, A.V ,«irl,, (1H<)1) 2 H. li. IJI : (Ui 1,. .). il. 1!. ,-;)i7; (i4 I.. T. Niil ; ;i!i W. U. .-.4:1: hM. 1:. K. 171 .... 70.-, CiiU.ii .. lUwiii, 1,. T. vlO; 2(1 T. I.. 1!. 4iM) - - ii;i. 11(1 Culli'ii Thi.iiii)«wr« Trustwv, 4 Man|. 424; (> I,. T. N7(i; !» Jur. N. S. S.5 - - . . . . . ,-,j,j CulliTiio I-. Uiiiilon and Subuihim S., 2.1 U- 1!. I>. 48j - - 7kn Cuniiiiin(,'8 c. Stiwurt (liHK)). 1 Ir. If. 2;l(i - . . . ;i7!) Cuminl .St.am--hiii Co. -■. Cdulsmi, (INIMC 1 Q. ll.N«.V HH I, ,) (^ |i j.)4 ; H(l I,. T. ,1211 - - ' - . . '. \m Ciinunl ." ("uiilitT.' ltri")k> \ Co. ,-. lilnckburn Ituilding S.. 1 App. Com. "■'' ----- |i!»N, 11!W, 1200 CuiminKhiUn, 1(. N.. /.V, :,H I,, 'f. Hi: :)(! C. I). .■);i2 : ,57 1,. J. Ch. ••"* ------- 510, 710 Curl r.roN.. I.til. r. Wt;b«ter. (1!M>4) 1 Ch. (iNj; 7.'t I,. J. Ch. 540- W) L. T. 479; .-.2 W. K. 41;) - - - . - 337 Currin r. Mina. L. U. 10 Ex. I(i2 - - - . 1180,1194 Curry v. KiUmHor, 3 T. E. .J24 - . . . . 1214 CurtiHV Caw. (i Yjf\. 4j.j --..-. 072 CuthWt 1: RdliurtH, Lubbock A Co., 2.) T. I.. E. .•|8:t ; W. N. {UK>9) U, I2o - ...... 1194 Cutli.T r. Southiiu, 1 WniM. .Siuiid. 11 j - - . . 124ft Cyclists' TounugClub, (liM(7) 1 Ch. 2. w • Daimler Motor Co. <•. Hritieh Motor Tractidn Co,, IN R. P. C. 465 - 4,j3 Dale 1: riant, 43 C. I). 255; 61 L. T. 209 ; 1 M,.j». ;i:l8 - 147, ;t2;f. 725. 739, 759 Dale's Case, (i o l»ttItou Tiuio I/)ck (."o. r. Dalton, (i(> L. 'f. 704 (C. A.) - - 46 Damieiitt c. Motlem Soc, 27 T. 1.. 1{. 174 - . . . i;j5o Dauby, In ,;■, A,'.. ,,artt liroughaui, (1911) 1 K. li. 95 - 126, 954, 1384 Danby V. Coutts, 29 C. D. 500; ,-,4 I,. J. Ch. 577; 52 L. T. 401 ■ ;t.i W. H. 559 ' . 1137 Daimbiau Sugar Fuctorit-s I-. Inlaudjltcvonue, (1901) 1 U li. 245- 70 L. J. U. K. 211 ; 84 I-. T. lolj; «5 J. P 212 (C. .V.) - 340, 342 D'Arcy 1-. The Tamar, &c. Bail. Co., L. K. - Ex. 158 4 II. & C. 463; 36 L. J. Ex. 37 - - - . . 710,74* I. TABLE OF CA8E8. xHx Dar— !)•• Diirloy Main Co. r, Mitchell, II App. ('!»», ll'T DarliiiKt"" F<.rK"'<'o., AV. 34 C D. dT2 , :W W. B. .■.;tT , .'.« I.. T. «27; 3(1 1,. .(. eh. 7.«> --.... I luvid i: Fniiid, I My. & K. 2()!i ..... DiiTid &Miitlhow». (iwm) I eh. ;i7H; tW I.. .1. Ch. \h:>: so I,. T. 7.); 47 W. U. ;il:i I>ttvi(l ruync & Co., (1904) i Cli. «W : JOT. I,. U. 51Ht : 7.1 I,. .1. Ch. MO ----- . Ml'. tiNtj. 710. I laridsou )■. Tulloch, .3 Macq. 7fi;i - - . . . Duvi.M !•. ]{. Itdtdii & Co., (1N04; :! Ch. «7H ; «3 I,. J. Ch. 74:i: 71 L. T. ;t.m: 4.1 \V. 11. 171 ; h II. Bn.5 - h\. n,(, «h6, 71(t. 7fi«, 761, Davien r. Itiiniott, (l!t02) I K. It. fifKi; 71 L. .1. K. H. Hjj: Hd I,. T. .">ii.j ; jO W. It. 301 ---... DaviM (. Dnviog. 3»! C. D. 359; ;J«W. V Hti; .j»U,.T. 401 ; a«I,, .1. Cli. 4H1 - Davir.i <: DaWes, (1N9^') 3 Ch. »i3 : lil I,. ,1. Ch. J9.i ; ti7 I,. T. 54H ; •«1 W. U. 13 ,i77, Davic'H 1'. Ebbw Vale Urban Council, ;!7 T. I .. li. 543 Davioei v. Ou.t Light and Cokr Co., (1909) I Ch. '.'I.v DavicM r. Loiiilon & l'n>v. Co., H C. \), 47,') .... Daviod, TuniiT & Co. i: Lowcii, t>4 L. T. f!3.) ... Ouvif* '•. liiink of England. '2 Iting. 393 ... ti(i7 Duvisr. I'orciiiiin, 43 W. K. I(W ..... Davison c Ihincim, 7 K. & IS. 'Jlilt . - . - . Davison <■. GillioH, 1« CD. 347, n. (INNO); 44 L. T. 92, n. ; 50 L. J. Ch. 192, n. .... HH), N73, s7N Davorrcn r. Wotton, (1900) 1 I. R. 273 . . . iio7 Davy i: AValkor, 81 1,. T. 107 - - - - . Dtw c. Terrt'll, ,33 IWav. 21S . . . . . DawcB' CaHO, 6 Ei). 2.32 : 37 L. J. Ch. i«)l : H! \V. II. mo - ,jN Dawkiiis r. Antrobus, 17 C. I), tild ; 29 W. K. Jll : 44 L. T. 5.'>7 - Dawkins v. Hadnor, 3 Dow. 53.'i . - . . _ Dawson & Jenkins' Contract, (1904) 2 Ch. 219 . - 1157, DawRon t'. African Consolid:ited ( 'o., (189H) I ( 'h. li : 4f) W. R. 132 - 730, Duwson r. Itoeson, 22 Ch. oO.j - - - . . Dawson r. Islo, (1900) 1 Ch. ()33 ; 9j I,. T. 385 ; o4 W. R. 4.52 Day. //., 1 C. D. 699 Day r. lirownrigg, 10 C. D. .304 : 27 W. R. 217 ; 39 L. T. 553 • 48 L. J. Ch. 173 I>iy r. Singleton, (1899) 2 ch. 320; 08 L. ,J. Ch. S93 ; M I,. T 30(i; 48 W. R. 18 (C. A. ..... Deano r. Wilson. (1906) 2 Ir. R. 405, K. B. D. Dearie v. Hull. ,3 Russ. 1 ..... . Do lieers Consolidated Mines r. Howe. (1905) 2 K. \',. 612 (C. A ■ 54 W. R. !i ; 22 T. L. R. 756; (1906) A. C. 455 - 95, Debenham r. Sawbridgo, (1901) 2 Ch. 98 - . . . Do Bouchont c. Qoldsmid, 5 Ves. 213 ... 1157, 1)B Bussche ". Alt. 8 C. D. 3(M) - . . . 73;' Do Clifford (Ix)ra). Jle, (1900) 2 ( h. 707 ; 23 [,. T. 160 ; 69 I,. J. Ch. 828 715, Deeley v. Lloyds Hank, (1910) 1 Ch. t>48 ... 1190, rum »1 1395 679 ;t57 , 778 208 8.(4 .367 .3.'. 7 , i>78 442 71 II9ent V. [.ondon Tramways Co. (1880). 16 C. D. 344 - 860, 879 Dent's Case, 8 Ch. 768 - - - - - - *^* Denton v. MacneU, 2 Eq. 352, 356 ; 14 W. B. 813 ; 14 L. T, 721- 189, 192 Denton i'. I'addison, 68 I.. T. 409 - - - - - 1246 Denver Hotel Co., Re, (1893) 1 Ch. 495 ; 62 L. J. Ch. 450 ; 68 L. T. 8; 41 W. R. 339; 2 R. 330 (C. A.) - - - 751, 1495 Denver United Breweries, W. N. (1890) 143 ; 63 I.. T. 96 - - 1393 De Pass' Case, 4 D.> O. & .1. 544 ; 7 W. H. 0S2 ; 28 I,. J. Ch. 769 - 665 Derby Canal Co. c. Wilmot, 9 Kast, 359 - - - - S4 Derinatine /■. Axhworth, 21 T. I.. R. .MO - - 510, 711, 752 De Rosaz's Case, 21 I.. T. 10 - - - - - 51 De Rosaz i: AnKlo-ltuhun Hank, 4 Q. li. 462; 17 W. B. 724; 38 L. J. a. IJ. 161 1444, 1446, 1474 Derrv <: Peek, 14 App. Cas. 337 ; 58 I.. J. Ch. 864 ; 61 L. T. 265 ; 38 W. R. 33; 1 Jleir. 292 - 186, 187, 189, 192, 203, 2(H, 205, 206, 216, 224 De Buvignes Case, 5 C. D. 306 ; 25 W. R. 476 ; 36 L. T. 329 ; 40 L. J. Ch. 36<1 - - - - 306. 714, 718, 722, 1352 Devalu Mining Co.. Rf, 22 C. D.. 593 ; 31 W. R. 425 ; 48 L. T. 259 ; 52 L. J. Ch. 434 190, 192 Development Company of Central Africa, (1902) 1 Ch. 547 ; 71 li. J. Ch. 310 ; 86 1-. T. ,123; 50 W. R. 456 - - - 1259, 1263 Dever>p» .-. Sandeman, Clark & Co., (19(k') 1 Ch. 579; 71 I.. .1. Ch. 328; 86 1.. T. 269; 50 \V. R. 404 (C. A.) - - 1142, 1220 Dexiue Patent Packing & Rubber Co., W. N. (190.3)82 - -1264 Dexter i\ United (Jold, &c. Ste Hilda c. Dexter. Diamond Fuel Co., 13 1'. D. 400 - . - - Dicido Pier Co., (1891) 2 l h. 3,'54 ; 64 I.. T. 095 ; .i9 W. R. 486 821, 1119, 1123, Dickenson i: Valpy, 10 li. & C. 128; J M. & R. 126 Dickin, Ex fnirtf, 20 Fxj. 767 . - . - - Dickinson r. Harrow, (19(M) 2 Ch. 339; 73 I,. .1. Ch. 701 , 91 I.. T. 161 IHck.'^m r. Uw, (189.-) 2 Ch. 62; 64 1.. .1. Ch. 490; 72 I.. T. *iS0 ; 43 W. H. 596; 13 R. 431 ... - - 1;141 Didisheim r. 1 ^mdon & ^V ■■stminster Bank, (1900) 2 Ch. 15- 667. 680 Dimes r. . Suckling, L. R. 1 Q. H. 585 - - - -1195 Dore Gallery, Rf, W. N. (1890) 62 ; 62 L. T. 758 ; 38 W. R. 491 - 1391 DorW^ r. South African Super- Aeration (1904), 20 T. L. R. 425 (Div. C.) ----- - 690, 763 Dougan'8 (^asp, S Ch. 545 ; 21 W. B. 496; 28 L. T. 649 ; 42 L. J. Ch. 460 - - - - - - - 514, 1481 Douglass i: Rowland, 24 Wendell, 35 - - - - 1249 Dover Coalfields Extension, ;?«, (1908) 1 Ch. 65 ; 98 1.. T. 31; 21 T. L. R. 52 - - - - - - 728, 734 Dovcy I'. Corv, (1901) A. C. 25: 70 L. ,J. Ch. 753; 85 L. T. 237 - 713, 714, 766, 777, 864, 865, 892, 897, 899, 904, 906 Downes c. Ship, 1.. R. 3 H. L. 359; 19 1.. T. 471; 37 L. J. (^h. 642 - - - - - 52, 1K4, 196, 242, 238 Dowses Case, 3 C. D. 384 ; 35 !.. T. 633 ; 46 1.. J. ( h. 402 - 1329 Dowson, /<^ W.N. (1889)222 - - - . -1391 Dowsonand Jenkins' Contract, (1904) 2 Ch. 219 - - -1138 Doyle and O'Uara's Contract (1899), 1 Ir. Rep. 113 (C. A.) - - 334 Drant v. Brown, 3 B. & C. 666 - - - - - .338 Driffield Gas Ijght Co., (1898) 1 Ch. 451 ; 76 J-. T. 162 - 657, 785 Drincqbior -•. Wood. (1899) 1 Ch. 393; 68 L. J. Ch. 181 ; 79 L. T. 548; 47 W. R. 252; 6 Mans. 76 - - 192. 217, 259, 1347 Drum Slate Co., R-; Mil^ean's Case, 53 L. T. 250; 55 L. J. Ch. 36- 142, 1401 Drummond's Case, 4 Ch. 772 - - - - - 39 Du Houluv r. Dm Boulav, L. R. 2 C. P. 441 ; 17 W. R. 594 : 38 I,. ,1. C. P.'35 - " - - - - - - 452 Duck i: Bates, 12 (J. B. D. 79; on appeal, 13 <1. B. I). 843 - 44 Duck V. Tower Oalvauiziug Co., (1901) 2 K. B. 314 ; 70 L. J. K. 11. 314 ; 84 L. T. 847 - - - - - - 81 Duckott r. Gover, 6 C. D. 82; 23 W. R. 334 ; .6 L. .1. Ch. 407 - 74, 1359, l:)60 Dnffin r. Mnxiraii, &r. Co., W. N. (1890) 116 - - -1:591 Duke's Case, 1 C. D. 620 - - - - - 479, 483 Dukr of Beaufort c. Neeld( 1843), 12 II. & F. 248 - - . 293 ,12 r lii TABLE OF CASES. ^:i S'i' Dun— Eaa Duncan, Re, Terry v. Sweeting, (18W) 1 Ch. 387 ; 68 L. J. Ch. 253 ; 80 L. T. 322 ; 47 W. B. 379 - Duncan, Fox & Co. v. North and South Wales Bank, G App. Can. I - Duncuft V. Albrecht, 12 Sim. 189 - DunkleyV Case, 7 T. I-. R. 234 Dunlop f. Dunlop, 21 C. I). oK3 - DuFlop /•. Iliggins, 1 H. L. C. 381 Dunlop Pneumatic Tyro Co. c Action Ooxellschaft fijr Motor, &c., (1902) 1 K. B. 342, 349 ------ I>uune f. English, 18 Eq. 524 : 31 I>. T. 75 - Itunstor's Case fOlory Paper Mills Co.), (1894) 3 Ch. 473 : 03 L. J. Ch. 885 ; 71 I,. T. 528 : 43 W. fi. 104 ; 1 Mans-on, 438 ; 7 1!. 450 (C. A.) - - 47 Dunston r. Imperial, &C. Co., 3 B. & Ad. 125 - - 29 Durham County Society, 12Eq.516 Duthy and .lesson's Contract, (1898) 1 Ch. 419 : 67 L. .1. Ch. 218 ; 78 L. T. 223 ; 46 W. B. 300 - Dutton V. Marsh, 6 Q. B. 361 Dural I. Cans, (1904) 2 K B. 685 ; 91 L. T. .iON ; 53 W. B. 106 - Duvall Ceylon Estates r. I'-u Ceylon Eubber Estates. 103 L. T. 410 Dyotfs Case. 43 L. T. 85 . - - - 1440,1441, Dvmotk r. Showell's Brew.TV Co., 15 T. I.. K. 13: 79 1,. T. 329 (C.A.) - - -■ D>TievorCo". ,. 11 ('. D. OO.j - - 1490,1497. DjT>anion, i V\\. 223 . - - - - PAM 207 1247 1350 197 058 48 1.341 733 , 485 , 724 1199 353 51(1 :M4 4.J2 1464 355 1503 OOS £. I i i I i .1 E. W. A., Re, (1901) 2 K. li. 042 : 85 L. T. 31 ; 40 W. E. 042 - 1245 Eagle Co., Ex pcirU , 4 K. cS: J. 549 ; 6 W. B. 779 - - 79. 701 EaglesfieW v. Marquis of lx)ndonderry, 4 C. Div. 693; 25 W. K. 190 : 35 L. T. 822 . - - - 187,194,1190 Eales V. Cunilwrlaud ISlackload Co., r of Nuath, 22 U. li. 1>. 555 - 470, 002. 004 Earl .if Sti-aftord i: Maples, (1890) 1 <'h. 235; 05 L. J. Ch. 124: 73L. T. 586; 44\V. B. 259(C. A.) . - - - ;l.H Earl BusKoll (Trial of), (1901) A. C. 440; n5 1.. T. 253; 70 I.. J. K. H. 998 ------- OW) Earl's Trust. 4 K. & J. .300 - . - - - -1158 1-jiKt -•. IWnuett Bros., (1911) 1 Ch. 103 - - - 579,698 East Anglian Bail. Co. v. l-lastom Counties Hiiil. <'o., 11 C. 11. 775; 21 I,. .1. <'. P. 23; 16 Jur. 249 - - - - 460, 465 East Anglian Bail. Co. r. Lythgoe, 2 1.. M. & P. 221 - - 442 East Pant, &c. Co. c. Merryweather, 2 U. & M. 354 ; 13 W. U. 210 ; 10 Jur. N. S. 1231 ; 4 N. B. 641 - - - 703, 1301 East Wheal. &c. Co.. .33 Heav. 119 - - - - - 675 .it*,^! TABLE or CASES. Kii lta«-EU MOB Eastern and Australian Steamship Co,, I46 Ehrman r. Bartholomew, (1898) 1 Ch. 671 ; 67 L. J. Ch. 319; 78 L. T. 646 ; 46 W. R. 509 - - - - -358 Ehrmann Brother^ (1906) 2 Ch. 697 ; 54 W. R. 555; 22 T. L. 1!. 734 ------ - 617, 1424 Eichbaum ,: City of Chicago Co., (1891 ) 3 Ch. 139 ; 61 I,. J. Ch. 28 ; 40 W. R. 153 - - - - - 750, 751 Elder /•. Now ZcaUnd Und Co., W. N. (1874) 83 ; 30 L. T. 285 - 646 Eldert-lifi Steamship Co. ,•. Borthwick, (1905) A. C. 96 ; 92 I.. T. 274 ; 74 I,. J. K. B. 3;« : 53 W. R. 401 (H. L., E.) - - - 594 Electromobile Co. v. British Electromobile Co., 97 L. T. 196 ; 98 L. T. 258 ------ - 451, 452 Eley .-. Pofsitive Government, &c. Co., 1 Ex. Div. 20, 88; 24 W. R. 338; .H 1,. T. 190; 45 1.. J. Ex. 431 - 147, 148, 441, 633, 6.34, 6;i5, 643, 728, 748, 758, 838 Klkington's Case, 2 Ch. 511 ; 15 W. B. tMiJ ; 16 L. T. 301 ; 36 L. J. Ch. 593 - EUerbyV Claim, 2 W. R 855 ElIeBmBre Brnwery Co, >•, Cixipflr, (IMJW ! O. B, 'S EUiman, Sons & Co. i: Carrington, (190n 2 <%. 275 Elliott c. Turquand. App. Ca«. 79- - ii; 55, 257 - 1149 - t24A , 358, 424 - UM Kt TABLE OF CASK8. PAW 709 .181 1021 1497 768 121(> U47 XU— Eup Ellin V. Ilarfleld, W . N. (18D1) 84 EUis .'. Dodwii, 00 I,. J. Ch. 353 ; 7 T. I.. H. 318 - Ellis r. Josevh EUis & Co., (1905) 1 K. H. 324 : 74 L. J. K. It. 229; 92 1,. T. 718; o3W. R. 311 (C. A.) - - . - Ellis r. McUenry, 6 L. B. C. r 228 . . . - Ellis V. Kowbothum, (litOO) 1 Q. IS. 740 - - - - Ellison r. Wright, .'t Buss, 4.')0 . . - - - Elphinstoiio (I/>i- jiarfi. 82 1.. T. JOl : iiffirmetl 48 W, B. t>9;! (C. A.) "*' Emma MininL' Co. v. Grant, 11 (\ 1). 918 ; 40 l„ T, 804 : 17 C D. l''> • 29 W. R. 4H1 : .50 1,. .1. Ch. 449 - 122, 123, 131, 13.3, 138, 1 «», 207, 14(K) Eu.nmMiningCo.r. Lewis, 4r, 1>, D. 396; 27 W, B.836; 40 L. T. 168 ; 48 L, .1. C. r. 2J7 - - lli^, 123, 125, 133, 1;K» Emmeni. r, I'ottle, 16Q. IS. I>. 334 - . - - - .J46 Empire I if.-, 31 C. T). 78 - - - - - - 1-198 Empire Mining Co., Wc 44 C. I). 402 - 1493, 1490, 1497, 1501, 1502 Empress Kngino. ring Co., 10 C. I). 125 : 29 \V, B. 342 ; 43 L. T. 742 67, . 322, .323, 324, 306. 370, 441, 044, 1149 Engletieia ColUery ( ..., 8 V. P. 388 ; .38 L, T. 112 - 715, 722, 748, 88. 839, 1403 T. 580 ; 748, 759, 839 514. 786 - 1229 - 1(H) English and Colonial Produce Co., (19<10) 2 Ch. 4.35 : 95 L. 22 T. L. B. 009 - - 139, 117, 14s, 32.3, 301, English and Foreign Cnnlit Co., 1 Times L. B. ji. 1 English Hunk of Biver HaU-, 0!t L. T. 14 - English Crown Spelter Co, '•. Baker, 99 L. T, 353 - English, Scottish, and Australian Bank, (1895) 3 I'h. 385 - 707, 1497, 1602 Englishman (Tlio) and AustraUa (The), (1895) P. 212 ; 04 L. J. P. 74 : 72 L. T. 203 ; 43 W. B. 070 : 11 B. 757 ; 7 Asp. M. C. 005 Ennis, He, (1893) 3 Ch. 242 Equitable Life Assurance Society of the United .'^tat^s r. Itishop. (19(M>) 1 Q, H, 177 - - - - Era Assuraneo Co,'s Case, 30 I., J. Ch. 137 : 32 L. .1. Ch J. & S. 29 : 11 W. B. 59 ; 7 1.. T. UM - Erichsiii )•. l^ast, 8 Q, 11, 1>. 414 - 1247 1245 101 207 ; 1 I). 514, 1481 94, 119 Erlungiir r. New Sombrero Co., 3 App, ( 'as, 1218 : 27 AV. B. (i5 ; 39 i: T. 209; 48 L. J. Ch. 73 - 33, 12, 121, 131, 132, 1.33, l:t4, 136, 137, 13,s, 141, 143, 239, 645 Ernest r. CroysdiU (1800), 2 1>. F. & J. 175 - - 712, 1350 Ernest i: Ixima Gold Mines, (1897) 1 Ch. 1 ; <>0 J-. .1. Ch, 17 ; 75 L. T. 317 : 45 W, B. 8(i - 698, 099, 705, 708, 1090, 1098 Ernest V. NichoUs, (i IL li, C. 401 ; 8 C, 1». 679; 3 Jur. N. S. !tl9- "s, 239, 450, 400, 500, 'i 10 Bsdaile f. I,a Nan/e, 1 Y. & C. 394 1157 Esparto Trading Co., «f, 12 C. I). 191 . - - 47 Eepuola I-and and Cattle Co., W. N. (1900) 139 ; 48 W, B, 684 ^ 814, 817, Easex and Suffolk Equitable Insurance Society, W. N, (1909) 102 - Estates Investment Co., 27 S. J. 585 . . . - Euphrates aad Tigris Stoam Navigation Co., (1904) 1 Ch. 360 ; 73 L. J. Ch. 175 ; 90 L. T. 56 ; W. N. (1904) 23 - - 1311, 131* 058 096, 1081 1319 1337 TABLE or CASES. Eup- Fau Eupion Fuol uud Oas Co., W. N. (ls7a) 1(» - European Hank, !{•■, Agra Bank Claim, H Ch. 41 - 11 European < 'o. r. Bailoliffo, 7 Ch. H. 73.'{ Evans's Caso (1S07), 2 Ch. 420 ; ;i6 I,. .). Ch. .Wl : 16 I..T, W. R. u4:t Evans c Itoattie, 3 E»p. 2<> - - - - EvunH c. Hrown (18-I3), 5 lloav. 114 Evans r. Chapman, 8(! I.. T. .381 : IS T. I.. R. .Wfi - Evans v. Coventry, S De G. M. & G. K.'Jd; 5 W. I!. 4;t(i; O. S. 118; 20 \.. .1. I'h. 400 - Evans r. Hearts of Oak Society, 12 .lur. N. ."*. 163 - Evans v. Rival Granite Quariiis, (li)lO) 2 K. 1!. 97il Evans i: Smallcombe, I.. R. .1 11. I.. 24!» - Evans i'. Truman, 1 Moo. & R. 10 - Everitt r. Automatic Weighing Machine Co., (1H92} .i Ch. r,. T. :i4!i: 62 1.. .1. 1 11.241 - K. W. A. ,/?<■, (1901)2 K. 15. 642 - Ewing r. Ewing, 8 App. Cas. 822 . - - E.xchange Draper^- Co., 3s C, I). 171 Kxchiinge Tnist, Limited, I Jirkworthy 's Case, (1903) 1 Ch, !.. .1. Ch. 387: 88 I.. T. 56 - Exeter and Crediton Rail. Co. v. ItuUor, j l!y. Cas. 211 J27 ----- - Exploring I ..and and Minerals Co., 94 I.. T. 234 Expre.ss Fuel Co., «., \S. N. (isio) 10 - 1401 92, 119J, UO.j - 1354 232; 13 - 16, 47, 484 - 1248 - 112 - 0 ; 11 Jur. - 74, 75. 1360 - 714 - 87.^ Kairbairn Engineering Co. (Ej- />"W.' Ijidd). (1893) 3 Cli. \M . 63 I.. .1. Ch. 8 : 69 I.. T. 413 : 8 R. 16 Fairbrother i: England, 40 W. R. 220 Famatina Va. v. liury, (1910) A. C. 439 Family Endowment (^o., 5 Ch. 118 - Farley, /■■> imrtf, 1 M. 1). Jt De G. 683 Farmer v. Pitt, (1902) 1 Ch. 934 ; 50 W. U. 43:{ ; 71 I.. .1, 655, 638 - 3.>8 - 1125 - 1448 - 1186 Ch. 5(H) -1185, 1186, 1217 - 98 (i. li. Fanner c. Scottish American Co., (1912^ A. C. US - Farmer & Co. -•. Inland Revenue, (189S)2 H. li. 141 : 67 L.J. 773: 79 I.. T. 32 Fai-nham Flint, &c. Co. v. Famham L'uiou, (1901) 1 U. B. 272; 16 T. L. B. 199 - Faruham v. MilwarJ, (1895) 2 Ch. 735 . . . - Farrar v. Farrars, 40 C. 1>. 395: 58 1.. .1. Ch. 183: 60 I.. T. 121 : 37 W. R. 196 Farrer <•. liary, llHrtland ^ C..., 25 C, Tl. K.W Faure Accumulator Co., 40 U. D. 141 ; 58 L. J. Ch. l.S: 59 L. T. 91S; ;17 W. R. 118; 1 Meg. 99 - 30, 277, 466, 587, 672, 712. 7S» - 340 106 680 29 !217 •if ■; ! iTi TABLE OF CASES. !W, J I H '••—For PAOE Paure Accumulator Co. r. Phillipart, 38 L. T. o24 - «34, HSB, 661, 728, 740, 744, 1342 Federal Supply and Cold Storage r. AugeMen, 103 U T. 150 - 442 Felix Uadley & Co. v. Hadley, 77 f.. T. 136; (1898) 2 Ch. 680 - 42, 62, 135, ;M7, 948 Pell f. Ooslin, 7 Ex. 185 - - - - - - 1243 Penwick v. Schmalz, L. R. 3 C. P. 313 - - - - 601 Fenwick, Stobart & Co., (1902) 1 Ch. 507; 71 U. J. Ch. 321 ; 86 I,. T. 193 ----- - 142, 759, lOil Furguson r. WUflon (1866), 2 Ch. 77; 15 \V. E. 27 - 29, 36, 57, 710, 711, 723, 789, 1351 Forgusson c. Pyffe, 8 C. & F. 121 - - - - -1193 Fernandez's Executora, 5 Ch. 314 . . - - . 678 Fielding and Bimington's Case, 2 Ch. 714 - - - 477,1113 Filby V. Hounsell, (1896) 2 Ch. 737 - - . . ,335 Finance and Issue, T^imitod v. Canadian Produce Coi'pDration, (1!)05) 1 Ch. 3; ; 73 L. J. Ch. 751 ; 91 L. T. 685; 53 W. R. 170 - 11, 18 Financial Corporation, 27 S. J. 199 - - - - 1337 Financial Corporation, In re (Ooodson's Claim), 28 W. R. 760; W.N. (1880)88 - - . . 467,507,314,787 Pinck V. Tranter, (1905) 1 K. B. 427 ; 92 I. T. 297 ; 74 L. .1. K. H. 345 ----.-. . 1186 Firbank's Executors v. Humphreys, 18 Q. B. i). 54 ; 5C I,. .1. Q. B. 57 ; 56 L. T. 36 ; 35 W. R. 92 - - .iSS, 687, 710, 711, 741, 1141, 1199 Finnstone's Case, 20 Eq. 524 ; 23 W. K. 867 ; 44 I-. J. Ch. 617 - 484 Fisher's Case, 31 C. D. 120; 36 L. J. Ch. 497, 597; 53 L. T. 832; 34 W. E. 49, 335 55, ^57 Fisher i-. Block and White Publishing Co., (1901) 1 Ch. 174; 70 L. J. Ch. 175; 84 L. T. 305; 49 W. R. 310; 8 Mans. 184 (C. A.) - - - - (M3, 76c, 766, 790. 814. 866, 871 Fisher r. Hull and Barnsley Rail. Co., 25 S. J. 353 - - 871 FitzGeorge, In re, (1905) 1 K. B. 462 - - - - 1250 Fitzgerald, He, (1903) 1 K. B. 462 - - - - . 1250 Fitzgerald's Trustee v. MoUersh, (1892) 1 Ch. 385 ; 61 L. J. Ch. 231 ; 66L. T. 178; 40W. R. 251 1193 Fitzroy Bessemer Co., He, 32 W. R. 475; 32 W. R. 312; 60 U T. 154 - - ... - 141, 144^ 1401 Flatau I'. Cullen, 81 J^. T. 402; W. N. (1899) 206; 48 W. R. :t6 (C. A.) 1341 Fleetwood Estate Co., W. N. (1897) 20 - - - 1311,1313 Fleming r. Bank of New Zealand, (1900) A. C. 577 - 644, 741, 1180 Fletcher v. Oalland, 90 L. T. Notes, 278 - - - - 313 Flitcroft's Case, 21 C. D. 519 ; 31 W. R. 174 ; 48 I,. T. 86 ; 52 L. J. Ch. 217 - - 27, 28. 30, 150, 463, 712, 714, 715, 766, 860, 871, 872, 873, 1311, 1313, 1356 Floating Dock of St. Thomas, (1893) 1 Ch. 691 - 389, 1120, 1269 Florence Ijind and Public Works Co., limited, 10 C. I). 330- 27 W. R. 236; 39L. T. 589; 48L. J. Ch. 137 - 401,616,1180 Forbes' ("aae, SCh. 7aH; 42 1.. .1. Ch. S57 (C. A.) - - - 476 Forbea and Judd's Case, He Heyford Ironworks Co., 5 Ch. 273; 39 L. J. Ch. 422 ; 22 1.. T. N. S. 187 ; 18 W. R. 302 - - 61 TABLE OF CA8E8. Ivii Tor-Fri '*" Forbos V. Jackson, 1» C. D. 615 ; 51 1-. J. Ch. 690 ; 48 L. T. 722 : ;» W. R. 632 1^47 Fonler .-. Handyside. 1 Ex. D. 233 ; 43 T-. J. Ex. 809 ; 35 L. T. 62 ; 24 W. E. 764 100 Fore Street Warehouse Co., 39 L. T. 214; W. N. (1888) 155; 1 Meg. 67 .... - 1118, 1257, 1306 Foreim and Col. 4c. Co., (1891) 2 Ch. .395 ; 63 1.. T. 78 ; 39 W. K. 699 1311, 1312 ForcHt of Dean, &c. Co., limited (1879). 10 C. I). 430: 27 W. R. 594 ; 40 L. T. 287 . - - - 712,713,714,789 Forrest B. Manchester Rail. Co., 30 IJcav. 40 - - 4f«8 Fo9» >: Hurbottle. 2 \ldv>\ 461 - 74, 75, 633, l3io, 1357. 13J3, I.T/i 1360 Foster i: JJorax Co., (1901) 1 Ch. 326; 70 1,. J. Ch. lt>2: 83 L. T. 638; 49W. E. 212(C. A.) - - - - 457,1447 Foster r. Coles, 22 T. L. R. 555 - - - - - 813 Foster i'. Inland Revenue Commissioners, (1894) 1 Q. li. 516; 6.3 L. J. Q. ]{. 173; 69 L. T. 817 ; 42 W. R. 259 : 58 J. P. 444 ; 9 R. 161 (C. A.) 27, 29, 939, 956 Foster v. IJTerpool Athenaeum, 97 L. T. 692 - - - 106 Foster i-. L. C. &, D. Rail., (1895) 1 Q. 15. 711 - - - 467 Poster ('. New Trinidad Lake Aaphalte Co., (1901) 1 Ch. 2!is; 70 I.. J. Ch. 123 ; 49 W. H. 119 ; 8 Mans. 47 - 286, 765, 706, 865, 871, 873, 880, 88!». 896 Foster c Pontoons and Drj' Dock Co., 9 T. L. R. 450; (i3 I.. J. Q. H. 50 - - - - - - - 674 Fothergill's Case, 8 Ch. 282 ; 21 W. R. 301 ; 27 L. T. 124 ; 42 L. J. Ch. 481 484 Foulkes V. Quartz HiU Co. (1884), 1 C. & E. 136; Em. Dig. 1884, p. 102 201 Fowler v. Uroad's Patent, &c. Co., (1893) 1 Ch. 724 ; 62 L. J. Ch. 373 ; 68 L. T. 576 ; 41 W. E. 247 ; 3 H. 293 - - 649, 689 Fox's Case, 6 Ch. 183 ; 24 L. T. 336 ; 40 L. J. Ch. 433 - 75, 786, 1335, 1444, 1445, 1448, 1451, 1486. 1487 Foxton V. Manchester, 4c. Bank, 44 L. T. N. S. 406 - - 1192 Frames v. Uultfontein Mining Co., (1891) 1 Ch. 140; 60 L. J. Ch. 99 ; 64 L. T. 12 ; 39 W. R. 134 ; 2 Meg. 374 - - 432, 723 France v. Clark, 26 C. D. 257 ; 32 W. R. 466 ; 50 L. T. 1 ; 53 L. .». Ch. 515 - . . - . 652, 669, 670, 70K, 1142 Frankenburg v. Great Horseless Carriage Co., (1900) 1 Q. B. 504 ; 69 L. J. Q. B. 147 ; 81 L. T. 684 ; 7 Mans. 347 (C. A.) - 222, 1.346. 1348 Frank MiUs Mining Co., 23 C. D. 32, 56 - - - 7t>, 878 Frasor r. Whallcy, 2 H. & M. 10 - - - - 655, 1408 Frazer v. Jordan, 26 L. J. Q. B. 288 ; 8 El. & Bl. 303 - - 1247 Freehold Land Co. i: Spargo, W. N. (1868) 94 - - - 1418 Freehold Land Co. f. Suffleld, (1897) 2 Ch. 608 - - - 83 Freeman v. Appleyard, 32 L. J. Ex. 173 - - - - 1207 Freeman v. Cooke, 2 Ex. 654 ; 6 D. 4 L. 187 ; 18 L. J. Kx. 114 - 1140 Freeman v. Fairlie, 3 Nev. 40 - - - - - 771 Freeman v. Green, 1 J. & W. 133 ----- 771 Freeman v. Pope, 5 Ch. 338 ----- 1364 Fftiweu Co., /?r, 60 L. T. 953 ----- (579 Friend v. Young, (1897) 2 Ch. 421 ; 66 L. J. Ch. 737 ; 77 L. T. 50; 46 W. R. 139 - - - - - - - 1190 Iviii TABLE OK CA8E8. 71 I,. J. C'h. 433: 86 L. T !»3; a» L. J. C. 1'. «3; 19 Vri— Oen Frith f. Frith, (IWW) A. C. I'M : 94 L. T. 383; 34 W. B. 618 Frost (S.) & Co., (1899) 2 Ch. 207 ; ti8 L. .1. Ch. i44 : 80 L. T 48 W. U. 39 (0. A.) Fryer v. Ewort, (1902) A. ('. 187 ,H. L., K.) - Fuontes r. Montie. L. R. 4 ('. P 3M: 17 W. K. 20N .... FuUor r. McMahon, (1900) 1 Ch. 173 FuUrr v. Whito Feather Reward, ;iOOti) 1 Ch. S23 22 T. L. R. 4(K) - - Fullerton <■. I'rovincml Itank of Irolanil, (1903) A. C. 309 ; 72 1'. C. 79; 89 L. T. 79 (U. L., 1.) - - . Fumi'KK Rail. r. C(>miiiis»iiinprs, 33 L. .1. Ex. 173 - Fumival r. Ciiombcs, 5 U. & Or. 73t> ; (i Sc. N. R C. r. 2fi.i ; 7 .liir. 3911 - - .. . PAOE tlA8 849; . 242 L. T. 9.-. I,. T. 101 ; 1437 I,. .1. . o22; 12 L. .1. 1458 1211 679 14.i8 1181 070 328 Oadd .-. llouphton, I Kx. I>. 357 ; 24 W. R. 875; 35 L. T. 222 ; 4(i li. J. Ex. 71 - 334,711 Galloway r. Hchill, .Sobohni Ji Co., W. N. (1912) 131 - - fi24 Gallsworthy -•. Si'lby I»ain Commissioners, (1892) 1 U- H. 348; «1 L. J. (i. li. 372; 66 1,. T. 17: 8T. I,. R. 60 . - - 37 Gaudy c. Gandy, .30 C. I). 57; :13 \V. R. 803; 53 L, T. 306; ,J4 1,. .T. Ch. 1154 - - - - - 149, 323 Garden Gully, &o. Co. r. Mc Lister, 1 App. ( as. 39 ; 24 W. R. 744 ; So L. T. 408 - - - - - 6.')4, 058, fi»H), 73(» Gardner - , Indalo, (1912) 1 Ch. 700 [«. 265 - - . - - - TOS Gatling Gan Co., «-, 43 C. 1).«28: 59 L. .f. Ch. 279; 62L.T. 312: 38 W. R. 317; 2 Meg. 114 - - - - -1119 Oaussen . . Morton, 10 H. & C. 731 - - - - - 292 Oelly Deg Colliery I o., 38 L. T. 440 . - - - ;{64 General Accident Asaurnnce Corporation /■. McGowan, (1908) A. C. 207 ; 9S L. T. 734 ; 24 T. L. R. 533 (H. L.) - - - 101 General Accident Amuranco Corporation r. Webster, (1902) 1 K. H. 377 ; 71 L. J. K. H. 2;{6; 86 L. T. 355 : 50 W. R. 381 - - 330 General Accident Assurance Corporation, (1904) 1 Ch. 147 ; 73 L. .1. Ch. .W7 ; 52 W. U. fi02 - - - - - - 112 General Auction, &r. Co. i-. Smith, (1891) 3 Ch. 432 - 467, 473, 509 General Hank, 17 W. R. 3(M - - - - - 1293 General Mill Posting Co. r. Atkinson, (1908) 1 Ch. 537 - - 359 TABLE OF L'AU£S. lis 0«n-01e '•»<»* Ooniral ( riHlit Co., W. N (IN«1) 133; (1002) :! (I tiOl - 12«;f, l^H UommlEHtatoKCo., //<>, ;M"h. 76a ----- ■'•lO (K'ucral Kxi'hanK<' Hunk, I'rtvton'i* Cueo. 4 K'.' IliOiV :,H9 4ii L. T, Opuoriil KxchiinRu Itank, I.. If. « «^h. 81h - Oeiicrul Inilustritw Duvelopmont Syndicatf, W. N. (11HI7) 211 Uiiitnil l'hoH|.hat« Co. c. IIorrockH, N T. I-. K. a.V) - OiMierul I'ropoitv Co. -■. Miithosou's TrustT. 1.. 1{. 24- 125 (iilbtif-s Ca.si;, 3 Ch. 339; 18 W. R. 9;t8; 23 L. T. 341 ; 39 L. J. 463 199 334 743. 7.j» 327: 470, t>(M) - 787 - 22ti 20«> - 1 197 i3 li. T. 330 : 509, 686 724. 747 - 190 - 496 - 1195 - 1216 - 100 Ch. 837 - - - 603, 654, 655, 037, 665, 7 Uill>er» .-. Endean, 9 C. D. 260 ; 27 W. R. 232 ; 39 L. T. 404 Oikhrist, (1893) ICh. 367 - - - - - Giles r. I'likins, 9 East, 14 - Gill i: Downing, 17 Eq. 317 - GiUatM and Wutts -■. Colquhoun, 33 W. R. 238 GiUetipie c. .Vlexander, 2 Ruas. C. C. 136 - Gillingham .•. Bi^ddow, (1900)2 Ch. 242 ; 69 J,. J.Ch.527 ; 82 L. T. 791 ; (H J. P. 617 - GUmanV (^asc, 31 C. D. 420 GIamorgan.-.hiro Canal Co. v. Merthyr Tydtil Union, 89 I,. T. 85 - Glamorganshire Quarter SesBions r. Wilson, (1910) 1 K. B. 723 Olaagow V. Independent Printing C.i., (1901) 2 I. R. 278 - Glasier <•. Rollr., 42 C. D. 436; 38 L. J. Ch. 820; 62 L. T. 133; 38 W. R. 113 - - - - - 1**. 191. 203. ^'l Glenton and Saunder«, lie. 53 1.. T. 434 (C. A.) - - - 352 679 ;{37 485 106 102 1020 TABLE or CA8E8. V. Olo— Or» Olory Paper MiU« Co. (Uun«tcr> Case), (I8W) 3 (."h. 473 : 63 L. J. Ch. HS3 ; 7t L. T. 528 ; 4d W. R. 164 ; I Muiaon, 438 ; 7 H. MM iA» (C. A.) OlOHSOp I 610 16N, 721 tllodsop, (19<>7) 2 Ch. TO: 97 I.. T. 372; 76 I,. J. Ch. 24 38 Ulouccstcr Municipal Election Petition, (19U1) 1 U. U. 683 • Glover r. Giles, 18 C. D. 180; 80 I,. J. Ch. 368; 43 K T. 344 ; 29 W. H. 603 - . - . - . . ia GluckBtein r. l»ame«, (IflOO) A. C. a40; 69 I,. .J. Ch. 38.-» ; 82 ]» T. 393; 7 Muni. 321 (H. L, E.) - 131, 132, 134. 135, 136, 138, 141. 112, 143, 144, 150, 174, 192, 241, 645, 839 Godfrey v. Watson, 3 Atk. 517 - Ooert ACo. V. BelH1904)2K. It. l;«; 73 i-. J. K. U. 448; 90 1, 675 ; 53 W. B. 64 Gold Co., He, 11 C. D. 719 - Gold Hill C V 03 C. D. 210 ; 31 W. B. 853; 49 L. T. 66 - Gold Om» ,1 luction Co. ••. Parr, (1892) 2 Q. B. 14 ; 61 L. J. Q, 522 ; 66 U T. 687 ; 40 W. R. 526 - - - . Oover's Case, 1 C. D. 182: 24 W. R. 123; oJ i.. T. 619; 45 L. J. tTi. S3 - - - - - 132, 142, 193, 227, 229 Goremment Stock, 4c. C«. v. Manila Rail. Co., (1897) A. 0. 81 ; 66 li. J. Ch. 102 ; 75 L. T. 553 ; 43 W. R. 353 (II. L., E.) - 616, 718 Government Stock Investment Co. (No. 2), (1892) 1 Ch. 597 ; 61 L. J. Ch. 381; 66L. T. 608; 40W. B. 3K7 - - - -1313 Gower v. Couldridge, (1898) 1 Q. W. 348 - - - 1348, 1349 Graff V. Evans, 8 Q. B. D. 373; 51 I,. J. M. C. 25; 46 L. T. 347; 30 W. R. 380; 46 J. P. 262 - - - - - 367 Graham f. Van Dieman's l,and Co., 26 L. J. Ex. 73 ; 1 H. & N. ^'1 638,692 Grai'ger u. Aynsley. 6 U. U. D. 832 - - - . io21 Grainger c. Gough, (1896) A. C. .325 - . . 94,119 Gramophone and Typewriter v. Stanley, (1908) 2 K. B. 89; 99 L. T. 39; 24T. L.B. 480 - . . . 75,96,736,747 Granite Supply Association v. Inland Revenue, 8 F. 55 (Ct. of Sesa.) 101 - 1216 T. - 93 26, 1099 - 1411 II. - l:t42 - 1361 :, 934 672 467 1447 672 1149 335 358 361 200 593 658 771 34» «L*^^ TABLE or CA8BH. Ixt Or*^ Or* '*»• Qnat V. Gold Explown., 4c. Syndicate. (1900) 1 U- B. 233 ; «0 L. J. Q. Jl. 180; 82UT. 4: 48 \V. B. 280(0. A.) - 134, Ul. 733, UOtI Oimnt V. iMugton, (1900) A. C. 383 10* Or«nt V. United Switchb«:k Rail., 40 C. D. 134; 38 U J. Ch. 211 ; 37 W. H. 318 ; 80 L. T. 524 : 1 Mag. 1 17 - 37, 74, 447, 411. H02, 6iH, 711, 732, 741, 1048, I04H, 1100, UJ4 Oruy I. Ford. (1896) A. 0. 44 . . . - - Grey V. .lohnson, I-. R. 3 II. L. 1 - Oray v. l^wit, H Ph. 1040: 21 W. U. 923: 29 L. T. 12: 43 L. .1. rh. 281- .... 2!l, 141, 040, 1344, (Jray •■. Poareon, 6 II. L. C. Itm - - - - 4»4 Oray r. Stone and FunnoU, 89 L. T. 282; W. N. (1893) 133: 3 R. «i)2 ------- fire.it Hritain Mutual. 20 r. D. 341 ; .«) W. R. 374; 46 1,. T. 816; 41 L. J. Ch. 7, 406; 1« C. D. 246; 19 C". D. 39 - (iroat Eastern Rail. Co. v. Turner, 8 Ch. 142; 21 W. R. 163: 27 1,. T. 697 ; 42 I.. J. Ch. 83 - - 27. 484. 711. 712, Great Northern Salt, 44 C. D. 472 ; 49 L. J. Ch. 288 ; 62 L. T. 231 ; 2 Meg. 48 - - - - 717. 734. 742. 744, 744 (ireat North-We»t Central Rail. -•. Charlcbois, (1899) A. C. 114: 68 L. J. P. C. 24 : 79 I,. T. 34 (P. C.) - - - 30. 42 Oreut Western Rail, i: Rushout, 4 Do O. & S. 290 - Oroiit WeBtern Steamship Co., 34 W. R. 144 Great Wheal PolKoe O. M. & G. 449 - . - Oreon-.v(,od r. Frane.is, (1899) 1 (*. B. 312: 68 L. .1. U. H. 228 ; 7S» 1 r. 624 ; 47 W. U. 230 (C. A.) ... - Grwmwood r. Humber & Co. (Portugal), W. N. (1898) 162 - 207 Greenwood v. Leather Shod WTieel Co., (1900) 1 Ch. 421 ; SI L. T. 494 : 69 L. .1. Ch. 131 ; 7 Mans. 21(» (C. A.) - 174, 192, 214, 227, 230 Gregory i . Patchott. 33 Beav. 394 - Oregson, Itt, (1893) 3 Ch. 233 ; li2 I.. J. Ch. 764 ; 69 1,. T. 73 ; 41 W. R. 641 (0. A.) Greshain Life, Re, 8 Ch. 449; 42 L. J. Ch. 183; 2N L. T. 140; 21 W. R. 186 - - - - - - 737 Gresham life Assurance Co. v. Bishop. (1901) 1 Q. B. 143; 70 !,. J. Q. n. 298 ; r.;l L. T. 654 ; 65 J. P. 1 (C. A.) ; (1902) A. C. -'a? - Greaham lifo Soe. -•. Styles, (1892) A. C. 309; 62 L. J. Q. I!. 41 ; 67 L. T. 479 ; 41 W. B. 270 ; 46 J. P. 709 - - 97. 98- r.HO 1192 134K . .W7 - 6«^f - 1331 1346 746 , 2«3 412 1283 126 1204 38 1362 441 1247 IS, 734 - 46(i 91. -t 1247 222 216, , 232 H9S 668 .747 101 Ixu lARLK ly PASEf. tl Orejrmouth Point, v.'. f'o,, (liuki; | eh. i^i : T.J I., i I'h. M VMS T;i. 740. 74t, 7»-- T. "143. > • triffltl.. Hj jKtrU. I:- Wilkinwm, .';! r. i. «» ( Tiffitii ,■. Pnm-t, j 1. j I sfM «i i ■. I), | ; gs W. \^ .'.I'S • Ul : 4« I- .1. Ch. »i».i - Ttl, 7s J.I, i:«», JtW. 7H«, : ■ WH, l,4t. Ifti, 1 ita. US;:. I47<5. I y t» (< I;. ]' '-iT; ,," : ?, Q, Jt. .M.i; 47 I,. T. 10; :«» \v. l; 7!(; «<; i. i'. i .1 jojl' Orilfith lycleCorp. f. Ul; j«r. (iNi*** l" I!. 41« >1 T. aiu W I.. J.Q. 1). aw . . 330 Grill I-. Oon-ral. i . Co., . i;. 1 (' ,•!; j, I,. U. ;JC. '. 476; :W !,. J. 1 . P. 324 . , ' . ^ ;,;, •irimwailo, f^x jKir- /f^ Tonnont. 17 j. I! 1). . ^ - . i;{67 Oniirtley, /ff, Clews 'IriniUcj-, Ih'JW) . t 'h. . "^i.i • ;» |,. T 10-5 • 47\V. K.53 . ' ;,5. 1402 Ori-««U -i Cane, 1 Ch. .>2« . i ' , K. 101.5 : U i X. «4 : 3i I-. J. Oh. 7i2 - - . ... Ml Oroven .. Wimbonii , (1 tH) 2 li. li. i 'i i f, r. 2H4 47 \V. H. H7 Oiiiiidy r HrigifM. I'JIO} 1 i h. 444 - Uuardiui: ir« 4 Li!=' Aiwiranco Co. v. ftiattitan >' Qr ..mv ,.. \A T r. 781: •,. I.. J. Ch. im;! uudiaiin of M. i.,-<.ii-irds . i'mTiklin. 31' r. !). 377 * saenwo >■ -- do. :( H. & Ad. ' - ■uest. K' Wr!^ ' '< r. ' /uinii"H-i Tr.i irk, ijuimwitw r. i aid Corj* ition 1 7«, 2(i4 lUH, 721 Inaur- - 4W 44 - 1157 101, 117 346 341; 47 T. -'7: .1. ;. i,19\' I K. I!. 713 - p. Pat I i< ,18 Inland. L"' < . U. 34!' , :11 W. 1{. i '7 7''. M», 476, 482. 59., li i TM. N61, 871, 873 - 31 - 1207 - 713 21 L. T I -Hi; 3s L. .1, - (172 mg (1822), o H. & .\ld. <,28 - . . nui liros., 24T. T,. H. 515 - - . 675,1143 Oiivot ' Hi. .,u, (1894) .'! I'h. 388; 64 I,. J. Ch. .'ii ; 71 U T. .!81 ; as I,. T ' • rtmn '•. lk)lckow. \ tiighan & ( f'Mrn.' A: Co. i, (Ml, 5 H. I,. 4N(1 •Oa !ai. !t Caw. 8 Eq. 438; 17 W. K Ch. 610 . Blackburn. 17 r. II. N. S. «7'. - BttUet* Rt, ,' I- /»/)■(• N'atiimul Iniiuraiice I'or^ H.-iUidu •. a. is!«t- ;i I a»9 llailmaiiHCaw 9 ' I ,-'9 H»ll.ivn> Foruw. 3 h. 177 ; 10 W. li. h7;) •'h, Jfl7 - . . . H IUini/n> >•. Bim, iin'!< i^in: .mU .ibb, H (h. 54H - IfiiM, Hrogii, .v. (INOl) .W; <;0l rnii. &c. Co.. (ls!»4) . Ct \V. I!. 12« 1. \ F. Ut!» ' ... ,•. Taliik.T lUntillery, (1^94) A. i. :'' .>40 (H. L.. Sc.) iVixkI. (1N91> 2Q. It. I'^H; m I„ ,1. n. n. T.i4: lij ],. T. W, R. 24 112 I4. T. «0H - . . . . 1(1 Co., (1806) 2 Ch. 747 : (;-J L. J. Ch. HttO; 7.'. L. T. •. R. 136 - - 1 1-', (W«i, 692 69ti, 710, 77H, 1051 , neo'n Patent Caii.llo Co., ir> L. .1. Ch. 437 ; 34 L. T. fJl , -^t W. R. 754 - 7o. t4«i, ,JOM, «H6, 6S8, 747, 765, 1023 lamptot Urban Council /■. S itliwarK and Vauxhall Water Co., (19(Hr A. C. 3; 16 T. L. 1!. 60; ffli I,. J. Q. H. 72; >*! L. T. .)47 ; 4N W. R. 2(KI : 64 .(. 1'. 260 II L., E.) - llunu.i .-. Ehrlich, (1911) 2 K. B. IO06 ... - Ilanlmry '. Cumly, .J8 L. T. 135 ----- il iiinan'H Empress, fit . 1 'o., A,> imrU Curmiehael, (ISWl) 2 Ch 65 I.. .1. Ch. MO- , 7) L. T . 45 - llauimn%. Km\r, &. . Co . 14 T. L. It. .iM - - - Uan ins I^akf Xinw ('«iitT!l <-. Annstrnni;, 16 T. 1,. E. i; ' llarlx-n r. I'hiUips. 23 C. I". 14; ;l ''.V. l!. 173; IS I,. T 633. 705, 7'. :40, 744, l;556, 1357. llurbur^- India Rubber Co. i-. Martin, (1902) 1 K. V. 11^ K. li. 529 ; N6 1.. T. ..'■); 5(1 W. R. 449 (C. A.) lUidoon V. Belilios, 1!K)1 A. ''. 118; 70 L. J. P. C. 'j 573 ; 4r> W. H. 209 V. C.) - 63, 323, 652, 661 llarc'.- Case, 4 Ct.. 563 : 17 \V. R. 62S : 20 L. T. 157 llan.Tt;aVfx (.loseph), Limited. (1900) 2 < h. 347 iliirsrov... A> fiarle. ' Ch. 12: 23 W. Ij. ;:;)»; ;12 I.. T. T. L. .1. Ch. 569 - - - - Harman'g Ciino, If.!' .•)26 ; l.i I,, .i . ( h. :)32 ; .ii I,. T. 760 Uan. tn <■. Ain^lw, ^194H) 1 K. '■ «1«n : 7.( I-. .1. !\. li. mm : 90 T,. T. ti24 ; 32 \V. R. 613 - 'i:tt&irf '■. '■'OHi---:-. O '". H. N --. 2-'-- - - . - Harper -■. (}od»oll, 5 U. B. 422 . 39 L. .J H. B. 1N5 ; l.S W. U. 934 - Harper r. I'upet --.... Harrington ■. Victv.na Dmk, ii 1, H. 1>. .V19 - - 733, I OH 441 :i58 MM :,-'!) Ixiv TABLE OF CA8Ba. Ch. 687 ; 20 \V. B. 690 : -'6 h. T. 781 Ill 41 L. J. Ch. 52, 258, 739 27 I,, .i. »1i. 874, 44 1,. .1. (12 I.. .I.U. H.75; ti7 I-. T. Har— Hem Harris' Case 621 - Harris .-. Fawcett, « Ch. 866 Harris r. IrTinn Corporation. W. N. (1901) 18 - - " Harris ». North Devon Rail. Co., 20 Beav. 384 Harri:*on, A> /-ar^, 26 ('. I). 522 - " ■ ' ' Harrison, Ainsleo 4 Co. v. Morrow-in-Furnosf Corp., 63 L. T. Hi - Harrison v. Mexican Rail. Co.. 19 Vai- 358; 23 W. R. 403; 32 I.. T. 82 ; 44 h. J. Ch. 403 - - - - 480. 575. 637, Harrogate Estates, Limited, (1903) 1 Ch. 4"^ • : 72 L. J. Ch. 313 : 88 I,. T. 82 : 31 W. R. 334 - - - - ' Harrow .-. Plnntv, a901) 2 Ch. 314 ; 70 I,. .I.Ch. ^{2 : 83 I,. T. 45; 4'.» W. R. 646 - Hart V. Clarke. 6 H. I.. Cas. 633 ; 32 L. T. O. S. 380: 2 613 ----- ■ Hart 1-. Frontino Co., L. R. 5 Ex. 11 1 Hartf. Hart, 18 C. D. 683 - - - - Hartley's Case, 10 Ch. 137 ; 23 W. R. 203 : 32 I.. T. IW Ci. 240 Ilarrey, fcV piirtr, 4 !>. M. & O. 801 Harvey l*wi«" Cii8«>, 26 1,. T. 673 - Hastings r. Po-irson. (1893) 1 (i. «. 62 5.>3; 41 W. E. 127 - - - " Hatfield f. Phillips, 9 M. & W. 047 - Hattersley f. Shelbume, 10 W. R. 881 Haven Gold Co.. 20 C. D. 181 ; :«) W. R. 389 : 46 I.. T I,. J. Ch. 242 Hawke .-. Hulton, (1909) 2 K. H. 93; W. N. ;1909) 88 Hawkes, Ackern.an r. IxM'khart, (1898) 2 Ch. 1 : 67 1.. 78 !,. T. 336 ; 46 W. R. 443 (C. A.) - Hawkos i>. Eastcni Counties Rail. Co., •'> II. l- C. 331 : 609; 24 U J. (Ti. «i01 - - " " Hawkins r. Rutt, Prake, 186: U«ke, 897 - Httwk^l.v V. Outram, (1892) 3 Ch. 3.)9 : 02 I,. •(. < h. 213 804 (C. A.), reversinR 61 I,. J. Ch. 429 : tMi I.. T. 763 - Hay'H Case, 10 Ch. 593. 604 : 33 1.. T. 4»i« : 14 1.. J. Ch. 721 Haycralt Oold Reduction and Mining Co., (1900)2 Ch. 2:«); I, J Ch 497 ; 83 I.. T. 180; 7 Mann. 243 - 30, 691 Haynes r. Uomau. (1899) 2 Ch. 13: 68 L. J. Ch. 419; 80 I,. T. 369 (C. A.) - - - - - ■ Heap I'. Hartley, 42 C. D W. R. 136 Heather, ll>; (19<«i) 2 Ch. 2:K); 93 I,. T. 332 : 75 I.. J. Ch. .568 - Hebbs Cas.., 4 F.,. 9 ; 36 I.. J. 11.. 748: 16 1.. T. X. S. 3(« : 13 W. R. 7.-)4 - ■"'• '^ Ueffleld i: Meadows, !.. R. 4 C P. 593 - - - * Helby'B Case, 2 Eq. 173; 14 W. R. 417 ; 14 I,. T. 47 Helby .•. Matthews, (1893) A. C. 471 ; 64 L. .1. U. B. 465 ; 72 K T. sm : 43 W. n. 361 Hehnore r. Smith (No. 2), 33 C. D. 449 - - - - Hemans r. Hotchkis. Onlnance Co., (1899) 1 Ch. 113 ; 68 I,. J. Ch 90 ; 79 I.. T. 681 : 47 W. R. 276 : 6 Maus. 32 TkOm ,743 1246 103 650 679 335 1106 617 1186 658 1140 :H9 s 1247 723 1206 1212 1339 322: 31 469, 600, •I.Ch. 284: 3 W. R. 431 67 1,. T. 69 740 , 461 ; 38 I.. .1. Ch. 790; 61 I,. T. 3:i.s : 38 700 44 771 ;io 770 11. >8 722 , 744 :»57 381 769 , 290 1246 878 1212 442 - 68.> TABLK OK CASES. IXT H*in— Hig TlomininK i-. Miiddick, 7 Ch. :W'i - - - - ••' Homl.rBoirsNijrelCo., 103 t.. T. H70 - - - H<^ llenileiH,.!. r. Ajlwiir.1, (liHW) A. C. ir.:i - - - - Henderwm '•. Hunk of Austmla^ia (PoiiRi.m Tnsp). 40 P. P. 170; 5H L. .1. th. Iit7 : Jit I.. T. So(i; :»7 W. U. liM - -46., uOs. II.iulers„ii , . lt«nk of Auntrulia, 45 ('. 1». .WO ; 59 L. J. Oh. 794 : \! iivSi.Mn ••"-• II..„dor«.n ,-. I^con. r, E.,. 249 : 1.! W. B. :.2«: '',1;; T^;»;,., ,J,. ilen.Iiick. .-. Montagu, 17 C I>. ;«,7, Harrison;, 09 1.. T. iM - 48. Henn- Clay ami lUxk & .<. 81.j. Ilontlion. -•. Kn.^r, (1892) 2 Ch. 27; 01 I.. J. Ch :t7:»j «•;••• T. 4.19; 40 \V. K. 4:W - - " <«■ "-• -'•"• -•»^- ''*"• llwhort <1»M Co. ,: lluycraft, C. A., 27 March. 1!M»1 ; Timt.-, 28 March. liH)l ------ '•^"' Hcrb.'rt r. Suliohiiry, vtc. Co., 2 K<\. 221 - lU-rcyni-i < opper Co. (Hithard»ou'» C.!^), (1894) 2 Ch. 4(>3 ; 03 I.. .1. Ch. 507 ; 7(» 1.. T. 7(« ; 42 W. B. 593; 1 Maim. 286 ; . R. 214 (c. A.; Iler.liii.m c. WliooW. (liK)2) 1 K. H. .Mil ; 7« I- J. K. 15. 2.0; 86 I.. T. 48; .iO W. H. .100 - - - - - norefor.1, &c. Wagp.n Co.. AV, 2 C Div. 021 ; 24 W. B. 9.V1 ; :I5 1,. T. 40; 45 I,. .1. Ch. 401 - - - - '^'*' llcrewar,! (The), (1895^ 1'. 284 : M I... I. 1'. 87 ; 72 1..T. 90;); 11 K. 798 •^'*' lleritiifTP's Cane, 9 Kq. 5 ------ llnrt'HCase, 1 C. 1>. :t07 ------ Herts and Kone.x Wat.rwork.- ( o., W. N. (19(»9) 45 - Hesketh r. Bray, 21 Q. U. 1». 444 - Hester & Co., Kr. 44 U J. (N. S.) Ch. 757 - 1439. 1441, 1445 HetlinR and MertonR < ontract. (1893) 3 Ch. 209 ; 62 L. .1. Ch. -83 ; 69 I.. T. 200; 42 W. R. 19 - - - " - Hewai'd V. Heatlev, 3 I»o O. M. * C. 028 - - - - Hewlett .•. Allen, (IW"') A. C. 383 ; 02 I.. .1. U- H. 008 ; 71 I.. T. 94 ; 42 W. R. 670 : 58 ,1. P. 7tK> . H. 175 (H. 1..) - lleyl-ltiae. l-MmundH.\V,N. (1899)222 - lieymau r. Kuropean Central Co., 7 &(. 154 Hibblewhito i . McMorine, 6 M. & \V. 2(K) - HiKpi"*'. f<»tt, 2 n. & Ad. 413 - - - - HigKinson and Dean, «-. (18W») 1 U- H. 323; 68 h. J. H. H 79 L. T. 673 ; 47 W. B. 285 ; 5 Man«. 289 Highett »ud Hird's Coutract, (liHW) 1 Ch. 287 ; 72 1,. J Ch H7 I.. T. 697 ; 31 \V. B. 227 (C. A.) P. 186 652 14 ;4, 1481, 198; 112, 220; , ti52 1 (51 1217 1025 , 095 185, , 213 , 453 1191 119 292, , 294 :t46 . 814 1401 , 670 1223 723 768 8;t.8 559 57 , •>a(). »)77 llilli* WateifuU, &c. Co.. (IMUO) 1 Ch. !»47 ; •!.') L.J. Ch. 476; 74 I,. T. :i4l Hill & Co. ,. Uill, •■.J K. T. 7iii>; :i.5 W. If. 1;17 ; jl J. 1'. •J4ti Hill .-. Muiichoster, &v. Co., ."> U. & Ad. StHi lliltou f. Ikkersley, 8 - Ha iia. 117 It. fiS ; itJ 7:1:1, 11J7 Hiiii>i!>l<'y I'. I,. T. JO Hinim Maxim Ump Co., (19(»:l) 1 • h. 70 ; 7J I,. J. Ch. 18 ; 17 I-. T. 72!»; Jl W. K. 74 l^^M Himh & Co. .-. Burns, 77 ... T. :J77 (H. I,., K.) - :««i, 381, 44:J Uimhcf. HiiuH, (1M94^ A. C. 4 - - - - - 114'J Hirst .-. Wfrt HidiiiK Union Itankiii;.' Co., (liK»l) i K. B. .> i«irl>' Offiriul Kir.iver. (IWIO) 1 (J. H. 1 (C. A.) - - '00. 8Hj, 807, 870, Ui2, 12j8, 1201, 1262, VHa, 1277 Uobbx 1'. Wayit, ;lti C. 1). 256 - - - - - «"» Hob«.n 1: Ba«>, 6 Ch. 792 VHH Hobeon r.Gorring.', (1897) 1 Ch. 182 .... .343 Umkoy f. Clydesdale Bank, .36 Sc. I.. R. 120 - - - 40 H(Kk«y ,: Westtm, (1898) 1 Ch. 3oO ; 67 I.. J. Ch. 166 ; 78 I.. T. 1 ; 46 W. U. 312 (C. A.) 652 HwlgBon . . B.II, 24 Q. L' '■ ■\! 1205 Hogg f. Smith, 2 'fuunt. :'' - - - - - 1158 Holbr«M)kK, Limitcil, 18 U. .. .. I'ns. 447 - - - - 346 Holland r. Bygrave, 6 M. & . . 653 ----- 1195 Holland <•. Dickson, 37 C. D. 669 - - - - - 771 Holland K. HolUnd, 4 Ch. 449 - - . - . 770 Hollinwood Ksteto Co.. limited, W. N. (1887) 17 ; 31 H. J. 125 - 1337 Holmes' Cagp, 2 Ch. 714 - - . . . -1115 Holin.s .•. Hi(fpn«, 1 B. 4 C. 74 - - - - - 149 HolmtM -•. Newcastle. &c. Co., 1 C. 1>. 682 ; 24 W. R. 505 ; 45 I,. .1. Ch. 383 ------- 872. l:!(M) Holroyd r. Mar«hnll, 10 H. I,. C. I'll - - . -1183 Holt V. Collier, 16 C. I). 720 ----- 595 Holt' a Ca«j, 1 C. D. 307 - - - - - - 636 Hon. T District Co., 39 C. D. 546; 5S I,. J. Ch. 134; fiO li. T. 97 - .lO, 710, 741, 1311, 1389 HonK Kontr and China Uaa Co.. W.N. (1898)158; W. N. (1 899)25- 1311 Honig I. BlaikettH Min.i>, 49 S. J. 770 - - - - 511 Uuuuur i>. lUiuitablo Life, (1900) 1 Cb. 852 - - - - 1418 I'ABLE OF CAHE8. Ixvii Hoo-Hoy ""; II,kh1 & Moore's Htoros i: Joiu.-, HI I-. T. 1«!< ; -2 T. F.. U. l.".! - M> lI,K,lc ,: G. W. Kail. ••.... -.iCh. •J.il' ; 1« W. R. JH«; IT l- T. «3 T^.. i)l4. juN, HMl,J H,«,W -•. Speuk. (liMM) J fh. T:f.'; 7;t I.. J. - 070 »»1, 741). 7-II. 7Af» 8 143^ - .WT W. l: Jl„„i».r '■. KoiT. Stiiart &(',.., 45 S. .1. l:«»: h:! I.. T. 7L'n l|.K>ppi- .. We.-tern i nuntiex, \. . «'<>., 41 W. If. Hii ; tiH !,. T II,,.,iM.r ■. Willif. 94 I,. T. ti-J4 - - - - ll„p.. ,. CioTCi-m Tniii.wa.vs, (iwm} 1 Ch. :«« Jl.iiw .■. Int^niBtioiial Financial Sociotj-. 4 ''. I>. a'J7 : -' :■(•.■< ; ;i.'< F.. T. '."24 : 4« I.. J. ' '!■• -'••> - •>•■•!•. ««*>. 7MI, .ol , IJMiti .41 ! Jlopkms.. I,iw#vp.- 1-t.J . 101 li. T. H3« - - - - :J71t Hopkins' Tni«t. IN K.]. •*«: t;l L. J. fh. 722: M\ I- T. (127 : -It \V. 1!. «H7 - - - - " ' ■ '^ llopkin^on . . Rolt, ;» II. L. '■. :>\ » : :*4 L. J. rii. 4«H - ««{. .i«4. 1 Ifla Horbury liri.ip, Co., U < . D MH* : 27 W. U. 433 40 I. T jWa ; 48 Ij J rh. 341 - - - - •'*'^'- •>™'. 701. iOlC, 105<»> Ilomw y School o( Art -■. lidmaaton t 'luon. 94 1.. T. 20;i ; 4 1.. G. H. I7N; 70 J. 1'. 121 - - - - - - "^ ilorsev EHtatfi, I.ta. c. Steiger. . il«l»H i U. B. 25W: 67 L. J. d. B. "4" ' "() ITllrt - * " " ~ ' Woo Ilort's CW, /('. D. 307 ; 33 I.. 1. 7fi6 10 L. .1. (.'h. 321 - - 1329 llorton & Son c. Walsall Asscssi-.cnf t '..uiuijttee, ( 1S98) 2 (i. B. 239 ; 1(7 \.. J. (X. B. 8(H : 78 I<.'r. App. Ca^. 320; 28 W. H. 077: 42 I,. T. 1!»4 - - - - 30. 41, i(>, 203 10i> 443 70 lIouMsworth >■. Yorkshire Wooicombors, (1903J 2 Ch. 2ti4 ; 72 L. J. Ih. 035; 88 L. T. 811 (C. A.); (mM) A. C. Mo 617 Hou8.hoia Fire Inmiranco Co., lU, 4 Ex. D. 210; 27 W. B. 858j 41 L. T. 208; 48 L. J. Ex. o77 - - - o2, io., 258, i80 Hovonden & Co. c. Millhofl (1!«»0). 10 T. L. B. 500; 83 L. T. 41 (C. A.) '••'■ "''^ Uoward'8 Case, 1 Ch. 561 ; 14 W. U. 942; 14 L. T. 747 ; 30 I-. J. Ch. 42 "^^^ "•■*» liowanl c. I'atent Ivory Co., 38 C. I). 150; 57 I,. J. Ch. 878 ; 58 L. T. 395: :W W, B. 801 - - 81, 324, .10, .22, .49, ,61 llowar.1 .•. Sadler. (1893) ' U. B. 1 : •» L. T. 120: 41 W. R. 120: 5 li. 45 '2« llowbnach Coal Co. . . Toagne, ;. ll. 4 N. ISl : 29 1-. J. Ex. J3J ;_s _ W. K. "204 ----- 654, .1.. 730, .44 llovlakoUail. Co., «f, 9Ch. 297 *«» llovlo & Jackion i-. OWham Union, (1894) 2 (i. B. 372; 63 L. J. M. C. 178 ; 70 L. T. '^ll ; 58 J. 1'. 009 : 9 U. 287 - - 109 Hoylo r. Uuylc-. ;i«5':i) 1 Ch. .H4 ; 62 T.. J. Ch. 182 : 67 L. T, 074 : 41 W. B. 81 : 2 B. U.'i (C. A.) - - - 335, 336. 1184 el Ixviii TABLE OF CASES. Hub— Inc Hubbard, A'xjwrt*. 17 Q.B. D.B90 - . - . HuKgett r. Miff, 5 D. M. 4 O. 910 Uug^DS r. Tomptoir d'Ewompto, 23 Q. B. I*. S!9 . - - Hughes and Ashley's Contract. (1900) 2 Ch. 595 ; 83 L. T. 390 ; 49 W. B. «7 Hughes I'. Morris, L' De G. M. & O. 35« - Hughes i: Pump House Hotel Co. (No. 2), (HH>2) 2 K. H. 485 Uugueniu >\ Baseloy, 14 Ves. 273 - - - • - Hulkes, llf, 33 0. I). 552 Hume r. Ilentley, 5 De O. & S. 520 Hume V. Rticitl Boijm Jubilee Synd.. 80 I,. T. 404 Hume r. Uundell, 2 K. & H. 177 ; 7 U. L. C. S9 - liunniiigM I'. Williamsor, 11 li. It. I). 533 - - - - Hunt, lie, (1900) 2 Ch. 54 Hunt's Claim, W. N. (1872) .53; 20 W. R. 435 ; 26 I,. '£. 384 Hunt t: Great Northern Kailway, (1891) 1 Q. B. 601 Hutchinson's Case. (1895) 1 Ch. 226; 64 I,. J. Ch. 131: 71 I,. T. 667 : 43 W. R. 267 : 13 R. 56 - Huth r. ( larke, 63 L. T. :M8 ; 25 Q. B. 1). .litl ; 59 I.. ,1. M. C. 120 ; 59 W. R. 655 - Huttly .-. Simmons, (1898) 1 Q. H. 181 ; 67 K. J. Q. H. 213 Hutton i: Scarborough < lift. *<•. Co. ( IH65), 4 Do G. .1 . & S. (i72 ; 2 Dr. & Sm. 514 ; 13 W. B. 1059 ; 13 L. T. 87 ; ;{4 L. J. Ch. 643 : 11 .lur. N. S. .'jol - 480. 481. 4S2, ■'>75, 637, 6;J8, 639 Hutton r. Vfimt Cork Bail. Co., 23 C. l». 654 ; .V2 1-. J. Ch. 689; 49 I,. T. 420 ; 31 W. B. 827 - - 76, 4««i, 508. 1025, Hyde c. New Asbestos Co., 8 T. I,. B. 121 - Hyderabad Doccan Co. (1896), 76 L. T. 23 - Hyslop V. Morel, 7 T. I.. R. 263 PAoa 516 um KMl 350 1185 1348 1.18 142 3.'iO 110 597 728 (i67 787 1021 723 743 445 , 8I9' 102'5 192 1261 185. I. I Hfracombe Huildiug Society. (1901) 1 Ch. 102: 70 1,. .1. Ch. 66: 84 I.. T. 146 no llUngsworthr. Houldsworth. (l'.K)4) A. r. 35.-. - - - 616 lllustrao'dNewKpaperCorp., 16T. r,. R. I.'i7 - - - 441 Imperial As^urance t: Coleman, 6 Ch. 568 ; 19 \V. B. 481 ; 24 I-. T. 290; 40 1,. J. Ch. 262 ; I.. H. 6 H. I,. 190 - 173. 710, 732. 733 Imperial Bank of China. 4c. v. Bank of Hindustan, &c., 6 Eq. 91 - 1097. 1448, I486 93 100 Imperial Continental Gas Co. i: Nicholson. 37 I,. T. 717 Imperial Fire Ins. Co.. 35 L. T. 371 ... Imperial Hytlropathic Co. i'. Ilampoon, 23 C. D. 1 • 632, 633. 634, 695, 7.35. 736. 1102. 1357. U06 Imperial Inctitiite v. St. Mary Abbot. . Times. 7 March, 1895 - 108 Imperial Mercantile Credit Association, 12 Eq. 504 : 41 I.. J. Ch. 113 - - - - - 140, 1441, 1445, 1474. 1487 '.icp Hal! C.-i., fe, 3:1 C. 1). 845. n. - - - - - 478 Inohbald t>. The Wotitem Neilghirry Co., 17 C. B. N. S. V33; 13 W. B. 94; 11 I. T. 345; !« L. J. C.P. 18 - - - 44.1 Inchiquin'8(Ii0rd)C««e. (1891)3Ch. 28 - - 719,720. TABLK OF CASES. Ixix Inc -Jac TAOg lutorporatod Council of Ijiw Reporting, 22 Q. 1!. D. 279 - - 601 Indcrwick -•. Snell, 2 M. & O. 216 ; 2 II. ft Tw. 412 ; 19 I,. .1. (N. S.) I'h. 542: UJiir. 727 - .... 7:17 Intlinn Mechanical. &c. Co.. (1891) ., Ch. 53« ; «1 I,. .1. ' h. 31 ; 40 W. 1!. IM; \V. N. (1891) 153 - - - - 1311.1312 lii.lmii/.«(lone(.'o.. 2«C. D. 70 - - - tiiKt, 701, 7iw. 74H IngliH r. .lohn HutU-ry & Co.. 3 App. <'»». 5.J4 - - - ■VIA InjfliH r. Uobertgon. (1N98) A. C. Hl« ; 67 1-. .1. 1'. C. lOH; 79 L. T. 224-11. 1-. (Sc.) .... 12«m, 1207. 1212 lulttiul Itovcnm^ 1. Fonost, I5A. C. 334 - - - 104 Iiiliiml Revenue 1: Miiller & Vo.'n Marganne, limitetl. (19(»1) A. C. 217; 70 h. .). K. 11. 077; M4 1,. T. 729; 49 W. R. tM)3-lI. I.. (E.) ..---. 340, 341, ;H2 Imuttu .•. Ackroy.l 4 llest, (1901) 1 K. 11.813; S4 L. T. 344 : 70 I.. J. K. I!. 1.M) ; 49 W. 1!. 3«9 (( '. A.) ; H2 I.. T. ti20 - 7 2,). 726, 727. 728 .-.1 02, l;t.'. - 749 72,'i. 7'>7 Iniiw. & ( o., (1903) 2 Ch. J.V* ; 72 I.. .1. < h. 043 ; S9 I,. T. 142 ; W. K. J14(C. A.) liiiiBofCoiu-t Hotel Co., 6 hij. 82 - - - . Iiifernatiouul • able Co., (Mi 1,. T. 253 - 441, llliO, 721, International ( onti'act Co., W. \. (1809) 24 ; 17 W. 1\. 4.V1 ; 20 i„ I' 100 ... - - KiH, 507, :m IntcrnHtiunal Conversion Trust. W. X. (1892) 100 - - -1283 Intomutional .Society of .Vuctionm'rH, itaillie'^ Cane, (189^) I Ch. 110; 77 L. T. 523; 4«W. R. 187 - - - - 48 Internationiil Sponge Importers r. Watt. (191 1) A. C. 279(11. 1,. .Sc. 1- 1 158 Inland .•. Hart. (1902^ 2 Ch. .527 ; 71 I.. .1. Ch. 270 : 8« I.. T. ;m5; 50 W. R. 315 . - - - - «.'»2, etiti. mi Iron Ship, &c. Co. .. lUuut, L. R. 3 C. I'. 484; 10 W. R. s6N ; .ii I„ J. V. P. 273 - - - - - 442, 654. 729, 730 Iron Shipbuilding Vo., /;., .14 Beay. 597 - - - - 1391 Irrigation Co. of France, A'r /i«r(f Fox, 6 Ch. 183 - - - 1439 Irviuu ■■. Union llank of .\u^t^ulia, 2 App. Cat*. 306; 25 \\. II. 082; 37 L. T. 176; 46 L. J. I'. C. 87 - 37,82,686,710,711,761 Ifdiic'ti Case, III- Anglo-Aiiirtnun Printing Co., (1892) 2 Ch. 158; 61 L. J. Ch. 481 ; 66 1,. T. 593 ; 40 W. R. 518 (C. A.) - 636, 723, 724 iMmcM c. Royal Insurance, 1-. R. 5 Ex. ;t90 ... 718 Isuac« '. Towell, (1898) 2 Ch. 285; 07 L. J. Ch. .108; 78 I.. T. 619 . 333 I».le of Wight Rail. <■. Tahourdin, 2.) C. I). 320; 32 W. R. 297 ; 50 L. T. 132; 33 L. J.Ch. 353 - - - 091,692,691,736 Islington and General Electric Supply, W. X. (1892) 81 - 1 123. 1261, 1263 IsHue To., (1893) 1 Ch. 226; 71 I-. T. 667 ; 43 W. R. 267 - - 720 IxionTyr.'Co. r. apil»bury, (1898)2Ch. 484 - - - 381 J.* J.Caahi. Cash, 86 I,. T. 211 460 Jackson & Co., (1«9«) 1 Ch. 348; 68 L. J. Ch. liKI; 79 L. T. 662; OMsns. IW ._.--- 617. 1422 JackTOUHCaBe, 18W. R. 804 197 Jackson .■. Dickinstm, (1903) 1 Ch. 947; 72 I.. J. Ch. 761 ; 88 L. T. 507 "8», 140,1 JtM'^'^^^'Am Ixx TABLK OF CASES. Mil IMQK 9J L. T. 591 : M AV . U. 4'.'K : (!«<»«) I • h. 41i ^ ^^ ^^ Jackwiii r. Turquan /""•'<•. 10 •'h-2>' " ' " ' iai '.'Ai ..,« ,.. (Vdit I.yonnai., VI Q. B- »• ;!«• - " •^;'- •J(il • "0 1.. J-' n- '^•>; "* ^'" '■• . .' 1 Ch. - i;hi •Iac< J„o.,W - ^Tjs (190.| M n^ - -.^ri^rHm .- 1157. 1.58 Jacbv -. Whitnu.ro. 4fl L. T. :«:. ; 3-- W. U. .H: IS ... V. ..-. -_.H..^J5J Jtt..R.n. &c. Co. .. Valloi,. 7. L. T. .S(l - • Jamaica Rail. C • Colonial Itenk. (1!H)5; 1 Ch- »' > : '^ I- J- '^■ 410 : »V> L. T. 54H : 5'» W. T!. .'64 (C. A.) - - " .Iam«. Colmer. Kimitol (.s97) 1 Ch. 324; 66 L.J. Ch. .-b. _^a. L.^l^. ^^^^ Jamif r^ lluol "^nll, *>• ^-W-t"- (»«»"^ ' ^''- ^'" ^ 1'' ''• 'l .iM Ch. JM ; 74 L. T. 1 : 44 W . U. -t.a - JainoH I. Ev.'. I.. R. 11. li. .»1.> - . , ..^ , t .,.,3. .,4 Jamvs .-. ln.stitut.. "f Charter... Accuntont*. m 1,. 1. -.0. -4 T. 1-. li. -^ 362, im James.'. May, 1.. U.«n. I.. :42N - " " " ; Jara.« > . Smith, 1 Ua. 4;! - - .„"^ -..Lx ,.„, Jam.« W.ngato & Co. .•. Commu»iou«r«, ^^ • N. (1898) l-H. Ja.nii«.u ,-. Jami.*>n. io Rop. I'at. Ca«. 19:i - - Jarrah Tin.UT and W0..I PaviuB •'°7'"^"";/»^^ •^, ^ ^ 33-, • Jay ,-. Bud.., (.8»H) 1 Q. B. 12: 66 I.. J. U. B. 8«,J; .< l.T. 33... 4«l W. R. :m (C. A.) - - * „ ..„ .., , T tuv\ Jay AV r.Hr. Ur HarriHon, .4 C. D. 19 : 2S W. R. 449 ; 42 L. T. 6(K) •>3 T I.. R- •«•**•• -•* T. 1.. R. <» - ■ . , , JennerVCa^.. 7 C. D. i:.2:_26 W. R. 291 :_37 I.. T. 807; 4. U J JoJor liute of Prevent^.. Medicine .St. O^rgesW^^^^^ Committee, 69 U J. Q- B- «H ; 83 I.. 1- M* , 10 u. ^ 787 1031 1U2 430 12;» i;mi 679 1193 - 333 71» Committee, 444 - " " " " JenninK- .•■ Broughtou. .-. D. M. & O 126 ; 17 Boav. 234 441 : 22 li. J. Ch. 383 - - - - Jennings .•. Hammon.1, 9 U. B. ly'i'ib: .11 SV. R. 40: .1 1 Jen.2iji'.'^'!ienuing», (1898) 1 Ch. 378; 67 L. J. Ch. 190; 77 ! 786- 46 W. R. 344 - - " " ' Jen-^y (Earl of) r. Ouardiann of N..«th Poor, 22 H. B. 1 .. 3.',3 287 ; 99 L. T. 243 109, 1U81 1 W. E. 194, 201 J. - 110 T. ■ 337 - 470, 602, 60S - 679 - 1212 24 - .312 68. 147 - 1337 Jervi» .-. Wolferstan, 18 Eq. 18 Jewan r. Wliitworth, 2 Eq. 692 Jewish Coloniimtion Trurt, (1908) 2 Ch. T 1.. B. .'i95 - - - - Johannesburg Hotel Co.. (1891) iCh. 119 - - - Johanneeburg Mining and OenerHl Syndicate. W. N- V»90yjl« ^«n?t?^9'^)fcir--"-^^^^ JohJiLn 2 Co. .."Bother^am Union, 83 I. T. 193; 64 J. 1'. 380 - lOJ John Cro«.ley & Son., /?., W. N. (1892) 3.-, - - - " >"S3 T.VBLK OF (JA8KS. Ixxi Joh-Kel John M.-rluy Ituil.ling ( o. ,• Ha.n... ^IHHlj J < h. :lN.i ; .«. I- ; •.• h John* -■. isalfour, 5 T. K. a. :iHJt ^«3 .).,lm«... & I'o. (J. CO. (1!K)2) 2 Ch. KM (< '. A.) - •.IT. 1 m, 1 »2;l, H|i4 .lohuxon f. . :« - " - 12»W .I„hMs.,n ,-. l,vttl.,V Iron Aj^-mcy. .-, <'. I). .iH" : i5 W. If. .M « ; ^ I T V'f • »(i I.. .1. <^h. 7H (C. A.I - - ^J. 4"'. '"'•• '•"' Johnrton .-. Toronto (ijan C»n-um.T«' Co.. (IWW) A. C. 447 : n JoncH 1-. Oorclon, 2 App. Cum. (iUi - J.>no« f. Hottv.ns, 4 C. 1). 036; io W. H. 4(M) J.moH -•. Paciiyu Rubber Co., (1911) 1 K, B. 4.T Jon<>s 1'. IVppen'orne, Johnx. 43() ; "N L. J. < 1 JonoB V. St. I>ungtun Ovorstwrs, 94 I'- T. 7N' L. O. R. 147 - - - - JoncH -•. Scottish Accident Insuninco Co. (18N6}. 17 Q. li. 1'. 421 - 86 Jom-sr. VanoouYorUnaCo., (1910)A.C. 317 - - •«9, 660 Jom« -■. VicU.riu On.vinp IKnik Co., 2 (i. H. D. 314 ; 25 W. ». 34H ; 176 :W1: 17 W. R. 1037; 20 I,. T. - 4.»ti. 4(i(>, 471, J07, .'(ON, 712, 710. 7.V5, 7.-.!l, 7H!», 1103 - 103 - 1210, 1211 - 3.>8 19.S, (i.>8 l.W - - 1194 23 T. I,. R. 13: .-. - 109 :J6L. T. 144; 46L. J.U. n. 219 Jomni'ujoy <•. Watson, 9 App. Cus. 561 Joplin Urewery, (1902) 1 Ch. 79 ; 50 W. R. 75 Jordan v. Money, 5 H. L. C. 352 - Jo8t.ph llarp-eav«w. Limited, (IWM)) 2 Ch. ;H7 336, 141. 1184 - 1147 617, H23. 1424 188 . 104 K. Kaltenbach I'. liuwia, 10 App. Cas. 617 . - - - KarberK's Vr^, (-892) 3 Ch. I ; .HI L. T. IM ,-„,_'.;*,• '.f^j'^^ Kave .■. Croydon Tramwav«, (1898) 1 Ch. 358; 67 L.J. Ch. 222; 7k L. T 237 ; 46 W. R. •;03 (C. A.) - 694. 696, 732. 1(M8, 1449, Keatingo r. Puringu ConsoUdatod Mines, W. N. (1902) 15 - Keoton r. SheBiold ( W Co., (1901) I d. U. 26 ; 70 L. J. K. H. 374 ; 84 L. T. 387 ; 49 W. R. 349 ; 65 J. P. :»41 - - K^iKhloy, Maxtcirr«toTi« -, 7 L. J. ( h. 977; ;«i W. R. HIS; ,-,9 T,. T. 449 ; 19 Meg. H9 391. «.'i7 Kei? jtti Exploration < 'o. .•. Murtiti, 1« T. L. B. 486 - - 1349 Kont (^oalfioMs SvmUcate, (189H) «1. B. 744 ; 14 T. L. B. 77 ; 67 L. J. (i. B. MW; 7H L. T. 443; 4« W. H. 453; 3 Man». »« (C. .V.) - - - - - - - 71, «NN, 772 K«itOntcropCoal('o., W.N. (1912) 2(1 [«f. Addenda] - - 'W9 Kent V. Freehold I^nd Co.. 4 Ecj. .W« ; 3 ( h. 493 ; 17 L. T. 77 - 17. 190. 191. 193, 197. 1»!», -MtO, 281 K< pitigulla Bubber t^taten i'. National Bank of India, 2o T. L. K. 402 - - - - - - - - 759 K.t1v. /?', (11K)1) 1 Ch. 4ti7 ; 70 L. J. f'h. 1H9; 83 T.. T. 099; 49 \v. R. 211 (('..V.) i;««i KeiT V. JoneH. 1 Dow. j3n ..---- 718 Kpv & Son, Ltd.. (19021 1 Ch. 407 ; 71 L. J. Oh. 264 : 86 L. T. 374 ; oOW. R. 2:M - ' - - - - 70. (WO, 1139 Koynshum Blue Lian Co. . . Ilurkor. 2 II. & C. 729, 733 - - h7 Klmraxkhomu Svndiciito, (18»7) 2 Ch. 4 jl ; OH L.J. Ch. 675; 77 L. T. s2 : 1(! W. I!. 37 «<> Kiinhorloy Co.. K>. 58 L. T. 305 - - - - - 6tJ9 Kimberloy North Blof -. Diamond Mining Co.. W. N. (1888) 126; 59 L. T. 579 (C. A.) 1390 King I-. Howpll. 27 T. L. R. M4 1160 King. The r. Do Boron({ur iinJ othirs .... 234 Kiugilon r. Kirk. 37 C. I). 141 1340 Kingsbury C».llieric«, ;i9ti7'> 2 Ch. 259; 96 L. T. 829; 23 T. K R. 497 - - - - - - 457,467.474 Kingston, Br j,artr. 6 Ch. 632 . - . . 1 lie.!, 1195 Kingston. Miller & Co. ••. Thomaw Kingston & Co., (1912) 1 Ch. 67*;. Srr Addenda, ungston Cotton Co., (1896; 2 Ch. 284; 63 L. J. Ch. 673; 74 L. T. 568; 3Man». 171 .... 775, 776. 777. H64 Kiunaird (r»rf) v. .Snlt.iiin (Ijuly) (181(i). 1 Madd. 227 - - 1188 Kinnaird p. Wobster. 11) ( . n, tiw - - - - -1191 Kintrwi, AV j^iHf, 5 Ch. 95 ; 18 W. R. 197 ; 21 L. T. 688 ; 39 L. J. Oh. 193 • - • - - - - 19G, i:t89 Kirhy'g Cano, 46 L. T. 682 - - - - - 68 Kirby v. Duke of Marlborough. 2 M. & S. 18 - - 1 190, 1246 Kirby v. Uunnlet, (1906) A. C. 43 - - - - - 106 Kirk I'. Bell, 10 U. B. 290 - - - - - 740 Knight's Case, 2 Ch. 321 ; 15 W. B. 2fr! ; 15 L. T. 546 ; 36 L. J. Ch. 317 - - - - - - - - 659 Knight V. liulkoley , ri I.. X . 7 ; 3 Jiir. N. 8. 817 ; Storey on Agency, s. 475 -.--.--- 705 Knight, fif. (IMW) 1 Ch. 257 ; «: L. J. f'h. 130; 77 L. T. 773; 4fl W. B.289(( . A.) ..... 680,745 Knowles v. MoAdam. ': Rx. D. 23 ; 47 L. J. Ex. 139 : 37 L. T. 795; 26W. B. 114 - - - - - - .881 TABLE OK CA8M. Ixxiii K„.,wl.« .. Scott. (INOI) 1 fh. TIT : («» li. J. Ch. 2M ; IM L. T. Vi ;J9 W. B. S.'.J Knox -•. Havmtti.. «T 1,. T. UJT - - i>^. ll>2. lit.".. K,-lak. l-tcl. .•. Clark. {\«0H) 1 K. B. .V»'i : T'.' L. J. K- »■ L. T. 1.V-. ; 51 W. B. 4J» (•'. A.) K(.tTvf"iifein MineB v. M.^-eloy, (191 1) A. C 4(«t - Krtw '•. John-on. (IHON) 2 ({. M. i»l : liT L. J. «1. H- TKJ : iMT ; 4t> W. U. «:«); tH' J. 1'. 4')»; 1» <'ox, C. »'. 103 KvKho I'. AltHitw., :«« W. R. 4WJ .'l«U< : TH I, I'tQE 111 •.'o;i. '.'OS ;•<;. 9* - IKU r. - T.>5 - Ht).i 1.. J. I'. 1(H; !S0 L. T. HJJ; - 1341 SS; .,.. 1,. J. 741. 13.jt>. liiiil 1413 357 1185 1392 I,.i ««urgo|nie, (If*!*) A. f. 431 ; H« I HA-p. M. »•. 55(t; (iNiW) 1 1'. 1- Iji ( 'oiniwL'nie - -■. Whitlt-y, (iwm) 1 «-'li Ch. T29; T4 I,. T. 441 ; 44 \V. R. .^W - 1,11 So'ii, 3 Prew. .)T» . . - - - L. I.. Svndicuto. I.ta.. W. N. (IWK)) KM - l^iidi.V Drew. AwKR-iatioii -. 1'ulbr.Mjk, (IIHJO) 2 U. B. 370 ; «» l- J. il. II. 7(13 ; 49 W. U. ti ; T Muiis. 465 (C. A.) - - 25, tWil. 12.S5 Lu.lv Fom-st (Miirchison) Oold Miuo. (19«1) 1 Ch. 582, M I.. T. -.-,«,, . - - . - - 134. 13N, 14<> UilvwoU Mininj? • Brookes, 35 C. I). 4(K) : 35 W. U. TS5 : u»i L. T. 677 : 56 I.. J. Ch. tW4 - - - l^^. la^. 137 Utunas Nitrate Co. .■. UifjuuaK Nitrate Syn.licatp, (1n99) 2 Ch. 392 ■ 6» I,. J. Ch. 699 : Nl I.. T. 334 : 4H W. U. 74 (C. A.) - 37, 123, 127. 134, 1.16, 142, 144. 145, I5(t, IWt, 1S4, 192. 211, 713, «39 Ugunas Nitrate- Co. .-. SchroedtT ri"«>n 17 T. L. R. 625 ; M I,. T. 22 - - - - - - 7l»5, I^ing r. Overseors of liiBhopweannouih, 3 Q. H. I). 299 - 106. I*kr. View Kxtendod Gold Co., W. X. (1900) 44 - Uiiib r. Evans. (1.S93) 1 Ch. 218 - Umb r. Great Northern Rail. Co., (1H91) 2 Q. B. 2S1 ; 60 1,. J. (1. II. 4^9 : 65 L. T. 225 : 39 W. R. 47.-. ; 56 J. 1'. 22 Jjiinb .. Samba.. Rubber, (190H) 1 Ch. .S45 ; 98 L. T. 633 : 77 I.. J. eh.386 198, «,-.8 Umbert i'. Nt>rthern, &c. Co.. 18 \V. R. 180 - - 725. 737 Ijiiiison, &c. Co.. lie, (1895) 2 Ch. 726; 64 1,. J. Ch. 777 ; 73 I.. T. 311 ; 44 W. R. 42 Vm, 1290 Uni»on Pueumatic Tube Co. .. ThilUps. W. N. (1904) 134 : 91 I.. T. *i3 ------- - ;'*" Uno»«hire Banking Co., W. N. (1897) 3 - - - 1311. 1315 J,uuciiBhire Innurauce Co. r. Inland Revenue ; Vulcan Boiler i: Same, (1899) 1 U. n. 353 ; 68 I.. J. U. B. H3 ; 79 1,. T. 731 ; 47 W. R. 396: 63 J. P. 21 424 Uncaahire Plate OUi*.. 105 L. T. S70 - - - - 1331 i.ancashire Telephone Co. .■. Overseers, 14 U. B. I). 267 - - 108 767 !07 1462 442 1020 /:•«<:! .-^alfei^ai^. Ixxiv TABL.E OK CA»M. J. 1'. ('. 49: 76 - «H, «0, 13d, 391 til(i XiMi— !<•• I^nciuter, tU i^,rU, A r. D. »ll ; iJ W. K .W9; 36 I. T. 674 ; 46 h. J. Itttllk. 90 - 700 Uncanter Hunkiiig Co.. W. N. (1897) 3 ; 7S L. T. «H7 - 1311, 1;)14. Una CKl.t (■..: of IreUnd. «-, 4 Oh. 469: 17 W. «• 8«»=%1'- T- tUl ; ;t!< L. J. l"h. 389 - - - 79, 334, 410, ,39, 741 land Oodit Co. of Indund -•. I/>nl Fermoy (1870), 4 f"|i- '22 _- 4w, 7H, tO"> I*nd Credit Co. r. M»rkirell, 21 W. R. 34 - lender and Walfonl'- Contract. W. N. (1900) 1S3 - r..nd-< .\llot,n..nt Co.. (1894) I Ch. 61.! ; «3 L J. CL. 291 70 K. T. •.•S(i : 42 W. n. 404 ; 1 Mann. 107 ; 7 R. 114 - WI. 446, .1 J, nfii, K7Z, I^an.'-Caw, 1 U. J. * S. ,>09 - - - ' " UHRtr-. l'a«3, 37 L. J. Ch. 292 : \H !,. T. 67 ; W. N. (186») H - I.*n«tou Moiiotyp. <■■ .Vn.l.Tsou, (1911) 2 K. H. 1.) Iatimimio r. Boauchemin, (1897) A. C. 34R 66 I, L. T. 473 ; 44 W. H. 039 Iia»t .-. I: Chartered llauk. 17 Kq. 20J 1-auglilau r. Millor. F. 413 Laughton v. Hi»hop of So Society «. l»ank of England. 24 U. B. D. 408 62 L. T. 496; 3S W. U. 493 : 44 J. P. 682 T*w .-. l-ocal hoard of Redditch. (1892) 1 Q. H. 127 ; 61 L. J. M. H. 172 : 66 1-. T. 76 ; 40 J. P. 292 (C. A.) - I,iiwe'» Case. 1 1>p G. M. & O. 430 - lawTence-M'a«e,2CTi.412; 16 L. T. 222 : :«i L. J. Ch. 490- 72 Uwrence & Bullcn, Ltd., W. N. (1901) 14K lawronr.) r. Wj-nn, 4 M. & W. 345 - - ' „ " . I^xon & Co., AV (No. 2), (1892) 3 Ch. 445; 61 L. J. th 66, ; L. T N4 ; 40 W. 1{. 621 - - " Laythorix' ''• Bryant, 3 Scott. 250 - - - Ii.'ach -■. Jay, 9 "c. D. 45 - Leatbaui ,-. Craip. 2 Ir. R. 667 Lti- ,■. .M«xander (1883), 8 App. Ca«. 843 (H. L., Sc.) L«e /•. iiutler, (1893) 2 Q. B. 318 - I^ V. Oaskell, 1 Q. «• D. 700 - Lee r. Haley, 4 Ch. 161 ; 18 W. E. 242 ; 22 L. T. 241 ; :« 284 Lee f. Jones. 14 C. B. N. a 386 - " " ' ' Lee ,. Neuchatol Co., 41 C. D. 1 : -.7 L. J. .fh.«a2 ! *» J^' „^.*^^^' 4H L J Ch. 408 ; 37 W. H. 321 - 766, 840, 862, 863, 86o, 866, * •'• '»•"'• -^'^ g. „7g f(„o „S4^ „a9, H90, 892, 893. 894, 897, 898, 901 I/wda Bauking Co., Ex i• '«"^: *^,^-,«^ Ch 46 57 L. T. 684 ; 36 W. B. 322 - 712, 724, 743, 7^, "'•*^' 777,862,891,898,904,906, p^a , 708 1328 , 761 203, 1402 679 343 746, 1402 746 668 101 . 484 101 1247 716 1246 ,617 1448 672 - 369 , 242 :, 268 1283 666 67 26, 26, 44 IL. J. Ch 451 , 483 1180 496 446 696 1212 343 , 462 1197 867, , 894, 1, iKl3 46 776, HS6 <»i.%iT>i''rt>>. -S^TSS-i TABLE OK :u) .------- L«.ko'« CuKi- (JHTO), 1 1 K.I. tWt : e Ch. '89 - - - - L,.» «n«k SpinninKCo.. /« rr. (1906) i Ch. SW ; 9a L. T. 34 : 3j W. It. 503 ----- " '"'• I^« !■. Martiu, 17 Eq. 224 I,..K'«1 und Oi-nerul Investment Co.. W. X. (1901) TJ - 1391, l„.i...rter Club Co.. Itr, M C. D. 6'.t»: J5 I. J. Ch. 20«; *» W. H. n:.-i.i I,. T. :mo - - - - - I/'ifchild .« Cam, Rr British and ForeiK'n Cork Co., '. Va\. 'iA\ ; ':» I,. T. 207 ; 14 W. R. 22 Ix-ith < 'ouncil f. l,«ith Harbour CominiHHionpr», (181t(t) A. < . Mn - U,th Hull, 4c. Co. .•. Mu»g«v.-, W. N. (1900) 210; 1 Kriiwr. 1117 l*n.uxr. Brown; 1852). l-'^'- »•*«*> • ' ' ' l/»t*r .'. Koxoroft. 1 Coll. P. C 108; 1 Wh. * Tu. L. C. Eq. 76« - l/thebv ' . Christopher, Limitwl (Jones' Caw), (1904) 1 Cli. si j ; 73 ■ •'- ■ ■■ ■ ■" "•■ S2W. R. 4B0 - - •«' 12-i» 59 130A 1194 1424 726 467 ,->r2 11H5 1,.'J. rh. 509; 90 1-. T. 774 U-vpr'sCiuM,, W. N. (1«7»)204 - - - " LvT.T Hro«. .'. lledingtield, 80 L. T. 1(K» - Lcv.r -■. KoWer. (1901) ICh. o4:i - - - - l/'vi i\ Ayros, 3 App. Cas. 852 - - - " (/.vita s Case. I.. R. 3 Ch. 3«; 17 L. T. 337 : W W. B. 9o - U.v,t..« (O. H.) Ca8.>, L. B. 5 Ch. 489 - I^vy I . Walkor, 10 (\ Kiv. 436 : 27 W. K. 370 ; 39 L. T. 654 ■ I^wis. Rr, 6 Ch. HIH; 19 W. B. 791 ; 24 1.. T. 787; 40 I.. J 129 - - - - - ■ " l^wis .-. Nicholson, 18 Q. B. 403 - U'vliiiid and Taylor's Contract, (1900) 2 Ch. 625 ; t>9 L ■ N3 I T. 380; 49 W. B. 17 (C. A.) Liberiun Oovemment Conoeawons, 9 T. L. B. 136 - licensed VictuaUers' AssocUtion, Rf, 42 C. P. 1 ; 58 L. J. Ch 60 L. T. 684 ; 37 W. B. 674 ; 1 Meg. 180 - - 2(5, i. Life and Health Ausur. Assoc., (1910) 1 Ch. 458 - TJmiuer Asphalte Co. v. Commrs. of I. B., L. R. 7 Ex. 211 J. Ch. 669, 671 - 483 - 450 - 337 - 668 - ^H 4H, 51 450, 453 Ch. 662, <<64 - 59* M : 192, \»<. 467; 8, 298 - 52U - ;«*! limpuft I'. London General Omnibus Co. Ex.34 - 1 H, & C. 526; 39 L.J. .221 Undsay Petroleum Co. v. Uurd. I* B. 5 P. C lindus I'. Melrose, 3 U. 4 N. 177 - lion Insurance Co. v. Tucker, 12 Q. B. D. 276 Liquidators of Imperial Mercantile Cn^t Aswx:. e. Colemau, L. B 6 H. L, 189 Lister & Co. v. Stubbs, 45 C. I>. 1 - Liverpool, 4c. Co. v. Houghton, 23 W. K. 93 Liverpool Corporation v. Birkenhead Union, 94 L. T. 509; 4 L. O. B 273 ----- ■ ravercoo! CorpoRitimi v. Llsmfvllin Absm"*, (>m., (1899) 2 U. B. 14 ; ii»i•. Smith, :)7 ('. It. I To riiv«>rp. -'«». ;im» I.loyil ■• l.lny.l (IH.17), 1' My. .* Ci. I!f.' lilynvi. Toii.iii, Ac Co., «! W. R. .Vc 37 I-. T. .(73 Uwk ''. (liiiM'ii-iliiiiiI Iiivtwtmi'iit *'<)., IMIMi) A. t'. AIM 41 - ; Hi L.T. ^;«: 1411 11)2 W«» IlkH .w- I2M •. H71 1 :>()«> 443 744 4(i» 191 442 lUU, 1IJ3, Ho L. J. ch. 7UM : 75 li. T. 3 . 4 ■ W. I! flj - - 4.m, 50;», WI3. fW Irfx k .•. WriRli-y. » (J. It. T). 397 - ... - r,.Mkctt <•. Ukiuiiui Nitnito <'o.. Tho Tim"*. -27 Mar. HKH» - I^Kklmrt r. MolilttC«)tt, .5T. I,. K. .!ii7 .... [rf>okw.i«d .. Hop Kittm-H Co., .1 T K. «9H - r^).lwiik i: Kurl of IVrtli, I T. I,. I!. 7tl - jAtgixu, Kr /HirU. 9 K<|. 14l» IS W. If. -213 : '.'I I,. T. 742 - iMnan r. Bank of Scotlmid "4) 2 K. B. 411.); 73 L. J. K. B. '•: : !•! I . T. 232; n-vtrwui In I. I*., 21 Uv. UKW . • ! ..'h LoKiiii •■. (.'(lurtnwii (»-Jir!), 13 l(,uv. 22; 2«l 1,. J. Ch. 347 - ■ ■:,, H -n K. 1. 1'. Fitirclough, 2 M. & O. 074 - ilj I-..ii(lon .iikI ( lawloiiiuu Co. 1H79), 11 C. I). 140; 27 W. B. '. 4(» L. T. (WH - - - - - - .... 14 ; Loii'liiii unil c.4iiiii)iun T^iin, &c. Co. i'. hu^gaii, (llS9;i) A. C. MHi; «3 I-. J. P. C. 14 : 1 R. 413 (P. (".) .... 070 l-r)ioi'ntion. 77 L. T. I4ti; 13 T. L. R. 57ti{C. A.) ....... .WM, 467 London and Connty Banking Co. r. Uoddard, (lSil7) 1 Ch. 042; »»» L. J. Ch. 2»il : 7rt h. T. 277 ; 45 W. R. 310 - - - 1217 liondon and County BankinR Co. r. I ..wis, 21 C. I». 490 - - 1190 Iiondon and County Bankin^t Co. '■. :;adcliffe, I! A. C. 722 - .1191 London Coiintv <'onncil c. Attnri;- y-Oeneral. (1901) A. C. 20; 70 L J. U". B. 77 ; H3 !-. T. no., : 49 W. R. »W6; 65 J. 1'. 227 {H. I,., E.) - - - - NN, !»2, 101, 102 London and Kantom Counties, &c. Co. <■. Cmu^^y, W. N. (1897) 4N - 346 I^iondon and Edinburgh Shipping Co, (1909), - C. I Ct. of Sem. . 1313 lAindon and OoDunil Bank (No. I) (auditor ai. .IHcer), (1895) 2 Ch. l.i«i, 673; 63 L. J. Ch, S53 ; 43 W. R. 481 ; 72 L. T. Hll 714 I-on.lon and (Kiicral Bank (No. 2). (1895) 2 Ch, 673 ; «4 L. J. Ch. .S6»i; 73 1.. T. ;«M; 44 W. R. 80; 2 MaiiM, .V.5; 12 I! .Vit* (C. A.) -.---- 863, H: 2, 898, 906 I-ondon and General Bank (No. 3), (1895) 2 Ch. 073 - 775, 777 Ixmdon liii.I niob« Finanw Corp., (10O3) I Ch. 728 : 88 L. T. 194; 51 V>. \i. 651 -----. 873, 1401 Tendon and India 1 looks .'. Poplar L'nion, 83 L. T. 371 - 100,108 liondon and MaNhoualand Co. v. New Maohonaland Co.. ^V. N. (1801) 165 ..-.-.- 734 J,ondon and Mrrcantilo Diwount Co., //., 1 Vai. 277 ; 14 W. R. 219; 13 I-. 1'. 665 - - - - - - - 7(W Irf>ndon and Midland liunk ''. Mitchell, (18!)9) 2 Ch. 161 ; 68 L. J Ch. .J68: HI L. T. 263; 47 W. R. 602 - - 1186, 1187, 1 194 ^[^f^aBSi. . I ABLIC OK C'ABKH. Uxvii Lon-^Lon '^^ l,..i»li)ii aii.1 NVw York liivi-»lnii-iit > o.. (1hW.>) 2 ( h. N«i .37. 711, IJM lomlnii «iul NiTth.iii IWiik. K< ,,,irtr ianw. (l«Mt) I i'h •,-2«: «» I.. .1. Ch. i* ; "1 I- T. .MJ : 7 Mann. Wl - IN, .VJ, W7, 7H»I b,i, ar«l N.)rth-W«.t.Tii lUil. r.i. r. I'rict., H «i. II. 1>. 4H.5 - 4«H l,„n,l.,M uii.l l'n.TiiH ml ('..., /.v, .) f, I>. :,i:,: :>^ I.. T. •. 1" 1" J- 'h- •!' . . - - U.iiiloii ituil H;i, .-.4 I.. T. ^^ ; J3 I.. J. ^'h. 2*24 . . - - I ouiliiii uuil '^""tl'*'"''' t" '"""'"" "•"* Ijtnciwhirf. if NV. II. !>*<•>. 4.' I.. T. 217 Un.l.m una Staffonl-hir.' • u., H C. !>. 14!»; ;U W. U. 7.S1 ; 4H 1.. T. ll.Vi ; .-i:} I.. J. • li. 7H - - - IW. im, lUO, -'4J, law* Uii.l.m anil W.«ttiuiuiit«-r Bank r. Smitb, tW .1. I', ttia ; k7 I.. X. 224; ti7 .1. 1'. :i-*!» londoii anil \Vt>»tniinstm Bi»aer, U H. B. 1>. 7 Ij.ndoii .\K8iirani«. ! Virjioratiou '. Thi' I/iiulon and W cMiniuRt*'! A^snrallCB i '(>i|.iiratioii, I.-uiit«l. '.» Jur. N. S. N4a b.ndon llunk uf M-xir., .■. A| . .orpe. (1N»1) 2 n. B. a7N IJ. H. tija; 0.> I. T. M\ ; :i» W. H. JtH (0, A,) - Und..n rhurU'TOd Bank .. White, 4 App. <'tt». 422 ^J. C) Undon County Council '•. Att.-(ien., tl!HI2) A. C. ItU liond.iii Couut y t 'ounoil c. Churcuwardou> ol Erith, (lM9a) A, J62; 42 W. I!, aat); J7 J. 1'. >*2l ; « 11.. Feb. Ut (II. h.J Ixiudon, dto. Electric lanhting Co., iO I.. T. ti'O - - - Uudon Financial A«8oc. -•. Kelk. 26 C. D. 107; iOE. T. 492; 53 I,. J. Ch. 102J ----- 42, 46». j(t, Loudon Founders' AHHociatJon i: Clarke, 20 Q. B. 1>. o70 - Uudon Freehold, &c. Co. .•. Suttield, (IM97) 2 Ch. (KIN; m L. .J. (i. B. 7l<0; 77 L. T. 445: 4« W. H. 102 - - (*3, N4 lA)iidou lieueraH imnibua Co. r. IjivoU, (1901) 1 Ch. 135 - - 453 Undon ln.li» Kubber Co., 5 E4. 5lit ; 10 W. K. 334 ; 17 I.. T. 530; :i7 L. J. Ch. 235 - - - - 577, 7M, 810, 843 Undon Joint i^tovU Bunk 1: Simmons, (1892) A. C. 201 - 1142, 1187, 1210, 1211 liondon Marine Awociatiou, />, « E) 170 ; 20 T,. T, 943 ; 17 W. R, 7H4 ----- • Ixjudon (Mayor of) and Tubbs' Contract, ,1894) 2 Ch. jj! , s^ L. J. Ch. 580; 70 I.. T. 719 - Ixindon, I'aris, .*<•. Anaociation, Re, 1» T L. 11. 669 Undon Wnting Alliance v. Cox, (1891) 3 Ch. 291 - Undon .steamboat C..., 31 W. B. 781 ; W. N. (1883) 123 - 1284, Undon and ^J. W. Canal, (1911) 1 Ch, 341 - 168, .•J92, 670, 715, 722, London I'nitwl Tramways 1. Brentford 1 uion, 96 L. T. 528; 5 L. (i. E. 682 I«)ug ■'. AndroTTB, 25 T. L. E. 93 - Ungdale, Re, (1901) I Ch. 3 Ungnuin >: Bath Electric Tramways, (1905) 1 Ch. 646; 74 li. J. Ch. 424 ; 92 L. T. 743 ; 53 W. B. 480 (C. A.) - 4.Vi ;i7 13:10 105 1474 1363 - 152 i9 I«„l (%u.le ll«milt..n'» C.«o H < h .,4N - ^ ,,,^ |,»r.l Imhi-iuiiiV CiHO. l""!) < 1 h. -« . 'h . .^^ .^^^ U.rii.K.. l)«vi«.:«<'I>«'« - - . 32 U.rraino'HdiBe, 2»'h. '.'7 - - ii Jur. N. S. (Mil : i:i W. It. hs:j I^.uiH r. John. !• Sim. :«Mi - - I>,„..ianu ana SoutWru Stat-. *o. to.. jm<) . I...v..n ...a .ViKtma. ,. WaU. (!«««) A. U. 4.i; m U T. h.'- ;:::;:lr:;•£;/::u^::a(.-).-^>':-^,-^ . 1444 - lilH - 44J 12tiJ, 1271. I.j7(i, l'.!77 - i,a. 11!», :i3H 7n:{, 7«5 - 7'J7 . til . .•IKti, 7. «'w, **«**• SrtM, H7il, NWI. X'MK 1411 - 7(1.^ I.U.-.W, AV, 17 Jut. 11'*6 - - ■ ' . ,49 ,,,,„,..»..a.h. lMa...&«lr.417;4Ju,....M - ^^^ r.ma-.. 1»-Trieii, 7Taunt. 2.N - " :«7. H«8 l,„..a, ,■. Kit/p>raia .1!H.:»}, JO T. L. It. !♦. - ,^5.^ l.uckvOun"'. I-i«nit.-a. 70 L. r. 7'i2 - - _ ^^^ ,,„„W ,. Gy.., .! K. * 11. Jl« - - - . . „, LmiwlViiKfa*-, 4('h. :I4 - - .,„ , -rr ,173 . - !«« i.vamy ana wwh-i. 4c • ;■•••»'"'• '' '; ,V;,, ,.>,, lici. \m, r.-. jsa .. c !•.. ^Ha(t^ I I'h 17>< ; •'•^ ''• ■'■ Ivn.l-,. AnK>..-ltaU..MlI..ml'.A'^-'"- ^'**"« ""■ _ . ^m (li. Hfl; 7:11-. T. 5«»2 --■'_. ,9.2 I.yH,.Khl. «.I.y«i(il.tr. Ly'>aKht.(lSW)M''" • .,_^ ,„, eh. lili; - - ■ ' i TABI.K OF CASKS. Ixxix Kac Xad Miir.lnnuM i: l.«w rmou liiMiniiuf < o. ,l«T:t), I,. K. J U. H. •!-'«: ■JJ W. 11. .WO; .«• I,. T. oli; la I.. J. ;w. <>mk rm. nn. \-w>'. i.i.»h. i;ijn, iiiw .Ma(Iln«i.ir«<';i«', .T.'f. n. :l»i(i - - - - - 444 Mii.ilufT '. Maitluff. (IWW} jrh. 4.-il - - - - 4im Mii( farlaiii' ''. iMiinbiiitoii Sti-ambouts Co., .'Mi .S^'. 1.. R. 771 - Uo" MarksfUim, W. N. liMXl) lU - - - - - 730 Ma.kav, /.V, (lilUn rli. .XMt - - - - -715 Mai kuv ' . < omiiirn ial liaiik, .-. I', i '. :t!»4 ; J'J W. R. 47.t ; .10 I.. T. ISO: 43 1.. J. 1'. r. ai Ma. kl.-vH (•»«.•, 1 ('. 1). -241 : l.> I,. J. (1i. 1.-.M; .W I.. T. 4 A. f. '.M ; 04 I,. T. 41 (iS; .'14 \V. 1(. -ili. Mailiin-, /■'.' i-iiff. .^ t'li. W. It. 1122 174. 177. 17S. I!»4, 20,1. 214. 227, 220, 2:tO, 232 :iOF,. .1. 111. OK,-,: 23 I,. T. iw.-| : |m Ma.iiim.ln, It.. I'.iili.'ld .•. Maomimlo. W. N. (1H!»2) 73 Ma.X. , OiJiNt. 4 1'^. 31.') Mcfolliii .•. (iilpiii. .» il '.I. II. 3!>0 - MiCoiiiii'll't. Ca^o, (1901) 1 »h. 72«: 70 1.. J. :>. 7211, 730 Mctoim.'ll r. \Viij,'lit. (liioa) I I'll. .-.40; 72 1.. J. < li. 347 ; hh L. T. 200. 211. 212, 211. 2iri, 220, 227, 220, 1350 4)1 : .il W. R. Wil (<'. A. Mr» ulluiii, /•'. ;i!H»l} 1 I'h. 113 - M.li.Mi«ttll .-. ,I,.i,iey IiiiiMTia! llot.l I'..., 2 II. At M. .VJH; 12 W. R. 21 Mi 1142; 10 L. T. H43: 34 I-. J. fli. •il6, N.j7, N73, 13<>0 M.Karhaiii ■. I'.iltoii, ,1!M12] A. C MM : 71 i.. J. P. C 20; s.'i L. T. .•i!t| IM .) - - - - - - - a,M NMiiiith.r .. I'il.'h.-r, ; MHH) 2 Ch. .loti: .-.:< W. It. 13n; 20 T. I.. 1!. M. lv.T'rt CttK.. 5 Ch. 121 - Ml Kays Ca«r (No. 1). 2 C. I». 1 ; 24 W. R. 4!M> : :13 I,. T. .>17 : 4.-. nrtH. r.'4 - N17 L. J. ch. liM 130, 7.W, 1362 M.K<' IW>ii.l.iiil. I', v.ril w., ,. Joint stcM'k liistitiitf. I.imiti.l. (INKO Ml,. 071: i>x I' I,. J Ch. ;iiMi : m L. T. 041 ; li M ill'.. ;:.i>» M.Mall. //.. h'ull.r i: M. Mahoii. ;i!HMi 1 i),. I7:i: liti |,. ,J, I'l,. '1 I. r. 7i:i: 7 Ma MiMillau l"Uoi M null); I W - .llKMij 1 Ch. .331 lN»i 701 .M. Mull.'ii r. >ir .\ltnd Hiikmaii SUtiin-hip Co., 71 I.. .1. C|, IH r. I., li. 0,^> MNiol!\ Caw. 10 K..|. .'UH. 707, 7t»N. M54 IS \V. I! no.', ll-.'i!: '.'3 I.. T. 207 39 1.. ,1. < h. N22 IS« Madili »>»cr, /if 27 c. II. j::a M»ild»"n !•. Ahler.Hoii, H Apfi. i an. 4'I7 ; .V.' 1,. .1. (J. H, 7.37 ; 40 I.. T. \V U. sji,: 47 .1. !• 1^:. lh^ Ixxx TABLK OF CASES. If I: Kkd-Kar r*w Mwlnix Irrijjation (',.., \V. N. (1881) 12(1 - - - - 14B9 Madriil Hunk H', Kr /i./i7^ Willium«, '.' Kq. Jlti; M W. It. 708; U li. T. 4.V» :;«!,. J. Ch. 474 . ; . . . m,i MHdri.l IJunk r. I'.lly. •> E(|. 216; 14 W. R. 70«; 14 I,. T. 4.'iti ; :i.i I-. J. Ch. 474 : 7 Eq. 442 - - - . 838, 839 Mafpw, Ar. la Q. B. T). .-m - .... -1148 MaKnolia Motal ('o.'« Tnulr Murku, (1897^ 2 (li. :171 : tl« I-. J. Ch. .>!»S; 7(i I,. T. (172 - - - - . - ;l4(i Miihoiioy >. fjist Ilolyf(ml <"o., I,. H. 7 II. I,. 869; ;V.i I,. T. 'iHA - 78, 79, SI, 8:j, ««ll. 719. 74;i, 7.W, 7ti<). 7fil MaiiilAiid '. U{i,ii>hii. 41 ('. Ii. 120 - - . . . i'.>;{i) Mair .•. llinmiavii T.at'o.. 1 h*^. 411 ; 14 W.I{. l»i.); I:{ I,. T. J8(i ; 11 Jur. lOl.l - . - - . . - 441 Malam <•. Hitchonn, (1894) ;i Ch. iJ7N ; ti;i I,. J. Cli. 41 : «9I,.T. 778: .W J. 1'. 148; 17 Vox. C. <•. 7(M ; 1.1 B. Jan. 17n - 49. 7li8, 7ti9 Mallumm i\ G)>iii>ral Minoial i'utfiit Svnilicat>\ I.imitiil. M8941 :M'h. .VJ8: K\ I<. J. Ch. 8H8 ; ,1 L. 'I'. 47fi; 4H W. II. 41: 1.) K. Jan. 29fi ----... 4;,;, Mallpwn (. Xatiiiusl liiMirniico <'».. (18911 I Ch. 20l»; «;« \.. J. Ch. JHii: 70 L. T. 1J7: 42 W. U. 249; 1 Miin*ii., 249; s U. 91 - .i,s9. t>:to, (i:i*!, 1102 Malvirii I'rban Dintriet Council i. Malv««iii Link tJa* Co.. s;i I,. T. ••'-'« :M»1 .Mani'ht>Nti'r anil Ijouilon liifc AHMiirtinoi Co., Z^-, 9 K<| . »>49 - - 1418 MwnchesUT and ( )ldham UaLJi, W. \. ( 1 88,5) 1 K9 ; 44 fi. J. Ch. 92(> - 1 ;j«9 Mancht>Ht«'r Hri'Wpry Co. v. Ciximlw, hi T. f.. H. 291»: 82 1,. T. :I47 : (1901. 2 Ch. (H>8- --.... Manolu'Mtcr Ilrew«ry Co. >■. North Chi'«hirc and Manohei'tfr Browcn- Co.. (18(»») A. C. 8:{ - M»niho«tflr C(.iiM)nition .. Williamit, (1891 , I (i. 11,94; tio |,. J. 1.1 1». 2.1 ; 03 I,. T. 80,-. : .)» W. K. 302 ; .VI J. 1'. 712- Manrheator TniM r. Fiinioiw, (1893) 2 (J. U. 539 ; *H I.. J. (J. I!. 7Wi ; 73 1,. T. 110; 44 W. R. 447 fjll .ManchiMtcr Union Itauk <•. liooch, 34 L. J. Kx. VXi- - - J'.m; Manns Caw. 3 Ch. 459, n. - - - - - . »j72 Mann r. F^linburfth Northeni Tr-aui*. Co., (1893, A. C. «9 02 \. 1 I'. C. 74; tW I,. T. iW; 57 J. 1'. 245; 1 li. 8(1 (II. L.. S - 134.278. MHnniT* ' St. David'H. &c. Miut>rtiirt«r'o < '„f. ,1899'! 1 < h. 4 H (is I,. J, ( 'h. 21.1 ; 80 I.. T. 28.V 47 W K. .•,«»; tiMan«. 84 . . . . l||| MM-k« ■•. Samuel. > ImH J K. H. 287 90 1,. T,.rf«» ; 53 W. H. HM . flH7 Mariiior, I,td. iv AloXimUtr (IMHC. S, f, 78 Ct. of ,"<,«,. . 7^5, T4.5 Marnhani .. Weaver, 80 !,, T 41.' - . . _^,,-, ;J.i9 4.11 33 283 73 I,..) Ch 1457, HHI! - Hv \W, - .114 »7« - .'Mm .•20 m^H TABLE OF TAffiR. Ixxxi M»r—m»g i-'Hi Murf(iii- of Hiite'i* Cam' < iirdiff S«Tiujti» H«nk .'IHOr 2 Hi. UXl; HI i.. .1 Ph. .'MT : <«! L. T. 317 44 W. U. (.IN - - - 711 Man* ' Thomp«>n, Hii T. T. 7,W - - - - - 111 MHradan HwBsim. 'JX W. 1!. HS4 - - - - 3.W Manrnft^. *<■. <"o., 7 I h. 1«1 - 142, 710. 744. 77S, lo.'.l M!0K - . - - 3oo Mur Miii»hall r. Soiilh SulTonUhirf Tr«mwavs ( ,.. (IHHi) 2 Ch. :«! ; 72 i.. T. .-.42 - ..... .irt« ManiaJls iJmitMl -•. l-»k. 17 T. I.. U. 2f! - - - - .'HT Uanwoiiii V'ulToGewOo. •>. Muttiiiu!;, Wttiillo & *',>.. ,I!M«^ I I'li. JS7 - - - - - 7.'>, 737 747. i:i.">l». IIWI Man.U««HininTill<, /fr, 24 ( . 1'. 17 - - - 3.iM Martiii-t'iuMt. 2 H. 4c M. (Hi'.* . . - - -1444 Ifctrtii. .. lt."id, 11 C. 11. N. S. 7:«i - - - - llii.i JtMtiu . S».upi)i-«^r. SI !.. T. 117 - - - - (i«.f Wmf/^V-i- Cum-. .'S W. U. J4I . 42 I.. 1. JHC ; W. N'. ISNII .Kl I.Vl. 71.".. 7+». 7Xi» Ji»-«m's ( JM-, .ai \V. |{. .■17.H - - - - - 727 M,-Mi, A- !««♦>)' *'h. '^T. •'»"<' ----- km; SS.«-.ti . . ai*rn«, 1 1 I . 1 ». »7 - - - IHO. 7o.i l.Mio M««m .. Botor Tmftioii >'i.., [VMKk I < h. 41H: 74 I.. J. I'li. 27:t . 112 I,. T 2:»4 . - . . .Ml. 1440, 1487 .\lii«mi.iu)d l 1« \V I!. 1 l.i ; 2:i I.. ! 74». 4*» I.. J. .t:l2 ..------ ;i7 Mttxiiii X-wdrafrldt .-. .NimLnfoldt. IMHi A. c. jaA: tw I,. J. c|i ms: 71 I,. T. 4WI: II H. Jan. I (il. 1.) - - - :C't Ifcwm. Wt«,t..n C.,., VV. N. (1SN.S)2I1 - - 1270.1272 JfcM'imnlV LimitPd, (IMm) 1 Ch. jli; ti7 I.. .1. C\\. IKfi '« I. T. ■ !^: m W. l{. ;mi: 77 I,. T. l.j« - . . l;«#5 MxvniMM .-. . .m-olidat".! K.-nf ('..lliiri. - Corim., (190.1) 2 K. H. 121 ; '-.Zl.JIk n. Oftl ; sM I.. T. tl7ti; .•)2 W. It. 1 17 c A. -•ti«7. iMiK, «7". H72 Maj.irof »'.»1-m..uth .. .• .\. <'. :iti4 - - - WW Mav<«- of .'*h1*.^ >■. Ia-m-t, IMII) I H. li. ^<^s - 1(4, 141, 7*t. 14W* Mbvw of the i*t«j,|.. . Ilmik ..r KnsflaiMl, 21 H. II. !>. HWI «:S 742 Mt'ur" ' WVxIirii Cuiiiuta I'lilp ami Tafn'r Cn., IWhj 2 i ii. Uau . 74 I.. J Ch. JMl ; l»:U, T. I.W^C. A.; - - l.i, «4« M.am.nw Hr.» ■. Inland l{«viiiu.>, H2 I-. T (iWt - - - MA Mi'iMiif-^ IJr<*., Ltd. •: M. u»ur»», litlO: 2 ' h. 24>t 442. 44:i. T.W, 1#77 M.-.-.-i»(Th.\ (1N»7) A. C. -(«■ - - - - - ll»l M.ili'W"- Tniat, 2ti lt«a\. .)hft - - - ll»l Mi'ic .iiid ViitfifrV Ctt*', W. \. ;187.> 20>» - - - tiii V. I ixxxii TABLE OK CASKS. Mivruth/. (Jraj, L. B.ttt'. r-:il« - " " ' '^*' Mtlbourno Tramway* Co. v. Fiteroy Corp., (1901) A. C. 153 - 108 Molhiulo .•. Hamilton, 20 L. T. N. S. .KH ; IX W. B. 019 - - HW MclbH.lo ,: IN.ito Alenre Riil. C... L. U. » C. P. 503; 23 W. B. 57 ; ill I.. T. a- ; 43 L. J. C. P. 253 - - H». «»•*• **» Mellor .. South AuHtralian Uml, (1907) 1 Oh. 72: 95 L. T. 724: 7(iL.J. Ch. « 665, Ci« M.Iw.hkI .-. Thatihor (1S92). 2 T. L. K. Nl - - - " **'^ M. nitr ,•. n.K>mT-.-. Ttl.-jrraph W..rk», 'J Ch. :{.M); 22 W. B. 39«: 30 I.. T. 2(»!t: •»;! I,. J('l . 3.10 - 75, 5W). fMO, 7(»3. KIH, 1349, 1360 Mercantile, &c Ck. ,•. Intcmiitiuual <'ompuni<-» of Mexico, (1893) 1 Ch. 4K4 - - - - - - - •*'** Mercautilu Hank of Sydncv 741 (P. C.) Menor . . Whall {:h45), 5 Q. H. 447 - - - " Morcnunt HankiiiK C«. of Ix>nIller Steel Co.,.^ C. 1).216: 25 W. H. 457 : 3ti L. T. 3».); 4ti 1,. J. <'h. 4IM - - 42, 43, 1207 Menhant* Fire Oiliw .•. ArmstmnK, 17 1,. T. H. 709; W. N. (1901) _ lU .14.-25 Merchi-tou Steauinhij, i ... - . Tiiin.i, (1910) 2 K. II. 923 - - 102 Merwlith. fl,, «7 I,. J < h. 409 : 7S 1,. T. 492 M(nTvw».itber - IfcuBrn, (l^wa) 2 Ch. 51- til !.. J. Ch. 505; H« f ., '•. 719 ■KtW.li. f40 »Mw>v itoeki. ttoni ••■ Birkenhsad A»How>mont Com.. (19011 .\. C. Taylor, (1H93) A. C. 317: 57 J. P. . . - 1245. 1247 442 6H 442 m:, L. 93; 14 W. U. (*72; l! Hoimv I>■. Oiblw. I.. B. 1 It t>T7: 12 Jur. 571 - - - ■ " lllormv I Hicks v. I.uni., H App. C^^. si)| Monii'm an.l .Atfauu ( C, /Ir, o T. L. K. HHO ; 1 Meg. :I41 - .\l..U«lfe« t'aae. 13 C. IHv. HIS: 49 L. J. Ch. :I47 ; 42 1.. T 2« \V. n. 435 - Matniimlitan .VKviumw ilrntnl too I.. T. .17. 42 'JH. 103 It).".. M71 17N; l;j9, 14(1, 714, KiMKliam, OT. L. U. 217 - !352 Ml r71 24 M«!l i:»>.i M.tr.)p«litau. &v. Bank. /••> i-"''- l»«»vi», 1« W. K. H«K Metropolitttu Bank .. Heiron, 5 Kx. liiv. 319; JH W. E. 370; 43 L.T..i70 - - - - 42.141.144. MetroiK.litan Coal Con»uni<>r«' ."VHwHaatioii '. SnmuKour. (IH95} 2 U. 11. 'KM ; «5 K. J. U- It. 22 - - - 27H. 2H4, 400 Metropolitan Ci.al Conaumen" Co.. Wainwrif**'" < aae, W. N. ;IH9«))3 ..---- Metn.jioUtan Klw^triu Supply -•. (linder, (IWIl) 2 <^h 799 ; s4 1.. T h\H; 49 W H. .'.ON . . - - lletr .politan Klettric Tniinway.* . . Tottenham Crli»n HiiAnct. 2K T. I,. H. 234 Hawkins, 4 II. & N. !HI (1!HH)2 K. B. H«7 ■ . . Chumherii, 4 Ch. ;«« , (lf*0,i) I Ch. 207. n. ; 74 L. T. 714 - 14».i. m* MiilluiKl t '.lUnti.'H District .■. Attw.Mj.1. , l!«i5) 1 l h. 3."<7 ; 74 L. J. Ch. ■>m\: i»2 I.. T. 'MM .... - 113,444 MidUiii.l l!.«il. Co. . .Vtt.-Oen.. (1902) A. >. 171, 71 1.. J. K. U. ;il4; m h. T. 206: 50 W. U. 433 (H. 1... E.) - - ■ *»'• Mi'tnipolitan Sal nm •■ Mii'hael >'. Hart « Co. Mi« I.. T. - HO - 124S til. Mtl ; 651, 11H2 - I UK) ; inw.K. h.W, s7:» - 8ia I'rotcction Society .•H9 IDi 1.114 :H4 666 .1.17 3S7 - 666 Kig-Kor Mip>tti'» Cwi, i Eq. -JSK ; :I6 L. J. Ch. .>31 ; 16 L.T. 271 7ai - Milan Tramway (,'o., Limitol, id N7 ; 32 W. B.601 .V»5; .VtT,. J. til. 1068- Mil<*, Hr l-i'l-^. 1 I>« O. 'US Mil.H -■. N.w ZeuIaiiTl, &c. Co., :12 T. I>. .'fiS; .m T,. .T, .il I.. T. r>H-2: 34 W. H. 669 - MilU "•. Fi.wkiw, 5 UinK. N. C. 4J5 - Milln !•. The Northom BailwHy of Uueww Aynxi, a ■. Thatcher, 2 T. U. Si Mihi '■. Arijsona Copper Co., 36 S. L. H. 741 Milne* v. (Jory, 14 Vue. 406 - MiniTiil \Vut»>r llottlo Kx<'hiin);<> and Trad- Itooth. 36 C. I). 465 (C. A.) - - - - - MminK Sharps lnvo«tment Co.. (1»93~| 2 Ch. 660; 62 L. J. t'h. IIM ; 6,H I,. T. J7«: 41 W. K. 376; 3 U. 4N0 - - - I26.V MiKwiuri Sti'unmhip Co., 42 C. U. 321 .... Mitrhill's Ca»> (.Uex.), 4 App. Can. .567 . - - - Mif.h.'U i: HoynoldH, 1 Sm. I,. C. 43<» - - - - Mo.iiich .'. Kf'iiestre, 67 L. T. 7()« - Moffat '■. Farquhar, 7 < '. D. .Wl : 26 W. B. 522 ; :« L. T. 18 ; 47 I,. J. Ch. 355 - Mopil St.'ttui8hip Co. r. McOn-Kor, Oow & Co., (1K92) A. C. 25 - 114, 117 Molinpanx «•. Ixindon, &e. Inmiramv Co., (liM)J) 2 K. H. 5H9 ; 71 I,. J. K. B. 818; 87 L. T. 324 ; ..l W. B. 36 (C. A.) - 720, 721, 723, 724, 7:»0 Molvn.ux r. Hawtny, (l!t03) 2 K. It. 4S7 ; 72 L. J. K. 11. 873; 89 I,. T. 3.50; M \V. B. 23 (C. A.^ - - - - .131, 'Wi Mulyneux -. Bichif-1, (llMHi) I Ch. ;14 ; i»3 U. T. 698 ; 54 W. B. 177 - :J55 MoiiryiM-nny r. Mum-yimnny, 9 H. L. C. 146 Monro '■. Taylor, 8 lla. .»l - MontaiKnac' r. Shitta, 15 .\pp. Can. 357 ... MonUttiorr 1. Gut. Ijpbt'nthal. (1898) 1 H. B. 487; 78 L. (<". A.)' .Montreal I.itho(,Taphinfr Co. i: Sabigton, (1899) A. C. 610; 68 I, i\ V. 121: 81 L.T. 13.; (A. C.) Moorn HroB. & Co., Hi. Itartholmni'wV CafM'. 7!» I.. T. 70 MiHiro c. Kxplomvcs '"<).. 56 L, J. Ch. 235 . - - Moori' r. North VV..«t Bank. (1891 i 2 Ch. oIW ; CO L. J. Ch. 627 : I,. T. 4,-xi: 40 W. H. !i3 ..... M'">ri' • VoiiKhton. Stark. 4S7 . . . . - M.>id<\ , f'arn.-y & ('..., Ltd and Bim1uc.-.1, 51 I.. T. 736 M..i(f.ui» BivworvCo. i: Cro>und. den. n,nnih>ig Co.. 13 »i. H. D. 8.32 (C. A.) MoriHon .. Thompwm, I,. B. (J. B. 480; 22 W. U. 859; 30 1.. T. wy 43 I. J. Q. 1!. 215 ..... - ,J94 - 595 - 1159 - 769 T. 406 362, 782 J. 451, I.W IN8, 189 - 192 61 - 6.52 - 119.-J - l;!0« &H 1021 733 Ixzxiv TABLE OK CASES. 9 Kor— Xut fAOk llunvU >'. Oxford Portlaml Cuioeiit ( <>.. M T. I.. B. HH'i - TH, 72A, 728 MorriB r. MorrtH, W. N. (IH77) B - - - - - KWl MorriMin, Br, Morriiioii >: MomMm. (I9UI) I Cb. 701 ; 7U L. J.Ch. ■.im : HI L. T. -JM ; iV W. U. ^41 ; 8 Man*. 210 - 940. lOOJ MuiTiMiii r. Trufcteen, *c. Cor]>oration, «N L. J. t'h. U ; "!♦ L. T. iHtS ..... ~ . -6m tiortitafcv IiiHiiraiiCf Corjioratioti >'. Canadian Agricultural, &c. Co., (nM)l)2('h. .177 ...... 1364 Morton » . Copeland, 1« C. U. .i:i5 .... - 1(M7 Moi-iuh ConsoU, *r. Co.. ■• Ch. Div. 1 ; 24 W. I!. 490 ; H.l I,. T. .>17 : 4,5 T.. J. ("h. 14N ...... T:i;| Mcwl.'v <•. Crwwv'H r^m.lon Co., 1 ]-.,\. iM: 14 W. K. '.MH - - I« Mowl.y .. Koffyf.mtein Mini*(i;, (HHil) •.» Ch. 10« ; 7.J I,. J. Cli. Wit ; !»l L. T. '.'«', : :>:i W. K. 1 »l> - fiO, n.!, 4/«ir^, .t l»o«J. & Sm. JiW - - . - - 118« Mosta. «f. fIIHM> 2 K. H. 307; TJ L. J. K. ». 7tH ; !>2 I-. T. 777; 43 W. K. 558 - . - - - - - \-iMt Mouuft, /{i; (!s(t«) I Ch. 831 ; 8() L. T. 400; 47 W. R. 40fl . - 1;J.V4 Moud.-t -•. Coll.. r.. K. s Ex. .r.': 21 W. K. 17.-.; 27 I,. T. «7n : ^2 L. J. Kx. H - - . - - . - ;i J8 Mount Moiffan, •>« 1.. T. ti22 ... - 191,200 MountHt<>]>Iif-n >'. Lakenian, L. U. 5 U. li. UI3; 7 li. I.. 17 - - 1248 Mowatt r. Ca«tlr> .Sti-ol. 4c. Co., 34 C. I». .58; 53 L. T. (WJ - - fij Moxlmiit •. ». 74, l;!57. l;t,w. 135it Miiir r. Citv of Glasgow Bank, 4 Apji. Cii«. 337 ; 27 W. K. <>03 ; 40 J,. T. .139 - - - - - ~ - 652 Mullen >■. I,. ('. C, 51 Sol. J. H2 .... .1:178 Mullpr « Cn.'ri Margarine r. Inlunil Revenue, (19(M)) 1 U- IS. 310; 09 I,. J. (}. B. 291 ; SI I,. T. 6<17 (»'. A ) ; (IfM)l) A. C. 217 - 310 Mnllett r. I'nitp-.l Frenrh I'dlwhcrf" So«!i«jtv, 91 L. T. 133; 20 T. I,. U. 59.-, - - - -" - - .115 Mur.ioiiMil FmhoM, &i: Co. r. IVIlington, 59 I,. J. Ch. 7;t4 : fKl r,. T. 23S ; 2 Nfpjf. ;«)7 - - . - 72.3, 7f!0. 871, 872 Mnnicipality of i'i.toii .■. (Wilnrt, (IH93> .\. C. .V.'4 - - - I7i> Munroe, Kr ,„i,U, 1 (J. H. !). 724 - . - - - i!7 Muiister V. CaniintU Co., 21 C. U. 18c ,0 W. R. 312; 47 I.. T. 44 . 51 T4. J. Ch. 731 .... 7;i,i, 7:1;, i;|,i7, hoa Munt I'. Shrfwnliuri- and Chtn«t«r Rail. Co., 13 Btav. 1 - 33, 457, 405 Muntz Metal Co., A. rf, 18 W. R. imn ... - 7(W Muris /■,■> /"ir/.. 2 Cox. 07 - - - - - 705 Mumiv 1: IliiHh. t; II. 1,. ,)3: 22 W. R. 280; 29 I,. T. 217; 42 L. J. cfi. .■.><(! - ..... «70, 7.'2, 744, n7« Mnrnv .■. Flavill, 2.') C. I»iv. s!i; .Vl I.. .1. Ch. is.-i; 19 I,. T. r90; .12 \V. li. 102 - - - - - - - 149 Murray .. Scott. 9 App. Ca». 519 - - - 003, 1 198, 1H«J Muto»co|M. and Hiogniph Syndicatf, 181W) I Ch. 8(8!; 08 L. J. Ch. 417 ; 81 L. T. 22: 17 W. R .V.'d : fi ManK. 29« - . 755, 7'<4 Mutf<'r 1'. Ku«f4'iu. 4r. Co.. 3'l C. I». 92 - - «8N. 771 Mutton i\ Peat, (1900} 2 I'h. 79: 82 I,. T. 440; 4N W. R, 480 . 1192 91 IWTh I'AHLE UK CAHE8. xxxv Miitonl Aia 1'. B. Buililing ScK., Ht, 2« i h. li. 182- - - 1198 Mutual Ij-au Sockty .'. liUiUow, i l'. B. N. 8. M9 - - - 1247 Mutual Kewrve Fire i: New York lafe, 75 L. T. 52N - - 441 Mv'xk '■ Heataon, 13 (". U. 3HS; 2M W. H. 31»; 42 L. T. 141 ; 49 ■ I.. J. Ch. 127 I4t>0 M.v.'i> .•. Saril, :» El. 4 Kl. .MW .^96 Myliim I Market Ilarborounh Ailv.-itmnn Co., (19. 53*; .W L. J. fh. 711 ; 111 L. T. 453 : 37 W. K. 7»4 ; 1 Me^. :H7 - - - 1444 2ti W. U. 124, 13!t, 142, 7Iti, 13,i2, i-evi'i-uHl bv li. !<.. l.j !)««■., 177, 211.'). 214 T. 376; I Mutl^. 4.)«; 10 It. '•. I'auliiie Syn\.u Hi,. T. 07S(1'. f.1 .icat«, (IWMl A. ('. 120; 73 N. Niiiit-v-<41o and Klaiiia Iron Work* c. Onive, 12 f. 1>. 73.>> .■MM; ;1HL. T. 345 - - "" '"" "' Niwh .. Calthonw, (1»«5) 2 »1i. 237 lWt5 . . - - .^■u^NiU riioniiliat.- Co., 2 C. [>. 210 - N8-*uu SU'iiii. I'lftw ■ . Tyler, 70 L .)H2 Niiliil \mui\. &< . C< I,. J. 1'. C. 22; «» I.. T. 07S( Natiou.)! Anns Cc. W. N. 11897) 31 Nath.iiul Hank of Chimt, Timen, Fob. 14, ItMiu N,iti(.iml Bunk ..f WuUw, (18»») 2 Ch. H^Sl : am»7j r,. J. Ch. 222; 7(i L. T. 1 ; 45 W. H 401 - _. . . 8«4. K'i. 874, N79. SS4, N8!> NatKitiiil, &<•. Btink -■. (liiiuu.., 31 C. I). .J82 - - - 12111, NatioMul Bi.il.r luHurMnce Co.. (1892) 1 Ch. 3tM, . 'il L. J. Ch. MH ; ti5 L. T. H49 ..----- National Coftw I'ab.ce, Vr, 24 C. U. 307 ; 32 \V. B. 23ti ; M I.. T. :W: .-i3I,. J. Ch. 57 '^^*^ Niitional TM»iituw Coqx.ration, «c. (IXitI) 2 Ch. 505 ; (K> I,. J. Ch. .«3; tH li. T. 512; 30W. H. 707 . . . - National PwolliliK" SUini{« .Sicietv t-. HvkeH, (1894} 3 Ch. 139; »i3 L. J. C mm. 42 W. II. fWi ; rManH.457; W. N. ;i894) 127 : s R. 75s National KxrhanRO Co. /'. l>nw. 2 MmMj. I(W ; 25 L. T. 223 - 41 National l-unil't AsMjranco Co.. 10 < '. 1>. I IH ; 27 W. U. Mr2 ; ;«» 1,. T. 420 ; 48 L. .! . < h. Ui;t - - - 714, 7Hfl, 787. 859 National Motor Mail « (MMih < "., 1 1908) 2 « h. 228 ; 99 L. T. 3;«4 ; 77 I-. J. Ch. 7Wl - - 15. 18. 19. 139, 148, 149, 199, 25^. 322, 323, 3«ll. t>18, 748, 7.i9, 8;i!». National i'. B. B. Hoci.ty, //f, 5 Ch. :KH» . - - National rhono^raph Co. of A'l-tmlia r. Mnnck, 27 T. I.. K. 2Ji» - National I'honoftranh Co. r. l->liH.n Bi-ll C,,.. (lOOK) 1 Ch. 33.i ; !•« L. T. 291 ; 24 T. li. R. 201 - - - —158. 424 National I'lovimia! Bank ami Mar«l», ^1895) 1 Ch. 190 Naitonal IroTiucial Brnik, Kx purtt, Itc R<»!H, 17 C. JJ. 98 - National I'mviucial Bank, lU fxiHt, Itr iituM. 1S9«^ 2 W. B. I?, iw I.. J. U. B. 481 ; 74 L. T. :t8.i; 44 \V. 1!. 588; 3 Mani.. 1 ..> - Nutiunal l-roriniial Bank -•. Mai-hall, \V. N. (|892) 34; 40 C. 1' •.12 - 7»W, 897 1217 Kilt T41 25 !2A9 Tirj , 772 '. ^72 ■JSI , 11172 !I»8 ;UH .444 350 I24M 1J48 Mm IXXXTI TABLK or CABKH. Pi M ?r J-' (1900) aril. 2HI) - • ii-to Vat Haw N.itioiiul SM'uty for Diiitnbutuiii, »V( . i . Oibl)- Natioiiul S|K.rtiiiK Club r. Cojh', 4H VV. K. 44« Xittiniiul Stiinilitnl Life IiiHurmiiM' Co., 'JT T. L. ii. Jil Nutiiiiiul ri'l('|ihc>ii(' Co. I'. I. It. Comiiiiniiiont-n, «! I.. T. jiti; 47 VV. U. 247 - National Trui>t«H> lit .^ui-tniluHiii r. Oi'iicral Fiiianrs Co.. (11(04) A. I". ;t7:J: W L. T. 7:»i: >i \V. H. I - - - - 71.>. NuvuMium- .•. Bn.wnriKJf. 2 DrU. M. A «i. 419 - - 12-.\iii('ri(^iii I und MortKiM(<'-VK<*i"'V Co., ^1NU7) 1 Cli. l.K): H■. < 'ity nf Oluaf^ow Kunk. 4 .\|i|>. • ^nl^. 021 - Npttlc«hi|i, A'j /-«.fr, 2 M. 1>. & l>«»i. 124 - . . . NptiI r. I'liio ArU Insuraiiic Co., Limited. {1N95) 2 Q. 15. 40 ; 72 L. T. 52.-> ..... :iH. New, /;.. /.V I,oitvtn, lit Morlev, ..IHOI) 2 Ch. .»34 . N<'W llalki^ K<'n-t< Vwtt >. Huii'lt (i .hi Mining; Co , (1904) A. C. 4(M; 7.t I.. J. K. B. .' . ; >M !.. T. 194 ; .V2 W. H. 3«l - 060, ««1. New ItniiiHit ilk r. MugtfurMli^, , 1 Dr. 4 Mm. IlHIi . Npw KruuKwick Rail. Co. i'. Conylwurc, t» II. I,. C. 711 ; III W. R. :«».), i; L. T. UY.i . ;u L. J. cb "'7 - 41. 1n7, i«2, -.mo, New Chile ( o., 4.-I C. I>. olW ; 0:i I,. 1'. 344 : •«• \V. I!. .W - CMI. mi N<« ' t»iliunlt Co.. 4.J C. D. ;1N : .W W. R. 97 - Nrw Kix'iiix CoiapttKiiio 1'. (leiioml Areident Corji.. (1911) 2 K. U. B19 .-...-. . N6W FU->»affCo.. /;»•, W. N. (1NH9) 12a - - 1445, 14.>1, Npw I.OII iou and lit i/iliaii Bank '-. Lrocklebuiik. 21 C. 1>. 302 ; •'<() W. R. 422 ; 47 L. T. 3 : 51 I,. J. Ch. 711 - 051. B«2. WW N»w Ori.nfal Bank «.'«•. 41 W. R. 1« N» w Qu 'liruitu Co., Fontifex'ii d «". 15 '-V. 1(. 965 : IV-mbei-toii <«i!i: W X. ;i:.HN)233- .... :27o, K-w l!n-rCo r llprifonl Union. (1901)2 K. U. tw»: 70l,. J.K B. 7411; N5 L. T. 1.12; 49 W. It. r,Ui . 1902) 2 K. B. .V>7 - Nvw Smiliroro Phosphatp Co. .■. Erluii){pr. '> C, |t. 7;i ; ;J App. Ca». 121S; 25 W. R. 436; 27 W. R. «)>; .W I..T. 222, .19 1,.T. 2H9; 4H L. J. Oh. 425 ; 4H T, J. Ch. 73 123, 139. 142, 143, 229, 240, 241, 742. 1351. NpwTranmaal Co.. (1H9«) 2Ch. 7.>ti . . . . Npw Univpniit.v nub. 1» (i. B. I). 720 - Nrvr Wpi«tminntpr Urewory Co., 5« S. .1. ! M Npw York Bn-werien Co. i: Attomev-Ucnpral, (1N99) A. C. 02 ; UK I.. J. U. B. 135; 79 L. T. iW: 48 W. R. .32; 63 J. I'. 179 (U. L., K.) 42 New York Bwurity and Tnut Co. r. Keyner, (1901) 1 Ch. tHH> ;!7» .i67 1441 :is| 1402 1210 i 258 I .'.. Z^', i '•''''•>. i'„. JflJ ; «S 1,. r'.-.n:!; M W. U. ij" ■ ' N.wMw"' *'"■*''"• •■• Arni-7. All, «>:i, tiW. «77, U:i». UVt. I I.Vi - II IN :MH; 77 1,.T. «<•:«: - Ul»7 !. 17'.' Cli. 4tt ! l.'il ni I, .1. 1.'>4H 'i.'i I .-Ml l.MI ,10 r. f». ;m:» 4(i7 111, 744 - :i.>h •.1)7. •-•■.i'.' 72 . 765 - MI'S - :»() ■ill N.wliiiK '• \>',UU. 1» 1.. T, ION; UN I.. J. fh. Ill - N.wiiian. /.', A. /""•'. lti.H.k.% M C I>. 4!tl - N.wiiiun rCiwMKiJ *•'"••(''"'•'') ' <'h. •«•">; 'H I.. •' <'1> I,. T. ii»7 : 4;i W. It. 4M.I - - - Niwimm '. <>,i(tlitini, (lllll; 1 K. H. 7!t2 N.wtim r. llirinii>(.'limn SiniiU Xrmx *'».. (1!<«I) l' ''h •i''* - Kicholl .-. K\.-iliunlt. til I.. T. 4S1I - - - - Nuhol'. «ii;.l r. (l.ii.iul Uni..ii of (),!. Tutiv.. iuiiKiil.n., 10:1 I.. T. 4.> - 113 NiK-i M.i. l.rtiifH . . Capi^r, IH V. I). ^J7, t.. • J.'. W. U. m'J - Ul I Ni...l« t aii.l 1 '..«•■< I'.mtroct. AV. IWt.i^ 1 ili .WI - - :110, :«1 Nitiu-l'h.wphaU'l .W. N. (!«>» 41 Nixun'» NavigBtion (\>.. (1»97) I h. NT:' ; «»M. 7tt 7)U .1. ('!). Iitti - 1311 ■ ii-ia. 1J.>7. VMi UN). 101 ! . M> - \1-J» '.Hi. 07 Xi/aiu Ifail. r... r Wyatt, IM (i. U- I> VJ-* N...,k.H .-. Itir.., ilSMfJ) S. V. •>\ -! K .;. <\\. i;i!': Mi 1. " ■•- W. 1!. :i4i.-nll. I.., v..) . - - ■ • N.>l«t I>yi.ainit.' Tni»t f... <-. \Vy«t lNt»3] \' W i<. :il W. U. .i^-- -- L T. 400; ,>aL. J. ("h. 1»» ..... NonLiifililt (Maxim) ••. NoH.uMilt. [IHM] A. * .WA ; i... !. ). ' h. WW ; 71 L. T. 4H9 , 1 1 n. Jan. 1 H. L. Nonuaii, «., \V. X. (IW'O) tJ» Noiiiiun . . Mitcholl, 10 lUniv. ■J7h ; d Ih- O. M. i U. MH : 2 W. B ■J47, (WO - - - '"•'• '**■ Norniaiidv --. iiul, <'.".|m' & «'".. (HHW; i < li. h4 ; 97 L. 1 H7a ; 24 r. I,." U. 47 - ■ 21>, 75, ti»l. 724, 72ti, 7:12, WMJO. 1 140. HH« North llrazilian Supir Factiirien l'<>.. 37 ('. I»i». "^7 : M t.. T. TZi>: w. N. (IHN7) ;i - - - - - "2- '••'" North Hriti-h, Ac. «'o. '. l.U.yd. 10 Ex, 42.1 - - 1106, UIW North llritwh Rail. Co. r. T.id, 12 <1. 4 Fin. 722 - - ■ IM 347 ia«2 14«M> IxxxTiii TABLE or CAMEM. M«n'. Maniho»U)r Hrew«i7 Co., (1890) A. C. HH : AH 1.. .1. iTi. 74 ; :» I.. T. t»:> (H. L., E.) *i'i,m North of EnKland Sti>amihip Co.. (IflOa) 2 Ch. 4.'.; 74 L. J. 11>. 4()4 : 9.1 I.. T. 1 : i3 W. U. 499 (C. A.) - «9«. »M». > hiiuii '■. Ilonion, 4 II. L. C. 1W7 (hnniiiiii I n Vi-otnu-iit Co., (INOJ) 2 til. \2' - OiiK mill .Ml 8iiku(<« Akhoc., W T. 1.. ». •174 IhihloWH I'luin, i" L. J. Ch. 33» • mininiiii to. r. KowT. (IHU?' A. C. 124; «1 L. J. Ch. ;i;i7 ; iMi L.T. U- ; 41 \V. B. IK) ;H. I..) - .W, «», «l. nh.>im«r ,: AtteiihowuKh. (1IX«) 1 K. "t. Til ; !W I..T. »4 ; •.24 T. I.. II. 114 '**■ •-"' ( )liIK uhi-mior i-. Uritish iiud Fomin< Co., j«iih.iiii.T .'. Kiazer, (IW)"} '.' K. B. .M» : '•7 I,. T. .1 i't T. 110 1147 .. 1{. I20», I'JIO - I KM tl.W - 1247 i;i.'Ki i:ill 47, Olrou Mortgajr. Co.. ll»>0) S. C. IHH. Ot. of 8..W.. - Orii'iiUl Hank Corporation, 2» C. K. «43 ; 42 I-. T. 170. 172: .H I.. J. Ch. ;K7 Orintiil Finamiul Corji. r. OveT^>u I.. T. N. H. HVi; 41 I,. J. Ch. .a: Ori. htul Inland SteHm Co. ,: Hriitgn, 2 J. & II. 024 ; 4 I), (i. V. & J. m : tn I,. J. Ch. 241 ; 10 W. It. 125 - - - '7. OriM.tulT.U'phonoCo., W. N. (IBOI) IJU . - - - Orl.un-MoU.rCo., (lllll)2Ch. 41 - - - - "l". C)nn.r.Hr« Cane (Hur\ey'B Oydti-rCo.), (1894) 2 Ch. 474 ; 03 L. J. Ch. :,:h- 70 I,. T. 704; 12 W. H. 701 ; I Mant' I.W: H R. 715 2h!t. 2m Oniani.iiUl WcMKlwork Co. ,-. lirown, 2 II. & C. 2 nvcreua, Ouniey & Co. .■. N 113 737 ttl4lf-l^. J xe TABLE OF CASKS. FIOS 1200 1020 Owe- Pat Owen V. Roberta, 57 L. T. nI Owner.', lloopor, 89 L.T.i;iO - " ^^ ^^_ .. Oxfora IS.iil.ling Sr°7-,?r' 7 •' 7^^ 7r.(!, Sfil, 871, Hi)K, 90 Ansuranc- •V'^"^i''t^''' • -" ' • ' ''V ''' ■.m: J5L. T. 774: ol h. J. ( h. ..44 - Paige's Caso, LJ W. 1!. s9-2 - " .',,,,. ",,^ ,.■ {, :j.,.5 Pain., r. ( V..k C,,., (l!«H)) 1 Ch, :iOS ; H-> 1.. 1. 44 , IN ^\ • U- -i-' Pttinef. M.Uor, ti V.s. :!»!» - - " Pake.. Thoativ Liiuitoa ^Simpson ■•.), bJ 1- 4- •" PalmiT <•. Eiui-mm, (1911) 1 Ch. 7i.K Palmer -•. Johi.s• ^^l " " Palm.T .-. Mulk'tt, :5.i C. D- 411 : o. 1- J- <-!>■ -'-'' Pain ..r r. Wick StoumshippiuK Co. . ,mi) A, < . .ilK Pan;;!l-cific C;. ... maia Rubber Co., 10 CU, 51. - 73:. 1400 Paudoni Theatre, 2H S. J. 23H Pane- ('. Att.-Geu., (1901) 1 Ch. IJ ' ' .., t T -nfi • Su^vC Case, (..mi) 1 Ch. .00 : .5 L. J. Ch. 104 : -3 L. T. O06 . 44 "W. R. 107 - - - ' _ . Parish r. I'urish, oi I-. T. 37 - " " Park C.ate Wupp.n ^''-'/^^-^H-.f " '. ". 0-4, 690. 763 Park V. Lawt.m, (.911) 1 K. B. oSH Park .-. Rovulties Svndicate, (1912) 1 K. B. 3.iO Parker, 7v;/".'(s 2 Ch. 685: 15W. U. 121. Parker ,■. Guiuess f;^-^;. ^,;';;.-b. ,,,;, .,, j,. T. 199 - j::t:::S:;::'o"rAp;."is:23w.R.27i:3iL,T.7:^^ 44 1>. J. N9 : 3S L. J. Ch. 412 ------ . 19H, 199 Paxtoii r. IJaiid, (1X93) 1 Q. U. lliU ; 02 L. J. Q. U. ITfi; 07 L. T. ti2;{; 41 W. B. US; oR. 129 - - - - -1342 raxtou & «'o. i: Siu'lliu^r, Lumpard & Co., (I'.IOIJ A. (.'. 30, 311 - 4,j3 Payuf (David) & Co., (1904) 2 Ch. UOK ; 73 L. J. Ch. 849 (( . A.) - (i86 Payne r. Cork Co.. (1900) 1 Ch. 308 - 031. 080. 7Nti. 1440. 1457, 1487 Pcabody Miinufr Co., W. X. (1897) 171' - - - 583, 78,i i'liik nil! Coldtield, Ltd.. K.i i>'d c. Ward. TiiiU'K, 24 April, 1902- (1902)2K. B. 1; 87L. T. 50 - - - - - 44 Pearl r. Deacon, 24 lieav. 1S6; 1 Do O. & J. 401 - - - 1192 Pearson'H CaHe, 4 C. D. 222 ; 5 C. D. 3.30 ; 25 AV. R. 018 ; 40 L. .1. Ch. .339- .... 139, 714, 722, 7.33. 13,)2 Pearson r. Pearson, 27 C. Div. 145; 32 W. R. 1000; 51 T.. T. 311 ; 54 L. J. Ch. .32 - - - - - - - 3j7 Pea.se i: Courtney, (1904) 2 Ch. 503; 91 L. T. 341 ; 53 W. E. 75 - 355 Peat <■. Chiyton, (1900) 1 Ch. 059 ; 94 L. T. 465 ; 54 W. R. 410 - fi52 Pedlar r. Road Block Co., (1905) 2 Ch. 427 . - - 470, 601 Peek /•. Derry, 37 C. Div. 541 ; 57 L. J. Ch. ;i47 ; 59 L. T. 78; 36 W. R. 899; 14 App. Cas. 337 - 20, 189, 195, 203, 205, 206, 207, 208, 210, 215, 229, 240, 1350 Peek V. Uunuy, L. R. 6 H. I,. 401; 22 W. R. 29; 43 L. J. Ch. 1!» - - - 142, 180, 185, 186, 188. 197, 203, 204 Peel's Case, 2 Ch. 674 ; 15 W. K. 1100; 16 L. T. 780 ; .36 L. J. Cl\. 7.»" - - - 24, 25, 77, 196, 197, 239, 242, 471, 598 Peel V. L. & N. W. Rail. Co., (1907) 1 Ch. 5; 95 L. T. 897; 23 T. li. R. 85 - - - - . 469, 705. 708, 8,i5 Pe^ge /■. Neath District Tramways Co.. (1898) 1 Ch. 183; 40 W. R. -'^=' - - - 1240 Pell's Case, 5 Ch. 11 ; 39 L. J. Ch. 120; 21 L. T. 412; 18 W. R. 'i\ - - - - 59, 60, 02, 331, 478, 485, 94.> Pellatt's Ca.so. 2 Ch. 527 ; 15 Vy. R. 726 ; 10 I,. T. 442 ; 36 L. J. Ch. 61:5 51,25- Polly and Jacobs' Contract, 80 L. i. 45 - . - . 354 Pelly's Ca.so, 21 C. D. 4 .' 712 Penarth Pontoon Co., \t. ^1911) 240 . - . -1095 Pender i\ Lushington, 6 C D. 70 ; 46 L. J. Ch. 317 - 633, 006. 7ol 703, 704, 1356, 1357, 1300,' 1,361 Peninsula Co. f. Fleming, 27 L. T. N. S. 93 ... 47fj Peninsular and Oriental Co. r. Leslie, 82 L. T. 137 ; 79 L. T. 118 - 100 Peninsular and Oriental Co. v. Tsune Kijima, (1895) A. C. 66'. - 1,347 Penney, Hx jiarte, 8 Ch. 452 ; 21 W. R. 186 ; 28 L. T. l.iO ; 42 L. J. Ch- 1H3 ----.. G47. 671, 1390 Penney ?■. I'ickwick, 16 Beav. 240 . - . . . 770 Penrose v. Martvr, P,. B. & P, 499 ; 2.S L. J. Q. B. 2S 3 Jur N S :<«a - " ' - ".MO. 7.W xcu TABLE OF CASKS. n r ' . B Pep- Pie PAOB Pi'pe c. rity and Suburban I'prmanont Building Society, (1893) CCh. •f" - - - - - - " - tiSg, 640 I'lTcival .. Wright, (1!M)L>) ■> Ch. 4l'l ; 71 L. J. Ch. 840; 51 W. 1!. •"------ .588, 647, 712, 747 I'irkins, /,'., AV /mrte Mcxiciin Santa Uuibaru Mining Co., 24 n. n. 1). Meg. 1!»7 : 7M. H. H. ;i2 «,M,(iti2, titJU Perl.v ,■. SaallVld, (1N«2) 2 Ch. 149 ; fil L, J. t'h. 409 ; (Mi L. T. 6t>(i; 40 W.Ii. .-,48 (C, A.) 358 I'i'iTins /•. n.-llamy- (1899) 1 Ch. 797: 80 I,. T. 478: 17 W. K. ■*•'------- 715, 1402 r>riys Ca.-e, 34 L. T. 717 - - - - . - 714 riny .-. liarnett, lo(i. B. D. .iSS - - . . - (>69 I'.rry .•. I'loviucial Ba.nk of Kngland, (litlO) 1 Ch. 264 - - 1247 Peruvian Guano Co., «c Kemp, (1894) Jt (^h. 090; 03 L. J. Ch. 818; 71 T.. T. 611 ; 43 W. J?. 170; 1 Manson, 423 ; 8 B, 544 - 724, 824 Peruvian Hailwa.vs Co. ,■. Thames, &v. Co., AV Peruvian Railways Co., 2 Ch. 617; 15 W. R. 1(^2; 16 'j. T. 644; 36 L, J. Ch. »M - - - - ■ 457, 471, 306, 507, 510, 747 IVtcrs '■. Audor.son, 5 Taunt. 59(i - - . . . uoo PevevilOold Minois. (1898) 1 Ch. 223; li. W. R. 198; 77 I,. T. '"'■' - - - - 381, 593, 631, 640, 786, 1445, 1457 I'liarniaceutical .Society r. London Supply Ass., 5 App. Cas. 802 ; 49 1,. J. (1. H. 736 : 43 I,. T. :m ; 28 W. R. 957 ; 45 J. P. 20 - 44, 210 Phillips /■. Homfray, 24 C. I). 439; .52 L. J. Ch. 833; 49 L. T. 5- •■*^ W. R. 6 14.2, 207, 222 Pha'nix Bessemer Co.'s Case, 44 L. J. Ch. 683; 32 L. T. 854; 1 *-'• I>- 1.>1 - - - - - . 4(i8, 1.500 Phionix Electrie Light and Power Co., /{e, 48 L. T. 260- 31 W. R. ••i9^ 700 Phosphate of Lime Co. r. Green, li. R. 7 C. P. 4;j - . . 42 Phosphate Sewage Co. r. Ilartmont, 5 C. I). 394; 37 L. T. 9- 47 L. .1. Ch. 661 ---.-.. 7;ja Photograi)hic Co., He, 23 C. D. 370 ; 31 W. K. 509 ; 48 L. T. 454 ; 52 I.. J. Ch. 654 - - - . . - 1416 i'iekard r. Sears, 6 Ad. & K. 469; 2 X. & P. 488 - - - 1110 Pickering ,: Stephenson, 14 Kq. 322 ; 20 W. R. 654 ; 26 L. T. 608 • 41 L. J. Ch. 493 - - - . . - 789 Pidcock '•. Bishop, 3 I J. & C. ()05 - - . . . 1197 Piercy, In n, [IHdl) 1 Ch. 289 - - - . . 1257 Piggot c. Cubley, 15 C. IS. N. S. 701 - - - - 1195 Pike .-. Ongley, 15 U. B. D. 710 - - - . . ■j:;4 Pimlico, &c. Tramway Co. r. A8Kes>ment Committee of Greenwich Cnion. 9 (i. B. 9 - - . . . . ]o,ij Pincknry & Sons' Steanisliip Co., (1892) 3 Ch. 125 - - - 1283 PinetetCie. -•. Maison Louis Pinet, Limited, (1898) 1 Ch. 179; 67 L. .1. Ch. 41 ; 77L. T. 613; 4(i\V. E. 506 - - - 431 Pinkett r. Wright, 2 Ila. 120; 12 Ct. * Fin. 764; 12 L. J. Ch. 119; 6,)ur. 1102 I ,j«2 Pinto .Silver Mining Co., 8 1'. D. 273: 26 W. R. 622- .38 L T, 366 47 L. .J. Ch. ,591 Ill', 1451 Pitturd r. Oliver, (1901) 1 Q. li. 474 - . . 097 Plaiiitow Wurkiug Men's Club ••. llarrod, (1910) 1 K. H. 582 - .567 Pledge r. Buss, Johns. 663 1247 TABLE OF CASES. xcni PAUE - 20/5 - lis; Pol— Pry rolhill I. Walter, ;j H. \- Al.1. 1 H - . . . rollard, Kj /larle, 4 J)eac. L'T - - . rominory and Oreno i: Apfhoipr (1N.S6,\ :>!'> L. T. Jl Poole, .liuksoii and White's Caw (187.S), i) di. D. :'.22 I'oolo i: National Hank of China, (liidT) A. C •>•><(• "i(i 1 x nn'i" •-•KT. I,. 11. -,<;; . 11,7, ,,,9, ,^.,; ,^.;^ l:i'i<,,ijoo; ,2,;^, „ , T. ■ . ,, , '-"1, I'ill' I'lxiloy r. Driver, ■) C. 1). -|,-,H I'op..,-.nawtroj.lTT.I..l!.71T;.5I..T.20:i " '. u,iH. vZ roplmm c. I'cckhiini, 7 II. & X. ,sill . . . ,., - Popular I.ifo A>sun.nc<'{'o., //, ,-., (19()») 1 Ch. H(l ... y...[ I'oital /. Kniinons, 1 C. V. I). I'Ol, (KH . . _ ' ''' Portulis /■. Totloy, ,-. C. Eq. ,-HO - . . ' !l"„- PortufTii.s.. C.pjKT Minix Co., IJ ( ■. J)iv. Kil : .is |,. .1. rli Nl.i" lAI^K. .4(, - - - . 50, 710, 7)0, 741, I.W 1 osta-o Stamp Automatic Delivery Co., (189l> .-J Ch ,ViO • (il I I ,. .1'!^ '''V ''"/'• '^- '' = " ^^- "• -" - "'•^- •'«^- «'^. TU. 722. I;i52 lostl.'thwait.. -■. I'„i-tI'hilipCo.,4;f C. I). 4.-.2: ,•,!! I. .( el, o,,, . ,j„ I.. T. 00.- ;m W. It. 24.i; 2 .M,.;r. 10 - 1440. 1441, 14 ('i, 144." 1487 Potter '■. Kdwurds, 20 I,. .1. Cli. 4liS . . . ,„ Powell an.l Thomas ,■. Kvaii .l<,nes ,^C„., (Mfoj) 1 K. M. II . T.n n,':,', Powell >•. Itrodhurst, (I'Mii; 2 Ch. 100 . . _ ' — Powell .. |,„nd. \- I'rov. Itank. (IHiCIl 1 CIi. Old: (!,s!t;i) L> Ch. ,■„-,,-, - ) 1 (i. )!. 710- (Jn | I ,. f 477 : ,s.. I.. T. ,->o.. : 47 W. It. 419 : Man.,'. 1 "7'(. M'.) iVi Power r. lloey, 19 W. R. 910 PowiT '■. O'Connor, 19 W. 1{. 92.'t - - . I *" Powers ,: Fooks, 17 (i. li. 1». ,-,.i7 - - . ! ' 'iT> Prefoutuine ,-. (Jrenier, ;i907) A. C. lol ; 9,} L. T. 02;i ; S.i T. I,. U Premier ( yeUi ( 'o. -■. Prenjier Tuhe ( o.. 12 T. I,. P. (m . ' | -,1 Premier Indu.strial Hank --. Carlton Manufaeturinf; Co.. f 19091 I CI," 107: (1909)1 K. p. n,n . . - . "■„ -,.. Premier Imlnstrial IJank. Ltd. ,•. .1. * W. Crahtr ':, T 1! l"- ' ' " ,1909)1 K. li. io(i . . . . •- -.j^'-.Jj'^; j^._^ PiV5.eutt. Dimsdale ,»i ('„. ,, lj„„l, „,■ K„^,l,„„i, (,sj,:j) j ^^ ,,' 'j]. j' _' ,^i'., I're^eivatiou Synrlioate, (189.); 2 . 08.j - - Ol») - IISO XCIV I'ABLK OF CASES. Pry-fttii PAOB riyoo.l.moB '•. Williams, (I'JOJ) •-' eh. .51 : - - - - 112 'A-yco -•. IJuiy, -2 Ihow. 42 - - - - - - llH.- riickloV, ( 'use, I.. J. N. (". (1N7J) 19 ... - ti7] I'ligh iinil Shiiniiiiu's Case, !:» E(|. lilili ; 11 I,. J. Ch. .'iSO ; 2fi I.. T. 271 ..-..- . 1,5, JK I'ulbrook r. New Civil Sei vice Co., 2(> W. R. 11 . - 4(iH, ,')H Pulbidok '-. KichinDiid ( 'o,, il ( ', D, filO : 27 W, 1{. :i77 ; is \,. ,1, ( h, f).> - - - .j!M ii;i:i, 72(1, 7:!7, i:i.J7, i;is<», iJi'ji, 11(1.') PiilNfnid -•. I),.voni>h, (100:() 2 Ch. i,.',); J2 W. U. 7:i - - 1448 I'uiit i: Symona * Co., (1000) 1 Ch. tiJC; (190.f) 2 Ch. oiW - ti30, »«(), 040, t)47, ti.J5, 704, 747, 1408 I'uicoll '•. Fowler, 2C. P. I). 2i;) . - - - . 697 Pure Spiiit Co. r. Fowler, 25 Q. B. I). 2;?.i ; .18 W. II. 680 - .1416 Purvis, Itf. (1904) 1 Ch. ;!7a; 90 L. T. :i94 ; 73 I,. J. Ch. 281 . 680 Pjlc Works (No. 1) (1890), 44 Ch. J). 534 ; 59 L. .1. Ch. 489; 62 L. T. 887 - - - - - - - 657 Pyle Works (No. 2), (1891) 1 (^h. 173; 60 I-. J. Ch. 114 ; 63 I,. T. 628 : 39 W. R. 235 - 657. 686. 688, 74t>. 747. 753. 787. 788 [hi ■ Uuartz Hill Co. -•. Iteiill, 20 C. D. 508 ; 30 W. R. 5S3 ; 46 L. T. 740 ; 51 L. J. Ch. 874 ..... ;J3, 697 Uuartz Hill Gold Mining Co. ,: Kyre (No. 1), 11 (i. R. ]). 674; (\o. 2), 50 I,. T. 274 - . - . - . 1411 Qufbrada Land Co., 40 C. I). .363; 58 L. J, Ch. 332: 60 I,. T 482; 1 Me-. 122 ..... 1119,1283,1494 (iueen )•. Abney Park Cemetery Co., 8 Q. li. 515 ... 106 Queen i\ A^l)inalI, 2 d. B. D. 48; 25 W. R. 283; 36 L. T. 297 ; 46 h. J. M. C. 145 ...... 238 (iueen r. Cooper, 5 Q. B. 457 - - . . . 701 Queen I'. General Council of Mediiiiie, (1897) 2 Q. B. 203 . - 708 Queen r. Government Stock Investment Co., 3 (i. B. 1). 442; 39 \. T. 230; 47L. J. Q. B. 478 1406 Queen r. Oumey and others, Finluson's Report, 254 - 233, 873 Queen (The) v. The Justices of Kent, L. R. 8 (i. B. 305 - - 1047 Queen r. Morton, I,. R. 2 C. C. R. 22 ; 21 W. R. 629 ; 18 L. T. 452 ; 42 L. J. M. I'. 58 ..... 1142,1143 (iueen -■. Reed (.*AO> Ruilwiiy ami El.-rtni: Aiipliuncc Co., Itf, MV. I), sy; • :,- 1; j (h lkill c. Kdwards, 31 C. It. 100; .(4 W. U. 96; 53 L. T. 949 ; 55 L. .1. Ch. 81 - - . . . 140, 142,788, 1403 Rancors Case, 6 Ch. 104 ; 19 W. K. 291 ; 23 J.. T. 828 ; 50 I.. J. (h. -" " " - - - 714, 767, 85S, 887, 898, !M)4 Itiindall, Ltd. r. liritish and .Vinoricaii Shoo Co., (1902) •> Ch ;J51 ■ 71 J.. J. Ch. ti8;j; 87 L. T. 142; 50W. }{. 697 - " - 453 liaiidt (iold Minin-Co. ,•. AVaiiiwrijfht, (1901) I Ch. 18|- 70 ], J Ch. 90; 84 I,. T. 348; 8 Mans. 61 - - (;«,)', (i7„, 7„h, ] „»4 l{aiidt(J(ddMiiiingCo.,(1904)2Ch, 468; 73 L. J. Ch. 598; 91 L T 174; 53 \V. H. 90 ... Eanilagh c. Uayus, 1 Ve8. 189 Riugir -■. (ireat Wostcrii Rail. Co., 5 II. L. C. «(i Raphael r. Bank of England, 17 C. U. 161 - Rapier c. London Tramways Co., 69 L. T. .361 467, 674, 1142, 1143 - 1051 583, 786 - 616 54 RawlinH .■. Wickhaui, 3 D. & J. .304 ; 28 L. J. Ch. 188 ; 5 Jiir. X. S. 660, 661 - 1246 36, 40 ■ 1187 38 .'78 195, 213 - 921 - 106 - 361 - 221 - 1197 145 450 Raybould, lt<; (1900) I Ch. 199 liayu.r ,-. Jlruwitt, 82 L. T. 718 - Rayiiov r. I'rcston, 18 C. 1). 1 - . . . _ Read '•. Hrort'n, 22 'es r. I'.errington, 2 \es. jun. .540 - - . . . 1040 Reese River Co. c. Atwell. 7 K(i. 347 - . . . |JJ,y, Reesi! River Silver Mining Co.. 2 Ch. .\pp. 611 - . 1U7, 213 Ree.se^ liiver Silver Mining ( o. /■. Smith, L. R. 4 II. L. 64 ; 39 L. J ^''' ***" - - - - 1". 71, 73, 190, 197, 198,199, 200 87 L. T. 308 Reeve i. Berridge, 20 (i. B. I). 523 lieeve I'. Jennings, (I9I11) 2 K. B. 522 lioeves «-. Lisle, (1902^ .V. C. 461; 71 L. J. Ch. 768 (ILL., Iv) ..... R«'ginfs Caual I'o., Itt, W. N. (1837) 79 - lieg«'nfs Canai Iron Works Co., It . ;i C. D. 43; 24 W I! 687 • •!> L. T. 288 ; 45 L. J. Cli. 620 - - . ■_>■'' 3.-16 441 1239 743 687 IW^ XCVl TABLE OF CASES. Heg— Hei paof. Rg. '■. Armiiid, i) U. U. «(K> ; Hi L. J. (i. II. ,')0 ; U Jiir. 2T!t - ■>», 53H R<>f,'. - . AHpinall. 2 (J. B. D. 4N, J9 - - - - - 131 Rug. I'. Iliriniughiim nml Olouci'Mti-r Biiil. Cii.. .'i (i. IJ. J2."i ; !• t'ur. & P. -»«!» ...... au, 42, 44 Hfg. c. Urightwell, 10 A. & E. 17fi ..... T.J.) Hej:. '•. Catholic fiifi". &i-. Assui-anii" Institution. 4M L. T. . :ii;{ Keg. -■. DOyloy. 12 A. & E. i:«t . H.'g. '■. Ewlailc", 1 K. & v. •Jia «!«•. TtiJi - 7(il - I4.T.I - 103 701. 702 im. Hoi. S72 Reg. '•. Oi.v.innient Stock Co.. ;i Q. B. P. 443; 47 L. J. U. B. 47H; .39 J,. T. 2.30 ...-.-.. Beg. c. OraLain, il \V. R. 73K - - - - . Ei'g. r. Oroat North of Englunil Rail. Co. (1840), i» Q. B. 31.") ; . Ouust, 7 Ji. J. M. C. 38 : 7 A<1. & E. Ool - Hall, (iH'tl) 1 (i. B. 747 - Rfg. Rog. Reg. Rog. Ri'g. Reg. Rog. Uaslain. 17 <1. B. 220 Iloilgo.-, 12 .v. & E. l.W Ju.M, 37 W. R. 143 - , l,anih»th. N A. & E. 3.jli . Langhoine, G N. & M. 203 Rog. c. Loo Overseers, L. R. 1 H B. 211 lie (HI ■ 701 3<», 42 10(i - 23.-) ■ 107 - 701 ■ .)4»! - 701 ■ ()'J7 ■ ION c. Mariiiuita. i&c. Co., 1 E. & E. 280 ; 23 L. J. (J. B. t)7 ; .■> Jur. N. S. 72J - - . - - - - 771 Reg. i: Maj-or of Iiiver])ool. 3 Eact, 80 . - . .42 Reg. f. Mayor. &c. of Ijondon, B. & C. 1 - - . - 702 Rog. -•. Mayor of Wigan, 14 Q. B. 1). 008 . - - 724. 731 Reg. - . Morton. L. R. 2 C. C. R. 22 - - - - 84 Rog. '•. Xowtou, 48 L. J. .\r. C. 77 . - - - - 763 Rog. -•. Ployov, 2 B. & A. 707 ..... 73.-, Rog. r. I'rio.-, 11 A. & E. 727 - - - - - 23.') Rog. r. Registrars of Joint Stock Companio:*. (1891) 2 (i. B. .398; 21 a B. 1). 131 - - - - - - 1(MI2 Rog. r. Saddlor- Co., 10 LI. L. C. 404 .... 72O Reg. ,: St. I'auoras, 11 A. & E. 15 - - . - . 701 Reg. 1: Towkosburv, L. R. 3 Q. B. (i.tj ; 1(> \V. R. 12(Kt; 9 B. & S. (183 ; 18 J.. T. 80I ; 37 I,. J. Q. B. 288 - - - 73.i Rog. .■. Tidy, 2 (J. B. 17!" - - - - - - 442 Rog. 1: Tyler. Ac. Co., i,1891) 2 Q. B. 588; 01 I,. J. M. C. 38; 6.) L. T. (i«2; .)(> J. V. 118 (C. A.) . - 42, 181, 235. 230, 624, 7(i3 Rog. '•. West Middlesex Water Works, 1 E. .<; E. 716 - . 108 Reg. '•. Wimbledon Local Board. 8 (i. 1!. D. 459; 51 L. J. (I. B. 219; 30 W. R. 402; 46 L. T. 47 - - 593. 700. 701 Reid's Brewery Co. ,: Male, (1891) 2 U. H. 1 ; 60 \.. J. (i. B. 340; 64 L. T. 294 ; 39 W. R. 459 ; 55 J. P. 216 - - 99, 539 Reid V. Explosives Co., 19 (i. B. D. 264; 36 L. J. (i. B. 388; 57 L. T. 439 ; 35 W. R. 509 . . - - - 444 Reid '•• London A SfafYordshii-e (^>., .32 W, R, 04 ; 49 L, T. 468 ; Hi I,. J. Ch. 361 - Eeidpath's Case, 1 1 Eq. 86 - 2(KV TAHI.K OF UAMM. xcvn Bern— Sis l!.iiimiii;.'t<)ii '•. .S(h.i]i.s, iNitT) .' Ch. I : (it; I,. J. el,. ,-,L'(i- :« \,. [• liiiT: l.'i W. I!, .wo . . . . ■_ ' ,.,.„ Iiinsh.i« &(',,., W. \. (MtON) u'Ki - - . . . ,j|^ n.iWM r. I!,,., j II. I,. I7,i .'..._ L>ti. 4,-,. ,-,,•>!» R'UHK '. I'i.ltKlry, r,. H. 1 Kx. .■jii' - - - ,t;i.-i, :{:«)" .ws. 11 s4 Itivcll /•. K(linl.iiif.'li I.itf Insuniiici- Cii., .-, Tux. Cu-. JiM . . i(v.> Krvcr-iioiiiiiy Int'ii'Mf Socicfy. {\HK) 1 Ch. (ilo: til F,. J. Ch. ;(7!t : m L. T. VH) ; 40 W. 1{. :ivj ; W. \. ( |H!)L>) (io - . mi'j, i:ii;» Kcx ' Aluahuiri-, ;i!HM} 'J K. It. sVJ; jil [,. f. iji.-j . .j,, -p [_ |. (i.sl - 1:.'0.» - I OH - !»9 - l.-)l - 702 - lOH lllMi Rix .-. Uri-hton (iiislijjht Co., .") H. ,t ('. |(i(i Idx ■. ('niiiniissidiicrs. !»1 I,. T. !i| - IJcx .-. I If I', r; - Ut'.x c. rnil)(niau, 11 ICust, 77 - - - . . Hi'x r. V . . .J7 ; •.'( W. 1{. 107.'^ • .(4 h T .sflo- ■17 L. J. Kx. .)[).! ;j,:, ,^.. IfhiHli'siau rrop.rtii's, \V. N. (liioi) l;ill .... -,;q Ificlmrd Mills \- Co. (Itri.rliy llill\ \V. \. (190..) .ili . - 112 Billiards & Co., /,',, 11 0. I). (>7(> . 1 . . . ]-,„.] liichards ,-. Home .VssuraiKo Assoriatioii. I,. 1!. ti C. I'. Ml . -,> liicliards 1-. Kiddcniiiu.sttr Ovorsoers, (l.silii) ■> Ch. 'IVl : ti.) I,. J. Ch. Ml ; 74 L. T. 4.s;i ; 44 W. 1{. jo.j - . . ' ,' HichanlsouV Case, 19 Kq. .WS ..... liichimlson -•. Mothlcy School Hoard, (iHil.l) :) Ch. olO; (!•_> L. ,J. Ch '.HI!; Ii9 L. T. ;(fl,s ; 4'i W. 11. 127 : li R.'7t(l - . . Richardson v. Smith, b Ch. 64.S - - . . . Richardson c. Stormont, TtMld & Co., (1!)()(|) 1 (i. Ij. 7()i Richardsijn r. 'Willianison, I,. 1!. (i (i. 1!. 27tj ; 40 L. ,1. (i. R. 14j . T4I, iim> Richmond's Case, 4 K. & J. :i2.') ..... -^- Ridfiway --. IlunKcrford Maikct Co., .f A. & E. 171 - . . 442 Rid'.'way r. Wharton, (i II. L. C. 2!)U .... ;j.)i Ridley 1: I'lymouth d.. 2 Kx. 711 ; 17 I.. J. Ex. io'l ; 12 Jiir. ,542 - 71^0 Ridout c. Eowler, (liKH) 1 C (i5N ; 90 L. T. 147 ; 73 I,. J. ( 'h. 32 j . :i49 Rilcys, Limited, (1903) 2 Ch. .J90; 72 E. J. Ch. *!78 •. 89 T.. T. .v>9 ■ 5 W. B. 681 - . . . . ' . n Bipley >: Paper Bottle Co., J7 E. J. Ch. 327 . . .658 Eisdon Iiou auJ Locomotive Works r. Fumess. (190(i) 1 K B 49 • (190o) 1 K. B. 304 ; 74 E. J. K. H. 243 : 93 L. T. *W7 ; 54 W. R.' 324 ...... . ,jy_ g^ 9 44 4H 73() 349 (>St» f -■ 1 x«;vni TAHLK OK CAHKR. IliJ !*" ! s ilia— Boy l{inlitoii r. UrixiwU, j Eij. {J20 - . . . I'itHo's Ciiw, J ('. I». 7N1.' ----.. KoM) ,. Orroii, (isilj) •_> H. 1». 1, ;n,>; VV. N. (1W»5) II j - l{..l»rt- r. Cn.ff, -.M lirav. 22:t; !• Di. O. & J. I BiUrtH r. Neurit)- Co., (INJC) 1 U (C. A.) - - . . R«l.eit«m ". Willuiott, I'j T. I-. R. (W;f . . . . Bi>b. I.Vi - - . . Biibiiisou's t'lisi'. 4 Ch. ;):)(); ■.>(» L. T. !«! ; IT \V. K. ioi H<>I>i i«'iii <■. A:-hti)u. L'(t Km. 2h ; :i;t W. 1!. (iTi ; ;t:) L. T .>SN ■ 44 I, ,1 Ch. r,v> - - - . . -'.''. Kulnii^m i: !!l,,ml, 1 \V, HI. "i.W - . . . . RobinMin c (iirroy. V (i. H. I). -470- - - . . Rdliinsm ,-. llaikin, (lH!»r,> 2 <'li. -lI,-); (ia F,. J. Ch. 773- 7J I, T 77V ; 44 W. R. 7(»2 - - . . . RnbiiiNoii i\ Mi'ntgiimi'iy Hrewon- > '.., (t8!Mi) -j Ch. N41 ; (i.j L. J. i.taK , 888 47 44^ 118« >4 .f,i8 :»44 jl .ST8 344 219 - 7S8 42 1209, .>2 I,. J. Ch. (>!»M. lOHo, Ch. 91,i; 3 Manwm. 279 Robinson ,•. R.'Htill. 12 T. L. R. 174- Roddy '•. KitzffiTald, (i H. T.. ( '. n7(; Riij;ii>' Casn, 3 Ch. ti33 - - . . Rojiirs' Case, Harrison's Case - . . Rogers -■. Dniry, 3(i W. li. 4»t> ; .")7 I,. J. Ch. ,">04 - Roknpr r. Andorson, .1 Ksp. 23o - . . Eomford Canal Co., AV, 24 C. I). 85 ; 49 L. T 118 • 729 Rmey's Case, 4 D. J. & S. I2(); 12 W. R. 815, 894; 10 L T 770 33 L. J. Ch. 731 ----- 057 Roi .y '■. Stanton, 17 T. L. R. 272 - - . . . RiM.ts r. AViUiamson, 38 ' JJ. 485; 57 L. J. Ch. 995 ; 58 L T 802- •"'W.R. 7,-,8 ,.,5,65^, RommiIkt^ r. Northumberland Land liuilding Society, 22 (J. H. h. 373 ; (iO I.. T. 558 ; 37 W". R. 368 - . " " . ,);}(,'_ Ross r. Kstates Invostnu-nt Co., 3 Eo. 1.34 ; 3 Ch. 689 ■ 15 W R 104; 16\V. R. 1151 ; 15 L. T. 272: 19 L. T. 61 ; .16 L J Ch" 54 ; 37 r,. J. Ch. 873 - - . 155, i8,j^ 190 oj;) Riissiter I. Trafalgar Co., 27 Beav. .380 - - . . RothiThani Alum, &•■. Co., /fr, 25 C. I). 103- 3' W R 131 • io L. T. 219; 53 L. J. Ch. 290 - 147, 148, 149, 323^ 366,'441, 745, 740, 748, 758 Bouse «•. Rradionl Banking ( 'o., (1894) A. ( '. 58ii ; 63 L. J. Ch. 890 • 71 L. T. 522 ; 43 W. R. 7S ; 6 R. ;i49 - - . 1 BouHxell r. Hurnham, (1909) 1 Ch. 127 11, 12, 16, 230, 256, 259 Rowf, H,. vl904) 2 K. B. 489; 73 L. J. K. B. 594; 91 L T ■>'()■ 52 W. R. 028 (C. A.) .... ea",,:^ Rowo's Tnistof 's Claim, (1906) 1 Ch. 1 ; (1905) 1 Ch. 597 - (i55 Ror.liind's Cas.\ 42 L. T. 785 ; W. N'. (1880) 80 - Iwiwland <•. Chai)man, W. X. (1901) 153 - Ro.^burgho c. Co.\. 17 C. D. 520 (C. A.) - . . . Roxburfihe Tress, (1899) 1 Ch. 310; 68 L. J. Ch. Ill ; ,>,0 L. T. 280- 47 W. R. 281 ; 6 Mans. 57 - ... .' lloyal Bank of India's Caoe, 4 Ch. 252; 17 \V. R. 359; 11* L. 1'. ^^ 334, 507, 686 1210 .594 55 .55 359 442 1096 , 745 1440 . 666 1205 , 281 7.39 633, , 838 1249 . 2»iO , 662 , 785 1141 734 1195 1390 I'ABLK UF CASES. ZCIZ Roy— Sdl li'vil It ink of S,,,tl,,n.l Tcittnntmn. IHHJ; 2 U ». 715 : fll L. J. U. II. !»!•: 71 I,. T. KiS; .|;| W. R. ■>:•; ji U. vii»''('. A. y.il llriti-«h lUiik i: Tiirqiiiiml, li K. & H. ,l-.'7 ; n h, J. n, n. ;ii r*oi 708 1 Jur. \. S. losii Knyiil Coll.'u'c of MiiMic ,-. St. Miii"ar.t'-< <)v >*(•!»; (iT I, J. (^ li. :yii). 7,s I, T 4,1 H. xo. h;). (ii(i, 710, ;ii_ 7,i|_ j,,.-,,, jj.,^ c'lxoirs, (1S9H1 1 Q. 11. •i-- ■!. I*. X'. A UhviiI f'olli'pof Sur'Ttoiis, (lh9!») 1 ({, II. .s;i ; (i7 1-. .1. U. 11. Td.-j 109 ■» li. T. HU lio.vnl Inxuranco To. -■. ■Wutoon, (ISOT) A. ('. I : «« L. J. (J. H. 1 ".■J Ij. T. ;134 - - - . liovai Soti.'ty of F.ondoii -•. Thnm|won. 17 C I). IJuK 1U4, 10« 'II i: Unat Fiiipill Co., (litlKi) \. ( '. .(.jy 107 100 - 4'Mi - 41, Si. N.l, (i7l.';7(i, 7oi>, 7(io, 701 . N.i), mo - l.J'IO ■m-. H'> I.. T. •.',-,(! : 351 - ll'J I ■-'•»>. i;ti4 - 114!) llHj Uiil^.v ( 'oiiM)li(liiUHl Miiiiiij{ Co.. 4.') I.. .1. Ch. 03.1 Itii.M .-. r,a-<,litiiii Bunk, !M1. H. I), im l!iis„l ,. Uiisstl, 1 15,o, C, C. l'»i!», 1 Wh.& Tu. L. C. 074 - Hii>s..ll r. AiiialBiimut(',l Socifty of Ciirpnntorc, (1910) 1 K 15 500- ,m^) W. N. 7!.; -'H T. L. R. i:;,; (II. L.) . . ,,,.,, ,i,,_ ,,„ liii-*ll, li-mlof Karl, (1»01) A. C. 440 - . , . (j,^ liiHw-ll ,■. Ka.t Aiifrliau Rail. Co., 3 Mac. & li. 125 - - 407, 473 liussoU -•. Waketicld Waterworks, 20 Eq. '74 • •>3 W R 887 • )' ' I-. T. 085 ; 44 L. J. Ch. 4!»0 - 29, 712. 872. 135,3. 1355, 13,5o" 13.-.9, „. ,, laoo, 1402 UUijsi'll s hxpCutorsCas*?, 15 .^. J. 7!l<» - . . . j-q li.vau r. Mutual Tonfiiic, &c. Anwk'., (I8<»3) I Ch. 110- 0' J, J rh 2o: ; 07 L. T. 820; 41 W. R. 140; 2 '. 156 - . '. 44, Ityhopo Colliery Co. r. Foyer. 7 U. U. D. s .5 - . 2i», 102, lli3 UylaiwU (ilass Kiifriaviiifr Co. ,-. I'liGonix Co., (JUU) 2 Ir. R. 532 -"l31o ""'"'nTl'l'la k' V/'m;™'"''"' •*""*"■''' ^"" "<'J"'1«" Actienposell^rhaft, (1!»11)2 K. li, 510 Hacrhariti Corp. v. Rcitrneyor & Co., (1900) 2 Ch. 059 .Si.lffrovf. r. liiydeii, (1907) 1 Ch. 318; 90 L. T. .301 255 - . . . _ .^aa., r r. (J. W. Rail. Co., (1890) ,V. C. 450 - Safety ExplosircB Ltd., (1904) 1 Ch. 226 Sahty (Jil (• , . W. N. (1892) l;i3 - Sahlj.Teen and Carrall's Case, 3 Ch. 323; 10 W. R. 49 Sailing Ship •• Kentmero " Co., W. N. (1897) 58 - •alainan v. Warner. 04 L. T. 598 - - . . Sale Botanical Gardens. /;,, 78 J,. T. 368 - ]•;"- Sale Hat,.], *o. (■„.. W. N, (IS!.-) 174 ; 77 L. T. 6S1 ; 78 L.'t SOS-"* •low. R. 314; W.N. (1898) 40- - . ^^^y Salford (Mnyor of) v. T,ever. (1891) 1 Q. B. 188 - 134, iji, 7;i;i HO, :3 T. h. R. 705 - 1.348. lL'88, 1294, »>I5 - 002, 091 1341 119 708 1.349 1422 1305 , 75B ,737 151 , 839 , 143 1400 "i w TABLK OP CABKH. .'I, :h J*aliHl)iirv, iVc. Co. r. liuthoru. (IWtT; A. C. •^Ii« ; 0« I,. J. 1'. c. «2 • 7« I-. T. Jia; 43 W. li. 391 -...'. 70,. Siilmliiirj-JiiniH and Diili'V rii«', //, liolton ift (n., (iHiM) a Cli .li^i- <) l:|,-, l.W. Kid, 221. til.-). !HI!I, HI.-., !I21. IMO, !M2. !H7. l(ti>3. I'lW.' H.v'i S:ll(imnli, r. f^iiillK. 12 Mi^llV. AW - - . . . 4,j,( ■Silt r. XorthiiiM|it()n, IN!»2" .\. C. 1 . .... p^;}., Saltnii ,•. N,.w H.'CMtoii Cvcl,. ('„. (J), ^lj«KI) I Cli. r.i; «!• I,. J. Vh. 2(1 HI I,. T. VM : IN W. I{. I»2 : 7 M.u.h. 74 - 112. 72ii. 727. 1 1,M Suiim.lAllwppiPit.SiiiB, 31 \V. It. (i-U; W. X.;i!Hi;r 1:J2; lit T. Fi. It. *•■*' - - - - - - ' 12(il, 12(i3, 12ii7 Sail I'aulci Uiiiziliaii Uuil. Co. .'. Cmtir. (lSi(.>) 1 (J. H. 3S0 7'' h. T. 211: isiiti) A. c. :tl - - - . ' .,;,, 1,4 SuiuUmkIi .Hinl KdnioiKUoii, /fr. ;iN!ll) 1 (1,. mt : (Ml I,. J. Cli lio- •;:} I,. T. 7! 7 : :i!» W. I{. Kt.l (C. A.) - - - ' ' .!.-,(► Suiiil..iNoii .•. Itlvtli ThiMtiiB. (liHKll 2 K. It. :,Xi: 7' r,. J K It 7lil ; ,s) 2 U. R. 724 ; 61 L. J. Q. B. 738 ; 41 W. I!. 431 - 93;i 69 J. 702 - 201 - 624 - 4.50 17, 197. 200, 243 - 1193 - 1431 (>:< 116; 67 I .82: 57 J. P. 21.J: 4 R. 42 (V. A.^ Scott /'. Corporation of Liv 236 ; 3 Jiir. N. S. 104 - rerpool, A De O. & J. 360 ; 28 L. J. Ch. 150 359, 594 TABI.K or VASIJI. 8co 8ha >H.<)tt -•. Fn.i.klin. 1,-, h-Mi,t. UN . . J'JI)!^ S•;.. ,..,,/. l,", . I) -o <•<• I<. .1. ' h. U ; m I.. T. II2(!; .W \f. U. HNl - '. ' "•„• |j „ SoltHh lMv.ttn..Mt Tiu,t .■. Surv-vor, 21 Sot. S...., , •„„., ill,' NiiM's. 2h'2 - _ _ ■ 11" S,„tfi,l, Mnrt^ap, .'„. of M.xuo -. M. Krlvi... 2fi Sr I, It ,hT ■ •' lux. ( in. I(i.i - . . . . Srottjih l'..t.»l,.um Co., /.',. j:i ( . K. 4i:j; .n w. U. ,s4(i 4!) j i •'*■ „ - , - •'• ■•'• •!'!• I!«i. I!'T. Ii«», JiK», (il(i, 7i!S, Till, lo::i soai c, lloiiw l'ioi»Ttv and Invostinrnt ^;ocil■tv, 10 t '. U. :!sT . .i,-,,-, Sutnii ,: ItuniiiiHl, ^I'Mio; A. C. l:l,i; (i!» J,. J^ ,. i, .„,,,. .(„ . i! i r i .i- M» I.. T. I : ,M W. K. (i7.-;(ll. J., K.j . ' '" [- ■'• "'': „„ Sfcuntii-- IiiMiraiiic. Soci.ty. '!> .) - W. H. •.'7.1 - . i (i,s tt.Tii Salt Co., (DM),-, 1 c|,. .i-.,; ■ 71 r I CI, 1!H"; ill I.. T. 7ii.i: j,j\V. 1{. •.>,)•.' . .' ." ' ^ .,„,- .Sflby «. WhittukiT, ti C. I). J,'}!* . . . _ !' S. If-actiii- Sowing Macluiu' Co., H L. T. tiTfi; :H \V. li. 7jH '. 719 SHinnian r. |'rin«. & Co.. Limitc.1, II T. L. 1!. 47:i C'.lJuni., |h<..V ■ nsiiji uch. tii7 -....; . S.'Vi.rn an,l Wy,., &e. Itiiil. Co.. (IStMi) 1 Cli. ,-,ai» ; (i,) L. J. Ch 400- 7^ I-. T. Jl!»: 44 W. R. ;U7 .... -(;'-,--„ Sru.lls Cns,., .1 Ch. lai : IK I,. T. J : Di W. U. .tsl . 72. 77,V7li, ^ „ ., i''- iii4«, rin,'i4Vi Nymour .•. Itri,!-,.. II ti. M. 1). 4,jo . _ _ Svmonr,.. I'iokott, (liNl,", 1 K. B. 7l.i; 7J I,. J. K. H ll.i- <<■> I-. T. .-,!!» (C. A.) - . ' " .. ShiickMcnl, Ford & C„. ,•. 1 imifr.Tli.'ld, I,. K. :( c. I'. 107 . . yy,-, Shand '■. StuiisHild, Si'toii, 1711'.' - . ,," Slur],, 4.) C. I). I'sii . . . ' " '**** sharj, ,-. ]),iw..s, 2 (i. 1!. j .. -'r,- j.-, w. n. ,;,) . ;(,; ,_ -j- ysf<'ir,T J "" (J. li. lot - - ' .. Sharp.., /;<., MuM.nic ,,nd to.n.n.l I,ilo As.s. Co. r. .shaipo, (Is!)-) ^, '•'•'•'■^^ ^ - - HI. -'O;?. T14, 76 C D 033 ■ ii I T 71;4(iL.J.ni.2,M. - - . • : n;;,,;:-2oo. ,H« shaws. Uryaiit&Co. W. X. ;i')oni.!4 - - ->--», ShawVCase, IH L. T. 71j- - '- . . '-i. '-iJ Sliaw, F.x imrli. 2 (J. IS. 1 1. 4().{ . . . _ Shiiw .-. Arnott, L' Stark, '.'.jfi - . . . Shaw -. lifiisn!,, 11 (J. p,. ]\ ,-,(;;j Hhaw , . Foster, L. K. j 11. 1,. ;i21 . - i;wi) - 442 - 110 list! ClI TABLE OF CASKS. M ! ■ ^ * I t iN<- Sha— Sim Shaw ,■. r.jit I'lulip liolJCo., l:m. I!. 1). l():i; aj W. R. 771 L. T yi L. J. (i. H. ;i»ji) j(» Sh, iw /■. liowlov, I! M. & W. MIO Shiiw ;•. A\'flli-slcy, () CI. i- Kin. :f.j:i Shaw /■. WiUdu, !) CI. & Fin. ;t,Jo - Shi'.irirnin's ( 'um', Shofficl. i L. T. :).S.) ; (i(i L. J. Ch. >:> ri, 761, lUO - o(l. 44 C. II. 41U': -jil 1.. .1. (^h. .'M : Cr> L. T. (i7N --.-.. 4(j<(_ 7nf» Slioflifld (Kail of) -■. London Joint Stoik Hank, l;i Ap]). ('as. ;!;i;j • .■)7 I,. .]. eh. Osii; ,)N I,. T. 7;J.'.: .■i7 \V. K. ;);i - \]r>, n.W, 1In7, IJli Shi'lticld & South Yorkshiw I'ciin. Hldfr. Soc. M,'.iL'(J. H. 1 1. 47()- ■Vs r.. J. (i. J!. L'(i,j ; m I,. T. lf<() : .-.:! J. 1'. -.i::, . . 27 ShiHiWd Nick.l Co. r. I'nwin, '.' (i. H. I>. 214: 'Jj W. 1!. 4!».( • -((i K. T. i:l»j; 41! 1,. J. li. H. -jiii) . - . . - :j(i4 Sheil. A'./ /«ir/.. 4 C. I», 7lS!» - - - . . ny)C. I >. (i!l2 - - - Uim, 1191, 1192, I24tj Sherwell r. Coiuhiiiptl Iiuandrstent .Mantles Synd., 23 T. L. 1!. 4K2 12, IMI Ship's e'aso, 2 l)v U. J. & S. ,544 ; 1:5 W. 1!. ,J99 : 12 I,. T. 2jti : 1 1 Jur. \. S. yyi - . - . . . ' . ijjjj .Ship f. Cios.>kill, 10 H,|, 7;i: .i'Jl..J. Ch. O.JO ; 22 I,. T. 31.i- IH W. K. (ils - . . . . . • . ^,,3 Shipley r. Marshall, 14 C. li. X. S. ,)(i() - - . - til 7 Shipway -■. Hroadwood. (Ih99) 1 Q. 15. ;jti9 ; OK I„ J. u. B. 3(>0 • SO I-'l''li«'-A.) ' - 733 Shirrell's Case, 14 Kq. 117 : 20 AV. R. 900: 42 L. J. Ch. .i - 442, 444 Shrewsbury Kail. Co. ,. X. W. Hail. Co., II. L. C. 113- 29 L. T IHO; 26 Ij. J. Ch. 4ti2 - - - - '. . 4e(> Shropsliire Union, v<£c. Co. v. The Uuc«n, I,. R. 7 H. L. 490 ; 23 W. U. 709 ; 32 L. T. 283 ; 45 L. J. Q. li. 3 - 006, l'l,i9, 1 140 Siddall, //., 29 C. I). 1 : 33 W. R. 509 ; .J2 L. T. 114 ; 54 L. J. Ch «>■*•-' Ill Silber Light Co., 12 C. D. 717; 27 \V. R. 427: 40 [.. T. 90; 48 L. J. Ch. 385 . ,466 Silkstonu and Ilaigh Moor Co. 0. Edey. (1900) 1 Ch. 107 : 09 L. J. ''h. 73; 48 W. R. 137 - .' - . - -1438 Silvester, It,, Midland Rail. ,: Silvo-stor, (1895) 1 Ch. 573 ; 64 L. J. Cli. 390 : 72 L. T. 283 ; 43 W. R. 443 - - - . 1245 Simm V. Anglo-Aiiioricau Telegraph Co., 5 Q. B. I). 188 ; 28 W. R. 290 ; 42 L. T. 37 ; 49 L. J. (i. B. .392 ; 44 J. P. 280 - 075, 1141 SiiiimonM I. London Joint St<.rk Brtnt ■'ma-)\ A f -iir i..,,„ Simms Registra 82 L. T. 433 (P. C.) ; Prohates, (1900) A. C. 323 : 09 L. J. P. C. 51 - 937 TAHt.K OF CASES. ClU Sim-Smi ,.^og Siiiii.Miu's ('.i«c. 4 Ch. IH4: IT \V. H. 42); .«• L. J. cii. 121 - 257 Simpson i: livuisim, 1(1 Ha. 51 - . - . 7,-, (,-,7 Siiii|)-on .'. ICbliw Vul.> Co., (I!)(i,.) 1 K. U. 4Vi ; 71 I,. J. K. |! ;u: ll>> I 'V 00.1 . ••> Al* 11 ../v,i '^-» t \ !I2 I,. T. 2S2 : :>n W. 1:, :m) V. A.) 1021 Simpson ,-. rulucc Thoativ ISiP.i). (i!) I„ T. 70; 2 li. 4.'j1 (C. A.I 1411, 117K Simiisoii .-. Wistiriiustir I'alaci' Hotel ('..., N M. I,. C. 712,- li Jul. ^'- ^- "**■' - - "•■'. •■n.i. 4.-.7, Kil, 4li7. 171. l.f.V., IliliO Simsoii ;•. Iiifrham, 2 1!. & ('. (i.'i - - . . - 1191 Siirmjfani'diis Ciildiir rriiitiri^ Syml. r, l^'owerakcv. (IllOl) 1 K. li. T71 - - . . . . '. . ,._^^ Siiijfir irachiiio )•. Wilson. :> Apji. ( 'as. ;{7(1 ; 2i) W. R. (!(i4 ■ .'is L T •lO.i: 47 L. J. Ch. 4H1 - . . . '- ' '. ^m .Sissoll iV Co. /■. .Sissons, .■)4 S. .1. ,S()2 - - . . 7;(() Skcat's .Scttli'mcnt. 42 C. I ). 522 - - . . . 7;(g Skclton's Caso, »i,s L. T. 210 - . . . _ ]y7 Skinner, /■.■.'■/"(/■/-, 1 I). ,V C. 4(K! - . . . - 1in7 Skinnor -•. City of London, Arc. Co., 14 U- !!• I >. >*n2 : .'Ci W. 1{. (J2M • .WI,. T. l!)l ; ,-,4T,. J. (i. H. 4,J7 - - . ' ' ,j,i,j ."Viator's Case, .i.", IVav. ;iill ; 12 Jur. X. S. 242: ^i.". I,. ,T. Cli. H04 ■ II \V. li. 44(1; 14 I,. T. X. S, (I,-, - . . .' ,;,;,; Sl(.ij:li .-. Glasirow anil Transvaal Options. C, V. 420 (Ct. of .«li-ss.', - 12, l.SO, 2.S0 .Slator r. liarlaston ^■.■cl Co., W, X. (1.H77) l.iil - I4!i:i, 14mi, 14 Snieltinjr Co. of Australia .•. Connnissioners of Inland Hov L. J. Q. IS. I;i7 ; 7,-, I,. T. ,j;i4 4,-, W It' •J«:J; .!1J. ]Ml(i(C. A.) - - . -;i4i;;i42..i02 Smith's Case, 2 Ch. WM ; L, I{. 4 II, X,. 7!!; I.') W. K. H82 : 1(! L. T. .")49 ; ;jr> L. J. Ch. (>1« ; ;!'.» h. J. Ch. S4<> - l!)n. lit,-,, 1;{S!( Smith, Knight & Co., 4 Ch. 671 - - - . .' mf^ Smith, Smith and Lowis, /iV, (1902) 2 Ch. tJ(i7 • 71 I, J Ch s.s.j ■ 51W. R. 11 --....; ,,.^, Sunlli, //,, Smith r. Thompson, 71 T,. .T. Ch. 411 ; 8(1 I,. T. 401 71.j, 1402 Smith 1: Anderson. l.'> < '. 1). 247: 29 W. li. 21 : 4.t I,. T. ;i29 ; 50 ''• J- f'h- '''9 110,111,535,711 Smith 1: Hetty, (190.1) 2 K. Ij. ai7 : 72 L. J. K. B. H5:t : 89 J,. T. 258; 52 W. R. 1.17 ;C. A 1 .... -119« Smith 1: Chadwick (1884), 20 C. I). 45 ; 9 Ann. Ca.x. 187 • ;iO \\ U fitil : 32 W. B. 687 ; 4H L. T. 702 : 50 T,. T. «97 : 61 L. J. Ch! 597 ; 53 li. J. Ch. 873 - 144, 177, 189, 193, 194, 195, 197. 202, 203, 205 Smith V. Duke of Manchester, 24 C. D. (ill ; 32 W, 1(. 83 - 751,' 7s7 Smith V. Hull (ilass Co., 11 C. B, 897; 21 L. J. C. I'. KmI; 7 Ry Ca..287 - - - . . -■ ■■ 761 Smith I', Lion lirowery Co.. 1 19(19) 2 K. H, 912: fU'lH A. C. 150- lOI T,. T. 145 - - . . . . ' 9'9_ loy Smith 1: Nealo, 2 V. 11. X. S. (17 - - - . . ' ;j3n Smith 1: Packhurst, .t Atkins. 13H - . . . . g„.j <'1V TABLE OF CASKS. Smi— Sou '^' '■ Smith r. I'ariiiL'ii Mini's. 'IDOo) 2 fh. 1!»3; !H L. T. o7l ; 7J I.. J. Ch. 702- - - - - - - - '''•"• Smith -•. IVtcrs, I'O Eq. all - ----- i)!) Smith -•. Richmimd, (1N99) A. < '. 44N ; si I,. T. -im-, iH W. U. llo- loii Smith -■. liobiiison, 13 ('. D. I-IN ----- ;i5(l Smith -•. Thompson, 71 !,. J. fh. 411 : S(i I,. T. 401 - 71.-.. 1402 Smitli r. Tom|ison. H <'. IJ. 44 - - - - - •''- Smith -■. Wallace, lH!»j) 1 Ch. :!«) - ... - :{.V-' Smurthwait.' '. llannav. (lMt4) A. < '. 4',)4 ; li:! I.. J. U- 15. 737; 71 L. T. 1J7; 43 \V. it. 113; OK. 2!t9(H. L.,K.) - 1347, l..i^ Smyth r. Darloy. 2 il. L. r. 7Wt - - - - (in2, (i!»7 Snook f. Solf-.^ctin-Co., 3Timi'sI,. 1!. ()30 - - - 1!»1 Sociuti' (li'S ^[anufactiiriw do Ohiii" --. Tilnhraiiu's Co., 2.) ('. I). 1 ; J3 T.. J. ( li. 1 ; 32 \V. It. 71 ; 49 L. T. 151 ; 4H J. 1'. f.M - :W1 Sofii,-.ti' O.m. '■. Walkrv. 11 .Vpp. ('as. 2(1; 34 W. It. (i02 ; J4 L. T. ;i,S9: jj 1.. J. I'h. Iti9 - - <)7, 070, 1110, 1143 Sociitr I'anhaid ': I'aiihanl Lovii-xir To.. (19011 2 13: S5 I,. T. 20; JO W. 1!. 74 - - - - - 4.>1. 4.J3 Society of I'nictiial Knowlcd^'o '■. Abbott. -' li.'av. 007 - - 27 Solway Steamship Co., 01 I,. T. 0o9 - - - 1270, IJN.i Somerset '•. Land Socuriti.'s Co,, \V. X. (1S97) 29 - - OS.s. 072 .SomeiHet .-, Wade, (1H94) 1 li. I!. o74 ; 03 L. J. M. ( '. 120 : 12 \V. l!. (1894) 399; 70L. T. 4.J2; lOK. 10,) - - - - 3.-)f< Somervail r. Cree, 4 App. i'aa. 04H ----- Oo2 South African ISreweiieH --. KinR, (19tM») 1 Ch. NS, 273; '1^99; 2 Cli. 173; 09 L. J. Ch. 171 ; n2 L. T. 32 ; 48 W. li. 2.S9 (C. A.) - .341 South African Supidv and <'old Storatre Co.. (1904) 2 Ch. 2«H ; 73 I,. J. Ch. 0.)7 ; 91 Ij. T. 447 ; 52 W. it. 049 - .'iH. 7N). 7nO, h17, 1433, 14K2 South African TenitoHis ,■. Wallinstou, (1H97) 1 n. B. 092 ; 0() ].. J. U. li. ool ; 4J W. it. 407; atfirmed by H. L.. 14 T. L. K. 29S ; (1H9H) A. C. 309 ----- 290, 294 South African Trust Co., /iV, /;..• /..irtr llirsch ;1N90). 74 I,. T. 709 - 1:J0 South American Co., 31 C. I). 201 ----- 4S0 South IturhamCo., «., 31 C. D. 201 (C. A.) ; 34 W.K.120; o3 L. T. 92H; ,•.0 L. J. Ch. 179 ----- 4S0, o7o Soutli lletton Coal Co. o. N. K. Nows Association, (1.S94) 1 U. 15. 133: 03 L. J. U. li. 293; 09 L. T. H14 ; 42 W. K. 322; ,JN J. I'. 190; 9 li. 240 M '. .V.) ------ 33 Soutli of Kufjland Natural Gas, &c. Co,. (1911^ 1 Ch. 573 - 13. 175, 229, 235 ,South of Ireland < Ollierv Co. r. WadcUe, I.. It. 3 C. 1". 409 ; 10 W. It. 750 ; in I.. T. 405;' 37 I.. J. C. 1'. 211 - - - - ;J34 South Llanhurrau Co., ICe. 12 C. I). 503; 2S W. K, 194; 41 L. T. 567 ------ - 42, 304 South Loudon Fishmarkot Co., AV, 39 C. 1). 324 ; 60 L. T. Oft ; :t7 W. E. 3 ; 1 Meg. 92 - - - - - OtiO. 072 South WalcH Atlantic, &c. Co., 2 C. D, 763; 40 L, J. Ch. 177; 35 L. T. 294 - - - - - - - 110 South Wales Miners" Federation i: Glaniorffltn Coal Co., (1905) A. C. 239; 74 L. J. K. li. 525; 92 L. T. 710; 53 W. U. .i93 (11. L., K.I ----- ;13, 115, 44». 445 South Western of Venezuela, &c. Co.. (1902) 1 Ch. 701 ; 71 L. J. Ch. 40. ; HO L. T. 321 ; 80 W. R. .•«K» - - - - 727 TABLE OF CASES. CV Sou— Sta i.^,^, S.mtli Yorkshire \Uu. Co. .-. (J. V. I>,|ii. (■,,. ., j,;^ ,-j^ . ,; u i (• ";• -------- 46(1 >oiitlmll /■. liiitish Miitiml Life Assuriinco Soiietv. II K.i.fij- (i Ch •:ii» : lit W. I!, wr, ■. m |,. j. ch. t>»8 - im. :;i2, ".•{.•t! um.' !;):.'!», 1440. 1444, 14.')L' 14*86 Soiithiiiiiiitiiu Cci. c. ririiiock, 12 W. It. ;j(l - . . . --,;j Si.iithiiiiiiitoti Dotk^ <'m. <•. Kiihiiids, 1 .M:,n. & Or. 4IH - - UH S()iitlioml-nu-So;i ('iniK.rittiuii ,». White, 8;{ L. T. 4()S - . |(|<| SouthtMU Brazilian l{i(i Giand.' do .Sul liailway, (l!l().-,^ " ( 'h Ts ■ !»2 I,. T. .-,!I8 ; ,->;i W. If. iHU - . ■ . . '_ ,;_j., Soiitli.Tii Coiiutik's licposit Bank .■. liiihr. 7:i |,. T. .ili - i;!i:, i.-i-j.', Southwark Co. 1-. (iiiirk. :i (i. J!. 1). .■Jl.-. - . . -lild't .■Southwell ,-. .Savill L!r..s., J(.01' L> K.li. 34!»; 70 1,. J |< IJMj V> W . \i. r,s-2 -....._■ „„ S.iveici-n Life Co., /,',, v: C. I). :,V2; :,H I,. J. f'h. Sll • ,;| |, T 4,-..-,: :iH\V. |(. ,W . . . - ' . .\ll". ,;(o., Sovrrcigii Life ;Salt(-i's (Liiiii;. 7 T. L. R. (iO'J . . . ,43 Sovi rcijiii r.ife .Vssiiiiiiice lo. .-. Iiod.l. !l8!»2) 2 1.1 \',, .;-;•, . . |4i)(;_ lllt7. 14!t.S ^Ip;lck_Inan r. Lvaiis. L. 1!. :j H. ],. isii; l!) |.. T. ir.t . .i7 |,. J. I'h. ""*-"-- (ij(>, i'ioX, 77-i S,,aMish I'rosp. etui- Co., (101 1) 1 ( h. 02 - - U:K ^H.",, .SOS. .S81 Spai -e's ( ase. 8 ( li. 107 ; 21 W. li. ;iOli ; 28 L. T. 1 j;! ; -12 L. J. I li. "'^'^ " ■ - - - - 1>^. '10. i:i.j, ;iOL 48.'. Spark.-) .-. Liverpool Waterwoik^, l:i Ves. 12s - . i]M lilio •■spiers r. I'oiiil, W. \. (18!),-,) l;i.-, . . . _ j.ji I. i;)],-, SpiraKilobc Co., /,',.( 1002. 1 Ch. :iO(i; 71 L. J. Ch I's- So \ T 77S; JOW. If. 1S7 ' - - . - • ■■■ *• Spit/el '■. Chino.-it, ( orpoiatioii. 80 L. T. ;i47 ; ti Mans. .l,-.,-. - 40, ,-.4, .'.j, 7:J Sjiokew r. (jioBvenoi Hotel Co., (1807) 2 (i. I!. 124 : liii L. .1. \i. li. •)72 ; 7ti L. T. »i70 ; 4,-. W. R. .■.4(> - . '_ • - '_ ^.^.^^. ."^pottiswood, liixoii and llmitintr. Ltd., A'.. (1012' 1 Ch. Ilii - 112 , . MH, 1482 •Npiiif '•. liayerA Co., (1001) 2 K. H. 2011 - - . -1021 Siuiie (CuHh Chemist). Ltd. '•. Hall. 27 T. L. 1! ■'(JO- 's T I 1> 81 - ■ . -. ^- •'• !>• - - - 7(0.007.007 Squiro c. Midland Lace Co., (10((.>) 2 K. 1!. 148 - . -10'>1 St. Hilda's Incoipoiated Collejre. Cliidtenhani. (1001 1 Ch j.iii ■ 70 L.J.Ch. 200; 40W. K. 270 . . . .-,01, I'il.i, I:J14 >t. Louis Breweries .-. .\ptlioipe, 70 L. T. .>,i2 : 47 W. R :i;fl • (i'i J.IM:!,-, - . . . . •. • . ,„, Stace and Worths Ca.so, 4 Ch. 082 ; 17 \V. li. 731 - 71^. MM, 148,5 Stattonlshire Ga.s Co.. ft, tio L. T. 4l;j - . . ;.).i ^^^ Standard Manufacturing Co.. /.V.,r,01) 1 Ch. 027 : (iO L. J. Ch. 292- ' (i4 L. T. 487 ; ;i9 W. H. aOO ; Meg. 418 ,C. A.) - "^"l'. I )8,{ Standing c. Rowring, .'M C. D. 282 - - . . _ ,j(.,, Stanhope's Case, ] Ch. 101 - . . . _ Stajile (Mayor of the) -•. Rank of Kngland. 21 Q. It. D. 100- s.l, 742 ."Staples r. Kastman Photographic Jfaterials Co.. i'l89(>) 2 Ch .iOJ' • 0.-. T,. .T, Ch. KM2 : 74 L. T. 470 . . --'- ^,.. , ' •> t t t "fin Star Firo and Burglary Insuraneo Co, r, David.son, 4 V. 09" ( t of ,,, ., - - - - 1410 ^tar >owspaper Co, <■. O'Connor. W, N. (1898) 114, 122 - - 141 CVl TABLK OK CA.SK.S. it- Sta -6tu rAOi Stark, A'.i/..(;7r, (lSi»7) 1 Ch. u7.> - - - - - 29.< Starkey r. Hunk of England, (19i):{) A. C IH - - i>S7, 711 Starr v. llowkett, 42 ( '. D. lilij .... - ;{52 State of Wvominj,' Svnditat.', (I90I) -J ( h. r.il ; 17 T. I;.;U. l>:il : 7(» r,. J. Oh. 727 ; Hi 1,. T. 8(W: 4!) W. U. OJO - -6'J1,74(), 741, 744, 739 Stool's CaHe (/.V Whitloy i'artnor-.), M C. I>. .•i37 ; 49 L. J. Ch. 170 : 4'.' L. T. 11 ; W. N. (1H79}217 - - - - l(r>2 Stoole ('. llarmpr, 14 ^t. & W. h:!1 ----- .jl(» Stophcn. /,V. 2 Ph. j62 .-.-.- 149 Stophons r. Mysoro Beofs. &c. Co., (19(12" I Ch. 74,') - 47<», ()■. Iluil.-'on's li:iy Co., 101 I,. T. 9(i - - - - 99 Stovenson .■. Maclc;in. .) S StivonMin r. Wilson i, 1907), S. C. 44.) ... (iOti, l:!ti9 .>^tewarf- CaM-, 1 Ch. .■)74 ; 14 L. T. ^17: lij L. J. Ch. 73.S - 1S4, 19(>, 242, \.ix'J, l.i90 Sti'wart's Precision Carburottor Co., l.til.. I,. ,1. Xoto.s, :{0 Marcli. 1912, 2I.S ------ - 1J20 Stowart ,. Wclx-r, C. .\. (Times, lUe. K, 1903) ; 89 I,. T. jJ9 - IJl Stilling' c. Burilott, ;i911) 2 Ch. 41S - - - -1245 Stirlin;,"-. Pas.'^lmrprOrainrt, 8 T. li. U. 71 - - - - 192 Stoek.ii'sCasi', :i Ch. 412: 10 W. It. :t22 ; 17 1,. T. .V,4 ; ;J7 1,. J. Ch. 230 ------- (ijO, (iOl Stocker r. Hrockelbank, :! M. & ,v .'. Kckt^wicli. (19(Mi) 1 Ch. (57; !t.l L. 1'. 71H- 51 \V K -•'" • . ■ : ;k7 Studderf -■. tirosv.nor, Sli C. I). ,j28 : .U W. K. 7.M ; o,", L. T 171 • 03 h. J. Ch. tJNfl; 50 J. P. 71(t - - MM, m>, li):,. 70,S, fi.VI, ,So5 t^tvl.s ,-. Middle Tempi,- (Treasurer), «1 I,. T. 42« - - - 105 Siifrdeii i: Alsbury, 4.j ('. 1). 237 : 00 L. J. Ch. 2!l • OH L T .">70 •iH \V, I!, 136; 2 Mo- 340 : \V. N. (IS'JO) 112 - ". ' I 7.04 SuUey '■. .\tt.-Oon., j H. & X. 711 - . . . .114 SuUivuu ,'. MitCiilfe, ,-) V. P. 1). 4Jo : 2!» V. . U. IKl • 44 I T s • ic( L. J. C. P. HI j - . - . '_ ' . ' ' ". 227 yuiiimers /■. lioyce, 23 T. L. 1!. 724 ; !t7 1-. T. Mo - - - 442 81111 J-'iie Olllee c. Hart, 14 .Vpp. O19. !I.S ; .iM,. J P c li'i • ihi L. T. 337; 37 W. K. .-.01 ; .)3 J. 1'. o4.S - 1 ' . 072 iSuii Insui-anco t)Hice ,.. ('l„rk. \V. \. {1!I12) 7!i - - !),S, lol Surrey County Ciickot Club. I!)01) 2 K.J!. 400; 70 1, J K H M23; 05 J. P. 4.S8 - . . . .' ' i k,,-, Sussex liriik Co., (1904} 1 ch. ,-,!lS ; 73 L. .1. Ch. 30N ; !«) h. T. 420; 52W. R. 371 - - . . 092. 138H. 13N9, l.ino, l.iHl Sutton's Hospital Case, 10 I{ej). 13 - . . . ;j„ ^., Sutton /■. Knprlish and Colonial Produce Co., (1902) •' Ch .".()•'■ 71 I.. .1. Ch. 0N5 : s- I,. T. 43.S ; 50 W. If. 571 '- 0(>7, '720."721, 1.357, 1400 Swalicy r. P,,it Darwin Co.. /It. I Meg. :(N5 441. 0.(5. 030. 724. 72!> Swain r. Fleming, HI L. T. 202 - - - - - 105 Swaine I. Wilson, 24 Q. «. 1). 252 - - . . - Uti Swansea Harbour Trustees 1: Swansea Cnion, 97 1,. T. 585- •>" 1. L. n. 433 - - . . .'.'"! i(i,j Swansea Improvements and Tramways Co. /■. Swansea Ciban Sani- tary Authority, (1892) 1 (i. Ij. Jjo" - . . . los Swayiie r. Inland Revenue, ^1900) 1 (J. H. 172 - - . ;ti9 Sweny,-. Smith (1807), 7 Kq. .324 - . . . 0,i9, 00(> Syers ,•. Brighton Rrewery Co., 13 \V. R. 221 - . . 47> Sykes' Case, 13 Eq, 225 ; 20 L. 1. 92 ; 41 L. J. Ch. 251 - 057 7-''7 Sylvester, /if, (1893) 1 Ch. 573 - - . . -1240 Syinons' Case, 5 Ch. 301 ; 18 W, K. :i0.i; 22 L. T. 217 ; 39 L J Ch 401 - . . _ '■'.■- ,.. . 01. ().2 Taddy & Co, -•. Sterious & Co., fl!H)4) 1 Ch. 354; 89 I„ T. «''8 ■ 5- \V. R. 152 - . . . . _ ' '^"'^f)9(m^'p ^",« "---^r'fVf'lr* Society of Railway Servants, (1901) A. C. 426; ,0 L. J. Q. B. 905; 50 W. R. 44 - 114, 115 Tahiti Cotton Co He, Kr i,„rte Sargent, 17 Ep. Ciis. 523 ; .■.« T. J i> 1! 7-,- no L. T. 102; 3/ W. R. 5l; - . ". '" , ,., " Tait V. Macleay, (1906) 1. C. 24 - 19, 177, 178, 194, 205, 228 230 Taito's Case, 3 Eq. 795; 15 W. R. 891 ; 10 L. T. 343 ■ 36 L J Oh 475 - - . . .... 424 41 1 , 708 1183 232 197 ■CVUl TABLE OF CASES. ri -i:i«S- PAQK 770 - 1271 ISj i;m 1210 ia42 t(i(i, 471 Tal-Tho Talbot V. Karl (if Shri'wsburj-, Hi K(|. I'S - - - Tambrarheriv <'o., /^, 2!» V. J). «K;t ; ,vj I,. [\ 7ij • ,-,4 j, ,| (■[, 7!»:i '--.-... Tu^lpliu■^ Ciise. W. X. (IM12; il-l, l4ti TaiKiui'iay i'. Bowles, 14 ?]<[. lol - Tate (■ Williiimsoii. 2 < 'h. 00 - - . . Tatlmm .-. Haslcr. 23 Q. H. T). ;i4;f - - - . Tutham .. raluio Kestaunints. ."»:( S. J, 743 - Taiiiitoii ,■. Riiyal Assuraiici' Co., 2 11. \- M. llj,) Tfturin.' Co., Limited, /.V, 2.j ( '. 1). IlS; :)2 \V. I;. 12!»; 4H I,. T. '''■*- - - - - - e(iH, rv Co.. {l!l((4^ 1 K. 15. s:i,S ■ 7;i I, .1 K It 4(iil: !M) r,. T. ;«i;j; ,J2"\V. 1!. 417 (C. A.) -' - 102:i. KM,:; Taylor <■. Kyiiior. ;i B. & Ad. .■(.');! - - . . . tl!i2 Taylor c. Midland Rail. Co., H \V. 1{. 4(11 - - . . (;.-,] Taylor /•. I'il.son Co., 27 1 '. 1>. j«s : .-,() L. T. j.so ; :,;i L. .J. ch. sjti - 1 Ur.i Taylor, I'liillips, ami Rickanl's Cast', It. Xatioiial Bank of Wale.-^, (IH97; 1 Ch. 29S; «i(i r-. J. Ch. 222; 7»i L. T. 1 ; 4j W. K. 4(11 - l.is.s Tayl(.r"s A^jn/rinent Triints, (1901) 2 Cli, 737 ; 73 l„ J. ( h. ,-).57 • .',•' W. U. Iitl2 112, 13.3.S TaylorV TriLsts, (liMi,-,) 1 ( h ;;t4 ; 74 I,, j. ( 'i,. .»]!): W2 1,. T. r,on ■ 5;i w- li. HI : 577 Toa Corporation, (IIMH) 1 Ch. 12 ; s'.i I,. T. :,Ui ; J2 W. K. 177 - 14 - 3H4. 443 Tenuent r. City of Glasgow Bank, 4 App. Cas. «15 ; 27 \V. H. 649 ; 40 I.. T. 694 ---.... 19.) Tinell /■. Hiitton, 4 H. I.. Cas. 1091 ; 23 1,. J. Ch. 345 - - Hs Thairwall /■. (^.rt-at Northern Rail. Co., (191(») 2 IC. B. 509 - 769, 770 Thames Con.serTatorM r. .-Inieod, Dean & Co., (1H97) 2 ti. B. 334 ; (i6 L. J. U. li. 716; 77 I,. T. 32.-i ; 45 W. 1!. (>91 - - 1094, 12O0 Thar-is Sulphur Co. <■. Soi-ii-te, iV:c. des Metaux, 60 L. T. 925; 3S W. R. IH ■ 5H L. J. Q. B. 435 - - - . ' .(oi;, 7,S2 Theatrical Trust (Chapman'.- Case), (1K95) 1 Ch. 771 ; W. N. (lN!»j1 •>*' - - 60, 62 Thiery -■. Chalmers, (iuthrie & Co.. (19(M)) 1 Ch. SO; «9 L. J. Ch. 122; SI L. T. 511 ; 4HW. R. 148 - . . .' rm Thomas, lit, 14 Q. B. D. 379; 54 L. J. (l B. 3;t(!; 51 L. T. 602; ;!3 W. R. 583 - . - . . - - 110 Thomas v. I'uited Butter ( ompaiiios of Fraiiue, 127 L. T. News. 34,") - I486 Thomas -■. Dovonport Corporation, (19(H)) 1 H. 1!. 1« - . 77fj Thompson's Case. 4 I)e O. J. * S. 749; .34 L. J. Ch. 525 ; 12 L. T 717; 13 W. R. 9.58 - . . . '. " ' ,-. 1(9 I TABLE OK CA8EH. CIX Tho— Tow ■niiiniiwon ,•. ('itv!) I). & li. ;ts(i - . . . .'.".; ,-,|„ Tliiiiiixm's Cusi! (Coiitriil Kloiiilvk.' Co.), ,-, MiUis. -.'82 . . jc)., TliDiiison r. I.oid Clmunorriw. liMH)) 1 Ch. 7l,s . . ou, .,.),, .,.,| Thiiiliys Cattl.' KooH \V . 1{. Oti" - - . . . _ ' 14 - Tibbatt«.. Hoult«ii, 7;i L. T. .'At . . . '_ i^s •>()(» TioRson c. lIciiiliTHou, (1N!«)) 1 Ch. ,s)ii ; ,js j^. j (.^ .,_..j . j^„ , ,p ' " 483 : 47 W. I{. l,-,!l : li Mans. .•i4(. . . ' ,m.'im. 7;)2.' KMK, Kix;}, 10!t7, 144<». I4f,4 . iIliMtd. AV, 3 1 .. J. & s. ,-,l!» : 11 \V. B. 7(H ; H L. T. oN7 - . |4!» Tillitt '. Chariiif; Cross I.'ailway. 2ti liiav. 41!»- 2N h J Ch sfiS • .5 Jur. \. .•^. IIIH- - ■ . . . ' ■ . ■ : .,^,> ■""1::^^7h\';".;; w:'^"i;,i"^"- ^ ''"■ ^"^ •" ': -^^ •■':; ^'^^ ^i;_ .,, Til^oii /•. Warwick Caw Co., 4 1!. & C. !«i2 ... .>2|' (;•!•( Ti«hU-r& C,.. r. Ajithorpi' (ISNi;, J2 L. T. sn - . "-'95 Ti\(.li, Mauchotor, Ltd. r. Collt'v, J2 \V. K. (!32 ; 2(1 T. L. R 437 - 35*7 Todd ,-. MiUai (1!»1()}, S. C. ^(i.S. Ct of Scss. . . " . ih!» Todd r. l?obius<,u. U (i. li. lliv. 739: 53 I,. J. (J. |! •»,-,! . o(, | -r 2y,S ; ,J2 W. li. Not* ; 4S J. 1>. .i!)4 . • - " . _■«• ■,. I. _^^ Tolhiirst .'. .Vssociatfd Portland (Vmiut Co., (lyo.'f) A. C. 414 • 7'> L. J. K. |{. 8.)4 ; SU L. T. 19(i; ,V2 AV. 1{. 143 (II. L.. K.) I I4(i(i ToUoniacho, /,V, (1903) | Ch. 9,iJ: 72 L. J. Ch. .539: .8S I T 7(C ",1 \v. 1!. ,-,97 ;c. A.': . . . - .' ' . .,,• Toiiikii.siV; Co., (1901) 1 (^ H. 47»i - - . . _ --[, r.inikiMHin -■. S. !•;. Kail. Co., ;« Ch. 1 1. tilo : 3.) W. 1{. 7o^ ■ .-,,; L.T..Hl;J:.-,.iL.J.Ch.932 - . . . " ^.j,. ,,„ lomhu8Cu8e,(l«98)ICh. 104: 4GW.R.171; -7L.T..i21- 201 I:t73 Tonipkins-.n r. Malkit. Co., (IWi3) A. C. 39ti; «3 L. J. Q Ji l'4 •' •i'J L. T. o9« : 42 W. l\. 204 ; I K. 78 (H. L.) - - ' 674 1 h , Tom Tit Cych. ( ■..., Fishir's Cuw, lo T. L. li. 1.32 ; W. N. (1899) 35 -' I4"' TorboL-k ,•. Lord AVostbury, (1902) 2 Ch. 871 ; 71 L. J Ch HA; ■ ,S7 L.T. l«5;oMV.l!. 133 . . . •. •„,,,, ^,,- lorva, &c. Syndicati- -•. Kelly, (11*00) A. ( '. (il2 ; 1(! T. L. 1{. 495 • (i<) L. J. r. C. 115; 83 L. T. 34(1'. C.) . . "•_"•■ ^_ Tothill .1 Caw, 1 Ch. 85: Iti \V. li. 1192 . - . . -',,■ TotttrdeU r. Farehaui Brick Co.. 1 C. 1'. 674: 14 VV. I!. 919- .Jo I>. J. C. P. 278; 12 Jur. X. S. 901 - ■■■•.■ ^ ^^^ Toiiche I-. Mctro}iolitan Co., 6 Ch. 071 ; 40 L. J. Cii. 496 - 129 I49 Towers I'. African Tug Co., (1904) I Ch. 558; 73 L. J. Ch 395" !K) L. T. 298 : 52 W. R. 532 - 465, 714. 767, 787! 868, 872," 1353, 1355, 1359, 1360, 1410 i'X TABUK OK CASES. ■t ■ M i 5 1 : • ' . I } < 'h. i>'.]K)rt, Ltd. r. Shoiiborf;, 21 T. L. 1!. .lOfi I'lvg., -•. Hunt, (l,S!i.-,) 1 Ch. 4(i2; W. N. ;i,S!i.j A. »'. 7 - TieiR'hiinl r. ]Ii)skin«. Winch. iKl TrcnihMiun ,. ( althorin, Jo T. I-. It. 420 . r. vcix-l by U. 1,.. ij iJec. IJtOJ, 22 T. L. I!. 14il ----.. Trt-vor r. Wliitworth ;iN87\ 12 App. Can. 40» ; ,«i \V. 11. 14.5; .J7 r,. T. 4.i7 ; ■>7 L. J. Ih. 28 - :«!, .".S, ,l(i4, 4»>0, 465, 477, 478, 5Ui, d'J.l, ti.n. 74i», 7.')0, 751. 'm, 8r>l, ,S71, 81)1, 9;J9, itfiH, 1118, 1124, 1125. 1:(!K>. Vi. 40; 46 1,. J. (\ P. 636- 36 I T 812- 27 W. R 87 (C. A.) - - . -' 142, 207, 222, Tyne Boiler Co. v. Overseers of Lougl)enton, 18 U. B. D. 81 Tyne Mutual Steamship Insurance Assoc, r. Brown, 74 L. T. 283 • 75L. T. 483 - - . . 81,710,722.736 20 L. T. 765 ; 713, 61 L. T. 571 ; 452 62 I,. T. 633 ; Tyrell v. Bank of London, 10 H. L. C. 26 iiiii; 343 691 206 744 "i 598 230 515, 911, 1411 41 1284 1326 484 664 231 514 728 715 1402 358 443 442 1210 443 1354 1402 ,453 451 679 208, , 722 1350 107 , 744 131, 133 e i TAHI.E OF CAHE8. CZl U. XTnd-Ver v\at Unl. rliill 1'. H.>i>wcM«l, 111 Vis. •_>J(i ----- 1245 L'iiil.i«.ici(l <•. Harkor. (Isitit) 1 ("h. :i(IO; (is L. .1. Ch. 201 ; Mt L. T. :iiiti; 17 \V. U. ;M7 (r. .V.1 - . - - . ;(57 riiiliTwood -•. Liiudi'ii Music Hall. ;i!M)l) 1' Ch. :)(»!»; 47 W. IX.M)1; M L. T. 7.W: 7:i ; t>7 1.. J. 1'. C. 1'j:( (P. I'.; - - ' -■ . - . |i!(;( \'iauu r.ank of Kin-st(iii-ii})(.n Mull, A'., l;i I h. l>. 8IIS : "JH W. H. MIS; 42 L. T. .■l!l(»: -lit L. J. Ch. -'IH - H4.). 1444, 1471 ri.ioii liaiik (if Scotlaiiil r. r.)Ktir, (),■> J. 1'. s'Jl - - - lo.', I'liiiiii Cicdit liank i: Mitmv 1 lucks and HiirlKuir lioard, (iMftJI) "J (i. a 2 Cli. 707 : Is \V. li. lo.'iO ; 2:> T,. T. .iiil : ;iO I,. J. Ch. 7:io: (J Ch. 212 - - - - :i7 (Tiiitrd Sho<' Minhiiicry Co. of I'anada i: Unmet, (1000) A. C. .liiO - 424 liiitud .'^taUsCabk' Co.. /^, 4»L. J. Ch. 6(ij - - -144(i Unitud Stati'8 Koliiiiturp Cor]H)ration, Times, 2 Au^. 1005 - - 754 I'mtid Telcphono Co. ,•. Sliaipl.s, 20 C. I). I(i4 ; JiH W. U. 444 ; 02 L. T. ;is4 ; 54 L. J. Ch. (i;i;i - - - - - 381 Unity, &c'. .\s-sociatioii c. Kiufj, '.'5 lieav, 72 - - - 1186 I'liivcisiil lifo AMMUiaiKu Soiictv >: IJishoj) (1809), fW L, J. U. B. 0(12; HI I,. T. 422; (i4 .1. P. "•! - - . - . lol I'riiviMsal I>if(i AssuraiifoSocii'ty, 18 T. L. n, 19S - - - l:j;«» I'raHiolil Fields .-. Pappa. 1"> T. L. II. ;(;50 - - - - titili rriiiston -■. Whitelffff; (1875;. (ill 1,. T. 455 : 55 J. P. l.W - - ll»i Vuftliaiio .Viitliiacito Co., W. X. (lOlO) 1S7 ; lO.J L. T. 211 - H45, lioO Valiutiiic .M(^at Jiiiou Co. c Vah'iUiur K.xtrait Co., I(i T. L. 1!. .")22: sa I.. T. 259 (C. A.) - - - - 450,451 Vallombni.sa Kiibber Co. c Inhiiia Jieviuur ^1010), S. C. 519, Ct. of Suss. - - - - - - - -101 Vallftoit Sauitaiv I^uiuhv Co., (1003) 2 Ch. G54 ; SO T,. T. W; 72 I.. J. Ch. G74 - " - - - - - - llSO Vance ,'. East Ijiiiciishire Pvail. Co., 3 K. & J. 50 - - - 457 Wnabh'S c. liaiinj; lirothors & Co., (1802) 3 Ch. 527 ; til Ij. J. Ch. liOO; 67 L. T. 110; 40 W. 1{. (iOO - - - -11S7 Venning c. I.ecki". 1:! Hast, 7 - - - - - 1214 Vernor r. Ueneval and Coiiiniercial l o., (IS04) 2 Ch. 239; 63 L. J. Ch. 456; 70 L. T. 516; 7 it. 170 ^C. A.) - 766, 841, 863, 865. S6ii, 870, 874. 875. 879, 880, 881, 889, 8:13, S05. S96. ^07. 898, 900, 901, 902 CXll I'ARLK OK CA8K8. M 11 Vernon -■. II,illara, :H ('. D. 7|H - . - . - ;|,-iH Vick.'i> <•. Si,l(l..Il, i:. A. r. .-.iii; ..... •.>;i7 Vkkorn '•. Vkk'T*. 4 Ivf. .VJ!» ..... :«« Vick.TV i: (fr.iit Ka-terii Hiiil. I'.i., 7!t [,. T. IJl - . - .W Victoria Stf,nnl)niif< Cc, (1H!»7) 1 Ch. 1,")S - - - - 1117 ViniiiKHra*-, ti rh. !(»i; lil W. H. 17.1 ; 40 1,. J. Cli. 7!t - - Ulii Violot ' (ipsoliiluted. &c. Co., W. \. {mm) ;tj ; Hi) I,. T. ()H4 ...--. (Wlii. |:|S)» Viviui. & Co. (H. II.;, ;iiMM»,i J Ch. tM4 : ti9 I.. J. til. tij!»; ,S2 L. T. •174 ; 4N W. K. li:t(> ; T Miins. 470 . - . 457,1447 Viviuii 4Cn., /;^. ;i4 W. U. 411: W. N. ( 1 WHO) ;12 : .HL.T. .•1N4. tilO; j.i I,. J. Ch. 4;«i - - . I. lil, ll'.'.i. ll'.M, UJN. ]-iM Von II..V.U11 , . Ntil"t:ult, 14 f. II. -'liO; JN \V. U. 4iMi ; 42 L. T. :i(Mr ........ JH] Voiw and Saundors' (ontnict. 10;( L. T. 493 ... yo.i Vulcan Iron Workn. /,V, VV. \. (ISN.j) \>\> - . . . 1141 I J' Vm. \v. Wolfe, L. U. a Q. li. .li.-); -.'.i W. i!. 44 ; 4.J 1,. J. (J. li. , T. 30: 63 L. T. 420: 59 61 L. J. Ch. 670 : ION, 6jH, 7K:i, 370: .ii) I,. T. 654; 4.s 705 2S W. 1!. 163; 4!l 630, 636, WaddoU 1,38 Wudo I'. Ward, 4 1 Irew. 601.' Wuinwriphfs ( 'ase, W. N. (ih90) 3; 62 1 I,. J. Ch. 2.S1 ; 1 Mog. 463 Wakefield KoUin-r Stock Co., //«, (1892) :i Ch. 165 67 L. T. N3 ; 40 W. B. 700 Walbiiin r. Infrilhy, 1 M. & K. 61 - Walkir r. 13ri..(ley, (1900) 2 (i. B. 735 Walker /•. Hackney, 57 L. T. 763 - Walker .•. Levy, 10 V. I). 43(i : 2; W. 1! L. J. Ch. 273 - Walker f. London Tramways Co.. 12 C. Ii. L. J. Ch. 23 Walk, H»1I W,il!i< r. Smith. •.'!('. Ii. l!!:! ..... .-.oo W,i!lwyn I. Sliiphi'iircl, I Vex. 11!) - - - . . USA \V:iMi i: Si'crc tury of Stuff fi.i Iiniia, lO II. I,. V, .IfiT - .■t«4, I'SO Walfirs >•. (irwii. (lK.i ; (i:i [„ T. 7 r.' .... i:mk, iiutt WaltorH .•. Xciitlifin Canal Co.. .•. V>: (i. M. & 0. C'JIi; 1 W. I!. I iO; 2(1 L. T. 107: •J.Tur. N. .S. I ..... .tjh Wulfcrs r. WoiKlbriilsc. 7 (.'. P. 5(H .... 7,s7 Waial^wnitJi, \c. Co. ,: Wiii;lif. •.'•-' f.. T. ^(»■^ - - ilHil, 701 Waicl and l!ciin'« Ca>e. •_• < ii. 4:11 ; 10 L. T. 2J4 ; .Ki 1.. J. Cli. 4(1-.' . ■ - . . . . . . Klito Ware v. Tho Grand Jnmtion WufiTworks Co., J I{. & M. 17(» . !)V1 Warner r. Milliinrton. ;i Drow. o'l'.i ..... a is Warri'ii. lie, 7 Maii.«in, 1:17 - - - - - - 1197 Wnrriii;,'fon c. Kurl»v, .S Kawt, lM.5: (i E-p. N'J - - - I'.'U Wnrwii k r. liidianlwon. 1(1 M. & W. 2M4 .... ;(4!) Warwickf i\ Xoakr.-, I'oakc'. (17 .... . 770 WusliMifrton Iiiamoial Mini..tr <'o.. > INO.'t) :i Cfi. !t.-, ; t\i I, J. Ch. Mj : (!!l L. T. -.'7 ; 41 W. 1{. (JhT: 2 1{. .Vj;i (C. A.) - (i.J7. 7i'7 Watkin, /■:.r/,inlr. 1 ( '. I). l;)() . . . . . 144 Watkiiis c. Calcloiiiun Rail. Co.. (1S!)2; 1 (i. 15. HII3 . - 1::4(» Watkins r. S(ofli>h liMjiirial Iiisiirana- Co. (l^S'J . 21) H. li. I>. -■'<■■' ------- Hii. \JW Watiiiy r. MilsgraVf, o Ex. 1). 241 . . . - .100 Watson. /•,'. /.../■/,. 21 li. It. 1). .iOl . . . . - 1199 Watson & Co. ,•. Sj)iral Globe. Ltd., (!9(,2) 2 Ch. 209; 71 I.. J. Ch. .W.S; MIL, T. ^99 (JIO, (il7 Walson '•. Ealos, 2.'S Ilcav. 291 ; 2N L. T. O. S. 24;! • 2(i I-. .1 ( li y. »l:'7; :n \V. It IKI . 17 \.. T. MM (11 J ;m», IID'.I, \M-i U... ks .•. I'r..i«i'. I,. '!. s r, I'. ■».>: : .'l \V. 1{. (iTH; )_> I,. J. C, 1', 12!) - .•|;ij. »W7. TKi \V.i.'.:l'rii>».r /■, Dn.i,,-, ImC)! I (j. |!. lus ; ii| |,. ,1 n. II. I ; ;■< \.. r. s; i:| W. 11. IK. W'-ikiT-lnim'^ ( Il-W N ■ il. >;i - l-J'iti 4.1 llurrw, W. N. MMil* ua^l ... 11. il. A \-.\. 1 1. '.'MS; t7 I,. J. Kx. 704: :ls |,. T. ifJ iMHi •Jil \V. 1!. 71(1 ..... LMKl, ;>•.'(;, 7«iH W.IU ,. Mim.iv. 4 ICx. S4;l ...... 71. j Wcl-hii(i\ lihiiidi-r. lit 'li.s l.'.'hfiiiK ( ,.., l!Mi4) 1 ( |i. nT ; 7.'l I.. .1. ('II. KM ; Ml I., r, >.\:, W. li f . \ 4M(. 'I'd, ■>7ll, .i^I. ^ll. "In. ir.'-J. I'J.Mf. I'.'dO, 1^'til, IJd.i. i;i(i;t W.-UUnIi liicHIi'ii— I'lil (in- I.i;.'lililiir ('ci. '■. XfW Siiiili(„'lit liiiuii- ci.-rrtit ( \V. I!, .-.i).^ (( "to •_' 111 I : (lit I,. .1. (11. ■"ilti : x.\ 1,. r. ■»( : 4s i;t(;: WrM, j. ,.1 Tw.-..! (• •-•(» 1;, 1:1 W. I!. .•.,->« ; 1., .Kil : n I.. ,1. r W. .t. , ^\ li.-ky lli^-tillc 11 ' , .^,il|. iv . I^ I .-. W. 1:. .-.(IS - ;iiii .... , \V. N. ,lii(H>', .".;•: (iHT. 1,. 1{, ^it 7N.-) .\.('. 2!l!l: ()(> I,. .I.Ch. .id.': 7(1 I.. '1. 506; .1(1, :l(l. (>(l. ii;!, (i,j, ii7. 4(i.j. 47(1. 477. 47x .")!»:!. nil. iv.Va. (i:i;t. »>,s;j, u.l W' lri\s» ColIii'lii'M Til 'V^nlnck lllllul:,-.,} , .>,-.4 Wiiili nimii '■. M.'lv s r. 11 HI4 liiv.T il.!i- (' (174 : Id A)i|i. CuH. it.' (it n. rale, lH ( '. Ii. :;4(1 ;i(». 4(1(1, .)MI, M.'i.i :tMl.4(i.'i W. st I 'oii.^t ( M>M I'k'liK. Uiiwc'* Tiii-tces, If'd.l} I ( h. ■j!i7 ; J!iO(l) 1 111. 1 ; 74 1.. J. I'll. 347; !•:' I-. 'i'. bWi: ■);) \V. Ii. 4J& - (1(11. H4;i W.'.^t ('iiiiiImtI.iihI. .Vr. 1,1.. .•)•« 1,. T. 152: \V. N. (18hs) ,-,i . u.^;), ijH.j Wi-t .1; hii-laml lluiik. /,'.. 11 C. I). 7(iH; 4H I.. J. (,'l,. o77 ; 27 \V. K. .V.'ti ...... \Vi..97 1 Q. n. 2'.'(i, Cd 1,. J. n. H- :t(i: '■> I'- T. j(l4 - Wot lid.a anil I'urili. Stram.t. in Hank ul Si-.,tlan.l . . A.lili.-, 1,. I{. d FT. L. S.) Id^ W.wtein t'l.untiis Steam Hak.ncs t'l .. (1S97; 1 <'h. 617 (('. A.); (1(1 J.. .]. t'h. 1554 ; 7d I,. T. 2;i9: 45 W. H. 41s . - - 777 Wi'sKlii i'[ Canada Oii Co.. \V. N. v!S7i^ i4-> ... 1502 W.f.1.rn Wapiii Co. r. West. (Isy2 1 Cli. 271 ; (11 L. .J. Ch. 244: GG L. T. 4U2, 4(1 ^\. 1{. 1S2 Wotmm>tcr Kloitii. Suiijiiy Co., (lNy7 - 29(1 12dl, 12(12 TAHI.K OK (No, I). I rh. Jd; I7W. It. tlj; I't I,. T. .LiT : :1n I.. .1. Ch. 4)t .... 7(i, nil.', (ii,.-,, (,t,ii, 7'j'.'. l;t.-)'.> W-tcmV t'ttw (No. 21. 101'. |i. ,-.79; •J7 \V. It. :110; 1(1 I.. T. i:(: IN I.. J. t li. ti-> ----- 1140, net \V.-t..ii ., N.iw H. H. It. Kill; 'JN W. U. M.ll ; II I.. T. ti74; 4!l h. J. U. 11. :c.'« - . I'.'j, i:i;|. ;;(:! wiH.itiTipit'iiCuM:, L"j I,, r. ;m - - . .w. 7.-,it, m.su Uh.iitl.v .. .'^ilkxtofir Co.. Jit r. It. 71,-): :i;i W. U. 7!'7 ; .V.' I,. T. 7il'<; ,M I,. J. r),. 77S . . - . . tjifi W li.iitl.yx I'lii-t II. Wlhiitji y. I.imitiil (IIMH'. s.l I,. T, itii . ;ic.i \\l..liiii. /.v. (I>;., 1!» Vi'H. 'JOll - . - - . iisii Wliitl.i.iul .V (o. ,. Willi. J'Jtl.'M fl:. n:),-,; 71 I,. J. CI,. 4-.'| .Mi I,. T. ;!!»,-.; jd \V. U. 44J(,C. A.) ... ;(((, Wliitrlii'K'li ((liMirKd), I.imitiil 1'. CnvaiiuKli, N.'i 1,. T. .')l!t - . (i(i7 Wliit.' ami Sii,ifir« Ci.iitnut, (IMMi) I Ch. (i;t7 ; ti.') I,. .1. ( h. ISI ■ 74 1.. T. .■177: 14 W. II. 4^4 - - . . . :i,„-> Wliti- >'. Iliiyiiiaii, 1 Call. & Klli^, 1(11 . - j-jit, ^jiio Wliite '•. Land, &c. Ci... W. N. (1NS:») 174 . - - - 77N W hit.' ,■. Mm i.lii, N Von. .■«>;) - - - - 771 Vliit, r. Mitculfi', fliMCi) 2 Ch. .»(i7; 72 L.J. Ch. 712- M' I, 1' I'H 1217 WliilH .-. SpalTunl. (liMli: 2 U. n. 241 ; 70 I,. J. K. H. ll.,^ ; ni I,. T, .■<74 iC. .\.) . - - - . . l;i(i4 While. Tiiiii)ikiiiw ami Comagi' >•. Wilson, 2:! T. L. U. 4411 . - :t,>N Whil. .hiinh ;(!ci>i!.'..) & Co.. (IIMII) A. C. 117 - . •i7ti Whitehall Com t, /iV, i)(i I.. T. 2H(l ..... ,;).^ Whit.lioiisf, 42 L. T. •■(N.-i ...... 7ois WliitMhous.."« Ca-p, ;t Kii. 794 ; l.i W. R. NH2 - - . 2(11 Whitiloy'.- Cas<>, AV Ocn. l!y. Synd., (KMIO) 1 Ch. Wi; (i9 I,. ,J. Ch. 23(1; H2 I.. T. i;i4; 4H W. U. 440 (C. A.) - - I!i;i. ^00 Whitthy -■. liaih'V, 2] d. B. I). 154 - . . - 7;il Wliit.'h'y KxtToivr, I.iniiU'd '■. Guiii.j(?f>. (lWi8) 2 Ch. 4(1.") ; 67 I,. J. Cli. .ViO: 79 L. T. 20: .'j Mans. 249 . - - lll.M.Jl Whitii M .■. South Kastvin Hail. Co., K. B. A K. ll,i - :is, .140 Whitli'y, //., fi.5 I,. T. Jijl .... - T.-.l, 1047 Whithy I'a.tnfTs, Hi, Stwl's Ca.-c, ;J2 C. D. ;j:i7 ; 28 \V. U. 211; 49 I,. J. Ch. I7(i; 42 h. T. II - - ,,2, Hi, JJ.S, 481. 491. 10.-.2 Whitwaiii ■ . Wiitkin, 7M I-. T. ISH - . - . ;,-,. i;i.-,;j Wliitwood CUiniicul Co. r. Ilardmaii, (1,S91) 2 Ch. 410; (10 I,. .I.i ii. 42,S; 64 I.. T. 710; ;J9 W. K. 4:j;i ... - -HI V\i(;hfl(l f. I'otter, 4.1 li. T. 612 - - - - - 111 '^■•rmi i: Biioklcy, (l.';94) .'i Ch. 483; O.i I,. J. Ch. (iH9 ; 71 I,. T. 2H7; 43 \V. li. 147 ; 7 R. 469 (C. A.) - - . 11h9 /<2 m CXVl TABLE OF CASKS. Ill Wil Woo FAOE Wild -•. Scutli African Supply, *r. ("o,, (1904) 2 Ch. '.'fiS : 73 T,. J. rh. tl.-)7: '11 I,. T. 117 ■)2 W. It. lint Wilkii ('uiniiiiTiw. 1 1 Mil. ;i;)7 Will r. I'tiit. (1 I.unkat I'hinnitions L. J. Notes, Ml May, 1!I12 Willrtt r, Ar;,'riiti, \V. X. {iss'l) (ifi; lid I„ T. 7;i5 - 70, 704 - (iS.j .•i.i:i \Vi \Vi Dul.iii HiMiiT. IS'IH 2 Ch. 451; 07 I,. J. f'h. 044; 79 L. T. 2H1 : 47 W. H. .14 (r. A. Iliilliis, /■.■/ Ch. 474 (rfr. 2Kq.-.'lH; ItW. H. 7(10; 14 L. T. 4.-)0 ; :«L.,I. WilliiuiiH Williams Williams Williams Williams 44: WiUiai ( artwri-ht, MSO,")} 1 (J. H. ll'J Colonial Hank, .'iH Ch. I). ;)!».) lliithiwav. C. L>. J44 - hlLTil 10 T. I,. K. 4:J4 :!■-)« 2.19 86 1142 :i2.s i:iO:j . Xorth's N'avipitioii Co., (lilOO) A. C. IJiO; (UH)4) 2 K. H. ::i I,. J. K. M. .)7 il L. 1. W. 504 l(»2(t ns r. Stcpni (lN!>r 2 U. M. 257: 00 h. J. H. li. O.iO; 05 I,. T. 2(IS: :i!l W. I!. 5;i;i (C. A); nversin^', (l.sOl) 1 (i. 14. 7('0; 0» L. T. - S42 William Stt' (i. n. I). 4(19; 2S W, H. 901 ; 42 I,. T. 719; 49 I,. J. Q. li. OO.i WiUii Will lamsoii. I ■'I- 542 Willmott ■. I.omlon Hoail i 'ar. (191(1) 2 Ch. .>25 - Otio - ii9y il. 44. Wills r. Mini I Kx. Sl:i; 19 I,. J. Ex. 209 H55, 421. 14.JS - 092 Wilmov r. M'Naluaia \ I.td. ;s95 : ch. 245; 4:i W. H. 519; i;o, «o;i Wils 1(1 St.'vons' Contract. 1S94) :J Ch. 54(;; 0:i 1-. J. Ch. sO.i ; 71 r,. T. .'WS : 4:i W. It. 2;! ; H It. 041 Wilson ,-. Hrett. 11 M. & W. 115 - Wilson .-. Lord lliivy. 5 ii. 15. I». 51.S Wilson .-. Moyd. l(i Kq. 00 - Wilson r. Walluui. 5 Ex 1). 155 W'ilsoii '•. Wiltshire Wost Hartlf .1 Itail. C 2 Df (i. .1. \- S. 47.1 ims. 1 Cam]). 25.^ - ;ij4 - 7l:i i7, 7.S9. 1402 - 1247 705, 1175 .(7. r.i, 1185 - 1157 Wilts and Horks Canal ( 'o , :{ Ad. & El. 17 Wimhleilon Olvn ;i910) 1 Ch. 7:!(i - 17 Winchuni .'^hiiihiiildi; C /,V, 9 Ch. Div. .i22; 20 W. It. Nj;i ; .'iH h. T. 059 ; 4N I,. J. ( h. 4S Winirato (James) \- Inland Uevt 'oirimi-sioners, 24 Kfttie. 9;i!»; W. N. (1898) 129 Winstone's Case. 12 C. D. 239 Winterhottom. I!'. IH (J. H. I). 440 102 479 050, Wi perpetual Tiuste , (1903) A.C. I'. C. 139: r,. J. p. c 31 ; 87 I.. T. .509; 51 W. R. 241 ;i'. C \t itham line, C lallis (2nd ed .). 401 !»50 Wittaker r. Kershaw. 45 C. D. 320 Wolverhamiiton. &c. Itail, C I,. & \. W. Hail. Co., 10 E.i. 4:J3 - 411 Wood'sCase. :! I).iO. & J. 85: 15 E.|. 230 - - - - 55 Wood -■. Aiidor.ston Koundiy Co., 30 W. It, 9IS - - - 1^40 Wood ■■. I >e Mattes. 1 Ex. KtO - - . . . Ui)(j Wood '•. (»dessa Waterworks Co., 42 C, D. 045; 5H E. J. Ch, 028; ;i7 W . It. 733 ; 1 Mog. 205 ()33, 034, 70N, 10<)3 TABLE OF CASES. CXVU Woo-Yt Wood '■. Woodhouso, W. X. (ISnO) 4 - - - - Wood Ships, &<'.fo..f)2 L.T. 760 Wood, and Lewi.' Contract. (1S9H) 1 <^>;; "'■';! :(1«3?) 2 Ch. 211; «- L. J. (^h. 473 ; 7S L. T. 06.^ ; 4H W. H. •!•»;) (C. A.) - Woolaston'8 Case, 4 De O. & J. 437 ; 28 L. J. Ch. 721 Woolf r. East Nigel Co., 21 T. L. B. 660 . - - - Worth's Case. 4 Drew. 529 - Wr.i?p, Limited. /?»■, (1807) 1 Ch. 796 7)97 ; 45 W. R. oo" 66 L. J. Ch. 419: 76 L. T. 62, 3U1, 359, 478, 485, 909, Wrexham Mold Bail. Co., lif, (1899) 1 Ch. 440; 80 L. T. 130; 4 W. R. 464 - . - - 25 L. T. 471 ; 41 L. J. Ch. 1 - 19, 192, 199, 201, 692 35 Wripht's Case, 7 Ch. 35 ; 20 W. R. 45 (C. A.); 12Eq. 3.33 Wright V. Chappell, 17 W. R. 635 - Wright f. Ilorton, 12 App. Cas. 371 ; 36 W. R. 17 ; 36 L. T. 782 ; 56 L. J. Ch. 378 Wright r. Simpson, 6 Ves. 714 ; Smith's Merc. Law, 11th ed. 625 - Wulff I'. Jav, L. R. 7 Q. B. 756 - - - - " Wye Valley Rail. Co. v. Ilawes, 16 C. D. 489; 20 W. R. 177; 43 " L. T. 715; SOL. J. Ch. 223 - - - 871,872. Wrlde i>. Radford, 9 Jur. N. S. 1169 - - - - Wynne's Case, 8 Ch. 1007 ; 21 W. R. 893 ; 29 L. T. 381 ; 43 L. J. ' Ch. 138 - - - - - - ■ *'^' T\Ot 1451 725 .354 659 727 204 945 686 993 , 358 688 1245 1247 1336 1186 1481 z. Xenos V. Wickham, L. R. 2 H. L. 310 83 T. Yarborough v. Bank of England, 16 East, 6 - - " ^" Yelland's Case, 4 Eq. 350 **_^ Yeolund Consols, 58 L. T. 922 "" YoUand, Uusson and Birkett, Ltd., (1908) 1 Ch. 132; 97 L. T. 824 - York Glass Co., 60 L. T. 744 - - - York, &c. Rail. Co. v. Hudson (1853), 16 Beav. 485 York Tramways Co. v. Willows, 8 Q. B. D. 685 618, 1-285 - 1124 711,712 60, 736, 737, 740, 742, 744 Yorkshire, &c. Co., 9 Eq. 630 ; 18 W. R. 541 - - 688, 772 Yorkshire Miners' Absoc. v. Howden, 21 T. L. E. 431 ; (1903) A. C. •2oO - - - - ^ Yorkshire Railway Waggon Co. t'. Maclure, 19 C. D. 478; 21 C. D. 309 ------- " "■*" CXVllI TABLE OF CASES. < J Tor— Zuc Yorkshiit' Rail. Co. r. Miichirf, L'l ('. IJ. lidT ; 30 W. U. 7(il ; 47 L. T. :;!»(!; .■.) L. J. Ch. w; . - . - - Yoiiiifr. AV;^»irf'-. 17 ('. D. 6(i.S . . . . . YounsanJ Ifarston'sC^Dtnut, fr, ;tl r. P. ItiH - Yoiiiii: .'. Ashlfv ( iiiriLms I'n.iK'iti.w. (19o:i^ 2 Ch. IT.'; 72 1,. J. Th. 520; NH L. T. r)41 {C. A.) - - - - - Yoiinif I'. Uiiiik of Hinftal, I Dca. fi22, (177 - - - - Yoiin;; c. lirownlw & Cc (1911), S. C. (i77 [Ct. of Scs^.) - Yoiiiiff -. Daviil Pavnc & <'H : 53 W. R. 447 - - 71-'. 724. 725, 745, 787 Younsr r. South African. &c. Sviiilicntc. (18HC) 2 Ch. 268; 65 L. .1. Ch. 638; 74 L. T. .-.27; 41 W. H. 509 - - - 692, Ystalyfera OasCo., /iV, W. \. (1887; ;iO . - - - Ystrailvfodwfr, &c. Board v. Xowport As.sessment Com., (1901) 1 Q. li. 406 - PAGE 474 1248 ;i54 355 1194 752 1051 1192 , 788 1099 l;!89 - 108 ^h..- ^Jli Zuccuni c. Xaeupai Co., 61 L. T. 176; 1 Mof;. 2,30 1440, 1443 i;" ADDENDA AND CORRIGENDA. l';i>,'0 l02.~Liverpool and London and Globe Co. v. Bennedt, re- ported also in (1912) 2 K. B. 41. 453.— Refer also to Kingston, Miller d Co. v. Thomas King- ston d Co., (1912) 1 Ch. 576; following Fine Cotton Spinners and Doubters' Association v. Harwood, Cash d Co., (1907) 2 Ch. 184. 554.— F. Stacey d Co., Limtd v. Wallis, also reported in 106 L. T. 564. ()89. — Clause 66, in note refer to Gardner v. Iredale, (1912) 1 Ch. 700. 691. — Note to clause 59 on the oonstruction of clause 66 of Table A., see Fruit (Did \egetOBlUUJillfiA, •» ioc/l.J iTaftc$p. 1 of Sig. B.] MWhiUMHHi (X)MPANY PR[](^EDEMS. OUAPTEK 1. PKKI.IMINAKV \OTKS. I'A'IK Funu.itidn I Kt^triftiiinf nil Tiaininjf Hiirrtor?*. . <» Miniiiiuiii SubxTiption " (Aminifiic* iii»'iil nt" nusinrs-* -^i: Effect ..f liicori».r:iti.iii -Jl ''nr;.ur:iti- rjtj>.u-itic> '2' Action of t'umjmny'H iViT'iit;* 'Mi MiiiilHivhip 4.'i Subwriptiim 4t> AlL.tniiiit I'.i Li:ibility to jKiy for Slmrrs . , .»s Amount of C.tiisiilfiation .... (in Ke^i^TtT of MciuU'r-i 'i) I'owcr- of Muj()ritii'.> Li rartinr!.liip Law, appliiahility of . . 7"' Iiriplii'd Noticoof Mom. 1111(1 ArtiilcB "T rriMimjitioii i,( Rogiilarity :cs ro- jrarils Indoor Manii^romi-nt 71' ComnioM .Sial S'.' Ki'>iil> mo or Doniii'il 84 Incim,. Tax 87 ( 'oqioration Duty 11)4 Kates 105 lUotfal AsMKialiou.H 10!» Di-.'olutioll 11) Nfortmaiii \l-_ Trailo I'nion.H 1 1;, Fort'ijjn Compauii-s lis The Formation and Registration of Companies. Tin; CiMipaiiio.-^ (C'onsuliilation ) Act. 19(18 (8 Edw. 7. o. (i'^). uow iroveni-; tlie lormuliou ul Kiinpanu'.-i. and lia^ taken tlic plaoo nl' tin C'oiupanios Act. 18G2 (2:> ^\ L'fl Viit. t. «',i i. and of tlio iiiaiiy Acti- umoiKliuo- and e.xtondiiig- the provision.^ of tliai Ait. 'I'lie ,\it of 18U2 was aincniied and oxtcmlnl liy the followiinr \its; - 1. Tlio Companies Seals .\et. 18(J4 rJ7 \iet. e. 1(1). Tliis Aet enipowercd eoinpunies in eertain ■ ,i>es to nave itlieial seals for use aliroad. 2. The CompiMiies Aet. I«(>7 (30 .n. HI \irt. e. lUl). This .\et provided for ret. IH77 (10 A: 41 Virt. .■. 211). This Alt provi.lMl further for rcilui'tioii of cnpit.il. ft. The C'uiii|.ai.i.'s A. t, 1»7!» {fi L 43 Viit. r. 7ti). This Art provided for r.-rciri-'tration with limited liability of unlimited compuni.-^ and al.o for llie >r,ati..n of rewve capital. fi. The C.mpatnes Act. 1N«0 i tH Virt, .■, l!t). .... Thi» Act prnvido.1 for p;.vm-nt,olf of proHt* in rnlu.tion of capital, „nd .ripowcrcl th- l(. ..'i-tr:.r to -trikn nan,.- of .lefi.nct .ompaniei otr th" ri'iriilcr. 7. The Companies I'oloni^il l!-;i,trrH A( t. I8sa I »« .V 47 \ ict. c. :10;. This Act j.nniiled for cdiinlal rcffi«ter« in ccrt;iin ens,.* 8. The Companies A. t. iNSli I (•» Vict, c, S.IK This Act ;,mer,dc,l tlic \ct nf IH(i2. :is to windinjf-up in MotUnd in certain p'spects. H The Preferential Payments in llankrupt.y Act, IH8S ^ol \ .V. Met. c. 6.). tl.ouph not one of the Companie. .\.ts, nevertheless affects the windinR-up thereof. See also the Act of 18117, ■nin,. 10. The Companies , .Uemorin.lum of Association) Act. I8!m '.".;! ,V ..4 \ lit. e. IVI). This Act prinicled for the extension of olijects. .Vc II The Companie, \Vindin--up \ct, 1890 (.^3 i .^4 Viet, c oi), largely modified provisions of the Act of I8(i2 in ri -ard to w>n,lini,-up. !•• Th,. Director*' Liahilitv Act. 18!»0 (53 ii 54 Viet. e. 04). This \3 (;V, ,^ .57 Vict. c. .58). modified the Hankruptey Act. 18.><3. in relation to \vinilini,'-up. 14 The Preferential Payments in Hankruptey Anienilnient .\ct, 1897 (6(t Vict. e. lit). The Companies .Vet. 1898 i.ll ,v «-> Vict. c. L'li). mo.lihed sect. 2.. ot the Companies .\ct, 18(17. The Cnnipanies Act, 1900 (ti3 .'^ (il Met. c 18), extensively amended the Com|>anies Acts, 18fi'2 and 1867. ,. Companies Act, 1907 (7 Kdw. 7, e. 50 1, amended the ahove .\cfs in a nuniher ot im]Mjrtant jmrticulars. 18. The Companies Ad, 1908, enabled certain Inrcitrn and colonial companies to hold land and other property. In (lie followiii!.' [tiv^c- tin" Coinji.anies (( on>oli(liitioTi,i Aci. l'.»08, is irenerally roiorrcd to as •the Act," but soiuctinies as ih.. Act of l!)08," and sometimes as 'tlM' Consoliilation Act." The Act eotitomplates the foi iiiation of three c!a.ssos of rr)mi)iuiips (■ 1 ) companies limited by .sharos; (2 ) companies limited by tcuarantfie; ,;!) unlimitod ujrain into (a I A prM-iioctiiH romiiiiny." that is to say. a i i>nipany whinh i-i fonnofi on this footinr.'. tliat on its formatiDn there i-i (o lio an invitation to tlio jmlilif liy prowpoftus to -•'h.icril>o for shores. (bl 'A non-pio^pi'cHis i-oiiipany." tlinl in to s.iv. u com- paiy whii'h is formed on the fooling: that it is imt to l)e a prosppftns ximpaiiy nr a privalo company. )inl is to fiJo a siatomi'tii in lieu of |)rosppc|iis: or i2) A jirivalo coni])any." tliat is to Hay. a private company as defined in soct . 121 of the Art Tlic formalion and C'lMstiinlion of a private company is dealt with separately in Chajilor X.. ;„/,v, and it will make for clearness if the picliniitiary step.s lo be lukon resjioclivoly in the cn-e of the public riinpany. inclndin>r iheroin the prospodus cornpanv and the non- |||.ispoclnfi company, arc licre sunmiariscd. The Public Companies. Prospectus and Non-Prospectus Companies. The foilowinf,' are the roiiuisite steps for formation:- - l,li Prepare the menioranduiii of association in accordance with sect, .'i of the A takin<^ care to state therein - ' I I The name of the proposed company, not foruettinj^ the word ' limited " as the last word of the name; (2) In what pari of the United Kingdom— I':n^'land. Scotland, or Ireland -the ^ibtercd office is to be siiiia'c; (•'i I The objects of the company; (4 I That Ilio liability of the members is to be limited; and I'm Tiic amonnt nf the capital and of the shares intn wiiidi it is divideil See Form 70. infrn. p. 10i». There mii-1 be at least .seven snbscribers to the memo- randum: no subscriber i.s to tal.ie less than one share, and the number each takes must be .set njiposiic bis -ifrn-Nir.'. ( Sects. 2 and 3 of the Act of 1908, "l (2i The memorandum must bear a lO,!!. stamp, and must Iw signed by each subscriber in tjie presence of and be li 2 s«.4 - ■* ■ i. I'KKLIMINAKY NOTFJ*. [('UAP. I. (Soil •> of >l'» ■^'' „ltc-t«Hl bv Olio witii«'H> at the l<'u«i ,,...,1 ,„ ull..t..uM... u^ providod lor »» Horts. 8.. uud ol ;ll:^:l.o'„.on, un.U tho .l,on.auvo o,,o.od l.v , Uo„ ,4, Tl!o Sr!. u,>.iau,.u ,l...u.,I bo o.,.,o...;I .u .opa.^- • rinuph- and numbered a.i.bu.o.i.allv. They .n-.' V ' i 'and .nav adopt or ox-.udo all o. anv of ho p . vl'ions .on.aincd in TaMo A in the iir.^. -l-»"'^' '" "" Ai.t (Sort.- l^Jand 1 I of tho A(t.i • !. Tho ■... lo- .UUM boar u U... >.au.p. and mu,l Ik. ..^n.o.l '" '':; .uZn«..>... Ua. nK.n.on.ndun. oras.oc.aUon Se l^oMhoAH., Ha,h .ul..nl,o. .lu.uldwn.. 0,1-;:- hi. M^nauno hi- addro-- and do,.np .on .So- ■Zn t'H - Kaoh M.b>. ribor ....... m,m. .n .ho pros.m.. ^ L 'n-"MS,na.u.o .nus, bo a.to^.od bv one ,v..no>< a. Ill; (Sec. 12 of .ho A... S.. Fo,n, :-... <./.«. ,6, If anv PO..-OU i. appointed by iho arti.lo-- a dnector ho .; -t,'bofo.o tho a.,xelo. u>o .o,Mo,od. ..g« ---;;'■ ",itin,- ... a.-, a. Muh ^.e.t. 72 of .ho A.., --e 1- onn 22J>. i ',.,0 .utuK- .04ui.e the di.o.to.s to hold a sha.o ::^ldi.a.K,n. ho n.u«.. al.o before .uch ....t.^on^ ji.ho. M,b,..ibo tho n>e.uovandan. of assoo.ut.on to 1 > "ualihcation or enter ruto an a.^xx.e.no.X to lako .u. 1. .,uah- Ikation Ibkl. See Form .-.0. ,7, Person- who huvo oon-onted ,o bo .liroo.or- shn.dd. ..-ulo. .i..„inu an a.-... m w.i.i"^- -^ "''"ve mont.onod m,m. a_i a:thori.y ,o lilo tho a-.^ou. .i.h tho Ko.M.trar. ,.o.. .. of tho Alt. I 8. P.ena.o a li-t of po.-ons ,if any. who have consontod .,. be dhtotor.-. a. by .o.t. 72 ,2, of .ho A.t ro,,unod. Soo Form 2:U . Q to, .. statuto.v .Uvlaration be made (if tho company is *'' '1.e:ii.ed"n England, by a solicitor of tho Hi... Court „,. -v-oil in tho formation of the company, or by a per.-on uami-d in tho artiik- of a.s.ocia.io„ as a director or .e.-.o- tarv of the co.npany. of compliance vvitlr the i-oqu.sr t.ons of "the Acts in respect of rej^ist ration, and ot matter. I'KOSPKtTIJN AND N0N-PKO8PtX'rU8 (OMrANIFi*. Si'i) Koirn 227, und prt'fwiiiiit aiiit 111! id.'iiuil ihuicio "Oct. I" C2). tiltt., hifnn llio r.iiiMi cKunii J.ll), ami (Icilaiaii.iii i Form 221). and onv uffitH-iut'iit 111 lukc i|iialiliiiiiiiiii >liaii).s. lo Iho Keiri-ilrar of rompaiiiu-. Si)riillici wall an aiilli.iiilv in wiiliiiM liy I'arji diroclor to lilo his luiiMjiii lu ail and lo Uio his contract to take qimlilieutiuu -haie.- I'a\ lo th<> Itogistmr tho reijuisito I'ws on r<>y:i«liali(jh. ii.ini.'l\. ih.i^o li\ftl l.v Tahlc B in the Hist SI hodnic lo the Ad, and the luhliiional foe of .>«. por 100/. ol capilul imposed hy tlie Fiiiamo Att, 18"J'J. ill) la di" fiuiM' liie ltc;,M>irar will issuo tin .eililifaH) ot iiKnip.iialiuii .\« lo the ell.-ci ol wlii, h. .-, e miru. p. I't el s)'(i. >„ nnich lor toriaalion. I.ul in the rase hoili ot llie prospectus •tmipanv and ot the n..n-prn-perin.s .onipaiiy the Ait presi'ribos iinllior lOiidiiiohs whirh nuist Ik> loiiiplied with hefoio the .'Otn- |iiiny I'uii I iiiiMieiiie lin»ine.s-. or exercise its Ipnrr.iwiiiu- powers. These diller soniewhal. jis appears lielow: In tip I. I'm IVn,p.i,.fii- (•..ni|wi[y. In fliciaM- ..f a N'iiTi-pni-|nituhC„i,ii. luy. \l i'riiini' iii-.>sii' .if till' i' I'oiirsi' file ;litatt'nirutin liiunf prospii tuH, tikinif upccial lari' t imply with Hrct. S j of the Art. anil lit -mli "statenifiit bf ilatiil anil -iitmil in ,ii lonlanii,' with the -iiiil St itioii anil till' form sit forth in thr Mi-unil whtiluloto thf Aiit ,iiit',;i. p. I'll-t;. Afttr thi -tatuniint has httn tih'tl, Ktthe niinimmn siibspription In- ol.tuinti], and lot thf company tfo to allottnint, and in duf course lilr tin tliilanitiou nn-ntiont-d in ^^t. S7 of thf Act. and obtain thf RfKistrar'sivrtitioate. undfrsub-sfct. (2) of thf samf SOI tiiin, that it is piititled to fomnifncf husinoss. Airordinn; to the latest Board of Trade return, the total number of lonipanies registered in 1910 was 7,184. that is, ,",,4.^9 private innpanins 1,085 public- ^vit'i a prospectus, and 40 public companies "itli ;i statement in lieu of prospectus. T2L.*^JBT*B- -••■.».-; r^tW^^ypBE-SHMx::?- fi- I'll -ji H«pftrictioii- on imuiiuj ilirei turn. Not cHpal'i' ahaUnot U uaiued, &( . PKKLIMINAKY NOTES. [ClIAl-. Restrictions on naming Directors (i^«'t. 7J). One of till) lir^l .sU'ps in tin; t'onuatiuii ul iv company is tlie clioifo of (liio.'ois. With reioifiic.' I.' tlii- s,Mr. 72 of tlio Ai-t providui- that: — (.1.; A i.er.-uii >liu!l iiot hv iNiiJutile of l.-iii- appoiuU'd diirrtor of ;i eompiiny l.y the articles, :init shall not bi- named us a director or (.rojio-.i-d dirci-Uir of a lonipany in any prospertus issued liy or on helialf of the i-onipany, or ill uny statement in lien of prospectus tiled l.y or on behalf of u eompany, unless before tiie registration of the arlieles or the publieation of the prospei.tus, or the lilinsf of the statement in lieu of prospoetu-, :•> the la'e jnuy bo, ho lias by himself or by his ajtent authorized in writin^,'- (i) sijfiied and tiled with the Uetristr.ir of Companies a consent in writinir to act as such director; and (ii ) either si|.'ncd the memorandum for a uumlicr of sharc< not less than his i|iiaillieation (if uns ). or -i^ned and tiled with the Kcuistrar a eou- trael in writintj t.. take from il jmpany and pay for iiis iiualiheation shares (if any). Vl.) On the ajiplicatioii for rcLristratioii of the memorandum and articles of association of a .ompany. the applicant fliall di'livcr to the Registrar a list of the persons who have consented to be directors of the company; and if this list contains the name of any person who has not so consentivl. the applicant shall bo liable to a iii.e not exceudin;? fifty i>ouiids. a.) This section shall not a|iply to a ijri\ate company nor to a prospectus issued by or on behalf of a company after the expiration of om' year from the date at which the company is entitled to couimencc business. Shall not be capable of being appointed director of a com- pany by the articles . . unless. &c. These words, so tar as the artieio- me uouconied, dual ouly with actual appoiutiuout. Persons can still, it would seem, witliuul cuiuplyiiiy; with those conditions, be uauied in the articles (thougii not in tlie prospectus) as ■'propo.scd' directors, and a power can be inserted for someone le.u., tli<> aubscriliers lo the memorandum ol association, or a majority of them) to appoint such porsotis to be directors. If no share ijualilicalion is required, by llic articles, a ikjisou can be named as a director, subject only to the consent being si<,'ned and hied as required by sub-sect. 1,1; i,ii. it i» uot uncommon for the quali- fication clause ill the articles t,, u.xcopt the tirst directors from it« operation . Shall not be named as a director or proposed director of a company in any prospectus issued by or on behalf of the company, or in any statement in lieu of prospectus, unless, ' &c. These womIs jilainly apply to a prospectus issued after the refris- tration of a company, but il seems very doubtful wiielhor they can be held to aiiply to a prospectus issued before the company's incor- poration. Where they apply tliey cover botli persons 'lamed as actual directors and persons named as proposed directors. UES rKlCT10N.S ON NA.MlNCi UIKKLTuUS. If jio sliaie (lUiililiialioa is jreijuiivd, a diroudjr uiuv be luiiupil in the piospeLtu,-., subject oiilv lo llie ^i<;niIl^,' .lud liliiio uf ibe cohmmii as rO(|uiit'il by ;-ub-sect. (1) (ii. Articles." Those wonU lelor lo the iirticles iii tone, wliothei \r;..l,., iri llicii- .iiiLriiiul hinii or a> altered by s|i,.,iu| ir-.,hiiioii. S.^e >ect. 2.S.".. Or by his agent authorized in writing. W lieie a person i- Xgni. iianioil in llic arli(.le> a- a diriTior tlic aiitliority under uliicii (hi' ajfcnt ia auiiioii/od to sign must, if reciiiiivd. lie |)io m.-iy be a -.'[.aiale docunieni lor (■■n-.-.it fill 1 1 .liiecloi, or several prupo-ed directors may . oucur iu one coii- seiii See Foriii 42, Board of Trade Ordi'i-. Match 2'.>. litltlt, Foiin 2.'8, infra, p. 606. If preferred, an a--enl to sign iind tile can be ajipoinied thus: I the underd'^ned. hereby authorize .Me.s-i-. . of . tn si-n iin .oiisenl to act as a director of The - Coniiiany. I.iniiled. now ati.int to be ro<.'istered under ihc Compaii.c^ ^ ( on-oli, la-ion i .Act. i'.'iis. and lo lile .such coiimmh on niv bclialf wlili tie- b'c^i^i rar of (■oiiipaiiies pursnani to iblo the liliiii,- of hi-^ coii.'^cnl, or i^ about to ^i abroad, he may in wrifin? .nuthori/e hi-^ a^ent not only to ///,• the eotmnit. but also to nii/ti it. Either signed the memorandum of association,' &c. If the article, do not coulaiii any clause Je(piinii- a .inaliilration iu sli.ire., the coiiditious in ..ocl. 72 nil liave not to be .ompliod with, but if die articles contain -iicb a clau-e. t^ii; must be complied wilii. Ill sub.-cribinjr the meniinanduni ot u.-otiation it mn-( be borne ji, mind that a lirm (onlract i-; iheieliy constituted as from the m nl •if incorporation to take and pay in money or money's worth bir the shaiu.s sub,-ciibed for. and that the subxribei uili be liable, even thuii-li the company should not becomo eii;iiUd to cimimenco busi- iie>>, under .-ect. 87. Hence, if the directors subscribe the meuio- i.iii'iaiii for their ijuiililicalions and then the company does not f!oa:, 'III? "ill. to the extent of their qualiiications. be liable to pa\ up. c '/ to jiro\ide for expenses Itut if the alterinuiv is ndopi^-! iianiciy, the filing-- of a contract, the jiosiiion of the directors is mad.' <'.i.sicr. for the cmitract to bo hied may I>e made luovisioiial on ihn ' iiipanv becoming;- entitled tcj conmiemo bii-iiie.ss. liitliiTHit'iiMd. ■H -■M til i *;. riM'-IIMINAKY NOTKS. [UlIAP. 1. iV.vi- 1 iJar; ,„coo,l,-„l in n.f M.n.iM- ,.1 .. poi-ou iu^* a .li.v(tor in llu- p.os,H..lus ot '. .oinp.MN M.,l N.'t ivo-i>loml. thn ,ontr..t slimiM, as tl..- eompanv uill not !.f ii. .■^iM.■lM.■ lit iIm> tiiu.N !..■ mw.Ic uith Boino oiio as Irust.-e ior the r.Mupauv. IlarlU'tf.^ n,^c. loth. l.",;. Tl,o li.-isl.ar. how- .nor. aiipcai-.- to 1m. .aii-lird «ill. ill- lilinu' "I' an ins|n,ni..nt whirl, l|0(•^ lint npciali' as a roiitrad. s<'f hlirn. Follil .■)il Whcir ihr rnMliart i< In l"' tilc'l "I'i'r iiKnipnrallnn. .■,-/. a- a rnii- .Jilioii pro. < I In naiuia- ^nni.' nri - .> a ,liiv, Inr in a i,.ns,M.clus it >hu..l.l hv ma.lc will, Iho ,n„ipa„v itsHf nv wi-l, a .lalv aalh„r,«Ml a<,'tMil (if llif ((inipauy. Shall deliver to the Registrar a list oi the persons. Tlus .s,il,..sLHl. Cii 111 l<'ri„s n.ily .ipfiau-s nil llic appliialini, in, i.^mMia- lion of a „,.Miiura„.liii„ ./-./ >'Vi aili.l.'.s .,1 a-u.iatini,. a„.l :l,t is tn specify tlio i>eisnii.s who i,au> rnii.oiHi J to be dire, tnr.s. aii.l i.s ih.'n.fniv iint in t.Mius .,mliiied m those who are appointed l,v the ariide^. Il i.s appieheuded that a i,im-oii .aiinot he treated as bavin- ,„n~ei,ted if his ronseni lie nion-l.v ( niidilioi,. I. r.,,.. if ii" has signed a .on.sent in writin- tn a-t as a dir.-Hor r,.„dilinnally n„ ilie oinpanv l.ein- iv-iMeiod with a .^-perilied ineinoianduu, and articles, nr .onditinnally on a sperilie.l board beinp- ;,pp„inlod a.s the li.st directors. If, however, Uio list is to inrhi.le Mirli per-nii-. il is appre- hended that any eondilion should he slalod in it, lor oiher«iv a p,.nallv would he inrui red under s„l,-M-,f. ^.Si. Th,' . nns,.„t need not l,e"ii, writing: a verbal mnsent brio-.- the persnn t;i\ing it wilbi, tlie iroid^. unless, as seeln.■^ pos=ible, the ,'on-^ent iiientinued in sub- vert. 1 2) means tlie .signed eonsont referred to in paragrapii in >•. the preceding sub-seetion. On the other naud, tliere docs not seem to be mu.h obje.'t iu iilintr lists of consenting directors wliei, their uritleii eonsent.s are alrea.ly on tlie file. But for the "=afe(y nf the ;,]!pli(;,nt ft written enn-enl i.s desirabhv The applicant is lo deliver the list to tiie Hegistrai. and this statnt.nv .lutv the applicant must inuform. There is no penalty lor not r. March 20, I (too, and Form 2.'ll. infra. \3: This section shall not apply/' &c. This sub-.sectiou is of ;^reat impoiiame. It enacts in ellect that the sei^tiou shall not apply— I a) Ton private company; or. MINIMUM SUBSC'UIPTION. Til ii j)io-siip«i l)y or on bolialf of a compivny after tlio f'spiratioii ol' one year Iroiii tlic date at wliicli f)iP rompaiiy 1^ otilitlod )o i(iiiiiiioin(< liiisino-*s. The Minimum Subscription is.e(t. sO). Till' ;iliii-i', \in) (.DiiiiiiDU at one lime, ul' K'^'inp; lo allni iiiciil on a »li(i||y iiiadiMjiialc ^iilif-ciiplioii Icil In the iiilcrfcicnrc of the l.ofjis- jlniL'. aiJil M'li. 8."i of llip Art. iv|ilii(iiij; scci . 1 .il tlic .\i\ ol I'.tOlt. iiiiw provide^ at^ follow^: 1.) .Nil iiliiiini" -h.-ill lie iiiaili' ul' any sliari' ■apitiil nflVri'il to the jiiiblic f'lr ii'.--i-ri[itiiiii. iiri.r>> tlu' fdlluwirit,' ciirulit'uM)^ have lircn (-ouiplit'fl witii, nanu'ly, — '^ 'I'itf anion, it 1 if any I tixrd Ity i!ic 'iirtii or ariii-ii-^. anil nunnil H! lln- j.ri)-|if. Ill- as the iniliiiMiini .; .■m iipuii m liiili iiii' *iir('cr(n-s may jirdt'ccd In ailnlniciit : ni' '- i il' iin ainniint is m) fixrd ••iiid iianinl. ,' . rni' \\ linii' aiunnnt ol' ilic |ilii'atioii fm- the aiiiuuiit so Kxi'd ami iiaincd, or for tlic wholo amniiiit olVcroil foi- snl>srriptii>ti, lias Ikm'ii paid to :inil [I'ccivcMi hy tin' roiiipany. ■-'.) Till' aniiiuiit so tiNc'd and Mamcl and tin' wlinln amount al'oi'i'said shall hr ni i.'iiH'd oxclusivcly of any amount p: yalile otlicTwisi' tlian in lasl,, and is in this \i'T rrfrrri'd |:i as the ntiniinum siibscriiition. i"i.) The amount payalilf on ajipli.allon on I'acli slmir shall not lii' h'ss ilnin live ppr iTiit. of III" niiniinal anionnt of tlio sharp. ill If the iiinditions aforis.iid liav(> not liii'ii compliod with on ihr cxpiralioii of flirty days aftiT tlir lirst issue of tin' jirnspcrtus. all mont'y rcccivod frcm appliranti for shares shall lie forthwith repaid to thi' appliiants v, itlnmt interest, aiiil. if any ,-uih nloluy i.s not .so n'paiu »illiiu forty-iinht days after tlic issue if tlie piuspeetus, till' dlreetorn of the lompany shall lie jointly and severally li;;lile to -ipay that nnmey with interest at the rate of live per i-entum jier iiiiinm from the expivatioti of the forty-i'ii.;lit days: Provided that a direetor siiall not he liable if he proves that the loss of the money was ?iot ilne lo any iniseonduit or nei^licenee on his part. a. I .\iiy condition reipiirinff or bindinir any applicant for shares to waive "I'lplianee with any re(|iiirpnn'nt of this section shall lie void. I'l.) This section, cm ept sub-section (.'i) thereof, shall not apply to any allot- Mil it of shurc, snbse'incnt to the Krsf allotment of shares olfered In the public fnr siihseripfie'i. "•' In M ase nf the tirst allotment of share cap'' d p.ayable in cash of a •'■Mipaiiy which does not issui' any invitation to the public lo subscribe for it.s -lines, no allotment sIi.tII he made unless the niinininm subscription (that is to s;i_\ 'I'lie amount if nnyi fixed liy the meinoraniium or .irtidcs and named in the statement in lieu of pros|iei-tus as the minimum .subscription upon which the directors may pnieoed to allotment: or, i'" if no amount is so fixed and named therein, the whole amount of thi' share ea|)ital other thnn that is,sned or agreed to he issued as fully or partly ]i:iid up otherwise than in cash, lias b.cu suhscribed. and an amount not less than five per tent, of the nominal niioiint of cMch share payable in cash has been jiai a pri\ai« has ulh>tU'(i any sharr^ or dcli'-ninic- hrl.trt hundred aud eiirht. ciMiipany ur lu a nuiipaiiy whirli tin- tir-t liay t bi' liiiriie iu luiuJ;- ( I) It ai)|ili<'N to |)iu.--i.ioi til.-- cuiiiiiiiiiii-~. See .v«//n(, ji. !. (2 I I( applios to ii"U-iiio.-j)i'(iii-^ coiiUMiiii'^. Si'e suiirn. p. .'t {'i) I', 111)1 M|i|)lv III luivatc coiiipani*'.^. See \i. .'i. (-1) E.\iO[)l as regards ])aragruijli (^ ) it Joes not app.ly iiiilo-'^ t^harc capital i> uUcrod to tlio jmlilii' lor subscriptinii. (5) It dot'-; not apply to a coinpaiiy wliiiii ollcr.s only dt>bejituri>.- or debouinrc slock for piiblii' subscription. (G,l It is nol conlined to au ollor made by or mi behalf of the Loiu|iaiiy after im nrporalioii: it applies also, it would seem, to au oiler made before llie incorporation. The section evidently eonteiiijilales that the oiler will be made by a prospectus. ^See sub-sects. (^1 i ond (4i.i liiit it must nut too readily be a-sumed that an oral oUer would not oonio within the section. {1 ) Wliere it has once applied, and the loniimny luis proceeded to allotment, it will not (e.xcepl as reifards para, i .'! ) ; apply a second time should (he innipaiiy in;il;e ii soi'iiml (u- miI,^,.. qnent oiler of shares (8 i The .section prohibit.s allolnienl unless ihe inlniiiiui:i subscrip- tion hiu? been eub.scribed for. and the sum {)a\able on application for the sum fixed (which must iiot be less than ."> per cent, of the niiniiii:il iiniount of the shares i has been paid But subscribed '" here inoaus applied for — nol taken: and as loufr, therefore, as the a}iplicalionis arc sulU- cieiil. ihe diioctois lun make a.s small an allotmout as they choose, so far as this .section is concerned; but. having regard to seel. 87. the company cannot commence business until the miuiiiiuin subscription is dllollcd. and until tlie company is entitled to < ouimence Inisiness it is apprehended that the contract constituted by the application and allot- ment so made jnust be regarded as provisional onlv. .'^ee sub-sect. (3) of sect. 87. (9) The section leaves il to the partii-s lo ti.v the amount of the minimum subscription upon which the directors may pro- ceed to allolmeu:. They may by the articles fix a large or small amount; but il must be borne iu mind that the pro."ipcctus or statement in lieu of prjspoctus i.see sect. 81 (1) (di, infra) Ims to specify the minimum sub- .seription, and if au unduly small minimum subscription is fixed, it may discredit the pompany and deter possible MINIMUM SUUSt'ini'TlOX. II .-iib»ciil)('i>. ONpeiiallx il im-«<|im|km-- rail all«>iitiull to tin- fact and eoniiiiciit thereon iiuravdiiiatily . (10) An allotment iiiade b} tliicctors hol'oio the iiiininumi 8ub- stiiption is obtaiuud is voidablo. iiot void i^>oct. t'li), and may be avoided by the alloltco al any lime within one month after the statutory nieelini.'. hi the iMse ol a eompaiiy lu which tiie stutiiloiy inoeiiiiLr t^sect. (i.j i do<>s not apjiK tlicn^ is no limit of time on tho Hllottee'N li^'jit to repudiate S((c, l.hiilti'il v. ('iiiiitili-iii I'lmliici' t'urp . ( r.KJj) I L'h. .i", luoie fully releired to iiMilei- seel. Sij. Tile allottee only, and not tlie eomiiany, is enlitled to repudiate. UuiloH V. lieraii. (l;t()8) 2 Cii. 2K). Coii-iderinir that the ^e(■tion ul)tiolutely prohibits allolmenl. e\(e[)t under delined condition-, it niij,^ht well be held thai non-compliiiiice rendered the allotment void, e.\ce|)t in case.- comin^j within .sect. 80 {hifiu), where the company is one which must hold a .slalutory meetiiiir. that i- to -ay. a company regiittircd after Det"jml)er .'U.st. 1900. ( U I Thearticle.a may fix the ininiinum subsci ijnion " at a.-pecilied number of the .shares or a specillod prccporlion of the .-hare capital or ai a specilicd percenta;^'e or picii)oilion of llie shares oUered to the public fcjr suliseriplion. Wtsl York- siiire Darraai Aiiciici/. li.") T. L. U. 77. (12) The section applies nol only in the case of a ioiu[)aii,\ which issues a prospeclu> in England, but to the case of a c onn)any which issues a ])rospectus abroad. Jtousaell v. liuniham, tl'JO'Ji 1 eh. ll.'7. In that case the coni|)any had i.^in'd in France an abridfied prospoctu.s not statinj,'- the minimum subscription. The plaintilf, ii Frenchman resident in France, subscribed for some shares and received an allot- ment thereof, but tlie minimum subscription wa- nol sub- scribed within one month after allotment, lie sued tho company for the return of what iiu had paid, relying- on sects, t and •"> of the Companies A 't. 1000, corre.spondinc,' to sects. 8.". and «(! of the Ac- of IOCS. It was held that he was entitled to recover, and ilial. in his case, 'the pro- spectus" in .sub-BCcl. 4 i8.">) ,. i> the defective prospectus ou which he subscribed. W here the minimum subscription is fi.xed at a small amouut, the prospectus sometimes seeks to justify the Cxing of such a (ipure. or endeavours to anticipate adverse criticism, e.g., by some such stalo- ments as follow: — The minimum subscription is fixed by the articles of association 1 *t per cent, of the shares olleied, but the directors do not ]iro- ()o.so to allot unless what they consider to be a suUiciout subscription is obtained." .illUplc Ii I m 1 t; ■ t 11 Hf^ ■ ^ . ^ I \-> ortiT f. til. publi' . PKKLIMINAKV NOTE.". rCHAP. I. ■' ilaviiip rofrard ii> ilu' ■•iiiii^t'ii; iinivi.-ions of stn-t . S."! of llie » Companies (Coiifidlidiitinii i A(!l. lliKS, (lio iiiiiiiinujii siil)sii'i|iii^iiiption i-; rccjiiired, iiid will CNPici^o tlit'ir discretion aciordinnlv ." I.ookiiiy; III llio fart thai llio vPiidor^ aif uillini; lo Mili^niiie for • ii.iri's to sill li I'MiMil, iiiit I'Mi'oiliiin' till' rasli jmrtioii of ihi' )iiirilia.so- Mioiiov. a-i llic luinpany may inniiio. the iiiiTiiniuMi milisciiplion has iiooii lixod at loo shares, iliiis inakinir it icriain lliat tho i oinpany will proceed to allmimnit." Thairnc(j Ai)f)tci/. \V \. il'Ml.Si i'.;(;. Till' ^lalcitioiil iinisi do express I{oii^locteil ciisiomerM, have mil hitherto been reuardeil as bavinur been olVeiiHl lo the public. In -iicli cases il is lummun m amioiinie publicly that ' none of the -luires \ull be offered to the jiublic, the wimle iKivin;^' been taken iiji by llie vendors and their frieiiiLs and customers.' So, too, if a roiupany i'^ formed by tlie members of a club to provide I. house for the club, and the offer of shares is made er.clusively lO members of the club, it would not in common jiarlancc bo termed an lifer to itie )>iiblic. .\i>ain. an olfer by a comiiany of further shares to it.s own shiirehiilders, Imwever niinieiniis. is not leirarded as an offer 10 the pnlilic. but as a domeslic Iransaclinn . .An iiO'er by a jiromnter to a few of his friends, relations, and cus- loniers was held in a Scotch case iSlrifili v. (llosfioir mid Trnmtnwl Oplio>ii. V . 120. Ct. of Sess. I not lo bo an olfer lo the pulilic So where a syndicate had had a prospectus printed mniked "Striclly private and conlideiilial: not for jiublication.' and some if the directors sent copies of it lo their friends. Shrriri'U v Cniti- hiiKtl I iiriiiiii4-srfiit Moiitlff! Si/iiditnti'. '2'A T. L. K. 4S2 -Vii uil'oi', iO'i. upon the reciinshiiclioit of a cin!i|)any. "f rharo^ in the new company lo members of the old company in respect of their -hares in that company is not an olfer to the public. Rnnfh v \V(/' ,\i>irni>rl4'r fn.i lilO.'fi 1 ( h 20.V MINIMUM SUBSCRIPTION. (»ii llic (ulici liiiiiil, wlu'io a prospcciii^ iiimkiMl ■ I'ruale iiiid nm- liiltMilial " wu» lilfil Willi tlic ll».'j,'istiiii' of ('oiii|>;iiii('-. and not i'\- .t'tJiii^- -l.tJOd coiiit'^ wore issued liy the pioiiioler to sluiielioldci - ill leilaiii fius coiiiimiiies in whi, li he was iiileie-led. it \\;i^ held liv Eudv. I . lliul it was an oiler lo the |)iildii- Sontli of I'.iniliiihl y,iiiii7.!. The ollei, to t uiiie within the section, niiisl, il lias I i said. Ih au oiler hy the coniitaiiy not an oiler liy some iiidi\ idiials. Iml Ihi- i- not the ra.«p. for the section I'milie^ lo every jirospedns is^ui.,! li\ or on heliail' of a cumiiaiiy or by or on liehalf of «/(// pernitu trim ig or liu.s hfcii riiiitifii-d in the fori.ialion of the coiniiany, and sect. 8li |:riivide- for iiliiirs of a particular prol'e.ssion. or to the investors ji, a particular dass of compunios - or that Ihe jirospcctus stales iha' ,1 pieference in allotment will Iw j;iveii to a jiarlii ular -lasH or seclioi "f ihe public, does not make il the less an oiler lo the public. An.l 1! i~ apiiiehended lliat ihe nier<' fact thai an oiler is mafle bv ciiculai uddros.sed by name to a number of persons dcn.-^ noi ,if itself lake il onl of tlie calev'ory of oilers to the j)ublic 111 IhorDir.i v. Mdl'ibrlc (iohl Hn-fa. ( lilOl i i> ( h i>;!. 27 i overruled h.v inidrr V. Dcrfrr. ( I'.tOlii A. C. 474 i, Farwell. .!.. appears to liavc thoiiirht tha' the terms of .sub-.soet. (,4j of sect. Il) of the .Vci of I'jui providing- that the seiiimi 'shall iint apply lo a cin ulai or iiolir,. liivilinti- e\i-liii}r members or debenture holders of a coiiipam lo siib- -cribe for fiiiiher shares or debeiilures," niiiiht be trenled as a '•clue In what was meant by Ihc word public." not only in rhat. bul in olli.'r -eclioiLs. And some jiersons have as-niued thai ihe learned iud-e meant lo siin.„est that every oiler of shares, however pri\at. or dome-tic. i.s to Ik> refrarded as an oiler to the public, unless ij,,. "Ilei is made to ihe shareholders „r debenture holders onh: bir ii 1- more than doubtful whether his l,,,r(Miip iiieani ihu- lo iuii..||Hvi die word public" throughout the Acl. and in any case it is siib- uiitled that siidi an iufereuiial delinilion of Ihe word as i.>oa,d- -il.c. s<.c.inns o!,.-h! n..t m !«. ad^vpfed. ta; because ih,. dciiniii..,. (lause of the Act dn<'s nnt ihus deline the lerin ' oiler lo Ihe jubli( ■; and (hi because the words of sub-.sect. (4) of .sect. 10 i Act of I'.IOS. - SI laieeonliiied l,, lliut .-edioii ; and Ici because ilius to i-ousuue the u ' If- .fs.i'&r* i>'i3R "' ; ■ 14 PRKUMINARV NoTKS. (.'IIAP. I. {! ■- words would be to depart without .s\illi. -81. If a prospoftuN addref->od to the jjeiicial publir. or to a • public, is published, that no doulit coiistiliiies an olFer to the public, even though none of tlie jMiblir cuinc in. Tlii'io i^ no ohlifra- tion to allot to the public; all lliat i< rvipilMilo to brinp;' the case wilhin the ^Ol•lion is ihiit tlnTc shiill bo an ollor. but |)o>>ibh' if this oiler is maile without any iiiicniion to lot tho public take up any of tho pharos d g.. as where all tho shares were already taken lirni;, it miglii bo found a^ a lact That there was no real oiler to tiio public. See furlhor as to litis, ilic jioles to sect. S'.t of the Act ol \\MA. infra, p. 279. The prouiotors. befnrc u|i|il\iiij,; for the ii'ililiran^ to ( oiiiiiiou c liii>MH's> under .sdi. H7. iilini. p. l't>. have l<) dctciininc wlicthrr t mav be added: it. i tor .--uh- H''rij»ti'tn. Mnb«^ritK.<1. For subscription." The term, offered to the juiblic for sub- -' ription." evidently inc.ins an ollei of unpaid sbiires nhich is to be ■accepted by allotment, for the section i.s dealinir with and in uhicli tlie lojupaiiy. a! ilio roipu'-t of (he vendors or promoters, oilers for public -ale fnliv paid u)) shares to whicii thev have become entitled. So also wliere on a reioiL-triiclioii paid up or partly paid up shares ill tho now company are otlrred tu the sharelioldors in tho old com- |':iiiy. iliat \v(juld not appeal to be an olVer to the public 'for siib- -'■M|)lion." 11,11/1, \. \,-ir Africdiidi'i- f-olil Mhiilh] Cn.. llOn.'ii 1 Cli. 20."). Has been subscribed, &c. .Vs no allotment i> in be made uniil llie specified amoiml has l>"on subscribed, it luliou^ tlial ' ■.lib- scribed ■■ here means ap[iliei for, and ilo<'s not mean iipjilicd lor ami Hi ken lip. If. then, .">0,0()(t 1/. shares are li.\ed as tbc ininimuin subsciiplimi, and .'lU.OUil shares are applied lor and I.s. per sjiare i i.e.. •"> jjer cent, i lias been paid up on apjjlication. the company may pro(ecd to allot- ment of the whole or anv part of tlie shares applied for The section does not preclude allotment unless and until tho allotment comprises ihe mininmm subscription: it contains nothing to prevent the liroctors from g-ning to allotment on less than the minimum sub- MisiMi'M siiHsciariioN. \:> Miiplioii, it' onlv liu" iiiiiiiniiini Nubs thi\v iiiii-it liciir in mind. Toirard hciny ha to .ornnMMico hn^inoNs iin!il tlii< full ninonnt .f tliP niiiiinnmi suhscription ha> Ih-.mi iiUnttrd: and, what is nioro. lli.il the lonfracts for llio l.ikin.,' of il,,. Hharcs a.lnally alloltod will lip provisional onlv Spo si mi S7 i :!). The sum payable on application .... has been paid to and received by the company." Tho sum must he paid in cash. 11 I- iioi PMousrh that tho money has been sent by cIk-.iuo in the wnhrinry way, for the ehequos must be rleaonl before tho allot- Hirnl (an he properly made. Manx v. Wr^lrrn I'niiwl.t I'lilp and r.iprr Co.. ( IIH).-,) 2 Ch. 127 iC. A. i: Xufional Molo, Mail Coach ( ■>.. I I'.tim) 2 Ch 22H; Ihtrton v. lirvati.. i I'JOH) 2 ("h. 240. Exclusively of any amount payable otlitrwise than in cash." i;,ciuM»fiT I uii-ideiinf,' that by the word.s ut the eomnionconient of tho s,h tion its il.piuliou is limited to shares • olTored to tho publifi for subserip- ;i\ i- paid out: II' williiii foitv-i'ijrht (la\~ the luiniinuni .-iili-( liption i^ not oli- UiiMf. Tilt' iieiiiid ot loH\ - iMii.s I'loni the ' first i' . unit'*!' tho loutiavv ln' pio\f(i. Iln date of llic i,r(i.^ii<'<•(■ ItDtisurll v. Hiiiiiliam. (IW>'J • I < h. 1:27 Seo also .sfit. 80 r2). and the notes on that sciiioii. iiifiit. Thet-e pi-etautioiw arc lU'icssary i)e(au-i". lookint; to ■iuli--iMl. ^4i il is appiflitinded that the appliiation iiiomcv i« -poi ili.allv appro- priatfd lor ri'liirii in tiio t'\eul nionlioncd. and. until tlial fveiil does not lieconm llu- ab.soluli.' piopcrtv of tin' . onipany .\( i ()rdini;l\ MonfU'H \ CirMxi'i/sCu. (1 \-J\. t;'.'>' will nolapidx Kttc. t nf iriovulai ali'itriHiit. Any condition requiring,' &c. Thcso word- jiiol.alily n-fcr i. a londilioM in tlio pro-pocln-- or in ilio form of appliiiiliou, but tin \vord> would not ai)[iear to preclude a fresh contract by the applicant for, althon^xh tho words at llio coninuMiceinent of sect. 8.'> » ' no alloi- nieut sliall !«• nuidc "; are very einpliatic. il i-s clear from sect. 8tJ tlia' ihey do not make an allotment iu contravention illcfinl. for (^ect. 8t: e.xpressly piovides that such an allotment is only to be ' voidubh' ai the instance of the applicant within one month after the Btatutor\ iiieetiug." Suppose then that the minimum subscription is noi leached, the directors can send out a circular statins: tlio fad, ami proposing a uioditication of the sclieim which would render a iiiinli >maller subscription sulliiient. and ask applii,int,s to sijjjn a lie^li application for shares, and aureeiiii; to waive sub-sect. (1 1 of sect. 8."i and suli-.",ecl. i 1 i of seci . 8(i: or. iu the alternative, the director.s ini-ilr -end out a circular staling- the fads, and proposiuir a modification in their -ciiciue and the adoption, by special resolution, of a rednccl minimum subscription, and enclosing a fresh prospectus alK'rol accordingly, and then ask the parties to siyn and send iu frol applications with reference to that prosjiedus. Dillicnltie-. however. Iie'sel each of these course-, and they leiidci it very desirable that a company should make sure, as far as ii jHjssibly can. of obtjiiuiny: its niiuinmm suliscri|ition. The consc- i(uence- of disre<;ardiii>; the statutory reslriilions on ^i'oinp: to alloi- ment are stated in sect. 8(>. as follows: — Sect. 86.- (1.) All allutmeiit made by a oniiiiiaiiy to an a|ip!i>aiit in contra vcntioii (if the last forcuninir s'^ction shall he voidahle at the iiistanee of th< ;ili).li.;iiit. within one nicmth after the holdinif of the statutory ineetint' of tin i 1—-- MINIMUM siritsirKIITlON. 'I'"".*' :"iil ""' laliT. ui"! "Iiall Im *, M,i,l„l,l,. iii)t»ill,»tan.lint; 'li.'t ll"' '""i* l«iMy 11 ill I ■icir»c nf luiii^r wiiumi up ■ ■J. If liny (liri'itiir .if ii riiiii|.:iny knim iiuj-ly ii.ninp in-. ,,,■ (KTiniH or .iiitl,..n-,-, Ih.' ». ilamuKr.. .,r .0.1, will, I, tlir .oiupapv or tlio iillottw may lia>i- Mi^lniiiril or iiiiurri'il tl.ii-.l.y : I'ro.Ml,-,! that pio, .riliu-, to n.i.vn -11. Ii lo... ,|amaf.'r., „r >;,.u ,|,.,ll i,>,| I,-- ,. n,,.!,,-,,! afh-r Ih.' . \,,ir.,tini, of i»,. iiMl> flcriii (III' (late of till' allotllirhl Voidable at the instance of the applicant. Am alJMiiii.'iii jn V, .Hiili,U('iili..ii ,,|- >,.,!. H.-, i.- iiui \,.j v(;i,l iJioK- is 111, iniiira. I in ■•.iMoini-; 1ml in '!"• '•' ' " vuiilalilf Kiiil.ai I tiii'if is a niiiliai'l. ami allliuiioli ll ai MMiiiail i- lajiaMo «( lioiii" a\oi,l.'il. ii is valiil ami liiii.liii^ iiniil ill-Mliiallx a\(.iil(il. Sec (>,iLi:s \. Tilliiiluild t I.. H . 2 U. I.. .:.>;, illi . ill which l,nl,l Ciiollil^lolll. I. (■ . ,.ai,l: Tll.' rii.lillrlinl, 1 o- luooii M.iil ami Muilahlr mnlnicl^ i- one uliiili uill 1„. j I mm \ iicii-s.iiv ic. Ill' Im.mic ill inimi „|„.|i v.f ((iiiic to iiniMiliT llir U(,i,i- ■I till' Cuiiiiiaiii.'- An. IHi;:.'. ii|h,u «lii.|i lli.- .,ii.vsii,,ri .ll OaK,..'- li.il.ilil.v uill iillimatrlv i„,ii It i. a .si'lllci nili> nl Ian. a^ CnMiii,- i-i:. .1.. -aid in ( h,ikc V. /»;,/,.„.,/ , !•:. H. A Iv I 18 . i|,al a ci.itia,! inilii,..,! l,v I'laii.l i> iii.i xui.j. lait vni.lalil." .nilv al ihr i,|iii,iii nf ih,. j.niv ,l..fiau(l.'(l.- If ii »,.,|. ollioiui-.., ir a idiilia.-l jii.liir,..! In liaiid ».M.' void, thfic would Ik' an I'lid ol' the (|iii.-(ioii in il.is .a-.', i"|.iM-r a (ontia.t void in iusi-lr ran have no vali.l Ii.'oinnm-. .mil ":iKi- i.i'M'i would have bri'onic a .Hlniichiild.T of tlio (oin|un,v.- lliMHo if an ajiiiliianl I'nlill.'d lo avoid on llw o-,-,,Mnd tlia! 111.' alioi- iMciii ua- mad.' in coiitiavcnlini, of ,o,.|. H.", d,,,- no' in lad avoid iiio ■ "filial t williin one nionlli alici- ilif lioldinn- of the -taliiloi x ninciiiiM. Ill' l'-i'> his ii.,r|,( „, ||,.,|„, i, ^,,j I „^, ii^^^i ,^,,„„„/. .j,„| r,,',.,|,,,,. i, ■[, ^i||ii"li(iid.'d thai il l„.|..i,. thr .•'v|iiialion of thr nionlh la- .loots "i.'"l'ii^<"^ill.\ lo alhini thr . oniiari. 1... will 1,,. ,.sto,,pod fiom si.l.s,.- ■|"'""l> avnidin- ii on mi, I, ^!,,i,n,l. |,„ thai is <. l.v ,,avino- .alls 01 in,|aliiKM,N "I- M'ecumg- ,livi,l..nd- 'S.lu,lr;i v. < ,'ii1n,l Had. Co.. 'J K,,. 2<;ti, A,,/ v. Frr.hnhl Im,i,I < ,,.. I K,,. ,-,SS; ami Sl„w„i,nry rirw. T.'. '. I ■■:«••. I. or Iiyalt.Midin- and M,lin-at a <:cncral nii'.'iiiiL; in jm.!,,,], "1 l'\ prow i.shariiU'i/ v. I.n,ith. ,i,-. ( .^C. I), lif,:'. , . i,,- may lost- ■''- Muas III av.,i,i li,.- ollolni.'ni ,>,.,•. fiirilior. hnrn. |i. I<,i;. It IS inn iieccssaiy tha' ih,' ai)pli,anl clciinu lo avoid the , .niiraii iiNd.T SCI. 81: sln>ul.l take a, lual ioo-al ,)r.i,-,.odiii^rs lo avoid the ,.m- "•I" within the month. \oii,o ,,f avoidaiifO followed by i)romi.i iM.'iM. -*■' • ;jl !i' 'ig IS PRKMMINAKV NOTES. [ClIAP. I. loj{ul |iiii<<'i'«liM!.", lliiiiiuli allJ'i' the luiiiilli. i.>- "iilliiii'iil Hi- .\iiliiiiiiil Motor Miiil < iHuh r„ . i HioNi •> fli 22« It i- oulv llic u|Hiliiiiiil wild if* (Mitillcil to iivoiil the luiiliiicl. Tlu' ruiii|iiiriy rumiril iii«i.st mi ]lilvill^' bii'k iho iippliiiitinii mniicvs. lur llu< u|iiili(aiil iiiuv piclfi- to ki'f|> tlif .sliiiroM. Hiirlim v. Ilrvuii. 1 liMlSi 2 eh. 2»tl Hut ill ^'Uih a tlio linl rlial tin- iipjilic ant kccp.s tin- .-ihari-H uill not (lisciililli' liiiii to his ri'iiicd.v a};aiii.«t tlir (liioctois wlio liavf kiiowiiii;l> i initiiivoiiod " lln' wctioii. the liijlit to roiiipcl them to make '^iHxi the los^ (M'i'a>*ioiii'il to liini li\ ihi' irn';julaf iilloiiut'iit Ibid. M^itutolJ ■ The statutory meetinq. " ''I'f a- to ilii*. ^•■ii t>"i of Act of I'.his. hifni, Appi'iulix. This iiit'ctiii;; is tu Iw hi'lil within .1 jn^riod ol not Icsi ihaii 'y sect, il.'i lo hold ihe slaliilorv iiieetiiiy thus icferied to is a eonipaiiv " liiiiiled liv -h.iii'>,' and theiel'ore seel. Mil 1 1 1. eiviiiy: a ri;4;lit to repudiate an iirei^iilai allotiiieiil within one iiionth alli'r the date of the siuliiiory iiiectiii^. would a)i|iear lo l«' iiiap))liral)le in other lases, r 7.. yiiaiiintee eoinpunit's, or iinliiiiiled coinpanie.s liaviiiir. in ''itlier 1 a^e a -hare capital. Moroovcr, sect. ti."). under which the nUitulory niei'iln^- is lo he hi'ld. only apjilies to coinpaiiie.s ro}.'ist»Meii after .Ian. I. 101)1 It is olivioiis therefore that seit. HIi (Ii does jujt apply I'l coiiipanies which were reijisterod iK'fore .Ian. 1, I'.tOl. liiit it was held under the correspinidiny; ^t■l Hon of the .\ct of lltOll that whore such a company tor the lii>f time went to the public after .'Ust Deieniher, UtOtl, and allottod whan's in \iolatioii of that seetiori, an allottee wiu< entitled to repudiate the allotment allhoutrh sect. ■") of llio Act of 191)0. currespondiiifj: to sect. H(> of llio Consoli- i 1 Cli ;17. " And shall be so voidable notwithstanding that the company is in coarse of being wound up." Thi.s is a new and uoleworihy provision for tlie iirotoi tion of the allolt<'e, for apart irinn this pro- vision it would no doulit lia\e lieen held that (he piiiii iple of Oake.f V. Tiiiijimiul iL. R. 2 H. L. .'!2.">) was a;iplicab!(!, namely, that a voidable contract of membership cannc! ii avoided after the oomniencenieiit of a windinlicaiit slioiilil notify to the company that he itvoids the eoiitrau! ami demand^ icpaymciit of lii.s inonev and the lemoval of Winding-up. i .M "1 MINIMUM sUBS(;KII'lioN. !!• (u- ii.iiiic li'iMi liir n'«^i.-.|('i- ol iiioiuIm'I"' ir (lie > .ijn|,jMV i;uiii|)lii's «iili llii- M'i|iH-i lie uill lx> II Wriiihl'M ms,-. 7 ( li ."i.">; llrrsr /,',(./ In \. >iii,lli, L. R. I II I, lit illiil 7li; lull ir tli4' ii.iii|)!iiix iil'ii-r- l.. M>.-i'iil III till- uvi)iiliiiin' till' allniifc ■.jiuiilil, li\ ^11 limi III l.\ Mlilliiill 111 -IIMIIlMlllS IIIKJIM -.(N I . :ll> III lIlC Al I. |II1M('ImI In l'|||'ii|ii' lii^ ri'|iiKliiiti<>ii ll 1- 111. I IH'rt'.^s.il \ , llDUfVcl. timl llll' .lllilltl'l' >lllll||i| l.iU,. ai Illiil lcj.'.il |'i'» Iin«> ll! :>M.i(| lilt' iiiiiii'iiii uitliiii till' iiiiiiitli N.iii..' if n.ll.l.llh !■ IiiIIdWImI I)^ Jll<)lll|lt U>!.ri|l |)|IM' lillU'., ll nil ,,|||.|- (.\|iiriiliMii III til., iiioiilli. i- -ii||iii,.|||. I{, .\,il,i,iliil Mull,) M.iil (,„„// t „ . MiiiM. -2 I'll. :iJH. S.M. lurlli.'i. ;„l,„. CliMi. W Tl,.. |ir lin:;- -IikiiIiI In- liikni in ihr ( .mil liminy; jiii i^ili. limi i,i reclilv ill.. ii.u^i«li.|-. Ill- vvlicrc llioic i« a « iii.liiin-ii|i, in ilic Ciiini haviii;.' jiiii-dirliiiii lo wind ii|i t|ii. iiiiiipaiiv. Wlii'ii J » iiiiliim-ii|i hii- riimiii('iiM..I, till, niiiii ). i.|iiiiili| Iii. iiililit'^-i..j ll" 1» •" '111- iiiiii|i:iiiv. lull ii\-> III llic lii|iiiihi< r. 'I'li,. |',,||,| ,,|- in'iir.'.jiiiu uill i||.|M.iiil nil «|i(.||ici' |||(. M|i|ilii mil Ini- .n- li,i, imi liocii phi.i'.l ..It till" ii^i ..r . .iiiiiiliiiiiiiii.-. s<.|. I'liii 11 . ;i:i,| .„/,„, Cluiplcr W. Knowingly contravenes, " &c. Knii«iiiyl\ ' . nniiuvoninfr llio Ku.minirly. H'lii.iii i.i..;iii> r.iiiiiiiu'iiiii;.' ii wiili kii.i«l(.il^i. ,,( rlii. f.i.N iipim niii.li till' ...iiliiu<.iiliiiii i|i.|M.|i.U. It is iin itiiI h|ii.|1,|.i- iI,,. iliii'il.ii' li.iil kiiiiulc..ioi. i,( i|ii. law .11 ii.il. Ihiihii, \ IUr a lii.aw lmi(l..ii i.i .msI .,ii (|„. iliioihii-^, l.n- llio miiiil,|.r of t' •»• all..ile(.< . laiiiiiiii;- .•ip|iiii(.|i>alion iiiuy lie us inaiiy a- iIh'iv an- appli- laiils foi sliaivM. Till' iiiiifrnitiiilo of this risk ('iii|iliii>i/.'s iho iu.f..ssitv lur iiiakin;;- llu« niiniiiiiiin siiliMiiplioii small. ..i- ali-.iiiitclv i-nsiiriiij,' 'll'' -111.-, liption llu'ivof. uiiil in oIiIkt lust' UikiiiK- s.mi|.iiIoiis rare to ii.uiply ill all icsp«'i|.s with llic pioviwions of .sp.t. «.'.. A- t.) 111., .oiiipiiny.s •■ loss, damufros and costs." iIh-m; wonl.l appoai til in.iii.l,. all pxpon^.'.s in.iin.'.l by reason of lli.' alLitiucnl Jiavinu- Wii ma.!.- Ill .■onnavcntion; Imt it is appioli.-ii.li.il iliat lli.. u..r.ls 'i') not in.luil.. iliiiiui.^>-o o.-. a-ioued liy roii-soii of tlio |. ,if moiiibur- -lup, for llio contiaveiitioii would bt) tli<> ,illotii..i.t, and it can -can. U 1,,' li.'M iliai |1„. .•ompany is cn'i anl to .l.iiua.-os fur Ilio "f *i - •>o PRKLIMINAKY NOTKS. [ClIAP. I. avoidaiRO liv the allotH'c >2. could, bv virtue of s<'il. IS liieicof. conuneiKe business m dialely after its incorporation callable forthwith of exercising; company." and this power of titartin: lor bv thai .section it m ill I functions of an mcoipoia s business at once is lade tod 'ded t p a private coiiijiany a id i< a CO mi)a nv ri"- the 1st of .lanuarv. I'.HIl. impany icfiisieret 1 befc ill con- ciimI before e 1st dav of July. I'KIK. uiiich doe- not issue a prospectus inviting' the public to .-ub.scribe for it- share- See sub-sect. f. of seil. 87, re- placinij- sub-.sects itli and 7i of sec set forth. Rut as regards evei\ conipiin\ bavin;; a ca| ■I ti of the Act ( it I'.tOO below )ital divided into shares formeaiiie' e>tiicte "/" diriM'tiir till id |iany has pan p. 9 I : 1 hIii < t iki'ii iir contra to pay ill la 1 til the iciiiipaiiy III! I'l'h iif the tod tci lie taken hy liini. and fur whieli lie i.s llalilc di. a propiirtion ecpial to the proportion payalile on appli- aiid uIJMtiiieiit nil the KJiare^ olfered for pulilie ^iliserlptinn ; or axe of a cunipaiiy whieli doei not issue a prosppetiis invitini; the public to sub-crilie for 't^ shares on thp shares payabU and (el thorr ha* been (ibil with the roaristrar of eorapanios a statutory dcclara- (XLMMENCKMKNT OF HL'SINKSS. 21 tiiin liy tlie sivntary or imc nf tlio liircitois. in tlic prosi'iibi'd form, that the aforesaid ('rosj)eetMs. r2. The reffistrar of eonii)anies sliall. on the filiny c>f this statutory deehira- tldii. eiTtify that thi> ronipany is entitli'd to <'oininencc Imsiness, and that eerti- ficate sliall I inclusive evidence that tlie company is so entitled. I'ruvided that in the case of a lonipany which (hies not issue a prospectus inviting' the puhlii' to sniiserilie for its sliarcs, the rciristrar shall not jfive such a certificate unless a statement in lieu of jirospcctus has hcen tiled with liini. (;i.. Any contract made l)y a company hcfore the date at which it is entillcd to ccnnnr'nce hnsincss shall he provisional only, and shall not lie liindinsr on the conip;iiiy until that date, and on that date it shall lii'come liindinfr. (4. Nothinir in this section shall prevent the simultaneous offer for siih- scription of any shares and dehentnns or the rci-cipt of any miinc>y payalih' on application for dehcntures. (.'i.i Jf any i-ompany eoniiuences husiness or exercises liorrowini; powers in contravention of this section, every person who is rc'spiin-ililc f,ir the mritra- vcntlcMi shall, without prejudice to any other lialiility. he lialde to a tine not exceedinsr fifty jiounds for every day durin:; which the contravention continues. (I>.) Xothinir i'l Hiis seition shall apply to a private ccnipany or to a conipanv registered liid'ore the first day of .lanuary iiiniteen hundred and one or to it company rc(;istere»c jiiiiv i.siuiis is c)bviim>ly tn sociiro a icituiii JeirK'O ul' siib.sta nihility in a ((iiiipaiiy liolciic il ciitor?! inlo oii^iii'.'c- uipiils with oiit.siclois or ulnaiiis iiicmcy bv boiiciwiiio-. Till' Icillo-.viiio; iicitcs iloni willi tlic al.nvc .sociicin in ilotail: - ■^t Commence any business. ' Tlicsc word- aic vfi> wide. Iml thuv (■oinmence. uvidciillv do not iiuliido ihc is.-^iic of pro -'it'it uses or tlie making of provi-ional tontiac t<, or tlie alloHiient of .sliaios, nr the oiiiploymont of experts, or fhe takino- of cither preliiniiiary stops. See snb- seel. ill uii uud sub-sect. (4 . I niess a eoinpauy eouid take thes<' preliiiiiiiarv steps it could never (lualify to coiiinience business at all. Biisine.ss." lociking at the I'x ideiit piiriiiise cd the section, must be construed aecordino-lv. Exercise any borrowing powers. " Uorrowing- mi^'hi sceiu to l'...rrowinir. lie cc,v(.ied by tiie words commence any business,' but the presence of the addiiiiinal word.s uinpliasizes the intention that borrowiiiff iis not to be allowed. Xothiiio: i said about ruisinjj money on peipelual ciebeiitiire stock. Whether that is or is not bcirrowino-, it would seem lc» lail within the word.s " loinmeiKC business." I iicjer sect. H,") there can be no allolment unless the minimuni sub- sciiplmii iias been applied lor, and under sect. 87 ( I i, clause (a), the eonipany is paraly.sod unless the minimum subscri|)iion, at le^st, is ^Hulled; that is to say, until then it cannot commence business. 22 PREI.IMINAKY NOTK.S. rCHAP. I. Hh'l li DirtHtuiv' imyment*. Statutory ill claratic'ii. All iillotiuoiit of not loss tlian tho miuiimiin hiibsciipli'in is a lirench of sect. 85, but the conipany cauiiot repudiate the allotnieiil ami insist on imviny l)atk the inuiiev. liwfo)i v. lirruv. i I'.tOSi 2 Ch. 240. Every director of the company has paid." Diiectors are not lo lavoui liieiaselve-i or any one of their number in tiii.s matter of [layment. This seems tiie moral of tlie condition, tonf. Alexander V. Aiiloiiuitic Tdephmic Co.. !l',KtOi 2 Ch. 56. The words, it may be uoleil, put it in tlie power of any director to pi-echide the company from coinmencinfr business by nbstainiiifjr from payin!X up tlie allot- ment money on his shares. In view of this risk it would be well to provide in the articles that a di . .ior shall )>w facto vacate office if he does not. within a siiociti' li periixl. pay up in accordance with sub-sect. (1) ih) on «'very share, whether forming part of his i|ualificalion or not. which is taken by biiu A statutory declaration." It is to lie noted ilmi. althonah tho liliiif,' of the (leclaralioii is made a condition precedent to coinmeiaing liu.siness or boirowiii(l to rotnmence businesw. Re Otto Electric Manufacturing Cii.. .Ifukin'a cane, (1900) 2 CJi. \VM. Tiien? w, tlicrofore, no need In iii^ipit uii cxpre.M.s condition to that offoct in each oontraot, for ilic statut*' implies it. r lie condition in tlw contraot in Homo cuwos Nevertheless, it niay be conveuieut to set out And on that date shall become binding." These words on the tact' of them would make every such provisional contract on that (liilc hccdiuo liindinp:, and thus confirm by statute every Ruoh pro- visidiiul eoiitraet. whatever its merits; but probably the words mereh n|i(MNle to teiiiiiiiale tlie jjrovisional statu.s of ilio wiitract and to make it ;il)sulutc, but only for whot it is worth, so that any rijfht to repudiate III rescind e.fi.. for misrepresentation — will remain undisturbed. Nothing in this section shall,' Ac. Under this sub-sect- ii shwe^or ;i iHiiipauy is left at liberty to issue a prospectus ollorin of it from acting in contra- "^''o" voriiion of the section, but it .se<>ms not unlikely that the section will 1 v<'rlooked in f .1 many oaseis. Every pei , lO is responsible for the contravention." LiabiHtr Those vvords a, 'i ,) include the directors, niaita:to.'k. the sociiou dues nor ipply. So, too, if the company is a mere reconstruction, and onlv iiotities the shareholders in the old company, tlirough the liquidator. 'it their right to subserilK", the section would notapplv. «ppiy- lu:=p f i 24 InsufScieut tiibscriptioa. Older law. Pter.i ftf.tt. PRELIMINARY NOTES. [(JlIAP. I. Once tlip coiiiiwinv Iium l('<>:iliinat<'ly coiiimi'iii'tMl Imsiiirss witliout brciiili of tlio Mectidii. il is cxi'iniit for the future from tlie i)r(ivisioiis of tlio st'i'tion. Thii '. if a coinpany iiiakos iirniii<^"iuout.s (o purcliiisc a f)U.siiir>.s and \-(riljO for sharps, it (an roinniciKt' business \vitiir)Ut <'oin|)lyin;;- witii tlu! conditions of the seciicui, and then hiler on jt can offer shares or debent'.ires or debenture stock for |inbiic sulisc-iption. Insufficient Subscription. Vv hci'<' tiie niininiuiii .sidisci iption is not furtliconiitiaking with i-eference to Ihi.s provision, Lord Cairns said in reeVs case (18(i7), 2 C'h. (i74: "When iii<(iiin'tl into as to lh« rojrulaii(y of the prior [irocoeilings." \rid shortly afterwards, Ijord (hcliiisfonl, Fi. ('., in Oakes v. Tni'iiiniid. li. tt- -' H. li. ;!2.'!. said: I think fhat the lortiticate |.irMMil.s all rci nrronio to priir inalti'rs c-snitial lo rcirislraiion. aiiniiiL'st whiili is tin- -nlisi i i| ion of a rnoinoranduni of as-oi-iation l>v -I'viT ji(>r>on>i. and that it is lonijnsivo that all provions ro(|uisition8 have Ix'Oii i'oinpli<'d with. " SiiloiiKiu V. Sfiloiiioii lit aMi<> ollcet. *''«"«"' »• Tlio Conrt of Appoal there, whilst holdinf;- that the ilefendant com- " """^ '' paiiy had been formed 'for an illeijfiliinate |Mirpose," and "for • iliiccis not authorized hy the Act,' n<'\eriheless held the eertilirate .if iiiiiiriioralion conilnsive that it was incorporated, although sect. 6 rci|iiires that the snlisi^rihei - should lx> persons associated tofrother |iii- rjiiirali(ni. i l«!)l i 2 ( h. ."iD.j, a learned .jiii\ and of course these mere ilhtii could in no wav derogate li'UM the amhiirily of the decision in that case. With leference 111 liiive dicta, Vauglian Williams. .),, in Luxdh d' Co. i2), i lHi»2) ■■; ( h. .■).■;.'). said that he did not uinbrstand how they con, i be recon- ciled ttilli llie decision and wdiils of the judt;iueiil of Lord Cairns ill I'lil'x ruse. III)) siiinii. .\nd it is t(j be noted that the Court of .Vppeal in SiiIohidh v. Sulitinon <('• Co., as apjieai-s above, followed. I'ri'l'.s nisr. .\nd in f.iiilics' Dn'sn AnsnciiiliDH v. Piilhrooli, ^^19()0) 2 (,>. I{ .'STti, ;J81, a decision on the word "conelusivo" in another section of the Act of ISi'iT. where tlu-se ilicln were relied on. Romer, L. -I . whilst holdiiigtlH'Ui not applicable. signilic;iully added that "u it were not so it might be lu'cessary for us t > coii-iider whether those ilirtd cdiild be jnstiliect. 1 Conclucive- ■ if 111- fompanies Act. Ut(M) ! e\pr(>ss!y pv.ivid"- thr,i ) -wtilirate of '.'^^cate iiiiiirp(uatiiui given by the Registrar of C()ni]ianies in rcpect id' any a.-isocialion shall be conclusive evidence that all the iV(|uisition» ':if this .\c(, in ies|)ect of registration and of matters precedent and li' , 1 ii;-i4 26 PKI'XIMINAHV NOTKa. [Chap. I. int'idoiiful thereto, have b(M>n ((niipliod with, and that the a«.soeiatioa in a ciiiupany authorized to be ropistered and duly rejiistercd under this An. The iuwrporation of a company in to take ellect from the date of incKirporation mentioned iu the certificate of incorporation. 8w> Meet. l(i of the Act. li4>ol H. L. I7(i. The (|ue tion there arose as to the regularity of the constitution of a con';,auy— "The General Company for the Promotion of l^nd Credit. Liuid. All the subscribers to the memorundiim of tiiis company were foreigners, and there was no intention to carry on bu8ines,s in England. Neither of the.se circumstances atlected it.-, validity, but the articles of association containeti provisions i-uitrary to the Com- panies .\ct, and Lord Hatherley. L. ('., said: .A.1I we have to ask ourselves is this . . . Has this company come into existence? Has it bwn born';- . . . The tjuestion is therefore simply whotJier it has been created. If create of. by which, through any rosidt of a formal ap|)licafion. like an application for scire facias to i-ei)eal a charter, the comjiany can be got rid of, iinles,- by winding uj) ; and the observations of Lords Cairns and ( olonsay wen- to the same ellect . S<>e. also, w hat was said by Fry. .1.. in Glofer v. Gilo's • 1881 i. 18 Ch. 1). 18(1. The same principle apjilies to a company uwler the .\ct of 1908. The Registrar of Companies has now. however, jurisdiction under sect. 242 of the Companies Act. 1908 i re])lacing sect. 7 of the Com- panies Act, 1880. and sect. 2 N'nturc of •2i»t under the Act— whether as an unlimited compauv or a» a "'""Tora«»''' ' • ('"Mipimv. I .>mpanv limited by shares or by puarantee— becomes, by virtue of »ect. Ki (U) of that Act, upon the issue of the certificate of incorpora- tion, 'a boily corporate by the name contained i> 'he memorandum n( association, capable forthwith of exercising all uie functions of an iiiiorporatcd company, and huvipe: jwrpetual succession and a iiiinmon seal, with power to hohl lands." The body corporate thus created is a '' lejjal cntit}-." It is not, like DiHtinction ,1 [lartiiersiiip or a family, a mere collection or a<,'i>:reo;ation of indi- ^"i'l!^" and vidiial units: it is a distinct entity, existiufr in contemplation of law its immb«rH. but imvin 2 Ch. .'123). reversed by the House of Lords in Salomon v. Salomon d Co., (1897 i A. C. 22, and further wnsidered infra. Chap. X. If the corporation is entitled to property, the title is in the bodv corporate, not. as in the case of a partnership, in the members loUectively. "An incorporated company's assets are its proportv.. and not the property of the shareholders for the time being." J'er Lindley. L. .1.. George Newnuni rf- Co.. (1895) 1 Ch. 08.). ' In the I'ase of a corporation it is the whole body— the abstraction ai law— ihat is seised. The tnesDhera Rre no mare sei-ed than the niumliers if a man's body could be said to be seised of his estate." Per Maule, .!.. Baxter v. Broune. 7 M. & G. 210. "The individual -liareholdeis ai-e rpiite distinct from the corporation; they are vn- i ll 28 I'UKLIHINAKY NOTKS. rcHAP. I. tilled to iiu iliri'it iutt>i<"*l in tlio laud iif tlif rorpoiutimi,; no p-;rl of tho realty is hold in tiii>t for them." P(>r Fai-kt', It., W'alson v. SpriitU'!/. 1'4 L. .J. K\. j.'t. Tliev havo individiiiilly no -ciiin, legal or (•((iiilul)lc. Ailaiiil v. Li'iri". :\lt ],. .). ('. 1'. IJ'.t. The intcti'st of tho sliari'lmldiM' in tho ((iniiiany uliilc il coMtiniics a ^^oIuh: loncoiii ■ i-^ not an intorost in tlit" real or (icrsonal ])roi)t'rty of the company, inclnding its hiisinesss or jf(M)dwill; Imt il in merely a ri^'lit lo have a share of the j)iolilM of tlio eompany when realized and divided imonsrst its memhers. " I'ei Bnvilj. V. .).. Hani,- af lliiiiliistan v. Alison, \.. R. (i ('. IV 7.1. The individnal niendpers of the corpo- ration no donbt are interested, in one sense, in the juoperly of the <'<)rj)oration, a,s they may doriv* iinlividnal henofit from its incroaiH' or loss from its deslruilion, but in no leu:al sense are the individual niemlxM's the owners. ' Per Deuman. ('. .1.. /i'<-f/. v. Arnaud, 9 (^. 15. 8lHi; It) L. J Q. li. .")•">. Hence u leuisteied comjiany may hold land, although all the mendxM-s are aliens mid dis<}nalitiod from doinff so. Even in tho case of a so-called "one man companv," where the great bulk of the shares in the company are held by one person, the company is a dislinil ])orson. "The company." said Lord Mac- naghlen (Hiilomoii v. Salomon it (v.. ( 1Mht he may havo acquired, lie must sue the company, and not any of the members of whom it is composed. Per Lord C rannorth, OnkeH v. Tur- quand. L. R. 2 H. L. .t--); ' The creditor has no debtor but that impalpable tliiiii;, the corporation.'' Per Jessel. M. R., Flilcroit'x ra.se. 21 C U. .j.'t;t. Evon if the com- pany incurs liabililies in a foreifrii itiiiiiirv. !iv iho !aw« ot which the shareholders I{ATK POWKKS AM> DIHIKS. 2» -hiiri'lioliU'i^ and llii' (■oinpuiiy iiroiit or tiumw uad iK^ncliciuiv. Sulnnioii \. Siihmim i( ( It., .suiini : Ffitiuxoii \. Wihoii. 2 ( li 77. «!• I 2) A- a conciul iiilv. the moiiibcis of tlu- cornpany propci plaintill. and tlic oidy prupui plainlill. ■ IVc danu's. I, J., ariii/ v. I.nris. 8 ( li Kl.Vt: .\fi>:lri/ \. .\l.^l„„. 1 I'll. 7'.M»; Miinlimnoll \. Cnrilhirr. 1 ('. Div. I.I; lliissrll \. Wohclirlil W'litrnntrl.s ( d. ^i) Dij 47t: niiiliiii,! \. /•;((/•/(•. iHIOL'i A. C. 8.1; .\oniunihi/ v. liiil.Cixiiic d' to.. I \ I Cli. 84. (.ii .V nifmk'i- of tlif company ciiii (Mnitiad with and boioinc a ncdilor of llio conipany. and can sue the company and lew ivNcciition on its pioiK'ilv jnst as if he «orp a stran^rcr. ' A iiKMnlK'i- of a corporation is for this pnrposo suiiip on a contract a- dislinct from a ((nporato body as ,iiiv third |)cis,,i,.- i'cr I'arkc. 15.. IhiiLsh,,! v. Imiwriul (Inslhihl < .'). ,\inl in tin: i-vcnt of \viiidint.'-ii|i. a iiicml«M. niw crodilor. can. in rc~|i"ci of vtirh niattd , jiiovc and lako dividunds in coniiii'iilion with out-jijc ciodilurs. (hi^seir^ case. 1 t'h. r,'2H. .\ „alo by a jicrsun to a cor- poration of which ho is a jucndxM is iu.t. uilln>r in form or in snbstamc. a sale by a jioisun to himsvlf. To Imlil ihat it is woiihl be to if,aiori' tho piimipl.. wliidi Jios at the lool ol the loyal idea of a corpora'o body, and thai iilca is that tin- corporato body is disiinit from tho persons cum- pn.in- il." l'(-r Liridlcy. I.. .1.. /■•„n;ir v. luirniis. I.ii,i!tr,l. I^M . Div .-IK.-,. 4(i!i. And this is M> ovon wlirro the vendor- are the only members of the corporation; in such (use tlicx ate not scdlin;^- lo themselves, but to a third parly, nameh . the corporalion. Per l.in.lley. L .1.. Fo.sV.r v." /Jommi'.^ of I li.. 08!t| I {). 1!. ,-,li;. .-.L'K. .See also ll,ih„,„: ,('r ( n. V. Foijri. 7 (l 1!. I). 18.-); and .\„,lh-\\,..' PKKUMI.NAUY NOTKS. [Chap. I. Kiiiii:tiuiiii I if I'limpany iindrr ('c)ui- )Hiniefi ActK. l>i>tiiictioii a^ (ii fuiictiutis company and ■■% i.-itnimon law i)r 4liBrtprf>>l I'onipany. ItllW I,.. I. timtion. coiuj)uu_\ Uixi iiu poHor to clo. A»libuiy. dv,'. to. v. Richc, L. H. 7 H. L. «.).{; FliliroflH <■««■, ai C. Div. 519; .IWi- fci/r// V. WiitKuii, ."10 C. D. ;J7t>; Faure Electric Co., »t) Cli. 1). I JI; Hiiti"h. dr. \ . Cuiitia. i 1«'J4 I A. U. at p. lO:,, Wvltuii V. Sujjfrii, I IH'.tTi A. ( . :J*J'.», .121. A.lll ill Sllrll a (tfO U jtlll^lllOIlt h\ I'cJII.M'Ut ^ivC* III! ji:rt'ului- vuliilitv. < I real }it)rtli-\\ est ( ciitriil Ilailway \ Chill U-boiK. I8'.t'j. A. ('. 111. Allluiiiuli seit. Hi 2 .(f till' Alt 111 I'.MiS . if|iliuiiidly limit ami ii'stiiit the fiiiicliiiiis of the rompauv to rari'vin^ out the ohjoil- ~|;oiilleil ill its mi'iiioianiliiiu of jissociation. and to the iioiii<; of iho-i' ihiii^s niiich iire incidental thoieto. Ill this le-peit the loiiipaiiy dilVeis esseutiallv from a I'omnion lau '■■iijioiation conslitiited liy loyal chartor. The company is a .slalu- loiy corporation with limited ca]>acilies. and accordingly stands "ii the saiue footing as railway and other corporations constituted hv special Acts of Parliament. .\s Lord Selliorne said, in Axhlntrii. ifc. Co. V. liirhf, L. R. 7 H. I., till-'!: " A statutory iiir|ioratlon, croateil liy Act of Parliament for a particular inirjioso. is limited, .is to all its powers, hy the piirpii.ies of its incorporation as deliiied in that Act. The present and all other comjianies incorporated by virtue of the Companies .\ct of 18(i2. apiK-ar to me to he .statutory corporations within this p ciple. The iiicmoiaiidum of assoiia- tion is under the Act then fundamental, and (except in certain specified partiiiilars 1 their unaltorable, law; and tlicif are iniorpo- niteil oiili/ for the ohjrit.s mid piirpoxf-i i:rprc.i.'>rd in that nicmo- nnidttm." The distinction iielween (oiiimoii Itiir lorporatioii.s tmd t-Uitutorii lorporation.s was deliinvl by Howcii, L. .1., in liarone^n Weiilock v. I{iver Ih'v Cuiiipiiiii). ."ifi ('. 1). p. G8."i, n., as follows: — " .\t ciiiuinnii law a ciirpiiratiim created by thr Kin); 8 cliartcr Ima, primti jaiie, and lia.s lippn known tii have ever since Snlhm'n llniipilnl rnup (10 Hep. 13), til.' piiwer ti) di) with its property all sueli nets as an ordinary person can do. and to bind itself to such rontraet^ as an ordinary person can bind liiuiself to; and even if iiy tlie cliarter creatiiiir the i'or|ioratioii the Kinir imposes some direc- tion wliiih would have the effect of limitinif the natural capacity of the IiihIv of which he is speaking, the eonimon l.iw has always held that the direction of the King mifjiit in- enforced tiirniiiih the .Vttiirney-lieiieral ; but althiiu;rli it mifjht contain an essential part of the so-called bai'ttain between the Crown and the corporation, that did not at law destroy the lejfal power of the body which the Kini? ha.l ereatinl. When you come to corporations created by statute, the n»im)KATK PCIWKK8 A.\l» IJIMIKS. M I H l|llltl' .|umi"Pi «.™i» to III.' ciitiri'ly siiy that ymi must tiik.- tlii> ^tiiliiii- .in if it had i r.'ut.-d it ™miiiiiii law, uiiil tl|M|| HI'.. Mli.'tlicr if tiM.k away any .>r tin' in'iil inr|Hirali.>ii ut ..Miini.wi law. luiaiKi' that li."f'< || -iifi a .'.ir|>.iratnni 'III- lu'i;i till' i|iii".'« niithini; nf tin' "int. may lint li.> iiwaiit tn |i.i ».'> u lurpiiratinii at lomiiM'ii la whiih it t" tr.-'K'l mil"! a.'.-.iiiiii' that it Ini w.nil.l hav.' at .'nmiiinii law uiili'»'< tlin itatiif.' tak.'-i it H„t ivliat til it'hat th in a wnui).' liiip nf tliniiifht. What vnu In • ■rylliiiiL' I lliiiik. i'. Htatiitnry .Ti-atiir.' \- ami what it in im-ant tn .In \r t(l iln ]< tn lin.l III tn tin. I nl.l iiH Htatiitnry in-ntur.. is you muHt I.H.k «t thi> statiitn oiilv. In. an..' il,. an.l tlnTi' al(im>, is foun.l tlii' ili' inition of thin ii.'w I'ri'aturn. It ...iiHiil.r III.' .lU.'Hti.iii nf whi'tlinr ynu an- ^'.liii^ t.i .'laHHify it uml,.,- ,||.. Ii.a.l .pf iiiiiimnii law I'.irporatioiis. I,.j.ik.iij,' at this »tutiitn lit wliat an- itn [...w.r'.. what i'. its vitality, what it ran il.i. U iry ir.aturc nin' li i,. to lin.l itf IMTMIIH w 11 ai't withi I.I. II .'.'rtuiu liniiti. Iiut I ' th.' limitH. w,' iiiiiHt I.Kik tn the stitiit.'. Tlio corporat II order tn M-..'.'rt;i 11), Un iliiH '.tatiit.'. for th.' lip-t nf all r.'a«on'<, that it in ion .'aiinnf .'.1 lii'v.iii.l a •impli- Htatut.irv 1 ■ I.-. Cu. V what lilai'kliiiiii. .1 . iiiil III iho jin\il('jii.>; I. .\ im.hoi' is iiivolvfil in tjie jiKivinioii that the tomiMiiy iiuiy <'.\tM-(is,. all Iho liniclioii.s ol' an itHofpoiaU'd <(iiii|iaiiv. mnl i- li<\von.l (iiio.-ti.in absoliiu-ly e-*seii'ia: Mi i1k> |ii-osi.,iiii,in of tlio I'.imimiiy'M ohjects. Sec fiut.'icr. inini. p •!(; ■1. It is abli'. l.y ]ii(iiK.|' |)i-o\isioii.s in i,, ..rii. l.-s .n' av-,,, i.iii,,,,, to tlpfini', limit and lostiii t tlio iiowors oi its diirclois .,i othei agonts in siu-li iiiui.nei' as jimy soem <>.\po,'ula- tions without sip-ninjf any .l.n'iiment; and ihc\ may sue S|iu. i.il itiaractir- isti.'M .if a company utiihr till' Compatiii". A.'ta. 't 31 ^h'I m ruKi iM,\MV \ yiKs. [Vh.w. ami Ih' sut'il l)v • iii|. iin If it 'lic\ wcii' .-ti.iiifi-('r> 111 tl ic la-^c . ill ji' jii'olif'' williniii iiiM'lv iii^ lliciii 111 liiiiiiu'u ii :l'tlii\. iMiiI i" tliii^ i'iial)li>tl lo tililiiiii ru|ii!ul 1 1 ii tliiit i: ^'< < ' ft (,l niilitll r.i)iituli>N Wllicll 1- llll>li->|)U I'll Ip , llll.lfll!^ llic Ulljlll of uikI aiixK'lv ultciiiliiiu' iiiiliiiiili-tj ji.ihil m K The ^lian'liiildiT- ami lniiiu:<'i^ iltMliiiy |i III' • 'iipaiiv ill' llXC'l Willi null I' "i llii' jiii'Miiiiaiii ■ ilioii. aii>i iiii-iiiiil«-.| aUo ol llic iiilii li'> I ir aiix i iimli'i « n |i ii ]•« Ilijiii. |i. 1~ . Till' iiK'iiilii'i - all' ii\ iiM'iiilM'i^lii|i, willi" Ni^imtilio. Iioiiiiil liy the iiiciu Damliini .iii.l artirlr Sect. U. y. Tlu» |)o\vt'i-s of tilt' n)iii|iaiiv UK' Jihiilcil tioil in ilx inoinoniiiiliuii max from tiiiio to tin (•poiial it'>o|iiiion. alU'i n'llalii raniliiiii hkI a!'tirlt>~ ol |i| ii\ P-loll-i of ll - Illl'lih ii--oi'ianiiii. -iili|("!. us io ihr nieiiioiaiiiiiiiii. iii somt' I" ll K' 1 of (ho ('oiiii I'lo. tliu-": — or tilt" Boaid of Tia'lc U'iiiy .laaiiicij x\v (a I Tlic iiaiiH' iiiav lio cliaii^cil wiiJ! jho -aiii li m of llif Board of Trade. S«'(t. 8 ('t). I b The olijorls in llio iiit'iiioiainliiiii iiiay lie alti'iod In s))Oi iai lo-njinioii »aiitlioiii'd li\ lir ( oiiil Sit! . !). Tl ll' uiliric- iif a^-orialimi oilier n'i;ii|:i-io!i ; ii/a\ lulioij. or iii« fiiini (iilic to lime lie alleied li\ ~|ii" iai re-ol H';:iilalioii^ max' lie tli<'iii>x ail"|i!i'l Sc i 1:1 (di ill till' ciisc of a .oiuiiain Siiniied liv ^' 'o^. llie aMi limi liic iiil m, be iiieroaM'd, uiid I he sliare^ max 1 «' foiiNOlM (lixiiled. or I (iiiM'i'tcil. w Ipcic jiaid ii[). into s|( ■ct. I And such •-iork max bo leioiixerted into jiaici ^iiaii of aiix- dpiioiiiiiiati 10. In tl IC case of a loi S'(t. 41. t.'d ii|iaii :''ii|t<'il hx' ^lian tn- v..irr,ini- lo bearer max be i--iii>il ii ^(leci Ol' oiil- II III the ra-e ol a coiiiiiaii'. iiiiK'il hx ■'liar* the iincalleil t a|iiial iiia\ be i "iix ertod iiiio n tieet. .".!•. 12 I nilerwiitinj;' and otiier ronniii- \'<\\> lliav in- to lilt lU'ovisions ' i-ajii . i)H \ • OKPOKATK POWKHH aNU IM m>. ii 1. .arrit'M oil i.ii'^iiMHM u .i..u(l. iu irilinh « •..loui..'«, ii ,.s plHIHrnftwl «o liax- 11 I,, ,1 ro>fi-«T ,1 uwiuh - Ih.omiM h a it in (111 ' '" "' > """ni^'iiK ill the ,ir. iii.(.i| lateil i'()iii|,aii\ , • Iiun tlio iufht uii.t 111 Til resist uiiy (i'iIhh \ iiitoi'li'i- ii('<> wi iiiid pro|M)it; Thorle'fs ( tie FmU i o v. f. D. 7t>:i, «•{/., u ti^lo III-,. I ,,„ ii„, oriipfti, mil. iff. Co V Ai,v)//. >i\ (• irisolvoiirv to In .., ,|„,m lliiirkiii.s. Ml N ;»(! il»> Tu uluii Iho j)ioi.' Ill' mill in -iipiHirt of ii u^'hts ii- m i .(ivt Hi i-erij r„. y. Tentuint, < i:|i. 212 V,„«/,rf/„ ; App. Lu< 121«, .>„„//, //,//„„ CotU Co , \. A'. Aws- A-iJ^'iriati,,,, i 18a4. I (,! K. |.)3; M„Hche.^t,r '■orpunUio,,, H . :.«^. (.ISOl , i (,» I: 'jt. South Wale. Miners FfUt'mtHn, Ulatmu :„u t .»,/ r„ . i'i<(„ , i A. C 2.1!l. !<■) T.Mififf, lopoppos..;.. . i.,,,.i ,„. liners, hu, ,„uv I liioiijrht ttjfuiijj't it. ill To impri.iiiiiiaiivi Uiiii, „iii|, ii; II i;,iih\ ..isf. H ( Div. ;)■! !• W.11V0. or ' 'I' my liiivf. beer- II /aim.- ■- iiiav ^ < l> '-'2 ( To ! I'liii , i'liri. Iiuni Hit, I ,, 1.1 [i,.»v »:i ■ii.iiico of 1(1 'aw City nf I 'jnduii Krhnn-T V. .Vcm- «ruiiiie lint ii. impeu, ,. .luy wron;; no Id II .iiul u, wuiv(> or iili.iii.lon ilinitill \ shares and dclK-iitnres and dohun'm.^ I the company havo tli- same vifrht. and the compunv ouforni thereto. Sect. 114. my i.s bound, under |)0nalty, lo keep a refjistur of h< ■crs. Sect. 2.'.. This rej-isler is to Ih) open for puMi ■tioii. Sect. ;tO. Tiu.s(.s arc not to bo entered in .• :i>, It muy lie reclijie.! !>y the {'oum. H,-ct. .;2. iipany is bound, under penalty, to Make certain an. ,1 1 iirus as to its members, capital, assets .md liabiiiti'v. In 'iio Registrar of Companies. .« :i* »n tlio nllotlco-i mii'I ■ apitiil. and in case of slmrcs issued ollicrwisi' tliuii fm- "■a.sh. lilf rortain coiilractM. ."<<'ri. H« SfM- infra. \>. •!!(». . Im> dated and sifiiiod and tlion tiled, liefore publication, ami tho fad of lilins must, accord iiifr in ciniiinsliincos. roniply with all or sonio of the rpipiisites i<\ sect. «1. Soo infra, p. Ifl'i. If ilu- company niot licint;- i private (onipany) does not issue a pros])ectus. it must ii)r a statement in lieu of prospectus. Sect. 82. Ill The <^)mpiiiiy is bound to frive notice to the Refristrar of iii- erca.se of capital or members i sect. 44 i: and of consolidation of sinires and conversion of slmres into stock 'sect. 42 . but not apparently of the reconversion of stock into shares And lis to special resolutions. Seit. 7tK ^C ' 'I'he company is bound to have a i-ei;isti'reJ . anil notire of the situation thereof lor the time lieiiijr has t.. lie ijfiven to the Kegi.strar. ."N'lt. i'>2. h ' The company, if limited, is bound in have its name up out«i(|c ever\ place where it '-arries on business. ;ind on its seal nn'l on all bills, Ac. Sect. O. ■ i . Xolices and other documents may be -erve*! on the c<^mipany bv leuviiii,' the same, or .seiidinir them by post, addressed to the lompaiiv at il.s registered oflice. Sect. lUi. ■ ji The compiiny. if limited, is bound, under penalty, to keep ii reu1>lish iinnmillv a statement of its nllairs in the statutory form .Sect. 1(18. Ill' The 'nnpMii.) must ..end a list ol' .lir.-. tors to the Rpgistrul' CORPORATE POWERS AND UUTIR" % each .year, aii.l notify u, him any .hrtiigo in it., .Ji.octorate Scd. 7.".. (o) If Hit" .oiii|niiiy cuvii.N on hiisiiioss lor six ii,„„tlis ufU>r th.) iiu.nlH>r of il." inoiiil«ii« is vtuUiml below st-v.-ri, its moiubcrb iiiiiy incur iiiilimit«'(J liability. Sent. 11.".. {],) Jiustea.l of (ho general nioctino; witbin four nionlb, after its iiic.rpori.tion, tho (N.nipany, if liniile,! bv shi.res ' uuil re-isirro-l aflw the end of 1!KM», niusi hol,| ii. slutiifory ' Mi.eiiiiM; „„( less than one month n.l to .•..mineu.v business. SiMl. (i.-,. The report then .lis.n- -M „„„, be |ih>.l wilb the Hi'yislrMr. Ih. (()) The i-omiiany nnist hold an at al nu'etin^;-. .Si'el. i; 1 (r) The romiKiny, if limited by shares, must n.jt prior to ,he «uitu- Un-\ meetin- yary the terms of a .ontract reforn-d to in llio prospectus ex.epl. subject to .he a|.proN;.l of ihe Matulory meeting:. Sect. 83. is) The ,nrnib..rs n.ay apply t.. the lioar.l ,.( Trad.' lo appoint, inspeclors to e.xaminc Ihe iillaiis .,f the < oiupuny sect. |o<( • "•"' i"-l><"'">'> .an I j.p,,i„ted by sp.vial resolution" Sell. 110. 'ti The company nm.st ( nmply with .secl>. 112 and J I.! as to audit. II It a hankin-c.nnpany, il.s accounts must |„ „„ally auditol 111 accordaiKC Hilh m>c| . ||.!. an.l it may be that" .sect. 112 apj)lieH. i'yi (u-neral m.H-tinps must be calhd on ro,,uisition, as proyidcd by sect. 0(i. (^vl The memlK.r« of the com,.any are entill,.,! to the as.sistunce of the ( ourt to restrain the .loin^. of Uial which is ultra vires <'■ the company. <.v. The .omjiauy may be ttoun.l u|) by the (.ourt isect. 12'.)) on the petition of a momlR.r or rreditor, or of the romi)any il.-.'ll .sect. l;!7., or of the ollicial r.^viver in companies wiMdmjr-np, if it is already in yoluntary li,p.idation. Ih •V ll-^ni'Miil-ers may yolnntarily,,lacoitin liquidation (.••voluntary li'iuidation ■ so .alhvli, and .so end the business; and brin- into f)pcration ellicient proyi^ion.s for the xvindin--up of iti alluirs and il.s dis.solution. Sect ]<».! enabb's creditors to apj.ly in a voluntary yviudiuf^-up, a* the li,,ui,lator or any ooiitrihutory might aj)i)ly under sect. 138 of 18(i2. -■ It i.s subject to the t^-neral law, so far as applhalde. and if it uirrios on Ihe busi„os.s „( a money-lend\ wr! 4 of tin' Aut. .S*'e further, iufru. p. t>28. Tho iiiowt ofiMt'iitial powor of u ixiiiKJi-utinii i-» the junvin- to aot by ap np'iits can l)e empowered to do: for instance, they may iK-rform a contract liy the company to each its uppivntice his l)Usine^.s. liiiriili-ii l-li/iiiliihlr Sniirtii v 1 asxnii. I IK'.tl I 1 {}. H. 7J. Uut il is dear that the a^^euts of the coiiipanv cannot hy any lueaiui 1m- invcste of the company. HV//oh v. Saflerif. (1807 i A C. 229, .•J21 : Treior v. W'liil ninth, 12 App. ('an. 4(HI. N »r can its ajrents be empowered to e.xertise powers which the Acts \m\ in the members, and make uxerciwable only by resolutions of p-neral niwlin-rs, c.ij., the power to itHiuif capital, or to sub-divide shares, or to wind u|. viduiitarily. As the law by uotv.s.sary Miiplicatioii confers on an iiK orporateii t-unipany the power to act by agents, it \wV\n the company, liku any other principal, ivspoasibie for the acts or defaults of its u^jt'iit.s within the scoim- of their employment, liaiuji'i v. Gt. W. Kail. ( <> . :> II 1.. ('. 80; Huru-Uk v. EikjUmU Joint Stock Htinkintj Co.. L. R 2 I'.\ 2.'>'.t; lloiildHinirlh \ . (it;/ nf (iUin'jou- Ihilil,-. J App. Cas. ;i2ti Thus, if the duly authori/ed ajreni of (he company enters into a contract on its behalf, the compuny is bound thereby; and if the company's a|rents commit a brf-ach of that contract, the company is responsible accordingly. When', in contracting, partiiu)>i)iiv Tntmnn'K cane. otiicr < oiriiiiuiiii.'ationN on U'lialt ni the il8H I ;! ell. 272. lint a comiiaiiy will not. it h(h'iu>, I>o IioiiikI l)y any acioptancc of a hill vi ('xcliaiiRt' unltiiw the iwrsoii ac<;('i)linK for llu> coiiipany undor ftpd. 17 of the Companies Act, 18()2 ( ( 'onipanitw Act, 1908, s. 77), udiiiilly. anil not uicTOly ostonsil.Iy, ai(K)j)t.s. PremU'r Induntrud Rank. Llil. v. ./. rf W . ( mbtrcc. I.ttl., i 1 <»()!> ) 1 K. B. 10(!. Ami a (oinpany can, ex /xw/ l.ulo. ratify that which has Ih-oh dono R«ti«c«tion. on Its U'lialf without authority, wlior<> the a(^t ratitied is not iiUra rires the i(>ini)any. linnit v. Siritthburh- (it., 40 t . U. 13.'); Wilson V. Itc.«/ llnrlli' 111)1)1 ( II.. 2 !)«> (i. .1. .t S. 47.">; lirine v. Union liiinl, .)/ .lii.slniliii. 2 A|)p. (as. .((ifi: Ijondnn anil S'eie York Inveatmenl Cor/) , ' IH'JJi 2 Ch. H(;o. \ coiiipaiiy is lialile, moreover, not only in rospeet of (!ontracts made Tort*. on il.s Ill-half, hut in r<«s|H'ot of wronjjs committed hy it« a^'nt« in the .•oiirse of their employmen., and for the honofit, or intended henelit. of the company. Tin' j riiuiple omlxMlied in the maxim, Qui sentif i-ommoilnw xenlire debet et onim. is ii))))lie( Irehind, (I'M)'.)) .\. ('. 22!»; Britijih Miihial liiink v. ( hiirnwoo, ' (, f UuU., 18 Q. B. I). 714. .Viid the extent of the c(m n- liability is not limited because it^ eonslilution limits the aiiiou. ' i its e.\i)onditure. GnlhicorUiy v Selhij Dam ( omnii-isionerx, ■ lH'.l2i I I}. H. ;i48; rnited .•^erriee Co.. •> Ch 212 -a owe as to the loss of dej>osit<> . uiid I'm- «H'iii;fiil di-ipusilioii of plaintifF'.'- sharcs , /Wi/" lloil. ( l>v is a'jcnt*. |)io\ idcd .-ncli act* arc sutllcicnilv fonnpcti'd with tlio scop." and olijfvt of tlii' cinipaiiy'.s incorporation. Thus, in Whillirhl \. Smith luixtrrii Hail, f u . K. 1$. iV K. 121. a company \va> hold llald(< for a inaliciou.-^ liUd: and Lord ('ani])l>"ll Maid: "The •rnnind on wliiili il is conti'ml'd that an action for a lilnjl lannoi po«.-il)ly lie niainlaiiKNl aLrainnt. there may ht- trreat dillictdtx in 'ayinir that, under corlain circumstances. e.\pros> nnili(e may not he iin]iuted ti> and proved asT.iiu.st a corporation. .\ltliou}rh the servant of the corporation may have liud no actual authority, express or implied, to \vrit<' the lihcl, if he did so in the course td' an einployniuni which ii authorized, the corporatiuu i^ liable. So the I'rivy Council held in Cltizois' Life Axxuraiuc Co. \ Broun. ( l'.>()4 i .\. ('. 4U;i. Ami t^ei' Scvill v. Fine Ait.1 linfitrana Co.. Ltd.. (!«!».). 2 g. n. i:)ti. And in Green v. Lrmiloii Gen Omnibus ( I) . 7 ( . H. N. iS. 290. it was liold, on denmrrer, tlmt au action would lie a^piinsl a corporation for driving its omnil)uses so u.- wronpfully to molest the |>laintilf in the u^e of tlie hi^rhwa^ . .'Viid see /,i»(//((,v V. IadiiIoii Gen. Omnihun Co.. X H. & (.'. 020; e.vplaiuod in VicLeri/ v. Great l-Mnterii luiil. i ».. 79 L. T. 121. .A corpornli'iii may also he lialde fur a nui-. Ua/iier v. IaiikIoh Trinineaii.^ t i,.. ti'.t I. T. :!(il. In F... Ii g. Ii. D. 2«7. Fry. J, reviewed the authorities, and held that a company was liuhle to an action for malicious pro-ecution. .And ihi.s was followed in ( oniforit V. Carlloii lUnik. 1899; I {}. Ii. ;!92: affirmed, i'19n(), I q. H. 22, the point l>einj> conc«'dtsl at the Inu Se(! also .Mnuitli v. diencc of the law, then if theif is iiothiiijr in the statut<' either expressly or iiu|)liedly to the coutrarx ihi' lireach of the statute is an ofleni-e which can bi' visitpil upon the c pan\ \t\ mean" of an indictment. The <^ue^.)i \ Tillei. . 1891 . 2 (^ H. 588. 592 W^KI'OKATK, linVKRS ANIJ Ul.'TU-S. ■Hi [ii He;/. V. liirwinfihani mid i. Ifcitti.siiii. J., in dolivoriufrtlu- judgment of tlio Court, said: fliut 'on L'frnTiil principlps ... a corpuration niav be iiulictod for breacli ..(■ a duty imposed upon it bj' law, though not for a felony or foi • liiiu's involving pcr.soiiul \iolencc, as for riots or assuull.s." Thai wii.- a I'tiso of non-inisfea.sanoe; but the sauu' doclrinc \vii> applied III .-a-scs of misfeasanre. In Hfi/. v. drriil Surth i>\ KmiUnid Itml I n.. l! i). 15. .il.5, where Lord LH'nman, wiio delivered the judgmoiii ■ il the Court, said: "'The argument is that for a wrongful act n r.MfKiralio'' i.s not amenable to an indietuient, though torn wrongful .•iiii.vsioii i( undiMibledly i.s. u>,siiming in the lirsl plaie thai there i- .1 plain aiiei-s to the Registrar as recjuired by sect, 2t; of the All of 18(;2 (now^ Hcct. 20 of the Act of 1908.. wa> a criminal |iiocec(liiig, and accordingly that where the Queen's Iknch Division -raiiknl a rule nisi for a iiiaiidanms directing a iiiagistiiite to hear iiid dclemiinc the application for a siiininons, there wa.s no a|)|>eal. nixMiMich as jiidgmcnl was a iudgmcnl in -a criminal cau.s« or Hi, liter within sect. 47 of the Judicature Act, 187.i. It was argucxi iir iliat (aise that although the WHI . 2(> imposeil a duty on the com- p.iiiy, Ihe non-performance of that duty was noi a criminal ollonw !■> the company. Hut the Court held otiicrwi.se liowcn. Ii. ■)., in ilic course of his judgmont. said: " It would iiiiie<'d be a ix'iiiarkable Mcw for the Legislature to take that the obligation imposed upon 1 ((mipanv wa.s of such a nature that its brcaili by thi^ compiinv wa.s not an ollence. and yet that a dinntor or manager of the i i.inpany »lui sloixl by and ac(piio.scem MJKini Ihe duly wa.s inipo.s<'d from the iiosiii.,ii i.l dllciider and would .niiiKliice into the class of olVenders the diicilois .uid iiiaiiauc is onU ulin stiHKl by and knowingly acipiiesced. I laiiiioi think that that is ilic- true reading of the section.-. . . . Therefore a breach of the I ii'\i>ions of sect. 20 is an olVem.*, and it is none the less an oMenee l«(ause «««!. 27 imimsos a |H3v V«>lnpttliy tA tl.c An 40 Fraud. If HRKUMINAKY NOTES. [(.'HAI'. 1. " It 18 not iiocoHHarv to in(|(iirt> wliether the ('Oiiipuu> I'ould bo iuf fraud. But where a corporation is formed for the purpose of currying on a trading or other 8|Mer.sons for whom they wcw acting would have l)een affected by tlu'ir fraud, the same principles nuist prevail when the prini'i|)al under whom the agiuit t»cl> is a corporation." I'er LipkI ( r.iiiwurlh, Uaniicr \. G. \V . Hail. ( ii.. 5 H. L. ('. H((. Ami tile lu« seems to be the same in Scotland. Hockey V. LliiiU-mlule liank. .'!« 8c. L. R. 120. In Baririck \ . KiiylishJoiiit Stixk Hankinf/ Co.. L. R 2 K.v. 2.j!». a eompanv was held liable for the fraudulent niisrepr<>s<>ntation of ii« agent. Willes, ,1., in ilelivering the judgment of the Kxcheipn'r Chandler, said: " With resjK'ct to the i(uestioii wholJier a principal i- answerable for the act of his agi'nt in the course of his master's biisi- uoss, and for his master's beneht, no sensible distinction can Ix" draw n between the case uf fraud and the cas«> of anv otlier wrong. The general rule is, that tin- niast(>r is answerable for ev<'ry such wrong ol the servant ur agi>ut its is coinmitttHl in the course of the serviw anil for the muster's b<>neKt, though no express command or privity of fh<' master 1m> proven applied also to direct trespa.ss to goisN, 4»s ill the case of holding the owni-rs of ships liable for the act 'jI masters ubrmid imjiroperly selling liie cargo. li has lM»en hehl applicable to actions of false imprisonment in cases where oflii-ers ol' railwa\ coin))aiiies. intrusted with ihe execution of l)ye-laws relaliiii: to iniprisdiinient. and inti'iidiut; to act in the course of their duly, improperly imprison imtsoiis who aiv suppo.smi to conu! within llii' terms of the bye-la«s. It has Ikh-u acted upon where |K>rsons em- ployed by the owners of boats to navigate them, and to take fares. have conimitlcd an infringement of a ferry, or such like wrong. In all tluw' cas«>s it may be sai it was .said here, that tJie master has not aiitliori/e«l 111,- act. ll is true he has not uiithori/ed the par ticular act. but he has ]iut the agent in his place to do that clasp of acts, and he must be answerable lor the manner in which the ageiii has c«>nducle A pp. C'as. .'120, Lord Sciborno rcfcriwl with approval to tlir priiK ipl<> laid down by Wilitw, .1., in tho po-ssage cited abuvo, and siiid: " Tliut |)rin('i])ic rowivi-il full rocofrnition from thin liouiie in Thi' Snlioiuil Exchange Co. v. Ilreir. 2 Maci). l();i; and Mew llrum- trirh- litiil Co. V. Conyhettre. 9 H. L. C. 711; and was certainly not iiiouiit l|>licalile whether the agency is for a mrpiiratioii (in a matter within tin scope of the corporate powers i or for ;ni iiidividiial; and the (lecisions in all these ca,ses proceeded. iiiil iin the ;rronnd of any imputation of vicarious fraud to the priii- ripal, lint biH'uuse. u.-i was well ))ut by Mr. Justice Willos in liarivick s lUKV il>. K. 2 E.x. 2it\i), with res|)ect to the question whether a priniipal is answerable for the act of his agent in Uie course of his niiL-ilers business, no .sensible distinction can be drawn between the ftusc uf fraud and the ciise of uuy other wrong.' " Tims a comjumy may be lioble for misappropriation by it« clerk. Trutt V. Mutiaml Ducount Co., 17 T. L. R. .$7. Ill Adtlie V. \\ intern Bank of Siut land, L. R. 1 H. L. Sc. 145, ItJT, alicive rclerred to. Lord Cranworth said: "Corporate bodies niav be inailc i-cs[Minsible fo!- the frau 8iil)iiiiilcii.s\ . London (iemralOniiiibusto.); why. ilii'ii, slii.iild ih.re be a limit in the ca.se of frauds In Uouldsuorth \. I ill/ III (ihmiioir llnnk. •". App. Cas. ;117, a2U, Lord iSolborne said lliai tlu' words iu italics might re((uiie "sduio enlargement or explanation." Il is, however, to Ih" borne in mind that a corporation is not liable wlicn- the act vjf it« agent is for his own l>enefit and not that of the cmpuiiy Ihilish MuluuK o. v. ( hurnwood, iff. Rail. Co., 18 Q. H Uiv. 7Hi; or where he is actinj,' outside the sco(w of his authoritx (lianult, limns it Co. v. South Londtm Tramways Co., 18 if. U. D si'>: lirard v. London Ccn. (hiinibiis ( o.. i, 1900; 2 Q. B. j;)0; liubeit ' l. ;j by llu! luM. nliitlu'i of uoiiiiiii.ssi(iii or oiiiiHMion, tor luUfeuMUctt or MHu(>iiue ^Krhtii/fr v. .V<«- Sombrvfii i o., .! .\ji|>. Vim*. \1\h. MefroixtUtaH Haul, V. 1 1 ('iron. :> E\. I)i\ . .Il'.»: Londou Fiiiancinl .Ixsdc. v. Kelk. '2i\ V. I). 1(1"; Mitors (xme, 'V.> C. 1). 4U9;, except in M'spei't of ultru fires nwiit'r.s {Anlihur;/. dc Co. \. Hkhe, L. R. 7 H. L. (i.i.Ji. hi miitldr intra rircn \\\i' i'onipan> is bound by the conical of all the fiii'Mibt'i-s. and fn-mTal i'i)n:4;ut niuy lio inforrtii wht-rc a course of doulin^r ih piir-^urd wliich was within the knowlod>r»' of most of the incnilMrs, Felir Hadloj d Co. v. Hadleij (l^DTl, 77 \,. T. l.'JC.; I'hoHphalf iij Linn- Co. v. (fr"('ii. L. R. 7 I'. P. 4.'{; Kimnn v. Sniiillromhr. I,. H. ;; H. L. '2W. A lorjwratioii, tli(iu<;h it lia« no « vet. of it« own, may ncNcrlhoh'.s.s Ik- trcatol as havinjrMi'n what iU a>;<>ntt nii^rht Ml'; for "altliouirh it nuiv not havo pycs and .so*- what i^ jroinjr on. il ha.-, au'onl.s who can mcp." CrooL v. (Orporation of Srtiford. ti Ch. .-..>1; Mcrxri/ /tor/.s Co. v. (libb.i. I.. H. 1 H. U. !t3; lUlwden \. London. Kdiiihiiri/h d (iUiK'iotv Co., ^18'J2i 2 i). \i o.U Jt must Im' trodit.'il, too, with imeliigence and with unih'istanilin^ what llic cun.s«>i|upucf> of it- auts will be. Merchantii' liankinij Co. V. I'lurnir liexHrnirr Co . '< C I). 20."(, 217. Si>. too, u eui'|)oralioii mm Im- i',slop|H> ajrainst H. the xmipany is cstopjx'd from saying' that thf .shan-s ar" not paid up. liiiiLinshuH- v. SicoHs. ;J App. t'as. 1001; Mardomild. So>l» d' ( ().. ' ISm 1 I ( li. H',l. For other ca.scs of evtoppt-l, ,scc lUhin Hail. Co.. I., li. ;! (^ M. .-.Ht: ( ofetttr;!. d<. Co. \. (1. E. Hail. Co. II g. n. I>. 77: afKriiwd xub vim S'r'i- York lireu-eriex \ .Alt. -den.. ( 189'J) A. C. 02. It in liable for moneys i!6; COKHC;{ATi: K)WKK« ANU Dl'TIK."*. «;{ ' Icinf Ik'I'ii applied In tlio pavmciit of itr< ik-lil.-i. HiiruHcxs Wviiloch v. Il,i\'r llee ( n.. 19 y. B. I). I.'»."i. And a fhurj^i- on it« a>st'i>i, whidi i> iillrit ciret as n<^'unl.« pari of tin- nuiiify advaiu^eil. iiiav In- •(^.toA ,i« ic!rar(l.-i tli<' moiicN wliich liiidN iis wav to iJic liaiid* of tin- luiii- paiiy. JnlnixliiH Forviiju I'alviitu < u.. (I".»01» '2 (h. '2'M. It ma> In del- la-ic the lijrhl to fnlorco sputiiic iK-rforiuauci' of a loiitract. Mnil'^ lasi: 29 V. I). »29. It nay bv lii-ld huund in tijiiily by :i paiiil coMlratt iu ridatiun to imwl wlu're tlii'n- li js Ikm-u sucii part |MTlipriiiaiKi' at would take tlio caM! out of liio Statute of Frauds if iMldial persons wviv parties to tlu' toutract. Wilson v. Wfxt llnrllf- nl (\ '1 l)c (i. .r. * S, 47.). So, loo, a col ii|iaii\ w llirll III iii.'-lniiiii'iit ill a form wliiili will oiialilc tho huldor ti> lai^c i 'II it may in cnuity In pi-i>rliid4i M\ writ if Heoue-trali 11 ai.'-ainst their propel i 'III au ■ 'crrtpaiiiNl aeorporafion wdl iiol I.e enforced hy the ittadiiiii'iil of • liicclor unless he ha> hceii personally .served with the order. .V- >\fiiint v. Join/ Sfiirl: Instilulr. Limited. 8l) I.. T. ilds on the U-rnis and ohjects of the sfalule. '"''"''™' Thei-p can he no ..... ;.. ... *- .„„ ,„,,,.,, A... v-;;,;-:,;^;::r:;r';:,,;:i,'i,';;, :,.,;«- a ,..nm..n. //''''•^- ''''''7' ' '^'"i;.;,^ ^,"■ i;. ,,.. , ourt of ,J.'.,„„,,,„i,.. ...Hkn- .1.- A.t .,1 m;-2. An.l s.v lu.}umh^. Tlu. IK.oon„<,/. v. ./«.v, u t. l. k ;!ti5. iilliniiiHl //».. ,1... Sil.. i>r Ki».cl A . ..nM..nv hxs boon l.ol.l .■■ I- a ,k-.so,. un.lo. ''"> ^"^^ '" >" A.„, a '-7-"- ";;;;",' ' . ....l U.o.or...v no, liu..lo ...a :-;t;:=::::r,::::./...-y;-v-.;^- -— ^' '7;;ri:::;:;::;: :;.:::::«;-'■' ••-"-■•'■■--- poai fi.r no ono <«u !i|>|iotir ' ConilH. «<■. Hut it i-< otlierwiM- in tli / (iUmc'xier Rail Co.. 9 Car. & V 1.0 Kint; - Hench Division, ttiui perlmi>> ai the font 111 I Criminal Conrl. Jill MKMRKKHHIIV 45 Memberihip. lla\iiiK^ tliUH brielly diwcuisttl tin- jiuwi'ii" ami (luti«'> "l a roiiipany MsmUnihip 111 ilMo'liciiatc tapufily.il may iio« l)n tniivoiiii'iit |..«ay a lew \m.i.|s alxmt the iiK'nil)cre iit tlic i(iiii|>aii\ liow lll«•.^ iHt-oua' iih-iuIrtk. what It) llu'ir n'lalion to llio ciuiipaiiy, uii«l \un\ tlioy u-a-so to Ik) iiieinlK'iM with spfiial nfc'ifiicc to u tomiwiiy liiuit^'d Ity Bhuio.s. Ami first, who may hwoiiH! nii'iiilKTt'/ Aiiv si'M'ii. or, ill thf fa, nriMiii.- iiiav Hiilisnilic the iiM'iiioraiiMi(ialioii. Si'ct. li of ihc All of ll>08. And ett'ct. 24 piovidcs tluit:- • TIk- .-lulHiribrrH of tlio nn'iuDranituiii iif u.iaiHiiition of any i-onipany iimliT Who are thiK Alt ^liiill I"' Ji'i'iiuil to havi' aurc.-.! t" bvr.ni imbcM <>f tin- ioni|p!iiiy ni<-mbcr». wh"»r iiicnioianiium they havi- iiul>«rilM-o iMitcntl n< mrnihiTi nil flir r.-ifi''i\. and i'iitv i'Hht (ktwhi wIio im* aifri'iil t.. lirionii' a iiiiniliiT of a I'liuipany iiiicli'r tliix \it. and wliow iianii' i< riitiTi'd .III till- rciriilcr of mi-mlnTx, shall hn di'i'iinil In !»■ a iiirniliiT of ihr ioiii|iany. " '^llll^. a- ii'irardsttuhscrilh'i-, '■aii\ |ici»oii may suloiriln'. Tlifii' i~ iin liiiiiiatioii: no r(-.lri( lion. ImiiTil. ihc uoid •any ' .M liidi'^ liiiiilution or tiualilitiitioii, iicr Fry, .J , Ihich- v. Uiiti". l-'l ^} H "■ ■SCi. «.'il. Accoidinjjly, not only may any «ul>jf< t ol Ills Maj:'^l,\ ^uL.-'crilM' liiil aliens al-io may «ul)«4rilK! , /'noros c' Hi-iix" \. /i"" 18711. L H .') H. L. ITlii, in whii:li cast' all tin- .sc .ii .siiliv lilM'i.-. «fii' aliens. And it Ihih even Ui'ii held that an infaiii (iinies williiii the niiid.s any iieiwa " > fM.ron it' ( n . i 18'.lL' > "J ( h. .V.."> , ami may lie one of (lie .seven .suliserilH-rs. .\ linn a.s sinli is not a ' ikm—hi. The individual iiarlneri*. or some dnl\ authori/ed aj^eiil on ilieir hehulf iiin.sl suliseribe. This was deeidiil in WiiiU'Iiid .{HthnuiU- Co, T'.l I., d. eh. "■W, and ditldi W. N, 1H7. See. ho\ve\ ri".;i>leied its surli LiKikiii" to the wnoralitv of the.se words, il is well settled that Who may "^ ■ 1- I •!• I 1 »i 4 take share*, aiiv |ierson not under disalnlity may Iwome a iiienilier. tluit a luurried woman may lake Mhart'.s ■ l.i'nls liniikiiKi f'o. •■» Eq. 7H1; .\!arried Udiin'n'.s rrojxirlv Aet. IH'.i:!. >. I ; thai u lompaiiy haviiijj: power to take .shait's may hocome a iiiemU'r i Harncd'H H'lnl.in;) Co , ■ '< ell. U2i; and that an infant lu.iy lieiomo n iiioiiiher. Mihjcet, howcvir, to the lii^ht l^i ivpinliate the .shares when lie uttailid majority i ru/i/icrf cane. :\ (.'h. I.>.S; I'lii/h ami Sliiii iiKiils cttHf, l.'l Ei[, MM',', and of courrte an alii'ii ii m li.iiiknipt ma\ Leeoiim a uiemher. ^wCr«>-1^ t(i l'KKI.IMIN\KY N(»TK.S. [Chai'. r. How a Person may become a Member. if,i) ti Otiwr. ■ll. Willi tH l>'i\<' M.l...riU<.l Iho .■..nipnny'H nuMiiu- rinulimi '>!' .(--"ri.ilinii. rji rii.w iMTson- «lu. luiM- a-i.'nl I- U- iii.-imU-i>. ami «li'-<' iiaiiii'M ari' I'litt'ii-il in llii> rc;n-<'''' T(„-.. an.l III mI> .an -uinK 1m. .all.-l '-r-. in H'" >'•» ' havi.iu .iM,MinMl 111,. |-mI1 M,tM-..r innnlMM -n,,.. MrnlS ,„«,■' \Ht. llMTOlnr. . Imm.h,,.. a ni. n.l"T -r .Imirhol.lcr iii umn of till' iDllowinu' wiivK:- ,|i Ih .sul.s.iil.ini: 111.- iii'Mii.iiaiHl..Mi -I asM-iiitii.ii Im'Ioiv iI« ii<' Mk"' '» "In.ir "r nIihi."., an>l liriiiu- .'iilrml Oil llic ivi.'i'^l'r of inoniU'iv. , ;; \U lakinu a transfor ..I a -lian' -r ^l.ar..^. and Lrinif .-nK-nMl ..i, till' i:'j;inli'r lit nii'ml'i'l-. I |!v i,-islraii..n on -M..-.-ioi ,l.-,;-a-.'.l or l,aiikni).l uii'iuImm . ,;,. l!y allowintr hi- nam.' i" 1"' -n ll'«' ic-i. •')•>. '2 l'ivn.i.>intr tlm>* iiiu. Ii. l.'t n- pHMi^tnl to ni.rtlvM- n litilc mo..- < Iom-Iv iho .on.litio.H .T.-atin- ihostalu- of iiu.M.l.prsl.i|.. ami li'-l of ixT-ons .-.iili<( ril'inj,' till' iiii'inoraniliiiii *- r Siibw ribcr» 1i mt'mitmn- iliiiii. Subscribers to the Memorandum. Evon MibxiilKT to tho mfinoian.liiiu luiomos a sharclioliU'r />•«. fnrlo Oil llio in(oi|.oiation of tlif ..nni.anx . aiul liaM." a.-< llio liold.-r ol wliativci- nmnl..'!' of sl.anw lie- l.a- suLMriU..! for. Tin' 2:!r.l mmIioii ..f 111.. \«l of lH';-2 MK.w r.^jihuca l>v .s<' 1 . 21 of ill.' ni-w A. I ., a- l!ow..ii. 1.. .1., V',i»U'i\ out . .V.V.>r« msr, 2<.t C. D. 4*7 1, -Iwim- Hi-' >luliis ..f a Mil.M ril.or of ill • nitMiioraiiamn .)f iL^-^-Miation in a .li!! .uiiipany. Ami Kiw. Mhintirs ,,i.s,'. 4 Ivj. 2:;h. In tho vaso of llio ...ul.-.ri4..Ts ,,f till- ni.'iiiniaii.l.ini, thoicfoiv, no allotiii.-nt is nor.M-ary < London „n,l I' orinrhl ( o..', C. !). r,2r, ■ : no entry on llu' rcjrisU'r of nipinhrrs is no. ^-^iirv. Mml'-- ni-c- snprn: Mi-.rmdcr v. Antomaiu- Co, MKMHKKSHII', 17 , IfMMii 2 < li. ti.i And tlio wlmnv"' MiihsiiilK-d lur .ni' I'l U' i, iiai.K'il ^u> i-.ii('il on iIk" i^iK- of tl!i><«i \ /<iilisiiilii'i- i-i I ii.l to lilkn tll<< .lmrr-< from iinollior iiicnilii'i': llu' onlv w:iv lie can |>o-ilit> i* I IV mIiow in'^ lliiii nil tlii> sliiiii"! liii\o Ikst :iII<.iI<>lliir» Mm l.lt'fi s i-ii'i'. I < li. I) -IT: Ei'iiim' msr. siiimi Si ■ .iN" I'.flHiiln I'liiilhni i It.. 12 < I) l!'l. wlliTi' a ■'lilKirilrt'l «lio liiiH llnl l.l'I'll |lllll<>ll 111! llu' K'trislCr «ll> IlI'MTllll'll'-* lll'lll liilllll' I' ' till •>haii'.H In' hml milworilHHl for iifU>r a iajHO of nini' yoar^. In .'.I'lf/lf. <(/ Til . .'il 1.. T. 2;17, liiiliiiiM vviv< iMifoii'i'il allcr a lii|>«i<' ol' foiii yi'.ir*. N'lir r:in a «uli-nrilH>r vi 'idiut*' il»' ^illan•s In- siili>i lili' ' . 'ni ijn' •jni uikI "f iiiisii'|irc>«'iilali'. I.nril Liu iinii's miv. < \'Mi'- \ '1^ "'17 liii wliiMi' tln'Mtili'1'rilipr ^iiowdl that liiw.^iili-rriiitioii . i ,;"••■ li.' t'l Ih< on lii'lialf of lijv llrni. iinit till' sliari'o wi'i'c alloti ' n. ;i ■;i> liri.l thai III' ha! ili-ii'liarjfi'il hi- oiiliyalioii. Ihi„.i, ■ .; , IMiti a ( h. t7;i. \^ III the .«iil'>. I'iU'i K lialiility i" |ii>. "t'l" iitlm. |i. 'if* Other Members. Tc Miiiir ni-sl to the si'i'omi clu-i- of |M'r-Miii> ih'alt wilhliv ^'rt.2t Odi.r I'viMV niher |M'r.>on who Im.s ajjfrpcil to Ikviuih' a iiii'IiiIhm' of a i'oiii|iaii iiniliT thiH .\rt and \vlio,si> nam*' !•< I'lili-ri'il on the ri'y:i-: '1' an auii'i'inont ; '1'' I'litrv on till' ri'^.st<>r. An .i^rrPi'iiM'nl aloni" iIim>i not i mate Ihf status of tnonilirr.slii|i. It is a ii'iidition jirivt'di'nt lo ariiiiirin;; mirli rshi|i that tin' sliandioldor s naino slioiiid aNo In • iilrii'd on tho ii';ri.sti'r. I'or Vr\. ].. .F . .V/'v,/"v <(i.ic. Uit ('. I). J2I; SO" finthor. iiifri}. j) 72. The Agreement to take Shares. Then' is no ditrcrcniii, as f'hitty, .1., wild in S'niA'i^ < -io. 20 f". I) 421, lii'iwoon a rontrart tn l«k<» sliariw and am other rontrai't. A foriiml a^T<'«'iin'nt is not nro«>ssary. If, in siihstanro, nn •iirn'oinont !■* Mi;iiii'. tho form is not mat4>rial. Hilm's rase ' IH77), 4 (.'h. I). 782 To loii.siitiilo a liindinfr oontraot tii tako shares in a company, whon .«ii(li iiintrart is ronstitutcd. as it usually is, liy ,t 'ilication and ailiiiini'iit, tlioi-o nuistho an ap))lic'ation hy tho intondiiiir sliaroholdor, an allolniont hy th'j diroctnrs of tho roinjianv of iho shari-s appliod loi, aiid a romiiiiinicuiion by ihi" liir.'iiurs to llio a| i.m.l.' in uiitmp «itnuHl by tho upplicant, but an uppliculion by «<.rd ol mouth will .b.. Kr piirle Bloxam, 33 Ueav. 529a; Lf«/«« .--■. 1.. K. 3 Ih. 3.!. An applica- tion i.- an oiler l.v the UppHiant anil, like any other olTor, it nmy be witlulrawn at auv time b«'lore ace.-|>l«'"*' '« «<>tiH«l »<' »'"' upi'l'"*"'. or if the acceptance i« bv pe.st, ul any tinit Iwfow- the letter of acceptance is inxsteii , llebhs <•«.,■. 1 K,, \>; Dnnh,,, s. Iln,;l'ns^ H L I' 381; UenlliarH v. Fras,;. .I«tt2. 2 Ch. :i7i, ,..-.. m the ,mual wav (Lo«rfo« rf Sorlhcn li,n,L: ^iWO) 1 Ch. :i20,. ^\.th- dravval nmy be bv wor.l of mouth. TrumauH vane, (IHtM i 2 t b. 2-L. Withdrawal bv \^^\ is not dVctive unU*> it reaches the .ompany before notiw of allotment is po..t.vl. H>n nc v. Van lUenhnvvn. o ('. P. D. 344. The rule Qui fucH ,ur alium I,; ,t ,,i'r «• applies to a contr.ut to take Hhart..s, and. a.s an- allotted to .\.. !.<• l«cor..es a men.- ber ft(i, 2 Ch •i43; lllmlU-H" '..sr. ISlHlt 1! t'h. 121. And it .> not'e8.scntial that the u-.'nt should have actual authority: it is .sulH. ient if he is held out as liaviun uulhoril> Thus. «h.-re A. -nves B an open letter authoii/inj.' him l^> apph . ami -ivs l.iin (irivate in«tnictions limitin>r the authority, ami ». applies .Lowm- hi, aufhoritv but 2, /«//". Il A. applies for share, in a linitiuii, name and is allotted .-oiue. lie uill be held liable m* a n..u.bcv in re>|..Mi thereof, an ,««r, W. N. (1899) It; but, to constitute liability in such a case, there must 1h> a contract, and there .an l.e no ...nUuit where there i- „o intention of contra.tinsr. <:„ ■ "I"''-*' '1«'''" '« •» ""st^ke on the applicanfs i«»rt a« to the company s identity. lnt,'.rnal,omt S„net;, „f .{urlumerrs. li<,iUiv>' ,m,'. (•IS98, 1 Ch. 110. Ami m.' ( urmtn, s .use. liritannm Fire .hsorudiou. O^'-"/ ^ ^^ -"2 (^' A. '. So when- a director «illiout authority ap|)licd in the name of a third l.artv who wa« xui iini.^. and allotment was made to ,u.h (hinl vartv it wa« held tlml the lin>ctor could not l)e nuule liable a^ a .ontributnrv So. u»>. where the applicinl iiiukes a mLslake a.s to the ALLOTMr.NT. 4» lonipanv, thnro is do ron'rart. S 1 Ch. Hit Allotment. Afwplaiic*' of nn applicufion foi' .«liiiros is iirdiniirilv ovi.lonofld bv what is toniwHl "allotniont." ■ Wliiil is Ipiniod 'aliohnoii(, said Cliitlv. 1.. .(.. 'is }r«>norally .icitlicr iiiiirc nor less than tiio iicc«>ptaiiM' liy the coinpuiiy of tlw i.llcr t" tak<' wliaivs. To take the (iiinnioi case. (Ik- ollor i.s to tuko a iiTtain iianibor of Rliarps, or .such u !<•?> numlxT of shares as may In- iillottcd. That offer is arfOi)tont oilhor of the total iiiimhor mentioned in the offer, or a lofw niinilK>r, to 1><> takon l>y the pcison «lio miule tho offer This eonstitiitos a liindinji: eontraet to i.ike that mimbor acx'ordinp to the otter and acc<>ptanc<'. To my mind iheii" is no mafric whatever in the term alhitment a> used in these 1 iroMuistances. It is »iiiM not, however. mnke llie jiersori who has ||nis ajjreed ti> take the shares a memlK>i tiiiii lliat iiiomi'tit: all thai it dix's is simply this it. ctmKtitutes a liiiiilinir coMtraet une(ilied niimlM>i' of sliares. and under whieh ihi' person who has maeil to liecome a inenil)er on th<' K'L'isler is a mere matter of form, anil iimi\ be described as a mere lllilli^ll'rial aet ; liut it appears to me that in point of law all that is .1 'lie liv the process I have jusi indicated, and all that wan done in this lii-^e. was t(i make a comph'lc and bi!idin<:' ••ontract ' Xuitfy -t/vc, 2!t C. I). 4:21, 4'Jt!. This, no doubt, is peifi-ctiv s(iunectalion that thov will bi- acicpted. See Hoitrh v Spnnilr. 12 .\pp <"aK. .'t«.'i: Miilnin \ Hililienn. (18'M) ;{ Ch. .".82 In such ptani'<<. Ii may be u.s<>ful here (o refer tJi what wa- said by S(irlin(7.-(7 V (hine.1t' I'nrjwnttrni. IJmiled. 8(i L. T. .'t.jl (ISO'.n III the (irst place, 'said the learned jiidye. I have to ' oiisider what iiMMninL.' is t■ t. m I'KKI.IMINAKY NOTK^. rC^llAP. I. III.' ..Iloti, r iii.n III' .111 mil |il.ii|i<' "I' ill! .■]i|iliriilinii l.ii! .il it-cir ,tTi alloliiH'iil ilo.'- mil n.'i-<-- ilv .iviii.- ill.' -I >:ii-- "i iiK iiilii'i^liii. Til.' ,ill^>lHh>iil iiiiiy 1m'. an. I I'm -liair- \<\ il. .ill.illi'i' .I..I..II.U :: 111 i.illv l> I nlii'l'c II i~ .111 .11. T'. '-II. Il ii-* t.. 'jivi (ill' Ik IIiI' -IllIK' lll'illK'Hl till' all. .11. iiiiiiiiiiiii. a l.-< I II. a .'.'J) 1,..-.' ,liri'.'t..i- make th<' alLilinciii : luit ii IK' ihal III.' all.ilmiMil iiia\ !"• !«ill>.i a i ..ii-lilion, a-. I(«. thai l!ii. allolK'.' ^ll"llliii|iain . >\ .1' <'\aiii| an..'. I. Ill |..'il'.iiiii .-'in.' oMiiT a.l. -n. Ii a» |.:niiii III .if a ■ inn "I liarc-. Ill III ..th.'.' u.iiiN. I iliiiil lliai < .'..iiiiuin ma\ ..ll'-r -|m.. ili..| Ihal iIh' lill<< .>(■ A. If. -Iiimid n..l an-.' A. n .'II iIk' ii'i II iMilil 111' liiiil jiai.l a -Hill ..I' iii'.ii.'\ I" ll"' .'aiiy. am I ilii« iM'iii'j a . i.iilia.'l liiav |.|..\ I i.lili. I.- a- I iliiiik. lli.il all..tia"iii -liall Im- -iil.j.'. i wlii.'li 1.1- 'I'll aiiv ll'. U.ll I 1— II.' I- "IK' \.'\ .1. tiiiili' li"_'al iiiii'iirl <■• iili i. Ii'i. ii"' I" -liaii'« I! :l: lal-.' i-,|il .,1. ;||i' l.'lll. .llliiillli'Ill ill ill' l'"l|ii.\ iii'.' pa'.:.'.- III. all- alli'tiiii nl in i.'-|i.iii-i' ,|i|ili. .iii'iii lli:.i i- \.< ~:\\ . I!ii' a. . iilaii. I l.v l! n' 1 .11111.111% I'-. I f,<./,. Ill .'\.il.i|' ,1 i|,,. -Il I.,.'. .1,1. 'I - lii-t . ..iiiiiiiini' ali.iii "1.1. ll.' ... (.1,111. , .111.1 1...I .11. ".l.T. - '■■ '.'./"•ll' I •<• .1 ( 1, I.-.:, .111.1 |..ii.' H. (/'.„, ■■, .,,.,.'. , i;t'iH •J I ll i;7l T.I 1 ili'iii\' .III. iiii>lili..n. iiiii-i ll. I'liiii |.-. ('I'laii.-.' an. I i- i.i Im i ll ll It ml . i')i'.ii 'I .111 .i|i|>li. ■" i.i'liii .'■> a II. .v l.'i 111 1 1 .11 I'll -li.ni'- iiiil-l 1 ..w - lii.il iIh' -liaii ii. .' nil li'i )H'i..i \\ ..!' l'..!'!. i:i II l- 11"! I, I 1- .1 iii".^ !,v ll II' . <.iii|iaii V.I, nil «ill ii.'l I.' nil i mnt ni,'. ■-. a. ' ••iH'- I I'V 'in' .i!i,.li. ini /.,■•. /V /.../■ I'l l{<;l,i,'..„ ,ni,i Miit.ii.i ( II . ' I'.'ii" - I !i ■■'- Itui ll,< ml.' Ill /.'.,/n/ lir.li.'.h Itiiiik V. 'I,ir.,-"ii'l- """'• 1' 7''' » '^ -..III. !ili:. - M'liil.'I- an ,il|..|lii HI l.v an iiii '.'ulal' I...11I rlli'ilivp. .nil th. ml.' 1- ii..» .-ii|.|il.'iinMii.'.l 1'^ M..t 71 -.1 111.' A.l .'I I'.ilS. |.i'i.vi I- iiiu llai nit-xil a .liic. 1..1 .n ni..ii.j.'i i...li I •' ».ili'l iiot.viiliil.ui.liiitr a«n I.i-.' III. II iiiav i»lli'i»ai-.li l.i' Iim..w'|.| in In- .i|'|) "iiiiiiK'iil ..r ..»tall(i. .Ill ,1. M"-' 'i'i|i'i' ■ 'ilti'l''' ...liMl.l .1 -llllil.ll- I'l"- Msl'ii t.ir .miii'j .jrli'.l.- I 11 ir'jiilarilii-: ...ill lal.l- A. \i'l '.M All , I I ■„. In .1 l"'.ii'l 111. .'111. nK ■■ iii-liliii.'.| iii.iy '.I.- -ll.-.' ;ii"iiil' lalili,.! Iiv .1 i.".:il!.ii l....i'l r.rhninrHr 1 u,,^uli,l.iU;i I ,,llfi-. I- 1 ll |i,ii \ .111,.. 1,11 «li.. h.i- I .iii.il III an alluuiH'iil III liiiii-cll' uill |(t< .•-»..|.i.i'.l Ir.'iii .illi'.'in- ill.' iii\.ili'.lu> "I iln' .illnliii.'iii ><"' Trill, ".('"/« ' ■' > 11 ''.'■"•■'* ' !''«- » Q '* '* ''**■'' I NoricK «iK ai,i,()tmi-;nt. 'jl When first Allotment may be made. Ill liic i.i-i' '.I a |iri\uli' i (iia|>:iiiv ullDtiiifiil liiii\ In- luii.lc iiiimi'- R'»tii>tiiiii» li.ili'h ilKrl >''ul~l>,ltliill ol till' iiilil|iaiiy III' ill ini\ >lll)~i'i|llrlil lllilr ,,||,riiltl iilliiliiiiMil is liy ^iTi, M'l III ilii' Alt |iii^l- I'lilili'-. jnhi'il llll ll'llllill Ml||i|ilill||~ ,111' l'i>lll|llil'll willl jr. llll' . MllljiaiU . >!•' .^iii'iii. p '.• (7 ><■■/. M.iin.vi''. Ii\ M'l t . hii i ic|)liii iiiy -ci I . .'i iil llir ( iiiii|i mil"- A'l. KlL.tnf I'.'iiii r !> |.i.nii|i'| ili.ti iill alliilliiciil iiiiiiji' Ipv ,1 1 i'iii|piiii;, 111 nil inlfi'i'iilll^ i||.|ii,ii.: Ill I i.iili JM'iiliiiii 111 llir la~i ri.ii'i^iiiii;,; -iMliun ~liall lii' V i i,.Mi' .1' ill!' ii;-'..ii I llll' ii|i|ilii ,11,1 vvilliiii 1.111' iiiiMi:li ,illr|- llir !i.lli::..'l ..,.' -l,i;ii .11 V iiii'('liii'.i «////((. |i. llMII n! llll' !■ iiii|i,iii\ airl :; ri i iii'i , ami ■liall i"' >ii \ Mii|,ili'i' iin'w illisi,iiii|iiii: lli.r llii' i iiiii|i,iii\ i- .11 1 mil- ■ I'l' l';'iii'_ \Miiliiil U|i. Si'i- al»ii >((/./((. |.j>. Ill, 17 Notice of Allotment. I liui.k. .11.1 I..M.I t.iiMi.- ill I'tll, ill's iiifi. \. \{ -2 I 1, .iJ7. I. .<■ uliM' ,11, iii.!i 1 I liial a|!|ili;'~ I.m .-li.ijcs in .i . iiiii|i.i n \ . ihi'ic i.. .!.■.: ii'i i.i.ii..ii|.i!i |.. li'l liiiii liaM' iiii\, llirii' iiiiinI 1«' a ii'-pmi-o '•» !l iii| .iii\ . ollii'i wi--.' llii'H' i- 1 llll a.! ■ ; an.! llii- v|,iii.|ii(int •I '■'' !•'" Ii-i ■ alw.iv- l.r.'ii a.i i'|::i',|. Tlii. i ..iniiiiiiii; aii il llu' ■ 'I '.111 1 :i.i .l ii..l iir.r-vii.h 1.1' 111 iiiai i.r in <\ • ' iii^-. Iml i! um-i ' . 'laii i..ii .1 ill -niiii- w.iv. ulirliM li\ \\:i iiiu .11 '.I'l li.ilK . ,,: ■^ ...ii'.'.i, (.'iiii'." 'iMc. !,, If .S ( h. HI. I'liniii i,i,i:\ ii'iliit' 111' :! .iiH'i. 1.111-' 1.1. ^i\,'ii t.i ill.. a|i|iliaiil ur ;ii lii- .i.ji.ni i|iil\ aiilli.i- ^■•'.l t.i I' •••\'' II.. i r alli.'liii'iil ./.(■.■•(/,('.-.■ (,1-c, "p ( \i !h;I; / i, !•''•-' '•■ '" ' -I 1. '1", In ; I'll .111 a'.;''iil In c/ ///// lo' ■■liaii'i li,i~ ii.i .i:i| Ih'.I .iiili:...i v ;.i ii'-.-JM' II. 111. |. 1,1' alliHiili'iM . I!ii'i,ii,.,,ii' ■: i.i^,-. II \. .••,;!ii: i: ,.//;.■■, „s,. I, I! | ci, .'.^.-i. „ i. Iiimi".!" A . Hi .,) |i|\ iiijr. t-:i\ -. ( iIm' iiii'ii |. Ill alli)lliii'iil 111 r. . ni.l ii'ilii. i- ..11 ._;.i..,. ill.)' i^ «iilli. ji'iii , /),. /I'ljw.-'s- ,,(>,' I |^S•.l , -Jl '• I '" -iii-i .1. l.ii. :iii .i|i(ilii .in; iii.i\ u.iivi' ii.i'i i .illuiini'iil ■III. II \ ( :il.i,l,r. .('■ f'li . . IH'.i:;, 1 {) I! -j-ii; liii-ii' .I'l. uHivr la-c- .lU.i 111 uliili im i i- nl' allii: iin'iii i> imi .ii\ 1.1 in:ii|i!i'.' ill). ...iiir.ni. , .i,, !• In ;| I !■, nl.lV I ll |l|..f lilt I, llll Ci, ,-,,l,|. III. rl.ijii, . ill Mil. 'Ill ,,1' ni -!...iii.^. Ill Ml: h li ,. ..; alliitiiii'iit iiiav imi " IHTI --aiy .r,'„„,, V ,.(.,• I. U S ( 'i |i) null...., iii,|,.i.|, ff... llviil;,.- .>|.,.«. tli.il ll n.f |. iii'i'iil.'l In Hivil. ,ij,j.||.ali.i||. II..' i'.i'|ii:iitii. II ,»//,.,,•■*• ,((>,.. 1 |',t(»ii :» « ll liTI . I|...\ ..'i-. ill am !-•• ill nlii.Ji 111.. ..inipun li\ I' ',•<■ »■• Kthi'iui-i.. )l,„-| ,iir,.; . I '"llll' I iiMiii|..i .i -hail'- Ilia |..'i ...1, ;iii,| lit' Hii i.- |,a. li a<'(i'|>»- aj ll :•• .. r , iii.ilif III. 'ill' 111 alliitni. ti i- iifti-.-u-i N.. I iff. if .'illiiinii'iii. b-i Hr pout. Proof of notiw |a#" j Mt I'KKhFMINAKY NOTKH. ri>lAl-. I. Alloliiienl will) «»Mi.<' ui- = . . ■«i|)oialp. iii r»'>|H>ii>^> to an iippli- ration Ixifow iiinii|.wiaiioii - -Midi- iciii \>' . •iistiditt) ■■> iMUiipletc li'-Htii«ii o|>ora»e» as a. foiitimiiiin: oH>|ilni>.* 1>v the rtnn|i«i.v tt(N>r incorpornlinii. A" I p«nrrttl ink', iiotiw "i ull"liiw*! inu.v Ih' u:iv*'ii In (■■i-'t . \. (irmmi 4 Ex. D. 2lti: llriithwii V Frnxri. i IHWi 2 ' h. 27 i. .iml in -iwt r«,-c tl«> ■ntimcl is • ninplctp whoii till' l«>lt«'r is ]M>«*«wl. i'M«ii lli(>«tc*i it J^ npvei rwn'ivO'l Ihtrrin- riiK,- 7 ( ii .".«7, lin.m, » U.mc- 2»» T L R I'Ji Hut th<' jnwli^ iiiu.st Im> iiMjriiliir. fitr haiKliiip: to a to»ui p«>»a»»u« in the .•M-rcet is- *et oMoiitfh. I.oiuhfu rf yorthern tbmk ^Vmm \ Vh 22it If iiotix- lit »H.>iiiMMii ! (li'*|«it«'«i th*- (>iiu» is (III the cvuniiauv tn jirove llic iioluf Iteidimlh • nine. 11 Ei) ««i). Iml this ..iiu- 'i may di.srhurire bv i>K«imr u«i« <« 'hf )iun (if the iilluirod iiu'iiili^r ir<)iu)f to show ihHl b»- ivu- avvurp •». the allotnwiil uiitl assented to ji iCrawle.if s <««• ■ IH«S , 1 ("It. :J2t for formal notif*' is not (i««!(>-**»r\ nichinis \ R„,m.is..,„,iiiK' A>m^Mitkm.l. n 'U I'. ISl Nolic*- of alloiiiifni. if lir.Hi;rhl home t.. itw i^ottee. iioi from Hw KiirifMtiv liul iiliiiuih: nill hind luni • Waili* ram:. I. H. 4 Ch ^Ut"'. III. (' '7 . if tliti alloti«'(' IS jiivsi-iit at a board m^^liutr m which t*t' iillotment is revilvi'd on /■> jHirlr SimetUe>l and FU'limi'i . W. N \M\~ > 2ri!i 111 I riiwU'ii'K iif" -'i s|iur<., "iia: v.'ore nui ullotu-d to him for foitrtecn months, ami ac'-"r(4»iiB:ly t»^ mii-iw. have refu»«'d the allotiwni '>ii ilw jrrouiul that w "« not mauf uoeiiii n reasoiMildf liiiic S< iic«' of the aliotnu-nt »»> ^iv(>ti i : Iihb. ini; some iii.iiiths iift«T«:ird«. I»f al »'t«- i('(|ilfsi "t B . siennd a MaikK irunsfer of tin- nhan>^. and that «as h(dd siithi-«Hi' to -iliow 'iial t^ iiiusi liavf kliowii of. and a— ented In. the aik>tiueut 1 fhuu after tliat a. i." said >elwvi,. 1. .1.. p .■!2!«. he laiiBW \>f lieani ti> Ml- ihiil Ik' did not know '>l iIh' aUotiiien! or iha' it iiad -tot t««-(Mi isiiiiiniinK'iiKMl to him .\ letter ol alloliiwut aiiti h«tter of iviiuniialioii <>i aiiy oilier d(H'ii- iiienl hiiMiii: the oHe-! of a letter of allotment of any rompaiiy had |p\ ihc Stiiiii|i All. IM'.ij, to li»> -tumped with a i«'iin\ stamp under a |ienalt\ on any person (•m'ciiIiiii'-. y:iaiiliiiu:. is>uin Kinaiice .Act, IKiHi iti2 i ti''i \ict • >»i. a duly of »>// is siihstitiiiid for the 1(/ dul\ when the iii>iiiiii:d amount wliicli is :illotted or to ^^lli(•h the letter of allotment lel-jle- i- not l(>«« lliiiii .W . and a separate duly i- iliai;;ed in re»|>ei I of leiieis of allolnient and reimiM iaiion allhoutrli eiltv leil in the same ilonmieilt .\ letter of allotment. tli"ii'.rh nil- .stamped. i> if jioskmI m di'liM'ted. an elfeiliM' an <'pl.iiire of the appliialioii Wliillrii I'liitinit. ''lit (' 1' ■!^17 KNTRY IN KWilSTKK. 53 Entry in Register. U licif iiiL'mboi>liip i^' loiisliiuK'd olherwiNe thuii by subscribinj? till' int'iiioriiiiiluni of u8!iiib(l uiiIcsm uiid iiiiul ii laii be prcditalod of lh<' pi'isoii lliat ho is. wiihiii the words .,i llii' -^'cliiiii. Olio ' who bus ujiit'od to U'coiiio a iiiuiiibui of u r'iiii|iimv under this Ad. and wlioso imino is onluti'd in (he register." Ill tin- respect llii'ic is an I'^sonlia! dilli'ii'iue Im'Iwim'ii the ivrpii- -iir- III iiicfuU'rsliip as K'gards persons who mi1)si lilio the nieiiio- lainliiiii. and llio.se who otiieiwise aj^ioe lo l)OroiiK< ini-nibois. The Iniiiiii. a- we liiive seen (p. 4(i i, lK! n-irisier .rl iMtMnlK'rs; llic latler do not Iwv oin cniliors nnlil airieeiiiont pUis I'nii V m I lie H'y:i.-.|o;'. This disiiiKiion is < learlv in oij^ni/ed in A ii nls a(.v, J'.l ('. I) 421. Tliei ■ A had aK"'e hull. Ion iii- iiaiue had not been entered in the letfistei Alter soiiu' vears, the itJiieeiiKMil to'.- ineinlH'r^hip not liuviiiii: iieen afted nn. a \vindini;-«tf> order was made, and it was »>ii!rlii lo pluro A >- rti'Oim... jtatl limMi lakeii. I<> reiidet the ini'inlxi -liip i ninpleie ; ami lionnii. 1. -I . -»iid. il appeal^ to me that .\ never iiipiireil tin' -luiii- "I .1 ineiiilier of the roiii|iaii\ . I llilhk lliiit Jie <lt i^nv of a -liaii'liiiliifi on lln' i'e;j;is|t'r a i midition prei-wleiii lo iiieiiili»- shtp ' N •■ 'loiibl. where iln-ie is .m a^reenienl to take -liaies. htil Im ohiM III the leirisler. either parly may lie enlilied to riaim .iiul in-i-i oil -)i.iilii' |H'i lorinaiii'<' of the a^reeiiKMii i sts' p. .')7 ; Init ihut einuin- .stiiii'i' .1- till' ah'vi' 1 a-^> 1 h'arK shows, is not e* na:MMiNAKv .\oti>. L<"ii.\i'. I. Niii i- llic iiilv. lliiil riiliv ill llii- it'ui^ti'i i> jif(i'->iiiv to i -liiiilis till' Matii- 111 iih'iiiIh i-lii|i. in aiiv Wii\ iii x.uiuin^' uiili tlic ml"' m- i MllliiiLT till' li'l '1 I 'iiiliiliiMi'iic-' ill vMiiiliim-ui). iiaiiii'lv. Ihal ii [ici^u wliii liii-* ii;ii<'< il III lii'iiiiiK' II iikmiiIh'I'. and nlin^- iiaiiir i-- mil. lull Ifllil 111 In'. III! llir [\'< i- 111 1m' imliiclcil ill -mil li«l. Im' in t iiiiliii;:-ii| llii' ( null h. lull iwir tn ii'ililx llir rc'ri'l''!' I'l IIKMIIIh'I- ■ -I'l I- :.', Iti;i (il till' .\ii ; lull I'M'ii in ciiiiiiiliiilniv ill' ( I will n.i' cM'ii i-i' llii« [inwi'i iiiili~- llii' ii'j-ri'cnii'iil ii'lii'il mi 1- line wliii II. al llic i iimiin'iirctiKMii ul llii' wimliiiLr-ii|i. ilir iiiiii|i;iii\ i.ivr -|M H'l'ilH allv cnriiiri'i AiiidI s •ii»r. -Ill < . I > Wlull^lul niiioVHl fr.-n r")£i-t iiin-l al-u lie ili-l iii:;iii-lii'l liuni lliu-v in uliiili a |ici.-iih wliii lia- .ni|iilrcil tin' lull >lalii- iil iii<>tnlM>l'>lii|i i- allinvaiij- \M(iii};lull\ U'liiiiM-il riiiiii lilt' ic;ii>lt'i. a-, loi ('Vanillic, in mii^i- ijilfiiit' (il a Idi;;!'.! liaii-lfl' liaviii'j Ikm'ii [ikim-iI. In ^ui li a i a-i' iIh' |it>r-(i|i KMiiaili'- a iiu'IiiIh-i , lit' lia- ai i|iiiri'il llii' lull -talii-. ami tin- tMllll'.'lllI It'Mliixal III- tiani" iliK /. ,1 .\ II /.'<(,/ - mil alli'i I III- iiitMi 21 (,• l; l» 77. liiih lln'l-ll 1, II lia- Ik'i'Ii lit'lil llial hIicH' -li.iii'- air .iMulli'il -iili|i'il lltirliiii \ i) I! i) MlllCiiM'l , I !u .1 rnmliiiiin. ami llit> naiiH' nl lln- all'iilcf i- I'lilfii'il in lln' i('L;i-li'i willi wiiiil- i'\|iii— 1\ r.'li'uintr In 'In' i miililiiiii. Ii"' Ini- mil tililaiiu;il llic ( .i|ii|iU'M' -iaiii- 111 a iiK'nilii'i. >/i/7:(7 \. I Imirxf I ni jidiiiIioh I'.MIli:. Hii 1,. '[' ."17 l'ii'|'i'il\ . hi- iiaiiii' tiiiulil mil in Iw 'iii llii' it'l^i-K'i Tlif nii'ii' I'lil 1 V 111 a |ii'i-ni;- iiaini' iin llii' ii':;i-ti'i' caniini. iif c Iii- ii:;lu 111 ic|iail;ai lull jiriiiii|illv il lie lint— nnl lie will 11.' Iiiiuml. (/ jiiilinii il iicjiini -' liirlil- lia\c iiiltl- \oiici| li\ a u imliii^;-ii|i Itiii/li's m.-i. i'l.'i \\ . |{ li"; ( iniili-ij * ci.sc. M II. ■',•>:',. lhil:i^\ I'liniii.tinl. I. I{ 1' II 1. ;12'i Conditional Applications. CiiiHliiiiiiiiil SiiiiicMinc- an applii alinn Ini -liaic- i- iiiailc -iiliici 1 In a i nniliinni •iiiplit uticii- , . . ,1 . 1.. -11 |ii'ici|cnl. r. itllnlici'. I'm- ivIiiti- tliiTC I- .1 I iinililioiiHi ii|>|>li< iilimi loi "liari'- iiiiil an iiii< iniililiniial allnltiu'iii iliii'' i- i\" I'lic ((iii^ciil atiil llicrt'l'iiic iMi riiiiirail ; I li (i.!;i. WDimI's iiist'. :', \h' (1. iV .J. 8.">: Slimrx lai-r. .'U I.. T.7I.">. II r.,../ < i.;vc. la Ki| l!"ili. 'I'Im- ciiiiililiori li<'i'il mil lie ( niitiiiiH'il in ihr icllcf 'if a|i|ilii aiiini. Ii i< Milli( lent if tin' IcItiT iimtailiiiiy- llir . rliiii.ii r('a( li iIh' iliiT'liii- Im'Ihic allnliiu'til Itiiiieix' nisi'. Hill- i,-.:,iis (loc. siiiiiii. lint ill siicli laM'-i if, allcr iiolic*' of iillnlniciil .ml ii'iri-ilialiiiii licfmi' tin- I'omlilioii is t oiiiplii^l willi, tJu' alicillci' il,-! nil- iKiMi rt'|iiiilialiiit;. In* uill 1k" laUi'ii to liavc waivi'd lln ,.,h.liU(.ii ami 111' liuiiml i\\'l,,uilrii,fl s ,,;.v.". •.".• L. T. .TJI'. iiiilc» ilii .iiliA III till' i<"^i-Ii'i i<'t>\|>ifs>ii'cl III 111" Mihjcit 1<> llii' (iiiiilili'iii >i,il:,-l \. (liiiii'Kf I 1)1 iiiiiiiliini. HO I, T. .117. J!' iliis naiiii'i liiiii lliiit' i-- a vi'iv iiiaKM'iiil ili-liiirlioii lu'tuccii an i|i|'liialiii|i willi il iMiiiilitiiiii |iicik'iIi'iiI aiiiicxt'il. uikI an ii|)|ili("iliMii Hiiii I lollalcial ajri<'<'Micnl ur a rnmlilinii -.nlisciiiii'iit . In the litlci !-■ ilii' aiiplicitiil on alliiliiK'iil Im'cihim's a .slmreliohlci' in jirr~,'iiti .ili-.iliil(l\ . willi (inly II ri;j-lil In cnlino' i if valid) IIk" i ollaKTal a::ii'<'- iHiil iir cdii'liiiiin stili-iviiK'nl a'^ainst llic coiiiiiuiin . I!l!,iii(il(iii'.s ///>■< INiir I. I, li. 2 ( 11. ."ill; Fisliir'x ia: in arii'iil tin' ^aiii" in am li'-- iiiiililH'r \^\^, .),„r«.^ iliii! iii.i\ 111' allolli'd In liiii'. Ill n'spoiisc til llii- a|i|iliraii'in. (lii- 'III' . Inl.~ Il .nUt' llial a -|iri ilil'd nilllllll'r nf ■^llali'- \»' allnltid in llilll. ni'l until I' nf ..lull allntiiii'iit i< ;;iv<'ii In llilll. 'Ilii^ i nil- I itiiln- llli I'^iiiiiii'iii and his iiaiiu' >li mid 111 niin' In' I'lili'ii'd nii ilii' rn'^'i-lcr. I' Tlir I nm|iain allnl« ni . illi'is I.. .\ . a .s|M'i iliml niinilirr nf >lmii's 111' I A . iinlila's in tia' rnni|)aiiv his ai i i'|il:im <' nf the .sliair- -.n ml^'i'd Tlir api.'i'iiH'nl i.s cniiiiilrli'. and .\ . .diniiM Im I'lili'ii'd in llii' ii'i:i-.('r. .\ anilinri/c.s siiiii' a'jTiil In a|i|il\ fnt shall'- nn his lii'li.df, ami -II 11 a;;i'nl a|i|.Iii - a-nidinvlv Tlir .sli.iii'> arc allntlnl l.i .\ . and II. line is iriM'ii In llilll a- alinM'. and In i- diilv rciri-liicd lie is a ■tltiulicl d> I' willn lit aiilliniilv a|i|ilic.s fur .-huic- nii licli-ilf nf .V . and •III ilucclnr.s allnl ^llll!1•s In A . iilid ic^M-tor llilll Snli-cijiii'iiilv \ I. llilll- I'. '- ait, ( .(/ . rillu'i' i'\|irivss|v, ni- liy dninn- .snn.olliiiiir 1 1' '/ . -il;iiiu.; a liaiisfn . m lakiic.' a dii idcnd • w lii'li -Imws Hi a I he i-scni- • ilic alliitniciit .\ is a nit-inlii'i 1' A Ill-ill^; ih'' fmldci nf .shall-. tr,.iis|i'i- iliciii l.\ an in.suniiiciit ■'iii|iUiac uiih till ifi.;uhitiiin.s nf lli«' i niii|iain In I! . r. lake- the M 111- III- In the < niiipam . and the roin|iaii\ |iass(- il and jilace- I! nii f ■i i r*:'. t1 «ri(or:iii(ili of llii- coiniiuny, ho i« to he lU'i'wid !•• Iiuvi" iiifn-iii lo liikf llio Klmirs from the coniiwiiy, iind is (o !«• ivj;iMl«Ti'H not lake up tho slwnw williin tlir Mionlh, mid hhuitly iirt».'iwiinl> h<- i», hy iho ollkisrM of Iho i-onipan\, plicwl on ihi' it')j;irili'r as tin- lioldcr of such .ihunvi II<' lluMvli\ if i..im* II iniMhlx-r in rcspcl of -inh .-hiinss. Hv iiiMi'plin'r Ihf 'illiic li.' i.- iT in cllfct iiirni-ins; to lo'niply «ith llu- iirtuUw. anil l>\ pliK inu liini on iln' n"_''i-''<'i- lli" rouipuny uict'ptu liis ollVr; and pp. 71H, "lit, iniia. ■ri A. i> >hi!> a) im.uiUhI a .lin-ior Tli" arii( Uw slati' (hal lli« <(ualili>alioii ui' a c iiicuitiiT 111 H'.>*p('(l of llif hhaii's Ihii^ [.•j;i.-.td as .1 rioiiilHT in A., wlio liu» not upplird for sliui'<--, is iiifoiiiKsl that ln' lia- licfii ifiristfiiHl as II li..ldt'r of a -jKiiitiiHl number of sjiai-os m .1 .oiii|iaiiv. Ill) si>;na u proxy paper iu i('s|M'rt of such share*. >•. .ithciui.M'. in etlei •, act.* a.-< the 'mncr irf Mirh -hares. He is estopp" i iiuiu deiiviiijr tiial he is the holder ol siiih sjian . ('niirli-if's '• tin '-onipuny i.s lomplotc. The i-atM's under the la- 1 t«o laiids eoine (o this: that a ]ier~oii 1^ 1 - he i-»'j.'aii'ei,.eiit. or if he is e-top|K-d fnini »hnyin|; lh:i> he is i-i'^i-- teied -,\itlioiit KUiM'iil. Me may Hot luueappl'ed tlie share, nia hu\e Ih-<'ii plaied tliei-<' without his eoiL-eiit and eoiitjary to his wi -he- hut if le a— ^'iits to his name Ihmisi- on the n-^fister, he i^ to I,. 'tiusidered tt meiiilKT of llf i-oinpaiiy. CX)NTIUCTH TO TAKK »HAKt>. 47 M,.|v ,1111 V ol u pfiwrn s null II IIk- <(iiii|iiiiiy « u'j;i-U'i. h«>wv\.>r rtiiliuut u^rrn'Miont or iu««cnl, )» not .Mionirli. Tims if ii iini<> for Uikiiij,' up lii-* (|uulilicuti..n -liait>s liu- ,.\p?iv,l, ami tlu- roiniKiiiy ha.-, notwitlw»»iiiit, iw lh« lioKlor of ihf .|Ui»liliculioii .ii,iit's!"ho iimv i.aiiM'l tlii> itiiiipuiiv to tukK his iiiiuw oil ih<' iv^ri-i. r ,v,/,W.»<'/-./«»Vs* am; (IH'Jl) .'« Ch. ;i5»i. So, too, if a m.in .- iiaiiic i- ,,ui on tlif ivtriMtt>r upon lh<- appliiutiois of soiiio iwrson piofi'ssiii-,' 10 ,1. 1 11.1 1, is asieiil l.ul ttilhoiil any authority in fu.l, liio .ionipuiiy cmi. I „iiipt'll«Ml to lake llio naiiM' otf. Ornu-rodH rase, ^ 1H«J4 i 2 < 'h. 17.". t(r. ii^'aiii, «ln'i-o a iimii i*|.pli.'.H lor >hiiivs, Iml witlulraHS hi.s applua- u.„i Ul».i>' awt-ptuuw, and the conipany allot** iifvcrthfliws aixl put.- hi, iiaiiH- on the rritistcr, he may ha%.' it tak<'ii oil llrhhS ,.,.«'. 1 i:.|. !i; Tniiiian'i rwu; (IKiHi ;l t'h. 272. A pfisoii iiiipioiM-rly rftristfif'Jl. V.« to ii'MiiidiiiK 111.' a>;r«oniont, «<■(■ Injru, p. \'M- Th.' alioM' arc all < a-f.s of pcixms s,ii juri^ In Ihf la-c of p CU .■»I2: i.ij.frrs uis.'. ••! t'h. t.-.H: Vrnhni.l Ciisoh. .".H I-. T !»22: Sifimins' „•-.•. .". til. 2'JH. Til"' inlaiil •■ii .oinmu ..I'.il'C may aiiiml tin' i-<'iilra«'t. In; !.■■ iiiiisl I'lt'it promptly . .-hair is not. Ilri ihii/i'ii Specific Feriormancf I'lic Coiiii has jiiii.sdi.tioM to s(M'(ilirally cnforw a rontiait liy a spwiiii per- l« i~..ii to lake, or l.y ; roiiipaiiy to iillot, sliaros i An.- liniiKirirk Ci>. ','.'™^'7,,','' V Mii,i>i, riiliie. I Dr iV ■''m ■!''•!; Oiii-iiliil liihiiiil Stiuitii To. v. talif »hun.«. /(,,<,, ,v .IHtlli. .11 L. .1. t h. •HI: Oilfxsa T' iniirniis (7.Hi. ,H t h 1). 2.'l.'i'; liiit if hcforc arlioii hrou^'ht all the .slian** \ui\'- Ik vii .illoii;vl to olhcv iH-isoiis. the only ii'mody of a plaintiff ilaiiiiiii- an iilloti.icnt i.s an ulioii for diMiiau-c.s loi- liifat h of i-oiilnu't. h\,uisi„i v. II -/«oH tlK(,:>i. 2 < h. V". \ roiupany may, liy dfluy, h-. iiiiili' iiM'h In t iiiiin ' an ajiP't'inent . .V/co/t '<(<<•. 2'.» Ch. I) 121. Causi-r oi M I > Im' a iiit'iiiiN-r of a I oiii'ii.iiu Owpi of ,1 l;\ tiiii.fcrnnsr hi'*..'taMs toanotli.'i pori ii. .ii sui-li 'jim', ' ihc iNiiLsfcidr (■CMi.sefi to l.e a hk iiiU'r si; soon ;i.s. Iml not, lilt r.'. the itanofi'io- is i«'i;ish.|( d ; hut tlio transferor iw Mill li.ihle to Ih' placed on the ii list of ct)iilrihutany i.s uoiiiul up within a year. SUnihufn's <■, «> K.|. .'-.. I t'h Ifil: lltiUun'x ■«■•«• ni ii 5H l.iabilitt I'll "hiirMi. I'KKI.IMINAIIY Norr,S. t MAI". I. I I \i\ lii> -hiiruii\ iiiidir m'Mii' (umi. .-•ioii ill ii- iii'lii'li'-. 1 (■ i in liis ]i|:ii-<' lU ili'iilli: lull in -iiili it .' iln' iIoici-'mI lucnilHT ^ i-iaii' rciiiaiiis liiil)l" until tlii> n^'i-lratioii i>l Miiiir |h'i-i>ii fiilitiol iimliT II tiaii.'- trotorf llfininl v. Wlifnthfi. -^ l>'' «• M 'V- «' *'>'i^ lUiirii !< (iinr. ."> ( li. 7-'i. I .■> Hv II .HiiiK'iiilor ifi the rtiii' i ii-i-i wlii'if a siiiri'iiilrr i" Miliil Tli-it)i \. Whihnirth. 11! Ajili. ( ii« lO'.i III I'.v llu' llii«lcf ill Icniki iiplrv uI iiii iii-^'ilM-iil 'mpiuImm ili«- < laiiuiiiK lii-i >liar('-, Sim' Maiikni|!< y Art. IKSM. « .'..".; HaiiliMi|.|( \ All. IH'.H). (■ 71. V |:! 1 7. ' l!\ ic^i i^'i'iii (li till' 1 iiiiiiai ' I'l iiiiviili' r-lii|i mi llic ;.^|iiiiiii| "I liii>i-"|.ri-<'iiMliii,i 'pii. 111.'!. I'.l'.lMir lili>t:ikr ' p. 2IMI 'Illi.-. Iiiiwrvi 1. ill"'- hill a|i|il\ In sli iH'- 'iili^rlilii'l I'l ■ ill llir iiii'iiiiiiaiiiliiii III .i^-iii ialii'ii. /.(«. 1 ell 707 iM \\\ iiMii'lip;.' ^^ I I'iii llic ^latiil'ify lU'viucI iii allnliiu'iil a- iiia (Mitimi nl ki'i '. X.'i nt' llu- .\i i Sn' ."I'l'l. ."i. .vij/;r«. [I IN. Liability to Pay for Shares. Till' l.t 111- 111 ill" .\' • "i I'.MIM ll'|i|,|i illjr til ,1 ih' .\. I lit I ■ III till' rii-i' lit II i'iilil|);lliv lillli'l'.j liy -liaK'-. allil ill |i:t: lii'lllar till' |lli>- \i-iiiii' lit M'rl-. "J .1 I'l Ij;!. Ic.iv.' nil li'iiilit iiImui! tir <)lili;;ali'iii nt ■>liaii>liii|ili't» til |)iiy In till' iiiiii|i,iii\ tlir full aiiiniiiil nl' 'lirif 'lian-- Tlic wniiK III .■MM t 2. liiiiiuii'/ llu- liiiliiiiu 111' Mii'iiil't'is til ■ tin- uiiiiiiini uii|>aii| nil tlii'ii' -liaii'-. ' can iiiilv mean, a^ l.niil .M.n na<:lil*Mi |iiiiiil('il (Jill III till' tliiii'iiniii riisf. iH'.fJi .\ . ('. II'.. that ill!" lialiilil\ nf llii' iiumiiIht iniiliiiiir- >ii Inii^ a~ aiiviiiinii ri'iiiaiii-- iiii|i.iiil mi lii~ >liaii'- Niilliiii^ Im; |iayiiiiMit. ami iia>iiii'iit in lull, i ini put an I'ml In tin- linliility .\ll llir ji'iri-latiirii ' said lii> l,i)nl-lii|i. ' |iiiin'ciU mi till' I'lMilini: I'l ii'in'jni/iiii.' ami iii.iintainiiiu ili<^ liiliililv nt llic inili- viiliial iiiriiiliri tn t':)' rmiipaiix iiiilil tlic pro^i i ilM' |>iliil-lip •<'il tlic nii'iiiminiluiii for linil •'lniro«. I lAltll.llV \<> I'AY fltU SIIAIfl.-. .*>it 1 |i.iiiii „„| |,y (ho tiiii-l<- i' «■!' inoviili«l tluil iIkm' -liiiiv- ^Im.uI.I !.■■ ,j,,,,i„.ii u< U' liill\ (Kii.t ii|.. II lH'iii'_' ol.\i..ii>lv iiit.'ii.U'.l lliul llii-x .|„Mil.l U' I'li'l ii|' I'V "lakiuy: .n.i llic i..llifi\ n. llif ..>iii|uiin. ami |i, , illlfIA »ll- ill I I' I >llli»'illlfllll> lll:l'lt< "\<'l I" IIk' i<'III|1UII\. il ,. lii'M ili.ii ill'' »lii«i<'- "<'U' |i.iiil-iiii ^liiin-. Ill iliiil iii'«'. liilliii.1. I .1 alliM n'K'iiiii;; l" ll"' pinvi-iiii-' nt the Ai I. >u'u\ lluil : Tukiiiy ,l„ .,■ M, linii^ tifji'lliir. 11 jM-i-im wlui MiliM lilM-. ihc uHMin.iaiMllI I ,,-.„iiiliun i^ I.. 1m« lu'lil I- liiiv" iij:i<'<'.| I.) U- li .|iuivliol,|..|- lur tlir |„.i ,,( hIihio- ill ii'~|W'it 1.1 wlii< Il lit- «iil.M liU- il lu Mkf lIuMii r..| In |i;iv I |>i.>|><'i -iiiM.itii.n Inr tlinii Tlni" i- im.i :iin ,u,..piMM.iii V UiWiiMi .1 inciiit.iitiiiliiiii whiili i- yicm-rul in it-* UTiii". ,,„| aiMi I.- wliidi Niiil.' iIkiI il.c ii.iviiMMit It.i «li.in'< i> I" Ih- made in iiliii «:i.v aiMoliJiii'; 1" llu' K'llii- "I a ...iitia. I ii-l.TM-d I" m ll"' , Il, I .CI- ihal |ia\ nii'iii in kiii-l .i. mnliiii; lu a >iil>-<"|ii<'iil I,;„i wi:li llic ((pMi|'iii\ i- iiiii.ii-i-H'iit wi'li -mli a iii<'iii-.iainiiiiii II ill. I." !"■ a iuiii:i. I 111 -iirli H iiaiiiK llial mi l-ill liicil l.\ llif ii>m- j,!ii' 11 (^.iilil iMPi lie >■ t a-i'li'. u |iiiyiiiiMil 111 »liai->-^ in kind aii'niliiii; ll,.ii iMi.ira. 1 i> li'-ai . Tin- n-t to In' a|.|>lip. iPii llif iniilfiin'. tliul llu- pipiiijiaiiv iliaily < mild iid II uii- inircd llial the )iarli<'< only airn-cil with iIiciii««'Im'^. and thai h,. I. lure llii'pi' «a- nil ..pnliad. liiil "V.'in pi.iii|.an\ i- «iarii'd li\ ,..1111-^ auti'p'iiii; .iiiiipii- iIhiiim'Im-. ami ii i~ idl" i" -ay ilial lli<'\ lia\c iiiilinh |M ajifi' rtilll Si'i' al-pi I hiliiniiiiinl 'i i :.tr . 1 ( Il "7;;. and /'<■//• t li. II In /,r<'/.<- .ow ■ l«7l l I I r'..| Mil. Sliia.i. \ -• . .|ni'^ii..m'.| liii'x' .If i-i an.l •■\|.h'-m'iI llir ,,|.ii I liial lla'ic u.i~ n.itliin;r in ill'' »lalnt.' ..I lrtli:i I" ■ ..niiicn.in.i' il,.. III. II I iiiivihiii'^ I'lll ni..n<'V lii'inir a ^ai i-laill'.n ..I tin- liinili-.l lial.iliu iii.lc.'d.' >iid III" Iviimi'.l jii.i-.- llii' iin.in'v ilm' m i,-|c.t ..I lali- ni.i.n -liai"'- i> l.y the MalilU' niadc a s|m.. iall\ .i.'l.l i.iciil a- ihi' all laliipn ipI lh<' law .'I' iiiiili.i. I i« wlii- li iIk' -^lalnlc lia- iii.i.l.'. iIk' ia. ili'\ I'll faii.l u.'iild 1.1' iiit.'li'ialp|«' il' Ipv .h\\ au'ii'i'ini'iil iliii.ii;;-! i1iciii-i'Im'~ I III Ill' I . 1 .11 Id li" di'jiliM'd f. t lii» llliiili'il i.;lil. and 1. 1 lie ali> "'lit.' li^'' ■ t.i lln' liinilod am. .mil <.l iiiinirx i)'ilal All iivii'i'iiKMil aiiiinijr-; llic »liaii'li..l>li'i-- l" ■ ..nliil.iili' lli.'ii ■ ,i|iial 11"! ill niiiiiiN 1. 11' ill iiin r.iniiinidiiy . «ill lili'iimi ul \alii(' l.iil the airn'iMiiciit ul lln- Nlia!'-lup|di'i>. wniild lliakr (In- miI'- -.lilnd i.i|iilnl a iiH I' dclii-i.Pii " HiH altlimi^'li tin- .In i-ii>ii of tin- \ -I Ul- alliiini i 111 a|.|iral ' li t'li. »i>!t i. lii< opinion on llii" point >.as «'\lra-iiiilit iai. ami il i-* ii. i:|iposiii(.ii ( . a loiiu >.|.iii'> of miI.^.' iiu'iil dci i^ioii*. iii.liidiiitr di'i i^iopi- of tin' lloii><' 'it l.oid-: ami ■ ■il" ai:|«'al from llic \ -( i •'. (1. I'i'i'. laau'-. I. I ^aid In' did i I'l tti-li to l.c .•.iii-idcrcd ,1- 1 MH 111 liii.^- in all lliai tin' \ -• lia.l ■li.l Si'.' liiiilii'i iiifr". p «." Tl (HTaMoii. Ii..«('\ 'I . .'I llii' A. ' <.t IHilJ Ha- ini.'lili.'.l l.\ -i'. l li'i i ill"- ( liiniianii- A.l. IMI'.T lU tlial ci; |. tnn'iil llii' l.i"ji-l ilnir WP (iO PKK.LIMINAKY NOTKS. [Chap. 1. i-' Value of (on- rtdpration for paid-up <«l)arofl anil Hct-off. As to eou- "ideratiun in kind. io>liktC(l ill" ])()wi"r to pay olliciwi^o tliaii in tiush bv j>iovi Ch- •!"!<>. The shareholder^' liability is limited even as leg-ards debts incurred ill a f.n-eigu country. lii.tdon v. Iniit lUhl l.ofoniotivr Wnrk.i, flOO.) - 1 K. I!. ;!04. Amount or Value of Consideration. It is well settled that under the Act ol lilOS, as under the earlier .Vits, shares (annul be issiu'il at a discount, that is to say. the liability in respect of a share can only be satisfied by payment or satisfaction nf the lull aiiiounl. and that an a;;ifeMi"iil by the company to accept in satisfaction a cash p.iymenl of le-s than the full amount is iillrii riii's. Oon-HKM ( n. \ . lt,>r<'r. ^IW2' A. ('. 12.'). That ca". was in force, but it \v:'- decided on the principle tiial the liability to pay the full aiiiouni is imiio^cd by the A ' ol 18i;2 (now 11)08): accordiMo:ly it is still a ^overniii^- deci-ion. Hence, to issue shares at a discount is illlni rirt'i oee the case last nieiitioiied, and Abtuidii 1: Wrlloii v Satlrrii. il8!)7i A. V. 2'.i'.t; Mo.yclrii v. KotU)loi04i 2 Ch. lOKi; and a foilloil lo issue bonii- shares is nlti-a rirr.^. Eildnsl'iiii- M,iniir hi.vir W H. 10 Xevertheles-. share- may be |>,ii(| tip in moiieyV wor>li. and theie need nol be evidence of an e\ai 1 eipiivaleni in value in the con- sideration. It was hold, manv year- siiKc, tiial wlieie shares have been issued as jtaid up. upon the foolinii' that .ertaiii specilied property shall In- accepted bv the company as the coii-iileiation fo;' such issue, the ( (iiirt will not. whilst the contra, t stand-, imiuire as to the value of the consideration, even at the instance of a litpiidator. Pcir.s i-nsf I ISOO), .■) Ch. 11 : ItiKihnt HiiU Co.. .1 Ch. .Uti. Ami see Oorrrinm Co. \. Uopfr, iihi siipia: Thriiliical Tnitt. ilS'.t.'n 1 Ch 771. ti.- AMOUNT on VALUK OK CONSIDKKATION. 61 I'cH'i' tiixi' was tiecidt'J iii 18ii!t I'oll had iifiicod In sell to a coiu- puny the froodwill and stock-iii-tnuh' of \\i-< Imsincss, in consideration of l,r)00 20/. shares in the company fully paid uj). In a windinp-np, l,oid Roinilly, M. R.. directed an intjuirv as to the value ol' the piopcity handed over by Pell to the company under his a Cli. 27.'!, clearly ai)proved of I'cU's caac : and in BagUiu Hall ColVu'iii Co., Giffard, L. J., soon afterwards again laid down what he had stated in PcJVs cane. In Oorcgiim (lold Mininq Co. v. Rnj,er. i '8!)2) A. C. 12.>. Lord Wat.son said: "A company is free to contract with the applicant for it.s shares: and when he pay.s in casli the nominal amount of the shares allotted to him, the company may at once return the money in satisfaction of it.s lepjal indebtedness for goods sui)plied or .services rendered by him. That circuitous jjroc'Css is not essential. It has Im'cii decided that under the Act of 18f)2 shares may be lawfully is>ncd as fully paid up, for considerations which the companv ha.-^ ;i!;reed to acco])t a-s representing in money's worth the nominal value of tiie .shares, f do not think any other decision ccjuld have Jx'en i;ivcn in the ca.se of a gtMiuine ti-ansarticui of that nature, whore the (onsideration was the substantial equivalent of full payment of the .shares in ca.sh. The possible objection tc. >\u\\ an arrangement is that, the company may o%-er-esfimate the value of the consideration, and ihcri'foi-e receive less than tlie nominal value of its .sliares. The (^ourl. would doubtless r(et ol properly, goods, or service's n-ceivcd '■" the company, but tlio Coiirl.s will not iiujuire into th(> adecpraf ' the consiileration, and icrlaiiily have not re(piired it to be prov.,. that the consideration urivcn was ecjuivalent in cash value to the nominal amount of the shares : and Lord Macnaghten said: ' It .seems to me that all that has been determined .so far is that the Couri will riecline to rip up a iraiisaction not impeached as dishonest, and not |)roved to bo such, merely because the company may have paid an oMiavaganl price f(jr ilicir properly." Tlic principles laid down ,uid ie<.);;iii/c.i i i sr . ' ;i.i t: ) wm if-'i •i^ rKr.r.iMiNAiJY N<)ir>. [Chap. 1. „„„,„ ,.. i„„„„.„ ,h,.ir :u,tl,orilv - au ..•..,.,. ^^ln,•l., .t .-U....-I. I. ,.,ul.llKU ...• .,I.M,ll...<<-..„r„.i.>.. ln-lK,,..-M!.>a,™.,.. ,i,,,i,l'„.,ll,at ,1 n-i.l,.n„i.u,;.p;>n,.n...-l, „• .t.n. was ov. >- ,,,,., 1.. ,,■..,...! a^MnpaihlmM!..-t.Hn-,.,.M-..l.av,lnM.lll,.M.n I l,r,l„., i-inniM /',.//■.,„.,■. v„K.,au,i, I,. I lloH,!.n.-n.-. 1,1,,^ .,i:l l.in^ll-. I. .. I. . iu tlM<,M~ •.-..-'■.■ v.-t I .>l.Tnlo.l ,,,.,,H:Mi,..lnMMK^,v.aMH,Mian-p.•op,■n^o.l.,^l.rM.vvI,■osaU.n^ ,,,;,.,. i, .lunks i.r-M.,.,- an.l ,MV ...th.n, -n .nil;. |u„l-Mn -ha,. -. .,.,.ia,.,lalin,i,,..l. panv,l.„.<>,.l„ .1, aa,l n.. ...lou.a -ly, a-1 ',.li..,.,l .V i,>i.a,va.n.i> ..,.,---<"' ^'^ ''':''''".'". ^ ,'^\ ,..„u,an,..-..,.a^..c,-l-— ■■.— 'M-l-P ''^"■'^7'^,:'' • imI l.iM.liii- ..II III.' - 'H,|.."i: ■ li.l .■.'■" .1"". "-• „,,:, ,.„,vi~M,,v>-.ir M.;, .l,.|.li.va:^!..l..l..-.l^|.an^:l..M. ,,,,„, ,1,:, i..l,inU^i.u. . .:!..- -nil,..,, a., ni.v. W iuM .in' nan- :tii,ii 1- \imni|.' • If, ,~ai(! A. hicii ill.' .iiiiil ,-1i,m1 llii^i- .1. S,i;illi. i. Iv valr..' 1.. 1.1' .■..iiMil.T.' ■ u nil- -..!..•• I a-. ilir I ■,ii-i;!i'rali"n .am ha-> a'^v. t,i a -.111 :,- iriili'^l'lllHIL;- .11 lll.in.;\ - nil III.' ii.iiiiiiial valiii' .!!.■ :-lia ■i-.i.i'in iM.i licall I n..!- il.ii- „l.,uiaM ,(,ii-iil. raliun laniin i-v, llicn, Hi u'v I'M'jm ,l. lii.' a 1.' .M;ii ,v I if .li .1 liv a I! iiii.lal ,1- mil,'-- .li" i-.m- lia> M..I ..|.' ;ui al.-.i aicn.. ti. U'l Hi li) ill ' a.li' .11.1. \ 'j1 ,1. ,1!! 1 I t.ik.- I. I' ... 1- al.l:' . ll|. \]\ • l;iu .ill. i. i- IH'uli .h;' auivi'- ui.ai I.) .-Ii.iu iiiii|ia ii\ iia\i' atir.'C. Ih.il \U- ilii.' fi.r v.liat .l:i>y li.iM' a i.iliov will'. I-. ilic Ciui'i .l.K'- 11 iCVl-t' llll.' I li rvctii)!! .if .Inc. lni.-ini'-'< tiaiis ml lai.li. rtioii ual.-'- .Ill' all' -u.iuii no. ^('i' al-i. /••,■/,> ll.iillni <(■ '. //,„//,•// , 1 ;>'.•: .), I,) liii\.> a.lc. Ji. T. !.-)l. ill .lii.l ■a-i' I ipiiiiv. Iirnrj' ill a :■:<> \nj: .Dn.f'i'n, -".. iht. (. L ,lM' ,l,.f,'n.la..l. fnmi u a it iia'! L.^aJi. l-rnp-M-lv, r,.s|M,nM!.l.- in .1 inia'jc' 1,11. r.\ii..'. for I'livinu ;\< il u:. - ail "!■!' 1, I 1. llll (\\ri'"ivc iinco: !,. ill'.- s.iii-lii'il .lial .111' Jirii-.' «as cm i\ .,1 ill,' aiti.n. All I iiM. !i. iiij- .-a \iil 1 ill ati i'-til I a- I <>.. in Sr.i. 12 Ch. •2r,l. ri';t(./. I H li. 771; /" k lan.j. IkoiniV'f, !'> tilimur • .>Voi s .11 tiic l.uv 11^ laid ilciaiioii. It i^< well scltlcd that til. f ))io|a;!iv or ^oivicU'i, .Jf tiiiy otlicr AMOUNT OR VALUK OK roNSIItKKATlON'. i.\ liOiii'lit-< 111' aiU :iiil;i'4('-^ uhidi llic cuiajr^iiiy di'^'iii^ of value .nul lia-^ piUM'r Id i'\|ii'iiil its I'liixK oil. I!ii( 1k>iiii> I !ililirali'-< i-^iicd with iv in I'act assi'^aie.l, Ian ihe shaii'- ucre ui'\ cil heli-- helil to III' and to roiiuiin j);ii ('. I)i\. ."iili;. riie 1 oiiipaiiy iiiii-t. it is said, either a|i))niliale or reprohate the i on- iiacl .see . I ;/(!, /'.v.yj/'.s (ti.si\ per .|e--:'l. .M. 1{ . . 7 < . I). ~.'i ; Inn iiii- dei ni- open to .;ii.'siinii. I'm' no i"-|oppcl I an ai i-i' under an ,'l!r:i rii <■- tuiil rail . If llie 1 mitr.u ; is ullni cVcv. ii iiia\ lie that llie allollc!' can w iiliin a leasiiiiablc lime leiaivli.ile it, as in . \liiiiiil:' d Tir.'li ' «., .')S ( '. I). ;:i:;; hut on." il is vl;o\',M thai In- is on ihe rc'^isler wiih his i-on-'rit, ih.il imports an olili'jation 'o piiy ■ Wfllan v. Sdili'i/l. (18!l7i A. ( '. ll'.t'.i; "nilini;/ 'I l.-iir 'iilhl-.- ( •). !L!C. I). ILS-, (htvcijn:,! ' o, v. /,'o,«r, . IK'.H' ( IJ.'ii; f.i' persons tru~! the company ici lln; fai'h of the nam.- ippca! ill'.:' on i Ic i"",..ist;.r. Shares, ajzain. llioiiijh inn in f.ici paid lor, inav lie iiiiprc~scd wilh liio character of fully juiid-iip shares hy reason of tlni company licini; csioppei! from -ayiii;;- that they have not. Iiceii ]ia;.l I'or. snjim. p. IJ "i.lr l-:..|i,..|. Who is liable. The i'<'(;ist; Haiihi'iu v. iirliin im 64 I'RFXIMINAKY NOTKS. [Chap. I. Ri'tum as tn aUotmpnts. • -I 1 r Tl.o holder « lial.ilitv t- pay in .ua-t. t!;,.;^.. ,o the ..„n,;u.y .uulev the ™ ;-"•;"" -^^l^I^X^ .. ,leht due from bin. to the company, and .n Ku,^lund or Irol-*"J ^^^^ the nature of a specialty debt ": anly on the promise there.n to pay ^e -1 "Je - part bv specified instalment.. In a winding-up .be l.ab.hty to pa> whatev-er mav be called for arises under sect. 12:'. of the new Act. iSucing sect. 88 of the Act, replacing sect. .8 ot the Compame. Z 1802 Where the holder die., his estate remains liable m inspect of bis share until some other person is registered as the holder .hereof. StH> mi>ra. p. 58. When the hol.ler transfers and he trans- VnH> is roer.son who has. by transfer, forfe..ui-e, or surrender. •eascHl .o iK, a n>ember, still ivmains secondarily liable as a past member , H. <.>n.ributory . in the event of a winding-up ..)mmenc.ng within one vear after he ceases to be a member, as by se.t. l..> ^repro,lucinsr sect. 'M of the Companies Act. 18.;2. provule,l. Returns as to Allotments and Filing Contracts with Registrar. Bv ,e<-. . «8 of the Act. replacing sect. 7 of the Companies A.t. 1900. special pr<,visiou has been made for prompt fil.ng wnh the Regis rar „' partieuh..s of all allo„nen.s from time to .in.e ma.le. The section runs as follows: 88 (11 \VI,..n..v..r a compMny lin.it.a l.y shaivs mako- any Mllonncnt of it- .Z:t ni-any si.al. within on,- n.„„,h tK-n-aftc,. «„■ w„h t,„. r.^.trav r„1 ., roturn nf tl„. allotnnM.t.. stating' tl.- nnn,l,.r an.l nom.nnl anw.unt ot ho shar,M comprised in tho allotment, the name-, ••uhlrep... an.l -le- I'riptions of the allottees, an.l the an.onnt (if any^ pa,.l n,- ,l„e and n'lvalile on eaeli share; and . rM in tie vse of share, allotted as fully or partly paid up otherwise than ' in .;; a eontraet in writin, eonstitntin. the title of the allottee to he alh fment. to.-ether with any eontrae, of sale, or for serv.ees or It, ; onsideration in respeet nf whieh that allotment was made, sue " ntraets l,ein« duly stamped, and a return stat.n-, he number am ,n ll "r..ount of .shares so allo.t,.l. the .xtent to wh.eh they are to Wtreated a- paid up. and the consideration for wh.eh they hav.- heen r Whei^*sueh n eontraet as aho.e n.ntioned is not redu-^l to writing, the .„v h U within one month after the allotm..... ftle with the registrar of ::i:X:£ "'l^hed particulars of the eontrae, stamped with the same RETURNS TO REGISTRAR. ♦!5 Etamp duty as would have been payable if the contract had been reduced tn writing, and those particulars shall be deemed to be an instrument n-ithin the nicanin): of the Stamp Act, 1891, and the registrar may, as a condition of tiling the particulnrs. require that the duty payable thereon be adjudicated under section twelve of that Act. (3) If default is made in complying with the requirements of this section, every director, manager, secretary, or other officer of the company, who is knowingly a party to the default, shall be liable to a fine not exceeding fifty [lounds for every day during which the default continues: Provided that, in ease of default in filing with the registrar of companies within one month after the allotment any document required to be filed by this section, the company, or any person liable for the default, may apply to the Court for relief, and the Court, if satisfied that the omission to file the document was accidental or due to inadvertence or that it is just and equitable tn gran* relief, may make an order extending the time for the filing of the document for -uch period as the Court may think proper. Tlio object of tliis hoetion is to ullurd tlioso wlm doal or propusc to Ojjut. deal with a company the moan.-* of ascertaining a])|>i'o.\iniutelv tlic position of the company us rcj^ards its issued shares. Under tl r law as it .stood before this Act (sect. 20 of tiio Act of 1802 i a coin- ]iaiiy \va.s only bound once a year to make a retiiin .showiny' it,s cipital issue, and, accordingly, a searcli at the Registrar's ollire in many cases all'orded very little information, for the hied return very cmmunly showed only the position si.K or eight months before the search. This wo-s supplemented by the now repealed sect. 2'> of the (-'om))anies Act, 18t)7, which provideil for the liling of i(in- tracls as to shares issued for a consideration other than cash; but even after compliance with both sections the informatiun disclosed was not up to date. The section now under considenilion brings matters up very nearly to the date of search. The first sub-section is divided into two part.s. {a i and (hi Part I ((I reijuires "a return of the allotments." stating certain jarticiilars, including ■the amount lif any) paid, or dm and pay- able on each share": and a question at once arises whether this ictiini nmst include shares subscribed for in the memorandum of association, for shares so subscribed do not require allotment {nujini. \<- Itli. the subscriber obtaining a comi)lete title immciliately on tlic iiK i'poration of the company. Upon the whole the answer ^c Ills 1,1 1,0 that where there is no allotment of shares so sulwcribed llicrc is no obligation to include such shares in the return; but. liidiigli not necessary, it is not uncommon to pass a resolution for :d|niiiioiit of the shares o ■ tibscribed for, and where this is done tJio sli.uo should be included in the return. Another question which arises on part (a) is whether the return tliereby required is to include all shares allotted, inrluding tliosp which arc allotted in whole or part for a consiiloration other than iulios. The words used in scif. 2."i *'"'"'»• '(f iho ('ornpuiiios Ai t, 18(i7, lor wliicli sfct. 7 of (Iin Companies Art, 1900, and now sort. 88 of tlio A, meant .ontract iu wiitin- sipjned by tho p.Ti lies. And in /•> parfe Mumo. 1 i). U I). 721. il was hold that an 'agreement in writing " between a .sidiVhst not caxh. PREUMINAHY NOTES. [Chap. I. nominee was effectually protCLtod by the tiUug of a contract providing for allotmenl of paid-up shares to A. or his uoininoe. iCarUn,j s case 1 C D 115), or oven without those words (Kirby s cane, H> L T 082; Common Petroleim Enghie Co.. (18«J5) 2 Ch. T.VJ.); but the words of sect. 88 of the Act of l'J08 are very different. The contract is to be fded within one month after the ullo.aent, and tlic 4UOstion sometimes arises whether a contract hied b.>forc allotment will suffice. Considoriug thai the obvious object is u> secure the disclosure, it may 1m> that a contract so fded is suUicicnt; but it is -ater to adhere to the express directions of the .section, the policy of wliich is to ensure disclosure of the actual allotment, not of that which is in contemplaiion iiicivly What is Cash ? Sub-ect 1 (bi of ..eel. 88 deals with shares allotted as fully oi partlv paid up otherwise than i.i cash, and the question thereupon urisei as to what is cash. There is, of course, no question that .t the .sliare is issued e.xpresslv on the footing that it is to be pai.l up by iuslalments, or with reference to culls, or without any stipulation as to how the amount is to be paid, it is issued on a cash footing. So aNo if the share is issued credited as fully or jiartly paid up jn consi'deralion of the payment to the company of a sum in .ash equal to or exceeding the credit, the share is issued for cash. But it has been held that where a share is issued as u fully i.iud-up share iu consideration of the release of a debt presently payable^ by the allottee, it is not issued for n-ou shares, so that if bank notes had l^een handed from one side o the table to the other in payment of calls, they might legitimately have beryo-.s- ra..'. L. U 8 Ch. 412; Xorth S>ju^y I''veM Co (1809) A. C. 353; Larocque v. Beauchemtn, (189,) A. I- Ja8; But there must be "cro-ss money payments presently enforceable. Re liarroa-in-Funie.^s Ini'e.stme„t Co., 14 Ch. U. 403, supa. If shares are issued as fully or partly paid up, in consuleratioii of propertv to be made over to the company or services rendered to the companv, or in cK,nsidoration of the release of a debt or claim, or by way of"con.promi.sc. the share is iss«e iUso where shares are issued without any sum credited, but u„on the footing that the whole or some part of the amount may be making over to the company property, or rendering it pu up WHAT IS *' CASH "? services, tho ^liare in itwued, at any i:ite in pint, for a corisidorotion other than roah. Siib-sppt. 1 (1)) ot m-ct. 88 mily douls witli "hunw* iillotttHl I'or a I I iiisi\veii on a cafh basis and uftorwunis paid >ip wholly or in piiil liy iiiakiny: over to tho company proiH>rty or rendorinj? to it ,'<<'rvi(i>s whitii it is willinj^ toaott^pt in satisfaction of tho amount of tJio .Hhan-H or some part ihcreof. Sect. 2o of the Aot of 18G7 having); been repealed i.see infra), the la« now stands as it stooil under tlie Act of 18t)2; and accordin)j;ly ■-imreN, whether subscribed in the memorandum or otliurwiso taken up. may be paid up in cash or vOwrnise. ' Ita man contracts to tako -liiires, lie must pay either in money or money's worth, and payment in either will bo a satisfaction." Per Cliifard, L. J., in BiujUm Hall Colliery Co., '> Ch. 34G, 3.Jo. And in the .same ease lie says i p. .i.'il i that lit* does not see that ' payment in kfud according: to a sub.seijuent lontract with tho company is inconwistent with such a memorandum. If there be a contract of such u nature that on a bill tiled by the any it cati^lied by making over to the company property or rendering it services which the company is willing to accept in satisfaction; but III such a case the company must lile a return under sect. 88. Moreover, the sectir lin no way interferes with i^iH'-'jn's i\t/tc, 8 Ch. 407. and aooordingly any bond fide transaction wb. : in an action for calls would support a plea of paymort is, a fortiori, fiillicient. lAirocijuc V. HeaurJiemin. (18!t7) A. ('. .'i'lS; Sorth Si/ihu';/ Invcat- nirnt. .Cc Co.. (1899) A. C. 26;t. .\s to applications for relief wher(> there has been an omission to cotiiply with the section, .see the decision.s on the ( ompanies .\ct, 1898, infra, towards tho conclusion of Chap. XX. Penalty. riie penalty is > orj onerous, namely, 50/. ^jcr day ; but it is only to reiuUty. be enforced against a director, manager, se«;rotary, or other otli«>r who is knowingly a party to the default. Knowingly " means knowing tho facts " {Bui lou v. Bei-an, (1908) 2 Ch. 240), and a man comiuits the offence if he knows of tho allotment or knows of the contract .u! I does not procure compliance witli tho .section; the mere fact that iie erroneously believed that he had complied with the ■-e.rivn would not, ncntblc, afford a defence. Tui/cross v. Grant, ■I C. P D. 169. 70 PRELIMINARY NOTES. ClIAl'. 1. 'it ■f ! dlli' I,.* Result ol Non-filing. Rcnult uf Tlif uoa-liliiijt ol tho roiiuijtite toiitmct will not, u« uiidor soot, a.'i of ■"•"*"*■'• tlio Act of 18(J7, Im'Idw refj'rred to, ii'ndvr tlie slures liublo I., jwiyiuoat in cuhIi, hut will cxixjat' tho diiwtors uiid other oUitiaU of llio eom- puuv to hi'uvy iic'iutltioH S«f r,i} Act of I'JiiS. Register of Members. KeK>»t»«- of Kven coiii|Puiiv under llio Act i« to cauM! to U« kept ia one oi more member". ||^,ks a n%'i-t<'r of its nn'ml«'rs. Sjh' .-wt. 2.) of the Act of 1908 ( replacing.' hcci . :».". of tin- A( t of IHtil! i. This rcj,'i.-it(!r, us will he swii, is ntic of lh<' cardinal points of our coinpuny syst«>ni. Contents. Oontmito. This ri';;isU'r must contain: lU) Names and luldresses and the occupations i if ui>y ) of the iiienihers of the company, tbi .\ statement of the number of shaivs hold by eucli share- liolder. di-!in)iui»liinc each shui-e by its number i sect. 2-2} and tlie amoi'.:,' paid or Uffreod to be considered as puid on each slmiv. ui The date at wliioh tlie num^of any person Wii.s entered in ilie rejrister us a member. id; Tlie date at wliich any person ceased to be a memltcr. lu default llie company and every director or manaf^er are liable to heav}- penalties Notice of any diuuge oi address is to be entered on iho reffister. As to share warrants, see sect. ;J7 of the .4.ct of 1908 (replacing sect. 31 of t!ie Companies Act, 1807). rriind facie a company is not entitled to enter a lueworanduni of lien on the register. Re Key A Son, (1902) 1 Ch. 4f!7 A.s to register! n{,' u firm, supra, p 4.>. Inspection. IiupeotioD. Tlie ifgister of ineuilK'i-s coninieneing from the date of tho regis- tration of the company is, by sect. 30, to be kept at the registered office of tho company (sect. 62, infra) ; and by sect. 30 such register is to be open for insiMJctiou by members gratis, and for inspection by any other person on payment of one shilling or such loss sum as the company may proscribe for each inspection. A right is also given to »■ e a copy of such register or any part thereof, and a penalty is ,,/o.sod for refusal of inspection, and in additiou to this peiujlty. a judge sittiiiir in chambers may by order IN8PKCTION. 71 wmpfl an imnwdiafo iiwpoction of tho rcgwtor; and disobediom 9 of ihal (inlor lK>injr a rontompi of Coirt niiiy Im- pun: hod by .m- prisonniont . Tlio risrlit of in«iMvtion dors notmrry wnth it iho right to "• .o froo .'\lruit/f. The sum of Cd per folio of 100 words must lio paid. liaJwiluU OnU Mininfi Co., (1901 ) 2 II H, (iO.I, overruling Ro'ird v. Afrirait, ; (i«'JH) 1 f'h, rm TIk' " register" iniludos the entries of tiie immen of persons who hnvo been. bu( liuve rensed to U\ nieniliers of tlio company by rriisoi uf llif forfeiture of their shares or otherwi-e tinord v Africun I 'on- nolidated, dc. Co., supra. Tho right terminates on a \vintlinir-u;i lu-iit ('tmlficlds Si/nd> section means u distinct and delinilc refusal, lirjc V Wilts and Uerhs (ami Co . \\ .\d \- Kl. 177. See, too, 8 Ad. !c i:i. aoi A credil"!- or member may inspect by his solicitor or agent. Hcran V. Wfbh, (1901) 2 Ch. .V.t. Tlio motive for inspection is immaterial. Darirs v. Gnu Light and Coal (\>.. (1909) I Ch. 24H. Closing of Register. The company i.-^ empowered to close the register by advcrtisomont, Closing <>( but not for more than thirty days in each year. Sw .sect. .".1 of 1908. "^ST'^t. Register Primft. facie Evidence. T!io register of nicmbi'rs is to bo iirinui facie evidence of uny inutlt^rs by the Act directed or uutliori/.ed to bo in.-ertod thcroiu. Scci. a.'! of the .\ct of 1908. Ilcnco it is not conclusive. /I'cf.vd Uircr. dc Co. v Smith. L. 11. 4 H. L. 80. Publicity of Register. It is important to note the fact that the regi.-;ter of members is, by Publicity of the Act, open to the public until winding-up. In this respect the Act "K^ter. of 1802 (tillers from tho Act of 1844. By sect. 50 of tho Act of 1844 every sharchnhler wa" to have lilvrty to search tho register at nil reasonable times, but nobody was to be at liberty to search it who was not a shareholder. There was a similar obligation as to keeping a register in tho Act of 18t)2, but that Act introduced an important change in providing (sect. ."50) that the rofrister should be open to tho inspection not only of shareholders, but, on payment of one shilling, of all other persons. Tliis would, of course, include creditors and persons about to deal hMi 72 PKEUMINABY NOTES. [Chap. I. Object of jiublicity. II" Doctrine of holding out. with the couipauy, aud the change indicates unmistakeably an iutcu- lion on the part of the Legislature tliat the cifditors and ])crsoiis who conteniplatod dealing in soimc way with the cuuipuuy were to be entitled to look at this document as showing thoin to what extoiii they might safely trust the company. While the liability of shareholders remained uidimited " such ii power of inspection was not necessary, or, certainty, not at all s.. necessary. . . . But when the Legislature enabled shareholders to limit their liability .-lot merely to the amount of their shares, but tu so much of that amount as remained unpaid, it is obvious that no creditor could safely trust the company without ascertaining first who the shareholders might be, aud, secondly, lo what extent they would be liable. This is obviou-ly the reason nhy the new statute opened the register to the inspection of all the world. . . Thi' Legislature took caro to provide the register as the means of eiialdint; persons dealing with the company to know to whom and io whai they might trust. It intended to put the persons whose names an- on it in the same position towards creditors (^subject, "f course, t<. the statutable restrictions I as persons engaged in an ordinary partnership, or persons trading formerly under the Act of 1844. Per Lord Cranworth, Oakei v. Turquaiul, L. R. 2 II. L. •'!•>(;. Li the same case his Lordship also said: " It is a fallacy to hold that the liability of the partners in these companies inunt rest entirely on the same principle of contract which was the foundation of the liability of the partners of any unincorporated companies prior tci the institution of this class of associations. The (juestion is nm whether there was any privity of contract between the appellant iind creditors of the company: but it is whether, under the con-ititii- tion of these newly-created societies, there is a statutory liability imposed on persons in the positiou of the appellant. Secondly, ii is an error to hold that creditors are not supposed to trust to the respoiLsibility of the shareholders. The careful rejiulations as to the register of shareholders and the publicity to be given to them form 11 suilicient answer to that argument. Ins these cases of the elfect which a man's name being on the register has in inducing other persons to alter their position. " Laivrencc'n case I loUT I. 2 C'h. 417. it ' PUBLICITY OP REGISTER. r:{ "nclucivc. Tlio result of this doctrine of holding out is that if a person's name i< oil tiio rogrister with his consent, and he claims a right to have it removed on some ground or other, he must exercise the right Iirotnptly, otherwise he forfeits it. See Scottish Petroleum Co., 2;i ('. D. t.U, in which Baggallay, L. J., said: ' The delay of a fortnight Delay. ill reiiiiitiating the shares makes it in my mind doubtful whether tiio repudiation in the case of a going concern would have been iu liiiie. No doubt where investigation is necessary some time must bo allow. !. as in the Central Hallway Company of Venezuela. L. R 2 H. L. U'J: but where, as in the present case, the shareholder is at ,uco fully informed of the circuuistani-es, he ought to lose no time iu repudiating." Even where a name is, pursuant t'> a ruid con- tract, placed on the register, delay may be fatal. Rnilu-ai/ Titnr Tables Co.. 42 C. D. 107; supra, p. o4. Nevertheless the reliance to be placed on the register is qualilied HeBii|nr nut to tliis extent, that anyone dealing with the company mu.st be taken ti. know — (1 1 Tliat shares may be transferred in accordance with the rcgulii- tious, and thus an insolvent shareholder may be substituted for a solvent one. i2i Tiiat a member who has been induced to take shares by mi - representations or mistake, .ven tiiough on the register fm years, may. while the company is a going concern, repu- iliate his shares and get oil tlio register. See p. 1'.17, /«//«. I .! < That there may be jiersons (jn tli(^ rcurister placed there without their consent who may subsequently enforce the removal of tlieir names. See further, Ree.'ir Hirer Co. v. !-!mith. L. 11. i H. L. 8();i; and Haillie.^ rase. ylS^S) 1 Ch. 110, iu which a person on the register escaped on the ground tliat he had made a mistake as to the company. i4~i That persons ou the register may escape under sort. 8ti of tlie Ciimpanies Act. 1908. on the ground of the allotment being irregular. 0) \\liere tiie en'iy on the register is there staled to be subieel, to .some condition membership is not complete. Sjiil:i'/, V Chliirne Corpnralion. 80 I.. T. ;547. See p. 1!>, v»/)»v/ \- 111 reitiljiation nf the renjisier, s^o inUa. Chap. X.\. Powers of Majority. It is a cardinal rule of the law, as applied to corporations, that fowprnnf rnima facie the majority of its members are entitled to e.xercis.' its "">io"'y powers and control its operation^ generally. ■ Where no special provision is made by the constitution of a "orporation, the whole are bound by the acts not only of the major part, but of the major part of those who are present at a regular m ■A\ k'l t I? u PRELIMINARY MOTES. [Chap. I. t'orporale meeting, whetlier the number present be a majority of the whole or not.'" Bacon, Abr. II. 269, citing 10 Mod. 75; 12 Mod. 232; Cowp. 24r tiie action shall proceed. IhtckcU v. Gover, ti C. D. H2. As to further jiroceediugs, see 25 \\ . K. .VVl: I'.xelcr and Cicditon liuil. Co. v. Bullcr. o Ry. t'as. 211. The cases following illustiate the iin))ortauec which the Courts, and especially Courts of equity, attach to the will of the majority: — In Fo.s.v V. llarbottle, 2 11a. 4(31, two members of au incorporated company tiled a bill against the directors aad others, praying that the defendants might bo compelled to make good the losses sus- tained by the company by reason of the fraudulent acts of such directors; but the Court, being of o|iinion that the acts of the dofen- Uuut complained of were capable of coulirnialion by a majority of the members of the com])any, declined to interfere. See also Mo:li ij V. Alston, 1 I'. II. 790. So, in Macdungall v. Gardiner. I C. Div. l;i, wheiv ihe plaintill. a sluireholder in a company under the Act of 1802, sued in respect of alleged misconduct of a director at a meeting of the company, it was held that he had no lociifi standi to complain; that the wrong, if any, was a wrong to the company, and that the conipanj' in it.- corporate capacity could alone sue in respect thereof; that if the majority sided with the plaintitf, there was no difficulty in suing in the name of the company; and that if the majority were against the plaintill, thci-e was no use in litigating the matter, for the will of the majority was entitled to prevail. "In my opinion." ,snid Mellisli, T,. ,1., in that case, "if the thing complained of in a thin/ which in substance the majority of the com- POWERS OF MAJORITY. 75 paiiy am cntitlod to do. or if soinothiug h^s b«eu done irregularly wliic h tlie majority of tlif coiniiuny are entitled to do ro>rularly, or if sometliiu-r ims been done ille<;ally which the majority of the company are entitled to do loyally, there can he no use in havinfr liti^'ation aLuiii it. the ultimate end of which i.-< only that a mcctin>r has to be .ailed, and then ultimately the majority get.s it.s wishes. See also /•> ijarU- Foj. G Ch. i;(i, Ilarbtu v. Phi'lii>s, Ua V. Div. 14; WhiliMin V. ^yalki>ls, 78 L. T. 188; Exelcrniid VrediU»i RiiiL Co. \. BtiUer, 5 Ry. Ca.s. 211; and Sormaiutij v. Ind. Coojir d ('<>■■ 10(18) 1 (h. 81. Bui the rule of the majority is. as above staled, subject to the provisions of the Acts and of the company's memorandum, and in some ca.ses the articles of association. Thus, if the articles provide lur the continuance in ollice of the directors, and do uoi contain any puwer to remove a director, tiic company cannot remove a director without in the first plac^' procuring; the insertion in the articles of a power of removal. IlaiiijitoH v. I'ricc's ['iiiciit Candle Co., 21 \V. n. 75 J. Su. also, wheiv the artiiles provide that tlie directors shall have all die ])uuers of tiie company, subject to any le^'ulaiions made by the , (iiupany in n-euoral ineeliiifi' ' not inconsistent with the articles,' a ■.'('ueral mcelinj;- cannot oveniih' the directors, eg., by directing them K. iiialcc a particular contiact or to disre(■., applicable to i^iher p:irtnersliip>; for, after all. these companies are commercial partner.ships. and are. in (he ab.seuce of express provi- sions, statutory or otheiuise, subject to the same considerations. ' See also Weston a case. \ V\\. 20: Mciudi'n cane, G V\\. 'A; Guintirxi V. Land Corp.. 22 ('. Div. ;i77: floiddsirorth v. (Ha.i>jntr Haul:. 5 App. Cas. .'il7; ]yilkiiMnii v. Cummins. 11 Ha. •i.'!". These judicial dicta notwithstanding, an incorporated company is nut a partnership, as appears elsewhere (p. 27 i, and partnership ru](>s are for the most jiavt inapplicable to it. For instance, in the case of a partnership, the unaidnious consent of the partners can e.xteinl the objects of the partuorship. wlioreas the majority of the members of a company have no such power { Anhbunj. itc. Co. v. liichr, L. R " II. L. G94; Hutton v. West Cork Rail. Co.. 2.! C. D. 054, t!7I; Stroud V. lloijal Aquariioii Co.. W. \. 1 190;5) Hii i save ;i.s otherwise provided by .sect. 9 of the Act of 1908 incorporating the provisions of the Companies (Memorandum of .Association) .\ct. 1890. So a 1. so the practice of the members of a partnership may override the provisions of the partnershi)) deed: whereas practice, in the ca.se of a company, cannot alter or override the provision.s of the memoi-andiim. or, as a rule, the regulations of the company. Frank Milli Mining Co.. 2.T C. D. .-)2, .">0; Afilthnri; v Wat/iun. .io C. Div. ;f7(!: (Mfjnnk Oil Cii. v. ('rum. 8 App. Cas. ()5. Though long ac()iiiescence may prove the informal adoption by the company of new articles. See Ho Tutifi v. Man On Inmiranre Co.. (1902") A f. (P. C .^ 232. The agency of directors is circumscribed by the company's articles; the agency of partners only by the scope of the partnership business. The remedies of a creditor of a company are solely against the company, not the shareholders personally, whereas in a p.irtner- ship the creditor.5 of the firm are creditors of the individual partners Other illustrations in plenty might be given. And as company law NOTICE OF MEMORANDUM AND ARTICLE. frrowi more complex tliis differentiation between the company and till' purtaership becomes more and more marked. Those compuuies," says Lord Maenaghten in Welton v. Safjcrii. (IS'JT I A. C. 324, "arc tlie creation of statute, and by the statute lo wliidi iliey owe their being they must be bound in regard to share- hoKlor.- a.s well as in regard to creditors in all matters (oming within the roiiditions of the memorandum of association. ... A limited coriipaiiv cannot, in matters coming within tlie conditions of it« memo- lumiiiiii, go on leading two lives, one strict, and precise and regular, ,111(1 the other a life of greater freedom and la.xity, substituting the i>ii.Mcr yoke of " social contract ' for the rigour of statutory diivctions. Tlio confusion would be hopeless.' Notice of Memorandum and Articles. .\ comnanv's memorandum and articles of association being public Notice of ^ - 1 1 1 ! ij inenior;uiauni (Ificunientfi registered at Somerset House, not only the sluireliolders ^^^ article>. ■jf a company, but all strangers who have any dealings witli the com- pany, are lixed with notice of their contents, as well as of the Act or A(t.s under which the conii)any is constituted. Spoukiug of this constructive notice, with reference to members of ilii' cimipauy. Lord Cairns says, in Pivl's case, 2 Ch. 071: "If the iiiciiuirandum and articles of a.-*S(Kiatiou arc in oxistonce when he the member] applies for shares, and if he agrees to take his shares (111 till' footing of the memorandum and articles of association (which would seem to be the case here), then I think that ho ought to 1)1' held bound to look to the memorandum and articles of ajssociation bcfoit' he applies for shares. But where the memorandum and articles of association are not in existence at the time of application, I tliiiik that, at tiio very latest, when ho receives his allotment of shares, he ought to .satisfy himself that there is nothing in the memo- randum or articles of association to which he desires to make any i/lijcction." And the same learned judge, in SewcU's c^iKe, .'i l.'h. 140, nlisiTvcs: "Tlie company wa.^ a company consisting of share- hnldcr.-,. It is impossible not to impute to over) shareholder of the loiiipauv the knowledge of what has been called ;.he charter, of iloi iiiuonts under which the com()any was trading. The comiiany was iiadinii- under the memorandum of a.ssociation as its jiiiucipal docu- iiieiit. I think every shareholder must be taken to have known the ( Diitents of the memorandum of association." Other eminent judges have fully recognized tl'o same principle. .VII tlio shareholders of the company must, have im))uted to thoni kmnvlcdge of the Act of Parliament and also of their own memo- I itndiuu and articles of association, and of tlie fact tliat the nrtichiii JmI lint lius they stood before this resolution was nassed) authorize the proposed iucrofi,se of capital; and from the i ,' «s which convened the two extraordinary meetings it most I .ve been clearly understood l: .1 7» PRELIMINARY NOTES. [(vHAP. I. Vi .J !! tliot without the sanction of tliose meetings the proposed increase of caiiiiul could not be niado." ( Umplirll'n t-ii^r. !t Ch. 1, por Lord Sclbornf. ■ Poopio who onter into these piutiiorsliips under articlus of asso- cialion - tliat is, artiides of purMiorship -must be taken to liavn read tlieni, and must be taken to liave lUKh'rstwxi thuiu; mid if tliey are to be taken to liavo read them, and to have understood llii'in, whicli tlu'v Dtight to do before entering into these contracts, tlicy cannot complain if the contract is afterwards carried out. Tliat appears to mo a conclusive answer to any notion of hardship. Whether it is conclusive in fact or not is a matter upon which men who have e.xpcrioncc in the world may have ditferout opinions, but I must hold it to be condusivi- in law." Per .lessol, M. R.. drif/itli \ Pdijcf. f) V. D. .J17. ' Each party must be taken to have maile liimsolf acciuaintod with the terms of the written contract contained in the articles of asso- ciation, aud the Acts of Parliament, so far as they are important, lb' mus' also in law lie taken i though thai is sometimes dilferont from what the fact may be) to have understood the terms of the contract according to their proper meaning; and. that Ijeing so, he must take the consequences, whatever they may be, of the contract whii li ho has made." Per Lord Selborne L. ('., Oakhaiik Oil Co. v. (rum, 8 App. f"as. at p. 70. fr.Jitore, ic. Tlie principle was stated thus by Lord Hatherley in Mahoiwtj v. East Holyford Co., L. R. 7 H. L. 8tJ'J, 8i»:!. "It is senlc has a riit|ii"n<«*. iiiasnuirli as everyone dealinpr witli a company is to bo doomed to liavc iiolico of its momorandum and articles, it follows liiat ho is lixod witii notice of the extent not only of the company's powers, but of ti.e directors' powers and of any limitations and restrictions iiiilio>oJ thereon by the articles or other regulations. Thus, if the articles provide that a bill of e.vchanpfO to bo binding on tlie com|)any must be signed by two directors, an outsider or anyone dealing with the company must soo that it is so signed, riilicrwi.sc lio cannot claim under it. So, too, if the articles provide that the .seal of tho company is to Ik; fl.\ed in tlu; presence of two liirectois, who are to sign ijieir names, a peiMin dealing with tho I'liiipany (anuol safely loly on an instrMin"iit not so signed. See /:,/-;/,! Co.. 4 K. & .1. .-,4!t: At/nr v. Mhriuium, Snc. .'f C. H. X. ."^ 7:;."i. Tliis is a sulficicntly onerous obligation to impose on those who i|c;il with a rey^istere handled over to the mortgagee. It was -"utended that the seal had not boon duly afli.\ed, since the two directors, not being a ciuoruni, had no power to act. but it was held that this was only an internal irregularity, and that the e.xecutiou of the deed was therefore valid. AH tiic public documents,' said Lord Halsbury, "with which an outside person would be acquainted in dealing with the company would only show this, that by some regulation of their own — what Lord Hatherley described a.s their indoor management — they were capable, if they had thought right, of making any quorum they pleased; and an out.side person knowing that, and not knowing the internal regulations, when he found a document, sealed with the ^•omraou seal of the company, and attested and signed by two of the diroclois and the .secretary, was entitled to assume that that wii- the mode in which the company was authorized to e.xoiute an instru- ment of that description, it turns out that their own internal regu- lation was that the number of directors should exceed two. But that is a matter which was known to them and to them alone. The only external fact with respect to the management of the company ol' which an outside person would bo cognizant, would be that they had power io make any quorum they pleased, and 1 think ho would be entitled to assume that the proper quorum had been properly summoned and had attended to ell'ect the completion of that instru- ment."' And in the same case, Lindley, L. .!., said: '"What is thci- to give them notice of anything irregular, if there was anything irregular? If a person looked at the deed and looked at the articles, ho would not see anything irregular at all. He would bo at liberty to infer, and anyone in the ordinary course of business would infer, that, if the directors had appointed a quorum, they appointed the two who signed that deed. But supposing that three were wanted. HULK IN KOYAL BRITISH BANK V. TUUQUAXl). lie 1^ uuL liouiiil to gi« ami lnuk at tlio directorw' minutO's. Ho Jm> nil iii;lil to liiLik ill llioiii. »'xif|)t us u matter of biiryaiii. Tlic (lii.i tur.s' niiiiiilf-, uiiU'--< liu km)«> uliul tlicv uri', ilo nnl mIIoiI liim ,11 all. Thi'iv i^ iiothiii^ irro^riilir im llu- laid ot tlu> iloocj, taineil for a luniiioiit; uiiil I liiivi) nut liit> sliL'litn.-Jt doubt iiiy.soll that tli.il docd i- as (jond a-* iim\ mOihI tliai inoi wai ^oalt'd.' CouhIi/ of (iluitii'Mfr liiuiJ: v. Riuh//. ,(, . Co.. ( IHii'.i 1 C.'li. tili'J. 'i:!.!, tl.Jt; So. if i\w:r lid ii iiiaiiau'-iiiLr diicMor. and iiiitlinrit y in tlio ri>triila- lii>ii.--. f(ir tlin diifct.or-< to ili-li'.fat(' to iiim. a iicr^nn (Iculinj.' witli hiiii i.- I Miitlcd to a.N.-iiiiii' lluit 111- lia.< po'Ai'i- lo do wliat In- pui']i(^it.s U do. pruvidcd that it is within thr iDinpaiiys olijocts and ai)i)ai'cMil\ ri'^'ul'ir. All he lui> !o do j- ui soc tliut t\w iiiaiiai;iiiu: director inii/lit liavo [lowrr to do uliut lie ptiriiorl.-* to do. Thai i.-i oiumrjli for -.i nor.Miii ih'aliMLT with him hotid fiili'- liiinp-iS aro diro<'tor^ i/r jurf. It mall( IS not lo hiiu that they have not licon duly ajipointcd -thai i- p.irt of tli:' ind'ior inana^>'im'nt. Mt^limiri/ v. Kist ll(>hiii:ril Co.. I, K. : H. L. «(;'.»; Count;/ Life . Miinui'V ( ,,.. ."• Ch. li«H: Dwlr \ Tnu'cr (ui!f(i)ii:iu'j Co., (I'.tOl) 2 K. H. oil: Darii.i v. Ilnlloii it' I ,1 . 1 '.Hi .; 111. (.78; -'iii: V. I'oivi'r (lidritiihiitii Cn.. ■•nijini. I.onl Alvccsinno. ('. .1. ^iiid lli.u I'ld-" ca-i.'s all'oidod ample aii'.liority to .-^how that no iiil'or- iiialiiy ulll ait«'v tlii- riuliH p(w; a.-.,-<'iil of a ;^oiieial lu'OiiriL, and without such iu-soiit had :^.-ii.'0. A person doalinj^ with a company must take the articles to ho such a.s appear at the olUco of tho Reij;istrar of Coinpanie-i to ho in force. If liie diructor.s pio[io.st' to do sonioilum;- iii e.\i-<'-s of (lii-ii powers Lheruuudor, ho is notoutitlo a rorponilioii iSnltona Hospital ra^,: 10 lU>p- "•'> *"• ^"* "<"'*• ""' ^"^ '''' ""^ •'^"' "^ !'"^'*' rcprcxliirinjr WKt. 18 vl thr Act of 18t;2. makos nn fxpro- proviMi.n on the siil)jprt, and, liv f-oct. 03 of tho Art of 19(18, tho <<.mpauy is rc.|uirod to liavf it.- name ■ oii^ravtv! in lors on it« spal." The ritrht to use the seal of the company for the pur|.()-*o> of M l.usiupss is usually vested in tho directors. Ocoawionaliy tli<- power is \ usted in them by express word-, but. mui-c us\mlly, thi'ir [.owur arises liom tho terms of a jrenoral clau.-w enabling them to exercise all tlie powers (if the comprii • (kcp fur example, ClausM' 71 of Table A): it lias been laid down that tlio executive of the company i>. rrimd f'lm. .'ntitled to use the common seal. Barnrd's Banking Co., a C'h. 105. .Vs to contracts under seal. sect. 7(1 of the .Vcr. reproducing sect. M if the Compunies Act, 18(;7, enables a company, as a general rule, to <«ntriu't without seal: il need only contract under seal where a private p »pal lia in accord with tlio ro^culalioii.s, aii !■ upplv. as ill the cas? of a nou-lradiiig corporation, all iusiruiuent I., uhich tiio n'al lia.s boeu iriv;;ulaii.v atli.ted is inoperative. Ba>il. ..I liiUuid V. Emus Trustees ■> 1!. A C. .tSK; M,ii/or of the Staple \ HiihL u!lirld. i.l.S'JT.i ;: Cli. (iOH. \ dwd, to Ix) olfci tiial, must in- .scaled and drlimci : hnl, in iIk' ..i~c of a rorpcnatioii. llic alU.\iiiL;- ol tlio r-oal imports delivery. ' 1.'" ; .11 dun eorporation uo be.soiirn iwcun delivery nies Tapposilion del . iniiion seale done jiorfoetion al ce,s t^aus a.scun delivcrio." JJol. Abr . ; I 1 . JO; and see t^niyiis' Digest, Fact A { 3\ that ' a coiiiiiion seal li\ed lo the deed of a corporation is tantamount to a delivery. ■..iKjrdiaijly, whilst in the ta.sc of a jirivate individual it is usual to 111 an uilc.station clause Ui liie ellecl tliat theinsirume'it was '•.sjnued. - ;lcd and di'lirrrcd" in the prosenco of the witness, in the c:ist' of a «-iiipany the clause merely stutos that "the comnion -e:il w.i- .illiveil Im'1i'|(i in the pre.-ence of - and .' I'riiiii'i facie, therefore, if the common seal is duly aliixed to a deed li liccoiiies operative. London Erecliold. dr. Co. v. .^iifjicld. IS'.'Ti J I h, OOH. Nevertheless a corporation can execute a deed in escrow, i r., mn -I ,ii ii .-uhject to a coiuiiiioii suspending its etficacy. Vs l.i'id Cranuorlli .-aid in Xctiosw Wiehliam, L. K. 2 II. L. -Uo. The i u deeiolute. and the maker of the deeil lli-livfrv Ir. .1 : l« :-.',|iiiri-il ..f t 1 i '.l}«>r:lMfii H4 I'UKLIMINAKY NOTES. fCllAI'. I ipis ' j WllltjKT «!uk'.-..u pprfornu.l, iho iti.-.truni.iit i" iiut u .Ictl It i» a riiort' 0:'(Tow. . I know of iiolliiiic iiiti'rm.'.liato l.etwi'<-n u dmi un.l an e^-row.' WliL'tlior li i«'iiil.i on tho intontioM of tlie parti«M as oxprcs>crtain aifouats woio adjusUil. I>iml Kll.'nboroU','b, (-'. .( and till' n St of the I'ourt heUl that, " in order to trivo tho iiustrunu'iii ellect, tliu atlixint; of tiio -lmI niu>*t bo iloiio willi inti-nt lo pass tlii esUit<>. OtbfiAsisc it operutos no more than a foollnifut would di without livery of wisin; whereas liei<>, lliou-h the seal «a directed to be and \va« allixwJ to the in.strmneiit for form, yet it wa> with a resiTvati^n of any present etVect to i>a.s.s the title out of tin company, us tliey did not ( lioo.>. to deliver over the possession of iIk cnnvexance till the acoiinta wen' settled bet w on them and tin pnrlia- T. See, t..,,, Moirutt v. ( «.vf^'.s7/v/. dr. Co.,:; t (•'. 1). .-)«, iu which the Court found as it fad that debentures (o bearer sealed by the company had not iu fact boon delivered. Iiut it is iiiito cou- slMeiit with' this that whei-e an instrument un(!"r the .seal is taken in j.nn)d fi'.ilh the company would, a.s a ;.-eneral rule, be estopped imn, setlins up non-delivery. Cminl;/ of (llnwxhr llaik v. nitroris.. s,n...ii..r in flic rouiilrv niiin.Ml in Iho in.-iuo.aniluin n.u-l !»• -non ,,, i|„. iiriri^irar of Coniiiaiii.-. Having ro^raid to sort. 7 "f VMW. ^ ..mpii'.v ro-iMo..Ml under ilio Act caniiol now cliantvrod ollico, or from tiic provisions of sect. 110 of ihc Comp^nlos Act, 1908, irliich provides for tl.o srr^iro ..f writs ,111(1 notices at tho rcgiiterod ofUco. But within that, country, tho ,.„inpanv may from liiup to timo chan-o the situation of it.s rc-is- UTcl oilico. "thou.„'h it mu^l jrivo notice of oach change to th" Rcfiistrar ('.sects. (i2, l:U (8)). A .-..nipnny refrisleied in Sc'laiui or lici.iitd m..\ lunprlhcle^-; jn iTtain i.i-c" lie sucl in Knjrland and soiveil v.illi a j)roi o-^s of M Si !■ ■iiinm ■i) Ir-I :l,c Kni.'li>ti Cnuit-, und.'V tiic sfrvi. o-out-of-thc-jiirisdirtion order ^ U S (■ Ord. XI r 1 Thi- rule is as follow-: •in.' out of the jiirist^ of any written in^rument, of which th- person to I.e served is u tru-ti'C, whi. h oujrht to bo executed .lecordin- to the law of Knjfl.ind ; or (.1 The .action is founded on any breach or allefjed breach within the juris- diction of any contraet wherever made, which, aicordinj,' to the term* th>.rcof. oujrht to be j crfornied within tlic jurisdiction. iinlcs.s tho de- fc;iJaiit is dumicilei! er or.lin:irily resident in Si otiand or Ireland; or ifl .\ny iiijunition is s..u:-'ht a^ to anythin;- to be done within the juris- (iiition, or any !iuis:inre within the jurisdiction is sought to be pre- vented or removed, whether damages arc or are not also sought in respc.t thereof; c- iL'i .\ny person out of the jurisdiction is a necessary or proper party to an a'< t'.on properly brou^dit against some other person duly served wittiiu the jurisdiction. r ~!i cnm- aiiies. when II il'h- in ■'.n.-land. -i-. 1' 111 ilic aliovc rule per-on ' imludes 'corporation " (V.. S. C. •ird LWl. r. ,., 8rt PRELIMINARY NOTES. [Chap. i;i I Scotch "'.111- paiiy witli jijt'ciK its ail'! chiff oftiri in Kiiu''l:ni'l County i'Mu jurisd'^tir'Ti The discretioa to grant Icavo is regulated by rulo li of Hio Order, whuh provides that 'Where leave is asked from the Court or a jud-a. .o servo a writ, under the last preceding rule, in Scotland or in freland, if it shall appear to the Court or judge that there ina> be a concurrent reniedv in Scotland or Ireland (us the case may be; the Court or judge shall have regard to the oon.parative cost and ..onvonlence of proceeding in England, or in the place ot residence of the delen.laut. or person sought to te served, and particularly in ca.ses of small demands to the powers and juri,diction, under the statutes establishing or regulating them, of the Shonlt s Courts, or Small Debts Court.s in Scotland, and of the Civil Bill Courts i„ Iioland, le.speclively." See Annual Prac'ice. ].. h:,. Ou the construction of Ord. XI. r. 1, it has been held, that a company which had its registered olBcc in Scotland, but had agencies and a chief otli.e in England, was not "domiciled or ordinarily i.sident" within the jurisdiction, and that leave to issue a writ for service m.t of the jurisdiction could not be granted. Jo)ies v. Scotti>>h Accident Insurance Co. .188G., 17 Q. B. D. 421. See al^o Watkins v. Scottish Imperial Insurance Co. 1 1889). 2;i Q. B. U. 285; WilVuuris v. Carticright. (1895J 1 Q. B. 142; Lopez v. Chavarn, W. N. (1001 1 nr,: and the Ann. Pr. 1912. .As to domicile of fok' ign companies generally, see Chap. XVIlL A foreii.-u companv mav reside abroad and also luu-e, and it will be taken to reside here if it has loa agency here for transacting business, or if the company carries ou business at a lixed abode in this country. Saccharin Corp. v. Chemi^che Fabrik run Ileyden Actiengeselhchaft, (19111 2 K. B. JlG; Actiesselkabet Dampskib Hercules v. Gratid Trunk Pacific Rail. Co., 105 L. T. (J95. : As to County Court process, as a general rule the district in which actions ami matters must bo commenced is to bo ascertained from .ect. 71 of the County Courts Act, 1888 ^,51 & 52 Vict. c. 12,1, that is to say, except where otherwise in the Act provided (see sect. 59), in the Court 'within the district of which the defendant or one of the defendants shall dwell or carry ou his business at the lime of .ommencing the action or matter." This is a re-enactment of i.ld County Court legislation. The words " dwell or carry on business " occurred in 9 &. 10 Vict. c. 95, s. CO, under which it was held, in the cases of niihs lud other oarrying companies, that a corporation dwells wheiv it carries on its principal— that is, its administrative as distinct from the manufacturing or trading— business ^Taylor s Crowland Gas Co., 11 Ex. fi); and that ordinarily it carries on its business where its chief olHco is (Corbett v. Gem-ral Sleani. ^aL■(■ gallon Co., i H. J: N. 482j, or where its general as (apposed t.. a part, or even a material part, of its business is carried on. ,-lJu/rt.s v. G. W. Rail Co.; G 11. k X. 401; lirouyn v. L. d M. W. Rail. Co., 4 B. li, S. .■12G. This is generally, but not in all cases, its registered ullice in tho case of a company registered under the Companies Ad^ INCOME TAX. H7 Keywham lilue LUts Co. v. liurUr. 2 H. >v C. 72U, 73a Aud »v.' Ukov. Coiilliit of Laivs, 2uil oil. MO: aud taniiii;.'iv. as a ^.^eiioral but not univer-al rule, a lompany iiu.iiriiorated here can sue and be sued in fureijrn Courts. More- ovei, in a considerable numlier of ca^es. conventions have boon concluded between this country and otlier countries ex|)re~ii ''ntn- I'liiiy xiiiicL^ <»r -II. it ai>r.i:(d. Income Tax. Without attempting' to deal fully with the (subject of income tu.x it may be u.M-ful to refer to som<> of the principal provisions of the Inc ine Ta.\ Acts and to somi> of the leadir.p: cases which have fieen dec ided thereunder. The income ta.\ is levied year by year under an Act annually passed win h fixes the rate for the current year (coinmoncin^j: on the tilh April in that year aud ending' on the 5th of April foUowinix) and niakes the provisiuu of the principal Income Tax Aet.s api)licul)lc with more or less modiflcalioii to the lax as rcj^'ards th<' particular vcir. for. siraufn' to sav. thcii' i-' no '^ciieral .\ct which makes tiio rei|iu.site |)rovi.Mons opciatc aulouiatically as and when each year .s inc. Ml." tax is };ranted. Two Acus constantly referred to are , 1 1 Th" In.ome Tax Act of 1842 i :. i Vicl . c. ;(.". i. .2) The Incme Tax Act of 18,")3 {U) & 17 Vict. c. ;i4i. As a specimen of the Annual Act, attention i.s called to the Finance Art, l'.m ( I >.V 2 Ceo. o, e. 48), ect. 14— ill Income la.x for the year boiiinniny- on the of income tax lijantod for the year bofrinninf? the 0th day of Ajiril, litKt, shall have full force and I'irert with respc;ct tu any duties of iiKcmie tix hereby crrantcd. hi thc> n'siilt the Income Tax Ac t, 1842, and the Income Tax Act, lM,j:l, as nKKlilied by suli^i lueiil Icfii^lation, an' levixed and brought into operation a^ain. Ilv the former Adiilc 1! iclati s to duties in ii~])Oi i iiMiciiicni-; and hcrclininiont-i. .1 Ihr x'cupatlon of lands hclicdiiic iviilrnil-^ (■ dales t" dulir-i in ii' to thi-i. M'c iiilni. xvlicic ihf sclii-didc is in purl sot lilt. Sclic'ilidc K I'ldati'.- duties ill ro-ipoL-l of ]nibli(; oHiucs and iiiiiHiilii's. peii.sKins niililir I'l'vcniic. and stipond.s pa_\ablo by tlio Crown out of the It inuv !)(• coiivciiiiMit, Innx! Uj call a'tciilion to the fa; I that the iiicouH' ta\ inipi ■d by Sc hodule D is not an essentially dillorent kiiied in Loiuloit Counfy Coiinril v. AH.-C!i')i.. i l'.»on A. C 2(i. In tliat ease Lmd Mai imirhteii in his s]ioei li dealt wiili the matter as foUi: " Inoi)mi-ta\. if I may lie pardoiifil for sayiiii; so, is a tax on iniwni'. It is not nii'ant U, l)e a tax on anytliint,' clfo. It i^ oni- tax, not a I'oUoi-tion of taxes (■.■i-eiiti,;lly di.-timt. TIiitl' ia no di!leruni.e in kind biHween tlie duties iif iiiiMimr tax assfssfd midiT Schedule I) to tiiosi- assessed under Srliedule .\, or any of tli'' otli.T neliedules of charge. One man has fixed ]in>i"Tty, another live.s l)y lii wits; eni-h eontriluites to tho tax if his income is ahove the- jire- scrilied li.iiil. The stand;ird of ass<.>;nnnt varies aecordinu; t.i the nature of tlie source from wliich tlic taxal)lc ineonie is derived. That is all. rfci]cdiile .\ confaiiis llie duties charijeahle for and in respect of property in all lands, tenements and hereditaments capable of actual o'vcujiatioii. Thi-re the standard ;s aunu.il value. It is ditKcult to sec what utlic-r standard c.)uUl have been a<)opted .IS u preneral rule. Hut there asrain, if tho subject of charge be lands let at rack-rent, the annual value is underst lod to lie the rent by the year at which the amc are let. In every case the tax is a tax on income \vhat"ver may be the .standard by which the income is measured. It is a tax on prolits or gains in the case of duties < harircablc under Schedule A, and everything; coniin;; under that schedule — the annual value of lands eapabb- of actual occujiation as well as the earnings of railway companies and other concerns connected with lands- just as much as in the case of the other schedules of ehargo. . . . I'nfortunately the learned judijes of the Courts Ix-low took a very different view JM regard to this point. That, I think, was tho initial mistake. In the Divisional Court the argument on behalf of the Crown as reported was this: 'The tax under Schedule A is a tax on property, and is totally distinct from tho income tax under Schedule D.' It .appears from the shorthand notes that that argumint was adopted by the Court without any qualifieation." Tax Aet. 18.');!. (iutier Schedule D. Sohedalcli By Schedule D isoel. 2) of the Income were granted to tlie Crown — For and in respect of tho annual profits or gains arising or accruing to any person resident in the United Kingdom from any kind of property whatever, wiiiithiT situate in the United Kingdom or eiicwlierr, and fur and in fespett of tho annual ])rotits or gains arising or accruing to any person residing in the INC(iME TAX. I „it«l Kirifrdom from any profession, trade, rmploymont or vocation, whether tl„. same -h.ll be r.spertively liis and (fains. ... . , \„a for and in respeet of the an^ .al profits or ^»ams arlsln^' or aecruing t.' ■i„v pcrsu,, whatever, whether a i-ubjert of Her Majesty or n..t, allhoufib not r.Mdent wiiliin the United Kinu'dom, from any im.perty whatever in the United Kin-don. or iinv profession, trade, employm.'nt -.r vocation exer,-is,.d witlun ,l„. United Iv.nij'dom, and to be char-cd for every twenty shillings of the annual itnnunt of sueh jjrotits and ynins. \nd f.>r and in r.^spect of all intiTcn on inomy anii.iiMe, and other annual l.rotits and c.ins not eharsfed by virtue of any of the other seliedules .•onluined ill this Act. and to b- eharu'ed for every twenty -liillin;,'s of the annual amount thereof. Xl» Am) lilt: lolluwiit;^- littles m- Ael 1S-1-. iiitplieaUle: - I IV socV. Km of llii' Iiieomi' Tiix iil ... 5 # Rules of Assessment (Schedule B). I'lIlST C.\sn.-- Duties to be (harped in respent of any trade, m.inufacture, tidvenlurc, or uiiieern in the nature of trade, not .ontained in any other Schedule of this .\ct. ^es where and loin- l{ii.t;s. First. The duty to be eliarfred in respect thereof shall bo eomputcd on a sum not less than the full amount of the balance of the jirofits or sains of sueh trad.', m.inufacture. adventure or eoneorn upon a fair and just average of three yciii-', endinir on su.'h dny of the yar immediately jirecedin? the year of assesi- "mcit'on which the accounts of *ho said trade, manufacture, jKiventuro or eoiMcrn shall have been usually icade up, or on the ,')th day of .\..ril preeedinff tlic year of as-e-sment, and shall be assessed, charge.l, ;:nd paid wituout other d.dtiction than is hereinafter allow, d: I'rovided alway;;, that in c.i th.' trade, nianufacture, adventure or eon.ern shall have been set up mcn.ed within the said period of three years, the computation shall be made f.ir one year on the averag<- of the balance of the prolits and pains from the period of first settin? up the same: Provided also, that in eases where the trade, inaiuifacture, .idventurc or eoneern shall have been set up and eommeneid within the year of assessment, the eomiiutati.in shall be made according to the rule in the Si.'ith Uase of this Schedule. Si'cond. Tii.' said duty shall extend to every person, body politic or eorporat", fraternity, fillowship, eompany, or society, and to every art, mystery, adventure or I'on.crn . arried on by tliem resp.M:tively in lircat I'.ritain [the United Kingdom I or elsewhere as aforesaid, cscej.t always sueli adventures or eoncerns .HI or about lands, tcncm.- hereditament-, or lieritaL-i's .as an; mentioned in S.hclule .\, and direct." ^ lie therein clcirgeil. Third. In estimating the balance of profits and pains ehartrcable under Scheilule I), or for the purpose of assessing the duty thereon, no sum shall he -.t against or deducted from, or allowed to be set apainst or deducted from, such profits or pains on aec.iunt of any sum expendid for repairs of prcmiKcs occupied for tiie purpose of sueh trade, manufacture, tidventure or eoneorn, nor f.ir any sum evpended for the supply of rejiairs or alterations of any impli nients, utensils, or articles employed for the purpose of such trade, manufacture, :i.l-,i.ivt.;i;> .;r cnsirrrn hcvimd the sum usually expen.led f.>r «uch purposes averap.' of three years pre.'oding the year in which sueh rdinp tn 'JO PREUMINARY NOTES. rCHAP. I. ■ i- * i iisnessmcnt shall be made ; nor on uccouut of loss not loniicetcd with, or arising out of, such tradu, manufacture, advciituri; ur coutern, nor on aecount of any capital withdrawn therefrom, nor fur any sum employed, or intended to be employed, as capital in such trade, manufacture, adventure or concern, nor for any capital employed in improvement of premises occupied for the purposes of such trade, manufauture, adventure or concern, no.' on aecount, nor under pretence of any interest vvhidi miglit have been made on such sums, it laid out at interest, nor for any debts except bad debts, proved to be sui'h to the satis- faction of tho cummissioncrs respectively, nor for any averatre loss beyond the actual amount of lojs after adjustment, nor for any sum rceoverabli- under ai. insurance or contract of indemnity. (And see so^. 1.59.) Fourth. In estimating' the amount of the prolits and gains arising,' as afore- said, no deduction shall be made on account of any annual interest, or any annuity or other annual payment payable out of such proKta or gain-. AlrzuHilriu liaUr Cu. v. Mus'jruir, 11 Q. 1!. U. 174. Slco.nu C'ASt. -The duty to be charged in respect of professions, employ- ments, or vocations not contained in any other Schedules of this Act [with special rules]. TiiiuD Ca.si:.— The duty to be charged res|)ect of profits of an uncertuiii annual value not charged in Schedule A fwith special rules]. KotuiH Cask.- The duty to be charged in respect of interest ari.-^iiiL,' from securities in Ireland, or in the British plantations in America, or in any other of Jler Majcsly's dominions out of (ireat Uritain and foreign securities— except such annuities, dividends, and shares as are directed to be charged under Schedule C of this .Vet. Tho duty to be charged in respe -t thireof shall he computed on a sura not less than the full amount of the sums (so far as the same can be computed) whicn have been or will be received in (Jreat Britain in the current year- without any deduction or abatement. FiFTli Cam:.- The duty to be charged in respect of jwase^sions in Ireland or in tho British plantations in America or in any other of Her .Majesty's dominions out of Great Britain and foreign possessions. Tho duty to be charged in respect thereof shall bo computed on a sum not less than tho full amount of the actual sums annually received in Great Britain, either for remitt-iiiees from thence payable in Great Britain or from property imported from thence into Great Britain or from money or value received in Great Britain and arising from property which shall not have been imported into Great Britain or from money or value so received on ere>..i, or on account in respect of such remittances, property, money, or value brought or to be brought into Great Britain, computing the same on aii average of the three jireceding years as directed in the First Case, without other deduction or abate- ment than is hereinbefore allowed in such case. Sixth Casi;.— Tho duty to be ciiarged in respect of any annual profits or gains not tailing undir any of tlie foregoing rules and not charged by virtue of any of the other Schedules contained iu this Act [with special rules] . Supplementary Provisions. The following Rules which appear iu tho same seotiou may uUo Ih) nieiilioued: -^ lU. INCOME TAX. V\ "First. Ill cstimutiiig the balaiKc of tin" profits or giviin to bo chargod iminlini: to ultlicT of tlic First or Jit-.-oiid Cases, n„ sum shM be sit against or iloductcd from or allowed to be set against or .Icductcd from such profits or -aiiis for any disbursements or expenses whatever, not beinu' nioney wholly Mid cxclu.-ively laid out or expended for the )mrposes of such trade, munufae- lurc, adv.nture or concern, or of such profession, employment, or vocation, nor •ur any disbur-'-'ients or expenses of maintenance of the parties, their families, ,r .^alilishmc ,= nor for the rent or value of any dwellinif-house or doiiielii|,, fraternity, company, or society would be chargeable if acting on his or their own behalf. i!y ^e^t. 40 of the Income Tax Act, 1842, it is enacted that, • all . . . t.impanics . . . whether corporate or not corf jrate, ahaU bo chargeable with ,u,li and tho like duties as any person," and certain officers thereof are re- quired (sect. 5!) to make the recpiisite ret- liy sect. 41 of the same Act a y person lent in [the United Kingdom], wl.c'ther a subject of Her Majesty or u be chargeable ie i!ie name of .ii.y trustee . . . , or of any factor, a„ or receiver havi. he receipt ..f any prohts or gains arising as herein meutiomd and belonging to suih pel sun . . . Foreign Investments. By the Income Tax (Foreign Dividends) Act, 1842 (5 i: 6 Vict. c. 80), it is enacted tliat, "All persons intrusted with the payment of annuities or any dividends or shares of annuities payable out of tho revenue of any foreign state t«. any persons, corporations, companies or societies in Great Britain, or acting Uicrein as agents, or in any other character," are to make a return of the same as therein mentioned, and are to pay tho duty on such annuities, ic. out ..f the moneys in their hands on behalf of tho persons entitled to tiie same, and tii j i !»2 I'KKI.IMINABY NOTES. [Chai'. I. i>y 16 & 17 \ iot. c. .'il, ri. II), tlitMi! prnvisiiins aru extended to '■'all interest, dividends, or other animal |iayiiii'nt.- i.ayable out of or in renpect of tlic atoeks. funds, or shares of any foreii;n lompaiiy, society, adventure or eoneern," and intrusted to persons in the I'nitcd Kinpiluni for [layment. I!v 24 6i 2.) Viet. c. HI. s. 38, the«> provisions are extended to interest, .luidends, and annual p.iyments payable out of or in respe^'t of sto.'ks. fundi!, -hares, and .securities rjf any colonial company, soriety, adventure, or eoneern. intrusted ti any person in the I'nitrd Kinifiloni for payment. .\iid liy set. y of 2'J Viet. e. .Ili. the aliove provisions are extended to di\Iili'n(ls and intere-t when the title of the person to whom the same may he pay.ible is show i by registration or entry of the n.iuie of such person in any liooli or list ordinarily kejit in the I'nited Kinjfdom. \nd Ijy 31 Viet. c. 28, r.. 5. the ;irovisions as to interest ])ayablo in tin I niled Kinjrilom arisinif out of a loreiifn company or eoneern are extendoii t'l annuities. pen->».. (1901) A. t . '■ li^isidcncf " of « compRuy I{olViriiiu' ay:aiii lo StlioduK' D, .sol out in |)art supra, p. 88 et seq.. Olio would liiivi- lliou;jrlit lliat a coiuiiany I'oriiiP'I under (he Companies (^(/onsolidation) Act, 1908. or uudcr any of tlio [jrecedinj,' Acts for wliicli that A( i is suhstitutcd iiid having:: its n'oistered ollicc within tln^ linit.oil ixiti^-dom.and lioiiio- a sulijoct of His Majf •■; y,and ftijiablo of obtainiii"? froui the proper Court in the I'uitod Kingdom an order conlirmirip an alteration of ol)jects or a reduction or reorganization of rajiiral. or an a'ran rosidemo, ami that in reality a cuinpiifiv io>idf~ lit it^ liUiiJ otlico. tliiit is when- llio lOiitiul of i;s ,i(liiiiiii-trati\ l.jsino-^.', rests anil is oxeiiisfJ— tlioiitrii its iiiiuiul'uetuiiii',' or tra.liiit; biisiiit'ss i> carried on ciscwiicrf— an in ietfntiiiiing siuli rf^idemo. Sio Craeiui SuliJutr Co. v. Sirhnhoi. and ( nUutta .lute Mills Co. v. Sicliohon (,1H7G., I Ex. !'iv. 4:28. The (juostiuu was lirsi raised in the kadini; case of Ccviui .s»//,/i/// (v.-«.. ( o. V. Swliohon and Calcutta Jute .V(7/.s' Co. v. Mcltoison (187ti., ■^" ',';*,"„,;^ I Ex. 1>. l-ti- Each of the cunipauios in those two ca-es was formed /««- r under the (.'ompauies Act, 1802 (now replaced by the Act of UtO.s i Willi a re-isteied ollico in England. The bu-iness was carri.-d on abroad, where tlie prolits were made, but was controlled and directed [■v uieelings of menilers and diioctors held in En!,dand. Only par! uf the i)rolit.s was remitted to the United Kin^rdom. On the-^e facts, both comjianios contended that they were liable to income tu.x onl_\ uii the proportion of the jirotits actually received in the United Kiiiirduni but this conteuti'>:i was overruled and it was held tha' both companies were ' rtifiiliiKj iu the United Kin<,'dom " within ■Siiicduio D, and were liable to pay iucoimi ta.v upon the whoh (if their prolits wherever earned: that tlio test of residence was no; iho situation of t!i(? registeied olHco nor where the company's tradin<: uf manuiailuting was carried on: that a company ro-ides where Its real bu. 717, in uluch ca.-e it was held that an En, ami San I'nulo lha:iLuii Hail. Co. v. Curler, (18'Jtil A. ('. .'il; and Alexandria WaU'r Co. v. .t///vr/»(U-c i^lSSl i, 11 il B. I). 171; Bank of Mexiru V .\ythori,e. til L. T. IU). A iiMdiii<4 b> iho Inland lle\enue Commissioners that a compiinj iisteied abroad is resident in iho United Kini'iloui on the ;j;roiin(l Jiat Uie control of th,' comi.aiiy is in En;,^land i- conclusive i f ih. 1 . ...t" |! -evidence to sui'port it imerican Thread Co. v. Jcyte, 28 T..L. 11. 31 PKKLIMINARY NOTKS. i C'llAT, 1 'i I •;«■■ I Tho onus of proving residence in tlie Liiiiioil Kiiigdmn is nn iljf Crown. All. -Gen. v. Alexandria, h. R. 10 Ktj. 2f). Having regard to tlie loading ca^c above rol'crrdl to, it would sccni by parity of reasoning tli;it ii comininy. ihougti regi^lorod in the United Kingdom, if it has no bourd lU diicclui^ ur <'.\ti(uiiM' hero, and diH>s not liold any poiii'ral niootiugs of rliiirohoMprs lien', i.r carry on busiiic-s here, docs ii,il reside in the liiiiK'd Kiiigduin (■If tl].' |)iir|iuses oi' Scliodulc I). Exercises a Trade. .>i'c iianiiiiaph Ui ui .Sriicdnle I), o//"./. |i h'.K Tho iiii'iiiiing of tlio o.spit's^ion cxorci.so il.> irado lu Silic- dido I) is also niaUuial, for wlictlior a company resides or ions both as regards companies constituted in the United Kingdom and foreign companies. Of these, one of tho most important i> San Paulo Brazilian Rail. Co. v. Carter, (1890) A. G. ;il. In th.i! case tim company was registered in luigland but its .'ailnay wa- in Brazil, and was worked there. Tho dii(>ctors purciiased and .icni nut to Brazil materials fir die purposes of the railway, but the general control of the company was in Enirland. ' It seems t" me," said Lord Ilalsbury, L. C. lal p. -iS:, ■iha'.. as v.a-> said !• Cuckburii. ('. .1. in tiie ca.^c of iS'»//('// V. Aitornry-Gcueral, oli. & N 711, ' it i.' probably a (ptostion of fact where the trade is carried on ... In Brazil the payments are received, and in Brazil tic:' p.i-- sengers and goods are carried, but tho form of tiading laii make ji' dillenmco. . . . The person who governs the whole coinmcriial adventure. . . . The person who decides what shall be <1oik' in respect of the adventure; what capital shall be invested in the .id- ventur«': on what terms the adventure shall be carried on: in ^llort, the pei'son who, in the .strictest sen.se. makes tho prohts by his skill or industry, however di,->tant may be the iield of his adventure, is tiir person who is trading. Tiiat person appears lo nie, in this ca^<\ to be the appellant com|)any. ... It appears to me that tlii> :i)i[iellant company is carrying on the trade in London, from whii h It issues itjs orders, and so governs and directs the whole commercial id\cnture that is under its superiuieudcnce." See also London Uinil. m IN«;i>MK TAX. 't.'-i 2 i\ oi Mi'ikc V. Apllwrpv, ilS'Jl) 2 Q. li. .iTH; \\,il.-,i,u v. Sand u; and lldll. ilHOSj 1 Q. B- •■l-'ii; TUchhT d (it. v. Aidliorpe (IsH.'.j, S2 1.. T. K14; uud I'omDwrij and Greno \ ■ Aiitlim ^ic (,1K80>, Jti L. T. JJ A tompaiiv legistcv-oil nbroail, but liiiviiifj its Ikm.I ollice in [.omlnn, wlioio llif raeetings of the directors arc lii-kl uud whoro tiio diroctiriK ;ii,.l coiitrolliiip pouiM i- oxoi-'i-^ed. i-< a-ic-sablc li> iiKoiuo t.i -ii rli'whult'ofits jirolil-tiH ' u person rosidirifr in llio Lnilod Kiii^duui uilluii t!if iiieaiiiiiy: of Schodulo 1). s.; .\i„n;r.i,i Thrr.id lo. v. Joifcc-, 28 T. L. R. 2M, Vvh. I'.tlL'. It has, liowpvoi-, been hold in the Quoeu's Bench Divi-ion, applying: :li.. piiufiplc of Colqtthoun v. Brooki. 14 App. Cas. 4'J.!, that whero A ■oiiipany. residont here, is a partner or a sharoholdcr in a (oiiccrn ^\vA\\ carried on outside the United Kingdom, the prohts of the ...mpany are chargeable under tlip Fifth Case, and acioniingly that iho company is only liable in respect of what it actually looeives in the Inited Kingdom. And it is not at -\11 uncommon, whore the iiniieitaking of a company regi.stei-cd hero is situate abroad, to vest I ho ^aiuo in a local company in exchange for shares therein, with a lieu to bringing the case wiiliin the Fil'ili Case. Wlierc lliis is done, jiL'olits made and retained abroad for resorvo, or for improvcmcnl • lud capital expeuditure. or for distribution among sharcholdor> or ■ icuitors abroail. escape the lax (unless il is shown that the conir.il .1' the company is in the United Kingdom). Tlie following decisions .supported this view. Wiiere an Eugli-h iompauv, \\hich carried on no business of its own, owned all the -harps hut ^e^eu in a foreign coniiiaiiy larryintr on business in a ("■■ri'iirn (oiiiitrv, and the foreign com|)any, on a dividend being de- ilared hv the Knclish - li jlders as woio resident abroad, and the English company directed •':e dividends aeeniing to it from the foreign fompanifs lo bo paid .M,|1 h"M I'.iiu-! ..i I. -r>! Miy ■ sbM-r* l,y my T. IM.l. M. M. 'M I'KRI.lMIN'AKy NOTK-S. [OlIAP. I. -I- lii||f ■ \ '*t ■: i to bankure abroad for di^tributiuu uriioiiir its tiiit'ii^'u Mliarulnjldei»: ii was hohi that tlio jirolits ol" the Kn),'lisli ( oiupaiiy caaio witliiu .Vliciliiii' 1). l-'il'lli Case, llial tlii! iimtiovs iplaiiiod aliroail for 'li.-.- trihiitioii iiiiioii;,' uliaiulioldi'i-^ lesidciit abinad wuio not ii'' i.iviubsfnuonlly hold lliat where un Kii^cli^h Loni|iany uunt nearly all tin' share- in a liiri'i;;n <'()in[)any, and has toiuplom i ontrni and diri'iliiii; jinwcr uvn- llio atl'airs of suih forfij^n lunipany, it (the Kiigli>li < iiiniiaiiN > is lialilo In jiay imonw tax uimn the wliulc prolits, and not meiely upon thiii part ol' tho prolits whidi i-. traii-- mittod to Knglund. A/jIIkiiiii- v. I'ctir SchneitJiofnu Hiiicri/ Cu 80 li. T. ol),"); .S'. Loain lireticriin \. Apllioific, ?!• 1- T O'lL'. TliLSr two decisions appear to ignore tho iundainonlal dl-iiiuiiuu botwci'i! II conipanv and ii- sluiivholdirs (siipr., (\s'j:,) '2 I'll. .IJ.; Tho authoril\ of the cuscs is luuth shaken by 'he decision of ilio Court of Appi'ai in Kodak Ltd. V. ( hi:l:. I VMir.) 1 K. l). m:,. In that ca--e Kodak, Lid , cariying on business in the Lnilcd Kinirdoin, owned U8 per tent, of the shares in a foreign company, which gave it a preponderating inlluenco in tho control of tho foreign conipuny, the remaining shares being lield by independent persons, and there was no evidence that tho English company had ever attempted or had power to control or interfere with tho managomnnt of tho foreign company fitherwise titan by voting as sharehohlcr Tho Court of Appeal held that tho foreign company was not carri.'i! on by tht . Inglish company, and was not the agent of the Engli-ii oirrilcr v. Sttinlcij ^19U8,) ■! is.. B. «y. Tho company iregisteied and resident in England) owned all the shares in a German company. Tho Uerm.ii' company out of its prolin in one year set aside the sum of l.i.OOo/ to meet deterioration in patents. Tho coniuiissiouers found tha' the English company controlled the German company, that the heaii and seat and directing jiuuor of tho English company wore at it- registered oUitie in London, and that the entire business of tli Gorman company was carried on by and was the busino'-s and pro- perty of tho ap()cllant company, and that the prolits of tho German company wore tho prolits of the appellant company, and that lhi.s sum of la.UUO/. was proiits within tho meaning of the Income Tax Acts and thai ait tiiu proat^; of thu Cermaa company .should be assussC'J INX'OMK TAX. niilii'Cii n'y:anl lu tlit' mode wl' upplti atloii ol hui h pnitilx. Walton, ,J.. Kin-nliTi'il lliitt I III" cniiimi-oiiiiMMs wnii' wikiij;, iiiitl on a|i|ioal tin- CiMMi 111' ApiM-al took the saiiit' VHuv, uu(l i'i>iisiil((I thai tlio Kii'jli-i|i M)in|.iii\ «a- iiiilv lialilc to pay tu\ mI' iIk' iTiiiiaii ciiiiipaiiv a-. Iiuil Imh>ii loci'ivoil in tliis lounlry, thai 1- [:i NH. ihi- Ciiml loiisidiin-d thi- u-sHosMnicnt iiiiy;ht In lio unilci ilii: Kitiii Case. Tlic Cduii oinsidorod that tlio niuro tact that the Kii^li-li r(iinpaii\ had u;J) 2 Q. B. '19!l, in wliiiii il uav |ii>M that tho term " foroi).tn possession " in tho Fifth ( ..M. iiiriii.lc^ tho income of an Ku^flish company dorivod from in- \i-liiii; aliKiad in shares of various compauios, Kn;;li-.li and foroiun S.. I...., Iho lorni includos incomo dorivod hy an Kinrlisii compan\ in'iii I partnership Lonstitiilo.l and carried on ahro.id by person- M'M.hii..; aliroad. Cohiiilinun \. Uionl.s (188'.t). It .\pp. ('as. (ii.t Schedule D. Profits and Gains how Estimated. I'i'i ilio imrpuses of S.diodulo I), •profits and g:ains of a oon.ern K>tim!.(i,.M..» iiiiiM ho ii-ioitaineil on onlinary -• -inoiplos of cDniniorcial trading." l'".*'" '""l I'i'i l.fiid ilajsbury, L. C, (Iresha,, LifiuSor. v. .s7//i'r.v. ( I«!»2^ .\ "c. ^"""'' :ii |i. ;ili;. Siibjcil. howevor, to tho spooial provisions of Iho .Arts wliii h exfiressiy disallow cortuin deductions. The Aft plainly contemplates t.ie propii • 'in of a balance shod Ml "hicli proper tradinj; disbursonionts am liabilities are lo be sol iii;miisf tnidr assets, so that tho surplus (if any) of Iho latter will rppn fill tlie assessable profits or },'ains of tho concern . . . . IJiilo .{ ■■I tlio liisi case (above I specifies certain items which a trader ini^Iii »;'iMiallv oiu.uc:h for hid own private purposes insert in tho dol.il si'lc ..f il„, .sliee,. .^,^,l ^,^.^^^^ ^^^^^ ^,,,,^^ ^,^^1, ^^^^ ^^_ allowed as '''"III. lions in estimatinn: not profits for tho purposes of income tax ' I'i'i- l,.,r,l Watson. Ibid., p. Ml. Whoihor there bo such a thint; as profit or srain can onlv bf. .•s.,.,,aino.i In setting.- against the receipts the expenditure or obli- ,!!■ •♦K I'KKK... 'NAHY N lif ii'>i«'«M'i| i« llii' liiiliiiH'i' i)f till- (fiiilii-. iir liiiiin- III' ii liiifli'. lliiil i-. In tiiv, the >iiiii Icll lifter Niililnicfiiiy tin- |lll)|H'r llodui liilll^ lllllll lll4' |l|illilN 1)1- ;;;(lll«. Tln' All l|lll'» not .ilfiiiiiiili\<>i\ 'tall- »lial lii«M"i iiiav !«• ili-iliicU'd. It liii im- incii'lv m'y:ali\<' iiitm illation." I'l-l- L'Uil I.od'Iiiiiii. I. (' . Shnnii • I < n \. Wuoililirlil. i I'.HMi) A. ('. UK. A" Tiiiiliiijrly. it »iiH lii'lil, in IIm' (in-xhiini i,mi'. ahovc icII'iiimI tn. lliat an in^iiraiirn (iiiii|iaiiy uliiili laiiio! un llii* l)ii-iiri<>ss nf ^>l■llillL: .iiiiiiiitif~ alllmiiuli liiiiiiiil lit ri'fiiil till* aiiiiiiMl witli it~ i'('ri>i|ii< in ii'spcil of flic |)mi Ini'M'-iiionoy of iiiiiiiiilii-> ■'iilil iluriti^: tin" liin-f M'iir«. \sa-< t'lititU'il to ildliit \\w acioiiiit uilli iu |iayni*'iil.-< in ii>~|ii'i't of aiiniiitii.'-i i|iiiin«x till' ■iiiiiic (XMiod. It v\a-< iii'u'tHi lliat llif ]iiiynii"nt-< ill ii"|«Mt of till' aiiniiilici himi' williiii iIm- wouI* of llii- Foiuili Hiili' lo till' KiiMl ( 'aM> alioM', uliii'li |ii'o\iili'^ lliat im diMlnilion >liall Im' iiiailf on ar'oiinl of any annual iiiliMrst, or an\ ariniiit\ or i>tlii>i' aiiiiiial jiaviiii'iil |ia\alil<> out of •^iicli |irolii^ or o-niiis. Itnt ii v..i^ iilri<'il thai llii' mil' in iini'^tion «a-> ili'«iuni'il to iium-i mii Ii a i ih- 1-^ tlial in wliirli a Irailor !. nl ('oiitrart«>rson who hail inailr a loan on tin* IcriiiM of i<>c'*>iviii<;° >'iirli |ia\iiii'nt. anil olhi^ wliirli it was not iit'rt'^iary to ilclinc > |K'r l,oiil WaHon i, ami wa~ not iiilrodncod lo disallow a dodui^tiou in iosjh'cI of the cosf of ohiaininjr llip iinoiiio. You call no niiiw rcfux' lo laki- that 10-1 inin your i'iilisid(>rutiuii. when asi ortainiti^' the Italaini' of |iro|it- .iiid '^aiiis. lliuii you could the cusl of the coals or llic corn of tho coal ini'icliaiil and corn iiiorihant in asci'rlainin<:; uhat an- tin' |irolll-. li'oni his Iradi" ." I'cr l.onl llalsliury, Ihkl.. p. ;iir,. The di'cisiiin in ihi- cu'-o was in accord «ilh llic |)rinci|)l(' oslali- lislifid ill Miisi'ii Jhiilrs v. IjKnis. H .\\>]>. (as. Mi)l, that the laxpayi'r is entitled to ik'duci froiii tho f;ios-i jirolits i.t his trade or linsines^ ihe «'.\|ienses necessary to earn ihi'iii. sulijeci in ihe ney-alive provi- sions of the Act. So. loo, interest on li'inporary and llucliialin;;' loans may |)roperh lie deducteil just as iiiiich as rent of olljces or hire of iiiachiuory. FnrniiT \. SroltiMli A iiicrimil Co.. ( litl2i A. t'. p. IIS. lint interest oil deheiitures for a terrii of years lannol lie deducted. Ali'.rdiiilrin "' ■!■)■ (it. V. MuxiiKive, 11 ks. Sim liixunuiri' Ottirr v. ('Iark\ House of ].or«lK. 7 March. H»lL'. \V. N. iJ'Jl^i 7'.>. In that case the cimipany treated lit |)er ceni. of the pieiniuiii receixcd each year as a fair allowance i INCOMK TAX. m 111 i."|MTl nl III.' mif\|.iii'(l ii«k>. mill iIk'K' "'is t'\ iilr'i. <• lli:ii lliis wan it f.iir all.ittaiiif Hiuv. .1 , Ih'I.I thai iln' ai iiii Mii-lit I., lie all.iufil ill a'K-iiaiiiiiiK ill" 'oiii|.aii\ - y:aiiis. ami llii- IIhiim' nl I.mi.js ii|>lifM llii- il<">i«i'' 2 K. I! '.<\-2. I'»ll At l.-.tl All iiiiiiiiil.v "liiiii r.|ii-.'.sciil- |iaill\ in. mhm' and paiilv .ajiilal i- , ,; .,i\al.l.' a- r.'-ar.|- ill.' lalliT )Miili..n. >.'(./-'/■'/ hii lii.li,i \. Srohlr, I H«i;i, A. »• .''.1. lU MM'I. :J:l .if lilt' Cii'l.imsaii.l liilainl l{i'\.'iiii«' A.I. !>!.••• '■"'•' ^'i'l I...-.- •» ... Hi. • WIi.'I ' aiix |ht.soii sliali sustain a hx* in anv Ma.).', i n- '""*"■ la. •lint' <|Vs«iiin. ciiiiil.'Vim'iil •<{■ \..r.iii..ii il .-liall lie lawful f.'iliiiii loaplilv d' tli'' ' .aiiiiii--i.iii.'r- I"!' an a.liU'liiK'iil ..f hi- lial.ilily l.v i.'fi-ii'n. i' 1.. Ih.' 1..-- an.l \" ili.' au'i;i''i;ali' aiiLiiiiil nf hi-, iii.-.inir ' <>ii lli.'-c \\ni.l> il wa'* h.l.l liial lli(. M'ili..ii il...- iml a|i|il\ 1.1 a |.ani.iilai- lii-< in a-.-.'ilainiii'j- ili.- lin.lits ..f I'll' paili. iilar liaii-acli.ni \vhi< h lias m. inn'.l in the .•.iiU'-i' .if Ihi- liii.-iii 's--. hilt t'Mi .j:iMiiMal his- n'-iillinir frmn ih.' Ini-iin'-s. ihat i.-. a I..S- a- t.i llic inlal i.'-iill "f the Im-iii.— ' ..|i rai i..iis /.'. ' v. t'i,illlllisKi'>iiri X. !l| 1. 'i" '.II W'licrc ill' lin-iii.'— nf a i.iiiiiiaii\ ...n-i-t- in pari <<( liiyiii- and lV..Ht ..n -nl.- ^cliiii'^ iiiv.-lnu'iiN, it has hri'ii h.'ld that innlil on --ah' nf inv.-t- m.'iil.s i- 1.) he lir.)ii).'lil inl" aciuiinl. Sarllicni A.-'-^iinnur Co. v. Ii>liurl Itrniiiir U'll Si I, K. :!.'.0: .s.n//;>7/ hnr.ttiii.iit Tni.it v. Siin-cyor. i;'i Sc..: . S -s. ( a-i--, till s.'iii-. 2ii2. ( ,ini|iai.' lli.'s.' la-i's willi Sicviiis \. Iliiilsoii" lUi'l ( (I. 101 I.. T. '.Ili. iiiil a i.aiiiiaiiv f.iniii'd fni' iiihl .'i prndiulinn is not. i liar;.:i'ahl A -mil nf inniii'v icpic-.'nliii;^ iniifil on a ic-sah' nf its csialcs to a iii'w . 11111), any. Tflinni '-loltorc) Iti'hbir Si/ndinitf v. F,inii<-r il'.tlD), S. (:. '.Klii, *'t. of Scss. Sn. tun. wlicK- a jici.-oii hiiys ii|i ill.' iiiidi'itakin;^- i>'-- -11- al a in-nlit In an.ilht'i' . niniiany, and the liaii-ae-linn is niio ..f .-cvcial lilu' liati-ailinns in tlic nrdinaiy coiiiso of hi- lin-incs.s, ihi- |ii'nllt is .har^'oaiili' In im-niiu' ta\, lint ii.ii uli.'ic llic hii viTi;;-ii|) anil ic-si'lliii;;- of llio lin-ini'ss is an i-ohitvd lian-ailion. ami imt nii<> .if a .s.'iii's of iiki' traiisaitinii-. Whoic, loo. a cnniiianN !<■ nii-lnictis an.l -u pari- vith it- Inisiiics- fni' a cniisidiMaliun oxrt'jiliii;,' tlio aiiiniiiil of its paid-up rapiuil, .hdils and liabiliiio.-, the o\ii's.i is ;i;;! ihuri:iM!i'K' a- profit . As to th<> tax boin;:- payuhlc wlierc tliori" is incunu iiii.h'i- one ln'ad hill a loss oil fhc hii-iii.'-.s u- a whole, soo Aniiilwje v. Muoic, ( 191)0; II 2 %W:- l.''.: W ik:?? 100 I'KKLIMINAKY XO'I'KS. ClIAI'. I. Dvduetio Tl Arl,- ■\iVl I 111 a li'u lii- illiriti k liat . Illil\ nf .11 d. I'liiiu^lii'^ I'l'i- tlic iiiii-l 1'; iiogiuivc iiilomialioii. supra, \>{k iS'.l, I UL'ilf II IK tl iV 11.' Vil I. I I. Ml (hiiliit; I 1... .-. I: '(liu-lii)ll^ ale 111 III ar ol' anv iiiarliiiii'iy ami plaiM. illowci Am ' lUIUllI SlfdlJ^flli (»((/.m;/;. I iH'.i!), 1 (.). i;, hi;, ilniil.llill (li'lii- Mi.n Im' o^liiaali'ii. Sci I . SI m llic Aii.l Ta\ All. IH.j.!. Li> 111 aliali'iiifiil.^ I'm ■ r l«'in|io~l. ii All. ISl-J A> til all'iwili:^ I'm iiilcii'-t mi the aiim mil 111 nil' cliiil iull> ulliiuri mil ti)ii.>iili'iiiiij I. .1/ ilai/nii'i' Mil; 1 Fi lal i> iIk' lil'i'ol' tlio plant, .■^(.m' Lcith. [full. dr. Cn. th .sorii-). HIT: W. X. I Court 111 Scssum. .V IUiti.
  • ■ \. Lrsli, T. L. I{. 10 1; i;i:; bi .1 r, i/iti-^iiliir (III I OiUiitc.l < l.r.si;,; H2 1; ClDU. •"I'liiinlc ar '.I I,. T. 11,S. What tin iidiiii;' tl •i)iiimi»iiiii<'i- III In ill) is tl what i> just and rcasonalik"; llicv arc not liuiiiiii tl) take an avciauc ol' the di'i>r<'(iali<)ns during- the tlir»>e [irci-vdin;^ _vi'ai>. ( iiiiiinl SUvmsliiji ( n. \ . ('(jiilsaii. ( IH'.l',); 1 (). V> i *:ist> wllcr- (li-ilui'iiniiv ilisililllWIil, ill' iii'i;ati\c iiiloriiiiilimi. (k'diirtiij IVU ll'll'llt' il li i> lni ilir luiisi |)an 11)11 laiuod ill ilif Tliiid and Foiulli l{ult'> to Fiist I'asf, v/(/;n/. J)]) 8!l. W>. Xuno can voJ for nimicv canioi I to lOsciAC lor cimHiiizcai •ics ,Fo»(/.Y V. Unnd;i>^;de, 1 E\. I). 2:!:i Im dopicriatimi ol leases yWutiivij v. Mitii)raci\ 5 E.\. 1). 211 i; or lor interest on Imnowi'd money, «liicli in substance is [laii of the coi;i|iaii\ - wiirKiiiL; ca|iilul I Alcidiiih ill til. V. Miisiiriii sonl mere teiiipuiary Inaii^; or lor ('.(/. debenture^ or delaMilure slock '. 11 (I. I! I). 174!. and doe^ not renin?- Iinniis ■apil, (.l/V- : It nil (\ dead 'I'i •I'l- Vo. V. Siiiik's, 2!i li. R. Sr. 1.11 i: or for past rent and mvallio.s >, llioiiijhluii. i( . (.'• Kirlji'ilrirl,-. II {). U. I). \'J\ : or, as a jjeiicral rule, for sinking' iieu [lits tCi/lliu'ss li'in ( II. \. Illail.-. li A|)p. (as. .'il.")): or for recoiipmenl of lapital ill il e\tracl4'd iiiinerii Mi<'li:a r II. V llill. I l'.»mii A. C. 181 Il for lia lance of annuity ]i; lit. 1 a sinking fund A'/r((/« fi'iiil. C \\ ffdit. 21 <>>. I!. 1). •") 18 I : or for costs of embankments to improvi- the rondilinn nf land, an! iml laci.dv l" juolert it from .sea or lidal river I //rt/,(7/(. V. lir preiuium iliiipe ■III/. '.] (>>. B. Div. 1441; or in respect of ii rued ,1 /•• , 187Gi, ;).") L 271 I for preiiiium jiaid for a lease [(HUiiIk awl Widln v. Cnhjiilii, ;i.! \V. |{. 2:)Hi (\ II ,'>iirlli I' < I iiiaiiaui'i 111 commutation as a rule. I'.ir lo^- on loans at intciie^l > Kii'iliih . linker. '.I'J L. T. .'(.Vi; or for a sum payable to /{oi/iil I ii-iiiraiiii' ( II. V. Wiil.ioii, ( 1S97) .V ( )f lii-d hi lu 'i!s,i\S'JS) or loi repair.-^ ol Ui-d lioucs : I>riru'iiut::; v. I,c;i7i'::ils, I (.). 15. '.1.') iC. A.ii; otherwise as to compensation paid to leiLint-s ol tied lioiises under sect. .'1 of the Licciisine- Act, 191)4 i.SinlHi v. Ltoit Ihcinnj ( II.. llMi'.ti 2 K. I! '."12; i I'.H 1 ' A. ('. l.)(h; or for EBB Illll.ll -'I'll- 1''"' INCOMF. I'AX. I C.i- iho li'^lil I" '■■' uhhr-liiiu-c iKCiiros, oi- till- CSpiMl^C tor ti< « liccii-i< Stifilllirrll \ ■ ^'1 :ii II (,y;i l,i,,. ,/,,»,s7o// Mf.iwl!li»' V. Aiidrr»>n. H'J 11 |ni' till' Mirii'irlor ot' ill, i,l(MH;il t" iii>i)li'atioiis 1 1 1 2 K . 15 I'.uM , I '.mm; : Cll. V. Jul- ilanius..- imi.l lor iii.imy rauMv a' 111,. Imililiii- iStninn .1 ' " ^ ~ti(lU "if liiw lll.lU'l ^ (■ (i« i; "!■ i'<"' <'^'''"i lirll. 1 I'.tiHi \. C. 18 r. HI' I'll' i'>^P< now |iri'iiii-i'- .-.5. ft. Ill' S(- (iriiiii tr Si'l'l •In 1 til ii j;iM'-it 111 ail mil W'oiiililit'ld. .ll i .Mitni:a I tu « F. Ill riMiinva I, ll, 1,1)1 lurriiiir Oil tlic ii; li(>r haiiil. u lii'ii' ail aiiiiii itv (c)iisj-i|> in pail 111' laiiital. iin'in 1(1 la,\ 1-^ mil V-^>"'^ lili. nil llial liar I . Sl-.rl-fl'dfl )f >'/(//(' V. >r' hh: I'.iUili A. ('. -^W- III \ iilhiiiibiii^il li'iihhfi I o. V I III, mil I! I'.Uiij. I . •-.l'. ^., ,,[■ Sr>-.. :'\|i<"ll-('' 111 Wt'W lin-aiHlNvat.liiii-paii ..I iIkm nmii, ilicl' estate. \v licri' ill"' liw- '>■«' ""' >'■' '■''■ ilioil the nililiiM' iMMiiiii:- Ptaui'- "I'll' " lldwcd. Ill (iiii'sl. I\ri-ii yt'llH-ihl- V. l-ux-Ur. .I'.'Idi I K. 11. 7l: (iitrilnitiniis pri •e.-i wi'io a l,y iiiaiiufacUiiois til an a-.ina llowcd to 1)0 (lodiictoil. (1 hv a lifoa.~siiiaiuo.iiiiiiia-,\ im (Uiii I'll- Uoi'iniii: 111' Miiiicv.s rop;! ,1' lidiiiis 1(1 paitiiipatiii';' p Irr'iilil riilUia' I- \;f. a^ allllUi ll pnilit- 111- U'-i"' ,|i,.\-li(,iaor>,aiva-M.— .iliU'ln iiimiii.' 11. 1.. .Liinl HiaiiiuolMi-M'iiliiii;! ImsI v. I.oiiiIdii .\ssiu;nitc( orj I „y.l. , ISS.-)), 1(1 Alip. (■ 'dA' h, ,il III,' r,iil,;l .• \;-...,i, siiih- H'lil <;,. \. Wiiiiir 1 (.). li. i: iii ii'iii X- to Jiiutiial sociclio' ,s7 ///<■•>. U App (as. .".HI. ami IS pi'lMU ~.iliif ii poii ol iiiioxi 21 (,). i!. I> "ilH. -No ilelmlioii .iiv.l' risks ulioii ihi' fads ,l„ ,ioi M-(inir.,i,. ii^Mlv llio -ami' (;,-,i,-i,il Arri.lfiil .\:.x,ii;ni<^- I «i I' I '.108 ' sUfllll. p. \ { -JiiT. .•\plaini'il 111 >"" Illsllll <)l>i' ■llllil' 1). ( t. IS ilea It with 111 ihi- ii'coiil laso' ri-i I- to till' am' ia\ on ilivii l.'Uils and iiili'ri'-l> d I'l'oiii -o'linlii's al'i I'liii-fiKii' I. Iff .1' inniii' .*>or/i'(.'/ /// \ . Ilisllll ji. Ii l-JJ; an I (,r,''-l>inii l.ii' .!•> I 1.. ,1. t). 1',. 'Iiili; 81 llhl,,,,.. ' I'.Mltil .\. f- 101 .\s t'l a I'onipaiiy s ii^ i( lu di'dii'l and ivlain iiiiiniii' la\ "iil ol divi'li'iids paid out „t in''ini."iMli'"oiiil'^«;i> "'" sect . ■d with iiix.iiH' tax ' <'.'/.. ilivii M ,,r .V'-t of IHHH, suiini. p. •ll lias ali'oadv Iclld.s fi-olll ollior roIlipallK -). s,M> '.IJ: aii'l l.iiiuliiii ('■III III II <'-l (Iciixcil Iruiii i\- Im-^iuc-s imt'-itiiiciils, lor iIh' liinydiii;'' nl the Art iimkcs jm di-liinlioii licluccii ilii' i ln~>- 1)1' iiiM'-'tiiW'iiN i\('(('~-;iiiv (ii irinx on llic liiisiui (I iiilicr iiivcst- iiKMil- ( Ifiiiiil. Mi'iliiiil iiikI (Iciii'iiil I. iff .if.-:iin(iiir Siiciffi/ V. ('mill. 22 (,>. I! I). 114: IJminnil. Lumlnii niiil dlnhr I iisiinniri' Co. \ lii'iiiicll. I'.ill 2 K. I! lllilllK'll III! ^I|>|>< ('. A.. 28 I,. U. Nn. 17; \V. N. , mi2 7.;. 'I'1k> ciiM' la>i lucnlioiic I iilliinii'il il II' \ ii'u i'\|iri'---i'M III llic ( nlllt 111 Sv^~iiiii liv l.ciiil Diiiicliii ill llcii'll V I'.diiihinfih Life I iixiiiinirf I'll.. .". 'I"m\ Cii-c-. 221. 22u. ;iiiil In ilii' I, Old l'ii'>iiloiii in Sciilfith IDI illllllf I II. II M r.nrii \ . MiImIi- 2ti Sr I;. K. S7: 2 Tux ( u>c n; .1 l.v Wiiirlii. .1. Ml .\iiriiii h I .III /•■ ic/rr iKiii; . u W . H .'.M; ;! Ta\ Ci-. 1-1 II II Ml 1 1\ iiil; :it till' priiliis miiiI '.jaiiis. I he |)iiilil> «liiiiilil '«' c^liiiniU'c a^ iiiilii~i\(' aii'l imi cxclii^ixc ul the iiiiiiiuiit ]i:iyiilp|c lor llii' yiMi' d iiiiojiH' la\. A sill 11,1 (,,IS ( Ml.-dl'll.. . I'.MMl A. <'. 111. I. 21 oi tlic C'li-^loiii- ami liilaml Kcvciiiii' Art. l.HMS a coiiiiiaiiv lia'l |io\\ci and -eel. |o o! ilic In il. Ill) Ml lliv h ■|'a\ .^.1. IS 12. mil' 'I'ax .\rl. IM.Vi: Inn \va~ not lioiinil to ik'diii I ilir iiiioiiii' ia.\ Irom dividfiiiN and iiilcic^l jiaxaliU- liy it. Till- Ad of IKSh allcK'd this. • N'ow what." -^aid Loid M.iiii-ii;litou in a rcri'iit ra^i-. ' lia< tin' Art ot i8H,S ically done? It i-i no lont^iT o|iional lov a |M'ison nlio luw to inaUi' an annual [lax iin'iit lo dodiu-t iiiionic tax; till' C lovMi llic ainoiiiit dodiuli'd iiiilc--^ iiaviiiciit i omcs out of iinoinc lie i- lioiind to niaki' till' dcdiiition and |iay ovcf i o \v ''' liiili lias already paid llic duly." Si'c Ln'iiliiii ( tHDil'l ('iiiuirH \. Mini iicil-ihiuriiil. t I'.tOl > A. (■ .V |ic'i-on re rn lilt;- intercut lioni wiii'li iihoiik la^ not lic'ii ta.\ I dciliirtod is lialili' to pay iinoinr \n\ ijn-n'on not u itlislandiiiii tin; duty lii'iii;^ iiiip..~i'd liy ^I'rt. 21 ol' tlic Inland Ki'm'iiiic .\it. I.S8.S. on till' iiorsoii |ia\in 'J- lln' inicrc^t ah lllllU'/lilii :ilf (fiiii)h' Wihini. I'M 111 1 K. IV 72.".. iinii.riiv. tliP Wlicrc a pal ln('i~lilp Inisincvv u,i~ loiiM'itcd in'o parlni'is rcrcix iii;^ -liair- in cM-liaiiuc tor llu'ii inlcic^t^. it v\a- lliiit lli(> ionipan\ had ' --iii i I'cdi'd "" to tin' hiisinr-^, .ind \\a- i li,i i lh' ■Ul ihli' on thai tooling . /.'///'i Fiiil.u-. 7 (,). I". I). IS.-, .\ lol npany trad idlll'^ ullll onr ~I|M1 not start a new l)ii-i tic an-i' I ^/l/,- ( I |o-o~ its s o. V. / III iw) mull' -liip anil laiv^ ai I'.iUi' 2 K. I'. '.12:1 pi her Miiihi.^liiii sic IHI- •.- to spii. tl 111 tiic (iiioiih' 'I'ax .\i|. 1H42. I'ji'iii witiiin ihr I iiiti'd Kiii'^iji XII flic • I. till III ot a lorciijii roin|iaiiy larryiiiff III lillsillc- till the I'llili'd K'ill;;d' III I- proiKM l\ ihuiucahli' ill hi s own naiin' in ri'spoii of |||i> piolils di'rivcd from triuh' in thi.s \V. X. n«08") iiHiiinsxiDiti'it (■(iiiiilry. sec ./mill's Wiiipafr «(■ Co. v < ['>'.>: 21 Rpttic. '.t.!!i. When fo!i'ii;n priniipajs 1011^1^11 '^oods from aliiuad for .-ale hy .la-ciit- in tlii- I ti\ I he 1,1 i' fait that I hi' ai;riil~ >i'll in their own INCCiMK TAX, t(»:< *:f iiic~ ilix's not iPlitno tli<> (iiiiK i)iiil> lumi lial.ility lo piiv iiitoiiio tin ii|..i Scliccliik" l>. S<'c H (//.«/«. \. Stindic(i)iil Hull. ( \H9H) 1 Q. 1'. /,()(■ W UMC :iii allowii '.It. iiud infill. |). l til tlic ciiiiinii Ih' <;laiit<'il liiit i-i rt'l'u^cfl. :i »iuiifis ciiiniiiaiKliiif; iIkmii k. prunt iiml ( iiDiliiissiniifIs 1)1 liKiiliir liir V. I nil cililv tln' .illnuiiwr l.s'.H A ( . ■>■■'. 1. A, I,, -cri. :,:) (it till' liicciinc Tax Ad. IHI-'. it wa-^ ln'lil lli.H a l„i-.nM «!!'• Iiad ilt'livcKMl witlioiit frauil. an imni-icrl statciiUMii ,.| lli- |ilcjlil- nr ;;a' iaii;i'aliM' Willi iiKonic lax uii(l<'r ,Srliiv|i|li' I) liirli, ihinii-li neuli,i:»'iin" /. imi>(i-C(l l>\ tlial iMcorii'ct. wa^ -(•(•iiiiii. am 1 that tlio sfdioii a|i|)li('il <> i Iv illiisoi \ slaloiiicnt i. .|cli\civ 111' a more fil a >tal('iii('iit wliiili puiiiorW an ll-(U'li\l'l\' 111 I net Ironi tM iIk tlio icvcisci I i-- iiitcniU'il to lie a line and 1 liv >(>rl . :,2. but wliicli is ('iicni"oii~ in (iiniiol V Till. (I'.Mliti 1 K. I! il'il ll-itin \ hv till' linns., of Lnrils. ( lUllH A. C. .Mt As In llic (Intics (ni Miini'>. ijiiai lies, (locks, watcrwoik*. lanaU iVc. »i'0 •> A- (i Vict. 1'. ."1.'). s. »>(». ami .'l/rT.vc.v Dofhs v. hum!'. H \\\ Oas H'.tl; lii/lini,!' Ciillii'iii Cn. v Fi>i)i'r. 7 (y M. I). -IHV r,,ll)i, hiiii <'o. V. Wiiik. •> Ap)) ('as. ;tl.'>; llntiiiiiUiii (nnl «'<). l„itiiiL\ H V- '* " *'■"■ ■/""<•■'>• ^ ■ ( ii-nmrthi'ii Sliilr di.. ■"> •.1.1; lliinix V. /^r//«^ lori... W. N. O'*'"' l«- V. Kirl.- Kx. Div. .\s In uddilioiial a^scssnicnls on a .siicccssi m In lin^inos-. s..(. Ii,'ll V Siili In as-es.^nKMil, see .-ecl. 4 of Taxes .Manaiiciuenl .\cf. 1J tn place of usses.snie!il. sect, "(.'t: as In errors, sect. '<'>: a.^ lo .illnuances nf assossnient-, sect . .")(i; us in a|ipeals liy person a>;yrieved IIM <'iii|iir!itiii duty iindn < 'us! I mis, ^ K-\, ISS.-.. PRKMMINAUY NOTK8. [Chai-. I. (uiitlor seel. 80 of Iiicdinc Tiix Act. I«»2), soi\. .'tl: n- to iiis<'> fur 'ppiriiiui iif Hijrli Cdiirt, Mort. 59. Production of Returns. .\> III urderiii^ |iruii|)i"i- ui\. Calling for Returns before Act passed. Ifi'liiiii.- iimv lie imIIciI f(ir iu any yciir licfoic tlic .Ail in iia-Nin); •jianlin;^- iniiinic ta.\ fur lliat yoar, f<(H' m'cI. liO of the ( uslonis ani.stj'rcd without the word "limited and on the fooliuL;- (hat no dividends are to he paid. ( itiiihil 'if I.dir Iti'iiwIoKj. 122 i). n. D. 27'l. Theiv in also an exci'jition in respect of property which, or I he iiiiomc of which, .sliull lie lecrally apiirojiriatcd and applied for any jinrpoNe lonnected with any reliirioiis peisnasion, or for an)' charit- aliie puipose. or for the piomotion of education, iitoratiiit', .scieni e or the line arts. See IiiUiikI [{rcfiiiif \ . Ftint'al, 15 A. (.", ;i.'i4, in which the Institution of Civil Kiif^ineers was lieM exempt. The holdinj; of examinations and ^rrantinjr diplomas in sur-jerv are not a ' pro- motion of science ' within suet. 11 ;(), of the (,'ustonis and Inlaml KeveniH' Act, 1885. Hoi/at Colli-iji' of Siir;ici>ii.s, ( 1809> 1 (). 15. 871; f. . .1. {). B. 705; 7!t L. T. 8!i. As to a cluh, see New Inircrxlti/ aliib. 18 (,). n. I) 720. (;0KPORATioN duty: I'OOK kmks. \s 1., piopcrtv net .Milirrlv apinoiinaK-d l.- !"■ api lin) to llio pri>- As 1(1 (li<" liioiK'i" '» „'1p of attt'-iiiiitr aiinual valin\ imoni". "i- )y,M< so,- >»<7V7 r"»W// r,vVAT( r'».'.. - hmu i -J K. H too 105 Inhabited House Duty. l.,,llv ,o>i,l..nlinl. I.umlm, ,u,.t W ,'sl,„n,^l,r lUinl, n. S,„;ih. ST ■ -p :,,,. ,;7 I 1' •>"<»■ rnhn lioiil: «i S,t,thiii,l v. l-oxirr, t... , V H->^'. Ma,U- .f ro. V. Wdsun, 4U W. H. .170; ^:, L. T 221.: „„,Arr V. nn.lr,..mm 2 (^ H. T.W,: <^r..n, v. /-;;;"''"';' i;;|^ A (• ;!h;C S/v/.'s- v. .!/;,/'i. X\ I- T. 2(i2. Poor Rates. |<\ii"(l ill Pour iiiti." |iui>.n,Mo ,.„.Ur .:t Eliz. a.h l>aiMi for tlH' i.-lir|- .'f llie pool'. 1>.v taxalion ol .'voiy inlml>ilaiit, ^. ,^_ ^ , ■ ar. and ..tli(>r.s and of .'very oioujiu'r ..l lands, limine-, l„ialc. iMuiiiialioiis of tillic-. <":<\ unin- "i- >al II til,, paii-h. (n !>,. -atlKTcl .alt ..f til," |>aii-li a.mi tu il> al.ility. Th,. I'ai.M-liial .\»." fnitlirr iirnvid"s •• Tha, no rutc for ti.e .rlief of the puoi- la ICnu'lan,! ami Wal... >l,all bo alluw..d by anv jus,i,.« or be of uny force wl,i,h shall ...a be a.a.le up.a. an ..tnaa.e of ,l,e „;.l annual value ,.f the .sev.Tal bere.litan...nts related ther..u.. o. that .. to rent at «hi.!. th.- same n.i-ht n.as.aiably be .-xpeeted to ht Irom fr ,r all u-^ual tenants' rales and taxes and tithe -IlKMll- A,l. IS.'.li '•'■ A Will. 1. !n;i. !• the II year. iininiat.ition renteharu-e (if anv „ and deduetin? th.refroin the prebable annual avera-o ■ o.t „f ihe repair,, insi.ran, ,■. and oth..r exp..nse. ,if any'. n.M-essary to inan.ln.n th, m ,i,d s.ieh rent ; provid,-d always, that niilhin.,' her.an .untamed lies or ilillerent ri'lativi' liabilitii-s rdlnu' to «-hl.h .lilf.T.'nl kinds „f Imredi uiu'iits aiv now by law in a state to eianni; shall hi' ei.iir.trued to alter .ir atfeet the prineii ;il rat any i ahie ai-.'i.i I Ion As i„ evid V I,, alter iiio.^s ,.>liiiiah'd iisial ,.n aina'al, sfe //- d Son V. li a,Vi// .l.s'.sr.s. il! iV "i.'! \ Id I-, '■'/'■.•. <(v. As.- ( [C'llAH. I. and Hill foil V. iS7 fi;». ' l!t(MI. 1 (,» B. ;;H!t. A(.itj.i 111 u\i l,v\i. .S/,,,7// \. ifiihmniid. ( IHiMO A (' UN: .•l//o« I'llmii ( oiiiiiil V. >'/;/.(•/■. I HM)4. 1 K. n. (;7«. JUiKAKWAlEU AM. I,AM>I\.; SlAM:. <,(//,,,•.,/,■; /JllllxHIl V. J'li/nipliiii I'liimi.iy.i ■). I". J!l7. Canai . C.7, I.. T. .s:.. 'tlliiui ijdii laliMM plot-^sold. •I I „ « (^ IJ. .-.I.- and roi ivoyod plot- lui- ■■r.ive- siil.ji'it t4, III ll'-IICll llf tli< l'o\i. Mini-, liriiuii v. Ilittliriliinu Axsfssniriit (ini,iiiiH,-c H.i L. T. I'.i.l. Dock. Siniii.-ni Hininnii /'; ((.v/crv \. Sinui.si'n riiiiiii, UT L. T. 5«."i. W illi:ili>i -1>, Si-r l.i,,„l„ii nil, I lutliii Ihirl,.- V. I'ui.lnr I L. T. ;!7i J>i. /•'( hliiil. <((. Co. \- . t'limJiiiiii r iiimi. 8.'i liiii,iill,'i\ I HIOl I A. C. I7."i -^; '.S ■ { 1 J' .\[aCHI\KK\. M.lcllilKM \ or ollior Kxliiies wlii |>aii of the stoik-iii-iiado. tlioiijrh llicv lio|oiin- (o iho (ciiaiit, iiiii-t Ik- lakiMi iiiti ai.i (iiiiil ill a'-N(w-iiig the ratoabl*' value ol' the iiieiiii>e-. The piiii- ciidi- eMtililished in h'ti). v (iiir.-l. 7 L. .J. M. C. ;I8; 7 Ad. ct E. 9.")I, and lidlowed ever since, (aniioi now bo disturbed: h'irlii/ v. Huiislrt, (lOOr.i A. (. -I.;. H. I, ,K.i: and see Crorlrrif v. Xoillutwjiluii As.sr.'ixHiriil (iimmillei: 72 L. .1. K. H. .".20: Lniiu) V. OveiKi'ir.' itf Bi.'dioi, \\ runiiinith. ;i (^. B. 1). 2'.i'.»: In this case it wii- held, tliiii ill ;i.,(.<-ji|u shi|iliiiildiiit;- pi-eiiiises to llie ))oor into POOR KATKS. 107 III!' \U llllu ((111*11 |„o (,|- iiiacliiiKMy allu.lu'd t.. ll..' i-irnii-cs wa-^ I.. I.o takci Icratioii in as( eitaininn lln'ii' ralcalili' value wlific suili illiK IlllK'lV. tl Kdli'll '^IllUf (> I it iiii<;lit Ix' capalil'' "t licin^ lomov 0(1 tlidiit iniurv \i> iIm' ir (ir llic trccliold. \va< cssoiiliallv IK' ■aiv l( »|ii|iliiiil(liiin' Im^iiic* s to wlii(li tin' ]ii«Miii>i'* «<'ic' (li'v (tod. i,il('ii(lod to icinaiii poiiiianoii ucic apiiliod t(i tlioif |(ros<"nt imii tlv atliicliod to thc'iii *(• Un\iiii .1 iMiikin«- tlioiii lit a-f iiroiiii l(ir such a iiiaiiiitiK tdiv ai< t., he iiitd accdiiiil a-i onhanciii^' tlio va luo ((I tho horoditaiiiciil. Itl ;:' h >ii(li inacliiiioiv and |ilaiit loinain ]ioi-i.iial ] I p. (ic n((t pliv^ii Iv atluihod to tho pioiiu-o-. ai a\ Ih oncitv. iiMi • vvith-tan III Act .i' \- t Vict. c. h;>, s. I isiii.rif. which o\ |>t-* pov- lip Id that A'l had Ix'on latoil.h liallcl- liciii latmu. wiilc M ».. c in; chil (l(.'d a> pi il chalioN. Tho (piotidii is. \\llOtll01- till io~ ai(> Id tic aic to I'c iiikoii inid accdiiiit 111 ostiiimlin^:- tho raloiddo valiio id tiio piciiii~o I lie s'.atii to :! & 4 Vict. <■. S'.M iiiikos ini dilVcroiiio. and ail I lie ca^c- u illi rci;ai(l to ostiniatin;:' tlio \ lino dl' loal priipi x'liiaiii n iiidiichod tiv it ■ AI;or (itm^ Willi iipi'' iiii\al tho lasi" /..(/■//(/ v. (>y<'/-.sC(';.-( 1)1 lii^liui. Wriiiiiiiiiilli ."iii'i'i ■ ;""' Ma-tor di I noid ' atlai |„(liim A',.,/, v. ll„sl,n„. IT (>) 11. UU" !"•' I'^Kto.dK. ,1: ■■ l)do~ tin- Cdiirt ilioro moan ho Hdlls loiitinuo •Ii.mI' that tho tiling;- nm I'K'iniso' iidt have nioaiit to i iio(('~-arv Id inipiin Id tiio llci'illlld. ' d ,t lie lidltod dl- -(fo« ■! Id tlio ] dd ni.l tliiiik sd 1 think liiat tiiov cdiild lillor In. ill I'allosdii. d.. when la- -aid liia' it wa- vliol i(>i- tho iiiacliiMoiA wa- ll- wa- iidl aiiMoM' riio aiidvo doci-Kiii. (s 1(1 plant a ml inacli norv not at ta( hod tl ll itod iironiiso- lioinii' takoii into accmint in osiinialiiifi 'lit' latini;- \ahi" dl tin' proinisos. was rulliiwo ' /(..((/. and (iitfdid. For cl' To ulicic t d itl [i,iilr,i ((■ ' ". V. f! S.niu: 7T 1.. ir 1-il ■diiiv. IH'.M),. 1,0 t (iiiil i.r Appoal ( E-hoi-. M. H , and l.indh-v and I. .Id. I alliniiod la- lo llio -oinn I ca-oi t H.1 lio doi-i-idii dl a l)ivi-i' I diiii I i;:; I.. T. 'IW). 1 1 IS not oa 1 1, c. Sit. an sv td loconcilo tlic-o t wi I in l.S'.l.-) a ll wa- iiiliiiitiii I 1-1(111- will IiIcimI lilt' ('\-'in|U inai ■hiiioi-v a- in Scdiland an 1 ludand. it(>;i!dc valiio in ca- dio Act ;; A I I'allialiioid td if Moil h(iil-o> i 1 r.IK -tllHM.s. vtlus ,li,va-<' lit valiio \i\ prciuiiiiii |iiiiii l'"f IciiM' iCiuiihfnrrlt A>"^r-isniftil Coiiniiitlcv \. /•,'///<, (l!M»i)i 1 (^ I! t;«: Mllirmoil in K I,,. Itl T. L. I{ ".(Mi. 'l'i;i,i;i'iio\F W •rli(;ii|i. I.iniiashhf iili'jihiiiii: l\ Oicrxms. M {}. li. I). :i(i7: ( (miiiimiiv liold iiil('iil)l<' II \MU .\'l>. <( ( , 'rnniiintij Co. v. Jx.viv nit ( 1)111 mil Iff 'it (irci'iiiriih I'liiiiii. ',> (^. 15, 9. Tlu' coiniiiiiiv "as loinuvl iiinlcr llio TriiiiiWii.vs All, 1870 .:!;! ,V ;!J Vict. f. 7H), iiiid liid duwii a liaiii\\a\ ill a liijiliway. llie sull ol wliicli was vc^icil in ilio di^ni. i Imai'd: Hold, llmt llio cimipaiiy was rateable in ii'<|ie(l ol its ona- |iaii(iii ol ilie road liv its iraiuwav. Oiiiei- ( ascs mic Milbimnu- Tiiuii It'll 1/ C' I'.lfi trir Till Fit: nil/ I oij}. I'.Kii 1 A. c. i: Mil rojio litiiii ,(' I//.S \. Tiitlfiilii'iii iihiiii hislitrl. :!H T. L. K. J!IJ A.i; oveniiliii^ Siciuisfti I miirvcriiinilx anil Traiiiway Co. v. (Mv/ I I hull Siniiliiii/ Authoiifi/. (KS'.ti'i 1 i). 15. .•5.)7. LiK I .{■■ee ,/ 11 /(•<■ lli'ii'lrr.i 1»2 I, T. iii;2; /ioo'lr Or irrriiiKil 11 iirriiDiiyiili) S.-, L. T. I.- I lid I, Olid 1 1 llliliii /'nc/,-; /'ri/./dC r 8.! 1,. T, ;J71. W MKKWOHhs \M> li VsWOUKS See /('('./■ V. liriiililiiii (iii.iliiiht ( ."> H. A C. 4i;ii: llcj- \ . llDilidi'lr Wnlirirorhs. 1 M. iV S. (!.!l; I! Mi II I I. ( ■ 71i;; /, . i;i!i; /, Lie Or. liuii V. Lhiiifj/lliil As V. Illllloill t'lli 1 1' I). \ Wr.sl M;,!illi:-.i:r W.il rnror iff). \ U. I (,> ii. I'll: Li !:.■<, 1 E )l( ]■: rcijioitl I or 111)111- iH 1(1 T. L R. (ill: /., Ciir)m>iilii)ii V. liirki'iihiuiil I' '.»» 1.. T IjiOol The true test of lienoliiiiil o(rii|);itii)ii is m,! wlieilier a jncilii laii lie made. Init wlielliei' llie oiiiip^itiuii is of value LdiiiIdii CdiiiiIi/ I'liiiiiril \. ('hiiriliiriinli't,.-< of E)i"i. i Wy.\) A. C Vi^. Ja that ease jieil of siMvajfe j)iiiii|iiii';- .•^tfilioii the ( oiiiKil uei V. Iielij ratealil"' in le^ anil woik^ wliiili tliev o(iii|iie(l mid ii^ed to <'iialde 'hem to jioriorin llit'ir statiitiriy diilie-. and to lie juojierly taken into ;i(i'ount as tlie liy|otlietiral tenant, alllioiurh lliev liad no jiowor to lake (he [jie- hn I'i'iiti I lii^lihilr St. M II I' It i 1)1)1)1 Is. Ti 7 Maivh. IS'.I.".. Hut it a poiscin is a iiieie laietaUer ol a lioii^e. jint ui to jiiosei\(' the hoii^e tioiii depiedtilion. the master who jnit in sucli (aretalcer is nil lirtlile to he rated in respect of the house, heeaiise he has no henelicial m nipation. The i]iiestioii in each lase is wliptiior there ll,LK(JAL AsaOCUTIONS. 10!> iicrtMint 111 otimatiiik.' riitiug V iliir ,,Ueu into ...iMsidomtioM iu tli. a^so^suH-ut -t ru..-^. -s,,.., .alls uIm.. , ,.w... U, „ ,,;,,.„„... is p.o,lu.c-d tl.al .1.0 .W.^iuon, Cumuu...... l.u, , ,,,,,10.1 .h- K.M.t..a! ,on.i.,t:ou.y ..f s,,ik.-. This was so lu^M n \s u. il.-M....' ..f sl...|.- .hi.i-;;- «i"!''' i"..nihs. s.M' .so»//,<'//,/-o„-.>, ,/ ,,;„,,„,,„, :. Il7,//r. 8.-! I>. T. lO.H. .lis.iM;;ui-h,..l '"/•■';'"_'■"'•'" -,v,v ^ Lirr,f"»l Wnrclu.ii.i,',, I ».. S.". 1.. T. LV, ti-. .11.. " V. t.. de.lu.li.ii.s lor lopaiis „i M.in,.s. sol- ,loll» lin„n, ,( To. ^ /;.,/„.,•/.«.« t;»/o». 8:! L. T. M.!; HV.,. <(■ T.rs. l.rilh IHU. .( . . r„ , / /f 1 F. 1117: W. N.(1;k)0,)210. IU i; A 7 Vin .•. ••til. >. 1. <'M-.iil';i"i' I""" '"'^'^ '-^ all..«.'.l I. ,,„.„.iMw ,Kru|.io,l i.v "any socivty inslitut.-.l for |,.mi...s.-s ol' s.io,,.-.- l„,,,„„o. ,„ .1... lin- arts ox-lusivlv: ,,.uvi,l.-.l .hat such so.ioty fi,,.. arts _^^^ sivill 1.0 s„|,i,oito,l wlu.liy or in part l.y Miinnal v..lni.lary .■..nli.l.u- ,,,,.,„^„j. ,i„„s an.l shall ...>.. an.l l.y its l.yo-lavs n.ay >K.t. n.ako any .I.m.I.miJ. ..if, .livisioM. ...■ hotn.s ill ni..m>y imt.. ..r 1 'v.-on aiix -I n- H,..iuh.Ms- S..O Saro,/ Ovcr.rns v. .1// ri,;,.>, ,.( Lon,U,>,. ( l«'i„^ V ( -'.111: lioiial CoUege o/ Mn^ir v. SI. Mar.nn-.'Vs Orrr^rrrs. ,18'.8i 1 Q B 80'.); ./«»»»/'»■ Insllhitp of Prei't'nlirr Mrr v. >/ ,ienrc,rs .Us,-s.mr>,l Committer. U: T. L. K. M4; (HI !-. •». Q I! Sll:'s.! r.. T. ai4; Ilornsrn Scliool of Art v. Kdmwtnj, I >nu>,. '.M I T. 20:i; ,/'>»t« V. St. Duii.^liin Occr «•<■). v, '.C 1.. T. 787. As M tiio liiiiitali.m of timo for iivov.My ..i latos, .,.,. A,r/...' \. ShrlHrhi Cool Co.. (1901 1 2 Q, H. 'it!. As to tho io,..voiy of latos jioudiiK^- apiioal. s,.,. t{nrtn,> v >t (iil,:s.in-tln-Fwl,l.^<. (I'.tOI) I K. U. ti'.o. What ^riclltitir. liti'rarv, ami Illegal Associations. Tho A. I of I'.iii8- liko Iho A.l ol I8j1', alLiiil.- tacililii.'s I'oi' lUeirsl foniiin- .oiiipaMios. hut hofoif il iiitrolu.-.'s tho niarhino.y ..t l..ima- tiou. tho A.l, iu .set. 1, liivs; pi-..toods to cU-ai- tl.o -lo.iu.l hv (leulann- illooal all lai. -■ unro-i.storcil .oiiiiiaiiios .a- as.s.j.iaiious suhsoiiuoiilly loiuuMl. ai.d'thu.s indirootly o..i.ipolliii- assoriatioi.s to aviil ih.-ni- .-oK.v^ of tho provisions of tho A.t. Sooti.... 1. tho -o,t...u in .|Uoslioii, piovlilo.... ill oHoct. ;.- t■ollo\^^<: , 1 . That after tho .oiunionoc.iioiit ..f the Act uo .ouiiiauy. a.s.o.ia- tion, or partnership tousistiug of more than ton ii.oiuher-s is ,o lio formed for oarryin- on tho husincss of baiikiii<; unlo.s> rogi.steiod under tho Aol or fornu.d iu pursuau.e of soiiio other Act of Parliaiuenl ov of loiters patent: and (2 1 That no oompany. iw-sooiation. or partiiersiiii. oousistiuji- ..f ;i..sueiiiti"U'. .,-a^ no I'UKI.IMINAKY NOTKf*. rCllAI'. I. 1->I I if above riiiiri' lliiiii iwi'iilx |ifi>iiii> I till" An Inr ill llli'lli iMIIl'lll II iitlirr lm>iiii'~^ < < '•. n' ^li;ill III' liii'iiini iilliM' lliii iiiiii- i> |ilii|ii>^i' III rui'i'viii;; nil iin\ III')' than liaiikiiiLTi iliii li I lias till ii> ilijcit iIm' iiri|ilMlinli 111 •f.llii li.V llu- I iiiiiiiiiiiy. a'*'\ llic iiiil,\iilii:il iiiIh'1'> ilifrcnl', iiiili' If |> ii'yi-li of l-nllll- iitlicr A't. ii'il iiiiiirr ilii' A '1. il j- Int'llH'il III )>lll^liaili I la'iMit. iir i- .1 iiiiiii>iiii\ in wuikiiiL; iiiiin'^ wiliiii tin' Siaiiiini n" l).'\. ami ( oi iiwall III; Til.' ailing:' 111 ilii'M' im :iii >'. a> iiiii-i |iU! i- I li.v llic (uiiri^. i,« inn rmiiiiMl ill uiila.iuii nl tlif >i'riiiiii i» I iiiiN riiiii)iaii\ 111' a»iii lai |irovisioii-. an ill(';:al a.->. L. -I . in Siinlli \. Amlii ■iiiii IH,Siii. I.I C, I) .11 1" !. Till- uliji'i I 111 till' Ai I. It tl l> llir l.nl'il .ln>;irl'. ijONont till' iiii.^ili id aiisiim rniiii lai'_i' i i'.hIim'.:' nnilt'i'iakiiiy" Ih'iiil; till'lii'il nil li\ lai-yc llmliial wil ill:; li.i. Ill's. -I) ill. 11 |irl'-oii> sii iIimIIii'j h iIh'Iii iliil iii'i kii'iw uiili hIi'hii \\w\ wi'H' ■ luili-.irlin;:'. ami pill 1" y rral i'\pi'n-i'. » In ll u.i^ a piililii' mi-' iiirl' lipii ll Anil tlii- l|l'r| llll' All !ll;H jili.'-ln'il. It lia> ili'^linMMl li.i i-.iiil clli" ;iiall_v In lia\i' in - alu- nl .Mirli a^-mialioii~. Tliii- .iii a.'-'^ni latum \v l.'^H^. at llll liiili i- ill(';;al raniinl liu wnilii I up, unili'l' llu' .\i t m.-iai'i' I'lihi'i' nl till' a>-nria;inn. ni a cl'L'.lillil'. n|- nl' .1 .-liali'linlili'i. ,Si,////l \\,it,x Mhliilii. ill:. (>>. IST.".!. 2 C I). '*'<■'■■ I'filsloir Assdthtliitii .IH.S2I. liil ('. 1). 117; /'.'(' /"(i >nr.. ( I'.lOl I 1 I'll. 1112 li\ an illc'^iil a.-ssin ui inn. win' li'T ii;.:aiii.'>; .i iiii'iiilifi is| I'ail ir 111 ■ iiL'.:ili;v nl' tin.- assmiatinii i^ ^n. tnii. an ai'linn oi aiiv ntlu'i' iii'r.sun. nil disiln-i'il. /,'<' /<((// ilHTIIi. 1 ('. I) li'.K. Il tl II' aNSiH lalinii iia-< li'iil I nli:;!i|il'll ,l~ -,' inil\ a p!nllli>-nl\ llnlr. il „. 11 ^l li. 1). .".i;.!. Ami. iiin- \('i'.~('l\ , in'illn'i a nii'iulici' noi an niii~iiiu ran sue smli an a>-nt iai inn. Ii'lit.-. {Loiiihiii Miriiif .[sstjfiiiliDii ItSli'.li. liiniicv. Ini- iii.stainr, an lannnt .■•in,' llii'lt'nn. Inr It tan rmitiarl iin < « Ki). 17G; // /(//'(' \ Itvrord /, IC'IIII .I.ihh;- Siiiuliralr. 80 I.. T III I I. anil I a 11 I'litrr iii!o im i imiian-.. ,trii ,i'nii].< \ //ll ll , IKS:! ll 111 It (^. H. I). 2l.".l. In a wnnl. the a^-n i.i'.inn i'^ a pli.iiitnin. Il lia> ■III l(';;al I'xi.slciui'. Maiiv attonipl.^ liaM' lici'ii iiiaiic in I'-i ipc liniii tlic iinivi^inn.s nl tin' M'l'tinn. lint sclilnni siiiii'.s^liillv; llic wniiN nil' Ino «i(li'. ll was at oiii' time tlinii>i'lil. I'ni' cxanipli', lli.i iiia;u.il asMiiamo a-i-^niiatinii.s wi'i'c nn t witliin llll' ■'('('liiiii -nnt .I'-n ii in i.s Inr yaiii ; Inil ilii'-i" i|iiiilil.'< -nr linpc- WI'I'C iliipclli'il liy liiiMle ■i.-'inii in I'liihloir .[.i.yiti iii- li'iii iHSL'i. .'fi r. 1). t;i7. Ill Id' Till, inns IKHIl. lH) M. I). .IT'.I. a^raiii. it wa-^ fnnU'mli'il thai an iiiii'Cjj'istoi'Cil Iniii Micii'ty i-onsi.siiiiL! o. iiiou' lliaii twonty iiiciiilii'i'.< vii-i no! ilN'iral. In'iaii~i' in its imcpii m it i oiiiprisoil loss than twenty DISSOLUTION. Ill moinU'i-. l)Ul iliix tliti".v <"ii'.'iili.iM «ii- |,ic.im|.>I\ ox.mhiI.I I ,,,„„„i. ■ Kii.l Cuvf, •!., ■.iHs..al U, the .l..,liii..« linn. 1,.-:.mm. a .M-iot.v ,^ ,„.>i.-l.',l \n Ic-- lliaii tvvrntv |«m,|.I iirii.i.llx. .iii.l hul,-..,,mMill> .,,.o«s to innr.' Ih.iii IH..1.IV. il i-' oiitM.lv ll.r A.t an.l .ln..> ».>l r.-.,m.e '..i.i.,in.lin,i. Tliis W..11I.I bf mukiiiy: ;i lauKliitiu-to, k "I ill.- Art. Tho>.- .:i.s.-H imisl. Ii..w.-vi«r. he usal «illi >«/'7/( n .l/n/.'/v,,/ 1 IN«" '. I , (■ I) 217. a .I'M i>i<>ii "t «lio (Vmri ol A|.|)0:.l. in «lii. Ii it «ii'* Ik'1'1 ,|,.„ .,„ i,n,.-.t.M.Mit misl was not an ilU'-al Mssuciiilion Mlllioimii ili-'iv ,v..„. .I....V lliuii t^riMV iHMiHi. iurir- rnlitl.Ml lo llw' l..-m>lil ol ,1. iIm- ,„i;„ .Irrnhmi; iM'i.i- ll.ui iho l.i.Mm-'. il' lMi>.n.-> .t wav ua- r.ni ,(M .„, I.v ihi' tni-ilcc-. will) wr*' li"s in iiuiiiIht lliaii l\\i'iil\. So in 0,„' ami All Slrl,-,u-ss A.soc, 2:, T. I, \i. .IT*, a .h>u- . Inl- «iis lu'hl not to U« an ille};ul asso Mil,-,, i|Hi,,',v ir;-/^-./.' V. /'..//.r 1 IHHl). I'' l- T. (112; < rn,rlhr, v 77/-,;/..'/. ■■"' 1, T |:l; /.'<■ S/,/,/./// - I8S.-.). 29 (• J). 1. .II-.- ..:li."r '•..-<■< ni ulii.li ii'iin.-iM.M.Ml lan.l ,<.iii|.;uii,-s .,f mov.' Hian l^^.■nl^ i.wiiil,.'!- hi.vr I, |„,|,| t,, l,i> U-al .>n the ki-.»iii'1 'Ii''' '!'"'> "''"' I'""'""' i'i""'l.v I'" :„ ,|,iii iiii: aii.l .liviiliii,: l.m.l l,i'!ttiMMi tli.- iii.'imI,.'! -. an - i, II i,M\ lai>iii«— ol lanil joMiin- or iialli,kiii- in laii'l. '\l.,Hs V. Thowiisoii, 80 L. T. 7.V.), in wlii.h t|„. trnslo.-^ oi a., „iii.-islci «.Mc l.cM .Milillel to -no tl..- -o.i.Mv- u-o.i-mrv i.„ ,,M,,v,iv or i,i,.n,'V.,ftlu>.si,.i.-lv in lii- han.l-. -.■.•n.- to lun .• 1 fi" .,f tli,,«> liat-.l ra-es wliich make bad law: at . Dissolution. A ,„i,nn(,n law . .,.i..).atiuu was .li-.-oKeil \,y lo-> ol all .1.- 1, ■lub.i-. Di^^.lut.ou. (iiaiil ,,a t'oiporations, p. ;i03. Bnt it is a|)|)iviRMKlo.l lliat a luiu- panv. niulci- tin- A.l of 18ii2 (now litOSl, boinj; a .-taint. ..v .■,,ip,,ia- tion.an.l an in.U-poiMont.lo-al iwrsnn.i. i- not -odi-.-lviMl . AV,r//-,T.'> of iln' Ail Mmhi,lo.s a .snbsei|ueut winding-up order, or jiroieodings for ;.•.,, v. ■!•> of anv outsiaiidiiig iusscta 'oxon V. Uorst. ( 1891 I 2 Ch. 7o: l'tiil<. Silcci- MinuKj ( o ( o. 8 C. Div. 273; London anil CaU'donkni Co., 11 C. !)■ 14U; 'Knoivlc>s\. Scott, (1891) 1 Ch. 717; Whiteky Exor/.s.r 113 1'UKI.IMINAKY NOTI'>. [C'MAP. I. V. lulllllKlf |«'.»H,) 2 I'll !'»•■> SiiUnn V. .Scii> Urmtini fi/clr ('<>■ C (1900 I eh. »;l; WrxlhiDiiiir (.Voiv Ihaprri/ ( ■>: \v. u. .j; liut ulicic (•orii|iaii\ iiiiiN Ih. Iw ri" iliilinii liai (akiMi pla. o iimli-r co t. 212, llii» .(I liv ipkUt i)f tliK Cimit M- ilii'ioiri iiH'riliuiicd \ i\i'(l liv ipkU Skc rmi II. ('Iiii|i. \A. (H-Mt's lui\i' si>m('tiiin"< i«v ircM'iJilih' (li.-'.'>i>liiliori. ii-^(M« UTOil III wliiili. alii'i .III olVi'.livi' ami Ol' I III '|)III|I1IIIV lui\ IVt' hioii lit iiiMMI'U 01 ilfi-l'l^ Ml|l|>ii>lM to It.' miIii.Id-'s li.ivo lici'ii I'.miiil til 111" !>'' ^''Ii" Siirli aiM)|i, sii lur ii" tlii-y ui<' ica I av«- lli'inin""" "'"' ''''<"'■ ' '^•''•" ' liiit aii\ lni.'*t alTorliiiy: iIk- i impcrtv 1-- n it ilisiil.!' I'll shonjil Miili U ra.-i' iMi III" ii- to h'lii'i riniiii iilri ■• \iiil .-I' C.T'.l; /')/' /,'<■ RuIkI. I'tllll'S \ Hi. Citntioi I: V. r.itirinlt. ilS'.tr, 2 Cli 1 soil I 2 Ch 1S»; Unii llitr I'll. Ml -dfii MM)| I I ell. l"i: /V.V'v ./, OOL'l 2 Ch. ■ii: Cii'.li: 111 i.lhiM- I'l iLrhl- it i' a|i|iii'hi'iiili'il ■>]' h '> I I'liiiuu I'lr a ;;iai |il\- 111 till" Ciiiuii al.iv Willi .-III rl' — . a lia.' loiiipaiiv it lo a triiMt vest ill the Cniuii, tlio Ciown as ,1 trustee In that iise (lere a.ssel- .iidiji in- trii-t. hut apparently it wiil m See He Tiuilitr's Ai\v I imilu.^ioii- (Ifiicri'l Arcidrnt Assnrftii'-c Cori 1 KMM and 1 Ch 1 17: Ui'har.l Mllh ,f- Co. (lirlrrhi lUm, W. X. < l'.M»-.> Hd: his view has hfHMi followed tiy Warrin-tou, d.. in He S„. !>, liownr. Rmil. ' I'.MHii 1 Ch. .'iV.t. Sec. too, limldingtoii L'lU'L l'") I. T. ti4H As to destruction of book^ on ii dissolution, soi IZl of the f li)OK, and us to the Court".- power to dn hire this resnlnti Art void. .se<" seit (1912 I 18. 22'i. and !\ A •".•■. lU TRADE UNIONS AND COMBINM. \,i r 73t Und (iiKlu.iinK tenomontoandhorodilamenu .orporwl or .nrorporcal, of auj touur... but no. ...onoy. m. uml o>, I .nd u' .-the. ,..r.onal cMulo ar.Mu^ Irom or conmvto.l with land) .^ not t., U Uured to or for iho Ixinefit of or a.-quirod l.y or ou bohall ..I an; iornoral.on in mortmain othorvvi>o than under tho uutl.or.ty ol u l,.e„co of tho Crown or of a statnto for tho tnu. ^ 'I'.i,' ... 'orco; un.l „ anv luml i. «o assured othcrwi-s,. than a« aforosaU. U.o land i. U. I- „„f..ii..d lo tho Crown from th« dat*- of tho a^suranoo. and ihe K.i.K ,..,, ..„l.M ..pon and hold tho land ar.ordindy : but tho Act ot l»^^ ,o.>tain.s a proviso enablinK tho n.osn- led. to fu.er within a speohrd IX'.'''"' • . I 1',,. \ lu.-n.r u not necessary in tho ..u-o ot a i-nipany n.-i.stt>nH oi ,,roHt, or to bo taken to bo r«pi«t«..rLHl nndor iho Co.upanu-^ lO.nm.i.da- l,ou) Alt. l'J(m, for by sec t. 1.; (2) of tho Aft it is expressly prov.dod •u,. tho c-ompany «lioll bo a bo. How far .an a foroipn .i.rporation hold land hero witiiout iicenc.' I, is .loar that under tho MorUuai.i Act, 188S, it .'aunot hold land a. all uilhont Hoval licence, but of course it can form a company ho.v and tliat company can hold land, and a foroi-n company can hold „ea.lv all the shares in such company {supra, !>. 4 J ). This course has Uvi, "a,„ I, combinations woro rojrardwl a.s in restraint of tru.le, and conl.rury 1.. public policy. The common law n.le, as enunciated in Hilton y Krk.-rsky, 6 E. eV B. 47, is tlu.t. ,,ri»:d /<„„■, it is the privilofre of u trader in a free country in all mattei-s not contrary to law to re-ulat<' his own mode of carrying on it (his trade) in accordance with hi.- .nvn discretion and choicv. And see Cullen v. EMn. 'Jo L. T. 840; UumAI V Amah]amated SocieU, of Car,H-ntcrs, (I'JlO) 1 K. U. otJti: athiined bv Ilouse of Lords (1912), W. N. 79; Mdd y. (leiien,! Vnion of Operative Carpenters, Wi L. T. 4.'.; (hbornc y Amahin- watcd Sncictii of UaUway Servant-, (1911) I Ch. .JiO. in Hilton y. Eckcrdoj, supra, .several manufacturers, with a view •■ proto! tiiiu' themselves air-iinst the combination of workmen, entered into an agreement aa to regulating wag«s ami hours of wot Ic as to sn- pending work partially or altogether, and as t-^ the in., i-ement ol their business by the decision of .i majority e dieir Pumbor, and it '■•n'.'i'i'i i 114 PBELIMINAKY NOTES. rCUAl'. I. iliJ ... hold ,1KU .he a,.<.on,cn, ... in — ^ « ^"'"^n'ain/tr:; ,,,„ „,,, oufov,..al.h-; an,! Crompton, .)., was ot opm.on that tja , ,..,„i„al .onspl.e,. That o.^ion^.. -;^::^^ f cX ^S S:! „ ,,,,„i,cd the Trado Tuiou Act.. 1H71 a.ul 18,l> ,. ^ ,-!' ) ! * .! '^^'^ „„, ',0 ., ,0 ViH. <• -). to .-.novo tho .ln,.l.t. I :nha. .ont e,a d ,, M...„a..|.. n TnU \ ulr Hall <<>■ ^ ''"' '-'/■"''":"■<." , -. , ,,,,,,, V (' 1>V, ■ ha> loiralisc.l trade unions, ;.„,.. o,- ,1,0 ...ost .oniavkahlo loa,. ol' ,u„dor., a..v ,onun,> a,, allo.od .o havo 1. o„ .....n.-lod ;::;;;■,!;; mL ..f ,l.o-,.ado ,.„io... sl,all ..o. l.« ontor,a„.o.l l,, any ' "'"1: ,ho p,..,n,so. ..nl,o>o A. t. ,1.0 -onn nad.. ..n.n,, i- do,,>.od . |,v -o.t 1(1 uf (lie Act of 18-0), as follo^\>-.- ■ r,-a.l.. n,dn„- .n..a.,sa.,, ,.oml...,a,.o., who.l...- UM,,.ora.v or ,: o l.otwoo;«orU,.,o.. and U...on, o, l,o,uo,.n n.as.or and /,„,/,. ,„■ h„.iacs,, wl.othrr .M..h ,.o,„!.,..a,:o., uonid .„ ■-"•'•■■ , , 1. „..,u-,pal Act i.c . Iho Act of 1S71] had ..ot l,c..n pa.sod luu.. U.:!: di;n.oha,n(,nl,.:,d l h. A(l.> aro not t/i alk'ct ,, ) V.v anroo.non, l-ot^oo.. pail..o.-s a~ In ,hoi, own la.^inv... ,.;' A..; a^.vo..,on. l.o,«o..naMOM.ploy..an.i.l,o... o„,,d,.,.dh: him as tosiuhoniploMnoiil: ,, , X,n a...oon.onl in oon^.d.natiun ol ,ho k.Io .,1 ih- ...-du .11 ol .," hir-ino,--s ...• ol' i„,,.,.r,i..n In ai.v pru|V>Mon. I.ado. or lia.iilitiatl. r, .,.., -nt li.o A.I ol 1871. ,. I- provided ,l,a, ,!,.■ pn.-pososolany „.ad.. ..ni ..r.hall ..ot, h> .-a-on ...o.oly ,ha. .hoy a.o ,.. ,os.ra,..tof Z:i ,.., doo.aod to 1,0 nnla.lul .o a~ -o .o.,dor any ..,o,„1.m^ ol such , ,„,„•„„;„„ !i,,.,., ,0 ,.rin„.,al proMvu,.,,,. tor , o„>p..a.. "j' "' '''-'-^ ,,„l ,„ ...... ;l. ,hat tho pu.poM.s ol- a.,y Lad,. ..n.on .hal ..o,, 1,> ,,.a a,,' i.. ,. M.ain. ,.. .i.t i „„„,.,, void or voidahio a.,> a;:n.....o,.. or ,r..s,. ^o, , 1 prov.lo. U'a „.,thi....- in this A.t shall o..ahlo any Co...-. t- o..,orla... a..y lo^al ;:;;;;::d.,;", ...sumtod wm. 11.0 oSjoo, or .l.roolK o,..or,..n, or TIMUK UNION!* AND COMKINKS. ..cvcrin, .lan,a..s fo.- ,l,o .....ach of anv of ,„o foHowin. a^e.- "T'^::":'::..,. .„... of . ...u. ....ion .. ..i. con. '• ■ Ui .. ,1,,. ,.ou,li,ioM. on whi.h a,,v ,n..,nl,ors lor .lu- Ume i;;;,;;. ;f .ad, ivaa.. ..,,10,. .^M o.. .l,aU ..ot .A\ .ho,r .no,b. „,in«act l.usines., on.plov u. In- ..nploy..!. o Anv aaro..n>en. for tho paynont Uy any ,,.-rson ..f a„y .ub., r,p lion or iioiialtv to a trade union :, A„y\.^Kvn,.n, f<.v H. a,,,li.ation of Uu- f 1. o, n .rad. union (a) to provid.! bonolit.- t^. nM-Milx'rs, or ,1, io furuisl. rontril,nti..n. to any .Muployor ov norUnmn ,„„ i „,cMnl,o,- of M,.l. trado nnion in .on^doration oi .sucl, .,„,U,ver or worlunan a.tin, n. .onfornnty wi.l, .ho rnlrs or n-soluliou.. of surl, tradi' nnion, or ,,,, ,„ .lis.lKUur an.x linos in,,>o-od ..|-nn any person Lv M^nionf-o of a fniut of .luMi.f. , ,V„. ...,..,.n,o,a lua.lc l-nvoon h.wlf un.on and another, or •: \,;v i:.nd .o ,M.. u,.. tho iH.for,., ^f any of tho above-men- lionod ;iur'0Mion1>. ,;,„ „.„|,i,„ „> this Mvtion ^hall ho d..on„.M.. ,.on.M,uto any of tho ,l„,v..-nivnliouod u-rooiiiont.^ nulawfnl. •^;,,,,,,,K.o,:,hoaho....,,i...uh.,>l „ hoU ,h,., a ...a-,. „„„ „..i...,...a uu,:..r .h.. A,.. n>a> ho M.ed m uyc,..e.od nan.. ,:,;„, X r ..';. S„„lh Wales Mi.rrx- rr,lrrnUo,>^.(n.u,..n, o> ,l,v un>on. \ orlslur. Mhu:r. .Usor. v. ll..n!' " ''•.'•" , ..,-„, A n.oudK.r .anno., houover, sue ,o nM.a.n .... -xo, ,..ne ■lii T i:i:!-2..T.L.R.;;i.- Nor .an a wido. of . doo-as-d n..„.hor ;.„,,;,, ,,, ,,,,,„ ,ho ho>.oii.. ^.vou hor hy dn, ^''1-, /;"^;; ' ^ ,„../, ■,/,./ SorU-H, of iar,,n,lrr.. Hou.e u. Lords , 1 M-^ \\ V ;;. 2)'. T K. H. UT.i. A« lo alio.ali.Mi of rules, see Burl.c v .1'*""- ,','„„",,„/ So,.,,./// o/ l)!icr.% I I'JiHii :; K. 13. 583. ■Il„. \, ,.s nn.vulo f.,r the n.-i^t.a.i..n of ira.lr unions ,».o so.ls. ., • „„| ,.; ,„ ,h„ .Vc. o( l«;i. a.i.l s,.. ... .; and S of the Act. of 18,., ami „ ,„„„, „„.i ,„ ...,,, .-, ..t f ,. A,t of 1H71. i. IS a,no,i,.st o.hor ..hm- .• ,„„vido,| .hat .ho .on.i.a.a.. A-.:-. W.2 a.id IS.iT, now .-..i.^ood b^ !l,„ ,va .,f i-ius ...- .ha. A... M.,i. -.M). Shall not apply to any trade union, and the registration of any trade union under any of the said Acts shall be void. .So., l-.linbnnili and Ih^lrul ,,,„„,Mi„/,.,-, .1,.. .u.„..v,./,.K,;n.w,,,-,r n^^. ,. „f se-... n,.. ' 1. 'l"llo'u",'.hen. iJial .lis no. alh.v.ahU. .o ir-JsU'r. .in.lor tho A... II-''. 1,||. Ulli.'ll ■ nut 1... :i-ti'ri(i a,« ipiiiiy. t iin'A B 116 PBELIMINAKY NOTES. [Chap. I. J»i *■ ■. i. ■1 ■ Pr»-(*"iir«' I't *uTu»' tr«di' auioM ruli . Hi)W to ■trr HKr Viil oo-"iit:rati"i of 1908, which exprt'sslv preservof (,.s<-o -eai. 294) the provisions of tho Tr.i(lo Unions Ait, 1871, a, lompaiiy whicli is foririod for itadu union purjwsfs, wliothor oxclusivoly or iu i^oiijunction with oUnr objects. Thus, if it bo dowired to registur a company for th« purpose of regulating the pricofi at which the membors of the company are to wll the goods manufacturt'd or supplied by tliem respectively, or ti) regulat*.' tho wages to be paid by them respectively, or the output of their ri'spectivo works, or tiie cases in which thoy shall concur iu a lock-out or suspension of opiTatioi"*. difficulties at ouo« arise; for, it' the a(»sociation ajipears to bo a tr-iu union, tho Registrar will refuse to register it, and if ho should, b> -jversight or error of judgmom,. register the association, the registration will, by virtue of the -Yet of a clause savouring of trades unionism or restraint of trade. Jii .such case it would seem that tlie registration should liold goo'l, Ijiii that tlie clause, as being in restraint of trade, will be invalid un.l obtain the reipiisile control as owner. Sometimes, however, to vos' all the undertakings in ono company would bo prejudicial, in the ."onso that it might destroy or detrimentally allect the goodwill oi some or one of the businesses or invito competition, and, where thi- is 30. it is very common to ail"pl the ex[H!dient of vesting each el' tho undertakings in a separate company, all tho siiaros in whicli aie lakeri Ijy I'li- now company or its noiniiii'ent, in whirl, .overal co.uorns join, an.l it is provulod ,1 at the prolit. of each of tho concern, shall for a U.nn bo pooled. ,|.ai the pool shall bo divided in spociliod proportions anion-st tho vuious companies uud that in tho n.-antinu. they shall co-opcrato^ 'll„. „bio.'tion to ,-uch arran^'oiuonls very commonly m that any ono ot ,|,e parties can, at any rate by H.,..idation or rooonstruHion e.scape U,f ivstraint of the coulr.ict. See iu^ to i,.x,.nc tax in su,:h ca«08, (,,„sl Kc-n, dc. V. X.-ttlclold. , 1010 , 1 K 1' 71- Las'tly, it is very common for a number of companies and ix.sons to I .j;;n«;-;^^ cmur in an agroomcnt savouiiug of trades unionism (e(,., u, iimit ,. Uput or fix prices, or resist labour dictation), wll knowing that its ,,,'isions cannot bo enforced, but relying on the dislncl.natior of ;„embor« to break faith, especially in view of the fact that the other ..ombers may l.c in a position to punish the breach of taith l.y «PC"^1 c.mictition or otherwise. Hilton v. Eckorsley, C h. ii IV 4- C8 ..J<. p 11- See also ro»/-/.sv.J.oW,T., a number of shipowners , a view to keeping up froight.s, and the cora- binadouwas declared illegal by the IIou.so of Lords. " The agreo- „...„t" said Lord Watson, -of which the appellants complain, leti ,1,0 contracting parties free to recede from it at their pleasure , and in the same case Lord Bramwell said: " Let it b: that ead. i„..,nl«>r had tied his hands; lot. it bo that that was in i-estramt of ,Mde 1 think, upon tho authority of Hilton v. Ecke>slcy and othor a,^<. we should hold that the agreement was illegal, that is, not eo- iiTceable by law." A.nd in Chamberlain Wharj v. Smith, K^'im) 2 Ch. 005, a number ul persons and companies, including tho plaint iff.s, having formed thomsolves into an association (unrogistorcd) for keeping up the piioo of tea. tho committee appointed under tho rules expelled tho plaintifts for alleged breach of the rules, and tho Court, holding the association to be a trade union and unkwful for want of ,egist ration, refused to grant the plainlilis an injunction, as that would, it con- sidered, be directlv to enforce the rules. On tho other hand, an agreement between vendor and purchaser of gnods providing that the purchaser shall not sell below a specified ] rice is unobjectionable. Elliman & Co. v. Carrington d Son, (1901) :; Ch. 27.1. >H.'e al.-o pp. ".SI, 424, infra. Although a company which is u trade union -annol be registered Conmbnt,|« under the Act of 1908, cannot, that is to say, emancipate itself from the etMutory restrictions of the Trade Union Act«, it by no meanfl pally trivin;.' tl' a' t for liim, V McGrefioi. .uded togeth 118 PRELIMINAKY NOTK8. [Chap. I. . .i follows tliat tho obje. is oi a .oiu,kiuv Io bo iegislei«il under that .Vet may not, iiiclmlo i.owui' for the coinpauy to join a. trade umou or to Bul)scril)e to a liudo union, for, as wo have seen, sect. 2 of the Act of 1!H)8 autlioii/es tlie ro^'istraliou of a comijauy lor any lawful purpose, and tho Trade Union A.is, 1871 and 187G, expressly provido that a trade union sliall noi be unlawful. No doubt, if the funds of a tonipany are e.\pende(l in sub.-iiiplions to a trade union, it may find that" it can obtain no ley;al a;,-istame in enforciug its rights, but ii r ,.v well 1m! woiil, the wliile of ih.' conipaiiv to run this risk. Foreign Companies. It has loii^r l)een an anomaly that loieio;!! companies should be at liberty to come liere and ih> busine-s wilhou, disclosiiiir anything' as to their constitution oi financial resoune- Tlie ("oinpaiiies CCon- solidation > .\ct of lOOK roctilies thi.s. Section 27f of the .\c. imposes certain r»'«juireinenl.~ on compauie.« incorporated outside the I'nited Kingdom, which, on 1st July, 1008. has a plaip of hi. ines- in the I'nited Kingdom or afterwards estab- lishes snrh a plaie of bu-iness Su. h companies are rc(iuired <0 file with the Registrar of Companies: - la) a certilii'd lopy of the charier, statute^, or memorandum and articles cieating the i-or;oiation and delining its constitu- tion: (bi a list of the diiectors of the com|)any: (c) the names and addres-es of some one oi more persons resident in thi^ I iiited K)ng(Upm autliori/ed lo mcepl seivice of pro- less and notices on behalf of the compauy. In ca.se of an\ alterations in any of these, noti.e of the alteration inu.st be tiled with the registrar 1 i. Service on the pcLsons made agents lor seiviie iindei ('■) is to be sufficient (2). Every such company must also lile with the regi.stiar an annual statement, in the form of a balann" sheet, containing the particul.iis leiiuired to be given in its annual summary by a company registeied in the I'nitj'd Kingdom with a shate (apilal. If the foreign company u.ses the woitl Limited' its part ol its name the .section make.s further reipiitements lai The comiiaiiN must, in every prospectus it i.ssues inviting sul^- .scrijitions foi its shares oi debentures, state the countr\ in which it wa.s incorporated, (b) It must loiispii uou-ly exiiil it in every place in the I iiiied Kingdom where it d. (f,l It imist have the name of the company and of the country of its incorporation mentioneil in legible characlois in all bill- hcudo and letter p.ipei. and in all notices, advertisements, and other (jfficial publications of the company. KOUKIGN COMPANIES ll» Th.-.s. a,v iu..l and roasouubk- cou.imou., to whu.|. no h.m M Jtu .radiu,- con.pauj cau lairly take oxcnmou; wlule .o . - ;h:":i.ed Kingdou.. th<.v alVn,d ■nu.h-do.in.d .ufonnat.ou and ,1.0 , dud ICiulllou. wldch .arrio. .,u an a.surane. bus.no.s ..tlun L Kindlon., whc,l,..v inonrpovaUul o,- ,„„. Soe ,l.o A^snv- ,..,.e (on.pan.o. Aa. ••"'•'.• ,,a.in,.s<. ,1,0 word- III ii.'^-nianio Imishr'.--. ti.ivin^ a i>ia u>od in MM-,. 1-71, aro uul quite synonyn.ous. Bv so,. 27.-, of iho Act, H .•on.panv ..uoiporatod m a 5ut,^l nos.'os.si.m which ha-s tiled with the rogi.tra.- the doomuents and ,., cular. .spooiiiod in paragraphs ,aK ib, and ,o) ol ^nb-soct. 1 o '",':. is .0 have tin. san.o power to hold lauds .u ,ho Lnded Kin.Join as it il were a company in-orpora,o,l under tbo Act. ":..'io„ 274. above referred to, is of parlicdar nnporu.n, o ,n re,..rd ,o"lncon.e ,a^ payable by foreign con.panLo... In many cases ,>ucb :, ;^ s. ac,n.g hen. by agon,., haye escaped the ,ax. hut now , ■■ : latiou ,o .egi.ler an,l have a de«ni,e pUrce lor sorv.ce scno,.l> ;„.., ts ,he position. It has been hel.l .u several ca,ses ,ha, a tl.. who car,.os on business nr England tbvon.h an ,^cn, ^ ,,,„ioablowi,h u.con.o ,ax accordingly Ms..,.. /.-.^•/.8 ^ IV )■ „.: r;.,..„. v. ao,„l.. ^ iSlHi, A »•. :V2:,: U./.-. v. >.»-... •«.'«' U. :!2t!-. Lorrll n. (hrislw.'.s. n' („„u>nss,„iins. , IJ0« i A 1 K' 217. VA. ot Ses: ,,, rr„rlrst„„ v. hil,n„l Kevenue. il'.tlli S. IJ. ,,;„,/,.„. Thn.4 ro. .. ./o,cc. 28 T. I. K 2:i.i a,.d v.,n,, ,«. • - , .ill ,,.. ,he cou.pa«v's duty, thorof-ae. under ,he Act to n,ako the ,;;s.,e return, al.d it will be no .lefen.o ,o say ■ There .s no one he e having ,he requisite .ntorn.atiou." lu order to es. a,,e. a torev.^u ccnpanv wdl have to torn, a con.pany here, and ;-'"-' ^'^j; a., a principal. soUinu- to it and buvtnnr fron. .t . T h tax wdl then bo pa\ d,le otdv on the proli.« utado by ,ho con.panv so ..corporatod. [ turei.M. corporatic. .■an m.e and be sued here. //<■.»«/"<- ^• Urneral fnnlc,„'d IMrA Co.. 2 Rayn.. 15.2. S,Kr/,„n. iur.on. ,U,n y. U,-i,n.e„rr d' To.. , I'.m... 2 Ch. .i.V..; ».'/<--/- '';'"" "J^ further. Vouu. on Korei..n. < on.pa.nos a-.-l other ( orporat,on> n ill w i)i 19 .r .stands in a fiduc.ary pf^'it^n ■ owards the company he promotes; and by virtue of such relationship ,o>ne.s under certain obligations and disabilities: and (2) borauso -ect 81 of the Companies Act, 1908, requires certain contracts with and facts as to promoters to bo specified in prospectuses^ In Krlnngrr v. Ncu, Sombrero. 3 App. Gas. 1268. Lord Blackburn * ;-y;^- ,, ..id that the term "promoter" was "a .hort and convenient way of ,le.M lar a.s it goes, is accurate; but it is not comprclien.'^uo enough Wluit wa.s i-uid by Bowen, L. .1, in Whaley Bridge v. Orecn, o (t B D 109, is a more adequate description: 'The term pro- liioter'" he said, "is a term not of law but of business, usefully ..umming up in a single word a number of businos- operations familiar to the commercial world by which a company is generally brought into existence." Rut this statement again is open to tho objection thai it at once ,:ii=-e3 without f^nsworing the- further question, what are those busi- >,es.s operations? Moreover, it stops short at the incorporaiion of the ■ ompanv. whereas the floating of the company is clearly within the ~,flpe of the promoter's functions. It is not practicable, in fact, to \ii I*KOMt»TKK.S. [(^IIAI-. li 'i;s' l«" '. I < I dram . jiivc ii coiii'i.su (k'liiiitinii ui llic luriii piomoU'i' owiii^ lu itn iii- lioruiil iotiiplc\il_\ . W'licllici ii |)iM>Miii i> c)i- is noi. ji |iriiiiiiilor i.s ^i iiuosiioii iii' furl Mill ol' liiw. iiiid iiiii.-i 1)(' (li'li'rmiiu'd xvitli iluo loyjnnl lo all tlu' cii" lunula IK ('~ Whiilifi liriih/r I'riii'hi;/ 'o v. Urrcii .". q li 1). Ill; liitnil^ili V. Carlton, •! Cli I). W\ . Enniui Siln; Miiliil;) ( (I. \. I.ciri.\. I ('. i'. D. ;tS(). i'.,HiitH Slim Minhifl Co. \ (inuil. 11 til. I), '.i.tti; lliihn v. I'htsl.it. :, ('. IJ, 2(1.', ( lli/in/ii,!. Lhl ilMHi 2 ell ISI: 1111(1 l.tfili ,iihi lliiiiliii I'hfiilirs „i I niirlir- il'.MlL'i 1' <'|i, .Sd't. Wlia: llu'-c 'ir-i'Uiiishuii'i'^ ari' or iii.iy Im' i- illu.-iiaU'i] ill llu' lolliiwiiitr (loci.- i (Ills. ill I iri/tiiht.i \ iiriiill ,-(' . 1'. V'\ . Ki'J, llic ilili'ii(laiil> iiid liiU.Kii u >( lit' 1 1 IV fdi' I he I'oriiiatioii til iIiim i>iii|iuii> , I on mi lli(> (liieiuir^, ((iiiili li(!(l tlit'iii. paid IJK' iirt'liniinufv o.\|i('ii>e-', and arrauged I lit" loiitrac:- aiid «('i(" lo li'i('i\n l,iij:t' romiiiicialidii I'loiii llic vclidoi.^; and it u.i- held licy(iii(l didi'it ilial llivy wi'io iiii)iiio;<'i> In thai <-a.~i' CuckLiii n <'. J . (:ou.*id<'ieil ihal ilu' tcriii " pnniioloi " moaiit one who uiidi'i- take.s 10 iuvm a (.oiiiiianv with rotoroiu c lo a yixcii pi'(jJ0(.-l. and li set it ttoinjr, and who takes the in'ii'-.--ar\ st<>p> lo acioiiiplisli tin- purpose." 5)1). ill liagiMll v. i'arllnu. i> ('. l)iv ;i7l. the piopiieloi^ ol' ihc (Onc<.'iii entered into an a<;ieoiiionl to sell tor :i"Ji>,o70/. lo C.altdii - nominee, aiiiuir a.s trustee tor llie (imipany. and eniried inlioii ol' i.O.ixMi/ for forniiny: and Ijoatiiiir the loinpaiiv, wlmli he uadeiiook to do Carltoii enteied into an a^rreenieni with (irant that ihe lalier .-lionid cany the matter ihronf^li and lake the roniniission. Ie>.> :ilt,(IIIO/. Tin solicitors of tlie proprietors wore lo have a eoumiisfion from them oi X.'AMl. if llie .sale wa.s ellected. and the proprietors .s.ilicilor.-. ami tli rari'oii. and !\v him to the i)roj)ri*Mt;i.-. and known to and not. di.«a|ii)rovpd by them, since one of ihem made pencil iilterations in it. In the face of these plain facts 1 car lind no room for dnubtinp that the persons I have named, each INTKODUCroUY NOTES. \li ^„a .,v..ry o, I- .li.Mn. nm.M l«- i.tU.-.. t.. I.avo i».-. (..onu.tor.s ol ll:.' TZ.. .U...; ro. V. /.w. ..... Tm;;s m: r .)......... ^ d„,enda>.,.s had as.si«u.a .ho uw„or .f a M,iuo u. 1... ou.le.vour ,.. m II ,0 a co,„ra„y .0 bo fonnod to punha^o i., .l.-ro wa> a,, und.-r. a,..l- ,„ , or arn.n..oM..-ul lor their romuooratiou oui ot tlio .haro^ (u "• ,,:.,v..d r,n,ulh<.oml.auv; ih., doloudaut.s K-li ,1k- ^;.,-tH»..'-..|, ■>! . ..• .o>M,.a..y 1.. lh« owner; allowed iheMU.elvo. .0 ho ..•lVrr..l ,0 .u ll,.' „„J,H-r.u. for inton.KU,o,. .onrcrnir.tr ihe rnin,-. an,l. m> l-m-ua.,,.. !., :,', ..„der..a..di.,,', re,.ei^ed >...n. i-ai.l-ui. -ha>e> Tl.e ,,uy lound „,„, ,1,,-v wer.. i,rom..UT-. and the Court refused to set ;.s,de tl... '"'t\."cSo.,.hrcn.<:o^.l':rb,„^>r.:.C. Div. 7;i: :! A,.iK<'a.. I2IH. ^ „,.. .lolondau, and nine o.her pe,.,on. fo,„,od a >vn,l.. ate or ,.ar.ne. - ,i,n, -o l,„v .he property «>,1, a view to the .e-sale llioreot a. a luol,, |.-,l„,,.or a.tiu-onhehall of the .«y ndi.ate. forn>ed the.o.upany pro- ,,,,„Mhe director., mottled the eontra,,. and ,,ro-,,ee,us. aud adver- ,M uud eirrula.ed the s. It wa- held that all -he n.ond.er^ o. the -syndicate wore promoter.-. The l.a.n.ua.s Nitrate Cotnpany wa« promoted an.l lorm.'.l by tl... direelor.^ of another .otnpany ealled the I.atruna,- Xittau- ^ ,d,. ate ,„ ,.,,l,.r to l.uv propertv Udott-ing to the ^yndi.■a,e. 1 he d.to.tors of ,i„. syndicate in promoting and forn.i..- the ,:ot,.pany were a, Im- u„hin their powers a< mi, h directors. I.indley, M. R.. ^uid: 1 Ho ,vndi,a-<. therefore, a.- a eotapany, .nay he properlv do.n.hed and oa.d.t to 1«. re-urded. a.s the pro.uoler. by their due>tor~, ol the nitra,,. eo.npanv. The .yn.licate i.. therefore rospo.i.s.ble tor the a.t- ami on.ission.- of it.s directors in pro.i.otin- and lor.n...;,^ the nitrate .on.pany." fM!i»»n. Nilr.Ur. Co. v. La:,um.< s,i,,Ui,... \..ain. in l^nn.a Moii,,,, To. v. Grunt. 11 I'. D- yl«, thedelendan ; Cra.M ol,tai.,ed Iron, the vendors an a-reo.ne... that they should sell „„. none ,0 a con.pa,.v to Im- fonnoary tJial he should have done all these things to make Inn, u promoter ^von some of the.n would be 8uffic.o.it-but he is nn- dnnbtedly a promoter." In Ludnru ar,d Wicpool, do. Co. v. B.rd, 33 U. Div. 8:j. the do.en- danl Dird, pursuant ♦.o an agroemont with tho owner.-* of tho ptoporfy, au.l for a commiss.o-i of 10,800{., procured tho formation of the company, took an active part in the preparation of its prospc lu. Mi'i'if I. ^,h II „i I 7 'Hid V44 AViN'-v-'V/*' ».,rf ll'i'hu I Lff'U 'in Ha„le'i Bxuniplfs < promotion. I'KOHOTKUS. [Chai'. II. ■.inii niemorunduui hikI urtir, had written to tho defendant n letter, in wliirh "lie explained to him the operation which he then desired to •■floct for tlio promotion of tho < ompany, and suj^pfosted the ilesirabiliiy of havinsr for directors jiorsons of weight and (on.sidera- tion — ])orfons wlin-so names would he likely to in.spire confidence in I he public- and a.skod Mr. (.Jrave to become a director." Mr. Gravr ajrreed to become a director on the terms of receiving the remunera- tion which the articles provided, namely, 2nor a year, and a further proportionate divi.sion of pnifit^s, if there . that he should have fifty of tho deferred .shares which at that time had been parted with by the company, or ujjreoa to be parted with b}' the company 'I do not think" i.iaid liaoon, V. -(,".) "that it would be forcing the law of thL' case in the slicrhtest def^ree to sa^ that, from the time the letter was received and mlopted and acted on, .VIi . Grave became a-i much a promoter of thiri company as any otlier person t'Ujfutred in it. In I.rrflf! and llnnleti Thralrrn nf \ aricties. 1 1002) 2 Ch. H0!», an incorporated syndicate procured a person (a(tinf;, in fact, as itt- trustee or nominee) to enter into an agreement to purcha.se certain theatres with a view to the renulo thereof to a company to be formed The property was conveyed 'o the syndicate's trustee or nominee, a- the ostensible pureliasor, ar was afterwards, by the direction of the .syndicate, sold to the proposed company at an increased price. Tho promoters formed tho company, nominated the first directors of the rompany, and provided tho qualification of some of them. It was I'ouud as a fact that from first to last the syndicate had acted as pro- moters of the proposed company. 'The conclusion" (said Vaughan \Villianis, L. J.) 'at which 1 arrive, taking all tho facts together, is ;hat, from first to la.'^t, the syndicate were promoters, thai from first 10 last their intention was to buy the music-halls for tliu purpose of .^ailing them to a company which tliey should create. They inteudcil from the first to do that which they untimalely did: to create a board "if directors which should be under their control and carry out their desires, which it is abundantly clear, on the evidence, was to sell the music-hall which they had bouLihl for 21,000/. an infiatcd price. ' It is obvious, thenslorc, that a person who originates tlie scheme for the formation of the <-<.>ni{>ou\ , has tho i)iemoran) A person who o.'!:i..alc.« the »chon.o for the forn.at.on of .J,.< ■ .^mpanv. and arranfe-es the term« of the p.eU......ary con- tract M-y-. f^r 11'" '^"i" '° ^''*' ^•"•"i"'"> ■ "' '" ^' ^r ^"\ the company, of the busiue.. the company is to be torn.... ,0 acquire), and is .n a pos.l.on to exerc. don.in.on .n the format.ou of the company, ta ) One of several pe.»o..s carryi..;; on toK^'lher the work of ,.ru- ^ motion, for in .nany ca«t« the work of pron.ot.on .. carrtod ou by several per»o..s in co-operut.on. Thus. o..e ...ay provide the rc(,uiMte fu..ds. another n.ay p.ov.de .!..• directors, or himself act a« a d...-cU.r, another u.a.N arruu-o u contract with .1... vendor; a..d U.etv- n.ay b, «the.rtakin- ...ore or le«>* i.artiu tho forn.ataou a..d lloat- iu.' of tho co.npany . In such a ca.^e ! he tern. ' pr-.motor ex°tc..d.s to each of the several per.-on.s .o promoU.rs, a..d ..ccordin^-ly it i.~ very < .m.".."" >'. . prospectus to fin■■ pronioter. Emma Minh'H Co. v. Lcuix, I C. 1'. U. .l'*'' 407; see ««prn 1,'t. I"i(nio! Kl; ('MM. II. » ... TC tlift. (V>) III ndtm: caaen u jx" ^!h, t.J l,< • rii.vtt'.ii ,r llip ('(iiiijianv u^ .n^ no'liiT tt«, hir iri-ilaiii I', w hij.!<' iii.uiolt'i.-. .. 1 ■irnpaiiv if it cu'i li»' Wfii Itia: llioy m^^' iimIIv diiin: ■IIK" llill''- ill 'III' U IV il' -|M^riil t'ioii i.)i' -ai'ir iM:i"|-i' he |ir< luiii or iiiui.M I'lf if 111- lift" .>tli. iii : li. I II fiu'l . llic ^('i 111 |iiniiin!ii mils of lliK t .piiiiiaiiH'- U lii'liiiLf-ill' \'''- '■"" 'l\V ll'pl I rt Jl.'l nt tllC \r| 111' I'MIM ■■ llil M'll (Ml I I fi iIm oriiiaiinh (II :riiiiiiilimi III tli<> iipaiiN . hilt u pel- •11 wliii uiUo- I'iriih/ u Mibmaiiiule |iai' in iv I'miii . if tin- rDlllpilllV a" ' .'/ ill 111 or -cvvaut of anoliicr is nni a pr..inM|( 1' -'■llrl'lir. II' > lii.ii III' lia~ Mill Mlllinl. IlKi' a piM- jiiiiiiir, tlio ad\frti-iiii; a_-iM iiimiMiii ii» St ..f th.' (• .iiipauii- A'l. I!i0,s uv-i'iiailiiij; lilt' piiivisii i)f llic DiriMtor-' l.ialiiliu .\il. IS'JOi, It. 1>\ till' i'\p ii'ils (if >iili-s<>i-t. ( .'ii, p, iiiilii.lc ■■ am pi 1' i-iiasiiii 111 hi-- a^ Uiiu' 111 .1 pi(ilt'--iiiiial lap.i i!\ .a- piTsmi^ i pioriinii;; liiv liiriiiati'iii i Nil duiili' .Ilia siMi^c. , i III' '1' 1'. ^inii )M'i-ii'i- iiii^iit In -.ml -'i |iri."i ti(i ihi iiii|iaii\. pi^l a* a saiiilui' li-iii:iii uliii c.umi-^ abmil a I' ••I ail I'liisiiiLr a I'miipuu in mii- .- rmn)iim •|„'li — lii'V ail' II 111 > milllHI!: \ .ivl.iii. I'. tiM Hi 1. Ill TIk'v art' iiicri'u liir ai;('iils m sciMiiii^ I-. piiiiiiuli'r^. 111. am-, S>.. (,,,:il 117-. 'I I'liliiooHi . I'l I.. T. Uil .An I tli l„- -.i',| III l.i.ikci^. Ii.ii; I'T- ami -llil iliii-». nlm. willi il: !!'■ ii.ini."! a- -11: Il ill llif pr '-p 111 praitiK' liu'io is ii-u.iliv \. ili' .lilliciili '. in 'pii'stimi. I'm' liiii-i' uh" an' ini('r''-1iil in tin' fniiiiar"' llji' I'lliipaiix laii'K I'lilliu' ill' "Im'- 111 i"pii\ii'al mil alw.ivs -II. ami uiiiTC llii'!<' a! -i'\('ral persons priaiiiilin!' "f il'i' ■':!!; 'H ".i, .r .1 >i"ii~l\ pSMM"!' piT^mis ail' assi~t»'i| in (Ic uork iiimi' nr ■!'--. Iiv o'iii'rs. vlii'tlicr llii'-f sill),,, .lina" allii's ai'i' nr ari- nm proiimtcrs ,1 ..;,.:,• .!;!i;..|.ll V ■ :l!lll y.:A llill !(l-s SI! \. luT!!. as Il'lt ! lappcns, llicv aif cxtroiiicly anximi- tii ili^ lailii llio iiaf; ■( - ■ f prDinolcr In (li'ti'iiniiiiiiL; vvlK'tluT ccilain acts li >«' I'liiistitiltcil iir will ranli"i [> pi. O Illi! •I-I'lll nil- ;■ I III '•■' 11(1 ,- ipic- V 111' !!!!i!0!i!^ .1 -tain- ivii'.ipri I'lUV NKins. iv: lUlIt" ,l„. ,.ll.l .1 I' ulicl!..M il:'' •' HI ;i till"' "^"7 Im> U^l-jlll ••' <*'■' •II .(l ■ iiioii ' „li..i. ir.ivc 1 :!i ,rf.,-«» Uw iiiip.i'i k lul ilii'llici l(ii> .i '- .ir'' li.lii i;ii> „ot vt'i-y HI '••■ ■ Mi-iuiiii ;iiiil 1' il 111 !ifi. ill!' \< \.; iir- U> tl l|l-C.|ll'lll' .liii.ii>l> iilii> 1„. .1 >-ilir.| I |'i,,t('~-ioliai I'lmitt.K' ■J ( (na-i'iii.il )'■ i»i'>'! ' l'|„. ,,,.,lc--lnll,i: IIIUL. ■■■ lll^l' I 1- ilv lllOl' I'll 'I'l" ,1 Irff ■MU llliMli'* I.H-lhl'-~ ' ,1 ;l llU..M« ,1 111., I. 1 .. U-r iit HI. I' lot Mv ;o ,_r il,' I li ■'11'- " 111,. ;, I h;i,< . I'lin V !■ I, a. I Tlii- liiK' 'I' 1 h, ilic liiuii' liiiij.' ll:|il<'f. Ntl iiti.li'r I' .. v. Id I.' ' 'I'l' 1" .1 iiu'l nill -uowc .1 I rl.h.l'i liu-lll.ill .'hlii.ii'i. li lilt- iiv •liil iironi') ill- re art' ^^. ,ilj'-! "Hi l>avf lH..>u})tlil •--lull 11 1 l,Ml!.'. . .llr -1 ill'l' 1- tor-t of slin (Mllllnt 1- i,l!.. ilis- 111 V uilli it' iiiii'i \v.r.<. M K I'S 111 1. 1 I i i .it IM ,111.1 li.i' -.1 rv)lM|ii . Ml ill tllll ' I"' iiiio-~ ii"i" ''. '■ IMC .ll' 'llflil - '■ .t T' ,lil. i.,(vtl<-- •ir. I 1 i.la - 1' l|--. Mill' " llli 1 .1 si'll .iis-.'ralp i |)ii.i-|" rin' i>v..\ ■ i- i.ikiii kill - Ili'llH • - ;„, /.( II I. mtl ijiK--' ■ !i I" il.'ir r,r,- I- l.K- 1' ,„^.|,j-0~ 111 .11 111 a l> riilar lU'-i'. an ,1 .ail iiiioU'i .1- an i.iva-i mil 1' ■111. .'IT, 1 lo iiiav . I tlif I'lupi' lu atijiiiii' .111 iliMiiliril "f -iiiiit'i a pati'iii " \v J .'11. 1 work 1 ;-^ ui'ii . MlJH'.'U' .|Tt>cl ': iriviii^r It Jiii" • n'mnnfiatinii -//fi jivoiii'Hi'i- .I..1 I ■.\i\< il lOlll) miiaiiv to ta ;c over -.'lui liiiii: M ihi' j.i -iiioti'l ;/o lliir i-iif lliiv .--ollli' iinl'lli .. Ill ail) ii> i.isi' of il ui a iiioli iiiid to piiKii. oc. lor i-xiu- r.nih; (IH'JO^ 2 Ch. -.Vil: lif.>:diui /.' I'jlli 1 t'li 12V. nnithiik V. Ffiiii. 12 Aj i.nr»*>, *I^-Tt,'"' '»"■-. .itA ' ■fl 128 PBOMOTKRS. [Chap. II I'll Functions of a Promoter. Puutioiu Tho functions of a pioinnlor HuUiiiiiiitly apjKjar from wlmt lui- already been stated; and it is obvioiit thai, tho etlicioiit dischargo ol those functions may b« of vilal iippoitanti! \<> tho cunipauy and ii- suareholders; provided, ul roiirw, ihal tlie mil.-iiakiii!,', to prusi- cute which tho company i> formed, lie one ol' a homi jide oharactci. and has in it tho elements, at any rale, of success. For instanco:- (1) Tlie lino> "i\ uliii !i lli<- > i' paiiy is to come out are nf priniarv importance. Tak«' the case of a going concern: U the capital to be large or small? What is to bo olleied to the public for .subscription -ordinary .shares, prefoionce shares, debentures, or debenture .■stock, or somo or all of these' How Ls the vendor (if any) to be y.v.d? Is there to be an independent report as to the pii-r proliii of the concern, to b© remunerated? How are the j;reliminary e.xpenses to be Mti^lied? The deterniiiiition of thoe iiialt<>rs is nialeri:il not otilv a< l)eariiig on ilie future of the t'liiipany. but o-^ allecting the term-' '.f tli<> prospectus, and in many rases ot the articles of a.-^-^ociation. (2) The |iro.spen of liie dirociois is another uialU'i of g.cal importanc*' .\re they to be competent busiues- men, though iinknowii lo lame. or aie ihcy to be ornanieut;il director- witii a title oi .-oci.il i('|.iiUition, and little else to retumnienvl tliein, or are iheie U) be some of both kinds; oi are ihc} lo bo diierlorii who are both competent busines,- men and also well known a-s persons of position and in- tegrity' Who, again, are to be the eolicilors and auditors There can be no ijuestion that the names of the director- solicitors, and auditors largely inlluonce tho public a- to oubncribiug. It i> i.-.>uiiiod, and in most cases '[uiU' righil_\ that a man of integrity and po.'-ilion will not lend his iiaim to an undertaking which tho public are invited to subscril r fo unless ho is satislied as to its bona )itU-s. (4) Tho ternuj of the memorandum and article.s of a.-«jocialiou an very material, and must be framed to accord with the pro- wpettus, juusi, give practical clfect and froo play to llic •cheme on which the company is to bo formed, and muM INTRODlTCrOKY NOTES. 1*^ lontuin all tho requisite pruvisions for the protection of the ))artic.'< intorosted. without itnyttiin^r oppn to hostile criticism. ('>) The proiinMnurv coiilracis <■.(/.. Inr tho ac(iuisition ot tho husinoss or property to ucipiire which tho company is started —are ulso of vital importance. On what basis is tho busi- ness or property in question to bp acquired y Is the prico to lie hi take over lialiilitiesr If so. have those liabilities been ascertained, or is the com- pany to be asked to make a leap in the dark • is the vendor to be at lilHJrty to compete in tlie business with the companv ? Is there to be power to rescind the contract if the conipain- does not float!-' Is tJie company or the vendor to pav lh(> preliminary cxjienses? («» Underwriting. -Ls the capital, or at least the miniuiuni sub- scription, to be underwritten before the company is broufrht out? If so it may materially assist the iioatinu' of the I'ompauy. Profit or Remuneration of Promoters. The professional promoter and the (Kcasional promoter always, and Rcmui«m- ||]<' promoter pro hue vice .somelime.s. ex|)e(^ts to make or obtain some *"*" |irolit iir advantage out of fit« in amiex.'d theroio. <•// • omvlhird af!., puvinjr a <1 |.pr <-.Mit. dividond on tlio other shares llv uKHtMiUMit holwfci. tho .oinpai.y ai.d il.o promoters iIm-. .iharos aro sometimes issued as fully paid up, in .■oiiside..- tio.i or part .•onsideration of the promoters paying the p.r- limiimrv expen-ses. or niakinp over either a eontra.t or il,.. iKMietit of peiidin- negotiations. Tl.ert« is no ol.jeetmn I.. this now a c.nipanv .an aceei)t in payment ot shares muv thini: wi.i.h Ihev honestly think the ,M,uivalent ol .;,.!, Sometimes the promoters sulwcrihe the memorandum ..I iu^soeialioa for the deferre,! or foun.ler- shares, and pav for them in .ash. so as to av.iid the n.M-.'S.ny l..r anv otl,-. cimtrat't. (5) S.m.etimes p. n>lers are remunerated hy an ..pti.n to t.k.. as a ■■.all ' of a .ertain p.^rtion of the .■.m.i.an, ni-M„.,| shares at par. or at a low premium wiihri -ay i a ; .ar oi — Ah to the etteet of a volunWry Avindinjr-up on su.h an oplmn. stH,. Re South Afrhr,,, Trmt Co.. K.r ,<">*'• '"rx'h ' !«!•', ^ 74 L. T. 709 ,6) A eontra.t is u.a.le un.l.-r whi.'h the promoters re.MMve Iron. ih<' eompanv a .ommission. provi.le.1 a .^-rlain nu.ul.er ot shan- ar.' taken up within a .•«>rtain peri.Hl. S.^- se.t. 89 ol ili.' (■ompani..s A.t. I90H. n m pay a spe.ili.'d sum to the promoters in ri-s,M-r.al whether Ih.. price is a. pri.-.. pai.l in i-ash or in shares, the value ..f tJ.o c.ns.dera in the latter -ase dep..n.lin^' on an unoertain event, the suc.^es^ ... failure of the ...mpanv Ue lirazilian Hubbcr ria„talio,», tNo n ,l<»lli I < h. 422. Sometimes th.< pr.uu,.l<-r is a re-isU)rcd company or syiiduiiW carryintr "M ll«" lmsim>s» ,)r promotinp companies or lormed with a view t.rthe pvom.ption ..f the particular company. As to this siH'^i- (ion, see p. iJi'.t. iiifrii. . As to ih.. ohlijrati. 'he part of promoters to disclose th'.r profit, SK>e iiifrn. p \-^-^ INTKODUCTOKY NOTES. |:M Fiduciary Position towards Company. Tlic |)romnlci.> "( a coiiiiiiiiix , it i-* now woll m'IiI<"<1, umipv lUlirciun |ii),siliiin towan tl i(> ('i>iu|iaiiy tlii'v I rin Fidurutr' IHmition. sUiiid. Slid l.iircl (aims, in Erluiuji-r \. Si nhii I2.'i(i. unddnlilcillx in a (lilmiaiv |M)>iiiiin mwanls ilic tdinpanv. Tl it'v have in tlipii' liuniis till' crt'alion ami niiiiil('ivi>i(pn, i ,11(1 kI i» rin to act a> \nu\ inu: roriioraliiin I .-liall -lait into cxistoncc Ami in ilic -aiiic caso. l.oi'd Mlaiklnirn at |i. l2l'>Ki rjii ■aid lliat ilii- Ad of \HW1 llii'in an a linost iinliniil(>i' to in iko till' ('oi'|iui'alioii «iil>jt'(t li mil icjriilations as llioy please, and for siicli |iiir|io«<'s a.s tlicy please, and to ( icat<' it with ii iiiani'jriii>> IiikIv wlioiii tliey ^ielel■l, having Muli powers as tliev ilioose to jrive to those iiialiu^M's 1 tliiiik. that liose wlio ai( are not allojiclhor. cept and use smli extensive powers rnlitli'd to lisie^iard the interests nf that corporatiijii Thev inn.st make a reasoiia Ide if tli< i powers w hii'h lliev accept frcnii the \. slat lire aiKl ciMi.sei|nenil_v tlu'v Iv tli< do stand, with retraid to that corporation, ^v hen foriiied, in what is iniinoiilv called u liru intervened to ro^traiii uii if tli(> iitlii it It was lOt until F.rUniiur v. Siiiiihrcri) I iihi siijini) that it was decided that an analoj^oii.s relation existed lM>tw(H'n the cumpany and the promoter. Iiy iva.s(in of tho lattc iirolli ng inliueiice Commencement of Fiduciary Relationship. The iidnciary relation.ship of the promoter (■oinmencen wluui lie When rt- l"';.'inN tu promote or act on lichaif of the proposed company. See ,,*,'",^„'J^ (ilidkntvin V. llanii'K. I^IOOO) A. C. 240; Tiirvll v. lUtiL of ImhiIoii. 10 11. K. C. •2(,: llitchiuii V. (A/ii!iret;i; I Rii.s.s. A My. I,")0; Emiiii Sikrr Miiiiiiii ( <>. v. (Irant, U (J. D. 'J18, 'j;it>: Lectin and llaiiU-'i Tlualrvs oj \ iirietii's, ( 11)02* 2 (li. 80'J. Thus, if lie enters into uejfo- tiatioiis for tho acipiisiiion of properly or rights on liehalf of an intended company winch is Huhsoi|Uently formed, h« iw to bo taken to have lieeii a promoter al) initio. iSo, too. if he |.'ei« other |)er»(i K 2 192 PKOMOTKKS. [Chai'. II. i'ii «i! IS t 1 iH to agnv to »ul..sciilH< U. u (>roi.osi'comes a i)romoter from ihnt time, supi«J.sinv' the company to lw> subsequent Iv formed. When several jK-rsons af'ree to form a oonipanv, they are therMft.r in a fiduciary iK)Hition to the Mibseciuentlv formwl comiMiny. Gliirk- sipin V. Banws ( 1900 J A. f. 240. But tlie mere fact that a person, or por.son.s buvs pro|K'riy with the notion that it may bo desirable to form r. company, does not make him a promoter. .\ pro.jems to me. after their purchase was made. \m- fectly fi-e<' to oment to purcha.se certain mines, and the conr- sponden.-e prior to the a-nn'ment slunved that they conteinplate.1 the formation of a company to acjuire and work the mines: notiiin^'. howev.'r. had Immmi done in the iiiiitter of the formation of any par- ticuhir c.mpanv before the a-reeiuent wa^ made. Ssliortly afterwi.nl.< the c.mpanv wa« fo.roed by A., B. and C, and lliey re-.sold the mine. U, tlie comiiany. It wa.s hold tliat at the date of the lir.sl ajfreonici.l. A., B. and C. were not in a iiduciary relation U) the company. In Uwer-R r«Mf, I C. Div. 182, >x\pxu\. A. entered into an ajriwment with B. to sell to him piitent.s for tJ-VOOO?., payable partly iu cash ami partly in shares, in a conii)any which B. agreed to form, and if he failed tin- ament with a trusti>o for an intended conii)any for re-sale It wa« .-.Mi.sideusl by .Faiiios. MelU.h. Braiiiw.-l! ■■v,v\ Bn-!t. I.. IF. that at the time the iirst afrreement was made B. was nnt a promoicr The question when the status of a promoter was first acquired is oceasionalK one of -real moment. f-|.e,iallv where the promoter INTKODUCTOliY NOTKH. ia:» ,.^,^,11, u, ilio lonipauy at a piolit pioiK-ily low.itl.v a.iiuiiu.l by l.im; tor if lio l)(uiglil bcl'orc lio becaiiH' a |.r..iii.)tur ho may resell to tho ,„„HKiu\ at a piolil, Mil.jett only to Jiiakiiis is oiilillod lo treat tho iiroiiiotor as having ;„ IO.I on its behalf in aniuiring the pn.iHUty, anil to insist on taking' it at tl.,' inice the promoter gave lor it. llilrliam v. iniKjrece, I Ru^~ .\; -Mv '•'>"'. TijreU v. lUnk of Luiiiioii. U> H L. C. '2(i; Amhios, Tea Co., 14 f. U. .i'J; r,i//,- Hnloii Co., 2'.» C. 1). T'.'.'.; Uh/inll Mniiiifi Co. v. limoLr-s. :;:, C. I) H' ). An.l no ,lis.losure ,,11 the pari of the |)romoter «ill enable him to retain tho prolil, for the property is in ociuity not liis but the .•onipunys; that is to «a\. ii i- inipre-seil in the jiromolerV liands with a trust lor tho loinpany . The status of a promoter is not jiei-essarily terminated by the Termination foriuation of tho eompany. Of .ourst', if a , in 'J^jP'""'"*''''" the shape of diifetors, has once boon formed, ami ihey lake, as I uwd not sav they may, what remains to bo done in forming: the roHipain into their own hands, the functions of the promoter are at ail Olid. Hill so Ions; as the piomoleis are jieniiitled by the diiet tors 1(1 (an\ on tho work of formation, tho latter ivmaining passive, "o long, I think, would a jury bo warranted in linding ihat what was dune b> them was done as promoters." I'ci t'oikburii, ('. J., Tiriiiroxx V. (./<(«/, 2 C. l". Uiv. Jti'.l, Ml; and see Kmma Mining r„. \. Lrirls. AC V. D. ;(0(!. The o.vistoueo of a lidmiary relaiionsiiip has important < ouso- CouH.-,iiieu( e .[ui'iKi's, of which the followiii;; aio the iiio.st notable:- <>f fiilaciary relitionnhip. I J A promoter may not obtain an\ .ii-rii-f piotit at llie expense of tho compuny he promotes ic.^., any sjiare or part of the purcha.M'-i ley payable liy tho company i. and, if ho does so. the company, on discovering the fact, can compel him to snrrouilor any such protit so made in violation of his duty to the eompaiiy. The moment a iiuin is in u lidiiciaiy position, liowever that liiliiiiaiy position may arise, he must, liefmc he can retain .i profit for him-elf, deal with his pviiuipal on the footing of making a full Hill ll f :ar disclr i.f evorvtliins.': maloiial to the dealing or Iraiisac- timi ill which ho ads in a liduii..i'y capacity Per id, M. U F.mmn Mininy Co. v. (Ua It, II C. D 'J.t: 111 sw lliif mill v Carlliiii ('. C. Div. .ITl; Lijiliie,/ nnd ir/. ^^ H D !<•!•; i:tniiM Minini) 4 (■ r. 1) ;!w i! ll! i! ;i-.i's iiromijter-. secret arrangoinent re o promotion, am ith tho veiulors to the company, obtained a *ii bslunt untial ho proi'oeds of sale or commission for thoir :i wore held accountable to the com- Hii 1:M rROMOTKRS. [Chap. II. pany foi ilip saino Otlior cH-ips aro Minin v. Kflhihuifili i\ortht'ri Tnim.i Cn.. i \H'.t:\\ A. (" ti'.t. in wliicli |iiimio(ois were held uccoiiiil ihle f II' pMiinotiiiii Mill iipv socrellv ulitiiiiieil tlii'reteii(liiip; to ilisclcixo thoir proHts, kept iiikIj.h- rlcised Niinie extra profits S also Liifiiuuix Xitiiitc Co. y. Lnfjnuiiit Si/ntliralc. i IHit'.t •> Ch. W>. 4(>;t: ami Mni/or of Salford v. Lrrn. I 1H91 I I g li. KiM: (Irani v. (lol,l HiiJorafioii. dc Si/iidiralt: ( I'.MMh I (^. n. 2.12; Hf Lull/ Fnrrrsf i .\t„nliisoiO (loM Mini: t 190(1) I Cli ■>H2; Ri- f^t'cils iiiiil Hiiiileii Thenlrts of Viirit'tien. i 1902 i 2 Cli. 809 .2i I'rihu'i jiiiii- a prdiiioler wlm piopdsos In iiiakp u contract, wlielliei- In uav of Nule or ntlierwise. with the conipanv lie prouHiies, or ti ,jll^^tilil atioii tor uL I'lv on ilixlosiiiv to tlie ilireitors a> M^ a prolit tor wliirli he as ,i jin motor would In- uccoiiutulile. must provide the I'oiiipaiiy with un iudc|iendeiit e\ecutive alile to protect the coiiipaii\ and oxerciM' on its lielialf an inde|HMidunt and intellij.'eiil jiidjr at. See per Lord CairiiH, hWluiK/er v Si'w Sniidircri) Cit.. A Apji. ('as. 12;{i;. anil (!lii 1900 i A. ('. 240 What loiisiitiites an iiide|)endeiil executive lia» not lieon ilecided, but it is olivioi!^ that a director who is iiiin.self one of the prn- inofors. or is under oldipiiions to the promoters, or is to he reinu- iierated hy iIk'iii. cannot 1k' ley^arded as iiidependonl (llurkslriii \ . litinu'M. .«((/.(!( Iiidoi«Midence is a (piesfioii of fact, and all the cir ■uiiislances .\H\ lie it'frarded. The mere fact that a person is requestpd hv the proinotors lo liocoine a director iIih'^ not deprive hi f tin- cliaru; tcr of iiido|H'ii(hMiic. He may still do lii^ duty. The tact that a directoj puts his oHii money into the concern allords some indication of indc- pendenc*' hut this may go for little if the remuiieiation attached to the «i(lict> is ivlatively larjre. The conduct of the directors may throw light oil the ipiestion. In a ling on liohalf of the (ompaiiy. have they taken aii\ of the reasonalde )iiecautions whiih a prudent man takes uilh regard to his own atVairs- If not, ii may not require niuch to prove ilieir want of independence A diivcloi is not relieved from the duty of exercising an indepen- dent jiidanient on a contract jiioposed for adoption liy the compary lliongh lla- conipany was formed for the express purpose of i arrviiig lint the particular contract. Himilinii liuhUer I'laiilnliitiis (No. I), ' 1911 I I Ch 42.1 " Al)j):ifvii!i\ . .-. t" IM-l.-o) th.< .h.ui'l.cl.lcrs, ihey ,„„„, M...... to have tl.o..trl.t of .lui..- it Tl...ir al to tho public. .s„/.,/»o„ N . Sah,Ho„ ,( Co.. < IKtiT. A. C. -.'2: liritish SV,, »/ A. C. :«: and »;• per Lord Watson to th.- -*:imr t'tfcrt. p. 37. pi Tl.o followin^r oxtiact.s iM'ar on this point: ■ I. was urgo.! that th.- pri. f thi- prop.-rty Whs not lix.d or .-ons.d.-n-a l>y ,u M,.l.-,K.nd.nt l..wrd of dire.tors: and that, in thi* rp»p.-.t, tho ,ran«a.t,on was „„pr..p..r and fraudulent. This arKumi-nt 8CH-n.s to 1..- hascd on a inis...n..pt.on ... tiM- d.-.isin-, in A;,'«»7.v v. .\r,r Snmh.r.;.. *-•. (',.. (XHIH). i .\pp. Cis- 1211*: «l»n- the fa.ts wrr.- vrrv ultfvri-nt. In the pn-«>nt .-as,-, it was not disput.-.! il.al .v.-rv sinxl.- sharehold.-r was |H-rf.Htly awar.- of all th,- .■inumstanc.-s ..ii.ialintr th.' formation of the .o.npa.iy. and thnt nolMaly was or .ould hnv.- I..VM diioiv.d.' Per I^ird MocnaKhl.'n. I.«,„i,,,ir v. Brn.^rl,,,, (1H»7) \ C :|l>«. •Of coursf, on.- lan .-asily .saa-.-iM- that thr tiling' mitflit liaM- I. m'-r.- .|,a.... or .va-ion. or tri.k. t.. |f.-t rid of the- olf.'.t of th.- A.r of I'arlian..,,, ; hut .,„» .u^Ki..tion of sham, or fraurf, or dweit. seems to ho onlir.-ly out of the m""'- tioii iu this oaso. KvoryUnly in tho •ti..ip»iiy know of th.- transaotion; ovory -liariholdi-r of iho .ompany was pros<-nt and was a party to tho rosolulion llioro was no docoit pra.tisi-d on any oroditor. nor was llioro any rouristration ,.r tlio«. sharos. oxfopt as shai.-s paid ..p. That sis-m* to mo to dis| ■ of Ihi- .aso." for .lanii-s. 1,. .1.. .V//m j/oa (•««'•. H Cli. 4IU. ■■0.10 of Iho U-arnwl jud^w ass.-rls. n.id 1 spi- no i-oaso.. t.i .piostion th.- .i.Huraoy of his stato.nout, that .roditors mvor think of oxaml.iiu(r tho ro^isti-r ..I ,l.l»'nluro», hut Iho apathy of a orisjitor .a.in.it justify a.i imputalion of rniu.l iiicainst a isimpany, or its moinlHrs, who liavo provided all thi- moa.is of im I'KOMOTEKS. [Chap. 11. iiifiirniiitioii whirli tin- Arr of Imi-i n^iuiri's; itnil, in my opiniun, a criMjitnr who will not tako the tniiihio to iiw the- mriins wliii'h tho statute- providm for •maliliiiK him to protect hlmwlf. mi»t boar the iflfw<><|m>nroM of hi« own iicirli- (feniT." I'rr Lord WutMin in Sninmim v. Sa'omiui. (IH97) A. ('. p. 40. ■■ Xiir WUH till' abwiK'u of uny indepi-n
  • nt board material in a ciwo lik<; thf prcM'iit. I think it \» ;in imiitablc infiTcnrf from thii cirrumatanrra of the mm that I'vi'ry minibiT uf the iniiipany axcnti-d to the purchaw; and the voiupiiiiv is Ixiiind, in a niiitti'r inln- ■ irri. by tho ununinioim aKri'cmrnt of itn mmnlHT' In fact, it i« lni|Hm»ilili- to ■«iy who wa^ defrauded." I'rr l/ird Itavcy, Sitlnmi.,, >. S,.l,„„n„ * Co., (Ih97) A. C. .>'. It is a •• well nettled principle " that " a company when renintered is i r- poration capable, by its diret'tors, of biudini; Itself by a contract, with themselvi* as promoters, if all material facts arc dischiM-d. S,ili>iiiii,i v. Snfiimon >V r.,.. ll**37i A. ('. 22, is the Icidinir authority for this primiph'." I'er I.indlci. -M. II., in l.ilitiinnH \ihiit.- I'll. V. I.n.m.rli S „„ilii;ifr, ( I HH!( p 2 CIl. 392. f.'.' .\nd at pp. I2.i, »2l>, he says, " Notwithsiandin!; all that has been said In Kilii.iiiii- V. \i>r S., ,11/1,1111 /'/•i,„/j/i,ilr I',,, about the duties of the promoters •>>' a cimipaiiy to furnish it with an indc| .lulcnt board of direitors, that Tisi>in does hot nsjuirc, or indeed justify, the conclusion that if u company is avuwiill) foriueil with a board of direitors who are luit inde|N'ndcnt, but who are stulisl to be the intended vendors, or the ajjcnts of the intend«sl \eni ,n r, I think it inipos^ibh' to hold that it is the s or their sharehoblers as so many rr,if,tin f/uf t,-,i„i under disjibility. nor even as ,,-,/.<,« ,/,«• irii-t for whom trustees are ap|Hiinti'd without tlicir cmMMit." Hill llif (liMliKini' l.\ llii> |ii'iiiiiiiloi'< iiiii^l lii-a icii! (liselo.sni-o to the ji(i>oii> iiiten'sU'iJ tlie f-liiii .duildeis iiiiil not a iiioio .slmiii \Vlnie tfi'iilltiim-ii .set uliDiit I'liriiiiiig it ('iiiii|iuiiv to jiiiy thoiii a huiiilMHiie siiiii lor takiiiu: ntF llioir Imiidx a |)Im|«'iI; uliiih (liev Itail loiili.n leil tn, l)iiy with ihul ciul in xicw . . aji|) word to ii.sc v hi'ii a [lei.suit wiiii |ila\.-- iaan\ |iurt> uiuiouikos ti< hiiiiiiulf iu one churaiicr whut hi* liiiM dune and is ihiin^ ia another To talk of disejasnri' t<> th»^ thinjf rallod the eonijiany, when as vol there were no shnroholdei-. i.s a mere laree To the iiitende<. W , i , On... Iho i-roM.nU.i l.u> loi.iui.M.i i-.l llio pioumliui. Iiu in.iM give „, the ..,i.ii.au3 tlw iHM.olil ul mmv .suL^tM,,.....! .ontniM loi ,1,,. ;i..,ui>ilioi. oi ,>ropo.i> «lii.h ilio .o.i.|Mii.y, «h.i. luriM*..!. l.»v.s ,■-;.. if. ultt-r iM-ninniny: t» pnuum.'. I.o emo.> iu,o a ...laiu.l K. i.ui>lia.M> i....,,.tI>. lu- .unu-.l |moi..-iI.v H'll lo ilic .nM.|.unv at .. l.i«h.-i- prici- ihui. !»• -:iv'- »iili<'"ii ,1,„. ,|i«|.,HUio ,u..t M..'n-lv of Iho prirt' he -av.-. Ihii ..I lli-' la.t llml llu> .oinpanv i« .-ntitlwl to luko tlut picpeiiy a. thai pii.«M, anil il la- 'lo. ll.o .oii.paii.v. on ,li.s. ov..ni.>: >i- ilLht;*, iiiav oilher. al itn option, ifs.in.l tli.' roiitrail or ,oni|)fl llu> pronioti'i to Miir.-n.li'i lii« prolil -o" ■■.' «•>'■' Ami in sncli rase- tlif fa.t tlial it has Ikm'oui.- inipo^'^ihh- lo iv.s.in.l .1."- noi alt.Mi ;h.' . nni- ,,any s ah-.Tnativr liirht-. S<^' ••<"/'/•«. p. i;t;i. ■'•"' '""" Tho.v i^ no.hin- lo l-rovri.t p.-i-ons Ii..m. l.uvin- p.op.Tty with a view (o roseliii.tr it to a eonti-any: l.ut if they on.e l,e,o„.e p.nn,oter> ,f a ..m.panv «hi,h is to U' fonno-l to ur,,.iire a part., iihir property ^ ,l,ev .antiot atterwanls a.-iuire tl,,.l prop...ty for ihen.selves an.l sell „ 10 the conipanv at a protif, the ..iiipaiiy is entith-.l to >uy . Ion aero aetinR for Us; you were In a li^lu. la.y poMti.,.. a- .vyanN thi> l„M|H.rtv. anrcll Mn,h,,J i'v V. lirnuW.. .!.-, C. Div. 4(H.. a.nl (',„>,' Union <'o..-2'jr. Div. T'.t... appiove.1 l.y the i'rivy C.ua.il .n lt>,rl,uid V FMtU: ' VM)-') \. (". M: H.. .'i (' I) '■'' I , Wheiv a |M'r-on a<.,iiiies property or rijihls on his „w n a.Toonl. anl hin. to pay .laiuas:.-s lor his Inva. h .if t-, suprn. p VV-i. Aiiorilinj.' Ii' !'"' oMe' ta.ses, wheio restis-i.)!! wa^ iiiip..ssil,io, .•.<;.. bv reivon uf Ur' pr.ip.erty having h.HM. sol.l. lorfelto.l or lost, the .oiapanv wa.- T.ot entitle.], iw an ullornulive, to eoinpel the pnanolor to ai..>iiut f..r his protil ou the sale However, in Renlhuk v . Fenn. \1 -Vpp. (as. ti.-.:., t.oiJ M..aiaphtea lonsidoHHl that a p.-rson m a. li.lu.iary i..kc, thou;rli bo niitrht not 1m* mi-.mntahle for prolit.s. w.ml.I he li. hie to pay ■laiims.'e.-^ f.)r sn, h hrea, h ..! .Inly .'m'u where rescission "a> iuiprm- rt !lf *h 138 Ul n I* •tiMi, Bf Alloinui('<>» made to promoter. [•KoMtd'KHS. [ClIAl-. II. ticalilc Anil ilii» view in rrliition U> proniotori* «iim uiI(>|iI(>(I I>\ ihc (JiMirt of A|i|M>ul ill Lfrilx tiinl lliinlri/ Thi'nlres of Varielirs. i \W>\ 'H'\i. KOit. In lliul itisi- r('-riiili'> IaiiIh Fiinist Muriliis(tn) liitlil Minr. ^ liioi) I Cli '>82. iiiul prii. . fi(all\ (li.sp« of tlic arlii'r ium)- aiio\.' ?pf©rr»'(l to (r>; A pi'oinotor who i.«i not u I'oiil owikt or |hii'I o«in inlcn'-^iN cif ila> conipany. anil iiiii.-'i aliNtaiii from csci-ci^ina: iiinliif iiilliKMicr and. a fortiori, from fiiiiid. (iihsiiii V. .Ii'i/i'.s. Ii \«'s. J78; 1 1 II fi urn ill \ . IUihi'Ii'i), H Von. :i7."t: Krlatr/er v. A'r"' Soiiihrrro ( o . ;l .Vpp ( 'a>' \'2\H. (ifiiflisli'ln V. liarni'i. supra. I 7 I .^ pi'i' who prup(>.M'>i to sell hi.s piopiTlv to tlio conipain 111' proinotoN. or «tliorwi-»« to ohtniii «onM' a .A).]! ( a.s 121«, 12'!li; I'rcsliiii's ,,/vc. |t; W. R. (itiK. I.itnlmii I'rirolruiii I o. v lluril. I,. H. .". 1'. ( JUl; (llasiri \. Hulls (18K!t.. llM h I). 442: lU-litiiirl,- \ . h'rini. IL> App <'a.s. »i7l. Tho di.sahility to wciiii' sccnM Ik'hcIiLs al the cxpciiM' of the conipanv which allaclics tn a |ii'oiiioicr is a pci.s. ii.il i|i.'>ahilit\ aiisjuy from tiio liiliniaiy i-clatiniiship which -iilisists hi'twi'cii him anil the cumpaiix WliPii a pcr.->oii .-taiiiliii).-' in a lidiiciiiiv relation ohtaiiis a m'cici iM-tiefii, |!.c toiirt doe« not eiitei uiio the .|ue.stioii whether the panv at ihoHc A|M'nse the lM»iielit wa^ ohtaineil lian or han not lost. All thill the Court hiu< to do i.s to e\aiiiine wliciher a necret prolil has, in fact l>e<'ii iimde: anil if it has. thiii prolit iiiii.st !><• coimieil foi SiH' I'lirkrr v. M, luiimi. Hi ( h App IIH; Ahrnlrvn l ■/. \ . lihrkii'. '■ Maci). 4til; an. I Eiiuiui MiiiiiKj ( o v. (inint. I I ('. I) il.lH 111 a.^certainiiij: the profit for which u promoiei i^ to I. made aecuiiiitahle. \ns dishnrseiiients in relation to tin- c(jropaii\ may in .some case* he ailo\vcd. Tims, in Kiiiiini Miiiiiiij ms to ini' thrti in eslimauuc lii« the defendants, profit. 1 ouiflit to find out his real prolit. that is. the real result of the transaction which was left Ut him. . f think, therefon-, we inioJit to a-sivrtiilii the iiel prolil. simply on the )iriliciple of ilediictini.' fioni all the i. eipi.- all the |iaviiieiils " Km IMUODItToKV \<)TV>. I.W , ,,.„„.„... «iii ..... iH. uii..«...i ... 1.....U ...."■.'• ' I'" ":'"•' "'■;'' „ M 1. .„■ U.... ulfn. rin: .1..- <• l-".^ '-.'/./».■// ' »';/":;"', .' •! I ( Div ■..-. S.... al..o IU,.„>nU V. r „r//..». •; < D '• ' V, Lu... WillM..,.. 1. .1 -x' u.. , H-..-.,: O, Urp..o.l. - ,,„„.„„i,„ ,.,„„,,a..x. parllv in ,.r...„..ti.... .-vtHMiM-, a...l ,.a..l> ... ...,l,,..iaii.i" ll..' I.all.-U.„.'. \u- ...^.v a" .1" .,,,U„„ „.■ .1... ......l.a..^. !..• ......1..-I1.-.I ." PV.- ..|. ...- "I'i" '^."■ J,.,„„„ ,„, „„. ,,r,H...,..ls ..f .al.-. if -^ >'""•""-' ' '"'1' -^^ • '" 'r is u. ,..-.......i.... ... •■■; .1 '•> ^ i";;;;;;-;;^ i::;;:;:::^^^^ ,,.„.,„.„^ ,„ .v.xli.aU. ,..^nM...t.,l ..,..I.M tl..- ( .....|.a....- A I I.H.H. ... ,1„. \,;~ «i.i.l. i. l.aH .-.■i.la.^.l. Sn.l. :. ,..■.-.........« .' !.""> ... .UMli.af i .allv ....<• r..n....l x«i.l. «i'l.- Ii'.a....ai ul.,....> ^ .... h.-l- ,„,, il,.. ,,........li.... ..f ......l>....i.>.-... a...i ii ...a.v Ik- a r.m.vr.. . an ^ - ,.;. CM I...M a.r...-.li..jrl.v a..,l .M.^ra..-,! i.. II..- ................ ..•-. I....." „;,i„ f ,...n.,.a..i..s; l...t ......v .,...........!> i.> .^1 a...l >..l.Ma....ul ,1,„„„|, u..,.X|..«-o,l ..t.j.M. i> ... |.r........<" "•"• l.a......lar . ,....|.a.,> . •liH.uaHi..^ «l... W....I.I ..li..-.«iM- l.av.- a-u....- l„.,..u». .l,a.cl...l.Uns in tl.c ,.r..im.ti..>: i.a..,v. an.l il...- ...«• l-.-'v ,„, ,,.. a.H-^ tia- i..-........in^r, a...l «!..•» .1.- ,.r........i.... •> .-..M-lotc ,1,.. ,..,.n,.a..>. a. U>».liil.....'l .„.Kl.. .,f p..,......i.... is s.„.....i....-s a.l..,,UHl «..h a v.. w .o u.n- LUh.iit^ of ...alin.' .1... i.l.M.titv <.f »h.> ,K-i^....s «1... arc in roahlv .nlvn-sto,! in li.e ,,„„„„li..... r..r tlL-ir ,..Msonali.> is n.orjrivl in tl... .„r,.or..t.>...ns int.Mv-l.-,l a... this is s„: t„r ,-xttn.plo. thov a.r ... n.. way lial.h- on a .■..n.m.t ...a.l.- !■> .h.- p.-........in>r .■..n.pu..v .so<- >-"i'r<'- |. 281. l.nl thorc M.H ronuiin <-asMC)TKK.s. [Chap. II. (lar tiv^ III a traiiil m ■■ It \u't ui'oli;; HTv iH'i-mia llv liul.l" uiiiuiittiHl u I'ruuil III' ulht't wioii^ u< IjiMDUse no iiiitliurilv tun HUiiilinu mix li can |)l)>it limi mm v riiiiiiiiuiil> iH u Iraiid iiiav ■»• a lii(iiiliiii>iii Im-ai I'll I if liii»l ( Ki u I III 11 'I ( <>. V. (Innil, 17 ( 1) ir al iiiiv ralo u lin>u< li It:! IiiimI ill which the ilinilnr.- kllllwlll;il^ roiuiii'. likinifK v, Ailtli). ;» (II. I). 24 ». Miiv(>r. if tlio >yii mail*' illii ii |irulil^ uiit ijf the >uiii|iaiiy iii'iiiiinKil, tin' |iriiiiii>t<'il ('iiiii|iaiiy iiia\. Ii\ viitiii! i>l' the liiluriaiy rclaliini nf lln' |iiiiiiiiiliii<; riiiii|iaiiy. folluu Miih |iiijlit» into till" liaiiiN ol ilio iiicnilrt'i-* of fho prouiotinu riiiii|)aiiy Baukruptcy In luosi i ax's a |MiinioliT in iriviv iiii: illo;.;itiiiial<' ;^ain.-< ri)iniiiiw ..fpMmoUr. ^ 'fraiiil or frainlidi'iit liiiai It of tiu>t' witliiii M-iit. .10 if tlif Hankiiiiitcy Act. IKh:!. Soo Ki'imu Mitihiii Co. v. (Irani, i' *'. U l'^2; UaiiiitLiH v. Kilioiidx. 'M (' I). Iim>, Miliiii Tniiiiiriiiin. ;j.'. ('. l)iv. ."iS7. But it .lot's not follow that iion-iiaynicnl of >'iin|>«'ii- satiuu for thi' frand or bioaili of truil will amount to dofaiilt liy u triisHt' ol' jM.'rM)n acliiiu; in a liiliiciaiv lapacily, and ordorod I" |)ay, by a Court of Eijuity. any Mini in Ihm jios.M'-^ion or under lii~ 1 outiol, within .sect. 4 of the Dtliturs Ad, IXii'.i (;{2 & 3.1 Vict. c. 62i Mihiilji'x mm: 1.1 CV U. 8 1.". A coiiniany wliicli has ici omu'iI daiiiau:i's a;{ains| a pronioter in resj.ect of a secret prolil iiiadi- liy liiia on a .sale to the coiiipuiiy inav prove for such damages in the hankriiplcy of the promoter, i-m li duiim^fes U'iiig ast-ertained and iheiefore a ' dcniaiid in the nature ul iinliipiidated dania^:es aii-inj;' ollier^isc than liy reason of a con- tract." F.niiiui Silifi Miiiiiiii Ci). V. (iiiiiil, IT t'h, 1). 122. Limiutiou. As to the period of liinitalinii. .V |)ioinoter is usually held liahl" ii- a coiislriiclive trustee, and iipoii the fiMiiiii^r that he has l>een guilt_\ of Truud. .\ccordin};ly, he (aniiol rely ;iii the provisiouH of wect. f* of the Tnisloe Art, 18«8 i-il i ."i2 Vid. r .V.l, not repealed by tln' Trustee Act, ISl'.'ii; for the si\ years' limitation wliidi in lerfain cu.'ies that statute establishes in favour of trustee!* i including con- structive trustees I is not available, as its operation is e.xcludeil where the claim i'; fouudeil u[iou any fraud or fraudulent breach of iiusi lo »hi(li the iiu-icc w.ts jitin^ ol piivN. or is to locovi'i trust projMjrij-, or the proifi'ds thereof still iitained by the trustee, or previously rei'eived by the trustee and converted lo his u.se.' See Sale Hotel, dc To., 78 L. T. .'ill8 That llin Act of 1888 applies iS- iNTKonrrroKV \otk>. 1(1 {llnlmriil '■<'■' I !• IK'U' I Cli •■•!'• ,ii»inii liN'' mi~l<'>'». I.iiiuls hxi'ii » |l,.|V ll»> MittlllC (I.H-^ ll"l 1>|'1 l>lv I liiiiii .lUiiiii'l i« (iii.niKH'r U< Imiiol l>\ iiiiiil"S.'> til tlif ^iliiHHi' li\ l.i|"<' »' ""»•' ,„, ,, «., „,.ll -.IU-.1 U.f..... tl... Mill Ilml .. .I.H.u ..L'a.n^l ■' I'r- ,.., a. .. ..u„M,..,tiv.. 1.U-U-. in n-|H-.. ..f a ...-..■ ul,lii,u...m t,. „.v a- ,l,.t...^M.i>l,..a fro,,. ... u.tual ,..i- ,,.,.li.ut,oM -.1 U..M ..,..,...>. :.:i,a,.W l.v MX v.vr.- .IHuv ,.f/,. ./-><--...V !■> .Ih" - ,„.,,m,.v ,- .he ,„,, Vrl.o,..l.l.n, n„nl. ^ Ih-ho,,.:. Kv l)u.:il',.. ,.n.lM.../^v■/.- ,„„,\ „,„,<■. i: w. ■..:. /f.oo,-. 20 •• DiN iH!.. «,'»,... ^ /(.„,./.,.•, IK.. I) 2.-... / >Wk i«'.'-i' 1 ^'l' l>'- "•• ;^'' ,., „„. „...ou..N of l.nlH.s ,,,., 1 to „;:.>....- of .o.njMn...,. mh- /,<..•- ,, r„ V Sluhhs. f.-, (■ D.v. 1. •"".'/<" «.» S„ll,.,,l ^. /..•.•,•,, .IH.tl' , (. 1! l.iH. //o,r«./.-» >..»« V .U,7//.o.(. 1.1 T. L H ••.<»■• 'I A ■• H., I. T II: Cnnil v. «... ' K.v,,h,rali„„. I'M.... I (^ . :•!. \ud ^ n- tu Foiiii "i'"! . to .I..- '».ai.l ' ■','■ I ■,• ,, „„t.... lo ll»' ..oiiipMiv M,'lr<>,>olilil. V. //.-/..« • ".' j ' ■ ,,„.„, ,1„. ,|,,..,,O.S an- tool- Ot tlOll.iM Ml tl,.. i.i-oii.o.,-.. 1. I. „.., ,„ii.,« ,1,.. ,.o.i,.- to tl..- ,ii.v..o,> ,- ... U' ,u-..H-.i ";"";•"■ ''"• ,m..v. hii:rou «.««<»«'' ' " • ^'-^ ^^ H j:.-; f ^N « -'-^ ,;,7,;„„;.r V. .NV»- .S,,„J..rr„ To . :'. A,,,' «"- '^l«^ ' ''^ '' ""''■" 77,.,//,r.- oi \,„u-l,rs. .I'.H.'i. -J , .I'.t.Mti A. <• .i'.ta. F... .1,.- |.r ...|..i..i. i- ll'^" 'l"'.^ "'•"''' '"" ,li>.|oM. lli.-i. "«i. «!oni.' '<■.>;:> 'h.-v «ill -xa........ ...to :...>- ,|.i„. l..arin- <... ll.a. ...at..-.- .ha. .h-- .,". X-H i'- "«" ^'"O "" "~ I,,,. I(,.l. ii. Ih<- pn-si-n. .UM., th.- ......l.a...v »a-^ |.aial\/.-.l -■.) I..r as ,,„i|aH.-.. a.Ml •■.i.i.iM.i «.•..- (.-...V I f... th.- h..».l r....... wa> ,„.,,. ,,i.-.l l.y tlw- otioitiv," sav^ l.o.-,l H..I.. .1...... i i;h,rh-. S.h- r;. v l''» Thus, whoif tho diivrtoi-s of .ln> )....-.!.asin;r . ..uii.a.iv u.tp also ,|„. .li,v,.|...s of tl.,- sy...li.a.,- vvhi.h p. ......I.-.I th.- ...lopi.iy a.i.l -.,.1.1 tho pr..|K.rlv to It.' hii..ll..>. M K . .".! ii.al -J., iiupui.- I ' ^'^- l:,l.•(•l.aHi..^r^ ,„i..pa..y th,' k..o«h-.l-v «hi.h tho .li.<-. t.,.s l.a.l a. - .,i,il<>.l i.i aiiothor capa.itv. ai..l ^^hl.ll l.„..»h..|.j:,- ih.-v .li.l not .1." 'M «i 14-2 I'KOMOTKKS. Interest. [Chap. II. ,.,...,„. ..n....l..-H.w ,.,..■ ......-•■ L,,u»..sM,...t.ro.^. No.i..o u. air..,.,,... i. n ;'''--'7 3''^-;;;^:, i" ,f,. r„. 7 (1.. K-.i; '.'"■,•,■ s ns... M I .V •«- ^„., lh,„k l.i '.V K. l.''.»T; ll.,»,i.slinr huHl ( <>■ . IH.M., . i I.. . soi, /Mr;./ /•-.'/."• 'f '■"•''•""'-'''' """ ,. . . '^''•- -7'''''7V;,rT:; ^ .: I -V I ..i^. uikI IK.) .....i.i'l ' 1'-'^" "" '" '", ' *■..„,,;,•/.■ Stohrit ,( To., . I'.t..:ii 1 til ■'•'" A. ... .....i... ... a.l ...^' ^...».vl.ol,l.-.s .....ui.' ....... >.. ...« •■-".->. As to Interest. w ,. „ ,..,-.„ ii. .. .1^1". »■- i""" i- ••-'""I '■■ ■;■■•■■"■" ';' ,„r;: .., .'. >■- .- .■".»■* "■■■•"•:' ';',:;:;;,,";;„„ :;;;;,r,:",',:,.; ...::- '■ '•»,'!.',"■■«'■' -.-"' .•^•''"•••"■'''■■'-■;:.;'t';'kV,.:;:; :,.,.^'™i'^^ ^Uru.^Uu^u in <./«.A.^7.'." V. /{,„»...v. . l'.»'") A. C at l-. -.■.• Death of Promoter. ,..,,1.. „,,.., a., i. V ,lM.......,.a..> |.,i .1......... ....-..';' >'..;...• .I.' : . L U .i,...ll.^ ....• '.■...... ... 1...>"1' "f >"- A..,.- >.»»'-. 'It /V..A- s r;,,n,.v. I. " •>" '• ''' .<"'.'/"—'- iiioriliii •III" jirinoiltl- INTKOUUCTOUY NoTKS. 143 21 .:t> As to Disclosure. H..« .1...... i.. ...a.v bo .^k,..l. is u ,,.„.n..,o. . .vl.o .I.-m.-.-s ... ...aU a IWJi. .X.,v. a.ul ..l..ain i.« .onson.y la ...dor ... au.w...- ,l..s ,uo., ttc liavc t<. lioai in iiiiii'l: 1 , Tl.a. tl..' .■..M.pauy in. a, anv rau' in nnn... .a^-. tn 1..- .I.-.- I ,„ hav.' n..tir.>..r iho fa.ts sta-.-l ... itn 1.....-I"""" ' '"' '•;"" Ciri.H 1. <' . F.rhixirr v. .V,-.r Som/.nn. ''" ■ :' Api' " •'" |-;i..- '...'"-.' uow that a i.r...iHM„,s. ...• .he stato.n.M.. .» I.-. ..t .<• -« re.i..iro«. - «" That in ll.«- "I.S.M...' ..f f.a'.'l. ''vo.y .nt.n.l..-r of ,1... |.m..v . ,,„;, a, .....lin^rlv the .•.m.panv ..self, is .l.-.-n.-.l .0 l.av.' ....... ." of what is SOI f..rlh in the ..m.|.an.v's in an-lnni a.i.l u,ti.h-s ..f association. S,..- (ihlJUh v. /'.<././. f. C. I) 'I-. .,,,1 „,!....• niM-scito^l mrr.. n> '*> "' '«• '"" 'l'"".^' ^^'""■'"'' ,hi.. sort ..f iinp."."'! "•'>•"• "-»'''' '■'"''' """-' '""I""'" In Mvt 81 ..f tho A.-, t.. ho ^I.o.•ilio,l in Iho |..-..s|.o, t..s. an I ill fail ni.l s|ioiilioii iho.oin That ... Iho ahson.o ..f f.an.l ...• n.is.o,....MM..a..on l,fr,>,> ^ /.•,rf.v. !.;,>,. ^ . Tu'ss. I«'.m , A. C. -JT.t .. .•v.v ...o...ho, «..o .suhs,-.ihos .... Iho f.M.li..;. ..f .1 l....s,,..H..s .....s. 1.0 ,k..>n..vl ... havo ....'i.o ..f tho .....t.M.ls of .,..v .•-.ntr-.s tl.o.ohv ..llo.,-! lo, in-p.' .....h-. mm,. «1 -.1 . .il «. wi.h ..o.i o ..t a...v .onl.a, . :i„..'.n,..nl. or n.al.or n... s,K-..ili.all.v rofo..v.l f. ... so. h ,,r..s,«M...-. is v..i.l S..,.. 81, suh-«.o., I, ot l'.M)H. Th..s. in r....... o ... .1 . -.;".'. vvl'or.' had lia.l l..r ...sporLoii. .lo-sol. M U ■ ^.u.i. i' ,„„|,,i, Sjono ... MH. it .an.l I -Link i.i " ...ur. ..I J..^t.,o .!,.■> . a....... . -.n,. a,n thai .hov ili.l ..... MH. it. h... .uusl he h,:,ted as hnn,., „oh F,l,u,.,v, -.(1)111. An.l in tho Honsr ..f Lor.h 1.. tho sa„... ....«.• i;,.,..| Ularkl...... sai.l: ' 1 .hi..k .ha. oa.h all..ltoo was Kxo.l «..!. .!.■• k„.,.l..,l,.. ho W0..I.I havo ha.l if !..- ha.l r..a.l i. .-.•.•• " -■'";':: " .,„■. ,wsr 7 I' I) :•"' hi:!, aii.l //..//"•'•< v h.rin,'. ■\ < 1. \'< sair iioi.i. .('■ ' " . -X •" '1' ■■''"'• ^^■"«'"- ' • ^'I'l'""'- "• '-•';;• ''•- „a.i.. I from tho r.ilo thus lai.l .h.wn, a...l I., hou' :.v..l.-l tho ..llor o. ;. ,..,„,,a,, f,„. i„s|M.r,i..n as inotV....>.v... .... .h .'• -'.I iha. .1 «. ,u,lon.a.s Iha. sha.ohol.h-.s sol.h.n. ...ok .ho t.onl.l.. to l„.,k at ..o...ra.-.. so 0H0.0.I. Tho ..as..s al,..w ..M«rr...l to u. n' ...... hn«."v ■ . ; ■ ' ' ' ii If 144 riJOMOTEHS. ii: [(•map. II. cI'.m\, aiiiil>U> It'iiniivl loiil.t wlio took purl in tho ileciNion in Aaron's llrrfs v. Tiriss, i IHUIJ) A. ('. 27;t. up|iiii-oiillv rccojjnized flii. mic i»> Niiiinil. for whilst lioUliii^ (liKcJiisiiri- in u jiro.s|i4ti'tiis of the flau- and |>iirti<« to a conirail iiiMillicionl nolict- of itx foiiltMilH. thcv (li('liis conlai i a iiiiMri>pn'- M-iilalioii. and llnrrfitrr ri'jicved an applirant from iiispiMtin^r iIm' cuntracl . anii. on the wuiiio ground'*, in (iltivkxlfin \. liuniix, (llMMt) A. ('. 2»(t. .lensel, M. II., (juv<« the true principle in Smitit v. Cluulii'nk. 2(1 ("h. I). :u: ■ It, lia« ahvav- Ix'i'n In-Ill. anil 1 think rijfhllv lu-ld. thai if a man in a i)ro«piTtii> .... fulMd.v Mlatos the ronlontti of u written docnincnl. ho cannoi I'Miipe from xiiiii falsi' Nlulcmont hv .suyinjf. I ollvred to fihow mmi llu> duiumi'iit ' llul if ho make an iiiitiniplolo .sialeniont. alto| 'riial notici' to ^ho din'i'toiK of iho rompanv. //' thfii n/c mi I'lili'iH'iuh'Hl ijcriitiiH'. lint iiol othorwiwo, i.x oipiivulont l^ nolic«> to the rompany Mi-troimliltui Hunk- \. Hi-iron. :< K\ Div Mit: /,V Fil:roi/ l{t»s,-nifr <',,.. .(•_» \V. |{. I7i .'!.'i \\ |{ .'!I2: Lecd.s and Hdiilei/ 'I'lTtalri'n of \'iiiirtii's. ' MMi-'i L' Ch. HO'.i; (iluikstem v. ftirw*-... i I'.MHI) A. ('. 2Ki 1 1> I 'I'lml iho momorandiim and articlox of n.-isoiiatioii aro. Ii\ M'li II oi tho .\i I of l'.M)8. iiiailo hindinir on tho eompanv and tho niomlM'r.- tlioroof. aixl accordiiiirh iho lonipimv niii;l Ipo lit'aU'il a.'* i onsontinj;- to what i.t dono in piir-iiiaiiri' Hi iho iojjal pi ivi>ioiif ihoroof (h^rrrini '■iirii''>i luw«o inonoy. In niioIi iiiho Iho contra, i for -ah- !•> il»' 1 oinpiiiiv v»ill di^i'liiM' Us inio'i'st ; tho iiioiiioiaiiiiiim and .irliilos will rolor to thai o'liliail and discji.M' vsliat I', i^ to "i-l .md ailllinri/o Iho diifv-t'irj- t" iarr\ it out ami «ill iwrliup- stalo ih.it I! i> not, h\ rou*i.-n of hi.- lidin iar\ lolalion-hip. lo |.r pioi Inihtl hdin aici'ptin^ iho ronnMM'ialii'ii; tho pros|M'otiiM or Htalt'iiiont in lion of pro"|H>('ti|s iiiiist loh-i 1.. iho i'oiiira< I and "llor it for insiM'ition. and hiII diNiloru' tlio lad that U iis l«'iiiif n'liiiinoialod. anil llio aiiioinit paid or In- (■■iidtd !• I"- pai.l In him ai! I llio • nii.sidonilion for llio paviiioni 1 -••' ' M t I of Iho A.I and Iho .■•; pain will ho f.oiii.'d with Ata KiLxa INTKODIICTORV NOTK8. I4> ,, i„do,K on. il-d to ,,„„mcn.v lmMm-s«. Compani.v. Act. 1-JtiH « 87 CD. (•a«... I.owrvor. ,s«n.otin,o« ariso in wln.li Uuto .h an .nsu,H,.ablo .laiioul.v in .onM-lyinjr with tho r«le« ubovo rotVrnHl to; .•..;. "• the ,,„. of a ..rivuto .•on.punv fornuHl U. ,.ur.ha..o «.«! work tho Ims.ucmM .,'f „ (irn. 11.0 n.on.U.rs ..f which are to \m Ih- only .l.rcclo.^ and to l,old pmctimllv uU the «han.K. In nn.li a < ..>i- .lu-r. .h no rndepondent ,.,<.,, 'tiv,. «n.i it tho rnh- hud .lown l.y l.oni (aims in l:rta„„.-r v. \ru- Somhrrro to woro uppliaihlv, the i-arlio.s roul.l not ..llo.t.voly ;,rrv ont a transaction whi.'h is p.-rtVcly h-j;it.in.alo. 1U.1. >n s.u-h ,..,...,... ina..|K-ndo«t oxecutivo is not .'ss,.ntial, lor the snnph. r-ason ,i,at all tl... parti<.» an- fully .■otrnisa.it of all tho fu.t.s ol th.- .-a-s,. ,.„.l.on~.M.lin-tothourran>,iMmM.t. S.h- Mi;.n.. p. l:t-.. \,„l ,>v.r. whorr tho .•on.pany is not a privato ono and ihon- is not. u„ in.h-|K.ndo«t. oxooutivo. if tho arti.los of .wss^niaUon show this la.-t ,. ,, l.y slatinjr that tho .liixTlors of tho .unipany uro all dirooK.rs ,,„, ,1,.. onlv ,|iiv,.t.,rs of tho von.h.r syn-liralo «hi.h is ..il.ni^ to ,,„,.n,„panv „n.i tho pn^iHHlusslalos that tho pr torsaro >oll.n^' ,„ ,. pn.lit. a sulli.iont dis.l.K.ur.' is ina.lo. /.„-;./»./.s- Sil'olr < •>. v. Uho.ho,- a pron.otor i«, apart fron, sect. HI of t.ho Act hound to r.,...l.H.ure of ,|is,.|.».o not onlv tho fact that, ho is n.akin- a prolit. hut tho amount ,|„.,vof, is uitsotthHl. Acordin- to (■li,:' \V. I{. :iti7, and Livjinuw SilnUci <,. \ Laijnmis Syiult- call- t.lnyndi(ato ,1,,. V. M.lor and piunwlois \ and -f tho prolils made l,v iho sa\<- lo tho N.iiaio t ompaiiv a-s f.ilal 1m tho vi.li.lily of iho.-aio U„ I Ih-r hand, in 0/.v»,;;i »w,lr awl s|M-. i„- u.i« dolilMT.ilolv misl. a.lin..- l.ui l,..|.l UoU-rt^..n. ■ l'.X«»i A (' •J.-.M..av-: I ooiiM.hT that 111.' liansH.tioii in ii...i1'4...v:<'h, -.ii wlii.li a -.o, n-t pn.lit had 1..VI1 ma.h', «a«. sM rolovaiit l.. ih" .|UoMi..ii «li,ii pro.' r.hoiil.l iho ...mpanv (my f..r ih.- pioporty. thai .• «a- iio.^v..arv that it ,h..ul,| Im' dim'l.w.-tl to tlM- o..mpaiiv t-otiniU-ieUj at a discou.ii 'lerlaiu iuort«»'.n'« on th. property. Is «iih hold tW". tiw •pp«-llaui. ii mem- ber of the svudiciiU', «*•* liable Ui :iccount tor M»is furiimr i)rolii This tujfe at any iaw sliows tlmt U) make a iiiif4f«i».iiiie ■•■•■■ inorn'ut or imperf<!r!» of a ntnimaiy who wer« interested lu the promotion of smh ■•ompuny were boiMu4 t« disclose llie amount of tlio prolit whirh. as menilH>r> of the veii.r r syndioule. rhk-y w«m' niakin-.' ' Tlwy i|i-Hi iiiii j«»dare, t.fie fact iteit they were directors of the vendor symlieaie an* theroliy they ntiamt- Karily di>clostHl that th.y were niakint.' "oim proMt It is .{«») truo tliey did not disclowo what i»robt they \»«iv naitiug, and au tliat, as it seems to me, they were wronp, aad svUtj >i a breads wi duty." This i.s potxi sense, for witkout sucli knowledg*- hfiw can tte- tomiKinv pive uu iiiU'lU^.t-nt o-twent to tae profit lieinj^ aswle '■' The Companies .Vet, l'J08. hais nt.** niai*; jiositive priwiwons for disclosure in a pro»f>ectus iuvitinc sub>nture i-fcutk, and tlus i»«itiui.>ry ofilijrauou latoives the direct di-t'lo.-iiie of promoters' pront*; i i! any i >«! iu ^^a^tu!»iai■, sect- M ■ 1 ' "I ihi' .\it. elau(.es if . i- . Ai<. li.i. 1 . iki .uid imi, iiljia. rriK-jiectUM'S. Liability in respect of Prospectus. LUbility on Not oidv are |iromoter» liable under the obligations above referred pro.peotu8. ,„_ i^,„ ,i|t,y ,„„y incur lialiiluy iu rc^liect of misstatcnioiits in the I rospettu-, wlieie ihey lake any part in its pivparalion, or auhori/c Its i.ssuo. As to tins, »tions of tlie UiretUirs Liabilily Ad. 18'J0, and infra, p 105 Vmler- Underwriting. or lute it li:i>^ Ixx-onic very comiiioii to i^'ci the capital of a company or a sul)-iair;i(l piirt tlicicof, under" rittcu licfore ihc pro-poctns ot the company is pithlidu'd The underwriiind is u'enerally ar- ranged by the promoierB of the company la makin<; any «uch INTRODUCTORY NOTKS. 147 wruiif.'^mtinr liio coiiililioii* of Mict. 89 of tlio Coiupaiiies Act, 1908, »iiu~i Ik' iHniir ill iiiirnl .Si-o fiirthor, infra, ]> 271t. Preliminary Contracts. r-Yi.iiioloi^ -i.iimiiiiK-s (Icsiii.. i(, briiin- lilt! r..iii|iuii\ into o.\i iiio- "«>tr«oU. p«iiy ul 11 s|M-( ilioil piiif, or to pnv a .spoiiti"il nuiii for pii'liiimiary ox|iiiiM'.>. To lio tliis is, howovor, dillicull, if not iiupo-isiliin. As up|H!i*i> Jwlow, p. ,'i21, a coiiiract inmlo on U'liuif of a iioiapanv Iwfdix; il> iiiroiporulioii is not binding on llio uumpuny; ami a pro- vision in the urliilc-^ of a.s.sotiatiou lliat llie lonipauv tiliall mlopt and I'V liound by such a contiiKl, or -hall fiiilfr into a partimlm contract, -nil loavoi- tilt' coiupany fivo, iinlo.s.s and until after its incorporation :t iliooM-'s to bind itself by llio contract. Kvi-n tlion tli<> contract iiiiiv Ik- provisional nnly iiiiiil tfir iniiipany is oiititk'd to coiiiniciicc buMiio.,.^. S-.' t oiupanittB Act. i9liijfcl S!i,i,l,.iil,: IH99. '2 *Jh. Wt, A. -/•//( .>>/»,•// ],in'stm'-nt in v. U,,i,,.M. i imw. A. » 2ti;;, bai md. by mi'iely aciin^r tl,rouf,'l) its directors i,n u cvmtnicl iimde h^mrn u.-, ionnalion, incur any couiraciual roLiiion Willi or ..iiliiimiun o. ihf vendoi Snrlhuiidhrhuul Av.cmie Hotel (it-. sutiM S.tttii >iMm!>i lmvM)H4'ut and I uimHuii Co. v. Ili,i,i,,.s. ■•ui,r,i: .IttHantmKhurii Hotel (it.. ilS'.lli I (,h 1 !;»; Ii„<)nt i'mu- iHui., Tjire to V. I lipper I'iwiitmiltc Ti/rc Co . mpra. Or evoii In iitkiUK the l»ei»tii of a pn-iiicorponuion cnlract. Rotlurhnm Aliti,,. lie. Co.. 2r, Cli 1) llt.i; ( liulnns rhiim. . 1!M»«) 2 ( li :,i:,, ovcrnilini.' I'.i>'ll<-li ami ( ohtiiml i'roiliire Co , , I'.IOti . 1 ( li. I.I.", Noi can :i i oiupany ratify a coiitr.i.i inado Ixifoiv ii was iw^w- poialfd heln,T v tlurter, I, K 2 C. I' 17t, ;ippr.o..d bv !«•• Vnvy » oumil ,n S.dul Land. ,(. Cn v I'aidin,, tte .^'/n.l,<;tte. (V.».-.• ,«/ru. (hap. IV ■M'-'i' " ^t'oaled by oach niomlMT and coniaiiiod covenants on lie part of each imMiiUuImc, 1 iu the provisiou.s of the Act." JJut tho dc isi,,ns in /./,y eompMiy. i>R<)MOTEK8. [Chap. II. I'otitive GoverntHtnU Co , I Ex. Uiv. 88; Jiiuinn- v. Im Trinidwt Co., ;(7 ('. Uiv. 1; and Dariiiij-Uoul'I v ShurjNUf/lon. iPc. Syndicate, (18'Jl>l 2 L'h. 80, flirow doubt on tin- olluuc.v ol such a. jiliiii. and in the result it 1ms not Ihhjh usual to jnoiwd in this wiiv. The u.suul und iii...st oirfilivo luodd of hindiiiiT .i coinpiiMy is to inwrl in llio MiCMioruiiduui «nd uitiules j)ro|HT duusos iidorriii;.' to the i)ro- posed apiwiiRMits. and directiiij,' or I'injioucrinv' the '^lir.'ctois In oxoculo und c.irrv the «ainf into «.|r«.it The proposod dir.'(,.(or>s ii.Hually i«.\aMiin«' and consider thu aiu'rc-uifnts |.,.f,,ro !li.. fonnaliori of tho lonipany. und tho snhsc'.(u«>rit adoption ihereof. in such ii inunner us to tonstitul*- a now . ontnicl. is, thoroforo, in most lasos ;, forejroni- i-omlusion, ihouirh iho fait thai .a .oinpany is lonn.'l f„r Iho ...xpri'ss purpos,. of carryinir out a particular contr i t will not rclit.v< Ihi- diruciors from the ol.lipiiion ..f cxcrcisin^r ;, |. ,.„,„.,. .iud-uicnl on Iho UH-iits of such contract. lirazUmn Unhhrr Pin,,- latiojis vNo 1 1, (I'tin 1 Ch 42i"> It if., however, far liotter. in tho interest of all j.artio in lii.-sc (■HM>s. not lo seek to c.inlrol tho discrotion of tho directors, but 1 . leave thoin fn-e to adopt or not, as they think til. the iueliii.inar> ■ ontracts. Occasionally, however, in ndiance on Ashbiir;/ v. Witl.soi,. M) ('. I)iv ;J7<>. tho nionioraiiduiu of association refers to a j>arliculiir eonlrucl. and provides that it shall l.e .■vociod and .-.irriod int.. eth'ct Whichever couis,. i^ a.loptod, sul.-sect. (,'{ of seel. 87 of the An of l'.tll8 (wliere that .section applies, whereby a contract made before tho company l)Oconies entitle.l to coiiiiiienc«- l.iisiuess is merely pr..- visional, niiisl !«> borne in mind. Siiimi. pp. ::i), 22. There is some authority for sayinj,' that a pr(un..ler mav. oven in Iho ubson.D of any express .(.ntiac t. U> onlith-d, as against ihe com- pany, to compensation for si-rvicvs ron.leivil iK-fore tho formation of the company, provided that the company can luoiM-rlv 1m> ooii- Mdori'd to have a.lopie.1 and .b-rived U-netit from those" service- n,r,'f„r,L lie W.uiot, (•„. 2 C Div. (i2l; T.;r,-ll s ll,i/h„i. I H I. (' 10'.».i; Uollicrham Miiin. tfr To . 2.) t Div lo.i liut i- is no easy niattei t.i prove adoption and iM-nelii. .See ItotheriMm Alum, dc Co., 2.". CD. lO.t, and .\„l!o,uil Motor Mail Coach Co, Ctintou'g ease, i I'JOH) 2 Ch, .M.-> The mere fa. t that the promoter pays the ro.,ri,tiation f<-es an.l «,/ rnlorrm flamp oi, n ^rislerin;r a cnipany dcK's not in itself entitle him to rew.vor tlie.ii from the eoiuj)any ( IIhIohk claivi, mpra. oxerrulin^' on this point tho decision of Huckley, .1 , i„ i:,l,,lish a„,t folonial I'mducr. C„ I i'.»ti . Clinton s cUtim, I'JoH) 2 Ch. ."il.">. Whollier a soliiilor han or lias not a rijflil aM afraiii>t tlii' rnui|i.iii\ iiiiiy dciiviid on uliolhcr Uv bus a>,'ri'od in locik to tin. coiniiaiiv I'lU- payiiiont or lia^t hwMi rolaincil hy and ii;;rc('d to look lu ilii> |itiiriiuli V. Div. I2.">; llnthrrluuu Mum, ,(; . C, . J.. (' Div. 103), unlftis it tan Im) inado out that llicro is a trust I'urilic soiiiitor. S«'0 tho almvc .asi's. iiinl (,',in
  • »' Div. NO. Tourlir v Mvlroiutlilan. .(c. to.. ti eh. G7I. .\.s a Rcnoral lulf. lhi> promoiois ..t tonipaiiii's an> not |i;irlnoi> I l.indlcy on (' iiupanii-.s. )*lh od p. 1'.).'!), l.ut they may a^Mcf to he sm, and whothcr ilioy havo so a(,'r('pd or not is a (pio^lion c.| fail Thcrr arc many <'a*08 in which tho arraiig«Mnont betwoon tho pioniolnrs dn.-. U'voiid question lon.slilulo thoni j)artiiors. qua tho particular advcn- tur.'. with Iho i onwMiucnl ntrht i i,il,-r aliu) to oai h prMuiotor lo oohlrart i,n Ix'half of Iho pariii Mship; l>ul wIumo ihoio is n.) juirtnci-- .ship, one co-prnnioler has n.i iiupliod aulhoiiiy as su< h li hind iho prmnotorrt iolleoliv l>v himself or with his authority, and, if ho is «u.m1 on a (oiiira'f niado hy anothor, that aulhnrity ini:,-t iio nhown Uhothor profimlcrs .no or aio mil in any parliiular ra.s" partners, liioro is not, in the alispini. of riiulratl, .my inipliod rijrht in ono of ihoui, as asrainsi tho others to roMiuneratiiin for nerviee.s rendered l-y Imiu for the juinl henolil ft himself and ;heni. lloIm,:i v. lli,,<• ('. 71; /.i/.yi.v v t'^ac/i. I Man \- (Jr. (17; I indh-y on Conipanie.-, Otli ed. p. HI I !>..' oi loiirw, there is nothing' lo prevent promoters from joinih fonlradinc with, and iMVominjr liable lo, a third parlv: /• -/. if Ihey jointly retain a «oli lo him M,int v Sm.lh. t H ,\t \. ,12J), and eillier of them is . ■milled l.. haw the hill la\ed U,' Slr))l,,n. 2 Ph. .">il2. And where pronso'ers have thus hecunie jciinily liable lo a lliird Part\, and by virtue of that liability sotiie are ( ompelled \„ pav. lliev may have a rijrjit as a^'ain-l IJie olheis to enloriiiiiitiiip^ anil foriiiin<; oIIpt ('nin|mnio a.x to loiilributioii, -<>o /'7i7ero/r.vf.i*(', I'l ('. I). 5!".'; (llufkHtiin V. li:>, 2V.) Oiiiite uf prKle-sioiiiil jiiomoler.-. liii- coliiitur ciiiplow'd ui.'rtM'.s til look to tlie cuiiiiiuiiy fur |KiyiiiiMii. ni I < luil.e no ill' II i!Xie|il I'^r ' uiil 111' po krl " exiii'iise-i, mile-' tin' umipuuy lloiit> I'lDiiiiiteiM .-lioiild 1)1' laret'iil lest, in ilit'ir desire lu lluiil the Loiii|iaiiy llie\ i>vei.-te|i iIk- liiii- of ,vhul i.« loj^ilmiute iiiiJ |ifriiiissibli' Tor e.\;iiM|ili", iiii> iiiuiii|»i 111 iu;ike a iniirket " fur tlh' .sluire- liy luiyiii^', or iiK'teii'liii^ I'. i"\. :ii a liroiiiiiiiii ur by ' ri;;;;iiij^ llir iiiarki'!. lull.-' Ik- itvoiih .il'-::il':Miate and dun^^cMoiii. 'Phis (iin'iaiioM wo* rciViicd lu foll..n,-: iai t' till V.\t lialiy ■.- M H , ill Morzettis ,;i>. :.'« W. l{ .ill. u.. I dn ii'>. Miuw till' terliiii' ai term I'm tlic thiiiLT. Iml il i-* to valui-. Ill a|>|iai>'Ut value, of llir .-han- uii ilie .Stork by bu\iiij;; up tlie few that ari' i-.>ued at .i (iiemiuiii. so as to indii'i' the publir tn tome in uiid Mubscribe for the ■•liares in the company under the notion dial tliei • is a l)0)lii fidf preniiiiiii In 'e oliiaiiied by .siibsi ribiii;: Whether mie oiii.'-ht tn r.ill llial a im\- spirury ui ii'it do<'- nol mil' h luiiller, but I supp(,s<. buih in |.i« iuid nioruliiy it is a « iiu.''piraiy to ilefiiod thi' public' and notli ii_; else And ill I'uiirrii.-x V. (iriiHl,-V I' iJiv I'i'i I'.t.'-, itriimwell, L .) , iiaiii thai till' deli'iidaiil ' weni into llie in irkel and hiiu>r|it a larp) liunibi'i ol sliaie-.. and various ne |iup<'r> \' eie imliired. bv piyiniiiis to subordinal" peisous, to '.vrile favourably of the company. The *lniro> ni^e I" a preiiilnm; ilu' piibli' \ i aUr.eli i and sub-cribed for the rapi.d, <.r a lai;;i' pan of ii. both ftiiaics and debentures Tli9 defendanl a'leiiipii'd in juhlily Ki'"' '' '''i" faKe appeaiau'O )>eiis that sliares ure made to appe.ir worth le.ss tli.iu iheir leiil value by people .selling them when they have iioi u-iit thoni There aie tw" anwiver'i to this: first, ibi'ie is no nait'in to suppose tha' any mh li jiiailioe was appn- hendeil by tln' ronipaiiy. next, ib.it it riui: t be rijfhi to .oiinteru'l Kuch u proieedini; in the way here uihjpted; iiiid iiiie ed. fiirtln'r, if it is believed ili.it a .-■. lieme is a f;(Kid one, and |)0O|ile tay to de- jjrtH'iate it by selliiiL' iu- shares, they should be niuuteriiiined honestly, lltt «b,i tiriik \\i:\\ iii il buviny the sbariti HO old. Aifaiii, in .»o// \ Ihtnrii, i I8".»L'I 2 i) H 721, it v,a.s held that uD Ai^reetiM-nt between two nr inoie to piirrh imo Hliaros in u ^umpuuv in onif! Ill induro [mmsoiis who mijrht th"reufter iiiiri ha^e slian-s in •mi. euiiifiauy tn Iwlieve, rontrary to the fai t. that there was a Imm INTBoDUCTORY NOTES. 161 ti,h- ninrkcf for in» chnnn, and thut tho nhuroH wore at u rral prpmium, »:ii. all illt'k'tti lrttiit*ttcii<>u and might bo iiuulo llit> suliju-t of uii iiidi -t- ni.'ii' I'll (H)ii.>.iiira. V. Tliif dcti-ioii wtw LomhI on Ilia: v. Lu IterenijiT, ,1 M X S. ti7, in vvl.i i. it wua liold thut it »us n criuiiual njiispinuv t-. iij_'r rai.'o tho price of tho piiljli- funds on a |.jrtilii' t'> raiM' tho value of tho pulilio fiiri(l«, but liemiiso It i« fraiiduli'iit iipiiui't ihi*o who purrha^o a xcmliUU- cummndHij li> lai.-e tin- I'riii- of il at tin ,iui. diey purcha-i- it by fraiidiilont lalsu- ;m.,..I,h on ul'irh Ihey arc iiit«'iidcd to aft. The c.iii.-'i.ira' y was Iicid I-) JM' ciiiiiiiuil, not I^HuiiMo the artii If to \ H Div. 4«, 5'.l. The crime lie« in tho ttot of conspiracy and i(;iiil)iiialion to elteet ilial piiriHW, and woidd hove l>oen complete altliou'_'h il hail not Im'^mi |iur.-.ii,'h, liir v />-• Hiretiiicr. uhi ■ iifim l'..;uallv, any alteiiipt to obuiii a (|iiolation of the .-hares on I lie London or other 8t*«t dejil in tho shares , n lU.ii foolini^ Any scheme, theief. , to l.i'<'iv(> tho oommittee mux uiioiiiil to a consjiiracy to ;heal and detraii,! those persons who I liLiiii bv reoi-oii of the (piotution Ije inducts! lo dee.l in the shares. >«s> II, , I V. AkiiumU. 2 <• H. Div. 18. in that ca.st luo defoiidants, ilic proiuoKTs of a conipany. wore convicted of a criininal conspiracy M iiclia:id They had ubtai 1 a .luolation b\ falsely repro.senlin)? thai more than Iwo-tliirds of the cai)ital had been .subsi rilx'«l by tho |Hil,lii an.! that the application money of ll»#. |)or nharo hail Ix'en paid up theiviin; wlierciw in fact tho .shares were applioc:ii'e amount i>ui, 8 I'll. IU.1.>, lOol; Slimirf v. Wihr i« A j, Tiiiic.s. IVc. 8. Itttta. ai.d SaUiman v. llurH.r, Gi L. T. iOi. All a>.'r(.iMiienl for .su.li a scheme, however clearly expressed, cuniio! be eiiforrt J or Kued on n] ',2 FKOMOTRKK. [Chap. II. K«aumro«iuU- lion* to pmiaotan. Reconunendationn to Intending Promoters. Id coiic liiNiiiii it iiiuv bf iix'liil in suliiiin i|j<> tollinMiii; riH'iiiantoii- ilutiuiiH t4> |iri>iiiot4>r-i: (1; Wlii-n- It in iiit4>ii |iri>|Mjii\ and ri-^rll ut u j)rolii, fitlxT tu u r<>iii|>uiiy iir olIitTwiNo, U* iiix'iil not l<> tuko uii\ Ktt'|t« t4>wui'iuiitii>ii 1)1 ili<> i', until vmi liavo a \iili'ini|ili'l(>rt|H-cr tliat |r|'an|iiii;.' at Iik) ininli [irnlii nui> <'a>ilv ilufcat ilM'il' liv l>iini.'iii}r alumt llic liiiliiio nl llic i'n!<-r|>riM> I 3i SitN) that tilt! i'(ini|ianv in |ii' is nuido tn llu-in and lu tiir ouJiipaiiy ludt'lM ii'ii 111 liuix' incaiiM diitH'tnrs ivlio arc ijoi iiiif>i-<.s|4'd in ihc jrr..ni()lii.n, •' ij., Iiy rrrciviny M'ndor- bliuri'N or Iwini? i|u:ililio(| |)\ t|i<> pminiiterN (i> !iei< lliat, wlioru iIktc i.i or tuuy Ix'uny .1 mlil a^ to tJi indo|a'n- donou of llio «'.\('«uliv<', lull dix lo-.uro is niadx ol ail thi- variety of iiiatti'rt wliidi iiriiiiii /iiWc oiiijrlil to Kc di.-cloMMl to an ill . (.rndt'nl <>\(>iutiv«' S*-*' \t. l.il. siiiiia. c5l !><■<' lliat tliH uifuio/aniiuin and ailiil<'.s conlain uU roijuiMi-' |irn lo lioxiilo couinit'nt or an\ lliin;^- unfair (.i tlu- <.(jni|>uny or ll« Nulisiriix'r-i n>) S^H' that tli< pr>i.-|ii'( his or -latonii'nl in iii'u iji. ii..f, f-p.., iailv if tlio ]iroinot4'rM liav<- anv port in it.'* pn'paratioii or issii.'. is laiily and lioni'stly franitti hifni, pp. H;.') vt uni. I 7) 'i'-ik.' uiif in i>urli(.'ulat ihal the pro\i>ionM of i, i.,. kI and K- ol tlio Alt aif lohipJiiMJ wiih. (,8j Ii«>ar in iiiiiid wet, 8'j of the z\(t, and do not Im> a party to ili. ])a\inont out of the purcliu^.-iuoufy, «liilln.r diriiitlv or indirccily, of any loiiimifi^iou for sub'^criliin;.'' or procuring ilif .siib^cription of »liaroi>. 16a PKKCKDKNTS. \..HVKMKM hif I'HoMorKkis to I'w I'rrliminnrf/ K\n ssm in Form 1 . nmiiuh'riiliun of Vi.mhik's Siiviiks. AN V iiK.KMT ma ^Ml^:ll^.\^ liv tho mi h<"cliih'il contnut il i-* iiiiiontr other thiiiirt piovi.l.-.j iliiii ilie m\ A -hall pay all tlie pn-liiiiinury ••vpfiiMo^. that ii to ha\ h.ri- ^rt out ittirtiruliirsl: A.\D wiiEKK.^t lh»' pros|HM tu.*. a <.»py ol vvhidi 1." himMinto aiinoxtil. has been approval by tho hoanl ot .lirpdorK nf the .ox, ami has Immmi duly (ilo.l with tho Hcirislrar "\ t (w, ami the jmnip is willinsr to advi-rtiso tho kuiiio at thoir own oxpcniMv NipW rMKKl:l-OKK IT IS At.Kf.KK a.s |(dloW«: I riio proiip Hhull a.lvortiso and ( inulato the m1 pro»|>ortii>i in a "utlii iiTl and i>H.'.iiv.« inannfr or in lu i;roiif) Khali pay all tho proliniinary cxponsos aforosnid, and shall iudoriinify tho ml A a^'aiimt all procj'oliupi. o|aim» and doniandu 111 respect ihoioof. .t If tho jrroup Mhnll iliily (jerfonn thoir oblipntions undor ilauww 1 .n.l J hoit'iif, thoy (»liall bo ontid i of tho sd 1,.->0(I fully paiil-np >lian's. and tho -d A will priKurc tho r<>y to allot tho .-ami' to ihoni aiionlin^'ly . 1 I nli'-s U'l'iii" til day of next tho coy shall have Imtomh- entitled to <'iiininen< ■ liu.siness, the K^oop whall forfeit all rlaini to the -d iiilly paid-up .-hares, ,iiid. t-ax-' :i« hnlM'fore e\pio-.sly proMilod, the ;rruup shall not 1)0 onlld to any remuneration for thoir servi<-«s in re.siM'ct of tho preniL-os. In wiiM.ss, At. I'MtiM. ItwitaU. Wlmt B. Ui (to. Kurthrr, ('omiidcm. tiiiu. I'ooditioDi. Schedule^ Ai Ui till' ><.iu|iuiiy iM'in)! rntitlisl to ri>iiiiii<'ii' " 1 iiaiiifn \i*t, tufira, |>. 'JU, ■u-t. 87 iif till- v-.-'isaBisi^ >3 164 PRUMOTEKS. [Chap. II. u i Form 2. PartieH. Recital. A. to pay tlip preliminary expense!*. Condidera- tiun. Agreement to Pay Frdiminary Expenses in consideration of Commissions. AN AGREEMT mado, &c., between the Coy, Limtd (hnfter culled " the coy "), of the one part, and A., of , of the other part. WiiERE.vs a prospectus of the coy (whereof a copy is hereunto annexed) has leon tiled wi,a the Rejristrar of Companies and is about to be published and circulated. Now TIIEKEIORE IT is AfiRKED aS folloWS: 1. The sd A. shall procure the sd prospectus to bo extensively advertised and circulated, and shall jjay all the preliminary expen-^os of the Coy, that is to say, all the costs, diarp^s, and expenses of and incidental to the preparation and filing of the sd prospectus and the publication and circulation thereof, and of and incident to the pre- paration, execution, and rej^istration of the coy's nioiudni and arts of asson, and of these presents, and all other expenses of and incident to the establishment of the coy down to the time when the coy becomes entld to commence business, or if the directors of the coy .'e sd I to purchase irom hi,, the sd concession, tho sd B. shall have the option of saUs ying anv part of the balance of the purchu.sc-n.or for the amount, and may authorize any persons to accept the sums on behalf of such defaulting subscriber, and such FORMS. 157 HCcopUin«. shall be cffoctivo. and such bill of cx.-hancr-- -nay be made Pom4. ''f^:^ZL .onnniUoo are to .„b- nbe tho n.en.d.u of a.ou Kc^.' of ,he coy tor the whole of the fouuders' .hares m tho ooy .s capital, LdL in due course to distribute the «amo amon.nst the subscribers ritoablv in ,)roi.ortiou to their contributions hereunder. . ^ „ , Anv noticJ for the purposes hereof n.ay be .iven ... any sub- Not.ce of .,riber bv sending the sa.ne thro„-ued. scaled, and ( 1 delivered by, &c. ) Instead of forming an asxociatio,, .is above, it is more u.ual to regisU-r a promotinsr syndicate. Sec infra, p. -S8- SvM.ic.vTi; AciREKMEXT foy FcuHAs..; and Re-sm.eo/ Mines. Form 5. Headu of Agreement. 1 .\ .svndi.ate is hbv established for the purpose of u.-.iuiriug the Syndicate^ Mcinos situate at , and known as the mines, and of disposing of the same at a profit. The capital of the syndicate shall be i — , ( apit.l. aud shall be considei-ed to be divided into - - shares ot i - - each. The holders for the time being of the shares shall be members ol the Member.,, syndicate. Each of the subscribers is to be entld tn the number ol •shares set opp<«ite his signature. The shares are to bo Irauslcrable. hut not divisible. A transfer must be reg- tered. 2. In enterin..^ into the contract dated - for the aciu.s.tion ol rrehunnary tlLC sd mines, A., one of the subscribers hto, shall bo deemed to have been acting on bc!.alf of the syndicate, and the syndicate shall for h- with repay him tht deposit, and shall indemnify him against his liabilities under the contract. ■i. A. and B. shall be managers of the syndicate. Ja*""*?' JU.. ii' ij 168 Form 6. Calla. Application of luudii. Conduct of busine- Express powers of managers. Meetings. Divisiou of procet'dw. PROMOTERS. [Chap. II. Noticei). 4 £ per share shall be pd to the managers forthwith, and thej may from time to time make calls on the members in proportion to their shares, but no member is to be liable to pay more than the amount of his shares. 5. All moneys pJ to the managers in respect of calls or otherwise Mhall be applied for the purposes of the syndicate. G. The managers shall have the entire control of the affairs of the syndicate, and may conduct the same in such manner as they think best- 7. It is expressly declared that the managers, if they think fit, (a) may sell the mines to a person, or firm, or coy; (b) may form and float, or procure the fomiation and floating of a y to purchase the mines; (c) may fix the price and agree to accept any pt of it in fully pd-up shares, debentures, or otherwise; (d) may keep the mines going until disposed of. 8. The managers may convene meetings of the syndicate to doli- borato and decide on any of the affairs of the syndicate: every share to confer one vote: majority to decide; votes may be given in person or by proxy. Three days' notice of each meeting to be given. 9. The conson for sale or disposition of the mines shall bo applied, first, in paying all debts and liabilities of the syndicate: secondly, in repaying any capital contributed by the members in re.-ipect of their shares: thirdly, the surplus shall be divided amongst the members in proportion to their shares. And for the purposes of this clause the managers may convert into money any shares, debentures, or other specific assets, and may divide any such assets in specie, and make suf h other arrangements for adjusting the rights of the members as they tliink fit. 10. Notices to each subscriber may be given by post, addressed to him ut his address below mentd. Not ice so given to be deemed served twelve hours after posting. Dated the day of . Syndicates. Sjiiiiitatcs are sometimes formed under an aErrcement as above, but tlie a^'ieemont eonstitutos a partnership, and tlic inembers arc tliorefore individually re-iM.iisihle fur what the managers di., wiiiiuut any real limit of liability; and if thr- number of members, by oversight or otherwise, exceeds twenty, the syndicate becomes an illegal association. These objections to a .syndicate agreement now very commonly induce the formation of an incorporated sviiditat!'. rill' foUowinR arc a few examples of the cases in wliicl syndic.itcs arc r.inM!y formed: — 1. .\. has a patent for an invention, but no capital. The utility of the invention is fairly obvious: but it requires to be more thoroughly testwl, and expense must be incur'cd in so testing it, and also in obtaining foreign patents, and perhaps in floating u company to purchase the patent rights. B., C. and D. agree to form a syndicate FORMS. 159 . ■ I. .hall and tho requi.ito funds. The patent nght. arc made oter which '*»",.87 *''° ' \ . ji„_ that A. shall have, .ay, ono-th.rd of to the »yad.ca c <>" t^" '^''"^ *^„^ ^..^^ ,,,0 other subscriber, shaU ably amonst the members of "'« y"*^ ;„„ „, ,„„t,act ,. C. ha, obtained in Amor.ca or ... one of "- ^ J" """^ ^^ ,„„j „„t ,„ to purchase «.a.e m....ng P~P"'y- !^°;;^ho property to a limited 'trr; tirpro:e1trct'bi.Uie:C.%re, 'hi, U^ -r con. : ^t Id knowledCat the dUposal of the syndicate in coas.dera,..,n business and the power to d.spose o .t. J^^^ 'y""^"=;'^ favourable the business, sets the concern on .ts legs, ""d 'hen, on a ; a limited period and then resell on the best terms obta.nabk. 5 Some me cantile commodity is likely to rise in value. A 'ynd-ate formed to acquire a..d hold a large stock of it a.,d to r.-soU when the « A cS,Ir tl-Sr-be b.ou.ht cut, but considerable preliminary e.- '• .e c' -will have U, be incurred in advcrti.i„K', le.al ■•'■7-- ^ ^ „..,kor< M.Ucitor.. and otherwise. A synd.oate ,. formed t. find th. t ^t'c fund,, the v,.,ul,.r .•..r.ein, to rep..y the,,, w.th a bonus o,., ,{ e purcha,,. consideration which he i, to obtain from the companj^ 'n.e company is then floated, and in due cour.e tho vendor pays otf ♦be syndicate's advance and bonus. 7 It is desi^ by certain parties to apply to some govcrnme..t author. ty forrlcLion, charter, or other special privilc^o. In order o ,b ain this expense must be incurr«l, and the rc.,u.,.te funds can only bo found by co-operation. Accordingly A., H.. and L. and others form a syndicate. In order to form an incorporated syndicate it is necessary to pr-'pare a suit- In ordir lonu .,,',.,:,,,,,, ..f association. The name of the company able memorandum and short artiU. s ot assooau S..n,li,.nte ,„„ u„™,„„um!y includes the word " synd.catc c.^.. ^ ''^' ' "J^ "7 j^ j 1 :„t«l 'l-l,.. ubjcts must be made wide e,un,^'h to eover what .,s w.int, J, a. d L^W It is consid a expedient to express th™. in tcr,ns ,0 ^-n,... as no ,. di.l the particular sehemc the part.es have .n v.ew; cj., d tl,> r. al objc * s to acquir. a particular concession for which A. has been ncgo t.at.ng, the hilrwill be to acquire any concessions, and to work and d.spose o^ he^ nd to form any company, and to raise moucy, tc. Sec Fom 173. The capital Form 5. f. I llii 160 Forms. PR0M0TEB8. [Chap. II. will bo fixed »t such » figure a* may suffice to cover the probable outlay. The articles of awociation will probably adopt Table A. w^tli modification!, dee Form 262. The syndicate la usually registered a* a i ..ivate comi-any under sect 121 of the Act. See infra, p. 910. In due course the syndicate will enter into an agreement with A. to acquire the benefit of his negotiations and services in consideration of some paid-up shares, say one-third of the capital. The rest of the capital of the syndicate will then be subscribed, and steps will be taken to obtain the concern. When the concession has been acquired, it will be sold to a company promoted by the syndicate, and the proceeds will be distributed and the syndicate dissolved. There is great advantage in an incorporated syndicate, for it is a separate entity rccogniied by the law and not a mere partnership, and accordingly in all contracts its corporate name is used, the members enjoy limited liability, and the directors or managers arc not the affcnts of the members individually but of the body corporate, which is the promoter, and is responsible for the acts and omissions of the directors, laffunns Nitrate Co. v. Laguna, Syndicate. (1899; 2 Ch. 392, 423. Besides, it is often found that capitalists and others who wo' .; •> become members of an unincorporated syndicate arc ready eno incorporated syndicate in their own names or through nomineei As to syndicates limited by guarantee, sec infra. Chap. X. The doubts as to the status and regularity of incorporated ►/-li . a. .he rate of one «l>are i« the pool fo, Form 6. »;;■ •;;:'::'r t,-s ;.;t::;ir.;:::'';:;r. ,« ., , »-. JnTv c.„.ider expodU-ut, .i.h full ,....or to pay ....unn««.ous .., ; r . . for plao/n., or us^isUM^: to ,.la... any of tho s>-"i' ,s:";,:,; r« ic'.i.rt •- „., i ^ ,- ■ - the prici.' of till' share*, wo ««/"«. p. l"'"- , ,,,.. Has,.... shall apply all n.oncys roo..v...l bv th-m und.. >,.t..,,.n,.„ tho.0 pn..son,s in or U.wanls payin.^ all costs cha..^.. and expens . ; ::d ,. ,1... in rela,>on t. the trust, hereof. -";'-'^ -'; -' ' ,0 time, a.; and whomnor the ..urplus .n hand ts suth. on t., pay .. Ilividond of a, Ica-st i- . applv .uch ^urplus in pay.n. to tlu, hoKler- of shares in th.- pool nratTiible dividend. ., . . r T o Shan, in tho pool shall be numbered - to - tne us.v... .Vr,„„ ..... and ea holder of any Ihare in the pool shall I. entld to a cor. > ... " t.tle to hi« eha.. ov shares therein, fran.e.l .n acordanco wUh . ZL set forth in tho so..,ud s.h.lulo h... Su.h ..ortU.ca.o shall b.. under the seal of the tni.st. ; „„■ of th< ,i The trusUe.s shall keep at their ro;.is,..n.-d oth.e a ro^i.lo. ot th „!:,. J !;: ,h. pool and the re,i. t.ro inspect the s.l ro...tov. 7 Kvovv holder of a share in the pool ...ay .ra.tsfor the san.e b> i„stru,..ent in .r.tin, in tho ..sual o,„..n.o f..r,u, « ^ ' ;;';^J:; si.^ned both bv the transferor a,.d by tho l.unsloree. ntil the reg s a".' of the transfer the tra.isferor .hall be dee.ned to re.na.n .,• holder of the share. The iu..tru.nent of transfer .uust bo^e -J ^^ ,ho trustees, accon.panied by the (*r,.li.^ate relal.t.f.' to the sh.vM . ,.p Ld therein, and su.a, other evidence .s U.e trustees n.a, reX to prove the title of the tra .eror; and the trustees ...a. pharze a fee of 2s. 6d. for each transfer registered. K. irot'v It is not usual fo make share* in a pool transferable. s The n-^istered holder of any share in the pool shall be re...,- K;..i.- 'li^ ni/ed and treated as the absolute owner thof. and .n tho case ol (h. Sil ^m ■ \' 1«'J PHOMOTKR8. [Chap. 11. Form 6. hiMili'iiiU p.i-titi. (1. tujr p*M |ti(*tributi'iii SiipiviuU-i* ' mtifiratcw. .I..ath of anv ono or two or nioro joint rc^'ist. rod holdcm. tl.e coy will .mlv roco-nizo fho survivor or Kurvivors as tl.o al.-oluto owuor or ..xvnors thof, nnd the rccoipt of any siioli iKirsoii or person." 'O ri-cog- ni/Hl o.. ob-soluto owner or owners afsd in respect of any moneys puvub! I)y the trees in respect of »ucU share sliall bo a good dis- rharpo to the trees, notwi-listanding any nolii«, oxpross or otherwise, ihov nmv Imv.- as to chiM.i-: undor any mist or otherwiso. li All ilivideuds o.i .shares in the p-ol inuy bo paid by rhnipie .r. or in ciisi' ot ;oint holders, to the .opistered a.hliess of that one ol ;hern who .s hrst named on the resiisior in re-ipcl ol surh shares. 1 10 Tho pod .shall bo closed at the expiration o*' ono yo u Iroiii the late hereof but tho hobiers of two-thirds cf tho shares in tho jiooj ,uay at any time previously, by notieo in ^v.iting to tho trees, Ho=o the |.o(d. and tho sumo shall bo closed aroordinjilv. 11 When the pool i.s closed as afsd. such ot the pooled shares a. have no' been s.dl, and also any cash in tJi- hands of the ireo^ and ;,vailablo for distribution, shall bo distributed among *he holders ol -hares in tho pod as nearly as may bo rateably in propotlion tx> the diares in lh(> jiod hold by them rcsply. 12. Before making any su. h final distribution as afsd the trees may ic.pliro all or any of the certilicates afsd rolaling to shares in the pool to bo given up to bo cancelled, and the same shall bo given up iiccordingly. i i u K! The trees guarantee that their nominees afsd shall duly hold ..nd di.spo.se of the sd 20,000 shares in accordauco \vitli tlie-e pro.scnis. 11. The trees shall bo entitled as remuueraliou or their trouble in executing the trusts hereof to be remunerated at tho raU> ot the sum of £ per annum. 1,5. The trees sliall be indemniHed out of the trust premises against ,dl expenses and liabilities inrurred in relation hto, and they shall have a lien for such indemnify on the pooled shares and all money.- irisina- therefrom, IG. The holders of thrce-fouiths of the shares in tlie pool may. by writing under their hands, a.sscnt to any modifications of tlie right- hby conferred on the holders of shares in the pool, and .such a.ssent -hall bo binding on all tho holder." of shares in the pool, and they -hall all Vk> bound to give effecl thereto. K..ti...-. 17, A notice under these pre-eiii.s may be .se. ''d by the -loes upon aiiv registered holder of any share in tho pool, either personally or by .sending it through the post in a registered prepai 1 envelope or wrapper to his or her regLstored place of address, and any notice so .^rved by post shall be deemed to '■ o. served at the expiration of forty -eight hours after it is posted. Il.-IM ti"ii III I' IllTiitV. M.«lilii-uti. of riifht.- KORMB. I hi) First Sciieuui.k In /ire columuK (1) mniirs, (.-'> aJdreaHU, (M) descriptions, (I I iHiiiirulirn of pn'dcd Kliiires, (•'.) purticuUirit of »han-i in pool] The Sr.roNU Sciikdii.k [Form of Certifintle ] I, „ n..t ut uU umunii...... to ctablUh B {h«.I sc tlu.t :, nui.iber ..f .|>ar.-h..!Jer< ,M.iv ln-iH'tit I'liri imt'ii. . L _ S,nu.|i.n« a p.K)l i« .v.»«l,li-he.l wh-ro a nu.nbcr of umlerwnterH hiivo hc-n ,t irk with larito bl'X'k'. "f ■ • .„ 1, not to r.in the prir.- .l.mn l.y ..vorlo:.,!;,.- Il.o tnark.-t. tn «.■.•!. .a-os j„. „„.,„1„.» of the p.«.l aro -pnerally prohibitoJ from tranHforr.nu-. In othor ,M,.-s, th.. ol.joH of the pool i- to .roato a voting trust which w.ll 1..- worknl r..r llio hcnifit an! prote.tion of th<> nu-mhcrs of the pool. At other ti.ne. a piH>l is .■s.tahrMhed for thr p.irpo.,' of splitting up a -er.os of r.Hindc.,- shari- ..to Vra.tions. ■.,,., KIO founaorV sharci n.ay he repre«MiteU l,y, say. 10.000 -har.- in the pool. S,.n,eti..MH theterm - Iru-t " or " syndnate . in be U"ih1 inMeail of '• p(")l." , ,. , u» » .i It \» not ..afe to provide tor the pureha-e of »hore« for tho bencht of th. pnni, for if the p.K,l by pur,ha,in« runs op tUo pric, there will be danRor of ll„. aisoeiatioii beinK' heli to be a con^piraey. Sc-e .<«,,r«, p 131 Form 6 l',„.i.iNi. .\..Ri;i-:.Mt.NT irilh I'kovimon for Thassier oi' Shakes VX ACiHKEMT made, At., botwoon A. U., oi — (hnftor called ilio ira'-ieo " ). of tho one pt, aud tlie several other persons wiio shall -i;l.-eiilM> ihoir nanio-^ hto. of tiie olhur or second pt. [Uecitab, see l'n,m (i.J I Tlii> sd chart's Uinftr called - the pooled shares " i, iic. IForm (i.J J Tli.> iiool shall 1)6 deemed to l.o divided into as many shares a.s :t,f pooled shares, and each of the parties Uio shall ho entid to the -aiiKi number of .shares in the pool a.s the uumber of share- sol opp-'- -I'l' hi.s sifjnature hto. ;l. The tree shall hold, &e. L^'"'''" '' J I It .shall rcjl with the tree to determine which of the pooled -hares shall on each occasion bo sold or dealt with, and for tJio purpo-o ii -ivins etl'ect to aiiv sale or disposition of any of the pooled Kharos, ■lie re:;istored holders of the pooled shares shall resply. upon tho H-.|iio.st of the .roe. siiiTi all tiansfors thof which the tree .shall reipiire. iiid if any holder make."i dctaidt in complyinpr with any stich ro.iiiest. he tree liiay sign any such transfer for the i'q. on lines of Form C.j Fo«n 7. Ai.i>ther I hntf l'..ol. Shares in I '■ 1 r:il>ff(-. IW> i>i{()S!M:crrsi'>. niAlTKH 111. INTUOniTCTOKV NI)Tt>«. W I.I lu: it is imoiultv. .. uppoal lo l ublu lor the eai.i'al rtMiuirod ,„ wuik tt .oiiipanv, llio usual .'ours. to i-s.u- a pru.poelus i:iviti.ig uppliratioiis lor shares or U-bo-aures or holli. I'nor to 1802 a ,uus,„Hlus was aliuosl iu ij- issued before iho formation ot u ,ui.ii:anv; 1)U' 'fior the .- >' \S'>'2, whitli ronJorocl tho loruutiou „f a cuiapau .. li a -i^'^p. '"- ',..1. ill riH|uirfd ri'i rcsiM.n- I ility n .Ivill. •'r.i.lt-.-. lei the direction of the proin.ilers, and with the privity 1 1 IK ihrector^. )f the il. I .tj \m l>Ku»l'ECTUSt>. [Chap. III. It-; Impnrtiiii' points ti) ii' obM'lVL'll ii settliiijr a prospt'fitii* Very co.n.no«lv, legal advi.e a« well i. .akeu en the J-aU; tor ..noraiue of law in t;e>.o.al and of the rc.,uiromenls ot the Act ot 19U8 iu particular, or waul of jmlg.ucut o.. the part ot those who isHuo a prospectus, may lead to the most disastrous co„soci«encc. Horn Mcs and hotu-sty arc indeed al.M,lutely o<.onfal. but by hem- solved they are not a suffirieut proUMtiou. A person, for.nstanco, mav bo fully aware that he i. bouu.l to state all matonal facts; but from his position, or under the l^luenre of .sanguine expecta- tions he mav be unable to form an in,i,artial judgment as to what facts are material, lie may know well enough that lio nmst abstain from misrepresentation, and yet be totally unable to see that an ingeniously-framed statement, which he or some other person de- Bi^es to insert, is misleading. He may believe a state.nent to be true, but be forgetful or ignorant of the danger he incurs m stating as a fact that which he only knows by hearsay. He may lorget. or misconstrue, the provisions of the Act of 11.08 with reference to prospectuses. He may think thut as documems ate ol lered for Lpection. applicants will be ii.xcd with knowledge of their con- tents, and may not notice in the prospectus a misrepresentation as to their terms which renders the oUer nugatory. He may unagi.io that this or that is onlv a small matter, and may be surprised a -w months or years later to lind that his want of judgment Has led .0 his being made a defendant in seventy or eighty actions. All these possibilities make the a.ssisU,ncc of a trained legal mind very desirable. , ... The memorandum and articles ,.f a-ociatioi. and any prol.minary contracts are generally settled at the same time as the prospectus, for these documents are commonly framed in contemplation of the prospectus, and with reference to what it is desired to say or not to say therein. The prospectus should not be finally settled until al:or the formation of the company In settling a prospectus it is uece-sar> U^ bear in mind \ That it should be framed so as to compl} with the uumemw-s and in many cases onerous requirements of the Act ot 1908, particularly sect. 81, so far as applicable. B That the prospectus should be made as attractive as is con- sistent with truth, and should not be open to hostile criticism on the ground of significant omissions therefrom, or vagiK' statements on vital points See infra, pp. 182, 183. C That it should bo framed so as to comply with the geuoi al law, apart from the Act of 1908, and so as not to give rise tu any charge of aufairi,es^ or de.cop.i,„i. See w.'m, p. 183. i:i INTRODUCTOKV NOTKS. h'T Provisions of the Companies Conholidation > Act, 1908. Particulars to be disclosed. Sccl. «1 ol tlw Actoi lyu8 luu- lluu,. „1 I , (.■.,T. IT... .„. i>-.,..,l l.y ..r . M !.. l.air "f ., ■ «m,.H,.y ...by ,.r ur li.-l.a'.f o.n,.ol ll.o d.^closun. .u a pmspo-nu- ■ .1 .0.U- 01 la,;t= wlu.li .1.0 l-o._a-laturo run.ulor. u mutonal to hav.. diM iosca to .HTson. i.n-it<.d to l.LVon... subscribers -fact-s wlaoh ar. tilbin ,1.0 kuowlo^. ,...ti.-e. .i.vi.hr, advertiscM.ent or other iuv.tat..,.. o !er- ■„.■ to the in.blh- lor bub^criiHiou or ynvAux^v at.v shares or del,.,,- tui...s or debenture ^took] of a .•oiLpany.' Issued by or on behalf of the company. The wo.ds or in r..l,„i.m to ..,.v iuteuded com,,anv .- whi-l. o.-. ur .,. s.., - . (see ,»/ra ,, ,:;,.do,.ot\.pi,,.a,.here:l.ut,heuo>a-'o..by.,roabehalf ofa,,J ,..,s.,u ^vho i, or has be... e„,a,,-a or i..MHeMv,l in the turn.at.o.i o {h,. ,..,n,,a,.v ' .|.|"'"- t" I- '■^i'l^' '^-"'^■'' ^" ""'"' '' I'^^'-l"^' '"-^ '':'7 h^ the ,,n,mot*.-r,s before the refri>lratioi, of a eo..ii.a..v esinvially ha^i,,.' .e-ard to ih.- uord. of sub-,ecl. (L: M.bie.t, .^o., this .ectiou .hall api>lv to a..y pro-^eaus, whether is-ued ou or w„h relVre.iee to the f-jniiatiou of a eoinpan.N or subse.iuent.) . Se<.t. Jlo makes the socliou apply ,.. -N.-ry .-xistiu- e.....pauy as .t .1 had been ivoistered uii.bH .~,„...,.i.. a- I..!- ' 1 uliil^ ."■.'"1"' n Contents of Memorandum. iu) till. (-(.ritiMit- 'if till' iil..TlPMan.hM,i of !1 -f ri|.tion<. lUiil ai|.h-cs.i ' tin' ■■i._'iiatMi.i «nliMrii".d t'.T I'V tlii'in T.-pr..ll\..ly ,»anu^n.nu.,>t or ".l,.!-... n..i -h.u,.-. il ...y. ami tin- nu.m-.. :»..! >-.,.nl ot ,|„. i„,or,..^t of tiM- hol.iers i„ (he ,.r..,,.T,v an.l l-r-lit. ot the ....„- i.iati.>li. .villi ill'' nam..-. 'I''- iil till. nuniliiT ot •Lni's 111 till' ■niinliir ol' l..iiiHl..i - nr . tlini: 111 li'lliiilaliilillri l.ui.y itjiii lAervlhi... in the menuiraudnn. eseepl the si-n,uure> ul ihe vvilne.ss; - is u, lie set out . .\s the jiraethe .s to siuii the nan,e.s ,n loll the whole .uen.oranduni i> praeti.ally re.p.i.vd m be eop.ed into ,l,e prospectus. There seems to be no objeeiio.i t,. the laeihod nv^. a ~iilisi'iili' fi)i ill llio inoinoiaiKlum. Till' iii.iiiuriuiddiM ilM'li ii.-ii;.ll\ -:imi.'> .ill lliiit is iv(|uiiv(l l>y tln' -section iis to ilio I'ouiiJois'. niaiiauouieul iiiul (k'lVri'rd .■.liiirc- i if iinyi, but somL'liiiu>- llio', whilst uiukiiifr it uiiiie(.es,~iied as u ne\vs|iaper ad\eni-oiiit'nt the .■oiit<;nl.s of tlit meaiorandiiin, Hie si^-iiatories ilieieto and tiio nunilici- of shares sub- scribed for liv tlieui, dues imi e.xioiid llie provision I., ihe [Kirti'iilars ;Ui to tlie fouiidci.^' or niiiiiau'eiuetit sliaro^. ill jt.- Artiilo :l.» to tiirrvti.r^" 4u;iliHi;tti". aii'i reiiiuiii' rHli"ii. (VHnlitiiviticin. (h) The nninbpr of shuri-s. if ;iiiy, lix'xl liy tlir artii-los of u-^-^OL-iatinn a* tl.i' (|iiiililic;itioii i)f a liirnrtHr, .and ;i;'.y |ir(ui-ioii in the artii-l'-" as ic. tl.c romunrratioii of tin- dirct-tnr-: Mnd Articles of association." Tliis e\pie~>.ion nm-t nu an ilic articles in fore -Hlieii (he prospectus is issued, includiu^,' any aliera- lions (hat niuv have been niiwle hy -jx'cial lesidmion. 'riie si-, iioii loos nol -iay the original articles. Tliere is no obliiraliou to insert in I lie article' iialilii .ition ■■lau.se, but if sucli a clause ho in.scr(ed ami provide for a f-'biir.: (jinilill- cation, the number of share.- mu-.t be staled in the ]iroipec(iis. .V director may be cpialiliol l.y lioMiu'^' the reipiisiie niiiiiber of shaie^ johith/ v\ilh anoth<-r. (ihrtj Pajnr MUln. Kr ynrii' lUiVi^trr. I IH'.-I , a eh. i:;i: (:rii,iilii\.Ihi'jns,i.\'.^M^ I <'h. III. l-'or diiiM-|..i- lo accept (lualili'-alion shares from a promoter on the terms of lioldiii;; them on trust for him is misfea.~anco. London and S. W . (Uuial Cc, (I'JU) 1 Cli. ;!4ti. .\ debentm-e or debenture stock i|ualilica1ion need not he mentioned in the piospectus. A. ,r. Miniiiiuin ^ulcirrijitiou. Applii'tttiuii HTidalliirtii'iit (f) tlie naim-s. dccriptiim-i .uid M'kln ->''s tit' tin- ^li^^■c■tlPI■■^ nr iiri>po.-irrs; and i^fl) tilt' minimuiu ^nbscriptiuii on wliiili the directors may proi-rcfi to allot- inrnt, and tin' aminint jiayaMc on aj»i>lication and allotmt^nt on oacli '*!iart»: and in tlio ca^io of a r-ocond or sul)S)'(|ut'nt oiler oP shares, the amount offered for .-ubseriptlun o.i eaeli jire\ioiis allotiiient made within the two precctling years, and the amount aetually allotted: and the amount, if any. paid on thn shares so allotted; and As to "Directors or proposed Directors.' It must uoi bo tor- jrotten tliat by sort 72, where the proKpoctU'* is ' is-iuocl by or on • -A M'uiimim ill riptiim. ISTRODUCTOUY NOTES. i,,i,,|f .,, ,he compunv ■ ^nui boi„s a .o.npauy roKJ-stercKl bcfon- ,, ,st, 1000. 1 a ...npany ro,ist..r..d afU-r that , ato wlu,.h h.. 1 f r a vcar Qlior boiu- entitle,! to commcico bu-sincss), and ";;r:i ; H^le "u,.h u;;,.^. ,u,n. .^..n^uon. ior .,.^.. Zl. of directors or proposed directors are not 'oj^staed -n .,„ prospeotn.s unless tho n..,iuirement.s ot ^eot. ,2 have been ^a,..l..e ,,„ S-,':f.iVA mmUou ,81 , v're.,uires .ho n.ininn.n. subscription as re^rards .han-s to b,. . iod But the wor,ls an. wide cnou.d, t- cover bn.h The expres ,;„. -■.he -mninrnm .ubsoip.ion ..„ which the diredu.-s ,uay p.-occed ,„ ,,u„„n..ut is pclecllv sen^ilde, whether ap,.hed l.. shares or Jobcnnnes or dol-outtire stock, and nmy. consistently .v.ih reason, b, read as retorriu;:. iu ivaard M .-haro-, t- Ihe unnnnu.u .-uh«cr.ptu.n „„„,i„n„d in .lause 85, and as ro....rds ,h-bentures or debenture stock, ,o .,,..1, M.inin.un. M.hs.aiption as nuiy be lived in the prospoc.u.. Bm when tho whole of sub-sect, (d) is road, and note >s taken ot ,1„. lact that the clau.se is .silen, as to .lebentures and .iebonture s(,„ k ^vhen^as shares are expressly mentioned, and when Ibo clause , ,,,',.1 with sort 8.-. ( n i-2>, wherein the new cxj-res^i, ii - minimum M,l.>.'nption- is dclined. ■.here can be liMh- doubt that ^e, t . 81 . n ul > is iiiMnl to iipply to. -ha.es .oily Ai J ir. the case of a t.acond or subsequent oSt;--. Thi- rc- ,,„,,,,„o,„ i„ i,.s original form was a%ery onerous one, as t.he<.unp:n,y ',i„l,l iu the course of it.s career have ntade many issue- ot ,anw a„.l .Icl.c.urcs i«~uc,l, „r agreed to Kully pauj ,„. i..,„.,l. n. fullv er p.,rtly ,.ai,l u,, ..tl.orwi... tl.an ... -ash, and ... ,,;;::;„;„, ,|„. I otor cnvo tl>;. ■•Ktcnt ... whirl' they arc .o p.ii.l "p. a..d .n r.thcr ,.„.,. the ,.„„shlorati.m fer which ll.o.c share, er ,l,.hentur,.s hav,- h,;„ issued ..r are propos,.,| i.r intend-d u, I..- issii.'d : and The consideration.- U .- appn-hendcd that ii will be -ulli- ;^';;^:X;"m;1 1,.,,' to stale the general n.uuie of the eou-^ideration. and that it will no. be noee.ssarv in each etuso to set out all tho deUiils of the o„>id..rat.on. ,V luo.^t .C <:o.. ( IS'J'.M 2 Ch. 207. Th.at may be ...s.ertained laf-r on from the ret.trn of allotment^ re.pnred by -e. I 88 I I'l ( b I . , , ,1„. „.„„.s and addresses „f the vo„de, f any prnperty punha«ed or r..pa.id_ .„-,niired l.v th- .-..inpany, or proponed .. U, I.e p..rohas..d or a.-.,u.red, ^ ^^_^^_^_ ^^ «lmh i- .."> !..■ paid f..r uh.div or partly eat „f the proe.-ds of the 170 PROSPECTUSES. [Chap. III. Aniciuiu unpaid viifior Piircliiw- munej paiil or payHhlr issue offtTCii for :iui>S(;riptiua liy tiie j»ru^poutu?*. or the purchase or ui;i|UL.''itioii of wiiiiii Il.is not bocn iDinplcti'J ^it thr dati- of the is.-iur of the prO'^pciluH, and the amount paviibic in ca^h, .-harej, or dfb(;ntures. to tlie vi-iido:'. and whore there is more than one separate vendor, or the company n a .aiy to .^j.ocify the name of each vendor and 111.' amount pavable to hiiiiV If the pioporty 'is to bo paid for wholly or partly out of the pioeoed.s of the issue." it is appreliended that the .sub-.-:ei;tioii ajiplie-; but when goods have lieen sold on credit. so thai the proi)erty has pas.sed and the company has obtained po.s- .-e.ssion. il may be lliat .sueh good-, do not fall within the words "the purchase or acquisition of whirli jias not been completed at the date of the jiublicalion of the j)ro.speetu- The aeijuisilioii in sueh ca.se has. in a .sense, been completed. Doubt.s like tl'ese help to make the section very troublesome to bu.-inoss men with the best inten'ions. It contain.s no o.vception ol purchases in the ordinary course of business similar to that in par. ik^. infra, but looking at the .-.ense of the thing and the policy of the pro.sjiecius section, it seems highly improbable that the clause w;is intended lo apply to ordinary business contracts. The wlioiurchaser for the purposes of this paragraph unless it has to pay purchase-money to someone other than its own vendor; nor need the prospectus contain a statement of the amount of any consideration paid or to be paid hy anyone other than Ihe eompany itself. ((7) the amount (if any) paid or payable as i)urcha«e-money in cash, shrinks, or del«>nturoa, for any sueh property as aforesaid, specifying the amount (if any) payable for goodwill; and INTRODUCTORY NOTES. ' ' Tho lonrluding words will render it nooossary or exi)ediont to 8i)ocifv tl»' nount paval.lo for srooiwiU soparatoly in tho ooritract. for wiioro it 13 not so staled diUimlty will or may ari.-.> a*, to the ftpportionraent. ,A) the amount (if a..v) paid within tho t«ro preceding- y.ars, or payable as ''"•';;.«"';"« commission for subsc-ibi..),' or uKru1,h, rib.-, or pro, ura.K »r ■■ >""" »'■•'"• agrcoinf? to proi ore 8ub,«ription.i, for any shares in or debentures of tlic conrpany, or the rate of any su.h tominissioii; I'rovided that it (.ball not be necessary to stale the poiiiiiiissi.,n payabb' to sub- iinderwrit«r8 ; and Sco sect. 89. which legalise." suuli payment on term.-', and infra, Chap. IV. It would seem that uudorwritiug and placing luntracls uro not in all es material tontrants. the dates and ;iartio.s to which inu.st, under iiaraoraph (7v), mfra, be stated in the pioopcetu.s. Il the uniouut to bo paid-whieh is the material matter-is di.sclo.sed, it may bo that tiio dates and parties need not be disdo-sed- are not material: but see infra, par. {k). (t) the amount or estimated amount of preliminary expenses: and If the amount is stated, as by thio paragraph re(iuirod, the (lates and parties to tho contracts can scarcely be material to sub.scribers: at all cvent.s. tlicy are not reiiuired to be sot forth here Perhaps .sucli contracts, even if material, come within the O.xe' tion in jiaragvaph [k}, as contracts in the ordinary course of busincs.- . It i.- not to be necessary to disclose the amount or estiniatoJ amount of preliminary e.xpenses in a prospectus published moio than one year after the date at which tlie company became entitled to commence business See sub-sect (8). I'li'liinil irT . \pcUl*« '** 'Ui ^i) tho amount paid within the two precwiin- yours or intended to bo 1 .yni,i,i^ t-. paid to any promoter and the coneidcration for any Bueh payment; !'n>Tn.)t.r- aud As to what persons are promofars. .see supra. Chap II ( It) the dates of snd parties to every material contract, and a reasonable time and place at which any material contract or a copy thereof may lie inspected; Provided that tliis reijuircment shall not apjily to a con- tract entered into in the ordinary course of the business carric'd on or intended to be carried on by tho company, or to any contraci entered into more than two years before the date of issue of the prospectus; aud This provision is in substitution foi sect. 38 of the Companies Act, 18 bo carried on by the company. More than two years before, ' Ac. Two years is now substi- luied for three. Thus u company is relieved from the necessity of INTRODUCTOKY NOTI'^S. .oin, baeU for an n.doliui.o iH,rio,l. I'Lv n,a,er.al 'i^'^^^^^ J^^^^^ have to be .pec. ed are only H.o-- .nm-n.,! into «Ulu.. U.o j.-a - b^Ioro .he da'to of is.«. of tho pro^pc-.u. A., --ee .1.. po-...l. shorter time in the ...r» 1 .Upurti-ulars of the nature and extent of the nUore.t (.f any) . „..,,. every director in the promotion of or in the property p.op.«c^ to I.. u..er.-.« : "uired by the e„u.pa»y, or wi.^re the iu.ere.t ot - ' » J'^ ;;' 2.UU in being a partner in a lir.n, the nature and ext.nt of ll . i,„ere.t of the firn., with a state.uent of all sum. paul or a.-reed f. i;e paid to him or to the Hrra in ea-h or shareH, or otherwise l.y an.v :.r!on either to induce him to be,on.e or to .,ualj.y huu a. a d.r..to, 'r otherwise lor »ervic-s rendered by hin. or by the t,ru, .n .onuect with the promotion or formation of tlie eonipany. Full particulars. Tito object ol llu. i> to enable ^ub.cribur^ ,u iudt(0 liou far the tlireclof.s who invito .ubscript.o... uro mJepon- deit and unstwortlty. A., B. and V . named ft -V--l-^'";^ ,.,utstitu.o an apparently i.tdependen. attd truM worthy boatd, bu . the fact be disclosed thai tltey are all in the . ay or under the conttM ,i the vendors or prontoters-have, in otleC. accepted a retutn.ng c. uom sottteone with interot. diiierenl to lhu,e ol the conrtpany-thev have disciualilied thetnselves fro.a acting a. adM.er. ol tlte company, .ud intending sub.cribet. NviU be put on their guard. It xs not enough to indicate thai the director has an tatere.t. 1- nil ..articular, ol the nature and eM«nt of the interest are to be given As an lUu^tratiou ol lhi.>. ■•<•. /w;. 'lai- L. R. 6 H. L. 190 „., \Vh«. the company i» a company having' share, of more than .u. ' class the right of voting at me<.tings of the cm.pany .„nterre.l U, the several classes of shares respectively. ,■', Kor the purposes of this s.-.-Jon every person shall be deemed t- 1- ■< vendor who has ent red into a„v contract, absolnte or conditional, tor the sab- o, ;,urfhL: or ior any option of purchase, of any property to be ae.,u.red by th, company, in any case where— ,„-, ,|„. purchase-money is m.t fully paid at the date of issue ot tl,. prospectus; or For the purpose,- &c. Thi> sub-,ection ntu.sl be read in con- nection with .^ub-^ecl. (1 Mf>. xi'Wa: -"^ ""te thereto. Deemed to be a Vendor,' &c. See note to .ub-sect. (1> a- fupra. ,6, the pureha«e-money U to be paid or satUfied wholly or in part out of ' the p^ds of t^e i«ue offered for .»b«=ripUon by the prospectu. ; or ir:5 Wliat • »..ml"r ' |,„.lua,^. 1 1 .M 174 1..-^^ PROSPECTUSES, (Chap. III. Wa.v.T coTiitifiiiii' in r;ts<' mwspM itdviTii Uelttx. (,) the contract depend, for it. validity or fulfilment on th,> result of tl.a. issue. (3) Where any of the property to bo u, quired by the rompany is to be t.kcn on le. this ition Jll apply as if tl.e expression " vendor .mluded th. " J>r ami .he expression " purcha«..mon..y " inelud.! the ..ons,d,.ra„on for th. lo .-e and the expression " sub-purrhaser " included a Hub-l.-s>re. ; Tny conditi.,n rec,uirin, or bindiu. any applicant for share, or d.-bentures , „ J .ive ou,pliau.c with any r,.,,uiron,ent of this so.-tion, or purport.ns to al .■ t ;;;, .Twhh notle of any contra,,, document, or matter not specHeally referral U. in the prospeotus. shall be void. ' Any condition,- &c. Se.-. r>» uf tho Coiupauks Act. 18.i7, .lul ,.ot prolubi. a condition lor .aiver. an.l i. was for .nauy y..n^ ou.tomary ,o insert waiver . lausos in prospctu^cs so a-< to rroloct th directors and prontotcrs from th. dangers of that vory va..uo an,l strinpont euactnieut. Tl.e exact oUoC of a waiver clau.x^ ^)"%;"'." Ion- time tiol clearly anertainod, but in Maclea;) v. Ca,!. O^UOi -V "■ •>! it was dccUlcI bv tlie House of Lords ll.at a .l.roctor or prontot'er' mi.'l.t be protected by a waiver clause provided n waj Lnest but i. must bo bones,, for tho proper function of .such « waiver .lau^o is to avoid dant^or resulting from an unintentional sl.p^ It will not avail wI>.m<- used for "tho protection of trickeir (l^""' 1 indlov) or "as intrt of the machinery of fraud" (Lord HaKbuiy. il.Ul And .ee raclcett v. Keswick, (1902) 2 Ch. 4.3G; Greenwood V Leather Shod Wheel Co.. (1000) 1 Ch. 421. A waiver clause should contain a frank tind fair avowal of tho nature of tho contract ,n re.spect of which the subscriber is asked to waive his right, under .oct ;!8. Watts V. Buclmill, (1903^ 1 Ch. TOO. For the future, houever. this sub-.-ection invalidates, as rogar.ls ,ho section, any such condition. Tho section, indeed, goes furthei. lor it invalidates anv condition binding any applicant to waive o. purporting to allect' the .ub.scribeis with notice of any oontnact. :i„,.'„„e„, or matter not specilicallv relened to in the prospectus rims i, is useless to sav in a pros,)Cctu.s to which tiio .section applic- ,|,.U applicants will be deemed to have notice of contracts iioi .pccificallv n..ferred to. i.e.. by .lutes and names, ^^^..s to con- snuctive notice of documents, Gluchstein v. Barne.^, (lOnOI A. ( 240, and Aaron s Uej-U. Limited v. IVm, (18U A. C. 2/.!. liut as a set-oU against this disallowance of the ' waiver dau-.v ,ho \et allows a director to set up is,^- sub-sect. (G) (a, (bit ir.ound- .,f defence -i'n,:,.ance and hone.st mistake of fact -which were not i'Jiablc to ..im under sec HH ot the Ac. of IHtiV. Th.s redresses I ho balance. , 5 . Where any «uch prospectus as is mentioutHl ... this section is pubii-h.->d ^^^ ■;:;■"" „ewsU . ad"'r.isemrnt,'it .hall not be necessary in 'he advertisement ... I'r .p^Ify 'the content, of the memorandum of association or the ^gnatonea therete, ..nd the number of shares subscribed for by them. liil.ili'y »1 iNiuomrcioKv notks. Thi. «ub-section n-du.^s the vorv luavv ..... -f advortiMnR a pro- . ,,t U a«or.ls ..u\v a H.imll .n,;.-.,.. of rc-li-f. It .. tl-rofore ■" :"v., 1 ^o's of «ot.iu. o«. tho n.a.- of d.tail whi.h .ho "" \^ , OS iH rro.nco.us. As to tl.i.. i. is apprchendcl ..>at .. tZ::^^^rZl pro.,«o... ■o.Tcr.n. U.,ho ..uU;- jor .u,.- ip n or ,.nn-.„..r, sl.ar.s or doben.uroH or .lo.HU.ur. s u„.k, ... . u 1,0.1 l.v .ho .ootio,. Thus an a,lvor.iso,.,oa, wh.. h .lu.. no. ;; „i ollor .haros. *o for ..l.Mnption. but .Ulo. -hat .ho con,,.any Sn^ a rroM.oc.us .vhor.l.v it olVor. for suWr.p..on c.r.a.n Lr'Tlohon.uros or .lohon.uro ..-« U. and that .ho pn.pc.as s.ato. M^'L^ ^o and .o, and that copu. may l>c d,U>uod a. .po,..ho,l „,acos appoars not to bo a prospectus .vithin the section. S,..> f,M.ho>.. i„fro. pp -JV.. 2.i(., whnro .ho ..uhi.-l ..t al,r„l.vd ^,i,i-|M'(lu> is toucliodon ,„ ,„ „,e oven, .-f no,.-..omplmn-.< with any of thu '-f'^'X^f.'^Z .„:til„. . aircc.or or o.h.T ,..™.. rc.p.,,.,1-1.. for tho ,ro„..|.tu.. ,h«U not n.,„r ,„y Imbilitv by rea-sou of the non-fompUanoc, it he proves that - ,., as're..ard» any mat-.r not dUelo^.-d, ho wan not cognisant ther.ol ; or ■„ ,l.c mm-..ompii^-.,.o aro..- from an honent mistake of fact on h,. part. t-r,,- lde<> that in .ho ovent of non-coniplian<.« with the requirement, eontam... „ , ; . ap ,«■> of suh-..,.t. (I) of .hi. section no diro-.tor or other pcr.on .:,H ■:™;'anv liahUity in re.pe.t of such non- ..mplian.. on.e.. .t be prov... .lr,t he hn.l knowlodiro . tho natun^ of tho i>Mlro..s available to a ,H)r.on .subscribing on .ho taith of a prosneolu,. '.vhioh doos no. oou.pl.v with .ho statutory rcpuremont... [s it a ronH.lv by action for damatres u-aiust tho directors or other p,.r.sons issuin'sr the prospectus' Or is it rescission of tho contrac. f. take siiams? Or is it both? t>r may .;nminal pro.oe.hu-s bo taUonr FioMi some i-ecout decisions (]yi,>,hrrdon Oh,mria, Limib'd, (1910. 1 n, iV.w and South oi EnnUuid .\.>:.ir.ns Co., (1911) 1 Ch. 57:!) it .,pp,-ar.s that rcscis.sion is no. .he remedy given by the section, an.l th:a tho remodv given Ls an action tor damages against flic director^ or ...hor persons responsible for the prospectus. In the former ca.so 111,, piospcctus on.ittod ..> mon.ion tlic tact that on two previou,^ oc,a.si..i.s tho conipanv hn.l ollorod shares for jniblic subscription ,in,l the luimbor allotted in resp.m.e to those otlors, and it was con- loiidod that this omission entitled the applicaii. to ivs.ission <)\ (OM.ract. XeviUo, .]., ho\vover, held that .hi.s was not so. "Tho iuii of aiiv of the facts rC'iuirod by this r ground'^ entitle llio >lmn'hol(U'rfi to thin irliof (ho. infra, jij). IH.I, l'.»''l. l!*''>- ••"•■ '» "''•' '"•'"'' '*'' ''•'^■" ""'>' ''"' ^^^" '""" ..f oinissioM." This was followed by Swinfon Kady. .1.. in tho .-..con.l ,.iw«(. In thftt ra^e the pio^-pcctu-* laJU>d ti. mention « picviou.s ollci to ll... iml.lic of Bhaws, but it wa-. liold lluif this did not frivo ai. ullolloc tho right to rescind, and that his rcim-dv wa- an action lo, daniafjos u. 'I'li.^ learned jiidj,'C drew attention to tho fatt that sect h(1 t'ave to an allottpo the ritrht to n return of his mouoy where an all 'iiiH-nt wa.-. made in brfuch of «u.t. Ho, but that there was no corn>s,,ondiii^ provision in retrurd to M.t. HI. "There is no provision," naid hi^ l.ord.^hip ..f ihal kind in .-.'it «1 nor in any othi-r scciioii ivlatiniri- the omi.s.'^ion tvlied on in this oa.se, but the .-action does .onii-mplato the liability in daniai.'es on the part of the (liroi;tor,> ami otlui persons r is u .t entitled u> rcMiud his le w,a.s l.iid down tJial «henevei a statutory duty is ereaU'd, any person who can show that he lia- sustained injury from the non-performance of that duty can bnn;; an action for damages against the jiersou on whom the duty i^ imposed; but in .itkimnti v. Scircantlr and (iateshnid Waterworki I o. ( 1877 ), 2 Ex. Uiv. 141, it was deci.led that this proposition lould uot be supported— that it was too widely slated- and that in dolor- mining whether a person projudioitl by tlie non-performance of :i statutorv duty was ontilloQ. B. 402. There can be no doubt thatseit. 81 of the Act of I'.tiis impases on the directors and other jx-rsous responsible a statui..r> duty to comply with it.s requirements, and the purview of tho A, i and the language' employed both indicate an intention to prol.M i subscribers who ad on the faith of a prospectus, and lhoi«fore entitle them to sue for damages sustained by breach of the statutory duty. In such an action the plaiutill must prove ("a^ That the defendant is,sued, or authorized or sanotionod tlu issue, of the prospectus; INTKODUcruKY Nori'>t. (ill TIml iIk' iinwpt'tlu). «lali' liy tlu' iinn-roiii- pliurii'U with the jtoclioii; ,(•1 Thai lht« phuiilill hii.* -ii^laiii.'.l . ()ii,s(.,|ueiiliiil Tlieie i.« iii> need In imivo Inmd. uimI. cm the nlher liiiiid, iion-rciin- |.|i:iiu(' Tii;iv lio I'xiUM"! whpii' the dolfiiduiit liii< no iDi^iiizamr. Si-i' sul.-M'' I. til tai of seel. 81 I'or iiiMaiite, he is not mi-ih'd m (hiiria;;«Ml whew lie i-* -^howii In h.no hul IsMuwlcilgo of the oiuitlod iiifi.inialioii. or ulicio. hv his own ar|iiii.-.-ioii i.r ollierwiso. it i.i .shown liiai, ha.siaiu froni a|>|il_\ inu- In ihis respert Sash V r„Ulii'. I I'Jit'.t 2 C\\. ■l:\' . ihnugli decided on w'lt. .'IH of \\h- ('(iiniiariie.s .Ad. 18ii7. ii|>|iears |o lie in point: and see .S/(u7/( v. fiuidii-irh-. ;• .\pp. (a.s. 187; Mirlviiii V T,iit. ( I'.tlM'.l ,\. C. Ul. With rc-ard. imwever. to the inlliieme of a pro.spe(tn-. Lord llalshiirv'w uli-ervalioii^ in ihe ease last ineiilioned inav he ci'', I. wiieie he sav> •liai where iid.s.^lalenients iiave licen nia(U> in u pro.spe(tus and people heen h'd iherehy ' 10 lake .sluir'^s, the takin;,' of whiih has led to loss, ii is (|iiile a fair infereuie to draw, that if the prospoetiis is eakulatc him fro.n liability .f U turned ou havo a«.er.ain. -1 .i.at bv >.mkin^ ,.roiK.r »n.,.nnos 1 «' «""«»^ L. '\^ of ,ho A. . of 18r,7. revrrsod. but no. on th.. point, .a ( 1900) A I 'm Vnd 8e« Wntlx v. Burknall. .190:1, I Ch TO.'.; and Brazdu^n /; ;: ,o i .....l ,ha, M.h-M.,.t, .«> i.. ,.c «.>■ a,,.li... .o . ..u,..,n..n, in lieu of ,.r,..,.<'rt„s und.T soot. H'i of thn -Xr. Honest mistake of fact." This reia.«. u, facU wLkI. by .ho ,e.,ion have „. !>-> MuUhI, .hu., .f by uu ho»e..t nns.ake the d.root r. ..ate Iha. A. U i. the vendor, wh.roa. C D. .'^ the vendor, .he direotois will bo ab.Molved. Whether a ,m.,i,ular .ontra.. i. or i. no, ,naU-r.a vsnh.n para- graph a-, of .s'ub...... - .- .1— of f-\^":' /:•;;",' Jt :.>i.ik.- .he director, hold that it i^ not ma er.al. "'"^ ' ^ absolv..d. The fact .ha' -hey have taken legal a.lv..*. mm,! lunc ....e,l lluTeon. i« evidence of honesty. In this .OMuv. the .ection an.olioratc^ the law as ...stood u . W^■. V.W.v,,, v /„-/. I'-'O'-'-N Jl And SCO infrn. p. 20.'i. The orus probandi. ii the pUu.mtf in .... acion p...vo> a bivach ,„ the «ub-«e.tiou, he is not bound U. go further and prove that he .lirector or other person sued was coguisan. ot the matter no d.,- .lo,ed, or that he uCed dishonestly. It is tor the dCouda.a to set ,., and e,tablish. if he can. o..e of the defences allowed by - ■ Action. In thi.s respect puttin,: the onn.s -;«.l- •--'■';-',"; J ,nent follows the at.alosry of the Directors' L.atuli.v A,t, WM. no« ..mbodied in .-e. t. 84 of the A.'t of 1908. (7, This section shall ne,t n,.,,l.v to a .ir. ,.lar or notice i,.vi,ii>.' exi^tin,. ,l..l.e„tufOs „f th- .o.npanv wh.-th.r with or without the rc.-ht ,o ..nouncc n i:::;::;;!: whHhor -....^ r .-. f..rc„cc t-, the fom,. , ..r . ,.o„,p.nv Shall not apply," &C. The wonls shall not apply.- .ic, ,..:..!S:;! a^ ,bvilw reasonable .p.a.ification. lv.is.n. nu-mW .,„ „„. „oed .he .Hau..e protection as persons newly .subscr.b.ne:. There was an a.ubiffuitv in the lanffuajre of the «ub-sec,ion us .t Mood in Z let of 1000," which left it doubtful whether the words «-ere to e nt disfibut.vel: . n..n.ely. as refer-in. , . ;- a circular o.fenn. |Nrit«U»UCl<»KV NtUKS. „.,„.b«r^ furthor Himros. a.,,! (2) lo a c.realur o«er.u« .lol..ntu« ,H.l.|on. lurth«r J..h.utu.o..: or wlu.ther thoy .ndudod « ..r-ula oltor- ,„. ,0 >no,ul.«r. ei.ho. .I.ures .,r dol.e..tur«M, ami to a .ircular otIurinK ,l,.i.o..tun- l.olJ.r« either ,lm.es ..r dol.cMUure«, or ''"'''"»" „„l,iguify I...S l.e..n . l..ur...l >.,. i.i the Coneoliaation A.t ol IIM.8. Subject as aJoresaid," 4c. Ti.nM. «..„ls .uak- it .1,.,.. that the ..„ ,,ou i' n..l ...nli.uM to the HrHl iasue. ^.^..■,.t i.. the -u^e. expressly mentioned. .,.■•,„, , ,lmmnt. ..> I- tl. i„....r.i.i.liuii. :.i»l tli.' ,|,i.iliti,a.i,m. r.- !{..!,„.., t ,Zrl.ZZ or .iir,...,..., ...nption. ».,.. aa..,..-- f ^;.-;;;;;- l,,-..,t..M ..r ,m.p..-r.l .lir...i..r-. nml tl,.. :...m,.nt or ...tnnafsl imouiif "I pr.'- ^^^^__ _ .,„.. y,.;r :.f.'.r fh.. .l,.t.. at wh,.!, .!,.• .o„Mm,.r i" -..titl.Hl ,» ...mm.n.-.. u,..,. '_';;'« «>•;«; ^^ .'titiilinl t.. The requirements, &c. ii.e.e ie<,uii ents are ihuno »et „. „,., ,orlh in Mdl-l. . 1 > u. .I>e ..uliei ,.,.,. of ..hu.M- a. and .a elau..e« > «• III. (cl. < i) and i m i. Entitled to commence business. Sco suet H7, MUIJIH. [I "J". .) N.ithihK in tin. -ition ,hall limit ...■ ,iii,.i>,i.l. .o.y li.it.illty wl.u I. ,,. r-..ii may inrnr uml-r flu- i,'.ii"r'l l^* "l""t from tin- ^o. tmu lien, e an^ u. uoi. .diRh Nvould lie, apart from thi« »eclion, «ill «till li, ;ivaih.blo Thu.M, even if the prcM-octus complies with the -so.tion. It muv still l.v roasou of fabo or fraudulent Htateniont" privo a »ub- M lilie. the ripht lo tak.' le..'al pr.ueo-liui.'s for re-scUiion of his con- M.,.i or for coniiieimation or .laniaffe.^. umler sect. 81, incorporat.MK ■I,.. |„ovi.>ions of the Direwois' Liability A-t, I8'J(l. or in a„ a.t.on ol I,., ,.ii S.'o liinhei. i»!ni, p. -"»2. 1 i«t ■11 1.!, i.iw [ llilv -r ■.'♦■iit'i i! iri.iM r\. .1. Naming Directors in Prospectus. in pro^pc'tlu-^i ■ * ,■^^^ As to naming un(iuali.lied direitoi 'i.f .\(t of 1908. sitpni, p- 'i. see set I i| S.I. 7J ..I Art nf I'-.IS As to Filing Prospectus. iM i..MitioM 1.1 ihe abo\e provision, sect. 80 of the An nin-' be I..MMU in mind, wliiili run- Ibus:-- 80.— (.1.) l-^Ty iirosp.-.tiis i,>ULil by or ou liclialf of a. tompuny ur in rcla- Kilintf "f ■:..i, to any intondid i-ompany slmll lie dated, and that dat« shall, unless the i.r..«p..lu ..iitiary he prov«l, he taken as the date of puhlieation of the prospeelus. .■1) A eopy .,f every su.h pr.ispe.t.is .shall he siRnitl hy every person »h.. i» ..1111.4 tli.T.iii iis a director or propos«Mi din-.'tor uf the eoiupaiij . ..r t.y his aprnr lutliorised ill writing, and shall he tiled for r.jristration with the registrar ..f ..mi.aiiies on or before the date of its pnhli.'ation. N 2 lS(t i'Kusi'iaTrsi> [Chap. Ill i i; ■ fi ?■ (I! ) Th,. rc^Mstrar sh.ll .,». raM^trr any prus.uHta. ..nl... it is a.U.d u„,l ,1,. 'li rT:i:",r;:;::,:i;:;" :i": :- -• - ^' "■- ■ "^ '- •- -" ,.o1pL and ry p.rson wl.o is kn.win^ly a party U. th. i.suo of the pro :;: r'shlll I,.. na.,le .« . H.,,. ... ox......di,,. «.,. pou,,,. .,.. o..ry day fr„„: L dato nf the issu.. of th. prospertu. until a copy th.-r,.ot ,. «. hh.!. The object oenevullv of thi« «e,Uou is twof..!.! d ' To pro^erve a,, .uthe.t.i..\e.o.d of ,i.V .enu. o„ .vlti.h ,l.o publt,. '--^ ''--■'V;'; , ,0 .ub.cnbo for .sliarcs debentures, or debenture «tock; =^"^ "> secure that the direciors of the con.pa,,, accept respousibtht> Un the siateniouts in the prospectus, .„.,„,„.„„ ;„ It wouhl seem to make a company's prospectus (or state.n. nt u. lieu of prospectus, see sect. 82,, like its n.etuo.andum and artulc. a public doiunteut, of .hich all persotts dealtng wt.h the co.npan ,vill have constructive .tothe, anti it retna.ns to be «eeu ho. 1> new departure may affect the pu.chaser of shares rn the marUc (IS'.k;) 1 Q. B. 172. The words -every prospectus,- >.c„ mean every prospectus, untice, circular, advertisement, or other invttatio.t ojenn!) to tin public for ,ub,cnption or purchase a.ty shares or debentures ^n, debenture stuck] of a company," See sect, 28o. The words ' bv or on behalf of a company or in relaticm to au^ intended company • apply the sectio.t to every co.npa.ty re;,iste.^ed un.lor the Act, The section al^o ext.Mids to every prospectu> issued before the company is registered, M .roover, it is no. co.dined tn prospectuses .d a company o, notices inviting persons to xuhscrihc for shares, a. was the no« repealed sect. 158 of the Act of 18G7, \ appbc^ also to a prospectus which oilers shares debentures Of debentute Mock for sale, e.g.. where they are taketi by vendot, o, (iuanclers and then ollercd for sale by the co.npa.ty. It does not apply to a prospectus issued by the owner> o ...... u. a company which has been actually registered -ho d^ o .lispose thereof, for the prospectus is ,to, • Ksued by or on bel.a of -the ..mtpanv.- but it would seem to apply to >uch a pros,., .t..- il- issuetl bv the cotnpa..y ot. behalf of the owt.e.s. At.d althou.^h .ect. 8., do;.s not apply in a given case, it may stdl be "<;- ''--J' j con.,dv with sec. 81. c ,.. where the pro-peCus ., ...ued h or behalf of sonie person 'who is or has been ongau^ed or """■;-'' i„ ,l,e fortttation of the company " See lir.st paragraph ot scct_ 8 I o.t.r- of a p.ivute nature reco,n...e.t.ling shares to a tew bus.nes- ,He..ds ate t.ot a prospectus. SU-.jh v. Ula.„o,. and Urau.nu. Options, (■> V 120. Ct. Sess. Nor is a p,o.p.vtus n.arked ' Strictlv pn^.;c an:'. T I' R- 482. Date of Prospectus." TIk' jini-|ii'i in- iiiu>i bo Jatcil. .iml tin' |;ito i- "I irniioilanre, :i<, unl<',- tlio contraiy i- proved, it i- t^' bo Mlion as tlic date of publimiinn of the pri>-|MTins, Sep -.M . 72 ) Hid soi-t. 8,'> (.1). A c()[)\ of lliP pM-i)('iiii- niu-i ti<> lili'd <.|nii.>d" it is 1101 to be ren'Klrr,-!. \\\\\''\i |.io1i,i1j1.v mean- ilial a ,11 V iinisl nol lie accepted for tiling unlo-> ii i-^ so dali'd and -^ij;ned Apparently, tliereforc. it may Ix'ar a date po-itcrior to tliai nf th,' liliiiu' On (lie ntber Imiid, it must, before it i- i--iiod. stu'e on tins i,ily, a- a copy niii-l bo (il. d. liui: copy iilso must stale thai the pnvpocliis has boon lilod, altbough ulicn the pro^peeln^ i- -igiied -and if must bo signed before tiling 11 has no! I)oon llloil. To ni.ilio sense, the words " propn-od to be i^-iied" .-lieiild In' road iiii.. Mib-soct, i2i after th.' uord pn- -portn-. " No prospectus shall be issued until, &c. riii> in.iho- compli- ai.ro with '.he section a condition precedent fo the i-siio of a pr. ^-pectus J- lolined bv ■^oct. 28."). If a prospectus not duly dated and signed i~ -abinitled for filing the registrar will reject il. The section extends not merely to the Jirst prospectus, but to all -iii.M'.niont prospectuses. If a pro-poctus is i-.sucd before it has I n tiled the issue is illegal, and those who make il may bo iiiimiially liable. Ucf) v. Tiih'r. il,S'.)l) U Q. B. •■)04. Moroovnr, aiiXuiie who subscribes on the faith of a prospectus so issued ma.\ 1» hold entitled to repudiate his contract, for no company can keep ,1 iniiiract obtained on the faith of an illegal prn>pe( ins .1 foiiiori, if the prosiiectu> thus wrongfully issued slates, in a| paiciil compliance with the section, that it has been tiled, this laUe -laleineni entitles any subscriber to ropudialo his contrail and tc lake proi pollings under sect. K4, replacing .soils. ;! and t of the Hiieilors' Linbility Act, 1300. Soil, K:; of llio Conipanio- Act, l'.)08. is jis follo\x>: ■ S3. .\ i.oiniiany i,li.ill mit liririr to tlic statutory meeting vary tlic tiTiii'< iif a I!r,.tri. limi un • "'tr.ut rcferroil to in the pro«|mctiii, c\i-ept siiliject tii the approval iif tho ah. nitMii "f tiTins nu'ii- -...atory m.-eting. tiomd a, pruspei'tU'*. h« .v'litiiinrv :nc notes ici'ouiii: t' cl. t; MUt I. 87 ill flw Av: fn thf i.tUt'I and the nolo- thereto in Chap. I\. p. GHO inil IS? A'tlH. t'V, Kfflv! , juibli' < iiani' - I )'n.k f'TH. :ir'tl uit<. PROSPECTr its ox, cljenco. the capital \rill not be forthcoming. It need scarwiy be said that the names ,if the directors, brokers, auditors, and solicitors given in a prospectus are regarded by the public and their advisers as affording a good criterion of the character of the scheme put forward: for it is— perhaps too readily -assumed that persons of credit and position who thus officially associate them- selves with a new venture, have at any rate satisfied thom.-elves as to the harm fides of the undertaking, and think sufficiently well of i*:^ prospectft to lend their names; whorea-. if the direijors and others arc unknown persons, ,) fortiori, if any of them are in bad odour, the public and their advisers may uatnr.ally feel distrust, may hesitate and think it better to abstain from subscribing. So. too, the fact that a company is launched by professional promoters may aftect the public snbscri))tion unfavourably. The above are matters for the consideration of the promoter and financier more than of the lawyer: at the same time, when a pro- spectus is submitted to a lawyer for settlement, he would bo wanting in his duty to his clients were he to confine himself to the mere legal aspects of the case, and not to point out pi\t( lical defects* whir h strike him as likely to prejudice an appeal to the public. Significant Omissions and Vague Statements. N" -isriiifioai.i Take, for instance, the ca.se of a going concern: the following (|uestions may nri~e on the prospectus :- (1~> If this is such a very iirofitabh' louccrn. wh\ does the vendor part with it — or part with il on such moderate tonus? (2"> What have been the average profits during the last few years? Have they been rising or falling? onilsslunR i. IHii 1,1 1 11.;. uu\ iudt'pi'iKleiii i)i'i-won or tinii cxaiiiiufd tiio liook^ aiui rcrtilioi] n.-< to the j^rolit^V (4 1 Docs llio v(Mi(lor lake atu Mil^taiitial proiHirtioii of llw |iur- oliusc (.oiisidoratiori in share, or (Ioom h«' rcliiv altoirothor - i5i }lus anv and what indnpondont valuation been mado of the a-sol.'« lo l>i' tnkou omt, and Imw nin.li is to ht' yriven foi LTOodwillr (I'll lIuM' iho M'lidor- a^if.d n.ii u. miiipvU' uilh iho lonipany r i7) Is tlic rt'al proprietor sellinii' to the comiiany, or is (hero an intorniediaU' vendor, and i~ he inakintia profit on the trans- action V i8i Are the vendors pavinu- any promotion money and. if so. how much ? The General Law as to Liability in respect of Prospectuses. Sect, .si (Iti of the Act provides thai " nolliinc in (his section sliall limit or diminish any liability wliich an} ; < -son may incur undc! thi? general law or this .Vet apart from this sc. iion." Hence, an\ cause of action, which would lie, apart from se( t . 81, is still available. Thun, even if the pro.siieetus complies with that section, it may by reason of untrue or niisleadin iiijro. Il is uoc-essan, therefore. In . on.,ider what are llie n-ipiiremcnt.s of \,.-^t\ the -enorul law as to prosiiectuses irie.-pective of this .-section ■/,;;f,';*"'^';','.,f 'sect. 81 I, and as to this the followintr rules should bo borne in mind: ' I 1 I The pioN)ieclus should not contniii a ndsre[U'esentatiou of any material fact, or any deceptive or inisleadinj^ statement, or anv aud)it:uou.s statement, which i^ not tru- in every sense in which it mij^ht reasonably be understood. ii ll should disclose every tniterial fad subj< ct (o the nualilica- tions below nientioneil As lo what are material fac'Is. see p. 171. supra. i.'l' 'I'he provisioii.s of sect. Kl i reprodu< iny: the Diroitors Liability .Vet. IH'.Mt I p. 20811. should be li..riie in mind, and tin' pic- lantions below snarjrpsted (p. 22' rf sci/. i should bo taken. The disresrard of these rules niav p;i\e any allott<'e of share.' — 'ai The rijrht to repudiate llie alh'lment and rescind ,''o lontract; lb The riL'hl to sue. for ne the pros|K'i tus. and others who are by statute re- ■-ponsible a most serious liability I'.tdii KIT. i ..f lum- i-..iinili!ini't . .\iid, llisl. a^ to ihe ca.~e.-. in wliiiK the allottee 'd ! prospectiLs to subscribe, is entitled to ret^cind on the fjround o )v Inc mis- ■r i.\i representation or non-disclo;; 184 PROSPF.CTTTSKS. [Chap. III. 1!^ 1! I'l ,„f .it I- ir Iv. <■■■ il|IHTt\ ilifLH-tnl- . In order to cstnblisli ihi^ riLrlit. the nUoltpr must provo — (I I TIkiI the piu.spoi tu< was i-»ued bv tli" (oin|)aiiy nr liy somo (liiccHir, )iruiiiut('r. oi otiioi |.i'i>nii wliose ads tlic com- pany has aii!lniri/(>ii or aii of the coinpany, and willi tlic sannion of its dircpfois. Clearly, in siicli casos (ho rcprcsi'Mlatiniis nf ilip pni^poc-liis ai'f a 1ioi\\( the (iiiiipaiiv- l.iniiii' is Xitriitr < titi')>n)iy v. Lii'l'Diii^ S,ii,,i;< ilf. IS'.l'.li :.' Ch. .".'.I.'. !l!H, |.;I. In niie:' ci^cs llin pro.>p('otus is i--ti('d by the pnmmtt'i-s on tlii' formation of iho com- pany, and the diivitors allui with knnw ji'duc that tho shiros are .siibscrihfd nn iho ba^i^; of tht> prospo.'tn-. Hero again tjic company, in olli'ct, ad.i|)ts iho ]iri)spi'ctus. Occa.-iiinalh a |irosppiliis i> i.-. made on tho basis of ihat pro-|iectiis and bandoil in aflcv inriifpoialioii. in sin-h cases il~|i t!ic ■iiiiipaiiv. ill aiii'ptin;j' the ap|iiiial ion- aiiil allMtiint:' ihi' ^haro-, ill elicit adopt-- tho pid-pedu- and. if it i- iiiisli'iidins:. cannot ivoep liie contract so obtained. Karhcrii'.i cinr. il.Sii2l -i Ch. l-">. ■ SpcaUiiifr uenoiailv, there is, " said liindlcv. L. .)., in that i L^o, no doiibl that n misropreseiilalion, in order to vitiate a contract, must bo made by a parlv tu it. or hy his aueiil. lint this nile is not without exception. Stiurdii'.s cuac. I Ch. .'>7i. and lionnrx v Ship. {,. W .'! H li. ;3b). warrant the proposition that an aiiplicalion to a • om)iany, when formed, for shares ba'-ed upon a |)rospoctiis issued by the pi-oi. lers of the company before iti fornution, cannot be dis- severeil bv the company from sinli prospectus." In Karhenfx . /.«', tupra. the ai)p'iication «as made before incorporation. It was .idnpanv roroived from Mr. Karbcrg an application fot shan-s iii.iepon'fi.Mitlv of any iiruspoctus: it i^i not shown tliat they ever knew thai he inadc- tJie appiifuition on the faith of the prospectu3, nor ■von tiiai lio hii.l rivoivoil any piospectiis at all from anyono." Thi- i|, pears to have been ovt-rlookod in Li/iiih v. A>i;ilo-ltalim Hemp, ,(r. Co., {\SOi>\ 1 Ch. 178. forinthatca.-'o l{onicr,.I.,tn>at« Karberg:< ' „s.' n-^Vii i.isi;.M.'.' of an nlloliiiPMl wli.'n< 'Vlio diroi<(if- of m ,om- ,,;iMv know, when allotting, that an upplioalinn for sliaros is based on ,|„' statciiient.s contaiuod in a pvl. (til the Hanie principle, where A. takes shares a.s asont for li., but wilhoiil disclosinsr t<.i the comjianv the a'rency. IS. lannot . laiin relief unless ..\. wa.s .leceivoil. r«;>/'/ v. S///-.*. .'.H 1.. T. S07- Ihixloi' v. M.„el. : T. I,, li. Jti.'i. .\.s 1,, I 2 I, the ohlio-ation of tho-e who i>sue pio-peclu-es invilinj,' ,i|ipllcatioii ' )r .-liares wa- lonjr sinc«> hud down l.> Vice-( hancellor Kiiidi'isloy in liniii.sirirL-. dc <<)■ v. Muii(irridiiv\ Iwuderslcv. V.-f.. ' who i-suo a prospectus hohliiiir out to the publii' the jri ; .dvanta::es which will .uvruo to persons who will tiike -hares in a proposed uiiderlakiieT, and invitinir them lo take shares HI the faith of the reiire.s. [Chap. Ill .':! dv tlie public who wore iuvitod by a |.ro8|)«ilus U, join in any now \enturo ow^ht to have the sam.! opportuuity of jud-inf,' of overythinji which has a. material bt-aring on the true tharaeter of the p.dventuro as the promoters themselves po>sef^sed, and that the utmost candoui ought to characterise tlieir public statementa: and his Lordshii referred with ap[)rov!ii to the rule laid down by Kind. i>ley, V.-C.. a- above mentioned. Nevertheless, tlii- ' i,'olden rule" partiike- fomewluil oi the naturr of a. "I'oun.sel of perfection"; at all evont^s. it has been qualified b> subsequent do. ision. Thus, in I'cek v. Ourncy, L. It. that which is stated absolutely false: but this, it may !)<• ob.-crved. was said in regard to an action of decoii, in wliicl. fraud is of the essence of tho action, and which dilfers essentiallv from (me biought lo obtain re.seission on the grouiul rry v. PfW, ( 1889). 14 App. ("as. ;i5'J. In MiKcown v. Boudurd, dc Co. (1890). 7i L. 1". '.VI, howevei. it was held that oven in an action for rescission mere non-disclosure of material fact.s is not sullicieni. to vitiate the toulra.t. ' I think, said Klgliy. L. .1.. in that case, the law is this, that if you relya.- a ground fur the re.scission of a contract on the omission of a state- ment, vou must show that the omission of that staU'ineiit makes whai is. siateil misleading. It is not that the omission of material fact is an independent ground for rescission, but the omi.ssiou must he of smh a nature u.s lo make the Ktatemont actually made misleading In other worils . . . suppression of the truth may contain a sug- gestion of falsity.' And see < owponenis Tube Co. v. .Saylor. ( 19(10. 2 I R I. So, also, in A„rons deejs v. i^v'-sv, , 1890 , A. C. ITi, l,ord Watson said: ' The duty of disdo.siire is not the same in a prosi)octus inviting share subscriptions as in tlie case of a proposal for marine insurance In an honest prospectus niany fact* and circumstances may be care- lullv omitted, although some subscribers might be of opinion thai the^e would have been -jf materiality as inlluenciug the e.xorcisc of their judgment. But the statement of a portion of tho truth, accom- panied by suggestions and inferences which would be possible and wedibl.- if it coiuained the whole truth, but be ou;os neither possible nor credible whenever the whole truth is divulged, is, to ray mmd, neither more nor less than a false statement.' See al.so, Hi'i/imnin v. European Central Rail. Co., 7 Eq. 154. In Aarons Reefs v. 2Vws the prospi^cius standing alone did i.ot .ontain any misrepresentation of facts, but road in conjunction with certain .'ontracts offered thereby for inspection, it was false and mi-sleading, and relief was granted accordingly; and the foUowmu 'SP?""^"^ iNTKouircnmv noit.-*. „ord. ..f l.oxl Halsbury aio -periallv descrviuK of ationtion: ' It "sahi that there is no .>pe.:ili. ..llo^.Uion of fart which .s proved to h.I t A,ain. I prote.., a. I havo .a.d. a.aiu.t thu, hen, the true test 1 .hould .ay, taking tho whol. thmg to;,^3lher, was this a .nisrop.esontation? I do not oar. by what n.eans it i. ..onvoyod-by .hat ;ri,.k. or dovic*. or amhiguou.. lanjruap.>-. all tho.e are eM'cd.cnt^ U which fraudulent people seem to think they can escape fron. the al ^^^ itioas of thi transaction. If. by a uun.bor of «tat< tn. o" intentionally ,Mve a fabo impre^-ion, and u-luce a person to ■ , upon it, it isnot the less false, although, U one take, each ^tale- ;„en. hv itself, there n«ay bo a diUiculty in showing that any .pec.hc statement i.- unuue." See, further, .s«pr«. p. t, . . Bu, of cour.se, a person gt^ting a false wnpross.on fron. a ...ospcctus does not make the pro.spectus n.islea.hng. unless there is .'onKMhins in the prospectus calculated to caa^e such a lalse unpres- sion Many people deceive themselves. f f , , A nu.svepresentation of law_i^_ not a mi.sreprocntatum of fad ,, Eeattie v. Lord Ebunj, 7 Uh. "77. But a statement of son-ething as a fact is not the less a representa- tion of fact because it involves a repre^enta. ion of law 11 e.t London. Com>nenial Bank v. Kitsou, n Q. B. Hiv. ,m. Derr, v. I .rk.U Un, Ca-s. .•i:!7; Sew Brmu'orick Co. v. Com/bcarp. 9 U.U < 'H. 'E„l,leslieM v, Londondcrnj. 4 C. Div. 003, 702. In the case as, .ueutionod, Jessel, M. K.. saul, ' -V misreprcentauun of law i.s tlu^. When vou state the facts, ami state a conclusion ot law, so as to dis- tinguish between facts and law, the man who knows the 1 act^ is taken to know the law: but when you state that as a fact which no doubt, involves, as most facts do. a conclusion of law, that is st.ll a sUU- ,„cn< of fact ami not a statement of law." Accordingly^ in lUrry V reek ubi *»p.. it was not disputed tnat a statement that a com- pauv l>ad by special Act of Parliament ce-lain powers was a state- ""Treprl'mation that sou.ething will or should be done or con>e to ,^'.. is not necessarily a represenUtion of fact; e.g., the company will construct," or " will acquire further concessions, or on the.e ti.^ures the profit* shoul.l be very largo.'' The authoriUes establish timt a mere repre.sentation that, something ' will" be done is not a rcnre.sentation of fact; for ' there is a clear dillerence between a mis- representation in point of fact, a repro,sentation that something exists m ,hc n,on.ent whi.h does not e.^lst, and a representation that some- thing will bo done in the fature. Of course, a representation that something will be done in the future cannot either be true or false a. the moment it is made, and although you may call it a representafon. if it Ls anvthing. it is a contract or promise." Per Mellish L. .1 Beatlic y.'Lord~Ebury, 7 Ch. 804. And see Alderson v. MuddiSG>j_.' Ex D 2^3, and {sub nom. Maddi.ion v. Alderson) 8 App. Cas. 4b ,^, H..iJou-s V Fernie. 3 Ch 4«7; Brlhir.'i v. Tucker, 13 Q. B. D. ■>*>■.; n..ii.f, ')])illinli inti'Iltion. I 188 VKOSPECTITSF-S. [Chap. 111. •I !♦[!• ■it m' Knox V. Ho'im'!". 07 L. T. i;i7. Thu.s a calculutiou as w future nrofitfl is nol u sUiIoiikmU ol I'.ut nmtU-if v. fltirfc, 9 T. L. R. ..80. But "a repm^eniaiior. of b.-lief, opinion, expectation, or mt«ntion ,8 u ropppsontation of an evi^tin- f.vt. lor the .tatc of a man's miml ,.H u> murh a fact as the stato of hi.s diifo.-tion If is trni- that it i> verv (lillifih to prove what i-s the state of a man's mind at a parti- , niar time, hnl if it .an he a^ocrlain.Hl. il is as nmch a fact as anything ,.U- .\ misropivs,.nUUion as to the .^tale of a man's m.n.l is, there- lore, u misstatement of fa.i " IVm Ho«en. 1,. .1.. /v/-/<".'/'o« v ril:mnunrr. -.• <'. Div. »:>',», IS:!. See also I'rek v. (lun,^!,. L K r. H I -A" MM where I.orJ Cairns appears to have consKk-ied thai ;. ..tatcmenl as lo tlie opinion of the director, mid.t. if f'»l^e. '"^ve .niounlG.1 to n misvepreseinauon of fact And see KnrhrniS ca.r. , IS'.liM .! Ch. 1, U. , , ^ , ,. . H,„ I do not think.- Slid I.oid Ilal-htiry. L. ( . v. ■\arons /.-.vfs v. T.-i... , Ih.m;. A »'. Ii7'.. 2Ht. 'any p.ttintlar form .■,!• nonl. .-■ iio.e-iuv to convey a f.Ue iii.,.re-i.m. S,.pp<,so a I,e,-nn .n,e- to a hank where the peoph' aie looii-h enniiuli to behove his words and house is not completed, but in the course of next week 1 expect to have it fnllv completed.' S,ip,,oso there was not a liou^e upon h.^ land at all. and no po^ihiiily, therefore, that it .ould be luliy coin- ,doto,l can anvbodv s,,v that thai was not an affirmative i-eprescnla- ii,,,, that ther.; was a hou^o which was so near to completion that it ,,nU reouired another week's work upon it to complete ii .' . . . Soliere, when I look at the lan-na-e in which tins prospectus i. .onched and see that it s,„.aks of a property wlii.li re>,uiies only ,|,P ,.,eciioi. of uiMchinerv to be either at .,ii2. :Wt): and VaMison v. Ahlevon. 8 App. I as tt;7 " \ man who trulv states his intenti .n is not estopped frotii .■hanging that intention. The expression of .t.lenlion may, m .omc .ircumstames, amount to a -ontracl. or to evi,lence of a contract, but it does not -ive rise to an estoppel. See lie Moorr Brothers . IM» r , „Luv sL^icd by iho v.-u.lo.,. nvI.o nvo.v diro. tors .,1 tho .o.u- i: ■: .;^' of .bo onUn..> «ba:e.- .-.I n was ).o.. on tl. Su.o.'s ai-pb Uiou to put tbo V.UJO.S ou ibo l.M ol co.., nbu or.o.,. ' 'l-,. 1.0. d'OuK 0^0.1), /.'..' -Woo/v nrotlur.. .up, a. tollowod I, (^ luibilit,! in CCI.C of carele.s.< Lm!J>u,„o and ,unln„it.,uou.s, if it ts reasonably cupabU, of boan„« . . "„u.t, wbich tbe allo„«3 at..ibu,od to i, ; for ' .1 P--.- P" '; Sr.' a ,.ros,..HU.s use sucb careless lanj^ua,., .ba. 'Itcnr «ta„-- ; : li,e.ally road, at. untrue, uUbou,b tbis luoral .ense .s .Unore, ;:;:„. ;bat 4- --^-'- >'- --"- - v;"^ 'pr^ ■! ;i "1 . li Lord Cbebnslord, llallotr. v. fV///"-. •■• ^ '' •''- ""^ I as r.ion r epeutodlv btid down by ju,l,es of enunon.e. ' A person wbo tssu,.^ .s a neat is no, only answerable for wba, be tn b.s own nut, l^Id ,o ..present, bu, ite is answerable f.n. wbat an,...e m^b- ,.ea.onably suppose to be .be t.teani,,, o. .be won s he bas used. I'er (otto... L. .1 ., Arkwriiilit v . .\e,rboht. 1. t. Uis •!- ,f a .na.. .nakes a sla.cn.e..., wbbb acrordi.,;; lo i.s ord.na.v .neantuK bear, a par.icular eonstruetion. be, in "'^ "P""'-'; ';;;': to tbuse wbo leading i, u..d con-t.u.n^' it roasot.abb do pu ...» n . I. prin.ary .nea.ti..B u..d the fatr .o..struct.on ot tbo .or.is used. Per Cotto.., L. .1 .. I'erl- v. De^ni- :57 C. I). .. H . In tbe cas.' of a., antbiguous sta,o.«e..t, it is i.nn.a.erta .bat the «.nls are in.e.tded by .boso who issue tbo prospo.tus to be under- ...a u. a sense i.. wbi.b .boy are true, if tbey are reasonab capable of being t.ndorstood i.. a sense ft wb.-b tbey a.e tal . I ,l.e allo.tiK. sbows that be uttderstood tbe.n i.. .ba, se,.se. ,^>ndh s Vhadwkl: 20 C. Uiv. 27, 45; '.. App. C'as. 18. . • If a .nan uses language wbicb .ake.i m its ..alu.al sen-e .■o..n.> ..,;!,:-:.Os.ion,i:;.,.a.,..o.beb .d,o.,y,ba.bedidno,t,ne,,d ,o deceive ■ I'er l.indlev. 1.. •!., .\nuson v. >//-/^//. 41( . D. .!,-. Bn, ,ho ro,.stnn.tio.. wbi-b tbe .-eripie... of a pn.-por.ns ,- en,..led H, pat upo,. V. ...ust be a .easonalde .ons.rueU ...U i> one w „.b ,l,e wonls wUl fai,lv ad...it of. See Ed.n.i>,lon v I dzm.una .' r Div 1.-." Tbe.e it was bold ,bai lb- l.lai..Uil bad no r.rrh, ,,, as.un,e ,ba. .he wonl ■■.lebe.„...es - n ed tn .be p-o-.pe,„,s ......0. anv cha."e on tbe oonipa.iy s properly. Mi.rep.e^e«.alioa of a si,.gle n.a^erial f.ul o,' . i. 1 be . a-e of -l.a.,.^ ..,pp,.es'.o.. of a si,.gh. .naterial fa., n.ay be sulh,..e,„ .0 e..Ulle ,1h .iJ^.ee to .■es,.,..io,.. nrrr, v. IWL: U App. .s. : .: ; /,o../-. and SlulJordMn- Co.. 21 .'. D. 1 I'.': PcUo.^. Mncu-d, 1 Ko -.- ;;:,.-,. Bnl 8«.'e i.-a.-es ai ii. i:"'- «((/»«. I iiiu'iiiiiri 111' siii-1. iiii-n |ir. ~i iitatii I ,,. -.ii.]..-. "i.i >iirtii'it'm. If I!MI Jiri. i"i> Ml tnith.'f "♦s incTit. F.viilciH-. 1 mii-rt'lirr M tatiuii ami uk>(*ure. I'lKlHrKCirsKS. [(.iHAr. 111. And wliero a ropre»ei>latio!i as t.. a iiial..n,il Ui. t in a pr(.>i.oclu> ib untruo it is no dofeuce, wliere nixeis^ioa of amtrart i-* souglit. that it wa.s au iunocont one, and tl.o diivtois when they made .1 boheved it to bo true. The Hlmrelu-ld.-. i^ i-.|u,illy prujudi.nd. S.... judBment of Lord Cairns in ,S>«<7V. ,;m'. 2 fh. •101, 01.-. aud ... Reese River Co. v. Smith. L. R. 4 H I- -"^ .IWarri;/'-' v. Ar...-/>oW, i: CI,, u, ;«2i). .Uaf/.«.* V vw/«, (•; i.. t m-2 .<'i. of \pi..t. Iv /,. ,'r,;lr>nv of m.sr.'/"-'''"-"'"'"^" "'"' '">«-'''■•'<■''"""•'' ■ The shareholder, whether lie ..^-s as '^ bind the con.pan^ Wor e.xa.n,.le, in HriMi UtirMih (<>.. oi, 1.. T. 8lo, the coiupanV had directed au expeit to i-eporl ou the value nl tl..' „„„e and h'is report, to the ellect that it w.i.s worthless, thou-li rea.l ;il a Lrene.al n.einint; of the .o.npauy and .irculat«d aiuon- the ^hare- |,olde.s, wa- not allowed to he taken as an admission bv the companv ,'mli l'n,-i'l>;,t Co.. 22 D. .V.t;t. Examples of Misrepresentations. K.Attnii'i. iii.itt I i)il IlllMiprr ^t'!ltnt!^l] .,„ The loUowiug are exa.,.plo.s „t material ,n^.rel..eM-,.t.u^..n^ nw\ iion-di.s.h)Sure entitling 1" rescission: - . ,; \Vl,c.rc the ,.ou.i,any «a, form, d I.. • .n,>t>uc, ...d work u "''«-y. -''•' it «-.^ 0) -"■•"Iv »'''«'"J "'^' "'^' '■"""■""' ""■ ""■■ '■*'■'■"""" "' ,' wurk. had l.cn e.,t.T,trulv -tated that th<. .on.raH price was ......id.Tably with.n tuc .-.va.lahlc .anifil- (S) n.'t mention.'.! that thi- . ..n.-.s>i...i.-, whuh the e.,mi » w's f..r,».Kt t« earrj- ....t had h.e,, |„.r.haM.d !r..n, -h.. ..r.^n.c.l ^ra:,). at a .'o-t of .50,00,)/. S.H. Oi.nnl R„. Co. .-/ r,"'-"W-r v. Ar.-.., ■1, NVlie": u'L!'a!!unly staled that - n.or,- than half th,. ^-' ':;>-;' .l,an- has i..-en air, aJv M,l,serib..d for," and that - upwanU ., .1 .0(1.. ha. alr..a.ly b..e,. cM-ended on th.. estate l,y .1... vendor ,n haihlin!-'- and improven.ents. in addition t« the purchase-money pa.d l^X '"'"■;■; U>e land.- ."^ce /...- v. i-.^.<.- /-■.«' "' '•"■■ 3 N. ^1: * ■■ •- ,:U When, it was stat-d that "one-half the reiu.red .ap.tal ha. h. , . • ul. • ..ribed by the directors and U.eir friends," wherea. not .>.,e-.our h h .1 ,,..en .uhseribcl. KrW v, ,'■. > . I' Vu.' r„. . K,,. oHS: •< < '■■;'-^'- i;. Div. 348. , , , . O; Where it wa= »tat.,l that a parti,-..lar >-"'•.•■'""«";■""« ^"J^,),"'""''; elaims, some of whieh are in full operation, and n.ak.- lar;?. da.ij returns.'' had b.^cn ..on.raet.d to be pnr.hased. wherea., th,.^m.ne was. iu fact, worthless, and there were .... elaims in ..peration. H..'>e. Ji,r.. Co. V. .Vm.M, L. U. 4 11 I- «<■ INTKomMriOKV NOTKJf. ,.,,t.,l f .. I.nnkinir company, it »«• r.iiirnly -t;it.-.l « <>< " ,) wi,..r. .t w« M,l.-.l that •"' •»n „ . ,„„,, „„.,.. !I; 'r ;ven.«..l .- ".u.-h. ^h.r-a. in fa-t ,hey wcr.- n.,,,!, I--. '■ "11." 1 lin, ... •'•'■"■ 1" '"■'""" '" """ ""■" '"'"'■ ,t,or<. wa. au aer..ment t« ,.ay laree «unH. /."'/" -/ '• f-^^' I T i R 76 «::;rizr-f-!:;r="r:';=r"S"'.: iulilition. '171 Wliirc it was wlicrpas thp mini inc ,„„ .. ,,,. . ,H«i H.ni wa> t,. be paid for tl.o |.r..i"rly liidod a larpr sum for ,,rom,.tion money, hmly st;if''il I hat a spei /•', .A ,w /."'"/ '■"■■ » '•"•'I- **"*: ''■'■'''' '■• Ct. of App. 10 Feb. 1«H2: Cap 'I V. «V'"/rt« t Sniitli'-rv M \.. T. ml il„,„rr Cn AH) When- tlic coiupany f was I'oriiiMl to buy a mi iirt of an expert win »et f.irth whirh irav ami extract- from thi' a misleailiii',' impre^-tion ,{ tlie report, and induiec e| rieb adjacent mine. li)) Wiiiie the rnmi>a!iy 1 the Mief that the mine wa . ('as. ,l;i; "f til- Mnirtl of Trail raili" iipuiit •ui it iiiily liud iliii rv V. /'. <• It wui untruly ,i,iiii| tlmt iIk i'Ji«»it witJi lru»ti-.< ..f a »ulti< A ' ■ J- V. Jlulim.ii. ti7 I.. T. |;17 rj2) W li.r- u (iminot^.r. hIim was (.; tfuaniiiti'cil iliviil. mi >'''>l ^iiiiiiunr iif i.iivi'niiiii'i (23; \VI truly put fiirward iw mil' iif till- unilcirs •■' I'liri „r t|„. pur, lm».- was si'i'iiri'il It si'i'iiritii's ry, was uii- iim Urr it WU.S uiilruly ,t.,i.',i that tl '/ V. v,//).. :,H I,. T. HOT (24J W luT.. It « unary ••xpcnsfs. //'„ as unt 111' vrndiir was to pay all tlir pni «T. I.. H. I.m rn> r, turiTs of u»||i'«t .Ishnl.. ruly statH tliat tli.. ..ompttny wnr,. tli.. soli- manufa.. 'i«- in I'-ranir. anil imil n practiial monopoly. //„,/, v Ci:>) VVh. . « T. I., a. 121 it was unfuly »t:.tii| tlmt tlir menial kuhi'sn. .v/ (2(i) Wliirr it wa Hii.dOd/. IS »ti.iiil that til, iipany's proirss wai a ' ■ ^ I' r,. 1( 71 (layahlo in ift.sli. unil hail at- il-- I'. IJM limp: "■"il to ri'-si.|| t>> flir liiil imn liii-.'il til IK",(MH1/.. wl„.r..a» ,l,..y liaii also |,uril,a-id .l,.|,..nt onipany for II • Baiiii' projurly, uii nliiili {\, wliiili «ai only rcfirrnl lo in tli. pri.lit-- inaili hy i|„. .yndiiaii uients ari- cxilu |i-d Irmii fii. Ila, urrs iiii-iiiiilii'rini.' y li.id iiiailo a furdicr proiit of 2(i.(hh)'.. |T...p,.tU, ,„ follow,; .. \„y „„|„^ (luoo; \. c. •.>((). ■ 111 -:,||. to tl fn lie ''"mpanv. Ill interim (27) Whore if »■ iis stali'd that tin • fiiilors of nitrate (•rouiiiN ha. I olitairnd a.1.1 ,ro,l,-ht. ,„ pipes, t „. :, „.,,,|j. „,. ,,„,,,_ ,.„,, „,,,, „_ , , would have the ridit of iHiu, a ler.ain par. of tin water, where, the water supply «•„, insufHeiei,, . /„,,,„„ .,„,„,„ ,.„ , ' ,'l ■''9>'/ioJ II heel Co., lUioo) 1 C'h. '121. 29J Where it was stated that .share eapital had been - sub-rilied," when in fael It had only heen allotted in fully paid shares „, ,he c.mpanv-- eontractor. Jn,i»on v. im.M, lu ( h. D. 5»i7. Is l,.n|,.s,.) '■a»i s «i,ir. the riiarepri - SI -il ■i. rcn or Don -di.selosut'i was iii-ufti- ■•it'll other nu^unc^. of ...i,s„.p.vM.„,.u,.n- in;,-, i,.. i„,.,i,| i,. j,,,.,^.,^,, , [''r'T ■ '^ ' " '' ""• •'^"'"•'' " ^'V Wtv-Wo., r,G L. J (h ;;'•:; ^^""''': r'- '• " • '■'' ■'■-•■■ f^!">n'^ ca,-:, :'.:, ifcav. <;i.;. Mk^rs .. larLrr, 1,! (^ 15. I), .-,»;,,; x,,„ nn,r,s,nU- Co. v. To.,.- ,'."!;! ,"■" """' ■ " ■ " '■''• " ■''''■'■■■ '^'i'mbier V. Uo„,/ I I«JJ) 1 ( h. .-.o.i: romimw.ih Tube Co. v. .Vi,///or, i I'jtm) j I,-, i; The Killowin^. are in..tatues in whii h the .nisioiMx-oiitation or tii,,,- li.'^tlOMiic ii'licil 1)11 was held ,0 l,c iii.siiUi, iiMil : leen te.ted and that a,.cord,ni; to the experin.e.ts the material eould I.I' !.roduee,l at a spoeified lo.st. but that it wa. intiiiiled to test the mveiition further, and it in faet turned out worthless. ne,to» v Miuiuu, 2 l.ii. :l,ij. ■«r.! ■ -m-^^ Ti ET rr. iNrK«>i)L'cn)uv NorK>. !!»:» '■■i) will I.' ill- |.ni-|.<'. rii> iiii'iiliHiii'il ■ :i KiuiniiilK'il ili\i>li'ii.l of iit liw \..ir»," wlnrrai tli.'rc «a« iiiily .«jnii' iiiircci.nliil iind.r-l.iii.liiii.' uitli iIh- m mlor tliiit In- win tu l'Iv.- -iitt li u-iiar.iiit.-.-. A'..-' \ h,..h„l,i I , ..,( I.... I |;,|. ,-,HH, II, .f It «,'i. ■ iiii«liliiiilh V. Vhndwiik. It .\(>|). ('««. int. UlitTC It wu» slul.il Ihut tliu iMiii|iaiiy Ha- I.i lani- "a frii' ifiaiit of ilu.lliMi ain- ill tlie [iriuimis ihrouKli whn li tlir railway ii to jm™>," wliri-ia- tlic 3(1,00(1 aire- wirr 10 I,.' i,'raiiliil uu\s out of tlir pr.nitii.'« l.rii, lif.'il l.y tlip railway, ami |oi\aii' |ir.i|ii riy in tlnw |.ro\imi-i «ai i'Xi'('|it.il r^„tr„: /,'„,/. f„. V. A',-',. I.. I?, i II. I., at p. II.-.. Wliprc a (.'OH ri nt ifoaraiitvr of )) piT iiiit. pi^r aniiiini 011 thn rapitnl wa- iiii'iiti..iii''l, ttiilioiit nfiTi'iiir to thi- I'.nt lliat it wa-i to lait ii. lonir only a- tlif lapital iliil not prmlin ,■ p.i- ,,.„t. f,,, ., r,.a«,ii nut iiiipniilili to till' ininpany. W Inn il wa. statiil that n-rlaiii rrport. on thr propi'ily Innl lum prr panel -for tlir ilin-itor-," thousrh really niailr for thr pioniofi.r.s. I'.'ii in llii.^ i-a»r then' wa* no llmliiiL- of fniinl, („./". v. f'iti, ,,■ri-.i,)ii imle^.' lie Wiis imiiiicil lu 'liii'i- into ilic I iiMii-iir( la llic it'|iii'-oiihilii)ii or mi|i|iiosmm|i wliirli liu ' -!alili-lio^. lliai is uulcs.s it \\\ui i/iu/.v luniiii luiitiiuhi). It !.•- 111)1 iili iiileiCMuv 111' liiu iliDi a inuiy ul,,. liki s -liaio~ mi a ;'lo.-H|i<'(lus coiiiaiiiiii^i- a iiii-iciiicsciiiaiiun «a^ iinlmcil 1.1 -ulisi 1 ilic I'.v ihal MiiMO|iio liiviiiii.-iaiiri'.-. Bin ' il il is |i|,ni.,| thai ihc 'ictfiiilaiil.- ui;li a view to iiiilii-|. ilic plaiiiiiil invnlor iiiloa .onliail. iiiadi' a .-taHMin'iil lo ilio |ilaiiiliir o| sii, li a iiaiiiir a- »oii|.| l„. jikoiv H) iMiliiic a iiviM.ii to ,.|iti'i iiiiu a 1 oiiliail. anil il i.s |)iovi'il ilial the phiiiitili iliil (Milor iiiio llic louifart. it i.-. a lair iiif.'iciur ol larl thai !"■ wi.s iiuluwd lu do .so l.y the mIuhmik'hi.' I'i>r l.oril UlaclJiiini. '"'/ p. I!tt;, .And tht' lolj'.wino- |,a.s.saoo frnin thi> jitd-iiioiil of l.oiil llil>lain. K ( ,.i„ Am, son \. Smith. H V. 1). .■{(('.), in.iui.s in ih,. Kami' •liii'rli,.ii. ■ Il i,. -ai,l ]ii~ l.,,i(|.-lii|i. an old pxpcdiciil, and -fldoiii >in 'o-.'.liil. Id ( i-o.'is.oxaniiiK' a jicixoii who ha.'" tiMil a |)|-os|m>( l-is. a 11 I nd; him a,- 'o caili |.artiiiilai- siaiciiiful what iMlliii'inc il had .ui lii.'^ 1 and. and hou tar ii diMcniiiniMl him tn I'nIiM- into ihc lontraii I'lii- '- 'i'""' laii.i' ion.-; li ass,inu'> iliai a pt'iNon who leads a |ii-o-|iim'|i! ami d.'li-nnini'.s to lal-i' shales on tl,,. faith ,,|' ii, can aii|in.|.ii •'iii'iiit;- iIk .iillciiMil pari'S of ii. the iMlcil inudined hv ihi- wholr I ln> .an laivix he done cvoii at iho limo. and for a sliaielioldcr tlin- .N 1 ii'si-iMsion It all.lli-.- wai. 11 t io'l i| I'V II..- r.-pn'- ", ■ '1 ,:ioii,,vi .. lo .■•iii'rait t.. ta ,-. t'lr A 0.'.. 194 PROSPECTUSES. rcHAP. III. I'sual statofl u'lMirnds for nOiof. ()nu(* of jmiof ; u. aiii.lvM' hi.- n.enlal imim-ssioMs aUev an interval of .-overal years. >o as to say wlilrh ropre.sentatioii in particular iiuliicod him to tiikc shares is a thin- all t.ul impossible. .\ ix-rson reading the pro- sp.M.tus looks at it as a whole, he thinks the un.lertakmK is a fine , oinmercial speculation, he sees poo.l names att.iche- ment to enter into th<. contract, the inference is. if he entered mto the -ontrart. that he uct«' suhsrrihe l.y arrangement with promoters. (.3, Tliat he was really induced to sul,s.Til.c l.y representations made by parties for whom the company was not responsible. (4, That he did not rely on the statements, l.iit investi^'ated tbe matter himself. Jenuiug, v. Hr„u.,hU,n, .5 U. Al. A: (J. 12(i; H lieav. 238; and see -VaMm* v. 1V»», 46 1.. T. 497; Ea„lr.HM v. Ma,,iHv, uj Lviiduuderry, 4 Ch. U. 693. ,5) That the prosp«tu8 itself showed that the statements were basod on hearsay, and wore to be verified subsequently. ISriU'^h Bnr«mk Co., 56 L. T. 815. ^^SSMmsssk iNTRonuaroKY notks. l!»". Imniiter th:it it .11) Tliat the ulliittw is a jiorsoii of suili ixpcriiiui- aii' i- not irpdibic that hi' wa» niisl(> <'. Div. 459; Carlini/ v. L'nulnii ami Leeds ll,ii)l:. M, I, T. II."): irnmm v. Smith, il <". Div. ;tl8; Scott v. Sni/ilrr, ,1,. ( „.. lii; L. T. liH:!; S. r., OT 1. T. 1114: I'ecl,- v. /»«•/•;//, 37 1 li. IJ. .">41: Kwu- V llii'iiiKin. tiT 1. T. 1;!'J Ii is -ulliiicrit lliat It was a:i iuJiuoiiMMit . Whoiv tlio prospoctus iiM'iolv stales llial A. li. iP|iur|s so ami so. tlif a|)i>li(ant is not, as l>olwt'Oii liimsolf iiiul tho ioiii|iim\ . entitled I.I a.sstinic Ihut those who issue the prospectus j;uarantee ihi' Iriilli ,11 acdiiacv ol' .\ 1''. s report. Smith ■•< (n.sc. 2 Cli. till); limrlins v W IrLlimii. ••! I). A .1. .iiU; lioillei/ v liltirl.-. '.» T. L. H. :>»{). Tims where the proniolers of a coiupanv to work a load mine in Biirniah i.ssiied a jirospecliis having iipiiondorospeclus. ii \\,is held thai the promoters had frankly told the allottee all they knew, and could imi 1)1' taken to e;uarautee the truth of the report. lie liritUli Itiniiiah Lead ( o., 51! L. T. 815. lint it i.s otherwise if the oompany rei)re.seiit.s the report.- us faetw. If.' .said Turner. L. .1.. "a com|)anv will take njion it> I U -' "The applicant is entitled to sav: Vtween the objects of the con.pany. a,s sfat ••< «'•-_<'. ■1 He i; .T * S .-,44; Meh^terx --rsr. 2 V.<\. Vtl : Sfnnirfx 'tJ.sc. 1 ( h "But this curse is n.)«- rarely mlopted Moreover, in I'rrrx c<,sr. •> Oh r.74 Lord Cairns lai make any objection.' This vva~ ....proved in Oatr.y. T,m,i>,nul L. R 2H. L. :i52; and .see Ih„n,r. v' Ship, L. R. :? H. L. 359. Sometimes a representation which wa< true when the prosp,..iu- «,«. issued becomes false before the allotment is made. In sudi .a^. the fact ou'dit to be communicated to the applicant. .Sro/^,s/i Prlm- l.;w 2.1 C^Oiv. 4:!H: TraUly. UarUu,. I D. ^■ & S. ;n8; lh;>d.'rs,„ V. Im>-uh. •! Ell- 249; and per Lord Blackburn. Umirnllr \ Cawiiln-ll. .-. App. Ciw.950. ; --I Contract Voidable, not Void. I„ .very a... A contract to take shares, delK-nluies. or debenture stock, whirl, ha- «..• -.mtrart is i.pp,, induced bv misrepres«.ntatioii or suppiession .,f material tact- voidabl... .... _^ ^.^i,|^^,e notvoid: that is t.. say. the sl.a.el.nlde, hits the opliui. I.^ allirm or avoid the contract, but until the shaivhohler elects to avoiJ INlUODUCriOUY NO IKS. 197 .,. i, .omalns p,od. Oake.^ v. Tunym.**./. L K 2 H. L .ii:,; /'.vA- v '"Tho^'i-'lit l„ ,ivma tlio i-..1.a.t is, lu.ucvor, .lualitlod. lluu i^ to sa\ . I-'-nipnu-uo.. , 1) il niu-l ho exoni-iMl, if ut all, i.iompily on .lisrovenn;,' the luol^. ;i„.,i„^.„p. ,„,! r>. Ilio risrht, in the case of sl.aros, will bo lost, if u w,n l„>--u,. !..,„m.o.uos hofor,. tl.e ooutnK.t is i-llo.tuallv a^oldc.l. If a man claims lo irs.-in,! Lis ,o,uia.l to take shams n. a ,,„„„..„y on the gro.HMl thai ho ha« bc^ou iudu.i'd to onl.-r into it by n,i-'o',..osontalion, h. n.nst .oscind it as soon as he learu« tho laets. „, „n' he forfeits all .laiu.s ,o relief - I>er James. L. .1 .^h.nplen V Loulh. rfc. lt,iil. Co., 2 f Div. .;.i;i. tifs:.: and s,m, .Uhlr.i ^ ca»: ..K, 2.i.l: Ogdt-ie v, (>..,«-. HT L. .1. VU. .-.41; «.'.'>6 RivrrJ>d,-,. \linuu, Co.. -2 d>ershi,. , ., T„r,,u«ml. I-. K. 2 H. 1. ••12:.. Heme, l.oid fauns. L. L . . , Srholdi V. Cealral limL Co. of \,-nr:,n-la. '.• Eq. 2i.i, n.. ,„ ■ Ho .«rtainlv thouohi tho Court would 1k) most tareful U> see, ,„ ihe ,ase ,)f a .ompanv -oin- ot. an,l Iradui-, in which the rights „f ,|,e sharehohlers ami others varied fr.nn ,lay to day. that a i-ersou comin.. lo .oniplaiu of misrei-reMmtalions. and .oniin}; \" avoid a voidable .„nlnul. raiiie within the >lioneM linii; ol (ini.- ulii.h wa- faiilv possible in smh a ease." \shorl dclav may be sullicient to deprive him of the nurhi to l,„l„., rescind. Thus in Taites case, \i Eq. VXu a delay of a month after the .liareholdor had given notice of repudiation, wlucli the directors a.Hlined to permit, was deemed fatal. And in Peels nixe, 2 Ch .;7t. Lor■■) (;. Div. 413, i;i4 (.where, however, the point was not iiecessar\ i„ iho decision of tho case); Skeltons case, 68 L. T. 210; Jmk.wn.- ,«.«• 1.-. W. R. 8'.»4; Kent v. Freefwid Laiul Co., -i Ch. 493: Re*:s, Itinr Co. V. Smith. 1-. R. 4 H. L. t!4; Central Hail. Co. of rc^wznelo V. le to g" ""<' ascfrtaiu for liimself whetlior tliere i-^ u miHicprosonlatiori or not." I'er Rumilly, M. K.. Ashlei/'s ra.ic. '.> Eq. 2*j'.t. Neverthek'ss, mere rumour that tlie coiuiuiiiv is a swimllo, or molt' suspicion, is not onougli. Tims, iu I'eitlrai Itnil. uj Vni<-:uclii v. Kisrh. L. K. 2 H. L. '.•'.•, tlie aUotmont \vu.s on Jul.v 15tli, aud tlie allottw adiiiittod liaviiirlil have hoard unfavourable rumours, and con- ceived suspicious of the lompany at an early period after lie obtained his shares, yet that ho rec'eived no certain iiiforniulion upon which he could acl until the month of November, aud he did nothing be- tween that day and the 28tli of January. 18lio I when ho tiled his bill), which amounted to uctiuiesienco." And see /tow Riirer Co. v. Smith. L. H. 4 H. L. t>4, and Aoiuux Uei-fx v. Tiriss. (IH'JtiiA.C. 27a, 293. It has beou held that when a company relies tor defence on non-repudiation within a reasonable time after n-ceipt of a circular disclosing,' facts ■.'iviiifr a right to repudiate, it is for the oompauy to prove the receipt of the circular. London and Stalf. Co.. 24 C. U. 14'J. A limited delay may be e.xcused where it has resulted froiu bond tide uegolialions between the repudiating shareholder and the coiu- pany. ^eill.s aisi; !."> W. K. 8'.t4; I'airlex tiixe. 4 C\i. 497; libbatls V. lioulluii. 7.! L. T. .")a4. If the company forfeits the shares and gives nolic-e of tlie loifoilure 10 the shareholder, and the shareholder had not lost his right to rejiudiaie at the date of the notice, the relation of company and shareholder is severed, and the latter becomes a meto debtor to the company for calls: and if he has not done any act to repudiate the contract, he is not then bound to l^ke any step ioi the mere purpose of getting rid of his liability to pay the calls, but to an aetiou to recover them may set up the misrepresentation as a defence Aiironx Ue^'.fif v. Twi^fi, (1890) A. C. 27;i. 295. When a shareholder is suing for rescission, the Court can restrain a forfeiture of the shares pending the hearing. Lanib v. :>amb(is Rubber Co.. (1908) 1 Ch. 84."); Jone.s v. I'acnya Rubber Co.. 1,1911 i 1 K. B. 45.-.. A shareholder must not only give prompt notice of repudialioii after discovering the fart^ entitling him to rescind, but must follow up the notice by proceedings to have his name removed before a winding-up has commenced: that is tu say, where the winding-up is by the Court, before the lireixmtation of the petition on which tlie order is made, and where the winding-up is voluntary (with or without the supervision of the Court), before the resolution for winding-up is passed. Oakes v. Turqtuwd. L. R. 2 H. L. 32o; INTKODUtnOliV N<)Tt>S. A>„^ V Frerhnhl Luul ,u,d linrkm.kin,, Co.. a Vh mi Sinn.- v^ rit„ ami nnu,h, lU.k: .( V. V. Div. 28- »-2: drnrrol IMu:n, s,i„d,r,it,: ,„■ not nuikos no llilIclOl,..^ liur,,c^^s-< ru.^r. i:. C D. .O, Bui iJ.i> inl.' ii.-^ I" '"ki"'r;' ''-■•'^^- >H'I'^» '''"'■^ """ ^'IM''>- '« ''"' "^•';"'- ■UMO of ;.n in,.-ului- ullolnioni uii.I.t .so.l. «r, .,1 tl,e ('o.n|mn.os A,-i P.OS 111 tliul <^i-se ""ii'<^' "»■ >"i.u.liaun,i i> .Miou-li. //.■ \at>oMl Molnr Mail Conch Co.. (IWHiliCh. 2-J«. ' TlR- ".ouii.l ni ih.' ,,„na,l. ah, .sapia, wius ,i,al tlio .oiitia,-. w.i.s vni,lal.l... not voi.L llu.l a vni.labl.- cout.a<>l ,,o„l,l ,i„i !«. avoitlcl alter iho li^'ht.s ol' ihi.d i.a.lies had supervouod. that bv the win.li.i--ni. the ri-ht« of lite coinpuiiy's .■re,l.t..rs liad supervened, aii.l that tliereuiion a .!<•«■ «laluton l.abilil.v a.osc to ronliibute tu the assets. 1«« What i.- ail ellecliial reimdiation; — Klli'ctual repudiation . , 1 , Hi. Miili.icnt if the sl,i,nh„li If is sufficient if the shareholder, without undue delay, and before a windins;-up commences, takes lejial proceedings to enforce rescission, even fhouith the windintr-up connncnccs befor.' the order tor rescis- sion is obtaimHl. IU-r»e liiver Co. v. Smith, L. U. 4 11. I Hut it mav he too late if the proceedings are not taken u . alter the company has iMHonie i.ublicly insolvent. ir„ni;,l v. Citu "/ (il„>.,jnu- n,u,k. 4 .\pp. C„s. (il5: Cmllra, v. l.n,vlo<, .n. 10 K.|. 503; AfhleyH cine. 9 Kq. "263. ■.'t) not rnitK(i<>nt- ( 1 ) it the ^|]arc■l."l(l«•r j.'i"-' imtiir of rfpiidialion, l)iit the ilii-crtor^ dm Imr ti> ii>«i>nt to rwiission, ami tin- ■.liari-li.ililiT, Ills iiaiiii' liriiis on tli- rcu'i^tcr. dors not promptly tak.> ll).'i; /.'-■ SiniHsl, /•.i,„/,„,„ r,,.. ■z:. ('. Div. ll.'J. i-2) If tl]r "liarrl.oliliT talic- pro. r.-liiiL'-. I'ot almndons tli.iii. It,:,/ , /,„,„/„, ,/ Si„lf,., v. T ,n;i«<'»'' ■ I- H- 2 II. I- :i2> : /•''■'■"■ ''■'■' r„. V. Sii.ith. L. U. I II. I., lit. (4) If the shan-lioldiT to an a< li.>n for calls plcailcd tliat he was induced t take the shares l,y fraud, and ..l.lained a verdict. Iiut took no fnrtiM . .i.tion to have the contract res, inded hcfori' a windinj,'iii>. Vlcvi-!'!., /,„„ r,... Hi \V. H. !»."i: lint >ec Wl.u.l,-,,-- -•„„.. -,• ,rn. in whiili lilts i-as|. was dolllit*si. '& Conducl ol shareliolder apparcntlv aftiniiinLr contract. II a |ici.-(.ii /(■/(() hux iiiTi'i ii'M-i,\< r„s,; 8 ( li. App. .-.ID), aud tliG «umc principle applios wlicrc lli.MO lias iiceii no real aoieeniont t^j take shares owiiip tou iiiictakf as t-i thr eoin])ain's idtiilily. /{,(//^V'.s- <•,(.<,•. 1S08 i I Cli nil: ('iniihi\. L'lialsiiii. ■■'> '■^\\. \\^V l">'J, lti.">. The rio-hi toii'-cind may lie Inf^l not only liy d<'lay .ir a windim;-ii|i but al.s.) liy londiict which .slmu- an I'leclion on the par! ol ilic siiaiv- liolder to uflirm the contract. Thus, if the .shaipholdcr. after discovciy of the fact.s '/\\\\\'y him ;. rioht 10 rosi ind. troals ihc cnntiart as suhsistinfr. <'.'/•■ ^'.v ondoavnai- ino- to sell the sliares , E.r ,,„rlr lirlmis. 1 f-'l •«■!'• ''.v <'\'"' utin- ■' iran.sfor of tho shares ( /•,/i(/<7/'.v <:,.s,; 4 Ch. JiJlij. or otherwise tleal- ino- with the .shares .V/co/n rnxr. 3 I), it •) . I.'il), by iiayiu-r calls oi instalmont.s or receivino: divith'nds iSrholr;/ v. Criifrnl null. <'o.. 9 K,,. 2t)i;, n.; Kent v. Freehold Land Co., I E.i. r,HS; Shearman'^ aise. 60 I.. J. Ch. 2.">), or by attending and votinc: at : j^a-iioial meet- ing in per.son or by pro.\y iSluirplei/ v. Louth, dv. Co., '2 i'. Div titiTi). ho cannot afterwards lepiidiale. So, too. he may bo bound il he lakes a transfer of other sbares i l'ol W ■ K. 892), but a transfer of part of the sliaies before discovery does not proolud. relief as to the rest. .Mount Morn'in ^We.st) dohl Mine, oG L. T G22. And the Hhareholder is alhiwed a leasoiuiblo time to obtain evi- dence. ( enlml I{,iil. Co. of Vene:iielu v. Kisrh, 2 II. L. 99; ami BrIfU-h lhiiw,ih Lr„d Co.. M\ L. T. HM. Xeo;„tiations ,my ex( use delay. Tihhnlts v. Uoullon (1895,), 73 L. T. b-W. It" is conceived that acting as a member will not operate to affirni the uU-sr io, U,l. l.r.a; r/o«r,/,_ v^ /.. .A- » /"' ^■ ' - F, •.;; Soo ul«o Nr,. ; :|,i'l, ,'.:,M.'l.or,l m..kl,».n, rolVnin.,- to .1... above .naxun. Ha„l: "',; ;.. upoa lanU.K.n. an,l 1 .1 lou... .ha. .h..,. a... ...an, , ,, ; , ,„,i,ie.. .0 ,1.0 sun,.. olVo,.: lu., .l.at .ule l.a. bo.u u,..lo.-...h ! L IK..... a,. ol«,..i... u> .lo one of two >hi..,s you .......0. ,• ra.-, ' ;,M .lo ,l.o ,.tlu..Ml.i,.,^: II..- olo,..io.> .....o ,..a,l.. .> I...all.v ...a,!.. ,:...' or a w..i. ,.l:u>..i... .-.issio,. of ....n.,-. was a ,l.fin. . o.,io„ l,v ,h- plain.iil .o avoi.l ih. ,.oa..a-,. an,l a..,.o..ln..jN .h.. ... ..,;.lvv,'.„^a,a„ u„.o,,l,o,o,„p,.,.vh.>,l,a,,o,p.O,,..,l..- ,,.„„„■. T a.,.i>no, .vponMoaappeal.l.... :h,Molbw,a. Jappea,-s in ^U' .opo.. ahov- .Ce.-.o,! ...: • Tho (our, ol App.al ::::,:!.,Mh..a .,..i..'Mon.h,.i,ii,...ha,,hoiss., ,h. .,w..^.. ,,.„i„i,ivo ..h..-,i..n to ros,i...l, a.ul that this ole.l.o.. was „o, th<. .M.l.^i'.pK'i.t voii..;.- a, ,hL. ...e.-ti.ig." Tl.i. > .s .loa.- ....oa^h. a,.,l ,ho .„U- was ,o,o,.,lv a,„-a o.. .y \V,i..h,. .) . i.. To>„lnrsr.,.e. 1S.,.H, 1 ( h. MM; Im, .ho l.'a.,..a ,,...U;. ,,,::.rs ,o havo .lo,.b,...l " wl.,..!.o.. ,ho . oart ■aoa,,, '" '»-';'"" ';' , . so ah.ol..,oly as is s,a,...l i.. -he -u-u. ,0 ,ho repo.- , .s, .ow .,,„, .um.uh ,0 soo how so «on-s,.„loa a .-,.10 .-..M 1.0 la..i .low., o'li.'.wiso ,haii ahsol..l<"ly . X .l,a...l,oMo,- who, al,.-r a,-,o.wa.a> 1,0 .......lod ,o ,o.,-,...l .., ,.,.,,.,, ,.,■ s,..;,o M.l,s..,p.o,.,ly ,lis..ovo.ca ,uis...pr.-s....,a„o,. lo. ;■! 'uv .1 . /.o.,/. ..,/ /Vor. ro.. .-..-, 1.. T. .;:..; /^nW, /.-.. /' ' " K,v' I "l .(....o, IH8S. Soo. howovov, Cnn^Ml v A /.•/'"".'/• ' a!',V k' ly. a.„l as ,o va.ia...o i., ol-jcts. s..o WhUchnn.^rH .:um'. ' li' ,1a. sl,a.oi,ol,lor olo,-,s ia .l..o ,i...o a.,.1 ... pn.po.' Tor,,. ,o ,,vol,l ,1,., ,.o,.,.a, , . i. is avoi,lo,i ...,o,^o,h..r. a...l the c.se .ta.tJs as .. tt ha, „..vor hooa .aado: ar.onli..-ly. ho ca..nol ho l.lar.-d o„ ,1.,. l.s, ., ... ...iw;! i.M.mtio.' to,' ,1.0 ioutiai , .s avonloU roi.,r.h»lo.ios, cvoi. as a pix.s, .at a.i't. • , , , ,•,,„„ „,, ;,;,,„. ^Vri,,|,rs rosr, V> K,, :U1 ; 7 < h. :. lo.al l'--^-^ l,v a ..ha.ol.ol,lo.- ,0 havo his oo,.,.aot i-os,.,..,locl a...l h.s .o..c> ,..,a,-..oa. ho will ho j.ivo., i...e.e.st tho.oo.. ahhoagl. ao .a.^e ot 1,-,.,.(1 1,0 ostal,li-l.o,l luirlM'rus mse. (18'.»;$) 3 Ch. 1.. Unt ia all tho.-o ..as.'s. what I.or.l .I...s,i,r T„...o.' .-ai,l iu J,',,,,,,.!^ V nron„hton. .". I) M & O. ll>.l. H.., sl.oahl ho ho...e .a .u.,„l ■ M,l,o,..d, i, is tho ,...doul.,o,l -lu.y ..f this Coar. .o .ol.ovo porso ,s .via, l,a^o l.ooa do-oivo-l by f,iLse roprese.,tations. it .s oqua Iv , „■ ,1,,.^ of ,1.0 CMTt o bo oa,of«l that, in it.s ,mxioty to .o.-.oct frau.ls. i, doo- ..ot oaahlo persons who have joined othe.^s .n spo-,.htt.ons ■m Lrrouiulf* l"'»r :ivoiu' IllttTot. 04 ■202 PK08I'KCTir81'>l. ii Actiim ui decteit, nr uiidi-r Direi torn' Lialiili A.'t. IH!((i. What tM prcvc [CUAl-. III. to uunvui't their H^KXMilutioiih into (M-rtuiiitie^ at th*> e\|iiMiNu of ilio^u with whom thev have joined.'' Action oi Deceit or other Remedy. A (loi-bou whu han Iwi-ii iiidiiced Uy liaiiduieiit uiiHrepiuseiitatiou tu Hulwrilie lor fhnre.s, ilclKMituren. or dolpentiire .stock, iiuiy, us an . additional or alteruuiive rained)', hp entitleil to tirinjj an aiiion of 'y deieit u'jruinHt those who liavc deceived liini, or to take proceed! ntr* rt^tainsl them under sect. 81 ol' the Act i_incori)oratin}.f tlie provisidun ol the Uireclors' Liability Act. 18'J0 i, or under sect. 8G i2) of the ,\i i (repidihiciu^ wect. •■> of tlie C()mpuiiie.s .\ct. 190(1 1. Whore those sections u|)ply. thoy jjive to the suliscriher a more effective remeilv than an action of deceit, and have to tliat extent displaced tlie reinedv olituinalpje! in .such an action: hut there are still a considerable nunibei of citscs I see infra) in which the statutory remedy is not available, and in all such ca.ses it may be nece.SNarv to have recourse to the old remedy by action of deceit. It will therefore be convenient to state here, concisely, .some of the ))rincipal rides applicable in the case of an action of deceit. " In an action of dec«'it ... it is the duly of the |)laintilt to establish two thintrs: lirst, actual fra\id which is to be judjred of by the nature and oliaiacter of the representations made, considered with refereuco to the object for which tjiey were made, the knowle fornmlated as follows: The plaintiff must prove — ('al That the defendant issued, or authorized the is.«ue of, the pi'ospectus or notice, or .sanctioned its issue, or that the misrepn-sentation relied on was made by the defendant to those who issued the pro-sjiectus with the intention that it should be u~ed for the purposto of the pro ^ctus. (b) That the prospectus or notice contaimnl a misrepresentation of a matter of fact. (01 That the fact misrepresented was a material fact. (d) That the plaintitl wa.s induced by such misi-epre.sentation to euKscribe or buy. (0) That the plaintitl has sustained damoge. {^ij That the defendant made the misrepresentation fraudulently . INTKODUcrOKY NOVKI*. , . 1). -MX: r.lasier v. /f..//«. U ( D^ ••' • '^ I7C I) .101; Am.xv. //a.v'"■'>" ^ , -.rlUtu., T1.CV could bo int.rro,^at.xl. it .•< true aud wo« 1 h iuT^ li.ion to .lony re.pousib.li.y . Eu.n U a d.roc or ,lonuMi ; L .,v d.n..> n.i.l.t bo forth-onunsr ( .g.-ihat he <'- -''"'^;; P^- ' ut or concurred in the aUot.non. • whi.h .ould c.untervad ,u denial Soo Peel: v. Dm;,. 37 C Div. 541; (//....t ^- flolUf E., -;. //-.'/— V. 7.co«. r, E,. 21.... n... .u ,ho ab«on^> of lomo Lch evidence he waa not liablo. U «//. v. .U/n».so», 8 T. L, R. ''t . that a copv of everv ,.n.iK3ct«s i. ro.,ui,vd .o bo tiled. ■ si.nod ,,v„vorv person who i.s namml thcroin a. a di.e.tor or propo...! 12/ J the con,>a„„ or by hi. a.o„t author. .^.u wr. n., .oct 80 (21 of th.. Art ., the nrnttor ..s frreatly snnphlio.ome hnn or tompauy ,,, f ti,- Zo! n .^. or on behalf of the oUn,, of the .hares debenturos. ,.r ..r... a..- ^ ilei'l^turo .to^k orto,^! for subscription or «ale, there .^ rarolv anv litfipultv in Brovini? the issue by the tinu or company. ., , „ Whei" prospectus i. i..u^ on behalf of a company w.th U.e Co;,;,».v u.thoritv of thedirectors actdn- a-^ its agents, the company J'^- 1" P"'^* isK,.,. l,v „„ that fooUnsr see su/rra, pp. .56, 3- et .stq. , unicss uiu p lo.t his right to repudiate his shares; tor it :s now ^ettl^l t»-t '.n uUottc. of shart^ cannot keep the shares and al^o olain. damages as ..gainst the company , Honhh>rorfh v City of GUis^ww Rank, o App 'V'L third party may make himself liable. Thus, if A. (..,. ^a r..„.,^. promoter of a company) makes false representations to B. and u. ^^,^^,,,i^.^ \e n directors of a company), with the intenrion that such represen- tations shall be embodied in a prospectus of the ^I^P-/ '-!^"? public subscription. A. may be held liable, in an action of deceit by i !i »i ■ '.>'] •,'04 ^ail h.iiiti'M'i'.i' if ■tu- taticn ,11. to • xi^tinu'" I'act. NMll-.lis- I'l.'uHPKCTUHM. rcii.vi'. m. ol'.-urli t'aUc rfjiri'M'nt.i- .1 ,V II I ; .i|)|iiii\/.i;/, 'J IWk\. (iiinuii. I. » •; II I. Il:l; mikI «. 1 \XW\ 1 (,l IV .'.TJ. .178 U('.'*|Hiii-iliililv lui II iHi-ri|irc>i'iiliUii'ii iiia\ aN'i In' liniiiriil In laliliciition, for a \>>\\ iiia\ lie lalilifil. i iiihr \. SI. }f.iri/ Ahbol'.s \isliy I llHili., lil .1. I' .■>!«; ( l"rk .V l,irilil t',8. lilt. Ill; I'.iiiuiiis l.i'Lral Maviiii-. I'.t S .1. ;!I7. Il iiiiimI al\\a\>. Iiowcmm. lie Ikiiim- in mind wlial tli<' liiiiclinn ot a pi(j*i|i(Mtii.~ i- 'I'll!' i<'|ii('.^cntalliin- lonlaincd in it arc nuulc witli n view ol iiiiliiiiiiL; |ici>oii.- to applv tor ami tako from llio minipanv the shnri's or ^cciiiitii'- lli('n'|i\ ollcrcil lor ^iilixription. and aciordiiiKlv it i> llioM'. and llio-.> only, wlio .>o upplv ami take ii|> -liuro^, who arc cntillod to rely oil llif .-liilfiuciitN and to coiinilain if they are iiK (irrcil. Ilrrin' a pirsoii who, after rcadiii'^ the jirospoclu.', liiw- houjrli! .«liaie- in tiic niaiki't i- not juiinii /«(•/<• entitled to lomplain IWL- V. (.111 III!/. I.. K. ti 11. L n;i; WorUi'i nmr. I Drew, :>2'J. So llio .«tali'iiu'iiis in u rejiort to the Nliurehohh'r^ in f;eiieral ineetin;.i- 1 iiinot priiiii'i iiirir lie relied uii hy a suloiTiher a^ indnrinj: him to -iilisoiilio Mtnl's fttui'. :\ 1). 11 A- .1. •187. They are nut made to /)/'*//. Where, however, it is proved that the pro^peclus was iu fact intended to iiidn-e people to liuy in the market, tlioii those who i-.sucd it may be hehl respon.«il)li' to tlio-e who act on it. Anilri'im V Mockjoril. (^IS'Jtii 1 Q. 15. :!72. .la to (7;V--The inisropresentalion relied on must he a misrepre- .-entatioii of some existing: fact. See as to this, supra, p. 190. In the ciuse of an action for resii^sion, the non-di-closurc of a material fact is sulHcieut to entitle the ))laiutilf to relief; but iu tiie I'ase of an action of deceit, non-disclosure is nof enough, uuless it renders what is stated false, and so fraudulent. " Mere non-disrlosure of material fact, however morally censurable liowever that non-disclosiire mii>:ht bo a ground in a proper proceed- ing, al a proper time, for setting aside an allotment or piirciia.se of share."!, would, in my opinion, form no ground for an action in tlie nature of an action for misrepresentation. There must, in my opinion, be some active misstate-nent of fad, or, at all events, sncli a partial and fragmentary statement of fact as that the withholding of that wiiich is not stated makes that which is stated absolutely false." Per Lord Cairns, /Vc/r v. (Itirneij. L. K. (> H. L. M):\. Aaron's licdsv. Ticixs, i; 189(0 .\. C. 273. " Kvervbody knows that soin<>liine^ half a truth is no ijetter than a d'.'wnriirhf fuNehood " Per Lord Macii.Tijhlen in tiluiksh'hi \ Barnes, iltiOO) A. C. 240, 2.'.1. .\nd see A.kiiright v. Sewbnld. 17 Ch I). .■!20, and Dernj v, PtvV.-, 14 App. Cas. 359. ■' Though a person may be dei^iived by another with the knowledge of a third |)ersoii, if that third pei-son is not |)arty to tjie deceit and IM'KoUL'UroKY NOIM. •.'o.-» iiwus 111) k'isiil duly ui' ubli);iiti(iii to lla' {turmoil decouoil, .tail (J>>ri4 iictliiii;^ but )>ie.- laiiiiul In' held liaMi' in ni\ .iiituu tor duiiiatfi'" ill tlio iii»lam«' ol' llii' paitv dtMi.'i\ud Miii itlmiii V. WKirii. «!' L. T. 41J, iK'i Kuii'oi, .1 A-* tur as I know. niIimih' lia-^ lU'M'i _\»'t Im'imi licld In uiiiouui I" miiiepit-oiitalioii." I't'r .Iomv. .1 . \u Snliluii \ . Snrlh I'.n.^lii ii >iilt I ,j.. y\'.iii:>) I cii. .laii, a.i.'i .!» to If) -I I mu»l bi' -liouii lliul llio iiii>)t'|iii'«oiilatioii »,i» NrmiMl 1 1. 1 Miali'liul. It i" not ovoiv mi^i<'|irt'-.<'iil;ilioii lliu! y:iv»'> a iii;lil ul' ,1' Hull A iiii'^laltMiii'iil.' u^ .It'-sfl. M. |{ . said, in Sitiilli v < hnihrnl, .Jii ( li I) Ki 1. iiiiiy Ih' SI) iiivial a< tliat fli<> Coiiil will In- <>( .]iiiiiuii lliat ii loiiid !in| lia\(" allcrlcd ii»> plailititrs mind ill nil. "v inijiiccd liiiii to t'liH'i into the coiitruii ' Kof iiii-n'|iH'M'iilaliiiii- nliiili liivi' Ikm-u lit'ld iiiiili'iial, .-<■»■ .•'K/i/k. |i|i I'.til l','^ .Ixtinih. It liliist Irt' slioHii tlial iht' jrlaiiilil) was iiidlHi'd li\ siicli Suli^.iil 1 1 iiiisii>|ii(>-cnlalioiis lo subsiiil (' or Imy (Icin'rally. llio |)laintitl I,',',,,'',',"'.,',! '•* -uiMi» to the tail, and when the iili»i('|iii'Tiilalioii is .natcii il. and ii i~ ~li(i«ii tlial liic |daiiitill took ^liarc^in response lo ihe |ll•o^I)el•l^^s. It i- a lair int'ereuce ol' I'act tliat he was inuuicd by the |)rospeiius In subscribe. Siiiilh \. ('h'uliviil:. !• -Vpp. ('as |87. /{riliinin- \ lliml. 211 eh. U. I: \asli v. CallUnrpe, cllMKn 1 Cli. sr, . and .-ee ilii> nli«ervalinns of Lord Halsbuiy in Marlfu)/ v. Tail. ( IS'Oti i A. (' :;i, .y«/»n;, p. l.-'S. As to wliut is sullieient to prove or netrative reli- iii'e on the iiiisrepre.«eiiliilinii. see xiiiirn. y\). IHI. I'.l-'i. .\ |iiaiiilill nun >iuci'i'd e\en where llie misrepresentation ix'lied on was not th" Mile iiiiliiri'aienl to sub-uripti'-n. luliiiii'ilnii \. h ihniiiiirnf, 2'.t I . I>i\. 4-V,i; t'ailiiui V. I.Diuum urn'. Li-t'dx Itiinl;. "ii! I. 'L' IIV /'(./, V. l>i-i>!i ;i7 c. I»iv. :,\\: Aniiv'ii v s„iit)i. II c I). ;tiH .l.^' Id I <• I - I iiless daiiiu;ie is >hjwii. liie plaiiilill )ia~ no liLffit lo |).ii,,.,j^, iiiiiplain. Smith v. Cluidirirl.-. '.> Apji I'a-. IM7, folliiU \. U ,(//,•; . »>"'»ii- ■1 r> iV Aid. 111. When u |.ersoii is indini'd by tiaiid in a prospcriu^ t" II) ply t'ni vhaies. the lo^- is susiaiiii'd iis xmhi a- he |i,iii^ with lii^ III 'lux Ani.ls()ii V Sniilli. 11 (h. I). IKiii. .1.- /oi/i Fraud by the delcMdaiil nin-l be eMaMi^hed II i^ nl Frsu.i. • llii' '■— eiit-e of the a'tion. And it is osiablisjii'd Alien ji i^ ~liouii ill lliiii the i-epie,eiilalion relied on was fal-e lo tlir Iciiou Iniye i.l llic defendan;. or i2> that ii u;is made b\ llie defendant l■el■kle-^ly . villinii' laiiiiir whether it was une or fal-e. o* , .! • iha! llie delendani <\i'i 11"! ill fa. I believe i' lo bi- inir. I)<,iii \ I i-i-l:. II -\|:p. (a •i-i7. The la^l all< rnntive. in fail. i..vci- b.iil; ihe u'li r-: and, ur'jurdiiejrly. in an ai lion of doi-oil, the h ili.il iiiii-l iie | lovc.l. ill order to establisli that a false statenionl w,.^ frauduleirK ;iiiide. i- liial liir d(>leudarit did not in fui i believe that 'he maleniunl \\a>- true .V)(iiUi him "(If dwcivifl. Limitatio of tmit i. rKotiPEcrieiKs. rCiiAP. III. Niitt.' till' (litloruiicti ill tliut roK(M3i i ix'luorii ail mliiiii 111 iliMHil ami uii iiiiiori for «'M(is(.i(»ii, in wliii'li iti liiul tiaiiil iio'il nut liu .^Ikiwii And MoU' t'liillu'f thu liillcicm c in tlio cii>i' oi iiiiii-iiiiu|i1iiim. i- mill un\ iif tilt" n'.|uirt'iiituit(i of -ocl H\ nl' ilic (■()iii|iuui<>H Vet. liinN III the oaso (if nwt. 81, lu) tlioiv i" tin liuliilil\ uiiiler llir ^rrlum Im i-i!i*lo-"nr(> if tlio aiu"!) tioiii an >iakt> of fail; 111' 1 1' I wluMo I lie noii-i iiiii|ilianr(' riiii»i-.t.s in n.n ;il\Ultr full parlii iilaif of a diit'iloi'i iiilvicxl in inoiiiolinn or |ii |n'iiy ari|niit'il li> I Ik' ri>iii|i.in_\ . kno\vlud}.'<' of llic iiiailcr-^ mil •! iiik'-i-^ It !-• pi A Sci'l. HI (til ■il I lull ho li.iil Sot' siiiiiii. I' i: If, in an ai'tinii o t .li' (let! an |irov<' lliat III Ix'iit've the sialoiiii'ii I III lie II III. Liiiiiill iiiii^t tail, iHi'ii tlioii'. llial till' L'liiund-i on wliii li iIk." Ut'lii'l wa^ foiiii Ivd iiiiica^iiiialilc Till- was d>'ci(l<'il liv tlu' lliiii-<> V. I'rcl,-. If \\)\>. I'lV*. .'1:17 iini'i-intr tin ol l.iiViN in /'<■; if I III' I Ollll Api il .\. ;liek"- run 'iiU'tatioii of lilt' i::iiiiiiiil> of lii'li dmilil, an iiiipoi'taiil iiul in ii~iortaiiiin(j uliotln'i tli< Iii'licf Wii- I A iiii 111 -i luoit) assertion thai Im'Ii ' of leasonalile ground fm a*, in spite of his assortioi , to rarrv i oiivii linn to ilie rill it he had not reiillv the belief illejrod. l.onl •II. ih. I'l' .!;!!), .W l-'iaiiil limy be e.stabli.shed when the reprosentali hdi lull- belief iliat it wi true. d hofo ilmi Iti ■ made III tlie par ho Miaile it tiiids nut that il was milriie an I reii laiiis silent P. l.i.nl HIaikbiirn, li, ia.~e ilie ilirerioi' v/Zi iirht III ('iitniilifll. •) App. Cxs. '.I. lO li a|i|i||i a' loll wa.s lia.-i' TIk' Olllv lliiiii; ' We caniiol eonlrad with the ;xi'ntle- i| nil a iiiisHtatonient iiiiihoii/od by iis to do l.s to tell hini Ih.il the prospect ii> i.s erroiieiiiis. and thai we lannot a<'ee| It hi Wi Mill ileii'ive, III ihli'lsDii \ III 'I'xiiU \ li, i,>i reiii'ii his niniiev. s applicalion. IVr Paire-Wood. V.-( 'I- lM'.I; and see the remarks u f Tun I, .1 mil. » I), .1. A S. ;U8. Iv III till' jK'riiiil of littiilnlioii in iin iirtioii ul ih'ci'it. Havin;; ill' In 21 .laf. 1. r. 11). an uelioii of dereit i.s jirhiiii fnric barred ii'oiiirlil wi thill voa. from the time when the iau.se ol : I ISiil when ihc ))laintill tihow.s that he did not disi over. ilili il di; the frami iiiiiil within ~i\ yeai> I friiiidnleiit iitoM' the ai lion, and that the e\isleiire of .siicii fraud wa- l\ romealed bv the defendant until within the «i.\ voui>. tune will not run till >uih discovpiy . (iihlisx. t,iiild. '■> (^. H. 1). ■"'!'; and .sef> Kr McCidluni. i 1901) 1 (Ti. U.i. Xo delay in brinfrinjr an atlion of deceil Khort of that lixed by the statute will bar ihe u'tion. I'cil: v (iiiniey, L H. ti H. L. .'!77. IMKoDiJCTOKV MriKS. tW .1-. lo .tr.iti, „r biiHlMuptcif. -On ilio .lo.illi ..i l.aiikni|.tcv ol a iMiihur l«'i.-uii ill whom ilicM.' is vi-siod a liyln oi a, lioii (<>r rruuiltilcni iiii»- '■ '"'■'■"1"' > .M'liluti'iii wli.Tfbv Ui' ha- |n-(i i.io.iov. ihi' liHfhl ol a.iiaii pii>..st>« !i.f™ud!^| in lii- h'-al |i."i-i>ii.il ii'iiu-.-iilulivp!* Ml ini-ti'c in iMiiikiupIi v, .w th»> .;i,-.. liiav h.t I Tiri/imss v ^■rrl(//, t (' I' Div IDi. hul .Huhject to lh>' t:.'i]t (he a|>|iliial)i|ii\ ,.l ilial ml.' i-. I. a- iho wmiiir-loii .i .'.-latf piolil.Ml \,\ ihi' wr.in:.'- Il i! liaw. the .•\.tiii.,is .m adniiriisda- i.ii>,,t a o,l 11 i tlih'ss sharo- in a ronipaiiy lor .'.III/ and (■laiiMOolongo .. Slate mipht have licnedted h\ tho wron;,', and that the .lama;.'*'- were moii<> the lo-> unlicpiidat.'d and uncertain from the fact 'hat A miy^hl lie iihle lo prove that the measure of his >laiiiat;es wa- thf amount of tho purehase-monev . !{,■ Ihiiniin. Tiiri/ \. Sweflimi IH!l!»i I Ch .•|«7. .\s III hniil.niiitr;/ Demands in the nature of imli.pii.hih'd i',.„,,f ii, ilamattes. ari>iii<_.' ollierwi-e than hv reason of a ronlraet, piomi-u. or I'.iukrupKy. Iiroa.l, of Irnsl. are not provalde in liankniphv. Seel. ;17 ( I I of tho liankrnpt.v Act, IHH;!. Honce. damasres ior" frau,|uleni misrepre- -iitaiiori l,v a direetor are not provable in his hankriiptev, iinle-.s tlitn have been ascortained hv judirmetit obtained before th",. re.yiv- 111- nr.Jer //,• .\rmninn. .} ('. I), tit); (ir,;-uwimd v. Ilnnihrr <1 to. VnrlHiiith, W. X. (1898) Itil'. Hut if jiid^rmoiit Jia*i been obtained tlioy aro pro\ahle. Einw,i >'Viv, Mhi.Di, Co. V. Grant. 17 Ch. I). 122. If not provable the, .lie no! evlin"" '/vr iiartr ( ,,k,r. 10 C'h. 1). (;,-,;(. i Qun,,; if ho did not, "liother the Statute of Limitations would not run apiinst him Hie iiiea.~.,,e of dainaees is the liilleience bolweeii the amount paid \h:isny. ..f ■lie shales and tlieir then \abie, i.e., iiii lediaiely after aHotmcin ' i"i.i>f"s This value is not ne.trssariiv the inarkot • for the allolt4>e is not iiuiid t., M.|l nn. inari' value always rue wilue. The true ■n*^'- •? 'he lif,'lit of Mu queut events showin-.' • 1 1 % 20H l'Rt)(iliT\ t'n prosptM-tui-. Sett. 81 ol ilic Ac) \a\n's tlii' phut IS'.tO It llCh.^ lliii.~: l;irt. vi llio Uiro(lor.<' Liubilitv Act. 84. -(1.1 WliiTi' u iini^iicit 'lrl)cntiirc^ "f a i(>ni|);iiiy. every prr* of the H«ui> of the prospei til- ii> invite" |i('rs aiiiini; of him iiml is iiameil in the priMiieetus us a diredor 11 who U a director of the eonipany at th^' and every person who him authorlui'd the or as having' aureeil . h< • a ilirector eitlier iiiiniediately or after an in tervul of time, and ei of thi eomp; ry p. ,vh • debentiin-s. as fhe case ma and. V be. belii . I.) With respect to eveiy ni itriH- -tatcmi'iit purporting' to be a statement h> or cimtaincd in what purports t o be a CO py of or extract from a rciM v.iluatii of an expert, that it fairly represented the statement, er orrect anil lair cojiy of or extract from the report or vatiiatioii Provided that the director, person nam persi'n who authorized tin pay compeiLsation as led ilirci'tor, pi of thi' prospectus, shall be liable t" aforesaid if it is proved that he had no reasonaM. 1(1 to believe that thc> person makimr the statemi'nt, report. ..r valuation was com pet ent to mak It ; III, It) With rcspci •t to everv iliiliu.- -tateiiiciit |iur|« to b; ide by an official of or extrait fmi piibii ruiitainci "tHeill I in what purports to bi dociinicn piirpi t, that it was a id Im in seiitation of lie- statement, or copy of or extrai ■t fn the document. it IS pro •d (i) that, havinir consenti d to become a director 'if tic onipany, he withdrew his consent before the issue of the prospecti it was issued without his au anil tli.i! uthority or consent, or (U) ''i''t the prospectii ■d without his knowlclu'i' or coiisiiu, and that, on beeomiiii; awan , he forthwith (rave rea.-on is-uc knowliHlire or consent, or (iii) lalili pu ibii. olice that it was issicd withonl lii that after the issi f the prospectus, and bcfurc allntl lit thereunder, he, on becomimr aware of any untrue statenien it till withdrew his consent thereto, and pav<> reasiin.able public noliii diawal, and of the reason therefor. of the will ri.) Wi ere iiisimpaiiy ex laling 1 thf L'iircrnth d.-iv of .\::u'n'f. ciL'lit hnndred and iiinciy of obtainin^r fnrthi' ll •d share- or deb. id for the pur|" .ital by subscriptions for shares or debentures, issues INTKODUCTOKY NOTKS. 20f) l.ro»iioctu<.. ii director shall not 1)0 liable in respect of anv statement therein. unl.ss he has authdrijcd the issue of the prospeetus, or has adopted or ratified it. (.).) Where the prospectus contains the name of a person as a director of the rnmpany, or as havinj; affreed to become a director thereof, and he has not consentcl to be. le a director, or has withdrawn his consent bcf.ire the Issue iif tlic prospectus, and has not authorized or consented to the issue thereof, the directors of the company, except any without whose knowledge or c.nscnt the prospectus was issued, and any other person wlio authoriz.il the issu.' thercf shall b.. li.ible to indemnify th.' person named as aforesaid aijainst all damai,'.-s. ...sts and cxpen>,-s t.. which !..■ may b.' nia.l.. liabli' by reason ..f his „,„„e UnvwK been inserted in th<- pr..sp,.ctus. or in d.^f.^ndini hims..|f a-ninst any uition or le;;:!! pr.x-ei'dinirs bniuirht against him in respect th.^n-of. (1. Kvcry p.rson who by reason of his b.inif a .lir...tor, ..r nanoil as a dire, tor. or as having' a^-rc-d to b.M-.mie a dir.'.tor. .ir ..f his havin;; aotliori/.,..! th,- issu.. of the prospi.tus. b,..on.,-s liable to mak.' anv p.-.vm.-nt und, r this sectuin. may r.-eover .-..ntrilMilion fr.uu any oth.r p.rson who. if su.-d s.parat.lv """''' '""'■ " ''•'''!'• f" niake th.. sam.' payment, nnl.'ss th.. p.-rson wh,. has b.s-..m.. s., hablc was. and that other person was not. -uiltv of fraudiil.nt misri'prcsi'ntatiou. iH. ■ i'",ir th,' purposes .if this si.i'tion The cxprcssi.in ■• pr.im„tiT •' ni,.ans ., pn.iiiot.T wh,. was .-i party lo th,. lovparMti,.,, of th,. pr„sp,.,i„s, .„. „f ,|„. ,,„„i„„ th,.r..of ..ontainint: 111., untrue stat..m.nt, but docs n,,t ir,..|u.li. anv p..rs.,n bv nas,,,, „f |,i, a.trn;.- in a prof..ssional .apa.ily for persons enu-a-d in i.ronrin- the birniation of th,' cuiipany. ■ ,.xpressiun " ..xp.rt " inelu.les ..ni;iu,.,.r. valu,r. a,.,„untant. and any oll.i.r p..rs.,n whose pr..f..ssi.u, ^nv.s aulh.-rity to a statem.nt nia.l,. bv hilii. Indemnity where Dame of perN.tn has be*.|i improperly insert,.,! as a director. Cmtribution fr,)m ro- ,lirct.tor*. &,■ Til, l-;'"liih-i.l llu. iMl<..|,n>tali<,ii.s,.,.|i,i„ ,,.,..(. US.", . it is .I...,.' that iln.s Nvii,,ii ,. .i„lv , appk t,. |.r,is|„...t„s,.s itiviiii,^. s,il,s,ri|,li„Ms |„r -li :n-,.>. ,l,.|i,. „,„,,... iir ,|,.| ,„,,. st,i,k .,!• , niiipaiii..- Ion,,,.,! „,„!,.,. ||„. .\cl (,1 I'jdH. Th.. >,...(i.,„ has ii.i a,.|.lieati,,M I., lailwav. p-,i.s, «al..i inimnav. ,„■ ,„h..r j.arliaTa.-i.lary .•,ii..pa„i,.s. ,„• t,. fun.io,, .„• ,„|„r,i,,l """l'."ii'~. "V t,i ...)iii|iaiii.vs ii„..„-|,,,ralo.i |,\ ,„val chartor. „r I" ..Muiiauii..s ,,ii,s(it..l<.d In ,1,>,.,1 (if ^..tth'tiiont aliil n,.t hr.m.^ht "iilun th.. oporati...! of th.' Co.i.i,ani.>.s A.I. liMiH. Aiiv ri,.-!,) „f ""■■m umhT th(. ..irrosp.in.lirie; I'r.ivi.si.ms „f ih,. ,vp..al"..n..r,.,l .s,„.h .shan.s Cir p„hli.. sali^tiptj,,,,, it w.mM s„„,„ ' i^'t Ih,. ,s,.,t,„„ „„„|,1 ,„„ „,,,,!,. ^,,,,1 ,„|,,„,,i|,„,,,, ,„„,, ,.,i„ ,.,,|^ ,,,^ 111" '.;i licial \n\\ II'" >ii.hitn..nfall.v altors Ih.. hnv as t.i tho .■..n.s,.,,,„.„,.,.s " miM-..p,.,.s,.„,ati,.r, i„ |,r,w,„.,.,„„.. i„viii„o- >„hs..,i,,ii.,„s |„, ->i-nv^. .l..hi.nturo.s. or .IoIk.,.!,,,.. st,„.k. It ,1,,,., „„, ,,„,,„,,, „^ ""'•nipt 1,1 all,.r ..r o.xtoiul Hip rtMiio.l.v ml„nl,.,| l.y the a,li„ii of ■ ece,! !t ♦■•sfa!,li.slu..s a iirw aiki uiudi ni„iv t'lVtvliiai foiiicly. • The •^" Mil, which the pifsuiit. .sooti.Mi is l,a.sass,.,| ■ v,v..s »"/(Mis.llar,ly, L. ,1., i„ McCoHneU v. \Vri,,ht, , l!»(.;t i 1 (h .H.l A, t only upj)lit.s t,> ""iiipaiiic^ uiiiler Coin- paniis Act, UMIS. Sul>-w.ot. I jL'iM.H new remwiy. m if- ivi •JKi PROSPECTUSES. [Chap. III. (Jiiistiona under [*ub- -iict 1. \VliO may be sued. Director. as director. 1*1011101 cr. 558, "in 1890, the voar .atU>r I>erk v. Dcrry t^U App. Cas. 337;) had betMi decided in tlie H(ius<> .>f Lnnls and, us it sccui'! to inc. for the expreis.-* purpose of fretting rid of the olVect of tliat deci.'i become a director of the <'omi)any, either immediately ..i after an interval of time. ^.•}; Kvery promoter who was a parly to the |)reparalion iie lu.i- sjiectus, or of the jiorlioii thereof KUilain . ■ iiiruc stutenieut. I 4) Every person who has authorized the issue of I actus. (ll ■• DiriTtor ■■ lic-re includes ■•any person oeeu|.yinjr ilie po-ition of dire.t.ir hv whatever name called." Sect. 285. 1 ^f|- ■; iff (■(iriiiinition as I'D'Hi'iter. V.''- As to (3) - The ipiestion whether a hody •■orporate is a iiersou or jiromoLT within this .se( tioii and so callable of l)oing sued, is one of s"iiic dillicullv. Hv sect. l'.> of the liilerprctaliou Act, 188'.i i .")2 .v .i:! Vict. e. (i.-l ', the word - person, " uidess the contrary int<'nliou ajipciii-, is to include any biKly of persons, c,>r|".rut.' or uiiincorporate. N'iw Ihe .scclion make- 'lie i«'ison or promoler liable to pay .oniiiensatioN. unle.s.s, amongst other altornatives, it is pn.ved that ho believed tlif untrue slatomont and hail reasonable grounds for such belief; and il mav be said that a lnjdy lorporaK' is incapable of lielief, and accord- ingly would not be able to prove the facts reiiuisilc for its deleiicc S*-!' rhnriimrciilinil Sucii-t;/ v. l.i,ii.s ivlial-o- • •\ 1 Tlii.s vii'u, it iiiiiv 111- (.iiilcmlod. i> i'i|iinllv a|i|)liral)l(" to llio (ii-c ..| M -latiilc, like tli:it now iiiulcr iiiri-iiili'mlion. uliiili prox idc.i lliui .1 |Mi-.s(.ii shall (io a |iaiii(iilar ail. iniiu'ly. |iav ■ i.iii|)<'risali()ii miN«- li' ..,iii|)lifs with a |>aiti(ulai- «• lilidii. iiaincK. piiiv.'s liclifl. Oj, ill,. oiIh'i hand, it may justly Iw .- id (iiai (•.ir|.niaiiuiis arc within i\v liii.-cliii'l' iiiti'iidi'd to Im- rcincdit'd liy tlin Act., and that tlic wnrds aiv .-.iilliiiiMill\ wide, and shiaild. if |mssil>!(., |)t> held lu covor such li iilii>. hn ImmHcs coriMirat*' may and do act as proniolcrs. and mi^'ht I.. Im .ind ai.' Ii,ild<> for the acts ot' llicir diicctnrs Ltinmnis Silinfi- (', \ l.tiiiiiii,is Siii„i;,;it,', (ISll'Ji :.' eh. ;j;t2i, and tlicif would Im no riMJ dillicully in lln'ir cMal.lishino' a dolVnco since, in tlm ca.s<> of a niridialion. llie htdiof of its airciits actinia in the matter must bo imputed to tlie corporation Iji an action of deceit aj,'ainMt a cor- poraliou proof of it.s ajriMits' liciiof would relieve t Ik- coriiorat ion. See .N"///w. pp .•)■!. .'it ft xfij. Nc al.-o a.s to a limited (onipanx l>ein>< a |iersoii, ' \\ illmott. v. Lndhiii lltiad ( ar Co.. i lulH) 2 Ch. .'lU'y. .\stoi4l - Person The \vords hasaiithori/e inana^^er of a news- paper who authorizes the puhlication of the prospcrlns therein. But it W'lM he absurd to place sii.h a constru.iion on the words 'Pjiov (aiinoi reasonalilv lii> hehl to ap|.ly to such persons as hankers, brokers. accountuiit.s, solicitors, and enyineers wlio inereU i oiisenl to iheii luiiie.. appeariuL' as mk h in the prospectus. Lord .\lv<.|stonc. «lieii .Vlinnicv-Ceiierai, and Lord Davey when .it the l.ar. both .so adM.scd; anil the ,-ectioii it.self distiniruishes between authority to luiine and authority to issue. It is >, iil,ed. and that ''"' i"'"' "1 1- llie initial piiltino- forth, or launching of the doeii- ineiit. and not the subsecpient distribution of it. Ill the case of a diivctor there is seldom aiiv ditliculi\ in -howin.»):',, \ (h. j«i;. allhiiicd .IS .s//, '/,//, ■(//■(/ \ . lliiKiiiit', infra. 1! Wiiiii iy ■■,( .shifi'iiiciil" ir, III III till' .■ii'iliiiii' \ii oidinaiy slatenient of fact, <>.ctus. or by reference iiiKii- polatwl theiviu or i.s.sued therewith, but not iiuulo by or contained in what purports to be a coi)y of, or extract from. a report or v.ilualion of an e.\pert. (21 .\iiv untrue statement in any such report or memoran.lum pur- porting lo l)e a statement by or contained in wliat purport.- to 1* a copv of or extract from a i-eport or valuation "f a" •■Xpert, where it is proved that the director, person named, promoter, or other person who authorized the issue of lli" prospectus or notice, had no reasoiiabh' ground to bclunc that the person making the statement, report, or valuatiu" wiis competent to make it. " Expert " here includes engineer, valuer, accountant, and m\) INTRODUCTORY NOTES. 213 Wli(» limy Hilt' iiinlcr HtM't. :J r SuhwribtTH • 111 f:iith of other person -whose profeaaion {/fives authority to a htatoinciii luado bv him. As to reports, see Re Reese Silver Mining Co., 2 Ch. A))p. fil I ; h'owlinny. Wi/^kh/im. a D. G. & .1 . .'t()4; AH. -Gen. v. Ha;/, 9 Cli. Ajip. Id-'. II.; Briliuli litiniuih Latut Co.. .ili I,. T. Kl.j; Ani/iixw ('liliiird. :\\>\\. K. L'J2: (1891) 2 Ch, U'J. As to thp lial)i!ity of oxporl-s for falso or nof^liiri'iil roporls. -ci' (nil II V. \yill.ctiis.'' Tliesi; words ;^.v(' a riy^ht of action for loiiijicnstilioii to cvi'i \ >ii( li )iri>oii. It is pn.'suiuod that the word ' sid)scrili(! " nioaiis apjdx fur and accept any allotniont from the cMini|)aiiy ' This is the usual set. o ill whicli the word "subscribe'' is used. Un.\.t v. Estates Investment ( II.. :i Ch. Eij. 2.)8; Arni.-'■ on behalf of the c<'iiipuiiy. but by or on behalf of some jierson. ii i, or coinpanv uho or which had previously become owners thereof, w hother by allotment. oi piiichuse; e.g.. suppose that a company is formed to aci|uire a liiisiiiess. and that the consideraticm for the acquisition of such biisi- iic.-s includes lOtt.OOO/. of debentures, and that the vendor, after lioMin;.' ihe.se d r.^nturos for a time, sells them to a trust conipany or hank, which in its luni olfers them for public subscription or sale. Ls the .-c. lion to ajijily to sucii a case? For the reason already slated ahcvc il is submitted thai it is not. If it did. this anomalous result «iiuld follow, lluit directors and others who have had nothine ...lernative defences contained in the hnier pari of .siib-,sli.'six|UPntly uctinl as ii iliri-itor. tliat wmild 111' coiiiiiliTcd /-/./«" /"< .' oviHonif of iiutliorify; mid if lie knew ho was so nainrd mid did nut di. \ till' |H.iiiiiii ilii'M'i't ininjiiiiiiii;- lln' iiiiliiii' sl;il('incnt : It i~ ni>t I'Mi-y pri)i|ioti'r wlio i" to Ih' lialili-. \"H imly tlrn-^i- will. niiHldli' witli til! |iios|ii-ctii>. Si'c •'iili-M'it. (li. 1,1, (h ijiiii till' ilclcndMiil Miitlifiii/cil the i.-^iir hI' iIh' |ii(i.<|ifi Ins 2. 'I'liiil lliCK' «ii-- .111 milnir ,>iiitciii(Mil III I 111 the pi-o.-lH'rlu^. In Of in siiiiif r(>|iuil or iiiciiioiaiiiliiiii ;i|i|ii';iriii^ I'li llif liiii' till ii'ol. Ill liv ri'li'icin I' iiiiiiiiioriitt'il lliini'iii of i-^ni'il tlii'icxv illi. A hii.-lt'uiliii-; .-liili'iui'iil is iUi uiilfiif .-uilciiiciii (Ircfiiirood v l.riillii'i SIhi'I \\l,i'iH'n.. vHtO(l) 1 Cli fJl Winn rlw itati'iiii'i' is that tin' |irisi)ii inakiiiir tin- statrnunt lu'lii'viil. anti- cijiatiil. Iiiipi'd .11- iiitfiidi'd w> and so, iir was nf tliis or fliat oiiinimi. it is nut enouirli fm- the plaintilV In prnvc that th.> liflii'f. \r. was not will foundi'il: 111- niu)i.-- V. //wi/c. 2it T I. R 1117. This no doulit im|iurt^ that tlir staii-nii'iit must hp inuti'i-ial. fur otliirw i plaiiitiiV r:iniii>t show loss or daiiia;;i' liy rrasoii of tin- nntrutli of that stat'iniiit. As to wiiat statt'inciits may hi- inatvrial. scp .•.H//,y<. p. IW). 'I'll!' rxpri'ssion •• liy riMsoii of th>' untriii' stiitinnnt." appiar- to no .in hy roa«oii of till- plaintiff lia\ini.' hpi'ii indui'H to part with his nuinoy on tlii> fnitii of snrli nntrtii' stiitonipnt. ihiiuiiof is ail oM-iiliiii l.uioi ill thi> liijiii oi .1. lion, and ilifrffuii! inisft'iifcsciitatioii willioiil daiiiatfi' is not aitioiialilc' IVf Ciilliiis. M. 1{ . in MiCiiniifll \ . Wiiiihl. s-iiiiru Sec also Art*/) \. CiilHinipi'. ( lito:. , L' (Il li.ir. and Miirlinnw T,>il . i \r till' I'lss or (laiiiu;:*' llicy luav liiivc MiMlaiiicil ' liv ica-im >>i l]io iiiitriK' .•\ leusoii of tlio plaiii- lill .< Iiavintr li<'<"ii iridiKtHl l)V the uiilnic statcnirnl to sulisciilic. S<'f iIk- .ju(lf,'imiit ol Culliii.s, M. 1{.. in MrCuHiiell \ Wriiihl siiiira. ",''.i< aiiMiiinl |iri'- . .iiialiiv llic -aiiic a* tliai in an action nf flcifil. iianiclv: tlio dillor- ciK c Ix'lui'cn lli(> ainoiinl |iaial valiio o( ilif ..-liaK'-. (li'lx'nliiK'^. or (It'lMMiiiiic .-loik al the dali' thai tin' toniiiany iiad aLiiiiiit'd ii \aliial)l<' |>i'n|)criy , wliicli it had not in laci a(i(iiirt'd at the date wlicii tiic |H(is|>tMtii'- wa-^ i>.sii('d. and the |iiin(i|il(' on wliiili tin' aiiiuiini of roiii|ii'nsiiiiiii was to lie asrin- taiiipd wa.^ stated liy Collins. M. H.. as follows: it is uol an action lur liriacli nl 'oniiiici. and. tlicicfoic. no daniay:t.'s. in n-spoct of |iros|pc( li\c >;aiiis which the ))i'rsiin <-oiilractiii;r was ciititli'd I'y his iiiiitiai 1 t(i I'xpcct, conic in. Init it i.- an action nf tort . . and llicrcfiin'. iiniiii'i iaiie. tlio hijihcsi limit of lii> damaui'-- is the wliolo extent of hi.-. |os>, and that lo.ss is measured In the iiion(>y which was in hi- piM ivci and is now in the pocket of the coinpan\ Thai is the nlliinale. linal. highest M.iiidard ol hi^ los-- Miit. in so far as he has y:oi an eipii\alent for thai money, that loss is diminished So far as the assets are an eipiivalent. lie is not damayed: so far as they fall short of iieiiie: an eipiivaleiit. in that proportion he is daniaui'd.' In sill li an action, if there lie ati iintiiie s!atenienl of a material chaiaclei .in I daiiiaA-, 1 » App. Cat. 337. (L>. I In the case of an untnio wtatpmcnt purporting to be a stal.>- n.pnt bv or coutainod in what purports to be a copy of, or extract, from, a report or valuation of an en-rinoer. valuer, accountant, or other export. / e., anv person whose profession -rives authority to a statemi.nt. made by him, he must prove that it fairly represented th.. Ntaloniont made by the engineer, valuer, accountant, or other expeii. or was a corr.nt and fair copy of. or extract from, the report or valuation. . Hut this doftMue in respect of a misleading report is not sulhcieiil if the plaintilV can prove ainrniatively that, notwithstanding such untrue statement fairlv represented the .statement made by the expert, or was a correct and fair copy of. or an extract from, the report or vahmtion, such .lirector. person named, promoter, or other person who aulhorized the i.ssue of the prospectus or notice, as afore.sa.,1. had no rea.sonable ground to l«»lieve that the exi)ert was competent to make the statement. I'eport. or valuation. See .l«,minent engineers wer.- in fact prepared for the agent of the veitdor to the company. . :t. I In the case of every such 'iitrue statemeid, puriiorting to be a statement ma.le by an ..ilicial jierson, orcontaine under I lie wilion nuist bt'ar in mind that, if at some future time a statement turns out to be untrue, he may Ix' called on to prove that he had ica.iunable <,'rouiids for believinsr the stateuient to bo true, ami liiul it will then be for a jury or jud}re to decide, not whether the director cousidei^Hl the {^rounds reasonable, but whether such jury or judtre I'onsider that they were rea.sonable. So, too, he must ivmember lluit a mistake by him as to the materiality of a contract re(|uired to be disclose lonsidered in this view, and the following- iiucstions should be put, namely:- What are my ^'rounds for believing the statement to lie true? Do they socm to ine, uoiifliinjr them inipailially, to be rea.sonableV What inciuiries and advice sliouhl I make and take to as(.<>rtuin whether otiiors think them reasonable? Would they be likely to .seent reasonable to a jury or judge? What evidence can 1 preserve to satisfy judge or jury of the rca.sonableness of my belief? It may be well to give cwo or three examples: — 1. Supiiose the pros|)ectus to state that the company is formed to ac()uire a business, and that "the average annual profits of the business during the last five years have been 1I),00()/." The mere lussertion of the vendor that this was the average could scarcely bo considered reasonable grounds for believing the statement in the prospectus to K*'aMitiabI»' l.TtiUIliU '»f (Irffnilullt*!* b.lief. Kxiinipifs. ui .r 21f* PKO»I'ECTlT8ES. [Chap. III. hv liuf. Ill order t" juslit'v lliu stutoiiii'itt, H|)veiiil iitvi>» »liuuld hi> taki'U to tont iU trutli l)> iniloiK'ndfiit ini(uir,\, €!.(/., I>\ tlio einpliiyinout t)f « liruiot'iitil'iiI mi|i|)Iv III uali'i-. Tl lis IS a statciiK lit iili\iiii|s|v iiiattM'ial wliic ill llic ali«'iic<' (if lorsiiiial know lei l;;c. slnuild not In' iiiuiji' witiiiiiM iiiil<>|i<'iiil('iil <'X|i(>ii <'vid<'iiic a Sii|i|Mis»' a larl ad'd wliirli is in tli<' kiimvli'il":!' of illllv llIK* III' IWll I I tin- diicilois, liiit tl- »(> IHTsnll- .1 |;riMiil\ . il lid sft'iii llial lliis liiiulil d III ailniil it'iisoiialiN' jrriiiiiid on wliirli llu' nilicis iiiij^lii i oiniir wiili tti loiii III iiiakiii<:' lilt ■('IlK'lll. Who in all ixi»'rt 'f Wlial all" ri'asoiiahlf irioi;- loi- lu'lioviiiji lliat an i'ii;.'iiii'ri . valuer, ariiuiiilaiil. or other » Mi is i'iiiii|)Ot*>nt ii.r.. iiualilled m lit I to make a siateiiieiit. iciimi. in- xaliialion' This miis| depend on tlie iiiTiimsiame- it tin T leie ale some men ullose euni petoiir d rredil is iN'voiitl dispute, men «ho are at the head m the trout rank ot their pioression: niheis nuiv hold a leioirni/i'.i diploma or rerlill(ali>: lint where a man is not in this position, it nia\ lie nei-essarv to olitaiii miiim' eollateral evideni-e of his iniii- peteiir\ Thus il mav lie \vi II tl itaiii leleicnies to some leadmu- ilier or luemlieis o tl or to soiue piMsoiis ol posiiioii who have em| le |. rotes-ion to w h; hiili the expert lielmi: ■miiliived him and »p( Ills coiiipeleiii V Will ' <'.\perl IS a foreigner, and lliere |s im nine to rommiiiu- ise than l)v lele;:ra| li. with persons in the liiialit\ ti iliicli he lielonL''s. il will 1m' prii|M>i to riimnmiiirale, li\ lelcirraph (ale. oilierw with some lianker or iihi ler I ei-on win n lie trusted in llie Imalitv lid snili person should lie reipiesied to iiii|iiire as to the roinpi a (encv o f II IP expert, and it he r< poll- liv leleir .'iMin lavour alilv reirard thorelo. it is ruiin'ived that sui h inipiiry and report woiili be held to alliird reasoiiahh' (jrriniiids for WHS eompetent lii'vin;r that the expi The nei'i'ssitv of olitainintr and pn-serviii^- written exideiuc ihal reasonalile <>-roiiii( ;it In too stronely imp ssed those who mav lie lalled on to del'end their statements in a \:t"- spei Ills. As to the defendant ^riviui;- partiiiiliiis. Alnuni \ Ojiin-ii. (19(11 I 2 K I! ."i7(; II Willi is nil r.rjiri I ' Siili-s<>ii ilr of seit K4 Uses the expn'ssion expert." and by siib-siM'i I ."i ! llie expression ' (ixp<'rt ' imdndes eiiu:iiieei. vainer, ISTKODUCTlJKV N^»r^a^. !l!> lliiiit«tii>ii. .ictuuiilulit. .iiiil iin\ ollioi' ■i:ei-i<>ir vvliox^ |ii(.tf--'ii>ii /im'* mllm- liu 111 14 III ho iilisorvfil tliul ill*' word ust-U is ' iiruirsHioii." imt liusi- ji,>~ III iHi ii|juti<>ii, " tliul iililiouuli till' iiifuiiiiiij; nl' tlif wonl ii« ^luU'il ill Jiiliii''iiii iiiid cl-cttlioiu ti) Ih,' Mtiutioii, kiiiittii (•iii|ili>v- iiiciil. 11 mm Ik' duiilili'il wli<'tli. I;ihm'i>. and ijiHiur- Siiiciv, lim. ill Imiikiiiu iiih!H>im ii liaiiki'i i-* I" lin . nii-idi'ii'il an »'\ivii williiii lin' dclinilinii. .1 lircwi'i in Ihimmhh uiiilli'i-. n ;;i'iicial iiiiiiiii^i'l "I a railwa\ in iiilwax nialli'i-. miiI a l.iwM'i «lirii -laliii;; lil> ii|iliii"ii nil a lilii' I 11 /„(/ ;.y III,' 1,1-riiiil 111 liiiiilnliiiii in, Inniii'iiii mi 1 I,,,,, ii„,lrt f'"'.'^**."! Ilir All ' III ill, I,. I III \ l.iiril t'liiiiimiiiix. il'.tilil' I (ll TlH, il >v.i- ai'.'iiod •hai tli' it'iind 111 liiiiilaliim wiis ^covt'iiiod li\ sect. .'1 til tin- Civil I'l... iMJuK \.t, |.s;!;i , ;t ,'. I Will. I. 1. V2>. wliiili |;ii>i rilrt'- tlial m lie ia~t' 111 a'tiiili- Im |.iMialti<'s. ilaiiiayi'-. in >iiiiis ni iiiiiiii'v jiivi'ii 111 liir |arl\ uiii'\<'d lix .ui\ >laliitr nmv in liii.!- nr iM'rt'al'tcr In In' III i..iri'.' ilif jiciind >liall !«' iwn viMi-i allfi iln' laiisi' nt a' linn, r.iii till- Cntirl 111' Aiipoal lu'ld ilial tlic-c wniiU did iml cnvi'r llii" ii~c. ami aiiH'aiiMJ iinliiK'd In In. Id ilia! llif |H'iinil wa^ ,-i\ voai- riii- ill' i-iou. lin'M'M'i. lia- mil i^i i|iimI ciiliiiMii. and il iiin-i Im- .li'iliiillcii llial il i~ linl al'ULi'lliiM -al i~l.11 lni,\ I'liiiii'i liiiif. till' uiiiiK 111 llli' .Vi 1 111 IN.'il. aliiiM' 'I'lciicd .i| |i;mi I'l |iiiiiil ill th i|i'uM'»l wa\ tn ,-iirli an ai limi a^ iiia\ huh lif liiiiiiylil under m" 1 SI nl \\w ( 'iiiii| anic- .Vil, I'ms 1 ri>|ilai iiiL: ilu' l)i -■ l.ialiililx All. IH'.tlli h .annul l.i' in.iiiilaiin'il llial llii' Ail nl l.s.lo >|]imiIiI iml be iii'lil In .i| |il\ lii'.ail^t' llir M'llinii \\a« mil llicil in Iniic. Im ^I'cl , .J nl' llic \ii nl is:!.'! i-i imi iniillncil M statiili'-- llii'ii in Im •■. il i'\|iic~-ly -:\- ;;i\i.n li\ aii\ --laliiU' im" in I'm i- inliiifiiilfi fn hf hi iniif. Ni.i laii it lic< dt'iiied llnil a { likiiilitV in .siirli an ai limi. it hi-- < Iniiii lii' well t'iniiided. is ;i pt'i'soii 01 paiiy ' •rricM'd " The (•\|)H'>siii|i is Mill 1 Ici liiiii al ('.\|;ii'ssi(in ; tlio wmils arc mdinaiy Knuli-h wnrds, «liirli aif 111 have llic mdiiiaiy iiioaiiiiiji- ) nt ii|iiiii ihi'iu" I't-r r.iaiii«('ll. I.. .1 . Itiibiiistiii \ ('iirri'n. 7 () I!. I) t7ii. .And lioyniid .Imilii liic o\|ir('ssioii a])tlv ih'si rilK's a |K'Isi)ii vvlin has |i(.|.m iiidmi'd i'\ nnHiii slaH'iiK'lit- in a iuhsihtIus to suhsciiho I'lir .sliaics. iIi-Ikiii- iiufs. nr dcin'iiliin' stm k. ami has thcit'liy siisiaini'd ilainayf. \i;aiii, ilip I iiii|:<'nsaliuii rt'KiMMahlo in the action fall- iloaily within the words |;oiiulties. daiua^fcs. or smiis of iiini •■ jrixcn hy tin- .st'ctinii to the (ailv ijiicM'il. No doiilit. iIk' (■niiiju'iisatinii ;ii\oii is not a ■VjiU I . ^m ■>l) PHOHHEr i i;8K>. [( HAF. III. Pf 'lit \i' liavo {."Uttlly. Iirjl iho tti'idu " danutgi'-" or ««/«> of umiief/ ' iim liiiMr .Ino Ptfj'rt. '■i)ir| cii^li •» lor \itHH or ilarniiyc in tlie iirociso ( ihf loronii cii-i that i« ^ivou by the jiiiv to the plaintiff I'or the wrm j ihi' il<" laiit hitii done uiiio liiui." Co. Litt. 2, 2j7ii. Ilei -tect. Hi 111 tr'*'"K' ("iii|)rr> Indeed. I..iiidl' \ .M H . Ill the rA«J under dii(M--iiou wii.s lonsl ruined to uilniit th- itnd 111 MiConueH v. Wrif/hl. i\'M>:i< I Ch ".•>«, all • '»• ju lajmeni rel"! 1 1 til'' ■■ ilainujjeH " ulmli the iiluinii!' ni an aiuon u '"'■ the Ai I of lH'."i U'ow sect. - I "I 1!»ii hIiooM lie :i|>|)liod: liiit a.-Miiiiiiii; il fli">ild. and tl the W"i-dj< ■or olhei.sui Mil' 111 liiMcad iiH nieaiiiup: ■ ■ t 'iili- iHii .- ot .. lik.- kind. tlio.atiiiii paN.il'l" under the se-tion, lor o-h ■niiii lii.stiii'fiii-liable from daniajre-. Why. li , if^ no- lo liiiM' full elfei t 111 aiconlani-e with tip lain ii.i -ii me iiiiii^' of the wnrd;: lo tho plain literal and l:i liiuutical iiieaiiuiL' of liic \vi ' Is in wlir h they are < re- 1. unlc-^- hat coii- Htrui tion leads I" i plain and elear eonn ; iction of the ujiiiarent purjiose of the A' or to f^onie palpable ami . ideiil In Tlwiiiftiiii \ i rd ('hiiunorri». siijn i. tl. jiidire.- Appcal, in disrei; iofthi nilo, have ren -e ' to - 1H;1;J. on tho groiod !. ; r exiliisivoly (■ .< il nierelv iiiijertura -oi Ml and llic ' onrt ii- h'.M' wtiii! Hfrol^ if have 1 1" !i led thei. ■r ab.-ordi!' ■. oii'd tes\: - beii! sto* p^ritHl "f h word.-i of the .\' I the Lefri.-lalme |i i.- .■'ubmitieil the wtatnle ai deny opoi Lefri.slafuri No iucon^jfr contrary, "ix action on *he i. for ' ilen- able enouj::li. ii d, •iiil be the period ii ictiuu in • reiit ::!i.-ireprc ;.;: :'.!: i not only to prove hat he had reasonable gro. the omory o' what ' Leg -lature, in jiassing lii A the ■or lity. Coiirl ..f U'ct to the I'lided b\ i,.~ Thi.-. il The word.'* nf 1 cut down or iinises that the ■'(. ling so. On llic in rojrurd to an lisM-pre.sei; it secin.s iim.>>oii- ■ tors, iwo years shouM .vhat ma 1)0 a perfoclly inno- •-•. in whi'-h tho dofeudaut b^is It he stated to be true, but that . iieving. Time soon obliterates ■ e thought or believed, and the 1890, havinsr in miml. as it iiiii>t -ST •""7^. ,'-^- 'JJ^L' iNTKODirtrroKV notm- ^,'1 l«iv»' Iwd li** A. ; . la! I'olltt yei«r» iiMollt'i \cdati.'' )>:iriii'Ui.ir i«lttl*ii « ciiii A|hm:>I. hi 77i ^M, iiuiv well hii lln.iiy;hl iliu tlio roii» 11 (lir»" I- liiul lln'V* ' ■ ''" All "I IWlht ! of li .itioii; i»r how |K!i)iili' al'iri u 1 reuttiiiii the k' •- on which iliey ill u proM|K"lii> -ucil I'V tht'in ' II \-. l,nnlll hn\<- lollcnvc.i in- iimI..Hiiii,iIc | ic,-..,1. iit llilr Ken ihoil .i,i> .'iiiill' '■ I" 'h'liv ciii. a. .,' iiitu Iroiu a |)ii'riiii'fi>li"ii a> in Ihi" iiilciiU vfi'.s(>il ihi'> I ( /„, MX M'tMllwl (lispowcil to lllHlk (,v :;| i iiiif.- 1. I Hi, that in, hix v • ;^ a ililli' iill.\ . lor MOtt. ;J of the ( iliiit ill ilic 1 i-c of all ■uiUiU.'* " 1 hci .•«pc. iallv ihc )" «I ' • r till' oaii.-i' of .1' Hiu * '■' ,.|ilai in;,' the Ait or 1890 l>!iiiir an ailioii of t iipi I . Ihc -ol. .1 the tra'm'i iiiiii; ol II f a hut rt ■t . HlCl i iiaill .1 1 iitunou is II TliDiii - V. ii«l of liniitu- ... • ,( of the >ti V l.iril lalioii li.M'il ,cNcr. there .1:1, pioviih'M iipi.ii aii.v 11 .ml »• twenty vears II -latult iH no iliiubt that seel K4 iiart\ irrievoil the riurht to I. Si-c Tilsoit V. W'tirwick iSj:, ,. 4 U. oc C. OOJ, in vvh. Ii i; wu» hohl that where an \.t of .wts of oldaiuiiiir it «houlil I.. l>aiil the ati.)nic\^ wli.i ..litaiiicl llic Aii f.iii.iileil iiiioi ;li" .staiiiie i.'i- then r -eel. m i- . ' .( -,ifchill:i. l"r it i- ,1 SI. mite is .11 irti-n on .i >p".i;il' ,ij,/c, 1 'C. Ii. fv-7 ■ A case I'lrliaiiieiil provided that the ..in ..f the innii.'V (siibsi-rilie. 1 iniiili maiiilaiii an ai lin- .1 I tiNls. Villi fiirthei. ilie aili. ■.■illeil law lliai all ailii.: ' •III: d llillhhill Hiiil. Cii. V ' II .-,1.111110 is a ■loilaration mi a liist lefemHl lo. ami see Willi,. lu-' .S.iuh.lei*. 1K7I eiliii..n, \ .1. !. I'.U. The.-c . msiilciaii.in-' i.lil m ''h" in oiix.iiicnie of the . imslni lion iiilo|ile(l ill Thiinsiin \ \r to the iiiu. ■lien iIh' . iii.»c iiii^c^ ■•. 11 I /... i hell. 11 A ('. ll'T; .; Il I) ;-.>8l li.il IS. when lie p.ir!- '»illi lii^ . Snutli. U Cli U ■;'''''>i- for daniay;e i> uiic of the ilie cause .it ai 'ion. i)Ul .1 iniinij: io 77ii///(M«f ■ /,i/»i/ ( iHHnfirris. sui'ni. the An i- to Ijo reiul - iiiiposincr on llie .iiic lois l.\ nii|iliiation a new -latutory duty . uracv,' ami lime runs troui the broa. h of thai duty. The aicni. i daiuanres is the - mic ■n •>'>•» KtfiHt of iliatli or Kitikruiifi Whiit ini- I !iuti<>ii> (iin-^'tor*, (>rniin>t<*n'. \f . to tiikf . PKOSPKCrUSEJS. [ClIAP. III. ,i> ill \\i<- .M-f ')t .HI aniuii of !..r.'M. .l/.r <,ii,irll \ Wrii/hf. I'.in.i, 1 ( li. .",.'iS. See siijini. .1 What rllnt linrf ilnith ■mil h,iiil,iii l>l< ;i ' ;, , //, ,„.>,■ ul n^iiirirrnl ,;irl!l. Il .1 l»'i—ii .•nliil.'.l im.lcr llip ...rii,.ii 10 .•oniiiL'iis.li.iii .iii- ..!■ l,c,.Mi..- liMiiknii'i. till' liylit ul arii„h M,„|,.l il Hill |.a.v. lO lli- ll"y.ll l.,T>n|ial Ivpn-MMIIMlivi- ..!■ IIIKI.M" in iMiikiiiiH. v.a.- the laM' iiia.\ l.<%a- a iliwc in aiiinii loniiiiifr l>uit 01 hi.- t'ltate. ,1,1 In <,isc „j director. In the .-oxuiilh .'aitioii ol this u.uk till- oiiiuiuii Wits L>xi>re.>.siMl thai if a por.xni liahi.' iiiiilor the Act (Diiiclur.s l.iahilitv Ait 1 I.. \, c.r aiiiilM iiioriliir cum pcrsomi. wmilil not .set-Ill to apiilv. ■ 7"«//iv. IH; l'lnllii,.s V. Ili,wlnifi. 2\ C. D. l;l'.» H'lt the |>oiiit i> not vet ^ettle.i. An.i ih a <:i>,' (leridivl ill I'JOO, Lill.ilex , M. H., aii.l Homer. L. .1 . a^;ieeil in ihiiikiii;.' tiiat tlie puinl "as slill oiieii. ami the former would ii..t eommil liiiiiM'lf to saving' «lielliei exediloi- of a derea. -d diien.ii' were ,.r weie 110! lialde iiiidei- the Diieetors' l.ialdlil.v Ad ,„.,« MMt. 81. ( niiipaliies ,Coiis,didaiioii. Art. I'.HIS). The MaMiM of ih. K'dl.- adde.l: ■ It iii;iv Ih- that there i- a slaliiloiv lialdlity lo which the maxim ' Actio //.rM-/(,//;.s." >Vc., aiiMii'r otherwise liiuu hy leusou of a eonlracl, iironiise, .n hieaih of liusi," under ~e,l. W. ill of the Uaiiknipl'V Alt. IH.h;} .««,„,(, p. iMlTi, when it would he exeliided fiuin ,,rool f.;f()i"oo./v. II loiihrr ,1 ( o. 1 I'l.rlnual , W. N- ilHM' |.;j The di>ihur;,'e of the haiikini.t. where th.' li.ihililv i- )pro\eahle, irli.;iM.> him from iiiiy 1 laim under llie -eelioii. unless the liability u,i- innirri'il hy fraud or fiandnlent hreai h of trust. Sih> siiprn. |, J07 a.- 10 the Uankrui.try Ait; uiul Ite .\cini>,in. ;J V. I). 4'J4; an. I /■;, i„irt,' okcr, 10 Ch. ti.)2. K !l /.•-/ iiiriiiitioii" ilin'rl,,r.'>, inmiiotvrs. and others should take. 1 \- leLMid.- any .statemoiil— ill 111 the jii'oeiMjclas; i->\ In any leiioit or iiiemoriindiini a|)iieariiiir on the fucc thei-ei.l; ■;t I lu uuj reporl or inemoiui idiiiii r<>f<'rM'd lo therein; (4) 111 uii\ report or meinorandiim i--iu' .1 therowiti INTRODUCTORY NOThS. 'A':i and ' in iiises i 2 ).(•'{).( 4 ) t not purportiiifjr to he iiiiide dm tlio iiiithority (if ;ui oxport, or by a piihlio otfiriiil doouiiient or statemout, take care thai tlip statement is not made unless each dii-ector ha-* reasonable .rrmind to believe, and d.s lielieve. tliattlie sfutenient is true. The fiillriuinjr are examph>s of statements purportintr to lie made 'HI the Iiiithority of an expert: — , :i I Mr. A., or aii engineer, has examined the reef, iimi slates tiiat it is rieh in jrohi III Mr. A. lias made tlie iVilhuviiif;- rejiort. Scl il uiit.j , i-i Tlie follow in;j e.xtraots from the report which li;i.s been made by ^U-. A. show the value of the jiroperty. Si'l tliriii uitt.'] ,d) Thr statements in paia'^rraphs of this prospectus are made on iheauthori' of Messrs. . the well-known iicciiiintanis, wlio luue examined the books. CM .XiKirdinjr to the report of his Majesty's ( onsiil of I'lililished in the Hoard of Trade .luiiniulof the of . the ex|Mirts from. itc. ■2. .\s leiiaid- e\erv statement piiiporlinjx to be a statement by or Mill. lined in what purports to be a copy of or extract from a report ■ ir \aliiatiiiii of an eii<:iiieer, valuer, accountant, or other expert, take caic lai that it fairly repre.sents the statement made by such ciii;iiieer. valuer, accountant, nr other expert, or is a correct and fair ((ipv of, or extract from, the report or valuation; ibi that there is evidence that the jM'rson niakine; the slateiiieiit. report, or valuatiou was coiniietent to make it. .1. .\« leirards every slali'iiient purporting- to be a statement made \'\ nil ii||ii-i,il jiers, . or ' ontained in what i)ur]iorls to be a copy of or 1 \tiait from a public olJii iai doeument. take care that it is a correct and tail lepre-^eiitation of such statement, copy of or extiact from such document. 1 ( arefiillv a\nid staliiiuas mntleis of fact what the direi lor-^ do i\'<\ kiiiitr to be trill'. Where it i* de-^irable to slate facts which the diieitor.s do not know to be true, lei such fads 1«< embodied in u rcpiirt by some conipelent expert, and then set out that report, or cNtiacts fruiii it, iu the ]irospectus. .">. Whiii a report of an expert eaniint lie obtained, let lhr>.slaleiiieiit lie i{iialilied. ('.;/., " Kniin inipiiries which the directors have made, llicy believe that so and so." Il If il i- de ired to make use -if a staiemeiil m.ide bv -nine per.son «liii i.- ii'ii an expert, c i;.. bv a vendor, let il be slated Ihii-: " Thi" Mihlni- stales that the supply of water is ample This avoids the il-ii iii\n|\ed ill sialiiii; ' the supply iif water is ample " 7 liear in mind thai expressiuns such a- that "the liireclors hope, iiiii' i|iaie. piopo.se. or intend are statemenis within the .section, and ili.it if lliey are made when the directors d'l not hope, anticipatii. pro- |M.sc. or intend, the directijrs will be in dan5.^er of niisslatin<' a fact. i;. f. T 224 PR081 ECTU8E8. [Chap. III. But a statement in Uii« lonu i. much lo«. dangerous than an ord.nary statement of fa. t be.uuse Ic^ eu^v of refutation, t or example, it the Htatement i. that the pn-.K-rty i. rich in g' l.I, and .t turns ou, not to bo true, the directors, if 8U«1, «ill have to prove that thev H,h.-v,Hl, and had reasonable ^round^ to lK,lievo, the sUtemont to bo true; when.a«, if the .tate.nent Ls that the director, beheve that the pro- portv i« rich in gold, the plaintiff will have the d.lhcult ta«k of prov-injr that thev did not believe. Of cour^*-. however, an iK.nest nuu, will not «av that he lM)lieve.s unkvss ho ha. goo.v expert w lade any report or memorandum set out oi r-fenvd i. a, or issued with, the prosjiectus. As to .8) the onus will be on the plaintiff in an action to prove that the defendant had not' reasonable grounds to l)eUeve in the .ompelencv. Still it .seems wiser to ,.resc.rve the evnler.ce. tor tl... plaintiff will be entitled to a.sk the aefen.lunt. ■What were y.MO grounds of belief?- and if the .lefendant thus challenged .ouM not rememUM what they ue.v, this, taken with other ciicumstaic might enable the plaintiff to .lisduirgi the onu^ and mover c . .- ct'iisation. , The object, of course, of tiie lecor.l i^ that the j)erson who make it may, if the occasion arise, be- able to lefi'esh his memory in the witness box bv referring to such record. In the ubsem* of such record, it may (after a laps,., ,H.rhaps. nl vears . Ik- a matter of gival .lillicilty for a dire.lor. ,.r other person sued, to pn.ve his U.lief. still mo.e to prove the gr.mn.ls ot beliel The rules as to refrt^shing memory by n.ferri.ig to sn. Ii a r...o.,l are state.l in Stephen's Law of Evideti,-,.. p. Tit, as follows: - ■ V witne.ss may. while un.ler examination, refivsh his m,.mory hs referring to anv writing made by himself at the time of the transac- tion concerning whi.h he is .,uesti..ned, or .s.. s.mii afterwards that the judge conshlors it likely that the transaction w.i.s at that tnn,. fresh in bis memory. The witness mav aho rer.,r to any such writing nnule by „:iy other porson. an.l rea.1 by the witness within the time afor.^sai.l. it when he mad it he knew it to be correct." INTKODUCroRY NOTRS. •225 A (Icliix !•( .--Diuc Hi'fks III writing oi' rouiliii^ ilu' icionl mitrlit niidcr it iimilini>."'ilil«' Soc Tiiylur on Evult'iin', sect. 140»i dill' 111'mIc vf iiinkiiij; llii- ivnml will lie lor lli»> iliicclnr to tiiki- a (III V of llii' |)io>|«'( III-. uikI liiiiiscll iimko liu> roioiil tlicicon. or on .1 -JKi'l of [KilK'r :iiili<|.\o(l liicicio, ami pliHi' Mirli coiiy and ii'i nnl in sill' 1 iisUidy. Aiiiilla'r iiioilo Hill lj<- lo loiiMidur llic |iros|M'iiii. and oihor doiii- iMfiil;- at u liixird iiK't'lin^', lu'loiv tlie\ arc i.ssij»>d. to uikc the -laicmciils .svi iiilint. and a- lo cui li to >tatt' tlw jiiomid of ticliff and ihc l.n I that all tlic dirirtor> Im'Iu'm' il Inn Lot tin- jnaulc- madi- liv ilic i^'cictaiv ix'curd uil tliis in ik'tail. and vviilijn tlw- m-M !.■« il;i\-. K'l the formal niiiiiiti'N ho road and initialled U\ all tl»f* iliivitors: k'l a coiiy !«' fiirni-liod lo t'ai h of iho ,liri'iir,tf. ^iid Ih carli forlliwith ioin|iai<' his (•o|i\ with llio orijiiiial, .iiid iMiUif and initial and date a iiionioranduin llit'roiiniier to the I'lli'i-i tlnil I cmni aicd this coiiy with tho oiijfiiial iniiKitcs. and foiinii it i nrrii ' III this wav till' formal miiiiili's may Ix" rcfi'rn'd to. and if tin- .'■liiiiild lio lost, tilt' iliit'i'tor will iirihaldy Ih' allowed to lelei lo ihe in|y Taylor, sei I 1 »t»K. 't Lastly, it is lawful, sulijci to sei I SI ( t' of the I iimiianies All. lIHis. for a HiiliscriliL'r to conlract him.-elf out of some of the iil;IiI- sei iii<'d to him liy sert . 84; anil tlieiu may Ik? rases in whiili il will he desirahle. under |;id|)er advice, to artimne for sinh a iiiiitiiiit or waiver S •<■ iiifni. |i|). 2.'ll, 2.12 <■/ .si'/y. ; and Hnr.iluin lliihliir I'laiitiiNims i No. 1 i. tl'.HIi I Cli. 12."i. .|v Id siili-sfit. I .'t I of .sic/. 84 of flif All i rflil'icillfl tiul J of III)' luilcninitv nf li,ii,U,i.-' I.i.ihililii ,\ctus or iiotii'e. and has not aiitl con.s«'nU'd to the is^nc thereof. ore the ishuc ori/eil or Kach of th«s« |i«rr I i iildes him to v»i6 liiilemnitjr Hgaiust rnni|>any. .s«ct. S of Ac Hight of <(intributioii PROSPECTUSES. [Chap. III. It would scHMu that a .Uro.'tor nvIk. without fraud or iioghnjoiuo incur, liability andor tho section i- oi.titlod to in.lon.nily ii« aj^ainn. thecon.i)a.>v.rnrlioi8anaKont,an.) an agent i.sontitlod to imK-mnitv from his prit,. i,ml in thi- -as,, tho .onipanv in the al.«on.e of frau,l or nuMon.lurl Story on A(r«.n.v. «>.t. ^W: H,'IU v. dihhius. ' ' Uto'mh-sert. (4m*,-W. .". »f the m,,-m.H v Sirnvnti. (l!"i:}i 2 K H ^C A.* 107. This is an imiiorlant nltfrati..n of the law It di-- pla.^s the old rule whiih disalh.w.-.l contribution betw.-en tortfeasor,., and i.i substitution treats the relation of the .lelin.|uent -o-direcfors or co-promoters as a ef)ntractual one. li S.<-t. 3»of t .Vet »f IM!7 Section 38 of the Companies Act, 1867. Sect. ;t8 of the Coinimnies Act. I8»i7. was repealelore. no applictttiou to any pro-iK'ctus issued afur Ueconiber :il.st, I'JOO, But the repeal is, by virtue of sect. .tH of tif Interpretation Act, 1889, without preju.lice to any rijrht of action oi liability incurre .,ueHlio'n.s as to it« etfe.t may still for some time arise with refercn.c to prosi)e.tu.ses i.ssmvl before .January Isl, 1901. and, in fact, th.■^ have fre.|uentlv done ho. The derisions on thes.. lases under ic, i. M often throw lijrht on the probable attitude of the Court. io»ard> sen. 81 of the Companies Act. 1908, more especially a,s regard, material contract*, which by para, .k^ of sub-se.l, 1 of that section are required to be distUwed. and for that reason deserve attention The Hection is as follows; 38 Every proKpcttiii. of « i^ompany, and every notice invitiiitr per-ons to H.ahserilM- for .han^s in ai.v joint .toek eompany. «l.all -pe-ify tlie .late, aii.l ij.e nam..» of the i,artic« t« a.iv contract entere.1 into l.y the eompany. or the promoters, dinstor-. o- trn.tee« thereof, before the iwue of !.uch pro«pe. t.i» or noti.e whether .uhjeet t.. adoption by the dinntors or tlie eompany, or other- wise- and anv pr.wpctu.. or notice not siMTifyinit the xanie hhall be d.i.m.Hl frauduh.nt on the part of the promoters, direet.-. and olK.er- of the eompany knowingly issuing the i-ame. m regards any ;,er»on takinir shares in the .ompany on tlie faith of »u.h pro.p«'«us. unle« he shall have had notice of such eontraet, M, uoinK of Muary In -|M'iirv CM'ry imilriiiil uiiiraci niailc liv llic c i>rn- |iiiii\ III- lln" liiitiiiiir.s III pioniDicrs iIiciimpI. incaninir ''^ niili'ii.il idhlrail every (nulract wliicli might rea.>i>nalily he e\|iei leii id inlliience the ju(l'_'iiienl of a per.idri reading; the prdspeiin- a.- to wh<'llier he nhoiild dr .shoiiKI nol apply fdi- shaics: and il i-i ndw well selilid. a- appears liejow. that tlii« i* thn true runstriielidn df the wiil'in. Si'cl. 81 li iki df llio T'dinpanios (^Consolidation) Act, |yo8. ill tonus liiuitH the disclosiii-c thus roquired to " inatoriul " conlruotii. The following are pxaniples of contracts wliiili haxe heeu held to bo inatorial: — iai Conliaii liy prMirioiei lo Imy Irannvuy eonces»ion, and Mibse- i|iiently re-.M'll to the <'ompany. Iii t ontract by same promoter to give to another promolor re'iiu- iieration lor luisisting in the prdinolioii of the compam . 7'iri/fTo.«.v V. liriinl. '2 ('. 1'. I). 46!t. II 1 Conlract iiniler which jUoiiKner wa.s to receive from the ostennihle veiulcrs to 'he company a portion of the proceeds of .siile. (IreenwnvK^ v. Lrnther Shoil WhrrI Co.. ilOlM)) I ( h t;!l. Ill; (iinlract lHn promoters and K . the future chairman of the cunipany. whendiy the linn of which K. was a nieinher wa.- Id ri'ceive a lilnck of vendors' shares as coniinisKion for iiMilei writing and for the use nf ihe tirm's name. ('iirl,;'lt \ hixH III,-. '• l'.M»2) 1' tl. lei ( onlraclft hy jiroinoters to transfer to the company certain paid-up .shares in another contvrn in consideration of u lilock of paid-up shares in the company. MrCoiitwfl v Wrli/ht. il'.Mt.li I Ch. .-147: Callhnrjw v. Tn'rIiiiKiini. and Miirlriiii \. Toil. I HHKii A. (' 1»» 11. I,, i. if I Conlract hy eoni|iany with its promoter for payment of a large Mini to hiui for hniling a depasit and other seixiies. (g) (.'outraet rosoinding such oontracl with a promoter and j)ro- \iiliiig that Ihe promou-r's claim to remuneration should 1h' ■■ honoiiralily met " Itniome \ . Sprtik. i llMl.l) 1 Ch. ."iHli; alliri.ivi! liy II. L. mb nom. Sliephrard v. liroome. . I!MH) A C lUU tin Contract with promoterK by which u certain firm were to bo ciimmercial agentw of the company, to receive 10,001) fully- paid shares, unrf a partner in the tirni to be ft director. (Uukvtt V. Kemrick; i l'.»lll.') '2 Ch 4.-.7; Sash v. Calthorpr, 11905) 2 Ch L»;J7; Mailfaij v Tail, »upra. w2 ''.\;iii(pl(M of ■ 111 itfri.'il ;n' >28 i'Rosi'KcrnisK><. [Chap. III. m -if Executory and exerut*^! c<>ntr» This wrliiiii wa-^ U'll liiuili'il to t'xfciitoiv coutnicl.- iilod l( «'Xt>(UtOii llccl licfi.ro tlu> inosiii' ( arii<>il iiili" < Nor \va> it |ii.sHil.lc lo cm mi«" lioiii tin- soitK rliis i-i issued llrniniif v. Si>vtil tiacl all '>iii' ""' <(iiilia«l~ lira! as for il \va.s oil as wri W. K tiH'.t: :.« I,. T S'>< Co . .11 ■tltl: Ul \V. K. 82!>. 1 liy iiiakin;.' tin- roii- iiolil lliat till' scition (•(iiiii>iflH>ii.lril ittcii ( iivfl V Sims Sh!i> <;,i>ii><,sitmi .lil,liri 1(1 lilt" nil aiiinir ot iIk' "oi< 1(1 Tiri/iiiiss V (iniiil. IHoinoKT. SIM' slll'lil. \< \'2'i I't C. 1'. I) (•;!». .'it);!; nN", fill' '•"• I'lM- llO>«>' !>!' H\ ((lii-<>ctiirs' lialiililv Till iiicaiiiii III' till' won lll.-s 1(1' llio sodion. iiiL' ' ill ■-'■I I :;h 1, llCCIl ''OHM i|<>r<'(■tll^ «ll sect ion. am Sec also CiK (■ \va.s ol „f tl o|i|llloll lll<>\ II CMSIC'IICC h klli>vvU'(|irc I iiiU-iilioiiallv oiuiiliiiu- llu'iii ■kftl IlKMIlt IS- ll I'Olltl'IK 1,1. L'C !• 1) .(liiiir iIk" I'l"- ■t.s nil hill I III' Horn iliv piospt'cH K.-suirk. I'.'Ol-'i -1 rli. t.V.l. ail. Ihiiilf Sfifiil , |'.t04' -1 < ll. 7.!^ Ill lll'lllltif V. >'/ (lain- liad kuottiiiu .■«!/,■ Iilii- lia\ III'. 1 1. iwaic ol 1 III' I'xisli'iiii' ol lilt' loiilia ■is and oiiiiiifd llii'iii liioii'jli m liftmrauii d th'' law. •_>• ^o llicv lia lirnoialii'i ll aiU'd ill '-:i" .f ill.' .h d failli oil l.",ral ail\i. >' 111 sliclii'i a dii.'.l.n .1 aii\ oili.'i • lat.'i [leixili ill ludcd in If a man . IiikiM's Io lici-.niit' iii»'iitioii«' . ,|iiloi\ oliliu;ati.'ii^- '"' '"•' bla uii\ iiionil liiri' IV lii' lialili' lov a sialiiior; frail. I uilhoiii oldi'i'lily whalt'v.'i 'd it ridil that lliis Thai is his niisfolliini' Th sl:,- sIlOlll.l and ihoii'^li ilia' -<'''i' i.s now ii'iicali d. ii f.till iiiivcnis till' |>iv.s»'iil la-o It i- ll n'l'cfor.' i.llc I. iuu aii\ ■iav thai III.' .I< lishoii.'sU lo ift'iidaiit was not ili dlOIK ^1. \\c arc not iiii|iiil- liiiii vM-.'iii I In- slaIiitoi'\ fiaiiil lit ll al.'il Ifrnorance of e»iiiteiw'.' "f coiitni.t" H.' >lu ■alinot sill « , or oM'ii >|„'1|<'|- liiiii-.'lf fi'oiii ihal s,':l|o;i I .'1 li\ saxiii'j: I hat ln' iiixilf. ill to tin' law. anil di.l ""' :"' '' llS.'lf. !) I ( h TWi. wan liiithi'r <'. ■i\ ill 7'iii( N M'kI'' l|llllloll "I Wlllfx N I I'.MIt thai .asc a < liirilor issiit'il a |iros|i('. •tiis whi.li oniill.'. at.'iial .■oiiliacl. Iml al ill.' iiii'-lin^' " tiis w :s iijiiu-ovcl. Ill' I'U if .1 >.S|1C1 i)iitnv.t ill mii'stiou. -v'd it f..i>r<'iiiii'-' III'' ' ''I iri'it.irs ill III iwiihstan.liii;.' lliai ih.' niiiiiiK' lIMI'llll', at w vhiili lli.il N<'i> ■oninift wa^ roiisi il.'1-.'d. ntiriiu'il ill hi.'* pn'siMu-.'. and lli.myli h.' Iia.l liiniM'H approved of lii- ..-aUa... U «a^ ^!.-,, h.=.ev..r^ thu- h-' had a ..elu'ial k....wlodjro .d- till' ,.,M,st.M..^. of .■.mtruels W1...I. ...ijrl t '.I ;itl.i.. tl... M'.-tioii, and lio nia.li' il- iiLimrv as I.. iJ.o.^' .outru.'..--. Iml ,1'liea upou the assuranir of the loinpuiivs solicitor that the pi"- ^1?. ' ^Se 'c "■ INTRODUirrORY NOTKS. •i2!t -iii'i iii~ .liscliisod the ((nitmct* wliidi ili«i lo^tMl. I' «a.- Ill-Id tliiil he 'lail kimiviii^rlv i-isucd ilic |(i()si«M'tii^ wiiliiii lh«' M'li'iii UomtT, L. •! . ill srivinsi jiult'iiii'iit, said lliut llio M-clinii iiMiMi.~»il ii|ii>ii ii diM'cliir wliii is M'tlliii^r ;iiid is-iiiiiirn |iiii-|MMtii'- iIk! Iiiiv "i iiii|iiiiiiiy «lial ruiiliai I- iliciT iiiT ill cxi-loiiK" « Ilic li uiiirlil I" I, ~ii Mill ill lln' |H'i>|ii'iiiis, and if a diii'idn- kiKiu- ..n'liiMalK ilial ilii'ii' jii I'liiiliai t.s ill cM^ii'iK'f wiiirli iiiav i iliii-c riintr.i'l> mi llial lie can iitilljliillv nav tlial In' had no knowlcd'^:!' ol aii\ < onlracl.-* in jiarii' iilai wliirli oii;:lil to In- »t't ioiili ill llii' |ii'oi|M«i-liiH. In' caiiiioi •■\fii-<' liiiiiscll Iriiiii lialiililv iiiidiT the -t'rlion on ilii' (dcii of ijjnoiiiiiM- if il. iliriAaids tiiin- out ilial -onii' of ilic conliait-' of wlijili lif Imd a i^iiH'ial knowl('r iiniiiiiici*. Tlii- la-f «ai ii'VCix'd li\ iIk' IIoii-«' of l.oid'*, l.'i Dec. I'.KI.") • Miiflnijl \ '(lit, ' I'.tlllii A. ( . 24i. lull the \ ii'w alimi' m'i foiih was a|i|iro\<'d. Till' j^idiiiid of rrvi'i-al wa-i iliat il wa-< cslalili-ln"! paiilv fioin ihc |M:iiiitlll > adiiiii-ioii.-. and jiaith on otlici' ^:roiiiid~ llial i'M'Ii had ho kii.iwii tilt' "Tal fa 111- Would Hiill liavo siilisiiiU'rl. \- In iIk' li'iiiflv. il « I- jnni; ^iiui' held dial wlicii' ,i | Tlii niiu'dy li.i> lakt'ii .sliait"- '>ii the fiiitli of a |)ro>|ir -iii- wliirli i~ uilliin. and ^^(|„„ Miiciids a:.'■aill^t tlic -I'liioii. his liulii .oiiim' i^ lo sue, not tin- roni|iaii\ . liiii ilii' |ironiot»'rs, diri'Oois or ollin'V i--iiiii'^- the ■^aiiM' for ihc 'liiiui'^r III' lia> Mi il'ovi' iiit'iilionod \.- IM till' iina.-iiii .if ilaniaui'>. llii> i- in -iili-MU'r ilii' -anic ii.v ilio Mi'imiin' of i!i.',i~iiii' iii ilaiiia'ji'^ 111 an aiiiiin ol ili'i I 11 I ni: \ . I ifi r;i.' i ' i'i\. ."ill S.-.' ■/■»■//<•( o.v« V. (iiiilil.l^ r l> I'i'.'; I (hi:, 11 \ hi:siri(!:. ' I'.ini: -J III. \:>y\. M(<,„i,>, \ Wifihl. ij'.tii.ii I ( il .'.li;; .md liccdhc \ >;ici(/,'. I htii.ti I < Il .S(i, allirnii'd li\ llon.-c .if l.ords >;//» !}•(((( ' ii and dial a man iiia\ In' liaiili' .ihlmnuh llii. .nd.'-i.ili M ioiM|ilv wiih ilic -c.-lioii ir.i-o niriclv fioiii -.mii' l""r::i.|fiiliii"^>^ or ini-iiiidrr-tandiiiy. Itiii iIk' ^ertioii is applic alili' only to a jiiosj).., m- .ilfciini: -li.iit's Aict. :in iloti" i.i -iil.-iri|i!ioii. and nol i.i oni. iilf.rin- li.m !>• fi.i- -iilisciijiii.iii. ""•*'""-'' ' . . ' ilcln'iitiin* iiiii(V\ lliifi. \. l( '■> < ' I'. -i^K. Nor .|ni..« I! iiiiiili' ;lii' 1 oni|iany IioUUts. t" i..|!'.| Sen- Siiiihnri) Id.. -'I \|'li. ''as j'JISi, or ...iifi'r .iii iho sliuii ii.rldcr a ri::lit to ri'|iiidiati' hi- ^llal<'- doci';- r.(>/. It I). I^i; loni. \\ hiililid'i.ii OhiiKr'ii- /.'//"7i (/. ' r.'lo . I III i;;;ii; >,,»//( ''f I. I'lldKil \ahiiiil (liiM <'i) . I mil ' I (II. .'iT:! .\ii ilii idf.'('d |iriiK|n'(liis |.. williin Ilio m'.iioii .'M'II ilioii.^h -mli .Miriil^rwl |iro-.|i(clii..- .stall's when' full |iros|i('riiisi's inij;lii Uc olilaiiicil. While P''""Pi'''»"". » Ihiiiii'iiii. I Call iV. Kllis. lot. Aiiiii/. it r Sdiietfi \, < 1(1411, H <*« ^^15S^ w I u£ 230 What piniii till mu«l pruvf. PKOSPKCTUSI'>. [Chap. 111. ilirH-tm liHblf i<> nitifii'Ml !•»> *• Notiw "' iif T. L H. J27. Com. «...(««•« V. Uunihaiii. {m)'J\ I Cli 1:!7, ««/;<«. p 11 Sh'O aUo (»/rii. l>l> ^59, MO. Ill ..kI.t tix.htaiu r.'Iiol under <«ct. amlio pluintitl iiiusl »liow that but lor tlii> ..Mii« ii.iilraol, \w >u\d not Imvc sul)- Hiiil..-.! Tlii- .^M'lUial (omlitioii «a- not luilv ^(.priKiuled until tli« 11. HI..' ol l.c.i'.l< •*<> Ji'(i Hluii.- il 111.- oii.itt*-,! ...iitra.i lia.i, or that he wu« i,idu.r.l t.. lak.- 111.- slu.r.<- l.v lualtt-r, altoj^Mlier oiil>l.le the r.v-eipt of til.- i.r.« oiiii.-ioii' i" a i,ros|..-,tiis js-^u.-d without. Iiis kiio« UmI^'i- .,r authority. .An.l ill a If. -.lit .a.M- it was held thai, .•vt-ii tliouffh h.- sul.se<,uoiitly ralili.-.- a.i.l .l.-riv<- ailvanti-c- uikUt th.- i.io~ik-. lu>. h." .-amiot l.v .s.i.h raliliiaii.iM l«- niaW.- lial.l.- uu.h-r tli.- .-.'.tioii l[,„>lr \. >>/'™/.-, , I'.Mil 2 Ch. 7.!J Til.- l.-arnoM,pp<)se» kiiouli-.b. .Ml th.- pait ..I tli(- .lill >t..r~, awl it point-- t.. an ../l.-ii.e hoinir ,.,„„i.iin.-.l ai th.- lii.M- of tiic i-u.v II aiipi-ar- I., in.- tli..! I .-hould bo (■ontKi.li.tii.j; ill- lan._Miaf;t- of lla- statute oiitirelv. an-! .•hall liav.- id iio'lro of smdi .■oiiira.t," uro the .■.Mi.lii.lin- uoi.K ..f th.- wlion What .h,o-. "M..li.-- her.) luoany It mean- lii iL'ti..' no! onl.v of llie oxisteii..- .if tl ilract, bui al-o .it it- ...iiients, a- heai-iii- upon tho .staleniont.s in tla- pro- 4:osninj,r th<- pro-pe.ln-- t.. alloid i.. poi-|..iis invited to tak(3 isliaro- the inluiinatioii H-.iuirc.l l.v tho soeliou, it 19 obvious that the wor.l- ' unlovs ho shall have hail notioo of such eontr«.-t' n-.-aii a jjood .leal inoio than ' unh-^ ho shall h.avo -oiiie va^'uo iiitoiniatioii wlii- h. if followed up, will lead to su. h fiotico ' Xotico in the si-.ti.m mean- not what is .alle.l .•.in-triiersons who olo>i« to iiixort in an\ proMiKMiiiH tn which ihf , and it wuuld ncom iluii till- ^aiiK" nih' applio-; to a conilition in a form of appliiation rciiiMird liv the |ircispc('lu< to lit- ii Art. I 'MIS ireiiroihiciHfi Ihf firoriKiony of the lUrcctom' Liahilifi/ Irl. lH!Mli [xuimi. p. 20H1. lIcK' lh« I'aso i-i dilloront. Tlit; ^-rlion incridy impose-; on tho Waiver of iliicri,,rs ond otht-r'* a statutory ohlitration in pay (..niiK-nsation lo Li']['^'n,'iV A.t. ;lif injiiivtl suh-* Tlii-* i>l>ligation i» iiisurtcd obviously for IH'JO now ili.ii bcnclil, and liokin'r at the la^u^ Ixlou icfiMri'il in. it is appip- ^^^J'^^j |yy^ hoiiiii'd that. b<'\nnd all doubt, the ri'cpiiicinonts nf the -ortioii can bo ual\rl, and thai a .siibsiribor may k'j;ally coiili^K-l liimsolf nut of .eriaiii liabili'lo-^ undor sub-sod. ( li of sod, «4 (soil. 3 of tho said iO|oalod .\it It would not. indood, bo prop4'r. or iiidood praotic- alili'. to nuiko a ('ontratt to tho olloct that tho subscrilMU- shall not -lie I'.ir r()m|.on-alioii in lospoii of a frantluliiil luisropiosontatiou; I. Ill ilioH' wcmld .sooiii to bo no iiuprojirioty in a cnnlrad to the I'tici; ili.i! tlio subsiribor will not suo in rospo.l of a missiatomont iiiiii'i'itih niado. aiid thai such a misslaloniont shall not invalidate ii icnilor viiidablo the .iniliad TkII!" v. Jiuxon. i^lMltJi 3 Ch III And soo Ili(i:illini litii'bii I'ldiiliitioiis (,Xn. 1 i. vl'.Uli 1 I'h. \-2:. Sih Ii ;i inlrad. assuniiii'^f tho above view to bo loiiod, lui^ht bo Ry what iiiiJo by lifHd of lovonant with the directors, but thai mmlo will ""•'"""foi- rarely Ik? pradiiablo; and if tlioro is to bo sinh a cuiilrait it musi, II. 1 di'iibl. bo ombodiod in iho pro^poitiis or in tho form of application fur 'liaios or dobonturos. But a contract so embodied will, as be- iwooii tho siibscrilior and the directors, be open to the objection tiial it is ic.s iiitw alios iiilu (sw 8th oil., p. ISHi. unlo.ss it is made with the company a.s trustee: e.g., .\iid I Hjtrec vf itii tlie comp.iny (as trusU-r for tlio (lircctors ami other penon* liablfl that 1 will not make oiiy claim, or take any prociHiIinjfs, uuder »cet. 84 •I-.i'i I'mmiMcnsKi*. [Chap. III. of th.> Ci.niiMiiiiM (t'..n«.lid»ti..n) Art. IWW. r«>r . .,iN|i.Mi»«timi in r«i>«Ki ,.f «.,» mi"t«t.'m,iit ill tlir .ai.l ,,r.H|„. t«.. mud.- I.v il.-' .lif. i.,r- in ili.- l.-li.f rlut It «:i, trii.-. iml lliiit llii« iiiv .•..iilriiil -li.ill n.H !..■ iin^Mithitiil l.y ii-.i«hi ..f uny i*ii''l> ini-iitiiti'mi'iit. Or llin |iriir>|M'iiii- iiiav -liilf llml; - Till- liu-til »i< iiiri.riiiiilliui rmiii-liiil l.y i,. vi.|i<|..r {•:■ l.y A. It. |. I.iit iii.|.li.-.int« « ill !»• .(.•.■m.'.l t.. Jiirr.-.' will, tli" ■ |.a!;v {a* frii-tif fi.r tin- iliri-.l..r-i lliat tlii>y will 11..I imiki- uny flu'iii iiiiilrr ~.i t n| nf til.' C.mii.ttMii'* iC.ii-.iiil.-.ti.iii) \"' "' 'I'l- volmnc. ami tlif |iii.|iu-iti..ii llicir . ..iil.ii.li-.l l..r. uami'lv. l'';il 1' WUH in |:..inl t.f law ullnwat.lc \« "..ivc . ..ni|.liaiii i- «illi ><■' ' 'W .inlif ('i>ni|iani<'« An. IStlT. is n,,« -.MHMall.v ii'. ..uiii/i'.l asr.pnr.! .S'*. ItiiiKWuiit V. ihnkf. Tiiii<~. l:illi Nn\<'ml«'r anil Mtli DciiMnlxr, IH'.tT; (in-rninx„l v L,-.,lU,r Shod \\lu:rlr<>. il'.'mt. I ' h. I'-M. Cirkrtt V A, >•/<•-. A-. . P.MfJ > :.' < Il » ■)•; . M<'>uii>i \ Jiiil. MKti; \.i Bui. us Fuiwoll. I . sui.l iii CirMI \ A.---./. \ man «li.. f tin- r..iilia.!s. or if In' .stuti's thai tlioiv ' may ' I..' 1 oiitiucts. wln'ii he kii .ws that tlioiv iiir. ho liinnot ii'Iy i.n llic i laiici' I" (iioK'i t liini Si'c the uIm.vi' .l.'.isii.h- So also if the ilaii.s(> piii|i..il-< f. ail... t ilu' .iiipli.anl with untiic ..I lontiiKt.s which aro iiiiiir..iK"ih . on.i'aliil. it i- inrllc 'i\i' The intrfxluctiiiii of a Nti|.iilalioii ilial an api.ti. .inl f..i -hairs i- t., |„. ,!(.( .i-..iir.si' to in or.li-r M i-va.li" th.' i.'ii-. - .(n.-nien of 'In' ini|>r<.i)or lonK'alnn-iit Siirh u sti|nilaiioii in a tin k\ waivorilaii- 'iko tin- ono l(t.f..rp mm iillniil^ no proUMii-.n 10 thr |ii'is.iii who sjK-ks |.i ..it'ctioii ff.iia it . Thi' pririiipk" of i('fiisiii<>: 1.. /ivc I'tltv » to piirtw lit .I.KUim'nt.i so .u-i to pivvont »ii.-. 181 ). Tli<> rofii il is I -''(I on onliiiurv priiuipli-s of honesty, ami 's as :!!iplicab!e to trirkv »:i!vor ilaii.s«>s as to other tricky iloomiiont- " Pit Linillfv. M H.. (Inriiti-onil \- Lf.ither Sh'»l Whiil ' <>.. siipt' Rut. .Hiil.ji'. t to these reservations, a waiver ilnii^e properix fraiii.'.l and honMtiy iiswl i«. in the opinion of the Hons.. of Lords. |p..'itiiiiate and hindins; Mnrlenf/ y. Tnil. (V.mU \ (.2). INTKODITcrtiRY NOTM. iVi Criminal Limbility in respect of ProspectUBes. x, I SI .>! lllf l.a|...|i> A.I. IHiil r2i \ -.'.'i Viil . 'Ml. |i|..Mi|i'« tluil: Uli"»"i"i -'-h iiuh' "r !ii'"iiiil «liiili In- .liiill khiiw 1" I"' fi'l*'' i" •'">■ matiTi.il |ii>rlii'>ilar, with iiiii'iit l.i iltniix.' nr ill lr:iiiil uiiv niiiiilMT, f •iii-li ImkIj- rnriMiratf or |iiililii' ,,,lii|.;iliy. ... •"'/' .«/<-.' '" ./../•...■ ".,* ,..■,."/. '.> >;,„.„■ .. ^h.iiihfll', •Mi|iaMy. "f tn rnli'r inln uiiy "wiirily for lln' l)iii. tit iImth'I'. -hall I... ^'uiitv .if a miwIi'iii'Mr.mir, ami. Iniiii; iiinu.li.ntioiied. < riiiiiiial liKhility. Till' |.;iili-lliii' 111" H'l'llfl In wt'H' T." I«' tt'l'i III la'lial -I'l \ lliiili' ;,,! .WW li'iiii ii.il . N.i'MJiii'^ WNt'ii M'lil- iiikI 11.11 It"*-, lli.iii ilircf \i'.il«. ,i •■. Im- iiiipii.-iiiKNl (or :iii\ liTiii II. )l fv. I'f.JiM^r m.. M-at..^. uilli ..r iMidi.iil hal-il liil..'iii. .ml will "l \\illlinil hnlilaiv roiilini'iiiciit ///,./ M'l t Ti all.lM'l't lllM\ - >l:llllll-.<. 'illl I'll \"l ;'.. p|i '1'1\. -If*. iHij. r til I I iiHiu.il l.an . \ |ii(i-|ic. tn- - I uiilli'ii ^lali'liiciil »illiili llu- iiKMiiiii;/ ".f llii.< . ..I.I. iiin'til. aii.i .1 ..I liii'.'lv it a ii|i..i|i<'.lii« i- i-'-.-iicil .■.iiilaiiiiii'j; 11.111 Illl. Ill iiii.-rc|in'.-''iiiiiii.iii-. llii- iliin. I..|> i."-iiiii!,'- it will In' li.ilili' II |.riM'. utimi nil h'l ili.' \.i. 'Ii.'\ mav aN.i In- |iic.-i' ■iitc.j 'iiri.iii- -j.iia. \ t.i . niiiniit illl- -..1IIII..IV 'ill.ii'i' MoKHiv.'i auv iMT-aiii, will 'lii'i :i .liii'ildi- III li.il. .^Ii.i i.--iii'~ "I i.iko* pari in llic i^sin- 'if it |ir..-i>t> pi.i- -VI iisi'il i.ii ' iispita. \ I" vl.'lr;;ii.| I'.iil ol' . iiiir-^i' ^ii. It pi-r-niis .a. iii.it I iiMiii.l niili'^i.- it .an Im- priivi-.l ilia! lln>_v knew tin- icprosi'iita- I - ii, Ih tiiKf. anil, ailing' iip.'ii that !.iiii«l('<|._'<' iiid with ilie ml. lioii I. li'fiM' ami (li'fniml. i.v^iicil tlic prn-'pc. ins JNt Cock- l.iiiM ( ! in Till- (^itrrii \ l.iii iirif miil nlhrrx. l''iiila\s.ii|s Hi-poit, Ill till' i.-<. la>i iiKiiiioni'il till' pi-.i-'i'.iiliiiii wii.s iiuiUm- hi"1. S I "T lln' laii tin' |iiiv,.-uiil lliai ' the -niii uii.l ■iili-iai|.<- III illl' .liai-Ki' «••- 111."! iln' l'i!siiii'-» .if Ovni'iiil. 1.imii.'\ .V 1 '. In'Miir hi>p<.|i>.4 fran'^fi'trcil «iili a lii'H .if i|.'fraii(lniir atnl <'li<'aliii por-smis so lakiiitr anil payiiit; Mr 'lull- stiaii'.-i ii( the pini> wliirii lh(>v w.inl.i inni' ii> pav Tiiat i-« listamc ..I till' iliiriTi'. If v.m hIi.iII licjicvo in tin' I'liil lie -iiiii ami >i tliiTP nm lip no lliiil "lull a roii«pii-ary t (KiKi-illi' ilnnlit that tlifv liuvo coiiiniiili'il an olltMiip u;;aiiis| iiii> hi »'K>*. [('HAI'. III. Kor ..>.i i.i.K .l.sult ol ii .oa.-*piiu.v> or ii-i, Hi.- jhiI. Ii.,hiu.' ol Hlato.ii.'i.l. Ui.uwn i" !»• fulM', in or.lof 1.. iiuln.f |H•l*.m^ to luUr Amu:-, aii ..Hri.rr, 1..11 ih.Mr .all »«■ no .lo.il.t npou ll..- UPn-'ial lau of tnr lan.l llial u ,. uu-uns of faL..' pi-Hv... .■• i^ an oIUm,,... an,| an olt..,,.- of a vrx mtio,,, na.ur.. It i, noi il.o lo«- an olItMiro hmau-) il is .iir.',!.-,! a(,MiuM .>*(«H-t; it Ihi .• an.l UvixMM' tli.' iiiarl.inalion:' r.f tim not linr l».,'.. ,liii>.tcMl airaiiiM pa.ii.nlir indivi.lnals. If a nnint-cr ol i>.is,.„> ,o..,l.iti.' an.l ...„..<.I.Ta;.- t,. . h-:.! a ,Mrli. iili.i iti.liv i.l.u.l thor.- .>an !»■ ,,. ,l„ul.t tl.ui il i- a .liininal . .n-i.ira.v at law ll i>. not tos,- .... l„Mai..-r ih.- iMTM.n- to 1... .a.i::.,. ...i.l to I,.. .|,M-,.iv.Ml iitr no! in'l< vi.luallv ill ll V .111.1 . oi.l.Miiiila.i..M of tin- . <.n>|.iral.ii> Thai w., M.||l.'.ri..iiu' a-..' in til.' .ase to «lil. li lIu" \r.inu.i ...iiii><- ll,rr„:,.r .u„l „th.rs: ani uliauniM n'maik- Mi Soli, il.M -C.Mi.-.l i.m> liav a.lr . au.ll.l iaiall...iiirov.M! ^vllatll«•^.l^- lo M.. u thai ill.' vn !.■• ill timt ra.-c was iinsaliMfa.torx . ><•! lli.'iv .ao !"• n- .loul.i that ui.n, iJioC.nii ol Kiii'.'.s ll..n.h. IO..H..M.I.1 ,l-l..» upon li.^ Knl.j.'. t tiK-.i .l.M i.-ioii «a- fo.iii.lf.l ..n s 1,1 aii.l uisr foin.ipt..-. an.l that ii hii., .Mil... l,.M-n iv.cimm! an.l oii-lil t.. I..- n...'iv.Ml a- law. nam.-h, tl.ul i, i. „o, l,...a.,-.. a .oM-! ...l.N lo .l.'fian.l i> .lim I.mI a-ainM il..' p.n.'ial iml.li.-. it i-- <\- l-'-^x "■> "Hfn.o l.y r.-asoi. that y» liav.- n..' it. v.mr evo a paitiniiai in.lni.lnal who i.^ lo In- .j.iia.i.l.' I lii.l. p. .,- ilontlv of whi. h it i..^ .p.il.' plain that any .-.m^pii;.. ^ h'^n'-' l"i 'I- purpo-.- to .lofiainl ih..-.' ia.livi.lual^ oi ih' li.'iM'iai p.ihii' «iio ii.;..> U' -a.i"hi h\ it. i.' a . .iiiliiii.n.- .on>pira. y nniil it f^hall hav<- anix.Ml at ih,'i.,uinpli.shnicni ol it- puip.-.' A- ^o..n a^ ih-' paili.ular in- diM.li.al i.~ i.roii'.'ht into. a. t with ihi' .on.-*pirat.i.-. tin' .on.-.piia.A . whi.h l..'lor<- wa.H -,ii.-ial. h. n."- in Iti- "k-^'-- i'' 1 '"".v "■^«' ''"■ •■^- pn..~-ioi,. in.llvi.limliMHl an.l lix.vl. an.l that whi.li wa.s a ...i.-pn... v to .{....■iM. an.l .h-fraii.l tho t'.'neral j.nl.li. h. n.'s a . ..ii>piia. ,v ;■' .lo.oiv.- ami .l..|tauiifnlation, an.l that il iia^ en.h-.l m .1- fraiidinsr tli«' parlio.< to whom it wa» ud.livss.'d. th.- fair and hrit>".ai.' ii.!ei(=.i..> i~ !h:u !h.' i!o«n!i"ii wi..-* that thi- a.t uiiil)i: ■" niaj h.' rehutiwl hy th.' other .•in;uin.sLanc.'.s of the ra.-*t', un.l wh.i'' intention pnt«T» so' latir<>ly into the ..on-i.k'iali..ii of tho .pio^li.'ii ot ,^ilt or inn...i'n.e, lu* il .hK-s in a rhari^o of oonspiracy and fr.nid. mmmmm INTKOlUrCTUKV »»»TK> •.M"« ,( k.coini». imwl iiiiportaul to look to -<>•' whui molivu ..miI.I havf .iirt'iii'oi] ii|M.ii llic MUM. I <>l till' |.iirl\ ■ ImrpMl lu iiiJiuf him toiominit ;li,. iilW-iir.' ,iiii| »<■<• Ar.hlmld'K Liiiii. I'r.. ;;;lid ••■! . p IJHI |, 1(1 < itiiiiiuil l.iiihihli/ liii Lhrnibvutitii >rctMli Ml ol lltf i •nii^inniet 1(7. iwm .nmi Ml ol till' <'..iM|iuiiit-' All I'.tim. ix posiiivr in it> icriii- It -u- iliiii i'\i'r\ |ir(»,'."tii- i.«.«ii('il by i>r on liphiilf of it loiiiiuiiiy. or |,\ .,!■ mi hcliull ol any |MTM)n whi. i.s or lia-" Immui ciiL'iiy^o,! ..r iti- i.'ii'^K-l in till- lormulioii ol a ((iinpuiiy. mu^t ^(ati- ri-rlain thinsri ilii'iiMtliT I'liuiiierativl Tlicii mili-soii. (1 -iiyf* timl in lln' fvi'iit Mj iii.ii-i(iiM|ilii ' . 'Ii any of tlio rfnuiri'iiiiMilji of llii^ ^imihhi. a .liicrioi ..!■ nih : Ml- ' --"oiwilili' for »lio iMvv.xpoctu'^ -hall noi iii.ur iin lialiilifv 1)\ .< <-'■■• i i- •' non-roinpliaiiio if hi- pnnc^ ili.'i ui a.- M'L'urilH 1 M.i'i.'i 111)1 ili~. 1o.mm1 hf «a^ iioi i oLriii-aiil lh«'rf(jl (b> ihf noii-'oiiip!iuinf ..roM' Hum an huncsl iiiisluko ol fni "ii hii- purt ' ; nl 111 ilic ca>i- of a iioii-(IimIo-<'.| inlcrc-i in ihc liiii'ilor- il i proM'd r^iin-t him thai ll<' had knowlcdp' ol ti;o iiialli'lN not di'-i lo-.t'il Thi- x'-ilun . 17.'i. xuimi >, tliou;:li that implied riirht. or the hi' i|i«;il of it. i> wit v\\m>^>\\ o-iven by ihe statute Hut over imi iliove the eivil rom^ily, it i^ a irrll-hiiitirii iiriiiriilf tlii'l a luiin ii.MJi- ilie\^ an Alt of I'urliaineiil «iiiili piv~.iil)es no.iihei- remedy. i.~ liahle to iiiilii imeiil for iiii-deiiieanour l)'r;i. v. I'riie. II V. A K •_•: /,'e7 V !hilf. I IK'.Ui 1 (i H 717 7i;7: Hr-i \ 7'///o/-. i IHC! i Li,i I! .-.9 J. Til. .piestioii whulher the o!ili- for the breach, there i-- nothiiifr sudicient to sl.ow that an iiition loi damaf;*- i- the only remedy open. Tiiercforo, ii person :ts« j'^*-' II 286 IMiOSPKCTUSKS. fCHAP. HI. villi omits ti) |ior ■riininnl nlVpiut'. lonn hi" stiiliiKTv .liily irmv l.<' comniittine iiilo is tluis KMsi'ly i'\|ir<' ',1 III Atti.lc I2» "f SK'pli.'ii |)it;,.-t ..r Ciiiniiial l-iiw K\<>rv(.i ..iiiniils a n vli.. «il('iill\ .li>i>l>''\> ;iiiv sl.iliiK- it liiibiils Ml mil iiltinu 111 ill' :iii\ i> lisiliMiiiMiiniir f III.' ivaliu li\ 1 ;ni 111 llx' Ji'ililii'. mil a|> lis Ipilll I Ik- siatiiH' llial il «a.s tin- iiili'tiliim linn 111 till' l.i'L'i-latiiii |i.i\i(l«' siiiiH' iillii'r |iciiall\ I Till' ill If i- v'''v I /■,//,). . IHUI i! (^ It .•.«•< ili^nlirilit'liri' llMllv I'NIilailKll l>< I'.owi'li I. .1 . Ill rill (fi 111 ihal .a-i- a ilul\ I" ii''''»'" ^ti'imil ICllll lis «as llll|:usc ami a [ii'iuillv wa.s l,\ iln' Alt III' iHi;:; .-.mi. nil a i>>iii|iaii\ li\ -I'll -J, |i i,|,.il l.il- hifatli .if lliv ilii III i.iiU auaiiisi tin' 11)11 iiiaii\ lull airaiiisl the ilii.'.liiis am Kii.n\iiii:l\ a «a- Ih'IiI lliai a ml uilliillv aiillnii/iiii; "!■ I'lllii itliiiLi: (li'I'aiill liriMili '.I' 'III' M'l linn "a« a . i al illi ■A l..ir.l .lu-li :!..». 11 ■ if .1, :ii riMlIll Mil roMlpahV (|..iil.ti'il llml i' '■'"■ ,1 ;i il.ilv 'II H iim|i:iiiv. .1111 ul ll . I il thai if tl„ iliii l:iil .•..iHl'lV W II Il ihi- .lir ■■ liiiii- I if till ttlulll III it a I., It «■; ■ ;rli .,1' illlly. 1 tir-t 1 " it'll 111. \v..l|!.l .1.' Ill -II Il II .a-.- I ill ill. ill iiliiliaiiv ■M i|,.,l .111 l.i-lmlf ■•;■ till' ii|'|. lllllllt lll.ll fri.iiiiii?H .all Mill«t a i.iiiil iliilMliv. all il it liiMiiiii.'- Ill' rlMllilial |. aiv lliiTif. nl.p 111 iiuik.. Ill'' -t. ji- ■a-ininif . I.ar. ihiit w.- -Imulil .XMiiiili. \\r. priiiMisitiiiii am I „■.■ if li .iiiviliiiitr ill i 1. Il «.iiiil 1.1 M.|l III .III if -11' Il ;i rhi :.i ■I -t:llllii' . ri'i nil - ^1 .lalv ll|" iliiliviilila^ li.T-.iiH. il slraiti.'*' r.'-iili int. I a jiiiiii -'. ,f till' liaiv Ill I'. ,,l..'l liv tli. ii|.: 111.' ii'iiii -till ir-in-' iiirniiii'j riinri' ill. a|ial Wli. Mll'l il ,1.' .if IP.. lit wlll'l.' ill.- -IIIUI. I'l il,.' .liii\ .11 111 iii|.a'iy 1 ill' I'lia' tiiii'i ili-.ilii'ili.liii' I'l 1 diri'.t.ir* iir ..llu" i- ..i' tin nf till itiiiijiaiiy t.i ii.aiiilv al liv till- -t itiili'. uiiil III. ili~il..'.'iii'iil .iiiii|i«iiy. mill— I III' <■'• i! l.i 111 iii|iahy ii. Ollli'l Wi'i' |..'ll l|ii« 1^11 all .iillr- 11.' illy l'('-|iiin ■ ill!'.' fill- ill. itii il,.' -I .<"I. I'V ri"| iiliri'iiii'iil- nil iil.l 1.. ,,f .'iifi.r :».; til.. \::\\ iirain-i I't'i' i;i -lli'll ra- kIv I'V i"i ilirllM It uas iIk'i ill that a -.'. li.iii ill an 11, I II. Ill' ilmi' lU II il.ii'- lint II.'. ii»,-.' a I" II. ■ilv lllilivi' I \..| nf riirlianiiiil « lli'll iliri'.i- m 1,1 i|,-,il.,.,li.'ii. .III. '11. ..f 111. nil iin(u'rali\.' a'li \,n\ Il i- ini' I ,1. l.'-lltl ..! Il'itl iiilll|'l .h.ii tli.Ti' .iri' -tatiit" ,1' 1 1,.' \.i «i;l. ill. ivlli.'li ill. 11' I ill.' ri'-ii ill .if i-.i.iiii tili;ilr.'- « • Inly I . ill.' pill '111 111 ■ ilii.'.li. lll- lli.', lull «lii. !i .iiily iiii|.. ,,f th.' -lal.il.' 1 |i.'. illii. Ill' 11 ilivi.liial "li" il' ..I .-iini|.l\ 111 -mil I,. nil. .11 1.1 III. l..'L'i-l.i'iii .iiiiiiil'; it i> "iilv III'' I niplv »illi 111'' Jiri'i'tiiiii'. ill .'iiw il i" a .|iii'stiiMi 1.1 IIIiIm .II,. lll-.lll.'.li. Ill III, nil, .11 I.. |ii iif 111,' -l.iliii i,|, lli.i; if '11.' |i' II, 1..I1-I -illiinit I. ,,f tin- iin-lni.'ti.iil »llHl .11,1. \\i. iniiil. ilifri'l,>r>'. .'xmn. ,,f tin- \.'l. 1.1 I', t, ''7 l.i'fi.r,' if 111. ► Iii'tliir llii' Inii' >ii'" 1 thai thi rl.iiii inalli'l'" w 11 ill',. ill, hi. h .11' III 111- I i„.i I I'l'fiirni ,1 l,v a 1 i|..i.iy wilh Ih III,. r,-ii Il ,,iilv ilial it till' .'iini|iiiiiy il. 1 iii'i l.iria 111. III. il 'aa.v |i,- liy [layiilL' I" ' I 1- II, .1 tin-, thai a |H)siti\r ■lull IU1|1. ..1\ '_.i\.'li I r.iu.ily ilv li'i«i ■• .-r. iiliii 11 i- lilt. 'Ill I'll .III Im.Ii ,iliv . IT alit'l! ir Ihi' m till' ,i>ni|iHiiv anil an a|i|ii' „,',.'.l iil.-tl 111 11, INTKOUIICrOKY NOTja. ■r-n li.,. iiil,r.-l- "f 111'' piihlii-. ami "111' wlii.li i\.-iit ill.- f.iilulc ol lli< ,„ii.|.an.v I' n'liii.ly Willi tiM' riiiuimn.iiH .if tli.- •..•.•ti..ii fmiii ImIiik h ilis^ !.l.,.!liin.', 1.1 111.' I1..V "1.1 :i »r..ii-fii! a.t. ll -.'.'iii' t" «»■ tl.iit «-,t. 'JT « li.-i. ,t i» l,«il,.'.l at. «. f; .- fr..m -.iLiwiiic llmt Hi"' lir.'a.h ..f flif r.-.|uir.-m.Mit'. I.v tin- .„m|.uiiy .'f »<•''♦• •-'« i" ""< " Hiiiil""!"-'"'" '" •'"• !"*• "'"'*" """' ' ''■'"•'.v ■'"»• I i.. aii.l llmt llii" "I'H". 11"! Ii-'l'iiiit t.. tl la--. ..f .a-.'s in wlii. ii 111.- xtatiit.- „„. ii.i.iul til.' I.ri'a.'li ..r il^ iir..vi.i..iis t,. Im' .11. ..tr.ii. .'. I.ut iii.r.lv „t,.ii.N -11. 1, a l.r.'a.i> t" I"' a .•..tiiliti..ii |.r.i .-.l.-iit I., tli.' r.'.'..>.ry »f a l.iirli.ular |..-. iiniary .■..m|..n>atii.ii. Si-.l. '-'T, lli.T.f..r.-. llin.w. liifht ..11 ►..I- Hi. ,i„| ,1m.w- lliii .1 l.r.'a.h ..f ^.-.t. 'ili i< an i.ir,.|i.-.', an.) thai .. |.r...- liiiir ,,ii.l.-i -."I. '.'7 i- a .rimiiial |.r... .'.iliiiL' ll » iiil.l iii.l.'.il I"' a r.'iiiarkalil.' vi.'« .,„ !!.' 1.1-iri-latiir.- t.> talc, tlial ll I.lii.'ali.>ii imp.i-'.'.l "P"" a .■ [.any was ,f .11. h iiatur.' tliaf it- lir.'a.!i liy tin' ..iMi|>ai.y wa-. ii.ii an ..tf.ii.'.'. and y.-l llial ll I ,r ,,r MLiiiaii'T "f ll"' .'.•iii|iaiiy win. •'.'r an ..tfin.-.'. . Tl.. .limMr^ an- I- I"' |.uni«li.'.l if il„v -lan.l l.y aii'l |Mrmil tl..' .• paiiy t.. I"' in .l.-faiill. . . 'I'll.' A. I -ay-. tl.ai .1 ...n.paiiy iliall I"' •H'.t'ik'iI ''I'" .liM'i'l'H - "ii" I'Hl <" I .•iliiiiii ill.' -luliit.iiy >llll^ iMi|i..-<'.l I .1 tlu'lii li\ .-("1 Kl ,ili' . liiiiiiiiil ' ll.'ii.l<'r> Sill. --.Ml. lit. Ill tilt' x'lli.iii favi.iii'-. llii'- \i.'W. Scr .siiimi. p 1 7",i I III nil' iitlu'i' Imiiil i' i- ilillii'iill t.i Ix'lu'Vr. l...ikiiii_.^ I., ill'' A. t 11- ., ,^||I.I.■. lliiil I'arliaim'ul iiili'ii lanj.'im^.f nf iln' x'.ti.iii I I T.i lii'iziii «i'li. Ilif w'.nls ..f llif sfdiiiii ui'c lliiil iIk' |ii-.i- M..-.III- iiiiisl slali-. not llml i'kmv |iri.s|M'.'tiis i.ssiic.l .-liiill sUiU'. iml ill.' "i,|-.| 11111-1' may well, in 'In' .-in iiiii-l.ili' i'-*. I'' M'l.l ..- iiiiciiiiiv i.iii\ s.'" r;<-/..i.- s S(./(/.7r i.'i Apii i i- v.ni '.' Ill ill.' ii.'st |;hi.<' ill.' 1 r iiri-.iii >>\ >'•' 1 HI with -.■' 1 Kl I- a-aiii-l til.' i'l.'a <.l' .liiiiiiiMl lialiilitv Sen S» -Im- a .|iialili.'il ii-lil I'l aili.'ii I'll- ."iiiia'ii-'ali.iii "i ilaiiLiirc" airai'i-t iIih'.I.iI's and ■ih.'i- ill I'l-iH'.t mT .'Vci-x uiirnif ■•l.il"!':.'lit in a |iiii-|mt|ii«. Iml II iiii|ii-i- ii'i criiniiial li.il.ilii_\ . ami il wnulil 1m' . ■.|i'iin>r' lliiiiL' if. iii'iiiT thai -.•.tii.ii, lli.'ic -1 I'l I"' ii'i 'li'iiinal tialuliiy Im | ■.-iliv.- lui— lal.iii.'ii!-. «liil>l iiikI. r M'll, SI ill. 'I.' ■.Ii'iiil'l I"' u .liniiiial lia liliu fur till- mil. ll iniiK' \ciiial .iricii. c .'f nnii'liiiL' 1" li- l"-<' -"'ni' III anii'liir^l liif niiil'ilii.li' S1 1,1 III.' All. Iix uli'h in |i'i-.ii i-iAiii'j .iii\ i.'liini. lt'|."il. .■.•rllli.al.'. halai- .'--In'i-I. .'i "IIk'I .hi' h- 11;. ill i."|iiin'.l li\ .11- f.ii ill.' |;iii'iMiHi«- 'll ih.' |.iiivi-i..ii- "I tin' A. 1 -ii.ili I il llic Kiflh S.h.'liil.' Ihi'n'li.. wilfully mak.'- a -lalt'in.'ii' 'll-' ill am malri'ial |iaili' iilur kii'Hvin;; il I' !»' fal-.'. 1^ Ki ^ .iiilu ..; I iiii-il.'ini-an.'iti' ami I" ' ' liublv In iniivi. linn un in.li' ii. Ill III (luni.'ihuicnt ivccordingly). ■M>< i'K<)SHK.rrusj'>. [Chav. III. -IM tinll ilk 14 to /»' ■»'"''■ !•' ual >»"i^i imU- as a ma \iMiiiiii |miii>li"i''iil ,vl.o l.v aiiv laN- i.ifl.'.i.v: i.liiaiiis fii'iii aii\ [.|iull«'l, luonovs. or va ^.,1. m of itio Laictiiy liiaMf r*«'i iinl' V with iiiHMil Art iHCi 21 .V :!•■. Viit. iillltT |H-l>oll UIH Id i.'irauil. Set' [Mil To -^iiiiiiort . li:ii<'«' ol' ol.lainiiii.' mom-x 1,\ lalx' )i"'l 1,1 uluiw ai I'liininal miml fii.-l. tlial lio I lid tli«'H't'oic a ll,..i- llial iIk' 1'"' ell'-*'-. i>i- «i(li ■.laH'i 1 -.,,iii«tliiiiK » lii.h il UiH' till so with iuiviit I,, JllOi HIT tlio 1'"'^"' .1 wiiKi'.l anil \vuiilxiMiii(r ,iiiii of nionov. Ii.ii III- kiu' hi- siaii'iiKMit »a- iil is to .sa> thai so t'ur ajt his iiiiii< •il. la- iii'<'i .l<>< h« 1 ri I lllol hat ho .liil th.>i.'l.x ..Uiaii. moii.-v that till' ~l.«U'iiu'iil la.t 1 i(UV» V iiurm- ill 'hi- ~<'ti-«" ,f iK'ili'-' ili'orifrl I'.ICII. 1, .1 V lf,,k\ I IS'.H (ba: the uHtruo s .1. «/"■(" ,/ 2tt. 1^ 1). ;iH,al.lH. .,1 ill V" 1,1 the lasl iiifiilioiKM 1 ..iMi it a|;|)i hail U I lie lU-lVli'huii l.i.iil Kiis-i liliiii'iiitr I del. iiaai.l had -.lubliHli.-'i an a.lv latciiKMits, am l,ill.-."ll to 1^ lviTlis«>mii iha! sui 11 1 Il iH.'r»'iii nil t h». faith ol tlu- laU- iiriM.'ii.H. | ■ «i iiiililir:i- Ti hoi"*- kiiowl*»lk'«' >l ""*> liivlTtlVllK'Ill I' I iiiiif and "lio i.IiIk th I III all jcrsoii*' Il nil it il.'-iri' Il ,i| if a lairtiiiiliii 1" „1 .„... Ill th« jaT- alu'i' si'i'iii',; iir hfiiiiit; "I " •"•' "I' from w iiiiiii H iiriiif'-'l-. uiii I u,. ■11 tin ijii 11 faith ..1 11 1 irl.s « iilai \A iih hi- iii'iiov \U" i- ol s a Iran ,i i.ii I hal if ]•• ,-,111- \>'r vili'iiii iiiloui A^ to crimiiia l,.,i ■ An.l.s.v Ar.hl..'hrst 1 i.,(i-<'. iitioiis iliii'i it'i 1- :;iiil i'|> il liv ihf I "lilt III ,Mii'luii;-iil> ,.lll||lllls(l> V iiluiitarv, «»•<• (•..iii|i \.l I'MIS. - Jl' UlK \V !iii'_'-ii|i I'r rt 11 w INTKODUtTORY VOtVM. •,':iM How Disclosures should be made. T dill 1)1 •< I 1.1' t U>l I 1,0 n....le in *vhi. 1, .lis, l.,-..|-..s shoul.l U< "udo l.v prumoU-r- ,,.|(.r-> 111(1 olliors, to tlio .•..mijuiiy uii.l to iK^^rsoiir* i.iv.lo.i i^ ,.,„. sl.an-li.iM.TS Miust ,11 ,>..iiM. .i.>iK-iul „.. llio oin^uinslame. lie ,a-f. l.ul iLor.' aro m.iu.- ..slal.lisl.,.,1 i,.iii,ipl-* «h..li sh.ml.l l.niiio ill liiiii'l. "lul in imrlii uluf iIk- l,.lli>\viiii;; ■riiat ai.v , ilili-'" "'.iinriiii: nr l.liulinv' aii.v appliiint lor ,|,an'> ..I .U'UMiliin- I,. waiM' ,«ini.liun,<' with ruim-iit or iiialt«-r iiol sp<', Hi, ally rt'lVrn'.l to i„ ||„. ,„„s,K.,lM-< -hall ho v.ii.l ■• S<',t «| . :, , of .l»- <'oii»- laiiios A-« of some fa,-t- with rcjranl to this .■oiilia.t «hi,h api-'ar 1o mo 1o !«' of irivat ihipi.rtaiiii- Tho i.impany ua-i iiilormo.j . IVr Lonl Cairns. I. (' . /•>'/!» /'•'■ v \i-ir s.,t,ihi.'n, r,, ;l A| p ''■>■' I2IH \'2-V.' :; riiai ,li~.| n> 1.. ih.' ■ p.>ii> i- ii"l ' arily ilKMli-rl-.-ur.- villi, h i- ii'ipiiiv.l to I ia».voi ii..fivirtMrtl- who !,„■ ||„- timo l,iiipa»v i- t^a*' suoh iIk.i ihov .-shHM*''*!*^- »•' tho por^'iiis «li,im 'In- ,..iiipaii\ i- iin«"fwl««-»4>r-, lif (IlltV '// .ih'Mil t. ilato,! -harohohi'T- 1','r Collin". I. I in Is In all till- pt-rsiMi-i who aro t,> Im> .iinloiii| l.t,l . . |X!'H. : c I.-..!. I. 1 Tli.ii .i| art from till- A, I .,1 I'.iOH, v\ri\ iiiotiilrtT ,if a , oinpanv is ■ tifiiwil I'l ha\,' ii'iti-i' oi tho iilfiil- ',1 tho iiiiMiioran,l>Jiii .IlK irio if a-, ii'iali<:|i. an I ,.1 ►inra.l- .In in wi I I iiliiil liiiil '' ,f » t'Hi'CUf'hl \ ri,. I. n 2 II. I. ',''.1. I'J.I h/ v Suffinlh. I, H I, in< PM. /•> jjurtt^ tt,llu!::i- -J K,| 1\H. F.'tnl i>i Tttrlti'ij \ muiimiii •i F^, /', H'h i,T4, Ur.fhth \ Paget i'^< U ill. 24*» j'HtwHwriimEs. rCiiAP. 111. f i- M fi .. vtl -I... 4u.M.lu,l.l...> ... .1.. ..-.*<"•> '"-' ''•-• i'"!--"" """" ,.,..|..m .a.i Hrl.rU-> ..t ,.^^.. mn.,„ I .-. 1..-..I . • 1- l„«.«. I, < Cniiiihrlls r,i>. . ■•• < li ' . ' „.,.,„ ... I.„»l :*.- -'- 1 a. u.allv iM-nn,.. .- r^: .':«...!.::. .-... .au.... > m "-• i*^- ' , ,,,„,..- ... :...........■.. vlv 1.-. uu... 1... 1...1 ..... MU'..... " -. l"l .; " , „ ,,. „..,.„ ...,„aii.x M,.....i ... -I."' " • •"" '""';'■•"■ :--->• -"-''•-'-:•::::!: r:;::i::'::;':;;i' it tl-.M— ....—;- ;;;:7;'"; ' T..h.S!..> . "- 1.."-.-"- -'^''■^'•••'''''''•'''ir::;;:: ,„..ri. .»■ N..- .-,.-.•..-" ■'" '"■■ ■•" "■; ^""':',. J . -,, TT ?,<'/.'„,/ ' .. ■" I".'.-""'- ^ '"-•'• ""* "■ '";'■ -.iMTtu^. .mta.it*.'! !iii»*»f«'*^'"B"'"" . 1 , ,„, r,..„..M 4.. .h.. ...i. «.ii 'v- -PI- '" "••■ '*''-^- •; "" ■ ''"'""' ,1,^, !,,.«. 11 »..litti ".•I'll. r«»«* tW«. .\ ' JT.- Tl,.r..l- —...l.<-.-.a...iv «...'-. MM' • P'",, . J,iuu.>..lv.. .1. ,..,...,..-, ""-' nlv u,.|Ml... .■.■.,.....■....•.■..-... -H «l '- ■' ' " , ;)-.^«.. i;)l|..M I I , Ki ,.i ilif \|.| .'I i.""*. <•^'•.^ |...|— ..1 »li. • "t.;'!: ■ i-f .-;■;;; .1.... I. .......■• ." ......•..-■■'■'- ""'^;' ;■' ,„i,.., .1 ■..' •■ii''"'i '"■ "-I " ^ ''"• ' • , ,i ..,. ^.. ...."' - ■ T"^:'';. : T ,,..... . I... ....'I"-'-'"-'' -•"""";"•' ;7:j;;;;ri, INTKODUCIORY NOTIM. •i4i a lourl of JuBtic*' they niuiiol coiii|»luiii thul ihoy did not see it, but must Ik,' tioatod i»» hilviuj; noliie of its loiiti'iitif) lli»\v would have found u r.'. itul of tJic toiitrutt froui C. to K. ouiilliiiK tlu' pri.c. .Wic Soiiihnro Cu. v. KrUin;irr. '» t' l>iv 111 Aiul ill iIk- Houm- of Lord-, in lh<' numk- viun> ..I A|.|». Ca.v l:JHi»i. l,„rd HUi.- not upplv; lor wluMi inou issu.- u prospirtus in wliich ihi'v iM.ikr tuU' »tat«Mi«'nl« of the .onlra.t^ umde before the fotiuatioii „l i^ , ,,auv, aud then nay that the eoiitraet** theumelve.- may be m.-pe. ted at the ofh.es of the sdli.ilors. it ha- ulway.-* Imhui held that ,1,,,.,. ul,.. a.cepi.d ihox- ful-e Maleiuei.l- u- true were m.l .bprive.1 ,1 their reuiedv inerelv be. auw lhe> nejjlo.ted lo p. and biok al |,e,eulia.l,< " I'e. .leM*el, M l{ . I{e,i.,nuc y //Hr,/. IIO ( ' Div M \„.l ,i.e -ante b-aine.! jud-e aibb-d >»//.7/l v. ( h.idiHA'. :.MI fh 1) :: li ha.- al»..\- I II liel-l. and, 1 think, rijrbliv hel.l. that it a ,,.„ ,n a p. -IM.. !u.- lul-ely Maten the .nntenl- ..1 a written do. nt l„. ,.,,iho' . >.i,p,- ti -If h f.iNo >lateineiii \>\ ^a^in;r; 1 olVeio.l to -l,o» v.i, the d.MuiiifUl Hut if he nuike un incomplete htaliMiient . .liiiiL^'ther Iruo but imperlei t I take it he ran." ( hrt»iri. «her»' fnn..lulen1 iiil<-nt is er*tabli^h.' ili" <'^>' witiiin lb- -ame rule. ailh..uy:h tbefe ma\ U. i„..|..wnrmbi lal,eh..o.l <./„, /,.W.v« \ /*." m > \wn .\ ^ JUL l)i>. I.^niv. .• ./ b> a promoter ..I liio pi. 'lit b.^ I- in..kin..; um-i b- ■.. III.. .-bar.-h..Mer> as a UkK Um-Iosui.' to a sele.i <-ir,\r of tiu' |,i,, let,- ..\\n iioiiiiii»»'- will not a'ail. '''('/ Ollermir iiu«l-^ 'ton ■.( u luuteiiul .-«liw will no' .Ib.iil pi.,t... li..ii ... j».i>Mi,.- i.4HUins pri*!*. iu»«'- *tler ;l-i !»...eiiiber. I'."'", where the .1.1!...- and partie- ar^ IK.t, staled in u...HiUn..' with -o. t HI. .-iib- M-t I k' of tlie \ii of I'JOH: a».t ».. waiver . I.iu". ..m . me tiii- .Iclci S<.cl HI . 4 .\..or.iiii-h. when pr..iiiot.'i- iiiK'ii.l i.i ..l.iaiii .i pn.li' ..i ih.i <.ih..i I,. I.- «bi. b ..u^fhl t.. b.. .|i«l..s..d, i> is ..%,M..|i.-.>i t.. .ii-.l-.-e il..i„ bs the pr<»'iH.ttuM ami al*. bv tho arli.k* .■^' -e. t HI • 1 ' if I 1.1 IJM' I ■inpanies .\,t. I'.MIH It it i- iMip.w.-lble to «!al.. th.-iii Inllv II, tl... pr..>p(..tu-. they sh..uM be .liM.!-.-.-.! in tli" aneb--. or at aiiv rule 111 .-oiiH. ...ntra.l ih.-t. in r..|erre.l t.. an.l nll.-r«i l.v the pr.np. .Iil- li.i iii.iM-li..ti .\n.| It may uIm. be .•xp.-.lient. both in the pi..-i«'.iu- aii.l .iiti. I..- |., -tut.' llial appli.antH are to be deem.-.! t.. Iiu\. no i.-.' of the n.ntBul* of tia- loairtt.! But "... It eiu.e utii'{.iUi:cTs ol n..M pHorvatioii. oral .(lisil.isiir.', il i" w( fCnAl'. III. lliiit liaviiiL' rc'.'iircl >|| in lil< oil tlii< -all' side, ami I" !>« "V<'r-(a 1,11.1 laili.T I hail not to 1.0 .aiidi-l I'liuii-li. I ill. reqiiiniti 111 ti:imiii|r ^tat.iimi' .'t Till' f'liv iiii|>..rlain I' liMTvalioiis arc miMick-ii '.iin;^' nil*'' iif fiaiiiiiil.' tli<' IT""!" I, ,o <|h,w tin' cMromi- itiis Willi tlio iimi i)^t iili"' Siiiii'. lilt .Iniiiintr »'"' I.- r.. i.ini' of iiiH IM'iliaiw. Ik' '"><'" I uitli. lit .lnii'_'<'r; lait il .i loilakiiiir i- ■' I""""" :ii|l^ olli'. •VI til n-al iiH'i'it- lijerlc iiioiiciatt" H(r.r,.i;|| |..| SiMt MM'III to I.IK' i.|i.Tallv l.iill" ,1 to Ix' til." iiio>t attriMtiv.' |l,..^l'|.« -M-| .11 »illi III' .,.,U-r-i.uii.l.Mlaii.|.l«'l'"iil^ il-i l-A- HII ol' 1 |„. A.I ol' I'.iit.-*. ami II"' pirliiniiian "oi lis (if MN.| si, sliow thai I. >lli iIk' '""•" ,, jilv lo i,ro-l)<'...t. I l.a Hut. itxl-'l I aii.l if tlii- i> til'' ""'■'■"•'•• "»'-•>•'"- u-l 1..' -lat.'i! ill 111'- pi—l""''"^ ,.,,„.„.l.Miilv..ftli.'A.'tof 1!M>S. ,tii> I- 1--II"'' I l„.f..r.> tlic mI. ..rt'ut I'lin- .-III li.iiil.l U' laU.'ii ill "I;'! j„,,^,.i| ..iiii|i' f..i It 1 |„. ..l.jvit- ol tin ,aiiv liaH lioi'ii iT'.'i' i„,_,. ||„. olijct.s of till' I'l''- vIlTcl iiiiiaiiv vvlii'li ..I ol ilitli'i' II ,ll\ li.iiii llio^<' .tal.'d ill '111' l>i"-l'<"t'i- '>!• lituiil.'^ iiia^ 1,,. abli' t I I'll"- alloiiii.'iii. or K. r.-pii-liaf 'I"'" ^liart'w afii'i- alloiiii-'iil. i- ,\i,|..il lli.'v ail' II .1 .jriiillv II K. •U.'!; >l<'inii I's iitxi r.cax,'. 2.-i(Hialioii Bill, a.'* .1 hi'a.lv iiicinioiif'l Mi/"^'. I' lill ;. llii- i-.liiio-t iinaiiiilil' |, III. I ill' at iIk- iiK'M'ii li,.ii of till' ..iiiipaiiv. an. Ii.iii of ill" I .lav is I.I 1- tln- iii(.-|«'iui~ .("!•' II, ;■ IJK' fiTlllil- wli.'rc tin- pro>l" .Ills i~ iiol i^-ii< .1 II I.I I )((.'( IIk' f "iiiia iiii|.aii> . ••<'' i;iiiK rc'iiiii"'- t hat i'h' loiiK 111..; of iIk' iiH'iiioiaii ivhi.h .-lat. IlllLsllCI III-. tl„. .ilij.TH ol III iiili.itt' wln'i<'l<'il toapi il\ t.. Ill' Ni.i.k K\'-li.iii'."' I'"!" K\.l.i.ii>!' ,j .(.tilciiiciit o!' .|iiolatioii ol I Ik- .«liai'«'^ i.ll<'i«"l f..iMil.-.ri|ili'>ii II ..siii'i 111- ii i- iiiMi'ssi IV to imlinl<' in iIk' pi '*1> ii.iiior.imliiiii ,f i,.-'"ialioii of thi- ...mlKiii ill ill'' , 111- n "M'v of ilii' It li.i- lii'i'ii u-iiall*- il .'III- iiii il ii.av ^lill I"'. I'liiil''' 1 wilhiii tin- lol'l "' '111' l""-|i'""'- I o||.- iliilalioin .\'l- I!"'**- «1. Mill-- 1 |oiiml<'l- "< liiaiia'.: "Ill -haix"'. tilt' ri'iMiii'Hii'ii Wiii'ii ili.i'' it- ,,(■ 111" .laii-. la.-l ii'fi'm'.l to iiiii-t r.i-.'iM'< 1 h'oi .'SI ,1 KmIi.11. M'l- //((/.(. ]< -'>■'■ U.vi.w l.v .. In i:I)r(T'>KY NOTKS. Wi i- ,„ :,,,,...,. 1- tl,.,.ii. -I I h■i^, l.,.|..,-,. I,MM th.. r..ll..u,,..j: y- .1 ,| l|,n,.|li,. i.'.|"i>-lM>'nI> Ml >...l H[ Mtlli.t ,.,„|.;iiii..- \M. I'.H.S. 1„..M ...in|.lir.l Willi. Mini lla^<• ^"<> ''■''i' n'l^ i-'''l I'.v """- lii'K'Ilt IMTMiIl- tlli't III'" '^ ~"' ,J A,,. .,11 ill,' -lill.MIK'lll- ill lllC |ll..-|-llll- nil.' tu \..M1 o«ll (."•■"It'll:-'''- IKiv.' Mill .-i'«'ii iIk' mine Ml (.i-..i>i'il\ - lla\« \ .11 I'Viiiiiiiii'il till' Im.iiI,-. Ai - ,.;. A> Mvar.U lli'ix' -lal.'iii.'iiK wlii. Ii .iiv ii"l mi'' i" '""< ""i' kii .«li'.lj-'<-, vvlial .'\i.l«'ii.v iJM v" "'^ "" ■'•■* .l>'-'i',^"'- '•"' ^1 liH'Ilt,- I).. V..U 1.1'lifM' III-' :'lat<>lll<>ll(.- In hi' till.'. iMl.l i|- .-(.. vvlial ar<> tlu' u'li.mnl- 'if \"'"' l'''liL'f- \ i<' iIu'n ri'a.-niialil.'/ \Vnul>' l'arl\. arc xou >ati-lii'.l m tak.' tii<' li.-k III* alln|itiiiirlii< viiit.'in.'iil-'aii'l iiiaUiiiir ila'iii MMirmvn \\,,lllll il II. •! I..' 'M-l'l I" ivukI ilii- r.-i -liiiliU - Si-,' -/•'■' I' '■■•■ ,.-,1 II ilii- |ii"-|i.'rliiN ii'iilaiii- .xlia.t^ Iroiii aii^ i<'lii>rl> i.i olli.r .I.MiiiiH'iili-. ail' till- I'slniil- .'.iri.'it' ami i-< tlii'i.' aiiMliiii'^ 11, ilir ,-,,iiti'\t "hill '-'Ill ill tairn.'f^-' I" In' -tat.',!' S.iiii.'- liiiii-' an cxtia't vviilnml ll'.i- i .nili'vt i.-- iiii-il<'!iilin'j:. ,ti, lluc.> III.' |,n..i,...ni- ^lali' lliat -' ininli i- li> Ix' paiil mr tin- l„i.|«'ri\ aIiiii In vniii- I. iiovv li'i l-t' il lai'ifv i.ait of l!i.' prirt) I.- .jniir_' In iIk- inoMi \<'f If -'. Ill'- "lali I I ina,\ •ininiinl In a nii.-ri'iii'-i'nlalinii. inili'|x'iiiili- M'. 1 ■ \ ■ j- nt' til.' A.I ..t l!"m ,;, A,,. ,,n n| th.' ilir.'.tni- intJ-i.'.-i.'.l .i- x.'n.lni-. nia- liaviirj ■,U,\ aL'-ll'I'lll'-llI ""111 111"' N.'ll'lnl-- nr pinlllnl.'l" ..I' nl II,'! « l-'>. ;iii.l. ir .-n, il..,.. ihi' in-.-i Ill- .li-cl'i-i' ill" lad- An, I -^co :-..,, M, Mil,- .1 . I , nl lllf All nf lllim ,H All- llinrc an\ ;..at«'rial i.intrail.* »lii.li ai-.' imI .-|Mv ilii',!' St-o mtI Nl, viil.--.Tt. I 1 ' k ' .!», llaM' \nll ;illV .^l|i II innlni' I ill tin' < a-" nf \nlll ' nl|l;iall\ '' D'l .nil .Innv a 'li'^lim limi Im'Ih.'i'ii a l.iinliii'j- I'.nira.l ami a iiiiiv nnil'T^ianilin.^' «lii.li \nn .n.il.l imt i-nf'ir.". I'lil liav ,,,, ijniihl Hill I iiri,'.| inin I'lV.- I' Tin- < 'iiii- aiv -ml .ilu.n.- |i|.'|iar''laii.l llial if lli.Ti' l- an" ii.iii.i.' a, t< -n.-iil in till |,i...s|M', iii~. nl- ill an\ r.-|inil m iin'inni.in.liiMi ciiilin.lii'd ili.niii "t Ls^ui'i! tli(>r('tii>, inil may lie li.'l.l liaMi' ill .a. li 1. 1 inn In |.a\ , .ini|M'ii(iati,)li uiilo>-* vini rail cstalilisk 11 :• i r i si J- -I 244 PROSPECTUSES. rCUAl-. 111. to nniuuil f ,1.., .l«f..iiro.- abov*. n.tcrr.Hl to ( PI' >'•»«• I'-'""' "'»'» r iX 'L^' In - «.Uo„. a... P....U >-• inilirU"*! for a iiiuMloiiioaiiour :• „. i.:': ™ "-;"v:; ;:r,r:::;v'i/;: »".':: 111' iH'lii'fV Circular disclosing MisrepresenUtion. ,.ro ..U..U.. o. > 1- '"'■'7""^.; "/ , ,, ■„, .1..- >' ■'<• :;;;:„t'r:;:;,;:;;:: ;:''-" ;!r-;;..::'t ^ the ii^l.t o« re«i-Moi., » i l .^ ^ u„f„iiii.- ...>i...i>. ■'''j-'-''''''^'''-;i^ .: !!...J.... r.i,.. wmMlu-. m,.u...v. ....... ,....„l..l> ..M . n.„ i:::,;rwt;.r=;::":'-:.:;:.:.-^ ' «lH.r.. .he ,Mu.,K-,.s ol ,..0 .u...,.,u.v .m k .,i.,.|n>ur.' -a^ i" '•■^■■v'''>'-"''r::.:::^:-i:;;"..'t ;.::;: .- ■.'"-- :;:';;: H;r;:::s:;:;':t.,.....^o...--^ -"- Act of l'..OK, r.., I...i..>f 'I'" prov.s.o... o. .hi '^"" ' ' . . 7 U .. J...< ..—'■■V 't.al i. sho,.M n... ...orol.v s.a.o .h. 1.. ^ shoi.h! a!o ......lain un olh-i .o r. -. l. a m aa iSE»jL2o INTRoniTCTOKY NOTV>. 346 , „, ,., .hiM effect. We havo .lo...ivo.... :,. Lv.. vour mouoy back,' .l.o .a., ^vonkl h.v h„..,.1 vo, v , hll.- ,v a..il 1 re«,n-. my opinion «« .o «h«. wo,. I .hen hu... ;H., .ours.. f..r.l...<"ur. ....ak.. I. .m.x ..• ,l.a. m. ..., h .. „ .. ,; W..U1.I I* hold n... .v.,..na..U. U. -h- ,,hu N ... •„.. .... ;„h .lu.ir evOH op.n ami in.u. fu.-.h. ..- L - '-< '- "■ 'j'- li ...inion .,n .ha. .a-se; in n.y ..,.»"'... """ -'"• '" """-"■ "r"* " ,.UM I .10 no. a^^m. .ha. .ho .ir.uhir pu. a.,v ..no .n iho p..s,. !f kno«.».^ .he ....... fa.'s of .ho ..imo. llof-r- .o.ornn^r «. .I." ■I' — „, I «il. obsorvo ,ha.. a.^um.n^^ u ..u,..l ... h,..- I - ...u.M.. 1, „,;„....lv .^stH on .hoso «h., .olio.l .... a ,..b,..,,,...... .xpla.,......, , ,|,„„ ,1.,;, ...-h oxr.lana..un w.»s .,..i,o . lo... 1. .ho ,|..o. .o.« ba.l „,,,.,..o.l ..f wl.a. .hov haa .lono. an.l ha-i U b-.-.-i.^ ol n...ku.l: ;„ ,,..,. ,hov vv..ul.i havo .aiUMl .he a..o,.,i..n ... .ho ,.!:...... IW ... ,1,, u.. .hat .her« was a soriou. error in .ho ,,ro.«p.-. n.. , H... ,„„k al .he -in'ular .i. a whoU. ... No a.l.n.s^o... ... ......ak.. .s „,.lo bu. .he inforiua.io.. is «ivon, -o ... sa.v. .......h..,...ll.v ... .he n.;.Moiaun.uU.rof...horma.lers N ,ha, ,ho ... ... wi-.-h ,h.. wlor. of a f.a...i..U.... ...isMalo.nont is ... bo i.".: ...I .'I ' "• ,„.,..,,..s up,M.a.s .„ ...o ,o huso boon ,lraw.. ..,. ...b .h- ..".-' LsLu^ a wronvt in.p.e.-..M. ..n.lor «,..,ls s..lh.......l.v no.u- .ho ,r,„b''.. .>s.apo boins; ..va-c.l a- a ini^ro,,. ...- • an.l I ib.nk : „ ,1... (iiTular was f.un.o.i rM.I. a -in.ilar n.o«. l. .vool bn..-....- ,.,',1,0 .nin.ls of .ho phiin.it.s ,ho real ia.ts of .ho mso, «h.ls. .Ma....- ,.„,„,,,. ,„ o..abh. .ho .U.fon.tan.s ,o sa> .h,U -ho lh......lU w.-o ,n.-ormo.l of .hos« fa..s. I .hinU. .ho.ofo.o. .ha. tho . ... ..bvr -b..- a„, M.or the .asc. a..d .ha. .ho a|,,.oal .....s. bo .l.s.,.,^,o.| ||,„ .\,.t of H...H, s. SI. ,„OM.n.s s„,„o f.„lhor ,1.11,. ..It...s ... Ow „av ;< ...rinK delo, .s in p,..^, .uses ,h. ....b non- o...,,l.an. .. «„h I, i, „r urroa. i...po.-.an.o .o ..b.a... s„,..o a-k...... lo.l._' ■■■< .ho ra,. ...• .1... ^haroh,.l.lor of .he .o-vipt of .bo , i,.„i,.r. m., ... o.dor ... b....l b„n, k,..,«lo.l«o ..f .he fa...s ...„s. iH. b.„....'b. b..M.o ,.. b.,„ .. howovr, .. .«n U. provNi bv his .».l.,...sio,. ..r o.horu.so ihal Ihe cir. ,.lu, .on. ho.| hi,., ho «ill iH' p..' 'V. 1 '.■ "^— •'•"' " '"■'>"'''" p,„ i, i- „o. cno„Kh, ,o IVaiso... .1.. hob! in l.'.,.h» ,.(fon/- ■ 1 ami... i.»'n>|-"> ;- - ku..«lo.lu'o of .1.0 lr..o fa.-.s has 1 n b...UKb. 1...... h..,. Ass..,..- int' i>, ami SMU>r.Uun' i „ . .o have bo.-., well .1... ..lo.l. .. sh..«8 the ;:roul i.npor.an.e of pio,..rinB evi.len.o of .he roo.-.pt bv iho ,hHr..|,..Mer of the noli.* This ...ay of.on \w olT... . d by sending S_ 240 PKOHFKCTUblW. [ClUI'. III. „„h ,1a. ......lu. ........ ....... <«.t,.rri,.« u. .I.«- . n.uU. . ,.- .• M«..ed aad .o..ir,.c..l WI.e.. u,. um.-ur.M-y ... .!..• l...-,...e.u, ,. .I.MUvored l,.f..n. ,.ll.....»..-. .1... .»llo,„.t.... I..n..-. ...uv ........... u -U.U......... CO,. ,., alt. ^vl... ,.iv. hi. .ill.......'... ..........V, Lul ul. ....^1.. ....U-h. the „ i; i. vcrv ...nou... ihc .......bo. -I all.-.. •'" «'" ■"•""'""• nZ IH, -.nu.ll. i. -....- v.r.v d....l.t...l wh.-.l.." .1... -"'••";;"'- ■-; «i,l.... .1... I r..l..l.i.i.... ol -..l— -t .».. :...-! "—'I' ^-"•' »t; PHKCKDKN'I'S. Til.- -iih-'criplioii list will "IM'h "" , luM (ir l><'K)n> ■"lay tin- tlllV llf .l:t\ i>l A., B., C. 4 Co., Limtd lmo.,M.iut.vi i.H.l.'t 111.- Co.. A.i^. IN.;:: I.. I'.'".. ( apiliil i . .Ii\itl<'Uu■ l.nlui.nll.il .ilM- l,,„| ,,! li..' ..it.- '>< I" I' " "" "'"• •■•'l'i'"» '"'• '»«' '""" ^'"^ , ,|,..,,.„„. an.l nink, Loth ..- •-.•un.-.U .iui.l-...l and .aiHlal. u. „ u, />„„,,„/„.. I ..1..,. .1..- ..... .. ..f .1.- .V.t ... l»i.H .,r|,..r«.«. „,,.,r,.. ■•,l....A,,r,..i.H. ■,.r...|H-.>..-- m-.i- -".> ,.r..,p,..-.,... ■„.,..■... cm-uUr „i;,„i,..m...,t. .., r i.ni.uti..,.. ..ll. rU.,, to ll.- l.ul.l.. f-r s«l...r.,.t...,. .,r ,,u,.l,.... any -l.ar l.-l-....- f a ,• any •: .....I - .1..' --1 "' ll„. .(„,>.. t..r.n ..f ,,r..Hi..- 1..' i' fra"'.-.! •!"- " >'-* "' •""•'-••""- "■' ,„.,,„ ,1 ..|..ra.i..n ..f --t M .-f tl..' A-t *'...l. a,.,.li.'. I- ' .wtv ,,n..|- <"^ ;,.„.,, r n, Imll ..f a ,on.,.a„y. ..r l.y ... .... .» >.air ..f '."> l-.r-..'. *l- •• „ 1 „ ■.„:_.aL-..f ..r i..t.r.-,l.-.l ii. H"' f..r.i.al,.m ..f tlir .•..mi.ai.v. • N'-l »•. "trll-' l.-t. M. .ub-,.-.t. ,7,. ..1...:. l....w,l.- • Tlu. ..-..".. Hh.a.. ...a .,.,,h t., a -ir.ulur ..r imti.- i..>it...« .^i-'int-' •"•>••'■■•'' '"■ J-l""'""- '"••''■■■' „;V...mi.a..v U. »ul.«ril.. ,.,.l,er f..r .l.ar.., or .l.t,.M,tur.-.. «l..tl..r -.1. or .„ , tl n«l.t to r..,,,,,,, M, fa.our „t u,l...r ,..t~.,.s l-.t. -..l-J.-t a, afur.- ^,,1 ,l„. ,.v„o.. -hall a,.,.l,v I" a..y (.r -.•.,., wlHtl..r .«...hI .r »Mtl, nil.. I.... I.I 111.' r.iriimtiiiu oi a ...iiiiwtiy o.- MiliMija. ..lly \„„ „l-i. ihat liy ^.ili- I IM "•''•"'• n.|uir..m.-nt._i.f tl,i> -.•.no" nr.. .li- i*u..,i ».thor .iualiH.Kl in |.arii.uUr .a..-.. (S...- i.|.. 171. I .a. ! A.v lomlition n..,,iirui« or l....ain;r any a,.pli.a>,t f-r .liar-, or .l.-Uiilurc. V, .a m,ili..i... «illi any r,.,u.>...... nt of llii. -i- ti. r ,iur,H,rtinK t-. .«„, will, iioti f aay .-onlrait. .li-iini.-nl . or .t.r n.it ,,a.-.h.-.lly rrl.rra.1 L. in tl,.- ,.ro.,«M.tu.. .I.all !«.• voi.l. in to i/et the xhares. e.g.. tlie founders' or inanaifemontj shares liave been miliscribod by the vendors and the principal eniphiyes in tlie business, and will be pd up in cosh]. Of the above sluinvs, — ordinary shares and proferenic shares ocjual to t'— an; to be is^ueil and creililed as pd up. and a- below mentioned the reniaininy: shares are now olVered for i)ublii' subscription, payable as follows: lo.s-. ()(/. i)er share on applicatinn. 1/. lo.v [)(i. per shine on allotment, \l. Itt.v Or/ |)er share on the of \l. lOv. 0(/ per share on the of The shares may be pd up in full on allotment on or before the day of , interest at the rate of .'> p.c.p.a. being allowed in respect of the prepayment id' instalmcnis. Applications have already been received from the employes of the lirm and relations of the late partners for shares e<(ual to £ . The rig-lit rf voting at general meetings is one vole for every two preference shares, and one vote for every ordinary share, and ten votes for every founilers' sliare(c). Directors i rf). Sames!, AitdreKxrn, ami I)i:.rs Mdiiiex and Addresses.} 3 1 i $ I f 'i I 'Ji. II: ' .\uditors I f/i. Saiiiex. Addre.'ises, and Dfii(rii>lion.s\} (li) FoiiiidiTs' LShnrt'.'. The prospectus must stnte the nuiiil>cr of fduiiilcrs' or maniiitomciit .•(hares, if any, and the nature and extent of the interest (if the holders in tlie property and prolits of lhi> eomp;iny. (Sect. H\ (11 (ii;.) \s to founders' shares, sw pp. 587, 810. (el Tlir Hlf/hl n< )■"';«;/. --Where there are several classes of shares the prospectus must state the riifht of votini; conferred by the shares of such cla-s. (Sect. 81 U) <") of the .\et of 1908.) ((/; DirccldiH ami .(((rf.Vor.<.— The prospectus must state the names, descrip- tions, and addresses of the directors or proposed directors, and the names and »ddrcssei. of the auditors (if any). (Sect. 81 O) fe) and (I) of the .\et of ISOS.) But it must he liorne in mind that, having reirard to sect. 72 of the .\ct of 1908 (subject to the follmvint' proviso), a person is not to be named as a director FORMS. Solicitors. . Sai/ies and Ad4rrssrii.^\ Brokers. Stiiiivx and A(ldn'.'<-srs ] Socretarv in otliw. Xa)iif. Addj-enft. and [trscription.] PHOSPECTUS. The woll-kiiuwn l.u«iiio.ss of A.. I?, ami ('., , mamifiirlun-rs of . which this coy has been formed to aoquiro and carry on, \va~ founded iiiuvards of sixty years ago by the predecessors of tlio pres.Mit veudor.-^. and lias continually <;rown until it has reached its present niagnitudo. The business, which comprises both wholesale and retail departments, is carried on upon extensive, well-built, and commodious leasehold premises situate at , comprising, &e., the whole forminj,' a comiiact l)lock of warehouses, factories, shops and offices, held at, Nory low rents amounting in the aggregate to £. per annum. Large sums have been spent on these premises to adapt them to the purpose.-^ of the business. The leases, with trilling and unimportant e\c«ptions, liave sidl upwards of years to run. Tlie remarkable developments nf the last live years have so largely irii rea.'^ed the magnitude of tiie undertaking that the vendors consider the time liiis arrived for converting tlie business into a joint stock coy. The employes of the busin^'ss number about - - . and the cu-tomers many thousands, the whoh'sale accounts alone on the books of the tirm amounting to upwards of £ . It is proiroscd to make a liberal allotment of shares to applicants connected with or ( .tntribut- ing to the business. Tlio business will bo taken over by the coy as a going concern iu* from the day - , the date of the last annual stock-taking, and the cov will have the benolit of all profits rc^li/ed from (hat date alter allowing int<-rest on j)urchase-money down to tlie time of (he com[)letiiin of the ]>urcha.se at the rate of ■') n.c.p.a. ■i4« Forms. «M' proptu aii(liiiri/.( li.) y liimsclf iir iiy iiis iii;irit a i(in»c'iit in wrltini; -I'd iliri'itur ill any pro<|ipctiis nnli'^-i In •d ill writ in;? — si;;ni?il and tiled willi the rccri-itr.ir of lomiianii ti> act as such director: and I'itliiT sijincd tlic memorandum of association for a numlicr of .shares not Ics.s than his qualification (if any), or siirncd and iilwl with the rc^fistrar a contract in writing to take from the lompany and pay for I. is rpialitication nharcs (if any). Provided that these conditions are not applealilc wiicrc the prospectus is issued one year after the ilatc at which the company is entitled to rommence liusiness. (See pp. 8, 9.) »,; 260 Forms. PKOSPKCTU8ES. [Chap. III. The projiertv U) ha transterivd to tlie co} will comprise, in odditiun to the goodwill 'o of the businass, the following items, coiistitutiug the whole ra al of the buwiiiosH at the above-mentioned date: — Slock ul toftt or under IJook debts (wholesale i - - £ Ia'ss trade discounts, i>er cent. £ ISook.-- (!oht.s irctiuh after allowing for ba<^l and doubtful Cash in hand and at bank, and bills not dis- counted .-..-- .\dvancos on scouritv, &l-. - - - - Goodwill ------- Leasehold premises - - - - - Huildings, tixUiie.s, tittingt;, fiiruiimv, plan,, liorse.s, vans, cart.-, &c. - trade liabilities I I 1 IP The stock was t4ikeu strictly at cost price or under, and the vendors are satisfied that i( has been realised at the usual trade profit. Tlie greater projiortinn of th<' book debts luvs already been ;;ot in, and the vendors guarantee that those outstanding. i)liis what has been so got in, will prixJuce the amount above stated. As regards working ojipital, it is consiol the tive years as follows: — endiuK the — - day of January. 1008. have been Pom 8. £. \oar eudinp: January, 1904 Year ending' January, 1905 Year ondiuj,' January, 1900 Year ouding January, 1907 Year ondiuf-- January, 1908 Average tor Uio tive years In arriving at tliose figures we have not dol)itod prolit, and low. accountr with inteiwt on borrowed (^pital. or loan-, nor uith income tax. Sufficient provision b^i* in our judgment been made tor depif. iulion of the leaseliold premises fixtures, furniture, horses, vans, lie. Yours tailhtully, (Chartered AccounUml.si, £ Tlie average annual profits of tiio business on t he ba.si.s of the last five \ cars is - The annual dividend on £ o pc. pre- ference shaves is - - - - A dividend of say - p.c. on present ordinary shares would recpiire £ Leaving a surplus of . - - - il Is prupnseil to continue the business without, break or interrup- tion upon the lines which have proved so successful in the past, retaining the services of the present managers and staff, who have so brgely contributed to tliat success. T/) The vendors, Mr. and Mr. — , will act as managing directors for the period of five years, and during such period wiU retain an interest of at least £— in the capital of the company. , (j) The purchase price for the sale of the above properly has been fixed l)v the vendors, who are the promoters of the i oinpany, at +! , of which £ - is for the goodwill. Of this sum one-half will be pay- (f) VendnrH .Van,r.«. ,ftr.— Tlie nani.s and addrcHses of tlir vendor- must be .taW. (Sect. 81 (1) (f) of tho .Vet, 1908. Sec yy. Ifi9, 170.) (7) The prospectus must state tfie amount (if any) paid or payafile as purehase-nionev in ea-li. shares, or del.entures of any sueh property as afore- said. speeifyie.J the amount pnyat.le for e-oodwifl. (Seet. 81 (1) (u) of the .\ct; and pp. 170, 171. m/im.) Sec also seet. 81 (1) (f), «"/"'' !'• "'''■ H Form PKOSPECrUSKS. [Chap. III. able to Mr. , and the other half to Mr. — - . Each sum of £ will be paid and satisfied as follows:— that is to say, as to £ in taj^li, as to i' — ■ by debentures, and as t^) the balance of £ by the allotmoiit of ordinary shares credited as fully pd up. The business will be taken over subject to all existing; trade cou- IracUs. The.-ie are of tho ordinary trade character. The dillerenco between the purchiiso price and 'he capital when paid up will also provide the company with neari\ £ cash, the vendors fitu.< must state llic i \ \ I minimiiiM sul)siri|itioii (in which the direetors inuy procpcil to allotment, and the amount piiyiilile on applleatinri and allotment on each share; and in the ease of a scoond oi' suhsecpient offer oi >li,ires, tin- amount otfereil for ouliseription on each previous allotment, and the amount aetiially allotted, and the amount (if any) paid on sueh shares. (Scet. HI (1) (d) of the Art; and p. Ili«, "//'(". I In relation to the minimum subscription, sect. »') of the .\ct must be bi)rn4' in mind. That section provides as follows; (1.) Xo allotment shall lie made of any share i apital of a company oHered to the public for subscription, unless the followiiisr conditions hive been .oinplicl with, najnely — (a) the amount (if any) fixed by the nicnMirandum or articles and flamed in the prospectus as the minimum subscription upon which the directors may proceed to allotment ; or (b; if no uucunt i.s so lixed and nannd. then the whole amount ol the share capital .-o oH'ered for subscription, has been subscrilied, and the sum payable on application for the amount so Hxed and named, or for the ■ ;iule amount olVii-cd for subscription, has been paid to and received by the corai>any. Vl.) The amount .so fixed and named and the whole amount aforpsaiil shall he reckoned exclusively of any amount payable otherwise than in cash, and is in this Act referred to as the minimum subscription. (a.) Tho amount payable on application on each share shall not be less than five per cent, of the nominal amount of the share. (4.) If the conditions aforesaid have not been complied with on the exjiirution of forty days after the first issue of the prospectus, all money received from applie:int3 for shares shall be forthwith repaid to them without interest, and. if any such money is not so repaid within forty-eiu'ht days after the issue of the prospectus, the directors of the company shall be jointly and severally liable to repay that money with interest at the rate of tive per centum per annum from the expiration of the forty-eighth day; Provided that a director shall not be liabi f he proves that the loss of the money was not due to any misconduct or nejjii 'ice on his part. (5.) .\ y condition rcciuirinff or binding any appliiaut for shares to waiie compliance with any requirement of this section shall be void. («.) ThiH section, except Bub-seet. (3) thereof, shall not apply to any allot- FORMS. Ill ii(Mition to th« shares aud debentures which are to be issued 10 tJie voiidiirs as above lueiitioued, tJie company is to issue to ,,i fully paid-up ordiuary shares in the uoinpany, itnd i' llelwiilures. in considoration of his soUinfr to the company the rover- eHaiit on Uu> lease thereof to be acquired by the company from ilie vendors. ly) The shares now ottered for subscription have been under- written for a commission at the rale of — per cent, on the aiiiouui 1 hereof, anil such commission is payable by the company. /,• I The vendors are to pay the preliminary expense- of ami iiici- (leiii to the formation and floating of the company down to the time when it becomes entitled to commcwie business, exclusive of the uiKlerwriling commi.ssion above uientiom-d, and the estimated umouut I hereof is £ ,/i The sum of £ • in cash i.s to be paid by the vendors to •.>.-.;< Form 8. ,u..nt nf shares subsequont to tl.o tirst ulU.tn.cnt i.f shares oir.Mv.1 to the Vtioii. (See pp. 9. 10. «((/';«. ) (7.1 [This sub-seetioii deals with the iiiiiiiimiiii sul.seripiion in tU<- case iit a ...ni|iany which doe- not issue a pnispertus, and is not a privat npany. (Set- 7„-./. p. 10.)] As te the •■tfe.t of iiiakiii!,- an allotnieiit in eontravention of sect. H.), see MTt. 8(i of the .\et: and p. 51, miiiru. (.) ru/ht rui.l SI,o,;h. ,Vr.- The prospectus must state the number and :,iii(niiit of shares and debentures issued, or airreeil to be issued, as fully or partly paid up otherwise than in cash, and in the latter case the extent to which ihey "are s„ paid up. and in either ease the consideration for which such shares ,)r "debentures have been issued or are j-roposed or intended to be issued. iSeet. 81 (1) (e) of the Ac! ; and p. lt)9, si,j,ia.) ;;> r-,„lnvrill„',. -T\,r prospectus must state the amount (if any) paid or payable as commission for subseribini; or ai;reein.„' to subscribe, or i>n.curinK' or airreeiiiir to procure subscriptions, for any shares in the' company, or the rate of ai.y such commission. (See se54 PR()8PE(rrrsi'>«. [Chap. V i^ kk\ Form 8. Mr. ror lii« soivuos lo thoiii in the pioniotion "f the coy. and M,. , who liius joined tlio dirc'.lorat« at the roiniost ol' tlio vendors, L lo le. p'ivo iro.u thcni a «uiii suHirient lo enable liini lo pay lor his iliialiliiiition sharon. , „i I The ( oiilia.i for llie xnle of llie liusiiie--* is dated the - day of , and made between A., \i. and ('. of the one part, and tlio coy of the other part. Tiie .oniracl iiiihides lerlain p|)l,v situate at - , whi".l til.. ui....,i..t pMval.l.. in .as!,. slK.rrs, „r .IWuntur.'s t,. tl.M vcMlnr. i.n.l wIut.- there is more ilmii -lie .-epanite veiia-r. or tlic ..oiii|..uiy is ii siil,-|."rtlm«T, tlic anmunt. so pavalile to ca.li vendor. Provi.l..d il.ut wh-re ti.e vendor, or any of tl.eni are a Hrni the m. nil.ers of tl... lirni shall not l-o treated as separate vendors. (Seet. 81 (1) (f) of the .\et.; .\s to th.' meaoini; of - >,.l.-p»fli:'«T ' TOP i:,,inkr> V. ll„„se„. (190(0 2 <'li. 12!). and j.p. Itiil. 1"". "','■"■ Kor the purposes of tlii.s swtion (,H1) every jierson shall !»■ deemed to be a vendor who has entered into any eontraet, al.solute or eonditiunal. lor the sale or purehave, or for any option ol pnrehase. of any property to be ae.pured l.y the eom|iaiiy, in any la-^e where - I a; the pnrehas.-money is not folly pai.l at tin- date of publication of the prtispeetns ; or ,1.) the purehH.se-moriey is to !„■ paid ..r ^atisHed wholly or in part out of the pro. ds of the Issu.- ollVi-ed for viili.«-i iption by the pr.isp.v.tus; or (.•> ihe eontraet depends for its validity or fiiltiln...nt .in the r.-nl' of sueh is.sue. (Sist. (Si 2 J of th.' .\.-t.; Wlier.. aiiv of the prop.rty to b. :ie.|uinHl by th.^ e.mipany is to be taken on lease, this section shall apply ai it tie' .•xpres.ion " vendor '■ ineluded the lesw, and the expn-sion " pur.-ha-r nion.w " iu.lud.-d the .on-ideratnin for the lease, and the expression " snb-pnnlniser ■• inelu.led a s„l,-lessee. CSoet. SI (31 of the same Aet.) (,„j f„„h<,cli>.--T\w i.rosp.-etus must als.i ^taf ih.^ dat.'s of and parties to .■v.TV material eontraet. and a r.asonabh' tiiii.' and phce at whieli any materi;il .ont'raet or a copy then'of may be insji.-.ted: Provided that this r...iuirenient -liall not apply to a eontraet eiit.T.'d into in the ordinary course of the busin.ss .arried on or" intended to be carried ..n by the company, or t.> any eontraet vnt.red into more than two years before the date of issue of the prospectus. (Sect. HI (1) (k) of the .\et: and p. 171, «./;'(■".) A ...inpany .shall not pr.ni.insly to the statutory mi-.tin- vary the terms of a ■ontiact relerre.1 to in tli.' prospietus, or stati-ment in lieu of pros|iectus. except .subject to the approval of the statutory meeting. (Sect. S3 of Act: and p. 332.) („\ (iunlitic'diuii and Ucmuncralion of JHnrl,m.-'nw prospectus must state the number of shares l^if any) Hxi^d by the article., of ass.,fiation as the iiualili- cation of a dir.'itor, and any provision in the articles of association as to tho r..muneration of tie directors. (Sc't. 81 (1) (b). See p. 1C8, suprn.) FOKM8. ,1,0 (0> ill •iCiK-ral lu.'OliuK iiiiiy -laiit. ainl Ihat xiirh n-inunoratioii is to lie .lividfil uiiiniitr tliuiii ill t'l"'' lH'Olioilioii.'* a- tlie diiPilor.s may ,|,.i.'iiiiiin' And lu iior ntnte ax to ri-mntnnilion of iii,imiiji)uj ,ia;>l,ir>. iiilrii. \>. 7.1'.». iiiid iis In rrlni rcminirnilioii. infra. i).741i. TIk' iliitilois art' inloto-tod as fallows xMr (>ill jxirtirnhm as r,>,iiiirr]■ Tli(< .erlilicalo of Messrs, . and ( opies (d the Mioiiiduin iin.i iirtH 1,1 a.i llio al.ov.' ( oiitracl.s (.^ of shares. \|, plication for shaves sho.ili' lie made upon the form accompany- i„'.,hcprospoctu..andsen( ■ hankers. Hank. I.i.uited, K ( . ,,r to (me of the hrai fr witii a remittance of the iniomit of the i,,,.pcituses and forms of appliialioii can be obtainc.l ai ihe ollice ,,i the inv, or from (he .solicitors or brokers, Louflon. Till- pi,, -pectus liiis been ,luly hid "Mb the Ue-islr.ir of ( ,.s. Dated, . //cm ,li'!l I" l»- lil>''l ll'<' si'iiiuhliex III Dirritnrs i /'•. Form 8. ,.., Mr„„.ni„'lu,n ,.t .ls.,.r:.,l,o„. Tl„> |,r„-pc.'lus must xtatc tlu- ,.ontDnts of tlic- niciiMirantlnin ,.f i,ss,H.iati..n. with the- ii.oiips. ,l..>,Tiptioi,s. Miul adclr,Ns,.s of tlio sisriiatiiric-,, ami the iminli,r of shanks suhs.TihiMl for liy thiiii nv^rPi'tivoly. (S^.t. SI (1; (a) ,if th,' Act. S,h! .s«/;/'(. p. lt>7.) (>) Si,i„ii,ii iiii'' rUhi'j. I'lKlor sect. »(» of the A,-t il) Kvcry pr,»p,', tus i-sii,',! hy or ,in li, half ,ir a ,oy or in r,'latioii to any inti'iuliJ >oy >hall he flaf,d. anil tliat date F lli,' pnlili,ath>n ,)l' th,' prospectus. ■ ■J I A ,',i|iy of i'v,'ry sucli prospeeius. siiiii,,! le- I'very person who is iianicd li„ lelii us ;! ilir,',l..r or propos,Ml i\\vt;\ ,; ,,1' thi y. »r hy his a^'ent .•nithoris,'d in writiiii;, sliall l)i- fih'd for r,s,'istration with the rc^ristrar i,f iiinipanies. on or l)efore tli,' date of its puhlli'ation, and no suih pro-pei'lns shall he issued until a eopy thireof has heeii ao iik-d fur reijistration. >w PROSPECTUSEit. [Chap. III. IW t% ■• ml ■ lit' How far Act applies. Thb ui)plicutiou of suet. 81 of llio Act of 1908 ia oiforwl aud -juulified b> the foUowiu-j sub-sections dealing with (1.) waivor, (,2. advertisement, (3) existinjr member.-.. (4) prospoctas issutd luoro tliau u year after startiup. (i) .Vi.y condition rc.iuiri«({ or binding any applicant for nhares or dubiu- turcu to waivf .ompliancc with any ro-iuirnni-nt of thi» section, or purportini; to alfoct hira with notice of any . ontract, document, or matter not »pc,M«cally rcfcrrctl to in the prospectus hHmU be void. (5) Wlicre any such proapc tiis a« i- mentioned in this wctiou is publi-h.il tt« a newspaper advertisement, .t shall not he necessary in the advertisement t,. specify the contents of the niemorundum or the si^'natories thereto ami tlic number of shares subscribed for by them. (7) This section shall not apply to a circular or notice inviting existini: members or debenture holders of a company to subscribe either for shares or debentures, whether with or without the ripht to renounce in favour ol other persons, but, subject as aforesaid, this section shall apply to any proHi)cctus whether issued on or with reference to the formation of a company or subse(]uentlv. (8) The requirements of this section as to the memoninduin, and the (,u.ili tication. remuneration, and interest of dir.M-tors. the names, des.-riptions. ais.l addre-ses of directors or proposed .lireetors. and the amount or estin.at,.! amount of preliminary expenses, shall not apply in the case of a prospcctu- published more than one year after the date at which the company is entitled to commence business; in the case of a prospectus published more than one year after the date at which the company is entitled to commence business, the obligation to disclose all material eontrae* shall be limited to a period of t«.. years immediately pree.slin^• the public! .. of tli.- prospwtus. The obligation of disclcsinv in a pio-pcctii.s attache^ none tJie Ics- that thf pio.«peitus is pul.lislioJ in :iii abridged translation for circulation in a foreign country. /f(«(.-.sc// v. Hunihaiii, aWJ) 1 ( li. I:;:. Si'e further a.s to an abridged pri)S))ovtus. supra, pp. 17."), :iJ'.i Note the detinitiou of prospectus in sect. 285 of the Act of 191)8, h\ wiiich the expres,sion ■prospectus ' means any prospectus, notiie, circular, advertisoinent ui Mthor invitation offeriuf, to the public for subscription or purchase au\ shares or debentures or ir nllArun KoHM oi- AiTi.nATiio FOR Siim;i> To tilt" I)ir<'ftors of 'I'lic Cov, LimUl. {iKSTI.KME.N, Having.' pil of i'- - per share on -sliaiv^ in tlio al)ovo-naniG balance of £ \H)T sharo on uilotnu'ii;, ii.'< provided !,y tho «d pro(*iM>ttiis; and I autliori/(> you to rpy:islr, J r,i>r, 2 Cii. S27; .s'/m/)«<i- a form of rrccipi. a* follown: — TiiK Coy, Limtd. llanLrrs' Iteieipt \^to be rchihwd hij tlir uiiplicant >. licwivcd this -day of of Mr. - , Uio .■.um of £ , being: .1 deposit of £— per share upon shares in the above-named il)V. For the Bank . To he xigned '>y the- hankerii or setretary, and retained by the applicant] .\n applicant for shares is iumnd from the time when notire of allotment i, L'iitn or p'wtetl. Household Fire, ^v. Co. v. (Iraiit, i Kx. Div. 216; Ilrnlhorn \. Fra 1S<12) 2 (.'h. 27. Until notice of allotment is {?ivcn or posted then' i~ iici (Oi.!....!. and the ajiplicant may withdraw, WaHiic's rnsr, (^IflOO) 2 C'h. I'Tl. .\s to what is postini?, see Lniidoi, iiml Sorlhrnt Bank, Ej-p. .hnirx. 1 liWM; 2 t'h. 28it: I'fUiitt's rnnr. 2 Ch. .r27. The withdrawal may l)e oral. rr,iinROSPFxriiai'». [(.'HAP. m. iiifffectu.!. //....;-■« .'■«». 7 Ch. .W7: SUr.»„m v. .!/./.'««. 5 (J. 11. D. 31S; /(yrn^ V. l/m fii-nhmrn. 5 C. H. 3»4. .\n uii«tiim|MKl allotment letter may be MifTiiicnt. n-hillry /•■irlnrr.. Slerf, ,'./»,•. -JH \V. It. -Ml; 19 li. J. (.'h. I7«; fi L. T. II: llrnlhorii v. franff. niiiini. WhiTR notice of all.itiii.iit i« .liily |.o"'l,l Fi>>: *<•, '„, v. Or>ml, ubi ,u,.ra. Ilenthnrn T. Frnirr. tii/irn. \f no allotnicnt i« m.i.li-. the ,,;>„y i- ImmiimI to n|..iy the .leim-it. but the J,.|»Hit in not u tri.>.t fuml. M,.,,t.v .. Cm ■..,.»•. <;>.. 1 i:.|- •"'•^•. '♦ W. U. •Jlti Where the mmpanv iloci n.it pi to allotment owin^ to non-.>nl)«.rii.t;on of the minimum, the applicati .on. y mu-t !"• retnrn.Ml within forty-niifht .l»y,. See sects. M. «B, t'omimnies \ct. I»08; »n.l ll"rl..i, v. n.rnu. (HUH) 2 Ch, 240; ,,„d «»• .Vrt/...»n/ V''lnr Co.. (liltW) •-' Ch. ••2»; al*! pp. !«. 17. Where .\. applies on I., half of H.. hut without authority, an.l 11. npu.liate. the allotment. A. in liable in ilamap's to the company, and the mc.ii.ure may he the par value of the shari'H. \rl.,mil,-' ,■"-,: 33 W. K. 4.5(1; K„,h,r,,' e«.e, (!N»2) 3 Ch. I. See further as ti membeiship. p. IS. »"/on. $ r-i l,^j 1 :V 1'* "■ 1 " : ■ ■ * • i ; 1. H ■ '■!:]{ |: -'T ■i , 1^ ;Si m J. Form 11. rtdvtTtiMt*- iiicnl nf* to ^.nt-iJH'CtllS. The Coy, liivrn. Xnticp i.s liby given tliiit tiie Abo\.-uaiutd <pectus raeann any prospectus, notice, circular, advertisement, or other invitation ,.lJ,-rin,j to thf i,„hl,r for mh^rriptinn or purchase any shares or del)entures of the company." And sect. 81 of the Act provides that "a prosjiectus " (this is a prospectus defined as above | issued by or behalf of a company, A;c. must contain .rrtain items uf iiitufmiition. ■' "'I'm. p. !li7 nl sea.) Sub-sect. (,.5) of sect. 81 runs thus: - (.i) Where any such prospectus as is mentioned iu this section is publislii'd as a newspaper advertisement, it -iliall not be necessary in the advertisement to KOKMX. mi ,fv ||i«> cullteilt" "f th<> llirMli>rilllituin nr tlir M^Mi-ilnrH')* tlliTflo or r iiiiniliiT uf Hliari'J «iil>«rib«i for by tln'iii. I'hi' <|ii<"itiiin i> wlinlliiT nil iiilvrrti«<>iiii'iit fruiii<'t invite the publii' I' -tubsirilic. ti merely ntat-ft wliat in tli<- fact, tiaiiii 'y, tliiit a pr()i«|iectUM im iM-iiiif i..ii>'it, anil it K'^'*"* «>nio mipiilcnu'iital iiifurniatiiiii. In many cnsc^ the r.irlicr «iirii!i. " notii'i) in hereby (fiven that," are in far a» «ub-nfi t. (5) othi'rvii»e |iri>vii|p!i. Hui \»»n lOiiiiiiciiily Hii iitiriilpetl proHpocitiM dot'« not comply I'lillv wiili .-fit 81. (!.(/.. oiiiiM to iliiilu.st' nuitoriul I'OutructH niid parti- riilai.- of iliroetiir.s' iiiloicsts, tliuii^li il may tMiil with llio vvoiils "full |iru.>|ir(tii>(- t upon the tortus of which applicutioii will alone be leoMvcil I ami fonii.i of upplictttiuii iiiuy lie oliluiiiud from the co^ Imukcr.'" ninl from [the ci).s brokersj.'' .\ii alirid^d prospoctiiH III llii.- form, llioiinh nailiiifj near to the wind, dooa not uppjar to 1n' u pro.-ipeciiis iavitiiiy; iho public to subsiribo. Not uiicoiiiinonly. limvcvcr, an ad vert i.-iod abrid^ud pro«peclus, v 'lich does not coinply »iiii .-ci I 81. >(ibjoinH a form of application \\..ic|i .states on it.- fiico iliai 'llii.-i form muv be lorn out and ii.sod.'' Smh .111 abridged proiipeetuei Hppear.i to bo u perilous mode of inviting tiub- ■ ription. It ilea.-ly comes within the definition of a proapeetiis in »ei>t. 'JH.t of ilie .\it, mi/irn, p. 'idH, n., and also within the mi.sihief sou^'ht to be remedied by ■r, t. 81 of the .Vet. It is, however, u somewhat favourite expedient with un- ■iiiipiilous promoters who lind the reijuireinentK of sect. 81 inconvenient. Where directors authorize the publication of such an abridged prospectus, and ill"t shares in response thereto without tnkini; care that the allottee has in la t seen the full prospeetus eoinplyin); with the .\(t, they must be prepared to tiiiil themselves in a i sition of tfrcal dirtiiulty if the company should co wronij .inil they should be . n-d for damages by an allottee who ha.s subseribed on the .il'rick'ed prospectus. They couM not in defence be heard to say that the allottee uu'lit to have obtained and read the full prospectus, or oujfht to be bound with I'listriiitive notice of the contents thereof, for sub-sect. (^) of .seit. 81 is a.jfains: -II. Il a ilefencc. Atorcover, the allottee who subscribes on the faith of a pro -p.ilus is entitled to say, " This is the prospeetus on the faith of whii h I .i|iplicil: it is dcfiNtive. and it is nothing to ine that you Issued another pro- file, tus which eimijilied with the statute." Dri„ciilii,r\. Hoot/, (1899) 1 Ch. .'JUS. Mi.i: J!,iiiKs,ll \. ISiiriihmii, (1909) 1 Ch. 127. Sometimes the abridged prospectus (lies not include a form of appliiatlon, but even in such cases, if aUotnient is made on ap application which refers to the full prospeetus by date beinir the same a- the dale of the abridired prospectus, the directors cannot with safety assunc tliat the apjilicant was aware of the contents of the full prospectus (see tlr i''- last mentioned), though possibly if the form of application states that thi- I'plication is made on the terms of the full prospectus, " which I have read. !^i iMt of the abridged pro.>peilii», the applicaut would bi- estopptti from -ayiiii; that he had not read the full prospeetus, unless indeed it should be held iliat these words were put into his mouth by the directors, and constituted a •rap ur device. The mere fact that an advertisement is called " an abridged S 2 wm \.\ r-t mo l>KO!SPKCTUSi:s. [CiiAi-. II!. H'. I. f^;: > j,ro.i.e<.tus" does not protect tl.o* who hmo it, for a., applicant .s eutUU-d ,o aLn.e that being a " prospectus " th- directors have comp .ed w.th tl„,. tatut^rv ro.,uireme„ts. If the adv tisement sets out a torn, ot appU.at.un, whether" it contains words t» the elfect that " tliis form n.ay be used or nut, it appears to be hopeless to eo.itend that the advertiseme.it .s not an .nv.tu ■„„ to the public to subscribe, yvt promoters no. uneora.uonly say that the add,.,,,,, „I the form of application is the vital part of such an adurfsement f,>r tliut •hey want to induce the reader to sign at once the form, and so eon.ma Inms,!. -whereas, if he has to apply for a prospectus he may change his mmd. In regard to •' abridged prospeituses " it is well to bear in mind tl... cle,,..,,. in n-hil V. //«y«.-'« '.»■/ '.""■-, 1 Cab. & KM IDl, 1««3. 2.,th .June. In .hat .a»e a so-called •' abridgcnl prospectus - ..ot containing the date or iiaiues ot .lu- parties to a contract for the sale of a paten, to be worked by the company uas held U, be fraudulent under sect. 38 of the Companies Act 18b7 (..«,.., „ -'Sa), although it stafxl where full prospectuses could be obtained I ,c learned judge. .\Iathew. L. .1. (then .L), .onsidered the ease to be within , . ,u;schief intoided to be met by sect. 38. "The abridged prospectus said .1.,. earned judge, "is clearly a prospectus within the m.^aning of the ..ct, «l „l, .,,,,li..s I every prospectus. The defendants further rely on he eonc uJ,„, «l'rds of the section, but I do not think they assist them. If »-'""■ ' ■ onstrucive notice were appli.-able the objcc. of the section would be delca,d l„r that object is to avoid the necessity of being put up..., that ,n,,uiry « h h ,.. invehcd in the doctrine of constructive notice. There must be judgnicn. ..,r ,.,e plaintilf." It cannot be maintained that this .ase was tiot pro,H.r y arg,...l for Vinlay, Q.C and Moulton were for the plam.ills, and .Jell, (U-, and i:. S. lord for the defendants. Sck, also the .Irm,,, -V'-J"'"'' ";,'.' •;"-• r,..o,erative Socely of h,.lo,. l.unM v. Crai'j. 10 1. h. K "' ^'««-,> l,efore Charles, J. There the plaintilf company sued the defendant for ca ., .nd the defeniant pleaded tl.a. he was indued to apply tor .lie shares on c ...ith of a prospectus knowingly issued by the diree.ors and "*cers o t plaintiff company, which omittd to comply with the provisions of »e, t. .W uf he .\,t of 1867. During the lieari.ig of the case a compromise was arrived at the plaintilf being relicvd of his shares. In the course o, the case . vva. sUited , hat it could no. be too widely known th.,. an abridged prospectus (as .In, «,,-, „!er.ed in the Fin.nri.l .V, ,c., came within sec.. 38 of the .Vc , as prove l,y nm. V. II,n,meu, su,>r„, and his Lordship fully assented to this pn.posH.m, and U) the proposed compromise. Tl,„„. who isider that an abridged prospectus may safely be used as an instrument for obtaining subscriptions must of course treat sub-scC. O, " "et 81 U> "f tlie Companies ,Con-liJation ) Act, 1908, as a nullity, i.r otherwise that sub-section in providing that i. should no. be necessary ,n .l.c adveitisement [of a prospeetusj to speeify the eonten.s of .he "■-'orandun, .. ,!.e signatories there.,., and .he number of -hares subscribed lor by .lu . ,.'early implies that these ar,. the only par.. «! the pr.wpctus whel, ,. -h.ill „„t b.. necessary to specify in an advertised pn.speelns. Form 12. Kesolution tci Mgn and tile prospettus. Thul tlR. font, ol- prosiioctu. .subniittoil to thi.s ....■e.iu-. and dauM ,U, - .iuv of - -, by whuh ,,.,r....f i' --■a.h'u.u. .ni.al of .he c:oy aro to bo olloto.i to .ho public tor .suhsct.,...on, .2i ,l,e «.,t.o is hby a,provod, and that tJie copy ot --'^ l'-;';;;;;^ : uho submitted to Uiis o.eo.i.ifr bo forthwith .ipiod by ull iho di.octo. KOKMS. 2«1 an.l lil<'ii. 8() of the Cos I Coiisulidatioin Act. l'JU8. the allo"""ni of - shares oi" £ each in your capital luado to nio iu tlie month of - I'.iiio, and roijue-st you to roiuovo uiy name from tlio roe(l, of such shares, with iiitercsl at tlio rate of jour per cent, per annum thon as from the tinu- u-lu-ii I paid the same resply to you. And take notice, tliai uulo^.- wiUiiu seven days from tlie date hereof you notify to mo your assc^ni 10 .-mil avoidance and comply with my reiiuest. af-d. I shall lake such prorcodiiio.- against you as I may be advised. Dated the day of . Signature of allottee . Name in full . Address . Description . Form 12a. Not irt» avoid- ill); allotment ill t'outraven* tion of .Hect. 86 ..f tlic Aotof lUOs. M SiTt. 86 (1) nf the Companies Act. 1908. provides tli.it '■.•in allotment niado by a oompany to an applicant in contravention of the forejioini,' provisions of tfi.' last foregoing section of this Act shall be voidable at the instance of the iippliraiit within ow month after the holding,' of the statutory meeting of the , ipaiiy and not later, and .shall lie so voidahle notwithstanding th.at th. icinp.iiy is in course of being wound up." Sec l{e yntionn! Molnr Co., (I90S. 2 Ch. jis; P„rto„ v. Hrrnii. aooSI 2 Hi. 240. and pp. 16, .51. s.-iovr- ffn,,..^ > H,r„lu:m, aOOO) 1 Oh. 127. Statement in lieu of Prospectus. The obligations, at once onerous and indefinite, as to di.sclo.suio iinpo.sed on directors and pionioters by sect. 10 of the Companies Ac;. I'.iOii. and the serious conseiiueuoos attaching to a neglect of thom had the effect of checkiuR U) u large extent (ho u.se of the prospectus for piiriiftses of company promotion, and augmeiititig the number oi coiiipatiics lioated by otlier less perilous methotls, e.g.. by obtaining siilisi ripiions on forms of application on the faith of oral statoment.s. r.> .Miiii,-- the company's shares in the stuck market through financi^il agoiit.-. brokers and others, or through the medium of a (looling ^^ndilatc The law's over-s(rictnes.s defeated itself, as so often Luipcns To remedy this undesirable result tho Legislature, in S'tatcment in li. u of ppwlMH-tUK. 2»2 PKOHPECTUSKS. [Chap. III. .b w(-t. 1 of tlie Act of 19(18 (replacing sect. 1 of the Act of 1907J has i( on or with refiriinB to its formation, shall not allot any of its sliari'-' or (ii'lu'Otiircs [or dehi-nture )>Un-k j unlfss before the tirst allotment of cither share-* or (teU'ntures [or debtn- ture stoekj tliere has been filed with the registrar oi companies a statenient in lieu of pro^iiectiis, sifjned by every person who i< named therein as a director or a proposed director of the company or by his ai^ent authoriztnl in writiiiij, in the form and eontainlm; the particulars set out in the second schedule to thi> \it. el.) This ^el■tion shall not apply to a jiriiate company or to a company whiih has allotted any shares or debentures for debenture stock] before the first day of .Tuly nineteen hundred and eight. « i f ; ; " I'ro.sj.ectus " in ihis section means, as piovidoil hy .sect. 28:'), auv prospectus, notice, circular, advertisement, or oliiei invitation oll'ering to the public for subscription or purchase any share or debentures [or debenture stock] of a company. The statement in lieu of (irospectiis is to bo framed in accordance with the form set forth in the second schedule to the Act (see injra, p. 2GI 1. and on reforrinp to that form it will be seen that the disclo- sure re wnrJ- refer to seil. H'l. which provides, in para ("I, that — " (.".J In the lase of the first allotmint of share ca|iital, payable in cash, of a company which does not issue any invitation to the public to subscribe for its shares, no allotment shall be made unless the minimum subscription, that is to say. *• (a) The amount (if any i fixed by the nieinorandnm or articles, and named in the statement in lien of prospectus, as the miniiuum subscription upon which the directors nuiy proceed to allotment: or " (b) If no amount is so fi.xed and named, then the whole amount of the sliare capital other than that issued, or a^rreed to be issued, as fully or iiartly paid np otiierwise than in caciitiir(-< |i)r (Ichiiiturc -tcick ] liffore thr 1st day c.fJiily. IftOH." In lolluwiiijr llif aiialuiry of a plo^■l(e^•tll-, .-eel. «(i in elleii jnuvides lliat an alluliiioiit niadu by a conipaiiy to an applicant in (.ciutra liall lie voidalli', and vontiun of tlio above sub-sottion, t-oct. ti'i i^T », h llic (lirocloi- lialile to , wliile M'.l. 87 juiiliibils tlio touii)auy fioin t imiiiioucing biisin(>ss, or exor- . i>inir il- l)oii-o\vinir powers, unlil I lie londitions sperilied in the t liavc lieeii eoniplied with. Sect. 83, wliich piohibits a -luU'nien um jianv from varying, before tlie istatulory meeting; any coutract bjeul to tlie the contnictK ivtVrred to in that eonipanys prospectu.s. except approval of the statutory meeting, applies enually ti releiied to in a statement in lieu of prospectus. Ai:ain. the .statement in lieu of prospectii-- i^ i leaily a dotiiment itMinired by or for tlie purposes of the .Vet. specified in the lifth MJH'ilule. /.(' . a document recpiired to comply with >"ct. 82. and ,irr,.i(lingly if any person wilfully makes in it a statement false in aii\ material particular, knowing it to be false, he is guilt\ of a iiiImI. meauuur. and liable on indictment to imprisonment for a term uiil cMeeding two years with or without hard labour, and on suin- luaM conviction to imprisonment for a term uol cv ceding four inniiilis with or without hard laboni'. and in eillicT ca-e to a line mot cxrci'dini,'- lO'l/. I in lieu of oi in addition lo -^uc li impri-oMiuenl . See -eel. :281.. N'.M is the liability a eiiminal one only. It would -eem ibal untrue -latcmenls or material omissions in a statement in lieu of prosjiectus iiiav give tu anyone who acts on the faith of such statements being line and complete a right of action against thos(< who signed the -tatciuenl in lieu of prospectus Seet. 81'. it will be observed, pro- vide that the statement in lieu of prospectus is to be signed by every por-on who is named therein as a direc tor or a proposed director of the cdinpanv or by his agent aiillioiized in writing, and the obvious ilc-igii of this rei(uirement is to impose cm thc> siguatoiies a statutory duty of di-c Insure for the beuelit cjf the persons who may deal with iliiMompany. and this statutory duty inclmles the duty (see sect. 281 ) lo >ee that the statements contained in the statement in lieu of i:ro- -pec Ins are true and tomplete, iu aeeordancc with the statutory form. If lliis statutory duty is not performed, it to! vs. on the principles uliovc relVrred to i pp. 17.") el .«•!/. i, lli.it tlio-e persons who sliow^ that Miiv liav.- been piejudiced by the breach of duly have a right of action M-aiiist thn-e who arc responsible for the breach. See the cases cited .il>i>\c. pp. 17.') (■/ s('./. The liability thus iiu lined is oven more 'cicToils than the lialcility of those who i~siie a prospectus; lor in the • a.-e of a prospectus the persons making incorieii statements arc. by |.ii;e.;iapli l»ii of .seel. 81 of the -Vet. relieved from liabilitv if they 3n4 PRO.SPEfTU8I':S. [(^IIAP. III. can prove that they have contravened the section in ignorance er niistake, but no such defence is available to an action under sect. 82 of the Act, for, prima facie, ij^noranco or mistake is no answer lu a claim for danm*ro.s for breach of a ^latulory duty. Couch v. Sie4^}. 3 E. A' B. U)2; droves v. \Vi}uhor)ie. ( 18'.»S) 2 Q. B. 402. Acconl- ingly the sifj;natories of a statement in lieu of prospectus seem to occupy a more perilous po-^ition than the authors of a prospectus. and it boliovos them therefore to :*iake sure that the statement is correct and complete. Tm. ('itMr\Nn:s (C'onsoijdath'N) Act, 1908. The , Lioiiu^d. Statornciit in lii-ii of Projjpfctns. filitt by . pursuant to sect. 82 uf the al>o\c Att. Pri 'seiitt (1 for tiling i>y . The nominal share capital of t!ie company Dividftil into Namf'H, dewrriptiouH, and addrfHHf.'« of I diruitorK itr proposed directors. i Minimum .»*ubHcriptit)u it* any; Hxt-d by I the memorandum or ;irtit'les of associu- | tion on whi(;h the - '-mpany may pro- I eeei to allotment. Shares of £- each. sh:ires of £ , fully pai'l. NhareH upon which £ |«r ^hare rredited as paid. ~ debenture - - £ NumU'r and amount of shares and del)en- 1. tureH ajrreed to be isHuiHl as fully or ' 2. piirtiy paid-up uthcrwise tliau in va^U. i The e'lnsidenition tVir the intended i'-sue , H. lit" those hharew and del>entures. i |. ("onsidenition. Names and addresses (>f -i) vendors of [ proj>erty purohatied or aitpiired, or pro- i pt d to Ih.' C'j purehasetl or actiuired by the eumpany. Amount (in cash, shares, or debentures) payable t^i each s(>parato vendor. Amount if any i paid or pHVtble in Dish Total purehase price £ (tr sh;tres or delK'ntures for iiny suih pr^ or atfreein^"" to Hubs(;rib<' or piiK'urinjf or agreting^ to proeure subscriptions for any shares or debnittircs in the rompany, ur (rt) l-'or definition of vendor, sec sect. 81 (2) of the Companies (Consolida- tion) Act, 1908; and pp. 173, 174. i^b) See sect. 81 (3) of the Companies fConsolidiition) Act, 1908. Cii-h SliiirpH . IJebentures ( Goodwill Aniuiint |jui(l. pavuble. £ £ £ jt; FORMS. •2b» Bate per cent. £ . Name of promoter. Amount £• . L'ouxideratioD : — Riti' of 'tip commission . - - - Kstiiiwtcil amount of jirelirainary uxptuws Aiiumut jKiid or intended to be paid to ;mv pr(tmoter. i Consideration for the payment. D.itiH of, and pttrtii's to, evi ry material i .niitnief '..tlier than eontrftetw entered iuio III llie iircUnary inurse 'if the liusi- ! ucBS intended to be carried on by the | lomli'inv ■iriuleriHl into ni^re tlian two viar^ before the tiliiin of tliis -tate- ' i.i-nti. film- anil vilaee it wliicli the contracts or ni|iies theri'of may be inspected. N'ftnie:! and addresses of ttie auditors of ' tlie lonipauy (if any ■. Full |i!irtieular.s of the nature and extent | ,,f the interest of every direetor in the I proniution nf or in the jiroperty pro- ' posed to be acquired by the company, i .11, where the interest of such a director ,fin-ists in Ixiug a partner in a tirm, the nature and extent of the interest of the Hnn, with a statement of all sums jmidiir aijieed to be p.iid to him nr to tlie firm iu cash or sliares, or otherwise, by any person either to induce him to iRHi.me, or to iiualify him as, a director, nr uthiTwise fur hcrvices rendered by liini nr by the tinu in connection with the promotion or formation of the com- liaiiy. W'liitlier the articles contain any tirovi- i Nature of tl -i.in> iiricluiliii^ holders of shares or | ilel.i ntures nreivin^r and inspecting i lialauce-shccts or reportscif the auditors of a new loan previously to its being submitted to the committee, T-ho will apiinint a special settlini: day provided that sufficient scrip or bonds are ready for delivery and are in reasonable amounts {vidr^ ■• .'ndix 3d). I")il.-(1) The secretary of the share an-' loan dejiartmenl shall give three Speciiil day-' public notice of any application for a special settling day in the shares or s*ttliug day. otliii securities of a new company previ(m8ly to siu-h application being sub- .Spe.-iul -i-ttling day. lioans. 2»)« PR0SPKCTU8ES. [Chap. III. C'Miipiinn'h, Official illll>tUtil>Lid. ApplivutioU' Nolirf. Bnik.r. Quutatiuti of vt>iidor'> rwH'uritio. mitted to the I'ominittee, who will appoint u Kpeiiul scttlinf^ day providpd thtt Buttic'ient certiticaten or Mcrip art" ready for delivery. CI) Tlie committee will not tix u »peeial Kottliii^ day for bar);ain« in aharei or sei'urities issued to the vendors, credited as fully or partly paid, until six months after the date tixi'd for the special settlement in the shares or securities of the same class subscribed for by the public, but this does not necessarily appir to reorganisations or amalu'umations of existini,' companies, or to cases where no public shares are issu d or to cased where the vendors take the whole of the shares issued for cash (r!'lr Appendix 35). 151. — (1) The committee miiy order thi^ i|Uotation in the oflieial li»t of any sei-urity of sufficient ma<^nilude iind im{>ortanee. (2) .Vpplications for i|Uotation must be made to the secretary of the share and loan department, and must comply with such conditions and rcHjuireiricnts as may be ordered from time to time by the committee (eiV/c Appendix .36). (II) Three days' public notice must ')e s^iven of every application. (4) A broker, a member of the Stock Exchange, must be authorised to pivp the committee full information as to the security, and to furnish them with all the particular^ they may reiiuire. 152. Securities issued to vendors credited as fully or partly paid shall not be quoted until six months after the date lixi'd for the special settlement of the securities of the same class subscribed for by the public nor unless a quotation for the latter is al.so granted. i! ' '' ! r \ 35. S/jiciaf ScttUmfltt". The following doeument> and parti ulars should be sent to the secretary of the Share and l^oan Department when application is made for a •special settlement: — {Rlili-< Hit i'IkI l.iO.) A. Scrip or Bonds of New Loans. A specimen of the scrip or bond. A copy of the prospectus, cirrular or advertisement relating to the issue. A statutory declaration, stating- - 1 . The amount allotted (a) to the public. (b; to others. 2. The distinctive numbers and dcmiiiiination of each class of scrip or lioud 3. The amount paid uji thereon. 4. That the .scrip (jr bonds are ready to be delivered. B. Shares of Xew Companies. The certificate of incorporation. .\ specimen of the share certificate. A copy of the prospectus, the statement in lieu of prospectus as filed with tho Registrar of Conipanie^. circular (tr adxcrti.^ement relating to the issue. .\ specimen call letter. Certified printed copies of contracts relating to the issue of shares credited as fully or partly paid. A letter from the secretary of the loaipany stating — 1. That the share certificates are ready to be issued. 2. The distinctive numbers of tlie shares allotted (a) to tho public. (b) to the vendors. FdKMM. 3 Till' particulars of the compniiy's lapital. 4. Thp nominal amount of carli share an.l the amount paid in rasli or credited as paid on each share. 5 In cases where tii.^ whole of the capital has not been issued at the time the applieatiou is mad.', whether the unissued shares are vendors' shares or are held in reserve for future issue. ( . Sliuk or Dchenture Stnck of New Conipanies. \ specimen of the scrip or 8t<)ik ccrtifieato. A copy of the pr<.spectu.s, the statement iji lieu of prospcrtii- as (il.'d wi'h the Keu'istrar of Companies, circular or adverti-cmciit relatin- to thi' isMic. ..V letter from the secretary of the company statinjr 1. The amount allotted (a) to the public. (b) to others. 2. Tlic amount paid in cash per 100/. stock. 3. That the scrip or stock is ready to be issued. 30. OfUci'il Qiiotiitiuns. \. Conditions precedent to au Application for Dfficial Quot.Wion. 1 . That the prospectus — Shall have been publicly advertised : Agrees substantially with the Act of Parliament or articles of association; Provides for the issue of not Kss than one half of the authorised capital and for the payment of 10 per cent, upon the amount subscribed; If ofterinf; debentures or (bbeuture stock states fully the terras of redemption ; In cases where a company !ias sold an issue of debentures or debenture stock which is subsequently offered for public subscription either by the lompany or any subsequent purchaser, states the authority for the issue and all conditions of sale. :. Tliat two thirds of the amount proposed to be issued of any class of shares nr securities, whether such issue be the whole or a part of the authorised .(mount, shall have been applied for by and unconditionally allottcil to the l.ublic. shares or s.curitiea granted in lieu of money payments not being con- -idereil to form part of such public; allotment. 3. Thai the arti.le. of association and the trnst deed where such ia required ..intain the provisions specified hereafter. 1 That the certificate or bond is in the form approved. ■-'•17 I 1 »rl . .\rticlea 01 .Association. Articles of association sho'ild contain the following pro\isionB: — 1, That none of the funds of the ^ PKOSPKCTirSES. [Chai'. 111. 7. Tlmt fiill_T-[i.iid >liari"< »hull lie trcr from all lien; 8. That tlie interest of a dinftor in any contract ahall be disclosud bcfur" execution, and thiit such dire< tor shall not vote in respei't thereof. 9. That tlip direitors shiill have power at any time and from time to tini" Ui appoint :iny iitlier i|ualitied person as a director either to fill n ca!rinted copy of the report, aircompanied by the halancc-nhoii and statement of uecounta, shall, at least seven days previous to the jreneral meetinir, hi' ileIi\iTed or sent hy post to the re^istertd addrci-i of every member, and that two lopios of each of these docunient- shall at the same time be forwarded to the secretary of the Share and Loan Department. The Stock Kxchanire, London; 11. That the ( har?e for a new share certificate, issued to replace one that has been worn out. lost, or destroyed, shall not exceepointin^ new trusti'cs hereof shall be vested in the company, but a trustee so appointed must, in the fir.n place, be approved of by a ri'solution of the delienture (or debenture stock) holders passed in the manner speiified in the schetlulc hereto. A corporation or company may be appointed a trustee of thesi' presents." 3. In the clause re^rulatin); the eonvenins of meetinsrs of the debenture (or debenture stock) holders the followinff words should be inserted:- " .\nd the trustee or trustees shall do so upon a requisition in writini: sijjned by holders of at least one-tenth of the nominal amount of debentures (or debenture stock) for the time i)eintj ontstandinf?-" 4. The clause defining an " extraordinary resolution '' must provide that " ihc expression ' extraordinary resolution ' means a resolution passed at ;i meeting of the debenture Cor debenture stock) holders duly convened and held at which a clear m.ijority in value of the whole of the dc'jcn- ture (or debenture stock) holders is present in person or by proxy ant! carried by a majority consisting of not less than three-fourths of the persons voting thereat upon a show of hands, and if a poll is demanded, then by a majority consisting of not less than three-fourths in value of the votes given on such poll." 6. Should debentures or debenture stock be entitled " first mortgage." pro- vision must be made for the creation of a specific first mortgage in favour of the debenture or di'benture stock holders. KOKMM. .•«S» |>. Shan' and Stink CirtiHi'tttcK. All lertitiiatf* •.liould ^'t:ltc ou tlu'ir fttic tlii' autliDrily umliT wlii.li the- coui- i,»r V ii idii-tiliitid uiwl thr aimmiit "f tlie iiutliorisi-d capitiil uf tlir lompany. \'ll , i-rtiticatiM should bear a fixitiiiiti- ti« tlii< clf.'it tliat no tramfor of any |,„rtion of the holdiii)? lan !»• re)fist.ri-d without the |ir.Hliiition of the rcrtilii'ate. Wliere the lapitil of u ioni|iauy lonaiats of luorr than ono ilu^- of ahart■^> of IIm- saiii'' ileuuniiuatiou. thi' dislimtive numbers of thf nliares of raih class um»t In printt'd on the fact- of thi' share icrtiHcatcs. \!l profirencf share icrtiticates should hear on their face a statement of the ,,.mpaiiy's eapifal and the eonditions both as to eapital and dividends under wliieh the shares are issued. Debentures and debenture stock eertiKeatus should, in addition to legal re- ,|uirenieiits, state on their faee the authority under wliieh the npany is ron- -i, lilted, the nominal eapital of the company, the dates when the interest on 111,, dehentun-s or debenture stock is payable, and the authority under which tlio i.>.ue is made (i.e.. articles of association and resolutions); and on their back the conditions of issue, redemption and transfer. i; liunds. Iluhds must Bpucit'y the amount and conditions of the loan, the powers under fthich it has been contraetetl, and the numbers and denominations of the bonds ..-ued, and in the case of a hian issued cither wholly or partly in l/ondon, those i-ued in London must bear the autoirraphie siifnaturc of the London accents or lU'itraetor^. I New Companies. H, fore the application form can be i-sni-d for siijnatuie there must be -applied: A coiiy of the prospectus. Two copies of the articles of association. In the case of debentures or debenture sioi-k the trust deed [ ; chair- itian and secretary. Should the .illoCnent have taken place at an interval of six months or nn/re iiufuri- the date of the application, a eertihcd list of present sh irelioidcrs will .i!>u he required. .\ cujiy of the letter of allotment, and the date when posted. .\ -peeimen of the share certiticate. il- J 118 ,^7i) l'UOSrK( 11 SKS. [('IIAP. III. Tli» baiikt'rs' |>u»« book, a' cunipanicd liy a iiTtiHiati' on a Hpwial form from the company's bunkrrn, stating; tlio uiiiiMiiit of (li'|HHit'< nseiMd l>y tliKni. an.>>., application money ' nly, being A per ahsre) were paid. Authentirated copies of all conccMioiiM and niniilur clixuiiiiiits with iiotariall} certified printed trsnalationH and icrtiliid printed itipici of all lontructn ujid ■trreomenta. A statutory dui'l.iratioij liy the ihairman and Heirctary vtatiuf; tlu! followiui,' partieulari: 1. 'J'httt the pn»(*pectU!* c4tmplicH with the proviNions of the (companies it "on solidation) .\rt, IWH. 2. That all docunicnti rei|uired by the I'ompanies (Consolidation) Act, HtdS. have been dniy tlli'd with the Ket'i^trar of Coinpanici and the diite- uf tiling. 3. The number of ^h ( licin^r NOB. to ). 6. The amount of depoiifi paiil and that su( h deposits . ..• ali-ohilely fne from any lien. 7. That the share eertifieatis are ready for delivery, that the purchase of th' properties lias been completed and the purchase-money paid and th.it no impediinciit exists to the settlement of the a<^connt. 8. The total iiiiinber of the alluttceii, and the larijest nuuiber of sliarc^ tai apjilieil for by. and (b) all»tte iliarift' rreatod thereby in favour of the debenture holder*. 111. The total ii.iinber of allottees. II. The larpest number of debentures or debenture stoek (a) a|iplied for liy and (!)) allotted to any one applicant. .\ .«tatntory declaration by the ehairman and secretary, statin);: - 1. The total amount of the authorized capital of the company, and how constituted. ■j. The number of shares allotted unconditionally to the public (Nos. to 1. and the amount paid on each share in cash. :j. Tlie number of shares taken by conc(»ssionaires, owners of property. contractors, or other parties not included in the public allotment (hcin^r Xos. to ). I. That the >h:ire certificates have been delivered; that the purihasc of the pnipirties has been completed and the purchase-money paid. 1. Scrip, ill :i(Mitioii to the rcs{uirenicnts made in the ca^e of detinitix 1 -[)ci-imcii of the scrip eer*itieiite must be snpplii'd. vtock or bonds, K. .\ltcr the uppiication form has beeti signed, there must be supplied in the • it-e uf -- Further /unices. V Kiiijj's printers' copy of the Act of Parliament authorising,', the resolutions. ,^c. ( rcatiii^', and the circular or jirospectus otferinu, the new issue. If shares have been issued credited as fully or partly paid, certilied printed ciipies of the contracts relatinif thereto. A cojiy of the alliitmciit letter. V copy of the la-It report and accounts. .\ specimen of the .share eertilic:ite. The allotmeiir book, unless the allotment is /<,u ,(ili>. A statutory declaration by the ^.eeretary stating- - 1 rimt tlte pro^ji'T-tus ui- circular cfjtnj;!ifs with tlic provisions of ihy Companies (Consolidation J .Vet. 1908; -. That all documents required by the Companies (Consolidation; .\ct. 19(18, have been duly tiled with the Kegistrnr of Companies, atid the datet of filing. Vi PRtun'Kcrv^yjf. [CUAC. III. 3. That the uliarM (No*. to ) have bprn sppliMl for by uuU aa conditionally uUnttrd to tin- ■Imrclioldf'r'i i>r thr publir. or wl'l u|H)n the market un the rati* nmy be; 4. The amount per •faiirc paid in caah ; 5. Tliu tcitul number of ulliittma and the larKeat numb«r of iihartM a|i|ili('i| for bjr aud ullutled ti> uny oni' uppliiunt. 6. Tliut < crtiticiiteii are ready tn bo initueil, und that thire i» nu ini|K'diiui!nt to the Hettlenient of the ueenunt. It niunt al^u bir stated Hhelher or nut tho ahiiren are in all renpei t" lilentieal with thu"!' alreaily iiuutiil iu the tillieial li->t. The xlatempiit that ahareaure in all renpeetn identical luearu that- 'I'hoy are uf the Mime nominal value, and that tho name amount per nhure lia.- been called up. Tliey larry <'ie Miniu riKhi' an to iinrintrieted tranifer, attendanen ami Mitini; at mcetin);!! and in all other rexpei ri. They urc entitled tn dividi'iid nr the name rate and for the name pericHl. n> that at the next i iiiuiii); distril>ul i 'n the dividend payable on lueh >>hare will uninunt to exactly the ^^anie num. The Mtatenient that ^4t'>ck is in ail reH[>eetn identieul nieaiin that - All the ntock in entit r the name |ieri(id. no that at the next cnnuin); dintriliution the dividend payable on eai h IIIO/. nf rlie ^U)fk will nnioiint to cxaetlv tb' '^me num. i^i * , .1 1j. After the appliratiun furm has bcfii Mi^iuKi thore inu^^t be ^upplifd in the cM>o of: — I'tUflorH Shares. A i-ertitied liNt of the pruiwnt holiierij of thu veiidur*H Hhareti. A <>crtitied copy of the la^t publi'Uifd report and account!! of the company. A •specimen of the share certificate. \ statutory deciaration by the secretary stating: — 1. That the vendur*e4 shares (Nos. to ) have all been issued and certificates delivered. 2. That the shares are in all respect"* iilentical with thnsc already qunrcd in the official ii!t. M. After the application form has been signed there must be supplied in the • a-ie of: Old Comptinif.^. The certificate of incorporation or \ct of Tarliament and the certificate tliat The company is entitled to commence bu-^iness. Authenticated copie-^ of ail Cdnces^^ion-; and >iniilar floeumenti with notarially ccrtifiwl printed truii^ry «t th.' iiim|iaiiy, «-ttin^ forth iU nriirin, pmifm*, diiicli-nil- ^, till' humhcr iif tniii'ftTx ri'ifiitiTiil iluriiiif thr Inst twelvo month' anil 111- iimihIh I nf «li»n~< r('|iri'«rnt<>ini tUH c(iiu|iliiMi witli thi' (irii\i»iiiii» of Iho Cuiuiiiiiiiu" (* mi -nli.lation) Alt. IW08. J. That ; II dm uniciiti rii|uir<«l l>y the ('imi|miiiiw (('onsolidation ) Act. Iil(l8. haM' liicii duly lili'd with the Uetri-tmr of i'ompaiiirii and thi> ditl.- iif tiling. :l Tlii' iiiridier of sharea applied for liy Ihu puliiic. 4 TIm- iiumbt'r of 8hare» ullolti'd uiiciniilitioiially Ii) thf publii,' (Son. t.' ) and thn amount piT Nhuf paid tlnTf-oii in la^h. ,1 I'lii' number of nhareii allotted fur a conKidpratlon other than i-mli ( licinL' No». to ). i; 'I'liai till' sliarr iLTtitiiati'H liave been di'liviTPil : that thi' puriha ! lln propiTtie» h»< oecii loniplcted and the purelia-e-money paid. N \flir llie appliiiition form ha< been «i(»ned there iniint be Miipplied in tin- ,aM' iif: Ciiiomn/ inni Fintmjn tUtmih'Ptitx. Tlie .cititiiMte of inriirporation or Ait uf rarliaiueni or other siniiliii fiiH-umiMit. Tn" ii>pie< nf the statutes or artieles nf a^soriatinn or notarial (ran^^latil)ll- ..f th.' ^ame. A lertitied list of prewnt nharehiildcrs. A f[iii inicn of the ••hare certitiiate. Ciipii'. ." a.s the expression is uxcd in company matters, is a well-known business term sifrnifving the entering into a contract l.y which a person (known as " tlie underwriter " > agrees (u 0. I). 1; TMiidon, Paris, de. Assoc. 13 T. L. R. 560: Consort lU'cji.d-c. Co. nsOT) ICh. (C. A. t.57.'>. Sometimes the contract binds I lie iiiidorwritor either to take u]) the shares, &c. or to find responsible |M'rsons to do so; it is none the les.*, in either ca.se. iiitled un under- wrifiiiLT contract. Occasionally one f)erson, or firm, or company, iiiidcrH rites the whole issue, but it is more common for the under- iviiting to be done by a number of persons, each of whom underwrites ii specific amount, and stipulates that the public subscriptions are to ::ii in relief of all the underwriters' liability rateably in proportion i- of. I Ml with, and gradually dispose of it to the y^uci A public. Set' Konns 6, 7. By having a propo«ed issue undtirvvrilteu in tliis way by reNpon.sibk' persons before tlic prospectus is published, the 'utcess of the issue L-. assured, and the < unipauy and otiiers interesteU are relieved Ironi \hv risk of loss and inconvenience likely to ensue if the public ^>liould uoi be disposed to subsciibe. Thus — (.a) Suppose that a company is registered to acquire a business, or to carry into etlect a scheme which will re(iuire the provision of al least jO.OOOi. cash, and accoitliugly, tliat by the article- of association the miniumm subscription on which (purbuani to sect. 85 of the Act of 1908) tiie directors may go to allot- ment is lixcd at 50,000 shares of il. each. If tlie public du not come in and take up the amount, and the shares haw not been underwritten, the company will be unable to jjro- ceed to allotment or to commence business unless it cau find people ready and willing to take up the minimum subscrip- tion. This, after the failure of the invitation to the public i^ known, it may be impossible to anange, and in the result the preliminary costs and expenses may bo thrown away. wheix;iv8 if beforehand the minimum subscription is under- written, this danger is averted. Accordingly, it is now very common to have at least the minimum subscription under- written and so secure the company going to allotment, lb) Suppose, however, the amount of the minimum subscription fixed in the articles — a matter left to the discretion of the promoters — to be so small that the directors will theiuselve!* be prepun'd to subscribe it if the public do not come in, still it may be neces.sary to resort to underwriting if the scheme on which the company Ls started requires any considerable cash subscription. (c) Suppose A., B., and C. are converting their business into a company which is to oiler its preference shares and deben- tures for public .subscription. The business is well kmiwii and successful, but a large portion of the capital emi)loyed represents loans, deposits, and other capital left in the con- cern by a deceased partner: and the proceeds of the pro- posed issue are intended to clear oil all these liabilities. In the circunistantvs it is essential, in the interests of A., B.. and C, that the issue should be placed without fail; if they go to the public without any uuderw riting, there w ill be risk of failure by reason of some unforeseen conliniroucy, «.<;., the contemporaneous annouuooment of some other or more attractive scheme, the ;ipi)earance of a hostile letter in a nevv.spapor, .some great commercial failure, or some dis- turbance of the money market. Accordingly stops ai-e taken to eliminate the risk bv having the issue underwritten. INTRODUCTORY NOTES, Ji A going: company may dosiro to raise further funds by the issue of additional shai-oe, or debenturo-s, or deWaturo stock. To offer the new capitiil vithouf sucoess would involve risk to the company, indeed failure to obtain a subscription niiL'^ht prove disastroi!-. The company's advisors are of m mion that in Uie state of the market, or in the special circnmstdiices of tlie i-ase, the sucf-'rdii)(jrly, und<'! writing is almost a necessity. ;ei A linancial or mhei com|>any iui,-- become possessed of shares, .stock, or .securities i.s.sued by sDinf other concern. It desires to di.spose thereof to the public, and, in order (o ensure the success of the i.ssue and avoid the serious detriment which non-success would involve, underwriting is resorted to. Sometimes, as above mentioned, it is considered sullieieut to have t'ii'l"\vritiiiu: only a portion of a propased issue underwritten, eg., in the case of ]|j L-isuf' " ' a now company, sufficient to ])rovide the nece.ssary working capital, and so murli cash as the vendor absolutely requims; and where a M^oiug company wants furtJier funds it may often be thoujrht sutlicient 10 have (inly a part of the j^ioposed issm- underwritten. Old Law as to Underwriting in force before the Companies Act, 1900 (,now replaced by sect. 89 of the Companies (Consoli- dation) Act, 1908), came into operation. Trior to the coining into ope»'atiou of the Act of 1900, the under- writing of shares or debentures wa.s attended with serious difficulties ill (Ousequence of the then e.visti'it,- law as to the payment of under- wriiing commissions. The law stood thus: — 1 1 1 It w.as extremely doubtful whether a company, even if autho- rized by it.s memorandum and articles of association, could legally pay oi't of its capital conunisaion for underwriting shares in its own capital. TliesG doubts arose, if not before, at any rate with the decision of Kay. .T.. in Faure Accumulator Co.. 40 C. D. 141 (1888), and they were certainly not losseneil by the decision of the Court of .Appeal in [.ijilncy (t Wigpool Co. v. Uirtl, I!:! C. D. 8.j, in which Lindloy, L. J., in delivering the judg' \^ of the Court, said, at p. 95: " It appears to me wholly wrong to make a company pay for the issue of its own shares. Xo part of (he capital could bo so applied": or by the ile< ision i<{ the llouwe of Lord.s in OoreyumCo. v. Roper, (1892) A. C li'.'i. in which case it was held that to issue shares of a company at ■i. (li.si oiint was yiJIra vires, from which it seemed to follow that to pay ii coniini.ssion to a subscriber for share.s for subscribing was ultra rircn. These doubts were emphasized, too, by the fact that some of t'lUnpHiiy, ilioii^h ainlio. ri/od by nii'moniiulinii, • ■..iild n.'t ^:ifcly piiy • ■ominissioii out nf ruj»it;i!. ovcept small tirokeni^rs fi) brukirs. f ! 27H IJNDEKWRITING. [Chap. IV. t" profits I'l Tiiiuiii<4. All(l< liulcllMV out Ot |-!t|Utitl t'(»r pliiriiiir (Iel>«'iitur«- riirht to (rall- for ■ luir.-s. l.'utitTwritiiiii ubliKutioii uoultl 1h' atil<:lK?(i t'. purtii;ul;ll- fl;|HSot sllHrt's. lll.'tr>>t itidireit pHTlUcllt of i:UIuni)>.sintl uat of capitul. the most eminent lawyers at the Chancery Bar from time to time advised against the legality of payments out of capital for under- writing, altiiough there were dicta in the Court of Appeal in Licensed Victuallers' Association, 4:i C. D. 1, to the contrary, and although in Metropolitan Cwtl Con»umcrs Association v. Scrimgcour, (ISyr)) 2 Q. B. tj04, payment of a 2^ per cent, brokerage commiaaion to the broker for hi.s -services em such wa.s held legal. That decision was, however, strictly conliued to the ca»e of brokerage to a broker at a rate not exceeding 2| per cent. (2,1 A companj- could out of protitd, including premiums on shares carried to reserve and other as.-et.s not being capital, pay a commission for underwriting shares in its capitiil (3) A company could pay out of capital, proKts or other assets, for underwriting its debentures or debenture stock, or for underwriting shares in or securities of other companies, owned by it, and which it si entitled to dispose of. (^4) A company could, as considei m for underwriting contracts with it, give to the underwriters the call at par or at a premium of shares in the company's capital, that is to say, the right to call for the allotment thereof on the footing that the allottee was to pay or be liable to pay the par value thereof to the company or some higher price. (5) The obligation to underwrite shares could validly be made a condition attaching to the ownership of shares of a parti- cular class in the company, for example, the memorandum might provide that each allottoc of founders' shares should be deemed to underwrite 101) ordinary shares. (6) It was not legal for a company indirectly to pay out of capital commission for underwriting shares in its capital, e.g., by agreeing to purchase properly at a price which a company through its directors knew was fixed so as to cover under- writing. " There is no doubt that, if it cannot be done directly, it cannot lie done indiroilly," said Lord (,'helmslord in James v. Fye, L. li. ti H. L. .385, in relation to an ultra vires application of capital; and the same principle was recognized in .Munn v. Edinburgh Tramways, (1893) A. C tJ'J. Law and Practice since the Companies Act, 1900 (now amended and replaced by sect. 89 of the Companies (Consolidation i Act, 1908), which came into operation 1st January, 1901. The Act of I'JOu materially altered the law as to the underwriting writinir inav °^ shares, fur it expressly allowed (sect. 8) a company, in certain cases now be paij and Subject to certain conditions, to pay out of its capital for under - <«P>t»l ^ writing shares in its capital. ' The Legislature,' said Lord Davey lu. In ccTtsiiii ctuif J* tituk'i- INTROUUCIOKY NOTKS. •J7!» Hildei V. Dextir, (1902) A. C. 474, 479, "was desirous of ouabliiif; reiminerulion to be paid for services rendered in placing or procuring- tiubsi liplions of the company '« capital, and it appears to have hit upon wliat may be termed a compromise." Sect. 8 of the Companies Act, 1900, wiiK amended in some impor- tant particulars by sect. 8 of tiiu Companies Act. 1907, and both Bpclions. ajrai ,, 're now replace*! by sect. 89 of the Companies (Con- solidulioii I -Vci. 1908, whicii ruu> as follows: — t i iKin^ 'l}l(f lli^rriiilttx per 89. 1) It shall be lawful for a wimpaiiy to [lay a. cunimissioii to any ruwt-riopaT n in iiiii>idiTatiofi of his subsiiihiiis; or aj^ruiiiu,' I') suli-irilic, whfther certain iiim- inih!,ionN, Hiid (li-w-duiitH, ,Vr. abnilutcly or nniditiuiially, lor any shares in the eompnny, or proeurinir or i"'s. ions, ai agieeint; to procure sub.seriptioiis, whether al)solut« or conditional, for any |^, .my,u,.ut shares in the company, if the payment of the eonimissiou is authorised by the ,,i „ll „tlier articles, :'nd the commission paid or agn-id to be i)aid dcx's not exceed the coinniissloLs, amo'.int rospectu»; or ih, In the ease of shares not ort'ei-cd to tin; public for subscription, disclosed in the statement in lieu of prospectus, or in a statement in the pre- -cribwl form si),'ned in like manner as a statement in lieu of prospei lus aiid tiled with the rej^istrar of eompiinies. and. where a circular or notice, not beinff a prospectus, inviting snb«rrip; imi for the shares is issued, also dischtscd in tli-:t circular or notic. I.'; Save as aforesaid. !}o conip.iiiy shall apply any ot il« shares or capital moncv either direi'lly or indirectly Iji payment of any commission, discount, or all"«:Mice, to ;iny person in consideration of his subsiTibin^' or aixrieini.' to sub- scribe, whether absolutely or conditionally, for any shares of the com]iany, or procurins or acreein<; to procure subscriptions, whether absolute or londitional. for any shares in the company, whetlier the shares or money be so applied by beiu^' adiied U> the purchase money of any property aeciuircd by the company or to the contract price of any work to be executed for the company, or the money be paid out of the nominal punhase money or cnntrmt price, o. otlei- wise, (:i) Nothing in this section shall art'cct the power of any coui|i.iny lo iiay such bn>kera);e as it has heretolure been I ' vendor to, promoter of, or otlic pers»»n shares from, a company shall have and . power to apply any jiart of the money or s.. ciininiission. the payment oi' which, if maile have been lepral under this seetiou. for a company to pay, and a eivcs payment in mimcy or dv'cmed always ' Slave bad so received ia pa^, . it of any directly by the company. »onld Till! section, it will be observed, frot's far lioyoiid aiilliorizing pay- liives nn- , .,. . . r •, 1*1 1 i 1* limited scope iiu'iit ot an uudorwritino' coniniission, lor it allows the payment ot a f,,r i,»uinit coniiuissioTi \n any poisioii in consideration of his "subscribino: or sb-m-s at dis- ULTPcinij to Kubscribo, uliotln'r absolutely or conditionally, for any '^^^ j shares in the company, or procui ino; or agreeing to procure subscrip- observed. lions, whether absolute or conditional, for any shares in the coni- pauy, -words wliich onaole a company in effect to Issue its -hares at •2^i> lINnKHWRITINO. [CUA1>. IV. {■i ■I discount subject to tlie conditidiis iiuposod by sub-sect. I. And ■-iib-sGft. 3 iu elicit allows u vendor or promoter to pay undorwdtinjj cominisMon out of what ho roK-ivi's from (lie roiupuny, subjpct never- ihelcss t ( h. 'S.: <. that an oUer by a i .impany of further shares to its members was not an 'olfor of slures to tlio public' ; niir was an oiler of shares on a reconstruction bv the new company to the shareholders of the old company tlirou<;h the luedinn] of the li(|uidator [ ISoolli v. Mr.ir AhlniirU'r (iiild M.iiii'q Co.. 87 1.. T. ,■)((!•, ('. A. i; nor was an oiler maih' by a ])ri)iiioter lo a t'nv nf his friends iSlrijjIi v. Clasiioir mitl Tnuh-iriKd Options (•'. /'., 120 Ct. of tjess.i: and in all these ca.sos therefore it wxs not competent to a company to pay a commission. Now it is so for u private company as well as a public loiupany i I loiiiiiiion of Camidn (inirnil Tnuliiiu Si/Hiticdte v. lirij/tiluke, (,11)11 i 2 K. 15. (il8,i, and the question when shares are otl'ered to the public for subvri|ilioii i.^ only niateiial for tho purpose of delorndnin^ whether the cSnb-sect.s. 2 und ;5 tend to .show tliat ihe word ' jiay is u-iil in the wider sen.«o, for. save as ufore.said, that suh-seciion prohibits the iippliaifioti by the company of any of it.s Kluircx or capital money in payment of any comnjission, and thus apjjears to recognize the werd ■'payment" as au apt description of an application of shares in a company iu payment of a commission. Mv allowing the payment of a commission, the 8(-iilt i> ilie Kline as if the lu/. had been issued at a discount of .')0 jjer (III.; hut as a matter of form the iransaction is corrorl : llie shares iiv liill\ jKiiil up liy the suhs( lihcr. and llie conunis-icn is paid to hiin |j\ till. Kiinpany out of it.s lunds as puil of its hu-ine-s e\penililur<'. In consideration of his subscribing, &c. Sulist rihing ' here .11' an.-, ii i- apprelii'M(' llie wni-.K. See .lr//8.s-o/( v. Sinilh, 11 (\ I). .'US; /I'/ivv V. Eilntex liirrshiii'iit Co., ■"■ Ch. ti8J: Kctil v. Freehold fximls Cii . .! I'll. tl)2. -A-S to reeonstriK'tion. see Chap. X.\I., infra. Whetiier absolutely or conditionally.' The uoi.l (.uiidi- 'ieiially '' hero ii.sed is no doubt introduced lO cover the underwriter s iiact. wliicli has almost invariably londitions aiinoxeil to it. Tin' "' ■ " " ' ulllcicnt ' casi uliscribeN -ronditionallv. rOllUT wdi'ls • uhethei abscilutely or londitionaliy '' ajipinir amply si 10 -ver ihe ease ol a man who subscribes absolutely and the case of :i mill who oiilv uinlerwriies that i.s If the payment oi the commission is authorized by the articles. ' It follows that to loiiiply with tlio section the aiiioiini or i:i;o must 1)0 aiilhorized by iho articles of association, aiul the coiii- lui.ssioii paiil or agreed to b(! paid must not exceed iho amount or rale ~o aiiiliorizeii. The ''articles'' here mean the articles a.s origiuall.\ •i.uued or as .iltered by special resolution (see sect. '2Hr>). Accord- iiiuls. any (omjiany which lias not got in its articles a suitable pro- vi-ioii can. liv special resolution, aller its articles so as to inlroduco lie |iiiivision.and lliis pouer can be used loth whore there is no ]U'o- vi-ioii at all anil where the e.\isting jirovi ion is found unworkable. • ' 7 . when it provides lor the ))aymenl of commission at too low a ,alc The articles may [irovide that a specitied sum may bo applied in (layiiiir comniissioii. or that a sum not exceeding a specitied auiouni may lie .so applied, or that a particular rate may be paid, or that a l'.iw:ient not exceeding a particular rate may bo paid. Does not exceed." The amouut ui laie of ronuiiission which 'he ri,iii|!,.,iiy iiiiiy pay niu.sf not rrreeil the timoinit nr rnf.- per rent. p ' ■182 UNDKHWRITINO. [Chai-. IV. ff. J autliomed by the articles of .is-xocw^/o/t and disclu.i,-d in the pro- spectus, but, subject to thi;* lomlition, iho rtiiioiint or raU' is lolt by th.i I.egislalure to tho company to sottle. it beiug cousidorcd, no doubt. That tlie matter niifrht salVly be left to tho company's advisors, wlio would not be likely to sanction any e.xtravas,'aut «um ; boinji b„ e.vpoudod, reoing tiiat thui.- would lunr to be i.ubliv di.-^clo-^uro. In onP case (Keating,^ v. Pariiuia Consolidated Mines. tVM-2) W . N. IT. , a learned judi^' .s.'emcd to thiid; that u •■ommis-ion uii-ht be so largo a.s to invuive i.ssuinu the <*lumvs at a discount, but it is submitted that thi.- lv authoii/es the payment of a .oinmissioii to a person in con- sideration of hi^ suhseriinn,, for shares, and this is for iinauc.l purpose- cpiivaleni to jssuiuir the shares at a discount. And disclosed in the prospectus ' The amount and rate per cent, of the com.nission must uot only he authori/e.l by the .•on.pany's articles and keep wilhiu 'hat liit.it, but it nmsl be .ILselosed in the company's prospectus where old shares are olfered to the public If the .ompuny is one that does not issue a pro-^penus then the amount an,l rate must be di.sclo.ed m the staU'- ment in lieu of prospectus, or in the tiled statement iu the proscribed foriu See paia. ih) of sect. ». If a dirortor pavs money out of the company's funds by way ot commisMou when "tiic pavmeat of such commission is uot disclosed in tho con.panv'.s prospectus, the company luay recover the amount from bin: i.i an" action. Donunion of Caimda (leneral 1 ruding bynd.- catry. liriqxloke. a',>ll>;2 K. H. ilis. A-. to ,>ub-~eit. •! of sect. 89:- Save as aioresaid no company shall apply any of its shares or capital money.- The.se, the pix..liminary words of sub-sect. (2 .. leave a cotupany at liberty to apply any of iU profits in paying con,- ndssious iu accordance with the practice above referred to as ex_ist- in- before the Act ot 1900 {Hdder v. Dexter, (190::) A. J^ »•»'• bu't thev prohibit a company from applying any of it^ shares or capital money to the payment ot con.mis-sions except in a case co.nn.g Within sub-;ects. 1 or :! ' Tho.e woiJs uaturaliy mean apply H-s capital, eidicr in the form of shares before issue, when they may be described a.s potential capital, or in the form of money derived fron. the is.uc of ii» shares" P-r Lord Davey in llilder v. Dexter, (190. . \ C 17 1 They do not alleit the company's power t* grant to under- 'writens as die ccmn.ission or part of the commission for underwriting, the opti.M. to take up shares at par or above par. Udder v. Dexter, .viipra. Either directly or indirectly.' What u.uy bo .I.e oxu.t .ueau- !J ,lL wcmis has jot to b. .le.or.uiuod. The word ■diroctly nil to ;oint to a .ru.u.a.f.0.. by which the .o-upan, by .o»>e ;; X ol^rir ... bn.. about tl.e p-ohibi^d payn.„t, or ^s o.d •I in HiUer V Dexter, mpra. by -allottiu- the >h,ir.> ":::;:; ^it" t^:tou.ioa ,hat tLy ...aU u..i.„a.o,y .1,.. .h... : ;; .0 su, h perHon or bo applio ,„l,-..>o p.i.e payable by the co.«pauy was loaded by -1'' "^" L o! ,he 'o....ission. Shorty ot this a -""P-O; -'^J ^''^ or e.,.er into au agreon.out lor tho purdia.«e k.,ovv.u^ that tlu al'ws going t; pay for undor-ri.in.. a,.d .ni.ht there ore bo lied .0 have Qxed tho price with .•eterence thereto so that the ^o.npau^ would bo indirectly payi,.g for s..,h uuderwriUng. So Zn ;. rJinl>ur,h Trannra,,.. ,1803) A. C 77. .n wh.h case Lo d " rsohoU L. C, said. "It is obvious that .n es.Mna.n.g '.M.-JOt^ ., •'was .0 be paid by tho Tran.ways Co.npany to the (abb •o Ltion. 17,000?. of it wa.s esti.nated as paid tor the an.oun of le^penes, bec.au.se the whole a.reo.ne.U was under ne.ot.a..on !:: ,L sa.ne ti.ne:' an-l see arr„> Sor,„.W..f re.tral H.u,n.,„ ^ r/wWebo(>, (189S^ A.. C. 114.) See v!i;>r-*it. i2), und thus atfords iiiiich-nwded relief. The romhidiiitf words of the suh-soclicn are material, the pay- iiii-iil of whi( h if made directly hy the iom|miiy would have lK>on leuiil under the Keotion." They show that a vendor or promoter In* no fioo hand to pay .oinnii-sion, lie m.iy agree to pay .1 .oninii-sion, hut if he ds m> it must be seen to that the oora- [lany coidd lefraliv pay such i ouimisHion; that is to say. that llie articles allow it. and that the c.inimi'^sion is duly disclosed us in (hi .if sub-sect. 1 1 > |ir(ivicU'd. i^ili-li: .•\~ Id Mlll-^L'Ct. (^.l)'.— Such brokerage." Suh-seci. (,■!) gives a slatulory .sanction to the decision- c)f ilio Court ni .Vppeal above referred to ii: Melru- I'olilun ('(Mil ('onsuiiicr.'i' .|.vm«//i/(o;i v. Stiiiii^.<>rv<>d the learned judge, "that tlie section was intended to prevent the vendor from giving part of his shares to underwriters, but assuming this to be so, I can see no reason why the words of the Act should not be applied to other mk INIhOUUtrrOKY NOl'KH. •iH."» ...... -a.. u.n- whirl, arc t.iirly witli.u tl.o exp.e-«d uiicnti.... of tl..' V,., und .1.0 ...i^cluor ...to..ao.l ,„ 1... thoivl.v ,.r.,v.-.UMl, It w,i~ ;,,,...I tlm. .l.e iHcmiu...^ ruuUl ...» U' ■' -i-iU I, a.ul ll.a. the .0.1- ile. ..in., lu. ,1.0 u.ulerw.ili.ii,' ...ife'l.l 1h> puid ou- of ,,re,mu...s, bu. ,L .< ,.... tl>.- -a.*- Mow ...o. Tlu. An disti..K..i«l.<'> b.-twoo>, ,,,,,,.1 uu.l .-l.a.t-, and ....bid. .!.« upplitutiou of ^.i.l.e.- iu puymou. ..'f u...ie.«r^ti..i,' co.u...i.-io„, u..d 1 buvo ,0 .onMdor only a .loahnu «ill, -hart- not with the n..MU>)- i.ro.l...>ed by those ^hart's. lln- .loei.ion was affirmed o.. appoal. ■ How," «aid Rigby L, J .-ca., sou ■•iPldv- siia.us more .loarly than by allom..g them? When v,,,, illut the shares vou apply n..t their uun.i..al valne, but ih- ,l„rJs un.l that is «"hat s..b-se,t. (2) prohibits.- Thi o.m.hk.u «... In.wever, overruled by the llou-e of Lords in Hildvr v. Prxfrr ,l.Ui->i \ C. 47t fn that ease the company determined in I'.MIl 'to i 'sue a |...rtion of the shares in its .apilal. and it .lid so b> ,,le„„.- the shares not to the publi.' but to f..ur.iK.n persons. ..I «i,on, Hihlor wu-s one. Ho api.lied for and was allotte.l shares on th.- ,„||„win.' terms, nameiv: "For each share allotted in a-vordanc- will, this application a subscriber .shall have the option, .lurii.},' th.' ,„,,i„.i .,1- one vcur fr..n. the ;i...„ th.'v ;• l.e deserilMsl a. pn.c„„al ,ap„al „r in .!..■ fer,n .,f .....,wv deriv-.l fr.M,. fe .^u,- .,r it« sltar,.^. • I.. p.y"..M,t o, „,v „„i,si,m. diseoaat or all..waa,e.- I think this ■„..». payuent l.y fl.- ci,nj>any. The won! Is ■ (lisioiint .>r allowance ' se.„> to mean the sami- thi,...'. ua,»ely.'a rebate on what would justly !..• .lue from the swl,s,-r,l,er on h,s .sha.es. The advantair.' which the appella,,, will derive fro,,, the ex.T.-.se of l„s opt.o,, „ ,er,ai..lv not a 'discount or allowance.' I.e.ans.- he will have to pay -in-. . ,I„. puund'fur everv share. N'..r is it. in my opini.>n, a eon,m.ss,on puul l.ytl nnipany. for the company will not part with any Jioi-t rc'-i'i vrd hy it intact, or. . 10,1 of its <':ipital. whi'ii lei'd, with any ii..i,i.y~ li.'loi,','in^' to it. i!ut th. rd- r..! t-.,ird on are * that the compiiny l>y enga future date is applyincr or using its »1 ther directly or Indirectly." and tin- arLTumcnt scnis to lie to allot shar.-s at ]iar to th.- sliarehi ; . r at iissihle heiielit at the expense ot iharcs eom er as to -riv.* hun a i the company in this sense, that it forepoes the 1) - MB v«i rNDKHWKlTINf!. [I'HW. IV, I'hsncf of i«^uiii({ them nt a proniiuiii. With nvafl •" ''"" lul'ff point it niu)- nr m%j not I>a at thn exprniM^ of the ciirMpuny. I am not uwurp of any U» which oliliifM a rompanjr to i««ui' itn «hari'« uImhi par biKaiHO thi'y arc ■•uhjlili at a premium in the market. It dcpctnli on thi' i inuni«tanci'» of each ca^ wliclhcr it will ho pruilont or oven |>o.4!iihlc to ilo «), anil it n a <|iir«tion fur the directorn to decide. Rut the poinl which, in my opinion, i^ alone iii:ii rial for the present piirpoy liim a; the expense of ilir company'* capital. Tl.e prohihitiil appliiation of the ^h.ircH may he dlrci I l,v allotliri^r them ,n fully or partly paid up to the per-on und.rw ritiu,' Ihe >ih:ii-c<, or hv allottinif them in .ni. particular ca«' a contract »uc luric- lo the coiiclu*ion from a con*idcration of the lanu'unnc of ^ect. S. *uh-«ei t 'J, tliii the prohibition therein contained extend* oidy to the application dcreit er indiriM-l of the cfiin|inny'* capital in payment of a eiminuKxion by the i.impany. ind the tran-aition inipcachcil in tin* ia*e i* not within it." <'.immi"ion Payment of Commission out of Profits. It i* ioicillii.\ iinm out. f profit*. |||j_^ (|f( isii)ii tliiit tlio ■' ijoii (l(Kj.-i not proliiliit the iiuviiicnt of com- iiii.-i.>ion out of iiii(li\ idol iiolit* ol' tlie c'liiiifiiiiiv, wlictlicr slainliiip: to lOHorve ur mil, l)ut iit' i(nii><' if paMiii'iit i< to 1)0 made out of ixi,*ervc. i! must 1m' soon that thn ic-orvc fimd ilaii.sc iiifrd. p. T")! cmil.iiii- uorilw, wpecific and jrein'ial. sulliiicnt to covor siicli a puvinont As to Premiums on the Issue of Shares, lieforo llio An ni 1000, \vlipr>> .slinrps woii" l paid "Ut of tlio ))rotniitni.s, and oinincnt lawvor* had advi*od that rho p.ivmcnt tlieiponf \va'< Ipo-al. There soonis tn he iKithincf ill .sect. H!» of th< Vet of \'M)H to iiivaliihito thin prdfliie Ap.irt from tho .^oftion and froii: any .special proviMions in the arliclc- iif a company, pr('mium.*i art> tisiialiy carried to reserve or broiiLrlii into tlie prolit and h).>;s account i.:* part of the companyV revenue ihey aiv not capital an apply the .same or part in payment of tic ex|M'nses of oarninir aavh premiums is rea.sonaljle enouL'h. Hir whether premiums (an now ho applieti in paviuir commission i- another matter; it involves dill'erent considerations from the applica- tion thereof in payment of dividend. To justify dividend thereout ii st he shown thtit tliey are net pvidils. J.iililxiek v. lirilish Haul: ui (18921 2 (.'h. 198; Foster v. Sew Trinidad Co.. (1901) 1 di • I.* Prohibited Transactions. Wh.at the Act then allows i> a fuil\ tli.sclosed payment subject to the sitccitied conditions; all other pay- ments are prohibited by sub-sect. (2). iNTK<»j)i:c"roin N(n>x Wt llonco ii in not iillowiiliU" to evadr lull ilUclixuro hv r^iatitit; th»t the wimiiifwion i." in lie at, vurviiiK rnit's not oxi-«'»'diiii.' 'i por i«nt , ' for tliw do€w nut disi'lasc tlio actual amount p.iiil or ay;rtHjtand^<: I. A coiiipanx which hii.n llu> rc(|iiixil<> pnwor in it/* articlw. a« ori^inallN Iranicil nr a.-. altcr(>iiin lor underwriting Nliaii'H in its capital, providcili(Hl in fiili-'wt. (1) of tert. 8'J of tho Act of l!tOH ;uw ic.iiiplicd wiih '2 A r whicn validly a-i"'-'* to p.iy a iinnniiM.iii.ii -tf aforesaid may, i' in concoiv(>d. ro-~ioii fur undci'writinf,' shares in it^ capital, anil that withoiil complying; with the cdndilions imposed liy sect 89 ( i i of the Act of I'.ms. ,">. A ((inipany may. out of I'Opital or prolitw. pay fo"- underwril- iic_' lielicntuivs iir nther .-securities of ihc company (as dislinjrnislied from it-i own sliare~ i nr sliar<'s in .ir Koeurilies of any other company owned bv it il A company nriy irive an option to call for ~li,irc-, in ii.v cajiilal as the consideration for uudorwritinfj either shares or ilebonluri's, debenture stcxk. or other securitiert of tin- company. 7 Save as afon'said, a company may not pay, direotly or indi- rectly, any underwriting commissions in r shall be ^ubsciiliuJ wiihin a spoiilicil period, and in that case tlie v(mi<1"1- ciiniiiioiily -ct^ ili. uutiilicf miderwritlon so as tn ensure the carrviii',' >ary to disclose the ainouiii or rate of tlir e-imiiiii.'^siuii ]iui(l or a to. the ciiutracts on the a.ssuinptioii that sub-soct. 1 (k) of sect. 81 reipiires such disclosure, and this is the safest cour.se. It may well be considered that as para, ih) expressly requires ,|is,losiire of tli. romnii.ssion. that is sufficient. Where the uuderwritinor commission is to bo jiaid out of uridividcl profits, it may sometimes be nope.s.sary to disdo-e the contracts undei sect. 81. sub-.sect. 1 ik). Heuiustrii' tion. 1 tain! As to Underwriting upon a Reconstruction. Wlmie it is pio- po.sed to rcdinstruct a lunipany by transfer of the uudertakinfr t" ii new company in consideration of shares credited as partly [lai.l up r.ij.. II shares with los. per share credited to bo distributed atifiif. the meud)crs of the transferring company, it is very coramonl\ desired to have su( h shares underwritten, so that the new compan> may start with sutlicieut capital resources. The didiculty in the way of this arrangement was that uiidci I be original form of the ])ower as contained in sect. 8 of the Cniii- jiauies Act, I'JOtl, the underwriting coumussiou could only be pai.l u[)0ti any oiler of shares to the public for subscription," and it wa- held in Buuth v. At'if Afrhamicr (ioUl Minlii;i Co., ^^191):!) 1 <'h 129j, that an offer of shares on a reconstruction by the now com(iaii\ to tho shareholder.s of the old company through the medium of llic li.piidator was not an 'oiler of shures to tho public' This dilliciiliv is removed by the new form of the power in sect. 8!» of the Cum|iuiiii- .Vct. l'J08, which does not contain the words 'on any oiler of shaiv- 10 the public." and therefore permits payment of undorwriliini . onnnission. whether the shares are olleied to the public for sub.scii|'- lion or not. A dilhiiilty, however, still remains, having regard l' the fact that payment is, by sidi-.^ed. d i. only allowable for subs. til. ing, or agreeing to subscribe, or procuring, or agreeing to proniic subscriptions, and "sub.scriptiou " is not, it, has been suirgested, n very aiiproijriato te'iu a.s applied to the taking up of a share, credited as partly paid ii]), which, under a contract of ro-onstruction, a share- holder is entitled U» have allotted to him. In a scum-, no Joubi, tic underwriter in such circumstances who agrees conditionally to taki INTRODUCTORY NOTES. •»S!> lip tho .sliarci< not taken up by tlin Khiiiolioldpi-s in tlio rpconstriirtinp iDiMiuuiv mav lio saiil to Imvu milisirilK'd. tor he iiy lilt" liijni- Jaior. but whollier he technically "subscribos " within the iiieaninf:: (if the .-eilion reiiiaiiiN for decision. It may also be said that the re- construct iiijr company is not in a ])osiiioii to ^^ive title to the shares, "Cciii" that bv the reconstruct ion afrreeuient they are to bi placed III the disposal of tlio sliaroholders or of the liipiidators. but neither of iIk'sc |ioints have much siilistaiU'e. and would |U'obably \ ield to a lihcnil 1 ou.-triiclion of the section as an oiiablin<;- one. But .sec ll,iin,ir V. Variiupi. iHIHO) 2 t'h. C.W. t 5 '■■% As to Framing Underwriting Contracts, lueal caic and < ii- . iiiii>|icciion are ro(iuisiic for thi- luirpi^e, iiiasiuiich as astute iHiilcrwi iters, when caUod on to peiforin their perhaps onerous ip|iliL;ali'iiis. raise every jiossible obiocfiou. and in :!ii ill-drawn iindei - uiitiiiu the uuderuiiler may sny: "1 ,i;rreed to underwrite on the lo'iiiiL;' >if .1 )n'ospeilus. to be prepareil in accordaiiie wiili a |':wli- ( ulai draft .--ubuiitti'd to me. and tliat draft was altered without my iiiii.-eiit. Thend'ore. I refu.se to apply. (If an underwriter may take this objeiiiun: ' I linil that the pio- f|icriii> oil the faith lavoiirable |(osition. .-is lei^^ards obtaining;' relief on the ji-round c: ijifci i.~ in a prospectus, than an nidiuary applicant fiu' -iliaii''. Sic /;,///,' \ . I\r.firiih\ 8.") L. 'I'. IH. Or a;^aiu he ma\ ii(".;leit lo ajiplv . and. wlieii siu'd for damaLi'es. may say: '' 1 niil\ undci'loi>k t'. apply (/ ciillril nil. and yon never called on mo to apply." Oi iiinrni's rust'. . IH'.ili 2 ( li. IT."). Or. if the shares have been allotted lo him. lie iua\ repudiate the alloliiieiit on the frroun faih'il \vhen idled on to apply. See Cinisort Ih'i'ji LrrrI (!i>hl Miiu'x. ilS!t7> 1 ( h. .">:.-!. Even where the underwriter has a'tiially a|)plied pttrsuaiii to the I'liti ct. he sdinetiiues. before allotmeat, serves the company with a icilirc that he withdraws his applicr.tiou. and. after allotiuiMit. he Miiiielitiies i-epndiales dii tho i libod, the company was not in cxistouco. KarhrruK rase. (_1892^ lU'h. 1. r. u I'rnlllilifr I'f uiiilt rwntiu;: cinitrai'ti*. 2;m» UNDEKWRITINO. [Chap. IV. f i :i riidcrwritiug letter prima /in " an (i&ir. \Vithdraw:il. Dfcasionally au uiidorwriter, williout uiiv sliow of legal justifica- liou, as ill liio above cases, sooiiig that an issue has not gone -wfll, simply roliises to apply, and says: " Bring your actiou, I shall defend it, and you will sutler by the delay and publicily, .so you had better tompioiuise ", or, in the case of debentures, he used sometimes to say to the company: "I decline to take u[) the debentures under- written by me. Bring your action if you like; but you cannot get spei ilic performance of an agreeniem tor a loan, or any substantial damages." Wr.slrjn W'aijuii Co. v. WcM, (^Wyi\ 1 Cli. 271; South Afrinin Tcrriliii/f.s v. Wulliiiijloii, [^IHW ■■ \. ('. ;i(»!t; liahanuts I'lmi- lalioiis V. liilffiH, 14 T ].. H. i;5'J. But this attitude of deiiance will no longer avail him in the case of dobentui-es or debenliiiv ^tock now that the duirt is empowered tu specilically enfone a contract to take up aiii pay for debenturc< .See fompanies Act, I'.tOS, s. 105. The above arc only a few of the difliculties that may arise, but they .-^erve as a suthciont warning to frame an underwriting contract so as specialtv to provide fptanre ( //i'/V/.< <•((•<'. 4 E(£. U) and by word of mouth. Tninuin'.'i cnxi: I 1»"J4; 3 Ch. J72. The oiler must bo accepted, if at all, within tlic lime s[)«'ci|ied i:i it, or, if no liino is sperilled. t' n within a reason- able time iCrnirh'i/s caxe. 4 Ch. o2;J; llitidlcij's case, (^Ibi-Hi) 2 I'h- 121, 134), and until accepted and notice of acceptance given there is no contract, ('oii.iort, dc. Mines, (18tt7t 1 Ch. ,'>'■>. An oral acceplaiR<« is of cour.se siiHicieiit. Xorth VhailvrUiml Co., 13 T. L. H. 80. In one case it was held that notice of the acceptance of the oiler contained in an underwi itiiig letter might be inleried from the incii' fait ot the retention of the letter by the person to whom it was addressod (UuUjonlciii Sun, dc. Mine, 12 T. L. R. 4Gli; but. in I he absence of e,\press words in the letter waiving notice of accept- ance (.see Carlill v. Cniholir. dc. Co.. ( 18113 i 1 Q. U. 2.')(;), it is dilli- cult to sec how- this decision can bo supported. An uiKlerwriliiig letter is nollniig more than m oiler, and an otler, c.;/., to sell land or to marry, is not regarded as accepted merely because it is retained unanswered. See the observations of Lindley, M. R., in Consort, dc. Mines, aS'Jl) 1 Ch. 5t»3. I XTKODtrirrf iry xoiks. ■.".i| III lllii'Uf.ifK rase. Urmj) Curiliifir to. ( iH'.Hi i -J ch. 121. Viiiijjflian Ihi W illiMiii-'. •!.. Iii'ld tlial nlioic tlio iiiidi'i vviiliiiir liMtcr wai not ae- iO[i(i'(l until iit'tin- iho sliarcs wt-ic oll'cioil to the jiiiMic lln wa^ I' >l tll.it tll<> iiiMloiwiilcv ii'ptaiiio ii-< ciititlcil to ii'piiiliiit(> ill'.lniiMit. altlioii^li wlu'ii III' I't'piiiliati"! ho liiiil I i(>i'ii on I 111' ;i~ii'f lipi- two voar- Hill thi-' (Icii-ioii nil- lovci'-ii'il on :i|ipi'a paiih oil 1 111' hiimI lliiit •)ii tlio truo I'onstruction of tlio lollor Ihn nllcr llioii'liy niiiilo wa-* left open for arioptaiiii' for two month'' ■tl. lis i'ii'.iiiL''<'i K'Mt i-< hiiiiliii": for two iiioati paitly < Ml till fjiMiniil ilial ♦III' 111' liaviiii;- I'.ili'il laros haviii"- liccn allotli'il to tlio tiiidcru ritor 1(1 mor thereof, he w.i-^ ostopppil from deiivin^ his ihers'iip, t\ir the Court is not ilisposeil to import iiiti ider vriliiicr I'ontracts imp' .onditions in doi'OLration of the e\[)ross if the loiitract. Croini /,(■<(.«\ iiiatciial i.i.ison with whom Vnidiiliility for raipTeprt'- pr.-|H I'JIMI. ladi'. Heme, it is important to .see that the [irospcrtiis, or di.ift Tins, or lirriiiar. on the liasis of which llio utiderwritinj; is i- pi i|«Mly framed: and in some cases, before the Act of jirovide expressly that the contract as found dosiiablo tc was iiiit^ thus to he voidable, at. any rate as re^^ards innoceiit misro- pri'-i'iitation. Ill ilie ias<' of a lonipanv re-risteied after Doceiiilier .Jlst, I'JOl), an uii(|"i wriliiiy- 1 iiiitract (like aiiv other irievo whom the aiithoiily is '^iveu ha-s an interest, has been deiich'd in several cases by theCoini of .\)>)i'al. In (aniticlmcr>i aixc. < 18'.t(i 2 Cli. i'«t;>. CarmicMael had MLnied an iiinli-r- wriuufi- letter addressed to the promoter of a company, by which he a'l-reed, in consideration of a commission, to subscribe for l.dOU .sliaw- in the company, the numlier t4i ho reducc- any repudia- tion by him, (should be sulhcient U> aiilhorize the proiiKJter to apply on his behalf and the company to allot them. The |)romoter by lettci accepted these terms. The company was then incorporated, and the Mibscription list was advertised to open on l27th March, and close on the .iOth. On 27tli March. ( armi of tlio uiMUTHriiin^' N'ttt'i', and alliioujrh A. had hiiiidcf! over ili<- h'licr In N' nil llii> distinct hut ])rivatc iiii(l<>i>lan I I li .")7.'). "iCI. was ost((|)|ii'l. naiiK'lv. tiial tho |itinii|ial is hound hy the arts of the aLr<'iit whicii aiv uilliiii iho ai>|iar;'nl smiic nf his aniiiniitv. Sco alsii Did.f of lirnnfiirl v. S'rrtih IKI'n. 12 CI. .V Fin :;is. and llmnhni v. Ihiriuuid. ( Ktnti 2 K. M 10. which shows that nhcic an ati'cnl, in contra w.i~ an nnderwritin;; letter in the shape of an oiler, and that olVer was ni \i 1 acccpled hv the ccaiipany lo whicli it wa> ac, ai.d theivfore thai ihe allotnionv made to the iindorwriier was inclVi'ciive. S<.incliiiies I lie iindei writ*'!', 'in .-i^iiin^' hi^ iinilcrwrii iicj- ieitcr. al.-o -iliiis and iiaiids over ai oinc an application for the full iininher of sliaic> underwritten hy him, t<);_'ptiier with a clicMiie for the applica- litm iii'iiievs. ('nriiiirliiirrx nisi'. (18'.M)i 2 » h. tlH. Tlii^ plan is in seme cases expedient, hnl the underwrilin. letter in sncl; a ca-e slionld hind the nnderwriler not to revoke llr ipplicalion. and as a irencial rnli' there is no special iidvantaw to 1 •■ olitained liv ailoptinu: this niode of iinderwrilinfr. \\ lieiv A. mMre.sMCMl an underwriline- letter lo li. aiiiceinn: "at any I'lidortiking liiiic within thive inonlliK aftor the date hereof, if and a- "ailed upon ^.'^u'l^^j „'.„„•• i\v von, to s||l)scrilie iw tind responsihie siihscrihers for any niimherof shall- yon may reipiiie. not c\ceedine; 1.000." with an authority for B lo :ij-.:i!v 'ill (he event of mv not suhscrihinp' or lindintr respon- «iliic -nhsirilwns," it was held that an allotment to .\. in response to an application hy B. was not otVectivp, H. not having:; called on A. 1 i ii •2it4 IINUKKWKITINO [ClIAI-. IV, to hiil)M lilif. Oiiiiiruds <■<(«<•. ( 18'Jt I -^ I li. 474. Tills tiist- tuinod , tJie |iri'-ciiri> .il ilic woiil-, ■■ ll iiiid ii> rulli'il iipdii Ijv voii. wlii'li uittdi' till' ;iutlKJiil V tu upplv <.< unlit iuiuil mi llio miderwiilci U-iii^r liist Ciilli'il nil. itiiil llius ;.;ivi'ii till' uppiiituiiilv ul lliuliui; suliMi-ilu'i- it Uiiwillinj;' liiiii>.cll In aiiplv. Sfi- aUci to tlie >aiiK' cIlLTt. /)V((s,v7.- ra!i'.nifiiiii Mine. 1'-' T. I., h" . ti;l . nlicii. tii.' •i\ni(l~ \ ri.' V, \\'\\<:\ : i- . all( d uiiMii. WliiTP (■"III- II, ;d! .-11. h ia-f~ till' ' i>!ii|iafi\ . ill doiliuj; willi liii> iiiidciwiiici' .■ tn'rill'f"'' au>'iii.i- lioimd to <,dl loi la> aiillu)iii\ . and i- tlui- lixi'd willi imtiir iiatlinrity of or till' iiii,ililiiaiiiin.~ and i nndiiimi^ ailailied to sucli aiitlioiitv '1'.'^*"'"^ ■■ W hciv. liou.'V/. the apiili^aiioii appeal.- 10 aiKnd uilli llic aullioiily ronlaiiiC'! Ill till' iindciuiiiiiif;' I'oninui. ilic roiii|i,iii\ i,-^ not to In licaic i a,- li.niiiLi aoij.r oi' pi'iva'i' iii^-lriniioii- i:i\('ii to tlic auciit //(,//.- Iir„ltr;i d ( I)., li'.i L. 'r. 20!. ylljuii l)(.r..L';it..rv o,, |||,, ..ii,i,|,, ]ii-iii. ipl,. li- Conn, ii-i i> o; ideni lioai the dcci.-loi! (■omlitiini> not , , . . 1 ■ ,. i #► ■ * /■ i t t 1 i? u,Mi!iIlv to l... 01 i!i<' I oiiil o| .\|ipc.il III ( rnnii /,(W.-c rniiincUnil I n.. 1 ! I . I.. I! impliiil in Hic .\- j.. ,n,; ,|[,|,,„.,! to iiiipoii into iindci u lit in.; miiliail.- inipiii'.i cu.rli'ioii-. II! dcio^'aiioii o| iln' ii'iin- ("^pn-.-Til . In tlial (a-n .\ iiiicln w loM' .-iiini- .--ll iii-i. and. o,,vc ];. aiidiiniiv to appi_\ . I!, applioii after !■ had Ik opi.' 1 I'mi iho ilic .-•lii'inc 1 ouH'inplatt'd l.\ die pio- .-pi'ctn- roidd iioi l.c i,iiii<',| iiin. ll wa-- held ne\ e; llieie- . dial A u.f- l.oiiiid. WhiTi m- Wdieie .\ ,-i::ned all nndei \\ ill ii|o- loiiirael "idl 11.. lai: failed "!lT'«l'tll'u''l. ^''"'I' '■''''■'' "" '',' '■ '" "I'l'l.'^ '•'»• '•"• ■■^"i>''<'- 'I "•'" lii'l'' '''•" ^- "'^•■ uiidiTwriti-r ciilided 10 iii- c onniii"ion tiiouoji lie had iiiadi' dcfaiill and IJ. had •indno'oi'urcs '"-'' i'l'l'l''"! ''"' 'li'" ''"!''" ^^■•'•- de ided on the oiuiiml thai pavnieiii wtTc appluci of tie ii'innii.--hiii ua~ not iiuide eoudilional on A. dulv ajiplyino. and that 1!. Inni no e;iii-e for .Diiiplalut. as hf iiiiirht lia\e applied on A.v hi'half. Saiii/ylrr v. Setter. 'J T. I.. I{. 111. Siiecific Till' Miideiwii'ino- of delieiitlllO.'- incscnted this diilieiill i . tlnit tl IHTformiUicc Coll,. I uoiild jio! iiiiiil ilic ( 'i)iii|iaiiii>.~ Ael. I'.t.i7, i-. Hi (now replaced 01 .inmjfo.-. j^^ ^^^^^ 1^^. ^^|. ^1^^^ t'oiiipunios Aet. r.l!l8 1. spoeitieally onforee an and sliiir.- aor<'Ctii('iit to horrow til to lend nioiiev ut tlic iii-taii.i' of citlicr llie ,listiii>r"i-lio. if a man Mlh.'-erilied for and Iteeaine the iilhitlee of .-hare-., and made default in iiayino- up the anioiinl in due eoiiix'. the (()iiipan\ eoiild and eaii recover the amount from him; lint if ho isiili.-erilieil for doheiiliire-. and made delaull in payiii'^^ the instal- ment.-, the lompanv coiiM not, prioi to l".)l)7. sie for the lialance ll could only claim damage.-, and in most ca-e- the damae-es ojveii would be uoiiiiiial. Smith Miiivil Tcniloiics v. Wdllinilloii. 1 I8OS1 tor in Iii- name. INTKODlICrOKV NOTK.x. •,*»5 A I ,!iHt; Hiilidiiinx I'litnlnlidiin v. (iriljiit, 11 T. I,. K. l.i'.i. Home, 111 ilii' r.iM' (il (l('l)i'tiluies, till' leal soiuiilv (i>v tlio |iaviiu'iil ul miIi- .-i(|iRiil iii.'-laliiK'iit.'* wiiN the umoiiul, it' any, iuMiuiIly jiaiil dii iippli- lalinii anil suli.-eiiuonlly which was uj (uun amiiiIiI citrliiic til riiiii|K'l .-|)riilic- port'orniain'C of a fonlrati to lake up licln'i;- luic .-lork pavaliio at a tixcil ilali'. (uv thr i'->iu' ol' siuli >i.irk ii'all\ .iMiiiiiiil- til a lioiTOwiug of nioiioy, t'i.mgii il inuy he tlial llii' nilf iliil iiii; applv to .-o-iallt'il pcipctiial ilic H'laliiili.>lji|i llicir iml belli;;- the oiiliiiaiy dmi' "I bniruwi'r ami li'inlri'. bill ill thi" iiatiirc of a luutiart tn punliasc a |ii'i|i(''iial aiiiniil\. a (iillll.Ht nf wllilll till' ( iilllt will 'Jiallt .-|ll', itii- |irl f.illiKllli !• I. Srr liiiiliii. I'.irl ill., loib nl. Kil. .\bii(n\(.'i, ihi' riili' iliil iioi apply ulii>ii ilir iimii'i u liiiii'^- iniilrail \\a> 'i: iilc, Jiol with ilio (.iMiipaiiy, but with a tliii-il pan; . c.i/.. tli»> voiyilcr. Ik' at any ralo woiilil be I'luitli'd U< Mili-laiiliai - pii.-iii^ I'f ib'bcHliirc.- ol soiiR' iilhci' runipaiiy. fm in siuh ra^o llu' iiaii>ai tiiiii i^ in <.'ll'ei-t. a ooutratt of sale, not of loan, ainj liii'i'of'iro .-|ii'i ilii' pcrfonnaiici' will lie derfeeil. Ill most ea>e>i the I'iehl to keep tlio amount pie\ iim>l\ paiil albililej ,1. Millirieiil ;;iiai'anty that a siib<' lilier wnujil ]iay the balame; Init .-oiiielinie.^. ami ospecially wlieii llie iu.slalnienl.'- ueie spread ovii a loii;jilieueil peiiu.l. il was ileeiiieil advisable i.. >iip|)leiJioni. tlds ;;uaianty by iiiserlin;.'- u provisiun einpoweiin;,'' tlie eoiiipany to aulho- li/e .>oine p<'i'son on the subsuriboi's behalf to aiie|ii the iiini|iany's Iliil of exrlianLTi', payable on demand, for any instalment in relation to wliirli the siilisiriber makes default, Such an authnrily bein^j: part ■ if ilie iMiiir.ni was inevof-able. and lln; aei-cpior wmilil liaM' to |ia\ ilie amuuiil "f the bill, and not. mero daiiiay:i!^i. Sot! Form Jl. .Ml llie>e 1 ^e li isi i ml ions mid deviros are now. houoM'i-, lendeied ■ ilis..|i'ie by the se. him above allmled to i Companies Art. i'.MiS. -. Iii.'ii. piiiv idiii;:' iIk.i " .\ iiiiiiiarl wiili a loiiijiany In take up ami pav liii aa\ debentures nr il'lientnio sioik of the iiimpan\" iiiav be eiilm :'i| b\ an nrder fm spi ilii; performaiire ' . a liin;i'-iieeili'il refm lu biiiit;iii;! llie 1,ih into line uilh i;iioil sen~e. .\ii nnderw 1 iiin;:' conlrait under liaiul reipuri's a lii/. Mam|i mdv: if under seal a llt.v. siaiiip. The fact that i( contains an authority to ap[ily on the underwriler's behalf docs not. render a power of attorney stani)) requisite yWalkrr v. lieiniiictt, la L. J. L'h. 8, 174 i. for tlie authority is imidentiil to the other provisions; hut- an aiitho- ril\ III apply, wliirh is not ])art • f a contrail, may reipiire a power of aiinriiev .slainii. Ills- Ibiil . TiTmiiiulI" ■ 1, iM-IltlllV 1.1 uik. ■• I'lipi Iiial " 'li-ln'litii! !■•• iir ili'liclituii' stii.k. S]H'iMtir |ii r- t'ormiilH-i'. '/v. S^icitic i ; "i I'l-rt'iiniriiir h ■iiiitnirl is *T with thii-il IKirtv or :i> til lii'lw'iitiin ■* I'f iiri'tliiT rill.lliliuy. I'orfiiturt I nt' ji.'liil ill -.liilniiiits Ul .lefiiiilt. IiIm'^ given. ■im m •J9« L'NDKRWRITINO. [Chap. IV. PHECEDKNTS. Form 13. UndiTwritiT's ]>|. upplicatiiin . IM..I Tin; A ('i)\iimn\. I,imhi:i) il' KiD.iMMI -liiirc- III' 1/ I'Mili. |i:i\alili' a^ tull' l(> llii' aliiiNt'-iiMiiii il I Clout IciiH'ri. I II '1 1 1 iii'.sl Mill t.11 ailiiiil nil' a- an iiiiilciwiili'r at a i-i>iiiiiii--'iiiii i>\ V il' lO(l) dl' tlic aliiivc shall aciv li'ss niiiiilicr mhi thiiilv lit, ami ii|iriii llii' torins .-ci loilli ill till' within iimii '^'n i.s 111 iiiitilv nil- liy pii-^t vmir ari(|ilaiir(' ln' IVIll'. \i,iii-.-. Ac Daii All iiiiilorwritinL' li'ttrr. if fi lull - I- ;l -|niT .■^ifiiialui'O . A(l,...tus. „,r i, v.rv rommonlv ha s that so .Iteration iMMono's „,.,-..-ary at the I,,, ,„„„„.■„,. an,l. in the ah-enee of authority to alter, it »o„l,l l.e ne.essary to ; L Vl the underwriters to eonseut. Oe.usionally a provision >s added as to „luTli-inL; '.'/., -aiHl sueh pro.peetus is to I.,- advertised and . ireulated to '„„„ extent as the eompany's brokers shall advise;" but it w.mid not be safe to ..V ,l,at it should be "duly" or -fairly" or "widely adverti-ed for then ,;\,„„1,1 1, „ to eaeh un.lervvriter to obj,-..t that the advert, senu'nt was n,.t .uffieient. Somel.no.s it is provided that the prospe,-tus must ,.p,'e,fy the day f„r np.'ninL' and elosinu' the list of subserii.tions. J JVli.io throe oeloek on tlif day on wliieli tli« i)ios|,oi-liis ndaliiiy: lolhe aliovc isstic is lirst ailvoitisod in tin- lunvsiiapi-is or ..ii ulii. li ,1,0 lisi ol sul.seriptioiw is opened, as H\miiml in the piosi.oelu.s wl.rn nnMislicd] •■ach nndfiwritor in U) apply for th<" miiubor of tlie slum* „„aerv,rim.n bv luin. and ovory sueh api)lie.^ i.ust Ik> .ueoinpan.od |,v a ehr,|n.. in lavour of iho haiikois of ih,. . oy lor .ho rrt by the underwriter or lii» nomine or ■• sitrneil by the undirwriter or It IS a .ipmniori plan to recpiire the ttliieh the list is opened. Somi'tinu's tiu> form runs, " si^'iied iiiiiuinees (upprovi'd by Ihi' eompany i." >.tlier r.plieatn.n as lollows: • V./(. I make this a|iidieation as r'lief, /II') I'll'i. of tlo' iinderwnters as an undervvritometime of the list^. ease substitute eondition H for 2, and let ilie I'ollowini.' rlau-- ' be eondition 3: :l II upon llio (•losing' of tho li.sf of -iibscriplions iJio whulo of llio t-iiuics (jil, ivd shall not have boon subscribod for by the puldic, each iiii.lorwritor. upon -ho ro(piost of the coy, is to apply, in actoi laiieo with the prospectus, for his proportion of the .shares not subscriU'd by the public."] V,i„,r„ .:;,!i ;i rondiiiun i.-. used, it is ne<'e»s.-,ry u, ^•ive lo the underwriter uutiie statin^r how many shares he must apply for, and until that notieo is Siveii and default made by hhn he does not " fail " to apply within eondition 4. C.,„^,„t..\-r. Mi,,,-., (1897) 1 fh. ■■,-,'>: /ln,.ir/. l>„/,'i;- uf runrlir' v. t',,i,-l,i,-i, in T. L. K. 72. IP'- •,'»H Fonn 13. UNUKKWK1TIN(J [Chap. IV. Ji. Till' jiublic niibHcriptionx for tlif fhurcs rcwivod lM>fon> lhf» flosinp of flio (iiilwrription H.^t uro (o jro in roliof of the uiKjorwrilors, in propurliun to tlic aiiiouiiln uiidcrwritton l)v lliciii i>'s|ily. Subscrip tiunx liv the jmlilic witluliawii U.'foro uUotnicnt, and nubsiTiptiouM I'ojtK'Icd ))v tho diiTclori an uusiilisl'ii'toiy, arc not to bo cciinttMl a« piil)li('. mitwciiptions. Siinii'tiniiw pn)visi(jn h iiiail<> *li/it applications initiulind uiid spnt in hy :iii undcrwritrr liofor.' tl»' licnin'i 'm »uliwri|itii>n list, ami iicci'ptiil by thi' ('•'Mipuny, ar*' to pi iti fiirtlit . rv on of -siirh nntlrrwritcr".- ohii^utiou. Sttnu'timi-^ liit? i^^av of a jmrtion ul' lin' y-iiaru?* Iia^ iit'cn otlnTwi^r Insuri-d. iityil in Hucli case it niny !"■ jirr<*sxary to add a rlau.*i' to tin* rffcct tiiat " the vcndt-r- ^llall lie di'i'iniii to underwrite - of tlic said Hliar('< on tln' fiMitin^.' of tl i'ondition<," and if »> arranifi'd it ran lir provirlnl tliat tin' pnMi'' "ulwriptieii- ■■ i coy is to bo at lib«'ity to noniiiiato sonic ]i('ison on l)t>hiih of siii'b II ndci-M liter, to.siyn and put in Miob ap|>litoii, and to (.ojiiliKloan aoTucnit «itii tbo coy for tbe aUolniont tplieation for the shares, the vendors beinjr empowered to till ni> tin Idank for the [iroper pro[)ortions when asiertained. 5. Eadi underwriter is lo bo [luid by ibc loy u coniini.ssion at tin rate of X. p.c. ou the amount undorwritton liy liiin, 8iicb ooniiiiis- eion t.o be paid within days aftor tlio coy bocouie,s entitlwl to et)iimn>nc<' l)usiness. Soiuctimes it is provided that the cummi^isiun was to be paid out of .-"iiie particular fund, e.g., "out of the cash portion of the purchase-money payalilu by the company to the vcndorK, and the payment to be made within ^~ days after the first ir<''"'''"' allotment of tho shares aforesaid, nr within days after the completion of the purchase." or within days after the payment of the first instalment of the purchaHc-money payable by the company to the vendors. See now sect. 89 of the Companies Act, 1908, »«//ra, p. 279. When the commission is to be paid by the company out of premiums, prei- sion should be made accordinijly, e.q., " is to be paid by the company out of the premiums received in respect of the above issue a commission at thi' rate of £ per cent.,'' &c. ^t^ FORMH. •'H!' \, li> payment "ut of proniiiini*, wo p. JMii. »«/./■<. Form 13. S.,iiiitin.i-. tli»' .otiipiiny rc..r»p-. powrr to K.-.tiify tlif r.,riinii->i..p l.v tlir i.-ue i.f paiil-iip "liiirr*. I, 'llii' iimlorwriKTM aw to U- wli<-vitl ultx>t;oth('r, llIllo«^ at l.'iw*! - ^ oi' Ihp «d sharcw aro undorwrittoii »M>f(iro the prtispeilu< i- (mH- Su> li tt riiiiilition ill «)metiiiifs inwrteil. Somctiiii"^ a icimlitioii us follows in inscrti'd: — luidi liiiiltTwiitor if to lie ill lilicrly In deliM-iiiim' lii-* nlili^'atiou i„ Mit.>rril.o if U'toTo the - day of tli<^ . t.v ■s has lakon phu'C S Aii\ allouuciil U> an uudfrwritor ;i.s smli niusi U' luado within weeks from tlic dati' uf his applii on for aii una lian''< of 1/ eiiili. i;<'iill<'mi'ii, I. With irlv ri'ini' Id ilRMliiili |iio.«|ii'i|iis. iti-il tl lii\ i.| - you pniix ami ijiarkfil "ilial'l .-.iilpjoil In ii'vi-i'iii,' wliirli wlicii linally M'ltlr.l to issue, ami loi' llii- riiii.'^oii In-low iiii'iilii. I llii' umii'i- ludciwiik' - ol' llii' aliovc .liaios no to lio olicicd ainl liaiiij you an apiilicon I'oi- llio ruiuc lojjfcllH'r with flu'i|ur Ini for ])ayiiiciit of llu' .l('|M>.-ii of per sliaio jiayabio on tlic sijriici hh I MOW IK'S nmliTwiilU'ii li\ nil" ulii'li is to l>i ip|ilii'il ari'oiiiin^'ly It U nuw viTV romiiiuii to ri'i|uiir uii iiiiiiir»rit<'r to "i^n at oui'p a form ■H'V lii'iit loii una iiav omt ttir a i|>))li'at Hill iiioiin till' [layiiii'iit roiiii- cuaraiitri ,f /,. h-./r '2. Mv .sulisrl'ipMoil Is tci 111' 111! llic tlTPIls ol your plospi'cfu- .IS finally sotlloil ami lili'il with iIh' Hi'jris'rir of Cuiiipanii's, .nid y. m are .it lilitTty to insi'il tlii' ilalc of such )iiospeitus in my appiiron ' r ■t •■ f ;t. If !)/■ liio wlioio of tiio .sil - .shaii's ill your lapila) .siiait bo applioil for by ami alb'tti'il to liie publir. I uiii not lo In; alloltrd any .slinios in rcsjiod of my appiiron: Imt if j^tlii' " nolo of .■ikIi .«ihar<'s bo not so applioil for anil allottod, ihon all ap])lirons ni idu In llic publir on wliiih allotmi>iit.s aro madi' an' lo bi- ap| iii'il in ii'iiil of the undorwritors, iniludino: mysi'lf, raloably in jiroporiion ;o ilic amount of tho .shares unilorwiiiti'ii by ihcm losply. I'rovidi'd tiuit ii any of (lio iindorwrilcr.s .shall, undi'r ilauso t of liio undiMwi iiin- lotlor.s. .siibsiribo or [iroriiii- suli.si ripiioiis for anion lus in cvii-s- of \]ir amount.- whirh llioy would bin for this proviso liuvo to taki' '.[i, tiun tho oxtoss shall bo applied in relief of tlio iiiidi'i wriiors wh" liavi' ii'h loniplctely roliovod ihoni.selvcs updor claiisi' 1. and in pio|iuilioii lo tho aiiiount.s undorwi illoii by ihi'iii rosply. I All appiiion.s initiallod li,\ iiii' and approved by you. sciit in i'> mo prior to tho time fi.xod by the prospertus for closinfr tlio list of .subscriliers, aro to bo applied primarily in ..>lii i "f my oblijiration iii Mibsiribo heroiindor and shall no! bo ronsniiii'il siiii-iriptions by tin' publir ."). II 1 witlulraw, or do not hand you die abovoaiiuld aiiiiiic'ii you are lo be at liberty to authorize any one of your officers in ni} 1. iine or on my behalf to si>;n and \y.\i in an apiilicon in the form rol'errotl to iu the prospeitus as published for the number of shares M KDKMS. Ml „i„|,.ivuii<'ii liv Mi- ..I iiii\ li'nx iiHiulM'r, aii4 lo uil.r uii ali'.'in.Mit iii Fonn 14 ',,,,,,..,■ ill. r.uL au'l 1 uill |«iv IIh' ' ' ' I'l'l''' ' "'"' -'H'"!!"''" inniifv ,l„ll,l■.llatl■l^ iilfc r.Tciviiiu fioti.r i.f alloiiiifiil I, \,.ii lie williin -.hiv.-ulKM _v..ii r-lmll I '.ivi.iiic i.ntilliMl to ,,„„iii l-usiiK'.-^ 1.1 pav nifaci.iiiiiii-^Moii -'I - p '• in .ii-li >>it tlii' ,„.iiiiiial ..iii-'iiiii "I ill" -liiiii- I.nviititii liv iii.'. r w< . .,i,iiiussi..ii is to !..• pa> - .,|,|,. uiiii! till' ' '■> a|i|)lin aii.l ,ill..im.'nl nmnfv.- |ia>alil.' Iiv nii' lia\.' l„,,.|i |>.l. an.l v.m laa.v appl.v llic . ..iniiii-M.m in or t..\vai.l< pav n1 .,|' .-U' ll Mli'fl('\S, ^(,11 all' In Inivi' lln' .iplion of Halisfvin;; lli.' aimainl pixaMc l<> Ml.' 1'^ all.itiinjr I" iiK' lnll.v P'l-iip "'i'"''''* '■" y"""' <'"P''"' '" '"' 'i»">ii''l ,,- ,,i |Mi valui'. ami it v.m clt-.t tn. ] A- iiiitluM (imMin, lam In liavf ilit' i i:;lil. i'\cr(i>.al.l(' a! my liiin> l„.t,.n' ill.' - l' tliP n.1 shares as I . Inmsoj 'i"li:it 11 . liiiisi- as al)i)V(> is valid, sec »i(;ji", p. 284. 7 1 am mil to !"■ lioun.l to hulis.rilic niiii-ss al IfaNt — of tin' s nn.iorwrilUMi jirior In lli<' pulili. ali.iii of tin- pr.rtpo.ttis. ami .ii,\ allotimMU t.. mo miisi lie nia.U- lu'fnrc llic .lay ot - ^ Ms oliiipilinn lii-rcninlor is to hold ^rood mnuiilistamlintr any filiation hctwccii tin' .Irafi pr.p.spc'tiis siil.mitU'.l vt mr. as almv." n I.Tiv.l to. ami tin' pmspivtus as finally M'ttleil an.l piihlishud, pro- V „l.'.| that till- amonnt "f tho .apital of tho . oy. namoly. f - divi.I.'d int.. shares nf 1/. oa.li, is nni altoro.l. '.I Any notico to mo may ho sorvod hv spn.liii^- ili, sumo hv iiusi I'l.lrossod to mo at tho snhjoincd ail on tho day fnlln\vin>jr that on whioh it is posto.l I'.. >.. M-nnd as i.) notify fi m.' your ari^.-pianc' "f this jn-.-iinsal. Da!.' I this - day of . [Si^iiiatttre of I'mliruritir.] A.i.ircs.s. I acknowlod^'o notioo of your acccptanoo oi tho iih- proposal for — shares. \ Siij i-'-t ufc o) I udrniriter. \ ■ W-2 UNUtRWRITING. [Chap. IV. i'l - J' ' • Form 14a. Acceptanc'f of iindfrwritinir J^ji- proposal . To of With icIort'iKP to \cmr underwiitin;; j)io|)0." rccfipt of tlio ilifi|uo for i' iiciii);' the (Icpor^it tlii'roon. Date . ■ ' ■ ' Directors, V. I). ) *I5 L t; I J \m h ■ I I Form 15. Sub-under- writinjr lettor. The — CoMi'wv, I.imitkh. Capital f . (liviilc'l iiili) sliaii>s of i/. catli. I'mpost'd issm uf — »hart'>. To - . of . Sir, L'uderstanding iis I do tliat you have, lor a ronmiissiou to bo paid bv tlio aliovo-naiiiod coy, underwritteu of the above shares, I hi'ivliv propose to Kiib-uuderwrito of the ^^amc .sliarc>^, aud now hand you an ai>i)licon for the «aiiie, tog^-ther with i1km(Up for £ for iiavnioiil of the deiiosit of ])er share payal)U' on the sliaix's siib-uiiderwritton by mo, wIulIi is to lie ai>pliepci tus for closiny: the list of subscribers are to be applied in further relief of my oblifjation to subscribe hereunder, and shall not be (oiisidered subs, ript ions by the public. If I withdraw or do nut hand you Uie above-mentioned applicon. vo!i arc t" be at liliertv in mv name aud on iny Ix'hiilf to sh^n and put FORMS. in an uiiplifoii iu the form referred to in the prospectus as published fur the nuiiiU-r suh-undorwritteii by me or any lews number and take an alloliMciit in respect thof, and I will pay the ap|)ii(:on ai.d allci- mciii money immediately after receiving notire of allotnii-nt. ^lu are. within days after you shall have been paid your uuderwritiiig oonunission by the company, to pay nic a commission of ppr tx?nt. in cash on the nominal amount of the shaii'.s .-iub- iiniit'iwr'ttcn by me, such commission to be paid wlietiier I am ix'i|iiiic<' to ;ii ccpt ail allotment of shares or not, but if an allofmont be nude to me no commission is to l)e payable until the a])plicon and allotment moneys payable by mo have Ikhmi piiid, and you may appiv tlie commission in or towards payment of suili moneys. 1 iim not to bo bound, itc. f>ef Form 14.] Mv (ijilii^'ation hi>n'under, Ac. Si'e Form 14.] Anv notice to me may be serv<'d. i^c. Sift' Form 14.] lie so pood !i-s to notify to me your acceptance of this propo-al. Dated this - day of Siijnature of I'ndfrinitcr.] .Vddress. :iO;} Form 16. I u( kno\vledi;e notice' of \our acceptance of the above proposal for shares. Sifinatiirf of rndcricrifer.] It i> pxticini'iy iiiipurtaiil to sciiirf tioui the underwriter an ai'kiicpwle();fiueiit ill writliii; (if the rei eipt of iiotiee of aeeeptatiee of hU unilerwritin); proposal, f.i otherwise wlieri' the party to whom the letter is adilressed, in exercise of tlie oiihority apparently eonfi'rreil hy thi> h'tter. proposes to Hiijn an iipplieatioii fur -!i:ire-, thi' eoiTi|i;Miy may not iiuproliiilily raise the (luestion v hether Ihe .11,1- iias I II a.eepleil. The i-oiii|iany has no riifht to presuiiie the ;ieee|itaie r "I the offer: anil if the offer leis not. in fa,r Mi,,,-. /'.'.. , lS!t7. I Ch. 57.1. 'I'm; 1) CilMl'WV, I.IMITKl). (About to be registered.) I'lnjiosed issue of lOO.tJOO shares of \l. each. I'll \. H., of - , as tiustee for the above-named coy. • iiuitiiiM • it is found desiralile t4i iniike thi' tinderwrilin;,' eontraits with a tee li>r the proposed eonipaiiy, o that the underwriter may he sreured .!■.' till' r\peii-e of ri'j,'istrulion is incurred. W iili lercience at in Form 14]. Mv sidiscription is to be on the terms of the coy'.s pro^x^^^^"^ ^ iiially settled and issued, and j-ou, &c. [as in Form 14]. Form 16. Underwriting letter to Irustte for ■ ompany aoolit to be fornnHl. I \\^ ;i04 UNDEKWHITING. rCHAP. IV. Form 16. If. i^<'- <(*^ «» Form 14J. All iippliuoiiK^Ao. a.t in Form 14]. If I withdruw or do not liaiul you the abovc-mcntiouud upplicon, vou arc to bo at liberty in my name and on my behalf to sipu, ic. as in Form 14]. The coy is witiiin day.s after it ha.s become entitlcil to com- menc«< business, itc. as in Form I4j. 1 am not, ie. an ill Form 14]. My oblijjation lioix>iintaiKl free from all obliaratioiis hereunder. 'The rc'^t ax in Form 11] Except iis allnwed I)j- sul)-siMt. 1 of srit. SO, conmii.^sions, ilim-ouiits .Vc. out of caiiit^il in rclatiiiii to tin- tiikini,' nf x'nin's ar.- pnihiliiti'd ; hut tlii> M-.tion i- not to aftVrt till' powiT of tlii' ( ip''".^' '" P-'X l'r"li''""aL'c' at thf or.linary i;it. u« lu-rt'toforr. Underwriting Letter. I \. To THE t'0MI'\NV, LlMlTRI). Form 17. l-mlerwritiiiK Proi)o.-ed i.ssuc of l(M),(ii)(( Ordinarv Share.-s of 1/. each; letter when- ,. , , ,, , , , application Payable a.-^ to - on uiiplu on. and a.- to on allotnu-ut, iV( not to Ite ln:i(le till list il(Md. tientleiiien. 1 aii-ree. for the con.snn below elated, to undcrurile sliar<- "l !/. t'acli in llic iilicive-M^imed co\ . iMv .sub.-cripliiiii i.-* to lie on lln' terms of llic coy - profpectii'^ a- linaliy settled and published, and upon the form accompanyinir oi referivd to in smh prospoctu.-. If ujion the ])ublicaliun of the prospectus, the whole of the mI 100,000 shares shall be taken up by the public, then no allolu; .il i- lo bo made to me; but if the whole shall not In- so taken up, then I am to be bound to subscribe for and take up the n^sidm'. The considei-alion for my enlerino: into this a:_'iveml shall I'C \v., &c. Applicons pnieuroil by mo and properly identified an. shall Hilliin liours from siicli iiotii* UMiifr frivoii I apply for thv -;iMii' Mill aro to lio lit liliorty to troat tlii-* lclt*M' its my applicoii Id the .Ninio. aiifl I will )iay tlic allotiiKMit moiioy iiiiiiKMliatoly nftcr icdiviiii: iiotico of iillotniont. Your TOrfitifalf in writinp: tlml I liavr so tailed and a." to tlio minihfv of shai-es I am bound to lake shall bp conclusive. I iiiidcriak<> not to ctlpci aiiv .••ale of shares in the coy, either .liicdly (ir indirectly, until at least fourteen days afun- the fir^-t ._y, lul allotment of fhares has tiikeii place Anv alliitinent pursuant to this afrreemi nmsi be made on or Ix'forc ihi' day of next. Aii\ notice to me may Im- sent tliioufrb the post in the sulijoiiicd aHilic^^s. and shall Ik» deemed to Ih' served on the clay following tlui on \vliitaiic<' of this propos.il. 1 lilted the day of . [Si())uitlir<' 1111(1 Aihhcf: of rinh'ririilir I ;irkno«ledly with sin h recjuest within \1\ liniiis atlei- the makiiiy; tbol you ma\ sij;n the sd poojiuf;' ayroeinl oil iiiv behalf. ■ onii.i (i. I , a ndS. TUK Com f ANY. Llmited. Form le Is-iic lit' 10.0(10 Piefereiice Shai<'s of l(t^ each, at a prpmium of 2/. Tmlprwritii. . per share, payable as follows: - sttite huir]. ...mtrw-t with » * • -i tho ctunpnity Conditio)!" of Liulcnnitiiiij. I The above shares are to bo olfered in tho first in.stanco to the AVhen.wau- I . I 111 ... , t ..It niiMiuii tmui oKliiiaiy shareholders iii the above coy in accordance with the arts ,,„t „! prv.fci- of ;i>.»on, and those (if uiiy) not taken up by them are to Vn' ollered till' [iiiblic sulisciip(i(in by a prospi-ctiis approved by the coy's brokers. Messrs. — -, and on the fooliiij;: that the issue price, 12/. [wr share. is 111 U' jhI up as above. - If any sudi prospectus is published, an underwriter. Ix'foro •'t 11 1 lock ou the day on which the list of subscriptions is opene, is to a > ••> o i ";S;ru. bv .„m,i„«-s .1 ... „„,l™.ri,e,. it „„„.nri ..v .„„,, ,„. "fljttlirSliu U,»,o.,.h..U,-M „,. .0. ;. .« b, M libonv !« no„,„»t. ..,. p.™.. !•> "»" ""'' I"" '" ot p t ■ o'l "»• •' , ,„j(,L.es of iillotniout ar.' :::r^:::-:.n; •::';.:";::;« 1..-.-... 7 \nv allot.u.M.I. fVw 13, t/«u.sr 8. 8. Auy nolUo. F«»>h 13. c/.iH.fc i» I , hbv 11';:;;;:" - z'j^, ... »b„v. .-« » ..m,, .. oniliodieil in tliis upplu'on. Bo so ^rood as to notify to mo vo-.ir a.copta..,^ herool Sifrnnturc. iMe. dc. as above.] I Form 19. t«i procure MiidMwritiiig liir > lump ,V.,KF.KMKNT TO I'KOrrKK UnDKRWKITKRS. AN AC.RKKMT nu.do tl.c day of between The — Co^v, I imtd of - . l.nftr called ■ the Coy "), "' the one par and A. B o"— hnftr .alled -Mr, H •.. of the o.hor part: ^^ ";-- ^^J anital o the .ov is 120,000/., dividcl into 120.000 shares of U. e.^ h^ As wm-R 's .1.0 eoy is about to oiler 80,000 of the sd shares lor rComp'anies: Am. ^v.■KKK.s Mr. B. has offered to pi-ooun, the i.latinp of -lOOOO of tlio shares so t : l« offered. Vow TIIIHKKOHK IT IS AGREED aS foUoWS: — T' , 1 "Ll. procure 40.000 of the shares so to be offer«l a« afed ,0 be under. rlHen by responsible underwriters withxn — days from Ihe duic lir.f. FORH8. ;«»7 2. Till' iniili'iwiilinK sliall l)e otl'ected In iii(>|M>i(ii)iitniit.- in wiitintj Form 19. sidiii'il liv ilio M'-tiM!! tivi' iiiiderwriters, ami t'rtiiiii'd in ilic loiiiis of the iimlt'iwriliiijj: l<'lt<'i' iinnoxftl lito, save timl if Mr. U. .-Iiiill iiiiiisolf uiiiliiwiilt' ))l iii>l i'.\ -ocdiii)^ shares 1 of tlic mI Aw llii idcr- wnliii' li'ttt'i- >i in (il i>ii\ iiieiit of the >iiiu (II l."i,(100/. l)oli)\v menld. ;i. The iiiideiwiiliii} lettoi dul\ 'd as afsd. nni>.l he delivered tip till >\ wilhiii davs from the dale Imf. aiid it shall I<'>| with I lie as I V on siiih deli\erv lo il<'ilaie whether it i< or is nni salislied aiiv nf the iiiiderwrilers, and if it so derlari's. Mi. I! slinll forth«itli siihsiilule nther responsible iinderwrilers a|iiiinMd In the fiiy. 4. On deiiveiv to the iin of the imderwritin;;- lellei.s afsti, the eoy is tu l«' endtled to (he full benelit thof, and to exenisi' ail ilie iio;his Ihbv iiinferred on .Mr. H.. and Mr. 15. .sjiiill be bound lo pay the roiiinnssidii jiavable under such uiiderHritin}^- h-llers, and l.ie coy fliall be at liU'itv, out of the sum of t' below menld. eiiher to iiav siidi roiuinission on his U'lialf or lo ri-lain the ie(|uisile auiouul imtil lie shall have satisKed the coy that he lias )id the iindornritinii; conunission. .'i. In ciiiisoii of the ]iremises the coy sliall. within da\s after it ln'comes (Militled to coiumence business, pay In the simi of £ - , willi full power for them to .satisfy £ part of ihe sd sum liv the allotment of .'J.OOO fully pd-up shares m Ihe coy. As wnvKss, iVe. •SciIEUl'LE. TirK (.'OMPANV. LlMITKIl. Issue of .{.."lOO.OUOZ. d p.e. First Mortj4;a},'e Delwiiture- For till' I'lH'pose of consolidatinjj and eonvertinjx the outstan.iiiig; llrst and second ')\ p.c. niortj^age delioiitnros of the co\ , Tin: new debentures will be redeemable at ln;{ p.c. in 20 years, by annual drawings, the first redemption to take plaif on 1st daniiary, 189(i. The coy will reserve power to pay oil any debentures at any time after tlie of — - at lO.j p.c. on giving si.v calendar mouths' notice. The new deiientures will l)e secured by a trust deed in the terms of till' diafi already pit-pared by the loy's solors. Tile lidhleis of the present debentures will be };;iveu the option of convertinjf their debentures into debentures of the now issue, the option 111 lie e.\ercis«d within 14 days from the first publication of the [!l..i-[i,.: !ll^: iif (|.,.-. new is-(ip, \ '1 Form 20. Uiiderwritinj,' of a tlcbeatiire Illli 308 UKDVUIWKITINO. [Chap. IV. form 20. :\H i«l Ak ruiidilhii^ of i'ndeniriliii;) llie iiboir l)ebviiiiii,->. 1. All uiidciwiilt't is (.11 tlip (lay of tlio jiuhli. ution "f the |)iu>|«-c tut. lolatiii};- to Iho iil>uv»' issuo to (Iclivor to Messrs. N M. ». & S,,,,-. at — "comt. Laiio. Londoii, an iippliton in \vritiii'" rofoiiod to in siuli prusiwctus, and diilv sifTiifd l.v sill li iiiidciwiitiT, for tlic HUiomil of tlio dobciitiiii's imdci- wriltiMi i.\ liiin: Iml. lofrard U'md l.v tin' d<'|.osit uiciitd in tlii' pro- spOOtlls. 2. Till' «-..v is lo li.' dci'iiiod to iindoiwrilo i. oi tin- di'lii ii.-. 3. Tin- pnl.lic sul.s. liptious for the di>l.<'iiliiii- arc to -o as to llip list X. - in iidifl of llio covs iiiiderwriliii"^ appliiatioii ul'sd, and as t*, thf siu|.liis in reliof of tlio uiulorwritfrs. otlior than the cov, iu proportion to the anii.iiuts inulerwritten hy tlioiu ix-.sply; and aa<.rdiu. Where anv underwriter fails lo pin in his applicon on the ,lav af.-d. the . ov i- to he at liberty to aiitliori/e any pers<.i, t.. siyrii an.l pill in Mi.h appli... I his behalf, ami such authority shall <;■ ullecti\e All appli must be made before the day of , oilierwise the iiiiderwriUT shall be reliev.-d altojretlior. If at auy time between the si-nm- of thi» applicon and the publication of the prospectus, owinji to ^ravo political or flnancial disturbances, the price of Bri.isb 2^ pc ( ousuls fall to or below ~. the underwriters are also lo bo relieved ot ll.cii oblisration K The cov within - days after the closinv;- of the subscription li«t.s is lo pav U< each underwriter a eonuniMsioa at the rate of p.c. on the .imouiit of the debenture* underwritten by him pursuant to these conditions. iiMt. FORMS. ao» ;i Aii\ iKitico I" ail im.li'iwriU'i' iiiav lji> "jiveii \>\ M-rnliiiy: tlio came tliKiuyli llif 1>"«1 in " l«-'"«-'' aildicsMMl Ki liini ill llie uWdifss ntato,\ . l.iiuKi. Cclllll'IIK'U. Huviufr imI K) viiiii' l)ankor.s. Messrs, X. M. R. A Sons. ( oiirt, - Lane, Luininn. ii --■ bcin^ a depiwit of .'> p.''. mi f ilobou- liin'.v ul' llie alxivo issuo, I lihy roniiosi you to ndinil iiic a.» an iindor- HiiU'i (it'tJiai aiuoiiiit elus oileiiii)i: tlieabove-meutioiied .lelientnres for public sul.sciiplioii. I will apply in the form n'ferred to ill such prospectus for i. of the wi debeiitiires. and will pay ill. re.in llie amount payable on aiiplicon, and w ill airepi the allotment • >i iin.l pay the alloliiieiil iiioiieyM and subHeciuont sums which beeotne |iu\alilc in respect of any debentures allotted to me in response to .-mil a|iplicoii. ll is uudeislood that lo Ihe e.vtcnt to wliiili applicoiis are received fiiiiii the imblic before the clo.sinp- of the subscription list. I, and all .11 lie- iiii.lcrwrilerM. are t^> be relieve np any of tho dobontures lihy undorwrittou. AppliconN rojoi lod by the (lirectom, and Bpiili<-oi:s witlulrawn Jiefore allotment, arc not to bo consi.Icred applicons from the public within the torojroinn words. If I do not put in such appliron ut the time afsd you are to ho at liberty in my name and on my Iwhalf to put in such applicon. and I will pay the appli. on and allotment, money immediately after mciv- inp notice of alloinient. In r under my hiiiitl served on you and accompanied by the p-.r value of the shares calM for. and you are to allot the shares so calletl for to mo or to my noiniueeMi.s I may direrty to draw a bill on me tor the amount, payable to you or order at the o.xpiration of .seven days from the date thof, and to authori/.e any per.son to accept such bill in mv name and on rnv behalf and such acceptance shall be valid, and payment of suoh bill shall operate in satisfaction of the amount in default. Ab to this clause, see n'pra, p. 29S. It I oflect any sales of debentures of the coy within fourteen iia,\s after the first •n'neral allotment I am to forfeit my right to .all as afsd, and my right to call as afsd sliall also be forfeited if I fail to pay the opplicon or allotment mo-ieys in respect of the to the above. For the coy. A. B. i (• I) ♦ Director.- F'dRMS. Call oi Shares. Tl,.. oon...,. tor umlovwritintr i> not unrou.monlv tho pivinp to tho u„,lorwritor the rail of sharo^ in tho coy oxoivisoable at any tiinr wi.hin a sporilicd Frio,l. an.l either at par or at a p.^nuum an,l of,..u it i« arrang,'.! thu. this rijrht of cm^ hvof, is entitled ou or atany tun.' l.cfoi'e the 1st dav of June. 1912, to call for an allotment ot - ,i,aies of 1/. each in the - Company, Limited, on payment in cosh ..f 1/ 10s. per share, bein- the full amount of tho share nlus ji premium of !(•,». iK'r share, au.l the following: eonditio., shall iipply: — . i 1 \nv cull hereunder nuiv be made for tho whole or part of the sd 8hare.s. Everv onll must be in writin- (in the indor.s<-.l fonn) under the hand of the registered holder for the tune bein- hwf, and must spe are to be allotleates liehl by the'iii i-osiiectively. and the registered holder may inspect such regisWT. r,\i Tho registeriHl holder shall be regurdod as e >;lusively entitled to tho benefit of this c«rtificate, and a.i persons may ad accordingly, and this certificate shall bo transferable. fr(><- from nnv 0(|uities, cross or other claim. I t > Every transfer of this certificate must be in writing under the hand of the registered liobler, and the traasfer must bo delivered at tho re it'taiti tilt' traiu>tVr. (5; II' uriii ho fur ai tli»> liislit c.l .all liliv jjivcii >liall ii'M !,.• cx.'rciMMl lu'lon- tl (iiiiriifiicfiiu'iit i>l' a wimliii^f-ii|i nl ilic ctn , it ^llall lajiM'. I tit Ain iioliio iim.v In' ^•^•l\^•ll l..\ llic 'ns mi llu' IidIiIcc I'or ihf liriii' liciiij:- ol this c'liilicaU' l.> M-mliii;; il llinmuli the jxi.^l in a incpaid lottoi aildroM'il lo hikIi |mms()Ii at iii> i('^'i«l<'ii>iialinn «i 2i liniirs at'lcr il i-* pn-ipd. r t'- . Iiciu;.' \l. lOv. pi-r Klmro in rrspt-. t of .t the allotnit-nt .>f the sd sliaros lo of - and I ro.pit'st you to issnc to ni»' a lialanie option (ortiti. at.- f.ir .sharps]. Dated this - .lay of Sii/naliDf III Kcfiixirred llnlihr.] Form 22. Underwritintc •'Ituses in msmoruidum ■>f aasociatinii . Tlie sidiMiihers of the foun.lers" s|iar.."< shall torthwitli pay t-i llie cov the fall ii.>niiiial amount .if the foiiinU'rs' shares subs. rili(-il inv .Uusesin '>y "'i'"> resply. and shall, in prop.irtion to tho foundors" s|n;ri.^ msmoruidum suliscrihed f.>r liv ihein resply, pay all the preliminary expenses .if forniini,'- an.l tloaliii taken np within f.)urleen .lays after the jiuhli- .atinn of the i'.jvs pros])<'ctus. ami a.cordintrly they shall lie Imund. in proporti.in to the founders" shaifs snlisciihed for liy them resply. to accojit an allotment .if su.h of ill.' s.l lOO.tlOO ordinary shares as shall not lie taken up within the s.l peri. id, liut so (hat no snih .siihscrilier shall Ik> hound t.i a.iepi an ;illotmont of more than ."lOll .)f the sd li>(t,()()0 shares in i-esjK!.t .if ea.h foun.lers' shaie sulis. rilied for hy him. and that any shares taken u|) liy him liefoi* the expira- tion of -\]ih jicrii'd shall lie treated :'.s in reduction pro tniilo "f his obligation to accept an all.itnient as afsd. Thu undcrwritintf u«h1 Mim.'tinu's t.i b.> ctt'oitcd liy mukintr p;irt (if th.- iiiitiiil cujiital n nerics of fuundurs' shuns, .say 2110 of 1/. .'wh, and conferrinjr on tin' holders spwial rights and privilegi's, uiid imposing on the subseriben under- wriliiii; " a|>|ily " tin- ruiimliTu' -hari't in pay- niihl uf a riatiiin with liin own hand: hr ran ■.(ili^rihi' hy tin' liainl of an aK-i'iit i''i'v iithorizi'il, ami tin- aiithiirity ran \iv lunfi'mii ritliir orally or liy in«trunii'nt in writini;; hnt thn lattrr i» to he pri'ferr«l. ax if the authority ii oral tliere may he a iliipnte ai to whether it wa-. in fait, iriven. The authority mav run ai foUowH- T" Mr. .Ill I. till- miil»'r-iH;m'il. Iili\ aiilliniizo iiiul r(M|iic-l viiii in my ii.imi' ami nil my liC'liiiil' til sulisci'ilx! the iiionioianiliiiu ami a. if ,i'«-*i)ii i>l' the - Cdv, Liiulil. now alniiil to lio ivg:i>t<'H»il, tor td lln' tiniinlcrs' shai'ivs ill tiio i'U|>ilul of such loiiipiiiiy. or such l('sM>r iiuiiiln'r a'> von iiiiiv ariaii^.a' on tlio toriir* of ■'iieli nioinorumiiiin anil .irt'-. \\ here a suhii ri|ition i« inade pur»nant to an uutliority ai aforesaid, the >uh- « riher '•lioiild -uliserihe the naiiie of Ilia priiiiipal lluH ' \. II., of — , jiistiie of the peaie. or ai tl aw may lie, hy •'. I>.. of . hi< duly aiithori/i il aifent in tiii-i hehalf." ai.'i Form 22. Form 23. Authority to >.ul)»«ribe. .VN .\(iUKKMT iiiailp, Ai'.. Im'|\v<'«ii A mi lu-lialf of liio '^i.eral jit'i'Miiis iiaiiioil in tlio .si-licdiili' iito i iir.'ti' tallod " the uniicrwritors "} of till' Olio |it, anil H. as livo for tlic Cos , l.iiald • now about to U' iiii'oi'iioraU'tl and liiiftr rotVrrod to a> ' rlic now roy"). of tlio otlioi- ])t, wlieioliy it is ui^n'od as follow.s: - I . Karli of (ho niidtM'writors ^liali uinU'rwrile llio iininlior of sJiures iu llio now I'oy sot opposito lii~ iiaiiio in tlio sehodiilo lilo, and shall an ui'dingiy liaud to tlio sd H. as sinli trw as afsd an niidorv rilin}^ loiter framed in the loriiis of the iinderwritinf": loltor annoxod hto with thu lilanks (horoiii lilled up for sinli juiiiibor of shares. 'i. The sd B. shall iniinediately on lh<^ iiuoriioralioii of the now i ly hand suih unilorwritiiif; letter to tlio now roy and use his iMjst endeavours to obtain the acet'pfaiu'o by the now coy of llio oll'or tluMviii coiitainoil. and shall notify such aii'Cptanco to the iiiidor- •.vii(i>r .\ eoinpaiiy can on iniorixiratlon acei'pt an offer addre.-M'd lo it though -liifniKi hefiire it wa'* iniorporated. and in the n-olt a contraet will ari'ic. thoii^jh pm- vifiiuimi. until tlie roinpaiiy i-* entitled to i-omnieiiee hu-^iner^i. Sect. 87 (.'!). Supra, p. '2iS. Form 24. .VKreement for under- writing shares: A. for undcr- writcni, and B. for proiHiHi'd eoiiipHiiy. 314 iJNf^niwurn: Chap. IV. F«nB24 .•i The miilt'twiilih.' lotlcis -.mil n<< ''■ i< .okMl l.v tin- iiii.lpr- rtuieis, liiiil in iIk' event of miv rcvi»nii. i tli.' -it f! ■■Iiiill \x^ nl lilM-ilv ill tl«- niiiiif an\- pi(".M'i| 1(1 ho ii'vokctl. I. Tlic mI H. ^luill ii-**! Iiis tit'st emh'avourn Hi jun. un- the loniiaii i ..)■ I 111- new i(n within - wwks from the iliiti- hof. ami iiiilo'^x il i BO foriiuMJ within (lays from tlio ilatf hof u.rl ai<«|)ts the iimlei- wriliii^ jptteri iifwl this ujrreiiiit shall beioini' v'iil ."i Aii\ until »■ may 1* served on uiiy of the iniilei wri'^'i- '>y .semlu - the -ume lhr<>U|i.'h the post aJiires.s! innlfi in lllii'i Irltii iiiiil ollirr i/o, miirnts. II till .AM Form 25. \\ At-iKKKMT made the — da^Mf !..meeii the l.iiiild .linttr called the Coy " i of the one pt. .iiid A 15 ol allot imid-iip tree lor the several iK^rsoiis iinlued in the >. Iii-.|nle hln ol !: Hharmiu ,„„., \\ hkkkas the lov reetMith issued a prospeitiis olferii mtinactK'n "f ■ . . . ,. , cninmii*i>inii. (jiv. a'- ' other •iO.dti" sndi I iheii '(>d to ■ ! i .'1 pi \l. -Iiaie> in its capital for piil lie ~iihscriplioii at par, (irospei Ills slated that the my would pa\ to allottees in cnn^. snhscrihinjr a coiuinisHion of lOx in reH|iect of each share ai them, and i-e.s'Mved the ri^dit to .s.i v this cond column ot the sd sdiclule Am> \viiKiii-;\ • ■■ eoy ,.xercis«> (if the ri iium!-i' of fully pd up shares in the capital ot the coy > I'l 1 For"* 25 Sunn- .ml Ai. Irt^-M » of AUi.'Ui?- Ni. ii*r:..f till- .N.iii th.' simrprt III •JO, rcH i«utiHfll«'lit'II Itf ill-' •lint '•)<< nil. l■cllllllli^«il■M to 1»' allotti.! !.' lU.li. ■, V 5 Ki \! r IU;i.l. „r - 'ii- 111' liul Ii . Illll llUsi WliKli - 'I ' uiii' !i ilii cii .iri|iiii iii'^ Ii- •ii.s« M"n r'u f IrOlW.-, ; \ , .mil II , ImiIIi I, Pis, ilir ..uc pait .Hill < ■ UTiil 1> . lonli I "I "f ill'' iilliiT [t.irl. iv. !' 'I i-iillt'il '111' toy, i.-^ ill'- mii'il 1 « i H'- olijoi I 1 /'///('(■ •ilid ' li\ ill-' \i'iiil"i'f .it .il»il : Ax:. AIIKHIV II i." illlCn.kxi |lll».|ii iv-lll- nf 1(10. I 1' . >|fl.i nii.ro .slock of llu' m iIm' !• tiii> ol' tin" piikspi'i ln-i, |.ioot' 1 iiil ol whitii i.- iiiiiK '<: ami li' il "it'fi "t"' '> '•■' '" ^"' DUstilii ml .s.'riHi'il l.v a 111^ li'ivl in (li.- Icriii> ol' ili(> lii.it'l ,\lni)i 111. .Illy iH't'ii iirojiiiioii l.\ Mv . ^'.lo|•. uml -i^rm'il Ir liiiM iq.n, Mt>«-, [)!■ .mil Kdiiir till' Milisi'i i|'' ion of thi' stm U afsil ii|ioit llir Mi !iil (oixlitioii.-. liiifir ii|ipt',i.iiiL; Now ii is itl i.rm \'.!!i i n - ' v.s. that is to Niy; I' cimliactiirs will on oi Im'Tom' tli. ila\ o' . I!' • "i ■ ill- (lay a.s ^llall Ixt agivi'il lu'twccu tlio paili 's In- is.sm .i ■ tus ill llii- terms of the pio--pri uis allin licil lito h >ii ' ioii.s of ami iiioililii alloiis in liu' iltnails ih a- llni" ..{ il 11. loi.s niav aiipiovo. ami will iaii>o tho sat,|i' In lie t>tlii u'uin ai. ; th- .ughlv ailvorlisod lu acionlancc as i arly as may 1 with ' aiivcrtisomeni, lisit anm'xod hto. The ion rai'lois x, ill al- — ue .ml ,irr:;!ate thryufrtl tlu' post at 'If !.-:in! :ot:i!'- ■: • SI P'O^p'" ti|- addresscd to tli*' persuii.s uaiiietl in llii' li-sts alivin ippi'vi"! I'y tin" parties hto. 2 Tho voimIoi-s willciiK-r into an .iirl-cenn « iili llm "■o> on tlio lii in- of iht' limit lotVi-i'il to in ilaii.se .'! of the con s arts of a-sun Form ilfli Form 26. UNDEKWKiriNU. [(,'HAI>. IV. riio ximkIhik will iirui UK N .)l IIIkI M. Ill' III aii.'('|ii iHifo a.■^ lii'i" I'illicr III liiitli till r ami mi ik'Ii liall III' till' ilflii'iiliiit' Mixkliolilcis. 1 1 'I. Ill' llif i.-~iii- il N .1 till' -il |i M liall ii'liix' III aiTi'l it iillii' ililr |Mi-iiii> III a'/ni' 111 ai |il~|l('l \ll-^. llll" V4'lllllirN will |I|1I1I1IC Olllll Im'iiIiiii' >Iiii k- I a^ iii'c^ llll llll' ill Ii.i|i|.'i> I. TIm- \ciiiliir> will. I licliiic llic ilav piiiii' m 'In- ilav u|iiin whi. Il iIh" jiri»iici !us i^ iiiulci- ilic airnHMiil In In- isMicil, laiiso iIh> ,ii\ to Ik- iliilv roifi.sK'ii'ii in urnndaiKc nilli llii- (ii* i ( 'nri^iiliilalinii i Ari, IIMIS. ami I'll 111' U'loio the .niiiic ilalc lU'livcr Id iIh' rniiliactiir.s a liiinn-d (lu|iliraic nl ilii' rupv jiiiisiiiMtii.- ii'i|iiin'il In Im- tilcil liy tin' All. iliilv .-'i^riifii ami ill all iillicr ilii'riiis ilit> wIidIc iiI' iIu' Hm.lMlO/. (IcIkmiIihv ulurk al.sil .-liall lit' Mili.si ril.iMl I'oi li.v rcs|iiiii-ilili' |ii'r-*iiii<. ami llii' a|ililirrii, ii.iim'\> |ii| llicn'iiii. ami llial all a|>|iliriiii ami aliiiliiiiMil iiiuiiov.-i am! iii.slaliiu'iil> iiayalilc in r.'^|i.'i I dl -n. Ii aiipliiims liii' ilic sd (U'lionliiii' >t(i. k as loiitrurlois, ami liit's<' |ii('sciiis shall Iw a -iillii iciil aiiilimilv I'm thai purpose 7. ir within "lays lioiu llic date liof the whole of tliu sd dclicntiii-c stoi k shall have I ii sulisciilicd by rcspmisihlu poisnu^. ami llic ainoiinl.s jiayalilc mi applirmi and allotiiicni for such shall have liccn duly pd. the \ciidors shall pay tu the coiitrihiilors the sum ,,l : hut this payiiH'iil is inndilioiial on the iiiuliaiUns |>crl'oiin- iiii;' all the nliliiz-atinns lilix imposed on tliciii in rmiforiniiy with the Iciins hereof. S The I ontraitiiis will prniiirc a hroker or (inn of hrokors in Loiidmi. Iioin^; nieinliers of the London Sloik Kxchaiifrc to net. as brokers to the coy. and will pa\ and diseharp' their foes and ull other brokcrujri' i'li's ami rmiiiiiis-.iiiiis iminrcd by the rontrarmrs in roiiiieitimi with the sub jei l-iiiattcr of this airreciiit. The vendors declare that ilicy beliexe. and have reasoinible ^rrouiids for believing, that all the stutenieuts eoiitaincd in the »d pros|M'cUis are true in ■'3 1 FDIfMS. 317 >illp'tiiiiir iilli I ill fiicl. and lliiit tin' ^aiiif (c>iitaiii> ii" iiii>-.>la(i'iiii'i I, Fonn ii>n|'H-i'ntatniii. <'i' ■.ii|i|ircs-i(iii o I a iiii.-— taU'iiiciil 111 riii-i|i'|irfMMilaliiiii I' fail hImiIi iiwn ill law aiiiiuiilt AN a(;wi:i:mt ma.ic tin ll 111 — . llt'l«(l('ll till' Form 27. ( 'iiiii|iaii\ . I'lM ilil iliiirii- lallcd •till' niiiiiiaiix ' 1, nT llu- one pail, AjfrwimMit tu i.| iiiillr lallfil Mr. N.. nl llif ullii'i |iail iiKiii \> Ilif I" \ i.» aliuiil III ollci 111. jiiililii Mili~i ii|)liiiii I underwrite dobentii Htork . I II r. iiiuil^iasio (U'Ik'iiIiiic stiiik wliirli is m Ikm oiisliliilcil aii(l.><'i iiri'il li\ an iiiili'iiliiif I'liiiiicil ill ariiiiilaiiif willi llir kmiii- si"- of idi'iitiliia- ;iiiii .siili,«iiilit'il hy I)., a .Sdlni- of tin" Su|iiciuo Court: .\\ii wilKKKVs iliii i(i\ i.- iloiiiiiiN of iii-iiriii^- llu- phuiiij; of tin" wl dcliiMiliin' slink: Now imiiMiiiiK it is ai'ii'i'il as fiillnws: lir siili-ci iiilinii till' sil t iIi'Ik'HIih)' I TIlC rll\ is III nlll'l llll |l stDlk. J .Sill h nllfi is III he iiiadi' liv a |iiiis|ic(lii.s fiaiiii'il in an mdaiii-*' uilli till' Iciiiis ..f llir diafi iiiiis|iciii|s aiilii'vcil liln. lull "illi fall |iii«<'i- till- llll' io\, prior to llic |iuliliraliiiii of .siuli prospi'riii>. to uiiHlifx till' ^alll<> ill siK ll iiiaiiiH'i as lli<> iii\ shall think til. |iio\id('v the sd l> :l Ml N shall lakr up and pav for at par tin' wlioh' of llic di'hriiliiii' slock afsd which .shall not liaM" 1" 11 laki'ii lip am illi'il I- |nrs williin H'li da\s afli-r llii' liisi piililiialioii of tho sd iliis. and llial in runsidcialioii of ihr olilii^alion so iiiipiis«il on . or to p r o| llic pri'iiiiiiiiis on to ollll pin>pi liiiii III' shall III' I'litilloil l< ihi' si t slo( k wliidi shall lir ivrci\i'd lix tin' i o> upon ihi' is-iic .if lli.il pniiioii wliii ll shall lie .iilisiiilicd for and allolli'd In pi'i^oii^ nllii'i liiaii till' .sd Mr N I Mr N. shall pav up tin' full nomiiial xalno of ili<> di'lii'iiluri' shirk l.lkl'll nil llN I mil a~ a fsd iiv ll 11' iiisialiiii'iil^ .Mill al Mil' Unit's spi'i ilii'd in ihr prospi'iliis af-d. I '>s. howt vcr. till* amoiitil of Ihr in'iiiiiini ,111'ordiny to lln' In iiis of ihr prospoi lus as i.s>ii<'d pay.ilili' in ii'spi'il ihcri'of .1 ll shall ii'~i with Mr N to li\ ihr pri'iiiiiini mi wliiili llic sd ili'liriilnii' si H k shall In' ollcicd for -iilisi i iplioii liv ilii'^d pio^pcitus, and if III' shall mil williin I w.'iii v -four hours .ifii'r iiotiic in wiiliuo- ti'iMi llir ro\ rw mv to li.\ llui piciiiiuiii. ll If al aiiv liiiit' lii'twi'cn llic dah' licroof and tlio puMicutioii of till' ptiicpt'liiis owiiii; to tiiavc poiiiiial or liiiain iai disiurliaii<'i>s thi; prirc of l!j pi. Hi il isli (on-o|s shall fall In or lii'low Km/ . Mr. X. is lo III' al lilicrU liv uoIii.t' in wrilini; in llic i o\ to rc-iiiid l.liis atruH'iill. :i ;{|8 Form 27. UNUKK\VKITIN(i. [Chap. IV. 7. Aiiv i...iici' tu Mr. .\". umy Im> given li.v .>oiidiug (he same tlirou^fh the post adih-OK-siMl In him at hin at)OVO-iiion(mi pii\alil<> on ajipliion. MradillK' llif tlriift pni. •ipirtuR for imil.Twritiiivr |>iiri>o(ici>. In iiidcr to iilitalii iimliTW ritiiiij MilHi>ri|i»i(iii^ it i- L'riH nlly fiiiiii(l i.fii><f tin- iiropuaiil |irpi-(l|.- mi tiic iiiii's iif tlir sul.j.iiii.'d: Form 29 Hradinu' f-.r drift i" -i"''"-- 'riic .-ulij. lined diafl |iro>p«'i In- iinlicalc- the gimcial Lines on wliii h Il is propiweil to frame the pro-peiius of the undcr-menid coy, ami -late.s what is anticipated will he the fail.- at the time of its issue, liiil I 111' li'rins v( the pro,»pe. In- cannot, id i.aii-c, !«■ linally isettled iiulil illi'i the rep:i«traiion of the coy, and until after tlio terms of the coii- . .'.— ion have Ih'cii olilained from the liovernmenl, and the terni- ih.if liiiallv aiTan;:ed. and until afler Ihe varioii.s conliacts with or in ri'lalion to the coy liaM' liccii made, and, ;.r,.rierally, the iii'o.sjx'ctus will liaM' to lie framed «o as to aiiord with llie aclnul fads at the time il is lili'd. and to i |ily with the n'.piitemciil- as to diwlosure of mtI hi of the Companies (Cunsolidationl Act, lao8. .1' KOKMS. HI!) Tlio lnllii»iii(r i- ancitliiT iXiini|iU': — Tli.w" ,l<'l»'iiluii.- xvill K' oiVciod to tlio (niblir lor Mili.vii|>lioii 1)\ ii l„.v.|H.tliis linltr .iillr-l iJm linal i)rorl..l uill bo isciiod in tin- (oufho .it ii fow niontlis. SikIi i>rosi>o(liif will 1)«' fraiiMMl on Aw frcnpial lin.'> oi iliis |,i..- MMvtii.s lint with fiucli nuxlifications a> nuiv socni .•x|Milin upplicon b.v the un.l.'ivMil.Ts -hall he ii>..(l for iIk' iiuiposc of provi.lin;.' the c|.<|.o-.if..< which arc to I..- pio- vi.hnl and l«l for the ..oncossion ami siiloidios to be ^;rant liavin^' bwn actually srrantod. Applicon.s for iklniissiou as undor- HriK'i's of the i~.»ue uni. , be made on the awonipau} injj: form, and ;,m.st •■n.liw the Miir of £ j.er dolHMituro bv wav of deposit in iispeot of each in(r the deposits which have to be jmI a- ,1,,. roniliti f the yrant of the conce.ssion and of obtaininy- the Mib-idics, and when the ronces.-ion and -^ub>idiiN ha\e been obtained tlic delHMituiH's will forthwith be oltereil to the public bv the linal prospectus as above indicated, and thereupon the coy will repay to the iii.hrwriters the deposits )mI by them resply except where an allot- ment is made in resjH<«. Bt:K)HK (ommonciii),' iM.siiio.s- a i oiu|miiv in most ras<'s enters into oi ralilios or adopts a pn>lin.iimrv .oiitrail for llio punliaso of somo siHMitlc proi)orty. e.q.. a iuim>. |i;.i.'iil. l.iiMm-ss. .oiicossion, or .'staHv Sovoral of tlw> following form.- of airi-ocMMMil-^ arc prccvlonts for «ii.li coiilrints. Ill franiiiijr su.li prolimiiiarv condait.- lli«> f()llo\viiiv niii-l Iw' borno in minn: I A ifmipany cannot l)t>foit' il i- iiirorpoiaK'rl oiilor into a coii- irait. for it is noii-«'xi«teiit •2 II i- not pox-ihh- hv any inoaii-. oxivpl an Act of Purlianicni . to liriii'f intoovi-H'iin' iindor tin- Conipanio'* i Tonsolidalion > Act. I'.t incorpoiaiioii \i\ some in'rson professing to act on its liclialf jirovided that lh«> lonliiul is one williin tlio jKiwcrs of the company, and in sucli ca.so after ralilication the company is bound a- fully and lomplctely as if il had orisriiiali\ aiitliori/iMl sim li |)erson to onlor into such contnyl on ils iK'half. For thai is tho (Tonoral rule in rejrard to ratification. ' VViienever. " said Lord Wensh'vdale. in Hitlgirai/ v. Wharloii. ti II. L. t". '2'Mi. 'tt man (Hirporls to mako a contract with the accent of aiiolher, in order to bind that o'!:. •• llie ajn-nl must have authority frniii him It matters not whether il is authority previous or miIi- M'lpienl If a man. professiinr to act for another, makes a contract for liiiii. anil aiithority is afterwards jriven by that other, the authority ijiven sul(se(|iiently is ecpial to the authority jriven l>efore. accordin A 111111111*1 i^ 111. Hill''-. II 1' " .1 lillllllMlllllI I' ilv a|iiilii;il'l'' "Ik'Ii' ■•' ''"' "" ,1,. tlii'iv i- ill i'\i-l<'iii.- .1 iiimii |Kil laiKil'li' III iili- lirn- ;iii .i;:H'<'lii<'iit 1* Mm |i' with a I ll'l'^illl >vli' ll|iulll til .uiiliari a^ uiifiil l"i- ail iiikmh li'il (• i>aii\. III'" '■iiiiil>aii\ llll.ll »llll«<'i|tllMll Iv n'u:i .li'ii'il laiiii'it < lliTHiall\ "ii!i I! J t . I' 171; /•; 11,1 ill) . .\,iliil l.iiiiil "iiil r,,l,,iii.siil \ (• IJii; .V \i-i|iMin'; II' iM .. I uiif 111 M H . ^aiil: Til - IIimI a^i'iil liif iIk' '• 1'"'^ iiiii)iaiiv. I'll lilt' "imi'i"'.^ l.iii.iiii'.j '111 'Ik- r'im|i.tii\ itiliiiitimi. lii'iaiiM' it ll.l~ I'I'CII nu'. \M 11 ,U- iilril. iliat llifiv laiiiiiii II ,f a riiiiliail » liii h iliulll lliit ,|i.,iiU-.l. ami. a-< H apiicai- l" I law t»> an i-lli'iliial laliliralimi 111 (111' lalilM'i- lia\i' lif"'" mail"' liiii.lni il llii' liiiii' 11 "a- nil |i.. lii'iaii- ;ln' lalilii'i- "a- ii' tl Ill r\i-l- I \\ lii-ii' an ayi'i'i'ii'"' '' '' iiriiiiili* til "iiitia'l a- Illlll I lie nil 1)V its I 1..I -al.' 1 liii^ti'i' lor an in' .Ir Willi a iiri^iiii "Il IV ta. I I lial ll 11' jial \ allfi 1'- Jii' 1" i,li' I Killljial .1 iiiinliiin a liiiTtiir^. I'll -1" I" a'^noiiK'ii llieifliv. or that it- ilin'' Mr- p^-- n t a- ll It "I'll itii'ii aili'ii'.iii'; -III ll yoKM'llll 111. (|iK- Mill :i''iil ilii|iaii\ iia liln on llii' a'^H ll mi'i '|\ ~i:;lllli«'~ ll ,1 ilir ."iii|iaii\ aiM'i ,1- .1.1 iio«llli)ll II I' rr.ilili 1 1 III llilsl 'I'liii-. ill \.iill. rcllliiiiiaiA ai;ii I II III I 'I I II Mui'iil "a- 111' I.iihI Air,. !,■ Iliilrl '■ !• I) Hi. ill' ,|c liclwi-i'li the iutoiiil"'' a'^-iirialioii lli(>i('l'\ i'/i<" iiaiil iciii lo t roiiniaiiv. all W'alli- .mil a liii-H'i' l"i rl.'- "I ,1 \,a- i'\\ Iv aiii.liK'il I'V iIk' :"I MnlOinCV. ill"' lollljli , lie ,U'ini>i'il. atiil .-|H'lil lie Ics-or. an 1 liv ic .ilntioii lo a.--('iil I" 111'" ili.alioti ll ilii' iiL::i<'i'iii<'iii ll ua- Im'M ilia! the loiniianv ua- li li.nU ,iii"<— inn 111 tilt- la. Ml Slim-, tlicri'oii a 111 ll' ilii' (iiivil'ii-.* |inr|>"ri'"l .Ml tlii> itiilwitli-laiuliir-. ,1 ImmiihI In llii' a;ri-<>i'iiicii! lie riiiii|iaiiv. .tai -.viii -ll (•luiijiaiiv wi'if an- |iiiii<'<'i .:\ vlll!Sl'l|lHM! tU to till- i-\i-li-iii I' 111 tin r till lin- on I li(> rritiiit - us-iiiii|iliou that tl iniiaii 111 I h.i 2»ili .liil.v ua- liiiiiliiip; on Hif ri'iii|iii" IV. Ill "'.V i|iinioii llial i'\|iliMii- I Ii(. \vli(.l<' of tlio-f tmii-iu'tioii-. • A 1 oiiipaiiy llll'lI'lN t.ikiii'-' iIk' I'«' nclit '■! a iin'-incnrpoia tlOll "111 lail iloos iii't INTKODt'CroRY NOTKS. ■M^ 1,111,1 ill,. , |i,iii\ I" liillil ill" oliliy:alious of thiii loiiinici Itnllin- It, nil .!'('/» il ' I I'.. L'.'i ell. I). lti;{; Stitiiiifil Moliti Mtiil ( onth <» I liulnii^ I l,'-iii. > I'.iOH; 2 ( II. •">!.">. oM'iriilin;^ Hiiiili^li iiinl I'dIoiihiI /',,„/,,,, ( ,, , lIHlii) 2 I'll. 4;i."ii. llimu'li il iii;i\ yi\i' iIh' !mi-Ici' h il^hi ,,\ iii.li'iiiiiilv : lliiKl-tiiii \. liilil'ii^, I I'.lol . A. ( . IIH Sm- .,|,.. \nitli Si/ihii'ii hiirsliiiiiil mill iiiiiiiirnii i'n. \. Iliti'iiiix. IN'.C.i ■Ji'.:',. ulii'ic a iniiliail liail lii'cii Jiiiuli' «illi •cil.uii jii'i^iin^ a-. .- lilt nil tllll'l|l|<':l l'all\ . .Ilhl llV I'i'^ollllillll III llic lll.'rtlH- V I III,, I ilir i:,iii|>:iii\ .- iiii iii|piii.iiiiiii lliMl 1-iiiilrail v\ii> .iilii| iiiliriiM'il. Mini II \\.i< lirlil liiil II liiiiiliii;^' nil ll !■ i i.lllll.MlV it ll Mill! TImmi l.iii ii"> lliiiik lliiil llir aiiiijilinii iiinl ' milii tii.i' imi )i\ i|iii.i I'li'^ lit a I lint I a lail iiiaili' li<||iiic till' t'lii'inalinii nl ill i> I iiiiiiiaiiv 1,11 - |iiii |iiiiiiii;; to art mi licliall of llii- iiiiii|iain ■ icali'* aiiv nil.. I Ilia! ii'lalinii « liali'M'i IkMuci'ii till' ioiii|iaiiv .iiiil III' otiii'i |.ar l\ |i. tin' iiiiitiart. or iiiipu'" ('■i aiiv 1 il.liuv liliM wliali'M'l I'll till' ilU|MU\ li.W.lli hat lii;rl\ . ,\"'M'i ■lull'.-- v^ Im'Ii' an . lu I rr I ill' ill c iil(' i i> I'S |'ii'-«"'i| In 111 iiiaili' \\iili .1 |ii'i.^iiii |iiiil'i'.~-iii^- to riiiMiari a- i<^i''i;l m- liii-lii' Ini- ail il iiI.mI riilii|iaiiv. lilt- roiiijiain wlirii 'nlllii'il I III I'li'i'i- iiiln a iirif a;jl<'('!iii'iil uiili tin' |iaitii-~ in lln" |iti'liiiiiiiai \ aj^i'i'i'iiii'iit tliai tin' roiii|iaii\ .-li.ill .iilnjil ami iiii'iil lliii,* made mi il» lu'liah m- Inf il-i I'l' Kiiriii> II tin- lit'iii'lil. ami llii~ ulll liiiiil ilii' i'i>iii|i.iii\ anil IJ 1,'r Ihilr ,1 J'liiiil. 01 I.. T. JHii; .V.»/i// l.niiil < n. \ I'liiiliiif I itllifi'l Si/iitliiiilr, \\\»l{ I .\A'. IJIl. Mmiinrr. .nl.' ilmii> liv a rniiijiaiiy iiiav jiisiiiv tlic iiiliTi'inn ul ,i iiru imili'.irl ill llii< ali.-t'iiri- of .'^miic aiillioiilx fi'iiii tin' \i aui'iit m iiii.^Iit ami tin' paiiv .liiiiiiiarv a^n'i'iin'iil iinnaiiv III. II till' I I liiiiii: ill"' ii'iiilm into rmilrartiiiil ri'latioii'* with llir imu- |.iii\ llii'iiil I'liriiiiiiilif T'lrf ( II. \. .nloplioii :iirimn' ■> n's nilrr iilins i In' nl'iii>i iirlii N'l I' III siirli riii'iiiii'-laiiri'^ ran thi iiiiii| .iii\ .-III' till' M'mlm- mi tlic pii'liiiiiiiaiv atrii'i'iin'in- l"i' iln' loiii- jMiiv i> II si|.,i;iir('i- lo lliai aifici'iiii'iil . iiinl il i» vm'II .>i'Ii|i'iI iIi.iI i |iii-iiii r.iiiiiui ■^iic on a loiitrai-t lo wliirli lit> i-* no: a paiiv iiiili'-> it I- inaili' iM lii>i lii'liaif liv an aiji'iit or a (riiili'c for him A iiii'ii- .I'^niiiifiit lii'UM'i'ii A ami li lliiii li. .tliall )i.iv ( , an a:ri'''i'iii<'iil I" ulll. I. I is 11. ll a paitv ciilii'r ilircctiv m iinlii('itl\ . will not I'li'Miit ,\ ami I!, froiii rouiiii^ lo u now iii>:t' "oiiii'iil llic next !la\ ;iir;i.-tii'i ,(11.' iiu-2- (l'roiH».iliou 5. ««/'r«i i» <'"teu-(l iiilo afUT tho iiuoiiH.ta- fioi. ..f th<- lompai'.v- » <<««l'a.( imv in «..n.e .mh.'s 1..- iii- foiuMl from the u.ts «f ii (•..iiijiaiiv aftir it« iii.oiporaii for «lthnu^'h Ih.' conipaiiv .aunot ralifv or l.v mor<- r...s„l„- tion adopt, -it .Icon not follow from tliut ll.uf a.t.< iim> noi Ik< .Ioup I>v tho romimiiv after il*< formation whi. li niak.. a „,.« .ontrad to Ml.- Hin.o .-II.mI a> tl.o ol.i oiu- ' I'ci .l.-«-.'l. M K.. KmiireiK Ktiiiivveritiii ( ».. U> •'. 1). !:iK AimI a.ronlinjflN . wIhmv a .M.utra, . of ^ul.' u.aJ." will, u tru.Hl,.,. Un a„ i„,..,..U-.l ,om,.a..v «..> .arri...! int.. .-IT.-., l.v .onvovan.- ot , „■ nroiK.rtv a...l l.v tlu- iKMK- of tlu- n,nl s rot.'»l Iron, Co.. 'M V. 1). l."..!. Hm ,. i. not prudent to ml on the as«umplion thai a di.c.t ronlrarl .a„ t«uf»'lv be omitted. Vn in.portanl aheraiion wa« made in .he matter ol eon.panie^' . ,.„. „aet.> l.v >e.... .; ;!. of the ( umpauie- A... I'.HM.. This MMfon .> n..« ...pla.-ed bv M-t 87 . :! . of the ('..mpauie^ A.t. l-.MiH. and pro^.de- a- follo«,>. • Aux .oulra.M .nade bv a eompanv befure the dale al «ln. h i, i., ..m.iled to ,nu..,.-n, e busine^- -hall be proviMOu..' ...Iv. and shall „„t be bin-linj. -n .he .ompanv uuu\ iha. dale, and on that date ,.fsj '■ ; J Ok. Jojberomi biii'.liiiji. '-^ ' l»rovi.M..nal here an- thai .be .omra.t .s to be .ead as .1 .1 eo.itained a provision iha. .1 shall .u.. Ik- l.....lin>r on .he .-...npany unless a.i.l nn.il the .o.npa- • '.en.n.es e..li.led to eomtnoiKe bns.n.->s. Hr Otto KM,i,-„J M,n,i,fart„r,„<, (« . .hi,l.i„s- nisr. (190... 1 U MW -Shall be bindin-' .nnsl nol be taken \<> y:ive any slatnl-.^ Minitioii I" the loii.ra.l Primal, eompanies an' exemp. fro... thi- ,..ovision. \no,he, s.a.u.orv aheration in the nmlt-r of .on.ra.ls by ...m- panies i- eontained in the Con.panies A,t. 1U08. «c.t. 8.1 repla, ..e.- ',.,, 11 „f ,|„- (' panies A.I. limo. A eompanv .shall ..ol P"'- X iu.islv to Ihe su........ V ...e,.ti..^' va.y lb., lern.s of a eo..trael relen.M ,o in the pr.*.lKHtns. ..r stu.e.nent i.. I.e.. of pro«po.t..s. except snb... t ,„ ,1... approval of Ihe .s.atuto.v ...eeti.ijr ' Ii' a .•..mpan.v «e.e all..w,.,l ... do .s... it nii^'ht evade .•rili.is... of the .onl.a.. by IIh sharehol.leis at ll..' s.atnlory .neetiiiyr. niieir Iheie is ... be a preli.i.ina.v ........a... ...le or ..the. ..I .la- follow!!!'- !!.>ir pb"!s is iisuallv adop.ex|iioh«p«I Io Ik iiiiido iH'twccii IMC vcnili'i- ami .-iiiui' u'^oiil I'm- tlio iiiiii- puiiy; it i« "ijfiK'il alU'i- iMriij|iiii'iiiiiitl>' ailuptCKl li.\ llio i(iiii|iaii\ . I'l vN :: A(.'ici Ill |>r<'paii'il licloif iiiciii-poialioii ami t'xproiwwl to !«• iiiaiic with the roMipaiiv: il i« waU'd l.v tlio n.iiipaiiv ultor iiudipnrali'm Pi j,, 1 Anil II'.- nl' a>si"iali <■ >ii('iil a» Io aiiv a>jii'i'm»>iit, hut lii\f iliiciliiis piiwi-r III piinhaur llit' piiipritx ^i Best Coarse to be followed. \\'li»Mwv«>l- llu-l-*' i- IK" parlii ulai- ii'ii^nii I'm' adnpliii'^ I'laii 1. il i» t'XIKilieul Id iidiipl iMull^ J. '•>. or t. lor, liv ihf adiipliiiii of any of tlii«.i' piuiif, lln' riinipany Ih'coiik's liound in dm' ri)iii>«> willioiil any apiii'ainniH' of ihf coiitrait liuvint; Ik""'!! fmct'd on il, ami ivillionl llio ui'M'K«il\ for any supplciiK'ntal iinitriiit . S«'<' tin- nulcn |o Foiin 2">1, '" ^**-*i I laiifi- .!. infill. Plan 1. r.ifiuv ihi' iiinii|ii)ialioii 'I llii'ioiiipany. iIk' puiinoK'ix proiunHhe I'laii 1. lAin r 111 (lie piupi'liy Io I'lilci' i llio an af^ri-fmunl witli noiiic por-on, a'- iii-i !■ ajiciil for tho intcntU'd roiiipany, for the muIo of llic property ■11 ilii' runipany upon itilain iorin-i and lomlilioiis. Tlic in«'iiiiiran- • liiiii and ailiili's of a.-s(.i iaiion of tlio lonipaiiy am solllcd, wilh lln .unriiiionrc of llii' M'lidor and of lln' piuiUoK'i.-, i onl<'inpoiancoii>l\ nilli lliis ai^iiHiuii'Ml 111 lln' arliilrr. is inMOrtt'il a claii-c iLMcrrinji- Io till' a;:r<'i'rm'nl .stui inl'ni, p. ans of a liiiif siippl'iui'iilal n^io/ xuili afiireniciil. infra, pp. ."tti'.t, .'im. I lie -iip|i|eiiieiilul affieeinenl in noieiwaiy where the jireliniii: I'v a>;ree- iiK'M' i.s made with an "anient. iM'cansu it Invs heeii held llial there ran Ik till I'lli'iliial ratitiiatioii in xiirli a i-asi', iiiasiniiih as ihe roinpanv .Xtffeoiiii'ut with truBtt-"' or aic*'»t fur iiitcnditl roiu- puiiy fuIliinTil liy «iippl»'- nii'Dtnl ailupti'.f HjfTts.niilit. u 9s» AOKKKMKSTM. CllAl'. V. w;l- ll'il 111 ,.vi-,-n..' «lu'ii III.' |.i.'l.iiiii^'i> iiiri.--iii''i" «"- '•• R«.n...».,v IMai I I. M.lilHi » ,..H...,v.l. I«m„h>..: ,„ I'...,.,.. ir-MUJT .o th.. '""'"'"■'' ,). V..M Ini 1 rl in M'll -m N"" i"'"' '••""- ''■'"' '"^ ' '' ""' i,' „ ,,.....i..i. lu.h.Ui.. I.. I...M. '- Th.- I....II.....-.- ma^ - .■M.v I.. l.iM.I ...i.pai.v ..l.s,.liil,-h ...;.,,|.ii..' "Ii- l•>"l'<■".^ "I""'"'" "■"" .,,.,,,„„„| |„ „„■.„ U.|...r i.> i.i.-..n.ni:..i...i Willi :i M.MMl,...vl... .1..- ,.nii;.i.v Hll,.,li..a.....t.a,la~i,. IMa.i 1 . ..ii.l In tl..' a.ti, L-. ..,,„.„ „ i„..„...l iiMiu.mi;: 111.- .lii.--- '■; '-■-. "V";"T VIl ' .„„„,,, I... ,\u.uU 1.-..II .-N- II....1 an.l ...ilv «aii^ t„r a:l,.,..ioii, .l„. .,i,,,,,„. ,ull hr !.■» liU.'l.v tn .ai- .,u.-tinii> a- ... Hl- i.'.iii- I.m^I „„.„„„„,., .„,...,„ i...l„.,li... ax-. l!„, iiMMMii... ...M.,.,....-.l.l,a, .,„. ,„„1, .la,.-.- .an l.in.l .l- ^li.-t....- ".■ ..l-. »li.'.li.'r '..■ I... 'I'" ...l..,..i.... ..I t ..• .■...i.u.l i, ,.,, ,1... ..„.,.,.aii>^ iMU.'lil. S'v /•''"•''"'" '•■"'''"■' ''''"'"'"'"■ , N,. I . I'.ill • M li f^v m I'Un 2. Atrf'emeiit witli tt)feiit for (ompiiny 'uh- si'quently iidopU-d under ■will of COIIl- piuiy. Ad»,.it«if<* ..fPlan .'. Plan 2. .,-|,„ ,„,„„„„.„, i. ,,i..|.an'.l l-f..M- 111.' ill.. ..I""''"'-'" "' "'•' """■ ,,.,„, ..,,,1 i. ..x,.i.-..d ... 1.0 ii.a.l.- !..•.« ■ '!"• v.a.l.-- .""' -"- .lui.i a.i.l ai.,.l..> ..•I.-- t'- th.- a..n.-..|....|i. as a .o....a.-, aU. ..iv ,,,..,.,...■.1 aiKl iii.-n.k.l ... l..-Ms:.a-i in Mliutol: oflcr tin- ..K..r,...ia- I..„; ,„ ,„.. ...n.pain. an.l a.i.l....i/.- .1"> .lin.'o.s ... rut.ty a.ul a.|..,. the ...... -. K..nn •...f. T .....|.anv i. tla-n .•o.^'..-.t,..o,l. and ;„„„;,.,.. ..U .,u.r.n,nls .i... ..aiU,- ... .!..■ a^.-.v.ia.n,. v i/ , .h- v.-nd... „,„, ,„. a^...|., M.a th.. «aia. S,.l.>.■.,l..■n.l^ ■ a in.... Mng ... tie ;,i.,,,,. u ,...i.i. ail.. a ...s..iun,.u . , M. ;■-':-';'.'; a,.n...in..' 1,.. .a.i.a.l ami a.l..,- L ""■I "-' .liv mmIL. aMiv. ... ,,' ,.Htlu.iv..r TlK..-al istlK.«alliM..I ...a.m..m.ian.ln.n...u..il...|..« ,h.' a.M. in .1..- t....i..: Tla- al...N.- nr wi.lii..-u, i...... J ai::,v- ,„..„;isl...n.l.Ma.ilU..lai„la.l..,....M.> '1.,. < ...v. lamm..L \s «i.i,.-^ .1... n..n M.al ..f .h- ^m-I ..■.nl.all^ U ,- dav ... Tli..n.-f...Hi. .1... .•..iH|.an.v .> .11.... laallv l....in.l l..^ "I." a-^"^ ' ,,.• .I... .v.lii.i.al ...U. ...lal.li^li.a in hrUrr ^ /{.....'. ' 1- « ., r |. ,;» ,1....^ n... appK . >iii.v Hk' atrrviianl » .s s.ir I .«'« •,„..„,,„.al...n. a.i.l i~ ll..M-..|<..v n,,.al.l.. of rahji. a.....i Plau •• i.< s.,in...ii....^ u.l..|.t...l l..'.aUM. .. av....l- .In- .io.v^m.n . . H.e ..,„...,.:,..al a,n...n...|i. ............1 U, .Man 1 a.al "' ;^;; ;•;- j;- „,,,,.„„ .....l ....f.Ir,. ai.v rosolution I'...- tl..- a.U.p.i 1 .1- ^.^-Toom !,;::, M....ni,W .. ...v ....... M......v.-, p...n » ..o...o.....«^ ,,„.,,.,. .., ..ulanit an asrm.inou. .... a.i..|..io.i mtLer ...an n .lOw ugit-e- INTKOIUJCTOK^ NOri->«. :w: „l |,„ ..v, utioM ... ill Plan- I. ;l. t W I I'l;.ii -2 is a.lo|ito hIioiiIiI Uiir in niiml llial il lh<>v uil >>ii il"' roiitniil. "i ,,ili.i«iv -\i<>\\ llifii ii'l"|'li"" iIk-h"'!. ill'- 1 ..iii|i;iiiv iilh !«• Iioiiiul l..\ iiii|ilii'ii ol llic ioiii|iiiiix an am^ si.l.> ..I ■^^^^^;;^l'^^^^^^ il„. j,r..|HMlv lJ.ili.M<.iii|.aii.v. i". willi tli.' jirivity of tli'' voikIoiiiihI iIh- i,^.if „i,|, p. iiiut.i-, iir.'|>aiv.l. The iiiciiinniiilll.xl will. lli«- lik<- priv l.v In the iiili.'l.iM i- "|^'",'„',; " iMMiii"! a . laiix' ■«•<• Korin :!'>l, liaiK*.' i, hum. |i. tillj rcf.'riiiiir I" iltcaffic'iiioiil ai.daii'liori/ii.t; oi- mi.iirinj; 111.- clirt'ctor-. foilhwitl. l" ;illi\ the -^-al "f till' .Miii.pai.v tl.i'i.'lo. or ilcflaiiiiir that tli<' n.iupanv -I, ill j.itiliwill.cxo.iit.' thoiiKK^'iiKiii Tluniionioriin'liiiiiaiiiinr(ii li'« aiv il.iii n';ri.-«t('it'(l, hikI tlif K'ui-Miir i-'M««. Iii-* corlilii at<>. At tli.' lii-i iini'liiii; of tilt' ilini lois iIm' ai.'T<.<'riu'iit i.- lakoii iiit (■oi.«i(li'ra- liuii aii.l u Lvoiiilioii |i:i-i>.'\c-iili'il. Immi.i:- afl.Mwar.l-^ ii. .In.' rour-if loiiicl liii" cir.'.'t Plan 4. Thi^ plaii'I.i.lvJililT.'r.s from I'laii .1 ii^^ i.>«pi'i(. nain.-iv, !h:il (lit- PI"' « .oil.j.v- .lo nni .-vpr.'.-lx ivh-r to tl..> air.v.Mii.'i.t. ImiI a.ilhoriiro ihv ^J'^;[:;',j;;*'; .lin'itoi> to piiiriiaM' tin- piopi-riy on "tiili tcii.i* ami r.iii liiion-' .t- ,iir agMM'tinMil Ovrmul. cii'-.tt.-|>.v iti.- r,V,/»7/',( ( ,> V. ii,hl<. I. K. :. IF L. IHO lint lli.- ..tli.-r plan- ar.' ..»""■>'.•■"• •j.ii.ialU adopted. And nii.' of iIi.jm- plan-- i-^ pr.'fciaMc nlii-n ill.' .Ii.iitoi - oi' .oini' of lliciii ni.' vomlois. u W licM'. a> ill Plan I. a pcixiii purport lo (onlrail as apronl for a P'^f*'."*' ... . . . llADtlltV Ol .i.iiipaiiv not ypt formed, he is piTsonally Imlilo on the .•ontnitt. ^entm'cac l\,lnrr\. Ihirlrr. L It 2 (' P 174. So, ulwi, a person .ontia. ting '^^'^J^";^' ;i- ■IriiMlrp" is peinoiially liulde Stirthnmherlmui Aretiup do.. 3.1 Div Hi Ami where u (.erson has s.. .ontract.'d lus "aiJitJlil." the fact that the iinpaiiy after its ini'orporulion iictn on. or piir])orts to niiify or adopt II' lonlrai t, will not ipli"vi' the airent from the i>eisoniil lialiility he iiiiiM irniM xiirniiiir iifi Udiiill' of a i.oi.-.>vi> teiii principal I Srott v. iin^actioii ainoiiiii-< to a im|>aiiy not vet fonw'L / .11 11 lontract, e.q . lut in Klnirji. 41. iniiit. So too, where the eontiaci I- made w ith ■trustee lor a minpai the trustee will not he -TiM AQRKEMBNT8. [Chap. V. \ 'S \i S4«l AgraaOHiut iliiiuld Ih.' pruned >«ithHt lii« lUbUity nhoiiUI be tiomuutl ProTUo limit- r,; iniflUbilityof •gent TitUd : «wiM, if pur- porting tu nUere him fnnuaU 1 U>bUit7. ProviidoiiH <>f 3 1'^ •rtinleR. i '1 i 'l ,el....M..t fioiii liability u, il.r vcid.u l,v iea«ou oi the rompany pur- |K»tliuK tu u.lo|)t. or aclin,r "•« iho r.mlinK that it i« o.il.ti«.itrtttl \orlhnmh,-rh.mt Arenne Co., AH V. Uiv Mi Wulferi, v. Sorthcni Coal Co., :> iK- li. M. & O. 1529; Cor v. /W/o,,. K I)., i; M. & ti «l' Tl.on. ...UM I..- ail oiroctiv.. uUmH not a.lopt tlio as;n-.ni.Mit before a oertain day i pno. Im the .lay fixed for toMipletion i, the u^'ent or truMee may at any tn,,.' ;.fl,.r«aidH ras-ind it ^lo eUo. I of the^e proyiMons is, that i .■o.ui.ai.y a.loptH the agreement, the ajreat or trustee is tree.l In.n, liability- aud if the r-i.ipaiiy i! .es not adopt it in duo -ourse, tl... ;,i;ei.t or ti.wtoe. bofo.e the time lixod for .ompletion, rescinds llir a^rreenienl. and ;hereb> teriiiiiiatis his liability Ix'fore be has bad t.. do anything under the i^tiiwinent. A pnniso thus limitinn the liability of .he so-railed aju-. trustee is yali.!: but, not uncoiiiiiionly, it is provided that h.' .-ball in.ur no ,j>'rso,uil responxibility whatever. Such a proviso is, h.,«- .ner, in Liw repugnant and voi.l. the result being that the agent ..i llu^lee is personally bound to iMsrforin th(! contract. Furnivnll \ CoomUex. :> M. A Cr. 7:tti: WiUi'Utix y. Unthatvu;/, 6 O. I). 044. Xti to the operation of clauses in the arti.rle.' of a.sso<-iation provi.l- ing for the adoption of an agretfuient, see infm, p. (>l:5. Kvcn befon> iho Act of 1908 wan passwl, when a eonipauy u;i> .Marled to ac.,uue a specific proiwrty, and Iho capital was to I..' lui-MKl by public subscription, it wa.s not unusual so to fr.un.^ ili" Hgr«>eiuent for the purcha«o of the property, that if within a iInc'I ,K-ri.Kl a .tsriaiii number of shares were uot taken, the company c oul.l rescind, the object being that if the company Bhould fail in raising tli<. funds noi-e «ary to enable it to .•onimeiice business it might Is- able ;o "tjl rid of the agreement. Somelimos a similar power was given to The vendor, for he might not U< willing to sell to a company wbi.li liad not the ni-an.s to develop a proiierty for which he was probably to be paid partly iu shares; or his own right to sell might be coii- tingeui on a ceriaiu number of shartw being taken up. But now. under the Act of 1908, s. 87 (3), 'any contract made by a company before the date at which it is entitled to commence busi- ness shall be provisional only, and shall not be binding on the coiii- pauy until that date, and i.n that date it shall become binding. ' INrKdUUCrOKY NOTt^l. .\M if t>M' All 111' milM. aii'l llif iiott"' rlii'ii'lii. M(/i/-<(. for ihUu. ;! II' \^ iM ilio iiii'iiiiiiiK "I |)ro\i»ioiml, m-" OIId F.h ■ ln'nl Eniinifiiini In . .Iiiil.'iis f Itiiiii. I llXHll 2 C'h. ;l'.MI. *«/)/.l, |i. J:.'. A." lit «lifii iIk' < ii <'iilill«Ml 111 riiiiiiiMMtn' liii-ini'MH, mt •.((///((, |i iti; ^iii'l i" •<> ''"■ li'i'iv*" "ft. >Hli ihf iiiiiiiiMiiiii i«iil.>rii|>- limi. M'f M'll. |i '.I. Ill i.ii.Kuiiiiu ;iii airiwiiiviil l«i wilf. till- liill'ivviiiu •!"• -"!• I "'"' l'"inw< ■ ' . . . , iltfTWOH pmiilM wliiili ailM' I'll roil-l'lcritlimi: ,11 On llif -iili' ill It liii-iiH"- All' iIk' liiiiiU ili'lii.« 111 111- iiirluiliMl - All' iiin III' lliiMii li:i I - U alli'Hiiiui' ii> Ih' iimili' Im lnnl ilcliln'r \\ ill til' vi'iiilnr ;;iiariiMli'i' llu' Imnk ili'lil-' If iIii\n aif 111 Im' «'xrliiii' ' liiiiii llii' "111*', i-- iIk" I'liiiim ■■ hIIi'' I iIk'Hi!' Ik iho hIixK il-lrinii' In 1»' iiiriMiim! ill r 'V iir III Ik> liikon ovor iit a viiiiiiilioii'' I-* llii' .• ' I'lliHl t'roiii ill" ilaif 111' llio inriiH'iiH'iil, III- f Hill till' . till riimplolii !. in I'luiii SI pafl ilalf' U llu- mh lllcrillllt'll I'iDlll i'iilll|H'lill^' will) till' riilli|lilllV '.' I >■.■ ' '•■: m-ss I.I III' caiiiwl nil till rimipl.-iioii mi licliall' "I 'in' M'tiii.M, Df ri)m|ilolii>ii. au'l In li'-riml if llio pati'iii Ik' pini!'Hiiu«'<.l iiivaliil'/ HI On till" Kulc ol a mini' I- il m Ik< ovuiiiiiii'il I'V an inilcpi'iidi'iil i'\|:i'rl livfiiu' niliipli'liniir Is iIm'k a y:iH«l ijllu;' If tlir piiiperlv is aliiiHiil ran ilif <■• ipaii> linlil il, and is tli«> [iiirrlias«> III lie rnnipli-liil alimail or in KiiirlanilV If alirnail, is (111' piiirhusi'-moni'v in lii' si-ni alimad. or is ii In In- paid hi'it' 10 tnisii'cs poniliiii; inli'iiiinU'ii as In i!ii' lillo and liaiisfi'i- liaxiiij; lici'ii minplfU"!' ill) On i!ii' salt" nf a iniirt'ssinn Is il ■, alid' U ii lialili' In fnlli'iliin':- ( an il Iw vsli'd in llii' ri.iii|iaiiy willi ol witlioiil iniiM'iit; and. in the fmiiiiT lasi-. wliai !•» m In- ilnni' if tin- riinscnt ruiinnt Ih' nlilaiili'd'' H'l On aiiv sale, is ihoif to lif pnwt'r lo ii'siind if lli niii|iaii> dni'S not fiout, and who. in thai ous*'. is to pay llio proliniiiiai y I'Vpi'llKeM? Pridiuiiuuiy a^ifciufut*! veiy i-omiiuuily jirnvidi- for iho isMio nl I'aid-np fully or jiartly paid-up sharivs for a considoratinn iith'.T than i iisli. «.(/.. utt the lonsidi'ratinii fnr the sale of properly or nf servii'i^" I'l be rendered in ihe i'nni|miiy . 'i 'i 11 3:j0 AtiKKKMKNr." rCllAI'. V, The law it.- I<» IlK" i*^'"' ii..|i ha- I n lii.iU'i iiillv a 1.1 hliaii- Imi a .i.ii-i.h'ialiiiii ollli'l lliaii lloK'il l.v ill'' < i.aiiii- All. I'Jitt' in(.« ifl larfil l.\ ll»' riitiiii)iiii<''< All. I'.HtKi Km iiiaiiv yai.-i (Mlur liMjwiiiiH' wlifii iluil Alt iani.Miilu..|»'ral iM .laiiiiai'\ liilic. vv lltOl I. M'll. :.'."i ol llii' ( 'imiiai All. IMliT. hail lircu m h.i.l.v il «a> iPiuvi.ini Ihai .-mtv ,-haM- ill aii.v ...m|Mi >h li»' hi'l'l ilij'-i I llii' I Il 111 llii' wlinU' ■• "Ill llii'ifcil ill ra-li. mill h,. .-aii.c .-I M liiiN<' l»-''i' "lhi-i«i-.' .l.-I.Tiiii.i.'il In a iiiailc Ml xMiliMi; an iiitiai'l iliiU I liji'il Willi ill"- Ui-ui-ii- I .loin! Sli.i k I ami'.- ai 111 llClill' llli' I--IK' ,| r-mli -hail'-. aiiil u «••• \\i4\ >i'il|i-.l llia< iIk' niiiilal lliii- ii'i|i(ii .;| I,, 1,1' liliil -1 «li"« :'i iiiilii'i 111 llif .»liai('- li) 1" all..li"'l. il"' .1111. nil I h. Ill' 1 ll'.liH'.l .i- I il. anil II riili.-lih'ialliili |i.i wlii. Il iIk' -Ii.ii !■- urli' I. 1 1. .lili'.l I'f III. -lull- i.ll 111 ll||. \.l. /l(l/i( .1 ihi' I ..iii)iaiiii' I.- Iiiiiii .l.iiiiiaiv .\.| I'.lilii. I li.iji .\\ Hill 1'.^ '''" .1 ilii. A. I 111 I.M.: "1- li'l"'; |,t I'.iiil. wilh lilt' n-iili iliil ll"' r \. I ..I IStil' ill iv-aiil I". |.a\iiii'Mi - I'll -lull- will- li'-l": .1. .mil III all' 111." .•iill...iliiil ill Ihi' < I'- ' iij.i ihi' .V.I "t IHii:! " >!' Ni.w Ullllllllll \. 1. I 'HIM hali'lii.l.li'i "■'- 111 liji. I. 'I ihr I. Ill .1 hi.- shall'-. '<.iM' -1. lai a- lln' aliiiMiiil iii.i> havi- liri'li |iii Iv |.ai.l n|i. .'iliu'i li> hiiii-i'll "r ..lln iw i- 1 ill thi' A I. lull v lull- M'H ilr.iilx r\|iii'— I .-iMili'.l li\ iiiiil.v ili'i i-i"ii thai jiaMiii'iit inn I"' m.i'l' m ' i inakiii- i.ui I., till' i-.iiiili.iin |ii"|» Til. liyaliiili l^ ii"l lli.it il i'\i-l- 1- " nil lii.-ix.l> ,| till' lii'^lii'-l aiilli.iii \ Il i- al-" -I'ltli' I. »h, ..I III il- '■■|iii^ 'li'iii. '■ 1/ n\ «li|. Il il lia- IM.VM'V 11. a. |iiii „ ....hIi'Iiml; ..I i-i.. in- I., ii'li.hi H -I'lM- »1> i' Il il I- « illini: '' 111 -.111-1,1. ii.. I. .1 ill! aiii. .11111 .1 ill.- -Iiai aiiv .-I" ill. |..iil|.,ii ilii'ii'iil Till i\\ . Ihi'ii. a- II II"" M.iiii |. I, a- I..II..U- I A 1 ..iii|.ain " II Il a .-I. .11'- ..ijilLlI iii.i* l-~ii'' -lii'ii'- •■! ''III'''! Iiilh 111 pai'lv li.U'l i|' I'" •! :i1mil; i.i-li "'I' .-iili'ialiiHi A I iiiii|.aii\ lii.K I'-il nil fill a . ..II- -Ii.,ii.- ,iiiliii-.| a- liill.x "I |.irll\ I'.ii'l h.iali llii'l til. HI -a-li |i|.i\i.|i'il ill 'I ll" .1111-1. Ii'i I .11 I- -i.!l|..tllll|.. ., |1|..|.. I I \ .It -I'l \ 1' I ll. - I I.. .,i,,iii.-itiiiii 1.1 "lii. ll i- "illini ill-' |'"»''i- "' 'I '"■ ,,anx anil i- n. ll"' I -' "I"" Inr Mi- ■•' a.|i.|il.iU' \ lliir >,il,.„.,l I , ,,| -... 1 HN ..t ill.- t ..m|.: - '■ ..liil ili.-nl V" I'.tii* I- .1- |m||..h- U|,..„..X.l- .1 ...lll|...l.» I.. I l.v -I..".- Ill-ll>'- '"> .H.'^'ILhl l.f it- •llllt- ll" ,.,„ii,.«„v -I ».iii.'. I'l' .1.. ..'iri.. III. V...1. Ill" li.-.-1-..Mi .■( I ■.|ll|MIlir» . , ,,, , \ ri'liilM l.f H.. ..Il..lm'iii- -'iiliiitf ll"- iiiiiiiIh>- •'■■•• """m"'' ■' i"' "' III.. -Iiaii- i..i.i|iri-Hl 111 111. iill.iliii.iil. Ill'- iiuim-. iiililr.'«i- ""'I 'I' INTItODUCiOKV NOTI'>«. aai ,,( III. .ill. .11..-.. ilili ill li ^liiiri'. mil M" 1(1 tip MllfMl.l ll .1H\ |>. 1 tin- la-i ill ril^li. llii' allolliii'ii i.f ►lurr- 11 11(111. ll 111- liill\ ""■ I'.iill.v |i'ii' "1 III IIP (III .1m.- .111.1 icrwi"*' til. Ill iilrn. I ill »rlliii(.' i ..n-lit" t, |i...'illi.r witli :iii\ ciiilni.t till..' Ilii .ill.- cf 111.' ;ill"tli''- I' ■ if >^ilc .11- r.ir M-rvi.T- iitlii-r 111"- iiliriilii.il ill ii'-l" III ttlii.-li tli.il nil. .till. -lit »"- iiiii'l"' iilr:ii-t- l.i'ilil.' "liii.V -I iii>|. iiiiiiiil mill. 111! t i.f -I,: il, iiiul a n-tiirii -taliiiL' . . L.ttiil. III.' I'xl'ii' 1.1 " 1 ll IlL' till' llllllll"' llll'l 1„. tn-.ltnl I" |.illil ll| Lirii al'..tt.-il I III. ami III. .'Ill aiili'iatii'ii hiili tlii-v all- t. f..i- «lii.li tlii-v li.n. A- I., ll it.-i' if>\ iMicini'iii- ^fi' (i.-, rl Siib-.-t'i I. iiH'iiliiiiii'il . .llll|lill'..V lllll- il Ihf >aMi<' .Vil jir (|i.^ ill ctli'ii lliiil it Mil' all' It li;i.- iii.i al llii' liiiH' 1 11 ii'ililrcil M "liliiiLt. III! alii'i- ill'- .illiitiiH'iil lili" Willi ll" 1 Hillllll nil'' I 'll i-..M.l I., liii'il n~ aliiiu I \\ liiic ,-liaii- all' i>*iii tl i.iti III 1 .1-11 I .1- liilh "1 I'litiU |i.iiil ii|i ..ili.'wi- HS 111' tin' .\' '- -111 • I' •,S ,1 It ili'laiih I"' I 11. nil' ill ruin lilviii'.- wilh ill'- ii"|iiii<'iii"'iii- .Ih imi'.. 111!' il:ii'i-i'.!- am 1/ ,1 il.U iti-li' ■ fill' I iiihi'i ..Hi. ill- "ill ill' 1" li.il \.\ i!i iii.i\ 111- ir'-.'ii jIhii- ll ii."i'.ii I" lil'- "1- ,1" ili'iilal "t 'ln'' 1' liia.lM'ili'ii"' Whcic .-liaii- an- i— H' iiilii|iaii\ Mili-i'.|ii''ii |ilii|i('l 1 \ 1.1 Ml V i' ' iIk'K'"!'. Mii'l il i> ii''t |i.,.liii'.; ll I- "I 11 ll. llii- il\ I" a.j^n-i' "II ll llic ll'.l.j.l I" i.'i'pt '^ ill -.nii-la' li.'ii "I I'- ll .ili-l,-. ii.'ii I'- iii'.-i'-«ai-v I" til" am "Uiii.i' I .ii (I ilii-ii-t". lull 111'' ■ ml- "' I'-l"' "*"■ '"1 " ml 1,1 -iili-li."l "ill liav" I" .i|'|"'ii ill llii' aiiiiiial li.-l mill >:iiiiiiiai\ mil li'i !.«•' I Jii : It a vali'l I'liill-ai 1 In- inaiji' l"i ill.' a. I'lilaii. . I'v ll- '"inl" 't ;-|ll'' lli'-' irii|«'rl\ "1- x'l 1 1 iia\ iin'iil "I «liai-i |uuiiii'iii "I pari 1 «hiUl till' ".iiliail -laii'l-. iii.|iiin- n •III. iiiii-i.l<.iali.iii t'\.ii al .li«' iii-l.iii'^' ' /',7/\ ,,iv \i,-i.> 111' -111 sliuilial i.iliii' 111 ihr ( ..III I "ill ii'.l ilii llii- iiili'iiti.ii \ .'I .1 llii' lii|iiilian'- "'il'li liaM ."••■" .iliilK"! lial'l'' i • |'i'- iiH'i'i III >a-li ;».V,' ACKKKMKNTS. [t'llAP. V. Contracts entered into belore the Company is entitled to commence Business. .Sfcl x: •>! till' Act ■■I' I'.iii8 |iiiivi ^o^i.i..llul ...ily, «nr t.. .. ,,,i,„y r.s.'i-l.ml iM-f.nv tli.' lir-l -lay of .Inly. niint.-.Mi i .lr.nl ami .litl.t nhi.li .I.M- not \'-»v u pr.iHp.-tu.. iiivilinu: tli.- piilili.- t" -nl'-.ril..- r..r it< >liar. - Tlic w.ikIk ..1 -I"' alH.s." Mili-M'. I :t ' ai-' « i.U ou.^'li \o .over ev.ii i..i.lialii|., >." tliai lli.iujjh tif ioiii|mii.v liuMillotted llf wli.ili- ..1 \\w iniiiimum suIim riptinii i-.>f.'nv.i 1.. ii. so.l«. H.> uml 87 ( 1 ■ of ih.> A.t, aiin'..l I., lli.- alloltws. uiii aii.l .1 ><■<• 1' •2if> «t >.-i s: li. wl.i.h ,11- 10 1m- ..jiiii.|if t., ulii.l. MNt Ii .(|>|)li'- 1- .•iititl<>. Iiavc UsMi sali^liiNJ And tli.-i-.. is atlfi all ii..lliiiio mii.a.-..iialil<' in it-«>lf in mi. h -., .■.)ii.stni<-li..ii. I<>i tio U|.|>H.an: 1..1, ..r .ll..ll.'c ..I. >lial.- in tin' X'mv •ally -i,.o I'.'lil m taiiiifws I.. U' li''l.i I" III-' liai-iraii it ilic ...iniMinx 1- ii« »<'r in . I„,.|||, 11 I,, ..iintiiiMi.i- l.u-iiH— i'i..\i>i..|iul iiH'iui- llial tli.' ■■■m- lia.t IS to 1. nvatcl a- H n ...nlaiiH'd a «li|>iilali'.n tlial il is li-M I,. !..• hiiiilii.u '11 tlw ...iniiaiiv iinl.>- I nniil il.c < ..inpaiiy i.".n)iiM- .iililkHl t.. i..liiliirii.v l.il>ill<'» (lltu EUrln-iil Mitiniiiftin iii. .Irnkiiis I hiim. > I'.'iiiii 2 • li -iWi rin'ix 1,' ii..|l .'..ii ■ .'Tiii'iil I'.ii the iH'intit .il tlif l.usiiK— man n..i Irann'ii in lliv luw I ■ ►.I Milt iln" i.'n.liti.'ii 11 III.' ...iiliait III -.'III" .a-- TIh' ».,rlaliis .,| tin- ...iiMa. 1 .iii.l 1. niak.' it al.s.ilul*-. 1. 111 it is onlv i.i...iiii..j I..I what il iiu\ \»- \\'illi. an.l tlicrcfiin' any ritrli' I" ii'ini.liai.- .11' ri's. imi .■ '/ I'.i iiii-i.pr ilali..n «ill iviimin tu- «listUllM'.l \- III \ar\in(f sit. Ii lunlra t''. -.'■' 'niiiii. |' -- i IXTUODl'CTOKV NOIK>i. •.w\ A8 to the Making o! Contracts under Seal in Writing by Parol. lU HM I 7.1 -t 111.' CMi.iimnif- A. I. VMtH . ix-ri.:i. liii': -m I .17 ol llic , „,„,„,„i.'.- A.I. mu . i( i> lM..\i.l.'.l ;.- Inll,.«s: ,,, (■.„..,:..,- .... l"-l.alf ..!■ .. ■• ..M.v .M„l,r .1,- |..-....l,...l \.t --.v 1- "-•■• ;>, rulliuv-: tlii.l i- !■> -:>y ,i , \„, ....Mtn... ui.i.ii. if ".-i" '-'«'-" i'^'^""" I"'—"- """.'• '■;■ '■■. '7 r.nu.ml I- h.' in w.iti":,'. ^"'1 if ""''- ^" '••r.liiii-' ;•• •••"-''"I' '''» '";"■ „„;i,.r -,..1. ...:.v I... .1 l.^'lf -f 'l-'Miv in »n.,nu' .....I.t ,,„. ,,m,„i..n -.':.l ..f t I''".v :.n,l ...i.y in ll..' ■':>» 'i.nn.r l- vniiiit nr .li«cli:iri.'.'.|- „; \„v , lr«.l whirl., if m^.l" l"t«.M .ivat.. |" r> W....I.I ^>'Uy !:.« ,,.:,„in.,l t in writing' -iu'-.e^ l.y ti..' pi.rti- ... l"- .Imri-'.-l <1"" «iii, .,...% I..- ...i..i '"'Laif '-f "' "'i""'.v '"' «"•'"•-'■ -"-'""' ':*■ .„v |..T«.'.n a.-.int' .....l.r il- :...tl...ri.y. .Apr.- .,r im:.li.-.l. .....I i..;.y ... tl... -......• mat r I..- v:iri.>.l ..r .li-'.liarir.Hl- ,„i \„v .■..ntnul wl.i.h. if n.,-..l.' l..-tw..... i.ri>..t.- |..T-..n-. w..nl.l l.y la» l,..\ali.i ..ltl.....L'l, ......!.• l.y |.ar..l ..nly. an.l i,..t ml...-.-! .i.t.. »r.....i.-. „,;,v I..- ......I.' I.v l..-.r I.air ..f th- .......pany. l.y anv p.rs..., ... ti..L' ,„„'l,.,- i.- M.itliMlily. .'xpr >■ in.pli-'l. ««^ '"ay I.. ll a....- .i.a..n.r 1.. -■., Ml ,„„na.-.- ...a.l- .......nlinir f. tl.. •'■•" "I'ail l- .■tl.-.l..al i.. la" .1 ,„ttll l,i,„l t ■...»pa..y an.l il^ >...-.-.-».r... an.l all ...I...' paHi.- tl,..-,„.. .1,.., |„',i-- ,v... .it..r-. ...• ...I...iiii-lrat..r.. a.^ ll..- •■'"■ ...»y I"- i \„v .I.-.-.I I.. «lii.l. a .-..mpahV i- a partv nl.a In'M I- L" ^al..l > ,.x,, „i,-l ... S....la...l r ..f ll..' .•..n.p.iny if it i- .v.....!.'.! ... l-r.... . I M.' ,,„u.i.... ..I- ll.i- \.t ">■ i- -al.-l «i'li " '""" "'"' "'' '' '"' ■ ,,,l.,..l l.air..f .!..■ |.a..y l.y .«.. "f 'In- .li>-'""r-^ a,..l I r.-tarv .,1 ,!„• ....apa.,y. .....I m.. I. ...l.s.Tipti n l..'l.alf "f tl..' .■.."il.a..v -l.all I.. . .|i.:.ll> i.iiiilii.L' <>l..-il.'-. ;.lt.-t.il l.y «ilii.-».-....r ii..t, Tl,,- -...I.IL.M |.-.>v.'l. i' v^ill !"• ..I>-<''A''-I- .'I'I'll'- '"'''I •"n.|...in'" ,,..,,, I..,.. I ..n.!.'. ll..' A.l. .in.l I.v vii' I il ^'H -'i' I' '""'l'""'''^ ""' ..x"..,.l ..- ..■i;...-.^ ll..- .-..uli.i.l- .[..'.ill-l in -'It' ' ....... 1 u,ii -..I ri- i-"">- "'^'> •" ■""'■-'■ '"■ '■■"" ■"'■•' "' M-i"""' 1 • ill. Mill, l<■^^ -.1 ..-^.H-iali..!. \. ,,, „!„, ,. ., |....-.!. ...1...'^ 'M.,l.'i ll..' .'M'"-- " '■"|>'"-'' ,,„!!, ...iiv ,,i il... ...i,.|.,..iv .....l.'i -.,I.-M.,|. .2 .111.1 ■■■•' ..1 -<'.'li"'i Tl,,. „ill .|,.,M.h.l ... tl..' .irli.l 1 111"' .■..in|.;ii.v < H'n.'nill;. .,,..,,1,,,,.^ ,|„.,liiv, |..i-l...v.'.'S|.r.'-". ..,.|.ll.'.l.iulli..nlv int.. li . ' Stit. .17 »t A.'l of IHliT HI. t.) CM.n- lrH H"" „H,,. , ,,,i.t Ill-' ■. I.'»'."l ii.<'.'ii"'- ■ '" ''^''I'i-'' 'I'"' ^'i'll""i'.^ It III. 1.....1.1 .l|.fHOV.'- •! I'l'-"' ll"' ■I'l'-""- ..".''l.l.l.'.l I1..M. .1 ,,„ -ly.. ll ..il..- "< l"-!'^''' ■" I'' I'''"' l'"'-'<-"" I" -,., 1 I'li III M .. .1111.1... i.- .1.. . I..." l..t- l|.|... ll..- ,..11. 1.'-. l.-l.-.^.il.- llwH 1...U.'.-.. ... ..I.'. "I 'l.-'l" ' '"""" - ""'-'-""^•' "' .,„ll l,l.',.ll..'l ..I U..'llll...«>■' .■i'l«'i 'III" '■ -!»■*- -i»H-i<" " •■■■■'■■ aM ^liKKKJIKNTfi. ('1IAI>. V CAMtTVU wfthtmt - t oulru'-t ' behalf ci( ■• liiinbm; jniwi 1 t" il|i > l.llllfli' fH nil in;>'iii-. Miiilin ii- ' I Ik 'IT llit'ti' iIp ih'li':;illr M M ill.lllilir"! Ill , ,liiK ,iuilii'ii.'>''l |"-i- 2». Kii IIJ lU'Hi-iiiii'i \ Jin „/. .,1 l„.l ( iiMi'i I i\ I'. :j: 'A. Mill. ' imiiiii'ii Hi s ■ 't^t . ;>iin-lhme^l. ■|'iii' lr-1 Ml hIhii 1 liuliuu 1 ..iiit»a.m -»» "■' I ,,ll„ III ill. iIm.». .Ml,.. iii«-«i 1- •.•n<'ii Ml •«<<( H, !.(,.• I. I! it !• li;'i Mlholll M^- 'il \. !.• tiK 1 1.1 III « lii.i. .1 (..ii(i.i> I I' >/,/• ( '>ii l,..| liiir III ;i I ■Un- it.: 'ilk"': ^«|>! ti. Iic ^1 I iililliii 1 I'i'l niMMi \ l> .IPI'I \ I! ..: /, Im.M • Mil I III in !l '\|llt-- :| III III' Ml. I'll In-U 11' ..in' |>ai he .iii|iiiii .1 I 111' .•»» |m'' 1111 I I) lllf I'l ••!/( "* /•'■I'll ,1 I,, , „l, \-^'\;i\\ III • h" inlli;t,ii\ 'III' iitH« I •li,. Ii >niii-i t- ^j-ut^.tli .|,.|.'.| ti,' •ll'l- 'lliUI. 1.: i|lf\ ;ltr •'i|ll,lll\ »'t'i' Hl.ll .li/l/» \,.i,i>isit,l. I U .V N It Willie IM.l.l -1 inllllllll ill \- \-. !' Ill'-- ill ,\- ..I Ih. I. II 111 l"-ll:lll "i ill'' '"III A I. :ll|i| ill" .llU'ilnr- iliui*-' tl :iliv ■ ".si mi A I' 'Mwi ' n '■• ' .1 III wiiiit- — ulmrcui iiM 'h«' .I.IIIJ4U1!' "* n- lltlilai: lll'll'lllll'i -«" llll'l: IliMlil- (It . oiir»<' 11" u— iiiiit.t.iiiiu ■U'lll li '»•' .lltlM' I 1- -l^'tl^l lllll-l' l"> 11«''' '«! ' I '■Hi- ll Jl » 111 ill- ■■Mill- V 1; 1) 1.1 ti !■ I 'lltpillt \;.'l'Iit III! Il It.. ;l>r<'l|l 1- 11 lil-i.^ |'.ll'f\ I •• 111'- K'-lllll'.Kllllll 1 I lll-l' 1: H -I'll, will HIM A- «|l triii'- li.'K'i.i tin' .lav. /'/hc/kk'' .ii'*'i'/'(. '|ii.ilil \ III- -I'jii.iliii'' I'* |.ii'li\i llH- "iiin |i it i'\|i«iiit'iil. (I ii 11- a.liliii'J- villi- -li.nviif.; Ill- ,i:ii'M' V, |i 1- J iIkiI wli.'ii' Mil ii'j-i'lil I'lit.'i- iiil'i .1 1 mil I' 1 nil riaii 1 /' I. W"- . liii' li.iiiil- '.: III. il III' lliiiil> •iiliiii. ill iiiiji". ill. II I"' Mi.i^ .uiinl jii'i-.ihil i'--|iiili-l i.u --i'MIi'iI. llnwi'V.'l li.li.ilr 111' .iiidiIh'I. m -ll.ilin II. ,i,| 1 ,iti\ iiii.ilil'. iiMj u ii.l- In 111- ./<;/(.(//( '/ . ■ a.* :i;;i>lit In \ I! I" l.i'l.iill III .\ II III .1 nil ,1 A I! A I! ■ /',,/»,; 1,1./.- i: 11.' -,'.;ii- \(illi"ill iiiiilili'Mliiiii, 111' ,Hv li.il.li- I. Ill i' I .1 Mil - lull limlv .1 ill.' I'JI. ,ii iiiiim: 111 . Ill 11! Ill' iiiii 111.11 |. I l..-li,ili 11!, .; iiili'iili'ii. ami il III ill' , . .iMli |. I .1- .I'^l'lll." .11 "11 Imi :iii.iiIi.'|-, In- w ill 1— .-:i)..- Ii.iliilii\ "11 till' I "ll'l. I. I 1 K. It T'.'T i< .\ ' \lili"ii-li. 11 M'.; A I,;, 1. 1 \ U.,i,,jhli>ll. I Is Hi i> :iii. ' /' ifnuut \ ,'//(,(/-/. I I'll.'.! U'li.il i/l'.j, III' lll:l\ 1h' li.ili ilaiiia'-x's t.H liit'.i' Il 111 u>iir.iiii\ .i" In [ll'l iiiilliuiil) t.\illiii < «iM INTHOniTCIDRV N< >1 KJ*. •.Vir, ,\^ I" < 'km Aiiii kmi s I- ■tir ,.tili..llH . Ill .l,i- I "IIIK'' li"l' . I ,l> I III > III I 1„. \.i ..; r. • I,,-,. CHI !■'• "; '1 ■••iiiiM't. I >.||I Milill.: Illlll''! ,1,,. ,.\|.ri— "1 iiu|ilii • iilv ■■! I, ,,| I oiii-'- iiiiiiiin''i,i l'.>:! i|l,-. SlllIlK' "I ||,| III' liiillK' Jll IIIKI'I Ki.iii.l- Mill ill'' ^.ili' "I '■ ,1. Ill , I V. ; \. til Si itiiti' lilll .ijlll'.llull 1 1.1 llir I I I'riilil- \. 1 |ir..\ I'll'- aiil- . ritiilii ii: ;HH'lll<'lll-. tllll I n ii.itli' 111.11 aii-\M I l"i I -|H'i i.il |ir"iiii-<' lliii-c III uiliillirl |H'l'> ,|l- 111 l.llli|>. lilli-llH'lll-. Ill lii.|r.|il. -Ill- nl i|l:\ 111 H'l*".! 1 It ■ "I .I'll' ill. II ^ Ji'i' '' •t nmu ill'' -.1111'' Ih' p,.tiiiiiii'''l "iiliiii ;ii'' r lilt' III. (km;. I ilii'ii'iil ; Jl IKIII iliiiJf U' ln"«ii;lil 'I (mil ^1' li ti'iK'ii il l«. Iir,i>i-lil, III -.illlH' II till. |i_'l<'lMlll'lll I'l"' li.|||.ilnllilllill "I If -Imll tx- ill " li'iif- .1' .1 -i-ii . I \,^ til. i,|. ill. oatttct' ill t||lM j I l-iiU lIlfK'tllll' (ll- .(..l|ii|l 'iiil IIIMtll \,\ liitn I m liilU .iiillf' lIl'lllClll I II I, 111' ill'' -i'/ III- piiil 'I 1' ,i-f|tili !i»(il(i-.l Willi tin -lli.il 1." I.fii ,1,1,... Il.il -.t^ Hl.ll mill' llJllli I ~llil ni|iii«il" III'' I'J < • III ii|iiiii II |: XIII ll->!llr » llo'llf- " II |„. \.||||. 1.111 11I1'H'I\ lli.ii If .l,.t\i- '' I l.-iiiiii- V I (ll .SI 'I"'" .illi ••BTr.iii- ii-iihi ,U 1.. |. i.-...'iii •"•ti iiii|i"i I III' 1.1- ll.lll t, .llill.ilIX lllljlall\ ' 111 111 ik)> :i |>. IllU'itl I ' -111 .1 «l'tlll' I hill .1 •! ic .ii;H'<>llli'ii' ' ii'i .lil'il'i C'l li ' .i'" ' - I.lki'li ll ■h.' H' III .1 llii ,.,i,|,.>)ii- ii'.|iiii ll till f.l l.\ iIh- -1 ililli liiii«-i"ii tlTIIH'lll -lull'' .1 ll 1/ r ifi .1' iliil' ,iiiii.iii/<-.l .tiiii.iii\ I 111 |.,. iiiiiiliii I'll Till ll lIlC -l.itllli lia\i' l.i'fii ' Ill-till' • I nilli ui'.i' lllii'i.ii''^ mil' iiii'iiH'i 1 t lil» ilittit .ill' li. I ||l..\ ll.lM i'.-ll lll'l'i I lll.lllJc in\ \vlill<'l' lili-llliilllli'lllll' ir ailllil--l"li if lilt' I. ,|„'-l,.', III...I" l..>r..r.< or iill.'r Hi' tn"'. |.t"v>'l'''i „v ...fii'ii lii.m'.'lil Tliii- 1 iii"|'-.il 111 >uitiinr .,. I- iiiii.il' l'< ,.. ,||\ ll , liK'll lll'lil :i -lllli' l''ll' lll'-'ll' .,lh. I II .\ < tllll 1 n-jiii-i ll .,'/.. ^ .1- .tiiil.iiti .1- lii.iiii-i ill'' |ii" />;,/,-/'/ I. IJ I K\ .11 •llvi- lllllll llll' I' lilt llll'lllll'/ III'' '''l III lillU . ■III- 'illli' ii'lil '.tC I! N S K»:l iltv M I" I li:iii;'"l I" ■'" '-'■'" '" Ir « illl -.nil' tllll I ■J ( ll 7:i7 /iliiiii|ilv hI i'\iiUMiii' Tlic Ciuiil.' -iM Uowoii 1. .1 . in //...//<• //.-///.■ IK'.t.t 1 Cli !•'.•. l" Ji"l 111 «| lll-^l III' till' lllKMltlllll () I till ii(i<'«. Imt Dill I cxidtMiif mil III tl II' run liiiil. timt 111' liii- I'tiK'H'il ml" 1 li'i till I III 111 mil' 111 lilt' imrlii'- Aiiv ill" iiiiK'iil lit'iiiil 111 lii> atrenl i. urn Hii |> Minii'MMI It fill III' •I" I iiiiiliiinliiif till' K'liii-* "t i \ Sirc)'tiii(i. I In 1h !• ('. n N H4;i. a UiiK'i- III ;iu i»u^'i" "I' •'"• I"''-'""' -"iij:'' h.'lil -iiltuK'nl. ami hIu'IIioi il i^ a Ii'II.t In an aui'n' liiirifc il III a Irii'ii'l IK ininiati'Mii Su ul IMII III \ I /(■/<)/ Ml tilliriH'l Hurl.. -1 (/I! u .in "111 un ajrvi'i'iiK'iil rta.- mallv niai in till- tl•l•lll^ III 11 •■••rtaiii ilialt. it "a' of iliici Inf.- ^it'iu'il h\ till' iliaiiniaii (ic lictwci'ii llu' |ilaiiitill ami tlii' n.niiiai.v liclil that il niimili' "f ill'" bnanl ami rcl'iM'rinir 'i I'll iltnt'l, ami How til comply witli requin'mi'iiti of Htatute lut ivfrardH paP' agrt^-iiipxit. #'^ I'.-oh thai il III' i| ami -.itriicil. was iiltii ii' iiliiin williiii till' Mlaliiti' It rdlltl'lli .-i^tiatii till II' 111 llic iliaiiniati In tin' iiiiiinti"- "a- li'ii ill tlii'^ ia>i' lliat llir i';i| ill Uili'l In ' i'ril\ iinii ri'iliii'j:> I I hi;: mil 111 nr ,1 till' liuaiil ill iilii'ilit'iiii' III till' ('iiiii|uiiii'> \'l ilcr to aH<'>t 111' vcfil* tin' rimtrarl. anil llial th.. .simiaiiiH' »a> i.iil „li„ i„l„.l„ il i-imlil iinl l»' availal.i.' loi tin- ,,ui|,.».|. 1.1 .-.ali-lvinu 111.' Staiiili' "I Kia.i.i» I'-iii tli- (•..nil IhM thai Ih.'i.' «a> 111. Iiminlation loi lhi> luiiU'iitinn Wlial. ^.ii.l !.lt^ll. L .1 . uhii ilclivon'il jiiil«:ni.'nt. ' is llii- Inn an a-MTlinn timl'" the haiiil III till' .i.ini.anv ••< ain'nt that ihi' ..iiiiliaii> lia.l i-iiK'H'iI tho ajfHM'iiii'iil "hi'li "'i- I'Hilain.'il in th.' diatt i.'f.'iii'il til- th.' iim'Mi.in is put what il* ohjo.t wum. Iml «li.'lli.'i it i- a «iin..n anil .-iiiii.'il siat.'im'tit m tin' .iMiliait ' S.'.' iil-i ifi,r.;,M».t. il ■ ( i, . > IH'.Mi ;■. <'ll IHI. ami In.liilhs r,„lr ( ,„ ,„„,il .';> v Ihimh,-, 1 IMlt'.ii :.' (^ I! II I TiiiLs. -ii|ilii.».' that ^1 ...nil'aiiv il-.-ii.'.- i" | I'a-i' .• |m'^-.' <•! I'l'"! ami llial Im -mm' i.'ii>"ii il f .■v|'"-l>''i" I" ' '" '^ ""' '"■i"^"""' tliioiii'h liv |.ai..l auii'. nl. ii «iiii I"' '' ''"'- '"' ''"' ■* '"' ' u,al^.'"a |,i..|...>al ill uiiiin;;. ailiiii' I tn l!i.' ii.ni|.anx. ami li't llu- ,lin.it..i> |.a>- a i.-Mi.liilioii aiithnn/iim m I lh.ii 1m..I\ m ai..'|.l >m I. ,,|-,,|,i^>al i.n i.i'lialf ..r thi' inini.aiiv. ami l.'t liim a.-i i'|il llm -.i i.ralh. ami l.'i him ,MlN*..ii.i.'iitlv i-'p-ri in wiilin- In tin' n'lnfaiiv th,. la.t that h.' has Diallv ai r.'l.ti'il llm r...|-s''l "^ aiilhnl i/ihI. ami h-t Miih 1.' t I"' ■••'"I '•< " •""""' '" '"- •""' ' '"'■'"' '" ''" niinnl.'- I- ill.' ii"*nli th.'i'' i" '• ^i'li'l "-ntiait. sati-fi inL- ih'' r,.,,nir..n,..nt> .if ill-' Siaim.' of Fiaii l.«. «hi. Ii.'v.'i j.ailv ha-^ oiTas,..,, 1,1 iih on il fill III- l.ri.j-K'^al lhn> mallv a...'|.l.'.l i' a miIIl nnt ,H,.„|oiamlniii a> a-aiiiM ill- M'mh.r i /^»"' * /'"'. "'.'/. v"/""' •""! , ,,rain-l Ih.' .i.ni|iaiiv ill.' niiniiti>- -ho« llm anlhrnitv of th.' a-.'nl . hi- li'ii.'i i- a Milfiii.'iil I lamliiiii -I'.m'l I'V th- ioiii|imiiv - u.v.'iif '../"«.» ^ ll;lUn,.t. \. H I < 1" I ■'""" ^ 1"''"' (In^run, /<-»/i -J <,> I! I» ■'■■;••■ /'■""'-■ ^ '/""/'• '«•''" " '■'' " V»,.w /..-..' .1. <■<> ■•«••" ■■' ''•' '^' " '"■•^ '"' "''''"'' INTROnUOTOKV NOTES. ,,„„ „ ,,ron.«.al Ihus orally u..,.,.i.mI ..Miui..- no Hm.np. S.... ,„/,,,. its \.. -ral ur,*|.laii.^ -f .'IM- ol l.w.. all.T.iativ...s roiilain.".! .u '.' uvittvn oil...- ...ak.>.< a., .-nf..., oaLlr ...ul.a.t a. UirainsI iIm- u.it.T. ■/,„.,•, X Knllhr, .I'.ml. I CI.. M-l I'"" )»'.l'-rn.au.,. ,.| an ..ral ;„„,,,, ,„ ,,.|l laa-l ...ax tak.- .1..- .as.. ..»l of ll..- S...t..t.. "I !• .au-ls ,/,„./,,»«.» V H«rro,r. .l'J04. :.' CI.. :WJ!.i. provia.-l sulI. |mH ,«•.- „„,„„„,,. sliall Ik- .......,..iv.«.ill.v .•.■tV.ablo to tl.o r..i„.ar, M.lrrso,, . »W..V.^„». S .Vl-I' Ca.. 1.:: .\s tu liliMir ,.a.ti.nla.> "t a., oral ,„„„,„, ,„, ,1,.. i.,s,H. ..t pai,l-..l. tor a ,-..„- :«I As to Stamps. All/ II mill Sriil St«mp«. |.;v.,.r«l..-.rn,lH.,«.s..,M,.x„l...ll.x .l.-S.a A,-.. 1 H-. I , A , .V .V, A^.^....;nr \„i r ,!'ti ail auiv.li. i.i vxriiiiu' mil iimlir »«■«/ .iiIimimI into l>v ^.^, ,„. „.|,alf ol a ...inpaiix i;.M....allv ■> .....l.-r tl..- lollnxviny: l..-a.l- i,„.. i„ ,1... mI,.-.|..U- lo .1... S.aii.r A,.. IK'.M: ' At;..-.-,,.....!, or a..x .,; ,a».l..... of an a-..H-m..,i.. i..a,l,. i.. K.,ula.Mi o. In'iaM.i .....I.. I,, M.I oi.h. or ii.a.l.. ii. So,|,,i,.l. «i.l...... ai.x .hLrs.- ol ,vj:..H..al.o.i. .,„.| „ol oll...r«i«. K,..riti.all.v .ha.-,..! will, anx .li.ix wl.P-h.-r tl..' Ka.M.' Im- onlv ..vi.l.M..-.' of a .o.ilra. I. or ..l.lip.toiv upon .!..< l.a.ti.-> f,. ii, JH.Jni: a «ril!.-.i ii..siniiii.'iil , aii.l a. .or.lii.ulv ..•.p,ii.>- a <"/ ii^rr.'oiiKMil .•itaiiip. ... lU ....t - o- ,!,.• .sa.,... A. t. i. i- p.ov.,l...l .l.a, .h. .lutv o, ..,/ ..p.M, Adl,.^...- ,.„ air..H..ii.-n! .nav U- .l..no..-l l.x an a.ll....-v.. -la.Mp. «l...l. .- «'• I"' .an.vll.Ml l,s 111.. P.MM..1 l.v whoiu tli.> iiiri ......I i- li.-t .•vo.iil.'il. Tl,.. I11.-I.. ol .an.,. u » pi..>..il..'.l l'^ -" ^ "' ''"' ■^''- ^^'J^!^ II. nil. In : ll> V„ i„..,nn,(i.l tl... .l.ity ..|...M «l.i.li i" r...i»ir.-.l ..r |" . mitt..! I.y l.i» . I» tHni|i. iiii >«■ siam|> i» i».t to Im. .I...I.I...1 .luly Maiii!....! Iix. till' |».r-«iii roi|uiroi' I.*" ■ii«M til', -tuin)* iir iiiilial- .if 111" Hri". l.V'l"'r »'•'■ 111., trill' .int.. iif hi., m. wril.inr. Ill ri'mliT" till alil.. of U.intf ii«iii|h«... or .ml...-, it i" otli..rxvi... pr..ui llmt til." utainp a|ip<.arine <>i> lirnp.'r tim.. he in.laiii|i- ar.. i>«.' or i-.i.rv .«lMiii|i I to il.>n.iti. ill.. -Iniii) "lii<> to li. .■11. fl ill till* ii..r afor.'«ai.l. :i, |. II \|.rv |M-r-i wIhi, tK'tnir ri'*|iiirinl I l.v law to lan.'ol an BiUionhc i.tumi> n..«l.'it'< .ir ri.fii«<.« .luly ami ..ff.Htiiiiily i I, .1 I li T'iil; \>* T I- •< '•'•" \lliril Uiil.iii'iii Stiinii'liiii ( Ajir*-*-!!!! nt I mill S,;il A foliliilil illiilrl -fill. <'\<>'|il lIlcH- ..llH'lwiM- ((KlvilltMi 1)\ ill- SUiii|> All, \K'>\. I- "'"•' of uu^ kiiiil «liul-i'< il"'> ii'i'l''' ''>•'' •^''' "* " .1 1 ill-. iIUnI ill llii'>' Ik'iIiiIc. (• . II r«'i|iiii f-ii ia Onil >»ct, lH,.f Lii uihI ayiifiiH II prfipuftul not. Oral. ,. ,,l i.-i', r.'.|iiii< - ii" -l.iin|i. >><"' .uill\ ,i..i'|iliMl -i... v,(/.r.i iliM'- ;i IIMM III vt Mtlii; l;r||.,'IIICIl( "I- 11" llllinilK I'll sll 1. ;. I )|'0|tO-,l| I- iilx .-,1 ■iiiir " ,.ii,,. <.| it iiiiiiiaii Vlil! .1. illnllllllH'lll liiiii .' .Ill iiL'ti'^'iiii'iil. "In'tli"'' ''" .ililiualHi V ii{ ill' I "•' I h, I III \ . lilniill. .t H A I lilill. III w lii< II. >ai< I. Till- "a> a itii'K' |)lii|ii'^al liu.l ■II an-i'iii (hI Ii\ \\ I ai'i')-|ili'■ ' «'l. I'll' l"i"- \.i\\ a (laiol ,il;i<'i'Iiiiiii au;ii'i'liii'iil v\a.- in .1 i„ I ,„l,ll V ' ,„/-../'. S»/.,/.v /(.(/' ' iliiHlii'l Ills iiiiiis III a |ir..-|ii .1 K\ -il'l- "Ill'K' •' rill- aii'l a ■.<•! I'al rll.r.ll iliai I W.I - II I I tli<'iiiriil. ami llial ii' i*.<|M|iliii;r iIk' |>I"|" iilmil slaiiip "I- iHsc—arv |iiii|iii^al ami i •' 'I'lif ilclcmlanl. ,1 ami >i .mill- 111- -nil' I" ill'' s'li'.'il. iiialii- n ■ aaiHi.iiii 'l""s 11"" i<''|i'ii" '» -'""'I' "'"■"■ l,..i|.ir » iiii'i'' |iiMiiu.-al ill 111'' lii-'l iii-lamr, H all'-rvvai llllMllllL' II.' ll\ .-II lll'lll liMll'l \ Milhii'ih. ^ Id. I'. I I'aik, ,lr. Jl I! N (i7: ami /I'l /(•> v /•„ ,/,•//. 1. H I K t »2 It V Wl'l I- * !uMijini-, \»". \"ii;i Act, !»«.!«. h9,.1 Aijreemcnta lor Sale oi Property. ; ,|i.. ( ,1- i-ai|.| liil.i-i'l li.^'iiii' A.i. ISS'.t „/ , ,( „/ .liil> ".1- iiiii"-'s| "M .'! .i-i>'''m.iil.s Klllf of UIIV pli'l'll p.. ^a^l' > III li ;i.s |i iM'M'd l.v .l.'C'l . I. Ill llii- U>. ami I" tu-ri. .V.l .if tlic Slaiiiji »u» )'uii-titiit<''l^ All. IH'.iJ ■ •'. I .V ■>'' \ I" .!'.•■ lll(> l'iill'>"ili (1) Vny iiailnul .It'l-' '■lllt'llt HI. Ill'- lit laiirl Ilk 1 'ir l'-'-l'i»ni uiiilrr .-I'al. >"■ , A. I, mIit liuii'l "Illy. "!■ '" 1.1. ' III S."tlaiMl, nilli iir »itli.iiil niiy '-lau-f re'ji'*lriili"»'i- f..r till' wli' "' iiiy .'liiitul'l'- .•.till.- ..r iiit.Ti'st III l>"'l' ,.r..|. l«Miy I rtv «lml»<.'>tHlr .11 III frri..,! Ill 11, V ■riv I i"|it liili'l«. •' 11 I'MiiMy -ifim'. "lit ' -I.Mk. "I • -. I,, n.lit:. iil». .)r ticrita:!'". I" .-hill. Ill' f il,.. I ml'.! Kink'il.'iii. '"■ l*i"«I-. 'viir' ■•. "r in;irkrtal>;- -isuriti.s. 'ir ;i>iy »lii|« of >''*"• t.r )i. .1. -Iiin . M |.r.i|.. rty «if or in anj '•'ii|i "i- »<■ rl, ikm. ,W,> Im' < li»rir>'''' ■'"' "•<»'' lllllv IM l>. i.) I.v 1 1.. |.iir- .1.1 if it »iTi' iiii :i< mill itiiiM yiiiii'' '"' -I'l' "f III' ' -lilt' iiitiri-"!. |.,M|itrtv i.Mitni'tiil iir :!(.' ..I I.. I..' «,lil. Willi, the |pllp!lJI«il- lil> I'iiill It" --ii'l iil.' ilh III. iliil V (111)- llilr -I" . I .if .11. Il .X. iMiil. I'lliiiii. Jiiil in iiin ..ili.r .ii»' uitli ill.' H\.il .liil\ iif li'ii -liilliiiif«, ..I ..f -i\|.. nil'. III. .1-1' iiijiv r."(iitrf. W lii'i' .|iit\ li» li»- l» illllv V (hli.l III ."11 f.iriiiiiv wiili 111.' f'.r.'L'.'iiiu' |.r..\i 111- ninvrvaii' III. •<• .ir lr.ili«fi'r liiiiil.' M lli'' (iiir. Iiii-. r "r 'iili iiui- iii«'r. .ir liny .illi.r | III lii» lii'liulf iir liv llii .lir.-.r ■.hall liiii'-fir th • ■" .i|».li |.iimIii. li.ili .if III.' .iililril.l ..r .lu'rii'liii'lil. III. '111.. .Inly «taiii|H. IliaV til Ilk iii.l.' ill llii- I'ir.'iini'.lii .1 111.' lu..'. Ih. i.llW'N all. .' . .hill! I..' -t inili|..l a.'.'..i'.lini.'!y . an. I tlir .u 111.' aii.l th I.I .hall 111' il.'i'ini'.l I..' .1 lllV .|.llll|.i I th. il \i.th r I r.iii.t'.'i' liil 1 "iilr ..I ..r ,li.ill alli-r ..r a Ml'. I th.' |.l'< i\ I'.tlHI. Il' I.. Ih. IMi:. Ill Ihl. .lami.iiiL' .'I' It ' ''11 • riiinfrp ulliT ill. .'X. Tiili.iii ihiriiif. :<|.'.l »l-.< llial 111.' "./ ituiy I'ltiil II)... I I .iliV ..I c-ii -ti.ill 11.' n-l iriiril I A 111.' r.>niiiii..i.iiirr. in I Ira. I ..I I' till' ...iilru.t /r.'.'iiii'iil In' aft.'rwaril. r.'-iiii.lr'l .»r aiiiiiiltiil. ..r f.n uiiv .iIIht ..I .iiti.taiit'ailv (.t'rf"ri.i.il .1 inn. .'iV.'it 1. I.. II.. rait' a.. ..r f.ill.iniil hv. a ..iii\ ..111.' Irali-ri .U lii^ Il . .Ill i t.. I ill' utii |i| .|i.'l I \ . ISllll llll -I" li'lll l ."I'.l '. I'X. <'|1I|..||. I.| riili'ii ii.j'H'fiiiiMit for ( '..uKtriictiuu .1 .1 llir ;il.ii\.' si. limi. iimjUIH" In I i' sI.iiujh'iI II ■.i|ii--i - I I I ) well' all I. Iliji . ..IIM'Mllll'l .11 Mill' III till' I'.liilc, iiilt'K'.l 111- |i|-.i|i.'ily loiiliu. I»}.1 or .1 1.1 I,,' ...ill llll', llll V ..II . .lUM'xaiiU'i All. In;i|. Ill L's li,/ |H.| I rill . ami mi mi |ii.>|ii.i limi. Iiii W.l.N lixcl ll\ llll 111 .S'liiiip l.\ 111. riii.iiiii I'Mi'.i III .\i'i, llljll, till, ilutv uii.-" i|...il.li'.| .S<'i' .('.I 71. 'aIui 11 |iini.|.". ;liii llll' ^.llll iliiiii". rli.iriri mIiIi' iiii. I. 'r llii' iM'.nliii'. 'MIM'Xaili'l' nil ...11 ll.lll.ll'l' 111 iiiix |iiii|i(ri\ III llll' III-' .. iaijuli I., ill.. Si iiii|i All IH'.H III this |i,iri "I tin* .\i I 'I'li il.. 111.' iiiiii.i|i li \, ill 111 lul.K' tli'iM. ..jii ilii'il III Hull 1 \fS. :mO AOHF-F.MKNTS. rCllAI-. V, a! ^i (I*. •choelulf, |ii..vI.I.hI llial llii.. wmIJ. .. hIiuII ii ■! iil'l''^ '" •' '"'*■ anG« or Irai.M.T "f ui.> sl.xk or murk.-Wl.l.' Nonirili.w a< .l.-tii.-l l.v Mxt. IL'U' «)l iliiil A.I. or 1" uii> <..in«'\iiii( trim^lfr »li, i. the iiiiioiiiil .1 uilii.' ol Iho ...iwi.l.'rulic.u I..1 lln' lali. .I.h I <'N""I .-.0(1/.. nriil iIk- iiiMlriiiiHMil ...iiKiins a Htui.Miwul .•..rlifviiitf ilml ih.' traiiwi.li.M. llion.l.v .•ll.-.le.l .I-- »<'< l<>'ir. |."rl -f tl... Iiiru'- M...,- anion nr -.1 lli.- -oii.-. of lr.uimi••' »l"''' ••''' ■" "" 01 Miliir ..1 III.- iiL'HH'KuK' '>iii'>i>'H '" vulii.' "I III.' ..m.M.I.-n.U..M JiMi"**.!.- Mill/ Willi I.'I.'IVII.^- K. 111.' lll"'V«' «<'.I1'>II-. H iiiit.v '"' '»iivt'iii.iii !■■ r<.ii..i«|oi ill .Ifiiiil -"iiK' "I" ill'" wi>i.linft — "Mftde in England, Ac. H i'' i<> »'<• «>..«<<• tlm» tho a ,,un'..n..-ul »:.-' - I- i" KnirlMi.l in- lii.linir Wul...] »r Ii.'laii.l ..1 >..>iUiiul." . . , Wli.'r.' a .0111. M. 1 i.« ..,ll^lilul.sl l.v oll.r ..m.I a..-..|.lam-.' U .- i" !»■ ,„k,.|i I.. 1..' • iim.l.' • «li''i> tl"" a. ■ .•|.lan«« vn-l |.la.-.' Miille, .( r„ . M„r,„nn,r x l,>l<.n.l lie, ,r. liHMI. I «/ II .'.to. ' I" mv .-pi ..i.M Mlliii- I. •• ill '•>•" '•""'' " ."III""" ■•* """'*' "'""" "" „„,.,.„„_ ..I ,..,1 V.l «!..... il...si;:„aliii.'..l I." la-l i,.-."'-arx yMU 1- lllllM'.l 1 1 II \„.l ..|""' ''IT"''' il"- ^"■« «■" |.r..iM.Hi.r.-.t ...rr.'.i l.v il..- II. ..1 1 l„r.l.- h,Un„l I! !»„■ V sum,; .( r.. . I'.M'I' A. ( . 217 \, , ....linirlv a . ..i.lia. 1 iiia.l.' al.i..a.l «:» IDI l..ii. IhmI l.v iIm' m" H'". „„,| it «a> at ...,.• Ii.n- .1 .........mil praci.-.'. in nr.l.'r t.. av.i.l ih.' .lun. ... ,..,.o. I,.... .. a.. .-...• .sal., in -.,.„..• fo...jri' l>l^>'^'- "y" «'"'"; ,h.. .....,,..rlv ... I- H,.l.l .va« «li..llv ..r in |.all within ill- I m"-' K„„nl I.... ..a... nmili' al-«"l '"■ '""I-'"' '•^'' "■''.;"' 1„ ,;,, 7 ,.(■ .1... I{..ui..... A.I. I'.M.'.i '.. K.hv. :.. I.e. i' >H 1""V'- '"I ,|'„„ Tl... In,, la.i..n ..I «" » :.!».•• 't"' Sl.....p A.t. IH'.M wl.n I. "lal..- ,.,.r. .in ...nl....l^ . Iiaiyoal.!.- f.-r .1..' piir,...-.- -.1 -lai,.|. .I.iI.p- .^- ■•■ ^„^.,,„,.„ ,,|,.i t.. ..mtra.t*' aii.l u.^rr..,.ni..nl« n.a.l.- m K.ul .„.l, „. .S,...ta..,l ►iiali . •"; '•!'• -''■' For the sale of any equitable estate or interest in any pro petty whatBoever." It lm> !«•<•" l'-''" """ " »....N ..i.'an - r Jl,.' -.1.' ..I an .'-,..,/..'//<• .'-ta... ..r i..l.....M »^ ,lis.,.,._n,i«li.'.l li...n 'I" l.,„t o,„„ in..'....-. »■<-' /-""-'"" >■'/"./"•"'<• ^ '"/"'"' "•■'•'•""• , |«..8, •> •<"/"' F«'l;,l,- V /»/,..'./ //' '"• , I 'Ml I I <^ It -J.".: Tl„..« if >l..' a-. nt i^ f- 111" ■*'«'<^ -'' ^•" <"1'"'^ "' •■'" 'I"""" „„. „,/ r,./..r.'.« il.itv i.s. .1 I."- » ''"l-l- l'".^"'-'" '•""••""= "7" " ""■ ,,r..|H'irx I..' .-it.. IK' .iiT'"'-! ^'•"""'>' '' ' " ^ '"'"'"' '•'■''' (IH<.iH>:.>V It III 4f ^ INTKOUl!«:rOKV NOTM. 341 ill.' Ir|;.(l .V.I.H.' "liall I"' It'll .nil-.litii.liii>: .umI 111 (iiitiild.- »»»UUi „„|» r„ii\.\.Hl. 111.' " ili« |>ui - ,Im.-.i ihf ..piii'ii 111 .vrlaiii I's.'ius ul lakiin: .i .1... laiulioii ..I liu-l ,1.^1. ..I i.l .1 ...iiv»-\uii.^' ul 111.- I.«p»l .-I"!.. .l.H!s II..I milk.' III., aitrt-.- im'lit ..iw I'-l ill.' ■*"l«' "'■ '"' <"|"llul'l<' illK'n*! ..iil,\ » «"< l.'indnu .s„H.hn,h V hihuni l<,r,i;i,\ .iN'.tHi :.' ^^ U. .••: Lands, tenements, hereditaments and other property locally situate out ol the United Kingdom. In Sim-n„i <> <>l .i'lstrnliit , /„/,.»,/ H.'rr,n,r. IM-JT' I <^ H i'-'- !• »"« ■ <»nl.'ii.'rl> l»"«ll.\ -iiliiiiH' ..111 -f ilio I nilt'-l Kiiitf lll<'> .1" 111'' "'"•.I- lilll'l-. It'lK-IH-'lll". ll.'l.-lillll.l.'llW ,.r lioiilaK'.'-. all ..I ttlii. h .i.-ii.)!.' kmI ).io|MMi\ ...iirlil !.■ Im' . ...i-imi.mI ii> iiM-aiiiin.' |.n.|M'ily ..I llu' sani.- kiii.l; aii.l I...I.I FMici. M » '"'I l.u|K■^. I. I . iMii. n-a.l; l.iit HiL'l.x I. I . .oiiwi.l.T.'.l that tlif «..r(U ..iiu'l'l "<>' I" •"• ^" lii">l<"l. aii.l 111.' .1." i-ioii I.l ill.' lli.ii«<< »i Li.ril-. ill /»'in\ ' I'.Mll • A. C. 1'17, i« ..l.vi-.ii-lv in. ..ii-i-l.'iH "illi -mil .1 rc-triiU'il loiiHini.lion .'I' tin' wor.U In il... .a>i' la«l iiicnlnm.Ml. l.iinlli'V. I. I . «ii.l I'll'' «"i.l- laii.l-.. i..m'iii.i.l.- ami li.'i<',liiaiiifni> ' iIi.'iiim-Im- .'\liaiiM i.'al |.|..- |H.||\. an.l til.' iiiii.hIii. ii..ii allc. lli.'in "I lln^ «"i'l |>i.i|i<'il.V ►li'>»» ll.ai .-..iiM'lliiiit; in..i-.' i« l« \h> .•v..'|.l.-.l N'-.lhiin: r.' .an I..- ^ii-- -.■>if.i «lii.|i i« ,iinil,„i ./<•("<'•" an.l iiDlliiuu lull |i.'i«>>nill |ii..imtI\ r.'iimiiiN." Locally situate, *c. In Siiwllinn Co. ,>) Awtnilui \ ( nm- «„.,-„,»,;. .,/ hiUii.i H,r<„,ir. IH'.tTi I if 15. IT-', il ""- l'<'l«l il"" ail ani.-.'.n<.nl iiia.l.' in i:n«:lanal.' . f a Nliar.- in a jiat.'iil ifiantcl ill N.'w Si.iilli Wale.-* anil a k..U' li.i'ii.i' l.> ii-..- in a iliMi i. I ..I ■tial ...I.. in ill.' iiu.'niion (.idUmLmI l.y ill.' palt'iil w.u* lialilc !.. .«/ .,(/„,,■." .lulv iin.K't III.' N'.li.iii .III lli»> (.'n.unil llial ill.' |.r.ii..'itv «a.> 1101 |.|..|M.||\ |.>.all\ .siliiai.' ..Ill ..I III.' Ini!...! Kin;.'.l..iii I...11I K.,.|i..|. M U , Ml liiul i'u.w wa> i.r ii|>ini.>n thai lli- .xipi.— n-n l(..all\ ^iliiali. 1..11I.I ii.>l apply lo M.mi.'lliinn wlii.l. .. iriilli ami in la. t ha.- ii» |.M.,lin 11 may U>.' «ai.| lii> l..ir.lHlii|.. lli.il lli'''<' .11.. .liallcU ol wlii.li it may faiily an.l Irnly U- pi...|i.uli'.l liial lli.'y ar. I... ally .-iinali' ..ill nl iht' I ait.'il Kinir.|..ni; ii i" m'l in'..'-'»ai v I.. il.Mi.j.. that il Im' si, I will ivt-iiim' ii II a . Iiall.-I i-i a pliNM..il. raiiL'ilil.. iliiiin. wlii.li .an Ix- 1.)ii.1k'4. ttiiiiU. 1)111 tlic pnip. ily Imtc in .|i|.-li 'nM nol I"' l - whoro • This decision was roforrod to in the arfrinncnl m hiUwd Ucu'ii,,. V Miilh-t d Co.'s M„r!,"r;nr. a901) A. V. 220 as an authoritv for tho proposition that an incorporeal rifrht can havp no local situation: l.nt Lord Davoy said that he .lecisions in the j.rol.ate cases." See Attonip,,- Geiwrnl V. ll,nu;;,s. 4 M. >V- W. 171. and in the saue case Lord Lindlev said, referring to the Sm-Uh,,, Co. of AuMralhi v. IxUnul licvcuu,: x„,»». -I-O"! F>h.'r and Lopes. L. .1.. consniered that incorporeal |.ersonal property conld not he sai.l to I.e situate any- where. This is. of course, true physically speaking, hut noi. I think, in couteni|dation of law.'" , i f» u In Dainihuiii Su,,ar Fartork.s v. liihml Ihn-pmw. (1901) 1 y. IV •'4 the attribute of localitv": and in th<" same case Lord Lin.lley said; Coodwill i- e, 82 1, T ilS'.t Goods, Wares, or Merchardise." ■ri,o>o words include electrical ener-v. Couiitu of Durham EU-c- ,n,„l hmer DMributhw Co. v. Inhnxi U,-ve„uc Commrs. (I'.tO!.) •1 K. 15. (104 {,C. A.y ■riu-v do not include li.xtuK's. uide.ss a.'tually s^evered. Lpc v. i.iidrll. 1 (^ B. U- """■ llol)""'!^ (iiirrivqr. (1«'.»T> 1 <'h. IK^. What Law governs the Interpretation and Operation of Contracts. 1„ framin- a contract it is i.i some cases material lo consider uliother it is or is not necessary or .le.sirablo to make special provi- sions as to the law which is to jrovern it. Of .ourse, if the contract is made in En-land hetween a company , isteretl in Eiifrland and some other poison or persoi.K also resident ihere. and it provides for ,K'rforiimn.'e in Ensrlaiid, the law ol i;,i-hiiid will apply; nnless. in(h>ed. there he some provision to the coiitiiirv in the contract. lint cases fretpientlv arise in which the circumstances are very diitereiu. Thus, some party to the afrre<'inent. ef).. the vendor, nmy he a forei.r„or or an En^jlishman resident ahroad; the suh.ject- nmiter of the contract mav l)C property situate ahroad. or share.s. , c.iicessions. patents, or other i^s.sets constituted nnder s„mo lornin;,, \■^^^ ■ iho pcrforinaiut' of the contract may have to take place ahroad. ,s «here property is to Im delivered or conveyed ahroa.l. or where services are to be rendered ahroad: or the coniract may happen to Ik. nu.d." ahroad, as where ihe conii.any hy its ay:tMit enters int,. a (pl>, and slight indications of intention may tuni the scule and suffice to determine tlie (juestion. Thus, when it is u (luostion which of the laws of two countries apply, and the contrai i t-outains a provision which is valid under the law of one, but inxalid under the laws of the other, tliat circumstance tends to show tliul it was intended that the laws of the former sho dd apply. Missoiui Steaiiifhip Co., 42 ('. 1). 321; and see the ca.se last referred to. Iji Jacobs v. Crrdit Lyonnais, 12 Q. B. U. 599. B^wen, L. J., said thai ■' The only certain guide is to be found in applying sound ideas ol business convenience and .sense to the language of the contract itself with a view to discovering frcjm it the true intention of the parties Even in nispoct of any performance that is to take place abroad, the jiarties may still have desired that their liabilities and obligation^ shall be governed by English law, or it may be that they liavc intended to incoqiorate the foi-eign law to regulate the method uinl manner of performance abroad without altering any of tlie incidentn which attached to the contract according to English law. Stereotyj)etl iuU's laid down by juridical writers cannot, therefore, be accepiod as infallible canons of iutei-pretation in these n,. (1900) 2 C'h. «9». .\s to the rlRht of a vndce t.> restrain a ven.lor from soliciting his old customers, and othcrwis.! interfering with the goodwill, see note. Infra, p. 357. .\ .onvcyance of the goodwill may carry the beneHt of t-ovei.ant« not to compete l.y employes or a late partner of the vendor. Jiimh^ v. Wlnhnorr, 49 I,, T. 335; 'I'liiriiaciil v. .Jii,mnii, (1900) 2 Ch. 698. The sale of a goodwill by a trust.* in bankruptcy .•arries m> implied restri.- tioi, a» a^..i.„t the bankrupt. Wathvr v. M,.n,.»,., 19 C Div. 355: i»--,.« v. Bermli, li <'h. .505. .VffTeemeut for saTe. Parceb . a46 AflREEMKNTS. [Chai-. V, ii;t \ -5 Fonn 31 •^" *" '''" ""'"'■'»'•>■ "f expronnly mcntinninf; ffoodwill. kw Nr H<',i,ii'li . Il,i,l.. 1 V. in,:i,: (I«9"J) 1 C'li. 316. Till- uinouiit |iiiyiil)lc for jfixMlwill H one of tlic ))a^til•lllllr^< wliiili iiiiHt li.- statci) ill till' iDinp.iny's prospcotiis. ('iiiupanicH A lm|iositl(iii of ronJitioiiM on Hip »alr of a pati'iitiil artiilr, -.-, yiitiiuiiil Vh,ii„i,iy,ii,h Vii. 1,1 AiiKliiiliii V. ilriicl;. 27 T. I.. [;. a:!!!. I'lidcr sect. 70 of tlic Patents. Desitrnt! and Trade Marks .\(t. IHMU I 4ti .V. 17 Vict. 1-. .)7.i. a trade mark wlien refristered was only assiifnalile in roiineitinu with the hoihIwIH of the l>usines,s. See .1/ nioliu Mft>'l fn,ii/>iiii,/\ 7',.,,/, Mfiils, (1897) 2 <'li. 371. .\ii assifinment in ^ ross was Invalid. Th'ui.ii,,. \ Hill, (l«nn 1 Ch. .V!i). The aliove -eetion is repealed liy sect. 73 of the Traile JIarks .Vet. 1»0,5 (.i K<1. 7. e. l.i), as from 1st April, IWOli (see sect. 2), wlierc it is replaced liy » similar enactment (in sect. 221. with the foHowint; additinii; " But nothinfr in this section contained shall he deemiil to att'ect the riftht of the proprietor of a rcffisteriKl trade mark to assifjn tli.' riitht to use the same in an\ llritish possession or protectorate or foreign eimntry in connection with any poods for which it is rcifistered toirether with the (tooilwill of the liusinc., therein in such poods." See Kerly. Trade Marks. 3rd ed. 34H. Where a company purenascs an old trade mark, which consists of or iiicluilc. the name of the proprietor of the Imsiness, and the company has taken that name with the word " limiteil " added thereto, l<>ave will he piveii, under sect. 92 of the Patents. Designs and 'I'radc Marks Ad, 1SS3, now ii'plami liv Trade .Marks .\' t, I'lO.i, s. 32, to add the wiird " limited " to the trade mark (liiiiiiii'xx * t'li.'s r,ii,l,' Mail, ."i Kep. Put. ("as. 31(i. since followed in mvcimI cases: and see llnirii Clini, *r. Co.. (1892) 3 Ch. .5.53: see Kerly, Trade .Mark". 3rd e xvhicli the voiidoiv aio oiitid in coiineeliou with tlie .sd liusiiie«s. As to the meaning of '• plant." sei. l.tiiulnn (iwl F.i'kIi',,, C,,',,!,,'.',. .\c. '"■ > Cren^ev. (1897i I (J. B. 7fi8. "Plant" and "machinery" are two i|iMte different, thinps: per Kekewidi. .1., Rr Hrn„k,; (U 1.. J. Ch. 27; and /.'■ Niillpy ai-'l Fiini. \V. N. (1894) 64: rhnmi>m„ v. C/Vy '//"«■< llnllli- Co.. (.I9U2> 1 K. B. 233: and Stroud's .ludieial Dictionary. FouitliK, all till' book and ntlicr dolitK due to the veiidoi> in eonueetiou with liie .sii Im.'siness. and the lull iK'ueiit of all seeuiities for swh debts. A eliP<|ue or hill of exehanpe piven in respect of a pre-e\istinp deht operates as conditional payment thereof, and on the condituin heiiip performed by actual FORMS. 847 „,vni.'nt th- l-uymont rrhitcs b,„k to tl.r tin..- wl thr ,h.-,...- or 1..11 «a. ';;,.„. uml tl.orof..r.. wl...,. .l.-f-ndant ...1.1 t.. « .•..«.,...„>• hi. '-"-■'-"•; '-^'^''"tj , I.;H...„.l.or 31, 18H7. wi.l. tl,o gmKlwill, .t,K.k-in-trH. .■ .ml "all H«,k an ,„„.r .l..l.t. .1.1. to tl..- vendor in .■,-nm..ti..n with tl.o «.,.! l.n.n.™., ami th- f..ll . «t ..f all -curiti.-. f..r s„, 1. .I..l.ts:" an.l ... ..anuary 1. IHHS h«,l >n h,. „l.sio„ .ho,,,-. an,Klwill of tl„. sa>.l business and all th.- ass-ts of the vomh.rs in .■..nno,ti..n with s..,l. bus ss , hut it is ^-n-rallv .■..nsi.lor.'.l pr-f-rablr t., jriv.' son.- ,l,.tails. li. th.. ab..v.. ,.|.,„so all tl,.. assi.is .,f tl... v-ml.,rs in .tion with th,- bns.n.'ss ar.. in.lu,!,,!. |,ut so.notini,-s a s,.l- only .-..mpris-s -rtaii, sp...iH..d as.,.ts. .:„.. jt.H'n-tra.l.., ....ntrmts. aii.l ....- ■ragements, thus l..a^in^. tl..' vomh.rs the eash, bills, n.,t..s. l,„..k .l.'bts. \.-. S„nu.ti s ..vrvthins is s,.ld, " ex,-pt tl.o b....k .l..|.ts. b..|..nuMn.,r t., tl... v,...4, «.) rl "i-.f. I'r.i- bably n.u.h ..f tl... .ase law .,n the r..p,'al,.n..y. s..,. Sl.'r/.lr,, \ h,;.r,r,r/,, (1901)) 1 fh. (i7. Form 31. •Part of] the conson for the sd sale nhall he the sum of f (Niusideration -• *" J " ,, ■ » ^1 I- in f.ush and which shall he pd and satisHed a.s toUows. vi/.; .\h to the sum ol share* [and i: i„ cash, and a.« to the sum <.f £ by the allotment to tho dob...jn.js^ vendors or their nominees of. fully pd-np ordinary or preferencoj ^4,^.^-1 shares in the capital of the c.-y of £ each, to be nuinberitl to ^ inclusive ami as to the sum of i! by the allotnu (U tlicii- noiiiiuei-s of i— - dobcntuiox or (lebonliiio wtock] of the toy lan viug iiiteit>,st at the rate of pf-iia. us from tho - Jay of - J. If till' allotiuciif is to bo miidc to uomiiiir* a supplemental lontraet eoii- stilutiii(f their titl« to uUolmvnt should he made hefore ullotincnt. for it is doulitful whether u subscriuently made eoiitract eun " eonstitute " their title. The prineipal (K)ntraet and the supplemental eontraet will have to he filed with the Ke^fi'trar within one month after allotment (seet. H« of the .\et iil imW); in default the directors and other olKciala will incur heavy penalties. J.cKikiiiK t« sect. S3 of the Act of 1908, which provides that a company shiill not prior to the statutory meeting »ary the terms of a contract referred to in the prospectus, except subject to the ajiproval of the statutory iucetin){, it will often be desirable to give by the contract alternative mmles of satisfying thi consideration, for the udojition of an ultornative is not a variation. The eonsiderution is wmetimes wholly cash, and sometimes wholly paid-up. or partly paid-up shares (I'.ij., shares in the company of 10/. each, numbered, A,c.. with the sum of 7/. jKjr share credited as paid up thereon), and -ometimes wholly debentures or di-benturc stock, and simictimes part of the consideration is of each kind. When part of the .onsideralion is to be salisHeil by debentures or debenture stock, the agreement should I'ontain elsewhere a clause, as f7, and scut. 88 (1) (b), ^■i/im, p. 64. As to stating the consideration for the goodwill, sect. 81 of the .\et of 1908, -ul)-sect. 1 (,g , re(|uires the prospectus to specify the amount payable for goodwill. In view of this it nniy be desirable to add to the above clause tlic words, "Of the said sum of C llic sum of e - is payable for the goo.l Consideration i2b. Tli<> cousoii loi the .sd sioik-iu-tmdo whall be siiuh a nuiu as '"V-'tiNs'"" •'^^*'' ^' ^•'''»''i''«l ^y -^It'"-*"'*- "'' "^ '" ^"^ ''"^ ***"' ^'"''"' '''"^' "' '"ertai'uedby if any (liflicuhy .shall aiiso iu obuiiiiiiio; il,eii- cortiticatc, then a sum valuation. y^^jj[ ,y ,|jg f^jj. ^.jjim. „£ ^^^^.\^ ppty; .md so that any difioieuce in regard llieitMo .-iliall be referrod to the duciisiou of two coiupeU'nt valuers, one to be appointed by the vendors and the other by the coy or by Messrs. - of ], and the 8ubniis«ioii may be m.-wie an order of the High Court. The uon.son money.s meutd iu thi.s clau«e are huftr referred to as the valuation uioney.-*.J KOKMS. M» SomotiM..- tlu- .on-lderation for fh- .r,„.k-i..-trn,l- 1. .l.-alt with «.,,.rat..|y. '%;';" n' . pur,- «» " valuut «f ..ny .-..n.i.lon.l.l.. ,ul,j,..t-n,all..r i. in .nl..l .. - .le,ir«l,lo -o to frame tl.,- .m.tra.t that th.- valuation -hall l- " "Imliun to arbitration within th.- Arbitration A-,. .Km., otberw,.- «or,on, li.i-i and inc-oiivcnicncr may on.iui-. , . • » \ .r,...m.-Mt to .ell at a pri,-.. to b- «x..l by valuers is not a ,ubnu.„on to ..rbi.ration within the meaning of the Aet. for thcr,. i. no " .l.fferenee between p ties, ana the A-t only applies where the pa. ties I"'- a,ree.l o sub ,t ese or future dittcren.es to arbitration. r.M;.. v. Cfn... 2., ieav .U..,. \,.eordinirlv in that ease the Court refu-eil to appoint an umpire on the val,.ers , efault \nd «l-re the Aet ,loes not apply the C t has no power to app.unt L in the pi, of one wl„. dies. ..r refuses t t. or to re„„t the Mi.. «her.. a mistake has hc.„ n.ade. Wh..re. however, the a^reem.-nt .s U^^ as above, these diffleulties are avoid.sl. for if the eert.h-ate of t b. nam-Kl referee is not obtainable, the alternative provi-.on "r.se,, and anv i«er7.n" .oos t bitration. U is the more important to see that the Ae ■nlnlv beeau." ♦!! f e valuation has been elfeete.1 the Court eannot w.ll apply. b.H.au. ^_^^^^^^^^^ ^ ^^^^^^ ^^^ ,v„„„„.,w. •... Ves. .Jr. 4:«.: >/e.« V. r.VAe.-.. 4 Kn. .«»: :'•'/''•" v. >■/,«.»,(,, ,7 V. //«/■', 18 Cb. I). tiH5: see also Fry on ^,n, tiiaos the eontraet provides that th.- diff.-r.'me Ponn 31. enfor..' sii.'.itie i Mil.ie^ v. l-'i->!/, 1 ,Vc', ('«., 2t> Heu.. Sp.'.ifi.- I'lrform-nei •slmll b.' referred to ,,-l.itration as ber.inaft.T provided," and e.mta.ns the „. a.bitrn.ion .hiuse. J.f,.. p. 367. See also as to what i» " ;;'"<•"'••■ ,„ arbitrati.m //- v. IhM, I.. H. 2 Kx. 79: IM.„.'I v. S>,.M. .. « h^ -Is'/ V l'r>.;. 20 Kq .Ml: r«, ... inu,.„. 1« Q. U. Div. 7: //..« ' '...,.i ilCnlon-s .hh.'hnr.on. fi2 L. T. K(m-, and ll..ssell on Arbitration, »th .-d., ,,,,. It. 45. :,. As the .«si,l..o ,.1 ,1.0 eottso,. r..f ,l.o s.l sul... .ho e.jv shuU uuJor- As^-«^-;[ luko ,.. pav. siitisfv. .liseharfjo. ami fulHl all the debts. Imb.ht.os „ to „„.„.a...s an.l .n^^^^n^.n^. of the vo.uh.vs i„ relatio.. to tho sd undertate l,„si,u.ss. ami shall iinloninitv thoiu apiinst all pro« ,u,d Voke Co. v. r„u,.o, /In ,'/ ' "•• (1903, 1 k. II. 5W. As to stamp duty where puymer < are to be made a« ,.art of the .ons.dera- tion, see .S'„«y«.- v. r>i!>n,il Iterrwu: (ISOO") 1 Q. B. 172. ,, ,„ /).;,«,,7.-Tt is n..t .isual to re,,nin- a deposit when a new -omp-nv '- pnrehasine, Imt when a deposit is paid the purehaser In.s a lien^ .^f the I determined without p..reh Watt, (1902) 1 Ch. 836 Ridout y. Fowler. (1904) 1 Ch. 658. ■II' :j.50 AOUEEMKNTS. [Chap. V. Form 31. ComiuoiK^e- mcnt uf title. ». Till' lilU- I'l lilt" *il ln.'mliliiiiit'iil>^ mIuiII « oiuniciuo— (uj .V-i ii> tilt" * the "(l sfveiut It'iiMfholil liort'dilaiiiPiits. villi ihu imloii- liirt"* 111" k>u>iiiifii(k'r cm suU'. uiiil u sunoudL-r uii'l adiiiittumt' ucioril- iii)fl,v ill till- voar And llic luv «liall mil iiivcstiyalf tir make any ru(|uititioii a. . r|,t.-(l. I>ut oci'asioiially BpiMlul i-omlitioiis m to tlii' titli' ari' made, tliiir naturr mii»t 15: /'""■'/ >■ .1/""'"". IJ <■• l>- i:il; '■"• >l,„f .\rrr\ r;>r, (1«»1 ) 2 Cll. lOH; /!>■ Mfhil v„.l l-nl l\ C,,.,!,,,,!, ( l!l().')) 1 ( ll. .■J91: but u eondition that llie purehasrr shall not ,„i;-,IUinlo the prior tille UH above is I'tfeitivc, and |)reelnde-i muIi an olijeclion. //«'/(,<■ v. Ilr„thi. a lie U. \ S. b'i»: A"'. /'."'•. /'""/ '""' .t/"'»',, (IH«.i 1 Cli. IHO; Williams, V. \ 1'. 161. It i\uv* not, however, prelude objection in re^peet of a defeet diselnsed by the vendor. Smlll, \. It„h.„^;,>. ViV . \). \W. And if li.e pureliaser proves ti , the title is bad. or too doubtful, specitii- perforniamc' will not be ordcre //' -'■ S,t,n n„J .\h;ui\\ Cniihiirl. (189.)) 1 t'h. .Wo; ■• Cb. ti03: ll> IVnIhs >i„'l linni'U'r. V„„l,„,l, (1899) 1 ("h. 51.5; Kr llvijh.', iiiitl AkIiIii/k Cniilioil. (19(l(li 2 Cll. ")95. fiOl': Sii-lmh aii'l Vn,i Jnrl'i fnuliorf, (19101 1 Ch. 43. As to the etfect of losin;,' title d. <'U. see ll„r,l„.r i%.,P,„r,,i,fl I'-nol; 'ml 11'.,.., I. 47 W. U. 194. and Dart. V. \ I'.. 7tli ed. 1,W. .^1 •\'l,'„'l (Irninille, 24 (ll. 1). 17); but if he believes the assumption to be correct, he is entitlwl to rely cm the provision. Snmlhnch iiiiil Kihiwiiil- »r,„, (1891) 1 Ch. 99; lUnihriu v. A'/c, ,-. , 190(i) 2 Cb. 17.i. What iucum- brances. 5. The sd iHfiiiisos aro sold Irtv from all incnmlirancos o.xociit the mui'l or afrroi'iuts for lou.scs uuJer KORM8, U>\ liU'iitity of parrrln. Ill ^u „|,i, i, tho ^auw aiv hol.l. Mii.l us n^pinls th.- . ..pvliolils Mibjo.t to Fom 3L_ ,1,0 , u«l■■m^ ..I ll»' M.vt'ial lu^.iiois ii.kUt wliicl. lli.'.v aif lu'lil. hikI IS rotrur.N lill Mi.h luTv,lila...«nl.s i„ all ri^'l.ls „f «a.v. li-ln. un.l „tli.". .M-M.m.M.1-, if iin.v. alloctii.K llx' -ami. ivsplv. :iii,.■>>, (1»»3) 'J K. II. M. \. to till' iiHiiiirii". t.i I..' iniiJc » lii'ii tliv lii..rt>ra,r<' >»'»>' >« arr .r,, / .;/-,.,/. .IHW, ■> Ch. :i4i». C. Ni) liiitlicr nr ntlicr evidfiut- .shall l.c reiiuiix-.l «i tlin i.lciilil.N ol' ;„iv ..I llir S.I luModitaiaeiits with tlio i.ply to which title is >hown l.v tho alv«tiu.( Ix'sidcs siicli . fuiiiid lliorciii, the wiiiic. if , upald.' of r.imi»-iisaiioii. slmll iml aiiiiiil llio s„ji'. lait a r.iir . oin- I nation -liall In- allo«.Ml liy tlio voinlois in iv-po.-t llicit'of. U.«,iii.tio,i h.rc means diwription of the .-orponal i-roprrty, m.t of the title, /.'.v^.v V. .\Jn.,l,;H. 3!) C. 1). 110: l>,l„;,h,n„ v. S.,,rl„ :,/,,. , (Ktltl i 2 Cli. W. It ran, of eourse. l.e extended to the title. Smli a provision does not prevent ih.^ ■ ndors from avoiding payment l.y • •inllinjr the rontraet under a , Ui.se lilie 71.. ./././,.',„., V. S,;,;>l, (IS91 -31.. Wi ; Uart, V. .V ''. 7th .d. '77, 17H. I iider smh a .lans.^ ip.Misation may he enfoniMl ,.>/-■ eonvi'yan.v as will ashef..re i /;,/„„,■ v. .l„/,„..„: 13 Q. 1!. D. 3.il ; C/,,,,!,.,, •. '.'■,'■/,, 41 Ch. D 1(13); hut the words -provided the same is elaiin.Ml l.efore eonvi^yani-..." .an hi- ud.liHl. As !o tl Ileet of similar words, see J.r,// / „„'/ T":,l,„\ i\,„l,n,l, (IWMIi 'l Ch. (i2.>; r,i,IUh V. S„li, Oi»06j 1 Ch. 33.5. The authorities as to ...nditi. .li- as to .■.impi-nsation w.'re reviewed l.y liueklry, .1., in Jm in., v. Ilnrll. (19(1(1. •• Ch. H.iH; and see AV S i-h,'l mi'l fiiif" V,„il,u,l. liitd.'.! 1 Ch. 3,l„„l,„i„ \ •ii,„-\,r,ilii a «il.> Ik a lompaiiy. th.- aKW.'in.-nt d.K-- not ronfain Biiy prini«ioii a« f-> r.>.|iiiKiti..n« or .)lij.-.ti.mi.; ami wli.TO tin- titl<- i" u.-.rpi.nt («» ill I'Uuw 7i'. iii'rn). thin rliiii«- will Iw omittiMl. I'ow.rof 71, If tin. i(,v wlittll inak*' or j-IiuII in-«iMt] on uny reiiiiiitition or whTrl'Tm- objixtidii .».M to titlo. ronveyuu.'O, or othorwi^o. whioh the vomlors »UiM pBiiy pcr«i»»- If,' uiuililo, or on tlio prniiiwl of p\i«'iimo, delay, or otliorwinp. sliiill In objectionH. Im! unwilliMK to i^imiily with. tli»> voii.lors may. not\vitii«taii.liiij: au> previous negotiation or litipition, l>y notii* in writing determine thi« agrcomt Except oa Ui olaime i;ja liofl. without giving rise to any claim for oxpCDKO or other wine ] 111 the ia-.e ..f u -air t« a «.ni|.-ny. the ajfrwiiient very coiiiiiuiiily cmtain- no proviKion or clau-e a* above mentioned, for the title in many <•««•>« i» m- vontigated beforehiiml. and even when thi^ in not doi»> thi. elaiw i. . 3..M. but. in the other ease the power to rescind does not arise until the purchaser not onlv makes, but insists. See Hr (llr„to„ furl S'.;,ml.;1<. »>>i »«/>,". A power to rescind must be exerciswl within a reasonable timi- and in jtiskI faith. S> .th v. \\;,ll,„;: (18»,^) I (Mi. SHi: M.u^.l,;, v. ,SV,».-.", 28 W. H. 9,14; Qmni.u, v. Ilnriie. (19()6) I I'h. .59«. \ condition of sale empowering the vendor to annul the sale, if the purchaser m»ke» any objection or nvpiisition " as to the title, particulars, mnaitions, or any ether matter or thiiiR relatinir or incidental to the sale," which the veiulor is unable or unwillin^r to a matter of en the vendor, on D«emoer 4. 189fi. !fav,. the purchaser notice of the re«-is«inn of the contract, and offered to repay t.ie deposit, and it was held that no misrepresentation was made out. Byrne, .1.. held that the notice was in time. .iai 1 ■n ■ Hi •\ FY)RMS. :1V» I iiiat tifp |iur. hB..T «;i> ..Illy .Mititlwl t" u roiiirn c.f hi« do rit wilhont Jorm 31. ,„t.n.t. ami U< tlio (■<).»« i.f tlio ...•ti >n up t) tlip tint -.r ill ipt "f the „„lh.' I., rex-inrl. ni»l th.it lir iiiu-t |my tlir il.f.h.lant' , ' m >>» tli i» 'Ut- ^„.„.- ». •/■".'■./^ 0'*"*'' - '''■■ -'*''^- Hul)-i«t. li, MK't. 3. f the ('"iMey.iiiiiiitf »'i'l I-"* "f I'roiMTty Art, 1N«I ,K. n.it iiff'Tt the orcliiiary rii;ht of it |.ur. hii«'r t.> huv.- the titlu-dwdt hiiii.l. il vor to him mi .■i>m|>lcti..ii, aii.l thr mure f.i.t thut .ilitiiiniiiK tl, iln-dn for ihi- l.iiriio-i" may >mii-<- th.- vemliir triiuhlr and i\|)riHr U no miiw r to thi' |>ui lia^rr'a cli'iiiiind. On nil "\x-n rontrait the vendor must lu'iir thi' ux|)fM« of obtuinitiK t'tl'- .|i'f.N rf|iiiri>.l liy Ihti purchaser to bv hiiniliHl n\ir on eom|iletii>ii, allh'iiiL'M -uih tilh-dwc' are not in the vondor'a |io.< '''•"'"•■I. (IHltHj I (Mi. II. On till! ■'uli' of thi- loiHc of u |niMii>-hoU»r thi- (•ontra< t li id a iluy for ,,.in|ilption. and the plnintiff. the pur< hii.pr. paiil a di'iimit to the dofcnilani- ,« ntukiholdprs. It wan a tc-ni of the i-oiitrait that th.' ili'po-.it shoiih' l.r hrfeiiiil if thi- pur<'li».-er refu-i'd to piirforni hi^ [i irt of ihi aifr.cniriit. llii li date tixt'd for nnuplolloi' tin- M'lidor roininittcd an uit of bankruptry. •>: ioh ranie to tin' lotiii' of the punlia.'.iT, who th.'rpupon rofiiwil to I'oinpli'tr, ,11,1 ili'Uiiind.Kl thr return of the deposit; und the Court of .\ppial Inld th,.l •!„.a(rli ilii- lontrui't for sale wa^ proH'itoil liy seit. I!» of thr Itanlirupii y .\il. |i-3, till' a-iijfmni'i.t and the i>aynicnt of tlir puri'liasi-nnoiry, in i—rnuan. ■■ I the loiitrai't liut after noti.i' of the ait of Imnkruptry. would no. ■ u lii'.ii jriutei teil, mill that the pureha-er wa< t!<'refore not houiiil to loin . und II a-i entitled to reiovor the dopo.sit. I'u .. ». M"r>/irc'nii.'i>. , tin' vtMulor.s' I' vilm-. wlii'u |ii..^M>ssion of tho iiroiiii^os .^Imll. as far a~ pracliiiilili'. he ^n, 11 to tlio iHi\ , uud tlio coiiwon al'sil «o far n.^ the -aim' i «ists of .ash uiiJ wharc* and debontiires] shall In" lid and sati.^llod siibjocl to the [irovisiuii.-, of this agreemt, and thoroupon iho veiidor.i and all other iioeos.-arv parties if any, shall at the cxpou-c of the coy cxoeuto ai:.l ilii all a.«suranro.-i and things for ve-tinp; the -^d promi«os in iho e.i\, and giving to it tJie full benefit of this agreemt a« shall bo roa-sonably required. at the c.Mipli ti"ii "f iia«'. .\s lo the eostn of obtaining a mortgasfi'c's eoueurrence, bob Ifillelt and .In,, nil, \V. N. (1889) G6; 60 L. T. 73j; distinguished in .Saml^-r nnupra, Bowen, L. J., sa.d: Default .- a purely relative term, just like negligence; it means nothing more, nothmtr less, than not doing what is reasonable under the circumstances, no doing something which you ought to do, having regard to the relations wh.ch you occupy towards the other person interested in the transaction. Delay in completion by the day fix«l, occasioned by the t.mc occup^d .n remedying a defect in the vendor's title which was not and cou d "»* ^e "cn^un o him at the time of entering into the contract, is not attributable to a "default" on his part so as to prevent interest running against the purchaser under a clause for payment of interest by the purchaser "if from any cause whatever other than the default of the vendor'' t^^.P^-^^V^^f/.^f '^ completed by the day fixed. In re Wood, and Lew,, Contract, (1898) Ch^ 483 affirmed, (1898) 2 Ch. 211; and see Bennett v. Stone, ,upra. Interest will run if the real cause of delay is the purchaser's inability to pay. Loudu,. (Mayor) and Tubhs, (1894) 2 Ch. 524. And the vendor's repudiation of the contract by resisting the purchaser's claim to specific performance docs not Necessarily constitute such "wilful default" as to disentitle him to intcrct. VorM V Percival, (1898) 2 Ch. 128. See also Bav!e,j-Worthington and Coh.n - Contract, (1909) 1 Ch. 648, in which aU the cases were coneidered. !r' Consents of ImidlordsaKtii il-^ijiTIlUlCIlt of leaseholds, or ill default declaration of nn>t for <.imijauy. 10 Divers of the leaseholds specified in the schedule hto ure only assignable with the consent of the landlords from whom the tsiime resply are held. Tho vendors shall use thoir best endeavours to obtain the requisite consent* for the assignment thereof to the coy and in any case where such consents cannot conveniently bo obtained tho vendors f hall at the option of the coy execute a declaration of trust of the premi-ses in favour of the coy, or otherwise deal with the same as the coy shall direct. Where the sale comprises leaseholds, the terms of the leases must be care- fully considered, and the agreement must be framed accordingly. If the covenant is merely against assignment, a demise for tho whole term Uoss one day) is allowable ; and so is an equitable assignment (Gentle v. faM-n.r. (1900) 2 Q B 267); and if there is a covenant against assignment and sub- letting, a declaration of trust may be available; and if there is a covenant only against sub-letting, that does not include assigning. Soifle and Ham ' Contract (1899), 1 Ir. Hep. 113. But if there is a covenant also against part- ing with possession, very special expedients are required. FORMS. X limited i^orapany may be a " respectable and responsible person " witl.ii. „.e „ Ti ofaco Xnanf not to assign without the consent of the lessor (such 1° tTofto be withheld in th. case of a "respectable and responsible ;::::. irU,.0U .. lo^on noa, car Co., (1910) 2 Ch "5 overrul.ng 1 this ,K,int) Uarn.on. Ain.lie * Co. v. Banow-in-Furne,. Corp., 63 L T. 84^ V breach of the <^veuant not to assign, 4.c. .nay give the lessor the right to ,e:enter Olarman v. Ain.lie, (1904) 1 K. B. 698; Conveyancing Act 881 14,- ev-en at the suit of an assignee of the c,uity of redemption M. (1906) 1 Ch. 34 Production of a rKcipt for the last rent due i. not concUmve evidence that the covenants have :r..alrformed. m.hett and Bird: Contract, (1903) 1 Ch. 287; explained , ;<.„ fl,«i Dri,ooU; Contract. (1904) 2 Ch. 226. „ „ , , So action lies for refusing to give the consent. Sear ..Hou>e Property ami l,„.,.imeM Society, 10 C. D. 387: Ooodtcin v. Saturley, 16 T. L. B. 437. Where there is a covenant against assignment without eonsen and consent is ref«,«i on grounds which are not obviously unreaso. e the *'«<' ;' » -* '' forced on an unwilling purchaser. Marshall and Salt, Contract, (1900) . Ch 202. But the Court will not allow unreasonable conditions lo^^s-T AMey Garden, Fropcrtie,, (1903) 2 Ch. 112; Jenkin. v. Price, (1907) 2 Ch^ ■no- S C (1908) 1 Ch. 10, C. A. The covenant not to assign runs with the Zi Mc'eLJ v. Colton, (1902) A. C. 104; Woodfall. L. ^ T. (18th cd.> '53 ' Where the vendor induros the landlord t« refuse consent, the purchaser may have the contract rescinded and damages against the vendor. Bay v. .^.».'/"- ,„„ (1H99) " Ch 320, C. A.; dist. Peaie v. Coinfney, (1304) 2 Ch. 503. The Court has no power, under sect. 14 of the Conveyancin- Act, 1881 to relieve against forfeiture for ' reach of covenant not to assign or underlet. Nor can the Court relieve on the ground of mistake, even when an "'^'gn-ient or sul>-lea«e is made in forgetfulness of the covenant (Barrow v. /.««,, (1891) 1 Q B 417)- or because it i. thought to be unimporUnt. Eastern Telegraph Co. V. Dent, (1899) 1 Q. B. 835. See also Dymock v. ShoivelVi Brewery Co., ii T. 1-. B. 13. m-i Form 31 The leases under which the leasehold portions of the promises are l,old have already been submitted for the inspection of the coy, and acrnrdingly the coy is to be deemed to have notice of the .ontents Ihof.] fnless otherwise provided, a purchaser of leaseholds is not, prior to compic tiun, fixed with constructive notice of unusu.M and onerous provisions ,n tl. • h'^m: Reeve v. Berridffe, 20 Q. B. D. 523; White and Smith's Contrncl. 1H96) 1 Ch. 637. „ , .\nd SCO sect. 3 (1) of the Conveyancing Act, 1882, and Molyncux v. Ilmrt,,-,,. 1903) 2 K. B. 487. As to registered loa-scholds, sec Vohs and Saunders' Contract, 103 1- 1 . 1»J. :iOa. As regards any of the premise.s subject to mortgacres whicl. As/^^^^^^^ rannot be pd oil until after the time for complelinn, the vendors .shall It so required bv the coy. convey the same to the coy subject to the iiiortfrages affecting the "same resply. and the coy shall be at liberty to retain out of the cash portion of the .sd conson a sum sufficient to pay olf and satisfy in full .all claims under such mortgages.] A A 2 \] H! ;i5« A0RfcEMENT8. rcnAi'. V. Form 31. This clause will, of coume, only be required if the vendori purport t.. 9.II free from the mortgages, and arrangemenbi in such a case are generally ina,l« for clearing off tlic mortgages without delay. V.ud..rt,. lOb. Save as hnbefoi* provided, the vendors shall pay, satisfy. di»charg. ^j^^ discharge all th ir debts and liabilities in connection with the ufdcr'tX;: " sd business as on the — day of , and shall indemnify the tov hy«.mpKiij. .jgainst all proceedings, claims, and demands in respect thot] The insertion of this clause depends, of course, on whether the company i.r is not to undertake all debts and liabilities. Possesttiuu to be retained liy vendors lUitil lomplBtion, and they tu carry ou business, \f. for oonnwuy . As ti> cajiitul- isiiig interim prt lilts. Vfiicloi n"t ti liirry lii similar Imsi- 11 The possession of the sd premises shall be retained by the vendors up to the sd day of , and in the meantime they -hall carry on the sd business in the same manner as heretofore, so as 10 maintain the same as a going concern, and they shall from the date hof or as from the day of ] be deemed to have been and to] be carrying on such business on behalf of the coy, and shall account and be entld to bo indemnitied accordingly. Where a business is purcha.=ed it is very common to make the purchase Iron, a past date [e.g., the date of the last balance sheet, made, perhaps, s..„n» months previously!; the desire being that the company shall take the proht, as from that date, and be able to declare dividends as if it had carried >m business from that date. There is, however, serious difficulty in giving cff.vi to such desire, for the interim profits, when aciiuired, represent so much capital -xpeiided by the company, and therefore constitute part of the capital osxt- „f the company, and to apply the same in paying dividend would be to pay a dividend out of capital, for the amount of which the directors would be per ^onallv responsible. Sometimes the interim profits are excepted, ,:ff., Uy inserting a .laus,' ex- pressly providing that " there shall be excepted from the sale the profit- .,( the business made between the 3Utli August last and the date hereof, and the profits of the business for the year ending the 30th August next sliall I.e ascertained in due course, and tlie vendors shall in satisfaction of the said exceiitcd profits accept a sum bearing the same ratio t.. the year's profits as the iieriod aforesaid bears to the year." Of course, there is nothing to prcv.nt the vendor, when profits are so excepted, from (subse a,, a similar bu.ine... e.ther .n the «am. i! ,'■ Cd or elsewhere; but he may net »olieit the customers of the ohl , : L Tr.,0 V. //.., (1S06) A. C. 7, which in part ovorru ed ~ /.„,,«„ 27 C U. 14.5. nnd re.toro.1 L„hn„chere v. «««-.<,„, 13 Km- 322, .J.X'v i;«l. CUH.O, 2 Ch. .2f.. The rule in Tr.^o v, Uu.u Ue, r , ■. erson. who were customers pr.or to the sale, and .s not h.mtcd so a. to , 'u le persons who, before solicitation, became of their own accord he vcndu . ie ,. C,.r, l,r,u., Ltd. v. WeH.t.r, (1904) 1 Ch. 68.5 And w ere th.- ,",ne.s is sohl or disposed of, this rule will operate for the bencft of the ;;,l;er. although .."^JwiU is not speciHcaUy mentioned, for a vendor „„t L principle derogate from his grant. Jenmng. v. Jemvu.j,, (1898) 1 Ih. 378! "3 a,„l Uanne.., 0«99) 1 Ch. 378. A.d sec MaHarlane v. Du,n- ■n,is state of things, however, is not in general suttic.ent protection; heme ,l,c need for a clause as above. The benefit of such a [.rovsion -^ "-'K""'' ' „.,„, U>e business (Bai,.. v. <^e,.,, 35 V.. .). 134; »,-:/*' v. U,„^^. 17 W l{. .io,-.), and may pass with the goo.lwill {Jarohy v. Uh,t,,,o,r. 32 W . IJ . IN), uaie^s the covenant ap,.ears to be merely personal. /*«,»•» v. />«.■.<•.., M- ' \UI,!ui. a general coNenant not to carry on business in competUion with th. purchaser would not be valid (,ee Trego v. lI.oU, (l^) A. f. „ 2,;, yet an Lrecmcnt by the vendor of a business not to .'arry on a .„»./«-■ '"'""•««'- valid, provided that it does not go beyond what is reasonably "^^-'"y '»;. *'; protecLn of the purchaser (iLfCell v. H.^nolU.. 1 Sm. L. C. 39 ; J^..,>r^j imtn, V. Sr/,ott, (1892) 3 Ch. 447; Aordenfelt v. Mar,m HordenfcU to.. Ohm, A C. 535; U„derwood v. Barker, (1899) 1 Ch. 300; Tivoh. M, v. Barke, , 1HM9I 1 Ch 300. And the covenant is not necessarily bad because it purports to restrain the covenantor during the whole of his Ufe. Ilaync, v. Domtn. (1«99, 2 Ch. 13; Hood * Moore, Store, v. Jone,. 81 L. T. 169; /.««"<"• I'm„maU.' Tube v. I'lullip*. 91 L. T. 363. Especially when the covenantor is . servant. .UarMl.. Ltd. v. Leek. 17 T. L. R. 26. As ^ an 'nfant eovc- aantor, sr. Uoopcr v. WiUi>. 94 T. T. 624; and Lon, »• Andrew,, (1909) 1 Ch. 703. v^ w A ■.iM Form 31. AGREEMENTS. [Chap. V. l-£l V covenant not to carry on within (say) the Unit«l Kingdom i« not diriiible, that h to say: if it is too wide a restraint it is void altogether, although if confined to London or some other specified dUtrict it would have been valid. But a covenant may be framed so as to be divisible, e-ff., " Not to carry on in London or within 100 miles or within 300 or within 500, or within the United Kingdom." If the reasonableness of such restraint is called in question the Court may hold it valid in part and void as to the rest, e.g., valid as to London and 100, and void as to the rest, for it is divisible. See Prirr v. Green, 16 M. & W. 346: Daviet, Tmntr ^ Co. v. towen, 64 L. T. 655; Badifche Amlin, fc. v. Scholt, (1892) 3 C. D. 447. But unless the provision is thus alternatively expressed it may be impossible to divide the good from the bad. Sfker v. Hedgeeock, 39 C. D. 520; Ehrman v. Bartholomew, (1898) 1 Ch. 671. For an example of a severable agreement, see William Sohinton ^ Co. V. Ileuer, (1898; 2 Ch. 451. Each case is to be separately considered with due regard to its circumstances, and accordingly the greatest care mast be taken not to make the restraint too wide, as otherwise it may be totally ineffective. Thus a restraint is unreason- able and void if it goes beyond what is required, e.g., if the business is that of a brewer and the vendor is restrained not only from carrying on such business, but any other business. Perlt v. Saalfeld. (1892) 2 Ch. 149, C, A.; but see Woodbridge v. Bellamy, (1911) 1 Ch. 326. A contract, though too wide as regards space, may be held valid it it only prohibits the use of the old name. Ver)ion v. Hallam, 34 Ch. D. 748; White. Tomkint and Courage v. Wilton, 23 T. L. B. 449. A contract " not to carry on " does not, in all cases, prevent the vendor from acting merely as maiiager or agent for anotlicr. Allen v. Taylor, 19 W. H. 35; 34 L. T. 249. But see Palmer v. Mallett, 36 C. Div. 411, and Sobertmn v Willmott, 25 T. L. B. 683. The words " permit or suffer " import knowledge. Somrrn-t v. Wade (1894). 42 \V. R. 399. " Not to lie interested " imports a pecuniary interest, and does lot touch the case of a vendor's wife or relations setting up and carrying on business. Hanbury v. Cimdy. 58 L. T. 155. And see Cade v. Calfe, 22 T. L. R. 243, and Gopkir Diamond Co. v. Wood, (1902) 1 Ch. 950. " Not to be interested or concerned " prohibits acting as manager or servant (^Jonet v. Ilenren: 4 C. D. 686; Newling v. Dobell, 19 L. T. 408; Hill # Co. v Hill. 56 L, T. 769), and being interested as a shareholder in a rival company's business. Wright v. Chappell, 17 W. B. 655; CaetelU v. Uiddleton, 17 T. L. B. 373 (1901). But see Cory # Son v. Harrison, (1906) A. C. 274. " Not to solicit within " or " do any work or act for, kc. within " the spoeiSed district, prohibits soliciting by letter posted beyond the district. Callard v. Taylor, 3 T. L. B. 698; Edmundton v. Render, W. N. (1905) 121. And soliciting within the district may, at any rate if it is at all systematic, amount to a breach of contract not to carry on business within that district. Turner v. Evana, 2 Ell. 4: B. 512. But " not to act as agent within " the district may allow acting beyond the district for a firm acting within. Fairbrother v England, 40 W. B. 220. "Not to sell below certain prices." Elliman v. Carrington, (1901) 2 Ch. 275; National Phonograph Co. v. Edison Bell Co., (1908) 1 Ch. 335; McOrutter v Pitcher, (1904) 2 Ch. 306. Distances in such contracts are measured as the crow flies. Mouflet v. CoU. L. B. 8 Ex. 32. If the restraint is from trading at a particular place, which is, say. a borouirh or any place within so many miles of it, the distance is measured from thi borough boundary, and not from the centre of the town. (Jattle v. Thurpf. \V. N. (1900) 83. FORMS. :Wft » v„, to compete directly or indirectly within the di'tnct," prohihit, dealing Fom_31 "^I^^f^d^- 'ie!::; a servant fro. hi, covenant. .,..W n. r,.,.», ro. V. .^^*».-» (1908) iCh 537 ^,,^ ^„„ . ."^TS^caro/rhtJenir:" tX I^^oin, the^roprictor of a hotel h h h re a nVa ovenant i, inserted that the vendor, his heirs and a.s.guecs. X^r:h^r^r.™.nth„co.p.^^^^ 4 cl>. App^054. C^W ^^^^ ^_^ j^ J ^^ ^„3^ ,, t^ T. 512), and runs " . „, but ith^s been held that, even when the contract expressly declares \ywCL \im) I Q. B. 382, 384; ,ecu. where payable m one event; Law ^. r S^i^tlntie^s^e^p^ie'^to add further w.rds en.phasi.n. Accord nglj. It is in some 1 ^^^ ^,^ ^^^^^ ^^^^^ .^ ^^^^^. ^„^,, r;r; ::;ragree1 clVn-tion for such breach of covenant, and without Zy e J . prove and irrespective of, the actual damages sustame,!. ritt could not well override this, for " to construe is nothmg more han ,„a;:i!.;:t the meaning of the parties as expressed in the language they ba.o ""^V ,..ovi.on for payment of liquidated damages does not prec ude th „„,,) from obtaining an injunction. XatiorM Prov,nc,al llanl v. M.nsMI, '"ruttcording to Wright, J., the covenanted cannot have both th., damage, and tlTnjunctfon, but must elect between the two remedies. Oe„er.! Acn,>n,> ■hvannc- Corp. v. H'ebster, (1902) 1 K. B. 377. . \ tl elease of the covenantor's obligations where the company goo. mto Uqull!:^io„. Measures Bros. v. Measu..., (1910) 1 Ch. 336; and ,eo Oe.er.f mil rusiiH,, Co. V. Mkius, (1909) A. C. 118. ri2a. Of the conson afsd, £— is the -onson for the sale of the Apj.ruon _ f^oods, chattels, m.moys, and other effects cai>abl.. of manual delivery j,,,^. and forming part of the purchased opty.] The Revenue authorities will not always accept a provision as above, and vendors very commonly prefer not to disclose the "PP^"""";.^"' '"".''' .tract. And see in Wragg, (1897) 1 Ch. 796, where an apport.onment claus, led to onerous litigation. 121,. All books of account of tl - x firm, and all books of referenoo B,,.,k. -•. ( , , >u>luiuer«, and all other b. ite and docuw-.ents of the «1 firm (except 11 :<6t> ACJKKKMKMS. rrnAP. V. Form 31. "uch as relat* (jx.lusively to the private affairs of the said firm or ilii individual luenibers thof ), hHuII be delivered by the vendufH to the Cdv ou possession boiug given of the prt'iiii-c-*, pursuant Uj the provision in that beiialf Imbofore contained, and the coy shall thenceforth, sub- ject to the followiu',' proviso, bo eiitld to the custody lliof, and h> the use thof for the purpose of carrying on its business; but ilie vendors sliall have free access, at all reasonable times, to such of ili« sd books and do,;uniont« as show or relate to the outstanding bouk debts and credits of the vendors, or may otiiorwise be requisite for enabling tlio vendors U^ collect and get in the assets of the sd iirm not hby agreed to be sold, and to li(iuidato the affairs thof; noverthelew, when and so soon as any of the sd books of reference and other books sliall cease to bo necessary for the carrying on of the sd business, the same shall bo doliveroi! osor to the vendors, who shall thoroupuu become absobitoly entld theroln] This and tlio next followiiif; r]:nw arc (X'casioimlly inserted. A«"iumuaa- 12c. The vendore shall be ontld to such accommodation a.s tho\ tioninotfii'e ^^^. r,,.j^,,„„i,|y require in the counting-iiouse of the coy, in the h1 rondnS."^^" ° leasehold pnMnises, for the purpose of collecting the book .and oihoi debts dm; to the vendors in respect of the .sd busines.s and liquidalitis: the attuirs thof; and the vi .idors shall make all such book and other debt.s pnvable a', the .■^d preuu.-es, and at no other place, the nl)jcrt buing to secure the continued resort of the customers of tlie sd iinn tn tlio sd premises, and .so to give to the coy tiio full benefit of the srood- ■.vill of the sd business] Vendor guarantees book do entld to the uncollected book debts af.sd.] Tlie above is sonictinie4 inserted. '12e. The cov shall collect, on behalf of the vendor, all the book debts of the vendor excepted fronri the sale hby agreoj..-. .. .i.« -u.on. of the olli., and to the J^^-;' .„,l;;,loIi„n of tho ,.urc.hn.«o, be .n.1.1 to .he henefit of the curn-nt in-iirimif .'f 'lie im'mi*'". "'""" * ?,«!,.<, f„r hh only rittlit is to indemnity (Vtelln„> v. Pre.^"-. r;'VT;l. Ih r- *re voTdor^ «- recovori„. the insurance n^on-y . «J, ffV,( nf Fnaland Firf Co. v. hnarf. (1897) I U- H- ^-»- ■'"' :r t c,.,W ;.: .nJhaser may. in son.o oases, he enabled to^ «ot t^ b .«; of ...e insurance ..y calling on tho office to remsta e under It Ge^ 3 , TS s HS- tmt. notwithstanding Ex part. Goreb,. 4 l)e U.S. H S. 477. .t _ o ,1; whethc; that Act applies beyond the bills of -« See d.c.a n ■■..l,„imle,- Fhe Oinre v. (Ha... *<•■ f>oc., 13 App. ( as. 714, 71b. In the . ro ,cr c„„r.c is f„r the purchaser. i,n.„,.di.tcly o„ the cKccnMnn o. :;.: '„';:».'., l. make arrangement, with the insurance office, and the above , Inline leave- him free to do this. \^: ^ ,,ia. Tho vondot^ shall pay all .he co«ts of. and meulont^l to. .h. P™i,n,,^^^^^^ preparation and execution of this agrooml, and of the mcmdum and ,^,, art. of a,s.on of the coy. and of the registration thot, and o all stamps bc^^ ™ by f....s and logal oxp.>n..c., incident to the formation of the coy, and .om.rallv all preliniinaiy oxpen^H). ^^•halevor incurred in relation to ,"l,e cov down to the first general allotment of .shares or to the tune whr-i the directors determine not .o proceed to allotment] S„„a.tinu.s this uUuse is varied so as only to eover costs up to ineorporation, and vcrv cdmn.only no such provision is made. The clause „>ea„s all the reasonable nk Ga. Co.. s:j 1.. T. 3'2l!, 328. A pro,uoter .an only recover from the company what he has paid m pre- liminary expenses where he proves a contract by the company to pay Snffl.^h and C.LZ l-roJuoer, Co., (1906) 2 Ch. 435; A-«^.«»"/ Motor MaU Coach, <19US; 2 Ch. 515. If Wi AGREEMENTS. [Chap. V. ill Fona 31. I3b The validity of this agreemt shall not be impeached on the ground tliat the vendors, as promoters or otherwise, stand in a t.,"l« ini"'' fiduciary relation to the coy, and that the directors, having accepted jwuchwl office at their request, do not constitute an independent board] A rlnu»c as above i» sometimes inserted, and may have some operation [Poftarjo atam/j Automatic Co., (1892) 3 Cli. 566) ; but it should hv mads to fit Ilie oiri'ura«tancc8, e.g., if one of the directors is to receive a payment from the vendor or U interested an a partner or shnreholdor in the vendor company, let the facts be disclosed here and the clause provide that he is not to be accountable. The clause is no use unless it covers the particular case. See Olympia, Ltd., (189») 2 Ch. 163, 167, 168; and p. 182, tuprn : and cf HrnziliiiH llubhp, Plantatioiu (No. 1), (1911) 1 Ch. 425. cieiitly •»Tibscribe«i I). 1, 1 ...in 1- l-f Unless before the day of the coy shall have become tion ifjsli.ires entld to coninieuco business, either of the parties hto may by notice in writing to the other determine this agreemt except as to clause 13a hof, but such determination shall not give rise to any claim for cOu\- ponsation, expenses or otherwise. This clause is inserted to meet the contingency of the company not becoming entitled to commence business under sect. 87 of the Companies Act, 1908; it will, therefore, of course be omitted in the case of private companies. , 1 Ser^-icc oi notices. 15. Any notice hereunder may be served on the vendors by send- ing the same through the post, addressed to them at Ho. , Street, , and shall be deemed to have been served witliin twenty- four hours after the same is posted. It would seem that notice might in the absence of such a clause be given by post. James v. Institute of Chartered Arcountnntt, 98 L. T. 225. ^' , M I Tliis agree- ment to take effect as an English contrp.ct. Appointment of agent in Englitnd to repri'wTit vencliir.i for legal pro- ce-se«. &c ! 1 ja. This agreemt is to be construed and take effect as a contract made in Eiiglaud, and in accordance with the law of England, and the vendoi's hby submit to the jurisdiction of the High Court of Justice in England, and hby ai)point the Bank, Limtd, and every clerk for the time being of that coy, to be tlie agent in London of the vendors for the purpose of accepting service on behalf of the vendors resply of any writ, notice, order, judgment, or other legal process or document in respect of any matter arising Oat of thi.s agreemt. and such appointment shall not be revocable, and service of any such document on puch appointee shall be deemed to be good service on the vendors for all purposes, and the vendors elect domicile at the registered office of the sd bank.] Where the vendor is a foreigner, a clause aa above may be desirable, see p. 343, aupra. Such a clause is effective, and cannot be revoked. Tharsis, ^c. Co. V. Sociiti, 4-c. des Metaux, 58 h. J. Q. B. 435; approved by the Court ot Appeal in Montgomery v. Liebenthal, (1898) 1 Q. B. 487; Copin v. .idam- ^0,1. 1 Ex. D. 17. FORMS. *>:» n doM not offend i«.ln.t tho rule tlut tho p»rtlei cannot contract th.t the Fom 31 Court Xui.^e a JuTi^iictioa act «:ven by Order XT r. . « A '»--.- - >. Oray, 11896) 1 Q- B. 39. 16 The coy shall cause this agreemt to be duly filed with the A.,-....., Registrar of Companies pursuant to sect. 88 of the Comrames Consolidation) Act, 1908, and also, in the case of shares allotted to ,ho vendors' nominees, shall cause a sufficient contract to be so (.led ,onstituting the title of such nominees Where the agreement provide, for the i.,ue of paid-up or partly paid-up j,.rMi a clauie aa above la uirful aa a reminder. If^her^ Utotl. nn invitation to the public to .ub«,ribe for .hare,, a contract ake the above should contain a new olau«. to the effect that- 17 This agreemt is provisional only, and is not to become absolute unless and until the coy has become entld to commence business.] See sect. 87 of the Act of 1908. s,„ua. p. iO. As WITNESS, &C. The Schedcles above referred to • r>g \H ll Special Clauses in Vendors' Agreements. Upon payment of lie cash portion of the purchase-money the vendor shall enter iut. a covenant with the coy for the benefit of the „.embers thof, guaranteeing that the net profits of the coy .n lespe, t of tho sd business during each of the three years next following tl>o __ day of next shall amount to not less than [10] p.c.p.a. on ,lie pd-up capital of the coy not exceeding 100,000Z., and that if there shall bo no profits, or a deficiency of profits, in any of the sd three V ears the vendor, his heirs, executors, or administrators shaU. imme- •liatelv after the same shall have been ascertained, and notice thof given to him or them, pay to tJie coy, in trust for tho members thof , a sun. sufficient to make up the amount guaranteed. The oe-t.ficato in writing of the auditor or auditors for the time being of the coy as to the amount at any time payable under this clause shall as against tho vendor, be conclusive evidence thof for the purposes of this clause. Guarantee of ProfiU. It occasionally happens, where a going business is sold to a company that the vendor guarantees that the proHts shaU, during a >'-te^P«"'^' 'T^l^X- . narticular sum. The guarantee is usually given for the benefit of the sharc- Form 32. Onarnntce of ],, fii. ),v VU11>1"1 to tho intent that the members may respectively Mie the com- pany for any breach of such covenant ;un AOKRKMKNTB. [Chah. v. Form 32. 11' r 1 lioldor., uiiil i« «tai.-d in th« i.rwtii. a» uii attrttrtion. Where the tr»nMi-tion it bov'i ll.U it h:iH IniTi hi-lJ that the iiipml«r< thorchy Bo-iuirc an ind.p.milont riuht, which thf y will Im' iihlc to roly on if tho profit- are iinufflcient. Sec lin»i}i I.Uinharrnu V,u. 12 ('. Div. SOS: and O'-H'i /), 7 *'nVifr>i (',>., 3H f.. T. 440. liut it would seem that mich » tfuaranteo rannot hi- con^idPrBfl hnni Hitr ({iveii where part of tho capital U paid to the vendor an the coniidcration for th'- ;;iiaruntof, ».?., where an addition to tho price it made in order to cover the Kiiarante.' no tfivcn. And '/u,-ri, whether these cam's are ijuit.' eonnistont with Iho principle- laid down in Trfmr v. irhiXn.rlh. 12 App. C'as. 409. In any ca-c, «neh cnarantees rciuire to be very .arcfuUy framed. See ,S<-/«r<« Tru^ti-. 4 ('. \). 213, where it was held that the (fuarantec araoiintoil to a provinion for payment ..f dividend- out of capiUl, and acordin^ly that the niemhers conld not claim tho bcnoHt Uicrcof a- a«aiint the conii«ny's creditor.-i. Sometimes the porformance of the jfiiiinintw i- -en red hy the investment of a fund in th." names of tru-twi. A ixjmpany can in some cases release a guarantee l.y ,> vendor. .vt./AVW .\''-krl Co. v. Inwin. 2 Q. 11. I). 214. Whore a vendor ,ii:irant«'- the I'onipany a rerta' dividend for a tixed iiumher of years there i- no implied contrnet by the e pany to carry on the husinc-a di-entitlinjr it. if it discontinncs tho bu-inws diirim; the currency of the guarantee, to sue the vendor on it (lli;,iin * Cn. v. Itrniin, .3t) T. 1.. K 2TJ>, « t<.,-ii(iil where the company di-contin\i.« only one out of several of ilic liusine-ses bought. Ihkl.: cf. 'nhn,le.. v. lonrmil. 1 A. C. 25(i; and A> ,,n,fi! Mf,rlw>: li. K. 5 Ch. 737; contra, Tcl>-;iraph Dfa/iatrh Co. v. McLean. ].. \i. H Ch. 658. Where there is a ijuarantee fund, it is sometimes providinl that if the profits in any year amount to the i;uaranteed sum, a part of the fund shall be released. In Soulh llnnh'tnan Cn.. iihi ,ii,>yH, it was provided that any moneys paid under the (fnarant*- should he repaid out of the 3urplu^ profits which in any subsC(|Uent year remained alter payment of a 10 per cent, dividend for that year. As to construction of a guarantee, see .VldUon v. .\> ,«, 9 T. r,. R. «07. The clause provides usually for a jjuaraulcc for a term of year-, but occa- sionally it provides for a perpetual RuaRintee. and in that ease the t.on of u -h.r-^ ,. 1 l.r, .ml i. thcr.fo,. « re.tui ,u. ,r„.t. K-.t .h.- more fact th« « .-..nt a-t r»ra.,t«. i. with tru.t..e. for the b«n.-t(Hu,io. d-n-, not arte.t th- ,K«.t,.m ' far ,» th. .mention of a perpetuity i- .oncermHl : whether the truntee, or th. Lenehciaries in ti.eir ri^ht ,ue. they mu»t sue on the eontta-t -a mere per«>.ml ontract -a. iu th. c.^ above referred to. They eanno. «ue by y.rlue o> th. devolution of title to any annuity or other property, and th., be.n« «.. ther. „ „,> foundation for the -ugirestion of inv.lidity above referred to. .^„ iKfUvwn Iho lioldern of the 12,000 »haie.s to bo ulloli.^d to ilu' Form 33 ,,,,.lor.- i-ursuaut to a«»>e - hoi i wl.i.l. .^huros aio huftr referred ^^^ ,„ us tlic vo.Hl.-rs' slKiH-«), ui>d the holders of (ho otlior slmnw ,n (ho ,,„rcH ...nil,! of tlu) .ov which have !«■.■.. aln-ady or .^hall hu.v.ifU-. Im. .leferr.,! i,.ue.l uol cxit'ediuK 20,000 iu uuiuhoi- ( haftr rutVrrod to as tii.' ordii.arv .shares >. the proBt« of the coy. from tlio U\ dav of .Jaiiuar), I'll" to thG ;U«t dav of DocMuhiT, l"Ji:, «liall bo applied lirsl in pay- ii,-"to the hol.lem of tho ordinary .shares a cun.ulativo proforeiitial .livideiid at tho rat« of C p.cp.a. upon the amount for the t.iue hem-,' ,„1 up. or credited as pd up, on the ordinary shares hold by then, ivsply . S,„„oti>».-s upon the «ile of a ^'oin;.' eon.'ern the vendor U(rree« to ^ive a liuiited preference of this kind to the share, taken up by the public. The n.cnorandun. will refer to the a«reen.ent, and set o.it the clause and -utc that the shares ineludc-d in the oertiH. ate form part of tho vendor s shares. So Inni; as the .apital pd up ou tho o.OOO 10/. shares to be i.ssuod Form 34 . lo the ven.lor a.s afsd shall e.x.s'od what on tho avorafre is pd up ou Another, ihe other Issued shares, tho e.Kcess shall not be deemed to carry dividends, and upon each eertiticate, &c I'he vendors shall have the option, during tlie term of three years from the date hof, of tukin^ up at par shares iu tho capital of tho ,ov forming part of it« initial capital, to an extent not exceeding in ll,e whole 100,000 shares of U. each, and tho coy shall awordmulv >ct aside 100,000 of tlie shares iu its initial capital to answer such o,,tion. and the following provisions in regard to such optinn shall have ellect. that is to say : - (ui Tho oi.tion shall in each ciuse be oxorcisoable by notice in writing lo the coy. rb) The vendors niav. under the option afsd, take up all or any ..t the .sl]iiri»;il ,ii. 1! ■'itftf Form 3A. AOBEEMKNTa. [Chap. V. ithilliDgB per (hare ia p«rt payuioot of the itharM f j be Utkeo, ftud the baluuoe of the aiuount of such aharoe, nauiely, ten •hillings per tttiare, ahall be pd to the coy within thirty (lay« after the allotment of the shareii xo taken. Form 36. Fit luniou of i'l.jectinn»bl'" .■.►».Hf. Form 37. A cUuM •tich M th« above i« not uni'ommon, •nd mmatimM auih an option may be of gn^t value. In giving iuoh an option tlie company doai not impliedly contract not to wind up until the option ia axerciaeabla, and if it wind* up the option itill remaina exeraiieable. If the Uquidatorii refute to give effect to the option, the party entitled thereto can prove for damage* and the re- version on hii thare in U>e exiiting aneta of the company after deducting the price he had agreed to pay for the aharea. Iliriek f Co. v. Burtu, 77 I.. T. 877. [Ihc coy ia to be at liberty, at any time within days from the date hof, to no ify in writing to the vendors that the coy object* tc any particular asitiet, whether bill, note, book debt, or ohone in action, comprised in the sale, and within days after receiving notice of any such objection the vendors shall pay over to the coy in cash a sura equal to the value at whicii such asset was brought into the balance sheet, upon the basis of which the sale has been arranged, and there- upon such u.sspt shall be deemed to be e.\cluded from the sale, and the vendors shall be entld thereto.] Vendor may pay Promoter Syndicate. The vendor shall be at liberty to make over to the B. Syndicate, l.imtd (hnftx called "the B. Syndicate") a portion, viz., £ , of (lie cash and — — • of the pd-up shares mentd in clause 2 hof in respect of the services of that coy to him in relation to the formation and j,romotion of the coy, and the syndicate, notwithstanding tlio fiduciary position it stands ••■. as a promoter of the coy, shall be in no wise accountable to the coy for what it so obtains, and the inten- tion is that this provision shall enure for the benefit of tlie syndicate. and the vendor shall be regarded as a tree thof accordingly. The object of the eoncluding words ia to give the syndicate a rit^ht to the benefit of the stipulations by ereatinff a trust in its favour. See Empreii F.i,(jiiieeiiwj Cn., 16 C. D. 125; Hulheilutm .Hum Co., 25 C. D. 103; Kelty V. Larking, (1910) 2 Ir. R. 560, and tupra, pp. 118, 149. A vendor may now, out of his consideration, cash or shares, pav I'ommission if the payment would have been legal if made directly by the coy. See sect. 89 (3) of the Act, and p. 278 et .^eq., supra. ^^rfj«in t' rOBMS. a«7 If *ny diflewnoe thaU ariw b«tweeu the puriie"* J.io t..ucl»iug ihwo Form 88. i,rM«iil» or the ooMUuction hof, or uuy cla.wo or thintf huroiu cou- Arbitmiion mined or any matter in any way conuecl^nl u ith thoM» i)re««ut.. or the oDeration thof. or the right., dutie., or liabilitios of oithor party lu connection with the premi«». then and in every or any such ca.e the .uitter in difference shaU be referred to two arbitrators, one to be appointed by each of the parties in difference. OccloMlly . cUuM. « .bove i> iii-rt«l in ««rc«raont., but it. in««rtion i. not to b4. recomm«nded. for . dl.put. c.n generally be «ttled more .,H-«l.ly .".d with IM eip.n.e without » reference to arbitration. be«ido. wh.ch .uoh n ■ lau« give, too muoh power to a hoitiU or oantwikerou. vendor, who can Ket up • dUpnt* and lo obtwa di«)oy«ry of th* boolu of the oompany. The vendom guarantee the due payment of the ovordrown icoounts Form 39. speciBed in the list, which, for the purpose of identification, has boon (j„„„„„.,. „, subscribed by and to the extent in each case set opposito the , ertnin H-n, sd account in the column of the sd list, but the coy shall he entitled to work all such overdrawn accounts either within the limit of or in excess of the overdraft existing as on the date hereof Neverthelees, the working of any such account so at to allow of over- draft ia excess of the existing overdraft af«d shall, as r«-<»rds the excess be at the sole risk of the coy. The guarantee of the vendors a-= regards pach such account sL-U bo deemed to be a continuing guarantee, and shaU extend to the payment of the balance for the time being and from time to time of such account not exceeding tlie amount of the overdraft at the date hof, and the vendors shall not be entitled to insist that payments into the account after the date hof are to be treated as in satisfaction pro taiito of items to the debit of such account on the date hot, and the coy, without prejudice to . h guarantee, is to be at liberty to give time to the cu<.tomer, and to release or modify any security, and generally to make any concessions I J the customer which the coy may think expedient. The above oUnse is occaiionally used, but it is somewhat stringent, and i- unlj to be adopted in apeoial circumstances. H .\greement for Sale made with Agent or Tri'STEE for intended form 40. Company prior to its formation. AKrccmcm with agent or This is an example of a form of an agreement commonly adopted in I'hin 1. [^'j'*,\^j'^"'' ,.« ■,. 325. eDmpntijt AN AGREEMT made the — day of , between A., of, &c. Parties. linftr called the '.-ndor), of tlie one part, and B., of, «S:c., on behalf I- ;'; ,^^' f ;i(!s AOREEMKNTS. [Chap. V. Rtvitals. Form 40. of the coy below nientd (which coy i« huftr referred to a« the coy ,. of the other part. a person l'"n-'t'n|^.'- -'•>««- '^V" ^1 ^^^ ^,^,, „ ,,„,,,, ,.„ ,, the company can claim "'«^.'"'"^",'' , "" .f,^ .^at the trustee U not entitled t., behalf before its incorporation, and therefore that the tru modify witliout the company-j consent. VVHERE.S the vendor has for some time past carried on business a... .e upou the he..ditan.euts huftr described. Am> whbhe.s he coy K. bo called The — Coy, Limtd, is about to be formed under ho n.s (Consolidation) Act, 1908. having for it. objects, among otl^r thinl. the .«3.iu-ition and working of the sd business. An wm^EAS the memdm and arts of asson of the coy have with ho uriXof the vendor been aln^ady px^pared. And whekeas th. n rillp tal of U>e coy is to be 80,000^., divided i.to lO-OOOshares " sHach Anu whkkeas by the sd arts of asson .t ^^V^oM t la. I'Z shall immediately after the incorporation thof adopt th.> Igreemt therein referred to, being these presents: Now ,t t. hkhebv A of the sd B., for the purpose of this clause. Agrctnieut to wH. UiM^liar^t' of B. P..W.T I" r.'S'-inil if not n l"pted. 17 If this agreenit shall not be adopted by the coy in manner afsd hofore the --- dav of next, either of the parties hto may, by .uj^j.^, .Ill AH FORMS. •{69 iKPticc ill writinjj to the other, determine the same; and in the case Form 40. of ill. iiivitatiou'to the public for tlio first time to Tiubscribo for shan^ ad.l the words of clause 17 of Form 31]. SiM' .<"/';■", P 328. IS Tlio detenuination of tl.is aprecmt under cbu,so IG or 17 hereof NojUim U* sliull not pive rise to any claim for compensation. exiKsnscs. or other- wi.'^c. S<'p M'jtyf, p. 328. As WITNESS the liands of the parties hto the day and year first above written. The Schedule above referred lo. \- to adoption ..f contracts, sco xit/im, p. 327. Soo also sect. 87, sub- ,,.,t. :! of the Act of 1908. liavinff rof?ard to this section, if the adoption takes pi lie Inforc the conipanv has become entitled to commence business, and there luis been, or is to be, an" appeal to the public to subscribe for shares, a clause slioiilil lie inserted a.s in clause 17, p. 3(13, ««/)>". I! .VlRIIMKNT hij C0MP.\.N\ .M)OPTIN(; CoNTKACT MAIIK ON ITS ^°"° *^- itKiiALF BKioRK ITS iNcoKPORATiD.N . Fof ind^tmment on (hhiinal Contract. ,\N AC;HI;1;.MT nuulo tliis day of , botwecn k.. of, &c., Partiis. ..f ilic tii-si part, B., of, Ac, of the second [lart, and The Coy, Liiiitd ' Imftr called the coy ), of the third part. Where.\s, since the Recitals. cxcciiti.ai of the within-wiittcn agreemt, the coy has been incorpo- rated in accordance with the intention in that behalf referred to in Btich agreemt: Now IT IS hereby mituallv agreed as follows: — 1. Tlie witliiii-writton afrreemt is hby adopted by the coy. and shall Adoption, bo hindin-r on tiie sd .A. and on the coy in tiie same manner, and take cllcct in all mspect.s as if the coy had been in oxistonco at the date tiiof. and had by these prosent.^* ratified the same. 2. Tlic sd H. siiall from henceforth be discharired from all liability B.diHch.rr^J. iiiider or in respect of the sd agreemt. In witness, ic. Where a contract is made on behalf of an iMtciidtHl company (.is .-;i)nvr-, pp. 327 rl «C7.]. it \s requisite to take steps to bind the company when it comes into existence. An idea prevailed at one time tliat u company could I'. 1 I' 370 Form 41. AGBEEMEMTS. [Chap. V. ratify 8Uoh a contra.t, but it is now wpH «ttlo.i that it cannot /.,«/»<■.« Efiginecrm'J Co., 16 C. Div. 125; So,th.;,.hr.la.vl .Irnwe Co., 33 ( . Div. IB. See ««;»•«, p. .T22. AicordinRlv the us.ml plan i» t.. exroute an a|?r...-ni,.nf aa above, «. oh t.> offoct a novation of contract. >.■•■■ »»,"", P- 323. W hero th.. preliminary contract i. made with B. a.s -'trustee" for the intended company, cUiuse 1 must run as in the form folh.wini?. That su.h an adoption is effe.- tive, see Boston Ihep Sea Co., 39 C. Uir. 3.M; .Vof,/ r-i»le. Parties: the coy. xa....=. ."- ^"., 1: the vendor, 2; A., A. Wi.ekkas l.v an H.M*«nit (huftr called the preliminary contract,) dated, &c.. and nmd.. between the vendor, of the one part, and the sd A., ii.s tree to,, li.e coy ( which was then intended, and has since hwu fornic.l under tlio Cos (Con.solidation) Act, 1908., of the other part, it wa.s agreinl that the vendor should sell, and the coy should purclia.se. certain ppty upon the terms, and subject to the stipulations tlicreiu e-vpressed: And WHEREAS a copy of the i.i-eliminary contract is set tortl. n. the schedule hto. Now THESE PRESENTS WITNESS AND DE. l.VRE aS folloWS-- 1 The pitjliminarv contract is hby a.lopted by the coy, and .shall (subiect as hnftr provided i bo bindin- on the vendor and the .oy m the same manner, and take etVect as if the coy ha*l been ui existen.v at the rtion ..f the purcha.se-mouoy, viz 50 000/., shall bo satisHcd as to 20,000t. by the issue to the vendor or his nomine,-s, of 2.000 fully paid-up lOl. shares in the coy s capital, and as to .W.OOO/. as follows: that is to say, at the time tor compl.-lion, one moietv of the then wpital mom-ys of tlu^ coy shall be pd t.. th.> vendor, and the other moiety shall be retained by the coy for its freneral purposes; and out of the capital moneys .ubse.iuently paid u|) the coy mav retain for its fj:eiieral purposes any sum not ,.N.ve.lin.' .-.,OOoV. and, subject as uf.sd, shall pay such capital moneys, a.s and when m*iv«l, te the vendor, until the residue of the sd sum of :K) 000/. has been paid, with interest, at the rate of u p.e.p.a^, lu* from 'the time tor completion to the time of actual payment. And. „nb-ss within six calcmhir months from Uie first allotment of the coy s Hhares the whole of such residue lias been pd, the coy may at any time theivafter satisfy the balance thof, then remaining unpd by ls.s.iiu" to tlie vendor or hifi nominee fully pd-up shares to be regardctl KOKM8. 371 as (jf par vttliio (»r the hulauwi simll thereupon iiuiuodiatoly become puval.lt' ill •ii.th). 4 11' at the time lor <<)iii|ilotion less tluiu shares sliull lia\o been lakoii up, tlieu iipoi payment of the aniouut linbefofo made |,a\ l)le at tlio time for completion, and upou the ullotmont of the sd !!.(i(Mi .shuies, the veii.lor will transfer the ppty to the coy in nccord- Imi- will! oii of the coy it is dechired that one of the objects of the coy is to sell the undertaking of the coy, or any pt tliof, for such coiison as the (oy may think fit, and in particular for shares, debentures, or frcc uiities of ar y having objects, altogether or in pt, similar to those of this coy: A.si) whereas the objectH of the corporation are in pt similar to those of tlio coy: And whereas the corporation is desirous of acquiring the undertaking and ppty of the coy. Now, therefore, it is .vgrekd as follows:— I. Tlic coy sliall sell, and the corporation shall purchase, the S"!*-- i!!i'!criiiking"of the coy, v.liiih expression shall be ileeiiied lo include all the lands, buildings, hcrediUmcnts, goods, chattels, moneys, iredits. ilobts, bills, notes, goodwill, things in action, contracts, « II '2 ;i72 AGREEMENTS. [Chap. 1 i' W u \v Form 43. C'oiiHidcra- tion. Further con- iiideration. Further con- sideration. Title. Completion. Conditions. Filing. agroeinciitf<. scciiiilies. and otlier ii.'*.-s(M.s whats.ievor ami « hoiosocvor of the (iiv, oxc<'i)t it.s uiieallod capital. 2. As a i>t of tlio ((inson for the sxecme aus. 7. This a^iTeemt is conditional on th<' same hein^'- ratilied hy a re.solution of"a fi-eneial meeting- of the coy. and if the .same is not so ratitierreemt. S. Afrreemt to he tlleil S(>e Furnt 'M. rl. 1(>.' As WITNESS, itc. Sale of under- taking before going itito liquidation. It is a very couunoii tiling tor a company to agree to sell its undertaking as a going concern without going into licpiidation. I>ut in order to justify such an agreement power to di.sposc of the undcrtakini: must be found in the memo- randum of aKSoeiation of thi- company. No doubt, by proceeding under sect. 1B2 of the Companies .\ct. 1(11)8 (replacing se.t. Kil of th- Act of 18(!2i. almost any company under tli.' .\.t can sell its undertaking, but there are cases m which it is not convenient to prcMceil und.'r that section, for an ctteetive agree- ment cannot be ma.le under the s,.,tion unless and until the company goes into li<|uidation. and appoints li,|iiidators. and invests them with authority to exercise the powers of the selii.n. Where the purchasing cimipany is already a going eiuicern with large resources, there may be no ()l)jection to the vendor cmupany, after settling the terms of the agreement, or entering into a provisional agree- ment. L'oing into liipiidation: but .•mo in such cases the vendor company some- times prefers to postp.me li(iuida',ion till differ cmipletion. And where the purchasing companv is to be form.-.! and ttoated the vendor company may tin.l itself placed in a very awkward predicament if it goes into li(|uldation with n view to making the auT i.uit, and then subsecpienily the new cimipany is no^t formed, or does not Hoat . In lie- le-ull llie .igrrcnu-nt may fall t.> >!■•■ -roiuv!, and the vendor companv may find that it has lost its status us a going concern without obtaining any' corresponding benefit, and that it -annot start again without eitloT reconstructing or applying to the Court to stay the windine-up If. on the oth.'r hand, the vendor company beinsf in a position so to lati»n, .l.nt .^y,:mrn* ran, o . :. nrrnid. tl,a.. umU.s the sal- i. -Inly ,a,.ri,..l in,,, ,.ltVH, .l„. a.M-c.nu.nt ,.av 1... r ina,.,l. an.l then, if thin,-> .'„ «r,.n.-. that ,.„«.. .an ho .■x.T,.-d. „„.i ,h.- v,.n.h,r , pany .an r.-unu. an.l .„ntinu.. its l.usin...s ^.m-tunc. sn.h : ..,•,■..».,..» i. n,adc. ,li.v,t with th.. n..w ,„n„,any, „,• wUh a fust,-.. t„ , ■ .„n.,.ti«...s it is mad., with s.Mne ,HTs.>n as an int..rn>,.d.ary. wh., r.-s-lls t„ tl ■■ n.'W .■.)mpanv at a profit. » 1 ..„ A ,..,nM.an.v .•ann.-t s..ll its wh,.lo nn.l,.,taki„. nnU.^s .h,.,,. ,s .'"--^^ •<;;'';. - ,„ its „><.ni..ran,ln.n .,f ass<.,iati„n. S, „,,,.„„ v. // r.!, .'o " ""• " ' ' • • H II 1 (as 71'J. lint wh...... th,. nK.»,.....,i,.]u .ak..s th.. sal,. ..f .ts un.l. . Ukin^ -HU. ..f th.. ...nnpany-s ..hj....ts. sn.h a sal.- is .,...■■ ...^ and a l,.w..,. .■. N,.v..,-.h..U.ss. a,-.„.din,' ... a r,.n.a..kal,l.. ,1.. i^i.m .,f 'l- « """ "' y'l'™' Ui:s„o,„l V Jlr.„lr,..o.: Tr.n. »/ K^Mr, r,,., .lOOH, 1 Ch. ,..!), or to the i..as.'ns assi(,n.-d for th.- .l.-,.isi..n, a sal.. ..f th.. nn,l,.rtaUin« for shares mad. „ith a vi.w t.. distril.ntion ..f the pr.„......ls ..n«st th,. n...mh,.rs .,f the s..ll,n« ,„„„,,,„. ,ann.,t he n.ade un.hr a p..w..r in th.. n .-..an.lnn. ,.ve„ ,l.o.,sh i„,n,.Kli;.tely f.,lh>w..d l,y a volnntary w in,lin.--„p. For ohs..rva„ons „n tins a,.,.ision. sei. .,-/-■'-. Chap. XNI. \f„.r the aiinenient has h,.en ratiH..d. the -al ..f ,1... .-ompany >!. ■ id hr affixed t.> a inem.iran.lnni at th.. fo.,t of the airr,...n.,.nt as follows; 1-, Hs, XNT W a m..,lulioi. imsso.l a. a o-o,,..,;.! ,„...Mit.o: o< Tl.o — Form 44. ( ov. Limttl, hel.l tho - .lay .d' . .he al-.-v aorof,,, ,s In.v lalilii'.!. .\.s«iluosstliiM.,>muioM.s..al.d ilHM„v.this .lay .d Son,..ti,n..s th.. a:;re,-ment is ,„a,l,. .-on.litiona „s l>..ins.- a.lopt,..!. nn.l, r „.,., I'i- of the .\,-, of I9IIH, r,.pla,inK se.t. Hil ,.f the M of ISW. '■."■• " > 1''^ a,rn'..m..nt is .„n,li,ional .n, the san„. hein^' a.lopt..d hy the li,,ui,lator ot the ,.,"mpanv. ..nrsnant to a sp.-.ial r,.s.dntion of the ..onM-any ,„nferr,n;r ..n h,m ,1„. ,...,,uisite auth.n.itv. nmler -e.t. H.> of the Compani..s A.-t. lims, l,n, n. sn.h ,as..s tl... provisi.ms of the ai;r....m.nt will n:|„ir.. ,„nsi,l,.rahle n.odihea- tioiis. S,... Chap. X\.. iifh". Som..tim..s tl,.. p..n.hasin« .-o.npany has not. when ,l„. a..M .a,.„t 1- n.;„l,.. p.,wer to pnnhas,. th,- hnsine.s. an,l in s,„h ,as,. it is ..s-ary e.tle,- t,, wa,t nntil the ..hjc'ts .,f th,. pnnle.sini; .-ompany have luen ..xt,.ml.,l I .'titions, Mem.trHitdiim of ratifi.^Htion. ,„/,... Chap. XVU... .)r i. he nia.l,. with C. D.. .>n 1) ;ns,.rt.Hl makini; the a^rree ad,,pt..,l hy the ..onijiany aft. . .if -mil a.loption." isi,,nal as.'r....nn.ni is ri'.iuire.l at .in,-,-, it .'an he ]iiir.-hasin»f .■ompany, and a ,.haise ,1111 he nditional. „". . - "" its l>ein'„' , t!V.•tnally ol,jl•,•ls shall hav,. . .n ,.xl,.ri,l,..l so as to allow .\s to transfer of life insuran,-,. I,usiness,.s. s.... I'oiin L") and IVtitions. Chap. XVII. ,/,", \s to transfer of hanking' l)usiiiess..s whcr.. the vendors ar.. a firm, I'orm 41! .■au he r,.,-,.iilv a.lapi.d. aad wher. the vendors an- :, ,...„i.;>r.y the ahov. lorm .an s.)metim.'.s 1,.. adapted, or .,ne of th.' forms in I hap. XXL, -'/''-. O.ea- si,mal'v, hot\e\er, sp,..-ial pr.ivisi.>ns ;.re r,..iuir,.d. .(74 AORKKMKXTS [Chap. V. It! ii- Fonn45. Ajfn'i'Uieiit fitr tratisfor of life iisfiuraiico buNinoHK. ( untracts anil lialiilitioK to tic taken iiTor. AHgef« to be made over to in(>et lia- hilities. How sueli :. The 15. shall make over to &3 ('. asset.s suHicient as on the .sd .ilst day of Uec<'mber. lit -. to provide lor the liabilities to be assumed by the ('. ns afsd. ;i. For the purpose of asc-ertainino- the amount of the as.sets to l)e made over to the (". a.s uf.sd the value of the liabilities Ui be under- taken bv the ('. as afsd shall be ascertained and certified by I,, and M. upon the bases and principle following, that is to say: — {I. ' Valuation to be made as on the 31st day of Dcroinber, 111 — . 1 2. I The Mortality Tables to be employed shall be (at for the assurance contract.s. the Institute of Actuaries" H. M. (5) Table, and ib) for the annuities, the tiovernnient Experi- ouie Table, 1884. (S. i The rate of interest assumed in the calculations shall be 3 p.c.p.a. throughout. (4.1 The premiums to be valued shall '..e the ordinary premiums only throwino- otf all e\tia i>reniiums for health and in- stalments and conimis.sion (if anyi. (.".. 1 The proportion of the annual premium income reserved as a provision for future e\|>enses and proHt-s shall be 10 p.c. and such further ])ercentaire as the valuers shall ajrroe upon, not exc(>ediuarticular assol.-< uliiih are to be made over to the ('. p\irsuant to clause 2 hof. .■.. If the sd L. & M. shall ditfer in repird to any such valuation as in claases 3 and 4 hof, then and in sucn case the ilifterence shall be referred to X.. of. I'kc., actuary, or to some other person selected by the B. and the ('.. and the award of such person shall be^conclusive. 0. The H. shall account to the C. for all ])remiums and other moneys tallinfr or accruinp; due after the 31st Dew'mber, 19—, and FORMS. .1 tl.fl B in loxwct of su. h ttssuniiK-c loiititi.ls as from the :::Uec.c' .1^^. 10 . 1! <•- CV shun ho docuod ,o bo 1....0 to boar Tan rtvoun all pav.nent.s ma.lo by tl.o B. iu rospo.t nt tho sd '" . ?i rrLt and annuities accrued or ou.orgod a. Iron, the T;;:::.' Zr.r l . and a ,roi.>r account shall be n.ade ou, :;..;. ^l"^ud if ll.e balan«, is against the C the asseU to U, ovtr to it under .lauso 2 hof .hall be reduced pro tanto. ""^ Th r ^idne" the asset, ol tho B. .hall be converted into nun.oy , V ,he pro..eeds of such conversion shall bo retained by ho Injr^^ : ^iTrt applied in payin, o.f the debt, and Induht^ ■ f the B which art., not to be as.sun.cd by the C. a« als.l, and ol "luhec^'s charges an.l expenses of the parties hto and of the hqrs , le rSl atncident to the winding-up and final di.ssolu.um ol 1 an^Hr surplus shall bo distribufed among the shareholders 1!, ,he B. in accordance with their rights and interests ,n the xssot. "^*'' Th^ C-. «hall accept, without objection or .-equisition, such title „. the B has to the assets to be made over as aforesaid. .The C. shall enlarge all the .ssuranc^ contracts to be made oyer ,s afsd and which shall not have bo.ome claims belore the agreemt ,s ■auctioned by the Cour, in manner following^ t^t . o say:- 375 Form 45. Application (if residue of .Vi-ct'ptiiucc of title. Knlar^piufTit of uxMuriincf <:ontriut^. (ill a>} ineu uv ine <„uuii «■■ .u......~ - c- Bv making all death or maturity claims payab o w.tlun • fourteen days after the delivery and approval of the proofs of death or maturity and of title. By freeing all such contra.t-s from all conditions in .estriot.on of travel, residence, or occupation. ,0. Moreover, tho C. shall o,H,n an account and on}h^'^^^^ December. 19-, and on the JUst December in each su-.toeding >ear shall carry to the c«,dit of such account a sum equal to o p.c. o he , cniuiuVevenue on such of the sd assurance contrac s .. con .bo i.li, to participate in profits during the year ending ''"''h • '^ IKliber! and the sums from time to time standing to the cr.ii o, „„.h account shall be deemed to carry interest at tho rate of ^P^^'^- will, voarlv rests, and on the SUt Decombei, 19-. and at the ox- J^^iTof each succeeding quinquennial period, , he ^;^o.ni..^^ I the credit of such account shall be appropriated by w. equiv.dent reversionary bonus for the benefit of tho holders ol the sd as::;a.. contract, whose assura.u.s .hall on -eh 3lst December^ 1..- or at the expiration of each such quinquennial pe.iod. bo in force or capable of revival and in proportion to the premiums ol *'"l r?he B. and the liquidators thereof shall procure the directors of the B to give to the C. an un.lertaking that .such directors shall, for a ..cnua of at lea^t three years from the date of the rosoludon con- firming the winding-up, for the same i-omuneration rosply as they now i^cive and from such last-mentioned date to be pd by the C, assist in consolidating the transfer, collecting the assets, and Quimtuennial account to h*" opencil for benefit of participHtiii)? holders. Dinwtors nf tranNferor i!ompimy to assist in cob.-^Udatin^ the transfer, 4o. -^maa^^- 37fi AtiKKKMKNTS. [Chap. V. Form 45. Stuff t« Iw titken over. linlaiiiiiij.' ami ilov<'lo(ii.i^' tin- l)ii-'iiio>>* . oniu'ctioiix «i lli<' H Inilcmnity ct< ir», tniMtt-*'?*, ttiid oth«r officer?*. Liability of transferor comp»ny liinitc'l to its property, and of its infraberM to their liability un their shares. Completion after xanction of Court. Charjres on aftwetH of transferor company not Ui be prejiiiliced. Winding-up. MfHlitieation of the arranjjenient . Deed jioU covenanting with piilicy holders, tScc, to observe thi; agreement. rolaticm to the poliiies ami aiiiitiilip-* i<> l>o tniiislViicil piirstiaiil lilo. 12. Tlu' {'. Kliall tako ovi'r the stall of llu- 1!.. ami imli'imiif.v tiic H. agaiiLsl all 4laiins ior salary or otlicrwi-o by tlio iiiciulxTs of thai ^l^ilV al fr.ni the .'list DccciulM'r, 1!» - . and shall n-coiip to tlio M. all lKi\ iiifiilN ma.lo l.y the B. in lospi'.-t ihoV. ami of all i>ro|HT t)tli(C ami other o.\i)Oii.ses inciilont to llio carry iiiu: on of tho Imsinos-. as from tho .seinn. and accordiniily the individual lialiility of each iiroprielor is linitd to liio amount unpaid ent to. I'.t. When and so soon as this ay:reeuit has been sanctioned hy the ( oui t as hnttr provided, the C. shall execiiti' a deed poll covenantino' with the holders of the assurance contract and annuity contiac t- t.. he taken over as afsd to olisorve the provision^ in their favour re-ply herein r-ontaineiiic-s is transferred on tlie footing' that the company which tjikes it over shall place the assets of the husnic>.cs in a separate rciiid to lie woi kcil for the benelit of the policyholders in tlic> tn'nsferrinsr eompany, and to he the primary fund for answering policies and claims, the transferrinif ccimpany •fiaranteeine its siiihcieney and takinff any surplus. Very commonly the companv which takes over the eom-crn is f;iveii tlic> riifht to a pcnciit:.-.' of the income of thi> fund FUKM8. f.,r working it. fh. f.-ll-wi...' i- «" ••"•'i"" "' "■;' .'■'""*'^ Fonn46. SS^n:";.:;:™' ::;:.. ....'-> ^ -•"■'-■ ^ uj 1(1111 |Hii«iit ion >rf F.M./»/ IIXM-X'.///" TlMNM.Kl.;(..Ml-\NV. Form 46. ■J..." ■ ■"■'■■•' ■-""'' ":;:rt:!.';-.;;:i!:.''u:t£,.,. ami i..- to 111' tii"''i of truu«- Till' \ '"V KllUil. ::la i!;'.;:" ^ ni; .. „....' ....■ .l... ,...,,..- l..,..- nu.u,i,.ue.l. ana ^p.„. is to ilill.' ;ilsa.ts In.- ^ho ...,.,• .mum- m.I.- ,f , All sums ..'•■oivo.l in vos,u..t .i anv ,n,n,..oM..so. •'^'""S^'^'"^; ♦• imHlili.-atiou. substitution, o, o.hor .R'aLu^- .a tvlation to tho A. policy ami aiiuuitv i-outracts. .. TlK. A . rami is to 1k' ki',.l ^oparati- l.o.n tho ,.-u.>al as.'.s of tho Jru^ of l; ■( ov ami is to 1... n.j,^ank..l a^- a t.us, luu.l appii.al.li' lor iho iK'noht of ,l...o outitli'd to A. policy ami annuity -ontnuH ami '■"'- 1~ t,,.a>.ls whou, thi' A. Coy .s uudcr lial.iUty. an,l -;-' '"^'^^^^^ ,1.0 \ fuml the 15. Cov i.s in.m liu.o to tuuo a.nl ui .In.. .-.Mn.s,. to ,,av .satisfy, ami .liMlnu;r.. all .lain.s an.l u.on.'vs f.on. turn' to uuo pavahlo in ,i.sp.',.t of th.- A. l»oli.ios an.l annuity .tracts, a... >U :uu.s paval.1.. in .vspi-.. of c,n..p..>...is..-. s.-nc-lc. <»• ■;"-"- ' rolati. n U, A . p.-licic's a...l ai.nuiti.'s. an.l all su.us ,.avahl.' to tin li. Cov liv wav .,t n'coup......t as l.nft, provnU'.l. a.ul all p.v.n.,....s ..u n'-■in^u.•an.;. poli.ios olU-cto.l in rolati.... to any A. p..l...cs o.- annuity co..l.a.ts, an.l all .lain... lial.ili.ios, p.'nsu.n. an 1 all su.ns tro.u tu.ie to ti...o pavahlo U. tho B. CMy ov ..tl.onvis.' hy way ol coutnl... U.m to n.a..a,o...ou. oxpeu.sos o. otho.wiso .....ler .■la..se .-, hot, a..a all ..th. , ^ ' .... ...... ..... tll.K) ... t lit llltll- ilchts a...l lia in.'iui'i.iom u li.ios of the A. ( oy oxis.i.i- at .1..- tin.o of tho .o.u hi f tlii.s All, iil all "ihoi- .'Uuis uM ilor tlio.at.u- pol.cy- holdocs of tho A. Coy. 37H AOKKKMENTH. [Chap. V. Form 46. Traimfrrw vumiwuy to undertake Iisbiliti>'» i)( tratiKfenir ronipaiiy. Muiiiiirvtnpnt I'Xp'IlHMI. Tompnrsrjr ailvuiireit. HBuafrement and control of fund. Quinquenniiil valuationn. No new polieied or annuitioH to b<' Krant^'d witli ri'fereurc to the fund. Participating holders only entitled to profit* of fund. Transfer of sUff. Fond and transferee's property alone liable. Aft of Parlia- ment or sanction of Court. .1. The H. Coy i" to I* lialilo in the plmc of tho .V. Coy upon ami ia ww|io( t of all tho (li'btx. liahilitios. lonfrartM and enpipnniontfl of flir A. Coy, incluilint? it« policuw and annuity contracts, but upon thr footintr lluil Hs lialtility is prinuirily to bo out of the A. fund, and if thi.'< simil 1)0 innumiionl or oxhuuHtiHl. thon out of its own fund iind ))rop«rty. I. Out of tho i)ron»iuin« « conliibution towards inanagrenifni exjionwoN to bo lakon by tho H. C>>y.l .">. H. Coy to be roiou|)od with inloiewl lonipoiary ad va net's. j H. I'roviKious for tho iiuum>roMioul and control of llif A. fund by the directors of tho B. Coy.j 7. iQuinquonniul valuations and distribution of suii)lus inonoys to participating policyluddor*. 8. No now policy or annuity coniract to l)0 gruntod with rcforoncc to tho A fund e.vept upon a surrondor and in mibstitution, Ac] 9. [^Participating policyholders of tho A. Coy only entitled to jiarticipato in profits of tho fund.j 10. [Provision for tho transfer of statt.j II. Provision that fund and proi)orty of B. Coy are alone to be liable if noctls be.] 12. [Provision for obtuiniug Act of Parliament to effectuate the transfer or otherwise for obtaining the sanction of tho Court.] Form 47. Acrf.emkxt /w S.m.k «/ P.vii xts. Considkk.vtion : ("ash «»provenients on the inventions referred to in tho sd patents lesply. and of all further inventions in connection with tho uianufactun" of -, which have boon already or may hereafter bo made by the vendor, and all Bri)i.sh patents which may be obtained by or on behalf of the vendor for any such improve- uieuU 01 futthcr inventions. aii;l the full and exchi-ivo boiiofit tltof , Having regard to the Patents, Designs and Trade Marks .Vet, 1883 (46 & 47 Vict. c. 57), as amended by the Patents and Designs Act, 1907 (7 Ed. 7. c. 28), there ia no need to provide that the purchaser shall be entitled to apply '(■i m;Ji ■(.M :»7rt POKMS. . ,. for infrintf.-nioi.t. nr to di«l..i.ii. in«»m...l. a» tl.v A. t form 47. ::.r;:rt :;;:.rr,;:-^e..^-.. ,.«.. o„ «.... «» ..... p. ";.r.u:r .1:::^.. u..ua«. fo.i.„ « w.« . b^uuh puten.. .nu- .. Tlio vrndor .hall «.U »nd «ho .■oopany .haU pur. h...rt- „„.ti.:t'rS- ..bU. .hereinafter ..».U^ .he pr t ...ve..- ir Nneti, of any foreign patent- whie. '''-''^j":::;;; .J I.., „, nn Uhalf of the vendor in respeit of th< pr.« m re:ftio'':. :J.l:tl.. of «.. ,.ndU.. ne.oti„tin„, for the r'"r'!i;1f':^'':.rin:;ntion, whh.h ..an ^.■ »...,. ..y the IL:::! el:!li.!: with the n.a„nf„..ture or worMn. of eh.tr... -^'C"'rsri=nrri::,i lathe he f iCnt'SLo... and prolon.atlo f the ter privileges Krant.Ml hy any m.eh patent. a» aforesa.d. T»i« fnllowinir i"* mon* Umitou: . he patent, for the United Kin,d,.n.. Krun.e. (iermany An.tr.«. ^dor or otherwise, for patents for sneh unproven.ents, a.u. th. full and exelnsive benefit of all patents so ohta.n.Kl. 4 n 111- Wnilaee and illiamson, Pat. p. 330. •^•v^-tJtha?::: "in>prov.n.cnts- under a eove,.ant to eo a.e .n.pr, „,ents, see //.,,A."« v. ;''''''«'^' /■'''■• '"^ ^ l,„7hv two or n.ore patentees. ^;*:.!r r:;7r r':-:::- :" v:ri. a««o, . c. .0= .., -1 S-f ;^S..^ ^- rid ...n.eU of ;--V ^ ---'^ '"-^ . to a limited eon.pany. f»».»-.»7' v. .SV,,™-7. (1900, 1 Ir. B. ., A. the .0U.SOU for th. sale, tho coy ^hall pay to the veu.lo. the C.,„«der:,. .u^ of 3,00«i. c^h. and Hhall i.s«ue to hint or Ins "o.-unoes tho who e o" the 100 founder^' shares of U. each iu the .>a,...a ot the .-..>. and .uch 8lu.rc« shall he doe.ned for all i^^^^'^'" f'.;'^.^, ,,.,,j incidental 3 The vendor slmll fi.-m ti.uc tu time, wth al! .ill ■luill I'lHiii liiiH' \« liiiK' ami al all liiucH ,lmiM« tlic Icniiof MMii.s tc. !«• ■■iiiii|iiin'il I'limi. .V.',. and uiilmiit iiiakiiitr iiii\ 1 liaiyv llu'H'ior. l'Im' iiH >'i' li advirr. cxi.laiialiuii. anil iiisinn limi to Ihi' .liri'.li.r.s ami i.llicf ..lliii-i'. ami wi.i kiiifii of iIm- i'ov aiiriio««". at lli.M'\|K'ii-i'i>f tlii'iuv inopaivaml fiuiiidi tollii' io\ all ruMi— ;ii\ |ilaii.'«. ilrauiiiirH. ami iiioilfl-' Tills ,liiu«. r.-.|iiiic> "Niir ilikriil iiimliliriitiiai wlan loiriKii |iutfiit.< iirr -"li. I. The imrliall be ii.iiiplcliMl nil till' da.N of .iH.Ac, when lli<> .■^d KUiii oi .t.tMIO/. ra>li -liall la' |"l to tlir MMidor.amI llio .-d foiiml.T.- shan- .shall Im. alhtllfd a^ al> ina.v r.'a.sonald.x la- iv(|Ui, ;'d 1>\ iIi.mov for lanvinir iIh' -ale into i'H.mi und jrivin^' to ili" lov ilu ill li<'m>tii of the aLrircnil. .••."riil.'.x^ l.ffor,. till' (lav of n.'\t ai Ica-l .^laif- in the lo.vs rapital shall liavi' I a taken ii|> hv r.-poiisiMi' |..msoii.s. oithor of the |iarti.'.s h a\ l.\ nolirc in «rilinin h ivMi.ssion sh.dl not -ive riliall not i»- s»M miiliT .i spci-iHi-il pri.e, and a jiun luHci- will not I).- ablr to as.' tin- article in i travrntioii of this condition. ltn,U,rhe Ai.ili,) ,IHr otherwise) t patented inven- tions for all or »pocitied purposes within a limited district. Hut there was prcat ditticulty in framiiiL' these concessions satisfactorily: for a patentinl article duly made und sold .arried with it in,,,,,; l„ ,„;,„ ,,i- ,,..„.„. r..r »ny p. ;""';,;,„,. ^,,„„„, ,„ .,„..,.., ,„ that M.„, ,.. .■tr....H.lly a* .r .1..- ,mt.-nt *'-r.- "^''^ '^ > "^^^ , ,|,.„l„„.,l ... f..ilit...- """.:r"Ti"7 : :t'ir: >" ..«, ..;'...■. « , ar.i,.i.. :M1 . 1H4: Wiillaci- mi.l iVilliiim- .„,. for infrin^-mon... if - 'nt-n-Uxl. //.-/y- ";' ■ ♦^ ,,^ - > III 'lUUa I a. .tlim I I I Hf I ll'l .I'll"'''' '■ -.. 'I.«t - l- iun. puy».l.- "''',;"''•,,.,,, ,^„,.,,,, for val, an„..t / rnl„rriH I'.itv UK iKjnmdrratioii t.ir a *•>'> ■ ^ ' " ;!.;:•;::;;(;.. revok.,1 ..y ».... ^r..u>r u. ..y th,. «ra„.,.. ..f .- ::s:':^".'t''^r:;;i:;:,r;r;:=.,;^-::r^. ,- '^' '• . , ,.ntitl...l l.v a-sii:„>n..|.t and transmi«u.i. ..r ..ll..r „ ..„t i;...„.-.., as to or ..t....rw,... .l..al wi... t.... .an..-, an.l o «,>.■ . ff. . I ;: ,, f. any .-.-nsid.-rati,.,, f.,r su... a.»i.M.nu.n.. li.-.-n -r < ..aln.«, prov,d.d rcMipt-. r.irany ...n „.,„.nf. d.-^iu'n. .>r trad.' marii may 1.0 that anv ».,|mt..- m r..^i....t of so. h pat. nr. . .,,.^,,. ,.nror...d in like niann..r a- it .n r..sp.-. . ..r .„.y "tl.r p.r-,..» -r jr.... rt> . - >; - ^-f^-t '■' "'^ '•:^r::i::::r" •:::;:;:.'"> -;:;-- ««f!^^W!"!P 4." ^.. :i82 AGKKEMENTS. [Chap. V. M m Form 48. Agreement to trrunt licence Ki company to manufacture li;ood<*for lioennor. Esoluwive licence to company. ( (nly tran«fcr- .iblc with ^•OIl^ent Citinpauy to Mipjily itynili - cute with macliines. Rt>i.'ulatiou an to ordens. Siijiplx . I'ric Nc« nc.l kindi' '.les. \X AGREPLMT nmde the - - day of , betwcDu The Syndiruto. Limtd vhnftr called -tho Syndicate'), oi the one pt, and The Coy, LLmKl (hniti called -the Coy"), of tho other part; W'HERKliV 11 IS AIIRF.ED aS foUoWS: — 1. The Syiulicate shall grant to the cny an exclusive licence - ,n To ii.anulactiire in tho Iniled Kin to carry on its business tho sd licence shall determine. ';; The deed -rantiui. tlie sd licence js to confer on tho syndicate Ihe ri-lil from time to time during the continuance of such licence to order and obtain from tho coy electri<:al machines of any kind from lime to time manufactn.vd by tho coy, wlielher under the sd licence ur under anv other licence or otherwise, but upon the footing that the goods sJ ordered shall only bo for use by the syndicate for tho purposes of its own manufacturing business. 4. Every order under the last prec^-ditig clause shall bo in writing and shall state spccitically ,a) The number and .liaracter of tho machines and apparatus ordered. ,bi Tho time when they are re na.uo ' ; iica.o for restraiuin. .he n.n.inuan.e ..f such ".•r."se,u.uj n.l .he ...V shall have full .o.ulu.. of su.h ,.,o,-..Kl.njj.., an, n a> a ; : , :l.ion ,rosecu.e. .o.apou.ul, dis...,utiuue. aban ,-n. nv ,1.m1 .. h ,„. .a.uo, an,l shall l-e cutld .o all .lan.ai.^es ol..a.u...l ,n n |,o, ,iK. ' , In ,,s.. be eu.ld m the na.ne of .he svndica.e .o ,ake al such "Ldings as may seo.u expedieu, .o ,h. -oy. ...h a v.ew .., eu- ?;.;.,, any undcrU.king or InjunHion .h.. n.ay he ob.a.nod .. ho " rs,. of such proc.>edings, and for obtaining .ho coumu.tal oi ay J,>ons for .on...up. in resinnt of any broach o anv such und«- Uin.' or injunc.iou. Nevertheless ,he coy shall at all tMne. Loop \l s;„dica.i inden.niiied agains, .11 expens.. and ou.gon.gs oc«j- ioned bv anv such proceedings, and on .he other hand .he svndna :i,ll exi-cn.e and do all such things us ,hc coy n,av rcasor.ablv rcouire for facilitating such proceedings. Proper accoun.« for the purposes hof shall be kept l,y .he o<^ Accu,,.. showing .he lowest pri.^'s from time .o .inu> chargc.l by .t and ,vndica.e shall have the option from ti.ne to twu,- ol testing th. ,,,,„,,„., of such accounts by employing an in.iepcndcnt auditor or auditors to oxaraiue the books of the coy. or by calling tor a stamtorv .ledaration by .ho sec..,tary of the cov veniymg t he pnco .ot forth in such ac-ount, and in the former case the coy shall g.v Mich auai...r or auditors all reasonable facilities for making such examination, and in the latter ...se shall procure its .e.relary to make such declaration. , , ,, ■. ,n. The <.onsou for the sd licence to be granted pursuant to c . 1 C.-'^-- l,„f is to be a sum of 1! , ^^•hich sum is .,. bo .satisfied by .ho allot- n.ont .o the svndicate of ^ fully paid up shares ol 1/. each in the cai.ital of .he xlensions .hof. |.. The licence afsd is to continue during all .he residue unexpired I-rao..,. of the terms of vears granted or conferred by the patents specihed in the schedule h.o, and during all p.olonga.n.ns and extensions of the same terms. Ill The .<1 licen.t.. shall be by dee.l. and it shall be .-oinplctcd on (^un,,,lct.o„. (he — .lay of ^^ . at the offi«-s of Messvs, . of - -. when .he and at the sam.- timu same s ihall iic executed and delivered to .he 384 AGKEKMKNTS. [Chap. V. t! Form 48. tl'C cov shall oxoculo a ((luiitfMimi'l tliof and deliver tlin same to tlie syndicate iiiid allnl the sd shares. Ix WITNKSS. lie. S( IIKDI I.K I'iDili iiliiis of Pdtciilx.'] Form 49. Parties. AifTt'emcut for sale. Inspection. Title. (Jongident- titm . Completion. TrauntniHsion J if r-"rtififat.pa and deben- ture.". A(iRF.i;Mi:\T /wSai.k to ('omivwy nf FouKir.s Minks. AN .VUREEMT made the f .3. The vendor .shall make out to the .satisfaction of the cov u tide to the scheduled ac<-or ai..i ilobeiiluie-. and tran.-iiiil the .-ame (o L.. there lo be ready for issue at the time for compl'lioii. Kadi of iIk' sd certificates shall compii^' share-, and the sd (h'benliiros shall be in the form set forth in the second schedule hlo. K0RM8. .'i«r» Anent. 7. Tlie coy shall also appoint some pei-won in L. to bo its attorney Form 49. or ayiuit, with full powers in relation to the completion of the sale, and t^Iiuil notify such appointinont to the vendor not Iot<8 tlian *Iiall be given to the coy at Pw^wic \\\<' tihio for completion, aname in good repair and condition, and shall work the mines and mill.- in as full and eilectual manner as the .same have liitherto been worked. As from the imnhasois or llioir iiwion^ shall have the option of (mi- (■liiu0,000/. (cl That the now coy has a workinp; capital of .)0.000/. ((\) That the jjurchasers shall have exercised the option fjivon them by clau.se 1 of this afrrcenit, ami shall have resold the coii- ces.sion to the new coy, or in the alternative that the new coy, as the assiffus of the purchaM>rs, shall have exorcised the sd option. .">. Until the time for comidetion hnftr mentd. or up to tho expira- tion of the sd period of three calendar months, in ciiso the sd option shall have been i)reviously exercised, the syndicate shall comply with all the terms of tho sd concession, and keep the same from beconiint; forfeited or void. (i. If the purchasers or their assi-rns should exercise the sd option. the purcha.se shall be complelerl with all convenient simed Ihoreaflcr. and before the - - day of — , 189ti, when po.s,session of the land comprised in the sd concession shall be f;iven to tho i)urcha.sers or their lussiirns, as the case may bo. and tho syndicate shall execute anil do all a.ssurances and things for vesting the sd concession and all it« interests therein in the purchasers or their assigns, and thereupon he 8(1 (onson shall bo pd or satisfied, and |)Os.session shall, as soon as oi> or ihoir Form SO. ii.-.sifrii- kIiuII. Iiofoie ihi; time linljefore (i.\ointl. cash, to raymont. Ill' pd hv the piircha.M-r.^ immediately on the e\erinion hof. and the -li -Krii ~iiall he letaineil liy the syndicate whelhei- the >d option t-hall ■II .-lull! iKil he exeniseii. and shall not in any ciise he treated as pd iri accMiiiil oi the .--d purchase conson. ;•. Should ilie mI anient not report as to the title to the sd concession Title. lo the .-ailstiii tion of the purchasers or their assijrns liefoie tlie (hi\ ol . I'.td , the piircha-sers or their as.siirn- may, at any time ilierciiftei liefore the completion of the .sd purchase, liy notice in "riliny to the .syiidirale, annul the .sale; an 8h1i'. t-|ieciliod in the .schedule hto, together with till Uie gear, stores, and other elfects. nnd the benefit of all contracts nnd engagements therein na'iitd rc2 i'll :«8 Form 51. ConHidprii- tion. Completion. AORRKMENTf*. [( 'H.\P. V. 2 The con«oii for the s.l sale shall 1)0 .12.000/,. which shall ho 8ati.>*fieai(l up tho eight «hiiro.s which by the .ov'h moiiKl.n of a.sson, the »iib.soriber.s thereto ( inoludinp tho vendors) have ncfreod to take up: and as to the balance (2 by the allotment U> the vendors, in the proportion specified m tho second schedule hto. of the re.uaininp: fifry-six shnres in tho cov s onpital: .xuch share^^ to he .loomed f..r all piiri)0>.e.« tully pd. S,.metii.ics the vendors smi tlieir friemls »iib,.oribo the momora-..lnm f,.i all the share!). .■5. The i.iuvha.se shall be < onii.letcd on the day of . and thereupon the vendor.-^ shall transfer tho sd steam-ship and premises to the coy, free from incumbrancos. No duty is pavablc on the r«.l.'. transfer, or otiicr disposition of any ship oi vessel, or int<-rest or property therein. Sec Schedulo to Stamp .\et, 1891 . 4. See Form 31. cUikxc lf>.i I.V WITNESS, itc. [Srheduh'-s-^ I I tllrm,, iH,r(>rMU,r.-< of shif. rfr, ; r2) shou-i„f, hn„- shares to he apportioned.'] Sometimes the a^retMnent for sale provides for the appointment of some of the vendors as nianaRors at spe.'ified remuneration; but it seems better not to disclose this in an afrrecment which mu.^t he filed. As to sale of ship at instan.c of share-owner where majority sell to a .ompnny. «ee Hr Urre^mrrf. (IBMi P. 284. Form 62. AN AOKEEMT made the day of . 1901, betweou A. H. Satisfaction of of , the vendor, of the one pt, and the - - ('oy, Limtd vhnftr part of price called " the coy '' ). of the other pt, supplemental to a contract (hnlti in paid-up , , nnal contract"-), dated the day of , and mad Himres called "the ppal contract "-», dated the day of , and made between tho same parlies: Wiif.rkiiy it is agreed as follows: — 1, The sum of £ . i)t of the cash portion of tlie price payable by tho cov under clause 2 of the ppal coutract, shall be satisfied by the allotment to the vendor of fully pd-up shares iu the coy of £ each, numbc. — to - inclusive. 2. The ppal con . . i .shall bo varied accordingly. ;i. This agreemi is conditional on the same being approved by the statutory mooting nf the coy now about tn be held. As WITNESS. &c. When it l,e.<.mes nei.ssary to vary a contru.t referred to in the prospcitu- suoh variation re-piires the approval of the statutory mee.injt. See sect, 8.1 ■>! the Act of 1908, Kiiprn, p, :J'24, F'OKMS. im Ar.RlKMKNT as to ISSIE of V\W-IV SlIAKKS lo Vr.NDORS NOMIMKS. Form 53. Ihmuo of puiil up 4iiireK til vi'iidiir's noniinoeo. Parties. VN MIKKEMT nmdf the .lav oi , I'J'H, l.<•l^voou .V. B., ,, ' ,liiittr .uUoJ 'the voudui- J, of Uio Urst p), iiml the — - ,0N l.iml.l 1 hnltr calk-l - the ...v ' i. of the .so.ond imrt, and C. I)., „,■ -- ,.f Iho third pi. Wmukk.s by a.i a-mMul .liidtr .•aUf< ■,!,.. ,„i.|iininarv .outract '), datcu th.' — day of -, 10-, and ,„a,l.. hclweon Iho vou.lor, .,f tl.c ...;o pt, and tl.o r..y, ol tl.o other ,„ ,,,.,vi.-i..n «a.s made for the .ale to the .oy of cerlain ppty, and ni'of the cousou for the sd sale wa« to be the ullot.uent to the vendor o, hi,, nominee, of fuUy pd-up .hare, in the .oy ol 1/. each, u,.n.l..-red - to ^ imln.sivo. And wherkas the vendor .lesiren to Invo divor.s of the .sd .hares alh.ttcd to the s.l C I), a., his nonuneo, a„,l 10 pla.e the eov in a po.sition t.. tile a contr..,! eon.st.tuting tiio title of siuh r-ilottees to .uch .shares. Xow iiikkkiohk m is .x.;kk!;u a* follows:— I Tiie .oy .shall a« and when tlie lime for the alioln.ent of liio etd Allotment shnre.> -hair arrive or shall forthwith] allot the sd - *s such nominee fully pd-up shares, pt of the sd - ~ «haros. ■2. The .S.1 shares shall be uumbere.l - - to - - itulnsive. Numbers. I\ \V I IN ESS, &0. \\l,..r.- shares arc to Ik- ullottcl to tho veiulor's .u.i.um.h., it appears to I.e ,le-ital,le to make and tile a suppl ntal eontraet as al,o^e eousftntmK H.e ,i,le ,„ allotn.e„t of the „o,nM.e.-s; for seet. 88 of the ,\et of I'MW re.pures that i„ the ease of shares allottel in whole or in part for a ,.„ns,o< heavy pecuniary penalties ,.n the d.pvt<,rs and ntKeialH for non-eomplianee. See «»;o", pp. (U t>(i. It is oiKM. to arninient that the principal e.n.traet d.K's not • eonst.tnt.- the title „f the nonunee to sue), ullotn.ent " ; his title a,.pears to I on- stitut.'.l hv the eontra.t plus the nomination: yet the section says, " eon- stitatin^' the title of the allottee to the aUotment," not constituting' wholly nr in part the title of the I'Mottee to the allotment. No .loul.t, where the se.tinn says "a contract," .l.at would cover several successive contrac s, SB fnr example, where the sale is for so many paid-up shares to be allotted to the vendor or his nominees, and afterwards, for valuable considera- tion, the vendor eontraets to sell some of these shares, and to nominate the pnrcha.-ers. The second eontraet would be a contract under which the title of the allottee to the allotment wa.s constituted. So, too, where in th.> original .ontraet the nominee is a .■e>t,n ./'"■ ''"»' °f *'"' ^■'''"••"•' '""^ '"*" «''<^''^f"'''' "" etiuitable rigbt to the allotment under the eontra.t, tliat would be sufficu-nt to constitute his title. The expression " a contract in writing " does not import that the writing must besigiKHl by the vendor and the c.,ii.paiiy and the allottee, but it must be a .ontraet eon«titutin« the title of the .lUottee to su.'h allotment. .Vicrdiiigly. where there are several nominees, it is a common pruitiee to make a su|ipleiiieutal contract between the parties to the original contract and »omo person purporting to act as trustee for and on behalf of the proposed allottees, ! £ »90 Form 53. AOKKEMKNIS. rc;HAi>. V. and then tn |.ri.\lilr thirclii for iillciimcnt tn tlicni acciiiiliiiifly. In ii»y riino. it Kccnia far l><>tlor ti. |)rcii on tlir ■Mitiiiii fl I" li'iiv"' tlis directors oprn tn tlii' ri«k of penaUic-i aciruiiijr. Sonii'linii-. iin allotment in niiiili- to ii iionii witliout filinit any i tim t ronstitutinn lii« titif to «uili allotrnint. and the i|uestion aii«i'< wlietlirr. after ullotniehl. it i" |M)i«il)le to make a rmitraet " eonstitutiiiK " the titl.> of the allottee to »iieh allotment. It \* diffienlt to »ce how this ean bo done. No diiulit « eontraet imrportin^' to .-onHrni or ratify the ajrropmont niiiili lie made and tiled. I.nt aniens the aM.itment was in some -elite irre).'nlar or voidalple. it seeniH diffienlt to hohl that «mh a eontraet '■ I'onstitntes " the title. Thn allottee ai nominee of the vendor nniy have a perfeetly sfiMxl title to the nharen as paiil-u|i -hares. I>ut i>enalties may nevertheless Xw rnnnintr. It niiiiht, lio« - ever, he |iossil.lo to olitaiii an order from the Conrt extendini; the tinn> for tiling the recinisite eontrait (^e,' the proviso to suh-seet. (3. of sect. SS). I'or this pnrposo it would only he neee-sary to show that thn>n(rh inadvertinee no eontraet (■onstitntin^' the title of the allotted hod heen mach- or tiled, and th" order having' heen ohtaincl. tlic> i|nestion wonid arise what ahoid the previoas allotmiMit; that wonId not he invalidat.Hl. and the order merely extends thi' time for tiling', anil does not exti'nd tla' time for makiiiL' tl ntraet. so that the trround is not icmipletely eleareil. Another plan is to proieed under suh-seet. (i: of seet. S,S of th.> Aet to Hie partieulars of a eontraet which was not redHeent this lias to lie done within the montli. Thus the makintr of a c.uitrai t with the ninninees of a trustee for them at the proper time, that is hefore allotment, is th y satisfai-torv course. Form 54. Agkeement h, Isst i. Paii.-i i- SirvKi.s in SAHsiArxioN »i Dtm mi, 1)11 Company. AN AGREEMT inade the - du.v of , bciwwii tlio A. M. B. Coy, Liiutd (linftr culled tiic A. Coy i. of the one pt. and the C. U. and E. Coy, Liiiitd (huftr called the C. Coy i. of tiie other pt. liccitals. WiiERKAs l)y an agroomoiit, dated the -- day of . and made hctweeu the C. Coy. of tlie oiio pt. and the A. Coy. of *hf other pt (boiuK the a,000/.. whereof the sum of 7.-.,0i)(l/, is payable by instalments in manner therein mentd: Anp \vuf.kk\s an instalment of 10,000?.. jmrt of the sd last-mentd sum, will become payable to the C. Coy on the — - day of next : Now IT IS IIIIV ACKKKII Us I'olloWs; The A, Com- 1 . The A. Coy siiall. on or before the - day of next, allot panr to allot , ,|,p (- (-^y j",|(K) shares of 10?. each in the A. Coy. which share- 1 .(Mill shares ; Lk^ KORMH. shall be .loomed, for all purpose.. 1« U^ fullv p-l ui'. an-l slmll l.o 891 Form 54 ,.,.,! ill tho liookH of the A Coy Willi the ihmuIh.i to - " ;•■'■" •" '■"■ ■'""•^^ " ' '• ■ t^t^Tuf. "".!" -nl^f. Cov shall a.i.p. the sai.l .hare, in lull ...iKfa.lion ai.-l .u.ip>^^^ ,i;"|,„.r,. „| the sv SiBsrRiBKK /'* Mfmokamm m o/ .\sso.tvti..n ^. Fom 66. sKLi. ftt>' Shark (*»(/ hoio In Thist. V\ ACIREEMT nm.le the - - day of . kMueen A. H. of - , .., Uic one pt. an.l the C. U. Coy, ..f - -^ (hnftr .alle.l ' the A.nencan ..„v-., of the other pt. Where..s the N. C.y. Luutd (hnltr cal ed ilK- English eov • i. was registered umler the Cos Acts. I8.i'.' to 1900, i„ die nwnth ..f April, liiO."., And wi.kkkvs the saul .V. H. Mih- «,ril.ed the meni.lun. of assoii of I lie English .-oy fo.' on- 10/. «hare. Am. WHKI.KAS the sd A. B. is willing t.. s-^ll the s.l .share to the Anii-riean toy. Now TiinRi'i-' IKK. rr is hf.ukuv aokkki. as f..ll..ws. 1 The sd A B. shall .sell, and the Anieri.an ...y shall purrhaso, tlu- ,d sh.. o in the English eoy subsLrihcd for by the s.l A B. i.s af.sd. -. The .■o.ison for the sd .sale shall 1« the sum of lO.v. pai.l ..n the ..xoi. hof, the .«.«ipt of which sun. the s.l A. B. hl.y a,kn..wl<>.lgcs. ;i Until the s.l share shall have lieen transferred 1.. lli.> Anuun-au ,..,v or its nominee as hnftr provided, the s.l A. B. shall .stuii.l ,„;s.os.eliip .> ih manner as the American coy shall from time )1 the sd share in time direct, and t.> shall account to the coy for a respect of the sd share. ,11 divi.len.l- an.l .itlior sums payable in :i9t> AUHKEMENTS. [Chah. V. : tl I ill! Form 55. Fnrahswr to indeBBify. Si)fii«tnre of 'nufer. Notiw. I Tlio AiiHMii'uii I'l.v >lia!l indemnify tlio !*d A. IV, liii oxocutorx, adininistmtriis und ii--sij{n« from and ajjuinNt nil lial)ilitiOM iucidtMit to the lii>ldin<> of the wl share. 5. The Auierjcan coy '^hall I)© ut HIkjiIv at any time lo milhoiize anv iieixon to «i^Mi in lh<> nanio and on Ifolialf of tiio M A.. \i a tian-fcr of tlu' «l share to the American co_v, or to a nominee or nominees of the American (oy. and the American coy may delogalo the aiithonly lihy conforitMl to any person or persons as it may from time to time think fit. ti. Any notiie to the said .\ nay iio given by soiKlinjf the .same tlirou^Hi tlic post addrcsso- -''"-' ^-^^^ '-' '- """"■ „„.,„ fr,.„„.,l «' al">v.-. _^,,_,^_^,., „i„, „„ „,.«Ut.ar. but it ,„,„r,.,. tlM' .o"tr.i.t I- ni«'n to .i.i.-tM.i.. I'-r i .^^ ^j^^_ ::;:!:::;;;1h wuS t':..« f«^ ...■■ .-, .-■^ - '-"- , , I..., I iM'twLMMi A. ol . Form 86a. \V VCUFKMT ma. <• the oli.l.i,iou, A.l, l'.M.«. a .oy .A»ny. i, .j:;:;f'tho .a .o, ...vo r^. .....a.^ a..a have boon ^ovod^ ,1,.. nartios hto, ami by the .aul arts the s.l AH., C- »ml /^^ « „.'., a. ihe liist .lirectors, ami by M.rh art. .t .s . oolaro.l t i.it the :;;::;i;i:„::;.„ ,, a .ii,o..tor ■,. «. b.. ,1,.. hoiai,.^ of .ha„.. m .h.. ooy ol the iioiniiial vubio of i' Now II.KHKfORK IT IS .X..KKKI. a.- folU>W«: , Fach of th. i..o,.o.soa .lir...tois .hall take f.oui .he .oy and pay ,, ,..!;':;;:.li,i.a.i.m .ha..^. af.1. ami the .,v .hall be at liberty ,o allot ihc name to hhu. .. „• ,l,e ,.„v shall not «ithiu - week, f.on, ,he .late hof lavome .„;i.l to eomnu-nce bu-iuess. either of the proposed direeu.r. or the «d M. may by u-.ti.e in wriliat. t.. the other partK>H hto .^.seind this a^icenit. ;; The s,! M. .-hall use his best u..doaN.m..> U< pio.u.e th.- a.l.-puon hof by I he eoy. As WITNKSS, &c. 3M A [ClI.VI-. V. Form 66b. A|(Te«mi'iit to tiikc (lualiticH- tiim unarcB by ilircrtor not H]ip<>int» » XHMl A . of |{, ,,| . V. of , iiii.l I) of , of tlio Olio |)t, unci llw - ( ..^ . Liiiild 1 hiifti- tiillwl • th« i-oy ';, of tlio other yt \Viik.kk\> tlw wl A , I! , (' iiiul I). Imvf Im><'ii duly iipiHiiiitod l>y tho MulwiiilxTx |. till' III) iikIiiiii of U.-'^OIl if the lov to Ik- (liroctoiN Ihof Am> wiikhk\« l.v ihi' iiit« of o.ssoii 111' lh»' coy Iho <)iuililiralioii s: Am. wiikkkas tli.< coy i- itlioiii to i 11 iii-oniH'ctiis invitiiijr KuWriptioiiH lorptof i\* sharu-: uliiin'- Now I IIKKF.KlUl; II IS A(.KKKII a. .. loll. 1 Ku.h of tlnMii tlu- »* II f-.l. Tlu tak kIuiU uUoI tlw sil nhurcs wlioii and ^o ^ooii us tho sLuivs the footiiiir of ciiwh paviuoul plus tho (.s hliy miIi- lii.h on up on >. liliod Hhnli tojxotlior uiiioiiiit to llio luiiiiiiiiiiii Kulv^criptioii on w llio diroilors may procooil to allotmoiit. uiiil not lK>foro tiiat time .1. Tho piopot«fcn tin- dioMtor^. Ah to the appointment of directors bv the siibseriber^ nf ttie niemoniiiiliiin. «e ■ |i. 717, i/i/i". ¥ ' •'1 Form 57 A(^rki.mi;ntom /«/«/// o/Ukdinvry SitAKKiioLi>i I's w» a C'omivny - for Sali; f<> Anothkk Company of all thr Okdi.nahy Si.akis in (in ExisTiNi: Company. Partic". Agreement un behalf of holders for the sale of ordinary »harc» and «mtrt»l of eompany Dcftnition <>f owner. AN AtiRF.KMT niado the day of . Ix'twceii .\ H. iV ( .. „l hnflr callod -iho hnii ' i, on holialf ol' liiom.soU.- and all tho ulhor .i\Mioi> ol' ordinaiN shares iu tho X Co . I.imtd. ihnfir callod tho (oy " ). of tho ouo pi. and tho .1. i< . - ■:\\ ''<>■. l-imld . nl (ho other pi: Wiii.kk.ii\ ii is m.hkkd as follov -: I Throiiohoiil ihisuiiToemt ■ owner of shait- in iho.o. includes liol onlv any owner who at the lime he ratili.'> is tlio rojrister.' in. I • '•"• -■""""»•• '""' «""•' ' """"- ' "^ Ill" "'^ •■''"'" ' ■ , ' ... .,,,1, ^..ii.loi ..lilli"l<-'i>i'''"""""'^' ■'rr;i*r: ;";■■- '-i.™-' ■ ..--—■ I .\ll\ OUIK'I the- tiiiii ti.ifi fi> Ix- - ; •*« 't*i:::;::":;ri. ,....,.■.. ■■T'l'r'uT -.i^:; """^^-.y" , ,;;;:';;;::■ i:s=- . .1 V .lull Imv.- nH.li.Ml iiikI .Ii'Hv'M-.mI hii. I. lalili.-ilinns ,„„ ,„ ,., .ls.1. .lion .1.. ...• ^^^ ^^^^^ ^__^.^^^ .__ ^^,_.,.,,^, „. „„. ,i,,„ ,„„ "tl.iU lliov .l.win. III.' ^.L'. • ^""1 wlin ^lliill C<..i.,..(»ioii. nnW» iIk" |>mi hi|.">"- - l;,l..r tliiiii tilt" "' ,„v ni.iU.uliun.. ..I«t 1.. ivumi.. l.i l-r.-,. ,„,;.. tlii.:. ,1,N a..- ,,...M..h.-,."n.i,a..a.,.l.ilou...-...,U :^v';:::";::;:;i"::i'::;;;;;:s';;;::..:;;" ^ ; :.:™.-...-M '■"'■■ "■■:;r™;;';.:;':;:::::::,i;.r;u: ;i:t;"::;::;:;*:.°i::™--;--'^"'rr'':::''::; -:;::-„-;:;;::;;;;;::l:::::.::;:, :;;:;:-:: -:;;;; :,.1,1<.. .hall pay Mi.h in....... a..,„nlin.lv .„ .1 ..il<..' - •" "<" firm on liis bohalf. ^i^,, ,|^^, Re,ig„uti.,n firm no rcsnlv" .„ u- .h.-ir l-o^. .'mloavour. u, ,.i.hu,.. ..a,l. I .Uo m,.m.«.r, and .ho i-.-rcha^r. shall ,k,v or ,nKU..- .- ^ , .1 eh r^^ ..nin. ,nomlH.r „.• ,ho a.lvi.ory c.o,nnu.,oo u ho ;'7'' ' ^,,f J' ^ ; rl .. ..on.,KMisi,tion for lo... ..f otli.e. an.l ho shall u.oopt tho same „ ,1., sa,L;a.-.ion of all claims on tho coy in ros,.. -t s-.o^, os. o om.o The rosi.^na.ion of th. advisory eomnu..o.. shall n... .nko olfoct ;:„c^' ;rovi:i„ns have l.on n.ado for tho ''P.'-;;;'-;,;^; I^ ,01. .,r o,hor oili,e.s U, carry ou the- V..^...oss. a... -ho h. ami he -.. - -.-.™ n>cml.«r.s shall ns,- their lic-s. emU-avou..s ... P o. ..re such i.l.orations in the articles of asson ahull reasonably re.iuiro. of tho 1' MHi A0KEKMENT8. [Chap. V. >■* ft. .. 'p. IB- 1 Form 57. Kmployi's to ODUtiiiUf. Aj^eut to continue. Condition of agreement. Firm to com- municate with •hareholdeiK. 8. Tho imiclia^ers .sliall procuit; tlmt all einployus of tlio coy and of llie linn shall l)€ employed by the coy, and no employe who -shall have been moie than 10 years in the service before tho day of — -and .-hall In) under the a ap:reemenl is conditional: — (1) On tiie lirm on complotinn ivsigning their ollice as managers of the coy; and (2) On the lirm having enteix'il into an agreement in writing with the purchasers in tlie terms of the agreement already approved by the parties hto to tho effect that the firm shall not nor shall any member of the firm for a period of 10 years complete [i!i'c.;. 11. The lirm do HO. If yo.. -le-^iro t<, ratify the a^rt-omont yo.. wll t :' ,o,fd a. to .i,n the form of ratifi.ation on..lo.od with ,.ri„t ot tl.c a.roe- me..t in the plaoo indioatcl, ami return the »amo to us hy post forthwith. Form oi Ratification. I ror wp) hereby ratify the aproomont dated the -- day of muUwid. be Jl -— & C... on behalf of themselves and all other holders of ord.nary ^^l;:,, the __ Co.. Ltd., of the one part, and -- of the other part, for the sale of my (or our') ordinary shares „, the - Co., I.trt. Signature . Address . Deseription . Signature . Address . ne.seription . In ease of joint linldincs ^,11 slionl.l sul.seiibe. Agreements for the Acquisition of Control over a Company. Cases not infre,,uentlv oeenr in whieb it is desired by some person, tirn, „r eompany to ae^piire eontrol over another .'ompany, e.fj.: ■ (1) In the ease indicated in Form 57. Here it is supposi^i that Co.npany \ desires to aequire the eontrol over Company I!., wh.eb is eairyinK' on a rival business, or one wliieh ean best be worked in eonjunetion with the other. Cnn.pany .\. has debentures and preferenee shares of large amount, and it is not desinnl to interfere with them. The ordinary shares are also of large an.ount, ard arc w'orth .n the market a eonsiderable premiun.. The agreement therefor.' provides for the aequisition of the ordinary shares or the g at bulk of them at a premium snffieient to attraet 'atifi-ations. and it is subjeet to the ratiKeation of the holders of ordinary shares or holders of, .say. thr fourths of them, and there is to 1 o power to reseind it less than. say. three-fourths ratifv within a speeiKed time. Assuming that t!.r fourths ratifv. Companv \., as owner of tbree-f,.urths of the shares. «lll have an elfe,•ti^e .ontrol over Company li., assuming thit the preferenee shareholders have no votes or a restrieted vote whi.h is m.t likely to eause in<,.nvenienee. ami thus the two coneerns will work in friendly allianee. ,2, \nother "eommon .a-e is that Company A. wants to ae.,u.re the shares in Cimipany H.. wliieh is ..nlitl.sl to .i eonees.sion of great value, anrt whieh is not transferable without the approval of a foreign govern- ment, and there is gra>e reason to apprehend dirtieulties in obtain- ing that eoneession unless upon onerous terms. It has preferenee shares, ordinary shares, and delH>ntures outst.inding. Company n. .lesires to aequire all the share- or t.he great majority thereof, and an agre.-ment is aeiordingly prepared for the sab- of all the shares at the market priee and something bey.md. The eonsl.b-ration to be satisfied by the issue of paid-up preferi^nee shares and paid-up ordi- nary shares in Company 1!., or it may be by the issue of .lebentan's . . pni f .._ : :*.. Mn^lfi. noil the of Coiiipanj partly e:r-h. The rrspii^ile majority tv ratifv and agreement is enrriisl thrniiL'h. a \d thus the allianee is eonipleted. 1 ii 3^8 Form 57. AOKEKMKNTS. [Chap. V. , . . , .;, ..ral iftlior coiiPCrns which tr,::z;;/,.:-.=:;:: X..;r :...,..;.• .....-...>■ "i:/:;;;/:;::':,;"':- > - ■-";■ ■"•r III moj't .11 f ,,,,„.,.rii uikI I"' ...are. or the .... rt ,.T h. 1. is n.Mv elasti- ....... a ,.ro.e..lin»r ""..er sect. 19>. ,„.lk -f ••-."• '^ HhanlioWer who does not .ome ni must, if he re.,iur. J. ^^ ^j,^^;,, ^„t^„, ,„.in, wliere • ''■ ;;3; "^ ;;, :.,.„„, ,„,, o, interest, it n.i.y '- » '■'■•'''■,""'':"' .u. to ^odH re,.„„stra.tion or amalgamation l.y be ..xtreinely leMiabU to a,o.d debenture debt wouhl :;r;h:'.h::i::M..: '''^i-y - •^-^ •" "■"■" ♦'"■ '''""'- '^tX^^ :t::it ..... if ... ... .-.uU .he a,...uirin« eompan^ *' I 11 ;.,„ .mlinarv shares it wi.l be in a ,K.sit.on. where it is :L:;:ri:;.ir'ntitiiere...ootr«the f.vouraV... terms ami so eomplete the transaet.on. r$n Form 67a. At,KKKMKM K TksNS, ,.RO/Lt.^HT.N.. Ok>,KK Io NkW COMfANV. AN AUHKKMT nuulo tho — .U,v -f , botwoou the U.bu.i A.N AUK1-.I-. , iK-i-oiualtcr called the Dlstrnt Conn...! ol »'' '"'^^^"" ,.„,,,.,, i^i„^ co.nu.il) of •'-'-»";;•- 2. ,ar W..KK..S tho council bcin. cuUod the rouipanx , ol . u otht. l-a. M.,l,ting .A.ct.^. ,Uo local au.ho.itv tor -he ,.uq>o. -^ ^" ' -, > , o fo a l.«>W«ional ,HH, and .««« -.^'l X'^' ^ ^V!' .Irt.er " . tl. authorise "• ■ '^ ■ „ , :i,..ivi Hitter calle.! the ami -I .-upi'b ' ami ■r;r....' :'... .l: ;:i^^'.« .■'• ■- ' "'" ' KOHM8. .3UU ,i„„. witl.in <.!..■ voa. altv. ,omnK>i..*.nt of lliis ..i.lor or s.uJi ox- Form 67r. ,,udtHl i..Ti.Kl not ..xn..MliuK i.. the wholo l.". ...ouths a. tho B ..I ,,,,v allow, tlH< uiMlortHkei-H innv, «itl. tho .oi.soi.t ot, and subjt to MuJi iev»^. an.l .■on.lous, ami for su.l. ,M.rio,l< as „.av 1k> approved bv ,he B of T. l.v deed, to be approve.! by th.> Board, tra...ster the ,„„lertak- aulhori.erities, ol,ho.,us. an.l liabi i- ,i,,.of the un.lertakers in ie«i)Cjt to the „i„vonse..nt.l in the deeil of transfer, be liansferr.'.! au.l may be exer- ;.i,od by and ^hall attach to that ...y who r-hall. s.il.ji t.. th.' ;.rovoi,s .,t ,hi~ ortler, become the undertakei-s for ihc pposes of ihLs onlcr as il ,1... .-oy had been named Uuin as the uuderUkers. And whkhkas the ,„v is'ab.iut to promote and register a limitwl coy i" be called. Ac. , ■ the Electric fo.' .) for the ppose, amongst other thinjrs, of supp'' infi- flcrtric ener-y lor i)ublic and private ppo-es within the ariM of sup ,,lv. Kow ir'is .v.^RKKi) by and b..twn the parties hlo as foUows. that i^ to say; - 1 The council shall r to obtain the i-ssiie bv the B. of T. an.l the sub.se(,.ient conlirnion b.> P.iiliament of f ■ " r.ler. an.l the before re.il.^y as their Parliamentary a^>nls .1 .>f, lie. : within >i.\ calendar months after date of .•.Jii- ,. . .,ent of the or.ler, |..nii an.l be the conson for the lianster of the .inler a^ hnftr provided 4. Upon the iief;otiali.)n an.l formation of the Elcitric Co. with M„ h .siibsirilK-.! .apital afsd and upon payment of all the sutns of money referre.1 to in cl, :» of this nfrroemt, an.l subject to the issue ui.t »pect to tr ill the matt •J. 'I'll.' c liiiuon by I prior to the m tinii sfer .if the .irder i. an.l I" the appro\al of tjie B. ol 1 ., liie I i' 4U0 AfiRKKMKNTS. [Chap. V. Fonn57a. sliall execulo, und the Elorti-ic Co. shall uiko u iiaiisfor of all that the undertukjr of the ccmncil under the order and tho dood of transfer sliall 1)0 in the form approved by the H. of T., and shall contain all the provons usual in such deoreasonable conduct of the council) the sd transfer shall not be mane within the period allowed therefor by the order, neither *ho coy nor the P^lectric Co. sliall have any claim whatever a^st tho council either for the transfer of tho undortaky or cost.- or expenses or otherwise, noi shall the couni^il have an\ claim agst the coy or the Electiic Co.. but the order and tho umlei- takp shall be and remain the ppty of the council a« fully and elTec- tuallv as if the order had conlvi''iiin>' meiitil at end of rhvise 4.] Sometimt'H the consideration or pnrt of the consideration for a sale ia the Issue of debentures to registered holdi'r< ns l)elow. The Limited. Issue of £-- — dclientui-es ( - - delienturcs of £- interest at tho rate of per «'nt per annum. No. . Debenture. each) carryinir £ . 1. For valuable consideration already i«ceived the Coy. Limited ( hci'einafter called the company i will on the — — day of o;, ..,. ^j..]; ertrlii'V diiy ii-; ihc priiuipal moneys hereby .j'ocured become payable in a'conbnce with the condons indorsed hereon KUKM.S. 401 . (^ of or other the i^friNtored holder for the time lieing Form 68. I ho sum of £, • •> Tlio cDinpany will during' lln' i (jiitiiiuauw of this security pay- in such rc<,'isle!re(i holder iiUewwt on the naid sum of £ at tho „,,, uf jwr cent. j>oi' lu'iuui hy half-yearly j)ayineut.-i on \^\» (lay of — and cUt; of - in each year, and the first of .-IK li half-yearly payniont.s will !« made on the day of - noxl .! Tho compuuy hereliy ( iiar),'v>i with wurh payments its undor- i4il,iii;; aud all its proiwrty. iiro>cul imd future, including: its unpaSlcd ('ii|iilal. 'I'lip above words creatt? what is uullwl a floatiiitt charge, wliich, an it m-rc. liuiifri over the whole of tho property eharged but leaves the company at lilurty to deal with it in tho ordinary eourse of bu^'inewj until tho eharK» civ^tallizpii by the appointment of a receiver or the commencement of a winding u)'.. See Hi- Manama, ^c. Co. (1870), I.. R. 5 Ch. 318; Govcrnmnit Sto, I. (■:. V. Manila Railway Co.. (1897) A. ('. at p. 97: Ulienthy v. Si/ksfonr Co.. ■:\t I . 1). 71,5. I This (lol)onture is issued siilijeit to and with the full beiu'lil 111 ilic londitions indors<>d hereon, vvliidi are to Ih) deemed part of il. The Condiiions within referi-eil to; I This dolientui-o is nne of a sfiies oi (lelii'Mturcs of the cinnttiiny < ..nditiuBK. fill seciiiiiif: principal sums not excwdinf? i" the uristMl in the indre heUnv mciilioiied. is to he a lloafinp' security. li si) (Irsiri'it. fiiti/ : lint the company shall not he at liberty li> < icaii' aiiv iiiorlfragt! or charf>-«' ranking' in prioriiv to i >■ iHiri pa.i.-'ii vvitji lie (liartro hereby created. 1 A lluatiii^r ilmrije operates aa an iniuiediafc and continuing i-hiirgc on tin- pivijiiTty chartrid, subject only to the lonipany's power to deal with the property in the ordinary course of its business. Florenro T.aitH Co., 10 C. D. 541 ; ,S' ; i ^'tdl V. Brown, (.1898) 1 Ch. 815. P. !> » 4 1' !' ■^■1 k'^^ii I If II! M)i AGRKRMENT8. [Chap. V. Pom 58- s... ... or the AH o. m. ..uauH. t^;--!;- ■:'::r'' s-'^iT:';:: (Hill, 2C1>. 41. .. . ,c.iHUM. .1 .lie .k.bouUMv« «ill l>- k.-l" "I "- <"';J"'">'^ - -^ iC!I»HUi " " ..iiii.MMl Iho iiumus. iiddrcs^'s aiul H ul he n t,i to . i ^^.^ .^^ ^„ ,,,„ ,, i.„.,«,l h..l.li-. I..'i«'"l au.l l.i- 1<-!^'I P '-""•' "I' a ,:,c~.u...n..ea iu«inu.« by hnuoMhoin. . s^v^ . iu the. coaa... ^^^^:^-Zl:^^^l •v^r:;::r:;r;r:;;::^^^^ ••■•• , , !■ ,1 o" -l.tored hnldor l.c.col, or his loKul ,M,Mso..al re,...- -:;-:'r';; .;..».;.;*-- ;--r;:r: :;;;':■=,;::;;»; :;'::-;^ -r'r™;;;:::"';;;: .... ..if.iiist tho traiisleior. uikI im' ti.ii.-iLi " r, ;;';,r ;;ri;'i. ro,i..va,i .1. .... i....o.s...i h... Thoooy.h.i. b<. .'ntitlo.1 to retail, the tiaiisU'r. ; I. ,1,0 -aso ..!■ i..inl r.-i.fr.'.l h..lde.>, ,!..> ,.ria.i,.al nujy^ on a joint acoouut. ,1 \o tra...lor w.il W r.-^lM-r..! uuria^' -hv hovc-u day. hnmo- aiil^oly ;L..e.ii... ..i.hor of .1..- half-vearly -lav. ..v th.. ..obo.„...v tixcd lor imviiieni "f iuttMcsl. : l„ respo.., or ..a.!, hall-v.... > .a..'..-. '-' 'hi^ .l.-l..M.t,.r.. a ...... oa !.. o.,.a,,a..vV baak.-s. pavabl. ,o ,h.. or.ier ot ho re,.H- .,,,,.. h..|.o„f.' -r ia ,.a.- -f i.i... h..i.h.> f. ^.^ -.nl-." ^ - .vhos.. aa.ao Maads lir.t -a ,ho ro^is.er, .s oao of s.ah jo.a. hollo. > :m ,. ^,.t by ..... lo tho ...istored addr... of ..oh -cj-sU- .. ,,.,Mor. a...l Iho coy .hall ..ol bo ro.po..«ble I... a..y las. u U^ lllMoa. aad tho pava.oa, .f .la, warra,.t, if parpor....^ to bo dul> u,do.>.'.l. >l.all bo a -....! .liH. l.ai>,'0 to tho ooiapany. fc^JI FORMS. ■m\ S TIk' |iiiin ipiil iiioiiox' iiml inlciCNl liPM'l>y •.ciint'd will 1

    oii'riiiiil „i' Hii> iiil.-niiiMliute iiol.lor liori'ol'. or uuy M!t-otV or rro-.-.clainis and tlio r.'H'iiit of ilif roRisiorod holder hereof, or his Icfj^al piM-ional i,'|.i.'M'fila(ivfs. for sii,h iuin(i|.al nionovw and interest shall lio a ,n),„{ diw l|ar^ro lo the i-onipan.v foi- tiio naino. /•,,„.,; f./...- II ill liciituri- lll■ill^' u clii)«! in actioii U only iiwiniialili' Kulijwt to :ill .i|ui(ii-i l)ftwii'ii till- ooiupany uiwl the ori);inal »»lwr iion>of, or his h't,'al ))orsi)nal roprosculaliv.w. of it.- jiili'utioa to pay oil' tliis debcnturi", and upon the cxpiiution of ► i\ caliMidar monllis from surli notiio beiu^r ^'immi tin' priniipal nioiKM.-i lii-rohv ■ji'iuted shall hocome payaldo. 10. Tlio priucipul inoiio.v« iH'iohy wiiii-od shall imiuodiately hucoine payable: -- a. If till' romiiany makes default for u perio a receiver or receivers of the pro|)erty char^'ed by the debeuturesTof this series and not com- prised in such indenture, jind mayiwitli the like consentjjeinove any sill li riMi>iver, and smli appointment or removal shall 1k' as effcctivo IS it all the holders of debentures of tho same series had concurred 'licrein. And a receiver or receivers so appointed shall have power — 1 1) To take jiossessiou of, collect, and get in the property charged liv the rlebeutnre^l. and for that purpose to take any proceed- ings in tho name of the company or otlierwi.se as may neeni exiK'dicnt. Form 58. 4(14 AdKEKMKNTS. [( 'HAI'. V. Form 68. (2) To utrry on or ctjiiciii in laiiving on liio Im^inu--' <>( ilic company, ou company (4) To nialcc any arran^'cinont or conipronMsc whicli li< uv they fhali lliink <'\|i('ili('rit in tho interest-, of the ildn'Miuii' holdeiit. And all moneys i-eceived by xuch receiver or receivers shall, after providiiif; for the niutteiM inpccitied in the first thrtH) pnmion ji- ;(liii\<' is effectivi'. U''»>>i Vn.'mh Sun .V II "''Itn'^ (iMh'Ji, VH'. n. 402 (C. .V.i. 12. Tho hohlers ot the debentures of flit" above issue aic and will be, entitled i>aii ;«/,sa(/ to the l)enefit of and subject to the jirovisii^H contained in on indenture dateI ilriil. l.'i. Where thcri" i> no trust deed it is u^iial to insert heic a dau-^e enablint;' a iMMJoiity of threo-foinllis to biTiil the wide clas,s of debenture holders. 14. The principal moneyts and interest hereby secured will be paid ■_at the Bank. Liniitod. No. . Street. London, orjat the registered office of the company Tliis ('lau'y t|\o coy upon tiie r(^u:isierod holder of this del)enture by .-.ending it through the post in a [irepuid letter addroti«ed to such per^oii at his rosrist^'ivd iwhlre-^s, and shall U- KOKMS. 406 (iiHiiM'd to Imvc roHilied suuli lioMor «ix llm .la\ lollowiiig that on Form 88. wliith it in [Kictwl, and in provinp: uiuli wivico il 'Imll li« siitlicient to pivvf thill tht> Icttor wiitainiiif; tlio rmtiiv wh.s |)ri.|iiMlv uddre««el. And whkreas R*. lli.'ii' arc iaip' iirrcar.s of profereni o diviiicnd on tiie company's |iiclcr<'nc»> .«iiaro-i. and it i^ desired to fund tlie sd arrears as linfir iiri>\ ided. Jr Now riiKKi'.KOKK II IS Ai.HKKi) as fidiows; - I riie loy shall, when tliis agi-oenit ha^ lieuii .Niuclionotl lus hnftr Issue "f provided, Lssiie to each holder of preforoiu-c »haro« a fundinjr eerti- pjlrtifii-i'iti'i'. Ii(aie lor .so much of the arrear of dividend afsd as .shall bo owing III respect of the pieferenco shares held by him, or at his option s<'\cial funding cert ificate.s oai'h for a portion of such amount atsd, and every such funding cortilieatc .siiail iio framed in the terms sot forth in the .schedule hto, and the principal sums .specified in every such oeriillcate shall be a sum equal to tho amount of tho arrear afful ill I'ospoet of which such certificate is is.sued, and such corlificato ur certificates .shall be in satisfaction of tho sd arrears, and the sd arrears up to the - - day of — - shall be cancolioil. 2. The principal sum specified in each such certificate shall carry Interest, interest at tho rate of 3 p.e.p.a., but sudi inteifst, as regards each year, shall Ijo payable e.xclusively out of the surplus profits of the coy of that your which shall remain after paying tiie dividend on the preference sliaros in the coy to the close of such year, and shall not be • nniulative. (nil AUKKKMKNTH. [('II Al'. V. ™7^- „..;,... .».<• -.1 .■.■..i.i.«..-l.an 1.0 ,Kl oil ..... of .1.0 M..„1U. ...SHO , ,. «inainp-..p. the Euflli-li «"v which sluiH 'oi"«i.i u icr | m. m k i u,. .... .1.0 prolo.CM..o .h.i.xw in .ho or.»...al rupitul. ..... simll .a..k n!;/;:;;::.! i.. ,.i...i.v .o anv ..e,u.-.. ..i ..M-Hai .....««• -^^^^^^ (shuro-. 4 Tl.i> ..■M.-..„.l i^ .....li.i....Hl 01. .1.0 sa...o hoi..,, «a..o.iono.l l,v ,h. ( .>.., ,.: ..n amui-.uont .....lor so,... 120 <.l .ho (,oni,.....,..> _--. ,l,.v of it shall -.1 that day l-orunic vokI. Spc fiirtlicr. As WITNK.- SHII. SC.IKIH I.K Sv, I.IMIK. Viindhui ('ftiificiUi- te,.e of .un.li..^ .o...ili.a.o. >..,. .'v.oo.li..^ :i:i.o..o/.. ,.a,-.viu,; ...- teres, ut .i p.-.p-a. .mi1..jocI u-< 1.."1<.w nii.i.l.i. FuiKlii.n .ortiti.aio .... ll.o piiixipal "'."" ol A- ■ 1 Thi.^ ....... iti.a..- i~ i"...-l iM .•-p.>o. of tho piofoion..- .^ha...- ia ,h.!;.ov. ,.,.n,l,o....l ... i'.'l'-v... a„,l ia .saUsla.no,, ol an an.-ar nf,Hviea .vhich ;hall romai... aftoi- payi...^ ov providi.,, for the }->■-■" j;^ the dividend on .ho profo.o.,.o .ha.o.s i.. the ...y a. .ho .lo-o of oa.h year, an.l .m..1. in'ovoU in .mi to bo ........dative ' 3. In the ovou. of the wi..di.ig-up of tho coy, .ho principal «un. n.entd i.. .hi« .•o.-.iK..n.o will l.o pd olf. kv. as ... clat.so .1 of .h- Bgreeiiitj K(*KM.-!>. 4W r,.i.i.Mf...M! hol'U-r for ili.> tin..- I«iinr li'-l. «ill !«• .m.iUI to iho l..-iiolii tliol ;, Tl.i.- (Oilifi.'ulo is i.i«m'.| ,mI..j.h I o ll ondition- iml..i>«.l Imh-oii. whi'h f-httll Ix- «lt'Oii\oivd cIcl.CllllIK'. Sw Koilll M. :lll Sr furtli.T *. CI arren^emPiitH will. .Ii.-^- -f .linrrl.i.iaor!., " ArrRnKom.-i.t-. ' nKiptiT XXIII.. infrn. A( iiKEMKNT for MlujijiiKj Vhwiv-ww. Dimokm.s for a Ti.hm Fora 60. fry //('•»*««■"/ DF.niMiKi SnKK ((•/(.»( (fM\.loT^lT^ Ci.visk M in Articlv-s. AN Ac:1{KP:MT. niadcthc du.v m . Ix'twi't-n A. B., of.Ac , I'artiw. C.I. Iiplialf (.f tho holders of the piofoioii'i- Hhan-s iti tho .-..y bolow ni.M.td of the first pt, the s.l A B ..i. l..-lmlf of tho hold.M-s of th.> ,,.,liiiuiv .simres iu tho sd i-..y of tho xMoiid pi, nnd the - Coy, l.iMiid "ihi.ftr .alU".! the .oy " > "f tho 'hiid pi Wiik.kkvs th.^ Knit,.!- .apilal of the coy Ls .-.OO.IMior. (livi .' 'M. each: And wiif.jik.vs ;ill ih.' s hv parafrraph a') of Artich' 1 Hi of the ait.s nf usson of the coy, the iliiwtoir thof have power. 1" fore re.oiar.i.'ii.lintr any ilivideml.-. t'. e in wh.oh- ..1 ill part dlstrilnited l)y nay of l.onu- aiiiony the issue of [iivleiei..'*' ifrl 4(W ^i.KKKMK*> IS. [('MAI-. V Form 60 Se«i divideud may be satis- lit. ul lluii • liwt". H that U iin.v mi. h -iiKial iiicotiiiK all (lie pn-vi-ioii^ .d tho wl .irliclo* r.hall tniil..i,i, wiita>i(li'< aj)|>l.\, l)ul >•" lliii il"' iM''t""uiy i|iK>ruiu sliall be ouo-li nih ill iiumlxT of th«' iiuiiilior- "\ tlio . Iii^^ liol.Uiii; or r^'pro-ciitiiii: I.. liiuxv (iiio tciitliof the lapil.il |,.l or . n-.lil-: Am) wiikuK's rhi'-'l .iiiiiiilalivt' ptofcrcntiil ilivid. "I m ICrtpvil. iif lllO .-(1 |ilof.ar: Am- wiikheas th. .\ ha> lifi'ii w) fur Mucos^ful in it-. l)U-*iimss a> to iiavo phaiiv.: Am> \viikhi;a.>> it has lpe..Miie tlie piactiv iu llie .li-lii.t in wliirh the eoy (uiries on bu.sine"- for brewery i.tj8 to make advaiuo t>j saloon k«>i)ei - and other.-. \\ itJi a view to ubtaiiiiiij; or ket'piiig lii.ii- .•u.>tuiH. .iiid the to\ lias been cciiiipeMed to .■ lopl ihi-s (^ii-l.nii, iinil iia^, foiiiid the adoption ihof ailvanlaueoiii- to it- Imsinoss: Ami wiihitiw il i.> iieie.-Kiuy to continue tlii- pimiice, and for tlie puipo-" ihe .- leipiiiw further wt)rking capital: Vm> wiiekkvs iu prc-M-nt circiim- Mances it is not practicable to laiM -iich further working cimital fmiii outside Miurces .'xci'pt on inieioiis t. ini-. \m> nshkkkv^ it i" < - sideicl that the most economical nuKle ol providinjr '^ amount icjuired in to retain in hand a sutlicient part of the ci.v accruing' incuiue. which would otherwiw be available for divi ■ nd: A o \viiKRi.\s ill the circuii.'KUmx'K it is cmisidereil that it i- , . irable ■■■■ make provision for fiindini; !• Uiiild perimi theacei ty I.) satisfv su. h rljvid. I, aw and when dei in like manner. I tare- iiid ■||,.. il.'l mIiii<- I MHMs. ,I.N k .itw -lutll li« 1 .11 ■! ,l,.|>.'ntim' " it.Kk 'I the will I is forth I'll to MMlJl !iro«<.I ("'ll Imin.-I • iiluiio- « ilh t A and l.ioh lins .ili.-tt(iv Ik'oi. approv.u l.y i i>.»r1i 1. I Wlii'iifvcr Ih'- I'^v I"i' '">" (lividi'ixl n •oiiil -ii'i-lit» ui >il(' I) hill' Ktock '«>. iil'-v th. |iit\ ill. hulf- 40» Form 60. flu f ittiirr k. nidnul Ubbit ,iii> .liviiU'iui .h *. l\H .1 _!••<' 'lilt 1.-. lllK'llli" I '•> I""'' iii I heir The ill till' cajiitii 1 ..f th .shduiholdi'i- in 1 1"' coy aixl III-*" iht'ir i«.'H|)ivo \^ 1 III! Ill bl.,.l. nil' (nvi>»>is '"I- till' Mill "11. U .1 tl tiuir ->hiur- .huil ;i- I ho ■•iiuie '«i«i! iiu> ' ii->l' ihsiilul' iii« .ii.;ni'iii', UIK 1 -hi' 11, a» Cu»l«)dj :tll-«- .1 not. t' , |P: 111! l.l' I « if tl.f ^ m«« il«viiij; l=<«foi'«' al,.-oluf<' Thi.s iimtH'u 1 will bflf-oii ,1 ...li i I It I'ofon' tli<> ''Ift il Ict'i'vi iihu»i"«l IIkim oI lialilll' U'lKMUl Will II uy nient »l"" it'". i-.'tinsp"'tthehol.k.i-..! ih<' ^1 1 ,,.ii.,".hui(-«aii.l 'I liari'-' M-i! •am III Utli III .ii'nlaii'v ^1 irrliJiii; ■ ■ritii'arv n ,i> f u^ II |»- T Ih. lot dii 'I i.tolior. I'.i ■aim> I'V oxtra- ihiii.s*- ii'.i <>i tho Hl aliovc ritt«'ii. ha VI I'll |ia--<'il -mil tioiiii ha.- l.i'K'iiicIo X I. hi- liaiiil, ami 1 111 allixtil till' tlaj ami vi'ar KM /.// 1' IIHNHKI Hoi. Ill H- /'. rrlcHff TlMK. f- 1^^ME^^ •ritnr „i, .|\.i in «'i\i>i' ..laSl. % .\i; HK KMT made till" .hiv'i . U'l««'eu lli« fov. I'Hrtie-. I ,li„|i,' lalli'il tho i'iv-|. .Jl Ihi" Olio |il. A. 15.. on holialf ol .iKloi- or llii..lol.Pulim-sol- lluMov lor 20.(M(0/ novvuil-taiKlinfr, ihiM |)l WllKHKIlV II IS M.HKlK a.-* follow-: The time for pavmeiit of the |.|..il iiiom'v- s^., „ie,l i... he -I ml- ^™*j,,, iliii^C ilelH'tiliiifs of the .oy shall be eMi'tile-l to ih-' f • J'i ,u,l .oiisliiieil and take ellcrt as if tlia date were siih- lutwl il oin lor the JOth DeiiMiiber. 1912. Iioiiiir th- 'l''le on'j-imill ti.xed t.lu-ivjn for paymciil. -V The eoy shall use its U.'sl e.ideuvoui- i" |..o. me ,11 the hol'lors K»tili»«tior, of the sd deheiimres to ralif> thi- a^rieeiin ind ii •sh.'il! he himiifig on ilii*i- who ratifv .so far a- loneenis ilieir dehentiiies afs.l rosply. 41U A(iKKKMKNl>. [Uhap. V. he iiiiliirf Form 61. ^ I iiU'>-. within iliu> liom llio dau- hoi' tlie iioKU-rs of niii.- lonlhs ill \uluf (il thv mI dci-fiilin-os simll ralif.v thit .iKroomI, it shall AvindaiMM'. . , uieit'Ujjoii U'coiiK) void. DeU-iitiirc, to 4. Eiu h «loU>iiliii-o hohloi iilsd wiio lutities this a({rt'eiiit iiiuxl foilli with giv*' ii|) hisd<'UMituwlothcio\ iiionlpi that a mpiiidin K'torriny hto iimv In' ii»dor»od tlion. As wiTNKNs till' foiiimoii "oal "f thf my and ilie hand «( tho vl A. H. tho du\ and v«>ai . &r. All sgrwiiii'iil a« «lM.\f lull ill); Ixi'ii M'uli-d by tin' iiiiii|)iuiy iiml sillied b\ A. J». (not i-iMilcil liy liini', Jirint'-d cnjiio* can lii- »ciit out to tlio dfln'iilMP" holders, and tliev 'iiii tic iiikod to ^\gn at tin- foot ii m-to u« follows: Ratification. "I, — "•' JL- , 11 II I ill ><■ ICC i-* a copy. " lioiii^' il liohlor of delioiiliiiOH of Iho wy for . do hli\ ratify thi> utficiMut of wliiili iho aluiM- Karh deboiifnrc liidder sliould tlii-n »pnd in lii>< ddicntui-i' l» In- endorsed, and r memorandum nhonld be put tlioreoii an follows: " Mrmoinii>liin> Tliiit by an a(rreonient dated the day of . and made betwi^n the nbovo coin|mny of the one part, and A. U., on behalf of all the then holdam of debentures of the company for '20,000/. (.including the then holder of ihl:' d.beiiture , of the other part, it wa« agrtH-d that the time for payment of the «iid debenture* of the company, including the within de- benture, should be extended t-) the day of . 1935. and that the >.,ii.l debenture should be rend and construed and take effect as if that dute had 1 ii >ubstitutitl for the -JOth December, lid'J, ori)finttUy therein tixi-d as the Ilia. for payment, nnd »uih a^niinent was duly ratified l.y . the then holder of the within deticntiuc I ' i V i Form 62. Acskki.mi.m //// DiniMi ki: llui.inns oll>>iriii'j (naluni "( I'ltioK LiiN Dkhinu Ki.s and nutkimj I.mkkkst an iri.slbtg Dehknti KKs pniffihic for Fi\i Yk\ks mil i,f I'koi ris ntihi {inajnnlii rtonsf Debentures now ioii«l:intly (..iitiiiT a ilaii-e iiMbliii).' a i(it:iiii mijority I'V resolution to bind the rest to a > [.niiui-e or luodilicution of llieir ri^'hi' m this way: but an aifriHMiieiit is n-efiil to rc' ilc and cvplain the cin iini-taie " (rivinir i.ccasioM to tli.. n—luti.oi S.s- ;,./,... p. t|:l: I'r. -ed.riN. r"l. HI . p. a73. I':irties. ReoiUlx. AN AtiUKKMT iiia.lo the da\ of . Ill . Iiolwooii A H on licliiilf of ihi' holih'is of iho uiiyiiial dplwiilmox hiiftr iiuMild. nt the one |.l. and tin' Coy. I.iiiitall«'d ' the mv "». of the otJior |il. WiiKUi :\N llu' <'i>y wiw innir|>oiatfd in tin' year iS . and has 11 iioiiiiiial capilal of .■.tiO.tMlO/,. divideil into .-lU.tnMl .shaio.s of Hi/ OBt'h, all of wiiii h shares Inivo Iteoii allollod and ain fully |m1 up FttUMS. 411 Vsi) xMimn- il«> ■" I'i'- '->"'•'• -^T"."""' "' 'l-lH-'"""-- '"'"' "- Form 62 ipmHl to HMlK. o.it.'inul .loluM,.,...-. ,uMl su,!. .lol„..,tu.os ar.. s,.,..r.Hl l.v .,u imlontiin-. Imlu .■.•forrP.l to as the oxistii.tr trust .I...mI. ,UiUH\ ,l"„. (lav of - .10. mill 'himI»' Ijftwcon llif coyot tlio one pi Iml C ai..Vl) of tl.o otl.er pt. Anu wiibkbas ll.o said .loluMituios ,,rrv ii.lvmM al ihf ra..- of .". i...-.|..a. pavaLlv l.alf->.-a.lv on il... •,|.,v„f .an.l ilavof : Am. w m.iu.vN iliv lm.>in.-K .,, ,l,eVov liaH iiol bcXMi si.r.«s»ful, u.ul the m-t levouiio fioui su, li |„mi,Hw.. U wholly inade.,..ale to i»v tho inti-a'st on tin- .s.l i-xisln.ff ,U.l,c.„tu.e.. .uoioovev th.- .03 hu ^.st a oo.iMdt-mblu puit.on ot „H pd-up capital and it i- takiuf,' step, to cancel the saum: Am. UHKHKVS the coy is iu urgent need of further (. U. to the extent „,■ :,(.o(.o/. or ihereahout., lor carrying on its j.uMness. and M.de>s MKh 'further fut.d^ can be raise.l tho coy will have to stop, and .lonpuge wouhl. it is aj.preheuded. di.sast.ously alloct tho .ecurily „f the holders uf tho existing deU'uturcs: Am. wukkkas it is con- Mdore.1 in.possil.h- to rai>e such further funds except upon tho -caritv of d..lMM,tmc. rankiujr in point of socunlv in pr.or.l.v lo ,1,0 eviMi.i- .lehenlnie^. and upon the fooling thai ihr n-hl- ol ihe |,„lders of the existing doi.enlures shall he uioditied as hnltr pio- xided so that the co\ ii.av have an opporlunilx of vvnrkiny and developing it> hn>ine.s an.l l.ringing it iuL. a i-aving cndtlmn without deplelint; its vev,,ur,-os by paving the intere-t ..n the exi-tn.- ,|cl>enliiies uut of (aoilal as I'rii.i- litii ilclii'Dtun- juav 1h> Now iiiiiiiioHi II I- \(.ias follovs: 1 The cox shall. a> -oou as this agrotunt shall Uvonic ab-'lute |,„|ir provided, be at liberty to issue further debeul.n 10 the _ u.'gie..ale a.nnunt of .W.OiMi. carrying inleieM al such .ale. not ,.r,.nt..,l. ox.veding .-. pep. a., a- the (oy may lix. ami having priority in point of charge on the nn.h'i taking au.l a-els of the < ..y over the s The sd further debentures shall l)e secured by a trust deed ll..« «"■""■'• .hnflr (alle.1 ■the new dowl • .. framed in accordance with the dralt which is aliea.lv luepawd and approved of by the parties hlo, and cvpies.<-d to be ma.le between the c.y of the lirst pt. the said C and D.of the se.ond pi. and K.and T.of the third pt. atid the ir...>< of the existing d<«s • sliall ru>ply suriend.-r to the . .,v to be , aa.elled tin . ,M,p.,ns velerrinu^ to »uch interest. , por ,|.„ ,^,.,„ „,■ fi,,. y.>..ir.s. a.- from the Isl .1 ulv, 1-J , the intere-r s,„l. not prohU* tl... ,,,„,„nt sl.all l«- .ro.lit.'.l will. .1.- -r.^^s ,„olii. an.l shall l.o .IW.ito.l «i,h all nutsruinKs lor ratos. taxos. waovs. an.l ..th.-r ..nt«..inf,'s noces- sarv ..> nropovlv in.urro.l in .arryinfr •"> il- l->.stn.-ss. ami ^v.lh a v..a>,.nal.h. ,lo.iu.ti..n r..r .|.-i..o.iati..n ..f [.Imm.. n.a.l..n.ny ami paKM.ls an.l with tin- int.-ivst on tho no« .U.|..M,lnn.H. and with anv ;.„„., ,„,,„„, i,.,or,.sl ex.opt tl». in.or-s, ,.n th. -xistinf; .lehonlnro. ,„„| ,|K, .relit balan,*, if any, shall lu- ropvr.lo.1 as tho not i.r,.ht ..f ,1,.. haU-voar lor |.urpo«..s hof. Ami sn. h .mlit l.alan.o «hall I* ,,,,.,i..l in or towanls the payn.ont of -ho int.-vs, on tho ox.s,„,^ .iLLonlim^s lor ih- half-voar .-n.prise.l i.> s,„h ...•■. an... ami . sn.l, n.>.li. l-alan.o shall l>o insnffi. iont I., pax s...h in.onwt l" '"H, thf in.orost lor iho halt-voar shall ho r.-;ln.o,l :i.ro,.linKHv: and it thoro ,„all 1„> n.. < r.Hlit l.alan..> for sa. 1. half-v • .ho... ^hall ho no .n.o.vM ■m tho .lolxMitiin's f.ir that half-yonr. ;, Tho ,0V shall, with all .■onvoni,.,.. sp,.,Ml aL.-r ^ -ho a.i.li.o.s of tho ooy, uml ^n.■h .M-rlificato shall ho com Insivo r, If ,hi.- a.MoO.n. l.o.onios al.s..ln.o. noli.i- lho.v..f shall, as soo.i .K^ M,. h oxtraonlinarv re8oluti..n as is hnftr .nent.l shall have bocu „aa.h of tho said cxistint;- dobontnros, ami tho hohior« thof shall dolivor tho .saino to tho ...y fo. -ho p.irposo • f sn. h indorscincnf boinR n.ado aoconliuply. 7 If this at'roon.t bo.onios abs.di.te. it shall tako ollocl and operalo l.v «av of .n.Klifi.ation .)f tho rijrht.s of the holders of tho existing .lobont'.iros. an.l of tho pr..vis.o.,s , ontaino.l i.> .ho oxist.iip trust .loo. ...no abs..lnto a> .soon i.s ,i .shall bo .sum - ,i,„.,,l l.v a„'",.xira..r.li.mry ro tiou. a-s dolin.Ml in tho thi. tll« A. H . till" ''".^- '^ „,„ , M...1 ui .la- .oy. an.l .1..' l.au.i "i U'" «'l Fonn 82. riiK S(M|.;mif> al>us.... t.. pas. a.. .■xt,a..r.lM.ar> r..»..... r 1 'u^ni- >C'..-.H..ati...M A..,, .. «=• Mm .atifyi,.. ..j. ..^r-o- , S,.o K..rn> in I'art Ml. 'I'i,.- r.-a-.... i. tl.a. .1,,. aitr ont :.IT..r.l, a. ;;;;.„!:;; !.r ;;iai. — ir....n.ta„..o. .... ........ ...o ...» ""iti-u... tl,e .,u..r...n .....l.r ....■ .l-«l i* •- lu^^^^ «r for otl... r-a..... i. i- U.0UKi.t ..otter to .ro..e.l ......r ...t. .20 of tl.o f„n.,.a...0H ,to,.«.l.da ..n) A.-t. „^ , . ,„.li. ..,.al .... tl... .a...o t»-i..K' «...-tio...Hl a, a,. arrar.B.-.n...t under «c-ctli.. :; r \"'. ■■>nd t...... a,,,..i.a,i..n wi.l l- -na...' .- tl.e tin^'. !<.-o ...'■'. •• Arra..B..m..nt«,- fhaptrr Will. A..Ri:i..MiNi to .vM.M^ U.-m - '"/ l'^-" "f f'^"-' SiiMos Form 63. VN UiKEKMT ......I.', i- l»-.«.-on il..- • l.i»'l ... ...•.Ii.>..l.v slw...s i.. tl.o .upital ..I tl.o ...v .i...l ;,. tmstoo to. Iho.... ..f • ■ olho.- ,.a.t. Whrukas, ut a,. ox.ra..r.l...ary j..,.„o..l ...ootii.ti- or . . UoM ou tl.o 2ltl. .lav of .lai...u.v. I'.MiS, il Wit.- ..■^olvo.l a« f.il - ^' il i" 10 NOV ; That it ..s .U'.si.al.lo lo .apilaliw tho h. .f l.«t, l.o a.. uuthorlzo.l to Hiitisfy Bii.h 1h)iui« 1>v tho .liMril..iti..i. amoi.},mt tl.o mo.iiboi> hohlii.gr or tl.o . ..y, .n-lilo.! a- fully i-ai.l in nati-^far- lion ..f .■*.iih l.o.ii.H. A.NU wiiERBAs. |..ii«..u..t to . la...M' of th<" ooy .- uiim of »^oi., the sai BHtiafy derlari-d boiiiiH iu paid-up »h»rp«. 414 ACKKKMrVTS. Thap. V 'N ii ' Form 63. A'li>tiii<"ii'. N>iiiilieriii(r. Fruriiuniil ..•ertifirat*'. Niti»f«i timi. Now IIIKHKHIKK II IS MiKKKI) ili" (iillow.s: I Tito f<>\ -liull allot niul i>s<'.i<' t" ourli ol iIk? jH.'i>oh-> uaiiied in the btliedule liio ilio uuinber of now ortlinun Aum'x of li". oaih (part of «lie Kil 100,(M>0 ordiniirv sluiix'si not oppo-ito liii or lior nutno in tlw KOtond i-oliinin of iho >anio Mchodiilo, and wlicro in sucli Rchedulc eevoi-al iiorwii-* nro l»raikot«Hl as join lioldor- tliov slinll Ik? ionsiiloro.1 one |ien*on for tin' purnoios of this chiiisc. •2. Till- Niid ^liaros shall lif nnmlwrod to inclusive, nn.l sliaii !)<• 1 M'diti-d US fuliv paid up. :'.. Tlio CON sliall also nllot to each of lh ■ Kiid lii.ldors iho fractional ccrtilicat*' (if an> ' set oppo-itc his or her iianK- in ilii< third column ot the sanif schedule, an The .S uEuii.K auove Rekkhukd lo. NaiiH" of sharehol.leni, juint Ihililern liein^r brxkcti'd. Numlier of Mliiircn Number of fniction»l to Im' Hllottcl ncrtitiratcs if »n)- to I'lii'li. t> ins alluttcii. i c If t I i Form 64. Aj^irement an to r»|uiiiitiiin and ((tncral Micf'tiiiir. AN .^ORKK.MT juude the day of - — , between A. H., on behalf of all the shareholders iu the above-nunied coy (^huftr called "the coy " i, e.xcept the present directors thof, and C. D., E. F. uud U. II , iinftr mentd, of tlio one pt, and ('. ». of , E. F. of — , andG. H.,of^ , of the other or second pt. WUERKBV IT IS VOKKKIias folloWO:-- I The wl < '. I ) . E . F . and O . H aw to use their best endeavours U> procure the si^uatiire by the retjuisite miinlMsr and proportion of shareholders in the coy of the roquisili of tl..< .ux ao U..1 ,..urml lo <;....« a .lu-oth.- to ,,.;,„.1.1 «i.hiu ,wontv..,no -lay.s fru.n tl.o .l«.o of ,1... >..,,u.s,t.on bon.,- : li,<..l. .IK- ro,,.iMtio..isN or .1.0 n,a.io.i.v „. .I.on. ... valuo or. ,„ „.„vo..o .1.0 .a...... «...! M.C. ...I V. 1)., ... la.l...« Inn. .I..- s.i v h ., i „,. I.i... .l.e .d ^:. H. U 10 lH< o...,si,l....Ml u, IM. a,,,.o.nt.. .r,,..i.od l.x ,,,.'. «,| '( I) K. K. and I! . 11 , .-i«H the .r,,..i-iliou a..d al-o .«,. yvvsy ,;„„„ ,,,.0 l..r ..a.h of th,. ,«o n.o,.,i..i.- . a>.d >hall loou.od I- „.,|„„i/P th.^ socrotarv to iill up the blanks tiu-roi... , Should anv ro^l..tio.. Ik, passed a. tho n..M.|i„u alsd. whothc-r „v,.,..mI bv tho b<.ard .d .liro.to.-« or by tho rc.,...s...o...sts, wh.cl. ... .,„,..,. ,., hnvo ..llo.-t ro,,..i.os U> 1k> ......tir.n.Ml as a sp.v.al r..>ol..t.«.., .,,.1 ,|„. .|i,o.1ors do ..ol .....vno th.. uiooli..;. within >ono.. .lavs Iron, ;,,., ,,„„. .„ ,„.. p«s.i.,jr of .1... ti.M ,osol..,ion. thon and ... s..rl. .a-o ,1 ,,. I, y K ui.d O II shall lonx Clio tho sa.iio. and tor that ,,!!,lo ,1.0 sd ( . 1)., .a- iaili..K' hi... tho sd K. F.. or failing hi... the ',1 .: 11 i> 10 bo .on.ido.cd to bo ap|.ointod bv tho .o,,M.H.t.on.sts for ,1,.. p..rp.w> of si^rni..n the re-iuisite notioo eo..vfcninK si.ch inoetintf. A^ wiiNK.ss Iho hands of tho pa.tios hlo thi- dax >r.)xii'i<. ■'•i' I'"""" -'il. ""*'■ ♦" •I'"'-"' **•■ TmK ('0V.I-\\\. I.IMllK.I) 415 Form 64. Form 65. •|„,i,r Ui.oaoi„oril.oabov(-nai...HU-oy. !'V''v"r!i",r!il- I'ak.' Muti,,. llmt wv, Iho ....dorsi-nod sl.a.ohuld...- .'. ll.o ab,.v..- ^_^^^ ^^^^^^^j nu.no.l .:ox, hol.linK i.. tho a-givpile not k*s than o..o-tonth of tho ,u«iiug. ,.ssn..d cupilal of tho S.1 oov upo,. whid. all .alh or other ^unis duo ^^-f^^^^ havo Uh'i. ihI, do libs lo.iuiro vou to .•unve.ie an rMra.nili.niiy j,'o..eral .n.H.|in- of Iho abov.-nanuM ,-.v f.>r tho objo.i,-. folb.win-, that .> 10 sa\ ; ,1.1 To pa.-.- a icMiliilion to the oiled thai the nicolin^r is di- sali.-llod with the eo.iduot of tho dir.Hlo.s an.l •-alls on them lo retire, and deterndi.es that it i- iiioxiiodioiit that tl.o\ should be aliuuo^l !•. iHt niiv f.n-thor a- dirtH'tor« of the w.y. (2.1 To i>a.s.s a .•esolntioi. to tho olfoet thai no sale of the .on > patent** i.« to he made widio.ii ilio M.ii.tion of a >,'ciio.al If .11. 416 Form 65. AURKKMKNT.S. [('MAI'. V. lueeliuji. iiud in luiilkulur tli^it llio |)iO|u«i'd nuIo !•■ j^f 1^ p . a Hharolioliler in lli«' lov. i« not U) Iw made williout such Nuiutiini. (3.) To select »luircli.)l(l«'i> in llio (ov to uol a-* a pioloctiv.- fommitf'ip and to paK- a ifsoliilioii ai.|M.iiitiii(r micli porsoii; 10 be a c.miuittcf and vesting in them hucIi powers as ni.iv wem to th<' nicolin),' cxpetlienl iu the iniowts of the ooy (4.; To pass a i-«>«oliition or nwolulion^ pursuant to clauw f the urt.s of aHson removing all or such one or more of tin- directors now iu oHice as to the ineetiup umy seeuioxpcdiein (3.) To appoint such iHjraon or ]>ers„M .»« the uieet.inR may think tit to bo directord of the coy . (6.) To pa** a Tcsolutiou altering clause 90 of fJie arts of asso.i U substitulini.' tlie won! " seven '■ for the word ' five " theren, See fompniiiM (Coiwilidati.mi An. I9(IS. -^ «•> , , , •„ < It .huald be •MH.ii that tlie ..rtirl.M all..« -"'I" "««•<''- '" '"■ '''■»" "'♦''• " infra, p. 747. Form I Bond depuait Mgieeinent. Recital* IntCTprota- tiuD. A(.HKl.Mi:VT hi/ MoNDMOl.DKHS i.,1 .VmIHK VN KvllWXN «'<>. I" Dii'osn thiir Ho.M^s trifh a I'ivir l<> imtki. \. ii..v. A\ AtiKKKMTmadelhis day of , l.elvveen A H . of on behalf of him.self .nd all the oth-r holders of l.on.ls ot the - Cov (a cov .Mm-stilulo.! in. A.-., and In.f.r calle.l the An.en..r> .OV). of' the one p(, an-i the Corporation ,hnftr calle.l the co, ■ poration. of the other pt: Wheuea. the .\moricau coy ..s«ue, ,. .stu'ies of tirst morl^'a.^.t« l.ou1.0tlO,l>0(). and such bonds are st.ll out*.ianding unredeemed: .Vnu wukhkvs the .American coy ha> become involved in hnancial dilticulties. and has „,ade default ,.. paymen- of the interest ou the sd bou.ln; and its undertaking ,s no« in the hands of u recr, appointo. it .. believed, held by per,sou« resKhn- in the l'nite w.lln.s- to net as trees for the purposes thof Now I IIKHKKORK IT IS A.jHKKl> BS foHoWS:- 1. In lhe.se prt'seut/i - "The bonds means the bonds alsd: " IV.n.lholdei n.ei.ns a holder of any of the bonds: FORMS. It; Effect of depoMit. • Tho .ortificatett" inean» the coiiiKcales issuea uiiiioi- Form ^ iluuse 4 hot' and for tlic liiiio I'tMujr ou(«taii(liiijr: •The lertifieate hoUlors ' ineaun tho holders for tho time beinp of the cortilioate.-. .. Fuch bondholder who ratiHe« this ufrret.in. i- forthwith to Depo.it. a.posit his houds with- the corporation upon the tootinR of thw „rroe.at an the b.mds .le- ,,„Mted with anv banker, broker, lawyer, or safe deposit coy ,„. a ,1 in the rnite- to the tenor thof or according to any such arrangement or compromLs" as af«ediont in the interests of tho holders ..f certificates (hnftr called ' the .ertificate holders ). ,c^ To deletratp anv of the sd powers and authorities and .liscre- tions to anv [lerson or |)cr«oiLs. or .oy or cos, and on snrli terms and in such manner as to the corporation m.'y from lime to time seem expodieat. ' » c JSS. ^' 'j*' '1i3&-JI»^ >-i il 41S Form 66. CfrtiHtate. AOKKKMKNT8. [Chap. V. 1 h CootribiituiD. Applit'MliuDof oMitribution. llimunt'ra- tion. Meeting. r ««w of , TLo corporation is to i^uc „. ea.h depositor a rort.hoate repre- s.,n,iu,' ea.l. 1......1 deposmvl l.v lu,n. an.l outithug the boarer to ,1.. riih.H'ariMU, tro,u .ho ,lopoM.. M.l>.iu..l to tho..e .oud.tu.ns; un.l Zu .*r,iti.a,o holder shall be Imuud at any tuue. and i rum t.n.. ,o ,i„,o. ..„ uotK-.. iron, the ...rponm-.n. to oxe^^uH- «u.h po«.r of .U,o,..ov and other authori.Uss in lavour of the corporation, or unv ,.„n.inec or nonunee, ot .he .or.H.ration. as U.e oorporat.on n.uy '""•'"7n order to provide the ne..s>ar.v funds for the purpo>os ,.. .l- ..or,,ora,ion. a ca - of the no.n.nal a.nuun, .,,■ 1,0 boudsdcposiUHl, .nu«t U. Pd In each depositor j.pou nmk.ng ... lolit; and if the corporation .hall at any time by wnt.ng nnde.. i,.s .oal. certify that .non- fund. .-.• ...p.ire.1 for the purpose. .,f .■ „,K,rJ,ion, then the cor,K,ru,i..n ,uav rai^ nuch further fnndn on ho M..l.ritv of the bo.»ds. a, su.h .... of interest, not excees afs.1 shall be appl.ed Uy .he ...rporation in manner foll..«ini.. .hat is to s,iy.- /n To the paynen. of .he past an.l futu.* ex.KMuhture o. Ic corporation, of a.nl i..ci.lental to. or con...oct«d ^u..., .he .leposit of the lKn..ls. a.id of .he doing of all such things as Uic corporation may think it expwlient to .lo in the interests of the ccrtitictttc h.ililers. ,■.. To the payment of .he .t>n...neration of the .orporut.on . ii, Any snrplus shall. «>.-■.. .he 'aU.urs of .he .orporat.o.i in .,■ u- iion to the bona, shall l.aye been ..Hnploted, Iw d.y.d.-.l an.ong«t the certiKca.e h-.l.lers in proportion to the a.n......t of the bonds represento.1 by certificates hel.i by .1.. Bubccribers. 7 The corporation shall 1« en.ld to such .■o.nu.ierat.on for it^ .eryices in relati.,n to those p.vse.its as it shall .leternnno, ... oxc^ocUag one-half p.c. of the ..o.ninal yaluo of the ^"^^y^^ H The corporation may at a.iy tin» co«yo..o a .neoting of .h. .o..ili.a.e holders. At least soyon .lays' notice by adyert.sonion. .» throe London daily newspaiK-r. shall bo gnen of snch >»«">' "&A ..uorum of any such meeting shall l.e at loa«t ton persons h..ld.ng .frtificHtes for at least f- of the bonds deposited. a At eyery such meeting the bearers of the cert.hcates atsd shall ,« regarded as oxclusiyely entld to vote in respect of the bond o bonds represented thereby, and upo.i the vot.ng for every #100 ef ppul owing in respect of any such bond or bonds «hall confer one v;>tc on the corresponding .«rlilicato holder. j.) A general meeting of cer.ilicate holders conveucl as afsd shall h*yofuU power by resolution passed by a majority ..f tho votes gnon J FORMS. 41« Form 66. „,..„ .he .,uc>.io. ... .auction a«d approve any course of action which ^^ ':r'"",r;:-a:;iX"tt .huH be .aUea in ,u.h n.unuor and at V.^^. " " " '" 1 rurL chairman of the n.eetiug .lue.... und 7='"£SI?S5^'=^-^-- ,1„. aa,iu..rnn.ei.t took place ......lioi. m a .Imiinu.n ..I a Wh....."!-" •■"r^^,:;'':^;;S«Te'h.,d.-. ,.. •> '«■ «■-; » - •;,;;'i;::;:::,',';;,rr.,i, ... ...e ....> -.."•.«i..» '■••" "■• ,,, M„„.t.s u , ij ,,^,1 1,0 mmle and dulv entered •\' ''T:;;';: ;m>:tl^ e t!;«-tion, and any «uch minute^. if '" ' V '" ; ,'; ' H 1.; U>e ch..nnan of the nu-oLuK a. « Inch .such ' '"•'•:": "''"l/ine iu r^ and until the contrary is proved. *'-' '':.::::: ^^Z^^l^^. preceding, of .hich uunute» ;:• ,: I^ Ian L, dee.ned to have been du^ '^^-•;';^ -- ;;;:., a.!d uU re^-mtion. paB«ed thereat, or pr.K*odu.p« hnd. to have ;,.e CO. ,H.ratiou nhall not Ik, bound to as^gn any n-a^or. .. . excrc».n, the power »o reserved. • ,„ j,^ n-u-arded for all i.urposcn N,.^,tiia.ility 17 Tl>c certificate in ea.h case w to be regardtU lor • 1 l .^.rtiti. ..u,. „; ucotiable in.trun.ent and as conclus.vely ^'v.d-«- g ho Utk :.• ,ho Lrer for the tin.e being and from twne o '-' ^'^ -^^^^ .,.. lK,.„l. .h. n-iu n.out.l and all por.sou« are mvite. ,-> ^'^^^ ,.„., ,1.. owners thot '.. act on that footing, and ne.thor the ' JM" r-< ,..., anv loldcn or depositor shall be affected by any not.ee to the : tr rV .tl no dopo^tor or holder shall Ik, re,u.rcd or l.ablo o ; .,. ... otlurwU deal .ith such bond or bond. ox..p ..p.m ,h Lu. ..f'the covporation. and the certificate holder i. not to be at liU'ily to witlulra t.uvo (vrliliod in writing u are cninplpte. l.dra.v hii bond or bonds until tin- e>n«>n -hull nder its seal that its relatiou« to U.e bon.ls E E : ji^m^^rsssm 420 AnREKMENTS. [Chap. V Form 66. Ciiiiditii'n. 18. This Hgrooint i* c-oiiditiunul uu ita beiu^; ratiticd in writing \>\ tho liuklvrH of ull tho tionds or l>v tlio holders of such proportion, being not loMN than oiip-foiirth in value thereof, as the corporation niuy consider siitKriont, and if this agreeiut docs not become absohite before the of , it Nhull on that day become void, and the deposited bonds shull l>o returnee«t endeavours to obtain the r^d leiuses. and after execution tliot the coy shall grant the sub-leaso und the coy shall execute countcr-|)artM of tho nub-leases. 2. .\' the -anie time the (■•i\ hhuil iijncur with the directors in cxerutii. J a tni^t (l(>eeting. I\ \vitne.ss. &f. The iSciiEmi.Es A limited company, it lui» bevn docidi..' i« a " rospcotal)!!' and ro»poii»ibU' {lerwii " witliin the mcanin)r of a covenant by a lemee not to auign withuur FORMS. 431 thf •inent of ihr Ibmop l'«at'h oon»ent not to \>e withhi'ld in flio ia»<- of n PoTlB fl7. • ri •'|>«'< '"III"' '""' r«lu |wri«>n ' j. Itillmail v. /.■■.- Ion H•. ihnfir lallotl ' ihc liiiii '), of the ollllT ]>t. Whkheby it is vi-rked a« follows: — I. Tlio lov »li:ill supply to thf linn, ami tlio linn ~liall piii'lia-o Miid Comimnj t B""*' &>'.. and siinilar irnods niaiitifiiehinvi li\ oiideaviiiirs tn promote siioli .iiid to tlie pulilic of — , ilie iiiv. and tlie firm sliall use tlieir tiest sale mid distriliulioii. Tiie prii-es at wliicii froi«|s ,-i. ill Ik' -upplie«l li\ till' (iiv to tlie firm shall 1m> those siHM'ilieil for such ;;oimIs in till' 1 urn'ut priw list for the time lieiiiu: of the .pecilie(l or rel tilled and supplied liv the cov a' le<« prii'<>s tliaii tlio^e -pecitied in llic iMv's ciirrt'iit (irii'e list, nor shall the tirm wiilioiit '■iich coiis<>nt ill'tvv anv rehate, hoiius. allovvaiiee, or rwluetion of any kind on such price citjicr directly or indiiwtly. .: The lirm shall at tlie cciiiimenceiiieiil of each season prejmre a |iin<-oiint leliiil pattern lioy the I'"''"'»""- viiie i.f a majoritv of a coinmitte*' i "iisistinir of two of the directors fill the time lieinc of tho coy and Iheiu-tin^r memln>rs nf the cimimittee i-stalilished under clause 20 hof. The linn shall not ti. ket or soil any troiids at a lo.N.5 prirr than tho coiiiiiiiiTOx' .shall is; uritini;- approve. .'i Siihjcct to ('lau.se 2 hof the lirm shall 1)0 at lilierty to ipinle their Firm'M lil«rty I'Wii net pri(vis for Htoek orderw. to quote. •i The lirm shall not ])ay the carriajre, exi'ejit in the I'ollDwinff CaniBL-c. ijiM"*, luunelv, &c. fi ■ 4,'-.' AUUICKMKN'IH. [(.'UAH. V. n. I I ! I f Form 68. IiMua uf Ilt'W Ht'MIM>ll |Mii »' iMMtk. Tl'l-IfC nf urttlpinMii to be iilloni'd hy Hrin. 'I'lnnii of M'ttli'Uient ti> )m' h1Iowi'T'u^^H^ puttcii l.(.oL> shiill Im' i^Mi.-il wiilim 111!' ImU'il Kiiiplom l>v tho linn or thf ...v i.rioi- t.. III.- - .lii> ..f ill oufh v«ar. When com- pany to pay rHnnajf'' p|' iciili'iiii'n t It. Iw iilJHWiwI l>v tin- liiiii ■'liall not ('X>.'(hI riiiliiwiiiK liitt'!*, iiiiiuclv, &r. I Ti'rins <>(' »«'tll«'iiiciit to lie ullo w«>il l.s llif rij.v l«i llif liiHi -^Iriii !■(> a^ riillow-', ic. Ill N.'w xMson's pxNls ileliviTPil lM'i«...-n SopK-mlrfr Nl in ..nx MMi i,w\ Ih.' ni'Xf H ^'oilinn •2'<'\\ Ffl.iUiUV lo in' chilc.l for lliv (.uri.-.^t-i ..f ll,.' :i.(.mnts in.Mitii.nfl m iIh' Ius( piv.o.linft cliin-.- a- of tl.c 1st .lav . 11. Ill 111.' ra«»> .'I' WW soii^.m's himhU supi.lio.1 liv lln' ; ni tlic tiiiii anil pai.l |..i in caili liclcrt' tin- iiaviiioiit ol' the niinitlilv ii..iMnit lor l. p.o p.tt. from llio dal" ->l |.aymoiit nntil Iho ihno vvhon llio piivinont of xtuh iiioiifhiy iio.oiint lM.l alior .lo.lMrtioii of tlio .|i-...,iiiit niloHi'.l nii.lor flaiiM' '.• liof 12. All jfi. '.l>t..l..' -iipplioill.y tlio.-ox to the linn shall l.o .-iippli'd l.v tho ..ly solely fo-- tho linir- l.iisiiioss at . or at sii> li "'her aihtross at tho ooy shall in wiitino; appimv. ami with all ro.i-.ii ihle ps,poiliti..n. ivoaid Iwinjr had to ollioi- ixMi.linyr ..r.lois for oj „k1s i„ he Kupplio.1 l.v tl oy t4> olhpr customors, hut the <<.y «hall not bo lial.lf tor any .latnairo which may ho oaus«> pep. a from the diite of paymont until iho .late wlion the pavment of the monthly aciiunt for su.li p.iHls hecoinos due in tho Mamo manner us is provided nii.lor olaiiso 11 liof in the cas*' .,f now Hcas.)i,.. fro.xI«: and tlio <'oy shall not Ik) bound lo siipplv I.. tlio linn any nimii'i kiml <>/ (/oo./x' the supply of wlii.h ma> U co.iliiie.l hy the i..y to any .leuloi ..r linn ..f doah'rs. or any place 'ir district, hut the linn shall have the rio;hl to 1)0 supplio.1 hy tho coy wiih any (iroods roprestmtod in the coy s i>uttern sots of any iiiami- factory ac.piiiod or taken over liy the coy, uiul now .supplyin)i; tiie linn refuse to pay tJia oorriagi' in any circiim^tanceii which tho coy may considof excoptioiial. H)KM'H. H The lirm «Iib11 not willioiil tl.c c!Oic«nt in wnunfi <>< 'h« ...% MiMk or -lit up imticriu*, or i«.uc. in ihoir pHtton. iMH.k- or ^ill for Hlmk UI.A «/»<-.7!/ A»«"'>""'""""'' ''^ I lie I'lv. r, TI.P tirm HhuM, on »ho wiiiton lOiiuost of ihc ro.v. .If-i-t f>'ini Mipplvinfe' P'«) whi.h rl.all !«' I.V0.1 l.v Ihc .ov in fu. h »uih year for iho coy to l«ko orders o„ .u-« ,,,„c.rnv So far us p. ti.al.k- paltorns shall 1k) sou* »'- 'lie liriii :, «,...k .arlior than »u< h M-uu-iit.l dale i; The tirm -hall not supply tii<> coys goods for ; ■ i;i'..i,..s< i liciiiL' «'hl l>y uuiti'U. IH hi ri.iison ol lie prtnnisos tin- (oy fhall allow thr ,, i ;. ii- ...iiiil of 1" jHJr tent, on tho uinount pd hy tho lirm I \ .h,.,s ../ -;.H,./*] purchaHwl by tl.v lirm direct from the coy at the IHi.o of tho coy'H current pri..- list, but this discount .shall not appl> lu goods of earlier seasons than tho soason of I'.iOi* l'.>10. H In the event of unv infringoment liy the lirm of the provisions i,„l except as to clause H hof. tho commilloo hnftr mentd shall have iiovver to sus,KM.d tho .liscount payable or allowe.l under .lause IM hof for s,„l, period and !■■ su.h manner as the .■oiii.mtlee .-hall lliiuk lit, aii.l the decision ot the committee, or of the majority ol i.s memlK>rs, shall bo ac.opte,! by the lirm as final, and the my shall further have the right, in.H.ciialcly ou such infringomonl. to c^-ase ,0 suppU anv more goods to the H u. I'rovi.led that, without limiting the righi.s and powers met,: i in this clauso, the hrm sha I l,cfore such discount is ,-usiK>ndony. WIm'U Hrtii ii.il to »iic|il)r : . ]iuHifiil;,t .\. I.> triviMii.i.' I .) ..nl.r- Atu ti«»i»- S|H'iiut 'll- I'DUUt to toiii for iittrti' iiiar .Su]«peitt*iuij n{ ilincouiit to ♦imi wlipfS iiifrinjfi'iii. "t. CommittM. Infrinifeini'nt uf Clause 14. 4t>l A»iHKKMKNT8. 1 i [!■ Form 68. Ku iMU« uf IMittem buuk to Hnull Imyfcn. lUi'iit to bind •ucceiwiHK of the parti«». 1>iiratiun of »Kreeiut'nt. Service** of noti't'i* fill flrm. '2'2. Tliu ciiv mIiuII not i<««uo ii rotuil ijricoii pattern bouk in Rmall buyers biilii (l(>lint><|. I'roviilod tluit tho voy «lmll 1h' iu uo wav roNlriclod from currying ou or pxteiidin); tbo busiiK-sses (.whetlicr of iluiiliM'H or oihjMttiM'i us now oxisliii}; itno.s nliicb inuy bo ui'<|uircnt smli pattern books sin,.- the luontli o.' — -, I'.t — . I'.'l. Thij* ao-ieeml >iiall Ih- binding: on and enure for tiic bcnclii >,( the ])er.«on> fur the lime ln'inj,' rarryinjf on business in smcessidu i,, ihe partii'.-. hioof ih( sei und part, notwithstanding any changes wliiih • biiino ihi' I iniliiiininie of th'>* .ii.'MH'mi may occur in the ii>n*tilutiMti of tli<' lirm by ihe dealli nr reiircmeiit of any partner or partner.-- i>r llie addiiioii of any i)ariner or partners lit This agreemt shiill 'eiuiiin in fori-e bir srvcn years from ihc - - of . I'.t Provided that tlu< my shall have [lower to ilcici- mine (h< agiei'ml h-.t the -llsi of I)e. -ember, 19 . by thriM- <-alcnd.ir months' noli(e in writing addi<'>sed to the lirm. i'rovidol fui-llii-i- that ilie my shall until the .'llsl I'f DewinlKjr in he year iu which tln- agiceml is ileiermined or e\piie» continue to supply to th.e lirm f ■! pattern bouk order.-- oidy iri""l-. the supply of whiih by the i-ov to tlic lirm foi suih orders is bei-eiii provich'd for. :;.■> .Any noli(e under this agreemt may be given Ii) the lirm In ■seniling the same ihroii'.'-h n-irisicicd post lo the firm at their l.i-i knowii or usu:il place of business, and any notice so .sent shall be dceiinMJ to have been starved on the lirm on tho ilay following that on «lii( b il is po,vU>d \ «ii\i>x iVc. A ijiaiiii'iii-tnriT who »i-ll- i,'o[.(|< i-aii laaki- it of the (-onilltinn- of "iilc tli:ii tlicy ^h.lli not he rc-oI(l ;il l*"*f* thiiii a --pccilitHl price. liUtntim k\ S',u \. i;i,.:„,,l,„. .\- .S„„.., HHdl , -.' I'll, ■il.'); Mri;,iirh>,- \. I',lrh.,. (1!M)») '.' til :UMi; t ,..l.,l .-/„„ M„,l, ./ 1... „l r.l.nnl.i V. Ilrnt.t. 1 I !)(«» > .\ . ( '. IM" Stii-li a I utiililiiiti uilt not run with tin* ^oihN mo an to liiad a iitiri'li»M-r with '•! wilhoiil noli 1- ■/■/■/■II/ ,v '■.). V. ,>7e,i).c ,v ('.»., i litJl) 1 Ch. 3.)1', unl---- iinli-e*l the i,'o*nh are paleiil'ti anil the ^ale \* mutle hy tli*' uwniT of tin- |i:iteiii riu'lil". /'.•/lie Millie a vile hy him iiiipli<'< a liei'iiee to -<"11 thi" p:itent.>l irix"!-. toit if. oil ihc Male, thi;* implied tii-'-nce i- (pialittetl, a Miih-ptircha-i-r, uttli or K ithoiit iiotie** fif the i|iialiii< ution, ii IhiuiiiI to k«*op within the iieeii'-e. Hi'iit^/'l*- .;„.(,/, 1.11./ s,„l,/ l„l,,,k \. I//I,;, ilitiMii 1 Ch. tiOi. \S h*-r.' a iiia(uit'aet!ir*>r <-elU to A. suhjert to the eontlition ttiat he -.hall ii-it ■i-ll to It . anil II. inilm.'" A. to i-oc.riil i lirea.h of the enntrait. II. i« li.ihle in datiiui;**^ to th.' maiuifactiircr for the tort. .Vi.fii.i.ii/ /'A'i».ii/.-«'/iA ('... v. /.'■/ - ■■■■ l:.ll, .n. (■„., (lm)8) 1 I'll. 334. See Kiif/r/t. p. 38U. |-OKM«. »io .\(.KKI Ml Nf '"/ /,// 1 .11.1) Storm. i. Kn I'l k> I» fxxx l„ iH)ul tiiiuss Kaumni.s Form 69. „„,(• fix Mini Ml M H^■'"ls AN AtiKKr.MT n.a.li' tlio for ST i»(>vi«riil I'artie*. ,1 ill 111.' I""! .mIuhIiiIo lito, whcicl.y it. i.- ;iL'ro( la- t(jll<"vi: I 111 lli<-t' liiv.-.oiilf, 11" lie.-.- ilii'ic III' .■MiniiMliiiitr ui ilu' sul'j lu' su1m>'' t '"■ '."''•' 1" ulltCXi illKllLSI •H'lii ihcivwiili; Tlif .si^aiiilum'.s ' im-aiis the pain I'iii' iiiiimiilloi.' hi. incaiiN ilif it>iiiiiiiili-i' liii- till" liini' I't'iii^' <^i'ii- iliiifil us iuilii- |iiii\i il.'.l. Til.- auliioii/..Ml i.ivnii.M- nirau- llie |>ivini-. ilif. I ill ill'' h1- and lov »^oivi( ...iMiiiiil coliiiiin Til" LMii-N cainliiii .-liiiaV!!' I 'I' Uo/on i:i> Veil I- iiu'iiiiH .•.oiiic < Ui .lanuai'v. Montir iiioiiiix laloiidnr iiioulli t the lii>l M-in'tliil*' 111" iiH'ali.'* llif "IiiiIp iiniiiiit> ari-iiit iriiin tli(> ('« imidi'iital I Ill-roll alfiidai- vcar iiiiiinii'iu iii^' Willi iMi- 2 K'-r I Ik- l«'i'i .i-ll.i'- i-aiuin--- .11 ill.- St. I- a-.' "f l>'>/«'" Ik- |..„.li.i i.iip.lii.r .11 liiiiilli' llli'l III i.'- ill a. .' 11.11' h'-K'i- an 1 iiiiiii aial li .i-r.'''i. ail. a-. -hall laiico «11 l.i.fir provi.U-d 1.1- .livi.U-.! I"i" i iln- ■•'-''•a- I ill.- tnlal III h iho 1H.-1V. '111.1-.- -o! ..l.l»'-i"> tl"'i'- 'osiH-.tno „• .sd poii.id .-aril <<( III.' „„„i,.,- in III,. liiM '''■li.'dulo hi... and d.iriiiLMli. . .i..i,a,..n.- -hall, lor . ,d.l M.-.a-,.- aii.l in i.h-i.ial m-iv,..-. .ha,., no 1.,^- ,1mi, 111.. iiiiniH IM..- iM .l.a- Mmlf ^Im- ili.' 1 >" 'l'" -'"^ ..|,..d.ii.- ht.. or o,li.-i ih.' niininiiiii. lau- lioiii Huh- to Uni.- 1in.-'I iu ,i,,oidaii..- «illi .l.in.-<- '.» liol' :, Willi, in...i.l.Mh..o. .li.'.'M.i.ali , .-a. h >.-a. , oni- A<.ou„U. ,,,..,1,111^ «Mh. hi- uar ...i,hoMlK-M;.nalo.i.--li.lll,.nu-h.o ,li,. ,o,„„H„.-.- a ,,.■;.,....■ .I.'laih-I a,.o,.n. of ih- .n- .-a. n.i,.^- ol h. h -i.M.aloiv dm in- l!i.- |.r....'.linu' v.'i.i-. ami th.- .-.i-inni -hall lu- at l,U.,,v ,o .-nii-lov an a.-o.,i,.aiil or o,li.-r .-.x,m'I. io .-xauiin.' m.. i ,,,,.„„;„ ,,„d ...riilv a- lo ,1... .orr... t.H'.- th..l. ami mi, h M-natoi ^ -hall ;,|„,id to 1 ..Mimiu. r aiiv Mu. h ■ir.oiiiiMnt -r ,'Xl.orl all iva-n- ;,|,|,, |,,.ili,i... for ^.-rilM.i'j- ihi' ...•niia.v of tho o.oiint. , Wi.hin ..-M'n .lav> ol il..- .oi-i ii.,..H,-nl .-i .':.- h lah-iidar i.h M.-«^ly_ .,,,,1, „| ,h,. .-iunalori.- -hall pav int.. .- l.ankin-^' a., .mnl to I jn-n.-.l ,„ ,«„u. U ,1, iM.Mti.M- or IO I... under th.-ir .oni.ol. tm p -■ >•' tl-' -i"- niniin^r., .11 -mh siRiiatorv .luring ihf im-.'.-.UaLr ni'-nli .-, Tl..- ...iiiniltt mn tr,.... lin.o „. -itm-. o-.t of tin- i..on.-N> I'.l t- .V.Wa,.... ,l,o .,d a^ a.lvam.- to ih- si.nia.oi i-^. .a an; of ,1. on a. .•onnl .,1 ,1,.. |,i.po,„on of ,n,..l |,i... I- - vvhi.l. -.'1' -irnaton,.... ..r 4-.'t> AUHKEMENT8. rCllAP. V. mi: . H I Form 68. i'njniciit of balance. l>iviiiiou of KVitilable balHDoe amongst «i!i.iiitoric». Iiiinntatiou. I i.u-it of 'iblif^tioii- of niirtittfori- «iguulorv arc or iis an hitt'u iiiontionud nwplj uiiiilled, hucIi ainoiniu tt» tho (uiiiiuitteo iiiay tiiink fit. (i. As xodii after the expiration of ouch year u8 the gcuHN (■ariiiii^-^-. of vacli signatory hIiuII have bwu uui-ertuiiieJ by thu loiiituiitoi- uuiu.s of clauMo :i hof, tho eominittoe Mhali cull upon oach of the Kifrnaiories to pay the balan-* (^if auy) of the gro'w earnings of such signatory into tlio sd bunking account, and upon Huch payuiont'- being made tho coininittoo shall divide the tutal aiiionnt so )id into ili>' sd bunkiuo' atoount uniong^t tho signatories in duo propoiliuns. regard l)eing hud to auy sums in rogaid to \vhi

  • afsd so thai tho gros- earnings may Ik' divided in lonforniilx wiiji clause 1 hof. 7. Full iiitoni:alioii lu be given to coniuiiilo*'. Ai . 8. As to each of ilie signatories, it such conlriliiilory fail- lo ni^iki a'ly uiunthlv ol otiiei paynieni herein provided to be iuatioii shall (certify to bo the sum whii li iij their opinion re[ires«'nls the fair me;;-iire of the daiiiito-e >o c.m-cii to sui h ■ tlior .-igiialorie<. and the amuuni .«ocerliliccl >liall lie ic.nci- able from siu h signa1or\ bv the other signatories a- li.|ui.lMieil ■ l.ima|iv~. irre>(M'ctivc of ani..- portiuas. it The following provision.- shal! Iia\c elled. naiiielv : iai Not to part with uutlioria»d protnises. (b' Not to Ir' concerned in any other cold storage i oiicerii (e) [Not to cxtoud uutiiorize0 a rotioiiittee for the purpow's hof. Fach "f the dignaiorie - shall ht. ontid to aitpoiiit : <'o iwrsoiet us moinl)ors ot the ooiuniittoe IpDWir to fill nft Vnciitirii'* I'rotetlnii' {funrtiw F0I{M!4. 427 , , Tho «iLM>ato.io« »hull bo l...und by tho .le.iKioa« o. .ho cm- Form 69 II The «ibMiaioiii» urovisioiis liof aro placed DecUi..i.»of i,„K. upon ttU matters which uudei tlio P'"^'^'""^ ^, . ■ '^^ j^ committee. !,or the control of tho committee or declared to be subject III IIIK (li'ii^ion. ,o TJ.n ro.niuitieo shall, if aud whonover requirod «o to do by any ^^'^" ;:,:;;,rraud th^r de^^lon .hall bo biudin, on the H.gnator.es. ,, Subioct (o U.O la«l l.ro..Hling clauoo hof, ..o commi^^^ionH N.^u-J..-^ I .u.ul ilbwan.*., conc^ions. bonusos or reduct.ons. d.rcct .,,.A,,.., . S; 's Ul bo paid, given or allow,Hi by anv of the n.^natone. ;:;: ::;C, 1 cm lov;.'.hof t,. anv n.or..hant«. broke, or oMjov 11 whotn^oover but tho rates for tho tinio bcnfr ... lorco horo- '"'r^.i U ■ . Hv ch..r,.>.l to all ,>ers,.„s bv all tho .i.natono.. ; ' „ :nC oi::.. of tlli. a.roo„tt that all ,1.0 si^natonos «^. . ;,,l:;:,W ......o rate, in the fuHos, a.td vvid.«. .o..so ot that oxpros- ,iou. M.bjo.M to the provisions of ilau>so I 'J liof H. All the c^t. and expense, of aad i...-idont«l to ^^ V-'i^ ^^"'•- .,ul exo.utio.. of thi. a^^ix^cmt, or in a..v wav „u.,.r,.Hl b> the con : t^i.. .......oetiou w..h the n..*ting« or other pro....l.n.. tlu. . :,.„..,..,,. .M..rt a^iH.a..c., or for He.....ar.a or o.h... !'->"-- .„,H..«i,-.. lor . arrvinp ont the provi.-io..s hot, .ball bo pa.d out ol the : b nlin, account, and m. borno bv tho si...a.o.ios. u. aocordau.. :.,h the proportiouK in which tbov aro to >ha,o ti.c total a...o..n. of ill" ijroiw earnings. HI ^ 1.". /'/lO'/xi/ins- hi' luhitriitioii] Art'itrMtii'ii. In \vitnk>». Ac The S. HKl)ii.f> above roforred to Fimt Schedule , i Pniiwrtiini "f iirixcifls to \»- N;,m. - .1,1 .\ddiwi«'<« ot , l>„.|ui»." iiutli'.ri/.il. rt.„,rv.-.l hy iii' li SiKiiHt«r> Sijfiifttoht***. I M KNT8. "Chap. V. Farm i Stu^tnd '•iriii'iliile. It. .. riptini. of Kro/.i, l'n»lii. ., RHt''^ »H'l C..ii.llti»iiH. SliariiiK grow ivfwrM, as hove. *>.w mit, tt i- api)r.-l..-ii.l.«l, cM.iwtitm.- a partiierHhii. a'"tt«* "•» l'H'tn 'W,., intiml hill) f'H to (>i 1 1 II >*MK <"»■ I'l HI It Si i(Mii!!i-i..s. for sale "f 11 I . . I stock .V\ .\(;RKI;MT iiiat»m.ii tin <'c»v. Laaul linl'ii "), of tin' iiiif 111. •mil A -jati K ilmnr riUimi ' luv ,™.~ .. mntimfors 1 ul the Tiht-r |ii \\'in;KKA> '*• -'V i> itb<.ut i» crwiv ,«piUllirtN J j^^ 0,MMMM»/ .-. lie .U'twUttirf sIimU Avi- \VIW11K»» -•Uiil wliii iimv "tter """ i ••« -- . r same for (Icbt'iiiiiw HMf'k is to Ih> .■.■u«rituMNl anti ^twsapett l>v .t xram tHH-o «"''"'!.!'.'''" iniiiii'*! ill tlx" •<'"ii<« "I tlw 'It-at' wfaidi lia^ afe»i'«dy twpii |»i!par."i. """'""' an.) 11 cofv ..I tthi.'li hiu*. I..r rti.- i.iirtMiM. .,; KteiitttifUtiim, l.'-t. -itilwrilttHl bv .\., a ^«>li(•lt■«l■ ■>! Hif >ii)ir«*iiip \ l\ -n.li ! i-iic ~hall ll.- |.ai.l liv liic .ii.-laliiK'iit- fojlouiiij.', lliul i- to >ax .I.H ol .la\ of oy ■'liall pay .-iii li inlrn'fl mioi<|iiio-lv J KOKMH. .. .,.,,, ,,„.,,a<..ur» >lu.ll U' .■ntl.l U, ,uv oacli of ,h.> iu«taln...ut. ;• , ,, „; „M.f U..ur. .he .bv Hx.. ...r .la- ,.uv.u.M.t ,ho «. a .1.- " : ,;; l ,.. .a^ . i».err.t a. tlu- .a,, -f - ^ ,..o. ...a I... .....o. ;;;:;;;;;;:,„. ,.u. .lu-u ...l. i....al.no... .hal. ...uaUv U. ,,a.a a,..l ,l„, ,,a,.. «lK-n the «iUR' Uhou.o.. aue uuiv Ik.' .l.-h..a«.l. , „. „,, ,,i,,.,,.,..,s sl.all .lo....».i.M> ... ..tU-r all or any part ot ih., ml ., ...11 c.r .li.M.oM. ... tlK. KUM. i.. anv ...)».. n.a.n.or. ,|.e c.. >l.a 1. . tl . , n . a^ .lu> .ouUt.o,.r. .hall ..-a^.nal.l^ .-.miuu-o tor .1..; pur,...-.- .. . p, ,M-.u~. an.l .hall .u.aish .u.h n....naa,...u ... m., 1. -, Tho .■..^ -Im'l pa^ all -"."'P ''"'i- l"'.^"''''" "' '•'"'"■", "' "'" , ,;.,,i.,„ „, ,|u< ^a a«I...H....- --.«k. a,ul .1.0 <•<-.« of ..an.p...« lh<" -us. ;::;:; ill ..,..1... .•..■ ^- ».-• "- <— -^ "- '""♦•■"•"'^'' """' "" ,n..-...a,..li.. .via...... '• ly ii.for- iniitit.n i. iimkf jiulilir iirt.rttny t" puy "tiiii.p duti.'N tt> I.' (Tuati'.n ... ^t.K!k ttll.i tru«. dwJ ,. , ,„ „, , V ,1... ...ntrH.,..r> ..f .!..■ t..>. ...>.al...o..t of — - p. ..,.1 ,lu. ..:.v shall .^M... ... .1..- ...........o.> ..-■ -hoir m>n»,HH.s ., ,. :.ia. ;. .... .;. i.^- .«-.. ,o .... ...... a .. -; ^ ,„.„ .., tiu ..nuMor^... ....- .^...-..f .... s..Kk hl,> a.M...I ... w.^... 1 ,;,)! U. ..*,..l.-.-.i ... !«• at'**'''-' '" "»• -"»' -'""■""•^ ""''■ "■ '"' auv ..«.riteu..-.- .~*ued i.. .ulMi.u...... lor H"- ~..n..- - a a«v -. np .•en.li. ..... h.-l-U- a.^i ...ak.-^ .I.'lu..l. L- ...o,v thao ,l.v> ... .HL. ,mv........ ... a..> ...... IHiNahl.. ia a. - o..la...« with ih- ,.^. ... tl np i.-r...i.a.o, ..... ...v ^....H. i- ov--- "' t «.- powor ,„ ,«., .„..«a. n..-v..l I.N ...0 ^.-..P .*r..«.a.os, ,..r.... .h. ..o-k ,.,.U. .'...kI M.. h ...Maul. «.thi.. a«v.. a.,.l .he ...... r«.-...r> -..,.11 ,„,k..T.„„l su.h .h-.a..l. a. li..W'lv. a..,l -hall .h..r.'..pon n......v.. ,. ,,..,h M-np .t.r.iti.a.- -I"' -v "''I"""*-' '" "'" ""' ' """ ' ,,,..UuHl «i.h .... «u... .... l.....r .o ...o .orf.-....r.v —i -.h aa^ -,„„. ,„1 l.v th. .•..n..a.-...r- ... a... ...I - «'th «.uh .^..^ H |'uv>..c.U ... auv ..rii- ...r.ili. a..- hohl.T of a..> ....-.^«« •" a- . ..r.l- ,„„. ,,ro ia.U,. ..f .1... ...U-..M paval.U. ... .h- .■..u..a..or. u...«.r . lal.M' -1 h..i .. \VI,......v.-. .1... I...I..-. o' aoN -..'1' -r.ili-a... al-.l .-hall. ... u.M„... ..f tl..- Mo,k ......pri-0,1 .!....•...... ....•.■. '- l-ay a..v .....al....... ,...^..l,l.. lh...t>... in a.lva,.... a. a ,1.......... .h .I'a.l.-s -l-all '"■ ,1,,.. ,1 ... olo.. ... ...ak." .I... lik.. p.^ i.. a.Ua..... a. a .I........ in ,..,p., ,.f .h.. >u..... H..,.U a«..l ^h«l. i....h»i.h pay .ho a.........' ... tht' iDV a€C"i^ly S • rtifl- h..J.i.. rn tiiiilo. of the sale of the st.uk to the ooutrartors. 1 1 .\lthoiieh the stock (.»'rliti(at«'^ :ii«> to he is-^uod in the name of the ...v, Iho sums pavable bv the holders in iicoordaneo with tli- terms hof are to 1k) pd over t-) the contractors, hut witliout prejn- lo their oldi(ratioiis to pay the coy the full instalments payaMc in rcsiK-ct of the -i.le hl.y iigrei'd lo U- made in accordance v iili clause 1 hof. I.N W 1INK>S, Ac. hi the- ...M. of ^1 tfointf c-oi.i,mny xvlii.h .l.-sire< to .li.!."*- of a l.lo. k .f d.l,..|itiir.-« or cleLentur.- -t-n^k or prof.Ton.r .hares it i* som-tlnn-. thouirht ..»|MMii.iit to «.ll the i«ii.- to «.ii.r .aiiitalist and to le»»c hi»i to offer it to .!,.■ ,,ul>lic at hi« own ri«k and di,.rctio„. Ow advantage of tins ->!.•.:: i-, that >i the i,ur.has.T i- no? a i«-nH.n who ha» l>e..n .ntfaged or interested in i,..- formation of t on.panv. a pro^-e'tus i-."-! hv him, on hi» own neeoum. ,< exempt from the onerous re-piiremenf. of «.'. t. HI of the Conipanie. .Art, l«W S.-« .«,.ra. p. ll!7, .\ee,.rdin(flv, a« lon^ a. the pr«peet.u» i> an horn-it uiic, the pureha-er i« not bound to make any -p« ial dixlo-urei as to contratts, 4... ■IL Form 71. farties. Ap|>oiutment to ottire Temi. A. to jor.io,. for any ''- l'-''"^ rh.. s,l .al,.. V shall .onnuou.* from .he .lu.e hof. un.l ^hall Ih" ,,,l I... •!... lirul lllor V llilVIlHMlt .O 4ai Form 71. iii.iK'ilv on till' lav of , &' ■ <•"« '•'•■*• 'I'laHorlv piivnuMit .o ^;'-:;\;;i:.;:L.oi:;:a;isala.rl.lA ll..U..in.hi--;e , „„i,... ,.,.1. IH. ..ntl.l to the Kharo in the profits o. .h. . o.v M. ,,., ,1,.. arts of asson thof. is ,«vaMo to tl.o u^-n.-ral .....na^^or In, ilir linw U'injr "f the roy. - Tl..' -.1 ^ "hall IK) at lilwrtv to resiga tho s.l oHi.v at any tin... „,,;,„ ,Mvinsr to .ho -oy thrtM, calendar ninths' no.i.o of h.s .Iosmt ^'T 'li l„.fo,v .1... ..xpirati.m of voars fr.Mn tl.o .la.o hof tho .,„ is «onn,l u,,. or it l-v any other n.eans. ,.x.t,,.t .ho .loath ..r ,.:iK«a.iou of tho sj A., his tontno of tho .d olH.^ shall l.o do.or- ,„i,.^,, ,ho .oy .shall pay ... the xl A. the smu. of 2.000/. as h.pnJu.o.l hiiiiii'.'os f.'r lii" !"■<'' "f oflii*.] 1\ WIISF.SS. &v. Ul I. S,„u,.„u,.-, u .lnu«. .» i..»«rt«l in an aKr.H.m....l *UI. uu -...ploy.-' t- the olt... I : .■ a. h..n... «r-..l.r,.«a. ..btainal.le in ro,pe.t thereof. ,UU b..|.,n, ... h n ...v: ..-.d .u.h .-.nploy* shuU, npiiti» «» |MT arlii lp". .\. m«y rrsiirn. tion t<. A. 11. auie of wind- ing lip. *'•• \,.HHMiM for Ihr Appointmknt of a Sk.ki;tahy '"/ « r..MfAS^ l.,mfl of AhlfrfH-e. I'oinr tn Frntiiut. Form 72 THIS \(;HKKMT.A.. Parlies: - 1) (ho ,ov ; and t,l») B. Wiikkk.i IVrti.. ,lu. . ap.ial ... the . ..) i« !■ - -, aividwl iulo - «l.aro8 of £ - - omh ,<.. it.l- Am. WI.K.KK..S tho .lirc.-.or« of tho ooy aro. by tho art« of a8«...i U.ot. ..,upo«enHl ... uppoi... a Htrrotary of the- cov, oithor for a fixo.l txrn. or otho.u;.-o as (h.-roin inont/l, and to fix and dctorn.ino his rnn.unora- .ion, whi. h ...av ho i-v «ay of salary or o.horwiso iw. in tho ud arti.lo- iMcnld Nov. 11 IS llll^ \.,KKKI> u« f..''hl^v^l:- l Tl.o .S.I It. .-hall U' so,r...ary of .ho is.y for a lorm of — yea.-, Api-.......^ Hi Ih' ..oii.puHMl fioin .he duto hof m (,.■) S .fc/ro, j: *•.!, •• to upp"in?flnnt of ofHccn. i t ■ ! * r,vi AMUKKMKNTS. [Chap. V. Form 78. italarr. I« It. ■ utitled to \i»\e of ulmitiut. Sh»r*» to U) »llott«d to B. I'OWIT to rMuiiid. Form 73. CumnUMiuu oil aurplua pruflU. C'omiiiii>"i"' on pri'Sts. Form 74. < ■')roini'M«ion 2 Thoru »liull U- |xl l.v iho «(l B.. as «u
  • paViilili' .|.mri«Ml.v ..« i-v.-ry (lav of . - - day of — . (lav of — , aii.l .lu> of ; the first of such (pmrterlv |iuyiupiiin to be luinle on the duv of iwxt. ;i. Tho .-(! H "liall. iiiiloss iiicMiiK',1 .tiiiirn. y iM. cl. 3j. ». Tlif .-.(I H shaU. dnriiii: hi- tPiinro of th<« wl olli'C. \to oiitld |n leave of ul».HOii((> for a period in ein h year not eMoedinjr wcekv and, uulo.s.s othcrwiKe arran(r»'et«een the iH.ard of .lire.lor.s of tlie coy and the >*d H , »u.li leave of ab-^onoo Nliall he irranted in ea. Ii year ns follow.s. namely, from the (lav of U< tho day of " fir , \r Tho alwl sahirv of the «! H nhall continue notwiili- Mtandin^r "uch leave of al)»eni ( ,-,. Ir ni! of the pr»>mifeH. the <.iv -hall forthwith allot .m.l i8.MU> t. ••. I H l»>n >i Ua «hare- of t — oaoh. whi.h -hall I.p nunil.0. I :.. the hooks oi riie coy to - - hoth iudii.sive. lui.l .shall 1>. ileein(Hl for all i)ur|HK«eM fully pd up (i. Either of the partie- hio may :>< any lime after the - day of — determine thi« apreeiut by tfivirij,' to the other not loss than — calendar montlm' notire in writinjr. ami upon the exidriition of tin- jK-riod .';pecifio\ the coy. In witness, &c. The (ollo»iii(f cluiw- iir.> K(tt»ioiwllv iimsl; - " VVhonevpf the prt>«l« of tho ioiii|)aiiy niudc duriiiK tin- flnamiiil yi'nr or ..tin r IktuhI .•oiii|>ri«si in ilii- airomit. «ul.mitti-.l to thi- ordinary ifonoral mrrtin- in oai-h y.nr arc nion- thai, -iiffi.iont I. j hv n .t the rate of S ,ht cent, per .iniiuni, the "aid - , in aililition to hiK salary afore»a;/:, -hull he paid a ■..im cpial to ".i per cen. . .•■ ih. vxii—. The cerl.i'e.'c in *ritiii.- of the .vinpuiiy'^ auditor an U, tho amount of tUfh execs, or an to ilicr.- l"inK none shall lie cole .usivo." Hometino- an emphiy' i« ttiveii a» part of his rciniineriition a eoniniissioii on . ! .hare ot proHt«. Such .irranyenicnt. «hould Ih' .•nrpfiilly cxpn-swl. and < irewrally de-.-nlde to make the auditor's c, rtiflcate co.iclu-ive, /ti.',';,, .. 6V,,..//, 5 l-;.i. 32«; and /■■■»... v H ■"'■■.t^.» Co.. (Ibtfl) I Vh. Uu. -Hr. elauiHsi may run thu«: " In nddition t« l.i« -alary aforesaid, the .aie inistrporalion of ihc company to the tunc ol F0KM8. w ^^l.«t.u. of .->h divided, th™ .nd in «.eh cm* th« -id -- A»U. iu :?;,,:!««.'! ht„„i«ioa »» b, ...id wh«, tl.« di»id.nd ^a,.» p.,.bU. A. »!• the »[.]«.intment of ofBoer-, »«. p. 441 4;« Form 74. AN A(M in similar ca.sos. On , i,.u,..r. ollct ..I by Iho m1 L for ,Iio coy ho .hall bo ct.-l-l to rocovo. ir..ni the shipowao.-n a commi-.«ion not ex cs.liug 2i p c. on Uic ^*"' u.iounl of ff. i.,-lit, ai.d ho sliail inaU no char^ro a-aiiLst Hic coy lu r,.,.,K..l of ^u,-'. ciiarU'rs. but shall account to tho coy for any com- „„.vMon and allowan.o k-yond 2^ p.c. whic".. !»o may recover. .-, The sd L. shall koop tho cov duly .ulvi.<<-d of all salos and pu. - ;^;;,;|,";,\' ' a..s, - ai.,1 . harlor^ oticrio.l by him, and will in dm- ■ oiirsc loinbT pn.por ac<.,unt« of tli.- same, and from tiino lo tim- remit or pay to •he coy the aii.oui.U which sluill bo duo t« th- coy on tho u.-o,int^ • urrrut. r. T!,e s,l I,, shall keep in proper books full and proper f. rds nl .V ounu- ill the «.vs bu.sii..-.K pius».ing tlirouu'h his hands, and tho s.1 iocor.1- ..nd ail dvcuments rolatiiig t;o tho premises in the possession or under K 1^ ■■!■-. if •1 ! 4Ht AOBEEMK.NTS. •"Chai- v. y«ni7» lulerpivtB tkioii. ,l,e control o( th« mi L .h.U »t •« n*^..«».lo tim..- U open to tht in.,HKrtion of th* coy or their .gen.., who «h«H h.v full l.tn-rtv to ..mke copw. or extrwU. of or from the ,mm> or any of th«m ,.,^.......«.. 7. The «) L .h.ll .t .11 timw .luring tho continuance of ih» atfrcenit obwrvo all the direotion« and in.tru.tionM which may b« ^ven bv th« «ov n.l.ti.,u' to the pron.i.seH. and in (ho .l.-«m>. of «,,e.ial inMruili.m-. nhnll «.t in -uch n.a..n..r ... I.r ^hM doen. m.« bnncticial to tli« I'oy 8 The exprewion • L " hnlH,f...« u«e-rrwe vlau^,- U ,,t |. :«i2 suiira ] In « riNKSH. 4c D'lntiuii. hi. Form 76. »•«">•■ \.;RKhMKNT to >mplo>f Ar.ENT tO f,0 ABROAD „nd KxvM.NK TiTii fn and CnABACTEE of MisiN'i Phopertv AN At;HEEMT. Ac , between A. H , of the one pt, uud ,.;„„„ 0."ftr called "the ,y..,liu.te ■). of the "^^r^'-^'^V^. ,. ha., been .*pre«ented that there exi,t« m the emp.ro ot t ., aho..l ; ..,,0 miles N N.W. of T) and about 3.000 f.*t above m-a leve., .... ,.,.;a of ■ ver nine H.p.«re mile... cnta.ninjf a virKin matm'' diatnonds of the finest ....ality, yielding; an avera^-^- of one '•»^'' "•;''* .';;,. „.„... of the ,roun.l. and lyin« at aU.ut fifty to seventy fo^^. 1,. |,.w t>.,. Hurla« . and tluit the present ..wuer or owners of this pptj ,;„r ,,ro wiUin^f to treat for the sale thof, and .t ha.s b«.n arranH that U.0 sd A. H ^hall pnKHHHl to I)., with a view to n..iu.r.n^ .ntoth ...atter. ..n.l if p....Mbl.- obtainin,- ..n behalf of the hv nd.c~.tc an opUou for the purcha.se of the m1 ppty or -o„,e interest thore.n: Am. WHEKBA. it ha- b.H,n further arwnjt'Hl »bat .he par u* hto -h..!! enU-r i..to the aijreemi l.nf.r .....taine.! i.. .elation U, the premises J I'tlKMM. i:\'i ■ Tl. «i A H .hall pr<^\ .o I. bv th« outKoin, m«.l M..-r A^ P ... .. ""I""-;::; 1. «.,ta. LruLlm. ...«» .he o.ner or owner, of the '" • a 1" ilUng to tree, for the «lo thof or for «,m« .nt.r«* ,,,„, ,. or «r« *''''"8 ^ i„„ i„^, „,«. ,i,|« „,■ the p.«M.„( owner or r-^ "irr^re : ttil." ...e^n U he .ha.. eo..iae. -'" '"•^^ r h;;c- -» '^^^^^^^ -"•""•"'°*"' """■ . , . ......si,.... I.ut the .vmli.«.o shall hy le.ler or .ah.e '"'". .'"" " . ' :, r. i,u,„«lmt«lv pro..ee.i to ,uake persona. re,,uir,. ...... m. .o <'''^ ''^^ "^ „' , .„a nliall .au-e the name to , f h .o.^i.ler that the re.ulu of ....^h iu.,ui..e. ju.t.fy h.n. ... Me H..all not «, «o..Mider. bu. tJ.e .vndioat. -ha I U^ , 1 t..e ..wucr . r o«..e.« of .he sd ,.,.t,v a ......n.. . «.vu.« ...e k>.. d. „„., f..vo..r«hle .ern>« .i.a. he .-an arrantfe. and .hal. ..ur«..p ■■■': ".•ridf'.nS'l.U. ... .> . -.«.«. aU .uch .„for„.a.on^ O^.,,... ,,., . , vi.h n,,ard ,o the ppty i.. ..uestion, it- .«rr<.u„d.nR-. a..H „",,-„ am. ...hor ohara,..eri«ti».. and the n.ean« of .<^ : .'7 ...» a.^ t.. ...e mining ai.d o..,er la«. of I) «<. far as .he.> ma m . ..o Irki... and doveU,p...ent of ,he pp.v in .p.e.Uon a.u l"li..fr an.l exporting of uian.ond. therefron.. and «'— '" '':,:, „..n'a,i,„. .1. re..-,.ion to the pre.ni«e, a- he .nav .h...k ,.lvttnlu"eo>t'» or uncfn^ »«^ 'hP yndicate tl reports and information, and a.l .-ontract,, aK..^....«. • I .. a„'..ntAvhioh the ^d A. B. ..«T make ..r obta.n .n re.at. on ;„.i^> haU he on l.eha.f of a..d for the boneht of the ^v.... ...^ .,, ,.,.d ..UaU .. all .i...e. Ik, their abno.ute ppty. aiid s.u... .. :„n.ni,.a,ed hv the .. A .V ... t..e ^yudi-ate at the «ar..e-. .,.,.o.^- ,..,.i.i.w. and ..,.^^.1 X . H -l..." ->t di.e.o..e M...h .nforma ,on. ..p.. . . ,„„,ra...s. a^mH...N. or ...v.n.-enwnts to any ,«>.-..» ...he.- I mm ,.„.„.,.r;, oti..-.. an., mm van-K for the .i...e ..cin, of ..... sy.H.n.to^ ,,!..« ,.> his ..re..i. with a hank o- nK.r.a,.t..o ..o,...e in I.....!".. « " ',„„ „f r,....r. ...i.>h is to he draw, on by h.m a. he «ha.l ro.p.ire .... ,h.. p..rposes ..f ..efrayi..,' hi« -.-o.-arv an., proper ,l..shur«.n.on.. . onteniplated iu ilii.iw 1 h". 1.2 .MiiVrat)* \ii>.iii. I- ii 4*; Form 76. Furtlitr A. K. to account. AOUKUMliiNTb. rCHAP. V. Ueiuuuera- tion of A. 1 •i If the ad A. B. and the syndicate shall consider that the in- ..uiries, investigations, and reports under clause 2 are satisfactory, the syndicate shall place at his request to his credit with a bank or mercantile house in England a further sum of 1.400i.. to be drawn on as the sd A. B. chall require for U.i purpose of defraying his necessary and proper disbursements in connection with the further investigations and business contemplated under clauses 2 and 3 hof. 7 The sd A. B. shall account to the syndicate for all moneys ■irawn by him on the sd credits, and shall keep full and true aceounU •if all his drawings on the sd credits, and of his expenditure thof, under clause.s 5 and 6 hof, and shall, if and when required by the syndicate, duly vouch such accounto, and the syndicate shall not be under any obUgation to advance to him for the purposes of such .lauses or otherwise any moneys in excess of the sums ot 600/. and l,400i. therein resply named. 8 If the sd A. B. shall obtain from the owner or owners of the sd ppty a contract which shall be accepted by the syndicate, giving the" syndicate the option of acquiring the sd ppty or some interest therein, then the sd A. B. shall be pd for his services in connection with this business a sum of 1.000/.. but if no such option shall .e obtained and accepted by the syndicate, the sd A. B. hhall not he ontld to claim from the syndicate any remuneration whatever. In witness, &c. Form 77. A. B. to !«■ editor. Poliny and rOTuluct of this ut'Ws- pHjur. Vgkkrmknt oontiniihxi Vu: Appointment of a Person who hwi been Editor of a Compavy's Newspm-ku, and. has hreom.- a Director. AN VGREKMT. made the — of • . between fhe - Coy, I.imtd, of the one part, and A. B.. of — (hnftr leferred to as Mr. li.;, of the ollior part. Whkrkas Mr. B. is the editor of 'The - Nevvspapcr," which is owiHHl by the coy. Ano whereas it is proposed that Mr. B. sl.all .ouliime to"uefttiduct. buiikrupt«\ . &e. Notice l>y eoiiipiiuy to determine for iiiciipii'ity. A. B. not to bi' inti'iented in «ther newsp;ipert* in ( ertiiin evelltt*. il As WITNESS, &0. lit ii! 4:«« AOKKEMENTH. [Chap. V. It i i ! Form 78. Aokkkment to appoim Two DmtcioKs ,/8 Gknkral \1anu;eks of a Company's Business, nith Delegation of Dirkctoks Powers- Company to Share any New Business ol Managers' Firm-Remuneration of Managers out of StRPi.rs Ph-.hts, Reserve Fim.. Transfer Fees, &c. Special Provision <« r.s of the bu.siuess of the coy for Pinn to !>*■ niHirnrerw. IVr f anil powrr t.t TrvmiiKite. Mttiiai^'-rs ti the tor.i. hnftr specitiwl. and if either of them during .-^uch term ceases to 1.0 one of the managers, the other shall become tho Hole manager of tho bu.-.inoss of the coy, and they or he, as such manager or managers, are hnftr lefoircd to as "the managers c,r manager." i; The managers or manager shall hold office for a term of tea vears from the regi.slraticin of tho coy, but with po« . for them or hiiii at any time during the ad term, by notice in writing to the coy, to ...Mend such term for a further periotl of three years, and if, during; the continuance of this agreemt, the managers or manager shall bo incapacilato.1 bv ill-health, or shall discontinue in oflice, o. shall hnd that they or ho canm.t satisfactorily continue with tho coy or o'.hci director,s ,jf the coy. or if tho arts of usson nhall be altered by the oov without tl.oir ur his consen!, such manager.-' or manager shall have power, by notice in writing to the coy. to terminate this agreemt. ;! The managers or manager shall during their or his tenure of office provide and maintain for tho coy suitable office accommodation iu London and a secretary, and grant to tho coy tho assntance of their or his staff in London and South America resply for the purpose t carrying on tho coy's business, as may reasonably bo require,!, „nd in conson of tho services of tho managers or manager, includniff tho serviws to he rendered to the coy under this clau.se. tho coy shall pav (o the managers or manager reasonable working . xponsos, and Mich payments shall be in addition to the remuneration of tlift managers or manager prescribed by clause 7 hcf. F0KH8. «V.» 4 Tl„, .na,mKer« or .nau.g^r «hall manage and coaduc, .he bus - Fom 78. ues. of the coy aocording to the best of their or his judgment and , „, „,. uT.co .J regulations, general or special, a. the .l.r.oiors , 1 ,.,.. ov .nv fron. .in.o to time u.ako. and nhall for that purpcxso. huI.jo I 1 ^,^. ana a" have full control over the assets of the coy and t ho pouer ..; uso s al. and to make contracts of all kind, wi, nn ' - "".l<"-^-;;" Z L and frenorallv to exercise for ,he purposes afsd all .ho powe... amioii.". La discretion, of the directors under rho ar.« of asson of tlio cov capable of being delegated to managers. , Without prcj.ulice U. the gt-nerality of the foregoing provudon.. S,,»dal ,he .uanagor.s ov n.anager shall on behalf of the coy have power to ,a. Make and effect all such purchiises and sales of ppty and ,laim« a.s they or he may think proper. ,1,, Muke all .such loans and advance, as they or he may th.uk proper. , ,.., Tran-sact all general contango busine«.s for the boneh. ot the cov. „| , Invest n,onevs of the coy in stocks, fund.s,.shares, bond, dob..,,- ,„>es. . y o.- he consi.b..- expedient in the inloiest of the coy. ,i S,.bject as afsd the ...a.iagcrs o. ma..nger shall, wb.lst tb..y -r ^^i,;-^- • |„. hold oihce, procure the Jir.u of L- - & Vo. .is the .sau.e shall iron. ,.„.„ „ ,„.,. time .0 tin.e be constitut^^l to oiler fro... ti...o to ...ac t. the coin- pjiiiy a fHM - fime to t.ine o.! .i.ii.shiuk^^ .^ . ' il, iHirm'- !,1 „ ,. at least of such tirn.'s interest i.. all ..ew b.is.noss I. on tn.ie ,„ „ ,„,,. ,0 ,i,.,o u,..ler,ake„ or propo.sod to bo u.,e o.. o . n business i,. whi, h the .sov shall .lu M.g their or h.s term of otiice a Is. pay to the ma..agers or ...anager as i*gards each li..an,.ial year ot tb. .oy; (1, \ su.n o.p.al to one .p.a.ter of the p.olits of the coy ol such year after provision is ...ado t..e.eo..t i,a) for a.,y dopre- ;.ia.i<..., ^b) for reserve f.i.id or any addi.iu.i ibe.elo as may 1,0 .le.er.nine,l bv the .li-ectors, ^c) for the paymon. ol .livi.len.ls a« rued up to the cU.^e of such year on 8..y shares ranking in priority to the ordinary shares of the coy. an day of such vacating of office, and if it shall appear that the value of the coy's assets exceeds the amount of the coy's debts and liabilities including pd-up capital, then the managers or manager or their or his legal personal representatives shall be untitled to one quarter of the value of such excess. In making out such a balance- sheet assets sliall be taken at their market value, and all asseta not having a market value shall be taken at tlie fair value. All disputes with reference to the sd balance-sheet shall bo dotciminod by arbi- tration, und the Arbitration Act, 1889, shall apply. !t. In tlie event of the winding-up of the coy the managers or manager sliall bo pd their or his share of the value of the surplus to be ascertained as afsd pari passu with the other persons eutld to '•hare therein, and at the same time. But if the managers or manager shall vacate office for any of the above-mentd reasons before the winding-up of the coy they or he shall receive their or liis iiharo of the value of the surplus .so asceitained as afsd at the option of the coy either (a; by a cash payment for the whole amount due to them or him, or (b) by transfer to them or him of such aliquot jiart ot each kind of asset of the coy as shall together represent the f.mouut duo to them by him, except where any assets of the coy shall not consist of cash, stocks, funds, shares, bonds, debentures, or debenture stock, then the value of tlio aliquot part of such asseN shall be pd to them or him in cash. The coy shall within one month from the date of the balance-sheet referre'»• ««; Ro^Znn, Co., 25 C. Div. 103; f.mpre.. ^"^"'f'""/ .^"ofi ch 324 il'. Jirn«,ne V La Trinidad, 37 C. D. 1; Ex parte Beekwith, (1898) 1 Lh. «*."»- ZTnernat^na Cabl Co., 66 L. T. 254; Su,abey v. Port Daru,in OoldCo. m89) MegC. C. 385; and i..fra, p. 635. As to what is evidence of an IppTn'tlent of an officer by the company, see Bro.nin, x. «"^"t ^«"'";'' TLe Fire v. AVu- York Life, io. Co., 75 L. T. 528. C. A.); at the «me time words though positive in terms may in sabstanco be negative. C«U v. 7Wr4 Ch 654 But doubt has been expressed whether an injunction w.l be granted where there is only an implied negative. Vavi. v^ tore^man « W. il. 168. See, however, what was said in Wolverhampton, Je Ry. Co. v L. I, N. W. By. Co., 16 Eq. 433; followed in M. Cary Elwe,' Contract, (190<.) ' In'thTabsence of exp«-s P-Jion - employe-titled - ~ J--)- of dismissal or eompen«atmn. Green v. WrxgM, 1 v.. r. , He,.>paper Corporation. 16 T. L. B. 157; African A,«,»aUon ;/«-- tl9'»> 1 K B. 396. In the ease last mentioned power wa. reserved for the employer to Appointment of otti< PTt by artifleM ol atU!HM-iiitiun. An u^TO*'niei»t ^tbuuid be executed. ■i|>eririO ici-foriiiano*. litjiinotioTi Notice before (lismisrial. [•fpr HV AO- ..MEN'lH. [Chap. V. hiii ! JJ, Iii(oiii))atibli 'rniilH «l'«iue with raaMjnablo notiur. but he may be dimnUMeil without notice for wilful disobedience of an; lawful order of the employer. S/uiir v. Arnoll, 2 8Urk. 25tt; Calln ¥. Brnun- clrnr. 4 C. & P. 618; Amor v. Tfimn, 9 A. & K. 84N; TtirHor T. MatOH, 11 M. 4t W. 112. iMoral misconduct, whether in relation to money alfaira or otherwise, ia oiioufrh. Callo v. Broitnelrar, $iifirn; Jlrnwn v. Croft. 6 C. 4i P. 16; I'farce v. t'oner, 17 Q. B. U. ."iSe. So ia takini; a bribe. Am^om /'»«;» «»o fo. V. //!««<■//, 39 C. D. 339; «aWi> v. Kelt. 4 Bing. N. (5. 638. It ia Hufflcient, it was said in the former of the-«' onsea, if a valid rcaaon for dismissal existed at the time though the master was not aware of it. Uiscloaure of a, company's accounts to a person connected with another ooiu|>any will ju.stify dismis-wl. E/ot Anillnn Rail. ('". v. L^thfino. 2 1.. M. ft P. 221 ; .tf»r/ -, V. n'hnll (1845). 5 Q. U. 447. Ho will habitual neprllRcnoo or conduct ealcu latwl to prejudice the employer's business (Hokner v. Andemon, 3 Ksp. 23i; fiitlf/imi/ V. Iliniifrlnrf/ Mnrket Co.. 3 A. fc E. 171; Umith v. Tompton. ti ('. H. 44); or incompetence or permuncnt disability (Harmer v. Cornrliiu. h C. Jl. N. S. 236); or stock exchan(?c speculationa (Powern v. Fook>, 17 Q. It. I). .'537); or Kettinf; a list of customers for his private purposes from a receiver and mana;,'er who is carrying on the busiueds 0( the company {Mefuuret JlrotKem r.ld. V. .l/c-M"-v». (1910) 2 t"h. 248); even a single act of forget fulne« haviPK, nr calculated to have, serious results, may justify dismiisal without notice (llajclei- v. Loudun and CoiiiUi/ I'rintimj Works, (1899) 1 Q. B. 1)01). A fortiori where an employ^ nnderiakea aa one of the terms of his employment to use liis best endeavours to promote the interests of the company and commits a breath thereof the lompany may dismiss him. Ariiing v. tomax (1854), 24 I.. J. Kx. 80. As to absence tlirouKh illness, sci' Darii,, v. Khliw /"/<■ I rli,,,, Chhk U . 27 T. L. R. 543. If an employer makes out a iirinm facli^ case of misconduct, the onus is on the employer to prove the innocence of tho transaction. Federal Supply and CoM Storage v. Ani/rrreH. 103 L. T. 150. An oHicer who accepts an ineunipatilile office vacates priutd Inciu his original office. Eal,, V. Cmbi rlawl Lnvl Co., ti II. & X. 481; Iron .S'Ai> Co. v. l}!iiiil. I.. H. 3 (". r. »«4: Me/wood v. Thatch,;- (1892), 2 T. U. 81; ««'/• v. Tidii. 2 <}. B. 179. An employe or cx-eniploy4 may generally be restrained by injunction fniiu revealing trade secrets. .HenywaUher v. Moore, (1892) 2 Ch. 518; Robb v. Oreen, (1895) 2 Q. B. 1 ; affirmed on appeal, (1895) 2 Q. B. 315. See also l.oHiK V. Smellie, W. N. (1895) 115; Lamb v. Evan>. (1S93) 1 Ch. 218; llelmorr V. Nmilh (No. 2), 35 Ch. 0. 449; Summers v. Boycr. 23 T. L. R. 724. 1 It is very common expressly to tix by agreement the compensation to bo pay- able to the agent in case his agency shall be terminated by the company. Thus, in r,o;/nns oaae, 9 Ekj. 149, l>. was by the articles appointed managing director of a company, at 800/. per annum and a commission on profita. It was also (irovided that: " In the event of the said I., lieing at any time deprived of or removed from his office for any other cause than gross misconduct, the directors shall pay to him as compensation for loss of ofBoo a snm equal to three years' salary. . . ." The company was ordered to be wound up, and L. was held entitled to prove for three years' salary. See also Shirreff't cote, 14 Eq. 417. But where an order had been made to wind "p a company of which T. was an officer, one of the terms of his engagement being, that " S,000t. be paid to him if the company discontinue to employ him," it waa held by Lord Cairnt that " T. was not entitled to prove for the 5,O0W., aa there waa no roluntary, 4!:i VOVMH. ^.iv.. .od inU.Ui«..t di.o„U..u.u«e b, |he «»o.p.ny of th« ..payment o, T - > "•";„?rrhtTrJifoJtr lot::' if .0. ,,.>... ...nd.ujr-up. entitled ^ P^^f „ ^^ „, . voluutary wimlinK-wp. »"■« "» :r r::t^'ts^ ip^y >- . -^-^-^ t^s- ^- " ,-:;. .s...,-. ....... . T. -•«■-•;:<* -J7;t„ a....e.«a„c.e or . bu»ine« whether by winding-up. «lo or otherwiie, i. a »"«»«»<» » » UusineM wnei 7 oBTinent of remuneration out of pmflb.. fur employmont or for the paymem oi . j n n,.» H ahould l«- ,U,,,„y and «.!. their Kood, and not .. -«"»"};.;'»"'_'';'' '':Lld for the ,hUh would prevent him from -"f "«""\,'^^^ ,;;'::' '..'...IhI dire-t tron. uext four years distribute to .uch of '>;--- ""^^J^ ^"^ X„., ,„a „,.. the „..,.t in.,, voluntary '^'f* '^"^. "^-^^T/dL^^^^^^ trr;;r"v"^z-r^;^^; ^;;t\xr(i-) .v. c/ ^.. .... cc.. I,,:., ,„, wa, entitled to damage. ^''^7;^ J"^^""^" f;, ^.^'^pa,: >««•>* ,4 r. I. H. 480: and Jlirsch # Co. v. /(«,»., ."pr« wh.eh all . I» ate the d.a, ul tv of reading in implied restrictions ; and soo 2'«r».r v. Oald th Om) 1 ]• 544 and c".X<.rrf v. TH. Q»»n, L. U. 1 Q. U- 173 (comm.-s.on) \ .er a company has not «,ld iU bu,ine« and is not in U.,uid.t,on. .t » Uable .or damajrZpLpective commission if it repudiate,. Loek.U v. .«..»«. Sit.att Co., Times, 22 March, 1900. But an agreement to employ a -^^^ -\f J^ t ^^^rd^ .=!: Idm with work. Turner v. Hawdon # Co., (1901) 2 K. «■«!>■». .•„„«*.>. n,-.rr,e« B«n*.»j, Co. v. ^««>ooi|' I'tlliiHd't •"■■■ A>f BaT»vmeiit U4 AORKKMENTS. [Chap. V. Whaii A aompalaory windloc-ap ordar ii er|aiva]«nt to k diimiawl of ■ Mimpany'-* windiug-up ntntnti. Chapman't eaie (1866), 1 Rq. 346. Thii cam wm daeidf^ on tiii> a diamiaaal. yronBd that the winding-up order which i« advertiaod in the newiipapan ii notiof to all tha world of the winding p, and accordingly the applicant waa held entitled to prove for bis lalar; on the footing of having had notice of diichargo on tha day the order waa made. And thii deciiion hu never been overruled. I'er Chitty, J., MaeitowaWi eaie (1886), 32 C. D. 366, 368; and tee Rtid r. Explotivet Co. (1886), 19 Q. B. D. 264, in which it waa held that tno uppointment by the Court of a receiver and manager in a debenture holder'n action alao operatei as a diamiaaal of the company's aervanta. It waa alto held in tShirreff'$ cate, 14 Eq. 417, that the same rule applied in a voluntary winding- up. " I am of opinion," said Lord liumilly in that case (1872), " that thu recolution to wind up the company ipio facto put an end to Mr. ShirrelTs employment as manager, and waa equivalent to his dismissal." No doubt thiii also was decided on the ground that there would be notice of the passing of thr resolution advcrtiscl in the " Oaxetto " in accordance with sect. 132 of thi< Companies Act, 1862 (now sect. 183 of the 0>mpanie8 Act, 1908), and thr decision has ever since been acted on without question until the dtcision of Warrington, J., in Midland CounlK't Sitlriet Bank v. Attwood, (1905) 1 Ch. 3S7. In that case the question waa whether a former employ^ of the company could be restrained from committing a breach of the covenant that he would not within a year of the termination of agreement, whether by notic or under th>< terms of a special cKiuse, enter into the service of anothei' bank carrying on husincM within certain di^tricta. The company had passed a resolution to wind lip, and the defendant contended that as this was a wrongful dismissal he wn« not bound by the restrictive covenant. The learned judge hold that the resolu- tion for winding-up did not operate as a discharge of the servants, thus over- ruling Shirreff't catf, fupra. The ground of the decision was, that regard being had U) f t. 131 of the Act of 1862 (sect. 184 of the Companies Act, 1908), the coriio- 3 existence and corporate powers of the company subsisted, notwith- atanui.ig the winding-up, and that as the liquidator was appointed by and is an oificer of the company, there U no such change in the personality of the employer ns> to dismis-i the servants. On the other hand, the learned judge considered that I'n the I'osc of a compulsory winding-up there was a change of porsonality. seeing that the business, as from the date of the winding-up order, was cai ried on by the Court for the purpose of liquidation with the asaistnnoe of the official liquidator, an officer of the Ckiurt. It seems, however, doubtful whether this distinction can be maintained, aeeing that the corporate existence subsists in a compulsory winding-up as much as in a voluntary winding-up. Chapman'' cnne waa decided on the (ground of notice, not of change of personality, and there is notice given in the case of a voluntary winding-up. No doubt, in a sense, the liquidator in a compulsory winding-up is an officer of the Court; but, as pointed out by James, L. J., in Ex parte H'alkln, 1 C. U. 130, he is appointed by the Court to act for the company, and acts as agent for and on behalf of the company, subject to the control of the Court. In the case of service contracts, if a third party, without justification, induces either of the contracting parties to commit a breach of the contract and damage party procur- g^gugg^ ,„pi, third party is liable to an action for damages (Lumlej/ v. Oye, 2 IDK breaih of ^ ^ ^ ^^^ Bourn v. Hall, 6 Q. B. D. 339; Sntith IVnle^ Minera' f'ri,.r,ifkon V. Morgan Coal Co., (1905) A. C. 239); and, as the case last mentioned shows, the principle is n.-^t confined t« service contract-i. See also National Phonograph Co. V. Edison Bell, #e. Co., (1908) 1 Ch. 335. Very commonly, interference with service contracta arises by the action of trade unions, and it waa held in Taff Volt Sail. Co. v. Amalgamated Soeietp of Railwaf Strvantt, (1901) A. C Uain:iges against thint ing oontract «;»M^ KUKM«. m that . fKi.**!"! tr«l« union miKht b* ™cd In iU r.Ri.«T«l n^« in «-p«o» .i^rJ^Ze on iU b.h.lf. Uut thi. prinHpU wa« virtu.lly .broK«t«d b, ITX Z^Z Act 1906 (« Edw. 7. c. 47), b, which " No Court "J, now toVn^ t.ln .n, «tl«n . . . a^.ln.t . trad- union in r.,p^t of ..., tortiou, .ctriTto h«»e been commltti by or on behalf of tho r.d. umon^ Thefollowing .r. .ome of the l^adinR c«o. in relation l« bp.a..h of .ontr^t orlurrf b^tLc unio.,:-'AlUn v. Flood. (1898) A. C. 1. m wlu.h the SLfnt neither utte«Hl nor carri«i into effect .ny thre... but .mply «.rn^ «,^ V. Fri^l, So«et, of Operatn.S,o.e^a,on,(im)^ 'J" i «- V v. ,. A««.on«/ ^«a/j««««*o,.r,r. L mo,,, (1903) 2 K. U^ 6W) H« y . n«B81 1 Q U. 181; L*atham v. Craxj, 2 Ir. K. 867, .l/r«o »^ •rT« /l898) I Ch ■ 274. Bit by far tho mo,t import..nt i, the decLion of :' ouJ of'^ d? in"!-M Wall. M^n.r,' F.,Ur.ion v. ^"r^'-^-'J^^ bove r^hrrod to. In that cm. .11 tht previous cm.. ..re oon..dored. and the 'inciprw- clenrly laid down that procuring a broach of con rac^ .» ,.n X!b. wrong unl... there b. ju-tiflcation for interfer.ng w.th the e«« !ht There minor,. em,.loyod in .•.Uierie. without g.vn.« not.ce to t hmr e,^S oyer. ..d Tu breach of their contract-, ab.Uined from working on certa... Z und"r U.e direction or order of the 1-cderation of Miner* by the.r bxecut.vo rouncil t". federation and council acted honestly and without mal.ce or 11- wiU «ain t the employer.. Indeed, they considered what they were doing ildT for h. beneBt'of th, employer,, and their only object wa» to ko.,p «,. Te nrici of coal by which the wage- were regulated. Uut .t wa, held that an itio'n for d..mage/lay by th. employers again-t th. f«ler.t.on and .t, officer.. i,o jurtifioation for their action being shown. ♦4"» H •p MKMOKANDA OF ASSOCIATTON. OllAPTEU VI. INIROUUCTORY n«) •ir namcii to a mpmo- (ii) a \n, .even or m»n- |H-r«.nK (or, wS-re Uip «>my ■ prixat. company within the moaning ' h.s A.t, ai. ,.«c.u,cd ■• - any lawful purr- !°»i_ '"'"'S the r..,"irement, of .hi, randum ot ..so.iat.on and ,..l»rw.«c '^™P'y'"« *J' ^ ' ' ,ith or without Vet in r«pe.t of registration, f-rm «n incorporated company, w.tn liniitiHl liul.ility (that i» t.. say), cither- "• ^„:r: r :;,:;:,.".fS ::;;r:^} "».•■' - randl t« -u.h amount .« the member, may re.pect.vely .her 1, "dc take to contribute to the u,»..ts of the ^rnpany m the event of .,r "Ik wound up (in thin Act termed a c..mp,.ny hunted by (li, /Z;:!:;'m:huvin. an, limit on the liabi-ity »f it- m er, (in thi. Act termed an unlimite the memorandum of a company limited by (yuarantee, sect. 4 of uMocintioi- ^j ^j^^ ^^^ ^f jgog is as follows:— »■! cumpaiiv g^'!^tw. 4. In the case of a company limited by guarantee- (1) The memorandum must state - (i) The name of the company, with " Limited " as the last word in ita name; (ii) The part of the United Kingdom, whether Engl "d, Scotland, or Ireland, in which the registered office of the company in to be nituatc ; (iii) The objects of the company; (iv) That the liability of the members is limited; (v) That each member undertakes to contribute to the 8«cts of the company in the event of its being wound up while he is a member, or within one year afterwards, for the payment of the debts and liabilities of the company contracted before he ceases to \m a member, and of the costs, charges, and expenses of winding up, and for adjustment of the rights of the eontributories among themselves, such amount as may be required, not exceeding a specified amount. (2) If the company has a share capital (i> The memorandum must also state the amount of share capital with which the company proposes to be registered and the division thereof into shares of a fixed amount; (ii) No subscriber of the memorandum may take leas than one share; (iii) Each sub.scriber must write opposite to his name the number of shares he takes. i ^ I Menmrauduni i)f aMsociation of an un - limited company. As to the memorandum of an unlimited company, sect. 5 of the Act provides as follows: — 6. In the case of an unlimited company — (1) The memorandum must state — (i) The name of the company; (ii) The part of the United Ivingdom, whether England, Scotland, or Ireland, in which the registered office of the company is to b.' situate; (iii) The objeits of the company. (2) If the corajiany has a share capital — (i) No subscriber of the memorandum may take less than one share; (ii) Each subscriber must write opposite to his name the number of shares he takes. II 11 • te'«»» ' Hi For form of such a memorandum, sec infra, p. ."lO:?. As to tlic signatui-c and stamiiins,' of tlio momorandum of a com- pany limited or unlimited, sect. 6 runs thus: — g The memorandum must bear the same stamp as if it were a d.-cd, anil -iL'natut- ..f ..list be si^'ieil by each subscnlier in the iiresonco of at least one witness wlic niemiiraniUnii, ,|,,„t attc-t tlie signature, and that attestation shall be sulfii-ient in .Scotland at «ell as in Knttlund and 1 1 eland. INTRODUCTORY NOTES With lo.wd I.- tlio resist. alien ui the luonioi-an.lmu of lus-criation, i, i- ,„ovi.k'.l l.v KO.!. 1.-. -r tho Art of 1908 that: 16 Tl„. ,n..,n,.ra,.dun, a„.l tho ar.i.lo, (if any; .1 l-o doliv.ml In tl.- ...ri.uar ..f .■„n.pa„i,.s fnr that part of th- Initod Kini-dom n, wl,„l. tl... |„^,is,omi nfH,o of t -oinpuny i- -tat-.l l.y tl.- n.omora.uln,,, to 1„. ^.tuat.-, an.> he *hall retain ainl ro(.'ist seMM-al ,„atU.r. mentioned in Tal.l.. I!, in the Hrst sehednle to this Aet the several fees rrein speeilied. or snel, sn.aller fees as the Hoard of Trade n.ay from tane ,o "";:/AMl:.e. paid to the registrar in par-nam-e of ,hi. A,-, shall U- paid in,., llie exelieipier. Copie.s ol' Talilos i\. and ('. will ho f»mal hilni, w tlu- Avpoiulix. As to tiiv olhTt ,.r i(>oistiu!i(in. sod. Iti of this Act iiiovi(hw ihat : 16 (I) On the re^Mstration of the menn.rai m of a .oinpany the re/Htra, -l,all eertifv nnd.'r his hand that the eompany is ine,.rp..rated. and in .h .so ,,f a limited rompanv that the e<,m|iany is limited. .M Krom tho date of ineorporation mentioned in tl erfheate of ,ne.,rpora ,i„; ,|,e s„l.s..ril>ers of the inemorandnm to,...tl,er with sueh other persons a- „„v from time to time heeom.. members of tl,e eompany, shall h.. a hody ,.,„:,„„ate hv the nam, tained in the memorandnm. eapa Me tur,h« ,tl, o ..xeeiMHu' all the fnnetions of an ineorporated e,m,pany. and hav.n,' perpeta.l ...eee^sion and a ..ommon seal, w..h pow,.r to hold lands, l,nt with s„,.h l,al„l, y „„ ,he part -d- the members to .ontril.nt,. to the assets of the eompany m th,- ereiit of it- heind wound up as is mentioned in tins Aet. A.> 1., 111.' staiu)., si-^initmo. and ctVo.t of uiouMiaudiuii, -o.-l 1 I of the Act of l'.H»8 provides a> folhnvs: 14 -(1) Tho memorandum and articles shall. « hen registered, hind th.. ..HMu.any and the members th,.reof to the same cMent as if .'ey respe.,u..y 1,„| 1,,.,:,, siur„e,l and sealed by each member, and contained covenants on ih,. ,,art of each member, bis heir-, executors, and a.lministrators, „, oln..,vc all the prnvisions of the memorandum and ,u the article-, subject to the pr..ws,ons ot '"("•'i'vil monc.v pav.dde bv any member to t ..mip^ny ""dcr the m..mo- randum or artiHos "shall b,^ a debt due from him to the co,np..My. and o, i;.u;land and Ireland be of the nature of a specialty del,t. \V,lh ivouid to the .sovoial .iai.M.s coM<..i'a-d in tho nioiiioiandmo of a.s.sdciutioii: .t.s■^> the. SAME:— This ehuise is n'.|<'ii«'.l in ovovy nioinorai.iM' of niime. I'liiicii'Ii.' f"i' ititt-rventii'ii ,.f (V.iirt. I'riuiliiliiit lilt iitiiin or nut. 1 ■ .... ,1 i,v ii iiainr iili'iitii'al witli tliat l)v ,1... ,.our.o <.f l...in« di^«.lve,l and .i^-nih... its ...n.ont ... ,-..■ h m.inn reui-trar lo luirc-i. ,i„..,,.;

    --■- « ^^_ ,„ 1. aforesaid, rc.l.tc.c.l -y ^ ;:J-^' ^ '' :::;lil^ ^ ., to be ca,,...i d existence is previously '''''•""'^'"'.Zl"^^,^ .he sanction of the rc:ristr,.,-. to deceive, tl.c lirst-incitioneJ co.i.panv n.,i). «.in '•'T;rvn;';:::;:anv y, ..y speOa, .solutio,. and with .he approval of .,. Hoard of V.ade signified in v.ritinfr clian»:e ^^^^'"^ ^,,^„ ^...^^ „,„ „,.,, .::::r:^:;r;-."=-:^5r''-" ' and any le.-al pioucJ.n t. ^ ..„n,„ienced airainst .t hy .ts ,. w it hv its torn.cr nan.e .«a\ Ipo (oniinuni name. Soot 8 i~do>in<,tuId W L.\ ^ id .ee nc,,,L„ V. Aiaers, 10 R^ P- 0^12; Cn>^ v^ ^ • HO L. T. 211: .Ja„ne.^ v. Ja,„i.son U lop. Pa Cas- 19,, Vakntine McH SidiistoH, , (.1901) 1 i8'j'ji A. «". t; 2 (. h. dl;i; ^l«•a^*r»• /,v,/;.s/( i> .hidlv .horo, hut to «omo Mnall es,.-nt als.. n, .Man.hos.o. ,„ ,„a, voar ; ISUT . .ho hushu-. .T .l>o hut.r n.n.pany wa. M.ld , ,„„.„•, „1,„ Man.l a now conM-auy uau.ed -Tho ^oiah Lho-shn. and Manche-.o. lUvnory Cou.,any." The llouso oi I-.ds atluuun, ,1k. ( ..n.l oi .\piK-al, hold r.hai ihou-h it , in .!.<■ ono and h..st in th. o.hor, ,1808, I Ch. y.^'X S,. alM. Premier Cjele Co. v. Premier I nhe < o.. 12 1. !-. H- ,S! a.'d .l.,hn Brinsmead mid Sons v. T. E. tiri„.^n,e.,d ,n,d ^on.< limited 1807. 1 Th. 4-J, 4l:$. whor.- an injun.li,.n was -.an.o. ,.;.,„ nuin- .ho ns,. of tho uamo of Thomas Edward IJnn.smoad and SoM.s' l.i.nltod, or tho wor.l ' Brin.s.noad " by tho defendants ,n con- noHion with the ruanufaeture, .sale, or hire of pianos ^vl.hout adding .hereto an expn'ss stalen.ont that the oon.pany wa.s dist.net Iron,, an, ha,l no ,-onne.tiou with, tho ol.l firm ,.f dohu Hrin.sna.a,! .t Nms; an,l Sa..M,ner v. Apollinaris Co., .1807, 1 Ch. 803; t iUnet .iU,. V .M.iso, Louis Pin^t, Ltd.. .1898. 1 Ch. 170: a,.,l < hap. MX-, „,/„,; Arm,, and Sa^U Co-operative .Soei.'H, v. Arm,,, A-try «.owover, that tho dofon,lant.s luive not only adopted a nan,o .e.soniblinK that of tho plaiutitl, but have ^el up, or propose t,. .set up. hu«iues,s in the «ame stroot, or have issued .Icoptivo nrcnlars, ,nK'< far t,) show a fraudulent intention. «eo Lee v. IMe,,, ^> ( h. ICl; Merehant Banking Co. v. Mervhantx\ £c. Bank, »? -npra. The Court has trreat diffioulty in intxjrferin- whore ihe name Nam,- a, - The Court has trreat ailtioulty in inwrici .,.;.; ».— ••■- •-- 8„r,ptiv.ni a.lopted Is merely descriptive of the character of the deloudaul s bu«no«.. 452 In Bi Mere Mmilaritr of nHine. Whert- are dittercn Whei p Ui • danger of deception . MEMORANDA OF ASSOCIATION. [ChAP. \ I. ,,aM.u.>.. and a.vor.liuglv, in .-a.l. of ,l.o ,lueo followi..,. .a^os an Z 'r Lomlon ami Procincial JoinI Slor, Lii. A...ra,.ee(o 17 I Ch ;i:. Colonial l/>fe.Us,,rann-ro.s.llo,,u-a,,ri( oh, .al Lumncc Co.. LUL. M Bouv. .-.t«; Th,- London A.^snranr. . But .00 uou lirdda.ra,, .. fianl 189.;. A. C. i;.'..-. ami UriM, Vorua,n Vie,,,,.-'- Co. v, W Uu„a. rlean... rv,.. , I'.K.T. 2 Ch. .'U- l^MronM ^ . Hn U.h Llr,,,,. ,o,ilr ro.. 98 L. T 2.--H: ,.u,l Sorfh rMnn■and^.n,rh,.'n iLrcni n, V. M,u,rU.:U-r liren-rr, Co.. • 18W) A. • . 8... oft. uu.uo.a ....innou .o.,! fn.n. .ho Eu,li«U lau.ua,.-. whaU-vov .- ;,„,, ,, i, „..o so as .0 prove,., i.s ..so u. ,ho ..a-u ;- ..MM.ontlv iogis.o.e.l .■o..,i)nny. Analor., Lnn.lcl ^ ;"''•';•"-' o cl. .,... I„uv,?^ C,.„lon KsMr.. v. fn, rV,?o. nald.r l:laU.. l(i;! 1- T. 41(1. , . . Men. >i,uila.i.v of ..au.o is ..o, in i.solf enough .0 ^.^o a v„ ,0 a.> iui...u..io..: for tl.ce is uo vigl.- of^,ro,,er,y ... .ho .m ua . ,hi.s ,.u, uuv wo ,lo no. .coo-.uze .ho al.soh.to .■.gh. ol .. 1.0..0. ' ",,,.,,,.,;, ,,,„.,. ,, ,1,0 ox,onl of on,i.li..g' hun .0 provcM.. i. assuiapliou of .ho ..au.o hv a -..a.i-or />" »'""";/ • , ,{.,, 1.441. H,.u,o.if..oiMU.s,hns...o,a.-..vo.lm>. e>s.>,.> 1: ;;o.;;..ou,ors. u.alor .he ..au.o of Day au.l M..Uu. the .oll.k..ou„ Mackiu'- luakois could uot loslia.u .lio.u. Tho plaiutills ,uus, .0 fu.-.ho. a.Kl show ,l.a. .hoy h'-o .an .od - .OU.O .ado or Imsiuoss ....dor .he ,.ar..o..lar ..u.uo. aud ,ha. 1: ;^ 1. ...s- .ouduo, ...ay load .0 .ho.r so-uri.., by do,o,,.ou ,a ■ ho aiu.ills' busiuoss. If. .hou, .he dofo,.dau,s are oarry...g ... ' |;;oso ,0 carry ou. a di.foro... ki..d of bus.uo.s. t'.ere^c..M ■. • ;,,„Ur of deroptiou. au.l .horo.oro ..o legal ..,.,...>. ^ot Da;, Hroirnrhifl. H» < ■ l>iv. mil. There is for oxau.ph-. i.. h." ..o absolute ...ouopoly .u the ,.au>,. .,f :;wspapor. To i,.,..h. the proprie.ors of a -spa,..- .0 an ..■ junction o restrain the publi..ation of a..o.her "--^l-l"'' ' ;, iiu.ilar nana., thov uuM show ,ha, the us- o. .ha. ....0 . ^ ' ,0 load to the belief that tho dofe..*fv yorlli (livshircir- .,-«../...■'•"* ■-•- ,„,„,,,„, Ounub.s Co. V. /.ur/ . ( UKl • ' ^ ., , , ■ . im nrniuotors „uiv 1..- .OMmlno.l Inm, i.-isu<,.,i-.. ;::s,M:.^..-.■'.^7»7■-;^.■-:;::;;^,::,,, ,',;;:. ::;r,;;*,t::;r,:::r;:;:vu.i- - ■"■■ "" 1""'"""^^ ' . '. „„ „, i,.i„„ ,ii ,,.,1 ,....1 ..- .'■ "'»• ,„:uU-;;>:o-.-o --"-•''>7''';;;;;'r/;;ir;.i ' W.'; ' a ...upan pun-Uasos .ho .o,,,luiH .„■ a., c..,n. ... >^. I l„ ,1h. al,~omo ,.1 a.mH.m.M,l tu tlu> ronuaiv. a .L^l.t lu .au> . „,,„„„, IOC. 1). U.l; .....p. ..-0. ../.-'K an.l.lH a I ,':;: lu .... ...an.,. ,1.0 .ana. i> u.Ho.l w„l,_. o , onM^... ,1 V li.:;roul.;.ino.s.,Hi,o.,au.oora,.plvo.l, paav , o V f,„oi..>. .uHlo.' who has no E„frli>h aj.o>...v, hn. ,W.ose good. u. i„L .;p,o..av unpoHod .n.o En.U...a i. ;•«';;;; „,„Uc, .o o..ahlo hi... to ros,.a... p..a.y „l h.s nade ua .o i oUm^ ;r'.,,,,„,,,,S.:,,:M<...r..^^^fo.od:.aS..W^^^^ ,„ „„. la-, .an. Ka.«vll, .1.. hohl ,ha, who.o a ,.a..pan> ,. .o.n,.,l ,,„ _,u,lulen, purpose, .ho s.,.,.a,o.ies ,o ,h,. ,.,o...o...nd..... uo , , . ■ ..„»„..». I,. >t iiMiiiosc. l.ithatcaso ^.i.Uv o| a tiu.ldulo... the nien.oramlum, who were the ..„lv .lir,M tors an.l shan-hoMor,. uoro nwtraino.l from Ms.ng the nanio i"u ,o,uK..tion with tl.at husinc^,. and tho sijjnator... were further r.-lrain.-d Iron. alh)vvinun». anpoa.^....-.- of ril^ht to ..m> the ..an.e of X. and V.. a tirn. k..ow„ :.s „I.u.ufa.tu.ors of a,, a.ti, I... will not p.ote.t the purcha^-r In.n. ,n. i„j„„,,i„n. .1^.-/ Morr„ll, Ltd. v. T, //.«.,» .f To., It. U. I • ( ■ ...... K ,„av ho w.dl l.o.e to draw alfntion to a rul.- .nade son,,, v■ea.^s ■ „.o l,v iho lioa.d of Trade, viz.. that tho ,-o-isl.ar shall not regisl., anv nHMnon,..dun. of as.o.iation for the in.orpo.ation of a .o.npanv l,v"a ..an, ' which the wo,-d ' Royal' or • l.nporial tor.ns par,. nnle..^ Ihe.e he special .in un.sta.nes for .■ola.^..,ir ihe rule. e.,j.. whe,e the word Itoval" has U,en ..se.l in .o....e,tion w.th p.nperlv ,vhi.h the ,on.pa..y'is .o a.-.,ui.e. o.- whe..o per.u.ss.o,. t,, ..-.. the w...a has hoe., -.a.iled hv the Ho.nc Oth.o. /vhe.e .he royalty .oferre.l to is ,..it British, .he H..aid ol I .ade ,< not .so .nine tilious. . . . ■ i ,„ .,:„„. , a-.., it ...ay. i.. o.-.ier to avoid .lelay. he des.rablc. lo applv to the Ho.i.e Dlliee for liherly t.. use the w<.rd • Royal. X. ,„ the pe..alties for u..authori/od ..so of the Royal -Vr.us. o. o ..„v ■ devi.e e..dden.. or title " suggesting o...ployn.ent by tho Royal Fa.nilv. see se.l. (i8 of the T.a.lo Marks Act, VMh. lielo.e Ih.allv .settli...,' o,. a ..a..>e an.l gettin^r .lo,u..ieuts pr..,te.l. i, i. ..■e..erallv' ,ie-irable to as.ertai.. fro... the Re-istrar of .-oi.„ Stocirio.npanies that no obje.tion exists to tho proposed name. Is- to drniiK' of iminc. see Chap. X., infra ]U to onnlfnv, Ihr irord ■ limHcd:' [.. >o...e case, a oompa..> ,„av by li.-.M..-.- of the Board of Trade he ro-i.stcree hifra. p. 4'J8. ,o -i- . .• 1, has bee.. l.eM (F. Stu,:,/ c(- Co. v. WalV^ < I'JIU'. 28 1 . h. h^ ;.(.<♦) thai the ahb.evialion 'Ltd." .nay in the cas.- ol " ''''1 '^ ox.l.an..e be ..se.l. B..t the Le-islat...e has pe.'sis.ently ena.ted that ,1„. w.,nl -lin.iled- shall be u.sed, a..,l it is not easy to jusl.ly he de.isio... seei..- that the ena.tment is tor the benefit ol tho pnbU.. See .seet.s. (j.t. G" of th.' A... U to the reqixterrd otVirc of the cumiHUUj :- (•hu..so •> of overv ...e.,..)randu..i must state i.. which part ol tl,.' Ui..L'.lo..i the rogistcreil ..ffice is propo-ed l- bo situate^ This det^r- n,i,ro.s where tho .■o...pa..v is to he registered, and also the junsd.ct.oa to which it will iH. s..bje.t. See sect.. 15 a.id XM oi the Companion IhMk INTKOUUCTOKY NOTES. ^:,r, i ^M 1U.2). '. Ami th.< .^omiuifiy muHt. under •" '"" ""'"f ':, oe, tin U. Lvo an ad.hoss a. which tlu, . on-pany ;:;J;;.v:;i.nam..oni..-lamli,.d,.,.unK.n.....M. .1. tc, the nhjrrh of the company:- i. In Hir nh ^'l't■^< 01 me cumiK^n-j ■ (il,i„ . ,!,.,.„: »"' i-- "■'■*»■'-' ' '-th. it;* o|iinitit'n. 1 • * ; nnt -1 unuv IV. onl of wluit is lOU- .,.:i:,:;"iri"i:i::::i;;:-: ^i: : ...... ^«"-- " - '"'■■" '-jr:;::;:: :"".'''' •-" •» :::,;',;;:;•; •.,.;;,.,t.».i .•..>■..■..."-. '-' -• thus conlorml. >ii\o i^o lai .i> 1 ■.I .1,,, ^.ilxciibovs to .lo.'hiio Uip objLHts. It „,, ,„,„>,, ,0 bvin. into cx..l.n.o a "-'^^ ," ^ „.„,. ,. their .„.,„. that body .,,h .uj P- ;.^'2' s-;;.!..,.. .i,ht, and i.« „„pmtiiua- .•an.i.-t be oxa.-vralo■-"'"-■ ■»' >■">■ ;■;'; ,''„u °...nl- 1« i»™»- """■ : "''i.:';;r£:f^ ■■ . .v';;;..i!i"..i.i .« .„:. o„,.... 1.. oninlovi'S, toi tlio.^c imn^^ , ," , • „.i ■■ Sm.hao«n.pany.nayal..oiu> al .M.0 .^^_^^^^ ^^^^^ ^^ luul rcnNlor no- tho lompany, and it iua\ \uiy :,,,„,.,wt ii," an.l nu; p.ovKle fnr payment, oven out ot cap.ta o nt.u ,„ ,,,,;„, ,„id I.p in advance of call., for clauses .' I - " T blcA Jubs.itutcl for clause. 55 and 7 of the 0">r...al T Mc .V, t.at «uch ont.oin.s and expenses as pro,.r y ^^ ^ ^ articles, and what Table A. autlion/.e» iS fires. Lock V. QvccnMand Mortqage Co. ISyti) A. C. 101. AW MKMOKANUA OF ASSOCIATION. r('HAI>. VI. ■tn m Neccf-itv of Hiiiplifying objects \Vi(K iif till- I iUmI till', t'.\ poll llU- ■'llDWIl ill. II ihcv iin' mil wu arc found ikhimmiiv or cdiivo lt> eiioui'li to t'ovfi- nmiiy "I iIk' Uiiii»iiitioiiN wliii li l)iisiiK>w, iiTt"4|H'itivu I iiiiciw hliitt'iiioiit III' iihjei L'lil ill lliv foiiiif i>l' a ioiiii)uii\ ^ it lln! fact ulreaJv allu(lt'c I'^l loi inonlv found in nicmorandi jf a.s.sDciution: — I. lillisc autliiiri/iiifi ilic cmnpany to carry the particiil.n business which it is tlll'l' bll-ll|C>so> Willi III ill cnnjiinclion .. , o-cd to carry on, and also to curry on vurm I'll it may iirobaldy or jiossibly be desirable llierewith or in lie lieu thereof. The object of this is to avoid the necessity for n iiitr to the ('unit ndor .-cct. 9 of the .Vet of 1(108 to <-xlend the objects, ami aho m give the cnmpanv full free.lom for developiiii: its business. 2 A claii.se emi.oweriufr the company i.. acc|uire any oilier busiiic" Miuilur to its ,j„n. for it is extremely .litHcult to imply sii.h a power from the inemorandiim. /•>/«■■•*/ v. .Mrlnilh. li H. L. C tol. ;i. .\ clau.se .•mpowerin- the .ompany to enter iulo any a-reeiiiei,l for .sharintr pr-lils. ioiiH adventure, reciprocal concession, or oilier arraicemeul of a like nature with other persons or compamcs carrvi"i- on any -in'ilar buMue>.>; for very clear powers are necessary to justih such tK.n~action>. /:.• inirlr Ihllish Salioil. ii,i < <>.. :i ( h. lo.. Lands Mhiimeitl ( u., i,l«'.'t , 1 '-h. ti.io. .•>. A clan.se empowerin- the company to promote miier companies for aav purpose calculalcl to benelit tlie .(iniiKUiy, This power. thoujili often i-eipiired, cannot lie implied. .Iu},il SU,rk DisroiutI 'u. V. ISiuini. 8 r.ii. .SSI. ti A power -eiierallv t.J a.M)uire |.inperly and ri-liUs which the companv may think necessary or couveuienl for the purpose of it.s busiiie.ss. In dealin- with outsider-, it is loiiml useful lo have uu exprnss power like this, and so preclude any .luest ion of caiiacity . 7 A power to leud monev and ^?uaruutee the perforiuauce ol tomract.s bv c ustomers and others. Tiie-e loan and -uaiautcc trau.- actioiLs are' constantly called for in bu.sines-, and yet the powerisoiie not easily implied. INTRODUCTORY NOTEH. ,. ,., l,orro« or ruiM. n.on.y l-y the insuo ol dolMM.tun^. ,,„l„„„„r,. Hl.Hk or othenM . . ">•. »; ,^, ^^ „.^soimM.> ' '• •;, '^ .;;;::i::i:r o ^L!t. t... cxi.. .w,hor .w. - „.i,son uou-s bills ot ^^""'»»^ • .,,,i,a,.l... ..a-, alli.ous.1. a ti-adin- compunv ha- m.l.U .1 1> '^ l,„-in.-s (mm. h> /<• "' ;;'"; •■',»";"i' ':;','.'■;;;:;':;;':. , ™- -i-'- ,•,,,„•,„» /,«.'. 'Y I- . - ■ „ , .,,,1, i,„|.li,,l |.....-v ;:L;:rri;.:;:-" '-'■''■"--"■ ■« -""- "'■ '", ' '"'T H r o!.nriuo,of any othc .,>any l.av.n. '^ ..V.uve. S,.o ro,jo« V. /...n.^, ^ - ; ^^^ ^,^^ ,^,,,^,,,.^ „, '':;,r:'; r.r:^:^ t S it - aiMin..t.v .... Y '•''-••••'•^^ ,1H;Ui 1 (.) 15 "". , „„>„„„,ui,lun. was val..l. A,,,,..„l .Im. a saU- un-le. th ,,o u. n ^^_^^^ ^.. .^^^ ^^ ^,^ S„ t,M, in l-osl,-r V. /Jonrr ' o.. » U >l) » n. ,,„,n, •' Cii tW^. i.in.l...v on Compani.-*. Ml. 0.1.. -..•-. ,11111(11 . V n. "-T .onnianv caiinol soil or ,,,.„„.. of a., oxpro-s powor .kc ... ^. '" ^ ■ , ^,„,^„„. ,/„„,, :^>"r H ." . :1 a c.o...in...lov...-, ,o /i^,oo,^ . . //.../...o. . "•""-, , ; , ,„rt, , (1, 7..1. Ila> powor .o sol. lo.- s.,a,t.s „ „t-:^,::;i:'- .- -r,:rrr:; :;:■,™;;;:;^:tL;^:rl■^;=::'p:: ;,;«.£ ,;, i.„,v. 1; .s;./r')» V. /V»»;.so». K. Ilavo. -l , \,u,., iMmua..a,o, .U-ve.op, ex.- .u..o. a. I- f i,,v,i to vmninl. or ot ifrwiso des.ra.do .. ..a., express and Jxplidt poweis on .uel. .na..ers. a..d so preei.-de all .p—u uud doubt. SiM^ Khvj^bur,, (olUeyie.^, O'J"",' ^ ^ ''• -•'•'• 467 i I. 4.W MKMOKANUA OF A8MK,'IATION. [ClIAI'. \ 1. H The BubBcrilitTN* diacretioQ. Ah reKU"'" loKi'li'.V. the follHwiiij,' lulc^ arc upiiliiniblo:- (n) Tht! olijortw niiiHt mit iiicludo uiiyiliintf i" contiuvfiiiioii <,( tho Act. For oxumpl"-, u liiuilfd ooiiip.my ninnot loj; illy Ihhuc sharCH at a diKcoiiiii, iind accnrdiiij^ly, to make tlic iwnuiiijf of its shurt'. at a dixoiint oiio of tho obji'i ts ,,i «u( h u (oiiipaiiy is not all<.wald<> ()ori') Tlio ol>j(v l.s Slated luusl not imlmlc anything in i ontravcii- lion of the gonorul law. For o.sainpio, it i.'* not a la«tid objt'i't "to keep a ganiblinf,' Iioilso in tho United King- dom," or 'to uKlahlish and work lotirrios in England, " or "to work and develop iiivonlion.^ fnr inipoiling toKa"'. iuto ' I'nited Kingdnni free of dii'>." or to work a hdieniw for delia.sing the coinage,' or to facilitate tho (•oinnu*xi(in of lairglaries for all thcKe objects ore < - trary to the general law. (o; The objoct.s ninsl n..! include an,\ uliicli «ould render the conipuny a trade union, f complete freedom to frame tho objects ;..- they diouso. It i> for them to say whether the objoct.s shall bo wide or narrow, cautious <,v speiulative. wi-^e or ridiculous. rcaMinable "V unreasonable, congruous or iucougruous. ditfnse and rambling, «i concise and delinile, whether they shall be concurrent., or indepen- dent, or substilutiniial, or contingent, or in the alternative * 1 « ii •No doubt some pcisoiiH Imvc arirucci that wliat the l.cffislaturc ri'ttUy in- tended was that the principal ol>jeits sliould 1)0 speiiticl-not the power-* l.v which those objects are proposed to be attained -and pnxecdini,' from this premiss maintain that once a main or primary "object" is specitied it is improper to .set out in the memorandinn further objects wliicli merely I'Oiil'r " powers." Hut there is iiothiii}; in the Act t« (,'ive colour to tliis coiitenti-n. or to show an intention to discriminate between main objects and objects men ly conferring powers. Kvery object stated, whether main or auxiliary, in elYcct endows tho company with a power or powers. To exclude objects eonferrinu: powers is to nullify the Act. Besides these critics there is another class who complain of wliat may h,' called the multifariousness of tlie contents of a memorandum of association. The objects clause, according to their view, ought to specify the leading objects, he thpy one or manv : and thnt is eninigh ! To go on and sjKK'ify as an object any- thing which is implied or may possibly bM"'«';'" n a I ii:iiii> K'li-lii «lii liii li ili-- l.iiiiit'*'""' ,( I..W. 1" .hot uU M:ilut.>r\ ...114HI iiiHiiiio^ iii'oriioiiil.' ,1 for HiMj.itiixl |nir- ';„„„„.„ ok lor Hill I tiii'l in Act iir llif f.MHirioi 11 u> ,,|iiuli"ii " ,1 the (Oiiiiuni) ii'ij' ,,!> ,,rc.liil.iiin;; lln' <•"»» ijtanv liuiu nail ilio .Hit'ssiiig il" "1 cilii'i I oUjiot'*. Ii>r it i^ \v M of opiiuoii :< «>\i>l»* I in iheroiiMitii'ioii «> I till' CKlllliallN Thuri' to wllcHu 1 1 r this liiiiilulioii 1)1 till' powiir- -«• lIlCN lire 111 ln> 11 thin l.l.'mrit I ■■ .„,,l„„t ..( ,,| ,,„.|, , omiKlllK'- '•^""'- ■ , „,,:,,,.,, ,„. (2l Ill'lMIl^'' .IK'U i..g ""> J"'»«"""" "' ' ' / ; i-n's Ai. oi l'a.li.-""-" „,. ,, ,,arti,iilur pur,.o>.-, .- ,,,,,..1 in tluii Aw. The proMoni Ai-t of lHi;2 ipiu'.i'- «' "" '" ,,,.,,i.„i;,„ ... uu.Um- 111.' A.i, th.'ii- 'uuJaua.u.al and l,ex.v,i- .11 .--"''"^ ^ ' ,,,^, ,1 „,. ,,„,.,,. a,nl u.ial'.oiable law: ami //.'7/ "-' ."."'^ '"' •' ^ j, ^,„.„., ^o u.- ,; In iliii iiioiuiiiaiKliiiii »'"' ""'■'""'"■•'■'"■ u. V thai tlu> iuahil.tv of -..h .mupain^s .0 „„ko Muh lOUtiaiH u..' . ^':^^ ""'';" , ^^^„,. I,, ,1,0 Unv ami for ,,... .,,„... of thoir "i-l-'il..." Ihan ut 1 . ^_ ^^^,^^^_ .„,„;,.. o, „..l.lica pmhiliilion, niakii.t: a.i^ u ulauli. ,vi . Ihov wouhl l.aNO Ua.l a lopal ,a,.ai,tv .0 > " i_„,.j ,,,,„,.._ t.. Thi- ;.'.■ i< in a ih «Uh ...' ;n.--- ;M- ^^ ^ •^,„, „. uW,.eH,... i.auirilal.' M H • i" '"'■""" ^ '• ' '' " ._ ■ •. • mitter for tin- -abs,:ril.pr»' discretion. If tl.ey ;„,ain the miswiT i. tl.at it is u m.utu for ^^^^^^ ^^^^^^ , ^.^l,„^„ ,„,,„, it .loMraMi. ... .et out ""■."'•J"; ., ^ ;";;,'.,,» to pn-vint t.iim, and «.„uia considiT nc..e,«ry. tl.ore is ""• '« ^-^Z' ,, „^ „f J„ in favour of tl.e „.er. i^ much to l,e .aid from tlu- " "l"'"""^;^:, ^„" „ ,„n.,„„v, Tt i, unni-o.- ,arv, any irit.,' n^'l.t say. to m. Indi decisions, in.,.l.e'l . and nadin, ..oinpany. for »«..h a powo - ^.^•^^^^,,^,.,, „„t tl.e po . to .„ it is to til. traim'd lawyer familiar *'" ;„ ,h, „,,i„ „„■■. of „.hon. a niomorandum « V^" tl I' i i «P-li-t that the powers of tti* business, not lawyers, and for thoHc it . P ^^^ ^j^^^^,,, „^j ,,.. ...nipany should be made ...amfest by »^;'^^^ ;; \, , p,i„eiple has l«en ,.„ as far as possible to -'^"".^ rdurin"t>- last thirty years, and has ,.xtensive!v and almost universally aeted on rturin? _^^ ^ ^ _^__^ ,i,h referenee to a , ompany's objeets have hei n al.iiosx ltd MKM< )HANl»A OV ASSOCIATION. [ClIAP. VI. I '■fc: ♦.'(intiarv oi>iiii •«". Sti't. 7 ' Act. riiwtr'. Salomons v. /."""/■ '-' H<"'»^ •'•>■'• ■""' "'''' *'"' '"" '"'"' 'l"«»_"' a;'(iii < n. V. /■;,•>.^v■<* < om«//V* /f-n/ r,»., u c ii ttv jl I, .) c. IV ;>.(. wlicic .Ifivi-". r. .1.. ^iiiil: It it clo.ii' lliiit tin .lfl<>iim\>'< iiiaUinu ^linl iKaiiilaihiiiK tin r.iilHav «aii. - ticMMl l.\ 111.' A.I. an.l llial lii'-ir iHii.l- '■ '"ilv l.i' a;)|.lii'.l In: III.' |)m|...-<-s ,lii..,u>,l aii.l |.r.i\i.l.'il l.v lluit MaiiiK'" a ,..«<• to «lil' 1. l.,.r,| S'll...r>n' r.'l't'ir.'.l ;f mm aiilliDiilv in .\- \. Ilirh, ill>l .<»/-/■«( S... al-... uIh'I. /(,//.-»<•.« Uiiilurk \ Ihr liirri !>,■<• iii 111 ( Div ti7». \\a' 1.1'lovi' llif r.mil ..I .\|iimmI, llio Cmil il I IMi.'i. M » . aii.l ( Dliim ami n.i".'ii. I. •Ill "fw n" '••' "|>iiii"ii ilial. ill llif 'MH' .pl' a -.lalut.irv .Dr|Miiali.)ii. il i-* u.il iif.i«ssarv I- ^■«'k lui a in..liiliiti..ii. r.'i- ->»li 'I ...ip.'ralioii ..iil.v liii>* -u.li |m>«.'i> as aio ciiitViri'il .m il t'\l>r<'"lv lalillui .,.i|)..rati..ii- arc I.. I>t' n'u:ar"i; |M'r l,..i.l CianwDrili. .>.7(/<'"-.W>'.<,'/ It^iii. r.. N .V II lt,i,r to. f. II. I., r ii-t; an.l i»m Loi.i Hla.kl.nin. in Ml -Crii v (;. A.' /.'.(// '" • •"> Al-p. (as. tTo In 111.' last laM' lii> l,.H.Is|iii>. iclVii in;;- I.. A^lihiuii v liiilic. iil.i ^iil'iii sai.l Thai .a-.' a|ii"'ais I., i.i.' I.. .Icci.l.'. al all .'vciil-. llii-. lli.n when llii'ii' is an A.t .>!' I'arliaint'iil .i-aiiufi- a . .iiiK.iali..ii l'..i- .: parlhiilav i.nri....M.. an.l -iviiiL; il |...«('r- t'..r ihal jiaili.nlai |im|io.r whal il il.'cs 11.. I i'\|.n'-s|y or iiii|ili('.li.v aiilh.>ri/<> is iin.liil.ilfil. In llio .a-i'. Ii..ui'\<'r. iii ii(iii|iaiii.- -iilijct I.. lli<" • '.iiis..liilali..n A.I. I'.i0«. K'lila. iiiy s(..l. \> iif till' A.I .jl IHill'. il is II. >l iic.fNsaiA I.I lOM.n U) oilhfi' "< iIk' ah.iM' n'a-..iis-. |.,i, a> uc have seen, sect 7 of lliL' .Vil .'\i>i.'"K i.i.ivi.lcs that, -a\<' a- tlioiviii iiK'iili.iii.'.l. A .■<..lii|iaii\ may ,-../ .ill.'i ill'' ...iLlil i..n- .•..ii'ain.'.l in ils in.'in.,i,iii.liii.i .'Mci.t in llu' .as..> an.l in tilt" moil.' an.l to llic I'Xti'iil lor "lihl. ,.x|u-,'s.. l.r.,visi,,n i> mail.' in this A-l ••. ami it is w.'ll solll-l tlia tlii'M' u.n.ls. ;,W.r '(/'■/(. i.r.-hil.il ill.' . ..m|.aii.v Inaii .l.iiiiLi aiivlhinti' oi loutravunlioii ol lli«' . ..nilili.nis iiu«i«'..l. A-I'l'iiin v. lilrlw. 7 II. 1. O.-.o; 7V.T..C V Whitiioilh. V2 \\>\>. t'as. H)",i. .V .■..mpauy iiii.U'i lli.' A.I lia- the follow iii^' p.-wcrs: t 1 I l'..\M'r I.I .1.1 whalovcr il is iict'-sarv tu 8l sMtcl in n- iiicm.iian.liim. ami also uhatovov may fairly he ic-arJcl a- iii.i.l.'iilal loaml (■..us4...|i!i'n'ial .ni ihc staled oh. .-- (-2) Power lo ilo w lialevcr eNo is aiitli..iiz»'.l hy llip other elaiise- of ils jnemuiaiKlnm. (■,i) Power to do such oilier lliiiiy- as it is allowed t., ,lo hy tlio A.t of 1!H)H or bv aiiv other statiile. INTKOlUt lt»KY NOTK>. Oil ■llllll ill*' IM'Wl'l' .1 ,\ n>ni--l««niil riilii('iHi> "' I'll' ili'|ii'ii(lriil I II u |,v il'< Miilf'l ol.jw t^ rf(iH{iii/i''l III nil ''iiil> ••I" lid ili'i iilt'd llllll iumI Iiv il'< >i«Ii''> ""J"" • ' - . 1- : , . .,„.i;, s u i .m.,.,.uio. A, .. IS...... .ho i i"'-; ' •:'"-""■ "' 1,1 i.iiiiiiiiioii llllll""'' I'" I'll' '" "'' ' ; I .. , ,S.:.. Ill, UM1....II..A,. i.'.,uii.'I.U. I.I..I....I.....I.. 1„.1,1 Mau- .111' ..l.|.-«^ ." "'" l""l"-'' "•'"'"'"^ ' " '"■""'"'" ;i.o.an,„..ir. l.H .uiu,..liiin..'..i..|i...ia.....iii.. ,L.,,,U,iM 1, «a. ill ..•tH.i..l. ..iMl-i.vK.i lu...K.i_ll.pA.. ;,,,, s,„„„„» ^ u. ■>/<»;.>/..■ /•.'.'."< ""'•'■ >* " '■ V ,"- 7' ,;...«.... In .11.1 — -I- -""' - '"'■;' ""; , ,. ,„|. ivlnil. 1 ^ .>.'M,..iMiol...vil..'im..li-'.l J„|„i|,lh.n,M...l..Tin,..W..M,ui..M..r.tI ••• •"'''-''"'^ U..|,„„. „l .„ 1. 1 ami lav.'n. llu'i.-i". an.l ili" 'i"ii'^: ' '■ -" '' "^^ : . in....U'ii.al ,..■ wi-,.,: i- -,. 1 , 1... an.u: .,,... - , ,„ Tl... .li..-....>. ^^lMl>' '!"• '""'"' -'- """"•- "":, ,„. ,, „p....,l ,0 U.| ..IV i"i a s,i,,uia,...l ,.m-....l a h-w v.ar^ a lai „ ,,.. iiuMiu .■ ii- otii"-. "-"' "vi''-'- ^\- "-"" "'^';, ^'"■'' ;' • in. „a>.al,ulau..l... I-: l-iv ^^'^'^';^^^: '"'';' '^ /„,.a.,.i,i.'ii.i.aMi-.'i-.ii. ---•'''/'■' 7- '•'>;''',:' ,. 111.,.'.. M- !..■ UI...1.- i.oi.i..' '1—.-' "• ""■ i-i-M""!"-: ■■' ,!' Th.ru...l.oraj..i...M.„.U..„.i., v..s,al.l.... V,.. .|i.i.'|- ;,,, ,„, i.s ult,;, r/n.v, au.l al.h...... .an,n..uo.l l.> al .1. „„, |,v a la.-,. .na.,,.n.v ..f -lu' sha.vl...M...s. a,. M.i.U- ^'- '' ' ;:; ,;„,:; „M.in..io.i. A.a.lwav......,.a.iy.:.ni.-^.....^- y-^- uliidi til.' .•..nii.aiiN \\a.4 ( .msliliitcil. ■^. ...mi.'". \ luMipanv ....tal.li-ho.l ... mako a r,..lwav an.l .-x.-n im- tl.o traUt , , , ,,J ,r,Klo ..I- a s,..aiM-,,a,.k... l.ai.v; au.l u,. .•..mpanv .an 1 I i.ruM. thai till' .a-se .U'l.oiuls u i.m .In' 'an ;:,;:: ;::,n-..'\...l.i: J .>ni..'M. ..i,.."rAs....ia„..i. ., :i.,,HH|,.ul,via.avin..haUh.'lo..in.of...lar,..a,,,,.....u^^ ,.,„i,„.. „!• „„ hn.ol or tavi-rn th...ri.r, l.ut I . our.'.v.' that it 1.. ... I>t «.,nls.r .ho thinl ilau>o. M.,!..^ a ,hi..;r ...hi---' -;'"'""";;;,;;:; ^,„,i,„„,,„ „,. „a' .l.-.^.v.l..'.l ..l.joets ..f the .....h'.-.ak.... A.. luM ,0 1... -.0.1 a. such ,s,ill rcaai..- ia .ho ha...ls .1, .ho co,..,.a.o . This -t- 4ti-' MKMOKANIJA OF ASSOCIATION. Chai'. VI. :1 AubbHry \. Kirh: i^;,■ House of Lords' dtfiNioii, lioK'l i.s luiiror iliiin aiiv dthor lioicl in Kiij^hiiid, anil in tliin poilion oi iIm' liniliiino llic ii>nal Im^incs-i (,[ an lu'ld ami lavorn is lo ho (anii'd '>n 1 K'lv nun h iijiun 'lie (Oii.'^iilcialion tiiai till' atranootnent is tciiiiiuraiv ami jiu'liniinai \ . am! i-i'ndut iv*' to llic uliiniato objoctof tlic wliolc l>iiilini'-:-i nf (lie iiutcl." and lli(> oilier loainod lurds comunod. Alior llie Acl of 1802 faiiii' into (i|ioialion lhi> deri-icni ua- IiimiimI as ,i|ii)liialilo (o cniniianies r("_'i~i(Mcd under thai Ait, and as iiiniwi- iiiLT that a eoni|iaiiy so refjisterej was, as ri'u:aids its powers, siih- slaiiliallv in the same position as a raihvav. water, ij;as or otiiei roni|iany iminpoiaiod for .specilied piiipuses m nhjoct.s, and wa> not endowed with the o^ueral powers of a comiiion law corporation ixiiiira, ]). .">()), Whctiiei- (his was ihe Inii' ](osiii.in of sinh a loiii- panv was not, however, linallv settled until 187.'). when (he lelebrated ease of Ashhurij Unilwiin ('(inidiic and Irmi Co. v. I{iiii,\ L. H 7 H. L. (i);t, was deiided by the House of Lords. In that rase the obi<'r(s of the company were "to make and sell, or lend on hire, railway carriages and wagi;ons and ali kimN of raihvay plant, ami to lany nn the business of mechanical (MiLfiueers and i;eneral con- Iractois; lo puriliaso. lease, woil; and sell niiiie^. ininerals, land- and building:-; to purchase and sell, as merchants, limber, coul. nie;als and other matorials; to buy and sell any such materials on commi.ssion or as ac;eiil.s: lo aciiuire. j)utcliase, hire, construct ov I'lcc! works or building-' for ihe ]uirpo^es of the company: and to do all Mcli other thinijrs as are iiecess;ii'y. cnnlini;ent. ini idi'nlal or loiidiii i\(' til all or any of sicli olijei-is.'' The loiiipany with this meinnraiidum delininj^ its objects had entered into a contract with the plainlilf in relation to llio con- striictiiMi of a railway in Bel;;ium, ami the ipiestion r.ii~ed in the action w.is. wlielli(>r that contract was valid. Tlie lAiliei|ner ('hiirulicr. aflirmiiiL:- the derision of ihe Coiitt of K\ilicipicr, held thai ihe contract was nltra virea. but in (ho Kxchecpier Chamber, L. 1? !• K\. 2t!t, Ihe judges were e\eiily divided in opinion. Klackburii. .)., in his judiriiient, in which lirott and drove, ^^ . al.-o ci.ncurioil. was of opinion that the company, beiiif^ incorporated, was like a chartered or comeioii law corporalion endowed with full powers, dial, althou^'h the Act mitrlit have o.\press|y or impliodiv cut down these powers it had not in fad done so. ami (hat in (hecir- cumstunces (he contract was unly iilint virex the direilors, not uUni riri'x the coin|)any. and capable, thcrid'ore. of beinj; ralilied bv (lie shareholders. On appeal, the House of Lords held that the contiact was iiUnt rirr^- the coni|)any and therefore altooelher void, and that (ho views put forward by Blackburn, J., and tho.so who concurred with him, wore erroneous. The view of (heir Lordships was that a company uiidei- the Act of lHii'2 wiis not to bfl regarded as a common law eor| laiion endowed IMKOUUCrOKY NOTKS. tt;:{ wiUi lull |Hjuors. 1ml a.s :i .sluuilorv ( oi|POiaii'iii ciidowcd willi liiiiit'il iM.wns oiih . l.iinl Cliainolior (\iinis. iilln- |))('iiii-iii(; • p. tilil)) lliii iIh' .siiliMiiliPis 'aro lo sUilo the (ibjoit.^ lor wliidi tiio [iioposoil ,,,iii|iaii\ i> lo bo uslablisluHl. anil thai llii' u\i.--lcii'0, llic iniiiiiif: into ( xisli'iiK' ol liic ciimpanv, i.-* t4j bo an cxisicn'c and U> bo a coniinij: iiiio o\i-H'M'<' lor Iho-ie objoits. and for llioso ubjocl.s only," and iilior iclrniiijr to lliu word.-i at the end of srct. lU. to tin' olVcil that tio alloialidii shall be made by any comipany in tin' condiliniiN >on- liiiiuMl in il.s nicnioiMndnin of association.'' pinici'ded :i> I'dllnws: Now. iiiv l.Mids. if that is so— if that is the toiidiiion upon whith GiuumUfor flic loipoialion is ostiildishcd -if that is the purpo-e for whiih the , nriinriMoM is ostabli-^licd i( i^ a mode of in'orpinal ion which con- i.iiii- ill il both lliat whi. h is atliriualive and that uhidi i- neiralive. Il .■.late- allirinalively ihe aiiiliit and extent of viialily and jiower «lii(b b\ law .ire o'i\en lo the ciirponilion. and it slates, if it i-; iic.e>saiT '^o to slalt'. in'^'alixely tliat nothiie.i- shall be done bryund iluii niiibil. and thai no atliMiipt shall be made !■> ii-e ihe corporate liic icir aiiv oiher purpose than that which is >o spccilind. A slaliitury ii.ipnraiioii,' said l.oid .'^clborne in the same case. created by Act of Parliament for a particular iiurjiose, is limited as to all its ]iu^vers by the pur|ioses of its incorporation, as deliiied in ihal .\ct. The pii'senl and all oilier i paiii<>s, incorpoiated by \iiliic of the ('ompanics Act. lSi;:2. ai.jiear to me lo be ^talut^jry . uporalions v\ithin this principle, i'lie nieiiioiaiidiim id' a-socintion i-. under the Act. their tiindaiiienlal and, excejit in eerlain spccilied oiirliciilais, their nnaltciabic law; and they are incorpor.ited only for ilic objccls ,111(1 |Miiposos e\prcsM'd in that meiuoranduiu. ... I ^iiii unable lo .see any distinction for this purpose between stalntm-y coiporalions under the Railway .\cis ^uid sl.itnlory i orpoiations under the Companies Acl, ISdll. ... 1 think llial contracts for clijeiis and purjioses fmcio-n lo, or inconsistent with, the meiuoiaii- .liiiii of .issoiiation are iilhii r/Vr'.s' of the corpoialion itself. And it scciiis to lue far more accurate to say that the in.ibilily of such eom- |i,uiies tt) make such contiacts rests on an orioinal limitation and cir- ciiiHsciiptidii of their pow<>rs by the law and for the purposes id' their' ill. orpoiation, than that it depends upon .some e.vpress or im])lied piohibition makine- nets unlawful which otherwise' they would have liad a le;:al ca)iacity to do." -Vnd all the li'arneil I. nils were of o|jiiiioii that, if it were necessary to lind words of |)ioliibition. (he uoids at (he eonclusiiin of sect. 12, to the ellect that. ' .-ave as aloresaid, no alteration sliall bo made in (ho conditions iiuitained in llie memorandnin of a.ssoi iation," were sulUc ieiit, and that in thus pioliibitinii- aiiv alteration id' the cnnditions in ihe meuiorandum tiio \'{. in ellect. juohibjted the doine- of aiivlhiny: beycuid tlu? objects exint'.ssed. Thov further hold, us a cmoUary from the above, that the contract, boiiie- ultra rircx, and therefore void in it.s incci)tion, was VJM m p m- ^m m i Am MKMOKANDA OF ASSOCIATION. [ChAH. VI. .! i ill iiioapaWo »( ratiKcuiiim <'v .slmroliold*"' oil l)v the luianiuiouM (X)ii»ont of all tin Alt. -a, II. \. '-. E. Rail, r, II n a stil)s('ini('iit ca-M' ( Att.-(i V. fircal Eastrru Ihiil. C A|))). ("iis. J7.'{i, the |)riii(i|il«' laid down in Axhlmni v ///'■/(( ayaiii iccof.'nized in tlio lloiisi- nf Lords, l)iit it was piven a frrcalcr (■lasticilv liy the nilo laid down by Lmd Splliniiio. L. (' . and \\\v odicr Law l-ords, to (lie ollocl lliul the luinciplo was one to In- ii'ii.s(.nald\, and ncil mircasoiiablv. undoistood and api)lio ultra vire.i the cniiipany, restraiiiel, and it make-* no ditierenco that ili- f-harehoider has hiniself been a party to similar iiltni rirea acts in the past, as. tor instance, an idliii rirff i-^iie nf shares. Mosrlr;/ \ Kolhiioiiteiii. /.^/.. (I'.ni . 1 Cb. ::!; i I'.Ul i AC Ki!». riret. Il.I.l sniXTIONS Ol I'llKA ViKI's Tk\NSA(TIONs.* Where tin' pro.^pcrity of a milway riiiii|iaiiy ilcpcniU'd iiiatcrially on tlic niu jatioii of a river lieiiii; iniprovi'il. aud a-i-ordinirly lln'y proponed to I'urliiiiinn • -'An iilli-d rirm contract or IraiKactioii is not ille;,'al in the sense tint no ri(,'lit of action can arise in conneition tlierewitli. It ix not, merely be. ,ui rwiuisitc powprn. Hold, tlmt ;iii appli.-utuin ..f flic liimis of tlir ("ii.i.iiny l.nv.rd^ the promoti..!. of tl.<- Hill was nhr.i ,„,■-. M»„- i . shrr...!,,,,,, fr... ll! |'i,..v. 1: «mt so.- AV,W .ln,ilia„ ll.n/. Cn. V. A'. C. /^'-V. r.,.. 11 ('. ». 77.V S,f furthor, (»/'<», I'liap. XXI II., niul I''«rni 116. Whero a railway compaiiy pniposcil to »(Huro tlio lapital, ami puarantoo tlio profit- "t aiiotlior "oompany ahout to run stoamlH.ats in .onniitiori witli ll>" Im"'- i;,l„i,. \. A. ('■ it""- <'''•■■ '" '*•'»>■• I- '" •'"'* '■""' '•'"''' '-»"»''"''•' -^'- "■• -aiil; ■■ It lias l>oon very proporly ailmittod that railway coiiipaiiios lia\o no ii.r|ii to outer into now trados or liusinos.^os not piiintod out liy th.' Aot; lint it l,a, Ihcm contondod th.t flioy havo a ri^'lit to pLMtro. without limit, tho fniids ,,f ,1 (iiiipany in tho onoonraironiont of "tlior tran-actioiis. howovor \arioii» :„i,| ,NtiMi-ivr. |)rovidod tho ohjo.t of that liahility i-< to in.Toaso tho traltio upon il„. railway, and thori liy to inoroaso tho protit-f of tho shari'holdors. TIht.' i-. liHWovir. no authority for anythiu); of the kind." Wlioro a railway oompany proposed to suhscrilio to tho Iniporial In-tiluto. r.,„it,„s,„. V. .V. /;. J/: 5(1 L. T. S13. W horo a railway company was workiiij: coal mines and dcalini; in coal for pr.ifit. .IH.-'.-ri,.'\. (.'■ \.'ll>'il. (•«.. 1 Dr. ,V Sin. 2n;!. r.iiiiity eouncil runnintr oninihusos in connection with t-aniways, lawfully w.rkcd hy tlio c.nincil, liiit without any stitutory aiitlioi.t, he council licin- iMily a statutory corporation. /..,W..„ r„«„/y C„„„.J \. .til. -(:..,.. (HlirJ. \ (■ Ilia. Local authority usiu).' land, ucipiiri'd for a scwa;»e farm, as a l„-|.ital >itc. .Ml. -■(!.„. V. 'll.'uir.tl r. II. '■.. (I'.md- -1 fh. :i77. W ii.re the capit;il of a company was alioiit to he applied, or had I n applied. t,, tlie payment of dividends, l/iii.hirny v. /,.///./ Ci.i/i'n-.ilno, «l /irl, ■■.■/. 22 ( . Div. 342: l-lilrrofl'« fn'i; 21 (', IJiv. .i33. Where the capital of a company has lioon appliinl to tho iiurehasc of its own flijre-. or a contract has lioon irado .-o to do: /..oc/ CrnlH Co. v. /."/'/ I'rnimif. ,-1 (ll. 7i;3; r,-en.'r v. Il/iilirnrt/,. 12 .\pp. Cits. Wit; oven thcuiffh oxproMsly aiilliorizcd by its momoraiiduni. Kniiir'n vmr. t T. I.. U. 303: Miryiin ii.nl .(,/,.,,.' V,,.. 5 T. r,. U. (i8(l: (li'iirnil /•/■"/"'(■'.'/ ('i>. V. .l/"'/.c.v.,„\ •/■, /<../,'.-.v. 111 C. of S. (a-. 2S2 (Sc): /,V«7iVi. S/r. Co. v. r,,,,,,,;. (I8>H) .\. C 33<». Provision that dismissed employe shall surrender his shares. IV,iU:;). nl L. T. 7(i3. W liere a railway compiiny sniiscrihos to the lui|porial Institute. T,„ji/:i,i'ii„ \ ,^. /.. Il'i;/. Co.. 3.5 C'h. It. 675. W l.ci-e the comjiaiiy had issued shares at a discount: .lliimihi out/ Tirilo Co.. US C. Div. 415; A'ai/inni Timr Tnlilr^ Co.. 42 ('. Div. 98; Oon-iniii. .('■. Co. v. ;,'./",, (1HH2) A. V. 125; even thon)fh expressly authorized hy its meiuoranduiii i,r articles. IVeltuH v. !iolfi-n,i, (1H»7) A. C. 2!i-i Where a company issued bonus shares pursuant to a filed aurceniont. I it without cimsidoration. E'lilii^toiif. >(c. Co.. (1893) 3 Cli. !•- W licre a company offers di'bentures at a disciciiit with an option, at oiiee e\.Tii-eahle. to oxehanco them for shares, fully paid, oipial in nominal value tM tlie fa.'c value of the dohcutnros. Mos,h-,i \. h'otfii/oolnu .V.,/. v, (llllili 2 (ll, ins. W iicre an arrangement for partnership or amal(.'amathin had been made iV /yoilc Jlriliah .Sutiuii Life Association, 8 (.'. Div. 679, 704. ex|.eiiiled in rolation to that cintra't as constituliri,' a misapplication of the coiiipaiiy's funds. (1. E. /{nil. Co. v. 7'ir,/;c,-, H Cli . Mil; Colhnoo v. Co!l„:o.,. l:i i'. il,v. 04. T .,» V. .//-, T.:.:i r.:.. ilnOI; l Ch. ::-. A:-:l l!r- dinitors and other parties iinplieatwl in the transaction mny ho sued in re! ition tliciclo. and may have rii.'hls of contribution iiilt'i- .■■<•. 4i» n v. n II 4GG MEMOKANDA OF ASSOCIATION. "Chap. VI. El B Where flic Xic/H.l/n, 6 11. L. C. 401. Wlioro the i"m|iaiiy w:is iindprtakinif of another company was taken over. Krneit ?. f(irnu'il tu larry on tliu business of a bill bnikor ami scrivener, the nialiiri(,' adviui. c-i and proeurinn loans, and invcstinf? in seiuriti,., and other specified objects, it was held that the aubscril>in(f for shares ' a new comj.any i" order to assist in tloatinu' it was not a hour, fi,U- invcstiu - ■, ami was theretore uUr't ilrr^. ■I"i>il ^V'-A- Disminif ('". v. /Irowii, 8 Eq. ;i8I. Whore the company was formed to make and sell railway carriaRi's and wagsons, and railway plant, and to carry on the business of mechani.al enirinccrs and .i.iurn'l n.ntrurtoro, and to purchase mines and lands, and tn buy and sell timlier and coals, and other specified objects. Held, that the «or,l* •'g^eneral contr.ictors " must be read as rcferrin? to such contracts, and to su li contracts only, as were incidental to the business of a mechanical cn,;inoer .Ulihiim <••>. v. H,rl„: \.. R. 7 11. 1- t>«5. Where the funds of the company had been applied in paying the costs of ;, ,.' -c.ution a-ain-t a pcrM)ii who had libelled the company's directors, the lib,! 1, oplvint; to the company it-elf. StuihlrrI v. (!r„Hi;;wr. 33 C. 1). 528. ,\ here commission luul been paid for placin;; shares. Fnurr KUrlrir A,;„m„. lator Co.. 40 C. »iv. 141. liut sec Mrlm,mlit,n,, ,^r. .hmr. v. Srrim;,r„,n. (18W) 2 (J. i!. (101; and sect. SO of the .\ct of lilO.S, .u,,,r,i, p. 27!», Where directors were issuinfr new shares without the sanction of a resolution of tin company in t'eneral mcetini;, .l/r.«c/e;/ v. Koffuiontein Min>s, f.l.i.. (IHIl; .\. ('. 409. For action nirainat tramway for nmnufa.■tarin^' rollinij sto;k, sue .Hl.-f;,„. v. .\'«illi Mrlraii. Tniiii. C"., (1S<»2,1 3Ch. TO. Ap]ilyin{f the company's net i>rofits in buyinj? ott opposition to a parlia- mentary bill, or ^'ettinir a public body to exercise powers in its favour wliicli T.erc for the public benefit. Grrriivir/, Pier Co. v. Tlinmrs C„ux'-n;if-r., 21 T. r.. H. «6il. Where a c(,rporation acts as carriers in relation to tramways. .!■ ■.-(;,■>!. v. .V,n,r/„sf,'r Cu-rnrnf,,,,,, (1906) 1 fh. (143: and see .tH.-G,;,. v. Sorlh J-mi,;,, ]la,l. Co.. (190fi) 2 Ch. (175. The jurisdiition of the .\ttorncy-Gcncral to decide in what cases it is prnpcr for hiin to sue on behalf of relators is absolute. r.n,„!o,i CvoiKj Coiiw,! v. .itl.-Cpi,.. (1902) .\. ('. KlJ. Where, in the windinij-up of a company, a re-iulution was passed for llio distribution of a lari;e sum amonjj its officers. Slrnud v. Ito,ril .Iqwirinm, 19 1". r,. 1!. (i.)». Where a companv issues debentures with bonus certificates for payment of an additional sum ."mt of profits, it cannot afterwards, by arraniicmcnt, is-iio fullv paid shares in sati^artion of the certificates. Bury v. l-amalhm Jh'vcl,,,- meiit Co.. a»09) I Ch. 7.11; HoUwa; Tim,' Tabhs. 68 L. T. 649; Mo-^dey v. Koffi/fviitrii, Miiuf. f.l'l.. (1904) 2 Ch. 108. li.i.isiHvnoNs OF Intr\ ViitKs Transactions. Cases of I-.*™ Oil tlio ollior liami, tlio follo\vin<,' aro c;i.ses in ivliich i raiisactioii.s *"'"■ huvo ln'<.a lu'M within tlio po\vor.< of u tcimpaiiy:- Wherc an insurance company bad paid losses not strictly covered by it. p.,ii<;e<. Tur::rr,: ^. /^.y.•' /.,-<.^:;.-<- r„., 2 11. A: M. 13-i. Where a companv had given to its employes a bonus beyond their wa-ci. /l,„ni,soi, V. I'rirr's l'„l.'.,t C,u„lh- Co., 45 I.. >I. Ch. 437-. 21 W. K. wl- But see Jlullou v. We,t Cork Sail. Co., 23 C. D. 654. Compare Utroud v. , coiniiany »;rantivi a piii^imi to the wiilnw of an i-x-.ini.ir „! tlip //,„•/./■."■" V. Iliiiik iif .tHKlr.ilosh. -lOCIi. 1). 170. 1 a hniir! fill- iit(>. Ililh V. r' .«,-. H Ch. Hov'l hi'"'"""'- '" dire, ii.rs and other oHircrx. W lirr. \y|„.r.. ;i I ipariy (oinproniUc D. ^■>■ Winn oftiM-. Wncr «.<■. I I^M When INTKOnrtTORY NOTKS. I". I,, li. fiSfi; \V. N. fliiil3i Kfi. a-- t« ^.'ratiiilics to 487 srrvaiit •(I a Ic-isi', n n.nipany. with wiili^ |ii>with nf li'iidinir. I''iit inuiify I i| .my. i;''tlli V. ./n»ir« A'r.V/., ( 11IU.">^ 'J Cli. 1 17. I .•,.]]i|.aiiy loriiicd to wofk a patent purclia-^cs tlic |ia(i'Mi. .ll; and a.^e lln'jlnn IloU <'"-, •> ('!■. SSH. ompany was fornicil to work m>m<. and havin:- aKiuinvl it arirnvard- iM.iiK'lit til.' ficchoM. incliidinjr tlio siirfarp. .Ini,,:. v. r,;ll.,„r. i 'C. I.. 1!. ;!*. \\|„rc a Im.U'1 company, not re piirinj,' tiic wliolp of its prei.iiso-, lot part off, >'i"/""" *'• >l'fslminK/,'r I'nlare llntrl Co., S 11. 1... t'. 712. \\l,,r.' a lolliory ompany sold land from time to timr wliiri lli.' sal.- wn< roa^unahly ni,ps>ary. i;i„>j^h„nj Vollwn.-s, (liM)7) 2 fli. 2.V,I. WliiT,' a railway eiimpany contraited to supply rollinir stock to another ecnn- pany in ^pcc■ial , i'reunistan.es. .HI .-'>) 1 'i- "• "": '"' " '■'"''* "f "'•'>■ "''" '*■' """• ^""*'J '■ i/,„,,./,.-/ ,' ,w. It,nl. C;.. (1898) 2 Q. B. 439. WhiT ^111 uiiliiniled eoni|iaiiv. pnrMianI to provisions in its reLfulations, |)aid out «iU,drawiliL' meniher.. I.nn.n;/, <;.,mn.Tci,:t . ,\V. S,.r.. (1S<»3) 2 Cli. 212. Will re a Iradin'j eomjiany created a morl','ai.-e to seenre a debt dni^ to its bankers. /'«,',»/ l-:l,' Co., V\\. H3; diiii-r,:/ .hirllmi C. 3C'h- l-iii; sei' further, inlm. y. 472. A eianpany iniurrini; dehts for tlie purpose of il< liu-^ines: Anijliiii: H'l'il- ''".. 3 -M. .V: li. 12.). Willi,- -I'veral eoinpanies li.ninf,' power to borrow money on delieniures. priMte.l jninl debenture- ehar^'ioL' all tlieir properties, the ehariro was ln'ld flood on ilie Miiarate property of eueh company to the extent of the nu)ney aetually revive! by that company, .h.huxfn,, l-\„r„iu I'^'IrHls C<,.. (1901) 2 Ch. 231. U Inre a ((Hupany was fo. nied to create a societe anonynie in IVru. and to trail l\r the assets to that company when formed, and the memoranduni also frevided that " in order to the attainment of the main object of the company. nay do, either in the United Kingdom or I'eru, or elsewhere, whatsoever ly from time to time think incidci 'al or I'onduc ive thereto." Held, tliat iipany could vnl' "ly accept bills of cxchan.;e. Hut for the words in .ed connnas it wa .isidered that there would have been no such power. Pivi,'-:,,,, /,'./,,. Co., 2 Ch. 023. Wlier one company took shares in another. I!»,i,:'/'s ll'mhiiuf r..., /:.>■ /-»»/c C<.>.i.„,-i C,,riu,rtii:ui,, 3 Ch. 10.'). In that ea^e the objects included power " to pun iac or accept shares in any foreifin or Kn^lish company." Sec. aUo. h'inniiiifil Cniii>,riilinii . (iooilxim'.i cloini. 28 W. U. 7(10, Tlicre the obje;t- of the company included " the undertaking', assistinir, and iiartiei|ialin;,' in linaiii ial, icimmenial, and industrial operations ami nnclcrlakin^'s, botli in Kiiirlaiid and abroiid, and 1 cith sin?;ly and in eonne /tiou with other persons, lirms, winiiiaiiles. and corporations." Held, that the takin',' of shares in another cMim- pany was iiilru vires. Jcssel, il. U., there saicl : " Ueadini; this memorandum in li.u ;arj;c-i ,.-o,e, a» I tiii^.i. it ou-ht to be and w a- i.i!-.:!-.! »•> be rend, it s,-.m» to me that these words are meant to iinlude almost everytliin(,' in the way of financial operations. The words are | as above]. Now, I can iniau'ine no wider terms than these; it appears to me that the Iftst words I read aru unite wide II II 2 S„nl/,. (1H91) /;,ns,ll v. Ka^i hs- W" 46i< MEMORANDA OF ASSOCIATION. [Chap, VI. enough to ciimpriso the hiiyiiij; and rwlliiiif nf nhurc!*. and the Hucoppdin!; wordi cinly add '.:> the pxtt'nt of thpir iipplication." See, alw). Inffrii'iliiinnl I'milrinf f'n.'n /■««<■, 17 \V. H. 454. wherp a hniikiiiL' pompany holding sonic de'.)pnturp< liy way . 317. Ihlil valid. Where u (nnipuny haviu(f power to enter into any arran^fement for :iiii:iIi.m- mation with re(pc;t to the union of interests on anialjianiation, either in wjn.li- or in part, with any other rompaiiies or persons eiirryintf on any trade or hii-i- ness of a siniihir nature to that of the eompany. entered into an ai;reenic>nt to acquire, in consideration of paid-up shares, tlie undertaking of a soany contracted not to carry on th" specified business otherwise tliiin in conjuncfiiin with and for the benefit anil on behalf of the !»■»• com|Kuiy. II,,, .'J- Cn.. 1-,1.^/ir V. Il,irn.r I'li., (19011 1 Ch. 32«. And see Chap. Wll C.\mul),'amation). Where a conip:iiiy which was bound to supjily Imk.vs for a ferry cinploycil lli. boats. \»heii not wanted for the ferry, in excursions. r,ii;i,il v ,)/«/./.-' It'll'. ('".. 3(1 Iteav. 40. Where a railway ccunpany, liaviii}; prmidcd a vveicrhinp machine for th. purpose of its business, let the public have the use and made charires for tli- use. r. & S. II'. Hall. Cn. v. /'/or, 11 (J. I!. 0. 48.5. Where an in>uianec company, havinj; power to j^ive and take pidicies by way of guarantee, entered into an ajrrecniciit with other offices for joint liibllily .\,ir,ri'-li K'/iiltiih/i: ,57 L. T. 241. Where a company was enipoweri'd to insure ai^ainst sickness, ill-health, ain) other specified eontin;,'eneies, and life insurance, and to grant aiuiuities, and " trenerally to make insurances against all and every kind of risk, special or general, whii-li may be ell'ected acconling to law," Held, that there was jiowir to carrv d the doctrine of nnmitui- n kh'-Hm, when you cannot suggest a single instance of a risk having any connection with life assiiraiai which is not included in the expresM t<'rms of the prior part of the clause.' .\nd see I'lm nix Itenximir (',)., 44 1... .1. Ch. (>83. Where the eompany was formed for carrying on the business of discounter-, lenders of and deah rs in money, .ind a number of other specified objc't-, and " the entering into and carrying on any monetary and financial arraiigi- ments or ope- tinns, and the doing of all matters and things wbi' h may appc;,i- to the company to be incident or conducive to the obje t< aforesaid, or any of theui." Held, that a purchase by the company, jointly with other partii's, of an escate on whicdi oiu! of such other parties undertook to finish tlie .\lcxandr a Palace for 200,(100/., the company undertaking to float another company to acquire the premises, was not ultra vires, /.om/nii Fin"nriiil .liimri,itiini v, Arlk. 26 C. Div. 107. In that ease it was argued, inter alia, that the general words INTROniTfTORY NOTW. 4«9 „ ,he con.I..»lon of the objerta clause ouRht to bo tr.ate.1 a, merely ano.Uarj to " , |,a.in,«se. menti»no,l at the Pomraen,.,.n>.-.,t of th. objootn; but Iln.on, \.-C ' li„,a to a.lo,.t that arRument, sayinp. " It h -nouffh to Kay .n an,wor to ,t 1 it it «ero to prevail all the »u,-vcMng word-, would be H«el<..». \ am .,.. at I .„v fo «nv that thn parties to th., .■ontra.t in.ant nothin;? by the wor.N they live "thought fit to employ for .leHnins au.l reitulatl..^ the eondu.t of .h-.r li«rnl business." , . . Uh.r- a .-.mipany was forn.ed to wquire and work an iron-or.> mine, it «as ,„„.i.lcr«l that the ...mpany n.itfht properly pay f.rs for a report ,,« .ts nnue. and f.es to soli.'itors, brokers, and for advertisements, printing, .V:,h,r, ,n„l II .-„ ' ' "• V /;;/■(/ 33 C. Div. 85. Whore a eon.pany is seeond mortwco it may be entitled, if called on. K. pay „ll ,l,e first morttfaKe, and where it is mortRa-ee of leaseholds it may be en- tithd to pay rent and otherwise prevent forfeiture. NA^^ffW,/. ,yr. Son, I,, v. i,l,,rno,l. U f. 1>. •H2- ' Where the funds of the company were applied in paying the .osts of pro,eeu- fi„„ ■, person who had libelled the company and its directors. SVW-/.;/ v. ,!':,;!„„•. 33 r. DIv. .52«; «.-„, v. Rnu.> IMM .V».«V ./««.. (1H07) 2 Ch. "'wiicv ■. reasonable commissioii or brokeraije is paid to brokers for phiciiuf ,|.,n-. .\lrO-o,,olilm, Cat <'o>,.u,„e,-.- .(«». v. Sryn,.f,r,>„r. (I«!).5) i IJ. »■ liOt; and so.' I'ompaniis .\ct, I'JOS. sect. Kit. .v«,,<", p. 27it. Whcic a cnipanv. with a view to advcrtisinR its patent lii.Hli.ii,,.. offered a pri/c 1.. be shot for at Wimbledon. l.nH- v. rio,, Ihiirr^ fo.. 3 T. I-. I!. I, {,HS. I'.uf qiinif as to this. \\1„,-, n company in.urreul se.Kliii!; out nrr.xv pupers and circulars to secuie the defeat of a resolution which the dim'l..r- lonsidcred adverse fo the company's interests. l'.-rt v. L. .f .V. U . It,,.! r,... 0(107) 1 t'h. S, overruling Sludihul v. f/intrriwr, 33 ('. D. rt2H, i.n this point. W lu'ilioi any jiivfu liaiisaLlion i.> i>v is not witliiii the jiowei^ of u c.nst ruction (oiniia.iy i« a .luestiun of law .lopeiidii.- on the coustriictio.i to W [[^^^^^ (ilaro.! on its momoramluin ol' as^oiialion: aii.l that [ onstnirtioiij ,„ii.-! 1.0 [ron.sirued] in arcordauoo witli tlio rules goiiorally applic- ul.ii' !o iho con-slructiou of wiilt«n dotmiiCMil.s. Heiico, tlio whole duruiiifiit iiiu-sl ho road. thoy pi-odiuo aii imoii.siMciioy. in- ail iib.suidity 01' iiioonvenioiice snUiiionf to show tha^ the iutoulioii could not have heon to u.so them in their ordinary Kii?nilif4itioii ; to> .Uaiu ob- it l.eliove> ihe draftsman to bear in luind a novel rule of eonstruclion J^'* ™1* Ui.si .Mi-yesied in Haven Gold Mlnin,] Co., 20 C. D. 151, and in •Siv further as to the interpretation of the memorandum, in/i". Chap. \ If. p. i>91 ft »eq. t i f !| -i. * i .» , •r 11 ti 1; i i\ Si? 470 MKMOUANUA OK ASStKJIATION. [('HAl'. VI. German Unle Co., :2il V. 1) Ititf, iiinl siilw c^iul)- li-sliod. it is, of course, to be boruu in mind that like every oilier rule of construction it may bo excluded or nioditiod by the contents of the docuinouts to be construed, for every rule of construction contain.s by iuipliiation the sa\ing; clau-o " unless a contrary intention appear by tlio dwumont. "* ArcoriliuHly iho rule must be applied with ( uii'ioii; it has only a prima furk' application, and it nui-t bo seen :hat there is no'hinu in llio document to exclude or modify it. For cases in •nhiol) the rule was held In.ipplifablo soo Pcdhir v. Tfoad Block Co.. ( 19i).Vl L' Ch. 427; and nntlt-r v. Sorlhfni Territories Mines of AuxIkiUji. 9(! L. T. 41. Sometimes the memorandum declares the iulenlicii lo bo that the objects speciiiel in each paragraph of the clause, or in each of three or four speciliod paragraphs, whall, except where o'horwi.so expressed in such paragraph, bo in no wise limited or resiricled by reference to or infoi('nce from tlie terms of any other paragrai)li or the name of th<' comp:niy Thc.^c words are obviously intended to e.vdude or modify the rule, and the Court is bound to give ellect to the intention thus indicated. f There are other mode.^ occasi(Mially adoi)led of excluding the artilicial rule in tpiestiou. For e.\ami)k«, .several of the leading objects are sometimes made to commein c with the words " a^ an inde- pendent object." In other ca:ie.-, the first few paragraphs are exprnssed in very wide general lornis, and any .-pecial object is made subordinate thereto, and is sometimes expre^^ed to be " witiiout pre- judice to the generality of the preceding olijecf.s." Sec further, as to interpretation, Chaii. VII., infra, p. 391 el .srq. ■ I •Hoc pel- Buweii, I.. .)., ill I^ki/ vf Ji-rsc;/ v. (.iwrdiinis of I'ltor <>' S'-nth, 22 Q. B. D. 548. tVtt, stninirc to say, in SU/iheits v. .Mysore Jlcr/s Kiimjiuitij Mi„i,-:i Co., ru/Jiir, ii loariK'il judiju disrcjiardi'd ti.o preseni'e of t.u> Ii wuois mt lli.> g.ouiia that ina-miicli as wlicn applied to one particular pirajfi-apli tlicy would be non»cnsi-, thoy could not he hold to apply to tlie other twcnty-thioo para- graphs. Suih a doctrine is at varianci- with the sottlcd principlni of construc- tion, and cannot, it is uppruhtnded, be maintained. INTBODUCTOKY NOTES. 471 TKo objects clau.o i,^n>,nMy closes witli tl>c following «ord«: j;^ff;;:^;/„.„^, .\ 1 lu .lo all smh other tilings as uro incidental or comlu.^ive to j,, „,,j„,„ ,,:c".'n a"..>ont of the above objects, or any of them.- It ...1-1.1 Lave clau*-. le,.,', Mippo-cd thai these VNurds wore i.npliod-for Qmindo aUnmd ',uui,l,ilnr, imudatur et omne per quod penrciilur ,ul (//«./ -and „ero u.eordin-lv superlluou.s; .nince Expressio corum qua: hide „.anl nihil ofcralur. The Court has however, on ^ovo.al ..cca- ; n lioiiod -uoh words as material. Banhm Hall Co., 5 Ch. a-.G; s'»,).m;« V. \V,'.st,nia.sUr Palurr Co.. H H 1- C. 712: Tanulou v. R,„l.il him-aiirc Co., 2 II. & M. Uir> ,-..,„ ^„n.t-tii..os the words "as the co...i.au> ...uv IIumJ.- condunvo aie ai.Miu.iod for the words " as aw- .:ondu( ivc." These were the words ,„ea i.. rcruv!o wide that they iiocos^arily include a pjwor of that kiiKl. This i^ a i>o\ver which, of course, may re(iiiire to be excici-cd by a general meeting of the shareholders, or it may be ,.;i|,iil)lo of being exorcised by the directors "; and it appearing that by t!ie articles the general conduct of the bu-iuess was vested in the diroclors, his Lord-hip held that they could e.xercise the power. Thi- ca-« goes further to show that the substittition of tl.o words as the company may think conducive," for tho words ' are con- ducive," is not wilhoiii effect. Hut no doubt tho operation of the uoids must be limited to such things as may rmsomihhj and in good laid, be deemed conducive. See Joint Stock Di-'icount Co. v. IJroivn, ■t Eq. 1.".0; 8 Eq. .181; and Aft.-den. v. (it. Kii.fteni Kail., ."> App. Cas. 47.!. Funnel ly it was the pr.ictico of the olfice of the Registrar ol .loint Prantioeof Stock Companies lo iO(iiiiro general words to strictly follow the "^ce- .tululuu forms. iVr/'*- ca^c, 2 Ch. 075. But thi« practice has been ubaiidoiiod, and general words may be made as extensive as desired, llv considered better not to rely loo much on gi' tho •fleet of gene.al words, having regard to the artilicial doctrine I'll »7> MEMORANDA OK AHSOCrATION. [CllAP. VI. ii ; I ill ill I'owrr to i'Xt>'ii2; t I'li. 117; Syrrs \ liiiijltlon ISn-irvri/ Co., Vi W. 11. liai; comiiare with Ashhiin/ l{„,l- irai/, dr. Co. v. liklie, L II. " H. L. «.").'l. Hut such words oii-Im never lo be inserted, a- Ix'iiijr mij;iitoiy and mish-arliiiy;. ,1.'* to imitlU'il imiin:s. Theie arc some im|)lied pnwors uhi.ii tli,. (ompuuy possesses in \irtiic of its lioing a biuly corporate. Tlni.. .t Lompuny may appoint and act by agents, and as |iiin(ipal may im ur the ordinary cuii.seiiuoiKes .see siiiini. p. ;!•> K and in ftnlli's ./(., 8 C. Div. .S.'U, it was held that a power to conipromiso a hoiid ll'lf dispute is incident to eviMy l)oo, '' we are warranted in li(ddii|i>: that a \m\\>Y bond tide to ionipromiM> any dispute whatever is incident to the 1c;.mI existence of the /kt.vowi of a body corporate. ' .\f;ain, aciuiiinii; I • Viilciil File Co.. •> Cli. H.i. a body corjxn-.ite as such has an impbo.l power to deal with its properly. In that ca-o. .James, L. J., t-aid: The (unipany is a body coipoiate, and by the laws of En;j:lund .< bodv corporate can hold properly and disi)o-e of it as freely as mi individual, unless it is specially prohibited from so doinjr. I" the momurandiim of this company I can liiid nothing: to j)ievcnt the ( ni,i- paiiv ijiid i-ompany from pledtrinj; pail of its property lor iiavniciii of a debt inclined in the course of its bnsine-s." And .\lellish. 1. .1 . said: '" It was ui'irod that no company can nioitirajre unless oxprcs-|y aulliori/ed to do so. Xow, the company has property which il i^ authori/cd to deal with, and I stionld say tlial the Irno rule is jii-i {lieconirary. namely, that the conipaiiy can mortoao-e unless expros-lv prohibiied from dointr .^o." Hut too much reliance must not bo |)laccci on tiiese dirtn. for (he company in this case was a tradiiifi romp.niv. formed (ci ac(|uir<' and work certain pateiitecl inveiilioiis, and " for llic doinj; of all such other ihiiijrs (includinir the pun liasin;.,', leasiiiL; or othorwiso acquiring, lioldiny: and disposing;; of lancis and biiildiiicsi as are incidental or loiidncive to the att:iinmoni of the above olijccN. or anv of them.' The (|iiesiion for docision was whether the company luid power to iTiort-" mi^rht very well have been treated as covered by the j^iioral words, or as justilicd by reason of the com- pany beiiiir a trading; comi)any. Moreover, the dicta seem scarc.'ly oonsisteut wiiii the priiu-ijiic O'tubli.-hed in A.^'fil'Unj, tf'- Cn v Birhe. L. R. 7 II. L. (>•").!, which was decided five years later. It is .submitted that the powers of a company to deal with it.s pro- perty and to borrow dei)end (in tho ab.seuce of express power in the memorandum of a.ssociationl, not on its beiny- a botly corporate, but INTKODIICTORY NOTES. 47:1 ;, . invi..-' iini.li.xl power to .1.) whatovor is fairly and roasonal.lv ;;;;,1.;; „:..n,J.uat« ... «,K,.i.ied ..LJoC., in .^h c-*.« tho ,ue«t.... JK-o; __ I , 1 ,„. tlu. sncriKod ol.j«ot« of tl.o toinpunv. TlniH, a .ompany «),«t Kpe.iHr. "■';''„/„. ,ar.v on the b..m.u>.ss of a tolliery proprict,.r .night uo ■••.J-t. :,;;,; ;.,,,„i,.o a„d work collit.ri..8; ...isht have a bankint. acconnf. .-n.p.o. ', 'i.,.|,. ,.,r ihi- p..rp.«c« of it« business borrow .nont'.y on inortuMip:*' or ,i;,.«is,. and d.aw, a.H*pt. and ondorM, bills of .'xchant;..: ....jrht i,,„„„.„„„.so .lai.ns inad« a^rainnl it; n.it'ht ro.nuneraH. .Ih .Muploys; ,„i,J„ pHN .lividonds ... it. .han-.h,.ldor«: n.ii:ht advor.i^^ ..-< p.o.lu,t^: „.iM,i ...s.al.lLsh branch otP ; .ni(;ht a.M,..ir« rolling: .....k, an.l ,„,"luiHTV. and vo.-sols f.-r .■onvovin-r its coal; for all .hex- Ih.n-s ,„„1 ,„a„v otlu.rs. u.v reasonably i"'.plieed; an.l '„ l„rl,„n it n.ijrht do Ihene thin-s if the objects .onclnded with ,oiiil words as above, p. 471. W.uu. if a co.npunv is formed simply 10 provid* .1 lo«.i Ibill U " and .0 h't the same fur any pnrpose, public or piiviile, .In- i,„„,„nv i..i-ht no donbt purchase a site an.l erect a bnildi..-. ■..,: I ,„i„|„ |,.i it, and n.i-ht .•emnno.'ate its employes, and do var.ou, „,|^., t|,iii.rs; but it seems (luublful whether it c.uld wilhuii' 'nihc^s .„„ in i„ its memo.amlum accept a bill of exchan-e, or Im.,...vv. !,i-cll. c.r nmrK^'a-e the property lVrhap.> ii miyh. boriew m y lo ,,,v inr the erccliun or roj.air of the bnil.linfr 'see /^• Ihuirivr. . lltn.-' 1 1 Vl, .-„iH I. bu. that ...ust bo because the power is reasonably implie.l ,,.,„„ ,|„. (.bjects specified. It will not have the power .iierely hccau--c ii i. a , oriH.ra.ion. In this respect what wa-s suid by Cotton, L. .1 .. in 7/„. i^n.rn v. Sir (harl,:^ li,,-d, .". ^^ H- IHv. 1H3, may be c.telitiite(l. . . A tradiiifr .orpoi-ation stands, as rcj-ards an power of borrowing, in a vcy .lilVorent posilion fiom a ,oiii-d.' In this case the ditan OnonhHS Cu , -A I)e IJ. & J. 12;); Aitntralian Co. v. Mnume>i. 4 K. k .] 71;!: a..,! Company Prec. Part III., pp. 47. 48): it has :,ls„ an iniplifMl power to incur debts (see Hussell v. FmM An. iiml iDrl: lluil I'd., t ( h. 7»8i; un »m>I1 iiiiU moritfuj^o (soo (iardni-i \. /, <;. il it Co., 2 C'h. 201; Yurk-Hhirc Hail. Co. v. MaHure. lil r Div, Jn?, I\itii/.ihiiry Collifrii-n. i l"J!)7i 2 Cli. 2->'J). Having rc^rard to thcNo doubts uiid dillieultioi* at Id corpoiate cuputity, it in cxcwdiii^'ly dodrablo not iiioroly to stale tlio iii;iiii • ibjfcti* of llio (»iii[iaii,v, l)Ut iil.so to stato any uiicillary objects «lii. Ii the cuiupiiiiy is int(\iidcd to liuvo, or iiiiiy possibly recjuire, and win. h iiro not ncccs^aiily iiiiplicil li\)ni the siaU'UH'iil of llic main objiv t<, or cannot with contiiloiirc bo left lo llio opt' ion id' tlio <_'eiK'ral «nrda with wliioli (>von moiiioiandmn .oncluil whero to draw tlio line, but it hax no.. ' i Praeliiv varies us to 1' . ii.>toiii.ir\ ,.i M'L iiiit Old pnicticn as tn ittutiii^ ubjevtH. Prewnt practice lli(> objfcln ill fon«idoia!ilo dotiiil It was foriiM'ily not iiiMi.-iiai lo slate iho olijccl.^ in tin- nicnioiaM- dum willi till' uluHHl iiiii'i-ciic^s. and then to clulionit ■ iIksiii in ilie aitirli'-i; toi- iii.-.ianio, tin- olijtvts as sUiilhI in tlio inomoianduiu iiii;;lit bo: " Tlio woikinfr of loal initios, and llio dojn^' ot all smli tliiiiLi^ .i^ iiro fiiiiduLivc or intidonlul thorclo." Tlio aitiules woulil ilion nui- tain, inter alia, ptuvor for the diroclors to soil tlio uiKlotlakin;; of llio runipaiiv, in considenitioii of fa.sli or sliaros, to promoio ollinr coni- paiiios. III puuliuso ane contracts, and so forlli. Tlio daniror wlioio thi.-: iiluii was mioplod was that somo of tlio powers o.v|ir<;s>ly ctjiiforrod on iliti (liroctor.s by tho urlii'ios iiiitrlil bo b dd ultra vircn of tlio coinpaiiy Accordiii',' to pros<'nt practice, llio rovorse of this plan is ado).ir(l. Thus, in the above caso the powers conferred by the articlos on the diroctois wiiuld bo in.^ortod as objects of llio company in tlie nioiiio- raiidiim. while tho ariiilos wduld oinpowor the directors to o.\orci<" all tho powers of the coiii|)any not by statulo loijuirod to I o c.\cici-o.l in poiioral iiioolinir, .subject, ])crhaps, to certain reslricti iiis. Adviiutajfcsof No doubt in the result llio objects clau.se of the iiiemorai. I'jiii. as •uch pruciRo. j„j^^. fi-iiiiiod^ i,s ia many ca>os uuiiocos,-arily lontr, and stale-, iioi only what may bo callod tho leading or jirimary objects, but expressly einjiowern tlio company to do a great iiiaiiy tliin;_'s which, if not expressed, would or might bo implied as rcasimably incidental to tho leadiiif;' < lijects, or which may novor be re^iuiied. lUit, after all, it must be borne in mind that the objects clause of a inomorandiiin is intended to be road and undorslood, and acted on not merely by lawyers, but by ordinary busiue.ss men; and such men like to sec the powers of the company o.xprossed with fulness and in con>idoialilo deiuil. iiu-'tead ol lo.siiii^ lu iliipiicalioli. Take, for o.vample, Iho case of a company whose objects aro "to buy, sell, and deal in coal, and to do all things incidental thorolo. " What an imperfect guide such a spocilicatiou of objects allords to business men! They may be taken to know in a general way that INTRODDCTOBY NOTM. 476 ,h.. o Uiilv i.i.„lm..al thoroio Hut ll..' pruDi.al .[....Minn „„ Willi' ii lairlv itiri^limn»l (li.T.-io' Wlioii' U Hx' lnui to bo ",','iu, 111'' aiic" lo.H will Huv: • Miiv wv l.iiN ari.l work u .M.lli.Ty? (1„, „.. Imv odirt,.. iin.l «tor.M? May w- l.iiv .in|M'^ Mii> wi- n.ako ,„i'n. lufl'i' Nh.v «" "^•'"1" '"'"-^ '"■ "^'''^"f^''' ^''.^ "" '""''■"* ||,!„„n - Miu wo 'i««uf (ioliciiluru stock i- May wi> iiMul iiioii.'> ' May 'rfn:ci into |.u.lii.T.sliil. willi otiiors:- May w(> taUo s|,an-* in other I!„c.'iii--- MaN wu soil Iho wholo uiLlcrtaUitij,' if a cliaiic. aiistM' mIn ^u■ "iv./a ),'uarailtoo? May wo promote another coiii|>ariy to ,„',kc ail alliauc. with our fomiiaiiy? May we buy up the business of ,„u.: he. company- May we buy a patent?- .\,, 1 ,1,1 ,1 |;,l^■,oI■c(ml.lall-^^"^ ihc'.-.e.piO'^lioii.-.aniUay, • .S,)mu ol .|„'.r 'hill.'-' vou may du; oilier- you eaniioi ' Hut surely the busi- ,0- man lias reasonable groun,] to a-U. "Why is .so mud. bft to |„,,,li,ation? Woul.i it nut havo been more cmvonieni to slate the „|,',,i> ill -teater detail, ami thu- let llie .l.Hiimeiit it.s.-ll a.iswei ,i„...;i,,„> ili:',i are sure o> ari.se:" N,,i i, 11 ea-y to answer thi- cpiesii,,ii i.ib.Twis.. iliaii in lb'' alliMiialive, , \,„| ,.v,n the liiwver cannot but .-.ympaibi/e in the matter with llie l,„',i,i,- luaii. for liie ,h' ■iHi,ui> a- to what is aii,i what is iiol :.-• ate not alto-ether in aecor.l. ami althou-!i a com-ise objects ,.lau>e mav .sullico when ri'a.l in the li-ht ol the .h^ •iM,.!!.-. it appears 10, > Mion-i-hie.l aiui iiiip,,liiic to I.mvc to i,iipli,,iiioii poweis «ith „|,i,l, ,: ,-,lcarly ,i..-i,al,|o lo iiiv-, ,lie. ...aid 'liiis in elVe.t •0 pau' llic w.iy f.ir .lilVereiew of opinion. H) (Kvpa:,' jiillalN tor ii,e iiiinar\. ami to eompol the pru.h'iit ilirc lor to seek lei;al a,ivi,e at every step. Seo further, on this p,ani, Company Law (9ih e,l. i, ''''A,''t''lberi,i^ ami exiemliiio ,hc ol.ject- ol a ..ompaiiy. .ee sect. 9 ^^^^^ "' ,,1 til,. ( oinpanios A.i, l'.IU8, inti.rpoi.itiii- tlie provishuis ol the rompanies ( Moinoramlum of .Association) .\cl. !«'.">. hifra. Cliap .Wll. The ,o,e-,i„. matters ,p, 449) must be in-LMte I in every niemo- ^;;^;^^^ kuhIuih of a.s.socii.tioii, whether the company is to be limite,! or uiiiiiiii'ei In the ca.se of a eompaiiv limit^-d by ^r„aranloe. thoro I- onh Miic more clau.se— viz.. the j.'iiaran!e" i-lau-e. iinh'ss it is to have a ,apilal divided into shares, in which case there miis' also I :■ a ..ipilal elau.so i.sce no't. 4 (12) of the .V.'t. repl.icin- se,.!. 27 of •lie Companies Act, 1900); whilst in llie ease of a oompany limited l\ .-lu.ie- thoie are two m,ire i lauses— viz.. the declaration of limited r ,1,,;!;.^. .,„,| .j.p ,.;,j>;.:,! rbsuse-. The al'ov iiieniioned aro coiidiMons ol the "memorandum which sect. II of th,-> Act of 19 18 would seem 10 render unalterable. Tho word "seem"' is used because, singu- irly eiiuufrh. it lia.s boon hoM that tho.so conditions do not iiievent the company from imposin},', by ius regulations, ou its mcmlxus a greater or further liability. 11 476 MKMORANDA OF ASSOCIATION. [ChAP. VI. Thus, ill //,7r.v ra8e, 20 Eq. -.85, and Maria Anna Co., f. C. I). 447. il wii.s held by .Milling V.-C. that the arfirlos coiihl oft'ortimllv ini|ri,.s,. il liiiliility in exce.s.-; of the aniomit of tlie nharos hold hv tli,. iii("iiilioi-.s. and tho la.-^i-inontioued decision was iiHirniod l>_v the ( oiiri of .\|i|i('al. Sci' also I'lnhimhi ( n. v. Flevihi'i. 27 L. T. X. S. l II. Il involves a iieedle.-s expeiidiiure in stjimp dulv; no savin-. howc\er, is ellected in slainp duly or otiiei wise by siartiii"- with l.-- than 2.0011/. capital. 'I"he amuuiii of the share- dcpond> on a number of eoiisideralioii-. If tho public are lo be invited u< iij)|dy for shares, the aniounl shoiild be moilciate. for il is treneially found thai there is a better inarkef lor 1(1/ or .W. shares than for lar^-er ones. Indeed. II. shares aic now liie iiiMsi popular. Moreover, if is ;,reiierally e.\-pe,iiont noi to leave much, if any, liability on the sliari's issued. So lonfj- as shares are not fully paid up. their value, unless in exceptional cases, i- impaireil by the e.\isienie of ilio liabiliiy; and if the eompaii\ shuulil meet wiih reverse-, its shares may bei ome almost unmarkeliible There may, however, bo cases in which those disadvanta fundamental con i riMlinii ol' new >liali's. (/;i Tin' shaioi may Ix' iim-ioliilalcil. <■.(/. icii 1/. iiit c Id/ in I'aid-iiii shares nu ho (((iiviMloil into slork. i(/i Slmk may Iio icioiucrtivl into liilly-|iaiil shari'- • (■! Tlic shaios may lie suli-iliviilod liy ^pt'cial ifsdiiiiidii. in/, into Ion 1/ '(< Shaios which have not liccii issncil mav he (Mriccllt'd I (/ 1 The caiiilal may l)(> iimIiikvI Ii liv (ho < 'oiiri ,(/ . one spcrial rcsoliiiion sanctiont'i i,(i. ih< and i ot the Act of 1877. all now loiisolidated in s,.ii. (1 of I ho ( ompanies Act, litOS; ( (; ) liy sect. 9 of the Ad of 1H07, o.xplaiiiod (.\ the Act of 1K77, now sect. -l(i of the ( 'ompanics Act. 1'J(I8. Sa\o as aforesaid, and subject to the power now jriven to a coiii- pauy to rcorjr'uize it.s capital (t'ompanies i (.'onscdidation i Aci. l>t(»S, V I.I. Mil alteration of the capital of such a imnpanv can be lenallv iii.clc. l-'u'l'liii/i eh. 711 i un.uilhori/od Hil.-di\i-ion of sharesi; Srin-H's ,vi.sc. .'i Ch. |:>1 .■ unanihoi i/eil in- I MMM. (if ciipiial i; I'riiiir \ . \Vhitini)ih. Ili App ('as. |l»',l; II (•//«/(. \ Sdiicri/, • I.S'.i7 A. ('. U'.)!» (unauthorized red in sect, fli of the Conipaiiios .\ot, I!H)8. liv the provi- >i"ii- of ihat section the interests of <'redilors are carefullv sal'e- f;ii.uded; for ihe reduction to bo elfective recpiires tl) the Siiiiction ci a spoi iai resolulicHi; l2i the consent of t^yt^yy credilur, or provi- si.ri till \n< payment, e.xcept as pinuded by sect. I!l; i :t i Ihe con- l!nM:iii(.n of the Court, exctipt .is provided bv sects. IS ."iii .Soo, !!Hilicr. Chap. W'll.. iiifrii. Niir lan any words inserted in the memorandum or articles of Wurd,- in ci-ii. iation abroc-aio the di.sabilitv imposed bv the Ad. or enable the ""■"'",'•■''"'' '" |Miiies lo escape Iroiu tlio eoilditioiis which the l,ey:ishiture. on the caiin.it hIut lii'uuds of public policy, has thoufrht Ht to iin|)ose. Thus, if u '^*"•'•■''''■i' - c.iuipany, by its memoiaudum of ussociatiou, takes jiower to buy it« n ^i'S iil 47 M MICMOIJANDA OF ASSOCIATION. [ClIAP. VI. I.iulpility to pay for all Kliari'* in full. No powtT to iHHUu at ducouut ; nor bonu!* •hiirc«i. IwHiie of paid- up shurt's. own share-', or fo pay (liviii( of capilal, inasmuch as tha oxcrcisc ot' iho ])()\v('i- uoiilil involvf a ve(lu(tioii ol' iho capital, tlio powcj (aniKil ho validly cxoi^ isoil. oxii-pt in aoiordanio with tlie statiituiv jnovisioiis. 'I'rcviir v. Wliilirortli, 12 App. Cas. 40"J. What cannot ho duno diroctiy cannot ho ilono indiioctly. It may ho convonioni hero to note that tho liahility imidcnt to a sliaio r:\n only ho satisfied hy paynioni in Inll. I'aynient may now ho made in ca-iji cjr in ])i(i|rt)riy. in' soi'vicc^. . lOveu when! all liahilili s to outside creditors have been satis- lied, the discount share'iohlor nmst pay up in full to adjust tlio riohls of shareholders intir se. Wclton v. Safferi/, (IS'.tT) A. (' 2'.tl'. .Vnil () forliori bonus shares cannot be validly issued, i'.ihbi- xtiiiic Marine, dc. Co., (!«',);!) •'! (;li. it; .Mosclei/ v. h'olji/foiilcin. .l//»c,s. tl'.t(l4i 2 Ch. 108. A ( i>m|Mny cannot is-^ne paid-up shares i-xcopt on tho I'oolinp:' tliut they are to he paid for in cash or its ei[nivalent in value. Triie, it may |iay a commission to a suhscrih< . and thus, so far as tlio linancial result is concerned, issue Iho shares at a discount, hut in theory the shares arc still paid up in f'lU by tho underwriter, t!ii]iit;h part is returnt.i in the form of commi^>ion. See .sect. H9 of liii^ Companies Act. I'JOS. siijira, p. 27'.t. Au agreement to issue paid-up shares in consideraliou of ))ro[)ertv, services, or oilier consideration of value is only eiroclive because it is in •^iih^taiKO an agreement hy the directors to accof)! the jjioperly, servile^, or other cou'^ideraiion in |)aymont of the amount i>t tiio share While the agieement stands unim|)eaclied, tho Court will mil iiiipiire into the value of the property or .service^, hut will assiuiio the directors to liavo exercised an honest judgiuont and liio cmi- sidei.iiiou in property or services, itc. to have been the ciiuivalcut of the capital liability on tho shares. /V/f.s ca.si'., ■> Ch. II; /I'o Wnif/i/. ( 18971 1 Ch. 7;tii, supra, y. 02 ft Kfq. liul this dooi not import that shares can bo issued as fully paid-up in ■: •••i-ideratioii of projiorty whivli the ruiitrrict it-elf =how3 tliiit tlie parlies valued at loss than the amount of the shares. Almada and Tirito Co., ubi nupra. INTRODUCnOKY NOTJM. 47a Minimum Subscription. \\ licrc -Imrii f;i|iitiil of llio cuininiiiy is to bo olloioil lo i ho pulilir fur Mili-ciiplioii. tlio aiiKMiiit of "(ho iniiiiiiimii sub'-rriplinri upon whi' h llio ilircctors iiitiy j)roioO(l lo allotiiiont " iiKii/ In' " lixcd by (bo iiKMU'Tiniiliiiii " of associudnii. See •<0(l . 8', of ("ompaiiios Ait, l!t()S, ai;.l |i. II'- ■•^ni'rii- It iiooil not bo statod in (ho iiicriioniiiibnii, 1hi(, il iiiusr lio fixed oillior by (iio luomoranduni or by tho artii li'-< of asso- (iaiiMii. Ibid. And il ii boltoi' to !i\ it hs llio articlos, for if iii- MMloil in the laonioraiidiim it is iiiialteralilo, and may. if nut olitainod, wiv k iho (iini|i:iny, wlioroa.s if inscrlod in llio arlii-los i( can, if l|„. [lubl vi|)(ion ]irovos insulliciont, bo allorcd. Additional Provisions. |!c.-i(li'> llio^o conditions widch llie \i\ of 19(18, s. ;t. n'((uiros (o l>o C.inliiiiins i" -^|ii I ilii'd in (iio inoniorunduni, any material piovi.-inn wiiicii is in fact j"/.'|','i,']'j''|,'|,,''I" • lUl iii the nK'niorandiiin of assoiiatiou (';/ , a.s to tho amount of lln- r.taiuiuiy ilic niiiiiinuni (jub.scription — is (.subjoct to what i^ suid ubovo) uiialter- al)lo. Tlius, if tlio nionioranduin of association of a companv states mcM Kxiiinplcri. ,,,..,,, ... , An tdilirtcniit tlic capital and divides the Hharo^ therein into .several clasfics, and , la»»(» uf dcclarp.s the rights as roirard.s dividends or othorv.iso assicjiiod to "'"'"'''• each cla.ss, ^ucli declaration is a condition of liic nionioranduin, and i» iiiialtoiable by sjiecial resolution or oth>.''\viKe. Ashhurij v. Watson, K) C. Div. 370. lu that case certain .special resolution.s had boon p;i,>sod liy (ho Smyrna and Cassaba Hallway {'onipany, and acted on fur iiioro than ten years without objection, which purported to alter ilic ligliLs hilor se of (ho dill'oront classes of .shares as dohiiod by the iiic'inoranduui of association, and it was liold that those ix!solution.s uciv vHra circs and iiioi)erativo. In support of (lie validity of thics case, 112 C. i). '2'M, that tho dolinition of rights WU.S not a condition witliin tho nn>nninf; of sect. 12 of the Act of 1802 (now sect. 41, Companies Act, 1908),and that tho condidons which, by that .socliou, are iiiauo unalterable, were only those oonditioiis which tlic -Vet n'i|uirod to bo specilled. iJut it was held otherwise. Urett, M. Ii, after referring to the word.s of sett . 12of the Actot 1802, said: "•■Vnytliing more plain 1 cannot conceive. It does not say, 'the iiun in (■l;i'fHt-.s. M* iiioraiKiuni Hiltilt, but jnnvt-v in iiri- l!iu;tl urtii lis. Preference and other Special Classes of Shares. Noi iiilii'^jiKMitlv llic ciiiiilal is, liv llio iiU'iiuiriiiKliiin and ailidis 111 ;u->MMiuli(Pii, (livi(l('s(M of sliaios witli dilli'iont riiflits atlailit'd to tlifiii; fill- instance, intn pn'foronco and oitlinarv sharfK, or pioft'ivnui', oKiinaiv. and founders' sliaies. When this is tlic case, it is nui unooninioM to (h'tine in the nieiuoianduin some of the riijht.s alta. licl to tlie dilleivnl clas.M'- of sliare^ lo^pectively, or to some one liii^^ul thoni. The olijeet of so d<'(ininjr llie riy:hts of shareholder.^ in the jmimiio- raiiduru i< to fortifv the po^iiion of the class, for rifi-iils once iincnii- (ll/Uimilli/ altaihod hy the nieniorandiini to a paiticiihir class of sli;iic>; caiiiiol Iw altered or iMfrinu:eiiiill.i/ nUaiAwd, that is, if thoiji.'li s|ieiili<'d in the nienioraiidnni thev are coupled «illi a clause in ilic nieniorandiiin providiiij.^ fur alteiittion. such a specitication in llic menioranduin d(K\s not t;ike elfecl as an nnallerahle condiiimi Wclnhiirh. <(■(•. Ci).. (I'.tOt; 1 C'h. K7. Mor(> often, however, the nieiiutranduni merely contains a cIuum. ;u j^-eneral terms to the ellecl that 'the shares in the (ai)ital lor llic 1 imc Ix'iiig-, whether oriijinal or ineiioa.sed. may be dividcs: liiit evcM in such cases it was lorn.;' siiict> Jield thai the article-., as orii^inallv franicij and rejjisl*'!^^!, (ould etleiiually diviile. or ei\e power to divide, llic ca|)ilal into dilfeivnt clu.sses of shares with |)refereiitial and other rigrlit.s attached. lltinif^nH v. McjiruH Hail. ( o.. lil E(|. :\-')H: /o South Dnr'na)!! lirfiiirii < o., 'M ('. I). 2()1. This conclusion w.is iini arrived at without dilliculty, for the doci.sions in Hnltitn v. Srm- h(,r<>U(fh (tiff, (tv. Co. I No. li (MSti'd. 4 De (-. J. & S. 07:2; iiinl (No. 2i 2 Dr. it Sill. .)21, hotli appeariMl to point to the coucliisidii that wheiT the inenioranduiu of a.ssociation wa.s silent as to (lasses, there wius an ini|)lied condition of eipiality, ;vn. liiivMixcr. mil mil iiiiiiiinii Id linil iliiii ni'itlii'r llic iiH'iiiDiaiiiliiiu Whi-n- miiim- Miii ilif iiitiili's. ji.> iiiii;iiiallv liiiiMi'il. i;iv(' p.iut'i- to i>.-,iH' iiri't't'i-cricc ''".•'"'"'""' ... .' Ill :irl nil's :irr .mil iiiIhm .s|ilia-t's, and. wlicic Imtli aic -ilciil. llic Imtli »;i.iit ii» inlliiuiii;; i|iu'.-.tiiin.^ .<()Mi("tiiiics arise: li ('an llic ('oiii|iaii\ i.-n an iiHica.-i' dl lapilal wiili ipn't'crciitial m- .-.|ivvi'r('(l in tiic lu'^alivc. .\.- Ill till' lii>l i|iu'stiiiii. it wa.-< (locidcd hv l.nid \\ C^iliiii v . L. ('. ihal ulii'ii liulli iIh' iiii'iiiinandiini and uilitlc.s witc .-.ilt'iil a^ in )ii<'- hniii I' .«liai(V-, a coiniiaiiy cnuld not issin' sliaios in ii,v ui iyiiial caiiilal a.- |iiclViciuo .vliaio-i. at aiiv rak'. wiliiunt allciinn- il,-^ ailirli'^. and lijiilici. Iiiri LiPiil>lii|i c.xpicsstid diinlit. ulirllur cvi'ii li\ allciiii^- ii^ ailiil<'> till' |i(i«cr Luiild lie olilaiiu'd (//«//<>« v Scmhunut'ili ( lill. il' ( n.. 1 I).' li. .] . A S. i;--2<: and llic dci-i.-imi ol' K indci.sh'N . \ -I .. Ill llllll'ill \ SrillhninlUlll (lill. dr. (il. I Nn. L'i. J |)|-. ,V .^111, .'ijl. uiMii fai 111 riiidiini llii.-- dmilil. .\ nd a.> in ilii' -.iTind i|iii-.liuii. il \\a^ aii-ui'icd in the iicualivc In llii' ilcii.-inii i,j' Kiii(l''i.~li'\ . \ .-( .. ill the ra>c la.--!, iiu'iitiniu'd. Ilii' llii> il(Mi»i(in iia- nuu lici'ii u\cii nlcd li\ iho ('uiiii nf Apiical The law .i- III Aiidirir.. \. (i,is Mrlcr ( „.. IH'.m;) 1 Cli. ;!i;i. In ,||;,| ..-iso ihcro ""»""'"'"'■ \\a.- 11(1 iiiiucr in llic original niciiiinandiiiii nr ailirli'.s to ismio pic- Icicinc r'liarcN. Inil powor wa.s taken hy .s|)tMial icsdliiiinn and acii'd "11 Till' ( imrl III' A|)|ioal hold that the prd'oi't'inc .shales wore \.iliilly I ii'iilcd. on the jri'iiund thai. allliiiii 111 .-laic the ainiiiint ol' liie oiieinal ca|iilal. yet in other lesper - the liplit.- ol llie shaieholdeis in fes|ieit nf iheif shares and the terms on ■iliirli aiiv aildilioiial capital iiiiiv lie raised, are inall'is t., he rei;ii latcil \i\ the ani.les of assmiai inn rather than liy the iiici ainliiin. and an- theielore nialters which unless provided for liv the iiieino- raniliini, as in /slihiiri/ v. Wdlsoii. .'iO ('. I). ■.i7l>) may lie doterinined liy the loiapaiiy from time to time liy special rosolution. piirsnanl Iii.vcl, ."ill -f ill,. Act of IHilL' now sect, .'i of the Act of UMIK i. Tlii- view (learl- ■iee;alives the doctrine that then) is a condilinii in the nicMioiandu.il of associalion that ail shareholders are to lie on an i'i|iialin unless ihe ineinoranduni it.solf shows the contrarv. .Sec l.iiiillev. 1,. .1. Acroi(liiii,dy. the eiirrect answer m ihe second (|iie-- tiou is: ■'ies. hy altoriua; its articles so a^ to t.ake the reipdsiie |ionci . Moicnver, the eroiinds of this decision •ro far to show that the same aiisHer should lie p-iveii to the lirst (|iiesiioiK for it is now alnindaiith clear that a meiuorauduiii lieinv' silent. :i,s to any distinction !.,.(•,; 4>i.ii sliaieholilers does not amount to iin implied coiidiliun of eipialily a.s IjolHoeii the sharos in the capital. 1' , . * } '<■ 4H2 MEMORANDA OF ASSOCIATION. [ChAP. VI. Atlvorliii^r to tlii.s pnim, (otloii, L. .1., iu (fui)ine'<.i v. fMiid (\ Itonifioii III Irrhtiil. 'l^l ('. n. .U'J. .'tyy, r*iii(l: " In roiilily it is not liv Pi V ■t', LiiiL^H .^^H baaiJMMg MMe il '.nSa^B <'<^'' ' ■« ij'^i^W Su^scribtTs* de'litratimi. r 3 5 :i ? Memorandum 1 may be in f writing or printed. inipiicalioii frnin \\w cnn.st ruction (if llio iiiciiionimliiiii that tin eiiuality of tlio .sliarcliokiors as logards dividond arisiw, but liy tlic im]di«itioii wliicli tlio law raises as iHStweeii partners, unless ihojr contract lias pri'vidcd to the contrary." And in a later ease { lirilisli Co. V. riiiiinr. I 1S'J4) A. ('. .'WOi, Lord Macna(rhten -said: 1 H'^Trv lliiU ihe oijuality of whaieholder.s as rey:ards dividouil is nu; an iin|ili(' I londilimi of the nieiiioranduiii; hut I doulil whether ii is iieiessai'v to have recourse to the doctrine of j)artncrship. li xt'Mi.-- to Mie that if the sum of the interests of persons conccriicd in a joint venture is divided into shares of e(iual amount distinnuislioii bv nuinhers for the purpose of identification, but with no other distinction lieiween them, expressed or implied, it follows as a self- evident proposition that the interests of the shareholders in respect of the.se shares, as repanls dividends and everything else, nmst 1" equal." There lieiiiir, iIkmi, no imi)lieil cotulilhiti of ecpiality, it appears tu follow thai silence in the memorandum docs not jirecliide the issue (it' preference .sliaies, but that the articles as oriirinally framed or as altered by special re.solution can give the requisite power to issue part of the original shares as preference shares. This (>onclusiou is not at variance with the decision in Ilutton v. Scarborough ClilJ Co.. 4 I)e li. .f. (t S. I No. 1), Kiipra, for in that case the company was seeking to is.sue preference shares, although neither its nuiiiD- randuni nor articles gave power to issue the same, and although its articles expressly, in ellect, provided that all dividends were to he paid jxiri jxiio'ii. It is only contrary to the doubt expresM-d In Lord Westbury— a doubt whicii gave rise to a dictum merely. As to alleriiiir the rights attached to eli. ses of shares, see /»/ra. p. •)•">' ; and Wclshiich, dr. Co.. supra. On reterrinii to the forms of memoranda of association uiven below ipp lint .lOa). it will be se<'n that each of them conclude- with a declaration that the subscribers desire to be formed into a company. It will also be observed that seeta. 4, 5 of the Act ro(juire thai, "in a company limited by guarantee or unlimited, and having a capital divided into shares, each subscriber shall take one share at the least, and shall write opposite his name in the memorandum of a.s.sociation the number of shares he takes." It has been considereil that the word " iiiemoraiiduin " in this paragraph is an error for "artides," but the i)ractice of the registrar is to re([uiro the jiumber of shares taken to be slated in the memorandum. If the shares an; of ditlerent cla.s,ses it should be stated which class of shares the signatories subscrioe for. The memorandum may be in writing, but where articles are regis- tered it is usually printed with them. If in writing, it is sometimes filled in upon a skeleton printed form. It must be signed by at i' ' i INTliOUUtni >KY NOIKH. 4h:{ Ion.-' ^«'\<'ii ii'Tt-oiis (di- ill the cii'^c ol a |iiiviiii' i ()iii|)iiiiv ivvo persons, Ml' |i !ill . ill llic |)ii's(.riaiiH' wiliK'fo iixiallv atii'sts ilic -iu'iialiiro ol .ill tin- .-iil'M riluT,-. 1 . rtiticalc tviilriKi' tliat r''|uihitionM (tf A' t ciiniplicHl with. Certiiicate of Incorporation. Scr! 17 of ihc A. t of IIMIM ri"|ii('.-('iiliiij,' M'l-I. I of the (' paiiir^ A<|. I'.iiMii |iidviilcs lliat: ■ l.i .\ rntili.;itc iif iiiiiirpniation t'iveii Uy tlio n'cistrar ia rcsiiiM-r of any i-so( iatio.i Hliall be TOiii'lu''iv<' pvidenci' that all thr riviuiri'mcnt.! of tlip Art in n-iiici iif ro/ist ration ami of inattors priM cdpiit and imidrnial tlirrcto have hcfn (■■iiiiiliwi Willi, and iliat tin- as.^ociatioii is a iuiii|>aiiy aiitliorizi'd to be ratfis- iiriil and duly rciji^tcrol under this Act. ■ r.'. I A statutory dinlaration by a scdiiitiir xf tlii> Hlitli Court, and in S'ot- laiiil by an cnrolli'd law a','«'nt, ^■n^'atfl•d in the formation of tlic TOnipaiiy, or by a |rtr-(iii iiaiiiid in tbo artiidcs as a iliiv-tor or soprctary of the company, of conipiianrp with all or any of tlip said re^iuiremcnts, sball bo produced to the re(ri-trar. and the i-eiristrar may accppt such a dpi laration as nufficipnt evidpinp of cfunjiliance." See siiprii. |i. 2'). a-* t« the oiicralioii of lliis pioviKJoii. Tlie ix't^i.-il lar inakt* no olijcctioii to r«.'o-i.sloriiii,' u iiKMiioranduin Mili-ciilxMl liy a married woiiiuii. No doiiht he would rofiiso if he knew lliat ler(>d, it, i.s i(>n(l I f i' t 484 and pay fiiv ■hares. MEMOKANDA OF ASSoniATIOX. rCHAP. VI. Wheu still ri- 8ubscribf«l in memuriiiitluiii mtlrt hv J-tti'l for in l■a^'ll. opiMisifo t4> liis imiiio tlic iiumhor of xliurcs he takof*." Sod. ,1 of the All of l'.M(8 iM'cl,. « of tlu' Act of I8IIU1. Ii if* coiiwiviHl that where a .■