IMAGE EVALUATION 
 TEST TARGET (MT-3) 
 
 1.0 
 
 I.I 
 
 1.25 
 
 ij£ 1^ 12.2 
 
 i ^ m 
 
 1.8 
 
 U IIIIII.6 
 
 Photographic 
 
 Sciences 
 Corporation 
 
 \ 
 
 
 •s? 
 
 N> 
 
 iS^ 
 
 
 
 6^ 
 
 23 WEST MAIN STREET 
 
 WEBSTER, N.Y. 14SS0 
 
 (716)872-4503 
 
 

 z 
 
 ^ 
 
 ^ 
 
 CIHM/ICMH 
 
 Microfiche 
 
 Series. 
 
 CIHM/ICMH 
 Collection de 
 microfiches. 
 
 Canadian Institute for Historical Microreproductions / Institut Canadian de microreproductions historiques 
 
Technical and Bibliographic Notes/Notes techniques et bibliographiques 
 
 The Institute has attempted to obtain the best 
 original copy available for filming. Features of this 
 copy which may be bibliographically unique, 
 which mav alter any of the images in the 
 reproduction, or which may significantly change 
 the usual method of filming, are checked below. 
 
 □ Coloured covers/ 
 Couverture de couleur 
 
 I I Covers damaged/ 
 
 D 
 
 D 
 
 D 
 D 
 
 D 
 
 Couverture endommag6e 
 
 Covers restored and/or laminated/ 
 Couverture restaurde et/ou pellicul6e 
 
 I I Cover title missing/ 
 
 Le titre de couverture manque 
 
 I I Coloured maps/ 
 
 Cartes g6ographiques en couleur 
 
 Coloured ink (i.e. other than blue or black)/ 
 Encre de couleur (i.e. autre que bleue ou noire) 
 
 I I Coloured plates and/or illustrations/ 
 
 Planches et/ou illustrations en couleur 
 
 Bound with other material/ 
 Reli6 avec d'autres documents 
 
 Tight binding may cause shadows or distortion 
 along interior margin/ 
 
 Lareliure serr6e peut causer do I'ombre ou de la 
 distortion le long de la marge intdrieure 
 
 Blank leaves added during restoration may 
 appear within the text. Whenever possible, these 
 have been omitted from filming/ 
 II se peut que certaines pages blanches ajout6es 
 lors d'une restauration apparaissent dans le texte, 
 mais, lorsque cela 6tait possible, ces pages n'ont 
 pas 6t6 filmdes. 
 
 L'Institut a microfilm^ le meilleur exemplaire 
 qu'il lui a 6t6 possible de se procurer. Les details 
 de cet exemplaire qui sont peut-§tre uniques du 
 point de vue bibliographique, qui peuvent modifier 
 une image reproduite, ou qui peuvent exiger une 
 modification dans la mdthode normale de filmage 
 sont indiquds ci-dessous. 
 
 D 
 D 
 D 
 D 
 D 
 
 D 
 
 Coloured pages/ 
 Pages de couleur 
 
 Pages damaged/ 
 Pages endommag^es 
 
 Pages restored and/or laminated/ 
 Pages restaur6es et/ou pelliculdes 
 
 Pages discoloured, stained or f jxed/ 
 Pages d6color6es, tachet6es ou piqu^es 
 
 Pages detached/ 
 Pages d6tach6es 
 
 r^ Showthrough/ 
 
 Transparence 
 
 Quality of prir 
 
 Quality indgale de {'impression 
 
 Includes supplementary materi: 
 Comprend du materiel supplementaire 
 
 Only edition available/ 
 Seule Edition disponible 
 
 I I Quality of print varies/ 
 
 I I Includes supplementary material/ 
 
 I I Only edition available/ 
 
 Pages wholly or partially obscured by errata 
 slips, tissues, etc., have been refilmed to 
 ensure the best possible image/ 
 Les pages totalement ou partiellement 
 obscurcies par un feuillet d'errata, une pelure, 
 etc., ont 6t6 filmdes d nouveau de fapon d 
 obtenir la meilleure image possible. 
 
 V 
 
 Additional comments:/ 
 Commentaires suppldmentaires; 
 
 PULLED FROM "THE ATLANTIC", OCTOBER, 1891 
 
 This item is filmed at the reduction ratio checked below/ 
 
 Ce document est film6 au taux de reduction indiqu6 ci-dessous. 
 
 10X 14X 18X 22X 
 
 26X 
 
 30X 
 
 umi^^m aM^i^aHi ^^^^^ ^^im^m ^m^mi^ m^^^^ ^t^^^m ^^^^h ^^^^^ ^^^m^ i^h^^h h^i^^ ^^^^m 
 
 12X 
 
 16X 
 
 20X 
 
 24X 
 
 28X 
 
 32X 
 
The copy filmed here hes been reproduced thanks 
 to the generosity of: 
 
 Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, 
 University of Toronto Library 
 
 L'nxemplaire fitm6 fut reproduit grace d la 
 gAn6rosit6 de; 
 
 Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, 
 University of Toronto Library 
 
 Tha images appearing here are the best quality 
 possible considering the condition and legibility 
 of the original copy and in keeping with the 
 filming contract specifications. 
 
 Original copies in printed paper covers are filmed 
 beginning with the front cover and ending on 
 the last page with a printed or illustrated impres- 
 sion, or the back cover when appropriate. All 
 other original copies are filmed beginning on the 
 first page with a printed or illustrated impres- 
 sion, and ending on the last page with a printed 
 or illustrated impression. 
 
 Les images $.uivantes ont 6t6 reproduites avec le 
 plus grand soin, compte tenu de la condition et 
 de la nettet'i de I'exemplaire film6, et en 
 conformity avec les conditions du contrat de 
 filmage. 
 
 Les exemplaires originaux dont la couverture en 
 papier est imprimde sont fi!m6s en commencant 
 par le premier plat et en terminant soit par la 
 dernidre page qui comporte une empreinte 
 d'impression ou d'illustration, soit par le second 
 plat, selon le cas. Tous les autres exemplaires 
 originaux sont film6s en commenpant par la 
 premiere page qui comporte une empreinta 
 d'imprrtssion ou d'illustration et en terminant par 
 la dernidre page qui comporte une telle 
 empremte. 
 
 The last recorded frame on each microfiche 
 shall contain the symbol — ^- (meaning "CON- 
 TINUED "), or the symbol V (meaning "END"), 
 whichever applies. 
 
 Un des symboles suivants apparaitra ur la 
 dernidre image de cheque microfiche, selon le 
 cas: le symbols — ^ signifie "A SUIVRE", le 
 symbols V signifie "FIN". 
 
 Maps, plates, charts, etc., may be filmed at 
 different reduction ratios. Those too large to be 
 entirely included in one exposure are filmed 
 beginning in the upper left hand corner, left to 
 right and top to bottom, as many frames as 
 required. The following diagrams illustrate the 
 method: 
 
 Les cartes, planches, tableaux, etc., peuvent 6tre 
 filmds d des taux de reduction diff^rents. 
 Lorsque le document est trop grand pour dtre 
 reproduit en un seul cliche, il est filmd d partir 
 de Tangle supdrieur gauche, de gauche d droite, 
 et de haut en bas, en prenant le nombre 
 d'images n^cessaire. Les diagrammes suivants 
 illustrent la m6thode. 
 
 1 •! :' 
 
 ; ••§ 
 
 
 1 
 
 2 
 
 3 
 
 4 
 
 5 
 
 6 
 
He 
 
 $ 
 
 •^- 
 
 7t 
 
 f|fh«l4, tSf'-jtfiiin McxmMr 
 
 
 ;^r„ <•:.. 
 
 M 
 
 U i 
 
 \J'oimf^ 
 
 t^.wv^^ 
 
 i 
 
 3 
 
 Joseph ^- 
 
 f 
 
 if 
 
 ^g 
 
 .4. 
 
 b,^ 
 
 \ 
 
 r^ 
 
 ^^ 
 
 '<i^ 
 
 ■ '%, C- 
 
1891.] 
 
 Thk wn 
 
 over Cuiiat 
 
 Miicdoiiakl 
 
 The incidi 
 
 of the serfs 
 
 beginning 
 
 lated tlie z 
 
 them a cl 
 
 they have 
 
 feeling am 
 
 Ing fresh t 
 
 of their oL 
 
 In the 
 
 necessarily 
 
 lie sorrow 
 
 rounding 1 
 
 ed to ere 
 
 seventy-si; 
 
 John Mac 
 
 as Preniit 
 
 confidence 
 
 lianient o 
 
 nient and 
 
 passed av 
 
 in such a 
 
 to sorrow. 
 
 Tile lifi 
 
 almost wli 
 
 the discha 
 
 at Glasgo 
 
 aid came 
 
 an early 
 
 ton ; stud 
 
 admitted 
 
 tered on 
 
 A brief li 
 
 in the sei 
 
 the varie 
 
 life : — 
 
 Receivi 
 
 ber 7, 18. 
 
 Commi 
 
 cember 8 
 
 In opp( 
 
 Attornt 
 
 to Augus 
 
Od'v 
 
 1891.] 
 
 The Lille Sir John MdcilonuUh 
 
 m 
 
 THK LATE Sill JOHN 
 
 • 
 
 TnK wave of emotion which Hwept 
 over Cuiiada on the death of Sir John 
 Macdonald lia< not yet wholly siil)sided. 
 The incidents of the political struggle 
 of the sension of Parliament at the very 
 beginning of which he died have stimu- 
 lated the zeal of his followers, and given 
 them a clearer knowledge of the loss 
 they have sustained. Thus i)crs()nal 
 feeling and political fealty join in keep- 
 ing fresh the sense of regret for the loss 
 of their old chief. 
 
 In the nature of things, there has 
 necessarily been some subsidence of i)ub- 
 lic sorrow. All the circumstances sur- 
 rounding the death of the Premier tend- 
 ed to create a feeling that since at 
 seventy-six death must be expected, Sir 
 John Macdonald was fortunate in dying 
 as Premier of his country, and in the 
 confidence alike of the ])eople and Par- 
 liament of Canada, and of the Parlia- 
 ment and Queen of Great Britain. He 
 passed away with dignity, and dignity, 
 in such a case, affords some alleviation 
 to sorrow. 
 
 The life which thus closed was spent 
 almost wholly before the public, and in 
 the discharge of public business. Jiorn 
 at Glasgow in 1815, Sir John Macdon- 
 ald came with his parents to Canada at 
 an early age ; was educated at Kings- 
 ton ; studied law, and was in due time 
 admitted to the bar ; and in 1844 en- 
 tered on his long parliamentary career. 
 A brief list of his various emjjloyments 
 in the service of the state will indicate 
 the variety and extent of his public 
 life : — 
 
 Receiver-General, May 21 to Decem- 
 ber 7, 1847. 
 
 Commissioner of Crown Lands. De- 
 cember 8, 1847, to March 10, 1848. 
 
 In opposition, 1848 to 1854. 
 
 Attorney-General, September 1 1 , 1854, 
 to August 1, 1858. 
 
 MACDONALD. 
 
 X. 
 
 Postmaster-General for one day, Au- 
 gust (), 1858. 
 
 Attorney -General, August 7, 1858, to 
 May 2;i, 1802. 
 
 In opposition. May 23, 1 862, to March 
 30, 1804. 
 
 Attoiney-General, March 30, 1804, to 
 July 1. 1807. 
 
 Premier of New Dominion, July 1, 
 1807, to November. 1873. 
 
 In oj)p()sition, Novendier, 1873, to Sep- 
 tember, 1878. 
 
 Premier of Canada, September, 1878, 
 to June 7, 1891. 
 
 Thus, out of his forty-seven years of 
 jjarliamentary life, from 1844 to 1891, 
 he was thirty-two years in office, most 
 of that ti:ne leader of his pai'ty. He 
 was only three years in public life be- 
 fore he was in the government ; and in 
 all he was only twelve years in opposi- 
 tion, — still, however, leading his party. 
 His ojjponents always feared him ; his 
 friends never abandoned him in opposi- 
 tion ; and whether in jjower or in oppo- 
 sition, he was always the most versatile 
 and vigorous force in Canadian public 
 affairs. 
 
 In order to make as clear as possi- 
 ble to the reader the conditions of pub- 
 lic life and the questions which public 
 men had to solve at the time when Sir 
 John Macdonald entered public life, a 
 brief history of i)olitical development in 
 Canada nmst be given. 
 
 Among the possessions of the British 
 crown, Canada holds a peculiar place. 
 For Canada, the empire made a great 
 and costly struggle alike against France 
 and against the United States. For the 
 empire, Canada has thrice resorted to 
 arms — in 1775, in 1812, and in 1866 
 — and turned the tide of invasion from 
 the walls of Quebec and from the fron- 
 tiers of Ontario. For Canada, the em- 
 pire has exerted at all times its full 
 
528 
 
 The Late Sir John Manhmald. 
 
 [October, 
 
 diplomatic strenj^th ami skill, though not 
 always siiccesst'ully, and has att'orded 
 wliun necessary the valuable service of 
 her public credit. For the empire, Can- 
 ada has incurred great liabilities, which, 
 while develi)i)ing Canadian territory and 
 enlarging Canadian wealth and com- 
 merce, must inevitably be of signal ser- 
 vice in the future defense of the Queen's 
 dominions. India alone, an)ong the 
 other dependencies of the crown, has in- 
 curred great expenditure foi- inij)erial 
 interests ; but this was done, not by the 
 spontaneous and loyal self-sacrifice of 
 the people, but by the order of the 
 state. In the West Indies great bat- 
 tles have been fought, which have made 
 the waters surrounding those islands full 
 of glorious historic memories ; but those 
 battles wore fought by the British navy, 
 .. d entailed no struggle and little sac- 
 •' .ce on the part of the people. In 
 Canada, however, all efforts made for 
 the security and the interests of the em- 
 pire have been loyal, spontaneous, and 
 helpful. 
 
 Nevertheless, the political develop- 
 ment of Canada was slow. It did not 
 exhibit that progress by leaps and 
 bounds towards free political institutions 
 which we notice in the case of the Aus- 
 tralian colonies. These latter sprang 
 speedily into full life and vigor because 
 they had no long preliminary period of 
 military rule. They were settled rap- 
 idly by men who fully understood the 
 practice of constitutional government, 
 and therefore constitutions were quickly 
 conferred on them. But in the North 
 Ameri(!an provinces, though some be- 
 came British possessions in 1713, and 
 all in 1763, the acquisition of political 
 institutions of perfect freedom was long 
 delayed. Nova Scotia did not acquire re- 
 s])onsible government till 1848 ; Pi-ince 
 Edward Island not till 1851 ; New 
 Brunswick not till 1848 ; Quebec not 
 till 1841, at the time of the union of 
 Upper and Lower Canada, and indeed 
 it was not till the second session of the 
 
 first Parliament tiiat responsible govern- 
 ment was, in tiieory, conceded to the new 
 Province. 
 
 The reasons for this long delay in 
 gaining responsible government are in- 
 teresting. Tlio country was obtained by 
 conquest or had been always maintained 
 by arms ; consequently a period of mil- 
 itary rule was natural and necessary. 
 The invasion of Canada from the United 
 States in 1775 prolonged this period of 
 military government, and indeed ren- 
 dered any other government almost im- 
 possible. The loyalist inunigration into 
 Canada from 1770 to 1783, and after- 
 ward, added to the pojjulation a great 
 number of j)eople by no means disposed 
 to think that jjolitical agitation of any 
 sort was good for the peace and order of 
 the state. The war of 1812 strength- 
 ened the military ^nd conservative feel- 
 ing again, and gave an air of treason to 
 political designs and demands which at 
 any other time would have been deemed 
 worthy of serious consideration. The 
 rebellion of 1837 stigmatized as traitors 
 all who had joined in it, the penalties 
 inflicted having been very severe. For 
 these reasons, the demand made, and 
 ultimately conceded, for responsible gov- 
 ernment was met by the fierce and de- 
 termined opposition of the most influen- 
 tial, intelligent, and respectable men in 
 all Canada. The opposition to responsi- 
 ble government did not come from Brit- 
 ish officials or the red-tapists of Down- 
 ing Street. It came from within, from 
 among the people themselves, and from 
 the best and the wisesi among them. 
 For example, in Nova Scotia, in 1838, 
 resolutions were passed against the pro- 
 posed federal union of the Provinces 
 on the ground that it would " imbue the 
 rising generation with a fondness for 
 elective institutions." In New Bruns- 
 wick, in 1849, the people sustained at 
 the polls an administration strongly op- 
 posed to responsible government. 
 
 Responsible government having, how- 
 ever, been gi-anted to all the Provinces, 
 
 y 
 
1891.] 
 
 The Late. Sir John Mdcdoitdld. 
 
 520 
 
 
 I 
 
 / 
 
 \ 
 
 / 
 
 iiiul tlio union of tho two principal 
 Provinces liiivinir lieon iiccoinplishi;!! in 
 IS41, a new iield in jJolilicH was opened 
 tor public men. Tiicie were at this 
 time three classes of men engaged in 
 tile dis(;nssion and conduct of public 
 alfairs: (1) the old-time Tories, who 
 looked upon all demands for constitu- 
 tion il (ihanges as iireliminary symjjtoms 
 ol i-evolntion ; (li) the moderate Con- 
 servatives, who did not love change of 
 any sort for its own sake, but who were 
 not afraid of improvement ; and (3) tho 
 Radicals, who saw in responsible gov- 
 erniiu;nt and popular institutions the 
 promise of tho golden age. The strife 
 of these factions was rendered more 
 intense by the fact that the governors 
 had no accepted traditions of political 
 conduct, and fell sometimes under the 
 influence of one faction, sometimes un- 
 der that of another, while striving to 
 seem free from the influence of all. 
 To Lord Durham the i)eople of Lower 
 Canada had been hostile. Lord Met- 
 clfe had been unpopular in Upper Can- 
 ada. Lord Elgin bad been stoned in 
 the streets of Montreal and egged in 
 the streets of Toronto. The House of 
 Parliament had been burned by the ex- 
 cited loyal mob of Montreal in revenge 
 for the passing of tbe Rebellion Losses 
 Bill. The country was a victim to par- 
 tisanship, and the strife of pa)Lies was 
 unceasing. 
 
 Mr. John Alexander Macdonald be- 
 longed to the moderate Conservative 
 party, which he was soon to lead. The 
 older Tories had passed or were passing 
 away. The last of them may be said to 
 have been Sir Allan MacNab, who was 
 Mr. Macdonald's leader at first, and who 
 was in a few years succeeded by his sub- 
 ordinate. 
 
 The questions which the leaders of 
 public opinion had now to face were of 
 two kinds : — 
 
 (1.) Those arising out of the con- 
 quest. 
 
 These questions had by no means dis- 
 
 VOL. Lxviii. — NO. 408. 34 
 
 a])pcarcd in 1S4 1. The Quebec act of 
 1774, which coMJcrrcd on the French 
 Canadian sultjccts of the crown tlie 
 rigiit to tho use of their own langtuige, 
 religion, and laws, had always excited 
 the hostility of a considerable section 
 of tho liritish population. The military 
 rule of the liritish, however just, — and 
 its justice was not witiiotit flaws, — was 
 necessarily objectioniible to the French 
 people. Hence alienation prevailed be- 
 tween the races, which lasted long, and 
 which is not yet wholly extinct, — an 
 occasional eruption reminding us of an- 
 cient explosions. This feeling rendered 
 the government of the country as a unit 
 very difficult ; and in 1791 it was di- 
 vided into two Provinces, each with a 
 legislature of its own, and each with its 
 own laws. Out of tins state of things 
 political questions of much local conse- 
 quence arose in both Provinces. In each 
 there was a political agitation, which 
 resulted in 1837 in a double rebellion, 
 which was not suppressed without blood, 
 and which left behind it bad passions 
 that remained long a source of disturb- 
 ance. In Lower Canada the old royal 
 grants of land to the seigneurs had in 
 course of time become oppressive and 
 unpopular among the tenants. In Ui)- 
 per Canada the reserves of land for the 
 clergy — claimed by the English Church, 
 and this claim denied by the nonconfor- 
 mist bodies — had proved a source of en- 
 during trouble. In addition, there arose 
 after 1837 the claims of those who had 
 sustained losses in the rebellion. All 
 these (questions must be decided in some 
 H'anner. 
 
 One after another they were dis- 
 posed of. The Rebellion Losses Bill 
 was passed in 1849 by a Liberal gov- 
 ernment. The old Conservatives and the 
 moderate men alike offered opposition to 
 this measure, under which, they claimed, 
 men who had been in rebellion would 
 be repaid for the loss arising from their 
 rebellious action. In 1849 Mr. Mac- 
 donald was under the leadership of Sir 
 
nso 
 
 77/r Ijiitv Sir John Jldcdunn/i/. 
 
 [October, 
 
 Allan RlacNalt, and he votod aj^ninst 
 tills hill as a CMiici-ssioii lo his lender. 
 it was one of the last cuncessiuns he 
 was to make to the rtiiiesenlatives of 
 the old order, in 18r)4 Mr. Maedonald 
 himself brought in the hill which seeu- 
 hirized the clergy reserves in Upper Can- 
 ada by dividing them amongst the muni- 
 cipalities, vested interests being respected 
 during the lifetime of uicumbents ; and 
 likewise tlie bill which abolished the 
 seigneurial tenures of Quebec, securing 
 fair compensation at the same time to 
 the proprietors. The skill with which 
 this latter question was handled has in- 
 duced numy of those who remember the 
 events to believe that Sir John Maedon- 
 ald was the one man in the liritish Em- 
 pire who could have solved the laud ques- 
 tion in Ireland. 
 
 (2.) The next difficulties to be over- 
 come were those arising out of the union 
 of 1841. 
 
 The conditions of politics were as fol- 
 lows : The governors did not relinquish 
 without a struggle the valuable patron- 
 age they had hitherto jjossessed. The 
 legislative council, or upper house, was 
 nommated by the governor, who made 
 the appointments from a very narrow 
 circle of Conservative public men, and 
 a clamor arose for the election of this 
 chamber hy the people. The population 
 of Upper Canada, owing to the influx 
 from the United States and to the bet- 
 ter character of the country for the 
 purposes of agriculture, increased more 
 rapidly than that of Lower Canada, and 
 the Liberal leaders of the larger popu- 
 lation demanded a larger representation 
 in Parliament. This question was dis- 
 cussed with constantly increasing bitter- 
 ness. The parties in the legislature were 
 represented in the cabinet according to 
 their provincial and racial character, and 
 it became, in spite of every form of 
 reasonable protest, a practice to require 
 a majority from each Province to carry 
 on a government " having the confidence 
 of the legislature." Fiscal qnestions did 
 
 not disturb the jteace of parties in those 
 da} s ; the ])olitical battle was fought on 
 constitutional grounds alone. 
 
 Mr. Maedonald was one of those who 
 in \Hr>C) votiil for the bill which made 
 the legislative <'ouncil an elective body ; 
 and it continued elective till 1807, when, 
 on the creation of the Seiuite, the fa- 
 thers of confederation returned, very 
 wisely in a country where there were 
 then and still are too many elections, 
 to the jnindple of nomination by the 
 crown for life. To the policy of repre- 
 sentation by population advocated by the 
 reform loaders Mr. Maedonald was oj)- 
 ])osed, because his Lower Canadian al- 
 lies were opjwsed to it, and because he 
 did not think that the gain in political 
 power arising from an increased rejjre- 
 sentation in Upper Canada would be 
 any compensation for the feeling of in- 
 security .and suspicion that would con- 
 tinually alarm Lower Canada, which, 
 having been forced into the union of 
 1841 against its consent and with a sus- 
 pended local constitution, was naturally 
 in a supersensitive mood. Moreover, 
 the ju'inciple of representation by ))op- 
 ulation as then advocated "ou'd have 
 perpetuated the provincial differences, 
 which it was the object of the union to 
 efface. Mr. JNIacdonald's opposition ex- 
 posed him to attack in his own Province 
 and weakened his political following, be- 
 cause he thereby incurred the reproach 
 of governing Upper Canada by means 
 of the support of the Lower Canadian 
 member's. A like accusation was made 
 against him when, after a period of ad- 
 herence by way of experiment, he aban- 
 doned the practice of having a majority 
 in each Province to support a govern- 
 ment. This also tended i-o perpetuate 
 provincial prejudices, and he abandoned 
 it in his endeavor to promote a substan- 
 tial union of the Provinces and a sub- 
 stantial unity in the legislative chamber. 
 
 Up to this time, then, it will be ob- 
 served by the reader wlio understands 
 the science of politics that Mr. Mac- 
 
 • « 
 
 y 
 
 
-^ 
 
 1891.] 
 
 77/ r /,tt(c sir ,/ohu Miivihmitlil. 
 
 681 
 
 a « 
 
 y 
 
 (lonaltli ullliou^'li a CoiiHOi-viitive, uc(|iii- 
 nHiMjil rlit'oitiiUy ill tlic piissiiij,' away 
 of practicuH and iiirstitutioim wliii^li had 
 served their purpose. He had aban- 
 doned the tiieories of the old-time C'oii- 
 Hervatives; ho had assisted in tiio cur- 
 
 I'hu <-uuses of the truuhluo thus ul- 
 huled to liy the {ruveriiur were iis fol- 
 lows : — 
 
 ()\\ May 'JU, 1801', the (government of 
 Maed(»iiald and Cartier (Conservative) 
 was di I'eated, l>y the defection of some 
 
 tailinent of the powers of the governors; of Cartier's Quebee following, on the 
 lie hud voted for tlie election of the militia bill; and the ministry resigned. 
 
 fegislative council ; he hail opposed re- 
 presentation by population; he had given 
 up the double majority ; he had forced 
 the Mettlemeiit of tlie clergy reserves 
 (piestiuii ; he had insisted on the u - 
 rangement of the seigneiirial tenure dis- 
 pute ; he resjiected the ])ast, l)ut lie also 
 respected the future. He was always 
 thinking of the next session, the next 
 election, the next generation, the next 
 phase of public opinion and publii; af- 
 fairs. That the driving-wheel of the 
 machinery of state makes large revolu- 
 tions he knew very well. He was not 
 impatient for it to come round again ; 
 but he knew it would come, and he 
 was always ready for the opportunity 
 it afforded. 
 
 In 18G4 began the movement which 
 ended in the confederation of the British 
 North American Provinces. Professor 
 Goldwin Smith, in reply to those who 
 make claim for this or that man that 
 he was •' the father of confederation," 
 invariably says, " No ; deadlock ivus the 
 father of co?ifederatio)i." And this in 
 what he means. 
 
 On the 16th of May, 1863, the Pavlia- 
 ment of Canada was dissolved by Lord 
 Monck, the reform party being in power. 
 At the close of the session of 1863, on 
 the 12th of May, the Governor-General, 
 in his speech dissolving the Parliament, 
 said in general terms : — 
 
 On May L'4 the Sandliehl r»Iac<lonald- 
 Sicotte ministry was sworn into otlice. 
 On May 8, 1863, in the succeeding ses- 
 sion. Mr. John A. Macdonald carried a 
 vote of want of contiilence in this new 
 ministry. The defeated ministers, acting 
 witiiin their right, advised the governor 
 to dissolve the house, and Parliaineiit 
 was dissolved accordingly on the 16th of 
 May, 1863, as above stated. 
 
 The elections were held in June, and 
 the Liberal government was sustained 
 by a very small majority. After a 
 sharj) ))arliamentaiy struggle, the new 
 Liberal governnient, finding its position 
 dithcult to maintain, and thinking to em- 
 barrass its opponents, resigned. When 
 two other men had declined the danger- 
 ous task of forming an administration, a 
 member of the upper house, .Sir Etienne 
 Tach^, undertook the forlorn hope and 
 formed the second Tache- Macdonald 
 administration. Consei'vative. This new 
 government was defeated, by a vote of 
 sixty to fifty-eight, an a test question ; 
 making the fourth ministry condemned 
 in four years. The Governor-General 
 gave his new and defeated ministers 
 power to dissolve once more, a most 
 troublesome and financially ruinous pro- 
 cess, though i)erfectly regular and con- 
 stitutional ; but this time the dissolution 
 did not take place. 
 
 At this critical point, when parties 
 
 (1.) That it was not possible to con- were so nicely balanced that neither 
 duct the public business in a satisfactory could form a stable administration, Mr. 
 
 manner under existing circumstances. 
 
 (2.) That two successive administra- 
 tions had failed to obtain the confidence 
 of the legislature. 
 
 (3.) That these facts had made a dis- 
 solution necessary. 
 
 George Brown, the reform leader, who 
 was a sincere and able advocate of a 
 union of all the British North American 
 Provinces, gave it to be understood, by 
 means of a communication to the late 
 Hon. Alexander Morris, that he was not 
 
532 
 
 Thv Late Sir John Mnnhniiiht. 
 
 f()(t,(»l>lM% 
 
 iiiiwilliii^' to coitiiorate witli thu Cuimur- ntiitVilcratioii wiin foniuMi iiiul ^ovoriu>il 
 
 vali\e iniiii^lcrM in a coalilioii niiiiixliv, at iirrtt !i_v a iinioii nl' |iarti(>N. 
 lor till! |>iir|H)sc ol' jrL'Uiiij; rid t»l tiii' diis- Tin' atltlri'ss which, at ihi' chiNo of his 
 
 tui'hin^r coiistitutioniil (ititMtioiiH, uiul ut' forlieth yuar in pulilic litu, wuh |)ri'Hi>iit- 
 
 foi'initi;^ a t't'dcral union of I lie I'ldviiiccH. 
 ThuM thi' (h'adlock lu'twi'i-n tiio two jiai' 
 tit'H hi()ii^;lit. about the Lihi-ral-C'onMiiva- 
 tive alliancf which t'ui-iiioil thu Dumiuion 
 of Cana(hi. 
 
 Hut till! Canadian "duadlock" would 
 iitivur have produced confodemtion had 
 not otht"- causes contiihulcd materially 
 to that result, 'i'hc! lower Provinces were 
 ctonsideriiifT a union amon^ themselves 
 
 ed to Sir ilohn Macdoiiald in 'I'oronto, 
 in hSK'l, contains tht^ following pura- 
 jjraphs : — 
 
 "The luiiipy results of Hritisli ride in 
 North America, lie^un when the jiolic/ 
 of I'itt was a('com|ilished liy the valor 
 of Wolfe, would have been iniiierfect, if 
 not frustrated, liut for the cordial rela- 
 tions wliich you have for nearly half a 
 century maintained, in spite of unjust 
 
 on lines which lia<l been laid down in and unpatriotic criticism, willi tliu loyal 
 
 an indetinite way for half a contiiry. men of j^enius who luivc bet'u the chiefs 
 
 This was one contributinj^ cause. 'J'iien of the loyal Canadians of (.Quebec; and 
 
 the rccij)rocity treaty with the United on this occasion we would minj^lo with 
 
 States was about to be abolished. That 
 was clear from the expressions of opin- 
 ion in the United States, and the ne- 
 cessity for more interprovincial trade 
 bec;an to be foreseen. The Fenian inva- 
 sion of liStiO ffave. later on, a new im- 
 petus to the efforts of the fathers of the 
 confederation. The need for a larger 
 revenue, for more and more perfect pub- 
 
 our feli(Mtations to yourself a tribute of 
 grateful remembrance of Cartier, whoso 
 statue rises in another city to bear wit- 
 ness to his ])ublic deeds and to keep his 
 menu)ry green. 
 
 " The hopes of imperial and the i)ol- 
 icy of Canadian statesmen to found u 
 strong and lasting confederation of the 
 British North American Provinces might 
 
 lie works and railways, and for a more have been prevented from early accom- 
 
 uniforni trade jmlicy was ai)i)arent; and plishment but for your unselhsh conduct, 
 
 the wisdom of erecting a lasting bul- your generous recognition of the sincer- 
 
 wark of British power on this continent ity of political opponents, your willing- 
 
 was clear to all Canadian public men. ness to admit to your counsels men of 
 
 What was wanted at this i)oint was a genius and skill when the service of 
 
 man who could take in hand the varied the nation was paramount to the service 
 
 groujjs of political forces, unite them, of party. And history will recall with 
 
 mould them, inspire them, and give them impartial admiration your agreement in 
 
 confidence in themselves and in the fu- policy and your continuance in friend- 
 
 ture of the country. Such a man was shij) with Brown and Howe, with Hincks 
 
 found in Mr. John A. Macdonald, who, and McGee, rein-esenting phases of opin- 
 
 on the first day of July, 1867, became ion which, with the quick sympathy of 
 
 Premier of the Dominion, and who now, genius, you conciliated, at a time of cri- 
 
 by the favor of the Queen, became Sir sis, to the service of the state." 
 John Macdonald. He had at his dis- In substance these are the merits 
 
 posal at this time the leading men of which his friends claimed for Sir John 
 
 hoth sides of ])olitics ; for although Mr. Mecdonald ; and on the occasion in ques- 
 
 Brown, who had taken the first step tion, in the course of a long review of 
 
 towards the coalition of parties, had his public career, he took these i)ara- 
 
 withdrawn from the ministry in a short graphs for his text, and accepted and 
 
 time, he was unable to check the move- detailed the views ex])ressed in them, 
 ment in the other Provinces, and the The tasks which Sir John Macdonald 
 
IHJH.] 
 
 Thf Lntr Sir tfohti MnvihumUl. 
 
 633 
 
 ' m\ 
 
 ' m\ 
 
 Bi>(l Sir OeorKo Carticr and their ool- 
 len^fiiuH of tlio Liberul-CoiiNervnlivo gov- 
 erninunt lta<l beforu tlioin lU tlio ostah- 
 liHlitnunt of tliu Doiiiinioii of Caimda in 
 1K67 were no Hmall oiieH, notwillistaiul- 
 \\\^ tlio Hti'fain of tcixli'Dcy wliicii iiiado 
 for NiiccoHM and tlio iiu-ii of cxpuritMicu 
 tlivy liad in tlioir party. In tliu ttiHt 
 place, tliiTo was HiM-iouM disoontont in 
 Nova Scotia with tho financial terms on 
 which that Province had heen induced 
 to enter the union. This wa8 remedied 
 in 18r>l) hy an act jjrantinjr a larjjer 
 gnhsidy, and hy the settlement of some 
 minor (|iieHtion8 relating to pnhlic works. 
 In the next place, there was an ohviouH 
 geographical incompleteness in the Do- 
 minion. This was amended with some de- 
 gree of enterprise. The Northwest Ter- 
 ritory was obtained l>v purchase from 
 tlu) Hudson Bay Company in 1870, and 
 out of this territory the Province of 
 l^fanitoba was created in the same year. 
 In 1871 British Columbia entered the 
 union. In 1873 Prince Kdward Island 
 was added. Finally, in 1880, the popu- 
 lation of the Northwest Territory having 
 rapidly increased, a species of represen- 
 tative government was conferred on this 
 region ; a representative act was passed, 
 a governor was appointed, and the toan- 
 dation of a regular provincial consti- 
 tution established. Four districts have 
 been outlined, namely, Assiniboia, Al- 
 berta, Saskatchewan, and Athabasca; 
 three of which already send members 
 to the House of Commons, and all of 
 which will at no distant day form new 
 Provinces of the Dominion. 
 
 The geographical (piestion having been 
 settled, there remained the fact that the 
 means of interprovincial communication 
 within Canadian territory were very im- 
 perfect. From the East men came to 
 Ottawa by way of Boston. From the 
 West they came by way of San Fran- 
 cisco and Chicago. In sunmier the St. 
 LawTence aff»)rded communication with 
 the ocean. In winter our ocean port was 
 Portland, wliich the fitness of things 
 
 Imd decreed to belorig to Canada, though 
 Lord Ashliurton was not awaro of it, 
 and Daniel Webster confessed that ho 
 did not remind him of it. 'I'he govern- 
 ment of Sir John iMacdonahl undertook 
 to supply the means of communication. 
 The Intercolonial Railway, the first link 
 of which ha*l been begun by the Provincu 
 of Nova Scotia, was comi)leted in 1871, 
 and has been ma<le more useful still by 
 the aciiuisition of portions of the Grand 
 Trunk. Kxtensions of the system in 
 Capo Breton and «'lsewhere in Nova Sco- 
 tia have sin(^e addinl to the usefulness of 
 this line, though the fact of increased 
 conuiinnication must i»e ofVset by the fact, 
 of prol)able yearly deficits. 
 
 The bargain with the East having 
 been thus liberally fidfilled, the bargain 
 with the West, requiring the construc- 
 tion of the Pacific Railway, remained 
 to bo completed. This work was un- 
 dertaken in 1872. The next year Sir 
 John Rlacdonald fell from power, and 
 remained out of office for nearly five 
 years, in consequence of the revelations 
 made concerning the subscriptions paid 
 for political purposes by the promoters 
 of the railway ; but the Liberal gov- 
 ernment which took the place of the de- 
 feated administration went on with the 
 work, if not on the lines of Sir John 
 Macdonald's policy, at least on the lines 
 which commended themselves to the prac- 
 tical men of the Liberal party ; and the 
 value of the work done was acknowledged 
 by Sir John JMacdonald's minister of rail- 
 ways when, in 1878, the Conservatives 
 were returned to power. The work was 
 begun by the new company organized 
 in 1881, and was finished in 1886 ; an 
 exhibition of vigorous railway manage- 
 ment unsurpassed in the history of rail- 
 ways. But the government which un- 
 dertook to aid th i^ompany in this 
 gigantic task took its life in its hand 
 every session till the work was complet- 
 ed : for the vastness of the undertak- 
 ing alarmed the parliamentary support- 
 ers of the government, the most of 
 
534 
 
 The Late Sir John Macdoiudd. 
 
 [October, 
 
 whom were not in the liabit of thinking 
 in lax^b figures or of looking forward 
 to future ge aerations. 
 
 One other giert work had to be done 
 if the confederation of i.}\e Provinces 
 was no*^ to be a failure. 1'his was, to 
 diversify industry, to encourage manu- 
 factures, to develoi) the natural resources 
 of the country. The necessity for this 
 was pressing, for this reason. Before the 
 foundation of the Dominion there were, as 
 has been said, very imperfect means of 
 communication, and trade had not flour- 
 ished between the Provinces. The reci- 
 procity treaty of 1854, which made the 
 American markets free to Canadian pro- 
 ducts of certain kinds, and Canadian 
 markets free on equal terms to Amer- 
 ican products, had checked the develoj)- 
 ment of a varied industry in Canada. 
 The abrogation of the treaty found Can- 
 ada without political unity, without inter- 
 communication, with few manufactures, 
 and without an established foreign mar- 
 ket. Circumstances rendered the post- 
 ponement of this question of trade less 
 disastrous than it might have been. The 
 continuance of high prices in the United 
 States btiore the resumption of specie 
 payment enabled Canada for some years 
 to cany on a fairly satisfactory trade 
 with the republic, in sj)ite of the loss of 
 the free market. But this state of thi'^ ;S 
 changed about 1876. Prices went down 
 in the United States. The manufactur- 
 ers of that country became active and 
 enf u'prising, particularly in seeking for 
 their surplus a market in Canada. Agri- 
 cultural products were enormously mul- 
 tiplied. And therefoi _ the manufactur- 
 ers, farmers, and niineis of Canada be- 
 gan to feel the stress of this competition, 
 espcijiaiiy as the Canadian tariff of only 
 about fifteen per cent was opposed to the 
 American tariff of about sixty. 
 
 Sir John Macdonald, in 1876, was out 
 of power, but he and his colleagues in 
 opposition saw an opening for a promis- 
 ing political camjjaign. It has been 
 generally said that Sir John Macdon- 
 
 ald was always a free trader at heart. 
 This is not so, for in 1860 he had ad- 
 vocated fiscal changes on the ground 
 that they would afford protection to the 
 labor of Canada. His chief colleague 
 in the framing of his policy. Sir Leonard 
 Tilley, had also as early as 1852 been 
 a protectionist. They were consistent 
 enough, thereforf^, in advocating protec- 
 tion in 3876, 1877, and 1878, when, af- 
 ter one of the most exciting of all his 
 campaigns. Sir John Macdonald was re- 
 turned to power, on a promise to promote 
 by means of protection the agricultural, 
 mining, and manufacturing industries of 
 Canada. This policy was duly carried 
 out in the tariff act of 1879, on the lines 
 laid down in 1877 and 1S78 ; and was 
 sustained at the polls at the subsequent 
 general elections of 1882, 1887, and 
 1891. In this last election of 1891 there 
 was mingled, indeed, the element of a 
 promise to ncf^otiate, on certain restrict- 
 ed lines, for a renewal of reciprocal 
 trade relations with the I'nited States ; 
 but in the main the battle was fought 
 on the grounds of the old policy of pro- 
 tection, under the old flii<4 and the old 
 leader. That this policy was maintained 
 without mistakes and n 'scalculations, 
 without protests and opijosition of the 
 strongest kind, no one can assert, but 
 the government remained firm. In this 
 election there was certainly a revolt in 
 the Province of Ontario against protec- 
 tion, and in favor of perfect free trade 
 with the United States. The knowledge 
 of that revolt and the anxiety attendant 
 on it im])elled Sir Jolm Macdonald, dur- 
 ing a most inclement and dangerous sea- 
 son, to make such efforts in addressing 
 the constituencies as in his feeble state 
 of health he was unable to endure ; his 
 death was no doubt hastened by these 
 exertions. Before he died, however, he 
 knew that he had given strength for an- 
 other parliamentary term to the trade 
 policy he was pledged to maintain. 
 
 Some questions, indeed, he left unset- 
 tled ; among these is one which caused 
 
hor. 
 
 1891.] 
 
 The. Late Sir Join 3frtcdotinfd. 
 
 635 
 
 /t 
 
 him at all times the most serious anx- 
 iety, since it is one wliich hrs always 
 been a source of danger to British North 
 American unity. It is the growth of an 
 aggressive provincialism. Tlie union of 
 1841 was effected for the purpose of 
 putting an end to this provincial feeling, 
 with which were mingled racial and re- 
 ligious prejudices. But the very means 
 adopted to put an end to tlie evil "'ere 
 the cause, a." ro often happens in politics, 
 of its perpetuation and growth. The 
 representation of both Provinces — nay, 
 even the representation of geographical 
 sections of the same Province — in the 
 cabinet; the establisimient for a con'=id- 
 erable period of tlie double-majority prac- 
 tice ; the development of the agitation 
 for representation by population, — all 
 these things tended inentably to per- 
 petuate provincialism, and render unity 
 quite out of the question. These ten- 
 dencies were intensified by the mainte- 
 nance — the necessary and proper main- 
 iCnance, under the faith and guarantee 
 of tceaties entered into between Great 
 Britain and France — of a separate set 
 of laws and institutions and another lan- 
 guage in the Province of Quebec. The 
 establishment of the Dominion of Can- 
 ada, with added territory, a larger con- 
 stitution, a fuller measure of freedom 
 in self-government, would, it was hoped, 
 have a tendency to suppress provincial- 
 ism ; but provincialism has become more 
 powerful, more aggressive, than ever. 
 And now that death has removed the 
 one man whose great reputation and 
 whose incalculable personal influence 
 could add overwhelming force to his ap- 
 peals to national sentiment, the danger 
 arising from the aggressive character of 
 the Provinces becomes serious. Provin- 
 cial representation in the cabinet, provin- 
 cial representation ii- the public service, 
 provincial apportionment of the expen- 
 diture, provincial gi'ievances regarding 
 railways and public works, provincial 
 attacks on the stability of the federal 
 ministry, provincial demands for the abo- 
 
 lition of the veto power, provincial in- 
 terests in the arrangement of the tariff, 
 — these are some of the characteristic 
 dangers which menace the maintenance 
 of what was intended by the fathers of 
 the confederation to be a strong central 
 government. But it is the business of 
 statesmen to overcome difficulties ; and 
 the death of Sir John Macdonald leaves 
 us still with men of the first rank, capa- 
 ble, it may be hoped, of carrying out his 
 policy and completing his work. 
 
 At this point we may abandon for a 
 time the direct line of development of 
 Canadian history to examine briefly Sir 
 John Macdonald's attitude towards Great 
 Britain and towards the United States. 
 
 Great Britain, or, one mav say, the 
 Queen, never had a more loyal subject. 
 In these days when personal devotion 
 to the crown, to a constitution, even to a 
 country, has become merely a charming 
 legend to some, a cause of scorn and 
 mockery to others, the chivalric devo- 
 tion of Sir John Macdonald to the honor 
 and interests of the empire and the 
 Queen is most interesting. But at the 
 same time he was modern in his views 
 respecting the needs, interests, and policy 
 of all colonies. He was conservative of 
 the power of the crown, but he never 
 allowed the representative of the crown 
 in Canada to ^^ct against the advice of 
 his responsible ministers ; and when Lord 
 Lome, in discussing the Lettellier case 
 in 1878-79, exerted some personal influ- 
 ence against his ministers, and hesitated 
 about following their advice. Sir John 
 Macdonald prepared a minute which 
 was accepted by the colonial office as 
 true constitutional doctrine, and which 
 made it impossible thereafter for any 
 governor of a colony to refuse to follow 
 the advice of ministers who are guiltless 
 of political high crimes, who have an 
 ascertained majority in the legislature, 
 or who are willing to go to the country 
 on the advice which they have tendered 
 to the crown. Having thus maintained 
 the position of responsible ministers 
 
53G 
 
 The. Late Sir John Macdonald. 
 
 [October, 
 
 k t 
 
 against the action of the direct repre- 
 sentative of th ) crown, Sir John Mac- 
 donald went further, and in the same 
 case caused the disniissal of the repre- 
 sentative of th • representative of the 
 crown, that is the lieutenant-governor of 
 Quehec, for acting in a partisan man- 
 ner, contrary to the advice of his pro- 
 vincial ministers. Again, Sir John Mac- 
 donald was devoted to imperial interests ; 
 hut he forced the hands of British min- 
 isters to protect thi; Canadian ilsheries 
 when they were not disposed to be very 
 active ; he made it a part of necessary 
 policy that no treaty affecting Canada, 
 or indeed auy colony possessing respon- 
 sible government, shall be finally nego- 
 tiated Avithout reserving the assent of the 
 colony to the arrangement : and above 
 all, he made it a necessary part of 
 imperial policy that in all negotiations 
 concerning Canada this country shall 
 be represented in the negotiating body. 
 And at the ti'ne of his death it had been 
 made, to all intents and i)urposes. a fur- 
 ther pai't of imperial policy that none 
 of the British colonies of America shall 
 be permit' ad to make separate trade 
 arrangements affecting in any way the 
 interests of Canada without the consent 
 of this country. 
 
 Respecting the great question of im- 
 perial federation now attracting so much 
 attention and challenging so much criti- 
 cism, the at*' rude of Sir John Macdon- 
 ald was not jironounced ; it w.ts an at- 
 titude of friendly encouragement and 
 attentive consideration. The subject was 
 not a new one to him. In 1861, at Que- 
 bec, in discussing the question of repre- 
 sentation, he had said : " We are fast 
 ceasing to be a dependency, and assuming 
 the position of an ally of Great Brii.^.n. 
 England would be the centre, surround- 
 ed and sustained by an alliance not only 
 with Canada, but Australia and all her 
 other possessions : and there would tluu 
 be formed an innnense confederation or 
 freemen, — the greatest confederacy of 
 civilized and intelligent men that ever 
 
 had an existence on the face of the 
 globe." In 1885 he was quite as em- 
 })hatic. With regard to imperial fed- 
 ei-ation, he agreed that there nmst be 
 something of the kind, and that, as the 
 auxiliary nations of Canada, Australia, 
 and South Africa increased in wealth 
 and population, they must be willing to 
 accept increased responsibility. Speak- 
 ing on behalf of Canada, he declared that 
 she was willing, and tlnvt she would be 
 prepared, to join the mother country in 
 an offensive and defensive league for 
 the maintenance of the empire and flag 
 of Great Britain. It has been asked 
 why Canada should mix herself uj) with 
 the conflict of nations. Her answer was, 
 that blood was thicker than water, and 
 that her people were Englishmen, Scotch- 
 men, and Irishmen, far removed from 
 the centre, it might be, but still cl nging 
 to the mother country. He was by no 
 means rashly committed to ariy paiiic- 
 nlar scheme of union ; but there are the 
 strongest reasons for believing tliat, had 
 he lived. Sir John Macdonald would 
 jiave been fouml upon the side of thosii 
 who tbivk that the trade of the British 
 Empire needc guarding, consolidatiuf;, 
 and extending under a systeir of gen- 
 eral imperial policy which would j.vovide 
 for its ijrotection. It may also ' /C said 
 on authority that, had Lord Bea' orisfieid 
 lived, ho ami Sir John Macdonald would 
 liave been jointly engaged in populathig 
 and developing the northwest of Can- 
 ada, and in promoting the inrperial rse- 
 f alness of the Intercolonial and Canadian 
 Pacific railways. The policy was be- 
 gun in 1879 or 1880 ; for, after a visit 
 which Sir Jolm Macdonald paid to 
 Hiighenden, Lord Beaconsfield made, at 
 Bucks, the first of what he intended 'm 
 be a series of speeches advocating the 
 encouragement of emigration from the 
 United Kingdom into the " illimitable 
 prairies " of the Canadian Northwest. 
 
 In regard to the United States there 
 were only two great questions which 
 caused Sir John Macdonald to lip o any 
 
 '. ♦ 
 
 » « 
 
k t 
 
 1891.] 
 
 The Late *Sir r/o/in Mucdomihl, 
 
 537 
 
 </ 
 
 / 
 
 1 •* 
 
 » « 
 
 » * 
 
 policy at all ; and these were, the trade 
 question and tlie fislieries question. Sir 
 John Macdonald's attitude had always 
 been conciliatory in discussing the former. 
 He was the ablest member of the gov- 
 ernment which accepted and ratified the 
 treaty of 1854, negotiated at Washington 
 by Lord Elgin and Sir Francis Hincks. 
 It was Sir John jNIacdonald who set on 
 foot all but one of the attempts which were 
 nuvde to effect a renewal of that treaty 
 when, in 38GG, it was abrogated in what 
 must now be considered a fit of un- 
 warranted petulance at wliat was mis- 
 takenly called the unfriendly character 
 of Canadian action in the civil war. In 
 1865, when notice of abrogation had been 
 given, a deputation was sent from the 
 various Provinces to have the treaty re- 
 newed, if possible. In 18<)8 tlie first cus- 
 toms act of Canada contained a clause 
 offering reciprocal trade whenever the 
 United States was willing. In 1869 an- 
 other attempt at negotiation was made, 
 but owing to the continuance of un- 
 frie;idly feeling in Congress the attempt 
 utterly failed. In 1871, when the Wash- 
 ington treaty was being arranged, pro- 
 posals for a renewal of the treaty of 
 1854 were made by Sir John Mac- 
 donald ; but he was answered that it 
 was impracticable ; it " would not be in 
 accordance with the views of the people 
 of the United States." In 1872 Sir 
 John Macdonald's government, in reply 
 to resolutions of the Dominion Board of 
 Trade, based on resolutions of the Na- 
 tional Board of Trade of the United 
 States, stated again its perfect willingness 
 to enter on negotiations for reciprocity. 
 In 1 874 Mr. George Brown and Sir Ed- 
 ward Thornton arranged for a treaty, but 
 the Senate would not even discuss it. 
 In 1879, when the new national policy 
 was adopted, the customs act again con- 
 tained a clause making reciprocity in 
 certain natural products dependent on 
 the willingness of the United States. 
 In 1887, when the fislicry treaty was un- 
 der discussion, a new attempt was made 
 
 by the Canadian officials to .arrange for 
 reciprocal trade relations ; but this at- 
 tempt was also in vain. Finally, in 
 April, 1891, a proposition was made, 
 llie terms .and conditions of which are 
 mjitter of dispute as yet, for a meeting 
 at Waslnngton to discuss the trade rela- 
 tions of Canada and the United St.ates. 
 Sir John Macdonald did not live to take 
 more than the initiative step in the nego- 
 tiation, but it may be positively stated 
 that he h.ad the utmost confidence in 
 some friendly arrangement which would 
 remove all causes of dispute between 
 these two countries. 
 
 The friendly policy which Sir John 
 Macdonald pursued in relation to trade 
 matters he vas not unwilling to pursue 
 in regard tc the fisheries. That had 
 always been, and continues still to be. 
 an affair with which the ministeij from 
 the Maritime Provinces have most to 
 do. But Sir John Macdon.ald never for 
 a moment wavered in his determination 
 that the historical view of British and 
 Canadian interests in the fisheries should 
 be maint.ained, and th.at the prime pos- 
 tulates of international law regarding 
 tlie territorial rights of nations over the 
 waters surrounding their coasts should 
 be enforced. Yet he was ready at all 
 times to negotiate for the free use of 
 those fisheries and for the suspension 
 of the rules of law on terms of friendly 
 reciprocity. He had no hostility to the 
 United States ; he was hostile only to 
 certain phases of American policy and 
 certain moods of American opinion which 
 threatened the interests or the allegiance 
 of Canadians ; and to these he was de- 
 terminedly opposed. No citizen of the 
 United States who has studied the history 
 of the two countries can fail to see L^iat 
 a Canadian may reasonably entertain 
 doubts upon the subject of the friend- 
 liness and fair play extended to Canada 
 by the republic. It does not require ex- 
 treme sensitiveness to believe that in 1837 
 some encouragement was given to the 
 rebels along the border ; that in 1866 
 
538 
 
 The Late Sir John Macdonald. 
 
 [October, 
 
 the Fenian invasion was allowed to ripen 
 in perfect security till it burst, however 
 feebly, on Canadian borders ; that no 
 respect has ever been paid to the ter- 
 ritorial rights of Canada on the waters 
 along our coasts ; and it is a matter of 
 record that an unfriendly and threaten- 
 ing resolution was passed in 1807 in the 
 House of Representatives when the Do- 
 minion of Canada was founded. These 
 facts will suffice to justify a reasonable 
 amount of caution and reserve on the 
 part of a statesman who had had half a 
 century's experience of these unpleasing 
 and disturbing affairs. 
 
 In conclusion, one may briefly touch 
 on that most interesting yet most diffi- 
 cult subject, the personal ch.-vracter of Sir 
 John Macdoniild. Probably no man on 
 this continent was more familiar to the 
 people than was Sir John INIaodonald. 
 His picture, whether in caricature or 
 otherwise, had become the possession of 
 the whole country, and no one in Canada 
 could meet him in any place, even in the 
 remotest backwoods, without knowing 
 that he was Sir John Macdonald. He 
 knew personally a surprising number of 
 people, and stories are often told of his 
 memory for faces he had not seen for 
 forty years, and had then only encoun- 
 tered at a political meeting. He had 
 addressed at various times almost every 
 constituency in Canada, east and west, 
 and no man within driving distance 
 would miss the opportunity of hearing 
 "John A." 
 
 He was delightfully convivial in pri- 
 vate life, and for more than forty years 
 had mingled socially on familial' terms 
 with his followers. It cannot be said 
 that since 1867, however, he had made 
 any attempt to be on familiar terms 
 with his opponents. Political feeling 
 and personal feeling ran very high at 
 times ; and though he never said any- 
 thing on the subject, it was j)lain that, 
 as a general rule, he preferred to main- 
 tain an attitude of reserve with the ma- 
 jority of his opponents. Occasion.ally 
 
 this was to be regretted ; but he had 
 his own reasons, which were respected, 
 for his conduct, and he did not enforce 
 his example on his colleagues. His con- 
 versation was marvelously variable, run- 
 ning from the gravest to the gayest sub- 
 jects with the ease of a man who " ran 
 through each mode of the lyre, and 
 was master of all." He was full of 
 anecdotes, and used them freely in con- 
 versation and in his speeches. In the 
 natun of things, some of these stories 
 got old like himself ; but we were al- 
 w.ays quite ready to laugh at " the grouse 
 in the gun-room." for the sake of the old 
 chief and the old times when we heard 
 it first. 
 
 But there was one subject above all 
 others that he loved to talk of. and that 
 was the political iiistory and literature 
 of the eighteenth century in England. 
 On that subject he knew, doubtless, as 
 much as any man living. Lord Beacons- 
 field, who was also a devotee of that 
 splendid literature, was delighted with 
 Sir John Macdonald's laste in this re- 
 spect ; and in conversation told him, 
 apropos of his familiarity with the pre- 
 miers, that probnbly there was no man 
 in England, except Spencer Walpole, 
 who was writing a book on the subject, 
 who could repeat without mistake the 
 names of all the premiers since Pitt. 
 Sir John Macdonald could do that and 
 much more. There was no volume of 
 political memoirs oi that century which 
 he had not read. All his leisure was 
 passed in reading, for he was not a de- 
 votee of exercise, und seemed seldom to 
 need it. He liked to read and to talk 
 of books with men who loved them. All 
 kinds of books were welcome to him. 
 He frequently read novels, and enjoyed 
 Howells, Black, Hardy, Blackmore, and 
 Besant. He had a keen liking for po- 
 etry, especially ballad poetry, and all po- 
 litical poetry was familiar^to him. A 
 quotation from the Ant' Jacobin could 
 not pass his ear without recognition ; 
 a line from the Noctes Ambrosianse 
 
4 
 
 1891.] 
 
 would quicken his attention at once, and 
 he would give the following line. 
 
 It is very difficult to describe his ora- 
 tory. He was a master of all the arts 
 of public speaking except that of being 
 eloquent, if in these days this is an art 
 of any value. He debated with great 
 skill ; and he preferred brief speeches, 
 though he could, and occasionally did, 
 speak for hours at a time. His man- 
 ner was at times hesitating, but not from 
 want of matter, for he never rushed into 
 a debate without preparation, and he 
 knew always how to obtain accurate facts 
 at the shortest notice ; in this respect 
 his otRcers and secretaries served him 
 with conspicuous fidelity. He could be 
 humorous ; he could be pathetic ; he 
 could make dignified and touching ap- 
 peals to loyalty to the crown, to the 
 party, to himself. Before a crowd on 
 the hustings he was unrivaled in the 
 deadly dexterity of his criticism, his 
 humor, his appeals to popular interests. 
 It was, of course, in the House of Com- 
 mons that he was always at his best ; 
 and his respect for the traditions of the 
 house, the rules of the house, the kind of 
 conduct most likely to touch and please 
 and lead the house, was almost inspired. 
 
 He succeeded in keeping together for 
 a quarter of a century a political party 
 singularly composed of English, French, 
 Irish, Scotch, of Catholics and Protef 
 tants, of Orangemen and Home Rulers, 
 of old family-compact Tories and sharp 
 democratic labor agitators : and all these 
 men had mingled during his life on 
 terms of such friendly fidelity to the 
 Old Man that it will be some time be- 
 fore they remember that they have seri- 
 ous differences of opinion ; the habit of 
 
 The Late Sir John Macdoixild. 
 
 539 
 
 acting together will remain with them 
 for some years, at least. The clergy 
 were largely on his side, and he had a 
 strong party among what may be called 
 the academic classes. The reason for 
 this adherence to him of the clergy and 
 the professors was probably to be found 
 in the fact that in all things religious 
 he was known to be a sound thinker ; 
 he had no tolerance for the " scientific " 
 view of man's destiny and origin ; the 
 agnostic spirit of the age did not touch 
 him. This " orthodox " habit of mind 
 and the well-known taste he exhibited 
 for an intellectual life and for historical 
 and literary studies gave him a com- 
 mand of the clerical and academic forces 
 which added much to his strength. 
 
 The loss of Sir John Macdonald leaves 
 his party weaker and his countiy more 
 or less in doubt about the immediate po- 
 litical future. But other men will fol- 
 low in his footsteps, and indeed other 
 men are carrying on liis policy and per- 
 fecting his measures, witli what success 
 we shall not know till the next general 
 election. The old chief had faults ; he 
 often admitted them ; but it is not yet 
 time to count them over. He made mis- 
 takes; these he also would refer to, 
 though, like other men, he naturally pre- 
 ferred to have them regarded as strokes 
 of genius ; but we need not dwell upon 
 them now, — ic is so short a time since 
 his hand on the shouldor, his touch on 
 the palm, could thrill the feudal blood 
 of his followers with somewhat of the 
 tribal loj.ilty of the Higlilands; and in 
 this discussion of his career perhaps the 
 reader will pardon the impossibility of 
 writing without the sense of his presence 
 and of the sound of his voice. 
 
 Martin J. Griffin.