.^> 
 
 ^'fc^ 
 
 "> 
 
 ■. %^ 
 
 , •3*' 
 
 
 ^s > 
 
 IMAGE EVALUATION 
 TEST TARGET (MT-3) 
 
 1.0 
 
 I.I 
 
 1.25 
 
 • ■ iBi^ 2.2 
 
 :r «i 1112.0 
 
 1.4 
 
 1^ 
 1.6 
 
 v] 
 
 <p 
 
 /^ 
 
 '» 
 
 ^, "'^ 
 
 ■^■^ 
 
 <$> 
 
 
 
 c> 
 
 % 
 
 / 
 
 Xl^ 
 
 ^>^ 
 
 T^ 
 
 Photographic 
 
 Sciences 
 Corporation 
 
 23 WEST MAIN STREET 
 
 WEBSiER.N.Y. 14580 
 
 (716) 872-45' J 
 
 iV 
 
 ^\^ 
 
 CV^ 
 
 -b 
 
 ^ 
 
 :\ 
 
 \ 
 
 6^ 
 
 % 
 
 A? 
 
 ^.m."^ 
 
 a^ 
 

 CIHM/ICMH 
 
 Microfiche 
 
 Series. 
 
 CIHM/iCMH 
 Collection de 
 microfiches. 
 
 Canadian Institute for Histoiical Microreproductions / Institut canadien de microreproductlons historiques 
 
Technical and Bibliographic Notes/Notes techniques et bibMographiques 
 
 The Institute has attempted tc obtain the best 
 original copy available for filming. Features of this 
 copy which may be bibliographically unique, 
 which may alter any of the images in the 
 reproduction, or which may significantly change 
 the usual method of filming, are checked below. 
 
 L'Institut a microfilm^ le meilleur exemplaire 
 qu'il lui a 6t6 pofsible de se procurer. Les details 
 de cet exemplaire qui sont peut-dtre uniques du 
 point de vue bibliographique, qui peuvent modifier 
 une image reproduite, ou qui peuvent exiger une 
 modification dans la m^thode normale de filmage 
 sont indiquds ci-dessous. 
 
 
 
 Coloured covers/ 
 Couverture de couleur 
 
 I I Covers damaged/ 
 
 n 
 
 D 
 D 
 D 
 D 
 
 D 
 
 Couverture endommagde 
 
 Covers restored and/or laminated/ 
 Couverture restaur6e et/ou pellicul6e 
 
 I I Cover title missing/ 
 
 Le titre de couverture manque 
 
 □ Coloured maps/ 
 Cartes gdographiques en couleur 
 
 Coloured ink (i.e. other than blue or black)/ 
 Encre de couleur (i.e. autre que bleue ou noire) 
 
 Coloui3d plates and/or illustrations/ 
 Planches et/ou illustrations en couleur 
 
 Bound with other material/ 
 Relid avec d'autres documents 
 
 Tight binding may cause shadows or distortion 
 along interior margin/ 
 
 La reliure serr^e peut causer de I'ombre ou de la 
 distortion le long de la marge int6rieure 
 
 Blank leaves added during restoration may 
 appear within the text. Whenever possible, these 
 have been omitted from filming/ 
 II se peut que certaines pages blanches ajoutdes 
 lors d'une restauration apparaissent dans le texte, 
 mais, lorsque cela dtait possible, ces pages n'ont 
 pas 6X6 filmdes. 
 
 □ 
 
 D 
 
 D 
 
 E 
 1 
 
 n 
 
 n 
 
 n 
 
 Coloured pages/ 
 Pages de couleur 
 
 Pages damaged/ 
 Pages endommagdes 
 
 Pages restored and/or laminated/ 
 Pages restaur^es et/ou pelliculdes 
 
 Pages discoloured, stained or foxed/ 
 Pages ddcolordes, tachetdes ou piqudes 
 
 Pages detached/ 
 Pages d^tach^es 
 
 Showthrough/ 
 Transparence 
 
 Quality of print varies/ 
 Qualiti in^gale de I'impression 
 
 Includes supplementary material/ 
 Comprend du materiel supplementaire 
 
 Only edition available/ 
 Seule Edition disponible 
 
 Pages wholly or partially obscured by errata 
 slips, tissues, etc., have been refilmed to 
 ensure the best possible image/ 
 Les pages totalement ou partielSement 
 obscLTcies par un feuillet d'errata, une pelure, 
 etc., ont dtd film^es 6 nouveau de fapon d 
 obtenir la meilleure image possible. 
 
 D 
 
 Additional comnents:/ 
 Commentaires suppldmentaires: 
 
 This item is filmed at the reduction ratio checked below/ 
 
 Ce document est film6 au taux de reduction indiqu6 ci-dessous. 
 
 10X 14X 18X 22X 
 
 J 
 
 26X 
 
 30X 
 
 12X 
 
 16X 
 
 20X 
 
 24X 
 
 28X 
 
 32X 
 
:ails 
 
 du 
 
 )difier 
 
 une 
 
 nage 
 
 The copy filmed here has been reproduced thanks 
 to the generosity of: 
 
 National Library of Canada 
 
 The images aopearing here are the best quality 
 possible considering the condition and legibility 
 of the original copy and in keeping with the 
 filming contract specifications. 
 
 Original copies in printed paper covers are filmed 
 beginning with the front cover and ending on 
 the last page with a printed or illu3trated impres- 
 sion, or the back cover when appropriate. All 
 other original copies are filmed beginniny on the 
 first page with a printed or illustrated impres- 
 sion, and ending on the last page with a printed 
 or illustrated impression. 
 
 The last recorded frame on each microfiche 
 shall contain the symbol ^^^ (meaning "CON- 
 TINUED"), or the symbol V (meaning "END"), 
 whichever applies. 
 
 Maps, plates, charts, etc., may be filmed at 
 different reduction ratios. Those too large to be 
 entirely included in one exposure are filmed 
 beginning in the upper left hand corner, left to 
 right and top to bottom, as many frames as 
 required. The following diagrams illustrate the 
 method: 
 
 L'exemplaire film6 fut reproduit grAce A la 
 gin^rositi de: 
 
 Bibliothdque nationale du Canada 
 
 Les images suivantes ont 6xi reproduites avec le 
 plus grand soin, compte tenu de la condition at 
 de la nettet6 de l'exemplaire film6, et en 
 conformity avec les conditions du contrat de 
 filmage. 
 
 Les exemplaires originaux dont la couverture en 
 papier est imprimde sont filmds en commenqant 
 par le premier plat et en terminant soit par la 
 dernidre page qui comporte une empreinte 
 d'impression ou d'illustration, soit par le second 
 plat, selon le cas. Tous les autres exemplaires 
 originaux sont filmds en commenqant par la 
 premidre page qui comporte une empreinte 
 d'impression ou d'illustration et en terminant par 
 la dernidre page qui comporte une telle 
 empreinte. 
 
 Un des symboles suivants apparaltra sur la 
 dernidre image de cheque microfiche, selon le 
 cas: le symbole — »> signifie "A SUIVRE", le 
 symbole V signifie "FIN". 
 
 Les cartes, planches, tableaux, etc., peuvent dtre 
 filmds i des taux de reduction diff6~ents. 
 Lorsque ie document est trop grand pour etre 
 reproduit en un seul clichd, il est filmd A partir 
 de Tangle supdrieur gauche, de gauche d droite, 
 et de haut en bas, en prenant le nombre 
 d'images n^cessaire. Les diagrammes suivants 
 illustrent la mdthode. 
 
 rrata 
 to 
 
 pelure. 
 
 □ 
 
 32X 
 
 1 
 
 2 
 
 3 
 
 1 
 
 2 
 
 3 
 
 4 
 
 5 
 
 6 
 

 
 I 
 
 f 
 
 
 
 /In 
 
 

 
 •CJlje CanaWan fogalists 
 
 I 
 
 # 
 $ 
 
 
 
 .-ft 
 
 # 
 
 /t\ 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 m 
 
 
 
 ^ N D 
 
 IN THE 
 
 iistrirt of %Miih 
 
 B)/ Jno. P. JVov/e^, 
 
 Govv'exnsVif fe, P. Q, 
 
 X 
 
 THK NKWvS TYP., ST. JOHNS, 
 1900. 
 
 *^^^'^^^^'^^^^^^^W^^W.^'¥.^)¥.<¥.^^i^Ws'^m^^i^)¥.^W,^^^^ 
 
■M 
 
 >^ 
 
 V 
 
 ( 
 
 r 
 
 "^ 
 
■:il 
 
 Zhe Canabian fogalists 
 
 V >7 D 
 
 ^. ^ 
 
 ' sjl^ -); 
 
 ,V 7 
 
 ^^"^ TIJK 
 
 Distrirf nf BrUM 
 
 / 
 
 ^^1 J IK). !>. .\V 
 
 ^' ^•••>H,\).,^^ Hi ^^ |> ^-^^ 
 
 0\ G< 
 
 
 i9(j(' 
 
lo 
 
 hi 
 
 of 
 ot 
 fo 
 or 
 th 
 in 
 
 Pl 
 
 pa 
 
 li\ 
 ca 
 inl 
 th 
 
PREFATORY. 
 
 r 
 r 
 
 cs 
 
 ) 
 
 The followini,r paper is published by rcciucst of officials of ou 
 local Historical Societies, and of friends interested in early pionee 
 history. It was originally read before historical and other societie 
 of tlie District of Jk-dford durin-- the past year. In the desire t( 
 obtain brevity, many local references to Missisqiioi were omitted be- 
 fore Shefford audiences, just as those relalin^,^ to Shefford were 
 omitted before Missisquoi audiences. An effort is made to combine 
 them in the followin-^r paper. Many thinn^s deemed necessary to 
 interest the different audiences, as well as expressions peculiar to 
 platform delivery, have been omitted. But the substance of the 
 paper, and the historical facts and comments are the same as tie- 
 livered. This statement is deemed prudent to allay the zeal of the 
 captious local critic. The real object of the pai)er is to stimulate 
 interest in the laudable designs of the County Historical Societies of 
 the District of Bedford. 
 
 Co\\.\.\>\ iLI.i,, Au-ust K 
 
 jxo. i\ ^■o^•I•:s. 
 
 )00. 
 
ITbc Canadian Xov^alists 
 
 an^ 
 
 Earl^ Settlers in the iDistiict of 
 
 Bc(^for^. 
 
 The early settle iiunt ..f a country, the hahits, hanlshij.s and eN])erienees ui its 
 pK'iic-ers, have a ehann lor those i;erliai;s a seleet few-^uh.) delight in the i.ivesti- 
 j^ation ..I a snhject whieh exa.ts a certain amount of researcli in order to attain a 
 fair measure of acvuracy. Tlu re is a eomniendable ten.len.-v ..f late to regard with 
 favor the econ,;mic. or political value <.f historv, apart tn.m'its interest as a narra 
 tive of events, which shonhl assist and stimulate investiKati<.n. There are obvious 
 reasons tor this, and it is ,|uite dear, as well, that surh value depends not onh 
 U]u,n the truth ot the narrative, hut upon the lair appreciation of the facts. 
 
 The fitful, and, .it limes, acrimonious conlroversv ofthe past, as to the early sc-lf 
 
 lersot the District of He.llonl respcrtiUK h.yaltv. has obscured rather than eu'li^ht- 
 
 ened the subject. Tlure is no Lick of tnulitions of historical rese.irchand investi-a- 
 
 lion m the true .sense-in the historical sense, tlure has been pn.cticallv none. ( me 
 
 result IS. that the zeal of uninformed partisans has led lo the l,i];el"linK "s T F 
 
 Lc.yalists, many uho came ;,fter the fever of lovallv had been replace.l bv tlu 
 
 iactorol sc-lf-intcrest. ami even of tho.se whose arrival was lo.iK subsequent to the 
 
 necessities of loyal expressicjn. The result has been to create a feelin.i,^ of doubt or 
 
 skej,ticism, astor. I'.. I.cjyali.sts akin to that expresse.l bv the irreve'rc nt i.il^rim 
 
 "1 Koine. "Ihese new .saints make one doul,t the .,ld." It is r.ot therefore a 
 
 "latter ol surprise that the unwarranted as.sertions of such ill-informe.l a.lvocates 
 
 have caused a Kc-neraticn. not keenly interested in the r. !■;. I.ovali.sts, to surmise 
 
 that these loyalists are an historical mystery, and as utterlv discredited, so far as 
 
 relates to location, as the .lescendants of the lost tribes of Israel. It is fortunate 
 
 tor those of another turn ..f mind, uho .lesirc. historical accuracy, that the zeal and 
 
 
TIM'. CANADIAN I." >VAI,ISTS. 
 
 iiiiUistrv of (nir Caii.nli.m Arrlii\i>t liavi". within tlu- past tVw years, j)rncurf»l a 
 i'<>ii^i(Kral>lc i|uai'tit\ of thr <»tli«'ial tiionls ol the tarly sitlliiiuiit ot the rdiintry, 
 hy tncaiis «»f which the trivial iiaifleiits of criihilniis or interested news j^atlierers. 
 so zealously t'Nploiteil heretofore as liist(»r\ , an- sliow II to In- valueless. The idle 
 tales ri'sultin>^ tr<«ni the creative fatiey of iti.iii, cilhil tradition, nul which have 
 nneonseionsl\ a tenacious liold ii]M>n evrti inlvllij;ent jieople, thotij^h the t'tnes are 
 rei"iMil, .and writtc-n records availahle. are. liy means of these ricords. in a way to 
 he dis|pilUd. C.irlylc c.dls history " the letter of instruction^ from llu- old ,i;ener- 
 atioiistothc new." \ci-e]»tin.i; that ilelMiition. it is the duty of tin- jireseiit ;;ener- 
 ation to iNauiiiii' its letter of iiistiuctious, as containi'd in tlie ntlicial records, so 
 as to ])lace the ])iouier> of ilii- histrict in their proper class. This involves an ex- 
 amination of their credentials, .is well as the cousiileralion of their aiitecidents, and 
 of the causes and events which le<l to theii coming', as well a> thiir situation on 
 arrival here. 
 
 It will siarci'ly he clisputed that the e.irly Canadian Loyalists s])ranj; from an 
 aflveiiturous stock, whose escape from allej,(ed olil world persecntious to secure reli- 
 j^ious and political freidom in tlie new, in no w.i\ i|iiencheil their love of coullict. 
 or dislike of any antl!i>rit\ which they did. not dominate. Apart from the otiicial 
 an<l inleri sted classes, the mass of .\merican C(»lonisis on the eve of the American 
 KivolulioM, were practically united in op]»()sin>( the mother country. The leaders 
 of the pojiular cause were ahle, tai'tful and darinj.;. I'ul candi 1 American hi-- 
 toriaiis admit that they were leaders of a minority when it camo to a tlnal rnjiture. 
 It was unfortunate for the royal cause- that the loy;il majoritv had, from anioiiLi 
 themselves, no leaders. The Colonial officials who, hy nature of their ])ositions. 
 assumed to K^i'l*-'- 'f ""'^ ^*^ lead, wxre not in touch with the )(ei>])le. and were to 
 some extent discredited ])y the anta}.;oni^ms of loiij.r years of dispute hetween them 
 as to Crown rij.;hts. Tlu- dei-laratioii of inde])endence was the act of a Couj^ress 
 without )ej.(al authority. Bancroft, an .\merican historian, .sail 1 it w.is " unthin;.; 
 more solid than the unformecl opinion of an unformed peo])le." 
 
 The Colonists enrolled as soldiers ( lU the side- of the Crown ixceeiK-tl 25, mx) 
 and, durin^f the war, their homes i\ere destroyeil, their property confiscatt'd and 
 their families hitterlv ]>erseiaited. Justice re(iuireslhe admission that, in this, as in 
 other civil wars, llu-rewere rejirisals in whii-h the Loyalists iniitatiMl the deplorahle 
 eNam])le of their .adversaries. lu'eliui^s of intense hitteruess and mutual hatred 
 were created which, when the conflict etule<l, could not l)e dispelled, nor the desire 
 for revenge allayed. The coiKiuerors easily hecame ])ersecutors. 1 >espit(.' llu' pro- 
 visions of the treatv of peace. s])eciall\' ,i;nar.inteeing the proti-ction of the j);()])erty 
 anil rii.;hts of the Loy.ilists, uii'iv of the State Le,u;islatures ordered conli'-cation <>\ 
 their property. Persecution was encouraged ind u]>held. 
 
 This persecution drove the loyal Colonists into exile. There was a tn-meudous 
 rush into Can.ida and Nova Scotia, taxing severelx the resnurces of those volouies 
 to meet the urgent necessities of those destitute and sutTering exiles. .\nd it is 
 through the elTorts of the government to aid those exiles, and to give tluni a per- 
 manent settlement, ih.at one tnids from the ol'I'u'ial records a recognition of dilTereiit 
 titles — titles which design.ate a divisii'ti into three fairly marked classes. These 
 classes seem ;it times to he fused or bU-niled, hut a little coiisider.ition will show a 
 
 i 
 
Tiri': C AN API \N I,()V\I,ISTS. 
 
 i 
 
 I 
 
 Dinrkul flilTi riiuf in tn-Mttiicut, aipl a ilistiiu'tioii to which jtrai'liiMl i-fTi-i I was 
 ^ivin hy ;4u\t'rmiii'iit.il .iction. II will \>v niiilirslcxHl ihiit jitior to I7<)i Ihi" I'roviiici' 
 roiii])ris«il rpjiiT ami I.nwir (.".mail.i, in whii'h. ipatt frnm the si i^^iinirii-s. tht- 
 iiiiiiiL-ii^c art'.i fit" \va^U' laiitl In l(iii);ril t<> the Ciowii. As th»'\ ha<l no ni irktt vahu*. 
 a KT'iiit «>r laml was an fas\ tdrni <i| coinpt-nsalion. To locatt- lh» j^toninis ami 
 allot tlu- sfttU rs, a |irt'liinijiar\ snr\t y was ihr first stiji, anil for many n-asoiis ihe 
 first Infants wirt' on thf I'.ay i\v CliaUiirs, iinl "U tlu- north lianks ot tlir St. 
 I.awrtiu'c ami the laki's, the loyalists liciiij; .issi-niliUil at (Jmlni*. Son! ami 
 Moiitrcal tor transportation. 
 
 I, 
 
 'I'JK.' I'irst cl.i-s to In- ciiiisidfrt'd was i'oni|iosi'(l ot I'.in^lish otlii-i.ils, .ind Colonial 
 iion-conihat.ints who k-ft thi- ri'hrl tolonirs .it tin- lu-i^inninj.; of. or (hiriM)^ tlu- war. 
 Tlusc int'ii dill n<it dfpnciali- thiir nu-rils or niisrrit'S. Tlu-y had tlu- ,irt of 
 so cNposin).; thfir '^rifts and st-rvirt-s as to nutl, from a ^i-iurons y^' <\ irntncnt, a fair 
 nuasnrc of ri-ward lor fiij^itivc loyalty. I!arly in 17SJ an invcstij^alioii showed that 
 n]iwards of ^joo.tifx) had hciii ])aid for ill snjiport of ^i;; rifui;i'i' Loyalists, in 
 [.ondoii alone. 'I'liis was aji.irt from olticcs, pi nsions, ami land j.;rants li stowed. 
 It was further shown as an instance of loyal thrift, that after the death <>f 2>, ,,\ the 
 nnmlier, their deniisi' had hieti eoneeah • and the Mrit.sh ('.overnnKut hail con- 
 tinued its j.ii'mrous relief to necessitous loyalty by j avini.; for their sn])iiort Wluii 
 th. ;fiitish j)arliainent met in 17S;,, afli-r the cl >se of the war I lis M,ijest\ in the 
 s])eech from the throne said : " That a ilue .md L;ener(»us attention on.L;ht to lie 
 "shown to those wlio lia\i' relin(|uishe<l tip 'r ])ro|)erties or possessions from 
 " motives of loyally to jue, or atla(hnui;t to tlu- mother country." .\s a rt sidt of 
 this snL;,uestion a commission was issued to receive claims for losse^ from all clas.'-es 
 of sutferiiij.; Loyalists, which i-otilinued its work until 17SS, Cl.iims for the sum 
 '•'f >,S<»,. 110,9.^1 were fyled. on which was allowc.l an<l ])aid ^iS,c;i2,2() |, which was 
 repudiated l>y indefensihU' prelixls li\ the .\inerit.in ( lovernnient, thoiii;h the 
 lossi'S were shown to Si- in violation of the 'l'ri'at\ of re.ice. The niotlu'r country 
 was nenerous to all that class of sulTerers. The old Colonial olVice holders .ippear 
 to have heen .1 ^.^reedy lot. -ind dilticult to satisfy. Their names cut a l>i,L; lij^ure in 
 the ollicial records t'or frei- i^MTuits of land. ( )nt' sampU- will illustrate their 
 character, selectdt hecause his covetous e_\t-. ha\iny heen last ui)on our Townships. 
 j;ives his L,M'eed a local color. 
 
 .\lir.iliam Cu\Urw,is I'ostm.'istir at \lh,iu\'. when the revolution. iry stru;,^le 
 l)e,i.;.iu, ;ind luin^ a Postmaster w.is natur.dly and otlicially loy.il. lie I<.>t his 
 otlici', and took the mad of forced exile. lie came to Canada, and later went to 
 Cape I'.reton, and secured olTu'es at ditfereul tinu-s. r,inj.,'in^ frotn a modest Inspec- 
 torship to .1 Judj.^eship ; li.id a])]ilied for ,1 Customs appointment, a;id .ictid .is 
 I,ieulenaut-( loviriior, whilst ki i]iiun oii f\le sundry cl.iiins for land .and com])en- 
 satioii. He did not ,!.;et on well with the luc.il jiow'ers, so he resij^Mied from the 
 r.ench. and. the war Ijeini; o\er, he ])Ushed his claims for com])ensalioii in Ni'W 
 \'ork. as well as in London. I'lom the latti-r j)kn'e he wroti- tlu- Canailiaii .lulhori 
 ties for ,1 i^rant of tlie whole Townshi]) of Hemminvilord, which not biintj con- 
 ceded, lu' pointed out lands in Dunham, Staiilirid.L;e. L'.irnh.im, Shefford ,nid Stai;- 
 .stead, for which lu- desired a j^rant. Then lu turned up with a cla,i;) for ;i part of 
 
8 
 
 Till' CANADIAN LOYALISTS. 
 
 MoiilrcaL 1)Ul as this had l:i'.ii rc-^raiiUd to a clnirch, liis family was ,L;ivL'ii 3,6rxD 
 acns of hind elsewhere, .'is an t(Hii\a]int for the ehnreli ])r(.])erty. Later, as hi- 
 a])])earcd to want a farm of his own to carry C)n, ami the land ot'licials s(.eminj.( hy 
 that time to liavi- tired of his imjiortunity, it was ordered that <-)Ut (;f the dis])os.ihle 
 hinds in I'arnh.am, a j^rant shonid hi- j^jiven to IMessrs. Cuxler and Allso|)j). Ik' 
 and two of his sons, hecame AssociaUs of the To", nship of l"arnhani, and rereived 
 the nsnal allotments of }.irants as siuli. Hut ;is 'Sly. .\ll>o])]) had received ]irior 
 grants, and Judj^e (iale had to take a mountain, and liis wif .'s relations, swam])s 
 and led^res, towards tlu'ir considirahle shares therein, it may he fairly presumecL 
 that the dis])osahle Crown Lands in I'arnham were exh;uisleil before Judge Cuyler 
 got into tlie precinct. What finally 1)eca!.ie of him I do not know, hut one cannot 
 hel]) sadly reflecting, what an adililional glor\- il would have heeii for I'arnham, 
 had judge Cuyler heen entoml)ed within its borders, to exi'ite, in Liter years, the 
 grief and curiosity of searchers for jo!) l(*ts of L. L. Loyalists. 
 
 It is submitted, that the whole of this class, just considered, wire not I'. H. 
 Lo} ists. The Colonists were not inrolled as soldiers in the war, and the native 
 hon I'.ngHshnien were bound b\- the ties of birth and allegiance to lie loyal with- 
 out exacting C(jm])ensatioii for tidelil\- to such ties, 
 
 II 
 
 The second class of Loyalists com])rised tlu Colonial soldiers enrolkil in the 
 army prior to tlu' Treaty of Peace in 17.S3, and w luj came at oiicc. with their fami- 
 lies {() Canada at the close of the w ar. 
 
 'I'luse men ai)pear to havi' left i>\. once w ithout slojjping to l)arter their alle- 
 giance. Large as their numlier was, the Crow n was generous in granting thviii land, 
 in conveying them to the jilaci-s allotted for location, and in granting them teni])o- 
 rary aid and subsistence. And to estal)lish their identity, and to distinguish tlu-m 
 from the Refugee L(\valists, for all time to come, the (lovernment on the 9th 
 Novemlier, 1 7S(), by a minute of Council ordered, that : " .All Loyalists who joined 
 " ihe Standard bi'fore tl:e Treaty of I'eace in 17^;-,, and all children, and descen- 
 " dants of either sex, are to be distinguished 'n\- the Utters ' l". I'..' allixed to their 
 " names, alluding to tlu' great ]irinci]ile oi the unity of the Lm])ire." It was fur- 
 ther ordered, at the same time, that a Register should be kept so that their jjoster- 
 it\- might be discriminated from future settlers. It is reasonably certain that al^ 
 did not register. The Ontario list, containing many I. astern Townsh)i)s names, is 
 ju'ocurable, but there is no special list lor (juebec, because Loyalists wen- ex- 
 chuled from seltUinent on Crown Lands south of the St. Lawrence, 
 
 n\- the Order of Council we have a clear and authoritative delinition of tlu- 
 Loyalists. It is not a courtesy title, nor gained by common re])Ute. l!y it we find 
 the distinguishing conditions of a \' . I'.. Lovalist to be ; 1. An i-nrollment as a 
 Colonial soldier in the ann\' during the u.ir ; or 2. A desec nd.mt of such soldier. 
 The ilescent from such soldier is not dilTicult to establish where there was an en- 
 rollment in the Register. The absence of registration creates a ])resum])tion 
 against the claim to be a l'. I',. Loyalist, which cannot be (nercome by a bare state- 
 ment of such claim. Through ignorance of the ( )rder in Council many have as" 
 sumed that an earlv land Ljrant mu'-l ha\(.- been the rewanl of lo-^altv, ami there 
 
Till'. CANADIAN I.OVAl.USTS. 
 
 9 
 
 sceli- 
 llieir 
 i'ur- 
 
 ICT- 
 
 it all 
 (-•s, is 
 
 fnre. an effertive title to tliu distinction of lieitii,' a \'. I!. I,<>; alist. Hut all those 
 early land j^rants were not j^jiven on aeconnt of loyalty, The ollicial definition 
 should, however, determine the matter. The true l", I",. Loyalist, as just jiointcd 
 out, was a Colonial soldier who, us such, had suffereil the hardshi})S of actual war, 
 and had been ex])osed toits perils and risks, during which he had been conscious 
 of the ])erseciitions and sufferin,^s of famil\ and friends at home. He had under- 
 t^one the trials and. miseries of de])ortation when the war closed, and had emlured 
 }.{reat ])rivations for years thereafter through want of means, and hv reason of re- 
 moteness from markets and livili/.ation. It is manh'estly unfair to class such men 
 with those who had not l)orne arms, liowever nuu'h the latter may have suffepMl 
 through jersecutioii or otherwise'. ( )ne cannot read witliont interest, to say the 
 least, the jiainful records of those exiled Loyalists. Their primitive makeshifts 
 may, today, excite a smile, hut they do. not lessen respect. Matiy instances of 
 such makeshifts are recorded in local history, or have been handed dow!i from 
 gcni-ration to .plication. Mr I'.dward Harris, a descendant of a l'. !•",. I.ovalist, 
 in a |iai)er re,-.d before the Canadian Inslilute at Toronto in 1897, related one of 
 those incidents, common to most of the early settlements in some resi)ects, result- 
 ing from ])ioneer makeshifts, which deserves re])roduct;()n. He sai<l that in 1794 
 his grandfather became tlu' first settler in the Long I'oint country on the north 
 shore of Lake I'.rii-, having remoMil tliere from New Brunswick, where he had 
 settled in 17S3. "In the absence of all other clothing ami snpplits," he writes, 
 " the le^s fortunate .settlers, and as a rule, all the men, used the skins of animals. 
 " The girls, in mild weather, usu.ally wore a buckskin slip. ' White goods,' we:e 
 " not known in lliosi' davs. .Miss Sallv Sprague, a fine girt of i.\ or 15 years, had 
 " been in my mother's kitchen with her ])arents and noticed washing going on in 
 " ihe usual wa\- l)v boiling in soap and watei. .\ few days after, vSally took ad\ant- 
 " age of her pariiits absence lo wasli her only garment, the sli]). This she did, by 
 " boiling it. We all know the action of water ami heat on leather, and Sally had 
 " lo retreat into the jiotato hole inider the ilot)r. When her ])arents returned thev 
 "soon found the shrunken slip, and thi'ti the girl. She was brought down to my 
 " mother's house in a barrel, on an ox-team four miles, and temporarily clothed 
 " until inori' buckskin could be found. This Miss Sprague's gratid-daughter is 
 "now l.ady b. in I'.ngland." This incident i> also related in Dr. Ryerson's his- 
 tory of the r. I-",. Loyalists, with considerable dilTerence as to j)articulars, although 
 b )th he and Mr. Harris obt.'iiiu'il their information! from the same per.son. 
 
 III. 
 
 the 
 find 
 as a 
 lier. 
 
 en- 
 ition 
 Late- 
 
 as" 
 ere 
 
 The third class of I.ovalists comjirised those Colonial non-combatants who, with 
 their families, left aftei* the Treaty n( I'eace, at the I'onclusioii of the Revolutionary 
 war, through the fierce persecut:t)n which for a time followed. 
 
 'I'hat this clas!^ came to Canada ; a result of the merciless pensecutioii before 
 niiMitioned, is recordeil iu the histories of that jteriod, is treasured caniong the 
 annals of tlie ])eo]iIe, and is borne out and fully verified 1)\ the official documents of 
 that day. It is the i)iimi|.al, if not the .sole groutid n])on which that large number 
 of refugee Loyalists based their persistent claims for provisions, com])ensation and 
 
lo 
 
 TirrC CANADIAN F,( )VAI.IS'1'S. 
 
 1.111(1 grants. Thuv were (jiiick to see the strength of the cry of persecuted lovaUy, 
 with a well (lisjjosed, and not severely critical Ilxecutive. Hut, as the Provincial 
 authorities could not at once coinjily with all their urgent demands, theiC was 
 grave dissatisfaction, fc>llowe<l by strong complaints. It was impossible for them 
 to be patient, or to make any show of self-reliance, seeing that they had lost every- 
 thing, and were in sore distress, They were not in a position of isolated inde{)en- 
 deiice, with suiTicient means of support, which warranted their taking the stand of 
 those early Connecticut settlers, who proclaimed that they would be governed by 
 the laws of (iod — until they ha<l time to make better. The olTicial reports stated 
 that those earh- Canadian settlers would make malignant representations against 
 an angel ; that some of them would not carry the chain to mark out their own 
 lands, without exorbitant i)ay from the (lovernment ; that there was trickery in 
 dis]H)sing of their lands and seeking further coni])en9ation ; that there were laml 
 speculators and jobbers ; that there were clamors, jealousies and grasping greed ; 
 that there was sedition, led b}- an uidioly combination of a lawyer ami an apothe- 
 cary ; that they had " to nu^ke magistrates out of men whom (jod Almighty never 
 "intended for the office, but it was Ilobson's choice;" that there were many 
 worthless characters among the arrivals, and that some of the settlers were indif- 
 ferent. His I'^xcellency, the (lOvernor-C.eneral. finding that despite ell efforts to 
 satisfy everybody, the dissatisfaction and artifices continued, ordered the immedi- 
 a'e discontinuance of i)rovisions and aid to those who, from fickleness or languor, 
 threw obstacles in the way of the general good. The history of those (|uarrels, \>v- 
 twcen exiles and blxecutive, is not now really essential. !t is mentioned to show 
 the character of a class, which, coming so closely on the heels of the W ]'.. Loyal- 
 ists, and like them receiving land grants, has found iu our day peo]>le who rank 
 them with those ancient worthies. The claims have even been extended to cover, 
 as r. l\. Loyalists, th»" calm and ])eaceful (Juakers, forced into exile. The droll 
 effect of placing the unwarlike <juaker in line with the esscntiall\ wiirlike \' . \\. 
 Loyalist, because both recei^-ed Crown Ijounties, does not seem to have occurred 
 to them. 
 
 h<l 
 Ci 
 
 te 
 
 .An invident of that time, which the Ca.uadiau archivist says he luis never seen 
 referre<l to by an American historian, and which is recalled by allusit)n to (Jnakers, 
 is interesting, as showing a peculiarity of those early Lo\alists, though not other- 
 wise in line with my subject. The small Lslaud of Nantucket, off the coast < if 
 the Massachusetts coast, is said to have been iidudnted in 17S5 by Ouakers con- 
 nected with the whale fisheries. In that year they gravel\- ])roposed to separate 
 from Massachusetts, and become a neutral state, or, failing in this, to become an 
 ajipendage of C.reat Ikitain. 'i'he newly arrived Loyalists in Nova Scotia success 
 fully c)pp()sed the scheme 011 the ground " That in that case all the whale oil from 
 " the Northern States would pass throught Nantucket, as the product of the in- 
 " ilustry of British subjects, and be admitted into (ireat Britain free of duty, to tlie 
 " ruin of the same^trade carried on from Nova Scotia." The thrifty and sagacious 
 (Uiakers may have had in view the advantages of their position, as a point for 
 smuggling rather than any possible benefit lo the I'",mj)ire, bv adding their island 
 thereto. If so, they were checkmated by the foresight of the Loyalists. This, 
 
I 
 
 TIIIv CANADIAN I. OVA LISTS. 
 
 1 1 
 
 however, seems to be the first record of the ailoptioii of the National l*olie\ iii 
 ChikkUi, and should set at rest all recent claims as to its paternity. 
 
 .After these digressions we come back to tliis third Loyalist class, wlio have 
 themselves ])ri])ared the record which excludes them from the slightest considera- 
 tion as r. \'., Loyalists. The only reason they gave, at the time for coming to 
 Canada, and the only rea.son ever given on their behalf is, that after the Treaty of 
 Peace, they were grievously persecuted and driven into exile. What those refuijee 
 Loyalists, in effect, said, was this : " We desired to stay in our old homes and re- 
 " tain our ])r()])erty ; to do this we were willing to change our allegiance, to sur- 
 '• render the jiosition of British subjects and become citizens of the Republic ; but 
 " our i.iclinations atid good will were rejected ; they persecuted us, confiscated our 
 " })ro])crl\- and drove us into unwilling exile ; therefore we come to vou and ask 
 " for a land tyrant, on the score of loyalty, -and comi)ensation for losses suffered, 
 '• because not allowed to change our allegiance." It is clear they would have re- 
 maintd, if alli^wed to do so. Hence, their loyalty was not spt)ntaneous, or disin- 
 terested. (ii> they must and go they did, aiul naturally made the best of a bad 
 bargain, by getting as much compensation as possible, out of the Crown. 
 
 Whilst it is essential to the truth of history that the facts should be stated, it is 
 not necessary to harshly judge those unfortunate aiul impoverished exiles. The 
 i-oloniis were their homes. There they were born and reared. There were ties of 
 race, kindred, laws, institutions and religion common between them and the suc- 
 cessful Co:oi:isi> in the war. Together they had worshi]>i)ed at the same altar, 
 shared the vicissitudes and jierils of Colonial existence, and borne the burdens and 
 enjo\ed the comforts and jileasures of civil and social life in their several com- 
 munities. Tile change to them from a colony to an independent nation, accu.s- 
 tonud as tl'.e\ had been to a con.siderable measure of local .self-government, would 
 not 1 e so sudden or distinct as it would have been, had not the.se iditions 
 existed, or li.id they been con<|uered by an alien race. It is evident, as well, that 
 the british (Mjvernment had contemj)late(l their so reitiaining, inasmuch as the 
 treaty of ])eace expressly ])rovided for the protection of their ])ro])erty and rights. 
 The subse(|uent evasion of the treaty could not have been foreseen. Nevertheless, 
 we nnist be careful not to unduly magnify the passive position of neutrals in a 
 ci\ il war, into ihe hightest kin<l of patriotism and loyalty, by shouldering them 
 into the raiik^ of those who risked their lives, as \vell as their fortunes, as loval 
 soldiers (jf their Sovereign, as did the gemiine V. l\. Loyalist. 
 
 A fertile source of error respecting the old Loyalists conies from the long, 
 ali)habetically arrangecL and frecjuently repeated lists of applicants for lands, con- 
 tained in several years reports of the Dominion Archives. These are apt to mis- 
 lead, and, in fact, have misled many, as to the (piality of those therein naniecL A 
 very little investigation, and com])ari.son of (kites, will show that tho.se lists com. 
 prise the old .\ssociates, who were the jiioneers and actual settlers of the Kastern 
 Townshii'S, an<l who obtained their lands long after the r. \\. and other Loyalists 
 had been definitely located elsewhere. They were, on the whole, an absoluteK- 
 ililTerent class from the (-Id Loyalists, or any other, or later class of settlers. The 
 enor as to the .Associates has been greatly helped along by the ])ersi.stent claims of 
 
 
12 
 
 TIIK CANADIAN LOVAMSTS. 
 
 recent partisans, hy the luloj^ies of loial hiogra])hers exalting the ikad, to ])r<)- 
 ])itiate the livinj^, and l)y taking' early residence, lo\ alt\ , hind j^raiils and l'. I-",. 
 I.oyahsts as synonymons or convi-rtihle terms. The j)lacinj4 of the associates in the 
 old Loyalist I'lass which j^receded them, does them an injustice, for the .Associates, 
 bein.n more self-reliant, jiosse.ssed of .some me.ins, and not de])endent u])on (rO\eni- 
 metit 1)()unty, witc a better class of settlers to develoj) a new coinitry than the ohl 
 Loyalists could have been, had they .settled here, as a little consideration will show. 
 b'or several years after the treat\ of ])eai'e in 17S;, our ijovernment positively 
 refused jiertnission to settle aloni; the bordir. After 1791, when the Province was 
 divided into r])]H:r and I.ower Canada, the ])olic\' was chan}.;ed so as to induce 
 i'.nj^lish s])eakinj^ settlers t<i locate, and settle on the Crown lands in tlu- Ivasti-rn 
 To\vnshi])S, then unsnrve\ed, and a sur\e\ was the first ]iri-liuiinar\ to a !L;rant. 
 The intentions of the ^^overnment were \\idel\ dissi-minated in Ni \v l'"u.i;l;ind - 
 where over 150 years of settlement had exhausted the market for farm lauds iii 
 ordir to attract, as settlers, those desirini,^ lo secure ^ood lauds for settlement, on 
 e:isy conditions. So early as 1 7SS the advanta}.;cs had iieen nri^td (f .l,( Itini; fnui 
 New b'n.^land a i-lass of settlers, who had r<.]ient(.d of tlieir h(jstilit\ \': tlu- british 
 Ciovernment. 'I"hc new j)olicy com])riscd an or_nani/atiou, (/r ccm] any, called As- 
 sociates, to whom the new Townshi]) was j^ranted. The at^ent of the .Associates, 
 called the Under, was r.sually a man with ,s(,n'.e miaus and int]u(r.i('. lie bicniH' 
 lesjjonsible for the fidlillmtnt of the conditions, the oidv one ot the many nally 
 ])re.s.sed beinj.^ the cost of tlu- ] rimitiM- snrvew whiih had to be m: de as a jireli- 
 min;Mv to tlu- erection of the Townslii]i, and the u, ra n t i n ,n of tl.c lauds. Tlie 
 .\s.sociates, with nmarkalik' uuifoimitv, alleged jirior .ittacliuicnt, <.r le] eut.anre of 
 hostility, which, as they had ("ri^inidly bieii liritish subjicls, ir.\('".\i 1 no st vi u- 
 moral stiain. besides, tlu' war in N« w I'lnt^land, frc m whtnce tl.c \ mostly lame 
 had been on its outskirts, so that those li\ iu,u inlaml in the 'i/)'s h;.d ])r()b,abl\ ne\er 
 l)orne anus on cither side, 'i'hc (loxcrumcnt took no scntimer.ta! view of the 
 m.atter, and accejitcd means ;ind character as conditions, more than j)rolcssed ])rior 
 allegiance, or sorrow for hostilitv. The fact is, the (io\frmnent wanted settlers; 
 the settlers wanted lands. Inder such conditions, no tec-hnical or sentimental con- 
 siderations were likely to be an ol)stacle in the wav of an agreement between the 
 parties. vSome of the leaders and .Associates were business mei!, who went into the 
 undertaking.;' for s]iec-ulative motixcs. or to tmike u]) the rc(|uircil uund)er, aud who 
 disjKJsed of their interests and ue\er came, nor intended to come, at all. .\fter the 
 survey, the Townshi]) was erected, j^ivc-n a namc\ ;iud the lands allotted to tlu- 
 Associates by grant. Thus Dunham was created in 179^), Potton, I'.oltoh, and 
 i?rome in I7cj7, I'artiham in 1 7c>S, Stanbridgc in iSoi, ;ind so on up to 1S07, when a 
 h;dt was called. St. Armand, St. (icorge de Claiemeville and St. 'l"homas wcrc- 
 created Seigniories ])ric)r to the com|uest — and not being Crown laiuls, could not be- 
 granted or made Townshi])S. Governor I'restutt, a few years after the adoption of 
 the policy in (picsticm. divided the .\ssocialts into three clas.'"s; 1. l'eoi)le who 
 had always been attached to the british cause; 2. People who have been led 
 astra\ ; and 3. Mere .speculators, whose .ijijilications he said were inuiuTous. He- 
 comi)lained bitterly to the honu' (lovernmeut of the attem])ts of the specidators t< 
 obtain large grants in order to create a nic)no])oly ; of straw men being put up as 
 
 
TIIH CANADIAN LOYALISTS. 
 
 I ; 
 
 ;i])])lic{ints to evade the rej^ulatioiis ; of the i oiiijiliiity of iiieinl;eis of his own 
 cfviincil in the sehcnies; of colhisive tiii-ks with ImikI surveyors to firther their 
 jilatis, and the dissatisfaction of these hmd johliers, as Chief Jn:-tiee ?tIonk lalled 
 tlicni, when their jilaiis were thwarted. In the I'l-l-er I'rovinre th(. y wen- havinjf 
 their troul)ks. f<jr, in iSos, an ( fiieial elai-sified \hv latir refrs^te settlets from the 
 r. S. as : I. '1 Ik i^e enticed hy a j^iatuituoiis ( ITt r of land wilh.ont any ]in(lilection 
 for tlie liritish constitution ; 2. 'lliose \\h<; liad lied fr« ni tlie r. S. for crimes or 
 to escape their creditors ; and ;,. Kijuhhcans who came as settlers, lo jilot 
 a.nainst Great Britain. 'J'he Associates were of a bitter class of n:en than these, ])i!t 
 were not of the Loyalist class nitntii;ned, wliich came at tlie chsc- of tlu- war, as a 
 little consideration will show. .-\ ])erio(l of about 13 \ ears interxeiud between the 
 treaty of ])eace and tl;e j^rant of the fiist Tow nshij) to the .\ssoci;',tt s. Th.e bitter, 
 and .general persecution followinj.^- the close of tl:e war, as before nitntic ntd, drove 
 into e.xile every man snsjiected of attaidnnent to the mother countr\ . This l<>nj4 
 period is ccnclusive that tliose Associates wh.o came (n the creation of the Town- 
 shijjs must, during their rtsidtnce ft r so ni;;n\ yti'.is in tl.iir old lun.ts, have 
 satisfied the local authorities there, of tluir satisfaction with, an<l alles^iani'e to, the 
 new order of things. Had the\ not dune so, it is certain that tlH'\- could not thus 
 have remained among a peoj)le on the aleit \\>v Hiitish s\ ni] athi/.c rs, .".nd agains'. 
 whom that people were violently enragi'd. 
 
 This long residencee, where the authorities exacted active and open, and 
 Wduld n(jt tolerate ])assive allegiance to the new nation, ilispels ;iny p' ssible illu- 
 sion ;is to lo\alt\- to the Crown. Its tardv nianifeslatiDii, until stimubitcd b\ self- 
 interest, is iiicom])atible with lo\al sincerit\-, or consistent with theactive vigiLuue 
 of .\mericans towards suspected bo\alisls. .\ lo\ally which is doimant, or linger- 
 ing, until spurred into action by the pros] fit (A material advancement is not gen- 
 eralJN- thought to be of the highest order, or to contain the elements from which 
 true ]:atri(itisni s])rings. liut whatever face tb.e I'K.vincial autlK-rities ma\ have 
 ])Ut u])on formal professions, it is ixidiut, from tlie (I'lici.d dicr.mcnls, that ll.c\- 
 looked ujion them ,is a g( od natured contrivann.-, ami were n(.l lUceivcd as to their 
 value. They were (juile content tit leceivi- a g( od class (-f setlkrs, < n their own 
 rating, without minutely scanning nmiivL's. 
 
 l\unning over the list of .\ssociatos, a similaritv if well kmuu names, ci m- 
 biuid \\ ith ])arit\' of objec'ts, create s a pn ^uui])liou that someiif tl:e old I'lasses o' 
 lo\alists had gone astray, or had I crn belated in iecei\ing grants, aiul had joined 
 the Assen'iates, as their last chance. Their ren gni/ed Io\al (juality, throu,L;h early 
 arrival, would tend to aid, materially, the .Associates in obtaining Tow ushi]' charters 
 and alU,tment of lands, but there- weie not many of them at the best. 
 
 There also a].]Kar, n( w and ll'.en, isolatei! ^jeeimens (f the old Coh.ni.il 
 Lnglish ( ffiCials wl;o may liaxe- east in tl.eir lot with the- .\sM»ciates, for tlu- reason 
 before maintained. .\ case in ]:oiut, and close- at hand, is th.it of the l.ite Samuel 
 Gale, whose hscal title of Judge- Gale, it will do no harm to accejjt. 'I'ln- ilec.iy of 
 his tombstone in ICast I'arnham seems, at irregular intervals of lime, to e.M'ite the 
 grief e»f the c .sual and curieais visitnf, and as the trembling fingers ],ush aside the 
 moss from the e])it.ij)h commemorating lU-iiarted \irtues and grc.ilnes--, a new rule 
 of historical interjtretation d.iwiis u],on tlu maddened mind, and jndgt- G.ile- is ].ro- 
 
14 
 
 Till", CANADIAN I.OVAMSTS. 
 
 iiiotril to the r. K. Loyalist class, to which he has no more rit^hl than to that of 
 Ju(i,L;e. 'I'here are iiisunnomitahle objections to his bein,t( so cf)nsi<lere(l. The true 
 r. Iv. Loyalist was a native born Colonial soMier, or the descendant of one. Ju'U;e 
 (rale was i;eilher. He was an I-'.nglish Colonial olTicial of the non-combatant ty])e, 
 then a refu,t,'ee, and later an Associate. Horn, reared and educated in Ivnj^dan d- 
 he came to the Colonies in i 770, secured a public oiTice and was married. When 
 the revolution came, his remarks were not api)reciated ; they raised a prejudice 
 aj.,'ainst him. One of his bio.ifrai)hers says : "He may have f)verste])ped the bounds 
 of a calculatinj.^ ])rudence."' After release on ])arole from imj)risonment, he joined 
 the Hritish Army near New Vf)rk in 1776, and for several years ])erfornied clerical 
 duties as cashier and itinerant paymaster for the army, and came to Canada a few 
 years after the close of the war. In a memorial to the British authorities in 17S7. 
 he refers to these things : to his loss of olTice and its profits, to the confiscation 
 of his ])roperty, and prayed therein, " for such relief as may ;ip])ear proportioiiate 
 " to what may have been granted to other suffering Loyalists, wiio likewise served 
 "in dcfyartinents of trust iu the civil hranclh's of the ixrniyy The civil branch is 
 not the fighting branch of an anny. I'or himself. Judge dale never claitned to 
 have been a s<jldier, or a U. K. Loyalist. Had he borne arms, it would have been 
 mentioned in his memorial. After his arrival he was given an olhce, and in 1798 
 he became leader of the Associates of the Township of l-'arnham, receiving a land 
 grant. His kind solicitude for his wife's collateral kin — and there wee ten in the 
 family — procured each of them considerable grants. lie had lofty i eas, atncjng 
 them being the desire to establish in I'arnham a family estate, after the I^nglish 
 pattern, with tenants, dogs and all the baronial fixtures. But in a new country 
 where salts was the leading iiuUistry, neat cattle current money, and the hospitable 
 stimulant for lordly revelry was distilled from the succulent potato, lie had to con- 
 tent himself with a coat of arms, and a local title conferred by neighbors, 
 jirudently anxious to projjiti'te the only man in the settlement who had a grind- 
 stone. Having starte<l early in life as a jmblic otTicer, and followed in that line for 
 many years, he hankered in his rural retirement for public position, and as he 
 could not be a Duke, he was ai)])ointed a notary jjublic, then, as now, an oflTice of 
 mystery, honor and emoluments. With this ofilce, and the op])ortunity of render- 
 ing valuable services to the early settlers, he closed an eventful life. But, after all, 
 is it a surprising thing that, in a time of i)eril, Judge (rale remained true to his 
 Sovereign rather than become an ally of the rebels? Had he followed aiicien 
 jirecedent in preferring ]X)ttage to I)irtliright, and cast in his lot with the rebel 
 Colonists, he would justly be held up to scorn, as a traitor to his sovereign. Being 
 an iMiglishman he was loyal, and those who now claim a special distinction for 
 him on that score, do his memory a gross injustice, and dis])lay ignorance of the 
 ICnglish character. It is an indirect way of saying that Ivnglish loyalty is a subject 
 of dicker, and barter, fidelity to allegiance an unusual incident, and an Ljiglish- 
 man's patriotism l)ased upon expectation of rewanL The end of the (|uestion is, 
 however, that he does not come within the terms of the Order in Council as to V . V,. 
 Loyalists. 
 
 In studying tlie ([uestioii of early settlement one may well kee]) in mind that 
 it was about 13 years after the location of the Loyalists before the first Township 
 
TIIIv CANADIAN LOYALISTS. 
 
 15 
 
 was created, and j^raiitfd to tlie Associates : that a survey was an essential ])rior 
 condition to a j^^rant : that the want of such survey is conchisive against a ^ranl ; 
 tlial the Government had forbidden settli nietit on the border ; that the uims at.d 
 conditions of the t^'rants to the T. K. Loyalists ditTered frotn those to the Associates, 
 and that the Order in Council absolutely settles the matter. 
 
 Whilst it is perfectly clear that the first settlers in the Townships, as a whole, 
 were not the old Loyalists, but the Associates, as before stated, yet it would seem 
 that a few stubborn men pitched their tents in the Seij.(niories wuen and wlure 
 there were no owners on the s]X)t to warn them olT, and frotn thence imjiortuned 
 the Government for jjermissioii to settle tlierein, on and about Missiscpioi Hay. 
 This was firmly, and at times ani^aily refused, the (iovernment offerin,!.; them lands 
 elsewhere, wh.ere the Crown owned the lands ; and on refusal they were ofluially 
 warned that their provision allowances woidd be cut lAl — a more serious matter 
 about the liay in 17.S4 than in 1900. iMually, the (iovernor General ordered their 
 houses to be destroyed, and the settlers sent for location to St, Johns, which, even 
 then, was called " a curseil ])lace." 
 
 Dr. I?rymner, the Dominion Archivist, has kindly furnished me with extracts 
 from the ofticial orders, on fyle in his Dejiartment, relatinjf to the discontinuance 
 of His Majesty's bounty of provisions for the winter, at Missis(|Uoi Bay, as well as 
 a memorial from the settlers there, to the Government in reference to the same 
 subject, whereby it is shown that effect was given Ui the apj)arently harsh orders. 
 The memorial is (juoted in full, among other things, because it shows the action 
 of the I'^xecutive, as well as the prior condition, and the then pressing needs of the 
 settlers, and, in addition, has a f|uaint flavor, which gives it a peculiar interest. 
 The lavish use of capital letters and ])eculiarities of spelling and punctuation 
 therein cannot be justly attribute*! to 'lisrespect or disloyalty. The Ivnglish lacks 
 the finish and perfection which are considered indispensable by the best writers of 
 our day, but then there is no doubt as to the object. The charges of fraud and 
 underhand dealing are ambiguous only as to identity of the parties whose names 
 are .su])pressed. In our day, Ragged l'hiloso])her would solve the dithcidty by 
 in.serting the familiar names of "Willie," or "Dickey," or "Joey," or other 
 symbolic terms, by which he playfully represents certain phases of human deprav- 
 ity in the criminal exercise of political functions. 
 
 The ^Memorial is as follows : 
 ' To //is /ixcellencc Henry / laumicltou, /Isqy.. Hox'ernor /// ati over the /'ror- 
 " iuee of Ouehee and 7)'rri(orys //lereunto he/oiii^iiti;, c--(., e~'r. , <!-(-. 
 " T/ie /'eti/ioii 0/ l/ie Siihserihers /tinnh/y s/ieartli 
 
 " That tile fift day of Octr. in the N'ear u'. our Lord, 17S;, we, with many 
 " otheres Petitioned His Kxcellency I'ridrick I laldemaml, Ks(|r., the then Gover- 
 " nor, and Commander in Chief, for a tract of land Hast of Missis(|uie Hay, for i'.ach 
 " (jf us there to recive his Portion of land, a]l(<wed by Government for services but 
 " not Reciveing an Answer to our Petition untill late in the Winter I'allowing, and 
 "we being Desireous, to Gil in .some way of Liveing again, and to retrive a little 
 "of our Losses (by Cultivation 1 which we sntTered During the unhajjpy troubles 
 "in North America which losses were \ery considerable with some of us, and \'erv 
 " Sorelv Feel'd bv I-'verv ( )ne of us and Your huud)le Petitioners, would not be 
 
i6 
 
 Till", CANADIAN I,( )VA LISTS. 
 
 " uii(kr the neccssety of Irouhk-iutj you, li;ul they at j)resent what they have lost, 
 
 " aii<l were n])lei(e(l to leave in tlie h.iiuls of the I",iieiii\ , since they from the he,L,Mii- 
 
 " \u^ of the late troultles in America, adheared to I'ritish ( i<nernment, and joined 
 
 ''the I'.ritish I'orces in the War 1777, but since, as above mentioned, were de- 
 
 " sirous to <;it into some way of livein,i(, we bouj^^ht a tract of land of Mr. Kobert- 
 
 " sun of vSt. Johns, and some of us settled thereon Ijefore Ivver his Kxcellence 
 
 " iM'idrick Ilaldemand, Ivscjr,, the late Commander in Chief had (iiveii Crders or 
 
 " I'ointed out Places for the setlin.t,^ of Loyalists, but so it was, that since soni'j of 
 
 "us had setled at the Ikiy of Missiscjuie, and ( )theres Could not move, when the 
 
 " orders came out for to setle at the ajjointed Places, by Heasson of Sickness, and 
 
 "()tlKre hindrence in their l'"amilies, and all of us ho])eint,r that we should \'et (Vid 
 
 " the land in the I'arts we Petitioned for, l)ut .so it was, since we dit not Go, to the 
 
 ' Place or Places ])ointed at, we were struck off the Provisions list, j)art of us since 
 
 "the 24th of May last, the Otheres at Different times After, but all of us since the 
 
 " 24th Octr. last. Wherefore we most Humbly be;,' your Kxcellence in your Clem- 
 
 " en("y, and love to N'our P'eflow Men, who have sorely sr.lTered During the late 
 
 "Rebellion both in body and I'.state. and Order that the Provision and Othere 
 
 " Donations Allowed to Loyalists, by Government, Should be (liven to us from the 
 
 "time that IC\ ery one of us, and I'amilics were .struck ofT the Provision list. .\nd 
 
 "we humbly bej^ \'our Ivxcellence will Please t(j Conde.send, to favour us with an 
 
 " .\nswvr, Withere we Shall ha\e Provision, Or no, for it is our Opinion that all 
 
 "loyalists, vSettlin.ii; in the Province of Quebec, are Alowed Provision wethere (jn 
 
 " kin.<.,'s land or, not. if within the Province line. Moreover, we humbly be^ to 
 
 "inform N'our P.xcellence, that we little Kx])ected, Nithere do we think, that it 
 
 " is (".ovenimcnts intention or any Order, from our ^b)st Gracious Kin^, atul his 
 
 " Perliment, that all such of his true and faithful! Subjects as Your Petitioners. 
 
 " vShould I)e struc off of all beniiefits from Government, as Donation of Provs. and 
 
 " Otlu re Tilings, allowed by Govert. Hxcept such and only such, who setle in 
 
 " them Perticuhir Places, which Perhapes through the Indication of Selfe intersted 
 
 " Gentlemen, has been Put into the head of the late Conmiander in Chief, to Point 
 
 "out for Setlin,!.^ of the Loyalists in the province of Ouebec, Furthere more, we 
 
 "doubt. Yea we are most sure, that there is some underhanded rJealin,sr with the 
 
 " kint^s Provs, by them who have the posts for (riveing Orders for the loyali.sts 
 
 " Provs. as for instance at St. Johns. lS:c,, ]•'( r we sent a Petition to Your Excel- 
 
 " lence Deer, last, and Never hear'd thereof, Wherefore we l)eir Your I'.xcellence 
 
 "will Please to Coiulesend to Derect Your Answer to Chn. \Vehr Lieut Late Royl. 
 
 " \'orkers at Missiscjuie Bay. and to the care of 3Ir. .\lexr. Taylor at St. Johns, and 
 "if Your Lxcellence will most Graciously Please to Grant us our Petition. Your 
 " Petitit)ners as in Duty Ijound vShall F.ver Pray. 
 
 (sd) Christian W'l'.iiK, (sd) Jo.s.xmixi) DRt)\v, 
 " CoNR.vni; I'iiisT, LonwiK Strit, Junr, 
 
 '* Christian .'M.wi'.R. J.vcon Tiiom.xs, 
 
 " JOHN RriTi:R. i'Hir.ii' Riithr. 
 
 Adam I )i:ai., 
 John Com:, 
 LiDwu; Stki;it, 
 Gi:oRf'.i'; Fkij.i:r. 
 ]Missisc]uie ISay, F'eb. 7th, 17S5. 
 
 John \'an \'orst, 
 
 JaMIIS Hl-NHI'RSiiN, 
 
 Ai,i:xr. Tavi.or, 
 

 Till-: CANADIAN LOYALISTS. 17 
 
 The naiiifs of •iK)st of the sillers of this i)athetioally iiitli,L;uaiit iiii'iiiorial hear 
 the earmark of Teutonic origin, althouj^'h some of the expressions have a ilistitic- 
 tively Hil)eriiian flavor. Dr. JJrymiier says, that anions all the documents relatin)^ 
 to Missi.s(|uoi Hay, that memorial is the(»nly one which contaitisa list of namesand 
 adds : " Nearly all of whom, I am aware, fought diirinj^f the war as loyalists." 
 The pressinj^ ini])ortance of the matters referred to in the memorial is sufVicieiil to 
 warrant the presum])tion, that all the ])eo])le there at that time, atlixid their sii,nia- 
 tures. The untenable possession of these Loyalists, as shown by their memorial, 
 does not justify a claim at this time of a t'eneral sfille!;!<.!'.t , !'.or W!r5:i;;l the |He- 
 tension that their temj)or;iry sojourn in a seij.,'niory, l)y itself, estahlislus an earlv 
 settlements as \'. I",. J.oyali.^ts in the Townshijjs of this District. 
 
 Of the si.ijners of that memorial a few Ciin he found amon,if the Assoi"'-.'.cs, for 
 instance, Adam Deal, I.udwij.,' Streit and I'hili]) Kuiter in Dunhr.m in 1796; the 
 same Adam Deal and also .Mexandtr Taylor and Christian Wehr in Sutton in 1797, 
 and in the sami" year, Thili]) Ruiter in Totton. 'i'here were other Ruitirs of the 
 same stock and class amonf.j the Associates in Dunham, I'otton and Stanhrid^^n-, as 
 well as six children of John Ruiter in Roxlon. The Ruitirs seem to have ])ros- 
 pered despite the drawback of havin,ij owned lands in Roxton. 
 
 The early settlements in .Missiscpioi and Hrome Counties ran alonj.; in-arl\ the 
 same lines, at about the same dates, and an;c::t^ nuich the same class of settlers, 
 but it was different in the County of Shetford. 
 
 The Townshij) of I'arnham, east and west ])arts, and the Townshi]) (jf liroue 
 were within the limits of vShefford County until disconnected in the '50's on the 
 formation of I'ronie Count)- at the ex])ense of Stanstead, ShefTord .and }.Iissis(iuoi 
 Counties. After prior survey, the Townshii)s of the County of Shetford were 
 created as follows : Stukely in iS;x); ShefTord in iSoi, Kly in iSc)2, and draubv, 
 Milton and Roxton in 1S03. The leader of the Associstes in Stukely was Samuel 
 Willard, an Intluential man in his day, who has still man\- descendants in the 
 Townships and in the Company of Associates are the well known names of Knowl- 
 ton, Lawrence, Sargent and I'a.i^e, also well re])resenteil by local de>ceiidants. 
 The lonjr period which had elapsed between the clo.ie of the war aiui their arrival 
 indicates that they did not deliberate in haste, nor should the coincidence of a 
 land ,i;rant be construed as a motive for (|uickened loyalty. The leader iA tlie 
 Associates of the Township of '-"ly was Amos Lay, jr., a land sur\eyor, who was 
 i^ranted one-fourth of the Township, much of which passed to his sou, the late Dr. 
 AmosW. La\, who resided there for many years i)rior to his death. Cov. I'rescott. 
 in a letter to the home authorities in 179'^, <letailinjf at some length the fraudrdent 
 schemes to obtain Crown Lands, ai)pears to ai)prove of a moveuu'ut, of which he 
 ,i(ives the copy of an advertisement ])ublished in \'ermont an<l other States, in\ ilin;.^ 
 apjilications for lands in the Townshi|)s. This advertisement was ^iven b\- .\n.os 
 W. La\-, jr., co-operatinj.; with Capt. Ruiter of Missiscjuoi, to obtain members for 
 Companies of .Associates. Shortlx jirior to the first settlement in b'.Iy, .1 land sur- 
 ve\or l'\- the name of Trenholme met a tragic death near what is is now known as 
 Dalliiij;, in the north ])art of the Townshiji, wlure he was surve\inti- witli a party. 
 A fire they had kindled in the forest burnt <{i the roots of a tree, which, during 
 
IS 
 
 Till-: CANAIMAX I,(»\A LISTS. 
 
 llu- nij^lil ftll iipiiii Mild instantly killi'(l Mr. TrtMiholnie. !Ii- was llu- ^r.mdt'ather 
 of Dr. N. W. Tiviiholnif, of .Montreal, and of Kev. Mrs. I'lsscndtii, of Ilaiuilton, 
 whose zealons work in creating i;ni])ire l)ay has ^'aine<l well deserved reco>{niti«)n. 
 
 There are some indications jiointin^ to a ineniber of the Kuiter family as the 
 leader of the Associates of tlie 'J'ownshij) of Roxton. There has been no rush to 
 oht.iin rri'dit for the jiositioii. No one h.is clamored for the honor, or even f(jr 
 that of first settler, thoiij.jh it has usually been the home of slatesmen. Half a 
 cintury aj.;o or th.c reahouts, all the jioor land was owned liy the British .\merican 
 Land Conii)any, from which it niij^hl he inferred that it was ])ractically sole pm- 
 ])rietor. The first settlements were made about 1S34. 
 
 Ciranby and Milton were lars^ely {.granted to discharmd soldiers and militia- 
 men, aliout one hundred of the latter local in j.( in Craiiby, which ni.iy account for 
 its martial spirit ever since. The descendants of the orij^inal ^iiaiitees of .Milton, 
 which was not much, if any, settled until about 1S3U. nave disappeared from its 
 limits. 
 
 More local history ])ervades the early settlement of Shefford at the commence- 
 ment of the century, at least more available local history, than of the other Town- 
 shi])s of the County. 
 
 The leader of the .Vssociates of SheiTord Townshi]) was Cu])i. John Sa\a^e 
 from the- Iludson or Mohawk \'allc\ of New \'ork, with ^\llonl. as .\ssociates, were 
 two other b)lin Sava<.jes and a I'eler Sava,i,a', relatives, and the well known names 
 of Wood, Hayes, Ket/back, Lawrence, Lewis, I!ell, MotTatt, and Mcl'arlamL 
 b)lin Sava.ue. leader, made his first \isit to Sheff(ird in 1792, ha\in,ir come to 
 Canada by way of Lake Champlain in 17.S3. Capt. Savajj;e and his Ass(tciates 
 had a narrow escape from the wiles of land j.rrabbers and ofticials who, by im])os- 
 \n\f severi' conditions, and coiis])irin,u; with survcxors, usually forced money or land 
 from Associates or so discoura:.;ed them thai they threw ii]) their a])])lications. 
 Simon Z. Watson, land surveyor, employed to make the ])rimili\e survey, dis- 
 covered the attempts to rob Ca])t. .Savaj^e and his .\ssociates without their knowl- 
 edj^e, and Lhereu])on threw up his job, and made a deposition (.xjjosinjr the tricks, 
 which he forwarded \.o the ( iovernor-( lem-ral, who, in communicating; it to the 
 Eni^lish Colonial authorities said : "■ The imbecility sIkiwii in the ])ractical workini^ 
 " of the ])lans of the monojjolists does not lessen the existence of the j)lans them- 
 " selves." I lad tliese ])lotlers succeeded the settlement of Shefford would ]iroba- 
 bly havi' bci-ii as long deferred as Hly and Roxton. Whilst the official records 
 s])eak of Ca])t. Savage and S(|uire .Savage, it is prol)able that both titles belonged 
 to the same man, one for warlike, and the other for civil distinction. In his 
 ]>etitioii to the (ioverniiieiit in 171^2 for compensation for losses, hv alleged his ser- 
 vices as an olhcer in a New \'ork Colonial corjxs during the Revolution. His 
 (luality was acce])ted by the ( Vovernment. Ijut the grant to him later was as an 
 .\ssociate. In 1 7S3 a rejiort from a fronlier ])ost says : " Wright has returned with 
 " two brothers .Savage, who have come to look for an asylum for a great number 
 " of U)yalists, who are determined to leave a country wholly under the direction of 
 " the op])re.ssors." Cajit. Savage went on from that border jjost to St. Johns. An 
 ofllcial report from that ])ost on the frmtier said, that the ])eo])le on the American 
 side ware \ery insulting in their remarks, ])ut in a i)road sjjirit of magnaminity, 
 
 ih 
 \\ 
 
 tl 
 
 b 
 
 in 
 
 mi 
 
 be 
 
 int 
 
 im 
 
 Hi 
 
 WC' 
 
 ill 
 
Tin, CANAhl AN I.( »\' AI.ISTS. 
 
 '9 
 
 the <itlic'ial> sjiiil lluy ir^^iiK'ad ii ;■•< iiu nly " tlif mail .'•allits of \ iilj^ar fcols." 
 whiili iiiiiy iKt have hn-n loo n.\*.rf. 'I'lu m iiu' ( llirial rfporl as to S.iva^'e statts 
 that MisMs. Ci'Jii])l)tll and Ihiiitiiij^tiii, two luimd lo\ali>ls l.ail arrixiil, t'olli wtd 
 by a Mr. Wirt, \\l:o <kiiiain'nl ll.cir riliini to I'osion. Mr. Hr,iitiiij,;toii utiiaiiu-d 
 ill Canada, hut a littlf hittr Cainpliill \\i iit hack with S ivaj^^i- and Ira .\1U-ii to \\r- 
 monl, to aid in seltlin.n loyalists thin-. ])ursuant to a sidu-nu- of AlKn's, It soon 
 hfca'iic dear that this was a dod^c of AlKn's to inciti- Con.tjriss to admit W-rnioiit 
 into thi- I nion. ami lherfUi>on llii-y ahaiiilout d tht- crafty .\lUn, Thr Mr. Hunt- 
 inijtoii rc'fcrrcMl to was ]irohahly ;i relative, or ancestor, of iIk- late lion. Lucius vSeth 
 lluntinj.'ton, who reprcsfiittMl ;'litft'ord for so many yt-ars in rarlianuiit. It was 
 wi'll known that he was of T. I-",. I oyalist stocl;, thonjdi it liad not hecome a hal)it 
 in his day to hoast oi it osteiit.tt'i)Usly. 
 
 The early histo; y of SliilTord Townsliij) is the history of the Sa\a;,'e familv. 
 It was the dominant family in its e.irly settU'menl. and e\en u]> to the middle of 
 the century, hut (jidy a few are now left there. Tluy wert' of Hutch descent, 
 Ihougli the name creates a difticuU\ . it may have heeii .\niericani/.e<l and toned 
 down from a Dutch name, as have the Churches and I'ickels of I)unham, who in 
 the Dutch dialeit were resj)ecti\ely Schnrz and I'uyckel, or sonu-thin.i.; like. It h.is 
 als(. been said that in an early day an Irisliman named Savage married a Dutch 
 .nirl in the Dutch settlements of New N'ork, and hence the name, 'i'liis does m^^ 
 seem unreasonable when we consider tlu' not unremarkable ]»ro])i'nsity of Irisiniien 
 to coiinnil matrimony, and the facility with which the Dutch absorb the assimi- 
 lated races. I'.ut all this may be left to a future historian of Shel'ford or of the Sav- 
 age family. 
 
 In the uf'e c,i the leim. " Marly Seltkrs." in this pa])er. its meanin.y is]<ro]ierly 
 restricted to tliost.' who receixed free grants of land from the Crown, llowevi-r 
 commendable may lia\e bi en tb.e enter] iHse and virtues of those who " bouj..;lit in," so 
 tos])eak, thex' ha\e no s])ei'ial claim for consideration on the score of loyah\ bevd'.d 
 earlier, or even later settlers. Nor can it reas(jnably lie assumed tliat. because a 
 few Lo\alists strayed from tlie ]»lace where the C.overnment had located them, and 
 subse(juentl\- ac(|uired lands in tlie 'i'ownshi]is as Associates, or by ])urc]iasi-. a 
 claim of j^eneral settlement by I'. I',. Loyalists in any loi-ality can be justified or 
 su])]M)rte(L It is not, however, disireditable t<j those old I'. 1',. Loyalists that so 
 man\' in our dav are eager to idaim desi'enl from tliiin. It is an «. xcellent testi- 
 monial of their worth. It a])]iears to be akin to tlie claim of Puritan descent in 
 New I'',nj.(land. (<r Xormau descent in ( )M I',n;.;land. and exposed to the same scofTs 
 and sus])icions on the part of tho.se not oi the Idood. 
 
 but when one casts a retros])ective 5.;lance over tin- history of the settlement 
 and develo],nu nt of this District, anil of its first settlers and their .successors, one 
 readily sees that a fair ami moderate view is esstutial, and that to discriminate is 
 impolitic and unjust. The old .Xsscjciates were the true jiioneers, who bej^an the 
 forest clearinjf e](jch witlunit rel_\ iiij^ ujion (rOVLrnmenl bount\ for provisions (jr 
 aid. .\nd after tluni, in the 2o's. or about that time there came from New L'.ii.Ldand its 
 surplus of skilleil mechanics and tradesmen, and even jjrofessional men. wl.o. 
 
2t) 
 
 Till'. CANADIAN I,()\A LISTS. 
 
 with their triiiiu <! skill ami lai^rr tiu-aiis, plaiHMl thiir httk' sh«)])S ami ttiills an<l 
 hir.inlJrii N ami taiim rifs oii t-vi-rs roiuiniciit watir pnvvrr am! tl\iTi'hy aidiil in i'\. 
 irii(liii),' Ihr l;(i()i1 work hi-^aii hy thoM' ohl Assoi-iatis. Is it imt larLii'ly from llu- 
 (U'sc'iinlaiits of that lati-r class that have coiiu' tlu- men whosi- hiisim-ss fiij)aiMty 
 aiifl tiitirprisi- have done so mmh to Itiiihl n]» thtsf Masti-rn Townships. Norwil] 
 il hi- for^^ottcn that throiii^h all tlu- years, pcopk' of othiT races, and ]ico])h' fidni 
 the ohi worM have lilterifl into lluse Townships, assiniilateil with tlu- older stocks, 
 •iml aided in ad\ancin.u its pmsjierily. Ili-nct', the wisdom or exjiediency of nn- 
 dnly e\altini,r (Hie (-lass more than another is (piestioiiahle, thon^h, as an abstract 
 historical (|m'siion there ma\ he. and ari-, j^ood reasons for jndicions investij^ation. 
 I'.ut, ho\\e\er, lhisnia\ he, we cannot honesiI\ fcirL^el that it is from the fct hli-, re- 
 mote .m<l siattiTcd ^ettletnents wldi-h those hanh pioneers created ahout a ct'iiliiry 
 I'^o, I'.i.it have come material ])ros])erit\ . and the comforts of civilization, whicli 
 
 we, ( 
 
 )f thi 
 
 s lieneratton. so 
 
 fnll 
 
 \ ])ossess and eiiji 
 
 We should treasnre with honest 
 
 a])preciation tin- mi'morii-s of those rohnst mi-n of the olden time, who diij so much 
 nuiler adverse conditions .and tr\ iny; circumstances to huild up oin country s> i tli.il 
 life for us is iiiou' tolerahle, ami the future full of emdin;iu;eiiient. It is to he re- 
 j.;retted that the i>id\ ])hase of thi- personal life of those early pioneers can onl\- he 
 j.;athen.d from di\ oflii'ial records, di'.dini.; with the wants .and conditions of 
 materi.d esistt'iice. No historian recorded their .ids. nor jxiet portrayed tlieir 
 .sentiments in verse.