t^. 
 
 
 .orV«>:>^.A. 
 
 IMAGE EVALUATION 
 TEST TARGET (,V\T-3) 
 
 
 1.0 
 
 1.1 
 
 |50 ™"=^ 
 
 2.5 
 
 M 
 1.8 
 
 1-25 1.4 1.6 
 
 
 ■^ 
 
 6" 
 
 ► 
 
 m 
 
 
 
 
 Photographic 
 
 Sciences 
 Corporation 
 
 23 WEST MAIN STREET 
 
 WEBSTER, N.Y. 14580 
 
 (716) 872-4503 
 
CIHM/ICMH 
 
 Microfiche 
 
 Series. 
 
 C9HM/ICMH 
 Collection de 
 microfiches. 
 
 Canadian Institute for Historical Microreproductions / Institut Canadian de microreproductions historiques 
 
Technical and Bibliographic Notes/Notes techniquas at bibliographiquas 
 
 Tha Instituta hat attamptad to obtain tha bast 
 original copy availabia for filming. Faaturas of this 
 copy which may ba bibliographically uniqua, 
 which may altar any of tha images in the 
 reproduction, or which may significantly change 
 the usual method of filming, are checked below. 
 
 Coloured covers/ 
 Couverture de couleur 
 
 I I Covers damaged/ 
 
 D 
 
 Couverture endommagia 
 
 Covers restored and/or laminated/ 
 Couverture restauria et/ou pelliculie 
 
 I — I Cover title missing/ 
 
 D 
 
 Le titre de couverture manque 
 
 Coloured maps/ 
 
 Cartes giographiquas en couleur 
 
 □ Coloured ink (i.e. other than blue or black)/ 
 Encre de couleur (i.e. autre que bleue ou noire) 
 
 
 D 
 
 D 
 
 Coloured plates and/or illustrations/ 
 Planches et/ou illustrations en couleur 
 
 Bound with other material/ 
 Ralii avac d'autres documents 
 
 Tight binding may cause shadows or distortion 
 along interior margin/ 
 
 La »e Mure serrie peut causer de I'ombre ou de la 
 distortion le long de la marge intArieure 
 
 Blank leaves added during restoration may 
 appear within the text. Whenever possible, these 
 have been omitted from filming/ 
 II se peut que certaines pages blanches ajout^es 
 lors d'une restauration apparaissent dans le texte, 
 mais, lorsque cela 6tait possible, ces pages n'ont 
 pas 6t6 fiim^es. 
 
 Additional comments:/ 
 Commentaires suppl^mentairas; 
 
 T 
 ti 
 
 L'Institut a rnicrofi'mi le meilleur exemplaire 
 qu'il lui a 6ti possible de se procurer. Les details 
 de cet exemplaire qui sont peut-Atre uniques du 
 point de vue bib*iographique, qui peuvent modifier 
 une image reproduite, ou qui peuvent exiger une 
 modification dans la mithoda normaie de filmage 
 sont indiquAs ci-dessous. 
 
 I I Coloured pages/ 
 
 D 
 
 Pages de couleur 
 
 Pages damaged/ 
 Pages endommagdes 
 
 □ Pages restored and/or laminated/ 
 Pages restaurdes et/ou pelliculdes 
 
 □ Pages discoloured, stained or foxed/ 
 Pages d6color6es, tachetdes ou piqu6es 
 
 □Pages detached/ 
 Pages ddtachdes 
 
 Showthroughy 
 Transparence 
 
 Quality of prir 
 
 Qualiti inigale de I'impression 
 
 Includes supplementary materia 
 Comprend du materiel suppl^mentaire 
 
 D 
 
 7 
 P 
 
 
 
 fi 
 
 C 
 
 fa 
 t 
 
 s 
 
 
 
 f 
 
 s 
 
 
 
 rrja Showthrough/ 
 
 I I Quality of print varies/ 
 
 I I Includes supplementary material/ 
 
 I — I Only edition available/ 
 
 Seule Edition disponible 
 
 Pages wholly or partially obscured by errata 
 slips, tissues, etc., have been refilmed to 
 ensure the best possible image/ 
 Les pages totalement ou partiellement 
 obscurcies par un feuillet d'errata. une pelure, 
 etc., ont 6t6 filmies d nouveau de faqon d 
 obtenir la meilleure image possible. 
 
 This item is filmed at the reduction ratio checked below/ 
 
 Ce document est filmA au taux de rMuction indiqu* ci-dessous. 
 
 10X 14X 18X 22X 
 
 12X 
 
 1SX 
 
 20X 
 
 26X 
 
 30X 
 
 y 
 
 24X 
 
 28X 
 
 ■w 
 
Th« copy filmed h«r« has b««n raproduead thankt 
 to tha ganarosity of: 
 
 Metropolitan Toronto Library 
 Science & Technology Department 
 
 Tha imagas appaaring hara ara tha baat quality 
 possibia considaring tha condition and lagiblllty 
 of tha original copy and In kaaping with tha 
 filming contract spacif Icationa. 
 
 Original coplaa in printad papar covara ara filmad 
 beginning with tha front eovar and anding on 
 tha last paga with a printad or lllustratad impraa- 
 sion. or tha bacic covar whan appropriata. Ail 
 othar original copiaa ara filmad beginning on tha 
 first paga with a printad or lllustratad impraa- 
 sion, and anding on tha laat paga with a printad 
 or illuatratad impraaaion. 
 
 Tha last racordad frama on aach microfiche 
 shall contain tha symbol ^»> (meaning "CON- 
 TINUED"), or tha symbol y (meaning "END"), 
 whichever applies. 
 
 Maps, plates, charts, etc.. may be filmed at 
 different reduction ratios. Those too large to be 
 entirely included in one exposure are filmed 
 beginning in the upper left hand corner, left to 
 right and top to bottom, as many frames as 
 required. The following diagrams illustrate the 
 method: 
 
 L'exemplaira film* fut reproduit grice A la 
 gAnArosit* de: 
 
 IMetropolitan Toronto Library 
 Science & Technology DepartnMnt 
 
 Les imeges suivantes ont At* reproduites avec la 
 plus grand soin. compta tenu de la condition et 
 de le nettet* de I'exemplaire film*, et en 
 conformitA avec les conditions du contrat da 
 filmage. 
 
 Lea exempleires originoux dont la couvarture on 
 papier est imprimie sent fiimAs en commen^ant 
 per le premier plat et en terminant soit par la 
 darnlAre page qui comporte une empreinte 
 d'inr. nression ou d'illustration. soit par la second 
 plat, salon le cas. Tous las autres exempleires 
 originaux sont fiimis en commenpent par la 
 pramlAre paga qui comporte une empreinte 
 d'impression ou d'illustration at en terminant par 
 la darniire page qui comporte une telle 
 empreinte. 
 
 Un dee symboles suivants apparattra sur la 
 darnlAre imafie de cheque microfiche, selon le 
 cas: le symbole -*• signifie "A SUiVRE", le 
 symbols V signifie "FIN". 
 
 Les cartes, planches, tableaux, etc.. peuvent Atre 
 filmAs A des taux de rAduction diffArents. 
 Lorsque le document est trop grand pour Atre 
 reproduit en un seul clichA. il est fiimA A partir 
 de I'angle supArieur gauche, de gauche A droite. 
 et de haut an bas. en prenant le nombre 
 d'images nAcessaire. Las diagrammes suivants 
 illustrent la mAthode. 
 
 1 2 3 
 
 1 
 
 2 
 
 3 
 
 4 
 
 5 
 
 6 
 
mm 
 
 
 'A' ^ 
 
 
 PUBLICATIONS 
 
 FROM I UK 
 
 BIOLOGICAL LABORATORY 
 
 (IF TFIK 
 
 UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO. 
 
 No. III. STUDIES ON THE BLOOD OF AMPHIBIA. 
 By A. B. MACALLUM, M.B., Ph.D. 
 
 (Reprinted from the Transactions of the Canadian Institute, Vol. It.. Pt. S.) 
 
 TORONTC*: 
 
 ThK Corp, C'LAKK COMPANV, LlMlTBD, PrIKTKR.S. 
 
 - . 1892. 
 
 
 '" V 'V'tt^^'-'-i: .'''r. ■ L'^''*'/~ 
 
 '■f>r-^m 
 
 / ■>• 
 
 l^i:4 
 
 - .■■.^>;f SI 
 
 ■•*- . ■ f^l 
 
 
 
 ' 't'-~-. 
 
 -:...-vf'i*/- 
 
 
5-* 
 
 --9' ' 
 
 'jy 
 
 V« -iJ... 
 
 *■ ' y. 
 
 Mm^ 
 
 *? ■> 
 
 ¥• 
 
 iV 
 
 , Mfe ^:- AUG 31 tSSi 
 
 * '';..C 
 
 v.<- 
 
 ^^ s 
 
 <'.' 
 
 '. iV 
 
 
 f-?-. 
 
 'J^. 
 
 ':A^\ 
 
 H - V. »' '5 ' ", 
 
 « .^ 
 
 1?. i' 
 
 
 ^V' 
 
 
 \ ' 
 
 ) L '> 
 
 * w'r* 
 
 '\V 
 
 -^?^ 
 
 ^ / 
 
 S ^ 
 
 ' '.^ M 
 
 -«?. 
 
 .-VJ 
 
 ''^.- 
 
 <^^ 
 
 . V r K. 
 
 .VS&A 
 
 l.-T 
 
 .K\ 
 
[Exlnict Jrom Transactions of the Cancutian Institute, l,SH()!lJ.\ 
 
 STUDIES ON THE BLOOD OF AMPHIBIA. 
 
 By a. B. Macallum, M.B., Ph.D. 
 
 Lecturer on Physiology, University of Toronto. 
 
 (Read lyth January, i8gi.) 
 CONTENTS. 
 
 Section i. The Origin of Haemoglobin. 
 
 a. Methods of Study. 
 
 b. Structure of the Blood Corpuscles. 
 
 c. The Origin of the Haemoglobin in the Red Discs. 
 Section 2. The Fu.siform Corpuscles. 
 
 Section 3. The Origin of the Ha^matoblasts. 
 Section 4. Conclusions. 
 Section 5. Appendix. 
 
 ill 
 
 
 
 I. The Origin of H/Emoglobin.* 
 
 In the following pages are given the results of studies commenced 
 five years ago and continued with short intermissions till last summer. 
 The length of time taken up in this work was necessarily great because of 
 the lack of previous studies in the same line and because of the want of 
 definite and exact knowledge on the .subject of the micro-chemical 
 reactions of haemoglobin. The difficulty of detecting, by chemical or 
 microscopical methods, any antecedents of haemoglobin appeared so 
 formidable that, at one time early in the work, I was on the point of 
 abandoning the line of investigation altogether. 
 
 I have used for this investigation our Lake Lizard, Necturus lateralis, 
 and the larvae of Amblystoma punctatum which are readily obtainable in 
 large numbers in the immediate neighborhood of Toronto in April and 
 May. The advantages which the tissues and structures in the Necturus 
 present for cytological work far outweigh those which a comparative 
 study of the blood in a larger number of Amphibian forms would have 
 and there is, therefore, a justification for narrowing the investigation to 
 the two named forms. 
 
 * The subject matter of this paper was included in a thesis presented for the degree of 
 Doctor of Philosophy in the Johns lIopl<ins University, in April, 1888, 
 
 I*! 
 
46 
 
 TRANSACTIONS OP TUB CANADIAN IN8TITIITR. 
 A. METHODS OF STUDY. 
 
 [Vol. II. 
 
 At the outset of an investif^ation like this, one has to answer the 
 question : How far can we rely on the different effects in staining 
 pr jduced by a dye in determining the dissimilarity in composition of the 
 obj'icts stained ? We can illustrate the question by a case in point : 
 safr. nin stains the nuclei of the red blood cells of Necttirus orange-red 
 when they are fixed in a certain way, while the nuclei of ordinary cells 
 under ';he same conditions take a red color. Does this indicate that the 
 substance in the nuclei of the red corpuscles which is stained orange-red 
 is differiMit in its chemical composition from that in ordinary nuclei .' 
 An affirr.iative and a negative answer are equally consistent with what 
 we know .is yet of the relation between staining reagent and object stained. 
 It is quite possible to imagine the molecules of the staining reagent in 
 the object stained so placed relatively to the molecules of the latter that 
 though no chemical union results, certain kinds of the light rays become 
 absorbed in their passage through the object. It is further possible to 
 conceive th; t variation of the distance of the molecules from each other 
 in the object stained may result in a variation of the rays transmitted. 
 .Staining is n this sense a result of a physical condition, and as such 
 many consider it. It is easy also to understand that if the molecules of 
 one stained object should be different in structure from those of another, 
 the interarra igement of these with those of the same staining reagent 
 might .affect the light transmitted in each of the two cases differently. 
 In such the difference in color would depend on a difference in 
 chemical composition while the stain in itself would be referable to a 
 physical condition. In addition to these three possible modes in the 
 production of staining reactions there are two others, viz., the action of 
 the stained material in bringing about a change in the composition of 
 the staining reagent and the definite chemical combination of the staining 
 and stained material. The action of the stained object on the staining 
 reagent is illustrated by the effect produced by the chromatin of the 
 hsmatoblasts in the Amblystoma larva; on alum haematoxylin, the 
 usual color given by the latter reagent to ordinary nuclear constituents 
 being there turned to a slate tint. That chemical combination does 
 occur in the case of some reagents is shown by Unna's experiments with 
 several aniline dyes.* 
 
 There being, thus, probably several ways by which a stain in an object 
 could be effected, it is manifestly impossible to prove in regard to any 
 particular dye, whether, when it stains a .series of objects, the same 
 resulting colors in the latter are produced by the same or different 
 
 •Arch, fur Mikr. Anat., Bd. XXX. p. 38. 
 
 
1890-91. J 
 
 AMPHIBIA BLOOD STUDIES. 
 
 interaction, pliysical or chemical, of dye and object. It is of course not 
 even probable that the chromatin elements of all cells are chemically the 
 same except in the main outlines of their structural formul;e, yet aluin- 
 h.-ematoxylin or alum-cochincal gives usually the same color re.iction in 
 all Here the efifcct is the same but the interaction may or may not be 
 the same in all cases. The subject belongs to borderland between 
 physics and chemistry and we can conceive that the interaction may lie 
 on one side or the other of any arbitrary line drawn to separate the two 
 domains without resulting in any visible difference in color. If different 
 colors should result when chromatin elements, for example, are stained 
 by a dye, then it may be safely inferred that the groups of atoms in the 
 variously stained elements are differently related to the groups of atoms 
 in the staining reagent. It might be suspected in such a case that the 
 difference in stain might depend on a difference in chemical composition 
 and this suspicion would become certainty, if a second dye were found 
 to act in a similar way towards the same chromatin elements. 
 
 The difficulties which surround the solution of questions of this sort 
 are very numerous but they are multiplied when one multiplies the 
 methods of hardening or fixing tissues. These methods greatly vary 
 the effects of a single staining reagent on cellular structures. On this 
 account no conclusion of any great value has been drawn as to chemical 
 nature of any cellular substance from the employment of staining 
 reagents alone. On the other hand the employment in cytological 
 research of chemical reagents on objects under the microscope has not 
 been, even to a limited extent, successful. 
 
 I have put forward all the difficulties which a research like this 
 presents and they have all through this work been before my mind. 
 I have resorted to the processes of staining, because the question 
 of the origin of haemoglobin is an all important one and because 
 I can see no other means of settling it. It may be said that the 
 means are insufficient. I can only say in answer that I have tried 
 to do the best with them and the conclusions given in this paper are 
 drawn from the results obtained by the employment not of a few but of 
 a very large number of methods of hardening and staining. It is only by 
 the employment of various staining reagents that one can avoid the 
 errors resulting from an adherence to one or to a few microscopical 
 methods and at the same time reach, usually, at least, measureably 
 certain conclusions. 
 
 My first labors in this investigation were directed to finding a reagent 
 which would show the presence not only of h.-emoglobin, but of its 
 
48 
 
 TRANSACTIONS OF TIIK CANADIAN INSTITUTB. 
 
 [Vol. II. 
 
 
 antecedent if such existed. I need hardly go over the list of wearisome 
 experiments which I made for this purpose. Many, but not all, of these 
 were resultless. Of the dyes at my disposal belonging to the aromatic 
 group of organic compounds, Eosin is the only one which I found useful. 
 As will be shown below it reacts with haemoglobin and, in conjunction 
 with alum-ha.'nr,atoxylin or alum-cochineal, it is a reagent for the 
 antecedent of the pigment. Taken of course alone, without employing 
 any other reagent for control purposes, it gives results far from satisfactory 
 and it is also very misleading. Another reagent, the employment of 
 which has been of great value to me, is the .staining fluid of Shakespeare 
 and Norris,* and which I shall name throughout this paper, for the sake of 
 brevity, the Indigo-carmine Mixture or Fluid. 
 
 This fluid is made according to a formula which I have modiflcd from 
 that given by Bayerl, and consists of a mixture of equal volumes of the 
 following solutions : — 
 
 A — Carmine, 2 grms ; Borax, 8 grms ; Distilled Water, lOO c.c. 
 B. — Sulphindigotate of Soda (Indigo-carmine), 8 grams ; Borax, 
 8 grms ; Distilled Water, lOO c.c. 
 
 In preparing each of these solutions, the borax is ground up in a mortar 
 with the dye, the water poured on, and the whole allowed to stand for 
 from five to seven hours before filtering. Owing to the fact that much of 
 the Indigo-carmine in the market is impure, and consequently alters its 
 composition in solution in a couple of weeks, it is not advisable to prepare 
 more than 25 — 50 cc. of solution B at a time. I have obtained 
 quantities of the reagent which retained in solution for three months its 
 normal staining properties. As A, when kept for a year or more, readily 
 shows undiminished staining power, a larger quantity may be prepared 
 : as " stock " solution. 
 
 The section to be stained is left in the fluid for fifteen minutes, then 
 plunged in a saturated solution of oxalic acid for ten minutes, washed in 
 distilled water, dehydrated with absolute alcohol, cleared in pure xylol, 
 and mounted in benzol balsam. Preparations made in this way two 
 years ago still retain undiminished their original stain. When I first 
 employed the fluid, four years ago, I used clove-oil for clearing, and 
 found that my preparations faded, or contained a dirty precipitate after 
 three or four weeks. The removal of the clove-oil after clearing with 
 
 * I have not seen the paper of Shakespeare and Norris describing the stain or its properties 
 and capacities and my attention was first directed to it by Bayerl's work on the formation of 
 blood corpuscles on the margins of ossifying zones in bones : Arc/i. fur Mikr. Ana/. Bd 
 XXIIl. p. 30. 
 
 
1890-91.] 
 
 AMPHIBIA BLOOn STUOIKS. 
 
 49 
 
 xylol, postponed, but did not prevent, fadintj. It seems that the essential 
 oils, even in small quantities, possess an oxidising; power to which the 
 sulphindigotatc of soda is subject. 
 
 In order to get the best effects with this stain, the tissues arc to be hard- 
 ened with reagents which preserve the hiemoL^lobin and its norinal dis- 
 tribution in the corpuscles. Some of the ordinary hardening reagents do 
 not fix haemoglobin (Midler's Fluid and solutions of potassic bichromate), 
 others decompose it (weak solutions of chromic acid), while others again 
 cause the hajmoglobin and the so-called stroma containing it to shrink 
 irregularly in the corpuscles. The very fact that a reagent removes or 
 decomposes the haemoglobin does not prevent its employment in the 
 stutiy of the mode of formation of the pigment, but points to its useful- 
 ness in testing and controlling the results obtained by reagents which fix 
 the haemoglobin well. For instance, I have used chromic acid for the 
 purpose of removing the haemoglobin and fixing the antecedent. Even 
 in the list given below the haemoglobin-fixing prc<pcrty is not the same 
 in all, and again the reagent which fixes the h;emoglobin in the red 
 corpuscles in pieces of the spleen niay not have the same property as 
 regards cover-glass preparations of the blood. These facts should be 
 borne in mind in every research on red blood corpuscles. The method 
 which I adopted after a long series of experiments was as follows : — 
 
 Small portions of the spleen of iV^f/«rwj were allowed to lie half-an- 
 hour in a saturated solution of corrosive sublimate, or five days in 
 Erlicki's Fluid, or twenty-four hours in a \ — ,?,% solution of chromic 
 acid, five hours in a saturated solution of picric acid or two to five hours 
 in I % solution of osmic acid. They were afterwards washed in distilled 
 water and put in alcohol of 50% strength for two hours and then in 70% 
 for twenty-four hours and finally in 95%. The 70% alcohol was changed 
 several times, each at an interval of twenty-four hours in the case of the 
 chromic and picric preparations. The pieces were imbedded, either in 
 mucilage and sectioned on the freezing microtome, or by the chloroform 
 method in paraffin by which sections of about 5 — lO/^ were made. The 
 latter were freed from paraffin with turpentine and passed through 
 absolute alcohol to water in the usual way. These, as well as those 
 prepared with the freezing microtoine. were transferred to the Indigo- 
 carmine Fluid and treated in the manner described above. 
 
 The f^reat value of these preparations consists in the fact that h.-emo- 
 globin is stained grass-green or greenish-blue while other proteid elements 
 are colored red. This grass-green or greenish-blue is shown by a few 
 other elements, but thiese are so well known and so easily recognised that 
 no confusion can result. The numberof structures other than haematogenic 
 
flO 
 
 TRANHAmONH OF TUB OANADIAN INHTITI TE. 
 
 [Vol. 11. 
 
 I 
 
 to which the Indif^o-ciirmine Fluid pivcs ,i tjrass green color are so few 
 that thoy may be mentioned here : the yolk spherules, the degcueratin^j. 
 peripherally arranged, nucleolar bodies in the nuclei of maturing amphibian 
 ova, the nuclei (.f some of the clavate cells in the skin of Necturus, als(j 
 some of the nuclei of some of the ci'taneous mucous glands of the same 
 (in chromic aciil ureparations), the nuclear and cellular elements in the 
 stratum granulosum and stratum lucidum of the epidermis, structures in 
 the sheaths and cellular layers of hair follicles, yolk-lik -. elements in the 
 protoplasmic layer (syncytium) covering the chorionic villi in the cat, 
 the substance of the dim band in striated muscle fibre, and finally, 
 though not so distinctly, the lardacei •. of amyloid degeneration. It will 
 be seen from this list that except in the Amblystoma larvJE in which 
 there is abundance of yolk spherules, there is no danger of mistaking any 
 other compound for h.cmoglobin. Where such a mistake was possi- 
 ble as in the case of the larvai, I resorted to other staining reagents. 
 From the list given it is to be inferred that the Indigo-carmine Fluid is a 
 valuable reagent for certain processes of cellular degeneration. In 
 connection with striated muscle fibre the reaction is significant, pointing 
 to the derivation in the Amblystoma larvas, of a portion at least of the 
 dim band from the yolk spherules (the hsmatogen of Bunge?) or demon- 
 strating in the dim bands in Necturus the presence of the red pigment 
 described as haemoglobin (KUhne, Ray-Lankester, Levy and Hoppe- 
 Seyler) or as myoh,Tematin (MacMunn). 
 
 I stated that the reaction of the Indigo-carmine Fluid with haemoglobin 
 results in a grass-green or a greenish-blue color, but, strictly speaking, the 
 greenish-blue color or stain should appear only when the haemoglobin 
 has been fixed with corrosive sublimate. I omitted to state, moreover, 
 that the antecedent of haemoglobin gives under certain conditions the 
 grass green color with the staining reagent. 
 
 Bayerl* endeavoured in the following way to prove that the substance 
 in the red corpuscles staining grass green with the Indigo-carmine Fluid 
 is haemoglobin : A quantity of dried amorphous haemoglobin from dog's 
 blood was dissolved in water, mixed with the indigo-carmine Fluid and 
 the mixture treated with a saturated solution of oxalic acid. The color 
 of the whole was grass-green. This experiment is not so decisive as it 
 appears from the description, for I found that it is only once in a while that 
 a green shade appears in the mixture. I found also on spectroscopic 
 examination of the mixture, that the haemoglobin was on the addition 
 of oxalic acid more or less rapidly transformed into hsematin. Even 
 
 * Loc cit. 
 
1890-yi.] 
 
 AMPHIIIU IlLOOI) HTUDIKH. 
 
 Al 
 
 few 
 
 "If,', 
 lian 
 il.so 
 nil." 
 the 
 in 
 the 
 cat, 
 
 when a quantity of solution H. (sec p. 224) alone was mixed with a pure 
 solution of ha-mofjlobin and the mixture treated with a saturated 
 solution of oxalic acid there resulted only a dirty brownish precipitate 
 from the decomposed hiL-mo^'lobin. This proves that soluble hieino- 
 globin cannot yield any reliable reactions with the Indigo-carmini. l-'luid. 
 Acting on the view that the h.x'.no^lobin in my preparation is a 
 fixed insoluble compound and therefore quite different from that obtained 
 for example, by niere crystallization from dog's blood, I modified Bayerl's 
 experiment. I took pure crystallized h;emo^dobin from do^'s blood, 
 dissolved it in distilled water and mixed it with an equal volume of 
 ajjar-agar solution* made liquid at 42X. Stirred rapidly and then 
 cooled by plunging the base of the containing Vv'^ssel in pounded ice, th.i 
 deep red agar-agar mixturr 'incomes firm enough to cut with a knife. 
 I made pieces about one-eighth of an inch in thickness which I put in 
 various hardening fluids, as in the case of the spleen of the Nectiirus. 
 When the fixation was complete the excess of the reagent was removed 
 with alcohols 50%, 70% and 00% successively, sections of the pieces 
 were made on the freezinfj microtome and stained with the Indigo- 
 carmine Fluid. The preparations made with chromic acid or Erlicki's 
 Fluid gave a grass-green reaction while those made with corrosive 
 sublimate gave a greenish blue, practically the same results as in 
 the case of the hjemoglobin in the red corpuscles. The fact that the cor- 
 rosive sublimate preparations gave a greenish blue color with the Indigo- 
 carmine Fluid, while the other preparations gave a grass-green, would 
 lead one to suspect that there might be a difference in the chemica[ 
 composition of the reagent when absorbed in the two kinds of pre- 
 paration.s. If there is such a difference, it cannot be in the indigo 
 portion of the staining molecule, for blue and grass green sections with 
 the spectroscope, give alike the indigo absorption bands and no more. 
 
 I used also in staining sections of the spleen alum-hsmatoxylin 
 solutions, in which ammonia alum is dissolved to saturation, and Czokor's 
 alum-cochineal. These two reagents are of great value, especially the 
 former, in connection with the studies on the hasmatoblasts in the Anibly- 
 stoma larvse, the latter having been in various stages of their d velopment 
 fixed in chromic acid (/^°/o). Flemming's Fluid, corrosive sublimate, and 
 Erlicki's Fluid. Though the other reagents have their uses, the second 
 and third mentioned were the only ones to give good general results. 
 My preference is decidedly for Flemming's Fluid for larval or emb.'yonic 
 tissues. Half an hour is long enough for ihis reagent to act, since with 
 
 •Of the strength and characters recommended by Biondi. Arch, fur Mikr. Anat. \'A. 
 XXXI., p. 105. 
 
52 
 
 TUANSACTIONS OF THE CANADIAN INSTITUTE. 
 
 [Vol,. :i. 
 
 a longer stay in it the yolk-spherules blacken and the chromatin elements 
 in the nuclei are stainable with more difficulty in alum-hcematoxylin. 
 Alter the employment of any of the hardening reagents the larva; were 
 washed for a couple of minutes in distilled water, for ten minutes in SO^/o 
 alcohol, then in 7o*/o alcohol, until all traces of the hardening reagent 
 were removed, when they were put into and kept in 95 "/^ alcohol. The 
 larvae were, as a rule, and more advantageously, stained in toto in alum- 
 h.-ematoxylin or alum-cochineal. When the sections, obtained after 
 imbedding by the chloroform-paraffin method, were fixed on the slide 
 with clove oil-collodion, a second stain, eosin, was, when desired, 
 employed. I used, also, the triple and quadruple stains of Gaule for 
 the larvae as well as for sections of the sr' "vn. in Necturus, but I cannot 
 say that I have derived any advantage fi them. 
 
 Cover-glass preparations were made of the blood of the larvae and of 
 Necturus. These were fixed either in the fumes of osinic acid (l% 
 solution for two hours), or by a saturated solution of corrosive sublimate, 
 or picric acid, or by Erlicki's Fluid. These were the only reagents which 
 I found serviceable. The method of opera^^ing was to decapitate the 
 living specimen, to allow a small drop of the blood to fall on the cover- 
 gla-^s on which it was evenly spread, then to submerge the cover in 
 corrosive sublimate solution for five minutes, in picric solution for five 
 hours, or in Erlicki's fluid for two days. When osmic acid was used the 
 cover was put, with the preparation surface downward, on the mouth of 
 the unstoppered reagent bottle for two hours. The fixation was com- 
 pleted as usual with alcoho' and the various dyes referred to above were 
 used for staining the preparations. 
 
 Fresh cover-glass preparations of blood were also extensively studied 
 both before and after the addition of coloring reagents, such as acetic 
 methyl-green, acetic methyl-violet, picrocarmine, &c. 
 
 As regards the optical apparatus, I had for the finer work the yV in. 
 hom. imm. of Leitz, the j'j in. hom. imm. (r43 N. A.) of Powell and 
 Lealand, the yi in. hom. imm. and the L. (water imm. ^-g in.) of Zeiss. 
 I used during the last summer the 3 mm. apochromatic of the last named 
 maker when studying the blood of the larval Amblystomata. 
 
 B. STRUCTURE OF THE BLOOD CORPU.SCLES IN NECTURUS. 
 
 Th'j fresh y drawn blood of Necttirus contains the usual red corpuscles 
 of known foim, leucocytes and the so-called fusiform corpuscles. The 
 first and last classes of elements merit a detailed description, owing 
 
;l. 
 
 1890-91.] 
 
 AMPHIBIA BLOOD STUDIES. 
 
 53 
 
 of 
 
 to their relation to each other and to the importance of the questions 
 raised in these studies. 
 
 The red cells measure 50 — 53/i in length and 30 — 32/i in breadth. In 
 the fresh and normal condition they present usually in nucleus and 
 disc a uniform yellow red tint, and in the disc a completely homo- 
 geneous discoplasma. There are sometimes corpuscles possessing 
 \vhiti.sh nuclei which appear contrasted in this respect with the colored 
 disc, but these are not numerous until the preparation has been kept 
 under certain conditions, as in a moist stage, for some time. In such 
 nuclei one can determine the presence of a coarse network. The mem- 
 brane of the disc is very thin, so much so that when it is ruptured and 
 freed of its contents it is rarely visible. I have frequently, by artificial 
 means, ruptured a large number of the discs in a moist chamber and in 
 only a very few cases was I able to see the resulting free membranes, 
 although there were in such preparations an abundance of free nuclei. 
 The contents of the ruptured corpuscles have different fates. That of 
 the nucleus and of a portion of the protoplasm I shall describe fully 
 when treating of the fusiform corpuscle. The haemoglobin and the 
 stroma containing it become dissolved in the serum, hardly leaving a 
 trace visible. This points to the fluid character of the discoplasma and 
 I now proceed to prove that view of its structure. 
 
 If a cover-glass preparation of the blood is fixed with a saturated solu- 
 tion of corrosive sublimate, stained with ha^matoxylin and eosin, mounted 
 in balsam and studied with the best objectives at one's disposal, the 
 protoplasm of the disc will appear perfectly homogeneous and will be 
 seen stained uniformly and fntensely by the eosin. Granules and 
 vacuoles are absent, and if the nuclear membrane is shrunken away from 
 the discoplasma, the edge of the latter next it will then appear regularly 
 and evenly outlined. Vapor of osmic acid fixes the discoplasma in 
 the same way that corrosive sublimate does. This brings out distinctly 
 the fact that there can be no natural separation of stroma and haemoglo- 
 bin in the discoplasma. In other words, v.'e may say that the latter 
 is not homologous with the cytoplasma and enchylema of ordinary 
 cells, but that in the normal condition it is in the physiological sense 
 a single element. It is true that in certain methods of fixation the 
 protoplasm of the disc appears reticulated, and this may occur in a 
 few of the cells fixed by corrosive sublimate (Fig. i), but in every case 
 the fineness and arrangement of the reticular trabecular depends on 
 the method of fixation, and this shows that the reticulum is artificially 
 produced. One has but to look at Figs, i, 2, 3, and 4 to see how the 
 artificial structure varies in character. The preparation of the blood 
 
 !■ 
 
64 
 
 TRANSACTIONS OV TUI:: CANADIAN INSTITUTE. 
 
 [Vol. II. 
 
 corpuscles of the Amhlystoma larvae illustrates this variation also (Figs. 
 5, and 7), the corpuscles treated with Flemming's fluid frequently 
 presenting a coarse network ; those made with acetic methyl-green 
 showing a fine one, while those'fixed with osmic acid showed none at all. 
 
 If there is a stroma or any network, it does not separate itself from the 
 haemoglobin, when the latter crystallizes, even in the corpuscle. I have 
 often watclied in the moist-stage chamber the cr)'stallization of the haemo- 
 globin, especially when the instrument permits a slow evaporation of the 
 water of the blood, and found on the border or edge of the drop that the 
 ha-moglobin contents of a single blood corpuscle crystallized without 
 exuding from or passing out of the cell membrane. In some cases the 
 latter was seen to be more and more pushed out at certain points until 
 it possessed a rhomboid form like that of the contained crystal. The 
 membrane became invisible when evaporation passed a certain limit owing 
 no doubt to the greater density of the medium (serum). These crystals 
 are usually of the same length and breadth as the original corpuscle and 
 they contain, moreover, a large central oval space, the cavity of the 
 nucleus. Now these crystals differ in size, but not in form, from those 
 obtained by rupturing the corpuscles and slow drying of the blood. In 
 the latter the crystals are very long and narrow. If there is a stroma 
 why does it not interfere, not only with the crystalline form, but with 
 the power of crystallization in the haemoglobin ? 
 
 The nuclei measure 20 — 2IA1 by i2/x. With ordinary powers (Zeiss D), 
 they appear homogeneous, less deeply shaded than the disc, the haemoglo- 
 bin tint which they may appear to have being merely due to that of the 
 superposed portion of the disc, and they often are uncolored or whitish 
 in contrast with the latter. With high powers, such as oil-immersion 
 objectives, one can, in a perfectly normal and fresh corpuscle, determine 
 the existence of a wide-meshed network. This is formed sometimes of 
 thick, sometimes of thin trabeculae, and it is often straw-yellow in color, 
 in other word it apparently contains haemoglobin. 
 
 I now lea e the description of the red corpuscles to take up the 
 question of the origin of haemoglobin in them. 
 
 C. THE ORIGIN OF THE H.liMOGLOBIN IN THE RED DISCS. 
 
 If cover-glass preparations of the blood oi Necturus or portions of the 
 spleen of the same animal be fixed in various ways it will be found that 
 the haemoglobin of the red cells in the different preparations is obtained 
 in various degrees of preservation. 
 
 One of the most convenient fixative reagents for haemoglobin in the 
 
 
ir. 
 
 1890-91.] 
 
 AMPHIBIA BLOOD STUDIES. 
 
 65 
 
 ntly 
 een 
 all. 
 
 red discs, and especially when employed on the spleen, is Eriicki's Flu'd. 
 This, combined with the Indi<fo-carmine Fluid described in the foregoing 
 pages, gives a remarkably sure means by which one can determine the 
 presence of the pigment. The red cells of the spleen present with this 
 fixative reagent and the staining fluid a uniformly gra.ss-grcen disc 
 in which no structural elements can be observed and a nucleus which 
 may be either carmine red or grass-green, or of a s^ide in green. 
 Sometimes the nucleus presents a network as deeply grass-green as the 
 substance of the disc, while the substance in the meshes of the net-work 
 is red. These different effects obtained on the nuclear structures are 
 not due to artificial or physical conditions such as the early or late 
 action of the fixative reagent, for all the described features can be found 
 in the nuclei of cells placed side by side. Without raising the question 
 at present whether there is any haemoglobin in the nucleus, a question 
 which might be prompted by an observation already made above, it may 
 be concluded that the nuclei of the red cells are not all similar in their 
 chemical relations towards sulphindigotate of sodium This conclusion 
 may be also drawn from a study of cover-glass preparations of blood in 
 which it is often easy to see a grass-green network in the carmine-red 
 nuclei of the red cells. 
 
 In cover-glass preparations fixed with osmic acid vapor in which the 
 layer of blood is very thin, the haemoglobin is also well preserved. 
 Here the nuclei of the red cells have, after the employment of Indigo- 
 carmine Fluid, a grass-green network in the meshes of which the 
 substance is faint red. In similar cover-glass preparations in which the 
 layer of blood is comparatively thick the discs of the red cells are 
 grass-green, the nuclei distinctly red with a green net-work. In cover 
 preparations on which the solution (i%), instead of the vapor of osmic 
 acid, was used the same staining reagent gave red nuclei and grass-green 
 discs to the red cells. 
 
 In cover preparations of the blood made with corrosive sublimate 
 solutions the Indigo-carmine Fluid stained the discs and nuclear network 
 deep blue green, while the substance in the meshes of the net-work is 
 colored from a light to a deep red, oftener the former. Frequently, 
 with an ordinary power such as a D of Zeiss, very many, or nearly all 
 nuclei of the red cells appear homogeneously red, but with the employ- 
 ment of an oil immersion (yV in.) the presence of the blue green network 
 can be distinctly determined. 
 
 Flemming's Fluid, Miiller's Fluid and chromic acid dissolve the haemo- 
 globin out of the red discs in cover-glass preparations of the blood and 
 
56 
 
 TRANSACTIONS OF THE CANADIAN IN8TITUTB. 
 
 [Vol. II. 
 
 i 
 
 in such cases it is difficult or even impossible to get any reactions at all 
 with the Indigo-carmine Fluid. 
 
 In preparations of the blood, therefore, made with corrosive sublimate, 
 osmic vapor, and Erlicki's Fluid, and subsequently stained with the 
 Indigo-carmine Fluid, the nuclei of the red cells are shown to contain 
 two substances: one which stains grass-green or blue-green ^-langed as 
 a network, the other colored red (light or deep), situated in the spaces 
 formed by the network. 
 
 It is now pertinent to ask whether the nuclear network is formed of 
 or contains ha;moglobin, or whether, as it may happen to be chromatin, 
 it, as such, merely shows a special affinity for sodic sulphindigotate, 
 without pointing to any relationship between it and haemoglobin. I 
 have already stated in the description of the fresh and living red cell 
 that its nucleus frequently presents, under oil-immersion objectives, a 
 straw-yellow network which is seen in contrast with the slight pale- 
 ness of the rest of the nuclear substance. This would seem to indicate 
 the existence of haemoglobin in the nuclear network. That it is not 
 hemoglobin, though a substance allied to it — ^judging from its color 
 in the fresh cell and its reactions with sodic sulphindigotate in the 
 fixed cell — is shown by the employment of picric acid as a fixative 
 reagent on cover preparations and the use of the Indigo-carmine Fluid. 
 In such the discs of the red cells are somewhat vacuolated but they are 
 colored grass-green while their nuclei are either light red with a deep red 
 network, or, sometimes, light blue with a deep red network. If haemo- 
 globin is present in the nucleus it ought in picric acid preparations to be 
 as readily detectable there as in the disc. 
 
 The question now advanced is : what is the composition of the 
 substance forming the nuclear network and of that filling its meshes? 
 
 If a section of the spleen hat-Hened in chromic acid is stained with the 
 Indigo-carmine Fluid, the dis..i of the red cells appear faint red while 
 their nuclei are colored a deep grass-green. In the latter there is not 
 the slightest trace of a differentiation into network and mesh substance. 
 Evidently then the employment of chromic acid has converted the whole 
 of the nuclear substance into something which stains grass-green with 
 the Indigo-carmine Fluid. The latter reagent is not the only one which 
 shows this conversion for alum-haematoxylin, alum-cochineal and safranin 
 stain homogeneously the nuclei of the red cells of such preparations. 
 The whole of the nucleus, both network and mesh substance, must 
 be regarded therefore, as modified chromatin or as a mixture of 
 chromatin and achromatin, the latter being rendered capable by the 
 chromic acid of absorbing staining matters. That we have nothing to 
 
1890-91.] 
 
 AMPHIBIA BI.OOD STUDIKS. 
 
 57 
 
 do here with achromatic substance is shown in sections of the spleen 
 hardened with Flemming's fluid and stained with alum-haimatoxylin. 
 In such preparations the nuclei of the red cells take a homogeneous deep 
 stain thus proving that there is no conversion of achromatin into 
 chromatin or into a substance which reacts towards dyes like the latter. 
 Hence we may conclud ■ that the nuclf^ar contents in the red cells are 
 formed of chromatin more or less modified. 
 
 If the nuclei of the fully formed red cells in a larval Amblystoma 
 hardened in Flemming's Fluid be put under observation, a condition is 
 seen in them similar to that found in the nuclei of the red cells of the 
 spleen hardened in chromic acid, that is, they stain in the majority of 
 cases with alum-haimatoxylin, alum-cochineal in the same way, taking a 
 uniform homogeneous tint. There can be no doubt that here the nuclei 
 are well preserved. In some larva; again, there are found a few fully 
 formed corpuscles in which the nuclear network alone is stained. There 
 are also other nuclei in such larvae which present different amounts of a 
 stainable mesh substance and the inference gained from the study of 
 such nuclei is that the stainable mesh substance takes its origin in 
 the network and as the latter in the newly formed corpuscles contains 
 the whole of the chromatin, the stainable mesh substance is modified 
 chromatin. That it is modified and no longer fully functional may 
 be seen by glancing at Figs. 13 and 14 which represent fully formed red 
 corpuscles of the larva in division. Examples of the latter are not very 
 numerous, not more than three or four occurring in a whole series of 
 sections. In these one finds that there is a quantity of chromatin 
 between the loops of the chromatin figure in the daughter nuclei and 
 that this unorganised chromatin has only taken a passive share in the 
 process of division. The latter species of chromatin was in a few cases 
 so abundant as to obscure the regular chromatin loops. 
 
 The .substance, then, in the spaces of the nuclear network is a derived 
 chromatin which, fixed with chromic acid or Flemming's Fluid, gives 
 with alum-cochineal or alum-haematoxylin a deep and homogeneous 
 stain and which when fixed with chromic acid has the property of giving, 
 as haemoglobin does, a grass-green stain with the Indigo-carmine Fluid. I 
 believe this modified chromatin is the parent substance of haemoglobin, 
 that is, it is a true haematogen. 
 
 That this modified chromatin is derived from the primitive chromatin 
 of the haematoblast is also shown by a study of sections from the spleen of 
 Necturus hardened in chromic acid and stained with the Indigo-carmine 
 Fluid. Fig. 8 is an exact representation of a group of cells from one of 
 the blood sinuses in such a section, in which a dividing haematoblast is 
 
68 
 
 TRANSACTIONS OF THI CANADIAN INSTITUTK. 
 
 [Vol. II. 
 
 shown with the chromatin loops alone colored grass-green while the 
 cytoplasma and, if present, the caryoplasma are colored, in contrast, light 
 red. There is evidently no derived or modified chromatin here and the 
 only substance related to it must be situated in the chromatin loops. I 
 saw, indeed, in a number of other examples of dividing haematoblasts 
 that there was a grass-green substance between the usual chromatin 
 loops and this substance which was, evidently, modified chromatin, 
 varied in quantity from that condition where it was scarcely detectable to 
 that where it was so abundant as to obscure the outlines of the similarly- 
 stained chromatin loops. The latter condition is, certainly, a later stage 
 than that shown in Fig. 8 and the nucleus of the fully formed red cell, in 
 all probability, represents the culmination phase of the conversion of 
 chromatin into ha;matogen. 
 
 The chromatin of ha;matoblasts can be shown to be different in 
 composition from that of an ordinary cell. In cio^r *n demonstrate this 
 one must resort for material to those Amblystonia larvae in which the 
 majority of the blood corpuscles are more or less pigmented. The 
 latter condition can be readily determined by putting the larva in water 
 on a glass slide and examining its gills through the low power of the 
 microscope. Indeed almost any larva, not very long after its escape from 
 the envelope, will answer the purpose. It is fixed in Flemming's Fluid for 
 half an hour, then put in 5o7o alcohol for fifteen minutes, afterwards in 
 70% for twenty-four hours and finally in 95% for four or five hours. If 
 it is stained in toio with alum-haematoxylin, imbedded in paraffin, 
 sectioned, and the sections mounted in series on the slide in benzol 
 balsam, one can in the concave sides of the aortic arches and in the 
 developing spleen find a large number of dividing haematoblasts which 
 at once betray their presence by the dull slate, or slate-brown color 
 which their chromatin possesses, while the chromatin of ordinary cells is 
 stained a tint between purple and navy-blue. Figs. 9 a and b are 
 contrast drawings made from specimens in the concave side of the same 
 aortic arch and in the same section, the one representinj an endothelial 
 cell, the other a hccmatoblast. In the latter the slate-brown color of 
 the cytoplasma was not very marked and this may frequently be 
 found free from any color whatever. No more decisive proof could be 
 given that the chromatin of ha;matoblasts differs chemically from that 
 of ordinary cells. That which gives with the ha;matoxylin a slate-brown 
 color is probably a haematogen or haematogenous chromatin. 
 
 Flemming* has noticed this reaction of the chromatin of the ha;mato- 
 blasts on the haeniatoxylin, and he states that dividing haematoblasts 
 
 • Arch, fiir Mikr. Anat. Bd. XVI., p. 396 and Taf. XVII., Figs. 19 and 20. 
 
•L. II. 
 
 1890 91.] 
 
 AMPHIBIA BLOOU STUDIB8. 
 
 09 
 
 fixed in chromic acid have in the unstaiu^d condition a greenish-hnnvn or 
 brownish-yellow color which he considers due to haemof^Iobin. Tliis 
 color is maintained in the ha^matoxylin staining fluid while all the 
 nuclei of other cells become blue. I also have observed similarly 
 colored haematoblasts in chromic acid preparations, and I attributed 
 the color at first to the presence of h.emoglobin. In such prepar- 
 ations, however, there are examples in which the chromatin elements 
 only are greenish-brown or brownish-yellow, and from this condition 
 to that where the brownish-yellow substanct. is so abundant as to 
 obscure the view of the internal structure of the cell there are all shades 
 of transition. This substance is not haemoglobin but ratiier an 
 antecedent of it, that is haematogcn, and is of the same nature and origin 
 as the modified chromatin in the nuclei of the fully formed red cells 
 which also show the same greenish, greeni.-,u-brown or greenish-yellow 
 color when they have been treated with chromic acid. It differs from 
 chromatin in its action on haematoxylin and from haemoglobin in that 
 it is more easily fixed with hardening reagents in the cell, and in that, 
 as I will now show, it has a greater capacity for staining with eosin. 
 
 In the preparations of the haematoblasts of larval Amblystomata fixed 
 with Flemming's Fluid and stained, as described, with haematoxylin and 
 afterwards with eosin, one finds the modified chromatin or h?ematogen 
 stained very deeply with the latter reagent. The dividing haematoblasts, 
 according to this reaction, are separable into the following divisions : 
 (i) those in which the cell body is only feebly stained while the chro- 
 matin elements are stained deep terra-cotta red (Fig. lo) ; (2) those in 
 v.'hich the cell body is only little less deeply colored terra-cotta red than 
 the chromatin loops (Fig. 11) ; (3) those in which the staining in the cell 
 body presents conditions transitional between (i) and (2). There can 
 be no doubt that in these forms the eo.sinophilous substance originates 
 in the chromatin. The haematoblasts are the only cells in such prepar- 
 ations which show this decisive eosin reaction. 
 
 Now this modified chromatin or htematogen, as I prefer to call it, 
 when once secreted into the cell of the haematoblast persists there 
 through all the divisions of the latter. This certainly cannot be proved, 
 and I believe it is impossible to prove, but it is a rea.sonable inference 
 from facts gained by a careful study of the preparations. After a 
 certain stage in larval life, nearly all the haematoblasts show it to be 
 present and it is converted into hcemoglobin when the cycle of divisions has 
 been gone through. After the formation of hsematogen once commences 
 it goes on, with the result that each of the numerous daughter or 
 descendant haematoblasts possesses by inheritance and through secretion 
 
60 
 
 TKANSACTIONS OP THE CANADIAN INSTITUTE. 
 
 [Vol. II. 
 
 H 
 
 a quantity of hjematogcn as definitely as it has unmodified chromatin. 
 This h.-cmatogen plays no part at all in the division, and when the power 
 of division is lost or greatly diminished the unmodified chromatin is 
 confined in the nuclear membrane and the terra-cotta-red stain in the 
 cell body gives place to that characteristic of haemoglobin. 
 
 It has been already observed by Flemming* that chromatin is very 
 abundant in dividing haimatoblasts, and he compares this great volume 
 with that of the same substance in the fully formed red cells.f He also 
 speculates on the cause of the increase in the quantity of chromatin and 
 mentions two possible explanations: either the stainable substance is 
 taken fromthe protoplasm of the disc into the nucleus or the nuclei of 
 the red cells contain chromatin in a greatly condensed, form so when that 
 division commences it suffices to fill out the enlarged nuclear figure. 
 He, apparently, inclines to the latter view because the nuclei of fully 
 formed red cells stain mor^ deeply than do those of other cells, yet 
 expresses himself as not quite certain that a portion of the protoplasm 
 of the disc does not go into the nuclear figure in division. StrasburgerJ: 
 adopts the second explanation. Flemming§ further states that the 
 mitotic figure in the hfematoblasts is 2 — 3 times greater than the nucleus 
 of the resting or fully formed cell. 
 
 Flemming's observation as to the great amount of chromatin present 
 in the ha;matoblast is correct, but he has used a wrong or incorrect 
 .standard when he selected the nucleus of the resting red cell. I have 
 already pointed out that there are two kinds of chromatin in the 
 latter. The network chromatin is never reinforced by that in the 
 spaces of the network and it alone is a direct descendant of the mitotic 
 chromatin of the haematoblast. This is very clearly shown by hsma- 
 toblasts one of which is represented in Fig. 14. Now the original chromatin 
 of the hfematoblasts is from the time of their differentiation as such 
 specially abundant. The quantity of this substance is from this time on 
 to that of the formation of the red cells so great that the h.-ema- 
 toblast seems hardly capable of containing much else, and, as a con- 
 sequence, divisions appear so rapidly that I have never yet succeeded in 
 observing the resting stage and the -same has been the experience of 
 other observers. There is in this, plainly, a reason for a degeneration of 
 part of the chromatin into the eosinophilous substance already described. 
 
 * Zellsubstanz Kern-und Zellthetlung, p. 262-3. 
 
 + The two upper cells represented in his fig. T. p. 263, op, cit., are fully developed blood 
 
 cells. 
 
 J Zellbildnng und Zelltheilung, 1880, p. 330. 
 § Arch, fiir Mikr. Anat., Bd. XVI, p. 396. 
 
181)0 91. J 
 
 AMPHiniA BLOOD 8TID1ES. 
 
 CI 
 
 When the amount of chromatin has become 30 much reduced by division 
 and by degeneration of itself, then and it till then is reached the stage 
 of the fully formed corpuscle. Even in this stage there may be just so 
 much network chromatin left as to prompt a .somewhat imperfect division 
 (Figs. 12-14), but these forms are extremely rare and the fully formed red 
 corpuscle is incapable of division henceforth, in other words, it has less 
 than the usual quantity of unmodified chromatin that an ordinary cell ha.s. 
 It may be seen from this that Flemming's theory of the condensation 
 of the chromatin of haematoblasts is not supported by the example 
 which he brought forward. The chromatin exists in the h.tmatoblast.s 
 from the first, there is no condensation of chromatin in the nuclei of red 
 cells, but there is, for the greater part of it, degeneration. 
 
 Had Flemming, Pfitzner, and Strasburger studied fully the origin and 
 development of the haematoblasts they would, I believe, not have been 
 puzzled by the extraordinary abundance of the chromatin therein and 
 Flemming would hardly have striven to account for this abundance in 
 the way he did, either by derivation out of the cytoplasma, or by 
 expansion of originally condensed chromatin. 
 
 From a study of my preparations there can be no doubt that the 
 eosinophilous substance of the haematoblasts is,^on the one hand, denved 
 from the chromatin and on the other, transformed at the close of hasma- 
 toblastic life into haemoglobin. The transformation .sometimes occurs 
 before this epoch for in the freshly shed blood of larval Ajiiblystoinata I 
 have seen mitotic haematoblasts in which a faint haemoglobin coloration 
 was present and in a few other, somewhat deeply pigmented cells the 
 addition of weak acetic acid solution dissolved out the haemoglobin and 
 showed mitotic figures. This was the rare exception of course. I do 
 not think the eosinophilous substance, although it also deserves to be 
 called haematogen, is the same as the interfilar or modified chromatin of 
 the fully formed red cells, for the latter does not react so definitely 
 towards eosin, and it does not as readily affect the haeniatoxylin in the 
 same way. As I have shown, they both, however, are derived from the 
 same source, and, apparently, the eosinophilous substance is farther on 
 the '.oad to the formation of haemoglobin than the other. 
 
 There are a number of facts which also support the view that haemo- 
 globin is derived from chromatin. Hunge* has extracted from the yolk 
 of hen's egg and from milk, nucleins which contain iron very firmly bound 
 in the nuclein molecule. That found in the yolk Bunge especially 
 calls haematogen, because he believes that it is the antecedent of the 
 haemoglobin of the chick, and he puts forward the view that all the iron 
 
 *Ueberdie Assimilation des Eisens. Zeit. fiir Physiol. Chemie, Bd. IX., pp. 49-59' 
 
62 
 
 TRANSACTIONS OK TIIU CANADIAN INSTITUTK. 
 
 [Vol. II. 
 
 whicli enters tlie animal body for assimilation does so in firm combina- 
 tion with complicated orfjanic compounds, the elaboration of which occurs 
 only in the vegetable kingdom. Such compounds, he contends, when 
 absorbed and assimilated, yield hitmoglobin. Kossel* has corroborated 
 Bunge's observations as to the occurrence of iron in the nucleins of yolk 
 and milk. 
 
 Furthermore, Zaleskif found in the livers of various animals, washed 
 out and thoroughly freed from h;emoglobin and inorganic iron salts, pro- 
 teids which contained iron more or less firmly combined. These were 
 albuminates of iron (Albuminat-verbindung des F.isens), and two, probably 
 three, nucleins containing iron (Nucieo-verbindungen des Eisens). The 
 latter vary in the power with which they hold the iron, and in one of the 
 nucleins which he calls hcpatin the iron is so firmly combined that the 
 ordinary tests fail to show its presence, /'/ being only detected in the as/t. 
 This hepatin differs from the haematogen of Bunge in thuc the latter 
 yields up its iron more readily and has a greater amount of the metal, 
 the h.tmatogen containing 0297oi the hepatin 0'oii7o- Zalesk , more- 
 over, determined that his iron-holding nucleins are present in the nuclei 
 of the hepatic cells. 
 
 These nucleins have all the characters of the ordinary nucleins isolated 
 from pus, semen, etc., and as the latter are supposed to be present in, or to 
 form the sub.stance known as chromatin to the cytologist, it is possible 
 that chromatin usually if not always contains iron as firmly bound as in 
 the ha.'niatogen of Bunge and in the hepatin of Zaleski. It is true that 
 the analyses of nucleins, as given generally, do not point to the occurrence 
 of iron, but this can be explained by reference to the method employed 
 in their preparation. The nucleins, or rather chromatins, are soluble 
 in, and after a short time decomposed by, alkalies. Bunge has 
 shown that his hiematogen loses its iron in solutions of potassic hydrate 
 after some days and contact with ammonic sulphide causes its decompo- 
 sition with the separation of sulphide of iron. In the preparation of 
 nucleins alkaline fluids have been u.sed'to dissolve the residue left by 
 digesting tissues, pus, etc., with pepsin and weak hydrochloric acid, or 
 with hydrochloric acid alone, and the alkaline fluid used contains the 
 nucleins (soluble variety) which one would expect, from the results of 
 Bunge's researches^ to be free from iron (combined), if originally they con- 
 tained it. In this way we may explain why the nucleins from various 
 
 •Weitere Beitrage zur Chemie des Zellkerns. Zeit. (ur Physiol. Chemie, Bd. X., p. 249. 
 tStudien uber die Leber. I. Eisengehalt der Leber. Zeit. fiir Physiol. Chemie, Bd. X., pp. 
 452-502. 
 
 JSee on this subject specially the appendix. 
 
1890-91.] 
 
 AMPHIBIA BLOOD 8TUDIK8. 
 
 G3 
 
 sources analysed by different chemists present so many variations in 
 composition as to lead some observers, Gam^,'ce* amon^jst them, to deny a 
 chemical individuality to these substances. The nucieins so extracted 
 can hardly be considered as more than derivatives of the chromatin 
 substances, for the latter in the living' cell is undoubtedly the scat of the 
 more important vital processes, and the changes rcsultin;^ in these vital 
 phenomena can hardly occur in a compound so comparatively simple as 
 the nuclein, to which Miescher ascribed the formula C.^^ M^„ N„ I*,, O.... 
 
 I have succeeded during the last summer in definitely demonstrating 
 that the great part, if not the greater part of the yolk of the ovum of the 
 frog and of Necturus is derived by diffusion from the chromatin o( 
 nucleus of the ovumf. Now this chromatin so diffused is the analogue in 
 amphibian egg of the ha.Mnatogen of the hen's egg. This taken in con- 
 junction with the fact that the iron-holding nuclein of milk can apparently, 
 and possibly, only be the chromatins which Nissen* has shown that the 
 degenerating cells of the mammary gland throw out into the lumen of 
 the secreting tubules, distinctly points to the presence of iron firmly com- 
 bined in the chromatin of every cell. 
 
 All these points support and confirm the view that the haimoglobin of 
 the blood is derived from the chromatin § of the h.-cmatoblasts. It may 
 be asked, Why if chromatin contains iron, should not all cells contain 
 hnemoglobin ? All cells do not contain the excess which ha^matoblasts 
 have, and therefore have none to spare for transformation into that com- 
 pound. Why the hasmatoblasts have an excess of chromatin I shall 
 endeavor to show when I come to speak of their origin further on. 
 Enough has been said to show that the compounds which Bunge and 
 Zaleski isolated and called respectively hcematogen and hepattn do not 
 merit these names, the haematogen not going directly, except probably in 
 developing muscle fibre in larval amphibia, to form haemoglobin, v hile 
 Zaleski has not shown that every cell of the body does not contain a 
 nuclein in which the iron is as firmly combined as in the so called hcpatin. 
 
 As an additional proof that haemoglobin is derived from chromatin, the 
 occurrence of phosphorus in the haemoglobin of the blood of the goose 
 may be quoted. It is suspected by many that the phosphorus belongs 
 
 •Physiological Chemistry of the Animal Body, Vol. I., p. 243. 
 
 tThe results of the research will be published shortly. 
 
 t\rch. fiir Mikr. Anat., Bd. XXVI., p. 337. 
 
 § I am inclined to believe, from the results of my own observations, that the hjemoglobin of 
 muscle fibre in Amphibia is derived directly from the yolk chromatin or, as Bunge calls it, 
 hsematogen. 
 
64 
 
 THANHACTI0N8 OF TBI CANADIAN INHTITUTK. 
 
 [Vol. II. 
 
 li 
 
 |i; 
 
 to a compound which, in no way uniting with the ha:moglobin, yet in an 
 admixture with it, is so difficult to separate that after many crystallizations 
 of the h.L-moglobin some will always adhere to the crystals. Recently^ 
 however, Jacquet* has isolated the ha;moglobin of hen's blood alter 
 recrystallization and has found that it contains 0'I97% of phosphorus 
 and 0335/i of iron. Hoppe-Seyler had previously found in the h.xmo- 
 globin of goose's blood 077% of phosphorus and 0"437o ^^ ''O"- '^^^ 
 anomaly of the presence of phosphorus in the hsemoglobin of Avian 
 blood is readily explained away by the fact that the ha-moglobin is 
 derived from a class of prottids which are peculiar in containing phos- 
 phorus. 
 
 It is, indeed, an important question whether the chromatin of all cells 
 docs not act as an oxygen-absorber like hsmoglobin. I made some 
 experiments on this point. Methylene blue in living tissues in which the 
 metabolic processes are vigorous becomes discolored owing to the 
 abstraction of oxygen. This reagent has been recently much used on 
 this account in the determination of the course of nerve fibres. Into 
 solutions of this dye I put a number of free-swimming Lrval Amblysto- 
 mata and examined them from time to time to determine the effect on 
 the cells of the gills and in the tail. With weak solutions I found the 
 free portions of the membranes only of the epithelial cells colored, while 
 with gradually increasing strength of solution granules in the cytoplasma 
 of the same cells become stained, especially those between the radicles 
 of the cilia on the gills. Sometimes a red blood corpuscle presents in 
 the disc in this case one or more blue granules. If one increases the 
 strength of the reagent almost up to the limit of endurance on the part 
 of the animal, other cytoplasmic elements are stained, but in no instance 
 have I seen a single nuclear body stained. This was not due to slower 
 penetration and, therefore, readier deoxidation, or reduction of the dye, for, 
 in the few examples of epithelial cells in division which I found in that 
 stage in which the nuclear membrane is absent, the chromatin elements 
 were absolutely colorless. Indeed, it is only when the dividing cell is 
 moribund or dead that the chromatin elements stain at all. The pro- 
 bable explanation of the phenomena described is that the chromatin has 
 a marked capacity for storing up oxygen in itself and that it differs from 
 haemoglobin in that it gives up this element only to the products of its 
 metabolism. 
 
 If chromatins and the iron-holding proteids derived from them, like 
 the yolk nuclein of Bunge, have the capacity of storing up oxygen, then 
 it is possible that part of the oxygen required for respiratory purposes in 
 
 •Zeit. fUr I'hysiol. Chemie., Bd. XIV., pp. 289-296. 
 
I 
 
 1H!)0-91.] 
 
 AMHIIIHIA HLOOD NTI'DIKK. 
 
 05 
 
 the yolk-holding ova may be derived from this source. It is somewhat 
 difficult, otherwise, to explain the process of respiration in larval Ambly- 
 stoinata which pass a week or more imbedded dcejjly in i,'elatinous masses 
 floating in stagnant ponds. 
 
 I have seen, in a few cases, the straw-yellow crystal-like bodies in the 
 immediate neighborhood of the nuclear membr.inc as Cucnot* has de- 
 scribed. I have represented in l''ig. 26 the arrangement of the bodies 
 but they are not always a^ clo-fcly applied to the nucleus as there slu)wn, 
 for they, in the greater number of cells in which they were found, lie free 
 in an apparently empty space between nuclear and cell membranes. I 
 regard all these cells, as well as those describeil by Cuenot — who believes 
 that they indicate the secretion of luenjoglobin from the nucleus — as the 
 products of pathological comlitions. I have not seen more than half a 
 dozen of such cells and yet I have diligently examined the fresh blood 
 of several hundred larVf^e in various stages of development. 
 
 Research demonstrates more and more the influence which the nucleus 
 exercises on the nutrition anJ function of the cell and among the obser- 
 vations put forward in this lim; those of Korscheltf may be mentioned, 
 in which it is shown that the formation of chitin is directly dependent 
 on tlje nucleus. Among the covering cells of the ova of Nepa and 
 Ranaira the nuclei of two fused cellular elements approach each otiier and 
 enclose between them a cavity in which chitin is deposited. PlatnerJ 
 also considers that the derivation of enzymes in gland cells takes place 
 by the constriction and separation of a portion of the nucleus and the 
 subsequent formation of zymogen granules at the same time that the 
 chromatin of the separated nuclear portion is undergoing degeneration 
 and absorption in the cytoplasma. He believe^ that there is a direct 
 causal relation between th^ budding of the nucleus with the subsequent 
 degeneration of the separated part and the formation of zymogen 
 granules. I have failed to find that Platner's description is true so far 
 as formation of zymogen in the pancreatic cells of amphibia is concerned, 
 but I have found, nevertheless, that the nuclei of these cells play a very 
 important part in the elaboration of the zymogen. It is, also, evident 
 from the trend of researches in vegetable cytology that the nuclei of green 
 cells are the important factors in the elaboration of carbohydrates and 
 that the latter are converted into starch in the chlorophyll grains.§ 
 
 •Comptes Rendus. 1888. p. 673. 
 
 tUeber einige interessante Vorgange bei der Bildung der Insekeneier. Zeit. (Ur Wiss. Zool., 
 Bd. 45- 
 
 * Arch. fUr Mikr. Anat., Bd. XXXIII. p. 180. 
 
 § See on this point Strasburger's Histologische Beittage. Heft I. : Ueber Kern und Zellthei- 
 lung im Pflanzenreiche, pp. 194-204. 
 
66 
 
 TRANSACTIONS OF THK CANADIAN INSTITUTE. 
 II. THK FUSIFORM COKPUSCLES. 
 
 [Vol. II. 
 
 The f viiform corpuscles, which measure 26/1 x 16/^, are quite numerous 
 in the shed blood of Necturus. They, as their name impUes, are elong- 
 ated and oval, and with usually sharply truncated ends. They have no 
 ceil membrane, and their protoplasm, especially at one or both of the 
 ends, is amctboid or protrusible in the form of fine straight rays, which, 
 with careful observation, are sometimes seen to manifest a slow vibratory 
 motion. Sometimes these cells are fi.ved with the processes extended 
 (Fig. 22b). Often the' protoplasmic periphery is formed of a series ot 
 granules which render the exact outline indistinct. The protoplasm is 
 usually homogeneous, e.xccpt for the presence of one or more vacuoles at 
 either end of the oval nucleus and a few granules which seem to be of 
 the same character as those of the periphery. 
 
 The nucleus is oval usually and measures i6/jix 14/^ It may in some 
 cases be lobed, and the jobation may have gone so far as to originate 
 several small spherical nuclei. It may be homogeneous or it may be 
 coarsely reticulated. Kept in a moist chamber the reticulated as well as 
 the homogeneous nuclei undergo a process of chromatolysis. In the case 
 of the reticulated nuclei the first stage of degeneration is seen in the tra- 
 beculae of the network becoming elongated and paraliel, the elongation 
 occurring transversely to the long axis of the nucleus. At the same time 
 the spaces in the network become larger and the nucleus apparently 
 distended. This condition passes into that wherein the whole nuclear 
 substance becomes homogeneous or in whieh its chromatin forms a thick 
 zone next to the now spherical membrane. The history of the corpuscle 
 terminates with the disintegration of the whole into globules more or 
 less spherical and varying in size, suspended in the serum. Very 
 little of the cytoplasma is found in connection with these globules, 
 for, whih the nucleus is passing through the conditions described, the 
 cytoplasma granulates and becomes dissolved in the serum. 
 
 Such is the fate of the fusiform corpuscle when it lies by itself. 
 When, however, it meets with another the two fuse, either by their 
 ends, as is commonly the case, or by their sides, and this capacity 
 for fusion may be exercised so much that small masses of them (white 
 thrombi) exist here and there over the field of the preparation. The 
 fusion is complete, all the lines of demarcation disappearing, even the 
 granules which formed the protoplasmic periphery being dissolved. 
 
 These corpuscles are free from color and are like the leucocytes in 
 many respects. From the latter they are distinguished by the absence 
 of true amcEboid movement and by their regular shape and size. 
 
181)0-91.] 
 
 AMPHIBIA BLOOD STUDIES. 
 
 67 
 
 I have now to discuss the na'ure of these corpuscles and will first of 
 all detail the various views which have been advanced concerning them 
 in this respect. 
 
 It is probable that the first observation of these corpuscles was made 
 by von Recklinghausen* in 1866, who described structures, which could 
 have been no other than fusiform cells, in his preparations undergoing 
 transformation into red cells. He found all the stages of transition between 
 the spindles (fusiform cells) and the elliptical (red) corp'iscles, while he saw 
 under favorable conditions in .some of the spindles a red .shade like that in 
 the ordinary red cells and he regarded thcs . colored spindles as develop- 
 ing red cells. He refers to the fact that in his preparations there are at 
 first small white points, afterwards becoming flat islands (white thrombi?) 
 consisting of contractile cells which attain enormous sizes and possess 
 contractile processes. In the.se large cells are developed homogeneous, 
 refracting spheres, .sometimes to the number of forty, which may, or may 
 not, be considered as endogenously formed cells. 
 
 Ranvierf is the next to refer to these elements in frog's blood. He 
 describes them as .sometimes sharply pointed at both ends or with one 
 end rounded, the other pointed, finely granular and uncolored. He 
 considers them to be free endothelial cells. 
 
 HayemJ regards these, as well as the platelets of mammalian blood, 
 as haematoblasts. He describes them, as they occur in frog's blood, as 
 smooth, homogeneous, slightly clouded and with a tint less silvery than 
 that of the white corpuscles. They present sometimes a central area 
 lightly shaded, occupying the place of the nucleus, and inside this one or 
 two refracting granules. The nucleus is in every respect like that of the 
 red cell, oval, nucleolated and finely granulated. The disc which is small 
 in volume is flattened, has an elongated, variable form and contains, like 
 the red cells, two distinct con.stituents, a stroma and a specially organized 
 substance. The stroma is very delicate and, therefore, more difficult to 
 demonstrate than in red cells. The organized matter pervading the 
 stroma differentiates the haematoblasts from the red cell, and it is un- 
 colored or faintly tinted with a small quantity of haemoglobin which it 
 loses easily. This substance is extremely diffusible, and it is endowed 
 with a particular kind of contractility. It is very easily injured, and to 
 this property is due the formation of these corpuscles so readily into 
 granular masses. Hayem subjected frogs to repeated bleedings and 
 
 'j 
 
 •Ueber die Krzeugung von rothen Blutkorperchen. Arcli. (Ur Mikr. Anat., Bd. II., .S. 137. 
 tTraitd technique d'histologie, 1875, p. 191 and 192. 
 
 tArchives de Physiologic, Tome 5, 1878, Tome 6, 1879. Also a later publication : Du .San; 
 et de ses altetations anatomiques. Paris, 1889, pp. I24>I5I. 
 
 ' • 
 
i 
 
 lii 
 
 68 
 
 TRANSACTIONS OF THE CANADIAN INSTIIUTK. 
 
 [Vol. II. 
 
 found in the blood finally all the intermediate stages between the fusi- 
 form and the red cells. 
 
 Hizzozero and Torre* reject this view of the haematoblastic nature of 
 the red cells and state that though they are like red cells in some respects 
 they are smaller and unpigmented, while young blood cells are round in 
 form and always contain haemoglobin. These elements are also unlike 
 the leucocytes in their simple oval nucleus and non-contractile proto- 
 plasm. These authors believe that the corpuscles in question are related, 
 in spite of many points of dissimilarity, to the structures in mammalian 
 blood known as platelets. 
 
 Hlavaf considers the fusiform corpuscle to be a variety of the white 
 cell brought about by the contractile capacity of the latter. 
 
 LowitJ describes the transformation of the sp'ndles into spherical forms 
 like that of the white cells with which he classes these elements. He 
 maintains that all forms of white blood cells may appear in the spindle 
 form, but he admits that certain stages of the developing red cell exist 
 in this form from which haemoglobin is absent. According to his view 
 the fusiform cell is not a separate species of white blood cell but only a 
 form of the latter which may appear under those conditions offered by 
 the circulating blood, and it may in some cases have a haematoblastic 
 nature. 
 
 Eberth§ describes the elements as being spindle, club, or almond- 
 shaped, somewhat smaller than the red discs, probably slightly flattened, 
 possessing a finely granulated nucleus and an almost homogeneous cell 
 protoplasm which is chiefly gathered at the poles. Their contour does 
 not change, they have no amoeboid processes, and when they are 
 collected into great masses they never present a trace even of a yellow 
 or haemoglobin tint. When they are Viept for hours in their normal 
 physiological condition, e. g., inside the bloodvessels of an excised piece 
 of mesentery, protected from evaporation, they have never been observed 
 to change in .shape, they exhibit no amoeboid movement whatever and 
 they do not fuse together. In the spindles fixed by osmic acid there is 
 
 •Virchow's Arch., Bd. 90. 
 
 +Die Beziehung der I31utplattchen Bizzozero's zur Blutgerinnuiig und Thrombose. Arch, fiir 
 Experim. Pathologic, Bd. XVII., 1883. 
 
 >Ueber Neulnlduiig and Zerfall weisser Blulkorperchen. Sitzungsber. der Wiener Akad., 
 Bd. XCII., Abth. III., 1885. 
 
 Also: Ueber den dritten Formbestaiidtheil des Blutes. "Lotos," Jahrbuch fiir Natur- 
 wissenschaft. Prag, 1885. 
 
 §Zur Kentniss der Biutkorperohen bei den niedern Wirbelthieren. Festschrift fUr Kolliker 
 Leipzig, 1887, p. 37. 
 
)L. 11. 
 
 fusi- 
 
 1890-91.] 
 
 AMPHIBIA BLOOD STUDIES. 
 
 60 
 
 V 
 
 the longitudinal stripe, or folding, described by Hayem and Bizzozero 
 and Torre and several refracting bodies in the nucleus, with one larger 
 and rounder than the rest to represent a nucleolus. 
 
 The spindles undergo change quickly under the microscope with the 
 ordinary conditions of observation. Their protoplasm swells up and 
 disintegrates into a quantity of fine granules which partly dissolve and 
 leave a faint, somewhat irregular body in which the nucleus still persists. 
 The chromatin in the nucleus of the ordinary spindle is more irregular 
 in its arrangement and more fully developed than in the white cells, and 
 it does not form a network as in the latter or in red cells. 
 
 As salient points in their character, Eberth emphasizes their colorless- 
 ness and their lack of amoeboid movement, both of which separate them 
 from the white and red cells. They are not young red blood cells, for 
 these even, in division, contain from their beginning haemoglobin. That 
 the fusiform cells do not contain even the slightest trace of haemoglobin • 
 is shown by the fact that thick masses of them have not the faintest 
 color, which would not have been the case if some of them contained 
 haemoglobin. Hayem regarded them as haematoblasts in his first paper, 
 but the phenomena of Karyokinesis* in haemoglobin-holding blood cells 
 was then unknown, and it is probable that he mistook the true haemo- 
 globin-holding haematoblast for the forms intermediate between the 
 fusiform and the red cells. 
 
 Eberth does not advance any view as to the origin or nature of the 
 fusiform elements, simply contenting himself with pointing out the 
 analogies between them and the platelets of mammalian blood. 
 
 It will be seen by a comparison of the above views that von Reckling- 
 hausen and Hayem postulate the presence of hremoglobin in the fusiform 
 elements while Bizzozero and Torre and Eberth deny this. Again, 
 Hayem and Hlava state that it is contractile and this is expressly 
 opposed by Eberth. Hayem considers them to be haematoblasts, with 
 Hlava they are white corpuscles or a variety of the same, while with 
 Bizzozero and Eberth they can only be compared to the platelets of 
 mammalian blood. Such constitutes, in brief, the diversity of views as to 
 their nature. 
 
 My own view is that these elements represent the remains of the 
 destroyed or broken up red cells and the following are the facts on which 
 the view is based : 
 
 I. Their nuclei are oval and nearly the same in size as those of the 
 red ceils {l6fix 14/n. and 20/ax I2ix respectively). The difference between 
 
 •In his more recent work (Uu Sang Ac.) all reference to these points is omitted. 
 
70 
 
 TRANSACTIONS OF THE CANADIAN INSTITUTE. 
 
 [Vol. II. 
 
 ifi 
 
 ii 
 
 
 the two in the latter respect is caused, I maintain, by the nucleus of tlie 
 fusiform cell enlarging in its transverse diameter and dininishing 
 consequently in its longitudinal diameter. If one keeps a specimen 
 of blood under observation for a while, during which it is protected 
 from evaporation, one finds that the nuclei of the fusiform elements 
 actually undergo this enlargement in its transverse diameter, the trans- 
 versely placed trabeculae of its network elongate till the chromatin 
 appears arranged in a number of parallel bars transversely placed. One 
 can, moreover, by sudden pressure on the cover glass, rupture a number 
 of red cells, set free their nuclei which undergo the same series of 
 changes that the nuclei of the fusiform cells do, and shortly after the 
 rupture the nuclei of the red cells measured exactly the same (i6/^x 13^ 
 and 14/t). In the free nuclei there is the same transverse enlargement, 
 the chromatolysis and nuclear disintegration. 
 
 2. When a number of nuclei of red cells are set free by pressure there 
 is the same tendency to adhere to each other that is so marked in the 
 case of the fusiform element. To each of these free nuclei there is 
 enough of cytoplasma adherent to constitute the cement necessary to 
 agglutinate them together, and in the masses so formed there is nothing 
 to distinguish them from the thrombi formed of fusiform cells. I have 
 not yet succeeded in observing in them any pseudopodial movement, but 
 it is not often that this is observed in the fusiform elements and it is 
 possible that it is the result of a survival from a well nourished condition 
 in the blood vessels, ri condition not at all present under the cover glass. 
 
 3. The free nuclei and those of the fusiform elements have the same 
 staining reactions. In a cover glass preparation fixed with corrosive 
 sublimate or picric acid, in which free nuclei are abundant, the latter, as 
 well as those of the fusiform cells, give with the Indigo-carmine Fluid a 
 blue-black, sometimes an intense black, and with haematoxylin a black 
 reaction. In fact there is the same, or nearly the same stain with all the 
 dyes. There is one important difference so far as the cytoplasma of 
 both is concerned : eosin takes intensely the cytoplasma of the fusiform 
 cells while it stains lightly or not at all the slender protoplasm around 
 the free nuclei. The explanation of this is that the interfilar chromatin 
 (the haematogen) of the nucleus of the ruptured red cell gradually diffuses 
 out from the nucleus into the cytoplasma without being converted into 
 haemoglobin, as it is in the normal corpuscle and that it is this altered 
 chromatin which takes eosin deeply. In some of the fusiform cells there 
 is the same differentiation of the nuclear substance into network and 
 interfilar chromatin, the latter staining deeply with eosin, the former with 
 haematoxylin. There can be no doubt about the fact that in such cells 
 
 
)L. ir. 
 
 f the 
 
 inieii 
 lected 
 iients 
 rans- 
 
 <itiii 
 One 
 iTiber 
 s of 
 
 the 
 
 lent, 
 
 1890-91.] 
 
 AMPinniA BLOOD 8TUDIKS. 
 
 71 
 
 
 the nuclear chromatin is arranged in the form of a network in every 
 respect like that in the nucleus of the red cell. In such cases one 
 rarely finds the Indigo-carmine Fluid to react as it does in the nuclei 
 of the intact red cells, giving a light red stain to the intcrfilar chromatin 
 and a green or a bluc-grecn color to network. These are evidently cells 
 which have had but a very short history as fusiform cells, that is, they 
 have been but recently formed, while the other elements which do not 
 sViow these peculiarities are more pathological by reason of their longer 
 existence as fusiform celLs. 
 
 4. The nuclei of these elements are admitted by Bizzozcro, Ilayem, 
 to present resemhlances to those of the red cells. These observers, 
 however, took for study the blood of animals in which tiie red, white and 
 fusiform cells are comparatively small, and consequently were unable to 
 determine the more important points of resemblance. 
 
 We can, therefore, on the view that the fusiform e'ements are the 
 remains of ruptured red cells, explain the absence of a membrane, the 
 capacity for adhering to each other, the similarity in shape, size, .structure 
 and staining reactions between their nuclei and those of the red cells 
 when freshly ruptured. We can, moreover, explain their occurrence 
 thereby without referring in any way to the ha;matoblasts or to the 
 leucocytes, and we have also explained to a certain extent the fate of the 
 red cells — what was not done before. 
 
 One can readily determine the fate of the.se fusiform corpuscles even 
 in cover-glass preparations of Necturus blood fixed with osmic acid, 
 picric and especially corrosive sublimate. Fig. 22 a represents a fusiform 
 corpuscle in which there is a distinct and coarse chromatin network with 
 a certain amount of interfilar chromatin. At a later stage the trabeculae 
 of this network become thinner and finally disappear, and when this 
 happens the whole nucleus takes a uniform stain with various dyes. 
 Sometimes the nodal points of this network alone persist and may 
 appear as nucleoli. In the now homogeneous nacleus lobation may 
 ensue (Fig. 22 c, e. /.), and the lobation may go so far, accompanied by 
 a transformation of the shape into that of a more or less round mass, as 
 to render them extremely like leucocytes. Tliey possess now no amoe- 
 boid properties whatever, and their cytoplasma, which is now compara- 
 tively abundant, begins to lose its eosinophilous character while the 
 nuclear chromatin reacts less readily and more feebly to dyes. As such 
 they are broken up, probably in the circulation and more especially in 
 the vessels of the spleen. 
 
 As factors operating in the production of the fusiform cells, mechani- 
 
72 
 
 TRANHACTI0N8 OF THE CANADIAN INSTITUTK. 
 
 [Vol. II. 
 
 M' 
 
 ||; 
 
 1^ 
 
 cal conditions inside the blood vessels may be mentioned. It always 
 appeared to me that my cover preparations were far richer in fusiform 
 cells when the blood was obtained from the firmly pressed or squeezed 
 tail of a specimen o{ Necturus than when the blood was simply allowed 
 to drop on the cover glass from the tail tip. Of course there may be 
 other circumstances which serve to increase or diminish the number of 
 fusiform cells in the preparations, but it seems reajsonable to suppose 
 that the pressure which is employed between two cover glasses to 
 rupture the red cells can be as effectually exercised in the blood vessels of 
 the intact body. There is, however, another factor which may be less 
 extensive in its effects. I refer to the giant cells in the spleen of the 
 same animal. In a portion of the spleen of a freshly killed Necturus 
 teased out, a few giant cells are always observable in which one finds one 
 or more large spherules of haemoglobin-holding substance imbedded in 
 the cytoplasma. These giant cells are amoeboid, and it is, presumably, 
 reasonable to suppose that these masses of haemoglobin have been 
 removed from the discs of red cells by the invaginating power of the 
 amceboid cells. There is in these same cells no evidence whatever of 
 nuclei, either chromatolysed or intact, which could be considered as 
 derived from the red discs, and the only inference possible is that the 
 nuclei and the remainder of the disc cytoplasma have passed away into 
 the general circulation as fusiform elements. What becomes of them 
 finally after they have passed through the cycle of changes described, 
 whether the leucocytes eat up their disintegrated remains, cannot be 
 determined. I do not know why the nuclei of ruptured red cells do not 
 possess the same amount of peripherally disposed cytoplasma as the 
 fusiform corpuscles do, but it is supposable that either the cytoplasma is 
 deposited from the nucleus or that fully formed fusiform cells are derived 
 from red corpuscl^ only at a certain time in the life history of the latter, 
 and that the conditions demanded by either of these hypotheses is 
 assisted, in the formation and transformation of the fusiform cells, by the 
 chemical and physiological equilibrium of the blood inside the blood 
 vessels. 
 
 We can explain the fate of the leucocytes. No observation has 
 hitherto been made as to the fate of the red cells. My view, I think, 
 presents the easiest and best solution of the question. With it there is 
 no necessity for considering the fusiform elements as htematoblasts ; it is 
 consistent, furthermore, with Strieker's observations on the transformation 
 of spin41es into globular "white" cells* and it specially explains why 
 
 • Quoted by L6 it, op. cit. 
 
L. II. 
 
 1890-9 1. J 
 
 AMP'IIBIA BLOOD STUDIES. 
 
 7J 
 
 the fusiform elements are found only in the blood of those animals which 
 contain nucleated red corpuscles.* 
 
 III. The Origin ov the H/Kmatv.>blasts in Amphibian Emurvo. 
 
 There is probably no biological subject on which there is a greater 
 diversity of view than that of the origin of the blood corpuscles in the 
 embryo and adult vertebrate. The views on this point have multiplied 
 greatly within the last five years and as they have not much in common, 
 a resumd of them can hardly serve any useful purpose in a paper so 
 limited in its scope as this one is. The observations, nevertheless, which 
 have been already published as to the origin of the ha^matoblasts in Fishes 
 . and Amphibia have an important bearing on the facts which I am about 
 to describe and I shall, therefore, give here an outline sketch of them be- 
 fore proceeding with the description c f my own observations. 
 
 Goettef found the blood cells arise in the mass of the yolk cells. On 
 the under and lateral edges of the yolk mass in Batrachian larva; blood 
 cells are formed by the breaking up of the large peripheral yolk cells into 
 smaller ones, and at the same time there separates from the inner side of 
 the visceral layer a number of cells forming a covering for the groove in 
 the yolk in which the blood cells are developed. As the interstitial 
 fluidity of the mass increases it extends over the yolk and affects 
 the surrounding tissue just in the same manner as the interstitial 
 fluid shapes the origin of the primary vessels, producing pouch-like 
 diverticula connected with one another, from the yolk vessels. Goette 
 regards the red and white cells of the spleen as direct descendants of the 
 yolk cells. 
 
 DavidoffJ reservedly expresses the view that the yolk spherules give 
 origin by, possibly, protoplasmic transformation to parablastic elements 
 and that the latter develop, in many cases, into blood cells. On this view 
 the nucleus of the blood cell is but a yolk spherule imbedded in a proto- 
 plasmic basis, and Davidoff thinks that this is, in a sense, a confirmation 
 of Brass' theory that the chromatin of the nucleus of every cell is secreted 
 or stored up food material. 
 
 * As the red corpuscle in mammalia is comparatively a fragile element its disintegration can 
 scarcely involve the survival of any formed or structural element. If the fusiform element is the 
 nucleus and a small portion of cytoplasma of the red cell in lower vertebrates, we may suppose 
 since the platelets of mammalian blood are recognised generally as the homologues of the fusi- 
 form cells that the former are nuclei which have been extruded from hoematoblasts, an extrusion 
 which Rindfleisch and Howell observed. 
 
 t Entwicklungsgeschichte der Unke. 
 
 + Ueber die Entstehung der rothen Blut Korperchen und den Parablast von Salamandra 
 maculosa. Zoologischer Anzeiger, 1884, s. 453. 
 
74 
 
 TRAN8AC!T10N8 OF THK CANADIAN INSTITUTE. 
 
 [Vol. II. 
 
 I 
 
 Wenckebach* found that in Telcost enibryo.s the blood cells originate 
 from a mass of cells placed under the notochord and between it and the 
 hypoblastic layer. The origin of this cell mass could not be determined, 
 when he published his first paper, but afterwards he traced it to the 
 mcsoblast and was able, therefore, to corroborate Ziegler'.sf first observa- 
 tions on this point. This intermediate cell mass may arise, as in Be/one, 
 from an impaired organ but in the Salmon it is formed by the fusion of 
 two separate columns of cells. The blood cells arc thus, according to 
 Wenckebach, of mcsoblastic origin and are not derivable in any way 
 from the hypoblast or from the periblastic cells. 
 
 Ziegler* confirms Wenckebach's observations on the development of 
 the blood cells in the majority of Teleost embryos out of the cellular 
 elements of the intermediate cell mass placed between the entoderm 
 and chorda. This mass is of mesodermal origin and the cells con- 
 stituting it wander away over the yolk and, in a measure, as they do this 
 they make the cavities previously occupied by them larger and larger, 
 the cavities forming, finally, the cardinal veins. Up to this time the 
 blood which is free from cellular elements, flows in closed vessels 
 represented at this stage by the heart, aorta, caudal vein and sub- 
 intestinal veins. The latter empty on the yolk and the blood passes 
 from the posterior surface of the yolk sack to the heart, not in 
 a closed vessel, but free in the space between the yolk and the ectoderm. 
 There arises in the yolk a corresponding furrow to which wandering 
 cells pass to form a vascular wall. These wandering cells are in no way 
 distinguishable from the blood corpuscles of the same stage which are 
 abundant on the surface of the yolk and which arise, as already said, 
 from the elements of the intermediate cell mass. Sometimes, as in 
 the pike, a formation of blood cells, similar to that occurring in the 
 intermediate cell mass, obtains in a portion of the aorta. 
 
 According to this view the blood cells are derived from the columns 
 of cells which occupy the position of the developing cardinal and other 
 veins and they are not, except accidentally, and through their amoeboid 
 movement, connected with the yolk. 
 
 * The development of the blood corpuscles in the Embryo of Perca fluviatilis. Jour, of 
 Anat. .ind Phys. Vol. XIX., 1885, p. 231. Also : Beitriige zur Enlwicklungsgeschichte der 
 Knochenfische. Arch, fiir Mikr. Anat,, Bd. XXVIII, p. 225. 
 
 * Die Enibryonale Entwicklung von Salmo Salar. (Inaugural Dissertation). Freiburg, 1882. 
 
 * Die Entstehung des Blutes bei Knochenfischembryonen. Arch, fur Mikr. Anat., Bd. 
 XXX, s. 596. Also : Die Entstehung des Blutes der Wirbelthiere. Berichte d. Naturforsch. 
 Gesell. zu Freiburg i. B. Bd. IV. s. 171. 
 
 i 
 
L. II. 
 
 18J0-91.] 
 
 AMPHIBIA BLOOD HTUDIEH. 
 
 70 
 
 nate 
 the 
 ncd, 
 the 
 rva- 
 lone, 
 )n of 
 g to 
 way 
 
 Ruckert* gives a full description of the origin of the blood cells in 
 Torpedo embryos. He found them to arise in the peripheral mcsoblast 
 where they constitute groups situated in cavities formed between the 
 spindle-shaped incsoblastic cells. Where the outer and inner layers of 
 the bl.istoderm arc closely applied to the yolk these groups give off cells 
 which constitute the blood islands of the posterior germinal area. At the 
 latter point, according to RUckert, there can be no doubt about the origin 
 of the blood cells out of the mesoblast. Laterally, and in front where 
 the mesoblast is thin, the formation of the blood and of the vessels occurs 
 through the accession to this part of freshly divided yolk cells (mcrocytcs). 
 Far anteriorly, the merocytes may be very large in size and appear then 
 as niegasphcres. The latter may, through unequal, imiircct division, bud- 
 ding and fragmentation, give also origin to blood cells and mesoblast. 
 
 This brief sketch of the various theories as to the method of blood 
 formation and the origin of blijod cells shows how discordant they are. 
 Goette believes that the peripheral yolk cells break up into h.tmatoblasts, 
 Davidoff thinks that yolk spherules become the nuclei of the red cells 
 and that the discoplasma is ^Icrived from transformed protoplasm of 
 the yolk, Wenckebach and Zieglcr considered that the h;ematoblasts are 
 of mesoblastic origin wholly, while Riickert is apparently disposed to 
 believe that they are derived from the yolk cells on the one hand and 
 from the mesoblast on the other. 
 
 As far as my observations on the Amblystoina larva; go they are in 
 accord with those of Wenckebach and Ziegler on Telcostean embryos, as 
 to the derivation of the hcxmatoblasts from the mesoblast alone. 
 
 The first blood corpuscles of the Amhlystoma larva; appear at about 
 the twelfth or thirteenth dayf after the deposition of the ova. At this 
 date the heart is in the process of formation, the endothelial portions 
 of it being derived from the entoblast in the manner described by 
 Rabl* for Salainandra and Triton. The heart cavity, for thirty-six hours 
 after this, even when fully formed, contains no cellular elements of any 
 sort. The first blood vessels to be formed appear also at the twelfth day, 
 constituting the subintestinal veins§ and it is in association with the 
 formation of these that the ha;matoblasts make their appearance. 
 
 * Ueber die Anla|,'e des mittleren Kiemblattes und die erste Hliubildung bei Torpedo. 
 Anal. Anz., 1887, Nos. 4 and 6. Also : Weitere Beitrage zur Keimblatlbildung l)ci Sclachiern. 
 Anat. Anz., 1889, No. 12. 
 
 + These dates are only approximate as there is a great variation in the development of the 
 larviB in the same mass of eggs. 
 
 iMorph. Jahrbuch, Ikl. XII. p. 252. 
 
 §The occurrence of two subintestinal veins .instead of one in Sclachii was first pointed out 
 l)y Mayer (Mitth. ans des Zool. .Stat, zu Ncapel, Vol. VII., p, 340) and subsequently by Riickert 
 ('.V. ,-/'.! 
 
76 
 
 THANSAC'XIONB OF THE CANADIAN INSTITUTE. 
 
 [Vol. II. 
 
 .M 
 
 i 
 
 I 
 
 At about the eleventh day the ventral portion of the mesoblastic plate 
 on each .side consists of two layers of cells forming the visceral and 
 parietal portion of the plate. These layers are closely applied to the 
 entoblast and ectoblast respectively, but not at first to each other, for 
 evidences of a slit-like space between them which represents a persistent 
 part of the primitive body cavity, can be very well seen at this 
 date. This slit quickly disappears through the growth of the adjacent 
 parts and the consequent pressure exercised on the mesoblastic cells. 
 The latter are, at first, more or les-- rounded in outline but the pressure 
 exerted on them gives them a somewhat flattened appearance, except at 
 the lower, extreme margin where the visceral and parietal layers become 
 connected, the cells of the visceral layer here retaining, to a considerable 
 extent, their original shape. 
 
 This part of the mesoblast seems to possess a greater capacity for 
 proliferation than the more dorsally placed portions of the ventral half. 
 The proliferation is limited chiefly to the cells at the extremity of the 
 plate and to those immediately above this belonging to the visceral 
 layer. The latter at the point in question is, about the twelfth day, 
 formed of two or more series of cells, those constituting the rriost 
 internal layer becoming very much flattened and like, in this respect, the 
 cells of the single layer of the parietal portion. The cells placed 
 between are obviously in the position occupied previously by the slit- 
 like space, the more ventrally placed portion of the primary body cavity, 
 and as they undergo division more frequently than the other cells, they 
 cause a still greater flattening of the remaining cells of the visceral layer 
 and of those of the parietal portion, with the result that these resemble 
 fully formed endothelial cells. In a transverse section of the larva at about 
 the thirteenth day, taken a short distance behind the developing heart, 
 the cells first described lie in two large masses one on each of the ventro- 
 lateral margins of the entoblast in which depressions exist to contain 
 the masses of cells. The depressions are lined by the flattened endothe- 
 lial elements derived from the visceral layer which are now recognisable 
 with difficulty, and covered externally by similarly flattened endothelial 
 cells derived from the parietal layer. The visceral and parietal layers 
 above this are still at this time formed each of only one layer of ceils 
 more or less flattened. The cells constituting the masses described are 
 the hsmatoblasts, while the depressions in the yolk or entoblast consti- 
 tute the site of the subintestinal veins. 
 
 As the subintestinal veins are followed backwards they are seen to ap- 
 proach, with the mesoblast plates, more and more the middle of the line 
 of the ventral side of the yolk and where the mesoblastic plates from 
 
1890-91.1 
 
 AMPHIBIA BLOOD STUDIRS. 
 
 73 
 
 each side unite in the middle line, the veins form a single channel, 
 till a point immediately in front of the anus is reached. In its 
 course backwards the vessel is filled with cells closely packed and derived, 
 in the same manner as those forward arc, from the viscer.il layer of the 
 mesoblast, although it is more difficult to exclude here the participation 
 of the parietal layer in the formation of the h.x-matoblasts. The nieso- 
 blastic plates again diverge at the anus and the venous trunk bifurcates. 
 a branch running separately on e.ich side of the cloacal cavity, the cells 
 contained in them becoming less in number till, for lack of them, it is im 
 possible to follow the veins any distance behind the anus. 
 
 When these veins and the cellular elements in them have attained the 
 development described the heart is formed and beats. At first it contains 
 no organized elements, the force of the beat being, apparently, exercised 
 on what would appear to be serum. About the fifteenth or sixteenth day 
 cellular elements in every respect like those found in the subintestinal 
 veins are found in large numbers in the heart cavity and as the 
 subintestinal veins are almost empty it is clear that the haimatoblasts 
 are derived from this source. It i.s, in fact, easy in scries of sagittal 
 sections of larvae of the fourteenth and fifteenth days to see the detach- 
 ment of the hjEmatoblasts in the anterior portions of the subintestinal 
 veins and their arrival in the heart cavity. 
 
 The haematoblasts are derived from this source alone. All the other 
 vessels of the body have a different origin, that is, they are not formed by 
 solid columns of cells exerting a pressure on the immediately adjacent 
 mesoblastic elements, but rather by the extension of the subintestinal 
 vessels and of the cavities of the heart. In Amblystoma larvae therefore 
 the haematoblasts are of mesoblastic origin alone and they are not in- 
 creased in numbers by additions from the yolk elements or entoblast. 
 
 At first they are large, not differing from mesoblast cells in any- 
 thing except their somewhat spherical shape. They contain in their 
 cytoplasma a large number of yolk spherules which obscure more or less 
 the nucleus. The latter is somewhat irregular, often amoeboid in outline 
 and richer, apparently, in chromatin than the ordinary mesoblastic cells 
 of the same stage of development. To this greater richness in chromatin 
 may be attributed the more abundant proliferation of these cells, for one 
 can see that cell division is more frequent in them than in the neigh- 
 boring cells. As the quantity of yolk spherules is limited, the repeated 
 division, probably accompanied by a digestive action on the part of the 
 cell on the spherules, produces a form of haematoblast (Fig. i6 and 17 
 a and b) in which the yolk spherules are few and in which nuclear 
 chromatin is very abundant. It is in this stage that one finds the 
 
74 
 
 TKANHAimoNB Of THK CANADIAN INSTITUTE. 
 
 [Vol. II. 
 
 h.T:matobIast amnnboid in outlines. Its cytoplasma is as yet undiffer- 
 entiated and it docs not possess a membrane althouf,'h the peripheral 
 portion {TJves evidence of its forniatic^n in tlic presence of a scries of 
 rcffularly arranjjcd granulc-lii<e bodies affording a sliarply outlined 
 border. 
 
 In Figs. 19, 20 and 21 we see the ha;inatoblasts of a later stage 
 with much fewer yolk spherules and with specialization of form and 
 structure allied to that in tlie mature red corpuscle. The outline 
 is o/al or elliptical and the peripheral portion is usually limited 
 by d clear hyaline, somewhat thick membrane while the cytoplasma is 
 differentiated into coarse or fine trabeculie strewn along which are 
 granules, some of them brownish in color like those found occurring in 
 the mc';oblastic and cctoblastic cells of this and later stages. Frequently 
 the cytoplasma in the immediate vicmity of tiie nucleus is den.ser, stains 
 somewhat more deeply than the remainder while it sends coarse pro- 
 oii^ations in a ra li.itinij fasliio;i outwirJs (Fig. 20). The corpuscles are 
 not as yet flattened, but about the twentieth day the majority of them 
 are elliptical in outline and fl.ittened. When the larviu of this date are 
 fi.xed with Flemming's Fluid the discoplasma and nuclei of such 
 blood cells are homogeneous, indicating that the latter arc fully formed^ 
 or mature blood cells. These corpuscles are no longer capable of division 
 and their nuclei give with alum crchineal a reddish-brown stain and vVith 
 haematoxylin a brown stain, in .-ach case like that given in the red cor- 
 puscles of the adult animal. There still persist ha;matoblasts in which 
 karyokinesis is very common and in which no specialisation of forT,,' 
 such as that described for the remaining blood cells, is observable. These 
 are the elements from which originate, not only the future blood cor- 
 puscles, but al.so the future haematoblasts. These elements form but a 
 small proportion of the whole number of corpuscles and as they 
 pos.sess the power of division while the mature elements do not, the 
 origin of these must now be considered. 
 
 In order to determine this, sections of larvjE of the eighteenth and nine- 
 teenth days hardened in chromic acid and stained with haematoxylin and 
 eosin must be examined. If a section through the sinus venosus be 
 under observation it v/ill be found that that cavity contains a large 
 number of blood corpuscles which, according to the staining effects of the 
 two dyes, can be divided into two classes: one, the more numerous in 
 which both nucleus and cytoplasma show a special affinity for the eosin, 
 the former being often stained only with this dye; the other, comprising 
 corpuscles in the nuclei of which the haematoxylin alone has reacted. 
 Both classes of corpuscles are fairly represented in Fig. 15, a and b, the 
 
II. 
 
 1890-91.] 
 
 AuriiiniA ntooD btudiks. 
 
 7.> 
 
 greenish elements of the cytoplasma in both beiny yolk splieruks coloreil 
 by the reduction of the chromic acid. In the corpuscles at tins st.i^c 
 karyokincsis is not more common than it is in ordinary tissue cells. It 
 would appear that tiie more numerous class of ct)rpusclcs, /'. «•., those 
 reactin^j deeply with eosin, become converted into the mature blood cells 
 existing in the larva up to the twenty-fifth day, for it is these cells onl)- 
 which illustrate the specialization of form and structure already described 
 and partly represented by Vh^s. 19-21. The cells which react with 
 hitmatoxylin alone constitute the persistent elements which ultimately 
 become the ficcjuently dividin;^ h.x-matoblasts of the later staj^es of de- 
 velopment. The cosinophilous cells are api)arently in a condition of 
 degeneration, for the division of their nuclei is not always followed by a 
 division of the cell (Fi^^ iH). Hoth cla.sses of h.eniatoblasts at this time 
 do not specially illustrate division but those which stain with hiema- 
 toxylin only .seem to retain the capacity for proliferation while the 
 cosinophilous elements gradually lose it within the next ten days. 
 
 At a period which seems to comcide with the formation of the liver as 
 a vascular organ and with the development of tubules in it, ihe ha;mato- 
 blasts, which, from the sixteenth to the nineteenth day, when hardened in 
 chromic acid, stain with ha;matoxylin only, now begin to acc^uire a capa- 
 city for proliferation far in excess of that which they previously had. It 
 would appear that this change is associated with the appearance, in the 
 blood vessels of the body generally and of the liver specially, of a serum 
 which stains very deeply with eosin. This serum stains slightly with 
 alum-cochineal but greenish-blue or green, like the yolk spherules, with 
 the Indigo-carmine Fluid described in the foregoing pages. I regard this 
 staining capacity of the serum as due to the solution of yolk or rather of 
 that constituent of it which has been called haematogen by Bunge. This 
 is but a reserve form of chromatin and as the undifferentiated haima- 
 toblasts float in the serum, it is reasonable to believe that they absorb the 
 dissolved chromatin. It is from this time on that the ha;matoblasts begin 
 to manifest the incessant divisions which characterize the stage repre- 
 sented by Figs. 9, 10 and 1 1. It is at this time also that the chromatic 
 figures of the haematoblasts increase in size. Previously their figures were 
 not larger than those of the other cells of the body. These facts can be 
 explained in no other way than by assuming that the haematoblasts sur- 
 viving as such, absorb the chromatin or " haematogen " which is dissolved 
 in the serum and thereby entered on a phase of renewed vitality. The 
 other cells in the body also exhibit divisions now more frequently than 
 before this stage, though not by any means as frequently as the haemato- 
 blasts, and this increased capacity for proliferation may also be explained 
 
76 
 
 TRANSACTIONS OF THE CANADIAN INSTITUTE. 
 
 [Vol. II. 
 
 I 
 
 II' 
 
 by the more abundant supply of dissolved chromatin in the serum bath- 
 ing them. 
 
 These haematoblasts are met with most frequently in those parts of 
 the circulatory apparatus where the blood current is slow or where physical 
 conditions retard their movement. Such conditions are found between 
 the muscle trabecule stretching through the heart cavity after these are 
 formed, in the concave portions of the aortic arches and especially in a 
 minute branch of the arteria mesenterica distributed in a plate of tissue 
 derived from the visceral layer of the mesoblast. This is the site for the 
 future spleen. The origin of the spleen in the visceral layer of the 
 mesoblast in the toad was pointed out by Goette* who described the 
 cells of the organ as direct descendants of the yolk cells (entoblastic 
 cells). My observations are not yet concluded in the development of the 
 spleen, but they have progressed so far as to allow me to say definitely 
 that the organ increases in bulk by multiplication of the capillaries 
 arising from the branch of the mesenteric artery to accommodate the 
 excessively large number of haematoblasts derived by division from the 
 original haematoblasts which have been caught in the narrow spaces of 
 the capillaries, early in development of the organ. At a date roughly 
 corresponding to the interval between the fortieth and sixtieth days, sec-^ 
 tions of the organ fixed in Flemming's Fluid and stained with haematoxr 
 ylin and eosin, contain a very great number of elements like those repre- 
 sented in Figs. lo and ii. In fact sections of the organ thus prepared 
 have a deep ochre-red or terra-cotta-red color, owing to the great number 
 of mitotic haematoblasts present in it. At later stages of development 
 haematoblasts are rarely found elsewhere than in the spleen, which is, from 
 now on, the organ for their production out of the original elements whose 
 history has been traced above and whose presence in the spleen is to 
 be explained as I have pointed out. Whether there is a secondary 
 formation of haematoblasts -out of the cells of the original tissue of the 
 visceral layer of the mesoblast, it is impossible to say, but as the 
 haematoblasts and the spleen are both formed cut of portions of visceral 
 layer, such a secondary origin is not, theoretically, improbable. All that 
 I can at present say is that early in the development of the spleen its 
 vascular channels become distended with haematoblasts, which are also to 
 be found in other vessels of the body where the blood current is slowed 
 or retarded, that these haematoblasts undergo rapid divisions and in- 
 creaoe thereby the size of the organ and that these divisions are quite 
 sufficient to explain the occurrence there of all the haematoblasts 
 observed. The first appearance of the organ in fact consists in the 
 
 • Loc. cit. p. 8 1 3. 
 
 \. 
 
1890-91.] 
 
 AMPHIBIA BLOOD 81UDIES. 
 
 77 
 
 presence of a few haematoblasts like those shown in Figs. lo and t i 
 in the channel of the branch of the mesenteric artery. 
 
 As I have never found in adult caudate Amphibia haematoblasts in any 
 other organ than the spleen and then only in its blood sinuses, these 
 may be regarded as direct descendants of the hiematoblasts which arise 
 by proliferation of the cells of the ventral portion of the visceral 
 plate of the mesoblast. 
 
 It is, I think, worthy of note that though there is but one source for 
 all haematoblasts, yet there are two stages in their history, the second of 
 which appears when the liver begins to take on its adult structure, the 
 forms belonging to this stage being remarkable for their great capacity 
 for division, while the first series of haematoblasts are, almost wholly, 
 formed in the subintestinal veins and the great majority of them 
 are directly converted into red cells, the remainder persisting to form the 
 haematoblasts of the second stage. 
 
 IV. Conclusions. 
 
 1. The haemoglobin of the blood corpuscles is derived from the abun- 
 dant nuclear chromatin of the hasmatoblast. 
 
 2. The fusiform cells of Amphibian blood are derived from the red 
 corpuscles, the latter in this conversion losing the cell membrane and the 
 greater portion of the discoplasma. 
 
 3. The haematoblasts in Ambly stoma are direct descendants of cells 
 split off from the extreme ventral portions of the visceral mesoblast and 
 they pass, at first, a portion of their existence in a specialized part 
 of the original body cavity of the embryo. 
 
 V. Appendix.* 
 
 The foregoing paper was written, part in 1889, part in 1890. The 
 publication of it now seems opportune since one of the conclusions con- 
 tained in it has been fully confirmed by the results of my investigations 
 during the last year. The chromatin of every cell, animal and vegetable, is 
 an iron compound and this can be proved not only by the use of freshly 
 prepared ammonium sulphide, as described in a communication sent to 
 the Royal Society of London f last year, but also by other methods since 
 discovered, the use of which excludes inorganic and albuminate iron and, 
 at the same time, does not affect the iron in haemoglobin or haematin. 
 With the more recently discovered methods, so easy is their application 
 
 * Written Feb. 4, 1892. 
 
 t Proceedings, Toy. Soc, Vol. 50, p. 277. 
 
78 
 
 TRANSACTIONS OF THE CANADIAN INSTITUTE. 
 
 [Vol. II. 
 
 and so definite their reaction, one may make permanently mounted pre- 
 parations of sections of animal and vegetable tissues, in which the distribu- 
 tion of the chromatin is shown by the iron reaction. The latter may 
 thus be quite readily employed instead of the staining methods with haima- 
 toxylin and other dyes which, when carefully used, are supposed to select 
 only chromatin. The results which I have obtained with the new 
 methods are so numerous and so important that I must reserve an ex- 
 tended description of them for another paper. Suffice it at present to soy 
 that the fundamental life substance is an iron cofitpound and that, in;- ren 
 tially, the chemical processes underlying life, in other xvords life itsclj ] n\- 
 to be referred to the constant oxidation and reduction of the iron of this 
 compound. This iron-holding compound being present in every living 
 cell, the mystery of the appearance, here and there in animal and veget- 
 able forms, of haematin* either free, or att iched to a proteid as haimo- 
 globin, is explained. 
 
 It is to be noted further that the iron, though not held in chromatin 
 as firmly as it is in haematin, is yet as tenaciously held therein as it is in 
 the ferrocyanides, which also yield, under the same conditions, their 
 iron to ammonium sulphide. 
 
 The methods referred to show further that the stainable substance 
 which diffuses from the nuclei and mitotic figures in hajmatoblasts, is an 
 iron compound in which the iron is less firmly held than in haemoglobin, 
 and that it persists for comparatively a long time as such, before 
 becoming converted into the latter substance. There are also facts which 
 seem to indicate that haemoglobin is a degeneration product and not a 
 substance formed in the synthetical processes of the haematoblasts. 
 
 The bearing of these conclusions on the currently accepted views 
 as to the pathology of anaemia is obvious. Since haemoglobin is a 
 derivative product of chromatin, and since the latter is an iron compound 
 all important in cellular life, anaemia cannot be, primarily, a deficiency in 
 the formation of haemoglobin, but, first of all, a deficiency in chromatin, 
 not only of haematoblasts, but of every cell in the body. In other words 
 the primary cause of all anaemias, other than haemolytic, is hypochromatosis 
 and the condition wh'ch Virchow called hypoplasia is as much a result of 
 this hypochromatosis, as is the deficiency in formation of hremoglobin. 
 
 Other points arising out of these investigations may be mentioned : the 
 differences between animal and vegetable chromatin and between the 
 chromatin of highly specialized animal cells on the one hand and that of 
 lower forms of animal life, on the other, the occurrence of haemoglobin 
 
 
 *Linossier and Phipson describe (Comptes Rendus Vol. CXII, pp. 40 
 occurrence of hiematin-like compounds in Aspergillus niger and Palmella cruew 
 
 : ^ 666) the 
 
 'k i 
 
1890-91.] 
 
 AMPHIBIA BLOOD 8T0DIE8. 
 
 79 
 
 chiefly in the higher types of animal life, the analogies between chloro- 
 phyll and hxmatin and the derivation of the digestive ferments from 
 chromatin. 
 
 These and other related subjects I intend to discuss in a future publication. 
 
 EXPLANATION OF FIGURES. 
 
 Figs. 1-4 are drawn from preparations from the adult Necturus, and Figs. 5-7 are 
 taken from larval Amblystomata (A. punctatum). 
 
 Fig. I. Red disc from a cover-glass preparation of the blood. Corrosive sublimate, 
 IndiRo-carmine Fluid— X 700. 
 
 Fig. 2. Red disc from splenic vein. Chromic acid. Indigo-carmine Fluid — X7oo- 
 
 Fig. 3. Red disc, cover-glass preparation. Chromic acid, Hematoxylin, Eosin — X 
 700. 
 
 Fig. 4. Red disc cover preparation. Corrosive sublimate, Haematoxylin, Eosin — X 7oo. 
 
 Fig. 5. Red disc from heart cavity. Flemming's Fluid, Haematoxylin, Eosin— X 1,000. 
 
 Fig. 6. Red disc from gill vessel. Osmic acid, Hasmatoxylin, Eosin— X 1,000. 
 
 Fig. 7. Cover-glass preparation of red blood cells. Fresh, acetic methyl-green — X 
 1,000. 
 
 Fig. 8. Group of blood cells from a vascular sinus in a section of the spleen of 
 Necturus. In the centre is represented a haematoblast in mitosis and with its chro- 
 matin so changed chemically that it takes the sulphindigotate portion of the reagent ; 
 a, a red disc, b a leucocyte. Chromic acid, Indigo-carmine Fluid — X700. 
 
 Fig. 9. From a free swimming Amblystoma larva. 
 
 a, Haematoblast from the concave side of one of the aortic arches, in division u 
 showing in the abundant chromatin as well as in the cytoplasma a slate or slate-brown 
 reaction. 
 
 b, an endothelial cell from same aortic arch in same preparation undergoing mitosis 
 and showing the normal reaction of the staining fluid. 
 
 Flemming's Fluid, Haematoxylin — X 1000. 
 
 Fig. 10. Haematoblast from concave side of aortic arch in a free-swimming larval 
 Amblystoma. Flemming's Huid, Haematoxylin, Eosin — X 1,000. 
 
 Fig. II. Haematoblast from same preparation as last — X 1,000. 
 
 Fig. 12. A dividing haematoblast in the last stage of its development, showing two 
 kinds of chromatin in the nuclear figures. Cover-glass preparation. Corrosive subli- 
 mate, Haematoxylin, Kosin — X 1 ,000 
 
 Figs. 13-14. Haematoblasts in the last stage of their development, showing a de- 
 generated chromatin between the regular chromatin loops of the dividing nuclei. 
 From the heart cavity of a free swimming Amblystoma larva. Flemming's Fluid, 
 Hematoxylin, Eosin— X 1.000. 
 
80 
 
 TRANSACTIONS OF THE CANADIAN INSTITUTE. 
 
 [Vol. II. 
 
 if {•: 
 
 
 Fig. 1$, a and b. Two ha?matoblasts from the heart cavity of a very young Ambly- 
 stoma larva (not free swimming). Chromic acid, Hematoxylin, Eosin. x 1250. 
 
 Figs. 16 and 17, a and b. Amoebiform hsematoblasts from heart cavity of a very 
 young larva (not free from envelope). The chromatin is very dense in the nuclei. 
 The cavities in the cytoplasma were occupied by yolk spherules. 
 
 Flemming's Fluid, Alum-cochineal — X900. 
 
 Figs. 18 and 19. Two haematoblasts from the heart cavity of very young larva (not 
 free swimming). Cavities in cytoplasma occupied by yolk spherules. Fig. 19 repre- 
 sents a more fully developed corpuscle with well defined contour and abundant 
 chromatin. Chromic acid, Haematoxylin, Eosin — X1250. 
 
 Fig. 20, a and b. Two hrematoblasts, from a very young larval Amblystoma, with 
 definite elliptical outlines, uncolored cytoplasma and the nuclei abundantly provided 
 with chromatin. Chromic acid, Haematoxylin, Eosin — X900. 
 
 Fig. 21, a and b. Two htematoblasts from larva of same age as in last case. P'lem- 
 ming's Fluid, Alum-cochineal — X1200. 
 
 Fig. 22, a--f. DifTerent forms of fusiform corpuscles met with in the same cover- 
 glass preparation of Necturus' blood, — b was fixed while exhibiting, apparently, the 
 slow vibratory motion of its thorn-like prolongations. Corrosive sublimate, Haema- 
 toxylin, Kosin — X 1,000. 
 
 Fig. 23, a—d. Fusiform corpuscles of Neduru^ blood exhibiting various intra 
 nuclear arrangements of its chromatin. Cover preparation. Picric acid, Safranin. 
 
 Fig. 24, a and b. A haematoblast (?) seen at two different optical planes exhibiting, 
 the peculiar yellowish granules (h.Tsmoglobin?) apparently like those described b^ , 
 Cuenot as secreted from the nucleus— a, at the plane passing through the upper 
 surface of the nucleus, b, at the plane passing the centre of the nucleus. There is very 
 little cytoplasma in this cell. Fresh — xiooo. 
 
 El ' 
 
^^s:W^ 
 
 
 via: I 
 
 
 % 
 
 ^^ 
 
 •% 
 
 1. >. 
 
 17 
 
 ,1 l> 
 
 IS 
 
 : \ ■'■fj 
 
 w 
 
 o 
 
 M 
 
 'Mfs* 
 
 /'/ 
 
 
 
 i! .■;■ ".';■■;•'' '''/ 
 
 /'; 
 
 'JO 
 
 
 ': f. 
 
 rc.;' 
 
 ■^y 
 
 ■••••■•, I ^. 
 
 
:i-; \ . II 
 
 W 
 
 i» 
 
 l(> 
 
 o 
 
 II 
 
 m 
 
 ^'£' 
 
 \ 
 
 jj 
 
 lo 
 
 ■■■(n 
 
 ^ 
 
 -;.' /'/ 
 
 \ 
 
 ■21 
 
 w-i 
 
 ,1 ' h 
 
 '^^fc' 
 
 ■•■•.■■r.^'.°'- 
 
 ,/ 
 
 
 S $ 
 
 /■ 
 
 v.. 
 
 w 
 
 ,^*^.